question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
int64
0
74.5k
sentence_embeddings
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
<p>Given are $Z_1, Z_2$ i.i.d. standard normal.</p> <p>Find</p> <p>$P[Z_1 &lt; t &lt; Z_2]$</p> <p>I have difficulties with working out how I should split the condition.</p> <p>Is $P[Z_1 &lt; t &lt; Z_2] = P[Z_1 &lt; t, t &lt; Z_2]$ or is some additional condition required?</p> <h2>My question</h2> <p>How should I approach this problem?</p>
74,289
[ 0.001127868890762329, -0.04309731349349022, 0.0016023579519242048, -0.019423823803663254, -0.005449292249977589, -0.0060168784111738205, 0.004314744379371405, -0.04776541888713837, -0.00427520927041769, -0.00610809912905097, 0.06123417988419533, 0.025319766253232956, 0.05500752851366997, 0.012569904327392578, 0.02831317111849785, -0.0034073328133672476, -0.01685725711286068, -0.03094230219721794, -0.01902298629283905, -0.0017009649891406298, -0.014581311494112015, 0.010061696171760559, 0.01828792504966259, -0.01221184991300106, -0.024055078625679016, 0.011863863095641136, 0.031438931822776794, 0.032671697437763214, 0.01474064216017723, 0.06292729824781418, -0.07421741634607315, -0.06704218685626984, 0.020847663283348083, 0.043750323355197906, 0.0031494530849158764, 0.024422552436590195, -0.03400111943483353, -0.041697513312101364, 0.0053252787329256535, -0.00497458828613162, 0.007392160594463348, -0.00009837893594522029, 0.004655671771615744, -0.009548707865178585, -0.021105073392391205, 0.06910683214664459, -0.019351907074451447, -0.0191204771399498, 0.03038908541202545, -0.05702908709645271, 0.04898696020245552, -0.017167041078209877, 0.03327156975865364, 0.02812844328582287, -0.02358914725482464, -0.026554862037301064, 0.043673813343048096, 0.06326055526733398, -0.012968692928552628, -0.0551971010863781, 0.012999914586544037, -0.03542272001504898, 0.010274538770318031, -0.015450624749064445, -0.06655144691467285, 0.00404627388343215, 0.023856136947870255, -0.003497827798128128, 0.003720272798091173, -0.01588069647550583, -0.012195408344268799, -0.00014215760165825486, 0.005856852512806654, -0.024077853187918663, 0.021534955129027367, -0.015191962011158466, -0.012514627538621426, 0.05696986988186836, 0.036739010363817215, 0.031710535287857056, 0.024861164391040802, -0.001229449757374823, 0.014775797724723816, 0.009051783941686153, -0.0019755808170884848, -0.03583173081278801, 0.0706135630607605, 0.011099493131041527, 0.006417793221771717, 0.026361849159002304, 0.026047280058264732, -0.0033688494004309177, 0.05510391667485237, -0.02258637547492981, -0.016234811395406723, 0.01578618213534355, -0.018657734617590904, 0.032109152525663376, -0.019427260383963585, -0.0037389781791716814, -0.005943930242210627, -0.05328153073787689, 0.020628685131669044, 0.05348102003335953, -0.03548585996031761, 0.009251817129552364, -0.052197400480508804, -0.0080548245459795, 0.016110381111502647, 0.0052534593269228935, -0.043593741953372955, 0.04686734825372696, -0.015501401387155056, 0.021177509799599648, 0.015187402255833149, 0.008101582527160645, -0.02046218328177929, -0.00045947791659273207, 0.0762074813246727, 0.022678472101688385, 0.058713313192129135, -0.024473443627357483, 0.024589236825704575, 0.019347181543707848, -0.047724321484565735, 0.029850803315639496, 0.026122240349650383, -0.008464357815682888, -0.030165933072566986, 0.045316342264413834, -0.02483263984322548, 0.008349023759365082, 0.009762970730662346, 0.018320009112358093, 0.039422594010829926, 0.028066541999578476, -0.03670400008559227, -0.06301011145114899, 0.024365462362766266, -0.021955421194434166, -0.010856526903808117, -0.09339684247970581, 0.0008497153175994754, 0.0525636300444603, 0.04550202190876007, -0.019923625513911247, 0.06848946958780289, 0.026902781799435616, 0.010421419516205788, 0.022602414712309837, -0.03412089869379997, -0.04089737683534622, 0.017494823783636093, -0.007153819780796766, -0.0036803775001317263, -0.051359452307224274, -0.003243344137445092, 0.02349298819899559, -0.023632405325770378, -0.001923629199154675, 0.05396824702620506, 0.0025962754152715206, -0.00675031915307045, 0.00287688709795475, 0.03136507049202919, -0.012869403697550297, 0.0631437674164772, -0.014806876890361309, 0.051604051142930984, 0.03571908548474312, 0.017878077924251556, 0.028537366539239883, -0.0337233692407608, 0.008905590511858463, 0.04388280212879181, -0.004599498584866524, -0.010431506671011448, 0.006772508379071951, 0.01215321198105812, 0.017155637964606285, 0.0032062253449112177, -0.011185281910002232, -0.02500147372484207, 0.008030597120523453, 0.00845402479171753, 0.03502242639660835, -0.004248686134815216, -0.01608145982027054, 0.01736527495086193, -0.0496925413608551, -0.011248663999140263, -0.01781853474676609, -0.017478829249739647, 0.024563655257225037, -0.03025604970753193, 0.00971937831491232, -0.002034061821177602, 0.022767838090658188, -0.03987197205424309, -0.016984520480036736, 0.004082308616489172, -0.007343360688537359, 0.04689815640449524, -0.03077833727002144, 0.018314804881811142, 0.05566530302166939, 0.05992452800273895, -0.007786279544234276, 0.017122207209467888, -0.024029651656746864, -0.027745889499783516, 0.012584458105266094, -0.04115772619843483, -0.003233185736462474, 0.018982579931616783, -0.0016245720908045769, 0.01077800989151001, -0.020476333796977997, -0.01713661476969719, 0.005725659895688295, -0.02909337542951107, 0.06496237218379974, 0.06277524679899216, 0.03703164681792259, 0.007953599095344543, -0.01687557063996792, 0.018196651712059975, 0.034227777272462845, -0.013764129020273685, -0.021722568199038506, -0.05582626909017563, -0.012058408930897713, 0.03638306260108948, 0.04322771355509758, -0.06760639697313309, 0.010680419392883778, 0.061523307114839554, 0.00655094999819994, 0.03995398432016373, 0.05632048845291138, 0.0027208798564970493, -0.014163036830723286, 0.03617485240101814, 0.02382424846291542, 0.03474095091223717, -0.011888278648257256, 0.018373899161815643, 0.016289012506604195, 0.02045321837067604, -0.007227784022688866, -0.007471464574337006, 0.03212866187095642, 0.001645076321437955, 0.02555583044886589, -0.011988542042672634, 0.007374801207333803, 0.02160692773759365, -0.029918134212493896, 0.024761054664850235, 0.03577829897403717, 0.022013630717992783, -0.014397961087524891, -0.005809318274259567, -0.01195105817168951, 0.00006549564568558708, 0.02123713493347168, -0.029498426243662834, 0.002270361641421914, 0.04884006083011627, -0.013171020895242691, -0.007290857378393412, -0.006498090922832489, -0.04669103026390076, -0.032483648508787155, -0.018981344997882843, 0.029078010469675064, -0.03273077309131622, 0.02522452548146248, -0.03671175241470337, -0.008129894733428955, -0.010004940442740917, 0.008956118486821651, -0.005042669828981161, -0.011002535000443459, -0.058320969343185425, 0.0006485623889602721, 0.026185786351561546, -0.04784441366791725, 0.0237285029143095, -0.011098675429821014, 0.016966596245765686, 0.018624797463417053, 0.01494012214243412, -0.043513935059309006, -0.04204520955681801, -0.04033305123448372, 0.04967740178108215, -0.04531630501151085, -0.037934206426143646, 0.07531172782182693, 0.013604843989014626, -0.044516000896692276, 0.02492520399391651, -0.016665704548358917, -0.02723749354481697, -0.04445634037256241, -0.008373502641916275, 0.025494061410427094, -0.014440488070249557, 0.04471870884299278, 0.04769686609506607, -0.05490727350115776, 0.04377998784184456, -0.07070218026638031, -0.0733272060751915, -0.012627029791474342, 0.00041043024975806475, 0.04156947880983353, 0.01961551420390606, -0.07201361656188965, 0.07834752649068832, 0.02709684893488884, -0.00506871473044157, -0.0281755980104208, -0.006301849149167538, -0.028758913278579712, -0.030448276549577713, 0.004056148696690798, 0.03057389333844185, -0.01865239255130291, 0.019340233877301216, 0.04413158819079399, 0.042846452444791794, 0.07251939177513123, 0.01398627832531929, -0.030795782804489136, 0.011599067598581314, 0.02592616342008114, -0.0007357267313636839, 0.04390525817871094, 0.016123590990900993, -0.009284093976020813, -0.010781480930745602, 0.011816558428108692, 0.04442758485674858, 0.022951636463403702, -0.050581421703100204, 0.011289980262517929, 0.005139779299497604, 0.02768012508749962, 0.006364539731293917, 0.03755594417452812, 0.046269118785858154, -0.06514386832714081, -0.016759464517235756, 0.0100928395986557, 0.017032580450177193, -0.023613816127181053, 0.015133722685277462, 0.08070320636034012, 0.06015785411000252, -0.03791819140315056, -0.0374109148979187, 0.00807105377316475, -0.03681230545043945, 0.03504927083849907, -0.0012820770498365164, -0.04488867521286011, 0.04703516885638237, 0.03711886331439018, 0.03152027726173401, -0.01612451672554016, -0.015394840389490128, 0.003943833988159895, -0.07981352508068085, 0.0047889333218336105, 0.007931128144264221, 0.052855756133794785, -0.0019572502933442593, 0.04803542047739029, 0.028843091800808907, 0.010687354952096939, 0.056534066796302795, 0.04462970420718193, -0.0813220664858818, 0.03348600119352341, -0.020593106746673584, -0.024416493251919746, -0.01584014855325222, -0.04753488674759865, 0.04719699174165726, -0.025882601737976074, 0.05886092782020569, -0.0150164058431983, 0.022992925718426704, -0.07074818760156631, 0.008526735007762909, -0.05565663054585457, -0.008623125962913036, -0.003959870431572199, 0.004718937445431948, 0.02332916297018528, -0.018269700929522514, 0.01748429797589779, 0.05015278607606888, -0.007773277349770069, 0.018974140286445618, -0.02879013493657112, 0.00805436447262764, -0.011863029561936855, 0.03954874351620674, 0.0032699150033295155, 0.002398295095190406, 0.00974523276090622, 0.03109140694141388, -0.04571154713630676, 0.06074070185422897, 0.020939543843269348, 0.03668055310845375, -0.004555494990199804, -0.023903295397758484, -0.028325246647000313, -0.019702447578310966, 0.023615306243300438, -0.025726106017827988, -0.03900108486413956, 0.03616632893681526, -0.011213301680982113, -0.03294084593653679, 0.05478653684258461, 0.05661352351307869, -0.004789748694747686, -0.025479815900325775, -0.03161320835351944, -0.04453841969370842, -0.029790634289383888, -0.015388622879981995, 0.04396553337574005, 0.010557232424616814, -0.024484436959028244, 0.02059009112417698, 0.038151293992996216, 0.013686331920325756, -0.027447249740362167, 0.03599243611097336, 0.009303383529186249, 0.019366387277841568, 0.020260022953152657, -0.053365558385849, 0.044421639293432236, 0.028290554881095886, 0.018436430022120476, 0.02831166610121727, -0.01684383489191532, -0.06776870042085648, 0.00826871208846569, 0.034267742186784744, 0.04208933562040329, 0.0110711008310318, -0.02772807702422142, -0.06929506361484528, 0.015864090994000435, 0.051209867000579834, -0.013738872483372688, 0.021726036444306374, -0.00357812293805182, -0.03624306246638298, -0.025689413771033287, -0.05303824320435524, -0.06503499299287796, -0.006681657861918211, 0.0016261733835563064, 0.03315846249461174, -0.015887601301074028, -0.03484589606523514, -0.04302866384387016, -0.0029241330921649933, 0.009510034695267677, 0.06715887784957886, -0.0049294233322143555, 0.003495238022878766, -0.003473015734925866, 0.039090704172849655, -0.020384805276989937, -0.05736801400780678, 0.005827359389513731, 0.004221330862492323, 0.018913110718131065, 0.013830090872943401, -0.036088015884160995, -0.03365810960531235, 0.05087808892130852, -0.007508604787290096, -0.006749807856976986, 0.03799432888627052, 0.03229200839996338, 0.039994414895772934, 0.05774552747607231, 0.05692547932267189, 0.029614420607686043, 0.03240828588604927, 0.02034054696559906, -0.01015707291662693, -0.023486286401748657, 0.006640234496444464, -0.03062925674021244, -0.00028301161364652216, -0.05444617569446564, -0.024944275617599487, -0.027402956038713455, 0.0387839749455452, -0.008058563806116581, 0.03188714012503624, -0.02851986512541771, -0.03781820088624954, 0.007254613097757101, 0.02025977522134781, 0.006735587026923895, -0.013162624090909958, -0.014657432213425636, 0.006566160824149847, -0.04480336606502533, -0.0052946400828659534, 0.0055810557678341866, -0.03356737643480301, 0.023217471316456795, 0.0071608154103159904, -0.027312934398651123, 0.06255348026752472, -0.06146823614835739, -0.017972534522414207, 0.016105616465210915, -0.05782639980316162, 0.02634631097316742, 0.019961629062891006, 0.039217039942741394, 0.0210172887891531, -0.010385865345597267, 0.007393738720566034, 0.02528216503560543, 0.02382294461131096, 0.02350636012852192, -0.04007767513394356, 0.04510410502552986, 0.01402333751320839, -0.028243189677596092, -0.05492076277732849, -0.052365176379680634, 0.0029793584253638983, 0.014083865098655224, -0.026651937514543533, -0.06675327569246292, -0.0037336288951337337, -0.023617062717676163, -0.01711858995258808, -0.022540509700775146, 0.02366243116557598, 0.013424531556665897, -0.0283987894654274, 0.002145594684407115, 0.026034189388155937, 0.06334439665079117, 0.0072887917049229145, 0.031399767845869064, 0.020197227597236633, 0.0028238187078386545, -0.004860691260546446, 0.0013903622748330235, 0.019464196637272835, -0.02186313085258007, -0.03458790108561516, -0.04659871757030487, -0.017240067943930626, 0.023869207128882408, -0.0163592416793108, 0.009607845917344093, 0.005642773117870092, 0.0025128249544650316, -0.0017615350661799312, -0.03654753044247627, -0.01604301854968071, -0.019619332626461983, 0.020412126556038857, -0.0015186106320470572, 0.02178029529750347, 0.007749565411359072, -0.033979929983615875, -0.008755250833928585, 0.012789297848939896, -0.011423040181398392, 0.004949657246470451, 0.07880239933729172, 0.04622206464409828, 0.0077842166647315025, -0.021376287564635277, -0.004400121513754129, 0.033852167427539825, 0.01856883242726326, -0.03771026432514191, 0.0461394302546978, 0.012175456620752811, -0.05023026466369629, -0.01852189376950264, -0.010694329626858234, -0.03089204430580139, 0.049512024968862534, -0.024192454293370247, 0.07838112860918045, 0.04974110797047615, -0.007925167679786682, -0.0016164215048775077, -0.00893878098577261, 0.021816633641719818, -0.02279290184378624, 0.0011261608451604843, 0.02646626904606819, 0.007202224340289831, 0.03325410932302475, 0.04148814082145691, 0.006462156772613525, -0.009098619222640991, 0.000133546520373784, 0.012808680534362793, 0.006110928487032652, 0.035809025168418884, -0.028367018327116966, -0.03723748028278351, 0.02000119350850582, -0.03117496520280838, 0.0034054219722747803, -0.04024925455451012, 0.007276303134858608, 0.01464059203863144, 0.044886514544487, -0.0324014313519001, -0.03551159426569939, -0.0024962620809674263, -0.018679656088352203, 0.013305215165019035, 0.02922561950981617, -0.03568889945745468, 0.03725682199001312, 0.009097769856452942, 0.03408196568489075, -0.018138553947210312, 0.02372094988822937, -0.015416271053254604, -0.02477152645587921, -0.02537573128938675, -0.05128195136785507, -0.019562870264053345, 0.019497094675898552, 0.03493776172399521, 0.002188695827499032, 0.02313615009188652, -0.04014667123556137, 0.021045254543423653, -0.013420434668660164, 0.03637494891881943, -0.03800906613469124, 0.06940144300460815, 0.03855891898274422, -0.01507294550538063, 0.009737842716276646, -0.005772881209850311, 0.09577014297246933, 0.06761043518781662, 0.029170190915465355, -0.05907605588436127, 0.04709034413099289, -0.04329119250178337, -0.01883741281926632, -0.03461192920804024, 0.03517786040902138, 0.007878475822508335, 0.021708933636546135, 0.028547344729304314, 0.022066976875066757, 0.005039603915065527, 0.01003234088420868, 0.040326956659555435, -0.0918176993727684, -0.000012752460861520376, 0.02186378836631775, 0.01639421656727791, -0.045096077024936676, -0.013397947885096073, -0.03212633356451988, 0.013431140221655369, -0.06022634357213974, 0.006146859843283892, -0.03853808343410492, -0.03483948856592178, 0.0005317397299222648, -0.03807026520371437, -0.022101877257227898, 0.005338693968951702, 0.03396454453468323, -0.008707973174750805, -0.030195176601409912, 0.004484921228140593, 0.010595961473882198, -0.026149526238441467, 0.02444901131093502, 0.0246940478682518, 0.0047822752967476845, -0.006974739022552967, 0.021970072761178017, -0.026529749855399132, -0.02861304208636284, 0.015114928595721722, -0.006236480548977852, 0.06527595967054367, -0.007152766454964876, -0.014494971372187138, 0.015564465895295143, -0.0065657696686685085, -0.006003185641020536, -0.03519830480217934, -0.023036986589431763, 0.005116953514516354, 0.018673043698072433, -0.0061210887506604195, 0.031076038256287575, -0.027334094047546387, 0.016200117766857147, 0.007603054866194725, 0.028609657660126686, -0.010248285718262196, -0.024333341047167778, -0.003984340000897646, 0.006857166066765785, 0.03707120940089226, -0.001022838056087494, -0.006166299805045128, -0.03457726165652275, -0.03849148377776146, -0.019087273627519608, -0.012737179175019264, 0.013498976826667786, -0.04106159135699272, -0.002568958792835474, 0.009529630653560162, -0.01762223429977894, -0.014646690338850021, -0.05326390638947487, 0.012762300670146942, -0.025411555543541908, -0.00896728690713644, -0.054096441715955734, -0.005195558071136475, -0.0009742393158376217, 0.06667999178171158, -0.0025268755853176117, 0.007074830587953329, 0.0023194756358861923, 0.07383940368890762, 0.020300962030887604, -0.028797898441553116, -0.009977683424949646, -0.0003754299250431359, -0.010981786996126175, 0.02223966084420681, -0.02459690533578396, 0.07346275448799133, 0.020639970898628235, 0.029216405004262924, -0.03983430564403534, 0.027343155816197395, -0.023366587236523628, 0.021300284191966057, 0.020963598042726517, -0.05540755018591881, 0.011008077301084995, 0.022149063646793365, 0.038970984518527985, -0.024146880954504013, 0.028974251821637154, -0.006478759925812483, -0.014480064623057842, 0.022598952054977417, -0.02665051445364952, -0.030637122690677643, -0.013080114498734474, -0.00977238453924656, 0.0008360444917343557, -0.03105660155415535, -0.0020235267002135515, -0.0148777449503541, -0.0013422972988337278, 0.014561738818883896, 0.02551630698144436, -0.04516648128628731, 0.022502323612570763, -0.03099108673632145, -0.0020595306996256113, 0.0538640096783638, 0.011532323434948921, 0.004315531346946955, 0.003364848904311657, -0.008864587172865868, -0.0016239972319453955, 0.05030917748808861, -0.03367483243346214, -0.026139099150896072, 0.03855711221694946, -0.021849842742085457, 0.028648141771554947, 0.030284259468317032, 0.033484458923339844, 0.03623279556632042, -0.0068519278429448605, -0.03162011876702309, -0.031722720712423325, 0.02267501689493656, -0.0075910137966275215, -0.032596804201602936, -0.015713775530457497, -0.023103777319192886, -0.030636945739388466, -0.018526224419474602, 0.015225582756102085, 0.014966276474297047, -0.02349807322025299, -0.021429946646094322, 0.034356359392404556, -0.01285478100180626, -0.003983781207352877, 0.01249782182276249, 0.014705130830407143, 0.02291191555559635, -0.0005830451846122742, -0.012005437165498734, 0.07066095620393753, 0.05724930018186569, -0.011102157644927502, -0.018502285704016685, -0.027710825204849243, 0.014942601323127747, -0.06595652550458908, -0.002763482043519616, 0.03883357346057892, -0.005184049718081951, 0.04333854466676712, -0.036559395492076874, 0.004486828111112118, 0.028435155749320984, -0.029857272282242775, 0.0005145514151081443, -0.0010384244378656149, -0.02571483701467514, -0.040030986070632935, 0.02442876435816288, -0.009076917544007301, 0.04492191597819328, 0.018060758709907532, 0.025961322709918022, 0.044758327305316925, 0.032403357326984406, -0.0009805748704820871, -0.017244191840291023, -0.008173787966370583, 0.007481476292014122, -0.0037423372268676758, -0.06330380588769913, 0.03098502941429615, -0.01061960682272911, -0.020545626059174538, -0.008567951619625092, 0.007127036806195974, -0.03648168221116066, -0.004040433093905449, 0.020097224041819572, 0.027715707197785378, 0.06310296803712845, 0.01810053177177906, 0.0008292656275443733, -0.014535482041537762, -0.04127787798643112, -0.0010078614577651024, -0.016358008608222008, 0.007891195826232433, -0.025356026366353035, 0.013892644084990025, 0.0001985135895665735, -0.034308191388845444, 0.02528945729136467, -0.0073903221637010574, -0.033809006214141846, 0.017367523163557053, 0.008591343648731709, -0.007437732070684433, -0.03714267164468765, 0.009393805637955666, -0.031166313216090202, 0.009684475138783455, 0.03802760690450668, 0.014192737638950348, -0.026530373841524124, -0.006128853652626276, -0.01645294390618801, -0.07210098206996918, 0.030163340270519257, 0.016734911128878593, -0.032495420426130295, -0.0758696049451828, -0.013234888203442097, 0.0011386482510715723, -0.02396170236170292, -0.009662624448537827, -0.03405190631747246, -0.0332837738096714, 0.009655670262873173, -0.006407587788999081, 0.02013862133026123, -0.00438265036791563, -0.014536718837916851, -0.011877793818712234, -0.054843585938215256, 0.06597161293029785, -0.030998315662145615, -0.020797790959477425, -0.04637964442372322, -0.013072014786303043, -0.09625696390867233, 0.026944288983941078, 0.04991547390818596, 0.029748311266303062, 0.02097199112176895, -0.006383445113897324, 0.04268019646406174, 0.02802281826734543, -0.07608573883771896, 0.01009693555533886, -0.008651040494441986, -0.05343499779701233, -0.00968876015394926, -0.0013371265958994627, 0.058382075279951096, 0.00808775145560503, 0.026644544675946236, -0.005243920721113682, 0.020047662779688835, 0.012800013646483421, -0.0022169887088239193, -0.007838101126253605, -0.01918332278728485, -0.014681699685752392, 0.0760493278503418, -0.05075627192854881, 0.035795122385025024, 0.028187843039631844, 0.014377090148627758, -0.02866552211344242, 0.032851692289114, -0.0804457888007164, -0.06032731756567955, -0.02140040136873722, 0.009145982563495636, -0.00656551169231534, -0.07993447035551071, -0.012628242373466492, 0.020970065146684647, -0.028022851794958115, -0.010616768151521683, 0.047846123576164246, 0.03218114376068115, 0.049948375672101974, -0.037596121430397034, 0.031944822520017624, 0.023183995857834816, -0.046651143580675125, 0.024741066619753838, 0.03491043299436569, -0.00480774836614728, -0.022438712418079376, 0.0011236411519348621, -0.008694002404808998, -0.006419734098017216, 0.011779907159507275, 0.01789046637713909, 0.028240825980901718, -0.0134446881711483, -0.03374047577381134, -0.00007225027366075665, 0.0032807341776788235, 0.024695543572306633, -0.019583581015467644, 0.013207469135522842, 0.03401568904519081, -0.022675268352031708, -0.006699427030980587, -0.06659070402383804, 0.025398429483175278, -0.033713873475790024, 0.01052451878786087, 0.03444157913327217, -0.0032554641366004944, -0.019360924139618874, 0.025108490139245987, 0.004375687800347805, 0.006569994147866964, 0.014654101803898811, -0.02035110630095005, 0.0013488783733919263, -0.004634421784430742, -0.021444017067551613, 0.0061776828952133656, -0.01804463379085064, -0.03197886049747467, -0.02124866098165512, 0.013030577450990677, 0.04528258740901947, 0.007897906936705112, -0.019724592566490173, -0.012008953839540482, -0.02502347156405449, 0.015081582590937614, -0.06021357327699661, -0.0240959282964468, -0.03787156939506531, -0.007762461435049772, 0.003464333014562726, -0.052060697227716446 ]
<p>I found an example for manually calculating the hazard ratio when there are two groups.</p> <pre><code>d2 &lt;- c(2, 2, 1, 2, 2, 0, 0, 4, 0, 2, 2, 0, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1) d &lt;- c(2, 2, 1, 2, 2, 3, 1, 4, 1, 2, 2, 1, 1, 1, 1, 2, 2) r2 &lt;- c(21, 19, 17, 16, 14, 12, 12, 12, 8, 8, 6, 4, 4, 3, 3, 2, 1) r1 &lt;- c(21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 21, 17, 16, 15, 13, 13, 12, 11, 11, 10, 7, 6) l &lt;- log(r2/r1) d1 &lt;- d - d2 dd &lt;- cbind(d2, d1) summary(glm(dd ~ offset(l), family = binomial)) </code></pre> <p>where d is the number of deaths in total, and $d_i$ is the deaths in group $i$ and $r_j$ is the number of people in risk group $j$. I understand how this works.</p> <p>I would like to do a similar exercise for when there are not two groups of people, but only one vector of continuous data (e.g. expression of a particular gene) and no grouping factor. How can it be done for this scenario ?</p>
74,290
[ -0.03300033509731293, 0.010974003002047539, -0.010817009955644608, -0.0008024717681109905, 0.021247027441859245, 0.01289574895054102, -0.02600294165313244, -0.034366022795438766, 0.04656264930963516, -0.0289129801094532, 0.021712815389037132, 0.0372166782617569, 0.043533455580472946, 0.017718007788062096, 0.0635426715016365, 0.013759411871433258, -0.0030314556788653135, -0.008542139083147049, 0.0066600763238966465, 0.00631282152608037, -0.0012067774077877402, 0.013445816934108734, 0.04614724591374397, -0.02995305508375168, 0.0064887297339737415, 0.05702264606952667, 0.0348900705575943, -0.011439214460551739, -0.026342421770095825, 0.0499453991651535, -0.03238026797771454, -0.037257276475429535, 0.010394119657576084, 0.030384104698896408, -0.02253970131278038, 0.040857117623090744, 0.0019210873870179057, -0.018351461738348007, -0.018030382692813873, 0.027855776250362396, -0.0725075826048851, -0.020168349146842957, 0.010363259352743626, 0.04269498214125633, -0.013079829514026642, 0.02954522892832756, -0.00474189966917038, -0.02924075350165367, 0.02082744427025318, -0.050542064011096954, 0.06408745050430298, -0.031849414110183716, 0.06381417065858841, -0.0027863935101777315, -0.018838679417967796, 0.030547257512807846, 0.04872898757457733, 0.08700746297836304, 0.012150745838880539, -0.04931104928255081, -0.05400090292096138, -0.03011658415198326, 0.007708633318543434, -0.001831872039474547, 0.0006611371063627303, -0.0012289052829146385, -0.011934593319892883, -0.037923283874988556, 0.020922336727380753, -0.022134628146886826, -0.008371731266379356, 0.009281491860747337, 0.04761388152837753, -0.03398827463388443, 0.03305187076330185, -0.014172558672726154, -0.0022707509342581034, -0.0009537910809740424, 0.022445296868681908, 0.032183557748794556, -0.01642366126179695, -0.010858778841793537, 0.044299863278865814, 0.04183584079146385, 0.005301443859934807, -0.02461308427155018, 0.06485730409622192, 0.008517293259501457, 0.05267978832125664, 0.022052453830838203, -0.012173709459602833, 0.023930728435516357, 0.025371242314577103, 0.011196382343769073, -0.053839266300201416, 0.049327388405799866, 0.0003950333339162171, 0.02770853042602539, 0.0013071163557469845, -0.009775548242032528, 0.0012420609127730131, -0.022486485540866852, 0.03483183681964874, 0.024899007752537727, -0.02869054488837719, 0.007513071410357952, -0.06724205613136292, -0.030504442751407623, -0.017570601776242256, -0.02327297255396843, -0.017513439059257507, 0.03595730662345886, -0.01071819569915533, -0.030194681137800217, -0.013972369953989983, -0.024411413818597794, -0.021829746663570404, 0.013185003772377968, 0.055145151913166046, 0.03600200638175011, 0.05859975516796112, -0.011923635378479958, 0.015934791415929794, -0.017692800611257553, -0.0254376083612442, 0.016032440587878227, 0.03675023093819618, -0.013507931493222713, -0.03556854650378227, 0.05118849501013756, -0.009219090454280376, -0.023146722465753555, 0.05320216342806816, 0.014648379758000374, 0.00016076775500550866, -0.02596859820187092, -0.0576900877058506, -0.048482682555913925, 0.03830638527870178, -0.035372085869312286, 0.0024769390001893044, -0.05587712302803993, -0.003933494910597801, 0.0221868883818388, 0.041921164840459824, 0.026993513107299805, 0.06342343240976334, 0.002001698361709714, 0.0021374807693064213, 0.02327968366444111, -0.015807533636689186, -0.0034893760457634926, -0.013910098001360893, 0.005580662749707699, -0.057857729494571686, -0.09656310826539993, 0.03011792153120041, 0.0358322337269783, -0.03089139051735401, -0.0013988607097417116, 0.046317629516124725, 0.0019383934559300542, -0.02289765700697899, 0.02698192559182644, -0.022684210911393166, -0.012916764244437218, 0.06646044552326202, 0.009509095922112465, -0.007746534887701273, 0.015666110441088676, 0.03003835678100586, 0.02378738299012184, 0.01792456954717636, 0.048705317080020905, 0.03054068610072136, -0.00040332050411961973, 0.00236748275347054, -0.01974969357252121, -0.0011504131834954023, 0.021211659535765648, 0.015634655952453613, -0.009501381777226925, -0.021849732846021652, -0.02253892831504345, 0.03573260456323624, -0.0008382892119698226, 0.0003630980500020087, 0.020774496719241142, 0.05796597898006439, 0.003961232490837574, -0.043417006731033325, -0.06904228776693344, 0.009821353480219841, 0.04216073825955391, -0.031041700392961502, -0.031166819855570793, 0.028285127133131027, 0.04100697860121727, 0.009674426168203354, -0.00798746757209301, -0.010967041365802288, -0.013313543051481247, 0.020601240918040276, -0.013309037312865257, -0.04140850529074669, 0.021760327741503716, 0.0693848505616188, 0.01712748594582081, 0.052284374833106995, -0.02691750042140484, -0.019538376480340958, -0.006056939717382193, -0.009393620304763317, 0.0194663368165493, -0.00825558416545391, -0.02363251894712448, 0.0012854015221819282, -0.011915992014110088, -0.022930188104510307, 0.035940952599048615, -0.061455532908439636, 0.062440626323223114, 0.12103581428527832, 0.03162671625614166, 0.022301316261291504, -0.030813083052635193, 0.013179440051317215, -0.016950810328125954, -0.030733807012438774, -0.007960503920912743, -0.049129191786050797, 0.0016872086562216282, 0.05392809584736824, -0.02153313159942627, -0.0269443579018116, 0.007282680366188288, 0.03248963505029678, 0.006085522938519716, -0.009173770435154438, 0.07688358426094055, -0.005372410640120506, 0.002547497395426035, 0.010566179640591145, 0.03137360140681267, 0.015346795320510864, -0.039016805589199066, 0.038047708570957184, -0.011698761023581028, 0.04753204062581062, -0.03285381942987442, -0.0025503034703433514, 0.06886199116706848, 0.010330837219953537, -0.0017067843582481146, -0.004259172827005386, 0.0016763757448643446, 0.052300211042165756, 0.004553723614662886, 0.029285132884979248, 0.02029467187821865, 0.025678416714072227, -0.04582350328564644, 0.028986221179366112, -0.025094591081142426, 0.02620718628168106, 0.05101563036441803, -0.07080118358135223, 0.012702171690762043, 0.0037124687805771828, -0.03705206885933876, 0.02641909383237362, -0.0012015033280476928, -0.03138508275151253, -0.05758475512266159, 0.026763372123241425, -0.0104159414768219, -0.0014345308300107718, 0.036125440150499344, -0.04195036739110947, -0.016673728823661804, 0.01086861826479435, -0.018557032570242882, 0.022815117612481117, -0.011364641599357128, -0.05192830413579941, -0.0005060978583060205, -0.008342592045664787, -0.02114703878760338, 0.02152959816157818, -0.014164701104164124, -0.037060368806123734, 0.00115361122880131, 0.023456735536456108, -0.0433308482170105, -0.04755568876862526, -0.02389749512076378, -0.003945327363908291, -0.025221573188900948, -0.03393733873963356, 0.022793440148234367, -0.013849351555109024, -0.05179955065250397, 0.019372284412384033, -0.051223091781139374, 0.015531749464571476, -0.042810045182704926, 0.010705688036978245, 0.022478988394141197, 0.008441958576440811, -0.002667513908818364, -0.019743094220757484, -0.033066265285015106, -0.012513106688857079, -0.07961495220661163, -0.07771014422178268, 0.009523780085146427, 0.05335506424307823, 0.012937811203300953, 0.0290138591080904, -0.008790938183665276, 0.05780571699142456, 0.015400279313325882, -0.011906099505722523, -0.035905349999666214, 0.007097890600562096, -0.02112177200615406, -0.04203678295016289, -0.0024019302800297737, -0.003001428209245205, 0.03422713652253151, 0.044760577380657196, -0.015594788827002048, 0.015775339677929878, 0.06293681263923645, -0.012536486610770226, -0.008557304739952087, 0.035855408757925034, -0.0015811934135854244, 0.013980892486870289, 0.045603472739458084, 0.025450190529227257, 0.023723185062408447, 0.05239930748939514, -0.000015057285963848699, 0.008326028473675251, -0.04102093353867531, -0.07487841695547104, -0.016833245754241943, 0.0011665947968140244, -0.0023924361448735, -0.022768734022974968, -0.0034190970472991467, 0.015029367059469223, -0.012877528555691242, 0.018417859449982643, 0.013464538380503654, 0.06377895921468735, -0.058715078979730606, -0.0015457413392141461, 0.0026433849707245827, 0.030663304030895233, -0.0011945540318265557, -0.010175066068768501, 0.036265648901462555, -0.016242297366261482, 0.02100435458123684, -0.020980916917324066, -0.024208586663007736, 0.008862965740263462, 0.0437290258705616, 0.04089832305908203, -0.024774864315986633, -0.04226648062467575, 0.04599153250455856, -0.03866219148039818, 0.004624653607606888, -0.046820737421512604, 0.04499230533838272, 0.0017486733850091696, 0.05142228677868843, 0.0023927707225084305, -0.020991353318095207, 0.03372281417250633, -0.030536452308297157, -0.07167933136224747, 0.02846885845065117, -0.019730886444449425, 0.025098826736211777, 0.02254679426550865, -0.01718294247984886, 0.0583360530436039, -0.015505790710449219, 0.004841645713895559, -0.014171849936246872, 0.02451002039015293, -0.008485042490065098, 0.0028004124760627747, 0.01268684584647417, -0.005679517053067684, -0.00465080002322793, 0.012609669007360935, -0.007784703746438026, 0.004962679464370012, -0.005056167021393776, 0.05248543247580528, 0.011125505901873112, 0.013480170629918575, -0.0115679781883955, -0.030148092657327652, 0.013019999489188194, 0.01804339326918125, 0.03844819962978363, 0.04839416593313217, -0.04109283164143562, -0.0026506218127906322, -0.026735907420516014, 0.02198842726647854, 0.04915028437972069, 0.024818895384669304, 0.0032467120327055454, -0.022554652765393257, -0.016033483669161797, -0.03395744785666466, 0.032171837985515594, -0.02963428944349289, 0.006710636429488659, 0.0667218267917633, 0.05576682835817337, -0.04949882999062538, 0.019847046583890915, 0.05785587430000305, 0.0164477676153183, -0.028732270002365112, -0.001589957275427878, 0.021543143317103386, 0.004312219563871622, -0.03266235068440437, 0.022640520706772804, 0.020122433081269264, 0.003823392791673541, -0.005390085279941559, 0.03315994516015053, -0.013470369391143322, -0.005252945236861706, 0.033836089074611664, 0.016802527010440826, 0.03580288589000702, 0.0408623181283474, -0.026522433385252953, -0.009373677894473076, 0.024008488282561302, 0.020700907334685326, 0.011733198538422585, -0.002250896068289876, -0.09026630967855453, 0.012789817526936531, 0.030502306297421455, 0.07641789317131042, -0.028240712359547615, -0.038454994559288025, -0.005956529639661312, 0.004302104935050011, 0.010985560715198517, -0.04333752393722534, 0.016111232340335846, -0.03158949688076973, -0.0021900141146034002, -0.011769167147576809, -0.01662885956466198, -0.06566743552684784, 0.042901456356048584, -0.031135892495512962, 0.009146963246166706, 0.024933291599154472, -0.014766374602913857, -0.06360591948032379, 0.018792105838656425, -0.001764384564012289, 0.053117815405130386, -0.04980366304516792, -0.04881240054965019, 0.015471769496798515, 0.037730321288108826, -0.029290372505784035, -0.023564381524920464, 0.010496173053979874, -0.002688224893063307, -0.014185242354869843, 0.08332739770412445, -0.0020003379322588444, -0.010975698940455914, 0.03744181618094444, 0.021458934992551804, -0.0009338967502117157, 0.013501200824975967, 0.004376526921987534, 0.027287745848298073, 0.0379374735057354, -0.04084937274456024, 0.050570081919431686, 0.0009152683196589351, -0.011857622303068638, 0.02746446803212166, -0.03591005504131317, 0.018432175740599632, -0.016039807349443436, -0.04733732342720032, -0.042213913053274155, 0.00486328499391675, 0.014736142940819263, 0.010606165044009686, -0.00918231625109911, 0.015491804108023643, -0.008779464289546013, -0.0023686294443905354, 0.027633827179670334, 0.03420903533697128, -0.011913369409739971, -0.015892677009105682, 0.012071623466908932, 0.013381141237914562, 0.010532679967582226, -0.02176741696894169, 0.021716302260756493, -0.0450420007109642, 0.015450588427484035, 0.008787821047008038, -0.08257806301116943, -0.00701863644644618, -0.00005186779162613675, -0.02454308420419693, 0.02238934300839901, -0.019508343189954758, 0.031244464218616486, -0.010191320441663265, 0.043207693845033646, -0.03001454658806324, -0.01790899597108364, -0.009447489865124226, 0.010549786500632763, 0.010323496535420418, 0.030958589166402817, -0.030657829716801643, 0.04829518124461174, -0.020470980554819107, -0.02287270873785019, -0.0669698417186737, -0.016615137457847595, 0.025702038779854774, -0.010530094616115093, -0.035102006047964096, -0.07758071273565292, -0.004575864877551794, -0.013057935051620007, -0.011572110466659069, 0.002709374064579606, 0.05989997461438179, -0.033228687942028046, -0.028494058176875114, -0.021635273471474648, 0.035130783915519714, 0.045945677906274796, 0.0056891730055212975, -0.03692285716533661, 0.009226156398653984, -0.020068898797035217, 0.004820141009986401, -0.0033222727943211794, -0.01604445092380047, -0.04909475892782211, -0.01689258962869644, -0.022643625736236572, 0.00508497841656208, 0.048133909702301025, -0.02327100932598114, -0.027198566123843193, -0.01619732193648815, -0.015379334799945354, 0.018231499940156937, -0.05620255693793297, -0.0003927087818738073, -0.03353308513760567, 0.015428577549755573, -0.04848940297961235, 0.0009655765607021749, -0.012015304528176785, 0.0044176774099469185, -0.0067129493691027164, -0.027756793424487114, 0.010794878005981445, 0.012370174750685692, 0.09703953564167023, -0.006322117988020182, -0.0065316022373735905, 0.016183355823159218, -0.012580827809870243, 0.05567057058215141, -0.015679648146033287, 0.022032981738448143, 0.026781508699059486, 0.016051674261689186, -0.02735726162791252, 0.004357277415692806, -0.017442958429455757, 0.00769144156947732, 0.042918719351291656, -0.04324707016348839, 0.04394719749689102, 0.02182055078446865, 0.03481088951230049, 0.03994668275117874, -0.024932602420449257, 0.026101747527718544, -0.014567872509360313, 0.006264742463827133, 0.060205958783626556, -0.0029366277158260345, -0.021002665162086487, 0.03490374982357025, 0.036596812307834625, 0.016643403097987175, 0.03401222452521324, -0.0152345672249794, 0.00885879434645176, 0.02351304702460766, 0.004289240576326847, -0.008620936423540115, 0.028995228931307793, -0.01586875692009926, 0.012130321934819221, -0.07737993448972702, -0.044344399124383926, 0.05781937390565872, 0.0019070326816290617, -0.023932401090860367, -0.0362190343439579, -0.027921408414840698, -0.03500308468937874, 0.0571434386074543, 0.05839505419135094, -0.036299046128988266, 0.04123234003782272, -0.003828109009191394, 0.03008842095732689, -0.018627887591719627, 0.008832921274006367, -0.021925054490566254, -0.053646523505449295, -0.03635791689157486, -0.019821664318442345, -0.041933704167604446, 0.03966338559985161, 0.007162763271480799, -0.016808651387691498, 0.01621260866522789, -0.003918764181435108, 0.016910502687096596, 0.001815826864913106, 0.050161246210336685, -0.01791462115943432, 0.08336229622364044, 0.030372317880392075, 0.04046002775430679, 0.0068567050620913506, -0.013695869594812393, 0.11911243945360184, 0.057880647480487823, 0.0689120665192604, -0.056435491889715195, 0.0003887206257786602, 0.00968619342893362, -0.005639379378408194, -0.022017044946551323, -0.012299314141273499, 0.03550447151064873, -0.016338197514414787, 0.050664257258176804, 0.06944924592971802, 0.016693715006113052, 0.010768306441605091, 0.05449940264225006, -0.048592373728752136, -0.022360121831297874, -0.00009557471639709547, 0.014814971946179867, -0.019480474293231964, -0.028276467695832253, -0.012154864147305489, 0.02039298042654991, 0.04351859912276268, 0.022360356524586678, -0.0613311305642128, -0.005268168170005083, -0.02649621106684208, -0.0051734112203121185, -0.03081146627664566, -0.01236785389482975, 0.027382204309105873, 0.0289359912276268, 0.00018583495693746954, -0.03786090761423111, 0.005190610885620117, -0.037812426686286926, -0.003506000619381666, 0.02143760584294796, 0.005806872621178627, 0.02160382829606533, -0.005439859814941883, 0.00566887017339468, -0.04071911424398422, -0.024882972240447998, -0.02203444205224514, 0.03848942741751671, -0.03764312341809273, -0.007948008365929127, -0.028091849759221077, -0.008617664687335491, -0.01741975173354149, -0.02743580937385559, -0.058550335466861725, 0.05025598034262657, 0.03312619775533676, -0.012091931886970997, -0.0019434940768405795, -0.04787299409508705, 0.03165829926729202, -0.010503566823899746, 0.038943931460380554, 0.023897288367152214, -0.034938883036375046, -0.043997179716825485, -0.033353351056575775, 0.053377874195575714, -0.012013918720185757, 0.015404286794364452, -0.017579583451151848, -0.009085436351597309, -0.009528804570436478, -0.014997575432062149, 0.013716121204197407, 0.003747468814253807, 0.022244811058044434, 0.01632661372423172, -0.027852917090058327, 0.025022422894835472, -0.036560721695423126, 0.01245473325252533, -0.0011338965268805623, -0.022538110613822937, -0.017804862931370735, -0.011011497117578983, 0.023570377379655838, 0.03744200989603996, -0.02194754034280777, 0.032847899943590164, -0.0002193954132962972, 0.05715317651629448, -0.010344461537897587, -0.036706674844026566, 0.0010567615972831845, 0.002931795548647642, 0.01837094873189926, 0.0018945763586089015, -0.025023987516760826, 0.04596695303916931, -0.007168775424361229, 0.02116483263671398, -0.011007796972990036, 0.04398811236023903, -0.029285261407494545, 0.0349651575088501, 0.019068216904997826, -0.05346330255270004, 0.009028472937643528, 0.008976872079074383, -0.0037304111756384373, 0.009635000489652157, -0.013726291246712208, -0.017824701964855194, -0.04574691504240036, 0.0030220302287489176, -0.05502806231379509, -0.04735273867845535, -0.025030946359038353, -0.014610480517148972, 0.01883501559495926, -0.02971571311354637, -0.03871979936957359, -0.03251967206597328, -0.011191194877028465, -0.013251319527626038, -0.043232791125774384, -0.0023776814341545105, -0.003230693284422159, -0.001496859360486269, 0.010618308559060097, 0.008870376273989677, 0.03418571874499321, 0.02812155708670616, 0.008217236958444118, 0.01043883990496397, -0.009120818227529526, 0.026007510721683502, -0.004212540574371815, -0.02271285653114319, 0.025034835562109947, -0.04227467253804207, -0.015528885647654533, 0.02097281627357006, 0.0059166899882256985, 0.05960547924041748, -0.028273021802306175, -0.0013827832881361246, -0.02493329718708992, 0.06339924037456512, -0.029288796707987785, -0.012900414876639843, -0.029400330036878586, -0.0115049472078681, -0.004900345578789711, -0.018173519521951675, -0.02540438249707222, 0.004473554436117411, -0.01894395239651203, -0.0017271462129428983, 0.038137033581733704, -0.0237418282777071, -0.016586774960160255, 0.02455354481935501, -0.00995427556335926, 0.04900370165705681, -0.002591883996501565, 0.016588011756539345, 0.023012183606624603, 0.037876833230257034, -0.006408750079572201, 0.014698022045195103, -0.04726782441139221, 0.02181248366832733, -0.07622847706079483, -0.031807247549295425, -0.015298599377274513, 0.00301050185225904, -0.0010642226552590728, -0.04879990592598915, -0.0010819624876603484, 0.016599468886852264, -0.027658985927700996, -0.01048310101032257, 0.009410759434103966, -0.007868661545217037, -0.03849681839346886, 0.014826154336333275, -0.025413861498236656, 0.03193051740527153, 0.026802556589245796, 0.014417226426303387, 0.04125552996993065, 0.004388508852571249, 0.014450703747570515, -0.0513419471681118, -0.00312164262868464, -0.00867913756519556, 0.018422070890665054, -0.06131082400679588, 0.0395662896335125, 0.021816391497850418, -0.001721901004202664, -0.014848240651190281, 0.004170062020421028, 0.013217435218393803, 0.055191170424222946, 0.030340414494276047, 0.009701156057417393, 0.05142182111740112, 0.017257066443562508, 0.03821078687906265, -0.011822996661067009, -0.003924551419913769, -0.00032633336377330124, -0.010839194990694523, -0.056335702538490295, 0.017098145559430122, 0.0429849773645401, -0.005683175753802061, -0.014612934552133083, 0.012755097821354866, -0.006450429558753967, -0.02551000751554966, -0.00863585714250803, -0.0014290520921349525, 0.04300445690751076, -0.0667300596833229, 0.029346704483032227, -0.04279610887169838, -0.01880795881152153, 0.06768912076950073, 0.03465251997113228, 0.000010794439731398597, 0.01588824950158596, -0.020300395786762238, -0.038261327892541885, -0.01704266294836998, 0.0023998699616640806, -0.04416298493742943, -0.037505216896533966, -0.0028940546326339245, -0.01707235351204872, -0.006193377077579498, -0.016321241855621338, -0.008436176925897598, -0.03452913463115692, 0.06419777870178223, -0.03141993284225464, 0.014103874564170837, 0.035657670348882675, 0.02787594497203827, 0.027446379885077477, -0.06020139157772064, 0.06756748259067535, 0.03683323785662651, -0.008618729189038277, -0.03727911040186882, -0.0019176768837496638, -0.05971058830618858, -0.005186985246837139, 0.04319081827998161, 0.007493000477552414, -0.0012682105880230665, -0.004689238499850035, 0.05025740712881088, -0.010961377993226051, -0.010538868606090546, 0.05475444719195366, -0.010107811540365219, -0.01767376996576786, -0.06379298120737076, 0.007400448899716139, -0.01112100575119257, 0.005072807893157005, -0.02515442483127117, -0.01989343762397766, 0.020055897533893585, 0.0005381906521506608, -0.012666046619415283, -0.030466271564364433, -0.03974542394280434, -0.015743842348456383, 0.03274625539779663, 0.0033599098678678274, -0.022849133238196373, 0.051769502460956573, 0.021283339709043503, -0.06343970447778702, 0.060170579701662064, -0.046855468302965164, -0.03251524642109871, -0.013515210710465908, -0.019637098535895348, 0.0029915596824139357, -0.0349566787481308, -0.003367947181686759, 0.008336384780704975, -0.031033074483275414, 0.0020274408161640167, -0.0026660568546503782, 0.01896367222070694, 0.032095860689878464, -0.03957028314471245, 0.009809352457523346, 0.016789570450782776, -0.02192108705639839, 0.015267860144376755, -0.007916789501905441, 0.024186227470636368, -0.02568451315164566, -0.008976265788078308, 0.023153314366936684, -0.019791971892118454, 0.0060266852378845215, -0.010755601339042187, 0.01879609003663063, -0.016831686720252037, -0.023252708837389946, 0.012805499136447906, -0.03670632466673851, 0.006267141085118055, 0.005131095182150602, 0.02545696124434471, 0.01636442169547081, -0.0046286312863230705, 0.032973237335681915, -0.01967134326696396, -0.05362739786505699, -0.03366885706782341, -0.029596174135804176, 0.04172622039914131, 0.052008867263793945, -0.01755630597472191, 0.024613406509160995, 0.007320888340473175, -0.047813091427087784, 0.026213260367512703, -0.006565935909748077, 0.06085832417011261, -0.0050093065947294235, -0.016122549772262573, 0.014607205055654049, -0.03321755677461624, -0.009465495124459267, -0.06334075331687927, 0.0394146628677845, 0.049795836210250854, 0.03117036446928978, -0.04936650022864342, -0.027246840298175812, 0.05359657108783722, -0.0031146903056651354, -0.01737380586564541, -0.027474861592054367, -0.02514547109603882, 0.0074334959499537945, 0.0026939748786389828, -0.036137666553258896 ]
<p>I am reading a code for a Bayesian clustering method. Both prior and the likelihood are normally distributed. If I understood correctly, such cases are called "conjugate priors"</p> <p>My question is about calculating the posterior mean and variance. So it is implemented in the code as following</p> <pre><code>d = nrow (data.i)##number of attributes n = ncol (data.i)##number of replication for each attribute Smatrix = matrix (1, nrow=d, ncol=d)##correlation of attributes Imatrix = Smatrix - 1 diag (Imatrix) = 1 prior.precision = solve (sdWICluster^2 * Smatrix + sdTSampling^2 * Imatrix) #inverting the prior correlation matrix (prior.precision) prior.mean = cluster.mean # mean of each clusters sample.precision = sdResidual^(-2) * Imatrix sample.mean = apply (data.i, 1, mean)#mean for each cluster post.cov = solve (as.matrix(prior.precision + n*sample.precision)) # posterior covariance matrix post.mean = as.vector (post.cov %*% (prior.precision %*% prior.mean + n*sample.precision %*% sample.mean)) # posterior of the mean </code></pre> <p>it seems the code has take the following formula, </p> <p>$\mu_{po} = C_{po}\times((\mu_{pr} \times \tau_{pr})+(n\times\tau_{li}\times\mu_{li}))$</p> <p>$C_{po} = \tau_{pr} + n\times\tau_{li}$</p> <p>As I said, this is the case of conjugates of normal distributions with unknown mean but variance known; however, it does not fit to the formula I have from <a href="http://www.people.fas.harvard.edu/~plam/teaching/methods/conjugacy/conjugacy_print.pdf" rel="nofollow">here</a>. (or may be it does by my eye is not able to catch). I appreciate if someone make some comments about the code and the formula</p>
74,291
[ -0.0074274917133152485, -0.01536865346133709, 0.000829877972137183, -0.07523934543132782, 0.06409159302711487, 0.022588245570659637, -0.03270915150642395, -0.005220439285039902, -0.006717388518154621, -0.02373184636235237, 0.028770210221409798, 0.061113957315683365, 0.09234851598739624, 0.04180387407541275, 0.054926563054323196, 0.027165429666638374, -0.014532282017171383, 0.00848899595439434, -0.006839617155492306, -0.0023739717435091734, 0.014526691287755966, 0.002980548655614257, 0.02469821460545063, -0.04920060560107231, 0.00768809299916029, 0.0035536205396056175, -0.0028927375096827745, -0.029722390696406364, 0.003782553132623434, 0.04214659705758095, -0.04710080847144127, -0.02375837229192257, 0.05863650143146515, -0.013275637291371822, -0.007590590976178646, 0.01807621866464615, 0.021566124632954597, -0.02432112582027912, -0.0030045609455555677, 0.03492946922779083, -0.022875428199768066, -0.020144738256931305, -0.006295019295066595, 0.047860000282526016, -0.0008331640856340528, 0.06120891124010086, -0.009054766036570072, -0.011174751445651054, 0.05518897995352745, -0.029534190893173218, 0.10218784213066101, 0.007712495047599077, 0.026567302644252777, 0.015915172174572945, -0.05063122510910034, -0.010544451884925365, 0.05030175670981407, 0.0262029729783535, 0.02302386425435543, -0.10026533901691437, -0.001938626985065639, -0.02406812086701393, -0.00012105666246498004, -0.045508868992328644, -0.030040310695767403, -0.001788499765098095, -0.0027480274438858032, -0.009089583531022072, 0.03529125824570656, 0.0005385414697229862, 0.032957449555397034, 0.01664508879184723, 0.004242578987032175, -0.03397795930504799, 0.019594524055719376, -0.02741110697388649, -0.020730212330818176, 0.025267239660024643, 0.045118920505046844, -0.0037354181986302137, 0.024148808792233467, 0.02966138906776905, 0.017515890300273895, 0.02190721407532692, 0.0029221840668469667, -0.02728673629462719, 0.04841664433479309, 0.015812458470463753, 0.022431515157222748, 0.03182956948876381, -0.03347513824701309, 0.049910373985767365, 0.0376662015914917, -0.020029621198773384, 0.009481601417064667, 0.04908028244972229, -0.02641039714217186, 0.044021446257829666, -0.029921939596533775, -0.004799594171345234, -0.03426900506019592, -0.04368872940540314, 0.005706801079213619, 0.04777897521853447, -0.016428237780928612, -0.04965309053659439, -0.035700440406799316, 0.022838998585939407, -0.01237400807440281, -0.030920449644327164, -0.04173129424452782, 0.007480771280825138, -0.021216196939349174, -0.0031853956170380116, 0.012561430223286152, -0.05661560595035553, 0.00177399639505893, 0.0023642678279429674, 0.07015923410654068, 0.05506535619497299, 0.0013908961554989219, -0.009586820378899574, 0.019966157153248787, -0.049982622265815735, -0.061005327850580215, 0.00010626049333950505, 0.023038499057292938, 0.008000192232429981, -0.03047565184533596, 0.022387364879250526, -0.011499241925776005, -0.03913780301809311, 0.022807804867625237, -0.025080805644392967, -0.007120183669030666, -0.013971778564155102, -0.060082342475652695, -0.03600349277257919, 0.018838318064808846, 0.000398565229261294, 0.01195547729730606, -0.06409851461648941, 0.014850469306111336, 0.02199195697903633, 0.0329863503575325, 0.01441978383809328, 0.03996783122420311, 0.03046632930636406, 0.011133424006402493, -0.015440900810062885, -0.04404107853770256, -0.011811727657914162, -0.022457797080278397, -0.008912966586649418, -0.03737599030137062, -0.07063249498605728, 0.012202775105834007, -0.005147014744579792, 0.011291722767055035, 0.02820349484682083, 0.03068786859512329, -0.004091567825525999, 0.005982712376862764, -0.015482845716178417, 0.0004859672917518765, -0.04696418344974518, 0.03176622837781906, 0.015214987099170685, 0.004271922633051872, 0.043389659374952316, -0.05354291573166847, -0.01587677001953125, -0.03623644635081291, 0.04651332646608353, 0.053574662655591965, -0.019281620159745216, -0.010671023279428482, 0.014418883249163628, 0.022132566198706627, 0.008580819703638554, -0.023969760164618492, -0.011599921621382236, 0.005659316200762987, -0.005315599963068962, 0.025310726836323738, 0.02237405814230442, 0.01423952542245388, 0.0026920472737401724, 0.015895575284957886, -0.03799740597605705, -0.01910562627017498, -0.06961777061223984, -0.022842640057206154, -0.03551279753446579, -0.024476593360304832, 0.020991461351513863, -0.01147383265197277, 0.039255350828170776, 0.052530210465192795, -0.02139422483742237, -0.057756178081035614, -0.02819976583123207, 0.04749533161520958, -0.013129359111189842, 0.02691395953297615, 0.05176622420549393, 0.04914653301239014, 0.005287559702992439, 0.0457611083984375, 0.009976857341825962, -0.014899932779371738, -0.01606743037700653, -0.04792697727680206, 0.024594813585281372, 0.015817707404494286, -0.033936161547899246, 0.02832815796136856, 0.014184238389134407, -0.00816100463271141, 0.024971015751361847, -0.04444028064608574, 0.008543780073523521, 0.08790554851293564, 0.00576621713116765, 0.011585257947444916, -0.0063200234435498714, 0.0013528249692171812, 0.009530296549201012, -0.00512591190636158, -0.005205117166042328, -0.05562664195895195, -0.011170160956680775, 0.02789047546684742, 0.04389241337776184, -0.011753319762647152, -0.00020291113469284028, 0.03438041731715202, 0.00791912991553545, 0.01209188625216484, 0.043441955000162125, 0.00019938863988500088, -0.054566849023103714, 0.028955668210983276, 0.010951971635222435, 0.01222489308565855, 0.016302907839417458, -0.008573619648814201, 0.01236831583082676, 0.059992674738168716, -0.03229450061917305, -0.023670213297009468, 0.0569930337369442, -0.01688236929476261, -0.029017996042966843, -0.011478262953460217, 0.0035084441769868135, -0.0020788272377103567, 0.013238600455224514, 0.00387125788256526, 0.015817368403077126, 0.011732527986168861, -0.030093686655163765, -0.029164785519242287, -0.03112386353313923, 0.0022181083913892508, 0.05914628505706787, -0.027377573773264885, 0.0028020974714308977, -0.0017143981531262398, -0.009282725863158703, 0.042134568095207214, -0.007525489199906588, -0.027484368532896042, -0.01475553959608078, 0.016552260145545006, 0.012202118523418903, 0.017853211611509323, 0.0012257241178303957, -0.021182015538215637, -0.05333500728011131, -0.014643264934420586, -0.0013600883539766073, 0.0318501740694046, 0.015184763818979263, -0.0723806768655777, -0.016987187787890434, 0.0033792725298553705, -0.0068657901138067245, 0.008488898165524006, -0.011139754205942154, -0.02378753200173378, 0.009708716534078121, -0.031657516956329346, -0.035937678068876266, -0.03044598177075386, -0.00468842638656497, -0.016375793144106865, -0.02256867103278637, 0.009411955252289772, 0.028472021222114563, 0.04656725749373436, -0.03391642868518829, 0.02191418781876564, -0.031056953594088554, -0.03361745923757553, -0.01907643862068653, -0.050143152475357056, 0.007289849687367678, -0.0048970249481499195, 0.07678433507680893, 0.04334716126322746, -0.028847625479102135, 0.032079458236694336, -0.06620512902736664, -0.03519122675061226, 0.023976482450962067, 0.016511207446455956, 0.027947230264544487, -0.008664689026772976, 0.017069026827812195, 0.057751573622226715, 0.01221612747758627, -0.02406870760023594, -0.0035689747892320156, 0.050858497619628906, -0.03771114721894264, -0.03520641475915909, 0.02185647189617157, 0.0019603813998401165, -0.006537808105349541, -0.009390645660459995, -0.0170879028737545, 0.017948972061276436, 0.05011991038918495, -0.004327227361500263, 0.01020419504493475, -0.01811824180185795, -0.009761599823832512, -0.012047325260937214, 0.025400308892130852, -0.0016082054935395718, -0.002218166831880808, -0.008491113781929016, 0.0063250623643398285, 0.034532271325588226, -0.005126131232827902, -0.059400953352451324, -0.0077151162549853325, 0.0009857865516096354, 0.014086163602769375, -0.07827331125736237, 0.04870832711458206, 0.010470944456756115, -0.062482189387083054, -0.007403186988085508, -0.00017723406199365854, 0.030167998746037483, -0.023675208911299706, -0.015583152882754803, 0.060486141592264175, 0.02534596621990204, -0.0064913383685052395, 0.013814118690788746, -0.022329922765493393, -0.014193646609783173, -0.014121444895863533, -0.04933818802237511, -0.010598008520901203, 0.02982356585562229, 0.07048413902521133, 0.015754161402583122, 0.01994982920587063, -0.0083107715472579, 0.004355614073574543, -0.022070251405239105, 0.04197033494710922, -0.044149596244096756, 0.0185163002461195, 0.024678664281964302, 0.05291704088449478, 0.02186720073223114, 0.0084801921620965, 0.024351879954338074, -0.007771816570311785, -0.06447400897741318, -0.0003497189318295568, 0.008261069655418396, -0.003449005074799061, -0.016529887914657593, -0.0419284887611866, 0.05615223944187164, -0.008006362244486809, 0.035335637629032135, 0.0010389202507212758, 0.02828921377658844, -0.023868508636951447, 0.038867268711328506, -0.04369466006755829, 0.060055509209632874, -0.011054068803787231, 0.03630278632044792, 0.0608542300760746, 0.008468564599752426, 0.06779512763023376, 0.00008411568705923855, -0.006006228271871805, -0.02575966715812683, -0.024883009493350983, 0.001720363274216652, -0.003153643338009715, 0.015803556889295578, 0.0236895103007555, 0.07437419146299362, -0.01472581084817648, 0.03785943612456322, -0.017127569764852524, 0.048207562416791916, 0.07909194380044937, -0.011928553692996502, 0.006472219713032246, -0.027903903275728226, 0.010365745052695274, 0.026476114988327026, -0.01682049222290516, -0.007393090054392815, 0.0029521617107093334, 0.03438001498579979, 0.014311184175312519, -0.01732526905834675, 0.056474003940820694, 0.051717307418584824, 0.008547935634851456, -0.012175939977169037, -0.0410362146794796, 0.015641985461115837, -0.006082405336201191, -0.0017396832117810845, 0.007854368537664413, 0.025278080254793167, -0.020347410812973976, -0.0011447969591245055, 0.049378652125597, -0.03478551656007767, -0.029224328696727753, -0.007868106476962566, 0.015116730704903603, 0.026279406622052193, 0.025612177327275276, -0.05501646548509598, 0.011387530714273453, 0.023364054039120674, 0.026943162083625793, 0.02179460972547531, -0.007699755020439625, -0.08246597647666931, -0.0004032439028378576, 0.012378006242215633, 0.04296869784593582, -0.02051698975265026, 0.013583599589765072, -0.06285403668880463, -0.02059662528336048, 0.013385232537984848, -0.02752087451517582, 0.030231881886720657, -0.015690423548221588, 0.025489280000329018, 0.004920314997434616, -0.02354797162115574, -0.037706006318330765, 0.027312995865941048, -0.026091311126947403, 0.006015797145664692, -0.050812121480703354, -0.022419512271881104, -0.02783970534801483, -0.0022735728416591883, 0.016803167760372162, 0.04748643562197685, -0.052299946546554565, -0.006717231124639511, 0.026600288227200508, 0.03769465908408165, -0.0017241869354620576, -0.053136974573135376, 0.02628163807094097, 0.020079391077160835, -0.021672045812010765, 0.029400043189525604, -0.01752067543566227, -0.022479910403490067, 0.04608679190278053, -0.0042379796504974365, -0.02130512334406376, -0.004966368433088064, -0.009016428142786026, 0.05512379854917526, 0.012075492180883884, 0.013822772540152073, 0.04074505716562271, -0.04244567081332207, -0.0027417426463216543, -0.0007309428765438497, -0.094760462641716, -0.019452011212706566, -0.010089016519486904, 0.012491056695580482, -0.061942581087350845, 0.02106742560863495, 0.013094215653836727, 0.020347509533166885, 0.0027919686399400234, 0.03631378337740898, -0.011980540119111538, 0.020496798679232597, 0.014575783163309097, 0.039197325706481934, -0.022331969812512398, 0.022604936733841896, -0.014165213331580162, -0.008005952462553978, -0.0009370825719088316, -0.012818887829780579, 0.02049468457698822, -0.01628386788070202, -0.014418651349842548, -0.014550036750733852, -0.006220108829438686, -0.006704302504658699, -0.0025504075456410646, -0.0032374721486121416, 0.0552070215344429, -0.0383237861096859, -0.008094651624560356, 0.030834686011075974, 0.0414043627679348, 0.005248310510069132, -0.014212872833013535, -0.020657356828451157, 0.019510790705680847, -0.0579514317214489, 0.012017265893518925, 0.004526384174823761, -0.0014338126638904214, 0.006161493249237537, -0.0018766648136079311, -0.024076856672763824, -0.026231804862618446, 0.017188208177685738, -0.04283430799841881, -0.044805895537137985, -0.053537607192993164, -0.01737094484269619, -0.023214178159832954, -0.035069458186626434, -0.02104843035340309, 0.023914270102977753, -0.061648763716220856, -0.018771681934595108, -0.025492394343018532, 0.00897953286767006, 0.06611938029527664, 0.011314842849969864, -0.010279200039803982, 0.03332441300153732, 0.009951317682862282, -0.014466708526015282, 0.03319479152560234, 0.013509555719792843, -0.027669502422213554, -0.008490905165672302, -0.02721947804093361, 0.017863193526864052, 0.059631817042827606, -0.008759034797549248, -0.03905954957008362, -0.02947726473212242, 0.05777609720826149, 0.003861384466290474, -0.04548478126525879, -0.017122512683272362, 0.00785941630601883, 0.017241306602954865, -0.0642523467540741, -0.017219943925738335, 0.00935184396803379, -0.011464836075901985, 0.025622231885790825, -0.023517552763223648, 0.012237371876835823, 0.02565436065196991, 0.06754747033119202, -0.010938199236989021, 0.00729059474542737, -0.0020549925975501537, -0.01098457258194685, 0.021786773577332497, 0.027781210839748383, -0.00021433638175949454, 0.020430007949471474, -0.022956160828471184, -0.02700529620051384, -0.005465085152536631, -0.058772388845682144, 0.02470066025853157, 0.08638855814933777, -0.004429646302014589, 0.03260191157460213, 0.0636884793639183, 0.02229692041873932, -0.0006993301212787628, -0.052196796983480453, -0.00767532316967845, 0.0012787944870069623, 0.027919631451368332, 0.0709882602095604, -0.061746444553136826, -0.009463331662118435, 0.03611229360103607, -0.0021445415914058685, 0.0064890142530202866, 0.024881277233362198, 0.0037063995841890574, 0.019472766667604446, -0.037227462977170944, -0.030263829976320267, -0.037240806967020035, 0.032518886029720306, -0.005958865862339735, 0.012763935141265392, -0.059285979717969894, -0.0392429456114769, 0.030703937634825706, 0.04322781413793564, -0.011770656332373619, -0.014744867570698261, -0.014661009423434734, -0.05869106575846672, 0.021865567192435265, 0.03736124560236931, -0.0305092204362154, -0.004858498927205801, 0.005987062584608793, 0.03839559853076935, -0.00930891465395689, 0.033862560987472534, -0.03975473716855049, -0.06402494758367538, -0.05455486476421356, -0.01684817485511303, -0.0005621477612294257, 0.032586101442575455, -0.0009441203437745571, -0.023868251591920853, 0.020562225952744484, -0.04009482264518738, 0.07260268181562424, 0.011497639119625092, 0.016573118045926094, -0.04359591752290726, 0.0862630307674408, 0.020633606240153313, 0.023137014359235764, -0.013838435523211956, -0.004636728670448065, 0.13355234265327454, 0.06478757411241531, 0.010845988988876343, -0.01284101139754057, 0.009963907301425934, -0.003230394795536995, -0.0057807378470897675, -0.039837244898080826, 0.006010344251990318, -0.00946743879467249, -0.03716287389397621, 0.06026994809508324, 0.03537504002451897, 0.029120728373527527, 0.010400859639048576, 0.014694987796247005, -0.040151484310626984, -0.048249900341033936, -0.01607288233935833, -0.01663380302488804, -0.03381313383579254, -0.0435040220618248, -0.056821562349796295, 0.0178962554782629, 0.015370501205325127, 0.010975045152008533, -0.03097194992005825, 0.03875185176730156, -0.03582451865077019, 0.02164577692747116, 0.03148242458701134, 0.01779792085289955, -0.0004528984718490392, -0.005579586140811443, -0.02071928046643734, -0.01178324781358242, 0.0318496972322464, -0.04491551220417023, 0.017042100429534912, 0.0309703778475523, -0.006419110111892223, 0.00396734056994319, -0.019826343283057213, 0.029363097622990608, -0.03169097378849983, -0.003494823584333062, -0.010528652928769588, 0.0698150098323822, 0.002345087705180049, 0.013708907179534435, -0.00020840694196522236, -0.006284744944423437, -0.011352167464792728, -0.041102807968854904, 0.020476005971431732, 0.02104194089770317, 0.01926918514072895, 0.004234843421727419, 0.004312514327466488, -0.03305843099951744, -0.00263152620755136, -0.0015232391888275743, 0.022782988846302032, 0.016914786770939827, 0.004767454229295254, -0.024861134588718414, -0.06713234633207321, 0.03220679610967636, -0.014451072551310062, 0.034413665533065796, 0.024148020893335342, -0.019708188250660896, -0.010361628606915474, -0.019523296505212784, 0.01990007795393467, -0.03315551578998566, 0.03960298001766205, -0.026393309235572815, 0.01497645489871502, -0.03163660317659378, -0.03541925922036171, 0.01925492286682129, -0.005764633882790804, -0.03204861655831337, -0.015345508232712746, 0.018806010484695435, 0.04316965490579605, 0.053483642637729645, 0.013241483829915524, 0.03562463819980621, -0.004435247275978327, 0.03806115686893463, 0.01737172342836857, -0.0053214034996926785, -0.06260935962200165, 0.022921551018953323, -0.03324640169739723, 0.005640540271997452, -0.010669572278857231, 0.03308870270848274, 0.05128970369696617, 0.021226663142442703, -0.024000173434615135, 0.03986063972115517, -0.035603027790784836, 0.00020928056619595736, -0.013936304487287998, -0.018643299117684364, 0.02974582649767399, -0.026111599057912827, 0.018155338242650032, -0.020295433700084686, 0.032008640468120575, -0.01234407164156437, -0.04354342818260193, 0.009077145718038082, -0.006792773958295584, -0.03598358482122421, -0.007412413135170937, -0.022279532626271248, 0.0034838542342185974, -0.014077014289796352, 0.015044862404465675, 0.0037862807512283325, 0.005932991858571768, -0.02117662876844406, -0.026784347370266914, -0.04089496284723282, 0.019615372642874718, -0.04600311070680618, 0.024683604016900063, 0.04586762562394142, -0.00246954383328557, 0.02607748843729496, -0.05927726998925209, 0.01266828365623951, -0.0032232427038252354, 0.03166230022907257, 0.03317055478692055, -0.015762675553560257, 0.05035880580544472, -0.02206108160316944, -0.04407817870378494, 0.006819566711783409, 0.06836546957492828, 0.01969805918633938, 0.017490191385149956, -0.0008464598213322461, -0.0355662927031517, 0.06525648385286331, -0.05624213069677353, -0.00888992752879858, -0.03129974380135536, 0.012240337207913399, -0.008347569033503532, -0.0070391809567809105, 0.010311899706721306, 0.014300032518804073, 0.013469596393406391, 0.009729625657200813, 0.012753751128911972, -0.026742970570921898, 0.0022917711175978184, -0.0028977468609809875, -0.05747976526618004, -0.036737944930791855, 0.018528802320361137, 0.013641251251101494, -0.026397425681352615, 0.05717518925666809, -0.012604894116520882, -0.0022140159271657467, -0.02017502672970295, 0.02610938623547554, -0.09296990185976028, -0.028099969029426575, 0.018475009128451347, 0.02639411948621273, 0.03888146951794624, -0.011312325485050678, 0.004624614492058754, 0.019942687824368477, -0.008740645833313465, 0.028585469350218773, -0.008366307243704796, 0.008594581857323647, -0.022142669185996056, 0.04430332034826279, -0.034434594213962555, 0.03052515536546707, 0.017940394580364227, 0.004804122727364302, 0.04254867509007454, 0.027269065380096436, 0.02461884543299675, -0.04391857981681824, -0.004938917700201273, 0.007951448671519756, 0.022905312478542328, -0.06901855766773224, 0.004324858542531729, -0.021226705983281136, -0.014125244691967964, -0.0001300356088904664, 0.02777121774852276, 0.005038483999669552, -0.009474970400333405, 0.06227477639913559, 0.013387818820774555, 0.05851152539253235, 0.01576831564307213, 0.011875908821821213, 0.011497137136757374, -0.006437704432755709, 0.02378370240330696, 0.017605694010853767, 0.022901451215147972, 0.02065984718501568, -0.00014107635070104152, 0.0072580380365252495, -0.03514333441853523, 0.010317365638911724, -0.027647925540804863, -0.022563057020306587, -0.023892967030405998, -0.014121015556156635, -0.03188597410917282, -0.029705623164772987, 0.030751047655940056, -0.05597880855202675, -0.010583439841866493, 0.07442396879196167, 0.05811749026179314, -0.023159896954894066, 0.033861786127090454, 0.008419572375714779, -0.039152681827545166, 0.011297695338726044, 0.006539337802678347, 0.000786623393651098, -0.06508443504571915, -0.020781824365258217, 0.007073462009429932, -0.008105705492198467, -0.011593225412070751, -0.00885794498026371, -0.06112230196595192, 0.07187846302986145, -0.02152521163225174, -0.014423171058297157, 0.009631193242967129, 0.04270832613110542, 0.03177361562848091, -0.06964334845542908, 0.05429675057530403, -0.04947064444422722, -0.03788679465651512, -0.04877477139234543, -0.0018861499847844243, -0.03461957722902298, 0.048817746341228485, 0.028698626905679703, 0.0048248725943267345, 0.023608500137925148, -0.012009721249341965, 0.004606558009982109, 0.011191591620445251, -0.05413906276226044, 0.04701555147767067, -0.003289134008809924, -0.001958233769983053, -0.0017107556341215968, 0.0015702982200309634, 0.007460145745426416, 0.008777359500527382, 0.013246101327240467, -0.026118306443095207, 0.003487847512587905, -0.004495448432862759, -0.031889453530311584, 0.005625282414257526, 0.013596644625067711, 0.007033407688140869, 0.02369094267487526, -0.010511349886655807, 0.00792977586388588, 0.05837434157729149, 0.02032666653394699, -0.03318484127521515, 0.03898553550243378, -0.018249159678816795, -0.050370171666145325, 0.010498744435608387, -0.008135470561683178, 0.006796273402869701, -0.04380911961197853, -0.012007944285869598, 0.051656316965818405, -0.05335802584886551, -0.022888755425810814, 0.029212534427642822, -0.03337334096431732, 0.04059702530503273, 0.012984496541321278, 0.007614310830831528, 0.02218848653137684, -0.03437868878245354, 0.044391099363565445, 0.012615727260708809, 0.03882196545600891, -0.03438722714781761, -0.0038431258872151375, -0.008077976293861866, -0.022286219522356987, 0.005042715463787317, -0.01159550528973341, 0.057511139661073685, -0.045514605939388275, -0.00021671276772394776, 0.030752625316381454, -0.03814869001507759, 0.058290887624025345, 0.023914653807878494, 0.0006835806416347623, 0.047984588891267776, -0.050120215862989426, 0.01041845977306366, -0.01841367781162262, -0.005169185344129801, -0.03566725179553032, -0.00795010570436716, -0.031080640852451324, 0.03831324726343155, 0.027209704741835594, 0.001683704904280603, -0.009279347024857998, -0.025732150301337242, 0.009380252100527287, -0.0812661275267601, 0.002196472603827715, 0.024051260203123093, 0.010047297924757004, 0.035032130777835846, -0.030933557078242302, -0.03263600170612335, -0.033444300293922424, 0.011741132475435734, 0.014918624423444271, 0.0009979067835956812, -0.03834494948387146, -0.03888624534010887, 0.030327903106808662, 0.017256638035178185, -0.03861309960484505, -0.0026942952536046505, -0.029700525104999542, 0.015137181617319584, -0.015220537781715393, -0.010847441852092743 ]
<p>I am plotting a density estimate for misclassification rate of some classifier using the standard <code>plot</code> and <code>lines</code> functions. Even though I've set <code>xlim=c(0.32,0.38)</code> and <code>ylim=c(0,100)</code> within the <code>plot</code> command, the x-limits and the y-limits are a bit wider than I'd like. How can I get the bottom left of the plot to have coordinates (0.32,0) and the top right of the plot to have coordinates (0.38, 100)?</p>
74,292
[ -0.03266116976737976, -0.0053494032472372055, 0.023940730839967728, 0.02740984782576561, 0.012517322786152363, -0.0015970031963661313, -0.020855551585555077, -0.007312399800866842, 0.028845323249697685, 0.003346562385559082, 0.05154402181506157, 0.06427054107189178, 0.07840784639120102, 0.03555317968130112, 0.06720726937055588, -0.01687420904636383, -0.00829189270734787, -0.007611778099089861, -0.004164697602391243, -0.062230587005615234, -0.021347053349018097, -0.011305191554129124, 0.030664145946502686, -0.0022352540399879217, -0.00017920360551215708, 0.027366897091269493, 0.01891212910413742, 0.02749398536980152, 0.00012815477384719998, 0.06154622137546539, -0.010344111360609531, -0.030515281483530998, 0.015403740108013153, 0.0060508050955832005, 0.05149791017174721, 0.011012342758476734, 0.0014313305728137493, -0.03168381378054619, -0.0132066635414958, -0.004442373290657997, -0.026291005313396454, 0.02240036427974701, 0.04455753043293953, 0.05314542353153229, -0.000877025187946856, 0.03570402413606644, 0.011609342880547047, 0.004227000288665295, 0.05025385692715645, 0.01959121599793434, 0.06411685794591904, -0.015826942399144173, 0.03859353065490723, 0.07217168807983398, -0.011545320972800255, 0.024204391986131668, 0.05336605757474899, 0.08165649324655533, -0.02662324719130993, -0.045963939279317856, 0.0111533859744668, -0.03861156851053238, -0.017180440947413445, 0.005775046534836292, -0.03447535261511803, 0.027230439707636833, -0.041441380977630615, -0.030833737924695015, -0.02393578179180622, -0.04963671416044235, -0.03490039333701134, 0.040552012622356415, 0.022284362465143204, -0.025470035150647163, 0.05465417727828026, -0.042140744626522064, 0.044174741953611374, 0.004765590187162161, 0.038753293454647064, 0.00944340880960226, 0.017026344314217567, 0.0439637154340744, 0.029621794819831848, 0.016601093113422394, 0.007195169106125832, 0.0030347148422151804, 0.11342620104551315, -0.014040691778063774, 0.04581565037369728, 0.03984903544187546, -0.015848631039261818, 0.036107517778873444, 0.06641780585050583, 0.023702695965766907, -0.0034766001626849174, 0.02648164890706539, -0.004319582600146532, 0.03187412768602371, -0.01012885570526123, -0.028579145669937134, 0.006331355310976505, -0.018872417509555817, 0.00969090685248375, 0.01864594966173172, -0.027779772877693176, -0.03009898215532303, -0.03062175214290619, 0.005067600402981043, 0.01729147881269455, -0.0007408791570924222, -0.00931931659579277, 0.011564735323190689, 0.0026252756360918283, 0.007190250325948, 0.027091704308986664, -0.02804953046143055, -0.0002712913847062737, 0.02690252847969532, -0.00482330983504653, 0.01613481715321541, 0.05534609407186508, -0.010901159606873989, 0.06209421902894974, -0.0021744698751717806, -0.0647946149110794, 0.010603739880025387, 0.004558579996228218, -0.014140763320028782, -0.022271787747740746, 0.01710670068860054, -0.011444383300840855, -0.01170678436756134, 0.046685900539159775, 0.015589014627039433, 0.0016293913358822465, 0.005511896219104528, -0.06141335889697075, -0.041083626449108124, 0.007039599120616913, 0.011950429528951645, 0.05208568274974823, -0.08862001448869705, -0.01073860190808773, 0.012895775958895683, 0.043947648257017136, 0.002987977582961321, 0.015168610960245132, -0.0018674202729016542, 0.022876305505633354, -0.02631283551454544, -0.03400081396102905, 0.010438586585223675, -0.024829551577568054, -0.03049391880631447, -0.001593106659129262, -0.06835097074508667, -0.011970452964305878, 0.01291847974061966, -0.01948663592338562, -0.02487753890454769, 0.056082192808389664, -0.003534184768795967, -0.007988953962922096, -0.06477610766887665, -0.026972895488142967, -0.06676995009183884, 0.0973859503865242, -0.011251728981733322, 0.01234236266463995, 0.05614005774259567, -0.03349963203072548, 0.04540923982858658, 0.008133066818118095, 0.016611600294709206, 0.06151298061013222, -0.052456602454185486, -0.0038273101672530174, -0.029981091618537903, 0.019569696858525276, 0.04330924525856972, -0.0053479732014238834, -0.021806346252560616, 0.0008235914283432066, -0.0067362431436777115, 0.02118610590696335, 0.004790511913597584, -0.014529477804899216, -0.033464863896369934, 0.012158581987023354, -0.04019526019692421, -0.019012877717614174, -0.052335500717163086, -0.0006836954271420836, -0.012279273942112923, -0.04587354138493538, -0.013162902556359768, 0.0245052520185709, 0.02519224025309086, -0.015874307602643967, -0.0328734889626503, -0.037439506500959396, 0.014528931118547916, 0.049618687480688095, -0.010160458274185658, -0.014809164218604565, 0.051789410412311554, 0.05111462622880936, -0.0035398928448557854, 0.03731381520628929, -0.030822882428765297, -0.02240574359893799, 0.0221242718398571, -0.022736798971891403, 0.0009266816778108478, -0.03148851543664932, 0.004348130896687508, -0.015373882837593555, 0.03650825098156929, -0.0049385009333491325, -0.0019044516375288367, -0.024173876270651817, 0.043492600321769714, 0.06563670933246613, 0.006597840692847967, 0.0021648360416293144, 0.0025854266714304686, 0.018992090597748756, 0.0487525537610054, -0.025898991152644157, -0.008360300213098526, -0.04792969301342964, 0.0043753404170274734, 0.02896958403289318, -0.028370343148708344, -0.021320758387446404, 0.007974743843078613, 0.05977607145905495, -0.023524336516857147, 0.00958459172397852, 0.020387426018714905, -0.008346764370799065, -0.007643943652510643, -0.0016626095166429877, -0.005766146816313267, 0.0037752005737274885, -0.003834230126813054, 0.04801945015788078, -0.005553095135837793, 0.025241293013095856, -0.009889261797070503, -0.012334060855209827, 0.01742011308670044, -0.05117521062493324, -0.009241626597940922, 0.026509998366236687, -0.006983114406466484, 0.030858388170599937, -0.01334209181368351, -0.022020386531949043, 0.030742298811674118, -0.003327504498884082, -0.039555177092552185, 0.04694092273712158, 0.033905740827322006, 0.003870996180921793, 0.08798656612634659, -0.04911992326378822, -0.013652036897838116, 0.005321217700839043, -0.06561664491891861, -0.005846268497407436, -0.020664365962147713, -0.024910593405365944, -0.036243170499801636, 0.03810904920101166, 0.046980567276477814, 0.04767167195677757, 0.017034733667969704, -0.044886473566293716, -0.01651649735867977, -0.002423785859718919, -0.021721582859754562, 0.05465813726186752, -0.008731627836823463, -0.0035579500254243612, 0.024283993989229202, -0.019086215645074844, -0.040648188441991806, 0.006166326813399792, 0.022891657426953316, -0.018811915069818497, -0.011533061973750591, -0.013561034575104713, -0.019258959218859673, -0.023460134863853455, -0.03412642329931259, 0.019350215792655945, 0.01919177919626236, -0.025356583297252655, 0.02623440884053707, -0.00709135876968503, -0.016469702124595642, 0.02388107031583786, -0.033174414187669754, 0.016386568546295166, -0.04546917602419853, 0.00012455206888262182, 0.019523004069924355, 0.03452669829130173, 0.01610010676085949, 0.032015107572078705, -0.011769376695156097, -0.028726238757371902, -0.04255462437868118, -0.030699875205755234, -0.011208771727979183, 0.005865472834557295, 0.0035790582187473774, 0.024583881720900536, 0.04190218821167946, 0.04581945389509201, 0.010052286088466644, -0.01781598851084709, -0.04388558119535446, -0.033468980342149734, -0.049981724470853806, -0.009407902136445045, 0.006297004409134388, -0.008391219191253185, 0.029273467138409615, 0.014198231510818005, 0.012182939797639847, 0.04437953606247902, 0.043060265481472015, -0.029472529888153076, -0.0027293541934341192, 0.019277069717645645, -0.003225632244721055, -0.02827916108071804, 0.02665857784450054, 0.019095800817012787, 0.011002626270055771, 0.006933253724128008, -0.017667151987552643, 0.0309292059391737, -0.014283210970461369, -0.018316416069865227, -0.008196623995900154, -0.005353768356144428, 0.06418322771787643, -0.009800620377063751, 0.021151935681700706, 0.030316811054944992, -0.02954775281250477, 0.00017289715469814837, 0.01676417700946331, 0.0890093445777893, -0.04425935819745064, -0.0159761980175972, 0.036187928169965744, 0.03921380266547203, -0.023947956040501595, -0.025475267320871353, 0.009974829852581024, 0.008305074647068977, 0.031332582235336304, -0.02686934731900692, -0.019937247037887573, 0.04554622992873192, 0.007388066966086626, 0.005938492715358734, 0.022807184606790543, -0.009658885188400745, 0.03689509630203247, -0.0798548236489296, 0.004468135070055723, 0.005454946309328079, 0.044345512986183167, 0.05604102835059166, -0.0015824140282347798, 0.053493816405534744, 0.014654251746833324, 0.001480812905356288, 0.0020124923903495073, -0.04152321815490723, 0.044783029705286026, 0.012598992325365543, -0.0009210697025991976, -0.038180187344551086, -0.014644534327089787, 0.026259955018758774, -0.02956293150782585, 0.01584048382937908, 0.015011440962553024, 0.004942258819937706, -0.020886028185486794, -0.01864202320575714, -0.0219930037856102, -0.016732940450310707, -0.01461219321936369, 0.03053406812250614, -0.007123336661607027, -0.016729479655623436, 0.029860887676477432, 0.032088764011859894, 0.006916732061654329, -0.050252530723810196, -0.021136993542313576, 0.028894973918795586, 0.003950993996113539, 0.03152795135974884, -0.010834445245563984, 0.015610603615641594, -0.044568680226802826, 0.002600142965093255, 0.00808712188154459, 0.06384716928005219, 0.041072551161050797, -0.011459214612841606, -0.009918618015944958, -0.011536229401826859, -0.03640136122703552, -0.008922402746975422, 0.039578936994075775, -0.008908017538487911, 0.0024367591831833124, 0.02800903469324112, 0.039334315806627274, -0.04282066226005554, 0.032985083758831024, 0.06342923641204834, 0.03251386061310768, 0.005708490964025259, -0.03139106184244156, -0.0008914484060369432, -0.02104400098323822, 0.01693134754896164, -0.0004729673091787845, -0.0029017082415521145, 0.028425021097064018, -0.026091570034623146, 0.03074989840388298, -0.03722596541047096, -0.026813948526978493, -0.0015788176096975803, 0.017641466110944748, 0.025570310652256012, -0.02992020733654499, -0.0002178617869503796, -0.0018378699896857142, -0.009774232283234596, 0.03839043900370598, -0.008539536967873573, 0.0010237189708277583, -0.07389754801988602, -0.0516844242811203, 0.018545925617218018, -0.003298084484413266, -0.002678000135347247, -0.03623412176966667, -0.06396522372961044, 0.016462424769997597, 0.045748040080070496, -0.035099249333143234, 0.026673367246985435, -0.013286092318594456, 0.022342119365930557, -0.02296062745153904, 0.003268273314461112, -0.07852134108543396, 0.002257837448269129, -0.01861875131726265, 0.01437663845717907, 0.01703658327460289, -0.005013959016650915, -0.06563758105039597, 0.04474935680627823, -0.019188903272151947, 0.07412716746330261, -0.02387508563697338, -0.03754064440727234, -0.011982457712292671, -0.019419891759753227, -0.015283449552953243, -0.045314688235521317, -0.013703797943890095, -0.0064519545994699, 0.00859117228537798, 0.030831074342131615, 0.011882330290973186, -0.010055550374090672, 0.02988331764936447, 0.01819545030593872, -0.025404060259461403, -0.016604769974946976, 0.0039335279725492, 0.026936424896121025, 0.04899778589606285, 0.03346148878335953, 0.022851260378956795, 0.020753968507051468, 0.023592598736286163, 0.01301613450050354, -0.08343895524740219, 0.02339210920035839, -0.022028852254152298, -0.01564241573214531, -0.05428246781229973, -0.021046744659543037, 0.00304750120267272, 0.019079916179180145, -0.01380445808172226, 0.0038133596535772085, -0.05633056163787842, -0.009455611929297447, 0.04045596718788147, 0.056276772171258926, -0.009923288598656654, -0.021743550896644592, 0.03769426420331001, 0.023343242704868317, -0.023931970819830894, 0.0024126472417265177, 0.01354696974158287, -0.02592713199555874, -0.012156356126070023, 0.03022809512913227, -0.02874874323606491, 0.02410736307501793, 0.01309341099113226, -0.00830268394201994, -0.02981415204703808, -0.043974801898002625, 0.027828896418213844, 0.0013106726109981537, 0.033903349190950394, -0.018135279417037964, -0.0412481352686882, -0.01005842350423336, -0.02212042547762394, -0.014440136961638927, 0.016416199505329132, -0.05465063080191612, 0.06357254087924957, -0.0068972231820225716, 0.018528621643781662, -0.060637980699539185, -0.07447029650211334, -0.009963441640138626, -0.0060995533131062984, -0.024552013725042343, -0.047969914972782135, -0.010634152218699455, 0.012034926563501358, 0.020482491701841354, -0.00909128412604332, 0.002401059027761221, -0.034774914383888245, -0.03966682031750679, -0.012276233173906803, -0.009024110622704029, 0.08330973982810974, 0.0064847394824028015, 0.02573615126311779, 0.019613848999142647, -0.012896137312054634, -0.02338794618844986, 0.0002853850310202688, 0.0033084817696362734, -0.02443939447402954, -0.03491467982530594, -0.00522130960598588, -0.010991505347192287, 0.045573242008686066, -0.003179664723575115, 0.0181565098464489, -0.00486391969025135, 0.025865094736218452, 0.01603018306195736, -0.058921098709106445, -0.04900693893432617, -0.03122333064675331, -0.008241715840995312, -0.03481345623731613, 0.0019293719669803977, -0.017745021730661392, 0.019481955096125603, 0.0007718097767792642, 0.02182029001414776, 0.011757243424654007, 0.03574158623814583, 0.08313854783773422, 0.00942661426961422, 0.008877095766365528, -0.019270088523626328, -0.012022381648421288, 0.029783863574266434, 0.02660270966589451, -0.029941733926534653, 0.01591542921960354, 0.03844144567847252, -0.02870098128914833, 0.008513635024428368, -0.054846424609422684, 0.016692591831088066, 0.03135323151946068, 0.0019726832397282124, 0.061948999762535095, 0.026549069210886955, -0.0010479665361344814, 0.0021813507191836834, -0.032514866441488266, -0.04716908559203148, -0.04787883907556534, 0.038501396775245667, 0.051428236067295074, -0.024754250422120094, -0.01966455765068531, 0.054882049560546875, 0.005955668166279793, 0.014655076898634434, 0.04817448928952217, -0.026195906102657318, 0.022774292156100273, 0.0031722516287118196, 0.03194296360015869, -0.05644768849015236, 0.000056552020396338776, 0.006207439582794905, 0.00872583407908678, -0.04714849963784218, -0.027248095721006393, 0.004336005542427301, 0.01152767427265644, -0.024183519184589386, 0.0003950955579057336, -0.026407212018966675, -0.03969525918364525, -0.04586231708526611, 0.014106654562056065, -0.009007616899907589, 0.0067102136090397835, -0.010744493454694748, 0.020092392340302467, -0.01947576366364956, 0.004800908733159304, -0.035767562687397, -0.06101636216044426, -0.044885195791721344, -0.05419708415865898, -0.028468145057559013, 0.04341456666588783, -0.005367052275687456, -0.017010292038321495, 0.03836236894130707, -0.015237061306834221, 0.04427406191825867, 0.0026333776768296957, 0.027876462787389755, 0.03414146602153778, 0.04479385167360306, -0.023731926456093788, 0.0229630209505558, -0.04506826400756836, -0.034066349267959595, 0.11736570298671722, 0.08360318839550018, 0.03895718604326248, -0.05974636226892471, 0.0161933321505785, -0.0095883309841156, 0.0066900309175252914, 0.0064976830035448074, 0.023864438757300377, 0.024983352050185204, 0.01663636416196823, 0.037864018231630325, 0.03449347987771034, 0.014454400166869164, 0.04347796365618706, 0.05211111158132553, -0.03110700659453869, -0.012563440948724747, -0.007641133852303028, 0.04013299569487572, 0.019555095583200455, 0.007277518045157194, -0.09441017359495163, -0.008077175356447697, 0.003740791929885745, 0.0003562822821550071, -0.05035192519426346, -0.03699555993080139, -0.00554111460223794, 0.02955360896885395, -0.05266192555427551, 0.0016493357252329588, 0.041381727904081345, 0.014148736372590065, 0.028735967352986336, -0.03090614825487137, 0.01591084524989128, -0.012330245226621628, -0.04917142167687416, 0.06214127317070961, -0.0019929816480726004, 0.015597475692629814, -0.01563013345003128, 0.01628182642161846, -0.022790897637605667, -0.0470442995429039, -0.015713080763816833, -0.008582929149270058, -0.04853034019470215, -0.026500888168811798, 0.01879722625017166, 0.011411904357373714, 0.006526358425617218, -0.05562950298190117, -0.03247333690524101, 0.031776074320077896, 0.014754245057702065, 0.039832353591918945, 0.027526140213012695, -0.004717128351330757, 0.026680557057261467, -0.010966152884066105, 0.018621377646923065, 0.011844758875668049, 0.002466656034812331, 0.010701211169362068, -0.05491497367620468, 0.07821458578109741, -0.037531476467847824, 0.0034024722408503294, 0.026873428374528885, 0.001460474100895226, -0.03185710683465004, -0.059947945177555084, 0.024126142263412476, 0.009513949044048786, -0.008256364613771439, 0.018212994560599327, -0.010650331154465675, -0.0020301237236708403, -0.04327787086367607, 0.017332065850496292, -0.013112678192555904, 0.011789515614509583, -0.021457508206367493, -0.006207719910889864, 0.050647981464862823, 0.04442038759589195, 0.026541592553257942, 0.0023141857236623764, -0.00846999790519476, 0.050762321799993515, -0.0014989039627835155, -0.012040774337947369, -0.018530985340476036, 0.07117284834384918, -0.02424050308763981, -0.014525656588375568, -0.010126875713467598, 0.10295078903436661, 0.035341084003448486, -0.0003870586515404284, 0.014332740567624569, 0.024459900334477425, -0.007781175430864096, -0.021126560866832733, 0.01477263867855072, -0.04689527302980423, -0.014401300810277462, -0.027447283267974854, -0.017181064933538437, -0.02754378505051136, -0.03639262914657593, -0.06811801344156265, -0.05508105829358101, 0.023526795208454132, 0.019961770623922348, -0.023667266592383385, 0.013863124884665012, -0.009308804757893085, -0.030659379437565804, -0.0042893546633422375, -0.01280025765299797, -0.030223717913031578, -0.009168481454253197, -0.018984679132699966, -0.021519992500543594, -0.01058141142129898, 0.018275616690516472, -0.05056646838784218, -0.0034825957845896482, 0.015525243245065212, 0.02927464246749878, 0.012001915834844112, 0.0065211826004087925, -0.01648946851491928, 0.05011533200740814, 0.0488656647503376, -0.034446120262145996, 0.01144033670425415, 0.006259097717702389, -0.056178171187639236, -0.04841626062989235, 0.0022449844982475042, -0.019988778978586197, 0.028906619176268578, 0.028445443138480186, -0.013591420836746693, -0.02487906999886036, 0.05658169835805893, -0.008788651786744595, 0.0029589305631816387, -0.0034389395732432604, 0.0004814225831069052, 0.04487791657447815, 0.030688375234603882, -0.008442454971373081, -0.04470611363649368, -0.018469834700226784, 0.008274064399302006, 0.040767960250377655, 0.013275861740112305, -0.03565843030810356, 0.010431342758238316, 0.0060736993327736855, 0.01893211342394352, 0.01649697683751583, -0.033139340579509735, 0.026556095108389854, 0.009347355924546719, -0.03751245141029358, 0.01786632463335991, -0.018682992085814476, 0.03766699135303497, -0.09959200769662857, -0.03218218684196472, 0.016341356560587883, -0.03125259280204773, 0.005585384555160999, -0.04440189525485039, -0.0304268728941679, 0.002065094420686364, -0.011106928810477257, 0.013591733761131763, -0.0015234139282256365, -0.002024158602580428, -0.041625723242759705, 0.02658812887966633, -0.012021660804748535, 0.034102827310562134, 0.03549285605549812, 0.0371813140809536, 0.011711619794368744, -0.02253086306154728, 0.0029975806828588247, -0.03323184326291084, -0.03798918426036835, 0.020830154418945312, 0.012077681720256805, -0.04564792662858963, 0.029566066339612007, -0.0554049089550972, 0.006832316983491182, 0.022270679473876953, -0.012290673330426216, 0.023937247693538666, 0.06147417426109314, -0.026921594515442848, 0.0260226521641016, 0.03354429453611374, 0.01084155309945345, -0.011233069933950901, -0.03885570168495178, 0.008848853409290314, 0.00956051703542471, -0.005131670739501715, -0.01599988527595997, -0.007778221741318703, 0.036831602454185486, -0.01487390324473381, -0.011776869185268879, 0.04409733787178993, -0.033008866012096405, -0.015855364501476288, -0.044070906937122345, 0.031729474663734436, 0.045212339609861374, -0.05172766372561455, 0.02330273576080799, -0.012929911725223064, -0.035326991230249405, 0.03656953573226929, 0.0176224485039711, -0.01237484160810709, 0.010288736782968044, 0.030549196526408195, -0.04263978451490402, -0.02147868275642395, 0.0120388213545084, -0.016825424507260323, 0.00273268879391253, 0.04114995896816254, -0.0010695795062929392, 0.011939589865505695, 0.012679891660809517, -0.007252759300172329, -0.041616424918174744, 0.05952105671167374, -0.02580270916223526, 0.0004929968854412436, 0.030339684337377548, -0.011003812775015831, 0.003033659653738141, -0.08295337855815887, 0.04285198077559471, -0.022068137302994728, -0.004691686015576124, -0.0513402484357357, 0.00786565337330103, -0.03178481385111809, 0.03299480304121971, 0.06175579875707626, 0.04796454682946205, -0.00007013228605501354, -0.02758275344967842, 0.04974936321377754, 0.027182573452591896, -0.04768461361527443, 0.0035588634200394154, 0.005505038425326347, -0.04367678612470627, 0.02515140362083912, -0.0008475231006741524, -0.016901057213544846, 0.03895428031682968, 0.0027520875446498394, 0.0023413309827446938, 0.025812482461333275, 0.002373319584876299, -0.04137304797768593, 0.006250710226595402, -0.020960647612810135, -0.012931104749441147, 0.025542302057147026, 0.005967045668512583, -0.002235613064840436, 0.044802211225032806, -0.008157052099704742, -0.06281527131795883, 0.0009357000235468149, -0.04140009358525276, -0.05127463862299919, -0.023171287029981613, -0.019010568037629128, 0.0023666154593229294, -0.02946920320391655, 0.018005704507231712, 0.009549961425364017, -0.014728475362062454, -0.02715812809765339, 0.03954993188381195, 0.019593536853790283, 0.04025356471538544, -0.01476525329053402, -0.004489016719162464, 0.004714475013315678, -0.022481970489025116, 0.02988750860095024, -0.018461741507053375, 0.024578670039772987, -0.0009641932556405663, 0.013071736320853233, 0.01330659445375204, 0.01765546016395092, 0.018622785806655884, 0.0032280320301651955, 0.07006698101758957, 0.004199684131890535, -0.021386800333857536, 0.02813018299639225, -0.02562892809510231, 0.011124631389975548, -0.023818589746952057, -0.018527189269661903, 0.021795956417918205, -0.02518979273736477, 0.0006391545757651329, -0.04839366301894188, -0.05237705260515213, -0.0195783581584692, 0.0036833141930401325, -0.01814911514520645, 0.04290374368429184, -0.015724366530776024, -0.005015095230191946, 0.015031907707452774, -0.027276067063212395, 0.050057489424943924, 0.000536395120434463, -0.007283167447894812, -0.03564503788948059, 0.016814107075333595, 0.01046357024461031, 0.012980402447283268, 0.003752090036869049, -0.004125279374420643, 0.0430104024708271, 0.039019182324409485, 0.011911093257367611, -0.040314216166734695, -0.03315896540880203, -0.015679780393838882, 0.032620012760162354, -0.0492427721619606, -0.04507894814014435, -0.008781087584793568, 0.011722128838300705, 0.03867597505450249, -0.051137663424015045 ]
<p>The structural form of the linear simultaneous equations model <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simultaneous_equations_model" rel="nofollow">simultaneous equations model</a> can be written as</p> <p>$ \mathbf{y}_{i}^{\prime}\Gamma+\mathbf{x}_{i}^{\prime}\mathbf{B}=\epsilon_{i}^{\prime} $</p> <p>which can be written in the reduced form model as</p> <p>$ \mathbf{y}_{i}^{\prime} =-\mathbf{x}_{i}^{\prime}\mathbf{B}\Gamma^{-1}+\epsilon_{i}^{\prime}\Gamma^{-1}\\ =\mathbf{x}_{i}^{\prime}\Pi+\mathbf{v}_{i}^{\prime}. $</p> <p>The reduced form model can be estimated with different estimation methods and if the model is identified the structural coefficients $\widehat{\mathbf{B}}$ can be obtained by using the relation $\widehat{\mathbf{B}}=\widehat{\Pi}\widehat{\Gamma}$.</p> <p>I wonder how to drive the variance-covariance matrix of $\widehat{\mathbf{B}}$. I'd highly appreciate if you point out me any reference. Thanks in advance for your help and time.</p>
1,034
[ -0.011639740318059921, -0.005821429193019867, 0.021758971735835075, -0.03459049016237259, 0.0508020780980587, -0.002319068182259798, -0.006319217849522829, -0.004339538514614105, 0.04804549738764763, -0.044306013733148575, 0.0008285490330308676, 0.047383178025484085, 0.0494895838201046, 0.02347562275826931, 0.016375331208109856, -0.009391911327838898, 0.013474542647600174, 0.005116976331919432, -0.04114750772714615, -0.0010198606178164482, -0.003931250888854265, -0.001616748282685876, 0.01538331899791956, 0.022460103034973145, -0.0034092827700078487, 0.04489099234342575, 0.0466512069106102, -0.03302657604217529, -0.003509218106046319, 0.04394866153597832, -0.011633937247097492, -0.02264411188662052, 0.004732056520879269, 0.023270726203918457, -0.00008567704207962379, -0.010024167597293854, -0.008787941187620163, -0.05282818153500557, 0.003481899853795767, 0.04290514066815376, -0.03383117541670799, 0.001791781629435718, -0.033149585127830505, 0.0265984907746315, 0.0006980521720834076, 0.022856466472148895, -0.02279534563422203, 0.014059129171073437, 0.02384231984615326, -0.023811357095837593, 0.12059099227190018, 0.008985002525150776, 0.04023004323244095, 0.03798380494117737, -0.04353129863739014, -0.01451194193214178, 0.0485154390335083, 0.053306493908166885, -0.005124459508806467, -0.03989032655954361, -0.0006585492519661784, 0.00521377008408308, 0.03344852477312088, -0.00515188742429018, -0.017737776041030884, -0.0006530116079375148, -0.007869435474276543, -0.012834538705646992, 0.02434401959180832, -0.031294919550418854, 0.033428143709897995, 0.0032162261195480824, 0.03777778521180153, -0.02186577208340168, 0.009990695863962173, -0.05753689631819725, 0.018987063318490982, 0.030734539031982422, -0.007611571811139584, 0.05517798289656639, -0.021359913051128387, -0.006980172358453274, -0.016443908214569092, 0.024128155782818794, 0.009069879539310932, 0.007146753836423159, 0.0370585173368454, -0.015357756055891514, 0.033302221447229385, -0.0016291252104565501, -0.038981541991233826, 0.019380327314138412, 0.017656201496720314, -0.00033213276765309274, -0.05322648584842682, 0.039775554090738297, -0.009469644166529179, 0.06064603850245476, 0.03968536853790283, -0.008238383568823338, -0.012641368433833122, -0.05972065404057503, 0.008414247073233128, 0.0563957616686821, -0.0018883880693465471, -0.010492398403584957, 0.011504663154482841, 0.01604088395833969, -0.0375160314142704, -0.058022238314151764, -0.029122186824679375, -0.006741395685821772, 0.007927420549094677, -0.01031800452619791, 0.0308074913918972, -0.03107326105237007, 0.008329329080879688, -0.007291673682630062, 0.05979934334754944, 0.10143604129552841, 0.05258214473724365, -0.03211302310228348, 0.010031607002019882, -0.01752479001879692, -0.0709969699382782, -0.017754610627889633, 0.013304299674928188, -0.05159619823098183, -0.03858165442943573, 0.03706447407603264, 0.025316676124930382, -0.027405349537730217, 0.03303741663694382, -0.0015802597627043724, 0.04292610287666321, 0.00989812333136797, -0.12007161974906921, -0.05938216298818588, 0.02454272098839283, -0.0034391647204756737, 0.035953231155872345, -0.06352739781141281, 0.008482063189148903, -0.010683790780603886, 0.06944635510444641, -0.014047110453248024, -0.006459321826696396, 0.025732718408107758, 0.017014864832162857, 0.02288671024143696, -0.013748807832598686, -0.016136400401592255, -0.010462239384651184, 0.006037319544702768, -0.03239649161696434, -0.08115340769290924, -0.0037212094757705927, -0.011106452904641628, -0.026353951543569565, 0.02534981071949005, 0.0537961944937706, 0.011961791664361954, -0.03909200057387352, 0.022413985803723335, -0.012826330028474331, -0.05063793808221817, 0.03987854719161987, -0.026576226577162743, 0.003572315676137805, 0.020123424008488655, -0.018433671444654465, -0.056042734533548355, 0.009245737455785275, 0.02774127759039402, 0.02596469409763813, -0.046716585755348206, -0.004275940824300051, 0.04039468243718147, -0.019072989001870155, 0.03036590665578842, -0.06974510848522186, -0.03473348543047905, -0.014503641054034233, -0.011768479831516743, 0.053583838045597076, 0.03439456224441528, -0.0010273914085701108, -0.016667230054736137, 0.019123129546642303, -0.04208721965551376, -0.026641443371772766, -0.06955619156360626, -0.006739648059010506, 0.0033728538546711206, 0.0013998845824971795, 0.025198815390467644, -0.022936975583434105, 0.006147151812911034, 0.01627456210553646, -0.003279438242316246, -0.021990396082401276, 0.019416814669966698, 0.04330837354063988, 0.00015598935715388507, 0.0269512627273798, -0.0019438678864389658, 0.06872235983610153, -0.023232514038681984, 0.02435825578868389, -0.009103495627641678, -0.014711866155266762, 0.0064339349046349525, -0.07058393210172653, 0.02428315579891205, 0.010311796329915524, -0.023934289813041687, 0.012074013240635395, -0.019219089299440384, -0.0030262756627053022, 0.02941718138754368, -0.07791315764188766, 0.02268478274345398, 0.10147906094789505, 0.010466678999364376, 0.04260271042585373, 0.02825942449271679, 0.015378295443952084, 0.03621098771691322, -0.017878185957670212, -0.02981625683605671, -0.006891509518027306, -0.0171313788741827, 0.02767910063266754, -0.02076839841902256, -0.06831449270248413, 0.04497261717915535, 0.026254521682858467, 0.03659532219171524, 0.016069989651441574, 0.031119974330067635, -0.03266991674900055, -0.02271389029920101, 0.003253698581829667, 0.02168874628841877, -0.005238455720245838, 0.021692080423235893, -0.03635884448885918, 0.019803214818239212, 0.030113400891423225, 0.007560056168586016, 0.013511596247553825, 0.03802909702062607, 0.01817145012319088, -0.01265526283532381, -0.000643684237729758, -0.012751762755215168, 0.07917308807373047, -0.003372188424691558, 0.032138723880052567, 0.02936892956495285, -0.026554450392723083, 0.0029408137779682875, 0.017912916839122772, -0.010133267380297184, 0.03895420581102371, 0.014390532858669758, 0.007569783832877874, 0.020532947033643723, -0.0031669463496655226, -0.023478850722312927, -0.01653364859521389, -0.020244436338543892, -0.0031552899163216352, -0.050478048622608185, 0.0003284673730377108, 0.035718515515327454, 0.010031717829406261, 0.017041148617863655, -0.03316166624426842, 0.015992596745491028, -0.008885493502020836, 0.003016664646565914, 0.042554982006549835, -0.005202800501137972, -0.03862811252474785, 0.002510442165657878, -0.025214118883013725, 0.02317836508154869, 0.017116013914346695, -0.02948182076215744, -0.02033797837793827, 0.03284817188978195, -0.00793356541544199, -0.05281268060207367, -0.0377311110496521, 0.015910768881440163, -0.0015308877918869257, -0.01575181446969509, -0.03346511721611023, 0.03473648056387901, 0.012911975383758545, -0.033469490706920624, -0.0052664754912257195, -0.05274512991309166, -0.032831136137247086, -0.027359502390027046, -0.004822302609682083, -0.006017268635332584, 0.007110722362995148, 0.04793490469455719, 0.014989673160016537, -0.01443195715546608, -0.0017265361966565251, -0.08267826586961746, -0.02862641215324402, 0.00009074688568944111, 0.043421171605587006, 0.0019947681576013565, 0.028994625434279442, -0.043247342109680176, 0.05509982630610466, 0.01597544550895691, -0.003945836331695318, -0.054303836077451706, 0.0033130322117358446, 0.013613250106573105, -0.05732849985361099, 0.026559676975011826, 0.031006231904029846, 0.011460092850029469, 0.029712755233049393, 0.009253187105059624, 0.04337363690137863, 0.04578786715865135, 0.00903331208974123, 0.0062270076014101505, 0.0010938398772850633, -0.02404830791056156, -0.02253590151667595, 0.01578659564256668, 0.003042785217985511, 0.01294702012091875, 0.0036497809924185276, -0.004200739320367575, 0.024452224373817444, 0.011346392333507538, -0.06417158246040344, 0.006023833993822336, -0.033809538930654526, -0.027341358363628387, -0.05748007073998451, 0.005263487808406353, 0.008362541906535625, -0.016778578981757164, -0.026637334376573563, 0.005094488151371479, 0.03486776351928711, 0.007253056392073631, 0.015728987753391266, 0.011984089389443398, 0.04652918502688408, -0.028178898617625237, -0.02839922159910202, 0.001212407136335969, -0.014498347416520119, 0.0524895116686821, -0.013438054360449314, 0.005393395200371742, 0.04845941811800003, 0.05123582109808922, 0.007661278825253248, -0.015183803625404835, -0.008437907323241234, -0.014941742643713951, -0.08407846838235855, 0.015960074961185455, -0.019520720466971397, 0.06880367547273636, 0.03173566237092018, 0.03476114198565483, 0.004812055267393589, -0.03769384324550629, -0.009242747910320759, -0.008446253836154938, -0.0593840554356575, 0.013560488820075989, -0.01673717051744461, 0.04405471310019493, 0.011034417897462845, -0.0042087300680577755, 0.04123768210411072, -0.011389534920454025, -0.014161464758217335, 0.003635526169091463, 0.01897723786532879, -0.03968863561749458, 0.00841849111020565, -0.02764691412448883, -0.012716060504317284, 0.0005037051741965115, 0.01817263476550579, 0.004853840917348862, -0.0760837271809578, -0.005625945050269365, 0.03758591040968895, -0.008711771108210087, -0.023816166445612907, -0.02946394495666027, -0.006877004634588957, 0.014614895917475224, 0.03231703117489815, 0.009533580392599106, -0.000313963188091293, -0.03874913603067398, 0.007071615196764469, 0.010202095843851566, 0.016955798491835594, 0.040725428611040115, -0.0012706562411040068, -0.041359834372997284, -0.003127653617411852, -0.008115753531455994, 0.0205873753875494, 0.003032268490642309, 0.011976649053394794, 0.0007570291054435074, 0.0678880363702774, 0.06984314322471619, -0.01803436689078808, 0.04506649449467659, 0.059175316244363785, 0.00552252447232604, 0.03602840378880501, -0.021238280460238457, 0.04053064435720444, -0.00021366441796999425, -0.010635570622980595, 0.03672127053141594, 0.008910050615668297, -0.009406555444002151, -0.014873629435896873, 0.07275088131427765, 0.005552683956921101, -0.004100005608052015, 0.020299838855862617, 0.022008763626217842, 0.05054362490773201, 0.040853068232536316, -0.003993788734078407, -0.01475868932902813, 0.06771387159824371, 0.027222145348787308, 0.03344285860657692, 0.016018925234675407, -0.06859871745109558, -0.014083603397011757, 0.011537852697074413, 0.0014633357059210539, -0.045391663908958435, 0.01330630574375391, -0.018567075952887535, -0.0371982716023922, 0.008783811703324318, -0.024035340175032616, 0.02584856189787388, -0.026553314179182053, 0.03539811074733734, -0.026624491438269615, -0.04721745103597641, -0.01679774932563305, 0.03792643919587135, -0.02229590155184269, 0.024973219260573387, 0.005883645731955767, -0.007911544293165207, -0.0007206902955658734, 0.011308984830975533, 0.01649371348321438, 0.04804402217268944, 0.005713863298296928, -0.03420925885438919, 0.02310996875166893, 0.013981318101286888, -0.05033814162015915, -0.07654161006212234, 0.020430514588952065, 0.012498711235821247, -0.005913169123232365, 0.05186130851507187, 0.00045014332863502204, -0.03738868981599808, 0.01733030006289482, 0.024084698408842087, 0.005282542202621698, -0.01646336354315281, -0.051015522330999374, 0.04147949814796448, 0.006171264685690403, -0.009511738084256649, 0.05281073600053787, -0.0017590571660548449, -0.039619330316782, -0.010727914981544018, -0.05332399159669876, 0.004500365816056728, -0.013802899047732353, -0.007534370757639408, -0.038655124604701996, 0.011530513875186443, -0.02295820601284504, 0.0443078950047493, 0.0009093330008909106, 0.008160478435456753, -0.013432355597615242, -0.029974287375807762, 0.0006698197685182095, 0.03803229704499245, -0.054771699011325836, -0.01148238405585289, 0.015630293637514114, 0.014131390489637852, 0.013013803400099277, -0.05297701805830002, 0.00601353170350194, 0.002453154418617487, 0.0032231207005679607, 0.014661207795143127, -0.007252571173012257, -0.0030325709376484156, 0.00470268540084362, -0.04081953689455986, -0.01701643504202366, -0.03642755001783371, 0.038861386477947235, -0.03783579170703888, -0.004513301886618137, 0.021852290257811546, -0.04455184563994408, 0.03927870839834213, 0.01020911056548357, 0.020181095227599144, -0.0001309946965193376, -0.01858924888074398, 0.015983600169420242, -0.00761202210560441, -0.04263002797961235, -0.08816113322973251, -0.04333879426121712, 0.014624213799834251, -0.015231870114803314, 0.0041319928131997585, -0.03458849713206291, 0.007122726179659367, -0.03958678990602493, -0.050507478415966034, 0.005913557019084692, 0.03124694712460041, -0.021795006468892097, 0.017937105149030685, -0.023940417915582657, 0.04461197555065155, 0.02680344507098198, 0.005814497824758291, -0.015621905215084553, 0.027950864285230637, -0.03468324989080429, -0.004205379169434309, -0.002650185488164425, 0.037486057728528976, -0.006773225497454405, -0.005141483619809151, -0.048966094851493835, 0.005865359213203192, 0.05182527005672455, -0.01877506449818611, -0.020551642403006554, 0.026100801303982735, -0.0022911829873919487, -0.011246748268604279, -0.03782450035214424, -0.02397509291768074, -0.008755221031606197, 0.0615055076777935, 0.01556886825710535, 0.02208014391362667, -0.049100395292043686, 0.000867191469296813, 0.051717035472393036, -0.011669565923511982, -0.0401897057890892, 0.022018983960151672, 0.04392995685338974, 0.001071079052053392, 0.018967781215906143, 0.030945440754294395, -0.015205852687358856, 0.07316935807466507, 0.03715737909078598, 0.023377982899546623, -0.009295652620494366, 0.00282640615478158, -0.03591497987508774, -0.013492723926901817, -0.06228914111852646, -0.018738003447651863, 0.08009929955005646, -0.0019099998753517866, 0.038271464407444, 0.04866268113255501, 0.0004999169614166021, -0.015879882499575615, -0.04737486317753792, -0.001103449729271233, -0.056374628096818924, 0.017284970730543137, 0.06291858851909637, -0.05384983867406845, -0.01838253252208233, 0.04015270620584488, 0.07110250741243362, 0.02313823625445366, 0.04883391410112381, 0.04169899970293045, 0.011894061230123043, 0.005253333132714033, -0.024498971179127693, -0.03155184164643288, 0.05379728227853775, -0.017366787418723106, 0.003483828855678439, -0.013006075285375118, -0.0016993620665743947, 0.03815704956650734, 0.05851801857352257, 0.02201012894511223, -0.02410353161394596, -0.027534199878573418, -0.04122229292988777, 0.019240424036979675, 0.004056662321090698, -0.039071373641490936, 0.0016595212509855628, 0.014582037925720215, 0.05364464595913887, 0.007152399513870478, 0.04120491072535515, -0.02439083158969879, -0.07654495537281036, -0.004765674937516451, 0.013521185144782066, 0.008775437250733376, 0.02381228469312191, -0.031055495142936707, -0.013448219746351242, 0.010473542846739292, -0.02237481065094471, 0.015747621655464172, -0.03310023620724678, 0.0017640175065025687, -0.014286195859313011, 0.06582142412662506, -0.008773211389780045, -0.010320290923118591, 0.0017426235135644674, 0.003358683083206415, 0.11563845723867416, 0.05875501409173012, 0.04799697548151016, -0.0677167996764183, 0.0007891096756793559, 0.028179991990327835, 0.01822752319276333, -0.03931288421154022, 0.014255222864449024, 0.010369139723479748, -0.020707305520772934, 0.02945622056722641, 0.05186186730861664, 0.028573360294103622, 0.003530384274199605, 0.00794178992509842, -0.030546586960554123, -0.04740415886044502, -0.0009961826726794243, 0.023568348959088326, 0.0034235911443829536, -0.008485537022352219, -0.020872488617897034, 0.008726896718144417, -0.01849084533751011, -0.055920206010341644, -0.021090440452098846, -0.03428985923528671, -0.0006812948267906904, -0.004371419548988342, -0.0034763840958476067, 0.03324306756258011, 0.05073166266083717, 0.04509919136762619, -0.0008892088662832975, 0.0019890207331627607, 0.026982758194208145, -0.00834984052926302, 0.03422325477004051, 0.012486432678997517, -0.012985806912183762, 0.018745457753539085, 0.01547151617705822, -0.0019355487311258912, -0.044250503182411194, -0.009154681116342545, -0.018665987998247147, 0.04333210363984108, 0.005229546222835779, -0.003905061399564147, -0.03722818195819855, 0.005096380598843098, 0.006339830346405506, -0.014871867373585701, -0.020707203075289726, 0.03783363476395607, 0.015325726009905338, -0.06437259167432785, -0.04954996705055237, -0.02965962141752243, 0.009302213788032532, -0.008285115472972393, 0.04512006789445877, 0.018247364088892937, -0.0326753668487072, -0.012058118358254433, -0.043388888239860535, 0.04854585975408554, 0.016195954754948616, 0.008190157823264599, -0.00446501187980175, -0.04539147764444351, 0.012286708690226078, -0.04497617855668068, 0.035691626369953156, 0.024226320907473564, -0.03198729828000069, -0.022472985088825226, 0.021457936614751816, -0.04026656597852707, -0.07492955029010773, 0.014590037055313587, -0.003966996446251869, -0.03167512267827988, -0.012279528193175793, -0.007478531915694475, 0.005192732438445091, 0.05020749196410179, -0.05864011496305466, -0.007273073308169842, 0.007011163979768753, 0.04579724371433258, 0.0012983566848561168, -0.06608471274375916, -0.052513834089040756, 0.025080908089876175, -0.02680562622845173, -0.01409718208014965, 0.02746800146996975, 0.014084416441619396, 0.0031524398364126682, 0.021655479446053505, -0.016428394243121147, 0.06911676377058029, -0.015916218981146812, -0.002777714282274246, 0.02654428780078888, -0.03092765063047409, 0.03616776317358017, -0.002906354609876871, 0.015481889247894287, 0.008908928371965885, 0.03608408570289612, -0.010432698763906956, -0.01617623120546341, 0.0016388840740546584, -0.023972785100340843, -0.04629647731781006, -0.0211294237524271, -0.029751960188150406, 0.013789701275527477, -0.06614141911268234, 0.015392615459859371, -0.04788089916110039, 0.010677746497094631, -0.019154947251081467, 0.00007658892718609422, 0.015557259321212769, 0.019690195098519325, -0.020654702559113503, -0.00561020290479064, 0.0513540543615818, 0.008956598117947578, 0.03931095078587532, -0.0126415453851223, -0.00258363364264369, 0.007157089654356241, 0.039683036506175995, -0.02407371811568737, -0.022259807214140892, 0.011706025339663029, -0.023404646664857864, 0.027401188388466835, 0.02251841127872467, 0.005292271263897419, 0.047106433659791946, 0.018865428864955902, -0.010513911023736, 0.0002550033968873322, 0.05422761291265488, -0.016845842823386192, 0.009778762236237526, 0.0073167625814676285, -0.015188971534371376, 0.00025509612169116735, -0.008448786102235317, 0.0252715814858675, 0.013832831755280495, -0.04346127063035965, 0.05665694549679756, 0.003093794686719775, -0.02866698056459427, -0.006990932859480381, 0.01682814210653305, 0.011953397653996944, 0.020312698557972908, 0.014545802026987076, -0.0011784688103944063, 0.018856223672628403, 0.02355387806892395, -0.01381539087742567, 0.016993790864944458, 0.005029600579291582, 0.018319258466362953, -0.06538383662700653, -0.030692996457219124, -0.014959012158215046, 0.03049139678478241, 0.023845700547099113, -0.04072452336549759, 0.0232707466930151, 0.03260284289717674, -0.026214975863695145, 0.0018985262140631676, 0.01133777480572462, 0.021726690232753754, -0.0027297064661979675, 0.00161995948292315, -0.015319046564400196, 0.05668368190526962, -0.0031072322744876146, 0.015786485746502876, 0.0329485684633255, 0.03971124067902565, 0.0019537119660526514, -0.054169490933418274, -0.026548827067017555, -0.014425347559154034, 0.019045168533921242, -0.0657285675406456, 0.0479472354054451, -0.008771450258791447, -0.042063888162374496, 0.04245125502347946, 0.01132397260516882, 0.03975887969136238, 0.020195260643959045, 0.044952571392059326, -0.012440481223165989, 0.04152097925543785, 0.054425761103630066, -0.007299409713596106, 0.015721192583441734, 0.0004426314262673259, 0.02232161909341812, 0.012336687184870243, 0.020572928711771965, 0.03169182687997818, -0.017950251698493958, 0.02057335339486599, -0.029278529807925224, -0.03352879732847214, -0.04043355584144592, -0.03496663272380829, -0.009887170977890491, -0.041982557624578476, 0.03682614117860794, -0.0427282340824604, 0.02501274086534977, -0.04741109535098076, -0.004064367152750492, 0.043580375611782074, 0.005598261021077633, -0.039762482047080994, 0.03441993519663811, -0.01698259264230728, -0.05191998928785324, 0.009218903258442879, 0.01028108038008213, 0.036451924592256546, -0.06977567821741104, -0.03495674207806587, 0.03560630604624748, -0.01192377507686615, -0.06088670343160629, 0.0013601667014881968, -0.020873961970210075, 0.04721555858850479, -0.011738384142518044, 0.006413010414689779, -0.013149367645382881, -0.02220309153199196, 0.005493214353919029, -0.035334646701812744, 0.002527279546484351, 0.024194834753870964, -0.04874178767204285, -0.024054959416389465, -0.009775909595191479, 0.01813535764813423, -0.022185200825333595, 0.06194393336772919, 0.010408353060483932, 0.0011265778448432684, 0.0024734430480748415, 0.031778834760189056, -0.01062844693660736, -0.060484495013952255, 0.031272921711206436, 0.013847017660737038, -0.03079495206475258, 0.019111761823296547, -0.048441264778375626, 0.0031716707162559032, -0.00182374007999897, 0.016499698162078857, -0.002180586103349924, 0.005805050488561392, 0.00503799133002758, -0.044806573539972305, -0.007353601977229118, 0.005483204033225775, -0.01753152534365654, 0.06981660425662994, -0.009141783230006695, -0.004816907923668623, 0.03687503561377525, -0.007084369659423828, -0.034214552491903305, 0.0013737640110775828, -0.04437887296080589, -0.008524836972355843, 0.001118038664571941, -0.02196843922138214, 0.003667575540021062, -0.05357993766665459, -0.009794207289814949, 0.0032117476221174, -0.019772088155150414, -0.01340835727751255, 0.03495973348617554, 0.005655229557305574, 0.015982912853360176, 0.034613240510225296, 0.0006439897115342319, 0.016958873718976974, -0.04754066467285156, 0.024947622790932655, 0.02748076058924198, 0.04425344616174698, 0.01785586029291153, -0.00017109762120526284, -0.006513973698019981, 0.0021807043813169003, 0.027452128008008003, -0.04597543179988861, 0.01698419451713562, -0.010636278428137302, -0.00025476657901890576, 0.012548151426017284, 0.01733683981001377, 0.03247787058353424, -0.032250698655843735, -0.01257854700088501, 0.08599457144737244, -0.03695416823029518, -0.004164210520684719, 0.01635490357875824, 0.03254209831357002, -0.04672396555542946, 0.028965551406145096, 0.026655305176973343, 0.009080575779080391, 0.012985162436962128, -0.015676651149988174, -0.014589156955480576, -0.058822304010391235, -0.016918795183300972, -0.020695611834526062, -0.0006905882619321346, 0.026738710701465607, -0.028883712366223335, -0.018765689805150032, -0.029522784054279327, -0.05767195299267769, -0.021426720544695854, 0.019977224990725517, -0.000778289744630456, 0.020509585738182068, -0.028564097359776497, -0.01023140549659729, 0.0046032811515033245, 0.06980511546134949, -0.09464608132839203, -0.0009692826424725354, -0.04430224001407623, -0.01365261897444725, -0.026472993195056915, 0.00883025024086237 ]
<p>I know there are methods to calculate a confidence interval for a proportion to keep the limits within (0, 1), however a quick Google search lead me only to the standard calculation: $\hat{p} \pm 1.96*\sqrt\frac{\hat{p}(1-\hat{p})}{N}$. I also believe there is a way to calculate the exact confidence interval using the binomial distribution (example R code would be nice). I know I can use the prop.test function to get the interval but I'm interested in working through the calculation.</p> <p>Sample situations (N = number of trials, x = number of success):</p> <pre><code>N=40, x=40 N=40, x=39 N=20, x=0 N=20, x=1 </code></pre>
39,847
[ -0.014381291344761848, -0.023159626871347427, -0.023105381056666374, -0.016527125611901283, 0.02306411787867546, -0.011280934326350689, -0.0032329377718269825, -0.04147721081972122, 0.023812729865312576, -0.014262329787015915, 0.056410063058137894, 0.08259756863117218, 0.025195550173521042, 0.04036910831928253, 0.017665034160017967, -0.02134701982140541, -0.021583912894129753, -0.010755032300949097, 0.0014042140683159232, -0.025926781818270683, 0.00858310703188181, 0.00581401726230979, 0.0019085367675870657, -0.008146578446030617, -0.01676436886191368, 0.033500973135232925, 0.05531688034534454, 0.00158743467181921, -0.013063516467809677, 0.07750774919986725, -0.0550229512155056, -0.04273897036910057, 0.02745913900434971, 0.04187729209661484, -0.009782875888049603, -0.007478978484869003, -0.016413986682891846, -0.03466178849339485, -0.020341239869594574, 0.017279306426644325, -0.04106355085968971, -0.0017335942247882485, 0.0018596724839881063, 0.01422163937240839, 0.041450098156929016, 0.008833992294967175, -0.017696674913167953, -0.045187193900346756, 0.045126624405384064, -0.04034621641039848, 0.0911845713853836, 0.011594297364354134, 0.06094764545559883, 0.020397720858454704, 0.017926018685102463, -0.015449674800038338, 0.07768453657627106, 0.06846851110458374, -0.03312717005610466, -0.06529118865728378, -0.029094770550727844, -0.08106248825788498, -0.004265255760401487, -0.030444283038377762, -0.0344940684735775, 0.004953897092491388, -0.02852487936615944, 0.0054500228725373745, 0.034503452479839325, -0.02561541087925434, 0.011239899322390556, 0.03571424260735512, 0.0380401574075222, -0.009646798484027386, 0.002093370072543621, -0.03872692212462425, 0.04850005730986595, 0.023146983236074448, 0.05209853872656822, 0.04977424442768097, -0.001885026111267507, -0.0008509923936799169, 0.053781382739543915, 0.06440677493810654, 0.014208169654011726, -0.018357237800955772, 0.0634213536977768, -0.018318841233849525, 0.03253055363893509, 0.008162888698279858, -0.03228312358260155, -0.030418332666158676, 0.044608838856220245, 0.0006032765959389508, -0.03893082216382027, 0.03870095685124397, -0.025796132162213326, 0.05494117736816406, -0.006090201437473297, -0.028017394244670868, -0.0013932078145444393, -0.029783131554722786, 0.021693388000130653, 0.04760105162858963, -0.025984076783061028, -0.0072334520518779755, -0.03533969819545746, -0.011178109794855118, 0.019905010238289833, -0.021333949640393257, -0.007554411888122559, 0.0597892701625824, 0.01204356737434864, 0.012452422641217709, 0.020242054015398026, -0.02954312413930893, 0.005069514736533165, -0.03858110308647156, 0.06594628095626831, 0.03785296157002449, 0.027653992176055908, 0.000049254376790486276, 0.03085988014936447, -0.023549169301986694, -0.029377523809671402, -0.00978289544582367, 0.007262915372848511, -0.006752063054591417, -0.03276366367936134, 0.03925874084234238, -0.024381257593631744, -0.03133444860577583, 0.04135433956980705, 0.015629980713129044, 0.03249000012874603, -0.006431423127651215, -0.07222434133291245, -0.052988409996032715, 0.016376381739974022, -0.00713413767516613, -0.019160911440849304, -0.0635528564453125, 0.03218996897339821, 0.03624590113759041, 0.018863914534449577, 0.01895328424870968, 0.03597290441393852, -0.015655409544706345, 0.01233377493917942, 0.012951808050274849, -0.051905374974012375, -0.006891293916851282, -0.015524924732744694, 0.007064961828291416, -0.015494544990360737, -0.06691744923591614, 0.04200192168354988, 0.023147152736783028, 0.009505005553364754, -0.03567331284284592, 0.015605256892740726, -0.0002839283552020788, -0.02147534489631653, -0.006235893815755844, 0.014979613944888115, -0.021498067304491997, 0.08532791584730148, 0.003223590785637498, 0.0057747275568544865, 0.002224010182544589, -0.015555129386484623, -0.011749441735446453, 0.03531569987535477, 0.01993658021092415, 0.06808178871870041, -0.03865636885166168, -0.013339720666408539, -0.03807133063673973, 0.02974577620625496, 0.031058546155691147, -0.025907058268785477, 0.00827855709940195, 0.017035868018865585, 0.008983731269836426, 0.017420602962374687, -0.0031718439422547817, 0.006045712623745203, -0.02910071238875389, 0.009315643459558487, -0.04224191978573799, -0.026616808027029037, -0.0943308174610138, -0.0050164805725216866, 0.041519585996866226, -0.019261837005615234, 0.005060904193669558, 0.01880462095141411, 0.032140444964170456, -0.05022158846259117, -0.024719005450606346, -0.02737516723573208, -0.032371535897254944, 0.03564202040433884, -0.059182073920965195, -0.017655426636338234, 0.04922565445303917, 0.06601055711507797, -0.03357250988483429, 0.0733090341091156, -0.049317266792058945, -0.04119417071342468, -0.03514750674366951, -0.047249626368284225, -0.006669613067060709, 0.0008826678385958076, -0.029589662328362465, 0.015900801867246628, -0.00006818981637479737, -0.015693778172135353, 0.024841418489813805, -0.05201025307178497, 0.057381972670555115, 0.07363424450159073, 0.04775159806013107, 0.01770205982029438, -0.030288610607385635, 0.017049334943294525, -0.009255087934434414, -0.013340955600142479, -0.015436451882123947, -0.04073411971330643, -0.023051097989082336, 0.062319789081811905, -0.01369057409465313, -0.04803686961531639, -0.00007317918061744422, 0.058991894125938416, -0.0034915662836283445, 0.017603294923901558, 0.05346975848078728, 0.0010443424107506871, -0.019999394193291664, -0.018251236528158188, 0.03705587983131409, 0.019249528646469116, 0.031488388776779175, 0.014049146324396133, 0.023227021098136902, 0.027976427227258682, 0.05000998079776764, -0.010044924914836884, 0.011065487749874592, -0.011001274921000004, -0.024126200005412102, -0.006677534431219101, -0.04532180726528168, 0.045363880693912506, -0.017352938652038574, -0.017831575125455856, 0.014208728447556496, 0.03203624114394188, 0.00009027997293742374, 0.01502273976802826, -0.014883948490023613, 0.014700332656502724, 0.060382820665836334, -0.06594006717205048, 0.004064938053488731, -0.0015375814400613308, -0.023654233664274216, -0.009943244978785515, -0.044106625020504, -0.021742185577750206, -0.051405999809503555, 0.0006673097377642989, 0.0119552006945014, 0.012675200589001179, 0.0357583612203598, -0.028244460001587868, -0.022916125133633614, -0.004222238902002573, -0.0007670588092878461, 0.0012139350874349475, -0.03144356608390808, -0.06094925105571747, 0.0070372275076806545, -0.0032776182051748037, -0.03657413274049759, 0.020946120843291283, -0.018878154456615448, -0.024532195180654526, -0.003945364151149988, -0.007492941804230213, -0.02667517028748989, -0.005224147811532021, -0.020466875284910202, 0.0013486401876434684, -0.02286667935550213, -0.0023660953156650066, 0.03353780880570412, 0.03260631859302521, -0.06603635102510452, 0.04210420697927475, -0.0013752552913501859, -0.03435174375772476, -0.04304828867316246, 0.015628907829523087, 0.010462399572134018, -0.020793696865439415, -0.01730906404554844, 0.017629345878958702, -0.0016449326649308205, 0.005512839183211327, -0.06500918418169022, -0.039900291711091995, -0.011822751723229885, 0.020197482779622078, 0.037696219980716705, 0.011176105588674545, 0.015590174123644829, 0.07482855767011642, 0.009081766940653324, -0.015249364078044891, -0.035807132720947266, 0.0008221087628044188, -0.0028820871375501156, 0.027348533272743225, -0.0003199336933903396, 0.033888425678014755, -0.005413847975432873, 0.012497929856181145, -0.004531365353614092, 0.01968831941485405, 0.045192915946245193, 0.024242134764790535, 0.01872253231704235, 0.009392973966896534, -0.002847909228876233, -0.027727318927645683, 0.03094589151442051, 0.02855248562991619, -0.026775453239679337, 0.01826099120080471, 0.004811758641153574, 0.022619372233748436, 0.0021069806534796953, -0.04838240146636963, 0.02457573264837265, -0.0539773628115654, -0.007359231822192669, -0.0409485287964344, 0.04859465733170509, -0.0012605336960405111, 0.0006706764688715339, 0.025860382243990898, 0.023366957902908325, 0.03917697072029114, -0.028201665729284286, 0.006539569701999426, 0.0635463148355484, 0.021646272391080856, -0.010087989270687103, -0.004821574315428734, 0.009257961995899677, -0.009909951128065586, -0.015422411262989044, -0.02005617506802082, -0.00654731597751379, 0.05004248395562172, 0.04872099682688713, 0.0447721928358078, -0.015544229187071323, -0.015186700969934464, 0.04175645858049393, -0.05864863842725754, 0.023141929879784584, -0.033705778419971466, 0.021897250786423683, 0.0017155712703242898, 0.05941426008939743, 0.010889513418078423, -0.01609175279736519, 0.005944886710494757, 0.019953016191720963, -0.06600147485733032, 0.05580448359251022, -0.045674145221710205, -0.04118627309799194, -0.017630917951464653, -0.00828548613935709, 0.018338991329073906, -0.0021774470806121826, 0.00365840015001595, 0.006365197245031595, 0.023081639781594276, -0.0011881584068760276, 0.05104948952794075, -0.0023494164925068617, -0.00918570812791586, 0.0038873301818966866, 0.029383748769760132, -0.006969037465751171, -0.021573832258582115, 0.015662722289562225, 0.03938843309879303, 0.002358307596296072, 0.026584329083561897, -0.0025863242335617542, -0.00510949594900012, 0.0263398215174675, 0.03389427065849304, 0.048512838780879974, 0.0171512383967638, -0.04688848927617073, 0.027377091348171234, -0.027145395055413246, 0.06033163145184517, 0.06344801187515259, -0.03468121215701103, 0.0020802062936127186, -0.01781516522169113, 0.001886760233901441, -0.0018567576771602035, -0.020740430802106857, -0.031402211636304855, 0.02231966145336628, 0.06811220198869705, 0.010021280497312546, -0.08262662589550018, -0.004717512987554073, 0.08097756654024124, 0.009269616566598415, 0.00020487175788730383, -0.06736154854297638, -0.0020208314526826143, -0.004993731621652842, 0.023116013035178185, -0.001355209737084806, 0.020576847717165947, 0.025369543582201004, 0.013132024556398392, 0.05616803839802742, -0.016532516106963158, -0.052162326872348785, 0.0016361016314476728, 0.0088180061429739, 0.06918220221996307, -0.0032003081869333982, -0.04807695746421814, 0.0047197649255394936, 0.01836627535521984, 0.03036949411034584, 0.011578727513551712, 0.002418591408059001, -0.0729842558503151, 0.01190902665257454, 0.04943282529711723, 0.04376868158578873, -0.05028887465596199, -0.004721306264400482, -0.017569981515407562, 0.011870583519339561, 0.04966123029589653, -0.03805546835064888, -0.008000311441719532, -0.04811985045671463, 0.00964051578193903, -0.03774086385965347, 0.015884479507803917, -0.05593407154083252, 0.009840226732194424, -0.02030334435403347, 0.008579682558774948, -0.028512299060821533, -0.00950930081307888, -0.03415569290518761, 0.037740785628557205, 0.04227036237716675, 0.09915235638618469, -0.03890594467520714, -0.0253969244658947, 0.0012023833114653826, -0.015198069624602795, -0.018958326429128647, -0.06839573383331299, 0.0024422567803412676, 0.012812924571335316, -0.006730542052537203, 0.03317415341734886, -0.020464641973376274, -0.02509564347565174, 0.0520768016576767, 0.0031245050486177206, -0.03755661100149155, -0.010348089039325714, -0.030782224610447884, 0.03029063530266285, 0.0069234962575137615, 0.007836523465812206, 0.047118641436100006, -0.002994459355250001, -0.013746838085353374, 0.004690920934081078, -0.0342085026204586, 0.02823563851416111, -0.012104308232665062, 0.002869211370125413, -0.03951292112469673, -0.0008458250667899847, -0.029178932309150696, 0.03300515189766884, 0.008032810874283314, 0.013211921788752079, 0.010415679775178432, 0.022554488852620125, 0.006206276826560497, 0.013597749173641205, 0.023192178457975388, 0.004170187748968601, 0.013266793452203274, 0.010855166241526604, -0.01867983676493168, 0.006660567596554756, 0.014182908460497856, 0.00011234437261009589, 0.004712405614554882, -0.003204441862180829, -0.03887848183512688, 0.020784219726920128, -0.03383868560194969, -0.04175788536667824, 0.014566916041076183, -0.036635156720876694, 0.04651467502117157, -0.04388700798153877, 0.010098892264068127, -0.04799554869532585, -0.03662210702896118, -0.017642159014940262, 0.023703617975115776, 0.0068738688714802265, 0.04945780336856842, -0.0438666045665741, 0.010758345946669579, -0.018220290541648865, 0.016074731945991516, -0.06480953097343445, -0.04768076166510582, 0.03799827769398689, 0.019442595541477203, -0.024429159238934517, -0.05477017164230347, -0.017788834869861603, 0.004081169608980417, -0.025670763105154037, -0.023860927671194077, 0.037694286555051804, -0.03016366809606552, -0.03349553048610687, -0.03191076219081879, -0.006807318888604641, 0.06333041936159134, 0.007337260525673628, -0.01014826912432909, -0.005006137304008007, -0.023142660036683083, -0.037423327565193176, 0.04827709123492241, -0.014927823096513748, -0.02789919078350067, -0.04532771557569504, -0.046532489359378815, 0.03566891700029373, 0.03345600515604019, -0.01719502918422222, -0.02344437688589096, -0.016054637730121613, 0.008665531873703003, 0.006844623945653439, -0.04094056412577629, -0.009790166281163692, -0.017166027799248695, 0.022587422281503677, -0.017746372148394585, 0.006056919693946838, -0.031602416187524796, 0.01622695103287697, 0.04337489232420921, -0.007092268206179142, 0.011060062795877457, 0.0037295198999345303, 0.08493924885988235, -0.017952051013708115, -0.006047705188393593, 0.00629253126680851, -0.02136918529868126, 0.011362098157405853, 0.03409823030233383, -0.024948006495833397, 0.02831242047250271, -0.009887629188597202, -0.010121101513504982, -0.011145314201712608, -0.040120337158441544, 0.0002866635040845722, 0.023280469700694084, 0.01826128177344799, 0.04166445508599281, 0.02197195775806904, 0.03473665192723274, -0.008772931061685085, 0.02558467723429203, -0.02452154830098152, -0.0013744219904765487, 0.05350464582443237, 0.036085113883018494, 0.012413379736244678, 0.0005869255401194096, 0.047329168766736984, 0.013468848541378975, 0.018846217542886734, 0.05482714623212814, 0.0060701691545546055, -0.013304498977959156, 0.045052576810121536, -0.024904975667595863, -0.0012995076831430197, 0.011329189874231815, -0.05105693265795708, -0.006238142028450966, -0.05926981940865517, -0.0320499986410141, 0.03824988752603531, 0.008627170696854591, -0.014230655506253242, 0.010920069180428982, -0.032528799027204514, -0.008206362836062908, -0.004263236653059721, 0.017666224390268326, -0.0029972107149660587, 0.035492297261953354, 0.012126201763749123, 0.0034596212208271027, -0.02214149758219719, 0.04677378386259079, 0.013448132202029228, -0.06352737545967102, -0.02566617541015148, -0.023849526420235634, -0.04966098442673683, 0.03974617272615433, 0.020935365930199623, -0.01010625809431076, 0.02445112355053425, -0.015002246014773846, 0.004561534617096186, 0.018989991396665573, 0.03192267194390297, 0.0009172094287350774, 0.07244886457920074, 0.033729132264852524, 0.026819594204425812, -0.0044220807030797005, 0.007682969328016043, 0.1038222685456276, 0.11110392212867737, 0.01596020720899105, -0.0762704610824585, 0.017447423189878464, 0.0007277537370100617, -0.006935318000614643, -0.02434956096112728, 0.00476732337847352, 0.01973438262939453, -0.040118344128131866, 0.06271377205848694, 0.05323722958564758, 0.001932083978317678, -0.024964267387986183, 0.05984735116362572, -0.02663111872971058, -0.03827407583594322, -0.004823287483304739, 0.037780120968818665, -0.02774571254849434, -0.0433521494269371, -0.03527900204062462, 0.017682060599327087, 0.0039301724173128605, 0.0034228265285491943, -0.028960460796952248, -0.015534132719039917, -0.014269453473389149, -0.0034688743762671947, 0.00043700149399228394, -0.033860478550195694, -0.0017269423697143793, -0.021849902346730232, -0.006123620085418224, -0.022527486085891724, 0.020101839676499367, -0.002976661315187812, -0.010136869736015797, 0.04512087628245354, -0.004824105184525251, 0.01826799102127552, -0.010769138112664223, 0.04341266304254532, -0.0381825752556324, -0.029234327375888824, -0.03910848870873451, 0.008927376009523869, -0.00260580494068563, 0.010919474996626377, -0.012177504599094391, -0.02515244670212269, -0.01570364460349083, -0.03738708794116974, -0.023013176396489143, 0.033985525369644165, 0.03824954479932785, -0.016240641474723816, -0.026566119864583015, -0.013400597497820854, 0.012726521119475365, 0.0003623077063821256, 0.029678918421268463, 0.016284579411149025, 0.0022480201441794634, -0.023256177082657814, -0.028454257175326347, 0.0175704974681139, -0.006831881124526262, -0.01321788877248764, 0.03521937504410744, -0.026309378445148468, -0.04876745864748955, 0.01802050694823265, 0.03781011328101158, 0.0045171077363193035, 0.03732619807124138, -0.006544295698404312, -0.015496697276830673, 0.027721110731363297, -0.03621077910065651, 0.014212106354534626, -0.04343351349234581, 0.004311971832066774, -0.04238513112068176, -0.013678052462637424, 0.022436749190092087, 0.03588726744055748, -0.013879280537366867, 0.04218456149101257, -0.016080716624855995, 0.032804518938064575, 0.02502770721912384, -0.019579360261559486, -0.03292282298207283, 0.010305777192115784, -0.040865350514650345, -0.012523945420980453, -0.02459152229130268, 0.06518155336380005, 0.028517112135887146, 0.009962375275790691, -0.00042860570829361677, 0.0024589395616203547, -0.022603675723075867, 0.008740831166505814, -0.017342841252684593, -0.04211897403001785, -0.031522590667009354, 0.026694446802139282, 0.022171638906002045, -0.03713452070951462, -0.025497913360595703, -0.03394576162099838, -0.03877488896250725, 0.008273609913885593, -0.010330541990697384, -0.026187753304839134, -0.0014219983713701367, 0.01576920785009861, -0.03682989999651909, -0.010525709018111229, -0.0067051369696855545, -0.03484651446342468, -0.016282863914966583, -0.017251180484890938, 0.0011766088427975774, 0.00021076561824884266, 0.007974812760949135, 0.000489050755277276, 0.027636531740427017, 0.04500529170036316, -0.0035202933941036463, 0.004774886649101973, 0.0030861967243254185, 0.012119948863983154, 0.023087870329618454, 0.01218419335782528, -0.02493005245923996, -0.012126664631068707, 0.06122981756925583, -0.059060368686914444, -0.05082404613494873, 0.004015191458165646, 0.008672773838043213, 0.05081534385681152, 0.03183247521519661, -0.008562006987631321, -0.004899737425148487, 0.044175662100315094, -0.024195091798901558, -0.027123156934976578, 0.0014684665948152542, 0.012532530352473259, -0.012659707106649876, 0.022102685645222664, 0.00949113443493843, 0.0029269468504935503, -0.010259488597512245, 0.019495729357004166, 0.054501283913850784, 0.017357749864459038, 0.008930525742471218, 0.03327971696853638, -0.007799040526151657, 0.02201862260699272, 0.04578617960214615, -0.0346100777387619, -0.007321628276258707, 0.05621271952986717, -0.025841806083917618, 0.04935657978057861, -0.03756172955036163, 0.019944578409194946, -0.09403615444898605, -0.013586537912487984, -0.013965381309390068, 0.03356197476387024, 0.029351787641644478, -0.05032883211970329, 0.012530125677585602, 0.016402175650000572, -0.0262916199862957, 0.03367855027318001, -0.012904324568808079, 0.015784548595547676, -0.02357419580221176, 0.02195890061557293, -0.020958932116627693, 0.03396308794617653, 0.01869388483464718, 0.01975623145699501, 0.037982381880283356, -0.003047647885978222, -0.005499585065990686, -0.014488957822322845, 0.010218493640422821, 0.019103605300188065, 0.020848408341407776, -0.07925675809383392, 0.008155225776135921, -0.015626218169927597, -0.02341322787106037, 0.03786398842930794, 0.008981551975011826, 0.037741243839263916, 0.028048912063241005, 0.0552375353872776, -0.001427859882824123, 0.05664754658937454, 0.028632592409849167, 0.012508541345596313, -0.011041390709578991, 0.017080435529351234, 0.019782841205596924, 0.0014246251666918397, -0.05886831879615784, 0.0035042259842157364, 0.046067412942647934, -0.000976906274445355, -0.04739537090063095, 0.020232511684298515, 0.00009082968608709052, -0.013817688450217247, -0.020284347236156464, -0.01236000470817089, -0.010097655467689037, -0.03692931681871414, 0.043191488832235336, -0.054036300629377365, -0.01852397993206978, 0.023552263155579567, 0.019013911485671997, -0.033943843096494675, 0.00475437194108963, -0.028833730146288872, -0.018298303708434105, -0.0018616359448060393, -0.006166836712509394, -0.031472839415073395, -0.06321264803409576, 0.01863117702305317, -0.009738560765981674, 0.03113500215113163, 0.0012027466436848044, -0.015042217448353767, -0.020034125074744225, 0.040867555886507034, -0.02525716833770275, -0.03891483694314957, 0.027228303253650665, 0.012662507593631744, 0.002087917411699891, -0.08987514674663544, 0.06102710962295532, 0.00557700963690877, -0.03433620557188988, -0.032240308821201324, 0.03136973828077316, -0.02031470090150833, -0.025711791589856148, 0.04179906100034714, 0.023516980931162834, -0.021660178899765015, -0.012485845014452934, 0.03927997872233391, 0.001277861651033163, -0.08524200320243835, 0.014565899968147278, -0.017328493297100067, -0.025681840255856514, -0.036413561552762985, -0.01957128383219242, -0.004462916404008865, 0.022427013143897057, 0.010987538844347, 0.012863102369010448, 0.005795090924948454, -0.0028837155550718307, -0.0034420457668602467, 0.0373019240796566, 0.029102925211191177, 0.01356302946805954, 0.05211183428764343, -0.0024438370019197464, -0.002604738576337695, 0.04931256175041199, 0.04214789718389511, -0.06790689378976822, 0.03511405363678932, -0.03694535046815872, -0.01929100789129734, 0.003229125402867794, 0.0023514474742114544, -0.00999478343874216, -0.058949366211891174, 0.006141012534499168, 0.012128777801990509, -0.03840844705700874, 0.028639325872063637, -0.008363636210560799, 0.003016020404174924, 0.0197269506752491, -0.013179907575249672, -0.016817735508084297, -0.0007332475506700575, -0.010292675346136093, 0.006565449759364128, -0.00976778008043766, 0.024181479588150978, -0.04578939080238342, 0.03757519647479057, 0.03369611129164696, -0.003760863561183214, 0.036512576043605804, 0.03707516938447952, 0.03845256194472313, -0.006368878297507763, -0.015944352373480797, 0.033912111073732376, -0.049870412796735764, 0.014529041945934296, -0.011047570034861565, -0.02889859862625599, 0.04736475273966789, 0.0004471618449315429, 0.037014495581388474, -0.035410743206739426, -0.021409625187516212, -0.030940596014261246, -0.0035300380550324917, 0.022527432069182396, 0.03344050794839859, -0.019326666370034218, 0.014057183638215065, 0.01219982374459505, -0.016274895519018173, 0.03253238648176193, -0.016589198261499405, 0.0508398599922657, -0.005179369822144508, 0.02908271737396717, -0.04137340188026428, -0.04359070211648941, -0.029143383726477623, -0.023287566378712654, 0.013880709186196327, -0.002067422494292259, 0.0313270203769207, 0.01522710919380188, -0.0248569268733263, 0.002890415955334902, 0.05044400319457054, -0.04247450828552246, -0.021415291354060173, -0.012818059884011745, 0.0036482883151620626, -0.007937694899737835, -0.014742291532456875 ]
<p>Okay I have given this a go but I think it is totally wrong. Can someone please make this correct for me ? To understand the MA(q) model I really need to plug some numbers into it as I', finding these time series formula epically confusing as it is never explained what any of it actually is in the real world.</p> <pre><code> Model : y = c + u + .5 et-1 + .25 et-2 + .125 et -3 Ya t Yf t mean U e t Actual Y at time t Forecast Y at time t 1.69% error at time t (et 0 is made up) y = c + u + .5 et-1 + .25 et-2 + .125 et -3 Yf t - Mean u 0 1.69% 0.03 1 0.63% 1.69% -1.06% 2 1.13% 1.69% -0.56% 3 1.36% 1.69% -0.33% 4 0.97% 1.69% -0.72% 5 1.11% 1.69% -0.58% 6 0.88% 1.69% -0.81% 7 0.90% 1.69% -0.79% 8 1.06% 1.69% -0.63% 9 1.38% 1.69% -0.31% 10 0.96% 1.69% -0.73% 11 1.29% 1.69% -0.40% 12 1.39% 1.69% -0.30% 13 0.98% 1.69% -0.71% 14 1.42% 1.69% -0.27% 15 1.21% 1.69% -0.48% 16 1.04% 1.69% -0.65% 17 1.45% 1.69% -0.24% 18 1.11% 1.69% -0.58% 19 1.92% 1.69% 0.23% 20 1.89% 1.69% 0.20% 21 2.00% 1.69% 0.31% 22 1.40% 1.69% -0.29% 23 2.15% 1.69% 0.46% 24 2.11% 1.69% 0.42% 25 1.76% 1.69% 0.07% 26 2.55% 1.69% 0.86% 27 1.80% 1.69% 0.11% 28 2.23% 1.69% 0.54% 29 2.39% 1.69% 0.71% 30 1.55% 1.69% -0.14% 31 2.67% 1.69% 0.99% 32 2.50% 1.69% 0.81% 33 1.88% 1.69% 0.20% 34 2.18% 1.69% 0.49% 35 2.42% 1.69% 0.73% 36 1.75% 1.69% 0.06% 37 2.54% 1.69% 0.85% 38 2.03% 1.69% 0.34% 39 2.08% 1.69% 0.39% 40 2.58% 1.69% 0.89% 41 1.71% 1.69% 0.02% 42 1.56% 1.69% -0.13% 43 1.98% 1.69% 0.29% 44 1.85% 1.69% 0.16% 45 1.66% 1.69% -0.03% 46 2.19% 1.69% 0.50% 47 1.52% 1.69% -0.17% 48 1.75% 1.69% 0.06% 49 1.92% 1.69% 0.23% </code></pre> <p>FORECAST 50 1.80% 1.69% 0.11% FORECAST 51 1.81% 1.69% 0.12% FORECAST 52 1.81% 1.69% 0.12% FORECAST 53 1.79% 1.69% 0.10% FORECAST 54 1.79% 1.69% 0.10% FORECAST 55 1.78% 1.69% 0.09% FORECAST 56 1.77% 1.69% 0.08% FORECAST 57 1.76% 1.69% 0.07% FORECAST 58 1.76% 1.69% 0.07% FORECAST 59 1.75% 1.69% 0.06% FORECAST 60 1.75% 1.69% 0.06% FORECAST 61 1.74% 1.69% 0.05%</p> <p>I have tried to do this to the step that I am upto before estimating the first error term for t = 0 and parameters of the model but it does not look right. Hope you can follow this it is hard to get the formatting right. It just looks like it ends up being too similar to the mean to be useful. I want something which tries to predict the random patterns seen in the time series, for example you can see when the point goes up, it is very rarely higher in the very next point.</p> <p>The formula for the forecasting is basically to take the mean and multiply it by the last 3 error terms and multiply by the coefficients that I just made up. Thanks. Thanks.</p> <p>As a side note I really find the notations and explanation about this to be very confusing.</p> <p>Thanks.</p>
31,305
[ -0.004323144908994436, -0.029303673654794693, 0.0036299065686762333, -0.018456514924764633, 0.057944975793361664, -0.00993107259273529, -0.008344518020749092, -0.03246872127056122, 0.01059007365256548, -0.02107734978199005, 0.026551740244030952, 0.043449513614177704, 0.0517936535179615, 0.021486615762114525, 0.007590740453451872, 0.029947586357593536, 0.015014695934951305, 0.010599189437925816, 0.00871512945741415, -0.017363455146551132, 0.010684335604310036, 0.008677403442561626, 0.009880322962999344, 0.02138565108180046, -0.04406595230102539, 0.061219386756420135, 0.04716489464044571, 0.000765472068451345, -0.005222655367106199, 0.021494891494512558, -0.027928151190280914, -0.001752156880684197, 0.010530595667660236, 0.005369305610656738, 0.008082466199994087, 0.048035234212875366, 0.00630963034927845, -0.02418122999370098, 0.00547460000962019, 0.04457269236445427, -0.015808310359716415, 0.002004627836868167, -0.015237235464155674, 0.021741217002272606, 0.0055262986570596695, -0.004372913856059313, 0.040729936212301254, 0.003118791850283742, 0.057876862585544586, -0.025063905864953995, 0.11375453323125839, -0.006325815338641405, 0.027300797402858734, 0.024912454187870026, -0.026238610967993736, -0.025985796004533768, 0.054646968841552734, 0.0533723346889019, -0.002162948017939925, -0.05256609618663788, 0.004521454218775034, 0.03003161959350109, -0.0016169067239388824, -0.06286394596099854, 0.004722360987216234, 0.02943573147058487, 0.0009641682263463736, 0.0066027152352035046, 0.04708431288599968, -0.04528164491057396, 0.03937021642923355, 0.0037783696316182613, 0.008747350424528122, 0.04375768452882767, 0.003256590571254492, -0.021095987409353256, 0.015605651773512363, 0.038083285093307495, 0.014269386418163776, 0.015347451902925968, 0.005082780960947275, 0.006039558444172144, 0.04541478678584099, 0.026975831016898155, 0.00567850423976779, 0.01513494923710823, 0.0755288377404213, -0.008254974149167538, 0.011650706641376019, 0.03303784877061844, -0.023263324052095413, 0.01691518723964691, 0.046178799122571945, 0.011074468493461609, -0.03260470926761627, 0.03656427189707756, 0.017210032790899277, 0.027458226308226585, 0.01875963993370533, -0.003960333298891783, -0.01543105486780405, -0.039190590381622314, 0.011251797899603844, 0.015157800167798996, 0.0037537384778261185, -0.044772274792194366, -0.02794506959617138, -0.03413587063550949, -0.013633877970278263, -0.0508793443441391, -0.013719430193305016, 0.011178938671946526, -0.014583274722099304, -0.013182519003748894, -0.010124334134161472, -0.051813799887895584, 0.027361370623111725, -0.03938046470284462, 0.04307008534669876, 0.07371486723423004, 0.05001606419682503, -0.0440860316157341, 0.03222241997718811, -0.005059489049017429, -0.057746950536966324, -0.0031537965405732393, -0.018333179876208305, -0.010943934321403503, -0.003630197374150157, 0.03130680322647095, -0.04854315146803856, -0.03943828120827675, 0.06366324424743652, -0.00042960752034559846, 0.047349680215120316, -0.016439732164144516, -0.09852591902017593, -0.03953879326581955, 0.03685916215181351, -0.01670280285179615, 0.03888414055109024, -0.05111965537071228, 0.0037097493186593056, 0.024837784469127655, 0.04130414500832558, 0.021483518183231354, 0.03822477161884308, 0.0030050610657781363, 0.017224011942744255, 0.010926862247288227, -0.041724350303411484, 0.01156709622591734, -0.016646752133965492, -0.00651088310405612, -0.014682749286293983, -0.053092435002326965, 0.013043482787907124, 0.024667218327522278, -0.03030339814722538, -0.0013228310272097588, -0.00286880973726511, 0.0033992971293628216, -0.02619556337594986, -0.004133621696382761, -0.02604423090815544, -0.07848505675792694, 0.024070145562291145, 0.009647163562476635, 0.0069578359834849834, 0.02660292573273182, -0.017831601202487946, 0.001350240665487945, -0.026738585904240608, 0.01218917965888977, 0.051311805844306946, -0.047729961574077606, 0.027172191068530083, -0.057004690170288086, 0.00345863145776093, 0.0029964055866003036, -0.08682708442211151, -0.03572078049182892, -0.027930641546845436, -0.023021994158625603, 0.0364081934094429, 0.03057112544775009, -0.005657802801579237, -0.01406161580234766, 0.04505857080221176, -0.03269939869642258, -0.07619567215442657, -0.05038478225469589, -0.009358520619571209, -0.053110189735889435, 0.022368231788277626, -0.06041470915079117, -0.02150239422917366, 0.03148045018315315, -0.006215378642082214, -0.012363934889435768, -0.009828836657106876, 0.01530902087688446, 0.0344620943069458, -0.035079777240753174, 0.029123177751898766, 0.032352570444345474, 0.015524196438491344, -0.018262265250086784, 0.03496674820780754, -0.04664801433682442, -0.0004117371281608939, 0.009905366227030754, -0.014347885735332966, 0.0483984537422657, -0.021178290247917175, -0.05756494030356407, 0.03197449818253517, 0.014272836036980152, -0.01510799489915371, -0.013619592413306236, -0.05180594325065613, 0.03073623776435852, 0.03936683386564255, 0.018576953560113907, -0.009704402647912502, 0.01676172763109207, -0.00012714375043287873, 0.068686343729496, -0.03921233490109444, 0.018345128744840622, -0.01345520094037056, -0.0068771871738135815, 0.04284525290131569, 0.0021681117359548807, -0.011383786797523499, 0.019217297434806824, 0.052600275725126266, -0.0009626279934309423, 0.032198335975408554, 0.04414127394556999, 0.018335901200771332, -0.005955621600151062, -0.017731593921780586, -0.01932532899081707, 0.005978749133646488, -0.008051061071455479, 0.03393813222646713, 0.03354928269982338, 0.016608357429504395, -0.0106910839676857, 0.0005924850120209157, 0.037557896226644516, -0.02611052617430687, 0.02028469927608967, -0.029476741328835487, -0.022095199674367905, 0.05455048009753227, -0.02954675629734993, -0.011065690778195858, 0.028246285393834114, -0.0008924083667807281, -0.013079814612865448, 0.011217882856726646, -0.03391195833683014, -0.008967004716396332, 0.03128509968519211, -0.008544588461518288, 0.011585856787860394, 0.014923243783414364, 0.003724740818142891, 0.01429130882024765, -0.016595883294939995, -0.030361436307430267, -0.047265004366636276, 0.01000833697617054, 0.048217788338661194, 0.03754372149705887, 0.033267099410295486, 0.0006978859892114997, -0.020594827830791473, 0.02642420306801796, 0.012284076772630215, 0.03588861972093582, -0.010798504576086998, -0.07255429029464722, -0.007191644981503487, 0.0006050541414879262, -0.009900172241032124, 0.05280144512653351, 0.0032384556252509356, -0.037638552486896515, 0.00688536511734128, -0.022875698283314705, -0.04064027965068817, -0.020216064527630806, -0.05788256600499153, -0.00357882515527308, 0.006209049839526415, -0.034018490463495255, 0.02595389634370804, 0.0034067414235323668, -0.05231372267007828, 0.02887069806456566, -0.05085286125540733, -0.03472132608294487, -0.04175969213247299, 0.0026925443671643734, -0.017565065994858742, 0.003724345238879323, 0.04344036057591438, 0.013226959854364395, -0.015379573218524456, 0.011851849034428596, -0.032672613859176636, -0.028385229408740997, -0.010617189109325409, 0.012033957056701183, 0.02076006308197975, 0.019515248015522957, -0.036545563489198685, 0.05632185935974121, 0.020419271662831306, -0.030312808230519295, 0.00023292044352274388, 0.03356584906578064, 0.002521660178899765, -0.03161240741610527, 0.006379031576216221, 0.02869345434010029, -0.005632979795336723, 0.006110418122261763, -0.039627689868211746, 0.0530606284737587, 0.04151783511042595, -0.007041925098747015, 0.04098047688603401, 0.0069733415730297565, -0.017298825085163116, -0.011958124116063118, 0.033994123339653015, 0.01630670763552189, -0.010579836554825306, 0.02315731719136238, -0.0027248787228018045, 0.06063151732087135, -0.0029568090103566647, -0.02012479491531849, 0.011846438981592655, -0.018042130395770073, -0.011819984763860703, -0.06845686584711075, 0.03217573091387749, -0.05305712670087814, -0.03548990562558174, -0.047107379883527756, 0.0007842120830900967, 0.01918805204331875, 0.02813105657696724, 0.011931288987398148, 0.06225554645061493, 0.023301469162106514, 0.013418403454124928, 0.007959901355206966, -0.03286518529057503, -0.015118216164410114, 0.021357562392950058, -0.028318332508206367, -0.015999488532543182, 0.07173234224319458, 0.05762046203017235, 0.018605850636959076, -0.0173470638692379, -0.008333691395819187, -0.011759212240576744, -0.07456237077713013, 0.029445946216583252, -0.04047761484980583, 0.05126885697245598, 0.033389490097761154, 0.06744419038295746, -0.014006015844643116, -0.025769170373678207, -0.019564218819141388, 0.0015533440746366978, -0.04386164993047714, 0.022506846114993095, -0.0005957660614512861, -0.016910532489418983, -0.025242997333407402, -0.015388465486466885, 0.03905956447124481, -0.05186416953802109, 0.019206508994102478, 0.01068794447928667, -0.013040106743574142, -0.015835393220186234, 0.04077042266726494, -0.00201101740822196, 0.03259117156267166, -0.05238429084420204, -0.03725298494100571, 0.04997095838189125, 0.028476795181632042, 0.02592056430876255, 0.026902608573436737, -0.028210850432515144, -0.04567025601863861, -0.010686867870390415, -0.002774800406768918, 0.07038280367851257, 0.018751896917819977, 0.0532478503882885, -0.01630616933107376, -0.03879862651228905, 0.008290521800518036, 0.018084440380334854, 0.016148852184414864, 0.05768539011478424, -0.006479262840002775, -0.027390051633119583, -0.009828879497945309, -0.038556307554244995, 0.054358839988708496, -0.010468029417097569, 0.031696390360593796, 0.008859831839799881, 0.053644075989723206, 0.0012427355395630002, -0.045610211789608, 0.018848929554224014, 0.06369723379611969, -0.019160369411110878, 0.027747005224227905, -0.08699508011341095, 0.016713609918951988, -0.03123609721660614, 0.012284199707210064, 0.035902462899684906, 0.010421525686979294, 0.013201973401010036, 0.0018321300158277154, 0.026564424857497215, -0.02107902057468891, -0.021363195031881332, 0.001532608293928206, 0.03728991001844406, 0.03464465215802193, 0.04250631853938103, -0.047766152769327164, -0.0074835834093391895, 0.032658711075782776, 0.0343393012881279, 0.020309429615736008, 0.0028715685475617647, -0.08984091132879257, -0.021689746528863907, 0.04313116520643234, 0.04323790967464447, -0.013020713813602924, -0.01687103509902954, -0.07651718705892563, -0.021426450461149216, -0.00044956017518416047, -0.0286522526293993, 0.045348525047302246, 0.015442545525729656, 0.01653873175382614, 0.010365148074924946, -0.07293272763490677, -0.051168184727430344, -0.004808247555047274, -0.0175771564245224, 0.032268259674310684, -0.027283407747745514, -0.028330162167549133, -0.01762690581381321, -0.01577538065612316, 0.03228720277547836, 0.021404210478067398, -0.036013878881931305, -0.0025977164041250944, -0.008136782795190811, 0.0290792528539896, -0.01617174595594406, -0.0462762713432312, 0.00528328400105238, -0.010240992531180382, 0.003967184107750654, 0.023916544392704964, 0.00882553681731224, -0.025799013674259186, 0.02885637804865837, 0.048358988016843796, 0.010615827515721321, -0.018976928666234016, -0.05764307081699371, 0.04131658747792244, 0.009539000689983368, -0.028821805492043495, 0.036275215446949005, -0.020703069865703583, -0.01120584923774004, 0.023904018104076385, -0.04182308539748192, -0.010647639632225037, 0.008240215480327606, 0.03838632255792618, -0.04498617351055145, -0.016958389431238174, -0.004117587115615606, 0.005232640542089939, -0.005992301739752293, 0.011263834312558174, -0.06842001527547836, 0.010000324808061123, 0.0128259202465415, 0.018466748297214508, -0.025368819013237953, -0.0010704494779929519, 0.01390042807906866, -0.027998579666018486, -0.027528442442417145, 0.00717970822006464, 0.003477341728284955, -0.031025748699903488, -0.03552187234163284, 0.030055910348892212, 0.00932241976261139, -0.01811818964779377, 0.0056249164044857025, -0.021805616095662117, -0.02074127458035946, -0.017902452498674393, 0.002182929776608944, -0.016990289092063904, 0.0234331414103508, 0.00489742960780859, -0.002322104759514332, -0.0248070377856493, 0.021603181958198547, 0.009393793530762196, 0.03581910580396652, 0.027381718158721924, 0.01345740258693695, 0.024918517097830772, -0.005291858222335577, -0.05893784761428833, -0.03050314635038376, 0.045559223741292953, -0.029600996524095535, -0.10265538096427917, -0.007884835824370384, -0.04424943029880524, -0.03839736804366112, -0.041408415883779526, 0.0037107891403138638, 0.031935229897499084, -0.05512078106403351, -0.009214408695697784, -0.010741282254457474, 0.01419751439243555, 0.0625443384051323, -0.005631831008940935, 0.00008113576768664643, 0.015707138925790787, -0.016698019579052925, -0.035886604338884354, 0.02670472301542759, 0.018404245376586914, -0.04628763720393181, 0.020800083875656128, -0.05298914015293121, -0.022503172978758812, 0.0717277005314827, -0.014092409051954746, -0.004452321212738752, -0.013762659393250942, 0.033465441316366196, 0.011971323750913143, -0.011351674795150757, 0.04149780794978142, -0.000190173348528333, -0.00251388899050653, 0.006733484100550413, -0.0071611893363296986, -0.0349888876080513, 0.01710926927626133, 0.0489099845290184, -0.036231569945812225, -0.04108593612909317, 0.016727380454540253, 0.05349620431661606, -0.020577702671289444, -0.011876198463141918, -0.012321566231548786, -0.0022985958494246006, 0.016474265605211258, 0.03702220320701599, 0.012232077307999134, 0.004751221742480993, 0.022626571357250214, -0.015828968957066536, -0.012732132337987423, -0.054207734763622284, -0.0016559751238673925, 0.05542311444878578, 0.018030408769845963, 0.028631016612052917, -0.004988221451640129, 0.02119261585175991, -0.012311462312936783, -0.004986720625311136, -0.0555063858628273, 0.018825219944119453, -0.02085324004292488, 0.024610986933112144, 0.00659192493185401, -0.021128151565790176, 0.015461007133126259, 0.014710153453052044, 0.04236002266407013, 0.027279166504740715, 0.04855408892035484, -0.007716766092926264, -0.00594228133559227, 0.012397854588925838, -0.030322585254907608, 0.032833658158779144, -0.0207854975014925, 0.011880512349307537, -0.022457696497440338, 0.027946343645453453, 0.05608220770955086, 0.04090997204184532, -0.042687565088272095, -0.0630250796675682, -0.011717814952135086, -0.06310147792100906, 0.00887711439281702, 0.011853850446641445, -0.003971830476075411, 0.019673770293593407, 0.01402550470083952, 0.0383562408387661, -0.019761350005865097, 0.07186553627252579, -0.014015956781804562, -0.06986358761787415, -0.030542688444256783, 0.0063283368945121765, -0.018339253962039948, 0.05344356968998909, -0.01287121046334505, -0.012109648436307907, -0.02441360615193844, -0.03911765292286873, 0.014835802838206291, 0.02184305526316166, 0.0002896227815654129, -0.02075306326150894, 0.06860079616308212, 0.007201830390840769, 0.007602396886795759, -0.028460286557674408, -0.023482048884034157, 0.15715894103050232, 0.059742361307144165, 0.0035606182646006346, -0.05571116879582405, 0.00012215068272780627, 0.02251432277262211, -0.0026995709631592035, -0.007190612144768238, -0.010455170646309853, 0.01468608621507883, -0.006388288456946611, 0.048718445003032684, 0.028653142973780632, 0.03316349908709526, -0.004643843974918127, 0.05040520429611206, -0.02677234262228012, -0.030799895524978638, 0.006260296795517206, 0.007217450067400932, -0.0050973049364984035, 0.009359977208077908, -0.04740177094936371, -0.0021996621508151293, -0.01514583732932806, -0.01097872108221054, -0.017277980223298073, -0.032282453030347824, -0.009520886465907097, -0.013781069777905941, -0.03369763493537903, 0.01856265217065811, -0.03457702696323395, -0.014891956932842731, 0.011739524081349373, -0.007278034929186106, 0.01553277112543583, -0.05557068809866905, 0.025036105886101723, 0.015252898447215557, 0.007101275958120823, 0.005945119075477123, -0.004316600505262613, 0.01917964592576027, -0.039035528898239136, 0.0064526330679655075, -0.045437298715114594, 0.044022444635629654, -0.019892938435077667, -0.002013103337958455, -0.0026767763774842024, 0.0018468826310709119, -0.0043313875794410706, -0.013341785408556461, 0.039065245538949966, 0.012621359899640083, 0.03981432318687439, -0.00625004805624485, 0.003468040842562914, -0.03588676080107689, -0.005857255309820175, 0.011217846535146236, 0.016755493357777596, 0.032975539565086365, -0.017641786485910416, -0.033637747168540955, -0.059609949588775635, 0.1027534082531929, -0.03783932700753212, 0.005069069564342499, 0.00008728816465009004, -0.023724360391497612, -0.01850818656384945, 0.01662355475127697, 0.02258317731320858, 0.006357336882501841, 0.0255227480083704, -0.02087988704442978, 0.015995454043149948, -0.008990141563117504, -0.02752995863556862, 0.013200669549405575, 0.00021792335610371083, -0.010671491734683514, -0.06225327029824257, -0.019641665741801262, -0.025777943432331085, 0.024097474291920662, 0.009754912927746773, 0.03458279371261597, -0.029479769989848137, 0.061825212091207504, -0.04080144315958023, -0.0317285880446434, 0.004087383858859539, 0.015623709186911583, -0.015353139489889145, -0.011939366348087788, 0.002777962014079094, 0.06906573474407196, 0.04797977954149246, -0.0262520182877779, -0.037987351417541504, 0.03362325578927994, 0.005415076389908791, -0.009618316777050495, -0.00980755127966404, -0.02973286435008049, -0.003475668840110302, 0.013166344724595547, -0.025450151413679123, -0.04452023282647133, 0.006210515275597572, -0.020462125539779663, -0.024318965151906013, -0.021961431950330734, 0.01888756826519966, -0.033235955983400345, 0.04524768143892288, 0.023012878373265266, -0.005526981316506863, -0.029800036922097206, -0.024100858718156815, 0.000510461104568094, 0.01608233153820038, -0.044560037553310394, -0.05999310687184334, -0.029746243730187416, -0.008589567616581917, -0.015070823021233082, 0.02237805351614952, 0.043935175985097885, -0.01208371389657259, -0.012682810425758362, -0.01786021701991558, 0.003082094481214881, 0.008426963351666927, 0.01402464509010315, -0.01312384195625782, -0.0020264217164367437, 0.02452780492603779, -0.01563737355172634, -0.04213970527052879, 0.024095874279737473, 0.031610503792762756, 0.05666468292474747, 0.013702798634767532, 0.03853416070342064, -0.017279494553804398, 0.070607490837574, -0.010721592232584953, 0.006495250388979912, 0.006084167864173651, 0.009241404011845589, 0.029172763228416443, -0.007310923654586077, -0.0172466691583395, -0.005580225493758917, 0.008308961987495422, 0.004239336121827364, 0.0711858868598938, 0.004974511452019215, -0.00018424632435198873, 0.02116866409778595, -0.015040517784655094, 0.0019905834924429655, 0.03199337050318718, 0.011276365257799625, 0.023098653182387352, 0.024220764636993408, -0.006274154409766197, 0.012798111885786057, -0.03808906674385071, -0.01581854559481144, -0.05508090555667877, -0.02569943107664585, 0.02105330117046833, 0.021259455010294914, 0.060218703001737595, -0.025439780205488205, -0.004930778406560421, 0.02246464230120182, -0.04210176318883896, 0.00890860054641962, 0.006951944902539253, 0.016127759590744972, -0.01284660305827856, 0.01760636270046234, -0.019223202019929886, 0.027072228491306305, 0.03360112011432648, 0.0027336054481565952, 0.07578150182962418, 0.014272394590079784, 0.018297739326953888, -0.036390893161296844, -0.04050072282552719, 0.026924485340714455, 0.003393468912690878, -0.0090492470189929, 0.04890447109937668, -0.052473776042461395, -0.010909234173595905, 0.051512207835912704, -0.00219114706851542, 0.031049443408846855, -0.013160211965441704, 0.044738441705703735, 0.017844868823885918, 0.029418909922242165, 0.049635205417871475, 0.011138662695884705, 0.006960997357964516, -0.00003226267654099502, 0.02004929445683956, 0.01155578251928091, -0.014349161647260189, 0.018817538395524025, 0.022015824913978577, -0.001918462454341352, -0.033743564039468765, -0.015176995657384396, -0.01273314282298088, 0.02162308618426323, -0.004406504333019257, 0.0024261067155748606, -0.01655294932425022, -0.05113187059760094, 0.021403184160590172, -0.0032477984204888344, 0.01779833994805813, 0.04314231872558594, 0.05120769515633583, -0.015469906851649284, 0.00435441080480814, -0.004921401850879192, -0.02734948880970478, 0.04150119423866272, -0.007356289308518171, 0.02243061363697052, -0.049670860171318054, -0.01813555508852005, 0.025348402559757233, -0.0010407791705802083, -0.016536548733711243, -0.009740348905324936, -0.0669051855802536, 0.023889562115073204, 0.008017483167350292, -0.012186864390969276, 0.008282269351184368, -0.009286283515393734, 0.03507258743047714, -0.09658893197774887, 0.051742855459451675, -0.03708591312170029, -0.0357724167406559, -0.022454846650362015, -0.0062947398982942104, -0.049501292407512665, 0.029020465910434723, 0.06032437086105347, 0.026242179796099663, -0.03387198597192764, 0.019137725234031677, 0.02426735684275627, -0.013307742774486542, -0.0562715008854866, 0.03622540086507797, -0.02443058043718338, 0.009228662587702274, 0.006938628852367401, -0.016270438209176064, 0.012028677389025688, 0.013753702864050865, 0.0032755036372691393, 0.0007104006945155561, -0.005092796869575977, 0.0020091079641133547, -0.011419021524488926, -0.006936577148735523, 0.011919092386960983, -0.036937642842531204, 0.024727046489715576, 0.02278245985507965, -0.017877550795674324, 0.047960080206394196, -0.013674317859113216, -0.08710598200559616, 0.018020467832684517, 0.01195392943918705, 0.03689844161272049, -0.03604934364557266, -0.038023851811885834, 0.03719295933842659, -0.03718309849500656, -0.031631335616111755, 0.039547111839056015, -0.01813293620944023, 0.005339100956916809, 0.02847558818757534, 0.028919273987412453, 0.06281356513500214, -0.019113998860120773, 0.04555007442831993, -0.03894142806529999, -0.006142323836684227, 0.04013383761048317, -0.01947224885225296, 0.04312381148338318, -0.02588503248989582, -0.005346122197806835, 0.023075954988598824, -0.0536370575428009, 0.001616187277249992, -0.030622612684965134, 0.03681524470448494, -0.04020124673843384, -0.02783028595149517, 0.040564246475696564, -0.034432895481586456, -0.01900833286345005, 0.04506690800189972, -0.0005353502347134054, 0.02525896579027176, -0.03233961760997772, 0.018193503841757774, 0.014948944561183453, 0.009911737404763699, -0.02521948330104351, 0.004217024892568588, -0.04262307658791542, 0.01700366847217083, 0.023346014320850372, -0.003772388445213437, 0.018013374879956245, 0.006132136099040508, 0.006034002639353275, -0.019085679203271866, 0.0011422609677538276, -0.0048687332309782505, 0.0033548688516020775, -0.020256688818335533, -0.006666685454547405, -0.05275382474064827, -0.015247910283505917, 0.053090400993824005, 0.029056888073682785, -0.01577298529446125, -0.03091326914727688, -0.02377736009657383, 0.002229573205113411, 0.07423795014619827, -0.06102888286113739, -0.023462345823645592, -0.022297168150544167, 0.010975255630910397, 0.014958839863538742, -0.06875107437372208 ]
<p>I am running a Monte-Carlo simulation and I sample from various normal distributions. I was just wondering, is there a way by which I can increase the probability of selecting a point from the tails (i.e., $[-5\sigma,-3\sigma]$ and $[3\sigma,5\sigma]$) as compared to the probability associated with the interval $(-3\sigma, 3\sigma)$?</p> <p>Edit:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/UzAEY.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p>
74,293
[ 0.019710145890712738, -0.03107375279068947, -0.01756037399172783, -0.00370383495464921, 0.02235708013176918, 0.03451463580131531, -0.04005642980337143, -0.04261516407132149, 0.023182431235909462, -0.037666525691747665, 0.005417865235358477, 0.07253391295671463, 0.019383778795599937, 0.01137425284832716, 0.0024266380351036787, 0.0038631856441497803, -0.029230985790491104, -0.037285756319761276, -0.025763582438230515, -0.02781151793897152, 0.017018619924783707, 0.05036992207169533, 0.015426314435899258, -0.011383026838302612, -0.029511017724871635, 0.04476388916373253, 0.048025667667388916, -0.015265914611518383, -0.005132813472300768, 0.057921815663576126, -0.0486418679356575, -0.009670406579971313, 0.07032781094312668, 0.06417954713106155, 0.03275522589683533, 0.00006282437243498862, -0.032052647322416306, -0.020937681198120117, -0.016497749835252762, -0.011797771789133549, -0.04728498309850693, -0.02577420510351658, -0.02118377760052681, -0.0030149416998028755, -0.004783883690834045, -0.01137629710137844, -0.024164309725165367, -0.09277771413326263, 0.026291335001587868, -0.03821730613708496, 0.06196726858615875, 0.0008298683096654713, 0.021351007744669914, 0.03303690254688263, 0.05121258646249771, -0.04124630242586136, 0.03409101068973541, 0.07049843668937683, -0.03029155544936657, -0.0397280752658844, 0.015268975868821144, -0.07506371289491653, -0.006629749201238155, -0.0020844710525125265, -0.025793474167585373, -0.011116668581962585, -0.005051004234701395, -0.01955256424844265, 0.024016214534640312, 0.00609167804941535, 0.008773448877036572, 0.03924505412578583, 0.033514268696308136, -0.028305286541581154, 0.017762543633580208, -0.04209161922335625, 0.033226870000362396, -0.015348875895142555, 0.04197285324335098, 0.006557452492415905, 0.025537703186273575, 0.02844993583858013, 0.021566396579146385, 0.01925027184188366, -0.0004406339430715889, -0.005045730154961348, 0.050589580088853836, -0.0365353599190712, 0.024761883541941643, 0.04313354566693306, -0.05573425441980362, -0.017962846904993057, 0.04469332844018936, -0.02386692352592945, -0.07619226723909378, 0.05601154640316963, -0.003502868814393878, 0.004224243573844433, 0.029010534286499023, 0.012041974812746048, -0.040984150022268295, -0.08892828226089478, 0.03240044414997101, 0.0556756854057312, -0.008087441325187683, -0.004277775529772043, -0.030696645379066467, 0.007037261966615915, 0.00191402283962816, -0.024457033723592758, -0.019550835713744164, 0.010640633292496204, 0.023181144148111343, -0.012675001285970211, 0.04530375078320503, 0.00016286091704387218, -0.015366382896900177, -0.023374902084469795, 0.03513281047344208, 0.04677693173289299, 0.03347678855061531, -0.019383393228054047, 0.028644895181059837, -0.020860988646745682, -0.07604147493839264, 0.0015320052625611424, 0.02347506210207939, 0.008107597939670086, -0.03436458855867386, 0.023747345432639122, 0.018317529931664467, 0.011519568972289562, 0.06958303600549698, 0.003160641295835376, 0.027455201372504234, 0.03324699401855469, -0.07535364478826523, -0.024389203637838364, 0.0407247431576252, -0.023269785568118095, -0.021527785807847977, -0.0747462585568428, -0.008086571469902992, 0.04982082173228264, 0.033754076808691025, 0.05601830407977104, 0.016298657283186913, -0.022288348525762558, 0.01510374341160059, 0.014488494955003262, 0.005826643202453852, -0.014447649009525776, -0.0484224371612072, -0.03267380967736244, -0.013105489313602448, -0.08627031743526459, 0.04520288109779358, 0.024113163352012634, -0.0043068681843578815, -0.026069486513733864, 0.026704514399170876, -0.024224577471613884, 0.014355647377669811, -0.034345854073762894, 0.006150622386485338, -0.021726584061980247, 0.09334145486354828, 0.004869708325713873, -0.00362963299266994, -0.02324538864195347, -0.0007522773812524974, 0.010451414622366428, -0.013728726655244827, 0.03776547312736511, 0.054912157356739044, -0.05108001083135605, 0.009312797337770462, -0.025599226355552673, 0.030009817332029343, 0.009559347294270992, 0.014124884270131588, 0.03383437544107437, -0.033213455229997635, -0.01066917646676302, -0.013483232818543911, 0.021932123228907585, 0.01742815598845482, -0.03804588317871094, 0.007687893230468035, -0.05094408988952637, -0.01522176992148161, -0.05632532760500908, -0.05698138847947121, 0.024999523535370827, -0.02799277938902378, 0.03331806883215904, 0.024648543447256088, 0.03262605145573616, -0.000769167032558471, -0.014797710813581944, 0.008239656686782837, -0.00010096012556459755, 0.05790695548057556, -0.061072152107954025, 0.02603021450340748, 0.06640206277370453, 0.042545199394226074, -0.010874333791434765, 0.026683714240789413, -0.03504219651222229, -0.03153173625469208, -0.02445472776889801, -0.06009184569120407, -0.005084141157567501, 0.026340311393141747, -0.026102254167199135, 0.000700323493219912, 0.026102446019649506, -0.001998306717723608, 0.004748560953885317, -0.027181003242731094, 0.06715551018714905, 0.08832983672618866, -0.015916313976049423, 0.0047860159538686275, -0.024999180808663368, 0.02410450205206871, 0.035079944878816605, -0.018504563719034195, -0.04432593286037445, -0.0476747527718544, -0.014774573035538197, 0.04619758576154709, -0.0012066538911312819, -0.06967092305421829, 0.021866420283913612, 0.0262150801718235, -0.005117813125252724, 0.0487234927713871, 0.05507306754589081, 0.0165037102997303, 0.016644256189465523, -0.0028335154056549072, 0.037138789892196655, 0.04853612557053566, 0.012180297635495663, 0.037865035235881805, 0.006883816793560982, 0.0017765210941433907, -0.020396141335368156, 0.0004166717699263245, -0.012616414576768875, -0.01915961503982544, 0.02796684019267559, -0.005758433137089014, -0.023372648283839226, 0.009434223175048828, -0.03658730909228325, 0.012322730384767056, 0.044362545013427734, 0.0001974372862605378, -0.0031555695459246635, 0.03193182870745659, -0.03798389062285423, 0.006556387525051832, 0.04800546541810036, -0.025682594627141953, 0.031479060649871826, 0.020907843485474586, 0.01546988170593977, -0.0037370524369180202, -0.012599374167621136, -0.0023648692294955254, -0.008854944258928299, 0.010272502899169922, 0.05207175388932228, 0.01026970986276865, 0.050296660512685776, 0.006776506081223488, -0.052632372826337814, 0.0009748367010615766, 0.030144060030579567, -0.013362071476876736, 0.052857138216495514, -0.07387659698724747, -0.006374478340148926, -0.004726216662675142, -0.028100596740841866, -0.0008218421135097742, -0.01870260015130043, 0.0048691146075725555, 0.0011921542463824153, 0.015258568339049816, -0.023656519129872322, -0.01203514076769352, 0.014468856155872345, 0.015543237328529358, -0.01966181769967079, -0.03765945881605148, 0.05445290356874466, 0.045251328498125076, -0.044500600546598434, 0.039484281092882156, -0.0397937148809433, -0.03956146165728569, -0.05259401351213455, 0.01971646025776863, 0.02446761727333069, -0.02332151308655739, 0.016231341287493706, 0.02469470351934433, 0.003231602953746915, 0.04487864300608635, -0.04984908923506737, -0.038558632135391235, -0.0002223941555712372, 0.0006297660293057561, 0.01790095493197441, -0.01682300865650177, -0.01203370001167059, 0.09183453023433685, 0.06179157644510269, -0.03311595693230629, 0.014383552595973015, -0.014704499393701553, -0.03843329846858978, -0.002804094459861517, -0.030243966728448868, 0.02539019100368023, -0.0022701756097376347, 0.030506975948810577, 0.022738097235560417, 0.02751646190881729, 0.041002850979566574, 0.020080070942640305, -0.028807582333683968, 0.026398543268442154, -0.0309746153652668, 0.004033992998301983, 0.048053547739982605, -0.029818220064044, -0.024796968325972557, 0.0040208627469837666, 0.0067211114801466465, 0.029032902792096138, 0.03512350842356682, -0.03862884268164635, 0.028558626770973206, -0.013369264081120491, 0.029708663001656532, -0.02017092891037464, 0.05795906111598015, 0.00859946757555008, -0.024449637159705162, -0.022084446623921394, 0.04483366012573242, 0.04351068288087845, -0.03623628988862038, 0.010772000066936016, 0.056757837533950806, 0.038748156279325485, -0.02130408212542534, -0.030253704637289047, -0.00923013687133789, -0.013258409686386585, 0.005501959938555956, 0.0018859987612813711, -0.03440091013908386, 0.025010213255882263, 0.051398180425167084, 0.014739886857569218, -0.012114692479372025, -0.03762764111161232, 0.001937497523613274, -0.03919272497296333, 0.00948069803416729, -0.018108675256371498, 0.04824107885360718, 0.022364623844623566, 0.03267104923725128, 0.032321054488420486, -0.004316912032663822, 0.005626840516924858, -0.006074727978557348, -0.0719505101442337, 0.03934565186500549, -0.0043171364814043045, -0.06297145783901215, -0.039309024810791016, -0.03761935606598854, 0.026455223560333252, -0.02443656697869301, -0.010270352475345135, 0.0022947893012315035, 0.01522008515894413, -0.047701094299554825, -0.024562673643231392, -0.04267822206020355, -0.01324880588799715, -0.00415229145437479, 0.04108508676290512, 0.007800288498401642, -0.03876003623008728, 0.023794502019882202, -0.004843086004257202, -0.005288668442517519, 0.004233699291944504, 0.0018628231482580304, 0.039597298949956894, -0.008888699114322662, 0.030733810737729073, 0.04421568661928177, 0.054599374532699585, -0.01621793769299984, 0.03478020802140236, -0.017725622281432152, 0.03947243466973305, 0.03489441052079201, -0.0033547456841915846, -0.012509378604590893, -0.06610367447137833, -0.02107241563498974, 0.0018545091152191162, 0.021625887602567673, -0.01021299697458744, -0.002725243102759123, 0.0626780092716217, -0.0081864632666111, -0.057205501943826675, -0.014560025185346603, 0.0469779297709465, 0.017621411010622978, -0.0117355827242136, -0.05690514296293259, -0.0021368672605603933, -0.006811481900513172, -0.03182944282889366, 0.024791887030005455, 0.031946539878845215, -0.053930774331092834, 0.02256760746240616, 0.018094921484589577, -0.0068713603541255, -0.009197767823934555, 0.0016277616377919912, -0.007371485698968172, 0.07120336592197418, 0.02796303667128086, -0.023311570286750793, 0.028872113674879074, -0.01821395754814148, -0.008322913199663162, 0.04887659102678299, 0.00832582451403141, -0.07160875201225281, -0.0048357052728533745, 0.019536010921001434, 0.04127805680036545, -0.037716787308454514, 0.04112876579165459, -0.05147479102015495, 0.01589079573750496, 0.07808332145214081, -0.04692453518509865, 0.011534659191966057, -0.034818124026060104, -0.015412984415888786, 0.0032079352531582117, 0.013091804459691048, -0.07004295289516449, 0.027565548196434975, -0.008832667954266071, 0.01089384127408266, -0.05679522827267647, -0.03938427194952965, -0.028293145820498466, 0.040690839290618896, 0.005841284524649382, 0.09697848558425903, 0.019545963034033775, 0.0015535617712885141, -0.022721784189343452, 0.027627350762486458, -0.006471485830843449, -0.06513404846191406, 0.0015875919489189982, 0.002498151268810034, -0.005582691635936499, 0.010029821656644344, -0.02943655289709568, -0.003797690151259303, 0.033265843987464905, 0.0015681961085647345, -0.002054869197309017, 0.01225689984858036, -0.019399821758270264, 0.012533912435173988, 0.03463275730609894, -0.012116112746298313, 0.03200479596853256, 0.044109370559453964, -0.01580827496945858, 0.009115670807659626, -0.018876614049077034, 0.04556049033999443, -0.031145788729190826, -0.005663493648171425, -0.024140262976288795, -0.03716544434428215, -0.00014114018995314837, 0.021325113251805305, -0.009798823855817318, 0.04551084339618683, 0.024944165721535683, -0.05865831673145294, -0.013854451477527618, -0.0075013781897723675, 0.025965481996536255, -0.021223174408078194, 0.009564859792590141, 0.02938888780772686, 0.013880083337426186, -0.00740413973107934, 0.0031379596330225468, -0.012277414090931416, -0.009200952015817165, -0.0058669839054346085, -0.049851447343826294, -0.000976579962298274, -0.03425314649939537, -0.01572134718298912, -0.0024861483834683895, -0.0424150712788105, 0.024029744789004326, -0.018992163240909576, -0.005886625498533249, -0.013499991968274117, -0.04131237417459488, 0.010883853770792484, 0.017239226028323174, 0.020732684060931206, 0.0037982123903930187, -0.07556671649217606, 0.09365754574537277, -0.010118435136973858, 0.04175548627972603, -0.07594310492277145, -0.048706989735364914, -0.03887827321887016, 0.0052368189208209515, -0.015285717323422432, -0.05494248867034912, -0.023083381354808807, -0.007001878228038549, -0.018241172656416893, -0.011844049207866192, 0.04782778024673462, 0.007145923096686602, -0.034362275153398514, 0.01867094822227955, 0.007212975062429905, 0.07138218730688095, -0.01623678021132946, -0.01410988811403513, 0.026773076504468918, -0.006161200348287821, -0.008814290165901184, -0.0034082646016031504, 0.026324402540922165, -0.040895529091358185, -0.011794734746217728, 0.039655327796936035, -0.007460025604814291, 0.022191200405359268, -0.017456980422139168, -0.05771250277757645, 0.02328300289809704, 0.0355447381734848, 0.030468128621578217, -0.0032418023329228163, -0.022454380989074707, 0.015542817302048206, -0.017502889037132263, -0.017163822427392006, 0.02249841019511223, -0.0005129313212819397, -0.010239608585834503, 0.021539418026804924, 0.03279207646846771, 0.011446957476437092, 0.019182980060577393, 0.0665617436170578, -0.010662157088518143, -0.013261061161756516, 0.0009740859386511147, -0.02739049308001995, 0.03160254657268524, 0.015725646167993546, -0.021877869963645935, 0.0373777374625206, 0.014129286631941795, -0.03734677657485008, -0.013510304503142834, -0.05009426176548004, 0.0028080882038921118, 0.025173796340823174, -0.008128258399665356, 0.04746859148144722, 0.05192292854189873, 0.018861735239624977, -0.028850367292761803, -0.022808078676462173, -0.018224362283945084, -0.015313435345888138, -0.02357599325478077, 0.06038660556077957, -0.016632581129670143, 0.041926972568035126, 0.0030255024321377277, 0.017712514847517014, 0.006944584660232067, 0.06592117249965668, -0.006385185290127993, 0.034215718507766724, 0.03488754853606224, -0.0031085419468581676, -0.021202711388468742, 0.007420978508889675, -0.048012133687734604, 0.016077371314167976, 0.013332036323845387, -0.033706240355968475, 0.015201503410935402, 0.011614642105996609, -0.026857484132051468, -0.04211922362446785, 0.001242755795828998, -0.017882732674479485, 0.02063620649278164, -0.01108957827091217, -0.011957814916968346, 0.04244088754057884, 0.014778886921703815, 0.03312896192073822, 0.0020887991413474083, 0.00009395115193910897, -0.020337548106908798, -0.06681443005800247, -0.02191474661231041, -0.04010235518217087, -0.04685359448194504, 0.017962072044610977, -0.02189587615430355, -0.01019361149519682, 0.023986611515283585, -0.04668911173939705, 0.012619160115718842, 0.02421717159450054, 0.028514502570033073, -0.0014747664099559188, 0.0966859981417656, 0.03031190112233162, 0.017498210072517395, 0.014729979448020458, 0.005357435904443264, 0.12904630601406097, 0.06964767724275589, -0.012006617151200771, -0.05642110854387283, 0.02895299717783928, -0.007295769639313221, 0.008708411827683449, -0.011132806539535522, 0.010021721944212914, 0.025134531781077385, -0.01470806635916233, 0.02390514872968197, 0.0710856169462204, -0.016241611912846565, -0.01206142921000719, 0.04760470241308212, -0.031009774655103683, -0.02641236037015915, 0.00849286001175642, -0.013998175971210003, -0.007872272282838821, -0.021988367661833763, -0.06060345470905304, 0.04982016235589981, -0.028801215812563896, 0.00034055847208946943, -0.004666887689381838, -0.01182396151125431, -0.0026343197096139193, 0.004339118488132954, -0.026274774223566055, -0.021175043657422066, 0.03138640522956848, 0.026630163192749023, 0.027059275656938553, -0.0004956548218615353, -0.00819515623152256, -0.006404106505215168, 0.008608799427747726, -0.009174959734082222, 0.004995387513190508, 0.002861324930563569, 0.001669441582635045, 0.01063400600105524, -0.046279292553663254, -0.04662137106060982, -0.024999691173434258, 0.00892771314829588, -0.006981009151786566, 0.013378072530031204, -0.012423146516084671, 0.016287339851260185, 0.04171427711844444, -0.05282902717590332, -0.028410304337739944, -0.026796456426382065, -0.00017061663675121963, -0.007024626713246107, -0.023379821330308914, -0.00976027175784111, 0.03724018484354019, 0.021995944902300835, 0.03338770195841789, 0.016351258382201195, -0.023772353306412697, -0.017828069627285004, 0.014944273047149181, 0.01997995376586914, 0.012735220603644848, -0.03177656605839729, -0.017157478258013725, 0.005939939990639687, -0.0420687310397625, 0.018462881445884705, -0.024312935769557953, -0.023101506754755974, 0.02675645425915718, 0.014990310184657574, 0.007117237895727158, 0.007640206255018711, -0.0038769941311329603, 0.008207900449633598, -0.04491160064935684, -0.003952458035200834, -0.016168123111128807, -0.013184911571443081, 0.012643221765756607, 0.03683212026953697, 0.02018897235393524, -0.014898015186190605, -0.024320296943187714, 0.04237900674343109, 0.019680902361869812, -0.04936305060982704, -0.012154895812273026, 0.009687935002148151, -0.05388046056032181, 0.0354015976190567, 0.01051416341215372, 0.06532610207796097, -0.024159513413906097, 0.02013516053557396, -0.01767166703939438, 0.02646099030971527, -0.01538150105625391, 0.012433324940502644, 0.004828012548387051, -0.04932471737265587, -0.03709930554032326, 0.004316229838877916, -0.03133006393909454, -0.03963353484869003, -0.032667893916368484, -0.011371944099664688, 0.012527164071798325, 0.01828545331954956, -0.008508116006851196, 0.004592600744217634, -0.015486684627830982, -0.00533977709710598, 0.00447809137403965, -0.015615045092999935, -0.0012546066427603364, -0.042737483978271484, -0.028165480121970177, -0.02415306493639946, 0.01237241830676794, -0.02781699039041996, -0.01033186074346304, 0.0011539820116013288, -0.003329835832118988, 0.01391827967017889, 0.04558990150690079, 0.04000777378678322, -0.043285708874464035, 0.04547880217432976, 0.019961895421147346, 0.07437395304441452, -0.037222057580947876, 0.02327180653810501, 0.05203094333410263, -0.05882744863629341, 0.0021209819242358208, 0.0038154604844748974, 0.019698845222592354, 0.05476784333586693, 0.001593835186213255, -0.011057563126087189, -0.009116929955780506, 0.07176937907934189, -0.019476622343063354, -0.039614710956811905, -0.02686411887407303, 0.030941132456064224, 0.006774770561605692, -0.018401725217700005, 0.0011591053334996104, -0.010988020338118076, -0.00008441226236755028, 0.006101222243160009, 0.009276855736970901, -0.021707510575652122, -0.0028921260964125395, -0.002234329003840685, 0.007792262360453606, 0.015488830395042896, -0.00028268934693187475, -0.0046304380521178246, 0.046963755041360855, 0.017816228792071342, -0.007404907140880823, 0.030181506648659706, -0.037905361503362656, -0.0015671212458983064, -0.08582679182291031, -0.006788260769098997, 0.03696277365088463, -0.02086254023015499, 0.011280263774096966, -0.044630106538534164, -0.003745450871065259, 0.008005434647202492, -0.0144327562302351, 0.009734900668263435, 0.009826571680605412, -0.0047279479913413525, -0.08109808713197708, 0.01543545164167881, -0.014769590459764004, -0.019626697525382042, 0.031720519065856934, 0.00997245591133833, 0.05543724074959755, 0.021142980083823204, -0.03861507400870323, 0.0023045046254992485, -0.0014266876969486475, 0.03468151018023491, 0.00579209765419364, -0.07111676782369614, 0.007572842761874199, -0.02686391770839691, -0.043094370514154434, 0.02077251486480236, -0.014373243786394596, 0.0010770694352686405, 0.001869806321337819, 0.012398375198245049, -0.019187694415450096, 0.021454283967614174, 0.05562036111950874, -0.0005818205536343157, 0.030664214864373207, -0.01752759888768196, 0.04080796241760254, -0.008313208818435669, -0.02530551515519619, 0.007940474897623062, 0.015308637171983719, -0.023424208164215088, -0.04859452322125435, 0.043906670063734055, -0.008022593334317207, -0.029033305123448372, -0.012974509969353676, -0.006527113728225231, 0.04417824000120163, -0.043889839202165604, 0.017978711053729057, -0.02726336009800434, 0.007206212729215622, 0.026071632280945778, -0.014048504643142223, 0.013157816603779793, -0.0018148247618228197, 0.009399717673659325, -0.06709657609462738, 0.024908557534217834, 0.017860690131783485, -0.019973786547780037, -0.05531778186559677, 0.0066674696281552315, 0.02267611213028431, 0.01495234202593565, -0.008272497914731503, -0.014515341259539127, -0.009391450323164463, 0.02648189291357994, -0.01829175464808941, 0.024190684780478477, 0.024224260821938515, 0.01731991581618786, -0.01857726275920868, -0.09647265821695328, 0.0570894330739975, -0.014088141731917858, 0.0006962197367101908, -0.028020961210131645, 0.008243869990110397, -0.0358753502368927, 0.011958212591707706, 0.022427158430218697, 0.014886414632201195, 0.024445414543151855, 0.0029015380423516035, 0.05148648843169212, 0.0321507565677166, -0.02315884456038475, -0.013961905613541603, 0.0091519420966506, -0.01370963454246521, -0.007871326059103012, -0.01659087836742401, 0.031958527863025665, 0.02279222011566162, -0.019425978884100914, 0.02025420218706131, -0.00020277286239434034, 0.0059794834814965725, 0.0004572439065668732, 0.04896135628223419, 0.009164527989923954, -0.006201463285833597, 0.046490054577589035, -0.00920846313238144, 0.008113023824989796, 0.005855284631252289, -0.009141380898654461, -0.02718871645629406, 0.04675373435020447, -0.0318337082862854, -0.07046141475439072, -0.020378559827804565, 0.010502645745873451, -0.022923335433006287, -0.046664755791425705, 0.0025479639880359173, 0.015382453799247742, -0.0016796854324638844, 0.008381573483347893, 0.003948299214243889, -0.021479148417711258, 0.039241500198841095, 0.016454316675662994, 0.029440363869071007, -0.009279490448534489, -0.005058049689978361, -0.00464352872222662, -0.0003305436985101551, 0.007613226771354675, -0.005351098719984293, 0.021257633343338966, 0.02826196327805519, -0.011377295479178429, 0.026799559593200684, -0.014659482054412365, 0.015193677507340908, -0.001239901757799089, -0.0016028725076466799, 0.02248656377196312, 0.005751849617809057, 0.04075353592634201, 0.0004986042622476816, 0.011427498422563076, 0.03584958612918854, 0.008230112493038177, 0.018226364627480507, -0.04404217004776001, 0.0019577040802687407, -0.03292124718427658, -0.008247083984315395, -0.015504960902035236, 0.026659730821847916, -0.003180020721629262, -0.026277761906385422, 0.019926872104406357, 0.006679845508188009, 0.016709286719560623, -0.03469677269458771, 0.05174857750535011, -0.009700920432806015, 0.031624216586351395, -0.02178758941590786, -0.02253139391541481, -0.04185718297958374, -0.02482132613658905, -0.00047529605217278004, 0.027508443221449852, 0.04613213986158371, 0.007723421789705753, -0.07411442697048187, 0.00015171685663517565, 0.07048819959163666, -0.025664081797003746, -0.025528673082590103, -0.02213774435222149, 0.009497849270701408, -0.02875206433236599, -0.012592353858053684 ]
<p>I am using logistic regression to predict y given x1 and x2:</p> <pre><code>z = B0 + B1 * x1 + B2 * x2 y = e^z / (e^z + 1) </code></pre> <p>How is logistic regression supposed to handle cases in which my variables have very different scales? Do people ever build logistic regression models with higher-order coefficients for variables? I'm imagining something like this (for two variables):</p> <pre><code>z = B0 + B1 * x1 + B2 * x1^2 + B3 * x2 + B4 * x2^2 </code></pre> <p>Alternatively, is the right answer to simply normalize, standardize or rescale the x1 and x2 values before using logistic regression?</p>
74,294
[ -0.03982004523277283, -0.010147460736334324, -0.045547451823949814, 0.03799968957901001, 0.03897113725543022, 0.008401967585086823, -0.022840280085802078, -0.021170994266867638, 0.05117570236325264, -0.04075617715716362, 0.042301975190639496, 0.009024840779602528, 0.04607154428958893, 0.0022028745152056217, 0.06455535441637039, -0.005597177427262068, 0.019140832126140594, 0.03471316024661064, 0.01389743946492672, 0.01002928614616394, -0.0023938780650496483, -0.001165179768577218, 0.03954443335533142, 0.008497707545757294, -0.004994682967662811, 0.0463993214070797, 0.034203074872493744, 0.017000367864966393, 0.0240399781614542, 0.04489228129386902, 0.02493935264647007, -0.018496371805667877, 0.0019640272948890924, 0.059488873928785324, 0.009214811958372593, 0.02202964574098587, 0.005567907355725765, -0.015966329723596573, -0.01930025964975357, 0.013945338316261768, 0.010299229994416237, -0.01502946112304926, 0.010700023733079433, 0.022210339084267616, -0.024918677285313606, 0.03326570615172386, -0.022732514888048172, -0.04665611684322357, 0.01771789975464344, -0.04047059267759323, 0.06408053636550903, 0.01913701742887497, 0.023282164707779884, 0.05765802785754204, -0.027490809559822083, -0.0058489348739385605, 0.06179974973201752, 0.05937055125832558, -0.009619864635169506, -0.07514429092407227, -0.030703449621796608, -0.022525452077388763, -0.006241894792765379, 0.0029451220761984587, -0.031355809420347214, 0.03662090748548508, 0.002928112866356969, -0.018100598827004433, 0.03015727363526821, -0.025212261825799942, 0.02999112382531166, 0.029890118166804314, 0.05042825639247894, -0.038337960839271545, 0.0299018956720829, -0.030725864693522453, 0.0017462796531617641, -0.005528487730771303, 0.040910422801971436, 0.03979690745472908, -0.006251295562833548, 0.01887294091284275, 0.011972910724580288, 0.020493267104029655, 0.010174822993576527, -0.0178967397660017, 0.07950400561094284, 0.0016108399722725153, 0.0208639707416296, 0.029209362342953682, -0.011791168712079525, 0.03711505979299545, 0.0676058754324913, -0.020905641838908195, 0.007783461362123489, 0.018540915101766586, -0.003777562640607357, 0.025516729801893234, 0.031408462673425674, 0.012474260292947292, -0.002014490310102701, -0.02316061593592167, -0.0052956887520849705, 0.03439648821949959, -0.03280484303832054, 0.0005500698462128639, -0.060717664659023285, -0.014147261157631874, 0.0022019757889211178, -0.057076845318078995, 0.027179216966032982, 0.002582234563305974, -0.006710979156196117, -0.0015809372998774052, 0.026853986084461212, -0.015138300135731697, -0.017065802589058876, -0.01330589223653078, 0.04486743360757828, 0.03877498209476471, 0.03921381011605263, -0.04174754396080971, 0.03479583561420441, 0.013307238928973675, -0.011444708332419395, 0.01716579869389534, -0.010549981147050858, 0.012555044144392014, -0.04931693151593208, 0.039432842284440994, -0.0003420673019718379, -0.010801048949360847, -0.0003035469853784889, 0.004397689364850521, 0.018941689282655716, 0.023349396884441376, -0.05575764924287796, -0.06613694131374359, -0.012625196017324924, -0.000015910249203443527, 0.015207734890282154, -0.033181194216012955, -0.01902235671877861, 0.029840661212801933, 0.054858461022377014, 0.03784843161702156, 0.02722308039665222, 0.03586399927735329, 0.02300814352929592, 0.02551155909895897, -0.025041237473487854, -0.0016399206360802054, -0.032240379601716995, -0.025577886030077934, 0.015658313408493996, -0.06907716393470764, 0.005846838466823101, 0.0250160600990057, -0.029084432870149612, -0.020776884630322456, 0.03574727848172188, 0.014842597767710686, -0.020856712013483047, 0.00637343293055892, 0.011266469955444336, 0.01738247647881508, 0.07946691662073135, -0.005724689457565546, 0.048738546669483185, 0.05569029599428177, 0.0048932950012385845, -0.0008281114278361201, 0.014440039172768593, 0.0458371676504612, 0.0409359373152256, 0.008109241724014282, -0.008542140014469624, -0.058633215725421906, 0.03324269503355026, 0.024447334930300713, -0.04338366165757179, -0.03512857109308243, -0.019392915070056915, -0.011910744942724705, -0.008715431205928326, 0.027470439672470093, 0.003928748425096273, -0.016153501346707344, 0.03894515708088875, -0.03510307893157005, -0.041644882410764694, -0.04523677006363869, 0.011538250371813774, 0.020360540598630905, -0.008912197314202785, 0.020045923069119453, -0.016972385346889496, 0.05333401635289192, -0.0011433351319283247, -0.013892906717956066, -0.017567766830325127, 0.013546734116971493, 0.04680613800883293, -0.031227830797433853, 0.013989665545523167, 0.07653751224279404, 0.038327910006046295, -0.04042234644293785, 0.06675421446561813, -0.03229894861578941, -0.0431261844933033, 0.030630603432655334, -0.01736348867416382, 0.0029795190785080194, -0.03969244286417961, -0.02068803831934929, 0.01862514577805996, -0.011862178333103657, -0.039145272225141525, 0.04106437787413597, -0.0836760550737381, 0.08163923770189285, 0.05935715138912201, 0.0022341974545270205, -0.00968462135642767, -0.005433918908238411, -0.017361517995595932, 0.013459810987114906, -0.036196332424879074, -0.04641297087073326, -0.07292100042104721, -0.024991530925035477, 0.015785373747348785, 0.04315846040844917, -0.036554593592882156, -0.014167267829179764, 0.04608216509222984, 0.031641725450754166, 0.034354038536548615, 0.01157399546355009, 0.0004060603678226471, -0.03874887898564339, 0.0045053972862660885, 0.021733654662966728, 0.0228170994669199, 0.008940759114921093, 0.004951606038957834, 0.00704868184402585, 0.036841511726379395, 0.0044519370421767235, -0.005230818875133991, 0.032558590173721313, -0.004771417006850243, -0.010058439336717129, -0.014779893681406975, -0.006778789684176445, 0.01171789038926363, -0.030525771901011467, 0.02283354476094246, 0.035744596272706985, 0.03842984139919281, -0.023580137640237808, -0.00443339953199029, 0.01005768496543169, 0.005831195507198572, 0.0740428939461708, -0.04224761947989464, 0.020355544984340668, 0.020357754081487656, -0.045701008290052414, -0.0027575180865824223, -0.018634507432579994, -0.044211626052856445, -0.06357015669345856, 0.0054754288867115974, 0.01569960080087185, 0.006007640156894922, 0.03809996321797371, -0.016572391614317894, -0.05477925390005112, 0.01580488681793213, -0.02623392827808857, -0.014306469820439816, -0.023057542741298676, -0.04881928861141205, 0.0006911581731401384, -0.03188927844166756, 0.0006255115731619298, 0.02489098347723484, -0.0030684208031743765, -0.003247797954827547, 0.019902104511857033, -0.0038526062853634357, -0.060053788125514984, -0.006781731732189655, -0.055194128304719925, 0.034990791231393814, 0.007758729159832001, -0.03766995295882225, 0.04563076049089432, 0.010297050699591637, -0.04863394796848297, 0.01888420060276985, -0.027377432212233543, 0.006156995426863432, -0.024842292070388794, -0.012675379402935505, -0.001365533797070384, -0.006489370483905077, 0.024965953081846237, 0.012735238298773766, -0.05334114655852318, -0.028157200664281845, -0.07429143041372299, -0.08219737559556961, 0.011670894920825958, 0.008800750598311424, 0.05188874527812004, -0.031074009835720062, -0.023718807846307755, 0.06985053420066833, 0.030831363052129745, 0.011495011858642101, -0.06073294207453728, 0.010163500905036926, -0.006662767846137285, -0.02905365079641342, 0.03106584958732128, 0.03443439304828644, 0.0034042163752019405, 0.019096169620752335, -0.012025970034301281, 0.021172137930989265, 0.060675475746393204, -0.009319839999079704, 0.016621820628643036, 0.015333320945501328, 0.039859555661678314, -0.03999162092804909, 0.04233381152153015, 0.0012308221776038408, -0.012336877174675465, 0.030073359608650208, 0.016473820433020592, 0.02747941203415394, -0.0012593282153829932, -0.03871726244688034, 0.004710838198661804, -0.009362801909446716, 0.03575584664940834, -0.024923842400312424, -0.007687672041356564, 0.032393064349889755, -0.06441642343997955, -0.01078805048018694, 0.029311904683709145, 0.018582552671432495, -0.01072127465158701, 0.00450889952480793, 0.03514419123530388, 0.09416177868843079, -0.023240260779857635, -0.0179781224578619, -0.0034183210227638483, -0.008581416681408882, 0.03337455168366432, -0.02458670735359192, -0.0069907354190945625, 0.03498595952987671, 0.02068805694580078, -0.0008649686933495104, -0.015062589198350906, -0.05747070163488388, 0.023125916719436646, -0.09085509181022644, -0.010203017853200436, -0.03679082915186882, 0.04888566955924034, 0.011993274092674255, 0.03207780048251152, 0.00955298449844122, -0.008356742560863495, 0.04093537479639053, 0.04699643328785896, -0.09592094272375107, 0.06307537853717804, -0.031169604510068893, 0.011495329439640045, -0.008467226289212704, -0.01798231527209282, 0.0229421965777874, -0.03352123871445656, 0.02445039339363575, 0.015801575034856796, 0.0027283038944005966, -0.025900231674313545, 0.009604043327271938, -0.030870448797941208, -0.016056641936302185, -0.008341229520738125, -0.0004159719974268228, -0.03678043186664581, 0.007475741673260927, 0.03883291035890579, 0.06336947530508041, -0.008253680542111397, 0.002636998426169157, -0.025076277554035187, 0.024484679102897644, 0.02383418381214142, 0.05608029663562775, 0.0029047359712421894, 0.004157510120421648, -0.03663904219865799, 0.01832297444343567, -0.007776884362101555, 0.03314051777124405, 0.03476041182875633, 0.007690350525081158, -0.012053118087351322, -0.018656082451343536, -0.010104038752615452, 0.00868947058916092, 0.002417675917968154, 0.00079726503463462, 0.016112307086586952, 0.04013201221823692, 0.03654882684350014, -0.04439720883965492, 0.019723467528820038, 0.09310226142406464, -0.004296343307942152, -0.04161425679922104, -0.03602674975991249, -0.0009674692410044372, -0.01405533030629158, -0.014655964449048042, 0.007521480321884155, 0.00483830738812685, -0.011452045291662216, -0.00020167983893770725, 0.03681785985827446, -0.019923416897654533, -0.029008492827415466, -0.013394189067184925, 0.029934098944067955, 0.03355928882956505, 0.0027455328963696957, -0.08405144512653351, -0.009673262014985085, 0.03475387394428253, 0.031126508489251137, 0.022009849548339844, -0.009533902630209923, -0.08415158092975616, -0.0002543176815379411, -0.006314401049166918, 0.05148480832576752, -0.026877528056502342, -0.011836710385978222, -0.023173384368419647, -0.0175420343875885, 0.044845107942819595, -0.03530200943350792, 0.02506978064775467, -0.017418241128325462, 0.012549315579235554, -0.033215124160051346, -0.014791524037718773, -0.0719064474105835, 0.01771099679172039, -0.0486784465610981, 0.029531113803386688, -0.0003450862714089453, 0.013832217082381248, -0.06253784894943237, 0.054776839911937714, -0.029529616236686707, 0.06655504554510117, -0.031006064265966415, -0.031564757227897644, -0.0067475032992661, 0.016193881630897522, 0.02319285087287426, -0.03292369097471237, -0.0038485443219542503, 0.0337921604514122, -0.01684948429465294, 0.042359720915555954, 0.028694208711385727, -0.04296772554516792, 0.024162784218788147, 0.028902359306812286, 0.007570294663310051, -0.001823669532313943, 0.008264737203717232, 0.03999244421720505, 0.03872748836874962, 0.010435961186885834, 0.0649249330163002, 0.03904202952980995, 0.014519085176289082, -0.002217954257503152, -0.038979671895504, 0.010294567793607712, -0.043648861348629, -0.021908916532993317, -0.030031798407435417, 0.00020151618809904903, -0.01977558806538582, 0.02381795272231102, -0.007105862721800804, 0.026363026350736618, -0.037109870463609695, -0.05106482282280922, -0.00010228943574475124, 0.04233308881521225, -0.009847333654761314, -0.016994234174489975, 0.025323063135147095, 0.02297230437397957, -0.02525910921394825, -0.02091832458972931, 0.014592066407203674, -0.010923726484179497, 0.014796408824622631, 0.014179401099681854, -0.04416263476014137, 0.0036296816542744637, -0.016585659235715866, -0.02315366268157959, 0.04178854823112488, -0.0443216934800148, 0.012584845535457134, 0.012503650970757008, 0.025275137275457382, 0.008630973286926746, -0.046598371118307114, -0.022107107564806938, 0.0038630347698926926, 0.005148442927747965, 0.016016989946365356, -0.04060621187090874, 0.022496318444609642, -0.006493504624813795, -0.017046771943569183, -0.06756597757339478, -0.04464511200785637, 0.013320043683052063, -0.009001219645142555, 0.018826313316822052, -0.03119756653904915, 0.009270879440009594, -0.03191545605659485, -0.002298535080626607, -0.03432207554578781, 0.0659947618842125, -0.027509033679962158, -0.021278003230690956, -0.020623499527573586, 0.020788542926311493, 0.07337738573551178, 0.02378496155142784, -0.009208337403833866, 0.0028825784102082253, -0.004754099529236555, -0.01892421580851078, 0.008108553476631641, 0.025441301986575127, -0.03041403740644455, -0.03025536984205246, -0.028338925912976265, 0.011779136024415493, 0.04465603455901146, -0.004351821728050709, -0.023723525926470757, 0.01605418138206005, -0.0041416604071855545, 0.03769240900874138, -0.013003317639231682, 0.005594018846750259, -0.0092222411185503, 0.016323568299412727, -0.025971468538045883, -0.031641364097595215, -0.026975322514772415, 0.001175826066173613, 0.018786534667015076, 0.029343102127313614, 0.006187582854181528, 0.022919511422514915, 0.059920258820056915, 0.062448903918266296, 0.012450285255908966, -0.03619127348065376, -0.03545750305056572, 0.08450162410736084, 0.006995120085775852, -0.011411740444600582, 0.0182300116866827, 0.0533054918050766, -0.017352450639009476, -0.022486306726932526, -0.026196973398327827, -0.02409493364393711, 0.03656609356403351, -0.010166910476982594, 0.041995514184236526, 0.05333460494875908, -0.0023675519041717052, -0.005072247702628374, -0.04695761576294899, -0.018136490136384964, -0.004639160819351673, -0.006276621017605066, 0.06064140424132347, 0.012092938646674156, -0.02450188249349594, 0.024770770221948624, 0.016052721068263054, 0.024819213896989822, 0.006546031218022108, 0.015700744464993477, 0.018307432532310486, 0.003371421480551362, -0.02885296940803528, -0.04607317969202995, 0.05601117014884949, -0.04346958547830582, -0.014602238312363625, -0.03816332295536995, -0.012040440924465656, 0.07339344918727875, 0.014966168440878391, -0.0013878080062568188, -0.06143330782651901, -0.025500042364001274, -0.04030809924006462, -0.004146152175962925, 0.01097160391509533, -0.010354177094995975, 0.054414354264736176, -0.013205022551119328, -0.010268671438097954, -0.019771544262766838, 0.0007776813581585884, -0.027797507122159004, -0.11722087860107422, -0.02219260297715664, -0.010263265110552311, -0.019122732803225517, 0.006714855320751667, 0.015027661807835102, -0.009149246849119663, 0.016385449096560478, -0.09398195892572403, 0.01715296134352684, -0.006918680388480425, 0.02479732781648636, 0.019610684365034103, 0.05439574271440506, 0.0001871255662990734, -0.008774533867835999, -0.004119220655411482, 0.007959362119436264, 0.1190175861120224, 0.10630650073289871, 0.012543934397399426, -0.06601640582084656, 0.03623189032077789, 0.010797714814543724, 0.0004925397224724293, -0.012172376736998558, -0.024518107995390892, -0.014347354881465435, 0.0010432158596813679, 0.037019938230514526, 0.03212565928697586, 0.032413922250270844, -0.015306335873901844, 0.06810669600963593, -0.05088941007852554, -0.022231223061680794, 0.03517713025212288, 0.03785298392176628, 0.004833351820707321, -0.019723448902368546, -0.04804418608546257, 0.00030833634082227945, -0.038227587938308716, -0.02783118560910225, -0.024307262152433395, 0.01699032075703144, 0.012178987264633179, -0.01014411635696888, -0.00920905452221632, -0.0011829431168735027, 0.02085043676197529, -0.011342576704919338, 0.006935609970241785, 0.011600191704928875, 0.03076169267296791, -0.031116575002670288, 0.004279017448425293, 0.03395266458392143, -0.02416204661130905, 0.02170751430094242, -0.004516764543950558, 0.0014759647892788053, -0.054725531488657, -0.0156352911144495, -0.04988687112927437, 0.032477572560310364, 0.009374827146530151, -0.011864272877573967, 0.007410270627588034, -0.0005384500254876912, 0.0025144966784864664, -0.042402107268571854, -0.023816891014575958, 0.04166344925761223, 0.017582587897777557, -0.02290634624660015, -0.01054380927234888, 0.004938710015267134, 0.03042067214846611, 0.015455980785191059, 0.03447045013308525, 0.015530655160546303, -0.03836629167199135, 0.004954058211296797, -0.02844715677201748, 0.06122026592493057, 0.001655857777222991, 0.01064217183738947, 0.03655359894037247, 0.007483349181711674, -0.047255292534828186, -0.013842834159731865, 0.010573320090770721, -0.0019281402928754687, 0.02333313226699829, -0.024995557963848114, -0.015049401670694351, -0.08178412169218063, -0.002194515662267804, 0.014421829022467136, -0.02483455464243889, 0.02324390597641468, -0.04634144529700279, 0.01712355948984623, 0.00015065379557199776, 0.03655577450990677, 0.040164146572351456, 0.01045969408005476, -0.03316331282258034, 0.029995426535606384, -0.013561663217842579, -0.04635484889149666, -0.020109035074710846, 0.016835985705256462, -0.039313558489084244, -0.00677527068182826, -0.01692134141921997, 0.07786255329847336, 0.002502031158655882, 0.03133496642112732, -0.013284905813634396, 0.030827008187770844, -0.02224082127213478, 0.022278310731053352, 0.01483842357993126, -0.027074428275227547, -0.0032486412674188614, 0.0019648035522550344, 0.008709060959517956, -0.0026949404273182154, -0.013243638910353184, -0.06311429291963577, -0.04029304161667824, 0.005487658083438873, -0.004040477331727743, -0.05334186181426048, 0.016165263950824738, -0.01030505821108818, 0.03430509194731712, -0.02889092266559601, -0.0032995182555168867, -0.010710391215980053, 0.041191309690475464, -0.04208545386791229, -0.06917144358158112, 0.009069517254829407, 0.02289116568863392, -0.02379085123538971, 0.009673116728663445, 0.030605727806687355, 0.013604657724499702, 0.032505493611097336, -0.006689185276627541, -0.016509920358657837, -0.02810324914753437, 0.02887164242565632, -0.04796716570854187, -0.023449817672371864, 0.005725233815610409, -0.029063470661640167, -0.01454180758446455, 0.02392004244029522, -0.007115837186574936, 0.01838282123208046, 0.018102165311574936, 0.023088445886969566, -0.03147326037287712, 0.054955512285232544, 0.005567158106714487, 0.005360633134841919, -0.00763173121958971, -0.0013964757090434432, -0.021073870360851288, 0.014881981536746025, 0.0023236447013914585, 0.0074813105165958405, -0.0240861214697361, 0.017237069085240364, 0.026505639776587486, 0.008641131222248077, -0.0012316085631027818, 0.005066438112407923, 0.015426358208060265, 0.05524498596787453, 0.013636133633553982, 0.0014026890275999904, 0.052483927458524704, 0.0535583533346653, -0.016506880521774292, 0.01572643779218197, -0.013926048763096333, 0.016833636909723282, -0.08226024359464645, -0.020671268925070763, 0.005297292955219746, -0.0011341596255078912, 0.013055811636149883, -0.029153283685445786, -0.017660176381468773, -0.007146882824599743, -0.01853596605360508, 0.00932229496538639, -0.0005720860208384693, -0.032676659524440765, -0.010650606825947762, -0.010315573774278164, 0.02361345663666725, 0.015164067968726158, 0.048062220215797424, 0.021394887939095497, 0.01731494627892971, -0.0007188671734184027, -0.0006122905761003494, -0.03321628272533417, -0.005891390610486269, -0.004723495803773403, -0.013967123813927174, -0.05394384264945984, 0.027762318029999733, -0.04558950290083885, -0.02243669144809246, 0.03647543489933014, -0.0008706833468750119, 0.0049514686688780785, 0.04130672290921211, 0.017243120819330215, 0.04663361981511116, 0.0462188720703125, 0.017675096169114113, 0.00538494810461998, -0.015651658177375793, 0.009707278572022915, 0.022714029997587204, 0.026108412072062492, -0.0406949408352375, 0.012191596440970898, 0.04139281436800957, -0.0028636842034757137, -0.02820894494652748, 0.013261490501463413, -0.027166197076439857, -0.023818306624889374, -0.04894639179110527, -0.009635714814066887, 0.0002827173157129437, -0.029201999306678772, 0.012381521053612232, -0.05538879707455635, -0.028183244168758392, 0.03522782027721405, 0.014175749383866787, -0.041007038205862045, 0.008702777326107025, 0.019386889412999153, -0.02973201312124729, -0.008117295801639557, -0.005675232503563166, 0.01324077695608139, -0.04106418043375015, -0.003977686632424593, 0.02281968854367733, -0.050427913665771484, -0.030187048017978668, -0.022621622309088707, -0.031557824462652206, 0.051629554480314255, -0.029892725870013237, 0.02424698695540428, 0.01630478911101818, -0.01522777695208788, 0.023368248715996742, -0.09195280075073242, 0.05905979499220848, 0.011557834222912788, -0.04025028645992279, -0.03467186912894249, -0.017064573243260384, -0.026255574077367783, 0.0058833276852965355, 0.0666394904255867, 0.01877286657691002, 0.006224968004971743, -0.012664888985455036, 0.05215955898165703, -0.009520272724330425, -0.025097889825701714, -0.01003488339483738, 0.016261162236332893, -0.033334676176309586, -0.031491342931985855, 0.006490401923656464, -0.007386445067822933, 0.012397046200931072, 0.03423403576016426, -0.013906548731029034, 0.014043301343917847, -0.006352023221552372, -0.014770681038498878, 0.04083848372101784, -0.027559097856283188, -0.022839365527033806, 0.04209092631936073, -0.026103803887963295, 0.012432209216058254, 0.040383294224739075, 0.022413304075598717, -0.0742977038025856, 0.01734474115073681, -0.06061745434999466, -0.013653436675667763, -0.0059999730437994, 0.0041002132929861546, 0.008975074626505375, -0.050128158181905746, 0.01551130972802639, 0.043634504079818726, -0.044643741101026535, -0.0014101106207817793, 0.03068860061466694, 0.029772458598017693, 0.013922497630119324, -0.011386810801923275, -0.02070862613618374, 0.04184968024492264, -0.03279717639088631, 0.00657748943194747, -0.001517460448667407, 0.02409941889345646, 0.023462777957320213, -0.0004229470214340836, -0.0009751673205755651, -0.0043451301753520966, 0.013686515390872955, 0.011901422403752804, 0.05022808536887169, -0.024018006399273872, -0.009801981039345264, 0.005327886436134577, -0.0033374729100614786, 0.04437869042158127, 0.004254025407135487, 0.0018487664638087153, 0.05277012288570404, -0.04671801999211311, 0.0019412955734878778, -0.03297219052910805, -0.013347344473004341, -0.023365749046206474, -0.0084917563945055, 0.011323006823658943, 0.008081904612481594, -0.00318677956238389, -0.0012272134190425277, -0.008680391125380993, -0.03894975408911705, 0.022023426368832588, -0.024275798350572586, 0.001103556132875383, -0.02563394419848919, 0.008351868949830532, 0.012044530361890793, -0.026433637365698814, -0.0412437804043293, -0.041061513125896454, 0.012584513053297997, 0.032292768359184265, 0.027246780693531036, -0.02189195528626442, -0.008310387842357159, 0.003911578096449375, 0.028208617120981216, -0.06800917536020279, -0.020658694207668304, -0.03625486046075821, 0.00309863593429327, 0.00913370493799448, -0.03611063212156296 ]
<p>An online module I am studying states that one should <strong>never</strong> use Pearson correlation with proportion data. Why not?</p> <p>Or, if it is sometimes OK or always OK, why?</p>
74,295
[ -0.005906754173338413, -0.029592344537377357, 0.028744803741574287, -0.014389182440936565, 0.03316667675971985, 0.016865914687514305, 0.01034723874181509, -0.019807826727628708, 0.03856604918837547, -0.02647366374731064, 0.019152283668518066, 0.04500177502632141, 0.024391764774918556, 0.039205584675073624, 0.019196365028619766, 0.023659488186240196, 0.0027821646071970463, 0.03397644683718681, 0.02437097392976284, 0.02059212513267994, -0.023287426680326462, 0.015367557294666767, 0.025201594457030296, -0.030774446204304695, -0.033477336168289185, 0.05852740630507469, 0.0071819317527115345, -0.032028310000896454, 0.03633042797446251, 0.06067677587270737, -0.07913203537464142, -0.01665034517645836, 0.04327510669827461, 0.04633144661784172, 0.015272634103894234, -0.004549551289528608, -0.021558379754424095, -0.000544051406905055, 0.024018656462430954, 0.025655308738350868, -0.03817255049943924, -0.05296393856406212, 0.029364489018917084, 0.025038788095116615, 0.00929615180939436, 0.051130663603544235, 0.007203876040875912, -0.051620546728372574, 0.03420563042163849, -0.024286625906825066, 0.06359342485666275, 0.009048321284353733, 0.007282155565917492, 0.05734081566333771, -0.008568414486944675, -0.0018785226857289672, 0.05968114361166954, 0.03492727503180504, -0.050562746822834015, -0.05460275709629059, 0.01993335783481598, -0.024519482627511024, -0.004179835319519043, 0.0039327689446508884, -0.0082011753693223, 0.017684387043118477, -0.01534673385322094, -0.0016681663691997528, 0.04224824160337448, 0.005824211984872818, 0.020442137494683266, 0.05207294225692749, 0.054298728704452515, -0.016011102125048637, -0.011344046331942081, -0.018170002847909927, 0.036029256880283356, 0.027163991704583168, 0.052537478506565094, 0.053498443216085434, 0.005206715781241655, -0.027458500117063522, 0.04871901497244835, 0.01717369444668293, 0.05070829764008522, -0.030603647232055664, 0.06315180659294128, -0.03744238615036011, -0.003254680195823312, 0.033479243516922, -0.027019180357456207, -0.015512678772211075, 0.024586565792560577, 0.0012900081928819418, -0.03242634981870651, 0.04596022516489029, -0.030749060213565826, 0.05782725661993027, 0.015733474865555763, 0.008962694555521011, -0.01503824908286333, -0.0271665770560503, 0.008984317071735859, 0.012603165581822395, -0.025004230439662933, -0.02533300593495369, -0.0366612933576107, 0.01890258491039276, 0.035793133080005646, -0.03321705758571625, -0.017516711726784706, -0.003995109349489212, -0.0131305493414402, 0.046574585139751434, 0.027670402079820633, -0.008899635635316372, 0.017321720719337463, 0.0009328637388534844, 0.056012142449617386, 0.07090397924184799, 0.009546785615384579, -0.003280472010374069, -0.001155518926680088, -0.002200731774792075, -0.01628218963742256, 0.04031916707754135, 0.01819145493209362, -0.0460243858397007, -0.03893658146262169, 0.058836281299591064, -0.016409290954470634, 0.007559488527476788, 0.03221346437931061, -0.0006452407687902451, 0.03565173223614693, 0.010591499507427216, -0.07052897661924362, -0.03489217907190323, 0.06002506986260414, -0.0006592138088308275, -0.014926750212907791, -0.049752697348594666, 0.013394882902503014, 0.05623747035861015, 0.06966817378997803, 0.0018894196255132556, 0.05901302769780159, -0.03151802718639374, 0.05135686323046684, -0.005457562860101461, -0.04012163355946541, -0.045180272310972214, 0.01815064065158367, -0.02608652226626873, -0.011406753212213516, -0.07205503433942795, 0.015911472961306572, 0.0254039503633976, 0.020767509937286377, -0.03732495382428169, 0.003650125116109848, -0.019613729789853096, -0.023567097261548042, 0.013208216056227684, 0.02207772620022297, 0.006022115238010883, 0.056572332978248596, -0.007883397862315178, 0.05173856392502785, 0.022049060091376305, -0.002752100583165884, 0.017653807997703552, 0.01606415957212448, 0.007976730354130268, 0.042968232184648514, -0.004713128786534071, 0.015110800042748451, -0.02256602980196476, 0.027834467589855194, 0.006549187935888767, -0.03837686777114868, -0.0015850730706006289, -0.020911721512675285, 0.02190321870148182, 0.020973728969693184, 0.03630100190639496, 0.015941835939884186, -0.01585252955555916, 0.036997757852077484, -0.032407570630311966, -0.05693428963422775, -0.05959011986851692, 0.006046972703188658, -0.0491255484521389, -0.026536012068390846, 0.02741939388215542, 0.0011018980294466019, -0.007488304749131203, -0.01439235731959343, 0.0048693702556192875, -0.02740938402712345, -0.02512340620160103, 0.03018510714173317, -0.06428293883800507, 0.019746502861380577, 0.030502956360578537, 0.023707885295152664, -0.015227620489895344, 0.029048960655927658, -0.04332219064235687, -0.0542466826736927, -0.00006742210098309442, 0.00034980502096004784, 0.005027242004871368, -0.01662633568048477, -0.024253206327557564, -0.01565050706267357, 0.011213176883757114, -0.050728365778923035, -0.0026877126656472683, -0.051361460238695145, 0.08802900463342667, 0.053191084414720535, -0.004135861061513424, -0.021599693223834038, 0.003375852480530739, 0.015512056648731232, -0.03524201363325119, 0.012313191778957844, -0.03929914906620979, -0.06424613296985626, 0.011081302538514137, 0.029658885672688484, 0.03443969041109085, -0.06686802208423615, 0.026637645438313484, 0.0538223534822464, 0.02260993793606758, 0.000819031207356602, -0.00042174957343377173, 0.018411479890346527, -0.031688425689935684, -0.006058367434889078, -0.0060616545379161835, 0.013832451775670052, 0.0033037455286830664, 0.0036288658156991005, 0.02382981777191162, 0.041474319994449615, 0.023066526278853416, -0.02003689855337143, 0.00943547673523426, 0.0036762463860213757, 0.03559695929288864, 0.030676569789648056, -0.018091922625899315, 0.034612078219652176, -0.047084588557481766, 0.015779631212353706, 0.013383529148995876, 0.014892389997839928, 0.008849096484482288, 0.006801363080739975, -0.03679932653903961, 0.009219769388437271, 0.06060761958360672, -0.05347048491239548, 0.021015699952840805, 0.01704292744398117, 0.0015825865557417274, -0.025337276980280876, -0.05504509061574936, -0.04065721109509468, -0.023534197360277176, 0.011573145166039467, 0.038780637085437775, -0.019577693194150925, 0.04586069658398628, -0.02547474019229412, -0.024566153064370155, -0.042962972074747086, 0.0037051516119390726, -0.046983204782009125, -0.02374676987528801, -0.0767819806933403, -0.026761369779706, 0.003917799796909094, -0.021669378504157066, -0.000008276906555693131, -0.023858584463596344, 0.00620891060680151, -0.005206362344324589, -0.011991879902780056, -0.05476043000817299, -0.04473540186882019, -0.0026316381990909576, -0.020068027079105377, -0.0151437446475029, -0.03695272281765938, 0.04925994202494621, -0.04594787582755089, -0.04315227270126343, -0.0016103230882436037, -0.023022422567009926, -0.026967836543917656, -0.012299139983952045, -0.007843033410608768, 0.0028524247463792562, -0.022205669432878494, -0.03948860242962837, -0.009365972131490707, -0.044981393963098526, -0.030050674453377724, -0.05830056592822075, -0.054496392607688904, 0.025268055498600006, 0.03367534652352333, 0.05020225793123245, 0.003044270211830735, -0.013935006223618984, 0.04404282942414284, 0.026058904826641083, -0.021679196506738663, -0.03776215761899948, -0.005776271689683199, 0.006173154339194298, -0.015587701462209225, 0.040797021239995956, 0.010170265100896358, 0.007812336087226868, 0.024872571229934692, 0.0013572146417573094, 0.04623127356171608, 0.05015799030661583, 0.0009598798351362348, -0.020466502755880356, 0.014657647348940372, 0.015640150755643845, -0.022596091032028198, 0.006719829514622688, 0.043264634907245636, -0.0769667699933052, 0.012076196260750294, 0.007007085718214512, 0.05489035323262215, 0.003733934834599495, -0.030570514500141144, 0.018203025683760643, -0.004028326831758022, -0.014303925447165966, -0.042947929352521896, 0.014472661539912224, 0.026061104610562325, 0.012069430202245712, -0.014112483710050583, -0.0031920806504786015, 0.013075342401862144, -0.048221033066511154, 0.012569209560751915, 0.05308838561177254, 0.03333756700158119, -0.0040734815411269665, -0.018576499074697495, 0.04373272880911827, -0.004552788101136684, 0.03283175453543663, -0.006032013334333897, 0.008244667202234268, 0.05793111398816109, 0.044793739914894104, 0.021323151886463165, -0.011706610210239887, -0.04457354545593262, 0.022175194695591927, -0.05898325890302658, -0.008485912345349789, -0.03292339667677879, 0.02420234866440296, -0.016582967713475227, 0.05552758648991585, 0.03870735317468643, -0.031724028289318085, 0.01575370691716671, 0.021371932700276375, -0.020660746842622757, 0.01156157348304987, -0.027160625904798508, 0.004880213178694248, 0.0015433825319632888, -0.02472659759223461, 0.01041124016046524, -0.06422512978315353, -0.0020954697392880917, -0.032620932906866074, 0.03610072284936905, 0.011288437061011791, 0.017101101577281952, -0.025485320016741753, -0.009551631286740303, -0.006763325072824955, 0.007823675870895386, 0.011362274177372456, -0.000386290717869997, 0.04678818956017494, 0.07894518226385117, 0.002962997416034341, 0.01049687061458826, -0.0063567133620381355, -0.004127464722841978, 0.028508612886071205, 0.05592166259884834, -0.008168678730726242, 0.02212662249803543, -0.05447530001401901, 0.027105752378702164, -0.011159231886267662, 0.049600750207901, 0.03497489169239998, -0.040482327342033386, -0.043993137776851654, 0.026562266051769257, -0.036288682371377945, -0.00003836370524368249, 0.016547536477446556, -0.0014150544302538037, -0.005035092122852802, 0.05543613061308861, 0.00514239864423871, -0.06330763548612595, 0.0007715587271377444, 0.05174020305275917, 0.037840355187654495, 0.014090859331190586, -0.03796630725264549, -0.002277723280712962, 0.03898157179355621, -0.011664563789963722, 0.02029464580118656, 0.0598381869494915, -0.01725221797823906, -0.0053742858581244946, 0.026759926229715347, 0.0018827958265319467, -0.05899249389767647, 0.02561565302312374, 0.0044535561464726925, 0.009632430970668793, 0.006019358057528734, -0.024683402851223946, 0.02352818101644516, 0.03414881229400635, 0.044332150369882584, 0.02009580470621586, -0.011884554289281368, -0.0694168284535408, 0.03327411413192749, 0.07913190871477127, 0.04337036609649658, -0.0701112300157547, 0.02022290602326393, -0.03741544112563133, -0.009201754815876484, 0.024185331538319588, -0.049620721489191055, -0.007878846488893032, -0.05663628131151199, -0.00054943683790043, -0.0213551577180624, -0.038577280938625336, -0.04811495169997215, 0.026972034946084023, 0.012085085734724998, 0.02647986263036728, -0.016390923410654068, -0.012661539018154144, -0.03974790498614311, -0.011912890709936619, 0.05106465145945549, 0.048947155475616455, -0.02661954239010811, -0.058405086398124695, -0.012512385845184326, 0.023437147960066795, -0.02017435058951378, -0.06213739514350891, 0.00982159748673439, -0.025349266827106476, 0.004983884748071432, 0.030615035444498062, -0.014412570744752884, -0.03384026512503624, -0.004898098297417164, 0.02103951945900917, -0.025862371549010277, -0.006744363345205784, -0.05205880105495453, 0.06298193335533142, 0.016937825828790665, 0.013418960385024548, 0.03841865435242653, 0.054337866604328156, -0.009619739837944508, -0.007021443918347359, -0.047148533165454865, 0.017707770690321922, -0.030687984079122543, 0.02482190728187561, -0.048332247883081436, -0.01899290271103382, -0.03623180836439133, 0.005669757723808289, 0.015285352244973183, 0.026865269988775253, -0.0005597997806034982, 0.003528715344145894, 0.014623034745454788, 0.014013591222465038, 0.0148355383425951, 0.015668466687202454, -0.005652345716953278, 0.0076865386217832565, -0.01555879320949316, -0.01616966538131237, 0.00776814017444849, -0.014735478907823563, -0.018637526780366898, 0.06646260619163513, -0.05106183513998985, 0.0036680942866951227, -0.044534772634506226, -0.022733574733138084, 0.0003737364604603499, -0.008308002725243568, 0.02368718571960926, -0.006692211609333754, 0.025090351700782776, 0.002910454059019685, -0.03627423197031021, -0.023827364668250084, 0.036585524678230286, -0.007097650784999132, 0.06446854770183563, -0.00622129812836647, 0.034874726086854935, -0.040071286261081696, 0.033935822546482086, -0.06925090402364731, -0.04444087669253349, 0.018675614148378372, 0.025879042223095894, -0.015001308172941208, -0.022668691352009773, -0.0019758599810302258, -0.0036237032618373632, -0.03680983930826187, -0.034121397882699966, 0.05780235677957535, -0.005880804266780615, -0.0366736575961113, -0.01194898784160614, -0.01625228486955166, 0.0757160410284996, -0.022899413481354713, 0.019183611497282982, 0.024263417348265648, -0.024551890790462494, -0.029758652672171593, -0.020024850964546204, -0.015588280744850636, -0.0397002287209034, -0.028317218646407127, -0.029640400782227516, -0.014472655951976776, 0.021566346287727356, 0.006860316265374422, -0.03713066503405571, 0.004148181993514299, -0.0065550729632377625, 0.007924486882984638, 0.014228135347366333, 0.011189700104296207, -0.017213881015777588, 0.005231265909969807, -0.011147349141538143, -0.004176317248493433, -0.03969475254416466, -0.016274256631731987, 0.030936624854803085, 0.01635761372745037, -0.034192025661468506, 0.045720700174570084, 0.05454224720597267, -0.04589039087295532, 0.004493327345699072, -0.003187688998878002, -0.03390920162200928, 0.019094951450824738, 0.023079082369804382, 0.006208945065736771, 0.01254324335604906, 0.010980742983520031, -0.02638253942131996, -0.009234144352376461, -0.015426014550030231, -0.004466143902391195, 0.05988660082221031, -0.008891263045370579, 0.024377645924687386, 0.01980704441666603, 0.00011179931607330218, 0.01366239320486784, 0.0001756420824676752, -0.02227061428129673, -0.021684555336833, 0.0025941242929548025, 0.01667279191315174, -0.01632438413798809, -0.021864481270313263, 0.013493381440639496, 0.021909110248088837, 0.007035448215901852, 0.018329288810491562, 0.023206109181046486, 0.009425526484847069, 0.03692314401268959, 0.025306856259703636, -0.06643043458461761, 0.02745266817510128, -0.07679195702075958, 0.0016735746758058667, -0.0493442602455616, -0.03260071575641632, 0.04630201309919357, 0.009870256297290325, -0.016431938856840134, -0.03990161791443825, -0.019105061888694763, 0.012817063368856907, -0.011076624505221844, -0.009931921027600765, 0.0061047011986374855, 0.029113905504345894, -0.03447221592068672, 0.06042327359318733, -0.026057980954647064, 0.0350223109126091, -0.03221554309129715, -0.0844995379447937, -0.03178127482533455, 0.007942107506096363, -0.014049244113266468, 0.01813153177499771, -0.023171966895461082, -0.019152341410517693, 0.019423093646764755, -0.016413619741797447, 0.022017130628228188, -0.0000747949379729107, 0.05163150280714035, -0.0239028949290514, 0.04711996763944626, -0.002214919775724411, 0.0019203732954338193, 0.004548004828393459, 0.009051104076206684, 0.11517512798309326, 0.05025346577167511, 0.033430423587560654, -0.06314041465520859, 0.04097164422273636, 0.0006871631485410035, -0.01164266373962164, -0.02566421404480934, 0.02950771152973175, 0.0006836258107796311, 0.02692905254662037, 0.05718943849205971, 0.042986977845430374, 0.06429340690374374, -0.005021008662879467, 0.07592320442199707, -0.0030893441289663315, -0.02672160416841507, 0.024655386805534363, 0.0075156488455832005, -0.015855759382247925, -0.013812387362122536, -0.017717979848384857, -0.013265986926853657, 0.011628156527876854, -0.03403223305940628, -0.007380529306828976, -0.02226736582815647, -0.01632128469645977, 0.01781393587589264, -0.023463569581508636, 0.013160597532987595, 0.04444880038499832, 0.008104601874947548, -0.02569770999252796, -0.043075624853372574, 0.004957405384629965, -0.03422101214528084, 0.011913714930415154, 0.0260761808604002, -0.02015838399529457, -0.0026725821662694216, 0.027890073135495186, 0.02031726762652397, -0.04998394474387169, 0.009828280657529831, -0.016604188829660416, 0.02042282000184059, 0.017043888568878174, 0.020150329917669296, -0.019343720749020576, -0.010972819291055202, 0.005206618923693895, -0.018984464928507805, -0.021132251247763634, 0.024456413462758064, 0.028050150722265244, -0.012113087810575962, -0.014864164404571056, -0.04482085630297661, -0.014890945516526699, -0.04920392483472824, 0.046153344213962555, 0.06195252761244774, -0.022755244746804237, -0.011254658922553062, -0.035665906965732574, 0.0197626743465662, 0.024316472932696342, 0.003795170458033681, -0.015752673149108887, 0.002242905553430319, -0.05648041144013405, 0.011915556155145168, 0.009873472154140472, 0.021379617974162102, 0.0486382395029068, -0.00013290633796714246, 0.004312385339289904, -0.023153340443968773, -0.047613099217414856, 0.024852141737937927, -0.00828605331480503, -0.012718609534204006, -0.03257175534963608, 0.003096044296398759, 0.01851375587284565, 0.023187313228845596, 0.012942710891366005, -0.00717361131682992, -0.028823712840676308, 0.05377958342432976, 0.014801688492298126, -0.04887915775179863, -0.020529447123408318, -0.03824640437960625, -0.06481216102838516, -0.003751236479729414, 0.016358956694602966, 0.005709697492420673, 0.037832293659448624, 0.02162657119333744, 0.019206836819648743, -0.01433364488184452, -0.006754046771675348, 0.020085792988538742, 0.014922576025128365, -0.04688994213938713, -0.0007785948691889644, 0.01769646443426609, -0.003403878305107355, -0.03774347901344299, -0.009772499091923237, -0.030482660979032516, 0.0067215184681117535, -0.019117001444101334, -0.010262313298881054, -0.020632995292544365, -0.016891900449991226, 0.005460336804389954, 0.025464478880167007, -0.000051812319725286216, -0.013531485572457314, -0.0629405677318573, -0.034157101064920425, 0.006828176788985729, 0.005722758360207081, 0.0037666151765733957, 0.020743489265441895, 0.007947840727865696, 0.05143935978412628, 0.05463116988539696, 0.006180514581501484, 0.02451566606760025, -0.03462272509932518, 0.0012999012833461165, 0.008409162051975727, 0.01729399338364601, -0.0451536551117897, -0.02731015905737877, 0.07648692280054092, -0.02821323089301586, -0.040768206119537354, 0.011379379779100418, -0.02006473019719124, 0.03327174484729767, -0.0029996384400874376, 0.019124723970890045, -0.020127812400460243, 0.032518595457077026, -0.04080799221992493, -0.0199960395693779, 0.009026932530105114, 0.037629589438438416, 0.010822859592735767, 0.00808221660554409, -0.010155453346669674, 0.007134887855499983, -0.005903459154069424, 0.03181025758385658, 0.07649189233779907, 0.030775723978877068, 0.007041135802865028, 0.006524082738906145, -0.002867664908990264, -0.00044418880133889616, 0.014091527089476585, 0.001334675936959684, -0.0036924949381500483, 0.05549832805991173, -0.04495270550251007, 0.016390010714530945, -0.00044426816748455167, 0.013316990807652473, -0.09124568104743958, -0.0500560961663723, 0.019252821803092957, 0.01633135788142681, 0.013683324679732323, -0.03986793011426926, -0.020325522869825363, 0.05848003551363945, -0.07817438244819641, 0.02918343059718609, -0.01306421309709549, -0.049572352319955826, -0.02719404548406601, 0.04529029503464699, -0.003778288373723626, 0.02140689827501774, 0.043869465589523315, 0.03790806606411934, 0.008330406621098518, 0.021454649046063423, 0.029145468026399612, 0.005576863884925842, -0.023590480908751488, 0.0027392893098294735, -0.022533437237143517, -0.04450049623847008, 0.034569401293992996, -0.001592932385392487, -0.033877432346343994, 0.04372082278132439, -0.013451253063976765, 0.029426252469420433, 0.0345081202685833, 0.029754385352134705, -0.017102649435400963, 0.0348348394036293, 0.07040274143218994, -0.0181113351136446, -0.019229179248213768, -0.0050316182896494865, 0.030226709321141243, 0.037728238850831985, -0.03140098601579666, 0.01480908878147602, 0.0067235445603728294, -0.01944076456129551, -0.0488000325858593, 0.006748950108885765, -0.02664291299879551, 0.0009781380649656057, -0.002671831054612994, 0.01607614755630493, -0.007325369399040937, 0.0005847609136253595, 0.039187125861644745, -0.06172396242618561, -0.021306095644831657, 0.02199973352253437, 0.018035849556326866, -0.014423796907067299, 0.0002449522144161165, -0.011911825276911259, -0.0025514010339975357, -0.006300706882029772, -0.019044851884245872, -0.0051048630848526955, -0.038519300520420074, 0.014067328535020351, -0.01374195795506239, 0.034562043845653534, -0.0031763610895723104, 0.015071572735905647, -0.018277190625667572, 0.051450930535793304, -0.03127707540988922, 0.03757281228899956, 0.021017126739025116, -0.016174204647541046, -0.0020703470800071955, -0.07196735590696335, 0.0626201257109642, 0.0029912427999079227, -0.036138586699962616, -0.0790056362748146, -0.010395032353699207, -0.0388210192322731, 0.003034450812265277, 0.05493452399969101, 0.003652743296697736, 0.03857821598649025, -0.008281990885734558, 0.05836479365825653, 0.013369404710829258, -0.05449416860938072, 0.010740533471107483, -0.015128230676054955, -0.014391298405826092, -0.016248425468802452, 0.010239075869321823, 0.022466136142611504, -0.024354293942451477, -0.006217089481651783, -0.010232110507786274, 0.04396285116672516, 0.015892276540398598, 0.004702798556536436, 0.04456744343042374, 0.02119220234453678, -0.0036683192010968924, 0.051792990416288376, -0.018799249082803726, 0.03951474279165268, 0.043024223297834396, -0.01979261450469494, -0.08605299144983292, 0.015807978808879852, -0.024920551106333733, -0.020280659198760986, -0.016119398176670074, 0.031743187457323074, -0.007718668319284916, -0.041207436472177505, 0.00024003027647268027, 0.049258261919021606, -0.07666105777025223, -0.01667136140167713, -0.0030187673401087523, 0.019125739112496376, 0.036524996161460876, 0.014115259982645512, -0.0004690944915637374, 0.02856968343257904, -0.03679727390408516, 0.00948800053447485, 0.025175612419843674, 0.032652948051691055, -0.01464427262544632, -0.001826307736337185, 0.01963082142174244, 0.019337551668286324, 0.0027432332281023264, -0.023066556081175804, 0.03752517327666283, -0.05103081092238426, -0.057838037610054016, 0.028803054243326187, -0.018329402431845665, 0.07790393382310867, 0.0205058790743351, 0.008805722929537296, 0.02541445568203926, -0.01846596598625183, 0.0025696393568068743, -0.02977769449353218, -0.0717417448759079, -0.03437291830778122, -0.011677646078169346, 0.03427819162607193, 0.02170983888208866, 0.009850743226706982, -0.00895274244248867, -0.011858350597321987, -0.017083585262298584, 0.00776309659704566, -0.03727065026760101, -0.003122954862192273, -0.015814049169421196, -0.0008728851098567247, -0.019432133063673973, -0.0036346663255244493, -0.006937028840184212, -0.02521657384932041, 0.01572721265256405, 0.029062552377581596, 0.001091521349735558, -0.029902614653110504, -0.011905800551176071, -0.01649320311844349, 0.04108930379152298, -0.04806265980005264, -0.005592311732470989, -0.022717991843819618, 0.017653081566095352, 0.0018238091142848134, -0.009431014768779278 ]
<p>I have data from a set of sensors, and would like to measure similarity between two samples of data ignoring local fluctuations.</p> <p>My problem is, my sensors are not regularly placed : some are quite alone, others are many in the same area, there is no regular pattern in their locations.</p> <p>I want to measure similarity in terms of large scale, local fluctuations (even of high amplitude) are much less important as long as they are balanced by other nearby fluctuations.</p> <p>I though about computing average values of a point and its neighbours, and making my indicator as the sum of absolute value of differences between the local averages of my two samples, but I have not idea whether it's a good approach or not.</p>
74,296
[ -0.010364874266088009, 0.03803480416536331, -0.00693344185128808, 0.010346801020205021, 0.027839049696922302, 0.02772977203130722, -0.008172447793185711, -0.027086514979600906, 0.018508991226553917, -0.0409744568169117, 0.02533993311226368, 0.008996381424367428, 0.05049000307917595, 0.04651737958192825, 0.011509986594319344, -0.024216173216700554, -0.042860545217990875, 0.003505249507725239, -0.026010697707533836, -0.08633271604776382, -0.012825436890125275, 0.010943149216473103, 0.04829153046011925, -0.05690201371908188, -0.06741643697023392, 0.03793308511376381, 0.006597546860575676, -0.041405875235795975, -0.021088991314172745, 0.05134781822562218, -0.07249098271131516, -0.03861371800303459, -0.026506392285227776, 0.03085979074239731, 0.02429511584341526, -0.000909603841137141, -0.03485492244362831, -0.023430202156305313, 0.013391062617301941, 0.04658928140997887, -0.055879782885313034, -0.028243117034435272, -0.015444908291101456, 0.029023971408605576, -0.018658999353647232, -0.006242270581424236, 0.0023982415441423655, -0.019281739369034767, 0.023784643039107323, -0.05068592727184296, 0.07084260880947113, -0.004569120705127716, 0.042749349027872086, 0.04471079632639885, -0.024812670424580574, 0.0033493852242827415, 0.0239328034222126, 0.049846623092889786, -0.03081277385354042, -0.029626527801156044, -0.017459243535995483, -0.029400499537587166, -0.023246286436915398, -0.040250781923532486, -0.02260257676243782, 0.029834162443876266, -0.023177102208137512, -0.024067791178822517, 0.055132169276475906, 0.036123521625995636, 0.009245003573596478, 0.04719490557909012, 0.0433104932308197, -0.010778375901281834, 0.02632821537554264, -0.022039495408535004, -0.0033873484935611486, 0.0021028192713856697, 0.04720541834831238, 0.025048954412341118, 0.007396384608000517, 0.004271990153938532, 0.02316070720553398, -0.013843825086951256, 0.04667355865240097, -0.04500254988670349, 0.04484180733561516, -0.03656191751360893, -0.03836435824632645, 0.0222286656498909, 0.01697641611099243, 0.018486112356185913, 0.059859324246644974, 0.024408923462033272, -0.03905687481164932, 0.01653110422194004, -0.012726488523185253, 0.029707245528697968, -0.01598522625863552, -0.009499691426753998, -0.03493218868970871, -0.059703681617975235, 0.04511863365769386, 0.04247826710343361, -0.019868753850460052, -0.019621407613158226, -0.05471806228160858, -0.010556261986494064, -0.03453200310468674, 0.023364130407571793, 0.019899560138583183, 0.0038327828515321016, 0.03414835035800934, -0.00969330221414566, 0.040150392800569534, -0.005419986322522163, 0.006180013995617628, -0.014132541604340076, 0.022346755489706993, 0.05894291773438454, 0.04391385242342949, -0.009703838266432285, 0.030377771705389023, -0.04464416205883026, -0.05660471320152283, 0.05702781677246094, 0.00438325759023428, -0.022322800010442734, -0.03734983131289482, 0.051263418048620224, -0.009011447429656982, -0.0005663425545208156, 0.0328926146030426, -0.05341486632823944, 0.050226785242557526, 0.015190276317298412, -0.07508530467748642, -0.02914510853588581, 0.0531763881444931, 0.006033038720488548, 0.0038725559134036303, -0.04926539957523346, -0.016262410208582878, 0.02902696281671524, 0.059333622455596924, 0.03599235415458679, -0.004651640076190233, 0.020131448283791542, 0.0320894680917263, 0.0009730449528433383, -0.044461365789175034, -0.06074799224734306, 0.00920068845152855, -0.03041110932826996, -0.009634661488234997, -0.049377746880054474, -0.0006277935463003814, 0.031018894165754318, -0.03765265271067619, 0.015254759229719639, 0.03101731836795807, 0.031699445098638535, 0.01978209614753723, 0.020273668691515923, 0.014034857042133808, -0.022182844579219818, 0.0675673857331276, -0.004480298608541489, 0.007835152558982372, -0.01277308352291584, 0.009244702756404877, 0.00313962041400373, 0.005656892899423838, -0.020325154066085815, 0.0693015307188034, 0.011836429126560688, 0.01318539772182703, 0.0003334202920086682, -0.0006249037687666714, 0.016356416046619415, -0.016581498086452484, -0.05321945995092392, -0.05060788244009018, -0.007133295759558678, 0.007716670166701078, 0.05758000537753105, -0.021461406722664833, -0.019994055852293968, 0.07312754541635513, -0.009088320657610893, -0.033670730888843536, -0.07023583352565765, -0.0039605493657290936, 0.0019586675334721804, -0.023669162765145302, 0.04688650369644165, 0.010738523676991463, -0.034878216683864594, -0.030497873201966286, -0.04084138572216034, -0.011321352794766426, -0.029536090791225433, 0.025707684457302094, -0.03319661691784859, -0.0027292610611766577, 0.033838264644145966, 0.016230178996920586, -0.010952096432447433, 0.04376933351159096, -0.019027208909392357, -0.02799399010837078, 0.014543353579938412, -0.02800358273088932, -0.009855869226157665, 0.002433458110317588, 0.0012600223999470472, 0.0034997977782040834, 0.011281292885541916, -0.020034225657582283, -0.01665271446108818, -0.05004643648862839, 0.07084477692842484, 0.04548374563455582, -0.0018326034769415855, 0.009027590975165367, 0.011417696252465248, 0.026415612548589706, 0.01133350096642971, -0.01871584914624691, -0.03405351564288139, -0.09425430744886398, -0.017414450645446777, 0.05493578687310219, 0.06160306930541992, -0.041277751326560974, -0.014391683973371983, 0.0736149400472641, 0.024159273132681847, 0.019225304946303368, -0.0022499780170619488, -0.003018237417563796, -0.015198463574051857, 0.02996852435171604, 0.022397197782993317, -0.0003150464908685535, -0.02451225556433201, 0.01219764444977045, 0.021916905418038368, 0.04338080808520317, -0.004306602757424116, 0.02508501335978508, -0.004650752991437912, 0.001399294356815517, 0.04953451827168465, -0.014106742106378078, -0.008067934773862362, 0.02854551561176777, 0.009931580163538456, -0.008665783330798149, 0.022561466321349144, -0.021317999809980392, -0.002647018525749445, 0.007528523914515972, -0.007320151664316654, 0.012808513827621937, 0.021817514672875404, -0.05279206484556198, -0.004722739104181528, 0.017348751425743103, -0.04921562969684601, 0.030821172520518303, -0.01262103021144867, -0.02564656175673008, -0.03135393559932709, 0.005126669071614742, 0.07407660782337189, 0.027193941175937653, 0.02366771548986435, -0.017539044842123985, -0.022335251793265343, 0.010688070207834244, -0.00706489896401763, 0.022081149742007256, 0.07561839371919632, -0.028242120519280434, -0.0003844261809717864, -0.011444715782999992, -0.0026221913285553455, 0.020635148510336876, -0.020537516102194786, 0.014044379815459251, 0.022760869935154915, 0.015214131213724613, -0.06533516198396683, 0.01785818301141262, -0.03011906147003174, 0.016323434188961983, 0.010071679949760437, 0.01985953189432621, 0.018476804718375206, 0.0016178826335817575, -0.05003213509917259, 0.011897370219230652, -0.04247592017054558, -0.019542766734957695, -0.044146113097667694, 0.0005866347346454859, 0.006886011455208063, -0.011959154158830643, 0.000985196209512651, 0.05410034954547882, -0.043824825435876846, -0.015650950372219086, -0.0634395033121109, -0.08425606042146683, 0.01885848492383957, 0.012873797677457333, 0.05309205874800682, -0.018363315612077713, -0.00907186884433031, 0.050397735089063644, -0.002515264553949237, -0.0331728532910347, -0.034837156534194946, -0.008849923498928547, -0.03432849422097206, 0.022977188229560852, -0.012572973035275936, 0.011257468722760677, 0.008175003342330456, 0.007417070213705301, 0.02050822228193283, 0.029851119965314865, 0.05530241131782532, 0.010034552775323391, -0.011856422759592533, 0.001998953754082322, 0.013788134790956974, -0.006618848070502281, 0.06551394611597061, 0.03090582974255085, -0.018915990367531776, -0.010259472765028477, 0.027145328000187874, -0.030930940061807632, 0.03835776820778847, -0.0677897185087204, 0.013942107558250427, -0.02484901435673237, 0.010003061033785343, -0.059051159769296646, -0.0010402973275631666, 0.0018603994976729155, 0.006974382791668177, -0.03153269737958908, 0.04029907286167145, 0.053876250982284546, 0.02799183316528797, 0.000924289517570287, 0.0734875276684761, 0.03816937655210495, 0.010506217367947102, -0.006149382796138525, 0.013826152309775352, -0.008945788256824017, -0.01783687248826027, -0.014047556556761265, -0.030141275376081467, 0.0189572274684906, 0.0358896441757679, 0.013511966913938522, -0.004751419648528099, -0.04722658544778824, 0.030947228893637657, -0.04594206064939499, -0.012638706713914871, -0.034533653408288956, 0.05024530366063118, 0.008389635942876339, 0.05047232657670975, 0.053937092423439026, -0.012580160051584244, 0.00818357989192009, -0.015887107700109482, -0.0442824624478817, 0.03844640031456947, -0.02941986545920372, -0.021047813817858696, 0.017481157556176186, -0.022312898188829422, 0.019028902053833008, 0.004873492289334536, 0.02047882229089737, 0.008064151741564274, 0.0598955936729908, -0.06732990592718124, -0.018233634531497955, -0.03193168342113495, -0.002471605548635125, -0.018098386004567146, 0.024188997223973274, 0.015080289915204048, -0.01823618821799755, 0.04823893681168556, 0.014469645917415619, -0.01523185521364212, 0.007740924600511789, -0.005856192205101252, 0.0117182033136487, 0.013815624639391899, -0.00595874572172761, 0.012391841039061546, 0.011174299754202366, -0.026550306007266045, 0.01889995113015175, 0.03259548917412758, 0.0598783902823925, 0.020509906113147736, -0.03666813671588898, 0.0024744239635765553, -0.013372388668358326, -0.039333097636699677, 0.0023190334904938936, 0.0601077638566494, -0.03431716933846474, 0.008542610332369804, 0.004311055410653353, 0.021125389263033867, -0.05382809042930603, 0.020977843552827835, 0.035194069147109985, 0.02037314511835575, -0.01538288127630949, -0.04138701409101486, -0.031219186261296272, 0.03433718532323837, -0.02373095601797104, 0.05158117040991783, -0.017012709751725197, -0.011370666325092316, -0.008769286796450615, 0.015879325568675995, 0.0317586213350296, -0.017438923940062523, -0.025707054883241653, 0.002873501041904092, 0.04204005002975464, -0.04486905783414841, -0.021945230662822723, 0.007639417890459299, 0.0015687912236899137, 0.04362332820892334, 0.03613658249378204, -0.002587562892585993, -0.11817419528961182, 0.0015837042592465878, 0.025745224207639694, 0.04776671901345253, -0.004974806681275368, 0.0038182041607797146, -0.051458828151226044, -0.037077903747558594, 0.0912066251039505, -0.02498432621359825, 0.025952937081456184, -0.013140685856342316, 0.0023180616553872824, -0.025942236185073853, -0.022512240335345268, -0.015197117812931538, 0.021018844097852707, -0.030849386006593704, 0.027896391227841377, -0.028340915217995644, -0.04308895394206047, -0.03274364396929741, 0.02977745048701763, 0.004526176955550909, 0.06449570506811142, -0.012446731328964233, -0.007727921009063721, 0.003255333285778761, -0.00402316078543663, 0.008488901890814304, -0.03570200875401497, 0.039167724549770355, 0.0384124256670475, -0.004540599416941404, 0.05261637270450592, 0.003942763898521662, -0.0264431182295084, 0.009487442672252655, -0.032350245863199234, -0.014898800291121006, 0.0014913954073563218, 0.018053768202662468, 0.0679398849606514, 0.047236617654561996, 0.01177656464278698, 0.06027349829673767, 0.028661439195275307, 0.011867922730743885, 0.028145775198936462, 0.01992987096309662, -0.0016108693089336157, -0.03514173999428749, 0.017991306260228157, -0.02969142608344555, -0.015552381053566933, -0.05683579668402672, 0.05077788233757019, -0.020278075709939003, 0.044613391160964966, -0.03517387434840202, -0.023463308811187744, -0.00400973204523325, 0.019926799461245537, -0.009907367639243603, -0.009011548012495041, -0.004500409122556448, 0.05667388066649437, 0.03409595042467117, -0.035207875072956085, 0.029899761080741882, -0.018304772675037384, -0.035213250666856766, -0.004664622712880373, -0.012752286158502102, 0.02297760546207428, -0.06318799406290054, -0.02436516247689724, 0.0023473603650927544, -0.0426383875310421, 0.021743714809417725, 0.01049952395260334, 0.0314016155898571, 0.02720661647617817, -0.022761758416891098, -0.034091852605342865, 0.014595291577279568, 0.018037011846899986, 0.05644039064645767, -0.0691542774438858, 0.024643680080771446, -0.01099276915192604, 0.003806322580203414, -0.07770109176635742, -0.021478183567523956, 0.022867754101753235, 0.021344823762774467, 0.008205614052712917, -0.09170185029506683, -0.02085394784808159, -0.0029171290807425976, 0.021843088790774345, 0.01241656206548214, 0.0014220821904018521, -0.0045704832300543785, -0.002070600865408778, 0.003097945125773549, 0.0007063275552354753, 0.09785117954015732, -0.010820038616657257, 0.01979917101562023, 0.028620436787605286, 0.004118496552109718, -0.017753619700670242, -0.012296267785131931, 0.04464785009622574, -0.040557801723480225, -0.011020926758646965, -0.03288981691002846, -0.003828260116279125, 0.026839466765522957, -0.03405188396573067, -0.036968618631362915, -0.009189256466925144, 0.012141663581132889, -0.004963004030287266, -0.0017392431618645787, 0.0016540582291781902, -0.010033284313976765, -0.020019102841615677, -0.0279349684715271, 0.012227390892803669, 0.01613154076039791, -0.026902081444859505, 0.017843594774603844, 0.016285154968500137, -0.012484264560043812, -0.022118961438536644, 0.031088057905435562, -0.006168782711029053, -0.01748264580965042, 0.025212641805410385, -0.004724178928881884, 0.018449779599905014, -0.03948003053665161, -0.00019498587062116712, 0.01851905882358551, 0.02374301105737686, -0.02720051258802414, -0.04076003283262253, -0.035402119159698486, -0.023946404457092285, 0.05668976157903671, 0.015229069627821445, 0.04300961643457413, 0.07368750870227814, 0.011196861043572426, 0.024684015661478043, -0.002957734512165189, -0.011992625892162323, 0.012629733420908451, 0.004865546710789204, 0.06248975172638893, -0.01069355197250843, -0.005600000265985727, 0.018876606598496437, 0.04517610743641853, -0.011892909184098244, 0.041398901492357254, 0.010265585966408253, 0.06656288355588913, 0.024939147755503654, -0.012316620908677578, -0.046555835753679276, 0.01920641027390957, -0.03241122514009476, 0.005137540865689516, -0.010653157718479633, -0.004889366682618856, 0.045619335025548935, 0.024701256304979324, 0.005800299346446991, -0.037026677280664444, -0.03966103121638298, -0.03680681064724922, 0.015681307762861252, 0.03535018488764763, 0.005646821577101946, 0.023620739579200745, 0.02121218480169773, 0.030040711164474487, 0.008383463136851788, -0.021537110209465027, -0.05617044121026993, -0.060193199664354324, 0.014665546827018261, -0.019546832889318466, -0.06640157103538513, 0.04275432974100113, -0.020337194204330444, -0.04818280413746834, 0.05396651849150658, -0.004903246648609638, 0.01926152966916561, 0.004665590822696686, -0.0072814952582120895, -0.009457346051931381, 0.062456078827381134, 0.017667945474386215, 0.04093465581536293, -0.008265837095677853, -0.010768653824925423, 0.12229132652282715, 0.02491769939661026, -0.005938532762229443, -0.04820237308740616, 0.010347481817007065, -0.0002363058738410473, 0.005652145016938448, -0.014315001666545868, 0.015416248701512814, -0.011431459337472916, -0.004811241757124662, 0.05541657283902168, 0.020986536517739296, 0.029571479186415672, -0.03557227924466133, 0.0592142716050148, -0.020604897290468216, 0.0006861352012492716, 0.032247528433799744, 0.025941278785467148, -0.022430652752518654, -0.008689092472195625, -0.028066087514162064, 0.0463760569691658, -0.027801118791103363, -0.005627548787742853, -0.023313766345381737, -0.000781095412094146, 0.014379161410033703, 0.017152003943920135, -0.04166150465607643, 0.037109773606061935, 0.007937869057059288, -0.015308643691241741, -0.023724058642983437, -0.008880378678441048, 0.024707401171326637, 0.0016151850577443838, 0.03643067553639412, -0.010373672470450401, -0.0020413631573319435, -0.03113257698714733, -0.007835067808628082, -0.018668638542294502, -0.04473062604665756, -0.03078886680305004, -0.042493317276239395, 0.05244336277246475, 0.007228490896522999, 0.002747474703937769, -0.021260565146803856, 0.04600920528173447, -0.0046966285444796085, -0.04858587309718132, -0.00009579822653904557, -0.0043966034427285194, 0.027920857071876526, -0.03847653046250343, -0.03968067467212677, 0.0014320738846436143, 0.03593715280294418, -0.004074518568813801, -0.01671450585126877, 0.0009913493413478136, -0.010641651228070259, -0.027470514178276062, -0.007506347261369228, 0.05577923357486725, 0.013960626907646656, -0.005027915351092815, -0.03692983090877533, -0.0320189893245697, -0.02642294391989708, -0.012763045728206635, -0.05440262332558632, -0.024034269154071808, 0.03482217341661453, 0.03257307782769203, -0.004608552437275648, 0.0005919667892158031, -0.042426880449056625, 0.015432959422469139, -0.035426270216703415, 0.005972863174974918, -0.009855701588094234, 0.004636440891772509, 0.06620518118143082, 0.033188629895448685, 0.03332457318902016, -0.016472497954964638, -0.002449588617309928, 0.0427180640399456, 0.015019231475889683, -0.014995471574366093, -0.02338108792901039, -0.018343301489949226, -0.037645839154720306, 0.040473077446222305, 0.019598742946982384, 0.020291222259402275, 0.014873279258608818, -0.005623954813927412, 0.040503039956092834, 0.03310434892773628, -0.045262835919857025, 0.01669153943657875, -0.041958004236221313, -0.03036670945584774, -0.024394847452640533, 0.005905208643525839, -0.014886537566781044, -0.039184704422950745, -0.02254783734679222, -0.02981667034327984, -0.011868033558130264, -0.042155832052230835, 0.01714234985411167, 0.002614694880321622, -0.03314370661973953, -0.012354915030300617, 0.020638344809412956, -0.018401838839054108, -0.008103957399725914, -0.03956739977002144, -0.025775521993637085, -0.017138779163360596, 0.008161664009094238, -0.02587280422449112, 0.004702999256551266, 0.003281425219029188, -0.02055470645427704, 0.02633853442966938, 0.02349519170820713, 0.024309081956744194, 0.03859274089336395, 0.002088121837005019, -0.01578478142619133, 0.04926624149084091, -0.024494312703609467, -0.03189810365438461, 0.032464805990457535, -0.01436533685773611, -0.06258347630500793, 0.04787374287843704, -0.006344988010823727, 0.028102798387408257, 0.013388422317802906, -0.010724827647209167, -0.007926958613097668, 0.01967833936214447, 0.014878091402351856, -0.014861085452139378, 0.003158154198899865, 0.010979863815009594, -0.0018547677900642157, -0.018053850159049034, 0.029497139155864716, 0.003259695367887616, -0.009184044785797596, 0.005156217608600855, 0.03141479566693306, -0.01835433952510357, -0.012361152097582817, -0.004215491469949484, -0.033976707607507706, 0.01458059437572956, -0.022069841623306274, 0.015066709369421005, 0.07313891500234604, 0.03593495860695839, -0.03980641067028046, -0.03568384051322937, -0.03269030153751373, -0.005863962695002556, -0.07154279947280884, 0.0026271759998053312, -0.004826166667044163, 0.006408015266060829, 0.025718331336975098, -0.07067332416772842, 0.014792525209486485, 0.058379124850034714, -0.056353770196437836, 0.01990855112671852, 0.01609741896390915, -0.039654843509197235, -0.016553763300180435, 0.02160552330315113, -0.019247068092226982, 0.0005283381906338036, 0.00236986530944705, 0.03637618198990822, 0.0021906611509621143, 0.052844732999801636, -0.009304960258305073, -0.012987328693270683, -0.029507705941796303, 0.004037418868392706, 0.019011905416846275, -0.03489011898636818, -0.00008123970474116504, -0.02385798841714859, -0.0019514973973855376, 0.02269795536994934, -0.06987311691045761, -0.0198396947234869, -0.011472498066723347, 0.039767149835824966, 0.005827801302075386, 0.05188165232539177, -0.01046378817409277, 0.00831039808690548, -0.018762849271297455, -0.024695904925465584, 0.00402145367115736, 0.050047218799591064, 0.004500456154346466, -0.0017423559911549091, 0.001879028044641018, -0.019784515723586082, -0.023512551560997963, 0.015205268748104572, 0.0019032206619158387, -0.025691775605082512, 0.02208300493657589, 0.017480572685599327, 0.007553200237452984, -0.021186573430895805, -0.0027473601512610912, -0.008514578454196453, 0.018486326560378075, 0.06522593647241592, 0.0006675167242065072, -0.03140106424689293, -0.015187626704573631, -0.02535836771130562, -0.0475526824593544, 0.005517303477972746, 0.020705129951238632, -0.026661235839128494, -0.05669032409787178, -0.02651725336909294, -0.024367915466427803, -0.006920201703906059, -0.002561930799856782, -0.020321346819400787, -0.012752121314406395, 0.03580157458782196, -0.019938383251428604, 0.022017130628228188, 0.0101856030523777, 0.014430312439799309, -0.03413712605834007, -0.09200982749462128, 0.03280159458518028, 0.01024728361517191, -0.0029941764660179615, -0.04053815081715584, -0.03547799959778786, -0.028646783903241158, 0.04703297093510628, 0.029878346249461174, 0.03662186115980148, -0.0016714964294806123, 0.021321898326277733, -0.007905099540948868, 0.025228483602404594, -0.01599324680864811, 0.027448933571577072, -0.020269373431801796, 0.005258367862552404, 0.03911822289228439, -0.029137393459677696, 0.015491322614252567, 0.008802227675914764, 0.023884862661361694, -0.01651998981833458, -0.012364023365080357, -0.012995453551411629, -0.0013601804384961724, 0.048851124942302704, -0.0026384133379906416, -0.02756357565522194, 0.041087210178375244, 0.006878326181322336, 0.005618435796350241, 0.014482483267784119, -0.0062438370659947395, -0.03542378172278404, 0.04002473130822182, -0.045285843312740326, -0.03942731022834778, 0.008062041364610195, 0.04614371433854103, 0.0031988462433218956, -0.0585499033331871, -0.01427269447594881, 0.0016561193624511361, -0.035870131105184555, -0.0027795147616416216, 0.06656106561422348, 0.02084263600409031, 0.038021519780159, 0.016650227829813957, 0.055181242525577545, 0.019312672317028046, 0.0158077459782362, -0.01175630558282137, 0.0010381386382505298, 0.01455854531377554, 0.0059501612558960915, 0.010749518871307373, 0.0336189828813076, -0.007628574501723051, 0.005104659590870142, -0.01594630442559719, 0.0057503520511090755, 0.026887038722634315, -0.0027032322250306606, 0.02136102505028248, 0.004278760403394699, 0.007510771043598652, 0.06320656090974808, -0.0016390689415857196, 0.08483485877513885, -0.00242185709066689, 0.02280924841761589, -0.04523026570677757, -0.029060009866952896, -0.01856650412082672, 0.00684268306940794, 0.007335711270570755, 0.03379349038004875, -0.008234472945332527, 0.02591005712747574, 0.0024403438437730074, -0.00517750671133399, 0.0019297805847600102, -0.06835054606199265, 0.055666740983724594, 0.0029684817418456078, 0.00022647780133411288, 0.02802935242652893, 0.00983931589871645, -0.049560580402612686, -0.011320333927869797, 0.004016018472611904, 0.03468414396047592, 0.04369261488318443, 0.04863518849015236, -0.031309425830841064, -0.007592777255922556, 0.031919214874506, -0.08391512930393219, 0.005012440029531717, -0.061716996133327484, 0.0024544126354157925, -0.01734173484146595, -0.019404888153076172 ]
<p>In <a href="http://surveyanalysis.org/wiki/Multiple_Comparisons_%28Post_Hoc_Testing%29" rel="nofollow">http://surveyanalysis.org/wiki/Multiple_Comparisons_(Post_Hoc_Testing)</a></p> <p>It states "For example, if we have a p-value of 0.05 and we conclude it is significant the probability of a false discovery is, by definition, 0.05."</p> <p>My question: I always thought false discovery is Type I error, which is equal to the chosen significance levels in most tests. p-value is the value calculated from the samples. Indeed Wikipedia states "The p-value should not be confused with the significance level α in the Neyman–Pearson approach or the Type I error rate [false positive rate]"</p> <p>So why the statistician in the link claims Type I error is also the p-value?</p>
74,297
[ -0.05244316905736923, -0.03697216138243675, -0.0021552136167883873, -0.03537243604660034, 0.04888381063938141, 0.04486782103776932, 0.00905117578804493, 0.003173542208969593, 0.0017625574255362153, -0.02644754946231842, 0.04988041892647743, 0.010720638558268547, 0.06407500058412552, 0.005280751269310713, 0.031557176262140274, 0.030664220452308655, 0.00854311604052782, 0.030364207923412323, -0.009834561496973038, -0.0038909013383090496, 0.029872622340917587, 0.010535656474530697, 0.003240590449422598, 0.008554462343454361, -0.015499740839004517, 0.032728761434555054, 0.03919466957449913, 0.035399895161390305, 0.016907835379242897, 0.05418214201927185, -0.0461282953619957, -0.011003519408404827, 0.019178396090865135, 0.02097686566412449, 0.007559758145362139, -0.011991928331553936, -0.011976957321166992, 0.026336830109357834, -0.01993740350008011, 0.06646116077899933, -0.013115828856825829, -0.019375713542103767, 0.011250747367739677, 0.02850869670510292, -0.020296363160014153, 0.011669070459902287, -0.012971247546374798, -0.04601629078388214, 0.018885673955082893, -0.0371694341301918, 0.058351822197437286, -0.00567334471270442, 0.04828128218650818, 0.037033241242170334, -0.006913415156304836, 0.0035578045062720776, 0.08917663246393204, 0.036148689687252045, -0.03581802919507027, -0.0595521442592144, -0.025129204615950584, -0.022778697311878204, 0.02056536078453064, -0.004925178363919258, -0.047292280942201614, 0.050177883356809616, -0.036303747445344925, -0.021365555003285408, 0.03388500213623047, 0.013717764057219028, 0.009423507377505302, 0.010743618942797184, 0.0004771030799020082, -0.026296382769942284, -0.004473571199923754, -0.04975442215800285, -0.0006298506632447243, -0.004763368517160416, 0.041563980281353, 0.04668687656521797, 0.011058729141950607, 0.00855239573866129, 0.043710656464099884, 0.04561612382531166, 0.005041890311986208, -0.016467519104480743, 0.05796252563595772, -0.033355098217725754, 0.024715710431337357, 0.012971023097634315, -0.03320559114217758, -0.0031301702838391066, 0.015889659523963928, -0.038769159466028214, -0.030539773404598236, 0.02400982566177845, -0.018414601683616638, 0.040981609374284744, -0.0005401427624747157, 0.005122228991240263, 0.0007689249468967319, -0.028207633644342422, 0.037280503660440445, 0.012689286842942238, -0.02387813851237297, -0.032942332327365875, -0.017709407955408096, 0.030726764351129532, 0.005639903713017702, -0.03636535257101059, -0.0062027741223573685, 0.038655053824186325, 0.02748255804181099, 0.011313723400235176, 0.02157176099717617, -0.03081812895834446, 0.001877953065559268, 0.019228938966989517, 0.09455634653568268, 0.04532639682292938, 0.0254091564565897, -0.028909822925925255, 0.024922408163547516, -0.021303625777363777, -0.07093627750873566, -0.008511882275342941, 0.003982339985668659, -0.03914733976125717, -0.003250599605962634, 0.0641302838921547, 0.002779566217213869, -0.003146147122606635, 0.04266001284122467, 0.0036711986176669598, 0.0422246940433979, 0.014517644420266151, -0.10765890032052994, -0.044639188796281815, 0.0553835965692997, 0.002831809688359499, -0.010627834126353264, -0.07730792462825775, 0.007924356497824192, 0.013256912119686604, 0.035899754613637924, 0.021738586947321892, 0.022644424811005592, -0.020505281165242195, 0.04421012103557587, 0.017357220873236656, -0.006202514283359051, -0.017343472689390182, 0.01122856605798006, -0.02179071493446827, -0.04127073287963867, -0.07903841882944107, 0.02236808091402054, -0.0019438620656728745, -0.010289500467479229, -0.01079029031097889, 0.01371017750352621, -0.024104328826069832, -0.008886203169822693, -0.0025157176423817873, 0.025361940264701843, 0.0048953392542898655, 0.07458669692277908, 0.0010203843703493476, 0.02837805263698101, 0.04199491813778877, -0.01868887059390545, 0.022646499797701836, -0.0051729753613471985, 0.0546921044588089, 0.03138156235218048, -0.04719894006848335, -0.01563243381679058, -0.036150045692920685, 0.035882335156202316, 0.021963993087410927, -0.04888901859521866, 0.020585346966981888, -0.009271794930100441, -0.021245719864964485, 0.027919456362724304, 0.05930541083216667, -0.023252977058291435, -0.00576036935672164, 0.031244581565260887, -0.03356551006436348, -0.07262470573186874, -0.06482666730880737, -0.030615543946623802, -0.031555306166410446, -0.013535658828914165, 0.027510223910212517, 0.024238456040620804, 0.017094526439905167, -0.03097281977534294, -0.003361040959134698, -0.02104462869465351, -0.01865958608686924, 0.03688528388738632, -0.05746271461248398, 0.0025044188369065523, 0.06407423317432404, 0.019254270941019058, 0.005901654716581106, 0.041128404438495636, -0.019005119800567627, -0.03248719871044159, 0.027613190934062004, -0.04125303775072098, 0.020646817982196808, -0.0037317657843232155, -0.02774977684020996, 0.01543688215315342, -0.007966456934809685, -0.019177734851837158, 0.048989225178956985, -0.03414890542626381, 0.053858306258916855, 0.06013244390487671, -0.0003856662369798869, -0.007490283343940973, 0.016640210524201393, 0.0120291318744421, -0.006924287881702185, -0.028340723365545273, -0.002987142186611891, -0.04349904507398605, -0.03066094219684601, 0.042400941252708435, 0.00668726209551096, -0.013710098341107368, 0.005402266513556242, 0.047840505838394165, 0.04381885007023811, -0.004519822541624308, 0.04928294196724892, -0.003974383696913719, -0.04293711856007576, -0.003406345611438155, 0.051608774811029434, -0.006372813135385513, 0.00883830152451992, 0.04043526202440262, -0.020226728171110153, 0.06502354890108109, 0.0010782759636640549, 0.000732755521312356, 0.03815019130706787, -0.04005808010697365, -0.023037564009428024, 0.005746390204876661, 0.021375244483351707, 0.011241049505770206, -0.018326304852962494, 0.033464331179857254, 0.03044833056628704, -0.00908899586647749, 0.005601873155683279, -0.029061436653137207, 0.0038384776562452316, 0.03981224447488785, 0.019786467775702477, -0.0296797938644886, 0.011097550392150879, 0.012281649746000767, -0.046784788370132446, -0.01749439164996147, -0.07049916684627533, -0.01314166933298111, 0.00048263874487020075, 0.023838911205530167, -0.022448984906077385, -0.002519572153687477, 0.03283269330859184, -0.04006100818514824, -0.024274809285998344, -0.03482368588447571, -0.04150130972266197, 0.016009211540222168, 0.015113461762666702, -0.059284742921590805, 0.013716372661292553, -0.025829831138253212, -0.03092244453728199, 0.03171154484152794, -0.014175735414028168, -0.004683583974838257, 0.032788101583719254, 0.004126762505620718, -0.01547274086624384, -0.03199215233325958, -0.04551400989294052, -0.015197730623185635, -0.00568911898881197, -0.03856189548969269, 0.011510767042636871, -0.029138341546058655, -0.011698043905198574, 0.04610760882496834, -0.026876550167798996, -0.0207351204007864, -0.021838143467903137, -0.015766533091664314, 0.01931912824511528, -0.008156954310834408, 0.005510066635906696, 0.023616556078195572, -0.04899279400706291, -0.022652380168437958, -0.005664547439664602, -0.06196734309196472, 0.027706826105713844, -0.019982991740107536, 0.005593635607510805, 0.0035792223643511534, -0.027642378583550453, 0.0833948403596878, 0.025883637368679047, -0.002192780841141939, -0.020638983696699142, 0.025021757930517197, -0.0537293516099453, -0.03293001651763916, 0.021163783967494965, 0.025921529158949852, 0.0010698725236579776, 0.01762826181948185, -0.03201455622911453, 0.026342175900936127, 0.058143120259046555, 0.008339925669133663, 0.0035023086238652468, 0.0003406000614631921, 0.0074891988188028336, -0.014735669828951359, 0.009132226929068565, 0.023972762748599052, -0.02307303622364998, 0.013699484057724476, 0.0027817690279334784, 0.04326699301600456, 0.013580449856817722, -0.005222325213253498, 0.022655729204416275, 0.003251452464610338, 0.014941016212105751, -0.05202244967222214, 0.0002662657352630049, 0.015509774908423424, -0.0015228145057335496, -0.020318467170000076, 0.03910859301686287, 0.01553177647292614, -0.04401986673474312, -0.02131010591983795, 0.038307808339595795, 0.02925802767276764, -0.032097574323415756, -0.04213542863726616, -0.00230786157771945, -0.018051516264677048, 0.022625794634222984, -0.021151628345251083, -0.05696748569607735, 0.04624024033546448, 0.039993766695261, 0.03339466452598572, -0.016368642449378967, -0.04400421679019928, 0.0005723504000343382, -0.0358472503721714, 0.021009914577007294, -0.009693426080048084, 0.03713131323456764, -0.038412924855947495, 0.03574557602405548, 0.022742731496691704, -0.027571652084589005, -0.014185345731675625, -0.00432143360376358, -0.042381931096315384, 0.03470122069120407, -0.03054630383849144, -0.039091698825359344, -0.001186428009532392, -0.048585548996925354, 0.006866379175335169, -0.01837759278714657, 0.03639710694551468, 0.002361758379265666, 0.023587068542838097, -0.02421935647726059, 0.022040871903300285, 0.006707196589559317, 0.014949549920856953, -0.03591308742761612, 0.03597472980618477, 0.034150633960962296, -0.0012387215392664075, 0.029921239241957664, 0.03481224551796913, -0.005421555135399103, -0.005042750388383865, -0.019863802939653397, 0.013400105759501457, 0.04508601874113083, 0.007457328028976917, 0.028796566650271416, 0.021918239071965218, -0.03896986320614815, 0.055908504873514175, 0.00427190912887454, 0.0313304103910923, 0.05941484495997429, -0.01662091165781021, -0.031581297516822815, -0.013820421881973743, -0.022965576499700546, 0.01139048207551241, 0.013753018341958523, -0.002847015857696533, 0.006953699514269829, 0.027390923351049423, 0.025809280574321747, -0.05879883095622063, 0.054029062390327454, 0.06304679811000824, 0.017320076003670692, 0.027089562267065048, -0.04677041247487068, -0.021163539960980415, -0.04732092097401619, -0.012308109551668167, 0.0350399948656559, 0.035216186195611954, -0.013733205385506153, -0.019260196015238762, 0.026735104620456696, -0.035570885986089706, -0.04642288014292717, -0.022380447015166283, 0.014039686881005764, 0.0005426702555269003, -0.010388770140707493, -0.029413430020213127, 0.024133935570716858, 0.028980368748307228, 0.04451018199324608, 0.0052913217805325985, 0.007889262400567532, -0.08491246402263641, -0.00247388519346714, 0.016315314918756485, 0.036756400018930435, -0.04885762184858322, 0.02274760603904724, -0.03489333391189575, 0.03638589382171631, 0.02670283056795597, -0.04103118181228638, 0.0314682312309742, -0.011949838139116764, 0.022722160443663597, -0.03501683101058006, -0.013072284869849682, -0.03272659331560135, -0.003259822726249695, -0.013182184658944607, 0.018750185146927834, -0.014498657546937466, -0.004379774909466505, -0.07027781754732132, -0.018942801281809807, -0.005553502589464188, 0.05464243143796921, -0.009095019660890102, 0.008565342985093594, -0.015050134621560574, 0.03591088950634003, -0.010682938620448112, -0.060203917324543, 0.015531039796769619, -0.009090815670788288, 0.013614158146083355, 0.03423735871911049, -0.031199363991618156, -0.028643349185585976, 0.03821951523423195, 0.027557140216231346, -0.04137379303574562, -0.02270815707743168, -0.012262041680514812, 0.011688503436744213, 0.013273858465254307, 0.004165844060480595, 0.08573127537965775, -0.010334375314414501, -0.02505781129002571, -0.01479524839669466, -0.0366281233727932, 0.05058835446834564, -0.06042730063199997, -0.02089734375476837, -0.03938673064112663, 0.023927299305796623, -0.03480811044573784, 0.037920430302619934, 0.04894651472568512, 0.00518005108460784, -0.013918227516114712, 0.004864858463406563, -0.0074118333868682384, -0.00009306854190072045, 0.009839873760938644, -0.025513233616948128, -0.0007924444507807493, 0.030384527519345284, 0.007681639865040779, 0.004876549355685711, 0.04178803414106369, -0.029695900157094002, -0.029737180098891258, 0.008164607919752598, -0.027927808463573456, 0.02436789870262146, -0.003400980494916439, -0.05876835063099861, 0.03307923302054405, -0.028836632147431374, -0.002264833776280284, -0.053463343530893326, 0.00819114688783884, -0.008835548534989357, -0.06870747357606888, -0.028248528018593788, 0.01667446456849575, -0.01004928257316351, 0.037847850471735, -0.05656977742910385, 0.04554684832692146, -0.003792266361415386, 0.02038324810564518, -0.0827937051653862, 0.0029697611462324858, 0.046385347843170166, 0.01412900909781456, -0.025356987491250038, 0.0004227978934068233, 0.008207772858440876, -0.005227607674896717, -0.008154409937560558, -0.00522989546880126, 0.037262316793203354, -0.017635878175497055, -0.05092979222536087, -0.017683591693639755, 0.028071686625480652, 0.06679553538560867, -0.01653289794921875, 0.005048559047281742, -0.020708510652184486, -0.021980930119752884, -0.004730137996375561, 0.013652320951223373, 0.023002417758107185, -0.0147081408649683, -0.002197772031649947, -0.03171940892934799, -0.022593356668949127, -0.0000802872673375532, -0.008092806674540043, 0.0000197658173419768, 0.015499379485845566, -0.0013629000168293715, 0.012256991118192673, -0.032376550137996674, 0.03162303939461708, -0.017309699207544327, 0.04441484436392784, -0.008021421730518341, 0.015968767926096916, -0.019354933872818947, 0.01312693115323782, 0.019919810816645622, -0.00407410180196166, -0.0010476737516000867, 0.04379993677139282, 0.051437731832265854, -0.04570530727505684, 0.017243407666683197, -0.012475956231355667, -0.050334688276052475, 0.009263369254767895, 0.03595603629946709, -0.01737365871667862, 0.006389558780938387, 0.007127835415303707, -0.039756327867507935, 0.0030290763825178146, 0.0019364983309060335, 0.03778543695807457, 0.05246588960289955, 0.002235663589090109, 0.0323135182261467, 0.035533417016267776, 0.01226337905973196, -0.010753207840025425, -0.009314650669693947, 0.0018145388457924128, -0.003604970406740904, 0.018954362720251083, 0.03188573196530342, -0.031028099358081818, 0.006571057252585888, 0.052574433386325836, 0.01620999537408352, 0.007720355410128832, 0.03381391987204552, 0.04267391189932823, 0.038620688021183014, 0.0029195367824286222, 0.004016071557998657, -0.02891348861157894, 0.07804053276777267, -0.016052361577749252, 0.011407836340367794, -0.0100377406924963, -0.03722167760133743, 0.05464897304773331, -0.0007958176429383457, 0.014148740097880363, -0.045394524931907654, -0.04578018933534622, -0.036873795092105865, 0.030776720494031906, -0.01411095354706049, 0.00507056200876832, 0.035211242735385895, -0.028041522949934006, 0.00030821870313957334, 0.00482738995924592, 0.027944838628172874, 0.01605101488530636, -0.05907236039638519, -0.06488004326820374, -0.03358637914061546, -0.025442516431212425, 0.019891604781150818, -0.037483055144548416, -0.05850638076663017, 0.00962295476347208, -0.05158543214201927, 0.008825276978313923, 0.027705809101462364, 0.04384381324052811, -0.06049264594912529, 0.03868608549237251, 0.019350796937942505, 0.0475197471678257, 0.005770481191575527, -0.05640418082475662, 0.10959798097610474, 0.07633167505264282, 0.03566182777285576, -0.06766041368246078, 0.03980991616845131, -0.024100057780742645, 0.004382392391562462, -0.007110514212399721, 0.040819838643074036, 0.021398374810814857, 0.005442167166620493, 0.04121970012784004, 0.07212191075086594, 0.02483411133289337, -0.009190861135721207, 0.06584709882736206, -0.02110173925757408, -0.030551137402653694, -0.006030798424035311, 0.011226505041122437, -0.01759091019630432, -0.04109613969922066, 0.010385903529822826, 0.0019687185995280743, -0.007763855624943972, -0.012230005115270615, 0.025370026007294655, -0.022160856053233147, -0.017611315473914146, 0.024277659133076668, -0.05661749094724655, -0.020581159740686417, 0.010224440135061741, -0.0005899760872125626, -0.04338764399290085, 0.0004946720437146723, -0.0062385317869484425, -0.0026315965224057436, -0.00036054477095603943, 0.06631419062614441, 0.019358070567250252, 0.006772549357265234, 0.007824634201824665, 0.06198558583855629, -0.04623038321733475, -0.005493939388543367, -0.010085617192089558, 0.05300574004650116, -0.012040415778756142, 0.013318781740963459, -0.02349117025732994, -0.02486913464963436, -0.017834017053246498, -0.01900542713701725, -0.0038994010537862778, 0.023288831114768982, 0.004648009780794382, -0.05030117183923721, -0.018561236560344696, -0.06599898636341095, -0.01448886189609766, -0.018632786348462105, 0.05356436222791672, 0.04138052836060524, -0.03552486374974251, -0.02902185171842575, -0.0022345015313476324, 0.04051528498530388, -0.007786741945892572, 0.031220851466059685, -0.0004904844681732357, 0.015532299876213074, -0.04752689599990845, 0.0017805644311010838, -0.026728816330432892, -0.02343383990228176, 0.05042462423443794, -0.020897820591926575, -0.006946357898414135, -0.011230182833969593, -0.035559263080358505, 0.029885470867156982, -0.046971000730991364, -0.02138448879122734, -0.055853623896837234, -0.0285172238945961, 0.037074826657772064, 0.027809955179691315, -0.016002219170331955, 0.02519374154508114, 0.016513939946889877, 0.003837554482743144, -0.001980552216991782, -0.07775142788887024, 0.014581025578081608, 0.006911814212799072, -0.03257504478096962, -0.027331899851560593, 0.005516229663044214, 0.03683803230524063, 0.0505867674946785, 0.03515608608722687, -0.0064188274554908276, 0.017336446791887283, -0.0009466647170484066, -0.001526987412944436, 0.008159876801073551, -0.005934806074947119, 0.0070189801044762135, 0.01461043581366539, 0.018039114773273468, -0.016733882948756218, -0.04046778753399849, -0.06433238089084625, 0.0022078303154557943, 0.03844073787331581, -0.0033088859636336565, -0.016946470364928246, 0.004082776606082916, -0.007358881179243326, -0.0018829884938895702, -0.029208283871412277, -0.01943371258676052, -0.04900386184453964, 0.002273784950375557, 0.008225004188716412, 0.001261598663404584, -0.034986820071935654, -0.013191730715334415, -0.014269057661294937, 0.004785969853401184, 0.039653800427913666, 0.017056239768862724, -0.013493814505636692, 0.0007471343269571662, 0.044408153742551804, 0.04000389948487282, 0.06262534111738205, -0.004248480312526226, 0.006876959931105375, 0.061807092279195786, -0.04915822669863701, -0.07405030727386475, 0.05427144095301628, -0.01074175350368023, 0.009473009034991264, 0.023895198479294777, 0.01825050264596939, -0.0111538739874959, 0.019194908440113068, -0.03271167725324631, -0.02702018991112709, 0.005061476491391659, 0.000987506122328341, -0.030333835631608963, -0.004814160987734795, -0.01819552108645439, -0.010499016381800175, 0.016080699861049652, 0.03142616152763367, 0.03625107929110527, 0.02602444402873516, -0.008442887105047703, -0.014361138455569744, -0.007051127031445503, 0.015132860280573368, 0.016318319365382195, -0.024902567267417908, 0.004886550363153219, 0.0787387415766716, -0.0320284366607666, 0.017792964354157448, -0.01047277171164751, 0.02587057277560234, -0.09948467463254929, -0.014062128961086273, -0.011592678725719452, 0.03217252716422081, 0.008842939510941505, -0.04674895107746124, 0.002522270893678069, 0.0021169567480683327, -0.0729122906923294, 0.0009047000203281641, -0.02568507008254528, -0.025353679433465004, -0.04084042087197304, -0.023138506338000298, -0.024777395650744438, 0.041780419647693634, 0.03462281823158264, 0.02216646634042263, 0.03066864237189293, -0.0013940337812528014, 0.0013228771276772022, -0.01303168572485447, -0.03849886357784271, 0.06576566398143768, -0.036788418889045715, -0.08595166355371475, 0.04886949062347412, -0.02126610092818737, -0.04465597867965698, 0.0432334765791893, 0.002339030848816037, 0.018654840067029, 0.05800914764404297, 0.03059910237789154, 0.03321623057126999, 0.007608606480062008, 0.0411602258682251, 0.007970423437654972, -0.025508252903819084, 0.04540155827999115, 0.029592406004667282, 0.03896806389093399, -0.013790528289973736, -0.006923454347997904, -0.0018805174622684717, -0.03476198762655258, -0.039388757199048996, -0.01142584253102541, -0.020950352773070335, 0.0018453843658789992, -0.008961398154497147, 0.004446337930858135, 0.0018274834146723151, -0.03513375669717789, 0.014371425844728947, -0.03375295549631119, -0.009447881020605564, 0.044851887971162796, 0.01205001212656498, -0.03188613802194595, 0.02361999824643135, -0.018371401354670525, -0.018928159028291702, 0.006923479959368706, -0.017622919753193855, -0.005204197950661182, -0.08272485435009003, 0.010704729706048965, 0.01768568903207779, -0.022094659507274628, -0.007297597825527191, -0.002511925296857953, -0.034834299236536026, 0.05141976848244667, -0.003214402124285698, 0.004606886301189661, 0.008677184581756592, -0.0315442830324173, 0.005387661047279835, -0.08652346581220627, 0.08031821250915527, 0.012919633649289608, 0.01215067133307457, -0.04042491316795349, -0.017297867685556412, -0.00990236084908247, 0.01179595198482275, 0.03741161897778511, 0.002919034566730261, -0.014182047918438911, 0.006560127250850201, 0.029426390305161476, 0.0064546107314527035, -0.07563793659210205, 0.04215634614229202, 0.0029187642503529787, -0.030436748638749123, -0.0029829181730747223, -0.02243463508784771, 0.041311949491500854, 0.009658406488597393, 0.007207476533949375, -0.02699826844036579, 0.032892607152462006, -0.021599896252155304, -0.003038124181330204, 0.04059002548456192, 0.012355417013168335, -0.02072540484368801, 0.04868658632040024, 0.0016930121928453445, 0.02851729467511177, 0.04248332232236862, 0.027614586055278778, -0.04068783298134804, 0.02391010895371437, -0.015353667549788952, 0.011025214567780495, 0.021628951653838158, 0.01687919907271862, -0.0025364067405462265, -0.028651943430304527, 0.00697218207642436, -0.0026218018028885126, -0.01839769445359707, 0.0023123270366340876, 0.02356182597577572, -0.007226255722343922, 0.014511161483824253, -0.015462891198694706, 0.050653886049985886, -0.009046402759850025, -0.03667331859469414, -0.019526280462741852, 0.039387281984090805, 0.013468586839735508, -0.00044003655784763396, 0.02217315509915352, 0.031224004924297333, -0.0022357094567269087, 0.017799047753214836, 0.0214756578207016, 0.0672646015882492, -0.02920505777001381, -0.015554780140519142, -0.009464045986533165, -0.01795373111963272, 0.0033973276149481535, -0.0016539888456463814, -0.0032586578745394945, 0.06950724869966507, -0.023100918158888817, 0.018311001360416412, 0.000015354436982306652, -0.03512382134795189, -0.024068834260106087, -0.02130078710615635, 0.026232875883579254, 0.041150130331516266, -0.011280280537903309, -0.0023072888143360615, 0.0029109627939760685, 0.024882139638066292, 0.01708652824163437, -0.03668593987822533, 0.023370957002043724, -0.013917381875216961, 0.007082279305905104, -0.054441940039396286, 0.02207345701754093, -0.012045423500239849, 0.016422776505351067, 0.0179605595767498, 0.003262667916715145, 0.008980455808341503, -0.02504078485071659, 0.00045786466216668487, -0.013801010325551033, 0.054476331919431686, -0.07121772319078445, -0.006165904458612204, -0.04894145205616951, 0.025034809485077858, -0.004344643093645573, -0.00985802710056305 ]
<p>I just used the standard formula to determine the sample size of a sample to match the mean of a pupulation with an error margin of 3 percentage points and with a 90% probability. I know would like to check that the mean of my sample is actually within the 3% margin of error of the mean in the population. To do so I am taking the population and appending the sample, identifying observations in the sample with a dummy called sample. Then I run the following regresion: reg var1 sample And I am testing wheter the coefficient for the dummy variable sample is less than 3 percentage points. To do so I am using a one sided t test.</p> <p>But this is only ok when the coefficient of the dummy variable "sample" has the "right" sign. I would like to test the joing hypoithesis that the coefficient of the dummy variable sample is greater than -3 and lower than 3. Does anyone have any insight on how to do this test? Thanks in advance.</p>
49,338
[ 0.006603067275136709, -0.01940343901515007, -0.012961041182279587, 0.02860443666577339, 0.033231064677238464, 0.015306279063224792, -0.02767462655901909, 0.011771776713430882, 0.0026181701105087996, -0.015049692243337631, 0.009731763042509556, 0.06211421266198158, 0.06816764175891876, -0.0010350750526413321, -0.005918311420828104, -0.005143116693943739, -0.01525807660073042, -0.007355041336268187, 0.008192315697669983, -0.062275346368551254, 0.009781304746866226, -0.024029826745390892, 0.033077336847782135, -0.005294834729284048, 0.015716511756181717, 0.024709992110729218, 0.0637250617146492, 0.00022405631898436695, -0.0014719553291797638, 0.04924950748682022, -0.0474008172750473, -0.04639185220003128, 0.01620263233780861, -0.002187888603657484, 0.02394021488726139, 0.022659925743937492, 0.021350814029574394, -0.035682301968336105, 0.0029207344632595778, 0.012717480771243572, -0.037660229951143265, -0.013500300236046314, 0.00763601902872324, 0.004709405824542046, -0.011073647066950798, 0.028492826968431473, 0.001114269602112472, -0.015372490510344505, 0.03722550347447395, -0.05817047506570816, 0.04529808461666107, 0.023450979962944984, 0.02477389946579933, 0.0060860104858875275, -0.00012344452261459082, -0.005994757171720266, 0.01424543745815754, 0.02934175729751587, -0.002034188713878393, 0.010231351479887962, -0.01099847350269556, -0.07044967263936996, 0.005537754390388727, 0.02031104639172554, -0.0660964846611023, 0.012915955856442451, -0.04797130823135376, -0.0135043328627944, 0.0009886791231110692, -0.02839444950222969, 0.013477016240358353, -0.010725891217589378, 0.01944875717163086, 0.004619787912815809, -0.0036714840680360794, -0.009564411826431751, 0.03645477443933487, 0.05786372348666191, 0.033387165516614914, 0.04313265159726143, -0.0036997580900788307, 0.01878010295331478, 0.017422063276171684, 0.041140493005514145, 0.04232018068432808, -0.005101916845887899, 0.08050628751516342, -0.0537167452275753, 0.02773948572576046, 0.02262437716126442, -0.027482399716973305, -0.0018624160438776016, 0.059040166437625885, 0.008848320692777634, -0.008530884049832821, 0.03316430374979973, -0.026510849595069885, 0.031103212386369705, -0.0038443284574896097, 0.015580186620354652, -0.04692757502198219, -0.05246753618121147, 0.046372611075639725, 0.03412584960460663, -0.02237139642238617, 0.015590907074511051, -0.029668331146240234, -0.013562467880547047, 0.03639791160821915, -0.024084635078907013, -0.0031346676405519247, 0.00518076354637742, 0.012425947934389114, -0.017720863223075867, 0.026445263996720314, -0.009776406921446323, 0.003512708004564047, -0.0061595244333148, 0.06301777809858322, 0.02670050598680973, 0.060327962040901184, -0.037260670214891434, 0.034132927656173706, -0.03377588093280792, -0.07030680030584335, 0.03604511544108391, -0.019948987290263176, 0.0016126949340105057, -0.03716735914349556, 0.06665831804275513, 0.02047419734299183, -0.06998053193092346, 0.03880254179239273, 0.008136412128806114, 0.04580465704202652, -0.022566109895706177, -0.07049158215522766, -0.04833066463470459, 0.0063601103611290455, -0.0009786804439499974, -0.003848734311759472, -0.061044614762067795, 0.0024928601924329996, 0.050184037536382675, 0.07965905964374542, 0.03148183971643448, 0.04368913918733597, 0.0006828466430306435, 0.012394602410495281, 0.0341101698577404, -0.045568544417619705, -0.026213934645056725, -0.038446806371212006, -0.011304310522973537, -0.03300129622220993, -0.06318211555480957, 0.01077994704246521, -0.01037211250513792, -0.028198543936014175, -0.03239439055323601, 0.023396842181682587, -0.017845463007688522, -0.013180687092244625, -0.013747764751315117, -0.006344788707792759, -0.05199494585394859, 0.059080954641103745, -0.027253801003098488, -0.0018028508638963103, -0.007852906361222267, 0.039140112698078156, 0.017723027616739273, 0.008575002662837505, 0.04716810584068298, 0.051424309611320496, -0.08134555071592331, -0.0051387157291173935, -0.030239088460803032, 0.03359123319387436, 0.005740026477724314, -0.00828516110777855, 0.007801883853971958, -0.021566083654761314, 0.014487703330814838, 0.02192464843392372, 0.028198327869176865, -0.009258119389414787, 0.008693545125424862, 0.06830277293920517, -0.02528904192149639, -0.05741547420620918, -0.032667286694049835, -0.01901106908917427, 0.040041059255599976, -0.048728346824645996, 0.019646810367703438, 0.023481758311390877, 0.02318463660776615, -0.011215024627745152, -0.003972888458520174, -0.015980517491698265, 0.005510799586772919, 0.04539060965180397, -0.05376524105668068, 0.027926364913582802, 0.024002540856599808, 0.05883852019906044, -0.03318573161959648, 0.039266813546419144, -0.010587363503873348, -0.02490111254155636, 0.03304801136255264, -0.0124422088265419, 0.011628923006355762, -0.005595460068434477, -0.011099517345428467, 0.01021254900842905, -0.0049192942678928375, 0.005613760091364384, 0.039711859077215195, -0.05776083096861839, 0.06099811568856239, 0.05267098546028137, 0.02914891205728054, 0.00008469176827929914, -0.013288482092320919, -0.010836176574230194, 0.01992442086338997, -0.016142822802066803, 0.020826352760195732, -0.031264275312423706, -0.030273372307419777, 0.0048859394155442715, -0.024861635640263557, -0.04383811727166176, -0.020248403772711754, 0.05177782475948334, -0.060812365263700485, 0.01869773492217064, 0.05445996671915054, 0.028403641656041145, -0.013105208985507488, 0.0021844152361154556, 0.0229318980127573, 0.00485795084387064, -0.00640665041282773, 0.028960958123207092, 0.01030076015740633, 0.057571589946746826, 0.03286200016736984, 0.0019005793146789074, 0.011863538064062595, 0.001894412562251091, 0.006541446782648563, -0.004683293402194977, -0.016838809475302696, 0.03668350353837013, -0.04316205158829689, -0.01123866904526949, 0.04748493805527687, 0.010247607715427876, 0.014261105097830296, 0.025972608476877213, -0.019137321040034294, 0.02234696038067341, 0.045665521174669266, -0.01450387667864561, 0.006772651802748442, 0.015934474766254425, -0.04976176843047142, -0.009404274635016918, -0.0015372508205473423, -0.013404719531536102, -0.041876666247844696, -0.0024358872324228287, 0.03887655958533287, -0.03739829361438751, 0.015283827669918537, -0.004894364159554243, -0.0013857195153832436, -0.03574216365814209, 0.010521035641431808, 0.021991752088069916, -0.006050195544958115, -0.05349978059530258, -0.008280347101390362, -0.0017084655119106174, -0.017247382551431656, 0.007029501721262932, 0.022287892177700996, -0.03351264446973801, 0.04466916620731354, 0.012979809194803238, -0.03336719423532486, -0.00436419015750289, -0.020342744886875153, -0.014378927648067474, -0.024404337629675865, 0.008954922668635845, 0.04386314004659653, 0.013599223457276821, -0.061697691679000854, 0.02057267539203167, -0.034422021359205246, -0.016385063529014587, -0.054912034422159195, -0.005247865803539753, 0.0064919488504529, -0.028656328096985817, 0.04012154042720795, 0.03408960625529289, -0.0010734857060015202, 0.0027597174048423767, -0.0513480082154274, -0.051582835614681244, -0.005056198686361313, 0.03319207951426506, 0.011768195778131485, 0.02618773840367794, -0.03565501794219017, 0.04601156711578369, 0.03625999763607979, -0.00521018635481596, -0.024105247110128403, 0.01967475935816765, -0.026206059381365776, -0.036876581609249115, 0.04744251072406769, -0.015014773234724998, -0.0025396740529686213, 0.015607060864567757, -0.0010285802418366075, 0.03190137445926666, 0.02530490607023239, 0.03799950331449509, -0.012351042591035366, 0.005991233512759209, -0.029373597353696823, -0.031337227672338486, 0.03768967464566231, 0.008681192062795162, -0.02774251624941826, 0.003950620535761118, -0.010587925091385841, 0.06702589243650436, 0.016934629529714584, -0.029047776013612747, -0.02430880255997181, -0.02570902556180954, 0.0169318038970232, -0.005542435683310032, 0.023715144023299217, 0.028746606782078743, -0.021411869674921036, 0.02461949922144413, 0.03997210040688515, -0.002222492592409253, -0.025213636457920074, 0.028540801256895065, 0.03068927675485611, 0.02204231731593609, -0.012106099165976048, -0.03079407662153244, -0.05270131677389145, -0.03150497376918793, 0.019376035779714584, -0.028888745233416557, -0.012927107512950897, 0.03763379901647568, 0.05726643279194832, 0.03357855603098869, -0.020587507635354996, -0.0002847283030860126, -0.018170520663261414, -0.024837585166096687, -0.007130899000912905, 0.007195012178272009, 0.02143322490155697, -0.012434125877916813, -0.014440082013607025, 0.04537589102983475, -0.001734888064675033, 0.021076293662190437, -0.0175241157412529, -0.05067620798945427, 0.0594576820731163, -0.026205603033304214, -0.045200444757938385, 0.008508997038006783, 0.020894328132271767, 0.007071430329233408, -0.04371199756860733, 0.027592113241553307, 0.018661649897694588, 0.03307702764868736, -0.022659771144390106, 0.033706676214933395, 0.017200196161866188, 0.03627530112862587, 0.011619416065514088, 0.03634241595864296, 0.010491251945495605, -0.0026391465216875076, -0.001211519818753004, 0.0387519970536232, -0.035962510854005814, -0.018864663317799568, -0.022745708003640175, 0.040372155606746674, 0.028536494821310043, 0.07498141378164291, 0.06289343535900116, 0.03465159609913826, -0.04673859477043152, 0.036988455802202225, -0.02232058160007, 0.016645243391394615, 0.05230259150266647, 0.008699208498001099, -0.00666850246489048, -0.03969306871294975, -0.043803345412015915, -0.008391104638576508, 0.0028363645542412996, 0.006292186211794615, -0.018766792491078377, 0.042670879513025284, 0.027714984491467476, -0.06451653689146042, 0.016556335613131523, 0.0818905234336853, 0.029839159920811653, 0.0054723285138607025, -0.057246945798397064, 0.0026707316283136606, 0.01889362931251526, -0.010743026621639729, 0.034103140234947205, 0.03283393755555153, -0.0028613058384507895, -0.024549249559640884, 0.06076084449887276, -0.048491980880498886, -0.0327346995472908, -0.0014040765818208456, 0.017045535147190094, 0.03690233826637268, 0.006585804279893637, -0.07450760900974274, 0.03201860561966896, 0.0328642763197422, 0.012043091468513012, 0.021262258291244507, -0.00514224311336875, -0.08565457910299301, 0.023181045427918434, 0.04026959091424942, 0.06843777000904083, -0.05694762244820595, -0.029412001371383667, -0.02532639540731907, 0.022558316588401794, 0.017181063070893288, -0.0695948377251625, -0.012509333901107311, -0.03482198342680931, 0.01043244730681181, -0.014058979228138924, 0.000015954241462168284, -0.07879862189292908, 0.007581683807075024, -0.015116794034838676, -0.012317592278122902, -0.012277565896511078, -0.02307519130408764, -0.046838194131851196, 0.02337588556110859, 0.029796458780765533, 0.0355704203248024, -0.04184892773628235, -0.006315876264125109, 0.02844030223786831, 0.0350203700363636, -0.03163580223917961, -0.04475236311554909, 0.020149296149611473, -0.02512330561876297, 0.015887947753071785, 0.002285194583237171, -0.024306630715727806, 0.0022105900570750237, 0.003556781681254506, 0.052206411957740784, -0.03533758223056793, -0.01667732000350952, -0.00997551716864109, 0.005461381282657385, -0.003095604246482253, 0.014897755347192287, 0.05773834511637688, -0.0016264445148408413, 0.06414949893951416, 0.005313101690262556, -0.050780992954969406, -0.01709570549428463, -0.008146040141582489, -0.02151663228869438, -0.05852057784795761, -0.010010241530835629, -0.004483603872358799, 0.018300119787454605, -0.027933234348893166, 0.014824622310698032, -0.06548098474740982, 0.01243455708026886, -0.011968300677835941, -0.02202661521732807, 0.02035464718937874, 0.01880546100437641, 0.03797874227166176, 0.013911194168031216, -0.017941216006875038, -0.02294806018471718, 0.03498014807701111, -0.04006612300872803, -0.02457556501030922, 0.010505294427275658, -0.021167736500501633, 0.028512900695204735, -0.007104832679033279, -0.02320592664182186, -0.00802671816200018, -0.01892629638314247, 0.015116020105779171, -0.049703508615493774, 0.05657991021871567, -0.04738575220108032, 0.011274625547230244, 0.025815753266215324, 0.04323546588420868, -0.018411556258797646, 0.04615543782711029, -0.0531284436583519, 0.024608373641967773, 0.0036021117120981216, 0.023273654282093048, -0.053962592035532, -0.06701656430959702, -0.004473014269024134, 0.029826033860445023, -0.010223540477454662, -0.04141353443264961, -0.05851927772164345, -0.0241513941437006, -0.009280374273657799, -0.016161931678652763, 0.04786112159490585, -0.025631776079535484, -0.007817371748387814, 0.0021743238903582096, -0.010294420644640923, 0.07065470516681671, -0.011485886760056019, -0.017791716381907463, 0.0028278359677642584, -0.01955864392220974, -0.021266544237732887, 0.01993700861930847, -0.03318392485380173, -0.041175249963998795, -0.009115980006754398, -0.0020184454042464495, -0.01279353629797697, 0.010358556173741817, -0.027370836585760117, -0.049924466758966446, -0.0005778520717285573, -0.023934224620461464, 0.009834193624556065, -0.06838709861040115, 0.011456835083663464, -0.00793508905917406, -0.008418227545917034, -0.030197694897651672, 0.009580928832292557, -0.005936554167419672, 0.007799947168678045, 0.0243709497153759, 0.014901284128427505, -0.021050944924354553, -0.01194078754633665, 0.058584537357091904, 0.014732010662555695, 0.027098873630166054, -0.020550107583403587, -0.00538735231384635, 0.050654053688049316, 0.017914891242980957, -0.03307652100920677, 0.013422396965324879, 0.017702748998999596, -0.05367143824696541, 0.00011487862502690405, -0.05223339796066284, 0.0015388865722343326, 0.03386840596795082, 0.005697110202163458, 0.05553930252790451, 0.05147175118327141, 0.00900351069867611, -0.009587416425347328, -0.007144475821405649, -0.042046159505844116, -0.02415473200380802, 0.007267505396157503, 0.04363720118999481, 0.0013988841092213988, 0.039533261209726334, 0.001704778173007071, 0.001144184498116374, -0.006166066508740187, 0.06319798529148102, 0.0062040057964622974, 0.025049900636076927, 0.046039070934057236, -0.003437249455600977, -0.026052318513393402, 0.0033933704253286123, -0.029612934216856956, -0.004259766545146704, -0.04276785999536514, -0.021741975098848343, 0.008499318733811378, 0.06096608191728592, -0.0038448506966233253, -0.03416914492845535, -0.055502813309431076, -0.04334147274494171, -0.0064559862948954105, 0.034899719059467316, -0.044205885380506516, 0.0541551448404789, 0.018741903826594353, 0.016745688393712044, 0.018404392525553703, 0.048397667706012726, -0.043023090809583664, -0.029418161138892174, -0.028444357216358185, -0.030662046745419502, -0.015264247544109821, 0.009092725813388824, 0.0034145559184253216, -0.0010868285316973925, 0.05503346398472786, -0.043224383145570755, 0.010863370262086391, 0.0003800614213105291, 0.05401565134525299, 0.008175290189683437, 0.0635422021150589, 0.03618398681282997, 0.0501662939786911, -0.0008748056134209037, 0.0030454066582024097, 0.10704050213098526, 0.07745226472616196, -0.00811372883617878, -0.07730796188116074, 0.03265366330742836, 0.009819408878684044, -0.011604084633290768, -0.02421540394425392, -0.008223204873502254, 0.002706897910684347, -0.0048460327088832855, 0.06634829193353653, 0.06268005818128586, 0.006604630034416914, -0.0004528376448433846, 0.044802144169807434, -0.016281940042972565, -0.04896387830376625, 0.00886740442365408, -0.010052262805402279, 0.01064107846468687, -0.05137762054800987, -0.0160355307161808, 0.028449056670069695, 0.013119461014866829, -0.034609582275152206, -0.004178475588560104, 0.004537227563560009, -0.013615358620882034, 0.015021865256130695, -0.03668232634663582, 0.01175262127071619, 0.011903573758900166, 0.003282152581959963, -0.03358025848865509, -0.03241854906082153, 0.0011661389144137502, -0.03962281346321106, -0.02179127372801304, 0.004881509114056826, -0.007123111747205257, 0.01557878591120243, 0.0060708187520504, 0.032888684421777725, -0.05943285673856735, -0.02583831176161766, -0.015020397491753101, 0.028613952919840813, 0.013284649699926376, -0.024515138939023018, -0.03224365785717964, 0.018212413415312767, 0.023436997085809708, -0.04165222495794296, 0.006527103018015623, -0.000165613935678266, -0.008102941326797009, -0.048995740711688995, -0.037954576313495636, -0.02673950418829918, 0.044558193534612656, 0.001558881369419396, -0.0015762071125209332, 0.02298051118850708, -0.01766176149249077, 0.019830692559480667, -0.044527728110551834, 0.035326555371284485, -0.006209452636539936, -0.04572427272796631, 0.032133299857378006, -0.001801351085305214, -0.024299897253513336, -0.001466146088205278, 0.04318688064813614, 0.0330827459692955, 0.0180862657725811, -0.016951724886894226, 0.0046045840717852116, 0.00036762640229426324, -0.03357343375682831, 0.02291092462837696, -0.05854609236121178, -0.028981348499655724, -0.06350062787532806, -0.04484205320477486, 0.027624422684311867, 0.030800044536590576, -0.0007669819751754403, -0.021362923085689545, 0.03995032608509064, 0.037430789321660995, 0.008321797475218773, -0.03162475302815437, -0.007455618120729923, 0.02524680085480213, -0.059613581746816635, -0.000011829494724224787, -0.030018962919712067, 0.07254144549369812, 0.027262607589364052, 0.028563914820551872, 0.0008147729677148163, 0.0057495892979204655, -0.01903434470295906, 0.02585572935640812, -0.014568756334483624, -0.03613000735640526, -0.016009138897061348, -0.010373770259320736, -0.008545871824026108, -0.01572510041296482, -0.017638280987739563, -0.06551486253738403, -0.03320861980319023, 0.030474800616502762, -0.008198159746825695, -0.05018690600991249, 0.042504120618104935, -0.00879919808357954, 0.015014495700597763, -0.012486121617257595, 0.014405723661184311, 0.0003471662348601967, -0.010520059615373611, 0.03422188386321068, -0.021685656160116196, -0.04021615907549858, -0.020703257992863655, -0.012377346865832806, 0.030966458842158318, 0.056973110884428024, 0.02782488986849785, 0.0304428618401289, 0.004155303351581097, -0.00015516691200900823, 0.027850965037941933, 0.06222521886229515, -0.02182946726679802, 0.024265598505735397, 0.07310979068279266, -0.06279807537794113, -0.009290953166782856, 0.02484704554080963, 0.012224678881466389, 0.03878357261419296, 0.016927292570471764, -0.011432180181145668, -0.020138252526521683, 0.04471459239721298, -0.008049994707107544, -0.042840030044317245, 0.00364225497469306, 0.009096161462366581, 0.02492433786392212, -0.005510381422936916, -0.006528773345053196, -0.01687624678015709, -0.02121313475072384, 0.02180030196905136, 0.06357113271951675, -0.01748039945960045, 0.028704579919576645, -0.003366299904882908, 0.020761797204613686, 0.0034602652303874493, 0.024336690083146095, -0.027306631207466125, 0.00853247381746769, 0.07378344982862473, -0.010159592144191265, 0.021945269778370857, -0.02308841235935688, 0.02345479279756546, -0.09695602208375931, -0.043387074023485184, 0.003457827726379037, 0.005847843363881111, 0.018250230699777603, -0.056542593985795975, 0.0012998438905924559, 0.03450245410203934, 0.0020302205812186003, -0.006402656901627779, -0.005365836434066296, -0.02171803079545498, -0.05658489465713501, -0.005580443423241377, 0.019704928621649742, -0.003979783039540052, 0.006431248504668474, 0.0014639077708125114, 0.02746344730257988, 0.02381550706923008, -0.04844474419951439, -0.04608490318059921, -0.01566549390554428, 0.027979770675301552, 0.007138182409107685, -0.044952113181352615, 0.010538691654801369, -0.049435004591941833, -0.046763695776462555, 0.03660853952169418, -0.014248115010559559, 0.019857805222272873, 0.027043864130973816, 0.026059336960315704, -0.014825365506112576, 0.029205407947301865, 0.07768328487873077, 0.008169829845428467, 0.0009832611540332437, 0.003571256995201111, 0.003925363067537546, 0.027466313913464546, -0.01851578801870346, 0.0063110110349953175, 0.07087694108486176, -0.0003619737981352955, -0.010959258303046227, 0.028507713228464127, -0.013605616055428982, -0.010705322027206421, -0.011420920491218567, -0.023611700162291527, -0.006907932460308075, -0.04645862430334091, 0.022138720378279686, -0.030019572004675865, -0.004810391925275326, 0.03644055873155594, 0.03720226138830185, -0.007168298587203026, -0.006260281428694725, -0.015143697150051594, -0.03999429568648338, 0.031229224056005478, 0.0007232918869704008, -0.00862580630928278, -0.03294914588332176, -0.021018074825406075, 0.00681554339826107, 0.033168915659189224, -0.04145127534866333, 0.011910133063793182, -0.008475854992866516, 0.04008607566356659, -0.0176988672465086, 0.0016965670511126518, 0.014540757983922958, 0.012928458862006664, 0.034557826817035675, -0.08276951313018799, 0.05141683295369148, 0.0013060123892500997, -0.01992928609251976, -0.03754866123199463, -0.014733853749930859, -0.0685151070356369, 0.007492084987461567, 0.015704410150647163, -0.015039428137242794, -0.007674519903957844, -0.00465768575668335, 0.03973190113902092, 0.004352583084255457, -0.04801374301314354, 0.03848709166049957, -0.003544003702700138, -0.02227848768234253, -0.006933777127414942, -0.0068780709989368916, 0.02840273082256317, -0.009174897335469723, -0.012240227311849594, 0.01441124640405178, 0.013519445434212685, -0.02572953887283802, -0.04312608763575554, 0.05205312371253967, 0.03307214379310608, -0.006996811367571354, 0.07923919707536697, -0.030214278027415276, -0.02081388421356678, 0.04673295468091965, -0.009154739789664745, -0.012017953209578991, 0.04666299745440483, -0.006747775245457888, -0.021057186648249626, -0.026333702728152275, 0.035621821880340576, 0.024225246161222458, -0.022305674850940704, 0.03410198166966438, 0.000244223017944023, -0.04309719800949097, 0.02615964040160179, 0.04341314360499382, 0.015349132940173149, 0.04439810663461685, -0.028371451422572136, 0.041997332125902176, 0.010840663686394691, -0.00806950032711029, 0.036762841045856476, 0.0363612025976181, -0.006815745960921049, -0.03273073956370354, 0.003505565458908677, 0.023614032194018364, -0.014349217526614666, 0.027791839092969894, 0.0011972595239058137, 0.02737433649599552, -0.010768909007310867, -0.013461398892104626, 0.056541889905929565, -0.002068223198875785, 0.04368280619382858, -0.009574058465659618, 0.012331734411418438, 0.06159556657075882, -0.024519329890608788, 0.0039166174829006195, -0.019603492692112923, 0.021876011043787003, -0.027735231444239616, -0.005476065911352634, 0.013595961965620518, -0.00787341222167015, -0.014259183779358864, 0.0005160234868526459, 0.017380857840180397, -0.02806125394999981, -0.008255736902356148, -0.0033539189025759697, -0.0045421672984957695, -0.045510102063417435, 0.006968760397285223, -0.03489871323108673, -0.005541378166526556, -0.006521681789308786, -0.0033597974106669426, -0.0003380990820005536, 0.017209505662322044, 0.013152429834008217, -0.02265211008489132, -0.01725088246166706, 0.01244345959275961, 0.017100481316447258, -0.05565245822072029, -0.036624133586883545, -0.06122780963778496, 0.019857363775372505, 0.008615802973508835, -0.019650952890515327 ]
<p>I know correlation does not imply causation. I have read it nth time. (i.e. weight does not cause height etc. etc.)</p> <p>However, to find the effect of a moderator variable on X-Y relationship, a regression model is used such as the GLM in SPSS to test for interaction or multiple regression. See <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/18693/significant-interaction-between-covariate-and-factor-in-spss-glm">here</a>.</p> <p><strong>My Question: If the X-Y relationship is a correlation, then why is a cause-effect model used in this instance?</strong></p> <p>As far as I understand, it makes little sense to classify a variable as independent or dependent in a correlation analysis.</p> <p>I apologise if this seems like a 'silly' question. In my past life, I had often told my students that there are no silly questions; just questions!</p>
37,371
[ -0.07491789013147354, 0.013034354895353317, 0.024696199223399162, -0.0020791226997971535, 0.029330065473914146, 0.032146163284778595, 0.010905776172876358, -0.013882646337151527, 0.035479769110679626, -0.0272599458694458, 0.008798736147582531, 0.03100522607564926, 0.07216257601976395, 0.03196583688259125, 0.009671127423644066, 0.03899851813912392, -0.017655059695243835, 0.026488257572054863, 0.011913641355931759, 0.015956981107592583, -0.02710537612438202, 0.02772274799644947, -0.00827729795128107, -0.016847141087055206, -0.008474313654005527, 0.04263448715209961, 0.02919764444231987, -0.043077532202005386, 0.030898701399564743, 0.028793271631002426, -0.03401654586195946, -0.004908333066850901, 0.02704591117799282, 0.04008568450808525, 0.032173171639442444, -0.019922643899917603, -0.014244921505451202, 0.012401808984577656, 0.011751390062272549, 0.046362120658159256, -0.0035300070885568857, -0.04137256368994713, 0.00807893741875887, 0.048228245228528976, -0.009928107261657715, 0.03267918527126312, -0.028276296332478523, -0.020304683595895767, 0.04273322969675064, -0.04127894714474678, 0.05508018657565117, -0.014423993416130543, 0.029303666204214096, 0.038795921951532364, -0.014424162916839123, -0.002308931900188327, 0.05447211489081383, 0.017377138137817383, -0.03285445272922516, -0.03130221739411354, -0.009122448973357677, -0.026999305933713913, -0.001973699079826474, -0.008411006070673466, -0.005874111317098141, 0.01629822887480259, 0.0018505778862163424, -0.004338948056101799, 0.06482549011707306, -0.01950724795460701, 0.022666292265057564, 0.01669965498149395, 0.055094681680202484, -0.015381455421447754, -0.0010842016199603677, -0.033064842224121094, 0.031135883182287216, 0.001688338932581246, 0.04601151496171951, 0.04305493086576462, -0.019627153873443604, 0.015582297928631306, 0.009692546911537647, 0.026751257479190826, 0.007477390114217997, -0.028429122641682625, 0.07681959867477417, -0.024144567549228668, 0.03391432762145996, 0.031893812119960785, -0.04784601926803589, -0.009761473163962364, 0.03234701603651047, 0.009212415665388107, -0.02558613382279873, 0.028523234650492668, -0.022847438231110573, 0.037765517830848694, 0.04736800491809845, 0.020881205797195435, -0.012623678892850876, -0.040597978979349136, 0.03199692443013191, 0.04985112324357033, -0.06621349602937698, -0.012029028497636318, -0.007812782190740108, 0.03238719701766968, -0.0018766369903460145, -0.0415479801595211, -0.0101160341873765, -0.00900294166058302, -0.0010671030031517148, -0.018793480470776558, 0.03251156210899353, -0.03947596997022629, 0.03174170106649399, -0.01279412116855383, 0.061485014855861664, 0.0705375075340271, 0.03520876169204712, -0.056629735976457596, -0.00028482399648055434, -0.01628994382917881, -0.03287779539823532, 0.011387201026082039, 0.007657703012228012, -0.03443793207406998, -0.006938386708498001, 0.07516329735517502, 0.004155064467340708, -0.0013814778067171574, -0.005917596165090799, 0.00797782652080059, 0.017897529527544975, 0.025923237204551697, -0.10853506624698639, -0.06305248290300369, 0.06492915004491806, 0.011949577368795872, -0.005252758041024208, -0.043659187853336334, -0.02253105863928795, 0.013172866776585579, 0.07198154181241989, -0.008335034362971783, 0.012052005156874657, -0.0019139619544148445, 0.031714193522930145, -0.007098511792719364, -0.010372089222073555, -0.032836105674505234, -0.010449082590639591, -0.06734103709459305, 0.008134918287396431, -0.09932388365268707, 0.0266482662409544, 0.026492729783058167, -0.011870733462274075, -0.014185274951159954, 0.03718715161085129, 0.006550246383994818, -0.002505464479327202, 0.011711322702467442, 0.016864962875843048, -0.02069893851876259, 0.021766297519207, -0.011775460094213486, 0.026280105113983154, 0.05265514552593231, -0.014492658898234367, 0.014452151022851467, 0.024890515953302383, 0.09512771666049957, -0.010880469344556332, -0.004093019757419825, -0.040524259209632874, -0.028173964470624924, 0.0077858297154307365, -0.016586290672421455, -0.05671015381813049, -0.031914420425891876, -0.028213204815983772, -0.023733798414468765, 0.015530557371675968, 0.05940970778465271, 0.0012839286355301738, -0.01030709408223629, 0.05120079591870308, -0.02002095803618431, -0.055036623030900955, -0.061773866415023804, 0.022176425904035568, -0.023719022050499916, -0.041659291833639145, 0.00961197167634964, -0.015225951559841633, 0.04815379157662392, -0.004898854065686464, -0.017407571896910667, -0.025129182264208794, 0.0007382656331174076, 0.03383356332778931, -0.007376696914434433, 0.01533082127571106, 0.028272224590182304, 0.03969370201230049, -0.03178377449512482, 0.006948135793209076, -0.04079776629805565, -0.018216919153928757, 0.025200126692652702, -0.0301874577999115, 0.004292340949177742, -0.04079415649175644, -0.018958555534482002, 0.007998134940862656, -0.02518780343234539, -0.06101857125759125, 0.05652492493391037, -0.0351751372218132, 0.08593476563692093, 0.08262277394533157, -0.01789131760597229, 0.005996979773044586, 0.0321243591606617, 0.02125021442770958, 0.015353500843048096, -0.030422430485486984, -0.0239083431661129, -0.07317128032445908, -0.03440478444099426, 0.007950259372591972, 0.018043262884020805, -0.030187595635652542, 0.022804418578743935, 0.038603171706199646, 0.03132949769496918, -0.007636487949639559, 0.017527788877487183, -0.006196925416588783, -0.01699601113796234, 0.006933292839676142, 0.024062536656856537, 0.02564583532512188, -0.0005998087581247091, -0.0319170244038105, 0.0384599044919014, 0.04629604518413544, 0.016118107363581657, -0.0188613124191761, 0.04764452204108238, 0.009642554447054863, 0.019291948527097702, 0.005967794451862574, -0.009526731446385384, 0.047233257442712784, -0.030484268441796303, 0.0503244549036026, 0.05722828581929207, -0.004611426033079624, -0.021848153322935104, -0.006137426011264324, -0.025256820023059845, 0.0051877484656870365, 0.04049519822001457, -0.046108461916446686, 0.01355411484837532, 0.011102990247309208, -0.026909688487648964, -0.003714629216119647, -0.000695059250574559, -0.05369296297430992, -0.0010442085331305861, 0.023031732067465782, 0.004763817880302668, 0.0008154806564562023, 0.0375673733651638, -0.0508035346865654, -0.017177952453494072, -0.030222035944461823, -0.030122479423880577, -0.012141996994614601, -0.03365299478173256, -0.06310843676328659, -0.016872115433216095, -0.023489270359277725, 0.025990480557084084, 0.011275378055870533, -0.042144451290369034, 0.009298659861087799, -0.002209689700976014, 0.012199155054986477, -0.05642976611852646, -0.032115861773490906, -0.04470407962799072, 0.003959339577704668, -0.006968913599848747, -0.042671721428632736, 0.025802887976169586, -0.01009026076644659, -0.04657972604036331, 0.0034352638758718967, -0.034323930740356445, -0.019797896966338158, 0.0022175044286996126, -0.028228040784597397, 0.01782078668475151, -0.010674004442989826, 0.0038563476409763098, -0.005842630285769701, -0.030256394296884537, -0.006503853015601635, -0.05518366023898125, -0.0639919564127922, 0.0503891296684742, 0.012501330114901066, 0.05841919034719467, -0.005120829679071903, 0.0031176514457911253, 0.0464872382581234, 0.012058298103511333, -0.025466514751315117, -0.06446236371994019, -0.023163000121712685, 0.006492980755865574, -0.050874076783657074, 0.035415440797805786, 0.027456218376755714, 0.02544216625392437, 0.02925574593245983, 0.02807179093360901, 0.012498874217271805, 0.015044935047626495, 0.03268592804670334, 0.004507924895733595, -0.0017309837276116014, -0.004029849544167519, -0.02055334486067295, 0.020825695246458054, 0.03005135804414749, -0.048746682703495026, -0.02096441388130188, -0.017914623022079468, 0.027888109907507896, -0.0105664087459445, -0.010392134077847004, 0.024054227396845818, 0.010455979034304619, 0.010078616440296173, -0.04190916195511818, 0.0017108314204961061, 0.026467008516192436, -0.02170410193502903, 0.007919239811599255, -0.021807223558425903, 0.023358788341283798, -0.025441672652959824, 0.0160019900649786, 0.044948454946279526, 0.015111830085515976, -0.018968144431710243, 0.014507302083075047, -0.0013007462257519364, -0.03501729667186737, 0.002673221519216895, 0.008960634469985962, -0.00007239390106406063, 0.03238411992788315, 0.019262226298451424, 0.00787140429019928, -0.02052905410528183, -0.052694886922836304, -0.0031768810003995895, -0.0629941001534462, 0.005448533687740564, -0.04065019637346268, 0.025777708739042282, -0.010634702630341053, 0.04065926745533943, 0.01765129156410694, -0.013721790164709091, 0.017496531829237938, -0.017857424914836884, -0.03565075248479843, 0.023768866434693336, -0.049318138509988785, 0.005294489674270153, 0.035839736461639404, -0.018645428121089935, 0.03203551471233368, -0.028118226677179337, 0.013724484480917454, -0.0087697459384799, 0.004801529459655285, -0.012139358557760715, 0.005388235207647085, -0.030838847160339355, -0.04345398768782616, 0.026099251583218575, -0.010801938362419605, 0.013746988028287888, -0.01713218353688717, 0.023579450324177742, 0.06217982992529869, -0.001299470430240035, -0.014706798829138279, -0.02597901225090027, -0.009491694159805775, 0.023072291165590286, 0.03098219446837902, 0.005150199867784977, 0.0012679670471698046, -0.026714323088526726, 0.05048328638076782, 0.0055771032348275185, -0.0026224374305456877, 0.031212197616696358, -0.01356145553290844, -0.03692556545138359, -0.013010676018893719, 0.01135680079460144, -0.007571666035801172, 0.01632486842572689, 0.005981671158224344, 0.008882115595042706, 0.04685886576771736, 0.010420267470180988, -0.04282420128583908, 0.04310358688235283, 0.054868802428245544, 0.0293915793299675, -0.025366870686411858, -0.020848117768764496, 0.005580667871981859, -0.013566965237259865, -0.010043163783848286, 0.05034983903169632, 0.018602121621370316, -0.005545967724174261, -0.0011266841320320964, 0.012225385755300522, -0.005923867225646973, 0.019701024517416954, 0.01023774966597557, 0.02468048967421055, 0.06975424289703369, 0.012639268301427364, -0.05578286945819855, -0.021023184061050415, 0.04566428065299988, 0.025438519194722176, 0.029396431520581245, -0.01996583491563797, -0.038651835173368454, 0.02702951803803444, 0.034684907644987106, 0.039315685629844666, -0.062194112688302994, 0.01751542277634144, -0.005628169979900122, -0.019666774198412895, 0.024090047925710678, -0.036456797271966934, 0.011157938279211521, -0.047339946031570435, 0.020506996661424637, -0.018864428624510765, -0.011068559251725674, -0.07234014570713043, 0.015420044772326946, 0.011942451819777489, 0.016112474724650383, -0.011378524824976921, -0.04440132528543472, -0.042276445776224136, -0.011094631627202034, 0.04231173172593117, 0.051898371428251266, -0.01982826180756092, -0.03501156345009804, -0.01250371988862753, 0.035971760749816895, -0.024555794894695282, -0.05776103958487511, 0.00289330305531621, 0.012668894603848457, -0.011486213654279709, 0.05691028758883476, -0.02693110704421997, -0.0327032171189785, -0.0016182827530428767, 0.03984583914279938, -0.019851326942443848, -0.00241265632212162, -0.014934667386114597, 0.06504105031490326, 0.03106968104839325, -0.012988382019102573, 0.028523581102490425, 0.020469192415475845, -0.01575242355465889, -0.03478490933775902, -0.024005848914384842, -0.0000023726495328446617, -0.04334728419780731, -0.042970288544893265, -0.040504034608602524, 0.00931637641042471, -0.019235771149396896, 0.02239225246012211, 0.004527286626398563, -0.012469557113945484, -0.04409287869930267, 0.007559868041425943, -0.007059311494231224, 0.027465246617794037, 0.00495517672970891, -0.007331181783229113, -0.029301201924681664, 0.013333704322576523, 0.00245546898804605, -0.009635590016841888, 0.015513350255787373, -0.008666761219501495, -0.015655940398573875, 0.0019748928025364876, -0.013784882612526417, 0.00846142042428255, 0.008474931120872498, -0.024246135726571083, 0.017628595232963562, -0.047240860760211945, 0.028950102627277374, -0.034230004996061325, 0.0163465216755867, 0.008478844538331032, -0.05731949210166931, -0.02447991445660591, 0.023456336930394173, 0.025376947596669197, 0.008709368295967579, 0.012023700401186943, 0.0070358277298510075, -0.04235618934035301, -0.011857787147164345, -0.06263355910778046, -0.056580234318971634, -0.0015224918024614453, -0.02059728465974331, 0.018651315942406654, -0.01848842017352581, 0.041969649493694305, -0.026483643800020218, -0.037959448993206024, -0.002059022430330515, 0.032627228647470474, -0.038703083992004395, -0.016874222084879875, 0.010048829019069672, 0.014304636977612972, 0.06882369518280029, 0.0028783204033970833, -0.010562107898294926, 0.03660714626312256, -0.006012546364217997, -0.0447552315890789, 0.01363325398415327, 0.017830222845077515, -0.015507818199694157, -0.02174045890569687, -0.023959282785654068, -0.03387356922030449, 0.02864116057753563, -0.025803009048104286, -0.020554587244987488, -0.0028650397434830666, -0.013249659910798073, -0.00034752889769151807, -0.036722395569086075, 0.024488985538482666, -0.0018603694625198841, 0.00047719079884700477, 0.012014665640890598, 0.013677776791155338, -0.02411506511271, -0.014585213735699654, 0.0747813805937767, -0.02736770734190941, -0.025443609803915024, 0.020685182884335518, 0.03009939007461071, -0.006387640256434679, 0.015101258642971516, -0.023414084687829018, -0.0022633110638707876, 0.04349799081683159, 0.006635686382651329, -0.015201263129711151, 0.002040770137682557, 0.02104017697274685, -0.02907790243625641, -0.02357390522956848, -0.024249017238616943, 0.0034503734204918146, 0.08826442062854767, -0.027622699737548828, 0.054364532232284546, 0.044001150876283646, -0.030252652242779732, -0.0027861169073730707, -0.019901219755411148, 0.022727666422724724, 0.0007171541801653802, 0.012320831418037415, 0.03871680051088333, -0.040963929146528244, -0.014904760755598545, 0.042397938668727875, 0.010853661224246025, 0.033008355647325516, 0.01538207195699215, 0.03878965601325035, 0.012863676995038986, 0.027161143720149994, -0.0021055471152067184, -0.06947918236255646, 0.05756514519453049, -0.024931933730840683, 0.004281660541892052, -0.023809336125850677, -0.040284983813762665, 0.034411974251270294, 0.04896979033946991, -0.023345129564404488, -0.06433694809675217, -0.01695351116359234, -0.03938720375299454, -0.013192473910748959, 0.017900293692946434, 0.0019924072548747063, 0.009398524649441242, 0.002399233402684331, 0.014249807223677635, -0.010150963440537453, 0.020866138860583305, -0.03915794938802719, -0.11713208258152008, -0.011223163455724716, 0.00969728548079729, -0.007281820755451918, 0.03929254412651062, -0.02043694444000721, -0.03335508331656456, 0.003158548614010215, -0.06088723614811897, -0.02442065253853798, 0.004977868869900703, 0.03856075182557106, -0.03029327653348446, 0.04378760606050491, -0.007641023490577936, -0.0180756114423275, -0.003981242887675762, 0.021877983585000038, 0.10226337611675262, 0.03667513281106949, 0.024306122213602066, -0.05651463568210602, 0.01721823960542679, 0.013850802555680275, 0.008517305366694927, -0.029107818379998207, -0.012389649637043476, 0.01464297715574503, -0.004222331568598747, 0.07103211432695389, 0.05756501108407974, 0.057334545999765396, 0.0033998743165284395, 0.08658858388662338, -0.0230491291731596, -0.02784006856381893, -0.012587864883244038, -0.019439153373241425, -0.022112756967544556, 0.009166545234620571, -0.01830136775970459, 0.00859007891267538, -0.02951015718281269, -0.020849954336881638, -0.025400804355740547, 0.004580989945679903, 0.0016223356360569596, 0.027591679245233536, -0.03333063796162605, -0.0007028718828223646, 0.0066199833527207375, 0.0029116838704794645, -0.05594469979405403, -0.012325644493103027, 0.04261654242873192, -0.015709945932030678, 0.013529796153306961, 0.018379582092165947, -0.03392871096730232, 0.002841625828295946, 0.015445329248905182, 0.02126666158437729, -0.058537960052490234, -0.03183099254965782, -0.004582365043461323, 0.0485711544752121, -0.0013130857842043042, -0.02380361594259739, -0.03628754988312721, -0.002505761105567217, -0.005893911235034466, -0.023309381678700447, -0.03475179895758629, 0.019290216267108917, 0.059460386633872986, -0.04493776708841324, -0.00607895664870739, -0.025929773226380348, -0.013954587280750275, -0.047649238258600235, 0.0627131387591362, 0.04199026897549629, -0.02638939954340458, -0.020587941631674767, -0.01966731995344162, 0.02115931175649166, 0.02052299864590168, 0.011367233470082283, -0.009390185587108135, 0.00011861368693644181, -0.027170654386281967, -0.00046778013347648084, 0.0299183689057827, 0.023200221359729767, 0.010418403893709183, 0.002857930026948452, 0.006630715448409319, -0.029359212145209312, -0.0024330958258360624, 0.03671965375542641, -0.007370566949248314, 0.00013485169620253146, -0.05883248150348663, 0.005148471333086491, 0.02088773436844349, 0.04255446791648865, 0.053027451038360596, -0.0018107126234099269, -0.02306765504181385, 0.020582003518939018, -0.008306987583637238, -0.04017496854066849, -0.032636795192956924, 0.01127967331558466, -0.028344834223389626, -0.0033124261535704136, -0.0019124435493722558, 0.03239484503865242, 0.018306415528059006, 0.041088588535785675, 0.007184458896517754, 0.005704463925212622, -0.0017466150457039475, 0.02415957674384117, 0.025870636105537415, -0.04984904080629349, 0.021687239408493042, 0.0012212309520691633, -0.0043068234808743, 0.006780616939067841, -0.028444813564419746, -0.014282449148595333, -0.0028356481343507767, 0.015421239659190178, 0.0025089497212320566, -0.026780016720294952, 0.009608943946659565, -0.014142508618533611, 0.01917775720357895, -0.051995161920785904, -0.008948114700615406, -0.09812743961811066, 0.020085040479898453, 0.038403067737817764, -0.030606230720877647, 0.00047566377907060087, 0.03244902566075325, -0.019380811601877213, 0.04354921355843544, 0.027921566739678383, 0.033616021275520325, 0.01742050237953663, -0.011363689787685871, 0.03494787588715553, -0.008023366332054138, 0.06318659335374832, -0.014992429874837399, -0.023970281705260277, 0.033290423452854156, -0.04990385100245476, -0.017513347789645195, -0.0033016230445355177, -0.01546280924230814, 0.04072032496333122, 0.036612775176763535, 0.016341738402843475, -0.032174002379179, 0.045405641198158264, -0.03230900317430496, 0.020604906603693962, -0.028157319873571396, -0.0026762112975120544, -0.009470446966588497, -0.00438748998567462, -0.019380908459424973, 0.004894594196230173, -0.019466212019324303, 0.04691619798541069, 0.07302182912826538, 0.00876111350953579, 0.021744070574641228, 0.030771559104323387, -0.003788859350606799, 0.008903891779482365, -0.008687430061399937, 0.006029442418366671, 0.0396517738699913, 0.046835821121931076, -0.010010682977735996, 0.033592306077480316, 0.0167927797883749, 0.03279339149594307, -0.0799180269241333, -0.0543174184858799, 0.01514403522014618, 0.03949771448969841, 0.031965743750333786, -0.035674672573804855, -0.006472418084740639, 0.005649528466165066, -0.057157743722200394, -0.007648244500160217, 0.0032917445059865713, -0.014287321828305721, 0.0002457494265399873, 0.015072113834321499, 0.006385535467416048, 0.027027003467082977, 0.04161949083209038, 0.03163310885429382, 0.01430876087397337, 0.04731057211756706, 0.007979072630405426, -0.0061270506121218204, -0.020900795236229897, -0.006155185867100954, -0.02922794781625271, -0.05559317395091057, 0.04714458808302879, -0.008552968502044678, 0.010525474324822426, 0.032511960715055466, 0.0199037604033947, 0.03578842431306839, 0.022518787533044815, 0.02903984859585762, 0.015767890959978104, 0.04137583449482918, 0.02374436892569065, -0.024361569434404373, -0.029772592708468437, 0.02638913504779339, 0.017350029200315475, 0.06538405269384384, 0.0018714620964601636, 0.0030502607114613056, -0.02191905491054058, -0.04484492540359497, -0.005753555800765753, -0.002429497428238392, -0.011948099359869957, 0.0160483680665493, 0.0005809785216115415, -0.014422852545976639, -0.0002757081820163876, -0.028719929978251457, -0.003922566305845976, -0.05547865107655525, -0.02681957744061947, 0.04092368483543396, 0.03529006615281105, -0.04287584498524666, -0.003944744821637869, 0.018429286777973175, -0.020126547664403915, -0.00745507562533021, -0.0008960439008660614, 0.0015669193817302585, -0.028806384652853012, 0.03691250830888748, -0.009706555865705013, -0.014296440407633781, -0.014602520503103733, -0.018795736134052277, -0.05874575302004814, 0.0636444017291069, -0.015535534359514713, 0.010912143625319004, 0.008762822486460209, -0.05872151628136635, 0.010991444811224937, -0.05482523888349533, 0.053867556154727936, 0.019941681995987892, -0.01274358294904232, -0.05045817047357559, -0.001031929044984281, -0.029665760695934296, 0.0014553869841620326, 0.05923297628760338, -0.026671046391129494, 0.026205675676465034, 0.01073336973786354, 0.05189932882785797, -0.01570427045226097, -0.040922582149505615, 0.03820202127099037, 0.026946019381284714, -0.008566970936954021, -0.01021667756140232, -0.012522086501121521, -0.0016774210380390286, 0.021616458892822266, 0.02793101780116558, -0.04580434411764145, 0.04193703085184097, -0.01265080738812685, -0.03343520686030388, 0.03542107716202736, 0.03671995550394058, 0.01407892070710659, 0.04063166677951813, -0.009115984663367271, 0.025144312530755997, 0.07264582812786102, -0.00951177068054676, -0.04179240018129349, 0.06045776233077049, -0.03176138922572136, -0.019324708729982376, 0.0038815904408693314, 0.019785404205322266, -0.03484043851494789, -0.0680423453450203, 0.005446841008961201, 0.03909663110971451, -0.0414382740855217, -0.01942489482462406, 0.0074083153158426285, 0.0039414349012076855, 0.02487899735569954, 0.009237794205546379, -0.014601138420403004, 0.003231906099244952, -0.01618073508143425, 0.03376546874642372, 0.03227035701274872, 0.05145065113902092, 0.009969496168196201, -0.03495160862803459, 0.034942664206027985, 0.03325491398572922, 0.02219090424478054, -0.030416442081332207, -0.0021740293595939875, -0.05660398304462433, -0.033307790756225586, 0.022246628999710083, 0.010615089908242226, 0.05495097115635872, 0.038001153618097305, 0.007550625130534172, 0.049167703837156296, -0.051126450300216675, 0.01941220462322235, -0.004337066784501076, 0.010503454133868217, -0.04718571528792381, -0.005104541778564453, 0.009774145670235157, 0.016413183882832527, 0.02368660643696785, -0.012426470406353474, -0.002306048758327961, -0.05973999947309494, 0.019559364765882492, 0.009259798564016819, 0.0030292558949440718, -0.031052596867084503, -0.028795205056667328, -0.010996484197676182, -0.012702997773885727, -0.03579911217093468, -0.016091030091047287, 0.09475994855165482, 0.05108625814318657, 0.004317024257034063, -0.05439445376396179, -0.002792404731735587, -0.0004689213237725198, 0.08003644645214081, -0.07957252115011215, -0.039156172424554825, -0.02007739432156086, 0.03489634022116661, 0.018323374912142754, -0.005690653342753649 ]
<p>In <a href="http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=6-Y8OL3sW14C&amp;pg=PA102&amp;lpg=PA102&amp;dq=deviance%20of%20a%20%22bernoulli%22%20model?%20goodness%20of%20fit&amp;source=bl&amp;ots=kb3FoEbN30&amp;sig=gJ28_j0CN8-WsFoYp4gDrL2eooA&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ei=SsFhUe3YL-Wa0QWTo4CwBg&amp;ved=0CDsQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&amp;q=deviance%20of%20a%20%22bernoulli%22%20model?%20goodness%20of%20fit&amp;f=false" rel="nofollow">Ordinal Data Modelling</a> by Johson &amp; Albert, page 102-103:</p> <blockquote> <p>For Bernoulli observations [...] the asymptotic chi-squared distribution of the deviance statistic may not pertain. Indeed, for the linear logistic models with Bernoulli observations, the deviance function can be expresses solely as a function of the MLE of the regression parameter, <strong>which demonstrates the futility of using this statistic to measure goodness of fit for such data</strong>.</p> </blockquote> <p>Could someone kindly explain what this means, please? </p>
74,298
[ -0.026468200609087944, 0.001133721205405891, -0.004893884528428316, -0.004034609533846378, 0.056041669100522995, 0.020035043358802795, -0.01787775382399559, 0.010465815663337708, 0.033046167343854904, -0.04625043645501137, 0.041437506675720215, 0.030449187383055687, 0.04939720407128334, 0.05311749503016472, 0.054717838764190674, 0.012258200906217098, -0.034688472747802734, 0.0023208155762404203, 0.005348504986613989, -0.009786175563931465, 0.05010636895895004, 0.05633535981178284, 0.026454340666532516, -0.008258728310465813, -0.029974155128002167, 0.05288942903280258, 0.05070881545543671, -0.005697804503142834, 0.004939483478665352, 0.0364832878112793, -0.060469917953014374, -0.019495408982038498, 0.01599869690835476, 0.027172936126589775, 0.020955882966518402, 0.003646446857601404, -0.003911173436790705, -0.029996344819664955, -0.008545394986867905, 0.0491253100335598, -0.032415106892585754, -0.04181695356965065, -0.0035906187258660793, 0.029698094353079796, -0.020661547780036926, -0.00603916822001338, 0.008510660380125046, -0.05532565712928772, 0.005609733052551746, -0.03572332113981247, 0.06309029459953308, 0.0026626151520758867, 0.013416802510619164, 0.009434807114303112, -0.003963490482419729, -0.008167284540832043, 0.01375430915504694, 0.08858481049537659, -0.02634318172931671, -0.07725397497415543, -0.03040228597819805, -0.05512532219290733, 0.025463080033659935, -0.01608934998512268, -0.024012692272663116, 0.01816263608634472, 0.020771339535713196, -0.07134968042373657, 0.050343260169029236, -0.0060743000358343124, -0.019547421485185623, 0.04425697773694992, 0.018885482102632523, -0.03005237877368927, 0.04517937824130058, -0.03747853264212608, -0.03302580863237381, 0.014357291162014008, 0.024546582251787186, 0.030613919720053673, 0.0066256336867809296, 0.01634269393980503, -0.018690528348088264, 0.019683916121721268, 0.0029001343064010143, -0.011527413502335548, 0.10739011317491531, -0.00651640584692359, 0.0008035427890717983, 0.01573810912668705, -0.037119634449481964, -0.0037753682117909193, 0.02079380676150322, 0.032791778445243835, -0.024420009925961494, 0.01219259388744831, -0.04741603136062622, 0.018169814720749855, 0.009124169126152992, -0.03136470168828964, 0.00044855300802737474, -0.04632241278886795, 0.027477703988552094, 0.045952457934617996, -0.04036765173077583, -0.04758794605731964, -0.012384230270981789, 0.02298206463456154, -0.02060508541762829, -0.06340792775154114, -0.02516299858689308, 0.03881080076098442, 0.010403093881905079, 0.03808309882879257, -0.01192354504019022, 0.011957025155425072, -0.017720818519592285, -0.04156599938869476, 0.05592864006757736, 0.03642035648226738, 0.040848348289728165, -0.05871378630399704, 0.0007058352930471301, -0.010252784006297588, -0.04937771335244179, -0.011701764538884163, 0.006139927078038454, -0.02449832297861576, -0.035732753574848175, 0.03391111642122269, -0.026168476790189743, -0.01769162155687809, 0.027962546795606613, 0.025104913860559464, -0.004538984503597021, -0.01337018795311451, -0.05945075303316116, -0.03396424651145935, 0.011491013690829277, 0.005557164084166288, -0.020046275109052658, -0.08268667012453079, -0.013792254962027073, 0.034532580524683, 0.023750383406877518, 0.0026983004063367844, 0.0002745854726526886, 0.00018971157260239124, 0.00975371990352869, 0.0147932730615139, -0.034207783639431, -0.0025066821835935116, -0.03127951920032501, -0.03569634631276131, -0.020469021052122116, -0.06326774507761002, -0.012055621482431889, 0.0003520416503306478, -0.0019608105067163706, -0.027458252385258675, 0.027082137763500214, 0.013894753530621529, -0.028054188936948776, -0.005780185107141733, 0.010095251724123955, -0.006713959854096174, 0.09605573117733002, 0.008056391030550003, 0.0441802442073822, 0.023294921964406967, 0.008556274697184563, 0.011135083623230457, -0.008275392465293407, 0.04219895973801613, 0.025597520172595978, 0.009880559518933296, 0.0024580368772149086, -0.04756858944892883, 0.045034125447273254, 0.011117913760244846, -0.03481048718094826, -0.01101403497159481, -0.016368713229894638, -0.04316273331642151, 0.00761090824380517, 0.06655009835958481, -0.011290731839835644, 0.004359362181276083, 0.07474826276302338, -0.07048016041517258, -0.032026179134845734, -0.07088583707809448, 0.0002540636924095452, -0.024147702381014824, -0.012188974767923355, 0.022885877639055252, -0.019484609365463257, 0.02381535992026329, -0.00533389113843441, 0.04124441742897034, -0.014889209531247616, -0.03787005692720413, 0.030346209183335304, -0.05199367180466652, 0.0008810104336589575, 0.04756120592355728, 0.032422009855508804, -0.003324284916743636, 0.023522038012742996, -0.05406975746154785, -0.058101214468479156, 0.011206028051674366, -0.04309491440653801, 0.03099038079380989, -0.012648839503526688, -0.03098747506737709, 0.00942310318350792, 0.0005176915437914431, -0.00952796172350645, 0.04059078171849251, -0.030998259782791138, 0.06280477344989777, 0.045528341084718704, 0.03050808236002922, -0.0127771170809865, 0.030239064246416092, -0.0027930366341024637, -0.0020649931393563747, -0.05262094363570213, -0.021801818162202835, -0.031875237822532654, -0.022897053509950638, 0.043260782957077026, 0.024548785760998726, -0.013355154544115067, 0.026403795927762985, 0.05518275871872902, 0.01800852082669735, 0.035208601504564285, -0.0032612113282084465, -0.023060651496052742, -0.03891470283269882, 0.015192448161542416, -0.01774774119257927, -0.015361630357801914, 0.023461906239390373, 0.002320606727153063, 0.010027033276855946, 0.01680532842874527, 0.014544340781867504, 0.011074915528297424, 0.049353815615177155, -0.006357613019645214, -0.018172388896346092, -0.06405498832464218, 0.020760543644428253, 0.053710535168647766, -0.0025100945495069027, -0.017118794843554497, 0.06297388672828674, 0.008249740116298199, -0.0003856467956211418, 0.011957492679357529, -0.011314347386360168, 0.06292970478534698, 0.06099942699074745, -0.039788685739040375, -0.015189755707979202, 0.0033044395968317986, -0.01263456605374813, 0.014552862383425236, -0.028562799096107483, -0.03757869079709053, 0.00746979471296072, 0.01815166510641575, -0.0040235924534499645, 0.04222165048122406, 0.02506793476641178, -0.017250623553991318, -0.03833306208252907, 0.004004690330475569, -0.0065356045961380005, 0.007634504232555628, 0.011759091168642044, -0.010357542894780636, -0.04087741672992706, -0.020682357251644135, -0.030016181990504265, 0.024004116654396057, 0.008650760166347027, 0.03587786853313446, 0.013241288252174854, -0.03768415004014969, -0.008894477970898151, -0.0364505909383297, -0.026953019201755524, -0.018590614199638367, -0.005909719970077276, -0.023028289899230003, 0.027789784595370293, -0.02708369679749012, 0.011995985172688961, 0.05100453644990921, -0.06642775237560272, -0.04607360437512398, -0.022638319060206413, -0.002471528947353363, 0.02502606436610222, 0.019451262429356575, 0.07457530498504639, -0.002844687085598707, -0.02579164318740368, 0.008456582203507423, -0.08687523007392883, -0.05439438670873642, 0.00890019815415144, -0.012996450997889042, 0.014335596933960915, -0.0037608223501592875, -0.037358611822128296, 0.07521612197160721, 0.04195648804306984, 0.007491435389965773, -0.03204118087887764, -0.0064560710452497005, -0.029900819063186646, -0.02713913656771183, 0.01021520234644413, 0.032961614429950714, -0.0075828805565834045, 0.05057466775178909, -0.025467263534665108, 0.027341188862919807, 0.04558935388922691, -0.0015290945302695036, -0.003728121053427458, 0.008210832253098488, 0.013726271688938141, -0.014720623381435871, -0.007323769386857748, 0.028837282210588455, -0.023911669850349426, 0.01104023028165102, 0.006402192171663046, 0.03623053804039955, 0.018935643136501312, -0.029185747727751732, 0.012724717147648335, -0.0008922390989027917, -0.007105133030563593, -0.024249037727713585, 0.056516002863645554, -0.003920139279216528, -0.05433700233697891, 0.016054583713412285, 0.049622174352407455, 0.015497362241148949, 0.007637882139533758, 0.004049655981361866, 0.030619299039244652, 0.007340411189943552, 0.023673705756664276, 0.0004409183165989816, -0.011511544696986675, 0.002310581272467971, 0.020113885402679443, -0.02362263761460781, 0.0030913017690181732, 0.0528123565018177, 0.04069511219859123, -0.018554074689745903, -0.01345206517726183, -0.03746490553021431, -0.0006454181857407093, -0.027667568996548653, -0.016879260540008545, -0.031664542853832245, 0.03872981667518616, -0.015887495130300522, 0.017855608835816383, -0.008032194338738918, -0.003537374082952738, -0.0010915575549006462, -0.003045285353437066, -0.08743015676736832, 0.025226255878806114, -0.018090717494487762, -0.0032227670308202505, 0.01098334975540638, 0.0124419080093503, 0.04421243071556091, -0.03367552533745766, 0.007362636737525463, 0.009532483294606209, 0.01818966306746006, -0.03937815874814987, 0.008059549145400524, -0.013329862616956234, -0.018802091479301453, -0.0066471160389482975, -0.01086396537721157, -0.010998539626598358, -0.018999477848410606, 0.030274448916316032, 0.03299001231789589, 0.003082854440435767, -0.02047090418636799, -0.03109261952340603, 0.026631418615579605, 0.009767558425664902, 0.010883716866374016, 0.017323974519968033, -0.0021268671844154596, -0.06672212481498718, 0.05452384054660797, 0.0008076134836301208, 0.04639467969536781, 0.04325370490550995, -0.011697945185005665, -0.01956430822610855, -0.04772618040442467, -0.015660470351576805, 0.012521620839834213, 0.010847391560673714, 0.03366544842720032, 0.03299475833773613, 0.05287880077958107, 0.012941808439791203, -0.008942659012973309, 0.036680918186903, 0.07091520726680756, -0.00017578148981556296, -0.03387868031859398, 0.017603958025574684, -0.0012864007148891687, 0.007916546426713467, -0.014583297073841095, 0.01886473037302494, 0.018348373472690582, 0.021181896328926086, 0.011209268122911453, 0.03315871208906174, -0.0033965930342674255, -0.03447577729821205, -0.056574393063783646, 0.023074008524417877, 0.015188825316727161, -0.00357064395211637, -0.035910654813051224, 0.04277228191494942, 0.034972283989191055, 0.03565271198749542, 0.036319319158792496, -0.008537021465599537, -0.09302099794149399, 0.012433182448148727, 0.04033806174993515, 0.05105152353644371, -0.04539071395993233, -0.022358715534210205, -0.042137064039707184, -0.006320829037576914, 0.01809358038008213, -0.03202347084879875, 0.04190647229552269, 0.009576118551194668, 0.01164086814969778, -0.01527843251824379, -0.03760360926389694, -0.04769408330321312, 0.01772463507950306, 0.01193229015916586, -0.003584169549867511, -0.029014399275183678, -0.06155361607670784, -0.06567075848579407, -0.01322154700756073, -0.023810237646102905, 0.03359541296958923, -0.023401984944939613, 0.003301298478618264, 0.00948318187147379, 0.009562375955283642, -0.015578671358525753, -0.027415957301855087, 0.02610301785171032, 0.010297546163201332, -0.004455920308828354, 0.06851187348365784, -0.012917788699269295, -0.03228795528411865, 0.003077325178310275, 0.00841764360666275, -0.040811244398355484, -0.00648455647751689, -0.057062458246946335, 0.05800454691052437, -0.007597723510116339, 0.026303082704544067, 0.0602450892329216, 0.030860673636198044, -0.037710100412368774, -0.018449081107974052, -0.0364946685731411, 0.029310692101716995, -0.03760844096541405, -0.04633054509758949, -0.06918765604496002, 0.01854526996612549, -0.007915382273495197, 0.01493656262755394, 0.03301580250263214, -0.0014672708930447698, -0.010274339467287064, -0.03418169915676117, 0.0071525052189826965, 0.054054804146289825, -0.010167105123400688, 0.03904000297188759, 0.042704109102487564, 0.03546759858727455, 0.00903220847249031, -0.013505591079592705, 0.04509921371936798, -0.01922510750591755, 0.003985479474067688, 0.02619759365916252, -0.0177250225096941, 0.01122808363288641, -0.0387352891266346, -0.020576227456331253, 0.011875773780047894, -0.008008237928152084, 0.04018775001168251, -0.004733160138130188, 0.027519933879375458, -0.005053996108472347, -0.03090032935142517, -0.03378699719905853, 0.02142811007797718, -0.00970425084233284, 0.033999934792518616, -0.023211529478430748, 0.00742770591750741, -0.0005790682625956833, -0.017019398510456085, -0.062231339514255524, -0.01891772821545601, 0.017687441781163216, -0.02017734944820404, -0.021370336413383484, 0.0037974051665514708, -0.017734743654727936, 0.010331639088690281, -0.024060629308223724, -0.021949458867311478, 0.0683717131614685, -0.0075586168095469475, -0.008628045208752155, -0.011866902001202106, 0.018455032259225845, 0.05479184165596962, 0.0390051044523716, -0.016383899375796318, 0.0011648103827610612, -0.006395536009222269, 0.017506951466202736, -0.001994381658732891, 0.06501089781522751, -0.025610795244574547, -0.020287472754716873, 0.004994634073227644, 0.003417165484279394, 0.034638915210962296, -0.03172571584582329, -0.027553491294384003, -0.03843311220407486, 0.01378418505191803, 0.008266621269285679, -0.00795670598745346, 0.005003324244171381, 0.003960623871535063, 0.007874347269535065, -0.03408486023545265, 0.004920313600450754, -0.010702558793127537, 0.0033847615122795105, 0.06862644851207733, 0.009762125089764595, -0.005240395665168762, -0.014732842333614826, 0.04354960471391678, 0.016993898898363113, 0.021730760112404823, 0.0023034100886434317, 0.016333555802702904, 0.05801757425069809, 0.029207833111286163, -0.003448953852057457, 0.018495788797736168, 0.018640099093317986, -0.01981527917087078, -0.014843452721834183, -0.034618910402059555, -0.00008678872836753726, 0.05434204265475273, -0.008469595573842525, 0.018753239884972572, 0.025906512513756752, -0.012546099722385406, 0.0026940833777189255, -0.046825211495161057, 0.005581186152994633, 0.00573295634239912, 0.003153371624648571, 0.042133428156375885, -0.04768914356827736, -0.019178826361894608, 0.03840517997741699, 0.013317059725522995, 0.00806078314781189, 0.014583265408873558, 0.041142918169498444, 0.03913658484816551, -0.015659315511584282, -0.005704713519662619, -0.025386158376932144, 0.0749480202794075, -0.02031133510172367, 0.021020211279392242, -0.01871408335864544, -0.014991833828389645, 0.03830718249082565, 0.02798786573112011, 0.05325589329004288, -0.050572313368320465, -0.02375156432390213, -0.06327546387910843, -0.0005147831398062408, 0.051270321011543274, -0.03701696917414665, 0.006630096584558487, 0.01746072620153427, 0.03373723104596138, -0.005153109785169363, 0.015499589964747429, -0.022984961047768593, -0.08105941861867905, -0.004176015965640545, 0.03979431092739105, -0.030948607251048088, 0.01723063737154007, -0.030609482899308205, -0.051831070333719254, 0.014186771586537361, -0.050237685441970825, 0.01619565859436989, 0.02246444672346115, 0.02941024675965309, -0.010206851176917553, 0.075997494161129, -0.01645403914153576, -0.002591612981632352, -0.007760303094983101, -0.02496083453297615, 0.13332107663154602, 0.06505272537469864, 0.03689689189195633, -0.04016141965985298, 0.015310230664908886, -0.014178081415593624, -0.002887109061703086, 0.002449651248753071, -0.010377367027103901, 0.001555285300128162, -0.018831204622983932, 0.06738505512475967, 0.07207483798265457, 0.035093601793050766, 0.0015258800704032183, 0.040840476751327515, -0.024230746552348137, -0.04298816993832588, 0.006414043251425028, 0.020912503823637962, -0.0029385422822088003, 0.01158204860985279, -0.039711419492959976, 0.013422416523098946, 0.034847404807806015, -0.014210953377187252, -0.0003225170949008316, 0.0042711603455245495, -0.013347737491130829, -0.011411215178668499, -0.03734776750206947, -0.03929785266518593, 0.012805486097931862, -0.010927107185125351, -0.002490672981366515, 0.013529762625694275, -0.005605465732514858, -0.027351781725883484, 0.03462779521942139, 0.04213910922408104, -0.006067131645977497, -0.01761901192367077, 0.0569433867931366, 0.022246336564421654, -0.061272040009498596, -0.05928979814052582, -0.035654086619615555, 0.046153195202350616, -0.04438377544283867, -0.0223171878606081, -0.00806558970361948, -0.004263168666511774, -0.003651026636362076, -0.027298809960484505, -0.0054452125914394855, 0.011310849338769913, -0.003621353069320321, 0.005564745049923658, -0.022999003529548645, -0.023374756798148155, 0.016640570014715195, -0.025367313995957375, 0.02310299687087536, 0.004376521799713373, -0.03787552937865257, -0.006448186933994293, 0.004522219300270081, 0.061185572296381, -0.013001909479498863, 0.017491035163402557, -0.018141284584999084, -0.031177125871181488, -0.0421375036239624, 0.014515533111989498, 0.0002536734682507813, -0.03358672559261322, 0.029675178229808807, -0.0250225942581892, -0.009568385779857635, -0.054027777165174484, -0.07321007549762726, 0.0307480376213789, -0.0026352861896157265, -0.005180027801543474, -0.05047927051782608, -0.018556132912635803, 0.019693154841661453, -0.0008959777187556028, 0.02030123583972454, 0.012547953054308891, -0.01749357581138611, 0.03368636965751648, -0.02538614720106125, -0.033165983855724335, -0.012866897508502007, -0.005784919951111078, -0.05901934206485748, -0.014115924015641212, 0.0008894684142433107, 0.015255616046488285, 0.02882169932126999, 0.009831428527832031, 0.017159007489681244, 0.04807521402835846, -0.010828714817762375, 0.028584662824869156, 0.030431298539042473, -0.034853074699640274, -0.016711225733160973, 0.03247092291712761, 0.02507947012782097, 0.023720307275652885, -0.056312087923288345, -0.054163746535778046, -0.05842515081167221, 0.03024555742740631, -0.02008352056145668, -0.040156640112400055, -0.027212150394916534, -0.014855984598398209, 0.010758214630186558, -0.0377497673034668, -0.005435147322714329, -0.014882009476423264, 0.024283355101943016, -0.008379872888326645, -0.007948513142764568, 0.016073450446128845, 0.003577018855139613, -0.010290751233696938, 0.025098668411374092, 0.021288897842168808, 0.011628725565969944, 0.012301350012421608, 0.005444174632430077, 0.02102632075548172, -0.008387471549212933, 0.032438408583402634, -0.027154866605997086, -0.00656465720385313, 0.055829402059316635, -0.01076541654765606, -0.05046439915895462, 0.04698111489415169, -0.005182769149541855, -0.0023484393022954464, 0.0023034459445625544, 0.016538554802536964, -0.02436417154967785, 0.05529174208641052, -0.014858013950288296, 0.007623482961207628, -0.001953447936102748, 0.0044854977168142796, 0.006299190688878298, -0.005015768110752106, -0.023979635909199715, -0.0034263471607118845, -0.021100260317325592, 0.015363888815045357, 0.08395007997751236, 0.016267456114292145, -0.005674163345247507, 0.029358956962823868, 0.0025013373233377934, -0.008650114759802818, 0.010779623873531818, 0.030478263273835182, 0.009014301002025604, 0.05525054782629013, -0.04442766308784485, 0.044736165553331375, -0.01664847321808338, 0.029220523312687874, -0.1120651438832283, -0.031507447361946106, -0.0004265268798917532, 0.039960045367479324, 0.012295668013393879, -0.07902230322360992, -0.00016187502478715032, 0.040527697652578354, -0.029497826471924782, 0.011500225402414799, -0.03434368222951889, -0.005399653688073158, -0.03372223302721977, -0.004020749591290951, -0.00032809912227094173, 0.04593116417527199, 0.010706266388297081, 0.013818834908306599, 0.031799379736185074, -0.030875511467456818, 0.006661351770162582, -0.02051355317234993, -0.0029124938882887363, 0.04598167538642883, 0.01783655770123005, -0.05733022466301918, 0.0208638533949852, -0.027819857001304626, -0.044893521815538406, 0.046513188630342484, 0.0005138659034855664, 0.03571463003754616, 0.029308363795280457, 0.016538213938474655, 0.003036734415218234, 0.034331969916820526, 0.054800376296043396, 0.01823175884783268, -0.033127956092357635, -0.024046318605542183, 0.022665079683065414, 0.034951891750097275, -0.035624854266643524, -0.007810073439031839, 0.011415692046284676, -0.025730928406119347, -0.031991146504879, 0.01809346117079258, -0.02765193022787571, -0.009748000651597977, 0.002224883995950222, 0.020210664719343185, 0.01892327331006527, -0.03616898134350777, 0.04601295664906502, -0.0592707134783268, 0.011116203851997852, 0.02622603252530098, 0.05078501254320145, 0.004158177878707647, 0.039265599101781845, -0.003461979329586029, -0.040265344083309174, 0.00018474525131750852, 0.024484531953930855, 0.004687007516622543, -0.05360748991370201, -0.01588202454149723, -0.014370875433087349, -0.008696546778082848, 0.0319015234708786, 0.002395713236182928, -0.04836362600326538, 0.045310452580451965, -0.023662570863962173, 0.03153339400887489, 0.01103139203041792, -0.024915946647524834, -0.008049482479691505, -0.06947825849056244, 0.09035881608724594, 0.007532594725489616, -0.01853123866021633, -0.039147887378931046, 0.0017560519045218825, -0.027843337506055832, 0.002689341315999627, 0.07002125680446625, 0.009631475433707237, -0.004252519924193621, -0.0024666006211191416, 0.02573108673095703, 0.004364829510450363, -0.020678509026765823, 0.02101789228618145, -0.022329311817884445, -0.026580095291137695, 0.00944375991821289, 0.010615459643304348, 0.01254662312567234, 0.0049626813270151615, -0.00487559987232089, -0.03315731883049011, 0.02806541882455349, 0.0041955262422561646, -0.005372864194214344, 0.027963507920503616, 0.056497808545827866, -0.010553386993706226, 0.06460634618997574, -0.013312951661646366, -0.0004367047513369471, 0.016836294904351234, 0.012749199755489826, -0.044594645500183105, 0.040707558393478394, 0.013925652951002121, -0.01565508358180523, -0.016585657373070717, 0.006089940667152405, -0.021154077723622322, -0.06371159106492996, 0.01206032745540142, 0.02353643625974655, 0.0010499637573957443, -0.008005009032785892, 0.022396640852093697, 0.016985232010483742, 0.042121440172195435, -0.013113459572196007, -0.022464945912361145, -0.021363528445363045, -0.029469111934304237, -0.0004155849164817482, 0.015390529297292233, 0.002248594770208001, 0.017214711755514145, 0.015462093986570835, 0.027005096897482872, -0.011199381202459335, 0.030504446476697922, 0.025973020121455193, 0.049082931131124496, 0.025073103606700897, 0.0019512631697580218, 0.022962462157011032, -0.004807804245501757, 0.00429142452776432, 0.012859988957643509, -0.0173313170671463, 0.04994239658117294, -0.00011728560639312491, 0.008315546438097954, -0.028809620067477226, -0.04523666948080063, -0.02813667804002762, -0.030505552887916565, 0.037117499858140945, 0.023444458842277527, -0.004744842182844877, 0.008628283627331257, 0.0019725284073501825, -0.008962588384747505, 0.031553786247968674, -0.0456392802298069, -0.000785311043728143, -0.008367709815502167, -0.008619233034551144, -0.02605026215314865, -0.033420830965042114, -0.015295162796974182, -0.0018273821333423257, -0.017748886719346046, 0.01585911400616169, 0.014535374939441681, -0.03118426539003849, 0.017452973872423172, 0.02401718869805336, 0.07870049774646759, -0.08699490875005722, -0.033100906759500504, -0.04275697097182274, 0.020428862422704697, -0.03795551508665085, -0.03920307755470276 ]
<p>I would really appreciate some advice.</p> <p>I have two sequential measurements of severity of illness $(s_1, s_2)$ that are incompletely observed along with an outcome measure ($y$). I am trying to estimate if the change in the measurement $(d = s_2 - s_1)$ adds anything to a model based on the second measurement $s_2$ alone. </p> <p>There is an extra complication in that the severity of illness measurement is a score derived by categorising 10 continuous measurements of physiology ($x_1,x_2...x_{10}$), and weighting them. This is helpful because it is the standard clinical method in which to report severity, and it handles variables that are not always linearly associated with survival (e.g. very high or very low blood pressure is a bad thing --- you're best off in the middle).</p> <p>I have been trying to use multiple imputation assuming MAR in Stata 12.</p> <p>The final model would therefore be $y=\alpha + \beta_1s_2+\beta_2d+e$.</p> <p>However, I think there are several different imputation strategies and I am not sure which is correct.</p> <ol> <li>I use the raw physiology in the imputation model, and then derive the weights afterwards.</li> <li>I derive the individual weights ($x_1,x_2...x_{10}$) first, and then use these in the imputation model. </li> <li>I use the aggregate score in the imputation model. </li> </ol> <p>I am aware that using a transformation of a variable in the final model after the imputation (e.g. $x^2$ when you only included $x$ in the imputation) biases the effect of $x^2$ to zero. I am not sure if this is also the case with a categorisation and summation? In which case, I assume (2) would be the best option. Otherwise (1) seems best to me. I have already discounted (3) because it seems to lose a great deal of the richness of the data.</p> <p>Thanks in advance. </p>
74,299
[ -0.06463393568992615, -0.007330475840717554, -0.0019074012525379658, -0.030048852786421776, 0.024849260225892067, 0.015032455325126648, -0.02570669911801815, -0.028178688138723373, 0.02532723918557167, -0.03736250102519989, 0.04690641909837723, 0.03019009716808796, 0.049761489033699036, -0.02369365468621254, -0.0075597078539431095, -0.0056735253892838955, 0.006843262352049351, 0.02335220016539097, 0.02265249937772751, -0.019475528970360756, -0.006372741889208555, -0.003911131527274847, -0.02299124002456665, 0.019592370837926865, -0.035773150622844696, 0.05396037548780441, 0.02578270435333252, -0.028859779238700867, -0.04518178477883339, 0.03677329048514366, -0.011640869081020355, -0.025821689516305923, -0.007544224616140127, 0.009220924228429794, 0.018901076167821884, 0.012426745146512985, -0.020191770046949387, -0.03662034869194031, -0.015199107117950916, 0.06170396879315376, -0.01754717342555523, -0.01546173170208931, -0.027930937707424164, -0.010068614035844803, 0.0018131725955754519, 0.02443557046353817, 0.005058908369392157, 0.018072940409183502, -0.003979676403105259, -0.045888882130384445, 0.04092225804924965, 0.001140015316195786, 0.07438187301158905, 0.021334923803806305, -0.02334529347717762, -0.009130633436143398, 0.053397342562675476, 0.06764093041419983, 0.029091112315654755, -0.04430307447910309, 0.0029854211024940014, 0.0028721499256789684, -0.002935323864221573, -0.02464810386300087, -0.015522793866693974, 0.004357703495770693, 0.04235091060400009, -0.0018466514302417636, 0.050828736275434494, -0.043932702392339706, 0.031806424260139465, -0.002471095882356167, 0.010067268274724483, 0.012436631135642529, 0.044727541506290436, -0.02426815778017044, -0.009587527252733707, 0.034818340092897415, 0.047457125037908554, 0.00561600411310792, 0.011531604453921318, -0.023999199271202087, 0.04554937034845352, 0.04513157904148102, -0.027210412546992302, -0.011186698451638222, 0.07049404829740524, 0.007286640349775553, 0.03083258867263794, 0.012881830334663391, -0.009749600663781166, 0.01756506785750389, 0.02109830640256405, -0.022559262812137604, 0.00345182279124856, 0.047522734850645065, -0.013650589622557163, 0.0329909585416317, -0.02097455784678459, 0.007106376346200705, -0.01667601801455021, -0.04627149924635887, 0.01628272607922554, 0.07171705365180969, -0.014997750520706177, 0.009688383899629116, -0.011177169159054756, -0.022017018869519234, 0.019789928570389748, -0.041664209216833115, -0.029936514794826508, 0.020864669233560562, -0.014067063108086586, -0.021114997565746307, -0.0027990364469587803, -0.037203989923000336, -0.01364397443830967, -0.00899683590978384, 0.03576483204960823, 0.060466401278972626, 0.03374548256397247, -0.049325328320264816, -0.006658698432147503, -0.015493291430175304, -0.04553689435124397, 0.003978305961936712, 0.008101679384708405, -0.024758657440543175, -0.025059930980205536, 0.04098496958613396, 0.018546149134635925, -0.03303247317671776, 0.06577643007040024, 0.005735019687563181, 0.008388696238398552, -0.009461351670324802, -0.07685774564743042, -0.029307963326573372, 0.009180850349366665, 0.000792958599049598, 0.010932160541415215, -0.008136279881000519, -0.03453214839100838, 0.07150549441576004, 0.07101194560527802, 0.03679222986102104, 0.050940513610839844, 0.05131550878286362, 0.036763645708560944, 0.019726833328604698, 0.018143123015761375, -0.012405049055814743, -0.03786052018404007, 0.012793567962944508, -0.037085432559251785, -0.04873956739902496, 0.002050775568932295, 0.04172031953930855, -0.03976673260331154, 0.0014835004694759846, 0.04010782018303871, 0.02678803727030754, -0.013977650552988052, 0.02706528641283512, 0.0034636228810995817, -0.005997681524604559, 0.05878261849284172, -0.002055957680568099, 0.013263002969324589, 0.003398333676159382, -0.0017705286154523492, 0.019434386864304543, 0.016860581934452057, 0.05669398978352547, 0.044334374368190765, 0.015038056299090385, -0.007486294023692608, -0.02503335289657116, -0.044851187616586685, 0.018263116478919983, -0.05115211755037308, -0.05931461602449417, -0.02527187205851078, -0.03531600534915924, 0.043075378984212875, 0.04196605086326599, 0.0051313224248588085, -0.030809300020337105, 0.06380734592676163, -0.03716282546520233, -0.06670542806386948, -0.04893676936626434, 0.002852299017831683, 0.0025921508204191923, 0.010872707702219486, 0.027119774371385574, -0.041710227727890015, 0.020711418241262436, 0.026196572929620743, 0.017820702865719795, -0.006595004815608263, -0.002825424075126648, 0.06740695238113403, -0.02216675505042076, -0.005857698619365692, 0.05952140688896179, 0.057478293776512146, -0.012534534558653831, 0.021827105432748795, -0.03800728917121887, -0.034738849848508835, -0.010750304907560349, -0.04366255924105644, 0.05208607017993927, -0.04926657676696777, -0.009925691410899162, 0.003224873449653387, -0.011994130909442902, -0.04405219852924347, 0.008026120252907276, -0.0671849474310875, 0.10644982010126114, 0.06854619085788727, -0.02005094289779663, 0.0023992720525711775, 0.024900957942008972, -0.003587117185816169, 0.04181777313351631, -0.03047237917780876, -0.021677084267139435, -0.010375546291470528, -0.021520603448152542, 0.026310494169592857, 0.010160266421735287, -0.012908732518553734, 0.031363409012556076, 0.035558849573135376, 0.009239745326340199, 0.0016521187499165535, 0.009937132708728313, 0.012870736420154572, -0.006501481868326664, 0.0003450748336035758, -0.0021033426746726036, 0.0066973804496228695, 0.00864762905985117, 0.0062468466348946095, -0.03735902160406113, 0.04339369013905525, -0.0004854003491345793, 0.034331053495407104, 0.056452490389347076, 0.019680708646774292, 0.030522139742970467, -0.024524280801415443, -0.04705709591507912, 0.05526174232363701, -0.002998270094394684, 0.03193742036819458, 0.05114239454269409, -0.02413046360015869, 0.018242279067635536, 0.03268113359808922, 0.002036167774349451, 0.018478279933333397, 0.03573073446750641, -0.032283201813697815, 0.020269686356186867, -0.003072234569117427, -0.04831928759813309, 0.024337977170944214, -0.011977063491940498, -0.03494057059288025, -0.025307316333055496, -0.022082461044192314, 0.038186922669410706, 0.00977425929158926, -0.023344678804278374, -0.04046390950679779, 0.002729942789301276, 0.03406776860356331, -0.023985834792256355, 0.051113713532686234, 0.045100677758455276, -0.07646635174751282, -0.03027857467532158, -0.06267919391393661, -0.012439641170203686, 0.04007154703140259, 0.013347835280001163, -0.02003379352390766, 0.01514502801001072, 0.019566621631383896, -0.03755159676074982, -0.031529560685157776, -0.008147558197379112, 0.007068456616252661, -0.007446362636983395, -0.028447920456528664, 0.07569706439971924, 0.03020280785858631, -0.0532037615776062, -0.008808603510260582, -0.0365002378821373, -0.02485763654112816, -0.03194926306605339, -0.001500269048847258, 0.0032534715719521046, -0.016229297965765, 0.000950001587625593, -0.0076646870002150536, -0.0015281285159289837, -0.013559418730437756, -0.06944762170314789, -0.04258761182427406, 0.04363901540637016, -0.007849134504795074, 0.04588458687067032, 0.01891026273369789, -0.019744833931326866, 0.07290397584438324, 0.021402794867753983, 0.014935871586203575, -0.02347935363650322, 0.04709692671895027, -0.005408773198723793, 0.0132340332493186, -0.015229369513690472, 0.007488293573260307, 0.00893937237560749, -0.003365373006090522, -0.012179293669760227, 0.026348385959863663, 0.022507471963763237, 0.01112756785005331, -0.016932759433984756, 0.05575425177812576, -0.004340983461588621, -0.023749971762299538, 0.048487965017557144, 0.021536031737923622, 0.01999589242041111, 0.02946021594107151, -0.051379479467868805, 0.013766365125775337, -0.013100948184728622, -0.028710391372442245, -0.008319912478327751, 0.009230210445821285, 0.000021755495254183188, -0.046507176011800766, 0.019494064152240753, 0.03112165816128254, -0.04260339215397835, 0.005243724677711725, 0.008192166686058044, 0.04107131436467171, -0.0352729931473732, -0.009850204922258854, 0.05694212019443512, 0.023191915825009346, 0.028118014335632324, -0.002378438599407673, 0.009400174021720886, -0.00024235236924141645, 0.06535819172859192, -0.041353512555360794, -0.01772330328822136, 0.023449819535017014, 0.06329482793807983, 0.020894348621368408, -0.01712542027235031, -0.04496763274073601, 0.016176696866750717, -0.051802922040224075, -0.01976602151989937, -0.026372842490673065, 0.07165206968784332, 0.008856670930981636, 0.01757209002971649, 0.020763924345374107, -0.013455016538500786, -0.011865193955600262, 0.02643612213432789, -0.06773407757282257, -0.002167296130210161, 0.03740744665265083, 0.028541645035147667, 0.02815823443233967, -0.009400631301105022, 0.007635404355823994, -0.016875136643648148, -0.019774055108428, -0.0606970377266407, 0.015948103740811348, -0.021450120955705643, 0.0009677304187789559, -0.027140945196151733, -0.006704370956867933, -0.02004355750977993, 0.025228314101696014, -0.0014135594246909022, -0.016206692904233932, 0.000517507316544652, 0.016805993393063545, 0.009709893725812435, -0.0033301759976893663, -0.05270720645785332, 0.025098087266087532, 0.020837949588894844, 0.0336386114358902, 0.008451691828668118, 0.014797362498939037, -0.06149936094880104, 0.004517239052802324, 0.029416320845484734, 0.012188171967864037, 0.022025216370821, -0.004101323429495096, -0.035694535821676254, -0.022275062277913094, -0.02036745660007, -0.010598652996122837, 0.0005961602437309921, 0.03361596539616585, 0.002161777578294277, 0.052867040038108826, -0.008146406151354313, -0.05044956132769585, -0.008866538293659687, -0.002581164939329028, 0.018295368179678917, -0.017751598730683327, -0.018020600080490112, -0.018819397315382957, -0.026355130597949028, 0.0025489404797554016, 0.047138337045907974, 0.011005529202520847, 0.035544928163290024, -0.027115855365991592, 0.05175241827964783, -0.03475535288453102, -0.007691953331232071, -0.02192731946706772, 0.04906262457370758, 0.03573936969041824, 0.05984022840857506, -0.044812291860580444, 0.02918088063597679, 0.025928031653165817, 0.03097369894385338, 0.026538891717791557, 0.03521214798092842, -0.07306783646345139, -0.02267163060605526, -0.0013533449964597821, 0.022971181198954582, -0.01303949486464262, -0.018147965893149376, -0.021181372925639153, -0.009609908796846867, 0.0060591562651097775, -0.042831115424633026, 0.0014822396915405989, -0.021959349513053894, -0.016732150688767433, 0.01927967183291912, -0.06352240592241287, -0.03242538124322891, 0.02515702322125435, -0.012714269571006298, 0.014791818335652351, 0.01477982010692358, -0.025289271026849747, 0.012163546867668629, -0.013065402396023273, -0.026803648099303246, 0.05195609852671623, -0.030827147886157036, -0.009030652232468128, 0.027999086305499077, 0.01862601935863495, -0.05418893322348595, -0.062593474984169, -0.02754720114171505, -0.011943337507545948, 0.0013528128620237112, 0.024727992713451385, -0.004366462584584951, -0.024116335436701775, 0.022024722769856453, 0.006768976338207722, -0.014907104894518852, 0.015047268941998482, -0.02397722564637661, 0.061732348054647446, 0.027221007272601128, -0.009069858118891716, 0.06693235784769058, 0.060208044946193695, -0.039195943623781204, 0.026407726109027863, -0.023738624528050423, -0.01328262034803629, -0.04130246117711067, -0.044176168739795685, -0.04568733647465706, -0.0023225650656968355, -0.010576749220490456, 0.0229649655520916, -0.012836559675633907, 0.06793299317359924, 0.0178501196205616, -0.022857626900076866, 0.04795598238706589, -0.0047203912399709225, 0.00786570180207491, -0.005915921647101641, -0.029235709458589554, 0.033779583871364594, 0.013430486433207989, -0.020838595926761627, 0.031157847493886948, -0.011773888021707535, -0.003932425752282143, -0.009646878577768803, -0.09217161685228348, 0.002119682263582945, -0.002769266255199909, 0.0007560219964943826, -0.0016648208256810904, 0.008695196360349655, 0.006622314918786287, -0.03574279323220253, 0.006324106827378273, -0.03295060992240906, -0.03061189316213131, -0.029989365488290787, 0.025850355625152588, 0.024090643972158432, 0.011898146942257881, -0.006397980730980635, -0.00561424670740962, 0.007421180605888367, -0.009278222918510437, -0.04699499160051346, -0.024178514257073402, 0.04327038675546646, 0.008524328470230103, -0.005748421419411898, -0.022972464561462402, 0.018368011340498924, -0.01113151852041483, -0.058084312826395035, -0.0021347692236304283, 0.0468977689743042, -0.03216248005628586, -0.002533226041123271, -0.031307537108659744, 0.04473424702882767, 0.0562465637922287, -0.01935320720076561, -0.004490129183977842, 0.015913100913167, -0.03350680321455002, 0.0009812231874093413, -0.010149631649255753, -0.019773444160819054, -0.047987356781959534, 0.011212293989956379, -0.013939578086137772, -0.027018768712878227, 0.01748676411807537, 0.029198337346315384, -0.015281313098967075, -0.019712794572114944, -0.024164114147424698, -0.007510365918278694, -0.017933407798409462, 0.0067802551202476025, -0.023178717121481895, -0.000220652756979689, -0.04287510737776756, 0.017771728336811066, -0.000591069576330483, -0.012018175795674324, 0.015977894887328148, 0.005984773859381676, -0.041553884744644165, -0.0037289164029061794, 0.035278286784887314, 0.02405410446226597, 0.02623056247830391, 0.004277427215129137, -0.02397632785141468, 0.02108200453221798, 0.006558734457939863, -0.005905333440750837, 0.010637705214321613, 0.01177733764052391, -0.024140702560544014, -0.027121972292661667, -0.057425569742918015, 0.03171807527542114, 0.06365019828081131, 0.007904953323304653, 0.0065152691677212715, 0.020678188651800156, -0.0036858341190963984, 0.023493455722928047, -0.04088745266199112, -0.0011790450662374496, -0.006788800470530987, -0.0008903181296773255, 0.0656658262014389, -0.004906440619379282, -0.03047832101583481, 0.06969966739416122, -0.0026497601065784693, 0.029220199212431908, 0.01671689935028553, 0.0045166704803705215, -0.016480864956974983, -0.001817819313146174, -0.061428893357515335, -0.046718377619981766, -0.0017519643297418952, -0.053456034511327744, -0.026192670688033104, -0.031264349818229675, -0.06057815998792648, 0.0353504940867424, 0.030030375346541405, -0.0051591238006949425, -0.040126994252204895, -0.024082470685243607, -0.07058046013116837, -0.03714480996131897, 0.01169744972139597, -0.02161991223692894, 0.0521734356880188, 0.008917241357266903, 0.07495524734258652, 0.001689782366156578, 0.024464311078190804, -0.030830349773168564, -0.059594932943582535, -0.022127699106931686, 0.00700528547167778, -0.04257488250732422, 0.03873028978705406, -0.013330160640180111, -0.020278535783290863, 0.012720591388642788, -0.02703302726149559, 0.007330551743507385, 0.010826535522937775, 0.044919490814208984, -0.026517067104578018, 0.047010280191898346, -0.015145916491746902, 0.0025883782655000687, -0.022519974038004875, -0.02998659573495388, 0.11375945806503296, 0.09394516050815582, 0.08637633174657822, -0.045287858694791794, 0.021366992965340614, 0.048899851739406586, 0.06570783257484436, 0.0015834636287763715, -0.003013808047398925, 0.013262735679745674, -0.05307583138346672, 0.01730452850461006, 0.05790164694190025, 0.0037562637589871883, -0.04631641134619713, 0.06908442825078964, -0.01866082288324833, -0.0006384241278283298, -0.0006511534447781742, -0.010074296966195107, -0.024651793763041496, -0.021243207156658173, -0.040566831827163696, 0.03412671387195587, 0.010886883363127708, -0.023929597809910774, -0.046710770577192307, 0.02194320224225521, -0.03644049912691116, -0.010651514865458012, -0.03464809060096741, 0.005960229318588972, -0.01731826178729534, 0.004280231427401304, -0.012011111713945866, -0.009004216641187668, 0.010922903195023537, -0.04218854382634163, -0.0007842118502594531, 0.04286212474107742, -0.010858621448278427, 0.03449888154864311, 0.010432927869260311, 0.014325540512800217, -0.08865101635456085, -0.040926821529865265, -0.017143165692687035, 0.04081960767507553, 0.003584344172850251, -0.008666650392115116, -0.008979398757219315, -0.0068818749859929085, 0.007971045561134815, -0.0360276885330677, -0.0016328933415934443, 0.022068830206990242, 0.030636833980679512, -0.00527602294459939, -0.028602024540305138, 0.013138879090547562, 0.0033847996965050697, -0.003070971230044961, 0.024888088926672935, 0.019109729677438736, -0.06367950141429901, -0.05262623727321625, 0.019561652094125748, -0.012246296741068363, 0.031915221363306046, 0.02935197949409485, 0.0008585278410464525, 0.005632046144455671, 0.00522170914337039, -0.037851281464099884, 0.04605169966816902, 0.017718272283673286, 0.046481434255838394, 0.0035138954408466816, -0.014512311667203903, -0.04883306473493576, -0.0555216446518898, -0.00844413973391056, -0.011808118782937527, 0.0014059580862522125, -0.0452563650906086, 0.005675193853676319, -0.007574057672172785, 0.04059525206685066, 0.009609292261302471, 0.0021850098855793476, 0.007171484176069498, 0.04957998916506767, -0.01817355491220951, -0.05604097247123718, 0.004872988443821669, 0.023725010454654694, -0.039085496217012405, 0.024404287338256836, -0.006292442791163921, 0.07117544114589691, 0.0417192243039608, 0.04114998131990433, -0.016312099993228912, 0.03291893005371094, 0.02391001209616661, 0.010917101986706257, -0.005196467507630587, -0.07525177299976349, 0.010116039775311947, -0.020316053181886673, 0.04349702224135399, -0.014674829319119453, 0.024024764075875282, -0.029637278988957405, -0.057554200291633606, 0.0067157261073589325, -0.0378747321665287, -0.002901710569858551, 0.0048566218465566635, -0.014399810694158077, 0.01363223884254694, -0.035852424800395966, -0.0031778004486113787, -0.04172397032380104, -0.025207659229636192, -0.03433219715952873, -0.05694479122757912, 0.0011640983866527677, 0.019418638199567795, -0.015251020900905132, 0.01915454864501953, 0.035546738654375076, -0.02559358812868595, -0.0011324716033414006, 0.01024231594055891, 0.032132022082805634, -0.0031931002158671618, 0.0340302474796772, 0.016841620206832886, -0.009921113960444927, 0.0022177540231496096, -0.015990380197763443, 0.0008105598390102386, 0.05523070693016052, 0.024281684309244156, 0.028381718322634697, 0.027834948152303696, 0.00437390198931098, -0.06047237291932106, 0.041993577033281326, -0.040783315896987915, -0.020443029701709747, -0.054589249193668365, -0.01276459638029337, -0.02534446492791176, -0.0024104961194097996, -0.01164400763809681, 0.0420084223151207, -0.022586947306990623, 0.017002714797854424, 0.0321878120303154, -0.00943529512733221, -0.020688246935606003, 0.014408118091523647, -0.011581165716052055, 0.034144967794418335, -0.011465277522802353, 0.019456027075648308, 0.020179590210318565, 0.023983169347047806, -0.0058621251955628395, 0.04533415660262108, -0.02023131214082241, -0.011167571879923344, -0.07369355857372284, -0.023718038573861122, 0.018172871321439743, 0.05999961122870445, 0.020937807857990265, 0.006813493557274342, 0.02153218351304531, 0.02220821939408779, -0.03163653612136841, 0.007039101794362068, 0.021133283153176308, 0.0302836075425148, 0.001660953857935965, 0.026542337611317635, -0.04340491443872452, 0.0053704348392784595, 0.002748160855844617, 0.035279665142297745, -0.009278679266571999, 0.04878123104572296, 0.021363163366913795, -0.03146486356854439, -0.05456036329269409, 0.01572990231215954, -0.005141403526067734, -0.06440672278404236, 0.03366129845380783, -0.04081239178776741, -0.029034242033958435, 0.02693290263414383, 0.020813774317502975, 0.056478679180145264, 0.02191975899040699, 0.061491355299949646, -0.007683365140110254, 0.047085415571928024, -0.007081749849021435, 0.017066171392798424, 0.03131682798266411, -0.008572346530854702, 0.015054093673825264, 0.007194576319307089, -0.059524644166231155, 0.03559268265962601, 0.03496252000331879, -0.023490307852625847, -0.004853974562138319, 0.001697221421636641, 0.0011749300174415112, -0.023714423179626465, 0.009774740785360336, -0.004114380571991205, 0.013842204585671425, -0.032284677028656006, 0.0030130704399198294, -0.016319023445248604, 0.0155337480828166, 0.06883347034454346, 0.011508259922266006, 0.007877628318965435, 0.022341594099998474, 0.005665447097271681, -0.016388224437832832, 0.010645166039466858, 0.012983875349164009, -0.014219888485968113, -0.0412394143640995, -0.01534099131822586, -0.019290942698717117, 0.00650061247870326, -0.019984832033514977, 0.025465598329901695, -0.04643520712852478, 0.022323263809084892, -0.02833367884159088, 0.011870600283145905, 0.0423160120844841, -0.027267472818493843, 0.03365238755941391, -0.09268303960561752, 0.022113794460892677, 0.0022108571138232946, -0.034102994948625565, -0.00749187869951129, 0.0014220341108739376, -0.028976624831557274, 0.02342628315091133, 0.07793664187192917, 0.00022102220100350678, 0.010928458534181118, -0.020397378131747246, 0.04311525449156761, 0.026251288130879402, -0.01437311340123415, 0.030222944915294647, -0.002825997769832611, -0.007978406734764576, -0.034911736845970154, 0.008416524156928062, 0.004454799462109804, 0.003137035761028528, 0.039715725928545, -0.03296491876244545, 0.012925772927701473, 0.0076093729585409164, 0.01695798523724079, 0.012420780956745148, 0.0036358570214360952, -0.039704978466033936, 0.027333179488778114, -0.008243809454143047, 0.006509935017675161, 0.04583341255784035, -0.03929007798433304, -0.04081809148192406, 0.005499702878296375, -0.0015545214992016554, -0.014538298361003399, 0.04448874294757843, -0.0177869014441967, -0.0004577132349368185, -0.07333023101091385, -0.01316634751856327, 0.008614220656454563, 0.013819613493978977, -0.02619541808962822, 0.06060222536325455, 0.009247119538486004, 0.0324501097202301, 0.026048116385936737, 0.03562407195568085, -0.0005461019463837147, -0.009800583124160767, 0.0068238102830946445, -0.013490059413015842, 0.06358685344457626, -0.002718094503507018, -0.03578972816467285, 0.043313875794410706, -0.014730295166373253, 0.030870065093040466, -0.012784654274582863, 0.028234707191586494, -0.05243949964642525, -0.026526808738708496, -0.002075140131637454, -0.006039247382432222, 0.01941368356347084, -0.016931012272834778, -0.006034635007381439, 0.050606511533260345, -0.01110674999654293, 0.01715780422091484, -0.006741066928952932, -0.04617515206336975, -0.034219782799482346, 0.0016471458366140723, 0.018614236265420914, 0.048270754516124725, 0.006919097620993853, -0.0029128107707947493, 0.006891122553497553, -0.028323331847786903, -0.010150657035410404, -0.011370345018804073, 0.030450759455561638, -0.0036966735497117043, -0.014952893368899822, -0.008579251356422901, -0.05249646306037903, 0.017471399158239365, -0.028712380677461624, 0.03494102880358696, 0.03301406279206276, 0.030688388273119926, -0.04339319467544556, -0.02865292876958847, -0.009009286761283875, 0.025870127603411674, -0.03131888434290886, -0.04222371056675911, -0.02672884799540043, -0.014189690351486206, 0.025173218920826912, -0.045600201934576035 ]
<p>This is a questions I got for homework in <em>test planning and variance analysis</em>. I apologize in advance for the way my professor phrases things :D I would love to hear hints or tips on how to approach this. So here goes:</p> <blockquote> <p>A statistician decides to perform the next a-parametric test to examine the $H_0$ of variance Analysis. First he will calculate the test statistic in the following way: Calculating the ranks of all observations with no affiliation to a group, and calculating F statistics of the anova test on the ranks instead of on the observations. Then, he will calculate the p-value using a permutation test, since under $H_0$ there is the same chance for all the permutations of ranks when dividing into groups. </p> <ol> <li><p>What is the SST calculated on the ranks of observations? Show that the SST does not depend on the observations, only on the number of observations.</p></li> <li><p>Prove that the p-value of this test will be equal to the p-value that is calculated with permutation on the Kruskal-Wallis test statistic. Clue: Show that the test statistic of Kuskal-wallis is SSB/(SST/N-1) when SSB and SST are calculated on the ranks of observation and N is the total number of observations.</p></li> </ol> </blockquote> <p>This is what I've got for (1). Not sure about it but it makes sense to me.. What I don't get is how to show that SST does not depend on the observations, because obviously we need them in order to calculate the SST.</p> <p>$k$ - number of groups<br> $n_i$ - number of observations in group $i$<br> $\bar{d}$ - mean of ranks of all groups<br> $\bar{d}_i$ - mean of ranks in group $i$ </p> <p>$$\operatorname{SSB} = \sum_{i=1}^k n_i(\bar{d}_i-\bar{d})^2$$</p> <p>$$\operatorname{SSW} = \sum_{i=1}^k \sum_{j=1}^{n_i} (d_{ij}-\bar{d}_i)^2$$</p> <p>$$\operatorname{SST} = \sum_{i=1}^k \sum_{j=1}^{n_i} (d_{ij}-\bar{d})^2$$</p> <p>And actually when I think about it, I'm not so sure what is difference between the test that is described in this question and Kruskal Wallis.</p>
37,119
[ -0.04770132899284363, -0.012672522105276585, -0.01273653469979763, -0.014747335575520992, 0.06525660306215286, 0.010634100995957851, -0.005621865391731262, -0.01122803334146738, 0.02699049934744835, -0.05885536968708038, 0.047536835074424744, -0.03736715018749237, 0.03232146427035332, 0.029591454192996025, 0.022118093445897102, 0.008662519045174122, -0.0343591645359993, -0.005087601020932198, 0.010132228024303913, -0.003650110447779298, -0.00014807308616582304, 0.039806243032217026, 0.011285037733614445, -0.03857928141951561, -0.0593513660132885, 0.030790729448199272, -0.02746114693582058, -0.028596285730600357, 0.0002681002952158451, 0.08473198115825653, -0.06183794513344765, -0.006730236578732729, 0.012138555757701397, 0.03959910199046135, -0.029358066618442535, 0.027763761579990387, 0.039397064596414566, -0.00692119961604476, -0.0045705195516347885, 0.013847318477928638, -0.049762651324272156, -0.0420011542737484, -0.014942395500838757, 0.001827365136705339, 0.03997037187218666, 0.033365294337272644, -0.022316360846161842, -0.020696718245744705, 0.005944097880274057, -0.045471176505088806, 0.0556107759475708, 0.036630433052778244, -0.007023930083960295, -0.009478828869760036, -0.054994091391563416, -0.003817677730694413, 0.030287666246294975, 0.016919126734137535, -0.0011565182358026505, -0.03122830018401146, -0.019471557810902596, -0.0426655113697052, 0.022620370611548424, -0.028284821659326553, -0.03850116580724716, 0.030424833297729492, -0.01389905996620655, 0.002822193084284663, 0.04405771568417549, 0.007576675619930029, 0.006754028145223856, 0.017505893483757973, 0.019189942628145218, -0.057903483510017395, -0.00957836490124464, -0.010097161866724491, 0.007448084652423859, -0.028491204604506493, 0.04857541620731354, 0.03856411948800087, -0.02202538773417473, 0.049464717507362366, 0.014239815063774586, 0.040848132222890854, 0.03431287035346031, -0.027515266090631485, 0.05049633979797363, 0.018068045377731323, 0.009586506523191929, 0.027831220999360085, -0.024838965386152267, -0.020406128838658333, 0.0356081984937191, 0.0016506187384948134, -0.03050505556166172, 0.017288314178586006, -0.04425409436225891, 0.005495985969901085, -0.02645297348499298, 0.0038062268868088722, 0.007930266670882702, -0.05227093771100044, 0.020963571965694427, 0.06854041665792465, -0.007999267429113388, -0.014916007407009602, -0.0027880477719008923, 0.028125030919909477, -0.01776471920311451, -0.015637697651982307, 0.001363676623441279, 0.026225879788398743, -0.034638386219739914, -0.03583582118153572, -0.02122369222342968, 0.011499593034386635, -0.013941401615738869, -0.025389745831489563, 0.04758129268884659, 0.043204259127378464, 0.07126390188932419, -0.02983870729804039, -0.028225010260939598, -0.03631677106022835, -0.03427976742386818, 0.028920825570821762, 0.005238871090114117, 0.006486912723630667, -0.006239740643650293, 0.05344962328672409, -0.006972973700612783, 0.00989771168678999, 0.03350919112563133, 0.021705064922571182, -0.0048589748330414295, -0.01820586808025837, -0.13804960250854492, -0.056443311274051666, 0.04936002194881439, -0.00676714675500989, -0.0019606826826930046, -0.04576922580599785, 0.0424264594912529, 0.033141396939754486, 0.039463553577661514, -0.011977029033005238, 0.05012140050530434, -0.018514685332775116, 0.01928653195500374, 0.04932862147688866, -0.0007120793452486396, -0.00379785499535501, -0.017681051045656204, -0.02435017004609108, -0.0035335649736225605, -0.08043017983436584, 0.03450263291597366, 0.025048788636922836, 0.000387649197364226, -0.008103063330054283, 0.040830858051776886, -0.0015747381839901209, 0.002213115571066737, 0.014899840578436852, 0.015379725955426693, -0.00317757367156446, 0.027518292888998985, -0.03295411542057991, 0.028446687385439873, 0.010529945604503155, -0.008413483388721943, -0.028130488470196724, -0.004236736800521612, 0.05034705623984337, 0.025216611102223396, -0.019587207585573196, 0.010970702394843102, -0.051284272223711014, 0.01054212637245655, -0.0221638735383749, -0.009113529697060585, -0.004786815494298935, -0.016539951786398888, 0.014552365057170391, 0.023399336263537407, 0.017460549250245094, 0.0004870535049121827, 0.03101356513798237, 0.028172997757792473, -0.051254112273454666, -0.047127991914749146, -0.05598025396466255, -0.026527849957346916, 0.006684836931526661, -0.05655757710337639, 0.009914526715874672, 0.008614233694970608, -0.0034620636142790318, 0.02307979203760624, -0.0004794276610482484, -0.01296978909522295, -0.025386527180671692, 0.038471393287181854, -0.0271584615111351, -0.004196372348815203, 0.029038842767477036, 0.05397437512874603, -0.009699354879558086, 0.009840465150773525, -0.03325329348444939, -0.01219626422971487, 0.0083896080031991, -0.03238917514681816, 0.015395567752420902, 0.003314105561003089, -0.010645605623722076, 0.0178196020424366, -0.006080161314457655, 0.029636112973093987, 0.0784747526049614, -0.038090258836746216, 0.02702157385647297, 0.04942263662815094, 0.006878724787384272, 0.023906759917736053, -0.0025487621314823627, -0.010228246450424194, 0.013780624605715275, -0.004361421335488558, -0.0024207409005612135, -0.018177859485149384, -0.012030497193336487, -0.004557474050670862, -0.03228063881397247, -0.016245823353528976, -0.006145469378679991, 0.06511418521404266, -0.005679660476744175, -0.015453709289431572, 0.033803172409534454, 0.01309949066489935, -0.023027556017041206, -0.0024609428364783525, -0.0040426962077617645, 0.033894121646881104, 0.006832570303231478, -0.030518166720867157, 0.006765022408217192, 0.044010937213897705, 0.03462320938706398, -0.004507898818701506, 0.03953898325562477, 0.018048780038952827, -0.026283549144864082, -0.02754952386021614, -0.021366605535149574, 0.029093388468027115, -0.0021381592378020287, 0.010520373471081257, 0.06499649584293365, 0.000879719911608845, 0.016723403707146645, -0.015402021817862988, -0.03357880935072899, 0.029931722208857536, -0.01328118983656168, -0.03170791268348694, -0.00946005992591381, 0.01603441871702671, -0.040493328124284744, 0.0038275776896625757, -0.036216236650943756, -0.06001507118344307, -0.016288623213768005, 0.007592886686325073, -0.009776556864380836, -0.00369186419993639, -0.0032356467563658953, -0.018974510952830315, 0.006262018345296383, -0.00927064474672079, 0.03952638804912567, 0.031870417296886444, 0.02689852938055992, -0.0691259354352951, -0.009314564988017082, -0.04803382605314255, -0.0015612138668075204, 0.023775918409228325, -0.021471461281180382, -0.02718948759138584, 0.06304901093244553, 0.023493167012929916, -0.05016548931598663, -0.046648621559143066, -0.017144624143838882, 0.005013083107769489, -0.06462787836790085, -0.029282761737704277, 0.041564714163541794, 0.014731062576174736, -0.0328177884221077, 0.0339447557926178, -0.02894754335284233, -0.005642749834805727, -0.0005200771847739816, 0.014855285175144672, 0.032745640724897385, -0.013398611918091774, 0.009737148880958557, -0.0040756938979029655, -0.00007385477510979399, -0.004880056716501713, -0.05738281086087227, -0.07345184683799744, 0.008674674667418003, 0.035706281661987305, 0.04438105225563049, -0.008788907900452614, -0.053931962698698044, 0.07024186849594116, 0.027920691296458244, -0.015764392912387848, -0.03788406401872635, 0.004750365857034922, -0.019708432257175446, -0.014504550024867058, 0.03515451401472092, 0.014466875232756138, -0.012001325376331806, 0.011863487772643566, -0.012129733338952065, 0.041252803057432175, 0.034272532910108566, -0.010182790458202362, 0.0014689858071506023, -0.01298372820019722, 0.017021602019667625, -0.0021251454018056393, 0.060898903757333755, 0.0035947319120168686, -0.013875863514840603, 0.0008614224498160183, -0.0032838601619005203, 0.018397996202111244, 0.04547250270843506, -0.04597731679677963, 0.0639694407582283, -0.033919557929039, -0.005974506493657827, -0.055523768067359924, 0.044488757848739624, 0.05422527715563774, -0.017031725496053696, -0.02866075374186039, 0.005725102033466101, -0.008465561084449291, -0.044883161783218384, 0.01656271331012249, 0.05192570760846138, 0.053936850279569626, -0.01682363450527191, -0.046029236167669296, 0.006892078556120396, -0.066118985414505, 0.025908157229423523, -0.03518792614340782, -0.0005793988239020109, -0.009220931679010391, 0.07335585355758667, -0.0010527336271479726, -0.026504358276724815, -0.016798710450530052, -0.01858922466635704, -0.014057734981179237, -0.009655351750552654, -0.037474893033504486, 0.034236326813697815, -0.013637798838317394, 0.07070503383874893, -0.02612849697470665, -0.00570693938061595, -0.03676244616508484, -0.02925153635442257, -0.029778890311717987, 0.035868946462869644, -0.0020489420276135206, -0.0404137559235096, 0.019831856712698936, -0.043917156755924225, 0.0269936490803957, -0.019884586334228516, 0.01071002334356308, 0.0030978138092905283, 0.06293611973524094, -0.05767277628183365, 0.025452585890889168, -0.03251465782523155, -0.005630879197269678, 0.008732126094400883, 0.01828976906836033, 0.02501995675265789, -0.03045995533466339, 0.02280360274016857, 0.013249523006379604, -0.01115377340465784, 0.02234748937189579, -0.024798313155770302, 0.005562918726354837, 0.02566070482134819, 0.05178806185722351, 0.01167844608426094, 0.00024992763064801693, -0.05318833515048027, 0.016777554526925087, -0.01796625182032585, 0.02497105859220028, 0.005489043891429901, -0.019028346985578537, 0.02446500025689602, -0.016215460374951363, -0.054766833782196045, -0.0060186441987752914, 0.029736526310443878, -0.010944198817014694, 0.01171232108026743, 0.061725832521915436, -0.011112879030406475, -0.028581323102116585, 0.02868090756237507, 0.019408093765378, -0.007053800858557224, 0.006860887166112661, -0.03503602743148804, -0.018091928213834763, 0.012199250049889088, -0.013560310006141663, -0.003357033245265484, -0.0035693550016731024, 0.009529233910143375, -0.0002197024441557005, 0.04418150335550308, 0.005756677128374577, -0.019401300698518753, -0.00437453668564558, 0.01946699433028698, 0.015860063955187798, -0.02074591815471649, -0.0017769968835636973, 0.00861428678035736, 0.0014879731461405754, 0.027333147823810577, 0.028208184987306595, -0.016483202576637268, -0.04433441534638405, -0.0073557510040700436, 0.03336575999855995, 0.054284416139125824, -0.0422978475689888, 0.07118311524391174, 0.005456362385302782, 0.012808241881430149, -0.017804134637117386, -0.018810832872986794, 0.023683497682213783, -0.002936667064204812, -0.005159825552254915, -0.05000435560941696, -0.03516197204589844, -0.05474342405796051, 0.017812984064221382, -0.010708888061344624, 0.006950709968805313, -0.0007844869396649301, -0.013906779699027538, -0.03238830342888832, -0.013443417847156525, 0.017006294801831245, 0.02175530046224594, -0.025707097724080086, -0.015062359161674976, 0.04571884125471115, 0.04748915508389473, -0.013971921987831593, -0.07112210988998413, 0.04957139864563942, -0.016969183459877968, 0.00015210472338367254, 0.06608203053474426, -0.044567108154296875, -0.04792915657162666, 0.03832666948437691, -0.04688761755824089, -0.016136357560753822, -0.010776093229651451, -0.03693544492125511, 0.06800767034292221, 0.05002779886126518, 0.02081170119345188, 0.05032473802566528, 0.008625490590929985, -0.015471473336219788, 0.018230728805065155, -0.02401166409254074, 0.007286766543984413, -0.03254476934671402, -0.002155027352273464, -0.008090971037745476, 0.010050795041024685, -0.03551002964377403, 0.030235199257731438, -0.015121237374842167, 0.020848797634243965, -0.03828118368983269, 0.0002844170667231083, -0.012339694425463676, 0.001979725668206811, 0.01565425656735897, 0.021352704614400864, -0.007647666148841381, 0.023311182856559753, 0.054887283593416214, -0.03138352185487747, 0.03380678594112396, -0.025881633162498474, -0.005684264469891787, -0.017801305279135704, -0.018774181604385376, -0.007291198708117008, 0.0019511255668476224, -0.03921271115541458, 0.033047836273908615, -0.02108665183186531, 0.032790012657642365, -0.03132789954543114, -0.003352175001055002, 0.001204272615723312, -0.04015456885099411, -0.03405950590968132, 0.01661447435617447, -0.004218232352286577, 0.023995492607355118, -0.013114087283611298, -0.00038841846981085837, -0.006267317570745945, -0.0036543020978569984, -0.05965958908200264, 0.005840744823217392, 0.02345638908445835, 0.018215004354715347, -0.04362070932984352, 0.02479170262813568, -0.01365351676940918, 0.003330870997160673, -0.0573803074657917, -0.005796121433377266, 0.04709335416555405, -0.019915156066417694, -0.02438666671514511, -0.007753788027912378, 0.05352780222892761, 0.08781561255455017, 0.007030887994915247, -0.012573734857141972, 0.0034190621227025986, -0.043687112629413605, -0.013783068396151066, 0.0021503297612071037, 0.010838904418051243, -0.012452192604541779, -0.001379696186631918, 0.007013773079961538, 0.026038477197289467, 0.020799996331334114, -0.0031148921698331833, -0.036731671541929245, -0.01065928302705288, -0.01369647216051817, 0.030458414927124977, -0.029441211372613907, -0.009999500587582588, 0.013182210735976696, 0.051167599856853485, -0.002832273952662945, 0.021547775715589523, -0.01835915818810463, 0.004778530448675156, -0.007736801635473967, -0.02726215496659279, -0.0005202884785830975, 0.05238911136984825, 0.09244076907634735, -0.0014839101349934936, 0.00041084684198722243, 0.01604350656270981, -0.03909021615982056, 0.02429681271314621, 0.03945665434002876, 0.010343438014388084, 0.006364781409502029, 0.010385419242084026, -0.0032298152800649405, 0.010153746232390404, -0.018871495500206947, 0.02431746944785118, 0.07642114907503128, 0.030251486226916313, 0.04402446001768112, 0.039794549345970154, 0.007555684074759483, 0.012472337111830711, -0.01819424517452717, -0.01908072642982006, -0.008174710907042027, 0.041871219873428345, 0.07392344623804092, -0.014391732402145863, -0.022119540721178055, 0.07053454965353012, 0.030469508841633797, 0.005185500252991915, 0.05450855568051338, 0.0581057071685791, -0.012018968351185322, 0.01699618250131607, 0.001978197367861867, -0.05970044806599617, 0.03861561417579651, -0.056274257600307465, -0.008360108360648155, -0.02702641859650612, 0.01232853252440691, 0.03895234316587448, 0.05340127646923065, 0.013655493967235088, -0.06290728598833084, -0.07868323475122452, -0.059417225420475006, 0.015391619876027107, -0.023076986894011497, 0.0016970011638477445, 0.02719077467918396, 0.013893572613596916, 0.0421539731323719, -0.04639138653874397, 0.014696569181978703, -0.0001493667805334553, -0.04876154661178589, -0.0683421865105629, 0.008136487565934658, -0.05514925345778465, 0.040784213691949844, -0.048506833612918854, -0.024485649541020393, -0.027547599747776985, -0.024173108860850334, 0.05492977052927017, 0.019355202093720436, 0.029503002762794495, 0.001640409929677844, 0.06979454308748245, 0.01513501163572073, 0.042305488139390945, -0.007227649446576834, 0.01558715384453535, 0.13414625823497772, 0.04144357889890671, 0.051790617406368256, -0.01340139377862215, 0.004698902368545532, 0.01599576696753502, -0.026455316692590714, -0.002284788526594639, 0.0065937284380197525, 0.01905651018023491, -0.012612739577889442, 0.04760816693305969, 0.060159869492053986, -0.008806387893855572, -0.026773808524012566, 0.010333241894841194, -0.03495335206389427, -0.02930530346930027, -0.01418501976877451, 0.00514574721455574, -0.00048142520245164633, -0.0163114070892334, 0.028535880148410797, -0.04751759022474289, 0.011148391291499138, -0.01745946891605854, -0.02245025709271431, 0.0028062628116458654, -0.025201348587870598, 0.013315863907337189, -0.0075430781580507755, 0.03365748003125191, 0.05452585965394974, -0.021130314096808434, -0.045112524181604385, 0.002403138903900981, 0.01141171995550394, -0.0674721896648407, 0.01822354830801487, 0.02401147037744522, -0.023480204865336418, -0.028514767065644264, 0.014606697484850883, 0.018066348508000374, -0.02626955322921276, 0.005658494774252176, -0.03201484680175781, 0.03708812594413757, -0.008762028068304062, -0.019863186404109, -0.0493108406662941, -0.028594695031642914, 0.024829210713505745, 0.0018081790767610073, 0.000015099569282028824, 0.015502745285630226, 0.0378979928791523, -0.0753474310040474, -0.06509259343147278, -0.02588091790676117, -0.021969307214021683, -0.009610896930098534, 0.02061815746128559, 0.03317449986934662, -0.005156314000487328, -0.031584322452545166, -0.01021556556224823, 0.02298196218907833, 0.010200978256762028, 0.03864274173974991, 0.001008912455290556, -0.021517358720302582, -0.035410646349191666, -0.017651371657848358, -0.004899392835795879, 0.002122933277860284, 0.05135283246636391, 0.006400556769222021, -0.0012542246840894222, 0.01001275796443224, -0.03788510710000992, -0.005840005818754435, -0.03331027179956436, -0.007648741360753775, -0.026465989649295807, 0.03621192276477814, 0.04648647829890251, 0.03183620795607567, -0.006509366445243359, 0.0164863932877779, 0.055627577006816864, 0.06806772947311401, 0.006383998319506645, -0.05318709462881088, 0.015782430768013, 0.003447861410677433, -0.006050777155905962, 0.008473269641399384, -0.009407920762896538, 0.03516487032175064, 0.04781880974769592, 0.028178658336400986, 0.009644413366913795, 0.025739429518580437, 0.011172596365213394, 0.019997021183371544, 0.010147379711270332, -0.07037325203418732, 0.022367151454091072, 0.03721494972705841, 0.024446481838822365, -0.030424030497670174, -0.0650767907500267, -0.006387318950146437, -0.02091718651354313, 0.04734091833233833, -0.05455004796385765, -0.023731298744678497, -0.009826162829995155, 0.0000878803912200965, 0.004298894200474024, -0.003964514471590519, -0.025863129645586014, -0.011170685291290283, 0.009948880411684513, -0.008550518192350864, 0.02409137412905693, 0.007368460297584534, -0.03021390736103058, -0.014868744648993015, 0.022347982972860336, 0.03605203703045845, 0.03007027506828308, 0.03869516775012016, -0.019781719893217087, 0.014144309796392918, -0.010072009637951851, 0.028787989169359207, 0.03860823065042496, 0.006845251191407442, 0.03015095740556717, -0.07481718063354492, -0.06466919183731079, 0.0348539724946022, 0.0008077726233750582, 0.029057558625936508, 0.028009753674268723, 0.002403637859970331, -0.0294942744076252, -0.009414889849722385, -0.04895264655351639, -0.013936571776866913, -0.03194688260555267, -0.014762600883841515, 0.013805228285491467, -0.033416684716939926, -0.02309921756386757, 0.033257097005844116, -0.0032978253439068794, 0.02139684371650219, 0.04298840090632439, -0.03914869949221611, -0.018851827830076218, 0.029273809865117073, 0.01471964456140995, 0.017423082143068314, -0.010891291312873363, 0.01838052086532116, -0.006923575419932604, 0.036452461034059525, -0.036843191832304, 0.04170073941349983, -0.05592729523777962, -0.0014980781124904752, -0.06145371496677399, -0.04873250052332878, 0.011683162301778793, 0.030994949862360954, 0.03853490576148033, -0.030723750591278076, -0.028632953763008118, 0.040986478328704834, -0.03914501890540123, 0.06446995586156845, -0.018331360071897507, -0.016003111377358437, -0.05445460230112076, 0.0011371751315891743, -0.0023871688172221184, 0.04178805649280548, 0.011780614964663982, 0.013058653101325035, 0.0291160736232996, 0.04784721881151199, 0.030860770493745804, -0.03908715024590492, -0.0026273580733686686, 0.024300720542669296, 0.022962452843785286, -0.07724064588546753, 0.05179685354232788, 0.014545171521604061, -0.004299558699131012, 0.056021157652139664, 0.0001466487447032705, 0.010044240392744541, 0.002425292506814003, 0.016093410551548004, 0.0019217084627598524, 0.04124100133776665, 0.011066076345741749, 0.04042121022939682, -0.004816719330847263, 0.023216063156723976, 0.03214702382683754, 0.02389557473361492, -0.0292441975325346, 0.010194621048867702, 0.03400032967329025, -0.022887516766786575, -0.02137141488492489, 0.0061106011271476746, -0.014242753386497498, -0.006869564298540354, 0.006778230890631676, -0.022317035123705864, -0.03870781138539314, -0.012668504379689693, 0.006007158663123846, -0.03347957879304886, 0.007334630936384201, 0.01612318493425846, 0.01460069976747036, 0.027203941717743874, 0.0628395676612854, -0.003024214645847678, -0.02738054469227791, 0.02594810724258423, -0.01194757129997015, -0.005043033044785261, -0.05033467337489128, -0.03478216752409935, -0.015906352549791336, 0.01957954838871956, -0.006841697730123997, -0.021191664040088654, -0.048358120024204254, 0.022938156500458717, -0.013169622048735619, -0.007559013552963734, -0.03165777772665024, -0.0013956993352621794, -0.007098604924976826, -0.09547228366136551, 0.06695584952831268, 0.022699572145938873, -0.007203766610473394, -0.048625264316797256, -0.004547703079879284, -0.020943380892276764, 0.024932388216257095, 0.061712972819805145, 0.02909587323665619, -0.006337293423712254, -0.003203092608600855, -0.0035342262126505375, 0.011478332802653313, -0.0697103813290596, 0.038465846329927444, -0.008943096734583378, -0.008098680526018143, -0.010277623310685158, -0.0006414498784579337, 0.04653231054544449, -0.010607730597257614, 0.014564141631126404, -0.028659537434577942, 0.03761409595608711, 0.024817368015646935, -0.010858696885406971, 0.024225639179348946, -0.0017394283786416054, -0.016991671174764633, 0.019963247701525688, 0.022649193182587624, 0.007598820608109236, 0.020902147516608238, -0.022400790825486183, -0.060290660709142685, 0.01229941938072443, -0.029017208144068718, -0.027447210624814034, 0.010317248292267323, -0.002364129526540637, 0.017258651554584503, -0.05277654156088829, 0.034773580729961395, 0.05168449878692627, -0.04693027585744858, 0.012125604785978794, 0.03489169478416443, 0.017204049974679947, 0.004585553891956806, 0.006875536870211363, 0.02425878308713436, -0.0068740760907530785, -0.03563031926751137, 0.04183690622448921, 0.03565672039985657, -0.026530129835009575, -0.0021407785825431347, -0.010740906000137329, 0.018208064138889313, 0.0029247114434838295, 0.02805526740849018, 0.011555060744285583, 0.02125750295817852, -0.00971299223601818, -0.018236499279737473, 0.022406544536352158, -0.0242098867893219, -0.008643808774650097, -0.01276660617440939, -0.022092027589678764, 0.05096191167831421, -0.04528430476784706, 0.028745494782924652, -0.025141963735222816, -0.024095788598060608, -0.03975561633706093, -0.030379662290215492, -0.01600118726491928, 0.04984848573803902, -0.02024742029607296, 0.017352884635329247, 0.014050958678126335, -0.007031172979623079, 0.0009456053958274424, 0.028122102841734886, 0.04464065283536911, 0.004909541457891464, -0.039037227630615234, -0.03194122388958931, -0.04164501652121544, -0.006540307775139809, -0.028273923322558403, 0.04062043875455856, 0.00992483738809824, -0.019052591174840927, 0.0030471759382635355, 0.0011495667276903987, 0.02205090969800949, 0.06615270674228668, 0.0018013727385550737, -0.04748682305216789, -0.05238039046525955, 0.03825977072119713, 0.01650913432240486, -0.021484723314642906 ]
<p>In this <a href="http://tamino.wordpress.com/2013/04/06/sampling-rate/" rel="nofollow">blog article</a> an example is given of one can use the DFT to detect frequencies much higher than the sample rate. In the comments sections I asked how it was done, since DFT normally requires evenly sampled data. The author of the blog responded concisely with: </p> <blockquote> <p>One can still define the DFT as proportional to</p> <p>$$ X(\nu) = {1 \over N} \sum x_n e^{-i 2 \pi \nu t_n} $$ </p> </blockquote> <p>How would one do that? I am asking for advice to do exactly that. I can replicate the example if I use the data compensated method of Ferraz-Mello <a href="http://tamino.wordpress.com/2013/04/06/sampling-rate/" rel="nofollow">1</a> but the blog author says that normally DFT will work using that hint.</p> <p><a href="http://tamino.wordpress.com/2013/04/06/sampling-rate/" rel="nofollow">1</a> <a href="http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-iarticle_query?1981AJ.....86..619F&amp;data_type=PDF_HIGH&amp;whole_paper=YES&amp;type=PRINTER&amp;filetype=.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://articles.adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-iarticle_query?1981AJ.....86..619F&amp;data_type=PDF_HIGH&amp;whole_paper=YES&amp;type=PRINTER&amp;filetype=.pdf</a></p>
74,300
[ 0.01359106320887804, -0.03837158903479576, 0.04796641692519188, -0.02990718185901642, 0.01017903070896864, -0.007229797542095184, -0.029264625161886215, -0.002088262466713786, -0.0025270702317357063, -0.06137584149837494, 0.05261075124144554, 0.035159267485141754, 0.05456734076142311, 0.051016807556152344, 0.01467439066618681, -0.0063264151103794575, -0.03313970938324928, 0.016979636624455452, -0.01579461619257927, -0.049398019909858704, 0.005842170212417841, 0.05740782245993614, -0.006457940675318241, -0.012589612044394016, -0.032162562012672424, -0.01951124519109726, -0.0033700678031891584, -0.005763411987572908, 0.010899427346885204, 0.03697798028588295, -0.024862147867679596, -0.022929614409804344, 0.024314697831869125, 0.03576786071062088, 0.005048057995736599, 0.019258229061961174, -0.04168840870261192, -0.025007857009768486, 0.032650187611579895, 0.038023922592401505, -0.05087464675307274, -0.007803201675415039, 0.02208710089325905, 0.009501917287707329, -0.007032051216810942, 0.046927452087402344, 0.03788738697767258, -0.04880135506391525, 0.04432990774512291, -0.04783685877919197, 0.07104484736919403, -0.0019793924875557423, 0.029980074614286423, 0.03378647565841675, -0.02027069590985775, 0.012880312278866768, 0.04159747064113617, 0.06956769526004791, -0.03466639295220375, -0.020538607612252235, -0.03226650133728981, -0.020943697541952133, 0.0031345784664154053, -0.0005427799187600613, -0.02288924716413021, -0.010787722654640675, -0.025603212416172028, -0.03540681675076485, -0.004316413775086403, -0.012694627977907658, 0.0007656904053874314, 0.010690760798752308, 0.017167238518595695, 0.005413932725787163, 0.009217320010066032, -0.04565967991948128, 0.01588447391986847, 0.01015959121286869, 0.031898777931928635, 0.02574961446225643, -0.022407621145248413, 0.0036154640838503838, 0.01046975702047348, 0.049026764929294586, 0.03989254683256149, 0.010116218589246273, 0.036257773637771606, -0.03234752267599106, 0.03774961084127426, 0.02943360060453415, -0.013814046047627926, 0.02053428441286087, 0.058901555836200714, -0.05286584794521332, -0.03716994449496269, 0.007632740307599306, 0.01477279793471098, 0.019082369282841682, -0.04844619706273079, -0.05299826338887215, -0.010573947802186012, -0.035167500376701355, 0.031517144292593, 0.05909433960914612, -0.012885281816124916, 0.03004637360572815, -0.06850432604551315, 0.01968977227807045, -0.0039567165076732635, -0.020852461457252502, -0.039764054119586945, 0.026085317134857178, 0.0053315917029976845, 0.01751411333680153, -0.013307739049196243, 0.059141699224710464, 0.017258713021874428, -0.020839395001530647, 0.06411576271057129, 0.05866656079888344, 0.07026706635951996, -0.005178511608392, 0.03467654064297676, -0.054518699645996094, -0.0664188340306282, 0.02814430184662342, 0.023216359317302704, -0.006696064956486225, -0.03759779781103134, 0.035201653838157654, 0.01912463642656803, -0.00505829369649291, 0.03606455773115158, 0.02322928048670292, 0.01727484166622162, 0.012742303311824799, -0.08727508038282394, -0.02186872623860836, 0.04449688643217087, -0.017795369029045105, -0.003986573778092861, -0.09138517826795578, 0.0013565828558057547, 0.037006448954343796, 0.06167488172650337, 0.02167378179728985, 0.020283322781324387, -0.061151571571826935, 0.011915006674826145, 0.047797560691833496, -0.02481965906918049, -0.018365122377872467, -0.004100201651453972, -0.03268551826477051, -0.03011935018002987, -0.0030306035187095404, 0.007821034640073776, 0.023441627621650696, -0.014620608650147915, -0.009062613360583782, -0.0008335396414622664, 0.044501837342977524, -0.05602816119790077, -0.004469865467399359, 0.014342877082526684, -0.02025212161242962, 0.048085667192935944, 0.009401114657521248, 0.0024515658151358366, 0.006199056748300791, -0.008849860168993473, 0.054924607276916504, 0.012016264721751213, 0.01235965359956026, 0.04990183562040329, -0.06413085013628006, 0.00706965709105134, -0.04602731019258499, 0.0005052500637248158, -0.0032354258000850677, -0.006816088687628508, -0.029087990522384644, 0.023562535643577576, 0.03335568308830261, 0.02058149129152298, 0.01857931539416313, -0.033043455332517624, -0.006792638450860977, 0.024684293195605278, -0.061739448457956314, -0.030316825956106186, -0.04844336956739426, 0.00959694106131792, -0.00708397664129734, -0.06799211353063583, 0.05356525257229805, -0.014834192581474781, 0.023962462320923805, -0.003497262019664049, -0.048056330531835556, -0.0110080037266016, -0.007230523973703384, 0.056326914578676224, -0.0203915536403656, -0.004552200902253389, 0.06221408396959305, 0.01671811006963253, 0.002934408839792013, 0.037934646010398865, -0.03636986017227173, -0.02412736602127552, -0.0001545825507491827, -0.028600631281733513, -0.007031152490526438, -0.01676485501229763, -0.02375330589711666, 0.013108932413160801, -0.01774243451654911, -0.004639174323529005, 0.023777570575475693, -0.046528927981853485, 0.048393309116363525, 0.06273218244314194, 0.0023136716336011887, -0.003858687588945031, 0.03491491451859474, 0.046838682144880295, 0.02045898512005806, -0.002741272794082761, -0.05685341730713844, -0.054710183292627335, 0.013288531452417374, 0.018538951873779297, 0.036632832139730453, -0.040593791753053665, -0.002125996397808194, 0.06245115026831627, 0.009829827584326267, -0.009094422683119774, 0.031613789498806, -0.004268412943929434, -0.031905125826597214, -0.01019246969372034, 0.04270011559128761, -0.009249712340533733, -0.011104474775493145, 0.022969262674450874, 0.011861012317240238, 0.02442527376115322, 0.003433260368183255, 0.009387402795255184, 0.013693723827600479, -0.030541885644197464, 0.00340066384524107, 0.01583366096019745, 0.020442591980099678, -0.024222051724791527, -0.02894318662583828, 0.00007489198469556868, 0.03859211876988411, -0.057000067085027695, 0.016366934403777122, 0.026651738211512566, -0.03568105399608612, 0.017647864297032356, 0.0014659056905657053, -0.040714625269174576, -0.01661672256886959, 0.029417788609862328, -0.06052243709564209, -0.0030093167442828417, -0.002570884069427848, -0.014437174424529076, -0.004031859803944826, 0.010159646160900593, 0.03247387334704399, 0.04016202315688133, 0.013411969877779484, -0.04573921114206314, -0.01566479727625847, 0.016158701851963997, 0.019179850816726685, -0.0006917144637554884, 0.003602090524509549, -0.03598274290561676, -0.014958525076508522, -0.02572127990424633, -0.030458375811576843, -0.004514521919190884, 0.021817393600940704, 0.012502736411988735, -0.011347468942403793, -0.016518983989953995, -0.07998202741146088, 0.008773858658969402, 0.01404765248298645, -0.017503950744867325, -0.050201062113046646, -0.04987337067723274, 0.05092504620552063, 0.024704862385988235, 0.0009809054899960756, 0.028406325727701187, -0.0052084363996982574, -0.01609661802649498, 0.0008814995526336133, -0.006367613561451435, 0.02887769415974617, -0.003027684288099408, 0.041577260941267014, -0.015245143324136734, -0.003379729576408863, -0.00818687491118908, -0.07239021360874176, -0.04159679636359215, 0.029723022133111954, 0.037247318774461746, 0.049377769231796265, 0.02759561315178871, -0.011659171432256699, 0.061690762639045715, 0.03828083723783493, -0.00495901657268405, 0.009942134842276573, -0.024859067052602768, 0.009665360674262047, -0.045075755566358566, -0.0007339899311773479, 0.050726450979709625, -0.03185327723622322, 0.028946515172719955, -0.028971441090106964, -0.025876551866531372, 0.08693470060825348, 0.0008079412509687245, 0.008445083163678646, 0.028044184669852257, -0.0369158498942852, 0.01932128705084324, 0.050788141787052155, 0.0069646467454731464, -0.02246786840260029, -0.007273366674780846, 0.006055100355297327, 0.003163358196616173, 0.028880225494503975, -0.03041739948093891, -0.015378967858850956, 0.024589845910668373, -0.011005034670233727, -0.04165874421596527, 0.0010759922442957759, 0.045590147376060486, -0.04136566072702408, -0.019862372428178787, 0.03439459204673767, 0.05106807500123978, 0.014574025757610798, 0.001254448783583939, 0.06009000912308693, 0.022969936951994896, 0.009669812396168709, 0.0023811920545995235, -0.015878543257713318, -0.029055174440145493, 0.012637249194085598, -0.04147191718220711, -0.01960400678217411, 0.01691356673836708, 0.021492579951882362, 0.011565646156668663, -0.013258558697998524, -0.003992910962551832, 0.021563271060585976, -0.05130596086382866, -0.0010697821853682399, -0.040035590529441833, 0.061590731143951416, -0.0010923614026978612, 0.045700039714574814, 0.01448389794677496, -0.001963713439181447, -0.0004901228239759803, 0.006182272452861071, -0.06045249477028847, -0.006378051359206438, 0.012016220949590206, -0.02683350443840027, -0.010386711917817593, -0.044346973299980164, 0.019466279074549675, -0.00959707610309124, -0.01754041388630867, -0.00901880394667387, -0.008239544928073883, -0.032724857330322266, 0.027090981602668762, -0.011581707745790482, 0.019046343863010406, -0.0065487949177622795, 0.051186755299568176, 0.029200362041592598, -0.01982821896672249, -0.006126841064542532, 0.04856779798865318, -0.023903055116534233, -0.0003657359629869461, -0.028866739943623543, 0.008387892507016659, -0.032509658485651016, 0.057971566915512085, 0.00895911455154419, 0.019249092787504196, -0.05744311958551407, 0.002940758131444454, 0.020867154002189636, 0.08896112442016602, 0.03846549242734909, -0.056293487548828125, -0.01878134161233902, -0.02015606500208378, 0.002105611376464367, 0.02635698951780796, 0.06904836744070053, -0.019972441717982292, -0.0052561331540346146, 0.04851558804512024, 0.007372804451733828, -0.01617101952433586, 0.054643772542476654, 0.024803897365927696, -0.024788593873381615, 0.06005625054240227, -0.03157953917980194, -0.004181298427283764, 0.01946628838777542, -0.003701225621625781, 0.03011460043489933, 0.015732835978269577, 0.027192525565624237, -0.008241810835897923, 0.022836735472083092, 0.021382179111242294, -0.01029038242995739, -0.006753107067197561, 0.001099835499189794, 0.012625330127775669, -0.033853478729724884, -0.024651970714330673, 0.03337264433503151, 0.03637997806072235, 0.046968936920166016, 0.04416404291987419, -0.006921543274074793, -0.10706238448619843, -0.01785840094089508, 0.0014176154509186745, 0.03973524644970894, -0.005318695213645697, 0.05615425854921341, -0.05318816378712654, 0.016191182658076286, 0.02733525261282921, -0.0039184545166790485, 0.009726196527481079, -0.015468280762434006, -0.0006725287530571222, -0.039518147706985474, -0.009186848066747189, -0.02251862920820713, 0.01207720022648573, 0.0015804986469447613, -0.007173995487391949, -0.03699676692485809, -0.0553441196680069, -0.0346154049038887, 0.0056687030009925365, 0.008034800179302692, 0.05941154062747955, -0.014230990782380104, 0.00264395447447896, 0.02687046118080616, 0.044549230486154556, -0.04222921282052994, -0.04333752393722534, 0.022912556305527687, -0.03845948353409767, 0.015004211105406284, 0.023387214168906212, -0.03753982111811638, -0.0405365489423275, 0.06513498723506927, 0.0010640532709658146, -0.041289761662483215, -0.005312643479555845, -0.039110541343688965, 0.055166542530059814, 0.03307107836008072, 0.034095048904418945, 0.06550884991884232, 0.0317576639354229, 0.03365783020853996, 0.03294534981250763, 0.003647231264039874, 0.019462114199995995, -0.05889556556940079, -0.005669956561177969, -0.0531875379383564, 0.014404124580323696, -0.03385152295231819, 0.019110212102532387, 0.03602606803178787, 0.04302766174077988, 0.009299428202211857, -0.02251015603542328, 0.01944267749786377, -0.005308637395501137, -0.02295660227537155, 0.055207040160894394, 0.0052178665064275265, 0.045450493693351746, 0.008511560969054699, -0.011436318047344685, 0.003965220879763365, -0.034844763576984406, 0.00022035602887626737, 0.03365231305360794, -0.0017120868433266878, 0.02380659431219101, -0.07233777642250061, 0.010475670918822289, 0.015241147018969059, -0.008761770091950893, 0.04037739336490631, -0.0112898675724864, 0.046836815774440765, -0.01528079155832529, -0.020609084516763687, -0.005747956223785877, 0.0258957389742136, 0.012346997857093811, 0.02491898275911808, -0.013689454644918442, 0.005774601362645626, -0.007977931760251522, 0.027305174618959427, -0.06567221879959106, -0.008977042511105537, 0.047398895025253296, 0.042359475046396255, -0.03326112776994705, -0.05192706361413002, -0.014238434843719006, -0.02379087172448635, -0.005783725529909134, -0.013868404552340508, 0.041715770959854126, 0.000793368264567107, -0.06005347892642021, -0.014229247346520424, 0.003645587945356965, 0.09369071573019028, -0.07560358941555023, -0.020598702132701874, 0.019612181931734085, 0.0039778477512300014, -0.0005564094171859324, -0.03404907137155533, 0.018507981672883034, -0.040032945573329926, -0.0191399697214365, -0.021381637081503868, -0.016335587948560715, 0.014338838867843151, -0.027267038822174072, -0.011911465786397457, -0.00123576819896698, 0.0010874313302338123, -0.0047528683207929134, -0.013678212650120258, -0.008167913183569908, -0.028166411444544792, 0.030278421938419342, -0.008858692832291126, -0.011265456676483154, -0.00984337367117405, -0.03177282214164734, 0.02211020141839981, 0.030349427834153175, 0.003584983991459012, 0.032071154564619064, 0.07365968078374863, -0.020181836560368538, 0.00709656672552228, 0.013294477015733719, -0.01966649293899536, 0.04862726107239723, 0.007315360940992832, 0.02316966839134693, 0.0022604018449783325, -0.030315091833472252, -0.012938881292939186, -0.05326438322663307, -0.05519498139619827, 0.0042923567816615105, 0.03398220241069794, 0.023326732218265533, 0.03771926835179329, 0.028814027085900307, 0.011405895464122295, -0.008017406798899174, 0.015576672740280628, -0.04115942493081093, -0.04677411541342735, -0.03052404522895813, 0.014483392238616943, -0.02415291592478752, -0.013014578260481358, 0.0171821229159832, 0.02614451013505459, 0.037220247089862823, 0.038402773439884186, 0.028162304311990738, 0.05647287517786026, 0.029400955885648727, -0.0027367963921278715, -0.030721034854650497, 0.055878449231386185, -0.07758387178182602, 0.023891715332865715, 0.005012453533709049, -0.015773948282003403, 0.06109168753027916, 0.05212140455842018, 0.0027155978605151176, -0.056341953575611115, -0.027266984805464745, -0.06433358788490295, 0.01686573587357998, 0.03344385325908661, -0.018428584560751915, 0.05242287367582321, 0.0024620534386485815, 0.03432420641183853, -0.0027667111717164516, 0.010224435478448868, 0.0077791460789740086, -0.041376691311597824, -0.045181263238191605, -0.024567630141973495, -0.050206005573272705, 0.03532201424241066, 0.006433572620153427, -0.048948075622320175, 0.03562287241220474, 0.008003663271665573, 0.08347669243812561, 0.009234312921762466, 0.0039251334965229034, -0.0007043742807582021, 0.07312238961458206, 0.03618541359901428, 0.034221913665533066, -0.011598918586969376, 0.018364666029810905, 0.12677305936813354, 0.07039549201726913, 0.03463699296116829, -0.04649820178747177, 0.01844334974884987, -0.00045632990077137947, -0.009257656522095203, -0.03130583465099335, -0.012684003449976444, -0.017836354672908783, 0.0053184134885668755, 0.02903866209089756, 0.0472370870411396, -0.0024657228495925665, 0.02217356488108635, 0.023777369409799576, -0.030221423134207726, -0.012913500890135765, 0.045864660292863846, 0.04643315076828003, 0.005825790110975504, -0.011946547776460648, -0.0320642925798893, 0.005580106750130653, -0.00836484506726265, -0.01214455533772707, -0.054617393761873245, -0.041522614657878876, -0.015663309022784233, 0.011936379596590996, -0.03856288269162178, -0.0195168424397707, 0.023026859387755394, 0.024942297488451004, -0.005580517929047346, -0.029077306389808655, -0.0181658286601305, -0.01353884395211935, -0.029062045738101006, 0.022450529038906097, 0.025418061763048172, -0.0000010391307796453475, -0.0021100880112499, 0.028830887749791145, -0.004515384323894978, -0.0012336845975369215, -0.005593723151832819, 0.0016122738597914577, -0.027631057426333427, -0.02759556844830513, -0.01674601063132286, -0.018478116020560265, -0.004549759440124035, -0.037966325879096985, -0.016311191022396088, 0.035573769360780716, 0.011639457195997238, -0.007887476123869419, -0.03895800560712814, -0.00405961973592639, 0.016388345509767532, 0.02606184035539627, 0.008227979764342308, 0.023335091769695282, -0.04111403599381447, 0.021692100912332535, 0.018755456432700157, 0.04336542263627052, -0.004114541225135326, -0.011388689279556274, 0.002633399795740843, 0.026951944455504417, -0.04904313012957573, -0.024331066757440567, -0.010911191813647747, 0.01021363865584135, 0.02006703056395054, -0.01013476774096489, -0.0027788730803877115, -0.03759744018316269, -0.06675256788730621, 0.050332289189100266, 0.005622415337711573, 0.014825046993792057, -0.011731227859854698, -0.030603209510445595, -0.04438648000359535, 0.004634814336895943, 0.0002689404645934701, 0.029193202033638954, 0.0131450230255723, 0.05234804376959801, 0.03507992997765541, -0.012528227642178535, -0.015613687224686146, -0.025579439476132393, -0.004866945557296276, 0.04267687350511551, -0.003507552668452263, 0.05622395873069763, 0.01022588275372982, 0.009430337697267532, 0.0043402970768511295, 0.03030182607471943, -0.06986995786428452, -0.032522737979888916, -0.025840971618890762, -0.026968125253915787, -0.0032240531872957945, 0.029207739979028702, -0.008299660868942738, -0.05661443620920181, -0.019756101071834564, -0.009292875416576862, -0.020712748169898987, -0.03384537622332573, 0.014929637312889099, -0.0448862686753273, -0.015101720578968525, -0.04177304357290268, -0.03503742069005966, -0.009482184424996376, -0.017203981056809425, 0.0015008589252829552, 0.01534244604408741, -0.022915570065379143, 0.034915998578071594, 0.014535674825310707, -0.01806938275694847, -0.052826687693595886, 0.006341078784316778, 0.04133041575551033, -0.004505691584199667, -0.019450565800070763, 0.0027595795691013336, -0.004404126666486263, -0.005397644359618425, 0.012437987141311169, -0.02906457707285881, 0.0018540887394919991, 0.032053347676992416, -0.04914037510752678, -0.02893119677901268, 0.02961461804807186, 0.005124522838741541, -0.007475974969565868, -0.012279299087822437, -0.009300312958657742, -0.010055636055767536, 0.01696610450744629, -0.049449533224105835, -0.00145894312299788, 0.009612812660634518, 0.018538057804107666, -0.0011868743458762765, -0.022809170186519623, 0.021798912435770035, -0.04253799468278885, 0.0003245394618716091, 0.0441967137157917, 0.02014266885817051, -0.0007606434519402683, 0.01232536043971777, 0.01747666299343109, -0.02705073356628418, 0.01747909188270569, 0.0018901067087426782, 0.024326244369149208, 0.011488345451653004, 0.05190453678369522, -0.01794338971376419, -0.017446601763367653, -0.022476820275187492, -0.014140625484287739, -0.09934332221746445, -0.00801396369934082, 0.0344478003680706, 0.01443964522331953, 0.020314212888479233, -0.05872150883078575, -0.0345277413725853, 0.005085794720798731, -0.051087863743305206, 0.025472909212112427, -0.03980325162410736, 0.011594986543059349, -0.048910725861787796, 0.015787823125720024, -0.04665326327085495, -0.004662833176553249, 0.01866481639444828, 0.030807385221123695, 0.03376970812678337, 0.0064371805638074875, 0.004082737024873495, 0.001532240305095911, -0.002808779012411833, 0.007065818179398775, 0.011943274177610874, -0.06677771359682083, 0.0497296005487442, -0.0025693802163004875, -0.03536698967218399, 0.005263427272439003, -0.005267973057925701, 0.007095448672771454, -0.003482961095869541, 0.018149882555007935, 0.006780647672712803, 0.008806302212178707, 0.03501689061522484, -0.001543899648822844, -0.007598270662128925, -0.006396369077265263, 0.03244255483150482, 0.019259802997112274, -0.021801702678203583, 0.0009779657702893019, 0.03495616093277931, -0.003977687563747168, -0.017062976956367493, 0.04946340247988701, -0.017966659739613533, -0.021896542981266975, 0.04558997228741646, -0.008899010717868805, -0.00417265435680747, -0.04346926882863045, 0.05928439646959305, -0.030393121764063835, -0.0005532092181965709, -0.011741621419787407, 0.031615354120731354, -0.02359967865049839, 0.00018622633069753647, -0.03619357943534851, -0.05197804793715477, 0.013119303621351719, 0.036378126591444016, -0.0238368958234787, -0.04028131812810898, -0.0077638388611376286, 0.035487305372953415, -0.013119522482156754, -0.009034642949700356, -0.008150970563292503, -0.053697194904088974, 0.044336602091789246, -0.002110256813466549, -0.0004577225772663951, -0.024468572810292244, -0.029798684641718864, 0.015221009030938148, -0.08679984509944916, 0.006166528910398483, -0.0020931283943355083, 0.017290739342570305, -0.015111111104488373, -0.01086965948343277, 0.007773365825414658, 0.0014935460640117526, 0.048315756022930145, 0.0011365595273673534, -0.005558083765208721, 0.023506266996264458, -0.03862868994474411, 0.0182862039655447, -0.01544303447008133, 0.025753716006875038, -0.013628876768052578, -0.013908134773373604, 0.02948499284684658, -0.040855176746845245, -0.0287596695125103, 0.012148899026215076, 0.02380450814962387, 0.02472761459648609, 0.03910170868039131, 0.032784201204776764, -0.024957627058029175, 0.05266167223453522, 0.023432321846485138, 0.05390724167227745, 0.04261847585439682, -0.03145592287182808, 0.004793746862560511, 0.012024127878248692, 0.014952892437577248, -0.09934629499912262, 0.04480540752410889, -0.04569878429174423, -0.0551627017557621, -0.008108844980597496, 0.020832885056734085, 0.01293631549924612, -0.028649592772126198, -0.0064669097773730755, 0.025794990360736847, -0.02490335889160633, -0.008413588628172874, 0.006579067092388868, -0.038031525909900665, 0.014511753804981709, -0.010119376704096794, 0.01647488959133625, 0.0016149621224030852, -0.023381922394037247, -0.039055053144693375, -0.024005090817809105, 0.005693914368748665, -0.007910063490271568, 0.016360541805624962, 0.03600480407476425, 0.00841303076595068, -0.004024298395961523, 0.0294867604970932, 0.011732158251106739, -0.018086394295096397, -0.038593590259552, 0.01898346282541752, -0.007988742552697659, -0.018810125067830086, 0.03105304017663002, -0.006639695260673761, 0.08029944449663162, 0.0038021511863917112, 0.03208259865641594, -0.04509438946843147, -0.04704447463154793, -0.006196886766701937, 0.037324052304029465, 0.009374063462018967, 0.03389619290828705, -0.031146837398409843, -0.005559766199439764, -0.01848069578409195, -0.011187460273504257, 0.013589940965175629, -0.031536635011434555, 0.009398738853633404, -0.023528244346380234, -0.012976443395018578, 0.018886681646108627, -0.013675243593752384, -0.01372414082288742, 0.012086564674973488, 0.029450548812747, 0.011651439592242241, 0.03465397655963898, 0.0036977955605834723, -0.012009181082248688, 0.029126303270459175, 0.04516071453690529, -0.06282345205545425, -0.009997108019888401, -0.02738649956882, 0.0046692294999957085, 0.02514093741774559, 0.007189156953245401 ]
<p>I feel like every question I've asked on CrossValidated has lead back to looking at the number of observations I have per variable. I understand that there are many rules of thumb out there depending on your field, your expected effect size, etc. These come back to recognizing that too few observations can lead to overfitting.</p> <p>I understand how overfitting can be a problem when looking at a regression model with a single predictor. Having only two observations leads to a perfect answer, whereas using least squares to solve an overdetermined model leads to generalization. However, I have trouble making sense of how overfitting can still be a problem if you have 20 predictors and, say, 31 observations. It seems like you have mitigated the problem with 10 extra observations, but I suspect I am missing something in how least squares solves overdetermined systems.</p> <p>What I assume follows if it is true that a system is overfitted is that the relationships between predictors explained by the betas also do not hold.</p> <p>Finally, if overfitting is a problem by having not enough observations, can this be solved by using forward stepwise regression? Or is there a good possibility of missing significant predictors due to eventually reaching a point where there are too many predictors and not enough observations?</p> <p>To recap:</p> <ol> <li><p>Can someone explain why the case where the number of predictors is $N-1$ where $N$ is decently large (say, $N &gt; 10$) can still overfit? Why is it not that you need a minimum number of observations <strong>regardless</strong> of the number of predictors?</p></li> <li><p>Can overfitting be solved by using forward stepwise regression?</p></li> </ol>
37,123
[ -0.03294039145112038, 0.01471851859241724, 0.0064584300853312016, 0.015308605507016182, 0.06221150606870651, 0.00623334152624011, -0.012465093284845352, -0.0069926418364048, 0.048334453254938126, -0.03272877633571625, -0.007565152831375599, -0.007642729207873344, 0.050260499119758606, -0.011391491629183292, 0.0143336933106184, -0.0004922199295833707, -0.0031941563356667757, -0.015552792698144913, 0.0016155922785401344, 0.01810336485505104, -0.011438364163041115, 0.04699699953198433, 0.02674812264740467, -0.0231153666973114, -0.015135630965232849, 0.04992540553212166, 0.027544241398572922, -0.007563220802694559, 0.021780340000987053, 0.013278891332447529, 0.0327414833009243, -0.01520052645355463, 0.02183816023170948, 0.05068453401327133, 0.008402570150792599, -0.034114282578229904, 0.0006369241164065897, -0.016094530001282692, 0.02024216577410698, 0.02842741087079048, 0.005895022768527269, -0.03923419117927551, -0.02980872243642807, 0.04379229620099068, 0.021194348111748695, -0.00892393384128809, 0.0038746879436075687, -0.009527589194476604, 0.03182358294725418, -0.056848347187042236, 0.06319548934698105, -0.0012996337609365582, 0.03602549806237221, 0.043790511786937714, -0.017500637099146843, -0.018996525555849075, 0.08653392642736435, 0.09116336703300476, 0.029924750328063965, -0.03281644731760025, -0.03794160112738609, -0.01277395710349083, 0.019713232293725014, 0.006148705258965492, -0.02642441913485527, 0.017567630857229233, -0.013989620842039585, 0.004014044068753719, 0.011682000942528248, -0.026927711442112923, 0.025310326367616653, -0.009448054246604443, 0.031773556023836136, 0.02817351557314396, -0.005955031607300043, -0.012571090832352638, 0.011752053163945675, 0.015650250017642975, 0.06377982348203659, 0.031093059107661247, 0.012430321425199509, 0.01261105202138424, 0.03066207282245159, 0.03568341210484505, 0.03128083050251007, -0.006467342376708984, 0.06576570123434067, -0.026800081133842468, 0.022324273362755775, 0.0026693050749599934, -0.007000230718404055, 0.022207489237189293, 0.03318402171134949, 0.01731661893427372, -0.029430802911520004, 0.051104262471199036, -0.005922771990299225, 0.007254475727677345, 0.006720264907926321, -0.0018290819134563208, -0.016080528497695923, -0.039636388421058655, 0.023472769185900688, 0.04830530285835266, -0.014449195004999638, 0.003858452197164297, -0.024804744869470596, -0.00532929552718997, -0.011325991712510586, -0.03917138651013374, -0.009635773487389088, 0.04997488111257553, -0.0057585155591368675, 0.014919251203536987, -0.013280361890792847, -0.023546623066067696, 0.016558855772018433, -0.013016469776630402, 0.030878879129886627, 0.06485245376825333, 0.04367772117257118, -0.043147653341293335, 0.0007233910728245974, -0.006793334614485502, -0.048362452536821365, 0.001503610284999013, 0.019504329189658165, 0.008461706340312958, -0.029695702716708183, 0.021840067580342293, 0.0072652604430913925, -0.03979239612817764, 0.05337194725871086, 0.028048135340213776, 0.008149941451847553, 0.01923341676592827, -0.09937052428722382, -0.0648488849401474, 0.07415132224559784, -0.038586728274822235, 0.018914954736828804, -0.05319599434733391, -0.02248843014240265, 0.006122906226664782, 0.05747156962752342, -0.006347466725856066, 0.005219985265284777, 0.06924979388713837, 0.02973966673016548, 0.0035857982002198696, -0.018334180116653442, -0.007179152686148882, -0.04001292213797569, -0.00123170530423522, -0.02387414313852787, -0.06787609308958054, 0.03417803719639778, 0.002654315670952201, -0.006724427454173565, -0.01558134239166975, 0.03589670732617378, -0.005332526285201311, -0.021679218858480453, 0.0005671189865097404, 0.013832823373377323, -0.032214969396591187, 0.04282977432012558, 0.017970014363527298, 0.040476441383361816, 0.032274868339300156, -0.009297587908804417, 0.006207388825714588, 0.007903574034571648, 0.07216084003448486, 0.025124507024884224, 0.03679941967129707, -0.004674805328249931, -0.02611529268324375, -0.015652760863304138, 0.017267396673560143, -0.047418925911188126, -0.051664840430021286, -0.012611990794539452, -0.013171087019145489, 0.025822285562753677, 0.027612576261162758, -0.022225216031074524, 0.013902834616601467, 0.051305223256349564, -0.06387951225042343, -0.064959816634655, -0.05728662386536598, 0.024532604962587357, -0.006723411846905947, -0.006195873022079468, 0.01939963549375534, 0.004106342792510986, 0.014400488696992397, -0.019121412187814713, -0.025262078270316124, -0.02585987001657486, 0.04752248898148537, 0.06350391358137131, -0.05290486291050911, 0.030176570639014244, 0.049609143286943436, 0.045601628720760345, -0.03371991217136383, 0.05298067629337311, -0.0428171306848526, -0.07118438929319382, 0.017130691558122635, -0.029236767441034317, 0.004813222214579582, -0.03749828413128853, -0.043946076184511185, 0.013415491208434105, -0.02573605254292488, -0.025863906368613243, 0.07007485628128052, -0.06279557943344116, 0.05467091500759125, 0.059052713215351105, 0.004962075501680374, -0.02152874507009983, 0.019659368321299553, 0.018658347427845, 0.00008436800999334082, -0.05427619814872742, -0.00846889428794384, -0.04555891826748848, -0.0392301119863987, 0.030427101999521255, 0.03143886476755142, -0.02293975092470646, 0.023626746609807014, 0.024261141195893288, 0.019170649349689484, -0.013419833965599537, 0.018165210261940956, -0.019769199192523956, -0.025639962404966354, -0.014731387607753277, 0.021980084478855133, 0.014480586163699627, 0.004041275475174189, -0.00694334926083684, 0.028499245643615723, 0.002756566973403096, 0.0032047503627836704, 0.01458637323230505, 0.06267638504505157, 0.01685219816863537, 0.012271502986550331, -0.014482774771749973, -0.01696006953716278, 0.05393034964799881, -0.025324584916234016, 0.015808112919330597, 0.021725645288825035, 0.04244234412908554, 0.03984205424785614, -0.008241673931479454, 0.004245386924594641, 0.015581966377794743, 0.018990619108080864, -0.04650599882006645, 0.02746201492846012, 0.008309884928166866, -0.05360913276672363, 0.025623125955462456, -0.07371807098388672, -0.040069423615932465, -0.02587297558784485, 0.0010985733242705464, 0.019949059933423996, 0.003034708322957158, 0.027545414865016937, -0.03587492182850838, -0.012119481340050697, -0.020031623542308807, -0.0356861837208271, 0.047961246222257614, -0.006293708458542824, -0.043908387422561646, 0.005792874842882156, -0.03941688314080238, -0.008455452509224415, 0.03870243579149246, 0.008659642189741135, -0.025745343416929245, 0.01787925697863102, -0.018465913832187653, -0.06299450993537903, -0.07048576325178146, -0.039747025817632675, -0.006472819019109011, -0.00963270477950573, -0.05306438356637955, 0.03321187570691109, -0.016423022374510765, -0.03631488233804703, 0.015458681620657444, -0.004230870865285397, -0.0205749049782753, -0.012244985438883305, -0.003566982690244913, 0.020351290702819824, -0.017931971698999405, -0.001989535056054592, 0.011182078160345554, -0.02881510555744171, -0.0168552715331316, -0.04827847704291344, -0.06679585576057434, 0.004428018815815449, 0.010568303987383842, 0.04463387653231621, 0.008418412879109383, -0.017041295766830444, 0.050826575607061386, 0.013623654842376709, -0.01834622025489807, -0.045248739421367645, 0.03527580574154854, -0.022550487890839577, -0.047224946320056915, -0.0015848350012674928, 0.012351925484836102, 0.037569258362054825, 0.047276873141527176, -0.02328556589782238, 0.014477423392236233, 0.042643312364816666, -0.0032636169344186783, 0.006990901660174131, -0.008678518235683441, 0.016194036230444908, 0.01354107353836298, -0.006919787265360355, 0.019332263618707657, 0.007854994386434555, 0.030460665002465248, 0.005125435534864664, 0.013136180117726326, 0.036894507706165314, -0.03174624964594841, 0.030770381912589073, -0.020642947405576706, 0.020313626155257225, -0.017956214025616646, -0.005708782467991114, 0.01625317893922329, -0.0349520705640316, -0.01827782578766346, 0.028994370251893997, 0.06642947345972061, -0.04312978684902191, -0.03484461456537247, 0.031006135046482086, -0.012692300602793694, 0.003998192958533764, -0.013621988706290722, -0.039645660668611526, -0.014502998441457748, -0.023116232827305794, 0.021641293540596962, -0.0009280657977797091, 0.021232210099697113, 0.05465415492653847, -0.004253803286701441, 0.005655440501868725, -0.05922504886984825, 0.004816120490431786, -0.0631108209490776, -0.014709199778735638, -0.04152783006429672, 0.04598916321992874, 0.010437138378620148, 0.018732825294137, -0.03681957721710205, -0.036888349801301956, -0.00006622786895604804, 0.02868514321744442, -0.06423173099756241, 0.026484614238142967, -0.019188037142157555, 0.03549807518720627, -0.010254157707095146, -0.026104465126991272, 0.051623910665512085, -0.005425487644970417, 0.0006085238419473171, -0.012926393188536167, 0.03365287557244301, -0.01458573155105114, 0.010300879366695881, -0.04791257157921791, -0.012487484142184258, -0.011189701966941357, 0.016594234853982925, -0.009116707369685173, -0.030552851036190987, 0.020141540095210075, 0.05378764867782593, -0.008347316645085812, -0.03128667548298836, -0.05671095475554466, 0.02434391900897026, -0.01808108761906624, 0.022303931415081024, 0.01889164000749588, 0.009656320326030254, -0.04495460167527199, 0.023055559024214745, 0.001980878645554185, 0.032174285501241684, 0.0673128291964531, 0.025249285623431206, -0.0365336649119854, -0.018053412437438965, -0.022070731967687607, 0.0280085988342762, 0.006041797809302807, 0.010404739528894424, 0.017086654901504517, 0.08889938145875931, -0.0038168919272720814, -0.03136171028017998, 0.013853388838469982, 0.06288716942071915, 0.02656724490225315, -0.0011728961253538728, -0.021474620327353477, -0.0057439678348600864, 0.014314319007098675, 0.02308352291584015, 0.02698575146496296, -0.016206087544560432, -0.00243677687831223, -0.005450957454741001, 0.0525473989546299, -0.046699222177267075, -0.02464025467634201, -0.0008110437775030732, 0.004112155642360449, 0.06674866378307343, -0.003119627246633172, -0.04084207862615585, 0.007404892239719629, 0.03132160007953644, 0.053622037172317505, 0.021390674635767937, -0.0075168185867369175, -0.09881217777729034, -0.00397613737732172, 0.025640252977609634, 0.04201209172606468, -0.03870151564478874, 0.0072113266214728355, -0.025166934356093407, -0.002106839558109641, 0.03236480429768562, -0.05136684328317642, -0.003649774007499218, -0.01261448860168457, 0.004143055994063616, -0.03433912992477417, -0.046589963138103485, -0.043658867478370667, 0.015003266744315624, 0.004368390887975693, 0.07741998136043549, -0.007102672941982746, 0.010718170553445816, -0.004998223390430212, 0.01317993737757206, 0.02368982881307602, 0.05230117589235306, -0.031757306307554245, -0.02129679173231125, 0.007186755537986755, 0.015601648017764091, -0.007230827584862709, -0.058944061398506165, -0.004449812229722738, 0.006826841738075018, -0.030536018311977386, 0.0381152518093586, -0.00846853107213974, -0.07299117743968964, 0.004309604410082102, 0.018604926764965057, -0.02756340056657791, -0.021977169439196587, -0.029865290969610214, 0.03964116424322128, 0.01757153682410717, 0.02046244777739048, 0.06751780956983566, -0.011051168665289879, 0.005939688999205828, 0.033371590077877045, 0.0006947437068447471, 0.013002932071685791, -0.013220877386629581, -0.01952560804784298, -0.01800731010735035, -0.025235438719391823, -0.02762901969254017, 0.02660631202161312, -0.007917530834674835, 0.006218498572707176, -0.003760552266612649, -0.04967546463012695, 0.000982767902314663, 0.03436611220240593, -0.0059922863729298115, 0.027195395901799202, 0.010475547052919865, 0.03057452104985714, 0.0026685779448598623, -0.00993857067078352, 0.012488055974245071, -0.0035083324182778597, 0.024837594479322433, 0.048292823135852814, -0.04075075685977936, -0.010973871685564518, -0.02662615291774273, 0.004587117116898298, 0.015413760207593441, -0.024668721482157707, 0.057269420474767685, 0.010863471776247025, 0.024277325719594955, -0.019185122102499008, -0.0254562608897686, 0.004778399132192135, 0.02028401382267475, -0.001250922097824514, 0.02797435224056244, -0.033961646258831024, 0.007776809856295586, -0.009053288958966732, 0.01982017233967781, -0.057404860854148865, -0.027498474344611168, 0.012862566858530045, 0.01307705882936716, -0.00850791297852993, -0.011378059163689613, 0.0009783287532627583, -0.027574991807341576, -0.043423958122730255, -0.03046305477619171, 0.02466047741472721, -0.021699467673897743, -0.018252147361636162, -0.0017538836691528559, 0.015128983184695244, 0.04934484884142876, -0.019830554723739624, -0.00205690274015069, 0.030281629413366318, -0.0018036867259070277, -0.01798969879746437, 0.009588000364601612, 0.00022794985852669924, -0.03176858276128769, -0.025232039391994476, -0.05094258487224579, -0.005700679030269384, 0.025049850344657898, -0.023141182959079742, 0.005386540666222572, 0.011397415772080421, -0.019027581438422203, -0.015385023318231106, -0.006429250352084637, 0.015028268098831177, 0.0025839663576334715, 0.03799726441502571, 0.002851315774023533, 0.02541934698820114, -0.011898563243448734, -0.031085330992937088, 0.013451828621327877, 0.01410756167024374, 0.0077446745708584785, 0.007766378112137318, 0.05722244828939438, -0.012749082408845425, 0.02523624151945114, -0.01378551870584488, -0.0218772292137146, 0.07119372487068176, 0.045710884034633636, 0.0144524946808815, 0.0009976591682061553, 0.055577196180820465, -0.02899208664894104, -0.07419998943805695, -0.03287649154663086, 0.027946773916482925, 0.04530065506696701, -0.035588089376688004, -0.020669950172305107, 0.0278294887393713, -0.013677330687642097, 0.0013793931575492024, -0.035070277750492096, -0.010869319550693035, 0.020647279918193817, 0.02640511468052864, 0.03189213573932648, 0.01784437894821167, -0.015080214478075504, 0.012715877033770084, 0.027498722076416016, 0.04476259648799896, 0.0225143413990736, 0.02532545104622841, 0.03200423717498779, -0.014039373025298119, -0.07726853340864182, -0.0642247200012207, 0.034122928977012634, -0.043058402836322784, -0.0187250766903162, -0.023588772863149643, -0.02276013232767582, 0.06215523183345795, 0.044677164405584335, 0.04231124371290207, -0.043793097138404846, -0.035156264901161194, -0.041302528232336044, -0.004790768027305603, 0.026997560635209084, 0.0034947406966239214, 0.01905772276222706, -0.022139227017760277, 0.00952177681028843, 0.025284746661782265, 0.036469146609306335, -0.05646028742194176, -0.0949070081114769, -0.038032352924346924, -0.009463170543313026, -0.04277297109365463, 0.03060406632721424, 0.014268744736909866, -0.061375170946121216, 0.01633758656680584, -0.03179974481463432, 0.026634149253368378, -0.006945685017853975, 0.034069083631038666, -0.02239225246012211, 0.0343838594853878, -0.0007813723059371114, -0.003157372120767832, 0.024340854957699776, 0.0025624411646276712, 0.12223920226097107, 0.11758661270141602, 0.014830855652689934, -0.04122680798172951, -0.0008268089732155204, -0.010765187442302704, -0.003257105126976967, -0.005398131906986237, 0.018477221950888634, 0.001031578634865582, 0.009118730202317238, -0.012727614492177963, 0.04281081631779671, 0.020698033273220062, -0.010767709463834763, 0.050475578755140305, -0.05504831299185753, -0.006937126629054546, 0.02590658888220787, 0.01038450002670288, 0.01851660944521427, -0.03776250779628754, -0.009106839075684547, 0.0017834516474977136, -0.008039050735533237, -0.004497457295656204, -0.01840467005968094, 0.00422668969258666, -0.009246093221008778, -0.0067425318993628025, 0.000882072898093611, -0.002805695403367281, -0.014472464099526405, -0.005279231816530228, -0.03231406211853027, 0.02459893189370632, 0.017257822677493095, -0.019575119018554688, 0.015769803896546364, 0.021448664367198944, -0.01586628518998623, 0.01722104474902153, 0.01829512044787407, -0.005447920877486467, -0.0448710173368454, -0.021602118387818336, -0.031212713569402695, 0.06586024165153503, 0.00022550413268618286, -0.01979130506515503, -0.003416005289182067, -0.00995028205215931, 0.007841444574296474, -0.016001082956790924, -0.012246388010680676, 0.05772601440548897, 0.04485606402158737, -0.02087738737463951, -0.045706845819950104, -0.03206677362322807, 0.010288137942552567, 0.011208840645849705, 0.027267424389719963, 0.027050618082284927, -0.03493425250053406, -0.008446893654763699, 0.0025913850404322147, 0.03522604703903198, 0.04578831046819687, 0.027405112981796265, -0.010674170218408108, 0.016667352989315987, -0.01693718321621418, -0.006456558592617512, 0.03397367522120476, 0.012729073874652386, 0.025524530559778214, -0.015158252790570259, -0.011552667245268822, -0.06456658244132996, -0.04809918627142906, -0.010236911475658417, -0.022683585062623024, -0.026293672621250153, -0.0436130054295063, 0.008616788312792778, -0.026190059259533882, 0.03484898433089256, 0.010552525520324707, 0.012520106509327888, -0.02175995707511902, 0.03737383708357811, -0.014275411143898964, -0.037786051630973816, 0.003871308406814933, -0.022189656272530556, -0.02802811749279499, 0.02439851686358452, -0.019481467083096504, 0.06919556856155396, 0.017862576991319656, 0.05794083699584007, -0.010549000464379787, 0.06490068137645721, -0.020440150052309036, -0.0014041891554370522, 0.016548946499824524, -0.0771128311753273, 0.014705118723213673, -0.0007707919576205313, 0.019620433449745178, -0.037927255034446716, -0.053763315081596375, -0.035349369049072266, -0.02732231467962265, 0.03752516210079193, -0.00850237999111414, -0.06416057795286179, 0.0319683812558651, -0.010247547179460526, 0.03143024072051048, -0.042307715862989426, -0.00768227968364954, -0.02586107887327671, 0.009837083518505096, 0.003167111426591873, -0.04854864999651909, 0.018876420333981514, 0.02242894656956196, -0.011866211891174316, -0.04370281845331192, 0.02666923962533474, 0.0161184873431921, 0.01048581674695015, 0.013944145292043686, -0.009105043485760689, -0.025871701538562775, 0.02116270177066326, -0.05383080989122391, -0.01988164708018303, 0.006103933323174715, -0.02036912925541401, -0.015905579552054405, 0.03380145877599716, -0.009792743250727654, 0.06329747289419174, 0.03413718193769455, 0.003992740530520678, -0.04958043619990349, 0.0221078023314476, -0.004361835774034262, 0.005999091546982527, 0.0404803566634655, 0.03702900931239128, 0.0005917273228988051, 5.457227416627575e-7, 0.02112407423555851, -0.003695093095302582, 0.011184538714587688, 0.003491875948384404, 0.032857488840818405, 0.029053865000605583, -0.02478933148086071, 0.01200939156115055, 0.0035914741456508636, 0.024337787181138992, -0.010037249885499477, 0.02055339701473713, -0.011268965899944305, 0.04040660709142685, -0.04493286833167076, 0.030109314247965813, 0.005376868415623903, 0.038064707070589066, -0.11539990454912186, -0.017760222777724266, 0.0058010900393128395, 0.031287454068660736, 0.030686838552355766, -0.030242661014199257, 0.027613740414381027, 0.015401707030832767, -0.06914403289556503, 0.0019792895764112473, -0.032577987760305405, 0.02957656793296337, -0.026426151394844055, -0.011794641613960266, -0.0423344150185585, 0.005205279681831598, 0.04120783880352974, 0.014804058708250523, 0.017505787312984467, 0.025696396827697754, 0.0039285472594201565, -0.07585055381059647, -0.012353376485407352, 0.01680476777255535, -0.00025086113600991666, -0.06295820325613022, 0.02406693808734417, -0.023112745955586433, -0.050159040838479996, 0.019939055666327477, -0.011427581310272217, 0.015175377950072289, 0.023227522149682045, 0.018462399020791054, -0.009923304431140423, 0.06040311977267265, 0.007100393064320087, 0.0025492049753665924, 0.0013498638290911913, 0.018588785082101822, -0.008701471611857414, -0.008765055797994137, -0.015442246571183205, 0.017032785341143608, 0.0339621901512146, 0.013111519627273083, -0.017385417595505714, 0.006558709777891636, -0.022029289975762367, 0.0025404184125363827, 0.02567751705646515, 0.009858602657914162, -0.020070457831025124, -0.03447466716170311, 0.0027523899916559458, -0.006081383675336838, -0.01604665070772171, 0.03141066059470177, 0.03736536204814911, -0.015076732262969017, -0.006591431796550751, -0.026544800028204918, -0.0421406589448452, -0.016063854098320007, -0.007737073581665754, 0.024780714884400368, -0.09155461937189102, 0.029074758291244507, 0.03323359042406082, -0.03218545764684677, -0.036723390221595764, 0.0026054694317281246, -0.06515110284090042, 0.07049266993999481, -0.00721557205542922, 0.03450198471546173, 0.014697159640491009, -0.08522973954677582, 0.002151994965970516, -0.08724138140678406, 0.06386853009462357, -0.018932517617940903, -0.0036003023851662874, -0.01133815199136734, -0.0015237134648486972, -0.02396460436284542, -0.026715973392128944, 0.06729517132043839, 0.0056670550256967545, 0.03479587286710739, -0.008438601158559322, 0.057445988059043884, -0.033383674919605255, -0.027058573439717293, 0.027598271146416664, -0.017150050029158592, 0.0026600828859955072, -0.04312936216592789, -0.02510126680135727, -0.003884275443851948, -0.014396882615983486, 0.0336669459939003, -0.018040237948298454, 0.0003780083789024502, 0.010383551008999348, 0.016626808792352676, 0.04278203472495079, 0.003324778052046895, 0.018916446715593338, 0.027809804305434227, 0.00012768663873430341, 0.04056496173143387, 0.030443435534834862, -0.00826509203761816, -0.058703742921352386, 0.008907326497137547, -0.018969397991895676, 0.008127420209348202, -0.023754017427563667, -0.0054187593050301075, -0.018491221591830254, -0.03566378727555275, -0.0001186898080050014, 0.035558465868234634, -0.01681511662900448, 0.002041606232523918, 0.03365189582109451, 0.04416269809007645, 0.018182853236794472, -0.009115125983953476, 0.0048231990076601505, 0.051809556782245636, -0.0017507816664874554, -0.010592537932097912, 0.015065460465848446, 0.036096323281526566, 0.004732199944555759, -0.007974696345627308, 0.03527815267443657, 0.012208526954054832, 0.03470825403928757, 0.018089987337589264, 0.052796293050050735, -0.023414388298988342, -0.020231101661920547, -0.0026723810005933046, -0.004771899897605181, 0.013950859196484089, -0.03380706533789635, -0.02848670445382595, 0.05231599137187004, -0.03826088085770607, -0.024447880685329437, -0.04241659492254257, -0.027310799807310104, 0.007734895683825016, -0.011013398878276348, -0.03407103940844536, 0.04467276111245155, 0.018253298476338387, 0.01940733753144741, -0.03035663068294525, 0.005108288023620844, 0.038237545639276505, -0.00804512295871973, 0.00872197188436985, -0.016571296378970146, -0.007962475530803204, -0.009098499082028866, -0.013370025902986526, -0.013075148686766624, -0.008604921400547028, 0.03414208069443703, 0.04735079035162926, 0.004575752653181553, -0.02434610389173031, -0.04442574083805084, -0.010979226790368557, 0.040808483958244324, -0.053606629371643066, 0.00828035268932581, -0.03468872979283333, 0.009792794473469257, -0.006510816980153322, -0.020225437358021736 ]
<h1>Problem</h1> <p>I want to estimate the probability of a user choosing a car or transit as a transport mode. Following is the output of the simple logistic regression:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/9qQZC.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I want to estimate the probability of choosing car (auto) if INVT for auto = 3, INVT for transit = 7, OVT for auto = 1, OVT for transit = 2.5, OPC for auto =2 and transit fare = 3.</p> <h1>What I tried</h1> <p>For the probability of choosing car when the user owns a car and work in suburbs, I am using INVT for auto, OVT for auto, OPC for auto and transit fare along with AO as 1 and DW as 0.</p> <blockquote> <p>The probability = Pr = exp(1.45 - (0.00897*3) -(0.0308*1) - (0.0115*2) -(0.00708*3) +(0.77 * 1) - (0.561*0))/(1+exp(1.45 - (0.00897*3) -(0.0308*1) - (0.0115*2) -(0.00708*3) +(0.77 * 1) - (0.561*0)))</p> <p>Pr = 0.893</p> </blockquote> <h1>Question</h1> <p>Is this the right approach to find this probability? Or should I also include the INVT, OVT and OPC for transit as well?</p>
74,301
[ -0.022399231791496277, -0.024736076593399048, 0.01690109446644783, 0.026976287364959717, 0.04627913609147072, 0.00947557296603918, -0.016432179138064384, -0.03536234796047211, 0.05371846631169319, -0.02626921609044075, 0.014173201285302639, 0.04359343275427818, 0.03957778587937355, 0.02140413410961628, 0.018433580175042152, 0.028547389432787895, 0.014302137307822704, -0.00013253616634756327, 0.016629554331302643, -0.023189980536699295, -0.03190525248646736, -0.0028949796687811613, 0.02724975347518921, -0.02176840230822563, -0.024118803441524506, 0.044267069548368454, 0.013476347550749779, -0.021234601736068726, -0.004552438855171204, 0.03122657909989357, 0.01609225384891033, -0.004850911442190409, -0.006568917538970709, 0.04424675926566124, 0.03306226059794426, 0.06294230371713638, -0.007948320358991623, -0.026272596791386604, -0.008710038848221302, -0.04380105808377266, 0.002040778286755085, -0.017018169164657593, 0.022897103801369667, -0.0016845909412950277, 0.00630664499476552, 0.029367072507739067, -0.016872625797986984, -0.018208345398306847, 0.008517258800566196, -0.04055623710155487, 0.042773209512233734, -0.015381422825157642, 0.011428803205490112, 0.002375734271481633, 0.008852025493979454, -0.007959164679050446, 0.06372644007205963, 0.07873088866472244, -0.010297100991010666, -0.026421094313263893, -0.017559148371219635, 0.0015497301938012242, -0.025951674208045006, -0.010647933930158615, -0.036695193499326706, 0.028484493494033813, -0.011600429192185402, -0.010807265527546406, 0.06090934947133064, -0.0010540197836235166, 0.02152232825756073, -0.021965276449918747, 0.004570662975311279, -0.005711812525987625, 0.033480625599622726, -0.004829532466828823, -0.004365847446024418, 0.025514254346489906, 0.052157118916511536, -0.012174820527434349, 0.04013523831963539, 0.01733401231467724, 0.005605673883110285, 0.04673777148127556, 0.024959605187177658, -0.04196798428893089, 0.06009313464164734, -0.029313545674085617, -0.015532397665083408, -0.009651816450059414, -0.002558586886152625, -0.001907089608721435, 0.06839802116155624, 0.008006494492292404, -0.018565375357866287, 0.058802150189876556, -0.022247591987252235, 0.011031568050384521, 0.004888469818979502, -0.009946687147021294, -0.033559031784534454, -0.03145046532154083, 0.014950890094041824, 0.027574557811021805, -0.008193902671337128, -0.03849484771490097, -0.017815206199884415, -0.03512926772236824, -0.005646868608891964, -0.04100700095295906, -0.029446052387356758, 0.025633279234170914, -0.0024707792326807976, 0.0011472475016489625, -0.003853904316201806, -0.012148295529186726, -0.024248449131846428, -0.03296293318271637, 0.04312538355588913, 0.060066141188144684, 0.037050340324640274, -0.04403720423579216, -0.022437095642089844, -0.05032853037118912, -0.04499935358762741, -0.011950310319662094, -0.006720797158777714, 0.012417197227478027, -0.016153819859027863, 0.03995765373110771, 0.010104663670063019, -0.041524842381477356, 0.006641455926001072, 0.009735863655805588, 0.008681261911988258, 0.02497778832912445, -0.037348851561546326, -0.04506460949778557, -0.016806351020932198, -0.003601694479584694, 0.05321037396788597, 0.024477621540427208, 0.00252470001578331, 0.017561519518494606, 0.03540440648794174, 0.00009699985821498558, 0.07209661602973938, 0.06626854091882706, 0.00014871053281240165, -0.0055350386537611485, -0.061368752270936966, -0.005486068315804005, -0.03429994359612465, -0.03422491252422333, 0.010894404724240303, -0.10102462023496628, 0.048167478293180466, 0.04169869050383568, 0.026219313964247704, -0.024453086778521538, 0.05216577276587486, 0.007982374168932438, -0.04362378641963005, -0.0042317151091992855, 0.011750373058021069, -0.037223927676677704, 0.07644153386354446, 0.019466469064354897, 0.041629984974861145, -0.01616726629436016, 0.021229833364486694, 0.021878613159060478, 0.02304016426205635, 0.009779976680874825, 0.03420371189713478, -0.009026981890201569, -0.014621211215853691, -0.023828566074371338, -0.008593958802521229, 0.01726800948381424, -0.019921083003282547, -0.03516746312379837, -0.018535610288381577, -0.026749780401587486, 0.02186686545610428, 0.028021521866321564, 0.023281386122107506, -0.011025973595678806, 0.021755220368504524, -0.025891337543725967, -0.05258858576416969, -0.02973286248743534, 0.022988736629486084, -0.011121271178126335, -0.03329477459192276, -0.003582446603104472, -0.006742936559021473, 0.011731411330401897, -0.006475172005593777, 0.026675669476389885, -0.03379705175757408, 0.01077171228826046, 0.039400119334459305, -0.04353448748588562, 0.0007217609672807157, 0.051363348960876465, 0.03900608420372009, -0.017983144149184227, 0.025806572288274765, -0.03306347876787186, -0.021402545273303986, -0.014177017845213413, -0.005552211310714483, -0.011793355457484722, -0.020165875554084778, -0.029230110347270966, 0.010043811984360218, 0.01166471466422081, -0.04069964215159416, 0.055822137743234634, -0.09004233032464981, 0.07360076904296875, 0.07396530359983444, -0.03332095965743065, 0.02410677820444107, 0.026830721646547318, -0.03737097978591919, 0.010666920803487301, -0.0033209770917892456, -0.038429006934165955, -0.05072810500860214, -0.008443954400718212, 0.03901524096727371, 0.00249089696444571, -0.01594984158873558, 0.03643353283405304, 0.0681559145450592, -0.0038401924539357424, 0.030756454914808273, 0.0045102061703801155, -0.0004201287229079753, -0.0038318654987961054, 0.03851737454533577, 0.03143785521388054, 0.015327763743698597, -0.02160581201314926, 0.007847321219742298, 0.007268579211086035, -0.007147262804210186, -0.019928602501749992, -0.024746783077716827, 0.04150669276714325, 0.019062954932451248, -0.006928146816790104, -0.03025185689330101, 0.020143160596489906, 0.056650836020708084, -0.014662639237940311, 0.007559074088931084, 0.04544221982359886, 0.0225692056119442, 0.013110636733472347, 0.04284936189651489, -0.01959926262497902, 0.0018140533939003944, 0.06110154092311859, -0.04790599271655083, -0.01792387291789055, 0.014597747474908829, -0.045027442276477814, 0.026312634348869324, -0.023147400468587875, -0.0191187746822834, -0.01021018996834755, 0.018445372581481934, 0.046573396772146225, -0.008398096077144146, 0.034428250044584274, -0.01760045625269413, -0.014462248422205448, -0.00011555094533832744, 0.009978087618947029, -0.03825807571411133, 0.01353196520358324, -0.07818349450826645, 0.006684549152851105, -0.04070277512073517, -0.022754311561584473, 0.038323111832141876, 0.007712960708886385, -0.0110481483861804, 0.035433489829301834, 0.00009614336886443198, -0.043174564838409424, -0.02553495764732361, -0.046545352786779404, 0.0019568665884435177, -0.017401963472366333, -0.06230950728058815, 0.045281440019607544, -0.02154430001974106, -0.0320097841322422, 0.012118836864829063, -0.060213640332221985, -0.028360137715935707, -0.008432303555309772, -0.01836216077208519, 0.014594423584640026, -0.03269265219569206, 0.028282761573791504, 0.0034487303346395493, -0.021113254129886627, -0.006211331579834223, -0.13345180451869965, -0.08204196393489838, 0.013053644448518753, 0.011457491666078568, 0.02435300312936306, 0.016401875764131546, -0.010162551887333393, 0.02065747231245041, 0.06411002576351166, -0.03249190002679825, -0.051151059567928314, 0.001782589708454907, -0.034341372549533844, -0.0030851964838802814, -0.015315579250454903, 0.0420297235250473, -0.0059999460354447365, 0.041269924491643906, -0.008965795859694481, 0.009327161125838757, 0.04330572858452797, 0.0017264294438064098, -0.027335437014698982, 0.0043867724016308784, -0.022288085892796516, -0.011576937511563301, 0.046570852398872375, 0.04570582136511803, -0.009450763463973999, 0.028802109882235527, -0.03755179047584534, 0.010769308544695377, -0.014616318047046661, -0.041891973465681076, -0.003353490261361003, -0.021473079919815063, 0.008278331719338894, -0.04477144032716751, 0.01993039809167385, 0.022243395447731018, -0.0251254141330719, -0.012892436236143112, 0.010761138051748276, 0.03509558364748955, -0.010715607553720474, 0.0025493495631963015, 0.05721796676516533, 0.0344245582818985, 0.005791290197521448, -0.0427510030567646, -0.014723094180226326, -0.02307562716305256, -0.030035391449928284, -0.006785674951970577, -0.03339410945773125, 0.008471538312733173, 0.055115941911935806, 0.021619673818349838, -0.014595388434827328, -0.02410188689827919, 0.02022368647158146, -0.0630633756518364, 0.006464439909905195, -0.00853583961725235, 0.05329778417944908, 0.024605313315987587, 0.013140511699020863, 0.006130439229309559, -0.024133866652846336, 0.010243413969874382, 0.022202417254447937, -0.0700279250741005, 0.05717480927705765, 0.04426088556647301, -0.02830236591398716, -0.005503685213625431, -0.08010446280241013, 0.016752351075410843, -0.0799928680062294, -0.015639739111065865, 0.022266048938035965, 0.01562102697789669, -0.00698008481413126, 0.021719129756093025, 0.01306736096739769, 0.005931084044277668, -0.019632894545793533, -0.04594307765364647, 0.02316957898437977, 0.03794938325881958, 0.011447139084339142, 0.08045540004968643, 0.0054666404612362385, -0.010421776212751865, -0.03670049086213112, 0.01332397386431694, 0.0382627509534359, 0.06093287467956543, 0.019056029617786407, 0.037749674171209335, -0.027819450944662094, 0.01717458851635456, 0.01007825043052435, 0.0009677228517830372, 0.05130536109209061, -0.038525279611349106, -0.04397011175751686, -0.035451628267765045, -0.024159880355000496, 0.01616295613348484, -0.013203500770032406, -0.04235520586371422, 0.013522009365260601, 0.049602117389440536, 0.017242368310689926, -0.05309128016233444, -0.0074586751870810986, 0.08127409219741821, 0.000965855666436255, -0.018276391550898552, -0.0704960972070694, -0.02629895880818367, -0.0012978576123714447, -0.006927993148565292, 0.04193742200732231, 0.07555130869150162, -0.004232964478433132, -0.035493526607751846, 0.022553732618689537, 0.011506359092891216, -0.03981761261820793, 0.0033398382365703583, -0.010892822407186031, 0.011267252266407013, 0.02360478974878788, -0.06437281519174576, 0.02204006351530552, 0.052276771515607834, 0.0020578005351126194, 0.04820515960454941, -0.005947104189544916, -0.11736927926540375, 0.023830454796552658, 0.01346506830304861, 0.04305068403482437, -0.012222398072481155, -0.028379129245877266, -0.0344599224627018, 0.003883898491039872, 0.0028718647081404924, -0.049332037568092346, 0.032789330929517746, -0.023678939789533615, -0.013292263261973858, 0.01451982744038105, -0.023712465539574623, -0.05075059086084366, -0.0063438210636377335, -0.060493070632219315, 0.00436513451859355, -0.04075838625431061, 0.009554463438689709, -0.03240809217095375, 0.02748642861843109, -0.008034063503146172, 0.033189643174409866, -0.03188610076904297, -0.04875273257493973, 0.006181101314723492, 0.004715267568826675, -0.027470262721180916, -0.05144685134291649, -0.0006128674140200019, 0.007372803054749966, -0.01851518079638481, 0.031927820295095444, 0.0074779740534722805, -0.01596718654036522, 0.020034819841384888, 0.0021183378994464874, -0.0003426359035074711, -0.010818448849022388, -0.06380826979875565, 0.04257551208138466, 0.012876094318926334, -0.003764817491173744, 0.04861949011683464, 0.05212856084108353, -0.006548014935106039, 0.03277112543582916, -0.05380094796419144, -0.015317426063120365, 0.005646660458296537, -0.059979990124702454, -0.02961650863289833, 0.004400786478072405, 0.012049530632793903, 0.0013209331082180142, 0.02062704972922802, 0.029360027983784676, -0.017659906297922134, -0.006278974935412407, -0.00841450598090887, 0.006523567717522383, -0.012363656423985958, -0.00959372241050005, -0.031017696484923363, 0.007780729793012142, -0.0008003714610822499, 0.023394005373120308, -0.011614436283707619, -0.03478538617491722, 0.015547249466180801, -0.006794679909944534, -0.004342883359640837, 0.017024973407387733, -0.020356960594654083, -0.028184108436107635, 0.01685539074242115, -0.05065768212080002, 0.024951715022325516, 0.014872307889163494, 0.03794025629758835, 0.00844130665063858, -0.02070358581840992, -0.03927817940711975, 0.012131283059716225, 0.0389346182346344, 0.04286433011293411, -0.007017524912953377, 0.05483817309141159, -0.027024077251553535, -0.049763210117816925, -0.06372153759002686, -0.03119732439517975, 0.03479988873004913, -0.0038839690387248993, -0.04289143159985542, -0.006510630249977112, 0.014151672832667828, -0.022615984082221985, -0.03740376979112625, -0.03821595013141632, 0.04394908249378204, -0.03206360340118408, -0.00022061030904296786, -0.013974614441394806, 0.01178818754851818, 0.05854005739092827, -0.0007858286262489855, -0.007381001487374306, 0.03288481384515762, -0.025004196912050247, -0.02274244651198387, 0.027104608714580536, 0.007863379083573818, -0.02433175966143608, -0.03959079459309578, -0.01730669103562832, 0.02806784212589264, 0.04332549497485161, 0.015325876884162426, -0.02643936313688755, 0.023317227140069008, 0.010887586511671543, -0.006110274698585272, 0.006995710544288158, 0.010903493501245975, 0.0269289743155241, 0.008922203443944454, -0.008404241874814034, 0.03372173011302948, -0.019199511036276817, -0.0012927097268402576, 0.03914973512291908, -0.006406448315829039, -0.02445916272699833, 0.011898108758032322, 0.08205849677324295, 0.03153498098254204, 0.02926897630095482, -0.013161261565983295, -0.005252119153738022, 0.04374396428465843, -0.015105150640010834, -0.016941741108894348, 0.010301083326339722, 0.019915854558348656, -0.036758676171302795, 0.010358168743550777, -0.03013949654996395, 0.010754693299531937, 0.027849437668919563, -0.02436162158846855, 0.05263178423047066, 0.06872881948947906, 0.01900244876742363, 0.0019355586264282465, -0.04766819253563881, -0.03571818023920059, 0.01909084990620613, 0.019528266042470932, 0.045610446482896805, -0.010446841828525066, -0.017398776486516, 0.027382701635360718, -0.0017600652063265443, 0.035162098705768585, 0.020698996260762215, 0.003642928320914507, -0.0023846416734158993, 0.04167822375893593, 0.005634951405227184, -0.006015499588102102, -0.017001895233988762, -0.014267945662140846, 0.01582464389503002, -0.051968444138765335, -0.008021402172744274, 0.03841647505760193, 0.04714293032884598, -0.009457138366997242, -0.04522620514035225, 0.011747637763619423, -0.050925254821777344, 0.012102922424674034, -0.007272533141076565, -0.022812316194176674, 0.025188734754920006, 0.02934928424656391, 0.03580985963344574, -0.020356856286525726, 0.00639835000038147, -0.009478872641921043, -0.07175567746162415, -0.018577756360173225, -0.013632599264383316, -0.033603519201278687, 0.022923722863197327, 0.020175276324152946, -0.016876839101314545, 0.018359333276748657, -0.03882276639342308, -0.003873733803629875, 0.020802095532417297, 0.03205963969230652, 0.03213603422045708, 0.09507422894239426, -0.0020341873168945312, 0.012156889773905277, -0.0242906641215086, 0.018951913341879845, 0.13777193427085876, 0.07972757518291473, 0.052333980798721313, -0.046238671988248825, -0.016391083598136902, 0.025858750566840172, -0.02329063229262829, -0.03473640978336334, -0.0013266494497656822, 0.018611103296279907, -0.0005520322010852396, 0.03996477648615837, -0.007870888337492943, 0.004104163497686386, -0.033939775079488754, 0.027846314013004303, -0.0536816380918026, -0.03524162992835045, 0.04060240089893341, 0.009812106378376484, 0.03751646354794502, -0.03506691753864288, -0.03439721465110779, -0.0325574092566967, 0.013912016525864601, 0.017424670979380608, -0.006180057302117348, -0.05900902673602104, 0.02949625439941883, -0.011429098434746265, -0.021839704364538193, -0.010861334390938282, 0.05387907475233078, 0.027469763532280922, 0.02605067752301693, -0.014329638332128525, 0.009055454283952713, -0.055979710072278976, -0.023769432678818703, 0.009799379855394363, -0.01971358247101307, -0.02205425687134266, -0.0036613852716982365, 0.007080601528286934, -0.039453983306884766, 0.01575428992509842, -0.07590098679065704, 0.04199898988008499, -0.004611223470419645, 0.043673932552337646, -0.0261112991720438, 0.02334275282919407, 0.010226033627986908, -0.04797380045056343, -0.027721719816327095, -0.0054693096317350864, 0.016449930146336555, -0.0072233593091368675, -0.03610547259449959, -0.04665509983897209, -0.019325926899909973, 0.013001900166273117, 0.012149152345955372, 0.026902174577116966, -0.031544290482997894, -0.030389657244086266, -0.029036806896328926, 0.051382165402173996, -0.00950734131038189, 0.028451697900891304, 0.01746606081724167, -0.03601469844579697, -0.054279085248708725, -0.00440578069537878, 0.005344666074961424, -0.007831985130906105, 0.0007692485232837498, -0.007021291181445122, 0.006542631424963474, -0.016679538413882256, -0.025079743936657906, -0.025602998211979866, -0.014806434512138367, 0.03172789886593819, -0.03692664951086044, 0.04571610316634178, 0.01068172138184309, 0.011790291406214237, 0.01488856878131628, 0.031015638262033463, 0.024641895666718483, 0.037728823721408844, -0.008183500729501247, -0.03161510452628136, 0.008319626562297344, -0.00790678896009922, -0.04048650711774826, 0.0077478038147091866, -0.016516244038939476, 0.06658662110567093, -0.013909718953073025, 0.03096325881779194, -0.025379454717040062, 0.023956164717674255, -0.0013229456963017583, 0.008197495713829994, -0.009970513172447681, -0.025278620421886444, -0.011830545961856842, -0.009566674008965492, 0.012822636403143406, -0.030514994636178017, 0.007250071968883276, -0.005476485937833786, -0.06166131794452667, 0.009033051319420338, -0.03444565832614899, -0.06352481991052628, 0.019740082323551178, -0.021722840145230293, 0.019659604877233505, 0.021672794595360756, -0.0003048722574021667, -0.0017199345165863633, 0.023614782840013504, -0.04392702132463455, -0.03258903697133064, -0.000046377906983252615, 0.037481267005205154, 0.0326935239136219, 0.012349775992333889, 0.02736264280974865, 0.05258272588253021, 0.021211620420217514, -0.002359757898375392, 0.033570948988199234, 0.006727578118443489, 0.05611412599682808, -0.034373939037323, 0.010124141350388527, 0.028387412428855896, -0.0132127171382308, -0.014782003127038479, 0.01662098988890648, 0.0015898843994364142, 0.03468377888202667, 0.011501103639602661, -0.004979942925274372, 0.036101192235946655, 0.04272346571087837, -0.039712708443403244, -0.015861544758081436, -0.004744513891637325, -0.00488403020426631, 0.019474409520626068, -0.031847111880779266, 0.006695098243653774, 0.02106514573097229, -0.02819935418665409, 0.025985706597566605, 0.03990892693400383, -0.013354535214602947, 0.03620470315217972, 0.00841558538377285, -0.0137185612693429, -0.02538284659385681, 0.007120311260223389, -0.03163803368806839, 0.017844272777438164, 0.03444334864616394, 0.005867949221283197, 0.0245117899030447, 0.005588514730334282, 0.008772483095526695, -0.07284101098775864, -0.03960854187607765, 0.056077588349580765, 0.009633657522499561, 0.05152609199285507, -0.055476561188697815, 0.027120735496282578, 0.04142354056239128, 0.0010593030601739883, 0.011209038086235523, 0.02991453744471073, -0.018123606219887733, -0.03702337294816971, -0.001572763780131936, -0.01725095696747303, 0.0020624769385904074, 0.022847594693303108, 0.00006628881237702444, 0.05355869606137276, 0.0020477580837905407, 0.005973948631435633, -0.019302545115351677, -0.010658076964318752, 0.04496331512928009, 0.010877777822315693, -0.03616061434149742, 0.042366936802864075, -0.028315475210547447, -0.007697096094489098, 0.057467903941869736, -0.014968025498092175, -0.008161282166838646, 0.01725860685110092, 0.012819981202483177, 0.027241799980401993, 0.020313197746872902, 0.04790564253926277, 0.022903425619006157, -0.007647646591067314, -0.01982799917459488, 0.04997514188289642, 0.020622028037905693, -0.03664063662290573, 0.030022645369172096, -0.003959003370255232, 0.011339199729263783, -0.02312193252146244, 0.04352538287639618, -0.00007856617594370618, -0.006114047020673752, -0.02969948761165142, -0.028190653771162033, -0.01931159198284149, -0.03127438202500343, 0.009868858382105827, -0.05802089348435402, 0.009182443842291832, -0.004549959674477577, 0.004576366860419512, -0.024365749210119247, -0.04079265519976616, -0.039212048053741455, -0.0285934004932642, 0.008496028371155262, 0.007375017739832401, 0.012716461904346943, -0.026195000857114792, 0.016977833583950996, -0.0013181327376514673, -0.01820324920117855, 0.004926546476781368, -0.006025039590895176, -0.06861159950494766, 0.05754494667053223, -0.0032615982927381992, 0.01665739342570305, 0.059779901057481766, 0.019780779257416725, 0.027669450268149376, -0.11848855018615723, 0.04836712405085564, 0.03576873242855072, -0.01629077084362507, -0.0003545969375409186, -0.012949123978614807, -0.04359962418675423, 0.01717544160783291, 0.04571472108364105, -0.01313511747866869, -0.03455449268221855, -0.011532305739820004, 0.024673674255609512, 0.011674081906676292, -0.013939437456429005, 0.02611762471497059, -0.01694841869175434, -0.0373898483812809, -0.017545875161886215, 0.01928424835205078, 0.0030218923930078745, 0.0012321147369220853, 0.03737674653530121, -0.014923480339348316, 0.03220495581626892, 0.013471586629748344, -0.006722845137119293, -0.015589606948196888, 0.02073352038860321, -0.009318671189248562, 0.024798227474093437, -0.012239028699696064, 0.027110708877444267, 0.008447504602372646, -0.0084697799757123, -0.05199231579899788, 0.013798659667372704, -0.03158025071024895, -0.04192033410072327, 0.00005160284126759507, 0.010399725288152695, 0.026881571859121323, -0.02109106443822384, 0.006967653054744005, 0.035293374210596085, -0.03006872534751892, 0.010501000098884106, 0.006386077497154474, 0.0008640605956315994, 0.03960670530796051, -0.01007904950529337, 0.07696452736854553, 0.007427185773849487, -0.03256048634648323, 0.002112963004037738, -0.012044102884829044, 0.02359090931713581, 0.009471035562455654, 0.012634477578103542, 0.054544415324926376, 0.002673726761713624, -0.023402800783514977, -0.021652283146977425, 0.0338878370821476, -0.019434716552495956, 0.015140512026846409, 0.011828508228063583, 0.024630656465888023, 0.03194063901901245, -0.013799050822854042, 0.01011577621102333, 0.051428984850645065, -0.009154466912150383, 0.007679507602006197, -0.02233147621154785, 0.022960366681218147, -0.021517731249332428, 0.020620590075850487, 0.053266771137714386, 0.01064172200858593, 0.02770540863275528, 0.017361732199788094, 0.022799182683229446, 0.008610744029283524, 0.026764415204524994, -0.0031698832754045725, -0.008816092275083065, -0.048915229737758636, -0.026789624243974686, -0.016427671536803246, -0.006704685278236866, 0.009674817323684692, -0.019736023619771004, -0.0354103147983551, 0.041039567440748215, 0.016308676451444626, -0.01572134532034397, -0.03614954277873039, 0.026324158534407616, 0.08113265037536621, -0.04624178633093834, -0.007871286012232304, -0.05622623860836029, -0.00447845458984375, 0.0009220995707437396, -0.04602719470858574 ]
<p>Context: I am working on a decision tree classifier, trying to classify businesses as to whether they are likely to have an event occur (default) in the next 90 days.</p> <p>One input I get is whether, and when, the business is scheduled to have a related event (let's call it "warning"). A business may have no warning scheduled, or it may have a warning scheduled some number of days in the future (e.g., we learn today that a warning has been scheduled for 15 days hence). If a warning is scheduled further out, we may presume that the business has more time to cope and fix it, so it is "worse" to have 15 days till warning, than it is to have 85 days till warning.</p> <p>I'm looking for a way I can massage/transform this data into a single, real-valued feature for use in a decision tree, that 1. preserves the natural ordering that intuitively exists here, and 2. won't make for too ugly of statistics?</p> <p>Possibilities:</p> <ol> <li>Just use the number of days until scheduled warning as a feature. Pros: preserves order (except for no warning) and natural interpretability. Cons: when "no warning" exists, "zero" is a particularly poor value to use, since it violates the ordering.</li> <li>Use "+infinity" or some arbitrarily large number of days when "no warning" exists, but otherwise use number of days. Pros: preserves order and interpretability (except for no warning). Cons: most values are going to be in the 1-90 range, so choosing a representative value for "no warning" skews the data.</li> <li>Use "zero" for no warning, and transform the number of days till warning with the inverse. Pros: smooth, well-ordered over the domain, output range of 0,1, "no warning" is interpreted as "zero" effect. Cons: loses native interpretability of values, unsuitable for other (linear?) models.</li> <li>Use two separate features, one a binary for warning, one the days till warning. Pros: properly separates the concerns (?). Cons: still doesn't deal with the question of what to put in for missing value in days till warning.</li> </ol> <p>If, as I suspect, this is something of a rookie problem, any pointers for standard approaches to this kind of problem are welcome, including "RTFM" responses, though specific sources, technique names, or search terms would be quite welcome.</p>
74,302
[ -0.013871575705707073, -0.005572878289967775, 0.006859901826828718, 0.027423139661550522, 0.0014403547393158078, 0.001517505501396954, 0.0028774584643542767, 0.022882811725139618, 0.015437532216310501, -0.0040083350613713264, 0.020365148782730103, 0.01869816519320011, 0.002154849935323, 0.007733990903943777, -0.02982724830508232, 0.04463084414601326, -0.013888601213693619, -0.019181258976459503, -0.013363771140575409, -0.020421583205461502, -0.007319837808609009, -0.003476663026958704, 0.055376749485731125, 0.015115498565137386, -0.0637252926826477, 0.05481782928109169, 0.019646596163511276, 0.010034139268100262, 0.0037824807222932577, 0.05136364325881004, -0.04495440050959587, -0.04025735333561897, -0.006990799214690924, 0.052617933601140976, 0.04005340859293938, -0.001047269906848669, 0.006648721173405647, -0.000510016456246376, -0.015943465754389763, 0.00748920813202858, 0.016144970431923866, -0.016457170248031616, 0.01615370810031891, 0.05518731847405434, -0.034226223826408386, 0.006976225413382053, -0.04198611155152321, -0.01284183282405138, 0.04865949600934982, -0.02658495306968689, 0.03405150771141052, -0.06629037111997604, 0.011425741948187351, 0.011616591364145279, -0.008495735935866833, -0.013316494412720203, 0.045868247747421265, 0.046144790947437286, -0.033576492220163345, -0.09313934296369553, -0.013065870851278305, -0.008370328694581985, -0.01561195868998766, 0.0066208490170538425, 0.018420692533254623, 0.024190515279769897, 0.016054334118962288, -0.02659880369901657, 0.04098062589764595, 0.0019156618509441614, 0.020384857431054115, -0.016787292435765266, 0.00782748218625784, -0.024384448304772377, 0.04903929680585861, -0.0314367301762104, -0.01869622804224491, 0.018655121326446533, 0.025810223072767258, 0.03613656759262085, -0.006558557040989399, -0.02630174346268177, 0.008549870923161507, 0.03743911534547806, 0.015938736498355865, -0.031955745071172714, 0.0677008181810379, -0.04623197764158249, 0.01345718465745449, 0.059033095836639404, -0.025206366553902626, -0.02103712595999241, 0.016869070008397102, -0.036816179752349854, -0.007560699246823788, 0.035070136189460754, -0.005540783517062664, 0.016398591920733452, -0.007443170994520187, 0.01562788151204586, 0.001669408055022359, -0.052234843373298645, -0.03168950602412224, 0.04196293279528618, -0.023074401542544365, 0.026004984974861145, -0.01653710938990116, -0.015105263330042362, -0.022834140807390213, -0.014811620116233826, -0.01673037000000477, 0.029421715065836906, 0.011754385195672512, 0.00893382914364338, -0.0508786216378212, -0.017177565023303032, -0.008005074225366116, 0.009150687605142593, 0.007981655187904835, 0.017317350953817368, 0.06455632299184799, -0.024145720526576042, 0.010331635363399982, -0.0012972761178389192, -0.04537588730454445, 0.00210589449852705, 0.03292187675833702, -0.011198610998690128, -0.008844578638672829, 0.047572579234838486, 0.013059999793767929, 0.007802977692335844, 0.07479538768529892, -0.02262248285114765, 0.035994723439216614, 0.0046623386442661285, -0.04759573936462402, -0.041707009077072144, -0.005722761154174805, 0.0092637799680233, -0.007835638709366322, -0.05443675071001053, -0.06310449540615082, 0.0173688642680645, 0.0357789546251297, 0.021511465311050415, 0.04879824072122574, 0.02828744426369667, -0.00655263289809227, 0.006306090392172337, -0.01989191398024559, 0.043306853622198105, -0.02042597346007824, -0.02777952514588833, -0.02597845159471035, -0.04612188786268234, 0.025924794375896454, 0.022359561175107956, -0.018904292955994606, -0.0006415531970560551, 0.014206662774085999, -0.021998995915055275, -0.013453151099383831, 0.014804699458181858, 0.025532081723213196, -0.028217025101184845, 0.09855031967163086, -0.01980304718017578, 0.012969858944416046, 0.027748985216021538, 0.02624034322798252, -0.006494005210697651, 0.03224503993988037, 0.039137937128543854, 0.06249723583459854, -0.02506929263472557, 0.004958709701895714, -0.052809782326221466, -0.002372933318838477, 0.0009253560565412045, -0.015520168468356133, -0.015725886449217796, -0.04158542677760124, 0.011764542199671268, -0.03181871399283409, 0.04482804983854294, -0.03386254608631134, -0.010855566710233688, 0.0633620098233223, -0.05203602835536003, -0.05275009199976921, -0.06840680539608002, 0.012621932663023472, 0.0035813271533697844, 0.002109429333359003, 0.0397799126803875, 0.006609973032027483, -0.019305864349007607, -0.022248277440667152, 0.03608328476548195, 0.0013211580226197839, -0.00600585900247097, 0.04248573258519173, -0.07907583564519882, 0.015674801543354988, 0.031233135610818863, 0.02620864100754261, -0.019279638305306435, 0.028692882508039474, -0.06598964333534241, -0.05842813104391098, -0.0017995444359257817, -0.03150434419512749, 0.018343515694141388, -0.034787148237228394, -0.0019675216171890497, 0.05276918783783913, -0.023512957617640495, -0.022064397111535072, 0.00678358506411314, -0.050135187804698944, 0.04745499789714813, 0.09722418338060379, -0.009522861801087856, -0.017682043835520744, -0.01638047583401203, 0.0399026982486248, 0.008127129636704922, -0.02562137134373188, -0.02796955592930317, -0.02915658988058567, -0.021954910829663277, 0.05225364863872528, 0.04753246158361435, 0.013826399110257626, 0.004348462447524071, 0.04223478585481644, 0.024812301620841026, -0.002246411982923746, 0.038133732974529266, -0.01589454896748066, 0.012037617154419422, 0.021953338757157326, -0.006523502990603447, 0.04102654010057449, -0.0038761047180742025, 0.05889129638671875, -0.016471587121486664, 0.048625629395246506, 0.026033150032162666, -0.004899109713733196, 0.013704524375498295, 0.03592599555850029, 0.012102159671485424, -0.0056713642552495, -0.031447868794202805, 0.024432029575109482, -0.03178897872567177, -0.02147291973233223, 0.03232520446181297, -0.013148585334420204, 0.020590202882885933, -0.003606012323871255, -0.016883142292499542, 0.015437590889632702, 0.051045168191194534, -0.04764494299888611, 0.03829001262784004, 0.01951240934431553, -0.044416721910238266, -0.010142792947590351, -0.012184619903564453, -0.06352414190769196, -0.03454156965017319, 0.027418365702033043, 0.07268860936164856, 0.031710606068372726, 0.015565662644803524, -0.04037749022245407, 0.013189522549510002, -0.0031021481845527887, -0.011376404203474522, 0.029851779341697693, 0.013961915858089924, -0.03297457471489906, -0.00019731275097001344, 0.008482423610985279, -0.06859422475099564, 0.05859038233757019, -0.003790144808590412, 0.006728463806211948, 0.022117918357253075, 0.005919315852224827, -0.03539218753576279, -0.07414675503969193, -0.03450368344783783, 0.02844550646841526, -0.007483525201678276, -0.04661780968308449, 0.0354829840362072, -0.002797158667817712, -0.08506058901548386, -0.009331713430583477, -0.06706379354000092, -0.014238827861845493, -0.04400007054209709, 0.00723646767437458, -0.016204504296183586, 0.0009726888383738697, -0.024640511721372604, -0.005433835554867983, -0.006542702671140432, 0.0033145721536129713, -0.06618155539035797, -0.09678948670625687, -0.009644139558076859, -0.016276879236102104, 0.03144865855574608, 0.020005235448479652, 0.010376529768109322, 0.0863204374909401, 0.024008048698306084, 0.019432006403803825, -0.04894566163420677, -0.0019008988747373223, 0.0011672242544591427, -0.02613125555217266, -0.028430454432964325, 0.002641657367348671, 0.037364207208156586, -0.0019244593568146229, -0.002027381444349885, 0.044682152569293976, 0.016580721363425255, 0.016467435285449028, -0.029183324426412582, 0.0315808542072773, 0.00003683131581055932, 0.005135664250701666, 0.002919306978583336, 0.05207844823598862, 0.012310252524912357, 0.021527228876948357, -0.04407131299376488, 0.024813005700707436, 0.019021080806851387, -0.04215209186077118, -0.000857811130117625, -0.013316809199750423, -0.00007357150025200099, 0.01611287333071232, 0.027112314477562904, -0.038824066519737244, -0.018687665462493896, -0.06826784461736679, -0.038393016904592514, 0.04617390036582947, -0.04180384427309036, -0.012435424141585827, 0.04308374598622322, 0.029914986342191696, 0.011534719727933407, -0.034524671733379364, -0.012769305147230625, 0.03942090645432472, 0.030409270897507668, -0.040307432413101196, 0.02616570144891739, 0.006038070656359196, 0.05699344351887703, 0.03471418470144272, 0.013849685899913311, -0.030299443751573563, -0.009894981049001217, -0.026074808090925217, -0.003480931743979454, -0.01675318367779255, 0.030567729845643044, 0.015960296615958214, 0.01690095104277134, 0.008510136976838112, -0.007212040945887566, -0.009628872387111187, 0.05014486983418465, -0.050149817019701004, 0.014962665736675262, -0.04103095829486847, -0.003350104670971632, -0.007638076785951853, -0.01770135574042797, 0.009491429664194584, -0.03248774632811546, -0.0009444566676393151, 0.004820956848561764, 0.026780229061841965, -0.027199456468224525, -0.02752910554409027, -0.02171449176967144, -0.015282263979315758, -0.03630869463086128, -0.00830939318984747, -0.011171103455126286, 0.020152203738689423, 0.03308548778295517, 0.027470607310533524, 0.024193216115236282, -0.008592787198722363, -0.00830756314098835, -0.02185617759823799, 0.011858858168125153, 0.04929780215024948, -0.016412779688835144, 0.013770997524261475, -0.02012655697762966, 0.009004291146993637, 0.04065012186765671, 0.03780870512127876, 0.042666465044021606, 0.02571088634431362, -0.023531697690486908, -0.022229991853237152, -0.014447338879108429, 0.01674708165228367, 0.010266117751598358, 0.018735215067863464, 0.024908781051635742, 0.03246418386697769, -0.016218168660998344, -0.014718661084771156, -0.05367257073521614, 0.0827191174030304, 0.014898275956511497, -0.031010305508971214, 0.025058548897504807, 0.03533260524272919, -0.0020223320461809635, -0.010854815132915974, -0.02629881352186203, 0.06447415798902512, 0.012589252553880215, -0.01036868803203106, 0.017264127731323242, -0.004867668263614178, -0.0477927066385746, 0.012142613530158997, 0.018577100709080696, 0.03402278199791908, 0.037968266755342484, 0.00466461107134819, 0.03267098590731621, 0.03369961678981781, 0.028060154989361763, 0.0459568165242672, 0.028690997511148453, -0.0868874341249466, 0.013967887498438358, 0.048169251531362534, 0.06648239493370056, -0.004187146667391062, -0.04129457846283913, -0.06036558374762535, -0.03651389852166176, 0.014924204908311367, -0.021678337827324867, 0.011926104314625263, -0.012491426430642605, 0.0218270905315876, -0.012169950641691685, -0.008509902283549309, -0.024897102266550064, 0.03457116708159447, -0.012467103078961372, 0.06983447074890137, 0.025418037548661232, -0.026455704122781754, -0.03191586956381798, 0.003810203867033124, -0.02415277436375618, 0.036354053765535355, -0.0379190631210804, -0.03960398584604263, -0.01223642099648714, -0.007425436284393072, -0.02688150480389595, -0.01942458190023899, 0.0007770275697112083, 0.0425335094332695, 0.02435808628797531, 0.05189583823084831, -0.014902755618095398, -0.0035651118960231543, 0.012920805253088474, -0.0019985828548669815, -0.027506327256560326, 0.02046545036137104, -0.026301801204681396, 0.0021480401046574116, -0.02127276174724102, 0.005596200469881296, 0.02817963995039463, 0.05948825553059578, 0.010853254236280918, -0.0054967389442026615, -0.02037578448653221, 0.030024176463484764, 0.001330919680185616, -0.014435884542763233, -0.014623652212321758, -0.01579233631491661, -0.03967447206377983, 0.012676511891186237, -0.010047569870948792, 0.007150978781282902, -0.005707239732146263, -0.00511609623208642, -0.02975899539887905, -0.0019050532719120383, -0.0102773979306221, 0.01604520156979561, -0.04292021319270134, 0.0036052304785698652, -0.039557989686727524, 0.022418169304728508, 0.030887853354215622, -0.03678567707538605, 0.016949033364653587, 0.05475255101919174, -0.062003131955862045, 0.04027114808559418, -0.019450951367616653, -0.025890761986374855, 0.007115811109542847, -0.0038816710002720356, 0.031365782022476196, -0.0017182278679683805, -0.006216361187398434, 0.01561807468533516, -0.02832239493727684, 0.027901776134967804, 0.04122869670391083, -0.015626337379217148, 0.03187563642859459, -0.03978535905480385, 0.006817439571022987, -0.004848625045269728, 0.018815642222762108, -0.04583628848195076, 0.002468842314556241, 0.008102078922092915, 0.018183166161179543, -0.046155836433172226, -0.011375905014574528, -0.006677707191556692, 0.004708442371338606, -0.03741627559065819, -0.01886487938463688, 0.06693493574857712, -0.0249345563352108, -0.0176409799605608, -0.0022106238175183535, -0.003181989071890712, 0.06950225681066513, -0.0017315965378656983, 0.012033886276185513, 0.0003221108636353165, -0.005636928603053093, -0.027578599750995636, -0.00788006093353033, 0.0247027687728405, -0.029081882908940315, -0.020032495260238647, -0.04550033435225487, -0.016865508630871773, 0.020312275737524033, -0.01113638561218977, -0.012980980798602104, 0.00030264901579357684, -0.028066478669643402, -0.012960979714989662, -0.024626046419143677, -0.010623965412378311, 0.004404939245432615, -0.010166584514081478, -0.002446575788781047, -0.002354545285925269, 0.0028344893362373114, -0.020317671820521355, -0.05519625172019005, 0.014747259207069874, -0.015912014991044998, 0.027328595519065857, 0.02828844264149666, -0.007170270662754774, -0.004623624496161938, -0.04307148978114128, -0.03566814213991165, 0.03207225725054741, 0.018886329606175423, -0.013849222101271152, 0.009930194355547428, -0.0005185696063563228, -0.03455422446131706, -0.007949970662593842, -0.0327109768986702, -0.004950426053255796, 0.03336025029420853, 0.0019525031093508005, 0.04661855101585388, -0.0022340991999953985, 0.03059287928044796, -0.01484102476388216, -0.05128231272101402, -0.009867314249277115, 0.020531149581074715, -0.0018345232820138335, 0.03710852935910225, 0.005035660695284605, 0.02399003505706787, 0.024096952751278877, -0.0007924154633656144, 0.034828849136829376, 0.046667907387018204, 0.02741633728146553, -0.009232311509549618, 0.045830175280570984, -0.05043516308069229, -0.04158853366971016, 0.02069038711488247, -0.054813921451568604, 0.01710495539009571, 0.0001504629763076082, -0.04645970091223717, 0.025011705234646797, 0.009440471418201923, -0.03795933723449707, -0.07421311736106873, -0.008924772031605244, -0.04795175790786743, 0.025751261040568352, 0.045646052807569504, -0.03258467838168144, -0.002325445180758834, -0.04118099808692932, 0.036328546702861786, 0.00511003565043211, -0.0006983291241340339, -0.000024623692297609523, -0.07642626017332077, -0.025712663307785988, -0.049629323184490204, -0.05210636556148529, 0.05350467190146446, 0.024206187576055527, -0.005341984331607819, 0.004547286778688431, -0.02564646303653717, 0.03914772346615791, 0.02460579015314579, 0.03605752810835838, 0.01032068021595478, 0.028038911521434784, 0.007330471184104681, -0.0030112541280686855, -0.02265091799199581, 0.0060003045946359634, 0.175428107380867, 0.11948887258768082, 0.042224086821079254, -0.044810011982917786, 0.011223770678043365, 0.044622957706451416, 0.0006997304153628647, -0.015170820988714695, 0.02469315007328987, 0.00405402947217226, -0.003566065337508917, 0.04780641198158264, 0.023384466767311096, -0.03217042610049248, -0.022594699636101723, 0.03899183124303818, -0.05042358860373497, 0.02160962112247944, -0.0026225834153592587, 0.05097122862935066, 0.06354860216379166, -0.02613666281104088, -0.05884227156639099, 0.02341865934431553, 0.022921275347471237, -0.003525136038661003, -0.002927700988948345, -0.013678568415343761, 0.005264315754175186, -0.0014167793560773134, -0.0353960245847702, -0.0012086582137271762, 0.06562630832195282, -0.0038834644947201014, 0.020326051861047745, 0.008466314524412155, 0.020106540992856026, -0.03347945958375931, 0.0017742646159604192, 0.06240064278244972, 0.01545509323477745, -0.03207068890333176, 0.010511262342333794, 0.020034879446029663, -0.07557996362447739, -0.014040037989616394, -0.03336748108267784, -0.0007216979865916073, 0.002064960775896907, -0.005287280306220055, -0.013655219227075577, 0.013624164275825024, 0.005301273427903652, -0.04682305455207825, -0.0018599864561110735, 0.016880035400390625, 0.05138496682047844, -0.007865926250815392, -0.039717260748147964, -0.0041301073506474495, 0.025465428829193115, -0.0018113114638254046, 0.05439000204205513, 0.03268727660179138, -0.04190870374441147, -0.011262346990406513, -0.013651269488036633, 0.024734530597925186, 0.013382175005972385, 0.018104292452335358, 0.040936365723609924, 0.02301982045173645, -0.04115184023976326, 0.004242661874741316, 0.00267963157966733, -0.03150494769215584, 0.004462006501853466, -0.01352873258292675, -0.014683874323964119, -0.029972240328788757, -0.003321872092783451, -0.009250328876078129, -0.013518746010959148, -0.009954333305358887, -0.042945850640535355, -0.000023332126147579402, 0.01368216797709465, 0.022462084889411926, 0.0008352064178325236, 0.04517465457320213, 0.03296016901731491, 0.0597834549844265, 0.013914352282881737, -0.02366943284869194, -0.007532382383942604, -0.009389603510499, -0.06315672397613525, 0.05527935549616814, 0.030698111280798912, 0.08628739416599274, 0.037711482495069504, 0.03351057693362236, 0.015733951702713966, 0.04844924062490463, -0.022776484489440918, 0.003448700765147805, 0.046121809631586075, -0.056238025426864624, -0.03433579206466675, -0.004917103797197342, -0.013799728825688362, -0.037034790962934494, -0.04180964455008507, -0.016121109947562218, -0.035088930279016495, 0.005608749575912952, -0.03448062390089035, -0.0331139862537384, 0.01677507720887661, 0.0005867290892638266, 0.004716874565929174, -0.011402824893593788, -0.032310836017131805, -0.028059886768460274, -0.03233158960938454, 0.0020784426014870405, -0.027770984917879105, -0.004944062791764736, 0.0031903728377074003, -0.042108722031116486, -0.015565311536192894, 0.01590598002076149, 0.026890689507126808, 0.01990082859992981, -0.0008034587372094393, 0.005382293835282326, -0.01573159359395504, 0.032054539769887924, -0.041484203189611435, 0.010801057331264019, 0.0006305415881797671, -0.013165759854018688, 0.0013431498082354665, 0.06368856877088547, 0.021240821108222008, 0.03424922376871109, -0.03344481438398361, 0.007517908234149218, -0.040818147361278534, 0.04408581927418709, -0.04465075954794884, 0.008052465505897999, -0.006318625994026661, 0.03514936938881874, -0.013998803682625294, 0.019250676035881042, -0.013758128508925438, 0.022157175466418266, -0.03423721343278885, -0.03070061467587948, 0.009491444565355778, 0.007458917330950499, -0.054796114563941956, 0.0005268803215585649, -0.044034142047166824, -0.041726838797330856, 0.003830310655757785, -0.012799086049199104, -0.002987271174788475, 0.0018138778395950794, -0.03400969132781029, 0.019642047584056854, 0.001586289843544364, 0.0033003452699631453, -0.07556159049272537, -0.018801430240273476, 0.03175134211778641, 0.016190797090530396, 0.022547047585248947, 0.0027270750142633915, 0.008995413780212402, 0.02003048174083233, -0.058346688747406006, 0.02855311892926693, 0.0212263036519289, 0.001243614824488759, -0.03147967904806137, 0.003147078212350607, -0.019226551055908203, 0.010416485369205475, 0.03508931025862694, 0.004502349998801947, 0.03910662233829498, 0.03562742844223976, -0.03249037638306618, -0.03462965786457062, -0.011918969452381134, 0.05249243974685669, 0.02818938158452511, -0.034277427941560745, 0.03272638097405434, -0.050121940672397614, 0.014135271310806274, 0.046408865600824356, -0.0340404249727726, 0.018255969509482384, 0.0680452510714531, 0.043714143335819244, 0.03382832184433937, 0.04572655260562897, 0.06031640246510506, -0.028788434341549873, -0.04069007560610771, 0.013233746401965618, 0.005784626584500074, 0.007699098438024521, 0.0015994582790881395, 0.02558598853647709, 0.0037571301218122244, -0.03857444226741791, -0.018264051526784897, -0.028877101838588715, -0.004573501646518707, -0.01643586903810501, -0.030881045386195183, 0.005547737702727318, -0.007611829321831465, -0.031312283128499985, -0.0013538151979446411, -0.013220811262726784, 0.015205764211714268, 0.0550355464220047, 0.01929299905896187, -0.006613268982619047, -0.015160106122493744, -0.04228685796260834, -0.04106975719332695, 0.009376918897032738, 0.026376456022262573, -0.0007456129533238709, -0.022885672748088837, -0.012103309854865074, -0.06861612945795059, -0.021756436675786972, -0.04288878291845322, 0.013621577993035316, 0.0027961081359535456, 0.011221807450056076, -0.03355282172560692, 0.022883448749780655, 0.004918415565043688, -0.02845745161175728, 0.020515546202659607, -0.08112984150648117, 0.07895451039075851, 0.025023439899086952, 0.03191797062754631, -0.05907052382826805, -0.037668343633413315, -0.0355500802397728, 0.026303820312023163, 0.04640853404998779, 0.00026495210477150977, 0.004000960383564234, 0.006618093699216843, 0.03324525058269501, 0.007319428026676178, -0.011110888794064522, 0.006057798396795988, -0.007689414080232382, -0.010480287484824657, -0.018496006727218628, -0.023200394585728645, 0.02917175181210041, -0.007359132170677185, 0.01677357405424118, 0.02097948081791401, -0.022585665807127953, 0.004145745653659105, -0.015368601307272911, 0.025892015546560287, 0.0008457702933810651, 0.005066526122391224, 0.061195358633995056, 0.011732451617717743, -0.019582228735089302, 0.010620267130434513, 0.005783239379525185, -0.06679826974868774, 0.045152682811021805, -0.03843463212251663, 0.01870603859424591, -0.00376812182366848, 0.03423086553812027, 0.03332030028104782, -0.04728899151086807, 0.0049864184111356735, 0.013887427747249603, 0.01593305729329586, 0.012667851522564888, 0.02110316976904869, 0.0005002085235901177, 0.05993516743183136, -0.0024738297797739506, 0.02850683033466339, -0.029581798240542412, -0.0001410181721439585, 0.03881201893091202, -0.019485225901007652, -0.006893351674079895, 0.017036134377121925, 0.019337765872478485, 0.05026064068078995, -0.026837466284632683, 0.02421512082219124, 0.0022788450587540865, 0.015329842455685139, -0.0031799147836863995, -0.00788950640708208, 0.0629979595541954, 0.00024580545141361654, -0.005627080332487822, 0.031085509806871414, 0.03284633532166481, 0.020531993359327316, 0.004469482693821192, 0.006518618203699589, -0.03987300023436546, -0.04375556483864784, -0.022082775831222534, -0.0049744173884391785, 0.005227343179285526, 0.02708977647125721, -0.019860032945871353, 0.04667520150542259, 0.02182280644774437, -0.013848752714693546, -0.019027123227715492, -0.03007684275507927, -0.03731437772512436, 0.009213683195412159, -0.007743907161056995, 0.027271142229437828, -0.033453620970249176, -0.02959967963397503, -0.009749418124556541, -0.0015216156607493758, 0.04619073122739792, 0.03789525851607323, 0.012482804246246815, -0.025646653026342392, 0.021090051159262657, 0.0015681494260206819, -0.031989481300115585, 0.03026565909385681, -0.04936523362994194, 0.014627579599618912, -0.03687959164381027, -0.04141544923186302 ]
<p>I am working with matrices, of the size N*M, where each cell corresponds to the Pearson's correlation between two time series. I want to threshold each matrix such that it would retain only significant correlations. Now, my problem is that the time series are very large (>1500 data points) and thus rather weak correlations turn out to be (very) significant. I am already considering only correlations whose p val survives correction for multiple comparison (to correct for the number of tests done within each matrix), however this still leaves quite a few weak correlations in each matrix. I prefer not to choose a threshold arbitrarily, so I was wondering if anyone could direct me to established methods for determining statistical thresholds when working with very large time series </p> <p>Many thanks for your help! </p>
74,303
[ -0.031675785779953, 0.020501786842942238, -0.004267973359674215, 0.013818473555147648, 0.04611087590456009, 0.03299077972769737, 0.007063634227961302, -0.013977818191051483, 0.009624723345041275, -0.038939643651247025, 0.03198734670877457, 0.050830863416194916, 0.03932512551546097, 0.06886795163154602, 0.034125734120607376, -0.02781694382429123, -0.020045222714543343, -0.008643463253974915, 0.018944310024380684, -0.0446731261909008, -0.005806801375001669, 0.0107809416949749, 0.015854960307478905, -0.02358427830040455, -0.02598220482468605, 0.053444623947143555, 0.024656321853399277, 0.0021275924518704414, 0.017539076507091522, 0.05061809718608856, -0.08500955253839493, -0.03621773421764374, 0.037009596824645996, 0.018173182383179665, 0.010798058472573757, -0.01711423322558403, 0.0032252457458525896, 0.0133082065731287, -0.0008917543455027044, 0.01799817942082882, -0.04856421425938606, -0.0035960376262664795, 0.020376894623041153, 0.02946070209145546, -0.0036613703705370426, 0.011266429908573627, 0.04427230730652809, -0.034612882882356644, 0.03586789220571518, -0.04417487606406212, 0.08141171187162399, 0.006822078488767147, 0.05512504652142525, 0.02770216204226017, -0.017712527886033058, 0.014112912118434906, 0.046573832631111145, 0.05006232112646103, -0.031501512974500656, -0.051313791424036026, -0.012610161677002907, -0.02434917725622654, 0.008557597175240517, -0.022477850317955017, -0.02576565183699131, 0.017608268186450005, -0.04463152587413788, -0.008161132223904133, 0.039708469063043594, -0.015297545120120049, -0.016512524336576462, 0.017234889790415764, 0.0336184948682785, -0.011445276439189911, 0.013575275428593159, -0.014682220295071602, 0.020336465910077095, 0.0021655780728906393, 0.05399138852953911, 0.04936179146170616, 0.015706945210695267, 0.028087928891181946, 0.029028117656707764, 0.03863660991191864, 0.02769823931157589, -0.018897593021392822, 0.05699930340051651, -0.06760402768850327, 0.016823839396238327, 0.039753660559654236, -0.02813965640962124, -0.037019599229097366, 0.0630018338561058, 0.03403489664196968, -0.05778827145695686, 0.026007670909166336, -0.010876483283936977, 0.04924163594841957, -0.0035597835667431355, 0.007998109795153141, -0.02962338738143444, -0.026702651754021645, -0.008661863394081593, 0.04059611260890961, -0.029575558379292488, 0.03614377975463867, -0.0408797562122345, -0.01757209375500679, 0.012188278138637543, -0.0074329674243927, 0.004210158716887236, -0.005537935066968203, 0.017357923090457916, -0.008576257154345512, 0.029974963515996933, -0.005215919576585293, -0.032135725021362305, -0.04398922622203827, 0.05495096370577812, 0.0812641903758049, 0.025161895900964737, 0.006576657295227051, 0.020133504644036293, -0.01761084422469139, -0.06545468419790268, 0.056848760694265366, -0.0020891064777970314, -0.032654158771038055, -0.038431573659181595, 0.04371644929051399, 0.01416956540197134, -0.04766414314508438, 0.01584731601178646, -0.056400008499622345, 0.07408427447080612, 0.0019397317664697766, -0.05864875763654709, -0.019694805145263672, 0.05949145182967186, -0.007360398769378662, -0.003956034313887358, -0.037045106291770935, 0.00027286491240374744, 0.034609775990247726, 0.07973936945199966, 0.03513893485069275, 0.016206815838813782, 0.009439556859433651, 0.0065538110211491585, 0.013236921280622482, -0.03393520787358284, -0.007318171672523022, -0.015695903450250626, -0.0036522354930639267, -0.00016359201981686056, -0.0736331194639206, 0.019334647804498672, 0.03821784630417824, -0.012171676382422447, -0.0006958573940210044, 0.02197156846523285, 0.02842070534825325, -0.029367931187152863, -0.03665217384696007, 0.025295522063970566, 0.019943615421652794, 0.0668451339006424, -0.028483275324106216, 0.03790828213095665, 0.007949969731271267, -0.030822427943348885, 0.00942310132086277, 0.030930783599615097, 0.060557860881090164, 0.03177275508642197, -0.008200554177165031, 0.01146960910409689, 0.013451519422233105, 0.030623234808444977, 0.00985046662390232, -0.02513829432427883, -0.024755995720624924, -0.011041530407965183, 0.002749464474618435, 0.030115190893411636, 0.05295775458216667, -0.02225051447749138, -0.04917033016681671, -0.009720904752612114, -0.025051739066839218, -0.018711386248469353, -0.03887120261788368, 0.02733985334634781, -0.011015782132744789, -0.03891399875283241, 0.04201280698180199, -0.01675569824874401, 0.011823724023997784, 0.010023224167525768, -0.016006946563720703, -0.045655507594347, -0.019251342862844467, 0.04064201936125755, -0.06907174736261368, 0.026770463213324547, 0.006304298061877489, 0.06426705420017242, -0.0005649901577271521, 0.06448894739151001, -0.023163501173257828, -0.02957976795732975, 0.03270282968878746, -0.02864113636314869, 0.00018050252401735634, 0.004732233472168446, -0.05187476426362991, 0.005635601002722979, -0.03379196301102638, -0.00938432663679123, 0.002590552205219865, -0.004198058508336544, 0.06277492642402649, 0.0022782247979193926, 0.006288973614573479, -0.0027572051621973515, -0.00980883464217186, 0.012935697101056576, -0.010535083711147308, -0.031097199767827988, -0.02779798023402691, -0.051002323627471924, 0.0036111169029027224, 0.038676030933856964, 0.06469559669494629, -0.06150360777974129, 0.007489560171961784, 0.06866740435361862, 0.013631666079163551, 0.02074267901480198, 0.02021191082894802, 0.00221003545448184, 0.017487773671746254, 0.015455050393939018, 0.020681655034422874, 0.004233797080814838, -0.0005682644550688565, 0.009207296185195446, -0.0006461190641857684, 0.039601005613803864, -0.0021937661804258823, -0.023327037692070007, 0.006111636757850647, 0.008970255963504314, 0.01168117392808199, -0.02759086713194847, -0.026611484587192535, 0.04753534495830536, -0.0021142156329005957, 0.0007175169885158539, 0.02303350530564785, 0.010735545307397842, 0.012030815705657005, 0.015660302713513374, -0.0195250753313303, 0.040137629956007004, 0.02133112959563732, -0.04306516796350479, 0.0036281230859458447, 0.0060980431735515594, -0.0015375466318801045, 0.029631713405251503, -0.017833629623055458, -0.01581640914082527, -0.016470741480588913, 0.041585903614759445, 0.05237904191017151, 0.0022027648519724607, 0.024425458163022995, -0.032555412501096725, 0.0023418411146849394, -0.045351408421993256, -0.03193153068423271, 0.012983554042875767, -0.015609152615070343, -0.04862072318792343, -0.016422132030129433, -0.005864111240953207, -0.027940988540649414, 0.043338850140571594, -0.04932054504752159, 0.020940298214554787, 0.02091236039996147, -0.020626328885555267, -0.04263199120759964, -0.0283080842345953, -0.03167252242565155, 0.014019032008945942, -0.009175408631563187, -0.02024485543370247, 0.060459502041339874, 0.01580188237130642, -0.07616633921861649, 0.025113701820373535, -0.02351010963320732, -0.002127555198967457, -0.039801325649023056, -0.018249547109007835, -0.010807299055159092, -0.033192574977874756, 0.027055654674768448, 0.017878107726573944, -0.05495245009660721, -0.0021560280583798885, -0.04177030175924301, -0.044510915875434875, 0.022768881171941757, -0.000024567643777118064, 0.024900635704398155, 0.00406766589730978, -0.020107071846723557, 0.04947744682431221, 0.03344564139842987, -0.013097982853651047, -0.029859239235520363, -0.00916287861764431, -0.018069008365273476, -0.04382836073637009, 0.038346000015735626, 0.010729585774242878, 0.018716037273406982, 0.01313316635787487, -0.0058143651112914085, -0.003404062008485198, 0.028762483969330788, 0.02895902842283249, -0.033876076340675354, 0.01320664957165718, -0.031215110793709755, 0.004151031840592623, -0.0018844295991584659, 0.007116283290088177, -0.04414989426732063, 0.01803712546825409, 0.019197555258870125, 0.021877439692616463, 0.030266428366303444, -0.009532163850963116, 0.0027503627352416515, -0.036934684962034225, 0.024375924840569496, -0.017512764781713486, -0.03880522400140762, 0.031239431351423264, -0.0034063563216477633, -0.017527999356389046, 0.034783415496349335, 0.008673346601426601, -0.03493713587522507, 0.01989663578569889, 0.033320359885692596, 0.020850621163845062, -0.016778048127889633, 0.020083513110876083, -0.00028252453193999827, -0.010526526719331741, 0.02517581172287464, -0.056238315999507904, -0.045131418853998184, 0.05203757435083389, -0.008423678576946259, 0.023257650434970856, 0.000034108019463019446, -0.031548697501420975, 0.029493756592273712, -0.054906148463487625, 0.03316669538617134, -0.03821353614330292, 0.047548580914735794, -0.00017342992941848934, -0.00793460477143526, 0.06536781787872314, -0.011608499102294445, 0.019594814628362656, 0.03193528577685356, -0.04371541365981102, 0.045423198491334915, -0.008394487202167511, -0.0360100157558918, 0.02696637623012066, 0.005179447587579489, 0.00469019403681159, -0.034263528883457184, -0.0005193067481741309, -0.01706308126449585, 0.04203394055366516, -0.029498541727662086, 0.012063516303896904, -0.02156287617981434, 0.00039783521788194776, -0.026414241641759872, 0.016905829310417175, 0.035553157329559326, -0.006295052822679281, 0.040005482733249664, 0.018246861174702644, -0.03884633630514145, -0.008958060294389725, 0.007236655801534653, 0.03140278905630112, 0.013481740839779377, 0.04431323707103729, 0.031040003523230553, 0.021415239199995995, -0.058303602039813995, -0.005999341141432524, -0.010499955154955387, 0.0301640797406435, 0.029481010511517525, 0.01376668456941843, 0.003662032773718238, -0.032819099724292755, 0.003217937657609582, 0.019426284357905388, 0.03193747624754906, -0.00661925645545125, 0.001304659410379827, 0.0323479063808918, 0.0147721441462636, -0.10357336699962616, 0.026870718225836754, 0.07048019766807556, 0.03586367145180702, 0.009779266081750393, -0.00816267542541027, -0.03146255016326904, 0.026975072920322418, 0.00810172874480486, 0.008210335858166218, 0.025661034509539604, 0.004953570663928986, -0.034027595072984695, 0.03630826994776726, -0.004609276074916124, -0.03896206617355347, -0.020181048661470413, 0.03821501508355141, 0.05309578403830528, -0.030621672049164772, -0.013672950677573681, 0.019645359367132187, 0.007077669724822044, 0.013333158567547798, 0.03521940857172012, 0.02497013844549656, -0.08675011247396469, 0.03827168047428131, 0.05069136247038841, 0.03561133146286011, 0.0007189159514382482, 0.0035645468160510063, -0.03355024382472038, -0.03223031759262085, 0.07242072373628616, -0.014277372509241104, 0.04664905369281769, -0.008559362031519413, 0.029126819223165512, -0.009939324110746384, 0.003160729305818677, -0.04851922392845154, -0.016438687220215797, -0.007663262076675892, 0.06573204696178436, -0.028116101399064064, -0.03326911851763725, -0.061785273253917694, -0.003882672404870391, 0.03700966387987137, 0.06256934255361557, 0.020971735939383507, -0.002329120645299554, 0.008908580057322979, 0.007845886051654816, 0.0029968752060085535, -0.04961839318275452, 0.02034452185034752, -0.006257861386984587, -0.013345809653401375, 0.04349972680211067, -0.025684203952550888, -0.016617918387055397, -0.0010225643636658788, 0.00940942857414484, 0.008438360877335072, 0.006778700277209282, 0.005666473880410194, 0.05369070544838905, 0.009361492469906807, 0.0018106470815837383, 0.03825298324227333, 0.019291821867227554, -0.0012994460994377732, 0.017760638147592545, -0.03240605443716049, -0.0028170370496809483, -0.04366294667124748, 0.010909773409366608, -0.03655870631337166, 0.026908183470368385, -0.04750440642237663, 0.05491618812084198, -0.0005406832788139582, 0.017813973128795624, -0.002571344142779708, -0.003245330648496747, -0.015472490340471268, 0.05655637010931969, -0.006353201810270548, -0.012083972804248333, 0.024331694468855858, 0.019574619829654694, -0.028943225741386414, -0.013357345014810562, -0.000626364431809634, -0.014978594146668911, -0.04314199835062027, 0.01575626991689205, -0.030493423342704773, 0.013845330104231834, -0.04055095091462135, -0.0018854085355997086, -0.012676110491156578, -0.01901230216026306, 0.02806013450026512, 0.002343556145206094, 0.03994716331362724, 0.0009328552987426519, -0.020168136805295944, 0.017613021656870842, 0.03646845370531082, -0.03465832397341728, 0.0522649809718132, -0.035900358110666275, 0.0399106964468956, -0.043523166328668594, 0.024339113384485245, -0.05624309554696083, -0.0542137436568737, 0.015596865676343441, 0.03976467624306679, -0.015156913548707962, -0.04522482678294182, 0.014189389534294605, -0.031894270330667496, 0.017796926200389862, -0.009767698124051094, 0.05256420001387596, -0.015075866132974625, -0.030665896832942963, 0.014171338640153408, 0.030886076390743256, 0.0778951570391655, -0.0353122316300869, -0.008003252558410168, 0.0178946852684021, -0.027729438617825508, -0.03810299187898636, -0.04422013834118843, 0.004516381770372391, -0.0455385185778141, -0.015533385798335075, -0.04875496029853821, -0.005421893671154976, 0.03804910182952881, -0.04560765624046326, -0.002468419261276722, 0.021977929398417473, -0.007547063287347555, 0.014314294792711735, -0.013599429279565811, 0.010198675096035004, -0.0270931888371706, 0.003670771373435855, 0.0054077692329883575, -0.03231963515281677, -0.02378685586154461, -0.04029208421707153, 0.021685976535081863, 0.03998555988073349, -0.030800264328718185, -0.013910531997680664, 0.035632580518722534, -0.007174021564424038, -0.0001397875021211803, -0.0042977044358849525, -0.006589678581804037, 0.05039199814200401, -0.006177222356200218, 0.00923576857894659, -0.01185399666428566, 0.005073760636150837, -0.040863342583179474, -0.044064950197935104, -0.01793115772306919, -0.003899727948009968, 0.030393604189157486, 0.00483127124607563, 0.028247997164726257, 0.023203639313578606, 0.020252736285328865, -0.02283528633415699, -0.02346652001142502, -0.014622789807617664, 0.019029704853892326, 0.005186318885535002, 0.021087374538183212, -0.02172050252556801, 0.009619948454201221, 0.02100410684943199, 0.0026801566127687693, 0.014658188447356224, 0.04440617561340332, -0.0008869169978424907, 0.02652638405561447, 0.032047294080257416, -0.03376588225364685, -0.017539774999022484, 0.03536734730005264, -0.047317471355199814, -0.0013279176782816648, -0.020082037895917892, 0.011855436488986015, 0.008656618185341358, 0.04579625278711319, 0.0030286668334156275, -0.008240832947194576, -0.03439006581902504, -0.014569256454706192, 0.0018739709630608559, 0.015837909653782845, -0.05455956235527992, 0.018009046092629433, 0.01895475946366787, 0.03336044400930405, -0.004554934334009886, -0.001245199702680111, -0.03170615807175636, -0.04826151952147484, -0.05732046812772751, -0.05792776122689247, -0.021274365484714508, 0.01585686206817627, 0.03481573238968849, -0.036622218787670135, 0.02232539653778076, -0.020713135600090027, -0.006108455825597048, 0.007153899874538183, 0.05181705579161644, -0.00737494882196188, 0.038071997463703156, 0.01082858070731163, 0.010781372897326946, 0.035164520144462585, -0.031859155744314194, 0.1028405949473381, 0.0921311154961586, 0.0018290571169927716, -0.0792141705751419, 0.0452633835375309, 0.00009115708235185593, 0.00915918592363596, -0.07739034295082092, 0.03169119358062744, -0.003983501344919205, -0.03057059273123741, 0.031907834112644196, 0.07397512346506119, -0.006164126563817263, 0.00975732784718275, 0.06402458995580673, -0.009898286312818527, -0.0024400416295975447, 0.02195664681494236, 0.059624820947647095, -0.002627635607495904, -0.01827237755060196, -0.06492192298173904, 0.026895606890320778, 0.009326322004199028, -0.044121820479631424, -0.023160520941019058, 0.0021360451355576515, 0.01822478324174881, 0.00034030579263344407, 0.015288150869309902, 0.0009653377928771079, 0.040115535259246826, 0.04337962716817856, 0.020293526351451874, -0.002314483979716897, 0.0005337327602319419, -0.013432992622256279, 0.020334437489509583, 0.0000810464916867204, -0.020400116220116615, -0.005668856203556061, 0.011459458619356155, -0.01568692922592163, -0.014466054737567902, -0.07248439639806747, -0.042720332741737366, 0.06685317307710648, 0.01698908768594265, -0.030388355255126953, 0.02284266985952854, -0.01935679279267788, -0.015791233628988266, -0.030144453048706055, -0.03316314518451691, 0.02056925557553768, 0.010052599012851715, -0.013907762244343758, 0.007850328460335732, -0.046560000628232956, 0.018471451476216316, 0.003365245880559087, 0.020408907905220985, 0.024982037022709846, -0.04207644984126091, -0.013036071322858334, -0.028490953147411346, 0.05700221285223961, -0.00798589363694191, -0.011061172932386398, 0.01793224737048149, -0.03446456417441368, -0.02285820245742798, -0.028134919703006744, 0.028234807774424553, 0.0042544398456811905, -0.010223101824522018, 0.006642370484769344, -0.014924134127795696, -0.01530193816870451, -0.03356841206550598, 0.00757635897025466, -0.0086898822337389, -0.055134229362010956, -0.014075333252549171, -0.03658172860741615, 0.03666643798351288, 0.02124868519604206, 0.04371750354766846, -0.015659131109714508, -0.037787485867738724, 0.011693942360579967, 0.05112290382385254, -0.05806944519281387, -0.03993857651948929, -0.03689997270703316, -0.023897388949990273, 0.03251924738287926, -0.02099660225212574, 0.06038129702210426, 0.02707052417099476, -0.006893669720739126, 0.01989048719406128, 0.028215566650032997, -0.011289517395198345, -0.00817208644002676, 0.01567988097667694, -0.05006843060255051, -0.015383957885205746, -0.0189511701464653, -0.021376071497797966, -0.02299799770116806, -0.016106998547911644, -0.053970444947481155, 0.01106941420584917, -0.01739886961877346, -0.011045320890843868, -0.023718228563666344, -0.005229269154369831, -0.027417311444878578, -0.00026478953077457845, -0.03726861625909805, -0.035455700010061264, -0.06466255336999893, -0.010449372231960297, 0.0018410426564514637, -0.008113653399050236, -0.010504844598472118, 0.00029633822850883007, -0.04033275321125984, 0.03299103304743767, 0.04232574626803398, 0.02307688258588314, -0.011910723522305489, -0.04045189544558525, -0.028014743700623512, 0.004543590825051069, 0.039920248091220856, -0.02839679829776287, -0.019520029425621033, 0.0661955326795578, -0.04773446172475815, -0.04005666822195053, 0.015562084503471851, -0.024339156225323677, 0.020708434283733368, 0.023807460442185402, -0.0013303020969033241, -0.042151909321546555, 0.05206681042909622, -0.012033011764287949, -0.039222028106451035, 0.002286965725943446, 0.05655789002776146, -0.019427333027124405, 0.01872381567955017, 0.021732820197939873, -0.023791279643774033, -0.0015203345101326704, 0.0019933877047151327, 0.06611066311597824, 0.01267901249229908, -0.02888619154691696, -0.0060598962008953094, -0.000010373733857704792, 0.037576824426651, 0.01607980951666832, -0.024558838456869125, 0.03800581023097038, 0.06059546396136284, -0.03513878211379051, -0.02552095428109169, 0.0045604282058775425, 0.0225016288459301, -0.07738874852657318, 0.0006792847998440266, -0.02127710171043873, -0.014427077025175095, 0.04645400494337082, -0.05526738613843918, -0.004998696502298117, 0.055379193276166916, -0.051525842398405075, 0.028777742758393288, -0.028118787333369255, 0.0005946117453277111, -0.03094632364809513, 0.005604077596217394, -0.024746548384428024, 0.048556137830019, 0.0228156466037035, 0.023166438564658165, 0.031226707622408867, 0.02855578437447548, -0.0044196490198373795, -0.04311287775635719, -0.022083807736635208, 0.019607963040471077, -0.02223794348537922, -0.05603707954287529, 0.03361116349697113, -0.044514406472444534, -0.04329599067568779, 0.03342926874756813, -0.06655417382717133, 0.004554948303848505, 0.018158582970499992, 0.026010995730757713, -0.0026448541320860386, 0.06578627228736877, -0.0015169373946264386, -0.038394518196582794, 0.06409651786088943, -0.006596616469323635, -0.007079222705215216, 0.02021290548145771, -0.02270309440791607, 0.011436756700277328, 0.0020804202649742365, -0.02850927785038948, -0.031049683690071106, -0.00964666623622179, -0.0165692288428545, 0.004615189973264933, -0.01754656620323658, 0.029819894582033157, 0.026987921446561813, -0.035193104296922684, 0.0435141958296299, -0.006354893557727337, -0.01358991488814354, 0.023940594866871834, 0.024913093075156212, -0.014161791652441025, 0.024103481322526932, -0.003796747885644436, -0.03556268662214279, 0.025811173021793365, -0.017881568521261215, -0.010426158085465431, -0.07518275082111359, -0.028508035466074944, 0.018000511452555656, -0.01822059415280819, -0.05489371716976166, 0.003807616885751486, -0.041821882128715515, 0.046928130090236664, -0.019920364022254944, 0.03621772676706314, 0.0022560334764420986, -0.0031244901474565268, 0.018398603424429893, -0.09247595816850662, 0.028900647535920143, -0.008870686404407024, 0.0115712471306324, -0.013545901514589787, -0.026739126071333885, -0.029694410040974617, 0.017016571015119553, 0.05236003175377846, 0.008391196839511395, 0.03898201510310173, -0.020818758755922318, -0.0031300997361540794, 0.01661079190671444, -0.03646058961749077, 0.03576391190290451, -0.016904041171073914, -0.026044121012091637, -0.01811821386218071, -0.036835696548223495, 0.07422379404306412, -0.022982247173786163, -0.00817763153463602, -0.01112973503768444, -0.018223971128463745, 0.025506040081381798, -0.02937569096684456, 0.029125478118658066, 0.004235848784446716, 0.004921402782201767, 0.01864093728363514, -0.005072391591966152, 0.05260506272315979, 0.04616718366742134, 0.011575485579669476, -0.04024037346243858, 0.04167507588863373, -0.04157186672091484, -0.04588797688484192, 0.01458194199949503, 0.050493694841861725, -0.02656366303563118, -0.05204303190112114, -0.016892965883016586, 0.017807893455028534, -0.00764641584828496, 0.021274292841553688, 0.018379470333456993, -0.017058249562978745, 0.0180807001888752, 0.0005751975695602596, 0.05633987486362457, 0.037355225533246994, 0.008718856610357761, 0.03603430092334747, 0.0319213829934597, 0.011746633797883987, 0.0005070209736004472, 0.028939198702573776, 0.024125780910253525, -0.022547025233507156, 0.03298041969537735, -0.01962990313768387, -0.0007585281855426729, -0.019706476479768753, -0.012578773312270641, 0.025693019852042198, -0.046587832272052765, 0.023213787004351616, 0.004698699340224266, 0.0037509023677557707, 0.02717738226056099, -0.05497366562485695, -0.020734675228595734, -0.033638644963502884, -0.036529067903757095, -0.007847038097679615, 0.010942958295345306, -0.005598803982138634, 0.0334758535027504, -0.02790379337966442, 0.039529163390398026, 0.030957181006669998, -0.00010453624418005347, -0.0172995924949646, -0.03250015527009964, 0.05518705025315285, -0.007431263569742441, -0.002780686831101775, -0.009394328109920025, 0.016324657946825027, -0.043570637702941895, -0.02218308486044407, 0.005646945908665657, 0.06003393977880478, 0.004353087395429611, -0.031100895255804062, -0.0070635355077683926, 0.003668481484055519, -0.001457833219319582, -0.05777296796441078, 0.007216697558760643, -0.022729070857167244, 0.036623090505599976, -0.02233879268169403, 0.04056825861334801 ]
<p>Let's assume we have a training set with $y \in \mathbb{R}$. Thus all the data is between $y_{min}$ and $y_{max}$. If we built a decision tree model it cannot return $y_{pred}$ outside the given range (using any combination of input features). Thus decision tree cannot extrapolate in terms of predicted values. Can a neural net regression model extrapolate and return $y_{pred}$ values outside the $y$ range in a training set? Does it depend on the activation function or not?</p> <p>Below is my attempt to answer this question.</p> <p>The output neuron of the model is just $\sum \Theta_ia_i$, where $\Theta_i$ - weight of i-th neuron on the previous hidden layer, and $a_i$ - value of activation function of that neuron. If we use logistic function then $a \in (-1;1)$. Thus maximum possible $y_{pred} = \sum \Theta_i$, assuming that all $a$ reach their maximum value around 1. But if we will use linear activation function, which doesn't have restrictions on output values of $a$ ($a \in \mathbb{R}$) the model will return $y_{pred} \in \mathbb{R}$, which can be ouside $y$ range of the training set.</p> <p>Is my line of reasoning correct or there are some mistakes?</p>
570
[ -0.01261474471539259, -0.0015055747935548425, -0.022373303771018982, 0.01412887591868639, 0.03569028899073601, 0.0019459356553852558, -0.048006944358348846, -0.028003375977277756, 0.04619578644633293, -0.03657073900103569, 0.03135246783494949, -0.007789242547005415, 0.03266353905200958, 0.029101742431521416, 0.0052061607129871845, 0.02715221606194973, -0.04012136906385422, -0.007189135532826185, 0.0006041518063284457, -0.007607131730765104, 0.014138249680399895, 0.05973603203892708, 0.021730685606598854, -0.0071915495209395885, -0.054925378412008286, 0.026476379483938217, 0.0019894575234502554, 0.00503691378980875, -0.004232488106936216, 0.0721961185336113, 0.0021326595451682806, -0.02109987847507, 0.016909612342715263, 0.08082588016986847, 0.03897998854517937, -0.0008004792616702616, -0.038127683103084564, -0.016048116609454155, 0.005478633567690849, 0.005057395435869694, 0.01795829087495804, -0.0609646700322628, 0.04646788537502289, 0.03674124926328659, -0.01697438210248947, 0.020717712119221687, -0.03730002045631409, -0.05298542231321335, 0.019269200041890144, -0.022756291553378105, 0.04382592439651489, -0.014703898690640926, 0.0239334125071764, 0.04985899105668068, 0.025778230279684067, 0.0020684595219790936, 0.07675068080425262, 0.073650062084198, -0.005955949425697327, -0.06527280062437057, -0.033035021275281906, -0.00978726428002119, -0.0040250979363918304, -0.0009540867758914828, -0.07465403527021408, 0.013120661489665508, -0.008183792233467102, -0.023384466767311096, 0.01715271733701229, -0.042108166962862015, 0.015043150633573532, 0.02311171218752861, 0.022985534742474556, -0.0056365313939750195, 0.003169242525473237, -0.019862649962306023, 0.005610020365566015, 0.02314750850200653, 0.024002566933631897, 0.025691380724310875, 0.0002534576051402837, 0.038588132709264755, 0.029470954090356827, 0.04284854978322983, 0.04466577246785164, 0.007826982997357845, 0.09415780752897263, -0.013667239807546139, 0.048007864505052567, 0.010682675987482071, -0.025480644777417183, -0.0017625662731006742, 0.04750772565603256, -0.04376235604286194, -0.03205641359090805, 0.016117753461003304, -0.018104935064911842, 0.009469687007367611, 0.04563681781291962, -0.0177160631865263, 0.006586181931197643, -0.05263500288128853, -0.01590556465089321, 0.06310806423425674, -0.016024958342313766, -0.0036510108038783073, -0.010113898664712906, -0.01258786953985691, 0.019041966646909714, -0.020759612321853638, -0.0014635047409683466, 0.045270759612321854, 0.0065602571703493595, 0.023225212469697, 0.00640106899663806, -0.00874389335513115, -0.011542928405106068, -0.037152666598558426, -0.000724430603440851, 0.0384858176112175, 0.019796395674347878, -0.04217126592993736, 0.019124159589409828, -0.020846834406256676, -0.02466999739408493, -0.002661630045622587, 0.020012076944112778, 0.010842520743608475, -0.04748063534498215, 0.0128098763525486, -0.00120738020632416, -0.04105081409215927, 0.034637048840522766, 0.007653255946934223, 0.054510004818439484, 0.005506887100636959, -0.08968078345060349, -0.04702799394726753, 0.024189654737710953, -0.03851666674017906, 0.03821978718042374, -0.042058005928993225, -0.003795533673837781, 0.04988880082964897, 0.01839473471045494, 0.033109020441770554, 0.03025777079164982, 0.017856324091553688, -0.0029224806930869818, -0.008685912936925888, -0.022108159959316254, 0.009429258294403553, -0.015750717371702194, -0.015780292451381683, -0.017318787053227425, -0.07293988764286041, 0.05558031424880028, 0.004955784883350134, -0.006925639696419239, -0.010190047323703766, 0.052283015102148056, -0.018996039405465126, 0.007651288062334061, 0.001433239784091711, 0.01787920854985714, -0.018634216859936714, 0.09993237257003784, 0.007898070849478245, 0.0524425245821476, 0.01961669698357582, 0.012629968114197254, 0.009560472331941128, 0.032600149512290955, 0.0416046567261219, 0.05798033997416496, -0.020410805940628052, -0.039314743131399155, -0.056367650628089905, 0.031171444803476334, 0.042708031833171844, -0.022334620356559753, -0.022656908258795738, -0.026824505999684334, 0.005827053915709257, 0.029383424669504166, 0.032618198543787, -0.013870706781744957, -0.04908458888530731, 0.035651013255119324, -0.03171176463365555, -0.00823916681110859, -0.021930942311882973, 0.025092657655477524, -0.0061519816517829895, 0.02261483483016491, 0.01655985228717327, -0.006014418322592974, 0.0315651074051857, -0.0022877203300595284, 0.0006895550759509206, -0.03474424406886101, -0.003740024520084262, 0.04984311759471893, 0.00009100297029362991, 0.021854257211089134, 0.06685641407966614, -0.002697564195841551, -0.007763877511024475, 0.05165744200348854, -0.05607645958662033, -0.07008066028356552, 0.03585737198591232, -0.028104735538363457, 0.010177486576139927, 0.0015504348557442427, -0.03339707851409912, 0.02271672897040844, -0.007160728331655264, -0.03579738736152649, 0.039152711629867554, -0.06043681129813194, 0.06580307334661484, 0.059837374836206436, -0.018364112824201584, 0.0013563933316618204, 0.028914285823702812, -0.00983244739472866, 0.02216903679072857, -0.03057914599776268, -0.03380117565393448, -0.04779350385069847, -0.015017951838672161, 0.008152426220476627, 0.046906862407922745, -0.023244431242346764, 0.032638296484947205, 0.04709243401885033, -0.00031056805164553225, 0.03063942678272724, 0.003841246012598276, -0.025190206244587898, 0.019742818549275398, -0.007402084767818451, 0.045553721487522125, 0.01115183625370264, 0.0004972548340447247, -0.02824588306248188, -0.010473951697349548, 0.009512168355286121, 0.012326075695455074, 0.0154985086992383, 0.038366857916116714, -0.00007174461643444374, -0.01708449423313141, -0.019520681351423264, -0.007920700125396252, 0.03466595709323883, -0.04126089811325073, -0.0058570923283696175, 0.01167088933289051, 0.007849401794373989, -0.028873460367321968, -0.012174035422503948, 0.015080461278557777, 0.04876298829913139, 0.05091124400496483, -0.051003459841012955, -0.011622095480561256, 0.03937581926584244, -0.06702349334955215, 0.027674227952957153, -0.048487503081560135, -0.038541410118341446, -0.03282663971185684, 0.039944231510162354, 0.06578810513019562, 0.015217936597764492, 0.014372097328305244, -0.039466723799705505, 0.0014173741219565272, 0.0005113493534736335, -0.03382120653986931, 0.043398406356573105, -0.006044846959412098, -0.03390495479106903, -0.03066468983888626, -0.03643917664885521, -0.03144404664635658, 0.03640623763203621, -0.01924990676343441, 0.0005254669231362641, 0.010385868139564991, -0.02295466512441635, -0.0491834320127964, -0.02372225932776928, -0.06273674219846725, 0.006286920513957739, -0.005017037969082594, -0.05346231535077095, 0.020264776423573494, 0.022982900962233543, -0.051887135952711105, 0.008196662180125713, -0.037425365298986435, -0.011827654205262661, -0.034285783767700195, 0.0054156784899532795, 0.015695588663220406, 0.0062104323878884315, 0.012783699668943882, 0.022988509386777878, -0.007644325029104948, -0.011557676829397678, -0.0953998938202858, -0.06704273074865341, 0.032671038061380386, -0.01584630087018013, -0.0060279471799731255, 0.03464382514357567, -0.0004820721223950386, 0.06575185805559158, 0.007556400261819363, -0.037153009325265884, -0.04917597398161888, -0.001221326063387096, 0.007596995681524277, -0.05437930300831795, 0.012172493152320385, 0.02319077029824257, 0.020848188549280167, 0.06370437145233154, -0.002075463766232133, 0.018832482397556305, 0.025706196203827858, -0.0231980811804533, -0.008009692654013634, 0.03073197975754738, 0.00808133278042078, -0.004980454221367836, 0.011924874037504196, 0.028118902817368507, 0.022287733852863312, 0.0397953987121582, -0.01847829855978489, 0.029346680268645287, 0.013151136226952076, -0.01961240917444229, 0.020555533468723297, -0.01822030171751976, 0.02408606931567192, -0.03058347851037979, 0.020492540672421455, 0.004089522175490856, -0.011341312900185585, -0.023267513141036034, 0.030393222346901894, 0.035913776606321335, -0.005784905981272459, 0.003896387293934822, 0.023508669808506966, 0.004910564050078392, -0.010234086774289608, -0.0036572369281202555, -0.009015720337629318, 0.004012296907603741, 0.010473296046257019, -0.0036088149063289165, 0.016865240409970284, 0.03784012794494629, 0.03141869232058525, -0.025614168494939804, 0.0033973893150687218, -0.012781175784766674, -0.005152304191142321, -0.040574077516794205, -0.018158884719014168, -0.01767854578793049, 0.06447877734899521, 0.017244920134544373, 0.0059058512561023235, 0.013688716106116772, -0.008784464560449123, 0.04736757650971413, 0.043576523661613464, -0.09994861483573914, -0.01055592205375433, 0.016239004209637642, -0.008078848011791706, -0.008025369606912136, -0.057337865233421326, 0.05904942378401756, -0.03486745432019234, 0.002556558232754469, -0.001148710958659649, -0.004955272655934095, -0.0313044898211956, -0.014678357169032097, -0.02681613340973854, -0.007157348562031984, -0.011507195420563221, 0.006953776814043522, 0.00879026297479868, -0.015109025873243809, 0.006349564995616674, 0.017939921468496323, -0.011710112914443016, -0.019198011606931686, -0.0194279495626688, 0.05218375846743584, 0.015034426935017109, 0.07627558708190918, 0.04329110309481621, 0.021167108789086342, -0.018104856833815575, 0.00828621443361044, -0.006975738797336817, 0.037183571606874466, 0.05902944505214691, 0.011813784018158913, -0.060099031776189804, -0.045371003448963165, -0.012935821898281574, 0.03465617448091507, 0.005264395847916603, 0.018010396510362625, -0.0016972884768620133, 0.042981501668691635, 0.032497141510248184, -0.055996544659137726, 0.008270983584225178, 0.04374448210000992, -0.014644638635218143, -0.011977089568972588, -0.012075121514499187, 0.010325412265956402, -0.01565035805106163, 0.030681684613227844, 0.029544809833168983, -0.04390886798501015, -0.011375093832612038, -0.008149998262524605, 0.032751183956861496, -0.014228208921849728, -0.04625668004155159, -0.012821451760828495, 0.022967450320720673, 0.03879536688327789, -0.020114418119192123, -0.03960438445210457, -0.0038878992199897766, 0.01954856887459755, 0.051379237323999405, 0.016167327761650085, 0.01628713868558407, -0.08656046539545059, -0.018202491104602814, 0.03145138919353485, 0.012337613850831985, -0.018269427120685577, -0.01736520603299141, -0.02198939397931099, 0.013465157710015774, 0.01883290335536003, 0.002785734599456191, 0.04271843656897545, -0.003418339416384697, -0.0233731959015131, -0.010328849777579308, -0.054378777742385864, -0.025526810437440872, -0.0026586749590933323, -0.0032730335369706154, 0.01750534027814865, 0.003408110700547695, 0.005694571416825056, -0.016730496659874916, -0.010639832355082035, -0.011451915837824345, 0.08771129697561264, -0.014305281452834606, -0.02374475635588169, 0.013345402665436268, 0.004360825754702091, 0.029118657112121582, -0.07015425711870193, -0.008473471738398075, 0.02943115495145321, -0.025374338030815125, 0.028898796066641808, -0.017420627176761627, -0.0396471805870533, 0.061109188944101334, 0.009019922465085983, -0.03304582089185715, -0.017293907701969147, -0.012193123809993267, 0.0725773349404335, 0.015553128905594349, 0.00979692954570055, 0.04968050494790077, 0.019805122166872025, 0.02804824896156788, 0.0018166769295930862, -0.020998362451791763, 0.00793373491615057, -0.015066769905388355, -0.0528562068939209, -0.030052516609430313, -0.008777698501944542, 0.009515387006103992, 0.025571230798959732, 0.009882618673145771, 0.047403305768966675, -0.009336156770586967, -0.008966385386884212, -0.03053925931453705, 0.026520483195781708, -0.03089422546327114, -0.008430493995547295, -0.009083724580705166, 0.03339122608304024, -0.01706382818520069, 0.021700793877243996, 0.008588509634137154, -0.007891377434134483, 0.016658157110214233, 0.054806847125291824, -0.028188198804855347, -0.012161526829004288, -0.017502574250102043, -0.010914633981883526, 0.007661221548914909, -0.011822647415101528, 0.0286187045276165, -0.008533644489943981, -0.016670549288392067, 0.027350174263119698, -0.05518082529306412, -0.02035130374133587, -0.0051360237412154675, -0.0038249290082603693, 0.002525256248190999, -0.02457355335354805, -0.010259543545544147, -0.027611561119556427, -0.006561276037245989, -0.05518884211778641, -0.03007606603205204, 0.02347223274409771, -0.011274759657680988, -0.014928207732737064, -0.01722516119480133, 0.010693001560866833, -0.01475026085972786, -0.017697978764772415, -0.01618730090558529, 0.061068762093782425, -0.026904847472906113, 0.008858509361743927, -0.0052686878480017185, -0.0007969623547978699, 0.06527658551931381, 0.013571537099778652, 0.010415676049888134, 0.024277353659272194, -0.009219298139214516, -0.0034838677383959293, 0.020274382084608078, 0.03123980388045311, -0.026280108839273453, 0.023583300411701202, 0.005195876117795706, -0.0070829493924975395, 0.03836692497134209, 0.01037532091140747, -0.021991277113556862, 0.02100854553282261, 0.01025026198476553, -0.014753596857190132, -0.02443167194724083, 0.008239038288593292, -0.022182606160640717, -0.006678121630102396, -0.01571875810623169, -0.016605712473392487, -0.020547272637486458, -0.022974470630288124, 0.036820683628320694, 0.005313302855938673, 0.01837107352912426, 0.014133477583527565, 0.07669109851121902, -0.0074133845046162605, -0.007449973840266466, -0.030630692839622498, -0.03763729706406593, 0.08766987919807434, 0.01989724114537239, -0.0004288859199732542, 0.009855685755610466, 0.029004927724599838, -0.06737072765827179, -0.03467629849910736, -0.04584339261054993, 0.012440950609743595, 0.025808438658714294, -0.01479532290250063, 0.05250448361039162, 0.004910506773740053, 0.00957003515213728, -0.002430328167974949, -0.051829542964696884, -0.010666185058653355, 0.005704998038709164, -0.006848657503724098, 0.04644504562020302, -0.003299583215266466, 0.0012364316498860717, 0.0173032209277153, 0.0018778461962938309, 0.0002329894050490111, 0.003938198089599609, -0.035716649144887924, 0.007941421121358871, -0.008597351610660553, -0.044802892953157425, -0.06294987350702286, 0.019945742562413216, -0.04677096754312515, -0.021793628111481667, 0.012031062506139278, -0.03897600620985031, 0.05959940329194069, 0.007908164523541927, 0.0553845651447773, -0.06891108304262161, -0.03460850194096565, -0.0484851710498333, -0.01129399798810482, -0.011376984417438507, 0.0040282332338392735, 0.020002786070108414, 0.0009586136438883841, -0.02097404934465885, -0.0359235480427742, 0.020583616569638252, -0.010005573742091656, -0.10990025848150253, -0.04424959793686867, -0.04998647794127464, -0.039463967084884644, -0.0005206445348449051, 0.0075120506808161736, -0.034762393683195114, 0.02949935756623745, -0.06046001613140106, 0.010877735912799835, 0.028433391824364662, 0.052717067301273346, 0.021934710443019867, 0.06633954495191574, 0.006693909876048565, 0.019523965194821358, 0.008670828305184841, 0.003912391606718302, 0.12487275898456573, 0.12689490616321564, -0.0064017437398433685, -0.0893586128950119, -0.006829455029219389, -0.004067152738571167, -0.027816228568553925, -0.019729679450392723, -0.002015591599047184, 0.02279217541217804, -0.010230428539216518, 0.013654974289238453, 0.0035942262038588524, -0.007855048403143883, -0.009974108077585697, 0.037038929760456085, -0.044645119458436966, -0.004443178419023752, 0.053960565477609634, 0.01548461988568306, -0.003280515782535076, -0.012724076397716999, -0.026272907853126526, 0.011733153834939003, -0.015082504600286484, -0.024921268224716187, -0.009945203550159931, -0.009734679013490677, 0.02393680438399315, -0.033196933567523956, -0.030262568965554237, -0.021632513031363487, 0.016050614416599274, -0.006138617172837257, 0.005323177203536034, 0.019050955772399902, -0.018000895157456398, -0.008647476322948933, -0.008604808710515499, 0.04553661495447159, 0.03636511415243149, 0.00026824959786608815, 0.018007898703217506, 0.006669502705335617, -0.037841327488422394, -0.02209111489355564, -0.05197480320930481, 0.0438697524368763, -0.010556225664913654, 0.00934771541506052, 0.014716481789946556, 0.009259180165827274, -0.007149703800678253, -0.020976509898900986, -0.018457621335983276, 0.011734127067029476, 0.023949971422553062, -0.00696117989718914, -0.021222969517111778, -0.023719338700175285, 0.03398676961660385, 0.028160110116004944, 0.02824673056602478, 0.010677208192646503, -0.022806312888860703, 0.016277818009257317, -0.029363784939050674, 0.0691712349653244, 0.02224980853497982, 0.016864221543073654, 0.03324705362319946, -0.0038204484153538942, -0.009218747727572918, -0.008279371075332165, 0.015057878568768501, -0.021370315924286842, 0.01020017173141241, 0.0006839619600214064, -0.012240207754075527, -0.02616015635430813, -0.0377013273537159, -0.02310161665081978, -0.019203534349799156, 0.035097938030958176, -0.03229602798819542, -0.01497870497405529, 0.01747545786201954, 0.04530630633234978, 0.04493590071797371, -0.00565583910793066, 0.0050803967751562595, 0.045348115265369415, 0.013007569126784801, -0.055659856647253036, -0.03659407049417496, 0.003607135731726885, -0.06251392513513565, 0.036623336374759674, 0.016404427587985992, 0.07242036610841751, 0.01515109371393919, 0.03226463124155998, -0.04242954030632973, 0.03200733661651611, -0.007828961126506329, 0.00829360168427229, 0.004031739663332701, -0.05081592872738838, 0.009495898149907589, -0.02201688662171364, 0.01739342324435711, -0.04031374305486679, -0.019424919039011, -0.014690449461340904, -0.07044121623039246, 0.026692356914281845, 0.00041664348100312054, -0.0023794714361429214, 0.009537025354802608, 0.01948527991771698, -0.009962261654436588, -0.021996336057782173, 0.0002992127847392112, -0.00210706889629364, 0.016307799145579338, -0.007711559534072876, -0.04862650856375694, -0.005036504939198494, 0.013677520677447319, -0.007915296591818333, -0.03994697332382202, 0.029014019295573235, 0.022627731785178185, 0.02008431777358055, -0.026235414668917656, -0.027584506198763847, -0.008766279555857182, 0.07139137387275696, -0.03061838261783123, -0.03057522140443325, 0.029296472668647766, -0.025992870330810547, -0.0038010987918823957, 0.03146921098232269, -0.04680956155061722, 0.05487027391791344, 0.018819188699126244, 0.0009187041432596743, -0.02581127919256687, 0.056257616728544235, 0.01591840200126171, 0.005500113125890493, 0.013771886005997658, 0.020328927785158157, 0.010152525268495083, 0.026755893602967262, -0.0004388296219985932, 0.004872338846325874, -0.009784474968910217, -0.022267568856477737, 0.03492548689246178, 0.021035606041550636, -0.05875857546925545, 0.025347964838147163, -0.005486838053911924, 0.01095766481012106, 0.0010608388110995293, -0.021030569449067116, 0.030503641813993454, 0.0061605023220181465, -0.01325055118650198, 0.047563277184963226, 0.01910228468477726, 0.014981965534389019, -0.08716312795877457, -0.04553435742855072, 0.01964418962597847, 0.015017985366284847, 0.020276183262467384, -0.06810029596090317, 0.01629783771932125, 0.014568409882485867, -0.07219350337982178, 0.015505911782383919, -0.007268898654729128, 0.0056764911860227585, -0.0016564792022109032, -0.007866797968745232, -0.030191466212272644, -0.012120828963816166, 0.03312826529145241, 0.038361236453056335, 0.013279009610414505, 0.011572997085750103, -0.011512460187077522, -0.028386833146214485, -0.04589105769991875, 0.03408670425415039, 0.0036034362856298685, -0.03399255871772766, 0.06694405525922775, -0.03474051132798195, -0.04577619582414627, 0.02687152288854122, -0.02343066781759262, -0.009939070791006088, 0.041983384639024734, 0.021308565512299538, 0.03603293374180794, 0.027908144518733025, 0.05000848323106766, -0.008329611271619797, -0.0008988724439404905, 0.01937798224389553, 0.028977086767554283, 0.005550412926822901, -0.03843625634908676, 0.01694371923804283, 0.005347121506929398, 0.01314638927578926, -0.042387500405311584, 0.0011735892621800303, -0.03054291568696499, -0.012555007822811604, -0.0072801196947693825, 0.0011421728413552046, -0.039438243955373764, -0.04676535725593567, -0.01438930630683899, -0.011985366232693195, 0.0014601952861994505, 0.00899998378008604, 0.04349297657608986, -0.033381734043359756, -0.012268994003534317, -0.006967170629650354, -0.040106795728206635, 0.009356348775327206, 0.0040559167973697186, -0.008134707808494568, -0.03657533600926399, 0.021394502371549606, 0.003456743434071541, -0.020737791433930397, -0.02707713097333908, -0.029393816366791725, -0.0686420276761055, 0.04244224727153778, 0.006788487080484629, 0.01881876029074192, 0.056839704513549805, -0.05621478706598282, -0.002679092576727271, -0.12726673483848572, 0.06248871982097626, 0.006881288718432188, -0.0042810263112187386, -0.024832354858517647, 0.020606914535164833, 0.004894503857940435, -0.00511923199519515, 0.07436925917863846, -0.013902710750699043, -0.0018379020038992167, 0.0023599520791321993, 0.055661577731370926, -0.014902324415743351, -0.0238496083766222, 0.013910534791648388, -0.023480882868170738, -0.015621147118508816, -0.02550390549004078, -0.024717478081583977, -0.00031847256468608975, 0.013706344179809093, -0.008205810561776161, 0.026325274258852005, -0.0012687367852777243, 0.0165169145911932, 0.013634862378239632, 0.05007399618625641, -0.009989726357161999, 0.019765080884099007, 0.06121395528316498, 0.0232143085449934, -0.010218433104455471, -0.003439034800976515, 0.009462209418416023, -0.06304692476987839, 0.006251836661249399, -0.011094301007688046, -0.0031623863615095615, -0.02684551104903221, 0.03706936538219452, 0.014267608523368835, -0.04609503224492073, -0.02293459139764309, 0.06518770754337311, -0.0006434701499529183, -0.009758023545145988, 0.05185610428452492, 0.007547827437520027, 0.03710127994418144, -0.02526121400296688, 0.04470151662826538, 0.009437132626771927, -0.0068522184155881405, 0.011737389490008354, -0.0012138515012338758, 0.006195345427840948, -0.024922316893935204, 0.011327792890369892, 0.016906773671507835, -0.0011487611336633563, 0.03555077314376831, -0.013934584334492683, 0.0643569752573967, -0.018969789147377014, 0.006697783712297678, 0.0038515045307576656, -0.018550241366028786, 0.020005542784929276, -0.005430905614048243, -0.009828334674239159, 0.0461328886449337, -0.025047797709703445, 0.003699743654578924, -0.03633338212966919, -0.027190973982214928, -0.004092110320925713, 0.00817863829433918, 0.01974671147763729, 0.029094867408275604, 0.010725769214332104, 0.010691315867006779, 0.022168293595314026, 0.01569218933582306, 0.005135652609169483, 0.003251534653827548, 0.005734854843467474, 0.005412172991782427, 0.005304171238094568, 0.010097022168338299, -0.02707972563803196, -0.041621580719947815, -0.02087213844060898, 0.015611618757247925, 0.045867353677749634, 0.0415751188993454, 0.009352308697998524, -0.008461814373731613, -0.010957935824990273, 0.02952169068157673, -0.05589291825890541, -0.0071523175574839115, -0.040455445647239685, 0.002533240709453821, -0.02859687991440296, -0.07347927987575531 ]
<p>I was wondering what the following OLS scenario would imply: a variable is endogenous (i.e. correlated with the error term) yet is statistically significant.</p> <p>Alternatively, what if in, once again OLS, the variable is exogenous yet statistically insignificant (although the overall regression is indeed statistically significant - by say an F test).</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
37,130
[ -0.020468123257160187, 0.014110268093645573, -0.014611364342272282, -0.005160988308489323, 0.06743225455284119, 0.058980684727430344, -0.010557172819972038, -0.00007117012137314305, 0.03660091385245323, -0.03996733948588371, -0.005820476915687323, 0.013631557114422321, 0.050615809857845306, -0.0054033235646784306, 0.018633058294653893, 0.018873225897550583, -0.03377774357795715, 0.033843979239463806, 0.024875273928046227, -0.005915832240134478, -0.0110783651471138, 0.02586793340742588, 0.014764447696506977, 0.0073887803591787815, -0.029742369428277016, 0.030606260523200035, 0.024505965411663055, -0.01019534282386303, 0.03082703985273838, 0.0514364056289196, -0.0010478695621713996, 0.02686757594347, -0.028685269877314568, 0.030461512506008148, 0.00941150076687336, 0.028048602864146233, -0.032550912350416183, 0.000750061881262809, 0.04155507683753967, 0.025447513908147812, -0.03327061980962753, -0.034128885716199875, 0.018534785136580467, 0.03195952624082565, 0.001992698758840561, 0.01039083581417799, -0.003986604046076536, -0.03142163157463074, 0.0412515252828598, -0.01979769580066204, 0.0705956444144249, -0.017920242622494698, 0.024829544126987457, 0.026857620105147362, -0.007727777119725943, -0.0013175138738006353, 0.05944092571735382, 0.030349289998412132, -0.00927277933806181, -0.037900496274232864, -0.024024393409490585, 0.02194879576563835, -0.013048283755779266, -0.020527565851807594, -0.01738015003502369, -0.004704976454377174, 0.0005850525922141969, -0.017556503415107727, 0.08238618820905685, 0.013636300340294838, -0.03146607428789139, 0.03190809115767479, 0.007734980434179306, 0.0005263038910925388, 0.018565300852060318, -0.016859041526913643, 0.01534619927406311, -0.0012031567748636007, 0.01727420464158058, 0.00847771018743515, -0.005757612641900778, -0.015196268446743488, 0.01917906291782856, 0.059645287692546844, -0.008970992639660835, 0.024947822093963623, 0.04050910100340843, -0.006841460708528757, 0.03245436027646065, 0.02916456200182438, -0.05339410528540611, -0.011881592683494091, 0.06355734169483185, -0.019961172714829445, -0.03134600818157196, -0.00014379578351508826, -0.022218581289052963, 0.03403909504413605, 0.05369896441698074, 0.02694447711110115, 0.010650742799043655, -0.03482946380972862, 0.014783093705773354, 0.0480104461312294, -0.01787104457616806, -0.029292365536093712, -0.00625432888045907, 0.01672324165701866, 0.007371793035417795, -0.052500925958156586, -0.002688952488824725, 0.0389910452067852, 0.009484483860433102, 0.008619572967290878, 0.052241526544094086, -0.018037980422377586, -0.018052760511636734, -0.0077464091591537, 0.057280994951725006, 0.05031486973166466, 0.04707898572087288, -0.03703637793660164, 0.00687412777915597, 0.025271158665418625, -0.018313663080334663, 0.009275686927139759, 0.02971644140779972, -0.02936372719705105, -0.026880845427513123, 0.06759291142225266, -0.011077397502958775, -0.03886675089597702, -0.0073219784535467625, 0.015353525057435036, 0.0418439656496048, -0.011404198594391346, -0.06327919661998749, -0.060622189193964005, 0.05249880999326706, -0.011213107965886593, 0.018494246527552605, -0.05972929671406746, -0.01707235537469387, 0.026414498686790466, 0.05825706198811531, 0.018630748614668846, 0.013940978795289993, 0.03184209764003754, 0.02214134857058525, 0.022811023518443108, -0.005486208014190197, -0.0070408242754638195, -0.006932344753295183, -0.018143313005566597, 0.015573445707559586, -0.07671383768320084, 0.0008788648992776871, 0.04498839005827904, -0.011685006320476532, -0.03845895454287529, 0.03342167288064957, -0.00473743537440896, -0.03176679462194443, 0.007623197976499796, 0.003495024284347892, -0.018424637615680695, 0.05650782585144043, -0.0262337364256382, 0.03392873704433441, 0.04445088654756546, 0.024629347026348114, 0.04289587587118149, 0.023879067972302437, 0.0621018223464489, 0.02396371029317379, -0.034901417791843414, -0.0056822896003723145, -0.028210043907165527, 0.0034425491467118263, -0.0017212779494002461, -0.08486098796129227, -0.04496528580784798, -0.02597089298069477, -0.02130225859582424, -0.0019139799987897277, 0.025050029158592224, -0.01649167202413082, 0.00033442804124206305, 0.016815850511193275, -0.06045558676123619, -0.030834492295980453, -0.04532213509082794, 0.020752085372805595, -0.005694286432117224, -0.047157254070043564, 0.03352273255586624, 0.0338490828871727, 0.015635831281542778, -0.022069424390792847, 0.021353919059038162, -0.018997589126229286, 0.014260193333029747, 0.03897806257009506, -0.05569888651371002, 0.045240018516778946, 0.03615486994385719, 0.06278764456510544, -0.02391548827290535, 0.02876139059662819, -0.010415703989565372, -0.036901917308568954, 0.023283470422029495, -0.0164424329996109, 0.03509897738695145, -0.02465030364692211, -0.02025344967842102, -0.0014030196471139789, -0.021190468221902847, -0.01097041741013527, 0.06100461632013321, -0.05147658288478851, 0.04817098379135132, 0.05427210032939911, -0.0012031658552587032, 0.0100405253469944, 0.00494993943721056, 0.029509196057915688, 0.023714253678917885, -0.012156210839748383, 0.003337893867865205, -0.048423267900943756, -0.03141830861568451, 0.03478288650512695, 0.032073963433504105, -0.03584722802042961, 0.003590532811358571, 0.08306921273469925, 0.016870105639100075, 0.04414765536785126, 0.046400073915719986, 0.002751750173047185, -0.010525757446885109, 0.00013699816190637648, 0.02271486259996891, 0.02309321239590645, 0.01113214623183012, 0.03675911948084831, 0.0029563969001173973, 0.04157743230462074, -0.005264464300125837, 0.02171577513217926, 0.06408132612705231, -0.02606070600450039, 0.02194000780582428, 0.020020851865410805, 0.012348495423793793, 0.03915134817361832, -0.040488339960575104, 0.00701082032173872, 0.033296551555395126, -0.0019228925229981542, 0.014410297386348248, 0.005916770081967115, -0.007078181020915508, 0.016116701066493988, -0.008210618048906326, -0.0333402156829834, -0.02444000542163849, 0.020181545987725258, -0.00036170470411889255, 0.008381557650864124, -0.022594613954424858, -0.01144481636583805, -0.02790735848248005, -0.011208429001271725, 0.03609466180205345, -0.015322506427764893, 0.01822567731142044, -0.006524363532662392, -0.019065644592046738, -0.024186713621020317, -0.04612237587571144, 0.002300132531672716, 0.0060298386961221695, -0.03636637330055237, -0.013677529990673065, -0.018316203728318214, -0.04872781038284302, 0.06620652228593826, -0.03212447464466095, -0.03041422739624977, 0.04006326198577881, -0.015096543356776237, -0.031073465943336487, -0.021329626441001892, -0.04050494357943535, -0.002996275667101145, -0.044434934854507446, -0.037358954548835754, 0.030925298109650612, -0.01890409365296364, -0.015587812289595604, 0.03559724614024162, -0.03848849982023239, -0.017414910718798637, -0.02399565652012825, -0.02793280966579914, -0.02175326831638813, -0.024218684062361717, 0.05294685438275337, -0.009448002092540264, -0.057497307658195496, -0.04186868295073509, -0.0574820451438427, -0.08415193110704422, 0.023252617567777634, -0.013712513260543346, 0.02191356010735035, -0.052983880043029785, -0.04139574617147446, 0.0747961699962616, 0.011740867979824543, -0.02790001407265663, -0.03271828964352608, -0.0115000419318676, -0.03146962448954582, -0.014457647688686848, 0.0316825732588768, -0.0046567367389798164, 0.026171348989009857, 0.05942605808377266, 0.01448063924908638, 0.041922904551029205, 0.013266448862850666, 0.017207950353622437, 0.025044400244951248, 0.011831033043563366, -0.02077736146748066, 0.023580417037010193, 0.021204816177487373, 0.03345984220504761, -0.03518833592534065, 0.041847314685583115, 0.022615497931838036, 0.058398086577653885, 0.02632477693259716, 0.0025342190638184547, 0.013378152623772621, -0.0006574771250598133, 0.0018624215153977275, -0.00940428115427494, 0.005061049479991198, 0.03737006336450577, 0.0045955367386341095, -0.05779343470931053, -0.015142116695642471, 0.051147229969501495, -0.01189467404037714, 0.029177168384194374, 0.03200840950012207, 0.038485605269670486, -0.004933530930429697, -0.034449253231287, -0.013580627739429474, -0.006344891618937254, 0.05075826868414879, 0.011300913989543915, -0.040168553590774536, 0.05840016528964043, 0.029982207342982292, 0.008361957967281342, -0.009027943015098572, -0.018268603831529617, 0.010864311829209328, -0.05384255573153496, -0.0025534960441291332, -0.026322832331061363, 0.003851311979815364, -0.004411026835441589, 0.015190169215202332, -0.014669926837086678, -0.021386831998825073, -0.020399276167154312, 0.0008379263454116881, -0.059663042426109314, 0.044797133654356, -0.01846865564584732, 0.0056380643509328365, -0.0021876792889088392, 0.0007167188450694084, 0.01673595979809761, -0.07462974637746811, -0.018219096586108208, -0.009569023735821247, 0.04273806884884834, -0.014670798555016518, -0.029976267367601395, -0.012406524270772934, -0.027027662843465805, 0.005677124485373497, 0.011233439669013023, 0.007950868457555771, -0.0000610326933383476, 0.023030225187540054, 0.029865315183997154, -0.017370281741023064, -0.02293296530842781, -0.04217153787612915, 0.0026182213332504034, 0.031239155679941177, 0.05786031112074852, 0.045413341373205185, 0.035430438816547394, -0.03283542022109032, 0.01988900825381279, 0.004631036426872015, 0.028757518157362938, 0.026332803070545197, -0.004459332209080458, -0.06678678095340729, -0.067487433552742, -0.03884962946176529, 0.0037391209043562412, 0.01827569492161274, 0.016553441062569618, -0.012346410192549229, 0.054272908717393875, 0.007797832600772381, -0.036816127598285675, 0.0363285131752491, 0.04187643900513649, 0.03938349336385727, 0.003512922441586852, -0.01887020282447338, -0.031383249908685684, -0.019371284171938896, -0.01550732646137476, 0.060607634484767914, -0.007544367108494043, 0.013447345234453678, -0.02648320607841015, -0.00419111642986536, 0.0004902203800156713, -0.021317338570952415, -0.004178150556981564, 0.02441316470503807, 0.03423042222857475, 0.00305197318084538, -0.04713710397481918, 0.04579225555062294, 0.028476297855377197, 0.021560871973633766, 0.06968384236097336, 0.02895490638911724, -0.06680458039045334, 0.01737319864332676, 0.03959113731980324, 0.00299271778203547, -0.04521201178431511, -0.008665790781378746, -0.009533403441309929, 0.008277682587504387, 0.03536611422896385, -0.008483322337269783, 0.0390760712325573, -0.021813534200191498, 0.030486658215522766, 0.0040547349490225315, 0.010737678967416286, -0.060597147792577744, -0.028458964079618454, -0.00403448985889554, 0.04136880114674568, -0.027260739356279373, -0.04841458797454834, -0.056712523102760315, 0.0226803719997406, 0.035457760095596313, 0.036169640719890594, 0.018766986206173897, -0.031087664887309074, 0.0007711652433499694, 0.06404877454042435, 0.006670556031167507, -0.0717480480670929, 0.035412076860666275, -0.0017691573593765497, -0.016966428607702255, 0.016371838748455048, -0.003646768629550934, -0.0563671737909317, -0.017342809587717056, 0.011589958332479, -0.039269041270017624, -0.013233009725809097, -0.009135184809565544, 0.041361406445503235, 0.04303158447146416, -0.0052423011511564255, 0.03086632490158081, 0.01634056679904461, 0.02321736328303814, -0.003022237680852413, -0.03057294525206089, 0.01644168049097061, -0.05917014926671982, -0.00963817723095417, -0.048677295446395874, 0.0051319473423063755, -0.017736220732331276, 0.00890602171421051, 0.026688748970627785, 0.0028222103137522936, -0.011025993153452873, -0.028729921206831932, -0.001276366994716227, 0.017841733992099762, -0.014068808406591415, -0.04398532211780548, -0.012234017252922058, 0.02825513668358326, -0.02600601501762867, -0.029685232788324356, -0.007462583482265472, -0.0028557362966239452, 0.021228590980172157, 0.030903873965144157, -0.022092947736382484, 0.00317073124460876, -0.016929076984524727, -0.014377713203430176, 0.0015824357978999615, -0.026807164773344994, 0.015815241262316704, 0.0013440439943224192, 0.010811193846166134, -0.035026535391807556, -0.04043366014957428, -0.013898611068725586, 0.03509298712015152, 0.003324326127767563, 0.032702405005693436, -0.03315498307347298, 0.02890772931277752, -0.0040004379115998745, -0.03704053908586502, -0.06275109946727753, -0.06341243535280228, 0.001999282743781805, 0.003908220678567886, 0.010931749828159809, 0.006526496727019548, 0.006828132085502148, -0.049846477806568146, -0.02689908817410469, -0.04049482196569443, 0.06383760273456573, -0.04678142070770264, -0.03837967664003372, -0.0006187194376252592, 0.005395952146500349, 0.06979206204414368, -0.029348550364375114, -0.034179702401161194, 0.01775752566754818, -0.021623877808451653, -0.038506004959344864, -0.01739540509879589, 0.046262141317129135, -0.009429187513887882, 0.014155362732708454, -0.023476822301745415, -0.02202887088060379, 0.029045267030596733, -0.025743385776877403, -0.04146861284971237, 0.006749313324689865, 0.02435588836669922, 0.04652637988328934, 0.003614157671108842, 0.029430383816361427, -0.013057475909590721, 0.05166631191968918, 0.030214710161089897, 0.0005754778976552188, -0.006403750739991665, -0.00977594405412674, 0.04308408126235008, -0.008795770816504955, -0.018542693927884102, 0.03769852593541145, 0.05771404877305031, 0.009212738834321499, 0.00852943491190672, -0.009463825263082981, -0.022829223424196243, 0.051849111914634705, -0.02572060376405716, 0.0052725267596542835, 0.003628500970080495, 0.03716970235109329, -0.05955113098025322, -0.06664010882377625, -0.03730360418558121, -0.0027948394417762756, 0.0721534937620163, -0.01729588396847248, 0.027808401733636856, 0.04067964479327202, -0.014654252678155899, -0.03476673737168312, -0.047485094517469406, 0.004174040164798498, 0.007069417275488377, -0.002243624534457922, 0.029253406450152397, -0.03840462490916252, -0.0023306100629270077, 0.05522364005446434, 0.030559880658984184, 0.004874732345342636, 0.045379363000392914, 0.053073521703481674, 0.015081861987709999, 0.016245001927018166, -0.02554829977452755, -0.07507824152708054, 0.029965205118060112, -0.04679827019572258, 0.02121957577764988, 0.0024758968502283096, -0.01112700067460537, 0.04163480922579765, 0.04947208613157272, 0.008094520308077335, -0.05063890665769577, -0.01512602437287569, -0.0499940924346447, 0.007476246450096369, -0.006921438965946436, -0.03207945078611374, 0.010650821030139923, -0.02063913829624653, 0.048002246767282486, -0.012455763295292854, 0.027512677013874054, -0.030609941110014915, -0.06133975833654404, -0.027554580941796303, -0.0104818781837821, -0.013982121832668781, 0.03650015965104103, -0.006585874129086733, -0.058707524091005325, 0.03767051175236702, -0.04814162105321884, -0.025191448628902435, 0.002756518078967929, 0.053412944078445435, -0.005736054386943579, 0.07485060393810272, -0.003622752847149968, 0.015277048572897911, -0.016794808208942413, -0.02677221968770027, 0.08282649517059326, 0.07187362015247345, -0.008197857066988945, -0.07494675368070602, 0.02091873250901699, -0.0375172384083271, 0.008657924830913544, -0.01755506359040737, -0.020849766209721565, -0.006668782792985439, -0.00967367272824049, 0.0372856967151165, 0.054166972637176514, -0.017186375334858894, 0.003362721763551235, 0.055999867618083954, -0.019768157973885536, -0.021334564313292503, -0.02020075172185898, -0.0002978179545607418, 0.004799005575478077, -0.01007301639765501, -0.046775318682193756, -0.00942600890994072, -0.004392237868160009, -0.04021189361810684, -0.01926664263010025, -0.01458645984530449, 0.01613965816795826, -0.012197437696158886, -0.04105101898312569, -0.015844281762838364, 0.03697098791599274, 0.010682611726224422, -0.0478171743452549, 0.010486177168786526, -0.021311450749635696, -0.0495426319539547, 0.016452554613351822, 0.02886229008436203, 0.007446558680385351, -0.0010415290016680956, 0.010897010564804077, -0.0027190863620489836, -0.04376193881034851, 0.005849193781614304, -0.0005180022562853992, 0.029936008155345917, 0.013628985732793808, -0.022478003054857254, -0.03108862228691578, 0.0011605960316956043, 0.006777934730052948, -0.023447534069418907, -0.026748191565275192, 0.02559233270585537, 0.0001438265899196267, -0.05008646100759506, -0.009985452517867088, -0.021838407963514328, 0.01339749712496996, 0.001788591151125729, 0.019326040521264076, 0.045710522681474686, -0.0154707171022892, -0.005023926496505737, -0.015899937599897385, 0.03366854786872864, -0.008296279236674309, -0.03968929871916771, 0.037011563777923584, -0.005540419835597277, -0.018482841551303864, 0.03004525415599346, 0.011590905487537384, -0.020879801362752914, 0.017415106296539307, 0.009802169166505337, 0.006889544427394867, -0.022017011418938637, -0.007987049408257008, 0.03143054619431496, 0.0034061146434396505, -0.02978171780705452, -0.04564818739891052, -0.007650727406144142, 0.016370462253689766, 0.014296946115791798, 0.03214535117149353, -0.024491623044013977, 0.013994711451232433, 0.03513365611433983, -0.02183207869529724, -0.06962800770998001, -0.013363199308514595, 0.017525339499115944, -0.006721959449350834, -0.012658948078751564, 0.00797967053949833, 0.04265769198536873, 0.012752964161336422, 0.020897559821605682, -0.010120444931089878, 0.014944062568247318, -0.012790974229574203, 0.008579127490520477, 0.027835851535201073, -0.04012008011341095, -0.008997887372970581, 0.019871534779667854, 0.028820941224694252, -0.03775220736861229, -0.029029114171862602, -0.036525946110486984, -0.0014469231246039271, -0.006260477006435394, 0.005326437298208475, -0.042909543961286545, 0.038350559771060944, -0.026169179007411003, 0.055777788162231445, -0.044565532356500626, -0.022007152438163757, -0.07256957143545151, -0.02648797444999218, 0.04749153181910515, -0.011832530610263348, 0.023957250639796257, 0.034082893282175064, 0.0009674079483374953, -0.0030717086046934128, 0.03321424871683121, 0.02125360257923603, 0.015433364547789097, -0.02756226249039173, 0.01578095741569996, -0.007666788529604673, 0.039667148143053055, -0.021258650347590446, 0.009092036634683609, 0.05130476504564285, -0.027466129511594772, -0.05141883343458176, 0.043812789022922516, 0.013869923539459705, 0.045825302600860596, -0.004282644018530846, -0.02026600018143654, -0.06871957331895828, 0.04177746921777725, -0.02777285687625408, 0.009406670928001404, -0.005636854097247124, -0.013361236080527306, -0.0023799228947609663, -0.007719739805907011, -0.0057463813573122025, 0.01653050258755684, 0.028181325644254684, -0.0007413577404804528, 0.06243224814534187, 0.0012455475516617298, -0.04466763138771057, 0.03212415799498558, -0.0012632852885872126, -0.03157934173941612, -0.004752784967422485, -0.03800585865974426, -0.01885710470378399, 0.034635163843631744, -0.03809727355837822, 0.008649082854390144, 0.009425786323845387, 0.017732048407197, -0.08897659182548523, -0.03828972205519676, 0.029117094352841377, 0.01192246563732624, 0.04046878218650818, -0.01801818050444126, 0.004318541381508112, 0.03785783052444458, -0.05251635983586311, -0.03062020242214203, -0.014967456459999084, -0.011080704629421234, -0.042262665927410126, -0.04139941185712814, -0.04361462593078613, 0.03543752804398537, 0.010560102760791779, 0.030357498675584793, 0.031915564090013504, -0.0037403772585093975, -0.0076269772835075855, -0.039906397461891174, 0.0031764099840074778, 0.006538235582411289, -0.008761649020016193, -0.057962674647569656, 0.0663948729634285, -0.02613682486116886, 0.001364228199236095, 0.049828652292490005, 0.0037187908310443163, 0.03892043977975845, 0.03326931595802307, 0.025581981986761093, 0.023118946701288223, 0.048307955265045166, -0.0024130730889737606, 0.008364032953977585, 0.002596129896119237, -0.012505396269261837, 0.020208843052387238, 0.03724153712391853, -0.024667177349328995, -0.016274040564894676, -0.011567830108106136, -0.01391565054655075, -0.007121049799025059, 0.014960522763431072, 0.003966102842241526, -0.00901341438293457, -0.006140821147710085, 0.014536482281982899, -0.0034192621242254972, -0.029776273295283318, 0.07019445300102234, -0.028710540384054184, -0.04729882627725601, 0.04281894490122795, 0.020673520863056183, -0.05004899948835373, 0.009083796292543411, -0.011215869337320328, -0.04147746413946152, -0.006878339685499668, 0.0003617593611124903, -0.01947544328868389, -0.04265540465712547, -0.028375238180160522, -0.0263187475502491, -0.0261346735060215, -0.04201149195432663, -0.02895858697593212, -0.06287514418363571, 0.04995439946651459, -0.0024210282135754824, 0.03399169072508812, 0.02421414852142334, -0.046910081058740616, -0.002556611318141222, -0.12498243153095245, 0.07858824729919434, 0.022551797330379486, -0.01203097216784954, -0.036086469888687134, -0.006603334564715624, -0.050376731902360916, -0.0006964951171539724, 0.06588798761367798, -0.03245483711361885, -0.016634704545140266, 0.009453730657696724, 0.024030806496739388, 0.007169319782406092, -0.0403485931456089, 0.05466226115822792, 0.007093088701367378, -0.02519252337515354, -0.02981802448630333, -0.0014001837698742747, 0.024555586278438568, -0.011996240355074406, 0.0027850524056702852, 0.0067667970433831215, -0.006006123032420874, -0.02559737116098404, -0.024239245802164078, 0.0534895583987236, -0.0029170974157750607, -0.013515569269657135, 0.028957514092326164, -0.000671373272780329, 0.0327368825674057, 0.010698511265218258, 0.002119636395946145, -0.04722275212407112, 0.05796074867248535, -0.009485404938459396, -0.0094711072742939, -0.004608836490660906, 0.029749451205134392, -0.01267278753221035, -0.03791804239153862, 0.000822697242256254, -0.004122952464967966, -0.02466396801173687, 0.010546591132879257, 0.013666513375937939, 0.022092152386903763, 0.046504776924848557, 0.007990140467882156, 0.010582465678453445, 0.01963936723768711, -0.019821081310510635, 0.020074943080544472, 0.036673303693532944, 0.03520520031452179, 0.029940197244286537, 0.021600335836410522, 0.022712718695402145, -0.010113238357007504, 0.03422805666923523, -0.0069914343766868114, 0.020597320050001144, -0.06168572977185249, -0.03153258189558983, 0.035096440464258194, 0.02468290738761425, 0.03681550174951553, -0.003811218310147524, 0.030721018090844154, 0.03716639056801796, -0.04288363456726074, 0.005425082053989172, -0.03288869932293892, 0.01313229463994503, -0.021301837638020515, -0.027018235996365547, -0.0007584549020975828, 0.003503241576254368, 0.0020482914987951517, 0.02039060741662979, 0.03106590360403061, 0.02651183307170868, 0.005297600291669369, -0.015216933563351631, 0.02004452794790268, -0.006133983843028545, -0.06457912176847458, -0.026169585064053535, 0.012348584830760956, -0.03486400842666626, -0.00948404148221016, 0.06261836737394333, 0.06085676699876785, 0.03467922285199165, -0.009032703936100006, -0.022949673235416412, 0.0053962781094014645, 0.04461245611310005, -0.06864634901285172, 0.022782694548368454, -0.012607468292117119, 0.040713582187891006, 0.019850606098771095, 0.007796340622007847 ]
<p>I found several similar questions with no answer. But I'm gonna give it a shot anyway. </p> <p>I'm trying to find assets (stocks) which are co-integrated, since Engle-Granger's test may give cause to spurious regression it's suggested by several articles that you use Johansen's test as well to ensure a long-term co-integration. Even though I've not taken any course in time series analysis yet the Engle-Granger's test was not to difficult to understand. Johansen's test was on the other hand slightly more challenging, so I'm trying to understand how the interpret the results you're given in matlab.</p> <p>So when I run the test for a nx2 vector in Matlab I get a 1x2 matrix as result with the inputs true or false. So the question is when I can reject/not reject the hypothesis.</p> <pre><code>************************ </code></pre> <p>Results Summary (Test 1)</p> <p>Data: Effective sample size: 13 Model: H1 Lags: 0 Statistic: trace Significance level: 0.05</p> <h1>r h stat cValue pValue eigVal</h1> <p>0 1 23.6646 15.4948 0.0031 0.7486<br> 1 1 5.7169 3.8415 0.0170 0.3558 </p> <p>h = </p> <pre><code> r0 r1 t1 true true </code></pre> <p>pValue = </p> <pre><code> r0 r1 t1 0.0031234 0.016977 </code></pre> <p>stat = </p> <pre><code> r0 r1 t1 23.665 5.7169 </code></pre> <p>cValue = </p> <pre><code> r0 r1 t1 15.495 3.8415 </code></pre> <p>mles = </p> <pre><code> r0 r1 t1 [1x1 struct] [1x1 struct] </code></pre>
47,705
[ -0.000523472495842725, -0.028017191216349602, -0.004362119361758232, -0.015271231532096863, 0.05235631391406059, 0.01974768191576004, -0.025285787880420685, -0.015528415329754353, 0.01991426944732666, -0.04941675439476967, 0.06238603964447975, 0.03421749547123909, 0.05573534592986107, 0.024988749995827675, 0.02402769960463047, 0.015003198757767677, -0.031837984919548035, -0.0057723564095795155, 0.015468968078494072, -0.017129044979810715, -0.0010294393869116902, -0.006952280644327402, 0.00011838728823931888, 0.010492837056517601, -0.00972640048712492, 0.030028633773326874, 0.022746125236153603, -0.0012632458237931132, 0.01808837056159973, 0.05007094144821167, -0.05773766338825226, -0.022282971069216728, 0.0010425406508147717, -0.007110188249498606, -0.018998747691512108, 0.035574305802583694, 0.02269173040986061, -0.017603708431124687, 0.014496386051177979, 0.030598612502217293, -0.0018142458284273744, -0.009268959984183311, 0.02217605710029602, 0.046029213815927505, 0.010186754167079926, 0.02698330581188202, 0.05219824239611626, 0.0012053881073370576, 0.062195487320423126, -0.007855416275560856, 0.09281932562589645, 0.03463565558195114, 0.015974150970578194, -0.00318894162774086, -0.010676809586584568, -0.024026136845350266, 0.018036074936389923, 0.03148162364959717, -0.01896222122013569, -0.054319266229867935, -0.042944032698869705, -0.016248049214482307, -0.011277399957180023, -0.025443920865654945, -0.007522455882281065, 0.0263917688280344, 0.01568516157567501, -0.003036491572856903, 0.05510871112346649, -0.05006130784749985, 0.009450911544263363, -0.005476514808833599, 0.015309109352529049, -0.0170426107943058, 0.05303493142127991, -0.011653820984065533, 0.015935605391860008, 0.0396360345184803, 0.01605413667857647, 0.034944504499435425, -0.003614290151745081, 0.030331410467624664, 0.03361076861619949, 0.03510892763733864, 0.05486076697707176, -0.00813623983412981, 0.04200441390275955, -0.025395460426807404, 0.03765777871012688, 0.01663847826421261, -0.018914688378572464, -0.017303016036748886, 0.03232654929161072, 0.0207515861839056, -0.02077552303671837, 0.0018829811597242951, 0.00994451716542244, 0.06277548521757126, 0.0074103111401200294, -0.021881019696593285, -0.04179650917649269, -0.04804275557398796, -0.002107705222442746, 0.017047839239239693, 0.0165773406624794, 0.0008318399195559323, 0.009393002837896347, -0.010658707469701767, -0.03329583257436752, -0.032221000641584396, -0.013712819665670395, 0.04629553109407425, 0.021223248913884163, -0.011105299927294254, 0.0097734946757555, 0.002349540824070573, -0.012189080007374287, -0.009686296805739403, 0.06984400004148483, 0.08954132348299026, 0.04298476502299309, 0.009083287790417671, 0.0014348331606015563, -0.006903162691742182, -0.044506680220365524, 0.020414328202605247, -0.004363533575087786, -0.017901545390486717, -0.03726925328373909, 0.06433209776878357, -0.0015873671509325504, -0.02906394563615322, 0.03674806281924248, -0.011868756264448166, 0.0458495169878006, 0.0012994727585464716, -0.09690507501363754, -0.07617110759019852, 0.0688641294836998, -0.0018627899698913097, 0.0077454810962080956, -0.05979033559560776, -0.01077264454215765, 0.01541670598089695, 0.046415746212005615, -0.007567271590232849, 0.09049993753433228, 0.005918672773987055, -0.02777150832116604, 0.02497180923819542, -0.015083705075085163, -0.02216029353439808, -0.06343181431293488, 0.0011074465001001954, 0.0035654150415211916, -0.025809789076447487, 0.01753953844308853, -0.004429309628903866, -0.0330599844455719, 0.018087174743413925, 0.014484787359833717, 0.04203081130981445, -0.03771721571683884, 0.0035459629725664854, -0.045186471194028854, -0.04476616531610489, 0.03728890046477318, -0.001802454935386777, 0.033574383705854416, 0.012333186343312263, -0.02149192988872528, -0.0006420808495022357, 0.0013850097311660647, 0.03750095143914223, -0.016565589234232903, -0.01766684651374817, 0.02469426952302456, -0.010145692154765129, 0.012198178097605705, 0.006482079159468412, -0.048640500754117966, -0.053734418004751205, -0.043988291174173355, -0.014974004589021206, 0.025264153257012367, 0.04021182656288147, 0.026782548055052757, -0.023312583565711975, 0.024215832352638245, -0.0484134741127491, -0.04498250409960747, -0.06555183976888657, 0.00021012708020862192, 0.014868119731545448, -0.06568075716495514, 0.03464113548398018, 0.00846551451832056, 0.029795635491609573, 0.015634579584002495, -0.011311321519315243, -0.045958325266838074, 0.01657872460782528, 0.028729310259222984, -0.04524197801947594, 0.010968257673084736, -0.0093397106975317, 0.05170685797929764, 0.004486992955207825, 0.02679884247481823, -0.02918517030775547, -0.028577830642461777, 0.0256801750510931, -0.031116051599383354, 0.005308490712195635, 0.03368546813726425, -0.06510986387729645, 0.01697511598467827, 0.025681985542178154, -0.001404538401402533, 0.01840038225054741, -0.010721874423325062, 0.011790219694375992, 0.041402582079172134, -0.007635295391082764, -0.0016372846439480782, 0.004396989941596985, -0.003602678654715419, 0.0259296502918005, -0.03819435462355614, 0.00913477223366499, -0.023019682615995407, -0.0029339035972952843, 0.04496638849377632, 0.05975554510951042, -0.0113380653783679, -0.019257361069321632, 0.04930577427148819, -0.019499944522976875, -0.0075200460851192474, 0.0553133562207222, 0.006626887712627649, -0.03404119238257408, 0.0032265426125377417, 0.033448476344347, 0.022204484790563583, -0.0165469478815794, 0.01951981522142887, 0.012745176441967487, 0.059744030237197876, 0.0023013167083263397, -0.025703171268105507, 0.04757033288478851, -0.046604692935943604, 0.0013187085278332233, -0.01933625340461731, -0.013476562686264515, 0.01782044768333435, 0.008889920078217983, -0.020992526784539223, 0.017004217952489853, 0.03642359748482704, -0.0017329303082078695, 0.0011209873482584953, -0.04009858891367912, 0.02325689233839512, -0.0072683244943618774, 0.011570250615477562, -0.01632874459028244, 0.03116554766893387, -0.011992452666163445, 0.005857132375240326, -0.030332718044519424, -0.02460612915456295, -0.07483179867267609, 0.03143427520990372, 0.04571215808391571, -0.009605963714420795, 0.011474305763840675, -0.03888458386063576, 0.0113285006955266, -0.009333367459475994, -0.024779971688985825, 0.011808210052549839, -0.023031892254948616, -0.0512842983007431, -0.010287397541105747, -0.016902528703212738, 0.017852477729320526, 0.043441612273454666, -0.016131894662976265, -0.0008870277088135481, 0.0628662109375, 0.0027389968745410442, -0.046215884387493134, -0.0473143607378006, -0.03516698628664017, -0.015132631175220013, -0.037745893001556396, -0.0336928628385067, 0.053447626531124115, 0.009842075407505035, -0.07403694838285446, 0.026950567960739136, -0.050617802888154984, -0.01711687259376049, -0.01022871769964695, -0.04474124312400818, -0.03137033060193062, -0.02066921815276146, 0.0022845035418868065, -0.017546746879816055, -0.02205781452357769, -0.01538584940135479, -0.05600075051188469, -0.05433186888694763, 0.005141009110957384, -0.01566869206726551, -0.014066234230995178, -0.01689334027469158, -0.02527468651533127, 0.009617320261895657, 0.01029269490391016, 0.007090628147125244, -0.07164730131626129, 0.0071393284015357494, -0.003587947692722082, -0.019290389493107796, 0.025100836530327797, 0.014527504332363605, 0.050064727663993835, 0.018013063818216324, -0.02819107472896576, 0.039271485060453415, 0.02887294627726078, -0.023117901757359505, -0.0038741561584174633, 0.03108174540102482, -0.05597672611474991, -0.0011832141317427158, 0.054700903594493866, 0.036241315305233, 0.005265293642878532, -0.001602560980245471, 0.030597012490034103, 0.045964401215314865, 0.038236118853092194, -0.02958589419722557, 0.01388680748641491, -0.05676500126719475, 0.015847651287913322, -0.044111452996730804, 0.042083729058504105, 0.015971122309565544, -0.033803340047597885, -0.008003861643373966, -0.018473871052265167, 0.015821242704987526, 0.02017037384212017, 0.02111433632671833, 0.06736678630113602, -0.013493312522768974, 0.010194764472544193, 0.022646358236670494, -0.006260683760046959, 0.008639461360871792, 0.01814235933125019, -0.07085564732551575, -0.04105648398399353, 0.081394262611866, 0.030402518808841705, 0.03689001873135567, -0.0036111981607973576, -0.04825129359960556, -0.02321443147957325, -0.015706917271018028, 0.007834152318537235, -0.043548133224248886, 0.042311377823352814, -0.002053193049505353, 0.04933793097734451, 0.03271269425749779, 0.013982843607664108, 0.00015129841631278396, -0.03799835965037346, -0.05927493795752525, 0.009447178803384304, -0.013147927820682526, -0.005353699903935194, -0.0010313690872862935, -0.027626780793070793, 0.005983363837003708, -0.04893060401082039, 0.04556793347001076, 0.028260720893740654, 0.00010507505794521421, -0.02573291026055813, 0.0277571938931942, 0.025357695296406746, 0.00046098994789645076, -0.04102465510368347, -0.0374780036509037, 0.04735414311289787, -0.009667566046118736, 0.033894848078489304, 0.028949342668056488, -0.018266119062900543, 0.042968425899744034, -0.010834863409399986, 0.00589780556038022, 0.07023316621780396, 0.034908827394247055, 0.06277672201395035, 0.015758180990815163, -0.014432160183787346, 0.002168371109291911, 0.03732549399137497, 0.020652420818805695, 0.029412036761641502, 0.02086348459124565, 0.028646385297179222, -0.030521152541041374, 0.014807991683483124, 0.01833016611635685, -0.001753777964040637, 0.012870080769062042, -0.010334242135286331, 0.01759575866162777, 0.050248850136995316, -0.01448937226086855, 0.012275455519557, 0.10338705778121948, 0.02686789259314537, -0.009511241689324379, -0.04044730216264725, -0.029415728524327278, 0.011410430073738098, 0.005746509879827499, 0.03239554166793823, 0.011089066974818707, -0.038386810570955276, -0.007029381114989519, 0.040234290063381195, -0.0358162596821785, -0.014802993275225163, 0.020150644704699516, 0.04357649385929108, 0.036425430327653885, -0.007286459673196077, -0.027226418256759644, 0.017525389790534973, -0.018840594217181206, 0.03469929099082947, 0.02815154381096363, 0.016828078776597977, -0.10226897895336151, 0.017855428159236908, 0.0667593702673912, 0.012366275303065777, -0.0436629094183445, -0.01295575499534607, -0.03515980392694473, -0.028817828744649887, 0.03512956202030182, -0.025074463337659836, 0.03039734438061714, -0.02268490381538868, 0.013637092895805836, -0.05763663351535797, -0.034363724291324615, -0.030972987413406372, 0.008736065588891506, -0.03843117132782936, 0.016603853553533554, -0.036973338574171066, -0.042408984154462814, -0.023435896262526512, 0.008055229671299458, 0.025061465799808502, -0.01234868261963129, -0.0744655653834343, -0.006722988095134497, 0.012151520699262619, 0.025020144879817963, 0.021527718752622604, -0.07997222244739532, 0.025414645671844482, 0.004481214564293623, -0.0025900432374328375, 0.049852561205625534, -0.005847185850143433, -0.005766724236309528, 0.05356171727180481, -0.008274322375655174, 0.03135086968541145, -0.020954085513949394, -0.03168417885899544, 0.03552359342575073, 0.00975813064724207, -0.00461309589445591, 0.02507568523287773, 0.011737238615751266, 0.007351198233664036, 0.004960097838193178, -0.022309329360723495, -0.029889913275837898, -0.04635113105177879, -0.000010438012395752594, -0.03711036592721939, -0.016722748056054115, -0.020049158483743668, 0.012934958562254906, 0.011004965752363205, 0.018962500616908073, -0.030411068350076675, 0.0376666784286499, 0.045321207493543625, 0.03228508308529854, 0.01669275388121605, -0.03861771151423454, -0.03509340062737465, 0.010857243090867996, -0.0574667751789093, 0.005889139603823423, 0.021934298798441887, -0.0013726106844842434, -0.04437931627035141, 0.020025456324219704, 0.012137006036937237, -0.021028008311986923, 0.02872484363615513, 0.015787063166499138, 0.007963638752698898, -0.009576297365128994, -0.006843654904514551, -0.012266313657164574, 0.0008091938216239214, 0.0018149841343984008, -0.013376960530877113, 0.006750644184648991, 0.039239075034856796, 0.001188497175462544, 0.035359133034944534, 0.028710592538118362, 0.010910896584391594, 0.01135894563049078, -0.03062523901462555, -0.06529103964567184, -0.04345748573541641, 0.00918081309646368, 0.03350574150681496, -0.053022582083940506, -0.02957204170525074, -0.05309772491455078, -0.0019051311537623405, 0.013131274841725826, -0.01625938154757023, 0.03940544277429581, -0.015870412811636925, -0.01765606738626957, 0.01758461818099022, 0.006532326340675354, 0.09392000734806061, -0.011186913587152958, 0.0029428373090922832, 0.021904613822698593, -0.009942890144884586, -0.0071424017660319805, 0.015598650090396404, -0.029987335205078125, -0.0240688044577837, -0.0008879881934262812, -0.06089048832654953, -0.01442806702107191, 0.020709015429019928, -0.03143712878227234, -0.05601156875491142, 0.014817625284194946, -0.02785756252706051, 0.02561767026782036, -0.024865610525012016, -0.01742677018046379, -0.008464326150715351, 0.03479662537574768, -0.014694418758153915, -0.04034788906574249, -0.01930920034646988, -0.008589998818933964, -0.011678698472678661, 0.002696085488423705, -0.027683276683092117, -0.0037188574206084013, 0.04450735077261925, -0.00908694788813591, 0.0074557289481163025, -0.0025067415554076433, 0.013940713368356228, 0.03695265203714371, -0.0036067981272935867, 0.022408628836274147, 0.008712336421012878, 0.01267070509493351, -0.01755204237997532, -0.019798319786787033, -0.05887146666646004, 0.03363173082470894, 0.058115504682064056, 0.00004212653584545478, -0.0003617892798501998, -0.0022416249848902225, 0.014967677183449268, -0.00526048056781292, -0.026548275724053383, -0.033735860139131546, 0.008263970725238323, 0.009223803877830505, 0.035287853330373764, -0.022501418367028236, -0.03792781010270119, 0.04541961848735809, -0.0021390337496995926, 0.020968783646821976, 0.03451289236545563, 0.010617381893098354, 0.010301048867404461, 0.011092995293438435, -0.016186492517590523, -0.03401896357536316, 0.052258044481277466, -0.004480169620364904, 0.029391318559646606, -0.049916286021471024, -0.007488660514354706, 0.027920974418520927, 0.05495608597993851, -0.016332801431417465, -0.07284559309482574, -0.02671121247112751, -0.06525655090808868, -0.01817987859249115, 0.017471570521593094, -0.021445931866765022, 0.018622128292918205, 0.005907236598432064, 0.03419196605682373, 0.01628330908715725, 0.0583542101085186, -0.03633100539445877, -0.057980623096227646, -0.014980973675847054, -0.02208874374628067, 0.005540417041629553, 0.05573924630880356, -0.004993694368749857, -0.028148317709565163, 0.010877246037125587, -0.051624756306409836, -0.0036160722374916077, 0.0008534556836821139, 0.025556521490216255, -0.012966511771082878, 0.042424384504556656, -0.019488200545310974, 0.03694940358400345, -0.017207656055688858, -0.011332067660987377, 0.13875950872898102, 0.06262657046318054, 0.01510592456907034, -0.054584722965955734, 0.007921121083199978, 0.03499989211559296, 0.01711118035018444, -0.052373263984918594, -0.00912987720221281, 0.00164779182523489, -0.008979915641248226, 0.037944894284009933, 0.04310205206274986, -0.013996614143252373, 0.005559864453971386, 0.02567092701792717, -0.03858152776956558, 0.0067409551702439785, -0.0179719477891922, 0.06638384610414505, -0.018880216404795647, -0.060818254947662354, -0.04068780690431595, -0.029818085953593254, -0.0013500549830496311, -0.019713789224624634, -0.009637237526476383, -0.01460697129368782, 0.017206313088536263, 0.017145317047834396, -0.03436718136072159, -0.012010079808533192, 0.006893424782902002, 0.01674543134868145, -0.025105955079197884, -0.015647804364562035, 0.0253696758300066, -0.023742418736219406, 0.016842443495988846, -0.0057352157309651375, 0.0009226971305906773, -0.034717634320259094, -0.015419271774590015, 0.03333941102027893, -0.04179311543703079, -0.009567364118993282, -0.05315117537975311, 0.06419626623392105, 0.01487500499933958, -0.05087503418326378, -0.004230219405144453, -0.013714109547436237, 0.015492760576307774, -0.0541766956448555, -0.015958160161972046, -0.009950113482773304, 0.0006590231787413359, 0.0027481766883283854, 0.018949447199702263, -0.05349738523364067, 0.015148831531405449, -0.019305670633912086, 0.034378163516521454, 0.040821291506290436, -0.038159776479005814, 0.0015748463338240981, -0.031277846544981, 0.0890585407614708, -0.03609852492809296, -0.005857568699866533, 0.045337311923503876, 0.02440849505364895, -0.02560603804886341, -0.004217492416501045, 0.044243741780519485, 0.031576819717884064, 0.013026202097535133, 0.017059680074453354, -0.03616670146584511, -0.012203412130475044, -0.04033411666750908, 0.017739271745085716, -0.02333950065076351, -0.003159257583320141, -0.04718475788831711, -0.007354925386607647, 0.029486550018191338, 0.006703127175569534, 0.010531073436141014, 0.021768996492028236, -0.006656299810856581, 0.06647549569606781, 0.022865137085318565, -0.07155676931142807, -0.0445503294467926, -0.029084544628858566, -0.04597264155745506, 0.0007167253643274307, -0.03181969374418259, 0.04300600290298462, 0.008079173043370247, 0.01038262527436018, -0.052697598934173584, -0.010908749885857105, -0.02824387699365616, -0.01988760009407997, 0.0208286140114069, -0.029341625049710274, -0.01245079655200243, 0.035733290016651154, -0.013871101662516594, -0.020590340718626976, 0.03310754522681236, -0.041627999395132065, -0.03006609156727791, 0.021032607182860374, 0.01019964087754488, -0.03257424384355545, 0.009595234878361225, -0.01089722290635109, 0.04200797900557518, -0.036214280873537064, 0.01993800513446331, -0.04236292093992233, -0.014053476974368095, -0.02035808376967907, -0.002541275229305029, -0.025531230494379997, 0.003050239523872733, -0.04479312151670456, 0.025638632476329803, 0.029615886509418488, 0.03399106487631798, 0.015080426819622517, -0.008690032176673412, 0.011402330361306667, -0.022554904222488403, -0.008894920349121094, 0.01830221712589264, 0.00758726429194212, 0.054705534130334854, -0.0038481387309730053, -0.03154143691062927, -0.005672302097082138, -0.013812616467475891, 0.025695547461509705, -0.010414955206215382, 0.03187480568885803, -0.02502858266234398, 0.05847881734371185, -0.01658199541270733, 0.014215124770998955, 0.00715918792411685, 0.013904484920203686, 0.023114541545510292, 0.017886485904455185, 0.01265142485499382, 0.030261466279625893, -0.011243676766753197, 0.020219819620251656, 0.040485724806785583, -0.01177882868796587, 0.006211915053427219, 0.004178836476057768, -0.01469598338007927, 0.00626389728859067, 0.04995094984769821, -0.03747415915131569, 0.031809329986572266, 0.053722627460956573, 0.010694311000406742, 0.02144131436944008, -0.03572097793221474, 0.026952547952532768, -0.04080795869231224, -0.017895665019750595, -0.02324105240404606, -0.0032867128029465675, 0.040102966129779816, -0.02699856460094452, -0.027304047718644142, 0.02342705987393856, -0.04805472120642662, 0.03664868324995041, -0.010523726232349873, 0.01694604568183422, -0.04573773965239525, -0.004292062483727932, -0.022874927148222923, 0.006101756356656551, 0.02860916219651699, -0.008489529602229595, 0.050927191972732544, 0.049867432564496994, -0.021713100373744965, -0.02587967924773693, -0.006272663827985525, -0.0008595843682996929, -0.0051842727698385715, -0.05207202211022377, -0.004112664144486189, -0.007276485674083233, 0.005057070404291153, 0.011196929961442947, -0.03168143332004547, 0.041286855936050415, 0.021451609209179878, 0.04350722208619118, 0.024140454828739166, 0.029398204758763313, 0.043398015201091766, 0.01917891390621662, 0.03213030844926834, 0.006189771927893162, -0.011992205865681171, 0.015757741406559944, 0.03320606052875519, 0.023128291592001915, -0.02176092192530632, -0.016345929354429245, 0.016401762142777443, -0.027037637308239937, 0.007094397675246, -0.00571265397593379, 0.011524786241352558, -0.014991793781518936, 0.0017589778872206807, -0.027606137096881866, 0.03380349278450012, -0.02691241353750229, -0.03181842342019081, 0.040884796530008316, 0.05249201878905296, -0.034166909754276276, 0.01176939532160759, -0.05507809668779373, -0.021793238818645477, 0.056092843413352966, 0.030414188280701637, 0.013221081346273422, -0.0379817858338356, -0.03605525568127632, -0.012558376416563988, -0.011000520549714565, -0.03388037532567978, 0.013349324464797974, -0.03451750800013542, 0.062296800315380096, 0.0034602058585733175, -0.020242050290107727, 0.041202060878276825, -0.011163905262947083, 0.05400310456752777, -0.07616419345140457, 0.07247009128332138, 0.001476320787332952, -0.023869043216109276, -0.01457352563738823, -0.03317189961671829, -0.03204720839858055, 0.02932620607316494, 0.03756862133741379, -0.0133597981184721, 0.005815289448946714, 0.0058348095044493675, -0.023281604051589966, -0.006578863598406315, -0.038421742618083954, 0.08361406624317169, -0.019552577286958694, 0.01357336062937975, 0.011615950614213943, -0.025009997189044952, 0.04144108295440674, -0.019689790904521942, 0.024088069796562195, 0.006054047029465437, -0.037343546748161316, -0.005995121784508228, -0.030376095324754715, 0.02178553119301796, 0.016409914940595627, -0.024782370775938034, 0.07078924775123596, -0.014841318130493164, 0.018719272688031197, 0.05128723010420799, -0.020977133885025978, -0.05871415138244629, 0.007917978800833225, -0.03154486045241356, 0.005523956846445799, -0.002094605006277561, 0.02050917036831379, 0.029416514560580254, -0.06493870913982391, -0.015261867083609104, 0.03466123342514038, -0.017002461478114128, -0.001852526213042438, 0.03304138034582138, 0.05100783705711365, 0.020110009238123894, -0.005026194732636213, 0.02757839672267437, 0.010730034671723843, -0.010997118428349495, 0.03402424603700638, 0.013708082027733326, 0.03996911644935608, -0.03341274335980415, -0.018997661769390106, 0.026467684656381607, -0.02484953962266445, 0.023948712274432182, -0.04375405237078667, 0.011280062608420849, -0.042498596012592316, -0.0053585730493068695, 0.0063310349360108376, 0.0022192029282450676, 0.006500806659460068, -0.005325512960553169, -0.00221928209066391, 0.07097310572862625, -0.04428019002079964, 0.005715562496334314, 0.03476405143737793, 0.0008429987938143313, 0.0007671226048842072, 0.025222700089216232, 0.03337407857179642, -0.012469365261495113, -0.007081351242959499, 0.019841743633151054, 0.0012638397747650743, -0.01180190034210682, -0.011655212379992008, -0.018628671765327454, -0.0009110703249461949, -0.006441410630941391, 0.003617967711761594, 0.014693234115839005, 0.0087781036272645, -0.05479055270552635, -0.04154261201620102, 0.026667775586247444, 0.004125176928937435, 0.001080288435332477, -0.046047039330005646, -0.028445333242416382, 0.019657405093312263, 0.03893867880105972, -0.06697794795036316, -0.021300053223967552, -0.03296946361660957, 0.011699341237545013, 0.01216223742812872, 0.027400055900216103 ]
<p>I've been using igraph and statnet to do most of my network analysis, but I am trying to replicate results that I use MPNet (an expansion to <a href="http://sna.unimelb.edu.au/PNet" rel="nofollow">PNet</a>) in order to perform some simulations on a multi-level network. I'm hoping someone has experience with PNet or MPNet and can offer a suggestion.</p> <p>I've run a few simulations of small networks, and the output for any specific simulation doesn't really lend itself to being visualized easily in igraph and statnet outside of manually inputting the networks and visual attributes of each vertex. This is problematic for me because I want to simulate large-ish (n>20 in each level) networks. </p> <p><em>However,</em> it does appear that the output is intended to be visualized by the way it is written (see below), but I'm unsure what program it's intended for and cannot find much existing MPNet (or PNet) help online. </p> <p><strong>My question is this:</strong> is there a way to use MPNet output for a specific simulation to visualize the network that is being simulated without manually entering in each network and visual attributes into some package? Or in other words, did MPNet designers have a destination in mind with their output?</p> <hr> <p>The following picture is a quick MSPaint rendition of this 10 vertex multi-level simulated network (because we all need a little MSPaint in our lives): <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/Lts6N.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I have four output text files for a specific simulation (sorry in advance for the huge amount of output):</p> <p>Network A: </p> <pre><code> *vertices 5 1 "" box ic Blue bc Black 2 "" box ic Blue bc Black 3 "" box ic Blue bc Black 4 "" box ic Blue bc Black 5 "" box ic Blue bc Black *matrix 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 1 0 1 1 0 Density 0.7000 Degree Distribution(s) Mean degree 1.4000 Stddev 1.9105 Skewness 0.8547 Clustering coefficent(s) Global 0.8000 </code></pre> <p>Network B:</p> <pre><code>*vertices 5 1 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 2 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 3 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 4 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 5 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black *matrix 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 1 1 0 1 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 Density 0.5000 Degree Distribution(s) Mean degree 1.0000 Stddev 1.6583 Skewness 1.2718 Clustering coefficent(s) Global 0.3750 </code></pre> <p>Network X:</p> <pre><code>*vertices 10 5 1 "" box ic Blue bc Black 2 "" box ic Blue bc Black 3 "" box ic Blue bc Black 4 "" box ic Blue bc Black 5 "" box ic Blue bc Black 6 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 7 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 8 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 9 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 10 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black *edges 1 6 1 9 3 7 3 8 3 9 3 10 4 6 4 7 4 8 5 8 5 9 Density 0.4400 Degree Distribution(s) Mean degree A 2.2000 Stddev A 1.4832 Skewness A -0.2648 Mean degree B 2.2000 Stddev B 0.8367 Skewness B -0.2459 Clustering coefficent Global 0.2667 </code></pre> <p>Network M:</p> <pre><code>*vertices 10 1 "" box ic Blue bc Black 2 "" box ic Blue bc Black 3 "" box ic Blue bc Black 4 "" box ic Blue bc Black 5 "" box ic Blue bc Black 6 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 7 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 8 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 9 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black 10 "" ellipse ic Red bc Black *edges 1 2 1 c Blue 1 3 1 c Blue 1 4 1 c Blue 1 5 1 c Blue 3 4 1 c Blue 3 5 1 c Blue 4 5 1 c Blue 6 8 1 c Red 7 8 1 c Red 7 10 1 c Red 8 9 1 c Red 8 10 1 c Red 1 6 1 c Black 1 9 1 c Black 3 7 1 c Black 3 8 1 c Black 3 9 1 c Black 3 10 1 c Black 4 6 1 c Black 4 7 1 c Black 4 8 1 c Black 5 8 1 c Black 5 9 1 c Black </code></pre> <p>*Also, if someone has enough reputation and feels the need to add the tags PNet and/or MPNet to this post so that it could be more specific, I would appreciate it.</p>
74,304
[ -0.039574626833200455, 0.012538489885628223, -0.01229553110897541, -0.014357296749949455, 0.04146050289273262, 0.009297115728259087, -0.006195013877004385, -0.027941888198256493, 0.020192842930555344, -0.04607800394296646, 0.04042819142341614, 0.07885118573904037, 0.036986976861953735, 0.026605363935232162, -0.0007100086659193039, 0.015533954836428165, -0.03252451866865158, -0.0011139101115986705, 0.003593354718759656, -0.028270261362195015, 0.007364840712398291, -0.0035468696150928736, -0.02184913493692875, -0.025113282725214958, 0.00862624030560255, 0.04982965439558029, 0.009519667364656925, -0.03034508414566517, 0.0038538675289601088, 0.008017542771995068, -0.028857601806521416, -0.01683313399553299, -0.008230985142290592, 0.026441393420100212, 0.004014072939753532, 0.0015322166727855802, -0.01851080171763897, -0.047057218849658966, 0.024010492488741875, 0.0008848963771015406, 0.01912076771259308, 0.04225010797381401, -0.02043052390217781, 0.017826806753873825, -0.021267175674438477, 0.016187338158488274, 0.004192080814391375, 0.0016167521243914962, 0.03145279362797737, -0.04096643626689911, 0.037907250225543976, 0.01044534519314766, 0.02400570549070835, 0.029534274712204933, -0.021236255764961243, -0.02854613959789276, 0.05648447200655937, 0.06167958676815033, 0.017088020220398903, -0.06887606531381607, 0.013299545273184776, 0.008557697758078575, -0.033942434936761856, -0.07410047203302383, -0.032767292112112045, 0.03570232167840004, 0.03231942653656006, -0.016657602041959763, 0.03774869069457054, -0.04129091650247574, 0.015730496495962143, -0.01148589700460434, 0.04204918444156647, -0.02336679957807064, 0.0028384418692439795, 0.03091241605579853, 0.06914818286895752, -0.01217165682464838, 0.04054660722613335, 0.045690130442380905, -0.02402307093143463, 0.0211295485496521, -0.01005309447646141, -0.006700946483761072, 0.03473414480686188, -0.002954609924927354, 0.04746565967798233, -0.03221782669425011, 0.014147335663437843, 0.011403238400816917, -0.04434408247470856, -0.023459335789084435, 0.027879739180207253, -0.0016544286627322435, 0.0007574254414066672, -0.001105593633837998, -0.02296239323914051, 0.04841877520084381, -0.014549726620316505, -0.017804061993956566, -0.03449148312211037, -0.02843233197927475, -0.037649739533662796, 0.022317688912153244, 0.02035623975098133, 0.03086381033062935, -0.016411179676651955, -0.006304319482296705, -0.005143309943377972, 0.004526903852820396, -0.03789428994059563, 0.013534557074308395, -0.00180765800178051, 0.03310244902968407, -0.001494361087679863, -0.057543884962797165, 0.022332271561026573, 0.03214886039495468, 0.008874306455254555, 0.07749154418706894, 0.0022375828120857477, -0.03687611222267151, 0.033719126135110855, -0.06524669378995895, -0.033385977149009705, 0.01161218248307705, 0.029072517529129982, -0.0011787788243964314, -0.02708391286432743, 0.04471290484070778, 0.01576271839439869, -0.011829928494989872, 0.021103184670209885, -0.019298706203699112, 0.026522232219576836, -0.01627972163259983, -0.07505512237548828, -0.04798448830842972, 0.036360375583171844, -0.012077673338353634, 0.01932719722390175, -0.029393775388598442, -0.02181590534746647, 0.03516509756445885, 0.03879737854003906, 0.0031837248243391514, 0.01891534961760044, 0.008717753924429417, 0.024788692593574524, 0.02313179336488247, -0.008731967769563198, 0.025025252252817154, -0.036738865077495575, 0.01767701469361782, 0.012103927321732044, -0.08853428810834885, 0.03932880237698555, 0.035229139029979706, -0.01553033385425806, 0.02083243615925312, 0.03271658346056938, 0.011040974408388138, -0.006306479685008526, 0.020614536479115486, -0.009620516560971737, -0.03386770188808441, 0.06887438148260117, -0.008702971041202545, 0.05066845193505287, -0.0006961768376640975, -0.0324234664440155, 0.014995378442108631, -0.008965964429080486, 0.023456526920199394, 0.013664083555340767, 0.014220895245671272, -0.009835255332291126, 0.015310916118323803, -0.024164773523807526, 0.02864925004541874, -0.020837701857089996, -0.03911310434341431, -0.027736255899071693, 0.004752376116812229, 0.004001920577138662, 0.04656496271491051, 0.007980539463460445, -0.019379541277885437, 0.0425218865275383, -0.04503851383924484, -0.061035335063934326, -0.026579611003398895, 0.026365378871560097, -0.03506350889801979, -0.0038546337746083736, 0.008197098970413208, -0.0228158850222826, 0.009503372944891453, 0.03090970776975155, -0.030840495601296425, -0.034147102385759354, 0.019476264715194702, 0.045455146580934525, -0.008478852920234203, -0.017418362200260162, 0.0058504738844931126, 0.07097131758928299, -0.01489993929862976, -0.00729760155081749, -0.05204174667596817, -0.02064264938235283, -0.004296792671084404, -0.015704406425356865, 0.014474217779934406, 0.0018887277692556381, -0.02739364095032215, -0.006259586662054062, 0.0322159007191658, -0.013910260982811451, -0.004281327128410339, -0.02285200171172619, 0.076589435338974, 0.07056000828742981, 0.024783886969089508, -0.0014507861342281103, 0.0005689737154170871, -0.003609603503718972, 0.007618304342031479, -0.00649080378934741, 0.026048623025417328, -0.07151118665933609, -0.03287482261657715, 0.03898366168141365, 0.014899572357535362, -0.06797585636377335, 0.0183863528072834, 0.0546148344874382, 0.02053866907954216, 0.0234344694763422, 0.014524225145578384, -0.014132664538919926, -0.010713687166571617, 0.026088282465934753, 0.04640552029013634, 0.039302121847867966, 0.02083800546824932, 0.04393823444843292, 0.0233069509267807, 0.019813133403658867, 0.009042704477906227, -0.01604923978447914, 0.01720009185373783, -0.06317757070064545, -0.0018479602877050638, -0.01711316779255867, -0.03364383056759834, 0.05836982652544975, -0.028229625895619392, -0.011654750443994999, 0.018946431577205658, 0.013751879334449768, -0.019865859299898148, -0.00027658301405608654, -0.030132150277495384, -0.006778042297810316, 0.05193915218114853, -0.02310332842171192, 0.004537856671959162, -0.0010680689010769129, -0.015841035172343254, 0.06465653330087662, -0.03127114847302437, 0.017980948090553284, -0.0651504248380661, 0.05354207754135132, 0.01512865163385868, -0.00816385354846716, 0.005757039412856102, -0.04751720279455185, -0.009911985136568546, 0.016220280900597572, -0.0287167988717556, 0.03460267558693886, 0.012832838110625744, -0.033204708248376846, 0.0009627193212509155, -0.01928139105439186, -0.04638819023966789, 0.03132309392094612, -0.02110111713409424, -0.04155220463871956, 0.009401875548064709, -0.013091810047626495, -0.04479462653398514, -0.05068904906511307, -0.022401805967092514, 0.008959682658314705, 0.0012296084314584732, 0.016001377254724503, 0.03953789919614792, 0.03194809332489967, -0.04993516951799393, 0.03849618881940842, -0.01217807549983263, -0.016553884372115135, -0.003606333862990141, -0.014785178937017918, 0.00885191559791565, -0.0033251899294555187, 0.012052370235323906, 0.03563692420721054, -0.045494597405195236, 0.00422642519697547, -0.04693707823753357, -0.04430564120411873, 0.012464644387364388, 0.009608198888599873, 0.022362999618053436, -0.005005496088415384, 0.02324938029050827, 0.0579833947122097, -0.007028259336948395, -0.06682707369327545, -0.05648605152964592, 0.014505758881568909, -0.017951196059584618, -0.005566829815506935, 0.03942028433084488, -0.011154341511428356, 0.01564585044980049, -0.016842594370245934, -0.0325511172413826, 0.034321192651987076, 0.06987947970628738, -0.03246137127280235, 0.00808052346110344, 0.05459173768758774, -0.019723335281014442, -0.04064546898007393, 0.018934298306703568, -0.009624508209526539, -0.03758930787444115, 0.005550513043999672, -0.01414503250271082, 0.015741683542728424, -0.01639348454773426, -0.06257016211748123, 0.04053105041384697, -0.022415898740291595, -0.01894417777657509, -0.04751267284154892, -0.027840755879878998, -0.019470253959298134, 0.003249415894970298, -0.0037925306241959333, 0.027544375509023666, 0.064287468791008, -0.017515337094664574, 0.007330609019845724, 0.07141974568367004, 0.003998391795903444, -0.03509136289358139, 0.013079631142318249, 0.026265164837241173, -0.017089804634451866, -0.010564872063696384, 0.001743115484714508, -0.0032847069669514894, 0.021890416741371155, 0.028059814125299454, 0.013768373057246208, 0.055578138679265976, -0.029299434274435043, 0.038624659180641174, -0.022098805755376816, 0.01984667405486107, -0.09240081906318665, 0.04865716025233269, -0.025241278111934662, 0.03794807568192482, -0.004856326151639223, -0.012878891080617905, -0.013834998942911625, -0.012604846619069576, -0.061065785586833954, 0.0041694194078445435, 0.02546878345310688, -0.012751792557537556, 0.03690870478749275, -0.023293163627386093, 0.027297869324684143, -0.01689600571990013, 0.027047624811530113, 0.0246724896132946, 0.04168495908379555, -0.03177909925580025, -0.00438799150288105, -0.0002192858955822885, -0.005500782281160355, -0.031928740441799164, 0.00876370258629322, 0.040424883365631104, 0.005108716432005167, 0.020548762753605843, 0.013018717989325523, -0.005097655113786459, -0.012341762892901897, -0.04154251143336296, -0.023174064233899117, 0.01913559064269066, 0.005926219746470451, 0.03214870020747185, 0.06599561125040054, -0.06922245025634766, -0.0024522922467440367, 0.001956409541890025, 0.06518152356147766, 0.02988489530980587, -0.0094257527962327, -0.006588665768504143, -0.06156080216169357, -0.03089009039103985, 0.03005894273519516, 0.03318685293197632, -0.006839223206043243, -0.01602519303560257, 0.05555568262934685, -0.004811118356883526, -0.05482584983110428, 0.08198262006044388, 0.05275273695588112, 0.0038555944338440895, -0.011380364187061787, -0.03414331376552582, 0.004834228660911322, 0.005444047506898642, -0.007356945890933275, 0.05206229165196419, 0.011738281697034836, -0.010955704376101494, -0.010076339356601238, 0.013444893062114716, -0.004313693381845951, -0.044320277869701385, 0.014149506576359272, 0.006096726283431053, 0.04001633822917938, 0.007680273149162531, 0.015130074694752693, 0.025886336341500282, 0.028784094378352165, -0.013568994589149952, 0.03761772811412811, -0.0006065478664822876, -0.09277292340993881, -0.0340447723865509, 0.03793160244822502, 0.02506030723452568, 0.003985943738371134, -0.01955472305417061, -0.04815495386719704, -0.01834900863468647, 0.028725143522024155, -0.027918560430407524, 0.0368986539542675, -0.014264795929193497, 0.036611348390579224, -0.0221610926091671, -0.011048072949051857, -0.012783358804881573, 0.01433476060628891, -0.06485309451818466, 0.0238482765853405, -0.06237603351473808, 0.012842644937336445, -0.015328091569244862, 0.009460899978876114, -0.002468389691784978, 0.06314738839864731, -0.015190273523330688, -0.005532742012292147, 0.023252880200743675, 0.002260626060888171, -0.03248881548643112, -0.08268376439809799, 0.04773135110735893, -0.009894615970551968, 0.011300872080028057, 0.043645698577165604, 0.013585417531430721, -0.016174571588635445, 0.034850962460041046, -0.0004290748620405793, -0.019234485924243927, -0.0050759995356202126, -0.04796973615884781, 0.07787161320447922, 0.007083056960254908, -0.04895438626408577, 0.025401972234249115, 0.014625873416662216, -0.02112870290875435, 0.009865840896964073, -0.03731554001569748, 0.04255025088787079, -0.03241916373372078, -0.03462233766913414, -0.029916295781731606, 0.009885652922093868, 0.02438538148999214, 0.029859593138098717, -0.00029070989694446325, 0.048832908272743225, 0.005885002203285694, -0.00836176984012127, 0.0055097294971346855, 0.0415356270968914, -0.014882538467645645, 0.014693408273160458, 0.022148022428154945, -0.022790418937802315, 0.00676491716876626, -0.04363071173429489, 0.022570179775357246, -0.009910660795867443, -0.021479040384292603, 0.03373778983950615, -0.03495551645755768, -0.01395361963659525, -0.0052819810807704926, -0.023830804973840714, -0.019468048587441444, -0.04261104762554169, 0.0687672421336174, 0.030856892466545105, 0.049997393041849136, 0.0014484463026747108, -0.059183839708566666, -0.03655688837170601, 0.04407444968819618, -0.006323444191366434, -0.02163155935704708, -0.013013816438615322, 0.00946680549532175, -0.05498519912362099, -0.009974065236747265, -0.04381555691361427, -0.06391483545303345, 0.009189576841890812, 0.02245592139661312, -0.03810814023017883, -0.03578552231192589, -0.030157914385199547, 0.04404952749609947, 0.00800221785902977, 0.01331652794033289, 0.024547051638364792, -0.039741337299346924, 0.014352926053106785, 0.0036528606433421373, 0.0025251121260225773, 0.07534456253051758, 0.023532792925834656, -0.002963100792840123, -0.011351929977536201, -0.022376863285899162, 0.01534968614578247, 0.020307675004005432, 0.017354892566800117, -0.004132622387260199, -0.003904174081981182, 0.0032793309073895216, 0.0313960500061512, 0.055505476891994476, -0.002697790740057826, -0.004785166122019291, 0.008909059688448906, -0.013583282940089703, -0.009209155105054379, -0.022938665002584457, -0.003935321234166622, -0.04119986668229103, 0.0062735904939472675, -0.030320722609758377, 0.027355792000889778, -0.03384232148528099, -0.015814272686839104, 0.006284408736974001, -0.019559187814593315, -0.008139829151332378, 0.029545633122324944, 0.07548058032989502, 0.019977331161499023, 0.006473993882536888, 0.00012635755410883576, -0.008350113406777382, 0.027133947238326073, -0.009150682017207146, 0.008403614163398743, -0.015782974660396576, 0.04194512218236923, -0.01963450014591217, -0.028685731813311577, -0.045520052313804626, -0.0002675908326637, 0.028685886412858963, 0.023271828889846802, 0.03535601496696472, 0.04148082062602043, -0.044667672365903854, 0.015495006926357746, -0.052742987871170044, 0.001544495578855276, 0.01881849765777588, 0.03293537348508835, 0.050950951874256134, -0.015627898275852203, -0.04008910804986954, 0.04334667697548866, 0.049988992512226105, -0.006436783820390701, 0.029195215553045273, 0.006848933640867472, -0.022304220125079155, 0.03629409521818161, -0.012786171399056911, -0.03514014557003975, 0.013053121976554394, -0.06831413507461548, 0.03835069388151169, -0.039244554936885834, -0.019729554653167725, 0.04132557660341263, 0.03623639792203903, 0.012126234360039234, -0.035211458802223206, 0.007646053098142147, -0.04494660720229149, 0.010893521830439568, 0.03528760001063347, -0.003950715996325016, -0.008841180242598057, 0.00506964884698391, 0.019100617617368698, -0.04517112299799919, 0.05470261350274086, -0.042284250259399414, -0.04403749480843544, -0.058255285024642944, -0.04118480905890465, -0.021275002509355545, 0.03507477790117264, -0.0011849629227072, -0.020425274968147278, 0.013854221440851688, -0.046139590442180634, 0.023781979456543922, -0.02573849819600582, 0.028103549033403397, 0.015539485029876232, 0.033625952899456024, -0.019456518813967705, 0.002817421220242977, 0.01063845306634903, -0.01514188852161169, 0.14056552946567535, 0.06906318664550781, 0.03781502693891525, -0.08917615562677383, 0.014969712123274803, -0.005598159972578287, -0.0017799966735765338, -0.027033602818846703, 0.019819263368844986, 0.015591725707054138, -0.038288574665784836, 0.011354620568454266, 0.05333612486720085, 0.013521062210202217, 0.028116609901189804, 0.04524170607328415, -0.03194538131356239, -0.04749445989727974, -0.0010689521441236138, 0.004354387987405062, -0.04567805677652359, 0.02043636329472065, -0.0994981974363327, 0.004434665199369192, 0.015051011927425861, -0.006147816777229309, -0.018548084422945976, 0.001340211951173842, 0.04892868176102638, 0.024229926988482475, -0.025180567055940628, -0.011361091397702694, 0.03316490724682808, -0.006090056151151657, 0.0006133405840955675, -0.021624799817800522, 0.007610696833580732, -0.019683053717017174, 0.03168885409832001, 0.03796156123280525, -0.007161491550505161, -0.005117082502692938, -0.041491392999887466, -0.029295455664396286, -0.016879741102457047, -0.0011330376146361232, -0.025314921513199806, 0.07049974799156189, 0.008116121403872967, -0.01792820543050766, -0.007389987353235483, 0.006921668071299791, -0.027154957875609398, -0.010038316249847412, 0.027013547718524933, 0.0025885161012411118, 0.021854933351278305, 0.013190806843340397, -0.0034068129025399685, -0.01682426407933235, 0.015280158258974552, -0.03146028146147728, -0.0029546828009188175, 0.0026986694429069757, -0.030320381745696068, -0.04084497690200806, -0.04225877672433853, 0.006841076537966728, 0.0009583948994986713, 0.011847512796521187, -0.008536843582987785, -0.03704864904284477, -0.007027026731520891, -0.055229444056749344, 0.0014403370441868901, 0.046350836753845215, -0.0015762709081172943, 0.04658924788236618, -0.01179223321378231, -0.012700756080448627, -0.02287628874182701, -0.00427298853173852, -0.024005673825740814, -0.02732781320810318, 0.00659838505089283, -0.007392530329525471, 0.07619345933198929, 0.06004764884710312, 0.014650429598987103, 0.024366162717342377, -0.010198039002716541, 0.022250747308135033, 0.03569253161549568, -0.046225015074014664, -0.01617325097322464, 0.004240906797349453, -0.04155343025922775, -0.008159812539815903, -0.019606074318289757, 0.03268323838710785, 0.03212645649909973, -0.02411576732993126, -0.0022722394205629826, 0.027944987639784813, 0.04669123888015747, -0.0011895326897501945, 0.014604258351027966, -0.059833962470293045, 0.05380420386791229, -0.006147772539407015, 0.007978594861924648, -0.01341732032597065, 0.017062800005078316, -0.005631502717733383, -0.027199236676096916, 0.010565822944045067, -0.017950057983398438, -0.040143851190805435, 0.027058232575654984, -0.019366713240742683, 0.034553077071905136, -0.018597623333334923, -0.00857190228998661, -0.055537447333335876, -0.04647107422351837, -0.005766586866229773, 0.006006831768900156, -0.04546875134110451, 0.020492374897003174, -0.018610013648867607, 0.005181115120649338, 0.04234975203871727, 0.02221912331879139, -0.009738229215145111, -0.00251846038736403, 0.004088855814188719, 0.034549281001091, 0.04247509315609932, 0.011344319209456444, -0.018268300220370293, 0.037856411188840866, -0.01755199022591114, -0.022310227155685425, 0.015723941847682, -0.01681617461144924, 0.057650126516819, 0.04157354310154915, -0.007584919687360525, -0.031641919165849686, 0.07977381348609924, -0.04390065744519234, -0.002720119897276163, -0.008129686117172241, 0.014751354232430458, 0.040668219327926636, 0.01753617450594902, -0.009494882076978683, -0.016980720683932304, 0.0028673314955085516, 0.004165349993854761, -0.009942421689629555, 0.007118595764040947, -0.06947824358940125, -0.047078851610422134, -0.027948047965765, 0.03466985747218132, 0.015556116588413715, -0.006822491995990276, 0.024718495085835457, 0.019391801208257675, -0.03550802916288376, 0.024923698976635933, 0.014278452843427658, -0.019246816635131836, -0.06742100417613983, -0.03257627785205841, -0.026416009292006493, 0.01541174203157425, 0.04442615434527397, -0.046592094004154205, 0.04004431515932083, 0.016305329278111458, -0.09622976183891296, -0.011354014277458191, 0.01861971989274025, -0.025726087391376495, -0.006680779159069061, -0.012564701959490776, -0.022387785837054253, 0.019944965839385986, -0.004309449344873428, 0.035621464252471924, 0.0175226591527462, -0.014721551910042763, -0.03915446996688843, 0.015189929865300655, -0.04210219904780388, 0.02232879213988781, 0.02687937021255493, -0.014928136020898819, -0.005643992219120264, -0.038337890058755875, -0.053530819714069366, 0.021948212757706642, 0.00532307056710124, 0.013911486603319645, 0.02346699684858322, 0.011948877014219761, -0.01713716983795166, 0.08068061619997025, 0.052635129541158676, -0.007343176286667585, 0.0511493943631649, -0.02327362634241581, -0.013642464764416218, 0.012541161850094795, -0.005414022598415613, 0.04189041629433632, 0.01281414832919836, 0.014384426176548004, -0.02101743221282959, 0.023035472258925438, -0.035987112671136856, -0.04540971294045448, -0.045295536518096924, -0.01686130464076996, 0.07064840197563171, -0.012218558229506016, 0.03576280176639557, -0.040203630924224854, 0.022510157898068428, 0.022997885942459106, 0.024694744497537613, -0.007607519160956144, -0.010522454045712948, -0.009413326159119606, -0.04843227192759514, 0.00815617386251688, -0.015513201244175434, -0.05508851632475853, -0.039123065769672394, -0.03404170647263527, 0.00878853164613247, 0.011803759261965752, -0.001187000423669815, -0.029110955074429512, -0.010349602438509464, 0.0258830226957798, -0.0050919861532747746, 0.01898852176964283, -0.012759632430970669, -0.03225202113389969, 0.05335415154695511, -0.05316491425037384, 0.025713423267006874, -0.007913514040410519, 0.0030039330013096333, -0.030531520023941994, 0.014791076071560383, 0.004245049320161343, -0.0033995495177805424, 0.057307735085487366, 0.018390726298093796, 0.009883393533527851, -0.003913705702871084, 0.0322551392018795, 0.029736848548054695, -0.03491765260696411, 0.026349587365984917, -0.01802341639995575, -0.020403629168868065, -0.019714834168553352, -0.015342014841735363, 0.022406987845897675, 0.041805483400821686, 0.03455474600195885, 0.05301741883158684, -0.038485921919345856, -0.006889827083796263, -0.018560532480478287, -0.007728779222816229, -0.035020861774683, -0.02018536627292633, 0.040960848331451416, 0.013319146819412708, -0.01910177618265152, 0.03880556672811508, 0.047012049704790115, -0.010225530713796616, -0.0010617619846016169, -0.026400882750749588, -0.0015675912145525217, -0.00038122799014672637, 0.01653578132390976, 0.016351299360394478, -0.0847487598657608, 0.043938178569078445, -0.025292254984378815, 0.007813414558768272, -0.028674501925706863, 0.06944192945957184, 0.034929607063531876, -0.016617363318800926, 0.015789708122611046, 0.03213440626859665, 0.0081027215346694, -0.039389804005622864, 0.009778594598174095, 0.002314602490514517, -0.011856372468173504, 0.01434548944234848, 0.048215653747320175, 0.019558675587177277, -0.011430308222770691, 0.058297038078308105, -0.010796144604682922, 0.0488421767950058, -0.030655857175588608, -0.013649837113916874, 0.051096733659505844, -0.014587032608687878, 0.034721314907073975, 0.0023695870768278837, -0.009261419996619225, 0.06330198794603348, -0.01685335300862789, 0.020074335858225822, -0.028840379789471626, -0.03199275583028793, -0.022503940388560295, 0.02278127707540989, -0.006350523326545954, 0.043021269142627716, -0.021008750423789024, 0.003175733145326376, -0.0186407919973135, -0.0010747724445536733, 0.029871048405766487, -0.04337625578045845, -0.005083155818283558, -0.0060165696777403355, -0.015401897951960564, 0.013858703896403313, -0.0013351135421544313, -0.0074731349013745785, -0.011981428600847721, 0.016396833583712578, 0.023882826790213585, -0.002010383876040578, -0.004825128708034754, -0.007033805828541517, 0.018731845542788506, 0.024310721084475517, -0.05558643117547035, 0.008614638820290565, -0.03780476376414299, 0.002427338855341077, 0.01174926571547985, 0.02972293086349964 ]
<p>I have a set of data that represents periodic readings. The data shows an upward trend but I need to test for a statistical difference from zero. I believe I should use the t test, two tailed but what should I use for the second set of data? Zeros, the starting value?</p> <pre><code>0.2245 0.243 0.2312 0.1795 0.1923 0.17 0.2025 0.2059 0.2394 0.205 0.2201 0.2261 0.1817 0.2143 0.2126 0.237 0.1984 0.228 0.2292 0.2236 0.2096 0.2258 0.2155 </code></pre>
48,875
[ -0.002451646840199828, -0.03439432010054588, 0.00425712950527668, 0.02715957909822464, 0.026253633201122284, -0.0012884577736258507, 0.019724320620298386, -0.017536288127303123, -0.0004779910377692431, -0.013795259408652782, 0.027318598702549934, 0.04211470112204552, 0.0199018195271492, 0.01796458102762699, 0.07899235934019089, -0.0029617655090987682, -0.03165565803647041, -0.031831223517656326, 0.0028226906433701515, 0.014547132886946201, -0.005530851427465677, -0.03549324348568916, 0.014858894981443882, 0.011474988423287868, -0.03779518976807594, 0.0415058359503746, 0.03022872842848301, -0.013651642017066479, -0.024519283324480057, 0.03745817765593529, -0.056800782680511475, -0.021923866122961044, -0.017269259318709373, 0.02708517387509346, 0.006629944313317537, 0.037277452647686005, -0.03233617544174194, -0.001067201723344624, -0.02484964020550251, 0.05673417076468468, -0.0005505766021087766, -0.02626100741326809, -0.015123751014471054, 0.014984683133661747, 0.00703513203188777, 0.0078066023997962475, 0.018795762211084366, 0.011811085976660252, 0.06623735278844833, -0.023465177044272423, 0.04199374094605446, -0.030273161828517914, 0.07454151660203934, -0.009359785355627537, 0.0017091712215915322, -0.02469574846327305, 0.031061479821801186, 0.058084581047296524, -0.02644202671945095, -0.08612023293972015, -0.020064160227775574, -0.04056008905172348, -0.005781626328825951, -0.02901296317577362, -0.009985575452446938, 0.001290567684918642, -0.021856389939785004, -0.0403987355530262, 0.0391707681119442, -0.029659075662493706, 0.010851421393454075, 0.042422983795404434, 0.011409087106585503, -0.02546422742307186, -0.0017947825836017728, -0.03236117586493492, 0.01571173407137394, 0.02261633798480034, 0.030896855518221855, 0.07927341014146805, 0.006960391998291016, -0.020574865862727165, 0.014721347019076347, 0.07281798124313354, 0.033078428357839584, -0.017353005707263947, 0.049970950931310654, -0.026194632053375244, 0.0019931744318455458, 0.021334033459424973, -0.011879115365445614, -0.004471606109291315, 0.03776854649186134, 0.03848395496606827, -0.046511210501194, 0.0501018688082695, -0.012015423737466335, 0.023103173822164536, -0.010638179257512093, -0.0091685326769948, -0.007815029472112656, -0.039265140891075134, 0.049505218863487244, 0.034665875136852264, -0.026357799768447876, 0.01243626233190298, -0.027260953560471535, -0.03805942088365555, -0.02908220700919628, -0.0005781655781902373, -0.01727745495736599, 0.013552837073802948, 0.02886376716196537, -0.0038571013137698174, 0.004869617056101561, -0.00019626235007308424, -0.012461486272513866, -0.011602439917623997, 0.06395861506462097, 0.03922896459698677, 0.06951720267534256, 0.007039248943328857, 0.03550469130277634, -0.0061608231626451015, -0.031845659017562866, -0.01614636927843094, -0.004208920989185572, -0.021582985296845436, -0.002933956915512681, 0.058971405029296875, -0.05306774005293846, 0.00440184073522687, 0.06919296830892563, -0.03327314183115959, 0.06332468241453171, 0.01033421978354454, -0.04729686304926872, -0.03144321218132973, 0.016953885555267334, -0.030514711514115334, -0.008189249783754349, -0.03470993787050247, -0.005754913203418255, 0.007179181557148695, 0.02665795385837555, 0.03484109789133072, 0.039607152342796326, -0.023880774155259132, -0.014733215793967247, 0.004043568391352892, -0.009404879063367844, -0.014858968555927277, 0.014260049909353256, -0.04089503735303879, -0.007947846315801144, -0.03714486584067345, -0.019574347883462906, 0.009725072421133518, -0.02211940661072731, 0.0044805677607655525, 0.03717669099569321, -0.01234092190861702, 0.008076337166130543, 0.005215932615101337, -0.010528857819736004, -0.037568170577287674, 0.07940667867660522, -0.004267496522516012, 0.007601212710142136, 0.02322065271437168, 0.02079048752784729, 0.042457882314920425, 0.013207195326685905, 0.031196843832731247, 0.06307213008403778, -0.038125842809677124, 0.0026168120093643665, -0.01965763419866562, 0.02405175194144249, 0.025796351954340935, -0.03647639974951744, 0.0002648893278092146, -0.005011931527405977, -0.01657100021839142, 0.006438574753701687, 0.033155351877212524, 0.003334074979647994, -0.017713626846671104, 0.04838462173938751, -0.037501681596040726, -0.013832278549671173, -0.06283653527498245, -0.011558255180716515, 0.019233351573348045, -0.023022009059786797, 0.014281868934631348, 0.020454242825508118, 0.02424592152237892, 0.008864778093993664, -0.01143557857722044, -0.01843424327671528, -0.021319497376680374, 0.01075202226638794, -0.06235098838806152, 0.04120931401848793, 0.05870474502444267, 0.026923341676592827, -0.022492634132504463, 0.059416498988866806, -0.00084934156620875, -0.006208307575434446, 0.00019312741642352194, -0.03847283869981766, 0.027238307520747185, 0.027153324335813522, -0.014838854782283306, 0.013299097307026386, 0.013258094899356365, -0.006350486073642969, 0.04436459392309189, -0.06512461602687836, 0.041548699140548706, 0.06636260449886322, 0.006386942230165005, -0.015837226063013077, -0.06292536854743958, 0.022607021033763885, 0.03745565190911293, -0.010209846310317516, -0.00041090528247877955, -0.0475638248026371, 0.006514708511531353, 0.07632029801607132, 0.01878405176103115, -0.047940805554389954, 0.019167084246873856, 0.05531982332468033, -0.025008710101246834, -0.026563355699181557, 0.040445372462272644, -0.005797205027192831, -0.022807979956269264, 0.01644393615424633, 0.029348798096179962, 0.050148770213127136, -0.003182956948876381, 0.05691478028893471, 0.003316773334518075, 0.02976551465690136, 0.03600695729255676, -0.014018937014043331, -0.0028660749085247517, -0.027128688991069794, 0.014565324410796165, -0.017360545694828033, -0.06308918446302414, 0.011885170824825764, -0.014177259989082813, -0.024506649002432823, 0.02075529657304287, -0.019946083426475525, -0.01525744516402483, 0.0039007386658340693, 0.000245771516347304, 0.018762443214654922, 0.03993809595704079, -0.01729188859462738, -0.006875373423099518, 0.03161934018135071, -0.052345771342515945, 0.0160383228212595, 0.006034861784428358, -0.07036436349153519, -0.06127944961190224, 0.005787959322333336, 0.04753660783171654, 0.013877958059310913, 0.03333360329270363, -0.012553030624985695, -0.018570929765701294, 0.00528577109798789, -0.030608970671892166, 0.019590172916650772, 0.004083385691046715, -0.022038619965314865, 0.006625798065215349, 0.0075929611921310425, -0.028589332476258278, 0.05016157403588295, 0.020229335874319077, 0.0023590349592268467, 0.020492905750870705, -0.015713265165686607, -0.026056846603751183, -0.010807866230607033, -0.023482631891965866, -0.0027740285731852055, 0.0028585519175976515, -0.014014112763106823, 0.04777008295059204, -0.018764831125736237, -0.058086708188056946, 0.03248943015933037, -0.07015708833932877, -0.018334059044718742, -0.03873855248093605, 0.02844434790313244, 0.012709535658359528, 0.006788590922951698, -0.016958149150013924, -0.0005280919722281396, -0.04596459120512009, 0.027764342725276947, -0.06850961595773697, -0.033743519335985184, 0.0011255602585151792, -0.020749807357788086, 0.03270311281085014, 0.008763449266552925, -0.02929934486746788, 0.04930910840630531, 0.06809064745903015, -0.0034177512861788273, -0.031119801104068756, -0.026146642863750458, -0.058274898678064346, 0.005417077336460352, 0.013388675637543201, 0.034209318459033966, 0.03862404823303223, -0.013086083345115185, -0.004593497607856989, 0.054509952664375305, 0.06212997063994408, 0.03509465977549553, 0.01858948916196823, 0.03356121480464935, 0.02906043827533722, 0.00976351648569107, 0.024009481072425842, -0.0065335542894899845, 0.0056195370852947235, 0.02325494773685932, -0.006215488538146019, 0.013969313353300095, 0.033017102628946304, -0.02389790117740631, 0.015690984204411507, 0.011486312374472618, 0.020897196605801582, -0.01444798894226551, 0.04596904292702675, 0.02245808020234108, -0.0048686848022043705, -0.030005577951669693, 0.029724974185228348, 0.017719009891152382, -0.017418207600712776, -0.014626797288656235, 0.03644762188196182, 0.008925455622375011, -0.015915609896183014, -0.0008782818331383169, -0.011466423980891705, -0.01277073472738266, 0.004519273526966572, -0.07024459540843964, -0.02242543175816536, 0.05283783748745918, 0.031894028186798096, 0.06134271249175072, 0.022300124168395996, -0.04722897335886955, -0.013542838394641876, -0.061880432069301605, -0.015482291579246521, -0.02501995861530304, 0.08532015979290009, -0.0030475903768092394, 0.059497471898794174, 0.017216317355632782, 0.011716905049979687, -0.008264565840363503, -0.0257389098405838, -0.06346017122268677, 0.026614610105752945, -0.008272061124444008, 0.009409165009856224, 0.009312390349805355, 0.0020836747717112303, -0.007172754034399986, -0.0322951041162014, 0.022540468722581863, 0.023435216397047043, 0.007648327387869358, -0.021688485518097878, 0.01713559217751026, -0.03448088467121124, 0.020086398348212242, -0.037129659205675125, 0.006463865749537945, -0.012706007808446884, 0.0038750183302909136, 0.03683493286371231, 0.01203532051295042, 0.0008810925646685064, 0.016268093138933182, -0.0209124144166708, 0.011840078048408031, 0.02561040222644806, 0.02406568080186844, 0.07442986220121384, 0.02604174241423607, -0.039728038012981415, 0.003905429970473051, -0.012279292568564415, 0.03804616630077362, 0.04394875839352608, 0.006909563206136227, -0.006341812200844288, -0.02634643204510212, -0.033874716609716415, -0.03602124750614166, 0.021577302366495132, 0.019981907680630684, -0.027993161231279373, 0.0034931935369968414, 0.0012801062548533082, -0.0310263242572546, 0.03290177136659622, 0.09593843668699265, 0.011180773377418518, 0.008376973681151867, -0.012194521725177765, -0.009296278469264507, -0.016498221084475517, 0.000021848964024684392, 0.028736857697367668, 0.011975150555372238, -0.0021762989927083254, -0.008688907139003277, 0.037178732454776764, 0.021765701472759247, -0.023162730038166046, 0.02199232392013073, 0.025759559124708176, 0.06564128398895264, 0.008842661045491695, -0.021808819845318794, 0.03699741140007973, 0.020154176279902458, 0.02835291065275669, 0.036930449306964874, -0.032827261835336685, -0.1103292927145958, 0.00023755902657285333, 0.03822298347949982, 0.07968290895223618, -0.049043361097574234, -0.055838532745838165, -0.05133126676082611, 0.01392590906471014, 0.0576741024851799, -0.058124445378780365, 0.007861536927521229, -0.03657884523272514, 0.004166152328252792, -0.023941682651638985, -0.011960936710238457, -0.04263203963637352, 0.033731505274772644, -0.024581141769886017, 0.016978945583105087, 0.0010827783262357116, -0.06911937147378922, -0.03001391887664795, 0.03245965391397476, -0.0043898518197238445, 0.03109014593064785, -0.06408406794071198, -0.0261355210095644, 0.011993111111223698, 0.0044212122447788715, 0.011236813850700855, -0.04585938900709152, 0.02492239698767662, -0.023686232045292854, 0.02676319144666195, 0.02681821957230568, -0.002217426197603345, -0.016052627936005592, 0.00004816138607566245, -0.01862889714539051, -0.022982096299529076, 0.02296268194913864, -0.02482624351978302, -0.010490555316209793, 0.02889600396156311, 0.0013312316732481122, 0.026486270129680634, 0.05070248991250992, 0.018437830731272697, -0.009602565318346024, -0.02184464782476425, 0.01978573389351368, -0.014856570400297642, 0.024112487211823463, -0.0601281076669693, 0.0063944412395358086, -0.04655589535832405, 0.018893036991357803, 0.0032185048330575228, 0.0077812206000089645, -0.02234148234128952, 0.00337682175450027, 0.025800932198762894, 0.00546113308519125, -0.003159234533086419, -0.02914789505302906, -0.0034451307728886604, -0.004361407831311226, -0.03977690637111664, -0.0031465631909668446, 0.007249253336340189, -0.03807468339800835, 0.016568122431635857, -0.003104228526353836, -0.03629264980554581, 0.03757048770785332, -0.029932530596852303, -0.020749878138303757, -0.0010290343780070543, -0.05318241938948631, 0.006361144129186869, 0.010562554001808167, 0.01989000476896763, 0.007215097080916166, -0.016865873709321022, -0.008845637552440166, 0.04424713924527168, 0.02982202172279358, 0.02423160895705223, -0.09485054761171341, 0.08038416504859924, 0.007649976760149002, -0.010487446561455727, -0.07097186148166656, -0.050259996205568314, 0.01445392519235611, 0.0371621772646904, -0.02025614120066166, -0.02733929455280304, -0.0031384993344545364, -0.009072814136743546, 0.013228129595518112, -0.00027579814195632935, 0.03581159934401512, 0.0014135092496871948, -0.008797566406428814, 0.014161705039441586, 0.03206421434879303, 0.07137526571750641, 0.014522921293973923, -0.018355846405029297, 0.03709026426076889, -0.008842533454298973, -0.027409499511122704, -0.014267035759985447, 0.008737527765333652, -0.029014725238084793, -0.014589875005185604, -0.0164914783090353, -0.0042982459999620914, 0.05504295229911804, -0.03878754377365112, -0.020825743675231934, 0.007296410854905844, -0.02258131466805935, -0.0027095854748040438, -0.06460598111152649, 0.007032732013612986, -0.04691310226917267, 0.005065811797976494, -0.03557117283344269, -0.0057221935130655766, -0.029590541496872902, -0.008827151730656624, -0.0013299788115546107, 0.028509171679615974, -0.05616256222128868, 0.03607797250151634, 0.07499537616968155, -0.003799695521593094, -0.03319401666522026, -0.004983707796782255, -0.012834371998906136, -0.022824011743068695, 0.0207427516579628, -0.007622379343956709, -0.0014443674590438604, 0.0074819703586399555, -0.027646739035844803, -0.0016908138059079647, -0.020904744043946266, -0.052769966423511505, 0.045781295746564865, 0.033541303128004074, 0.06180910766124725, 0.016403155401349068, 0.02354832924902439, 0.014013535343110561, 0.027162913233041763, -0.012234246358275414, -0.01648816093802452, 0.006238351110368967, 0.019392164424061775, -0.03261430189013481, -0.004876111168414354, 0.049391038715839386, 0.0020288676023483276, 0.033299293369054794, 0.05291350558400154, -0.001524398336187005, -0.026159659028053284, 0.047315921634435654, -0.005920111201703548, -0.0315210185945034, 0.004908722825348377, -0.04250263422727585, 0.060523420572280884, -0.04606243595480919, -0.010228455998003483, 0.031749267131090164, 0.03572119399905205, -0.01176400389522314, -0.040811970829963684, 0.0009369173203594983, -0.05768221244215965, -0.0031865935306996107, 0.027531735599040985, -0.011012710630893707, 0.02713465318083763, 0.025421664118766785, 0.037444472312927246, 0.023848537355661392, 0.044788941740989685, -0.022646605968475342, -0.03191716969013214, -0.016473421826958656, -0.007351710926741362, -0.04240866005420685, 0.07978139072656631, -0.00278491317294538, -0.010394119657576084, 0.018804209306836128, -0.042449284344911575, 0.022187646478414536, 0.021230356767773628, 0.01768917217850685, -0.009837326593697071, 0.06591515243053436, 0.0050657386891543865, 0.009717779234051704, -0.007943094708025455, -0.028684483841061592, 0.13423654437065125, 0.08906935155391693, 0.03316422924399376, -0.06406907737255096, 0.03387952595949173, 0.010370854288339615, 0.018571708351373672, -0.028359374031424522, 0.013810054399073124, 0.03257736936211586, 0.018208812922239304, 0.07725568860769272, 0.06910601258277893, 0.00744839571416378, 0.008512027561664581, 0.04495176300406456, -0.04579593613743782, 0.004020143300294876, -0.0356258749961853, 0.02201816812157631, 0.0030113914981484413, -0.011950228363275528, -0.08022631704807281, 0.018877187743782997, -0.0026133316569030285, -0.00011838965292554349, -0.020900322124361992, 0.0021224922966212034, -0.014457396231591702, 0.00006630388816120103, -0.013773682527244091, 0.028628798201680183, 0.007402167655527592, 0.013012737967073917, -0.023994019255042076, -0.03293589502573013, 0.003103305120021105, -0.017688952386379242, 0.03186602145433426, 0.0440826378762722, 0.028335995972156525, -0.02669818140566349, -0.007187611889094114, 0.022657498717308044, -0.06175427883863449, -0.043245721608400345, -0.027804337441921234, 0.030433783307671547, 0.0022113965824246407, -0.02189796417951584, -0.00017607193149160594, 0.004881988279521465, -0.01361893117427826, -0.015375294722616673, -0.01381328422576189, -0.0024762991815805435, 0.029389338567852974, -0.03386909142136574, 0.00537414476275444, -0.017411967739462852, 0.035542603582143784, -0.004312715958803892, 0.015413345769047737, 0.04048401489853859, -0.028321146965026855, -0.023475145921111107, -0.009886886924505234, 0.06624558568000793, -0.03664567694067955, -0.00047417136374861, 0.049768853932619095, -0.019642909988760948, -0.03395066410303116, 0.007185961585491896, -0.0076489439234137535, 0.02257010154426098, 0.01920006237924099, 0.001846218015998602, -0.029327986761927605, 0.020652657374739647, -0.007135371211916208, 0.02265199087560177, -0.007541806437075138, 0.024152236059308052, -0.012289756909012794, -0.021209299564361572, 0.0010928565170615911, 0.01437218114733696, 0.018544498831033707, 0.07301907986402512, 0.0404428094625473, 0.059225305914878845, 0.011839903891086578, -0.07928867638111115, -0.023146899417042732, -0.01394595392048359, -0.013106434606015682, 0.021582914516329765, -0.027515731751918793, 0.047242969274520874, 0.042477354407310486, 0.0061834510415792465, 0.00015567349328193814, 0.020529936999082565, -0.03582065925002098, -0.0030370985623449087, -0.010355972684919834, -0.0331101268529892, -0.03278275206685066, 0.01519624050706625, 0.0035535062197595835, -0.039310336112976074, -0.04147029668092728, -0.026779847219586372, -0.0023498088121414185, 0.0013347305357456207, 0.02767248824238777, -0.03256402537226677, 0.028351766988635063, -0.029773415997624397, -0.04251771420240402, -0.011738164350390434, -0.006783901248127222, -0.03688207268714905, -0.048996590077877045, -0.012351051904261112, 0.007788160815834999, -0.01789129711687565, 0.043004464358091354, -0.05422031879425049, -0.01067162025719881, 0.02326631173491478, 0.015346065163612366, 0.030293293297290802, 0.04138132929801941, 0.015525327995419502, -0.03466460853815079, -0.0015333847841247916, -0.006825405638664961, -0.011299746111035347, -0.003808521432802081, -0.0056307450868189335, -0.07095314562320709, 0.0048079099506139755, 0.006196127273142338, 0.02759213000535965, -0.03683585673570633, 0.0058169797994196415, 0.011798153631389141, 0.04504810646176338, -0.0023952822666615248, -0.009047569707036018, -0.016424337401986122, -0.0024478717241436243, -0.017092537134885788, -0.011029609479010105, 0.0031236375216394663, 0.04155484214425087, -0.019211089238524437, 0.0033542250748723745, 0.04605807363986969, 0.001538728130981326, 0.008439005352556705, -0.013985727913677692, -0.013559243641793728, -0.011601007543504238, 0.028390249237418175, 0.003530933056026697, 0.05628763511776924, 0.041700270026922226, -0.01398699264973402, 0.006309357937425375, -0.07374391704797745, 0.003283063881099224, -0.07083063572645187, 0.007205221336334944, 0.0007358121802099049, 0.004012929275631905, 0.003155697835609317, -0.039670996367931366, -0.0230706837028265, 0.020318467170000076, -0.039727210998535156, 0.03511872515082359, 0.0016791863599792123, -0.017924005165696144, -0.00949921552091837, -0.014367944560945034, -0.016709942370653152, -0.003910289611667395, 0.035776346921920776, 0.03165118768811226, 0.06293061375617981, 0.023303445428609848, -0.004212429281324148, -0.0130966417491436, -0.00921940803527832, 0.023338310420513153, 0.026536565274000168, -0.046703536063432693, 0.005469318479299545, -0.04264567419886589, -0.009379777126014233, -0.008467139676213264, -0.05027914419770241, 0.023385588079690933, -0.024874985218048096, 0.0229042898863554, 0.027893900871276855, 0.07968248426914215, 0.03586073964834213, 0.02914305590093136, -0.07272505015134811, -0.030981868505477905, 0.006861485540866852, -0.01217874139547348, -0.05161575227975845, 0.01876896619796753, 0.03155769780278206, -0.00039746181573718786, -0.007607833482325077, 0.0012213909067213535, -0.009528684429824352, 0.02359108254313469, -0.012391532771289349, 0.02128514274954796, 0.02065899223089218, -0.012084041722118855, -0.021475953981280327, -0.044652074575424194, -0.002864149399101734, 0.006739109754562378, 0.002364607760682702, 0.0041313921101391315, 0.0031076068989932537, -0.01656188629567623, -0.023940613493323326, 0.010801631025969982, -0.010669916868209839, -0.03225839510560036, -0.039618611335754395, -0.0040999907068908215, -0.043611012399196625, 0.022401822730898857, -0.027978161349892616, -0.029935920611023903, -0.0033279189374297857, 0.02526910789310932, -0.009429283440113068, -0.024577569216489792, 0.01035951729863882, 0.0064322142861783504, 0.011737953871488571, -0.09429766982793808, 0.04994013160467148, -0.015624361112713814, -0.005764290690422058, -0.0035389859694987535, -0.018602274358272552, -0.08352071046829224, 0.06025461107492447, 0.04095643758773804, 0.045494385063648224, 0.0009561561164446175, -0.04171686992049217, 0.026139361783862114, 0.01588408276438713, -0.06383650004863739, 0.051164157688617706, 0.006885072682052851, -0.06747961789369583, 0.00946318730711937, -0.019173892214894295, 0.001814145129173994, 0.021422524005174637, 0.012211431749165058, -0.02831304632127285, -0.005883179139345884, -0.027688222005963326, -0.007835916243493557, 0.025684082880616188, -0.0018314544577151537, -0.018988152965903282, 0.053510524332523346, -0.013763672672212124, 0.03209396079182625, 0.020302264019846916, 0.009317043237388134, -0.06540843099355698, 0.04743386059999466, -0.03535871580243111, 0.0029791577253490686, -0.018606944009661674, 0.010591060854494572, 0.000983700156211853, -0.04413614049553871, -0.0010414359858259559, -0.020567212253808975, -0.0040555791929364204, -0.005409658886492252, -0.0005712995189242065, 0.005168840754777193, 0.031826384365558624, -0.012972679920494556, 0.02989974059164524, -0.006442479323595762, 0.01711168698966503, 0.0252841729670763, 0.005577108357101679, 0.010573236271739006, -0.016252709552645683, 0.040180884301662445, 0.023591166362166405, -0.027271462604403496, 0.018442325294017792, -0.0009743922273628414, 0.003487846814095974, 0.0024280515499413013, -0.022426605224609375, 0.02569647878408432, 0.006725485436618328, -0.0397864505648613, 0.03791176900267601, -0.011372600682079792, 0.01150508038699627, -0.033028557896614075, 0.030451249331235886, -0.015166942961513996, -0.013917634263634682, -0.017986420542001724, -0.00477608572691679, 0.008039205335080624, -0.007274777628481388, -0.031125571578741074, 0.03530443087220192, 0.02839619480073452, -0.006408884655684233, -0.01863515004515648, -0.01799958571791649, 0.010362150147557259, -0.04309128224849701, 0.006596225779503584, -0.033521004021167755, -0.006185469217598438, -0.06042947992682457, -0.03559667617082596, 0.002450092462822795, 0.03735069930553436, 0.033498454838991165, -0.058855485171079636, -0.042740367352962494, 0.003019962226971984, 0.012023093178868294, -0.0309669841080904, -0.010239350609481335, -0.028993122279644012, 0.0008604313479736447, -0.01053893007338047, -0.06706346571445465 ]
<p>is it possible for an algorithm A to have a better precision but worse recall (or better recall but worse precision) than another algorithm B?</p> <p>Although I know that precision and recall are different things, it seems to me that if algorithm A has a better precision (or recall) than algorithm B then algorithm A will also have a better recall (or precision) than B.</p> <p>Thanks Ahmet</p>
46,203
[ -0.016116127371788025, -0.0277240127325058, 0.017814673483371735, -0.00964477937668562, 0.04063129052519798, 0.02539527229964733, 0.0020961607806384563, -0.010713855735957623, 0.01854659803211689, 0.003309117164462805, 0.017143433913588524, 0.001997746294364333, 0.05388389900326729, 0.022333361208438873, 0.03202053904533386, 0.0028696476947516203, -0.0160305704921484, 0.03446813300251961, 0.0036946400068700314, -0.0021147364750504494, 0.002374297473579645, 0.02538558840751648, 0.010987000539898872, -0.01030544564127922, -0.04296264424920082, 0.0016332264058291912, 0.04659018665552139, -0.0210732314735651, -0.007805375382304192, 0.07865047454833984, -0.025814905762672424, -0.010467211715877056, 0.026183653622865677, 0.05883423984050751, 0.023661650717258453, -0.010935463942587376, -0.03780226409435272, 0.013302607461810112, -0.05310652405023575, 0.01152411662042141, -0.01986541412770748, -0.04371646046638489, -0.023737311363220215, 0.03996804356575012, 0.011429626494646072, 0.023626208305358887, -0.039182089269161224, -0.028121886774897575, 0.0055014160461723804, -0.0450434535741806, 0.050663821399211884, -0.0031561104115098715, 0.02727404236793518, 0.09167270362377167, -0.005011780187487602, -0.022262217476963997, 0.058980703353881836, 0.08948744088411331, -0.014756537973880768, -0.048943717032670975, -0.0017663014587014914, -0.02438100427389145, 0.02169286459684372, 0.013409066945314407, -0.049487557262182236, 0.043491847813129425, -0.010200846008956432, -0.026559963822364807, 0.01626870036125183, -0.008607566356658936, -0.017830856144428253, 0.012462259270250797, 0.025490140542387962, -0.023148177191615105, 0.05306367948651314, -0.01042119413614273, 0.006068595219403505, 0.031468141824007034, 0.040318913757801056, 0.03004937432706356, 0.01874125748872757, 0.02758537046611309, 0.04028414562344551, 0.030550632625818253, 0.036077048629522324, -0.002722060075029731, 0.025939179584383965, -0.04943650960922241, -0.001575505011714995, 0.035880956798791885, 0.015745801851153374, -0.014872044324874878, 0.04322270303964615, -0.028479190543293953, -0.015429461374878883, 0.027808919548988342, 0.024654624983668327, 0.033253543078899384, 0.027582313865423203, -0.00641912966966629, -0.027749627828598022, -0.03354217857122421, 0.009418033063411713, 0.06575262546539307, -0.022293297573924065, -0.006905487738549709, -0.0457007959485054, 0.006324958987534046, -0.034417349845170975, -0.0037170727737247944, 0.012252308428287506, 0.01545655820518732, -0.03435054048895836, 0.0038931514136493206, 0.0038347281515598297, 0.002550106029957533, 0.0032339738681912422, -0.021014733240008354, 0.055400896817445755, 0.04607496038079262, 0.025391120463609695, -0.0098810950294137, 0.0019113614689558744, -0.04389635846018791, -0.03806755691766739, 0.010075289756059647, 0.04948805645108223, -0.04502405598759651, -0.05019354447722435, 0.05504411458969116, 0.0006622024811804295, 0.006934693548828363, 0.015912076458334923, -0.0010479532647877932, 0.024018028751015663, 0.009452508762478828, -0.07892704755067825, -0.03286813944578171, 0.0293858852237463, 0.021166309714317322, 0.012884941883385181, -0.09187449514865875, 0.03528277575969696, 0.03588675707578659, 0.054692987352609634, 0.05925394222140312, 0.05994922295212746, 0.05266547203063965, 0.016032155603170395, 0.006570702884346247, -0.0025138764176517725, -0.0010833294363692403, -0.013707456178963184, -0.036473292857408524, -0.020409125834703445, -0.07932863384485245, -0.019583646208047867, 0.030792221426963806, -0.0020291220862418413, -0.023102592676877975, -0.012409517541527748, -0.005846333224326372, 0.015047752298414707, 0.018687697127461433, 0.0321599543094635, -0.027176331728696823, 0.054947901517152786, 0.020067038014531136, 0.057485148310661316, 0.028753170743584633, -0.008002888411283493, 0.017336787655949593, 0.01575438678264618, 0.01341977808624506, 0.0807289257645607, -0.040930263698101044, -0.022336198017001152, -0.030152173712849617, 0.010401374660432339, 0.006507657002657652, -0.031028270721435547, -0.06342703849077225, -0.009564441628754139, 0.016117755323648453, 0.005993911065161228, 0.03367935121059418, 0.008928092196583748, 0.0014939522370696068, 0.04483823850750923, -0.028490962460637093, -0.0018835129449144006, -0.05032823607325554, -0.029424015432596207, -0.023720046505331993, -0.022399848327040672, 0.02192225679755211, -0.015615178272128105, -0.02004954405128956, 0.022497108206152916, -0.027431271970272064, -0.037462662905454636, -0.023403920233249664, 0.01289307326078415, -0.048580847680568695, 0.0053830635733902454, 0.037308469414711, -0.010104255750775337, -0.052623625844717026, 0.048661090433597565, -0.012018794193863869, -0.06924237310886383, -0.016308128833770752, -0.017149068415164948, 0.02828405797481537, -0.0027789969462901354, -0.03798547387123108, 0.04157645255327225, 0.011157606728374958, -0.0043625859543681145, 0.01877528801560402, -0.07023454457521439, 0.07482956349849701, 0.05875832214951515, 0.009161343798041344, -0.004597933497279882, -0.020223533734679222, 0.010530681349337101, -0.001834516879171133, -0.0011927136220037937, -0.0032016222830861807, -0.04260857775807381, -0.005610837135463953, 0.04167505353689194, 0.03903947398066521, -0.02946380525827408, 0.035459622740745544, 0.0670245960354805, 0.026166031137108803, -0.002692640759050846, 0.06805125623941422, 0.022638801485300064, -0.011334559880197048, 0.012504803948104382, 0.04302294924855232, 0.019135424867272377, 0.03618461638689041, 0.023666659370064735, -0.014677469618618488, 0.023450374603271484, -0.005006668623536825, -0.02411571331322193, 0.031900372356176376, 0.002260339679196477, 0.0030120655428618193, -0.020336797460913658, -0.021262913942337036, 0.03144872933626175, -0.022685173898935318, 0.006700829137116671, -0.00614806218072772, -0.020363790914416313, 0.0028219553641974926, -0.018078595399856567, -0.010602368041872978, 0.0196609478443861, 0.04801381751894951, -0.024497777223587036, -0.0074222213588654995, 0.022795896977186203, -0.024047328159213066, -0.00313378544524312, -0.04037344828248024, 0.032642025500535965, -0.04129338264465332, 0.02091325633227825, 0.03790273889899254, -0.03229135274887085, 0.0024804831482470036, -0.02598036266863346, -0.011075511574745178, -0.030608760192990303, -0.04006136208772659, 0.005889211315661669, -0.02384965494275093, -0.05176239833235741, -0.01271112635731697, 0.012939024716615677, -0.006700764875859022, 0.019091077148914337, -0.00881535466760397, 0.016102762892842293, -0.01144343800842762, -0.008946193382143974, -0.036283619701862335, -0.04931182786822319, -0.04505092650651932, 0.03744368255138397, -0.008435960859060287, -0.014493592083454132, 0.0022288337349891663, 0.04634692892432213, -0.07643842697143555, 0.032682083547115326, 0.010625259019434452, -0.05190615355968475, -0.013600417412817478, -0.034052833914756775, -0.00016403298650402576, -0.022171175107359886, 0.00022342886950355023, 0.0231272391974926, -0.04652460291981697, -0.04199393466114998, -0.03796997666358948, -0.04651234671473503, 0.06786317378282547, -0.028662176802754402, 0.012099474668502808, -0.006665695458650589, -0.015560135245323181, 0.10274398326873779, 0.006515674293041229, -0.011114862747490406, -0.025465603917837143, -0.0026585948653519154, -0.0337601974606514, 0.010083161294460297, 0.022003041580319405, 0.01956918276846409, -0.03048243746161461, -0.012993003241717815, 0.0030117840506136417, 0.0316731221973896, 0.06649811565876007, -0.011808768846094608, 0.004208700731396675, 0.030165087431669235, 0.06857370585203171, -0.05097876116633415, 0.01399912778288126, 0.00842983741313219, -0.03520194813609123, -0.006421064957976341, -0.0013909032568335533, 0.014372626319527626, 0.011983025819063187, -0.0035491532180458307, 0.030661607161164284, -0.062066420912742615, 0.011351018212735653, -0.0419185571372509, 0.03467615693807602, 0.00427046837285161, 0.0027764306869357824, -0.043995991349220276, 0.038576889783144, 0.010279547423124313, -0.027826160192489624, -0.02325858548283577, 0.001701793516986072, 0.06367654353380203, -0.04461666941642761, 0.002873893128708005, 0.0027085384353995323, -0.026269985362887383, 0.007394003681838512, 0.01239756215363741, 0.017933517694473267, 0.03221038728952408, 0.027182389050722122, 0.003949156031012535, 0.03454790636897087, -0.039000190794467926, -0.01546422764658928, -0.0912477895617485, -0.026510659605264664, -0.015825457870960236, 0.049683935940265656, 0.0061233509331941605, 0.024881010875105858, 0.015349451452493668, -0.00048566420446150005, 0.005529296118766069, 0.009811940602958202, -0.054376233369112015, -0.0047612497583031654, -0.0039037347305566072, -0.07471297681331635, 0.02112230658531189, -0.03815676271915436, 0.014618543907999992, -0.016356589272618294, -0.027788877487182617, 0.022514529526233673, 0.04854531213641167, -0.04622203856706619, 0.028986051678657532, -0.0011156813707202673, -0.0065753646194934845, -0.004995397757738829, 0.02371012046933174, -0.02395745925605297, -0.008077162317931652, 0.08243978768587112, 0.014995074830949306, -0.0216722022742033, -0.05397356301546097, -0.007543622050434351, 0.01796264760196209, 0.042205773293972015, 0.011999471113085747, 0.01565067283809185, 0.07750953733921051, -0.03650590404868126, 0.024367595091462135, 0.023731239140033722, 0.06960047781467438, 0.0097605986520648, -0.022002242505550385, -0.04390428215265274, -0.05459846183657646, -0.03040480799973011, 0.025277066975831985, 0.041795920580625534, -0.02765806019306183, 0.013886830769479275, -0.007340129930526018, 0.010494451969861984, -0.028957858681678772, 0.0035906187258660793, 0.033926814794540405, -0.005009150132536888, 0.019067684188485146, -0.036635782569646835, 0.03015035390853882, 0.005030226893723011, -0.0068086376413702965, 0.03306517004966736, 0.016154345124959946, 0.006765523925423622, -0.03347143530845642, 0.02590547874569893, -0.034851979464292526, -0.055725377053022385, 0.01281953975558281, 0.024753380566835403, -0.01656617783010006, 0.004821141250431538, 0.02929493971168995, 0.01178680919110775, 0.007981136441230774, 0.05823029950261116, 0.03104262240231037, 0.0007389854290522635, -0.06290039420127869, 0.009582136757671833, 0.07336381822824478, 0.03978310152888298, -0.06427370011806488, 0.01333392783999443, -0.0350276343524456, -0.03400009125471115, 0.029958903789520264, 0.012971124611794949, 0.05303793027997017, -0.01919872872531414, 0.004189582541584969, -0.022329701110720634, -0.01019620057195425, -0.012072227895259857, -0.005479069892317057, -0.007718594744801521, 0.05493861809372902, 0.0018989070085808635, 0.006145355757325888, -0.030922669917345047, -0.01978311873972416, 0.045937247574329376, 0.06849479675292969, -0.031031053513288498, -0.0065412018448114395, -0.002538873115554452, -0.01591821201145649, -0.04354475066065788, -0.07190081477165222, -0.006102133076637983, -0.0017659403383731842, -0.001106683979742229, 0.04196665808558464, -0.023338347673416138, -0.03681304678320885, 0.04684633016586304, -0.014217087998986244, -0.02790631540119648, -0.041771989315748215, -0.012767062522470951, 0.02566443383693695, 0.042085375636816025, -0.002817495260387659, 0.050195690244436264, 0.01982218213379383, 0.021685220301151276, -0.00954822264611721, -0.012545161880552769, -0.007956961169838905, -0.05002773180603981, 0.032092269510030746, -0.032041821628808975, -0.0018128033261746168, -0.026436181738972664, 0.03456564620137215, 0.03299413621425629, 0.05040670186281204, 0.004910577088594437, 0.0017110499320551753, -0.042584165930747986, 0.003792219329625368, -0.02079230360686779, -0.008223298005759716, 0.00398919777944684, 0.0284445621073246, -0.04555017873644829, -0.007509767543524504, 0.044502027332782745, -0.02448868378996849, 0.008089743554592133, -0.004217122215777636, -0.010763444006443024, 0.030871931463479996, -0.018302831798791885, -0.012802883982658386, -0.014904242940247059, -0.0007579176453873515, 0.06969600915908813, -0.01156663242727518, 0.008422059006989002, 0.015448315069079399, -0.05951195955276489, -0.011235841549932957, 0.013691884465515614, -0.011438156478106976, 0.01660539209842682, -0.05825255438685417, 0.03809544816613197, -0.003025631420314312, -0.033179812133312225, -0.05383720621466637, -0.022480405867099762, 0.01458946242928505, 0.015420549549162388, 0.0007691881619393826, -0.023458300158381462, 0.01539639476686716, -0.038906048983335495, -0.028814643621444702, -0.011557562276721, 0.06488408148288727, -0.014159741811454296, -0.032256364822387695, 0.05231991037726402, 0.003949809819459915, 0.0770057886838913, 0.005032305605709553, 0.013645226135849953, -0.0070287385024130344, -0.026154078543186188, -0.01469489000737667, 0.01786670833826065, 0.035785362124443054, -0.040278539061546326, -0.005794116761535406, -0.00761683052405715, 0.01896086521446705, 0.05404725298285484, 0.005951212719082832, -0.015659308061003685, 0.0161889735609293, -0.02105826325714588, 0.017265956848859787, -0.007489299867302179, -0.03721195086836815, -0.015493836253881454, 0.017165102064609528, -0.032266173511743546, 0.012752324342727661, 0.027423596009612083, -0.004275419283658266, 0.0121413953602314, 0.004521507769823074, -0.03350718691945076, -0.018335090950131416, 0.07736999541521072, -0.05192507430911064, 0.0032954879570752382, 0.016250599175691605, -0.023610269650816917, 0.02388937771320343, -0.02640923112630844, 0.038871947675943375, -0.022886913269758224, 0.043609730899333954, -0.04206129536032677, 0.0029309180099517107, -0.00684539508074522, -0.01591489650309086, 0.05448652058839798, -0.005463026463985443, 0.040956929326057434, 0.025978099554777145, 0.008488201536238194, -0.013053744100034237, -0.02248244173824787, -0.020322710275650024, 0.007842054590582848, -0.006057752296328545, 0.05159706622362137, -0.024991335347294807, -0.03752562776207924, 0.043257392942905426, 0.019647981971502304, 0.02301168255507946, -0.006717521231621504, -0.012251420877873898, 0.017458748072385788, 0.0139003349468112, 0.008571065030992031, -0.024408642202615738, 0.024506358429789543, -0.04072217643260956, -0.013049195520579815, -0.0065020667389035225, -0.004178885370492935, 0.048557084053754807, 0.028329044580459595, 0.014983453787863255, -0.014028499834239483, -0.03637294843792915, -0.04551845043897629, 0.0035108502488583326, 0.008671442046761513, 0.004829503130167723, 0.024444472044706345, -0.01467052847146988, 0.022777926176786423, 0.04776914417743683, 0.002047415357083082, -0.016177650541067123, -0.07968350499868393, -0.025064656510949135, -0.009177427738904953, -0.045007284730672836, 0.010296602733433247, 0.011472643353044987, -0.052044693380594254, 0.024522393941879272, -0.023438654839992523, 0.03745594993233681, 0.05482175573706627, 0.04019232466816902, -0.021770985797047615, 0.058730464428663254, 0.010116755031049252, 0.05404340475797653, 0.006441910285502672, 0.016920028254389763, 0.1085130125284195, 0.06309763342142105, 0.036242078989744186, -0.06920365244150162, 0.035713180899620056, 0.008357695303857327, 0.010844568721950054, -0.04150015488266945, 0.03482827544212341, 0.01606930047273636, 0.0026050203014165163, 0.029478486627340317, 0.014606020413339138, -0.003651368198916316, -0.0374482162296772, 0.01292624231427908, -0.01943998970091343, -0.01940394751727581, 0.003819100558757782, 0.03285205364227295, -0.002222642069682479, 0.012549960054457188, -0.03153544291853905, -0.022325152531266212, -0.005699323024600744, -0.018081242218613625, 0.01537128072232008, 0.0037871566601097584, -0.00671614333987236, 0.0024894392117857933, -0.017998376861214638, 0.008320832625031471, -0.0037295250222086906, 0.02080945484340191, -0.029096383601427078, 0.0246087908744812, 0.007115975953638554, -0.009017269127070904, -0.019946763291954994, 0.04376838356256485, 0.013632312417030334, 0.026703333482146263, 0.001435118610970676, 0.023428410291671753, -0.06798781454563141, 0.016218947246670723, -0.051344066858291626, 0.0017405461985617876, -0.031637806445360184, 0.01948997937142849, 0.028245920315384865, -0.029321394860744476, 0.0173785500228405, -0.06972366571426392, -0.02170395292341709, 0.0507027693092823, -0.01734282821416855, -0.025562535971403122, -0.03043641336262226, -0.00905646663159132, 0.05187936872243881, -0.03503455966711044, 0.012870099395513535, 0.013626941479742527, -0.05263623222708702, -0.008469842374324799, 0.002029096707701683, 0.02669375203549862, -0.023227402940392494, -0.008001858368515968, -0.00403930526226759, 0.011054376140236855, -0.015522314235568047, -0.015441210940480232, -0.018183739855885506, 0.012872359715402126, 0.021379103884100914, 0.013891873881220818, -0.01287265308201313, -0.02369290590286255, -0.04340575262904167, 0.030698880553245544, -0.03395036607980728, 0.024132132530212402, -0.045678604394197464, -0.013698697090148926, 0.06623949855566025, 0.02139025367796421, 0.00817799475044012, 0.00921359471976757, 0.013504790142178535, -0.0010941338259726763, 0.04213999956846237, -0.03821384534239769, 0.006180658005177975, -0.0005452510667964816, -0.05658220499753952, 0.025449885055422783, -0.0010267115430906415, 0.03810906782746315, 0.04864882677793503, 0.04998860880732536, 0.00008075179357547313, 0.021937033161520958, -0.001862047123722732, -0.0005145002505742013, -0.04237155243754387, -0.011949813924729824, -0.04596910998225212, 0.0075518907979130745, -0.002690402325242758, -0.045847322791814804, -0.019470393657684326, -0.04847140610218048, -0.016841121017932892, 0.014429713599383831, 0.012586151249706745, -0.0157899372279644, 0.006562074646353722, 0.004196942783892155, -0.0014590718783438206, -0.020843230187892914, 0.026438767090439796, -0.01390882395207882, -0.039898015558719635, -0.03510616719722748, -0.011564621701836586, 0.00621243380010128, 0.01052053365856409, -0.017500950023531914, -0.01131204329431057, 0.047832190990448, 0.012952224351465702, -0.0036126351915299892, -0.0231796745210886, 0.007271734997630119, -0.002775956643745303, 0.06238959729671478, -0.035997021943330765, -0.03940366581082344, 0.07681366801261902, -0.05456947907805443, -0.040099676698446274, 0.0020729321986436844, -0.02187669835984707, 0.003945306409150362, 0.04979700595140457, -0.027092667296528816, 0.009313570335507393, 0.07421530783176422, -0.01359536126255989, -0.009429967030882835, 0.002227104501798749, 0.013497719541192055, 0.04068625718355179, 0.028114665299654007, 0.022169392555952072, -0.014257621020078659, -0.036547496914863586, 0.0027554677799344063, 0.02734106034040451, -0.004478616639971733, -0.01744881644845009, 0.01687871851027012, -0.012803000397980213, 0.03779003024101257, 0.002008662559092045, -0.013062343932688236, -0.003580185119062662, 0.009275243617594242, -0.0007668649195693433, 0.024946490302681923, 0.01922796480357647, -0.013110959902405739, -0.07876496762037277, 0.003951850812882185, 0.011842889711260796, 0.030710605904459953, 0.026102818548679352, -0.010282349772751331, 0.010918018408119678, 0.016057848930358887, -0.05212175101041794, 0.008319039829075336, 0.022481853142380714, -0.01928504928946495, -0.06590981781482697, 0.020174473524093628, -0.02118619717657566, 0.0077132610604166985, 0.026196736842393875, 0.011819479987025261, 0.017806481570005417, -0.009960162453353405, -0.029293956235051155, -0.020932674407958984, -0.043084193021059036, 0.011289644986391068, -0.04913264885544777, -0.039143383502960205, -0.01924336701631546, -0.040301669389009476, -0.061874911189079285, 0.043112862855196, -0.013563599437475204, 0.022929605096578598, 0.00041164635331369936, 0.02939985878765583, 0.05377612262964249, 0.014388942159712315, -0.010209894739091396, -0.015238648280501366, -0.02194151096045971, 0.0016976656625047326, -0.008994033560156822, 0.018672239035367966, -0.012371490709483624, 0.024408390745520592, 0.02822202257812023, -0.005191978998482227, -0.04732920229434967, 0.04805156961083412, -0.016287917271256447, -0.04021768271923065, -0.025688938796520233, 0.012173643335700035, 0.0154105881229043, -0.001347885699942708, 0.004137652460485697, -0.029506834223866463, 0.00297525548376143, 0.02178075723350048, -0.0016731413779780269, -0.03733976557850838, 0.02179696038365364, 0.01718865893781185, -0.015938756987452507, 0.039126329123973846, 0.032232336699962616, 0.002027183538302779, -0.04328649863600731, -0.015796851366758347, -0.009507624432444572, 0.001423171372152865, -0.023289121687412262, -0.028593286871910095, -0.02382878214120865, 0.058767568320035934, -0.006066145375370979, 0.010202478617429733, 0.0021917824633419514, 0.01106908731162548, -0.0176018588244915, -0.09561768174171448, 0.0439024418592453, -0.035118211060762405, -0.016928771510720253, -0.05400742217898369, 0.027745338156819344, -0.04285753145813942, 0.04007790982723236, 0.058963876217603683, -0.002830904209986329, 0.003114531049504876, -0.030050387606024742, 0.0020037624053657055, 0.01054585911333561, -0.0668218731880188, 0.02670253813266754, -0.021453069522976875, -0.027277374640107155, 0.0028721364215016365, -0.038316138088703156, -0.015808384865522385, 0.027039015665650368, -0.01825731247663498, -0.02769804373383522, -0.016036050394177437, -0.025053421035408974, 0.0027063682209700346, 0.06587273627519608, 0.005248149856925011, 0.0033267708495259285, 0.04267272353172302, 0.019249340519309044, 0.022219128906726837, 0.02319655753672123, 0.009679538197815418, -0.06305501610040665, 0.01663270778954029, -0.04080534726381302, -0.016385221853852272, -0.01789785921573639, 0.0006174233858473599, 0.004779388662427664, -0.04063508287072182, -0.03768973425030708, 0.03192228078842163, -0.0437876433134079, 0.016510242596268654, 0.056803904473781586, 0.007957758381962776, 0.05752525478601456, -0.017170604318380356, 0.023055626079440117, 0.02161189168691635, -0.027496153488755226, -0.00814126804471016, 0.03755122050642967, 0.024491019546985626, -0.019904430955648422, 0.021565010771155357, 0.018793635070323944, 0.013164731673896313, 0.02130606397986412, -0.0325951911509037, 0.0670352354645729, -0.03316698968410492, -0.003681589849293232, 0.010226684622466564, -0.025777775794267654, -0.006114254239946604, 0.03790140897035599, -0.02051524631679058, 0.06504236906766891, -0.017178157344460487, 0.014481227844953537, -0.05086963623762131, -0.019872797653079033, -0.003831013571470976, 0.005420828703790903, 0.01717798039317131, 0.010310562327504158, 0.033350057899951935, -0.03265709802508354, -0.003931532613933086, -0.0003230501024518162, 0.044387057423591614, -0.021713124588131905, 0.0027177713345736265, 0.00691938865929842, -0.015600473619997501, -0.024139149114489555, 0.022695140913128853, -0.06316544860601425, -0.015003681182861328, 0.05988738313317299, 0.04404382407665253, 0.03733666613698006, 0.00603521941229701, -0.03355151787400246, -0.014382598921656609, 0.02868735045194626, -0.044479940086603165, -0.004455035552382469, -0.05785062909126282, 0.051590755581855774, -0.005548907909542322, -0.03199077025055885 ]
<p>Suppose I have some kind of distribution which gives the probability of observing a given value (assume that this distribution is <strong>not</strong> normal).</p> <p>Now, I have a certain observation and I want to calculate how likely it is to observe a value that is equally or more extreme under this distribution. So, I am thinking of doing this empirically by turning my observation into a quantile and calculating the probability empirically under the distribution of: quantile_distribution &lt; quantile_observation and quantile_distribution > abs(1 - quantile_observation)</p> <p>I'm not sure whether that is a valid way to do it, but for the second part I'm going to assume it is.</p> <p>Now, here's where it gets a bit more complicated:</p> <p>My observation has some sort of measurement error associated with it. I can model this error with a probability distribution (this time it is roughly normal). Given this spread, how would I calculate a p-value as above (or would it be a distribution of p-values, which I have never seen)?</p> <p>I've been hacking something together where I take the p-value of observing the mean and the 95% CI values under the first distribution and then just take the maximum and report that, but obviously there has to be a better way to do it</p>
37,136
[ -0.02919239178299904, -0.014846735633909702, 0.005169397685676813, -0.005012976471334696, 0.014297425746917725, 0.06065337359905243, 0.05002652108669281, -0.008491938933730125, 0.018130088225007057, -0.012229755520820618, 0.041874900460243225, 0.060194697231054306, 0.05032983794808388, -0.013373572379350662, 0.022993506863713264, 0.0011422582902014256, -0.031328920274972916, -0.009037808515131474, -0.01809287630021572, -0.013466176576912403, -0.006153028458356857, 0.044796813279390335, -0.009470737539231777, -0.021690258756279945, -0.04650020971894264, 0.03642243891954422, 0.046721234917640686, -0.005026229657232761, 0.017731400206685066, 0.0702863410115242, -0.015443061478435993, -0.029137497767806053, -0.01055852510035038, 0.046829044818878174, 0.032945387065410614, -0.013354582712054253, -0.03815160319209099, -0.0038188013713806868, -0.03356916084885597, 0.022480433806777, -0.045045170933008194, 0.003419009270146489, 0.01568801887333393, -0.006012677680701017, -0.0015228355769068003, 0.010219952091574669, -0.022387128323316574, -0.04968129098415375, 0.013480249792337418, -0.06559857726097107, 0.03921816498041153, 0.015422727912664413, 0.0505903922021389, 0.038375124335289, -0.01728053018450737, -0.016925795003771782, 0.0852062776684761, 0.04926350340247154, 0.0018689896678552032, -0.05415886640548706, -0.009935823269188404, -0.01121177151799202, -0.013983764685690403, -0.01343962736427784, -0.013078044168651104, 0.026450805366039276, -0.041514113545417786, -0.031160341575741768, 0.01364905945956707, -0.0019802390597760677, 0.0228304211050272, 0.015949834138154984, 0.03231314942240715, -0.007888378575444221, 0.01398773118853569, -0.03554663807153702, 0.05013004317879677, 0.006187999155372381, 0.04474867507815361, 0.03925706446170807, -0.003952330444008112, -0.004916167818009853, 0.017715943977236748, 0.03787672519683838, 0.02510928548872471, -0.024453412741422653, 0.07031509280204773, -0.020717572420835495, -0.004352133255451918, 0.02465607412159443, -0.035711321979761124, -0.0224745012819767, 0.03557383269071579, -0.028712695464491844, -0.045898403972387314, 0.021908393129706383, 0.007192914839833975, 0.01942300796508789, -0.02306911163032055, -0.006336559075862169, -0.013985383324325085, -0.027466531842947006, 0.0012279408983886242, 0.047244731336832047, -0.03210863098502159, -0.010558157227933407, 0.0012650301214307547, -0.0003247442655265331, 0.02008170075714588, -0.0063383858650922775, 0.010687715373933315, 0.01934831589460373, 0.01141582615673542, -0.007347393315285444, 0.02281627058982849, -0.015379548072814941, 0.011490728706121445, -0.06923270970582962, 0.05105816572904587, 0.03999563306570053, 0.05131806060671806, -0.026001309975981712, 0.025966687127947807, -0.02798992395401001, -0.031613416969776154, 0.017066454514861107, 0.031319234520196915, 0.008869095705449581, -0.03898568078875542, 0.05734097212553024, -0.01202516257762909, -0.0036561572924256325, 0.04875713959336281, -0.006110919639468193, 0.018913509324193, -0.028591951355338097, -0.06848270446062088, -0.0639936700463295, 0.02357296831905842, 0.02182069607079029, -0.012536309659481049, -0.08485091477632523, -0.0015682262601330876, 0.07332886010408401, 0.02875669114291668, 0.04187675192952156, 0.029205355793237686, -0.014911516569554806, 0.01753096841275692, 0.027763260528445244, -0.021470151841640472, 0.002912299009039998, -0.004787492100149393, -0.04117225483059883, -0.04723159596323967, -0.06710872799158096, 0.02713727205991745, 0.018793221563100815, -0.00395255396142602, -0.008378208614885807, 0.031026042997837067, 0.0022065278608351946, -0.004622876178473234, -0.0010401972103863955, 0.009715152904391289, -0.009350751526653767, 0.08644026517868042, 0.00819828175008297, 0.01735822670161724, 0.020978353917598724, -0.0004880006308667362, -0.013174653053283691, 0.01586071029305458, 0.011257987469434738, 0.015818290412425995, -0.05371123552322388, -0.008474921807646751, -0.0398290641605854, 0.021268587559461594, 0.02123221568763256, -0.010393884032964706, 0.01707003451883793, -0.03130683675408363, 0.008455085568130016, 0.015135842375457287, 0.04884735494852066, -0.028897857293486595, -0.01604272797703743, 0.03705796226859093, -0.04364031180739403, -0.06219664588570595, -0.018149802461266518, -0.007545737084001303, 0.005791008472442627, -0.00469563901424408, 0.03839627653360367, -0.005952941719442606, 0.007502343039959669, -0.005452150013297796, 0.0018641664646565914, 0.010144934058189392, -0.002456670394167304, 0.05185136944055557, -0.05956590920686722, -0.0027343437541276217, 0.06122055649757385, 0.024047674611210823, 0.006014086306095123, 0.03724835813045502, -0.027319803833961487, -0.03249409422278404, -0.0046426295302808285, -0.048132847994565964, -0.013193216174840927, 0.0012402759166434407, -0.025410015136003494, 0.034044019877910614, -0.020254140719771385, -0.02216763235628605, -0.010077523067593575, -0.03835691884160042, 0.07826872915029526, 0.072547547519207, -0.0021042078733444214, -0.047288764268159866, 0.008364860899746418, -0.00933037605136633, -0.01486506313085556, -0.011013463139533997, 0.00024725327966734767, -0.07016574591398239, 0.004526137374341488, 0.000047037181502673775, 0.012260646559298038, -0.02932140603661537, 0.010111948475241661, 0.05254409834742546, -0.00008507943130098283, 0.02611379884183407, 0.04683425650000572, -0.020311107859015465, 0.014120211824774742, 0.007701274938881397, 0.01841658726334572, 0.051905348896980286, -0.00499901594594121, 0.024606894701719284, 0.014183448627591133, 0.047662850469350815, -0.006017226260155439, -0.0029906248673796654, 0.027376217767596245, -0.019864128902554512, 0.012128210626542568, -0.007706130389124155, -0.02822975628077984, 0.03913089632987976, -0.030770065262913704, 0.03263983502984047, 0.039476364850997925, -0.04872001335024834, -0.017341334372758865, 0.0020559332333505154, -0.014762734062969685, 0.03324471414089203, 0.0490795373916626, -0.034945808351039886, 0.0030603324994444847, 0.019151249900460243, -0.009750356897711754, -0.006379075814038515, -0.050231024622917175, -0.03362223133444786, -0.041821952909231186, 0.02079576626420021, -0.001662859576754272, -0.0022721888963133097, 0.006543392781168222, -0.036382269114255905, -0.04641640931367874, -0.019369130954146385, 0.0048486595042049885, 0.020248794928193092, 0.022927384823560715, -0.03936116024851799, -0.01672837883234024, -0.016499662771821022, -0.03240594640374184, 0.014270482584834099, -0.0015737211797386408, -0.028372440487146378, 0.009781328961253166, 0.00984410010278225, -0.03100091964006424, 0.0058678872883319855, -0.00018736094352789223, -0.011748154647648335, -0.0476289838552475, -0.03196202963590622, 0.033476416021585464, -0.02225411683320999, -0.028785018250346184, 0.05627770721912384, -0.020675353705883026, -0.022089939564466476, -0.017001299187541008, 0.011431916616857052, 0.010021611116826534, -0.005491264630109072, 0.02351582981646061, 0.018703723326325417, -0.012297936715185642, -0.020101601257920265, -0.09109769761562347, -0.0673217698931694, -0.0006090655224397779, 0.008709664456546307, 0.018214523792266846, 0.02764314040541649, 0.001865423284471035, 0.07830856740474701, 0.03724818676710129, -0.026926275342702866, -0.013130025006830692, 0.02233756333589554, -0.012557164765894413, 0.0031228289008140564, -0.03524688258767128, 0.007127303164452314, -0.02435789629817009, 0.013780294917523861, 0.010355762206017971, 0.013343626633286476, 0.03486630693078041, 0.028037773445248604, 0.013790429569780827, 0.01168100070208311, 0.01330496184527874, -0.007245388347655535, 0.027018295601010323, 0.03040621429681778, 0.002477062400430441, 0.02760137990117073, 0.00256725843064487, -0.002361919730901718, 0.012545472010970116, -0.021009331569075584, 0.025858912616968155, -0.008342739194631577, -0.015350687317550182, -0.0532967783510685, 0.025917768478393555, -0.0026426510885357857, -0.0076505872420966625, -0.027975937351584435, 0.03137305751442909, 0.021281028166413307, -0.04084723815321922, -0.008014725521206856, 0.06637125462293625, 0.04531640186905861, -0.01153525523841381, -0.06358954310417175, -0.0065545691177248955, 0.010759392753243446, 0.02482026070356369, -0.03267368674278259, -0.00356547674164176, 0.04257851839065552, 0.047266192734241486, 0.042330529540777206, 0.006828479468822479, -0.02235753834247589, 0.033968668431043625, -0.03816702961921692, -0.000785970885772258, -0.009082837030291557, 0.06191122531890869, 0.030743461102247238, 0.03800009563565254, 0.04136483371257782, -0.00032830965938046575, 0.008173868991434574, 0.006584635935723782, -0.05957108736038208, 0.038965191692113876, 0.008874588645994663, -0.03522675111889839, -0.032599762082099915, -0.04266046732664108, 0.040678590536117554, -0.03242878615856171, 0.044014908373355865, 0.01761946827173233, 0.008325762115418911, 0.004033024422824383, -0.005009157583117485, 0.007718291599303484, 0.008852554485201836, -0.03687853738665581, 0.009700905531644821, 0.005799105390906334, 0.005311104469001293, 0.04692297801375389, 0.02152007259428501, -0.016758378595113754, -0.00186882761772722, -0.04336914047598839, -0.001159468898549676, 0.0013675023801624775, 0.0649610385298729, 0.002079830737784505, 0.028565697371959686, -0.005297800060361624, 0.030314024537801743, 0.013813179917633533, 0.06223289296030998, 0.06365072727203369, -0.012503248639404774, -0.024201901629567146, 0.002924061845988035, -0.0016530044376850128, 0.0019090613350272179, 0.00013681738346349448, -0.0390499122440815, -0.004247435834258795, 0.04682144522666931, -0.012517314404249191, -0.06883347034454346, 0.02222592569887638, 0.07896564900875092, -0.014820190146565437, 0.027537237852811813, -0.03600886091589928, -0.028209013864398003, -0.02414085902273655, 0.012141114100813866, 0.022142862901091576, 0.013099540956318378, 0.016160791739821434, 0.01208509411662817, 0.06784965097904205, 0.0006275380728766322, -0.0430806428194046, -0.029016319662332535, 0.03204408660531044, 0.02409437857568264, 0.015739163383841515, -0.018657147884368896, 0.03971879556775093, 0.044517114758491516, 0.0553266704082489, -0.000677474366966635, 0.00033045237069018185, -0.08812374621629715, 0.00841605942696333, 0.04863424599170685, 0.018068155273795128, 0.0014483457198366523, -0.017891649156808853, -0.04290127381682396, 0.003498804522678256, 0.0037206890992820263, -0.05108540505170822, 0.04612772539258003, -0.014706725254654884, 0.0045303041115403175, -0.022969406098127365, -0.030579330399632454, -0.05761375278234482, 0.015908487141132355, -0.021725617349147797, 0.028052078559994698, -0.01968306489288807, -0.025131268426775932, -0.03146905079483986, -0.0037071157712489367, 0.023148270323872566, 0.06312136352062225, -0.009165294468402863, -0.0381045900285244, -0.03463083878159523, 0.019502922892570496, -0.004917989484965801, -0.06916403025388718, 0.009091260842978954, 0.00032459304202347994, 0.03155124932527542, 0.06073345988988876, 0.014158247038722038, -0.006718631833791733, 0.02631491608917713, -0.0016361469170078635, -0.03245772793889046, -0.010025138966739178, -0.02188880369067192, 0.07099433243274689, 0.0039209662936627865, 0.009168781340122223, 0.04860153794288635, 0.012265585362911224, 0.02109905704855919, 0.017653873190283775, -0.02187364734709263, 0.012034657411277294, -0.01894499734044075, -0.009460916742682457, -0.03707156702876091, 0.015039312653243542, -0.033621665090322495, 0.01669761724770069, 0.011028342880308628, 0.044875890016555786, -0.02551606297492981, -0.019882718101143837, -0.0064938743598759174, 0.021643200889229774, 0.0308435820043087, -0.010290568694472313, -0.019315170124173164, 0.014718279242515564, -0.008603441528975964, -0.016715221107006073, 0.02659245766699314, -0.0007530025904998183, 0.018496543169021606, -0.0013655670918524265, -0.06872237473726273, 0.030542228370904922, -0.03998732194304466, -0.04206220433115959, 0.019091341644525528, -0.011234134435653687, 0.023930974304676056, -0.026586515828967094, 0.036111775785684586, 0.01922832988202572, -0.02252546325325966, -0.03924484923481941, 0.04655497893691063, 0.009133405983448029, 0.05316485837101936, -0.04722290858626366, 0.035838060081005096, -0.011517631821334362, 0.002893186407163739, -0.07520175725221634, 0.006871398072689772, 0.053112611174583435, 0.03252837806940079, -0.03722171112895012, -0.002393977949395776, 0.020876895636320114, 0.010797152295708656, -0.02867450937628746, -0.017946379259228706, 0.025984784588217735, -0.0071241483092308044, -0.021380361169576645, -0.011489639058709145, 0.04228794574737549, 0.05931354686617851, -0.04465263709425926, 0.014818510971963406, 0.031491972506046295, 0.0035059014335274696, -0.03244626522064209, 0.042055074125528336, -0.006412672344595194, -0.02279847301542759, -0.027202147990465164, -0.034744106233119965, 0.0080354493111372, 0.0073953550308942795, -0.0061539108864963055, -0.01636921428143978, 0.02599457837641239, 0.008530260063707829, -0.0051533980295062065, -0.04010792076587677, -0.007265995256602764, -0.021936597302556038, -0.0068238889798521996, -0.009587178006768227, 0.006676810793578625, -0.00006731622852385044, -0.0031145287211984396, 0.05198735371232033, 0.0002524281735531986, -0.030170977115631104, 0.016650404781103134, 0.0697842463850975, -0.0176809374243021, 0.013737618923187256, -0.011592838913202286, -0.006689114961773157, 0.023113876581192017, 0.012189956381917, -0.034745410084724426, 0.05816830322146416, -0.004820984322577715, -0.0375606007874012, 0.005032211076468229, -0.03646674007177353, -0.01663838140666485, 0.07100224494934082, 0.0035047968849539757, 0.0549907423555851, 0.01747957058250904, 0.02299942448735237, -0.01503711473196745, -0.011728789657354355, 0.006797135341912508, 0.007359914481639862, 0.011744959279894829, 0.02982614003121853, -0.0022569261491298676, 0.011597596108913422, -0.006611362565308809, 0.045171160250902176, 0.008391625247895718, 0.033986154943704605, 0.004449420142918825, 0.045151956379413605, 0.020191766321659088, -0.03437972441315651, -0.01144763920456171, 0.03873409703373909, -0.06492457538843155, 0.0011600780999287963, -0.04227384924888611, -0.03985891491174698, -0.0008627688512206078, -0.013684986159205437, -0.025865092873573303, -0.049194857478141785, -0.04106626659631729, -0.039044879376888275, -0.008756489492952824, 0.03255104273557663, -0.01789649948477745, 0.044056206941604614, -0.024789324030280113, 0.030268188565969467, -0.01950014755129814, 0.036483265459537506, -0.01753927394747734, -0.06889945268630981, -0.03492802381515503, -0.020449338480830193, -0.041385091841220856, 0.04510406032204628, -0.0017400258220732212, 0.012420128099620342, 0.06550326198339462, -0.04471899941563606, 0.035172238945961, 0.030119283124804497, 0.03399258479475975, -0.013071641325950623, 0.04839028790593147, 0.008174881339073181, 0.010543933138251305, -0.007446789648383856, -0.004409752320498228, 0.11234232783317566, 0.0943942591547966, 0.01291355025023222, -0.05276857316493988, 0.013555594719946384, 0.003749376628547907, 0.02236131951212883, -0.016249509528279305, 0.014444236643612385, 0.01233668439090252, 0.014134419150650501, 0.03613143786787987, 0.046161215752363205, 0.028350673615932465, 0.0038615765515714884, 0.06797394901514053, -0.025304164737462997, -0.013286774046719074, 0.005053970031440258, 0.022992707788944244, -0.008827833458781242, -0.053300533443689346, -0.0325893796980381, 0.03550694137811661, -0.02365737594664097, -0.03301030397415161, -0.04596761614084244, -0.011155241169035435, -0.02802051417529583, 0.00928786676377058, -0.033041078597307205, -0.010050889104604721, 0.01491300668567419, -0.02554185688495636, 0.011124311946332455, -0.017379987984895706, -0.0036610537208616734, -0.0025063699577003717, 0.01761329174041748, 0.03513866662979126, 0.023495784029364586, 0.013121948577463627, 0.02046421356499195, 0.01438300870358944, -0.04173137992620468, -0.03741912543773651, -0.034210462123155594, 0.04110849276185036, -0.011508669704198837, -0.024653151631355286, -0.03516599163413048, -0.015867121517658234, -0.0038985982537269592, 0.007653997745364904, -0.005254675634205341, 0.017937123775482178, 0.00801961962133646, -0.052759576588869095, -0.01807587221264839, -0.0011791749857366085, 0.023733587935566902, -0.0061616068705916405, 0.025579126551747322, 0.021634889766573906, -0.028995033353567123, -0.036672186106443405, 0.00006549980025738478, 0.046857915818691254, 0.007502085063606501, -0.040613677352666855, 0.006452356930822134, -0.00390710448846221, -0.03831274434924126, -0.021629299968481064, -0.017776768654584885, -0.034053537994623184, 0.038051337003707886, 0.0018501312006264925, 0.01544245332479477, -0.04149828478693962, -0.01740013062953949, 0.019932743161916733, -0.037753451615571976, 0.013576779514551163, -0.08204064518213272, -0.01568371243774891, 0.0080936960875988, 0.034645311534404755, 0.012608077377080917, -0.00023269491794053465, 0.010095230303704739, 0.07639779895544052, 0.0224152822047472, -0.026552824303507805, 0.021127108484506607, -0.02201945334672928, -0.03423748165369034, 0.010217227973043919, -0.01637549139559269, 0.07701323926448822, 0.027804916724562645, 0.02730257250368595, 0.0010295953834429383, -0.02022588439285755, -0.016580164432525635, 0.015388468280434608, 0.018937721848487854, -0.05835713446140289, -0.023358771577477455, -0.002275475300848484, 0.009805076755583286, -0.018347501754760742, -0.008218699134886265, -0.05693396180868149, -0.04596738517284393, 0.012042422778904438, 0.002722928998991847, -0.02331361547112465, 0.03187182545661926, -0.012786313891410828, -0.015879306942224503, -0.010731179267168045, -0.018550418317317963, 0.011922725476324558, -0.012872364372015, -0.01082336064428091, -0.019400758668780327, -0.037510450929403305, 0.0011482747504487634, 0.0072621796280145645, -0.03378353640437126, 0.00683597382158041, 0.02219996228814125, 0.028021609410643578, -0.0005596627597697079, 0.005469104275107384, 0.004018703009933233, 0.010938255116343498, -0.0532129742205143, -0.009754047729074955, 0.06901557743549347, -0.044322628527879715, -0.035437412559986115, 0.05461164563894272, 0.010233348235487938, 0.054659366607666016, 0.023658104240894318, -0.029800642281770706, -0.02868744172155857, 0.011917024850845337, -0.020204365253448486, -0.054014407098293304, -0.008312495425343513, -0.009065809659659863, -0.04602862894535065, -0.0056472416035830975, 0.02339785359799862, -0.006686647422611713, 0.008744573220610619, 0.023217108100652695, 0.038837019354104996, 0.04471081122756004, 0.044113535434007645, 0.022097133100032806, 0.013359857723116875, 0.01585935615003109, 0.03308059275150299, -0.009996797889471054, 0.02895727939903736, 0.033559754490852356, -0.027547821402549744, 0.02156969904899597, -0.029233526438474655, -0.006538221146911383, -0.061074160039424896, -0.03556140884757042, 0.04380451887845993, -0.007231353782117367, 0.019779324531555176, -0.04787422716617584, 0.022411730140447617, 0.045590873807668686, -0.04636881500482559, 0.021094923838973045, -0.03763983026146889, -0.009915243834257126, -0.03528249263763428, 0.04234756901860237, -0.053151197731494904, 0.029640670865774155, 0.02966141887009144, -0.011641152203083038, 0.040621303021907806, 0.0434100404381752, 0.020079398527741432, -0.02516135945916176, -0.025850310921669006, 0.007753702811896801, 0.031472109258174896, -0.0659346729516983, 0.061113160103559494, -0.04379810392856598, -0.025807328522205353, 0.017047660425305367, -0.03351612016558647, 0.01546209305524826, 0.010974098928272724, 0.02330317161977291, 0.045538466423749924, 0.029553579166531563, 0.01854768395423889, 0.005609213840216398, -0.0311269573867321, 0.0073152403347194195, 0.030415935441851616, 0.04301071539521217, -0.017872994765639305, -0.012097569182515144, 0.03344704210758209, -0.024835992604494095, -0.07131150364875793, -0.003091946244239807, 0.022893307730555534, 0.007934294641017914, 0.005588249769061804, -0.002546399598941207, 0.019712036475539207, -0.036592669785022736, 0.021586481481790543, -0.05296884849667549, -0.000331001851009205, 0.061856016516685486, 0.03057650290429592, -0.02709859050810337, 0.0037123747169971466, -0.03014390729367733, -0.04064484313130379, 0.006032225210219622, 0.03144688159227371, -0.011500940658152103, -0.06431596726179123, 0.003914289642125368, -0.02739611826837063, -0.015377677977085114, 0.01150577049702406, -0.003931007348001003, -0.06998258829116821, -0.0021322413813322783, -0.029288608580827713, 0.010454353876411915, 0.021767722442746162, -0.015645669773221016, 0.012617097236216068, -0.11376486718654633, 0.08111462742090225, 0.004530301783233881, -0.0007794649573042989, -0.02670370601117611, -0.00978502631187439, -0.0415620431303978, 0.01100760605186224, 0.040147315710783005, 0.019103337079286575, -0.02974664606153965, 0.013330881483852863, 0.027827976271510124, -0.007056647911667824, -0.0868101492524147, 0.01449981052428484, -0.029974112287163734, -0.005510362330824137, -0.030364589765667915, -0.022638319060206413, -0.0018609818071126938, 0.00020830279390793294, 0.012026134878396988, -0.014771279878914356, 0.040766675025224686, 0.008794277906417847, -0.002032229909673333, 0.05155086889863014, -0.003952463623136282, 0.01285446435213089, 0.06425396353006363, 0.02160036563873291, 0.0009476965642534196, 0.02570205368101597, -0.009192992933094501, -0.03822597116231918, 0.06313015520572662, -0.01386285200715065, 0.009249390102922916, -0.009015411138534546, 0.04108019173145294, -0.03326253592967987, -0.0639398917555809, 0.0009885220788419247, -0.0028037072625011206, -0.08464229106903076, 0.00863928534090519, 0.01723887398838997, 0.0037521258927881718, 0.04872782900929451, 0.00043694055057130754, 0.03407442197203636, -0.014365383423864841, -0.015162449330091476, -0.012240920215845108, -0.010487464256584644, 0.05709361657500267, -0.025245776399970055, 0.04165622591972351, 0.047880399972200394, 0.004871482029557228, 0.006937223486602306, -0.021824266761541367, 0.05505227670073509, -0.027328036725521088, -0.02423715777695179, 0.01223032921552658, 0.007802229840308428, 0.023098386824131012, -0.0005221916944719851, -0.03435639664530754, 0.03185303881764412, -0.017734229564666748, 0.01031513698399067, -0.0357789508998394, -0.047426074743270874, -0.018097924068570137, 0.0007083427044562995, -0.007999861612915993, 0.01926169916987419, -0.00013337901327759027, 0.03434951975941658, -0.007712639402598143, 0.020682893693447113, 0.008829504251480103, -0.03341930732131004, 0.042431268841028214, -0.03236380219459534, -0.01116323284804821, -0.030488552525639534, -0.029936980456113815, -0.021857134997844696, -0.0019271532073616982, -0.0005548550398088992, 0.011736125685274601, 0.0144394775852561, 0.029818035662174225, -0.07319854199886322, 0.007012967951595783, 0.015244074165821075, -0.07714302837848663, 0.012704669497907162, -0.04661445692181587, 0.01722424477338791, -0.03516817092895508, -0.03548174351453781 ]
<p>How can I find the standard deviation in categorical distribution, where the elements have non-numerical attributes (e.g. colors)?</p> <p>For example, I have a bag of marbles with $n$ colors. There's an infinite number of marbles in the bag, and are biased towards a certain color with a probability of $\frac{x}n, x&gt;1$. From the bag, I pick $m$ marbles and get the probability distribution with respect to their colors. </p> <p>From this distribution, by picking $q$ colors with the highest probabilities, I want to convince others with a confidence interval $k$% (e.g. 95%), that one of the colors I chose is the one that the marbles are biased towards.</p> <p>In this scenario, what are some of the analysis techniques that can be used to find $q$, given $x,n,k,$ and $m$?</p>
74,305
[ -0.017811115831136703, -0.030920008197426796, 0.028523435816168785, -0.01761559024453163, 0.017528189346194267, 0.0003151562996208668, 0.012966262176632881, 0.0005930141778662801, 0.006645669229328632, -0.04358668252825737, 0.0665762722492218, 0.03878459334373474, 0.06515920162200928, 0.06829927861690521, 0.011845370754599571, -0.00043722547707147896, -0.014405470341444016, -0.010394182056188583, 0.007624717429280281, -0.00794940534979105, 0.0024011500645428896, 0.046892933547496796, 0.016201825812458992, -0.044780898839235306, -0.03318089619278908, 0.019852321594953537, 0.03569144010543823, -0.014917581342160702, 0.030686207115650177, 0.03845497593283653, -0.03654274716973305, -0.020958311855793, 0.00031123237567953765, 0.03400842100381851, -0.00353355729021132, 0.0026680920273065567, 0.0018403728026896715, -0.02357364073395729, -0.009842351078987122, -0.005620755720883608, -0.040984269231557846, -0.006211000960320234, 0.02881951630115509, -0.013593623414635658, 0.00010095664765685797, 0.018246011808514595, 0.004563362803310156, -0.0858801081776619, 0.030070487409830093, -0.05873672664165497, 0.09607827663421631, 0.0280989408493042, 0.020526006817817688, 0.04129989445209503, -0.018783485516905785, 0.0003920497838407755, 0.004066220484673977, 0.059216201305389404, 0.0023779256734997034, -0.048301320523023605, -0.023739531636238098, -0.03631337359547615, 0.010551929473876953, -0.04395930469036102, -0.014306886121630669, 0.0029919359367340803, 0.008393796160817146, 0.016259904950857162, 0.048956263810396194, -0.015226415358483791, 0.007729005068540573, 0.053532715886831284, 0.05102209001779556, -0.0018326048739254475, -0.0022007382940500975, 0.0009148537646979094, 0.022849973291158676, 0.01827158033847809, 0.04061015695333481, -0.010095709934830666, 0.03290602192282677, -0.01684807986021042, 0.008780055679380894, 0.014673830009996891, -0.0050026243552565575, -0.05176457017660141, 0.048838064074516296, -0.01903015561401844, 0.010303583927452564, 0.004563114605844021, -0.021155018359422684, -0.05276910588145256, 0.05329475179314613, -0.01234048418700695, -0.055002517998218536, 0.03523319959640503, -0.032656386494636536, -0.0028820373117923737, 0.01632402464747429, -0.052550941705703735, 0.002210299950093031, -0.04790578782558441, 0.01540900208055973, 0.04819489270448685, -0.022066865116357803, 0.016975386068224907, 0.018799148499965668, 0.0018418921390548348, -0.02202688902616501, 0.007015852723270655, 0.012265972793102264, 0.012272799387574196, 0.031311530619859695, 0.009319528937339783, 0.026842908933758736, 0.029161449521780014, -0.034855276346206665, -0.060762666165828705, 0.023718614131212234, 0.048328764736652374, 0.012007556855678558, -0.004933350719511509, 0.0063626328483223915, -0.015902599319815636, -0.005861987825483084, 0.00986549537628889, 0.025706665590405464, 0.005040506366640329, -0.03702956438064575, 0.0333891436457634, -0.019969787448644638, -0.032038070261478424, 0.0354590006172657, 0.029072750359773636, -0.01405139360576868, -0.012500176206231117, -0.10404917597770691, -0.047220390290021896, 0.020087741315364838, -0.008422810584306717, -0.0006602405337616801, -0.0443611741065979, -0.02115209586918354, 0.07400795072317123, 0.03160957247018814, 0.024985136464238167, 0.061808228492736816, 0.002341112121939659, 0.030113577842712402, 0.03809743374586105, -0.03184155374765396, -0.0006304458947852254, -0.028580646961927414, 0.021880581974983215, -0.015565602108836174, -0.05594750493764877, 0.07167910039424896, 0.006072745192795992, -0.016907712444663048, -0.03971440717577934, 0.023394089192152023, -0.004235998261719942, -0.01748775690793991, 0.0218306053429842, 0.0037567352410405874, 0.0012646064860746264, 0.0667426586151123, 0.010805254802107811, 0.006215377245098352, -0.011036654002964497, 0.026386307552456856, -0.009546988643705845, 0.04957995191216469, 0.049531929194927216, 0.053631048649549484, -0.022330546751618385, 0.01969992183148861, 0.0003649301070254296, 0.019293371587991714, -0.01809048093855381, -0.04518788680434227, -0.025019686669111252, -0.010667217895388603, 0.013692536391317844, 0.012766256928443909, 0.03457267954945564, -0.016076071187853813, -0.030423490330576897, 0.05685010179877281, -0.03587770089507103, -0.016305003315210342, -0.04484546557068825, 0.01414196752011776, -0.019862700253725052, -0.0440228171646595, 0.05344807356595993, 0.0062935249879956245, 0.014452752657234669, -0.011613693088293076, 0.02774634398519993, -0.018988175317645073, 0.0002741818316280842, 0.04181380942463875, -0.06945328414440155, -0.0005336725735105574, 0.04867946729063988, 0.03638121113181114, -0.0077241635881364346, 0.03987470641732216, -0.04560213163495064, -0.07907681912183762, -0.004260397050529718, -0.04888128489255905, 0.006809879560023546, 0.004774848930537701, -0.02124740183353424, 0.022033264860510826, -0.011262550950050354, -0.004810227081179619, 0.011521680280566216, -0.02839094214141369, 0.06143386289477348, 0.01943362131714821, -0.016189590096473694, 0.00679036183282733, -0.008616173639893532, 0.024249285459518433, 0.01912321336567402, 0.012886409647762775, -0.02598530240356922, -0.014419770799577236, 0.0010612307814881206, 0.016415439546108246, 0.02385086566209793, -0.041046399623155594, 0.0016836501890793443, 0.006176311988383532, 0.012835371308028698, 0.017862429842352867, -0.0033642605412751436, -0.026804231107234955, 0.002053166041150689, -0.01302765030413866, 0.029736272990703583, -0.000041501796658849344, 0.00418836111202836, 0.0016807570355013013, 0.011930495500564575, 0.025428205728530884, 0.02362091839313507, -0.0036198750603944063, 0.03603295981884003, -0.008886110968887806, -0.009163899347186089, -0.011863477528095245, -0.03546689823269844, 0.03656245395541191, -0.02300655096769333, 0.003565586172044277, 0.060785554349422455, 0.011339172720909119, 0.00019356576376594603, 0.02498389594256878, -0.049895886331796646, 0.008965975604951382, 0.04313424602150917, -0.04802997410297394, 0.026893241330981255, 0.019449559971690178, -0.009982955642044544, 0.030169475823640823, -0.0014627021737396717, -0.0507793165743351, -0.0018696910701692104, -0.004912551026791334, 0.014803613536059856, -0.010103031061589718, -0.022039109840989113, -0.0014207427157089114, -0.01593927852809429, 0.018580187112092972, 0.004195801448076963, 0.027266914024949074, 0.022841796278953552, -0.07705499976873398, -0.01814907416701317, -0.048473846167325974, -0.029092296957969666, -0.010761510580778122, -0.03155859187245369, -0.03296032175421715, 0.06753122061491013, 0.012513394467532635, -0.048437416553497314, 0.007354180794209242, -0.008980955928564072, 0.018743619322776794, -0.03634503111243248, -0.014878406189382076, 0.010676166042685509, 0.008768565952777863, -0.05596739426255226, 0.04069212079048157, -0.05646299198269844, -0.054948851466178894, -0.044772740453481674, 0.013884657993912697, 0.016777167096734047, 0.013957430608570576, -0.004930776543915272, 0.0072330147959291935, 0.023817269131541252, -0.005366466008126736, -0.08828780800104141, -0.06411821395158768, -0.017690101638436317, 0.007833855226635933, 0.04842498153448105, 0.026680031791329384, 0.024935470893979073, 0.07301834225654602, 0.06780249625444412, -0.04457872733473778, -0.025486880913376808, 0.01226635742932558, -0.03483656793832779, -0.03580838069319725, -0.0006391879869624972, 0.012982555665075779, 0.008215874433517456, 0.02811821922659874, 0.007151145488023758, 0.0264715775847435, 0.03630249574780464, -0.02321639470756054, -0.03268088027834892, 0.042918842285871506, -0.0437590517103672, -0.003522581420838833, 0.03569465130567551, 0.017986712977290154, -0.046297669410705566, 0.021635141223669052, -0.0022406401112675667, 0.028027748689055443, 0.01036716066300869, -0.050667308270931244, 0.01913248561322689, -0.028106307610869408, -0.010836886242032051, -0.029774857684969902, 0.06008410453796387, 0.008709240704774857, -0.031063582748174667, 0.040740787982940674, 0.03782791271805763, -0.002692826557904482, -0.03610062226653099, 0.03181769698858261, 0.066889189183712, 0.06506554782390594, -0.02740461379289627, -0.04187387600541115, -0.0015137953450903296, -0.02258564531803131, 0.05418533459305763, -0.02972506918013096, -0.0028563663363456726, 0.004832962062209845, 0.0637459084391594, 0.050324585288763046, 0.00986361876130104, -0.006434640381485224, 0.013320043683052063, -0.05840194597840309, -0.02822532318532467, -0.025229668244719505, 0.06654851883649826, 0.022555239498615265, 0.05947059020400047, 0.0294177383184433, -0.01606571488082409, -0.022930700331926346, 0.016513140872120857, -0.07380779087543488, 0.019552724435925484, -0.011801568791270256, -0.005098943132907152, -0.03091295063495636, -0.04173225536942482, 0.026692938059568405, -0.019016996026039124, -0.0013574449112638831, 0.005108838435262442, 0.03850431740283966, -0.026884475722908974, -0.0019615106284618378, -0.04022158682346344, -0.03197942301630974, 0.016863500699400902, 0.025082621723413467, -0.0062158480286598206, -0.040178436785936356, 0.03391570225358009, 0.025121251121163368, -0.009940200485289097, 0.0007178523810580373, -0.03532806783914566, 0.021230382844805717, 0.009209827519953251, 0.03885846957564354, 0.023207053542137146, 0.04594329372048378, -0.03894931450486183, 0.017484622076153755, -0.0006192165892571211, 0.1009359210729599, 0.012110013514757156, 0.002091062720865011, 0.03625383973121643, -0.06699950993061066, 0.018223922699689865, -0.0015008007176220417, 0.015439669601619244, -0.017928479239344597, -0.032606031745672226, 0.07350925356149673, 0.024906162172555923, -0.07173293828964233, 0.01364015694707632, 0.019853467121720314, 0.012205074541270733, -0.03405870497226715, -0.01351843774318695, 0.0026726096402853727, -0.016895195469260216, -0.0008304487564601004, -0.009667580015957355, 0.008513346314430237, 0.02535153552889824, 0.008740793913602829, 0.04917160049080849, 0.013583596795797348, -0.046597469598054886, -0.04330133646726608, 0.037920992821455, 0.034926850348711014, -0.021366754546761513, -0.02488318271934986, 0.013461158610880375, 0.016725994646549225, 0.033055320382118225, -0.016660545021295547, 0.01448751799762249, -0.08948443830013275, 0.015071949921548367, 0.016692161560058594, 0.05233302339911461, -0.021804608404636383, 0.0035418467596173286, -0.034359872341156006, -0.0006196991889737546, 0.05162646993994713, 0.016769124194979668, 0.0115552619099617, 0.007542855106294155, 0.020184144377708435, -0.02105426788330078, 0.014978698454797268, -0.04306849464774132, 0.008474317379295826, -0.0021453560329973698, 0.03041795827448368, -0.020057665184140205, -0.026271147653460503, -0.0344676598906517, -0.00999793317168951, 0.04700438678264618, 0.043085984885692596, -0.012993128970265388, -0.006500802934169769, -0.004741176031529903, 0.017898961901664734, 0.02077697217464447, -0.06305497884750366, 0.02210574969649315, -0.0033887235913425684, -0.035822104662656784, 0.05072836950421333, 0.00346448109485209, -0.055383533239364624, 0.006402458064258099, 0.004366058856248856, -0.013622470200061798, 0.0020908936858177185, -0.010297177359461784, 0.027385065332055092, 0.0038900028448551893, 0.03708038479089737, 0.036942195147275925, 0.033392176032066345, -0.03255734220147133, -0.0057941703125834465, -0.04477459192276001, 0.03398716077208519, 0.009245732799172401, -0.050900693982839584, -0.0068685091100633144, -0.021866558119654655, -0.001605635043233633, 0.00649306271225214, 0.017391400411725044, 0.04120587930083275, 0.017175165936350822, -0.023275917395949364, -0.03990048170089722, 0.020081812515854836, 0.016668764874339104, 0.028356678783893585, -0.0012445485917851329, -0.0012428543996065855, 0.019546901807188988, -0.004512641113251448, 0.04535916447639465, 0.016087792813777924, 0.0037125782109797, -0.019587406888604164, -0.03820452094078064, -0.0006709783338010311, -0.0669599398970604, -0.03627258166670799, -0.009555330500006676, 0.008304051123559475, 0.061882492154836655, -0.022453032433986664, 0.0432666651904583, -0.010374234989285469, -0.035742711275815964, -0.035369712859392166, 0.02183469384908676, -0.016590531915426254, 0.036253638565540314, -0.05398864671587944, 0.034112703055143356, -0.015431576408445835, 0.009047787636518478, -0.06392330676317215, -0.013560089282691479, -0.02496171183884144, 0.026824157685041428, -0.05099736526608467, -0.025962233543395996, 0.005554218776524067, -0.00817201379686594, -0.02659040503203869, -0.00029418786289170384, 0.031137701123952866, -0.006285361014306545, -0.013596714474260807, -0.012173829600214958, 0.03018203005194664, 0.045419830828905106, -0.015121475793421268, -0.01596144214272499, 0.004845964722335339, 0.0012113169068470597, 0.003483670763671398, -0.017067817971110344, -0.015284947119653225, -0.017823686823248863, -0.01552809402346611, -0.014483107253909111, 0.043485332280397415, -0.0006804452277719975, -0.05475207418203354, -0.03580498322844505, 0.03269246220588684, 0.03136495128273964, 0.0010279444977641106, -0.012567625381052494, -0.008043739013373852, 0.015787651762366295, 0.007238907273858786, -0.01300686877220869, -0.005393711384385824, -0.023302441462874413, 0.011791515164077282, 0.05664333328604698, 0.02637660503387451, -0.028692102059721947, 0.04551122710108757, 0.08385246992111206, -0.013000481761991978, -0.014986703172326088, -0.0005093146464787424, 0.0036075927782803774, 0.038110386580228806, 0.014019165188074112, -0.029623016715049744, 0.01827378012239933, 0.003002093406394124, 0.026474224403500557, -0.012232685461640358, -0.026014747098088264, -0.003037414513528347, 0.05463641881942749, 0.0040428959764540195, 0.05094683915376663, 0.01738661341369152, -0.001861071796156466, 0.008630079217255116, -0.018196091055870056, -0.032629333436489105, -0.023306753486394882, 0.019792022183537483, 0.03797975927591324, 0.008022780530154705, 0.02409854345023632, 0.020196713507175446, 0.04967937245965004, -0.03946397826075554, 0.044486064463853836, 0.012489963322877884, 0.003626959165558219, 0.052252840250730515, -0.0606347993016243, -0.05167437717318535, 0.02790488861501217, -0.06433837860822678, 0.014822594821453094, -0.052331287413835526, -0.019893739372491837, 0.0158059224486351, 0.027838075533509254, -0.02901211753487587, -0.04872405156493187, -0.0019050186965614557, -0.04039757326245308, 0.008337738923728466, 0.02602342888712883, 0.01370382122695446, 0.01174166053533554, -0.01930919475853443, 0.01605398766696453, -0.03530016541481018, 0.02712215855717659, -0.00871710479259491, -0.06772732734680176, -0.039807435125112534, -0.012187951244413853, -0.044823404401540756, -0.004253241699188948, 0.02199438400566578, -0.015906432643532753, 0.022559460252523422, -0.04449528828263283, 0.06144361570477486, -0.010587397962808609, -0.001746875699609518, 0.005266031250357628, 0.06404318660497665, -0.009996946901082993, 0.02892990969121456, 0.021639542654156685, -0.009983842261135578, 0.11082302778959274, 0.060115739703178406, 0.0620272234082222, -0.07333982735872269, 0.002335197990760207, 0.015429085120558739, -0.01323067769408226, -0.00676747364923358, 0.005253782961517572, 0.025487199425697327, 0.02826027385890484, 0.019077705219388008, 0.0495714507997036, 0.010667997412383556, -0.006007487419992685, 0.05369754508137703, -0.02168715000152588, -0.014036351814866066, 0.025457117706537247, 0.000622158229816705, -0.02959510311484337, 0.012645212933421135, -0.04895502328872681, 0.006827100645750761, 0.004202320706099272, -0.016633348539471626, -0.031895846128463745, -0.02120334468781948, 0.007842506282031536, 0.0037540749181061983, -0.006926362402737141, -0.0020310149993747473, 0.019560087472200394, 0.0190728809684515, -0.02286648377776146, -0.019744740799069405, 0.010211781598627567, -0.04975918307900429, 0.0284897293895483, 0.0038033456075936556, 0.020386099815368652, -0.01599908247590065, -0.014572251588106155, 0.02243252843618393, -0.05183682218194008, -0.06031841039657593, -0.06772030144929886, -0.007378132548183203, -0.034200698137283325, -0.01767314411699772, -0.015346882864832878, -0.01887594908475876, -0.01216799858957529, -0.007746050134301186, -0.00776738952845335, 0.0072511644102633, 0.01778261736035347, -0.04002029076218605, 0.014896568842232227, -0.016716819256544113, 0.02253449708223343, -0.011096428148448467, 0.012251300737261772, -0.00047956500202417374, -0.014425734058022499, -0.03209368884563446, 0.021913103759288788, 0.01733420230448246, 0.033962130546569824, -0.02825837954878807, -0.027137640863656998, -0.030103685334324837, -0.014760860241949558, 0.016487356275320053, -0.02413182333111763, 0.00011065793660236523, 0.037407539784908295, 0.008133973926305771, -0.02397618629038334, 0.0168352872133255, -0.02440011501312256, 0.005349240731447935, -0.03223041445016861, -0.0016331493388861418, -0.028152575716376305, -0.00598449632525444, -0.018069084733724594, 0.022406546398997307, 0.018181519582867622, 0.005373109597712755, 0.0024224829394370317, 0.056005317717790604, 0.01787394843995571, -0.04307158663868904, 0.010871343314647675, -0.051078081130981445, -0.06126825511455536, 0.031420014798641205, -0.025961188599467278, 0.06298890709877014, 0.015402980148792267, 0.0018998845480382442, 0.005149237345904112, -0.010213254950940609, 0.015920985490083694, 0.018070608377456665, 0.019858602434396744, -0.044446129351854324, 0.007091093342751265, 0.03171919658780098, -0.00013856372970622033, -0.04533225670456886, -0.04119613766670227, -0.0019236203515902162, -0.06494972854852676, 0.0502549484372139, -0.016480840742588043, -0.02964235469698906, -0.023408742621541023, 0.0017601457657292485, 0.011655999347567558, -0.012251140549778938, -0.002722580451518297, -0.00384447886608541, -0.004945106338709593, -0.05082910135388374, 0.018481293693184853, -0.024963732808828354, 0.01076152827590704, -0.01896694302558899, 0.008332428522408009, 0.01988821104168892, 0.004839107859879732, 0.047988489270210266, -0.008656967431306839, 0.009335813112556934, 0.009928997606039047, 0.031031586229801178, -0.018413197249174118, -0.0008842837414704263, 0.05882934853434563, -0.04633516073226929, -0.015258926898241043, 0.0065499902702867985, -0.00394302187487483, 0.04914902523159981, 0.04166567325592041, -0.0016580622177571058, -0.007585793733596802, 0.02172894962131977, -0.05848316103219986, -0.03911124914884567, -0.007468216121196747, -0.008020597510039806, -0.012451188638806343, -0.021348323673009872, 0.01591801643371582, 0.011319209821522236, -0.014117945916950703, 0.03541647642850876, 0.04774143546819687, -0.02648717537522316, -0.009831949137151241, 0.05163439363241196, 0.0008931300835683942, -0.0014654031256213784, 0.05174751207232475, 0.0299378614872694, -0.0036216313019394875, 0.06293722987174988, -0.028763797134160995, 0.033561818301677704, -0.008307123556733131, -0.012237589806318283, -0.06379131227731705, -0.0485386997461319, 0.038944073021411896, 0.010541567578911781, 0.06336069107055664, -0.09054230153560638, 0.02000076323747635, 0.059879422187805176, -0.05049652233719826, 0.043665383011102676, -0.01585063710808754, -0.03745829686522484, -0.05192331224679947, 0.022961707785725594, 0.00838459562510252, -0.00010969296272378415, 0.02779076062142849, -0.011769641190767288, 0.04909341409802437, 0.04959305748343468, 0.010752111673355103, -0.014384162612259388, -0.018302423879504204, -0.012834747321903706, 0.03856584057211876, -0.06394102424383163, 0.021234212443232536, -0.030502082780003548, -0.027971969917416573, 0.011532893404364586, -0.0008952768985182047, -0.004289254546165466, 0.05656687170267105, 0.01920023187994957, -0.032893646508455276, 0.05687583237886429, 0.024446291849017143, -0.003800423117354512, -0.018910851329565048, 0.004376535303890705, 0.07089349627494812, 0.020255280658602715, -0.019581571221351624, -0.01573561504483223, 0.029480962082743645, -0.01142963021993637, -0.03148531913757324, 0.026499809697270393, -0.0015989206731319427, -0.04129400476813316, 0.04083321988582611, -0.017562812194228172, -0.01762007549405098, -0.018469948321580887, 0.06299030035734177, -0.03936954587697983, 0.012505078688263893, 0.0018367208540439606, 0.01294556725770235, 0.002781806979328394, -0.004816866014152765, -0.028077661991119385, -0.056064922362565994, -0.006324468180537224, 0.013667967170476913, -0.01079698745161295, -0.02570410817861557, 0.01746925339102745, -0.038103438913822174, 0.04616227373480797, -0.020368313416838646, -0.03647870942950249, -0.032542623579502106, 0.0442284420132637, -0.011864975094795227, 0.020518293604254723, -0.008009862154722214, -0.011962871998548508, 0.0221554022282362, -0.07522047311067581, 0.02984762005507946, 0.04189860448241234, -0.004940473940223455, -0.028235705569386482, 0.03433467820286751, -0.04957813397049904, -0.01988937333226204, 0.04689178988337517, 0.014016612432897091, -0.021178603172302246, 0.018525380641222, 0.006943824235349894, 0.025703564286231995, 0.0029205630999058485, 0.015149209648370743, -0.057524051517248154, -0.014957249164581299, -0.04536091536283493, -0.009393157437443733, 0.01907370053231716, 0.010268650949001312, 0.01295663695782423, 0.023298779502511024, 0.013019801117479801, 0.02795291878283024, -0.01949830912053585, 0.04322255030274391, -0.019257569685578346, -0.0022794061806052923, 0.02987009659409523, 0.004388069733977318, -0.03093973733484745, 0.011626724153757095, -0.0006682714447379112, -0.059038128703832626, 0.01703573390841484, -0.016568243503570557, -0.051624756306409836, 0.018271204084157944, 0.016103651374578476, -0.0041431463323533535, -0.05196563899517059, 0.003893115557730198, 0.06688950210809708, -0.03100310079753399, 0.007918131537735462, 0.012683138251304626, 0.03797386214137077, 0.03372415900230408, 0.006273935548961163, -0.010321165435016155, 0.02046586014330387, -0.011483520269393921, 0.046703413128852844, 0.016032399609684944, 0.006930704228579998, -0.02219514735043049, -0.004990461748093367, 0.02364574931561947, 0.0024223520886152983, 0.003916518297046423, 0.026217905804514885, 0.026272444054484367, 0.0006652214215137064, -0.017023522406816483, 0.03335358574986458, -0.000029224000172689557, 0.051457274705171585, 0.013485725037753582, -0.0391605980694294, 0.06249944120645523, -0.02451096847653389, -0.0026691341772675514, -0.05381664261221886, -0.0018596291774883866, -0.02604673057794571, -0.04198180511593819, -0.011598940007388592, 0.024017896503210068, 0.00631083594635129, -0.007880494929850101, 0.02465903013944626, 0.011840649880468845, 0.007061727810651064, -0.006623410619795322, 0.050083328038454056, 0.0049773273058235645, -0.005518666002899408, -0.02898496575653553, -0.06831999123096466, 0.004979641642421484, 0.0014984207227826118, 0.004041282460093498, 0.041358500719070435, 0.06288749724626541, 0.04091542214155197, -0.014275725930929184, -0.04009867087006569, 0.03036797232925892, -0.037453677505254745, -0.016330650076270103, -0.04096577316522598, 0.0016647777520120144, -0.009356123395264149, -0.03491426631808281 ]
<p>I have recently interviewed for a statistical analysis job and was asked a question about why linear least squares regression fails when the data is heteroskedastic. The correct answer to this question, according to the interviewers, is that heteroskedastic data means that the equation of the regression line produced by least squares regression is an unbiased estimator of the true relationship, but that it is NOT efficient, essentially because the part of the dataset where the variance is smaller than average is effectively underweighted. </p> <p>My question is <strong>which textbooks could I use to find more detail about this topic, and other similar topics at this level</strong>, e.g. </p> <ul> <li>the relationship between data being normally distributed and least-squares linear regression being the maximum likelihood estimator for the straight line fit </li> </ul> <p>[I have a degree in mathematics but with minimal statistics background &amp; understand general probability concepts such as the central limit theorem, random variables, etc, and I know high school level statistics up to the British A-level S4 statistics, however I lack a certain level of statistics knowledge and don't know what I don't know or where to find out more... ]</p>
37,138
[ -0.028511198237538338, -0.03957487642765045, -0.0004707859188783914, 0.0018186707748100162, 0.04028623178601265, 0.026014551520347595, 0.017354976385831833, -0.020173612982034683, 0.013785269111394882, -0.019157305359840393, 0.04609900712966919, 0.02326955646276474, 0.05718180164694786, 0.011821834370493889, 0.028535928577184677, -0.0005428249132819474, -0.030330296605825424, 0.00243851775303483, -0.04291531816124916, 0.0022689923644065857, -0.014470546506345272, 0.015691248700022697, -0.001488097244873643, 0.008250950835645199, -0.03588822856545448, 0.03715493902564049, 0.03927278146147728, -0.012834918685257435, 0.01963404193520546, 0.04512658715248108, -0.05510794371366501, -0.0026917147915810347, 0.007433480117470026, 0.03623603656888008, 0.02311817556619644, 0.028176160529255867, -0.013169473968446255, -0.05277567356824875, 0.0006997754098847508, 0.07725021243095398, -0.03541981801390648, -0.014914746396243572, -0.0031306566670536995, 0.06030627340078354, 0.008396289311349392, 0.028773747384548187, -0.005901745520532131, -0.03572823479771614, 0.011749492958188057, -0.05400170385837555, 0.07552111148834229, -0.011045802384614944, 0.030943213030695915, 0.04830299690365791, -0.010075726546347141, -0.011302885599434376, 0.04225209355354309, 0.07464709132909775, -0.04468910023570061, -0.0633731260895729, -0.02590605616569519, -0.0143062649294734, 0.005880336742848158, -0.021461250260472298, -0.029103873297572136, 0.012933030724525452, -0.011001497507095337, -0.018370309844613075, 0.056940365582704544, 0.014190243557095528, -0.0007838865858502686, 0.037045978009700775, 0.03760802373290062, 0.019332122057676315, -0.009494203142821789, -0.011880939826369286, -0.0030224730726331472, 0.021155621856451035, 0.05150129273533821, 0.018162401393055916, 0.013969382271170616, 0.01579567790031433, 0.015840895473957062, 0.03564722463488579, 0.03317625820636749, -0.01658320054411888, 0.0718226358294487, 0.0031572189182043076, 0.007009879685938358, 0.013746543787419796, 0.012174231931567192, -0.010557902045547962, 0.0021715741604566574, 0.0032187432516366243, -0.03748934343457222, 0.025685392320156097, -0.004531362093985081, 0.0442153662443161, 0.039706725627183914, 0.020966345444321632, 0.003727971576154232, -0.044529493898153305, 0.010331259109079838, 0.04469035938382149, 0.018339315429329872, -0.05726686120033264, 0.012785879895091057, 0.004555839113891125, -0.019261030480265617, -0.057083550840616226, 0.016283348202705383, 0.012288054451346397, 0.006497765425592661, 0.015073043294250965, -0.0025191539898514748, -0.016528060659766197, 0.008497693575918674, -0.029676394537091255, 0.06773214042186737, 0.08086013793945312, 0.011267164722084999, -0.04595993831753731, 0.01884661801159382, -0.002765102544799447, -0.026310820132493973, 0.018033454194664955, 0.01802603155374527, -0.031211720779538155, -0.025594398379325867, 0.06265237927436829, 0.014124399051070213, -0.019833384081721306, 0.005288262851536274, 0.02644454874098301, 0.03011472523212433, 0.0071257175877690315, -0.09977269917726517, -0.046281155198812485, 0.04408884048461914, -0.02039557322859764, -0.02168932370841503, -0.04605551436543465, -0.017727937549352646, 0.00013293598021846265, 0.033627547323703766, -0.03717676177620888, 0.05840407311916351, -0.0015062314923852682, 0.016010357066988945, -0.012305060401558876, 0.009323548525571823, -0.030375797301530838, -0.039818163961172104, -0.002058690646663308, 0.030504226684570312, -0.06576622277498245, 0.0039042867720127106, 0.02546802908182144, -0.00969533622264862, -0.03929661214351654, 0.00784597173333168, -0.011095216497778893, 0.007755791302770376, 0.024874409660696983, 0.0008920227992348373, -0.026580901816487312, 0.06994082778692245, -0.008183913305401802, 0.03479146957397461, 0.03212464228272438, -0.043264660984277725, -0.001664919313043356, 0.012752769514918327, 0.04525034874677658, 0.03485836088657379, -0.006889038253575563, -0.0009158499888144433, -0.015444198623299599, 0.007593126967549324, 0.0017792084254324436, -0.028555739670991898, -0.013778905384242535, -0.019613884389400482, -0.009159456007182598, 0.0032622995786368847, 0.03494757041335106, 0.030454151332378387, -0.02295891009271145, 0.017521006986498833, -0.0396181084215641, -0.036564864218235016, -0.04088441655039787, 0.011348106898367405, -0.007029098924249411, -0.014137640595436096, 0.04366510361433029, -0.025301923975348473, 0.0013791290111839771, -0.034033942967653275, -0.010228130966424942, 0.004135878756642342, -0.010881331749260426, 0.033978212624788284, -0.027130646631121635, 0.02597052790224552, 0.06313999742269516, 0.03601257875561714, -0.021774953231215477, 0.020062312483787537, -0.03069392777979374, -0.06108247488737106, 0.015209867618978024, -0.00429203687235713, 0.025814605876803398, 0.024947263300418854, -0.004472633823752403, -0.0037695656064897776, -0.01255941204726696, -0.016880052164196968, 0.040144357830286026, -0.03162708878517151, 0.03283515200018883, 0.06703193485736847, -0.0017240812303498387, -0.0007351498352363706, 0.05069667845964432, -0.0146412942558527, 0.02677910029888153, -0.0007121010567061603, 0.011091169901192188, -0.033531349152326584, 0.021501531824469566, 0.031724609434604645, -0.017893671989440918, -0.042162589728832245, -0.020469969138503075, 0.07593127340078354, 0.035484831780195236, 0.0029416861943900585, 0.019007554277777672, -0.046201590448617935, -0.04832873120903969, -0.0005869145970791578, -0.04766739532351494, -0.006144188344478607, 0.008398784324526787, -0.012782718986272812, 0.04534543305635452, 0.044194210320711136, 0.04646708071231842, -0.014708132483065128, 0.04693448916077614, 0.0026591182686388493, -0.013398272916674614, -0.03195211663842201, -0.010817901231348515, 0.05046096444129944, 0.0034066957887262106, 0.047612689435482025, 0.015482292510569096, 0.006413990166038275, 0.021982451900839806, 0.0017840361688286066, -0.021134981885552406, 0.017463110387325287, 0.023522550240159035, 0.0037850751541554928, 0.011494793929159641, 0.03329014405608177, -0.06607715040445328, 0.001222893944941461, -0.007299407850950956, -0.028936563059687614, -0.014973731711506844, -0.03317936882376671, 0.01290794275701046, 0.01497443113476038, 0.02086017094552517, -0.018795767799019814, -0.00986838061362505, -0.0012254114262759686, -0.0192289799451828, 0.03702131658792496, -0.005683115217834711, -0.04304046556353569, -0.012506107799708843, -0.03642117977142334, -0.002316985046491027, 0.003087481949478388, -0.004804564639925957, 0.0016638435190543532, 0.03908361867070198, -0.008904636837542057, -0.028045320883393288, -0.04850125312805176, -0.04865983501076698, -0.01557558961212635, -0.00928003154695034, -0.013396731577813625, 0.054672252386808395, -0.02622496895492077, -0.016383137553930283, 0.019419919699430466, -0.04538401961326599, -0.026809224858880043, -0.04015440121293068, 0.012170946225523949, -0.020411226898431778, 0.018806811422109604, 0.01205084752291441, 0.017705347388982773, -0.005203212145715952, -0.003256187541410327, -0.06887753307819366, -0.06613994389772415, 0.006426215637475252, 0.009243032895028591, 0.02690057083964348, -0.002006606897339225, -0.006115779746323824, 0.07039378583431244, 0.037360984832048416, -0.017391003668308258, -0.02705521509051323, -0.0028133082669228315, -0.03600812330842018, -0.045544300228357315, 0.027814891189336777, 0.0005617319839075208, 0.020098356530070305, 0.03680875152349472, -0.007133648730814457, 0.01747974567115307, 0.056895822286605835, 0.0030582707840949297, 0.02168302983045578, 0.012199808843433857, -0.04538656771183014, 0.04025203734636307, 0.028789153322577477, 0.01450883224606514, -0.06328025460243225, 0.003552807727828622, -0.0034997258335351944, 0.026781735941767693, 0.026106730103492737, -0.07095842063426971, 0.018513860180974007, 0.001022837357595563, -0.04575213044881821, -0.06106781214475632, 0.03238426893949509, 0.03167404606938362, -0.016948051750659943, 0.04468856751918793, 0.0046380143612623215, 0.0075876242481172085, -0.012084010988473892, 0.018582111224532127, 0.022559234872460365, 0.03471223637461662, -0.00957530178129673, 0.0026283247862011194, 0.003149083349853754, -0.007117654196918011, 0.021618666127324104, -0.014918789267539978, -0.00036091156653128564, 0.06846475601196289, 0.06551989167928696, -0.005314256064593792, -0.01852390356361866, -0.04065539315342903, -0.02177577279508114, -0.04387669637799263, 0.0010946228867396712, -0.006181338801980019, 0.03173849359154701, -0.002808818593621254, 0.01438738964498043, 0.054845716804265976, -0.040250375866889954, 0.006876795552670956, -0.01026524044573307, -0.08426468819379807, 0.03118021786212921, -0.0012639692286029458, -0.04765988141298294, 0.03524654358625412, -0.006872577127069235, 0.013466842472553253, -0.022510776296257973, -0.000701666867826134, -0.020900100469589233, 0.006466899532824755, -0.016842694953083992, 0.02719131112098694, 0.009142033755779266, -0.01640157401561737, 0.01113187801092863, 0.006627252325415611, -0.024933934211730957, -0.042624372988939285, 0.012820649892091751, 0.028416847810149193, -0.0226699560880661, -0.012217463925480843, -0.018895380198955536, 0.04369334504008293, 0.05380883067846298, 0.025654369965195656, -0.007689209654927254, 0.02264172025024891, -0.04151136800646782, 0.02999575436115265, 0.024136098101735115, 0.04851232096552849, 0.017163898795843124, 0.0331946536898613, -0.027712086215615273, -0.03374220430850983, -0.030103402212262154, 0.008854332379996777, 0.013769884593784809, 0.00357069238089025, 0.0029047003481537104, 0.0818559005856514, 0.02592329867184162, -0.05772973969578743, 0.034238699823617935, 0.02564757503569126, 0.01640675961971283, 0.020884905010461807, 0.002215889049693942, -0.03326498717069626, -0.04857383295893669, -0.017184380441904068, 0.059317171573638916, 0.007951498031616211, -0.001534870476461947, 0.007817336358129978, 0.05435001850128174, 0.03281144052743912, -0.04174719750881195, -0.004805608186870813, 0.003989726770669222, 0.02807954140007496, 0.0001684689341345802, -0.06308646500110626, 0.020517248660326004, 0.05092659592628479, 0.04691724106669426, 0.024934107437729836, 0.047464724630117416, -0.077446348965168, -0.015683114528656006, 0.008700551465153694, 0.04346882551908493, -0.03754688426852226, 0.014259200543165207, -0.011283858679234982, -0.018054991960525513, 0.031006593257188797, -0.010844367556273937, -0.00717733521014452, -0.013082736171782017, -0.007857038639485836, -0.044303249567747116, -0.027283869683742523, -0.06912683695554733, -0.010722963139414787, -0.01400207169353962, 0.045960355550050735, -0.03700347989797592, -0.04115236923098564, -0.06108755245804787, 0.015445555560290813, 0.02702951990067959, 0.04955201596021652, -0.03284260630607605, -0.029283473268151283, 0.0167861208319664, 0.03864581510424614, -0.021511439234018326, -0.07454618066549301, -0.020744387060403824, -0.0004045630048494786, -0.0005001567187719047, 0.06121297553181648, -0.006348528899252415, -0.034565094858407974, 0.036053821444511414, -0.02663630247116089, -0.03518695384263992, -0.03059263527393341, -0.019712107256054878, 0.01193499006330967, 0.016086449846625328, 0.045911941677331924, 0.05400144308805466, -0.016687219962477684, -0.018089700490236282, 0.02945302240550518, -0.042526327073574066, 0.006964100990444422, -0.08727145940065384, -0.02100852131843567, -0.08834658563137054, -0.01894298382103443, -0.03287351503968239, 0.013504459522664547, -0.017553485929965973, -0.001238758210092783, -0.05013474076986313, -0.0018442374421283603, -0.004165734630078077, 0.026095014065504074, -0.02620517648756504, -0.02298705093562603, -0.024854103103280067, 0.011820566840469837, -0.0097460662946105, 0.0015462801093235612, 0.024003498256206512, -0.011583234183490276, 0.004852472338825464, -0.0017101254779845476, -0.020579703152179718, 0.014538039453327656, -0.02658531256020069, -0.04528213292360306, -0.006757678464055061, 0.01160435751080513, 0.03937787190079689, 0.0052061863243579865, 0.029485218226909637, -0.01172083243727684, -0.0352073535323143, -0.02161562070250511, 0.014219067059457302, 0.005454949103295803, 0.03642278164625168, -0.03280419111251831, 0.015327271074056625, -0.01949840597808361, -0.01866348274052143, -0.056921154260635376, -0.02443397417664528, 0.027637243270874023, 0.0236724354326725, -0.020735593512654305, -0.010158715769648552, 0.009949698112905025, -0.003301402321085334, -0.023365575820207596, 0.0009346582228317857, 0.03783179074525833, -0.03571679815649986, -0.047058865427970886, -0.02647569589316845, 0.017521927133202553, 0.07997079938650131, -0.03407379984855652, -0.020283401012420654, 0.013055546209216118, -0.0007131408201530576, -0.021436862647533417, -0.037015702575445175, 0.027754224836826324, -0.050855882465839386, -0.015239921398460865, -0.016068851575255394, 0.009981432929635048, 0.05802788585424423, -0.045623939484357834, 0.012700581923127174, 0.019630447030067444, 0.01613057777285576, 0.0006912388489581645, -0.02958182618021965, 0.009108858183026314, -0.014641483314335346, 0.014193997718393803, -0.02617194503545761, 0.004805854056030512, -0.017812121659517288, 0.008380351588129997, 0.050179846584796906, 0.0023110960610210896, -0.02220821939408779, 0.015705930069088936, 0.05479288846254349, 0.010966653004288673, 0.027851473540067673, 0.03383268415927887, -0.02373368851840496, 0.04170305281877518, 0.009793474338948727, 0.005755178164690733, 0.0161624513566494, 0.03028750978410244, -0.01741350069642067, -0.09397894889116287, -0.033719297498464584, 0.017332518473267555, 0.05231142044067383, -0.014032473787665367, 0.06298765540122986, 0.07207158207893372, -0.006046110298484564, -0.018373357132077217, -0.04512479901313782, -0.01526774000376463, -0.009946935810148716, 0.015841634944081306, 0.04640292003750801, 0.005441880784928799, 0.02418086864054203, 0.04869842156767845, -0.006771716754883528, 0.01158867496997118, 0.012636405415832996, 0.026760805398225784, 0.02704097330570221, 0.031486425548791885, -0.008461441844701767, -0.05196421593427658, 0.057572659105062485, -0.043550118803977966, 0.020650384947657585, -0.02255452796816826, -0.00004668387919082306, 0.040947455912828445, 0.03219829499721527, 0.04173272103071213, -0.03899972140789032, -0.007945818826556206, -0.04387842118740082, 0.03316178172826767, 0.023787174373865128, -0.008482287637889385, 0.013367298059165478, 0.019151650369167328, 0.02344668097794056, -0.03335552290081978, 0.026780277490615845, -0.02067759819328785, -0.08427607268095016, -0.033298127353191376, 0.007260035257786512, -0.028330927714705467, -0.0043729920871555805, -0.001275711110793054, -0.019681375473737717, 0.007719824090600014, -0.0596688948571682, 0.024081889539957047, -0.00626835273578763, 0.03486456349492073, -0.04837700352072716, 0.0605621337890625, 0.0085026565939188, 0.005401299335062504, -0.03724445775151253, -0.029606802389025688, 0.12255455553531647, 0.05535248667001724, 0.0446205772459507, -0.05009795352816582, -0.003978990949690342, -0.0029549270402640104, 0.0013871922856196761, -0.04593156650662422, 0.014266831800341606, -0.019688328728079796, 0.03310814127326012, 0.04320936277508736, 0.05143534019589424, -0.01349461730569601, -0.0360897034406662, 0.06504058092832565, -0.03728726506233215, -0.008932561613619328, 0.0023231327068060637, -0.005548372864723206, 0.030096348375082016, -0.005068793427199125, -0.03826479613780975, 0.03978449106216431, -0.002297444036230445, -0.012528416700661182, -0.048265255987644196, -0.03561472147703171, -0.01201665960252285, -0.0026176252868026495, -0.06652184575796127, 0.013633912429213524, 0.03265633434057236, 0.030716173350811005, -0.0304558202624321, -0.00021113322873134166, 0.04511842131614685, 0.013212812133133411, 0.017165422439575195, 0.020209161564707756, -0.011396223679184914, -0.003262182930484414, 0.0389653779566288, 0.012950198724865913, -0.04776801913976669, -0.030301533639431, -0.06057239696383476, 0.03704105690121651, -0.01410746481269598, -0.017784947529435158, -0.010633205994963646, 0.010406178422272205, -0.0016561704687774181, -0.02972230315208435, 0.006201771087944508, 0.040581975132226944, 0.03195491060614586, -0.023201584815979004, -0.021300705149769783, -0.013535925187170506, 0.02155781351029873, -0.00252098822966218, 0.029028568416833878, 0.038331907242536545, -0.04536334052681923, -0.01050227414816618, -0.017959151417016983, 0.04169389232993126, -0.020900432020425797, 0.031201161444187164, -0.02562434785068035, 0.023010587319731712, -0.020312495529651642, -0.02697904407978058, 0.040916211903095245, -0.0022835677955299616, 0.03262196108698845, -0.0017894419142976403, -0.010357118211686611, -0.015729105100035667, -0.0840468779206276, 0.02627185732126236, -0.01711091212928295, 0.00432560732588172, -0.03395857289433479, -0.022715168073773384, 0.028588060289621353, 0.036730196326971054, 0.0478680394589901, 0.007586520630866289, -0.0025768678169697523, 0.020497789606451988, 0.011100951582193375, -0.05192314088344574, -0.026674309745430946, -0.006121152080595493, -0.008290617726743221, -0.008109421469271183, 0.03786561265587807, 0.041272979229688644, 0.03789706155657768, 0.06097960099577904, -0.004358900710940361, 0.021487955003976822, 0.010417238809168339, -0.008557653985917568, 0.016691114753484726, -0.07337847352027893, -0.011188734322786331, 0.022747036069631577, 0.04550638049840927, -0.02364206127822399, -0.026055870577692986, -0.011133112944662571, -0.03777008131146431, 0.0012851679930463433, 0.030374642461538315, -0.05287319794297218, 0.038137905299663544, -0.006424719002097845, 0.026527991518378258, 0.008381899446249008, 0.005916272755712271, -0.0024699773639440536, -0.003972742706537247, 0.02649540826678276, -0.029887231066823006, 0.011605992913246155, 0.004162218887358904, 0.02278219722211361, 0.01583198271691799, 0.021184293553233147, -0.008119698613882065, -0.002775653265416622, 0.009041317738592625, 0.013088837265968323, -0.02254628576338291, 0.03207169100642204, -0.017528366297483444, 0.0005769023555330932, 0.03568895533680916, -0.02734026126563549, -0.0263822078704834, -0.01406798791140318, -0.002053916687145829, 0.04523203521966934, 0.03979719057679176, 0.010406002402305603, -0.05414225906133652, 0.059328965842723846, 0.0021868145558983088, 0.003644011216238141, -0.01034571137279272, 0.004102134611457586, 0.017048515379428864, -0.003795976983383298, 0.003911048639565706, 0.007843805477023125, 0.011186648160219193, 0.0030714902095496655, 0.06032240390777588, 0.019271215423941612, -0.0025785965844988823, 0.023641301319003105, -0.01346540916711092, 0.013602004386484623, 0.0082847336307168, -0.02137116715312004, 0.023064913228154182, 0.04013767093420029, -0.014286648482084274, 0.043102651834487915, 0.02201373316347599, 0.031593386083841324, -0.11458569765090942, -0.020906630903482437, 0.0035518535878509283, -0.004474492743611336, 0.031047826632857323, -0.06932754814624786, -0.016113366931676865, 0.052956558763980865, -0.07057055085897446, -0.021176528185606003, -0.022583849728107452, -0.01275002770125866, -0.0288808923214674, -0.0032441511284559965, -0.004352941643446684, 0.0022800068836659193, -0.01536848209798336, 0.04421447962522507, 0.014195632189512253, 0.019604921340942383, 0.043196357786655426, 0.01210047211498022, 0.021239986643195152, -0.003090434242039919, 0.009320895187556744, -0.05052037164568901, 0.028061559423804283, -0.023998748511075974, -0.033208880573511124, 0.04592588171362877, -0.005109825171530247, 0.011376549489796162, 0.02410288155078888, 0.006196881644427776, 0.0035246459301561117, 0.04014897346496582, 0.036483243107795715, 0.025072870776057243, 0.01696496084332466, -0.02270808257162571, 0.01845083385705948, 0.04354451969265938, 0.0024659207556396723, 0.011694630607962608, 0.021058866754174232, -0.05038658529520035, -0.014560830779373646, 0.01917739026248455, -0.024993471801280975, 0.010471113957464695, -0.005455859936773777, 0.0017863897373899817, 0.026590917259454727, -0.030502039939165115, 0.022834036499261856, -0.04569469764828682, -0.01494347583502531, 0.04852203279733658, 0.04651276022195816, -0.020832985639572144, 0.028488604351878166, -0.04565395042300224, -0.018656184896826744, 0.004818605724722147, -0.0005633787950500846, 0.01601519249379635, -0.05917444825172424, -0.01596122235059738, 0.010885310359299183, -0.019825724884867668, -0.016562366858124733, -0.02108784392476082, -0.03275645151734352, 0.045870982110500336, -0.02465393953025341, 0.020283550024032593, 0.001527005573734641, -0.033921241760253906, 0.018173689022660255, -0.08730113506317139, 0.08152515441179276, -0.00404118187725544, -0.012317541986703873, -0.019521746784448624, 0.0007317658746615052, -0.02069064788520336, -0.004603578709065914, 0.025801142677664757, 0.0325477197766304, 0.014846709556877613, 0.014943192712962627, 0.008908440358936787, 0.002996726194396615, -0.023097191005945206, 0.0629281997680664, -0.006099143531173468, -0.025542953982949257, -0.001562270219437778, -0.04093194752931595, 0.007444036193192005, -0.0008750376873649657, 0.016315968707203865, -0.011593019589781761, 0.010186753235757351, 0.004721757490187883, -0.008764657191932201, 0.060916777700185776, 0.01773892156779766, -0.016318313777446747, 0.061101678758859634, 0.0007391746621578932, 0.0006683425744995475, 0.02418624982237816, -0.026688778772950172, -0.038630399852991104, -0.0011434793705120683, -0.01831687055528164, -0.014182524755597115, -0.02141311764717102, 0.004571855999529362, -0.027235310524702072, -0.037996724247932434, 0.009691827930510044, 0.043670427054166794, -0.041831038892269135, -0.011216075159609318, 0.029880136251449585, 0.007610353175550699, 0.033881645649671555, -0.023932060226798058, -0.024639347568154335, 0.02352309040725231, -0.011402662843465805, -0.022569317370653152, -0.017840340733528137, 0.04427935183048248, 0.008498871698975563, -0.008435788564383984, 0.023506782948970795, -0.013172169215977192, 0.01911580003798008, -0.05045337229967117, 0.03610606864094734, -0.07441389560699463, -0.006068869959563017, -0.016713745892047882, 0.012707643210887909, -0.0017512687481939793, 0.003151752520352602, 0.023521192371845245, 0.08397600054740906, -0.008017058484256268, 0.006378738209605217, -0.05018862709403038, 0.007932308129966259, -0.018401633948087692, -0.004884831141680479, -0.0010180470999330282, 0.017308920621871948, 0.003556591924279928, 0.03767717257142067, -0.019125258550047874, -0.0053886729292571545, 0.041864968836307526, -0.006787548307329416, 0.006675632670521736, 0.006779998540878296, -0.03710884228348732, -0.02284039556980133, -0.02196652814745903, -0.03423465043306351, -0.020200779661536217, 0.006176104303449392, 0.01673475280404091, 0.00919518806040287, -0.04840480163693428, 0.0030536698177456856, -0.03238213434815407, 0.05483200028538704, -0.08451194316148758, -0.018477438017725945, -0.04203569516539574, -0.01568719558417797, -0.036440085619688034, -0.03734152764081955 ]
<p>I am stuck in understanding how the output of convolution operation is obtained. Can somebody please show the steps? The question is an image is processed by applying 3*3 mean filter . What is the impulse response? </p> <p>The formula is $g(m,n) = \sum_{\alpha = 0}^{M-1} \sum_{\beta=0}^{N-1} f(\alpha,\beta)h(m-\alpha,n-\beta)$</p> <p>The image function $f$ =</p> <pre><code> 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 h = 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 </code></pre> <p>The result of the operation (obtained in Matlab) is g(m,n) = </p> <pre><code>0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 2 3 2 1 0 0 2 4 6 4 2 0 0 3 6 9 6 3 0 0 2 4 6 4 2 0 0 1 2 3 2 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 </code></pre> <p>I cannot understand the steps how to do it in paper, can somebody please show the few steps how to go about it ?</p> <p>Based on the reply and the formula, I have worked out one example, but the answers don't match with the formula and the other technique. For convolution at pixel f(0,0) the answer = 0. But I am getting 0 using the formula and 1 using the drag method. The cell to which this result will be mapped is g(0,0) and I have put the answer there. </p> <p>For convolution of pixel element at f(1,1) = 1 also, when I evaluated I am getting answer 2 instead of 4. The result should go to g(2,2). But how do I get values for g(5,0) since the original image f has no fifth row!! How to calculate values for fifth and sixth rows? Please let me know what is wrong in my understanding. Is my coordinate system incorrect? Shall really appreciate. <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/FKado.jpg" alt="enter image description here"> </p>
74,306
[ -0.01952964998781681, -0.010981518775224686, 0.015979290008544922, 0.0004058798949699849, 0.06106550991535187, -0.02548900619149208, -0.0645289421081543, -0.02968299575150013, 0.019593238830566406, -0.031990308314561844, 0.02242163196206093, 0.0182745773345232, 0.03989250212907791, 0.06813602149486542, -0.00280191283673048, -0.00315295672044158, -0.03949744999408722, 0.021314630284905434, -0.036835815757513046, -0.02122357115149498, 0.0022422426845878363, 0.058017246425151825, -0.020125776529312134, -0.024478984996676445, -0.019813518971204758, 0.029747353866696358, 0.02836102619767189, 0.005697411019355059, 0.02730054035782814, 0.04048793017864227, -0.04647940397262573, -0.02658924087882042, -0.012604909017682076, 0.009609954431653023, -0.029263023287057877, 0.017957570031285286, -0.03591414541006088, -0.03537171706557274, 0.013190878555178642, 0.005295015871524811, 0.009572950191795826, -0.029892096295952797, -0.004953447263687849, -0.013208836317062378, -0.027684079483151436, -0.006967402994632721, 0.013579795137047768, -0.005200780462473631, -0.0035612937062978745, -0.05159321427345276, 0.09049990028142929, 0.01795603148639202, 0.00487501872703433, -0.011985410936176777, -0.013340186327695847, 0.008809654973447323, 0.01419813185930252, 0.07493165880441666, 0.01580774039030075, -0.04289562255144119, 0.024551518261432648, -0.02175024338066578, -0.0032398817129433155, -0.00215161289088428, 0.0025829123333096504, -0.004605735652148724, -0.00004815460124518722, -0.005051486659795046, 0.05478392541408539, -0.014046728610992432, 0.014296876266598701, -0.0017873746110126376, 0.03554822504520416, -0.04225599020719528, 0.007812423165887594, -0.01988477073609829, 0.01019833143800497, -0.0012666808906942606, 0.0541195347905159, 0.002875308971852064, -0.013276533223688602, 0.04674562066793442, 0.0012180643389001489, 0.037157222628593445, 0.0377185083925724, -0.013680334202945232, 0.06775330007076263, -0.014892350882291794, 0.05600268021225929, -0.013052204623818398, -0.029465429484844208, 0.012106692418456078, 0.03344631567597389, 0.011202262714505196, -0.04567010700702667, 0.06709593534469604, 0.016394738107919693, 0.013951498083770275, 0.004423401318490505, -0.01749998889863491, -0.01548345759510994, -0.055762287229299545, -0.012359165586531162, 0.05991554260253906, -0.020374810323119164, 0.044785819947719574, -0.009311231784522533, 0.013245578855276108, -0.0026096601504832506, -0.022341156378388405, -0.019714821130037308, 0.02251877263188362, 0.029321769252419472, -0.0031523355282843113, 0.010884947143495083, -0.02334677428007126, 0.009242950938642025, 0.03416087105870247, 0.03694751113653183, 0.05302378535270691, 0.01567738503217697, -0.03564587980508804, -0.01475481316447258, -0.02384905517101288, -0.06757977604866028, 0.02428034134209156, 0.04153067246079445, -0.010517873801290989, -0.030932357534766197, 0.030061842873692513, 0.039590440690517426, -0.04231096804141998, 0.04506925866007805, 0.021938951686024666, 0.004985816311091185, -0.00924849882721901, -0.078789122402668, -0.042358171194791794, 0.054400455206632614, -0.045755524188280106, 0.0037882497999817133, -0.03289373591542244, 0.01404852420091629, 0.02831728383898735, 0.0571197085082531, -0.013873463496565819, 0.02604113332927227, 0.03760446608066559, 0.04224320873618126, -0.0037611189763993025, 0.005910583306103945, -0.03614704683423042, -0.03968249633908272, -0.019855394959449768, -0.025610122829675674, -0.02389257214963436, 0.029961170628666878, 0.02979421429336071, -0.0002283952198922634, -0.03065832331776619, 0.07787267863750458, 0.027830589562654495, -0.014258120208978653, 0.012085996568202972, -0.022899946197867393, -0.028973359614610672, 0.015512573532760143, -0.0025385492481291294, 0.04339972138404846, 0.019379092380404472, -0.032541900873184204, 0.015119832940399647, -0.045375023037195206, 0.02433324046432972, -0.0026192571967840195, -0.01593191735446453, -0.024613523855805397, -0.050601061433553696, 0.005389328580349684, -0.00810147263109684, -0.0013092901790514588, -0.05031812936067581, 0.001853239955380559, 0.01926569640636444, 0.03097577765583992, -0.002617715857923031, 0.009507548995316029, -0.026872923597693443, 0.010035714134573936, -0.010465750470757484, -0.03423628583550453, -0.08491595834493637, -0.01368241012096405, 0.005294195841997862, 0.007987194694578648, -0.013602019287645817, -0.0402781181037426, -0.00889409240335226, 0.05864609405398369, -0.006407848093658686, -0.003281895536929369, -0.0175322275608778, 0.003709423588588834, -0.032764073461294174, -0.007198103237897158, 0.07132458686828613, 0.04007134959101677, 0.02053038217127323, 0.0274883434176445, -0.043592315167188644, 0.048564568161964417, 0.019432293251156807, 0.018315164372324944, 0.021353110671043396, -0.011324476450681686, -0.021190691739320755, 0.02586064487695694, -0.007920901291072369, 0.0052600642666220665, 0.006131269503384829, -0.045501645654439926, 0.04153378680348396, 0.08934182673692703, 0.010445747524499893, 0.04601676017045975, -0.004095738288015127, -0.0036588748916983604, 0.008066734299063683, 0.00007762158929836005, -0.03708595782518387, -0.06234306842088699, -0.05319218337535858, 0.03070121631026268, 0.007374229375272989, -0.022201884537935257, -0.012615572661161423, 0.04449515417218208, 0.012062030844390392, 0.05781036242842674, 0.008562474511563778, 0.0007200167165137827, 0.009429248049855232, -0.021234717220067978, 0.011983110569417477, 0.01574658788740635, -0.005094890017062426, -0.03093905560672283, 0.013721251860260963, 0.06165197119116783, -0.010134665295481682, -0.00407358817756176, 0.04897988215088844, -0.02977045625448227, -0.00482269749045372, -0.05100402981042862, 0.019023675471544266, 0.0109193604439497, -0.0012151432456448674, -0.041793353855609894, 0.03539489954710007, -0.017485564574599266, 0.0023587739560753107, -0.005252600181847811, -0.011448812671005726, -0.008433827199041843, 0.02965310774743557, -0.019773270934820175, -0.047884173691272736, 0.02319812774658203, 0.007798245642334223, 0.061737023293972015, -0.008519506081938744, 0.0022565508261322975, -0.04460052773356438, 0.01675388403236866, 0.035025570541620255, 0.0010389469098299742, 0.010112456977367401, -0.053916364908218384, -0.0017040860839188099, -0.015806125476956367, -0.00045444423449225724, 0.04625105857849121, 0.04484230652451515, -0.07077561318874359, 0.0013141966192051768, -0.06071334332227707, -0.01212458498775959, 0.05216200649738312, 0.00865161418914795, -0.015296384692192078, 0.0010562456445768476, -0.0017825029790401459, -0.06475179642438889, -0.040654320269823074, -0.03421110659837723, 0.006385158747434616, -0.031321726739406586, -0.013293283060193062, 0.05014245584607124, 0.03535272181034088, -0.0519486665725708, 0.053411662578582764, -0.03317359834909439, -0.025845322757959366, -0.03391491249203682, 0.012305236421525478, 0.00978097040206194, -0.03228374570608139, 0.04563456401228905, -0.025355223566293716, -0.02296123281121254, 0.0030285806860774755, -0.04881827533245087, -0.002359736943617463, 0.011023950763046741, -0.012154735624790192, 0.03547459468245506, 0.020247584208846092, -0.008930891752243042, 0.0554509237408638, 0.06397157907485962, -0.017731966450810432, -0.030233794823288918, 0.007059608586132526, -0.011010064743459225, -0.04033776372671127, 0.024844536557793617, 0.042033642530441284, 0.029588276520371437, 0.008460992015898228, -0.03009944222867489, 0.03748360276222229, 0.08157854527235031, -0.009655635803937912, -0.014379408210515976, 0.015495466068387032, 0.011772909201681614, -0.01751832291483879, 0.06160411238670349, 0.015343100763857365, -0.006954653654247522, 0.03592841699719429, 0.013837100937962532, -0.018069416284561157, 0.008795714937150478, -0.03622783347964287, -0.004540205001831055, -0.008510362356901169, -0.001059584436006844, -0.05568115413188934, 0.0607183575630188, 0.025703035295009613, 0.0035736809950321913, 0.00772158382460475, 0.0049125393852591515, 0.03763740137219429, -0.029477983713150024, 0.013315298594534397, 0.06020050123333931, 0.006526248529553413, -0.022401170805096626, -0.022255130112171173, -0.01803903840482235, 0.002631788607686758, 0.032007232308387756, -0.047300785779953, -0.030411941930651665, -0.0033284155651926994, 0.05843336507678032, -0.002915570279583335, 0.015694255009293556, -0.005768963135778904, -0.031015358865261078, -0.047225650399923325, -0.018122440204024315, -0.02878294326364994, 0.053681325167417526, -0.00900406762957573, 0.08553481101989746, 0.030294038355350494, 0.03413376212120056, 0.027810661122202873, 0.010237844660878181, -0.0745534896850586, -0.02194712683558464, 0.055537816137075424, -0.007766854949295521, -0.011949536390602589, -0.023897023871541023, 0.03638136014342308, 0.007011450361460447, -0.01755107007920742, 0.006770968437194824, -0.020068420097231865, -0.07468294352293015, 0.01132822036743164, 0.0033484231680631638, 0.025914864614605904, -0.024362875148653984, 0.019952597096562386, 0.044088900089263916, -0.016018185764551163, 0.010840692557394505, 0.02483305335044861, -0.01730962283909321, -0.00015782636182848364, -0.005387975834310055, -0.01079881563782692, 0.0164310485124588, 0.023967275395989418, 0.01815456710755825, 0.023003654554486275, -0.04337458312511444, 0.010538945905864239, 0.011624212376773357, 0.05700879171490669, 0.05385764688253403, -0.012232265435159206, -0.004618843086063862, -0.02394232712686062, 0.02931252494454384, -0.0003716617648024112, 0.008628292009234428, -0.004654279910027981, 0.006494041532278061, 0.04979902133345604, 0.021741073578596115, 0.0016277997056022286, 0.05013956502079964, 0.04155203700065613, 0.006444612517952919, -0.015499213710427284, -0.09754161536693573, -0.010886970907449722, -0.038691725581884384, -0.00331317400559783, 0.056284304708242416, 0.017978908494114876, -0.0013939340133219957, 0.004105639178305864, 0.03033209778368473, 0.004977471195161343, 0.0014877880457788706, 0.016845976933836937, 0.03967629373073578, 0.0017205626936629415, 0.025848081335425377, -0.03671177849173546, -0.026681246235966682, 0.05431624501943588, 0.03215961158275604, 0.020287958905100822, -0.03520059213042259, -0.08621576428413391, -0.02162942849099636, 0.04322222247719765, 0.03612110763788223, -0.005364193115383387, 0.023975329473614693, -0.07621818035840988, -0.01561345811933279, 0.0052082170732319355, -0.033427994698286057, 0.030567601323127747, -0.0378083735704422, 0.005951190833002329, 0.00037653150502592325, -0.008546549826860428, -0.045708831399679184, 0.031209036707878113, -0.006464663427323103, 0.024454737082123756, -0.06616252660751343, -0.031389545649290085, -0.023687312379479408, -0.009672019630670547, 0.005936941597610712, 0.051721446216106415, -0.0036974968388676643, 0.01606016978621483, 0.01531424093991518, 0.004742807243019342, -0.07262229174375534, -0.04919349402189255, 0.034525737166404724, -0.012336568906903267, 0.013919061049818993, 0.06365373730659485, -0.03478886932134628, -0.010278753004968166, 0.03043372929096222, 0.017096972092986107, 0.020662713795900345, 0.014284376986324787, -0.05545656755566597, 0.06172395125031471, 0.056559547781944275, -0.025827152654528618, 0.06995199620723724, 0.011644185520708561, -0.024129673838615417, 0.013516906648874283, -0.020482484251260757, -0.013655675575137138, -0.011513357982039452, 0.001379014691337943, -0.03605688735842705, 0.006649143528193235, -0.014298726804554462, 0.02161952294409275, 0.0028542368672788143, 0.04216950759291649, 0.02702336199581623, -0.005822501145303249, 0.023183252662420273, 0.016595229506492615, -0.04429798573255539, 0.04311878979206085, -0.00395833607763052, 0.00953457597643137, 0.04381546750664711, -0.03890633210539818, 0.03481069579720497, -0.0104770977050066, 0.030592793598771095, 0.010058658197522163, -0.025356445461511612, -0.023282375186681747, -0.02569562755525112, 0.023608839139342308, 0.024136915802955627, -0.03721507266163826, 0.04712533578276634, -0.03693127632141113, 0.02224663458764553, 0.045543260872364044, -0.033535975962877274, -0.02169094793498516, -0.0011362993391230702, -0.030481582507491112, 0.005863032769411802, -0.029934203252196312, 0.03145471587777138, 0.053189173340797424, 0.01714765466749668, -0.05264868214726448, -0.03618750348687172, 0.015119589865207672, -0.012446824461221695, -0.01098700612783432, -0.024991663172841072, -0.04645676165819168, 0.0031732646748423576, -0.04563579335808754, 0.011692858301103115, 0.019450785592198372, 0.004143803846091032, 0.0009748605079948902, -0.0010993180330842733, 0.0071426089853048325, 0.09470854699611664, 0.0038952052127569914, -0.0036705865059047937, 0.0400657020509243, -0.022175677120685577, -0.03056478314101696, 0.008852179162204266, -0.004221613984555006, -0.040214136242866516, 0.0030204583890736103, -0.012562448158860207, -0.003158769803121686, 0.027516797184944153, 0.006570213474333286, -0.008589658886194229, -0.013696803711354733, 0.045206647366285324, 0.01330624707043171, -0.0432070717215538, -0.0155310845002532, -0.020289165899157524, -0.026965444907546043, 0.00047462008660659194, -0.015214283019304276, -0.04874558001756668, -0.01897735521197319, 0.05149584263563156, -0.009040797129273415, 0.005968878511339426, -0.0019385097548365593, 0.08426220715045929, -0.001214895281009376, 0.007680018898099661, 0.031036514788866043, -0.009680352173745632, 0.05091399699449539, 0.010880397632718086, 0.018477769568562508, 0.01849655620753765, 0.019851645454764366, -0.0455707348883152, 0.012759399600327015, -0.09090838581323624, 0.000276382255833596, 0.0745660588145256, -0.025985557585954666, 0.00931825116276741, -0.010884495452046394, -0.020475124940276146, -0.015276472084224224, -0.0036341040395200253, 0.006264968775212765, 0.025501495227217674, 0.012977302074432373, 0.06446906924247742, -0.02105383761227131, -0.01821312867105007, 0.011336776427924633, -0.011205395683646202, 0.02914544939994812, 0.011245336383581161, 0.00044415294541977346, 0.014409814029932022, 0.00312689202837646, -0.039578281342983246, -0.025392772629857063, 0.03768081218004227, -0.03116336092352867, 0.024793585762381554, -0.010715746320784092, -0.059388887137174606, 0.02568216808140278, 0.04477792978286743, -0.016771648079156876, -0.09439294785261154, 0.00958005990833044, -0.02810845896601677, -0.006557113025337458, 0.020901402458548546, -0.027252251282334328, -0.004669986665248871, 0.004633295349776745, 0.023019637912511826, -0.02574947290122509, 0.03388259932398796, -0.026484357193112373, -0.02746211551129818, 0.027289090678095818, -0.07339391857385635, -0.035652149468660355, 0.03356533870100975, 0.003022334072738886, -0.023085834458470345, 0.005809131544083357, -0.03759688511490822, 0.031277745962142944, 0.04133439436554909, 0.02460774965584278, 0.0018856406677514315, 0.05499234423041344, -0.01566881686449051, 0.036481939256191254, -0.004790437873452902, -0.016476016491651535, 0.12798453867435455, 0.073654405772686, 0.00458650104701519, -0.04286344349384308, -0.013465878553688526, -0.0004416489682625979, -0.015860753133893013, -0.04019981250166893, 0.014656459912657738, -0.0055566406808793545, -0.010482033714652061, 0.035079099237918854, 0.06037905439734459, 0.000056070686696330085, -0.022034013643860817, -0.006957955192774534, -0.047243691980838776, -0.043947529047727585, 0.012948757037520409, 0.009458345361053944, 0.03440297767519951, 0.016161717474460602, -0.06721222400665283, 0.00836473610252142, 0.04939313232898712, -0.007372666150331497, -0.042369794100522995, 0.019545303657650948, 0.03573305532336235, -0.0006881688605062664, -0.02142675220966339, 0.031129537150263786, 0.010965237393975258, -0.028262754902243614, 0.003723428351804614, 0.019125496968626976, -0.013776090927422047, -0.040098998695611954, 0.02408773824572563, 0.045911334455013275, -0.008032028563320637, -0.006072381045669317, 0.01221255399286747, -0.029222503304481506, -0.023138726130127907, -0.026746924966573715, -0.03865865617990494, 0.032108061015605927, -0.013153455220162868, -0.04874977469444275, 0.011829141527414322, 0.041024643927812576, -0.049191202968358994, -0.08077366650104523, 0.0015077012358233333, 0.03746791556477547, 0.02484762854874134, 0.007755279541015625, -0.01832626946270466, 0.015632741153240204, 0.03379054367542267, 0.0013235022779554129, 0.018420660868287086, 0.019704533740878105, -0.017096417024731636, -0.012810833752155304, -0.028788136318325996, 0.09066837280988693, -0.020788289606571198, -0.0056795887649059296, -0.00005888254236197099, -0.0033383599948138, -0.008725249208509922, -0.019025355577468872, 0.005510934162884951, 0.02298986352980137, 0.019068190827965736, 0.004544914234429598, -0.027145307511091232, 0.0078869154676795, -0.044097449630498886, 0.014351894147694111, 0.001788757974281907, 0.016341131180524826, -0.02328566089272499, -0.028993677347898483, 0.025619518011808395, 0.05040596053004265, -0.0037346710450947285, -0.007684274110943079, 0.010058136656880379, 0.05328870192170143, 0.05793827772140503, -0.03020453453063965, -0.019118648022413254, 0.0371900349855423, -0.024833615869283676, 0.01895241066813469, -0.030042843893170357, 0.03834632784128189, 0.019200066104531288, 0.014044967480003834, -0.012035209685564041, 0.04702981561422348, 0.005891029257327318, -0.03139186277985573, -0.04239385202527046, -0.03919319435954094, 0.0411335714161396, -0.006708518601953983, 0.03589429706335068, -0.02594676800072193, 0.039042286574840546, -0.0005246596992947161, -0.013604437932372093, 0.018813317641615868, -0.0035008094273507595, -0.007993984036147594, -0.012745457701385021, -0.007429224904626608, 0.0604221485555172, -0.016916364431381226, -0.0023771370761096478, 0.002485406817868352, 0.030769893899559975, -0.0027346874121576548, -0.0185370035469532, -0.05559643730521202, -0.000029752154659945518, -0.035723935812711716, 0.011752577498555183, 0.04404418542981148, 0.01830190047621727, -0.0009109392412938178, 0.030509905889630318, 0.02245565876364708, -0.034264083951711655, 0.03884834423661232, 0.035287681967020035, -0.0012130271643400192, 0.04057557135820389, -0.014400646090507507, -0.024085603654384613, 0.010497943498194218, 0.014076344668865204, 0.03729792311787605, 0.03619490563869476, -0.0016770826186984777, -0.028693316504359245, 0.07285748422145844, -0.015772465616464615, -0.04548925533890724, -0.0186096653342247, -0.027734823524951935, 0.005326680839061737, 0.004063792061060667, 0.00045271607814356685, -0.02094539813697338, 0.04153062030673027, -0.0033277985639870167, -0.007440268527716398, -0.010299322195351124, -0.013692935928702354, -0.007539146579802036, -0.04384083300828934, 0.009175761602818966, -0.002868504961952567, -0.023190032690763474, -0.02186083421111107, 0.06274458765983582, 0.00106302450876683, 0.0006447141640819609, -0.0313318595290184, -0.007727263029664755, -0.07361828535795212, -0.020031651481986046, 0.03033476322889328, -0.007538403384387493, 0.07186851650476456, -0.061790671199560165, 0.038511037826538086, 0.02101246640086174, -0.03477298840880394, -0.001099973451346159, -0.0008299429318867624, -0.04018144682049751, -0.021056633442640305, 0.03793446347117424, 0.000442480988567695, 0.007496022619307041, 0.005228956695646048, 0.009738112799823284, 0.02347680740058422, 0.01482508983463049, -0.018529217690229416, -0.008859574794769287, -0.018254689872264862, 0.035435907542705536, 0.03425797447562218, -0.009229816496372223, 0.027811992913484573, 0.014596250839531422, -0.007136608008295298, 0.002077274490147829, -0.022623589262366295, 0.0011590311769396067, -0.03543153405189514, 0.02661864273250103, -0.002084361854940653, 0.05438392981886864, -0.005482221953570843, 0.0012691804440692067, 0.0010968203423544765, 0.013250304386019707, 0.020790869370102882, 0.0007889519911259413, -0.0037813144735991955, 0.03893833979964256, 0.018905991688370705, 0.028212998062372208, -0.04405843839049339, -0.031059520319104195, -0.012067008763551712, -0.0725480243563652, 0.01694655604660511, -0.03841760754585266, -0.0037992398720234632, -0.04156064614653587, -0.010553834959864616, -0.026148708537220955, 0.00007007393287494779, 0.006972187664359808, -0.0012779257958754897, -0.016476409509778023, 0.004186311736702919, 0.008390487171709538, -0.040465325117111206, -0.007038540672510862, -0.012894135899841785, -0.010838529095053673, -0.026867369189858437, -0.028088275343179703, 0.03116869181394577, 0.01570497453212738, 0.017433881759643555, -0.03998500108718872, -0.010952926240861416, 0.0008944391156546772, 0.00914444774389267, 0.007233439479023218, -0.00143955007661134, -0.029934432357549667, -0.0390210784971714, -0.06055189296603203, 0.0337509885430336, 0.0006682305247522891, -0.05603687837719917, 0.0042653800919651985, -0.0025415117852389812, -0.04982946068048477, 0.051352567970752716, 0.04439164325594902, -0.0011830171570181847, -0.00737591041252017, 0.00860864482820034, 0.0243359487503767, 0.014301767572760582, -0.07291605323553085, 0.02764805778861046, 0.00847222562879324, 0.0028849642258137465, -0.03338266536593437, 0.01520058885216713, 0.00040157456533052027, 0.035208482295274734, -0.004728203173726797, 0.019306043162941933, 0.0037002291064709425, -0.01849190704524517, -0.03334619477391243, -0.013060609810054302, 0.033907365053892136, -0.03330904617905617, 0.050778403878211975, -0.03714380040764809, -0.003699192311614752, 0.01136320736259222, 0.0028179262299090624, -0.07162538170814514, -0.017839398235082626, -0.016530007123947144, -0.0259078498929739, -0.02059638313949108, 0.004676055628806353, 0.05586986243724823, -0.07875103503465652, -0.0030639718752354383, 0.004961066413670778, -0.029163610190153122, -0.01767033338546753, 0.05532458797097206, -0.013882816769182682, 0.02379721589386463, 0.014782503247261047, 0.03132782131433487, -0.006858775857836008, -0.048656586557626724, 0.002133486792445183, 0.022030390799045563, -0.030576052144169807, -0.03151226043701172, 0.0452926829457283, 0.025949474424123764, 0.007065286859869957, -0.0047860099002718925, 0.023451900109648705, 0.030589399859309196, 0.008834108710289001, -0.008148208260536194, 0.015894237905740738, -0.03416692465543747, -0.009979428723454475, -0.006596205290406942, 0.01544748991727829, 0.06597244739532471, -0.020628001540899277, -0.008946300484240055, -0.006524806842207909, -0.017344653606414795, -0.07471340149641037, 0.028409037739038467, -0.013006715103983879, 0.03917067125439644, -0.0058388616889715195, 0.01158070657402277, -0.030865589156746864, 0.0033319781068712473, 0.014756156131625175, -0.03995665907859802, 0.008126589469611645, -0.002595613244920969, -0.006948917638510466, 0.03482401743531227, -0.014690099284052849, -0.060506485402584076, -0.019595138728618622, 0.03377482295036316, 0.01006745733320713, -0.03549502417445183, -0.009806943126022816, -0.007219345308840275, -0.04181128740310669, 0.03891856595873833, -0.03573247045278549, -0.03611469268798828, -0.011997192166745663, -0.008535423316061497, 0.030033761635422707, 0.010583758354187012 ]
<p>Imagine I have a time series for an animal population and a time series for a climatic variable during the same time period and at the same location. Unfortunately the data are observational (i.e., no experimental manipulation). Now imagine there is a decreasing linear trend in both variables (and no seasonality).</p> <p>I know before hand that these variables will be correlated because they share a time trend (e.g.,<a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/a/8037/38125">http://stats.stackexchange.com/a/8037/38125</a>). But is there anything more I can infer from this data? </p> <p>I am looking for a rather low-level conceptual explanation as to whether this is possible and why.</p> <p>I have 2 thoughts on how this might be accomplished, but haven't figured on my own if either would be valid.... 1) Regress population against both time and the climate variable, or 2) "Detrend" both 'population' and 'climate variable' and regress their residuals against each other</p> <p>I can provide more detail if necessary but wanted to keep this original post brief. Thanks for your help! </p>
37,141
[ -0.0387568399310112, -0.013931658118963242, -0.017625931650400162, 0.05701658874750137, -0.013631193898618221, 0.01199548039585352, -0.014467018656432629, 0.004923531785607338, 0.015878023579716682, -0.039089497178792953, 0.021030288189649582, 0.05416535586118698, 0.044332489371299744, 0.009552862495183945, 0.03228244557976723, -0.0016594594344496727, -0.04736729711294174, 0.008739006705582142, 0.01096232607960701, -0.019123109057545662, 0.009993331506848335, 0.028536390513181686, 0.03659072145819664, -0.012035930529236794, -0.03864036127924919, 0.0653759017586708, 0.04353323578834534, -0.007246915251016617, 0.0021259484346956015, 0.052704788744449615, -0.03417490795254707, -0.03659076616168022, 0.015318645164370537, 0.05449303984642029, 0.020357757806777954, 0.007377852685749531, -0.04146408289670944, -0.031965333968400955, 0.03510456159710884, 0.07638424634933472, -0.0409613735973835, -0.04946427047252655, -0.021807638928294182, 0.02332041971385479, -0.007112185936421156, 0.0021588520612567663, -0.005591670051217079, -0.006414040923118591, 0.04726220294833183, -0.03685328736901283, 0.06755832582712173, 0.0013256901875138283, 0.034021686762571335, 0.02889036200940609, -0.00592732522636652, -0.0002948695910163224, 0.0855342447757721, 0.046918194741010666, 0.0013839604798704386, -0.052978694438934326, -0.03006593883037567, -0.017017722129821777, -0.00042355977348051965, 0.02450750209391117, -0.031774409115314484, 0.005063625518232584, -0.008701115846633911, -0.01313847303390503, 0.06033102050423622, -0.015402944758534431, 0.03441622108221054, -0.019827110692858696, 0.038808614015579224, 0.009491547010838985, 0.01347438432276249, -0.010595838539302349, 0.0063874730840325356, 0.03605269640684128, 0.03166525065898895, 0.02789412997663021, -0.012319170869886875, 0.03262828290462494, 0.026928959414362907, 0.05396340414881706, 0.04459892958402634, -0.008131113834679127, 0.0473502017557621, -0.056469447910785675, -0.0020651533268392086, 0.03380294516682625, 0.011207555420696735, 0.009579993784427643, 0.07314956933259964, -0.007482461165636778, -0.04570634290575981, 0.012950699776411057, -0.004190788604319096, 0.0475844144821167, 0.026895796880126, 0.01557221170514822, -0.01960405893623829, -0.013644238002598286, 0.015446437522768974, 0.03701411187648773, -0.053850702941417694, -0.00837560836225748, -0.041008852422237396, 0.017302164807915688, -0.021501963958144188, -0.04726386442780495, -0.034730181097984314, -0.0013592519098892808, 0.0010127496207132936, 0.0021990288514643908, 0.03703463077545166, -0.019174907356500626, -0.015405423007905483, 0.0024505823384970427, 0.06882934272289276, 0.05572698637843132, 0.014664563350379467, -0.016142401844263077, 0.01415348332375288, -0.003598706563934684, -0.04860697686672211, 0.0011014733463525772, 0.019398361444473267, -0.021303905174136162, -0.024387910962104797, 0.05747493356466293, -0.007008895743638277, -0.04157961905002594, 0.024215813726186752, -0.03886735439300537, 0.041840534657239914, -0.0029110810719430447, -0.08373335748910904, -0.03358913213014603, 0.061269361525774, -0.012325459159910679, 0.006798229180276394, -0.05391724780201912, 0.01722332462668419, -0.0024778181686997414, 0.06614315509796143, 0.004504780285060406, -0.005975918844342232, 0.004675216041505337, 0.0008793422603048384, 0.03134047985076904, 0.0010296432301402092, -0.025658290833234787, 0.016237083822488785, -0.013871108181774616, -0.03585712984204292, -0.09361911565065384, 0.031080882996320724, 0.030745450407266617, -0.0038902692031115294, 0.02853597141802311, 0.06182714179158211, 0.013500620611011982, 0.0011099998373538256, 0.004681396298110485, 0.05906413123011589, -0.03880498185753822, 0.0829562321305275, -0.03929539769887924, -0.012744380161166191, 0.008692387491464615, 0.006519137881696224, 0.023959722369909286, 0.02883279137313366, 0.07243198156356812, 0.048047568649053574, -0.0388435460627079, -0.008435163646936417, -0.00904854666441679, -0.04077675938606262, 0.023935606703162193, -0.054401692003011703, -0.0359656997025013, -0.01947743631899357, -0.04534861072897911, 0.05278940126299858, 0.04584294557571411, -0.0094815818592906, -0.03827923536300659, 0.04033543914556503, -0.07362008839845657, -0.0336611233651638, -0.09565117955207825, -0.028071267530322075, -0.004695285111665726, 0.004254717845469713, 0.03944028913974762, 0.010205359198153019, 0.027733607217669487, -0.002776661654934287, -0.044544726610183716, -0.019970552995800972, 0.0017157201655209064, 0.041111089289188385, -0.039240188896656036, 0.0187218114733696, 0.03820937126874924, 0.054364752024412155, -0.001943341107107699, 0.007876848801970482, -0.047585293650627136, -0.053926002234220505, -0.006256599444895983, -0.034911513328552246, 0.020684950053691864, -0.025920171290636063, -0.008417815901339054, 0.019246477633714676, 0.002073646755889058, -0.05033637210726738, 0.03213829547166824, -0.0321170873939991, 0.056395430117845535, 0.055165812373161316, -0.0092404680326581, 0.007786627393215895, 0.04042203351855278, 0.02875317633152008, 0.018791336566209793, -0.031583622097969055, -0.008970296010375023, -0.05683251470327377, 0.015067092142999172, 0.029116621240973473, 0.037711042910814285, -0.03751377388834953, 0.0571858286857605, 0.03898409754037857, 0.052987389266490936, 0.0011267494410276413, 0.03401002287864685, 0.03488808125257492, 0.006416464224457741, -0.016902578994631767, -0.016011379659175873, 0.006087709683924913, -0.008406154811382294, 0.026445593684911728, -0.03758716210722923, 0.04489300400018692, -0.014736880548298359, -0.019072022289037704, 0.04276008903980255, 0.016489749774336815, 0.007810207549482584, -0.025390708819031715, -0.013601010665297508, 0.045916516333818436, -0.048408959060907364, 0.0007024539518170059, 0.0176986213773489, 0.009758691303431988, -0.009916789829730988, -0.0018495830008760095, -0.0194692425429821, 0.0025569365825504065, 0.006823988631367683, -0.042637743055820465, 0.006959171034395695, 0.025806691497564316, -0.04212348535656929, 0.011225355789065361, -0.02419571951031685, -0.022030923515558243, -0.031340159475803375, 0.0028164905961602926, 0.017572594806551933, 0.021834859624505043, 0.023700563237071037, -0.033554211258888245, -0.0327906534075737, -0.009590060450136662, -0.026803743094205856, -0.008494202047586441, 0.009545096196234226, -0.03635288402438164, 0.013208020478487015, -0.012938755564391613, -0.014760496094822884, 0.03633607551455498, -0.003159443847835064, 0.018115529790520668, 0.009143078699707985, -0.02082708850502968, -0.08166392892599106, -0.05785653740167618, -0.04961446672677994, 0.00331946462392807, -0.011185791343450546, -0.02492147497832775, 0.060226552188396454, -0.007709426339715719, -0.006416636053472757, -0.020642582327127457, -0.04734836146235466, 0.010996432974934578, -0.04111717268824577, -0.01929675042629242, -0.004497434478253126, 0.006363889668136835, 0.011697372421622276, 0.01400918047875166, -0.03865734115242958, -0.013416147790849209, -0.0736408606171608, -0.05646895617246628, 0.03338446095585823, 0.028560170903801918, 0.04619564488530159, -0.014401084743440151, -0.025265926495194435, 0.046744879335165024, 0.0161574874073267, 0.008303241804242134, -0.05049050599336624, -0.017690127715468407, -0.025707876309752464, -0.018611764535307884, 0.015236218459904194, 0.0069933608174324036, 0.007677814923226833, 0.0450647808611393, 0.03088240511715412, 0.03529570251703262, 0.027013828977942467, 0.039802324026823044, -0.006455469876527786, 0.0026992401108145714, -0.010568941943347454, -0.002941098064184189, 0.043119922280311584, -0.004205892328172922, -0.03131461143493652, 0.007534517906606197, -0.008865204639732838, 0.014262459240853786, 0.028024503961205482, -0.0599655844271183, 0.027686074376106262, 0.007437687832862139, 0.016314739361405373, -0.0471467524766922, 0.03266533091664314, 0.014052932150661945, 0.006947820540517569, -0.014529713429510593, 0.010417245328426361, 0.06470158696174622, -0.005250692833214998, -0.020937861874699593, 0.07015958428382874, 0.0310001689940691, -0.03578173369169235, -0.007114172913134098, -0.021704360842704773, -0.018817555159330368, 0.027926431968808174, -0.008801689371466637, 0.00680552376434207, 0.04812564328312874, -0.006071547511965036, 0.017719095572829247, -0.018740352243185043, -0.03515642136335373, -0.007681680377572775, -0.08063159883022308, 0.007306259125471115, -0.01777470111846924, 0.04309583455324173, -0.020678343251347542, 0.027964679524302483, 0.01099378615617752, 0.003105127951130271, 0.04526481777429581, 0.01402332168072462, -0.049909599125385284, 0.031340550631284714, -0.01575705222785473, -0.03481290861964226, 0.016210991889238358, -0.0018649403937160969, 0.023945147171616554, -0.01835748739540577, 0.009052836336195469, -0.01301451027393341, 0.022050142288208008, -0.02178020216524601, -0.018112199380993843, -0.028132615610957146, -0.06613092869520187, -0.013872318901121616, -0.004640435334295034, 0.024015726521611214, -0.03594007343053818, 0.0542517714202404, 0.03409760072827339, 0.0016763086896389723, -0.03357420489192009, -0.04723668098449707, 0.034612078219652176, 0.06744632124900818, 0.024699406698346138, 0.04722931236028671, 0.008817956782877445, -0.04736959934234619, 0.037053368985652924, 0.028964359313249588, 0.018570175394415855, 0.014121963642537594, 0.02580796368420124, -0.01583326980471611, -0.027017181739211082, -0.02319122664630413, 0.025462506338953972, 0.034253835678100586, 0.026447836309671402, 0.012770882807672024, 0.020429840311408043, 0.02435905672609806, -0.03582258149981499, 0.02792603336274624, 0.03953009843826294, -0.015828711912035942, 0.03565492853522301, 0.00340293045155704, -0.023347871378064156, 0.014204769395291805, 0.013315154239535332, 0.03539479896426201, -0.007700447458773851, 0.0058508035726845264, -0.03562435880303383, 0.0335129015147686, -0.009048367850482464, 0.021050287410616875, -0.007103399373590946, 0.019813556224107742, 0.0812012106180191, -0.005964275449514389, -0.026077037677168846, 0.022077297791838646, 0.038471683859825134, 0.03788832947611809, 0.03814258426427841, 0.03240985423326492, -0.09966234862804413, -0.004516203422099352, 0.026532215997576714, 0.0027710674330592155, -0.04094411060214043, 0.00520193949341774, -0.06183421239256859, -0.037613533437252045, 0.024162976071238518, -0.0005670776590704918, 0.037548501044511795, 0.02547995001077652, -0.0019714264199137688, 0.00459153251722455, -0.043634962290525436, -0.01828734390437603, 0.02182677574455738, -0.007298395968973637, 0.032097239047288895, 0.00015006421017460525, -0.04866654425859451, -0.0449364148080349, 0.005819037090986967, 0.01885521411895752, 0.07276836782693863, -0.013698560185730457, 0.00056608667364344, -0.003458778141066432, 0.028609348461031914, -0.007160398177802563, -0.05819015949964523, 0.028260396793484688, -0.013306128792464733, -0.005715877749025822, 0.031978435814380646, 0.006628979463130236, 0.0012387668248265982, -0.024891706183552742, 0.006831359583884478, -0.027564413845539093, -0.01210878137499094, -0.037658993154764175, 0.0411071851849556, 0.029160160571336746, 0.005756030324846506, 0.04891669750213623, 0.031170526519417763, 0.022664261981844902, -0.022992011159658432, -0.008480637334287167, 0.036223698407411575, -0.0295722633600235, -0.021090351045131683, -0.02543679252266884, 0.0054028574377298355, -0.024295790120959282, 0.03206046298146248, 0.004701818805187941, 0.019215784966945648, -0.012710225768387318, -0.007331561762839556, 0.0017013723263517022, -0.003239752259105444, -0.02898944914340973, -0.012360616587102413, 0.010045667178928852, 0.019928498193621635, -0.028538547456264496, -0.03210233524441719, 0.024462947621941566, -0.002711863722652197, -0.030862702056765556, 0.02242640219628811, -0.031585343182086945, 0.03729234263300896, -0.033560823649168015, -0.024504417553544044, 0.008859793655574322, -0.01079179160296917, 0.011002455838024616, -0.03541053831577301, 0.035614263266325, -0.007839114405214787, -0.030811971053481102, 0.0008724387735128403, 0.05228427052497864, 0.00819528941065073, 0.028261030092835426, -0.051155343651771545, 0.053868286311626434, -0.009181041270494461, -0.014949080534279346, -0.053758278489112854, -0.04914518818259239, 0.02287987433373928, 0.037656333297491074, -0.01518337894231081, -0.06579332053661346, -0.017365233972668648, -0.04757814109325409, -0.010643531568348408, -0.019567960873246193, 0.06459853053092957, -0.04769355431199074, -0.01553571317344904, -0.023573094978928566, 0.029463399201631546, 0.08409243077039719, -0.03163016960024834, -0.013108248822391033, -0.004248389508575201, -0.014040069654583931, -0.020740965381264687, -0.014722724445164204, 0.045840322971343994, -0.023031052201986313, 0.012621304951608181, -0.014486380852758884, -0.020299240946769714, 0.05187433212995529, -0.015573404729366302, -0.043559908866882324, 0.02557581104338169, 0.03655558079481125, 0.020015455782413483, -0.026264376938343048, 0.01752648688852787, -0.022863008081912994, 0.010028052143752575, -0.018348170444369316, 0.007397612556815147, 0.014628731645643711, -0.04883408173918724, 0.018948744982481003, 0.016233036294579506, -0.0437806211411953, 0.02656491845846176, 0.06226731464266777, -0.022852694615721703, 0.006796495523303747, 0.014445663429796696, -0.006661526393145323, 0.009986811317503452, 0.01434405893087387, 0.012249011546373367, -0.013411663472652435, 0.007575316354632378, -0.03248365595936775, -0.04228094220161438, -0.007709122262895107, -0.01743357442319393, 0.07930929213762283, -0.01896999031305313, 0.03209521993994713, 0.03470331057906151, 0.004507812205702066, 0.013188578188419342, -0.03306867927312851, 0.024603750556707382, 0.01188849750906229, -0.01835489645600319, 0.055690981447696686, -0.046335652470588684, -0.015354523435235023, 0.024787668138742447, -0.0006239116191864014, 0.01267182920128107, 0.04755523055791855, -0.009268907830119133, 0.03334518522024155, 0.021903274580836296, -0.0077519286423921585, -0.056362397968769073, 0.031013106927275658, -0.053752750158309937, 0.007028945721685886, -0.04356979951262474, -0.005445207469165325, 0.056019898504018784, 0.06941083818674088, -0.018670225515961647, -0.06314615905284882, -0.03225189074873924, -0.059495776891708374, 0.0008242509211413562, 0.0007140967063605785, 0.009796353988349438, 0.055252816528081894, 0.016307100653648376, 0.05772048979997635, 0.0014468419831246138, 0.013100004754960537, -0.029750484973192215, -0.033884357661008835, -0.000807665113825351, -0.06214062124490738, -0.027935991063714027, 0.04561574012041092, -0.014735125936567783, -0.021636415272951126, 0.006789228413254023, -0.013552596792578697, -0.02305847778916359, 0.025715773925185204, 0.03516563028097153, 0.014869693666696548, 0.06563865393400192, 0.045700788497924805, 0.0033040018752217293, -0.02473396807909012, 0.005514263641089201, 0.10364042967557907, 0.07025110721588135, 0.04727485403418541, -0.06790671497583389, 0.04033162072300911, 0.007166550029069185, 0.021337440237402916, -0.02268170937895775, -0.005374873988330364, 0.010520177893340588, 0.004268593620508909, 0.05563763901591301, 0.04663027450442314, 0.03490390628576279, -0.02921094186604023, 0.06395979970693588, -0.018986796960234642, 0.019748186692595482, -0.002415900118649006, -0.006485056597739458, -0.0047542559914290905, -0.012070933356881142, -0.04308553785085678, 0.003433279460296035, -0.011438128538429737, -0.00021669823036063462, -0.02365143410861492, -0.019013548269867897, -0.024035057052969933, -0.02109203301370144, -0.038495711982250214, 0.004785636439919472, 0.018693363294005394, -0.004229845479130745, -0.044844336807727814, -0.016605304554104805, 0.011487719602882862, -0.027370987460017204, 0.01777389459311962, 0.014114259742200375, 0.005088556092232466, 0.029986491426825523, -0.0031574422027915716, 0.007180661894381046, -0.030860329046845436, -0.005960832815617323, -0.04933781921863556, 0.04266100749373436, -0.01914009265601635, -0.03564566746354103, -0.013701369054615498, -0.007660097908228636, -0.00554945832118392, -0.019769595935940742, 0.00003721437315107323, 0.008581952191889286, 0.024126948788762093, -0.042348433285951614, 0.006989895831793547, -0.02341463230550289, 0.00387923838570714, -0.01583511009812355, 0.012082936242222786, 0.018607094883918762, -0.03742275387048721, -0.018317384645342827, -0.017007941380143166, 0.03533884882926941, -0.01911633275449276, 0.004771300591528416, 0.0015079556033015251, -0.006581895984709263, -0.029617026448249817, 0.0020399526692926884, 0.0152207650244236, 0.00689877662807703, 0.022281015291810036, 0.002379822311922908, -0.019707512110471725, -0.0039207483641803265, -0.07117550075054169, 0.04791657626628876, -0.004259361885488033, -0.0033886260353028774, -0.04289914667606354, 0.017570098862051964, 0.0399804450571537, 0.02735402248799801, -0.010354149155318737, 0.010798254981637001, -0.03829674422740936, 0.05210992321372032, 0.008003647439181805, -0.06869269162416458, -0.023479148745536804, 0.00506135867908597, -0.01370934210717678, -0.010423866100609303, -0.034517914056777954, 0.051354944705963135, 0.02417195960879326, 0.01661527156829834, -0.026688791811466217, 0.03827347606420517, 0.014298642054200172, 0.030615322291851044, 0.016241826117038727, -0.039553675800561905, -0.000548991491086781, 0.020102962851524353, -0.0017305080546066165, -0.01966964080929756, -0.02992854081094265, -0.0033466254826635122, -0.01059915591031313, 0.00024874633527360857, -0.04853653162717819, -0.03979439288377762, 0.01199387852102518, -0.041343994438648224, 0.01831764355301857, -0.05525222793221474, -0.008955452591180801, -0.09035848826169968, -0.04236038774251938, 0.006688377354294062, -0.03699992597103119, -0.0004502602678257972, 0.009455570951104164, -0.024989666417241096, -0.027626292780041695, 0.06284818798303604, 0.011204389855265617, -0.0040249149315059185, -0.014562749303877354, 0.01122371107339859, 0.01933576725423336, 0.05305816978216171, -0.026943542063236237, -0.03786033019423485, 0.038062769919633865, -0.008944309316575527, -0.03493935614824295, 0.021545737981796265, 0.011732892133295536, 0.036293286830186844, 0.0004744153411593288, 0.02755240723490715, -0.033034548163414, 0.08322605490684509, -0.00478761363774538, 0.023167744278907776, -0.042584214359521866, -0.008772995322942734, 0.01700620725750923, -0.011656876653432846, -0.008936533704400063, 0.01638873666524887, -0.01730143092572689, 0.02183780074119568, 0.04492062330245972, -0.006830635946244001, -0.008237729780375957, -0.0004996790084987879, -0.02059059590101242, 0.021664073690772057, 0.0027626128867268562, -0.02985474467277527, 0.05777430906891823, 0.04474042356014252, -0.02561795525252819, 0.016416756436228752, 0.018971983343362808, -0.004394415766000748, -0.059371061623096466, 0.01909109577536583, 0.020993491634726524, 0.0031741438433527946, 0.02090618759393692, -0.02828664891421795, -0.0025452871341258287, 0.015119130723178387, -0.0011836123885586858, 0.00559251056984067, -0.0025283510331064463, 0.005121646914631128, -0.014308481477200985, 0.0010410031536594033, -0.0017040595412254333, 0.01903577893972397, 0.00439732288941741, 0.012566265650093555, 0.008102509193122387, 0.03376282379031181, 0.01755390129983425, -0.05218604579567909, -0.02959241159260273, -0.03954893723130226, 0.04172348976135254, -0.05824080854654312, 0.030562056228518486, -0.04297583922743797, -0.00250979489646852, 0.016477322205901146, -0.0448421984910965, 0.034522511065006256, 0.016064757481217384, 0.021476279944181442, -0.020362626761198044, 0.01956911012530327, 0.017723074182868004, -0.010716094635426998, -0.006128991488367319, -0.0040350197814404964, 0.019600694999098778, 0.015463615767657757, -0.01661553792655468, 0.020118556916713715, -0.0020757801830768585, -0.026946011930704117, -0.0033896637614816427, -0.00043255306081846356, -0.009249524213373661, -0.024568697437644005, 0.022713404148817062, 0.027465112507343292, 0.0075081344693899155, -0.002970385132357478, 0.015117735601961613, -0.034810833632946014, -0.017989210784435272, 0.03348996117711067, 0.035622358322143555, -0.025488359853625298, 0.009691153652966022, 0.0017592969816178083, -0.033869318664073944, 0.0027460334822535515, 0.007602374069392681, 0.01906566694378853, -0.05010344460606575, -0.026068462058901787, -0.01542825810611248, -0.028117891401052475, -0.0689878836274147, -0.03886471688747406, -0.0414201058447361, 0.03455856069922447, -0.011772182770073414, 0.018442096188664436, 0.014226567931473255, 0.007635404355823994, -0.0030169878154993057, -0.06702237576246262, 0.069627545773983, -0.006943956948816776, 0.010327480733394623, -0.04053165018558502, -0.026121065020561218, -0.055765796452760696, -0.000928702182136476, 0.0631868839263916, -0.007424528244882822, 0.023982681334018707, 0.029705196619033813, 0.0024961826857179403, -0.008014977909624577, -0.02457413263618946, 0.0607253834605217, -0.018682988360524178, 0.008949089795351028, 0.046283919364213943, -0.01657336950302124, -0.024014616385102272, -0.019666286185383797, 0.014436841942369938, -0.010213271714746952, 0.03045506589114666, 0.021244706586003304, 0.007567294407635927, 0.042792435735464096, 0.0022380738519132137, -0.021768396720290184, 0.02437681145966053, -0.006302566733211279, 0.027577025815844536, 0.024283388629555702, 0.00040268231532536447, -0.047845982015132904, 0.06058425456285477, -0.04781549796462059, -0.03251630812883377, -0.009865115396678448, -0.017079012468457222, -0.013642776757478714, -0.06029634177684784, 0.019084133207798004, -0.02789934352040291, -0.003636994631960988, 0.03445225581526756, 0.024331390857696533, 0.0029237044509500265, 0.019892236217856407, -0.011813348159193993, 0.01837904565036297, 0.009569567628204823, -0.01636911742389202, -0.00991306733340025, 0.039414770901203156, 0.027233228087425232, -0.018494220450520515, -0.001850971020758152, 0.015731818974018097, 0.04995356872677803, 0.03625752776861191, -0.029252057895064354, 0.025570353493094444, -0.02396959252655506, -0.012009774334728718, 0.015276880003511906, 0.006897085811942816, 0.0035860270727425814, -0.008003545925021172, -0.0024444079026579857, 0.01848783530294895, -0.03761407732963562, -0.006006923504173756, -0.026361260563135147, -0.013652162626385689, -0.03105076216161251, 0.012343154288828373, 0.008581333793699741, 0.004852773621678352, -0.009934008121490479, 0.033720504492521286, 0.03951408714056015, -0.0035162917338311672, -0.002490576822310686, -0.0026592190843075514, 0.014957358129322529, -0.023781541734933853, -0.028629550710320473, -0.018105870112776756, -0.014669244177639484, -0.02044246532022953, -0.05169779062271118, 0.05327149108052254, 0.051544588059186935, 0.04286464676260948, -0.022839117795228958, -0.0354677252471447, 0.002306015230715275, 0.03970882296562195, -0.06586393713951111, -0.02994401752948761, -0.030654851347208023, 0.03225111588835716, 0.026883404701948166, -0.042913906276226044 ]
<p>I was wondering if anyone could help me on how to interpret the coefficient from an analysis I have carried out in R (<code>survival</code> package). </p> <p>The data is right censored, the dependent variable (time to event) was modelled under the gaussian distribution and the independent variable is a categorical variable (3 categories). </p> <p>my output is as follows:</p> <pre><code>coeff se p-value -0.107 0.048 2.7x10-2 </code></pre> <p>Can anyone tell me how to interpret this coefficient under the following model?</p>
37,142
[ -0.004259668290615082, -0.05510564520955086, -0.007525942288339138, 0.010384438559412956, 0.025187723338603973, 0.0115470290184021, -0.0013113730819895864, -0.012607990764081478, 0.041650544852018356, -0.06266491115093231, 0.03937749192118645, 0.048745524138212204, 0.051465876400470734, 0.00163477030582726, 0.03569478169083595, 0.03662322461605072, 0.009190857410430908, 0.013673149049282074, 0.012805899605154991, -0.008874285966157913, -0.02156137116253376, 0.038048770278692245, -0.033796053379774094, 0.011483974754810333, -0.0320921391248703, 0.050972018390893936, 0.018699029460549355, 0.00030639965552836657, 0.017603032290935516, 0.041325561702251434, -0.02208646759390831, -0.04285214841365814, 0.010054491460323334, 0.002235998399555683, 0.0008914637728594244, -0.006900852546095848, 0.004777621943503618, -0.04621858522295952, -0.014680053107440472, 0.008199469186365604, -0.008164795115590096, -0.04762331396341324, 0.008785397745668888, 0.04785715043544769, 0.02306513860821724, 0.0009772266494110227, -0.012209964916110039, -0.023710915818810463, 0.04775358363986015, -0.019509263336658478, 0.05906979367136955, -0.021279316395521164, 0.06465452164411545, -0.021073797717690468, -0.011593155562877655, -0.0063769882544875145, 0.04081837460398674, 0.059508997946977615, -0.01872352324426174, -0.08254115283489227, -0.06260127574205399, -0.0533413328230381, 0.021570878103375435, 0.00000976226874627173, -0.029531601816415787, -0.018631136044859886, -0.006715298164635897, -0.05633743852376938, 0.05104425922036171, 0.007709953002631664, 0.019679129123687744, 0.014354139566421509, 0.030726367607712746, 0.0023202653974294662, 0.027817390859127045, -0.033716585487127304, 0.01692763715982437, 0.02021687850356102, 0.022708484902977943, 0.01959194801747799, 0.0081553990021348, 0.0035218684934079647, -0.019649164751172066, 0.05488738790154457, -0.011508719064295292, 0.01896498166024685, 0.06545770168304443, -0.04596786946058273, 0.05501418933272362, -0.004286350216716528, -0.04138566181063652, 0.033912815153598785, 0.04110348969697952, 0.014272338710725307, -0.04390374571084976, 0.06301600486040115, 0.005037232767790556, 0.054721612483263016, 0.01991560310125351, 0.031822480261325836, -0.018367579206824303, -0.04556427150964737, 0.024937713518738747, 0.017875220626592636, -0.03824300691485405, 0.02514973282814026, -0.04938206449151039, 0.003764313878491521, 0.007236395962536335, -0.0519012026488781, 0.0031764425802975893, 0.009992132894694805, 0.03788913041353226, -0.002454831963405013, 0.02119050920009613, -0.016406286507844925, -0.028614791110157967, 0.008129958063364029, 0.04711897298693657, 0.038804154843091965, 0.05478270724415779, -0.019923659041523933, 0.01707720384001732, -0.003818431869149208, -0.06310417503118515, 0.019200386479496956, 0.027448533102869987, -0.007240156177431345, -0.004128138069063425, 0.060682497918605804, -0.0176937784999609, -0.04400092735886574, 0.0437304712831974, -0.01053380686789751, 0.016965726390480995, 0.0014288901584222913, -0.09243624657392502, -0.03672793507575989, 0.010061021894216537, 0.0031993514858186245, 0.006361547391861677, -0.0776132121682167, -0.01655540242791176, 0.004879130516201258, 0.025987030938267708, 0.00873912125825882, 0.0008651483803987503, -0.0035041829105466604, 0.019849181175231934, 0.021244563162326813, -0.02083776891231537, 0.0035365724470466375, -0.04251399636268616, -0.01978432387113571, -0.04133691266179085, -0.07379943132400513, -0.020001599565148354, 0.023695213720202446, -0.011095365509390831, -0.0204874686896801, 0.03459496051073074, -0.0002635629498399794, -0.02175145410001278, 0.002206547651439905, -0.026539403945207596, -0.019580122083425522, 0.05776416137814522, 0.0036620614118874073, 0.04157918691635132, 0.0468834824860096, 0.004751058295369148, 0.038825616240501404, 0.019721154123544693, 0.05251644551753998, 0.008414736948907375, -0.014726921916007996, 0.0034901199396699667, -0.03830655291676521, 0.002393839182332158, -0.0040290020406246185, -0.029924506321549416, -0.029755983501672745, -0.03417608141899109, -0.02722196839749813, 0.0020993996877223253, 0.007981033995747566, 0.008419156074523926, -0.022779298946261406, 0.03947776183485985, -0.021953629329800606, -0.06205861270427704, -0.05778857320547104, -0.0009665407123975456, 0.005953202955424786, -0.02027411386370659, -0.021694306284189224, -0.00006499660958070308, 0.035978272557258606, -0.00824062805622816, -0.013614331372082233, -0.03775821253657341, 0.001971636898815632, 0.006009192205965519, -0.037992868572473526, 0.020151007920503616, 0.041606683284044266, 0.05253341421484947, -0.028147932142019272, 0.04470207914710045, -0.005980109795928001, -0.01650151051580906, 0.0401354655623436, -0.011445269919931889, 0.015022773295640945, 0.0026262118481099606, -0.04108541086316109, 0.02592037245631218, 0.008430433459579945, -0.036778077483177185, 0.0508141964673996, -0.044822487980127335, 0.06168172135949135, 0.04436185956001282, 0.03003837913274765, -0.007155716884881258, -0.01226197462528944, -0.018015356734395027, 0.034112706780433655, -0.029635371640324593, -0.03350880369544029, -0.019918855279684067, -0.030800633132457733, 0.032641373574733734, 0.001180926221422851, 0.002120976336300373, -0.0035044346004724503, 0.012398835271596909, -0.02198399044573307, 0.0413847342133522, 0.046193115413188934, 0.01901320368051529, 0.014375928789377213, 0.010098484344780445, 0.0024284222163259983, -0.016381878405809402, -0.0032761450856924057, 0.02946322225034237, 0.026429282501339912, 0.07289573550224304, -0.014139227569103241, 0.0043227351270616055, 0.07733447104692459, -0.02416512742638588, 0.010075842030346394, -0.018313609063625336, 0.008751563727855682, 0.03926977515220642, -0.020907774567604065, 0.027729514986276627, 0.04079582914710045, -0.0008357558399438858, 0.014194819144904613, -0.013382574543356895, -0.02367325872182846, -0.006815044675022364, 0.056287944316864014, -0.05295250192284584, -0.009668948128819466, -0.009331567212939262, -0.026376131922006607, 0.014196585863828659, -0.0037185822147876024, -0.03814782574772835, -0.03840084746479988, -0.012795058079063892, 0.03733281418681145, 0.006629916839301586, 0.025618378072977066, -0.018096519634127617, -0.06236400082707405, 0.013923143036663532, -0.033584725111722946, 0.07012908905744553, 0.016216767951846123, -0.053484879434108734, -0.01737089641392231, -0.011596599593758583, -0.005501542240381241, 0.028371484950184822, -0.02878403849899769, -0.0448700487613678, 0.028931327164173126, -0.02918343059718609, -0.014552322216331959, -0.005679715890437365, 0.009106695652008057, -0.0029488697182387114, -0.025616031140089035, -0.030271204188466072, 0.06358709931373596, -0.02069423347711563, 0.0009509108494967222, 0.037320878356695175, -0.07796981930732727, -0.04040095582604408, -0.021837767213582993, -0.005992571823298931, 0.026149770244956017, -0.002886200323700905, 0.03450844809412956, -0.015431441366672516, 0.00493621826171875, 0.009466482326388359, -0.06271013617515564, -0.06337009370326996, 0.03548147901892662, -0.014793534763157368, -0.0013254819205030799, -0.008855217136442661, -0.01628493331372738, 0.03975898027420044, 0.0354548878967762, -0.002131602494046092, -0.039721161127090454, 0.0022504148073494434, -0.04508122429251671, -0.010036646388471127, -0.006725396495312452, 0.0017239958979189396, 0.04794223606586456, 0.03491382673382759, -0.004152708221226931, 0.043149255216121674, 0.03321850299835205, -0.01479073241353035, -0.01957661658525467, 0.027630098164081573, -0.040429066866636276, -0.03707665205001831, 0.025035185739398003, 0.025445356965065002, -0.010577229782938957, 0.04434141516685486, -0.02992350608110428, 0.02184990420937538, 0.01882176846265793, -0.03734628111124039, -0.006321254186332226, -0.008716614916920662, 0.0023887234274297953, -0.017696568742394447, 0.029320627450942993, 0.0011766301468014717, -0.032477907836437225, 0.014354980550706387, 0.008899390697479248, 0.03552759438753128, -0.05959951505064964, -0.00024175307771656662, 0.03492286056280136, 0.0343361534178257, 0.0033144361805170774, -0.02065129578113556, -0.020068999379873276, -0.02859221212565899, 0.0327129065990448, -0.0005144665483385324, -0.02242443338036537, 0.06609523296356201, 0.03731277957558632, 0.026981815695762634, -0.01621854305267334, -0.04045457765460014, -0.013932505622506142, -0.04335612431168556, -0.002203452168032527, 0.027781780809164047, 0.06273055821657181, 0.0010685259476304054, 0.028860032558441162, 0.05225282534956932, -0.024610677734017372, 0.023037245497107506, -0.0075079393573105335, -0.05750081688165665, 0.04100465774536133, 0.0013842775952070951, -0.007651862222701311, -0.005930926185101271, -0.004948649555444717, 0.027423018589615822, 0.010255586355924606, -0.005402659997344017, 0.008710783906280994, 0.02236483059823513, -0.004521639551967382, -0.004587392322719097, -0.01792740449309349, 0.03139055520296097, -0.007213031407445669, -0.0137960035353899, 0.004944398067891598, 0.026417875662446022, 0.0064375330694019794, 0.04583500698208809, -0.004911244381219149, -0.0063470820896327496, -0.014127625152468681, -0.060633670538663864, 0.053166650235652924, 0.029029253870248795, 0.050668805837631226, 0.00488827470690012, -0.021789781749248505, 0.048476796597242355, -0.0039108553901314735, 0.029613476246595383, 0.04488709568977356, 0.007472940254956484, -0.025495778769254684, -0.03292931243777275, -0.00038087472785264254, 0.003974945284426212, 0.013445693999528885, 0.007011496461927891, 0.023230059072375298, 0.07651667296886444, 0.03168554604053497, -0.06924118846654892, 0.026778999716043472, 0.03793912008404732, 0.053233325481414795, -0.017179695889353752, -0.03298773244023323, -0.010910225100815296, -0.006179028656333685, -0.025365987792611122, 0.021041737869381905, 0.02576191909611225, -0.015148298814892769, 0.004760079085826874, 0.028453605249524117, -0.03857133537530899, -0.020251506939530373, -0.02734883315861225, 0.021442966535687447, 0.024486305192112923, 0.014769045636057854, -0.052759528160095215, 0.005613525863736868, 0.052490316331386566, 0.004890014883130789, 0.028508875519037247, 0.04210687801241875, -0.07633157819509506, 0.006637808866798878, 0.014535375870764256, 0.04394525662064552, -0.02472061850130558, -0.01855919510126114, -0.05125720798969269, 0.003492380026727915, -0.01253027655184269, -0.06678120791912079, 0.029478231444954872, 0.0020766255911439657, 0.006344465538859367, -0.009305443614721298, -0.005433734506368637, -0.08042895793914795, 0.054579976946115494, -0.02743414416909218, 0.019091807305812836, -0.010741802863776684, -0.053987644612789154, -0.04805869609117508, 0.00992084201425314, -0.012606299482285976, 0.023568497970700264, -0.03631042316555977, -0.014445490203797817, 0.019742196425795555, 0.03413577005267143, -0.007647158112376928, -0.030568063259124756, 0.005517561919987202, 0.0015413066139444709, 0.010131343267858028, 0.041710421442985535, -0.0076382895931601524, 0.008832371793687344, -0.0035180598497390747, 0.016305431723594666, 0.004620106425136328, -0.013767458498477936, -0.007670270279049873, 0.05364535003900528, 0.020763907581567764, -0.05821189656853676, 0.06316062808036804, 0.02282237820327282, -0.019435904920101166, -0.004549281671643257, -0.054052527993917465, 0.012679395265877247, -0.011508886702358723, 0.004676110111176968, -0.03369871526956558, -0.0036736861802637577, -0.02891518920660019, -0.005052828695625067, -0.022132469341158867, 0.015000269748270512, -0.055547840893268585, -0.0013126443373039365, 0.027177438139915466, -0.013125540688633919, -0.005911386106163263, 0.001981305191293359, 0.008727198466658592, -0.0015683998353779316, 0.02347123809158802, -0.04652215167880058, 0.0003068283840548247, -0.05081906169652939, -0.01351010799407959, -0.0011210220400243998, -0.04068824648857117, -0.009718451648950577, 0.002064398257061839, -0.06169299781322479, 0.023942891508340836, -0.03798496723175049, 0.009304900653660297, -0.03034639172255993, 0.023105643689632416, 0.017599400132894516, -0.014370981603860855, -0.02788105420768261, 0.03881486505270004, 0.0022736270911991596, 0.016246652230620384, -0.028236782178282738, 0.0369562953710556, 0.028125887736678123, -0.013695182278752327, -0.06570833921432495, -0.0549636036157608, 0.033891551196575165, 0.00039469156763516366, -0.07804553955793381, 0.0030676128808408976, -0.0513983890414238, -0.0259876549243927, -0.05780796334147453, 0.005063260905444622, 0.03133111074566841, -0.03535991907119751, 0.014214389026165009, -0.016988493502140045, 0.0075014568865299225, 0.05330587178468704, 0.024890730157494545, -0.0280863419175148, 0.01909068413078785, -0.0034200868103653193, -0.022735241800546646, 0.013687941245734692, 0.009610324166715145, -0.010267221368849277, 0.0042282394133508205, 0.003132041310891509, 0.020832715556025505, 0.015937548130750656, -0.018943365663290024, -0.03219270333647728, -0.020216291770339012, -0.017953045666217804, 0.0287550687789917, -0.009981793351471424, 0.03468428924679756, -0.005167544819414616, 0.013100847601890564, 0.018277591094374657, -0.00062414794228971, -0.009891759604215622, -0.0069189369678497314, 0.04802335798740387, -0.00873340480029583, -0.02356085367500782, 0.03563621640205383, 0.05538548156619072, 0.012849932536482811, 0.047644421458244324, -0.007899158634245396, -0.021100511774420738, 0.029448719695210457, 0.0478622168302536, -0.014550524763762951, 0.04478802531957626, 0.018818721175193787, -0.04030020907521248, 0.008149922825396061, -0.058033160865306854, -0.009699701331555843, 0.047640398144721985, -0.06164519861340523, 0.04707041382789612, 0.03638417646288872, 0.0011409679427742958, 0.007211117073893547, -0.03904646262526512, -0.014102686196565628, 0.004383377265185118, 0.020633863285183907, 0.02107461914420128, -0.015620970167219639, -0.001020269002765417, 0.04594956338405609, 0.03846703842282295, -0.018544895574450493, 0.05086956545710564, 0.03356557339429855, 0.00901256874203682, 0.023039735853672028, -0.008038601838052273, -0.020753109827637672, 0.06832163035869598, -0.019970113411545753, 0.0137863140553236, -0.058590978384017944, -0.023732353001832962, 0.010819964110851288, 0.013708851300179958, 0.005339696537703276, -0.05888991802930832, -0.006414380855858326, -0.06582767516374588, 0.008104889653623104, 0.05086161568760872, -0.04315900802612305, 0.03231155872344971, -0.006156178191304207, 0.047306980937719345, 0.024807002395391464, 0.061969902366399765, -0.005155120976269245, -0.03888960927724838, -0.02164989337325096, -0.02188742160797119, -0.011998850852251053, 0.00022401471505872905, -0.003878789721056819, -0.022222118452191353, -0.00855246838182211, -0.06908059120178223, 0.0043160924687981606, 0.007980415597558022, 0.022481374442577362, -0.0019064159132540226, 0.08994483202695847, 0.037343572825193405, 0.010463678278028965, 0.01769263483583927, -0.039202362298965454, 0.09203384816646576, 0.09834960103034973, 0.02548719011247158, -0.029304757714271545, 0.02690145932137966, 0.009274950250983238, 0.020461181178689003, -0.008008530363440514, -0.011034958064556122, 0.021608630195260048, 0.02393391728401184, 0.06584397703409195, 0.04777059331536293, 0.01950494758784771, 0.007825625129044056, 0.0620558001101017, -0.03446035087108612, -0.04854697361588478, -0.012698305770754814, 0.005774030927568674, -0.006389860529452562, -0.03823959082365036, -0.0324627049267292, 0.018216878175735474, 0.017649976536631584, -0.04802820086479187, -0.054085832089185715, -0.02042352594435215, -0.010835060849785805, 0.012220374308526516, -0.014291106723248959, 0.001524452236481011, 0.0032901510130614042, 0.018875865265727043, -0.02055208384990692, -0.005443738307803869, 0.017975741997361183, 0.0057691726833581924, -0.011832616291940212, 0.009747212752699852, -0.0009380800765939057, 0.0035028206184506416, 0.009758188389241695, 0.023860551416873932, -0.05627010762691498, -0.05326903611421585, -0.00920457486063242, 0.05362825468182564, -0.0011139737907797098, 0.019671201705932617, -0.030749963596463203, 0.008866919204592705, 0.033385127782821655, -0.04488310590386391, -0.0264156274497509, 0.006806325167417526, 0.008372968062758446, -0.03112119808793068, -0.02673216164112091, -0.0334332212805748, -0.0265041571110487, -0.04201328009366989, 0.04085239768028259, 0.02736835554242134, -0.029022276401519775, 0.000528659438714385, -0.058796972036361694, 0.030037537217140198, -0.017003361135721207, 0.01772264577448368, 0.009306914173066616, -0.04118502885103226, -0.03630424290895462, 0.008463053032755852, 0.0384729839861393, 0.014665166847407818, 0.013817527331411839, -0.01448945701122284, -0.022852525115013123, -0.033823054283857346, -0.023493563756346703, 0.05247132480144501, -0.018726497888565063, 0.007232836447656155, -0.05045158416032791, -0.027922123670578003, 0.013500092551112175, 0.048014502972364426, -0.020830392837524414, 0.028719346970319748, 0.005367252044379711, 0.0566580668091774, -0.006955633871257305, -0.042338378727436066, -0.0034112604334950447, 0.04207656905055046, -0.02448011003434658, -0.002330988645553589, -0.0005429050070233643, 0.08639966696500778, 0.010404955595731735, 0.00416076323017478, 0.028101490810513496, 0.004487037658691406, -0.009743587113916874, -0.012424309737980366, 0.015420544892549515, -0.043273814022541046, -0.002107272855937481, -0.004756596405059099, 0.011659813113510609, -0.01464033592492342, -0.014886791817843914, -0.028032120317220688, -0.04005279764533043, 0.026796966791152954, -0.013513610698282719, -0.021624036133289337, 0.008638031780719757, -0.03561665862798691, 0.016013922169804573, -0.024611055850982666, -0.01884482428431511, -0.0458509735763073, 0.00449490686878562, -0.02739616669714451, -0.0490308478474617, -0.010272246785461903, 0.0030657448805868626, 0.02605537325143814, 0.00819325540214777, 0.02170052006840706, 0.009186552837491035, 0.01355990394949913, 0.003334426088258624, 0.023789409548044205, 0.014012174680829048, 0.07365356385707855, 0.014908356592059135, -0.004804820753633976, 0.022096069529652596, -0.03654180467128754, -0.03910599276423454, 0.02421565353870392, 0.04113985225558281, 0.03380632773041725, -0.005919652990996838, 0.016256215050816536, -0.011521324515342712, 0.0377664789557457, -0.0260307677090168, 0.00018945704505313188, -0.018878402188420296, -0.029398050159215927, -0.010915383696556091, -0.019933663308620453, -0.04990151524543762, 0.009016738273203373, -0.011424806900322437, 0.010730713605880737, 0.04999436438083649, -0.015230211429297924, -0.010745778679847717, -0.0007804606575518847, -0.0013529936550185084, -0.006303881760686636, 0.024790601804852486, 0.013367938809096813, 0.010789843276143074, 0.037048373371362686, 0.018944958224892616, 0.08927196264266968, -0.030612802132964134, 0.01851997897028923, -0.09260058403015137, -0.01865609548985958, -0.02493620105087757, 0.02824709750711918, 0.05827394127845764, -0.044698312878608704, -0.001153505640104413, 0.02349635399878025, 0.0026937793008983135, 0.03635244816541672, -0.03592425212264061, -0.020038355141878128, -0.03293860703706741, 0.016641218215227127, 0.007536986842751503, 0.049271147698163986, 0.04536294564604759, -0.001788076013326645, 0.05805307999253273, 0.029861724004149437, -0.003770535346120596, -0.038550905883312225, -0.007933801971375942, 0.03501760587096214, 0.02410893514752388, -0.06308096647262573, 0.03562188148498535, -0.011394185945391655, -0.026567919179797173, 0.037347204983234406, -0.0049120220355689526, 0.013840105384588242, 0.09129635989665985, 0.027733860537409782, 0.015369599685072899, 0.03280226141214371, 0.026257552206516266, -0.010040883906185627, -0.026826348155736923, 0.014212979935109615, -0.0009157317690551281, -0.0019074544543400407, -0.02107607200741768, 0.021692194044589996, -0.0025137837510555983, -0.026382561773061752, -0.013283124193549156, 0.021393639966845512, -0.007265368476510048, 0.015582786872982979, 0.0032119324896484613, -0.021225349977612495, 0.012722264043986797, -0.02328878827393055, 0.04269697517156601, -0.058007653802633286, 0.010868696495890617, 0.02757790870964527, 0.016079245135188103, -0.006829399149864912, 0.03658270835876465, -0.030995776876807213, -0.032099124044179916, 0.015210293233394623, 0.022615792229771614, -0.008928204886615276, -0.010000219568610191, -0.012834771536290646, -0.018315814435482025, -0.004961247555911541, -0.02872765250504017, 0.009004250168800354, -0.0674869567155838, 0.057676058262586594, 0.00212994497269392, 0.009827576577663422, 0.058834828436374664, -0.00007612674380652606, 0.025359785184264183, -0.07734870165586472, 0.0441146120429039, 0.008057576604187489, -0.014084380120038986, -0.04657331109046936, -0.007566770538687706, -0.035364024341106415, 0.006270374171435833, 0.059657275676727295, -0.011764293536543846, -0.019031750038266182, 0.00998242013156414, 0.053131766617298126, -0.036755096167325974, -0.0705489069223404, 0.05161981284618378, 0.014363972470164299, -0.034265682101249695, -0.027455613017082214, 0.010364234447479248, 0.005291595123708248, 0.026008671149611473, 0.028894107788801193, -0.02207092195749283, -0.00010760566510725766, -0.030234765261411667, -0.02371525578200817, 0.025247059762477875, -0.0013918651966378093, -0.019102320075035095, 0.05594129115343094, -0.011802244000136852, 0.013573694974184036, 0.05575963854789734, -0.008404683321714401, -0.029494721442461014, 0.04277091100811958, 0.00719168595969677, -0.021421777084469795, 0.03849073499441147, -0.037693656980991364, 0.018357036635279655, -0.07228688895702362, -0.02805314213037491, 0.016463065519928932, -0.03709053620696068, -0.002679964993149042, 0.052305009216070175, 0.04127123951911926, 0.047814853489398956, -0.03366834670305252, 0.003040080424398184, -0.028710614889860153, -0.034701913595199585, 0.03439618647098541, 0.02212093584239483, 0.023751046508550644, -0.01532449945807457, 0.03388800844550133, 0.02832438424229622, -0.02744917757809162, -0.0010181763209402561, -0.0012865274911746383, 0.03130543231964111, -0.039541736245155334, -0.0062890141271054745, -0.010806340724229813, -0.007740537635982037, 0.03397512435913086, -0.03471484035253525, -0.012209955602884293, 0.026929765939712524, -0.017736423760652542, -0.0023439263459295034, 0.0036735590547323227, 0.0030376550275832415, -0.08556399494409561, -0.018437527120113373, 0.05322970822453499, 0.020224763080477715, -0.011789399199187756, -0.011834344826638699, 0.02147660404443741, 0.003252339083701372, -0.006159047596156597, -0.005568033549934626, 0.03695940971374512, -0.0049425880424678326, -0.024022407829761505, -0.028331546112895012, -0.024065949022769928, -0.00942463893443346, -0.029397236183285713, -0.005850272718816996, 0.011904879473149776, 0.016135720536112785, -0.02357913739979267, 0.0005412849131971598, 0.009903541766107082, 0.05512445420026779, -0.052132748067379, -0.017250562086701393, -0.03205836936831474, 0.030931925401091576, 0.006535357795655727, -0.02064296416938305 ]
<p>I need some help My project aims to develop algorithms for spatial temporal analysis of Flickr, Twitter and Foursquare databases to detect any kind of significant changes, named as “Event” in real time. Event can be defined as any anomalous user activity, which happens at a time or within a specific period of time. For this, different clustering methods should be implemented and the best fit has to be selected. The detected events will be visualized for further exploration.</p> <p>This information will be integrated with some other VGI sources to provide a series of Volunteered Geographic services.</p> <p>Could you please suggest me which clustering algorithm is good for this project? And also please suggest me some books and study material...</p>
49,929
[ 0.003400699235498905, -0.05803584307432175, -0.02153148502111435, 0.0202593095600605, 0.03271816298365593, 0.025147216394543648, 0.04697863385081291, -0.019884901121258736, -0.006616903468966484, -0.015084623359143734, 0.026720186695456505, 0.04889210686087608, 0.0036836734507232904, 0.005651062820106745, 0.019034015014767647, -0.010059908032417297, 0.007176135666668415, -0.02637639082968235, -0.045528896152973175, -0.004106259439140558, -0.00959049817174673, -0.02421853132545948, 0.015013006515800953, -0.010193995200097561, -0.06295906752347946, 0.005361515562981367, 0.02335786260664463, 0.003495070617645979, -0.03624752163887024, 0.07778981328010559, -0.058573316782712936, -0.03661919757723808, -0.026569649577140808, 0.007728293538093567, -0.017824383452534676, -0.026343584060668945, -0.05423783138394356, -0.039871327579021454, -0.017009593546390533, 0.02013963647186756, -0.03998523950576782, -0.03053525649011135, -0.014458660036325455, 0.053201574832201004, -0.020349131897091866, -0.005602980963885784, -0.04024333506822586, -0.00526534765958786, 0.00375504232943058, -0.026906631886959076, 0.10202740132808685, -0.038398902863264084, 0.019816815853118896, 0.002771055791527033, 0.00467217992991209, 0.0023809035774320364, 0.026376813650131226, 0.06465885043144226, -0.022900976240634918, -0.057711828500032425, -0.013202781789004803, -0.019669435918331146, 0.010169940069317818, -0.042258765548467636, -0.03290335461497307, 0.02179887145757675, -0.028991850093007088, -0.006645986344665289, 0.038791876286268234, 0.023782065138220787, 0.017086617648601532, -0.03983083367347717, 0.037959225475788116, -0.004549034405499697, 0.0027602682821452618, -0.04228895902633667, -0.0012534987181425095, 0.024845048785209656, 0.03294667229056358, 0.007908745668828487, 0.022674746811389923, -0.003515527117997408, 0.020991435274481773, -0.00046804617159068584, 0.019709458574652672, -0.03260570019483566, 0.0764259621500969, -0.0021481893490999937, -0.04122311994433403, 0.01735858805477619, -0.035395048558712006, -0.014860729686915874, 0.030741596594452858, 0.016165029257535934, -0.046514227986335754, 0.0117157232016325, -0.016249097883701324, 0.006986291613429785, 0.028361454606056213, 0.03263001888990402, 0.007112700957804918, -0.04755302146077156, 0.007618247997015715, 0.05718467757105827, -0.03053831309080124, 0.012872381135821342, -0.06139572709798813, -0.023416690528392792, -0.03236020356416702, 0.031100202351808548, -0.047542743384838104, -0.008399480022490025, 0.01595638319849968, 0.006330397911369801, 0.029071474447846413, -0.015058968216180801, 0.005502654705196619, -0.02884628064930439, 0.01965128816664219, 0.04711737111210823, 0.03936595469713211, -0.037287965416908264, 0.020528947934508324, -0.05048549920320511, -0.04293476417660713, 0.004152022302150726, 0.03271053358912468, -0.022881504148244858, -0.03027266636490822, 0.06251437216997147, -0.009019944816827774, -0.010648894123733044, 0.02023708075284958, -0.04490251839160919, 0.037662699818611145, 0.04267561063170433, -0.08178281784057617, -0.03336638584733009, 0.033602967858314514, 0.013110268861055374, 0.036095909774303436, -0.037242334336042404, -0.028867430984973907, -0.024454176425933838, 0.023233687505126, 0.01271824911236763, 0.047567568719387054, 0.010234873741865158, 0.04356389865279198, -0.03336886316537857, -0.06717907637357712, 0.0054389117285609245, -0.009898955002427101, -0.00322426063939929, -0.01436420064419508, -0.062027595937252045, 0.011125282384455204, 0.009163731709122658, -0.012467125430703163, -0.00785400252789259, 0.028990020975470543, 0.023702792823314667, 0.005999001208692789, 0.0028634017799049616, 0.013570030219852924, 0.012309250421822071, 0.04067381098866463, 0.0022565375547856092, 0.0045116133987903595, 0.02671707235276699, 0.009037725627422333, 0.052829306572675705, 0.005624931771308184, 0.03291167691349983, 0.04361836984753609, 0.0055143204517662525, -0.01174171268939972, 0.007653735112398863, 0.007365440018475056, 0.020873550325632095, 0.009490317665040493, -0.04456057772040367, -0.02908521331846714, 0.013419775292277336, 0.005815128795802593, 0.05351988598704338, -0.00397513946518302, -0.007649445906281471, 0.04650067910552025, -0.05255266651511192, -0.023609032854437828, -0.0498783215880394, -0.012710994109511375, -0.02498876489698887, 0.014096008613705635, 0.03585784137248993, -0.030776238068938255, -0.013657977804541588, -0.02289869636297226, -0.0020544552244246006, -0.03018065355718136, -0.0061776768416166306, 0.032290805131196976, -0.011671428568661213, -0.04293498024344444, 0.024552252143621445, -0.0311692226678133, -0.031137533485889435, 0.015063722617924213, -0.011857672594487667, -0.04438573122024536, -0.02567361667752266, -0.02019103616476059, 0.01895151659846306, -0.02694445103406906, -0.01626829244196415, 0.01876075752079487, 0.04943493381142616, -0.03764732554554939, -0.01844598539173603, -0.04397202655673027, 0.050400231033563614, 0.06824994832277298, -0.0029153020586818457, 0.02357444539666176, 0.0038565569557249546, -0.0064763338305056095, 0.019061045721173286, -0.025663303211331367, -0.02138754166662693, -0.061273008584976196, 0.026049211621284485, 0.05032273381948471, 0.011513832956552505, -0.023936677724123, 0.016254272311925888, 0.04801870137453079, 0.031841669231653214, -0.005866993684321642, 0.005168154835700989, -0.014568989165127277, 0.009174487553536892, 0.04524470865726471, 0.03430264815688133, 0.024521157145500183, 0.018719570711255074, 0.018556104972958565, 0.004499720875173807, 0.025982411578297615, -0.03313959017395973, 0.005666273180395365, 0.031031766906380653, 0.005331244319677353, 0.019484061747789383, 0.0006237010820768774, 0.016835974529385567, 0.03371791914105415, -0.011495279148221016, -0.018745116889476776, -0.0008541449205949903, 0.020860278978943825, -0.015659049153327942, 0.01697646453976631, -0.07524211704730988, 0.012796252965927124, 0.03967026621103287, -0.006611969321966171, 0.011031677015125751, 0.006027068942785263, -0.05510716140270233, 0.027197223156690598, -0.005756382364779711, -0.04001356661319733, -0.08327554911375046, -0.00002129900713043753, 0.05204099416732788, 0.006687015760689974, -0.02508470043540001, 0.006835389882326126, -0.0003389683261048049, 0.014001698233187199, 0.0023791026324033737, 0.014910644851624966, 0.03733797371387482, -0.046119436621665955, 0.020762454718351364, 0.013845018111169338, -0.00594444340094924, 0.027383042499423027, 0.0037448888178914785, -0.013307193294167519, 0.01902811788022518, 0.04649851843714714, -0.05997953191399574, 0.008120590820908546, -0.006197197828441858, 0.05168572813272476, -0.0275838915258646, -0.03344734013080597, 0.04121888428926468, -0.017480242997407913, -0.05210725590586662, 0.04228505492210388, -0.021493539214134216, 0.006279144436120987, -0.029356902465224266, -0.02123871073126793, 0.014830042608082294, -0.013649062253534794, -0.012073270976543427, 0.034177061170339584, 0.002725721336901188, 0.003926404286175966, -0.05401147902011871, -0.059682659804821014, 0.023970970883965492, -0.026101073250174522, 0.07437881827354431, 0.002455319743603468, -0.01286593172699213, 0.03048396110534668, 0.04058796912431717, -0.011929895728826523, -0.022721175104379654, 0.013479307293891907, -0.04871627315878868, 0.003315189154818654, 0.034827638417482376, 0.00459345942363143, 0.03674524649977684, -0.022530704736709595, 0.01212471816688776, 0.029922684654593468, 0.09804201871156693, 0.020198188722133636, -0.017219243571162224, -0.002791300183162093, 0.010042701847851276, 0.043420497328042984, 0.04544861987233162, 0.031899213790893555, -0.05818955972790718, 0.016704769805073738, -0.02724412828683853, -0.01567905582487583, 0.059818629175424576, -0.0313568115234375, -0.005607059691101313, -0.03260117396712303, -0.019225116819143295, -0.013675780035555363, 0.016058798879384995, -0.00235540559515357, -0.031297411769628525, 0.024463441222906113, 0.023276647552847862, 0.039815112948417664, -0.005642334930598736, -0.01865602470934391, 0.04997823014855385, 0.08003734797239304, -0.03738068789243698, -0.023005381226539612, -0.021910719573497772, -0.0015496835112571716, 0.01309155859053135, -0.03888554126024246, 0.017900297418236732, 0.02295892871916294, 0.022177234292030334, -0.008915640413761139, 0.0119996452704072, -0.046946629881858826, -0.014121015556156635, -0.0449635274708271, 0.03416791930794716, 0.0033353380858898163, 0.06150354444980621, -0.014424667693674564, -0.03140905871987343, 0.06306867301464081, 0.011077363044023514, 0.06417199224233627, 0.01173493918031454, -0.03884664922952652, 0.019945906475186348, -0.04258160665631294, 0.02744823880493641, -0.018370071426033974, -0.0034546833485364914, 0.007564888801425695, 0.02456873469054699, 0.021495619788765907, -0.03385080024600029, 0.01588277518749237, -0.05222834646701813, 0.00325861107558012, -0.026302261278033257, 0.028729775920510292, -0.01383228413760662, 0.04058877378702164, 0.044084686785936356, 0.003540092147886753, 0.05622218921780586, 0.03672770783305168, 0.009277128614485264, -0.026457449421286583, 0.01304814126342535, -0.011349273845553398, 0.017632456496357918, 0.019469769671559334, 0.010040352120995522, 0.03052748367190361, -0.018910545855760574, 0.006801445037126541, -0.02517077326774597, 0.00876939669251442, -0.030675576999783516, 0.0025640528183430433, -0.00884472019970417, -0.047037746757268906, -0.0028637798968702555, 0.013353557325899601, 0.032124314457178116, 0.03294140100479126, 0.026412563398480415, 0.007151286583393812, 0.03051898255944252, -0.05758267268538475, 0.005165112670511007, 0.0684010460972786, 0.002642220351845026, -0.01950986683368683, 0.0030079938005656004, -0.01364056020975113, 0.04349065572023392, -0.016702795401215553, 0.025360295549035072, 0.02127401903271675, -0.017142290249466896, 0.025976238772273064, 0.028103647753596306, -0.006812368519604206, -0.06807929277420044, 0.0017885706620290875, 0.010100062936544418, 0.023788325488567352, -0.005713277496397495, -0.01371694728732109, 0.0067571294493973255, 0.006669395137578249, 0.03901153802871704, 0.04369863495230675, -0.02751518413424492, -0.11089883744716644, -0.012455366551876068, 0.056288812309503555, 0.05769077315926552, -0.014880521222949028, -0.014887193217873573, -0.054902493953704834, -0.007648163940757513, 0.03444897383451462, -0.04311108589172363, 0.01835842989385128, 0.009086673147976398, -0.004063984379172325, -0.031488820910453796, -0.005532149225473404, -0.023305896669626236, 0.00824735313653946, -0.029391655698418617, 0.07220764458179474, -0.028006447479128838, -0.03689391165971756, -0.05062291398644447, 0.0075194076634943485, 0.008706762455403805, 0.05852951109409332, 0.007272382266819477, 0.02035635896027088, 0.009904311038553715, 0.00909449253231287, -0.054097142070531845, -0.04735371097922325, 0.019411738961935043, 0.028429416939616203, -0.005865807179361582, 0.050233393907547, -0.005223765503615141, -0.03642675653100014, 0.006975939497351646, -0.010712772607803345, -0.02575034834444523, -0.01773695833981037, -0.03347675874829292, 0.01347891055047512, 0.025450780987739563, -0.009742768481373787, 0.012603512033820152, 0.03681444749236107, 0.0005357092595659196, 0.04008544236421585, -0.026287542656064034, -0.0063076382502913475, -0.029743772000074387, 0.01114940270781517, 0.012716739438474178, -0.0069203125312924385, -0.033588822931051254, 0.02186802215874195, -0.04693662375211716, 0.014453555457293987, -0.014280586503446102, 0.02118823677301407, -0.0047254119999706745, 0.02879459783434868, 0.008527092635631561, 0.030407456681132317, -0.02223072573542595, -0.0026266591157764196, -0.004391333553940058, -0.0031705719884485006, 0.03891654685139656, -0.04168999195098877, -0.024063177406787872, -0.0005915945512242615, 0.006370935123413801, 0.020485900342464447, -0.06036171689629555, -0.004242694471031427, 0.014216933399438858, 0.0029041313100606203, 0.07439727336168289, 0.020011186599731445, 0.01878838799893856, 0.05782981216907501, -0.026977816596627235, -0.02963351644575596, 0.008508674800395966, 0.007485652808099985, 0.054484326392412186, -0.022183630615472794, 0.021962735801935196, -0.012626925483345985, 0.009674879722297192, -0.07409542053937912, -0.077138252556324, 0.046913519501686096, 0.006361126434057951, -0.0810115784406662, -0.07531020790338516, 0.023282712325453758, -0.02194785512983799, -0.008574720472097397, -0.028989167883992195, 0.04746406525373459, -0.011844666674733162, -0.017891963943839073, 0.01766892522573471, 0.016715016216039658, 0.075862817466259, 0.0065051596611738205, 0.03697006404399872, 0.04033283144235611, 0.029104704037308693, -0.04100026190280914, -0.00560599472373724, 0.028387440368533134, -0.024574730545282364, -0.013365632854402065, -0.043820712715387344, 0.027555381879210472, 0.021880272775888443, -0.03661170229315758, 0.04082236438989639, 0.003693832317367196, 0.03886200115084648, 0.010754410177469254, -0.047184184193611145, 0.008355042897164822, -0.009392732754349709, -0.024379147216677666, -0.0592058002948761, 0.022121543064713478, 0.010847607627511024, -0.008049912750720978, 0.007603657431900501, -0.005369284655898809, 0.005199343431740999, 0.025823311880230904, 0.031162504106760025, -0.030044887214899063, 0.027310935780405998, 0.03962540626525879, -0.03004680760204792, 0.03210599347949028, -0.019113929942250252, -0.002294001867994666, 0.009299419820308685, 0.035309143364429474, -0.06421799957752228, -0.01079493947327137, 0.02281234785914421, 0.018450014293193817, 0.06036490574479103, 0.006103109568357468, 0.03804055601358414, 0.0742361843585968, 0.022901862859725952, 0.010486182756721973, -0.030155610293149948, -0.012129837647080421, 0.022308163344860077, -0.00843583419919014, 0.0037849422078579664, -0.033648740500211716, 0.013878783211112022, -0.00846974179148674, 0.0029045187402516603, -0.005872937384992838, 0.04965804144740105, 0.019582927227020264, 0.032438330352306366, 0.012076625600457191, -0.051272980868816376, -0.05347679182887077, 0.003937731962651014, -0.028561195358633995, 0.037921275943517685, -0.014877391047775745, -0.014297839254140854, 0.033305227756500244, 0.027297433465719223, -0.0029804829973727465, -0.023349205031991005, -0.005383004434406757, -0.08709437400102615, 0.030711723491549492, 0.006173404864966869, -0.017181940376758575, -0.001277813222259283, 0.033841636031866074, 0.026173928752541542, 0.013391516171395779, 0.013657812029123306, -0.006534353829920292, -0.07541216909885406, -0.011260570026934147, 0.0006632989970967174, -0.07596379518508911, 0.026255300268530846, -0.019742337986826897, -0.0535859614610672, 0.011911144480109215, -0.029013238847255707, 0.0018640041816979647, 0.017129097133874893, 0.06518842279911041, -0.01719578728079796, 0.07126433402299881, -0.0037075509317219257, 0.03769112005829811, -0.009166176430881023, 0.007969353348016739, 0.10436376929283142, 0.0808953046798706, 0.01136555802077055, -0.07045596837997437, 0.025216594338417053, 0.0033065257593989372, 0.017285097390413284, -0.04703912511467934, 0.03378688171505928, 0.014807602390646935, 0.027426449581980705, 0.05784036964178085, 0.009177717380225658, 0.007735443767160177, -0.02568785473704338, 0.061342377215623856, -0.014490955509245396, -0.06649725884199142, -0.02644873596727848, -0.017628416419029236, -0.026374835520982742, -0.011315715499222279, -0.10015689581632614, 0.01898140087723732, -0.026609007269144058, 0.012125926092267036, -0.01508695725351572, -0.05907760187983513, 0.020801689475774765, 0.006291471421718597, -0.026645120233297348, 0.002965631429105997, -0.01277791615575552, -0.005550134927034378, -0.017824243754148483, 0.007618858944624662, -0.010541633702814579, -0.02698018215596676, 0.033681485801935196, 0.012299295514822006, 0.031072232872247696, -0.03976821154356003, -0.0016939520137384534, 0.007244808599352837, -0.03083554096519947, -0.027852915227413177, -0.04565582796931267, 0.06150445342063904, 0.013524342328310013, 0.05371259152889252, 0.007077810354530811, 0.017681816592812538, -0.019889017567038536, -0.03924313932657242, -0.01484773587435484, 0.010982895269989967, 0.05359228327870369, -0.004596117418259382, -0.01443492155522108, -0.06808071583509445, 0.044100575149059296, 0.0010051399003714323, 0.011408223770558834, 0.02299370989203453, 0.013741419650614262, -0.0226989034563303, -0.04108040779829025, 0.05255509540438652, -0.010878633707761765, -0.004988678265362978, 0.0009772939374670386, -0.013199898414313793, -0.00359276938252151, 0.006217771675437689, -0.006030078046023846, -0.014307587407529354, 0.0365387499332428, -0.0021872236393392086, -0.009289815090596676, 0.010960327461361885, 0.012981650419533253, -0.02149794064462185, -0.020113980397582054, -0.030264468863606453, -0.003585294121876359, 0.0150453494861722, 0.042887575924396515, 0.03598391264677048, 0.02474311739206314, 0.003923038020730019, -0.022205382585525513, -0.011058335192501545, 0.030440665781497955, -0.03586124628782272, -0.004835990723222494, -0.03653491288423538, 0.001874419511295855, -0.009382547810673714, -0.01430418249219656, 0.06781107187271118, 0.006390944588929415, -0.025318041443824768, 0.03173980116844177, 0.004579510074108839, -0.009349429979920387, -0.012031047604978085, -0.01116622518748045, -0.05159228667616844, -0.03453049436211586, -0.010388726368546486, -0.0036472128704190254, -0.0536225289106369, -0.039225295186042786, 0.029734624549746513, 0.028437655419111252, 0.0003392385842744261, -0.01787744276225567, 0.0029978002421557903, 0.030182847753167152, -0.029726020991802216, 0.07129216939210892, -0.02912691794335842, -0.004274249542504549, -0.022366704419255257, -0.020954597741365433, -0.0260027926415205, 0.005227988585829735, -0.0010738251730799675, 0.0006044289912097156, 0.0306303258985281, 0.019807953387498856, 0.038519758731126785, 0.01260112039744854, -0.0013922620564699173, -0.01866317354142666, 0.0024109836667776108, -0.023390157148241997, 0.03814833238720894, -0.0012569153914228082, -0.034705378115177155, 0.045303940773010254, -0.022398650646209717, -0.036929480731487274, 0.01392931118607521, 0.02067333459854126, 0.004891433287411928, -0.00039117044070735574, -0.004139096476137638, 0.001387291238643229, 0.06549100577831268, 0.012077664956450462, -0.021709155291318893, -0.011121070012450218, 0.021901335567235947, 0.023584574460983276, 0.03137413412332535, -0.0003555708099156618, 0.0072700260207057, -0.012450416572391987, -0.02137221209704876, 0.00973044615238905, -0.01656237244606018, -0.010052761062979698, -0.005874278489500284, 0.004147633910179138, 0.02266792394220829, -0.01003721822053194, -0.014723880216479301, 0.04294970631599426, 0.05157485231757164, -0.03360627591609955, -0.006311485078185797, -0.036121662706136703, -0.0025650227908045053, -0.011308664456009865, -0.0017844883259385824, 0.05187361314892769, -0.0163838230073452, 0.04992644861340523, -0.08424773812294006, -0.0037898956798017025, 0.04837482050061226, -0.035065095871686935, 0.014186134561896324, 0.04472612962126732, 0.004365471191704273, -0.0425141267478466, 0.00683777267113328, -0.0064336941577494144, 0.0267289150506258, 0.0298827663064003, 0.05135778710246086, 0.008789196610450745, 0.04529021680355072, -0.005041768774390221, -0.0036892378702759743, 0.027113784104585648, 0.004659680183976889, 0.03300735354423523, -0.03796184062957764, 0.020708151161670685, -0.05878353491425514, -0.019606804475188255, 0.004322736989706755, -0.030569564551115036, -0.011793989688158035, 0.041674189269542694, 0.022783692926168442, -0.03555573523044586, 0.05360594019293785, 0.027692949399352074, -0.011912280693650246, 0.016828563064336777, 0.007572740316390991, -0.014401805587112904, 0.05399496480822563, 0.01575191505253315, 0.009397739544510841, -0.04837499558925629, -0.05269481614232063, 0.024079587310552597, 0.0262161772698164, 0.0059212674386799335, -0.049320828169584274, -0.023930901661515236, -0.014832986518740654, -0.018890680745244026, -0.029795007780194283, -0.024397358298301697, -0.007264656946063042, 0.0004591584438458085, 0.042042624205350876, -0.016836468130350113, 0.002087377943098545, -0.012655102647840977, 0.0010053948499262333, -0.025930091738700867, 0.009945121593773365, -0.020867420360445976, -0.010179062373936176, -0.05311185121536255, -0.013636868447065353, 0.0006420773570425808, 0.010649456642568111, -0.0310978926718235, 0.026265962049365044, 0.008662193082273006, 0.04129209741950035, -0.013266995549201965, -0.030484890565276146, 0.05323588103055954, 0.029504654929041862, 0.017085116356611252, -0.04946403577923775, 0.04524768888950348, 0.03937820717692375, 0.002938795369118452, -0.026785168796777725, -0.008159274235367775, -0.043814048171043396, 0.022412847727537155, 0.044428128749132156, -0.02605140209197998, 0.003094244282692671, -0.002622022991999984, 0.02021578885614872, 0.020253369584679604, -0.05934743210673332, 0.02215469814836979, -0.039721522480249405, -0.01859784685075283, 0.0464881993830204, -0.024436838924884796, 0.008492461405694485, -0.006706832908093929, -0.035822972655296326, 0.009314342401921749, 0.007984207011759281, -0.020082343369722366, -0.01579776406288147, 0.002615378238260746, 0.005982627160847187, 0.020464740693569183, 0.043231330811977386, 0.004732285160571337, 0.0017367106629535556, 0.00790720246732235, -0.019797170534729958, -0.0064086029306054115, 0.05466651916503906, -0.04846944287419319, -0.05689684674143791, 0.01797710359096527, -0.027816670015454292, 0.00014148604532238096, -0.06425128132104874, -0.042342204600572586, 0.00024068741186056286, -0.00005142776353750378, 0.04527776315808296, 0.03370184823870659, -0.006383285392075777, 0.03558601066470146, 0.005849873181432486, 0.04144708812236786, 0.020182574167847633, 0.02713373862206936, -0.0010745064355432987, 0.017808938398957253, 0.004563161637634039, 0.005842830520123243, 0.010543976910412312, 0.009469380602240562, 0.02700948715209961, 0.03288942575454712, -0.02218310721218586, 0.021613765507936478, -0.0015551632968708873, 0.014912429265677929, 0.000057163611927535385, 0.02722473256289959, -0.006172914523631334, 0.06249365955591202, 0.02780986949801445, 0.02829594537615776, -0.040098242461681366, 0.010729450732469559, -0.0682854875922203, -0.04237747564911842, -0.04331193491816521, 0.027648312970995903, -0.01628214120864868, 0.008127443492412567, -0.02669609896838665, -0.005349131766706705, 0.009327765554189682, 0.030420832335948944, 0.04625257849693298, -0.0180344320833683, 0.032491374760866165, -0.03320625051856041, 0.0037624870892614126, 0.030233753845095634, -0.014836789108812809, -0.020720623433589935, -0.023813705891370773, -0.01172354631125927, 0.060741111636161804, 0.018066229298710823, 0.039731938391923904, -0.018181167542934418, -0.04312139004468918, 0.03952203691005707, -0.04957224428653717, -0.017718277871608734, -0.05111970379948616, 0.001260125427506864, -0.04390424117445946, -0.016890229657292366 ]
<p>I obtained data of typical time point in two conditions in this shape:</p> <pre><code>weight condition time 0.1307857 Transf 1 0.1926429 Transf 2 0.2734286 Transf 3 0.4403571 Transf 4 0.6037143 Transf 5 0.9036429 Transf 6 1.5454286 Transf 7 0.1370714 Unt 1 0.2005000 Unt 2 0.2973571 Unt 3 0.4592143 Unt 4 0.8336429 Unt 5 1.3099286 Unt 6 2.1470000 Unt 7 </code></pre> <p>I am using the package <code>nlme</code> in <code>R</code> to test the difference between the two conditions in time</p> <pre><code>fm1 &lt;- lme(weigth~condition,random=~1|time,data=data_new) anova.lme(fm1, adjustSigma = F) </code></pre> <p>I got this:</p> <pre><code>numDF denDF F-value p-value (Intercept) 1 6 8.421439 0.0273 condition 1 6 4.208786 0.0861 </code></pre> <p>Questions:</p> <ol> <li><p>Am I doing things correctly with this procedure to test the differences between the two conditions in time?</p></li> <li><p>If yes, which is my p-value, the intercept one or the condition?</p></li> <li><p>If this is not the proper test, what are the alternatives?</p></li> </ol>
74,307
[ -0.012294714339077473, -0.015320894308388233, -0.020860351622104645, -0.00016331351071130484, 0.014940617606043816, 0.010393012315034866, 0.020408812910318375, -0.02954879216849804, 0.039829764515161514, -0.009185976348817348, 0.05816221982240677, 0.049320414662361145, 0.057906847447156906, 0.024956561625003815, 0.04107584431767464, 0.0019349332433193922, 0.01179941464215517, -0.03127814084291458, -0.01624372787773609, -0.027271036058664322, -0.009223311208188534, 0.007415079977363348, -0.011183089576661587, -0.030386880040168762, -0.011453120037913322, 0.031266339123249054, 0.029994891956448555, -0.030794987455010414, 0.005744647234678268, 0.045731380581855774, -0.04916374385356903, -0.020762447267770767, 0.0020902585238218307, -0.0028534429147839546, -0.004523612558841705, 0.030681241303682327, -0.012293929234147072, -0.02334938757121563, -0.008625355549156666, 0.021827999502420425, -0.024810897186398506, -0.002945265034213662, 0.0029296809807419777, 0.020041488111019135, 0.021981151774525642, 0.030608758330345154, 0.05030620098114014, 0.016453035175800323, 0.06977641582489014, -0.04706214368343353, 0.022869326174259186, -0.03186362609267235, 0.030760260298848152, 0.003071562619879842, -0.048689477145671844, -0.03375951945781708, 0.032964058220386505, 0.060557860881090164, 0.00873167160898447, -0.05943840742111206, 0.0064056566916406155, -0.0314677357673645, 0.026843121275305748, -0.00041655657696537673, -0.03778288885951042, -0.019694041460752487, 0.006760078482329845, -0.01160015631467104, 0.05192413553595543, -0.028079800307750702, -0.013003802858293056, 0.021594299003481865, 0.04614963009953499, 0.004093701019883156, 0.018292509019374847, -0.02254325896501541, 0.020616641268134117, 0.011349065229296684, 0.06141921132802963, 0.03854009136557579, -0.03717256337404251, 0.025919033214449883, 0.013695674017071724, 0.05552039295434952, 0.0009487091447226703, -0.02512453868985176, 0.04958637058734894, -0.011402871459722519, 0.016463523730635643, 0.05020437389612198, -0.02495546266436577, 0.022159088402986526, 0.04411056265234947, 0.021427564322948456, 0.01348892506211996, 0.032205529510974884, -0.030787456780672073, 0.011013011448085308, -0.005691107828170061, -0.004564849194139242, -0.00006851559737697244, -0.06811804324388504, 0.037222933024168015, 0.03860459104180336, -0.011865098029375076, 0.005231993272900581, -0.033853281289339066, -0.014078861102461815, -0.009311867877840996, -0.023676209151744843, -0.0036732680164277554, 0.02047661878168583, -0.0343666672706604, -0.017873117700219154, 0.010140457190573215, -0.042997878044843674, -0.016421670094132423, 0.03325334191322327, 0.0842089056968689, 0.07036720961332321, 0.0575525239109993, -0.013558510690927505, 0.0001347026991425082, -0.016396675258874893, -0.048706382513046265, -0.010868605226278305, 0.032644983381032944, -0.00260691880248487, 0.005683858413249254, 0.05731840059161186, 0.0003269052249379456, -0.04458342492580414, 0.028773225843906403, -0.025311483070254326, 0.03271719068288803, 0.034102246165275574, -0.10897959768772125, -0.07170621305704117, 0.03456336632370949, -0.039204441010951996, 0.009242900647222996, -0.06218944489955902, -0.03242301568388939, 0.02765963412821293, 0.06206037476658821, 0.04076868295669556, 0.03756038472056389, 0.017565930262207985, 0.011633501388132572, 0.01387916598469019, -0.04647466540336609, -0.0006326530710794032, -0.015066894702613354, -0.00045022371341474354, -0.0016134538454934955, -0.06616130471229553, 0.00430002948269248, 0.013929206877946854, -0.013514197431504726, 0.0441751666367054, 0.05696479603648186, -0.023668304085731506, -0.01151286717504263, -0.008832443505525589, -0.007205632980912924, -0.0051903254352509975, 0.02956068329513073, -0.011365687474608421, 0.0328616239130497, 0.03797553479671478, 0.01915186084806919, 0.034532833844423294, -0.0333559513092041, 0.003751718671992421, 0.02876524068415165, -0.025896405801177025, 0.018206462264060974, 0.007032564375549555, -0.004292108118534088, -0.0017354829469695687, -0.03197631984949112, 0.0036124971229583025, -0.012956969439983368, -0.02024553157389164, 0.04738600552082062, 0.051870305091142654, -0.006704466883093119, 0.029585780575871468, 0.0801422968506813, -0.025812827050685883, -0.0428471565246582, -0.0477631613612175, -0.00769770797342062, -0.006729282904416323, -0.054058920592069626, 0.013241684064269066, 0.010482590645551682, 0.01696888916194439, 0.022623196244239807, -0.027369625866413116, -0.039388757199048996, 0.010873623192310333, 0.06297747790813446, -0.025060171261429787, 0.0010464192600920796, 0.02890138514339924, 0.06265655905008316, -0.029408060014247894, 0.0247507281601429, -0.04210710898041725, -0.00014958881365600973, 0.04486032575368881, -0.027041606605052948, -0.018141550943255424, 0.042451877146959305, -0.013531818985939026, 0.006210129242390394, -0.0054206037893891335, -0.009479779750108719, 0.06520518660545349, -0.03883131593465805, 0.05048740655183792, 0.08864321559667587, -0.01958250068128109, 0.04016057029366493, -0.00818038359284401, 0.0027911097276955843, 0.05662255361676216, -0.04134930670261383, 0.016635937616229057, -0.050704993307590485, -0.05831621214747429, 0.03596106171607971, -0.021594418212771416, -0.014073258265852928, 0.021864082664251328, 0.02768208645284176, -0.03601902350783348, 0.010891823098063469, 0.054715245962142944, 0.034424714744091034, -0.0684683620929718, 0.020479494705796242, 0.06081412360072136, 0.06221476197242737, 0.0056461370550096035, 0.03410119563341141, -0.0030459712725132704, 0.05709689110517502, -0.037939321249723434, 0.032938115298748016, 0.057663388550281525, -0.025904124602675438, -0.03946089372038841, -0.0027127941139042377, -0.015037001110613346, 0.02747398614883423, 0.007720029912889004, 0.0036906797904521227, 0.0401664674282074, -0.02308979071676731, -0.008859765715897083, -0.00008515506488038227, -0.010002325288951397, 0.01251254417002201, 0.02683870494365692, 0.009758753702044487, -0.038957733660936356, 0.0070223743095994, -0.041023243218660355, 0.01212309394031763, 0.003733632853254676, -0.026583613827824593, -0.044279731810092926, 0.008652463555335999, 0.024166906252503395, -0.00012337460066191852, -0.006807254161685705, -0.031012974679470062, -0.00010739947902038693, -0.0015569190727546811, -0.02188904397189617, 0.02929086610674858, -0.004850075580179691, -0.03878182917833328, 0.005723321810364723, -0.012347315438091755, 0.011340590193867683, 0.043194834142923355, -0.0019707842729985714, -0.019936678931117058, 0.030223874375224113, 0.025368398055434227, -0.0006278571672737598, -0.05550766736268997, -0.025579875335097313, 0.022580692544579506, 0.013297418132424355, -0.025791743770241737, 0.07128807157278061, 0.021396655589342117, -0.020712418481707573, 0.017503414303064346, -0.046439941972494125, -0.005033946130424738, 0.0067786951549351215, -0.005868814419955015, 0.0059134322218596935, 0.011619445867836475, 0.02352938801050186, 0.023282574489712715, -0.035656824707984924, -0.0016708734910935163, -0.0747104287147522, -0.028397684916853905, 0.008484547957777977, 0.0036007598973810673, 0.020201455801725388, 0.0003428676282055676, -0.02809765748679638, 0.0648176521062851, 0.054471246898174286, -0.0479198582470417, -0.048612892627716064, -0.012729693204164505, -0.04769913852214813, -0.006122494116425514, 0.00905892439186573, -0.014699344523251057, 0.0006363258580677211, 0.03289651870727539, 0.018307330086827278, 0.022429829463362694, 0.04074961319565773, 0.019946128129959106, 0.019739342853426933, -0.015714548528194427, -0.005776473321020603, -0.047962382435798645, 0.05378437042236328, 0.03825734555721283, 0.020009756088256836, 0.010734571143984795, 0.004210820887237787, -0.002139320829883218, 0.0031228098087012768, -0.054217346012592316, 0.009031426161527634, -0.01011057198047638, 0.039967890828847885, -0.04943155497312546, 0.0400141179561615, -0.011316769756376743, -0.017233088612556458, -0.03432217985391617, 0.002589350799098611, 0.026623129844665527, -0.02166605554521084, 0.004693143535405397, 0.056865837424993515, 0.03584835305809975, 0.0039546857587993145, -0.0001257913827430457, -0.023296751081943512, -0.02521922066807747, 0.030996697023510933, -0.06961216777563095, -0.0046812244690954685, 0.06763502210378647, 0.04457186907529831, 0.05154845118522644, -0.004525195807218552, -0.01764717884361744, -0.0019150198204442859, -0.08342530578374863, 0.010463201440870762, 0.010792176239192486, 0.0715799629688263, 0.03299589082598686, 0.050889451056718826, 0.026192517951130867, 0.004672594368457794, 0.014009307138621807, -0.049727730453014374, -0.06610450148582458, 0.04920193552970886, 0.011085854843258858, -0.012568043544888496, 0.024302639067173004, -0.0034083647187799215, 0.00904738251119852, -0.04106992855668068, 0.035933755338191986, 0.023103682324290276, 0.013786863535642624, 0.000712263339664787, 0.010503794066607952, -0.03710277006030083, 0.0049182153306901455, -0.0188475102186203, 0.02066894620656967, 0.04791095852851868, -0.012002605944871902, 0.029475493356585503, 0.05820967257022858, -0.012753226794302464, 0.001771500101312995, -0.022325150668621063, 0.011181599460542202, 0.011891440488398075, 0.050326649099588394, 0.03705717623233795, 0.012851056642830372, -0.03159834444522858, 0.07455478608608246, 0.047795381397008896, 0.0029723383486270905, 0.024669580161571503, -0.013036578893661499, -0.014282390475273132, -0.0271255224943161, -0.017276916652917862, -0.019833862781524658, -0.006206493359059095, 0.018282262608408928, -0.03309190273284912, 0.019861623644828796, 0.00725385220721364, -0.017031965777277946, 0.049251943826675415, 0.04290663078427315, -0.004542252980172634, 0.02759500779211521, -0.0473133884370327, -0.0066630179062485695, -0.030024578794836998, -0.01933242380619049, 0.04381483420729637, 0.03386937081813812, 0.008524595759809017, 0.00983540341258049, 0.014920764602720737, 0.0004910501884296536, -0.0006505391211248934, -0.0001534242765046656, 0.04704922065138817, 0.022337403148412704, -0.0014844064135104418, -0.03917988762259483, 0.02870006486773491, 0.017619190737605095, 0.031296972185373306, 0.0004886111710220575, 0.001848093350417912, -0.09257485717535019, 0.00785921886563301, 0.041621558368206024, 0.06707730144262314, -0.02350432425737381, -0.003267717082053423, -0.013234873302280903, -0.007570648565888405, 0.02990882471203804, -0.04055071994662285, 0.05607488378882408, -0.009056109003722668, -0.0006278508226387203, -0.03217868134379387, -0.031035732477903366, -0.047622520476579666, 0.005754048004746437, 0.0015706203412264585, 0.01498204655945301, -0.013449075631797314, -0.06296094506978989, 0.01228456199169159, 0.0023068441078066826, 0.018971499055624008, 0.0021519570145756006, -0.06147855147719383, -0.012271651066839695, 0.027120327576994896, 0.017792848870158195, -0.04068809747695923, -0.052421148866415024, 0.010692951269447803, -0.001989538548514247, 0.014203180558979511, 0.036635927855968475, -0.017500782385468483, -0.033566202968358994, 0.020454229786992073, 0.0057402863167226315, -0.013184229843318462, -0.014676311984658241, -0.025877252221107483, 0.04583703726530075, 0.01549939438700676, -0.006234943866729736, 0.034506797790527344, 0.02130957506597042, 0.022185692563652992, 0.0027993028052151203, -0.051051605492830276, -0.009722676128149033, -0.021567517891526222, 0.015190440230071545, -0.03409295901656151, -0.010274525731801987, 0.009920647367835045, 0.03202342987060547, 0.006724495906382799, 0.041132569313049316, -0.02287513203918934, 0.000423587451223284, 0.03276664763689041, 0.020988885313272476, -0.004632816184312105, -0.02480926737189293, 0.026111625134944916, -0.010295459069311619, -0.018414385616779327, -0.0022590593434870243, -0.012658791616559029, -0.016169462352991104, -0.012638218700885773, 0.010884610936045647, -0.028723588213324547, 0.014347688294947147, -0.015496968291699886, -0.04819193482398987, -0.00020574934023898095, -0.011772941797971725, 0.017990998923778534, 0.03204640746116638, 0.02568388730287552, 0.01092617493122816, -0.05940255895256996, 0.014726987108588219, 0.031826477497816086, 0.013490124605596066, 0.017047226428985596, -0.045519910752773285, 0.045913830399513245, 0.0325237438082695, -0.031626731157302856, -0.07285577803850174, -0.03853429853916168, -0.002276904648169875, -0.009114695712924004, -0.023674342781305313, -0.016158945858478546, -0.042205289006233215, -0.02268059179186821, -0.0006622395012527704, -0.03278140723705292, 0.04918089136481285, -0.00959310308098793, -0.016381194815039635, 0.01662205159664154, 0.040455080568790436, 0.06040310859680176, 0.019212756305933, 0.013239008374512196, 0.006102416664361954, -0.03111211769282818, -0.04398225247859955, 0.025347260758280754, -0.00561152957379818, -0.034499987959861755, -0.007925386540591717, -0.010407867841422558, -0.019969811663031578, 0.03841552510857582, 0.019166667014360428, -0.006821849383413792, 0.012596242129802704, -0.026115087792277336, -0.005852844566106796, -0.041759002953767776, 0.006976487580686808, -0.035810329020023346, 0.011592468246817589, -0.01683305948972702, 0.022094156593084335, 0.020657416433095932, 0.008789103478193283, 0.054809313267469406, -0.039413660764694214, -0.05315585434436798, 0.0017546660965308547, 0.08917628228664398, -0.03015097975730896, 0.0002673195267561823, -0.009429842233657837, -0.016252469271421432, 0.00043104044743813574, 0.01756126433610916, -0.03330526873469353, 0.0015918310964480042, 0.01795765571296215, -0.04043551906943321, -0.009368125349283218, -0.029584204778075218, 0.01159428060054779, 0.05094178393483162, -0.01769859716296196, 0.06422418355941772, 0.07621204107999802, 0.020463893190026283, 0.002848999807611108, -0.027944961562752724, -0.019948868080973625, -0.01371150091290474, 0.01075481902807951, 0.0618927963078022, 0.01716764084994793, -0.006666711997240782, 0.06320010870695114, 0.009554162621498108, 0.008052507415413857, 0.03111090697348118, 0.006730180699378252, 0.0021277894265949726, 0.02806035988032818, -0.0052048698998987675, -0.02344050630927086, 0.023977741599082947, -0.03309882432222366, 0.04481041803956032, -0.0696057453751564, -0.025320718064904213, 0.023623639717698097, 0.07079599052667618, -0.0014977854443714023, -0.08254130184650421, -0.002158842282369733, -0.055205509066581726, -0.008577416650950909, 0.013657607138156891, -0.042308904230594635, 0.017910201102495193, 0.028159910812973976, 0.05015105754137039, -0.01328573003411293, 0.016396675258874893, -0.038578297942876816, -0.06079951301217079, -0.03974263370037079, -0.006360130850225687, -0.02301998995244503, 0.03239458054304123, -0.038341693580150604, 0.003159382613375783, 0.033577535301446915, -0.034851305186748505, -0.02289762906730175, -0.010899262502789497, 0.03714292496442795, -0.007089809514582157, 0.05692322552204132, -0.0158250592648983, 0.016321146860718727, -0.010409733280539513, 0.00617167167365551, 0.1147276759147644, 0.05857154354453087, 0.06900645047426224, -0.05260251462459564, 0.027139438316226006, 0.010842357762157917, 0.00357626099139452, 0.001548446249216795, -0.0016947187250480056, -0.024025365710258484, -0.0023240731097757816, 0.05309337377548218, 0.025064438581466675, 0.019255002960562706, -0.009484758600592613, 0.0297196377068758, -0.0548323430120945, -0.00923314318060875, -0.007240981329232454, -0.004855712875723839, -0.01239811908453703, -0.04274478554725647, -0.017230724915862083, 0.04604971781373024, 0.011608732864260674, 0.01452458743005991, -0.005501452833414078, -0.046933386474847794, 0.022579781711101532, -0.016487089917063713, -0.005958865862339735, 0.04094484820961952, -0.00399386091157794, 0.013700372539460659, -0.031573936343193054, 0.020483849570155144, 0.009416066110134125, -0.05517910048365593, 0.03304256871342659, 0.03186746686697006, 0.010395481251180172, -0.03622933849692345, -0.02514212392270565, 0.01400762889534235, -0.026514066383242607, 0.003085946897044778, -0.021703975275158882, 0.049888912588357925, 0.001611156389117241, -0.035052742809057236, 0.019016621634364128, 0.004845971707254648, 0.026276864111423492, -0.04326014965772629, -0.03999868035316467, 0.002494773594662547, 0.026891466230154037, -0.0011922481935471296, 0.02560470625758171, -0.05222195386886597, -0.0026942070107907057, 0.022565877065062523, 0.021526336669921875, 0.025520550087094307, -0.00802950095385313, 0.03399408608675003, -0.02847490832209587, 0.02999350242316723, 0.0036567056085914373, 0.030474064871668816, -0.0053768642246723175, -0.014177546836435795, -0.009617296047508717, -0.011909243650734425, -0.0005809844005852938, -0.005065917037427425, 0.016675712540745735, -0.016388440504670143, -0.021960871294140816, -0.05695505067706108, -0.07047515362501144, 0.00427622627466917, -0.017113108187913895, -0.0040808180347085, -0.034638017416000366, -0.019109588116407394, 0.02103603631258011, 0.015140964649617672, 0.0034010792151093483, -0.004879454150795937, -0.013156816363334656, 0.06316642463207245, 0.00023470607993658632, -0.05940638482570648, -0.046036429703235626, 0.041086722165346146, 0.03897623345255852, 0.0018711484735831618, -0.043617114424705505, 0.09733549505472183, 0.020817534998059273, -0.019108276814222336, -0.009266558103263378, 0.008570859208703041, -0.02473863959312439, -0.01346536260098219, 0.002291414886713028, -0.029964538291096687, 0.005295161157846451, -0.010109702125191689, -0.00193606351967901, -0.020320884883403778, -0.041145142167806625, -0.05807982757687569, -0.06466224789619446, -0.008882937952876091, -0.028366750106215477, -0.01772402971982956, 0.029552573338150978, 0.018003886565566063, -0.028753861784934998, -0.03044835850596428, 0.01627701334655285, -0.042974215000867844, -0.0269864983856678, -0.0031916971784085035, -0.024162357673048973, -0.012365731410682201, 0.016766736283898354, -0.03011625073850155, -0.018715832382440567, 0.02602720819413662, 0.020754260942339897, 0.02515050396323204, -0.00606746319681406, 0.002779694739729166, 0.025768538936972618, 0.04861462861299515, 0.03303327411413193, -0.006977566983550787, 0.02161874808371067, -0.04442447051405907, -0.018324848264455795, 0.028334829956293106, 0.015849921852350235, 0.022088509052991867, -0.02541937865316868, 0.020387228578329086, 0.0035008066333830357, 0.02123468741774559, -0.016519714146852493, -0.003517663571983576, -0.0016705425223335624, -0.05237899348139763, -0.013285038061439991, -0.024341246113181114, 0.007603615988045931, 0.006229312624782324, -0.023409441113471985, 0.03533928841352463, 0.05220901593565941, -0.005758873652666807, -0.023301947861909866, -0.02046419121325016, -0.017838329076766968, 0.016523193567991257, 0.008732377551496029, -0.016507809981703758, 0.02564046159386635, 0.042894382029771805, -0.024880800396203995, 0.0005424281698651612, -0.08075364679098129, 0.003802164224907756, -0.0936124324798584, -0.02306850254535675, 0.022721976041793823, 0.019036952406167984, 0.03672642260789871, -0.045315176248550415, 0.02081836573779583, 0.023699341341853142, -0.009802212938666344, 0.027561599388718605, 0.008222687058150768, 0.026387376710772514, -0.021352320909500122, 0.018197014927864075, -0.024148643016815186, 0.009974665939807892, 0.013240131549537182, -0.006263092625886202, 0.033907584846019745, 0.004514854401350021, 0.018875330686569214, -0.023343859240412712, 0.011497711762785912, -0.0027703149244189262, 0.03801034390926361, -0.0989842414855957, -0.002069332869723439, -0.025346778333187103, -0.017214873805642128, 0.0049851881340146065, -0.034689564257860184, 0.02666603773832321, 0.008522764779627323, 0.012413384392857552, 0.00870763510465622, 0.027257628738880157, 0.008130754344165325, 0.0060571772046387196, -0.016256703063845634, -0.0024825548753142357, -0.006118618883192539, -0.010411846451461315, -0.01680697128176689, 0.015257375314831734, -0.034890592098236084, -0.011508234776556492, -0.027852429077029228, 0.005654304288327694, -0.0229342021048069, -0.008690453134477139, -0.009249468334019184, -0.002860537962988019, -0.008633988909423351, -0.011641422286629677, -0.021875936537981033, -0.013489472679793835, 0.01673097163438797, 0.020096497610211372, 0.02745591662824154, -0.029681548476219177, 0.04294271394610405, -0.01898696832358837, -0.037412986159324646, 0.020632367581129074, -0.0024599607568234205, -0.02521650679409504, -0.0259371530264616, 0.006390814669430256, -0.012291297316551208, -0.005938011687248945, -0.04897210747003555, 0.013730378821492195, -0.05012911558151245, 0.003795729950070381, -0.020124396309256554, -0.020886249840259552, -0.004840972367674112, 0.0036338663194328547, 0.03802001476287842, -0.11053197085857391, 0.04130340367555618, -0.016445454210042953, -0.01708291657269001, -0.040614236146211624, 0.017141714692115784, -0.08146820962429047, 0.03710135444998741, 0.042143143713474274, 0.025077786296606064, -0.0003343242860864848, -0.009425572119653225, 0.028548119589686394, -0.011663831770420074, -0.041020411998033524, 0.05594836547970772, -0.021836714819073677, 0.003780021797865629, 0.027279652655124664, -0.03160226717591286, 0.04315033555030823, 0.014183067716658115, 0.016720963642001152, -0.02651045471429825, 0.0013604017440229654, -0.0036479427944868803, -0.009751482866704464, -0.009232800453901291, -0.04163264483213425, -0.00615654606372118, 0.02556428872048855, -0.025546763092279434, 0.031336430460214615, 0.014720503240823746, -0.009188154712319374, -0.04548357427120209, 0.07384955883026123, -0.03486480563879013, 0.010416259057819843, 0.015321574173867702, -0.03950955718755722, -0.004929538816213608, -0.07746051251888275, -0.016891594976186752, -0.017830301076173782, 0.0025679718237370253, -0.037395525723695755, -0.017628777772188187, 0.03585150092840195, 0.036800727248191833, -0.01863233558833599, 0.022693542763590813, -0.013281842693686485, -0.007595987990498543, 0.011526823043823242, -0.003913805354386568, 0.035267848521471024, -0.013685515150427818, -0.010035689920186996, 0.02960829809308052, -0.032034385949373245, 0.019533637911081314, -0.006451285444200039, 0.05950860306620598, 0.03396688774228096, -0.03583837300539017, 0.032159268856048584, 0.0071205999702215195, 0.0025830792728811502, 0.007351927924901247, -0.003950800281018019, 0.01371006853878498, -0.05966702476143837, 0.035959772765636444, -0.017474478110671043, -0.0076774354092776775, -0.0476776622235775, -0.010227839462459087, 0.044846657663583755, 0.027515625581145287, 0.010812938213348389, 0.007446300704032183, -0.005059544928371906, -0.03456282615661621, 0.0065268720500171185, -0.024471692740917206, -0.004109149798750877, -0.02032821998000145, -0.02725028805434704, -0.010468395426869392, -0.022416967898607254, -0.02240963652729988, -0.027460066601634026, -0.00275535904802382, 0.004426405765116215, 0.04300326108932495, -0.05678088217973709, -0.013863171450793743, 0.02242310158908367, 0.05941612645983696, -0.02831451967358589, -0.011710047721862793, -0.020963015034794807, 0.01920166239142418, 0.019964925944805145, -0.024971576407551765 ]
<p>I have four samples $x_1, x_2$ and $y_1, y_2$ with $n_{x1} \neq n_{x2} \neq n_{y1} \neq n_{y2} $. I calculated, using a Wilcoxon rank sum test, that $x_1$ is significantly different to $x_2$ and $y_1$ significantly different to $y_2$. </p> <p>However, I would like to test whether the difference $x_1 - x_2$ differs significantly to $y_1 - y_2$ but I have no idea how do to that given the unequal sample sizes.</p> <p>Any ideas or suggestions would be really appreciated. </p>
74,308
[ -0.03437136113643646, -0.010135670192539692, -0.017037592828273773, 0.02848215401172638, 0.03887610137462616, 0.0352974571287632, 0.023159174248576164, -0.014420464634895325, 0.03563402593135834, -0.03236151486635208, 0.03918619453907013, 0.04417718946933746, 0.06415335088968277, 0.0033480399288237095, 0.013810328207910061, -0.015590145252645016, -0.028296425938606262, 0.009676854126155376, 0.01633525639772415, -0.030919428914785385, 0.01230308972299099, 0.01834246702492237, 0.03237559646368027, -0.016945822164416313, -0.04518469050526619, 0.030515898019075394, 0.016994047909975052, -0.04384905844926834, -0.0020181939471513033, 0.059828922152519226, -0.03831447660923004, -0.014879233203828335, 0.003114331979304552, 0.06595917791128159, 0.013091464526951313, -0.0004449532425496727, -0.013665670529007912, -0.04146223142743111, 0.019669221714138985, 0.036282215267419815, -0.031865380704402924, -0.02963939495384693, -0.013384138233959675, 0.016662638634443283, -0.014247438870370388, 0.016615845263004303, 0.0215141698718071, -0.048076264560222626, 0.020583102479577065, -0.059325266629457474, 0.057501088827848434, 0.007770587224513292, 0.03688487038016319, 0.03527320921421051, -0.029881935566663742, -0.013366484083235264, 0.011579519137740135, 0.06815041601657867, -0.025293519720435143, -0.009504517540335655, -0.033870767802000046, -0.02775305137038231, 0.013927346095442772, -0.0424455963075161, -0.07689177989959717, 0.044087763875722885, -0.008623016066849232, -0.03435147553682327, 0.020412294194102287, -0.023714210838079453, 0.009740065783262253, 0.03846849873661995, 0.027574261650443077, -0.007133773528039455, -0.003083303337916732, -0.00955719780176878, 0.01967061124742031, 0.02069051004946232, 0.02060209959745407, 0.036735955625772476, -0.015394859947264194, 0.0052932691760361195, 0.02570839785039425, 0.032023414969444275, 0.0073996190913021564, -0.013835073448717594, 0.026062022894620895, -0.012145331129431725, 0.008561952970921993, 0.052800994366407394, 0.002431501867249608, -0.02245735377073288, 0.06763651221990585, 0.0012513443361967802, -0.027341680601239204, -0.032704420387744904, -0.038956642150878906, 0.024801380932331085, -0.007534193340688944, -0.002168367151170969, -0.009470900520682335, -0.041388094425201416, 0.04361242428421974, 0.038469135761260986, -0.0050008236430585384, -0.012053393758833408, -0.01234345231205225, 0.03950481861829758, -0.0021759257651865482, -0.013456635177135468, -0.009697123430669308, 0.038652461022138596, 0.002629307098686695, -0.04159291461110115, 0.05086788907647133, 0.01397563237696886, -0.0344996340572834, -0.024518055841326714, 0.030026540160179138, 0.06275735050439835, 0.05907423794269562, -0.006561963818967342, 0.01564197801053524, -0.04263865202665329, -0.022562524303793907, -0.0007405193173326552, 0.01843603514134884, 0.00024030667555052787, -0.01734154298901558, 0.04958023503422737, -0.016722053289413452, 0.02460787445306778, 0.00910985004156828, -0.038082756102085114, 0.043937042355537415, 0.02893768809735775, -0.08467907458543777, -0.046487677842378616, 0.053186409175395966, -0.024302467703819275, -0.012950723059475422, -0.06820056587457657, 0.0025805362965911627, 0.02991386502981186, 0.03882056847214699, -0.007028684485703707, 0.02615358494222164, 0.00635348167270422, 0.01182204857468605, 0.049168799072504044, -0.009562388062477112, -0.004480982664972544, -0.04045761749148369, -0.0017269698437303305, -0.019890196621418, -0.053389083594083786, 0.013094308786094189, 0.04274841398000717, -0.012218078598380089, -0.007155115716159344, 0.037731993943452835, 0.05486614629626274, 0.001968311844393611, -0.010039600543677807, 0.06423599272966385, 0.005134952254593372, 0.0780327320098877, -0.00584305077791214, -0.023484140634536743, 0.008705154992640018, -0.009674270637333393, 0.04564957693219185, 0.026723703369498253, 0.03990308567881584, 0.07110821455717087, -0.013617418706417084, 0.003782750805839896, -0.026846667751669884, 0.005132688675075769, -0.012474381364881992, -0.02495354786515236, -0.006096252705901861, -0.03842424973845482, 0.0014809374697506428, 0.014498976059257984, 0.028280386701226234, -0.0003696319181472063, -0.032358117401599884, 0.05784280225634575, -0.023465080186724663, -0.042224302887916565, -0.0682065561413765, 0.012851263396441936, 0.048439789563417435, -0.06116262823343277, 0.039016399532556534, 0.018794972449541092, 0.022921398282051086, -0.02004404366016388, -0.023300066590309143, 0.00035660769208334386, 0.009012242779135704, 0.04860062524676323, -0.022683680057525635, -0.006047551054507494, 0.04253120720386505, 0.06959837675094604, -0.01679171435534954, 0.05287937819957733, -0.03834560140967369, -0.04184402897953987, 0.030382178723812103, -0.03708609566092491, 0.013664442114531994, -0.0006394344964064658, 0.004813625942915678, 0.004929868038743734, 0.006848116405308247, 0.004020338412374258, 0.05854780599474907, -0.05837864801287651, 0.079646997153759, 0.037020038813352585, -0.011021995916962624, 0.004233136307448149, -0.03264931961894035, 0.03519294783473015, -0.004055768251419067, -0.03678420931100845, 0.0022630251478403807, -0.060314927250146866, -0.004867919720709324, 0.04012361913919449, -0.011078516021370888, -0.06192047894001007, 0.0033156462013721466, 0.0910215750336647, 0.02209257334470749, 0.004423127975314856, 0.028426388278603554, 0.005398332141339779, -0.029974834993481636, -0.014906800352036953, 0.029023276641964912, 0.008279195055365562, 0.0017725316574797034, 0.028379248455166817, 0.00960518978536129, 0.050039660185575485, -0.006149796769022942, -0.023278873413801193, 0.03187655657529831, 0.002901586005464196, 0.020972223952412605, -0.023258058354258537, -0.027436895295977592, 0.06007739529013634, 0.0025612302124500275, -0.0047889514826238155, 0.07392998039722443, 0.008955775760114193, 0.007352874614298344, 0.004729375708848238, -0.015461067669093609, 0.05141578987240791, 0.009193425998091698, -0.03654864430427551, 0.03428879380226135, 0.017648393288254738, -0.04394400864839554, -0.003654331900179386, -0.03448185324668884, -0.04510195925831795, -0.03077828139066696, -0.010561617091298103, 0.035156067460775375, 0.02047097124159336, 0.014701459556818008, -0.016455842182040215, -0.02073487639427185, -0.016028622165322304, -0.021373579278588295, -0.014613228850066662, -0.011568370275199413, -0.05767261981964111, 0.023891370743513107, -0.019321605563163757, -0.0061768717132508755, 0.00649681780487299, 0.014667721465229988, -0.007165072485804558, 0.03832712769508362, -0.0027835716027766466, -0.05078272148966789, 0.00027564275660552084, -0.04488543048501015, 0.012921254150569439, -0.04329255223274231, -0.03916265442967415, 0.05409456416964531, -0.01272482518106699, -0.057300202548503876, 0.017933031544089317, -0.027945036068558693, 0.000517670123372227, 0.003228928428143263, 0.023728881031274796, 0.00553895952180028, -0.003905665595084429, -0.012236970476806164, 0.009114883840084076, 0.001655185711570084, -0.015738682821393013, -0.03850630298256874, -0.07864067703485489, 0.03559297323226929, -0.016089627519249916, 0.03698812052607536, -0.02219034545123577, -0.050588518381118774, 0.050460685044527054, 0.044125184416770935, 0.01613764837384224, -0.025841619819402695, -0.004630472976714373, -0.027915868908166885, 0.03097698464989662, 0.028473321348428726, 0.0020477822981774807, 0.01806868426501751, 0.051180921494960785, 0.03271390497684479, 0.0036392060574144125, 0.04428308829665184, -0.004322665743529797, 0.0032568450551480055, 0.020877858623862267, 0.016013935208320618, -0.0031615972984582186, 0.06358383595943451, 0.013738290406763554, -0.055060386657714844, 0.01193831954151392, 0.01425520796328783, -0.008484741672873497, 0.005102475639432669, -0.03495429456233978, 0.015027569606900215, -0.015408349223434925, -0.0031942282803356647, -0.011943736113607883, 0.057892076671123505, -0.007614856120198965, -0.007099521812051535, -0.032350920140743256, 0.023440536111593246, 0.026767060160636902, -0.005275138188153505, 0.0521816611289978, 0.06336601078510284, 0.041205041110515594, -0.02403986267745495, 0.001144620357081294, -0.013982939533889294, -0.019763033837080002, 0.030046431347727776, -0.017654908820986748, -0.02673812210559845, 0.04339190945029259, 0.037981048226356506, 0.012100298888981342, -0.0029666514601558447, -0.02862934209406376, 0.00823317002505064, -0.07645303755998611, 0.02099301852285862, -0.037453021854162216, 0.0459798164665699, -0.01667046919465065, 0.024005183950066566, 0.030281592160463333, -0.01902170293033123, -0.0056885345838963985, -0.016068175435066223, -0.04973132908344269, 0.011318227276206017, -0.033842191100120544, -0.01177369523793459, 0.03378117457032204, 0.02258775755763054, 0.0038417777977883816, -0.010243847034871578, 0.029040632769465446, 0.007204854395240545, 0.03631843253970146, -0.053179409354925156, 0.00765636470168829, -0.025437980890274048, -0.01636500097811222, 0.011231756769120693, 0.04489497095346451, 0.02536567486822605, -0.033186160027980804, 0.02656567469239235, 0.037007179111242294, -0.0040062908083200455, 0.027149440720677376, -0.04491688311100006, 0.011285834014415741, 0.012859048321843147, 0.022205032408237457, 0.011707421392202377, 0.022890686988830566, -0.04414990171790123, 0.028861768543720245, 0.00019277910178061575, 0.04356737434864044, 0.010436581447720528, 0.01060205977410078, -0.020534729585051537, -0.03245258331298828, -0.034392692148685455, -0.03288809582591057, 0.030109679326415062, 0.017934652045369148, -0.0068585737608373165, 0.0032334490679204464, 0.04757785424590111, -0.042649731040000916, 0.00004687158434535377, 0.04975372925400734, 0.03262745961546898, 0.03877909108996391, -0.04825099557638168, 0.0015764632262289524, -0.015132120810449123, -0.019067663699388504, 0.028663912788033485, 0.01652664691209793, -0.001320869312621653, -0.03024800308048725, 0.06470558047294617, 0.007909569889307022, -0.037427254021167755, 0.012033793143928051, -0.01136407908052206, 0.044539641588926315, -0.010875166393816471, -0.019290665164589882, 0.03832351043820381, 0.004544286988675594, 0.03181317076086998, 0.016620030626654625, -0.001440730644389987, -0.07084996998310089, -0.024980438873171806, 0.056766707450151443, 0.04626984894275665, -0.031433261930942535, -0.0007069606799632311, 0.004686221946030855, 0.023338252678513527, 0.049452800303697586, -0.031787700951099396, 0.03211555629968643, -0.0009320901590399444, -0.004959963262081146, -0.024093452841043472, -0.006575722713023424, -0.047331538051366806, 0.016291150823235512, -0.026407696306705475, 0.035760268568992615, -0.017489176243543625, -0.036840297281742096, -0.028822701424360275, -0.004493075888603926, 0.02532932162284851, 0.07882528752088547, -0.024821242317557335, -0.024806208908557892, 0.00633844081312418, 0.03810640424489975, -0.00689046923071146, -0.04196295887231827, 0.05962944030761719, 0.022802088409662247, -0.022406112402677536, 0.04707333818078041, -0.029607223346829414, -0.02748151496052742, 0.003908288665115833, -0.015130972489714622, -0.023312663659453392, -0.0018764545675367117, -0.0024735459592193365, 0.04357641190290451, 0.0632595419883728, 0.013853278942406178, 0.05378898233175278, -0.0036566946655511856, 0.028203360736370087, -0.015219765715301037, -0.0012079733423888683, -0.014297699555754662, -0.04434049502015114, -0.025241106748580933, -0.04055614024400711, -0.003712771460413933, -0.010594218969345093, 0.021845733746886253, -0.05810686573386192, 0.07230265438556671, -0.031447913497686386, -0.0010683969594538212, 0.009997167624533176, -0.014882841147482395, 0.0356462262570858, 0.018180042505264282, -0.023929014801979065, 0.003072280902415514, 0.01959053985774517, 0.00620134687051177, 0.012797192670404911, -0.017631448805332184, -0.011743428185582161, -0.01289677806198597, -0.013196971267461777, 0.013139918446540833, -0.042675331234931946, -0.013194325380027294, -0.00798457395285368, 0.0011181035079061985, 0.02772761881351471, -0.01264849491417408, -0.0006332088960334659, 0.00933532603085041, -0.009883951395750046, -0.02791612036526203, 0.062260329723358154, 0.009491820819675922, 0.04355514049530029, -0.04645547270774841, 0.016749192029237747, 0.002250958001241088, -0.0148311173543334, -0.06861329078674316, -0.04781131446361542, -0.0025089741684496403, 0.03602611646056175, 0.012206755578517914, -0.05996427685022354, -0.014982356689870358, -0.006139933131635189, 0.0017583422595635056, -0.017249733209609985, 0.0422518365085125, -0.017436305060982704, -0.030690791085362434, -0.007832271978259087, 0.006124975625425577, 0.10136913508176804, -0.048866525292396545, -0.03661467507481575, -0.0031933316495269537, -0.027509158477187157, -0.013796026818454266, -0.012423994019627571, -0.00612051272764802, -0.034973714500665665, -0.036587346345186234, -0.040648214519023895, -0.012875353917479515, 0.03295089676976204, -0.059113744646310806, -0.025035880506038666, 0.006726926192641258, -0.004184728488326073, 0.0034213541075587273, -0.05693788826465607, -0.01663999818265438, -0.022842302918434143, 0.006388935260474682, -0.03189953416585922, -0.0024539148434996605, 0.005577848758548498, -0.03585284948348999, 0.020933648571372032, 0.025012947618961334, -0.02198081836104393, 0.00006416647374862805, 0.07890696823596954, 0.011363272555172443, -0.017438353970646858, 0.01639755442738533, -0.02460670657455921, 0.03040093556046486, 0.031480222940444946, -0.00992940180003643, -0.008964035660028458, 0.03771300986409187, -0.04828793555498123, -0.04723919928073883, -0.013958093710243702, -0.0174456425011158, 0.07232748717069626, -0.022307273000478745, 0.03584831953048706, 0.07772611081600189, 0.013552652671933174, -0.0007541566737927496, -0.007739013060927391, 0.007514925207942724, -0.021141432225704193, -0.009214290417730808, 0.059505168348550797, 0.00855084229260683, -0.006820699665695429, 0.05179242044687271, 0.026735182851552963, 0.020137278363108635, 0.03432053327560425, 0.035112980753183365, 0.02840195968747139, 0.044444575905799866, -0.032493505626916885, -0.051061734557151794, -0.0033455058000981808, -0.07196002453565598, 0.010282312519848347, -0.03592413291335106, -0.011717241257429123, 0.035782404243946075, 0.02937769517302513, -0.00017849786672741175, -0.03920880705118179, -0.04729406163096428, -0.05361592024564743, -0.0081022335216403, 0.002854023827239871, 0.00823004450649023, 0.021527525037527084, 0.039115000516176224, 0.037130024284124374, -0.02298743836581707, 0.021089540794491768, -0.04017673805356026, -0.07709384709596634, -0.025718534365296364, 0.01060070376843214, -0.014902818016707897, 0.0028390511870384216, -0.023904524743556976, -0.018186019733548164, 0.02539185993373394, -0.02849408984184265, 0.025266088545322418, 0.004625801928341389, 0.03727997466921806, -0.02328677661716938, 0.022221919149160385, 0.013399115763604641, 0.045265838503837585, 0.02154560014605522, 0.007071611005812883, 0.08519306033849716, 0.05533406510949135, 0.052611105144023895, -0.05727473273873329, 0.017439762130379677, 0.00716534024104476, 0.004780057817697525, -0.016212482005357742, 0.015689292922616005, 0.01628294214606285, -0.010207556188106537, 0.05240854248404503, 0.047002121806144714, 0.014669414609670639, -0.0320594497025013, 0.06272155791521072, -0.024452604353427887, -0.016216568648815155, -0.004257846157997847, 0.0040186014957726, 0.02056979201734066, -0.027741950005292892, -0.060682959854602814, 0.040786176919937134, 0.01486526895314455, -0.03250871226191521, -0.043092165142297745, -0.011568070389330387, 0.011169439181685448, 0.013441265560686588, 0.0008612863603048027, 0.042528197169303894, 0.007456345017999411, 0.011847801506519318, -0.04653478413820267, -0.004361174069344997, 0.013817768543958664, -0.06460212171077728, 0.032935842871665955, 0.03233524039387703, 0.003895337926223874, -0.032350100576877594, 0.0018309931037947536, 0.015088099986314774, -0.07229804992675781, 0.008449723944067955, -0.04873790219426155, 0.022265946492552757, -0.0008948019822128117, -0.017548007890582085, -0.002450179075822234, -0.0027442516293376684, 0.0013331710360944271, -0.06200240179896355, -0.05484079197049141, 0.016955697908997536, 0.018860196694731712, -0.018868463113904, -0.008426089771091938, -0.005236538592725992, 0.03920317441225052, 0.004603629000484943, 0.01524632889777422, 0.018014464527368546, -0.009606759995222092, -0.0472429022192955, -0.0066872453317046165, 0.008860252797603607, 0.014972425997257233, -0.021659208461642265, -0.005443555768579245, -0.003060338320210576, 0.0012317211367189884, -0.0022044507786631584, -0.00947490893304348, 0.008321831934154034, 0.05542755499482155, 0.015941543504595757, -0.02275480516254902, 0.00519136805087328, -0.03718021512031555, -0.012507000006735325, -0.037987809628248215, 0.01633976399898529, -0.04540027678012848, -0.004627760499715805, 0.0498897023499012, 0.02246149443089962, 0.020449714735150337, -0.0035061954986304045, 0.03265799954533577, 0.06484995782375336, 0.03657228872179985, -0.043516431003808975, -0.030097806826233864, -0.022781502455472946, -0.0051102181896567345, -0.03447728604078293, -0.025355014950037003, 0.07095115631818771, 0.04388602077960968, 0.0062612066976726055, 0.03171297162771225, 0.002081416780129075, -0.032027073204517365, 0.018293069675564766, 0.00664669880643487, -0.055783115327358246, -0.01754462718963623, 0.02018890529870987, 0.0015872687799856067, -0.02114325948059559, -0.02498321421444416, -0.025345390662550926, -0.02056768722832203, 0.03223437815904617, -0.04012181982398033, -0.003059825161471963, -0.03824242949485779, 0.0029348700772970915, 0.02134457603096962, -0.013148423284292221, -0.017618020996451378, -0.0023927255533635616, -0.01809609867632389, 0.006919716950505972, 0.03305266425013542, -0.01873701438307762, -0.01748083345592022, -0.015844855457544327, -0.0035836545284837484, 0.04817378520965576, 0.002311950083822012, 0.01271588820964098, 0.010659335181117058, -0.0029187446925789118, 0.0072397999465465546, 0.048349689692258835, -0.029124662280082703, -0.0001333167456323281, 0.054123375564813614, -0.07472285628318787, -0.03862925246357918, 0.014603865332901478, -0.033056098967790604, 0.02494838833808899, 0.022004634141921997, 0.0007653679931536317, -0.023016341030597687, 0.03576967492699623, -0.04008615389466286, 0.005015532020479441, -0.034285977482795715, 0.013929479755461216, -0.0036164112389087677, -0.010818026028573513, -0.00393780879676342, -0.006532397586852312, -0.028187792748212814, 0.03555946797132492, 0.05420035868883133, -0.01231001503765583, -0.005074071232229471, 0.012436462566256523, 0.022429829463362694, 0.016893472522497177, -0.010705816559493542, -0.027343759313225746, 0.037680886685848236, 0.0549091137945652, -0.03869703784584999, 0.019191207364201546, -0.04575811326503754, -0.0040451535023748875, -0.0622493177652359, -0.021399009972810745, -0.00003912258762284182, -0.0066893380135297775, 0.01231362298130989, -0.07039698213338852, 0.010580413974821568, 0.017466772347688675, -0.048410817980766296, 0.05273720249533653, 0.013543040491640568, -0.014488587155938148, -0.05373828858137131, 0.026035740971565247, -0.010521591641008854, 0.0013020760379731655, 0.004315501544624567, 0.03969979286193848, 0.004436199087649584, 0.058307383209466934, 0.0005106585449539125, 0.013099659234285355, 0.03701949864625931, -0.013784492388367653, 0.01761200837790966, -0.09229186922311783, -0.007141761016100645, -0.03282175585627556, -0.040171824395656586, 0.06613606959581375, -0.05336251109838486, 0.013978632166981697, 0.0019323461456224322, -0.005908452905714512, -0.01701478660106659, 0.03220308572053909, 0.025996040552854538, -0.011766009032726288, 0.005299028474837542, -0.02756219357252121, -0.011455224826931953, 0.03860388696193695, -0.03488481789827347, 0.0028809222858399153, 0.06537831574678421, -0.00995909795165062, -0.006445091217756271, 0.00470943795517087, -0.012066778726875782, -0.013271905481815338, 0.007785753812640905, 0.025631027296185493, 0.01575441099703312, -0.015064000152051449, 0.027620874345302582, -0.023802248761057854, -0.012793158181011677, 0.02056106925010681, 0.013351029716432095, -0.04505019262433052, 0.007173298858106136, -0.023934707045555115, -0.03339995816349983, 0.011146939359605312, 0.006166896782815456, -0.005520146805793047, -0.05061592534184456, -0.002903470303863287, -0.006796561647206545, 0.001375949359498918, -0.02207113616168499, -0.05136305093765259, -0.029284967109560966, 0.019441107288002968, -0.05239884555339813, -0.02863536961376667, -0.011765386909246445, 0.0247089471668005, 0.004234916530549526, -0.0928974598646164, 0.026674477383494377, 0.03820594772696495, -0.009290761314332485, -0.03636350482702255, 0.006586465984582901, -0.08822178840637207, 0.008137593045830727, 0.07421883195638657, 0.03524433448910713, -0.0014048231532797217, 0.01925593987107277, 0.017664587125182152, -0.010352248325943947, -0.05231005698442459, 0.040355317294597626, -0.008904743008315563, -0.007880361750721931, -0.007585879880934954, -0.028210340067744255, 0.0004285682225599885, 0.006602398585528135, -0.0019063401268795133, -0.009102393873035908, -0.010444443672895432, 0.006100889761000872, 0.01557887438684702, 0.04005845636129379, -0.04035179316997528, -0.026486633345484734, 0.029690420255064964, 0.020381666719913483, 0.012629383243620396, -0.003410720732063055, 0.003368964185938239, -0.07021046429872513, 0.03038410283625126, -0.017664356157183647, -0.041172806173563004, 0.00652552954852581, 0.006470461841672659, 0.013716324232518673, -0.04852258414030075, -0.009282025508582592, 0.0062325787730515, -0.022320017218589783, 0.01867160201072693, 0.031290385872125626, 0.058276765048503876, 0.0051601049490273, -0.010068169794976711, 0.008882776834070683, 0.006482061464339495, -0.004332529380917549, 0.04537156596779823, 0.02473062090575695, -0.0050253430381417274, 0.02509463019669056, 0.007391573395580053, 0.02954685315489769, -0.029967624694108963, 0.03146279975771904, -0.021433206275105476, 0.0370480939745903, 0.02221195213496685, -0.019309567287564278, 0.03250766173005104, 0.002777464222162962, 0.010533178225159645, -0.007774427067488432, 0.0038663805462419987, 0.04607165977358818, 0.012412172742187977, 0.007461172994226217, -0.03669983893632889, 0.013685101643204689, -0.018392624333500862, -0.030054783448576927, -0.018004929646849632, -0.001135916681960225, -0.036959581077098846, -0.017506320029497147, 0.016406863927841187, -0.05862339586019516, 0.014529496431350708, -0.00574735552072525, 0.027778204530477524, -0.022575050592422485, 0.01947922073304653, -0.013749863021075726, -0.016827603802084923, -0.011117560788989067, -0.024309154599905014, 0.029492152854800224, 0.041087158024311066, 0.06307460367679596, -0.011976569890975952, -0.05593667924404144, 0.02615145966410637, 0.03149309754371643, -0.028273222967982292, -0.05020701512694359, -0.02745806984603405, -0.01133487094193697, 0.03076857142150402, -0.05032285675406456 ]
<p>I perform a permutation test multiple times on different datasets, each time I am only concerned about significant $p$ values. To reduce computation time would it be correct to introduce this kind of stopping rule: After a certain number of $N$ permutations to check whether $p$ is greater than a particular value. So, for example if $p&gt;0.1$ after $N$=200 permutations then the lower bound of 95% confidence interval would be greater than $0.05$. Therefore, calculations could be stopped as a true $p$ is not significant. Just want to make sure I am doing it right. Thank you.</p>
74,309
[ -0.005048715975135565, -0.011530297808349133, -0.028138786554336548, -0.009326521307229996, 0.022052139043807983, 0.010022646747529507, 0.01616150327026844, -0.02834557183086872, -0.0045663584023714066, -0.0386677086353302, 0.03366868570446968, 0.026296066120266914, 0.017261788249015808, 0.0039406148716807365, 0.01453231368213892, 0.013241364620625973, -0.03624163568019867, -0.00993382465094328, -0.007182018831372261, -0.01860063523054123, -0.01805833727121353, 0.022777097299695015, 0.014585917815566063, -0.02431964874267578, -0.04152810573577881, 0.01103559322655201, 0.014595558866858482, -0.007633469067513943, -0.018292248249053955, 0.065914086997509, -0.05489104613661766, 0.005620184354484081, 0.03688611462712288, 0.06915221363306046, -0.007576105184853077, -0.005275172647088766, -0.0008678844897076488, -0.057796161621809006, 0.016127992421388626, 0.005219501908868551, -0.03883526474237442, 0.003479847451671958, -0.01755562610924244, 0.034668873995542526, 0.04610038921236992, 0.006374538876116276, -0.009908018633723259, -0.03588152304291725, 0.007678503170609474, -0.014236653223633766, 0.08337190747261047, 0.02179187349975109, 0.023435071110725403, 0.006413718685507774, 0.0006638871855102479, -0.013349639251828194, 0.029403317719697952, 0.06344985216856003, -0.02276214025914669, -0.041651755571365356, -0.00314279249869287, -0.0744653195142746, 0.02411726675927639, -0.037256982177495956, -0.0360027439892292, 0.016908714547753334, -0.027638018131256104, 0.010075876489281654, 0.03475242853164673, -0.01942230388522148, -0.003992102108895779, -0.0023550542537122965, 0.049952033907175064, -0.03514513373374939, -0.005853177513927221, -0.01751605048775673, 0.03594042360782623, -0.0035026599653065205, 0.020071059465408325, 0.06689874827861786, -0.02178378589451313, -0.002871100092306733, 0.017798077315092087, 0.05648915469646454, 0.015463982708752155, -0.013664472848176956, 0.05520172417163849, -0.05315704271197319, 0.03247516229748726, 0.02626013569533825, -0.01348037738353014, -0.021184902638196945, 0.05957535281777382, -0.009874590672552586, -0.03693395107984543, 0.014051214791834354, -0.031145647168159485, -0.0034298242535442114, -0.009068281389772892, -0.021923314779996872, -0.015615330077707767, -0.0499207004904747, 0.04797382280230522, 0.03866320103406906, -0.013159280642867088, 0.001569760381244123, -0.044647663831710815, -0.018601620569825172, -0.02016972377896309, -0.022617226466536522, 0.014012675732374191, 0.010886702686548233, -0.016663523390889168, 0.006885071285068989, 0.012534807436168194, 0.012357925996184349, -0.010160045698285103, -0.03150474280118942, 0.05414659529924393, 0.07293519377708435, 0.04852300137281418, -0.0053331260569393635, 0.012049952521920204, -0.027867600321769714, -0.02900245599448681, 0.0007686683093197644, 0.005575475282967091, 0.007279074750840664, -0.05665261670947075, 0.0636870339512825, -0.012741739861667156, -0.0016166892601177096, 0.020848745480179787, -0.03638555854558945, 0.07213999330997467, -0.006823084782809019, -0.05876106396317482, -0.03197513893246651, 0.010650415904819965, -0.046246498823165894, 0.005261674057692289, -0.05449441075325012, 0.001877229893580079, 0.031409136950969696, 0.03503134846687317, -0.025279805064201355, 0.03806670755147934, -0.020473051816225052, 0.0532611608505249, 0.03808080404996872, -0.056112099438905716, 0.0030748462304472923, -0.005746342707425356, -0.0017453357577323914, -0.002992128487676382, -0.0681183934211731, 0.03878985345363617, -0.0014018097426742315, 0.03144041448831558, -0.03122587688267231, -0.011389290913939476, -0.04748512804508209, -0.005141938105225563, -0.028607146814465523, 0.016660409048199654, 0.012772328220307827, 0.081937775015831, 0.019931189715862274, 0.06430589407682419, -0.02064487524330616, 0.028290849179029465, 0.033854417502880096, 0.015508907847106457, 0.04525283724069595, 0.03993463143706322, -0.0618797168135643, 0.032706741243600845, -0.01454862393438816, 0.06606807559728622, -0.008105269633233547, 0.007083685602992773, -0.0003079920425079763, 0.01131492666900158, 0.00954049825668335, -0.009223704226315022, 0.008660875260829926, -0.005733846686780453, -0.02512485161423683, 0.04017689824104309, -0.04540306702256203, -0.012054524384438992, -0.062313806265592575, -0.011474551633000374, 0.012972326949238777, -0.026952210813760757, 0.05656920373439789, 0.011045082472264767, 0.021074894815683365, 0.009593646042048931, -0.04680389165878296, -0.023129554465413094, 0.001313945627771318, 0.02352517656981945, -0.06721989065408707, -0.01555607933551073, 0.03901910036802292, 0.026076465845108032, -0.002415772993117571, 0.06942719966173172, -0.03136478736996651, -0.022633010521531105, -0.010611298494040966, -0.03886739909648895, -0.006204607430845499, 0.011036474257707596, -0.03434894233942032, 0.03327867016196251, -0.01907666027545929, 0.009430230595171452, 0.03682331368327141, -0.04989811033010483, 0.06356855481863022, 0.04042157903313637, -0.008430704474449158, 0.025585170835256577, -0.03272758796811104, 0.030306179076433182, -0.0174085795879364, -0.012882180511951447, -0.026830334216356277, -0.04098692163825035, 0.0074696927331388, 0.05199602618813515, 0.01493213139474392, -0.05397113412618637, 0.01951221190392971, 0.06813256442546844, -0.012316342443227768, 0.033008214086294174, 0.05561210215091705, -0.0038965276908129454, -0.028259646147489548, 0.012584785930812359, 0.052258435636758804, 0.013385427184402943, 0.023020032793283463, 0.0018684789538383484, 0.017378341406583786, 0.028314420953392982, 0.04056265577673912, -0.007738358806818724, 0.012873437255620956, -0.0006758868112228811, 0.00022752511722501367, -0.004900027997791767, -0.026618799194693565, 0.011460019275546074, -0.029973391443490982, 0.00721626216545701, 0.03300420939922333, 0.018614357337355614, 0.02440618723630905, -0.007488667033612728, -0.029966168105602264, 0.004105959087610245, 0.03888127952814102, -0.05997690558433533, -0.0023724606726318598, 0.018211890012025833, -0.03197239711880684, 0.02065168134868145, -0.02915099635720253, -0.021394357085227966, -0.0047727650962769985, 0.04569210484623909, 0.03126862645149231, -0.022476758807897568, 0.044190797954797745, -0.04097960144281387, -0.015849431976675987, 0.008785558864474297, -0.005881183315068483, 0.02373697981238365, 0.003476380370557308, -0.07344815135002136, -0.026851333677768707, 0.003808209439739585, -0.054927192628383636, 0.015061414800584316, -0.044038351625204086, -0.0017726164078339934, 0.020215479657053947, -0.016806386411190033, -0.018434716388583183, 0.0006860585999675095, -0.05344507098197937, 0.029797885566949844, -0.039381057024002075, -0.06135965883731842, 0.03658439591526985, 0.010456401854753494, -0.0076633356511592865, 0.031688954681158066, -0.009621964767575264, -0.028671786189079285, -0.028280479833483696, 0.0014279860770329833, 0.0031951614655554295, -0.0032976733054965734, 0.0028471036348491907, 0.013925211504101753, -0.01725616492331028, -0.016807686537504196, -0.05596190690994263, -0.07464037090539932, 0.005105996038764715, -0.012469979003071785, 0.0577629916369915, -0.009871060959994793, -0.003959613852202892, 0.06988123804330826, 0.05146009474992752, -0.026966432109475136, -0.0032407292164862156, -0.031290557235479355, -0.03435361757874489, -0.0058623142540454865, -0.024124983698129654, 0.020325299352407455, -0.03255103901028633, 0.03840861842036247, -0.008936850354075432, 0.017544010654091835, 0.04478653520345688, -0.011062059551477432, -0.017519842833280563, 0.006829183083027601, 0.006807125639170408, 0.01128238346427679, 0.005433793179690838, 0.013277939520776272, -0.01688004471361637, 0.025854239240288734, 0.005318024195730686, 0.0075821653008461, 0.019545741379261017, -0.0445699580013752, 0.03419889509677887, -0.0244306493550539, 0.013721282593905926, -0.025773070752620697, 0.05146724358201027, 0.04129868000745773, -0.021246813237667084, -0.023084629327058792, 0.029277099296450615, 0.024062834680080414, -0.01715158298611641, -0.013882516883313656, 0.015637125819921494, 0.023895246908068657, -0.02796187251806259, 0.017987746745347977, -0.004017108120024204, -0.039256688207387924, 0.012001851573586464, -0.020377451553940773, -0.03287253901362419, -0.0031844235491007566, 0.04288607835769653, 0.04396439343690872, -0.005146290175616741, -0.02667238749563694, 0.027084743604063988, -0.021296748891472816, 0.013973060064017773, -0.0414857417345047, 0.01945655606687069, -0.017361018806695938, 0.04275225102901459, 0.027659663930535316, -0.03177521005272865, -0.045104920864105225, 0.04529288038611412, -0.061007943004369736, 0.04432762414216995, -0.028439776971936226, -0.0018017521360889077, 0.011385161429643631, -0.032027773559093475, 0.016369149088859558, -0.028932519257068634, 0.04329067841172218, -0.0028107319958508015, 0.03173384070396423, -0.03146453574299812, 0.011698042042553425, -0.05555758252739906, 0.0042871818877756596, 0.018832968547940254, 0.014520784839987755, 0.0013440103502944112, 0.0006872899830341339, 0.05535344034433365, -0.0023998606484383345, -0.02139205113053322, 0.025556547567248344, 0.014568716287612915, 0.02212507836520672, 0.014607556164264679, 0.018584907054901123, 0.027032950893044472, 0.0402563214302063, -0.02778816781938076, 0.0107489675283432, -0.01579248532652855, 0.04845334589481354, 0.018259573727846146, -0.014219710603356361, -0.006060021463781595, -0.025015195831656456, -0.035204555839300156, -0.0004975182819180191, 0.0012474233517423272, -0.01938893459737301, 0.0031477008014917374, 0.04892389476299286, -0.007152303587645292, -0.05176541581749916, -0.009395639412105083, 0.09170930087566376, 0.029851527884602547, -0.017062271013855934, -0.06630105525255203, 0.006532454863190651, 0.023907920345664024, 0.00027629805845208466, -0.03163435682654381, 0.017767848446965218, 0.006531637627631426, 0.005550098139792681, 0.0284378994256258, -0.01604204624891281, -0.051220063120126724, 0.010960275307297707, 0.004436727613210678, 0.05780583620071411, 0.017136232927441597, 0.024236049503087997, 0.06813042610883713, -0.005084934178739786, -0.02546677179634571, 0.028804058209061623, 0.0015988500090315938, -0.06438807398080826, 0.023230716586112976, 0.06840229034423828, 0.0831352025270462, -0.024359386414289474, 0.022063082084059715, -0.06059941649436951, -0.011187258176505566, 0.0488412007689476, -0.018865356221795082, 0.03291487693786621, -0.053535353392362595, 0.004068724345415831, -0.041469596326351166, -0.011767260730266571, -0.06779533624649048, 0.005470443982630968, -0.03336609899997711, 0.020242759957909584, -0.04427347704768181, -0.013463328592479229, -0.06287047266960144, -0.020445263013243675, 0.026985665783286095, 0.041749048978090286, -0.03037271834909916, 0.021114200353622437, 0.007362737320363522, 0.005497523117810488, -0.022635236382484436, -0.07341144979000092, 0.02660071849822998, -0.01974242366850376, 0.01707577332854271, 0.05050283670425415, 0.0014385980321094394, -0.022004064172506332, 0.04726928845047951, -0.017755085602402687, -0.02757401391863823, -0.005970640107989311, -0.00869874469935894, 0.08295497298240662, 0.04269886389374733, -0.00827585719525814, 0.0037114545702934265, 0.001345924218185246, 0.009308102540671825, 0.0262210164219141, -0.008131662383675575, 0.03897968307137489, -0.034268833696842194, 0.02188010700047016, -0.0243595652282238, -0.01958169974386692, -0.06174824386835098, 0.03669552877545357, 0.0016251537017524242, 0.008777055889368057, -0.007764949928969145, 0.020048491656780243, 0.01473708264529705, 0.006207252386957407, 0.027295570820569992, -0.009274899959564209, 0.008642730303108692, 0.02217775024473667, -0.010655066929757595, -0.005784230772405863, 0.020132659003138542, -0.022299109026789665, 0.03803562372922897, 0.029347090050578117, -0.003409862518310547, 0.009213593788444996, -0.05261946842074394, -0.011867071501910686, -0.021088698878884315, -0.03163185715675354, 0.003976321313530207, 0.001419404405169189, 0.004088070243597031, -0.02269633300602436, -0.04208636283874512, 0.005573149770498276, 0.02999628148972988, -0.006286331452429295, 0.02577327750623226, -0.036617204546928406, 0.056619249284267426, -0.04349362105131149, 0.03860858827829361, -0.0667247474193573, -0.041275616735219955, 0.017738517373800278, 0.026987090706825256, -0.01565539464354515, -0.05549554154276848, -0.015450791455805302, -0.01987556181848049, -0.019648445770144463, -0.03061794675886631, 0.016274387016892433, -0.005426665768027306, -0.01846129447221756, -0.007783005479723215, -0.012363780289888382, 0.06719370186328888, -0.03075479157269001, 0.013736598193645477, 0.01903870888054371, -0.022002583369612694, -0.018261689692735672, 0.005035990849137306, 0.039093468338251114, -0.0192495696246624, -0.029118245467543602, -0.008954500779509544, 0.0007418569293804467, 0.043243516236543655, -0.03892369940876961, -0.030088534578680992, 0.0060516661033034325, -0.00808513630181551, 0.0239797942340374, 0.0014377882471308112, -0.011922045610845089, -0.01735110767185688, 0.029660936444997787, 0.006748537067323923, 0.02655712515115738, 0.006261476781219244, -0.01716006174683571, 0.014243824407458305, -0.023381778970360756, -0.00494573125615716, 0.01284252293407917, 0.04828477278351784, -0.044542375952005386, -0.01943807862699032, -0.04906585440039635, -0.03652207553386688, 0.008908280171453953, 0.03245500847697258, -0.03196023777127266, 0.002064975444227457, -0.008410768583416939, -0.02175772376358509, -0.012101239524781704, -0.02746663987636566, -0.0407157801091671, 0.03963113948702812, 0.01740398071706295, 0.03202112391591072, 0.03112564980983734, 0.02506687119603157, 0.0020480460952967405, 0.026933390647172928, 0.010273978114128113, 0.0018246725667268038, 0.042282961308956146, 0.04343537241220474, 0.007452777121216059, 0.008317342959344387, 0.029786119237542152, 0.02365909516811371, 0.03469162434339523, 0.05958142131567001, 0.01670176349580288, -0.010454563423991203, 0.023130616173148155, -0.026262393221259117, -0.02159835956990719, 0.03410469368100166, -0.06147335097193718, -0.0017989866901189089, -0.03851079195737839, -0.039238423109054565, 0.028783496469259262, 0.032895419746637344, -0.007355985231697559, -0.020910082384943962, -0.043958570808172226, -0.05475777015089989, -0.001650206628255546, 0.025194721296429634, -0.025027131661772728, 0.03771432116627693, -0.019127115607261658, -0.0030646556988358498, 0.009222577325999737, 0.03433435782790184, -0.011949458159506321, -0.03129730373620987, -0.026134096086025238, -0.04248504340648651, -0.06144110858440399, 0.015270751900970936, 0.0011341423960402608, -0.018794754520058632, 0.004910395946353674, 0.005611966829746962, 0.032639965415000916, 0.013899175450205803, 0.03800762817263603, -0.027516117319464684, 0.08044373989105225, 0.029305405914783478, 0.04458501562476158, 0.013675829395651817, -0.027564503252506256, 0.13063205778598785, 0.08259879052639008, -0.004787102807313204, -0.0575251504778862, 0.035855717957019806, -0.027620509266853333, -0.011415014043450356, -0.04079420492053032, 0.0371861457824707, 0.014682766981422901, -0.015728911384940147, 0.015833452343940735, 0.08542026579380035, -0.017950886860489845, -0.008045883849263191, 0.06087790057063103, -0.030280591920018196, -0.016229087486863136, 0.033037219196558, 0.03241521492600441, -0.016529323533177376, -0.02638508938252926, -0.02313276380300522, 0.004125762265175581, -0.014694256708025932, 0.010261627845466137, 0.02347017638385296, -0.033318642526865005, 0.010034028440713882, 0.02666367217898369, 0.004115885589271784, 0.0030847652815282345, 0.03263511881232262, -0.019691411405801773, -0.030711641535162926, -0.022196531295776367, 0.013725881464779377, 0.0011359789641574025, 0.02064996026456356, 0.054752495139837265, -0.000998199451714754, 0.026325928047299385, -0.017818044871091843, 0.019876500591635704, -0.040629420429468155, -0.024476168677210808, -0.010279407724738121, 0.02028222195804119, 0.013660318218171597, 0.02238490991294384, -0.0036362740211188793, -0.01599235273897648, 0.01728358305990696, -0.035012222826480865, -0.021541710942983627, 0.017122361809015274, 0.0006408569752238691, -0.010871769860386848, -0.006641357205808163, -0.03210144862532616, 0.02235611341893673, 0.009630792774260044, 0.022985683754086494, 0.022163311019539833, -0.04276484251022339, -0.013151835650205612, 0.018507150933146477, 0.014705117791891098, -0.0025140545330941677, -0.005688818637281656, 0.007776691112667322, -0.021079275757074356, -0.03757717087864876, 0.012949908152222633, 0.017296260222792625, -0.01494645420461893, -0.00795828364789486, -0.022992270067334175, -0.04037773609161377, 0.008520906791090965, -0.02862117998301983, 0.03223979100584984, -0.019526518881320953, -0.014855720102787018, -0.04049147292971611, -0.011981821618974209, 0.037574414163827896, 0.030912412330508232, 0.003259701654314995, 0.03069893643260002, 0.025215698406100273, 0.06177093833684921, 0.028368502855300903, -0.046464838087558746, -0.021988261491060257, -0.007137947250157595, -0.04569214954972267, 0.043358344584703445, -0.02019822970032692, 0.055903851985931396, 0.016013629734516144, 0.02124553918838501, 0.017934417352080345, 0.005191315896809101, -0.027364356443285942, 0.02340814284980297, -0.007437269203364849, -0.053070489317178726, -0.02615862898528576, 0.019001616165041924, -0.023402053862810135, -0.030641620978713036, -0.04600480571389198, -0.021537084132432938, -0.003046570811420679, -0.00033757026540115476, -0.004579978063702583, -0.00863309670239687, -0.030051564797759056, 0.011191841214895248, -0.014878625050187111, -0.012113037519156933, -0.013018153607845306, -0.05689966306090355, 0.023887628689408302, -0.007580750156193972, 0.01850881800055504, -0.005227135960012674, -0.003173386212438345, 0.007008877117186785, 0.04303543642163277, 0.06263662129640579, 0.022543249651789665, 0.015165204182267189, -0.03162067383527756, 0.037766940891742706, 0.01945042982697487, 0.04605155438184738, -0.0189188402146101, -0.006136023905128241, 0.050756558775901794, -0.06126880273222923, -0.04248819500207901, 0.04109387472271919, -0.0037894805427640676, 0.02710343338549137, -0.000588525552302599, -0.013429381884634495, -0.008763706311583519, 0.026686862111091614, -0.02952052280306816, -0.022384600713849068, 0.02556644380092621, 0.03700363636016846, -0.008874797262251377, 0.008405754342675209, -0.014672372490167618, -0.00856367964297533, 0.012631753459572792, 0.02305389754474163, 0.040648192167282104, 0.009109215810894966, -0.0030825266148895025, -0.015414111316204071, 0.005430839490145445, 0.057084303349256516, -0.001291622407734394, -0.002603677799925208, 0.008268200792372227, 0.052839312702417374, -0.03605886548757553, 0.027623899281024933, -0.03644216060638428, 0.000619774975348264, -0.06441757827997208, -0.010548833757638931, 0.0007041707867756486, 0.03338007256388664, 0.048437874764204025, -0.023104505613446236, 0.0471588559448719, 0.018466375768184662, -0.0043108114041388035, 0.052362505346536636, -0.06107589974999428, 0.007181490305811167, -0.056796323508024216, 0.010756983421742916, 0.00257416651584208, -0.007416887674480677, 0.02542293630540371, -0.003007828490808606, 0.07384020835161209, 0.0026458799839019775, 0.016786471009254456, -0.02529834397137165, 0.03750152885913849, 0.03788874298334122, -0.04208573326468468, -0.0953073650598526, 0.03611920401453972, -0.025683926418423653, -0.057772450149059296, 0.03813935071229935, 0.0012295967899262905, -0.003172358963638544, 0.030633963644504547, 0.05252412334084511, -0.0090431347489357, 0.041512660682201385, 0.049450915306806564, 0.0038829022087156773, -0.011246982030570507, -0.013112837448716164, 0.007027796003967524, 0.019982686266303062, -0.05667712911963463, -0.001397957792505622, 0.012709012255072594, -0.017096566036343575, -0.03230131044983864, 0.01840214803814888, -0.025508815422654152, -0.007650792133063078, -0.004101601894944906, 0.017969073727726936, -0.017671409994363785, -0.02568240649998188, 0.03012978658080101, -0.04486352577805519, 0.021770862862467766, 0.012772098183631897, 0.03237763047218323, -0.016488585621118546, 0.016863256692886353, -0.027159525081515312, -0.06259141862392426, -0.022643854841589928, 0.020703524351119995, -0.0263287965208292, -0.0763712227344513, 0.013483249582350254, -0.020361363887786865, -0.016443222761154175, -0.009724847972393036, -0.02170843444764614, -0.020387789234519005, 0.048767294734716415, -0.0385255441069603, -0.0016645515570417047, 0.03151721507310867, -0.004005060531198978, -0.010714255273342133, -0.1238173395395279, 0.04689963161945343, -0.008778718300163746, 0.008948654867708683, -0.037216197699308395, -0.0070130908861756325, -0.04918015003204346, 0.030522454530000687, 0.016317542642354965, 0.009677453897893429, 0.015858402475714684, -0.03711148351430893, 0.020412571728229523, 0.04057559370994568, -0.07428151369094849, 0.02509043738245964, -0.05179033428430557, 0.016980402171611786, -0.044909875839948654, -0.023595213890075684, 0.0506114736199379, -0.008622786961495876, -0.02175847254693508, 0.008625213988125324, -0.009629352018237114, 0.024200545623898506, 0.009152557700872421, 0.04859650135040283, 0.007514696568250656, 0.009242499247193336, 0.010172858834266663, -0.004082829225808382, 0.015944115817546844, 0.02914109081029892, -0.0009409718913957477, -0.06448609381914139, 0.03131680563092232, -0.029720352962613106, -0.05354136973619461, 0.03545467555522919, 0.04022734612226486, -0.017569061368703842, -0.05906745418906212, 0.038260240107774734, 0.01565541699528694, -0.0354071743786335, 0.016517512500286102, -0.002783142728731036, 0.010876169428229332, 0.034957367926836014, -0.025170011445879936, 0.03989922255277634, 0.01284726057201624, -0.02679281122982502, -0.005222189240157604, 0.02315024472773075, -0.03269558027386665, -0.01618281379342079, 0.054428230971097946, 0.009720006957650185, -0.013765190728008747, 0.011129138991236687, 0.05334951728582382, 0.037658385932445526, 0.017194034531712532, -0.03568791598081589, 0.03933922201395035, -0.019698958843946457, 0.011488844640552998, -0.015867864713072777, 0.009781398810446262, 0.04293398931622505, -0.006190600339323282, 0.03577365726232529, -0.03354909271001816, -0.02532987855374813, -0.021669354289770126, -0.020600220188498497, 0.005782604683190584, 0.012299496680498123, -0.020466718822717667, 0.023377904668450356, -0.019091524183750153, 0.040765292942523956, 0.027594786137342453, -0.028556857258081436, 0.04386875033378601, -0.005392521154135466, -0.009288564324378967, -0.00806666724383831, -0.022426174953579903, -0.04165588319301605, -0.01587936095893383, -0.016591442748904228, 0.029455048963427544, 0.06917928159236908, 0.021272657439112663, -0.008575258776545525, 0.023525362834334373, 0.025830501690506935, -0.019405661150813103, -0.010716567747294903, -0.05160981044173241, -0.003597966395318508, -0.013234146870672703, -0.004283239133656025 ]
<p>I have read other posts on conducting Factor analysis (FA) with dichotomous variables and although it appears clear that FA done in the default way is not appropriate, I am still unclear about a few things. </p> <p>I have 7 variables that are yes/no responses. They are assessing peoples functioning (e.g., working yes/no, involvement with justice system yes/no etc). I want to combine these responses to have two variables that represent domains of functioning (e.g., occupational and social). I suspect three of them will be occupational and 4 of them social. I would like to do something analogous to a FA to confirm this.</p> <p>I only have access to SPSS (and am only familiar with this package) so am looking for advice on how to do this with SPSS. </p> <p>Do I do a FA with tetrachoric correlations instead of Pearsons (how is this done?)? Or can I do Latent Trait Analysis in SPSS?</p> <p>I am specifically looking for references with step-by-step instructions. </p>
74,310
[ -0.018869217485189438, 0.0027387377340346575, 0.012896607629954815, 0.015476813539862633, 0.06320688128471375, -0.007157200016081333, 0.013139158487319946, -0.03009088709950447, 0.016582535579800606, 0.003400359535589814, 0.02568512037396431, 0.030180469155311584, 0.0561097115278244, 0.0011045786086469889, 0.013621282763779163, 0.003768991446122527, 0.010459735989570618, 0.010833182372152805, -0.02900589071214199, 0.007722310721874237, -0.017602063715457916, 0.03870520740747452, -0.014078282751142979, -0.011633330956101418, -0.0014727907255291939, 0.06783144176006317, 0.012692352756857872, -0.05433688685297966, 0.03331783413887024, 0.04707563295960426, -0.028277939185500145, -0.00998841691762209, -0.03578859567642212, 0.028336092829704285, 0.00046046983334235847, -0.011474194936454296, -0.029274288564920425, -0.00085593038238585, 0.005694512277841568, 0.05561599135398865, -0.03907273709774017, -0.017450902611017227, -0.004299564752727747, 0.014519184827804565, -0.012913892976939678, 0.006220961920917034, 0.0010560376103967428, -0.011055255308747292, 0.006639509927481413, -0.03555586561560631, 0.09235760569572449, 0.015452506951987743, 0.01526029221713543, 0.050749521702528, -0.008842782117426395, -0.008577150292694569, 0.053882941603660583, 0.03435629606246948, 0.016771329566836357, -0.050148122012615204, -0.03580057993531227, -0.029950793832540512, -0.03015679493546486, -0.019975757226347923, -0.030376624315977097, 0.012705286033451557, -0.0004217632522340864, -0.0020205837208777666, 0.06833790242671967, -0.01131702121347189, 0.029303429648280144, 0.014565260149538517, 0.04529138654470444, -0.043555621057748795, -0.009180048480629921, -0.030828075483441353, 0.019070254638791084, 0.009656492620706558, 0.06395208090543747, 0.02423890121281147, 0.013789376243948936, 0.02433450147509575, -0.026266973465681076, 0.02919388748705387, 0.03054765984416008, -0.03478774428367615, 0.04391281306743622, -0.03226890787482262, -0.008418813347816467, 0.0026542136911302805, 0.005101020913571119, 0.007827629335224628, 0.07354395091533661, 0.017326464876532555, -0.04253543168306351, 0.04910861328244209, -0.03322567045688629, 0.038020726293325424, 0.012047949247062206, 0.00597491255030036, -0.014495493844151497, -0.013684473000466824, 0.003978560212999582, 0.037893008440732956, -0.005826926324516535, 0.012807497754693031, 0.0069649238139390945, 0.01102910004556179, -0.00929306074976921, -0.03336690366268158, 0.0014110166812315583, 0.02598230168223381, 0.02586541697382927, 0.0007369447848759592, 0.007384023629128933, -0.013780992478132248, -0.015035729855298996, -0.03898525610566139, 0.05362551286816597, 0.06553036719560623, 0.033476874232292175, -0.04330306500196457, -0.007267426699399948, -0.011779417283833027, -0.05964402109384537, -0.004037962295114994, 0.02593291364610195, -0.022619901224970818, -0.031989313662052155, 0.03341267630457878, 0.020812243223190308, -0.004703005310148001, 0.0539957731962204, 0.023756250739097595, -0.017653850838541985, 0.03391604498028755, -0.09262785315513611, -0.08552920073270798, -0.004976743366569281, -0.02623915486037731, -0.0025796054396778345, -0.047760359942913055, -0.0123288594186306, 0.014428995549678802, 0.05141204595565796, 0.012895624153316021, 0.01831241324543953, 0.027524229139089584, 0.04333114251494408, 0.01594037190079689, -0.06110071763396263, 0.00006775691144866869, -0.03709045797586441, -0.02200915478169918, -0.023895984515547752, -0.07628696411848068, 0.03073754347860813, 0.032466888427734375, 0.0061735487543046474, -0.011153126135468483, 0.05726553499698639, 0.01167849637567997, -0.03520829975605011, -0.03383799269795418, 0.014171052724123001, 0.014787647873163223, 0.028669964522123337, -0.043900638818740845, -0.0006050729425624013, 0.009417999535799026, 0.0023556151427328587, -0.020557785406708717, 0.022763071581721306, 0.08716440945863724, 0.023419329896569252, 0.010942652821540833, -0.02805069088935852, -0.0008825220284052193, 0.012504860758781433, -0.03036378137767315, -0.03290747106075287, -0.027787402272224426, -0.024562537670135498, 0.019502170383930206, 0.010068229399621487, 0.06066438555717468, 0.015442834235727787, -0.006251275073736906, 0.019221752882003784, -0.029153846204280853, -0.04559139534831047, -0.0524209700524807, 0.041773926466703415, -0.01825256459414959, -0.022213056683540344, 0.024130597710609436, -0.021848570555448532, 0.020838400349020958, 0.008300534449517727, -0.011069003492593765, -0.0072115627117455006, 0.011131116189062595, 0.06165055185556412, -0.024269580841064453, 0.031114501878619194, 0.022972626611590385, -0.007337583694607019, -0.03320583328604698, 0.017915435135364532, -0.03667348250746727, -0.03899560868740082, 0.024154342710971832, -0.023719096556305885, 0.05956106260418892, 0.017039472237229347, -0.025535978376865387, -0.008441000245511532, 0.02178344503045082, -0.03966023027896881, 0.03431306406855583, -0.012164587154984474, 0.10827624797821045, 0.07081440091133118, -0.03456847369670868, -0.026006778702139854, 0.0018763486295938492, 0.03589292988181114, 0.00299886055290699, -0.03361796587705612, 0.030212726444005966, -0.013656250201165676, 0.0006116319564171135, 0.043031223118305206, -0.00280684232711792, -0.06503152847290039, 0.009287849068641663, 0.03700711578130722, 0.024170953780412674, 0.00257932604290545, 0.008513204753398895, -0.008965985849499702, 0.006261328235268593, 0.007437551394104958, 0.023871850222349167, 0.018664417788386345, 0.02707119658589363, -0.018455032259225845, 0.009332655929028988, 0.03129786252975464, 0.017830457538366318, 0.005698662716895342, 0.057142119854688644, 0.024407748132944107, 0.03658444061875343, -0.022914884611964226, -0.016913454979658127, 0.0588412880897522, -0.016186565160751343, 0.029686106368899345, 0.07703971862792969, -0.001311380765400827, -0.04119696468114853, 0.04630277678370476, -0.025777410715818405, 0.03020288050174713, 0.03029317408800125, -0.021611208096146584, 0.01872507482767105, 0.0011467200238257647, 0.0045999204739928246, 0.008223608136177063, -0.03105824626982212, -0.011036436073482037, -0.04773470759391785, 0.003107505152001977, 0.034687697887420654, 0.0021312162280082703, 0.045688096433877945, -0.01282428577542305, -0.004201708827167749, -0.01624930463731289, 0.01611342281103134, 0.015498613007366657, 0.024409417062997818, -0.07512595504522324, -0.030527235940098763, -0.029434803873300552, -0.003535374766215682, -0.010122457519173622, -0.023818472400307655, -0.009789620526134968, 0.03597075492143631, -0.007877998985350132, -0.05009568855166435, -0.0063549368642270565, 0.036950159817934036, -0.00992421992123127, -0.025326302275061607, -0.013648576103150845, 0.014518394134938717, -0.02574070356786251, -0.06812652200460434, 0.0005412089521996677, -0.04506374150514603, -0.03037494421005249, -0.015173552557826042, -0.011018003337085247, 0.015192775055766106, -0.004285127390176058, -0.00721706310287118, -0.003619010327383876, -0.04652082547545433, 0.01647118106484413, -0.05810921639204025, -0.03478728234767914, 0.021966179832816124, 0.01448721345514059, 0.02391129359602928, 0.009891605004668236, 0.002080122474581003, 0.029112558811903, 0.03426814824342728, -0.010909203439950943, -0.052251894026994705, 0.009994802065193653, -0.021639537066221237, -0.03150251507759094, 0.026152653619647026, 0.030499815940856934, 0.0286108311265707, -0.004099742043763399, -0.04872654750943184, 0.028328770771622658, 0.06410950422286987, 0.04124564677476883, -0.002230691025033593, 0.008444933220744133, -0.02279750630259514, -0.016055995598435402, 0.042279358953237534, 0.013154254294931889, -0.024059943854808807, 0.03471347317099571, -0.021355319768190384, 0.017720460891723633, 0.02299283631145954, -0.03504218906164169, -0.005846282001584768, -0.009988677687942982, -0.031668175011873245, -0.07694359123706818, 0.0039470684714615345, 0.014436299912631512, -0.022413721308112144, 0.004230252001434565, 0.017543388530611992, 0.0186577457934618, -0.036239732056856155, 0.00152089714538306, 0.043130338191986084, -0.007424022536724806, -0.008562327362596989, 0.005769264884293079, -0.024136818945407867, 0.007806914392858744, 0.04640347138047218, -0.025280168280005455, 0.020391983911395073, 0.04669265076518059, 0.06795140355825424, 0.05012587457895279, -0.027306050062179565, -0.04055881127715111, 0.0461605042219162, -0.06797055900096893, 0.00026915091439150274, -0.01601923257112503, 0.05138712003827095, 0.0010667205788195133, 0.01744683086872101, 0.009869053959846497, -0.014915211126208305, -0.012209189124405384, 0.034246575087308884, -0.041079647839069366, 0.033290762454271317, -0.04274224862456322, 0.012922332622110844, 0.03338248282670975, 0.013601452112197876, 0.03651369735598564, -0.012822382152080536, -0.02147274650633335, -0.014244739897549152, 0.02231251634657383, -0.04395551607012749, 0.02277745120227337, -0.010065100155770779, -0.025835221633315086, -0.001553051988594234, 0.016729913651943207, 0.010022821836173534, -0.02216869220137596, 0.024468189105391502, 0.02608397789299488, 0.01408031303435564, -0.011283975094556808, 0.02429364249110222, 0.0015342074912041426, 0.005342890042811632, 0.011344621889293194, 0.015316756442189217, 0.04270398989319801, -0.016234735026955605, 0.028689347207546234, -0.012536206282675266, 0.051637884229421616, 0.03392060473561287, -0.02649458684027195, -0.011632904410362244, -0.0328558050096035, -0.028893478214740753, -0.0067985509522259235, 0.04718030244112015, -0.01453936193138361, 0.01784539595246315, 0.044295504689216614, 0.02725975215435028, -0.08032213151454926, 0.04647691175341606, 0.017650166526436806, 0.01035095751285553, -0.038631733506917953, -0.01833564043045044, -0.014960158616304398, -0.019472332671284676, 0.004935265984386206, -0.0013666563900187612, 0.011192822828888893, -0.003401892026886344, 0.013780983164906502, 0.04443235695362091, -0.027970554307103157, -0.023648805916309357, 0.016671650111675262, 0.0016296922694891691, 0.019988911226391792, 0.006776254624128342, -0.07922617346048355, 0.037235528230667114, 0.04826045036315918, 0.027461910620331764, 0.02066696248948574, -0.001004834077320993, -0.09334622323513031, 0.015320509672164917, 0.046040236949920654, 0.052374884486198425, -0.03180218115448952, 0.022463437169790268, -0.01734102889895439, -0.07876823097467422, -0.002094755880534649, -0.027063200250267982, 0.019853150472044945, 0.004617379046976566, 0.03257925435900688, -0.0448014996945858, -0.010125157423317432, -0.062108177691698074, 0.03066285140812397, 0.015895729884505272, 0.028765052556991577, -0.012844554148614407, -0.03174806386232376, -0.04964522272348404, 0.0161228496581316, 0.024960346519947052, 0.033518917858600616, -0.03760509565472603, -0.0446779802441597, 0.011440539732575417, 0.019573375582695007, -0.012645312584936619, -0.056620243936777115, -0.022415006533265114, 0.03809870406985283, -0.033482927829027176, 0.06098826602101326, 0.02238340675830841, -0.02473025768995285, -0.007337890565395355, 0.0022297136019915342, 0.0077261049300432205, 0.025908829644322395, -0.04338216781616211, 0.07989777624607086, -0.002457186346873641, 0.008197221904993057, 0.08322031050920486, 0.03482017293572426, -0.04653048515319824, 0.00008177684503607452, -0.08354955911636353, 0.006126347463577986, -0.024830875918269157, -0.01644018106162548, -0.040889572352170944, 0.0049721491523087025, -0.01894388720393181, 0.03444706276059151, 0.013542156666517258, 0.018092751502990723, -0.024624336510896683, -0.016955101862549782, 0.016925906762480736, 0.033180736005306244, -0.006353558041155338, 0.006482364609837532, 0.014127252623438835, -0.01342819631099701, 0.01582668535411358, 0.0075322589837014675, 0.003632523352280259, -0.0034289981704205275, -0.0006342914421111345, 0.0007940582581795752, -0.03814420849084854, 0.01857704110443592, -0.027234679087996483, -0.03577912226319313, -0.020144745707511902, -0.024166565388441086, 0.015475268475711346, -0.018531499430537224, 0.02249603159725666, -0.014353768900036812, -0.035452261567115784, 0.0004799594753421843, 0.03231809660792351, 0.008520854637026787, 0.0033390603493899107, -0.02157631143927574, 0.05793267861008644, -0.03766913712024689, -0.03104233928024769, -0.04724879935383797, -0.04561633616685867, 0.010065054520964622, -0.018271444365382195, -0.022891487926244736, -0.01729501411318779, 0.02636585757136345, -0.004158923402428627, -0.031400371342897415, -0.020031876862049103, 0.058081984519958496, -0.042728155851364136, -0.007535181008279324, -0.0072727627120912075, 0.022110754624009132, 0.05210330709815025, -0.02740212343633175, -0.0037834784016013145, 0.018728096038103104, -0.018417786806821823, -0.02364683337509632, -0.038175538182258606, -0.022441312670707703, -0.029377510771155357, -0.0300371702760458, -0.03599207103252411, 0.01709531806409359, 0.05274907127022743, 0.004951529670506716, -0.008368832059204578, -0.01604866422712803, -0.043695904314517975, 0.012741276994347572, -0.033264629542827606, -0.004849815741181374, 0.005931203253567219, -0.01865275204181671, -0.013954265043139458, 0.023483624681830406, -0.06752069294452667, 0.003509411821141839, 0.02775142528116703, -0.017551595345139503, 0.001367021701298654, 0.04062400385737419, 0.0610814169049263, 0.016646336764097214, 0.07376702129840851, -0.0012077722931280732, 0.014700576663017273, 0.023337898775935173, 0.053011272102594376, 0.0145292729139328, -0.007284646388143301, -0.007187937386333942, -0.024164637550711632, -0.02709874138236046, -0.0129020931199193, -0.01655861921608448, 0.05194495618343353, 0.001878072740510106, 0.037597231566905975, 0.08667473495006561, -0.026209048926830292, -0.029750416055321693, -0.024396607652306557, 0.02596070058643818, -0.007018502801656723, 0.006702824030071497, 0.0731215626001358, 0.0018426752649247646, 0.012734876945614815, 0.03711779788136482, 0.01873847469687462, 0.034977998584508896, 0.05161638557910919, 0.03549441695213318, 0.03926189988851547, 0.015982329845428467, -0.0359409935772419, -0.0423465371131897, 0.019263755530118942, -0.03955996409058571, 0.013822176493704319, 0.017646871507167816, -0.058494191616773605, 0.034531086683273315, 0.0466107502579689, 0.0036002604756504297, -0.06066996604204178, -0.0017845936818048358, -0.007839875295758247, 0.04014373570680618, -0.004886706359684467, -0.03734871372580528, -0.0012706601992249489, -0.028125585988163948, 0.07052019983530045, -0.0155284833163023, 0.02780914679169655, 0.006413085386157036, -0.061873361468315125, 0.016019102185964584, 0.004040622152388096, -0.04304565116763115, 0.036694422364234924, -0.051664989441633224, -0.013380483724176884, 0.007075133733451366, -0.05051727965474129, 0.009590372443199158, -0.03294572979211807, 0.019049568101763725, 0.005233722738921642, 0.04734066501259804, -0.018915342167019844, 0.00739770382642746, 0.033422600477933884, 0.00003876765549648553, 0.12809666991233826, 0.08968687057495117, 0.044365596026182175, -0.04440830275416374, 0.02452125772833824, -0.003947736229747534, 0.016506098210811615, -0.022084718570113182, -0.0008120015263557434, -0.0018481810111552477, -0.012916704639792442, 0.053457729518413544, 0.04809387028217316, 0.03112088330090046, 0.0014045356074348092, 0.0742221400141716, -0.028075190261006355, -0.015160067938268185, 0.00022587353305425495, -0.017201630398631096, 0.008723046630620956, -0.058792006224393845, 0.001986878225579858, -0.009580409154295921, 0.00973760150372982, -0.0229366235435009, -0.010949859395623207, -0.02894897572696209, 0.012320559471845627, -0.009893801994621754, -0.030293729156255722, 0.008382074534893036, 0.033902741968631744, 0.01619447022676468, 0.016817277297377586, -0.023629622533917427, 0.017064765095710754, -0.0683969184756279, 0.018833860754966736, 0.04467633366584778, -0.040963027626276016, 0.0073564378544688225, 0.012230915017426014, -0.019443266093730927, -0.04063066840171814, -0.018681351095438004, -0.03018179163336754, 0.03543857857584953, -0.0015821027336642146, -0.02172214910387993, -0.06607341766357422, -0.0043260520324110985, 0.025399161502718925, -0.01690649800002575, -0.046403951942920685, 0.023463647812604904, 0.02694522775709629, -0.03350703790783882, -0.02376675233244896, -0.05801984667778015, -0.02876729518175125, 0.011398387141525745, 0.050393346697092056, 0.019724596291780472, 0.01815667748451233, -0.009676787070930004, -0.04610227048397064, 0.018065588548779488, 0.022319989278912544, 0.003150029107928276, -0.016390888020396233, 0.011968751437962055, -0.041626643389463425, 0.007883056066930294, 0.035350825637578964, 0.04591033607721329, -0.007332698907703161, -0.008034825325012207, 0.002679763361811638, -0.07728683203458786, -0.03559303656220436, 0.022607851773500443, -0.030363870784640312, -0.03272349759936333, -0.020565027371048927, -0.0023234072141349316, 0.019507331773638725, 0.03543255850672722, 0.009931026957929134, 0.016957039013504982, -0.017904669046401978, 0.040880538523197174, 0.02856101468205452, -0.06147904694080353, -0.021341770887374878, -0.028890522196888924, -0.013004282489418983, 0.0015032554510980844, -0.0028262552805244923, -0.0011311090784147382, 0.0073456051759421825, 0.0036899910774081945, -0.019303927198052406, 0.013778622262179852, 0.0008708738023415208, -0.006408718880265951, 0.02487822063267231, -0.04032258689403534, 0.0035763627383857965, -0.006750069558620453, 0.011510159820318222, -0.02414381131529808, 0.004935717210173607, -0.053758785128593445, -0.011493309400975704, 0.010975710116326809, -0.0209826547652483, 0.018614087253808975, -0.02115217223763466, -0.02749200351536274, 0.02241870015859604, -0.04426237568259239, -0.025325829163193703, -0.04531315714120865, 0.004022710490971804, 0.010388134978711605, 0.013972749002277851, -0.007565848063677549, 0.04071221128106117, 0.0029051860328763723, 0.01971879042685032, 0.027615586295723915, 0.008050961419939995, -0.003712971694767475, -0.0069227940402925014, -0.00663366774097085, -0.006532934028655291, 0.040499888360500336, 0.005229718517512083, -0.029091866686940193, 0.026842018589377403, -0.05818246304988861, -0.0020437848288565874, 0.013112910091876984, -0.01842394843697548, 0.03865056112408638, 0.0010489424457773566, 0.021724244579672813, -0.024139270186424255, 0.016329502686858177, -0.000026478133804630488, -0.030585534870624542, -0.01081258524209261, 0.049270205199718475, -0.03160609304904938, 0.014675026759505272, -0.005168684292584658, 0.003960503730922937, -0.02658083662390709, 0.057331208139657974, 0.045469731092453, 0.0013824227498844266, -0.03205504268407822, 0.02933238260447979, -0.03269809111952782, -0.014404939487576485, 0.000591081683523953, -0.015744276344776154, 0.028266457840800285, 0.049638450145721436, -0.012887735851109028, 0.02521432936191559, -0.010603455826640129, 0.009971949271857738, -0.06630532443523407, -0.02818080224096775, 0.00030677521135658026, 0.011259025894105434, 0.01226715836673975, -0.05108204483985901, -0.00966479629278183, 0.013844910077750683, -0.013891331851482391, 0.0031589397694915533, -0.004119458608329296, -0.024075688794255257, -0.02172110043466091, 0.03753433749079704, -0.020763132721185684, 0.023458756506443024, 0.015073643997311592, 0.026650970801711082, -0.01351953949779272, 0.013369720429182053, 0.008406402543187141, -0.0048334673047065735, 0.004760428797453642, -0.006322950590401888, 0.04380575194954872, -0.06976676732301712, 0.03791986033320427, -0.03372185304760933, -0.013475816696882248, 0.029539242386817932, 0.01176921371370554, 0.031127724796533585, 0.03257517144083977, 0.026204153895378113, -0.00042615801794454455, 0.05231385678052902, 0.017216302454471588, -0.0024666241370141506, -0.006701904349029064, 0.03100587986409664, 0.03745913505554199, 0.03362594544887543, -0.04069671779870987, 0.01758691668510437, 0.041752249002456665, -0.035862043499946594, -0.000708478968590498, 0.013648968189954758, -0.03057916648685932, 0.013350504450500011, -0.005429517012089491, -0.05522145703434944, 0.0010585904819890857, -0.025065530091524124, 0.006674527190625668, -0.05436732992529869, -0.03507113456726074, 0.05751428380608559, -0.0027701195795089006, -0.005885399878025055, 0.02148548699915409, 0.0016333261737599969, -0.045951347798109055, 0.0203113853931427, 0.027386117726564407, -0.006096389144659042, -0.021003101021051407, -0.036572057753801346, 0.002956429962068796, -0.018493546172976494, -0.017431896179914474, 0.03013237938284874, -0.014312110841274261, 0.023844655603170395, -0.04626326262950897, 0.016684219241142273, 0.017619717866182327, -0.02643836848437786, 0.022204497829079628, -0.03502962365746498, 0.04025872051715851, 0.01876317709684372, -0.018808910623192787, -0.044184111058712006, 0.005317464005202055, -0.01364954374730587, 0.01424270961433649, 0.02450559474527836, -0.058584682643413544, -0.004353338852524757, -0.028976650908589363, 0.01778547093272209, 0.007756542880088091, -0.04796478524804115, 0.07144571095705032, -0.0048509868793189526, -0.020565368235111237, -0.030286846682429314, -0.013448404148221016, 0.0075677912682294846, -0.0223949383944273, 0.028801456093788147, -0.047456882894039154, 0.0079445019364357, 0.0035148707684129477, -0.02560270018875599, 0.03809083253145218, 0.013267217203974724, -0.03270145133137703, 0.01563101075589657, -0.0279392022639513, 0.010785192251205444, 0.07948602735996246, -0.023787079378962517, 0.0025115348398685455, 0.030408242717385292, -0.005543690640479326, -0.015418987721204758, -0.014212623238563538, 0.0287327840924263, -0.009409609250724316, -0.0738101378083229, 0.025947775691747665, 0.048271581530570984, -0.037304338067770004, 0.0020070946775376797, 0.07493085414171219, 0.011443703435361385, 0.018216734752058983, -0.008105017244815826, -0.0019472978310659528, 0.004636441357433796, -0.034912750124931335, 0.017522424459457397, 0.020613206550478935, 0.043157078325748444, 0.011891337111592293, -0.018462996929883957, 0.038190003484487534, -0.006680203601717949, 0.03958030045032501, -0.037311337888240814, 0.010906745679676533, -0.03913285955786705, 0.007556065917015076, 0.05438385158777237, 0.02681672014296055, 0.05030183866620064, 0.005332924425601959, -0.030628088861703873, 0.04576466977596283, -0.061911337077617645, -0.02108871564269066, -0.017380602657794952, -0.01137976348400116, -0.06883380562067032, -0.0006169387488625944, 0.035324566066265106, 0.05171035975217819, 0.007491808384656906, 0.025294702500104904, -0.02249394729733467, -0.035833582282066345, 0.013163947500288486, -0.022418539971113205, 0.032564517110586166, -0.033504970371723175, -0.008648976683616638, -0.026787566021084785, -0.02983054332435131, -0.0354495495557785, -0.04975781962275505, 0.0033528271596878767, 0.008334994316101074, -0.016397060826420784, -0.07305729389190674, -0.0109681012108922, 0.03546403348445892, 0.0347711443901062, -0.0284698735922575, -0.012373807840049267, -0.018402040004730225, 0.04924912005662918, -0.02254217490553856, -0.007118450477719307 ]
<p>I have a time series data set. I can decompose it and get the trend but I would like to put confidence ranges around the trend (past) not the forecast-ed component. The decompose function also doesn't handle N/As very well so is there another way to define the trend with data that has N/As. I have been trying to use Holt-Winters and ARIMA but neither seem to be able to do this.</p>
74,311
[ 0.03734196722507477, -0.028421614319086075, -0.013247172348201275, 0.013499262742698193, 0.018757617101073265, -0.016089502722024918, -0.007527971174567938, -0.002273482270538807, 0.03308240696787834, -0.05231275036931038, 0.0054880897514522076, 0.019711114466190338, 0.03567586466670036, 0.014049072749912739, 0.007540756370872259, 0.003947502002120018, -0.02213706076145172, 0.002642570063471794, -0.004190783016383648, -0.031078120693564415, -0.005770108196884394, 0.0127185620367527, -0.022350532934069633, 0.012963274493813515, 0.008423504419624805, 0.030535154044628143, 0.049478910863399506, -0.02337895706295967, 0.018135642632842064, 0.08543608337640762, -0.06518986821174622, -0.05319039151072502, 0.0017767692916095257, 0.07500691711902618, 0.03002399019896984, -0.004935898818075657, -0.012741515412926674, -0.04028462618589401, -0.02662188746035099, 0.04776715859770775, -0.030003156512975693, 0.009239698760211468, 0.016051510348916054, 0.041787102818489075, -0.016186121851205826, 0.035837531089782715, 0.004080025013536215, -0.029137928038835526, 0.01277710497379303, -0.040109533816576004, 0.10864897817373276, -0.03729948401451111, 0.0497330017387867, 0.04404963552951813, -0.02573433704674244, 0.0016204573912546039, 0.0642300546169281, 0.04368405044078827, 0.001704999478533864, -0.055995967239141464, -0.012867240235209465, -0.01613917201757431, 0.0004986340063624084, -0.03832792863249779, -0.024563539773225784, -0.020344143733382225, -0.022230612114071846, -0.0032702924218028784, 0.037217166274785995, -0.013824332505464554, 0.0138556445017457, 0.018669230863451958, 0.02847725711762905, -0.007426952011883259, -0.006452368106693029, -0.03879253566265106, 0.0013637058436870575, 0.0062002441845834255, 0.06285983324050903, 0.017421212047338486, 0.008501344360411167, 0.017670271918177605, 0.03891121223568916, 0.030758287757635117, 0.035044070333242416, -0.002279621548950672, 0.07060839235782623, -0.05001407861709595, -0.0033095763064920902, 0.060980524867773056, -0.03417328745126724, -0.01291683129966259, 0.05434868857264519, 0.0037919250316917896, -0.021938087418675423, -0.018295465037226677, -0.016280855983495712, 0.04531604424118996, 0.007600715383887291, -0.001741992891766131, 0.021121365949511528, -0.03247233107686043, 0.021704278886318207, 0.02046189084649086, -0.019313719123601913, 0.036044761538505554, -0.01070642564445734, -0.04807857424020767, 0.00958183128386736, -0.02058611623942852, -0.01679403707385063, 0.0047341627068817616, 0.021397311240434647, -0.0041946424171328545, 0.013185735791921616, 0.00660321582108736, -0.04827621579170227, -0.02062959223985672, 0.015853242948651314, 0.07260481268167496, 0.04407743737101555, 0.003359046997502446, 0.02016400918364525, -0.009420567192137241, -0.05776265263557434, -0.005816957447677851, -0.011604800820350647, -0.003443284658715129, -0.014977547340095043, 0.04772127419710159, -0.05750439688563347, -0.05349316820502281, 0.049056366086006165, -0.0011887690052390099, 0.06560414284467697, -0.043248482048511505, -0.056248851120471954, -0.032183967530727386, 0.004801367875188589, -0.022488651797175407, 0.01225070096552372, -0.04001641273498535, 0.04114148020744324, 0.019480807706713676, 0.019503798335790634, 0.04728182777762413, -0.0022737092804163694, 0.0291969645768404, 0.0324932299554348, 0.006878180429339409, -0.05161653831601143, -0.021118242293596268, 0.00024941033916547894, 0.005981196649372578, -0.021252157166600227, -0.04269209876656532, 0.05397217348217964, 0.036619655787944794, -0.016070988029241562, 0.010355425998568535, 0.03304349631071091, -0.001979058375582099, -0.04684785008430481, -0.014220480807125568, 0.026076482608914375, -0.02326887845993042, 0.07302496582269669, -0.018180081620812416, 0.002239141147583723, 0.00208694813773036, -0.002109949942678213, 0.00789636466652155, 0.021529724821448326, 0.03977449610829353, 0.08465611934661865, -0.023907996714115143, 0.012792781926691532, -0.03684727102518082, -0.022541886195540428, 0.01642172783613205, -0.016740411520004272, -0.04388440400362015, -0.012938980013132095, -0.024619635194540024, 0.014030130580067635, 0.013265895657241344, 0.00769012188538909, -0.05955629050731659, 0.03426302224397659, -0.0843244418501854, -0.005044176243245602, -0.05636560544371605, -0.006974811665713787, -0.008204524405300617, 0.02115142159163952, -0.010426538996398449, 0.00541485333815217, 0.04397295042872429, -0.0007076415349729359, -0.039675693958997726, -0.01326410099864006, -0.027282878756523132, 0.03280829265713692, -0.06915996223688126, 0.010657227598130703, 0.04059116542339325, 0.02683309093117714, -0.03293734788894653, 0.06735367327928543, -0.024942655116319656, -0.03409537672996521, 0.009484163485467434, -0.05610593408346176, 0.01605583168566227, 0.024338802322745323, 0.00295467977412045, 0.02210162580013275, -0.005088834557682276, -0.013919690623879433, 0.04320594295859337, -0.042610302567481995, 0.025907889008522034, 0.028235403820872307, 0.0008400891092605889, -0.0013037557946518064, -0.033610280603170395, 0.043295808136463165, -0.005131862126290798, -0.03391381353139877, -0.013832991011440754, -0.03645068034529686, 0.024241743609309196, 0.06122344732284546, 0.04654666781425476, -0.05277230963110924, 0.0013174964115023613, 0.10360922664403915, 0.004589924588799477, 0.05008229985833168, 0.059170398861169815, -0.01827338896691799, 0.003673361614346504, -0.020281780511140823, 0.0005873565678484738, 0.019730644300580025, -0.00862858910113573, -0.006568653509020805, 0.02516723982989788, 0.029959307983517647, 0.050249263644218445, 0.00023244191834237427, 0.04056892171502113, 0.041574638336896896, 0.001593549270182848, -0.021226294338703156, -0.04222780093550682, 0.03419513255357742, -0.06938391923904419, -0.02684531919658184, 0.016602737829089165, 0.018998214974999428, -0.01348497811704874, 0.03762767091393471, -0.027977803722023964, 0.03741935268044472, 0.045804060995578766, -0.005945886485278606, 0.0027680699713528156, 0.03037129156291485, 0.00855227094143629, -0.0063748229295015335, -0.04757313057780266, -0.008348328992724419, -0.06369002908468246, -0.0037278146483004093, 0.03838770091533661, -0.005201275926083326, 0.020936807617545128, -0.012680753134191036, -0.009053018875420094, 0.008561896160244942, -0.03028876520693302, -0.011318732984364033, 0.007607176899909973, -0.03495056554675102, -0.012746812775731087, 0.008402971550822258, -0.06672534346580505, 0.04277338460087776, 0.004046089015901089, -0.009598941542208195, 0.020319947972893715, -0.03898262605071068, -0.044089723378419876, -0.012057238258421421, -0.053699176758527756, -0.02535046823322773, -0.015770195052027702, -0.007348217070102692, 0.056486211717128754, 0.015455404296517372, -0.021542105823755264, -0.009362581185996532, -0.03162003308534622, 0.007603055331856012, -0.08657300472259521, -0.012408885173499584, -0.004277679603546858, -0.002860857406631112, 0.03402889892458916, -0.0019767782650887966, -0.006151306442916393, 0.04225904494524002, -0.03505401685833931, -0.03359987959265709, 0.001816967036575079, 0.011010635644197464, 0.03217180445790291, 0.03482017666101456, -0.011827470734715462, 0.05851934477686882, 0.025660065934062004, -0.04461310803890228, -0.04572107642889023, -0.017083706334233284, -0.014395046979188919, -0.057096611708402634, 0.016823017969727516, 0.008821604773402214, -0.0023997751995921135, 0.008526124991476536, -0.04178348183631897, 0.012945140711963177, 0.037066131830215454, -0.0005251092370599508, -0.032780446112155914, 0.02599046751856804, 0.020424719899892807, 0.035013388842344284, 0.045020367950201035, 0.005939781200140715, -0.028323795646429062, 0.0033998312428593636, -0.0239416416734457, 0.04461589828133583, 0.03681035712361336, -0.05326010286808014, 0.013033182360231876, -0.0052581047639250755, 0.0022229505702853203, -0.035621050745248795, -0.0012375450460240245, -0.004196008201688528, 0.017350077629089355, 0.01593550480902195, 0.038515523076057434, 0.024766240268945694, 0.01880253106355667, -0.011886777356266975, 0.054417677223682404, 0.028402162715792656, -0.017536060884594917, -0.006884950678795576, -0.018212728202342987, -0.011068698950111866, 0.02283540740609169, -0.024503229185938835, 0.010832457803189754, 0.028541844338178635, 0.01466841995716095, 0.049771010875701904, 0.02273164689540863, -0.05083777755498886, 0.00932698231190443, -0.0704990103840828, -0.011183559894561768, -0.009544728323817253, 0.06338371336460114, -0.0011697662994265556, 0.04943985119462013, 0.039952196180820465, 0.001215233700349927, 0.054327208548784256, -0.01237963605672121, -0.07677262276411057, 0.05832701921463013, -0.015254197642207146, -0.01112024299800396, -0.008698252961039543, -0.00045707845129072666, 0.0029996612574905157, -0.025092847645282745, -0.016446292400360107, -0.0033707316033542156, 0.02013210766017437, -0.03212222829461098, 0.009955736808478832, -0.01595293916761875, -0.01183935347944498, -0.037074748426675797, -0.011913543567061424, 0.015466044656932354, -0.009880765341222286, 0.048136260360479355, 0.031125744804739952, 0.040824633091688156, -0.017842857167124748, -0.008341459557414055, 0.02525300346314907, 0.002210787497460842, 0.014527937397360802, 0.03484155610203743, 0.008759524673223495, -0.04756946116685867, 0.017979485914111137, 0.001266309292986989, 0.04071156308054924, 0.02317933738231659, 0.0014734134310856462, -0.012056338600814342, -0.007211719639599323, -0.030701279640197754, 0.025211680680513382, 0.00807230081409216, 0.03078840859234333, 0.020118502900004387, 0.04267306625843048, 0.012510734610259533, -0.04388886317610741, -0.002237338339909911, 0.08847952634096146, -0.0029991946648806334, 0.0053855180740356445, -0.02530921809375286, 0.020888425409793854, 0.001162874628789723, 0.017759904265403748, -0.0030843529384583235, 0.0035204605665057898, 0.029606325551867485, 0.002992216730490327, 0.04732589051127434, -0.02428796887397766, -0.034496892243623734, 0.0064561194740235806, 0.056917089968919754, 0.06009945273399353, 0.01931554079055786, -0.040733713656663895, 0.02820918709039688, 0.027991363778710365, 0.031168732792139053, 0.05066002905368805, 0.0003359261609148234, -0.12367845326662064, 0.026886915788054466, 0.05414822697639465, 0.02793847769498825, -0.00370515463873744, -0.0489424504339695, -0.06584788858890533, -0.014562679454684258, 0.07325096428394318, -0.010905798524618149, 0.007700243499130011, -0.02509792521595955, 0.006239515263587236, -0.011377032846212387, -0.013622285798192024, -0.02054814249277115, 0.016757681965827942, -0.025690993294119835, 0.05019976198673248, -0.030626054853200912, -0.0534353144466877, -0.04200759530067444, 0.013224441558122635, 0.011346961371600628, 0.07251440733671188, -0.003142084227874875, -0.020086897537112236, -0.004741259850561619, 0.015209092758595943, -0.039702966809272766, -0.04835855960845947, 0.02207542397081852, -0.005207844078540802, 0.003157472936436534, 0.009736040607094765, 0.009596236981451511, -0.02090292237699032, 0.0009401307906955481, -0.008567774668335915, -0.022144164890050888, -0.011298389174044132, -0.010376336984336376, 0.06162417307496071, 0.01008349098265171, -0.005312345456331968, 0.03875429928302765, 0.0396258644759655, 0.038810502737760544, 0.016568098217248917, -0.048686228692531586, 0.013043977320194244, -0.03492441400885582, 0.018733123317360878, -0.03954271972179413, -0.012028414756059647, -0.04126535728573799, -0.012002003379166126, -0.01832757145166397, 0.026461953297257423, -0.0057210070081055164, -0.019224509596824646, 0.03162813559174538, 0.03065778873860836, -0.01049550250172615, -0.005248315166682005, -0.0041965339332818985, 0.004282672889530659, -0.03933302313089371, -0.004399244207888842, 0.00957544520497322, -0.004133020061999559, 0.005037812516093254, 0.012220699340105057, -0.026617880910634995, 0.04102393239736557, -0.01270294189453125, -0.012646973133087158, 0.01709628850221634, -0.025076450780034065, 0.0380399264395237, -0.02691076323390007, 0.008131357841193676, -0.0020801564678549767, -0.030796099454164505, 0.015560416504740715, 0.033753402531147, 0.008904949761927128, 0.01860133744776249, -0.051352884620428085, 0.018977617844939232, 0.024957463145256042, -0.014398285187780857, -0.0757637619972229, -0.058870166540145874, 0.027413057163357735, 0.025059737265110016, -0.03957629203796387, -0.02813900262117386, -0.02025669813156128, -0.02378121018409729, 0.0028205171693116426, -0.04115752875804901, 0.04103589802980423, -0.005903236102312803, -0.016492094844579697, 0.008028733544051647, 0.03547963872551918, 0.056308113038539886, 0.002965970430523157, 0.024609273299574852, 0.004796466324478388, 0.01085995975881815, 0.005677234381437302, -0.0021785518620163202, 0.013272123411297798, -0.03705814853310585, 0.028405455872416496, -0.011754504404962063, 0.0032851318828761578, 0.07212740927934647, -0.026034317910671234, 0.007940933108329773, 0.02880029007792473, 0.01408901996910572, 0.023574108257889748, -0.025223080068826675, 0.00804060511291027, -0.052268922328948975, 0.00015187589451670647, -0.02887360192835331, -0.014990769326686859, -0.014443041756749153, -0.031448572874069214, 0.014634591527283192, -0.030628276988863945, 0.02274417132139206, 0.006440338678658009, 0.029875721782445908, -0.002188293496146798, -0.03264226019382477, -0.017390858381986618, -0.008014424704015255, 0.02666817046701908, 0.06545137614011765, 0.0011801040964201093, -0.00928752776235342, -0.01409309171140194, -0.027191907167434692, -0.05115135759115219, -0.0028360621072351933, -0.029977478086948395, 0.0599142462015152, 0.0018804013961926103, 0.04413250833749771, 0.008229412138462067, 0.04083647578954697, -0.016070513054728508, -0.031625308096408844, -0.039091482758522034, 0.02535758726298809, -0.012044668197631836, 0.036685045808553696, 0.01087629608809948, 0.023501211777329445, -0.01845131814479828, 0.02929425984621048, 0.023101793602108955, 0.10552282631397247, 0.011644759215414524, -0.0006547269294969738, 0.019591836258769035, 0.02409498393535614, -0.010556906461715698, 0.017979012802243233, -0.04398446902632713, -0.009003781713545322, -0.029460569843649864, -0.014007117599248886, 0.013058464974164963, 0.020730750635266304, -0.02917948178946972, -0.023192642256617546, -0.024696683511137962, -0.04246814176440239, 0.0072263493202626705, 0.01864546537399292, -0.040887314826250076, 0.02366594411432743, 0.06946517527103424, 0.029747730121016502, -0.010314274579286575, 0.019175177440047264, -0.01585371419787407, -0.022197198122739792, 0.005980744492262602, -0.048058152198791504, -0.023320602253079414, -0.007007952313870192, 0.0031308219768106937, -0.01923675835132599, -0.0012467498891055584, 0.02462375909090042, 0.009597253985702991, 0.003939989488571882, 0.030763542279601097, 0.051644932478666306, 0.08517028391361237, 0.014539345167577267, 0.0355093739926815, -0.022781051695346832, 0.01011066697537899, 0.13820423185825348, 0.08650471270084381, 0.022944431751966476, -0.06471974402666092, -0.015360234305262566, -0.008770324289798737, -0.006826029624789953, -0.03938254714012146, 0.011417881585657597, 0.0403137281537056, -0.0070135099813342094, 0.04897207394242287, 0.0804603099822998, -0.011974680237472057, 0.0004608008894138038, 0.07310544699430466, -0.015299675986170769, 0.013617755845189095, -0.003508293069899082, 0.021455636247992516, -0.018227193504571915, 0.00016018211317714304, -0.08053038269281387, 0.03925514221191406, 0.01330362819135189, -0.0177411288022995, 0.006593025755137205, -0.030095700174570084, -0.0037064100615680218, 0.011408455669879913, -0.02296159602701664, 0.009862709790468216, 0.03028547763824463, 0.016878774389624596, 0.012743493542075157, -0.021237904205918312, 0.012512695044279099, -0.027682937681674957, -0.010640772059559822, 0.0017143774311989546, 0.03893454372882843, -0.010821403004229069, -0.029854711145162582, -0.016769567504525185, -0.03628180921077728, -0.012384099885821342, -0.050350990146398544, 0.012760602869093418, -0.0023578498512506485, -0.023835254833102226, 0.028743917122483253, 0.002914374228566885, -0.016196101903915405, -0.006121717393398285, -0.006746084429323673, 0.018596600741147995, 0.019764956086874008, -0.017474638298153877, -0.03104032762348652, -0.028218749910593033, -0.00861454475671053, 0.0018142042681574821, 0.05045762658119202, 0.03634946048259735, -0.010030499659478664, -0.0058190650306642056, -0.03188658133149147, 0.031757988035678864, -0.020454496145248413, -0.026389149948954582, 0.05503586307168007, -0.017023339867591858, -0.043517425656318665, -0.005224722903221846, 0.04443508759140968, -0.010098223574459553, 0.014240934513509274, -0.0003725802816916257, -0.003046192228794098, 0.03883073851466179, -0.020674876868724823, 0.024692989885807037, -0.045832131057977676, -0.025207674130797386, -0.004747055936604738, -0.010266861878335476, 0.020113103091716766, 0.017492257058620453, -0.000011453485967649613, 0.0227491557598114, -0.026264382526278496, 0.05721327289938927, 0.05929797887802124, -0.07763909548521042, -0.03104744292795658, -0.0076752896420657635, -0.05529162660241127, -0.00304787396453321, -0.025280844420194626, 0.07244411110877991, 0.02932029590010643, -0.026363642886281013, -0.03177886828780174, 0.01968882791697979, -0.024677174165844917, 0.02640916034579277, 0.015444706194102764, -0.0616610087454319, 0.018888700753450394, 0.014117143116891384, 0.012058338150382042, -0.031772736459970474, -0.034453969448804855, -0.030238119885325432, -0.010692386887967587, -0.005394743289798498, -0.03582998737692833, -0.039693329483270645, 0.05331200733780861, -0.0009589561959728599, -0.02210118994116783, -0.03246840462088585, 0.010308627970516682, -0.04254411906003952, -0.031571220606565475, -0.031503647565841675, -0.011661455035209656, 0.010489515960216522, 0.018766703084111214, -0.0416535884141922, 0.021198656409978867, 0.07467080652713776, 0.0029566630255430937, 0.0037764310836791992, -0.01933668553829193, 0.010468188673257828, -0.03194735199213028, 0.055183496326208115, -0.016600286588072777, -0.022126222029328346, 0.02539052441716194, -0.01243381667882204, -0.04903605952858925, 0.011947526596486568, 0.03284766152501106, -0.0017818480264395475, -0.0060288370586931705, -0.021547960117459297, -0.022037941962480545, 0.036097414791584015, -0.021362844854593277, 0.004454344045370817, -0.020072435960173607, -0.006531174294650555, 0.0203708428889513, 0.014257910661399364, -0.012069891206920147, 0.024592097848653793, -0.004638276994228363, 0.0031888841185718775, 0.04095887765288353, 0.030844703316688538, 0.004390015732496977, 0.02590051479637623, -0.009455396793782711, 0.02417864091694355, 0.0035541383549571037, -0.0030208041425794363, 0.04453834518790245, 0.0485963448882103, -0.03416292369365692, -0.0016779263969510794, -0.028754012659192085, 0.03440326824784279, -0.024511365219950676, 0.003383804112672806, -0.03347376361489296, -0.022783033549785614, 0.04582379013299942, -0.057575199753046036, -0.013333497568964958, 0.009848914109170437, -0.007022578734904528, 0.0023547129239887, -0.01218490768224001, 0.006693889386951923, -0.008807976730167866, -0.021512936800718307, -0.013962437398731709, 0.012212219648063183, 0.025462692603468895, 0.04743198677897453, -0.0006262835231609643, 0.015541864559054375, 0.027827762067317963, -0.05141264572739601, -0.019369235262274742, -0.014504903927445412, 0.035487592220306396, -0.06693412363529205, 0.004902439657598734, -0.035665277391672134, -0.037600480020046234, 0.03647018224000931, -0.03262903168797493, 0.01810099557042122, 0.040474291890859604, 0.03072340413928032, 0.008186610415577888, 0.044733259826898575, 0.020019996911287308, -0.002603791421279311, 0.0032227602787315845, 0.005953055340796709, -0.005507461726665497, -0.0012650417629629374, -0.011955125257372856, 0.012628358788788319, 0.01079589780420065, -0.04067113250494003, -0.052041616290807724, 0.01563214883208275, -0.008649522438645363, 0.01626467891037464, -0.01025274209678173, -0.0011053947964683175, -0.022127751260995865, -0.03266656771302223, 0.01785867288708687, -0.012209189124405384, 0.0005196875426918268, 0.03049430064857006, -0.010507323779165745, -0.008595607243478298, 0.003607659600675106, 0.004324716050177813, -0.05765412747859955, -0.013246527872979641, -0.0027984213083982468, 0.01141462754458189, -0.041267164051532745, 0.00465799868106842, -0.00876616220921278, 0.005173642188310623, -0.029299098998308182, -0.0021836753003299236, -0.011901858262717724, 0.033881813287734985, -0.034728772938251495, 0.0022133432794362307, 0.03906315937638283, -0.010183703154325485, 0.002577492967247963, -0.08420959115028381, 0.046010714024305344, 0.015093788504600525, -0.01919812150299549, -0.03502960130572319, 0.00007557278877357021, -0.026218125596642494, 0.00855337269604206, 0.023463863879442215, -0.0034307572059333324, 0.031858738511800766, 0.016966136172413826, 0.029405366629362106, 0.019060537219047546, -0.03746793419122696, 0.05143347010016441, -0.03155482932925224, -0.020549021661281586, 0.004115380346775055, -0.024475572630763054, -0.009051154367625713, 0.005338446237146854, -0.0017125692684203386, 0.011436277069151402, 0.005413771141320467, 0.05208597704768181, 0.011669524013996124, -0.019079716876149178, 0.009624209254980087, -0.017863651737570763, 0.030491860583424568, -0.008420576341450214, -0.026349054649472237, 0.012816689908504486, 0.022469084709882736, -0.036938413977622986, 0.06321705132722855, -0.043971531093120575, -0.0493556372821331, 0.015031627379357815, 0.002474922686815262, 0.012023048475384712, -0.05871780961751938, -0.057422760874032974, 0.008228793740272522, -0.0282636359333992, 0.04893678054213524, 0.015462981536984444, -0.02973630465567112, 0.03043465130031109, -0.02232726849615574, 0.0046025533229112625, 0.02599712274968624, -0.0002395426417933777, 0.00391188682988286, -0.012267300859093666, 0.030939385294914246, -0.023257585242390633, 0.030801519751548767, 0.013366752304136753, -0.03592701628804207, 0.02982739545404911, 0.007494425401091576, 0.014772937633097172, 0.005861435551196337, -0.0314856693148613, 0.0362202525138855, -0.016220659017562866, 0.0387035571038723, 0.014967196621000767, -0.014209859073162079, 0.019487176090478897, -0.05239822715520859, 0.023402323946356773, -0.06181463226675987, -0.025846153497695923, -0.0522485114634037, 0.02551770955324173, -0.003204371314495802, -0.021353676915168762, -0.0068829720839858055, 0.019625164568424225, 0.03687715530395508, -0.014375929720699787, 0.016857776790857315, -0.028678622096776962, 0.010923956520855427, -0.0197504460811615, 0.006835274863988161, -0.04319949820637703, -0.021420421078801155, -0.051025066524744034, -0.026522614061832428, -0.01423297356814146, 0.02144443430006504, 0.03872878849506378, -0.003958968445658684, -0.021355874836444855, -0.010320823639631271, 0.03509053960442543, -0.07594870775938034, -0.020803796127438545, -0.02918810211122036, 0.0023126578889787197, 0.0032572313211858273, -0.050598807632923126 ]
<p>I have a data set and I have to fit this data set with a stable distribution. The problem is that the stable distributions are known analytically only in the form of the characteristic function (Fourier transform). How can I do this?</p>
74,312
[ -0.009554736316204071, -0.017097651958465576, 0.002872519427910447, -0.016775228083133698, 0.029604032635688782, 0.0023440036457031965, -0.015229111537337303, 0.007829483598470688, 0.010860980488359928, -0.05278187617659569, 0.045569125562906265, 0.051631052047014236, 0.03126730024814606, 0.02164020948112011, 0.039550185203552246, 0.00940299965441227, -0.0088445283472538, 0.02982581965625286, -0.02781965583562851, -0.015722351148724556, 0.00704239821061492, 0.007530162576586008, 0.01375544723123312, -0.011963406577706337, -0.052710872143507004, 0.03869653865695, 0.02863324247300625, -0.0035789310932159424, 0.014802682213485241, 0.05814637616276741, -0.062132127583026886, -0.013500007800757885, 0.018722189590334892, 0.06849147379398346, -0.01004813052713871, 0.004845161456614733, -0.02603357844054699, 0.0004509956925176084, -0.015464723110198975, 0.04319629445672035, -0.05917968228459358, -0.02876237779855728, 0.01939891092479229, 0.057162806391716, -0.004497237503528595, 0.008945545181632042, 0.014715136960148811, -0.05402858555316925, 0.01919005624949932, -0.029903557151556015, 0.11517847329378128, -0.01771305873990059, 0.054410673677921295, 0.04944263771176338, -0.019125187769532204, -0.03235623612999916, 0.06353782117366791, 0.07073866575956345, -0.02600468508899212, -0.05636382848024368, -0.0489749014377594, -0.020054642111063004, -0.014627800323069096, -0.019386759027838707, -0.0037301424890756607, 0.016881950199604034, -0.013580149970948696, -0.05057639256119728, 0.04382728040218353, -0.01371810119599104, 0.028202101588249207, 0.0587700679898262, 0.028884729370474815, -0.047497402876615524, -0.0010247069876641035, -0.005955884233117104, 0.01613973267376423, -0.003479823237285018, 0.059762995690107346, 0.0027814314235001802, 0.041274409741163254, 0.03542652726173401, 0.025650769472122192, 0.03560328856110573, 0.011375878006219864, -0.016877375543117523, 0.07303689420223236, 0.01577027514576912, 0.015142509713768959, 0.05009637027978897, -0.018755637109279633, 0.007322072517126799, 0.08265066891908646, -0.02445369027554989, -0.025754740461707115, 0.03783540800213814, -0.008345021866261959, 0.06721210479736328, -0.01491113007068634, -0.026373520493507385, -0.001337185618467629, -0.03421434387564659, 0.014478412456810474, 0.06438164412975311, 0.006934171076864004, 0.011167203076183796, -0.041209883987903595, -0.010650782845914364, -0.0166143961250782, -0.012843621894717216, 0.03554609790444374, 0.028527451679110527, 0.009229389019310474, 0.013788988813757896, 0.026370255276560783, 0.021178610622882843, -0.023675458505749702, -0.06150946021080017, 0.03511635586619377, 0.07195267826318741, 0.026820171624422073, -0.010980944149196148, 0.01974480040371418, -0.0015831169439479709, -0.042016588151454926, 0.008036745712161064, 0.010155717842280865, -0.019888725131750107, -0.03011719137430191, 0.03739171475172043, -0.020310774445533752, -0.037339914590120316, 0.021126212552189827, -0.024851001799106598, 0.029955418780446053, -0.006625791545957327, -0.05604151263833046, -0.02479350008070469, -0.005668784491717815, -0.02100466750562191, -0.01721811294555664, -0.04935323819518089, -0.0153652997687459, 0.07468326389789581, 0.05552154779434204, 0.004487115889787674, 0.017400987446308136, -0.009428096935153008, 0.027266407385468483, -0.020946117118000984, -0.009473241865634918, -0.047568563371896744, -0.01072006393224001, -0.022840213030576706, -0.017090804874897003, -0.04822797700762749, 0.014704708941280842, -0.006785670295357704, -0.014498640783131123, -0.01988842710852623, 0.019805464893579483, -0.003284912323579192, -0.01727893017232418, -0.021181656047701836, 0.008655427023768425, -0.009387584403157234, 0.059961143881082535, -0.005379908252507448, 0.013212707825005054, 0.00034049272653646767, -0.022978900000452995, 0.002380369696766138, 0.012501382268965244, 0.045785143971443176, 0.03488284349441528, -0.004922224208712578, 0.005405473988503218, -0.017444023862481117, 0.020259924232959747, 0.00817127525806427, 0.0007824805798009038, -0.028310973197221756, 0.001992350211367011, -0.007936076261103153, 0.032970041036605835, 0.055125266313552856, 0.02608639933168888, 0.008551934733986855, 0.04296467453241348, -0.03870277479290962, -0.0034492630511522293, -0.047463688999414444, -0.009927439503371716, -0.02338867075741291, -0.018590042367577553, 0.0189043078571558, 0.014590246602892876, 0.006590503733605146, -0.018854184076189995, -0.027491319924592972, -0.005473110359162092, -0.04082304984331131, 0.020653173327445984, -0.03662559762597084, 0.016292711719870567, 0.04064522311091423, 0.06217651814222336, -0.026550836861133575, 0.05661537125706673, -0.007472041994333267, -0.014282414689660072, -0.0231215450912714, -0.04499465599656105, 0.02192622795701027, 0.0016948030097410083, -0.013251000083982944, 0.009885505773127079, 0.007848251610994339, 0.016877058893442154, 0.022960269823670387, -0.01984989643096924, 0.0421222522854805, 0.06602785736322403, 0.019397011026740074, 0.009676962159574032, 0.015341488644480705, -0.016838209703564644, 0.019537804648280144, 0.007136649917811155, -0.032402485609054565, -0.07361616939306259, -0.012296119704842567, 0.05372626334428787, 0.044973086565732956, -0.0625392347574234, 0.0033586788922548294, 0.09052452445030212, 0.03468339517712593, 0.05145961791276932, 0.02753031812608242, -0.02084614336490631, -0.011601732112467289, 0.028658058494329453, -0.03495759144425392, 0.0253059733659029, -0.001094192499294877, 0.03502914682030678, 0.028901364654302597, 0.009255753830075264, 0.02525535598397255, -0.018949031829833984, 0.03631385788321495, 0.02246711030602455, -0.002661062404513359, -0.004557011183351278, -0.025527680292725563, 0.01804034598171711, -0.028279902413487434, -0.018880045041441917, 0.01449982263147831, -0.008784049190580845, 0.0008918116800487041, 0.015741417184472084, 0.00611629243940115, 0.05531994625926018, 0.030574828386306763, 0.014799272641539574, -0.008886119350790977, 0.026037482544779778, -0.036478620022535324, -0.015833400189876556, -0.006889511365443468, -0.046446528285741806, -0.0016448586247861385, 0.02621423453092575, 0.0622076690196991, 0.022757750004529953, 0.007385525852441788, 0.029529957100749016, -0.04727081581950188, 0.037579819560050964, -0.016678515821695328, 0.02701718732714653, 0.0008230354287661612, -0.02416907250881195, -0.013188532553613186, -0.020590057596564293, -0.04835619032382965, 0.03330225124955177, -0.013717644847929478, 0.027247758582234383, -0.028982844203710556, -0.005566578358411789, -0.04595472291111946, 0.007185753900557756, -0.0036592381075024605, -0.0046819038689136505, -0.05474305897951126, 0.006438339129090309, 0.026666101068258286, -0.0024547067005187273, -0.030092300847172737, 0.026425732299685478, -0.047320909798145294, -0.029418282210826874, -0.026589632034301758, 0.0005534887895919383, 0.02368929423391819, -0.006685156375169754, 0.049668170511722565, 0.010593436658382416, -0.013446145690977573, 0.011036854237318039, -0.059454936534166336, -0.044744886457920074, -0.0057120914570987225, 0.009664149023592472, 0.03014666587114334, -0.0023887192364782095, -0.03811630606651306, 0.057454243302345276, 0.00019159290241077542, -0.03906290978193283, -0.03085043840110302, -0.031286563724279404, -0.03901252523064613, -0.04097534716129303, 0.02498614601790905, 0.005560189951211214, 0.01552180852741003, 0.028424086049199104, 0.000463621923699975, -0.03667408972978592, 0.047052498906850815, 0.0008926320006139576, -0.04195786640048027, 0.03590276837348938, -0.01822882518172264, 0.021589025855064392, 0.01445707120001316, 0.011530163697898388, -0.015765827149152756, 0.04298758879303932, 0.007516257930546999, -0.02358773909509182, 0.03987518325448036, -0.02386949583888054, -0.01014678180217743, -0.018510188907384872, 0.012353251688182354, -0.043152857571840286, 0.022179516032338142, -0.017381267622113228, -0.03899767994880676, -0.011644764803349972, 0.030604088678956032, 0.04290894791483879, 0.0253041610121727, 0.014486282132565975, 0.04294026270508766, 0.014254207722842693, -0.0047889514826238155, -0.011467988602817059, -0.022185949608683586, -0.03196294233202934, 0.005511564668267965, -0.037619899958372116, -0.04377731680870056, 0.03811503201723099, 0.04533611610531807, 0.04779597371816635, -0.021830322220921516, -0.021643944084644318, 0.01496006641536951, -0.0628155916929245, -0.00835367664694786, -0.008715959265828133, 0.06086115539073944, 0.025188887491822243, 0.0626402422785759, 0.05584784969687462, 0.03560665249824524, 0.004457628354430199, 0.007094321306794882, -0.07436197251081467, 0.07059874385595322, -0.01173488050699234, 0.011481133289635181, -0.029831459745764732, -0.003550904104486108, 0.02948400005698204, -0.01082141138613224, 0.018192870542407036, 0.0054008192382752895, -0.005852383561432362, -0.016364533454179764, -0.0007928957929834723, -0.010717207565903664, 0.0016522828955203295, -0.014408569782972336, 0.026262275874614716, 0.01744971238076687, -0.012453156523406506, 0.008893882855772972, 0.04040798172354698, 0.0016905599040910602, -0.0006510372622869909, -0.03560043126344681, -0.0008431829628534615, 0.011067505925893784, 0.03133866563439369, 0.035850539803504944, 0.03147753328084946, -0.011459710076451302, 0.036311790347099304, 0.005555472336709499, 0.0950252115726471, 0.025731654837727547, -0.028920968994498253, -0.014072762802243233, -0.048312798142433167, 0.001027710735797882, -0.0038228831253945827, 0.027536936104297638, -0.01678329147398472, -0.026239322498440742, 0.033217135816812515, -0.02121056243777275, -0.04568018019199371, 0.03538523241877556, 0.05122126638889313, 0.03578074648976326, -0.0049035861156880856, -0.01056597102433443, 0.02447802759706974, 0.0013244478031992912, -0.009385647252202034, 0.01610991358757019, 0.014943771064281464, -0.03066098876297474, 0.009414472617208958, 0.0330328568816185, 0.0027732495218515396, -0.007341353222727776, -0.030143598094582558, 0.03787674754858017, 0.054527752101421356, -0.006386589724570513, -0.0024565081112086773, 0.028890730813145638, 0.03408129885792732, 0.015190156176686287, 0.0422232486307621, 0.013201669789850712, -0.11410240083932877, 0.022969059646129608, 0.013109112158417702, 0.0324709489941597, -0.02416038326919079, -0.026697127148509026, -0.06174980476498604, -0.02719590812921524, 0.07709845155477524, -0.027745839208364487, 0.01460698526352644, 0.00014583337178919464, 0.002366628497838974, 0.0038464192766696215, -0.011150887235999107, -0.04199707880616188, -0.002738629700616002, -0.020135313272476196, 0.021771140396595, -0.04810413718223572, -0.03479825705289841, -0.05010661855340004, 0.02833680808544159, -0.010391700081527233, 0.04966836795210838, 0.012328766286373138, -0.027320390567183495, 0.015939811244606972, 0.035849835723638535, -0.01921304129064083, -0.06213975325226784, -0.018557781353592873, -0.012988829053938389, 0.029812360182404518, 0.025599518790841103, -0.013897440396249294, -0.02736060321331024, 0.012529253028333187, -0.028485767543315887, -0.012750942260026932, 0.015280262567102909, -0.009461801499128342, 0.02849976345896721, 0.006725724320858717, 0.0404406301677227, 0.06887555867433548, 0.05556900426745415, 0.006471458822488785, -0.01979076862335205, -0.023414794355630875, 0.006097962614148855, -0.032759733498096466, -0.0003642865631263703, -0.014969981275498867, -0.0031936103478074074, -0.015720603987574577, 0.031330473721027374, 0.0011844326509162784, 0.037779517471790314, 0.02453368529677391, 0.01624147780239582, 0.03804527968168259, 0.023954326286911964, -0.014621737413108349, -0.028735801577568054, -0.0015319916419684887, 0.03583810478448868, -0.01085001602768898, -0.03581978753209114, -0.01896663010120392, 0.006552201695740223, 0.004596400074660778, 0.01679401472210884, -0.005758631508797407, 0.021784840151667595, -0.05281088128685951, -0.005670484155416489, 0.002376446034759283, -0.015506628900766373, 0.04646345227956772, 0.002423220779746771, 0.025561943650245667, 0.04426557198166847, -0.0712515190243721, -0.008006344549357891, 0.010953294113278389, 0.015797890722751617, 0.06629745662212372, -0.028331266716122627, 0.018583282828330994, -0.008057121187448502, -0.0014900624519214034, -0.08276322484016418, -0.01067167054861784, 0.0054558017291128635, 0.044995639473199844, -0.026777630671858788, -0.07932231575250626, 0.013001409359276295, -0.0021492985542863607, -0.021055903285741806, -0.003950024954974651, 0.0431227944791317, 0.0008114310330711305, -0.029401669278740883, -0.0024894210509955883, -0.013479567132890224, 0.08030223101377487, -0.016018295660614967, 0.020381366834044456, 0.03967326506972313, -0.03034253790974617, -0.02046770043671131, 0.005304513964802027, 0.01884935237467289, -0.03601418063044548, 0.005780135281383991, -0.01323756668716669, -0.00200824486091733, -0.0010495941387489438, -0.0157419852912426, -0.023530112579464912, -0.017162298783659935, 0.033217888325452805, 0.017178192734718323, -0.011365805752575397, 0.0064615472219884396, -0.04826974496245384, 0.0200714860111475, -0.02675168588757515, 0.0032116908114403486, -0.03019428439438343, -0.025362923741340637, 0.03178655356168747, -0.006278804503381252, 0.013586817309260368, 0.014748523943126202, 0.06881523132324219, -0.009672588668763638, -0.014676644466817379, -0.003911509644240141, 0.025758415460586548, 0.01066419668495655, 0.022416992112994194, -0.006912787910550833, 0.009176726453006268, 0.029681947082281113, -0.02644379250705242, -0.031152980402112007, -0.03337327018380165, -0.0216487105935812, 0.031298812478780746, 0.010006788186728954, 0.07060343772172928, 0.03255707025527954, 0.008013058453798294, -0.029234379529953003, -0.011560422368347645, -0.03749442473053932, 0.0007938832859508693, 0.004306240007281303, 0.0455639623105526, 0.011404117569327354, 0.026366734877228737, -0.00018708808056544513, 0.007080547045916319, 0.0038192719221115112, 0.08479517698287964, -0.00477050943300128, 0.026576628908514977, 0.042483799159526825, -0.011484003625810146, -0.017511848360300064, 0.03173542395234108, -0.02467123419046402, 0.05334911495447159, -0.022382276132702827, 0.00815222691744566, 0.013875939883291721, 0.035166844725608826, 0.031426191329956055, -0.013903544284403324, -0.023687973618507385, -0.025073103606700897, 0.04165494814515114, 0.02679002471268177, -0.014105364680290222, 0.06233086436986923, 0.04543798044323921, 0.01685952953994274, -0.012466052547097206, 0.012220637872815132, -0.02382420003414154, -0.04081794247031212, 0.006452061235904694, -0.04025649279356003, -0.04183506220579147, 0.046862225979566574, -0.0027910128701478243, -0.017171667888760567, 0.0071158092468976974, -0.03252052515745163, 0.019619407132267952, 0.0044872271828353405, 0.010864232666790485, -0.03016488626599312, 0.0744197741150856, -0.005961086135357618, 0.00422590970993042, 0.010888950899243355, 0.011411013081669807, 0.12359806150197983, 0.08229769766330719, 0.034581009298563004, -0.07590217888355255, -0.025832457467913628, -0.06387576460838318, -0.01207372359931469, -0.048259370028972626, 0.027341272681951523, -0.008070908486843109, -0.0006200578645803034, 0.040928710252046585, 0.05116898566484451, -0.0006553709972649813, 0.033984873443841934, 0.052052829414606094, -0.025581583380699158, -0.007869613356888294, 0.0027076671831309795, 0.0007222953718155622, -0.01993703655898571, 0.008288642391562462, -0.04905451089143753, 0.04608485847711563, -0.03668157756328583, -0.031212184578180313, -0.05607687309384346, -0.02286096103489399, 0.01987599767744541, -0.002769503043964505, -0.039198581129312515, 0.0006894356920383871, 0.06100022420287132, 0.010000363923609257, 0.014428180642426014, 0.03328574076294899, 0.0028488878160715103, -0.014738804660737514, 0.01841401867568493, 0.020600199699401855, 0.006106367334723473, 0.0011993745574727654, -0.03821608051657677, -0.015821198001503944, -0.01498605590313673, -0.046902380883693695, -0.06112751364707947, 0.04034363105893135, -0.006319472566246986, -0.01002903375774622, 0.008807936683297157, 0.009098115377128124, -0.01840423233807087, -0.046819351613521576, -0.02764884941279888, -0.006439588963985443, -0.00802865531295538, -0.05043511837720871, -0.043846067041158676, -0.04023251682519913, 0.032559726387262344, -0.009081969037652016, 0.04400429502129555, 0.04254698008298874, -0.021464576944708824, -0.00860176607966423, -0.028966492041945457, 0.058826204389333725, -0.020662371069192886, -0.01103520393371582, 0.006430346984416246, -0.04941698536276817, -0.023386910557746887, -0.0379868745803833, 0.020314913243055344, 0.0044953408651053905, -0.01730930246412754, 0.002836306346580386, 0.0031815171241760254, -0.005360526964068413, -0.08527377992868423, 0.014727862551808357, -0.03594253957271576, -0.013975153677165508, -0.00904296524822712, 0.006125497166067362, 0.011026561260223389, 0.0683639794588089, 0.001412243233062327, 0.005661948584020138, -0.0062294285744428635, 0.003715493716299534, 0.05362529680132866, -0.06505991518497467, -0.04738066345453262, -0.01013974566012621, -0.025831200182437897, 0.021410401910543442, -0.012411409988999367, 0.06902243196964264, 0.01755630224943161, 0.006960167549550533, -0.00798546802252531, 0.02800167165696621, -0.059097770601511, 0.01854785531759262, -0.04754791036248207, -0.011249496601521969, 0.008115807548165321, 0.007681886199861765, -0.002678054152056575, -0.04352816566824913, -0.05079193040728569, -0.03228474408388138, -0.03772097826004028, 0.011049335822463036, 0.013773748651146889, -0.037263743579387665, 0.02422245591878891, -0.0013515610480681062, -0.0004408916865941137, -0.02013958804309368, 0.02621353790163994, -0.034453384578228, -0.006543106399476528, -0.022905267775058746, -0.00178302894346416, -0.0024440258275717497, -0.017430998384952545, -0.03045659326016903, -0.03225424140691757, 0.0422695092856884, 0.013723855838179588, 0.022394636645913124, 0.004507437348365784, 0.007419154513627291, -0.01099490188062191, 0.03682108223438263, -0.031747933477163315, 0.01058240421116352, 0.035572219640016556, -0.0657113790512085, -0.004493026528507471, -0.01534294430166483, -0.008194456808269024, 0.032474830746650696, 0.008656694553792477, 0.022730184718966484, -0.010998556390404701, 0.010845166631042957, -0.004085114691406488, -0.015989789739251137, 0.0010950160212814808, -0.008744729682803154, 0.015889665111899376, 0.04772326350212097, 0.037096794694662094, -0.03797018900513649, -0.0018180269980803132, 0.02153737097978592, 0.03347894921898842, 0.002933576935902238, -0.014164045453071594, 0.02719244174659252, 0.0016045309603214264, 0.04851606488227844, 0.0008565006428398192, 0.002200797898694873, 0.05078023672103882, 0.04370558634400368, -0.037355925887823105, -0.024626746773719788, -0.03139447420835495, -0.012302733026444912, -0.10153033584356308, 0.0009689144208095968, 0.009079383686184883, -0.023763367906212807, 0.03245323523879051, -0.04182783514261246, -0.029239123687148094, 0.036602143198251724, -0.018423940986394882, 0.013594960793852806, -0.039467014372348785, -0.004450141452252865, -0.028581652790308, 0.009604883380234241, -0.03978748619556427, 0.002984653925523162, 0.053172074258327484, 0.03472064435482025, 0.030416380614042282, 0.005779989995062351, -0.010287395678460598, 0.016422271728515625, -0.0005958722322247922, -0.013406762853264809, 0.01141261775046587, -0.035790134221315384, 0.011276697739958763, -0.021167917177081108, -0.02259477972984314, 0.025399671867489815, -0.010717108845710754, 0.015005315653979778, -0.004576170817017555, -0.0009779128013178706, 0.00012662168592214584, 0.04671779274940491, 0.028265343979001045, -0.010249762795865536, -0.014253288507461548, 0.011082766577601433, 0.02219659648835659, 0.013350775465369225, -0.02314736321568489, -0.009154321625828743, -0.009197916835546494, -0.02992268092930317, -0.024540934711694717, 0.019270051270723343, -0.005944390781223774, 0.004601916763931513, 0.0013669044710695744, -0.04613098129630089, -0.004586391616612673, -0.02031303383409977, 0.016017092391848564, -0.06780967116355896, -0.002865940798074007, 0.02295404113829136, 0.03580521047115326, -0.002220543334260583, 0.016798464581370354, -0.0648898109793663, -0.048260729759931564, 0.018665580078959465, 0.03089527040719986, -0.06152230128645897, -0.05971623957157135, -0.010776178911328316, -0.0003338384267408401, -0.0032476552296429873, -0.022539328783750534, -0.0212984811514616, -0.025881052017211914, 0.036966722458601, 0.0009085404453799129, 0.025298045948147774, 0.01852845959365368, -0.05044917017221451, -0.012748676352202892, -0.0574493408203125, 0.050865288823843, 0.00044674042146652937, -0.032385699450969696, -0.020095879212021828, -0.03475222736597061, -0.036619141697883606, 0.018646690994501114, 0.04292736575007439, -0.002763399388641119, -0.01832611672580242, -0.03384247422218323, -0.024655571207404137, -0.017806246876716614, -0.05573011562228203, 0.004741473123431206, -0.0158879142254591, -0.05265935882925987, -0.007083417382091284, -0.009760899469256401, 0.03063131496310234, 0.018865078687667847, -0.013759884983301163, -0.004579027183353901, 0.001882531214505434, 0.021223828196525574, -0.043914757668972015, 0.011939159594476223, -0.01926819607615471, -0.03795267269015312, 0.05701744556427002, -0.0016184955602511764, -0.007698035333305597, 0.0027412106283009052, -0.0009393759537488222, -0.052388258278369904, 0.04435401409864426, -0.05802531540393829, -0.0032739490270614624, -0.009233908727765083, 0.025307362899184227, -0.02602689154446125, -0.06117036193609238, -0.0013761570444330573, 0.02741958200931549, -0.03212883323431015, 0.005249812733381987, 0.009842180646955967, 0.01016874797642231, 0.032321617007255554, 0.01581370271742344, -0.007776395883411169, -0.0033055469393730164, 0.02233670838177204, 0.009993265382945538, 0.009659013710916042, 0.02874852903187275, -0.010595934465527534, 0.03774024546146393, 0.030302591621875763, -0.02878640778362751, -0.005350339226424694, -0.02634088695049286, 0.03578240051865578, -0.03539904206991196, -0.010105344466865063, -0.02635684795677662, -0.04680035263299942, 0.021815000101923943, 0.0019392665708437562, -0.03388328477740288, 0.08855532109737396, -0.014505910687148571, 0.00631604203954339, -0.050859685987234116, -0.025343531742691994, -0.02964056096971035, 0.033017415553331375, 0.06215855851769447, 0.020983196794986725, -0.008442424237728119, 0.03601003810763359, 0.0004518716596066952, -0.006806874647736549, 0.03180791810154915, -0.005552520975470543, 0.0018648392288014293, -0.03719786927103996, 0.003545383457094431, -0.006295562256127596, 0.00945559423416853, -0.055213071405887604, -0.016838418319821358, -0.020790794864296913, 0.02396264858543873, 0.05079854279756546, 0.0004473344306461513, -0.02348034642636776, -0.00026380951749160886, 0.061970602720975876, -0.09340757876634598, -0.008081384934484959, -0.022449657320976257, -0.01090692263096571, -0.010752217844128609, 0.0009504241752438247 ]
<p>I have two sets of data. The one is daily temperature data and another is 16-day vegetation observation data (value of Jan 1, Jan 17 etc), throughout a year. But I need daily values of vegetation observation data. How to obtain daily value from 16-day vegetation data?</p>
74,313
[ -0.016018643975257874, -0.02089579589664936, -0.025971194729208946, 0.0663309395313263, 0.0077676367945969105, 0.012109723873436451, 0.0060853804461658, -0.007524533662945032, 0.025980576872825623, -0.03685028851032257, 0.032129548490047455, 0.03148270770907402, 0.02425629086792469, 0.01687776669859886, 0.002680402947589755, -0.02704213373363018, -0.03911262005567551, 0.013720226474106312, 0.015648411586880684, -0.00332257361151278, -0.01638810522854328, 0.01813625358045101, 0.021871600300073624, -0.01880548521876335, -0.021260740235447884, 0.06868656724691391, 0.004317787475883961, 0.00561152258887887, -0.008952234871685505, 0.05533768609166145, -0.05863045156002045, -0.06156158819794655, -0.014447370544075966, 0.05136432871222496, 0.030988093465566635, -0.009687665849924088, -0.05635649338364601, -0.02359270118176937, 0.0032474531326442957, 0.014745092019438744, -0.04295997694134712, -0.029359156265854836, 0.004417834337800741, 0.03768095746636391, 0.004608576651662588, 0.005251821596175432, -0.012264086864888668, -0.025998076424002647, 0.0017976297531276941, -0.03666002303361893, 0.07740289717912674, -0.024121982976794243, 0.03429581969976425, 0.03933371976017952, -0.015482013113796711, 0.014811270870268345, 0.05040222778916359, 0.061323363333940506, -0.010542265139520168, -0.05033664405345917, 0.0007689011399634182, -0.024440808221697807, -0.0003255762567277998, -0.007298235781490803, -0.01709197834134102, -0.017468666657805443, -0.04107697680592537, -0.008894044905900955, 0.01270553283393383, 0.0009087953367270529, 0.021378112956881523, 0.014565867371857166, 0.04535019025206566, 0.002841584850102663, 0.01744941994547844, -0.015540426596999168, 0.017444327473640442, 0.03951362520456314, 0.05930789187550545, 0.00376934465020895, 0.03209211677312851, 0.05690281465649605, 0.007310110609978437, -0.00835956260561943, 0.02578151784837246, -0.005774566438049078, 0.0411519818007946, -0.017120670527219772, 0.023801064118742943, 0.0064077614806592464, 0.03391353785991669, -0.00079676927998662, 0.05121564492583275, -0.006233463063836098, -0.025428637862205505, 0.03309520706534386, 0.003615443129092455, 0.03153623640537262, -0.019511908292770386, -0.02009325847029686, 0.020809100940823555, -0.035558540374040604, 0.02947584167122841, 0.07114012539386749, -0.03389960899949074, -0.0035542401019483805, -0.00380287179723382, -0.022865962237119675, -0.006948521826416254, -0.013836921192705631, -0.013089926913380623, 0.023617539554834366, 0.02295800670981407, -0.020058628171682358, 0.052990298718214035, -0.03765210881829262, -0.04138493165373802, 0.005628473591059446, 0.04097846522927284, 0.037734504789114, 0.042825840413570404, -0.005932915490120649, 0.012119556777179241, -0.015722932294011116, -0.0852532833814621, 0.005290213972330093, -0.0121254101395607, -0.011879794299602509, -0.03674721717834473, 0.05242858827114105, -0.015077751129865646, -0.021268652752041817, 0.021574726328253746, -0.06330419331789017, 0.021314134821295738, 0.005903000012040138, -0.08100103586912155, -0.037123046815395355, 0.013059624470770359, -0.014890596270561218, 0.005650899838656187, -0.04885122552514076, 0.036573950201272964, 0.014897729270160198, 0.022837167605757713, 0.024868303909897804, 0.017657263204455376, 0.035975851118564606, -0.0014358310727402568, -0.0015965151833370328, 0.01970423385500908, -0.026449115946888924, 0.006601662375032902, -0.04578624665737152, -0.023545052856206894, -0.054445765912532806, 0.0360630638897419, 0.0550895519554615, -0.008011535741388798, -0.014668751507997513, 0.05096503719687462, 0.008565181866288185, -0.0014916377840563655, 0.02346149832010269, 0.029130887240171432, -0.04272862523794174, 0.04437028989195824, 0.02512616477906704, 0.009978336282074451, 0.015729475766420364, 0.017528733238577843, 0.006184029392898083, 0.011065056547522545, 0.041089195758104324, 0.046127915382385254, 0.016288259997963905, -0.0072453077882528305, 0.0069685522466897964, 0.006138188298791647, 0.05866113305091858, -0.026642056182026863, -0.017354553565382957, -0.01822770945727825, 0.008028627373278141, 0.029586272314190865, 0.04969032481312752, 0.022728025913238525, -0.011469265446066856, 0.00500175915658474, -0.10028937458992004, -0.01316928956657648, -0.06715971231460571, 0.0018492165254428983, -0.02093849703669548, -0.016688596457242966, -0.01175401546061039, 0.02603449858725071, 0.00813598744571209, -0.009980018250644207, -0.03261463716626167, 0.03202832117676735, -0.006774670910090208, 0.05128077045083046, -0.04314042627811432, -0.026375651359558105, 0.0683964416384697, 0.05721549317240715, -0.010065591894090176, 0.04709215089678764, -0.05285295471549034, -0.05834048613905907, 0.004782394040375948, -0.056867800652980804, -0.002987741259858012, -0.02525155618786812, -0.013983840122818947, 0.007494610734283924, 0.024603893980383873, -0.02654554508626461, 0.0029435388278216124, -0.02722308784723282, 0.0696307122707367, 0.08836743980646133, 0.018879005685448647, -0.01586584746837616, 0.020479336380958557, 0.03914806619286537, 0.025472620502114296, -0.056176550686359406, -0.029313258826732635, -0.06410019099712372, 0.01784481853246689, 0.03772794082760811, 0.010733324103057384, -0.04132790490984917, 0.018807586282491684, 0.07209210842847824, 0.056318365037441254, 0.027817727997899055, 0.04091302305459976, 0.01160756777971983, 0.060664065182209015, 0.013710511848330498, -0.015500690788030624, 0.02107645757496357, 0.029430370777845383, 0.00535690737888217, 0.015739651396870613, 0.03935236856341362, 0.01614893227815628, -0.009025800973176956, 0.04909660294651985, 0.0113614397123456, 0.010343878529965878, 0.021021027117967606, -0.05301394313573837, 0.034051429480314255, -0.0466531440615654, -0.023159511387348175, 0.03888127952814102, 0.006040057633072138, 0.003595731919631362, 0.0371427983045578, 0.009594646282494068, 0.04170794412493706, 0.017591629177331924, -0.05818411707878113, -0.014840451069176197, 0.01619955711066723, -0.021449893712997437, 0.010270576924085617, -0.010843777097761631, -0.024419253692030907, -0.021316038444638252, 0.02321617864072323, 0.04387206211686134, 0.004984470549970865, 0.016181398183107376, -0.03692903742194176, -0.01553700678050518, -0.019524788483977318, -0.03889870643615723, 0.004567638970911503, -0.020684756338596344, -0.07344365119934082, 0.013505508191883564, 0.04567663371562958, -0.05237305164337158, 0.018184274435043335, -0.01653372310101986, 0.004164698533713818, 0.033890776336193085, 0.013059870339930058, -0.04264276474714279, -0.0030311751179397106, -0.018564002588391304, 0.01218087412416935, -0.03121975250542164, 0.000951079186052084, 0.02391134761273861, 0.012750412337481976, -0.0394020602107048, 0.0010955261532217264, -0.056264277547597885, -0.04527886584401131, -0.043068189173936844, -0.003937947563827038, -0.009108549915254116, -0.023564783856272697, 0.0025705238804221153, -0.003251371905207634, -0.02707047387957573, -0.02056717872619629, -0.07243595272302628, -0.07897870242595673, 0.0026276151183992624, 0.021385475993156433, 0.022507548332214355, 0.01522849965840578, -0.030580701306462288, 0.02406284585595131, -0.0003003294696100056, -0.03977185860276222, -0.05382027477025986, 0.00995561107993126, -0.044932641088962555, -0.001954629085958004, 0.0009921115124598145, -0.04029635339975357, 0.01094469428062439, 0.014545061625540257, 0.01815129444003105, -0.000488320947624743, 0.08924398571252823, 0.008245158940553665, -0.05059126019477844, 0.002883948851376772, 0.01699783280491829, 0.00473775016143918, 0.03445594385266304, -0.004748157225549221, -0.01460668072104454, 0.014577013440430164, -0.018017970025539398, 0.02291400544345379, 0.02102537266910076, -0.021248525008559227, 0.01882052794098854, -0.008144781924784184, 0.010971542447805405, -0.027383146807551384, 0.019854919984936714, -0.0002836179919540882, 0.015543096698820591, -0.013229689560830593, 0.017470600083470345, 0.06191670149564743, -0.02045624330639839, -0.025119706988334656, 0.08767097443342209, 0.059606846421957016, 0.000864272122271359, -0.054152242839336395, 0.004018860403448343, 0.019686046987771988, 0.011423805728554726, -0.017328863963484764, 0.002647905144840479, 0.04943433403968811, 0.032665301114320755, 0.02386942319571972, 0.007205445319414139, -0.041163016110658646, 0.016141148284077644, -0.05007847398519516, 0.004293589852750301, -0.01459655910730362, 0.03682802990078926, 0.007148630917072296, 0.06275495141744614, -0.0049666776321828365, -0.01520311739295721, 0.041176069527864456, 0.014483439736068249, -0.019977282732725143, 0.03410349041223526, 0.007414424326270819, 0.0007293672533705831, 0.022677043452858925, 0.011719899252057076, 0.004159247502684593, 0.011779619380831718, 0.014209946617484093, 0.000916090386454016, -0.007499572355300188, -0.023825829848647118, -0.009283611550927162, -0.04761674627661705, -0.012245340272784233, -0.03153039142489433, 0.01649971678853035, 0.030455268919467926, -0.041337091475725174, 0.03863015025854111, 0.060913071036338806, 0.019742680713534355, -0.03293107822537422, -0.03885378688573837, -0.010789497755467892, -0.0009441626025363803, 0.012364462018013, -0.006421040277928114, 0.04484051093459129, -0.014031673781573772, 0.009447448886930943, -0.017521817237138748, 0.036065150052309036, 0.019157951697707176, 0.005313527770340443, -0.01613610051572323, -0.02567223832011223, -0.008743797428905964, -0.006398962344974279, 0.011486779898405075, -0.031320031732320786, -0.005022329743951559, 0.017816295847296715, 0.011022715829312801, -0.05592523515224457, 0.026021208614110947, 0.05725967511534691, 0.0008309585391543806, 0.006767791695892811, -0.00901865679770708, -0.019118361175060272, -0.02476733736693859, -0.029206056147813797, 0.02882116101682186, 0.020607825368642807, -0.003114353632554412, -0.01993730291724205, 0.04392337054014206, -0.018247568979859352, 0.02122594602406025, 0.010597716085612774, 0.02570710889995098, 0.032412391155958176, -0.015788033604621887, -0.0387813001871109, 0.009516137652099133, 0.0625111311674118, 0.01792183518409729, 0.01307983323931694, 0.022479882463812828, -0.09228172153234482, -0.01838766783475876, 0.01821274124085903, 0.03103717602789402, -0.015766140073537827, -0.027807356789708138, -0.06443550437688828, -0.0003558147291187197, 0.014080251567065716, -0.027142370119690895, 0.026998188346624374, -0.007359050679951906, 0.015037360601127148, 0.007662429474294186, -0.020643582567572594, 0.00209444435313344, -0.02150769904255867, -0.018408190459012985, 0.047795187681913376, 0.022688714787364006, -0.029006553813815117, -0.028695063665509224, 0.027567211538553238, 0.019106760621070862, 0.024563346058130264, 0.014305117540061474, -0.005093939136713743, 0.015054105781018734, -0.007482160348445177, -0.03483918309211731, -0.03757799416780472, -0.00485259247943759, 0.017163140699267387, -0.01705634966492653, 0.029025228694081306, -0.016983967274427414, 0.008204924874007702, 0.01785050705075264, 0.0014086064184084535, -0.010093876160681248, -0.014665771275758743, -0.04028991609811783, 0.02119670994579792, 0.009638999588787556, 0.006443969439715147, 0.0818953663110733, 0.03009500727057457, 0.011647834442555904, 0.009495717473328114, -0.012160432524979115, 0.05362209677696228, -0.009718907997012138, -0.05633395165205002, -0.003691354300826788, -0.014818970113992691, -0.005243571475148201, 0.015846610069274902, -0.015483573079109192, 0.02460489049553871, -0.03113681636750698, -0.035353612154722214, -0.01950540766119957, 0.00045975629473105073, 0.0038433223962783813, -0.009873481467366219, -0.021215708926320076, 0.0545097179710865, -0.031970638781785965, -0.038255613297224045, 0.028650488704442978, -0.024305161088705063, -0.02714136801660061, -0.0216412004083395, -0.016370369121432304, 0.009735762141644955, -0.05197015404701233, -0.03571860119700432, 0.005018552299588919, 0.0012361608678475022, -0.012082366272807121, -0.010732680559158325, 0.05646979436278343, 0.02584882825613022, -0.07918506115674973, -0.005564653780311346, 0.013366260565817356, 0.02202482707798481, -0.018514160066843033, -0.058092501014471054, 0.0058319889940321445, 0.0030167424120008945, 0.005271480418741703, -0.08943378180265427, -0.03095954842865467, 0.027745472267270088, 0.016663195565342903, -0.04687627777457237, -0.052947744727134705, -0.006779323797672987, -0.000596668804064393, -0.0029699772130697966, -0.010540813207626343, 0.05728140473365784, -0.007464793976396322, -0.03059152141213417, -0.01369255781173706, 0.04756002873182297, 0.05270933732390404, -0.03267788887023926, 0.05493326857686043, -0.011086332611739635, -0.002936306642368436, -0.048717301338911057, -0.008052963763475418, 0.02610289677977562, -0.01535884290933609, 0.018148284405469894, -0.02940342389047146, -0.02135184220969677, 0.03325996175408363, 0.027225788682699203, -0.01599954627454281, 0.02158309891819954, 0.02720584347844124, -0.044477466493844986, -0.03698644042015076, 0.04918438196182251, 0.000581375090405345, 0.003305237041786313, -0.059780921787023544, -0.006260143592953682, -0.004954097326844931, 0.003466518595814705, -0.02855606935918331, 0.007022118661552668, -0.003286053892225027, 0.01731034740805626, 0.06562884151935577, -0.03733060508966446, 0.0242389515042305, 0.022316843271255493, 0.03942563757300377, -0.0006026112241670489, 0.011476781219244003, 0.017056286334991455, 0.017579335719347, 0.009137934073805809, -0.040024347603321075, -0.004186650738120079, -0.015291004441678524, -0.03074515610933304, 0.07133401930332184, -0.023402845486998558, 0.0575602762401104, 0.024765556678175926, 0.030125143006443977, 0.02218727581202984, -0.023097854107618332, -0.0156520027667284, 0.002217793371528387, -0.026303699240088463, 0.059245459735393524, -0.00800585001707077, -0.009016862139105797, 0.024019291624426842, 0.004146948456764221, 0.015168472193181515, 0.06111295893788338, 0.012765762396156788, 0.017360767349600792, 0.005875172559171915, -0.0324351042509079, -0.05714620277285576, -0.0005805276450701058, -0.004015527665615082, 0.0343908965587616, 0.008661105297505856, -0.02438310533761978, 0.03596023842692375, 0.00910795945674181, -0.01760646514594555, -0.055556513369083405, -0.02822757326066494, -0.0553646981716156, 0.008360532112419605, 0.04632892832159996, -0.018416449427604675, 0.005721251014620066, 0.04726136848330498, 0.04211631044745445, -0.02354138158261776, -0.005689030978828669, -0.033224985003471375, -0.06265244632959366, -0.030706308782100677, -0.02022753842175007, -0.05236946418881416, 0.08424355834722519, 0.03538285195827484, -0.008567066863179207, -0.0016447084490209818, -0.00023708617663942277, -0.01828712970018387, 0.004705971572548151, 0.05869555473327637, 0.02748229168355465, 0.05854783207178116, 0.015009980648756027, -0.029741521924734116, -0.011484159156680107, 0.03496326133608818, 0.1327512115240097, 0.08982429653406143, 0.018735313788056374, -0.09200533479452133, 0.022225962951779366, -0.003478325204923749, -0.025243883952498436, -0.049343060702085495, -0.00469936290755868, 0.03316361457109451, 0.011144958436489105, 0.06469516456127167, 0.01780565083026886, -0.03468433395028114, -0.008261572569608688, 0.05069541931152344, 0.0031562428921461105, -0.01409604400396347, 0.016102418303489685, 0.029327930882573128, 0.01361264567822218, 0.022455936297774315, -0.0390896312892437, -0.0036124438047409058, -0.008518049493432045, -0.02867879718542099, -0.015585632063448429, -0.04910680651664734, 0.0289958156645298, -0.0016527074621990323, -0.0398545041680336, 0.003329233732074499, 0.03892683610320091, 0.043520402163267136, -0.030747678130865097, -0.02043049782514572, 0.014628571458160877, 0.005966473370790482, -0.010448619723320007, 0.005283955950289965, 0.01699300855398178, -0.023702044039964676, 0.01928175799548626, 0.03182859718799591, -0.0233922116458416, -0.03545162081718445, -0.04656970500946045, 0.030971545726060867, -0.022875597700476646, -0.006461062002927065, 0.015715399757027626, 0.007892094552516937, -0.021951012313365936, -0.029554661363363266, 0.011345705948770046, 0.04294703155755997, 0.04474426433444023, -0.05670444667339325, -0.020893188193440437, -0.01338255312293768, 0.03992091119289398, -0.02758677490055561, 0.011509876698255539, 0.02271297201514244, -0.01774897798895836, 0.006775617133826017, -0.020021723583340645, 0.06100746989250183, -0.0018520468147471547, -0.005439524073153734, -0.04933715984225273, -0.041952844709157944, 0.007829261012375355, -0.0029384098015725613, 0.0006928289076313376, -0.001174187520518899, -0.00725933350622654, 0.0021277153864502907, -0.06331043690443039, 0.010421434417366982, -0.0333416722714901, -0.00812469981610775, 0.007399684749543667, 0.0017361578065901995, -0.046694718301296234, 0.01882464624941349, 0.03400988131761551, 0.0029527696315199137, 0.03260922431945801, 0.011832660995423794, -0.025959357619285583, 0.03184390813112259, 0.04234658181667328, -0.04900413006544113, -0.028897065669298172, 0.013700136914849281, -0.04657265543937683, 0.0030800423119217157, -0.012563355267047882, 0.04970146343111992, 0.015998955816030502, 0.01394671481102705, -0.03648379445075989, 0.044103607535362244, -0.032508738338947296, 0.038113273680210114, 0.025467315688729286, -0.034113749861717224, 0.004755021538585424, 0.016600962728261948, -0.002039957093074918, -0.01565374992787838, -0.031950220465660095, -0.005547727458178997, -0.0435970313847065, 0.03659884259104729, -0.037868794053792953, -0.032823558896780014, 0.017951229587197304, -0.0402773879468441, 0.014651073142886162, -0.02013346739113331, 0.01693757437169552, -0.06450406461954117, -0.004292761906981468, 0.004121808800846338, -0.015438217669725418, -0.023691659793257713, 0.003291722387075424, -0.02899380400776863, -0.03492097184062004, 0.06162384897470474, 0.01627030223608017, 0.031267084181308746, -0.017742343246936798, -0.0015348365996032953, 0.012180402874946594, 0.07565796375274658, -0.002551516517996788, -0.05285976827144623, 0.038896117359399796, -0.027568839490413666, -0.007870073430240154, 0.034186847507953644, 0.015803953632712364, 0.04641847684979439, 0.005616993177682161, -0.019460909068584442, -0.0163450725376606, 0.06643089652061462, -0.03058902733027935, -0.02977774664759636, -0.022768940776586533, -0.019555866718292236, 0.015846990048885345, 0.02609643153846264, -0.0043326192535459995, 0.014370827004313469, -0.03609450161457062, 0.004550236277282238, 0.016530044376850128, 0.014712757430970669, -0.008235755376517773, 0.02163047343492508, 0.0006452501402236521, -0.009087747894227505, 0.02005206048488617, -0.035775721073150635, 0.0460335910320282, 0.04359797388315201, -0.03231991454958916, 0.002835870487615466, -0.012610510922968388, -0.018626820296049118, -0.02044885791838169, 0.02697005122900009, 0.044151950627565384, -0.006738853175193071, 0.045079126954078674, -0.03819930553436279, -0.0261978916823864, 0.047584522515535355, -0.014849238097667694, 0.005825625732541084, -0.013870465569198132, -0.007917690090835094, -0.01736835390329361, 0.03660149872303009, -0.012487274594604969, 0.020425349473953247, 0.029408330097794533, 0.03225409612059593, 0.011102837510406971, 0.02015766315162182, 0.01437318790704012, -0.021110305562615395, -0.0234356801956892, 0.004144261125475168, 0.03457009792327881, -0.08254339545965195, -0.0055742450058460236, -0.03743422031402588, -0.024908946827054024, 0.021160712465643883, -0.036837413907051086, 0.004306089598685503, -0.00340701499953866, 0.004557362757623196, -0.009610055014491081, 0.06975694000720978, 0.0219781082123518, -0.00781233748421073, -0.04458235576748848, 0.006430581212043762, 0.011628064326941967, 0.0046915896236896515, 0.003071412444114685, -0.028615467250347137, 0.02355443313717842, -0.016317524015903473, -0.018117127940058708, 0.046283550560474396, 0.00921555794775486, -0.031123509630560875, 0.010324378497898579, -0.0012816011440008879, 0.016797848045825958, -0.01609131321310997, -0.04025315120816231, -0.004187234211713076, 0.019557548686861992, 0.043889980763196945, -0.02099100686609745, -0.010924449190497398, 0.003497937461361289, -0.005869177170097828, -0.04410364478826523, 0.012494952417910099, 0.04351663216948509, 0.010672620497643948, -0.029748460277915, -0.0052589247934520245, 0.002665885491296649, -0.04537356272339821, 0.012524493038654327, 0.0046789152547717094, -0.049563340842723846, 0.04670122638344765, -0.012034610845148563, 0.04047611728310585, -0.019001487642526627, -0.018336812034249306, 0.023927845060825348, -0.0330488421022892, 0.05190347135066986, 0.006153203547000885, 0.015414638444781303, -0.025061020627617836, -0.005343562923371792, -0.0372467041015625, -0.016860896721482277, 0.018687918782234192, 0.020111050456762314, -0.016765952110290527, -0.028984202072024345, 0.022503912448883057, 0.011709415353834629, -0.05222414806485176, 0.06127641350030899, 0.008339843712747097, -0.04078439995646477, 0.027359528467059135, -0.029386572539806366, 0.0002432332985335961, -0.0055094389244914055, 0.001483974396251142, -0.03122895583510399, 0.027894239872694016, 0.023788122460246086, 0.009043998084962368, 0.0041414774022996426, -0.02598356455564499, -0.017124053090810776, 0.066372349858284, -0.008195674978196621, -0.0062551177106797695, 0.050640951842069626, 0.028721217066049576, -0.028812715783715248, 0.03639625385403633, -0.07190321385860443, -0.009215962141752243, 0.03330188989639282, 0.014113242737948895, 0.004092409275472164, -0.09402918070554733, -0.01704561337828636, 0.013556457124650478, -0.016064751893281937, 0.01598306931555271, 0.012959931045770645, -0.0003147068782709539, 0.025346262380480766, -0.008107193745672703, 0.05935736000537872, 0.023464763537049294, -0.009334567002952099, 0.012997296638786793, 0.013114284723997116, 0.01022335048764944, -0.016717342659831047, 0.0038090089801698923, 0.032376453280448914, 0.003454301506280899, 0.04092959314584732, -0.017792942002415657, 0.007322602439671755, -0.0030263722874224186, -0.05107082799077034, 0.000375622883439064, 0.013439063914120197, 0.006227630190551281, -0.0003895640838891268, -0.014524910598993301, 0.07087758183479309, -0.026017898693680763, -0.03656373918056488, -0.06303185969591141, -0.06102021411061287, -0.03185876086354256, -0.00885649211704731, -0.0010078155901283026, -0.00503352377563715, 0.0015024017775431275, 0.03317968547344208, 0.038157299160957336, 0.02215052768588066, -0.004947341978549957, -0.03978293761610985, 0.03343883901834488, -0.03686828166246414, -0.009918087162077427, 0.02139781415462494, -0.021998513489961624, -0.05775274708867073, -0.0203259140253067, 0.035193316638469696, 0.035691019147634506, -0.0038653924129903316, 0.006006782874464989, -0.04262864962220192, 0.009406598284840584, 0.026460107415914536, -0.08856727182865143, -0.016413850709795952, -0.03299733251333237, 0.00490831071510911, 0.0009268884896300733, -0.02099509909749031 ]
<p>I came across an article where the authors did a Principal Component Analysis on gene expression data, and found out the genes that are most correlated to the 1st principal component, and they used that gene list for further analysis. Can somebody tell me how to find out entities (genes in this case) that are most correlated to the 1st principal component?</p> <p>Here's <a href="http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2164/10/135" rel="nofollow">the link to the original free article</a>, and this is how they've calculated it:</p> <blockquote> <p>Results of the gene set enrichment analysis of the genes most correlated to the 1st principal component. The correlations of the genes with the 1st principal component were transformed to SDs from the mean, then genes with values > 1.5 (positive correlation) or &lt; -1.5 (negative correlation) were selected.</p> </blockquote> <p>I can make a toy example of 6 samples and 20 gene matrix and do the PCA the following way but how to proceed next:</p> <pre><code>rm(list=ls()) set.seed(12345) my.mat &lt;- matrix(rnorm(120,0,0.5),nrow=6,byrow=TRUE) rownames(my.mat) &lt;- paste("s",1:6,sep="") colnames(my.mat) &lt;- paste("g",1:20,sep="") head(my.mat) #Ensure that input data is Z-transformed pca.object &lt;- prcomp(my.mat,center=TRUE,scale.=TRUE) summary(pca.object) par(mfrow=c(1,2)) plot(pca.object) biplot(pca.object) #The Rotation pca.object$rotation </code></pre>
74,314
[ -0.03607040271162987, -0.004963924642652273, -0.004899284336715937, -0.0162515826523304, 0.05939238518476486, 0.009724128060042858, 0.0019273889483883977, -0.03889838978648186, 0.026470951735973358, -0.02045760490000248, 0.037515826523303986, 0.06291903555393219, 0.07148074358701706, 0.03134192153811455, 0.017916366457939148, -0.01802521012723446, -0.03907771781086922, 0.0222349613904953, -0.012168416753411293, -0.012177233584225178, 0.016309170052409172, 0.004006850067526102, 0.030399153009057045, 0.02047421969473362, -0.010283680632710457, 0.05470902845263481, 0.001959715038537979, -0.0008655519923195243, 0.00923866219818592, 0.031978096812963486, -0.06623894721269608, -0.015105265192687511, 0.053598351776599884, 0.005240036640316248, 0.034835055470466614, 0.009843696840107441, 0.0052892775274813175, -0.02279924415051937, 0.008217253722250462, 0.03822094202041626, -0.0008825529366731644, -0.030710631981492043, 0.014589950442314148, 0.03242726996541023, -0.017056573182344437, 0.030668266117572784, -0.009367880411446095, -0.03448744863271713, 0.08421143144369125, -0.030423520132899284, 0.0999809131026268, 0.007844327948987484, 0.02738053724169731, 0.02496410720050335, -0.04404269531369209, 0.023812396451830864, 0.04887593165040016, 0.04400169476866722, -0.009804385714232922, -0.08788593858480453, -0.014064488932490349, -0.014341329224407673, -0.0009753033518791199, -0.027603527531027794, -0.024133000522851944, -0.008425419218838215, 0.003980504348874092, -0.01823544315993786, 0.06751871854066849, -0.00999801978468895, 0.016367686912417412, 0.028625953942537308, 0.03552215173840523, -0.007314071524888277, -0.008278579451143742, -0.025911306962370872, 0.016114911064505577, -0.0004038448678329587, 0.03406587988138199, 0.008389250375330448, -0.024682587012648582, 0.012572522275149822, -0.0032569130416959524, 0.01839657500386238, 0.019524211063981056, 0.0026598589029163122, 0.05029875785112381, -0.01762511022388935, 0.02842993661761284, 0.01596573367714882, -0.0029483812395483255, -0.0010522789089009166, 0.03903687000274658, 0.05008288845419884, -0.04598330333828926, 0.023586193099617958, -0.011332334950566292, 0.07825691998004913, -0.0038904508110135794, -0.014073292724788189, -0.022227246314287186, -0.025914937257766724, -0.01916864700615406, 0.031800542026758194, -0.030424010008573532, -0.004364638589322567, -0.0425470694899559, -0.000908836314920336, -0.035457223653793335, -0.046591803431510925, -0.030660254880785942, 0.020049093291163445, -0.0036944763269275427, 0.0006123877828940749, 0.02534782700240612, -0.0158097967505455, -0.02596304379403591, 0.038078710436820984, 0.08197706192731857, 0.06548035144805908, 0.012329981662333012, 0.003706541145220399, 0.007289779372513294, -0.020710863173007965, -0.03720352426171303, 0.013035248033702374, 0.016303954645991325, 0.009955472312867641, -0.017230955883860588, 0.09185092896223068, -0.010062620043754578, -0.027551431208848953, 0.011342307552695274, -0.022280583158135414, 0.027524085715413094, -0.02325306460261345, -0.09494277834892273, -0.02799498476088047, 0.047166720032691956, -0.029854191467165947, 0.004531159531325102, -0.06403156369924545, -0.007209923584014177, 0.005883397534489632, 0.077448271214962, 0.012116413563489914, 0.018995018675923347, -0.008594301529228687, 0.014643268659710884, -0.007022542878985405, -0.0405711866915226, -0.02529449202120304, -0.036441870033741, -0.021147439256310463, -0.037083547562360764, -0.05045333504676819, 0.0053530847653746605, 0.017379872500896454, 0.017115959897637367, -0.02527572028338909, 0.02161570079624653, 0.020864780992269516, 0.00678612943738699, -0.013276171870529652, -0.030701769515872, -0.0025481150951236486, 0.07199620455503464, -0.008096277713775635, -0.0177351925522089, 0.024618348106741905, 0.0028567088302224874, 0.023422846570611, 0.011761767789721489, 0.06107934191823006, 0.07179860770702362, -0.0184327345341444, -0.013211873359978199, -0.00811982061713934, 0.018089117482304573, 0.02656358852982521, -0.025888465344905853, -0.035593077540397644, -0.02217385359108448, -0.008523620665073395, 0.027537228539586067, 0.029419761151075363, -0.022015942260622978, -0.0785243883728981, 0.02914206124842167, -0.04876401647925377, -0.0207956712692976, -0.07375495135784149, 0.022839408367872238, -0.02213599905371666, -0.018662985414266586, 0.002831079764291644, 0.04641897976398468, 0.030139410868287086, 0.020322760567069054, -0.0077928099781274796, -0.03373997285962105, -0.02847374603152275, 0.06242147088050842, -0.006090934854000807, -0.031006699427962303, 0.019870510324835777, 0.031258802860975266, -0.04443379119038582, 0.023561447858810425, -0.04534875601530075, -0.047913432121276855, 0.032963283360004425, -0.014322555623948574, 0.01523064449429512, 0.02130022458732128, -0.029660062864422798, 0.02901439554989338, 0.025474771857261658, -0.026327263563871384, 0.007882116362452507, -0.02295423485338688, 0.0485345795750618, 0.07343746721744537, 0.021087029948830605, 0.00770023837685585, -0.009442975744605064, 0.025268837809562683, 0.05538530647754669, -0.019158145412802696, 0.011437362059950829, -0.03959731012582779, -0.00030167351360432804, 0.07674206048250198, 0.01974872127175331, -0.050679732114076614, -0.03354867547750473, 0.06500706821680069, -0.0005320350173860788, 0.00034607824636623263, 0.05090385675430298, 0.007224374450743198, 0.0015269150026142597, 0.014145825989544392, 0.02738887257874012, 0.020954731851816177, 0.014553098008036613, 0.007026739418506622, -0.017170723527669907, 0.04769343137741089, 0.04865537956357002, -0.023050229996442795, 0.05857112258672714, 0.0075179822742938995, -0.0011311050038784742, -0.0024638113100081682, -0.026778291910886765, 0.022688236087560654, -0.032141026109457016, 0.0074910507537424564, 0.012456778436899185, 0.01996055617928505, -0.02597087062895298, -0.007820923812687397, -0.0036216808948665857, -0.021829860284924507, 0.05716703459620476, -0.06275457888841629, -0.007131564896553755, 0.0144162867218256, -0.01783647947013378, 0.026549922302365303, 0.0008927977178245783, 0.0007218100945465267, -0.04160723835229874, 0.017917364835739136, 0.02394304797053337, 0.0015669830609112978, 0.044654060155153275, -0.0048627848736941814, -0.035220108926296234, 0.0004145139828324318, 0.0031649870797991753, 0.011538546532392502, 0.028143657371401787, -0.07974199205636978, -0.018794288858771324, -0.016512667760252953, -0.045240938663482666, 0.0027918783016502857, -0.02471129223704338, -0.0279450211673975, 0.015578251332044601, 0.028180213645100594, -0.03172988072037697, -0.017711710184812546, 0.009585990570485592, 0.03259004279971123, -0.02837320975959301, -0.021037928760051727, 0.04807567596435547, 0.017434531822800636, -0.045895762741565704, 0.006423745770007372, -0.043950680643320084, 0.002323461463674903, 0.007873665541410446, -0.018457690253853798, 0.016412576660513878, 0.010184104554355145, -0.005065968260169029, -0.014790264889597893, -0.019423149526119232, 0.0011854254407808185, -0.0320756770670414, -0.05126543343067169, -0.0005701339687220752, 0.013127554208040237, 0.0355975367128849, -0.018607793375849724, -0.03183543309569359, 0.0701894611120224, 0.00973822083324194, -0.07438138872385025, -0.07745376974344254, 0.020027130842208862, -0.055497605353593826, -0.019096292555332184, 0.042945683002471924, 0.024439116939902306, 0.00564676383510232, 0.039076067507267, -0.002150294603779912, 0.027831073850393295, 0.053728874772787094, 0.0003755921497941017, -0.023912308737635612, 0.02863471582531929, -0.030536336824297905, -0.024604598060250282, -0.00849449448287487, 0.021388422697782516, -0.01813858561217785, 0.04712309688329697, -0.004263744223862886, 0.00040133899892680347, -0.01935497298836708, -0.057745326310396194, -0.00760563462972641, 0.013598144985735416, 0.023133300244808197, -0.024301128461956978, 0.015017728321254253, 0.04191621020436287, -0.00268731196410954, 0.02379905991256237, 0.032329414039850235, 0.0593760721385479, -0.01519864797592163, -0.018681490793824196, 0.06419610977172852, 0.008192711509764194, -0.006976297590881586, 0.011119038797914982, -0.024406975135207176, 0.002941289683803916, 0.023625576868653297, -0.027487168088555336, -0.031938549131155014, 0.06064683943986893, 0.01689707674086094, 0.00899470690637827, -0.006214275024831295, -0.03054187260568142, 0.04748620465397835, -0.054929573088884354, 0.022196458652615547, -0.03443659096956253, 0.021268565207719803, 0.001580192125402391, 0.0597403347492218, 0.012574180029332638, -0.01928304135799408, -0.011684052646160126, -0.014996614307165146, -0.08924911171197891, 0.02813791111111641, 0.020006656646728516, 0.017529921606183052, -0.0074677374213933945, -0.025631370022892952, 0.040806613862514496, -0.020775528624653816, 0.020266326144337654, -0.002270447090268135, -0.000037462748878169805, -0.03928068280220032, 0.017166633158922195, -0.015128481201827526, 0.0053542610257864, -0.0026074517518281937, 0.024950101971626282, 0.04435432329773903, -0.0008695777505636215, 0.03450780734419823, 0.02890160121023655, -0.029373886063694954, 0.02291225828230381, -0.003167885122820735, 0.010275927372276783, 0.056855540722608566, 0.04399135336279869, -0.013567148707807064, 0.006814311724156141, -0.01647702418267727, 0.037692129611968994, -0.056370992213487625, 0.02505040541291237, 0.049839671701192856, -0.004270668141543865, -0.007952168583869934, -0.004126445855945349, 0.008391286246478558, -0.02625647559762001, 0.008707600645720959, 0.007324355188757181, -0.034514326602220535, 0.06482527405023575, 0.03279213607311249, -0.05692720785737038, 0.016712132841348648, 0.06870602071285248, 0.0413624607026577, 0.0038952319882810116, -0.03595507889986038, -0.006938042119145393, 0.017452122643589973, -0.00900398101657629, 0.026272732764482498, 0.0131536815315485, 0.002311722142621875, -0.010934027843177319, 0.012814057059586048, -0.030299443751573563, -0.013873848132789135, -0.0005003775586374104, -0.007435111328959465, 0.06000106781721115, -0.022935686632990837, -0.012207329273223877, -0.023794369772076607, 0.03757106885313988, 0.03237168863415718, 0.0022183822002261877, -0.008402502164244652, -0.07220388203859329, -0.0075336419977247715, 0.05139788240194321, 0.032341353595256805, -0.011568575166165829, -0.008078273385763168, -0.028696978464722633, 0.008259766735136509, 0.016266096383333206, -0.03585059195756912, 0.02987101301550865, -0.0001738850842230022, 0.01775946281850338, -0.022315945476293564, -0.02850067801773548, -0.03801344707608223, -0.0007709485362283885, -0.0407320037484169, 0.029430797323584557, -0.030434928834438324, -0.0620962493121624, -0.04222717881202698, 0.019246311858296394, 0.0027020361740142107, 0.06452011317014694, -0.02644895389676094, -0.024230174720287323, 0.02237662300467491, 0.044681865721940994, -0.01316760666668415, -0.06358857452869415, 0.026659097522497177, 0.010401912964880466, -0.014766435138881207, 0.08597195893526077, -0.026570294052362442, -0.012791628018021584, 0.03197959065437317, 0.015276306308805943, -0.0058324565179646015, -0.009113568812608719, -0.014577499590814114, 0.028341885656118393, 0.056338872760534286, -0.016858378425240517, 0.05824697017669678, -0.028770945966243744, -0.04919407516717911, -0.014878557994961739, -0.05978145822882652, 0.0012960099847987294, -0.03252069279551506, -0.014821111224591732, -0.019861329346895218, 0.009117646142840385, -0.0030867294408380985, 0.005254008807241917, 0.01267179474234581, 0.05024241283535957, -0.03373582288622856, 0.00575633067637682, 0.00928923673927784, 0.02266119420528412, -0.04357078671455383, -0.015625234693288803, 0.025895195081830025, 0.025061236694455147, 0.02009132318198681, -0.04795048013329506, 0.02955765649676323, -0.003736798418685794, 0.0032107357401400805, 0.031772300601005554, -0.03547058254480362, -0.004346959292888641, -0.01023978739976883, -0.02881804294884205, 0.044935766607522964, -0.052859485149383545, 0.0011405621189624071, -0.013011712580919266, 0.027247978374361992, 0.030841004103422165, -0.04174981266260147, -0.020747749134898186, 0.010697318241000175, -0.008532739244401455, 0.020319953560829163, -0.04755097255110741, 0.003231922397390008, -0.030113646760582924, -0.005574495065957308, -0.030943848192691803, -0.053565144538879395, 0.0000782857823651284, 0.03384232893586159, -0.005841969046741724, -0.0526992492377758, -0.023784592747688293, -0.016883814707398415, -0.0030040862038731575, -0.0018091504462063313, 0.015033788047730923, -0.026245208457112312, 0.00307071884162724, 0.021970553323626518, 0.03516218811273575, 0.07972511649131775, -0.03947554528713226, -0.012515715323388577, 0.04264146462082863, -0.02270766906440258, -0.03307260200381279, 0.009313964284956455, 0.00021874018420930952, -0.02720596455037594, 0.0045694587752223015, -0.009986686520278454, 0.024481697008013725, 0.0410548634827137, -0.002527411561459303, 0.0005461283144541085, 0.009496597573161125, -0.006747257895767689, 0.014319871552288532, -0.063495934009552, -0.004771664272993803, -0.05721929296851158, -0.007571468595415354, 0.003867905819788575, -0.006818337831646204, -0.04010888934135437, -0.010021744295954704, 0.012250040657818317, -0.01302869152277708, 0.022488394752144814, 0.03593960776925087, 0.09725022315979004, -0.014489850029349327, 0.03811732307076454, 0.004481096286326647, -0.04376040771603584, 0.026299504563212395, 0.02708582580089569, 0.04210270941257477, 0.0028830624651163816, 0.019095947965979576, -0.011682317592203617, -0.01720299944281578, -0.033194541931152344, -0.014156869612634182, 0.05229944363236427, 0.015264048241078854, 0.05085514858365059, 0.07309827208518982, 0.0001644692529225722, 0.004310586489737034, -0.03891497477889061, 0.007538730278611183, -0.012173071503639221, -0.00367462495341897, 0.0530322901904583, -0.020495492964982986, 0.018080076202750206, 0.025518566370010376, 0.011833381839096546, -0.00442094262689352, 0.031413715332746506, 0.0019581089727580547, -0.0059130750596523285, 0.030425777658820152, 0.007064389530569315, -0.06223675608634949, 0.029404455795884132, -0.03411130607128143, 0.021778501570224762, -0.017016207799315453, -0.023915180936455727, 0.01944579742848873, 0.061721332371234894, 0.005910057108849287, -0.047831833362579346, -0.024481212720274925, -0.03310687839984894, 0.004529699217528105, 0.01055556908249855, -0.03276359662413597, 0.03915395960211754, 0.010061632841825485, 0.052742939442396164, -0.0007147990399971604, 0.05122306942939758, -0.054044049233198166, -0.047405704855918884, -0.02645091712474823, -0.04601005092263222, -0.03376547247171402, 0.015803944319486618, 0.028965719044208527, -0.00981493853032589, 0.018920235335826874, -0.06424835324287415, -0.00276193767786026, 0.016240281984210014, 0.056926388293504715, 0.010417363606393337, 0.08190762996673584, -0.0006904128822498024, 0.016336724162101746, 0.009350931271910667, -0.051240790635347366, 0.08390042930841446, 0.10022374987602234, 0.028659239411354065, -0.09195896983146667, 0.027820905670523643, 0.019378433004021645, -0.0036155073903501034, -0.04878990724682808, 0.0019106634426862001, 0.006517414469271898, 0.016891960054636, 0.05026755854487419, 0.06155060604214668, 0.016858326271176338, 0.001233644550666213, 0.04589974135160446, -0.03941800072789192, -0.012551696039736271, 0.03389807417988777, 0.004941438790410757, -0.01998862437903881, -0.067027248442173, -0.08360704034566879, 0.039816126227378845, 0.008832664228975773, -0.03412957489490509, -0.049651842564344406, -0.021431265398859978, -0.021675992757081985, -0.019323822110891342, -0.0018507899949327111, 0.023201540112495422, -0.0050585619173944, 0.026151081547141075, -0.021456150338053703, -0.0018981528701260686, 0.016501929610967636, -0.0017520410474389791, 0.0389566570520401, 0.02341533452272415, 0.00845115166157484, 0.026317670941352844, -0.010200133547186852, 0.04440230131149292, -0.04190678149461746, 0.0038558938540518284, -0.042392548173666, 0.043861083686351776, 0.00038869449053891003, -0.010541388764977455, 0.011250223033130169, 0.014301400631666183, -0.009612660855054855, -0.037113677710294724, -0.018482308834791183, 0.01599588617682457, 0.011421156115829945, 0.011443805880844593, 0.015046306885778904, 0.0031983524095267057, -0.00022576033370569348, -0.013644260354340076, 0.027532294392585754, 0.005881742108613253, 0.0036233291029930115, -0.0019673751667141914, -0.04411528632044792, 0.04680918902158737, -0.046706631779670715, 0.004406320862472057, -0.00784154050052166, -0.021492671221494675, -0.027484901249408722, -0.0008461180259473622, 0.021754296496510506, -0.0007717509288340807, 0.029627200216054916, -0.002996720839291811, 0.003382523078471422, -0.00378436129540205, -0.006949275266379118, 0.0024567903019487858, -0.008391945622861385, -0.03836875781416893, -0.011411708779633045, 0.005301595665514469, 0.06553135812282562, 0.0474553257226944, -0.01973961479961872, 0.01535956934094429, -0.021943021565675735, 0.0456203892827034, -0.007698365952819586, -0.03528834506869316, -0.015676677227020264, 0.0034950023982673883, -0.008423402905464172, -0.011953504756093025, -0.01612868160009384, 0.057241931557655334, 0.020535806193947792, -0.011898096650838852, -0.026847224682569504, 0.034560833126306534, 0.00112572917714715, 0.005855184514075518, 0.020800409838557243, -0.037998877465724945, 0.02968931756913662, -0.020831098780035973, -0.013296092860400677, -0.052359458059072495, 0.006136486306786537, -0.015417302027344704, -0.06357676535844803, 0.0535888634622097, 0.010936176404356956, -0.031556565314531326, 0.008393753319978714, -0.0006075780256651342, 0.010018054395914078, -0.02498805709183216, -0.037084877490997314, -0.0690915510058403, 0.015158675611019135, -0.001391471829265356, -0.013897706754505634, -0.03243308514356613, 0.02198389731347561, -0.025919627398252487, 0.020305311307311058, 0.02284214086830616, -0.005083417519927025, 0.0251987986266613, -0.0150311179459095, 0.010232734493911266, 0.006161617115139961, 0.05750235170125961, -0.021116402000188828, 0.005022733937948942, 0.023864172399044037, -0.057823698967695236, -0.000012210584827698767, 0.018159201368689537, -0.007970169186592102, 0.01716221496462822, -0.03357145935297012, -0.01540234126150608, -0.029806628823280334, 0.05575859174132347, -0.013702203519642353, -0.03451891243457794, -0.04122032970190048, 0.0006753634079359472, -0.022556692361831665, 0.039796967059373856, 0.020159773528575897, 0.004846784286201, -0.03274799883365631, 0.029921336099505424, 0.05189121887087822, 0.003074404550716281, -0.030191535130143166, -0.013022968545556068, -0.02227768674492836, 0.0256038811057806, -0.03396579995751381, -0.033808253705501556, 0.04285015910863876, 0.04423481598496437, -0.055060457438230515, 0.007309413980692625, 0.007671130821108818, -0.025873621925711632, -0.043188225477933884, -0.019677238538861275, -0.03733275085687637, 0.01700962893664837, 0.029510831460356712, -0.06932491809129715, 0.01875806227326393, 0.029317468404769897, -0.04522564262151718, 0.027941972017288208, -0.0037912484258413315, -0.014804016798734665, -0.025516290217638016, 0.0385134220123291, -0.008937017992138863, 0.019046055153012276, 0.026448190212249756, 0.007126280106604099, 0.05714479461312294, 0.00578731345012784, -0.018606241792440414, -0.00992835033684969, 0.004066186491400003, 0.02754202112555504, 0.013181691989302635, -0.058333851397037506, 0.03628261387348175, -0.034039609134197235, -0.06087438389658928, 0.010414761491119862, 0.002265251474454999, 0.019817115738987923, 0.036832019686698914, 0.01382065936923027, -0.0029434419702738523, 0.05597233027219772, 0.0174223892390728, -0.02561943233013153, -0.015138233080506325, -0.00995752401649952, 0.011377451941370964, -0.002775787841528654, -0.00550733832642436, 0.03783771023154259, -0.0028259167447686195, 0.021067075431346893, -0.012280154973268509, 0.002411814173683524, -0.02503070794045925, 0.02096334472298622, 0.0009641930810175836, -0.0033145591150969267, -0.004564565606415272, -0.022542467340826988, 0.014429206028580666, -0.055469244718551636, -0.010709665715694427, 0.02454378642141819, 0.035506486892700195, -0.012103613466024399, 0.025450292974710464, -0.013471141457557678, -0.0268529262393713, 0.016592254862189293, 0.004113547503948212, -0.03232317790389061, -0.06300640106201172, -0.026020409539341927, -0.00924045592546463, -0.01760377176105976, -0.04488464444875717, -0.02874663844704628, -0.018876802176237106, 0.02815110795199871, 0.004109719768166542, 0.01613098755478859, 0.010040750727057457, -0.033407315611839294, 0.015160179696977139, -0.06552862375974655, 0.023973383009433746, -0.014141608029603958, -0.009675951674580574, -0.04301253333687782, -0.0019400925375521183, -0.02529851533472538, 0.013420075178146362, 0.010180026292800903, -0.003887377679347992, 0.029300188645720482, -0.025199757888913155, 0.02153632789850235, 0.023811377584934235, -0.03743917495012283, 0.09067795425653458, 0.020763922482728958, -0.018884150311350822, -0.00548327574506402, -0.0018605192890390754, 0.035049472004175186, 0.0031300776172429323, -0.021731285378336906, 0.0027153322007507086, 0.021991850808262825, 0.004987777676433325, -0.037904661148786545, 0.010229003615677357, -0.02814122661948204, -0.0031687815207988024, 0.056275300681591034, -0.006652345880866051, 0.009747941046953201, 0.040253039449453354, 0.019712699577212334, -0.011342438869178295, 0.023164082318544388, -0.045115962624549866, -0.015733158215880394, 0.025821495801210403, 0.009052280336618423, 0.009770284406840801, -0.072841577231884, 0.007588480599224567, 0.018654808402061462, -0.027785878628492355, -0.0008141353027895093, 0.012650540098547935, -0.01878369227051735, -0.009618327021598816, -0.0033042198047041893, 0.028137318789958954, -0.01334744319319725, -0.05147291347384453, -0.034125056117773056, 0.018811630085110664, -0.0008335625752806664, -0.0016522861551493406, -0.004936487413942814, 0.054534055292606354, -0.01764628291130066, 0.0614888072013855, 0.013354554772377014, 0.029265182092785835, -0.0593709722161293, 0.0127499895170331, 0.0097608407959342, -0.01215791143476963, 0.03860662505030632, 0.003621191717684269, -0.000565787311643362, 0.021503381431102753, -0.050604987889528275, -0.015566525980830193, -0.05884740874171257, -0.0255110040307045, -0.024170270189642906, 0.029109742492437363, 0.010684718377888203, 0.009763907641172409, 0.02152210660278797, 0.035027481615543365, -0.016166551038622856, -0.010679604485630989, -0.00004019843981950544, -0.00058456213446334, 0.03982444107532501, -0.02074604295194149, 0.0045771817676723, 0.024898502975702286, -0.021816320717334747, -0.018905065953731537, -0.00671866862103343, 0.012032159604132175, 0.027887914329767227, -0.0007222098647616804, -0.045797012746334076, -0.014241237193346024, -0.026695217937231064, -0.008488229475915432, -0.034908585250377655, -0.053090810775756836, -0.02005717344582081, 0.019818879663944244, -0.0032915212213993073, 0.015186455100774765 ]
<p>The only thing I understood about fuzzy neurons is that the neuron's activation function is replaced with some operation used in fuzzy. Other than that, I didn't understand much from science paper I found. Also, it is hard to just Google it because of it's name, which results in listing some fuzzy or ANN or hybrid systems, which is not what I'm looking for.</p> <p>Is there anything more to fuzzy neurons than I have described above?</p> <p>Also, I'm curious, <strong>when and how to use it</strong>?</p> <p>And is there <strong>any other change in neural network structure or calculation that needs implementing</strong> if I'm going to use fuzzy neuron. </p> <p>If someone has a good material on this subject, please link. I really have had a hard time finding anything on this subject. </p> <p>EDIT: Title of the paper I've mentioned: Combining neural networks and fuzzy logic for applications in char.recognition. ByAnne Magaly de Paula Canuto. University of Kent. Can't find link to it anymore, i found it last year. But this is the title. Fuzzy neuron is mentioned in section 1.4. </p>
74,315
[ -0.012879401445388794, -0.055090274661779404, -0.002745438599959016, -0.013232686556875706, 0.03889217972755432, 0.010451269336044788, -0.00846846029162407, -0.029414383694529533, 0.0214682687073946, -0.010503246448934078, 0.024419277906417847, 0.07580755650997162, 0.02966751530766487, 0.017022933810949326, 0.02395121566951275, -0.018703725188970566, -0.012478021904826164, -0.012348688207566738, -0.017124278470873833, -0.009729117155075073, -0.014493784867227077, 0.03567030653357506, 0.005295948125422001, 0.011380377225577831, -0.009237965568900108, 0.04517451673746109, -0.009966523386538029, -0.014013445936143398, 0.06100798770785332, 0.04153452441096306, -0.03770732134580612, -0.002485012635588646, 0.0024047009646892548, 0.029327332973480225, -0.0074609206058084965, -0.0053513990715146065, -0.0031016995199024677, -0.05515260994434357, -0.01876036636531353, -0.0011608783388510346, -0.02671804465353489, -0.03272781893610954, 0.009893503971397877, 0.034014102071523666, -0.04792771488428116, 0.0360795296728611, -0.023945020511746407, -0.04554343223571777, -0.035387225449085236, -0.07000536471605301, 0.0763310045003891, -0.0004809452220797539, 0.018573498353362083, 0.04313230141997337, 0.03812683746218681, 0.027116982266306877, 0.06385711580514908, 0.06460077315568924, -0.011476865038275719, -0.06019699200987816, 0.010719039477407932, -0.04521407559514046, -0.0015466142212972045, -0.041973039507865906, -0.04498763754963875, 0.02593047544360161, -0.018379556015133858, -0.04349453002214432, 0.04413338750600815, -0.022577818483114243, 0.017619580030441284, -0.012456802651286125, 0.008985839784145355, -0.01121369656175375, -0.01264111790806055, -0.023991720750927925, 0.00833964254707098, 0.0322079062461853, 0.054702047258615494, 0.028307175263762474, -0.020806778222322464, 0.0380096361041069, 0.003612687811255455, 0.005541082471609116, 0.015193977393209934, 0.0005069930921308696, 0.0896032527089119, -0.03383977338671684, 0.021504223346710205, -0.0028296923264861107, -0.012283836491405964, -0.013021687045693398, 0.040583714842796326, 0.00767788989469409, -0.047905221581459045, 0.0089721055701375, 0.035687778145074844, 0.011243301443755627, 0.0036288094706833363, -0.03026217222213745, 0.03077033907175064, -0.015098024159669876, 0.029527602717280388, 0.047023773193359375, -0.018612900748848915, -0.0372479185461998, 0.001080437214113772, -0.009053097106516361, -0.01945750042796135, 0.03791682794690132, -0.0020488628651946783, 0.01754928007721901, -0.0013584542321041226, -0.002447050530463457, 0.040124304592609406, -0.03688004985451698, 0.00701875239610672, 0.01646769791841507, 0.010053473524749279, 0.04927701875567436, 0.030946077778935432, -0.03850908949971199, 0.0308645348995924, 0.005206207744777203, -0.07622623443603516, 0.030881626531481743, 0.022497527301311493, 0.010716474615037441, -0.02191871963441372, 0.07938455045223236, -0.016742508858442307, -0.023932764306664467, 0.022346042096614838, -0.02075560763478279, 0.029203619807958603, 0.02288668043911457, -0.08778511732816696, -0.02498645894229412, 0.0541934110224247, -0.05944445729255676, 0.03727331385016441, -0.06890786439180374, 0.039299558848142624, 0.029673082754015923, 0.07244887948036194, 0.0488598570227623, 0.014963384717702866, 0.027501899749040604, -0.01689128205180168, -0.0004890139098279178, -0.025901466608047485, -0.029857147485017776, 0.031183579936623573, -0.006452913396060467, -0.018832745030522346, -0.032781630754470825, 0.049578506499528885, 0.004186614416539669, -0.027560019865632057, -0.03643442317843437, 0.06330457329750061, 0.011870484799146652, -0.006979302503168583, -0.01702955551445484, 0.007727979216724634, -0.006760207936167717, 0.07961077243089676, -0.005604857578873634, 0.017639657482504845, 0.021115344017744064, -0.00039364455733448267, 0.006581540685147047, 0.015839632600545883, 0.03514019027352333, 0.06014195829629898, -0.029278412461280823, -0.0398007296025753, -0.01926398277282715, 0.007787399459630251, 0.005762787070125341, -0.04406857490539551, -0.033936358988285065, 0.00414253119379282, 0.0379338338971138, -0.004828060511499643, 0.03805575892329216, -0.0006003594025969505, -0.048694804310798645, 0.014476896263659, -0.03282376378774643, -0.03265610709786415, -0.09023313224315643, 0.01635565049946308, -0.03410770744085312, -0.042105719447135925, 0.021297024562954903, 0.00769073935225606, 0.02344021387398243, -0.022505560889840126, -0.024424593895673752, -0.046392329037189484, 0.011555826291441917, -0.01179832499474287, -0.002545108087360859, -0.0041065700352191925, 0.026637710630893707, -0.030468285083770752, -0.01644359901547432, 0.03065698780119419, -0.05238152667880058, -0.07012868672609329, 0.0052699437364935875, -0.002805685391649604, 0.017121367156505585, -0.008946721442043781, -0.03000042401254177, 0.01720467209815979, 0.008543466217815876, -0.011505451053380966, -0.005002137273550034, -0.026968006044626236, 0.07502559572458267, 0.035262931138277054, 0.008747472427785397, 0.037956804037094116, 0.05251391977071762, 0.016609780490398407, -0.0056400541216135025, 0.0184751246124506, -0.029983095824718475, -0.06830976903438568, -0.010900145396590233, 0.046040091663599014, 0.007694339845329523, -0.03445858880877495, 0.025107750669121742, 0.01655465178191662, 0.029066067188978195, 0.010531044565141201, 0.029048841446638107, -0.04646451026201248, -0.009204166941344738, 0.0020314243156462908, 0.008011864498257637, -0.0034438371658325195, -0.01612410508096218, 0.02194182388484478, 0.03209236264228821, 0.024962475523352623, 0.009827167727053165, -0.04628336429595947, 0.08715908974409103, 0.0018494771793484688, 0.01978844590485096, 0.00795179232954979, -0.03592206910252571, 0.013274582102894783, -0.049039166420698166, -0.0027890035416930914, 0.021915828809142113, 0.012011932209134102, 0.004795897286385298, 0.009691144339740276, -0.040500521659851074, -0.004255338571965694, 0.02954741008579731, 0.024073848500847816, 0.011263606138527393, 0.018819659948349, -0.02398625947535038, 0.017731420695781708, -0.03509854897856712, 0.008142028003931046, -0.03990167751908302, 0.02365521527826786, 0.015621275641024113, 0.008777718059718609, 0.03975572809576988, 0.005488611292093992, -0.0051661147736012936, -0.011902045458555222, -0.02878723107278347, 0.009664418175816536, 0.012147030793130398, -0.06788262724876404, -0.010236822068691254, 0.01531505398452282, -0.024143271148204803, 0.0374150276184082, -0.007708071265369654, 0.01315086055546999, 0.005196094047278166, -0.01863742806017399, -0.07436655461788177, -0.0020482419058680534, -0.04128221049904823, 0.03581663966178894, -0.004487513564527035, -0.028527935966849327, 0.005158618092536926, 0.0005248786183074117, -0.013273191638290882, 0.03604369983077049, -0.028715044260025024, 0.008432302623987198, -0.02126334235072136, 0.0071472544223070145, 0.008767075836658478, -0.020580889657139778, -0.011471699923276901, 0.044153161346912384, -0.016976192593574524, -0.011296022683382034, -0.05208522453904152, -0.048916809260845184, 0.027669206261634827, 0.006521585863083601, 0.0272815003991127, 0.014808084815740585, -0.020858487114310265, 0.07856011390686035, -0.03320321813225746, -0.06452810764312744, -0.027408886700868607, -0.00002593689350760542, -0.022057782858610153, -0.02533172443509102, -0.013179231435060501, 0.005600053817033768, 0.011872631497681141, 0.013229288160800934, 0.03170936182141304, 0.0068143634125590324, 0.06928067654371262, 0.016231074929237366, -0.02980932593345642, 0.021037301048636436, -0.010196030139923096, -0.04917159676551819, 0.03335016965866089, 0.024008262902498245, -0.03547096624970436, 0.03823447600007057, -0.011327298358082771, -0.01094770710915327, 0.01585882529616356, 0.021475007757544518, 0.04929277300834656, -0.0028556182514876127, -0.003439089981839061, -0.03879917412996292, 0.034232933074235916, -0.03900859132409096, -0.007545328699052334, 0.0011235404526814818, 0.025383345782756805, 0.07714027166366577, -0.02613174542784691, 0.0011037344811484218, 0.031468089669942856, 0.011520270258188248, -0.015839600935578346, 0.011021842248737812, -0.0038144595455378294, -0.03823992609977722, 0.019810613244771957, -0.04414573311805725, 0.03318440541625023, 0.030117018148303032, 0.0395166389644146, 0.013621962629258633, 0.041164666414260864, -0.01072657760232687, 0.004511982202529907, -0.048378851264715195, 0.0083532789722085, -0.04332279786467552, 0.07036423683166504, -0.005804075859487057, 0.05532832071185112, -0.0013709537452086806, -0.0004038205661345273, 0.04141051694750786, 0.007570807356387377, -0.09564020484685898, 0.01697179302573204, -0.010473020374774933, -0.0014022038085386157, 0.0077462634071707726, -0.011544576846063137, 0.013220313005149364, 0.00012565664655994624, -0.01573021337389946, -0.02836081013083458, -0.010109703056514263, -0.05227293074131012, 0.015567649155855179, -0.011076284572482109, 0.007457328960299492, -0.02145850658416748, 0.013702629134058952, -0.002397960051894188, -0.02895110845565796, -0.007210687734186649, 0.022284967824816704, -0.021374497562646866, -0.016103330999612808, -0.021854687482118607, 0.021114569157361984, 0.057147711515426636, 0.03732752054929733, 0.0350629948079586, 0.03150535002350807, -0.022249195724725723, -0.001527086948044598, 0.026408566161990166, 0.0787663534283638, 0.02534038946032524, 0.003197466256096959, -0.0204190444201231, -0.06185908615589142, -0.04428405314683914, 0.0062375180423259735, 0.06207137554883957, -0.006204553879797459, 0.012775547802448273, 0.020802916958928108, 0.026661431416869164, -0.062213197350502014, 0.02629220485687256, 0.06418277323246002, 0.022795287892222404, -0.03937002271413803, -0.0167451910674572, -0.011945025064051151, -0.035841524600982666, -0.007007015869021416, 0.05857808515429497, 0.0031032031401991844, -0.011048861779272556, 0.022188106551766396, 0.016473636031150818, -0.02702808380126953, -0.039745911955833435, -0.044231098145246506, 0.03674927353858948, -0.012122915126383305, -0.021270450204610825, 0.002393256174400449, -0.032051004469394684, 0.05611015111207962, 0.029316425323486328, 0.008094710297882557, -0.008368500508368015, -0.0685153603553772, 0.005654747132211924, 0.06970541179180145, 0.05020447075366974, -0.03788921982049942, -0.021553361788392067, -0.04533464089035988, -0.005695462692528963, 0.025655148550868034, -0.030953170731663704, 0.028702054172754288, -0.0239599347114563, -0.04754003882408142, -0.026392005383968353, 0.02202628366649151, 0.03701714798808098, 0.02711384743452072, -0.0006550505058839917, 0.018166400492191315, 0.005788843613117933, -0.0007109713042154908, -0.04147642105817795, -0.03133903071284294, 0.0015143934870138764, 0.04586535319685936, -0.021022848784923553, 0.00017947271408047527, -0.008774231187999249, 0.029709752649068832, -0.03943387791514397, -0.0687083974480629, -0.003480758285149932, -0.009744822047650814, -0.012256325222551823, 0.021486036479473114, -0.011454354971647263, -0.025091899558901787, 0.018560215830802917, -0.002520459471270442, -0.03374677896499634, -0.05223006010055542, -0.024835439398884773, 0.037844378501176834, 0.06828068196773529, -0.008853471837937832, 0.051139332354068756, -0.03541495278477669, -0.012394373305141926, 0.02901497110724449, -0.01026886235922575, 0.00311672524549067, -0.04181801527738571, -0.039517637342214584, -0.014864037744700909, 0.009660528041422367, -0.03286413103342056, 0.05500661954283714, 0.014513893984258175, 0.035095516592264175, -0.014024433679878712, -0.01754927448928356, -0.026501016691327095, 0.015036295168101788, -0.0011502568377181888, -0.02724432945251465, 0.024393519386649132, 0.022428788244724274, -0.0030266749672591686, -0.015620561316609383, 0.002176182111725211, -0.010393334552645683, 0.02346748858690262, 0.033033840358257294, -0.011238514445722103, -0.0434378944337368, -0.015739677473902702, -0.03936159983277321, 0.06271009892225266, -0.022164056077599525, 0.08009594678878784, -0.040694862604141235, 0.012819096446037292, 0.03795147314667702, -0.06576424837112427, -0.02856418490409851, 0.013903099112212658, -0.008196398615837097, -0.014298311434686184, -0.05235697329044342, 0.037937313318252563, 0.008941189385950565, 0.014852489344775677, -0.018432775512337685, -0.06587875634431839, 0.017979860305786133, -0.035214800387620926, -0.056579407304525375, -0.04338578134775162, 0.022995319217443466, 0.010963390581309795, -0.049644649028778076, -0.012311063706874847, 0.06256236881017685, -0.014818733558058739, -0.0174621120095253, 0.05511847138404846, -0.031153909862041473, 0.06766373664140701, 0.015686731785535812, 0.01707424223423004, 0.021107889711856842, -0.025993958115577698, 0.005757300648838282, -0.008758402429521084, 0.025838026776909828, -0.032713547348976135, 0.0011945291189476848, -0.007458848878741264, 0.0008556282846257091, 0.01612253300845623, 0.014767874032258987, 0.010252115316689014, 0.03157768025994301, 0.03442613407969475, 0.006742733530700207, -0.01865946128964424, 0.0130394846200943, -0.005087305326014757, -0.00047871534479781985, -0.008076799102127552, 0.017800884321331978, -0.021137814968824387, -0.015299536287784576, 0.03314394876360893, -0.003929181024432182, -0.02062172442674637, 0.013970350846648216, 0.061107948422431946, -0.02818319760262966, 0.015342095866799355, 0.012735327705740929, -0.03659527748823166, 0.04489203542470932, 0.001236092415638268, 0.009932294487953186, -0.03871510922908783, -0.003388868412002921, -0.01977437175810337, 0.0026825403328984976, -0.02584780380129814, -0.025132566690444946, 0.05419623851776123, -0.024241888895630836, 0.04585404694080353, 0.05232476070523262, 0.007077045273035765, -0.028749532997608185, -0.0015683904057368636, -0.024851614609360695, 0.008204308338463306, -0.037600383162498474, 0.0462050661444664, 0.0038687929045408964, -0.0014736837474629283, 0.012304478324949741, 0.02610444277524948, 0.024503739550709724, 0.020919661968946457, 0.0024063419550657272, 0.0443393774330616, 0.0018823634600266814, -0.023634755983948708, -0.049321770668029785, 0.04031221568584442, -0.0673626959323883, 0.021328281611204147, 0.054464805871248245, -0.02749890834093094, 0.06041543558239937, 0.02724534086883068, 0.00958215445280075, -0.024273034185171127, -0.00019074439478572458, -0.013374723494052887, 0.01853223517537117, 0.017703067511320114, -0.04156709834933281, -0.015297354198992252, -0.0033970430959016085, 0.024006856605410576, -0.008042962290346622, 0.020398836582899094, -0.040601104497909546, -0.05665985867381096, -0.02776600979268551, -0.05121133103966713, -0.036762136965990067, 0.02727913111448288, 0.03135905787348747, -0.05984324961900711, 0.05844442546367645, -0.009295661933720112, 0.04074433445930481, 0.01305494923144579, 0.04669126868247986, 0.011775285936892033, 0.0799461379647255, -0.026834042742848396, -0.0021678993944078684, 0.010624178685247898, -0.012308573350310326, 0.11296962201595306, 0.05869732052087784, 0.0058146994560956955, -0.0811496376991272, 0.0388534851372242, 0.004911663942039013, -0.00504400534555316, -0.0009942151373252273, 0.005932688247412443, 0.030689824372529984, 0.022906305268406868, -0.021481206640601158, 0.022003402933478355, 0.0037874376866966486, 0.009168234653770924, 0.07728036493062973, -0.02929692156612873, -0.059682514518499374, 0.011024201288819313, -0.009211305528879166, 0.002779349684715271, -0.018740592524409294, -0.07263017445802689, 0.012954279780387878, -0.012888836674392223, -0.018177738413214684, -0.053319696336984634, -0.017965620383620262, 0.040133874863386154, -0.015592221170663834, -0.037691619247198105, -0.01700032688677311, -0.03765721619129181, 0.00659105135127902, 0.017460813745856285, 0.021767985075712204, -0.011202224530279636, -0.014977098442614079, 0.015969227999448776, 0.0478389672935009, 0.04666928946971893, -0.029644489288330078, 0.014800697565078735, -0.00036612519761547446, -0.02289426699280739, -0.01838204264640808, -0.026792198419570923, 0.02054448425769806, -0.005550475791096687, 0.01420689094811678, 0.00014682032633572817, 0.06186201795935631, 0.034176331013441086, -0.03148583695292473, -0.0402052067220211, 0.029641613364219666, 0.026816608384251595, 0.03462633490562439, -0.018422851338982582, -0.029682593420147896, 0.017159024253487587, -0.010209727101027966, 0.004829378332942724, 0.026811057701706886, -0.03525878116488457, 0.0002427876606816426, -0.014428431168198586, -0.02087784744799137, -0.026539819315075874, -0.01099749282002449, -0.01570437103509903, 0.010567842051386833, -0.03325587883591652, 0.01882888190448284, 0.0038637667894363403, 0.02281280793249607, 0.01721687987446785, -0.038266878575086594, -0.019903240725398064, 0.0013709858758375049, -0.05862021446228027, 0.0549338199198246, -0.023036900907754898, -0.014014891348779202, -0.022798504680395126, -0.020244289189577103, 0.08571633696556091, 0.010357094928622246, 0.029933754354715347, 0.03769323229789734, -0.04199136048555374, -0.021861813962459564, 0.015596325509250164, -0.033743035048246384, -0.029406530782580376, -0.0023768506944179535, -0.03108327090740204, 0.016403023153543472, -0.04897897318005562, 0.03042815625667572, 0.06518536061048508, 0.000052577583119273186, 0.003472012933343649, 0.026023920625448227, 0.013792816549539566, -0.02151411399245262, 0.010320558212697506, -0.05478372052311897, -0.005943397991359234, -0.03027700074017048, 0.03151006996631622, -0.052921395748853683, -0.016753025352954865, -0.024693969637155533, -0.021686607971787453, -0.01910698600113392, 0.012210547924041748, -0.03805914148688316, -0.011952926404774189, -0.023854054510593414, 0.04527095705270767, 0.00884921569377184, -0.0003933896659873426, -0.026026232168078423, 0.00257739145308733, -0.013483035378158092, -0.033916670829057693, -0.035332657396793365, 0.025570550933480263, 0.011212455108761787, -0.0192304365336895, 0.02439454197883606, -0.006337038706988096, -0.006867825984954834, 0.0112422751262784, -0.013890152797102928, 0.0082929078489542, 0.040916185826063156, -0.0381665900349617, -0.0038067989517003298, 0.018195640295743942, -0.04949716851115227, -0.03608978912234306, 0.027806513011455536, -0.016850508749485016, 0.016552718356251717, 0.0563664510846138, -0.029039226472377777, 0.015622233971953392, 0.04997902363538742, -0.03201136365532875, -0.009412210434675217, -0.012860909104347229, 0.0008828758727759123, 0.016518570482730865, 0.017816836014389992, -0.006448862608522177, -0.010394617915153503, -0.01545630395412445, -0.005411665886640549, 0.04318816959857941, 0.01758556254208088, -0.006369707640260458, 0.024788787588477135, -0.010787572711706161, -0.005635787267237902, 0.0074800653383135796, -0.005234441254287958, 0.035483263432979584, 0.00830020196735859, -0.019723474979400635, 0.009215517900884151, -0.014387172646820545, 0.025998789817094803, -0.08210856467485428, 0.0000024711373498575995, 0.00838419795036316, 0.033314403146505356, 0.03155336529016495, -0.05556485429406166, -0.0032177746761590242, 0.021143222227692604, -0.043038610368967056, -0.012714043259620667, -0.028902370482683182, -0.021290946751832962, 0.028429973870515823, -0.01713964343070984, -0.004291471093893051, 0.02484622411429882, -0.002993121277540922, -0.005728557705879211, 0.02380484901368618, 0.0014713483396917582, -0.026033803820610046, -0.007282366510480642, -0.04870430380105972, 0.03451531007885933, 0.009584842249751091, -0.01325884461402893, 0.054937537759542465, -0.039781082421541214, -0.02527874894440174, 0.02631228230893612, -0.029219243675470352, 0.002279711188748479, 0.031336940824985504, 0.018477508798241615, 0.05388105660676956, -0.0006131476256996393, 0.010021607391536236, -0.019498780369758606, -0.010721578262746334, -0.0066124252043664455, 0.04401778057217598, 0.04383962228894234, -0.011565040796995163, -0.008317496627569199, 0.015304969623684883, 0.00023051517200656235, -0.01819603517651558, -0.021501725539565086, -0.03458046913146973, 0.0126099344342947, 0.01753837987780571, -0.0067801158875226974, 0.006470173131674528, -0.020650040358304977, -0.013881899416446686, -0.02678392268717289, -0.01185731403529644, -0.014754429459571838, 0.03658610209822655, 0.029766837134957314, 0.03400667756795883, 0.013435160741209984, -0.03355728089809418, 0.0020466770511120558, -0.005462481640279293, -0.0195634588599205, -0.02839602157473564, 0.030745165422558784, 0.014862415380775928, -0.0012145423097535968, 0.003172619268298149, -0.0276031456887722, -0.03815602511167526, 0.046894825994968414, -0.020897289738059044, 0.012823699973523617, 0.005441923160105944, -0.045214567333459854, 0.014576693996787071, -0.050842441618442535, 0.0713193491101265, 0.025047829374670982, 0.003700064029544592, -0.05393695831298828, -0.00832828413695097, -0.02740444429218769, 0.014788069762289524, 0.05530437454581261, -0.03855716064572334, -0.006492939777672291, -0.015444950200617313, 0.01934439316391945, 0.031034881249070168, -0.01720460131764412, 0.03302253037691116, -0.03260871395468712, -0.014485836960375309, -0.04906808212399483, -0.00788115244358778, -0.01970900222659111, 0.023315709084272385, 0.03607631474733353, 0.008315708488225937, 0.005998748820275068, -0.024136146530508995, -0.014190004207193851, 0.05812991410493851, 0.026482252404093742, 0.016221053898334503, 0.05949365720152855, -0.0341099388897419, 0.014791474677622318, 0.028404565528035164, 0.024494865909218788, -0.03829313814640045, 0.029019661247730255, -0.012869413010776043, -0.009742582216858864, -0.021333787590265274, 0.021656764671206474, 0.02156534604728222, -0.06304652988910675, -0.010509784333407879, 0.04842861741781235, -0.015044906176626682, -0.013913895934820175, 0.07108744233846664, 0.00941766519099474, 0.013267307542264462, -0.016356101259589195, 0.01834951899945736, 0.0005539028788916767, 0.007357088848948479, 0.0030549303628504276, 0.009659694507718086, 0.012104615569114685, 0.007888590916991234, 0.042487647384405136, 0.025780342519283295, -0.017847755923867226, 0.06622467190027237, -0.015110046602785587, 0.036760974675416946, -0.054310888051986694, -0.001564707956276834, 0.021312041208148003, 0.00464664725586772, 0.03768942132592201, 0.015568659640848637, -0.030753467231988907, 0.08743100613355637, -0.035956479609012604, 0.013409100472927094, 0.004479377996176481, -0.028064139187335968, -0.03198624402284622, -0.005908924154937267, 0.023606566712260246, 0.025388900190591812, -0.008763240650296211, 0.051523469388484955, -0.01273744273930788, 0.017802946269512177, 0.05745118483901024, -0.035565685480833054, 0.0245741568505764, -0.027374807745218277, 0.024558207020163536, -0.019801681861281395, -0.013693010434508324, -0.04190559312701225, -0.009852934628725052, 0.007850388064980507, 0.03566843643784523, 0.0236002616584301, -0.001877690083347261, -0.0035126940347254276, -0.014472839422523975, 0.04182150959968567, -0.06152775511145592, 0.007740432396531105, -0.02897489257156849, 0.038599394261837006, -0.030054636299610138, -0.02761777676641941 ]
<p>As title, I have a correlation matrix available with cor() function </p> <pre><code> corMatrix&lt;-cor(mydata) corMatrix is a 98 by 98 matrix storing positive and negative correlation values. </code></pre> <p>I want to assess which correlations values are significant among all the correlations. Permutation test has been suggested to do this.</p> <p>How to perform a permutation test on the correlation matrix ? How to obtain p-values for each correlation value estimated ? Any package suggested ? Or answer with working code will be well appreciated. </p>
74,316
[ -0.01422885525971651, 0.01933326944708824, 0.012760861776769161, 0.01060614176094532, 0.03690677881240845, 0.016436651349067688, -0.0022717679385095835, -0.02490612305700779, 0.018450427800416946, -0.03662661090493202, 0.025220753625035286, 0.0407329760491848, 0.016830718144774437, 0.03519267588853836, 0.021139727905392647, 0.002913384698331356, -0.017825905233621597, 0.006952371913939714, -0.00400394294410944, -0.0026846732944250107, -0.01183800958096981, 0.005133532918989658, 0.01770698092877865, -0.005677298177033663, -0.009138695895671844, 0.05695304647088051, 0.014531344175338745, -0.010116489604115486, 0.017164060845971107, 0.0727243572473526, -0.06972990930080414, -0.02632959373295307, 0.021948223933577538, 0.07301077991724014, 0.0164902675896883, -0.028940625488758087, 0.008141806349158287, -0.02193991094827652, -0.0054355585016310215, 0.027997933328151703, -0.022211384028196335, -0.03733731061220169, 0.021366596221923828, 0.03345781937241554, 0.009220553562045097, 0.015518811531364918, -0.021188199520111084, -0.029787501320242882, 0.044420406222343445, -0.04574726149439812, 0.10407864302396774, 0.0170819740742445, 0.02750769443809986, 0.0117963757365942, 0.004975358955562115, -0.008347941562533379, 0.056921083480119705, 0.03958095610141754, -0.0016668224707245827, -0.038499653339385986, -0.02125391736626625, -0.08032015711069107, -0.013108085840940475, -0.010335801169276237, -0.031827352941036224, -0.0025455683935433626, -0.006298053078353405, -0.003108449513092637, 0.03968463093042374, -0.01897050440311432, 0.008852682076394558, 0.03187054023146629, 0.028772952035069466, -0.0467824786901474, 0.012886006385087967, -0.04850732162594795, 0.009914498776197433, -0.009947599843144417, 0.015688829123973846, 0.04470039904117584, -0.004639502614736557, 0.016337327659130096, 0.002941224491223693, 0.025730162858963013, 0.028572358191013336, -0.03072427213191986, 0.04271267354488373, -0.04117452725768089, 0.030246617272496223, 0.002853574464097619, -0.010738659650087357, -0.028029292821884155, 0.04857763275504112, 0.025865867733955383, -0.05978725105524063, 0.027063649147748947, -0.026205383241176605, 0.046953096985816956, -0.0047090803273022175, -0.014532826840877533, -0.02082451432943344, -0.010152699425816536, 0.024103768169879913, 0.040238093584775925, 0.007152152713388205, 0.0415077768266201, -0.02318345569074154, -0.010610698722302914, 0.007833757437765598, -0.02535141445696354, 0.008489084430038929, 0.03451113402843475, 0.01589357480406761, -0.01335042156279087, 0.022299589589238167, -0.04264267906546593, -0.01011709589511156, -0.004994520917534828, 0.05677950382232666, 0.09199856966733932, 0.027341777458786964, 0.0008704920182935894, 0.02246352843940258, -0.03293928503990173, -0.032630082219839096, 0.011575394310057163, 0.007290107663720846, 0.003940742462873459, -0.0306965671479702, 0.05939609184861183, -0.004416873212903738, -0.05769873037934303, 0.027080951258540154, -0.026421036571264267, 0.03205018863081932, -0.0018062351737171412, -0.12220688909292221, -0.03868967294692993, 0.02744469605386257, -0.021764319390058517, -0.012748107314109802, -0.021425575017929077, 0.020098203793168068, -0.003390316851437092, 0.06137553229928017, -0.0012241764925420284, 0.03806254267692566, 0.005847512278705835, 0.047187332063913345, 0.025265304371714592, -0.0761672705411911, 0.021212991327047348, -0.026904480531811714, -0.02175644040107727, -0.03442268818616867, -0.0829348936676979, 0.008756102994084358, -0.01242082193493843, 0.02298929914832115, 0.003833635477349162, 0.014725429937243462, -0.0024937207344919443, -0.016748106107115746, -0.007029212079942226, -0.006844825576990843, -0.010573924519121647, 0.059044454246759415, -0.00001851582055678591, 0.01886039413511753, -0.000348647910868749, -0.025070803239941597, 0.04748021066188812, -0.00040520858601666987, 0.05693534016609192, 0.03782186657190323, -0.03146306052803993, 0.008633418008685112, 0.0099090076982975, 0.03704938665032387, -0.0043654427863657475, -0.022235587239265442, -0.034327320754528046, 0.03574226796627045, -0.019930381327867508, 0.03461066633462906, 0.02400861121714115, -0.000979566597379744, -0.035974886268377304, 0.0644809901714325, -0.04401816800236702, -0.0192253515124321, -0.05406588688492775, 0.003099756082519889, 0.0003665044205263257, -0.06124534085392952, 0.0328778438270092, 0.0322035476565361, 0.0593227781355381, 0.0527801439166069, -0.023501861840486526, -0.03756440803408623, -0.011069167405366898, 0.05447269231081009, -0.009245033375918865, 0.001253278460353613, 0.008033810183405876, 0.034523412585258484, -0.032642170786857605, 0.04155344516038895, -0.046736571937799454, -0.009562748484313488, 0.017034852877259254, -0.026663612574338913, 0.009878122247755527, -0.002830099780112505, -0.03184638172388077, 0.02577345445752144, 0.012579572387039661, -0.008507339283823967, 0.04338190704584122, -0.034981194883584976, 0.048648566007614136, 0.04457894712686539, 0.03247151896357536, 0.024678125977516174, -0.00737672857940197, 0.027388527989387512, 0.011159910820424557, -0.025274356827139854, 0.008061794564127922, -0.05286141857504845, -0.00036491526407189667, 0.017277248203754425, 0.03332328051328659, -0.03899554908275604, -0.005730125587433577, 0.05750598758459091, -0.0021617671009153128, 0.022380996495485306, 0.048838019371032715, -0.016886910423636436, -0.03309999033808708, -0.010487696155905724, 0.04135678708553314, 0.034049954265356064, -0.002010026713833213, -0.0017043312545865774, 0.009056461974978447, 0.07981756329536438, 0.01785195991396904, -0.027064165100455284, 0.05316039174795151, -0.033701080828905106, 0.004415017087012529, -0.011571446433663368, -0.02491975575685501, 0.03982231765985489, -0.020081685855984688, 0.016681574285030365, 0.025290023535490036, -0.007610679138451815, 0.01396364625543356, 0.03873603045940399, -0.018627775833010674, 0.013923700898885727, 0.057288702577352524, -0.05794740468263626, -0.012349260970950127, 0.012548000551760197, -0.04629206657409668, 0.035773735493421555, 0.0036035184748470783, 0.002821223111823201, -0.03862429037690163, 0.041647765785455704, 0.03960554301738739, -0.01895253174006939, 0.034964386373758316, -0.022745369002223015, -0.021492591127753258, 0.00008338917541550472, -0.0033674626611173153, -0.009182596579194069, -0.0028316094540059566, -0.07379608601331711, -0.02769971266388893, -0.018684852868318558, -0.03657355159521103, 0.01124476920813322, -0.017956342548131943, -0.004999794065952301, 0.029706580564379692, -0.017363131046295166, -0.04429969936609268, -0.01323046162724495, 0.0044421665370464325, 0.03978710249066353, -0.05130638927221298, -0.033563483506441116, 0.028850669041275978, -0.011567975394427776, -0.024156592786312103, 0.0012461537262424827, -0.04609903693199158, -0.01922796294093132, -0.0019566675182431936, -0.002470721025019884, 0.03081517294049263, -0.022073738276958466, -0.009306186810135841, 0.023032812401652336, -0.015292665921151638, -0.015152557753026485, -0.060201749205589294, -0.045226238667964935, 0.02228129468858242, 0.006297090090811253, 0.01094154641032219, 0.009278587065637112, -0.01943519525229931, 0.021682903170585632, 0.03135553002357483, -0.03601786866784096, -0.032293979078531265, 0.005654862150549889, -0.031073158606886864, -0.002866057911887765, 0.035022709518671036, 0.02539645880460739, 0.03358074277639389, 0.024308301508426666, 0.023637251928448677, 0.025270115584135056, 0.05424872040748596, -0.02507947012782097, -0.04218801110982895, 0.020819462835788727, -0.01421837043017149, -0.029989471659064293, 0.031470801681280136, -0.01496963668614626, -0.017075903713703156, 0.0189854446798563, 0.01512457150965929, -0.009063243865966797, -0.0036716226022690535, -0.03262307867407799, -0.025399839505553246, -0.0024494556710124016, 0.030955031514167786, -0.03924598544836044, 0.017950788140296936, 0.009569020941853523, -0.02749507874250412, -0.024405797943472862, 0.03488941863179207, 0.0124617088586092, 0.0021377811208367348, 0.0340389721095562, 0.058990322053432465, 0.005884852260351181, -0.026676412671804428, 0.02334633655846119, -0.0245274156332016, -0.026588546112179756, 0.006465245969593525, -0.029719078913331032, 0.0009456684347242117, 0.04234760254621506, 0.025136929005384445, -0.0017880250234156847, -0.008840171620249748, -0.044558487832546234, 0.0366022065281868, -0.01929096132516861, 0.00962721835821867, -0.03442895784974098, 0.03071737103164196, -0.03122016228735447, 0.034963272511959076, 0.035416170954704285, -0.026596087962388992, 0.012547319754958153, 0.0028641768731176853, -0.049326520413160324, 0.05134829133749008, -0.010730554349720478, -0.0019047806272283196, 0.017956120893359184, -0.021372919902205467, -0.011154542677104473, -0.006762797478586435, 0.007549760863184929, -0.005703824106603861, 0.029431259259581566, -0.03844466432929039, 0.03353467211127281, -0.0178050734102726, 0.0024486405309289694, -0.00906384363770485, 0.01934587024152279, 0.04261814057826996, -0.010568453930318356, 0.042027268558740616, 0.030204087495803833, -0.020880764350295067, 0.01202469877898693, -0.004960210993885994, 0.0002531627251300961, 0.025998253375291824, 0.03296389803290367, 0.0044739218428730965, 0.03012860007584095, -0.022717656567692757, 0.03092009574174881, -0.043172333389520645, 0.03883517161011696, 0.04910685867071152, -0.01746312715113163, -0.0009486556518822908, -0.027857927605509758, -0.01031072624027729, -0.028542043641209602, 0.011416577734053135, 0.01658465899527073, -0.009375466033816338, 0.08420612663030624, 0.027465999126434326, -0.049540165811777115, 0.02000362053513527, 0.08811625093221664, 0.059417594224214554, -0.0028953892178833485, -0.026704274117946625, -0.009835704229772091, 0.014343544840812683, -0.0018822873244062066, -0.003402451518923044, 0.009550262242555618, -0.015761207789182663, 0.0002933997893705964, 0.009508529677987099, -0.028662849217653275, -0.01555235218256712, -0.007203883025795221, 0.02995903044939041, 0.07190579175949097, -0.0366230234503746, -0.018389903008937836, 0.020190171897411346, 0.03010895662009716, 0.008471282199025154, 0.020608432590961456, 0.017081866040825844, -0.059929654002189636, 0.03667544946074486, 0.07144403457641602, 0.06062348186969757, -0.012993216514587402, -0.011873247101902962, -0.04671823978424072, -0.042017512023448944, 0.058451104909181595, -0.03208933398127556, 0.04607347398996353, -0.01152215339243412, 0.020107422024011612, -0.042650651186704636, -0.013555847108364105, -0.056755054742097855, 0.03507430478930473, -0.03013906069099903, 0.012063289992511272, -0.05515265837311745, -0.02914590761065483, -0.020773211494088173, -0.016867082566022873, 0.04385346174240112, 0.030175628140568733, -0.007241761311888695, 0.03878187760710716, 0.034593142569065094, 0.00984816811978817, 0.007224563043564558, -0.06143202632665634, 0.012844664976000786, -0.0016278768889606, -0.00974463950842619, 0.057477936148643494, -0.0014834034955129027, 0.007350434083491564, -0.020246626809239388, -0.010461217723786831, -0.018088441342115402, 0.009900257922708988, -0.01852959208190441, 0.0541718415915966, 0.014809382148087025, -0.026059072464704514, 0.049924906343221664, 0.007670388091355562, -0.01388769131153822, -0.0016974691534414887, -0.045527439564466476, 0.008893354795873165, -0.005269377958029509, -0.0030941602308303118, -0.03852108493447304, 0.00935223139822483, -0.05507620424032211, 0.03355215862393379, -0.0058350288309156895, 0.020881377160549164, -0.022785373032093048, 0.059612106531858444, 0.01707368530333042, 0.04231800138950348, -0.025134779512882233, 0.013911187648773193, 0.02243446186184883, -0.0005455168429762125, -0.007415709085762501, -0.028240056708455086, 0.0331939160823822, -0.006509803235530853, -0.020979035645723343, 0.02068726345896721, -0.033794187009334564, -0.006159914657473564, -0.03302374109625816, -0.041324976831674576, -0.029102211818099022, -0.0335879921913147, 0.03207956627011299, 0.03701954707503319, 0.030369708314538002, 0.01795937679708004, -0.059393975883722305, 0.0007533481111750007, 0.06087728962302208, -0.013264096342027187, 0.033636674284935, -0.022189058363437653, 0.02020944468677044, -0.03670477122068405, 0.021208381280303, -0.072215236723423, -0.07614339143037796, -0.0005739816697314382, 0.022708380594849586, -0.029062900692224503, -0.027702530845999718, -0.001481733052060008, -0.02195405773818493, 0.005311146378517151, -0.020853914320468903, 0.01525092963129282, -0.011110300198197365, 0.034332647919654846, -0.002103655133396387, -0.03293447569012642, 0.08831074088811874, -0.025162024423480034, -0.009617294184863567, 0.048288166522979736, -0.015546389855444431, -0.015831636264920235, 0.0016324801836162806, 0.005080312956124544, -0.01981363445520401, -0.02218717709183693, -0.01287687849253416, 0.007138143293559551, 0.06297344714403152, -0.017112858593463898, -0.02472580596804619, -0.030055871233344078, -0.003965998534113169, 0.0028887316584587097, -0.03700889274477959, 0.006311103235930204, -0.041221003979444504, -0.004886244889348745, -0.008089382201433182, 0.013714104890823364, -0.04569009318947792, -0.04403591528534889, 0.024243131279945374, -0.009998197667300701, -0.01028046291321516, 0.020574742928147316, 0.07382063567638397, 0.0035119398962706327, 0.012310648337006569, -0.033100273460149765, -0.027220983058214188, -0.009327861480414867, 0.014840672723948956, 0.013617982156574726, -0.0036668332759290934, 0.010951247066259384, -0.02448495291173458, -0.044101085513830185, -0.01920580118894577, 0.008495189249515533, 0.0485609769821167, 0.003065116237848997, 0.04203273355960846, 0.07341179251670837, -0.011306368745863438, -0.013874265365302563, 0.036122098565101624, -0.006054469384253025, 0.0020608685445040464, 0.03038131818175316, 0.020515797659754753, 0.005622700322419405, -0.013094333000481129, 0.029345041140913963, 0.008101465180516243, 0.01463183294981718, 0.04199348762631416, 0.0088000213727355, 0.018065767362713814, 0.005718421656638384, 0.004817092325538397, -0.03150838986039162, 0.02509204111993313, -0.03113403543829918, 0.043134286999702454, -0.035822395235300064, -0.04256113991141319, 0.03106972575187683, 0.040368884801864624, -0.00012967802467755973, -0.0008779755444265902, -0.03468605503439903, -0.0400298610329628, 0.00723163690418005, 0.036149222403764725, -0.023394223302602768, 0.0026802190113812685, 0.009201277047395706, 0.059303250163793564, 0.001141421846114099, 0.05516021326184273, -0.04817484691739082, -0.07402879744768143, -0.00967448391020298, -0.026071732863783836, -0.019856436178088188, 0.02719462290406227, 0.0005872668116353452, -0.042271342128515244, -0.0003993164573330432, -0.007818125188350677, 0.0015016557881608605, 0.025238877162337303, 0.04540127143263817, -0.029348023235797882, 0.07197866588830948, -0.017146799713373184, -0.007187907118350267, 0.05132516101002693, -0.023173093795776367, 0.1139506846666336, 0.1042240560054779, 0.03315792605280876, -0.09623903781175613, 0.02639951929450035, 0.004073288757354021, -0.01735653169453144, -0.0519758015871048, 0.03616471216082573, 0.0219221543520689, 0.015147924423217773, 0.05648354813456535, 0.05871525779366493, 0.007787672337144613, -0.001478285063058138, 0.0568537712097168, -0.005466827657073736, -0.029846282675862312, 0.014790539629757404, 0.02042258158326149, -0.03634684905409813, -0.010129745118319988, -0.0793604627251625, 0.017958737909793854, -0.01890360191464424, -0.0007451813435181975, -0.03280317410826683, -0.034024033695459366, 0.028584804385900497, -0.010719310492277145, 0.0175446979701519, -0.009106533601880074, 0.004767240025103092, 0.013169155456125736, -0.009723994880914688, -0.017063181847333908, 0.04408639296889305, -0.021853625774383545, 0.03833197057247162, 0.02843792922794819, -0.012397043406963348, -0.007096240296959877, -0.003190546529367566, 0.03146529942750931, -0.004809290170669556, -0.03001481480896473, -0.010761620476841927, 0.06101810559630394, 0.005556134507060051, -0.025163821876049042, -0.0004444012010935694, -0.008625331334769726, -0.006868239026516676, -0.04600439965724945, -0.004999373573809862, 0.010371542535722256, 0.024052433669567108, -0.047138527035713196, -0.027132080867886543, -0.06111901253461838, -0.003249538829550147, -0.030874067917466164, 0.03820668160915375, 0.0010896642925217748, -0.02758704498410225, -0.027929343283176422, -0.05775846540927887, 0.06175392121076584, -0.004909531679004431, 0.008600943721830845, -0.011507151648402214, -0.047247886657714844, -0.04558321088552475, -0.011241582222282887, 0.020971883088350296, -0.0003883065073750913, 0.0036301559302955866, -0.00460361922159791, -0.0012057841522619128, -0.0035193930380046368, -0.00815925095230341, -0.008821303024888039, -0.01414758712053299, -0.026866406202316284, -0.03333091363310814, -0.029815934598445892, 0.08412729948759079, 0.01592043973505497, 0.023136872798204422, 0.01702999323606491, -0.025097914040088654, 0.03231201693415642, -0.007753224577754736, -0.0521836094558239, -0.025514788925647736, -0.010346920229494572, -0.019645635038614273, -0.022908980026841164, -0.036388102918863297, 0.04152436926960945, 0.0033974747639149427, -0.02005467563867569, -0.007379188667982817, 0.020512457937002182, -0.03319850191473961, 0.012431323528289795, 0.023404715582728386, -0.0078057958744466305, 0.0010513152228668332, -0.019958732649683952, -0.02220936305820942, -0.022353937849402428, 0.012628412805497646, -0.03526521101593971, -0.033642616122961044, 0.021838398650288582, 0.0023281399626284838, -0.013820880092680454, -0.024789389222860336, -0.012317770160734653, -0.014390057884156704, -0.03619189187884331, -0.005061911419034004, -0.07247048616409302, 0.010294782929122448, 0.004817803855985403, 0.010911518707871437, -0.029193194583058357, 0.03133019804954529, -0.026222607120871544, 0.027569854632019997, 0.04481216147542, 0.008142038248479366, 0.018467295914888382, -0.008422935381531715, 0.004878385458141565, 0.009707079268991947, 0.05974804610013962, -0.007959768176078796, -0.01223146915435791, 0.051156751811504364, -0.05385373532772064, -0.013914081268012524, 0.005603088065981865, -0.02620336413383484, 0.028602616861462593, -0.004775593522936106, -0.004812145140022039, -0.017832409590482712, 0.03143109753727913, -0.034690432250499725, -0.003337293863296509, -0.02029379829764366, 0.02850191853940487, 0.0003524480853229761, 0.0077345590107142925, -0.006322139874100685, -0.0019980433862656355, -0.02012241631746292, 0.012000410817563534, 0.06334613263607025, 0.0030350128654390574, 0.01301867701113224, -0.02154693752527237, 0.002873803488910198, 0.004185142461210489, 0.025082621723413467, -0.026645252481102943, 0.015213986858725548, 0.06493909657001495, -0.040798284113407135, 0.06202260032296181, -0.012617192231118679, 0.009946843609213829, -0.05604615807533264, 0.002503438154235482, 0.011847310699522495, -0.03000892698764801, 0.06434763222932816, -0.054849326610565186, 0.006114708725363016, 0.04514866694808006, -0.01576220616698265, 0.04514919966459274, -0.035600289702415466, -0.016016585752367973, -0.014998351223766804, 0.015305669978260994, 0.007514979690313339, 0.04619278386235237, 0.0531856007874012, -0.0030908030457794666, 0.05551309511065483, 0.019491447135806084, 0.010483457706868649, -0.006492545362561941, -0.007310747634619474, 0.027256296947598457, 0.0003672104503493756, -0.05407140403985977, 0.020857280120253563, -0.029285013675689697, -0.03641100972890854, 0.027185536921024323, -0.021072234958410263, 0.004036521073430777, 0.013178856112062931, 0.06570408493280411, -0.015147417783737183, 0.060277268290519714, 0.03604154661297798, -0.010902614332735538, -0.030491359531879425, -0.007367569487541914, 0.017636310309171677, 0.011667060665786266, -0.03274449706077576, 0.023062752559781075, -0.01696797087788582, -0.01573239080607891, -0.009203972294926643, 0.018993865698575974, -0.033417996019124985, -0.0024502547457814217, -0.029472587630152702, -0.020353376865386963, 0.0030271902214735746, -0.012133829295635223, 0.03563845157623291, -0.03191455826163292, 0.025259021669626236, 0.014363306574523449, 0.04547745734453201, -0.03412903472781181, 0.007663121446967125, -0.025481699034571648, -0.06019103527069092, 0.01850389689207077, -0.02001759223639965, -0.005448561627417803, -0.08679977059364319, 0.0015096181305125356, 0.0038227930199354887, -0.014615694060921669, 0.001693636761046946, -0.005219016689807177, -0.024718785658478737, 0.0811135470867157, -0.018433723598718643, -0.006911103148013353, 0.010175318457186222, -0.03011435829102993, 0.024389533326029778, -0.041327595710754395, 0.01856590248644352, -0.013228337280452251, -0.017600998282432556, -0.028363589197397232, 0.01665276661515236, -0.044628240168094635, 0.02578296698629856, 0.016376135870814323, 0.000643273233436048, 0.01933114230632782, -0.02825254201889038, 0.03886829689145088, 0.01706875115633011, -0.08129462599754333, 0.04312269389629364, -0.041483793407678604, -0.05304792523384094, -0.03063387982547283, -0.027907777577638626, 0.04140019416809082, 0.00941090751439333, -0.018301164731383324, -0.043081268668174744, -0.007983504794538021, 0.010880455374717712, -0.038855504244565964, 0.04326055571436882, 0.0010883099166676402, -0.018310407176613808, 0.01870455965399742, -0.007019679993391037, 0.021937189623713493, 0.03276791796088219, 0.014187933877110481, -0.02398395910859108, 0.04316331818699837, -0.03802541270852089, -0.034792304039001465, 0.049081653356552124, 0.02001064643263817, 0.0015104309422895312, -0.08223776519298553, 0.013352830894291401, 0.024452025070786476, -0.03774656355381012, -0.005350964143872261, 0.05706310644745827, 0.01969246193766594, 0.04055051505565643, -0.016478408128023148, 0.023197315633296967, -0.001646913355216384, -0.041157178580760956, -0.002452195854857564, 0.03476449474692345, -0.015311427414417267, -0.014146722853183746, 0.007583381608128548, 0.008646626025438309, -0.028859710320830345, 0.04508742317557335, -0.024869196116924286, 0.007513973396271467, -0.02487419731914997, -0.006102403160184622, 0.012433323077857494, -0.03479965776205063, 0.040934816002845764, 0.011799229308962822, -0.001397254061885178, 0.01786866970360279, -0.06131669506430626, 0.018595248460769653, -0.010129607282578945, -0.04773035645484924, -0.024845248088240623, -0.012084487825632095, 0.0037960102781653404, 0.012277292087674141, 0.006828318815678358, 0.015395427122712135, 0.0002806501288432628, -0.007107395678758621, 0.023639509454369545, -0.01391100324690342, 0.037462588399648666, -0.03186185285449028, -0.014978546649217606, 0.0026882600504904985, 0.012915392406284809, -0.05394767224788666, -0.012777983210980892, -0.023672349750995636, 0.02479889616370201, 0.03196650743484497, -0.01925603486597538, 0.0014121168060228229, 0.013131724670529366, 0.04961705952882767, -0.04859957844018936, -0.016162198036909103, -0.06009940057992935, 0.0008591284858994186, -0.045822303742170334, 0.014100579544901848 ]
<p>One particular assumption is that $e_{i} \sim N(0,\sigma^{2})$ but I was wondering why we use a QQ plot to test this assumption since we have $n$ iid distributions to look at. When we use a QQ plot, aren't we looking for the normality of all the residuals as opposed to one particular $e_{i}$? I am confused about this assumption. Does the QQ plot somehow imply that each $e_{i}$ is normally distributed?</p>
74,317
[ -0.0044182357378304005, 0.011508635245263577, -0.03296821191906929, -0.018102217465639114, 0.03160331770777702, -0.000989019637927413, -0.005146735347807407, -0.004162019118666649, -0.007969694212079048, -0.0661415234208107, 0.026667332276701927, -0.0052238041535019875, 0.06558447331190109, -0.011558497324585915, 0.014337107539176941, 0.025280345231294632, -0.020529137924313545, -0.004483183845877647, 0.0006666648550890386, -0.006641990039497614, -0.01182010117918253, 0.033087003976106644, 0.022413823753595352, -0.02042645402252674, -0.043408602476119995, 0.02378217689692974, 0.014040278270840645, 0.015076887793838978, 0.03980513662099838, 0.0653018206357956, -0.03556106984615326, -0.022884491831064224, 0.014593309722840786, 0.05225689336657524, 0.008704490028321743, 0.010927530005574226, -0.0113060362637043, -0.040149204432964325, 0.018746132031083107, 0.017851855605840683, -0.02543078549206257, 0.002919311635196209, 0.03504602983593941, 0.0331304669380188, -0.011985931545495987, 0.024059908464550972, 0.010862396098673344, -0.04019082337617874, 0.026821348816156387, -0.054591890424489975, 0.05542834848165512, 0.024729730561375618, 0.038802169263362885, 0.043245647102594376, -0.007095702458173037, -0.03209734335541725, 0.03749317675828934, 0.022487260401248932, -0.009405611082911491, -0.07054190337657928, -0.0022690442856401205, -0.022896001115441322, -0.014265540055930614, -0.0005487075541168451, -0.056540727615356445, 0.012643752619624138, 0.04194919392466545, -0.021407034248113632, 0.013875029981136322, -0.004454214591532946, -0.01298364344984293, 0.05309796333312988, 0.02877357229590416, -0.025627637282013893, -0.0065243723802268505, 0.024953670799732208, 0.009782116860151291, -0.01426420547068119, 0.03940366581082344, 0.009704746305942535, 0.01119388360530138, -0.006718696095049381, 0.03136498108506203, 0.03707359358668327, 0.011045527644455433, 0.012438183650374413, 0.06620773673057556, -0.022438256070017815, 0.024134662002325058, 0.01904740184545517, -0.006509618367999792, 0.02983865886926651, 0.04991881176829338, -0.00456616235896945, -0.05503278970718384, 0.007006541360169649, -0.004577039275318384, -0.009061794728040695, 0.03416407108306885, -0.033925026655197144, -0.006837429478764534, -0.04259958863258362, 0.033259253948926926, 0.047900550067424774, -0.002373209921643138, 0.006852613762021065, -0.019783567637205124, 0.01911384053528309, -0.012790575623512268, -0.008111782371997833, -0.03990088775753975, 0.0273171104490757, 0.002120692515745759, 0.027835477143526077, 0.017389003187417984, 0.014666964299976826, -0.015507400967180729, -0.006142457481473684, 0.05661147087812424, 0.06825659424066544, 0.021715715527534485, -0.014751854352653027, -0.006844638381153345, 0.008475770242512226, -0.03543008491396904, 0.054097600281238556, 0.020629676058888435, -0.0011322041973471642, -0.030281661078333855, 0.028216104954481125, -0.01892470009624958, -0.01710418239235878, 0.005358432419598103, 0.013472823426127434, 0.0826687216758728, -0.019416330382227898, -0.09903198480606079, -0.03815199062228203, 0.04729323834180832, -0.05870283395051956, 0.016799869015812874, -0.06796090304851532, -0.011637484654784203, 0.04029706493020058, 0.02943860925734043, -0.02897564321756363, 0.054672639816999435, -0.019572574645280838, 0.0011509975884109735, 0.03412279486656189, -0.018950773403048515, -0.03803121671080589, -0.02535795420408249, -0.033335670828819275, 0.007130088284611702, -0.08329374343156815, 0.03430799022316933, 0.029966073110699654, -0.006841156166046858, -0.017627624794840813, 0.017968472093343735, -0.005133884493261576, 0.024292344227433205, 0.0034909588284790516, 0.028131864964962006, -0.022619808092713356, 0.06789049506187439, -0.002753084758296609, 0.040779195725917816, 0.02513180859386921, -0.03962090238928795, 0.01308564841747284, 0.0279189795255661, 0.08838129788637161, 0.018209757283329964, -0.04375169053673744, 0.025052808225154877, -0.045173387974500656, 0.044735025614500046, 0.0077066561207175255, -0.06337893754243851, -0.011283266358077526, -0.015387607738375664, -0.018983392044901848, -0.0066906469874084, 0.04697536677122116, -0.01764308474957943, -0.029077155515551567, 0.02338353730738163, -0.06714937835931778, -0.04079461097717285, -0.04637530446052551, 0.030816715210676193, -0.00500709842890501, -0.05558357015252113, -0.027527231723070145, 0.016429167240858078, 0.03562796860933304, 0.02891727350652218, -0.0064374227076768875, 0.016766497865319252, 0.008672050200402737, 0.00582349207252264, -0.058328405022621155, 0.010373716242611408, -0.021494442597031593, 0.05741061642765999, 0.03428337723016739, 0.039155710488557816, -0.06485655903816223, -0.06852632015943527, 0.011899632401764393, -0.04884414002299309, 0.019005529582500458, 0.005255599971860647, -0.028592200949788094, -0.008533738553524017, 0.0292202215641737, -0.009319806471467018, 0.023891326040029526, -0.027346281334757805, 0.029284430667757988, 0.05668780580163002, -0.00025598256615921855, -0.04711594060063362, -0.013181835412979126, 0.02124605141580105, -0.007367435842752457, -0.02680704928934574, -0.005179138854146004, -0.03918306529521942, -0.015554985031485558, 0.014066362753510475, 0.05125823989510536, -0.04035283625125885, 0.020430753007531166, 0.05189052224159241, 0.02418772503733635, -0.007498664315789938, 0.014882848598062992, -0.013520266860723495, -0.016137877479195595, 0.009606758132576942, 0.049901578575372696, 0.03087683953344822, -0.006122743245214224, 0.02175893820822239, 0.0007704338640905917, 0.03718269243836403, -0.015356902033090591, -0.007225716020911932, 0.044576410204172134, -0.04722455516457558, 0.013233844190835953, 0.006121956277638674, 0.0001689170894678682, 0.011635258793830872, -0.01710956171154976, 0.02750702202320099, 0.005764045286923647, 0.01937970705330372, -0.013278781436383724, 0.01841822639107704, -0.025035124272108078, 0.05433608964085579, -0.001197313773445785, -0.01713581010699272, -0.006695432122796774, 0.033951014280319214, -0.006730508524924517, 0.005235658958554268, -0.07242706418037415, -0.006845901254564524, -0.01849735900759697, 0.0026315157301723957, 0.03239774331450462, 0.0046620359644293785, 0.01668010838329792, -0.04341372847557068, -0.05473759025335312, 0.015318240039050579, 0.008850788697600365, 0.012156261131167412, 0.0170194823294878, -0.054505351930856705, 0.004269132390618324, -0.04148249328136444, -0.02277545817196369, 0.022699838504195213, -0.05004236474633217, 0.005874099675565958, 0.04262012243270874, -0.021409032866358757, -0.018800176680088043, -0.024323396384716034, -0.04101148992776871, 0.010354106314480305, -0.036824729293584824, -0.05086766183376312, 0.040162988007068634, -0.02232958935201168, -0.021265637129545212, 0.03601374104619026, -0.045312125235795975, -0.02122500166296959, -0.005471026059240103, -0.021379932761192322, 0.027225550264120102, -0.017371704801917076, 0.02632821910083294, 0.02282414585351944, -0.05464892461895943, -0.022708401083946228, -0.04662789776921272, -0.0922762006521225, 0.023974252864718437, -0.014959145337343216, 0.03822864964604378, -0.0001933970779646188, -0.04596250131726265, 0.06051034852862358, 0.020724425092339516, -0.007065644022077322, -0.00817193929105997, -0.009363331831991673, -0.01923980563879013, -0.04269680380821228, 0.01268297340720892, -0.018173344433307648, -0.014943831600248814, 0.0625067800283432, -0.020394153892993927, 0.005095146130770445, 0.03236868232488632, -0.034485455602407455, -0.02795201539993286, 0.01825696974992752, -0.001619288930669427, 0.0036973627284169197, 0.01745476759970188, 0.019765129312872887, -0.026262102648615837, -0.011592191644012928, 0.038661759346723557, 0.039836641401052475, 0.03294242545962334, -0.022688202559947968, 0.048119548708200455, -0.05236980691552162, 0.004804444499313831, -0.03124174103140831, 0.014397768303751945, 0.009545707143843174, -0.013254892081022263, -0.014393729157745838, 0.019797308370471, 0.010242804884910583, -0.03589974343776703, 0.03312796726822853, 0.02491406351327896, 0.02926020883023739, -0.04746120795607567, -0.011123358272016048, -0.014680108055472374, -0.020503627136349678, 0.024596402421593666, -0.028642190620303154, -0.031995970755815506, 0.021848194301128387, 0.0036547966301441193, 0.04347129538655281, -0.023806368932127953, -0.034849684685468674, 0.0016973589081317186, -0.022039050236344337, 0.005798574071377516, -0.0027468923944979906, 0.026433097198605537, -0.007434578146785498, 0.04892006516456604, 0.01991640031337738, 0.02254750393331051, -0.029219232499599457, 0.006829497870057821, -0.06130670756101608, -0.003493333701044321, -0.04990021511912346, -0.011830474250018597, 0.014322520233690739, -0.0252669807523489, 0.03527194261550903, -0.01653207466006279, 0.03970203921198845, -0.004082220606505871, 0.03414319083094597, -0.05096543952822685, -0.04089929163455963, -0.03598978742957115, 0.0072114490903913975, -0.020206591114401817, 0.02223842218518257, -0.023217903450131416, -0.03201473131775856, 0.008177421987056732, 0.025782976299524307, -0.022959671914577484, -0.029141608625650406, -0.0020238428842276335, 0.002520395675674081, 0.007602937985211611, 0.019307918846607208, 0.06020829826593399, 0.013267984613776207, -0.013327041640877724, 0.013041279278695583, 0.013127297163009644, 0.0862601101398468, 0.03727811574935913, -0.007256210781633854, 0.02428121492266655, -0.0289669930934906, -0.02866310253739357, -0.016282279044389725, 0.06362292170524597, 0.010945438407361507, -0.024993157014250755, 0.05109881982207298, 0.019290601834654808, -0.04367491975426674, 0.00037602768861688673, 0.07365049421787262, -0.007169048301875591, -0.007642607670277357, -0.011884087696671486, -0.01749388687312603, -0.0196588933467865, 0.013063361868262291, -0.011964322067797184, 0.011933286674320698, -0.029966315254569054, 0.01996871829032898, 0.0749237984418869, -0.038362350314855576, 0.009047682397067547, 0.001330956700257957, 0.019791308790445328, 0.05621476098895073, 0.02098110318183899, -0.04762755334377289, 0.03088448755443096, 0.01573621667921543, 0.04126381874084473, 0.0387539342045784, -0.02973203733563423, -0.07303155213594437, 0.018092650920152664, 0.05064477398991585, -0.018772084265947342, -0.004184692166745663, 0.004462237004190683, -0.06259161978960037, -0.014214840717613697, 0.0499228835105896, -0.028514057397842407, -0.003544527105987072, -0.0006497601862065494, 0.03910273313522339, -0.03314419090747833, -0.02345932088792324, -0.010206942446529865, 0.00317647703923285, 0.00702133821323514, 0.021887976676225662, -0.014979677274823189, 0.0009725334239192307, -0.04560931771993637, -0.014323687180876732, -0.0061133806593716145, 0.06498933583498001, -0.026255233213305473, 0.008257568813860416, -0.005052737891674042, 0.040911052376031876, -0.01705819182097912, -0.04908742755651474, 0.027120519429445267, -0.026813004165887833, 0.027196450158953667, 0.051875170320272446, -0.008316103368997574, -0.025165973231196404, 0.007045515347272158, 0.03621310368180275, -0.03567999228835106, 0.008400839753448963, -0.01378281693905592, 0.01951853185892105, 0.03072378784418106, 0.02776031382381916, 0.020865285769104958, 0.02038026973605156, 0.00931363832205534, -0.01589077152311802, -0.06422517448663712, 0.046538401395082474, -0.037894755601882935, -0.0405326746404171, -0.01130905095487833, -0.02161865122616291, 0.0027619849424809217, -0.0053233131766319275, -0.0423877127468586, 0.021826280280947685, -0.012517080642282963, -0.054734960198402405, 0.010077044367790222, 0.028526734560728073, 0.024899723008275032, 0.010107811540365219, 0.0019721088465303183, 0.05700306221842766, -0.014049679972231388, -0.011822635307908058, -0.0008560124551877379, 0.0025361014995723963, -0.003720083273947239, 0.026667268946766853, 0.0016230023466050625, 0.02879241667687893, -0.030039899051189423, -0.030849473550915718, 0.015863357111811638, -0.04375108331441879, 0.019447967410087585, -0.006692842114716768, 0.039660822600126266, -0.009740305133163929, -0.04280254244804382, 0.030539561063051224, -0.004035680089145899, -0.0496295727789402, 0.03761788457632065, -0.020026471465826035, 0.04160206392407417, -0.010145473293960094, 0.017939986661076546, -0.07942665368318558, -0.04289368912577629, -0.010416739620268345, -0.0037611874286085367, -0.004589078016579151, -0.021549852564930916, -0.01268662977963686, 0.00441287737339735, -0.02687404677271843, 0.016385750845074654, 0.04806266352534294, -0.0076033733785152435, -0.05186009779572487, -0.004789181984961033, 0.01976889930665493, 0.027528254315257072, -0.00914213340729475, -0.003272671950981021, 0.011794837191700935, -0.04412926360964775, 0.002442209981381893, 0.018482759594917297, 0.044827621430158615, -0.024774642661213875, -0.005274094641208649, -0.05882030725479126, -0.019777260720729828, 0.016547048464417458, -0.0445232093334198, -0.006155914161354303, -0.001989278942346573, -0.013629755936563015, 0.004239490255713463, -0.03241950646042824, -0.0423571914434433, -0.02008204348385334, 0.053197238594293594, 0.011316828429698944, -0.02398882433772087, -0.008861325681209564, -0.026938321068882942, 0.048503924161195755, 0.030073149129748344, -0.0222142543643713, 0.06529799848794937, 0.08794192969799042, 0.007580921053886414, -0.04140681028366089, -0.023065149784088135, -0.002439738716930151, 0.017527136951684952, 0.04813430458307266, -0.010026493109762669, 0.015582784079015255, 0.006466424558311701, 0.002699474338442087, -0.03732738271355629, -0.052253931760787964, 0.025470463559031487, 0.035178255289793015, -0.017397204414010048, 0.039091575890779495, 0.05651721730828285, 0.01939031481742859, -0.0316988080739975, -0.059175826609134674, 0.019755542278289795, 0.005342884920537472, -0.01698284223675728, 0.027671806514263153, -0.0027926061302423477, -0.015303809195756912, -0.004833601880818605, 0.0389714315533638, -0.016286589205265045, 0.024130433797836304, 0.023424405604600906, 0.01662491448223591, 0.01794455386698246, -0.0002678296878002584, -0.05765477195382118, 0.021336674690246582, -0.031811781227588654, 0.04406571388244629, 0.0034244479611516, -0.009728267788887024, 0.013500556349754333, 0.031602803617715836, -0.01281521562486887, -0.04173102229833603, -0.012773813679814339, -0.03588994964957237, 0.038752924650907516, 0.07118866592645645, -0.010494277812540531, 0.011104118078947067, -0.00922697875648737, 0.019473720341920853, -0.01884870044887066, 0.024366378784179688, 0.0076796384528279305, -0.061827924102544785, -0.07178514450788498, -0.0044191209599375725, -0.007981850765645504, 0.0043198587372899055, -0.02670815773308277, -0.030968105420470238, -0.01885354518890381, -0.04141507297754288, 0.040907200425863266, 0.012261202558875084, 0.02989734709262848, 0.010423066094517708, 0.07970412075519562, 0.015597224235534668, 0.01592942699790001, 0.009679156355559826, -0.018053434789180756, 0.12505179643630981, 0.06778797507286072, 0.03250936418771744, -0.05898258835077286, -0.02025739476084709, -0.003919211216270924, 0.008881118148565292, -0.0009556084405630827, 0.02870132029056549, 0.033726755529642105, 0.05577893555164337, 0.03394602984189987, 0.0437963642179966, 0.0021877868566662073, -0.006689941976219416, 0.039947640150785446, -0.04374875873327255, -0.05395510047674179, -0.015129846520721912, 0.029886294156312943, -0.018702378496527672, -0.014076570980250835, -0.0756649374961853, 0.011111179366707802, -0.0078065283596515656, -0.001403425820171833, 0.021593930199742317, -0.002967250067740679, -0.02620283141732216, -0.006675612647086382, -0.028280718252062798, -0.017062049359083176, 0.03136293217539787, -0.003172035329043865, -0.03482786566019058, -0.00936874933540821, -0.0012969383969902992, -0.05234535411000252, 0.029885856434702873, 0.00994070153683424, -0.01082430500537157, -0.031703025102615356, 0.012804852798581123, -0.0060503012500703335, -0.016163241118192673, -0.017881065607070923, -0.026598675176501274, 0.05019974708557129, -0.019293103367090225, -0.011117393150925636, -0.03790061175823212, -0.02416260913014412, 0.008766990154981613, -0.03821070119738579, -0.006437039468437433, -0.009144813753664494, -0.0021421927958726883, -0.010899041779339314, 0.007235676981508732, -0.013501386158168316, 0.0210951529443264, 0.03672303631901741, 0.028266949579119682, 0.016708647832274437, -0.01531100645661354, -0.010586914606392384, -0.023507369682192802, 0.02877250872552395, -0.007941925898194313, 0.00391028868034482, 0.016236884519457817, -0.009093857370316982, -0.040860865265131, -0.01944528892636299, -0.0040282695554196835, 0.008002559654414654, 0.07934246212244034, -0.012650727294385433, 0.00960762519389391, -0.009496078826487064, -0.04896584153175354, 0.01250853855162859, -0.043265219777822495, -0.00673690577968955, -0.047224439680576324, -0.021516861394047737, 0.06442268192768097, 0.04825151711702347, 0.015289943665266037, 0.040192920714616776, 0.018297191709280014, 0.07752248644828796, 0.026447519659996033, -0.0306855458766222, -0.012609793804585934, 0.010563266463577747, -0.009775415994226933, -0.003618884366005659, -0.030835431069135666, 0.024215692654252052, 0.017767315730452538, 0.03983032703399658, -0.00836471188813448, 0.04040860757231712, -0.022201135754585266, 0.018857376649975777, 0.01752339117228985, -0.0767660140991211, 0.029057499021291733, 0.029015032574534416, 0.014257163740694523, -0.04613493010401726, -0.013423515483736992, -0.030835729092359543, -0.044189371168613434, -0.006009732373058796, -0.029258646070957184, -0.035536251962184906, -0.00001436672482668655, 0.006170222535729408, 0.03547043353319168, -0.0422310009598732, -0.005732138175517321, -0.002801756840199232, -0.008589177392423153, 0.015910722315311432, 0.01857997290790081, -0.039737340062856674, -0.03753488510847092, -0.02639474719762802, -0.021554287523031235, 0.027797402814030647, -0.0026377441827207804, 0.003317337715998292, 0.00244341348297894, -0.01602468453347683, 0.003945479169487953, 0.012084254063665867, -0.03415657579898834, 0.004407536704093218, 0.04728158563375473, -0.034072112292051315, -0.030187373980879784, 0.03268757089972496, 0.03967200592160225, 0.00945794116705656, 0.03288514167070389, 0.01272297278046608, -0.06015879660844803, 0.000555767968762666, -0.0402885340154171, 0.012695414945483208, -0.019021257758140564, 0.012502875179052353, -0.004542191978543997, -0.0017184842145070434, -0.00280310888774693, -0.01752326823771, 0.02289564162492752, 0.02811668999493122, 0.07584932446479797, -0.004203401505947113, -0.02299734205007553, 0.04080963879823685, 0.02024323120713234, 0.024928394705057144, 0.05873670056462288, 0.014734907075762749, 0.03399539366364479, 0.0548492968082428, -0.009520298801362514, 0.023848162963986397, -0.036606837064027786, -0.010401316918432713, -0.07179298996925354, -0.012598373927175999, 0.0074891890399158, 0.027060605585575104, 0.043016575276851654, -0.02713335119187832, 0.01901441626250744, 0.036146312952041626, -0.0720171108841896, 0.011559716425836086, -0.018038781359791756, -0.027029048651456833, -0.06607837975025177, 0.03343997895717621, 0.026637572795152664, 0.04247470200061798, 0.04529927298426628, 0.018616411834955215, 0.03902609646320343, 0.0243819672614336, 0.0176059789955616, 0.005689343437552452, 0.01893518678843975, 0.00922978576272726, 0.0203413013368845, -0.0582333542406559, 0.010992836207151413, -0.04789908230304718, -0.030981294810771942, 0.02377229556441307, 0.024599863216280937, 0.0207617599517107, 0.0028564208187162876, 0.018369607627391815, -0.0009829209884628654, 0.02091877907514572, 0.03155168145895004, -0.004346185829490423, 0.0005187023198232055, -0.0043437061831355095, 0.057713937014341354, 0.0023107598535716534, 0.004967095330357552, -0.004698854871094227, 0.03546455502510071, -0.03750909864902496, -0.03622160851955414, 0.0278929453343153, 0.025753885507583618, -0.03524786978960037, 0.0004193984204903245, -0.00308241811580956, 0.009463225491344929, -0.02939360775053501, 0.04773639142513275, -0.0542985163629055, 0.02763696201145649, 0.02384968288242817, 0.06232064589858055, 0.0050331163220107555, -0.0033337261993438005, -0.001163948210887611, -0.08255675435066223, 0.014942765235900879, 0.014341587200760841, -0.028049737215042114, -0.07050921767950058, -0.015419689007103443, -0.03115970268845558, 0.005526201333850622, -0.013565125875175, -0.012361869215965271, -0.02468927577137947, 0.0005575661780312657, 0.0057117389515042305, 0.01858215406537056, 0.022359438240528107, -0.058805424720048904, -0.015603836625814438, -0.052918072789907455, 0.08401738107204437, 0.00670917984098196, -0.020318221300840378, -0.011183026246726513, 0.024089980870485306, -0.07686974108219147, 0.0014977784594520926, 0.03244585543870926, 0.02468658797442913, -0.013074779883027077, 0.012096049264073372, 0.02850406803190708, 0.014081669971346855, -0.03326018527150154, 0.04009993001818657, -0.00972171314060688, -0.0313919261097908, -0.05122784897685051, 0.03500049561262131, 0.035456858575344086, 0.007187705487012863, 0.000050075108447344974, 0.0048112524673342705, 0.021333031356334686, -0.0011343011865392327, -0.017734713852405548, 0.020999353379011154, -0.012951303273439407, -0.009269610047340393, 0.049710962921381, -0.02723492868244648, 0.007155961822718382, 0.03080584853887558, -0.015798216685652733, -0.04604696109890938, 0.05722631886601448, 0.035503000020980835, -0.013090944848954678, -0.019163351505994797, 0.01869061589241028, 0.0019281910499557853, -0.0749112144112587, 0.00041999053792096674, -0.002456898568198085, -0.010495767928659916, -0.017428478226065636, 0.03621887043118477, 0.0619075670838356, 0.026295632123947144, -0.006716553587466478, -0.006056415382772684, 0.023406822234392166, -0.005430450662970543, 0.05257943272590637, 0.029474899172782898, 0.014912363141775131, 0.009605794213712215, 0.005366455297917128, 0.03550979867577553, -0.03692626953125, 0.02562994882464409, -0.0233494583517313, 0.03869837895035744, -0.01924533024430275, -0.008670228533446789, 0.018529744818806648, 0.007240537088364363, 0.024331385269761086, 0.011257950216531754, 0.009096464142203331, 0.07290755957365036, -0.04792053997516632, 0.013285540044307709, -0.014412003569304943, -0.04225841164588928, -0.004501265939325094, -0.015624625608325005, 0.0005166633636690676, 0.018717961385846138, -0.0117107592523098, 0.013595742173492908, 0.0018243505619466305, 0.001508440007455647, 0.013109814375638962, -0.026537472382187843, 0.03875629976391792, 0.007668494712561369, 0.00794945191591978, -0.035397518426179886, 0.0018459151033312082, -0.017089080065488815, -0.036253422498703, 0.006370102521032095, 0.05333886295557022, 0.0021561826579272747, -0.028464842587709427, -0.04318828508257866, -0.007562223356217146, 0.037985660135746, -0.028764283284544945, -0.00885809026658535, -0.027935346588492393, 0.006870886776596308, 0.038585975766181946, -0.02442840300500393 ]
<p>Reposted from Math.SE:</p> <p>Continuing from <a href="https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/593512/what-is-a-function-satisfying-these-constraints">this question</a>. Given two random variables $X$ and $Y$ where $X \sim \operatorname{Beta}(a, b)$ and $Y \sim \operatorname{Beta}(c, d)$, I'm looking for a random variable $Z$ with a distribution supported on $[0, 1]$ that satisfies the following constraints:</p> <ol> <li>The pdf of $Z$ has reflection symmetry: $f(x;a, b, c, d)=f(1-x;d, c, b, a)$</li> <li>If $\mathrm{E}[X] &gt; \frac{1}{2}$, then $\mathrm{E}[Z] &gt; \mathrm{E}[Y]$</li> <li>If $\mathrm{E}[X] = \frac{1}{2}$, then $\mathrm{E}[Z] = \mathrm{E}[Y]$</li> <li>If $\mathrm{E}[X] &lt; \frac{1}{2}$, then $\mathrm{E}[Z] &lt; \mathrm{E}[Y]$</li> <li>Increasing the expectation of $X$ or $Y$ must never decrease the expectation of $Z$.</li> </ol> <p>Is an answer to this question even possible? The answer to my first question does not seem to solve the problem (the expectations are OK, but the support constraint is violated).</p>
74,318
[ -0.02598574385046959, -0.03295914828777313, 0.03821270912885666, -0.019413815811276436, 0.009303265251219273, 0.014658885076642036, -0.014418026432394981, -0.005648833233863115, 0.007175522856414318, -0.05482456088066101, 0.042616862803697586, 0.037822235375642776, 0.07019206136465073, 0.017598478123545647, 0.0046697212383151054, 0.010651219636201859, -0.009066306054592133, -0.023096207529306412, -0.06378965079784393, -0.013136118650436401, -0.024122992530465126, 0.057587720453739166, 0.038500040769577026, -0.0042187185026705265, -0.008385533466935158, 0.024822523817420006, 0.032898757606744766, 0.0022931306157261133, 0.001823906321078539, 0.08981114625930786, -0.053626649081707, -0.021975165233016014, 0.002955729141831398, 0.04236684367060661, -0.0058240629732608795, 0.0029157858807593584, -0.023795435205101967, -0.04667598009109497, -0.01807399094104767, 0.02029382809996605, -0.015011373907327652, 0.013916577212512493, -0.033767588436603546, 0.028146401047706604, 0.006818421185016632, 0.016072452068328857, -0.007116463966667652, -0.015028277412056923, 0.06576906144618988, -0.02506021410226822, 0.0864439457654953, -0.0017595031531527638, 0.014044197276234627, 0.025737741962075233, 0.01591789349913597, -0.07817897200584412, 0.046737879514694214, 0.07252378761768341, 0.03382126986980438, -0.003652824554592371, -0.04400964826345444, -0.03198890760540962, 0.026092199608683586, 0.002031209645792842, -0.04375551640987396, 0.0038208840414881706, 0.037662483751773834, -0.01394573599100113, 0.002624769462272525, 0.0045708524994552135, 0.018171636387705803, 0.04269351065158844, 0.014655161648988724, -0.0038425198290497065, 0.008034068159759045, -0.015916498377919197, 0.02843584679067135, 0.04475443810224533, 0.047460585832595825, 0.016865650191903114, 0.029860636219382286, -0.001212341827340424, 0.014242155477404594, 0.022625550627708435, 0.012797857634723186, -0.008060299791395664, 0.10300425440073013, 0.0019392194226384163, -0.02627033181488514, -0.0005590673536062241, -0.0015212036669254303, -0.040185656398534775, 0.06818666309118271, -0.03375040739774704, -0.06161072850227356, 0.004531070590019226, -0.018401067703962326, 0.039051007479429245, -0.004000286106020212, -0.051172349601984024, -0.03179682791233063, -0.05681132897734642, 0.02119440957903862, 0.03234179690480232, -0.003590905573219061, 0.020100317895412445, -0.031824931502342224, 0.02069680392742157, -0.030082542449235916, 0.0005080000264570117, -0.0014506032457575202, 0.05151643604040146, -0.027238095179200172, 0.012532073073089123, 0.023771561682224274, 0.024552635848522186, 0.0039843604899942875, -0.013063088059425354, 0.0460878349840641, 0.05004230886697769, 0.060247790068387985, 0.02528764307498932, 0.011501151137053967, -0.027044452726840973, -0.06491217762231827, 0.00942812766879797, 0.03177691996097565, 0.018347660079598427, -0.07047725468873978, 0.025147709995508194, 0.021014858037233353, -0.01574750244617462, -0.014123214408755302, 0.00876116193830967, 0.025777066126465797, 0.011299381963908672, -0.03541884571313858, -0.02983221970498562, 0.027047690004110336, 0.003821736667305231, 0.003733377903699875, -0.0739259421825409, -0.024303482845425606, 0.040698468685150146, 0.059236910194158554, -0.00852071400731802, 0.07171599566936493, 0.0021019570995122194, 0.05340360477566719, 0.012434831820428371, -0.03323987126350403, -0.030512699857354164, -0.030641498044133186, -0.024946777150034904, -0.009486844763159752, -0.03157943859696388, 0.04232608154416084, 0.0076098148711025715, -0.02935059182345867, -0.02241547405719757, 0.04942604526877403, -0.03264409303665161, -0.03496451675891876, -0.03868082910776138, 0.01712031289935112, -0.016123492270708084, 0.06504224985837936, 0.021878959611058235, 0.02631506696343422, 0.006597350351512432, -0.02992646023631096, 0.012350528500974178, -0.02401749975979328, 0.02957603894174099, 0.07152779400348663, -0.0578976571559906, -0.028009528294205666, -0.030961770564317703, 0.03162839636206627, 0.0231404360383749, -0.0016780523583292961, 0.006409325171262026, -0.04719868674874306, -0.0008787325350567698, -0.0249312911182642, 0.0184050090610981, 0.018664762377738953, -0.015940262004733086, -0.006402306724339724, -0.011717789806425571, -0.04134276136755943, -0.035314690321683884, 0.009034811519086361, 0.016021985560655594, -0.028323955833911896, 0.0193917416036129, 0.007174810394644737, -0.0026020228397101164, -0.028730712831020355, -0.02607043832540512, 0.013731959275901318, -0.005180459935218096, 0.06888256222009659, -0.010275253094732761, -0.00914046261459589, 0.052311718463897705, 0.061194244772195816, -0.006598036270588636, 0.030632315203547478, -0.020762434229254723, -0.029357152059674263, -0.02007097564637661, -0.019085301086306572, 0.026589293032884598, 0.0035528463777154684, 0.009028701111674309, 0.008319304324686527, -0.0017899303929880261, -0.012644924223423004, 0.013542793691158295, -0.040573980659246445, 0.02000729739665985, 0.04663032665848732, -0.0026495528873056173, -0.004493763204663992, 0.04253886640071869, 0.026867354288697243, 0.02232859842479229, -0.03819718584418297, -0.04304876551032066, -0.03951311111450195, -0.0256345272064209, 0.05313453450798988, 0.018753256648778915, -0.051995985209941864, 0.03896464407444, 0.03664179518818855, -0.0004922662628814578, -0.0005201121675781906, 0.020322339609265327, -0.008409352973103523, -0.030473612248897552, 0.03276422619819641, 0.007364118006080389, 0.07023491710424423, 0.0052039120346307755, -0.0018926990451291203, -0.02221125364303589, 0.005566842388361692, -0.008899502456188202, -0.012491277419030666, 0.0060088979080319405, 0.008509989827871323, -0.004612924065440893, -0.015622198581695557, -0.0015259552747011185, 0.026989245787262917, -0.014355375431478024, 0.009175465442240238, 0.03330007195472717, 0.007805320899933577, -0.006201858166605234, -0.0013603836996480823, -0.012346740812063217, 0.02428705431520939, 0.04314032942056656, -0.014061475172638893, -0.030201660469174385, 0.028584735468029976, 0.026704812422394753, 0.013729788362979889, -0.0013158564688637853, -0.06441859155893326, 0.019661540165543556, -0.02436310239136219, 0.001766123459674418, 0.008445249870419502, 0.029094181954860687, -0.05652444809675217, -0.020800892263650894, -0.005748957395553589, -0.0003781266859732568, 0.03155363351106644, -0.004220303148031235, -0.03695954009890556, -0.023365510627627373, -0.04084017500281334, -0.010987293906509876, 0.0219569131731987, 0.022948794066905975, 0.0014418988721445203, 0.003624137258157134, 0.009621155448257923, -0.06832868605852127, -0.013105432502925396, -0.03712818771600723, 0.010316255502402782, -0.06349585205316544, -0.042279813438653946, 0.04379533231258392, 0.004420294426381588, -0.04716109111905098, 0.040336158126592636, 0.003998886328190565, -0.048552513122558594, -0.050673600286245346, -0.003828264307230711, 0.023070750758051872, -0.013702204450964928, 0.052597664296627045, 0.013037965632975101, -0.003029926447197795, 0.026548776775598526, -0.05943787097930908, -0.05182883143424988, 0.012915483675897121, -0.019202958792448044, 0.0337546207010746, 0.01739470101892948, -0.04782560095191002, 0.05881012603640556, 0.040247593075037, -0.002105967840179801, -0.0016769421054050326, -0.019621467217803, 0.008156562224030495, -0.058034323155879974, -0.012820855714380741, 0.0403735414147377, -0.013695180416107178, 0.06849849969148636, 0.026533616706728935, -0.007597852498292923, -0.006964594125747681, -0.009784088470041752, -0.02206304669380188, 0.01215821597725153, 0.03312765434384346, 0.018369294703006744, 0.03226086124777794, 0.03166447579860687, 0.008399096317589283, -0.00978782493621111, 0.022023234516382217, 0.013126587495207787, 0.006209438666701317, -0.04136257991194725, 0.03114386461675167, -0.016813037917017937, 0.022099019959568977, -0.02193664014339447, 0.04903923720121384, 0.03067726455628872, -0.09617362916469574, 0.009954710491001606, 0.010148475877940655, 0.0578838549554348, -0.015235553495585918, 0.023624027147889137, 0.04964680224657059, 0.028983283787965775, -0.034694887697696686, -0.007286814972758293, -0.012086275033652782, -0.011150780133903027, 0.003948085475713015, -0.022697564214468002, -0.04575249180197716, 0.035433873534202576, 0.044584255665540695, 0.015064314007759094, -0.0031028217636048794, -0.0629177913069725, 0.004227909725159407, -0.05184662342071533, 0.04044872894883156, -0.03298896551132202, 0.01749490015208721, 0.0153434369713068, 0.04512133076786995, 0.036437246948480606, 0.007955540902912617, 0.011293875984847546, 0.01600942388176918, -0.0880146324634552, 0.014376090839505196, -0.033128224313259125, 0.05148760601878166, -0.06944561749696732, 0.005290170665830374, 0.06788056343793869, 0.0040024034678936005, 0.0037903222255408764, -0.03617933392524719, 0.031346824020147324, -0.018365398049354553, -0.0202581025660038, -0.06410568207502365, -0.06974528729915619, 0.007401175796985626, 0.014756516553461552, 0.010489791631698608, -0.058765705674886703, 0.05000913888216019, 0.03643782436847687, -0.03382115811109543, 0.0033254402223974466, -0.01993434689939022, 0.04538217559456825, -0.026465989649295807, 0.037632741034030914, -0.011274408549070358, 0.001290968619287014, 0.05419189855456352, 0.001898798975162208, 0.0023671865928918123, 0.050561919808387756, 0.038380514830350876, -0.009931309148669243, -0.021492358297109604, -0.029455427080392838, -0.029637392610311508, 0.0034356149844825268, 0.02720894291996956, -0.015100553631782532, 0.006639031693339348, 0.05434703826904297, 0.008627692237496376, -0.035085346549749374, 0.027747241780161858, 0.06343868374824524, 0.026724064722657204, 0.000008991205504571553, -0.008447683416306973, -0.012980039231479168, -0.02609957754611969, 0.0018222418148070574, 0.02061246894299984, -0.015429156832396984, -0.018599409610033035, 0.0007425419171340764, 0.02766595222055912, -0.010062426328659058, -0.008583780378103256, 0.01712452434003353, 0.026792971417307854, 0.03404233232140541, 0.023498792201280594, -0.039681028574705124, 0.0211107786744833, 0.009295467287302017, 0.0360005646944046, 0.034080829471349716, -0.017412830144166946, -0.031200896948575974, 0.03361090272665024, 0.04676800221204758, 0.05306164175271988, -0.019054831936955452, -0.006405646447092295, -0.048878010362386703, -0.020697806030511856, 0.01478886604309082, -0.0402376763522625, -0.01765010692179203, -0.04658491536974907, -0.01114744134247303, 0.005360987037420273, -0.05086865648627281, -0.05645976588129997, -0.008755656890571117, 0.020467964932322502, 0.0226571187376976, -0.020738642662763596, -0.047510478645563126, -0.01696653664112091, -0.004632371477782726, 0.03812532499432564, 0.05804597586393356, -0.0170472152531147, 0.004959094803780317, -0.009053987450897694, 0.027382342144846916, -0.013001642189919949, -0.1091124415397644, -0.011431203223764896, -0.0021848934702575207, 0.006537757348269224, 0.029461197555065155, -0.05085790157318115, -0.06285850703716278, 0.03988761454820633, -0.01935953088104725, -0.0057558827102184296, 0.0440724678337574, 0.02016613632440567, 0.057749416679143906, 0.05896103382110596, 0.05841219425201416, 0.04681505262851715, 0.049569886177778244, 0.023598989471793175, -0.0015825710725039244, -0.00447889044880867, -0.027680538594722748, -0.044511206448078156, -0.003475326346233487, -0.04227123409509659, -0.02735191583633423, -0.04941633343696594, 0.040405627340078354, 0.004143800586462021, -0.028925379738211632, -0.02095334418118, -0.040644094347953796, -0.0028070281259715557, 0.020856449380517006, -0.03806107118725777, -0.015448077581822872, -0.028051743283867836, 0.03279918059706688, -0.004613617435097694, 0.00030118587892502546, 0.006688401103019714, 0.0012432790827006102, -0.01670125313103199, 0.0009252140880562365, -0.030382392928004265, 0.010299489833414555, -0.05660167336463928, -0.010497640818357468, -0.00794210284948349, -0.018378419801592827, 0.05842443183064461, -0.005579711403697729, 0.03560781851410866, 0.0033586935605853796, 0.00031807823688723147, 0.010922511108219624, 0.030289335176348686, -0.01390276663005352, 0.010128309018909931, -0.04389863461256027, 0.030113063752651215, 0.0002679201425053179, -0.008052846416831017, -0.053917545825242996, -0.012522446922957897, 0.004744681064039469, 0.011748016811907291, -0.007653268054127693, -0.06746406108140945, -0.04570057615637779, -0.024117549881339073, -0.030005117878317833, -0.016683129593729973, 0.014825566671788692, 0.004754688125103712, -0.0013577030040323734, 0.028912236914038658, 0.03136291727423668, 0.051341086626052856, -0.0427963063120842, 0.026118943467736244, 0.033743966370821, -0.02268546260893345, 0.0021898543927818537, 0.00543095963075757, 0.020921854302287102, -0.025035656988620758, 0.004044527653604746, -0.010452157817780972, -0.0035885635297745466, 0.02776312455534935, -0.03692549094557762, -0.011877356097102165, 0.03441016376018524, -0.010130125097930431, -0.01096474751830101, -0.004463680554181337, -0.01802881620824337, -0.02117137238383293, 0.01940222643315792, -0.007846212014555931, -0.006567095872014761, -0.019017543643712997, -0.01038507279008627, 0.024531947448849678, 0.00039901980198919773, -0.000886923517100513, -0.008804266341030598, 0.10088802129030228, 0.015997255221009254, 0.004371597897261381, -0.01291736215353012, -0.0025150938890874386, 0.03550852835178375, -0.027065489441156387, -0.019240355119109154, 0.023632286116480827, 0.011069368571043015, -0.03575926274061203, -0.056715190410614014, -0.027246776968240738, 0.02744830958545208, 0.03193964436650276, 0.018712898716330528, 0.038272298872470856, 0.029750965535640717, -0.018848780542612076, -0.009039312601089478, -0.029506241902709007, 0.001101576373912394, -0.008072094060480595, 0.00200106599368155, 0.041796937584877014, -0.024442529305815697, 0.03007594682276249, 0.022727012634277344, -0.0016622324474155903, 0.027983708307147026, 0.011352150700986385, 0.018198778852820396, 0.024425845593214035, 0.046383343636989594, -0.05205690115690231, -0.04426794499158859, 0.018524086102843285, -0.0403466522693634, -0.009914068505167961, -0.024146948009729385, -0.011355607770383358, 0.02697867341339588, 0.051193904131650925, 0.010885068215429783, -0.025854477658867836, -0.026140054687857628, -0.08183738589286804, -0.003333661239594221, -0.003671934362500906, 0.009793821722269058, 0.04203059524297714, -0.05485495924949646, 0.012043650262057781, -0.0066922674886882305, 0.01265767216682434, -0.030126716941595078, -0.0783129408955574, -0.03897865116596222, -0.031630709767341614, -0.028365792706608772, 0.0002807824348565191, 0.03871858865022659, -0.008226829580962658, 0.03541744500398636, -0.061985041946172714, 0.00786655955016613, 0.01674731820821762, 0.01937912218272686, -0.01264625508338213, 0.03787823021411896, 0.02946643903851509, 0.03264852985739708, -0.01993601955473423, 0.0071083917282521725, 0.13334651291370392, 0.05191727355122566, 0.05080394819378853, -0.05642223358154297, 0.02571774832904339, -0.0509413406252861, -0.017920704558491707, -0.020530851557850838, 0.018690334632992744, 0.02363920398056507, 0.020713742822408676, 0.004078843165189028, 0.07677912712097168, 0.02510208822786808, -0.0030441388953477144, 0.04377315193414688, -0.047969602048397064, 0.012815635651350021, 0.03186184912919998, 0.025600723922252655, -0.03140241652727127, -0.005991492420434952, -0.05582476779818535, -0.0355958454310894, -0.03570551425218582, -0.02325552888214588, -0.025540588423609734, -0.046828821301460266, -0.012063194997608662, -0.013025649823248386, 0.021967003121972084, -0.00596870481967926, 0.024622175842523575, -0.01699373871088028, -0.006102016195654869, 0.0071060555055737495, 0.012289206497371197, -0.034085795283317566, 0.006716907024383545, 0.0258245300501585, -0.010155604220926762, 0.04286729544401169, 0.02811276540160179, -0.01810980960726738, -0.024227838963270187, -0.02809487283229828, -0.022924460470676422, 0.03936399519443512, -0.022106627002358437, 0.008801545016467571, 0.026785435155034065, -0.0660993829369545, -0.007463433779776096, -0.028170917183160782, 0.008887593634426594, -0.014169400557875633, 0.0031342634465545416, 0.0036126335617154837, -0.008540906012058258, -0.030126968398690224, 0.035082049667835236, -0.0008835057378746569, 0.027088569477200508, 0.029967041686177254, -0.05848374962806702, 0.0039670723490417, 0.0038524155970662832, 0.07726385444402695, 0.013932700268924236, -0.011162729933857918, -0.009336300194263458, -0.03188282623887062, -0.02887808345258236, -0.016408173367381096, -0.009540827013552189, -0.05398612841963768, 0.020538438111543655, 0.0028875640127807856, 0.010654181241989136, -0.015420029871165752, -0.03316401690244675, 0.0016154659679159522, -0.0495920293033123, -0.0008482402190566063, -0.03330151364207268, 0.00029469517176039517, 0.005832562688738108, 0.021659892052412033, -0.0017278649611398578, -0.010971185751259327, -0.0027383395936340094, 0.033658578991889954, -0.00914001651108265, -0.0393998809158802, -0.021132873371243477, 0.008954815566539764, -0.028702322393655777, -0.006334472913295031, -0.008083461783826351, 0.05996960029006004, -0.001355114160105586, 0.024703821167349815, -0.01582764834165573, -0.008631394244730473, -0.06183146685361862, 0.01082620769739151, -0.006759344134479761, -0.06023982912302017, 0.002139677992090583, 0.0338890366256237, 0.026793451979756355, -0.03674119710922241, -0.014784620143473148, -0.015817437320947647, 0.010132115334272385, 0.04248707741498947, -0.003055770182982087, -0.05267997458577156, -0.0213710255920887, -0.028127675876021385, 0.004374267533421516, -0.0010856190929189324, 0.00015227141557261348, 0.004400028381496668, 0.018906021490693092, 0.005268091335892677, 0.017195219174027443, 0.00647684745490551, -0.0004331265517976135, -0.0092533053830266, -0.011950654909014702, 0.033106982707977295, 0.02942097932100296, 0.02104717679321766, 0.009922115132212639, 0.027867969125509262, 0.016005197539925575, 0.017560487613081932, -0.04918767884373665, -0.010820328257977962, 0.033232178539037704, -0.0327591709792614, -0.008000737987458706, 0.01942349411547184, 0.006359077524393797, 0.03879405930638313, 0.008297008462250233, -0.005330588202923536, -0.02394014596939087, 0.026834694668650627, -0.005552907008677721, 0.01309107057750225, 0.002541802590712905, -0.0008972252835519612, 0.006787464022636414, -0.02289949171245098, 0.018956182524561882, 0.007310587912797928, -0.022942883893847466, 0.022048546001315117, 0.013228540308773518, -0.029445238411426544, -0.003831945825368166, 0.028345156461000443, 0.03523840382695198, 0.025268448516726494, -0.0019418229348957539, 0.007935045287013054, 0.037406016141176224, 0.07216469943523407, -0.027301855385303497, 0.040801335126161575, 0.0019926077220588923, 0.0006944932974874973, -0.07581925392150879, 0.009075039066374302, 0.019863827154040337, 0.00788953248411417, 0.045558951795101166, -0.0660509541630745, 0.010771640576422215, 0.0049072690308094025, -0.05146154388785362, 0.025296475738286972, -0.016636725515127182, 0.012234550900757313, -0.03838861733675003, 0.017078837379813194, -0.02732812613248825, 0.020442873239517212, 0.0035643172450363636, 0.05713836848735809, 0.017743948847055435, 0.043729305267333984, -0.004942052997648716, -0.03149079158902168, -0.006840023212134838, 0.008742929436266422, -0.04055247828364372, -0.02837502397596836, 0.07112263888120651, -0.035855982452631, -0.041041094809770584, 0.023157251998782158, 0.009928155690431595, -0.017025666311383247, -0.014348851516842842, -0.007859010249376297, 0.023654766380786896, 0.049201227724552155, 0.012049093842506409, 0.021489279344677925, -0.031452346593141556, -0.02610861510038376, 0.011697039008140564, 0.012158356606960297, 0.006599627435207367, 0.00520408246666193, 0.0033813633490353823, -0.006694710347801447, 0.0017682317411527038, 0.03492641821503639, -0.02942551299929619, -0.027330001816153526, 0.016997352242469788, -0.011355831287801266, 0.035517387092113495, -0.011523985303938389, 0.04679981619119644, -0.020556006580591202, -0.009533214382827282, 0.0272609144449234, 0.02379886992275715, 0.011719414964318275, 0.01472354494035244, 0.010904124937951565, -0.043447189033031464, 0.03254694119095802, 0.002468360820785165, -0.016086233779788017, -0.05126432329416275, 0.042499616742134094, -0.003198003163561225, 0.002072976902127266, 0.03747780993580818, -0.03000957891345024, -0.06209177523851395, 0.001419305452145636, -0.002678246470168233, 0.017889969050884247, 0.004630833398550749, -0.008263470605015755, 0.003413090016692877, -0.09445255994796753, 0.06286782026290894, -0.012090764939785004, 0.020249536260962486, -0.026928987354040146, 0.008644629269838333, -0.014148663729429245, -0.03441932797431946, 0.06341441720724106, 0.022307977080345154, 0.003935619257390499, 0.024295881390571594, 0.0387563519179821, 0.019306134432554245, -0.03480776026844978, 0.030445169657468796, -0.01874517649412155, 0.0005888444138690829, 0.013025888241827488, 0.008625471033155918, -0.0040932632982730865, 0.013148564845323563, 0.029944585636258125, -0.02490970492362976, 0.01258120872080326, 0.01753130741417408, -0.0022134382743388414, 0.03563535213470459, -0.005841266363859177, 0.007752531673759222, 0.05060785636305809, 0.023357819765806198, -0.009407349862158298, -0.054749540984630585, -0.005362784489989281, -0.029212461784482002, 0.07111753523349762, -0.06300802528858185, -0.07982045412063599, -0.03276921063661575, 0.009043997153639793, 0.03512154519557953, -0.04078591987490654, -0.02081962302327156, 0.03426890820264816, -0.023928090929985046, -0.019041666761040688, 0.036341700702905655, 0.02791300229728222, 0.06328610330820084, -0.028924155980348587, 0.008744953200221062, 0.012196910567581654, -0.016101326793432236, 0.02124244160950184, -0.01954694837331772, 0.021802976727485657, -0.05094989761710167, 0.016216160729527473, 0.022513139992952347, -0.024446118623018265, 0.02977473847568035, 0.019549120217561722, 0.01760796830058098, -0.005961383227258921, -0.043122630566358566, 0.025117037817835808, 0.028241261839866638, -0.006508162245154381, -0.02492130920290947, -0.0012957147555425763, 0.054976414889097214, -0.0034800057765096426, 0.0351509228348732, -0.0308308694511652, -0.02111933007836342, -0.020407965406775475, 0.007347294595092535, -0.004933774936944246, -0.018838655203580856, 0.012554295361042023, -0.010996730998158455, -0.016731666401028633, 0.009285922162234783, 0.006921811494976282, -0.016267165541648865, 0.019589876756072044, -0.013064601458609104, -0.01717934012413025, 0.0070657674223184586, -0.03278772160410881, 0.014394858852028847, -0.007453433703631163, -0.00035941851092502475, 0.05744012072682381, 0.020356088876724243, -0.012592584826052189, -0.01212718803435564, -0.02771376445889473, 0.06844668090343475, -0.05607031285762787, -0.02017957903444767, -0.04539352282881737, -0.011802391149103642, 0.02387283928692341, -0.016333788633346558 ]
<p>Here is the data I have:</p> <ul> <li>Response variable : It contains proportions and it takes discrete values 0, 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1. But there are 109 possible discrete values</li> <li>Predictor variable.1: Discrete and ordinal. It contains these values 10, 20, 30, 40.</li> <li>Predictor variable.2: Discrete and non-ordinal. It contains these values 'a', 'b', 'c'.</li> </ul> <p>Neither normality (checked with Kolmogorov-Smirnov and by looking at a qqplot) nor homoscedasticity (checked with Fligner and by looking at a plot) are respected.</p> <p>Which model should I use in order to infer whether any of the two predictor variable influence my response variable?</p> <p>What about a logistic regression? Would it work?</p>
74,319
[ -0.03460318595170975, -0.0331074558198452, 0.016438044607639313, 0.010100613348186016, 0.0528128556907177, 0.0029048786964267492, -0.015412884764373302, -0.014579719863831997, 0.02432073839008808, -0.031929176300764084, 0.02880520559847355, -0.021627718582749367, 0.04212794452905655, 0.012178639881312847, 0.003050911473110318, 0.017948592081665993, 0.011808382347226143, 0.0017051704926416278, 0.002631771145388484, -0.00023868028074502945, -0.01568782702088356, -0.00027409696485847235, 0.01532774232327938, -0.00034749426413327456, -0.021262573078274727, 0.04528063163161278, 0.07138577103614807, -0.004188903607428074, 0.021189866587519646, 0.006512089632451534, -0.005904411897063255, -0.05813054367899895, 0.016489403322339058, 0.06589685380458832, 0.02348315715789795, 0.018181586638092995, -0.01403606403619051, 0.007047641556710005, 0.006436879280954599, 0.007230260409414768, -0.029360849410295486, -0.015605519525706768, 0.02228861302137375, 0.019001061096787453, -0.0022469719406217337, 0.01742466725409031, 0.0017320796614512801, -0.03288058191537857, 0.0561760738492012, -0.06260661035776138, 0.08817426860332489, -0.007050891872495413, 0.042485736310482025, 0.03694853559136391, -0.021108122542500496, -0.03768983110785484, 0.053119778633117676, 0.09321881830692291, -0.02712520956993103, -0.07606083154678345, -0.01824931800365448, 0.0036330551374703646, -0.02795063517987728, -0.00785784237086773, -0.052318260073661804, 0.0209189485758543, 0.0065354215912520885, -0.029282182455062866, 0.031435634940862656, -0.0024915614631026983, -0.0013758721761405468, -0.0033869356848299503, 0.058058056980371475, 0.004473903216421604, 0.03185563161969185, -0.027298547327518463, -0.011612036265432835, 0.006739360745996237, 0.03944559767842293, 0.04380670189857483, -0.005117250140756369, -0.017055077478289604, -0.02123861387372017, 0.04073326289653778, 0.02886895090341568, -0.03542359918355942, 0.014087836258113384, 0.004744448233395815, 0.008039778098464012, 0.016628315672278404, -0.054134584963321686, -0.011033832095563412, 0.0378413051366806, 0.009579128585755825, -0.040705107152462006, 0.02432951331138611, -0.003430177690461278, 0.011229930445551872, -0.008009606041014194, 0.0007195164798758924, -0.03047160618007183, -0.04533519968390465, 0.04067867249250412, 0.08349188417196274, -0.03011411987245083, -0.009435840882360935, -0.0370149128139019, -0.02466481365263462, 0.009219042025506496, -0.025021132081747055, 0.008292348124086857, 0.05256480351090431, 0.008059936575591564, 0.0311763733625412, -0.022163057699799538, -0.035955797880887985, -0.04306744411587715, -0.05538303777575493, 0.04959908872842789, 0.05851012468338013, 0.023145651444792747, -0.04332009702920914, 0.01845322549343109, -0.018646785989403725, -0.023787034675478935, -0.018739936873316765, 0.01920827105641365, 0.020322971045970917, 0.007549939677119255, 0.06436464190483093, -0.02148096077144146, -0.0013299713609740138, 0.011657610535621643, 0.01729743741452694, 0.01784844510257244, 0.005903465673327446, -0.10068879276514053, -0.032216958701610565, 0.01561605092138052, -0.010195674374699593, 0.01681036688387394, -0.05575161427259445, -0.015300724655389786, 0.05094414949417114, 0.038410212844610214, 0.012161300517618656, 0.04770192131400108, 0.023163732141256332, 0.02968287467956543, 0.01823926717042923, -0.0016283561708405614, 0.003161284141242504, -0.03487586975097656, -0.04266124963760376, -0.017442315816879272, -0.05174043029546738, 0.006469076499342918, 0.016132701188325882, 0.016706842929124832, 0.01718772202730179, 0.009782744571566582, -0.010563707910478115, -0.024404393509030342, 0.011611046269536018, 0.028935808688402176, -0.0041778418235480785, 0.06680143624544144, -0.014266748912632465, 0.028364386409521103, 0.014930867590010166, -0.004793438129127026, 0.00640229694545269, 0.006408728659152985, 0.059829920530319214, 0.032698020339012146, -0.0016611680621281266, 0.009714530780911446, -0.07520033419132233, 0.02730480022728443, 0.01038455218076706, -0.04681394249200821, -0.020675191655755043, -0.036491937935352325, -0.018812241032719612, -0.0007225503213703632, 0.025306478142738342, 0.006877429783344269, -0.006925970781594515, 0.055422428995370865, -0.02678232081234455, -0.062271323055028915, -0.02612207643687725, -0.013628820888698101, -0.017061639577150345, -0.01069052517414093, 0.036263734102249146, 0.028363188728690147, -0.00021620896586682647, 0.013042003847658634, -0.0028345061000436544, -0.021664202213287354, -0.009292341768741608, 0.058857161551713943, -0.0394754633307457, 0.024996327236294746, 0.04707995057106018, 0.046979546546936035, -0.04700573906302452, 0.04055151715874672, -0.06550725549459457, -0.06388948857784271, 0.020949650555849075, -0.012866629287600517, 0.004995772615075111, -0.0445256382226944, -0.0207544956356287, 0.031226614490151405, 0.024987081065773964, -0.03389913588762283, 0.02360677905380726, -0.0893532782793045, 0.08712616562843323, 0.03407679870724678, -0.0021640071645379066, -0.02404862642288208, 0.002965532010421157, -0.01764887198805809, 0.019274555146694183, -0.022288814187049866, 0.002813931554555893, -0.04811851680278778, 0.011078939773142338, 0.03295307978987694, 0.0005923321004956961, -0.053193479776382446, 0.03957881033420563, 0.006903027184307575, 0.006369032897055149, 0.017181579023599625, 0.025035059079527855, 0.0017207760829478502, -0.02788030356168747, 0.0010764265898615122, -0.0005319498013705015, 0.01087973266839981, 0.008139504119753838, 0.011514903046190739, 0.02831723727285862, 0.05302010476589203, -0.010574269108474255, -0.01145666278898716, 0.0560682974755764, 0.011940655298531055, -0.023926934227347374, -0.00479127699509263, 0.0020376008469611406, 0.04889655485749245, -0.025091076269745827, 0.016425883397459984, 0.047486092895269394, -0.004262476693838835, -0.04129590094089508, 0.04085760563611984, -0.001997429644688964, 0.001019399263896048, 0.07496701925992966, -0.054180487990379333, 0.002748675411567092, 0.04056466370820999, -0.04850535839796066, -0.014782819896936417, -0.02656095288693905, -0.025331154465675354, -0.028880570083856583, 0.001479853643104434, 0.013759952038526535, 0.02681094966828823, 0.030050130560994148, -0.02841247245669365, -0.04900087043642998, 0.037226833403110504, -0.0133330337703228, -0.00028840082813985646, 0.019583387300372124, -0.059009749442338943, -0.014120494946837425, -0.03795330226421356, -0.009632701054215431, 0.011012069880962372, -0.012354427948594093, -0.004012541379779577, 0.001927499077282846, -0.021594634279608727, -0.06708431243896484, -0.029903193935751915, -0.030826471745967865, 0.025167277082800865, -0.027383025735616684, -0.06224381551146507, 0.029080359265208244, 0.0455167293548584, -0.02940291352570057, 0.011538811959326267, -0.01844765990972519, -0.009079238399863243, 0.006843081675469875, 0.017344102263450623, 0.005496435333043337, -0.005903187207877636, 0.0022943730000406504, 0.0025604497641324997, -0.023341339081525803, -0.0025209353771060705, -0.08335651457309723, -0.05451603978872299, 0.011652893386781216, 0.0016551697626709938, 0.04677237197756767, 0.009583458304405212, 0.00224773189984262, 0.05797361582517624, 0.04072839766740799, -0.02334655448794365, -0.041783224791288376, -0.0168652031570673, -0.02008829265832901, -0.01254959125071764, 0.034389086067676544, 0.006225767079740763, 0.00711621530354023, 0.029861727729439735, 0.00421183230355382, 0.036335986107587814, 0.02225329540669918, 0.00844193622469902, -0.04402817785739899, 0.061772871762514114, 0.034423816949129105, -0.03888621926307678, 0.006719653960317373, 0.025136267766356468, -0.035842955112457275, 0.004412180278450251, -0.01610325463116169, 0.028855761513113976, 0.027210190892219543, -0.04513551667332649, -0.011981233023107052, 0.008247279562056065, 0.02883456088602543, -0.02624557353556156, 0.028176279738545418, 0.008694020099937916, -0.06358741223812103, 0.0005714092985726893, 0.026160337030887604, 0.037446096539497375, -0.0002677366719581187, 0.012175829149782658, 0.04192914068698883, 0.054302409291267395, -0.0034031521063297987, 0.0007414366700686514, 0.014807269908487797, -0.01268300972878933, 0.01904359832406044, -0.02155955694615841, 0.0062868609093129635, 0.030431125313043594, 0.023096902295947075, 0.031456902623176575, -0.008052819408476353, -0.03242475166916847, 0.011964189819991589, -0.059867966920137405, -0.01858956180512905, -0.03817835822701454, 0.06388696283102036, 0.022061863914132118, 0.038399044424295425, 0.026130540296435356, -0.00045668601524084806, 0.014746369794011116, 0.019827326759696007, -0.07945600152015686, 0.03477197140455246, -0.0030047143809497356, 0.008636646904051304, 0.009695136919617653, -0.051789551973342896, 0.03050309792160988, -0.03748510405421257, -0.015675684437155724, -0.0018602961208671331, 0.027301011607050896, -0.020967228338122368, -0.02014688402414322, -0.03184332698583603, -0.034857798367738724, -0.0064840782433748245, -0.021052692085504532, -0.004753889981657267, -0.04306855797767639, 0.029340075328946114, 0.052374567836523056, -0.0012244735844433308, -0.044376108795404434, -0.02421320416033268, -0.0016200230456888676, 0.011357532814145088, 0.05371975898742676, 0.007790614850819111, -0.0007047748658806086, -0.040216170251369476, 0.0451742522418499, -0.0008751520072109997, 0.038959801197052, 0.02576255612075329, -0.017625590786337852, -0.023874586448073387, -0.018722256645560265, 0.007640531752258539, -0.01932448148727417, 0.009565361775457859, -0.013331334106624126, -0.0076225269585847855, 0.07819398492574692, 0.012216394767165184, -0.0549251027405262, 0.008663029409945011, 0.04050947725772858, 0.02420365810394287, -0.003319778712466359, -0.011836930178105831, 0.00804279837757349, -0.01888357661664486, 0.04205973818898201, 0.03664500638842583, 0.010996290482580662, 0.01301921159029007, 0.022329119965434074, 0.050820767879486084, 0.009986938908696175, -0.008042271248996258, -0.0010964208049699664, 0.024898985400795937, 0.05871274322271347, 0.003932307008653879, -0.07528115063905716, 0.012850792147219181, 0.027424592524766922, 0.028754929080605507, 0.021984271705150604, -0.003138932166621089, -0.1175062507390976, 0.007250176277011633, 0.036921702325344086, 0.049562595784664154, -0.0347491018474102, -0.016106171533465385, -0.026214709505438805, 0.022570721805095673, 0.021944532170891762, -0.04217620566487312, 0.0052076540887355804, 0.018841173499822617, 0.021729860454797745, -0.03269275650382042, -0.04026060551404953, -0.05184957757592201, 0.009820373728871346, -0.008417158387601376, 0.013877540826797485, 0.013011857867240906, -0.033521171659231186, -0.0323171503841877, 0.035575419664382935, 0.022676100954413414, 0.03659863770008087, -0.02452177368104458, -0.022668275982141495, 0.027948418632149696, -0.010786027647554874, 0.0021871146745979786, -0.064266636967659, 0.023542800918221474, 0.0018988334340974689, -0.009297811426222324, 0.06414525210857391, -0.0012936708517372608, -0.010357402265071869, 0.05558495968580246, 0.02883267216384411, -0.03608952462673187, 0.008837095461785793, -0.0428047738969326, 0.02735181711614132, -0.02304014004766941, -0.01903172768652439, 0.036018986254930496, 0.019090021029114723, 0.002345565939322114, -0.016705526039004326, -0.0393257737159729, 0.005411076825112104, -0.017261946573853493, -0.0333578884601593, -0.031172513961791992, -0.004580920562148094, -0.026874689385294914, -0.01176165509968996, 0.009587825275957584, 0.003582341130822897, -0.021571695804595947, -0.022282898426055908, -0.009376711212098598, 0.028807051479816437, -0.021347470581531525, 0.02649519219994545, -0.021516965702176094, 0.03187336027622223, -0.01435246504843235, -0.010796934366226196, 0.027737176045775414, -0.015440077520906925, 0.007505821064114571, 0.020072301849722862, -0.03864501044154167, -0.00005704056457034312, -0.05575985088944435, -0.020900849252939224, -0.0023953826166689396, -0.03075474314391613, 0.014437349513173103, -0.0017780510243028402, 0.03579147532582283, -0.014897285029292107, -0.04330886900424957, -0.030395783483982086, 0.010901043191552162, 0.01740317791700363, 0.027994420379400253, -0.002063636900857091, 0.05547425523400307, -0.018871212378144264, -0.007180422078818083, -0.06334716826677322, -0.0335870236158371, 0.0022666756995022297, 0.020615333691239357, -0.023539362475275993, -0.026043549180030823, 0.005270805675536394, -0.026206128299236298, -0.027257615700364113, 0.01090562716126442, 0.047665104269981384, -0.009152491576969624, 0.0007349444204010069, 0.004581837449222803, 0.021062292158603668, 0.056081708520650864, 0.013897975906729698, -0.008678246289491653, 0.0138395419344306, -0.01077182311564684, -0.02210335247218609, 0.035975132137537, -0.0041452073492109776, -0.06314282864332199, -0.02025664411485195, -0.025967683643102646, -0.016352979466319084, 0.049441270530223846, 0.004131547175347805, -0.0042440504767000675, 0.006238775327801704, -0.0038415067829191685, 0.0017149067716673017, -0.03718467429280281, -0.015742409974336624, -0.020999638363718987, -0.007000509649515152, -0.014802236109972, 0.016535144299268723, -0.02338610216975212, -0.0005095279193483293, 0.03373746946454048, -0.002691378118470311, -0.03736937418580055, 0.03441784530878067, 0.06574448198080063, 0.024347594007849693, -0.003081289352849126, -0.029979132115840912, -0.027248680591583252, 0.036555636674165726, -0.001838972675614059, 0.003365840297192335, 0.02428032085299492, 0.03018658421933651, -0.017623238265514374, -0.041790854185819626, -0.04644501581788063, -0.030666891485452652, 0.016328703612089157, -0.00013238386600278318, 0.018933823332190514, 0.03828335180878639, 0.012834292836487293, 0.005342664662748575, -0.0056829205714166164, -0.009824395179748535, -0.021838387474417686, 0.033181045204401016, 0.06318346410989761, -0.012474439106881618, -0.0226270854473114, 0.010381185449659824, 0.014826896600425243, 0.017462419345974922, 0.03171886131167412, 0.033768635243177414, 0.03538300096988678, 0.03695681318640709, -0.042032692581415176, -0.039066921919584274, 0.03193018585443497, -0.052393317222595215, 0.044183921068906784, -0.028664205223321915, -0.013332313857972622, 0.016377102583646774, 0.055591925978660583, 0.006675779353827238, -0.038208432495594025, 0.0009040109580382705, -0.05154725909233093, 0.03211245313286781, 0.010142193175852299, 0.016961930319666862, 0.01902652159333229, 0.009154459461569786, 0.015732770785689354, -0.01630268804728985, 0.022565286606550217, -0.007679993752390146, -0.10020746290683746, -0.02860538847744465, 0.008679955266416073, -0.01483183354139328, 0.023441603407263756, -0.01712198369204998, -0.041362788528203964, 0.011106990277767181, -0.06769496202468872, 0.023650363087654114, 0.013092761859297752, 0.02904779464006424, -0.023764781653881073, 0.04042660444974899, -0.0315844751894474, -0.016898075118660927, 0.005378966685384512, -0.017133178189396858, 0.11808019131422043, 0.09687954932451248, 0.025997024029493332, -0.0691172331571579, 0.04527286812663078, 0.052595652639865875, 0.01132057886570692, 0.013291974551975727, -0.01615939475595951, -0.00011373413144610822, 0.004577578045427799, 0.06313952058553696, -0.0031250594183802605, 0.021569380536675453, 0.02761922962963581, 0.06417806446552277, -0.04220937564969063, -0.018326492980122566, -0.0006239413050934672, -0.0038013015873730183, 0.004678608849644661, -0.006612431723624468, -0.02319878153502941, 0.0311381034553051, 0.006110476329922676, -0.00815378874540329, -0.01517023891210556, -0.014959604479372501, -0.03292812779545784, 0.014909121207892895, -0.038997337222099304, -0.008734568953514099, 0.024019641801714897, 0.035447265952825546, -0.006393864285200834, 0.015117092058062553, -0.0053021167404949665, -0.06403154134750366, 0.005538236349821091, 0.04611510783433914, 0.0016390527598559856, -0.008590670302510262, 0.0008810097351670265, 0.010220800526440144, -0.04449748992919922, -0.001069272286258638, -0.051351893693208694, 0.017110830172896385, -0.010778765194118023, -0.02352166920900345, -0.018970822915434837, 0.02134472131729126, 0.0011839441722258925, -0.029040342196822166, -0.02528386563062668, 0.01773037575185299, 0.007460359949618578, -0.032291945070028305, -0.02002827264368534, -0.021402506157755852, 0.014233913272619247, -0.007243840489536524, 0.04183181747794151, 0.029710084199905396, -0.03453924134373665, -0.02314586378633976, -0.012156950309872627, 0.06499217450618744, 0.009632119908928871, 0.007872371934354305, 0.02455078437924385, -0.021155865862965584, -0.0125591354444623, 0.013056131079792976, -0.009640395641326904, 0.024093953892588615, 0.018043862655758858, -0.022613219916820526, 0.013802257366478443, -0.0644579753279686, -0.012235306203365326, -0.004135745111852884, -0.021089667454361916, 0.04380789026618004, -0.05129936710000038, 0.003481220221146941, 0.0028455727733671665, 0.045780640095472336, 0.010806511156260967, 0.03261752799153328, 0.004241326358169317, 0.027472317218780518, 0.008814241737127304, -0.06030292436480522, 0.008489292114973068, 0.01765306107699871, -0.033476877957582474, -0.002933887764811516, -0.00034973048605024815, 0.09332949668169022, 0.013329519890248775, 0.02024032734334469, -0.011690542101860046, 0.05008508265018463, -0.025321422144770622, 0.04408074915409088, 0.009337732568383217, -0.04530985280871391, -0.0033016058150678873, 0.005696672014892101, 0.03716552257537842, -0.011335410177707672, -0.04931775480508804, -0.0243621077388525, -0.05383402481675148, 0.02129080891609192, -0.014316532760858536, -0.028623037040233612, -0.012921435758471489, -0.010331612080335617, 0.01651153154671192, -0.04778984561562538, -0.008536545559763908, -0.03980229049921036, -0.00817759707570076, 0.017685236409306526, -0.002273441758006811, -0.006718610413372517, 0.011485055088996887, -0.0037534378934651613, 0.02228786051273346, 0.023148858919739723, 0.016174955293536186, 0.02449975535273552, -0.004888035822659731, 0.011393044143915176, 0.016494913026690483, 0.034378331154584885, -0.02732575498521328, -0.018533460795879364, 0.033916182816028595, -0.032117582857608795, -0.01711903139948845, 0.024128751829266548, 0.003929247613996267, 0.019404685124754906, 0.03005071170628071, 0.006793152075260878, -0.018758688122034073, 0.060574136674404144, -0.011368301697075367, -0.013827359303832054, -0.023197326809167862, 0.01636483334004879, -0.006673518568277359, -0.035301562398672104, -0.017503950744867325, 0.030214205384254456, -0.018380431458353996, 0.05604364722967148, 0.06493362039327621, 0.046650148928165436, 0.023629792034626007, 0.024074401706457138, 0.0052614058367908, 0.01637228950858116, 0.011169398203492165, -0.0016579587245360017, 0.007214175071567297, 0.03216634690761566, -0.02408592775464058, 0.028450993821024895, -0.010414122603833675, 0.022459056228399277, -0.0943438708782196, -0.023146923631429672, 0.023957448080182076, 0.015850652009248734, 0.012240101583302021, -0.03447629138827324, 0.022578133270144463, 0.016901634633541107, -0.041749484837055206, 0.014076712541282177, 0.022804223001003265, -0.03224407881498337, -0.003497081808745861, 0.013708535581827164, -0.05109703540802002, 0.038401778787374496, 0.030710924416780472, 0.000055090007663238794, 0.03125514090061188, 0.013139819726347923, 0.02628093957901001, -0.013351005502045155, 0.03097199834883213, 0.008867998607456684, -0.004229986574500799, -0.0627954825758934, 0.008929245173931122, -0.054313354194164276, -0.031370777636766434, 0.02753358706831932, 0.02283594012260437, 0.07914535701274872, 0.03773295134305954, -0.0014391137519851327, 0.007324707694351673, 0.051239077001810074, 0.028416046872735023, 0.023646101355552673, -0.035190656781196594, -0.00581847969442606, 0.018727319315075874, 0.03524434193968773, 0.0035549523308873177, 0.017810026183724403, 0.032267484813928604, -0.0157629381865263, -0.03352801501750946, -0.009693673811852932, -0.02929811179637909, 0.012740129604935646, 0.01265748031437397, -0.019170764833688736, -0.01664387620985508, -0.018313933163881302, 0.003663394134491682, -0.06887462735176086, -0.02016618847846985, 0.03206957131624222, 0.023916112259030342, -0.03133169189095497, -0.005771035794168711, -0.02918476052582264, -0.022958051413297653, 0.007966647855937481, 0.009852034971117973, -0.00079550058580935, -0.03752293437719345, -0.0024281395599246025, 0.00134404213167727, 0.023376287892460823, -0.001301371492445469, -0.012135452590882778, -0.04911452531814575, 0.02421480044722557, -0.044649723917245865, 0.012595425359904766, 0.04257333651185036, -0.0238578412681818, 0.012523715384304523, -0.10413975268602371, 0.07769469171762466, -0.0018734794575721025, -0.036727093160152435, -0.033797118812799454, 0.015435140579938889, -0.05295177176594734, 0.009061980061233044, 0.05237428471446037, 0.04928671568632126, -0.017605233937501907, -0.013878465630114079, 0.035836782306432724, 0.018511639907956123, -0.04479982703924179, 0.006722124293446541, -0.0267341211438179, -0.012961069121956825, -0.032251808792352676, 0.0035726893693208694, 0.008018731139600277, 0.004788004793226719, 0.026765543967485428, -0.002818523673340678, 0.035932984203100204, 0.011343937367200851, -0.030026013031601906, 0.024790765717625618, -0.04634151607751846, -0.007247081026434898, 0.0406913235783577, -0.04743465781211853, 0.0076433648355305195, 0.039105791598558426, -0.03558710962533951, -0.06576719135046005, 0.06536342948675156, -0.0019426487851887941, -0.010584753938019276, -0.017683004960417747, -0.010889806784689426, 0.006739581469446421, -0.02879529818892479, 0.02291230671107769, 0.010354680009186268, -0.024544980376958847, 0.0002612560347188264, 0.0027605751529335976, -0.00024551880778744817, 0.062091998755931854, -0.02886105887591839, 0.0009392836946062744, -0.0008699924219399691, -0.022853007540106773, -0.012036186642944813, -0.025787541642785072, 0.030109135434031487, 0.017260316759347916, 0.0035880059003829956, 0.05518772080540657, 0.0012658097548410296, 0.02580760233104229, -0.003905954072251916, 0.00021879206178709865, -0.021375000476837158, -0.011696561239659786, 0.020528212189674377, -0.00720274168998003, 0.053444135934114456, 0.017219141125679016, 0.015973316505551338, 0.04977237060666084, -0.060778193175792694, -0.017912039533257484, -0.05372026935219765, -0.021558422595262527, -0.029561500996351242, 0.004466517828404903, 0.027273312211036682, 0.0038995747454464436, 0.027747465297579765, 0.015127179212868214, -0.007689737249165773, -0.00309806689620018, 0.02307351864874363, -0.01160509418696165, 0.012279652990400791, -0.011827978305518627, -0.0025071618147194386, -0.011301446706056595, -0.00824072677642107, -0.02525361254811287, -0.042430032044649124, 0.0834462121129036, 0.07497822493314743, 0.0058841886930167675, -0.031199682503938675, -0.006500793620944023, -0.02950148843228817, 0.0472673624753952, -0.049357712268829346, -0.03372754156589508, -0.05611799284815788, 0.016408197581768036, 0.013037643395364285, -0.061982423067092896 ]
<p>I am working on a machine learning experiment comparing the use of multiple different neural network classifiers by applying them on a large number of datasets, using stratified 10-fold cross-validation. I measure the performance as the average of the errors on the validation set (sometimes referred to as test set) of the 10-fold cross-validation procedure.</p> <p>My question is, would it be ok to use this same validation set to do an early stopping of the training procedure? This early stopping would be performed by applying the trained model after each epoch to the validation set and measuring the performance, and if it declines for a number of successive learning epochs, the learning would be halted and we would take the epoch that produced the last good performance. This would be applied to all the different techniques, and across all the different datasets.</p> <p>Is this ok? Or is it statistically inaccurate?</p>
6,992
[ -0.016712725162506104, -0.0014537526294589043, -0.03653803467750549, -0.012444042600691319, 0.05282380431890488, 0.0174118559807539, -0.026150178164243698, -0.04133503884077072, 0.02589101530611515, 0.0037525524385273457, 0.07096724212169647, 0.032282136380672455, 0.036358341574668884, 0.027869516983628273, -0.010105092078447342, 0.022302353754639626, -0.035527028143405914, -0.019380299374461174, -0.01159687153995037, -0.035442695021629333, -0.019623352214694023, 0.02360348030924797, 0.016062630340456963, -0.007960069924592972, -0.05273514613509178, 0.014409401454031467, -0.008672645315527916, -0.03464067354798317, -0.007415119092911482, 0.03985165059566498, -0.036813605576753616, -0.0023650266230106354, -0.0081271817907691, 0.0463862419128418, 0.0027399577666074038, 0.014088725671172142, 0.0031172207091003656, -0.049000147730112076, -0.03027968481183052, 0.024424927309155464, 0.013990656472742558, 0.004738768097013235, 0.016698244959115982, 0.05851681903004646, 0.03320107236504555, 0.0019958156626671553, -0.024312831461429596, -0.007130771409720182, 0.010526163503527641, 0.0009247416164726019, 0.027679910883307457, -0.024006159976124763, 0.015503870323300362, 0.05030285194516182, -0.01357514038681984, 0.006347364280372858, 0.058749496936798096, 0.0590856708586216, -0.006760041695088148, -0.04948035255074501, 0.0005829578149132431, -0.030882148072123528, 0.003944720141589642, 0.011440408416092396, -0.010422654449939728, 0.04074348881840706, 0.008935279212892056, -0.010314353741705418, -0.0020240237936377525, -0.03132445365190506, 0.01609879545867443, 0.020320950075984, 0.0422058142721653, -0.03160480782389641, 0.0035157273523509502, 0.009882751852273941, 0.006342957261949778, 0.039190907031297684, 0.05414161458611488, 0.035543397068977356, 0.006471700966358185, 0.018130773678421974, 0.02814527228474617, 0.05189337581396103, 0.03253458812832832, 0.01915127784013748, 0.08983605355024338, -0.019605016335844994, 0.03458896651864052, 0.021834509447216988, 0.014304395765066147, 0.008421719074249268, 0.04218783974647522, 0.01699073053896427, -0.038083937019109726, 0.026896607130765915, -0.0049179932102561, 0.035470910370349884, 0.031084002926945686, 0.007011603098362684, 0.005468668416142464, -0.008969319984316826, 0.014214678667485714, 0.02484559826552868, -0.04278535395860672, -0.0030510069336742163, -0.019093818962574005, -0.006744852755218744, -0.043541859835386276, -0.008096335455775261, -0.03682512789964676, 0.025465041399002075, 0.01202831044793129, 0.025517215952277184, 0.025279482826590538, 0.02739814855158329, 0.017190173268318176, 0.014092867262661457, 0.0016624231357127428, 0.02546851895749569, 0.043093256652355194, -0.026377031579613686, 0.026931609958410263, -0.0055398037657141685, 0.0032981084659695625, 0.008258748799562454, 0.028950698673725128, -0.01870608702301979, -0.029602620750665665, 0.029307600110769272, -0.0312546081840992, -0.046473585069179535, 0.009646623395383358, -0.043825339525938034, 0.05368563532829285, -0.007000199053436518, -0.04746217653155327, -0.05867549404501915, 0.025847962126135826, -0.02355680614709854, 0.024336447939276695, -0.034782640635967255, -0.004302836023271084, 0.0008731774869374931, 0.047181978821754456, 0.010036538355052471, 0.008856645785272121, -0.004218283109366894, 0.011699708178639412, -0.01565946824848652, -0.005723301321268082, -0.028563592582941055, -0.018826525658369064, 0.03554489091038704, -0.042972952127456665, -0.11754035949707031, 0.025851015001535416, 0.013604732230305672, 0.008268353529274464, -0.01742531731724739, -0.02636871114373207, -0.031182926148176193, 0.02060971036553383, -0.0007441006018780172, 0.029040712863206863, -0.02984067052602768, 0.07460001111030579, 0.018276086077094078, 0.05791725590825081, -0.004584143869578838, -0.003682546317577362, 0.010150869376957417, 0.025508075952529907, 0.04022765904664993, 0.038628824055194855, -0.014939011074602604, 0.03815781697630882, -0.035979222506284714, 0.03800512105226517, -0.012808372266590595, -0.018368566408753395, -0.024514608085155487, -0.00452614389359951, -0.025589358061552048, -0.023812860250473022, 0.02288687415421009, 0.008718541823327541, -0.03112928383052349, 0.019359126687049866, -0.020830025896430016, -0.043537434190511703, -0.08070813119411469, 0.020181968808174133, -0.02571340836584568, 0.0011386641999706626, 0.027098271995782852, -0.0006767943850718439, 0.03001859039068222, -0.038709260523319244, -0.026110490784049034, -0.025790385901927948, -0.010706263594329357, -0.0014083153801038861, -0.01284550130367279, 0.003852779045701027, 0.037790313363075256, -0.01407576259225607, -0.024377280846238136, 0.03995465114712715, -0.002698448719456792, -0.056175071746110916, -0.002856507897377014, -0.011735118925571442, -0.014715923927724361, 0.0046326094307005405, -0.03165743872523308, 0.05998671054840088, 0.00034447494545020163, -0.027658848091959953, 0.02559700235724449, -0.05272452160716057, 0.08302074670791626, 0.05918685719370842, -0.033440858125686646, 0.006973675452172756, -0.00878180656582117, 0.017385458573698997, 0.050686512142419815, -0.0012559057213366032, 0.0025464496575295925, -0.04809894040226936, -0.016476793214678764, 0.03742734342813492, 0.03886640816926956, -0.028127895668148994, 0.013668108731508255, 0.09528695791959763, 0.0015600195620208979, 0.033099737018346786, 0.007009229157119989, 0.03354094177484512, -0.0123749403283, 0.0005977990222163498, 0.037454959005117416, -0.001625536591745913, 0.018004074692726135, 0.020070843398571014, -0.010966906324028969, 0.0071387095376849174, 0.0108251441270113, 0.010958327911794186, 0.024740850552916527, 0.017151352018117905, 0.009296541102230549, 0.0055138417519629, -0.06161009147763252, 0.005902233999222517, -0.01109628938138485, 0.0538317933678627, -0.009122764691710472, 0.02489643543958664, 0.013246339745819569, -0.03427776321768761, 0.0021838017273694277, 0.03435666859149933, 0.017975028604269028, -0.020948590710759163, -0.027724364772439003, 0.038767118006944656, -0.05802958086133003, 0.010996188968420029, -0.03225759044289589, -0.03370388597249985, -0.04186442494392395, 0.02165142074227333, 0.054061733186244965, -0.023610129952430725, 0.06219824403524399, -0.058103449642658234, 0.0022992996964603662, -0.02396642230451107, -0.04156562685966492, 0.04643859341740608, -0.018138950690627098, -0.03967267647385597, -0.004173142835497856, -0.015127908438444138, -0.042221713811159134, 0.04243039712309837, -0.031221313402056694, -0.014878269284963608, 0.055515751242637634, 0.037976935505867004, -0.04070952534675598, -0.03753673657774925, -0.05786418542265892, -0.0034577969927340746, -0.0021783229894936085, -0.046789709478616714, 0.04788794741034508, 0.019254567101597786, -0.03894750773906708, 0.05939260497689247, -0.001844110549427569, -0.020437858998775482, -0.015615814365446568, -0.011121686547994614, 0.01018192246556282, -0.029776008799672127, 0.004168147221207619, 0.05764222517609596, -0.012674123980104923, -0.03058539144694805, -0.06776801496744156, -0.0955660417675972, 0.011138901114463806, -0.011427907273173332, 0.028223522007465363, -0.009704994037747383, 0.013875436969101429, 0.09705124795436859, 0.05091080814599991, -0.01616532914340496, -0.02651793509721756, 0.042359884828329086, -0.01796979270875454, -0.03439454361796379, 0.010568508878350258, -0.027431420981884003, -0.013281237334012985, 0.0025260322727262974, -0.040330782532691956, 0.020223306491971016, 0.0458848811686039, -0.0061769247986376286, 0.005387039389461279, -0.02113063633441925, 0.011903338134288788, 0.0033077269326895475, 0.010750546120107174, 0.014822937548160553, -0.0014761192724108696, 0.00825523491948843, -0.030622167512774467, 0.05006210878491402, 0.025350432842969894, -0.044264815747737885, 0.055025964975357056, -0.03940516710281372, -0.017669690772891045, -0.010324082337319851, 0.030127769336104393, 0.016816752031445503, -0.025847582146525383, -0.003937527537345886, 0.023522263392806053, 0.044225141406059265, 0.00677999434992671, -0.00015303032705560327, 0.010937368497252464, -0.002371142152696848, -0.02808210253715515, -0.045143354684114456, -0.004969399888068438, -0.005342226009815931, 0.037136659026145935, -0.0074192616157233715, -0.017030812799930573, 0.019721554592251778, 0.038564614951610565, 0.017498673871159554, 0.011442701332271099, -0.03264535591006279, 0.018673356622457504, -0.06872568279504776, -0.016175970435142517, -0.039557646960020065, 0.061461687088012695, 0.03273731470108032, 0.04632623493671417, -0.004493011627346277, -0.053110521286726, 0.02026999555528164, 0.020622557029128075, -0.07981804758310318, 0.026348119601607323, 0.0020376062020659447, -0.018329327926039696, -0.005413991864770651, -0.0595792792737484, 0.024834485724568367, -0.02947915717959404, 0.015338802710175514, -0.00930330902338028, 0.027551619336009026, -0.051771845668554306, 0.0156885776668787, -0.034752774983644485, -0.007849229499697685, 0.003061369527131319, 0.010331948287785053, 0.013210875913500786, 0.026221662759780884, 0.010481842793524265, 0.0010216019582003355, -0.014670943841338158, -0.017710456624627113, -0.01607922837138176, 0.02161809429526329, 0.0028243474662303925, 0.034114986658096313, 0.019256969913840294, 0.05808417871594429, -0.07906890660524368, 0.04233941808342934, -0.0015857253456488252, 0.05166466906666756, 0.06260116398334503, 0.020020529627799988, -0.058517806231975555, -0.05781256780028343, -0.029573194682598114, 0.05451762303709984, 0.011858347803354263, -0.0039623575285077095, -0.031897157430648804, 0.028246786445379257, 0.02981387823820114, -0.07103902846574783, 0.013815045356750488, 0.05568062514066696, -0.012843737378716469, -0.012496133334934711, -0.03504149243235588, -0.012002658098936081, 0.00017212846432812512, -0.013059692457318306, 0.002445759018883109, -0.0019786960911005735, -0.047395091503858566, 0.007313648238778114, 0.03893885761499405, -0.025762461125850677, -0.055071860551834106, 0.021921612322330475, 0.009051278233528137, 0.02162393555045128, -0.008315237239003181, 0.013492346741259098, 0.0199436042457819, 0.03096652962267399, 0.04631877318024635, 0.0285233985632658, 0.006925519555807114, -0.0595538355410099, -0.00990574061870575, 0.05782618001103401, 0.020171038806438446, -0.041773270815610886, -0.009312638081610203, -0.053186580538749695, -0.030313191935420036, 0.049109432846307755, -0.027498377487063408, 0.024979809299111366, -0.00010745011968538165, -0.00801676232367754, -0.04127874970436096, 0.002197482157498598, -0.00011264100612606853, -0.02134997397661209, -0.03752299025654793, 0.018386470153927803, -0.005268249195069075, -0.000011211621313123032, -0.026037676259875298, 0.013224954716861248, -0.01489639189094305, 0.057505812495946884, -0.04207569733262062, 0.00020691686950158328, -0.008579171262681484, -0.008355025202035904, 0.016736822202801704, -0.0708221048116684, -0.02146383747458458, -0.00990221742540598, -0.01703410968184471, 0.02778784930706024, 0.0047230832278728485, -0.031015655025839806, 0.04166413098573685, 0.007408646401017904, -0.02348310686647892, -0.009639116935431957, -0.05248304083943367, 0.0434710867702961, 0.05303057283163071, 0.024491840973496437, 0.024126261472702026, -0.0071181366220116615, 0.02295605279505253, 0.03631891682744026, -0.0039130751974880695, 0.024723639711737633, -0.053760554641485214, 0.014702600426971912, -0.02625144086778164, -0.008787822909653187, -0.03214177489280701, 0.047440942376852036, -0.011948957107961178, 0.030124608427286148, -0.006930418312549591, -0.020348312333226204, 0.01736556738615036, 0.017937300726771355, -0.008914579637348652, -0.02950183115899563, 0.008862472139298916, 0.017468303442001343, -0.032447293400764465, 0.008066095411777496, -0.016748370602726936, -0.009499290958046913, 0.0431671142578125, 0.037469811737537384, -0.027882331982254982, 0.0029984735883772373, -0.03372390940785408, -0.01044884417206049, 0.0009700750815682113, -0.018261950463056564, 0.029606202617287636, 0.03857607766985893, 0.03526639938354492, -0.027296341955661774, -0.008448665961623192, -0.010710726492106915, 0.039739739149808884, -0.005494179669767618, 0.009500953368842602, -0.04447312653064728, 0.035146765410900116, -0.009498432278633118, 0.005432614125311375, -0.057678088545799255, -0.017341773957014084, 0.04104949161410332, 0.011143716983497143, -0.020672377198934555, -0.015317504294216633, 0.00045384219265542924, 0.004584906622767448, -0.01464380044490099, -0.023577980697155, 0.04760186746716499, -0.019484806805849075, -0.02735413797199726, 0.0209361482411623, -0.01750762015581131, 0.08550189435482025, -0.00445380387827754, 0.02624988928437233, -0.010669933632016182, -0.02465182915329933, -0.03864583000540733, 0.006122769322246313, 0.0070357853546738625, -0.006661483086645603, -0.005898790899664164, -0.04910856857895851, 0.010632315650582314, 0.02724047377705574, -0.0037579957861453295, -0.019231049343943596, 0.05158666521310806, -0.036724161356687546, -0.021422425284981728, -0.004421334248036146, 0.016902847215533257, -0.031131276860833168, -0.020641349256038666, 0.027560679242014885, 0.009335743263363838, 0.0054412283934652805, -0.030405137687921524, 0.017257090657949448, -0.005674070678651333, -0.04365348443388939, 0.0028531646821647882, 0.06699446588754654, -0.03296908363699913, -0.032595738768577576, -0.0195279773324728, -0.05656095966696739, 0.05343560501933098, -0.006016465835273266, 0.000004868840733252, 0.00558012630790472, 0.0009787396993488073, -0.03879641368985176, -0.020618554204702377, -0.009690896607935429, -0.037741221487522125, 0.03885587304830551, -0.01054057665169239, 0.05311092734336853, 0.042114682495594025, 0.03242705762386322, -0.005687186494469643, -0.029138218611478806, 0.036423470824956894, -0.02408614382147789, 0.04195740073919296, 0.0661168098449707, 0.024908075109124184, 0.0022718645632267, 0.03992209956049919, 0.011247221380472183, 0.05324706435203552, 0.06737862527370453, -0.013401804491877556, 0.019578905776143074, 0.013837295584380627, -0.018897833302617073, -0.04515932500362396, 0.027495674788951874, -0.08985576033592224, -0.014354654587805271, -0.019191455096006393, 0.014424441382288933, 0.021838143467903137, 0.027523905038833618, 0.011033776216208935, -0.017379295080900192, -0.01198758464306593, -0.06057169660925865, 0.01200952474027872, 0.01658664271235466, 0.012099736370146275, 0.03774317353963852, 0.0012141275219619274, 0.041721973568201065, 0.011927355080842972, 0.029887432232499123, -0.032940398901700974, -0.03004186786711216, -0.04714711382985115, -0.03633628040552139, -0.023196877911686897, 0.022963721305131912, 0.011566661298274994, -0.03239070624113083, -0.006709295324981213, -0.009425900876522064, 0.027389269322156906, 0.002050256123766303, 0.04225882887840271, -0.017471592873334885, 0.028329377993941307, 0.023213660344481468, 0.02864746004343033, 0.02706541121006012, 0.013859023340046406, 0.13343164324760437, 0.09963685274124146, 0.0365997776389122, -0.0259853582829237, 0.002409987151622772, -0.017285143956542015, -0.023515483364462852, -0.03560766205191612, 0.014288563281297684, 0.03017677366733551, -0.01815938763320446, 0.01873582974076271, 0.02277294732630253, -0.01456870324909687, -0.03670721873641014, 0.05149225890636444, 0.019171269610524178, 0.03843240067362785, 0.03743140771985054, 0.030846374109387398, -0.005258420016616583, -0.0288190096616745, -0.00828647892922163, 0.020520532503724098, 0.011731821112334728, -0.02404036559164524, -0.008808002807199955, -0.002479186514392495, 0.025158202275633812, 0.007677522953599691, 0.011571566574275494, 0.010969447903335094, -0.001412931364029646, -0.011552661657333374, -0.023556169122457504, -0.0123562877997756, -0.016903579235076904, 0.0045718662440776825, 0.03703940659761429, 0.05534612014889717, 0.018188703805208206, -0.006216233596205711, -0.01160015445202589, 0.005173911340534687, -0.04454716295003891, -0.030528172850608826, -0.06509268283843994, 0.04923846200108528, -0.010195205919444561, -0.012775173410773277, 0.00359335751272738, 0.013956177048385143, 0.06390351057052612, -0.02945609949529171, -0.04210784286260605, 0.03952914848923683, -0.01663828268647194, -0.019258655607700348, -0.021138742566108704, -0.05024142935872078, 0.022850265726447105, 0.015974152833223343, -0.004378203302621841, -0.010857822373509407, -0.03670447692275047, -0.03203212469816208, -0.017376627773046494, 0.0273564662784338, 0.019826313480734825, 0.02034740336239338, -0.006445921026170254, -0.030066223815083504, -0.016538644209504128, -0.010691391304135323, 0.007979235611855984, 0.016858438029885292, 0.0025431415997445583, 0.0020189196802675724, -0.01649424247443676, -0.023381182923913002, -0.04237053543329239, -0.006556107196956873, -0.021806402131915092, 0.028355760499835014, 0.005007938016206026, -0.029718957841396332, 0.006254192907363176, 0.03184927627444267, 0.015470142476260662, 0.03042636625468731, 0.023795489221811295, 0.04069178178906441, 0.012150639668107033, -0.019692381843924522, -0.021868230774998665, -0.024176212027668953, -0.05382053554058075, 0.0570603683590889, -0.004991082474589348, 0.06964573264122009, 0.010887104086577892, 0.003343547461554408, -0.018153926357626915, 0.010510810650885105, 0.01992085576057434, -0.0037483235355466604, 0.014137640595436096, -0.0640060305595398, 0.0013793045654892921, 0.005862184800207615, 0.00469330744817853, -0.05226784572005272, -0.008334202691912651, -0.06526292115449905, -0.02611641027033329, 0.0025321280118077993, -0.011287174187600613, -0.031696952879428864, 0.012419270351529121, 0.019515836611390114, 0.03757764399051666, -0.003582384902983904, 0.013622465543448925, -0.06644252687692642, -0.011310171335935593, -0.05706074461340904, -0.06038707122206688, 0.011520717293024063, 0.008817341178655624, -0.010042713023722172, -0.011434593237936497, 0.03927252069115639, -0.034596577286720276, -0.011502559296786785, -0.023953314870595932, 0.000931916874833405, -0.0005832745227962732, 0.07686958461999893, -0.02121601440012455, 0.014115964993834496, 0.028405971825122833, -0.04900621995329857, -0.022659391164779663, 0.033156320452690125, -0.013298257254064083, 0.060996152460575104, 0.037532150745391846, -0.0033318866044282913, -0.002512152772396803, 0.031036024913191795, -0.011151562444865704, -0.03205643221735954, 0.009467005729675293, 0.00504983589053154, 0.041141800582408905, 0.06065921485424042, 0.024659330025315285, 0.027201369404792786, 0.03531758487224579, 0.003310726024210453, 0.025632193312048912, 0.015961779281497, -0.035776253789663315, -0.021141937002539635, -0.024492666125297546, 0.021883144974708557, -0.008043269626796246, 0.010733459144830704, -0.005851138383150101, 0.055215321481227875, -0.027035871520638466, 0.03805204853415489, -0.0009501478634774685, -0.02568177320063114, -0.07167034596204758, -0.03134046494960785, 0.00506017729640007, 0.05656006932258606, -0.004702130798250437, -0.029128745198249817, 0.022780269384384155, 0.04051714763045311, -0.05910228565335274, 0.0481482557952404, -0.008466144092381, -0.020113123580813408, -0.03509819880127907, 0.012059751898050308, 0.004822875838726759, -0.0173046737909317, 0.011797214858233929, -0.027043482288718224, 0.02725348435342312, 0.01109605934470892, -0.02037881873548031, -0.018152432516217232, -0.04803302139043808, 0.01761053130030632, -0.014031412079930305, -0.02273673564195633, 0.027976881712675095, -0.054084714502096176, -0.07314767688512802, 0.05072656273841858, -0.0229361429810524, -0.004292153753340244, 0.009010340087115765, 0.020388973876833916, 0.010854150168597698, 0.00825309008359909, 0.02412746474146843, -0.02262851968407631, 0.020451711490750313, 0.024197716265916824, 0.006433401722460985, 0.01365528255701065, -0.02674219198524952, 0.009893343783915043, 0.04698089510202408, -0.004345957655459642, -0.06271734833717346, 0.018851444125175476, 0.004627994727343321, 0.009007291868329048, 0.0012674186145886779, 0.027910182252526283, -0.011781779117882252, -0.039719123393297195, -0.02956150472164154, -0.019626663997769356, -0.003145475871860981, 0.011088636703789234, 0.03303240239620209, -0.019965574145317078, 0.006168432533740997, -0.04195326939225197, -0.04417690634727478, -0.00713591743260622, 0.005784892942756414, -0.033163756132125854, -0.054918959736824036, 0.024518268182873726, -0.013534177094697952, -0.038893911987543106, -0.04305499419569969, -0.02467046119272709, -0.0009408181067556143, 0.05022634193301201, -0.022351201623678207, 0.04227852076292038, -0.008100387640297413, -0.051630690693855286, -0.017883481457829475, -0.09796327352523804, 0.036485206335783005, -0.018492165952920914, -0.008528494276106358, -0.038951922208070755, 0.008351544849574566, -0.03406408801674843, -0.026817111298441887, 0.02418982982635498, 0.028451278805732727, -0.007423011120408773, -0.014891455881297588, 0.017091430723667145, -0.026519468054175377, -0.0779838114976883, 0.044003769755363464, -0.02651815116405487, -0.014778302982449532, -0.025663558393716812, -0.020130174234509468, -0.0012764923740178347, -0.005762601271271706, 0.018450012430548668, 0.017249394208192825, 0.03266781195998192, 0.0019591893069446087, -0.0006563455099239945, 0.05816151946783066, -0.007360835559666157, 0.009490324184298515, 0.026504212990403175, -0.009588056243956089, -0.011411593295633793, 0.015428795479238033, -0.02749178372323513, -0.0712500810623169, -0.0044082943350076675, -0.044302795082330704, -0.027750404551625252, -0.03446764498949051, 0.05594706907868385, -0.01208665780723095, -0.02561384066939354, 0.0025791896041482687, 0.03441410884261131, -0.023461027070879936, 0.02324022725224495, 0.04468958079814911, 0.051439154893159866, 0.014379903674125671, -0.034986063838005066, 0.046959612518548965, -0.008396264165639877, 0.004913604352623224, -0.005183898378163576, 0.007582248654216528, -0.009733221493661404, 0.00003417703919694759, 0.0573660209774971, 0.005394583102315664, -0.0016029119724407792, 0.015086107887327671, 0.01878417655825615, 0.08895828574895859, -0.036139748990535736, -0.005768354516476393, 0.028544971719384193, 0.004737718962132931, -0.013274596072733402, -0.008999528363347054, -0.002768176607787609, 0.04001861810684204, -0.033207863569259644, 0.006852163001894951, -0.02686733566224575, -0.05253155902028084, -0.006676711607724428, 0.012816399335861206, 0.02599993161857128, 0.03485073894262314, -0.007447212003171444, 0.0232827328145504, -0.0012766047148033977, 0.040784187614917755, 0.04733181744813919, -0.02586163766682148, 0.04446589946746826, 0.0030035621020942926, -0.005111956037580967, 0.011405964381992817, -0.025157717987895012, -0.009469330310821533, -0.0250686164945364, 0.023639017716050148, 0.04579104483127594, 0.02216411754488945, 0.013570019975304604, -0.006680913269519806, 0.0037522739730775356, -0.006205803249031305, -0.049612171947956085, -0.01270134188234806, -0.03651383891701698, 0.04285609722137451, 0.024590598419308662, -0.01670989952981472 ]
<p>I have developed two new sorting techniques using C language. I need to compare the performance of the both sorting techniques, to see which one is better than another. To do this, I used different input data, from n = 500 to n = 2500. For each data that need to be sorted, I run them 10 times and get the mean, standard deviation as well as coefficient of variation. An example of results are shown below:</p> <pre><code>n min max mean SD CV 500 24.07 24.52 21.28 0.11 0.47 1000 52.41 52.83 52.67 0.13 0.25 </code></pre> <p>Just to ask, can I only run each experiment 10 times or should I run more? If I run them 50 times, the results are very close and I obtain almost the same CV. The above results obtained when I run the first sorting technique. </p> <p>Can I say that 10 times is OK to get the results?</p> <p>I don't know how many samples should I use to test a particular data. Can anyone suggest any good reading books for this particular analysis?</p>
37,157
[ -0.028101280331611633, -0.021636096760630608, -0.04399818927049637, -0.00045109092025086284, 0.030939940363168716, 0.02059902623295784, 0.04689592868089676, -0.0525815486907959, 0.03102201782166958, 0.0009262979729101062, 0.02324782684445381, 0.030963167548179626, 0.045824725180864334, 0.0001864298974396661, 0.032954853028059006, -0.0033241850323975086, -0.02333294227719307, -0.008191851899027824, -0.005299992859363556, -0.008813804015517235, -0.027079207822680473, 0.025518322363495827, 0.009881209582090378, -0.009773594327270985, -0.06026376411318779, 0.004095990210771561, 0.02162701077759266, -0.0008113690419122577, -0.004342902917414904, 0.039154816418886185, -0.06261460483074188, -0.03321744501590729, -0.00890708714723587, 0.04150903597474098, 0.008298169821500778, -0.0010434712748974562, -0.02257971093058586, -0.02343573048710823, -0.02368021011352539, 0.0326932817697525, -0.036830686032772064, -0.019655121490359306, -0.010978990234434605, 0.012896860018372536, 0.036994416266679764, 0.00021583282796200365, -0.0008946388843469322, -0.03059808351099491, 0.00042102186125703156, -0.06941000372171402, 0.06447403132915497, -0.004035196732729673, 0.027430178597569466, 0.017206665128469467, 0.004996631760150194, 0.01547376811504364, 0.03248411417007446, 0.02510727569460869, -0.024405596777796745, -0.05767194926738739, 0.011627482250332832, -0.018966829404234886, -0.012372095137834549, -0.003989563323557377, -0.020099464803934097, 0.017815908417105675, -0.020824383944272995, -0.0011140668066218495, 0.06257762759923935, -0.01849127560853958, 0.02797335386276245, 0.013905560597777367, 0.030546413734555244, -0.020561741665005684, 0.0048340437933802605, -0.033931881189346313, 0.01297963410615921, -0.010157963261008263, 0.052985016256570816, 0.05047888681292534, 0.0034746374003589153, 0.03810574486851692, 0.019870303571224213, 0.0389396958053112, 0.024190053343772888, -0.04523259028792381, 0.0723184272646904, -0.04016066715121269, 0.01908557303249836, 0.006159777753055096, -0.00033147778594866395, -0.015465408563613892, 0.05486617982387543, 0.022112350910902023, -0.04954047128558159, 0.010437948629260063, -0.01402340829372406, 0.043336495757102966, -0.05205751582980156, -0.014783310703933239, -0.0142550989985466, -0.039313122630119324, 0.026009175926446915, 0.06891857087612152, -0.029031457379460335, 0.006013541482388973, -0.014816350303590298, 0.033084288239479065, -0.027709824964404106, -0.0013512849109247327, -0.005079355090856552, -0.016834810376167297, 0.027367617934942245, 0.012937571853399277, 0.013843181543052197, 0.006479052361100912, 0.01456337422132492, 0.0027115815319120884, 0.035190485417842865, 0.05625232681632042, 0.037979792803525925, -0.03547922521829605, 0.015865344554185867, -0.03615681827068329, -0.06361650675535202, -0.0009414124069735408, 0.02396012656390667, -0.02725283056497574, -0.042588550597429276, 0.06822402030229568, -0.04913391172885895, 0.02093600109219551, 0.023674936965107918, -0.034466035664081573, 0.011474923230707645, 0.017649047076702118, -0.09281715005636215, -0.05347667634487152, 0.054135728627443314, -0.045940667390823364, 0.029641633853316307, -0.06006663292646408, 0.023146647959947586, -0.0003330817853566259, 0.013837626203894615, 0.012300726026296616, 0.06834501773118973, -0.022779341787099838, 0.041310396045446396, 0.01838654652237892, -0.023986337706446648, -0.03793492540717125, 0.01499913726001978, 0.008983542211353779, -0.012564606964588165, -0.06939365714788437, 0.005726753734052181, 0.001958882436156273, -0.004917168989777565, -0.010191326029598713, 0.0019330400973558426, 0.025597698986530304, -0.006177352275699377, -0.038128409534692764, 0.0077086579985916615, -0.012874477542936802, 0.061927538365125656, 0.015116899274289608, 0.06414065510034561, 0.012386498041450977, -0.019225435331463814, 0.0244778823107481, 0.0065609063021838665, 0.0068049137480556965, 0.06803766638040543, -0.003067491576075554, 0.030647698789834976, -0.0040966724045574665, 0.02799857035279274, 0.019219858571887016, 0.00046957205631770194, -0.020008843392133713, 0.00558573380112648, 0.019381098449230194, 0.006964931730180979, 0.03834910690784454, 0.01587875746190548, 0.0016342446906492114, 0.032077606767416, -0.047163914889097214, -0.040411077439785004, -0.07751435041427612, -0.029826480895280838, 0.00772238289937377, -0.027005158364772797, 0.031916432082653046, -0.005496697966009378, 0.049678217619657516, -0.008441783487796783, -0.03654543682932854, -0.046336304396390915, -0.014123450964689255, 0.03394944593310356, -0.01062699407339096, 0.028736762702465057, 0.04660191386938095, 0.019038448110222816, -0.03654653951525688, 0.05690263584256172, -0.004772557411342859, -0.015614434145390987, 0.00014396998449228704, -0.012753289192914963, -0.017491856589913368, 0.03231251612305641, -0.005868515931069851, 0.05166791379451752, 0.035589396953582764, 0.011013905517756939, 0.026345228776335716, -0.04651288315653801, 0.10157867521047592, 0.07354915142059326, 0.02236333116889, 0.0033019487746059895, 0.00322576891630888, 0.035875771194696426, 0.015894398093223572, -0.01093050092458725, 0.0038272778037935495, -0.029445812106132507, 0.00039115798426792026, 0.03546689823269844, 0.06756732612848282, -0.07462204992771149, 0.0054343389347195625, 0.09660124033689499, 0.008068487048149109, 0.02782346121966839, 0.029977252706885338, -0.013630719855427742, -0.04980906844139099, 0.024334250018000603, 0.031712472438812256, 0.0034906729124486446, 0.028884554281830788, 0.014462102204561234, 0.0177569892257452, 0.026878679171204567, 0.00899604894220829, 0.019642222672700882, 0.054071635007858276, 0.0005298539181239903, 0.013378321193158627, 0.006138745229691267, -0.04186828061938286, 0.02491731382906437, -0.01625923439860344, -0.014258770272135735, 0.03469469025731087, -0.030413402244448662, 0.005673561245203018, -0.005888002458959818, 0.013363159261643887, 0.00902551133185625, 0.0267430879175663, -0.001471522729843855, 0.015171194449067116, 0.02318226732313633, -0.053217850625514984, 0.014865395613014698, -0.038331225514411926, -0.010892827063798904, -0.08288948982954025, 0.014845502562820911, 0.026901504024863243, -0.004569961689412594, 0.05218559876084328, -0.024499790742993355, -0.013079035095870495, -0.021411709487438202, -0.0500553697347641, 0.008318864740431309, -0.013287005946040154, -0.0675964504480362, 0.010656186379492283, 0.00914489571005106, -0.024461088702082634, 0.04145084694027901, -0.017982082441449165, -0.012307923287153244, 0.03490482270717621, -0.001972018741071224, -0.03331327810883522, -0.0037069765385240316, 0.01322229579091072, -0.004360421560704708, 0.017292646691203117, -0.03176484256982803, 0.04519438371062279, 0.007324907463043928, -0.050371088087558746, 0.03321142494678497, -0.04506714642047882, -0.04884935915470123, -0.011615338735282421, 0.019803188741207123, 0.001937808352522552, -0.024935850873589516, -0.03212805837392807, 0.030685607343912125, -0.012012207880616188, -0.020275428891181946, -0.0017178375273942947, -0.05278696492314339, 0.025800611823797226, -0.01964777708053589, 0.03622788190841675, 0.003092612372711301, -0.007266191765666008, 0.055188193917274475, 0.03835543990135193, -0.039037950336933136, -0.02734002284705639, 0.008206214755773544, -0.04449937865138054, 0.04472297057509422, 0.028053125366568565, 0.009538584388792515, -0.029243621975183487, -0.027956346049904823, -0.001777352998033166, 0.023573031648993492, 0.04129226133227348, -0.035189270973205566, -0.03189164027571678, 0.009815889410674572, 0.023250140249729156, -0.05185498669743538, 0.01956588588654995, 0.002014600671827793, -0.053526464849710464, 0.022901099175214767, 0.0053362175822257996, 0.03398726508021355, 0.02349967509508133, -0.012427553534507751, 0.06074777990579605, 0.0020141468849033117, 0.009649829007685184, -0.032744161784648895, 0.003125768853351474, 0.012017101049423218, -0.04283799231052399, -0.006437651347368956, -0.01094530988484621, 0.00027928443159908056, -0.015071285888552666, -0.026384131982922554, 0.04664122685790062, 0.06359928101301193, -0.0260043703019619, -0.019528454169631004, -0.023730304092168808, -0.018326645717024803, 0.020890086889266968, -0.03792302682995796, -0.044942088425159454, 0.02760225348174572, 0.042220231145620346, 0.027160590514540672, -0.0051314495503902435, -0.07959877699613571, 0.05296143889427185, -0.07830830663442612, 0.01492702029645443, -0.028263410553336143, 0.07722931355237961, -0.013787071220576763, 0.029497336596250534, 0.008400309830904007, -0.02954046055674553, -0.002856910228729248, -0.01622983254492283, -0.05272465944290161, 0.05675031244754791, 0.014411378651857376, 0.0053099896758794785, -0.003593847854062915, -0.02571912668645382, 0.047078169882297516, -0.016703752800822258, 0.049900464713573456, 0.00974071491509676, 0.026503082364797592, -0.04480535537004471, 0.01790168322622776, -0.06331486254930496, -0.001061890972778201, -0.0007353404071182013, 0.029255520552396774, -0.00016207194130402058, -0.02917284145951271, 0.04145676642656326, 0.0015839154366403818, -0.06454810500144958, -0.003474844852462411, 0.011541084386408329, 0.01898561604321003, -0.005228725261986256, 0.04301692545413971, -0.010878430679440498, 0.036417558789253235, -0.0666583701968193, 0.012498501688241959, -0.031129593029618263, 0.05406622216105461, 0.029765751212835312, -0.010718890465795994, -0.03376629576086998, -0.025054700672626495, 0.011294742114841938, -0.00869438610970974, 0.006623605266213417, 0.01682155951857567, -0.018800318241119385, 0.03210423141717911, -0.003483230946585536, -0.06280442327260971, 0.02446526661515236, 0.06622961163520813, 0.0009108532685786486, -0.003909031394869089, -0.028740761801600456, -0.01949722319841385, -0.008731633424758911, 0.0009805932641029358, 0.031172292307019234, 0.0274853203445673, -0.020360298454761505, 0.02615462802350521, 0.022792257368564606, -0.010975442826747894, -0.057443615049123764, -0.0029119751416146755, 0.03981935232877731, 0.04772008955478668, -0.030520420521497726, -0.03778807446360588, -0.003862204262986779, 0.018628938123583794, 0.043944813311100006, 0.03472541272640228, -0.0034554488956928253, -0.07366707175970078, -0.0020082532428205013, 0.0679834634065628, 0.06126554682850838, -0.08073063939809799, 0.010645652189850807, -0.008155228570103645, 0.005375558976083994, 0.03497172147035599, -0.05566396564245224, 0.030009638518095016, -0.05333373695611954, 0.001650822116062045, -0.06795090436935425, 0.005145226139575243, -0.04110249504446983, -0.00020430727454368025, -0.0110595328733325, 0.03306252136826515, -0.035979848355054855, -0.01346089318394661, -0.020130997523665428, 0.004690536297857761, 0.03109010122716427, 0.05067513883113861, -0.06507899612188339, -0.007132503669708967, 0.03167836368083954, 0.013099972158670425, -0.04807380586862564, -0.04792710766196251, 0.00854299496859312, -0.00871971808373928, 0.006064912304282188, 0.03732852265238762, -0.015104062855243683, -0.04142861068248749, 0.0037534981966018677, -0.002390458947047591, -0.01137121208012104, -0.016867371276021004, 0.00170037429779768, 0.028046462684869766, 0.014047457836568356, 0.005192142445594072, 0.02898373454809189, 0.0019272887147963047, 0.008144031278789043, 0.0060781980864703655, 0.0040454985573887825, 0.0432312898337841, -0.018932152539491653, -0.018000410869717598, -0.07002286612987518, -0.013284786604344845, -0.05646998807787895, 0.050720855593681335, -0.0009158686734735966, 0.0511576272547245, -0.014730083756148815, 0.010253826156258583, 0.025880996137857437, 0.04661601036787033, 0.033277302980422974, -0.002312109339982271, -0.008205778896808624, -0.008832607418298721, 0.00973550882190466, -0.04619666934013367, -0.0008037519291974604, 0.013273452408611774, -0.02991199679672718, 0.015349364839494228, -0.01783069223165512, 0.01674710027873516, -0.06907236576080322, -0.009297660551965237, 0.0027293043676763773, -0.013810606673359871, 0.05248613655567169, 0.034707602113485336, 0.027682630345225334, 0.0392279326915741, -0.05463189631700516, -0.010811366140842438, 0.048990339040756226, -0.033981066197156906, -0.003702527144923806, -0.06467057764530182, 0.06367143243551254, 0.00582685973495245, 0.03552115336060524, -0.07926703989505768, -0.0482901968061924, 0.040772564709186554, 0.010509180836379528, -0.013952381908893585, -0.03858494386076927, 0.015931887552142143, 0.026121960952878, -0.00035452013253234327, -0.052542794495821, 0.03603111580014229, 0.005091987084597349, -0.018894074484705925, -0.00032877633930183947, 0.003956038039177656, 0.11991392821073532, 0.03586593642830849, -0.006675579119473696, -0.0051776631735265255, -0.0027192591223865747, -0.040858518332242966, -0.0011930495966225863, 0.018915481865406036, -0.019108638167381287, 0.008757255040109158, -0.03135199472308159, 0.008748617023229599, 0.058106679469347, -0.002010989235714078, -0.01004509162157774, 0.026429809629917145, 0.002153960522264242, -0.0020856326445937157, -0.03821485489606857, 0.015351821668446064, -0.05847540870308876, 0.012437133118510246, -0.016569165512919426, 0.0012017599074169993, -0.012685973197221756, -0.01982375979423523, 0.010710548609495163, 0.028208235278725624, -0.018554044887423515, 0.039849407970905304, 0.01650819554924965, -0.016356652602553368, -0.022874269634485245, -0.03201393410563469, -0.02196425385773182, 0.004450283944606781, 0.014499741606414318, 0.011273151263594627, -0.004535353742539883, 0.022520240396261215, 0.007527390960603952, -0.023332223296165466, -0.0064994231797754765, -0.00031964838854037225, 0.07196489721536636, 0.016067642718553543, 0.026137327775359154, 0.06829635798931122, 0.006976490840315819, 0.02015404962003231, -0.024867068976163864, -0.005100289359688759, -0.012879748828709126, 0.032638728618621826, 0.06627657264471054, -0.010872778482735157, -0.028433356434106827, 0.043518319725990295, 0.02554168552160263, 0.03224808722734451, 0.015212668105959892, 0.0014563628938049078, 0.005223133601248264, -0.028814028948545456, -0.044025056064128876, -0.028233066201210022, 0.04576656222343445, -0.06261306256055832, 0.04104798659682274, -0.04346533492207527, -0.009960775263607502, 0.03718959912657738, 0.017264068126678467, 0.021060632541775703, -0.03984642028808594, -0.021402517333626747, -0.05747217312455177, -0.012182474136352539, -0.0032633678056299686, -0.004905520007014275, 0.018274223431944847, -0.011433632113039494, 0.03396138548851013, 0.03329369053244591, 0.04487594589591026, -0.02660544589161873, -0.04526667296886444, -0.03908863291144371, -0.007130962330847979, -0.021774081513285637, 0.052806250751018524, 0.01703028380870819, -0.04598890244960785, 0.0021474354434758425, -0.020915018394589424, 0.05780570209026337, 0.018242014572024345, 0.018149230629205704, -0.014263576827943325, 0.0873328447341919, 0.012333967722952366, 0.03564222529530525, 0.011350403539836407, -0.0030147265642881393, 0.11132917553186417, 0.04508603736758232, 0.01844918541610241, -0.028903959318995476, 0.04706653580069542, -0.0008985763997770846, 0.024105943739414215, 0.004335347097367048, 0.04034290835261345, 0.02014961466193199, 0.02386293187737465, 0.03829047456383705, 0.010975086130201817, 0.006563012022525072, 0.010112464427947998, 0.03858470544219017, -0.007022440433502197, -0.02770288474857807, 0.020902618765830994, 0.005004796665161848, -0.0012104243505746126, -0.03664540499448776, -0.04719628766179085, 0.022116193547844887, 0.0014738361351191998, -0.0006009110365994275, 0.005713676102459431, -0.019395068287849426, 0.0005869489978067577, 0.008118886500597, -0.001805758336558938, -0.0006194307934492826, 0.010483663529157639, 0.012074064463376999, -0.044294245541095734, -0.012874333187937737, -0.003151064971461892, -0.025208646431565285, 0.034073445945978165, 0.050069812685251236, 0.019935861229896545, 0.005522421095520258, 0.013071823865175247, 0.023328086361289024, -0.039407938718795776, -0.0011942655546590686, -0.021003246307373047, 0.030326778069138527, -0.0017881110543385148, -0.024445153772830963, -0.009938469156622887, -0.0010907757095992565, -0.012637069448828697, -0.06342857331037521, -0.00299832527525723, 0.012165344320237637, 0.020945101976394653, -0.004234863445162773, 0.0010745805921033025, -0.04541437700390816, 0.025316331535577774, -0.026629913598299026, 0.015141556970775127, 0.012571671977639198, -0.022540345788002014, -0.05064361169934273, -0.008061109110713005, 0.06775037199258804, -0.015404830686748028, 0.0021435669623315334, -0.007018378935754299, -0.006197728682309389, -0.031096909195184708, -0.025116922333836555, -0.0071364170871675014, 0.017250990495085716, 0.019039113074541092, -0.010745232924818993, -0.03169751539826393, -0.01083450112491846, -0.03580860048532486, -0.004502367228269577, 0.0035066402051597834, 0.009134958498179913, -0.021635688841342926, 0.02952643670141697, 0.020840361714363098, 0.03167267143726349, 0.04428502917289734, 0.009777459315955639, 0.02432459034025669, 0.0328405536711216, 0.020204082131385803, -0.040138907730579376, -0.02316294237971306, -0.016482384875416756, -0.02116437256336212, 0.004323513712733984, -0.04918446019291878, 0.059117287397384644, 0.018421193584799767, 0.011538974940776825, -0.0006668390706181526, 0.01278593298047781, 0.00022410956444218755, 0.025920918211340904, 0.02600914239883423, -0.02765626646578312, -0.0016151837771758437, 0.019198665395379066, 0.009697049856185913, -0.017814666032791138, -0.04430549964308739, -0.0410270057618618, 0.011555034667253494, -0.01947413943707943, -0.013802650384604931, -0.005838877055794001, -0.0019640580285340548, -0.036849670112133026, -0.0062391445972025394, -0.032831210643053055, 0.008677839301526546, -0.02705814503133297, 0.035820044577121735, -0.036285072565078735, 0.03615909442305565, -0.036270834505558014, 0.016670450568199158, 0.002825995674356818, -0.012022186070680618, 0.02199580706655979, -0.020924458280205727, 0.023391321301460266, -0.03638496622443199, 0.013186992146074772, -0.001314993598498404, 0.028381090611219406, -0.027227655053138733, -0.0077064186334609985, 0.04211944341659546, -0.04890143871307373, -0.05692971497774124, -0.004421877209097147, -0.01425006054341793, 0.026604142040014267, 0.0007450553821399808, 0.01616530492901802, -0.0011378219351172447, 0.06411032378673553, -0.022972289472818375, -0.029381992295384407, -0.03810250386595726, -0.030872613191604614, 0.011794834397733212, -0.010792586021125317, 0.034885842353105545, -0.0036572213284671307, -0.012365572154521942, 0.03898205608129501, 0.001923428033478558, -0.0022033830173313618, -0.005488052498549223, -0.016241559758782387, 0.013543805107474327, 0.018158884719014168, -0.00300980475731194, -0.03900713846087456, 0.038689740002155304, 0.06974311172962189, -0.004877516534179449, 0.007292603608220816, -0.051990337669849396, 0.009397679008543491, -0.06166427209973335, -0.012883446179330349, 0.006163837853819132, -0.000057110097259283066, 0.04503624886274338, -0.0356353260576725, 0.018390411511063576, 0.01152019016444683, -0.04441770538687706, 0.030816297978162766, -0.02501935511827469, -0.027081752195954323, -0.035140275955200195, 0.038621097803115845, -0.018021326512098312, -0.01053454540669918, 0.01946699246764183, -0.0037825889885425568, 0.04786219820380211, 0.010818098671734333, 0.0083242729306221, 0.011737127788364887, -0.01803157664835453, 0.02200513705611229, 0.005253170151263475, -0.049234092235565186, -0.0019947774708271027, -0.024216098710894585, -0.048941075801849365, 0.03204068914055824, -0.03303585574030876, 0.022560838609933853, -0.00016443773347418755, 0.021201562136411667, -0.031125621870160103, 0.0682288408279419, 0.027350692078471184, 0.00014735203876625746, 0.005532676819711924, 0.009333737194538116, -0.0007713398663327098, -0.005388881545513868, 0.000263384950812906, 0.037603359669446945, 0.044590845704078674, -0.01947649009525776, -0.00011308435205137357, -0.006127930246293545, 0.0016350715886801481, -0.0332937054336071, -0.0031812952365726233, 0.021637819707393646, 0.030282525345683098, 0.006180885713547468, 0.023034704849123955, -0.0018978877924382687, -0.006658296100795269, 0.015313119627535343, -0.0027917951811105013, -0.0024345992133021355, -0.020329590886831284, -0.009433818981051445, -0.001012588618323207, -0.021588876843452454, 0.008769884705543518, -0.011667851358652115, -0.04360828921198845, -0.024091454222798347, 0.037527039647102356, -0.006336600054055452, -0.03336039558053017, -0.05514683574438095, -0.004099187906831503, 0.04868818074464798, -0.006798557937145233, 0.010944617912173271, 0.02214592695236206, -0.00002744101766438689, 0.02593899518251419, -0.05199206620454788, 0.07290723919868469, 0.006399832665920258, -0.00008463154517812654, -0.0492866113781929, -0.010976946912705898, -0.022551096975803375, 0.04352748766541481, 0.05939292907714844, 0.011372302658855915, 0.005716854706406593, -0.03491029515862465, -0.007906727492809296, 0.019167741760611534, -0.06504948437213898, 0.015961620956659317, -0.04627423360943794, -0.03897920623421669, -0.010932376608252525, -0.023990988731384277, 0.0011791884899139404, 0.0050026788376271725, -0.0076160128228366375, 0.0021347443107515574, -0.002850149292498827, -0.012597170658409595, -0.007067353930324316, 0.02787937968969345, 0.006140382494777441, -0.016734616830945015, 0.031486496329307556, -0.040431585162878036, 0.04620158672332764, -0.0068243625573813915, 0.009343246929347515, -0.02985510230064392, 0.02253219112753868, -0.025106307119131088, -0.02386285923421383, -0.0038490102160722017, -0.00048575838445685804, 0.012356588616967201, -0.06374747306108475, 0.005870474968105555, 0.025782134383916855, -0.050872594118118286, -0.0026555585209280252, 0.01786835677921772, 0.0579330213367939, 0.010884176939725876, -0.027128465473651886, 0.024629732593894005, -0.0030533273238688707, 0.02050311677157879, -0.027804654091596603, 0.021937930956482887, 0.0028195001650601625, 0.031323883682489395, 0.015987306833267212, 0.027897609397768974, -0.014602555893361568, 0.0060329739935696125, 0.009365148842334747, 0.05096914619207382, -0.007616519462317228, -0.012033781968057156, -0.012015869840979576, -0.016254659742116928, -0.04213431105017662, 0.007376599125564098, -0.029699871316552162, 0.037039726972579956, -0.0504026934504509, 0.01975366845726967, -0.05808552727103233, -0.04469607397913933, -0.0016361813759431243, -0.01943153701722622, -0.03627753630280495, 0.03655492514371872, -0.01090626884251833, 0.01627402752637863, 0.0009862266015261412, 0.006806741002947092, 0.05459866672754288, -0.052734375, 0.053928956389427185, -0.049707282334566116, 0.00458416948094964, -0.013473876751959324, 0.006906166672706604, -0.06217144802212715, -0.010868074372410774, 0.042006127536296844, 0.018634388223290443, 0.017017193138599396, -0.016228437423706055, -0.03583488613367081, 0.02427666075527668, 0.043218955397605896, -0.011578159406781197, -0.024969052523374557, -0.05919792130589485, -0.01088100578635931, -0.04361582174897194, -0.02452494576573372 ]
<p>I am using a standard version of logistic regression to fit my input variables to binary output variables.</p> <p>However in my problem, the negative outputs (0s) far outnumber the positive outputs (1s). The ratio is 20:1. So when I train a classifier, it seems that even features that strongly suggest the possibility of a positive output still have very low (highly negative) values for their corresponding parameters. It seems to me that this happens because there are just too many negative examples pulling the parameters in their direction.</p> <p>So I am wondering if I can add weights (say using 20 instead of 1) for the positive examples. Is this likely to benefit at all? And if so, how should I add the weights (in the equations below).</p> <p>The cost function looks like the following: $$J = (-1 / m) \cdot\sum_{i=1}^{m} y\cdot\log(h(x\cdot\theta)) + (1-y)(1 - \log(h(x\cdot\theta)))$$</p> <p>The gradient of this cost function (wrt $\theta$) is:</p> <p>$$\mathrm{grad} = ((h(x\cdot\theta) - y)' \cdot X)'$$</p> <p>Here $m$ = number of test cases, $x$ = feature matrix, $y$ = output vector, $h$=sigmoid function, $\theta$ = parameters we are trying to learn.</p> <p>Finally I run the gradient descent to find the lowest $J$ possible. The implementation seems to run correctly.</p>
37,158
[ -0.03829329088330269, -0.025947431102395058, 0.009681413881480694, 0.013534044846892357, 0.018907202407717705, 0.02109670825302601, -0.031133810058236122, 0.02341737598180771, 0.04585991054773331, -0.023754414170980453, 0.015389233827590942, 0.05544280633330345, 0.04186216741800308, 0.02653558738529682, 0.03700457885861397, -0.01084911823272705, -0.04417409747838974, -0.022132370620965958, 0.017214076593518257, 0.002009335206821561, 0.031083647161722183, 0.06990521401166916, 0.05548682063817978, 0.028785239905118942, -0.018915193155407906, 0.02371172234416008, 0.01896434649825096, -0.008762406185269356, 0.03120587207376957, 0.07989471405744553, -0.0012415196979418397, -0.004565827082842588, -0.01629001647233963, 0.04750928282737732, 0.016616828739643097, -0.008705503307282925, -0.026194781064987183, -0.012579040601849556, -0.032777901738882065, -0.005704178940504789, -0.018433570861816406, -0.029407940804958344, 0.019530009478330612, 0.03710625693202019, -0.01607060246169567, -0.0018134396523237228, 0.01836843602359295, -0.03821584954857826, 0.04167701303958893, -0.051934368908405304, 0.07659784704446793, 0.017691347748041153, 0.016073500737547874, 0.046466290950775146, 0.007781337480992079, -0.015402323566377163, 0.05131838470697403, 0.09801438450813293, 0.0004638914542738348, -0.046836499124765396, -0.011634323745965958, -0.054361481219530106, 0.006820776499807835, -0.019465787336230278, -0.0022513524163514376, 0.04862838611006737, -0.006283157970756292, -0.031334176659584045, 0.02728801779448986, -0.020535988733172417, 0.03176093474030495, 0.026551051065325737, 0.022558145225048065, 0.013620415702462196, 0.011421005241572857, -0.030446819961071014, 0.0008526028250344098, 0.0521320104598999, 0.02190976031124592, 0.010602268390357494, 0.016268813982605934, 0.017436601221561432, 0.02561301365494728, 0.07808586210012436, -0.003140813671052456, 0.0026355164591223, 0.07917910814285278, -0.034876465797424316, 0.055385522544384, 0.015640806406736374, -0.024144310504198074, 0.023963378742337227, 0.03341080620884895, 0.004580752924084663, -0.027939695864915848, 0.023310109972953796, -0.03536900132894516, 0.020964916795492172, 0.056584637612104416, -0.007539205253124237, -0.02891455963253975, -0.0491638220846653, -0.024053847417235374, 0.05061374604701996, -0.04571583494544029, 0.018295779824256897, -0.013001536019146442, -0.007346044294536114, 0.018251534551382065, -0.054879214614629745, 0.0051464419811964035, 0.006350844167172909, 0.00488248048350215, -0.03588632866740227, -0.03009718470275402, -0.04295573756098747, -0.020249392837285995, -0.04120498150587082, 0.01420102920383215, 0.031678248196840286, 0.036735229194164276, -0.009080382063984871, 0.03341135010123253, -0.017915835604071617, -0.041063860058784485, 0.04377168416976929, 0.008737125433981419, -0.022204197943210602, -0.056005652993917465, 0.017947642132639885, 0.0190972201526165, -0.019741471856832504, 0.04779534414410591, 0.010364310815930367, 0.028555843979120255, -0.008112413808703423, -0.07789400219917297, -0.05956364795565605, 0.011982780881226063, -0.03861377760767937, 0.02629072219133377, -0.024750664830207825, -0.003556077368557453, 0.04557441920042038, 0.021992547437548637, 0.04260917007923126, 0.033923324197530746, 0.0312928780913353, 0.014689039438962936, 0.02969357557594776, 0.00549526559188962, 0.01065401267260313, -0.07341695576906204, -0.02761569805443287, -0.04358034208416939, -0.07035765796899796, 0.021054977551102638, 0.017551803961396217, -0.011958977207541466, -0.024040862917900085, 0.027822887524962425, 0.009509051218628883, -0.011460503563284874, 0.004235711880028248, -0.0404457226395607, -0.030770642682909966, 0.07968617230653763, 0.02191292680799961, 0.034550730139017105, 0.020586667582392693, 0.018935665488243103, -0.010818392969667912, 0.014058861881494522, 0.026786986738443375, 0.02067733369767666, -0.02770184725522995, -0.024099554866552353, -0.05210992321372032, 0.021271366626024246, 0.013294275850057602, -0.0021760279778391123, -0.06099458411335945, -0.03354937583208084, 0.017703495919704437, 0.007624482270330191, 0.027466880157589912, 0.012064509093761444, -0.024731766432523727, 0.04181816801428795, -0.013909372501075268, -0.03264560550451279, -0.03656396642327309, 0.0005591245135292411, 0.0006819761474616826, -0.005115294363349676, 0.035638440400362015, -0.004136151634156704, 0.044024765491485596, -0.010795259848237038, 0.0026829426642507315, -0.0264617707580328, -0.010044420138001442, 0.043574877083301544, -0.024520093575119972, 0.010234386660158634, 0.0373009592294693, 0.01176618691533804, -0.029231004416942596, 0.08632742613554001, -0.07443279027938843, -0.0507088378071785, 0.021397065371274948, -0.0023410029243677855, 0.003064695280045271, 0.010308431461453438, -0.020381350070238113, 0.017169637605547905, -0.01326785795390606, -0.01443729642778635, 0.020801857113838196, -0.07311220467090607, 0.08628279715776443, 0.08498742431402206, 0.014140593819320202, 0.002730404259636998, 0.02396703138947487, 0.0017155169043689966, 0.022237084805965424, -0.05120500549674034, 0.00966097041964531, -0.03428613394498825, 0.011471902951598167, 0.03467753157019615, 0.039361461997032166, -0.03382188454270363, 0.0027366005815565586, 0.0648934617638588, 0.017713503912091255, 0.022045951336622238, 0.012494401074945927, -0.00735543854534626, 0.021726297214627266, 0.024752793833613396, 0.026253722608089447, -0.009234443306922913, 0.0017879022052511573, 0.003938746638596058, 0.00863440241664648, 0.01593094877898693, 0.007898435927927494, -0.020229743793606758, 0.020438533276319504, -0.019821207970380783, -0.0013844133354723454, -0.039221134036779404, -0.0022676121443510056, 0.04130641743540764, -0.05667810142040253, 0.010846305638551712, 0.05375252291560173, -0.008549927733838558, -0.012632803060114384, -0.010017222724854946, -0.02015235833823681, -0.0005825759726576507, 0.05253710597753525, -0.015185450203716755, 0.042754363268613815, 0.024106111377477646, -0.06769120693206787, 0.019104672595858574, -0.005441502667963505, -0.015965845435857773, -0.04058953747153282, 0.052991390228271484, 0.03347988799214363, 0.00873357430100441, 0.003604837693274021, -0.023858387023210526, -0.047244004905223846, 0.005357950925827026, -0.01888085901737213, 0.016704687848687172, 0.007063914556056261, -0.02505580708384514, -0.015491212718188763, -0.054935604333877563, -0.01005353033542633, 0.053549107164144516, -0.02139926701784134, -0.018436172977089882, -0.023414969444274902, -0.0347273126244545, -0.010857045650482178, -0.05013455078005791, -0.03165454417467117, 0.012216828763484955, 0.004812249448150396, -0.032142870128154755, 0.04243232309818268, 0.010816158726811409, -0.049553342163562775, 0.015358969569206238, -0.05697830021381378, -0.04738781228661537, -0.057531196624040604, 0.009497905150055885, 0.006319455336779356, -0.008966505527496338, 0.0004375963762868196, 0.037561461329460144, -0.017865557223558426, -0.003957462962716818, -0.0837872102856636, -0.045737311244010925, 0.0036433017812669277, 0.005916242487728596, 0.010571063496172428, 0.016514413058757782, 0.0007670011837035418, 0.06803831458091736, 0.07441916316747665, -0.01938560977578163, -0.049267906695604324, 0.014921759255230427, -0.02829602174460888, -0.03294096887111664, 0.015841305255889893, 0.01381536666303873, 0.0432930588722229, 0.04845631495118141, -0.007620675954967737, 0.004809616133570671, 0.04394182935357094, -0.00758438091725111, -0.027377134189009666, 0.018686633557081223, -0.015163259580731392, -0.022874105721712112, 0.04135783761739731, 0.029867077246308327, 0.00015734427142888308, 0.02309858240187168, -0.0020937868393957615, 0.033135946840047836, -0.014229565858840942, -0.016132976859807968, 0.00960218720138073, -0.015621600672602654, 0.03662765026092529, -0.005442270543426275, 0.000808294047601521, 0.0006154633592814207, -0.01174209825694561, -0.029880190268158913, 0.01098576933145523, 0.0362282358109951, -0.05192708224058151, -0.006012864410877228, 0.03303555026650429, 0.01605539582669735, -0.014282072894275188, -0.01849338412284851, 0.014633236452937126, 0.0025729506742209196, 0.002680538222193718, -0.0050869351252913475, -0.009593556635081768, 0.025472227483987808, 0.019766442477703094, -0.015396345406770706, 0.006859796121716499, -0.04576379805803299, 0.003947095014154911, -0.06162724643945694, -0.02775350771844387, -0.005807334557175636, 0.07001470029354095, 0.021472517400979996, 0.0015111129032447934, -0.009155198000371456, -0.011082567274570465, 0.03239522874355316, -0.008485606871545315, -0.0952271968126297, 0.04517713561654091, 0.00804657768458128, 0.0011201296001672745, 0.027430474758148193, -0.02050882577896118, 0.010672156699001789, -0.06193538382649422, -0.0036553621757775545, 0.008256318047642708, 0.03126091510057449, -0.021381137892603874, 0.02992985025048256, -0.0024421564303338528, 0.0016509726410731673, -0.013028894551098347, 0.00875176303088665, 0.015937374904751778, -0.01565655879676342, -0.022165918722748756, 0.01070459745824337, -0.00379126681946218, 0.01649956777691841, -0.04080936312675476, 0.016086895018815994, 0.013511820696294308, 0.062374476343393326, -0.003941357135772705, 0.04932495579123497, -0.043352141976356506, 0.04706666246056557, -0.0077354335226118565, 0.03551893308758736, 0.030024508014321327, -0.01652619056403637, -0.0007068136474117637, -0.05245918035507202, -0.05616199970245361, 0.03711766004562378, 0.019996488466858864, 0.011976311914622784, 0.01230582594871521, 0.06410008668899536, 0.016337480396032333, -0.03411490470170975, -0.016790885478258133, 0.07076305150985718, 0.012154098600149155, -0.0032548520248383284, -0.025926044210791588, -0.008118378929793835, -0.038695819675922394, 0.02163504995405674, -0.0007514502503909171, 0.003852273104712367, -0.03118893876671791, -0.011925925500690937, 0.02495500259101391, 0.0026734666898846626, 0.01626051776111126, 0.01183380652219057, 0.04775623232126236, 0.04624657332897186, -0.01082577183842659, -0.02202649600803852, 0.02439897507429123, 0.05858271196484566, 0.025176387280225754, 0.0024013989605009556, 0.018786389380693436, -0.09879734367132187, -0.01661781780421734, 0.03370006009936333, 0.051180340349674225, -0.008899528533220291, 0.009258400648832321, -0.025612827390432358, -0.04734678938984871, 0.03729100525379181, -0.03154486417770386, 0.04666877165436745, -0.011005277745425701, 0.011245625093579292, -0.012487339787185192, -0.022906234487891197, -0.05015498027205467, 0.029607102274894714, -0.021583454683423042, 0.054659660905599594, -0.010122708044946194, -0.02992507815361023, -0.04294072464108467, 0.042357657104730606, -0.002753850305452943, 0.07289039343595505, -0.03310230001807213, -0.047188952565193176, 0.019421545788645744, 0.03259855881333351, 0.01663828082382679, -0.09014753252267838, -0.019829820841550827, 0.02027229592204094, -0.04677074775099754, 0.013805949129164219, -0.029573874548077583, -0.03685702010989189, 0.026928888633847237, 0.014147112146019936, -0.033638883382081985, -0.015581845305860043, -0.039229460060596466, 0.008554867468774319, 0.017799146473407745, 0.011582883074879646, 0.022737832739949226, 0.018082695081830025, -0.018035873770713806, 0.02233504131436348, -0.029563715681433678, 0.0029313266277313232, -0.013432829640805721, -0.029620695859193802, -0.028007397428154945, 0.0022103178780525923, 0.02342040278017521, 0.046617552638053894, 0.01523994654417038, 0.04534486308693886, -0.01230004895478487, -0.0010389158269390464, -0.020298151299357414, 0.020454851910471916, -0.020573792979121208, -0.0363653190433979, 0.037621211260557175, 0.04488299787044525, -0.006662491708993912, 0.014331130310893059, 0.021535564213991165, -0.030418187379837036, -0.00026129267644137144, 0.04699641838669777, -0.05653250962495804, -0.03696021810173988, -0.02185698412358761, 0.001745156361721456, 0.008619140833616257, -0.018876241520047188, 0.03303006291389465, 0.003920569084584713, 0.010426745750010014, -0.020460795611143112, -0.03383760526776314, 0.014198895543813705, -0.026260191574692726, -0.01850777305662632, -0.0009681591182015836, -0.04310258477926254, -0.010383675806224346, -0.002380679128691554, -0.0013995995977893472, -0.060325175523757935, -0.0074147251434624195, -0.029471101239323616, 0.008326921612024307, -0.04679987579584122, -0.01807720772922039, -0.007813350297510624, 0.003346100216731429, -0.03258166089653969, -0.0203388761729002, 0.0685124471783638, -0.020436713472008705, -0.010831650346517563, -0.00010993934847647324, -0.0032525351271033287, 0.08106415718793869, 0.009739411994814873, -0.026905782520771027, 0.03509851545095444, -0.021232975646853447, -0.020335327833890915, 0.009704427793622017, -0.016629233956336975, -0.04503701999783516, -0.020935704931616783, 0.006519836373627186, 0.0094687445089221, -0.0059518334455788136, -0.005946708377450705, -0.016734551638364792, 0.014803686179220676, 0.0008061008411459625, -0.003619797993451357, -0.03345560282468796, 0.03710870444774628, 0.002617300022393465, -0.021299997344613075, -0.010344267822802067, -0.007987611927092075, -0.02540564350783825, -0.00982065498828888, 0.04910474270582199, 0.008864449337124825, 0.0007647302700206637, -0.013299700804054737, 0.06521662324666977, 0.0002623467880766839, -0.013853493146598339, 0.007462504785507917, -0.05762491002678871, 0.07648799568414688, 0.024373382329940796, 0.04472891613841057, -0.002194550121203065, 0.05751022323966026, -0.02562068961560726, -0.022398902103304863, -0.06108921021223068, 0.005403256043791771, 0.06899482756853104, 0.012117350473999977, 0.056593529880046844, 0.004012885503470898, -0.011542865075170994, -0.000641666236333549, -0.02270384132862091, -0.052317120134830475, -0.009547138586640358, -0.0003409913624636829, 0.04221542552113533, 0.027369700372219086, -0.009527524933218956, 0.02214175835251808, -0.012708229944109917, 0.022603178396821022, 0.0254617091268301, -0.03252347931265831, 0.017416130751371384, 0.040706515312194824, -0.014843229204416275, -0.039445098489522934, 0.028171831741929054, -0.045335136353969574, 0.02360730618238449, -0.02381395362317562, -0.0426480732858181, 0.05000727251172066, 0.02284342050552368, 0.04324285686016083, -0.05709026753902435, -0.019236212596297264, -0.017694387584924698, 0.015476411208510399, 0.011706321500241756, -0.008519667200744152, 0.013741716742515564, 0.01667848415672779, -0.015759272500872612, 0.016467135399580002, 0.0247817225754261, -0.02239578776061535, -0.0926145538687706, -0.04270007088780403, -0.025109564885497093, -0.014129896648228168, 0.01621946692466736, 0.035607755184173584, -0.02152824215590954, 0.024961883202195168, -0.016585471108555794, 0.032105617225170135, -0.01910100318491459, 0.030714401975274086, 0.004039339255541563, 0.02969207428395748, 0.007116443943232298, 0.001165690366178751, 0.034995876252651215, 0.0011306331725791097, 0.12966535985469818, 0.09634871035814285, 0.04452241584658623, -0.06540870666503906, 0.004954138770699501, -0.013911749236285686, -0.013116100803017616, -0.027436044067144394, 0.03503991290926933, 0.006851895246654749, 0.007162846624851227, 0.032477010041475296, -0.0036869870964437723, 0.014299944043159485, -0.014720904640853405, 0.05437606945633888, -0.06038506329059601, -0.02766585722565651, 0.011043116450309753, 0.02028835192322731, -0.004885006695985794, 0.0013423593482002616, -0.022733541205525398, 0.0189958568662405, -0.011249522678554058, -0.021508747711777687, -0.004398270510137081, -0.015297709964215755, 0.012994501739740372, 0.0007873571594245732, -0.02957063913345337, -0.0003079863381572068, 0.016875775530934334, -0.0035191753413528204, 0.031893935054540634, 0.0011232715332880616, -0.0019450244726613164, -0.00782754272222519, -0.007414389867335558, 0.02043350227177143, 0.02543814852833748, 0.016716578975319862, -0.009166914969682693, -0.008238849230110645, -0.030940456315875053, -0.003899643663316965, -0.050499700009822845, 0.05516904592514038, 0.003228436689823866, 0.020979780703783035, 0.011709134094417095, -0.011073512025177479, -0.008760168217122555, -0.06604965031147003, -0.021562663838267326, 0.004312025848776102, 0.04992281645536423, 0.003336037741973996, -0.031106077134609222, -0.016564873978495598, 0.048263292759656906, 0.016590924933552742, 0.02803778275847435, 0.05212731659412384, -0.040993813425302505, -0.01134683657437563, -0.011840063147246838, 0.05139743909239769, 0.00798590388149023, 0.0017219682922586799, -0.025627803057432175, -0.03796137869358063, -0.03196953237056732, -0.012783118523657322, -0.013802965171635151, -0.019147532060742378, 0.03333934396505356, -0.006761437281966209, -0.04134067893028259, -0.024909475818276405, -0.04274890571832657, 0.006202567834407091, 0.023221846669912338, 0.002877776976674795, -0.03550056740641594, -0.013034239411354065, 0.0016578191425651312, 0.042045190930366516, 0.0374319851398468, -0.010686628520488739, 0.022727880626916885, 0.05348724126815796, -0.020609576255083084, -0.028619980439543724, -0.03478030860424042, 0.01090938225388527, -0.04222353175282478, 0.00646635890007019, 0.021417411044239998, 0.05880328640341759, 0.0031743370927870274, 0.0329800583422184, -0.01637606881558895, 0.04690491035580635, -0.005096296779811382, 0.010178899392485619, 0.008761106990277767, -0.028827669098973274, -0.0005112587823532522, -0.016650427132844925, -0.0035157455131411552, -0.02320675365626812, -0.03223924711346626, -0.046212248504161835, -0.02378564327955246, 0.025757959112524986, 0.01652977429330349, -0.03200947865843773, -0.00016221044643316418, -0.01308257132768631, 0.037513960152864456, -0.01697513647377491, 0.012981152161955833, -0.03149181604385376, 0.011649387888610363, -0.029231294989585876, -0.034422263503074646, 0.017858073115348816, 0.0027550524100661278, -0.020498977974057198, -0.00552681740373373, 0.034867241978645325, 0.03970570117235184, 0.04251046106219292, -0.010768095962703228, 0.019708197563886642, 0.016209838911890984, 0.03813334181904793, -0.025280164554715157, -0.014246360398828983, 0.01662263460457325, -0.028967751190066338, -0.013528674840927124, 0.038634493947029114, -0.021629715338349342, 0.02735123410820961, 0.010871848091483116, -0.026673821732401848, -0.05177491530776024, 0.024220550432801247, 0.021045012399554253, -0.0010424635838717222, 0.012164315208792686, 0.012416745536029339, -0.03208435699343681, 0.011420529335737228, 0.013249384239315987, 0.005334201734513044, 0.01901140995323658, -0.014855011366307735, 0.012066779658198357, 0.007892945781350136, -0.020128851756453514, -0.0019374352414160967, 0.006153162103146315, 0.04346415027976036, -0.006488662678748369, -0.022804202511906624, 0.026603566482663155, -0.009280308149755001, -0.03494960814714432, 0.029697706922888756, 0.004168913699686527, 0.02122112549841404, -0.09803181886672974, 0.0017660222947597504, 0.014683847315609455, -0.005824928637593985, 0.027172958478331566, -0.09129834175109863, 0.011497377417981625, -0.00009450835204916075, -0.017461556941270828, 0.02402486279606819, -0.020177606493234634, -0.03908994793891907, -0.02093205228447914, -0.016065320000052452, 0.009570465423166752, -0.015401870012283325, -0.005298976320773363, 0.031014883890748024, 0.03164803609251976, 0.013122385367751122, -0.0073191458359360695, -0.03818449005484581, -0.027102258056402206, 0.014440356753766537, -0.0308089479804039, -0.0181098822504282, 0.043831534683704376, -0.02821626141667366, -0.06990306079387665, 0.041075192391872406, -0.01096426136791706, -0.021530654281377792, 0.02332279458642006, 0.06589775532484055, 0.014703103341162205, 0.056119292974472046, 0.05182035267353058, -0.02288893051445484, 0.008181039243936539, 0.021129915490746498, 0.0058106426149606705, 0.0037102492060512304, -0.038378097116947174, 0.038317855447530746, 0.03352551907300949, 0.005996010731905699, -0.04030219465494156, 0.012439414858818054, -0.010310339741408825, -0.015182810835540295, -0.027931412681937218, -0.016505230218172073, 0.029784249141812325, -0.05657944083213806, 0.02246297523379326, -0.02824435569345951, 0.01287208404392004, 0.016846809536218643, 0.01449115201830864, -0.0289468914270401, -0.0031449999660253525, -0.006761380471289158, -0.04993342608213425, -0.02380777895450592, -0.009291932918131351, -0.02519523911178112, -0.03969160094857216, 0.014675128273665905, 0.019832711666822433, -0.008905351161956787, -0.021812042221426964, -0.0087563656270504, -0.05316327139735222, 0.0737810879945755, -0.047912925481796265, 0.03872343525290489, 0.04065321758389473, -0.029865752905607224, 0.021228188648819923, -0.10001193732023239, 0.03585762158036232, 0.007581739220768213, 0.0066026863642036915, 0.01882115751504898, 0.0018001715652644634, -0.020163001492619514, -0.018474722281098366, 0.07586324214935303, -0.021240998059511185, 0.0017672489630058408, -0.0008806072873994708, 0.02391870506107807, -0.0038554402999579906, -0.020227255299687386, 0.03249315544962883, -0.01487464364618063, -0.031184207648038864, -0.004681705962866545, -0.02259722910821438, 0.002180500188842416, -0.005741101689636707, 0.006412185728549957, -0.01654067263007164, -0.03607872873544693, -0.008217880502343178, -0.015427124686539173, 0.030190980061888695, -0.02328050322830677, 0.02963665872812271, 0.05716640129685402, 0.013086476363241673, 0.02558796852827072, -0.010599811561405659, -0.012790202163159847, -0.07682031393051147, 0.02791927382349968, 0.0007678520632907748, -0.027118902653455734, 0.03280394524335861, 0.016253996640443802, 0.04206738620996475, -0.03333165869116783, -0.013690445572137833, 0.0438135601580143, -0.009209204465150833, 0.004295866470783949, 0.02353854477405548, 0.01915804296731949, 0.015230629593133926, -0.01205355767160654, 0.015221254900097847, 0.01027306355535984, 0.007447626907378435, -0.006356782279908657, 0.034643884748220444, 0.006783602759242058, -0.010941821150481701, 0.022190742194652557, 0.0050427899695932865, -0.021715227514505386, 0.05457835644483566, 0.021669289097189903, 0.016208108514547348, -0.020921869203448296, 0.010843591764569283, 0.004113946575671434, 0.0006191032007336617, -0.007657896727323532, -0.05332888290286064, -0.009160907939076424, 0.05841169133782387, -0.03467566519975662, -0.011162864975631237, -0.059608761221170425, -0.03741074353456497, -0.0005398434004746377, -0.002247217809781432, -0.014925530180335045, 0.07190457731485367, 0.02280534990131855, -0.023401577025651932, 0.029575001448392868, -0.05045207962393761, 0.007157423067837954, -0.01258446741849184, 0.02725863829255104, -0.011494302190840244, 0.01083984225988388, 0.03369850665330887, -0.026442673057317734, -0.029191482812166214, -0.025621574372053146, -0.00402899831533432, 0.03612983971834183, 0.05244810879230499, -0.017896059900522232, -0.03916804865002632, -0.002883878769353032, 0.0096009885892272, -0.02428952418267727, -0.004820019938051701, -0.021747780963778496, -0.004322352819144726, 0.009820341132581234, -0.06294862180948257 ]
<ol> <li><p>If the items to be "summed" or combined to create an overall index are collectively the underlying construct (i.e. I am trying to measure compliance to an intervention which has different components), wouldn't combining all the components for IRT violate the assumption of unidimensionality since they represent the intervention itself? If so, do you have a reference for this?</p></li> <li><p>Are there any good references that say if Likert scores are summed into a scale and the Cronbach's alpha is relatively high (~0.8), this is appropriate to use as an index?</p></li> <li><p>Are there any other tests of validity I should do other than Cronbach's alpha if all I have done is sum the responses?</p></li> </ol> <p>Thanks in advance, any advice is appreciated!</p>
74,320
[ -0.021433930844068527, 0.005884901620447636, -0.01411331444978714, 0.01181531511247158, 0.05458443984389305, 0.002955632284283638, -0.029925014823675156, -0.06447086483240128, 0.02552628144621849, 0.00034374441020190716, 0.04933610185980797, -0.0256227757781744, 0.04659644886851311, 0.02320520021021366, -0.013155658729374409, -0.009036089293658733, -0.00980424415320158, -0.01037459447979927, 0.01251410972326994, -0.013792077079415321, -0.01052938960492611, 0.018203409388661385, -0.020238710567355156, -0.015938013792037964, 0.0043057831935584545, 0.07895037531852722, 0.01781938225030899, -0.0566072016954422, 0.026234112679958344, 0.03353535011410713, -0.05720476433634758, -0.010603788308799267, 0.017947277054190636, 0.029005631804466248, 0.02102506347000599, 0.007837997749447823, -0.012857958674430847, 0.02237424999475479, -0.023926639929413795, 0.051477134227752686, -0.001561368117108941, -0.030179258435964584, -0.04572279006242752, 0.03209559619426727, -0.013814653269946575, 0.02167578600347042, -0.03460320085287094, 0.002256933832541108, 0.0010123469401150942, -0.027800865471363068, 0.0632365345954895, 0.03078516013920307, 0.013755402527749538, 0.019251428544521332, -0.028546493500471115, 0.00031195557676255703, 0.0464276447892189, 0.062355026602745056, 0.04496968910098076, -0.031069627031683922, -0.01182720810174942, -0.003885141806676984, 0.017149513587355614, -0.038701996207237244, -0.036272406578063965, 0.07668112218379974, 0.048869721591472626, -0.003851663786917925, 0.06003435328602791, -0.019031625241041183, -0.010503987781703472, 0.03053862974047661, 0.016689304262399673, -0.025303639471530914, 0.015902355313301086, -0.036911964416503906, -0.011165555566549301, 0.020461978390812874, 0.04232830926775932, 0.02849748730659485, -0.0023807098623365164, 0.021501854062080383, 0.033802781254053116, 0.038804370909929276, 0.03865057975053787, 0.0005342182703316212, 0.07389993220567703, -0.0031778744887560606, 0.016431421041488647, -0.0015061839949339628, -0.010733367875218391, 0.011816508136689663, 0.003906435798853636, 0.03114529326558113, -0.019264640286564827, 0.04621018469333649, -0.040665194392204285, 0.04115935042500496, 0.0055373781360685825, 0.026109980419278145, -0.019821498543024063, -0.007153625134378672, 0.008700103498995304, 0.07266052067279816, 0.008297228254377842, 0.005470210686326027, -0.030278800055384636, 0.002150405663996935, 0.005525308661162853, -0.02848607487976551, 0.01223062165081501, -0.0012736732605844736, -0.008961144834756851, 0.013102199882268906, 0.023229552432894707, 0.016187749803066254, -0.017363712191581726, 0.004550230223685503, 0.043669313192367554, 0.039150748401880264, 0.020442567765712738, -0.03797038272023201, 0.010470487177371979, -0.023488983511924744, -0.06628382951021194, 0.0505429245531559, -0.0044500925578176975, 0.0015886765904724598, -0.029137838631868362, 0.051540154963731766, 0.029874807223677635, -0.04103734716773033, -0.00048104673624038696, 0.02703503519296646, -0.002734690671786666, -0.01975252665579319, -0.06532832980155945, -0.07504325360059738, 0.016946667805314064, -0.0043474952690303326, -0.013440593145787716, -0.039537474513053894, 0.01617366075515747, 0.028927231207489967, 0.03656928613781929, -0.031084677204489708, 0.04643751308321953, 0.022471800446510315, 0.0021801728289574385, 0.044886089861392975, -0.04365848749876022, -0.05968191474676132, -0.019532879814505577, -0.03228570520877838, 0.011687072925269604, -0.0903002917766571, 0.011255956254899502, 0.0318189300596714, -0.015343762002885342, 0.01836060732603073, 0.038091521710157394, 0.018799029290676117, 0.007245608139783144, 0.008865546435117722, 0.019947418943047523, -0.0071279448457062244, 0.04249877482652664, -0.009411872364580631, 0.011374571360647678, 0.008610495366156101, 0.012935456819832325, 0.005958068650215864, 0.007536953780800104, 0.03644305840134621, 0.03851819783449173, -0.013930138200521469, -0.012758512981235981, -0.06043072044849396, -0.013150963932275772, -0.0036968823987990618, -0.05584602430462837, -0.07234197109937668, -0.0414109006524086, 0.0017482445109635592, 0.036242153495550156, 0.04195059835910797, 0.002599905477836728, -0.0486113615334034, 0.04984268918633461, -0.02785983495414257, -0.026075009256601334, -0.03080785647034645, 0.02955733798444271, -0.014137858524918556, -0.06559938937425613, 0.02757721021771431, -0.019771382212638855, 0.02891000360250473, 0.003027583472430706, -0.01164085604250431, -0.017483936622738838, 0.007470866199582815, 0.030081065371632576, -0.010018318891525269, 0.019307374954223633, 0.047359272837638855, 0.07196789979934692, -0.025417709723114967, 0.028667142614722252, -0.036804553121328354, -0.07563076168298721, -0.02671591006219387, -0.022874679416418076, 0.01721828803420067, -0.04446559026837349, -0.012888475321233273, 0.007909122854471207, 0.022747831419110298, -0.011054382659494877, 0.029865002259612083, -0.05086270347237587, 0.07571732252836227, 0.047219276428222656, -0.027638878673315048, -0.013871690258383751, 0.01670219749212265, 0.04821392521262169, 0.010529032908380032, -0.05097850412130356, 0.02793005295097828, -0.04171216860413551, -0.006558094639331102, 0.022570954635739326, 0.022965189069509506, -0.04620538651943207, -0.00018985275528393686, -0.004645231645554304, 0.06198539584875107, -0.0160552766174078, 0.0055649071000516415, 0.010432399809360504, -0.0434880331158638, 0.005869367625564337, 0.0020721633918583393, 0.02698620781302452, 0.009916199371218681, -0.015934281051158905, -0.01772126741707325, 0.024069374427199364, 0.034573618322610855, 0.028875326737761497, 0.006149146240204573, 0.02723792940378189, 0.01755203679203987, -0.011964763514697552, -0.029683852568268776, 0.015558235347270966, -0.01929616928100586, 0.029351580888032913, 0.044712234288454056, -0.015481173992156982, -0.014104214496910572, 0.005594857037067413, 0.00122524902690202, 0.03229103982448578, 0.029017861932516098, -0.025284411385655403, -0.029855920001864433, 0.01998773030936718, -0.01907319575548172, -0.012595400214195251, -0.0741090402007103, -0.010379133746027946, -0.07617229223251343, -0.007237791549414396, 0.05266164615750313, -0.0066904122941195965, 0.01670144684612751, -0.05776135250926018, 0.04797050356864929, -0.023755870759487152, -0.01565597392618656, -0.021225951611995697, -0.00044172402704134583, -0.04676910489797592, -0.006701554171741009, -0.03311297297477722, -0.017603736370801926, 0.037566572427749634, -0.01841740868985653, -0.03657936677336693, 0.04597354680299759, 0.009834019467234612, -0.051649898290634155, -0.024660564959049225, 0.001045726821757853, 0.014694294892251492, -0.03848668560385704, -0.010375083424150944, 0.017640942707657814, -0.0008788933046162128, -0.06394529342651367, 0.0337798073887825, -0.04964429512619972, -0.029062816873192787, 0.005837032571434975, -0.04407854005694389, 0.023980701342225075, -0.0013552885502576828, -0.015492851845920086, 0.014147017151117325, -0.04918612539768219, -0.01737385429441929, -0.0873684361577034, -0.037136513739824295, 0.020291244611144066, -0.0007302429294213653, 0.052213143557310104, 0.03337133675813675, -0.01869996450841427, 0.031314339488744736, 0.017990484833717346, -0.04470587521791458, -0.06404080986976624, -0.014570276252925396, -0.0015070659574121237, 0.005663054995238781, 0.03712267428636551, -0.00517473416402936, -0.008661969564855099, 0.0031746369786560535, -0.0061011468060314655, 0.007770338095724583, 0.04818102344870567, 0.04176916927099228, 0.011348322965204716, 0.01865323632955551, 0.02075858972966671, -0.04595556482672691, 0.01617402583360672, 0.05550137534737587, -0.028398018330335617, -0.019814584404230118, 0.03022262640297413, 0.027274947613477707, 0.01663701981306076, -0.02735801227390766, 0.03821559622883797, 0.009107171557843685, 0.005761046428233385, -0.0380745492875576, 0.04924384132027626, 0.03812868148088455, -0.012688842602074146, -0.03205318748950958, 0.007068056613206863, 0.029237356036901474, -0.002172286156564951, 0.01951332949101925, 0.07487443834543228, 0.016480732709169388, -0.02443547733128071, -0.007558526936918497, -0.0068555655889213085, 0.028305169194936752, 0.008247471414506435, -0.03606877848505974, -0.02110869809985161, 0.05007067322731018, 0.050502851605415344, 0.02290653996169567, -0.008873047307133675, -0.06726641952991486, 0.01382393203675747, -0.08439944684505463, 0.0008661088650114834, -0.07122592628002167, 0.0706198439002037, -0.0019444208592176437, 0.04231909662485123, 0.03338974341750145, -0.0038361381739377975, -0.015153464861214161, 0.013647499494254589, -0.0447230190038681, 0.0006721781683154404, -0.02709188498556614, -0.005230466835200787, 0.04902321472764015, -0.024103030562400818, 0.007612011861056089, 0.00966472178697586, 0.0017224203329533339, 0.01231246069073677, 0.029376456514000893, -0.001739828148856759, -0.0032929314766079187, -0.0090761324390769, -0.013597163371741772, 0.024243101477622986, 0.03599672019481659, 0.00569682102650404, -0.025869527831673622, 0.01390914712101221, 0.026975171640515327, 0.03736940026283264, -0.009816465899348259, -0.02655288577079773, 0.00936176162213087, -0.0029478345531970263, 0.02125103957951069, 0.001731487107463181, -0.008723184466362, -0.027303649112582207, 0.059495337307453156, 0.045671138912439346, 0.040501248091459274, -0.018448110669851303, -0.05850646272301674, -0.00779331149533391, -0.017996998503804207, -0.02675994299352169, -0.0034223569091409445, 0.018007395789027214, 0.028164656832814217, 0.00020429313008207828, 0.04217088595032692, 0.05115438625216484, -0.030504519119858742, 0.03056923672556877, 0.038942597806453705, 0.004527388606220484, -0.017740409821271896, -0.019889479503035545, -0.04480380937457085, -0.003440605942159891, -0.00007471279241144657, 0.012447066605091095, 0.028710387647151947, -0.025915907695889473, 0.006142972037196159, 0.019523300230503082, -0.025482945144176483, -0.06254585832357407, 0.004044373985379934, 0.006425164174288511, 0.022303331643342972, -0.02330215461552143, -0.049231529235839844, 0.048810847103595734, 0.048663802444934845, 0.05575163662433624, 0.049034956842660904, -0.006668316666036844, -0.05635704845190048, 0.01665773056447506, 0.02164936251938343, 0.036213602870702744, -0.06752143055200577, -0.000502883514855057, -0.010869455523788929, -0.050552017986774445, 0.025950176641345024, -0.014279459603130817, 0.03298434242606163, -0.030077559873461723, 0.031889814883470535, -0.021870940923690796, -0.058353349566459656, -0.017979517579078674, 0.028794925659894943, 0.010970751754939556, 0.03249398618936539, -0.0064751869067549706, -0.014012880623340607, -0.007632850669324398, 0.020730627700686455, 0.004419287201017141, 0.054921478033065796, -0.038449641317129135, 0.009483028203248978, 0.02670001983642578, 0.04149026423692703, -0.04553087800741196, -0.06637109816074371, -0.013340831734240055, 0.01029430516064167, 0.002107937354594469, 0.027585867792367935, -0.025882894173264503, -0.015318977646529675, 0.015067812986671925, 0.03917856514453888, 0.007079548202455044, 0.009724974632263184, -0.048559654504060745, 0.06490707397460938, 0.03341488912701607, 0.013076222501695156, 0.04544738307595253, 0.013791822828352451, -0.003889215411618352, -0.0054046171717345715, -0.025916386395692825, -0.00513702817261219, -0.03684380277991295, -0.00944417156279087, -0.013227438554167747, 0.003228807123377919, -0.008342972956597805, 0.04377574473619461, -0.014279228635132313, 0.027882695198059082, -0.017626715824007988, -0.001465596491470933, -0.006250928621739149, -0.0036116845440119505, -0.0019114322494715452, 0.00173132901545614, 0.041759833693504333, 0.04740205779671669, 0.017271501943469048, -0.030333681032061577, 0.04893779754638672, -0.018141482025384903, -0.01809358038008213, 0.023391416296362877, -0.013682030141353607, 0.02775980718433857, -0.013856090605258942, -0.032777078449726105, 0.0044993748888373375, -0.004608134273439646, 0.02861197479069233, -0.04928618669509888, 0.005677248816937208, -0.017319295555353165, -0.03510693833231926, -0.0013565336121246219, 0.017890779301524162, 0.0028295638039708138, 0.026784200221300125, -0.020030220970511436, 0.02844000607728958, 0.010274004191160202, -0.05037802457809448, -0.06131039187312126, -0.021137850359082222, 0.020857078954577446, -0.003975347150117159, 0.024030715227127075, -0.025069916620850563, 0.021910235285758972, -0.019218752160668373, -0.03053106926381588, -0.03236015513539314, 0.06397049129009247, 0.001484319451265037, -0.013878864236176014, -0.028777990490198135, 0.016479413956403732, 0.047183021903038025, 0.0016479003243148327, -0.003877428360283375, 0.027031728997826576, -0.006503690965473652, -0.0032562287524342537, -0.005798923783004284, 0.001878092298284173, -0.04194160923361778, -0.030541133135557175, -0.01960551179945469, -0.0038944699335843325, 0.0386350154876709, 0.015328314155340195, -0.01698276586830616, 0.005082796793431044, -0.03842383250594139, -0.05175330862402916, -0.029729900881648064, 0.0007644649595022202, 0.032406650483608246, -0.01807822659611702, -0.007601298391819, 0.03270530328154564, -0.059017427265644073, -0.016757547855377197, 0.01448980811983347, -0.021022938191890717, -0.053499314934015274, -0.0004992444883100688, 0.06302735209465027, 0.002924850443378091, 0.019120480865240097, -0.022042443975806236, -0.009129435755312443, 0.03072524070739746, 0.0203800518065691, -0.016594180837273598, 0.027681324630975723, 0.007266787346452475, -0.0315743088722229, -0.014447089284658432, -0.00267853238619864, 0.006674233358353376, 0.06720321625471115, 0.008522255346179008, 0.012863130308687687, 0.07722757756710052, -0.03491872921586037, -0.0034484064672142267, -0.033568814396858215, 0.031162910163402557, 0.007339927833527327, 0.022297102957963943, 0.07753404974937439, -0.036335766315460205, -0.050214603543281555, 0.02897331304848194, 0.020514996722340584, 0.019077401608228683, -0.015936359763145447, 0.03449847549200058, 0.022172125056385994, -0.005206001922488213, -0.0420621782541275, -0.04410240426659584, 0.014320402406156063, -0.09192977845668793, -0.012698863632977009, 0.017288779839873314, -0.06705262511968613, 0.017395034432411194, 0.05001287907361984, -0.0056132483296096325, -0.021345175802707672, -0.003665623953565955, -0.0063518350943923, 0.03214440122246742, 0.015533004887402058, 0.0030009772162884474, 0.006328253075480461, -0.028424900025129318, 0.060812875628471375, 0.016400085762143135, 0.005834019742906094, -0.013653825037181377, -0.1015196293592453, -0.029740065336227417, -0.0005725890514440835, -0.0423540361225605, 0.009723802097141743, 0.014672496356070042, -0.00458524702116847, 0.020996036008000374, -0.034315355122089386, -0.010410591028630733, -0.0005634555709548295, 0.026819264516234398, 0.00011884692503372207, 0.0300576351583004, -0.009249160066246986, 0.024083446711301804, 0.01038523018360138, -0.018650135025382042, 0.11143726855516434, 0.06912677735090256, 0.011734113097190857, -0.03880668431520462, 0.018299387767910957, 0.03444990515708923, 0.023835832253098488, 0.0009687456185929477, 0.026976991444826126, -0.000852680706884712, -0.03040507063269615, 0.07357979565858841, 0.06483886390924454, 0.009923003613948822, -0.016137240454554558, 0.02887049876153469, -0.012093782424926758, 0.014199817553162575, -0.01269122026860714, 0.0016639137174934149, 0.009426741860806942, -0.016973651945590973, -0.04425418749451637, 0.01745581440627575, 0.007621956989169121, -0.009556316770613194, -0.01062172930687666, 0.01512925885617733, 0.0016339474823325872, 0.02911972627043724, -0.015904134139418602, 0.008714496158063412, 0.01184891164302826, -0.0051950025372207165, -0.026677481830120087, -0.02839253470301628, 0.038362786173820496, -0.0341225303709507, -0.005701631773263216, 0.04991486668586731, -0.019655875861644745, -0.012870006263256073, -0.036663565784692764, 0.019441906362771988, -0.050174273550510406, -0.01835462637245655, -0.03407737985253334, 0.025438178330659866, 0.002658252138644457, 0.0013463998911902308, -0.020626015961170197, 0.000400170887587592, 0.008905325084924698, -0.047745320945978165, -0.010455620475113392, 0.019575051963329315, 0.010540998540818691, -0.04025803878903389, -0.008465759456157684, -0.032762181013822556, -0.009282451122999191, -0.0037240548990666866, 0.03372557833790779, 0.008584153838455677, -0.022897401824593544, -0.017173735424876213, -0.045562583953142166, 0.006001350935548544, 0.024506356567144394, 0.015005800873041153, -0.003845140105113387, 0.012889066711068153, -0.02105797827243805, 0.02942032925784588, 0.0040896860882639885, 0.02014010399580002, 0.021129749715328217, -0.008795768022537231, 0.03584270551800728, -0.06028061732649803, -0.03396688401699066, 0.013543574139475822, -0.038483019918203354, -0.012620131485164165, -0.06750404089689255, -0.037464093416929245, 0.043074268847703934, 0.05027218535542488, -0.004388927947729826, -0.014978162944316864, -0.005058871582150459, 0.05383217707276344, 0.023034654557704926, 0.011654126457870007, -0.04113319516181946, -0.02123592048883438, -0.042967818677425385, 0.007373225875198841, 0.015810679644346237, 0.016054116189479828, 0.0632031112909317, 0.019390787929296494, -0.04895927384495735, 0.0579717680811882, 0.012861241586506367, -0.005369293503463268, 0.04219566658139229, -0.024939507246017456, -0.04534337669610977, 0.026369255036115646, 0.026445740833878517, -0.02779216319322586, 0.0016882034251466393, -0.05476666986942291, -0.04318171739578247, 0.015810159966349602, -0.03312807157635689, -0.02469770982861519, -0.02002136781811714, 0.01036500558257103, 0.042406413704156876, -0.02920261025428772, -0.0015898256096988916, -0.02101479284465313, -0.05605084449052811, 0.0006905102636665106, -0.0075776055455207825, -0.018441632390022278, 0.021349143236875534, -0.023262731730937958, 0.015038612298667431, 0.026743749156594276, 0.0020204850006848574, -0.04264102131128311, -0.0273983683437109, 0.022946931421756744, -0.0023693288676440716, 0.05549245327711105, 0.006422987207770348, -0.019550206139683723, 0.014662674628198147, -0.040799058973789215, -0.0035999997053295374, 0.0034191044978797436, -0.020583108067512512, -0.0006087791989557445, 0.014363921247422695, -0.0048856474459171295, -0.016879132017493248, 0.01698862388730049, -0.03951621055603027, -0.01566687785089016, -0.006773998495191336, 0.0029227600898593664, 0.016028109937906265, 0.017742417752742767, 0.01685738004744053, 0.04271623492240906, -0.026306064799427986, 0.018153518438339233, 0.03876761719584465, 0.025018921121954918, 0.011911793611943722, 0.025486912578344345, 0.0007498014601878822, -0.035722989588975906, 0.0213925801217556, -0.043201133608818054, -0.00823869090527296, 0.029771801084280014, -0.025029465556144714, 0.04316239431500435, -0.02491139993071556, 0.021153246983885765, -0.057125844061374664, -0.010796500369906425, -0.027762774378061295, 0.012080347165465355, 0.011283907108008862, -0.02834417298436165, 0.003575750393792987, -0.00312832766212523, -0.039611510932445526, 0.05263926833868027, 0.002511819591745734, -0.01386315654963255, -0.03061857633292675, 0.010577617213129997, -0.04690125584602356, 0.005579349119216204, -0.0018002833239734173, 0.03303425386548042, -0.04567711800336838, 0.028932876884937286, 0.0032974013593047857, 0.01150340586900711, -0.008204440586268902, 0.0014139938866719604, -0.0015378851676359773, -0.04924650490283966, 0.026948165148496628, -0.02251713164150715, -0.02342255413532257, 0.006948205642402172, -0.023946324363350868, 0.04086738079786301, 0.01588488183915615, 0.04177923500537872, -0.001557152601890266, 0.050199661403894424, 0.008962903171777725, 0.014569857157766819, -0.017019102349877357, 0.015401571057736874, 0.03967782109975815, 0.027200624346733093, -0.013615904375910759, -0.005362649913877249, 0.047024838626384735, 0.0065797739662230015, 0.00847991369664669, 0.0010287502082064748, -0.02684159018099308, -0.02017202600836754, -0.029010014608502388, -0.030978066846728325, -0.00251441216096282, -0.04944268986582756, -0.004503758158534765, -0.03881295025348663, -0.009133993647992611, 0.04841315746307373, 0.014555301517248154, 0.0024156130384653807, -0.0008406099514104426, 0.016144907101988792, 0.004657731391489506, 0.040999047458171844, 0.01772262156009674, 0.0013195071369409561, -0.042176589369773865, -0.03119310550391674, -0.009039715863764286, -0.020688094198703766, -0.0009191074059344828, 0.023604892194271088, 0.019368167966604233, 0.014625899493694305, -0.020872188732028008, 0.0032873679883778095, 0.03460172191262245, -0.049990274012088776, 0.026070792227983475, -0.054318394511938095, 0.06260017305612564, 0.012976879253983498, -0.007696302141994238, -0.03191804140806198, 0.002953091636300087, -0.02291146107017994, 0.00857741478830576, 0.08355201780796051, -0.017737967893481255, -0.0033468222245573997, 0.003113711019977927, 0.018341567367315292, 0.01930243708193302, -0.042214956134557724, 0.0437115803360939, -0.0032799700275063515, -0.005852336063981056, -0.028115548193454742, -0.01489389780908823, 0.019165582954883575, -0.053008534014225006, 0.05112813040614128, -0.031047560274600983, 0.000129309730255045, -0.016172345727682114, -0.015045253559947014, 0.011796112172305584, 0.009815391153097153, -0.008144802413880825, 0.04105160012841225, -0.03119709901511669, 0.03736216947436333, 0.06025242060422897, -0.03759755194187164, -0.06033061817288399, 0.026811392977833748, 0.013440782204270363, 0.004430451896041632, -0.02346663922071457, 0.04077260196208954, -0.009391030296683311, -0.09457211941480637, 0.007283969782292843, 0.010556639172136784, -0.03696306794881821, -0.015755951404571533, 0.07929310947656631, 0.007133780512958765, 0.050971150398254395, 0.005385564640164375, 0.00643194280564785, 0.03136233240365982, -0.06048990786075592, -0.00485489796847105, 0.04556114226579666, 0.04651213064789772, 0.031424324959516525, -0.022988339886069298, 0.034478288143873215, -0.011332790367305279, 0.03289831429719925, -0.008345948532223701, 0.008103793486952782, -0.018693653866648674, -0.005684621166437864, 0.01818041317164898, -0.02143210917711258, 0.06769251078367233, 0.0446416437625885, -0.028637398034334183, 0.0531729981303215, -0.04846380650997162, 0.006761263124644756, -0.024167144671082497, -0.029922062531113625, -0.03521162271499634, 0.016992568969726562, 0.0778539627790451, 0.046155896037817, 0.008684183470904827, -0.014793801121413708, -0.0478503480553627, -0.032974161207675934, 0.04489210247993469, -0.008739468641579151, 0.04241538420319557, -0.02952381782233715, 0.012435256503522396, 0.0019265726441517472, -0.052975598722696304, -0.03140864148736, -0.03653469681739807, 0.016247745603322983, 0.0048165530897676945, 0.012739915400743484, -0.017196670174598694, -0.032143816351890564, 0.0037529650144279003, 0.06981297582387924, -0.04775450751185417, -0.0029877189081162214, -0.06099862605333328, 0.014685848727822304, 0.02475210279226303, 0.017865998670458794 ]
<p>My memory is fuzzy on the advantages and disadvantages of various methods for detrending time-series data. I'm looking for a succinct summary of why and when one should or should not use the following:</p> <ul> <li>Differenced data</li> <li>Log-differenced data</li> <li>Error term, after regressing on <em>only</em> a linear or polynomial time series (e.g., 0,1,2,3,...,t)</li> </ul>
74,321
[ 0.001577256596647203, 0.005588307976722717, 0.0026019285432994366, 0.0016052951104938984, -0.012160858139395714, 0.022246120497584343, -0.0003131075936835259, -0.01211172342300415, 0.03536176308989525, -0.008227049373090267, 0.030068902298808098, 0.03473009169101715, 0.01602495089173317, 0.006071113515645266, 0.04196565970778465, -0.002634104574099183, 0.003746609203517437, -0.002208244288340211, -0.010263902135193348, -0.015969814732670784, -0.021422283723950386, 0.018522808328270912, -0.010192550718784332, 0.022173898294568062, -0.021338673308491707, 0.051642000675201416, 0.05163324251770973, 0.021868981420993805, 0.001879819785244763, 0.05875345692038536, -0.03890509158372879, -0.026738742366433144, -0.020531581714749336, 0.031407762318849564, 0.005034913774579763, 0.024302568286657333, -0.03647097572684288, -0.047832489013671875, -0.005628249142318964, 0.026190374046564102, -0.03337753936648369, -0.002611299278214574, -0.01523912325501442, 0.03659149259328842, -0.007889396511018276, 0.017723223194479942, 0.012497828342020512, -0.039116159081459045, -0.005440363194793463, -0.017336484044790268, 0.029749738052487373, -0.046908553689718246, 0.025410624220967293, 0.019672542810440063, 0.013374369591474533, 0.014903080649673939, 0.05389539152383804, 0.062166694551706314, -0.0035069617442786694, -0.07224147021770477, 0.005435565486550331, -0.015196849592030048, 0.015341613441705704, 0.007584093604236841, -0.019215699285268784, 0.02529701590538025, -0.0014449331210926175, -0.01943679340183735, 0.05293332040309906, -0.03139449283480644, 0.019270455464720726, 0.011333585716784, -0.0019862905610352755, -0.013551181182265282, 0.02367803081870079, -0.03902176767587662, -0.026546956971287727, 0.0019577948842197657, 0.07248689234256744, 0.04886903241276741, 0.0399567149579525, 0.022412866353988647, 0.059104204177856445, 0.03526429459452629, 0.033069510012865067, 0.010845509357750416, 0.10510373115539551, -0.033386651426553726, 0.009785160422325134, 0.030137687921524048, 0.026087015867233276, 0.00009500027226749808, 0.04465986415743828, 0.004419291391968727, -0.022075209766626358, 0.04828121140599251, -0.015044771134853363, 0.03616120666265488, 0.019628899171948433, -0.0036395748611539602, -0.029240738600492477, -0.02036348357796669, 0.03679216280579567, 0.0013063920196145773, -0.01560058631002903, 0.014139913953840733, -0.019342120736837387, 0.013691918924450874, 0.002045842818915844, -0.06630820035934448, 0.0017333998112007976, 0.03254932537674904, -0.000325235741911456, 0.022144155576825142, -0.01754649169743061, -0.003330216510221362, 0.0036713401786983013, -0.0017780715133994818, 0.03744896501302719, 0.09974474459886551, 0.023678340017795563, -0.020330186933279037, 0.014574946835637093, -0.004373667296022177, -0.06059638410806656, -0.0063916416838765144, 0.040157824754714966, -0.01579401269555092, -0.06272239238023758, 0.058309927582740784, -0.007033219560980797, -0.0449724942445755, 0.044913649559020996, -0.027087556198239326, 0.053461648523807526, 0.045080654323101044, -0.09188755601644516, -0.03066212683916092, 0.056738078594207764, 0.008372191339731216, -0.01768052577972412, -0.03237807750701904, -0.0007819650927558541, -0.006317747291177511, 0.05547857657074928, 0.03437051549553871, 0.025504572317004204, 0.004630693234503269, 0.013564154505729675, -0.0035800053738057613, -0.04165556654334068, -0.003996015526354313, 0.002644976833835244, -0.019896112382411957, 0.012381034903228283, -0.05026434734463692, 0.015831438824534416, 0.04612916335463524, -0.026444535702466965, 0.015072925016283989, 0.03649919852614403, 0.011085325852036476, -0.03373519331216812, 0.03372230753302574, -0.0062583996914327145, -0.029341408982872963, 0.08899633586406708, -0.012228855863213539, 0.04045185446739197, -0.002708698622882366, 0.027764050289988518, 0.021570099517703056, 0.006865846458822489, 0.03942958265542984, 0.042358990758657455, -0.019356630742549896, 0.011803989298641682, -0.020240815356373787, 0.01354446355253458, 0.009531798772513866, -0.061908382922410965, -0.016620352864265442, 0.01443404145538807, -0.04367963224649429, 0.017995376139879227, 0.028028467670083046, 0.010713508352637291, 0.017621036618947983, 0.04203754663467407, -0.03365949168801308, -0.030907759442925453, -0.05488836392760277, 0.00962977297604084, -0.03203919902443886, -0.0028482265770435333, 0.03923160210251808, 0.006793016567826271, 0.0246969535946846, -0.019198061898350716, -0.028847383335232735, -0.01085085142403841, 0.03567463904619217, 0.007515879347920418, -0.048049185425043106, -0.012589333578944206, 0.03309585526585579, 0.028343725949525833, 0.004509966820478439, 0.01563330553472042, -0.0406610369682312, -0.04076433181762695, -0.021819137036800385, -0.05429929122328758, 0.006784261669963598, 0.002152169356122613, -0.012807665392756462, 0.003051403909921646, -0.009115887805819511, -0.04076873138546944, -0.007703437469899654, -0.027698712423443794, 0.05085928365588188, 0.06918682903051376, 0.029559805989265442, -0.00030276685720309615, 0.011797639541327953, 0.009663098491728306, 0.002119622891768813, -0.022946592420339584, -0.009945017285645008, -0.04227122291922569, 0.012641487643122673, 0.05264792963862419, 0.06520037353038788, -0.024285614490509033, 0.059314947575330734, 0.06700708717107773, -0.005093814805150032, 0.014179199934005737, 0.03954264521598816, -0.01618928834795952, -0.03283891826868057, 0.0133985485881567, -0.01037257257848978, 0.010245421901345253, 0.005251921713352203, 0.0390750914812088, -0.024812079966068268, 0.00880232360213995, -0.00627153879031539, 0.0037337499670684338, 0.03872557729482651, -0.005036585498601198, 0.006126954220235348, 0.006574694067239761, -0.042289961129426956, 0.015918277204036713, -0.032402489334344864, -0.009191881865262985, -0.021448222920298576, -0.011141226626932621, 0.023103974759578705, -0.0056544882245361805, 0.00506131025031209, 0.029801737517118454, 0.02497720532119274, -0.03794281557202339, -0.007740484084933996, 0.03927167132496834, -0.04929788038134575, 0.0075136469677090645, -0.046461321413517, -0.022434337064623833, -0.07375910878181458, -0.004869137890636921, 0.015887649729847908, -0.0013347483472898602, 0.05039053410291672, 0.006967056076973677, -0.0168722216039896, 0.020086709409952164, -0.044172462075948715, 0.01657409593462944, -0.013910651206970215, -0.025633113458752632, 0.006770879030227661, -0.017015377059578896, -0.02132124826312065, 0.038714829832315445, -0.0028927114326506853, 0.041675910353660583, 0.01611396111547947, 0.0054565598256886005, -0.07003597915172577, -0.06816675513982773, -0.028890587389469147, 0.0021097951103001833, -0.0038678604178130627, -0.05984977260231972, 0.08344581723213196, 0.013969074934720993, -0.019610349088907242, 0.012802520766854286, -0.08220745623111725, -0.0070179239846765995, -0.06125049293041229, 0.03471303731203079, 0.014433945529162884, -0.0053209830075502396, -0.025411931797862053, -0.004799212329089642, -0.04870627447962761, -0.008882759138941765, -0.054659660905599594, -0.08219457417726517, -0.0020678453147411346, -0.006896473467350006, 0.03115554340183735, -0.007766932714730501, -0.04560650512576103, 0.0900522843003273, 0.022619694471359253, -0.019185664132237434, -0.05965493246912956, -0.019246213138103485, -0.02864951640367508, -0.029321232810616493, 0.015566812828183174, 0.005218535661697388, -0.007978969253599644, 0.013694480061531067, -0.01210394874215126, 0.06342538446187973, 0.022620687261223793, 0.01825518161058426, -0.005629560444504023, 0.02123890444636345, 0.022241702303290367, -0.02445461042225361, 0.02854393981397152, 0.02415444701910019, -0.03977225720882416, 0.021362008526921272, -0.005615826230496168, 0.02926880121231079, 0.009209400974214077, -0.051183611154556274, 0.0022770939394831657, -0.05085214227437973, -0.0048031285405159, -0.002835302148014307, 0.04926445707678795, 0.0062185549177229404, -0.02064678631722927, -0.02325611561536789, -0.0038130783941596746, 0.00030386343132704496, -0.021532410755753517, -0.0019388946238905191, 0.024835599586367607, 0.06019951030611992, -0.026720229536294937, -0.022870758548378944, 0.003423368325456977, -0.03442436829209328, 0.044283024966716766, -0.052548881620168686, 0.000907038280274719, 0.0580630749464035, 0.02392061986029148, 0.019767139106988907, -0.009095863439142704, -0.043103210628032684, -0.02952132746577263, -0.09389910101890564, 0.031135179102420807, -0.02309250645339489, 0.08676663041114807, 0.01032322272658348, 0.011501407250761986, 0.014419435523450375, -0.006208481267094612, 0.03249063342809677, -0.007266924250870943, -0.05959390848875046, 0.03131741285324097, -0.00665950495749712, -0.025226328521966934, 0.004888820927590132, 0.02682981640100479, 0.06304775178432465, -0.052110519260168076, 0.008860406465828419, -0.020454218611121178, 0.016117701306939125, -0.04758835583925247, -0.0021261577494442463, -0.009278679266571999, -0.013719811104238033, -0.04469867795705795, -0.018965717405080795, 0.044389817863702774, -0.03020532801747322, 0.026512933894991875, 0.03613400086760521, -0.002062841784209013, -0.02518867887556553, -0.008307192474603653, -0.0024288317654281855, 0.033579085022211075, 0.02924375794827938, 0.03554331511259079, 0.013776815496385098, -0.02810845337808132, 0.04567557945847511, 0.017991818487644196, 0.03151647374033928, 0.02665753662586212, 0.02185848541557789, -0.04082455486059189, -0.011327986605465412, -0.019139200448989868, 0.003909188788384199, 0.036885276436805725, 0.03813242167234421, 0.004967833403497934, 0.037341658025979996, 0.026236867532134056, -0.025446228682994843, 0.01613576151430607, 0.04001278802752495, -0.008818277157843113, 0.0010836705332621932, -0.014902787283062935, -0.01918843574821949, 0.014063982293009758, 0.008129364810883999, 0.008992561139166355, 0.014298135414719582, 0.005740179214626551, -0.01545745600014925, 0.05070934444665909, -0.024359239265322685, -0.022585561498999596, 0.012630871497094631, 0.05893022567033768, 0.042700063437223434, 0.028080327436327934, -0.029636714607477188, 0.061168819665908813, 0.02645912952721119, 0.06741578876972198, 0.038491927087306976, 0.028041835874319077, -0.1002107635140419, -0.0006116872536949813, 0.06264740228652954, 0.0397251658141613, -0.025600148364901543, -0.02881045453250408, -0.034210775047540665, -0.006504768040031195, 0.025004034861922264, -0.04495307803153992, 0.04983292520046234, -0.022690555080771446, 0.02764810249209404, -0.031809430569410324, -0.038988471031188965, -0.006474478170275688, 0.02381219156086445, -0.014267301186919212, 0.0657215565443039, 0.011044953018426895, -0.028716472908854485, -0.06153388321399689, -0.01689223386347294, -0.009871182031929493, 0.04939939081668854, -0.04354510083794594, -0.019421961158514023, 0.02800844982266426, 0.010798925533890724, -0.027708740904927254, -0.058490194380283356, 0.006736648268997669, -0.01030055619776249, -0.015458261594176292, 0.04818959906697273, 0.018806252628564835, -0.035769760608673096, -0.062460921704769135, 0.016873067244887352, -0.02034001238644123, -0.010280121117830276, -0.0334729366004467, 0.02084515430033207, 0.014014516025781631, 0.027414212003350258, 0.086934395134449, 0.061275698244571686, 0.007660971488803625, 0.023174747824668884, -0.01818702183663845, 0.018274232745170593, -0.03566043823957443, 0.008128645829856396, -0.027415836229920387, -0.0027706625405699015, -0.042227841913700104, 0.013070165179669857, -0.010746278800070286, 0.030555805191397667, -0.009336086921393871, -0.023685086518526077, -0.0028250906616449356, 0.02802959457039833, -0.000918643840122968, 0.0022781831212341785, 0.0400569885969162, 0.020550567656755447, -0.04130926355719566, -0.006472766399383545, 0.011206336319446564, 0.01631768047809601, 0.014811241999268532, 0.01784547045826912, -0.03685842826962471, 0.022340117022395134, -0.0016393796540796757, -0.013134794309735298, 0.025135232135653496, 0.0072302669286727905, 0.03265471011400223, -0.0054228659719228745, 0.006352896336466074, -0.0010280921123921871, -0.03908872231841087, 0.02811565436422825, -0.013765852898359299, -0.035803571343421936, 0.037953853607177734, -0.08451187610626221, 0.0625443086028099, -0.021724238991737366, -0.009170790202915668, -0.06908303499221802, -0.06536662578582764, 0.05579507723450661, 0.001951912185177207, -0.0401439368724823, -0.004289491102099419, 0.0057381982915103436, -0.0036378505174070597, -0.025035632774233818, -0.023621940985322, 0.04987344890832901, -0.024871524423360825, -0.00926110427826643, -0.008072814904153347, 0.04182080179452896, 0.07893294841051102, 0.010642911307513714, 0.019040483981370926, -0.015113506466150284, -0.01948314532637596, -0.010719699785113335, -0.024879660457372665, 0.04043879359960556, -0.03866236284375191, -0.004538408946245909, -0.009578120894730091, 0.0050164503045380116, 0.02757522091269493, -0.03332672640681267, -0.022846031934022903, 0.04364677891135216, 0.02073664776980877, -0.0018537899013608694, -0.024875866249203682, 0.022000759840011597, -0.05146292224526405, 0.021175382658839226, 0.010272147133946419, 0.009306623600423336, -0.0010230416664853692, -0.05437789857387543, 0.01139939296990633, 0.014587762765586376, -0.011314461007714272, 0.035140782594680786, 0.012416555546224117, -0.00958410557359457, 0.0021937310229986906, 0.01767903007566929, -0.024351680651307106, 0.02718152105808258, -0.0023123356513679028, 0.00682796211913228, 0.019265923649072647, 0.030121436342597008, -0.0325632244348526, -0.03730333596467972, 0.00043503535562194884, -0.012170679867267609, 0.07285790890455246, 0.009080687537789345, 0.03930972144007683, 0.031732793897390366, -0.011012091301381588, 0.0034284626599401236, -0.022408977150917053, -0.011479906737804413, -0.005849788896739483, -0.0005188603536225855, 0.05257173627614975, -0.008280250243842602, -0.015963450074195862, 0.005164150148630142, 0.01011276338249445, 0.003780210157856345, 0.04061463475227356, 0.007754243444651365, 0.004954911768436432, 0.0035467122215777636, -0.02692040055990219, -0.041980259120464325, 0.010691655799746513, -0.04358186200261116, -0.001418609288521111, -0.032656386494636536, 0.007379070855677128, 0.06106922775506973, -0.0011564483866095543, -0.005971744656562805, -0.07385849952697754, 0.0033275883179157972, -0.0775698646903038, -0.0050763837061822414, 0.03725668787956238, -0.03322584554553032, 0.042533837258815765, -0.010966939851641655, 0.06776664406061172, -0.0019025237997993827, 0.021862242370843887, -0.003205491928383708, -0.07353078573942184, -0.021454820409417152, -0.03057449497282505, -0.054845161736011505, 0.040001146495342255, -0.010673755779862404, -0.05934760719537735, -0.004510888364166021, 0.0066795046441257, -0.0054727899841964245, 0.023963630199432373, 0.03709885850548744, -0.007713905535638332, 0.06152195483446121, 0.003708526259288192, -0.031333863735198975, -0.0023172181099653244, -0.03363163396716118, 0.12033740431070328, 0.07423535734415054, 0.02782227285206318, -0.08002469688653946, 0.008206326514482498, 0.0034992473665624857, 0.02440548688173294, -0.0261464174836874, 0.036366138607263565, 0.0076916213147342205, 0.025701474398374557, 0.043700624257326126, 0.051609281450510025, -0.013026123866438866, -0.026727089658379555, 0.03641553968191147, -0.007326396182179451, 0.006025578826665878, 0.01608310453593731, 0.005569779314100742, -0.0062818084843456745, -0.008897094056010246, -0.06054532155394554, -0.0036556574050337076, -0.0021706046536564827, -0.01665244624018669, 0.004630011040717363, -0.03749072179198265, 0.007194064557552338, -0.019562315195798874, -0.030718721449375153, 0.0062892804853618145, 0.02003336511552334, 0.020762518048286438, -0.026604196056723595, 0.0011819752398878336, -0.01741904579102993, -0.03306907042860985, -0.0057230121456086636, 0.05837804451584816, 0.0038968187291175127, -0.021477872505784035, 0.012599260546267033, -0.0002455121139064431, -0.05155334994196892, -0.021372539922595024, -0.04816412925720215, 0.028009355068206787, 0.002252926118671894, -0.0027900533750653267, 0.017381422221660614, 0.031188514083623886, 0.015803690999746323, -0.03449495509266853, -0.03550242632627487, -0.0077024768106639385, 0.024244654923677444, -0.032739583402872086, -0.04679911956191063, -0.03434346616268158, 0.006790153682231903, 0.009398987516760826, 0.029984014108777046, 0.017823535948991776, -0.06379882991313934, -0.0066901869140565395, 0.020813575014472008, 0.012545987032353878, -0.015603693202137947, 0.024032926186919212, -0.014318635687232018, 0.03364326432347298, -0.017930278554558754, -0.0034473466221243143, 0.009668371640145779, 0.011351151391863823, 0.001599983312189579, -0.0017199164722114801, -0.00318205077201128, -0.01723770797252655, -0.06394136697053909, 0.03823455423116684, -0.016084451228380203, 0.005683741066604853, -0.037329982966184616, 0.013680923730134964, 0.06690630316734314, 0.014470590278506279, 0.026864541694521904, 0.0178294088691473, 0.0003736884973477572, 0.058936573565006256, 0.016836173832416534, -0.056427963078022, -0.005949107464402914, 0.005342329852283001, -0.014721062034368515, 0.0010803801706060767, -0.004312859382480383, 0.08101366460323334, 0.02707887627184391, -0.0030805072747170925, -0.0142736304551363, 0.04056580737233162, 0.012131378054618835, 0.006660934071987867, 0.0009951896499842405, -0.056662436574697495, -0.018826380372047424, 0.03452685475349426, 0.011319047771394253, -0.01540732104331255, -0.042715974152088165, -0.019831174984574318, -0.020101942121982574, 0.00019716224051080644, -0.00999424234032631, -0.04201977327466011, 0.007578837685286999, -0.015098861418664455, 0.0250103697180748, -0.012081463821232319, 0.028046945109963417, -0.04981107637286186, 0.006346658803522587, -0.048917077481746674, -0.03594321385025978, 0.005412839353084564, -0.0052689746953547, -0.02885708212852478, 0.011313552968204021, 0.04045815393328667, 0.007693066261708736, 0.021297570317983627, -0.004876157734543085, -0.0015101890312507749, -0.022248590365052223, 0.01928723230957985, -0.019524982199072838, -0.023087136447429657, 0.029367033392190933, -0.021231980994343758, -0.03932230919599533, -0.0018184343352913857, 0.008320949971675873, 0.017163759097456932, -0.021473729982972145, 0.00794614665210247, -0.030234577134251595, 0.017734698951244354, -0.00846786517649889, 0.009831973351538181, -0.022193221375346184, -0.014709163457155228, -0.0007994077168405056, -0.013542842119932175, 0.015946105122566223, 0.0032322697807103395, -0.003011577995494008, -0.01359168253839016, 0.04402659088373184, 0.02448469027876854, -0.014752451330423355, -0.032407864928245544, 0.0033425898291170597, 0.005510296206921339, -0.01297495886683464, -0.013411065563559532, 0.030581239610910416, 0.039143554866313934, 0.0018485793843865395, 0.010278679430484772, -0.001420369604602456, -0.008270095102488995, -0.06326135993003845, 0.011110077612102032, 0.011678595095872879, 0.02429748885333538, -0.003915990702807903, -0.026662737131118774, -0.00478388462215662, 0.0073099322617053986, -0.010803472250699997, 0.024451419711112976, -0.03955201804637909, 0.0021800457034260035, -0.005618538707494736, 0.009622231125831604, 0.016312260180711746, 0.014208490028977394, 0.06952331960201263, -0.023618599399924278, 0.012305028736591339, -0.013562357053160667, 0.017801182344555855, -0.012525509111583233, -0.008086458779871464, 0.010845819488167763, 0.006200844421982765, -0.05952330306172371, 0.03894911706447601, -0.04495151713490486, -0.026719551533460617, 0.02697916328907013, -0.023874176666140556, 0.04485639929771423, 0.01590166613459587, 0.02555026113986969, -0.03787034749984741, 0.030750581994652748, 0.008644679561257362, -0.045183856040239334, -0.019114259630441666, 0.0023590943310409784, 0.014020564034581184, 0.007457210216671228, -0.0399758480489254, 0.01916494593024254, 0.0044112191535532475, -0.022161712870001793, -0.01771393232047558, -0.016110271215438843, -0.0018922541057690978, -0.014057700522243977, -0.018940679728984833, 0.02729915641248226, 0.02503182366490364, -0.023107832297682762, 0.012038720771670341, -0.0013399547897279263, -0.0034128990955650806, 0.05381240323185921, 0.008900834247469902, -0.04867483675479889, 0.04827499762177467, -0.014031658880412579, -0.0566539503633976, 0.002348617184907198, -0.0007795502315275371, 0.00029993176576681435, -0.05259447917342186, 0.017096588388085365, 0.015856632962822914, -0.030822955071926117, -0.06508126109838486, 0.01132884994149208, 0.015350444242358208, 0.03942054510116577, -0.02644166350364685, -0.03411403298377991, 0.028407562524080276, -0.021363450214266777, 0.008039825595915318, -0.09173990786075592, 0.06667318940162659, -0.002121397526934743, -0.03888046741485596, -0.03681199252605438, -0.015775166451931, -0.037855666130781174, 0.02606554515659809, 0.09296299517154694, 0.003525768406689167, -0.003822930855676532, -0.011914508417248726, 0.03760486841201782, -0.014278729446232319, -0.017319800332188606, 0.013552716001868248, -0.014086666516959667, -0.019249850884079933, 0.028609804809093475, -0.009383182972669601, -0.01628948375582695, 0.021796053275465965, 0.025519635528326035, -0.0026127947494387627, 0.011596806347370148, 0.05119003728032112, 0.03247576951980591, 0.048179786652326584, 0.01819690503180027, -0.033745553344488144, 0.02648111619055271, -0.0226677805185318, 0.014878046698868275, 0.00938723236322403, -0.007604095619171858, -0.05235189199447632, 0.03974064439535141, -0.04516059160232544, -0.019391704350709915, -0.03823629394173622, -0.013681898824870586, 0.022498322650790215, -0.024746648967266083, -0.005785092245787382, 0.02589864283800125, -0.012858150526881218, 0.04081675037741661, 0.013590937480330467, 0.01855020970106125, 0.050665102899074554, -0.02449394017457962, 0.02694745734333992, 0.013915063813328743, -0.00994480773806572, -0.013024702668190002, 0.0345844067633152, 0.042695142328739166, -0.022794732823967934, -0.019708989188075066, 0.014159416779875755, -0.01964224874973297, 0.04695982113480568, -0.020952820777893066, 0.04423164203763008, -0.010422731749713421, -0.01314217783510685, 0.0008731588604860008, 0.00010620606190059334, -0.04722099006175995, 0.029092952609062195, -0.020874837413430214, 0.037111807614564896, -0.0003102957853116095, -0.009286196902394295, -0.0229031965136528, -0.05633487179875374, -0.038181122392416, -0.0014608989004045725, 0.005065464414656162, 0.02845248207449913, 0.021355466917157173, 0.008514958433806896, 0.0019525671377778053, 0.0029217691626399755, 0.01552971638739109, -0.0093528488650918, 0.033593978732824326, -0.01327517069876194, -0.01692655310034752, -0.019071711227297783, -0.042296379804611206, -0.06348481774330139, -0.022076979279518127, 0.048967666923999786, 0.03493421524763107, 0.027215972542762756, -0.024194220080971718, -0.020297765731811523, -0.021382944658398628, 0.017064228653907776, -0.05873885005712509, -0.029774732887744904, -0.027387849986553192, 0.020397869870066643, 0.017428547143936157, -0.024749627336859703 ]
<p>What is the best way of going about dealing with few instances in support vector regression, e.g. only approximately 40? Also - is there an optimal way of dealing with outliers in this case of few instances?</p>
37,160
[ -0.01813727803528309, -0.003382158698514104, -0.010104420594871044, 0.010214424692094326, 0.018890591338276863, -0.0019415407441556454, 0.007526841945946217, 0.004300814587622881, 0.030013101175427437, -0.012958555482327938, 0.01327592134475708, 0.037468377500772476, 0.037814248353242874, 0.003740954212844372, 0.005452759563922882, -0.039965517818927765, -0.013625962659716606, -0.01574702002108097, 0.015542566776275635, -0.006162781268358231, 0.0009487774805165827, 0.004762477707117796, 0.008587985299527645, -0.02489219419658184, -0.019842151552438736, 0.0181291401386261, 0.028501316905021667, -0.006862169597297907, 0.029676441103219986, 0.031388651579618454, -0.03844795748591423, -0.012084770016372204, 0.012704589404165745, 0.03972800448536873, 0.04047684744000435, -0.0227320808917284, -0.028230777010321617, -0.026660965755581856, -0.010247952304780483, 0.024101397022604942, -0.015583244152367115, 0.025523003190755844, 0.010451482608914375, 0.043145112693309784, -0.01498414110392332, 0.010300630703568459, 0.0065920669585466385, -0.061360713094472885, 0.041746802628040314, -0.051794517785310745, 0.1000833585858345, -0.011383291333913803, 0.024892639368772507, 0.031181830912828445, -0.014670763164758682, 0.005835581570863724, 0.04982001706957817, 0.05674057453870773, -0.0023440143559128046, 0.00027805077843368053, -0.02965579181909561, -0.011901551857590675, -0.009329595603048801, -0.017650600522756577, 0.0004507213307078928, 0.045548949390649796, -0.006528210360556841, -0.0022596297785639763, 0.022674188017845154, -0.01810358837246895, 0.024531470611691475, -0.03732149675488472, 0.045497093349695206, 0.02351500280201435, 0.010147538036108017, -0.01690262369811535, 0.014197487384080887, 0.044004641473293304, 0.049112267792224884, 0.0060603804886341095, 0.021411670371890068, 0.019058607518672943, 0.059776999056339264, 0.006669608876109123, 0.01917538233101368, -0.03888395428657532, 0.05395311117172241, -0.009362835437059402, 0.015945905819535255, 0.03571513295173645, -0.015263214707374573, 0.010215976275503635, 0.05778193101286888, -0.006066479720175266, -0.09184397757053375, 0.015370034612715244, -0.02096046879887581, 0.03907505422830582, -0.0007167421281337738, -0.00026105897268280387, -0.01623043604195118, -0.0295250304043293, 0.02685016207396984, 0.07658345252275467, -0.03564657270908356, 0.0021278902422636747, -0.030966009944677353, -0.013489717617630959, 0.01583702675998211, -0.007407005876302719, -0.03257662430405617, 0.008856476284563541, 0.027536476030945778, 0.010401605628430843, 0.02876187674701214, 0.016259560361504555, -0.01452132873237133, -0.05351688712835312, 0.018944747745990753, 0.07848680764436722, 0.022444356232881546, -0.05114961415529251, 0.041825588792562485, -0.026557859033346176, -0.002090444788336754, 0.040787819772958755, 0.024651315063238144, -0.012765034101903439, -0.04953089728951454, 0.009125840850174427, 0.012083910405635834, -0.02161971852183342, 0.019455548375844955, -0.026719562709331512, 0.021997608244419098, -0.015531003475189209, -0.08490906655788422, -0.048728618770837784, 0.024581870064139366, -0.01730608567595482, 0.021148785948753357, -0.05686740577220917, -0.0027724148239940405, 0.023137010633945465, 0.03704158216714859, 0.02031928487122059, -0.006598921492695808, 0.05966866388916969, 0.05314986780285835, -0.01573205552995205, -0.03956258296966553, 0.014462918974459171, -0.04761810600757599, -0.033675678074359894, -0.017143165692687035, -0.06817778199911118, 0.03098619356751442, 0.03887532651424408, 0.021321481093764305, -0.03214002773165703, -0.0003195122117176652, -0.017553724348545074, -0.01246540155261755, -0.014085772447288036, 0.059259332716464996, -0.02385031245648861, 0.05461033806204796, 0.0166127048432827, 0.03389483690261841, 0.02717566303908825, -0.017459699884057045, -0.012060506269335747, 0.04905372112989426, 0.0337364487349987, 0.039613235741853714, 0.04031169041991234, 0.007963025011122227, -0.04024215415120125, 0.03846915811300278, 0.014370611868798733, -0.059897590428590775, -0.02847149409353733, 0.027772657573223114, 0.041284382343292236, 0.018010003492236137, 0.04002855345606804, -0.018268169835209846, -0.02059343084692955, 0.028044166043400764, -0.07124621421098709, -0.0411645732820034, -0.03692058473825455, 0.010874878615140915, -0.009728866629302502, -0.022905686870217323, 0.03848087042570114, 0.01848750188946724, -0.011661265045404434, -0.037779584527015686, -0.03412438929080963, -0.04413718357682228, -0.011977451853454113, 0.03169601783156395, -0.080001600086689, -0.001442412380129099, 0.027597974985837936, 0.02562415413558483, -0.020534444600343704, 0.06176575645804405, -0.04979735612869263, -0.05383063107728958, -0.002920735627412796, 0.00013296703400555998, 0.0027457072865217924, -0.020981693640351295, -0.014915618114173412, 0.016362003982067108, -0.01011189166456461, -0.055838391184806824, 0.003950443584471941, -0.06043306365609169, 0.07918313890695572, 0.06957896053791046, 0.03132515028119087, -0.014420611783862114, -0.02971651963889599, 0.0006361884879879653, -0.017368093132972717, -0.01635647378861904, -0.018810851499438286, -0.05668862536549568, -0.014661308377981186, 0.023599373176693916, 0.03006027452647686, -0.05085384473204613, -0.011248961091041565, 0.05388159677386284, 0.03547219559550285, 0.02037491276860237, -0.01271847728639841, -0.027094712480902672, -0.02233733795583248, 0.04873925447463989, 0.0009631054126657546, -0.0004188051971141249, -0.01896457001566887, 0.005583294201642275, 0.020408138632774353, -0.017438679933547974, 0.03286708518862724, 0.015169098973274231, 0.04303603619337082, -0.009720024652779102, -0.00020816574397031218, -0.03547855094075203, -0.014408673159778118, 0.04081669822335243, -0.054796669632196426, -0.021070796996355057, 0.02400285378098488, 0.0046442048624157906, 0.0017042654799297452, 0.026449117809534073, -0.008846576325595379, 0.035878803580999374, 0.026249555870890617, -0.057420484721660614, 0.0253890473395586, 0.03616659343242645, -0.05316232889890671, -0.00915813259780407, -0.03976834565401077, -0.03553422912955284, -0.05258142948150635, 0.03981117904186249, 0.07286648452281952, -0.019997302442789078, 0.02608259953558445, 0.0020542037673294544, -0.027559101581573486, -0.006016228348016739, -0.0035981375258415937, 0.027160178869962692, 0.0017497946973890066, -0.055679239332675934, 0.02606024779379368, -0.014212307520210743, -0.04538898169994354, 0.02407044731080532, 0.011024446226656437, 0.0014212524984031916, -0.00459473580121994, -0.010731403715908527, -0.05267300829291344, -0.014695045538246632, -0.03125424683094025, 0.04311550781130791, -0.0010507948463782668, -0.015722835436463356, 0.040955595672130585, 0.012482904829084873, -0.04439321532845497, 0.007778155617415905, 0.00517656933516264, -0.0216062031686306, -0.05023971199989319, -0.010861058719456196, -0.005892504472285509, -0.004873603582382202, -0.01872969977557659, 0.05082549527287483, 0.0027495482936501503, 0.003998212981969118, -0.05251189321279526, -0.05536895990371704, -0.010711208917200565, -0.017207706347107887, 0.034199658781290054, -0.003404878545552492, 0.003232256742194295, 0.07920479774475098, 0.022516679018735886, -0.012719069607555866, -0.01673266477882862, -0.010684775188565254, -0.00935059692710638, -0.007122670765966177, -0.008932818658649921, 0.034056324511766434, 0.017855241894721985, 0.008292553946375847, -0.02819434553384781, 0.023534005507826805, 0.07983560860157013, 0.03344310447573662, -0.02649487927556038, 0.00561652984470129, 0.0028370157815515995, -0.0051049767062067986, 0.027572449296712875, 0.037249572575092316, -0.03299345448613167, 0.007408209145069122, -0.0012147292727604508, 0.022238407284021378, -0.006601762026548386, -0.018382050096988678, 0.0014435299672186375, -0.041024867445230484, 0.0034367567859590054, -0.002379973651841283, -0.010027707554399967, 0.018221745267510414, -0.016888367012143135, -0.0276121087372303, -0.0034645958803594112, 0.04165789112448692, -0.04570256173610687, 0.0040683262050151825, 0.06085219979286194, 0.041291363537311554, -0.012847783043980598, -0.008021559566259384, 0.0006006607436574996, -0.027820127084851265, 0.008186707273125648, 0.014120710082352161, -0.010662540793418884, 0.02739039622247219, 0.033823125064373016, 0.014569622464478016, -0.00315565406344831, -0.04739999771118164, 0.017966262996196747, -0.07624708861112595, -0.02106969989836216, -0.020262645557522774, 0.04569171369075775, 0.017248427495360374, -0.02430815063416958, 0.016076166182756424, -0.014577397145330906, -0.02313711680471897, 0.009316680952906609, -0.05152716860175133, 0.014335306361317635, 0.002848908770829439, 0.006180433090776205, 0.0030170311219990253, -0.026398103684186935, 0.036344751715660095, -0.034807685762643814, 0.0012337001971900463, -0.03826911002397537, 0.014383968897163868, -0.013008961454033852, 0.02519020438194275, -0.019408978521823883, 0.01251528225839138, -0.02554304711520672, 0.0015929813962429762, 0.022841906175017357, -0.04420268163084984, -0.0024584271013736725, 0.039605043828487396, -0.03600626811385155, -0.0057757203467190266, 0.0013129038270562887, -0.00598151795566082, 0.003519065212458372, 0.025801608338952065, 0.0002492859202902764, 0.027227966114878654, -0.076453797519207, 0.01940823346376419, -0.019147520884871483, 0.06082248315215111, 0.05762302875518799, -0.02861112542450428, -0.027166780084371567, -0.027200613170862198, -0.03296729922294617, 0.0023656829725950956, 0.02275051921606064, -0.006818007677793503, 0.02033405937254429, 0.0633794441819191, -0.005228388588875532, -0.08191999793052673, -0.01297449879348278, 0.053845856338739395, 0.03929808363318443, -0.020077049732208252, -0.02214508131146431, -0.013564756140112877, 0.026583600789308548, 0.02209284156560898, 0.024685025215148926, -0.001127950963564217, 0.021386293694376945, -0.003708460135385394, 0.03257071226835251, -0.032418858259916306, -0.017657360062003136, -0.016910308972001076, 0.02908387780189514, 0.04942574352025986, -0.021724747493863106, -0.04255339875817299, -0.006205237936228514, 0.033510200679302216, 0.05144225433468819, 0.05830640718340874, 0.010626975446939468, -0.09849679470062256, -0.0007221869309432805, 0.053099457174539566, 0.03629378229379654, -0.015345650725066662, -0.017885038629174232, -0.03989964723587036, -0.01548716425895691, 0.030809924006462097, -0.039024531841278076, -0.01780129037797451, -0.006652615498751402, -0.022402983158826828, -0.027774307876825333, -0.03463158756494522, -0.02479678764939308, 0.026093266904354095, -0.032665133476257324, 0.06162339076399803, -0.026879258453845978, -0.03284107893705368, -0.05323455482721329, 0.037220872938632965, 0.007228065747767687, 0.08897789567708969, 0.018689164891839027, -0.02739454060792923, -0.004761276300996542, 0.027190711349248886, -0.008849098347127438, -0.03543516993522644, -0.006569897290319204, 0.006609614007174969, -0.015904279425740242, 0.03304193168878555, 0.028726670891046524, -0.07203815877437592, 0.019186776131391525, 0.021842630580067635, -0.03285593166947365, -0.024635935202240944, -0.04533722624182701, 0.018283359706401825, 0.001862815348431468, 0.04247200861573219, 0.03941437602043152, 0.012398995459079742, 0.03427505865693092, 0.01570582203567028, -0.020078236237168312, 0.0049265306442976, -0.03868652507662773, -0.04048090800642967, -0.025680772960186005, -0.019138669595122337, -0.01544906385242939, 0.06010895222425461, 0.01129315048456192, 0.057207345962524414, -0.00498261908069253, 0.0019987537525594234, 0.011167438700795174, 0.049797508865594864, 0.011754683218896389, -0.016994260251522064, -0.017297355458140373, 0.04838557541370392, -0.014129284769296646, -0.016793115064501762, 0.011347387917339802, -0.0052807144820690155, 0.032278597354888916, 0.036813151091337204, -0.04317876696586609, 0.0115119107067585, -0.04807766154408455, -0.00031415082048624754, 0.020645922049880028, -0.03912106156349182, 0.05799563229084015, -0.013498544692993164, 0.01919330656528473, -0.006292982492595911, -0.01001103688031435, -0.00857530813664198, -0.007808428257703781, -0.02414151281118393, 0.04053157940506935, -0.0607929453253746, 0.04520523175597191, -0.009873908013105392, -0.0045375218614935875, -0.09252245724201202, -0.03434555232524872, 0.01458749920129776, 0.007126909215003252, -0.029489286243915558, -0.031575288623571396, 0.018302328884601593, -0.01596282608807087, -0.037062615156173706, -0.03323737159371376, 0.06598207354545593, -0.022755388170480728, -0.04164506494998932, -0.026884788647294044, 0.03855298087000847, 0.0633067861199379, -0.00211702729575336, -0.021937735378742218, 0.030441628769040108, -0.02408275566995144, -0.031066272407770157, 0.02060263603925705, 0.013017053715884686, -0.04524318128824234, -0.007554383482784033, -0.06672819703817368, -0.011733497492969036, -0.012676640413701534, 0.02181920036673546, 0.0346202626824379, 0.005639286246150732, -0.018718572333455086, 0.025109076872467995, -0.006636748556047678, 0.0021950870286673307, 0.01494628470391035, -0.020164303481578827, 0.015014863573014736, 0.013818426057696342, 0.014932322315871716, 0.006562315858900547, 0.03237253427505493, 0.030183104798197746, 0.000781094073317945, 0.0060636005364358425, 0.06065445765852928, -0.04471815377473831, 0.01663212478160858, -0.024637283757328987, -0.023157654330134392, 0.038651902228593826, -0.0059440406039357185, -0.0006011927616782486, -0.008134284988045692, 0.06295106559991837, -0.005229156464338303, -0.033586133271455765, -0.043788518756628036, 0.04902059584856033, 0.03464381396770477, -0.010621299967169762, 0.027021734043955803, 0.06167776510119438, 0.023045439273118973, 0.004484049044549465, -0.044666837900877, -0.031973935663700104, -0.015344128012657166, -0.021187452599406242, 0.037760984152555466, 0.023387538269162178, 0.028422337025403976, 0.006989226210862398, -0.007159782107919455, 0.006522969342768192, 0.05441122129559517, -0.006369647569954395, 0.023194247856736183, 0.04985571652650833, -0.04136620834469795, -0.026939135044813156, -0.03005877323448658, -0.009799225255846977, 0.01766233891248703, -0.007433011662214994, -0.015247954055666924, 0.034280866384506226, 0.006329223047941923, 0.045346006751060486, -0.03654668107628822, -0.023449702188372612, -0.04274654760956764, 0.009565305896103382, 0.03418418765068054, -0.03746064007282257, 0.06096956878900528, 0.02529202029109001, -0.01210524421185255, 0.030448058620095253, 0.008259161375463009, -0.03703838959336281, -0.06745270639657974, -0.02522789128124714, -0.003033171407878399, -0.018688829615712166, 0.04025018587708473, 0.04107556864619255, -0.047698795795440674, -0.016627121716737747, -0.009318570606410503, 0.010028827004134655, 0.006608760450035334, 0.04076097160577774, 0.016585197299718857, 0.03731318190693855, 0.010040713474154472, 0.014316845685243607, 0.010823346674442291, 0.02431238256394863, 0.10887493193149567, 0.12199897319078445, -0.010076414793729782, -0.04334161803126335, 0.014617078006267548, 0.013495049439370632, -0.013930397108197212, -0.018763268366456032, -0.004482676740735769, 0.004810548387467861, -0.006365095730870962, 0.016645871102809906, -0.005294409114867449, 0.010192487388849258, 0.023550163954496384, 0.06015155091881752, -0.04342297464609146, -0.0005270579713396728, -0.013107281178236008, 0.045180972665548325, 0.025665661320090294, 0.001658007618971169, -0.03901372849941254, 0.018856480717658997, -0.0018995594000443816, -0.006012606434524059, -0.011563696898519993, -0.002657204633578658, 0.013229475356638432, -0.01584734208881855, 0.00550535274669528, -0.025888776406645775, 0.006990430410951376, -0.022039761766791344, -0.018832547590136528, 0.0028592729941010475, 0.005989009514451027, -0.01877405121922493, 0.020549004897475243, 0.023260032758116722, -0.016968771815299988, -0.025244466960430145, 0.004914441145956516, 0.009918538853526115, -0.03120143711566925, -0.04398924112319946, -0.05751839280128479, 0.04047563672065735, 0.021148018538951874, 0.0037207710556685925, -0.01621401309967041, 0.00817817635834217, 0.025211196392774582, -0.03741898387670517, -0.01755564846098423, 0.025637466460466385, 0.037854377180337906, -0.014809408225119114, -0.04840810224413872, -0.00887405127286911, 0.029679100960493088, 0.005508739035576582, 0.031775373965501785, 0.02880365215241909, -0.035181675106287, -0.02155287377536297, -0.011249513365328312, 0.018022306263446808, -0.0002229796227766201, -0.00695552583783865, 0.017090903595089912, -0.047545917332172394, -0.008207220584154129, 0.005078149959445, 0.024501673877239227, 0.028721969574689865, 0.03823674097657204, -0.04259846732020378, -0.020269257947802544, -0.033415306359529495, -0.05549168214201927, -0.0004685197491198778, -0.02791113406419754, 0.01445396151393652, -0.03706922382116318, 0.016778670251369476, -0.025913434103131294, 0.03750342130661011, 0.026744460687041283, 0.02930344268679619, -0.014447920955717564, 0.05927981808781624, -0.008419138379395008, -0.016555912792682648, -0.0064208791591227055, -0.025191079825162888, -0.04538251459598541, 0.025523897260427475, -0.004678079392760992, 0.05875690281391144, 0.0058381566777825356, -0.024189315736293793, 0.027460122480988503, 0.044347137212753296, -0.014883346855640411, 0.016802111640572548, -0.004402322228997946, -0.07975761592388153, 0.015591821633279324, 0.006127288565039635, -0.019233498722314835, -0.03423573449254036, -0.005861904937773943, -0.008386372588574886, -0.023173969238996506, 0.01171274296939373, 0.017458846792578697, -0.043757181614637375, 0.03684629127383232, -0.02225470542907715, 0.04779202491044998, -0.0192536860704422, -0.0010081185027956963, -0.028657378628849983, 0.020675111562013626, -0.027654524892568588, -0.029084686189889908, -0.010079373605549335, -0.0027400364633649588, 0.013574838638305664, 0.00004546397030935623, 0.02056080847978592, 0.0059597073122859, 0.0318726971745491, -0.013146103359758854, -0.002389604225754738, -0.004447095561772585, 0.026953017339110374, -0.034173209220170975, -0.025794517248868942, 0.032797638326883316, -0.034909628331661224, -0.018132824450731277, 0.040832482278347015, -0.010962444357573986, 0.046900343149900436, 0.03685704991221428, 0.005580377299338579, -0.020642869174480438, 0.0350978821516037, -0.018918674439191818, -0.018646812066435814, -0.01052530761808157, 0.05549132078886032, -0.0003584517980925739, 0.006265374831855297, 0.025357522070407867, 0.0013610217720270157, -0.013514785096049309, -0.013167330995202065, 0.040375176817178726, 0.014907246455550194, -0.03172658756375313, 0.01871335320174694, 0.017089733853936195, 0.06636630743741989, -0.01146019622683525, 0.03466002270579338, 0.04581109434366226, 0.03511182963848114, -0.035750094801187515, 0.0342797227203846, 0.003048816928640008, 0.03635866567492485, -0.08668667078018188, -0.028818337246775627, 0.020750341936945915, -0.004687503445893526, 0.0351053923368454, -0.03535298630595207, 0.02446671947836876, 0.08720043301582336, -0.0530196912586689, 0.020026331767439842, -0.018851827830076218, -0.0033170555252581835, -0.0428503081202507, -0.02827855944633484, -0.03683450445532799, 0.01175118051469326, 0.03660000115633011, 0.03797965869307518, 0.0388999879360199, 0.0023573667276650667, -0.013515392318367958, -0.04641372337937355, -0.010048889555037022, 0.04441449046134949, 0.002265345072373748, -0.04799390584230423, 0.034830205142498016, -0.027399994432926178, -0.01280406303703785, 0.014309885911643505, 0.011122535914182663, 0.013870535418391228, 0.041373319923877716, 0.05712318792939186, -0.021188700571656227, 0.09072308987379074, 0.01705360971391201, -0.01742462068796158, 0.02388152666389942, -0.009607000276446342, -0.02493947185575962, 0.017632516101002693, -0.016399243846535683, 0.029951713979244232, 0.02799893356859684, -0.011060958728194237, -0.03881734609603882, -0.007970971055328846, -0.002555775223299861, -0.03093460202217102, -0.001167493173852563, -0.017063619568943977, 0.010092413984239101, -0.017767811194062233, 0.0258067287504673, -0.04894021898508072, 0.003658190369606018, 0.015748966485261917, 0.015752995386719704, -0.021297268569469452, 0.016778284683823586, -0.05872004106640816, -0.05073178559541702, -0.022345751523971558, -0.012649942189455032, -0.026580490171909332, -0.09061627835035324, 0.023236626759171486, 0.041200190782547, -0.027531156316399574, -0.052346549928188324, -0.011204983107745647, -0.019076313823461533, 0.06466113775968552, 0.0009375739609822631, 0.02497660368680954, 0.029227839782834053, -0.004760976415127516, -0.0074718124233186245, -0.06640344858169556, 0.06518453359603882, -0.006348961964249611, -0.01292643416672945, 0.011499662883579731, -0.027656754478812218, -0.0006951825344003737, -0.01175748836249113, 0.028968557715415955, 0.0035492978058755398, 0.006666266825050116, 0.0007537175551988184, 0.018080048263072968, 0.006957877893000841, -0.01620752178132534, 0.013839300721883774, 0.012760027311742306, -0.008066967129707336, -0.02872348204255104, -0.014773949980735779, 0.011048276908695698, -0.021711336448788643, 0.035812247544527054, 0.016546213999390602, -0.014407346956431866, 0.029312359169125557, -0.005196231417357922, 0.020439935848116875, 0.04361642524600029, 0.01652216538786888, 0.026902759447693825, 0.001815436757169664, -0.007635170128196478, 0.02176719531416893, 0.014729868620634079, -0.077405646443367, 0.014187964610755444, -0.020345168188214302, 0.0007114398758858442, 0.01271078921854496, 0.016508547589182854, -0.0078238220885396, -0.04287201166152954, -0.006159776821732521, 0.02966635301709175, -0.0018906939076259732, 0.02857869863510132, 0.034421466290950775, -0.015851259231567383, 0.02872052602469921, 0.007074978668242693, 0.007163349539041519, 0.03000780940055847, 0.013146881014108658, -0.030010532587766647, 0.014057510532438755, 0.007824010215699673, 0.002056133234873414, 0.02328772284090519, 0.026624249294400215, -0.029419593513011932, 0.019128577783703804, 0.0007361379102803767, -0.0007673269137740135, -0.028498271480202675, -0.018312502652406693, -0.0011270246468484402, -0.015141671523451805, -0.01589234732091427, 0.005791934672743082, -0.013859698548913002, 0.03071635402739048, -0.024961454793810844, -0.023135188966989517, -0.07805292308330536, -0.02155577950179577, -0.012637147679924965, 0.017544861882925034, 0.005123971030116081, 0.04331349581480026, -0.007328348234295845, 0.010777808725833893, 0.022313091903924942, 0.004251083359122276, 0.056514378637075424, -0.039257150143384933, 0.04438755661249161, -0.037547461688518524, 0.01170843094587326, -0.03384018316864967, -0.018702499568462372, -0.008465293794870377, -0.008598354645073414, 0.020609412342309952, 0.0722629502415657, 0.032642118632793427, -0.006095349323004484, -0.038163140416145325, -0.02871006540954113, 0.007752773817628622, -0.08336595445871353, -0.010089808143675327, -0.02643980272114277, -0.004918794613331556, -0.03751688450574875, -0.03474799916148186 ]
<p>I have two models - one is including a categorical covariate as a fixed effect, the other includes it as a random effect:</p> <pre><code>require(nlme) set.seed(123) n &lt;- 100 k &lt;- 5 cat &lt;- as.factor(rep(1:k, n)) cat_i &lt;- 1:k # intercept per kategorie x &lt;- rep(1:n, each = k) sigma &lt;- 0.2 alpha &lt;- 0.001 y &lt;- cat_i[cat] + alpha * x + rnorm(n*k, 0, sigma) plot(x, y) m2 &lt;- lm(y ~ cat + x) summary(m2) m3 &lt;- lme(y ~ x, random = ~ 1|cat, na.action = na.omit) summary(m3) </code></pre> <p>As you can see, both models <code>m2</code> and <code>m3</code> produce exactly the same coefficient estimate for x (including SE). Also the residual standard error is the same. The same result is produced when I simulate some missing data:</p> <pre><code># simulate missing data y[c(1:(n/2), (n*k-n/2):(n*k))] &lt;- NA m2 &lt;- lm(y ~ cat + x) summary(m2) m3 &lt;- lme(y ~ x, random = ~ 1|cat, na.action = na.omit) summary(m3) </code></pre> <p>So can we say in general that adding effect as random will have the same impact on the other coefficients and the overall inference as adding it as fixed? If not, can you please provide a simple example (or change the provided one) when this fails?</p>
74,322
[ -0.021745385602116585, 0.02979457378387451, -0.003060453338548541, -0.003948200959712267, 0.022641226649284363, -0.004212170373648405, 0.02137189917266369, -0.054175835102796555, 0.06105688959360123, -0.04690590128302574, 0.028444642201066017, 0.03507200628519058, 0.07985597848892212, 0.022901056334376335, 0.002938307588919997, -0.016219735145568848, -0.037022680044174194, -0.0022643988486379385, 0.012823343276977539, -0.014501379802823067, -0.0360276959836483, 0.06143941730260849, 0.010221799835562706, -0.019214699044823647, -0.012446215376257896, 0.02914517931640148, 0.029268836602568626, -0.04247122257947922, 0.02566341869533062, 0.009362793527543545, -0.03647669404745102, -0.0056078494526445866, 0.0031357137486338615, 0.01422637328505516, -0.01813548617064953, 0.004394997842609882, -0.0007796687423251569, -0.04942375794053078, 0.005579024087637663, 0.026392487809062004, 0.01640397682785988, 0.02297339402139187, -0.020810594782233238, 0.026895102113485336, 0.005829985253512859, 0.02019752934575081, -0.03719344735145569, 0.008568046614527702, 0.06375238299369812, 0.001190967857837677, 0.05216042697429657, -0.012040909379720688, 0.041723333299160004, 0.03324461728334427, -0.048843227326869965, -0.00820089504122734, 0.04159914702177048, 0.05755705013871193, -0.01576078310608864, -0.0320134162902832, -0.014291439205408096, -0.06479369103908539, 0.000010034068509412464, -0.00038851951831020415, -0.03187401592731476, -0.01631397195160389, 0.015719348564743996, -0.014829923398792744, 0.04909580573439598, -0.028087954968214035, 0.02174999564886093, 0.01677093282341957, 0.027274731546640396, 0.02551758475601673, 0.04109546169638634, -0.03481214866042137, 0.02364908903837204, 0.026952560991048813, 0.019604189321398735, 0.03268254175782204, 0.011563430540263653, 0.02711866982281208, 0.03918186575174332, 0.0598013736307621, -0.006285876501351595, -0.005732575431466103, 0.025601716712117195, -0.026747308671474457, 0.022664017975330353, -0.014440068043768406, -0.01942565105855465, 0.0021479048300534487, 0.04490260034799576, 0.013125237077474594, -0.05875337868928909, 0.03336357697844505, -0.007056513801217079, 0.022455185651779175, 0.045539017766714096, 0.01904294826090336, -0.04160255938768387, -0.0541607066988945, 0.03672481328248978, 0.047392673790454865, -0.018051909282803535, -0.022252550348639488, -0.023546511307358742, 0.02431725710630417, -0.026483090594410896, -0.01742412894964218, -0.010589494369924068, 0.012880590744316578, 0.0009165897499769926, -0.00623664166778326, 0.042050801217556, -0.02962064929306507, -0.030232258141040802, -0.007943585515022278, 0.06483832001686096, 0.08673986792564392, 0.059026170521974564, -0.023390142247080803, 0.01462333183735609, -0.025517253205180168, -0.01768069714307785, -0.008598225191235542, 0.005626000929623842, -0.03812476620078087, -0.014436902478337288, 0.0263961311429739, -0.012452451512217522, -0.014369938522577286, 0.035375017672777176, 0.007511116564273834, 0.07163705676794052, -0.011824210174381733, -0.09218844026327133, -0.06620699912309647, -0.029521722346544266, -0.02843930944800377, 0.03906485438346863, -0.048830173909664154, -0.02435937337577343, 0.02483413740992546, 0.06477920711040497, 0.043768491595983505, 0.01876920461654663, 0.01059365551918745, 0.01683804951608181, 0.03541279211640358, -0.033391039818525314, -0.021522747352719307, -0.037645839154720306, -0.03376321867108345, -0.07929226756095886, -0.08057890832424164, 0.015644073486328125, 0.032800089567899704, -0.01600581593811512, 0.005401258822530508, 0.0264875665307045, -0.0027041162829846144, -0.00559278903529048, 0.004187983926385641, 0.01374033559113741, -0.03858248144388199, 0.0725647583603859, 0.00785970501601696, 0.05467049777507782, 0.016331631690263748, -0.01569209434092045, 0.014189309440553188, 0.015028239227831364, 0.06491851061582565, 0.025177625939249992, -0.016212813556194305, 0.012609421275556087, 0.018315283581614494, 0.04132876172661781, 0.03403414040803909, -0.07547660171985626, -0.024798784404993057, -0.03815634921193123, -0.030313262715935707, 0.02439868450164795, 0.037715934216976166, 0.012453903444111347, -0.019874921068549156, 0.05731135606765747, -0.03340950980782509, -0.06723539531230927, -0.05458355322480202, 0.01047075167298317, 0.02117166295647621, -0.010382182896137238, 0.013609047047793865, -0.00970296561717987, 0.06053008884191513, 0.011299608275294304, -0.007065424229949713, -0.040468450635671616, -0.02555154822766781, 0.010739104822278023, 0.00017347457469440997, 0.019578566774725914, 0.020822186022996902, 0.03763752058148384, -0.015458324924111366, 0.0527009554207325, -0.02833697944879532, -0.03758430853486061, 0.0154207032173872, -0.0310590248554945, -0.012900659814476967, 0.0030683770310133696, -0.01249146182090044, 0.02100237086415291, -0.01952204294502735, -0.013540002517402172, 0.04603132605552673, -0.07202938199043274, 0.05919391289353371, 0.05739758908748627, 0.022709941491484642, -0.005694345571100712, 0.032553911209106445, 0.007330903317779303, -0.0034433389082551003, -0.025002678856253624, -0.012063340283930302, -0.012952190823853016, -0.017502618953585625, 0.06923584640026093, 0.006131553556770086, -0.048337921500205994, 0.013149494305253029, 0.036198098212480545, -0.03759351372718811, 0.024081068113446236, 0.0456402413547039, 0.022818423807621002, -0.008098453283309937, 0.016850247979164124, 0.025815216824412346, 0.041101373732089996, 0.007488914765417576, 0.040346659719944, -0.044937003403902054, 0.021726232022047043, 0.0003517442673910409, -0.007859563454985619, 0.0372513122856617, -0.02802768349647522, -0.005335521884262562, -0.03137790039181709, -0.03543021157383919, 0.034084659069776535, 0.014591015875339508, 0.009017116390168667, 0.049637146294116974, 0.0045860023237764835, -0.007025566883385181, -0.012509098276495934, 0.006509543862193823, 0.02165057882666588, 0.0009181114728562534, -0.0025394714903086424, -0.02988547459244728, 0.004121238365769386, -0.00754701578989625, 0.0056727007031440735, -0.04659541696310043, -0.016662459820508957, -0.04988156259059906, 0.018111804500222206, 0.019237395375967026, -0.036713890731334686, 0.025164879858493805, -0.02946498617529869, -0.01552536990493536, -0.017773408442735672, -0.001247488777153194, 0.0391792431473732, 0.0029516969807446003, -0.046068109571933746, 0.004672148730605841, -0.019768930971622467, 0.007537588477134705, 0.03951161727309227, -0.024757781997323036, -0.03346264734864235, 0.038085635751485825, -0.036628562957048416, -0.044183988124132156, -0.012286558747291565, -0.026300102472305298, 0.024187365546822548, -0.016855154186487198, -0.03938465937972069, 0.019323302432894707, 0.014684991911053658, -0.041571784764528275, 0.03792448714375496, -0.02738114446401596, -0.0009953469270840287, -0.017059482634067535, -0.009082304313778877, 0.02741161175072193, -0.01913648098707199, 0.01289339829236269, 0.028425751253962517, 0.0024356429930776358, -0.01824546791613102, -0.08266377449035645, -0.04497341066598892, 0.032481446862220764, -0.005336083937436342, 0.009936399757862091, -0.008419230580329895, 0.0160087700933218, 0.08073931187391281, 0.040937963873147964, -0.005439721513539553, -0.04287248104810715, -0.017732225358486176, -0.016290439292788506, -0.02256161905825138, 0.01339283213019371, -0.018037226051092148, 0.024630337953567505, 0.05664170905947685, -0.016273092478513718, 0.01526587177067995, 0.028383415192365646, -0.0014750441769137979, 0.00028002404724247754, 0.018309060484170914, 0.009991536848247051, -0.03555939346551895, 0.05045834183692932, 0.04185512661933899, -0.02903664857149124, -0.0037439479492604733, 0.003556294599547982, 0.03570039942860603, 0.01802324503660202, -0.05665804073214531, -0.014880909584462643, -0.04611164331436157, 0.015394897200167179, -0.03625231608748436, 0.028458693996071815, 0.019630232825875282, -0.0504152737557888, -0.02385479025542736, 0.007934416644275188, 0.03401864692568779, -0.008171475492417812, -0.01669466868042946, 0.06603464484214783, 0.05015438050031662, 0.0019739335402846336, 0.0023815298918634653, -0.011630198918282986, 0.0015361018013209105, 0.045682258903980255, -0.03731252998113632, 0.03046908602118492, 0.05373428389430046, -0.0015815113438293338, 0.01429135724902153, -0.008973083458840847, -0.021921593695878983, 0.01333821564912796, -0.06448226422071457, 0.019158609211444855, -0.04743540659546852, 0.05968817323446274, 0.015484316274523735, 0.02060004696249962, 0.005308140069246292, -0.0107428515329957, -0.029416412115097046, 0.015147355385124683, -0.07536353170871735, -0.007983529940247536, 0.011694259010255337, -0.0323527567088604, -0.0007702857838012278, -0.03232600912451744, 0.004545231349766254, -0.001430727425031364, 0.0046262782998383045, -0.010883663780987263, -0.01987643353641033, -0.01403047051280737, 0.006131935864686966, -0.0302275363355875, -0.010855501517653465, 0.0017811257857829332, -0.005189483053982258, 0.008264081552624702, -0.035264115780591965, 0.005572216585278511, 0.009751908481121063, 0.014571522362530231, -0.0059126378037035465, -0.03905636817216873, -0.006950296927243471, -0.008529910817742348, 0.038585416972637177, 0.07717382907867432, 0.017614910379052162, -0.043655477464199066, 0.03125175088644028, 0.012170248664915562, 0.018305040895938873, 0.04713411629199982, 0.017996685579419136, 0.0097273550927639, -0.007351998705416918, -0.028880080208182335, -0.000594896322581917, 0.018218738958239555, -0.018055764958262444, -0.020116297528147697, 0.050555139780044556, 0.07805473357439041, -0.024234207347035408, 0.03893888741731644, 0.05358848720788956, 0.009948711842298508, -0.007234795484691858, -0.04439900815486908, 0.027177251875400543, -0.0014034344349056482, -0.008355159312486649, 0.023425037041306496, 0.003630548482760787, 0.018125498667359352, -0.0016131279990077019, 0.02382754161953926, -0.05166644975543022, -0.03764764592051506, 0.014014346525073051, 0.05137743428349495, 0.014445479959249496, -0.01609950326383114, -0.007036455906927586, 0.003071567742154002, 0.03459526598453522, -0.012378605082631111, 0.03343525156378746, -0.024141576141119003, -0.08350437134504318, 0.015996234491467476, 0.05642237886786461, 0.03128323704004288, -0.04203120619058609, -0.00769174937158823, -0.040382735431194305, -0.00019465596415102482, -0.012501372955739498, -0.01521973218768835, 0.008628969080746174, -0.01750202290713787, 0.02578071877360344, 0.009404386393725872, -0.01754322461783886, -0.05179945379495621, 0.03482167422771454, -0.016062650829553604, 0.061442967504262924, -0.03272150829434395, -0.039874058216810226, -0.012465176172554493, 0.013385215774178505, 0.043387558311223984, 0.05920950695872307, -0.016745416447520256, -0.0443669818341732, 0.013295022770762444, 0.019233673810958862, -0.011634452268481255, -0.05977390334010124, 0.03959423303604126, -0.004150499124079943, -0.0115088801831007, 0.04189055785536766, -0.012209916487336159, 0.03280133008956909, 0.02137025259435177, 0.022296054288744926, 0.005345882847905159, -0.021823473274707794, -0.026149019598960876, 0.055085454136133194, 0.03915897384285927, 0.013812401331961155, 0.05116351321339607, -0.0020156537648290396, 0.012902956455945969, 0.022350281476974487, -0.05106688663363457, 0.012524118646979332, 0.0016919606132432818, -0.021037286147475243, -0.0826885849237442, -0.027631068602204323, 0.024059031158685684, 0.011486428789794445, 0.010057264938950539, -0.002661145059391856, -0.04849150776863098, -0.03912739455699921, 0.026342129334807396, 0.012612336315214634, 0.026344414800405502, 0.039106596261262894, -0.004444228019565344, -0.0004084352112840861, -0.0015337382210418582, -0.01976620778441429, 0.008072865195572376, 0.010854518972337246, 0.002108129905536771, 0.0024964683689177036, -0.016225457191467285, -0.0017979757394641638, 0.013056442141532898, -0.02178247459232807, 0.0018540665041655302, -0.024378987029194832, -0.0048355404287576675, -0.023591065779328346, 0.06978769600391388, -0.027849959209561348, -0.032281581312417984, 0.017775235697627068, 0.021006420254707336, -0.04375828430056572, 0.004790135659277439, -0.02712707407772541, 0.036786746233701706, 0.017227983102202415, -0.0014879675582051277, -0.08067017793655396, -0.05884765461087227, -0.02846463955938816, -0.016592981293797493, -0.022874992340803146, 0.007966234348714352, -0.04689120873808861, -0.036008071154356, -0.020391050726175308, -0.013086055405437946, 0.06717932969331741, -0.04315181449055672, -0.012059888802468777, -0.023932982236146927, 0.013103583827614784, 0.06404997408390045, 0.0022559394128620625, -0.025744551792740822, 0.01267015840858221, -0.05025668814778328, -0.0184667706489563, 0.015422029420733452, 0.022615527734160423, -0.02016366831958294, -0.025787102058529854, -0.04444408789277077, 0.00857993122190237, 0.05454430356621742, -0.009686937555670738, -0.017974721267819405, 0.039075374603271484, -0.011810175143182278, 0.04561752825975418, -0.05172549560666084, -0.013638440519571304, 0.010167711414396763, 0.029037289321422577, -0.0029996996745467186, 0.03486571088433266, 0.003947543445974588, 0.010029485449194908, 0.02943246066570282, -0.013041065074503422, -0.039129532873630524, 0.015169934369623661, 0.08444011956453323, -0.03863358870148659, 0.01220371201634407, -0.004017067141830921, -0.0007316166302189231, 0.05735725909471512, 0.025875447317957878, 0.002430777996778488, -0.0003215646429453045, -0.01143619418144226, -0.015376701019704342, -0.01019270345568657, -0.03835158422589302, 0.016635986045002937, 0.03614211454987526, -0.03626743331551552, -0.0061669605784118176, 0.031655747443437576, -0.02514406479895115, -0.0032931938767433167, -0.04229595139622688, -0.006037366576492786, -0.019605183973908424, 0.0032428300473839045, 0.06602147966623306, -0.024018391966819763, -0.029444638639688492, 0.018631501123309135, 0.03845703601837158, 0.01972690224647522, 0.004278669599443674, 0.005755925085395575, 0.025331100448966026, 0.03174620494246483, -0.004329663701355457, -0.03414810076355934, 0.01586734689772129, -0.05212102085351944, 0.014325490221381187, -0.06543917953968048, -0.024424729868769646, 0.03327680006623268, 0.03360222280025482, -0.015496351756155491, -0.054466962814331055, -0.01472140196710825, -0.04055183753371239, 0.007300170604139566, 0.01584092527627945, 0.006791230291128159, 0.04625708982348442, -0.042562905699014664, 0.06390099227428436, 0.0008248774684034288, 0.04343119636178017, -0.03277714177966118, -0.12316938489675522, -0.05553010478615761, -0.006484657526016235, 0.034402359277009964, 0.019735004752874374, -0.005156886298209429, -0.005687529221177101, 0.034898314625024796, -0.07153017818927765, 0.04280893877148628, 0.016285086050629616, 0.020871272310614586, 0.014730017632246017, 0.06717535853385925, -0.0036171807441860437, 0.016688046976923943, -0.0391644649207592, -0.0169904213398695, 0.11622902005910873, 0.06768108159303665, 0.052801962941884995, -0.07204744219779968, 0.016157452017068863, 0.034510478377342224, 0.029846467077732086, 0.03129224106669426, -0.015053431503474712, 0.035871393978595734, -0.019322579726576805, 0.06662636250257492, 0.04457367584109306, 0.021626075729727745, 0.0024765636771917343, 0.009449286386370659, -0.05469401180744171, -0.009537488222122192, -0.0040050167590379715, -0.019553283229470253, 0.005034835077822208, -0.022353291511535645, -0.05489054694771767, -0.02295146882534027, 0.0020487012807279825, 0.005728271324187517, -0.019017579033970833, -0.015295987017452717, -0.017278963699936867, 0.05441350117325783, -0.029469143599271774, 0.049415867775678635, 0.014968421310186386, 0.015805553644895554, 0.013911771588027477, -0.032362304627895355, 0.03453665226697922, -0.026787392795085907, 0.037188488990068436, 0.04623068869113922, 0.00964064709842205, -0.01609254628419876, 0.03241618350148201, 0.029023459181189537, -0.03566604480147362, -0.04214028641581535, -0.015963643789291382, 0.0709720253944397, 0.004569400567561388, -0.013257939368486404, -0.02464197762310505, -0.030707672238349915, -0.026579599827528, -0.02071218751370907, -0.014349361881613731, 0.025911379605531693, 0.021662389859557152, 0.004211149178445339, 0.01054026186466217, 0.02803942561149597, 0.035760872066020966, 0.007184445858001709, 0.025841131806373596, 0.024611767381429672, -0.006185634061694145, -0.00754956342279911, -0.004246414173394442, 0.04565043747425079, 0.0261002779006958, 0.010098358616232872, 0.01180176716297865, -0.021839717403054237, -0.03741098940372467, -0.027569567784667015, 0.009530303068459034, 0.024059081450104713, 0.03191855549812317, -0.050334472209215164, 0.0197451189160347, -0.008793882094323635, -0.051973748952150345, 0.0007680612034164369, -0.0020739042665809393, -0.027272658422589302, -0.055131737142801285, -0.02353215590119362, 0.03358080983161926, -0.0042072804644703865, 0.007709272671490908, -0.0005176684353500605, -0.007847060449421406, 0.07848984003067017, -0.017153246328234673, -0.04467855021357536, -0.05082206428050995, 0.010740169323980808, -0.02449125051498413, -0.002892704913392663, 0.011408740654587746, 0.01727236621081829, 0.014913884922862053, 0.018883777782320976, -0.011740569025278091, 0.017685968428850174, 0.016649404540657997, -0.0056239767000079155, 0.003016439964994788, -0.02941293455660343, -0.020224811509251595, -0.009734363295137882, 0.0021231439895927906, -0.0002851569151971489, 0.0036048709880560637, -0.05178195983171463, -0.03408361226320267, -0.004114191979169846, -0.027921359986066818, -0.05444798618555069, 0.010435971431434155, 0.004582083318382502, -0.00867499504238367, -0.01780744642019272, -0.010783390142023563, -0.02710067853331566, -0.02983548864722252, 0.02763066627085209, -0.031508009880781174, -0.03610404580831528, 0.03835536539554596, -0.033573541790246964, 0.0075979530811309814, -0.0028006993234157562, -0.00986454077064991, -0.004384575877338648, -0.001266245380975306, -0.004860216286033392, -0.02056620642542839, 0.05083104968070984, -0.034814540296792984, -0.004669581539928913, -0.01531117781996727, -0.021221326664090157, -0.02028902992606163, -0.0027981209568679333, -0.012070712633430958, 0.03062734194099903, 0.03572545945644379, 0.00709083816036582, -0.0019388708751648664, 0.059451594948768616, -0.032001376152038574, -0.010362035594880581, -0.02178816683590412, 0.0037616617046296597, -0.029096627607941628, -0.020007509738206863, 0.005312680266797543, 0.01170607190579176, 0.001554217073135078, 0.039076630026102066, 0.07045955955982208, -0.005165786948055029, 0.005647425539791584, 0.027038725093007088, 0.0038816325832158327, -0.0030684308148920536, 0.018017182126641273, 0.024693302810192108, -0.015752768144011497, 0.02195199579000473, -0.020091744139790535, 0.06358569115400314, -0.01685747690498829, 0.03642992302775383, -0.1102672889828682, -0.0490514375269413, -0.0035762537736445665, 0.01911102794110775, 0.030762791633605957, -0.009228133596479893, -0.0016541543882340193, 0.013635174371302128, -0.07215805351734161, -0.0004795684653799981, 0.013382316567003727, -0.008660945110023022, -0.042509954422712326, 0.03596533462405205, -0.006403427571058273, -0.016062598675489426, 0.053033459931612015, 0.009601062163710594, 0.02819541096687317, 0.008772595785558224, 0.027865201234817505, -0.009839649312198162, -0.04051396623253822, -0.001491508330218494, 0.024555649608373642, -0.04195287451148033, 0.003279301105067134, -0.020473333075642586, -0.0457044392824173, 0.0037228488363325596, -0.003129160962998867, 0.013657886534929276, 0.007935706526041031, 0.036567214876413345, 0.007963914424180984, 0.040765468031167984, 0.00683817220851779, 0.015803618356585503, 0.010021338239312172, -0.019818833097815514, 0.024029111489653587, 0.020669132471084595, -0.008719315752387047, 0.016752272844314575, 0.01587611809372902, -0.0003289406013209373, 0.01029199082404375, 0.013722856529057026, -0.001495899516157806, -0.022780578583478928, -0.0016852169064804912, 0.01202221680432558, 0.018594540655612946, -0.0029745756182819605, 0.008679217658936977, -0.04440879821777344, 0.009548143483698368, 0.06758562475442886, 0.02169482782483101, -0.008817926980555058, -0.01205705851316452, -0.023686328902840614, -0.015427500940859318, 0.000551012868527323, 0.028052978217601776, -0.022850558161735535, -0.046380333602428436, -0.013988791964948177, -0.008360607549548149, 0.0018070695223286748, 0.007444917224347591, 0.002691253088414669, -0.041204098612070084, 0.04825523495674133, -0.016379768028855324, 0.0008685940993018448, -0.01596728339791298, -0.006695014424622059, 0.02845916710793972, -0.07356450706720352, 0.04725869372487068, 0.0053356415592134, -0.005348970182240009, -0.058747969567775726, 0.021041160449385643, -0.0026719977613538504, 0.04656163230538368, 0.023180600255727768, -0.0017634420655667782, 0.00364102516323328, -0.009817441925406456, 0.03493321314454079, 0.021694177761673927, -0.05736595019698143, 0.04567131772637367, 0.019322963431477547, -0.013728742487728596, -0.01959017477929592, -0.0345362052321434, -0.0061347284354269505, 0.026373770087957382, 0.030942875891923904, -0.022806670516729355, 0.032265521585941315, -0.01845964789390564, -0.004265588708221912, 0.008096071891486645, -0.020176568999886513, 0.0010056177852675319, 0.04018497094511986, 0.013914454728364944, 0.029877357184886932, 0.009625946171581745, 0.026080956682562828, -0.03466823324561119, 0.049702517688274384, -0.030027367174625397, -0.02463371679186821, 0.002691487083211541, -0.01873745582997799, -0.026975762099027634, -0.05775300785899162, -0.005879371426999569, 0.022159699350595474, -0.008135925978422165, -0.0216476209461689, 0.00828640814870596, 0.03579472377896309, 0.02511966973543167, 0.006161185912787914, 0.0020833881571888924, -0.0007085188990458846, 0.021185416728258133, 0.04769065976142883, 0.01449094619601965, 0.0004855122824665159, 0.0011357637122273445, -0.0029843037482351065, -0.0049948361702263355, -0.024770788848400116, -0.005452878773212433, -0.04041095823049545, 0.07480686902999878, -0.023877376690506935, -0.02493874356150627, 0.028077425435185432, 0.011198618449270725, 0.044357992708683014, -0.01939546689391136, 0.005371707491576672, 0.0336846187710762, -0.04946533963084221, 0.04894361272454262, -0.025267546996474266, -0.0130477175116539, 0.0006394759402610362, -0.03406042605638504, -0.013296296820044518, 0.019546179100871086, 0.004773859865963459, -0.02827654406428337, 0.0034859534353017807, -0.04164164513349533, 0.020672842860221863, -0.04363936558365822, -0.0005159549764357507, -0.040255483239889145, -0.007442479953169823, -0.030408594757318497, -0.03462192043662071, -0.020121246576309204, -0.04293019697070122, 0.021948745474219322, 0.04649890586733818, -0.006051329430192709, -0.05332093685865402, -0.04895326495170593, 0.00825305562466383, 0.045334890484809875, -0.05563400685787201, -0.005156415980309248, -0.00575846154242754, 0.03952890634536743, 0.025891033932566643, -0.009662605822086334 ]
<p>I have always been taught that random effects only influence the variance (error), and that fixed effects only influence the mean. But I have found an example where random effects influence also the mean - the coefficient estimate:</p> <pre><code>require(nlme) set.seed(128) n &lt;- 100 k &lt;- 5 cat &lt;- as.factor(rep(1:k, each = n)) cat_i &lt;- 1:k # intercept per kategorie x &lt;- rep(1:n, k) sigma &lt;- 0.2 alpha &lt;- 0.001 y &lt;- cat_i[cat] + alpha * x + rnorm(n*k, 0, sigma) plot(x, y) # simulate missing data y[c(1:(n/2), (n*k-n/2):(n*k))] &lt;- NA m1 &lt;- lm(y ~ x) summary(m1) m2 &lt;- lm(y ~ cat + x) summary(m2) m3 &lt;- lme(y ~ x, random = ~ 1|cat, na.action = na.omit) summary(m3) </code></pre> <p>You can see that the estimated coefficient for <code>x</code> from model <code>m1</code> is -0.013780, while from model <code>m3</code> it is 0.0011713 - both significantly different from zero.</p> <p>Note that when I remove the line simulating missing data, the results are the same (it is full matrix).</p> <p>Why is that?</p> <p>PS: please note I am not a professional statistician, so if you are about to respond with a lot of math then please make also some simple summary for dummies :-)</p>
74,323
[ -0.038058534264564514, 0.023646164685487747, -0.02530214935541153, 0.00447836285457015, 0.027028582990169525, 0.000026321013137931004, 0.014594068750739098, -0.038652293384075165, 0.04445770010352135, -0.05980430543422699, 0.007118831388652325, 0.037303946912288666, 0.06183336675167084, 0.035310711711645126, 0.011240036226809025, -0.005693577695637941, -0.022492313757538795, 0.005576041992753744, 0.018946226686239243, -0.01059744507074356, -0.036472976207733154, 0.05321916192770004, 0.008941208012402058, -0.00337937381118536, -0.014537317678332329, 0.054643090814352036, 0.030878396704792976, -0.04106701910495758, 0.02336651086807251, 0.024686068296432495, -0.037994176149368286, -0.018528135493397713, 0.0032832236029207706, 0.0030640787445008755, 0.0028310029301792383, 0.02795438840985298, -0.015248428098857403, -0.036249637603759766, 0.009238392114639282, 0.027040481567382812, 0.016106873750686646, -0.016096610575914383, -0.0210561603307724, 0.032790519297122955, 0.004535444546490908, 0.0062769618816673756, -0.02167935110628605, 0.02325507067143917, 0.08777790516614914, -0.0067048813216388226, 0.04180195555090904, 0.0018934450345113873, 0.04840480536222458, 0.02641470544040203, -0.02249969355762005, -0.005224296357482672, 0.02849365398287773, 0.061305392533540726, -0.036709707230329514, -0.03874834626913071, -0.0017996079986914992, -0.057145457714796066, -0.006083556450903416, -0.008547551929950714, -0.014357976615428925, -0.019137371331453323, 0.0058580320328474045, -0.02845558151602745, 0.061910584568977356, -0.01426039170473814, 0.005851082969456911, 0.028020061552524567, 0.013937492854893208, 0.023004896938800812, 0.02879370003938675, -0.021968025714159012, 0.009287753142416477, 0.0037803419400006533, 0.01125819981098175, 0.05069912597537041, -0.0023055567871779203, 0.022390980273485184, 0.028471287339925766, 0.033076103776693344, 0.0073663415387272835, -0.02057594060897827, 0.043113283812999725, -0.013503837399184704, 0.03306444734334946, 0.0024495075922459364, -0.01030252780765295, 0.025325482711195946, 0.04595061019062996, 0.028742114081978798, -0.06341937184333801, 0.0502348355948925, 0.003447552677243948, 0.032113149762153625, 0.05854925140738487, 0.007127972785383463, -0.02687094546854496, -0.05789676681160927, 0.03401670977473259, 0.03614228218793869, -0.02741565927863121, -0.015769178047776222, -0.02238522469997406, 0.03233322873711586, -0.0299912691116333, -0.026877738535404205, 0.0033954193349927664, 0.005752273835241795, -0.008177672512829304, -0.02865569479763508, 0.02725599892437458, -0.04288449138402939, 0.005056113004684448, -0.0038727913051843643, 0.07750928401947021, 0.08266822248697281, 0.036403506994247437, 0.00024134741397574544, 0.015903403982520103, -0.0390641987323761, -0.04012871906161308, 0.0040998696349561214, 0.007181833498179913, -0.06325609236955643, -0.015911264345049858, 0.02531898394227028, -0.006041756831109524, 0.0007793486001901329, 0.05186868831515312, 0.012593058869242668, 0.05765681713819504, -0.0019340718863531947, -0.09052754193544388, -0.0629333108663559, -0.0028987836558371782, -0.04203537851572037, 0.03690916672348976, -0.038195718079805374, -0.03544265031814575, 0.0205568578094244, 0.05520688369870186, 0.016071651130914688, 0.01236063614487648, 0.0113840876147151, -0.0009928107028827071, 0.03788720443844795, -0.021891705691814423, -0.018506726250052452, -0.025762103497982025, -0.0375170037150383, -0.06066923961043358, -0.04584397375583649, 0.02147044986486435, 0.03299626708030701, -0.031223859637975693, 0.012244969606399536, 0.008936856873333454, 0.013575030490756035, -0.0075042033568024635, -0.001302153803408146, 0.0011260637547820807, -0.03851885348558426, 0.06589013338088989, -0.0021723820827901363, 0.05864541232585907, 0.03475748375058174, -0.01209990307688713, 0.03246002271771431, 0.004371420945972204, 0.059996820986270905, 0.037940312176942825, -0.02124050445854664, 0.02642154134809971, 0.01293946336954832, 0.013311641290783882, 0.004103024024516344, -0.08041070401668549, 0.0021381352562457323, -0.027655456215143204, -0.031177237629890442, 0.028239168226718903, 0.05257147550582886, -0.01724010892212391, -0.001513790339231491, 0.04368859529495239, -0.021424023434519768, -0.06027575209736824, -0.07796753942966461, 0.013560759834945202, 0.013831711374223232, -0.029997171834111214, -0.015098229050636292, -0.0011400580406188965, 0.03915964066982269, 0.017300892621278763, -0.003630740800872445, -0.04992370307445526, -0.022219909355044365, -0.002309847390279174, -0.014657603576779366, 0.014609113335609436, 0.039885517209768295, 0.046613018959760666, -0.008076435886323452, 0.05194156989455223, -0.028542794287204742, -0.03148781508207321, 0.023832669481635094, -0.015191661193966866, -0.0057031139731407166, -0.0161824319511652, -0.021055597811937332, 0.021649321541190147, -0.023902399465441704, -0.03236204758286476, 0.031318508088588715, -0.05884599685668945, 0.058612436056137085, 0.06342471390962601, 0.0017857267521321774, -0.006622884888201952, 0.02512102946639061, 0.004947626031935215, 0.004500678274780512, -0.03755474463105202, -0.017916183918714523, -0.024686019867658615, -0.0399797260761261, 0.05533603951334953, 0.010046746581792831, -0.05389901250600815, 0.01961040310561657, 0.046316858381032944, -0.021983180195093155, 0.014112730510532856, 0.002759316936135292, 0.010359177365899086, -0.011670338921248913, 0.03156823292374611, 0.0270747859030962, 0.028639860451221466, 0.010547458194196224, 0.05345883592963219, -0.017834506928920746, 0.028298284858465195, 0.007851623930037022, 0.0025561347138136625, 0.032442595809698105, -0.03055700659751892, -0.00790852028876543, -0.022493403404951096, -0.0320776030421257, 0.020527686923742294, 0.011842749081552029, -0.007405097596347332, 0.05016986280679703, 0.00041716068517416716, -0.0047516473568975925, 0.0021305843256413937, 0.0002620150917209685, 0.03317064791917801, 0.004934531170874834, -0.01938267983496189, -0.011715065687894821, 0.006544450297951698, -0.008702559396624565, -0.004337992053478956, -0.029438389465212822, -0.013502873480319977, -0.054662492126226425, 0.03971164673566818, 0.019037969410419464, 0.0011432272149249911, 0.009016294032335281, -0.03313349187374115, 0.013998186215758324, 0.000318327423883602, 0.0055014523677527905, 0.033363308757543564, -0.005582298152148724, -0.04598306119441986, 0.006048081908375025, -0.041776981204748154, 0.0012024726020172238, 0.03313634544610977, -0.007767003495246172, -0.054457131773233414, 0.04731939360499382, -0.032213009893894196, -0.04488126561045647, 0.0016839440213516355, -0.039074406027793884, 0.022155895829200745, 0.004794278647750616, -0.011808060109615326, 0.0257076695561409, 0.004795899149030447, -0.043792933225631714, 0.04009495675563812, -0.023552700877189636, -0.024343758821487427, -0.009476904757320881, 0.0013404471101239324, 0.023420684039592743, -0.018891073763370514, 0.026413192972540855, 0.010451344773173332, -0.01574663631618023, 0.001897599664516747, -0.050562627613544464, -0.039945874363183975, 0.02605152316391468, 0.00004447484388947487, -0.0035495359916239977, -0.0035657458938658237, -0.007399197202175856, 0.09245620667934418, 0.043670251965522766, -0.020197855308651924, -0.04176102578639984, -0.011419059708714485, -0.016027670353651047, -0.052158184349536896, 0.01587013155221939, -0.002262635389342904, 0.016029130667448044, 0.059542614966630936, -0.014405554160475731, 0.02581671066582203, 0.013526061549782753, 0.003777505364269018, 0.02367943339049816, 0.015826677903532982, -0.0070839389227330685, -0.06545516848564148, 0.04624992236495018, 0.025925397872924805, 0.0005888634477742016, -0.010153321549296379, 0.021186349913477898, 0.04263029992580414, 0.003933907486498356, -0.06618714332580566, -0.014875615946948528, -0.039127711206674576, 0.020631443709135056, -0.011063187383115292, 0.005996846128255129, -0.007097550202161074, -0.038975320756435394, -0.033208101987838745, -0.007684104144573212, 0.03249889984726906, -0.02434663474559784, -0.007547738030552864, 0.061248961836099625, 0.03568166494369507, 0.009770249016582966, 0.0028874289710074663, -0.01688615418970585, 0.008443831466138363, 0.05305838957428932, -0.039880432188510895, 0.014258868992328644, 0.06624650210142136, 0.011502787470817566, 0.00925507117062807, -0.015414048917591572, -0.02885405905544758, 0.00028344898601062596, -0.04864094778895378, 0.04441473260521889, -0.04431885480880737, 0.0480826273560524, 0.010283701121807098, 0.04734400659799576, 0.0007384845521301031, -0.009858326055109501, -0.032124102115631104, -0.006001493893563747, -0.07342811673879623, 0.002814284525811672, 0.00012848970072809607, -0.042185135185718536, -0.007483174093067646, -0.031363971531391144, 0.03461749479174614, -0.011982935480773449, -0.001185756642371416, 0.001120847649872303, -0.016375258564949036, -0.02764764428138733, 0.0068619754165410995, -0.006424333434551954, -0.02309127151966095, -0.007729633711278439, -0.005311513319611549, 0.0028635605704039335, -0.025663448497653008, 0.014842231757938862, 0.02667306922376156, 0.0167698934674263, -0.005417512264102697, -0.03241482004523277, 0.003956600558012724, -0.013862233608961105, 0.033708833158016205, 0.07169808447360992, -0.001665612799115479, -0.046595249325037, 0.027016596868634224, 0.016723286360502243, 0.03436380252242088, 0.05456693843007088, 0.023415954783558846, 0.00300619681365788, -0.0003420201828703284, -0.011471115984022617, 0.012817258015275002, 0.01493364479392767, -0.00264919875189662, 0.0006855175015516579, 0.0504574328660965, 0.06808542460203171, -0.031733304262161255, 0.033466264605522156, 0.051654573529958725, 0.02743355929851532, 0.011529536917805672, -0.048843421041965485, 0.04010472446680069, -0.015374593436717987, 0.00029043969698250294, 0.042926106601953506, 0.0056652589701116085, 0.031233957037329674, -0.025945642963051796, 0.03844893351197243, -0.04192054271697998, -0.02682417444884777, 0.0033421344123780727, 0.0359414666891098, 0.01858566515147686, -0.01326204277575016, -0.016940008848905563, -0.00391172431409359, 0.037513475865125656, 0.0016951087163761258, 0.026259055361151695, -0.030496589839458466, -0.08193065971136093, 0.0030542640015482903, 0.05724431574344635, 0.02674837037920952, -0.03940942510962486, 0.0014566037571057677, -0.05165983736515045, 0.016547173261642456, -0.0029226888436824083, -0.01911781169474125, 0.0254756398499012, -0.02400292083621025, 0.022992359474301338, 0.01313867513090372, -0.002114857779815793, -0.052133072167634964, 0.03313346579670906, -0.01961679756641388, 0.06434652954339981, -0.03978738188743591, -0.04052632674574852, -0.0006848190678283572, 0.05191623046994209, 0.0459737665951252, 0.06880136579275131, 0.00048315164167433977, -0.028759775683283806, 0.024907518178224564, 0.03312263637781143, -0.014853915199637413, -0.06862205266952515, 0.035207148641347885, 0.00973903201520443, -0.00834566168487072, 0.050089944154024124, -0.003160234307870269, 0.017165588214993477, 0.01575116254389286, 0.03907160833477974, 0.018114563077688217, -0.01956912875175476, -0.03349069133400917, 0.0435807928442955, 0.0325348787009716, 0.010624020360410213, 0.06695618480443954, 0.0025729553308337927, 0.00933774746954441, 0.014086944982409477, -0.05054148659110069, 0.008802573196589947, -0.021859100088477135, -0.032144125550985336, -0.08053777366876602, -0.008327254094183445, 0.02627379819750786, 0.013333705253899097, 0.007773602847009897, 0.00028637266950681806, -0.04134492576122284, -0.028446557000279427, 0.02272799238562584, 0.00628165015950799, 0.006572505459189415, 0.011586672626435757, -0.012620214372873306, -0.006824744399636984, 0.0012117993319407105, -0.004856552463024855, 0.006737553980201483, 0.006247835233807564, -0.017198661342263222, -0.005139433778822422, -0.032929204404354095, 0.002897645113989711, 0.010738330893218517, -0.04118836671113968, 0.0037436902057379484, -0.01647985354065895, -0.015114395879209042, -0.016709983348846436, 0.044528212398290634, -0.016242528334259987, -0.022128481417894363, 0.002948336536064744, 0.0036341215018182993, -0.03993973135948181, 0.019435670226812363, 0.0014683962799608707, 0.032348379492759705, -0.0020768812391906977, 0.019330279901623726, -0.0932328999042511, -0.07063870131969452, -0.021241702139377594, -0.024561330676078796, -0.016235921531915665, 0.015143627300858498, -0.03646220266819, -0.019157448783516884, -0.027829952538013458, 0.0014665373601019382, 0.05172969400882721, -0.06047450751066208, -0.023680850863456726, -0.01664033718407154, 0.018178464844822884, 0.06927835196256638, 0.0034873043186962605, -0.04531063139438629, 0.019078437238931656, -0.05751800909638405, -0.028325408697128296, 0.030000312253832817, 0.030849890783429146, -0.027672018855810165, -0.012841864489018917, -0.03977971524000168, 0.002227560617029667, 0.077972911298275, 0.0015571336261928082, 0.009437487460672855, 0.023086726665496826, 0.009014535695314407, 0.04716175049543381, -0.04049595445394516, -0.0159649308770895, -0.001121345441788435, 0.03220081701874733, 0.01004886906594038, 0.00981045886874199, -0.015807174146175385, 0.023790434002876282, 0.0361773781478405, -0.0127203818410635, -0.03373606130480766, 0.010502039454877377, 0.08747417479753494, -0.03236846998333931, 0.006728199776262045, -0.009209751151502132, -0.013713779859244823, 0.06331617385149002, 0.03217003494501114, 0.01233725342899561, 0.008023420348763466, -0.010204831138253212, -0.027611663565039635, -0.031503867357969284, -0.053294360637664795, 0.016555234789848328, 0.03803247585892677, -0.010544112883508205, 0.02637016959488392, 0.019631819799542427, -0.04778541624546051, -0.014146336354315281, -0.036447618156671524, -0.01718875579535961, 0.009015772491693497, 0.030434556305408478, 0.06477076560258865, -0.027951562777161598, -0.025387872010469437, 0.023119507357478142, 0.007342486176639795, 0.03615809604525566, -0.0034166951663792133, 0.011493085883557796, 0.02183121256530285, 0.030095577239990234, -0.0050704567693173885, -0.030381016433238983, 0.0013124130200594664, -0.04174437373876572, 0.04013805463910103, -0.045652151107788086, -0.017541689798235893, 0.0435611866414547, 0.03562324494123459, -0.00925022829324007, -0.04860102757811546, -0.007494916673749685, -0.03381218761205673, -0.01877151057124138, 0.0032437918707728386, -0.015026550740003586, 0.04034736379981041, -0.02477051131427288, 0.0451691672205925, -0.02079690434038639, 0.05402115732431412, -0.03434084728360176, -0.11202076077461243, -0.043106961995363235, 0.003403933485969901, 0.023730913177132607, 0.04037543386220932, -0.0034170723520219326, -0.014625837095081806, 0.03179745376110077, -0.06976468861103058, 0.02035577781498432, 0.021482519805431366, -0.0031642646063119173, -0.0012168667744845152, 0.05019357055425644, -0.005424073897302151, 0.039728958159685135, -0.022359339520335197, -0.01955866999924183, 0.10840601474046707, 0.07086359709501266, 0.04091615602374077, -0.07120298594236374, 0.0015451281797140837, 0.009581459686160088, 0.014518278650939465, -0.0005817129858769476, -0.01785377226769924, 0.03524518758058548, -0.014600868336856365, 0.06486118584871292, 0.04182583466172218, 0.04183611646294594, -0.000382700382033363, 0.023793790489435196, -0.05557670816779137, -0.028490114957094193, -0.011706377379596233, -0.005751707591116428, 0.009267149493098259, -0.024807794019579887, -0.0569051131606102, -0.004983687773346901, 0.01408954057842493, -0.009022490121424198, -0.03558609262108803, -0.01071073766797781, -0.031763315200805664, 0.034034572541713715, -0.019969359040260315, 0.03423174470663071, -0.0006660243961960077, 0.001184773980639875, 0.026953337714076042, -0.03874386474490166, 0.03821064159274101, -0.02512512169778347, 0.010058126412332058, 0.0469517819583416, -0.0015646175015717745, -0.03424927592277527, 0.04079117253422737, 0.002521311864256859, -0.04398944601416588, -0.027992457151412964, -0.029107578098773956, 0.07146482169628143, -0.014532577246427536, -0.019657645374536514, -0.009753158316016197, -0.016831418499350548, -0.05218924954533577, -0.03003588877618313, -0.02707492932677269, 0.035703059285879135, 0.009506474249064922, -0.008856548927724361, 0.009126146323978901, 0.02778708003461361, 0.036431409418582916, 0.006088560912758112, 0.020045429468154907, 0.022128282114863396, 0.008459711447358131, -0.011352703906595707, -0.013970914296805859, 0.06705978512763977, 0.011234167963266373, 0.04349761828780174, 0.04003007709980011, -0.022470731288194656, -0.04186136648058891, -0.036023546010255814, 0.01665623113512993, 0.004589141812175512, 0.04132881760597229, -0.03375454992055893, 0.020167775452136993, -0.0006328279851004481, -0.054836519062519073, -0.00027266511460766196, -0.0031910070683807135, -0.016238557174801826, -0.07966794073581696, -0.023883650079369545, -0.00024758331710472703, -0.006365365348756313, 0.0293066818267107, -0.006476170849055052, 0.013822966255247593, 0.07992109656333923, -0.034157801419496536, -0.05175066366791725, -0.0567011684179306, 0.005273712333291769, -0.02428952418267727, -0.008119408041238785, 0.024166522547602654, 0.02930876798927784, 0.018030595034360886, 0.005566124338656664, -0.01306232251226902, 0.049958012998104095, 0.0046627819538116455, -0.01965886726975441, 0.010012412443757057, -0.029142342507839203, -0.011350183747708797, 0.012823222205042839, 0.0016871411353349686, -0.02662695199251175, 0.01188481692224741, -0.05208467319607735, -0.042477305978536606, -0.023763734847307205, -0.00043629208812490106, -0.04004306346178055, 0.003465770510956645, 0.00996672548353672, -0.004778040107339621, -0.010402059182524681, -0.02440459281206131, -0.01917152665555477, -0.030758952721953392, 0.02241339720785618, -0.020048538222908974, -0.014134883880615234, 0.021351229399442673, -0.012132562696933746, 0.018490953370928764, 0.0024451836943626404, -0.014007652178406715, 0.0023541785776615143, 0.000523459748364985, -0.01299973763525486, -0.003903202712535858, 0.04708944261074066, -0.043450430035591125, -0.012326177209615707, -0.0034051015973091125, -0.029191158711910248, -0.03913097083568573, 0.006459733936935663, -0.006051482632756233, 0.021433988586068153, 0.015371117740869522, 0.015968969091773033, -0.003657587571069598, 0.0477779321372509, -0.03661031648516655, 0.0032623966690152884, -0.04140652343630791, -0.000761432689614594, -0.023746417835354805, -0.019682541489601135, -0.004852287471294403, -0.004779426380991936, 0.0016421162290498614, 0.04133876413106918, 0.07266063988208771, -0.015195471234619617, 0.006142049096524715, 0.04327239468693733, 0.0013059312477707863, 0.006551653612405062, 0.03196689113974571, 0.03628131374716759, -0.040096037089824677, 0.008665286935865879, -0.013277744874358177, 0.04440448805689812, -0.03303038328886032, 0.0358099490404129, -0.10382868349552155, -0.04387382045388222, -0.018687434494495392, 0.014459057711064816, 0.02468266710639, -0.018408235162496567, -0.0015938431024551392, 0.01311094593256712, -0.05862846598029137, -0.0019116088515147567, 0.0012007682817056775, -0.00789225660264492, -0.03623884543776512, 0.015094533562660217, -0.01210793573409319, -0.0016012343112379313, 0.05257312208414078, 0.007904109545052052, 0.05205335468053818, 0.007768364157527685, 0.03721374273300171, -0.012776941992342472, -0.03105420246720314, 0.0027242114301770926, 0.029627062380313873, -0.04739736393094063, 0.007322276476770639, -0.019304847344756126, -0.037594374269247055, -0.004973023664206266, -0.01830108091235161, 0.022777341306209564, -0.0008993725059553981, 0.027045955881476402, 0.004888757131993771, 0.06064670905470848, -0.002532362472265959, 0.02775518409907818, 0.017696470022201538, -0.03783715143799782, 0.010498201474547386, 0.020477760583162308, -0.012068741023540497, 0.03439611569046974, 0.011153647676110268, 0.007570883259177208, -0.009228144772350788, 0.011866193264722824, -0.02623714879155159, -0.03235366567969322, -0.013143626041710377, 0.02885654754936695, -0.012299824506044388, -0.03186310455203056, -0.001829334069043398, -0.03857089951634407, 0.011166625656187534, 0.07368510216474533, 0.04881303757429123, -0.012215000577270985, 0.011080589145421982, -0.014578117057681084, -0.005869229324162006, 0.011868943460285664, 0.023059122264385223, -0.016121098771691322, -0.04882640391588211, -0.02364419400691986, 0.01009145937860012, 0.007724641356617212, 0.020332148298621178, 0.010010769590735435, -0.04194820299744606, 0.028229624032974243, -0.011228115297853947, -0.010892755351960659, -0.005750548094511032, -0.027695830911397934, 0.0377594530582428, -0.07993030548095703, 0.04118543490767479, 0.003964843228459358, -0.012044353410601616, -0.0448133759200573, -0.005296285729855299, -0.01801222749054432, 0.02721772901713848, 0.028590822592377663, 0.00079394003842026, -0.00818612053990364, -0.010473654605448246, 0.05197766050696373, 0.01837095618247986, -0.05503556504845619, 0.054509978741407394, 0.0217283982783556, -0.01203822810202837, -0.009550285525619984, -0.054223958402872086, -0.0026481125969439745, 0.03743196278810501, 0.03662567958235741, -0.00964381918311119, 0.016800368204712868, -0.003254690207540989, 0.006123200990259647, 0.01682453602552414, 0.005823519080877304, 0.003052683314308524, 0.05621163919568062, 0.007660254370421171, 0.0350315123796463, 0.03451530262827873, 0.032296016812324524, -0.04127553477883339, 0.0217472892254591, -0.012858503498136997, 0.0007493035518564284, 0.0016010391991585493, -0.027872594073414803, 0.008070720359683037, -0.06694409251213074, 0.009287155233323574, 0.03292353078722954, -0.005317480303347111, -0.03363054245710373, 0.011313953436911106, 0.024784527719020844, 0.016911206766963005, 0.025170501321554184, 0.006264430936425924, -0.0059074340388178825, 0.015341431833803654, 0.0354265496134758, 0.019689330831170082, 0.009479637257754803, -0.011470857076346874, 0.0159069262444973, 0.0005688375094905496, -0.03014185279607773, -0.001045688521116972, -0.04907713457942009, 0.07540076225996017, -0.025528080761432648, -0.02943452075123787, 0.038874052464962006, -0.0035322371404618025, 0.022250819951295853, -0.02588776685297489, 0.009422296658158302, 0.04280593991279602, -0.06333014369010925, 0.0371139794588089, -0.019805897027254105, -0.027633946388959885, -0.017546752467751503, -0.028685228899121284, -0.024280330166220665, 0.013009315356612206, -0.013103757053613663, -0.011943631805479527, 0.017748652026057243, -0.04608979448676109, 0.00884755328297615, -0.04565846174955368, -0.015802331268787384, -0.027071885764598846, 0.0012147895758971572, -0.021914469078183174, -0.011832481250166893, -0.034453704953193665, -0.03561554104089737, 0.035746295005083084, 0.04446439817547798, -0.017814600840210915, -0.05802619084715843, -0.037939537316560745, 0.011760290712118149, 0.05133581534028053, -0.04185163229703903, -0.010090164840221405, -0.019563699141144753, 0.03038763254880905, 0.021174315363168716, 0.0025565549731254578 ]
<p>I'm analyzing users' in-game data in order to model whether they're going to be paid user or not. </p> <p>Here's my model:</p> <pre><code>Logistic Regression Model lrm(formula = becomePaid ~ x1 + x2 + x3 + x4 + x5 + x6, data = sn, x = TRUE, y = TRUE) Model Likelihood Discrimination Rank Discrim. Ratio Test Indexes Indexes Obs 1e+05 LR chi2 1488.63 R2 0.147 C 0.774 0 99065 d.f. 6 g 1.141 Dxy 0.547 1 935 Pr(&gt; chi2) &lt;0.0001 gr 3.130 gamma 0.586 max |deriv| 8e-09 gp 0.011 tau-a 0.010 Brier 0.009 Coef S.E. Wald Z Pr(&gt;|Z|) Intercept -6.7910 0.0938 -72.36 &lt;0.0001 x1 0.0756 0.0193 3.92 &lt;0.0001 x2 0.0698 0.0091 7.64 &lt;0.0001 x3 0.0020 0.0002 11.05 &lt;0.0001 x4 0.0172 0.0057 3.03 0.0024 x5 0.0304 0.0045 6.82 &lt;0.0001 x6 -0.0132 0.0042 -3.17 0.0015 </code></pre> <p>And in my model, I created couple of use cases such as:</p> <pre><code> test1 test2 x1 8 9 x2 10 10 x3 250 250 x4 6 6 x5 2 2 x6 0 1 </code></pre> <p>Then the probability of user test1 is to turn out to be a paid user is %.07 and % 0.84 for test2.</p> <p>However I want to calculate the cumulative probabilities such as users whose' x1 values are greater than 8, x2 values are between 10 and 20 and so on.</p> <p>Is there any way to calculate this ?</p> <p>Thanks ! </p>
74,324
[ -0.019470561295747757, 0.004318864084780216, 0.008767823688685894, -0.009213774465024471, 0.032244447618722916, 0.026780175045132637, -0.011375854723155499, -0.02795986831188202, 0.04154406115412712, -0.04431966692209244, 0.03603769838809967, 0.03656262159347534, 0.041568901389837265, 0.029404746368527412, 0.03899000212550163, -0.0020722215995192528, 0.00684499554336071, 0.02624174952507019, -0.0006668967544101179, -0.002830146113410592, -0.008396915160119534, 0.0010042928624898195, 0.04403815045952797, -0.023641997948288918, -0.02198830060660839, 0.030917475000023842, 0.0345868356525898, -0.051165465265512466, -0.04269084706902504, 0.04951229318976402, -0.003673258237540722, -0.01777803711593151, 0.019409658387303352, 0.016237033531069756, 0.022268759086728096, 0.023645775392651558, -0.01616392470896244, 0.00034975347807630897, -0.020618516951799393, 0.002493851585313678, -0.01908026449382305, 0.020769814029335976, 0.003919836599379778, 0.017652833834290504, -0.0023476353380829096, 0.01236734353005886, 0.005739122629165649, 0.005551239009946585, 0.011257442645728588, -0.00487437704578042, 0.04563667252659798, -0.022009700536727905, 0.05346500128507614, -0.0009516595746390522, -0.027624178677797318, 0.002655099844560027, 0.008416934870183468, 0.09453551471233368, 0.012184292078018188, -0.039162904024124146, 0.013685625977814198, -0.04976619780063629, -0.029387010261416435, -0.04431862384080887, -0.010596849024295807, 0.039001498371362686, 0.010985505767166615, -0.03529834374785423, 0.05219951272010803, -0.04382272809743881, 0.023591699078679085, 0.008812080137431622, -0.002771898405626416, -0.014985925517976284, 0.023709768429398537, -0.0214837659150362, 0.0027010408230125904, 0.008715374395251274, 0.018910320475697517, -0.015423331409692764, -0.022543679922819138, 0.029331238940358162, 0.0018641208298504353, 0.04518301784992218, 0.015174979344010353, -0.0320773683488369, 0.056333109736442566, -0.011509373784065247, 0.0321284756064415, 0.01185326837003231, -0.022702371701598167, 0.03430290147662163, 0.03979536145925522, 0.013807871378958225, -0.018349995836615562, 0.019853342324495316, -0.017203904688358307, 0.029280591756105423, 0.000460202107205987, -0.019733186811208725, 0.0010541288647800684, -0.07137858867645264, 0.01400878094136715, 0.03688395395874977, -0.0191618874669075, -0.034631770104169846, 0.01617753691971302, -0.02539091929793358, -0.01713939569890499, -0.07813341915607452, -0.01996191218495369, 0.051065925508737564, -0.019695518538355827, -0.021383751183748245, -0.020484684035182, -0.0481005497276783, -0.025332678109407425, -0.05391734465956688, 0.04978500306606293, 0.044203173369169235, 0.025818219408392906, -0.018572447821497917, 0.014815613627433777, -0.02924170158803463, -0.045674312859773636, -0.0028153343591839075, -0.016113510355353355, -0.0074056037701666355, -0.029078662395477295, 0.03640362620353699, 0.015569966286420822, -0.037339501082897186, 0.0629582554101944, 0.053490474820137024, -0.013242979533970356, -0.010671794414520264, -0.018481409177184105, -0.0329773873090744, 0.03413425013422966, 0.016413584351539612, 0.04115040972828865, -0.033350586891174316, -0.011649105697870255, 0.05411090329289436, 0.047954924404621124, 0.022371996194124222, 0.02783058024942875, 0.01973903924226761, 0.014126786962151527, 0.027753587812185287, -0.03644532710313797, -0.0001753529068082571, -0.08308618515729904, 0.02286984771490097, -0.018969818949699402, -0.07384736090898514, 0.014177742414176464, 0.001923897536471486, -0.05056032910943031, -0.018175970762968063, 0.012062831781804562, 0.02272770181298256, -0.014578800648450851, -0.03223738074302673, -0.022538984194397926, -0.046433303505182266, 0.07800185680389404, 0.02315598912537098, 0.0027513697277754545, -0.015202239155769348, -0.0023026110138744116, 0.005007070954889059, -0.017825940623879433, 0.058819498866796494, 0.08401872217655182, -0.032186467200517654, 0.0039033314678817987, -0.012809873558580875, 0.019916007295250893, 0.011275166645646095, -0.04555758088827133, -0.01450562383979559, -0.04044920578598976, -0.03404588997364044, 0.06852798908948898, 0.027466734871268272, 0.028902577236294746, -0.027668314054608345, 0.02264879271388054, -0.02768496423959732, -0.03482358902692795, -0.0662476196885109, 0.003433264559134841, 0.010286347009241581, -0.012448019348084927, 0.0028159786015748978, 0.003932567313313484, 0.024534082040190697, -0.004054088611155748, 0.025281472131609917, -0.0925738662481308, -0.002482661046087742, 0.06440762430429459, -0.03023706004023552, -0.020203521475195885, 0.038537222892045975, 0.0370970256626606, -0.014987124130129814, 0.06353762000799179, -0.06964457780122757, -0.03171369433403015, 0.008204330690205097, -0.0020748053211718798, 0.006792047526687384, -0.031606100499629974, -0.032726287841796875, 0.03559515252709389, 0.01566452719271183, -0.04023728147149086, 0.03421373665332794, -0.06422014534473419, -0.005806066561490297, 0.07743842899799347, 0.004390809219330549, 0.0036302898079156876, -0.030620167031884193, -0.05117766186594963, 0.023052755743265152, -0.012993457727134228, 0.004608740098774433, -0.034789372235536575, 0.0025202336255460978, 0.032879021018743515, 0.018359364941716194, -0.034676261246204376, 0.0055045573972165585, 0.08576475828886032, -0.018701663240790367, 0.02623859979212284, 0.03248795494437218, 0.010536719113588333, -0.013777573592960835, -0.003123405622318387, -0.006615635473281145, 0.017295347526669502, -0.012967832386493683, 0.03756148740649223, 0.02336731180548668, 0.013928367756307125, -0.005607904866337776, -0.026647020131349564, 0.02098420262336731, -0.018166299909353256, -0.006911959499120712, -0.014963227324187756, -0.03745081648230553, 0.049929551780223846, 0.020898357033729553, -0.03253639489412308, 0.046194568276405334, 0.009995752945542336, -0.041749387979507446, -0.004162511322647333, -0.02822946198284626, 0.009038261137902737, 0.05342697352170944, -0.030830400064587593, -0.019254695624113083, 0.01857689954340458, -0.028644489124417305, 0.043471142649650574, 0.03663605824112892, -0.02937994711101055, -0.037249185144901276, 0.03994125500321388, 0.05441727861762047, 0.02859860472381115, 0.021475641056895256, 0.010319418273866177, -0.0469500869512558, 0.0054744635708630085, -0.009928479790687561, 0.039155181497335434, -0.0003100822796113789, -0.08319062739610672, -0.03774699568748474, 0.005644659511744976, -0.03728802129626274, 0.014936168678104877, 0.019150657579302788, -0.03353940695524216, 0.03377265855669975, -0.02402837760746479, -0.013056769035756588, -0.009954540058970451, -0.020516978576779366, -0.0324961356818676, -0.010672309435904026, -0.0037390412762761116, 0.07297560572624207, -0.01043278630822897, -0.04241470620036125, 0.003952113911509514, -0.043328069150447845, -0.017909051850438118, -0.028637157753109932, -0.03447877615690231, 0.005850964691489935, 0.01575355976819992, 0.029383929446339607, 0.002036613877862692, 0.00429810443893075, 0.013495483435690403, -0.10547953099012375, -0.04520848020911217, 0.008380486629903316, 0.022031977772712708, 0.004937537480145693, 0.01967564970254898, 0.017193252220749855, 0.06691616773605347, 0.03897682949900627, -0.014669427648186684, -0.06954629719257355, 0.021232763305306435, -0.03713596612215042, 0.017994241788983345, -0.007028417661786079, 0.004572981037199497, -0.02122616022825241, 0.01789465919137001, -0.047449178993701935, 0.011066407896578312, 0.05203073099255562, -0.010750875808298588, 0.048127274960279465, 0.031156521290540695, 0.005926583427935839, -0.01924869790673256, 0.01693633385002613, 0.001102267182432115, -0.010576782748103142, 0.038898173719644547, 0.007561533246189356, 0.03127523511648178, -0.025590356439352036, -0.03168460354208946, -0.015285143628716469, 0.022080490365624428, 0.018335791304707527, -0.008876869454979897, 0.013889854773879051, 0.019605165347456932, -0.06189621984958649, 0.013705260120332241, -0.018948836252093315, 0.016432661563158035, -0.03775903955101967, 0.010837380774319172, 0.05649379640817642, 0.0038162562996149063, -0.0007750187069177628, 0.0075773196294903755, -0.019412579014897346, -0.020780714228749275, 0.04454182833433151, -0.08092106133699417, -0.001875034417025745, 0.03615979850292206, 0.023024199530482292, 0.009807725436985493, -0.00504803191870451, -0.0031121468637138605, -0.03412517160177231, -0.04769440367817879, 0.01732228882610798, -0.05309980735182762, 0.07933097332715988, 0.03831009939312935, 0.03464952111244202, -0.01588192582130432, -0.008740906603634357, -0.0158341396600008, 0.0058793858624994755, -0.06637836247682571, 0.032106224447488785, 0.028517702594399452, 0.0008697836892679334, 0.009007174521684647, -0.03022799827158451, 0.037037935107946396, -0.05840994045138359, -0.020773759111762047, 0.02341771498322487, -0.009417456574738026, -0.014934010803699493, 0.015337768942117691, -0.004313448444008827, 0.013289033435285091, -0.024450143799185753, -0.0217512808740139, 0.005510004702955484, 0.04827577620744705, 0.02935643307864666, 0.036835893988609314, 0.039077505469322205, 0.029004434123635292, -0.022677097469568253, 0.01776609942317009, 0.0893813893198967, 0.048791687935590744, 0.0013385543134063482, 0.005999730434268713, -0.04499448090791702, 0.01220215018838644, 0.007791658863425255, 0.03579188510775566, 0.09283256530761719, -0.008313454687595367, 0.009294349700212479, -0.05091452971100807, -0.021553969010710716, 0.011487393639981747, -0.005831305868923664, 0.008472736924886703, 0.004376364406198263, 0.04156104102730751, 0.01747080124914646, -0.02970016933977604, -0.0008905950817279518, 0.07841391116380692, 0.028034789487719536, 0.008565355092287064, 0.002224524039775133, 0.01749172806739807, -0.03269857168197632, 0.0022902050986886024, 0.015197494998574257, 0.021871417760849, 0.013497693464159966, 0.009949932806193829, 0.015203769318759441, -0.013266989961266518, -0.010818473063409328, -0.017977900803089142, 0.04298749566078186, 0.03926572948694229, 0.001267056679353118, -0.05912492051720619, 0.022107314318418503, 0.03741014748811722, 0.04006880521774292, -0.009263127110898495, 0.015906117856502533, -0.07410986721515656, 0.009190372191369534, 0.02981293946504593, 0.046857528388500214, -0.030231408774852753, -0.0249773059040308, -0.00957555416971445, 0.013666571117937565, -0.011508669704198837, -0.03167852386832237, 0.04011719673871994, 0.01634574495255947, 0.01910075545310974, -0.0016446267254650593, -0.03800069913268089, -0.07039573043584824, 0.06281682848930359, -0.06011760234832764, -0.010075907222926617, -0.044092871248722076, -0.04830263927578926, -0.020567195490002632, 0.04152917116880417, -0.00784627627581358, 0.028466248884797096, -0.03344366326928139, -0.011229299008846283, 0.023480014875531197, 0.013875948265194893, -0.014895671047270298, -0.02776758000254631, 0.04248584434390068, -0.004624704364687204, -0.00032199296401813626, 0.03980715572834015, 0.007768004201352596, -0.01608041673898697, 0.0040879868902266026, 0.00809121411293745, 0.03684563189744949, -0.0031478055752813816, -0.029611162841320038, 0.040514010936021805, 0.029944101348519325, -0.0308371651917696, 0.04902610182762146, 0.03957382217049599, -0.011476250365376472, -0.011384805664420128, -0.04636316001415253, -0.022038282826542854, 0.009240645915269852, -0.04362555593252182, -0.08063744008541107, 0.010151516646146774, 0.009681782685220242, 0.006622759625315666, 0.001677830470725894, 0.015151794999837875, -0.034660279750823975, 0.012632637284696102, 0.005996829830110073, 0.0035630837082862854, 0.007785511203110218, -0.023969661444425583, 0.03264768049120903, -0.009421061724424362, -0.02257293090224266, 0.00654155109077692, 0.025910930708050728, -0.02113892324268818, -0.006482144817709923, -0.036123450845479965, -0.02777296118438244, 0.0018118831794708967, 0.006365983281284571, 0.011135295033454895, -0.0036675292067229748, -0.030060824006795883, 0.02170064114034176, 0.040853019803762436, 0.042396072298288345, -0.012148694135248661, 0.00723440432921052, -0.011589321307837963, 0.052460476756095886, 0.028314590454101562, 0.015619909390807152, -0.006470976863056421, 0.04178024083375931, -0.013187195174396038, -0.03191160783171654, -0.042195066809654236, -0.00149123917799443, -0.00011235190322622657, 0.006959682330489159, -0.017018811777234077, -0.051177747547626495, -0.004284555558115244, -0.0015119384042918682, -0.011574027128517628, 0.002044697292149067, 0.01173668634146452, -0.038159728050231934, 0.027081623673439026, -0.011843967251479626, -0.014519291929900646, 0.07719303667545319, 0.015493057668209076, -0.008314196951687336, 0.026109347119927406, 0.006684452760964632, -0.02609286643564701, 0.028199179098010063, -0.03038313239812851, -0.0257712434977293, -0.02967211604118347, 0.001929975813254714, -0.0008360208012163639, 0.08034098148345947, 0.013989467173814774, 0.007588738109916449, -0.030178003013134003, -0.014755886048078537, 0.018009236082434654, -0.007387530989944935, -0.028692731633782387, 0.0021431902423501015, 0.019006608054041862, -0.02806134894490242, 0.009018425829708576, -0.012365361675620079, 0.05750250443816185, 0.04038264602422714, -0.00384404300712049, 0.023180918768048286, 0.012010776437819004, 0.06647785753011703, -0.0029624560847878456, -0.023494809865951538, -0.02001696266233921, 0.025965562090277672, 0.06241970509290695, -0.0036712849978357553, -0.007803747430443764, 0.02138718217611313, 0.03996066004037857, 0.0017851853044703603, -0.002641255035996437, -0.034614115953445435, -0.0038866845425218344, 0.034662846475839615, -0.017335494980216026, 0.0394594706594944, 0.016584089025855064, 0.018452433869242668, -0.0035142232663929462, -0.01947164162993431, -0.03790196776390076, -0.008878804743289948, -0.009162699803709984, 0.037819474935531616, -0.02842777781188488, -0.06129612401127815, 0.06405802071094513, -0.015097527764737606, 0.053231380879879, 0.0643882229924202, -0.03178088739514351, -0.017718862742185593, 0.002626306377351284, -0.014542557299137115, -0.027538247406482697, 0.049801819026470184, -0.05272345244884491, 0.01898978091776371, -0.03466202691197395, -0.0395149290561676, 0.0852835401892662, 0.0506654791533947, -0.03555603325366974, -0.03772815316915512, -0.037673383951187134, -0.06739138066768646, -0.0023470150772482157, 0.00551973283290863, -0.010317571461200714, 0.05510379746556282, 0.012462948448956013, 0.029674839228391647, -0.026501066982746124, 0.04474188759922981, -0.046771321445703506, -0.06865900009870529, 0.012790239416062832, -0.029166024178266525, -0.009561238810420036, 0.012607219628989697, 0.020545240491628647, -0.0037210576701909304, 0.009551670402288437, -0.029019519686698914, 0.012525388039648533, -0.0031271222978830338, 0.046221036463975906, 0.011033151298761368, 0.0584559291601181, -0.03650851547718048, 0.030596744269132614, -0.03760356083512306, -0.023821666836738586, 0.14617358148097992, 0.056808941066265106, 0.017679307609796524, -0.030100330710411072, -0.02399556152522564, 0.03370164334774017, 0.00990063976496458, -0.008169285021722317, -0.016933077946305275, 0.0017753588035702705, -0.06645183265209198, 0.05268256366252899, 0.01764838583767414, 0.0032722942996770144, 0.009016484022140503, 0.050102416425943375, -0.04075727239251137, -0.009839480742812157, 0.03630531579256058, 0.01238888781517744, -0.016482120379805565, -0.035520974546670914, -0.029917821288108826, -0.027146080508828163, 0.014806808903813362, 0.007440679240971804, -0.02730843611061573, 0.018144728615880013, -0.04711213707923889, -0.002674784976989031, -0.009428836405277252, -0.0035185986198484898, 0.020811326801776886, 0.025994248688220978, 0.030498703941702843, -0.012346575036644936, 0.016877347603440285, -0.04548395797610283, 0.004884419497102499, -0.0019200579263269901, 0.005881979130208492, 0.013817785307765007, -0.03136471286416054, 0.051126256585121155, -0.01238537672907114, -0.008463628590106964, -0.05383754149079323, 0.03456959128379822, -0.02021206170320511, -0.05080721154808998, 0.00687879603356123, -0.003405321855098009, -0.0026130122132599354, 0.004119653720408678, -0.03486840799450874, 0.028814950957894325, 0.012715987861156464, -0.003016871167346835, -0.0018215555464848876, -0.014005696401000023, 0.013474996201694012, 0.00757842930033803, 0.03134772926568985, -0.008391531184315681, -0.05953655391931534, -0.017433052882552147, -0.04243958368897438, 0.04618287831544876, -0.02062074840068817, 0.007724930066615343, 0.014016828499734402, -0.027827581390738487, -0.022831881418824196, -0.03679778054356575, -0.013306747190654278, -0.019046258181333542, -0.019383929669857025, -0.005824708379805088, 0.00351627916097641, -0.023640122264623642, 0.010843954980373383, 0.02379058487713337, -0.008678119629621506, 0.023747922852635384, -0.06947455555200577, 0.001967330928891897, 0.01970609836280346, 0.01584131270647049, 0.000289011572021991, -0.04052242636680603, -0.03096548095345497, 0.05216054245829582, -0.00816547591239214, -0.05496446043252945, -0.01620776578783989, 0.005775787401944399, -0.03255966305732727, 0.025489121675491333, -0.030589882284402847, 0.07542308419942856, 0.032301273196935654, 0.009411191567778587, -0.017656024545431137, 0.009088007733225822, -0.0294471587985754, -0.0009955931454896927, 0.012507139705121517, -0.022054176777601242, -0.02817726507782936, -0.01605655625462532, 0.0013047429965808988, 0.0039998386055231094, -0.013993697240948677, -0.04267469421029091, -0.03655226156115532, 0.02261880785226822, -0.01314771082252264, -0.04147564619779587, -0.008265428245067596, -0.0037256849464029074, -0.012599647976458073, 0.03940010815858841, 0.014243997633457184, -0.014219794422388077, -0.009739164263010025, -0.03432011604309082, -0.05327748879790306, 0.0007137449574656785, 0.0029936821665614843, -0.0013209034223109484, 0.012831415981054306, 0.021374275907874107, 0.029514510184526443, 0.020256146788597107, -0.025630401447415352, 0.037843331694602966, -0.008891970850527287, 0.030893884599208832, -0.007031983695924282, -0.04004747048020363, 0.004077555611729622, -0.009498587809503078, -0.009805319830775261, 0.026205947622656822, 0.0010201255790889263, 0.06453987210988998, -0.022570380941033363, -0.0034812481608241796, 0.027018167078495026, 0.015365524217486382, -0.018991323187947273, -0.020162435248494148, -0.019114460796117783, -0.005287472158670425, 0.02485862746834755, 0.007416021078824997, 0.00047260388964787126, 0.0008869253797456622, 0.01029782835394144, 0.005517769139260054, 0.04585057497024536, -0.014299346134066582, -0.022074708715081215, 0.017355086281895638, 0.009258778765797615, 0.010355187579989433, 0.025127455592155457, -0.009548169560730457, 0.01692679524421692, 0.02596023865044117, 0.0039217774756252766, 0.017291240394115448, -0.015187817625701427, 0.013207720592617989, -0.07836487889289856, -0.0606909804046154, 0.03920219838619232, 0.03447677940130234, -0.007458704058080912, -0.03777370601892471, -0.014535308815538883, 0.022922329604625702, -0.051206476986408234, 0.032403185963630676, 0.033068787306547165, 0.007118714973330498, -0.018693087622523308, 0.023669779300689697, -0.01047312282025814, -0.03372588008642197, 0.022614611312747, -0.02488676831126213, 0.03525895997881889, -0.00393663952127099, 0.020041387528181076, -0.04729283228516579, -0.04614974558353424, 0.013424809090793133, -0.008378745056688786, -0.057022277265787125, 0.033344823867082596, -0.04435696825385094, 0.003916300367563963, 0.005885519552975893, -0.0017390439752489328, -0.005189801100641489, 0.01417020708322525, 0.06039838865399361, 0.043194517493247986, 0.035034578293561935, 0.05661934241652489, 0.021355988457798958, 0.015166937373578548, 0.012268182821571827, 0.02223721146583557, 0.008218979462981224, -0.03817510977387428, 0.0346817672252655, 0.04206058010458946, 0.0072269258089363575, -0.024782676249742508, -0.00464200833812356, -0.021281950175762177, 0.011120032519102097, -0.03174630180001259, 0.008802630007266998, 0.0036124414764344692, -0.049770768731832504, 0.006928584072738886, -0.01483541913330555, 0.017993642017245293, -0.02467716671526432, 0.040354013442993164, -0.0045856572687625885, -0.010495265945792198, -0.015460329130291939, -0.04053286090493202, 0.025193441659212112, 0.024933302775025368, -0.025494730100035667, -0.06116005778312683, -0.0031643614638596773, 0.00792006403207779, -0.05641593039035797, -0.006763050332665443, -0.015859633684158325, -0.055373698472976685, 0.03423183038830757, -0.044761255383491516, -0.006021353416144848, 0.011238648556172848, 0.018713153898715973, 0.055956728756427765, -0.13028106093406677, 0.051624324172735214, 0.015808429569005966, -0.025153301656246185, -0.03143574669957161, -0.013267277739942074, -0.055225927382707596, 0.004253929480910301, 0.023722052574157715, -0.00217471644282341, 0.003967235796153545, -0.0005651740939356387, 0.024770626798272133, 0.012745410203933716, -0.02339741587638855, 0.0028601018711924553, -0.025823846459388733, 0.0014947536401450634, -0.03772734850645065, 0.017544353380799294, 0.01894313283264637, -0.005138791166245937, 0.018245654180645943, 0.006482293363660574, -0.021313393488526344, 0.013365432620048523, -0.021344618871808052, 0.03812496364116669, -0.005737165454775095, -0.011091222986578941, 0.017874108627438545, -0.02296997606754303, 0.02248089760541916, 0.033591970801353455, -0.008810240775346756, -0.05158684030175209, 0.029461238533258438, -0.03696445748209953, -0.030831752344965935, 0.04310306906700134, 0.0059088654816150665, -0.018542874604463577, -0.030904093757271767, 0.03407997265458107, 0.009436164982616901, 0.002563919872045517, 0.0027734709437936544, -0.012272188439965248, -0.014189858920872211, 0.026244744658470154, -0.0029770724941045046, 0.061584070324897766, -0.02105802297592163, -0.028254959732294083, 0.01254570297896862, -0.01654050312936306, 0.05675308778882027, -0.009587137959897518, 0.00978137832134962, 0.045244861394166946, 0.02341831475496292, 0.02029450610280037, -0.026274919509887695, 0.04183906316757202, -0.017367225140333176, 0.014536361210048199, 0.03956222161650658, -0.014020209200680256, 0.019523296505212784, -0.018307169899344444, -0.027909889817237854, 0.015825606882572174, -0.02865542285144329, 0.06085658073425293, -0.010551616549491882, 0.021265314891934395, -0.016702864319086075, 0.025468986481428146, 0.050241511315107346, 0.02488243393599987, 0.005948787089437246, 0.0017038919031620026, 0.0389208048582077, -0.011587603017687798, 0.0025570732541382313, 0.014673136174678802, 0.005316896829754114, 0.027795488014817238, -0.010080632753670216, 0.015046673826873302, -0.03500915691256523, 0.02027730830013752, -0.01988806575536728, 0.002664388855919242, 0.011244026944041252, 0.04219692572951317, -0.04193814843893051, 0.017347507178783417, 0.01859358511865139, 0.047336362302303314, -0.007739238440990448, -0.03566054627299309, -0.03145211935043335, 0.02686123363673687, 0.013652600347995758, -0.0537736676633358 ]
<p>I can think of different “types” of multiple testing when using linear models for example:</p> <ol> <li>Multiple inferences because we have several dependent variables</li> <li>Multiple inferences because we have several independent variables</li> <li>Looking at the data without making any test. Running a test on only the comparisons that might possibly yield to a significant p.value.</li> <li>Running multiple different tests on the same data. (try a LM, if it is not significant, try a GLM, if it is still not significant try a beta regression, etc.)</li> </ol> <p><a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_comparisons" rel="nofollow">Wikipedia</a> says:</p> <blockquote> <p>[...] multiple testing problem occurs when one considers a set of statistical inferences simultaneously or <em>infers a subset of parameters selected based on the observed values</em>.</p> </blockquote> <p>Does the first part of what wikipedia says encompass my first two points and the part that I put in italics (after the "or") is equivalent to my third point ? Is it correct that my point 4 has nothing to do with what we call multiple testing ?</p> <p>If my question is too blurry, I might rephrase it this way:</p> <p><strong>When does an issue of multiple testing occur ? How would you categorize (if needed) the possible events of multiple testing ?</strong></p>
37,166
[ -0.05316280573606491, 0.004672023467719555, -0.009198803454637527, 0.002496798522770405, 0.042624447494745255, 0.03740981966257095, 0.027259642258286476, -0.02414807863533497, 0.029188813641667366, -0.010483055375516415, 0.05847031623125076, 0.01617266982793808, 0.04676319286227226, -0.029946107417345047, 0.02715666964650154, 0.015750765800476074, 0.004364355932921171, 0.019004356116056442, -0.0021711739245802164, 0.016828827559947968, -0.014724208042025566, 0.023730311542749405, 0.012677079066634178, -0.0051191034726798534, -0.007922627031803131, 0.02866206504404545, 0.026815151795744896, 0.004472956992685795, 0.006390209775418043, 0.03844228759407997, -0.019380800426006317, -0.01773722842335701, 0.019902754575014114, 0.025736253708600998, -0.031064413487911224, -0.013060517609119415, -0.018064377829432487, 0.004880709107965231, 0.008860800415277481, 0.04668896645307541, -0.041593100875616074, -0.02061905339360237, -0.03471677377820015, 0.04747181385755539, -0.009866275824606419, -0.013690927065908909, 0.011051398701965809, -0.036774467676877975, 0.004068420734256506, -0.016668230295181274, 0.06585436314344406, -0.011835156008601189, 0.030225353315472603, 0.030855391174554825, -0.014261418953537941, -0.00733349472284317, 0.04569949582219124, 0.09363527595996857, -0.03309575468301773, -0.05218491330742836, -0.014313345775008202, -0.00527961365878582, 0.05509323254227638, -0.0009404921438544989, -0.06244773417711258, 0.048507072031497955, 0.002606755355373025, -0.018097160384058952, 0.027866574004292488, -0.00228216708637774, -0.0009687613928690553, 0.007231891620904207, 0.024958740919828415, -0.02094467543065548, 0.005661729723215103, -0.0216879453510046, 0.013777291402220726, 0.01860225386917591, 0.04585364833474159, 0.0600656159222126, -0.0017201901646330953, -0.003414024831727147, 0.008400504477322102, 0.04008020833134651, 0.03221267834305763, -0.011302651837468147, 0.0937318503856659, -0.02292119897902012, 0.007898076437413692, -0.033095233142375946, -0.0024129413068294525, -0.023592254146933556, 0.03415234759449959, 0.009633205831050873, -0.057779353111982346, 0.04332077130675316, -0.0406515933573246, 0.019485387951135635, 0.0020133727230131626, 0.01306999009102583, -0.003116204869002104, -0.03603116422891617, 0.04242729768157005, 0.03953571245074272, -0.03620192036032677, 0.0014041870599612594, -0.022243421524763107, 0.021564936265349388, -0.014865345321595669, -0.03283064439892769, -0.03389178588986397, 0.06484588980674744, -0.018337834626436234, 0.009287907741963863, -0.005636907648295164, -0.01584230735898018, -0.005927423480898142, 0.008121921680867672, 0.06116309016942978, 0.06489946693181992, 0.03572027012705803, -0.05349830165505409, 0.01570872962474823, 0.0020964343566447496, -0.0712217316031456, -0.009209921583533287, 0.016855591908097267, -0.01805201731622219, -0.03789651393890381, 0.06399795413017273, 0.034577008336782455, 0.013691743835806847, 0.012340528890490532, 0.037624865770339966, 0.031950775533914566, 0.0012580855982378125, -0.0949995145201683, -0.07742403447628021, 0.06605211645364761, -0.01077105663716793, -0.001612289808690548, -0.04111962020397186, 0.0011820332147181034, 0.01326933316886425, 0.05636688694357872, -0.011782084591686726, 0.025591403245925903, 0.0015196205349639058, 0.021165333688259125, 0.01008068211376667, -0.032492026686668396, 0.03087279200553894, -0.0264334287494421, 0.0018909950740635395, -0.00038099088123999536, -0.1034824401140213, 0.014771860092878342, 0.007388391066342592, -0.00906854122877121, -0.014400094747543335, 0.05619542673230171, -0.004471744876354933, -0.005949137732386589, 0.0012829029001295567, 0.021291740238666534, -0.0034939609467983246, 0.05145636573433876, -0.004578692372888327, 0.044525109231472015, 0.035888414829969406, -0.011598031967878342, 0.011129929684102535, -0.01641208492219448, 0.03792950138449669, 0.014806510880589485, -0.05021859332919121, -0.010841265320777893, -0.028010407462716103, 0.0214406568557024, 0.015002944506704807, -0.06281408667564392, -0.03217315673828125, 0.016136974096298218, -0.017817627638578415, 0.0217168927192688, 0.04746932536363602, -0.003943556919693947, -0.009640791453421116, 0.020005179569125175, -0.03972689062356949, -0.04155340418219566, -0.06447917222976685, -0.011878070421516895, -0.018751107156276703, -0.028335416689515114, 0.045219503343105316, -0.02418438158929348, 0.021443907171487808, -0.029527267441153526, -0.01366270799189806, -0.02863067016005516, 0.034058257937431335, 0.030258364975452423, -0.0033108724746853113, 0.01606058143079281, 0.05918730050325394, 0.029085073620080948, -0.012779961340129375, 0.013717059046030045, -0.02307320572435856, -0.031197022646665573, 0.030333606526255608, -0.05540400743484497, 0.021691570058465004, 0.002679315861314535, -0.024958480149507523, -0.004218508955091238, 0.00885519664734602, -0.03606443479657173, 0.06036178395152092, -0.049973323941230774, 0.04002275690436363, 0.06081681698560715, -0.009587622247636318, -0.0029016940388828516, -0.009278387762606144, 0.008591962978243828, 0.01404674630612135, -0.019420204684138298, 0.01564190909266472, -0.059505462646484375, 0.010612763464450836, 0.03841478377580643, 0.0050842235796153545, -0.057648949325084686, 0.053819913417100906, 0.026078980416059494, 0.030998945236206055, -0.02951718680560589, 0.038278307765722275, -0.00988126639276743, -0.0286488588899374, -0.0018265133257955313, 0.04485585540533066, 0.02883625216782093, 0.03998618572950363, -0.012217330746352673, 0.0009725709678605199, 0.04352971538901329, -0.007681886199861765, 0.01958988606929779, 0.08227147907018661, -0.02315295860171318, -0.01612865924835205, -0.0038965530693531036, 0.016133466735482216, 0.021146269515156746, -0.0005421684472821653, 0.012528426945209503, 0.03161168098449707, 0.026963545009493828, -0.00955679640173912, -0.020146502181887627, -0.003506006207317114, 0.028060274198651314, 0.015578387305140495, -0.06618097424507141, 0.005387190263718367, 0.017745330929756165, -0.04661001265048981, 0.015492926351726055, -0.054854072630405426, -0.010347854346036911, -0.0019979896023869514, 0.004722051788121462, -0.003970806952565908, 0.011360668577253819, 0.03255004808306694, -0.06175440549850464, -0.01844974420964718, -0.006277532782405615, -0.028162112459540367, 0.026242457330226898, -0.027717573568224907, -0.041398532688617706, -0.01498469803482294, -0.06080406531691551, -0.026407770812511444, 0.028160231187939644, -0.019913796335458755, -0.030119579285383224, -0.004456949885934591, 0.01719266176223755, -0.05996781587600708, -0.05389867350459099, -0.03358651325106621, 0.030677052214741707, -0.022938594222068787, -0.07022794336080551, 0.067904032766819, -0.011759175918996334, -0.029806070029735565, 0.030362827703356743, 0.009954854846000671, -0.005216182675212622, 0.006293634418398142, -0.016190964728593826, 0.005512995645403862, -0.009449939243495464, -0.009489900432527065, 0.04200080409646034, -0.04059448465704918, -0.025941934436559677, -0.0677918866276741, -0.04889635369181633, 0.03196844458580017, 0.009680519811809063, 0.059495314955711365, 0.00717189023271203, -0.018513359129428864, 0.06481926888227463, 0.03193432092666626, -0.00871566217392683, -0.04313661530613899, 0.004337510094046593, -0.07877442985773087, -0.03391715884208679, -0.024527834728360176, 0.0005042636184953153, -0.005716443993151188, 0.02560078352689743, 0.015805743634700775, 0.020946945995092392, 0.042934779077768326, 0.008390228264033794, 0.007110584992915392, 0.024525893852114677, 0.022749943658709526, -0.04209170490503311, 0.018827887251973152, 0.04026544466614723, 0.00011799413914559409, 0.012941976077854633, -0.013483223505318165, 0.020297124981880188, 0.011024035513401031, -0.023525971919298172, 0.04484368488192558, -0.0041639613918960094, -0.018896790221333504, -0.034742388874292374, 0.026631884276866913, 0.07457663118839264, -0.023831281810998917, 0.01263489481061697, 0.01953582838177681, 0.015229303389787674, -0.05053102597594261, -0.01234309934079647, 0.020966511219739914, 0.04177260398864746, -0.034520749002695084, -0.03019861876964569, -0.023373408243060112, -0.0035884177777916193, 0.006588264834135771, -0.018302297219634056, 0.007634966634213924, 0.036280956119298935, 0.032859835773706436, 0.017527978867292404, -0.0016805146588012576, -0.06394706666469574, 0.01877031847834587, -0.06974152475595474, 0.026574350893497467, -0.02370920591056347, 0.02274000085890293, 0.004718992859125137, 0.010040164925158024, 0.046578548848629, -0.039027098566293716, 0.0014541316777467728, 0.010075733065605164, -0.07109340280294418, 0.033545706421136856, -0.0071358815766870975, -0.010123994201421738, 0.01984468288719654, -0.021573588252067566, 0.010274222120642662, -0.05795660614967346, -0.005628377199172974, -0.023312995210289955, 0.01607714779675007, -0.012342412956058979, 0.022452201694250107, -0.019435003399848938, -0.0339326374232769, 0.023100720718503, 0.0305133368819952, 0.023260217159986496, -0.010375753976404667, 0.028885874897241592, 0.05454709008336067, -0.02548464946448803, 0.002905706875026226, -0.009004135616123676, -0.0034075172152370214, 0.01955972984433174, 0.021859778091311455, 0.0224081352353096, 0.0249261986464262, -0.02115153893828392, 0.034274663776159286, 0.024651093408465385, 0.026790576055645943, 0.06031395494937897, -0.03357723727822304, -0.03462684154510498, -0.04641924798488617, -0.006699469871819019, 0.008961591869592667, 0.005904631223529577, 0.039998892694711685, -0.02504071779549122, 0.04878190532326698, 0.03670455887913704, -0.04628859832882881, 0.03562469407916069, 0.06254158169031143, -0.02432098798453808, -0.010119819082319736, -0.015577279031276703, -0.029788276180624962, 0.024191632866859436, -0.010559417307376862, 0.052993059158325195, 0.013886372558772564, -0.024738704785704613, -0.014090956188738346, 0.005847471300512552, -0.039667267352342606, -0.028896428644657135, 0.016230519860982895, -0.008142078295350075, 0.039970654994249344, -0.0033659772016108036, -0.03499235212802887, 0.01876719482243061, 0.03481467813253403, 0.019622091203927994, 0.009363437071442604, -0.0169492419809103, -0.08731371909379959, 0.030426934361457825, 0.047201551496982574, 0.05811724066734314, -0.03277275338768959, 0.03703033924102783, -0.002423615427687764, 0.003786879125982523, 0.009237371385097504, -0.04444197565317154, 0.029467863962054253, -0.026456203311681747, 0.009870309382677078, -0.047356925904750824, -0.012932831421494484, -0.03259912133216858, 0.022675538435578346, -0.01417803205549717, 0.00740813696756959, -0.046960391104221344, 0.006747545674443245, -0.035785261541604996, 0.016671080142259598, 0.002653258852660656, 0.06532779335975647, -0.024936042726039886, -0.008349396288394928, -0.019894780591130257, 0.02091837488114834, -0.051324568688869476, -0.06957826018333435, 0.005291002802550793, -0.005916725844144821, -0.02305140346288681, 0.050958648324012756, -0.03491390496492386, -0.04116193205118179, 0.0401359423995018, 0.001036288682371378, -0.04516838863492012, 0.011903868056833744, -0.03792497515678406, 0.03497166559100151, 0.020270496606826782, 0.026485135778784752, 0.060419436544179916, 0.021221991628408432, -0.030329328030347824, 0.014825225807726383, 0.01153466384857893, 0.0004818139714188874, -0.04985828697681427, -0.020894071087241173, -0.044623278081417084, 0.0028323179576545954, -0.04927986115217209, 0.03797834739089012, 0.013413356617093086, -0.023154033347964287, -0.026195775717496872, -0.0025219465605914593, -0.014384876936674118, 0.023632045835256577, 0.021245885640382767, -0.002727130427956581, -0.0065564657561481, 0.023958677425980568, -0.041515640914440155, 0.019391080364584923, 0.017258409410715103, -0.003752727061510086, 0.010687721893191338, 0.026789873838424683, -0.015521513298153877, 0.03829208016395569, -0.012453662231564522, -0.015555815771222115, 0.006717512384057045, -0.03699946030974388, 0.0550224743783474, -0.004707311280071735, 0.0130732711404562, -0.017837699502706528, -0.05494191497564316, -0.00995317380875349, 0.048647403717041016, 0.00907916110008955, 0.027019774541258812, -0.023913010954856873, 0.04494060203433037, -0.010726815089583397, -0.011112181469798088, -0.024543551728129387, -0.02463272213935852, 0.029393190518021584, 0.015057488344609737, -0.004346498288214207, -0.021499160677194595, -0.006550684571266174, -0.031216854229569435, -0.014318077825009823, -0.0456356555223465, 0.05915284901857376, -0.04569312557578087, -0.03695453703403473, -0.016319528222084045, 0.048114191740751266, 0.04805054888129234, 0.011863721534609795, -0.009480091743171215, 0.008088880218565464, -0.0025822757743299007, -0.016861096024513245, 0.010676706209778786, -0.004909603390842676, -0.02900230884552002, -0.037181057035923004, -0.049582503736019135, 0.011832622811198235, 0.03613477200269699, -0.03175557404756546, -0.033295225352048874, -0.005461967550218105, -0.02268456667661667, -0.02035137079656124, -0.039782796055078506, 0.005721453111618757, -0.017876673489809036, 0.03932633250951767, -0.014702915214002132, 0.02017238177359104, -0.008692135103046894, -0.019134346395730972, 0.02997279353439808, -0.008366052992641926, -0.03300391137599945, 0.02888588234782219, 0.08643713593482971, -0.02233145572245121, 0.06643934547901154, -0.021114518865942955, -0.017535313963890076, 0.02547864429652691, -0.011064591817557812, -0.0002747742983046919, -0.006197027862071991, 0.016761306673288345, -0.04216370731592178, -0.009615874849259853, -0.007749855984002352, -0.011532874777913094, 0.04215056449174881, -0.023509269580245018, 0.0400172621011734, 0.07187202572822571, -0.029995454475283623, 0.01075031142681837, -0.021254397928714752, 0.019343994557857513, -0.012895569205284119, 0.03286120668053627, 0.04712797701358795, -0.01413093600422144, -0.0076011777855455875, 0.06822626292705536, 0.012953287921845913, 0.021377410739660263, 0.00032058428041636944, 0.03268337994813919, 0.013743630610406399, 0.008464019745588303, -0.015173285268247128, -0.03295275196433067, 0.061052463948726654, -0.06707034260034561, -0.0014957039384171367, -0.017070673406124115, -0.029952993616461754, 0.06014309450984001, 0.027472268790006638, 0.008283207193017006, -0.04828008636832237, -0.0090021388605237, -0.07007233053445816, 0.04875880107283592, -0.011725504882633686, 0.01573711633682251, 0.022224949672818184, -0.03510360047221184, 0.052202921360731125, -0.006970501970499754, 0.02405066043138504, -0.02308606542646885, -0.061479683965444565, -0.0451628714799881, -0.017170408740639687, -0.005439283791929483, 0.016160745173692703, -0.016600990667939186, -0.041044093668460846, 0.016712157055735588, -0.032707203179597855, 0.01671076938509941, 0.03844796493649483, 0.062302689999341965, -0.07150400429964066, 0.07713709026575089, -0.009505982510745525, 0.003095962107181549, 0.006214408203959465, -0.06510666012763977, 0.09913363307714462, 0.08188635110855103, 0.01245120633393526, -0.08309467136859894, 0.03627544641494751, 0.02170192264020443, 0.02208300679922104, -0.006574961822479963, -0.004421629011631012, -0.014631913043558598, 0.03534642979502678, 0.01593976654112339, 0.07368646562099457, 0.005414482671767473, 0.004029263276606798, 0.05886143818497658, -0.031295809894800186, -0.035836730152368546, -0.010817361995577812, 0.023378554731607437, -0.0017616894328966737, -0.03579891845583916, -0.02640700899064541, 0.008351761847734451, 0.008540025912225246, 0.014068384654819965, 0.009151739999651909, -0.03292269632220268, 0.010559375397861004, -0.00023447824059985578, -0.009268749505281448, -0.017542501911520958, 0.01333753764629364, -0.00876512099057436, -0.04128320515155792, -0.0037020693998783827, 0.013791603967547417, -0.018488220870494843, 0.0263045784085989, 0.06409122794866562, 0.013614504598081112, -0.019741922616958618, 0.014809642918407917, 0.04053543880581856, -0.05023721605539322, -0.020229294896125793, 0.00005700798283214681, 0.04235776886343956, 0.0032008688431233168, -0.03394206240773201, -0.035378359258174896, -0.0021783788688480854, 0.0015770259778946638, -0.03816612809896469, -0.011781466193497181, 0.021777179092168808, 0.037222396582365036, -0.03558114916086197, -0.024060556665062904, -0.027616042643785477, 0.01618020050227642, 0.010396653786301613, 0.0311586894094944, 0.019738901406526566, -0.024199005216360092, -0.017520079389214516, -0.02116011641919613, 0.0285909753292799, 0.010150725021958351, 0.0477106086909771, -0.015923526138067245, 0.016641559079289436, -0.01826908066868782, 0.010971725918352604, 0.02917664498090744, -0.004186674952507019, 0.02863151580095291, 0.0068059395998716354, 0.006047604139894247, -0.01358264870941639, -0.014824047684669495, -0.011518120765686035, -0.01547082606703043, -0.017632121220231056, -0.048491332679986954, 0.007263657171279192, 0.033061061054468155, 0.03794638067483902, 0.025415878742933273, 0.011683761142194271, 0.006549893878400326, 0.047224268317222595, 0.004439969547092915, -0.04769737273454666, -0.03299933299422264, -0.00407843803986907, 0.007974054664373398, -0.0033419528044760227, -0.01927613839507103, 0.05156246945261955, 0.011714420281350613, 0.041770968586206436, -0.002635215874761343, -0.002856503939256072, 0.003911134321242571, -0.0011376128531992435, 0.011512423865497112, -0.04628988727927208, -0.017155790701508522, 0.023357288911938667, 0.012981852516531944, -0.028727883473038673, -0.02730412222445011, -0.01656358689069748, -0.016067445278167725, 0.02913590520620346, -0.030870750546455383, -0.04496080055832863, 0.02646034210920334, -0.019982071593403816, 0.01447116769850254, -0.05410877615213394, -0.017362674698233604, -0.047017913311719894, -0.036565858870744705, -0.004244302399456501, -0.03389913588762283, 0.005020846147090197, -0.0027497548144310713, -0.01783084124326706, -0.009610193781554699, 0.030209656804800034, -0.00007824465137673542, -0.020031103864312172, 0.014932646416127682, 0.037435561418533325, 0.013428336940705776, 0.02332364022731781, -0.017819654196500778, -0.028713935986161232, 0.07232178747653961, -0.007444217335432768, -0.03202499821782112, 0.0238544549793005, 0.0024317465722560883, 0.02919716015458107, 0.01817343942821026, 0.0008021785761229694, -0.013660842552781105, 0.020402254536747932, -0.014622989110648632, 0.0016743614105507731, -0.0010518442140892148, 0.011246557347476482, -0.02458152547478676, 0.0010503330267965794, 0.022776028141379356, 0.012782001867890358, 0.010068321600556374, 0.03770020976662636, 0.04946862906217575, 0.014031309634447098, -0.025097791105508804, 0.0074372622184455395, 0.0006114343996159732, 0.04561952129006386, -0.003945318516343832, 0.010221476666629314, 0.019553352147340775, 0.03390703722834587, -0.026632243767380714, 0.05747193843126297, -0.014293858781456947, 0.006291850935667753, -0.10382211953401566, 0.0016467155655846, 0.009687932208180428, 0.011255878955125809, 0.02641746774315834, -0.039088357239961624, 0.02295050583779812, 0.02084064856171608, -0.04943372681736946, -0.002431954024359584, -0.023959944024682045, -0.00888002384454012, -0.04958478733897209, 0.0011466004652902484, -0.03949004411697388, 0.014544444158673286, 0.02307520993053913, 0.024286551401019096, 0.0328851081430912, 0.022877689450979233, 0.019263189285993576, -0.019228721037507057, 0.009774047881364822, 0.026587646454572678, 0.01638132892549038, -0.05683886632323265, 0.04630709066987038, -0.009202712215483189, -0.045378074049949646, 0.026564713567495346, -0.010079408995807171, 0.04938909783959389, 0.04438203573226929, 0.004779127426445484, 0.011979382485151291, 0.007083137519657612, 0.048042189329862595, 0.002959930570796132, -0.027149615809321404, 0.0026193680241703987, -0.0006422676960937679, 0.02918180637061596, 0.0079124690964818, 0.007905893959105015, 0.035780441015958786, -0.04502639174461365, -0.011802886612713337, 0.01656651683151722, -0.04163598269224167, -0.01393033191561699, -0.019535327330231667, 0.001725665875710547, 0.007247806992381811, -0.03051045536994934, 0.0028423264157027006, -0.021695690229535103, -0.02654036320745945, 0.04270678758621216, 0.03698718920350075, -0.026653066277503967, -0.007438085041940212, -0.002136422088369727, -0.025330882519483566, 0.011907942593097687, -0.03859728202223778, -0.00823378749191761, -0.07715044915676117, 0.01893787458539009, 0.006663973908871412, -0.021033747121691704, -0.05667059123516083, -0.0027086036279797554, -0.04556058719754219, 0.05450156331062317, -0.00952587928622961, -0.02336312271654606, 0.0002655382559169084, -0.019728587940335274, 0.00045380552182905376, -0.0869504064321518, 0.09377973526716232, 0.028233617544174194, -0.0037705544382333755, -0.04262238368391991, 0.0020619824063032866, -0.02653002366423607, 0.01594371534883976, 0.05296601355075836, 0.019348425790667534, 0.005184520501643419, 0.01844778098165989, 0.0395992286503315, 0.008224943652749062, -0.04502106085419655, 0.01898106187582016, -0.015586616471409798, -0.004541455302387476, -0.027587471529841423, -0.03608313202857971, 0.010347610339522362, -0.01367918960750103, 0.05075099691748619, 0.000013574433069152292, 0.03225049749016762, -0.0034241697285324335, 0.0018146359361708164, 0.04407618194818497, 0.002767708618193865, -0.03928472101688385, 0.02608136087656021, -0.0061707161366939545, 0.03298177942633629, 0.0031010645907372236, 0.009805567562580109, -0.05602452903985977, 0.02901911549270153, 0.00212671235203743, -0.024303987622261047, -0.006271923426538706, -0.015028283931314945, -0.02581283636391163, -0.04832307621836662, -0.022447409108281136, 0.009755604900419712, -0.0357615128159523, -0.015349688939750195, 0.0076822987757623196, 0.04959659278392792, 0.021049072965979576, 0.007558950688689947, 0.003077424829825759, -0.0033658342435956, -0.040254153311252594, -0.02970079518854618, 0.024117683991789818, 0.03845028579235077, -0.004056622739881277, 0.00020047755970153958, 0.046669382601976395, 0.0033862730488181114, 0.018032385036349297, 0.009654521942138672, 0.05720062181353569, -0.03385307639837265, -0.030241671949625015, 0.028182508423924446, 0.002187361940741539, -0.005710865370929241, -0.0056457980535924435, 0.012078740634024143, 0.038175225257873535, -0.031142907217144966, 0.003932910971343517, 0.000583210086915642, -0.0060725430957973, -0.022597189992666245, 0.010214107111096382, 0.020098738372325897, 0.033237915486097336, 0.015192460268735886, -0.0012873770901933312, -0.01765185035765171, 0.0031084734946489334, 0.0402064174413681, -0.013290686532855034, 0.018194928765296936, -0.027306929230690002, -0.03252773359417915, -0.017158430069684982, -0.03287969157099724, -0.019450483843684196, 0.0031520267948508263, 0.015939049422740936, 0.029329918324947357, 0.045452844351530075, -0.040804121643304825, -0.03414079546928406, -0.008978213183581829, 0.04763628914952278, -0.08424282819032669, -0.0011112772626802325, -0.02513929083943367, 0.0017369105480611324, 0.030304962769150734, -0.01285687554627657 ]
<p>I need to proof that $X$ follows a distribution $F$ with probability $1-p$ and a distribution $G$ with probability $p$ if, and only if, its distribution function is:</p> <p>$(1-p)F + pG$</p> <p>Can anyone give me some hints about how to proof this?</p> <p><strong>EDIT2</strong>: this is my <em>second</em> take based on comments:</p> <p>$$F_p(x)=Pr(X\le x)=\int_{-\infty}^x dF_p(x)=(1-p)\int_{-\infty}^xdF(x)+p \int_{-\infty}^xdG(x) = (1-p)F+pG$$</p> <p>but I am not sure if this is a valid proof</p>
74,325
[ -0.016014104709029198, -0.039661478251218796, 0.03355592116713524, -0.007190350908786058, 0.016288457438349724, 0.04076902195811272, 0.008358345367014408, 0.008583816699683666, 0.03166554123163223, -0.05156116932630539, 0.04886524751782417, 0.00808115117251873, 0.07402089983224869, -0.008091820403933525, 0.04433188959956169, -0.01516247820109129, -0.021902773529291153, 0.03467812389135361, -0.006160122808068991, -0.046631522476673126, -0.040809545665979385, 0.03913705423474312, 0.04255559667944908, -0.018402690067887306, -0.02146565169095993, 0.010621312074363232, 0.014381022192537785, 0.006755378562957048, 0.022931573912501335, 0.11600376665592194, -0.012074974365532398, 0.005506284534931183, 0.0010332181118428707, 0.06246993690729141, 0.01780710741877556, 0.02400309592485428, -0.022812755778431892, 0.014588483609259129, -0.03447714447975159, -0.005427286960184574, -0.01199373323470354, -0.0030874123331159353, 0.044090572744607925, 0.007268060464411974, 0.026759451255202293, 0.02882242202758789, 0.022744199261069298, -0.02574176713824272, 0.05111376568675041, -0.05670926719903946, 0.05764502286911011, -0.01956835761666298, 0.042201995849609375, 0.06709183007478714, 0.016236882656812668, -0.032332491129636765, 0.03403601795434952, 0.1042899340391159, 0.018836796283721924, -0.03290523588657379, -0.019727570936083794, -0.05127064883708954, 0.02907511033117771, -0.002002968220040202, -0.039354994893074036, 0.026247719302773476, 0.016184059903025627, -0.02086607553064823, 0.002421347424387932, -0.013453453779220581, 0.0005028952728025615, 0.047471269965171814, 0.022516736760735512, -0.0025272562634199858, -0.030481332913041115, 0.013742226175963879, 0.006642502266913652, 0.04324553534388542, 0.050744205713272095, 0.009756638668477535, 0.005077030975371599, 0.047145336866378784, 0.02332414500415325, -0.006653481628745794, -0.000040370217902818695, 0.025777768343687057, 0.09803123027086258, 0.008617907762527466, 0.013231919147074223, 0.033805571496486664, -0.038569483906030655, 0.004087446723133326, 0.02809537947177887, -0.0211581289768219, -0.023420872166752815, 0.0422428660094738, -0.02386428788304329, -0.00010203268175246194, 0.007941016927361488, -0.01391457300633192, -0.04568316414952278, -0.07814465463161469, 0.006464398466050625, 0.04982972517609596, -0.030189480632543564, -0.007615273352712393, -0.0262250155210495, 0.02671929821372032, -0.011827154085040092, -0.008843372575938702, -0.019967161118984222, 0.06907649338245392, 0.004633406177163124, -0.02300207130610943, -0.0019564349204301834, -0.002009353134781122, -0.02039964869618416, -0.02594195306301117, 0.04026496782898903, 0.05391189828515053, 0.05221502110362053, 0.006960077676922083, 0.008500556461513042, -0.023301176726818085, -0.04034946858882904, 0.014230853877961636, 0.027149368077516556, 0.02210799790918827, -0.023441791534423828, 0.07276281714439392, -0.010022787377238274, -0.027803555130958557, -0.015608723275363445, 0.057661864906549454, 0.02065787836909294, -0.01203248556703329, -0.07520479708909988, -0.01328804437071085, 0.04954610392451286, -0.012032458558678627, 0.021072745323181152, -0.042558908462524414, 0.006091652438044548, 0.05011359602212906, 0.047823626548051834, -0.01589750126004219, 0.052006762474775314, -0.02675243280827999, -0.018727334216237068, 0.00004314925899961963, -0.01604357734322548, -0.026017025113105774, 0.012258791364729404, -0.03597545623779297, 0.0033424829598516226, -0.06929032504558563, 0.017540624365210533, 0.020678360015153885, -0.01973293162882328, -0.05395856872200966, 0.053734082728624344, -0.03352862223982811, -0.022201744839549065, -0.0366886667907238, 0.029747946187853813, -0.027383791282773018, 0.05377358943223953, 0.021809523925185204, -0.011976173147559166, -0.010358124040067196, 0.056345388293266296, 0.02085280604660511, 0.0025284728035330772, 0.026957685127854347, 0.042671989649534225, -0.03680458292365074, -0.04140093922615051, -0.025787528604269028, 0.008847431279718876, 0.021737221628427505, 0.004379080142825842, 0.018481459468603134, -0.05128679424524307, -0.014696545898914337, -0.0047184475697577, 0.040094565600156784, 0.018491528928279877, 0.006317914463579655, 0.022830195724964142, -0.039408110082149506, -0.0320882648229599, -0.04726714640855789, 0.004623682238161564, -0.023404767736792564, -0.052272915840148926, 0.014886578544974327, 0.02771708555519581, 0.004279489628970623, -0.02884388156235218, -0.015323102474212646, -0.04118936508893967, -0.009970189072191715, 0.02380685694515705, -0.041534069925546646, 0.003131839679554105, 0.04025314748287201, 0.06754233688116074, -0.04331621527671814, 0.037444304674863815, -0.03890400007367134, -0.0009739255765452981, 0.020804785192012787, -0.05896450951695442, -0.02479802817106247, -0.02410249225795269, -0.003252460854128003, 0.02507445216178894, -0.018497804179787636, 0.01916835457086563, 0.028795018792152405, -0.05866503715515137, 0.054011911153793335, 0.0804581418633461, 0.005335927940905094, -0.017981907352805138, -0.011860284954309464, 0.012779711745679379, -0.016418861225247383, -0.017724808305501938, -0.03679690882563591, -0.005904025863856077, -0.025093069300055504, 0.04206272214651108, 0.03638700023293495, -0.014280881732702255, 0.018873868510127068, 0.04323147237300873, 0.005000264383852482, 0.02923242188990116, 0.058828696608543396, 0.020616726949810982, 0.00769429188221693, 0.0014996733516454697, 0.01119039673358202, 0.027845267206430435, 0.0036371443420648575, 0.005646873731166124, 0.012590871192514896, -0.0072410875000059605, 0.024663330987095833, -0.053642433136701584, 0.02791072055697441, 0.011985814198851585, 0.04258529841899872, 0.0086775291711092, -0.004905228037387133, 0.0295379851013422, -0.02304997108876705, -0.03464476391673088, -0.02309359610080719, -0.022170133888721466, 0.001404508831910789, -0.02522106096148491, -0.04637923091650009, 0.008937867358326912, 0.04148167371749878, -0.04722440615296364, -0.02878943644464016, 0.014597570523619652, -0.027383681386709213, -0.00668343948200345, -0.014297520741820335, -0.056264378130435944, -0.011278796009719372, -0.0026709805242717266, -0.019023913890123367, 0.036169275641441345, -0.012691613286733627, -0.021391388028860092, -0.027828892692923546, 0.02595958113670349, -0.02132832631468773, 0.030019471421837807, -0.00550400884822011, -0.03559611365199089, 0.0030623581260442734, -0.035136573016643524, 0.0016495446907356381, 0.047467879951000214, -0.00012394634541124105, 0.002371926326304674, -0.02911214344203472, -0.009165240451693535, -0.05840088799595833, 0.013213598169386387, -0.0637524425983429, 0.029715579003095627, -0.023738155141472816, -0.03322626277804375, 0.028862720355391502, -0.011095902882516384, -0.04530829191207886, 0.026738567277789116, -0.015551809221506119, -0.03779791668057442, -0.017307357862591743, -0.01127140037715435, 0.009098279289901257, -0.01283163484185934, 0.020539365708827972, 0.0017530411714687943, -0.04063147306442261, -0.022390590980648994, -0.029662014916539192, -0.06300211697816849, 0.0021950071677565575, 0.009631391614675522, 0.01072622649371624, -0.002343843225389719, -0.03197250887751579, 0.06098238751292229, 0.08200017362833023, -0.03415810316801071, -0.034219350665807724, 0.01457051932811737, -0.03138764575123787, -0.0027938818093389273, 0.023892533034086227, 0.02687591314315796, -0.01822587102651596, 0.09004346281290054, 0.02568446658551693, 0.017568537965416908, 0.028359580785036087, 0.007337318733334541, -0.014153479598462582, 0.01704167202115059, -0.025005938485264778, 0.021604981273412704, 0.009008454158902168, 0.024832921102643013, -0.006870560348033905, -0.002001778921112418, 0.008833672851324081, 0.009616049937903881, 0.00269195600412786, 0.0026325637008994818, 0.015923796221613884, -0.009334223344922066, 0.017935074865818024, -0.0719270259141922, 0.06454531848430634, 0.024645578116178513, -0.02900168113410473, 0.021846411749720573, -0.00938369520008564, 0.06251689791679382, -0.026119709014892578, -0.005258077289909124, 0.03969946876168251, 0.03427951782941818, -0.0243837907910347, -0.03573416545987129, -0.028451651334762573, -0.028643984347581863, 0.04765021800994873, -0.01059345155954361, -0.00802251324057579, 0.03110559470951557, 0.004054791759699583, 0.03698360547423363, -0.009531869553029537, 0.0021066933404654264, -0.009264598600566387, -0.05958141013979912, 0.03668278828263283, 0.035053838044404984, 0.04409113898873329, 0.022942187264561653, 0.056982945650815964, 0.008530871942639351, -0.03390884771943092, -0.017950451001524925, 0.019909145310521126, -0.07531747221946716, 0.06409250199794769, -0.0029953981284052134, -0.015240177512168884, -0.04052051156759262, -0.003773964010179043, 0.027926074340939522, -0.03585148602724075, -0.013706814497709274, 0.006854717619717121, -0.04664751887321472, -0.017640577629208565, -0.03085380792617798, -0.035505250096321106, -0.03295955806970596, 0.004157741088420153, 0.015894407406449318, 0.015436453744769096, -0.011233609169721603, 0.03719773516058922, 0.06007613241672516, 0.006339188665151596, -0.018243582919239998, -0.04529611021280289, 0.003905301447957754, 0.05511193349957466, 0.026634378358721733, 0.029073962941765785, 0.022742968052625656, 0.02686227299273014, 0.011870249174535275, -0.02450108900666237, 0.06118949502706528, 0.03238922357559204, -0.04795612394809723, 0.009309629909694195, -0.06316318362951279, -0.007643515709787607, 0.027772611007094383, 0.004863282665610313, -0.022508054971694946, -0.007468873169273138, 0.042888473719358444, -0.03292960301041603, -0.009112766943871975, 0.048771992325782776, 0.04850848764181137, -0.01045948825776577, -0.0040294453501701355, -0.0321105495095253, -0.02060592733323574, -0.048844702541828156, -0.000280716922134161, 0.012266158126294613, 0.010431078262627125, 0.015311573632061481, -0.016672197729349136, 0.014417489990592003, 0.01141553744673729, -0.003938915673643351, -0.02722444012761116, 0.021563900634646416, 0.03038126789033413, 0.0036643173079937696, -0.026529911905527115, 0.04743451252579689, 0.013424844481050968, 0.01938791014254093, 0.011502763256430626, -0.002509112237021327, -0.0536118820309639, 0.003188786096870899, 0.04401759058237076, 0.0708899050951004, -0.000044334010453894734, 0.022808806970715523, -0.01764826849102974, -0.034123655408620834, 0.029347030445933342, 0.004913146607577801, -0.0071439300663769245, -0.008330410346388817, 0.002891865326091647, 0.04591524228453636, -0.06207730248570442, -0.06957950443029404, 0.0299387164413929, 0.006378239020705223, 0.0001810884423321113, -0.030043628066778183, -0.0034417309798300266, -0.047533418983221054, 0.008823568932712078, 0.030272038653492928, 0.06347648054361343, -0.0046806721948087215, -0.00456049432978034, -0.0072876946069300175, 0.055822864174842834, 0.004380387254059315, -0.07001018524169922, 0.050757333636283875, -0.006510901730507612, -0.003820254700258374, 0.060421764850616455, -0.012352429330348969, -0.07776243984699249, 0.018651679158210754, -0.01667427457869053, -0.036113541573286057, 0.04415346309542656, -0.017878156155347824, 0.05024084448814392, 0.029681464657187462, 0.012554598040878773, 0.005451631266623735, 0.06540273874998093, -0.0056402357295155525, 0.005613731220364571, -0.011617161333560944, -0.005914142820984125, -0.04744875058531761, -0.00961623527109623, -0.036625590175390244, -0.012322971597313881, -0.04172782972455025, 0.01370313111692667, 0.009114325977861881, 0.017456533387303352, -0.014747057110071182, -0.011179981753230095, 0.00806925818324089, -0.00790109671652317, 0.007736983243376017, 0.0376809760928154, -0.015465311706066132, 0.005468369461596012, 0.041880641132593155, -0.01110547874122858, 0.003021740820258856, -0.014181438833475113, -0.008612035773694515, 0.008482469245791435, 0.015154200606048107, -0.008327635936439037, -0.021270131692290306, -0.030667748302221298, -0.030690956860780716, -0.03412861377000809, -0.006214624736458063, -0.005541787017136812, 0.013355385512113571, 0.017173752188682556, -0.0329214371740818, -0.03096340037882328, 0.022780437022447586, 0.012871629558503628, 0.03405552729964256, -0.068304143846035, 0.018403295427560806, -0.019948363304138184, -0.06605999916791916, -0.0680447667837143, -0.0376615896821022, 0.013959219679236412, 0.006537740118801594, -0.028590664267539978, -0.051784127950668335, 0.0390193946659565, -0.01222948171198368, 0.0175733994692564, -0.03499040752649307, 0.004278476350009441, -0.0030027255415916443, -0.00889351312071085, 0.016886714845895767, -0.017885008826851845, 0.09119410812854767, -0.03528957813978195, -0.014774447306990623, 0.013516881503164768, -0.027452656999230385, -0.06739428639411926, -0.0030461885035037994, -0.023145126178860664, -0.028149856254458427, -0.005141573492437601, 0.004623071290552616, -0.003181269159540534, -0.018530720844864845, -0.04311549291014671, -0.011244595050811768, 0.01833885908126831, 0.012011069804430008, 0.024986134842038155, -0.01408838015049696, -0.010333296842873096, 0.0007568313158117235, -0.004910297226160765, -0.00044370288378559053, -0.003252050606533885, -0.013168036937713623, -0.02702760323882103, 0.0359685942530632, -0.04349830001592636, -0.008534356951713562, 0.020385336130857468, 0.08453000336885452, 0.0024403748102486134, 0.006384051870554686, 0.029720764607191086, -0.005165872164070606, 0.033948346972465515, -0.033832352608442307, 0.004699855577200651, -0.01033456064760685, 0.02702774666249752, -0.03175332397222519, 0.011772800236940384, -0.024776320904493332, 0.0031481951009482145, 0.03301968052983284, 0.011757622472941875, 0.06982504576444626, -0.016390720382332802, 0.02294541336596012, 0.003419108921661973, 0.016748622059822083, -0.013793655671179295, -0.00647515757009387, -0.03391040489077568, 0.047591470181941986, -0.023811889812350273, 0.014765778556466103, 0.011859369464218616, 0.01664886437356472, 0.00445552309975028, 0.02109762281179428, -0.024161824956536293, -0.015629028901457787, 0.05120182782411575, 0.002367772627621889, -0.012112238444387913, 0.04486922174692154, -0.030306654050946236, -0.0004509407444857061, -0.05798919498920441, -0.010030635632574558, 0.046155329793691635, -0.00929361954331398, -0.033375248312950134, -0.0428205206990242, -0.0320461243391037, -0.025057248771190643, 0.017460539937019348, 0.0049872319214046, 0.015213404782116413, 0.07678432762622833, 0.00074168317951262, 0.028900334611535072, 0.0009545051725581288, 0.009177116677165031, -0.01881363056600094, -0.06705529987812042, -0.02306962013244629, -0.01838000677525997, -0.053141701966524124, -0.00205801404081285, 0.012852516956627369, 0.00788818672299385, -0.011552517302334309, 0.0020010608714073896, 0.010408115573227406, 0.038695331662893295, 0.012166289612650871, -0.010176769457757473, 0.10793764144182205, 0.01671951450407505, 0.07967276871204376, -0.0024235406890511513, -0.0009873182279989123, 0.10825662314891815, 0.002158219926059246, 0.039191827178001404, -0.02835072949528694, -0.006721321027725935, -0.029948456212878227, 0.016075486317276955, -0.04026097059249878, 0.0279674232006073, 0.009296055883169174, -0.003948665689677, 0.04941599816083908, 0.04857150837779045, 0.02775435894727707, -0.0364224798977375, 0.05403726547956467, -0.0493469275534153, -0.051475830376148224, -0.004134665708988905, 0.008228669874370098, 0.002845889888703823, -0.015200314112007618, -0.0345846489071846, 0.0009874115930870175, -0.02297479473054409, 0.023738320916891098, -0.0399940051138401, -0.045272283256053925, 0.02170274406671524, 0.027938542887568474, 0.02611626125872135, -0.039268072694540024, 0.033122554421424866, -0.018374286592006683, -0.008787877857685089, -0.01867097243666649, 0.011260450817644596, -0.04161715507507324, 0.0038320680614560843, 0.040499091148376465, 0.011209631338715553, -0.0028791502118110657, -0.0030171251855790615, 0.00939902476966381, -0.04065524786710739, -0.028803525492548943, -0.03488897159695625, 0.015034237876534462, -0.0043240878731012344, 0.03728238865733147, 0.030562805011868477, -0.0054641482420265675, -0.0257759727537632, -0.0633014589548111, -0.0077672977931797504, 0.020765509456396103, 0.04283512011170387, -0.018239783123135567, -0.0343802347779274, -0.025437600910663605, 0.027052445337176323, -0.00527201360091567, 0.005997991655021906, -0.00974829401820898, -0.04330820590257645, -0.010743082500994205, -0.021625733003020287, 0.03334593400359154, 0.0005047303275205195, -0.030292104929685593, 0.004957379307597876, -0.008063594810664654, -0.01626618020236492, -0.009274750016629696, 0.0038997074589133263, 0.0008120943093672395, 0.01810266077518463, 0.03999999165534973, 0.010443029925227165, 0.018978029489517212, -0.03038054145872593, 0.05202041193842888, -0.06300543248653412, -0.013309159316122532, -0.04159039631485939, -0.004753150045871735, -0.0011050510220229626, 0.04774276912212372, 0.001494850148446858, -0.0193199310451746, 0.020531559363007545, 0.0448012612760067, 0.037754762917757034, -0.03959830850362778, -0.010457673110067844, -0.004609602969139814, -0.023146502673625946, -0.000560341461095959, -0.0006634543533436954, 0.049296267330646515, 0.03227346017956734, 0.005609745159745216, -0.025871839374303818, 0.0008057995582930744, -0.036921896040439606, 0.03172240033745766, -0.02354159951210022, -0.0028547034598886967, 0.021430687978863716, -0.007518785540014505, -0.001202469109557569, -0.034545913338661194, -0.06149042770266533, 0.015228629112243652, 0.033712878823280334, -0.013646477833390236, -0.015288610942661762, -0.043574362993240356, -0.017705906182527542, 0.00775082828477025, 0.04054572060704231, 0.009406285360455513, -0.010105270892381668, -0.031224461272358894, 0.005775969009846449, -0.011581966653466225, -0.03050093725323677, -0.011669863946735859, -0.02004132978618145, -0.002403473947197199, -0.04874761775135994, 0.06023425981402397, 0.049733199179172516, 0.005181742832064629, 0.007287259679287672, 0.05016561597585678, -0.01515864860266447, 0.046985313296318054, 0.001637232955545187, 0.0002819689398165792, 0.07957220077514648, -0.0694512128829956, -0.057941000908613205, 0.029091589152812958, 0.039926156401634216, 0.023133620619773865, -0.0033663278445601463, -0.016930323094129562, -0.01383035909384489, 0.026490626856684685, 0.004628710448741913, -0.0076790787279605865, -0.02155858650803566, -0.017660154029726982, 0.043218936771154404, -0.025853000581264496, -0.015257532708346844, -0.03160058334469795, 0.0039268797263503075, 0.00705174682661891, 0.006013672798871994, -0.02786373160779476, -0.006992151029407978, 0.03931895270943642, 0.005034873727709055, 0.023096557706594467, -0.017070207744836807, -0.003762998851016164, 0.0306410975754261, 0.03294994309544563, -0.017238441854715347, 0.001378657529130578, -0.04245033860206604, -0.020081471651792526, -0.044863417744636536, 0.004030732903629541, 0.04733189195394516, 0.02237730473279953, 0.020810630172491074, -0.06444816291332245, -0.00887810904532671, 0.03677602857351303, -0.028129572048783302, -0.005704157520085573, -0.012783865444362164, -0.012500283308327198, -0.00859683845192194, -0.017686761915683746, -0.02670701965689659, 0.04156828671693802, 0.0007864631479606032, 0.0580906942486763, 0.05402236059308052, 0.011856650933623314, 0.03299592807888985, -0.02519984170794487, 0.012824724428355694, -0.0449705608189106, 0.0005452831392176449, -0.024727657437324524, 0.04290979355573654, -0.017290767282247543, -0.015539387241005898, 0.04118345305323601, -0.019825400784611702, -0.028349576517939568, 0.024175692349672318, 0.013913891278207302, 0.017475605010986328, 0.024835754185914993, 0.009560484439134598, 0.010032773949205875, -0.020736288279294968, 0.011010575108230114, 0.04606661573052406, 0.015161531046032906, -0.031664229929447174, -0.0007571456953883171, 0.02328665740787983, -0.015704918652772903, -0.01401049830019474, 0.023839838802814484, 0.003285434562712908, -0.023159118369221687, -0.022984934970736504, 0.005374107509851456, 0.008224531076848507, 0.000995691865682602, 0.02168099768459797, -0.06077795848250389, -0.022509923204779625, 0.020719217136502266, 0.012204554863274097, -0.014899231493473053, 0.014191120862960815, 0.007264658343046904, -0.0426301546394825, 0.03429434075951576, 0.014842361211776733, -0.027451450005173683, 0.013137904927134514, 0.016647538170218468, 0.01488615944981575, 0.04175114259123802, -0.014924915507435799, -0.055363886058330536, -0.057011328637599945, 0.0028582303784787655, -0.04378129541873932, 0.03198208659887314, -0.02117103524506092, 0.013815883547067642, -0.00446019321680069, -0.06914188712835312, 0.05242330580949783, 0.032038308680057526, -0.03443583473563194, -0.01887299120426178, 0.026235131546854973, -0.03873792663216591, -0.019801653921604156, 0.012463930062949657, -0.004759684205055237, -0.0015180978225544095, 0.00930663663893938, 0.015678169205784798, 0.015810195356607437, -0.06574245542287827, 0.026364076882600784, -0.015911385416984558, -0.041019972413778305, 0.010928314179182053, 0.03044222854077816, 0.01255850587040186, 0.015974299982190132, 0.011877350509166718, -0.03258594125509262, 0.01590886153280735, -0.0026719882152974606, -0.052900440990924835, 0.04890668764710426, 0.01328732818365097, -0.009325111284852028, 0.05167212337255478, -0.025231681764125824, -0.004632686730474234, 0.0013351129600778222, -0.02554076910018921, -0.04287560656666756, 0.012378484942018986, -0.03137258440256119, -0.03347966820001602, -0.0016198346856981516, 0.030018353834748268, -0.014073817059397697, -0.03171927481889725, -0.07178004086017609, 0.012742266058921814, -0.04054604470729828, -0.03420402482151985, 0.014950071461498737, 0.02502606436610222, 0.04341013729572296, 0.01985740289092064, -0.008343975059688091, -0.02004069648683071, -0.00006593379657715559, 0.02981703355908394, 0.014806208200752735, 0.023438598960638046, -0.024871034547686577, 0.05703099071979523, 0.0014336922904476523, -0.015772836282849312, 0.020694589242339134, 0.025074103847146034, 0.06448020786046982, -0.03791346028447151, 0.003960073459893465, 0.0021385548170655966, -0.0040499321185052395, 0.008045563474297523, 0.011846570298075676, -0.028968119993805885, 0.04702870175242424, -0.019233986735343933, 0.00577850267291069, -0.01581752859055996, -0.007524056825786829, -0.02457706816494465, -0.0008747876272536814, 0.06628861278295517, 0.03877411410212517, 0.004399506840854883, -0.01167898066341877, 0.00675128074362874, -0.01103096641600132, 0.021823368966579437, -0.011571947485208511, 0.03230581060051918, -0.02597617730498314, -0.03719962760806084, -0.007825600914657116, -0.0179667416960001, -0.001255971728824079, -0.02557823807001114, -0.004830439109355211, 0.048798784613609314, 0.05261915549635887, -0.03073015995323658, -0.02049894444644451, 0.011507703922688961, 0.06303611397743225, -0.06005305424332619, -0.011968161910772324, -0.038784172385931015, 0.0024052653461694717, 0.03248322382569313, 0.019680717960000038 ]
<p>In statistics people gather a lot of data (ie heights of people or gene expression levels) to get some insight. Then in order to perform statistical analyses they try to fit their data to a theoretical distribution (ie Normal Distribution) by computing some parameters.</p> <p>How do we know that our data follows such a distribution? If we were able to measure all objects in a population and draw a distribution we could probably get something different, a different shape than the theoretical distribution we thought of. Aren’t our calculations wrong then if we use a theoretical distribution?</p> <p>Please correct me if I am wrong and tell me what you think of this. I think this is a very basic concept in statistics and I have to clarify it.</p>
74,326
[ -0.06268709152936935, -0.021020706743001938, 0.00025233879568986595, -0.02769281342625618, 0.0390399731695652, 0.016736460849642754, 0.015744779258966446, 0.015104769729077816, 0.011486104689538479, -0.0007926340913400054, 0.024740813300013542, 0.005373000632971525, 0.03626898303627968, 0.0032829002011567354, 0.040743861347436905, 0.015202442184090614, -0.043105412274599075, 0.016428884118795395, -0.033100470900535583, 0.008934724144637585, -0.006577494088560343, 0.04100805148482323, 0.011959370225667953, -0.03229474276304245, -0.03266731649637222, 0.022618016228079796, 0.02001102827489376, -0.0047484589740633965, 0.039058320224285126, 0.05736001208424568, -0.018515298143029213, -0.04831032082438469, 0.023165982216596603, 0.0686776414513588, 0.025955846533179283, -0.007682326715439558, -0.020900042727589607, -0.006564529612660408, 0.01613788679242134, 0.020139187574386597, -0.03170259669423103, -0.021064041182398796, 0.021605199202895164, 0.021040301769971848, -0.03176382556557655, 0.015070430003106594, -0.02039075642824173, -0.06928669661283493, 0.022638464346528053, -0.041790977120399475, 0.09365981072187424, 0.0023177550174295902, 0.027882704511284828, 0.05049467459321022, -0.011876760981976986, -0.025108860805630684, 0.06937994062900543, 0.0633934959769249, -0.01778991147875786, -0.08449706435203552, 0.004997147247195244, -0.026012208312749863, -0.0033449383918195963, -0.009382802993059158, -0.022003937512636185, 0.01093760970979929, -0.03806769847869873, -0.014319218695163727, 0.038607366383075714, -0.011903773061931133, 0.016857460141181946, 0.06713394820690155, 0.039912477135658264, -0.005905484780669212, 0.030956590548157692, -0.0016156717902049422, 0.016913728788495064, -0.02270505391061306, 0.06406982243061066, 0.0279642716050148, 0.02200152911245823, 0.025260964408516884, 0.017171867191791534, 0.03707793727517128, 0.0389128178358078, -0.048342179507017136, 0.06576457619667053, -0.03948944807052612, 0.024920452386140823, 0.025236880406737328, -0.021058812737464905, 0.012315448373556137, 0.05061114951968193, -0.027690928429365158, -0.030559919774532318, 0.04735257476568222, -0.019382061436772346, 0.028843199834227562, -0.0013271472416818142, -0.01472711842507124, 0.02023635432124138, -0.04588082432746887, -0.0022178441286087036, 0.02183670550584793, -0.01981397345662117, -0.017288606613874435, -0.042624298483133316, 0.011373873800039291, -0.011808104813098907, 0.005471745505928993, 0.007455014158040285, 0.028018241748213768, 0.008931034244596958, 0.011573655530810356, 0.046511758118867874, 0.002754185814410448, 0.01885220967233181, -0.041254159063100815, 0.07059155404567719, 0.029603490605950356, -0.008498386479914188, -0.00713186664506793, 0.03500055894255638, -0.0038112991023808718, -0.028272615745663643, 0.025063997134566307, 0.042910344898700714, 0.0018883399898186326, -0.06595616042613983, 0.029499584808945656, -0.030485743656754494, -0.006545670330524445, 0.03192611411213875, 0.016698019579052925, 0.030303703621029854, 0.005454310216009617, -0.11098112165927887, -0.018763579428195953, 0.01847933419048786, -0.013256929814815521, -0.017169807106256485, -0.06418818235397339, -0.02233021706342697, 0.020462868735194206, 0.020717725157737732, -0.03698007017374039, 0.03995257243514061, -0.03688540309667587, 0.032400209456682205, -0.015859201550483704, -0.012767576612532139, -0.010848244652152061, -0.0005465401336550713, -0.04232252016663551, -0.027973627671599388, -0.08276297897100449, 0.01992063969373703, 0.006027146242558956, -0.0048093185760080814, -0.03696979954838753, 0.01656842976808548, -0.02682243473827839, -0.01582322083413601, 0.004311061464250088, 0.0069789402186870575, -0.03258778154850006, 0.06474717706441879, 0.010507212951779366, 0.025008587166666985, 0.030620373785495758, -0.010569502599537373, 0.05423571914434433, 0.006370286922901869, 0.03981785476207733, 0.028790898621082306, -0.016232579946517944, -0.0035404113586992025, -0.012714345939457417, 0.04023170843720436, -0.007042902521789074, -0.036297671496868134, 0.002596112433820963, 0.00926191732287407, 0.014208662323653698, 0.040087662637233734, 0.040321752429008484, 0.008987817913293839, -0.01014803908765316, 0.04435696825385094, -0.0712321400642395, -0.04300324246287346, -0.08986745029687881, 0.014474681578576565, -0.02841903455555439, -0.022874128073453903, 0.008838810957968235, 0.03374306485056877, 0.013497146777808666, -0.02789771556854248, 0.017895355820655823, -0.020884666591882706, -0.008019094355404377, 0.03400254249572754, -0.03141934052109718, 0.00858510285615921, 0.08277291059494019, 0.03594014048576355, 0.007069675251841545, 0.04579947143793106, -0.018373385071754456, -0.06806650012731552, 0.0226416178047657, -0.056908778846263885, 0.010916653089225292, 0.012037833221256733, -0.009659027680754662, 0.009609281085431576, 0.0042267730459570885, -0.028554437682032585, 0.028682179749011993, -0.03552767634391785, 0.05126968026161194, 0.050941143184900284, -0.0363255999982357, -0.009800170548260212, 0.00878702849149704, -0.005003666039556265, -0.006196761503815651, -0.0010663928696885705, -0.0225828904658556, -0.07098313421010971, -0.0035968911834061146, 0.016609253361821175, 0.010651578195393085, -0.03283378481864929, -0.016961796209216118, 0.038886167109012604, 0.025332128629088402, 0.024108434095978737, 0.03219646215438843, -0.007852019742131233, -0.005856746807694435, 0.02018265426158905, 0.03011261112987995, 0.025768831372261047, 0.0033896376844495535, 0.009741158224642277, 0.03312011808156967, 0.027221092954277992, -0.01046576164662838, -0.004382910206913948, 0.06031358242034912, -0.0060404143296182156, 0.007504203822463751, -0.002566196257248521, 0.01846182346343994, 0.023260440677404404, -0.02266875095665455, 0.0033621566835790873, 0.010769760236144066, -0.01583149842917919, -0.03363395482301712, -0.033325858414173126, -0.007490391843020916, 0.029563188552856445, 0.07007575780153275, -0.02681855857372284, -0.018180090934038162, 0.01828516088426113, -0.015415716916322708, 0.0036593894474208355, -0.03703756257891655, -0.05285205319523811, 0.008548413403332233, 0.030911294743418694, 0.043795548379421234, 0.037257932126522064, 0.04492349177598953, -0.0033945718314498663, -0.03368711471557617, 0.008104377426207066, -0.00660660769790411, 0.02551594190299511, 0.00006139092874946073, -0.0686296746134758, 0.00036559870932251215, -0.04009513184428215, -0.03505730256438255, 0.007813685573637486, -0.0342249758541584, 0.01742706447839737, 0.005218508653342724, -0.030397646129131317, -0.014080456458032131, -0.013718175701797009, -0.014065533876419067, 0.026003360748291016, -0.01004230696707964, -0.0051648844964802265, 0.025484880432486534, -0.025118689984083176, -0.019511640071868896, 0.02448437176644802, -0.02288929559290409, -0.04356537014245987, -0.02288226969540119, -0.016752243041992188, 0.02341131493449211, -0.00884159654378891, 0.06057906523346901, 0.011154752224683762, -0.04938817024230957, -0.01774614118039608, -0.051580507308244705, -0.04424118250608444, 0.02584993652999401, -0.024913977831602097, 0.07051775604486465, 0.011466066353023052, -0.016465360298752785, 0.09635495394468307, 0.011815495789051056, -0.039662834256887436, -0.008398953825235367, 0.010122336447238922, -0.04146364703774452, -0.03324194997549057, 0.04684756323695183, 0.026603279635310173, 0.008784126490354538, 0.02101234905421734, 0.022661786526441574, 0.027736954391002655, 0.04052067548036575, 0.0032555977813899517, -0.024925166741013527, 0.004534649197012186, 0.006355893332511187, -0.004394632764160633, 0.01988641358911991, 0.003870939603075385, -0.031692024320364, 0.04297192022204399, -0.014784225262701511, 0.0223183985799551, 0.004228435456752777, -0.05664648488163948, 0.04415562376379967, -0.02118241973221302, 0.03347412496805191, -0.05616762116551399, 0.022951196879148483, 0.008141572587192059, -0.05501929670572281, 0.0196255873888731, 0.03440754488110542, 0.008360574953258038, 0.002859968226402998, -0.016338028013706207, 0.04902470111846924, 0.05760519579052925, -0.01780140958726406, -0.044164277613162994, -0.00820957776159048, -0.035226501524448395, 0.005130889359861612, -0.01893698237836361, -0.05158361420035362, 0.04248161241412163, 0.06043136492371559, 0.005388318095356226, -0.035254575312137604, -0.04536285996437073, 0.005869064014405012, -0.05146634206175804, 0.00006685534754069522, -0.005799117032438517, 0.04171016812324524, -0.021156951785087585, 0.05798977240920067, 0.03737771883606911, 0.013404273428022861, 0.0029980982653796673, 0.027732836082577705, -0.08266132324934006, 0.026654090732336044, -0.013337752781808376, -0.008377015590667725, -0.019187748432159424, -0.04947127774357796, 0.03367312252521515, -0.018353011459112167, 0.026035569608211517, 0.006735318806022406, 0.024257516488432884, -0.021204380318522453, -0.027962392196059227, -0.004402033053338528, -0.034263115376234055, -0.01333553995937109, 0.0189499631524086, -0.010308795608580112, -0.0006395868258550763, 0.028301771730184555, 0.04903498291969299, 0.004384794272482395, -0.035222377628088, -0.02411387674510479, 0.013562961481511593, 0.05288655683398247, 0.03950967267155647, 0.052556317299604416, 0.017802271991968155, -0.051125384867191315, 0.028075218200683594, -0.003945809789001942, 0.09227954596281052, 0.03764866665005684, -0.02679089829325676, -0.007262472063302994, -0.04972127452492714, -0.017814571037888527, -0.004083874635398388, -0.0021890392526984215, 0.0023407801054418087, -0.020446736365556717, 0.030667461454868317, 0.021357115358114243, -0.03998809680342674, 0.01160900853574276, 0.06479671597480774, 0.007655445486307144, -0.010907447896897793, -0.048698488622903824, -0.00039368501165881753, -0.05102160573005676, -0.00385817838832736, 0.022650020197033882, -0.0039870464242994785, -0.012903217226266861, 0.03620881959795952, 0.018680844455957413, -0.00896664522588253, -0.018270429223775864, -0.006091563031077385, -0.002555473940446973, 0.05749685317277908, 0.0023659172002226114, 0.012261519208550453, 0.05692378059029579, 0.029777059331536293, 0.01758328452706337, 0.010181194171309471, -0.013347259722650051, -0.08561629801988602, 0.015995126217603683, 0.03713894262909889, 0.01988535374403, -0.021407196298241615, 0.012110648676753044, -0.03320339694619179, -0.003778659040108323, 0.056505780667066574, -0.026987992227077484, 0.0012970028910785913, 0.00028871712856926024, -0.003298568306490779, -0.015883028507232666, -0.00968058593571186, -0.05997622758150101, 0.013203459791839123, -0.005164647474884987, 0.003115109633654356, -0.028417328372597694, 0.013691636733710766, -0.07230973243713379, -0.0029979327227920294, -0.009692016988992691, 0.06207408383488655, -0.0041070906445384026, -0.004334523808211088, -0.007541090250015259, 0.010494403541088104, -0.010758353397250175, -0.07510854303836823, 0.02208195999264717, 0.01146028097718954, 0.003153660800307989, 0.04444834589958191, -0.007672138046473265, -0.04424590244889259, 0.020656133070588112, -0.014549126848578453, -0.01886230893433094, 0.017729628831148148, -0.022678710520267487, 0.03627724200487137, 0.025553546845912933, 0.01180905383080244, 0.03369947895407677, 0.0040350910276174545, -0.0003219496866222471, -0.02045474573969841, -0.04429292678833008, 0.02664465829730034, 0.014289436861872673, -0.003390732454136014, -0.06067284196615219, -0.0146377207711339, -0.0024823083076626062, 0.0005618457798846066, 0.04347311332821846, 0.0017168285558000207, -0.0023159850388765335, -0.02968895435333252, -0.010399403981864452, 0.03176019340753555, 0.025791743770241737, -0.009869204834103584, 0.0032705864869058132, 0.03210217505693436, 0.010858436115086079, -0.014061404392123222, 0.0008448385633528233, 0.022093985229730606, -0.006295386701822281, 0.009972876869142056, -0.0011936241062358022, 0.006159449927508831, -0.03660674765706062, -0.05142689496278763, 0.04220418259501457, -0.049346327781677246, 0.026302779093384743, -0.015173893421888351, 0.020644836127758026, 0.009958853013813496, -0.05005916208028793, -0.026628993451595306, 0.0020436467602849007, 0.014749106951057911, 0.052277255803346634, -0.021942144259810448, 0.022297153249382973, -0.02118239551782608, 0.024265658110380173, -0.059867143630981445, -0.002259611850604415, 0.022486688569188118, 0.04057847708463669, -0.024450598284602165, -0.03199036419391632, 0.03493066132068634, -0.01529737189412117, -0.046776965260505676, 0.003799318103119731, 0.031038975343108177, -0.0077250138856470585, -0.036970753222703934, -0.0100319292396307, 0.004236320964992046, 0.10724485665559769, -0.03429194912314415, -0.01952914521098137, 0.02883705496788025, 0.004201942589133978, -0.007795955985784531, -0.005837962031364441, 0.048091258853673935, -0.03401448577642441, -0.0021364407148212194, -0.02456381730735302, -0.0038176318630576134, 0.031876109540462494, -0.03319481760263443, -0.010309792123734951, 0.0012136903824284673, 0.014663265086710453, 0.002669531386345625, -0.0016246689483523369, 0.006768248975276947, -0.019131561741232872, 0.020581739023327827, -0.01925700344145298, -0.0004367598157841712, -0.0013456529704853892, -0.0017804724629968405, 0.06975351274013519, -0.012766671366989613, -0.0022168669383972883, 0.015959013253450394, 0.061440203338861465, -0.0414436049759388, 0.009060364216566086, -0.014435051009058952, -0.03722897171974182, 0.021347451955080032, 0.031106309965252876, -0.015395556576550007, -0.0168401300907135, 0.040793366730213165, -0.020678846165537834, 0.016698023304343224, -0.03943563997745514, -0.04227413982152939, 0.0516454353928566, 0.008296458050608635, 0.057388946413993835, 0.03854920342564583, -0.001709064468741417, -0.03066231682896614, -0.007388331461697817, -0.010570505633950233, -0.01993955299258232, 0.009122536517679691, 0.03976922109723091, -0.015543533489108086, 0.0074710785411298275, 0.0353594534099102, 0.01269878726452589, -0.020191935822367668, 0.03171785920858383, 0.014778364449739456, 0.006217218469828367, 0.03011753223836422, -0.00534014543518424, -0.012836126610636711, 0.054187096655368805, -0.04254917427897453, 0.01825285144150257, -0.015595445409417152, 0.002175057539716363, 0.04608878120779991, 0.014564351178705692, -0.006397999357432127, -0.03884923830628395, -0.013354621827602386, -0.027051977813243866, 0.012453424744307995, 0.014725263230502605, 0.01714814268052578, 0.016513466835021973, -0.032419197261333466, 0.009147482924163342, -0.01665721833705902, 0.03630107268691063, -0.012038204818964005, -0.05225926265120506, -0.03591030463576317, -0.03298502415418625, -0.033252544701099396, 0.012841461226344109, 0.008303338661789894, -0.015177309513092041, -0.014014762826263905, -0.04011818766593933, 0.026462038978934288, 0.029689162969589233, 0.031617432832717896, -0.0463547557592392, 0.07717476040124893, 0.011880294419825077, 0.03690393641591072, 0.009461356326937675, -0.006816887762397528, 0.10088050365447998, 0.06030743941664696, 0.035023096948862076, -0.07967669516801834, -0.002941905288025737, -0.03692624717950821, 0.010331655852496624, 0.002148988889530301, 0.028458353132009506, 0.01811871863901615, 0.04282606020569801, 0.020283248275518417, 0.03156210854649544, 0.019151225686073303, 0.028900576755404472, 0.08639989048242569, -0.04392452910542488, -0.07170774787664413, 0.02067510224878788, -0.0006506764329969883, -0.007816207595169544, -0.019681494683027267, -0.026428410783410072, 0.03081737458705902, -0.010024149902164936, 0.015113716945052147, -0.022121615707874298, -0.019910134375095367, -0.010151412338018417, -0.005630475468933582, -0.04507168009877205, 0.0028108067344874144, 0.04350169003009796, -0.02188563160598278, -0.033951569348573685, -0.021500777453184128, -0.002650982467457652, -0.029193619266152382, -0.00018285539408680052, 0.04463076591491699, -0.02152189426124096, 0.006477518938481808, 0.020151250064373016, 0.025498803704977036, -0.02070540003478527, -0.03317178040742874, -0.04612569510936737, 0.03636255860328674, -0.01676901988685131, -0.023515954613685608, 0.008022717200219631, -0.009652662090957165, -0.025343239307403564, -0.04811063036322594, -0.020182272419333458, 0.0078199477866292, 0.026693828403949738, 0.009321343153715134, -0.004162405151873827, -0.024312831461429596, -0.0051164161413908005, -0.004219688009470701, 0.023542383685708046, 0.0374765619635582, -0.0028420351445674896, -0.002578428015112877, 0.0011585111496970057, 0.06446871161460876, 0.005710040684789419, -0.0013458819594234228, -0.005480720661580563, -0.038950253278017044, -0.04185759276151657, -0.007489179261028767, 0.00859767384827137, -0.01171865127980709, 0.02348254807293415, 0.016995500773191452, 0.02819886803627014, -0.000665967061650008, -0.02794485352933407, 0.028920019045472145, -0.03200094774365425, -0.0048817540518939495, -0.05633013695478439, 0.012823319993913174, 0.03134099394083023, 0.08161179721355438, 0.022803591564297676, -0.021814601495862007, 0.005541852209717035, 0.023053187876939774, 0.0035909712314605713, -0.05062965676188469, -0.036157380789518356, 0.016069024801254272, -0.0266842283308506, 0.022253286093473434, 0.008959305472671986, 0.046889547258615494, 0.021035661920905113, 0.040711306035518646, -0.013403594493865967, 0.035667259246110916, -0.00788935273885727, 0.03880302608013153, -0.03486552834510803, -0.043667249381542206, 0.024131610989570618, 0.007403906434774399, -0.00365861295722425, -0.05910637974739075, -0.041219424456357956, -0.006235940381884575, -0.021370945498347282, 0.011405166238546371, -0.012435411103069782, -0.012197492644190788, 0.0070838662795722485, 0.01790604367852211, 0.006184488534927368, -0.014057368040084839, 0.008999726735055447, -0.024083515629172325, -0.03328115493059158, 0.002954169176518917, -0.03743307664990425, -0.0018747898284345865, 0.0005247760564088821, -0.007541567087173462, -0.020292853936553, 0.03249966725707054, 0.010637187398970127, 0.016267068684101105, -0.009936426766216755, 0.01646614447236061, -0.0037730003241449594, 0.028268955647945404, -0.028474628925323486, -0.022625604644417763, 0.04850007966160774, -0.017143793404102325, -0.04205142334103584, -0.0034624473191797733, -0.009057225659489632, 0.024817608296871185, 0.00200579478405416, 0.01991392858326435, 0.015304844826459885, 0.03775973990559578, -0.03085966967046261, 0.009584223851561546, -0.02405981533229351, -0.005121082533150911, -0.01695839688181877, 0.028027527034282684, 0.037000931799411774, -0.016314975917339325, -0.010620581917464733, 0.06104160472750664, 0.012166934087872505, 0.0006554311839863658, -0.01033797487616539, 0.04215611517429352, -0.008082841522991657, 0.02446702867746353, 0.00924721360206604, 0.010118142701685429, 0.02375458925962448, 0.06963583081960678, -0.023330973461270332, 0.025604724884033203, -0.03613091632723808, -0.039757657796144485, -0.10181654244661331, -0.02820858173072338, 0.03807481750845909, -0.033379606902599335, 0.030249230563640594, -0.03459801524877548, -0.029976943507790565, 0.02133745513856411, -0.03910098969936371, 0.04261067882180214, -0.02536914125084877, -0.0232548750936985, -0.016693394631147385, 0.01186321023851633, -0.032333772629499435, 0.05756291747093201, 0.044308051466941833, 0.03460787236690521, 0.013891390524804592, -0.01324770413339138, 0.02332109399139881, -0.00883920956403017, -0.013992332853376865, 0.04103488847613335, 0.005983628798276186, -0.046857018023729324, 0.03688253089785576, -0.007809428032487631, -0.0260297991335392, 0.03274372220039368, -0.006258441600948572, 0.03048769384622574, 0.021317247301340103, 0.006513588130474091, -0.006569105666130781, 0.03653033450245857, 0.03023490123450756, -0.004014724399894476, -0.0476858913898468, 0.026240546256303787, 0.03158716484904289, 0.042922623455524445, -0.02709995023906231, -0.009385373443365097, 0.019298378378152847, -0.0613839291036129, -0.012720360420644283, 0.019018907099962234, -0.018147295340895653, -0.02797345630824566, 0.007177216000854969, 0.015082514844834805, -0.013673537410795689, -0.0335194356739521, 0.047310035675764084, -0.051667023450136185, 0.008316412568092346, 0.029509907588362694, 0.07708822190761566, -0.01061983872205019, 0.008252052590250969, -0.02457047440111637, -0.03701281175017357, 0.011695780791342258, -0.004047225695103407, -0.02941238135099411, -0.04967861250042915, 0.010005631484091282, -0.02159867249429226, -0.011417080648243427, 0.006226941477507353, -0.05839923396706581, -0.037393562495708466, 0.03152690827846527, 0.017082976177334785, 0.00853681843727827, 0.022907573729753494, -0.03747788816690445, -0.046162404119968414, -0.07006517052650452, 0.0868874117732048, -0.012465705163776875, -0.02779500186443329, -0.06074604392051697, 0.031458187848329544, -0.03608841076493263, 0.008463679812848568, 0.027865881100296974, 0.040828023105859756, 0.02203204110264778, -0.012533948756754398, 0.014378223568201065, 0.006671368610113859, -0.08570273965597153, 0.004291190765798092, -0.030303003266453743, -0.03893054276704788, -0.026920275762677193, -0.0005764414090663195, 0.010273318737745285, 0.023457907140254974, -0.016517868265509605, -0.02140689827501774, 0.04127643629908562, 0.0024879034608602524, -0.01492616068571806, 0.029769884422421455, 0.018808405846357346, -0.0020333961583673954, 0.036059703677892685, -0.01986827701330185, 0.005402546841651201, -0.000034639717341633514, -0.001402780064381659, -0.03446759656071663, 0.01847134344279766, -0.052211396396160126, -0.030941244214773178, -0.011334240436553955, 0.0052126734517514706, -0.006755284499377012, -0.028852103278040886, -0.01497767772525549, 0.0374121256172657, -0.03560105711221695, 0.0018092874670401216, 0.009514573030173779, 0.037485022097826004, -0.005691130645573139, -0.025337262079119682, -0.004791724029928446, 0.008079277351498604, -0.010977287776768208, 0.002444034907966852, 0.013840158469974995, 0.03170444443821907, -0.005182391498237848, 0.011091268621385098, 0.047746844589710236, -0.019489191472530365, 0.02045564353466034, -0.012254932895302773, 0.060658954083919525, -0.04389283061027527, -0.03552759811282158, -0.025264466181397438, -0.010196170769631863, 0.029016561806201935, 0.0038060233928263187, -0.00551639823243022, 0.0816749706864357, -0.01090704184025526, -0.00507896114140749, -0.015155659057199955, -0.02039618231356144, -0.023166650906205177, -0.03317661210894585, 0.023662731051445007, -0.009723633527755737, 0.014591066166758537, -0.012429687194526196, -0.00755433039739728, 0.02295025996863842, 0.053035102784633636, 0.03152381628751755, 0.01471865363419056, -0.006615445017814636, -0.02735021896660328, -0.028009943664073944, 0.00047527215792797506, -0.04047273471951485, -0.009576999582350254, 0.03100336156785488, 0.018338853493332863, 0.03634871914982796, 0.03796013444662094, -0.034105438739061356, -0.012158806435763836, 0.05815649405121803, -0.08391448855400085, -0.025612227618694305, -0.06346336752176285, 0.014899784699082375, -0.008528056554496288, -0.05149121582508087 ]
<p>I have a 5 x 2 design where one of the levels of the first factor is a control, all others are experimental conditions. I'm interested in the interaction between the two factors and especially, if the interaction is present for each of the 4 experimental conditions with the control condition.</p> <p>I conduct 4 separate 2 x 2 ANOVAs where I pair each experimental condition with the control condition in the first factor. This seems to call for p-value adjustment to avoid the multiple-testing problem but what do I have to adjust? Are all p-values adjusted (the two main effects and the interaction)? Or do I only adjust the interaction p-values? Or separately for the main effects?</p> <p>Thanks a lot</p>
74,327
[ -0.04400775581598282, 0.001197470468468964, -0.02561347186565399, 0.04423082247376442, 0.03860525041818619, 0.04454909265041351, 0.018497971817851067, -0.03230250999331474, 0.023535773158073425, -0.03190078213810921, 0.04385813698172569, 0.02694733440876007, 0.03487207740545273, 0.006010523531585932, 0.005839414428919554, -0.005951861385256052, -0.008683386258780956, -0.033142995089292526, 0.019017018377780914, -0.008129238151013851, -0.03307780250906944, 0.018601661548018456, -0.007909096777439117, 0.008550891652703285, -0.034174297004938126, 0.059850309044122696, 0.03731803223490715, -0.03309748321771622, 0.034772176295518875, 0.019178487360477448, -0.02365868166089058, -0.041616033762693405, 0.02156771533191204, 0.0406014584004879, 0.021241556853055954, -0.009300578385591507, -0.023424403741955757, -0.008594468235969543, -0.012127389200031757, 0.037376951426267624, -0.035815734416246414, -0.011072370223701, -0.008328748866915703, -0.004892081022262573, -0.000569269759580493, -0.00043011573143303394, 0.013608905486762524, 0.004243758507072926, 0.05496549233794212, -0.08091884851455688, 0.05510319769382477, 0.014568482525646687, 0.04458770528435707, 0.04136322811245918, -0.02752544730901718, -0.011554333381354809, 0.06742999702692032, 0.0445365272462368, 0.007049159612506628, -0.05490471422672272, -0.008880714885890484, -0.028057130053639412, 0.02642235904932022, -0.014823739416897297, -0.0848967432975769, 0.007385066244751215, -0.005767706781625748, -0.025582270696759224, 0.0031549090053886175, -0.00036857245140708983, 0.013197379186749458, -0.010349025949835777, 0.05973225459456444, 0.01006285473704338, 0.0036223172210156918, -0.026667587459087372, 0.042990852147340775, 0.022711623460054398, 0.04024876654148102, 0.04618190973997116, -0.020103823393583298, 0.011477542109787464, 0.006186716724187136, 0.04420529678463936, 0.004554243758320808, -0.012086822651326656, 0.05240334942936897, -0.018246065825223923, 0.002690486842766404, 0.007974409498274326, -0.07495751231908798, -0.014478525146842003, 0.06556695699691772, -0.02221360057592392, -0.049862951040267944, -0.0033231915440410376, -0.03012472204864025, 0.03496946766972542, 0.0008404247346334159, 0.0041061462834477425, -0.011518574319779873, -0.004791599232703447, -0.0016503045335412025, 0.06656944751739502, -0.0343850813806057, -0.013026487082242966, -0.03015909530222416, 0.01985803432762623, 0.020825326442718506, -0.005038855131715536, 0.006653563119471073, 0.03202830255031586, -0.03660941869020462, -0.023489205166697502, 0.046238973736763, -0.038630373775959015, -0.03332214429974556, -0.003306547412648797, 0.0552547462284565, 0.035431258380413055, 0.05909201130270958, -0.04518803954124451, 0.03136127442121506, 0.003179920604452491, -0.04014354944229126, -0.006936376914381981, 0.013554101809859276, -0.02352789044380188, -0.009823777712881565, 0.06580285727977753, 0.02449808083474636, -0.010135951451957226, -0.0037669662851840258, 0.01098014134913683, 0.014135255478322506, -0.007552233058959246, -0.08243879675865173, -0.05262700840830803, 0.03284081816673279, -0.04647897928953171, -0.02466937154531479, -0.07755814492702484, -0.00627899169921875, 0.035671036690473557, 0.08766042441129684, -0.003500616643577814, -0.0012768590822815895, 0.002620598068460822, 0.00459681823849678, 0.04285137355327606, -0.03136580064892769, -0.023031184449791908, -0.03777477517724037, -0.04155992344021797, -0.01087071094661951, -0.08801756054162979, 0.007704886142164469, 0.019536217674613, -0.0004356283461675048, 0.03145116940140724, 0.04472598433494568, 0.015207638032734394, -0.023060617968440056, 0.010573591105639935, 0.046487271785736084, 0.01648201234638691, 0.027497628703713417, -0.03927725926041603, 0.06009351462125778, 0.04638393223285675, -0.0052484432235360146, 0.024664178490638733, -0.017491836100816727, 0.060013480484485626, 0.03994627669453621, -0.0013995686313137412, -0.028476249426603317, -0.009522262029349804, 0.0031928897369652987, 0.013311856426298618, -0.03860463574528694, 0.00933630671352148, -0.045877620577812195, 0.008592323400080204, 0.030930746346712112, 0.04646804928779602, 0.00586975272744894, -0.025263527408242226, 0.02661820873618126, -0.029881808906793594, -0.034846123307943344, -0.09396025538444519, -0.01584397256374359, -0.007174449972808361, -0.05178358778357506, 0.01866556704044342, 0.00019217257795389742, 0.030480988323688507, 0.000740846327971667, -0.024669388309121132, -0.0392102487385273, 0.006213212385773659, 0.051154520362615585, -0.04618697986006737, 0.028930077329277992, 0.0379410944879055, 0.07563961297273636, -0.03478042408823967, 0.05602266266942024, -0.061385627835989, -0.05635536462068558, 0.018580414354801178, -0.028683239594101906, 0.00865369476377964, 0.004187594633549452, -0.02536162920296192, -0.015490628778934479, 0.0028876548167318106, -0.0095437653362751, 0.045604392886161804, -0.0774526596069336, 0.08932361006736755, 0.08095225691795349, -0.020605355501174927, 0.018443075940012932, 0.030552443116903305, 0.010320072993636131, 0.025037631392478943, -0.037968773394823074, 0.008276622742414474, -0.03786536678671837, -0.03328850865364075, 0.030517904087901115, -0.004091320093721151, -0.030652543529868126, 0.03517456725239754, 0.03359556570649147, 0.026635784655809402, -0.0007531713345088065, 0.050403840839862823, 0.03125831484794617, -0.016622688621282578, 0.006404074840247631, 0.0649227499961853, 0.035505469888448715, 0.027073092758655548, 0.029373612254858017, 0.022899508476257324, 0.04845535755157471, -0.012490729801356792, 0.024664022028446198, 0.037725478410720825, 0.0012919044820591807, 0.01145231630653143, -0.018762821331620216, -0.013458628207445145, 0.013000079430639744, 0.00215046014636755, 0.030289746820926666, 0.05296214297413826, 0.014386498369276524, -0.037230685353279114, 0.03777199238538742, -0.026489917188882828, 0.023384856060147285, -0.00970669835805893, -0.043484725058078766, -0.019581863656640053, 0.0027832521591335535, -0.008878108114004135, -0.00674932636320591, -0.003659047419205308, -0.01464782003313303, -0.029122792184352875, -0.0022480436600744724, 0.007628796622157097, -0.015786204487085342, 0.06169180944561958, -0.037823859602212906, -0.026861105114221573, -0.040187299251556396, -0.01375840324908495, 0.015728242695331573, -0.0012787998421117663, -0.058938462287187576, -0.014374148100614548, -0.016737788915634155, 0.005622470285743475, 0.043573830276727676, -0.023560525849461555, -0.001652069971896708, 0.028894798830151558, 0.003634336171671748, -0.03196524456143379, -0.03335472568869591, -0.007734122220426798, -0.006694883573800325, -0.030749637633562088, -0.022524263709783554, 0.04072438180446625, 0.04098743572831154, -0.021543262526392937, 0.014834539964795113, -0.04518994688987732, -0.021219652146100998, -0.017210645601153374, -0.0031163550447672606, 0.02337774634361267, -0.012008165009319782, 0.0028095091693103313, 0.03827963024377823, -0.03214259073138237, 0.006699001416563988, -0.06500914692878723, -0.05977422744035721, 0.011149829253554344, -0.003104916773736477, 0.018804434686899185, -0.0266045443713665, -0.01286776177585125, 0.08349258452653885, 0.014247292652726173, -0.020722562447190285, -0.039974749088287354, -0.02806783653795719, -0.031028645113110542, -0.022753851488232613, 0.018771711736917496, 0.016881229355931282, -0.008442585356533527, 0.04533110931515694, 0.026729173958301544, -0.0007770935771986842, 0.02216474339365959, 0.04732859879732132, -0.003963042050600052, 0.018992995843291283, 0.04814270883798599, -0.025798454880714417, 0.03898980841040611, 0.026744266971945763, 0.008257470093667507, 0.0021638586185872555, 0.01561073400080204, 0.013740481808781624, -0.017605548724532127, -0.008350229822099209, 0.019926758483052254, -0.045132748782634735, 0.017671534791588783, -0.04286518320441246, 0.014199145138263702, 0.012804515659809113, -0.00990754459053278, -0.025702884420752525, 0.010716256685554981, 0.026261018589138985, -0.0241041611880064, 0.02739763632416725, 0.05695746839046478, 0.04050465300679207, -0.016682755202054977, -0.007140192203223705, 0.016871513798832893, 0.00017157275578938425, 0.03125377371907234, -0.03191129118204117, -0.005709606688469648, 0.04177146777510643, 0.014459922909736633, 0.023554544895887375, 0.01124285627156496, -0.03542014956474304, 0.03647025302052498, -0.10040438920259476, 0.017761852592229843, -0.03658604621887207, 0.041574422270059586, -0.005435112398117781, 0.04685751348733902, -0.00019950317800976336, -0.017567573115229607, 0.029188591986894608, -0.021296117454767227, -0.06527413427829742, 0.015782412141561508, -0.01312507875263691, -0.012845783494412899, 0.0057861353270709515, -0.0062068309634923935, 0.038377951830625534, -0.03737252950668335, 0.022389208897948265, -0.02788156270980835, 0.0229786466807127, -0.0033587380312383175, 0.0025687972083687782, -0.01936020515859127, -0.004773174412548542, -0.03027971275150776, 0.024445464834570885, 0.01943207159638405, -0.004849654622375965, 0.02096015028655529, 0.020914597436785698, -0.043085772544145584, 0.004396021366119385, -0.026669451966881752, -0.00996131356805563, 0.026073670014739037, 0.06405958533287048, 0.02488805167376995, 0.018151039257645607, -0.04469899460673332, 0.06500568240880966, 0.0040162126533687115, 0.053330112248659134, 0.03037813864648342, 0.0003430295910220593, -0.008362301625311375, 0.003268349217250943, -0.04216725379228592, -0.01975451037287712, 0.0038599008694291115, -0.003959131892770529, -0.0050819688476622105, 0.030045533552765846, 0.013194994069635868, -0.0865071564912796, 0.025022413581609726, 0.07704892009496689, 0.010026002302765846, 0.007899079471826553, -0.045968469232320786, -0.01795557700097561, -0.04446925222873688, -0.00021516486594919115, 0.026722906157374382, 0.012787986546754837, -0.010558166541159153, 0.021325819194316864, 0.04163767397403717, -0.005523106548935175, -0.017483416944742203, -0.00261587742716074, 0.03864024206995964, 0.040418144315481186, 0.04350957274436951, -0.010077569633722305, 0.005161822307854891, 0.030007990077137947, 0.0232084970921278, -0.01363472081720829, -0.019960567355155945, -0.0756923258304596, 0.021579407155513763, 0.04346892982721329, 0.05913929641246796, -0.02994009107351303, 0.002257406245917082, -0.0021589722018688917, 0.00926802959293127, 0.00479118013754487, -0.06243516132235527, 0.0491756945848465, 0.0019409091910347342, -0.011347729712724686, -0.02643764205276966, -0.028656499460339546, -0.04882921651005745, 0.0012402995489537716, 0.004086936824023724, 0.007458755746483803, 0.0034883779007941484, -0.027162184938788414, -0.026671888306736946, 0.0036198825109750032, 0.03913373500108719, 0.04904549568891525, -0.01049290131777525, -0.009427526965737343, 0.0084734121337533, 0.021065546199679375, -0.015165787190198898, -0.052712127566337585, 0.00910396222025156, 0.006281189154833555, 0.010974500328302383, 0.07043774425983429, -0.006289822515100241, -0.0015671184519305825, 0.005505278240889311, 0.0005884179845452309, 0.0009048828505910933, -0.02229902148246765, 0.018273252993822098, 0.04668136313557625, 0.03489008545875549, -0.0009219718631356955, 0.08533749729394913, 0.013465799391269684, -0.008110183291137218, -0.019387122243642807, -0.026972249150276184, 0.048157189041376114, -0.03702273592352867, -0.0042456951923668385, -0.016748039051890373, 0.004034064710140228, 0.0054016332142055035, 0.04998580366373062, -0.006465202197432518, 0.03787950798869133, -0.02097325772047043, -0.01732066087424755, 0.010668158531188965, 0.02210015431046486, 0.022997818887233734, -0.02770829014480114, 0.026254266500473022, 0.0002975052921101451, 0.0015356774674728513, -0.016813987866044044, 0.0011577393161132932, 0.006617385894060135, -0.015444551594555378, 0.0010854336433112621, -0.021892067044973373, 0.00950599368661642, -0.03480943664908409, -0.05769512802362442, -0.02640383318066597, -0.02563907951116562, 0.0435163676738739, -0.028454704210162163, 0.03349819406867027, 0.0044903322122991085, -0.051658131182193756, -0.012658834457397461, 0.03598959743976593, 0.01124756969511509, 0.03588606044650078, -0.02602481096982956, 0.07365545630455017, -0.025857698172330856, 0.0010604913113638759, -0.08061721920967102, -0.04718431085348129, 0.02287658303976059, 0.008604668080806732, 0.001792430761270225, -0.018922630697488785, -0.013043860904872417, -0.035916268825531006, -0.024889297783374786, -0.016530662775039673, 0.04917987808585167, -0.03977406397461891, -0.03221510723233223, 0.02868581749498844, 0.04047359898686409, 0.04814303293824196, 0.04083806648850441, 0.0005392524180933833, -0.0034633013419806957, -0.047308966517448425, -0.012710255570709705, -0.009922316297888756, -0.020305873826146126, -0.003262419020757079, 0.009255019016563892, -0.025224659591913223, 0.03866557404398918, 0.041549455374479294, -0.029897471889853477, -0.0003160390770062804, 0.012466336600482464, 0.0105384336784482, -0.004795954097062349, -0.062254950404167175, -0.01191131304949522, -0.0323842391371727, 0.018033836036920547, 0.036743320524692535, 0.022671392187476158, -0.024174215272068977, -0.01962728425860405, 0.010109763592481613, -0.01040286011993885, -0.042335040867328644, 0.011452266946434975, 0.09231216460466385, 0.036350227892398834, 0.022214114665985107, -0.007014325354248285, -0.012657273560762405, 0.01990712247788906, 0.005289043765515089, -0.0019502289360389113, 0.023842960596084595, 0.014761059544980526, -0.06214108690619469, -0.019220421090722084, -0.030016470700502396, -0.007010199129581451, 0.06806475669145584, -0.027863066643476486, 0.04022275283932686, 0.0788470134139061, 0.009214071556925774, -0.026164233684539795, -0.03760627284646034, 0.019716331735253334, -0.0026917699724435806, 0.008286875672638416, 0.07447817921638489, -0.011506656184792519, 0.0011050142347812653, 0.02185090258717537, 0.02020609937608242, 0.02171364054083824, 0.007872110232710838, 0.04455428943037987, 0.021239111199975014, 0.007876870222389698, -0.033010635524988174, -0.05005587264895439, 0.04522441700100899, -0.05424027889966965, 0.004235748201608658, -0.048511803150177, -0.018831368535757065, 0.029223455116152763, 0.055007968097925186, 0.010129384696483612, -0.027665959671139717, -0.03432070463895798, -0.003047720529139042, 0.016812561079859734, -0.021634623408317566, -0.020247016102075577, 0.01446385495364666, -0.0011738932225853205, 0.04115716367959976, -0.026157358661293983, 0.012801329605281353, -0.02670690231025219, -0.07931726425886154, -0.04270549118518829, -0.008381353691220284, 0.007239476311951876, 0.043109118938446045, 0.010034879669547081, -0.038977671414613724, 0.021204661577939987, -0.03469477966427803, 0.00738023454323411, -0.00678643025457859, 0.031377099454402924, -0.02160661853849888, 0.025497445836663246, -0.0028733108192682266, -0.0000827011390356347, 0.008890352211892605, 0.005978917703032494, 0.09474268555641174, 0.08606959879398346, 0.01850319467484951, -0.07757043838500977, 0.0292205847799778, -0.025073297321796417, 0.026355775073170662, -0.0291943047195673, 0.011949428357183933, -0.0015754435444250703, -0.035297926515340805, 0.034870099276304245, 0.06499899178743362, 0.04652953892946243, -0.010932511650025845, 0.06343842297792435, -0.03367025777697563, -0.035560544580221176, -0.004780762363225222, -0.00607533473521471, -0.023145923390984535, 0.001618375419639051, -0.02174477092921734, -0.011328903958201408, 0.0011251791147515178, 0.0046735708601772785, -0.037298306822776794, -0.019268512725830078, -0.0004854589351452887, 0.0182842705398798, 0.0044667162001132965, 0.013983392156660557, -0.013676772825419903, 0.008986817672848701, -0.05134853348135948, -0.004024355672299862, 0.0067506213672459126, -0.04753166064620018, -0.0020354522857815027, 0.008780457079410553, -0.011566496454179287, -0.011936851777136326, 0.01707305572926998, 0.02026371844112873, -0.04635010287165642, -0.03690705820918083, 0.012273350730538368, 0.05579722300171852, -0.006843952462077141, -0.02382650412619114, -0.007515453267842531, 0.021184436976909637, -0.005393997300416231, -0.021576568484306335, -0.05059865117073059, -0.0049882507883012295, 0.034973371773958206, -0.04939033463597298, 0.012321620248258114, -0.042334508150815964, 0.014101812615990639, -0.012178314849734306, 0.025526076555252075, 0.04754671826958656, -0.00414176844060421, -0.011965295299887657, -0.06394366919994354, 0.04420004412531853, 0.0039366926066577435, 0.010886574164032936, 0.007199322339147329, -0.00534486398100853, -0.023650553077459335, -0.012209614738821983, 0.01991504430770874, 0.037158019840717316, 0.02162998355925083, -0.012176989577710629, -0.022570326924324036, -0.03433001786470413, -0.0552499033510685, -0.011412004008889198, -0.03597242757678032, -0.0022105679381638765, -0.06532806903123856, -0.004275597631931305, 0.03662461042404175, 0.0382159948348999, -0.005583189893513918, 0.00765770161524415, -0.0345085971057415, 0.032048050314188004, 0.016263412311673164, -0.02322208322584629, -0.0029747472144663334, 0.016257895156741142, -0.010414356365799904, -0.031036268919706345, -0.009408289566636086, 0.07785971462726593, -0.014200245961546898, 0.0038075949996709824, 0.029367463663220406, 0.027428265661001205, -0.01807437464594841, 0.009128653444349766, 0.019978582859039307, -0.05009230598807335, 0.01428726315498352, -0.00461014686152339, 0.020166270434856415, 0.009629239328205585, -0.02242152951657772, -0.039930809289216995, -0.04485585540533066, 0.006670777685940266, -0.017636289820075035, -0.0072883316315710545, -0.019763480871915817, -0.026234081014990807, 0.006724763195961714, -0.04997137561440468, -0.0035673801321536303, -0.09489068388938904, -0.0029812364373356104, 0.02774203009903431, -0.007979082874953747, 0.0007402934716083109, -0.008946613408625126, -0.02991349995136261, 0.019798342138528824, 0.03154198080301285, -0.006696654483675957, -0.001918599009513855, -0.023729246109724045, -0.0005195759586058557, 0.0015851164935156703, 0.07253951579332352, -0.010230286046862602, -0.03770052641630173, 0.033971138298511505, -0.06940490752458572, -0.012201722711324692, 0.004774336703121662, 0.0009296259377151728, 0.05209682881832123, 0.04605526849627495, -0.012716331519186497, -0.03632495924830437, 0.03811550885438919, -0.002840302186086774, -0.036624446511268616, 0.0007922635995782912, -0.010276391170918941, -0.017778953537344933, -0.00927465595304966, 0.023593425750732422, 0.005625419784337282, -0.01655091531574726, 0.02248072251677513, 0.036992643028497696, 0.027701236307621002, 0.004836459178477526, 0.013138813897967339, -0.006402077153325081, 0.050300613045692444, -0.01094229519367218, -0.04812987893819809, 0.022201543673872948, 0.04855263978242874, -0.016429005190730095, 0.023284615948796272, -0.019671570509672165, 0.011098918505012989, -0.09184285253286362, -0.01904185116291046, -0.0023512530606240034, 0.019400080665946007, 0.023137977346777916, -0.03192826360464096, 0.03173721209168434, 0.006654702126979828, -0.033722687512636185, 0.013116512447595596, -0.016571925953030586, -0.01725117117166519, -0.025956563651561737, -0.022899022325873375, -0.00747128389775753, 0.021200096234679222, 0.005291613284498453, 0.008192826993763447, 0.02674482762813568, 0.007631325628608465, -0.01168763730674982, -0.0026648545172065496, 0.0030906444881111383, -0.00430629588663578, 0.02878480590879917, -0.057583894580602646, 0.0064492179080843925, -0.011129068210721016, -0.045900631695985794, 0.007204822264611721, 0.01073512714356184, -0.0015587720554322004, -0.007066857535392046, 0.022002631798386574, 0.014978787861764431, 0.09872877597808838, 0.008306741714477539, -0.005585603881627321, 0.005864018574357033, 0.029676377773284912, -0.009826701134443283, 0.02335798181593418, -0.027577118948101997, 0.021908162161707878, 0.003547009313479066, -0.014213292859494686, -0.037433329969644547, -0.007249321322888136, -0.012235007248818874, -0.023876450955867767, -0.010539418086409569, 0.015839360654354095, 0.024112820625305176, -0.017032552510499954, -0.006034196354448795, -0.04480887949466705, -0.0190335214138031, 0.013503040187060833, 0.019191723316907883, -0.03191579505801201, 0.030634108930826187, 0.00840867217630148, 0.009305407293140888, 0.026102913543581963, 0.004630661569535732, 0.01464941818267107, -0.06070975214242935, -0.0014199502766132355, 0.007920274510979652, -0.016464395448565483, -0.024353183805942535, -0.029905149713158607, -0.036530133336782455, 0.0026559121906757355, -0.026245081797242165, -0.0024497350677847862, -0.012181767262518406, -0.039901092648506165, 0.01124084834009409, -0.057257212698459625, 0.0519636906683445, 0.020815569907426834, -0.01024989690631628, -0.022970832884311676, 0.03008037619292736, -0.024379748851060867, 0.014311721548438072, 0.03662194684147835, 0.0095360167324543, -0.019583189859986305, -0.03166487067937851, 0.0409221351146698, -0.005325215868651867, -0.043193522840738297, 0.05473065748810768, 0.01744207739830017, -0.012317011132836342, -0.03441793471574783, -0.01540503092110157, 0.022407762706279755, 0.011920453980565071, 0.005629140418022871, -0.019725536927580833, 0.03414216265082359, -0.00810700748115778, 0.008270013146102428, 0.020220035687088966, 0.0032631598878651857, 0.010186503641307354, 0.0428474023938179, -0.0010075683239847422, 0.04144749045372009, 0.036424022167921066, 0.014124678447842598, -0.03501284122467041, 0.06011553853750229, -0.007258688565343618, 0.0004567870346363634, -0.0021018804982304573, 0.020251458510756493, -0.010028080083429813, -0.04588807001709938, 0.040573686361312866, 0.014199008233845234, -0.04628731310367584, -0.021781396120786667, 0.03729768842458725, 0.03988456353545189, 0.02860831655561924, -0.024210544303059578, 0.02783011831343174, -0.024013914167881012, -0.002689928514882922, 0.025445686653256416, 0.019431108608841896, 0.015255126170814037, 0.03185611590743065, 0.0005455606151372194, 0.03287549316883087, -0.01845383085310459, 0.03600667044520378, -0.0030969218350946903, 0.001319656614214182, -0.02166716195642948, -0.00453105429187417, -0.007010328117758036, -0.03786475583910942, 0.026813169941306114, -0.007389090023934841, -0.011967276223003864, 0.024917664006352425, -0.07496693730354309, -0.021283704787492752, -0.03535747155547142, 0.01041330024600029, -0.003875710302963853, 0.0012233515735715628, 0.020081764087080956, 0.054624855518341064, 0.00453965924680233, 0.00683944346383214, -0.0031385482288897038, -0.02808055467903614, -0.013171267695724964, -0.01803651824593544, 0.0635734498500824, -0.03470616415143013, 0.0010800089221447706, -0.040750376880168915, 0.014214817434549332, -0.05070696398615837, -0.04236390441656113, 0.04434619098901749, 0.03667426109313965, 0.024285132065415382, -0.0570966862142086, -0.02458076737821102, -0.005771023221313953, 0.018919844180345535, -0.03382100164890289, -0.023045431822538376, -0.0239072497934103, 0.004092272371053696, 0.0071004098281264305, 0.022375764325261116 ]
<p>The company where I work did a survey with a complex sample. Originally, the sample was a 2-step stratified, but due to some problems, we lost one of them (so, let's consider that the sample is stratified only on 1 variable).</p> <p>The biggest part of the questions is like "What you think the company can do in respect of X?" and then there is a list of options (some questions allow only 1 answer, some more than 1, others are Likert-type response options).</p> <p>My question is: Wow can I analyze this data? It would be nice if there were a test like Chi-square for complex sample (probably there exists one, but I don't know)</p> <p>Any software is welcome, but I prefer R and SPSS.</p>
74,328
[ -0.02696939744055271, -0.042649418115615845, -0.01601090282201767, 0.037109002470970154, 0.07356928288936615, 0.025313833728432655, 0.03190543130040169, -0.043169718235731125, -0.006357358302921057, -0.05587263032793999, 0.0518818236887455, 0.06952022761106491, 0.02059670351445675, 0.04159136116504669, 0.009715748019516468, 0.016589129343628883, -0.03551722317934036, 0.01744651049375534, -0.029491739347577095, 0.018125129863619804, -0.020176276564598083, 0.0011111507192254066, 0.014279364608228207, 0.00032341378391720355, -0.03437285125255585, 0.023473571985960007, 0.015143796801567078, -0.04065972939133644, 0.012732156552374363, 0.05708763375878334, -0.03724225237965584, -0.013032498769462109, 0.014731102623045444, 0.018635248765349388, 0.04284565523266792, 0.011692550033330917, -0.024612639099359512, -0.04478403553366661, -0.008198137395083904, 0.05110000818967819, -0.01130327396094799, -0.01342197135090828, -0.011002915911376476, 0.022148819640278816, 0.009296003729104996, 0.014074323698878288, -0.03550967201590538, -0.05428541824221611, 0.03954688087105751, -0.05333912372589111, 0.07919532805681229, -0.010375249199569225, 0.024926532059907913, 0.019562501460313797, -0.009598735719919205, -0.018998708575963974, 0.03139440715312958, 0.04360136017203331, -0.013732647523283958, -0.040882136672735214, 0.013330001384019852, 0.04267539456486702, -0.022744620218873024, -0.008855078369379044, -0.056308429688215256, 0.03428058326244354, -0.008540968410670757, -0.021044744178652763, 0.06762882322072983, 0.01249528769403696, 0.033720966428518295, 0.040469929575920105, 0.03331843018531799, -0.006237332709133625, 0.0008030651370063424, -0.08058484643697739, -0.008835157379508018, 0.025913065299391747, 0.028520694002509117, 0.023694759234786034, -0.017458178102970123, 0.019322410225868225, -0.008968468755483627, 0.047301724553108215, 0.00723997550085187, -0.004067426081746817, 0.0616648904979229, -0.019732629880309105, -0.012580201961100101, 0.00040486999205313623, 0.008500674739480019, -0.015838412567973137, 0.055300090461969376, 0.04051193594932556, -0.062245119363069534, -0.013525404967367649, -0.02915509231388569, 0.03757065534591675, 0.012163650244474411, -0.0008462799014523625, 0.03301376476883888, -0.00843645166605711, 0.04568082094192505, 0.0414140522480011, -0.001797660137526691, 0.04456352815032005, -0.002747685881331563, 0.013614441268146038, 0.008991648443043232, -0.037777725607156754, 0.017427891492843628, 0.002761716954410076, 0.020902449265122414, -0.0072869788855314255, 0.030178187415003777, -0.017730632796883583, -0.07231435924768448, -0.016456305980682373, 0.06399774551391602, 0.06685986369848251, 0.06515104323625565, -0.02593446522951126, 0.04846525564789772, -0.039974819868803024, -0.05411279946565628, 0.012302322313189507, 0.008759887889027596, -0.01775158941745758, -0.028912758454680443, 0.05486753210425377, 0.00529831275343895, 0.017580972984433174, 0.03372098132967949, -0.003717563347890973, 0.033042460680007935, 0.009839436039328575, -0.09275058656930923, -0.08786781877279282, -0.03278004378080368, 0.010816371068358421, -0.019345980137586594, -0.06875046342611313, 0.004381679929792881, 0.016494734212756157, 0.04522540047764778, -0.0005641024908982217, 0.021653367206454277, 0.012125602923333645, 0.014866543933749199, 0.03204485774040222, -0.01736867055296898, -0.0056770071387290955, -0.03603249043226242, -0.028255049139261246, 0.02305409498512745, -0.04221154376864433, 0.01019425317645073, 0.017624516040086746, -0.02686271071434021, -0.03588098660111427, -0.028650987893342972, 0.04126610979437828, -0.013833800330758095, 0.008033757098019123, -0.008238825015723705, -0.009827829897403717, 0.08002443611621857, -0.021224426105618477, 0.014753879979252815, 0.002947797765955329, 0.017412317916750908, 0.027876675128936768, 0.011149263940751553, 0.005874748807400465, 0.043543584644794464, -0.014271674677729607, 0.012941124849021435, -0.004968628752976656, 0.031047003343701363, 0.0113413380458951, -0.050387851893901825, -0.022585788741707802, -0.009804473258554935, -0.01032046228647232, 0.00754428980872035, 0.06121641770005226, 0.007763673085719347, -0.022253137081861496, 0.08147680759429932, -0.0733565241098404, -0.03706000745296478, -0.03676719591021538, 0.026815302670001984, 0.03308727964758873, -0.024538705125451088, -0.03292934224009514, 0.03055058978497982, 0.003126447321847081, -0.012969966046512127, -0.03577915579080582, 0.008585452102124691, 0.0072356038726866245, 0.06591076403856277, -0.009342268109321594, -0.0009871318470686674, 0.02673315443098545, 0.0033433802891522646, -0.03761828690767288, 0.030555594712495804, 0.008947882801294327, -0.03062056563794613, -0.002665410516783595, -0.034003350883722305, 0.033303603529930115, 0.008766304701566696, -0.015145058743655682, 0.018411092460155487, 0.014195632189512253, -0.01385403424501419, 0.06635373830795288, -0.03437446430325508, 0.07784842699766159, 0.02898862585425377, 0.021886112168431282, 0.013630760833621025, 0.003636391367763281, 0.010077456012368202, 0.02504320628941059, -0.0134089644998312, -0.005630844738334417, -0.032889414578676224, 0.02480749785900116, 0.047693997621536255, -0.0012635187013074756, -0.05578603968024254, -0.01795375719666481, 0.05797196924686432, 0.01520194299519062, -0.0038527995347976685, 0.02235940843820572, -0.010447750799357891, -0.023893453180789948, 0.0272209532558918, -0.0032505840063095093, 0.01156600285321474, 0.037156034260988235, 0.017541097477078438, 0.030261436477303505, 0.017004424706101418, 0.008466551080346107, 0.025090178474783897, 0.04016977548599243, -0.020197581499814987, -0.006071112584322691, -0.01568983867764473, -0.010608941316604614, 0.05167632922530174, -0.04058022424578667, -0.0039162482134997845, 0.05378885567188263, 0.0019964168313890696, -0.021777193993330002, -0.00893563311547041, -0.0028759571723639965, 0.04468544200062752, 0.02171650156378746, -0.054059948772192, -0.0122878048568964, 0.024892695248126984, -0.006166479550302029, 0.015774592757225037, -0.005280429497361183, 0.007985495962202549, -0.048737939447164536, 0.013642029836773872, 0.05934222415089607, 0.017133481800556183, 0.03740179166197777, -0.006291928235441446, -0.031584128737449646, 0.004218683112412691, -0.025597447529435158, 0.010154717601835728, 0.01778755895793438, -0.061842575669288635, 0.005926472134888172, 0.020237134769558907, -0.03740592673420906, 0.04065224155783653, 0.00892313290387392, -0.013008330948650837, 0.0765228345990181, 0.013116959482431412, -0.035025451332330704, 0.010066368617117405, 0.013502622954547405, 0.02036454528570175, -0.04780525714159012, -0.011128016747534275, 0.03455246612429619, 0.010788976214826107, -0.00300959637388587, 0.026777448132634163, -0.024854866787791252, -0.049364104866981506, 0.00044944408000446856, 0.001070892671123147, 0.028207071125507355, -0.000657151744235307, 0.01561918668448925, 0.0021107324864715338, -0.011717995628714561, 0.0075308955274522305, -0.02580077014863491, -0.09005039185285568, -0.005591935943812132, -0.019963862374424934, -0.00332515686750412, 0.0022573729511350393, -0.006764377001672983, 0.09387557208538055, 0.007007953245192766, -0.03538088500499725, -0.05534358322620392, -0.0282636396586895, -0.026213696226477623, 0.013913113623857498, 0.013366376049816608, 0.01502782478928566, -0.0065445443615317345, 0.0042240191251039505, -0.03136584907770157, 0.0452057346701622, 0.038033947348594666, 0.01646953448653221, -0.011512304656207561, 0.026586929336190224, -0.020278088748455048, 0.010063854046165943, 0.015504884533584118, -0.006879411172121763, -0.04299451783299446, 0.008039122447371483, -0.006184048485010862, -0.014992151409387589, 0.03129880130290985, -0.024289147928357124, -0.021518869325518608, 0.006148932036012411, -0.006769282277673483, -0.00021187572565395385, 0.03698333352804184, 0.023447642102837563, -0.01877240277826786, -0.00821353867650032, 0.025720082223415375, 0.03439890965819359, -0.011958086863160133, -0.024176623672246933, 0.08139093220233917, 0.02245347760617733, 0.00827788282185793, -0.000005108282039145706, 0.008859660476446152, 0.012777880765497684, 0.03437076508998871, -0.04049422964453697, -0.03693750128149986, 0.03391570970416069, 0.08599944412708282, 0.03741585090756416, -0.026368435472249985, -0.00852466095238924, 0.01931503415107727, -0.032338619232177734, -0.021260090172290802, -0.05184447020292282, 0.07172958552837372, 0.0009789011674001813, 0.06205139681696892, -0.0025906020309776068, -0.05563116818666458, 0.029740262776613235, 0.011236083693802357, -0.054735973477363586, 0.051938463002443314, -0.010013197548687458, -0.002666657092049718, 0.0387590117752552, 0.00349726271815598, 0.043204378336668015, 0.0029449481517076492, -0.010510304942727089, -0.010564688593149185, 0.012565034441649914, -0.018824640661478043, 0.02686161734163761, -0.007808383088558912, 0.02256455458700657, 0.027528872713446617, 0.046067968010902405, 0.006297261919826269, 0.0030843012500554323, -0.024380164220929146, 0.020566372200846672, -0.030463581904768944, 0.017872953787446022, -0.015305420383810997, -0.022299813106656075, 0.0199827179312706, 0.07120438665151596, -0.0053373537957668304, 0.03369132801890373, -0.024894122034311295, 0.03954259678721428, -0.032407574355602264, 0.03675545006990433, 0.04251399263739586, 0.015483574941754341, -0.0016346609918400645, -0.025913681834936142, -0.023285770788788795, -0.01635005697607994, 0.018864097073674202, 0.017872923985123634, -0.006040012463927269, 0.05461639165878296, 0.04200444370508194, -0.06332601606845856, -0.01185545977205038, 0.03708710893988609, 0.027172932401299477, -0.01530405879020691, -0.03344075381755829, -0.005219773389399052, -0.007947997190058231, -0.004444466438144445, 0.0010188057785853744, 0.01793794333934784, -0.017100870609283447, 0.005418692249804735, 0.03090777061879635, -0.01239596027880907, -0.05538449436426163, 0.005570200737565756, -0.0035437243059277534, 0.003453580429777503, -0.0021204897202551365, -0.03185883164405823, 0.049540262669324875, 0.04533936455845833, 0.05330781266093254, 0.007408279459923506, 0.015031303279101849, -0.08632852137088776, 0.011067376472055912, 0.0454927459359169, 0.028397073969244957, -0.04317105934023857, 0.008101323619484901, 0.007000284735113382, -0.0157724991440773, 0.049650128930807114, -0.03411099687218666, 0.04410412535071373, -0.029603619128465652, 0.04522232711315155, -0.029841916635632515, 0.005585077218711376, -0.03133390098810196, 0.006198113318532705, -0.007314319256693125, -0.0003172633296344429, -0.0002741417847573757, -0.03660564124584198, -0.03756946325302124, 0.02753392420709133, 0.019977962598204613, 0.04107575863599777, -0.013531445525586605, -0.011256065219640732, 0.019043931737542152, 0.03557850047945976, -0.023948919028043747, -0.05928334593772888, 0.01790471002459526, -0.003948268946260214, 0.005292737390846014, 0.06722591072320938, -0.034146748483181, -0.051019564270973206, 0.024379180744290352, 0.025300445035099983, 0.008231709711253643, 0.017524633556604385, -0.014666699804365635, 0.03961605578660965, 0.01902652531862259, 0.042134035378694534, 0.0327620655298233, 0.040146876126527786, -0.009939913637936115, 0.009931364096701145, -0.013447936624288559, -0.010860093869268894, -0.033395349979400635, -0.03990025073289871, -0.04243205487728119, -0.03878230229020119, -0.04163036867976189, 0.004641939420253038, 0.018069185316562653, 0.038498569279909134, -0.04497895762324333, 0.012557837180793285, -0.000766389537602663, -0.012538032606244087, -0.04318059980869293, 0.013451257720589638, -0.008106748573482037, 0.022813569754362106, 0.00000799132976680994, -0.04924117028713226, 0.002377786673605442, -0.04330785945057869, -0.02490594983100891, 0.0026327611412853003, -0.04778236895799637, -0.019792547449469566, -0.029879523441195488, -0.03940216824412346, 0.00001585835707373917, -0.020353015512228012, 0.06423117965459824, -0.039718929678201675, 0.027683300897479057, -0.01609455794095993, -0.019203951582312584, 0.006741274613887072, 0.048967763781547546, 0.009242557920515537, 0.02063959650695324, -0.014837373979389668, 0.04165225848555565, -0.009258102625608444, -0.030860785394906998, -0.0760025829076767, -0.05863621085882187, 0.05169375240802765, 0.016350096091628075, -0.0451761893928051, -0.02280893735587597, -0.026805711910128593, 0.009776700288057327, -0.021614208817481995, -0.020249174907803535, 0.01731201633810997, 0.015042446553707123, -0.007364403922110796, 0.00885878223925829, -0.016210051253437996, 0.07701835036277771, -0.0045359754003584385, -0.008333957754075527, 0.03580202907323837, -0.020982127636671066, -0.007456552237272263, 0.024683702737092972, -0.03793243318796158, -0.026468584313988686, -0.04231101647019386, -0.013243923895061016, 0.0028961384668946266, 0.0195020642131567, -0.006978012155741453, -0.010127102956175804, 0.0020790877752006054, -0.07091846317052841, -0.0139134107157588, -0.026476452127099037, 0.018058612942695618, -0.0077696386724710464, -0.0027744576800614595, -0.03009629249572754, -0.014994500204920769, -0.021591490134596825, -0.025974104180932045, 0.023744191974401474, 0.02197437174618244, -0.029576417058706284, 0.02028358168900013, 0.033845655620098114, 0.022341106086969376, -0.04696148261427879, -0.012702330946922302, -0.01229022815823555, 0.021946558728814125, 0.009270450100302696, -0.023007173091173172, -0.002107985783368349, 0.07704736292362213, -0.0297124981880188, -0.0020189147908240557, 0.0063279471360147, -0.007070813328027725, 0.04499378055334091, 0.017340756952762604, 0.030970605090260506, 0.05744374543428421, 0.00018244903185404837, -0.04079700633883476, 0.029039708897471428, -0.008092040196061134, -0.0030831715557724237, 0.01739794947206974, 0.03676271066069603, 0.003037722548469901, 0.018974950537085533, 0.021472644060850143, 0.01518060453236103, 0.017451943829655647, 0.03993670642375946, 0.026243412867188454, 0.022940076887607574, 0.002458532340824604, -0.014295068569481373, -0.03832000121474266, 0.0031163499224931, -0.030559847131371498, 0.020061565563082695, -0.0176045224070549, -0.006795292720198631, 0.02474389225244522, 0.04752666503190994, 0.02646460570394993, -0.04293212294578552, 0.0025397769641131163, -0.07370644062757492, 0.006147074047476053, 0.01781695894896984, -0.008227513171732426, -0.017907969653606415, 0.004329422488808632, 0.026604223996400833, -0.0024383594281971455, 0.012804092839360237, 0.016532639041543007, -0.06672009080648422, -0.010410355404019356, -0.01750398799777031, -0.06331076472997665, 0.018784118816256523, 0.021601393818855286, 0.009051688015460968, 0.02246733196079731, -0.054021548479795456, 0.014186770655214787, -0.012666339986026287, 0.041080575436353683, -0.014202913269400597, 0.037592146545648575, -0.019947031512856483, 0.014942837879061699, 0.025649599730968475, -0.01776689849793911, 0.1011953353881836, 0.04988734796643257, 0.015357254073023796, -0.025471072643995285, 0.029001224786043167, -0.038741111755371094, 0.02391122654080391, -0.016463030129671097, 0.005246971268206835, -0.021187417209148407, -0.02497120201587677, 0.05373480170965195, 0.056628283113241196, 0.02408335544168949, 0.012709490954875946, 0.05873727798461914, -0.011968346312642097, -0.05668303370475769, -0.005318579263985157, -0.005742943845689297, -0.016706911846995354, -0.0379994735121727, -0.026118701323866844, -0.0009321373072452843, 0.003434837330132723, -0.01686357706785202, -0.023211384192109108, -0.01819869503378868, 0.007073140703141689, -0.013593985699117184, -0.05555065721273422, -0.023364422842860222, -0.008533882908523083, 0.02302362769842148, -0.0353802926838398, -0.02638116665184498, 0.030595703050494194, -0.021599534898996353, -0.0063614072278141975, 0.071308434009552, -0.004218322690576315, -0.018648000434041023, 0.003853015135973692, -0.00007631551852682605, -0.05138358846306801, 0.015751421451568604, -0.04844289273023605, 0.00884176604449749, 0.021136131137609482, -0.030354294925928116, -0.029911400750279427, -0.008466116152703762, 0.003385131014510989, -0.0109113659709692, 0.013852160423994064, 0.033875320106744766, 0.02442644163966179, -0.05047161877155304, -0.06002926826477051, -0.00835118442773819, 0.007900147698819637, -0.01801716350018978, 0.021115755662322044, 0.0001565029815537855, -0.04921208322048187, -0.03161318972706795, -0.00754497479647398, 0.019690794870257378, -0.0249815471470356, -0.03251028060913086, 0.02918260172009468, 0.0001385794166708365, -0.03331674635410309, -0.002508624456822872, 0.004763754550367594, 0.03710955008864403, -0.0017244074260815978, -0.02606986276805401, -0.0028446372598409653, -0.02234562486410141, -0.009969961829483509, 0.009258503094315529, -0.0301533006131649, 0.010647277347743511, -0.05415566265583038, -0.028271136805415154, 0.019184280186891556, 0.024785079061985016, -0.0166363175958395, 0.003583357436582446, -0.0005443358095362782, 0.04202237352728844, -0.005642601288855076, -0.057883232831954956, -0.009335367940366268, -0.008367444388568401, -0.06758970022201538, 0.007540347520262003, -0.016837874427437782, 0.07685713469982147, -0.013873006217181683, -0.005733043886721134, -0.013513270765542984, 0.002209004247561097, -0.02589627355337143, 0.001897910493426025, 0.03664161637425423, -0.05837739259004593, -0.0040634614415466785, -0.012240570038557053, 0.008761223405599594, -0.020091617479920387, -0.025523992255330086, -0.09268583357334137, -0.03180205821990967, 0.01805834099650383, 0.011461270973086357, -0.021737849339842796, -0.0053675491362810135, -0.02561831846833229, -0.011668812483549118, 0.010781398043036461, 0.021055620163679123, -0.04654288291931152, 0.004352734424173832, 0.0029092191252857447, -0.025231610983610153, -0.00631740503013134, -0.04069561883807182, -0.00948818027973175, 0.026002436876296997, 0.023443059995770454, -0.016023974865674973, -0.0016074887244030833, 0.0173979289829731, 0.010463283397257328, 0.005555295385420322, 0.03803205490112305, -0.03713569417595863, 0.03638707101345062, 0.04221931844949722, -0.049881912767887115, -0.03096485510468483, 0.031830083578825, -0.02451169677078724, 0.051948197185993195, 0.01850978098809719, 0.0031213860493153334, 0.01781352050602436, 0.027163833379745483, -0.031402524560689926, -0.007649923209100962, -0.013092301785945892, 0.018924931064248085, -0.0009665279067121446, 0.026819655671715736, 0.002308553783223033, -0.02560945227742195, -0.03841470181941986, 0.057715315371751785, 0.0681028813123703, 0.005458055529743433, -0.007058786693960428, -0.023208454251289368, -0.02065279893577099, 0.013559465296566486, 0.027898482978343964, -0.017985522747039795, 0.054366033524274826, 0.015496250241994858, -0.039824552834033966, -0.0021443194709718227, -0.02153180167078972, 0.034523554146289825, -0.0783371776342392, -0.0068842507898807526, -0.0041245389729738235, 0.032158225774765015, 0.022296611219644547, -0.06005292385816574, -0.011834436096251011, -0.02109704725444317, -0.0606587752699852, 0.00028941527125425637, -0.018487675115466118, -0.0027857457753270864, -0.026758631691336632, 0.006930023431777954, -0.03029077686369419, 0.02710874378681183, 0.002822460373863578, 0.007010725326836109, 0.036292336881160736, 0.0069806850515306, 0.008823336102068424, -0.0029607771430164576, 0.037695206701755524, -0.013589897193014622, -0.02335214614868164, -0.05376136302947998, 0.0013290439965203404, -0.03156299889087677, -0.020112359896302223, 0.016776680946350098, -0.031233154237270355, 0.09576952457427979, 0.0610835999250412, 0.008387343026697636, 0.0030931581277400255, 0.048185646533966064, 0.028581291437149048, -0.01796102710068226, -0.04926950857043266, 0.01435620803385973, 0.010712356306612492, 0.037798065692186356, 0.006099775433540344, 0.01782524585723877, 0.057210542261600494, -0.010937999002635479, 0.06106787919998169, 0.03207309916615486, -0.031743474304676056, 0.011889282613992691, -0.030415842309594154, -0.03696765378117561, -0.006213002372533083, -0.010388631373643875, 0.058122437447309494, -0.054818045347929, 0.021190490573644638, 0.009027586318552494, 0.021523648872971535, -0.028183845803141594, 0.0033281398937106133, -0.017951928079128265, -0.050657715648412704, 0.02054990828037262, 0.0007263518637046218, -0.0010212970664724708, -0.04948226362466812, -0.027302471920847893, -0.0002746783138718456, 0.015687111765146255, -0.017635686323046684, 0.0043672178871929646, 0.010939734987914562, 0.056867677718400955, -0.009427031502127647, -0.019301842898130417, 0.020446669310331345, -0.02025219425559044, 0.022645128890872, -0.08449815958738327, 0.04796736314892769, 0.025381674990057945, -0.004055667202919722, -0.03624962642788887, 0.0027919691056013107, -0.0547039695084095, -0.018073715269565582, 0.05960306525230408, -0.03770000860095024, 0.005270392168313265, -0.018520932644605637, 0.01991339959204197, -0.011094256304204464, -0.06612778455018997, 0.00870286114513874, -0.029929522424936295, -0.024994052946567535, -0.024342548102140427, 0.006857590284198523, 0.034342627972364426, 0.0006939972518011928, 0.0337236262857914, -0.002087819389998913, 0.02611384354531765, -0.010971534997224808, -0.02034827135503292, 0.014537425711750984, 0.016428250819444656, -0.007745298091322184, 0.053678013384342194, -0.004403145983815193, -0.003368467092514038, 0.04516831412911415, -0.02539944276213646, 0.00223839795216918, 0.041171085089445114, -0.038599126040935516, -0.03969990089535713, -0.01575889065861702, 0.0233015026897192, 0.000957698212005198, -0.09127744287252426, -0.018769986927509308, 0.00641065277159214, -0.05887768417596817, -0.022868622094392776, 0.06595615297555923, 0.03168400377035141, -0.0017847205745056272, -0.005887851119041443, -0.0075287288054823875, -0.0076816268265247345, -0.024340610951185226, 0.007869971916079521, 0.008527588099241257, 0.03828934207558632, 0.012277001515030861, -0.027098091319203377, 0.04205624759197235, -0.018976710736751556, 0.029813989996910095, -0.008139686658978462, 0.02804023027420044, -0.010979462414979935, 0.005958209279924631, 0.013167712837457657, -0.011032480746507645, 0.021538592875003815, 0.020684020593762398, 0.004870393313467503, 0.08234819769859314, -0.013528573326766491, 0.01410529762506485, -0.040972188115119934, -0.016404401510953903, -0.042978838086128235, -0.006077755242586136, 0.05186183750629425, 0.02404242940247059, -0.005598518066108227, 0.003905167803168297, -0.0058190724812448025, -0.020911715924739838, 0.03196949139237404, -0.01566489413380623, 0.01912718638777733, -0.024868743494153023, 0.012035435996949673, -0.01108502596616745, -0.049621909856796265, -0.01717361994087696, -0.021450798958539963, 0.023319698870182037, 0.0007405088399536908, 0.03319425880908966, -0.022075537592172623, 0.006573693826794624, 0.005032417830079794, 0.056279268115758896, -0.05451617389917374, 0.004374566022306681, -0.037921879440546036, 0.03471146896481514, -0.01681826449930668, -0.023079730570316315 ]
<p>I have data that involves 2 groups (equal sample size in each) and data for each group over 3 time points (they are actually 3 different monetary reward conditions). I want to investigate within group differences. All time/condition points are important, I don't have a "control" time point.</p> <p>Any opinions on the following:</p> <ol> <li><p>If I am comfortable that sphericity is assumed by Mauchly's Test not being violated, would a multivariate Lambda F test statistic be more appropriate or a sphericity assumed estimate (within-condition estimate from SPSS)?</p></li> <li><p>If I choose to go with the understanding that despite a test result saying it is OK, assuming sphericity may still be over-confident, any thoughts on potentially reporting ALL Greenhouse-Geiser estimates regardless of Mauchly's or Lambda? I have read that this may reduce the chance of a Type-1 error without having to assume sphericity or equality of covariance matrices. Perhaps too overcautious? Or, is potentially adjusting df's more invasive than assuming sphericity?</p></li> </ol>
48,906
[ -0.03544079139828682, -0.009884712286293507, 0.001213398645631969, 0.04460378736257553, 0.03968131169676781, 0.006130977999418974, -0.02173241227865219, -0.041874054819345474, 0.03027183935046196, -0.039750367403030396, 0.023624032735824585, 0.03255696967244148, 0.035525429993867874, 0.04158769175410271, 0.011893431656062603, -0.01283026672899723, -0.0188601054251194, -0.0198791716247797, -0.014830098487436771, -0.005716419778764248, 0.005571808200329542, 0.013244866393506527, -0.01655273698270321, 0.00411685835570097, 0.001245655119419098, 0.05868205800652504, 0.00453004939481616, -0.03553945943713188, -0.01142970286309719, 0.05413223057985306, -0.06271601468324661, -0.041733842343091965, -0.013451260514557362, 0.010792026296257973, 0.018015678972005844, 0.0019307645270600915, -0.004533560946583748, -0.05040207877755165, -0.045365869998931885, 0.04331633076071739, -0.028370317071676254, -0.016574544832110405, 0.032935526221990585, 0.04401062801480293, 0.01707988604903221, 0.07886133342981339, -0.02554260939359665, 0.0017918350640684366, 0.06588577479124069, -0.02803218550980091, 0.053589966148138046, 0.007064058445394039, -0.0009369969484396279, 0.013666247017681599, -0.009218042716383934, 0.007484381087124348, 0.048673950135707855, 0.03674738109111786, 0.005811161827296019, -0.009369984269142151, 0.0004464538942556828, -0.01685747504234314, 0.02770061604678631, 0.015474353916943073, -0.021203085780143738, -0.010502712801098824, -0.021022148430347443, -0.013921485282480717, 0.03426571562886238, -0.007334441877901554, 0.008341995067894459, 0.00903139729052782, 0.005176780745387077, 0.00021854182705283165, 0.003722933353856206, -0.030715905129909515, -0.0006864025490358472, 0.054917845875024796, 0.06718257814645767, -0.0012756591895595193, 0.026844555512070656, 0.030327701941132545, -0.01600266434252262, 0.04205932095646858, 0.01604018360376358, -0.004882642067968845, 0.07899070531129837, -0.053937844932079315, 0.007763436995446682, 0.04569639265537262, -0.055531326681375504, 0.0063220420852303505, 0.019005071371793747, 0.013444770127534866, -0.03137947991490364, -0.0019188267178833485, -0.03661245107650757, -0.0011398150818422437, -0.039718806743621826, 0.025884991511702538, -0.03387412801384926, -0.01205322053283453, 0.044834792613983154, 0.040750205516815186, -0.001184025895781815, 0.011823751963675022, -0.02159740962088108, -0.006501070689409971, -0.02827449142932892, -0.05829588696360588, -0.006931762211024761, 0.022322794422507286, 0.010392948985099792, -0.01976471021771431, 0.011507603339850903, -0.020722543820738792, -0.02536342479288578, -0.03927598521113396, 0.05365651100873947, 0.059018705040216446, 0.05207017436623573, 0.010931654833257198, 0.04785549268126488, -0.0016290666535496712, -0.05001073703169823, 0.027546226978302002, 0.003981809131801128, -0.009716035798192024, -0.05094190686941147, 0.02704712189733982, 0.05077066272497177, -0.037500206381082535, 0.03812972828745842, -0.01815834641456604, 0.011789477430284023, 0.026248078793287277, -0.08495812118053436, -0.05567526817321777, 0.02969875931739807, 0.027443472295999527, -0.0029393420554697514, -0.03769688308238983, -0.04330398514866829, -0.028488721698522568, 0.0717063844203949, 0.0008688423549756408, 0.037266138941049576, -0.0021296897903084755, 0.05455983430147171, -0.0006549761747010052, -0.01592731662094593, -0.01242816261947155, -0.01823299005627632, -0.03199349343776703, -0.020525332540273666, -0.06698290258646011, 0.028119975700974464, -0.00643316050991416, 0.03578752651810646, 0.03913077339529991, 0.04374680295586586, 0.00013459094043355435, -0.059668347239494324, -0.028659475967288017, -0.005153133068233728, 0.006327168550342321, 0.01952550932765007, -0.02915377914905548, 0.052343081682920456, -0.030898410826921463, -0.0057603903114795685, 0.014237448573112488, -0.011148694902658463, 0.06708072125911713, 0.04132634773850441, -0.03582454472780228, 0.016123011708259583, -0.01835169829428196, 0.008288498967885971, -0.022541537880897522, -0.06939205527305603, 0.004350122530013323, 0.02162541262805462, -0.021425660699605942, 0.02398315817117691, 0.07516705989837646, -0.004384733736515045, 0.02367696352303028, 0.027658019214868546, -0.0464918427169323, -0.06775032728910446, -0.03279944881796837, 0.04207093268632889, 0.017670441418886185, -0.05227166414260864, 0.0395699217915535, -0.0012842289870604873, 0.024102604016661644, -0.01569061167538166, -0.027294255793094635, 0.005641864147037268, 0.020683739334344864, 0.04158172383904457, -0.05087270960211754, 0.03955322876572609, 0.026696905493736267, 0.03332996368408203, -0.05683806538581848, 0.015688838437199593, -0.0228462815284729, -0.009932241402566433, -0.007388812489807606, -0.04118866100907326, 0.03124937042593956, -0.0029142380226403475, -0.00204901909455657, 0.004725542385131121, 0.009988266043365002, -0.058624885976314545, 0.07741466164588928, -0.04122236743569374, 0.041716281324625015, 0.04324759170413017, 0.010827207006514072, 0.028987018391489983, 0.007147680036723614, 0.00533928070217371, -0.0015506609342992306, -0.039900150150060654, -0.045126479119062424, -0.02581811510026455, -0.007540605030953884, 0.007484361529350281, -0.010543489828705788, -0.001239751698449254, -0.01202397234737873, 0.032070014625787735, -0.00463904719799757, -0.010559686459600925, 0.04253726452589035, 0.022390777245163918, -0.039093758910894394, 0.0019567052368074656, 0.033364735543727875, 0.029497109353542328, 0.015847990289330482, 0.0216849185526371, -0.011643835343420506, 0.022473599761724472, 0.02766968496143818, 0.03659208491444588, 0.0275009423494339, 0.04530481994152069, 0.03495180606842041, -0.026365235447883606, -0.005222718231379986, 0.008124811574816704, 0.005416632629930973, 0.008748025633394718, 0.06193806231021881, 0.018031276762485504, -0.021204082295298576, 0.006636808626353741, -0.018860474228858948, 0.03497631475329399, 0.025826282799243927, -0.008114608936011791, 0.03424995392560959, 0.018266938626766205, -0.022544411942362785, 0.04286908730864525, -0.024495556950569153, -0.01705922745168209, -0.022042542695999146, 0.03750967979431152, 0.015189466066658497, 0.0011311968555673957, 0.0057577225379645824, -0.035815440118312836, 0.006296454928815365, 0.002363448031246662, 0.015636669471859932, 0.05690782517194748, -0.008741120807826519, -0.030811021104454994, 0.010884513147175312, -0.01622628979384899, 0.012502931989729404, 0.047048550099134445, -0.007519691251218319, -0.014484068378806114, 0.013691402040421963, 0.021382233127951622, -0.030039073899388313, 0.008684768341481686, -0.011171722784638405, -0.0005857704090885818, -0.013037837110459805, -0.03599928319454193, 0.0309621412307024, -0.002461466006934643, -0.06471700221300125, 0.03881515562534332, -0.013801227323710918, -0.009306289255619049, -0.0313517302274704, -0.004950367379933596, -0.0075712804682552814, 0.010806666687130928, 0.03463352471590042, 0.016118263825774193, -0.025277016684412956, -0.006924103479832411, -0.050661902874708176, -0.08846592903137207, 0.01047358475625515, -0.00598521763458848, 0.04272766783833504, -0.023901868611574173, 0.007709634955972433, 0.04661967232823372, 0.05132884532213211, 0.002060736296698451, -0.00846500787883997, -0.005360214505344629, -0.04419512301683426, -0.04888048768043518, 0.04737208038568497, -0.01719328761100769, -0.0024333817418664694, 0.03889276459813118, -0.021534347906708717, 0.04863980785012245, 0.007841574028134346, 0.03222496435046196, -0.010210193693637848, 0.03883998095989227, 0.032388731837272644, -0.0163043774664402, 0.05508691817522049, 0.055299025028944016, -0.007045251317322254, -0.004521733149886131, -0.011176654137670994, 0.021680066362023354, 0.028907522559165955, -0.02347646839916706, -0.008916330523788929, -0.023298466578125954, 0.016872281208634377, -0.018934840336441994, 0.006305335089564323, 0.019434668123722076, -0.05326087027788162, -0.019403817132115364, 0.0375232957303524, 0.04117072373628616, -0.00862426869571209, 0.002837598556652665, 0.05737384781241417, 0.0402364507317543, 0.00677912775427103, -0.010102991946041584, -0.0269033070653677, -0.009424564428627491, 0.055380288511514664, -0.005332267377525568, -0.020448513329029083, 0.041436128318309784, 0.024503909051418304, 0.021787004545331, -0.025060832500457764, -0.016753094270825386, 0.0014287997037172318, -0.06597086042165756, 0.03039524331688881, -0.01034199632704258, 0.054199397563934326, 0.018603555858135223, 0.05288754776120186, 0.018095269799232483, -0.020778611302375793, -0.00417922530323267, 0.01022934727370739, -0.03955589234828949, 0.018672335892915726, -0.04055843874812126, 0.023889552801847458, 0.020808037370443344, -0.00880446471273899, 0.03247795253992081, -0.041674572974443436, 0.0038095342461019754, -0.007284914143383503, 0.03912527486681938, -0.026237856596708298, 0.03956159949302673, -0.048677485436201096, -0.03735595941543579, -0.005888853222131729, -0.015364370308816433, 0.03364488109946251, -0.020031515508890152, 0.03896155208349228, 0.02181815169751644, -0.0388764850795269, -0.04450151324272156, 0.011478321626782417, -0.0033841803669929504, 0.014542602002620697, 0.06302295625209808, 0.0221510399132967, 0.04695725440979004, -0.01316995918750763, 0.0451449416577816, 0.009115654043853283, 0.010394403710961342, 0.024634912610054016, -0.023326141759753227, -0.0026928335428237915, -0.03016304038465023, -0.033798471093177795, 0.01310702320188284, 0.05842903256416321, 0.04758761078119278, -0.022790370509028435, 0.0010878993198275566, 0.011732089333236217, -0.038949113339185715, 0.006143754813820124, 0.025126999244093895, 0.0014219103613868356, -0.048542570322752, -0.04326079413294792, -0.01817038096487522, 0.02831401862204075, -0.015234383754432201, -0.00871183443814516, 0.04602907970547676, 0.0026159922126680613, 0.00725529994815588, 0.04873954877257347, -0.05117553099989891, -0.014341676607728004, 0.012136557139456272, -0.026319557800889015, 0.051279086619615555, -0.0053269220516085625, -0.018738966435194016, 0.0016244983999058604, 0.025392351672053337, 0.016662560403347015, 0.04145371913909912, 0.011576186865568161, -0.06897430121898651, 0.00003231419759686105, 0.04870201274752617, 0.07148782908916473, -0.02625230886042118, -0.004286419600248337, -0.023287838324904442, -0.012157806195318699, 0.060206588357686996, -0.02397947572171688, 0.02950335666537285, -0.009886949323117733, 0.002412166679278016, -0.058579180389642715, -0.017167747020721436, -0.028142787516117096, -0.012824531644582748, -0.016827018931508064, 0.03672115132212639, -0.005772868636995554, -0.009079252369701862, -0.01177489198744297, -0.006470577325671911, 0.003313144203275442, 0.030336875468492508, -0.008197704330086708, -0.03575572744011879, 0.0014650690136477351, 0.010934372432529926, 0.010771535336971283, -0.04110262542963028, -0.003449471667408943, 0.0076575614511966705, 0.004935245029628277, 0.0801154151558876, -0.004645646549761295, -0.06853476166725159, -0.006997371558099985, 0.02153034508228302, -0.022795334458351135, 0.009366284124553204, -0.01967022195458412, 0.08488740772008896, 0.013370932079851627, 0.03507201746106148, 0.03446250036358833, 0.019967926666140556, 0.005219365004450083, 0.03266521915793419, -0.038022447377443314, -0.009364954195916653, -0.0068229371681809425, -0.022668829187750816, -0.0373537577688694, -0.012502174824476242, -0.04189102351665497, 0.026249729096889496, 0.04318229481577873, 0.009314955212175846, -0.009049078449606895, -0.020545214414596558, 0.02009781450033188, 0.004044671542942524, -0.00733391335234046, 0.006572610232979059, 0.002362810308113694, -0.029306894168257713, -0.005095881875604391, -0.00006643599044764414, 0.010620786808431149, -0.03716912865638733, 0.015587110072374344, 0.012510553933680058, -0.03848464787006378, 0.030129343271255493, -0.0005486973677761853, -0.021374426782131195, 0.018753185868263245, -0.027217449620366096, 0.02726825885474682, -0.0030935206450521946, 0.03105265088379383, -0.006739157252013683, -0.0061361175030469894, 0.03847360983490944, 0.056839533150196075, -0.015996692702174187, 0.04298027232289314, -0.008826669305562973, 0.012183783575892448, -0.03359465301036835, 0.004467397462576628, -0.09092514961957932, -0.009134262800216675, 0.019102483987808228, -0.013247814029455185, -0.045249659568071365, -0.009045817889273167, 0.020084906369447708, -0.03461844474077225, -0.022906210273504257, -0.042632680386304855, 0.046861596405506134, -0.026697034016251564, -0.052246224135160446, 0.01582280918955803, 0.016229556873440742, 0.06909319013357162, -0.01246571820229292, 0.002844365080818534, 0.0040124752558767796, -0.001942067057825625, 0.0012084973277524114, -0.016801949590444565, -0.01710520312190056, -0.019203603267669678, -0.02484286017715931, -0.04757321625947952, 0.010763335041701794, -0.01775742694735527, -0.012272294610738754, -0.05163179710507393, 0.050531476736068726, -0.07342234998941422, 0.011193365789949894, -0.03809329867362976, 0.04227175563573837, -0.018004605546593666, 0.0309759508818388, 0.0035021062940359116, 0.002557380823418498, 0.006606522016227245, -0.0006254519103094935, 0.017196033149957657, -0.022718697786331177, -0.04898582026362419, 0.02631670981645584, 0.08369055390357971, -0.020275700837373734, 0.028140246868133545, 0.02034064382314682, -0.011187697760760784, -0.0028507052920758724, -0.008321121335029602, -0.00011973642540397123, -0.008918650448322296, 0.025581901893019676, -0.015948966145515442, -0.03478929027915001, -0.047480739653110504, 0.08041729778051376, 0.07708761841058731, 0.017867038026452065, 0.025459833443164825, 0.05662773177027702, 0.00466680945828557, -0.0463620163500309, -0.053245749324560165, 0.02321906015276909, -0.003443907480686903, -0.03324628248810768, 0.061376914381980896, -0.021216895431280136, 0.017397629097104073, 0.05869341269135475, 0.009959458373486996, -0.005696414038538933, 0.058164797723293304, 0.007164224982261658, 0.012825089506804943, 0.04287077859044075, -0.04206220433115959, -0.04480721056461334, 0.015252307988703251, -0.06695938855409622, -0.007340757641941309, -0.04022516682744026, -0.028473518788814545, 0.03425686061382294, 0.03110969252884388, -0.023456843569874763, -0.06231408193707466, -0.01864105649292469, -0.05431279167532921, 0.006854362785816193, 0.026351315900683403, -0.0189165361225605, -0.008075710386037827, -0.029139351099729538, 0.06758978217840195, -0.01648850180208683, -0.00304364669136703, -0.042432866990566254, -0.07563052326440811, -0.0016575154149904847, -0.000042482151911826804, -0.04708288237452507, 0.04251888766884804, -0.014511638320982456, -0.04373190924525261, -0.015979576855897903, -0.023808244615793228, -0.0022543559316545725, 0.02182486280798912, 0.020614290609955788, -0.006482609082013369, 0.06081659719347954, -0.016776977106928825, -0.022888273000717163, -0.01140575297176838, 0.012415475212037563, 0.13698872923851013, 0.03450324013829231, 0.008998347446322441, -0.031670160591602325, 0.022661250084638596, -0.013053329661488533, -0.005395183805376291, -0.012367465533316135, 0.015344979241490364, -0.01710123009979725, -0.00870626512914896, 0.03380173444747925, 0.08146992325782776, 0.02296876534819603, -0.01511241216212511, 0.043334316462278366, -0.019538216292858124, 0.004100306890904903, 0.009242748841643333, -0.0077096750028431416, 0.050221432000398636, 0.0021495239343494177, 0.007146790158003569, -0.029897240921854973, 0.0026385674718767405, 0.006765143945813179, -0.002404844621196389, -0.009604157879948616, 0.009288179688155651, -0.005619238596409559, 0.019890371710062027, -0.006060141138732433, 0.016664579510688782, -0.005925431381911039, -0.042008548974990845, -0.016373928636312485, 0.04089609161019325, -0.06457684934139252, 0.044296521693468094, 0.032975856214761734, -0.028984513133764267, 0.011347223073244095, -0.020937880501151085, 0.020864779129624367, -0.003905900986865163, -0.0424170084297657, 0.0028105995152145624, 0.021035244688391685, 0.009073706343770027, -0.028029782697558403, 0.008555390872061253, -0.011222777888178825, -0.004173723980784416, -0.056597400456666946, -0.010229968465864658, -0.02080785669386387, 0.03525043651461601, -0.034957293421030045, -0.03571700677275658, 0.00483869481831789, -0.03664679080247879, 0.026778172701597214, 0.04176146909594536, -0.008299934677779675, -0.016407115384936333, -0.019958117976784706, -0.02834794484078884, 0.03961934149265289, 0.024471605196595192, 0.02002631314098835, -0.011662840843200684, -0.018244115635752678, -0.00232782494276762, 0.016607113182544708, 0.005370303522795439, 0.02517600916326046, 0.03853600099682808, -0.025940120220184326, -0.0025435066781938076, 0.004745232407003641, -0.07329937815666199, -0.014531771652400494, -0.04361848160624504, 0.01783290132880211, -0.035484060645103455, -0.004724128637462854, 0.044009193778038025, -0.0222796481102705, 0.02865828573703766, 0.003677465720102191, 0.009117822162806988, 0.06182679906487465, 0.031318388879299164, -0.010687483474612236, -0.006468358915299177, -0.03503626212477684, -0.026927083730697632, -0.009546001441776752, -0.05449044331908226, 0.043909456580877304, 0.016460975632071495, -0.0028884282801300287, -0.029256142675876617, -0.0044656298123300076, 0.02032325603067875, 0.018906494602560997, 0.0197051502764225, -0.05848054587841034, -0.024463355541229248, 0.01842612214386463, -0.034464314579963684, -0.05770900845527649, -0.01793689839541912, -0.07141779363155365, -0.02285843901336193, -0.03376932069659233, -0.028727935627102852, -0.048718422651290894, 0.014090978540480137, 0.0012216906761750579, 0.009353320114314556, -0.0379827618598938, -0.016103597357869148, -0.0516810417175293, -0.046817392110824585, -0.0057803732343018055, -0.012751810252666473, 0.04334096238017082, -0.007289100904017687, -0.05069275572896004, 0.0031892736442387104, 0.050849463790655136, -0.036073993891477585, -0.02171231620013714, 0.010525771416723728, -0.017108764499425888, 0.010692819952964783, 0.016244402155280113, 0.012760969810187817, 0.019588736817240715, 0.03625039383769035, -0.03225400671362877, -0.02484361082315445, 0.020210759714245796, -0.0068327272310853004, 0.03638902306556702, 0.007643588352948427, 0.009255633689463139, -0.03013506345450878, 0.017414383590221405, 0.016807453706860542, -0.010995911434292793, -0.0018694127211347222, -0.007531864568591118, -0.008335879072546959, 0.0184255912899971, -0.0038635702803730965, -0.015960682183504105, -0.007689173333346844, -0.005157139617949724, 0.007347883190959692, -0.01413043588399887, -0.009375648573040962, -0.023857802152633667, -0.07114029675722122, -0.0034478551242500544, -0.010773219168186188, -0.02088337391614914, 0.04053083062171936, 0.06328226625919342, -0.015154493972659111, -0.008049317635595798, -0.011157423257827759, 0.0013569643488153815, -0.06755241751670837, -0.01782158948481083, 0.04484207555651665, 0.03704201057553291, 0.01966487243771553, -0.025403248146176338, -0.01914314366877079, 0.011047753505408764, -0.05380178615450859, 0.04288453981280327, -0.02654830552637577, 0.034639663994312286, -0.04056471213698387, -0.02206679992377758, -0.023325154557824135, 0.004980265162885189, 0.009474756196141243, -0.0006830067140981555, 0.04967007040977478, 0.057187628000974655, 0.002573450328782201, -0.03314691409468651, -0.025061214342713356, 0.03989912196993828, 0.012321216985583305, -0.07128360122442245, 0.01204202976077795, -0.005999956279993057, -0.02806002087891102, 0.020130999386310577, -0.00462702801451087, 0.0004353166732471436, -0.006521238945424557, 0.03567115217447281, -0.019958140328526497, 0.028102584183216095, 0.04055582731962204, 0.009526747278869152, 0.003619744908064604, -0.0002439589297864586, -0.009947852231562138, 0.030663086101412773, -0.0455036386847496, 0.017080271616578102, 0.005023395176976919, -0.030270548537373543, 0.00614501116797328, 0.027126962319016457, -0.01758526638150215, 0.004043471533805132, 0.005877309944480658, -0.010956685990095139, 0.019497867673635483, -0.002870375057682395, -0.002124243648722768, -0.034629352390766144, -0.01609690673649311, 0.037107307463884354, 0.05041356757283211, -0.016148025169968605, -0.011590084992349148, -0.004412356298416853, -0.03843690827488899, -0.005952322855591774, -0.02328687161207199, 0.018485406413674355, -0.05866827815771103, -0.002984762191772461, -0.02265818789601326, 0.009014850482344627, -0.04444928467273712, -0.013514776714146137, -0.04826662689447403, 0.07987070083618164, -0.01836945116519928, -0.024483617395162582, 0.01158240158110857, -0.019329609349370003, 0.0291729886084795, -0.09002984315156937, 0.04481293633580208, -0.020560208708047867, 0.010157891549170017, -0.00931495614349842, -0.018657442182302475, -0.0017420017393305898, -0.013108263723552227, 0.05170294642448425, 0.009898476302623749, -0.015006585977971554, 0.025805214419960976, 0.016411706805229187, 0.009520739316940308, -0.021048732101917267, 0.0733686313033104, -0.0027980117592960596, 0.0031832833774387836, -0.0037544965744018555, -0.007790513802319765, 0.0011254748096689582, -0.020623309537768364, 0.04401416704058647, -0.032871589064598083, 0.018811563029885292, 0.01830311119556427, -0.024727821350097656, -0.0018123104237020016, 0.03331524878740311, -0.040877677500247955, 0.022875653579831123, 0.0062449611723423, 0.005979730747640133, -0.010198056697845459, 0.004651004448533058, -0.06234037131071091, 0.01658814214169979, -0.014593967236578465, -0.029663417488336563, -0.011962623335421085, 0.008975108154118061, -0.013383869081735611, -0.0714452862739563, 0.02341986820101738, 0.014129847288131714, -0.08023056387901306, -0.0019690855406224728, 0.03150177001953125, 0.027266141027212143, 0.03065415658056736, -0.018145063892006874, 0.021789124235510826, 0.013529393821954727, 0.007511113304644823, 0.027380527928471565, 0.04614679887890816, 0.041590869426727295, 0.027162019163370132, -0.00202242867089808, 0.018628446385264397, -0.04228639602661133, 0.04847897216677666, 0.001175574609078467, 0.058061227202415466, -0.04266846179962158, -0.001118811429478228, 0.0692577064037323, 0.018916985020041466, 0.0014096919912844896, -0.0047655263915658, 0.008852292783558369, 0.03519373759627342, -0.0052805677987635136, -0.026653598994016647, -0.04102277010679245, -0.03912459686398506, -0.014646714553236961, 0.017708027735352516, 0.049983713775873184, 0.02530461922287941, 0.017436355352401733, 0.018296074122190475, -0.03290128335356712, 0.007845984771847725, 0.020903103053569794, -0.006939648184925318, 0.039532385766506195, -0.010299674235284328, 0.003599973628297448, -0.017496267333626747, -0.019346779212355614, -0.008354585617780685, 0.005276908166706562, 0.01877736486494541, 0.008470279164612293, 0.033368270844221115, -0.06789549440145493, -0.040860697627067566, 0.04572198912501335, 0.014529965817928314, -0.055694885551929474, -0.03227635473012924, -0.014192798174917698, 0.006104975938796997, 0.03629101440310478, -0.019328823313117027 ]
<p>I am trying to determine why people ask if a model of a health care risk (for inpatient stay, or acquiring a disease or any outcome) is a population risk model or an individual risk model. This is in a clinical setting where the outcome is some medical event and covariates are personal health history and demographics. The risk here is then the prob(outcome) as determined by some binary classifier.</p> <p>I understand there may be a different emphasis on the way quality of the model is assessed. For an individual risk model it is perhaps more important to have a small variance of an individual's score and this measure is not captured by AUC of the model or other traditional accuracy measures. Is that the main reason for the difference?</p> <p>If the model is created with observations of people's health history so rows in model are people, then is this necessarily an individual risk model? If not why not?</p> <p>Thanks</p>
37,174
[ -0.04840647801756859, -0.024181729182600975, -0.0012943253386765718, -0.029788462445139885, 0.025763699784874916, -0.010228590108454227, -0.024168476462364197, 0.02000330574810505, 0.034602418541908264, -0.016925528645515442, 0.025159448385238647, 0.03236169368028641, 0.07867229729890823, 0.03796248137950897, -0.010185644961893559, 0.03492380678653717, 0.0029071595054119825, 0.02322809211909771, -0.042562149465084076, 0.009061428718268871, -0.00046713222400285304, 0.008045947179198265, 0.036946482956409454, -0.024944039061665535, -0.010275205597281456, 0.05170673877000809, 0.06311482936143875, -0.03939957544207573, -0.0033088349737226963, 0.034302789717912674, -0.03212876245379448, -0.021134862676262856, -0.013856098987162113, 0.02849334292113781, 0.04404490441083908, 0.022968372330069542, -0.05159573256969452, -0.008059740997850895, -0.014742947183549404, 0.04185033589601517, -0.02767157182097435, -0.05786139518022537, 0.03595060855150223, 0.028670012950897217, -0.028993327170610428, 0.010697966441512108, -0.013080772012472153, -0.016751179471611977, 0.02436019480228424, -0.0349990576505661, 0.013514507561922073, -0.018861273303627968, 0.07128512114286423, 0.022262973710894585, -0.009542912244796753, 0.01880292035639286, 0.047961995005607605, 0.09516911953687668, -0.0021985594648867846, -0.03613428398966789, -0.006681669037789106, 0.002992904745042324, 0.020664051175117493, -0.019684437662363052, -0.0359266996383667, 0.03305737301707268, 0.0059404619969427586, -0.06319814920425415, 0.02018926292657852, 0.017861491069197655, 0.0018302121898159385, 0.0006457559065893292, -0.014485285617411137, -0.0416531004011631, 0.051732052117586136, -0.005083840806037188, -0.023010630160570145, -0.0177628081291914, 0.03399211913347244, 0.02067297324538231, -0.020615793764591217, 0.0029453556053340435, 0.03404008224606514, 0.02872377634048462, -0.013649691827595234, -0.013249346986413002, 0.05608826503157616, -0.01002940721809864, -0.005123562179505825, 0.00445375544950366, -0.014811419881880283, 0.05382420867681503, 0.032911013811826706, -0.012987703084945679, -0.041226960718631744, 0.05415404960513115, -0.007714795880019665, 0.04158095642924309, 0.01159096509218216, 0.00619145855307579, -0.02136235497891903, -0.033960435539484024, -0.009178743697702885, 0.035887815058231354, -0.03944782167673111, -0.021263541653752327, -0.03315988928079605, -0.060113392770290375, -0.011116355657577515, -0.046779174357652664, -0.03839654475450516, -0.0010695835808292031, -0.02178318426012993, -0.01377162802964449, -0.014650202356278896, -0.01578468643128872, 0.008743738755583763, -0.006042227149009705, 0.06361940503120422, 0.04301874339580536, 0.044974636286497116, 0.0018917693523690104, 0.013353229500353336, -0.06560328602790833, -0.04246590659022331, -0.002738082082942128, 0.010592374950647354, -0.01270321849733591, -0.0357154980301857, 0.057245370000600815, 0.0048323702067136765, -0.01458446029573679, 0.0339113213121891, 0.005908846855163574, 0.025229541584849358, -0.025927357375621796, -0.08667407184839249, -0.04277920350432396, -0.010410132817924023, 0.02126544713973999, 0.02162504941225052, -0.016914794221520424, -0.009061954915523529, 0.03602835163474083, 0.0240207277238369, 0.0147865554317832, 0.0595737025141716, 0.03195829316973686, 0.012420769780874252, 0.003505321918055415, -0.021513069048523903, 0.03268308565020561, -0.025555262342095375, 0.013879030011594296, -0.03401801362633705, -0.1166715994477272, 0.015847066417336464, 0.01282707042992115, -0.013992791064083576, -0.02582300640642643, 0.01855960488319397, -0.011169370263814926, 0.033040497452020645, -0.02375771664083004, 0.012673000805079937, 0.001099023618735373, 0.08899634331464767, -0.01660202443599701, 0.041546937078237534, 0.047255758196115494, 0.011574682779610157, 0.013872510753571987, 0.01645827479660511, 0.044184960424900055, 0.03292466327548027, -0.03597560152411461, -0.037163347005844116, -0.018183790147304535, -0.001080406247638166, 0.018247900530695915, -0.05513732135295868, -0.008646747097373009, -0.02699626423418522, -0.014306323602795601, 0.01667916029691696, 0.0009466952178627253, -0.01208348199725151, -0.029615331441164017, 0.05184965580701828, -0.0061786784790456295, -0.044411394745111465, -0.06893347948789597, 0.02130122110247612, -0.0013778683496639132, 0.01856035552918911, 0.013935178518295288, -0.035159047693014145, -0.004701415542513132, 0.005735753104090691, 0.012813168577849865, -0.04925009235739708, 0.002620250452309847, 0.03349243849515915, -0.02756483294069767, 0.051066674292087555, 0.01674431376159191, 0.028968622907996178, -0.012074999511241913, 0.04918229207396507, -0.04748621582984924, -0.06346137821674347, 0.011373713612556458, -0.034627515822649, 0.0323743037879467, -0.018080279231071472, -0.0292485523968935, 0.015333632938563824, -0.03774041682481766, -0.024575375020503998, 0.017216479405760765, -0.03074156865477562, 0.0739203691482544, 0.05398740991950035, -0.017518924549221992, -0.007160480599850416, -0.019020982086658478, -0.013397743925452232, -0.008816098794341087, -0.007358076516538858, -0.007204041350632906, -0.05256221070885658, 0.008279038593173027, 0.036237262189388275, 0.02985605038702488, -0.03394796699285507, 0.012545393779873848, 0.019882896915078163, 0.021217288449406624, 0.004801295232027769, 0.0051357317715883255, 0.009603278711438179, -0.04861607402563095, 0.023735523223876953, 0.039681535214185715, -0.004312700126320124, -0.0035658327396959066, 0.028343815356492996, -0.028452785685658455, 0.04703018069267273, -0.0328015573322773, -0.013896865770220757, 0.059941306710243225, -0.01679939590394497, 0.009397439658641815, -0.010325810872018337, -0.014285080134868622, 0.021189797669649124, -0.027203001081943512, 0.03452993184328079, 0.042160309851169586, -0.016186116263270378, -0.0016645241994410753, 0.006676006596535444, -0.007587951608002186, 0.02387341670691967, 0.08039399981498718, -0.03908553346991539, -0.012003876268863678, 0.013513056561350822, -0.05118684843182564, 0.027383241802453995, 0.0012287673307582736, -0.03682234510779381, -0.017311684787273407, 0.025705792009830475, 0.04110657051205635, -0.018911797553300858, 0.026255523785948753, 0.004710110370069742, -0.04345572739839554, 0.04345860704779625, -0.011051835492253304, 0.015764083713293076, 0.0004952900926582515, -0.0816662386059761, 0.016988586634397507, -0.03147235885262489, -0.008168662898242474, 0.04548183083534241, 0.0004815400461666286, -0.020546184852719307, -0.014045010320842266, 0.013720962218940258, -0.04450669884681702, -0.05538458749651909, -0.03334053233265877, 0.02768872119486332, 0.014394273050129414, -0.029820218682289124, 0.01532039139419794, -0.00844059232622385, -0.029056202620267868, 0.03749362379312515, -0.0319211520254612, -0.006015128456056118, -0.02373220957815647, 0.009626676328480244, 0.037366099655628204, 0.010195618495345116, -0.008258635178208351, 0.036123089492321014, -0.022500479593873024, -0.022126439958810806, -0.07561623305082321, -0.04661368578672409, 0.01881241239607334, -0.017805876210331917, 0.027774710208177567, -0.000255889433901757, -0.00515282666310668, 0.0737282931804657, 0.04154947027564049, -0.027916956692934036, -0.04023240879178047, 0.010680003091692924, -0.05248858034610748, -0.001080935588106513, 0.02353115752339363, 0.03781391307711601, -0.01684880629181862, 0.048959895968437195, -0.0371786467730999, 0.02707822062075138, 0.05088299140334129, -0.0033614591229707003, -0.017358776181936264, 0.014407454058527946, -0.008325030095875263, -0.033116236329078674, 0.03172900900244713, 0.01194218173623085, -0.01896841451525688, -0.009692440740764141, -0.015496558509767056, 0.026472685858607292, 0.009048860520124435, -0.045436400920152664, 0.04001810401678085, -0.044003527611494064, -0.02830767259001732, -0.037783507257699966, 0.00062983063980937, -0.02752656303346157, -0.04915966838598251, -0.011564292944967747, 0.014538011513650417, -0.0036613955162465572, -0.004065024200826883, 0.008860229514539242, 0.02817440591752529, 0.029134197160601616, 0.02476409822702408, 0.02618912048637867, -0.013617304153740406, 0.007859282195568085, 0.020239468663930893, -0.024293964728713036, 0.009495788253843784, 0.020915165543556213, 0.06017151474952698, -0.008188235573470592, -0.05197773873806, -0.049865853041410446, -0.01122534740716219, -0.06885608285665512, -0.017367936670780182, 0.006317737512290478, 0.03204860910773277, 0.023570768535137177, 0.03902461379766464, 0.016673577949404716, -0.06722413748502731, 0.008062055334448814, 0.015538831241428852, -0.023250021040439606, 0.0005961009301245213, 0.009571624919772148, 0.005519979167729616, 0.03246401622891426, -0.025762876495718956, 0.038149554282426834, -0.026568477973341942, -0.020451931282877922, -0.018359877169132233, 0.024022283032536507, 0.0046540540643036366, 0.03471125662326813, 0.013469279743731022, -0.007478183601051569, 0.010191213339567184, -0.0034447351936250925, -0.00540696969255805, -0.011904612183570862, 0.023472515866160393, 0.04808219149708748, 0.016890669241547585, -0.02687128819525242, -0.027541538700461388, -0.010172550566494465, 0.03350912034511566, 0.0467827245593071, 0.025885064154863358, 0.010457875207066536, -0.016819294542074203, 0.02682092785835266, 0.015276843681931496, 0.00920346099883318, 0.02195832133293152, -0.021361758932471275, 0.004132112953811884, -0.06844846904277802, -0.05564272403717041, 0.017957957461476326, -0.0026722766924649477, 0.02682918682694435, 0.011872351169586182, 0.05733804404735565, 0.027075912803411484, -0.044326845556497574, -0.015277006663382053, 0.06423113495111465, -0.0024143606424331665, 0.014239802956581116, 0.0073359450325369835, -0.0017819276545196772, -0.007130283396691084, -0.021306056529283524, 0.046931881457567215, 0.01973189041018486, -0.045405272394418716, 0.00839288905262947, 0.05714670941233635, -0.040037255734205246, -0.03757143393158913, -0.030528206378221512, 0.0004742636810988188, 0.011937752366065979, 0.030745116993784904, -0.0034937537275254726, 0.022586993873119354, 0.022993054240942, 0.07233713567256927, 0.048172254115343094, 0.025046000257134438, -0.0916311964392662, -0.010131090879440308, 0.021157821640372276, 0.022941583767533302, -0.05058281868696213, -0.03499911352992058, -0.029832245782017708, -0.03347839415073395, 0.028939643874764442, -0.0014063019771128893, 0.008116962388157845, 0.014507206156849861, 0.023825811222195625, 0.05059031769633293, -0.05392180383205414, -0.03940783068537712, -0.011006196029484272, 0.0014666402712464333, 0.016472982242703438, -0.038265276700258255, -0.0029755427967756987, -0.04477781057357788, -0.029696686193346977, 0.006680962163954973, 0.05892002210021019, -0.044106822460889816, -0.007324715610593557, 0.009324504062533379, 0.015609262511134148, -0.019150352105498314, -0.06359018385410309, 0.01165947038680315, -0.015938257798552513, -0.001925657968968153, 0.01465797983109951, -0.025083981454372406, -0.038935210555791855, -0.05404191091656685, 0.026116937398910522, -0.006277577485889196, 0.009424721822142601, -0.008981953375041485, 0.016324199736118317, 0.009251812472939491, -0.017001105472445488, 0.05011991411447525, 0.03647873178124428, 0.024788834154605865, -0.031207723543047905, -0.02213241718709469, 0.01975967548787594, -0.014952734112739563, -0.047030575573444366, -0.061090484261512756, -0.023523641750216484, 0.011558383703231812, 0.03504079952836037, 0.030811306089162827, 0.0323355570435524, -0.03502229228615761, -0.013066882267594337, 0.02476499043405056, 0.03386324271559715, 0.004908320493996143, 0.007438193541020155, -0.004398757591843605, 0.01122425589710474, -0.0003131605335511267, -0.01817283406853676, 0.008015872910618782, -0.04215722158551216, 0.014680649153888226, 0.007509511895477772, -0.0425911508500576, -0.012496918439865112, -0.012838254682719707, -0.06597983092069626, 0.002249360317364335, -0.017100824043154716, 0.014556004665791988, 0.006725659128278494, 0.05597960576415062, -0.021130241453647614, -0.04411911964416504, -0.022133775055408478, -0.02228286676108837, 0.001594799803569913, 0.04546107351779938, 0.010845111683011055, 0.02561115473508835, -0.02431836910545826, -0.0024697829503566027, -0.06000382825732231, -0.030567636713385582, 0.019072093069553375, 0.0135057233273983, -0.021542970091104507, -0.006040614098310471, 0.03947988152503967, -0.029107244685292244, -0.025150030851364136, -0.038824886083602905, 0.06093218922615051, -0.03802487999200821, -0.011247836984694004, 0.016206437721848488, 0.0012750177411362529, 0.060581009835004807, 0.029281798750162125, -0.00017006239795591682, 0.0470515601336956, -0.036927077919244766, 0.014543326571583748, -0.0232089776545763, 0.004101114813238382, -0.03133358433842659, -0.0183000098913908, -0.035638563334941864, -0.0406920500099659, 0.04104425385594368, -0.009591629728674889, -0.020695755258202553, 0.01176564022898674, -0.016330702230334282, 0.003054889850318432, 0.010092148557305336, 0.018270842730998993, -0.035184040665626526, 0.02449369803071022, -0.03357440605759621, 0.02807517722249031, 0.01334386132657528, 0.00842512957751751, 0.054161038249731064, 0.008820801973342896, -0.03135203570127487, 0.033028263598680496, 0.0310503076761961, -0.024406468495726585, 0.002540252171456814, 0.014296784065663815, -0.03381327539682388, 0.030305439606308937, 0.012721980921924114, 0.009394190274178982, 0.025649502873420715, 0.04088760167360306, -0.016702942550182343, -0.02802315540611744, -0.027168845757842064, 0.024554580450057983, 0.03958714380860329, -0.007353879511356354, 0.01979820802807808, 0.011292028240859509, 0.005122020374983549, -0.022179635241627693, -0.03848894685506821, -0.0006322524859569967, 0.04272656887769699, -0.02004900947213173, 0.05849917605519295, -0.06275999546051025, -0.022090449929237366, 0.032026901841163635, 0.015650423243641853, 0.00850666780024767, 0.037940580397844315, 0.010570939630270004, 0.00436423672363162, 0.020405007526278496, 0.00873760785907507, -0.026957962661981583, 0.04854477941989899, -0.03185724467039108, -0.021437088027596474, -0.03166509047150612, -0.012872911989688873, 0.04239402338862419, 0.019234709441661835, -0.010569487698376179, -0.035630691796541214, 0.016569709405303, -0.031082918867468834, 0.022564401850104332, 0.011640847660601139, -0.006745018530637026, 0.024653958156704903, -0.037828657776117325, 0.020230382680892944, -0.011113051325082779, -0.0009473738609813154, -0.00006165743980091065, -0.11271915584802628, -0.03419525548815727, -0.004746509250253439, -0.05891202762722969, -0.0003579772310331464, 0.02217090129852295, -0.027897575870156288, -0.014206340536475182, -0.03255279362201691, 0.003439618507400155, -0.005056255497038364, 0.03584809601306915, -0.015378935262560844, 0.05892151966691017, 0.0010597725631669164, -0.013617015443742275, -0.022866150364279747, 0.023287463933229446, 0.13008546829223633, 0.08240942656993866, 0.06324148923158646, -0.055576078593730927, 0.007333969697356224, -0.0006687365239486098, 0.02067047543823719, 0.019559862092137337, 0.020143527537584305, 0.04444456100463867, -0.014036460779607296, 0.08944852650165558, 0.023449964821338654, 0.04813675582408905, -0.018750345334410667, 0.044612422585487366, -0.04160582274198532, 0.007329192478209734, 0.008746755309402943, -0.0015108472434803843, -0.011793951503932476, 0.011259550228714943, 0.004229716025292873, -0.009906253777444363, 0.03994634374976158, -0.014644863083958626, -0.026465196162462234, 0.03733860328793526, -0.022853706032037735, 0.021006612107157707, -0.017595995217561722, 0.01287272572517395, -0.004620117601007223, 0.028235718607902527, -0.020995359867811203, -0.0086131626740098, -0.005041166208684444, -0.03275420144200325, -0.004273699130862951, 0.013326205313205719, -0.046284642070531845, -0.012586265802383423, -0.0061513688415288925, 0.0171518474817276, -0.05241711065173149, -0.043490804731845856, -0.016726359724998474, 0.03641264885663986, -0.01990385726094246, 0.012848591431975365, -0.04913065955042839, -0.01825554296374321, -0.008448868058621883, -0.03319617360830307, -0.05795958638191223, -0.012146467342972755, 0.025470560416579247, -0.018870534375309944, -0.01882842741906643, -0.027527280151844025, 0.022832391783595085, -0.014914012514054775, 0.04567080736160278, 0.02798927202820778, -0.07674096524715424, -0.032029833644628525, -0.027738479897379875, -0.005677677690982819, -0.000517930428031832, 0.06150801107287407, 0.015580425970256329, 0.03399116173386574, -0.03469778597354889, -0.013106077909469604, 0.014655709266662598, -0.0006712937029078603, 0.02053738944232464, 0.011721748858690262, 0.034654416143894196, 0.006622036918997765, -0.01879471354186535, 0.005982700269669294, -0.012066276744008064, -0.010508543811738491, -0.04885219782590866, 0.017571700736880302, 0.0006330066244117916, 0.03202075511217117, -0.0026908647269010544, 0.03427595645189285, -0.004823294933885336, 0.046610377728939056, -0.029373111203312874, -0.04059272259473801, 0.007335432339459658, 0.03731177747249603, -0.031659457832574844, 0.016150088980793953, 0.0025814941618591547, 0.051362235099077225, 0.021281447261571884, 0.02058650553226471, -0.029026789590716362, 0.03971400484442711, 0.010949238203465939, 0.027844039723277092, 0.020062943920493126, -0.0521233007311821, 0.004574488382786512, 0.01050487905740738, 0.026500636711716652, -0.03474223241209984, -0.02788349986076355, -0.021020988002419472, -0.019950274378061295, 0.005880478769540787, 0.016401760280132294, -0.03945692628622055, 0.0159183070063591, -0.003314513713121414, 0.0380462221801281, 0.011882844381034374, -0.02783028967678547, -0.04340576007962227, -0.00650261715054512, 0.04654143005609512, -0.03776335343718529, 0.0008675329736433923, 0.005264337174594402, 0.004512919578701258, -0.021555984392762184, 0.0069777402095496655, 0.02580583654344082, -0.015825241804122925, 0.024108316749334335, 0.0019138933857902884, 0.016792621463537216, 0.05593319609761238, -0.007185755297541618, 0.0055873035453259945, 0.05291716754436493, -0.04998759925365448, 0.003930818289518356, 0.02890225127339363, 0.004381499253213406, 0.012305794283747673, 0.023816902190446854, 0.030271731317043304, 0.013296207413077354, 0.03906065598130226, -0.039848003536462784, -0.03419571369886398, -0.028634801506996155, 0.03006337210536003, -0.0348353274166584, 0.006364044267684221, -0.0019336979603394866, 0.0006013544043526053, -0.010587853379547596, 0.02227887138724327, 0.0331338606774807, 0.023077983409166336, -0.013838707469403744, -0.013132112100720406, 0.00591157004237175, 0.01792287267744541, 0.0001980352826649323, 0.04278120398521423, 0.008916046470403671, 0.003976669628173113, -0.022203493863344193, 0.037690114229917526, -0.003965514246374369, 0.008972322568297386, -0.07792750746011734, -0.03613637015223503, 0.003489761846140027, 0.0275375097990036, 0.002660908503457904, -0.037321217358112335, -0.029208041727542877, 0.010858071967959404, -0.030158011242747307, 0.025707384571433067, 0.050555650144815445, 0.022712480276823044, -0.018107106909155846, -0.012519286014139652, -0.05754833668470383, 0.02563377283513546, -0.002930193906649947, 0.012866243720054626, 0.0322100967168808, 0.03689981997013092, 0.012829582206904888, -0.013875105418264866, -0.03488840162754059, 0.030337868258357048, 0.009960701689124107, -0.03268435224890709, 0.04012984782457352, -0.026337789371609688, -0.04343566298484802, 0.007877238094806671, -0.015213463455438614, 0.015302842482924461, 0.05508825182914734, 0.01948661543428898, 0.04228818044066429, 0.017007483169436455, 0.057370640337467194, -0.03582872450351715, -0.023358704522252083, 0.007553534582257271, 0.010181253775954247, 0.0266104806214571, -0.028367547318339348, 0.01755380630493164, 0.06375899910926819, -0.004039767663925886, -0.035632312297821045, 0.02154558151960373, -0.001807084889151156, -0.03844441846013069, -0.03669397532939911, -0.022959856316447258, 0.04518689587712288, -0.05717089772224426, 0.02845766767859459, -0.02091134339570999, 0.02067267708480358, 0.06246447190642357, 0.022321496158838272, 0.003581339493393898, -0.014674591831862926, -0.016691317781805992, -0.048531170934438705, 0.058231499046087265, 0.003925957717001438, -0.043752871453762054, -0.03170281648635864, -0.015098778530955315, -0.042437609285116196, -0.024279814213514328, -0.005304403603076935, 0.021903036162257195, -0.03235488012433052, 0.019317613914608955, -0.02203095145523548, 0.034836672246456146, 0.019771859049797058, 0.01658451184630394, -0.013393720611929893, -0.06975510716438293, 0.05912681296467781, -0.004343200474977493, -0.016438134014606476, -0.051096029579639435, -0.008036704733967781, -0.052085597068071365, 0.014107044786214828, 0.070319265127182, 0.038036130368709564, -0.017090938985347748, -0.004836440552026033, 0.026278268545866013, -0.001597841503098607, -0.008074079640209675, 0.04276645556092262, -0.024343302473425865, -0.000527025549672544, -0.027729099616408348, 0.0035840177442878485, 0.01805797964334488, 0.03001447208225727, 0.026679543778300285, -0.05887266620993614, 0.014916740357875824, 0.0003164458030369133, 0.013265675865113735, 0.01030130684375763, 0.0073076155968010426, -0.01973065547645092, 0.0632709488272667, 0.00433480367064476, 0.007959130220115185, 0.021409645676612854, -0.022831778973340988, -0.04304235801100731, 0.01894284226000309, 0.0005361781804822385, -0.03245047852396965, 0.006897175218909979, 0.04657956585288048, -0.02298658899962902, -0.03938591107726097, 0.018650099635124207, 0.03558358922600746, -0.060406412929296494, -0.006682397797703743, 0.024107888340950012, 0.03173014894127846, 0.042360104620456696, -0.0166240856051445, 0.02852875180542469, 0.03149928152561188, -0.01862744800746441, -0.0075536188669502735, 0.02280694805085659, 0.08200419694185257, -0.009318362921476364, 0.03250126913189888, 0.05105040222406387, -0.020510230213403702, 0.007811721879988909, -0.01033095270395279, 0.02260032296180725, -0.025647146627306938, 0.0003300656098872423, 0.0073613366112113, -0.008018036372959614, 0.028448428958654404, 0.04339994490146637, -0.029874108731746674, 0.04786447063088417, -0.016197092831134796, -0.008136766031384468, -0.03533552214503288, 0.02970568649470806, -0.011423630639910698, -0.040714018046855927, 0.06261859089136124, 0.047619666904211044, 0.03559619188308716, -0.006287570111453533, -0.03441181406378746, -0.017747623845934868, 0.028733300045132637, -0.0067787012085318565, 0.011724790558218956, 0.0014064613496884704, -0.002479689195752144, -0.045110203325748444, -0.028047718107700348, 0.006333949975669384, -0.0018473922973498702, 0.023394307121634483, 0.027905451133847237, 0.052496980875730515, 0.01229949202388525, -0.024101417511701584, -0.01561735849827528, 0.05660955607891083, -0.07944514602422714, -0.01943502575159073, -0.05837152898311615, 0.010212217457592487, 0.022438693791627884, -0.022745735943317413 ]
<p>Following cardiac surgery, patients are encouraged to exercise regularly (assume that regular exercise is defined as exercising on 3 or more days per week). A physician suspects that patients exercise regularly immediately following cardiac surgery but tend to reduce, even stop exercising completely, over time. An investigation is planned to estimate the mean number of weeks that patients exercise regularly following cardiac surgery. Assume that the standard deviation (s.d) in the number of weeks cardiac patients exercise regularly following surgery is 6.3 weeks.</p> <p>(a) If a sample of 40 cardiac patients is followed, and the number of weeks in which each patient exercised regularly is recorded, what is the probability that the sample mean will be no more than 1 week higher than the true mean?</p> <p>Under central limit therom, </p> <pre><code>standard error = s.d./sqrt(n) = 6.3/sqrt(40) = 0.99 X = true mean + 1 Z = (X - true mean) / 0.99 = (true mean + 1 = true mean) / 0.99 = 1/0.99 </code></pre> <p>(b) Find the probability that the sample mean is at least two weeks less than the true mean for a sample of 40 cardiac patients.</p> <pre><code>X = true mean - 2 Z = (X - true mean) / 0.99 = (true mean -2 - true mean) / 0.99 = -2/0.99 </code></pre> <p>(c) If the sample is increased to 100 cardiac patients, what is the probability that the sample mean will be no more than 1 week higher than the true mean?</p> <p>same as question Can anyone help me check my answers to see whether is correct or not? Please correct and explain if wrong...</p>
37,175
[ -0.026464782655239105, -0.0527554489672184, -0.01946420595049858, -0.0010722060687839985, 0.06977411359548569, 0.004112837836146355, 0.03971497714519501, -0.043944064527750015, 0.01221202127635479, -0.038379374891519547, 0.06502789258956909, 0.03370046243071556, 0.031320128589868546, 0.032114963978528976, 0.027426913380622864, -0.030603621155023575, -0.03834344446659088, -0.030841106548905373, 0.002112393733114004, -0.03163853660225868, -0.033207353204488754, -0.007607686333358288, 0.011535517871379852, 0.008420339785516262, -0.05055656284093857, 0.016694700345396996, 0.029165733605623245, 0.000017905016648001038, -0.015590659342706203, 0.05808733403682709, -0.05238623172044754, -0.02210855484008789, 0.008458751253783703, 0.0035855150781571865, 0.013431455008685589, 0.02583140879869461, -0.02402370236814022, -0.005649079103022814, -0.01766631007194519, 0.01583811827003956, -0.010578966699540615, 0.03355387970805168, -0.0003835327224805951, 0.019820772111415863, 0.03233734890818596, 0.023722544312477112, -0.031036071479320526, -0.01443423330783844, 0.05193447694182396, -0.0067632864229381084, 0.06428243964910507, -0.018626168370246887, 0.047536324709653854, 0.016037266701459885, -0.011726496741175652, -0.01538489107042551, 0.016838228330016136, 0.08093887567520142, 0.018473653122782707, -0.05445174500346184, -0.006306614726781845, -0.025532102212309837, -0.011490140110254288, -0.0041831559501588345, -0.04541284590959549, -0.02736041694879532, -0.04249066859483719, -0.029432235285639763, 0.027965079993009567, -0.01043339166790247, 0.04968718811869621, 0.02157626859843731, 0.0014556455425918102, -0.03590421751141548, 0.03911289945244789, -0.05704754963517189, 0.0012021625880151987, 0.004717440344393253, 0.01387614943087101, 0.016506008803844452, 0.0065846131183207035, -0.013552157208323479, 0.022540153935551643, 0.05571398511528969, 0.014465568587183952, -0.039360176771879196, 0.06679486483335495, 0.000025603285394026898, 0.03418629243969917, 0.022467229515314102, 0.02209930494427681, -0.012579519301652908, 0.00811594258993864, -0.03081309050321579, -0.012538638897240162, 0.06799551099538803, -0.018442971631884575, 0.06256794929504395, 0.0062586539424955845, -0.011334700509905815, -0.009323840029537678, -0.05409760773181915, 0.03243269771337509, 0.03350459411740303, -0.04772412031888962, -0.00681031309068203, -0.042939692735672, 0.010547631420195103, 0.008234295062720776, 0.0008863898110575974, 0.0029242991004139185, 0.008237602189183235, 0.009590686298906803, -0.007312217727303505, 0.009294940158724785, 0.02234220691025257, -0.008296625688672066, -0.027214525267481804, 0.030131541192531586, 0.058573707938194275, 0.05926159396767616, -0.008938362821936607, 0.013262408785521984, -0.021355917677283287, -0.0440259613096714, -0.0003852515364997089, 0.013708156533539295, -0.012581649236381054, -0.03359537944197655, 0.0557449646294117, 0.013125038705766201, 0.012768098153173923, 0.001463851542212069, 0.03184686601161957, 0.014095136895775795, 0.003222700674086809, -0.07553118467330933, -0.05980813130736351, 0.02004498988389969, -0.0022442592307925224, 0.008424598723649979, -0.06522209942340851, 0.0016596842324361205, 0.03690623864531517, 0.05282912775874138, 0.013101414777338505, 0.028420422226190567, 0.017229299992322922, 0.012980657629668713, -0.0041886186227202415, -0.035665664821863174, 0.008525031618773937, -0.018954697996377945, -0.028123626485466957, -0.0073354607447981834, -0.08676353096961975, 0.005626109894365072, -0.01792711205780506, -0.006388763431459665, -0.07332363724708557, -0.015103811398148537, -0.03641611337661743, 0.0015941503224894404, -0.057514939457178116, -0.008954479359090328, -0.026492131873965263, 0.08561582118272781, -0.010595880448818207, 0.026130568236112595, 0.013021823950111866, 0.04102072864770889, 0.01800035871565342, 0.011985194869339466, 0.014517267234623432, 0.07171881198883057, -0.01391688548028469, 0.0217641182243824, -0.024100029841065407, 0.0343971811234951, 0.025816181674599648, -0.014100373722612858, -0.0009369964827783406, -0.025951657444238663, -0.004531342536211014, 0.0168231800198555, 0.04051080346107483, 0.02437327615916729, -0.02759346179664135, 0.040331847965717316, -0.03050384670495987, -0.009741120040416718, -0.08402428030967712, 0.02701946534216404, -0.005504739470779896, -0.033274076879024506, -0.009337990544736385, -0.013724139891564846, 0.025642314925789833, -0.007785817142575979, -0.010837714187800884, -0.0018315644701942801, -0.0009227878763340414, 0.06728342175483704, -0.046819258481264114, 0.015707166865468025, 0.0431731753051281, 0.03471636772155762, -0.00886024720966816, 0.05523928627371788, -0.03469454497098923, -0.01371789537370205, 0.0050086514092981815, -0.030631598085165024, -0.020927757024765015, -0.004636639263480902, -0.023773163557052612, 0.029862139374017715, 0.018266985192894936, -0.014757070690393448, 0.02225961908698082, -0.06077229604125023, 0.047061987221241, 0.040890444070100784, 0.016038604080677032, 0.015128002502024174, 0.019643275067210197, 0.0028741233982145786, 0.011941064149141312, -0.004176162648946047, -0.016268042847514153, -0.04294871166348457, -0.017638344317674637, 0.026133637875318527, 0.021649189293384552, -0.02386484481394291, 0.026300042867660522, 0.061834145337343216, -0.03916558623313904, 0.018970152363181114, 0.013537555932998657, -0.002061625011265278, -0.012090347707271576, -0.011542919091880322, 0.03911837935447693, 0.02093060314655304, 0.01801927387714386, 0.005633040331304073, 0.02048289030790329, -0.0037538520991802216, 0.007943063043057919, 0.023315981030464172, 0.050666917115449905, 0.012497655116021633, 0.009507261216640472, -0.015294200740754604, -0.03136533498764038, 0.05967266112565994, 0.016024192795157433, 0.003228184301406145, 0.005945585202425718, -0.004154890775680542, 0.004338055849075317, 0.026216348633170128, -0.0480722151696682, 0.005324268247932196, 0.045996278524398804, -0.030057357624173164, -0.0031149324495345354, 0.01885838806629181, 0.0039402637630701065, -0.014834235422313213, -0.05610192194581032, -0.02531586028635502, -0.03667869418859482, -0.01090360339730978, 0.03789675608277321, 0.01620998978614807, 0.0437750481069088, -0.0015357151860371232, -0.016283230856060982, -0.01584685407578945, -0.029159165918827057, 0.028910839930176735, -0.014721968211233616, -0.08577552437782288, 0.014747386798262596, 0.012780838645994663, -0.03584608808159828, 0.001198246143758297, -0.009168621152639389, -0.01956024020910263, 0.04834926128387451, 0.008963976055383682, -0.05357809737324715, 0.009970240294933319, 0.0014368300326168537, 0.0028678812086582184, 0.0023422648664563894, -0.01728944666683674, 0.06949906796216965, 0.03700841963291168, -0.023987704887986183, 0.06163423880934715, -0.04661887139081955, -0.00463331351056695, -0.06618478149175644, 0.0011220418382436037, 0.011344145983457565, 0.014744454063475132, 0.008706113323569298, 0.008191383443772793, -0.01533760316669941, 0.01756998524069786, -0.0695725679397583, -0.04465958848595619, -0.011558441445231438, -0.02445611171424389, 0.024994084611535072, -0.011733236722648144, 0.02133079059422016, 0.07275670021772385, 0.026603467762470245, -0.017535770311951637, -0.0010178657248616219, 0.0010545030236244202, 0.0017481883987784386, -0.029357681050896645, 0.021432911977171898, 0.029523828998208046, -0.024666694924235344, -0.0020345356315374374, 0.008575605228543282, 0.012447014451026917, 0.03880569338798523, 0.03308407962322235, -0.0018996282014995813, -0.0008960366831161082, 0.032839808613061905, -0.019516557455062866, 0.05923564359545708, 0.011149397119879723, -0.0470627136528492, -0.01634492166340351, -0.014636019244790077, 0.03804758936166763, -0.00471907202154398, -0.050823669880628586, 0.016054833307862282, -0.03549143671989441, 0.036940883845090866, -0.020113561302423477, 0.04498650133609772, 0.028328364714980125, -0.05009913071990013, 0.01440280582755804, -0.0233891811221838, 0.03833528980612755, -0.030691759660840034, 0.012432880699634552, 0.06062162294983864, 0.024502592161297798, -0.048857465386390686, -0.0011425617849454284, -0.03226616606116295, 0.016065126284956932, 0.02806798182427883, -0.057245802134275436, -0.04350656270980835, 0.027888452634215355, 0.059977009892463684, 0.0545201413333416, -0.0006139017059467733, 0.005025532562285662, 0.016152778640389442, -0.0769646167755127, -0.010589550249278545, -0.02182738110423088, 0.07850445806980133, 0.012571850791573524, 0.03662465885281563, 0.03958458825945854, -0.02663743868470192, 0.004388315603137016, 0.029793810099363327, -0.07913625240325928, 0.03869734704494476, 0.001617754460312426, -0.03217616304755211, 0.01065751537680626, -0.03398388251662254, 0.019095083698630333, -0.0036151641979813576, 0.03911074995994568, -0.0014009802835062146, 0.014536423608660698, -0.05397449806332588, 0.018856536597013474, 0.010309160687029362, -0.009015735238790512, -0.013199526816606522, -0.020441090688109398, 0.053281500935554504, -0.022186964750289917, 0.062206000089645386, 0.014526049606502056, -0.04714814946055412, -0.012289398349821568, 0.00019852587138302624, 0.009429586119949818, 0.0010341411689296365, 0.04302332177758217, 0.013602889142930508, 0.030846724286675453, -0.011087226681411266, 0.005384914577007294, 0.03596503660082817, 0.02913747914135456, 0.04858943074941635, -0.0026264037005603313, -0.020831068977713585, -0.03385930508375168, -0.016562025994062424, 0.00800890102982521, -0.008829374797642231, 0.03418571874499321, 0.009606384672224522, 0.035944290459156036, -0.004369640257209539, -0.07693760842084885, 0.013300973922014236, 0.09491290152072906, 0.014925554394721985, -0.01689356565475464, -0.019478579983115196, -0.015383089892566204, -0.0475299172103405, -0.015932895243167877, 0.05702316761016846, -0.0015905656618997455, 0.029849091544747353, -0.010066141374409199, 0.039962369948625565, 0.007390918210148811, -0.04540116712450981, -0.004425935447216034, 0.026945194229483604, 0.029907891526818275, 0.014712253585457802, -0.02520149014890194, 0.003514146665111184, -0.011995400302112103, 0.03420669957995415, 0.008943997323513031, -0.022150341421365738, -0.06794080138206482, -0.00987962819635868, 0.034685101360082626, 0.08968740701675415, -0.05873820558190346, -0.01744248904287815, -0.05127749964594841, 0.016353828832507133, 0.0205113235861063, -0.050664786249399185, -0.006179272197186947, -0.05416979640722275, 0.015877699479460716, 0.003935186192393303, -0.024815702810883522, -0.07514964044094086, -0.011998246423900127, -0.035928498953580856, -0.00956969615072012, -0.01230028085410595, -0.03162824362516403, -0.02329268865287304, -0.030131153762340546, 0.061144717037677765, 0.06098233908414841, -0.048676226288080215, -0.014835236594080925, -0.009096021763980389, -0.007042992394417524, -0.032823141664266586, -0.058458637446165085, 0.012914284132421017, -0.0012810585321858525, 0.021640462800860405, 0.03630248084664345, -0.007535623386502266, -0.05849333480000496, 0.015481998212635517, 0.015197033993899822, -0.03983498737215996, -0.04044262692332268, -0.04168585687875748, 0.029253177344799042, 0.03764785826206207, -0.010947778820991516, 0.06316583603620529, 0.017343582585453987, -0.04599510133266449, 0.010138914920389652, -0.03542540967464447, -0.017303964123129845, 0.018430186435580254, 0.032738249748945236, -0.038572877645492554, -0.0418299175798893, 0.01113962009549141, 0.026071937754750252, 0.0192131157964468, 0.026495492085814476, -0.026380393654108047, 0.014774557203054428, 0.01896744593977928, 0.0034449698869138956, -0.0076175653375685215, -0.011431267485022545, 0.010695830918848515, 0.00004555732448352501, -0.0035889025311917067, -0.012512939982116222, 0.0072089494206011295, -0.027762925252318382, -0.035040177404880524, 0.026721293106675148, -0.03626434877514839, -0.007036059629172087, -0.006939214654266834, -0.03900318592786789, 0.02694600261747837, -0.04584220424294472, -0.018628772348165512, -0.028578367084264755, 0.03900560736656189, 0.027174746617674828, -0.03784305602312088, -0.01791178248822689, 0.012376460246741772, 0.03761950135231018, -0.03193214535713196, -0.017948035150766373, 0.07766720652580261, 0.028551209717988968, 0.0085020512342453, -0.057610463351011276, -0.017014913260936737, 0.026887260377407074, 0.0063722082413733006, -0.011721421033143997, -0.030435703694820404, 0.011573830619454384, -0.046954527497291565, -0.031037896871566772, -0.035243354737758636, 0.03265366703271866, -0.028636867180466652, -0.0263502337038517, 0.037261784076690674, 0.016676655039191246, 0.06418342143297195, 0.009173315949738026, 0.010188939981162548, 0.019901510328054428, 0.011221456341445446, -0.04337695240974426, 0.005207476206123829, 0.010488852858543396, -0.029803002253174782, 0.009470331482589245, -0.03097551129758358, 0.03437125310301781, 0.04254522547125816, -0.008287807926535606, -0.020936375483870506, -0.011633447371423244, -0.0018344903364777565, 0.005504866596311331, -0.0365985706448555, -0.04455016925930977, -0.015720298513770103, 0.04038147255778313, 0.01644507795572281, 0.020781848579645157, -0.007905159145593643, 0.014653485268354416, -0.008399676531553268, 0.018669376149773598, -0.0049181142821908, 0.0263865627348423, 0.04546010494232178, 0.013044674880802631, 0.01307570468634367, -0.028405215591192245, 0.0043166871182620525, 0.019316572695970535, 0.0014381039654836059, -0.013352731242775917, 0.04016824811697006, 0.0025805910117924213, 0.00019728440383914858, 0.009264020249247551, -0.028147216886281967, 0.006291016470640898, 0.05472315847873688, 0.04007378965616226, 0.053583066910505295, 0.008184586651623249, 0.012284177355468273, -0.022713471204042435, -0.0015263905515894294, -0.015619178302586079, -0.010030031204223633, 0.028506843373179436, 0.03203228861093521, -0.0036332702729851007, -0.005177785642445087, 0.05172555521130562, -0.03593454882502556, 0.01139975618571043, 0.03034243918955326, 0.02987510897219181, -0.0033220313489437103, -0.004402491729706526, -0.015054416842758656, -0.03997184708714485, 0.013729861006140709, -0.0026507133152335882, 0.024300090968608856, -0.03727393597364426, -0.006882478483021259, 0.026079323142766953, 0.015216751024127007, -0.03997577726840973, -0.017295649275183678, 0.0010349112562835217, -0.04725775495171547, -0.04852277413010597, -0.03474688529968262, -0.0033020302653312683, 0.0338481180369854, -0.031174538657069206, 0.012208557687699795, 0.015738576650619507, 0.04060797393321991, -0.03732123225927353, -0.06789016723632812, -0.04779532179236412, 0.007205942180007696, -0.013255474157631397, 0.0852353572845459, 0.01879619061946869, -0.01785195991396904, 0.005846887361258268, -0.03491158410906792, 0.04388795420527458, 0.05893963947892189, 0.025997210294008255, 0.02000436931848526, 0.08563714474439621, 0.014210036024451256, 0.02413255162537098, -0.013829981908202171, -0.0032509041484445333, 0.11433325707912445, 0.08314187079668045, 0.0050030481070280075, -0.047528792172670364, 0.02563890814781189, 0.008910934440791607, 0.02857491374015808, 0.006221647374331951, 0.04967221990227699, 0.01864067278802395, -0.011350185610353947, 0.07300438731908798, 0.02201024629175663, 0.010043805465102196, 0.0025829090736806393, 0.03654175624251366, -0.013867296278476715, -0.05945059284567833, -0.014757818542420864, 0.0010021778289228678, 0.002270044991746545, -0.025210045278072357, 0.00002647595465532504, 0.005444008391350508, 0.018407007679343224, -0.039931025356054306, -0.05339351296424866, 0.0030117712449282408, -0.03079277276992798, 0.013996629975736141, -0.03440914303064346, -0.003802756080403924, 0.0008406036649830639, 0.02094927243888378, -0.017786631360650063, -0.020186372101306915, 0.005388493184000254, -0.03128548339009285, -0.017897866666316986, 0.03865407407283783, 0.020338308066129684, -0.0148472860455513, 0.011933776549994946, 0.05075360834598541, -0.07098086178302765, -0.00433915201574564, -0.032100409269332886, 0.029858674854040146, -0.017873156815767288, -0.008956949226558208, 0.001279307878576219, -0.024976657703518867, -0.021061060950160027, -0.019497256726026535, 0.013652831315994263, 0.021741075441241264, -0.002568802097812295, -0.04419565573334694, -0.0014249110827222466, 0.018875282257795334, 0.0012374436482787132, -0.022928113117814064, 0.00545619148761034, 0.04731893911957741, -0.02452969178557396, -0.024831896647810936, -0.03256816416978836, 0.04000675678253174, -0.05665327236056328, 0.012062027119100094, 0.002051175106316805, 0.01085231825709343, -0.04665239155292511, 0.028060778975486755, 0.015709897503256798, 0.005338260903954506, 0.018470264971256256, -0.012175300158560276, -0.023966919630765915, -0.0009620885830372572, -0.026828326284885406, -0.00037690752651542425, -0.006370997987687588, -0.0003122745838481933, -0.0444507896900177, 0.02651309035718441, -0.006152274087071419, 0.028516152873635292, 0.006844848394393921, 0.010781416669487953, 0.003264616709202528, 0.056464262306690216, -0.006962139625102282, -0.037062034010887146, -0.008656884543597698, -0.011400728486478329, -0.032140325754880905, -0.006648820359259844, 0.0014744576765224338, 0.0831318274140358, 0.034840475767850876, 0.04811842367053032, 0.0029072521720081568, 0.017026342451572418, -0.006247317418456078, 0.008911240845918655, 0.010114353150129318, -0.03713906928896904, -0.024406898766756058, 0.027488326653838158, 0.034736406058073044, -0.03913256525993347, 0.0025916399899870157, -0.03462300822138786, -0.047766536474227905, 0.016674458980560303, -0.004762488882988691, -0.0355253703892231, -0.002092431066557765, -0.023905780166387558, -0.020922092720866203, -0.0033006216399371624, 0.02540893852710724, -0.016629086807370186, -0.01932399347424507, 0.004696024116128683, 0.0037730978801846504, -0.04011757671833038, 0.03284846246242523, -0.02003352716565132, -0.005166932009160519, 0.024844150990247726, -0.03571612387895584, 0.0006037107086740434, 0.009481176733970642, -0.005912680644541979, 0.013565008528530598, 0.025407949462532997, 0.004288260824978352, 0.0007654171786271036, 0.04892564192414284, -0.05647898092865944, 0.0003178464248776436, -0.003126287367194891, 0.02529750019311905, 0.021720299497246742, 0.0020853346213698387, -0.011195119470357895, 0.013495045714080334, 0.005077253095805645, -0.04897221550345421, -0.05515720695257187, -0.01612260192632675, -0.0237720999866724, 0.00947202555835247, 0.00629752641543746, 0.030678391456604004, 0.0008585107862018049, -0.033650439232587814, 0.015222079120576382, 0.06271563470363617, 0.011862196959555149, -0.023904765024781227, -0.011605514213442802, 0.01844821684062481, 0.00721772713586688, 0.011778047308325768, 0.012781507335603237, 0.023017488420009613, 0.047599151730537415, 0.010390820913016796, 0.059863246977329254, -0.0641031488776207, 0.004741643089801073, -0.07541397213935852, -0.04079849272966385, -0.006622901186347008, -0.005065702833235264, 0.020195480436086655, -0.03556546941399574, -0.006069411523640156, 0.005561070516705513, -0.05285995826125145, 0.021100347861647606, -0.028216121718287468, -0.0062324912287294865, -0.016786538064479828, 0.05779445916414261, -0.025213507935404778, 0.0054117427207529545, 0.019870581105351448, 0.010858944617211819, 0.07470068335533142, -0.012090550735592842, 0.019520560279488564, -0.006062300410121679, -0.035546351224184036, 0.006433447822928429, 0.001323246513493359, -0.06183403357863426, -0.013719694688916206, -0.049056049436330795, -0.027364732697606087, 0.003385553602129221, -0.013347025029361248, 0.041319482028484344, 0.011213823221623898, 0.0027708495035767555, 0.01619691774249077, 0.06972023844718933, 0.013941756449639797, 0.03260823339223862, 0.0018845697632059455, -0.0013272396754473448, -0.01211097463965416, 0.0340166836977005, 0.009504558518528938, 0.035149235278367996, 0.027346335351467133, 0.019168898463249207, -0.048933908343315125, 0.011952031403779984, 0.018733706325292587, -0.02040807344019413, 0.0028966551180928946, 0.0006243524258024991, -0.008603217080235481, -0.028916409239172935, 0.006481698248535395, -0.02786579728126526, 0.005151763092726469, 0.013350429013371468, 0.04929408058524132, -0.013667365536093712, 0.039510272443294525, 0.0001702581503195688, -0.005906118545681238, 0.004378326702862978, -0.01843097247183323, -0.02273019403219223, -0.0024863961152732372, -0.018750499933958054, -0.020280392840504646, 0.03218746930360794, -0.02694380283355713, 0.0029124999418854713, -0.027051955461502075, -0.005588195752352476, -0.003650826634839177, 0.02378331683576107, 0.004073694348335266, 0.04583599045872688, 0.023891495540738106, -0.09520841389894485, 0.046215739101171494, -0.01335891056805849, -0.02672833763062954, -0.06315173953771591, -0.006610695738345385, -0.06361403316259384, 0.030770253390073776, 0.04545998200774193, 0.044662464410066605, -0.034581754356622696, -0.028673682361841202, 0.04113798588514328, 0.01768377609550953, -0.05731401965022087, 0.04612898454070091, -0.04869615286588669, -0.015286033973097801, -0.022157853469252586, -0.0016943482914939523, 0.006379997823387384, -0.01311979629099369, 0.002668754430487752, 0.005576706491410732, 0.037734873592853546, 0.00017674436094239354, -0.006297152489423752, 0.008844740688800812, 0.016036972403526306, -0.019275611266493797, 0.0536336749792099, -0.028141086921095848, 0.046954721212387085, 0.05050395801663399, 0.010259222239255905, -0.04479832574725151, 0.03505812585353851, -0.055156249552965164, -0.014011955820024014, 0.019496390596032143, -0.03829290717840195, 0.0053465222008526325, -0.0723615437746048, -0.002117059426382184, 0.013887224718928337, -0.003202669322490692, 0.007864648476243019, 0.0524212047457695, 0.06357110291719437, 0.02061002515256405, -0.03917085379362106, 0.013637379743158817, -0.02290145866572857, -0.013634256087243557, -0.0191404540091753, -0.018862338736653328, 0.004593044053763151, -0.0556771345436573, 0.004023177549242973, 0.043194107711315155, -0.030066700652241707, 0.025875957682728767, 0.01056652795523405, 0.044274214655160904, -0.014634772203862667, -0.00368793704546988, 0.001970387063920498, -0.015169601887464523, -0.005494432989507914, 0.03194841742515564, 0.011287995614111423, 0.015858856961131096, -0.03022902086377144, 0.02567267417907715, -0.028188442811369896, -0.04628894478082657, -0.046887464821338654, 0.024338165298104286, 0.055400315672159195, 0.006145764142274857, 0.01601685956120491, 0.00006803230644436553, 0.05054137110710144, 0.021582914516329765, -0.009721092879772186, 0.02845374308526516, 0.023239044472575188, -0.020668111741542816, -0.03077966719865799, -0.019019421190023422, -0.014442999847233295, -0.00970564503222704, -0.007400691509246826, 0.03783199191093445, 0.04403512924909592, 0.021830465644598007, -0.005889659747481346, -0.015383205376565456, -0.0323282890021801, 0.04500127583742142, -0.029790421947836876, 0.005636246874928474, -0.03588135913014412, -0.02703627198934555, 0.008068527095019817, -0.04820957034826279 ]
<p>First, I need to prove that the distribution of a RV X, where X|lambda ~ Pois(lambda), and lambda ~ gamma(a, B), is a negative binomial. I know that it <em>is</em>, but why negative binomial instead of another 2 parameter distribution? How do I prove negative binomial is the best alternative in the circumstance of an overdispersed Poisson, basically?</p> <p>Then, I have to calculate V(X). I'm wondering if V(X) will help prove that negative binomial is best to use as an alternative in an overdispersed Poisson??</p> <p>I looked at <a href="https://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/37814/poisson-is-to-exponential-as-gamma-poisson-is-to-what/37884#37884?newreg=1c6cfdc8a1ce413489fc9274419b0b2a">this</a> post, and I desperately want to understand @probabilityislogic's math. I am new to notation associated with probability concepts (not <em>that</em> new, though), and I don't know how he/she jumps from line 2 to 3:</p> <blockquote> <p>$λ_i∼Gamma(α,β)$<br> On doing the integration/mixing over λi, you have:<br> $Y_i(t_i)|αβ∼NegBin(α,p_i)$ where $p_i=\frac{t_i}{t_i+β}$</p> </blockquote>
74,329
[ -0.0016546102706342936, -0.04289661720395088, -0.00114968023262918, -0.011328632943332195, 0.03628036007285118, 0.009961878880858421, -0.008174914866685867, 0.015434431843459606, 0.047340985387563705, -0.01998278684914112, 0.03799876570701599, 0.07544414699077606, 0.058554086834192276, 0.018296880647540092, 0.03194987028837204, 0.003173334989696741, 0.005242766812443733, -0.022306246683001518, -0.02808433026075363, -0.01031921710819006, -0.005226881243288517, -0.02801014669239521, 0.01634412258863449, 0.007156319450587034, -0.018097804859280586, 0.02313375286757946, 0.04720417410135269, -0.011311432346701622, -0.007569894660264254, 0.09706979990005493, -0.036222998052835464, -0.0025501481723040342, 0.034811682999134064, 0.024612531065940857, 0.01997343823313713, 0.03278888389468193, -0.04106440022587776, -0.040804699063301086, -0.006552178878337145, 0.03545152768492699, -0.04403100907802582, -0.029161231592297554, 0.005128233227878809, 0.03806530311703682, -0.007909558713436127, 0.03734584152698517, -0.005421468988060951, -0.006671356502920389, 0.01703164540231228, -0.04883694276213646, 0.04775582626461983, 0.015147833153605461, 0.06599509716033936, 0.06277719885110855, 0.025976838544011116, -0.015200876630842686, 0.04640357568860054, 0.050057727843523026, 0.03454219549894333, -0.02796228975057602, -0.011929094791412354, -0.015680842101573944, -0.01604951173067093, -0.0211587306112051, -0.011330541223287582, 0.0001185001092380844, 0.011370081454515457, -0.00868071336299181, 0.024305062368512154, -0.035639163106679916, 0.03691776841878891, -0.003611810738220811, 0.03765566647052765, -0.03474724292755127, -0.00640617311000824, -0.010875580832362175, 0.02205042354762554, 0.011022515594959259, 0.02683834545314312, 0.0358787439763546, 0.005298522766679525, 0.031950343400239944, 0.021720387041568756, 0.04882781580090523, -0.0037272870540618896, -0.03246369585394859, 0.09129530936479568, 0.03700825944542885, 0.022602712735533714, 0.003291996195912361, -0.009066317230463028, 0.019671184942126274, 0.023836567997932434, -0.0037755905650556087, -0.04316134750843048, 0.07198415696620941, -0.01401526015251875, 0.04948973283171654, 0.0328892283141613, -0.028398791328072548, -0.04292836785316467, -0.037171363830566406, 0.026075078174471855, 0.069886714220047, -0.02554512955248356, -0.024047913029789925, -0.021431801840662956, -0.011623319238424301, -0.030131103470921516, -0.034575819969177246, -0.028000926598906517, 0.004920179955661297, 0.032346460968256, -0.01317603699862957, -0.006953957956284285, -0.03069521300494671, 0.035073861479759216, -0.010132545605301857, 0.030810460448265076, 0.06571721285581589, 0.045943185687065125, 0.01374238170683384, 0.04905490577220917, -0.04190748557448387, -0.05132324621081352, 0.0007637324160896242, 0.013653576374053955, 0.02026524394750595, -0.06185978651046753, -0.0015630277339369059, 0.0451488271355629, -0.02650725096464157, 0.06373888999223709, 0.027885522693395615, 0.0131472647190094, -0.023258151486516, -0.09267085790634155, -0.07153737545013428, 0.04327197000384331, -0.009093089029192924, -0.004738619085401297, -0.058135904371738434, -0.011205536313354969, 0.046916112303733826, 0.029712019488215446, -0.025073695927858353, 0.01177824754267931, -0.0035205031745135784, 0.009873741306364536, 0.0034343411680310965, -0.03895989805459976, -0.04364045336842537, -0.03363129496574402, -0.027981087565422058, -0.003206520574167371, -0.09392008930444717, 0.020747419446706772, -0.007065240293741226, -0.027421677485108376, -0.016316007822752, 0.052252210676670074, -0.023190414533019066, 0.012818148359656334, -0.028229352086782455, -0.010754686780273914, -0.023555871099233627, 0.07091113179922104, 0.0033535126131027937, 0.013542371802031994, 0.00007246217137435451, -0.002752186730504036, 0.027186786755919456, -0.004968739114701748, 0.0222182497382164, 0.04150792583823204, -0.03982444107532501, -0.018067125231027603, -0.031232908368110657, 0.010486298240721226, -0.0028798154089599848, -0.028922125697135925, -0.04081299528479576, -0.039272550493478775, -0.0021260224748402834, 0.04337238147854805, 0.0285198912024498, 0.026972457766532898, 0.0357978381216526, 0.04342486709356308, -0.07274243980646133, -0.05483284220099449, -0.05516193434596062, 0.017256760969758034, 0.010281198658049107, -0.03721966966986656, 0.04684508591890335, 0.002922904212027788, -0.0038111850153654814, -0.004783811513334513, 0.014313924126327038, -0.004120388068258762, 0.02301689237356186, 0.04809631407260895, -0.02288757637143135, 0.026059065014123917, 0.0676986500620842, 0.05420496314764023, -0.019450724124908447, 0.03128742799162865, -0.02077026665210724, -0.05869070813059807, 0.0014476609649136662, -0.004885829985141754, 0.024297691881656647, 0.0060822563245892525, -0.038659218698740005, 0.0330803282558918, 0.011567853391170502, -0.013866547495126724, 0.022790653631091118, -0.06955939531326294, 0.04160124063491821, 0.08665602654218674, 0.03492463380098343, 0.015055478550493717, 0.04303702339529991, 0.002230186015367508, 0.018741412088274956, 0.021002380177378654, -0.0206886138767004, -0.027079759165644646, 0.012132279574871063, 0.04327419027686119, 0.013071369379758835, 0.011971715837717056, 0.03818606957793236, 0.02397925592958927, -0.006940270308405161, 0.003019387135282159, 0.03915258124470711, 0.02037857100367546, 0.0130324587225914, 0.01213859859853983, 0.0210722703486681, 0.010351888835430145, 0.007217720150947571, 0.02565842680633068, -0.03780481219291687, 0.037457920610904694, 0.009037789888679981, -0.022534450516104698, 0.04112952575087547, 0.020887358114123344, 0.015673315152525902, -0.017074501141905785, -0.007638269569724798, 0.046076271682977676, 0.004722065757960081, 0.028937293216586113, -0.0007733669481240213, 0.011787718161940575, 0.030643241479992867, 0.019036412239074707, -0.010077341459691525, 0.0052535939030349255, 0.03047209233045578, -0.02929334156215191, 0.0026111069601029158, 0.028603531420230865, -0.050357118248939514, 0.018395883962512016, -0.02759329415857792, -0.00795961357653141, -0.05940990895032883, 0.008342782035470009, 0.009114693850278854, 0.005136862397193909, 0.011136360466480255, -0.04118684306740761, -0.039666835218667984, -0.0286962129175663, 0.023828528821468353, 0.002236084546893835, -0.005945059470832348, -0.031511131674051285, 0.030041994526982307, -0.07276945561170578, 0.0014057449297979474, 0.029521755874156952, -0.019305450841784477, -0.04773170128464699, -0.019918149337172508, -0.019579581916332245, -0.08077844232320786, -0.03447264805436134, 0.013559781946241856, -0.005354453809559345, -0.03650937229394913, -0.03968171775341034, 0.0526224710047245, 0.0122678866609931, -0.046636927872896194, 0.02088478021323681, -0.04731566086411476, -0.0429064966738224, -0.042685285210609436, -0.01617131382226944, 0.054083339869976044, 0.009388274513185024, 0.021549340337514877, 0.006300751119852066, -0.011009457521140575, 0.0072560859844088554, -0.06531067192554474, -0.06123611330986023, -0.012969082221388817, 0.0008902187692001462, 0.03098626807332039, -0.0071169170551002026, -0.029987338930368423, 0.05417924374341965, 0.039365705102682114, 0.002203745301812887, 0.002689364133402705, 0.033030182123184204, -0.035383615642786026, -0.03283204883337021, 0.04701680317521095, 0.01629938930273056, 0.011680073104798794, 0.05252763256430626, 0.016418423503637314, 0.0259601678699255, 0.03145710378885269, 0.017777113243937492, -0.00875393021851778, 0.012979013845324516, 0.0126291923224926, -0.009550405666232109, 0.04755491018295288, -0.006980288308113813, -0.02230079472064972, 0.016250239685177803, -0.016551250591874123, 0.005845974199473858, 0.027094434946775436, -0.04274328052997589, 0.022396303713321686, 0.00931182038038969, 0.00432201474905014, -0.03650914877653122, 0.049519073218107224, 0.024253129959106445, -0.04389282315969467, 0.0071923937648534775, 0.019364774227142334, 0.021586313843727112, -0.04300881177186966, -0.0020273413974791765, 0.026624878868460655, 0.05384194850921631, -0.04831136018037796, -0.03709714487195015, -0.015908334404230118, -0.001205903710797429, 0.010643809102475643, 0.005063384771347046, -0.011964591220021248, 0.03477802500128746, 0.043838273733854294, -0.0005594597314484417, -0.048554692417383194, -0.06039918214082718, -0.030485723167657852, -0.032889582216739655, -0.0020842934027314186, -0.015387550927698612, 0.034300584346055984, 0.011039053089916706, 0.04486577585339546, -0.006508711725473404, -0.0020479869563132524, 0.01119630504399538, -0.015570716932415962, -0.05090424790978432, 0.04376555606722832, 0.002434021094813943, -0.0009565921500325203, -0.008472449146211147, -0.0007435155566781759, 0.06332013756036758, -0.025106817483901978, -0.003679826855659485, -0.0109816063195467, 0.00901633407920599, -0.030489522963762283, -0.012669572606682777, -0.03215130418539047, -0.027085505425930023, 0.0114080049097538, -0.016984401270747185, -0.019665207713842392, -0.015372061170637608, 0.03129520267248154, 0.040809888392686844, -0.004804978147149086, -0.00042830107850022614, -0.003998567815870047, 0.018920594826340675, 0.008989023976027966, 0.009178782813251019, 0.007511451840400696, 0.05206224322319031, -0.01750524714589119, 0.025766165927052498, 0.04248201847076416, 0.05177346616983414, 0.043879855424165726, -0.025488201528787613, 0.012152610346674919, -0.051513005048036575, -0.015425060875713825, 0.0039274804294109344, 0.025007208809256554, 0.02703119069337845, 0.0007158301305025816, 0.06751785427331924, 0.03751764073967934, -0.03342811018228531, 0.023494692519307137, 0.037371646612882614, -0.013903970830142498, 0.03550264611840248, -0.019778678193688393, 0.0012882874580100179, 0.007543517742305994, -0.008973752148449421, -0.012827631086111069, -0.00044364904169924557, -0.02881629951298237, -0.00204674806445837, 0.058300621807575226, -0.032467179000377655, -0.0027877057436853647, 0.0008283872157335281, -0.019550025463104248, -0.0003876107803080231, -0.016888204962015152, -0.03084007278084755, 0.007944975979626179, 0.009078606963157654, 0.031796276569366455, 0.016548074781894684, -0.00690477155148983, -0.05731118097901344, -0.040564898401498795, 0.05067784711718559, 0.05863798409700394, -0.012031340040266514, -0.0006623347289860249, -0.04887823387980461, -0.03965753689408302, 0.016402995213866234, 0.0035185900051146746, 0.009522585198283195, -0.06973995268344879, 0.01041061244904995, -0.025896919891238213, -0.07213663309812546, -0.05518823862075806, 0.02504032850265503, 0.033581290394067764, 0.011041220277547836, 0.0036814541090279818, 0.009804808534681797, -0.022072404623031616, 0.031462687999010086, 0.028163669630885124, 0.08684790879487991, -0.039620012044906616, -0.03454333171248436, 0.01521604135632515, 0.026629861444234848, -0.030868614092469215, -0.09489526599645615, -0.011073245666921139, 0.00922820158302784, 0.005518021993339062, 0.060200851410627365, -0.02981264889240265, -0.08147652447223663, -0.006774712819606066, 0.0292096845805645, -0.0317748486995697, 0.02209179289638996, -0.03334728255867958, 0.046401143074035645, 0.034480784088373184, 0.025941237807273865, 0.04699654132127762, 0.041637830436229706, -0.0021358185913413763, 0.03248323127627373, -0.05133965611457825, -0.00554696936160326, -0.011213961988687515, 0.015116254799067974, -0.04537975415587425, 0.004760377574712038, -0.008148293010890484, 0.027766797691583633, 0.0066964589059352875, 0.0018640512134879827, -0.0322272926568985, -0.04856666177511215, 0.01625138707458973, 0.02467396855354309, 0.003539007855579257, -0.02738138847053051, -0.01832154020667076, -0.027148984372615814, 0.053816333413124084, -0.026109542697668076, 0.025176819413900375, -0.023049985989928246, 0.007761502638459206, 0.035393308848142624, -0.006994972471147776, 0.011686446145176888, -0.02669328637421131, -0.006642168387770653, 0.01361371111124754, -0.04013563320040703, 0.02464398555457592, 0.03350201994180679, -0.01057148352265358, -0.005373323801904917, 0.0027198130264878273, -0.03731188550591469, -0.01284688152372837, -0.03282725811004639, -0.004607748705893755, -0.044152602553367615, 0.03735864534974098, 0.00028233701596036553, -0.034112635999917984, -0.09779554605484009, -0.02558879740536213, 0.008697020821273327, -0.035565029829740524, -0.024971745908260345, -0.053863052278757095, -0.008623858913779259, 0.004757166840136051, -0.036933328956365585, 0.005342742893844843, 0.035452667623758316, -0.006226675119251013, -0.00044296192936599255, -0.007870137691497803, 0.01085848081856966, 0.06383342295885086, -0.027915047481656075, -0.016454406082630157, 0.03469415009021759, -0.0031766665633767843, -0.010036974214017391, 0.03844264894723892, 0.010542872361838818, -0.01865336298942566, -0.013973821885883808, 0.01756090298295021, 0.004806733690202236, -0.005680185277014971, -0.035697098821401596, -0.02485409751534462, -0.007610118016600609, -0.0001840794866438955, 0.013829818926751614, -0.018133385106921196, -0.013710606843233109, 0.025937359780073166, 0.013174830935895443, -0.006056015845388174, 0.02350916713476181, -0.015990905463695526, -0.01723107136785984, 0.049102816730737686, -0.013701141811907291, -0.001436593709513545, 0.025955703109502792, 0.0858297199010849, -0.023865481838583946, 0.03737536445260048, 0.03387849032878876, 0.005478401202708483, 0.04671398550271988, -0.019763605669140816, -0.02311374433338642, 0.029658254235982895, 0.003458252875134349, -0.01330645103007555, -0.0009367672610096633, -0.09327944368124008, 0.02525584027171135, 0.028357261791825294, -0.006110601592808962, 0.03303024172782898, -0.0068059880286455154, 0.004185996484011412, -0.006939926650375128, -0.012118224985897541, -0.021647069603204727, -0.022752152755856514, -0.031232165172696114, 0.03779488429427147, -0.035783592611551285, 0.03200845420360565, 0.014532620087265968, 0.022983258590102196, 0.03468100726604462, 0.019274765625596046, -0.020045874640345573, -0.003596808761358261, 0.0064841024577617645, -0.022046739235520363, -0.056973569095134735, 0.04404241964221001, -0.04155287146568298, 0.0189650971442461, -0.035694655030965805, -0.08077293634414673, 0.050364136695861816, 0.003105941228568554, -0.0035119159147143364, -0.08106587827205658, -0.0018440881976857781, -0.05115135386586189, 0.018494341522455215, 0.04989149421453476, 0.018374232575297356, 0.05622939020395279, -0.032566361129283905, 0.045677460730075836, -0.0082032335922122, 0.020285455510020256, -0.03445432707667351, -0.04774274677038193, -0.04050556570291519, -0.008379746228456497, -0.041674498468637466, 0.010418761521577835, -0.01177713368088007, -0.020449938252568245, 0.008207547478377819, -0.045244064182043076, 0.0157423485070467, 0.015248240903019905, 0.031673114746809006, -0.01808582991361618, 0.07905866205692291, 0.0016637782100588083, 0.0592602901160717, 0.011323191225528717, 0.010959196835756302, 0.12047261744737625, 0.04681845009326935, 0.01486252062022686, -0.03771357610821724, -0.026780294254422188, 0.014941745437681675, 0.036480870097875595, -0.0374186709523201, 0.0037909504026174545, 0.013764342293143272, -0.02139289677143097, 0.021158572286367416, 0.09159748256206512, 0.009212042205035686, -0.013450363650918007, 0.02402191050350666, -0.029820850118994713, -0.02816815860569477, -0.002708510495722294, -0.009450315497815609, -0.0004211893246974796, -0.026209771633148193, -0.06309836357831955, 0.0030873373616486788, -0.013521524146199226, 0.012190123088657856, -0.02442828193306923, -0.026538772508502007, -0.03141126409173012, 0.02452140301465988, -0.0006824263837188482, -0.0046605309471488, 0.04453248158097267, -0.02081099897623062, 0.05845622718334198, -0.010092562064528465, 0.016078263521194458, -0.04683016240596771, 0.028976017609238625, 0.02651328407227993, 0.006229951977729797, -0.029091136530041695, 0.025084510445594788, 0.027948463335633278, -0.05034611374139786, -0.0005608185310848057, -0.002599177183583379, 0.01460674311965704, -0.017578033730387688, 0.011972189880907536, -0.01388996560126543, -0.021433254703879356, -0.007132462691515684, -0.016527190804481506, -0.003166801296174526, 0.02315220981836319, 0.00379326194524765, -0.03405481576919556, -0.010115995071828365, -0.01643606461584568, 0.005441403016448021, 0.015896787866950035, 0.014389392919838428, 0.03330102935433388, -0.04267824813723564, -0.020303508266806602, -0.011554254218935966, 0.07190217822790146, -0.003565882332623005, 0.006420049350708723, -0.03890574723482132, -0.006814859341830015, -0.020465316250920296, -0.019842777401208878, -0.009101638570427895, -0.022562384605407715, 0.02703346498310566, -0.0001122749163187109, 0.011266379617154598, -0.02255459688603878, -0.05662493780255318, 0.007846513763070107, -0.021727249026298523, -0.0041673555970191956, 0.007586288265883923, -0.022204171866178513, -0.0143019650131464, 0.04964825138449669, -0.002050448674708605, 0.003381280926987529, -0.0038214887026697397, 0.07926955074071884, 0.022257525473833084, -0.032782960683107376, -0.02383359707891941, -0.019602831453084946, -0.016664275899529457, -0.0023165589664131403, -0.011747391894459724, 0.0339738167822361, -0.002076687989756465, 0.026146745309233665, 0.01720407046377659, -0.00011359016207279637, -0.016626479104161263, 0.01600523293018341, -0.01899547502398491, -0.03745834529399872, 0.00895418506115675, 0.018395112827420235, -0.0009631534921936691, -0.030565468594431877, -0.015519952401518822, -0.0018656454049050808, -0.012652121484279633, 0.04096090421080589, -0.006106287240982056, -0.05760110169649124, -0.016220737248659134, 0.0024008078034967184, 0.02753998339176178, -0.024711772799491882, 0.018286196514964104, 0.005234616342931986, -0.01593790017068386, -0.033541250973939896, 0.005764451343566179, 0.024740513414144516, 0.010503103956580162, 0.025673775002360344, -0.03488997742533684, 0.01090209186077118, 0.039567042142152786, 0.00948821660131216, -0.009449166245758533, 0.020122598856687546, 0.026230841875076294, 0.026560597121715546, -0.007414399180561304, -0.04059232026338577, 0.07008012384176254, -0.006377665791660547, -0.009662366472184658, 0.025035066530108452, 0.026328379288315773, 0.04295702651143074, -0.0022594390902668238, -0.010839590802788734, -0.04185698181390762, 0.0075315386056900024, -0.015551453456282616, -0.02777305617928505, 0.013626151718199253, -0.040881767868995667, 0.027722550556063652, -0.013914952054619789, 0.008714556694030762, 0.010516353882849216, -0.01803203485906124, 0.0023887003771960735, 0.018105974420905113, -0.020460717380046844, 0.0030581222381442785, 0.0025865898933261633, 0.003213385818526149, 0.07291769236326218, -0.003771895309910178, -0.024336088448762894, 0.024819714948534966, 0.019524697214365005, -0.014567261561751366, 0.03119533509016037, -0.048018503934144974, -0.022501470521092415, -0.06927189230918884, -0.021977480500936508, 0.023681657388806343, -0.010262534022331238, 0.030804205685853958, -0.07672789692878723, 0.01876448467373848, -0.0002772106963675469, -0.026085201650857925, 0.019724387675523758, -0.00022667786106467247, 0.0009240364306606352, -0.03337815776467323, 0.013117439113557339, -0.0237111859023571, 0.03369472548365593, 0.02806815505027771, 0.019655292853713036, 0.02755865640938282, 0.039515458047389984, 0.008841993287205696, -0.05115226283669472, -0.006614708341658115, 0.0021027897018939257, 0.0014364364324137568, -0.0381784625351429, 0.05502955615520477, -0.00364283611997962, -0.00176548573654145, 0.026524515822529793, -0.002276200335472822, -0.0028325445018708706, 0.009244529530405998, 0.04454479366540909, -0.03281814232468605, 0.032277826219797134, 0.06091098114848137, 0.030882099643349648, -0.0031451061367988586, 0.007544385734945536, 0.037911076098680496, 0.03577332943677902, -0.006927581503987312, 0.002371851820498705, 0.022166287526488304, -0.009534488432109356, -0.007116999011486769, 0.03589087724685669, -0.022856229916214943, -0.027870437130331993, -0.016484446823596954, -0.0063976626843214035, -0.009282009676098824, -0.010438079945743084, 0.04634232446551323, -0.022977588698267937, -0.020986340939998627, 0.05897945538163185, 0.014089580625295639, -0.023874176666140556, -0.018974507227540016, 0.0005469341413117945, -0.053425222635269165, 0.002270758617669344, -0.001067807199433446, -0.004975111223757267, -0.03511638566851616, 0.004815693479031324, -0.011410036124289036, 0.00912452396005392, -0.038229603320360184, 0.0008657019352540374, -0.06788033992052078, 0.00981665775179863, 0.006787299644201994, 0.02590649202466011, 0.02339773438870907, -0.026005826890468597, 0.03909144178032875, -0.07867483049631119, 0.024878917261958122, -0.003564357291907072, -0.049693938344717026, -0.04018198698759079, -0.016976548358798027, -0.04680540785193443, -0.01838398538529873, 0.06706158071756363, 0.02001364529132843, 0.003520526923239231, 0.031037529930472374, 0.031950440257787704, 0.017474889755249023, -0.04390769824385643, 0.03470558673143387, -0.040224283933639526, -0.025444740429520607, 0.004257542546838522, -0.01786676049232483, 0.005020866636186838, 0.011672371067106724, 0.011963681317865849, -0.003405478084459901, 0.014269765466451645, -0.0074250176548957825, -0.05773645639419556, 0.017346099019050598, -0.01228396501392126, -0.018187399953603745, 0.06491260230541229, 0.02423464134335518, 0.02827558107674122, -0.0034316894598305225, 0.013309767469763756, -0.06960675865411758, 0.009806833229959011, -0.010176516138017178, -0.036644842475652695, -0.004614276811480522, -0.02408571168780327, 0.006322020664811134, -0.07956770062446594, -0.006071735173463821, 0.0034611192531883717, -0.06498582661151886, -0.013616281561553478, 0.032593078911304474, 0.047229282557964325, 0.0428665392100811, 0.012948866002261639, -0.0007919022464193404, 0.030016008764505386, -0.011039570905268192, -0.021395180374383926, 0.023138703778386116, 0.00553969806060195, -0.03910334035754204, 0.0060289641842246056, 0.03383168578147888, 0.01839386858046055, 0.04724014177918434, 0.01218153815716505, 0.05408412590622902, -0.024463562294840813, 0.005807625595480204, 0.0024022101424634457, -0.01800665445625782, 0.019615843892097473, 0.014112358912825584, 0.015162769705057144, 0.07025373727083206, -0.015210774727165699, 0.03243086114525795, 0.008132508024573326, 0.013030629605054855, -0.025463605299592018, -0.014786791056394577, 0.0322752445936203, 0.01918998546898365, -0.009753333404660225, -0.0128498999401927, -0.0231295358389616, -0.029224932193756104, 0.011728382669389248, -0.037179864943027496, 0.016806848347187042, 0.025600876659154892, -0.011198896914720535, -0.01855613850057125, -0.03871338069438934, 0.00868403073400259, -0.04420977830886841, -0.008537928573787212, 0.01796131208539009, 0.029247179627418518, 0.012237832881510258, -0.0320083349943161, 0.001229323330335319, 0.03385617956519127, -0.030867328867316246, -0.008114690892398357, -0.04860904812812805, -0.036602117121219635, -0.0007128777797333896, -0.01734180748462677 ]
<p>How can I interpret McLeod-Li test results below</p> <pre><code>&gt; McLeod.Li.test(y = data, gof.lag = 12, plot = FALSE)$p.values [1] 7.602866e-09 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 [7] 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 0.000000e+00 </code></pre> <p>And also fitting result .In fitting results, sometimes it says false convergence and sometimes relative function convergence what does it mean?. </p> <pre><code> ***** ESTIMATION WITH ANALYTICAL GRADIENT ***** I INITIAL X(I) D(I) 1 2.654366e+00 1.000e+00 2 5.000000e-02 1.000e+00 3 5.000000e-02 1.000e+00 IT NF F RELDF PRELDF RELDX STPPAR D*STEP NPRELDF 0 1 2.042e+02 1 4 2.041e+02 7.06e-05 2.05e-04 3.0e-03 1.3e+02 1.8e-02 1.30e-02 2 5 2.041e+02 8.08e-05 1.08e-04 2.9e-03 2.0e+00 1.8e-02 6.01e-03 3 6 2.041e+02 1.03e-04 1.03e-04 2.4e-03 2.0e+00 1.8e-02 4.82e-03 4 10 2.037e+02 1.89e-03 1.87e-03 7.1e-02 1.7e-01 3.7e-01 4.86e-03 5 12 2.029e+02 3.77e-03 4.42e-03 1.9e-01 1.9e+00 7.4e-01 5.03e-01 6 15 2.028e+02 6.83e-04 1.23e-03 6.3e-03 4.0e+00 2.6e-02 4.34e-02 7 16 2.028e+02 1.07e-04 1.29e-04 7.5e-03 2.0e+00 2.6e-02 9.17e-03 8 17 2.028e+02 1.47e-04 2.09e-04 1.7e-02 1.9e+00 5.2e-02 5.64e-03 9 18 2.027e+02 1.32e-04 1.68e-04 1.7e-02 1.8e+00 5.2e-02 1.41e-03 10 20 2.027e+02 1.59e-04 2.20e-04 4.3e-02 7.8e-01 1.2e-01 3.48e-04 11 21 2.027e+02 4.71e-05 6.10e-05 2.9e-02 0.0e+00 8.2e-02 6.10e-05 12 22 2.027e+02 1.29e-06 1.37e-06 5.2e-04 0.0e+00 1.8e-03 1.37e-06 13 23 2.027e+02 1.92e-07 5.61e-08 3.6e-04 0.0e+00 9.3e-04 5.61e-08 14 35 2.027e+02 -9.82e-16 1.27e-19 3.3e-15 8.0e+08 9.1e-15 2.68e-10 ***** FALSE CONVERGENCE ***** FUNCTION 2.026871e+02 RELDX 3.290e-15 FUNC. EVALS 35 GRAD. EVALS 14 PRELDF 1.274e-19 NPRELDF 2.677e-10 I FINAL X(I) D(I) G(I) 1 1.240313e+00 1.000e+00 1.250e-03 2 1.234210e-01 1.000e+00 1.351e-05 3 4.425966e-01 1.000e+00 2.553e-03 </code></pre> <p>Another results</p> <pre><code>***** ESTIMATION WITH ANALYTICAL GRADIENT ***** I INITIAL X(I) D(I) 1 3.736575e+00 1.000e+00 2 5.000000e-02 1.000e+00 IT NF F RELDF PRELDF RELDX STPPAR D*STEP NPRELDF 0 1 2.061e+02 1 2 1.764e+02 1.44e-01 1.61e+00 1.3e-01 3.3e+02 1.0e+00 2.69e+02 2 5 1.229e+02 3.03e-01 1.99e-01 3.7e-01 7.8e-01 2.0e+00 1.12e+00 3 7 1.070e+02 1.30e-01 9.76e-02 1.3e-01 3.7e+00 4.0e-01 2.19e+02 4 9 6.528e+01 3.90e-01 3.24e-01 4.3e-01 8.1e+03 8.0e-01 5.81e+03 5 11 5.613e+01 1.40e-01 1.37e-01 1.1e-01 8.8e+00 1.6e-01 3.40e+05 6 13 5.456e+01 2.79e-02 2.88e-02 2.1e-02 3.2e+01 3.2e-02 4.02e+02 7 15 5.217e+01 4.39e-02 4.78e-02 4.3e-02 2.6e+00 6.4e-02 1.08e+02 8 17 5.161e+01 1.07e-02 1.94e-02 3.7e-02 2.6e+00 5.7e-02 6.86e+01 9 18 5.132e+01 5.52e-03 8.37e-03 3.4e-02 2.0e+00 5.7e-02 4.83e+01 10 19 5.129e+01 7.58e-04 4.77e-03 3.0e-02 2.0e+00 5.7e-02 1.14e+01 11 21 5.123e+01 1.02e-03 2.86e-03 1.1e-02 2.0e+00 2.7e-02 5.80e-01 12 22 5.121e+01 3.58e-04 5.08e-04 1.5e-02 2.0e+00 2.7e-02 2.63e-03 13 25 5.121e+01 3.94e-05 6.44e-05 1.3e-03 3.8e+00 2.4e-03 4.69e-02 14 26 5.121e+01 2.55e-05 2.88e-05 1.3e-03 3.1e+00 2.4e-03 1.50e-02 15 27 5.121e+01 2.39e-05 5.20e-05 2.3e-03 2.0e+00 4.8e-03 8.22e-03 16 28 5.121e+01 5.18e-05 1.27e-04 5.4e-03 1.9e+00 9.6e-03 2.78e-03 17 30 5.121e+01 6.65e-06 2.50e-05 1.2e-03 1.8e+00 3.0e-03 8.02e-05 18 31 5.121e+01 4.39e-06 6.27e-06 1.7e-03 1.3e+00 3.0e-03 6.91e-06 19 33 5.121e+01 5.81e-07 2.26e-06 5.6e-04 1.5e+00 1.1e-03 4.17e-06 20 34 5.121e+01 5.53e-07 5.82e-07 2.0e-04 0.0e+00 4.6e-04 5.82e-07 21 35 5.121e+01 3.22e-09 3.35e-09 4.8e-05 0.0e+00 8.6e-05 3.35e-09 22 36 5.121e+01 8.01e-12 8.10e-12 2.4e-06 0.0e+00 4.2e-06 8.10e-12 ***** RELATIVE FUNCTION CONVERGENCE ***** FUNCTION 5.120700e+01 RELDX 2.408e-06 FUNC. EVALS 36 GRAD. EVALS 23 PRELDF 8.103e-12 NPRELDF 8.103e-12 I FINAL X(I) D(I) G(I) 1 2.113519e-01 1.000e+00 1.349e-05 2 8.757729e-01 1.000e+00 2.232e-06 </code></pre>
74,330
[ -0.003925125580281019, 0.014038917608559132, -0.0037742166314274073, -0.00954199768602848, 0.017244957387447357, 0.025395076721906662, -0.020325394347310066, -0.04477964714169502, 0.03134223818778992, -0.05133460462093353, 0.038017574697732925, 0.026622366160154343, 0.04173963889479637, 0.010087202303111553, 0.027652882039546967, 0.012942757457494736, -0.0065897125750780106, 0.016017353162169456, 0.03786272928118706, 0.000025912268029060215, 0.007391763851046562, 0.01459021121263504, -0.001843332196585834, 0.025964336469769478, -0.01243409514427185, 0.026936864480376244, 0.008460640907287598, -0.008962367661297321, -0.027087248861789703, 0.035768453031778336, -0.01942531205713749, -0.01677733100950718, -0.04759761691093445, 0.011218339204788208, 0.005689629819244146, 0.05649382248520851, -0.007322735618799925, -0.02051430009305477, -0.0073516168631613255, 0.05156532675027847, -0.020238664001226425, -0.011706709861755371, 0.016673626378178596, 0.05912359058856964, 0.01991519145667553, -0.0054965754970908165, 0.025065194815397263, 0.012813229113817215, 0.08151886612176895, 0.015768468379974365, 0.06178605183959007, -0.022316349670290947, 0.010994799435138702, -0.01603865437209606, -0.010237446054816246, 0.0015918752178549767, 0.06002698093652725, 0.05830097198486328, -0.018131094053387642, -0.03969477862119675, -0.011455360800027847, -0.019129179418087006, 0.02026718109846115, -0.01693696342408657, -0.011178475804626942, 0.026013126596808434, 0.00783979520201683, -0.029701167717576027, 0.011281009763479233, -0.03949735686182976, 0.02314663492143154, 0.00587068498134613, 0.01594362035393715, -0.03459980711340904, -0.002381920116022229, -0.007451139856129885, -0.0245402492582798, 0.03497221693396568, 0.007244063075631857, 0.02458968199789524, 0.006064667832106352, -0.0017953586066141725, -0.012981430627405643, 0.056024398654699326, 0.01370279211550951, 0.033461764454841614, 0.04525357112288475, -0.012051571160554886, 0.04342277720570564, 0.02822624146938324, 0.03542502224445343, 0.024161504581570625, 0.059980567544698715, 0.0026777656748890877, 0.012905844487249851, 0.030718261376023293, 0.014947288669645786, 0.016846973448991776, -0.017266014590859413, -0.0011979439295828342, -0.013673413544893265, -0.07913167029619217, -0.019708814099431038, 0.005154843907803297, 0.019091764464974403, -0.007243411149829626, -0.010896457359194756, 0.00986417755484581, -0.029635533690452576, -0.032931432127952576, 0.02590097486972809, 0.017526891082525253, 0.0029681387823075056, -0.002726399339735508, 0.0008039302774704993, -0.028458548709750175, -0.019083041697740555, -0.006037220358848572, 0.0398002490401268, 0.0348300077021122, 0.06456536054611206, 0.019703073427081108, -0.00012070615048287436, 0.004616421181708574, -0.059945277869701385, -0.009576471522450447, 0.03106607496738434, -0.017074894160032272, -0.01616007462143898, 0.03427984192967415, 0.0050703976303339005, -0.0060386271215975285, 0.04042958468198776, 0.027561577036976814, 0.04333645477890968, 0.022099878638982773, -0.10277391225099564, -0.0647074431180954, 0.026884248480200768, -0.01433516200631857, 0.03450381010770798, -0.021027754992246628, -0.015627041459083557, 0.022904645651578903, 0.03283471614122391, 0.016015712171792984, 0.029506001621484756, -0.004670913331210613, 0.007286922074854374, 0.003310606349259615, -0.035502150654792786, -0.02361094392836094, -0.01287170685827732, -0.01073333527892828, -0.0255805142223835, -0.047111205756664276, -0.007469621486961842, -0.0028384008910506964, -0.025866413488984108, 0.00011568468471523374, 0.009925161488354206, -0.024850420653820038, -0.015933280810713768, -0.04736488312482834, -0.057123828679323196, -0.02144937589764595, 0.05021202936768532, 0.011591661721467972, -0.009083437733352184, 0.021588463336229324, -0.03905843570828438, 0.05137792229652405, -0.04802543669939041, 0.043413784354925156, 0.01862400956451893, -0.04006195068359375, 0.002844984410330653, -0.049902744591236115, 0.02227100543677807, 0.04201579838991165, -0.07559968531131744, -0.012416026555001736, -0.019158106297254562, -0.022386115044355392, 0.013657349161803722, 0.046018827706575394, -0.00103693176060915, -0.022735705599188805, 0.05738866701722145, -0.07273747771978378, -0.050581108778715134, -0.06414604932069778, -0.015368836000561714, -0.013821475207805634, -0.030277069658041, 0.022025730460882187, -0.005394441541284323, 0.04072851315140724, -0.01079733669757843, -0.01883755810558796, -0.0610567070543766, 0.013910265639424324, 0.01095454953610897, 0.006209032144397497, -0.00515157962217927, 0.05625255033373833, 0.04894452542066574, 0.019410161301493645, 0.04005899652838707, -0.036356501281261444, -0.004486708901822567, 0.03289581090211868, -0.03441992774605751, 0.01460801437497139, 0.013325365260243416, -0.015538671053946018, -0.02281840518116951, 0.001993345795199275, 0.02592027187347412, 0.03116089291870594, -0.0569627545773983, 0.03708089888095856, 0.07135341316461563, 0.016178397461771965, 0.0021765786223113537, -0.005945815239101648, -0.033189497888088226, 0.013172931037843227, -0.029933299869298935, -0.011529362760484219, -0.013756387867033482, -0.028351984918117523, 0.0549011193215847, 0.03588727489113808, -0.026425983756780624, 0.02157754823565483, 0.04700999706983566, -0.015332519076764584, 0.03334282711148262, 0.04713377729058266, -0.011762120760977268, -0.026810340583324432, 0.018063612282276154, 0.01824217103421688, 0.007425125688314438, 0.018034161999821663, 0.024097170680761337, 0.007040638942271471, 0.03748631477355957, -0.04822982847690582, 0.002197721740230918, 0.029074611142277718, 0.002513751620426774, -0.030712159350514412, -0.017817551270127296, 0.0076087662018835545, 0.020177336409687996, -0.0191316120326519, 0.012255962006747723, 0.05338019132614136, 0.010145839303731918, 0.023472536355257034, -0.03386189788579941, -0.04873090237379074, 0.019450243562459946, 0.006176796276122332, -0.025681523606181145, -0.017763212323188782, 0.0024926525074988604, -0.041677381843328476, 0.028165312483906746, -0.06875208765268326, -0.03249191865324974, -0.03184022754430771, -0.012745833955705166, 0.030730372294783592, 0.05997144803404808, -0.012255809269845486, -0.04732837527990341, -0.0010253188665956259, -0.0010150749003514647, -0.000488419842440635, 0.07946798950433731, -0.0019340929575264454, -0.007349411491304636, 0.008621174842119217, -0.010519113391637802, -0.028746958822011948, 0.038313478231430054, 0.028244346380233765, -0.02892252430319786, 0.03372501581907272, -0.011080331169068813, -0.02066483162343502, -0.01787460967898369, -0.006272524129599333, -0.0160356592386961, -0.011492145247757435, -0.01141835656017065, 0.04254322499036789, -0.05454428121447563, -0.01534255314618349, 0.007341356482356787, -0.07971684634685516, 0.021284347400069237, 0.010956790298223495, -0.010649986565113068, -0.025112343952059746, 0.010404447093605995, 0.04102511703968048, 0.008219071663916111, -0.002770234365016222, 0.014661764726042747, -0.03830216825008392, -0.052022941410541534, 0.009755747392773628, 0.004617922008037567, 0.009168348275125027, -0.0039704409427940845, -0.016308682039380074, 0.07962746918201447, 0.018891390413045883, -0.05457655340433121, -0.07150156795978546, 0.016785742715001106, -0.040595799684524536, -0.020418591797351837, 0.037655532360076904, 0.02952597476541996, 0.05216210335493088, 0.03578170761466026, -0.020609311759471893, 0.0692986398935318, 0.05692133679986, -0.027901994064450264, 0.04918088763952255, 0.036356911063194275, 0.007371529005467892, -0.03146383538842201, 0.029514890164136887, 0.03804967552423477, 0.003406212665140629, 0.01373023260384798, -0.029959680512547493, 0.023206552490592003, 0.012857820838689804, -0.017005067318677902, 0.01968405954539776, -0.0020538917742669582, -0.0015070483786985278, -0.03034803457558155, 0.053039368242025375, -0.009142449125647545, -0.032798752188682556, -0.014115349389612675, -0.03360328450798988, 0.03596452251076698, -0.011230620555579662, -0.024381320923566818, 0.016013894230127335, -0.006941388826817274, -0.018133262172341347, 0.040681324899196625, -0.027365675196051598, -0.02208440937101841, 0.02093193307518959, -0.09674825519323349, -0.03725938871502876, 0.03936111554503441, 0.04424744471907616, -0.0009637107141315937, -0.00903548114001751, 0.002422851277515292, -0.003247633809223771, -0.05131330341100693, 0.006248699501156807, 0.0076131499372422695, 0.05070803314447403, 0.040904950350522995, 0.09085605293512344, 0.007838255725800991, -0.007840723730623722, -0.010930508375167847, -0.03403312340378761, -0.05776464566588402, 0.020508332177996635, -0.0033334139734506607, 0.005719732027500868, -0.004731957800686359, -0.03201599419116974, 0.02769763581454754, -0.04674450680613518, 0.039242442697286606, 0.009402566589415073, 0.028631404042243958, -0.013545379042625427, 0.015782281756401062, 0.02921110950410366, 0.006407111417502165, -0.03622974455356598, 0.00723126670345664, 0.04096042737364769, 0.0019981483928859234, 0.032146699726581573, 0.018119007349014282, -0.016734682023525238, -0.029880987480282784, -0.021264804527163506, -0.025154834613204002, 0.03578761965036392, 0.02330816723406315, 0.03835019841790199, 0.012182570993900299, -0.006259507033973932, 0.011718792840838432, 0.014634905382990837, 0.03212737664580345, 0.07538203150033951, -0.022780928760766983, 0.006876473315060139, -0.006571109872311354, -0.025569172576069832, -0.0022482164204120636, 0.012342767789959908, 0.04337887093424797, -0.004619779530912638, 0.03827040642499924, 0.03674298897385597, -0.014997550286352634, -0.0036545386537909508, 0.03244679793715477, 0.03035169281065464, 0.0053676413372159, -0.05518128722906113, -0.01716606505215168, -0.014513103291392326, 0.014618799090385437, 0.05100703611969948, -0.017999785020947456, 0.03147994354367256, -0.01437290944159031, -0.007949470542371273, -0.01943003199994564, -0.02742122858762741, -0.011816649697721004, 0.036180589348077774, 0.018078438937664032, -0.02676427736878395, 0.018485600128769875, 0.0020923330448567867, 0.04064425081014633, 0.04512137174606323, 0.01102322619408369, 0.013100937008857727, -0.09628654271364212, -0.01566670648753643, 0.05161923170089722, 0.05564924702048302, -0.06043625622987747, 0.01637893356382847, -0.03958245366811752, -0.0027824966236948967, 0.0005654670530930161, -0.03999004513025284, 0.010862053371965885, 0.002125880215317011, 0.01924128271639347, -0.04489355906844139, -0.04163621366024017, -0.040685489773750305, -0.004623293410986662, -0.006653815507888794, -0.0017524963477626443, -0.06203711777925491, -0.02650516852736473, -0.023835163563489914, -0.01986340619623661, -0.043126218020915985, 0.03513788804411888, -0.03871680796146393, -0.017147120088338852, 0.03335586190223694, 0.01808863691985607, -0.01021995022892952, -0.031543124467134476, 0.03792177885770798, -0.03412863612174988, 0.020052991807460785, 0.0427580326795578, -0.001894843066111207, -0.04618710279464722, 0.03558206558227539, 0.016480566933751106, -0.003577272407710552, -0.0067832511849701405, 0.0032932881731539965, 0.05683937296271324, 0.027733150869607925, -0.019268488511443138, 0.057204410433769226, -0.003393053775653243, -0.027590470388531685, 0.01022514421492815, -0.054716091603040695, -0.01091689057648182, 0.014095863327383995, 0.013902736827731133, -0.0580180361866951, -0.011975402943789959, 0.03247024118900299, 0.022125333547592163, -0.008500595577061176, 0.006685080472379923, -0.03914441540837288, 0.019317766651511192, 0.04693295806646347, 0.04159476235508919, -0.01946292258799076, -0.011248535476624966, 0.024275416508316994, 0.011544601060450077, 0.012523230165243149, -0.0022618554066866636, 0.013694758526980877, -0.015998588874936104, 0.012315274216234684, 0.028761282563209534, -0.011042676866054535, -0.0321812778711319, 0.007538071367889643, 0.010633374564349651, 0.0422702394425869, -0.043801143765449524, -0.012626821175217628, -0.026177482679486275, -0.01533552911132574, 0.018412990495562553, -0.02389337867498398, 0.007236632052809, 0.019704880192875862, -0.010099200531840324, 0.024562716484069824, -0.001975452061742544, 0.013048353604972363, 0.01366025023162365, 0.008439145050942898, -0.06738859415054321, -0.029864290729165077, 0.037869274616241455, -0.01150918286293745, -0.09261052310466766, -0.03722837194800377, -0.08443552255630493, 0.013949736021459103, 0.021708857268095016, -0.009833134710788727, 0.041974302381277084, -0.047761816531419754, -0.021578747779130936, -0.02258593589067459, 0.012033027596771717, 0.026794422417879105, -0.04281150922179222, 0.03531310707330704, 0.021542733535170555, -0.02878177911043167, -0.0032311351969838142, 0.04618395119905472, -0.018854906782507896, -0.048181723803281784, -0.004091435577720404, -0.02630610764026642, 0.022495634853839874, 0.024004504084587097, -0.004158251918852329, -0.037299994379282, -0.02848253771662712, -0.011425282806158066, 0.03145255148410797, -0.0074419183656573296, -0.013089227490127087, -0.02057942934334278, 0.03578592464327812, 0.013265135698020458, -0.014042826369404793, 0.015728624537587166, -0.03552377223968506, 0.055064648389816284, -0.02779887244105339, -0.03282793238759041, 0.027502628043293953, 0.06872360408306122, -0.06350643932819366, -0.01624058187007904, -0.004300680011510849, -0.008952577598392963, 0.03272645175457001, 0.014353630132973194, 0.02822812646627426, -0.004219592083245516, 0.033924736082553864, -0.05792545527219772, 0.0011156890541315079, -0.047474455088377, -0.000944082043133676, 0.032672494649887085, 0.018029959872364998, 0.04048951342701912, 0.029085585847496986, -0.04767845943570137, -0.004954908508807421, -0.04103121906518936, -0.03446401655673981, -0.0029262115713208914, 0.004964826628565788, 0.057366058230400085, 0.009511095471680164, -0.04571596533060074, 0.03486490994691849, 0.016311153769493103, 0.00029034019098617136, 0.020166130736470222, -0.02597886137664318, -0.006702493876218796, 0.011552666313946247, -0.013224969618022442, -0.03610050678253174, 0.08182936161756516, -0.02964579313993454, 0.040523555129766464, -0.008821921423077583, -0.02914252132177353, 0.05239671841263771, 0.041413333266973495, 0.005943175405263901, -0.08136908710002899, -0.022755960002541542, -0.09703554958105087, 0.009737451560795307, 0.009509888477623463, 0.019239474087953568, 0.004499840550124645, 0.02724337764084339, 0.019114380702376366, 0.0188421830534935, 0.05769278109073639, -0.007859228178858757, -0.05520760640501976, -0.013821982778608799, 0.015729598701000214, -0.0038012356963008642, 0.010813809931278229, -0.028062021359801292, 0.007340405602008104, -0.024494143202900887, -0.01868208684027195, 0.04540172964334488, 0.018566783517599106, 0.018029525876045227, -0.0186320710927248, 0.06478503346443176, -0.004442200995981693, 0.0228356271982193, -0.016731765121221542, -0.05092570558190346, 0.1576164960861206, 0.04029151424765587, 0.020074428990483284, -0.04904378205537796, -0.033632971346378326, 0.02254953794181347, -0.0067083765752613544, 0.010193698108196259, -0.0486687533557415, 0.03356313332915306, -0.019963767379522324, 0.08090762048959732, 0.03017929568886757, 0.02774425968527794, -0.010079002939164639, 0.0366678312420845, -0.05746233090758324, -0.01710371859371662, -0.02650180459022522, 0.014129918068647385, -0.002100282348692417, -0.02083728089928627, -0.01191861741244793, 0.0038645509630441666, -0.014579039998352528, -0.007696197368204594, -0.02216787077486515, -0.015267705544829369, 0.026944691315293312, 0.016485951840877533, -0.03687475249171257, 0.009750796481966972, -0.004279477056115866, 0.002257899148389697, -0.001350647653453052, 0.041160449385643005, 0.031893257051706314, -0.016248460859060287, 0.019515246152877808, 0.04075166583061218, 0.00843028537929058, 0.004924439359456301, -0.03242582455277443, 0.027989724650979042, 0.016713853925466537, -0.005426197778433561, -0.05125219374895096, 0.053198687732219696, 0.008984461426734924, -0.013721014373004436, -0.001752421143464744, 0.0029197658877819777, -0.016435960307717323, -0.0352097824215889, 0.01821253076195717, 0.01062812376767397, -0.011623794212937355, 0.0027018508408218622, -0.011046530678868294, -0.027870353311300278, -0.002095465548336506, 0.014349373988807201, -0.0009234255412593484, 0.04633991792798042, -0.05544856935739517, 0.013886756263673306, -0.06430712342262268, 0.07074932008981705, -0.022927654907107353, 0.03259864076972008, 0.02324795536696911, -0.00772304879501462, -0.02915746159851551, 0.0053732730448246, 0.030561355873942375, -0.001463854219764471, 0.042270828038454056, 0.010876939631998539, -0.028439566493034363, -0.0038694737013429403, -0.054975397884845734, 0.03143676742911339, -0.03582201525568962, 0.008737856522202492, -0.07991649955511093, -0.006276633590459824, 0.05098610743880272, 0.022366296499967575, 0.0467081181704998, 0.023464035242795944, -0.0070637590251863, 0.0693630576133728, -0.006164655555039644, -0.018069671466946602, -0.058122605085372925, 0.008062575943768024, -0.01345059834420681, 0.013725141063332558, -0.02043842151761055, 0.051170580089092255, 0.039916299283504486, -0.020995113998651505, -0.027558812871575356, 0.025328656658530235, -0.017489247024059296, -0.008005318231880665, -0.01891450211405754, -0.013727867975831032, 0.010806016623973846, 0.012934016063809395, -0.028012380003929138, -0.03269393742084503, -0.013971005566418171, -0.05333450436592102, -0.0634690448641777, 0.0023217597045004368, -0.003304005367681384, 0.007018933072686195, 0.012902247719466686, -0.007749214768409729, 0.014734913595020771, -0.013392046093940735, -0.02948397397994995, -0.012060828506946564, -0.02097991481423378, -0.0284346304833889, -0.022523703053593636, -0.006507308688014746, -0.04253276064991951, -0.012641429901123047, -0.018423737958073616, 0.06006065756082535, 0.024434378370642662, -0.010038314387202263, 0.004265655297785997, 0.030242104083299637, 0.0000031778054108144715, 0.014947842806577682, 0.019444463774561882, -0.03341029956936836, 0.003576980670914054, -0.06539192795753479, -0.0763939619064331, 0.023267565295100212, 0.017318399623036385, 0.01672476716339588, -0.005150556098669767, 0.027307817712426186, -0.03281012549996376, 0.005252916365861893, 0.03426213935017586, -0.015908582136034966, -0.007401579059660435, -0.006617788691073656, 0.02896723337471485, -0.04708952084183693, -0.021958529949188232, -0.018284324556589127, 0.020689763128757477, 0.00027225384837947786, 0.027171246707439423, -0.032721273601055145, -0.016169250011444092, -0.003478995058685541, -0.05282050743699074, -0.0010643533896654844, 0.026277529075741768, 0.005789726506918669, 0.03401416167616844, 0.027091870084404945, -0.0114004360511899, -0.0007514593307860196, -0.058097753673791885, -0.0060982233844697475, -0.07069699466228485, 0.002756193047389388, -0.006153645925223827, -0.009246943518519402, -0.0023473757319152355, -0.04737137258052826, 0.00008988871559267864, 0.012660808861255646, -0.04624342545866966, 0.034899018704891205, -0.004050133749842644, 0.01822151243686676, -0.037951577454805374, 0.008305857889354229, -0.015085315331816673, -0.011332272551953793, 0.036995720118284225, 0.05857215076684952, 0.03902637958526611, -0.022772833704948425, 0.0333881601691246, -0.022024711593985558, -0.009075532667338848, 0.0286396611481905, 0.024380533024668694, -0.04377807304263115, 0.003190091112628579, -0.021567178890109062, -0.0008152438094839454, 0.0033823149278759956, 0.013956320472061634, 0.02246054634451866, 0.013759063556790352, 0.021171094849705696, 0.01345888152718544, 0.018421964719891548, 0.017687054350972176, -0.003338515292853117, -0.06653361022472382, -0.0022978479973971844, 0.010038355365395546, 0.013325673528015614, -0.03793815150856972, 0.05255420133471489, 0.017393654212355614, -0.0009663834352977574, -0.03167837858200073, 0.04493742063641548, -0.0005779107450507581, -0.013677219860255718, -0.0009932885877788067, 0.00970077607780695, 0.001016021240502596, -0.03825245797634125, 0.033852797001600266, -0.002091603586450219, -0.006459318101406097, 0.004785012919455767, 0.0630125030875206, -0.02527880296111107, 0.04451679065823555, -0.005283987615257502, -0.01198064349591732, 0.016877448186278343, -0.010597112588584423, 0.0025747991167008877, -0.03969769924879074, -0.005661691073328257, -0.008761628530919552, -0.049619752913713455, -0.0155570013448596, -0.0006342348060570657, -0.044423170387744904, 0.04399136081337929, 0.011565872468054295, -0.02922043763101101, 0.019198307767510414, -0.03135744854807854, 0.032308727502822876, -0.12392158806324005, 0.07635091245174408, -0.001965982373803854, -0.019093526527285576, -0.028345083817839622, -0.021523740142583847, -0.01810571923851967, 0.03190861642360687, 0.027422763407230377, 0.000003009178499269183, -0.008312241174280643, -0.012310962192714214, 0.032930292189121246, 0.008625073358416557, -0.055965159088373184, 0.04731522873044014, -0.03371254727244377, -0.0015134467976167798, -0.006969038862735033, 0.011955497786402702, 0.008496934548020363, 0.03877231106162071, 0.01458678673952818, 0.029129810631275177, 0.011380122974514961, -0.0052153873257339, -0.04854864999651909, 0.031603094190359116, 0.020493175834417343, -0.01431154366582632, 0.03132816404104233, -0.008197477087378502, 0.015365300700068474, 0.01830950751900673, -0.03528300300240517, -0.05551724135875702, 0.013116803951561451, 0.03221258521080017, -0.02746504358947277, 0.0430053249001503, -0.013884107582271099, 0.04106341302394867, -0.04004565626382828, 0.007983549498021603, -0.0009006423642858863, -0.03644246608018875, -0.011171855963766575, 0.039044544100761414, 0.03750200197100639, 0.009098605252802372, -0.0032777225133031607, 0.013215630315244198, -0.007215964142233133, -0.006011738907545805, 0.00886605866253376, 0.004800927359610796, 0.03265906497836113, -0.003529276931658387, 0.054160285741090775, -0.0024248722475022078, -0.023798679932951927, 0.024033263325691223, -0.022925585508346558, 0.050958301872015, 0.00612735515460372, -0.010245081037282944, 0.047908782958984375, -0.016931967809796333, 0.0003389901539776474, 0.014357790350914001, -0.024925876408815384, 0.02850385569036007, -0.0747356116771698, -0.006486605387181044, 0.038251038640737534, 0.013763966038823128, -0.018834460526704788, 0.02227187156677246, -0.00024720263900235295, 0.01822449453175068, 0.003424969967454672, 0.024753093719482422, 0.0006146803498268127, -0.007897955365478992, 0.0004811753751710057, -0.009446115233004093, -0.005152303725481033, 0.0023199650458991528, -0.002217882312834263, 0.029622968286275864, 0.01140913087874651, -0.01816752552986145, -0.030808469280600548, 0.030393175780773163, 0.04656665399670601, 0.0012525995261967182, -0.05803406983613968, -0.0019446974620223045, 0.027512140572071075, 0.041092775762081146, -0.04988528788089752, -0.013397143222391605, 0.002147204941138625, -0.02392963320016861, 0.01896701566874981, -0.0294969342648983 ]
<p>I have a list of objects and their frequencies of occurrence in R</p> <pre><code> Names &lt;- c("a","b","c","d","e") Freq &lt;- c(12,45,67,100,1 ...) </code></pre> <p>I want to rank the prominence of these objects based on the frequency. Is there a way to fit a distribution on the frequencies and weight them to get ranks instead of simply sorting them in descending order?</p>
74,331
[ -0.028883373364806175, -0.037411879748106, -0.011569201946258545, -0.046453025192022324, 0.011981572955846786, -0.015968093648552895, -0.00429935147985816, -0.0012909392826259136, 0.036589205265045166, -0.030422046780586243, 0.04129094257950783, 0.048708707094192505, 0.07756520062685013, 0.03262126073241234, 0.043933697044849396, -0.008019103668630123, -0.0028572401497513056, -0.00007342508615693077, -0.0013689205516129732, 0.012615492567420006, -0.017732897773385048, 0.016802135854959488, 0.045699406415224075, -0.019358228892087936, -0.022088998928666115, 0.04736657813191414, 0.01874011941254139, 0.00007047072722343728, 0.017922937870025635, 0.036164503544569016, -0.07909879833459854, 0.0023743933998048306, 0.031304314732551575, 0.05068688839673996, 0.02816656045615673, 0.026154132559895515, -0.031009292230010033, 0.018470393493771553, -0.05335235968232155, 0.01655646413564682, 0.012038779444992542, -0.05856911838054657, 0.0017157166730612516, 0.037448372691869736, 0.018926488235592842, -0.0021231393329799175, -0.010784347541630268, -0.02674281783401966, 0.030892999842762947, -0.0403989739716053, 0.11379455775022507, -0.01441148016601801, 0.017268717288970947, 0.040144745260477066, -0.040070611983537674, 0.006722965277731419, 0.07418440282344818, 0.04997948184609413, -0.014287413097918034, -0.043693140149116516, -0.02902771718800068, -0.05342226102948189, -0.005556660704314709, -0.020346753299236298, -0.030228102579712868, 0.014824127778410912, -0.019803185015916824, -0.026649564504623413, 0.08610666543245316, 0.010144229047000408, -0.0036842406261712313, 0.04487016052007675, 0.0636797621846199, -0.030383003875613213, 0.014356223866343498, -0.030980395153164864, 0.042462605983018875, -0.0046798959374427795, 0.03644924238324165, 0.033728938549757004, -0.036540839821100235, 0.018688615411520004, -0.02387535572052002, 0.014620024710893631, 0.038781002163887024, -0.005862934980541468, 0.0409964844584465, -0.014584996737539768, 0.017855430021882057, 0.027529913932085037, -0.010789160616695881, -0.030021455138921738, 0.04970639944076538, 0.04411426931619644, -0.03270162642002106, -0.009603992104530334, -0.0022194033954292536, 0.03788692131638527, 0.01563137210905552, -0.0329938568174839, -0.011970925144851208, -0.03835713118314743, 0.023532824590802193, 0.043448153883218765, -0.04018718749284744, -0.024948906153440475, -0.06674940884113312, -0.021714674308896065, -0.026914115995168686, 0.014392472803592682, 0.008708438836038113, 0.007438772823661566, -0.0028772950172424316, -0.009917473420500755, 0.025785312056541443, -0.01798088289797306, -0.01918637380003929, 0.005240889266133308, 0.03698629513382912, 0.03815162554383278, 0.019350610673427582, -0.012986919842660427, 0.034060653299093246, -0.023933611810207367, -0.030670739710330963, -0.019680306315422058, 0.027394792065024376, -0.009573731571435928, -0.005965105723589659, 0.07879314571619034, -0.07015202194452286, -0.005965087562799454, 0.04543478414416313, -0.017454465851187706, -0.0019514374434947968, -0.054464638233184814, -0.07908081263303757, -0.03386763110756874, 0.022236114367842674, -0.03704902529716492, 0.027640309184789658, -0.03652558848261833, 0.003977105021476746, 0.019621044397354126, 0.0002801724476739764, 0.05201416462659836, -0.01027674414217472, 0.030555633828043938, 0.03567485511302948, 0.00042356387712061405, -0.010004378855228424, -0.025624198839068413, 0.0031739724799990654, -0.027565663680434227, -0.021579261869192123, -0.06189972534775734, -0.027564268559217453, -0.00520262960344553, 0.004113764502108097, 0.002731144893914461, 0.027675097808241844, -0.017408866435289383, -0.02574612759053707, -0.04436829686164856, 0.01617157831788063, -0.04059919714927673, 0.025287048891186714, 0.026981228962540627, 0.025367973372340202, -0.0012564572971314192, -0.05074215307831764, 0.008058649487793446, -0.0073045180179178715, 0.030557306483387947, 0.07264819741249084, -0.019793212413787842, 0.0001345168420812115, -0.02073582075536251, 0.037257757037878036, 0.00041818595491349697, -0.015925854444503784, -0.03071659803390503, -0.011789469979703426, -0.020712213590741158, 0.016616325825452805, 0.02623479813337326, -0.0013523378875106573, -0.0039051480125635862, 0.07061251997947693, -0.05134943500161171, -0.003963477909564972, -0.0977785587310791, -0.009516248479485512, 0.006315912120044231, -0.05567381903529167, -0.00447124894708395, 0.02939942292869091, 0.03497801721096039, 0.005881641525775194, 0.0097142169252038, -0.040090661495923996, -0.017420077696442604, 0.023507747799158096, -0.024581488221883774, -0.012636318802833557, 0.03959156572818756, 0.022419657558202744, -0.039936136454343796, 0.051660794764757156, -0.026680678129196167, -0.04705622047185898, 0.013745245523750782, -0.009101455099880695, 0.0018429718911647797, 0.013960468582808971, -0.016025252640247345, 0.03666423633694649, -0.001352087128907442, -0.011864687316119671, 0.02391822077333927, -0.04416670277714729, 0.047269463539123535, 0.0683659017086029, 0.00849818903952837, 0.008930392563343048, -0.007004000712186098, 0.030206996947526932, 0.050394609570503235, -0.00005399635847425088, 0.010747157037258148, -0.060014594346284866, 0.004155362956225872, 0.025743931531906128, 0.024638963863253593, -0.0526459738612175, -0.007228632923215628, 0.044810548424720764, 0.03161067143082619, 0.055291179567575455, 0.06347242742776871, -0.004850183147937059, -0.023333793506026268, 0.020404133945703506, 0.0442357175052166, 0.028130579739809036, 0.002109277294948697, 0.02366587519645691, 0.041750188916921616, 0.05212025344371796, 0.0034346964675933123, 0.01766885817050934, 0.024364400655031204, 0.003717853222042322, -0.004760225769132376, -0.002634728793054819, -0.017686400562524796, 0.04964612051844597, -0.030689338222146034, -0.008111653849482536, 0.0575425885617733, -0.00488678552210331, -0.0006126254447735846, 0.029779687523841858, -0.02951008640229702, 0.045942679047584534, 0.04288019239902496, -0.039592061191797256, 0.0018498634453862906, 0.02748720720410347, -0.036345306783914566, 0.021461278200149536, 0.000614939839579165, -0.05598713085055351, -0.041730187833309174, 0.0369265154004097, 0.05750617757439613, 0.03227396681904793, 0.030252782627940178, -0.0004834838618990034, -0.02038959413766861, 0.018149016425013542, -0.043839018791913986, -0.019786575809121132, -0.02168651670217514, -0.06561468541622162, -0.015468114987015724, -0.009567967616021633, -0.05912179872393608, -0.002091814298182726, -0.010847095400094986, -0.05202311649918556, 0.022975338622927666, -0.012611204758286476, -0.020900914445519447, 0.024315938353538513, -0.023090112954378128, 0.05084582790732384, -0.019438572227954865, 0.012432090006768703, 0.04260348156094551, -0.01113941427320242, -0.032234713435173035, -0.0022306099999696016, -0.03836820274591446, 0.00411019753664732, -0.009626257233321667, -0.02250407263636589, 0.0075957318767905235, 0.004254959523677826, -0.006488004699349403, 0.024064553901553154, -0.016681278124451637, -0.005111545789986849, -0.04125338792800903, -0.02849772199988365, 0.011927001178264618, -0.012127070687711239, 0.03896896913647652, 0.02390049770474434, -0.026444854214787483, 0.04364888370037079, 0.042129144072532654, -0.06827771663665771, -0.05785415694117546, -0.036374133080244064, 0.00626187352463603, 0.012674576602876186, 0.0063325269147753716, 0.026447413489222527, -0.004729919601231813, -0.027634654194116592, 0.045235536992549896, 0.00005344381497707218, 0.038891490548849106, -0.022093994542956352, -0.019505098462104797, 0.038413241505622864, -0.00713324174284935, -0.020913148298859596, 0.04076743870973587, 0.0140951843932271, -0.04102301597595215, 0.04590606316924095, -0.020232055336236954, 0.020755568519234657, -0.007538003847002983, -0.01362442597746849, -0.024960974231362343, 0.01161731407046318, 0.03298153728246689, -0.008641676977276802, 0.019590510055422783, 0.03266819566488266, -0.013997679576277733, -0.0034320219419896603, -0.011979508213698864, 0.03932511433959007, -0.019211703911423683, 0.003992825746536255, 0.03951040282845497, 0.05114994943141937, -0.02454352378845215, -0.00887176301330328, 0.023999206721782684, -0.007784303743392229, -0.008067969232797623, -0.041763946413993835, -0.02057100459933281, 0.021491676568984985, 0.007821553386747837, 0.059508468955755234, 0.03708118572831154, -0.06736613065004349, 0.04825131967663765, -0.02898075059056282, 0.010856572538614273, -0.038649626076221466, 0.05080854520201683, 0.02385270595550537, 0.06845574080944061, 0.01400463655591011, -0.007605664897710085, 0.004576381761580706, 0.00011646583152469248, -0.06613773852586746, 0.04106779396533966, 0.0002480595139786601, 0.026785237714648247, -0.020862549543380737, -0.0006183545920066535, -0.00578067172318697, -0.006912730634212494, 0.03076569363474846, -0.00987046118825674, -0.013080079108476639, -0.032195478677749634, 0.0201349426060915, -0.0237068273127079, 0.008153528906404972, 0.0008550396305508912, 0.017937103286385536, -0.006615976337343454, -0.024448227137327194, 0.059895921498537064, 0.012415096163749695, -0.020424509420990944, -0.00510806730017066, -0.0011379880597814918, -0.000749686558265239, 0.020124642178416252, 0.03666139766573906, 0.001279062475077808, 0.009179255925118923, -0.03508675470948219, 0.004562385380268097, -0.030972428619861603, 0.06898768246173859, 0.04135224595665932, -0.018471499904990196, -0.017163557931780815, -0.0307353213429451, -0.03416730463504791, 0.00046710699098184705, 0.005095098167657852, -0.037995461374521255, -0.011567669920623302, 0.049055565148591995, 0.01389539148658514, -0.0312514491379261, 0.040572308003902435, 0.03888942673802376, 0.04120853170752525, -0.019043121486902237, -0.015753841027617455, 0.027683889493346214, -0.0026393698062747717, -0.0033687674440443516, 0.019137660041451454, 0.02438112534582615, -0.003535306314006448, 0.020998531952500343, -0.009925933554768562, -0.03291952610015869, -0.012885179370641708, -0.004283261951059103, 0.020676765590906143, 0.02782696671783924, -0.04892845079302788, -0.027845144271850586, -0.007610619068145752, 0.022816991433501244, 0.04322515428066254, 0.006017322186380625, -0.03606908768415451, -0.1387815624475479, -0.00004705025639850646, 0.04442070797085762, 0.037852562963962555, -0.04517433047294617, -0.024477209895849228, -0.029330836609005928, -0.017894767224788666, 0.07360342144966125, -0.08499690145254135, -0.01348402351140976, -0.02202514186501503, 0.00549300154671073, -0.018130216747522354, -0.008383817970752716, -0.05266926810145378, 0.018079262226819992, -0.046808239072561264, 0.021443013101816177, -0.004839615430682898, -0.03471284732222557, -0.04190355911850929, 0.031206171959638596, -0.0010605104034766555, 0.02495064027607441, -0.017467308789491653, -0.009667780250310898, -0.01901143230497837, -0.00797487422823906, -0.0037436389829963446, -0.007337297312915325, 0.038934286683797836, 0.011020277626812458, 0.007741991896182299, 0.06790903955698013, 0.009711479768157005, 0.004212351981550455, -0.0017990199849009514, 0.016422593966126442, -0.02365453913807869, -0.008342116139829159, 0.004360847640782595, 0.030621100217103958, 0.03795551508665085, 0.007273195311427116, 0.03559819981455803, 0.015125403180718422, -0.02325972355902195, -0.006987023167312145, -0.03295305743813515, 0.024960355833172798, -0.006104165688157082, 0.004588681273162365, -0.013849847950041294, -0.02011284790933132, -0.039695803076028824, 0.008164141327142715, 0.0007719242130406201, 0.05321161821484566, -0.012131565250456333, 0.02974436990916729, 0.021127518266439438, 0.03247064724564552, -0.01637987233698368, -0.02814067155122757, 0.014276012778282166, 0.02284369431436062, -0.004086935427039862, -0.02524385415017605, 0.04761693254113197, -0.021200919523835182, -0.01426797453314066, -0.01155444048345089, -0.03997689485549927, 0.05266040191054344, -0.02246616780757904, -0.022884823381900787, 0.01971164532005787, -0.020275359973311424, 0.035297855734825134, -0.01177662331610918, 0.016625095158815384, -0.0027605146169662476, -0.0492398664355278, -0.02587779238820076, 0.012416265904903412, 0.014951205812394619, 0.02141265757381916, -0.05032580345869064, 0.04283572733402252, -0.007184539921581745, 0.005540530662983656, -0.052152786403894424, -0.030111068859696388, 0.022543808445334435, 0.04766877740621567, -0.009780537337064743, -0.049865901470184326, 0.030941389501094818, 0.002602641936391592, 0.020352454856038094, -0.0210603978484869, 0.022540343925356865, -0.02738841623067856, -0.007163569331169128, 0.00317744561471045, -0.007065917365252972, 0.09845902770757675, 0.007680609356611967, -0.011724448762834072, 0.017923174425959587, 0.026286933571100235, -0.008573181927204132, -0.02126147411763668, 0.011944098398089409, -0.06333959102630615, -0.008012676611542702, 0.007813472300767899, 0.008464084006845951, 0.04603780061006546, -0.007093328051269054, -0.01119038462638855, 0.024946993216872215, 0.012646733783185482, 0.03752567991614342, -0.04161536321043968, 0.007356681395322084, -0.051662836223840714, -0.018861589953303337, -0.05712742358446121, 0.016036465764045715, -0.054854702204465866, 0.007796666119247675, 0.002967311069369316, -0.0014316377928480506, 0.04209001362323761, 0.011475891806185246, 0.0562555231153965, -0.04423696547746658, -0.00012395143858157098, 0.0027746742125600576, -0.04065326228737831, 0.043710991740226746, 0.04582446441054344, -0.007522880099713802, 0.019010579213500023, 0.009634056128561497, 0.022224077954888344, 0.01881679706275463, -0.0380842462182045, -0.010488100349903107, 0.07544238120317459, -0.021668870002031326, 0.014974034391343594, 0.051747165620326996, 0.007250793278217316, -0.01188614685088396, 0.016823964193463326, -0.04130958765745163, -0.010474448092281818, 0.019324181601405144, 0.043419864028692245, -0.019684065133333206, -0.0027594072744250298, 0.04190024733543396, -0.016836415976285934, 0.02659435197710991, 0.0666092112660408, 0.005298445001244545, 0.009699171409010887, -0.004301662091165781, -0.00946857314556837, -0.0236530601978302, 0.03699377924203873, -0.040051333606243134, 0.01435128878802061, -0.010564194060862064, -0.030897676944732666, 0.02816001884639263, 0.025890346616506577, -0.00039188508526422083, -0.015981899574398994, -0.03678501769900322, -0.015131891705095768, 0.028630772605538368, 0.011972094886004925, -0.010716860182583332, 0.00781538151204586, 0.009496080689132214, 0.02181108482182026, 0.0018540866440162063, 0.0490691177546978, -0.03107178770005703, -0.08037994056940079, -0.019176660105586052, -0.004438352305442095, -0.07421541213989258, 0.03246519714593887, 0.01912681758403778, -0.0011727052042260766, 0.030071357265114784, -0.03091057762503624, 0.009790169075131416, 0.03484563156962395, 0.0327705442905426, 0.01270010881125927, 0.09600455313920975, 0.020780133083462715, -0.018199831247329712, 0.024007756263017654, -0.03192055970430374, 0.10700225830078125, 0.08018553256988525, 0.06569502502679825, -0.054486922919750214, 0.029356995597481728, 0.035935014486312866, 0.00357082043774426, -0.02576719969511032, -0.028647372499108315, 0.022325072437524796, 0.012397095561027527, 0.03601212054491043, 0.03814292699098587, 0.01546661090105772, 0.01333090104162693, 0.052392031997442245, -0.025999028235673904, -0.03343997523188591, -0.014192111790180206, 0.021830784156918526, -0.019478604197502136, -0.015851812437176704, -0.10261298716068268, 0.018916629254817963, 0.016590779647231102, -0.010194839909672737, -0.039438359439373016, 0.0007995255873538554, -0.042110469192266464, -0.006155097857117653, 0.008817748166620731, 0.0020701636094599962, 0.004888827446848154, -0.00441959360614419, -0.011900734156370163, -0.0022994906175881624, 0.03164643794298172, -0.017367344349622726, -0.002696917625144124, 0.01851179264485836, -0.012080390006303787, -0.0008992255316115916, -0.021967720240354538, 0.03765349090099335, -0.05710034817457199, -0.015236693434417248, -0.05994310975074768, -0.006114569958299398, -0.030991792678833008, 0.012292716652154922, 0.01573939062654972, -0.0007962721865624189, -0.024983875453472137, -0.031819917261600494, -0.013926095329225063, 0.023798713460564613, 0.01096679549664259, -0.005685236304998398, -0.029195798560976982, -0.05099145695567131, 0.03283482417464256, 0.0030849601607769728, 0.006360428407788277, 0.03883669897913933, -0.002165989251807332, -0.01777822896838188, -0.06164053827524185, 0.05545017123222351, -0.023785898461937904, 0.007562974467873573, -0.0076296660117805, -0.05850203335285187, -0.034341201186180115, -0.008078737184405327, -0.02358820289373398, 0.014417119324207306, 0.0028454402927309275, -0.0019921648781746626, -0.011027823202311993, -0.02532593347132206, -0.005481889471411705, -0.01111244410276413, -0.020672084763646126, -0.05794237554073334, -0.01659902185201645, 0.031451668590307236, 0.03035692311823368, 0.021447954699397087, 0.028610002249479294, 0.029820848256349564, -0.03786701336503029, 0.025286337360739708, 0.010850915685296059, -0.06738363206386566, -0.03411312773823738, -0.03244166821241379, -0.007123180665075779, 0.028758201748132706, 0.008135753683745861, 0.06383625417947769, 0.005542234517633915, -0.03372349962592125, 0.017798786982893944, 0.039763595908880234, -0.044102080166339874, 0.02586251311004162, -0.0020785918459296227, -0.030251452699303627, 0.014153340831398964, 0.00037035823334008455, -0.0007165519637055695, -0.049443792551755905, -0.046373676508665085, -0.03921939805150032, -0.028302175924181938, 0.006247370503842831, -0.014406506903469563, -0.014625126495957375, 0.001041342387907207, 0.011769376695156097, 0.011689284816384315, 0.008736292831599712, 0.022969653829932213, -0.011307237669825554, -0.01152840442955494, -0.018770534545183182, -0.02702692709863186, -0.01178221870213747, 0.002263130620121956, -0.05719093233346939, 0.020032817497849464, -0.017448557540774345, 0.012901892885565758, 0.0421600379049778, -0.017967280000448227, 0.012474038638174534, -0.018019596114754677, 0.05771976709365845, -0.006069127935916185, -0.029330581426620483, 0.01671411655843258, -0.07776715606451035, -0.023321842774748802, 0.019970595836639404, -0.044418081641197205, 0.03380374610424042, -0.004253772087395191, 0.015653422102332115, 0.010067698545753956, 0.047789979726076126, -0.027095437049865723, -0.011114380322396755, -0.01373328547924757, 0.00728289969265461, 0.04560118168592453, 0.022363103926181793, 0.01289178803563118, 0.020078960806131363, -0.01419660821557045, 0.006608919240534306, 0.05416414886713028, 0.016265150159597397, -0.014855184592306614, 0.031025569885969162, -0.00036080522113479674, 0.04376785829663277, 0.0002234940038761124, 0.0007143963593989611, 0.04751192778348923, 0.025170722976326942, -0.08229108899831772, 0.029848067089915276, -0.01537246536463499, 0.002038703765720129, -0.06310480833053589, -0.009782735258340836, 0.012138756923377514, -0.034351594746112823, 0.0669081062078476, -0.048362769186496735, -0.004695842508226633, 0.021204089745879173, -0.021617066115140915, 0.05246838554739952, 0.03224969282746315, -0.004363353364169598, -0.03434143215417862, 0.0321706086397171, -0.02277901954948902, 0.01392032578587532, 0.022410541772842407, 0.03759562596678734, 0.02168169803917408, 0.0006758294766768813, 0.02897643856704235, -0.010867944918572903, -0.016500454396009445, 0.012603912502527237, 0.022578056901693344, -0.06995341926813126, 0.04118809103965759, -0.0449109748005867, -0.012770387344062328, 0.049119144678115845, 0.02255517989397049, 0.022183479741215706, 0.03254226595163345, -0.007584685925394297, 0.0016428621020168066, 0.046463742852211, -0.00988731812685728, -0.0065863789059221745, -0.02824343368411064, -0.009420876391232014, 0.02047109231352806, 0.0020137790124863386, -0.007643372751772404, 0.009686262346804142, 0.046058934181928635, -0.01490603294223547, 0.001972324913367629, 0.027154535055160522, -0.02629837952554226, 0.009057121351361275, -0.04984774813055992, 0.0014468884328380227, 0.022931799292564392, -0.03430457413196564, 0.015708571299910545, -0.05968477576971054, 0.01941109634935856, 0.005744775757193565, 0.02546977810561657, 0.025048518553376198, 0.015783213078975677, 0.0005388165591284633, -0.06215713545680046, -0.011758366599678993, 0.025881819427013397, -0.03994550555944443, -0.029903579503297806, 0.0037838872522115707, -0.00325476354919374, 0.009979850612580776, -0.014973277226090431, -0.029776673763990402, -0.023721611127257347, 0.04008762165904045, -0.02178218588232994, 0.017782721668481827, 0.03759089857339859, 0.015418261289596558, 0.01971994712948799, -0.07764112949371338, 0.02940603718161583, 0.01405128464102745, -0.024887247011065483, -0.03963721916079521, 0.00026558691752143204, -0.033461641520261765, 0.04541252180933952, 0.03362814337015152, 0.02266913466155529, 0.006546166725456715, -0.037630803883075714, 0.013297555968165398, 0.028648152947425842, -0.07482471317052841, 0.03609849512577057, 0.02306242659687996, -0.060527253895998, -0.0023828954435884953, -0.005877329967916012, 0.015069839544594288, 0.00877211894840002, -0.01717020757496357, -0.022410910576581955, 0.025263777002692223, -0.0007935671601444483, -0.041802067309617996, 0.031240690499544144, 0.0011591828661039472, -0.011448451317846775, 0.025462504476308823, 0.002161190612241626, -0.002277144230902195, 0.05413050204515457, -0.01825227029621601, -0.03728853911161423, 0.05349142476916313, -0.04824353754520416, -0.006842970848083496, 0.03740798681974411, 0.0031753149814903736, -0.010079238563776016, -0.05092503875494003, 0.014860582537949085, 0.018586227670311928, -0.02069835364818573, 0.009764849208295345, 0.03777322918176651, 0.027590174227952957, 0.03165043517947197, -0.006963853724300861, -0.002430986613035202, -0.00017383859085384756, -0.03310343995690346, 0.006478847004473209, 0.008788850158452988, 0.0035277630668133497, -0.029924023896455765, 0.02340197004377842, 0.019235806539654732, 0.0027304664254188538, 0.03695700317621231, -0.01021619513630867, 0.013966325670480728, -0.005117932800203562, -0.008664037100970745, 0.014161435887217522, 0.005064227618277073, -0.011525626294314861, 0.014108667150139809, -0.02303488366305828, 0.0023794777225703, -0.017673803493380547, 0.028068363666534424, -0.04810108244419098, -0.04010333493351936, -0.036866694688797, -0.0060373712331056595, -0.011937898583710194, 0.006817490793764591, -0.03313016518950462, 0.05129707604646683, 0.0158042311668396, -0.01730228215456009, 0.030410144478082657, -0.007947273552417755, 0.007780388463288546, -0.04815855994820595, 0.005342446267604828, -0.0005408282740972936, -0.005344782955944538, -0.02813626639544964, -0.02138199657201767, -0.004405068699270487, 0.015739740803837776, 0.026173435151576996, -0.03528289496898651, 0.008027678355574608, 0.008405515924096107, 0.03269732743501663, 0.0010852767154574394, -0.030827699229121208, -0.0585508868098259, 0.020045094192028046, -0.00909148808568716, -0.03568118438124657 ]
<p>What is the difference between </p> <p>$ \lim_{n \to \infty} \ \mathrm{E}_{\theta}(T_n(X)) = \theta$ </p> <p>and </p> <p>$ T_n(X) \xrightarrow{p} \theta \ $ for $\ n \xrightarrow{} \infty$ ?</p> <p>(unbiasdness vs. Consisteny)</p> <hr> <p>Ups... there seems to be this question already :-( <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/31036/what-is-the-difference-between-a-consistent-estimator-and-an-unbiased-estimator?rq=1">Similar CrossValidated question</a> </p> <p>Shall I delete this question?</p>
49,379
[ -0.09022113680839539, -0.02681822143495083, 0.010264100506901741, -0.010855799540877342, 0.01564892753958702, 0.010180563665926456, 0.004105964209884405, -0.014345156960189342, 0.03536738082766533, -0.016001254320144653, 0.04634164273738861, 0.048501353710889816, 0.04546022787690163, 0.0488518662750721, -0.007668322883546352, 0.03704588860273361, 0.0011338500771671534, -0.019795987755060196, -0.012969383038580418, 0.0023321642074733973, 0.01382518745958805, 0.017971482127904892, -0.0043194186873734, 0.0016587137943133712, -0.051898274570703506, 0.019877726212143898, 0.05375475063920021, -0.01776120997965336, -0.008649543859064579, 0.06691651046276093, -0.04092220589518547, -0.023269696161150932, 0.020908290520310402, 0.0007955244509503245, 0.03230498731136322, -0.0029900996014475822, 0.0070864856243133545, -0.02556760236620903, -0.004855407401919365, 0.07034530490636826, -0.02788769267499447, -0.012093886733055115, -0.03613630682229996, 0.020271658897399902, 0.007953960448503494, 0.000073152084951289, -0.018529996275901794, -0.011753316968679428, 0.026494374498724937, -0.046129010617733, 0.05726911500096321, -0.03307552635669708, 0.01808115281164646, 0.015969671308994293, -0.004055880010128021, -0.017410757020115852, 0.055112700909376144, 0.06527972966432571, -0.01695428043603897, -0.07284518331289291, -0.0007037593168206513, -0.017061330378055573, -0.0023865927942097187, 0.0048769740387797356, -0.034272804856300354, 0.02221972681581974, 0.04687665030360222, -0.027491364628076553, 0.03433488681912422, -0.02286180667579174, 0.013869227841496468, 0.035070110112428665, 0.03565288707613945, 0.006668579299002886, 0.021152017638087273, -0.046727798879146576, 0.024508967995643616, 0.022493751719594002, 0.03913741558790207, 0.05456710234284401, 0.029522066935896873, 0.02086906135082245, 0.057491764426231384, 0.03909320384263992, 0.021015146747231483, 0.037893038243055344, 0.08844500035047531, -0.01085703819990158, -0.03156237676739693, 0.03096284531056881, 0.05044589936733246, 0.008806956931948662, 0.029325084760785103, -0.019832810387015343, -0.02510896325111389, 0.05201346427202225, -0.021657174453139305, 0.027739614248275757, 0.009223741479218006, -0.01621820591390133, -0.0047499025240540504, -0.05907532572746277, 0.022110985592007637, 0.026524843648076057, 0.0058430577628314495, -0.007797616999596357, 0.0080059003084898, -0.009612282738089561, -0.019559280946850777, -0.025434687733650208, -0.03546341136097908, 0.0089674461632967, 0.008232667110860348, 0.019266700372099876, -0.010577048175036907, 0.024235839024186134, 0.020324576646089554, 0.0028152575250715017, 0.05313168838620186, 0.06411651521921158, 0.04636436328291893, -0.005515574477612972, 0.027274683117866516, -0.03611510619521141, -0.06805714219808578, -0.02685510367155075, 0.050995148718357086, 0.014225534163415432, -0.04052882641553879, 0.04322307929396629, -0.0168899055570364, -0.010082047432661057, 0.027053574100136757, 0.003868031082674861, 0.023444753140211105, 0.038003452122211456, -0.08100199699401855, -0.07884751260280609, 0.06691339612007141, 0.012008337303996086, -0.003876487025991082, -0.0439104288816452, 0.011915681883692741, -0.0021824161522090435, 0.03626839816570282, 0.008459455333650112, 0.04453745856881142, -0.021697456017136574, 0.003489959519356489, 0.019260331988334656, -0.022470921277999878, -0.009591732174158096, -0.009400890208780766, -0.026051493361592293, -0.008266117423772812, -0.029187800362706184, 0.0012854503002017736, 0.02944054827094078, -0.03142818063497543, -0.014082587324082851, 0.033633556216955185, -0.018443457782268524, 0.009501313790678978, -0.01703506149351597, 0.028181103989481926, 0.003852895461022854, 0.07069645822048187, 0.02082935720682144, 0.016776906326413155, 0.008371444419026375, -0.01901201158761978, -0.0014815476024523377, -0.005549103952944279, 0.01648584008216858, 0.027660168707370758, -0.04087938740849495, -0.03422977030277252, -0.03216055408120155, -0.01300425548106432, 0.007350968662649393, -0.0371272973716259, -0.00149118946865201, -0.010828983969986439, -0.013989740051329136, 0.027752261608839035, 0.04227279871702194, 0.017992369830608368, -0.017895836383104324, 0.030253110453486443, -0.029589103534817696, -0.025358183309435844, -0.049348268657922745, 0.002804805291816592, 0.000007058755272737471, -0.01672016642987728, 0.04921986535191536, -0.02310098707675934, -0.051648594439029694, -0.05727461725473404, 0.01677296869456768, -0.005398057401180267, 0.038750749081373215, 0.03940775990486145, -0.02303125150501728, 0.016582977026700974, 0.07235441356897354, 0.02060733176767826, -0.038332074880599976, 0.02251512184739113, -0.05777626112103462, -0.06659331172704697, 0.012308787554502487, -0.0261547788977623, 0.04693656787276268, 0.012702429667115211, -0.0036908078473061323, 0.03923600912094116, 0.002422683872282505, -0.02576630562543869, 0.03241322562098503, -0.06334822624921799, 0.051811493933200836, 0.04429646208882332, -0.008108559995889664, 0.03219733387231827, 0.024506691843271255, 0.020411400124430656, 0.03850286081433296, -0.007163295987993479, -0.004518281668424606, -0.04570499435067177, 0.006645970977842808, 0.052073024213314056, -0.014949733391404152, -0.025456899777054787, 0.009641560725867748, 0.04450630024075508, 0.017426200211048126, -0.005356352776288986, -0.01657034270465374, -0.03120189718902111, -0.045691441744565964, 0.009426003322005272, 0.01863095909357071, -0.00728871813043952, 0.01849725842475891, -0.024669593200087547, -0.014273094944655895, 0.06564261019229889, 0.01840178482234478, 0.016819514334201813, 0.06496142596006393, 0.02875480428338051, -0.0020878445357084274, 0.005351550877094269, -0.024724608287215233, 0.032089222222566605, -0.02626468613743782, 0.01406848058104515, -0.015224950388073921, 0.006700257770717144, 0.031199373304843903, -0.01724124141037464, -0.008202068507671356, 0.019544441252946854, 0.03092815913259983, -0.02385261468589306, -0.0003034701512660831, 0.04109803959727287, 0.00512218102812767, 0.005974485073238611, -0.0426088348031044, -0.049094557762145996, -0.025643691420555115, 0.0007753531681373715, 0.013583970256149769, -0.006734222639352083, 0.01845700666308403, -0.04854554682970047, -0.006861594971269369, -0.016207976266741753, -0.02332632802426815, -0.017215533182024956, -0.05411166697740555, -0.0285201258957386, 0.0024834314826875925, -0.05722299590706825, -0.01989067532122135, 0.007666214369237423, 0.02217928133904934, 0.011440913192927837, 0.014794593676924706, 0.0018862857250496745, -0.06299860775470734, -0.019330434501171112, -0.038691919296979904, 0.02249525673687458, -0.022210411727428436, -0.07685678452253342, 0.04064462333917618, -0.02887590602040291, -0.024414677172899246, 0.05064578354358673, -0.07732286304235458, 0.00044683984015136957, -0.048525355756282806, 0.0263201966881752, 0.04174024239182472, 0.0018176118610426784, -0.0015540671302005649, 0.041151974350214005, -0.020286966115236282, 0.02040022425353527, -0.06960581243038177, -0.025190157815814018, -0.007679296191781759, -0.016352489590644836, 0.017702534794807434, 0.003320579882711172, -0.01441927533596754, 0.0704817920923233, 0.04173713177442551, -0.02033132128417492, -0.059136588126420975, -0.006544011645019054, -0.0317804180085659, -0.027562078088521957, 0.003141126362606883, 0.011074393056333065, 0.010869958437979221, 0.009568692184984684, 0.034371841698884964, 0.029149750247597694, 0.017311040312051773, 0.04676073417067528, 0.006083351094275713, -0.012881768867373466, 0.019351568073034286, 0.0017422125674784184, 0.06491749733686447, 0.007705666124820709, -0.053575631231069565, -0.010284650139510632, 0.008718633092939854, 0.02974948100745678, 0.016535142436623573, -0.05041583999991417, 0.010179493576288223, -0.0018181068589910865, 0.02715151198208332, -0.04938866198062897, 0.08960519731044769, 0.025735564529895782, -0.010461279191076756, -0.023114195093512535, -0.004061597399413586, 0.052877649664878845, -0.014373236335814, -0.024943698197603226, 0.0308996569365263, 0.02912764810025692, -0.04108697175979614, -0.002373409690335393, -0.0143821332603693, 0.0003579392796382308, 0.009392348118126392, -0.036276575177907944, -0.0607125461101532, 0.06880335509777069, 0.06528886407613754, 0.0005274002905935049, 0.02083742991089821, -0.06042410805821419, -0.06514474004507065, -0.07180306315422058, 0.029824426397681236, -0.024828199297189713, 0.05306064337491989, 0.018855813890695572, 0.05707255005836487, 0.025365615263581276, -0.023933781310915947, -0.03005998022854328, 0.0010539271170273423, -0.06296886503696442, 0.013151559047400951, -0.0007523616659455001, -0.037986163049936295, 0.020304739475250244, 0.012423219159245491, -0.008534910157322884, 0.014791498892009258, 0.029851622879505157, -0.03302953019738197, 0.013652004301548004, -0.015334323048591614, 0.037239011377096176, -0.012316965498030186, -0.03242993354797363, 0.012022717855870724, 0.0246916301548481, 0.030435452237725258, -0.03397597745060921, 0.0707322433590889, 0.005926644429564476, 0.009152304381132126, -0.0022466713562607765, -0.014312581159174442, 0.013348263688385487, -0.015466170385479927, -0.005523442756384611, -0.017152002081274986, 0.013560725376009941, 0.006644833832979202, 0.04103846848011017, 0.04586544260382652, 0.04271579906344414, 0.04954708740115166, 0.007303850259631872, -0.0322125144302845, -0.062020640820264816, -0.0010878233006224036, 0.00021610214025713503, 0.0038621705025434494, -0.006850539240986109, -0.008433789014816284, 0.07730711251497269, 0.004811123479157686, -0.005279707722365856, 0.032666001468896866, 0.042352769523859024, 0.0024259211495518684, 0.004854853730648756, -0.019336486235260963, 0.004064064472913742, 0.0037086636293679476, 0.02244456484913826, 0.01675267703831196, 0.024367211386561394, 0.0039688581600785255, 0.002873123623430729, 0.03735353797674179, -0.02554965764284134, -0.020011056214571, -0.045413870364427567, 0.018016353249549866, 0.009456164203584194, -0.024823468178510666, -0.028269927948713303, 0.02701338194310665, 0.007721105590462685, 0.054889269173145294, 0.02427911013364792, 0.013567868620157242, -0.057481106370687485, 0.005194390658289194, 0.06673584133386612, 0.03931484371423721, -0.02043480984866619, -0.03163851797580719, -0.02744230255484581, 0.0027555953711271286, 0.024544870480895042, -0.02655019983649254, 0.03961007669568062, -0.044742487370967865, 0.007638236042112112, -0.008645100519061089, -0.031129371374845505, -0.017090337350964546, 0.0019887839443981647, 0.023543721064925194, 0.05153283104300499, -0.017561249434947968, -0.005886082071810961, -0.03513704985380173, -0.020995499566197395, 0.0508703775703907, 0.04717892408370972, -0.033001285046339035, -0.005984987132251263, -0.006026486866176128, 0.01391638908535242, -0.012422922998666763, -0.08281504362821579, -0.003654888831079006, 0.0010056465398520231, -0.026763716712594032, 0.05497124791145325, -0.03187329322099686, -0.07011529058218002, 0.03055637702345848, -0.015394097194075584, -0.027095723897218704, 0.04827449470758438, -0.03682465851306915, 0.06697531044483185, 0.06038226932287216, 0.019155224785208702, 0.034682173281908035, 0.051386430859565735, 0.003749965224415064, 0.016050634905695915, -0.020142221823334694, 0.024670062586665154, -0.050088610500097275, -0.008415893651545048, -0.04169681668281555, -0.02099015936255455, -0.04548463225364685, 0.029000751674175262, -0.025021132081747055, 0.001411563134752214, -0.05855546146631241, -0.014276028610765934, 0.02976921945810318, 0.02974412590265274, 0.01908857375383377, 0.014101151376962662, 0.011527563445270061, 0.024799613282084465, 0.0077304053120315075, -0.02605176717042923, 0.03780170530080795, -0.020921826362609863, 0.029552387073636055, 0.04676626995205879, -0.01571929082274437, 0.000029723712941631675, -0.05060549080371857, -0.01680423505604267, -0.005514953285455704, -0.01770634949207306, 0.032020725309848785, 0.005598186049610376, 0.06980396807193756, -0.0005651316605508327, -0.014587437734007835, -0.014450741931796074, 0.015501045621931553, -0.01015781331807375, 0.011889793910086155, -0.06483597308397293, 0.0762147307395935, 0.00017748700338415802, -0.02430509589612484, -0.07608985155820847, 0.001145035377703607, 0.02406940422952175, 0.008463519625365734, -0.02635376900434494, -0.02850630134344101, 0.011366491205990314, -0.029013829305768013, -0.02938888594508171, -0.03824315965175629, 0.019273770973086357, -0.008558625355362892, -0.009619372896850109, -0.004964499734342098, 0.026240447536110878, 0.08467860519886017, -0.012412140145897865, 0.01181871723383665, -0.01685057207942009, -0.006430571898818016, -0.010517837479710579, 0.007457873318344355, 0.008716942742466927, -0.04334339499473572, -0.025142773985862732, -0.02111426182091236, 0.0010208850726485252, 0.02602820098400116, 0.00770988455042243, -0.009098133072257042, 0.019562453031539917, -0.048921775072813034, -0.026093441992998123, -0.006770563777536154, -0.00532194972038269, 0.001110554556362331, -0.01819388009607792, -0.01585565321147442, 0.00516494968906045, 0.005119755864143372, -0.05370255559682846, -0.009516752324998379, -0.000874379591550678, -0.0012694848701357841, -0.002343439729884267, 0.08145219832658768, -0.05217484384775162, 0.0007650439511053264, 0.029210055246949196, -0.03304026648402214, 0.049832191318273544, -0.018200339749455452, -0.009542926214635372, 0.0029282397590577602, -0.010018908418715, -0.013955267146229744, -0.026620134711265564, -0.02957409806549549, 0.0003605061210691929, 0.03172523155808449, -0.005288261920213699, 0.04339731112122536, 0.024856755509972572, -0.029733626171946526, -0.020574381574988365, -0.02952026017010212, 0.019778646528720856, -0.0322958268225193, 0.027811167761683464, 0.016301464289426804, -0.008143522776663303, -0.019903196021914482, 0.035312067717313766, 0.020723121240735054, 0.05451609194278717, -0.016522875055670738, -0.002655390417203307, 0.029711350798606873, 0.04142613708972931, -0.05138883367180824, -0.036605287343263626, 0.02586340345442295, -0.04870493337512016, -0.009533068165183067, 0.009031916037201881, -0.04235363006591797, 0.03503034636378288, 0.04484066367149353, -0.015909865498542786, -0.024486465379595757, 0.007818357087671757, -0.059875983744859695, -0.021580632776021957, -0.004525698721408844, -0.004184808116406202, 0.0033265023957937956, -0.006625873502343893, 0.006688638590276241, 0.011079631745815277, 0.005689050070941448, -0.048004940152168274, -0.04484130069613457, -0.033657174557447433, -0.02219708263874054, -0.051968611776828766, 0.05187352001667023, -0.016861967742443085, -0.035066455602645874, 0.02390866167843342, -0.03586771339178085, 0.026544688269495964, 0.017280153930187225, 0.027123039588332176, -0.06060997024178505, 0.04729817062616348, -0.0021652753930538893, 0.04973806068301201, -0.017871586605906487, 0.007034794893115759, 0.09939765185117722, 0.07477230578660965, 0.040083568543195724, -0.018928974866867065, 0.0075570582412183285, 0.012753930874168873, 0.04121062532067299, -0.00990866869688034, -0.0209945160895586, 0.01331576332449913, -0.018572671338915825, 0.026049446314573288, 0.06921588629484177, 0.02206498570740223, -0.0507199652493, 0.027447355911135674, -0.005405067000538111, 0.0164326224476099, 0.010076071135699749, 0.022943958640098572, -0.002963901963084936, -0.001633992069400847, -0.017036113888025284, 0.016871673986315727, 0.006050440017133951, 0.049285124987363815, -0.056615784764289856, -0.0009215104510076344, -0.004527925979346037, -0.0072735692374408245, -0.008283223956823349, -0.006867920979857445, -0.019746217876672745, -0.015472848899662495, -0.03667381405830383, 0.004060763865709305, 0.019068697467446327, -0.011922613717615604, 0.028798885643482208, 0.06000886484980583, 0.03414519131183624, -0.021752748638391495, 0.028932373970746994, 0.010535087436437607, -0.03889613598585129, -0.007949366234242916, -0.01680406555533409, 0.032745759934186935, -0.017384996637701988, -0.011155758053064346, -0.010401023551821709, -0.009966709651052952, 0.011890596710145473, -0.03894753381609917, -0.018230866640806198, -0.003575216280296445, -0.030121559277176857, -0.007916959002614021, -0.011776183731853962, -0.027873961254954338, 0.016656232997775078, 0.01574455015361309, 0.03812936320900917, 0.01770588383078575, -0.06106521189212799, -0.005581478588283062, -0.00541545869782567, 0.04133814573287964, 0.009030520915985107, 0.03329549729824066, 0.004201374016702175, -0.007842528633773327, -0.04483679309487343, -0.010008957237005234, 0.02790982276201248, -0.003063412383198738, 0.056210990995168686, -0.00979990977793932, 0.010571583174169064, -0.01871633157134056, -0.055792707949876785, 0.02111300826072693, 0.016707515344023705, -0.002363376785069704, -0.04015346243977547, 0.022467495873570442, -0.03729861602187157, 0.003122754395008087, 0.009843923151493073, 0.04517780616879463, 0.008680124767124653, 0.06757642328739166, -0.007272158283740282, -0.05586998164653778, -0.022084444761276245, 0.000627323635853827, -0.03831411153078079, 0.012324925512075424, -0.013493583537638187, 0.040870461612939835, 0.02340749464929104, 0.039540186524391174, -0.03756339102983475, 0.018328743055462837, -0.009111667051911354, -0.00147027219645679, -0.00656703719869256, -0.0566655769944191, -0.02788982167840004, 0.030635954812169075, 0.023228738456964493, -0.013849603943526745, -0.011964240111410618, -0.036285415291786194, -0.015148528851568699, 0.04642245173454285, -0.0022349327336996794, -0.0678696557879448, 0.0015377888921648264, -0.014179958961904049, 0.03385234624147415, -0.016981570050120354, -0.005198273807764053, -0.04007259011268616, -0.03217846527695656, 0.0035864657256752253, 0.0011023967526853085, 0.019932400435209274, 0.04517728090286255, -0.0033595492132008076, -0.021882418543100357, -0.0033674517180770636, 0.00886143185198307, -0.01706940308213234, 0.0010521657532081008, -0.010275278240442276, 0.012679405510425568, 0.009398002177476883, -0.010486206971108913, -0.02729087322950363, 0.041660938411951065, -0.012916995212435722, -0.02809801697731018, 0.015605214051902294, -0.006931549869477749, 0.043049730360507965, 0.015744272619485855, -0.02716226689517498, -0.02285057120025158, 0.03588201478123665, -0.03763540834188461, -0.014841901138424873, 0.014597466215491295, -0.017753295600414276, 0.019354311749339104, -0.03297267481684685, 0.011930418200790882, -0.0031988173723220825, -0.01703498698771, -0.001067330944351852, 0.052538976073265076, -0.00011889934103237465, -0.03430267795920372, -0.005976451560854912, 0.011717504821717739, -0.018439296633005142, -0.0161861814558506, -0.024955201894044876, 0.013324622064828873, 0.03595682978630066, -0.04111317917704582, 0.011477377265691757, -0.04710717499256134, 0.005739414598792791, -0.10632630437612534, -0.005896700080484152, -0.005990956444293261, 0.00624274043366313, 0.0020848442800343037, -0.02430441416800022, 0.014945748262107372, 0.034320928156375885, -0.06112925708293915, 0.06549166142940521, 0.012412848882377148, -0.0022090678103268147, -0.049900270998477936, 0.013208138756453991, -0.013376816175878048, 0.019981345161795616, -0.008448510430753231, 0.01726388931274414, 0.019869567826390266, 0.03813246265053749, -0.0015927617205306888, -0.056598495692014694, -0.0023003998212516308, 0.015451530925929546, -0.010611042380332947, -0.03617266193032265, 0.05173186585307121, -0.03458649665117264, -0.04246906563639641, 0.03646235913038254, -0.0005405821721069515, 0.022628875449299812, -0.018162567168474197, -0.0044763158075511456, -0.020853640511631966, 0.015296931378543377, 0.03847211226820946, 0.02015634812414646, 0.00046615020255558193, 0.0002255614090245217, 0.005373765714466572, 0.015530973672866821, 0.011249454692006111, -0.003614039858803153, 0.046778179705142975, 0.011858280748128891, -0.016630196943879128, 0.0027443612925708294, -0.02251730114221573, -0.0045672329142689705, 0.03296949341893196, 0.005721434950828552, -0.005756385158747435, -0.04933164268732071, 0.014935134910047054, -0.021336279809474945, 0.0062418133020401, 0.002016483573243022, 0.01774696446955204, 0.008582742884755135, 0.02879229560494423, -0.0019357579294592142, -0.035423628985881805, 0.007505553308874369, -0.035592369735240936, -0.009147397242486477, -0.04312078282237053, 0.03442481532692909, -0.012733525596559048, -0.007818251848220825, 0.0057981256395578384, -0.017294052988290787, -0.04514714702963829, 0.019376005977392197, -0.01636972837150097, -0.006543668452650309, -0.022117143496870995, -0.010524289682507515, -0.014407126232981682, -0.08689632266759872, 0.03206818923354149, -0.027282288298010826, -0.014829568564891815, -0.05966588109731674, -0.032568834722042084, -0.043089333921670914, 0.0044709560461342335, 0.06134190782904625, 0.022738641127943993, 0.02355382964015007, 0.013254068791866302, 0.019195733591914177, -0.025651631876826286, -0.05994800850749016, 0.0458235889673233, -0.005421197507530451, 0.02329186722636223, 0.0038207145407795906, -0.009413763880729675, -0.015094447880983353, 0.013104798272252083, 0.06842152774333954, -0.018964968621730804, 0.027889396995306015, 0.023814590647816658, 0.008023123256862164, 0.03875280171632767, 0.011517842300236225, 0.019362369552254677, 0.04772012308239937, -0.009170751087367535, 0.014871610328555107, 0.040550827980041504, -0.0033913380466401577, -0.03660694509744644, 0.036512862890958786, -0.050068944692611694, -0.016533171758055687, -0.04075673595070839, -0.002992199035361409, 0.010088423267006874, -0.06648175418376923, -0.02621852420270443, 0.06869849562644958, -0.04144122079014778, -0.0071745566092431545, 0.03108348324894905, 0.07747633010149002, 0.049050092697143555, -0.003998845815658569, 0.00024287236738018692, -0.006245679222047329, -0.023570748046040535, 0.004343696404248476, 0.028532246127724648, 0.05743490904569626, 0.0009404415031895041, 0.03430532291531563, 0.005035611800849438, 0.022712137550115585, 0.04488764703273773, -0.01618385501205921, 0.0399462953209877, -0.0021891689393669367, -0.050219032913446426, 0.009277639910578728, -0.002752716653048992, -0.004546689335256815, 0.043275631964206696, -0.043573785573244095, 0.033942047506570816, -0.008365116082131863, 0.012258931063115597, 0.008614403195679188, 0.013428060337901115, -0.022869953885674477, -0.021373702213168144, 0.03943943232297897, 0.019306058064103127, 0.01515351701527834, -0.029767487198114395, -0.00619451655074954, 0.021565143018960953, 0.0005354476743377745, -0.019261406734585762, -0.004495386965572834, 0.004330178257077932, -0.00034595950273796916, -0.04277421161532402, -0.021079666912555695, -0.027170108631253242, 0.0030611995607614517, 0.035457219928503036, 0.040288399904966354, 0.026064293459057808, -0.030101371929049492, -0.05703751742839813, -0.017186777666211128, 0.05776267871260643, -0.04833868145942688, -0.015664754435420036, -0.003961597103625536, -0.0028196482453495264, 0.017357029020786285, -0.03453411906957626 ]
<p>I have been trying to estimate the MLE for my joint posterior. I'm using R and the package stats4. I have 14 parameters and two of them are $\geq 0$, which I did not know how to implement (and I was creating NaN due to the minus log posterior required in for the mle function) and I just made it return very high value (1000) if either of the parameters were negative. Is this the right way to solve this problem? As I was forced to change my prior each time (because MLE told me that my prior estimates were way to high) and I find these nonegative parameters going down to were low numbers (0.001 and 0.01) which did not seem right and at each iteration way below my repeatly suggested prior.</p> <p>Also, since I didn't have the exact posterior due to the structure of the model and I tried to scale it such that the point estimate from the mle function plugged in the log joint posterior had the value 0. Is this approximation okay for this function?</p> <p>Regards, Raxel. </p>
74,332
[ -0.026932569220662117, -0.004492244683206081, 0.010793262161314487, 0.018110759556293488, 0.021826259791851044, 0.02892976999282837, -0.0033928072080016136, -0.00998691562563181, 0.029104167595505714, -0.03694932535290718, 0.047272149473428726, 0.055099967867136, 0.069734588265419, -0.0004666404565796256, 0.021090850234031677, -0.0005998513079248369, -0.030454088002443314, 0.0049248975701630116, 0.005621539428830147, -0.006828938145190477, 0.0019361156737431884, 0.026025352999567986, 0.05122780054807663, -0.013576769270002842, -0.003204470267519355, 0.028963671997189522, 0.015048058703541756, -0.018052853643894196, -0.02395237609744072, 0.11133424192667007, -0.04153497517108917, -0.023483015596866608, 0.004731598775833845, 0.025881389155983925, -0.01072707399725914, 0.025704598054289818, -0.024301622062921524, -0.01804693229496479, -0.035373613238334656, 0.06127073988318443, -0.020211169496178627, -0.04006902873516083, -0.01342042163014412, 0.030494628474116325, 0.0010331944795325398, -0.013786840252578259, 0.004608664195984602, -0.034606777131557465, 0.058369580656290054, -0.022034866735339165, 0.06580452620983124, 0.007446501404047012, 0.04751855880022049, 0.04135162755846977, -0.026194551959633827, -0.0448104627430439, 0.04388096183538437, 0.08129404485225677, -0.012930482625961304, -0.06238141655921936, -0.003394147614017129, -0.06398651003837585, 0.04499306157231331, -0.020366420969367027, -0.01635626330971718, 0.009017899632453918, 0.0026634533423930407, -0.023805560544133186, 0.017254028469324112, -0.030850987881422043, 0.03647992014884949, 0.03015083447098732, 0.0445711612701416, 0.022750724107027054, 0.019103527069091797, -0.03418881446123123, -0.0021309482399374247, 0.049241259694099426, 0.040985122323036194, 0.03912683576345444, -0.027426112443208694, -0.016723787412047386, 0.009357571601867676, 0.027411524206399918, -0.009492491371929646, 0.002728580730035901, 0.07427825033664703, -0.0067388080060482025, 0.03405774384737015, -0.0073163751512765884, -0.03344230726361275, -0.007017476949840784, 0.022780271247029305, -0.018946463242173195, -0.030035581439733505, 0.047593336552381516, -0.03169214725494385, 0.046037446707487106, 0.024688592180609703, -0.006652037613093853, 0.00969643797725439, -0.006759499199688435, -0.00419455673545599, 0.05547178164124489, -0.011507379822432995, 0.0011514236684888601, -0.036648958921432495, 0.0005745787057094276, -0.004905500449240208, -0.04208286851644516, -0.03894118219614029, 0.015767734497785568, -0.013992995955049992, -0.027085868641734123, 0.013378294184803963, -0.026359204202890396, -0.03490450978279114, -0.040209729224443436, 0.044603925198316574, 0.02406143769621849, 0.04910661280155182, 0.005895494949072599, 0.030124256387352943, -0.028184805065393448, -0.04842755198478699, 0.024930140003561974, 0.02177361398935318, -0.029521921649575233, -0.03903600573539734, 0.04599788412451744, 0.0031841385643929243, -0.0028228997252881527, 0.10656452924013138, 0.029656991362571716, 0.028682110831141472, -0.0057067577727139, -0.03639049828052521, -0.07131136208772659, 0.0554354302585125, -0.03160526230931282, 0.038195155560970306, -0.05170254781842232, -0.028147585690021515, 0.025243807584047318, 0.02154412679374218, 0.0030437472742050886, 0.04049098491668701, 0.02553008683025837, 0.000844558875542134, -0.007815320044755936, -0.015535549260675907, -0.009980347938835621, -0.07906107604503632, -0.004291806370019913, -0.03761468455195427, -0.05973246321082115, 0.019357923418283463, -0.006712107919156551, -0.0043908399529755116, -0.03435464948415756, 0.06279968470335007, 0.022708285599946976, 0.003622916527092457, -0.0007278624107129872, 0.007920307107269764, -0.045402366667985916, 0.08767549693584442, 0.011456882581114769, -0.0031592054292559624, 0.00800374522805214, -0.007447412703186274, 0.0343097448348999, -0.012929185293614864, 0.04622231051325798, 0.03974936157464981, -0.022604718804359436, -0.02104952186346054, -0.027879605069756508, 0.049411751329898834, 0.01875179260969162, -0.027269408106803894, 0.012623345479369164, -0.007138749118894339, -0.01707841455936432, 0.012134048156440258, 0.0027443082071840763, -0.026591235771775246, -0.04084270820021629, 0.03931166231632233, -0.04317346215248108, -0.033892374485731125, -0.074346624314785, -0.02948549948632717, 0.021677928045392036, -0.002804703311994672, 0.049988240003585815, -0.015875374898314476, 0.04602258279919624, -0.0006237545167095959, 0.007617751602083445, -0.022027581930160522, -0.02087169885635376, 0.032255012542009354, 0.02350042387843132, 0.026897665113210678, 0.05168836936354637, 0.0672341138124466, -0.008285826072096825, 0.04682578518986702, -0.028577672317624092, -0.04407867044210434, 0.025483528152108192, -0.003781843464821577, 0.004688307177275419, 0.018531672656536102, -0.03116169385612011, -0.0048019057139754295, -0.026836037635803223, -0.014350351877510548, 0.010837831534445286, -0.06330458074808121, 0.06928248703479767, 0.0656457394361496, -0.007691159378737211, -0.01730475015938282, 0.041090093553066254, 0.02159249596297741, 0.03758979216217995, -0.02966003678739071, 0.009005050174891949, -0.04456046223640442, -0.00809420645236969, 0.05240339785814285, 0.032514896243810654, -0.013116448186337948, -0.0073461816646158695, 0.03441111743450165, -0.009540354833006859, 0.04608945921063423, 0.01982123591005802, -0.005406609736382961, -0.021296992897987366, 0.023494049906730652, 0.03828788921236992, -0.013940058648586273, 0.030347922816872597, 0.02897925116121769, 0.012428978458046913, 0.05852682888507843, -0.02798738330602646, -0.019548306241631508, 0.045514535158872604, 0.013041889294981956, -0.0011945286532863975, -0.026951948180794716, 0.0022595087066292763, 0.07110133022069931, -0.025190329179167747, -0.005468340124934912, 0.011966207064688206, 0.014034661464393139, 0.0068773915991187096, 0.0015756178181618452, -0.036726586520671844, 0.044592976570129395, 0.06087091565132141, -0.0404837392270565, 0.012927275151014328, 0.01377822458744049, -0.030055640265345573, 0.02468123845756054, -0.040870897471904755, -0.03636358305811882, -0.044445574283599854, -0.002562769688665867, -0.0003431217046454549, 0.021807657554745674, -0.0053993891924619675, -0.05463255196809769, -0.04666062444448471, -0.0007608231389895082, 0.013046600855886936, 0.01735806092619896, 0.04781966656446457, -0.03619708493351936, -0.03052372857928276, 0.0036290702410042286, 0.00040978778270073235, -0.0028739646077156067, 0.01731037348508835, -0.03179165720939636, -0.00918564759194851, -0.046036772429943085, -0.05824665725231171, -0.033016327768564224, -0.015624278225004673, 0.023172153159976006, -0.014832996763288975, 0.008782131597399712, 0.043412256985902786, 0.013872921466827393, 0.0041373008862137794, -0.001779196667484939, -0.03966676816344261, -0.03136834502220154, -0.03815016523003578, -0.00011705135693773627, 0.008060354739427567, 0.006769947707653046, 0.028488315641880035, 0.01129717007279396, -0.009080888703465462, -0.01568145677447319, -0.09303154051303864, -0.022162960842251778, 0.01271030306816101, 0.02607383206486702, 0.013902615755796432, -0.002193103777244687, -0.02097182534635067, 0.06605318188667297, 0.04059874638915062, -0.03648075461387634, -0.0193612240254879, 0.0099617475643754, -0.03429621830582619, 0.0067133354023098946, 0.00198000343516469, 0.009783726185560226, 0.033879656344652176, 0.010207771323621273, -0.032915398478507996, 0.004255686420947313, 0.04426341503858566, 0.03178880736231804, 0.0020801161881536245, 0.02501203492283821, -0.022853896021842957, -0.04104657471179962, 0.05308161675930023, 0.019083665683865547, 0.0030076715629547834, 0.056144606322050095, -0.011331920512020588, 0.025890987366437912, -0.015040962025523186, -0.05008481815457344, 0.01114057656377554, 0.0277424156665802, 0.02219143696129322, -0.0439792275428772, 0.06277132034301758, 0.04499909281730652, -0.02570340782403946, -0.009865907952189445, -0.02021612599492073, 0.04599343612790108, -0.03763408586382866, 0.011998029425740242, 0.033165208995342255, -0.014962268993258476, -0.008387822657823563, -0.0010148310102522373, 0.006180556491017342, -0.006277256645262241, -0.018967295065522194, -0.010306552052497864, 0.036894749850034714, 0.00830055307596922, 0.01986551471054554, 0.027887871488928795, -0.016174418851733208, -0.0171850323677063, -0.021172840148210526, -0.026348743587732315, 0.04389018565416336, -0.017123723402619362, 0.026668783277273178, 0.025773851200938225, -0.007413084618747234, 0.012948013842105865, 0.019139280542731285, 0.0003367748868186027, 0.016690362244844437, -0.07691502571105957, 0.01763954572379589, -0.030755216255784035, 0.006044711451977491, 0.004187279846519232, -0.0482759028673172, 0.02404124289751053, -0.0519350990653038, 0.013380656018853188, 0.0033716773614287376, 0.02321002073585987, -0.02118704468011856, -0.012493868358433247, -0.016636358574032784, 0.01539529301226139, 0.003670001868158579, 0.005199896637350321, 0.022063016891479492, 0.014657639898359776, 0.0256344061344862, 0.033247292041778564, 0.008521093055605888, 0.0033012833446264267, -0.020455773919820786, 0.011051944456994534, -0.011869029141962528, 0.018905894830822945, 0.002292655874043703, 0.0238907840102911, -0.0345546118915081, 0.03131570294499397, 0.004474756307899952, 0.05983731150627136, 0.04082993417978287, -0.025463756173849106, -0.024433283135294914, -0.02381948009133339, -0.029529588297009468, 0.01001898292452097, 0.030913056805729866, 0.008630766533315182, -0.005406107287853956, 0.03437706083059311, 0.023083271458745003, -0.04851729795336723, -0.000037592981243506074, 0.10204830020666122, 0.025098765268921852, -0.008692270144820213, -0.03670259192585945, 0.0031372038647532463, 0.0021678281482309103, 0.011182991787791252, 0.03961825743317604, -0.012123101390898228, -0.020046118646860123, -0.05512940511107445, 0.006543971132487059, -0.01853839121758938, -0.005167997907847166, 0.0026094948407262564, 0.03427840769290924, 0.047846902161836624, 0.006891352124512196, -0.03223278000950813, 0.002340536331757903, 0.028167031705379486, 0.018488410860300064, -0.03217481076717377, -0.008780435658991337, -0.08146768063306808, 0.010079778730869293, 0.03318845108151436, 0.03822814300656319, -0.02314358949661255, -0.00029516799258999527, -0.049076147377491, -0.03518066927790642, 0.022908378392457962, -0.01847534440457821, 0.0036442254204303026, -0.0074934326112270355, 0.01032440084964037, 0.018629059195518494, -0.022046051919460297, -0.05754367634654045, -0.009075760841369629, -0.05601710081100464, 0.015155801549553871, -0.028059229254722595, -0.015630971640348434, -0.04743879660964012, 0.0379362553358078, -0.0011579326819628477, 0.07711333781480789, -0.02921454980969429, -0.040261756628751755, 0.020223945379257202, -0.004058490041643381, -0.009487220086157322, -0.05093298479914665, 0.03212570399045944, -0.0014274762943387032, -0.003848975757136941, 0.007550335489213467, -0.01041916012763977, -0.018853815272450447, 0.04946337267756462, 0.011234437115490437, -0.014338101260364056, 0.0025945263914763927, -0.03236387297511101, 0.012554972432553768, 0.013302767649292946, -0.0038835201412439346, 0.08296385407447815, 0.002539190696552396, -0.008084234781563282, 0.015741854906082153, -0.058364976197481155, 0.019468404352664948, -0.012711961753666401, 0.013086619786918163, -0.05640707165002823, -0.016425885260105133, -0.0030262754298746586, 0.028497224673628807, -0.0138373589143157, 0.043981753289699554, -0.013130543753504753, -0.007622724398970604, 0.011107590980827808, 0.012344731017947197, 0.007777551654726267, 0.02774721570312977, -0.010784918442368507, 0.01324761938303709, 0.002284267684444785, 0.030536029487848282, 0.025702307000756264, -0.03466920927166939, -0.01990850642323494, 0.023000912740826607, -0.04855094477534294, 0.014807342551648617, -0.023716028779745102, -0.054823923856019974, 0.012465995736420155, -0.0357031412422657, 0.014027668163180351, -0.01069248653948307, -0.007330329157412052, -0.01203073002398014, -0.011904276907444, -0.009889334440231323, -0.020296037197113037, -0.026383135467767715, 0.06414061784744263, -0.0332878902554512, 0.025141196325421333, -0.048522185534238815, -0.020381314679980278, -0.07779902219772339, -0.031144557520747185, 0.02887781709432602, -0.013505200855433941, -0.03819898143410683, -0.03102552890777588, 0.017611289396882057, -0.011741475202143192, -0.006520365830510855, -0.003459920873865485, 0.06590244919061661, -0.015228244476020336, -0.007558444980531931, -0.01190878264605999, 0.0295671746134758, 0.05264086276292801, -0.0009919570293277502, -0.0017018537037074566, 0.05727696046233177, -0.014652583748102188, -0.038770392537117004, -0.0241653174161911, 0.038288380950689316, -0.043505072593688965, -0.017356429249048233, -0.013911851681768894, -0.020248571410775185, 0.03688764572143555, -0.0037358743138611317, 0.010034669190645218, 0.019919129088521004, 0.021630600094795227, 0.032459430396556854, -0.0117874126881361, 0.0005945089505985379, -0.009883674792945385, -0.003064969787374139, -0.004235452506691217, -0.02061741054058075, 0.0030069684144109488, -0.02064269408583641, 0.07106142491102219, -0.019747024402022362, 0.018081147223711014, -0.015515637584030628, 0.06336186081171036, 0.010832804255187511, 0.016130758449435234, 0.010636481456458569, 0.0000287427355942782, 0.054106660187244415, 0.001095886342227459, -0.005720364395529032, 0.01609397679567337, -0.016778960824012756, -0.0652819275856018, 0.008912479504942894, -0.032916534692049026, 0.0005594341200776398, 0.06079408898949623, -0.014860275201499462, 0.03158299997448921, 0.0006079476443119347, 0.00037263549165800214, -0.0021602397318929434, -0.016707802191376686, -0.023121537640690804, 0.013815261423587799, 0.01811896823346615, 0.032367076724767685, -0.020006656646728516, 0.023206336423754692, 0.019104689359664917, -0.023327039554715157, 0.025137316435575485, 0.06701215356588364, -0.00750025175511837, 0.02173607237637043, 0.038159940391778946, -0.022537831217050552, -0.013987639918923378, 0.03641967102885246, -0.018296722322702408, -0.000634953030385077, -0.04110419377684593, -0.07169204950332642, 0.025571849197149277, 0.03417889028787613, 0.028022298589348793, -0.04746268317103386, -0.04720207676291466, -0.036076195538043976, 0.0009783211862668395, 0.011314990930259228, -0.0064925504848361015, 0.029063789173960686, 0.022284185513854027, 0.002086326712742448, 0.02034802734851837, 0.05145652964711189, -0.044222842901945114, -0.0881323292851448, -0.029165709391236305, 0.031588319689035416, -0.031590353697538376, 0.009645303711295128, 0.031949177384376526, -0.015363098122179508, 0.029300294816493988, -0.04439124837517738, 0.02876211516559124, -0.007253636606037617, 0.009649752639234066, -0.055940333753824234, 0.03497796505689621, 0.022481627762317657, 0.03522993251681328, -0.03041815757751465, 0.017254948616027832, 0.11052867770195007, 0.06957312673330307, 0.035924602299928665, -0.05085109919309616, 0.017211787402629852, -0.015110907144844532, -0.031724266707897186, -0.05114014819264412, 0.021376153454184532, 0.0011574423406273127, -0.022862881422042847, 0.010588186793029308, 0.017429132014513016, 0.013507317751646042, 0.014337540604174137, 0.012423593550920486, -0.023796167224645615, -0.035452380776405334, -0.004559702705591917, -0.004891445394605398, 0.004537208005785942, -0.03718271479010582, -0.01077356655150652, -0.02003285475075245, -0.03444504365324974, -0.02525799721479416, -0.04781464859843254, -0.025898408144712448, -0.014125251211225986, 0.013455206528306007, 0.020467400550842285, 0.007144209463149309, 0.009334993548691273, -0.015093876980245113, 0.014597384259104729, -0.03640805557370186, -0.0041220528073608875, -0.009209269657731056, 0.0408155657351017, 0.04871135950088501, -0.015392453409731388, 0.009249811060726643, 0.04266064614057541, -0.016261782497167587, -0.0366266705095768, -0.044364605098962784, -0.04395986720919609, 0.07449404150247574, 0.010588601231575012, 0.02824264205992222, 0.0018837153911590576, -0.014858774840831757, -0.01891937106847763, -0.06261979788541794, 0.0048387134447693825, 0.011499602347612381, 0.03572796657681465, 0.005284308455884457, -0.018115831539034843, 0.011070729233324528, 0.04695095494389534, 0.0020412083249539137, 0.01750355400145054, 0.01631246507167816, -0.018473753705620766, -0.010788030922412872, -0.033603113144636154, 0.046026989817619324, -0.00008702104969415814, -0.009931035339832306, 0.013581261038780212, -0.019374486058950424, -0.00497604813426733, -0.026285279542207718, 0.025687439367175102, -0.019373135641217232, 0.03348936513066292, -0.005305889528244734, 0.022413345053792, -0.02827359363436699, -0.05033000186085701, 0.006327623967081308, -0.03522898256778717, 0.0033222229685634375, -0.044295329600572586, 0.007731849327683449, 0.017581352964043617, 0.035778988152742386, -0.01041872613132, -0.005745097063481808, -0.03258727118372917, 0.05747535824775696, 0.023883497342467308, -0.048230383545160294, -0.0456494502723217, -0.0002443812263663858, -0.031020285561680794, 0.021646399050951004, -0.018931150436401367, 0.06746678054332733, -0.005401431117206812, 0.05374317616224289, 0.00022064452059566975, 0.03432128205895424, -0.021729851141572, -0.006882361136376858, 0.02483329549431801, -0.04145985096693039, -0.0073089986108243465, -0.04470037296414375, -0.0028231614269316196, 0.025793880224227905, -0.013595429249107838, -0.019660774618387222, -0.03747903183102608, -0.03312947228550911, -0.012259507551789284, -0.007380050141364336, 0.01267681922763586, 0.0051560611464083195, -0.0005699798348359764, -0.008207594975829124, 0.020240655168890953, 0.019384445622563362, -0.0110494215041399, -0.0004712808586191386, 0.004831026308238506, 0.022706205025315285, 0.01491702813655138, -0.026911204680800438, 0.007206745445728302, 0.03653101995587349, -0.016640985384583473, 0.038174115121364594, -0.01705615222454071, 0.019935496151447296, 0.021555516868829727, 0.0758742019534111, -0.013230780139565468, -0.01485386025160551, 0.0411875955760479, -0.07027649134397507, -0.03857676684856415, 0.03888838365674019, 0.02428988739848137, 0.011463131755590439, 0.011483223177492619, -0.0120150251314044, -0.026371799409389496, 0.0282460767775774, -0.033587563782930374, -0.004548295866698027, 0.010470839217305183, 0.034826721996068954, 0.01660226657986641, 0.029651395976543427, -0.013615409843623638, 0.01992887631058693, 0.009319378063082695, -0.010702020488679409, 0.039887476712465286, 0.005124275106936693, -0.019222019240260124, 0.028857233002781868, -0.012990886345505714, 0.01747777871787548, 0.004051835276186466, 0.011280402541160583, -0.0028247612062841654, 0.02560681477189064, -0.037046078592538834, 0.03683744743466377, 0.014153304509818554, 0.025583581998944283, -0.10830128192901611, -0.029125234112143517, 0.007560177240520716, 0.026191506534814835, 0.033119089901447296, -0.06365752220153809, -0.0015379743417724967, 0.05836302414536476, -0.020737210288643837, 0.027041997760534286, -0.008265098556876183, -0.0029557151719927788, -0.03732191026210785, -0.019839920103549957, -0.02382199466228485, 0.009462245739996433, 0.0023500204551965, 0.017308315262198448, 0.02526095323264599, 0.0016132742166519165, -0.0043785166926681995, -0.05012970045208931, -0.014898819848895073, 0.01794813945889473, -0.002860400592908263, -0.058751754462718964, 0.03750954940915108, -0.051800698041915894, -0.05428541824221611, 0.04720673710107803, 0.029331136494874954, 0.019045384600758553, -0.009740873239934444, 0.06316418945789337, 0.004944169893860817, 0.05375591292977333, 0.04826722666621208, 0.006815790664404631, 0.013244505040347576, -0.02753388322889805, -0.030102411285042763, -0.0014980935957282782, -0.031159337610006332, 0.03241564333438873, 0.007094942033290863, -0.015613044612109661, -0.01281191036105156, 0.024056080728769302, -0.02730158343911171, -0.02354903146624565, -0.016241135075688362, 0.011614237911999226, -0.010773285292088985, -0.04969213157892227, 0.012389745563268661, -0.013756886124610901, 0.02541065402328968, 0.08494962006807327, 0.038577545434236526, -0.023302875459194183, 0.005902718752622604, 0.0017649891087785363, -0.024835938587784767, 0.020154310390353203, -0.02871948853135109, -0.03404954820871353, -0.08009277284145355, 0.008468235842883587, 0.01061435230076313, -0.010366242378950119, -0.02264387160539627, -0.010467316024005413, -0.0675107017159462, 0.026949511840939522, -0.033705491572618484, 0.03317064046859741, 0.023482559248805046, 0.015434241853654385, -0.02326160855591297, -0.11688540130853653, 0.04529980570077896, -0.0005599161959253252, -0.03552340343594551, -0.02617761678993702, 0.016910793259739876, -0.02083270065486431, -0.013591447845101357, 0.04879039153456688, 0.00711263669654727, 0.004443406127393246, 0.028359396383166313, 0.03461210057139397, 0.028627855703234673, -0.006231372244656086, 0.03102583810687065, -0.01196863129734993, -0.026471661403775215, -0.01390126347541809, -0.003632686799392104, 0.006966901943087578, 0.009275111369788647, -0.015477723442018032, -0.014669752679765224, -0.0001322382886428386, -0.01305257249623537, -0.013793699443340302, 0.02604498341679573, 0.02327873185276985, 0.014157922007143497, 0.06350905448198318, 0.030957693234086037, 0.02009241096675396, 0.01830911450088024, 0.013875951990485191, -0.04294976592063904, -0.006616791244596243, 0.01410650834441185, -0.069045789539814, 0.008915961720049381, 0.004899042658507824, 0.02462664060294628, -0.05195724219083786, -0.010556125082075596, 0.047935694456100464, -0.04008279740810394, 0.03901902213692665, 0.004809582140296698, 0.018689919263124466, 0.03299752250313759, 0.010655028745532036, -0.0015106865903362632, 0.047102656215429306, 0.006340562831610441, 0.031610675156116486, 0.009378408081829548, 0.028782663866877556, -0.022533033043146133, -0.008017059415578842, 0.017320383340120316, -0.033820148557424545, 0.021241597831249237, -0.027980567887425423, 0.04157821089029312, -0.017446473240852356, -0.01088036224246025, 0.03271659463644028, 0.018164774402976036, -0.0067625450901687145, -0.03718631714582443, -0.0002301124477526173, 0.058651939034461975, -0.04538858309388161, -0.008776386268436909, -0.038697078824043274, -0.02967855893075466, -0.009738963097333908, 0.0339282788336277, -0.02346661500632763, 0.02682006172835827, -0.009019684046506882, -0.010630487464368343, 0.018259529024362564, -0.031377553939819336, 0.01488994900137186, -0.06860966235399246, -0.030285995453596115, -0.027287853881716728, -0.0056538889184594154, 0.001339493552222848, -0.031480833888053894, -0.0051078787073493, -0.033024150878190994, -0.013786891475319862, 0.02102711796760559, 0.04139762371778488, -0.046862710267305374, -0.03645690530538559, 0.029370015487074852, 0.034094877541065216, -0.051436491310596466, 0.0002692951529752463, -0.020194901153445244, 0.005325050093233585, -0.03312044218182564, -0.03482407331466675 ]
<p>Recently I attended a workshop on probability, I was asked the following question but I did not find a way to solve it. A discussion on this question can help to learn something new.</p> <p>We were told that, We are guests in a game show and close to win a great fortune. The quiz master asks us to choose one of three (closed) doors. She explains that behind one of them awaits you a million Euros. Once you fixed your choice the quiz mastress opens one of the other doors and shows you that this was only a goat. She gives you a final chance: you may either retain your door or switch to the remaining closed one.</p> <blockquote> <p>(i) Say door 3 is opened. How can we Calculate the conditional probability that our door is the winning one given that the door 3 is a fail, and its complement.</p> <p>(ii) How to Calculate the unconditional probability that our door is the winning one, and its complement.</p> </blockquote> <p>Thank you in advance.</p>
49,611
[ -0.049867454916238785, -0.03979053348302841, 0.018177466467022896, -0.00039235103758983314, 0.018613692373037338, 0.025957152247428894, 0.007175658829510212, -0.001755914301611483, 0.01498876977711916, 0.014346235431730747, 0.05812915414571762, 0.03532199189066887, 0.016984250396490097, 0.008630115538835526, 0.0072876145131886005, -0.004770292434841394, 0.016845472157001495, -0.021082067862153053, -0.005228569731116295, -0.04406172037124634, 0.004484172444790602, -0.023192528635263443, -0.009708630852401257, -0.02237529307603836, -0.017255952581763268, 0.018424775451421738, 0.050492316484451294, -0.03473665192723274, 0.0042815725319087505, 0.04173984006047249, -0.04009341448545456, -0.033794891089200974, 0.0641602873802185, 0.023663299158215523, 0.04344009608030319, 0.009606522507965565, 0.023499133065342903, -0.015108177438378334, -0.015042958781123161, 0.004546052776277065, -0.035617318004369736, 0.0013234212528914213, -0.029285568743944168, 0.06942417472600937, -0.00965116173028946, 0.022817470133304596, -0.05851475149393082, -0.01713356003165245, 0.011052004061639309, -0.04972595348954201, 0.08004657179117203, -0.01378982700407505, 0.02709326334297657, 0.007099900860339403, 0.02349647507071495, -0.021556638181209564, 0.06757917255163193, 0.09888675808906555, 0.0018941195448860526, -0.02574397437274456, 0.012945086695253849, -0.015537120401859283, -0.018097247928380966, -0.017130691558122635, -0.03378123790025711, 0.026274003088474274, 0.0142280962318182, 0.017468176782131195, 0.0509805902838707, -0.002105203690007329, 0.0038710578810423613, 0.018117671832442284, 0.04434460029006004, -0.015524247661232948, 0.031291354447603226, -0.002255582483485341, 0.022968893870711327, 0.06711398810148239, 0.03695280849933624, 0.01917848363518715, 0.025483688339591026, -0.01140348706394434, 0.052810437977313995, 0.02809068374335766, 0.03945156931877136, -0.04844636842608452, 0.05125626176595688, -0.05103057250380516, 0.03561447188258171, 0.027379250153899193, -0.014021613635122776, -0.02520156279206276, 0.04654552415013313, -0.008501652628183365, -0.043208468705415726, 0.024915045127272606, 0.014582071453332901, 0.05574612319469452, 0.0586174875497818, 0.018589291721582413, -0.01142920646816492, -0.03065558709204197, 0.027805721387267113, 0.03022117353975773, -0.021441971883177757, 0.0165255144238472, -0.01676289364695549, 0.023919997736811638, 0.007125394884496927, -0.012959441170096397, -0.054408639669418335, 0.05614585801959038, -0.018098529428243637, 0.018331535160541534, 0.002915342804044485, -0.04919956997036934, -0.01714988984167576, 0.011898313648998737, 0.08638470619916916, 0.05945608392357826, -0.010081900283694267, -0.007301833014935255, 0.015752825886011124, -0.07704698294401169, -0.06396620720624924, -0.01018097810447216, 0.01554301381111145, 0.003924068063497543, -0.052782800048589706, 0.03995504602789879, -0.008155161514878273, -0.03920165076851845, 0.017010025680065155, 0.014571008272469044, 0.012041684240102768, -0.03876465559005737, -0.10604295134544373, -0.03337005153298378, 0.035795945674180984, -0.033605579286813736, -0.03523702546954155, -0.06945919990539551, 0.012813253328204155, 0.055561695247888565, 0.04396950453519821, -0.0317155197262764, 0.009350689128041267, -0.0035212647635489702, 0.005694505292922258, 0.03415020927786827, -0.009903354570269585, 0.010687112808227539, -0.04403712600469589, 0.018760915845632553, -0.015017264522612095, -0.05341483652591705, 0.030724534764885902, 0.033219385892152786, 0.021310117095708847, -0.026219148188829422, 0.017916249111294746, -0.020562903955578804, -0.0013933602022007108, -0.007400949951261282, -0.009257298894226551, -0.03501134365797043, 0.10806234925985336, -0.0016041190829128027, 0.02340126968920231, -0.012381366454064846, 0.037528879940509796, -0.012128039263188839, -0.012148929759860039, -0.003249816596508026, 0.052757877856492996, -0.06210394203662872, 0.027198897674679756, -0.0029267880599945784, 0.02911253087222576, 0.007118656765669584, -0.003802902065217495, 0.005348580423742533, -0.05354861542582512, 0.006210454273968935, 0.040813349187374115, 0.01108701154589653, -0.0048367781564593315, 0.012488453648984432, 0.0028487180825322866, -0.006164195016026497, -0.07754022628068924, -0.060733236372470856, 0.01813490316271782, 0.001934011117555201, -0.011710031889379025, -0.0013684548903256655, 0.01167985424399376, -0.013544982299208641, -0.0212063267827034, -0.03722219541668892, -0.01629636064171791, -0.000991659122519195, 0.02971252053976059, -0.04400744289159775, -0.04029194638133049, 0.04262650012969971, 0.06376960128545761, -0.019476454704999924, 0.05693968012928963, -0.03559756651520729, -0.022893665358424187, -0.017832132056355476, -0.00019942862854804844, 0.02439211681485176, -0.017860284075140953, 0.002649192465469241, 0.029108967632055283, 0.031053822487592697, 0.004107625689357519, -0.016166573390364647, -0.0506560243666172, 0.019525397568941116, 0.06390107423067093, 0.002656053751707077, 0.032915037125349045, 0.002854077611118555, -0.008739689365029335, 0.011194590479135513, 0.022305089980363846, -0.037574056535959244, -0.0330679677426815, -0.02574707195162773, -0.013436397537589073, 0.003260324476286769, -0.016973963007330894, 0.002602470340207219, 0.04029660299420357, -0.009449446573853493, -0.008231648243963718, 0.022873731330037117, -0.012691181153059006, 0.041301168501377106, -0.012499263510107994, 0.02664247900247574, -0.017843272536993027, 0.020645130425691605, -0.008450294844806194, 0.007550831418484449, -0.030862577259540558, -0.02210150845348835, -0.016281215474009514, 0.02631615847349167, -0.01673535443842411, 0.028492920100688934, -0.04098426178097725, -0.03469991311430931, 0.047976620495319366, 0.0006752618355676532, -0.0024194850120693445, 0.028681088238954544, -0.0011370523134246469, -0.01371072232723236, 0.022386373952031136, -0.025406716391444206, 0.02083306573331356, -0.011751667596399784, -0.059726715087890625, 0.01363371592015028, 0.0374743714928627, -0.017969146370887756, 0.024052074179053307, -0.029973823577165604, -0.0541720986366272, 0.038305170834064484, -0.019851697608828545, 0.013551122508943081, -0.03444773331284523, 0.023288225755095482, -0.03509886562824249, -0.03558291122317314, 0.0039197951555252075, 0.008694822899997234, -0.008814800530672073, -0.002725541591644287, -0.06048284471035004, 0.04755566269159317, -0.04327044636011124, -0.038755279034376144, 0.03284873440861702, 0.0005672879051417112, -0.023597728461027145, 0.04647231474518776, 0.00045814330223947763, -0.015629053115844727, -0.036709073930978775, -0.03023044392466545, 0.008496110327541828, -0.03983108326792717, -0.017613032832741737, 0.040154073387384415, 0.025941558182239532, -0.021109100431203842, 0.01393276546150446, -0.0385245643556118, -0.058503951877355576, -0.014126220718026161, -0.02400439791381359, 0.0016856890870258212, 0.003604158293455839, -0.014646386727690697, 0.030444186180830002, 0.0006356094381771982, 0.016141284257173538, -0.05785714089870453, -0.09135518968105316, -0.0051906225271523, 0.004237612243741751, 0.0044234152883291245, 0.0005677297012880445, -0.00999612919986248, 0.08409852534532547, 0.0336591899394989, -0.008474895730614662, -0.013000868260860443, 0.015530976466834545, -0.024285869672894478, -0.028571486473083496, -0.014197954908013344, -0.01927882805466652, -0.01614489033818245, 0.040619734674692154, -0.03619953244924545, 0.012620353139936924, 0.02439762093126774, 0.011173457838594913, -0.002434269292280078, 0.021965550258755684, -0.010413752868771553, 0.007694303058087826, 0.01227868814021349, 0.0034590254072099924, -0.01963341422379017, -0.006701480131596327, -0.00989200547337532, -0.006856101099401712, -0.024558288976550102, -0.06189551576972008, 0.03202920779585838, 0.017330270260572433, 0.013810177333652973, -0.01898864656686783, 0.06084554269909859, -0.004413972608745098, -0.03341738134622574, 0.05065072327852249, -0.006117820739746094, 0.029843980446457863, 0.005945803597569466, 0.033137548714876175, 0.04827946797013283, 0.07278447598218918, -0.015763910487294197, -0.03812142089009285, -0.026176756247878075, 0.013951156288385391, 0.015525083988904953, 0.029406363144516945, -0.042431775480508804, 0.03999309986829758, 0.03240860253572464, 0.030306916683912277, 0.0007898070034570992, -0.01855209469795227, -0.03668567165732384, -0.021148161962628365, -0.00643217982724309, -0.012305098585784435, 0.029572337865829468, 0.03476642072200775, 0.021475711837410927, 0.024096334353089333, -0.0105571448802948, 0.001209262409247458, 0.006685877684503794, -0.09400565177202225, 0.0306195467710495, -0.012859545648097992, -0.02805420197546482, -0.017201926559209824, -0.009389241226017475, 0.022712593898177147, -0.02954401634633541, -0.0356668196618557, 0.010329670272767544, 0.010127387009561062, -0.05745377019047737, 0.0035902441013604403, -0.013334320858120918, -0.023452362045645714, 0.018570566549897194, 0.04741812124848366, 0.03259323537349701, 0.013489059172570705, 0.016250096261501312, 0.04446963220834732, -0.00797890592366457, 0.010654817335307598, 0.03186364844441414, 0.042494043707847595, 0.026231884956359863, 0.03538558632135391, 0.02981824241578579, 0.07154494524002075, -0.04682568833231926, -0.029713736847043037, 0.009065964259207249, 0.012192455120384693, 0.006538123823702335, -0.01694628782570362, 0.02398390881717205, -0.04760510101914406, -0.008981132879853249, -0.0032726924400776625, -0.0047843968495726585, -0.007793841417878866, 0.05557883530855179, 0.08245884627103806, 0.020098848268389702, -0.05558531731367111, 0.0046363105066120625, 0.06687802076339722, 0.06168593838810921, -0.03730775788426399, -0.05470258370041847, -0.00018146945512853563, -0.026397239416837692, 0.011463138274848461, -0.03168546408414841, 0.04802905395627022, -0.02761087194085121, -0.017578881233930588, 0.0185097549110651, -0.013365030288696289, 0.010125590488314629, 0.021226856857538223, -0.003659684443846345, 0.006756260525435209, 0.023541824892163277, -0.019139980897307396, 0.016060909256339073, 0.0032859190832823515, -0.012756215408444405, 0.015533281490206718, -0.03486458584666252, -0.005073195323348045, -0.04155793786048889, 0.031863462179899216, 0.0832810029387474, -0.04362202063202858, -0.023680422455072403, -0.028671005740761757, -0.024150125682353973, -0.008426935411989689, -0.02969137206673622, 0.03023354336619377, 0.014978155493736267, 0.0029007932171225548, 0.012394021265208721, -0.03873906657099724, -0.0338708721101284, 0.033140867948532104, -0.014624267816543579, 0.03684205561876297, -0.022024089470505714, -0.01639801450073719, -0.016956083476543427, 0.00022766084293834865, 0.06964176893234253, 0.027452688664197922, -0.03580847755074501, 0.008480851538479328, 0.012443607673048973, 0.010527853854000568, -0.029527124017477036, -0.07211564481258392, 0.03652457147836685, -0.024328311905264854, -0.043415337800979614, 0.006615740712732077, -0.0023316754959523678, -0.05630039796233177, -0.0041875215247273445, 0.016406113281846046, 0.0026271562092006207, 0.05727909505367279, -0.01835404522716999, 0.0301621463149786, 0.030658461153507233, 0.028836287558078766, 0.025380762293934822, -0.005739596672356129, 0.01508365198969841, 0.029700271785259247, 0.005405469797551632, -0.002358953934162855, -0.0202958881855011, -0.02184896543622017, -0.02171151153743267, 0.0014193464303389192, -0.009859301149845123, 0.03184786066412926, 0.005324290134012699, 0.023636480793356895, 0.0038281134329736233, -0.02614007517695427, -0.061850450932979584, -0.014494901522994041, -0.012377427890896797, 0.0030739784706383944, -0.02869313769042492, -0.007950164377689362, 0.027505869045853615, 0.003625615034252405, -0.0056250994093716145, -0.04628274589776993, -0.0024333451874554157, 0.007285223808139563, -0.017972232773900032, -0.006206660531461239, -0.01827392727136612, -0.036962322890758514, -0.0036948085762560368, -0.04495595768094063, 0.027699843049049377, -0.05635415390133858, 0.042268481105566025, 0.007247464265674353, -0.01734684221446514, -0.03822070360183716, 0.011457876302301884, 0.013230123557150364, 0.003174056066200137, -0.07028871029615402, 0.05812110751867294, 0.02857784926891327, -0.010402414947748184, -0.04269010201096535, 0.0059082992374897, -0.00136342435143888, 0.021093973889946938, -0.019775327295064926, -0.025589685887098312, 0.0025566050317138433, -0.021977677941322327, -0.06687570363283157, -0.05094388499855995, -0.011954107321798801, -0.028083760291337967, 0.03556239232420921, 0.015395842492580414, -0.013312370516359806, 0.011859527789056301, 0.004280915018171072, 0.013687463477253914, -0.006861384026706219, 0.0006968656089156866, 0.00678631104528904, 0.009539013728499413, -0.0017602938460186124, -0.042033422738313675, -0.03752809017896652, 0.00867949053645134, 0.04351670667529106, 0.05117605999112129, -0.05082445219159126, -0.00958374235779047, 0.032507408410310745, -0.02241288311779499, -0.007066638674587011, 0.047333840280771255, -0.00015945719496812671, 0.04838318005204201, 0.039663586765527725, -0.00010571586608421057, 0.013098679482936859, 0.0220296923071146, -0.007041214499622583, -0.003243125742301345, 0.012435533106327057, -0.010507381521165371, 0.015343213453888893, 0.06412182003259659, -0.011143777519464493, -0.005202877335250378, -0.015440642833709717, -0.01215076819062233, 0.02932054176926613, 0.002794932806864381, 0.0028674928471446037, 0.013756177388131618, 0.01760135218501091, -0.03458185866475105, 0.001440750784240663, -0.05387226119637489, 0.014390391297638416, 0.036530353128910065, -0.03996330499649048, 0.026802044361829758, -0.008632298558950424, 0.024573974311351776, -0.02728603035211563, -0.026625487953424454, 0.005797627381980419, 0.009659750387072563, 0.043917667120695114, 0.03473598137497902, -0.041233595460653305, 0.0476858876645565, 0.06615099310874939, 0.03266017138957977, 0.0032635401003062725, 0.0158376544713974, 0.0027292585000395775, 0.015076481737196445, 0.03222152590751648, -0.020843271166086197, -0.0419522225856781, 0.05347837880253792, -0.04669589549303055, 0.005679675377905369, -0.018987618386745453, -0.018530631437897682, 0.03419893980026245, 0.019656119868159294, -0.006536019034683704, -0.014262336306273937, -0.010007557459175587, -0.04783914238214493, 0.03549966588616371, 0.010763834230601788, 0.0035425752867013216, 0.017831722274422646, 0.015168823301792145, 0.056039683520793915, 0.01363211777061224, 0.01945466734468937, -0.015061399899423122, -0.04235990345478058, 0.014851432293653488, -0.04774118587374687, -0.02630169503390789, 0.012774492613971233, 0.00938758160918951, 0.0007427710224874318, 0.039458032697439194, -0.056216780096292496, -0.0148114999756217, 0.014373887330293655, 0.047609731554985046, 0.00896646548062563, 0.081901416182518, 0.023278385400772095, 0.04427098482847214, -0.020207861438393593, 0.02431529387831688, 0.11566261202096939, 0.03279440850019455, 0.0389692485332489, -0.07077410817146301, 0.006185258738696575, 0.008192622102797031, 0.01874113455414772, 0.009373185224831104, 0.01870766282081604, 0.023327456787228584, 0.006416631396859884, 0.025199390947818756, 0.07199127227067947, 0.025985928252339363, -0.0077422503381967545, 0.014401156455278397, -0.04883750528097153, -0.0531911738216877, 0.027688441798090935, -0.00847704615443945, 0.012398612685501575, -0.010915916413068771, -0.00202373368665576, 0.016619712114334106, -0.0004767993523273617, -0.04901542887091637, -0.008354376070201397, -0.011815899983048439, 0.007999038323760033, -0.015231701545417309, -0.007010506931692362, 0.0062788184732198715, 0.007771923206746578, -0.01641683280467987, -0.010150407440960407, 0.03135444596409798, 0.058074936270713806, -0.024941734969615936, 0.029394015669822693, 0.03779047355055809, -0.019111614674329758, -0.018566928803920746, 0.017236243933439255, 0.030856043100357056, -0.05196232721209526, -0.053766701370477676, -0.015502538532018661, 0.0004830352554563433, 0.01023988239467144, 0.02782769314944744, -0.015899110585451126, 0.001983833499252796, 0.03799806162714958, -0.04487110674381256, -0.011102699674665928, 0.013577384874224663, -0.02029695175588131, -0.051316842436790466, -0.03899436071515083, -0.005147465504705906, 0.01611514762043953, 0.019341055303812027, 0.0003683653485495597, 0.02019645832479, -0.020396580919623375, -0.016602350398898125, -0.03828953579068184, 0.027337176725268364, 0.02639300376176834, 0.0023464078549295664, -0.024437611922621727, -0.02132989466190338, -0.02742406353354454, -0.014113220386207104, 0.03326435014605522, 0.02112983912229538, -0.0026031166780740023, -0.008515574038028717, 0.010571426711976528, 0.006580800283700228, -0.02497592568397522, 0.031078984960913658, -0.05436810106039047, 0.003921328578144312, -0.03557952493429184, -0.01532743964344263, 0.02688770554959774, 0.029704846441745758, 0.02419288083910942, -0.023840149864554405, 0.019570276141166687, 0.04507385939359665, -0.005482668988406658, -0.024880949407815933, -0.024604875594377518, -0.0029146948363631964, -0.05023224279284477, -0.03853575512766838, -0.04668829217553139, 0.019207920879125595, 0.028158757835626602, -0.01222712080925703, -0.01790596917271614, -0.013141585513949394, -0.004030466545373201, 0.003475739387795329, 0.007565643638372421, -0.034413449466228485, -0.06100979447364807, 0.026545656844973564, -0.010388029739260674, -0.014845689758658409, -0.02490471489727497, 0.02829981967806816, -0.033367715775966644, 0.03813665360212326, -0.0057090651243925095, -0.03566398844122887, -0.005454412195831537, 0.023265322670340538, 0.058894556015729904, -0.005889056716114283, 0.004919171798974276, 0.023438241332769394, 0.008483817800879478, 0.014563611708581448, -0.043179951608181, -0.020232316106557846, -0.008086690679192543, 0.0229080468416214, 0.007925719954073429, 0.025271374732255936, 0.026664728298783302, -0.028892075642943382, -0.030832232907414436, 0.006076636258512735, 0.011648520827293396, 0.07458562403917313, 0.0004179727111477405, 0.005355025641620159, 0.04502292349934578, -0.073382668197155, -0.032868001610040665, 0.017739778384566307, 0.031680382788181305, 0.0529644750058651, 0.048211995512247086, 0.011174413375556469, 0.01425123680382967, 0.002882210072129965, -0.04750286787748337, -0.02050696685910225, 0.0011098913382738829, 0.016016928479075432, 0.015031108632683754, -0.01636487990617752, -0.02440865896642208, -0.009311740286648273, 0.016116417944431305, 0.03190784528851509, 0.05656786635518074, -0.007205770816653967, 0.017435913905501366, -0.03797788918018341, 0.003893102053552866, -0.0020811480935662985, 0.01660199835896492, -0.015542042441666126, -0.0002240016619907692, 0.03993166983127594, -0.0037880318704992533, 0.059815600514411926, -0.014560436829924583, -0.01366040576249361, -0.07961954921483994, -0.04643643647432327, 0.010781434364616871, -0.03428804874420166, 0.08098676800727844, -0.06533771008253098, 0.002521238522604108, 0.014383831061422825, -0.055648863315582275, -0.006888171657919884, 0.024441208690404892, 0.01946050301194191, -0.05128986015915871, 0.010948765091598034, -0.006002374924719334, 0.0332765132188797, -0.02415136620402336, -0.0023136737290769815, 0.016990795731544495, 0.00716231158003211, -0.022704539820551872, -0.0713096633553505, 0.0026803475338965654, 0.022569281980395317, -0.06506296992301941, -0.03229166939854622, 0.07101759314537048, -0.04345422238111496, -0.03331156447529793, 0.04526183754205704, -0.00698049645870924, 0.012104849331080914, -0.017094748094677925, 0.018972687423229218, -0.0012457052944228053, 0.04796018451452255, 0.043529558926820755, 0.015236085280776024, 0.05266716703772545, 0.02718200720846653, 0.013921667821705341, 0.011587009765207767, -0.014408158138394356, -0.016201864928007126, 0.04109032452106476, -0.015566452406346798, -0.013391845859587193, 0.000451143947429955, -0.013786472380161285, 0.03243960067629814, 0.013914592564105988, 0.0074950517155230045, 0.003213200019672513, -0.04957941174507141, -0.03277212008833885, -0.04319118335843086, -0.02667064592242241, 0.01689179055392742, 0.034661173820495605, 0.021858112886548042, -0.00900909211486578, -0.020209534093737602, -0.054347146302461624, 0.04024558141827583, -0.004401492420583963, -0.024435805156826973, -0.006341931875795126, 0.01592537946999073, 0.007411133497953415, 0.023772550746798515, 0.0511321984231472, -0.048980168998241425, -0.019451046362519264, -0.016631435602903366, -0.022514449432492256, 0.023771153762936592, -0.031718604266643524, -0.03128604590892792, 0.0021549491211771965, -0.07767282426357269, 0.013460529036819935, 0.023400425910949707, -0.003931403160095215, -0.042762745171785355, -0.002616191515699029, -0.03648477792739868, -0.031044449657201767, 0.047092337161302567, -0.04459579661488533, 0.014953424222767353, -0.005078818649053574, 0.011607561260461807, 0.054131556302309036, -0.0449046716094017, 0.02595341019332409, -0.022295774891972542, 0.025734642520546913, -0.01934959925711155, 0.003349599428474903, 0.005276881158351898, -0.011817405931651592, 0.03394915908575058, -0.02248833142220974, -0.032006993889808655, -0.00532892532646656, 0.005447406321763992, 0.026721367612481117, 0.013512963429093361, 0.010095607489347458, 0.04490504786372185, -0.007340030279010534, -0.0029046216513961554, 0.036518558859825134, -0.00884206686168909, -0.06565876305103302, -0.004337973892688751, -0.029573414474725723, -0.01429503969848156, 0.010194101370871067, -0.0068869078531861305, 0.033106397837400436, -0.04801091179251671, -0.029083114117383957, 0.02821524441242218, -0.012376520782709122, -0.017174674198031425, 0.03310660645365715, -0.0054372320882976055, 0.04893661290407181, -0.0076607465744018555, 0.02641012892127037, 0.00024842063430696726, -0.009599006734788418, -0.0012355641229078174, 0.002390650799497962, 0.01902344822883606, 0.0010013638529926538, 0.036747902631759644, 0.04109453409910202, -0.03235770761966705, 0.008802198804914951, 0.00427798368036747, 0.04372642561793327, -0.027893321588635445, -0.007853527553379536, 0.03817161172628403, -0.0012791756307706237, -0.03733094781637192, -0.03417148441076279, -0.021214131265878677, 0.06587298959493637, -0.005607071798294783, 0.030109602957963943, -0.012264850549399853, 0.029292747378349304, -0.043413955718278885, -0.027689719572663307, 0.019124353304505348, -0.007100685499608517, -0.005860559176653624, 0.007532830815762281, -0.011124015785753727, 0.026430165395140648, 0.06027538329362869, 0.026092343032360077, 0.025348952040076256, 0.0353332981467247, 0.002548803109675646, -0.056509364396333694, -0.02366255223751068, -0.0038853639271110296, 0.005293001886457205, 0.004659656900912523, 0.013917606323957443, 0.04649021476507187, 0.0015857289545238018, -0.010772478766739368, -0.04817844554781914, 0.07469715178012848, -0.014632496051490307, -0.03762729838490486, -0.07901214063167572, 0.05179031193256378, -0.00003038771501451265, 0.01002421323210001 ]
<p>Let $X_1, X_2, ..., X_n$ be a random iid sample from a population with mean $\theta$.</p> <p>Now I am wondering about the intuition behind $E(X_1| \overline X ) = \overline X$, the sample mean.</p> <p>If we just consider $X_1$ (or any $X_i$ for that matter) we have that $E(X_1) = \theta$ as the expected value of any random observation from a population will be the population mean.</p> <p>Now given that we know $\overline X$ how come that changes what we expect to get for $X_1$? $X_1$ is still the same random observation from the population as before...but it seems that knowing the sample mean 'overrides' what we expect to get for an observation...is this correct?</p>
74,333
[ -0.016654927283525467, -0.01852705515921116, 0.007972312159836292, -0.0322243794798851, -0.0037082850467413664, 0.044194165617227554, -0.01272630225867033, 0.024986058473587036, 0.007480039726942778, -0.05328547582030296, 0.025452610105276108, 0.05501792952418327, 0.0628267228603363, -0.018908167257905006, 0.06250011920928955, 0.044123679399490356, -0.047590695321559906, 0.010160444304347038, -0.013777566142380238, -0.010601778514683247, 0.037216898053884506, 0.04456150531768799, 0.02070608176290989, -0.02529728040099144, -0.059611812233924866, 0.04374377429485321, 0.04292159527540207, -0.007231936790049076, 0.04783090949058533, 0.0793423280119896, -0.007154360413551331, -0.03036518581211567, -0.013675038702785969, 0.025371696799993515, 0.01699591800570488, 0.010427144356071949, 0.006529083009809256, -0.01951424963772297, 0.051673393696546555, 0.042017243802547455, -0.07149798423051834, -0.006866079289466143, 0.012422850355505943, 0.0061540547758340836, -0.044771574437618256, 0.01089987438172102, -0.009952799417078495, -0.041096970438957214, 0.014000453986227512, -0.030431680381298065, 0.0907398983836174, -0.008037053048610687, 0.022621480748057365, 0.05027336627244949, -0.017592960968613625, 0.01635999232530594, 0.04321689158678055, 0.035217881202697754, -0.00455843610689044, -0.06087410822510719, 0.006749417167156935, -0.02608201839029789, -0.0029932076577097178, -0.008458390831947327, -0.029996933415532112, -0.0050991494208574295, 0.0024122584145516157, -0.006927126087248325, 0.04346271604299545, -0.00203551072627306, 0.022550683468580246, 0.02694203518331051, 0.014956084080040455, 0.0290557611733675, 0.00784244854003191, -0.02386091835796833, 0.01465996727347374, 0.00890938751399517, 0.04776240512728691, 0.03504398465156555, 0.017063608393073082, 0.018213437870144844, 0.043956462293863297, 0.03876239061355591, 0.011243194341659546, 0.006326089613139629, 0.06418567895889282, -0.0072714160196483135, 0.026665888726711273, 0.026226526126265526, 0.014082196168601513, 0.03312913700938225, 0.028898131102323532, -0.06970871239900589, -0.0159457940608263, 0.0626247301697731, -0.026604488492012024, 0.024408871307969093, -0.009703258983790874, 0.0039008173625916243, 0.015827195718884468, -0.028525827452540398, 0.0064208353869616985, 0.05533134937286377, -0.044794872403144836, -0.02702728658914566, -0.03204435110092163, -0.012589274905622005, -0.010230777785182, -0.020778672769665718, 0.03140614926815033, 0.015883876010775566, 0.004576432518661022, 0.02306440845131874, 0.006686592474579811, -0.004053330980241299, 0.04323897883296013, -0.009603743441402912, 0.034986305981874466, 0.039305828511714935, 0.01622164621949196, -0.015857333317399025, 0.012750942260026932, -0.020346222445368767, -0.028299305588006973, 0.043711576610803604, 0.005643983371555805, 0.01086258701980114, -0.03320801258087158, 0.013145028613507748, -0.0013288338668644428, -0.017208034172654152, 0.04895693436264992, 0.04688771814107895, 0.031016521155834198, -0.014681657776236534, -0.10355368256568909, -0.04756385087966919, 0.02129974775016308, -0.01551281288266182, -0.014512739144265652, -0.07640746235847473, 0.023199038580060005, 0.025133486837148666, 0.01532062143087387, 0.011539450846612453, 0.054804716259241104, 0.02398492582142353, -0.001942961709573865, 0.026774395257234573, -0.02087065950036049, -0.024810999631881714, 0.015618870034813881, -0.028522914275527, -0.008223985321819782, -0.06772786378860474, 0.019095344468951225, -0.011311766691505909, -0.040448933839797974, -0.017347298562526703, 0.03101494163274765, -0.025596795603632927, 0.0023510996252298355, -0.022285986691713333, 0.03362955525517464, -0.03711351379752159, 0.09927531331777573, -0.008186718448996544, 0.03776674345135689, 0.029884515330195427, 0.021450458094477654, 0.044950418174266815, 0.010101201012730598, 0.07624363154172897, 0.043402381241321564, -0.03754275664687157, -0.014097810722887516, -0.033739540725946426, -0.001116830506362021, 0.0064129396341741085, -0.07149866968393326, -0.013550194911658764, -0.004379797261208296, -0.0056630633771419525, 0.03635541722178459, 0.030453063547611237, -0.002284675370901823, -0.01861831359565258, 0.01930597983300686, -0.04128487408161163, -0.020789725705981255, -0.06166151165962219, 0.021100960671901703, 0.0006648084963671863, -0.02351507730782032, 0.008707687258720398, 0.0012997976737096906, 0.016174817457795143, -0.01795084774494171, -0.004414603114128113, -0.025024190545082092, 0.033850446343421936, 0.026800749823451042, -0.07247999310493469, 0.0066940211690962315, 0.05349297448992729, 0.031114857643842697, 0.0041799903847277164, 0.027117643505334854, -0.027321411296725273, -0.04573725536465645, 0.028750430792570114, -0.013544186018407345, 0.011808419600129128, -0.015312699601054192, -0.0034330717753618956, 0.012934902682900429, 0.0023524342104792595, -0.02009720355272293, 0.06355757266283035, -0.04783378168940544, 0.07993150502443314, 0.031273048371076584, 0.00140316819306463, -0.017362108454108238, 0.023138580843806267, 0.014863391406834126, -0.011809516698122025, -0.015813250094652176, -0.023315999656915665, -0.033824317157268524, 0.0011159718269482255, 0.014691335149109364, 0.012563405558466911, -0.005852875299751759, 0.016723396256566048, 0.05808721110224724, 0.015097834169864655, 0.013808773830533028, 0.014392019249498844, 0.01771378517150879, 0.0028923978097736835, -0.010768463835120201, 0.02017119713127613, 0.021197335794568062, 0.016078898683190346, 0.018854355439543724, -0.018501611426472664, 0.039840810000896454, -0.010771194472908974, 0.017015384510159492, 0.03868766501545906, -0.014704247936606407, 0.013687561266124249, -0.00018362195987720042, 0.006547475699335337, -0.00424652174115181, -0.029642868787050247, 0.02606535702943802, 0.004584205336868763, -0.007393771316856146, -0.0015763652045279741, -0.019310912117362022, 0.004406643565744162, 0.034902241080999374, 0.0254677627235651, -0.04767896234989166, 0.01200734544545412, 0.014577043242752552, -0.02810535579919815, 0.007814936339855194, -0.019144371151924133, -0.07242922484874725, -0.004260654095560312, 0.02452385053038597, 0.025563344359397888, -0.02893492951989174, 0.007886622101068497, -0.039860717952251434, -0.00986834242939949, -0.04536353051662445, -0.009364373981952667, -0.004404525272548199, 0.006363399792462587, -0.04266982898116112, 0.019526282325387, -0.031961433589458466, -0.024094145745038986, 0.020797373726963997, 0.003658450208604336, -0.004335341509431601, 0.02424200437963009, -0.032378993928432465, -0.049395814538002014, -0.005742400884628296, -0.03745315223932266, -0.004162157885730267, -0.0023383779916912317, -0.013554842211306095, 0.05665818974375725, -0.012709434144198895, -0.01749352738261223, 0.03801451623439789, -0.04588283225893974, -0.05364053696393967, -0.02422667294740677, 0.01901613548398018, 0.02122579887509346, -0.006557659711688757, 0.04025433957576752, 0.04396722838282585, -0.016721725463867188, -0.028959086164832115, -0.04722137376666069, -0.08219597488641739, 0.011591663584113121, -0.012694096192717552, 0.016724074259400368, 0.03061124123632908, -0.005781110841780901, 0.06047356501221657, 0.023038607090711594, -0.029003294184803963, -0.01326044462621212, 0.02857924997806549, 0.012609756551682949, -0.03043733723461628, 0.05072540417313576, 0.036964550614356995, -0.02221696637570858, 0.044178977608680725, 0.03361948952078819, 0.023567531257867813, 0.0178365558385849, 0.008243735879659653, 0.012794828973710537, -0.010208060033619404, 0.008467157371342182, 0.000365033425623551, 0.05872641131281853, 0.02199837565422058, -0.01610128954052925, -0.006745471619069576, 0.026492178440093994, 0.05340056121349335, -0.0005067092133685946, -0.013690212741494179, 0.03695767745375633, -0.02398846484720707, 0.03470711410045624, -0.032335806638002396, 0.06920135021209717, 0.00048137811245396733, -0.0019634051714092493, -0.0010052189463749528, 0.008973238989710808, 0.004536666441708803, -0.027769120410084724, -0.03058876469731331, 0.05127481371164322, 0.00445021316409111, -0.06232180446386337, 0.004645088687539101, -0.019794592633843422, -0.014983521774411201, 0.01691100001335144, -0.023251274600625038, -0.021756593137979507, 0.014545965939760208, 0.07132852077484131, -0.032002437859773636, -0.009270935319364071, -0.030029425397515297, 0.00034749606857076287, -0.04440418630838394, -0.0034323770087212324, -0.0033660619519650936, 0.038252633064985275, 0.01789112016558647, 0.0741969496011734, 0.01449232641607523, -0.004729720298200846, -0.013930893503129482, -0.00806910265237093, -0.06563760340213776, -0.0038787496741861105, -0.007938379421830177, -0.0226933304220438, -0.03787127509713173, -0.05557909607887268, 0.07690411806106567, -0.004337618127465248, 0.01379125751554966, -0.03205995261669159, 0.004507079720497131, -0.040815968066453934, -0.0034437261056154966, -0.0018853109795600176, -0.020194143056869507, 0.005016475450247526, 0.0659790188074112, 0.013780391775071621, -0.03014490194618702, 0.029102953150868416, -0.012027112767100334, 0.007480709347873926, -0.026703475043177605, -0.029110990464687347, -0.0009462691959924996, 0.03270520269870758, 0.022536812350153923, 0.011959679424762726, 0.0007800863822922111, -0.0274285189807415, 0.05007711052894592, -0.0031990997958928347, 0.09441733360290527, 0.04094782471656799, -0.016877422109246254, 0.014114727266132832, -0.0230745580047369, -0.03149257227778435, 0.015859726816415787, 0.012456410564482212, -0.0038935516495257616, -0.003316414076834917, 0.051077574491500854, 0.014421969652175903, -0.07464558631181717, -0.0028638725634664297, 0.01988314278423786, 0.01144983246922493, 0.02916104905307293, -0.028871634975075722, 0.015008428134024143, -0.04465997964143753, 0.005263474304229021, 0.0037768783513456583, -0.031884483993053436, -0.0011869012378156185, -0.010823777876794338, 0.04075620323419571, -0.008869663812220097, -0.029704509302973747, -0.03484254702925682, -0.009059848263859749, 0.05082354322075844, -0.01067223958671093, -0.048991937190294266, 0.01879875175654888, 0.015891775488853455, 0.042466484010219574, 0.03573177382349968, 0.044563669711351395, -0.06635067611932755, -0.019644591957330704, 0.022247998043894768, 0.04223570600152016, -0.03713226318359375, -0.0020120195113122463, -0.05337752774357796, 0.025747409090399742, 0.010268935933709145, -0.024869298562407494, 0.03322896361351013, -0.047254763543605804, -0.029336147010326385, -0.02509593777358532, -0.021533099934458733, -0.05851365625858307, 0.005631025414913893, -0.01009329129010439, 0.0485084168612957, 0.0045151421800255775, 0.006286019459366798, -0.028061537072062492, -0.003557554678991437, 0.04138922318816185, 0.04366261139512062, -0.019491691142320633, -0.03436735272407532, 0.004465118981897831, 0.07496799528598785, 0.01572508178651333, -0.07898801565170288, 0.04078930988907814, -0.007721736095845699, 0.00880354829132557, 0.005633763037621975, -0.02970636449754238, -0.07412102073431015, 0.010560543276369572, -0.003958772402256727, -0.003489956259727478, 0.006693597417324781, -0.005658721551299095, 0.028638619929552078, 0.03533845767378807, 0.01805349625647068, 0.05810929834842682, 0.009468103758990765, 0.012156715616583824, -0.008535304106771946, -0.04079454764723778, 0.029318856075406075, -0.06652233004570007, -0.03888706490397453, -0.04358302801847458, 0.0012720264494419098, -0.017112016677856445, 0.033717211335897446, 0.008686736226081848, 0.03817671909928322, -0.023566240444779396, -0.055249106138944626, -0.004724473226815462, 0.02226429618895054, 0.03279547393321991, 0.027739690616726875, -0.01385406032204628, 0.012585378251969814, 0.012281611561775208, -0.010301453061401844, 0.025885630398988724, 0.0056295632384717464, -0.002039206214249134, 0.005009451415389776, -0.039431944489479065, 0.006758110597729683, -0.050663579255342484, -0.03777250275015831, 0.021881872788071632, -0.03692419081926346, 0.02540012262761593, -0.029585635289549828, 0.036212995648384094, 0.009303590282797813, -0.01020915899425745, -0.022968027740716934, 0.016566364094614983, -0.015688763931393623, 0.02041153609752655, -0.03202954679727554, 0.001130407676100731, 0.03072146698832512, 0.013550608418881893, -0.07876831293106079, -0.04443167895078659, -0.001435518846847117, -0.009212026372551918, 0.010438850149512291, -0.019114229828119278, 0.015615087002515793, 0.022510234266519547, -0.05452578142285347, -0.009583111852407455, 0.02568330056965351, -0.0018796335207298398, -0.009263386949896812, -0.03659415990114212, 0.04086952283978462, 0.08889152109622955, -0.03334624692797661, -0.016128959134221077, 0.039080772548913956, -0.030648261308670044, -0.007624981924891472, -0.004601665306836367, 0.04924046993255615, -0.03326891362667084, 0.015972459688782692, -0.0332397036254406, -0.003448428586125374, 0.021111344918608665, -0.014178851619362831, -0.0190317053347826, 0.008432592265307903, 0.008844760246574879, 0.009847484529018402, -0.03165134787559509, -0.01869983598589897, 0.01154380664229393, 0.0520322322845459, 0.00507767079398036, 0.011711430735886097, -0.012881187722086906, -0.03942419961094856, 0.030182814225554466, 0.01167952362447977, -0.02064545638859272, 0.02516123093664646, 0.08691826462745667, -0.021163033321499825, -0.008151227608323097, -0.008832037448883057, -0.016113299876451492, 0.04956407472491264, -0.001889875391498208, -0.02159312181174755, 0.023312725126743317, 0.035999756306409836, -0.03598330542445183, -0.017285794019699097, -0.04981166496872902, -0.00932356622070074, 0.03912397474050522, 0.015287082642316818, 0.03890731930732727, 0.03829169645905495, -0.01224274281412363, -0.007097093854099512, -0.03291315212845802, -0.007739167660474777, -0.018028443679213524, -0.0284890066832304, 0.03724316880106926, -0.023716958239674568, -0.017154451459646225, 0.013980531133711338, 0.04740848392248154, 0.004084415268152952, -0.002729782834649086, 0.01974792219698429, 0.01556319184601307, 0.011146843433380127, -0.03331388160586357, -0.033070579171180725, 0.03055397979915142, -0.011195612139999866, -0.0008241701289080083, -0.053357549011707306, -0.006047034170478582, 0.03276412934064865, 0.0013118975330144167, 0.003457688493654132, -0.05186928063631058, -0.004365861415863037, -0.0552687831223011, -0.019860850647091866, 0.001713791978545487, 0.029896577820181847, 0.029686445370316505, -0.010323725640773773, -0.000796477310359478, -0.003400372341275215, 0.011912556365132332, -0.018597988411784172, -0.07736384123563766, -0.020839927718043327, -0.027075352147221565, -0.03737153857946396, 0.007986806333065033, 0.0022274896036833525, -0.024243369698524475, 0.030598806217312813, -0.062188971787691116, 0.04295579344034195, -0.02651364542543888, 0.01985831744968891, -0.03254219517111778, 0.06832528114318848, 0.012723731808364391, 0.06477957963943481, -0.004349721595644951, -0.006130899302661419, 0.0946006029844284, 0.018123110756278038, 0.038297101855278015, -0.05610036104917526, 0.009625264443457127, -0.0093295369297266, 0.015795966610312462, -0.020733190700411797, 0.02296490967273712, 0.0007955635664984584, 0.031711507588624954, 0.019101165235042572, 0.033047739416360855, 0.03178705647587776, -0.05068158730864525, 0.04522409290075302, -0.02918681688606739, -0.024557912722229958, -0.0015868571354076266, -0.011565975844860077, -0.0316195972263813, -0.012349257245659828, -0.07878652215003967, 0.032149843871593475, -0.008067547343671322, 0.0037975728046149015, -0.04308752343058586, -0.033941734582185745, -0.030918853357434273, -0.0035034569445997477, -0.004567126743495464, 0.00761553505435586, 0.006982511840760708, -0.029613805934786797, -0.03285916522145271, 0.014158767648041248, -0.012317146174609661, -0.004089329857379198, 0.03592301532626152, 0.014983939938247204, -0.01070096530020237, 0.010499358177185059, 0.011644606478512287, 0.01261161733418703, -0.03658978268504143, -0.019499417394399643, -0.020904716104269028, 0.050495825707912445, -0.001605054596439004, 0.011897278018295765, -0.03714333474636078, -0.0016509767156094313, -0.04599623382091522, -0.0438920333981514, -0.024128086864948273, -0.002698182128369808, 0.0073663219809532166, -0.017769217491149902, -0.020714566111564636, -0.011757239699363708, 0.042704325169324875, -0.01996932365000248, 0.022303156554698944, 0.03578440845012665, -0.04433922469615936, 0.0037959860637784004, -0.03610079735517502, 0.040409501641988754, 0.022315112873911858, -0.03734812140464783, 0.0025244879070669413, -0.004011998418718576, -0.042745642364025116, -0.04303814470767975, -0.010848114266991615, -0.045461077243089676, 0.04274970293045044, -0.017637642100453377, -0.0061647635884583, -0.013173462823033333, -0.048646826297044754, 0.026072802022099495, -0.007747110910713673, -0.0007476637256331742, -0.05716454237699509, 0.011541111394762993, -0.012978162616491318, 0.013975134119391441, 0.03674978390336037, 0.01926613040268421, 0.03484748676419258, 0.05838865786790848, -0.008746963925659657, -0.009762376546859741, 0.008382637985050678, 0.025149337947368622, -0.001017312053591013, -0.004719015210866928, 0.006852055434137583, 0.05393346771597862, 0.027516042813658714, 0.017474614083766937, -0.029473263770341873, 0.03214297071099281, 0.015398629009723663, 0.016323411837220192, -0.008283566683530807, -0.04819710925221443, 0.041111722588539124, 0.022730117663741112, 0.014903679490089417, -0.04186452180147171, -0.04751482978463173, -0.02989194542169571, -0.006080804392695427, -0.008671792224049568, -0.03009447269141674, -0.02304661087691784, -0.01575750671327114, -0.024957843124866486, 0.06924822181463242, 0.0038990508764982224, -0.03343435749411583, -0.017311938107013702, -0.01667528972029686, 0.015746215358376503, -0.015415720641613007, -0.04543790593743324, 0.02034696750342846, 0.008887029252946377, -0.03411475196480751, 0.03067735768854618, 0.017512451857328415, -0.007178186438977718, -0.016452686861157417, 0.0008422347018495202, -0.03331461548805237, 0.03132249042391777, -0.039449386298656464, -0.03804958611726761, 0.05639232322573662, -0.0360163077712059, -0.011450514197349548, 0.03504185378551483, -0.010252542793750763, 0.050659727305173874, 0.02036205865442753, -0.01601600833237171, -0.028510184958577156, 0.013679745607078075, -0.051245227456092834, -0.022364864125847816, -0.02743680402636528, -0.00925208069384098, -0.007684027310460806, 0.02338835597038269, 0.019629983231425285, 0.009888886474072933, 0.003740910906344652, 0.04240284487605095, 0.025009039789438248, -0.016066158190369606, -0.020100267603993416, 0.02977043390274048, 0.024742282927036285, 0.013881757855415344, 0.001080272370018065, 0.002845696872100234, 0.03725428134202957, 0.052741073071956635, -0.0364469476044178, 0.04770509898662567, -0.04241131991147995, -0.007440822198987007, -0.075974240899086, -0.02536330558359623, 0.040232088416814804, -0.00900407787412405, 0.031077297404408455, -0.0294675063341856, -0.018404975533485413, 0.018315082415938377, -0.04238618537783623, 0.007489596027880907, 0.015412062406539917, -0.03191511705517769, -0.06260229647159576, 0.04622550308704376, -0.007749364711344242, 0.018516570329666138, 0.03751010820269585, 0.012161418795585632, 0.03759939223527908, 0.016171133145689964, 0.011450115591287613, -0.05263456702232361, -0.05587970092892647, 0.03901246562600136, 0.001737958169542253, -0.04025523364543915, 0.031641844660043716, -0.03825673833489418, -0.015003851614892483, 0.040550317615270615, 0.029244842007756233, 0.017035270109772682, 0.017262428998947144, 0.019025638699531555, 0.0007135167834348977, 0.02155432477593422, 0.03151795268058777, -0.017860515043139458, -0.0022390857338905334, 0.023082219064235687, 0.014503651298582554, 0.01597278192639351, -0.012631523422896862, -0.04167121648788452, 0.05008826032280922, -0.0047193835489451885, -0.015487777069211006, 0.0034699260722845793, -0.004180471878498793, -0.05342230200767517, -0.012219834141433239, 0.023603208363056183, -0.022209038957953453, -0.042397238314151764, 0.054106585681438446, -0.006458261515945196, -0.028657907620072365, 0.047423914074897766, 0.020390741527080536, 0.002385214902460575, -0.0023197131231427193, 0.011125742457807064, -0.02834157459437847, -0.00471630459651351, 0.02776149846613407, -0.011140256188809872, -0.0592569038271904, -0.021811429411172867, 0.01402518805116415, 0.011536461301147938, 0.02248394675552845, -0.04155757650732994, -0.057494573295116425, 0.014528322033584118, 0.01066057663410902, 0.013977015390992165, -0.03441184386610985, -0.04044289141893387, -0.02528640627861023, -0.06343865394592285, 0.08743870258331299, -0.02047768048942089, -0.0063751633279025555, -0.07503646612167358, -0.01896229013800621, -0.04395376145839691, -0.00402478501200676, 0.03896976634860039, 0.05073575675487518, 0.022967971861362457, 0.017371946945786476, 0.03929566219449043, 0.016165640205144882, -0.03770395740866661, 0.030904646962881088, -0.04734601452946663, 0.0007903130608610809, -0.016322849318385124, -0.027170469984412193, 0.0038230970967561007, 0.025242911651730537, -0.00978490337729454, -0.025399452075362206, 0.031070226803421974, 0.0001272251975024119, 0.029538847506046295, 0.03566667437553406, 0.014721960760653019, 0.019487211480736732, 0.05235897749662399, -0.0020616629626601934, 0.022641416639089584, 0.005965075455605984, 0.0011863592080771923, -0.04941496253013611, 0.027252089232206345, -0.04762222245335579, -0.01625005342066288, 0.0025398063007742167, 0.010915474034845829, -0.004816029686480761, -0.042901672422885895, 0.00039369220030494034, 0.017450125887989998, -0.05104076862335205, -0.0041377972811460495, 0.07292065024375916, 0.02928033284842968, 0.04170232266187668, -0.010014604777097702, 0.025046108290553093, -0.012535741552710533, -0.010587753728032112, 0.010692424140870571, 0.0053112502209842205, 0.04157884791493416, 0.010855646803975105, 0.032087091356515884, 0.041205890476703644, 0.024537911638617516, 0.03341164067387581, -0.027641277760267258, 0.06463915854692459, -0.010406577959656715, -0.041905391961336136, 0.0007617399096488953, 0.004273790866136551, 0.032817721366882324, -0.002760702045634389, -0.020254135131835938, 0.06185660883784294, -0.01647629216313362, 0.011188234202563763, -0.04208521172404289, 0.006271818187087774, -0.013799138367176056, -0.059529922902584076, 0.0265924371778965, 0.023847008123993874, 0.0013901650672778487, -0.012365260161459446, 0.012064031325280666, 0.0224591251462698, -0.0038004338275641203, -0.01171595137566328, 0.039456795901060104, 0.010459620505571365, -0.013981631956994534, -0.03504551202058792, -0.0033366428688168526, -0.02233651466667652, -0.027138197794556618, 0.022341031581163406, 0.029099073261022568, 0.04316873848438263, 0.06537096947431564, -0.06343965977430344, 0.00026684420299716294, 0.03617699444293976, -0.06573821604251862, -0.02780975215137005, -0.014689956791698933, -0.004866582807153463, 0.017275864258408546, -0.0445391871035099 ]
<p>There is a situation explained below where I intend to apply MLE.</p> <p>The problem statement is that I am estimating a measure $X$. This measure is obtained my Maximum Likelihood estimation technique. </p> <p>I will apply this measure to an AR(2) model to find the parameters of AR model. The way the measure is applied and calculated is explained briefly. </p> <p>Considering a linear auto regressive (AR) model whose parameters are needed to be found that is corrupted by $\eta(t)$ white noise. </p> <p>Question : What is the effect of noise on MLE?</p>
74,334
[ -0.0017257004510611296, 0.009806781075894833, 0.0012597206514328718, -0.008778581395745277, 0.04190283641219139, 0.03001372329890728, -0.00656782416626811, -0.0544930174946785, 0.03394516557455063, -0.016485335305333138, 0.039147671312093735, 0.014349660836160183, 0.08580534160137177, 0.01816101372241974, 0.007271920796483755, -0.003969952464103699, -0.0669146329164505, 0.0064560240134596825, -0.005533265415579081, -0.002650128910318017, -0.01124044880270958, 0.026562703773379326, 0.004651808179914951, -0.04301588237285614, -0.016224220395088196, 0.04571106284856796, 0.008216168731451035, 0.01002431195229292, -0.020682312548160553, 0.061998575925827026, -0.047144629061222076, -0.017568282783031464, 0.01579483039677143, 0.01885942742228508, -0.01741674728691578, -0.016433533281087875, 0.005556369200348854, -0.028450271114706993, -0.0025443302001804113, 0.06089554354548454, -0.05481509491801262, -0.03926633298397064, 0.0173018891364336, 0.00028466482763178647, -0.010745299980044365, 0.00635260296985507, 0.008159969002008438, -0.04786798730492592, 0.015351010486483574, -0.002123909303918481, 0.09451743960380554, 0.012425504624843597, 0.014620577916502953, -0.0059514120221138, -0.0006781676202081144, -0.0147648761048913, 0.03938072547316551, 0.08763228356838226, -0.03293066844344139, -0.018457356840372086, -0.011564325541257858, -0.028896110132336617, 0.029392383992671967, -0.0076903183944523335, -0.05067741498351097, 0.0472206175327301, -0.0054830885492265224, -0.03484201058745384, 0.028702387586236, 0.01594797894358635, -0.011070521548390388, 0.024523666128516197, 0.02238062024116516, 0.005878901574760675, 0.01153380237519741, -0.010063061490654945, -0.0007086725090630352, 0.002944424981251359, 0.04931120201945305, 0.01570061407983303, 0.02621643804013729, -0.005231591872870922, 0.03244354948401451, 0.03267541527748108, 0.003507231827825308, -0.024852855131030083, 0.06413154304027557, -0.025676943361759186, 0.02946552075445652, -0.0015367279993370175, -0.02265605889260769, 0.00829742569476366, 0.0317414216697216, -0.011976183392107487, -0.03834247589111328, 0.05184869095683098, -0.049915753304958344, 0.05290909856557846, 0.037628866732120514, -0.022378211840987206, -0.02397172898054123, -0.027264785021543503, 0.01614472270011902, 0.04568472132086754, -0.006571163423359394, -0.006768450606614351, 0.01936650648713112, -0.014085706323385239, -0.060954686254262924, -0.04003491625189781, -0.03321169316768646, 0.02454119175672531, -0.01623343862593174, -0.02737148478627205, 0.034387070685625076, 0.027233803644776344, -0.00394927803426981, -0.018455594778060913, 0.036439646035432816, 0.06327449530363083, 0.03943200409412384, 0.00030948020867072046, 0.03943326696753502, -0.00816513504832983, -0.051078442484140396, 0.045781999826431274, -0.0012790446635335684, -0.04512908682227135, -0.05621512234210968, 0.05696948245167732, 0.008174301125109196, -0.00803303997963667, 0.06837949901819229, 0.019405635073781013, 0.03281771391630173, -0.008859296329319477, -0.08684051036834717, -0.06783702224493027, 0.04375072196125984, -0.02586960606276989, 0.04809988662600517, -0.07280945032835007, -0.013846542686223984, 0.022430062294006348, 0.08556836098432541, 0.03309367597103119, 0.06378693133592606, 0.038865309208631516, -0.00021476861729752272, -0.008372812531888485, -0.04667476937174797, -0.044775933027267456, -0.016205832362174988, -0.013504852540791035, -0.010646357201039791, -0.06256189942359924, 0.011761358939111233, 0.02244686894118786, -0.02980620600283146, -0.02326297014951706, 0.03401527553796768, 0.0293643306940794, -0.02294950559735298, 0.03678878769278526, 0.002401537261903286, -0.037529464811086655, 0.03054853342473507, 0.013023436069488525, 0.01718861795961857, 0.00924291368573904, -0.002323279157280922, 0.04789264127612114, 0.0059425113722682, 0.024769948795437813, 0.05230918526649475, -0.014407027512788773, -0.049488961696624756, -0.0034690850879997015, 0.012612382881343365, 0.029758919030427933, -0.0004189841274637729, -0.01942332834005356, -0.0007500974461436272, 0.020791837945580482, 0.01073764730244875, 0.03398273140192032, -0.011732290498912334, -0.018638556823134422, 0.04253191500902176, -0.0442369282245636, -0.015329942107200623, -0.09599369764328003, 0.014384704641997814, -0.018030013889074326, -0.020451640710234642, 0.027948804199695587, -0.035513147711753845, 0.008521798066794872, 0.0009134183055721223, 0.023841654881834984, -0.015418937429785728, -0.008444494567811489, 0.032410066574811935, -0.0197373628616333, 0.0456099770963192, 0.048256464302539825, 0.02331254445016384, 0.022835135459899902, 0.01496673934161663, -0.004561180714517832, -0.023715423420071602, -0.0038733091205358505, -0.010589325800538063, 0.00941376481205225, -0.003269747830927372, -0.010038129054009914, 0.029528088867664337, -0.02809709496796131, -0.04554762691259384, 0.03778134286403656, -0.03555087372660637, 0.05048070475459099, 0.03605658933520317, 0.012318884022533894, 0.02849314920604229, 0.027796557173132896, 0.004729823675006628, 0.019996069371700287, -0.020295275375247, -0.013956716284155846, -0.04175301268696785, -0.01887025311589241, 0.02348272316157818, 0.01764933206140995, -0.03150978684425354, 0.039470452815294266, 0.06254667043685913, 0.02259034849703312, 0.038719356060028076, 0.01680367812514305, 0.03968406096100807, -0.03694760799407959, 0.03554075211286545, 0.010794258676469326, -0.009460095316171646, 0.0027711756993085146, 0.011557630263268948, 0.005624124780297279, 0.05605636537075043, -0.015292222611606121, 0.01996055245399475, 0.0830768346786499, -0.03761362284421921, 0.015379641205072403, -0.02003323845565319, -0.01771877519786358, 0.027653813362121582, -0.025912323966622353, -0.028015589341521263, 0.033615585416555405, 0.01926039159297943, -0.009870006702840328, -0.01045969221740961, -0.00832838099449873, 0.010011830367147923, 0.007378879003226757, -0.023575350642204285, -0.01974157989025116, 0.020138420164585114, -0.04358212649822235, 0.036507558077573776, -0.007834992371499538, -0.007125081494450569, -0.0566617026925087, -0.00046697244397364557, 0.04184639826416969, -0.009296894073486328, 0.002067554509267211, -0.014173885807394981, -0.046533938497304916, 0.006668112240731716, -0.01407708041369915, -0.0019892482087016106, 0.014190305024385452, -0.02645176090300083, -0.021160505712032318, -0.06548427790403366, -0.0015883613377809525, 0.013385678641498089, -0.014376174658536911, 0.04053163900971413, -0.007791377604007721, -0.0369071364402771, -0.05689994990825653, -0.029703199863433838, -0.04427089914679527, -0.010196602903306484, -0.014737718738615513, -0.025880053639411926, 0.04491570591926575, -0.005338269751518965, -0.0012120949104428291, -0.0012034174287691712, -0.04674488306045532, -0.008070561103522778, -0.020355230197310448, 0.0035309502854943275, 0.019066262990236282, -0.025649914517998695, 0.011949076317250729, 0.03735879063606262, -0.02251746691763401, 0.029780911281704903, -0.061854276806116104, -0.01903253234922886, 0.01563350297510624, 0.0032021398656070232, -0.008838196285068989, 0.004784226883202791, -0.03217647969722748, 0.06844735890626907, 0.05271094664931297, -0.040358807891607285, -0.037489116191864014, -0.03421729430556297, -0.025577362626791, -0.05920605733990669, -0.006443285848945379, 0.02086656168103218, -0.0025590702425688505, 0.05191999301314354, -0.001256746705621481, 0.010641690343618393, 0.027088604867458344, 0.027163663879036903, -0.029627453535795212, 0.014758654870092869, 0.0097396494820714, -0.032913826406002045, 0.04430467262864113, 0.02653663419187069, 0.00375689216889441, 0.019317857921123505, 0.02350563369691372, 0.005646722391247749, 0.005977317225188017, -0.045426785945892334, 0.033243875950574875, -0.025944525375962257, -0.006558857858181, -0.04596609249711037, 0.041415829211473465, 0.027023784816265106, 0.011178441345691681, -0.03775681182742119, -0.00963748712092638, -0.0035595851950347424, 0.007801704574376345, 0.015564773231744766, 0.05357357859611511, 0.01493948232382536, 0.004785633645951748, -0.041830554604530334, -0.023305397480726242, -0.005207821726799011, -0.0014356531901285052, -0.014757185243070126, -0.03843275457620621, 0.019598526880145073, 0.02773177996277809, 0.02292877994477749, -0.0026986044831573963, -0.04109859839081764, -0.009321190416812897, -0.0866473913192749, 0.0029260411392897367, -0.03279304876923561, 0.07537012547254562, 0.0012065176852047443, 0.017283059656620026, 0.020785894244909286, -0.02420639619231224, 0.027981387451291084, -0.027030637487769127, -0.05151348561048508, 0.02371954172849655, -0.00087566371075809, -0.037175655364990234, 0.03801984339952469, -0.04119836911559105, 0.043552182614803314, -0.048038747161626816, 0.00887294951826334, 0.02039756439626217, 0.04551278427243233, -0.04400474205613136, 0.021252643316984177, -0.007253042887896299, -0.03242321312427521, -0.03777233138680458, 0.018453558906912804, 0.015099817886948586, -0.01288526225835085, 0.015525720082223415, 0.051476553082466125, 0.011788351461291313, -0.01082067284733057, -0.02792753465473652, -0.008318446576595306, 0.008475917391479015, 0.04520642012357712, 0.045527976006269455, -0.012620029971003532, -0.03456718474626541, 0.05009843409061432, 0.0435357466340065, 0.06905251741409302, 0.05183830112218857, 0.0423114150762558, -0.03177925571799278, -0.03188250586390495, -0.04824647679924965, 0.019748546183109283, -0.000826339703053236, 0.008025890216231346, 0.00009918127034325153, 0.042965732514858246, 0.01291271299123764, -0.04898401349782944, -0.0035311495885252953, 0.03499579429626465, 0.01745200902223587, 0.013536470010876656, -0.037074193358421326, -0.011462129652500153, 0.018235480412840843, 0.0055469367653131485, 0.032783143222332, -0.026732562109827995, -0.004675736650824547, -0.01601373963057995, 0.020766606554389, -0.017504636198282242, -0.03800445795059204, -0.029170922935009003, 0.04442378133535385, -0.01977793499827385, 0.03149530291557312, -0.02117004804313183, 0.017560748383402824, 0.049150362610816956, 0.03619607165455818, 0.013065988197922707, 0.011681787669658661, -0.100676529109478, 0.02323172055184841, 0.023132724687457085, 0.05164303630590439, -0.03268003091216087, 0.009781778790056705, -0.048053957521915436, -0.02489442192018032, 0.02769392915070057, 0.0021887703333050013, 0.024326922371983528, -0.06430255621671677, -0.01402207836508751, -0.004301784094423056, -0.013242020271718502, -0.03166801109910011, 0.001979734282940626, 0.030629685148596764, 0.011687377467751503, -0.02214997075498104, -0.004213821142911911, -0.016166672110557556, -0.023213252425193787, 0.00998151209205389, 0.06432364135980606, -0.006604761350899935, 0.012295085936784744, 0.026596417650580406, 0.03615972399711609, -0.024570075795054436, -0.0376134067773819, 0.012956946156919003, -0.00834218505769968, -0.01555777620524168, 0.022765321657061577, 0.003719705855473876, -0.031809743493795395, -0.0013449242105707526, 0.031155481934547424, -0.005049110855907202, -0.032125893980264664, -0.034893374890089035, 0.016289951279759407, 0.04209427535533905, 0.004389761481434107, 0.11040223389863968, 0.03586498647928238, 0.027500983327627182, 0.01738772913813591, -0.010363970883190632, 0.034556012600660324, -0.03599486127495766, 0.010993429459631443, -0.042879145592451096, -0.0025537956971675158, 0.0016055937157943845, 0.06932439655065536, 0.026480110362172127, 0.03342872112989426, -0.05424008518457413, -0.005752521567046642, -0.0050414809957146645, 0.059366531670093536, 0.005550582427531481, -0.00745368143543601, -0.00586399482563138, 0.03671649843454361, -0.027790149673819542, 0.011217696592211723, 0.019907867535948753, -0.051056258380413055, -0.004450186155736446, 0.02120087295770645, -0.023003235459327698, 0.0414607860147953, -0.005445598624646664, -0.018052060157060623, 0.006224268581718206, -0.004410531837493181, 0.01367439515888691, 0.003131667384877801, -0.002402095589786768, 0.02380811795592308, -0.060458991676568985, -0.024612218141555786, -0.00847935862839222, -0.021555129438638687, 0.05912578105926514, -0.013661069795489311, 0.02190886065363884, 0.000049656657211016864, -0.011332977563142776, -0.07600557059049606, -0.034507282078266144, 0.012337913736701012, -0.0029154643416404724, 0.007843967527151108, -0.007627321872860193, 0.005347684025764465, -0.011662653647363186, -0.008097164332866669, -0.04495342820882797, 0.052138932049274445, 0.019356973469257355, -0.0209446270018816, -0.002728939289227128, 0.037909749895334244, 0.07386992871761322, 0.02935386449098587, -0.01698393002152443, 0.014471928589046001, -0.03838518634438515, -0.025417586788535118, -0.01620778627693653, 0.035169512033462524, -0.06160278990864754, 0.004350144881755114, -0.023007329553365707, -0.03078957088291645, 0.060010768473148346, -0.03396466374397278, -0.037866801023483276, 0.0047213416546583176, 0.04084090143442154, 0.007185951806604862, 0.0027348569128662348, -0.02494889125227928, -0.025701448321342468, -0.007504174020141363, 0.034874092787504196, -0.005875182803720236, -0.03508887439966202, 0.012963909655809402, 0.0680558905005455, 0.01115068607032299, -0.01377447322010994, 0.0042732213623821735, 0.08921978622674942, -0.04023464396595955, 0.017859505489468575, -0.008233855478465557, 0.0010541431838646531, 0.027562955394387245, -0.009222762659192085, 0.011651823297142982, 0.029375454410910606, 0.02416272461414337, -0.04573522508144379, -0.016902528703212738, -0.021649077534675598, -0.005003041587769985, 0.07262571901082993, -0.031365178525447845, 0.035823605954647064, 0.020838169381022453, -0.008499170653522015, -0.02465081959962845, -0.02202972024679184, 0.015842312946915627, -0.015516199171543121, 0.011870691552758217, 0.008457165211439133, 0.0028009687084704638, 0.009074580855667591, 0.006005446892231703, -0.017239391803741455, 0.027276629582047462, -0.008355794474482536, 0.014651097357273102, 0.05186891555786133, -0.017561499029397964, -0.0398804172873497, -0.022146131843328476, 0.041139256209135056, -0.029390055686235428, -0.0008979739504866302, -0.048389531672000885, -0.012556783854961395, 0.03672115132212639, 0.014845515601336956, 0.007396726869046688, -0.023840025067329407, -0.008415589109063148, -0.05189596861600876, 0.00018567086954135448, 0.02786710113286972, 0.010120070539414883, 0.0853322446346283, 0.024156993255019188, 0.04711442068219185, -0.011437730863690376, 0.03738146275281906, -0.003508346388116479, -0.095758818089962, 0.003276658011600375, 0.0098587516695261, -0.03879185765981674, 0.048248812556266785, -0.019360998645424843, -0.018293360248208046, 0.025773318484425545, -0.034043747931718826, 0.0627935379743576, 0.026755385100841522, 0.0313580147922039, -0.0664372518658638, 0.0632982924580574, -0.002380570163950324, 0.02124287560582161, -0.015718858689069748, 0.03669803589582443, 0.0837322324514389, 0.06969419866800308, 0.018635712563991547, -0.056703489273786545, -0.034506455063819885, -0.023246971890330315, -0.0427863746881485, -0.022811610251665115, 0.04792056605219841, 0.012363080866634846, -0.022842152044177055, -0.0030340366065502167, 0.05712174251675606, 0.0032950681634247303, -0.02378477342426777, 0.03113509528338909, -0.021778177469968796, -0.06209907680749893, 0.02986159175634384, -0.004646113142371178, -0.00023195927496999502, -0.011248701252043247, -0.026931870728731155, 0.03185994550585747, -0.032369621098041534, -0.019004201516509056, -0.019554082304239273, -0.040992364287376404, -0.010474860668182373, -0.04805637151002884, -0.037150703370571136, 0.004383827559649944, 0.007307189051061869, 0.011124198324978352, -0.022479986771941185, -0.007580589968711138, -0.015226755291223526, -0.011343003250658512, 0.026086680591106415, 0.02266586199402809, 0.03132740408182144, 0.008374357596039772, -0.016052110120654106, 0.0025631776079535484, -0.026949461549520493, -0.049686748534440994, -0.009384545497596264, 0.046363599598407745, -0.024674277752637863, -0.005318008363246918, -0.03346775099635124, 0.030233869329094887, -0.026200877502560616, -0.03447659686207771, 0.01682543382048607, 0.00901684258133173, 0.006100998260080814, -0.03314666450023651, -0.0244408268481493, -0.029053356498479843, 0.01884816214442253, -0.02384352870285511, 0.034184135496616364, 0.004842184018343687, -0.02713821828365326, 0.01691059209406376, -0.014625035226345062, 0.03657655417919159, 0.03661922365427017, 0.010438544675707817, -0.04061853140592575, -0.039799679070711136, -0.04085705801844597, -0.027704935520887375, 0.028824523091316223, 0.0048958673141896725, 0.021260984241962433, -0.008470403961837292, -0.037019554525613785, -0.012345809489488602, -0.07089782506227493, 0.012328434735536575, -0.024114051833748817, 0.005064598750323057, -0.03316384553909302, -0.03148340433835983, 0.009131096303462982, 0.019042326137423515, 0.0299818255007267, -0.03988231346011162, 0.004924142267554998, 0.0331515371799469, 0.0236069243401289, -0.015365706756711006, -0.01024605892598629, -0.012950228527188301, -0.012492978014051914, 0.014250590465962887, -0.0032301212195307016, 0.034868888556957245, 0.00498628756031394, 0.03240020200610161, -0.035513874143362045, 0.028152696788311005, -0.011809632182121277, -0.02233256958425045, 0.013182548806071281, -0.01238697674125433, -0.015377365984022617, 0.016809973865747452, 0.032089803367853165, -0.012470842339098454, -0.006014329846948385, -0.03753551095724106, -0.012805234640836716, 0.018656406551599503, -0.02846076712012291, -0.043955523520708084, 0.04035215824842453, 0.009618141688406467, 0.018892578780651093, -0.02836146391928196, 0.035921137779951096, -0.004901017062366009, 0.012692074291408062, 0.0075923604890704155, -0.031609658151865005, 0.017617011442780495, -0.004555824678391218, 0.014090355485677719, -0.017166534438729286, -0.018995722755789757, -0.0009156825835816562, 0.009827463887631893, 0.0040727113373577595, 0.028184084221720695, 0.010448910295963287, 0.08506117761135101, -0.03443592041730881, -0.009337017312645912, 0.06004531681537628, -0.062166858464479446, -0.022972773760557175, 0.01161877065896988, -0.02779337204992771, 0.021036578342318535, 0.022137412801384926, -0.01403768640011549, -0.019232451915740967, 0.03653259202837944, -0.011627313680946827, 0.008689112961292267, -0.0029606041498482227, -0.0019058955367654562, 0.0030925432220101357, -0.003126349300146103, 0.012563272379338741, -0.007997192442417145, -0.011399220675230026, 0.007279370911419392, 0.06401508301496506, 0.023720165714621544, -0.012623638845980167, 0.04082832112908363, -0.023700259625911713, 0.011072352528572083, 0.026413915678858757, -0.010192950256168842, 0.009719102643430233, 0.010911312885582447, 0.00023888928990345448, 0.012316427193582058, 0.013500750064849854, 0.0013711670180782676, -0.1125413253903389, -0.0063499934040009975, 0.06263192743062973, 0.02285958267748356, 0.052104007452726364, -0.06890329718589783, -0.010779782198369503, 0.05634313076734543, -0.04727799445390701, -0.027710458263754845, -0.03340503200888634, -0.027008257806301117, -0.020025089383125305, -0.00017617909179534763, -0.03379937633872032, 0.053564414381980896, 0.04245385527610779, -0.006993050687015057, 0.035179659724235535, 0.01731123961508274, 0.0049592056311666965, -0.03956674411892891, -0.00659434637054801, 0.04284890741109848, 0.024985266849398613, -0.027149412781000137, 0.022591954097151756, -0.016573015600442886, -0.021064065396785736, 0.01161386538296938, 0.00867423228919506, 0.0428617037832737, -0.0037261678371578455, 0.03392878547310829, -0.002275223610922694, -0.007424134761095047, 0.05314137786626816, 0.0083241555839777, 0.016188427805900574, 0.02834114246070385, -0.00354875554330647, -0.004666374530643225, -0.002042268170043826, 0.003390219761058688, -0.011769098229706287, -0.00023657482233829796, -0.016115494072437286, 0.0017321283230558038, -0.01122218370437622, -0.021754249930381775, 0.0192180834710598, 0.008292168378829956, -0.022527651861310005, -0.0417441725730896, 0.0338892936706543, 0.03206365928053856, 0.0345425046980381, 0.06690013408660889, 0.03936808928847313, -0.03125743195414543, 0.016275277361273766, -0.007331467233598232, -0.06391441822052002, 0.04025272652506828, -0.00006243502139113843, -0.03968823701143265, -0.049367889761924744, -0.011744840070605278, -0.010143090039491653, -0.009315920993685722, -0.030358372256159782, 0.0031293495558202267, -0.04664763808250427, 0.042439866811037064, -0.03046533651649952, -0.010809330269694328, -0.0013570522423833609, -0.003965077921748161, -0.025074439123272896, -0.050239935517311096, 0.046365249902009964, 0.020346544682979584, -0.016971595585346222, -0.030870471149683, 0.0008248641388490796, -0.026966169476509094, 0.016370322555303574, 0.029297884553670883, 0.013183641247451305, 0.00022848030494060367, 0.02567625232040882, 0.015048063360154629, 0.006346503738313913, -0.01534369308501482, 0.037346940487623215, -0.03051850199699402, -0.004353867378085852, -0.02504330314695835, -0.022331010550260544, 0.0015597871970385313, 0.03667798638343811, 0.041925881057977676, 0.004302268847823143, 0.008787228725850582, -0.014062113128602505, 0.014714682474732399, 0.02813608944416046, 0.014745189808309078, -0.004595116246491671, 0.07036616653203964, 0.012052956037223339, 0.02702174335718155, 0.009030518122017384, 0.011813577264547348, -0.060411542654037476, 0.016387682408094406, -0.01996573992073536, -0.00545931700617075, -0.0018165867077186704, 0.023853875696659088, -0.030016738921403885, -0.04045170173048973, -0.0261837225407362, 0.051792044192552567, -0.017587261274456978, -0.022112304344773293, 0.034913092851638794, -0.012094909325242043, 0.011015345342457294, 0.009006123058497906, 0.03271593898534775, 0.026614194735884666, 0.017967352643609047, -0.03230307623744011, 0.019996823742985725, 0.03525478020310402, -0.01848836988210678, 0.026972275227308273, 0.021285327151417732, -0.020658450201153755, 0.007618909236043692, 0.00006488397775683552, 0.05292212963104248, -0.034680284559726715, -0.03732728585600853, -0.011427700519561768, 0.003552969777956605, 0.008258606307208538, -0.03326157480478287, -0.020218435674905777, 0.0731993243098259, -0.05075965076684952, 0.02329099364578724, -0.016702765598893166, -0.017223600298166275, -0.031017549335956573, -0.01177569106221199, -0.01622171700000763, 0.02216757833957672, 0.017283018678426743, -0.006881443317979574, -0.04147833585739136, 0.01040543895214796, 0.00892632082104683, -0.049638114869594574, -0.02213129960000515, 0.0063094873912632465, -0.04184453934431076, -0.03083435632288456, -0.014796040020883083, -0.04393167048692703, -0.048406414687633514, 0.01466749981045723, 0.039645854383707047, 0.013097530230879784, -0.04024306312203407, -0.038749683648347855, -0.009757782332599163, 0.08256343752145767, -0.043755169957876205, -0.0364273302257061, -0.007980774156749249, -0.04568610340356827, -0.029291434213519096, -0.029251396656036377 ]
<p>I'm struggling with mathematics behind linear regression. In the following lines I pasted the text from the book <a href="http://rads.stackoverflow.com/amzn/click/0387310738" rel="nofollow">Pattern Recognition and Machine Learning</a> (p. 46) where author derives the regression function $\mathbb{E}_{t} [t | \mathbf{x}]$. I want to understand the procedure from the equation (2) to the final result. Could somebody please provide me some useful pointers (and/or links) which concept from the calculus of variations should I study.</p> <p>The average, expected, loss is given by</p> <p>$$ \mathbb{E}[L] = \int \int L(t, x (\mathbf{x})) p (\mathbf{x}, t) \, d\mathbf{x} \, dt. \tag{1} $$</p> <p>A common choice of loss function in linear regression is the squared loos given by $L (t, y(\mathbf{x})) = \{ y (\mathbf{x}) - t \}^{2}$. In this case, the expected loss can be written as</p> <p>$$ \mathbb{E}[L] = \int \int \{ y (\mathbf{x}) - t \}^{2} p (\mathbf{x}, t) \, d\mathbf{x} \, dt. \tag{2} $$</p> <p>Our goal is to choose $y (\mathbf{x})$ so as to minimize $\mathbb{E} [L]$. We can do this using the calculus of variations to give</p> <p>$$ \dfrac{\delta \mathbb{E} [L]}{\delta y (\mathbf{x})} = 2 \int \{ y (\mathbf{x}) - t \} p (\mathbf{x}, t) \, dt = 0. \tag{3} $$</p> <p>Solving for $y (\mathbf{x})$, and using the sum and product rules of probability, we obtain</p> <p>$$ y (\mathbf{x}) = \dfrac{\int tp (\mathbf{x}, t) \, dt}{p (\mathbf{x})} = \int t p (t | \mathbf{x}) \, dt = \mathbb{E}_{t} [t | \mathbf{x}] \tag{4} $$</p>
74,335
[ -0.025010740384459496, -0.048659879714250565, 0.0273275189101696, -0.04391879215836525, 0.017110081389546394, 0.02522301860153675, 0.005335730034857988, -0.012170221656560898, 0.033843182027339935, -0.018636589869856834, 0.03010125644505024, 0.03524644300341606, 0.04053358733654022, 0.026131443679332733, 0.0232886653393507, 0.009499729610979557, -0.03374907746911049, 0.013823810033500195, -0.04875951260328293, -0.02263282798230648, -0.002608219627290964, 0.008807203732430935, 0.014290337450802326, -0.014822246506810188, -0.045601651072502136, 0.035392776131629944, 0.0004519908980000764, -0.02141510881483555, -0.0014791174326092005, 0.08847125619649887, -0.043857645243406296, -0.017924994230270386, -0.009518248960375786, 0.010670377872884274, 0.012510041706264019, 0.05031614750623703, 0.0031374143436551094, -0.02656666375696659, -0.0017981902929022908, 0.02599305845797062, -0.0027007160242646933, -0.01758585497736931, 0.037928514182567596, 0.04573778063058853, -0.001064751297235489, 0.02570968307554722, -0.004314752761274576, -0.05094660073518753, 0.040188223123550415, -0.015170369297266006, 0.07762443274259567, -0.01285361498594284, 0.04116170480847359, 0.03648018091917038, -0.006392626091837883, -0.011534208431839943, 0.007859541103243828, 0.06004208326339722, -0.03658701851963997, -0.06740465760231018, 0.013585868291556835, -0.02484387904405594, 0.02861775830388069, -0.0027873374056071043, -0.026019658893346786, -0.009867889806628227, 0.03539915382862091, -0.021868029609322548, 0.02622883953154087, 0.0033432254567742348, 0.013479319401085377, 0.019127869978547096, 0.014739402569830418, -0.004121096804738045, 0.033730730414390564, 0.009352052584290504, 0.0005830383743159473, 0.03790046647191048, 0.008150353096425533, 0.019482167437672615, 0.03895317763090134, 0.015203411690890789, 0.007350691128522158, 0.04263352230191231, -0.03286578133702278, 0.012175134383141994, 0.09328949451446533, -0.007985787466168404, 0.062029097229242325, 0.013696671463549137, 0.014023701660335064, 0.01223800890147686, 0.019320987164974213, -0.04140854626893997, -0.04045644775032997, 0.048541709780693054, 0.011541669256985188, 0.02292628400027752, 0.04475022479891777, -0.031574420630931854, -0.023059871047735214, -0.05559160187840462, -0.028828231617808342, 0.055942103266716, -0.013683880679309368, -0.0422997809946537, -0.006584284361451864, -0.010538897477090359, -0.005123347043991089, -0.04624752700328827, -0.050806790590286255, 0.053580574691295624, -0.010597531683743, -0.003833862952888012, -0.005832574795931578, -0.026406574994325638, -0.0010977593483403325, 0.010675261728465557, 0.019571829587221146, 0.05137244611978531, 0.04664000868797302, -0.04207007959485054, 0.034975796937942505, 0.0063034421764314175, -0.028957562521100044, 0.015946323052048683, 0.031108448281884193, -0.011321780271828175, -0.044711947441101074, 0.017918869853019714, -0.0037408405914902687, -0.005610140040516853, 0.007237199693918228, 0.04151439666748047, -0.013074664399027824, -0.016885945573449135, -0.06426921486854553, -0.053567979484796524, 0.0053922031074762344, -0.038367606699466705, 0.0015647379914298654, -0.04757186770439148, -0.03393782302737236, 0.011486847884953022, 0.03262984752655029, -0.0040681250393390656, 0.05431090295314789, 0.04775698855519295, -0.011779083870351315, -0.03253018856048584, -0.00516309542581439, -0.02820451185107231, -0.01723291724920273, -0.012010650709271431, 0.005105004645884037, -0.0464123971760273, -0.024405118077993393, 0.03163818269968033, -0.021088121458888054, -0.017973002046346664, 0.03191637247800827, -0.0033276216126978397, -0.04028506577014923, 0.02607725001871586, 0.0023809378035366535, -0.04338686540722847, 0.08707886934280396, 0.007872393354773521, 0.05213835835456848, 0.041499730199575424, 0.011807385832071304, 0.02432270534336567, 0.007148855831474066, 0.03817770630121231, 0.031074710190296173, -0.023518091067671776, -0.05197804793715477, -0.05474668741226196, -0.007285856641829014, 0.033043213188648224, -0.047526080161333084, -0.033535998314619064, -0.02542695589363575, 0.011483907699584961, 0.005627889651805162, 0.028393225744366646, 0.023003939539194107, -0.00013910372217651457, 0.018431834876537323, -0.028618453070521355, -0.0486755333840847, -0.04006042703986168, 0.01761065609753132, -0.0007923709345050156, -0.011933567933738232, 0.018232088536024094, -0.012045638635754585, -0.02426760457456112, -0.034639038145542145, 0.005377988331019878, -0.001995186321437359, 0.030804404988884926, 0.037192244082689285, -0.00796905905008316, 0.00496812304481864, 0.047941163182258606, 0.017261087894439697, 0.010438858531415462, 0.0009984716307371855, -0.0648251324892044, -0.016479631885886192, -0.00026149721816182137, -0.023689016699790955, 0.006093727890402079, -0.01932036504149437, -0.02561911568045616, 0.017172813415527344, -0.018940342590212822, -0.018648991361260414, -0.02032526396214962, -0.05872435122728348, 0.02018781192600727, 0.07289396226406097, 0.021390799432992935, -0.005584673024713993, 0.013535536825656891, -0.04406082630157471, 0.045470863580703735, -0.058684252202510834, 0.0018069841898977757, -0.022838037461042404, -0.015846122056245804, 0.03663065657019615, 0.0657268837094307, -0.02977302297949791, 0.004408505745232105, 0.07684749364852905, 0.01727871410548687, -0.012860355898737907, 0.01711081713438034, -0.008561844937503338, -0.007997705601155758, 0.021499328315258026, 0.0017401442164555192, -0.00820947252213955, 0.03320955112576485, -0.0180478747934103, 0.017780287191271782, 0.02045663259923458, 0.008062257431447506, -0.03517339751124382, 0.06503413617610931, -0.004228934645652771, 0.013930244371294975, -0.007777624763548374, 0.03458944708108902, 0.02665545418858528, 0.0062170810997486115, 0.0019214865751564503, 0.020094145089387894, -0.039039067924022675, 0.03587154671549797, -0.014062629081308842, 0.00857312697917223, 0.01832999661564827, 0.010877986438572407, -0.01341531053185463, -0.005318040959537029, 0.027175402268767357, -0.027734633535146713, 0.016335127875208855, 0.04183446243405342, -0.03542141988873482, -0.00782688520848751, 0.009248705580830574, 0.014007162302732468, 0.01863589882850647, -0.007701356429606676, -0.022823719307780266, -0.024838831275701523, -0.005750600248575211, -0.003147222800180316, 0.03366251662373543, -0.021400757133960724, -0.04130158945918083, -0.031667377799749374, -0.062045786529779434, -0.006244315300136805, 0.03262284770607948, -0.003787907538935542, 0.007847779430449009, 0.01990685798227787, -0.021074486896395683, -0.105693519115448, -0.04049523174762726, -0.015193705447018147, 0.009169349446892738, 0.00038857475738041103, -0.0007731338264420629, 0.019968749955296516, -0.010268347337841988, -0.06292685121297836, 0.034707821905612946, -0.0396265909075737, -0.03043440729379654, -0.06710699200630188, -0.02514275535941124, 0.003402490634471178, 0.031750697642564774, 0.045180968940258026, 0.008056359365582466, 0.00675630010664463, -0.010528486222028732, -0.10852056741714478, -0.023860929533839226, 0.0311347097158432, -0.010664284229278564, 0.009996363893151283, -0.0015108680818229914, -0.027167022228240967, 0.11444417387247086, 0.037056539207696915, -0.007670889142900705, -0.0008395836339332163, 0.0358901210129261, -0.003368320409208536, -0.02421744167804718, 0.04770774766802788, 0.033280692994594574, -0.00227118912152946, 0.03840642049908638, -0.029782580211758614, 0.0119610745459795, 0.07953239977359772, -0.021346639841794968, 0.02324208989739418, 0.01174875907599926, -0.028256749734282494, 0.007578209508210421, 0.03424425795674324, 0.04333382844924927, -0.004957214929163456, 0.04891851916909218, 0.020624294877052307, 0.02051297016441822, 0.024009907618165016, -0.05301504209637642, 0.007255323231220245, -0.014409719966351986, -0.032471880316734314, -0.016947029158473015, 0.01376266684383154, -0.02230818197131157, -0.057356130331754684, 0.01233415212482214, -0.003581233788281679, 0.048592451959848404, -0.007832680828869343, -0.008548258803784847, 0.026979925110936165, 0.06433738768100739, 0.010851937346160412, -0.0261765718460083, 0.010454430244863033, -0.02357381395995617, 0.014511753804981709, -0.00925149954855442, 0.004674819763749838, -0.006348582915961742, 0.05752906948328018, -0.011709028854966164, 0.0007693523657508194, -0.010782665573060513, -0.034762632101774216, -0.04161479324102402, 0.007422471418976784, 0.00987199041992426, 0.06029389426112175, 0.023761369287967682, 0.010194918140769005, -0.006219516508281231, -0.010159160941839218, 0.030943289399147034, 0.017425870522856712, -0.0922798290848732, 0.03617749363183975, 0.0035046401899307966, -0.03432474657893181, -0.008291787467896938, 0.0032954849302768707, 0.10119793564081192, -0.02673267386853695, 0.017434459179639816, -0.03346480429172516, 0.018161563202738762, -0.04374236240983009, -0.002460684161633253, 0.00177902658469975, -0.014943182468414307, -0.029392918571829796, 0.01880626752972603, 0.017957575619220734, -0.018000464886426926, -0.00802126619964838, 0.016761967912316322, -0.04076584056019783, -0.024582047015428543, 0.0014496021904051304, -0.012339132837951183, 0.0495937317609787, 0.03699734807014465, -0.008744924329221249, 0.007224548142403364, -0.003480825573205948, 0.01328201312571764, -0.007186631206423044, 0.04490673542022705, 0.03385591134428978, -0.03534913435578346, -0.034736283123493195, -0.06505478173494339, -0.003028668463230133, 0.011696486733853817, 0.02092433162033558, -0.008227336220443249, -0.002729070605710149, 0.0592317134141922, 0.013552047312259674, -0.020932355895638466, 0.01663830503821373, -0.004438234493136406, 0.010545263066887856, 0.0369073711335659, 0.002516942098736763, 0.015970218926668167, -0.007091957610100508, 0.005884503945708275, 0.02590920776128769, -0.023203609511256218, -0.031077448278665543, -0.03076544776558876, 0.0612969696521759, 0.04219015687704086, -0.014232556335628033, -0.014654199592769146, 0.026747405529022217, 0.03257592022418976, -0.006556934677064419, -0.043328769505023956, 0.015593569725751877, 0.06251797080039978, 0.04960816726088524, 0.03888992220163345, 0.022041013464331627, -0.05347300320863724, -0.03946985676884651, -0.012117033824324608, 0.08016842603683472, -0.006186025217175484, -0.009550821967422962, -0.03744036331772804, -0.012576499953866005, 0.012436753138899803, -0.004834138322621584, 0.011873307637870312, -0.013044309802353382, -0.007469226140528917, -0.008844474330544472, -0.041686512529850006, -0.05414198711514473, -0.016963202506303787, -0.008792693726718426, 0.05485572665929794, -0.036972127854824066, -0.020297467708587646, -0.020979054272174835, -0.0189913809299469, 0.0009858853882178664, 0.026247931644320488, -0.029603781178593636, -0.0355377197265625, -0.005303352605551481, 0.03548822179436684, -0.016851479187607765, -0.052938107401132584, -0.02451384626328945, 0.007034961599856615, 0.01474899984896183, 0.026212643831968307, -0.010058040730655193, -0.06297697126865387, 0.028468456119298935, 0.039904821664094925, -0.02648431994020939, 0.011233123019337654, -0.026733022183179855, 0.03175324201583862, 0.0698387548327446, 0.018518852069973946, 0.07313508540391922, 0.02333410270512104, 0.006044833455234766, 0.002139139221981168, -0.02153214067220688, 0.02899491973221302, -0.011959671042859554, -0.019784577190876007, -0.04610775038599968, -0.04472444951534271, -0.003947978373616934, 0.03531608730554581, 0.0010198816889896989, -0.011959332041442394, -0.05426616594195366, -0.023062795400619507, 0.008057024329900742, -0.002513336483389139, 0.007774473633617163, -0.019795790314674377, -0.01967490091919899, 0.06114598736166954, 0.01587969809770584, -0.00718916580080986, -0.007981959730386734, -0.014997350051999092, 0.014609846286475658, 0.03803512081503868, -0.01630345918238163, 0.011832945048809052, -0.023880712687969208, -0.03907134756445885, -0.007407543249428272, -0.01387151051312685, 0.022712532430887222, 0.053565993905067444, 0.020153474062681198, 0.011767236515879631, 0.024870730936527252, -0.043346796184778214, -0.025215286761522293, -0.007432325277477503, 0.02452036924660206, -0.0487922839820385, 0.014085641130805016, -0.007321896497160196, -0.030293835327029228, -0.06254341453313828, -0.05009116604924202, 0.0008893500198610127, -0.025834832340478897, -0.0357675701379776, -0.005883465986698866, -0.007424959912896156, 0.004055387806147337, -0.058446984738111496, 0.012783396057784557, 0.045913390815258026, -0.0034849299117922783, -0.023223120719194412, -0.0294051431119442, 0.006444485858082771, 0.045793283730745316, 0.022723190486431122, -0.013040054589509964, 0.015359090641140938, -0.008426442742347717, -0.021680058911442757, -0.023225069046020508, 0.04250520095229149, -0.019116435199975967, -0.000017238784494111314, -0.039060115814208984, 0.015795119106769562, 0.02494349703192711, -0.02314387448132038, -0.035363953560590744, 0.005776561796665192, 0.04491782933473587, -0.03962456062436104, -0.003158922540023923, -0.03330020606517792, -0.0005229274975135922, 0.021280216053128242, 0.014679779298603535, -0.02438289485871792, 0.007747529540210962, -0.014275172725319862, 0.040749020874500275, -0.02021678537130356, 0.004126186948269606, 0.010025587864220142, 0.05997253209352493, -0.008172950707376003, 0.011796986684203148, 0.004855703562498093, -0.018467925488948822, 0.05135508254170418, 0.015574530698359013, 0.006829626392573118, 0.0008265540818683803, -0.0032551984768360853, -0.06233545392751694, -0.039470426738262177, -0.08929140865802765, 0.013336140662431717, 0.062039319425821304, -0.010209166444838047, 0.06858539581298828, 0.061935774981975555, -0.0020963281858712435, -0.0016683214344084263, -0.028722913935780525, -0.0300503708422184, -0.03300165385007858, -0.02202221378684044, 0.04948752373456955, 0.004767443984746933, -0.03092467412352562, 0.07359609752893448, -0.0122048519551754, -0.03534254431724548, 0.018604286015033722, -0.006226742640137672, 0.019678406417369843, 0.02641213871538639, -0.06238124519586563, -0.03889114782214165, 0.0038977402728050947, -0.011230523698031902, 0.03240406885743141, -0.02068088762462139, -0.025561558082699776, 0.05097196251153946, 0.042441368103027344, 0.02048822119832039, -0.015526782721281052, -0.02777070552110672, -0.05669592320919037, 0.011585991829633713, 0.02894647791981697, -0.019224904477596283, 0.029313907027244568, 0.037791866809129715, 0.029431041330099106, -0.009715864434838295, 0.025456983596086502, -0.005779416300356388, -0.041068561375141144, -0.01856904849410057, -0.02266368456184864, -0.01669470965862274, -0.006802326533943415, 0.009742746129631996, -0.018953362479805946, -0.006901275832206011, -0.03850188106298447, 0.04383797198534012, 0.03554113954305649, 0.023983396589756012, -0.026623044162988663, 0.07921475172042847, 0.0010880137560889125, 0.0037960682529956102, -0.0443752259016037, -0.0003060627786908299, 0.12646648287773132, 0.06705275923013687, 0.051264211535453796, -0.0848180428147316, 0.006532697007060051, -0.03460339456796646, -0.005622034892439842, -0.039439357817173004, -0.005581460427492857, 0.022219566628336906, -0.00014937797095626593, 0.02781951241195202, 0.02466944418847561, -0.0025784503668546677, -0.06406131386756897, 0.024190442636609077, -0.041027218103408813, -0.0038365954533219337, 0.03883189707994461, -0.008712868206202984, 0.005593977402895689, 0.009356784634292126, -0.044783126562833786, 0.0036590490490198135, -0.002730723936110735, 0.016829561442136765, -0.015460487455129623, -0.07172498106956482, 0.0040725222788751125, -0.032485563308000565, -0.012268015183508396, 0.012466263957321644, 0.03455883637070656, 0.0253006424754858, -0.00013294740347191691, 0.014317414723336697, 0.0076652695424854755, -0.01549533475190401, 0.030911516398191452, 0.014518973417580128, 0.014744116924703121, -0.007917373441159725, 0.016713539138436317, 0.013657359406352043, -0.03267423063516617, -0.05012138560414314, -0.05462922155857086, 0.07093080133199692, -0.001357893692329526, -0.016087908297777176, -0.0005624194163829088, -0.0008322190842591226, 0.006800321862101555, -0.05243528261780739, 0.012159124948084354, 0.01859504170715809, 0.053613197058439255, 0.005378026515245438, -0.033673059195280075, -0.003637313609942794, 0.01464520301669836, 0.00019253139907959849, 0.007745947223156691, 0.05847807601094246, -0.026186347007751465, -0.03462192788720131, 0.0007868024404160678, 0.031373683363199234, -0.017792288213968277, 0.03159420192241669, -0.03618341684341431, -0.011983368545770645, -0.013885472901165485, -0.024245141074061394, 0.0097768260166049, -0.004232882522046566, -0.003441006876528263, -0.0009367575403302908, -0.026392491534352303, -0.017206834629178047, -0.05767102912068367, 0.029858753085136414, -0.03058103658258915, -0.011461080983281136, -0.033264514058828354, -0.004052302334457636, 0.01510513387620449, 0.02306710183620453, 0.0291596632450819, -0.021777261048555374, 0.03423728421330452, 0.03075295500457287, -0.006684792228043079, 0.004126624204218388, -0.016545236110687256, 0.024788910523056984, 0.013888458721339703, 0.0007888036197982728, 0.028142990544438362, 0.07252734899520874, 0.027721470221877098, 0.04895278438925743, 0.01049867644906044, 0.014783675782382488, -0.02933868207037449, 0.011881896294653416, -0.01480583380907774, -0.04410220682621002, -0.006845954339951277, 0.02759719081223011, 0.02548428252339363, -0.05074746906757355, 0.002148834289982915, -0.01868981309235096, -0.009753766469657421, 0.013220195658504963, 0.03808183595538139, -0.028190527111291885, 0.006503755692392588, -0.024324553087353706, 0.028200890868902206, -0.02155844122171402, 0.011391669511795044, -0.02429838851094246, 0.024368196725845337, -0.023834554478526115, -0.016216225922107697, -0.009876801632344723, -0.0072042983956635, -0.009058707393705845, -0.03371451795101166, 0.03173058107495308, 0.03757157921791077, 0.0029082547407597303, 0.002916463417932391, 0.03483889251947403, -0.03104213811457157, 0.023224541917443275, -0.006405247375369072, 0.011948279105126858, 0.033048130571842194, -0.036158911883831024, -0.014306005090475082, 0.01680735871195793, 0.016486382111907005, 0.02763683907687664, 0.005275201518088579, 0.0007489905692636967, -0.060688287019729614, 0.015849001705646515, 0.0005817650235258043, -0.0035054420586675406, -0.0267681572586298, -0.022209398448467255, -0.005123028997331858, -0.027734505012631416, 0.03177313506603241, -0.006061224732547998, 0.016380444169044495, -0.009068051353096962, 0.007732098922133446, -0.04633089527487755, 0.0009878042619675398, 0.022410385310649872, -0.01702728681266308, 0.028009045869112015, -0.02742580510675907, -0.004634012933820486, 0.028143268078565598, 0.029830966144800186, 0.01568993367254734, 0.01980014145374298, 0.023034419864416122, 0.0032691105734556913, -0.10788971930742264, 0.0042006755247712135, 0.0013163924450054765, 0.04177278280258179, 0.045812927186489105, -0.044127658009529114, -0.005474330857396126, 0.041835635900497437, -0.0018396780360490084, -0.00534704839810729, -0.028828637674450874, 0.008391947485506535, -0.0025732223875820637, -0.003910129424184561, -0.02809600532054901, 0.03948134928941727, 0.03575810045003891, 0.012511196546256542, 0.07126270234584808, 0.05257327854633331, -0.005351661238819361, -0.027502913028001785, -0.0127339456230402, 0.032579708844423294, -0.007760126143693924, -0.020479118451476097, 0.07735670357942581, -0.010804799385368824, -0.00825351569801569, 0.04142497852444649, 0.03031265363097191, 0.01343992818146944, -0.0013085484970360994, 0.0052873906679451466, 0.012666657567024231, 0.029944751411676407, 0.013998457230627537, -0.025151802226901054, 0.021383369341492653, -0.005753901321440935, 0.04042508825659752, -0.016346340999007225, 0.0031113559380173683, 0.005013990215957165, 0.016273876652121544, -0.01258098054677248, -0.02421700768172741, 0.017583737149834633, 0.03037341497838497, -0.03520909696817398, 0.04713350906968117, 0.02635914273560047, 0.01110571064054966, -0.047835733741521835, 0.029018724337220192, -0.010565011762082577, -0.003447932656854391, 0.028843307867646217, 0.018018975853919983, -0.0018205844098702073, 0.015620478428900242, -0.013636712916195393, -0.057523034512996674, 0.06126255542039871, -0.0003285787533968687, -0.04187306389212608, -0.07276037335395813, 0.03151647374033928, -0.005096232984215021, -0.027903670445084572, -0.012289761565625668, -0.00386996497400105, -0.0795927494764328, -0.0013176919892430305, -0.0027821839321404696, 0.007186719682067633, -0.025538304820656776, -0.02741391398012638, 0.021413667127490044, -0.09495553374290466, 0.06344623863697052, -0.01439537201076746, -0.043212924152612686, -0.00577299389988184, 0.00837131217122078, -0.018376978114247322, 0.03044889122247696, 0.0473831482231617, 0.008013984188437462, -0.004673337563872337, 0.0028694651555269957, 0.017422664910554886, -0.010923394933342934, -0.04814045503735542, 0.031109392642974854, -0.017270030453801155, 0.002940848469734192, 0.003402171190828085, 0.010758964344859123, 0.035645805299282074, 0.02217627689242363, 0.0363609753549099, 0.019883623346686363, 0.010526091791689396, -0.01803566887974739, -0.020828930661082268, 0.028836339712142944, 0.009108463302254677, -0.021385110914707184, 0.07629545778036118, 0.013082576915621758, 0.02586531825363636, -0.027917496860027313, -0.02689173072576523, -0.06025596708059311, -0.013742034323513508, -0.02621399238705635, -0.018998214974999428, -0.017604641616344452, 0.011136647313833237, 0.0204501710832119, -0.019922122359275818, -0.028934810310602188, 0.05496221035718918, 0.00858224555850029, -0.04608936607837677, 0.05809181183576584, 0.019839733839035034, 0.06289926916360855, 0.002236270811408758, 0.028430473059415817, -0.022378599271178246, -0.00372066767886281, 0.010522983968257904, -0.04551531374454498, 0.035232674330472946, 0.004063844680786133, 0.009377329610288143, 0.010605463758111, -0.053427744656801224, 0.028398143127560616, 0.008563503623008728, -0.005181037820875645, -0.05237150192260742, -0.027050143107771873, -0.010974036529660225, -0.01107864547520876, -0.016789980232715607, -0.00879297312349081, -0.014409048482775688, 0.0764371007680893, -0.01390568446367979, -0.01577124185860157, -0.012346162460744381, -0.014074102975428104, -0.017468268051743507, 0.015710683539509773, 0.008194329217076302, 0.04373907670378685, 0.01147981733083725, 0.050016388297080994, -0.0006719783414155245, 0.014824533835053444, 0.008261457085609436, -0.0044915322214365005, 0.026298699900507927, 0.02337060123682022, -0.03249608725309372, -0.017851432785391808, -0.03300561010837555, -0.033608581870794296, -0.028310760855674744, -0.02286362275481224, 0.05559879541397095, 0.029016731306910515, -0.018385857343673706, 0.0014507391024380922, -0.014250209555029869, 0.026420019567012787, -0.08148766309022903, -0.007948820479214191, -0.021167317405343056, -0.002378009958192706, 0.0008952469215728343, -0.03060135804116726 ]
<p>I have a list of parameters which correlate with 1-2 covariates that I want to control for.</p> <p>Following normalization, I wanted to do comparisons between groups, correlation analysis and probably use some of them as features in a prediction model.</p> <p>The problem is that I don't think I can use the normalized values following ANOVA for regression analysis (and so on), since they will be by default correlated as a result of the ANCOVA.</p> <p>Do you agree (or not)? What else would you suggest? </p>
74,336
[ -0.03001859039068222, 0.030979815870523453, -0.008202790282666683, 0.018913529813289642, 0.035936735570430756, 0.016589010134339333, -0.031383294612169266, -0.0294676274061203, 0.018286019563674927, -0.028687166050076485, 0.02997541055083275, 0.01539207436144352, 0.034231361001729965, 0.04018411785364151, 0.008516850881278515, -0.006294383201748133, -0.018734142184257507, -0.020518096163868904, 0.010461684316396713, -0.024522390216588974, -0.018991880118846893, 0.04632892459630966, 0.023476405069231987, 0.013196790590882301, 0.0027742465026676655, 0.03927500918507576, 0.004398195538669825, -0.055436138063669205, 0.021131642162799835, 0.030758555978536606, -0.0391993448138237, -0.03719028830528259, 0.002234117593616247, 0.06296700239181519, 0.011418881826102734, 0.002606936264783144, -0.02556244097650051, -0.007222378626465797, 0.012212255969643593, 0.027997827157378197, -0.011972169391810894, -0.029983120039105415, 0.015245429240167141, 0.05107319727540016, 0.005656029563397169, 0.0276042353361845, -0.0066257962025702, -0.02165207639336586, 0.005921957083046436, -0.05051156505942345, 0.08844088762998581, 0.013073119334876537, 0.024448007345199585, 0.08147063851356506, -0.008222571574151516, -0.0177693460136652, 0.05209703743457794, 0.030627189204096794, -0.006278586573898792, -0.08818474411964417, -0.008744673803448677, -0.019056037068367004, 0.014936690218746662, 0.02071998454630375, -0.048111096024513245, 0.00030290751601569355, -0.013835512101650238, -0.023523636162281036, 0.016567930579185486, -0.027231847867369652, 0.029418637976050377, 0.03659670427441597, 0.042556729167699814, -0.02030450478196144, 0.016600478440523148, -0.028029123321175575, 0.0346839465200901, -0.014215962961316109, 0.06071685627102852, 0.03473295271396637, 0.032857730984687805, 0.0354943610727787, 0.009883010759949684, 0.023513413965702057, 0.024929245933890343, 0.0172894150018692, 0.04423355311155319, -0.04162609949707985, 0.022810930386185646, 0.04790223389863968, -0.013275563716888428, -0.021470634266734123, 0.06635178625583649, 0.019360922276973724, -0.03974619880318642, 0.03866482153534889, -0.03765511140227318, 0.034577637910842896, 0.017895689234137535, 0.0009621084318496287, -0.023788856342434883, -0.020325850695371628, 0.024968283250927925, 0.013071713037788868, -0.00436836201697588, 0.007748214062303305, -0.03371216729283333, 0.0027554200496524572, -0.014369727112352848, -0.026385203003883362, -0.010043627582490444, -0.01297262217849493, -0.018960902467370033, -0.001805387088097632, 0.0468340739607811, -0.0024754225742071867, -0.019814008846879005, -0.0054855383932590485, 0.048761945217847824, 0.056832455098629, 0.030470306053757668, -0.009827809408307076, 0.00650844257324934, 0.00011698193702613935, -0.043463870882987976, -0.01634974032640457, 0.03885940462350845, -0.004381266888231039, -0.034348905086517334, 0.07524309307336807, -0.014622682705521584, -0.017189793288707733, 0.022334739565849304, -0.032634902745485306, 0.053331516683101654, 0.01822686567902565, -0.08877784758806229, -0.048463016748428345, 0.020635496824979782, -0.008830697275698185, -0.009971197694540024, -0.05486363545060158, 0.0011678219307214022, 0.02817704901099205, 0.06484054028987885, 0.008391167968511581, 0.008163833990693092, -0.024076025933027267, 0.03305346891283989, 0.01376738864928484, -0.00031409331131726503, -0.011453320272266865, -0.023393206298351288, -0.06224680319428444, -0.03528107330203056, -0.07035420835018158, 0.021496430039405823, -0.0028330206405371428, 0.036608222872018814, 0.03289302811026573, 0.021127521991729736, -0.03084760345518589, -0.043451495468616486, -0.004062009509652853, 0.013590216636657715, -0.039341554045677185, 0.05314895138144493, -0.0036263337824493647, 0.04822959750890732, 0.007666454650461674, 0.009007335640490055, 0.010514328256249428, -0.0356142558157444, 0.036053188145160675, 0.04331878572702408, -0.005948700476437807, -0.015021699480712414, -0.027406562119722366, 0.03960110619664192, 0.022998707368969917, -0.037113673985004425, -0.03760865330696106, -0.022715728729963303, 0.026148591190576553, 0.05458562448620796, 0.04130587726831436, 0.023378713056445122, -0.017507227137684822, 0.02664218656718731, -0.034010544419288635, 0.0201572235673666, -0.08567789196968079, -0.02630196511745453, -0.007432508748024702, -0.031321391463279724, 0.04155382513999939, -0.013114132918417454, 0.008085737004876137, 0.010623813606798649, -0.02264373004436493, -0.036178115755319595, 0.000859333376865834, 0.077884241938591, -0.0476277694106102, 0.0313425250351429, 0.012313161045312881, 0.05597054213285446, -0.027783188968896866, 0.06309875845909119, -0.02016756869852543, -0.053206972777843475, 0.010588998906314373, -0.03311699256300926, 0.009653560817241669, -0.004192696418613195, -0.0036523030139505863, 0.008814806118607521, 0.005940551869571209, -0.03983958810567856, 0.0426369234919548, -0.07503728568553925, 0.0668988972902298, 0.06351716071367264, -0.017212217673659325, 0.0011980982962995768, 0.01589890755712986, 0.03950737044215202, 0.026644041761755943, -0.05781380459666252, 0.005931450519710779, -0.010847623459994793, 0.0042783054523169994, 0.022004742175340652, 0.030958175659179688, -0.045102085918188095, -0.023777799680829048, 0.07071503251791, 0.015255704522132874, 0.038915980607271194, 0.030612165108323097, 0.03950515389442444, 0.004716814961284399, -0.010204131714999676, 0.020814545452594757, 0.03857308253645897, -0.0019136207411065698, -0.010111810639500618, -0.009087227284908295, 0.0475265197455883, 0.026068324223160744, 0.021152202039957047, 0.028226526454091072, 0.023269234225153923, -0.008345698937773705, -0.02072984166443348, -0.017762059345841408, 0.017085157334804535, -0.015867965295910835, 0.014077521860599518, 0.014977328479290009, 0.008373556658625603, -0.04786668345332146, -0.005276298616081476, -0.039107754826545715, -0.0003545587242115289, 0.02487991191446781, -0.0458158440887928, 0.02582421340048313, 0.009749991819262505, -0.010868406854569912, 0.007998629473149776, -0.016356684267520905, -0.025608139112591743, -0.01998891308903694, -0.007744200527667999, 0.02283691242337227, -0.008785000070929527, 0.039692189544439316, -0.0242164246737957, -0.031808964908123016, -0.006037308368831873, 0.01018546149134636, -0.004369169939309359, 0.03208509460091591, -0.03337477892637253, -0.017583133652806282, -0.03405291587114334, -0.030007731169462204, 0.011942123994231224, -0.01815018802881241, 0.025307100266218185, 0.02696726657450199, -0.0055793169885873795, -0.057327479124069214, -0.038716718554496765, 0.006768413819372654, 0.01785333640873432, -0.01382055226713419, -0.03818544000387192, 0.04463774338364601, -0.011557926423847675, -0.055317625403404236, -0.010733587667346, -0.012940613552927971, -0.018560731783509254, -0.02241682820022106, -0.004889368545264006, 0.005993555765599012, -0.011463693343102932, 0.002928456524387002, 0.025620535016059875, -0.04003002494573593, -0.03738471120595932, -0.04070809856057167, -0.05597317963838577, 0.02780180051922798, 0.022571120411157608, 0.04071584716439247, -0.02465311996638775, -0.009043979458510876, 0.08332043141126633, 0.02438565343618393, -0.04979277029633522, -0.05405934154987335, -0.010535565204918385, -0.04516727104783058, -0.039086680859327316, -0.0035702281165868044, -0.0010640815598890185, -0.007550396025180817, 0.01340476330369711, 0.006723362486809492, 0.025530079379677773, 0.05082441493868828, 0.021491091698408127, -0.00666393805295229, 0.03327739238739014, 0.03474457189440727, -0.0029519828967750072, 0.02687976323068142, 0.01334455143660307, -0.01833605393767357, -0.01943269371986389, 0.001880763447843492, 0.017741169780492783, 0.00485191447660327, -0.04532527178525925, 0.033877041190862656, -0.03628594055771828, 0.03625349700450897, -0.06055247783660889, 0.00465790368616581, 0.049666628241539, -0.014136645011603832, -0.0481632761657238, 0.018976980820298195, 0.008508313447237015, -0.02335282973945141, -0.001293141394853592, 0.03379428759217262, 0.04635065793991089, -0.0002842178218998015, -0.013402227312326431, 0.01117772702127695, -0.011748465709388256, 0.023005744442343712, -0.026753416284918785, -0.0033197933807969093, 0.047926586121320724, 0.022340571507811546, -0.02597668021917343, 0.005089725833386183, -0.06423088908195496, 0.0026703348848968744, -0.09016958624124527, 0.023101739585399628, -0.04216295853257179, 0.03593757376074791, 0.016605427488684654, 0.04498845711350441, 0.0026626300532370806, -0.02125617116689682, -0.008924348279833794, 0.0037390263751149178, -0.09010714292526245, 0.033442918211221695, -0.046296246349811554, -0.016894850879907608, -0.009879405610263348, -0.05927148088812828, 0.0046149855479598045, -0.0052508278749883175, -0.005659926682710648, -0.005976336542516947, 0.016839003190398216, -0.004744550678879023, -0.01631465181708336, -0.030416732653975487, -0.034873899072408676, -0.013263198547065258, -0.011575253680348396, -0.023908061906695366, -0.007430687081068754, 0.04562829062342644, 0.036138635128736496, -0.012747951783239841, -0.0136292465031147, -0.013795111328363419, 0.03241056576371193, 0.042150504887104034, 0.0523468516767025, 0.03547428920865059, 0.021090539172291756, -0.05539018660783768, 0.042779359966516495, -0.0062657673843204975, 0.02389838546514511, 0.03282957151532173, -0.001162954606115818, 0.00012416137906257063, -0.0312116090208292, -0.05504574626684189, 0.04071818292140961, 0.0018426142632961273, 0.018257800489664078, -0.04094906896352768, 0.03322780132293701, 0.030808020383119583, -0.03390585631132126, -0.009151616133749485, 0.05620985105633736, 0.021472305059432983, -0.018805211409926414, -0.023997001349925995, 0.021186398342251778, -0.0003172967117279768, 0.015014000236988068, -0.002370390109717846, 0.02186608873307705, 0.012443275190889835, 0.007157801650464535, 0.014774440787732601, -0.015553893521428108, 0.00017231811943929642, -0.006764986086636782, 0.04165293648838997, 0.0587298721075058, -0.0045909876935184, -0.008267193101346493, 0.01686011254787445, 0.02577054314315319, -0.0039707669056952, 0.02787686698138714, -0.012367954477667809, -0.07283895462751389, 0.022637996822595596, 0.03781641274690628, 0.05086855962872505, -0.03085760772228241, -0.028527939692139626, 0.02720266953110695, -0.035744935274124146, 0.03708109259605408, -0.0117349149659276, 0.015299713239073753, -0.017034076154232025, -0.01799887977540493, -0.03286973759531975, -0.035063236951828, -0.06779246032238007, 0.018954968079924583, -0.02374126948416233, -0.0027454416267573833, 0.005075789988040924, -0.023708604276180267, -0.060013286769390106, -0.01415778324007988, -0.009554379619657993, 0.07492376118898392, 0.005248046945780516, -0.00015291385352611542, 0.03341984376311302, 0.028379108756780624, 0.006606471724808216, -0.0689983069896698, 0.02143072336912155, 0.020131798461079597, -0.008569549769163132, 0.057950135320425034, -0.00020983166177757084, -0.019979650154709816, 0.026410408318042755, -0.006839795503765345, -0.018912557512521744, -0.0016042960342019796, -0.02140967547893524, 0.051962487399578094, 0.013250261545181274, -0.0005365744582377374, 0.06439543515443802, 0.0346875935792923, 0.0025489404797554016, -0.019897857680916786, -0.07664430886507034, 0.00685381842777133, 0.004387818276882172, -0.018024353310465813, -0.05608881264925003, -0.014458892866969109, 0.005114101804792881, 0.007698738016188145, 0.030919646844267845, 0.027161408215761185, -0.023466462269425392, -0.028165584430098534, 0.03546527028083801, 0.010227593593299389, -0.0012769345194101334, -0.04030949994921684, 0.02341928333044052, -0.010200293734669685, -0.006347284652292728, -0.039302222430706024, -0.007470718119293451, -0.006736536510288715, -0.005335681606084108, 0.03489766642451286, -0.05638175085186958, -0.03226165473461151, -0.04404579848051071, -0.02542843483388424, -0.01824658177793026, -0.04161844030022621, 0.00641345651820302, 0.03161798045039177, 0.045691102743148804, -0.011221596039831638, -0.052623238414525986, -0.00042292915168218315, 0.05199164152145386, -0.013499119319021702, 0.019626621156930923, -0.05506162345409393, 0.04673672467470169, -0.04651274532079697, 0.002779364353045821, -0.032537221908569336, -0.02146732248365879, -0.01061231642961502, 0.010748052969574928, 0.0015096073038876057, 0.0065106539987027645, -0.01452290266752243, -0.02763551101088524, -0.01934659481048584, -0.020625516772270203, 0.025741619989275932, -0.02240772731602192, 0.004073983523994684, 0.018261156976222992, 0.011940054595470428, 0.10678368806838989, -0.009040956385433674, 0.0028420474845916033, 0.030827417969703674, -0.013734821230173111, -0.023945432156324387, 0.0030585392378270626, -0.0040426417253911495, -0.038330595940351486, -0.0011324306251481175, -0.040635377168655396, -0.0004141172976233065, 0.045338910073041916, -0.0036074325907975435, -0.014804030768573284, 0.01973721571266651, -0.00961004663258791, -0.0181378573179245, -0.0423356369137764, -0.029893623664975166, 0.0008572396473027766, 0.009060888551175594, 0.0018925092881545424, 0.02895519509911537, -0.01470068097114563, 0.011892491020262241, 0.033850058913230896, 0.010234149172902107, 0.005274331662803888, 0.0007242601132020354, 0.05550427734851837, 0.019788099452853203, 0.013262261636555195, -0.005246999207884073, -0.02882426418364048, 0.05171556770801544, 0.023374978452920914, 0.017119545489549637, 0.0025327319744974375, 0.03188951686024666, -0.023876043036580086, -0.005312959663569927, -0.02621661312878132, -0.04762137681245804, 0.048284366726875305, -0.018798789009451866, 0.06798650324344635, 0.03601790964603424, 0.012575454078614712, -0.03725485876202583, -0.043587613850831985, -0.02493179403245449, -0.010608101263642311, 0.0017331494018435478, 0.04904738441109657, -0.029725536704063416, -0.028377098962664604, -0.004406216088682413, 0.01561794150620699, -0.005708056502044201, 0.04642751067876816, -0.0031042105983942747, 0.03328629583120346, 0.008780797943472862, 0.03533763065934181, -0.05903434380888939, 0.04654606804251671, -0.05330107733607292, -0.025266284123063087, -0.04266892746090889, -0.03352326154708862, 0.0364883653819561, 0.030657611787319183, 0.009241094812750816, -0.03525947406888008, -0.04651084914803505, -0.04596136137843132, 0.04542126879096031, 0.006389161571860313, -0.03683323413133621, 0.022171011194586754, -0.010455145500600338, 0.06093845143914223, -0.032689835876226425, 0.018314087763428688, -0.03336061164736748, -0.08210970461368561, -0.012375019490718842, -0.03323265537619591, 0.005742392037063837, 0.05235559120774269, -0.008242973126471043, -0.026876822113990784, 0.004305053036659956, -0.038229748606681824, 0.003863811958581209, -0.04085112363100052, 0.034182723611593246, -0.019304826855659485, 0.05171843245625496, -0.008271461352705956, -0.04152568057179451, 0.03685732185840607, 0.02079223468899727, 0.09467390179634094, 0.0664001926779747, 0.04139433801174164, -0.05955655127763748, 0.006755800452083349, -0.009209851734340191, 0.011909954249858856, -0.015769321471452713, 0.022880656644701958, 0.0028096323367208242, -0.029003258794546127, 0.062073417007923126, 0.02597982808947563, -0.0005073176580481231, 0.027425503358244896, 0.0607137605547905, -0.010444298386573792, -0.015677545219659805, 0.018067121505737305, 0.015243489295244217, -0.013773150742053986, -0.002301845233887434, -0.007006510626524687, 0.013695367611944675, -0.03814198821783066, -0.016044141724705696, -0.01560860127210617, -0.0012118476442992687, -0.00445557339116931, -0.017042849212884903, -0.020176708698272705, 0.003975871950387955, 0.03547197952866554, 0.018974801525473595, -0.024243783205747604, -0.015012082643806934, 0.03807278722524643, -0.043298784643411636, 0.0010881003690883517, 0.0013918541371822357, -0.02122422866523266, -0.0051165078766644, 0.008933547884225845, -0.012070599012076855, -0.04207699000835419, -0.012122755870223045, -0.011841841973364353, 0.04133183881640434, -0.0034261264372617006, -0.004866187460720539, -0.017049262300133705, -0.0009679118520580232, 0.010694300755858421, -0.03516964614391327, -0.019034655764698982, -0.0018724367255344987, 0.006606143433600664, -0.006554058287292719, 0.010559067130088806, -0.04440736770629883, -0.03965210169553757, 0.01927616447210312, 0.043865736573934555, 0.014004586264491081, -0.007168503012508154, 0.008206038735806942, -0.04999274015426636, 0.0442415289580822, 0.013086453080177307, -0.009190277196466923, 0.016294455155730247, -0.014083153568208218, -0.0446375273168087, 0.002929932437837124, 0.025367332622408867, 0.026268107816576958, 0.05433903634548187, -0.015710851177573204, 0.028248978778719902, -0.038381386548280716, -0.05090637505054474, 0.029376817867159843, -0.025556394830346107, 0.0038694569375365973, -0.010988637804985046, 0.012738502584397793, 0.04236626997590065, 0.08569374680519104, 0.010221943259239197, -0.014521051198244095, -0.001501713297329843, 0.05694754794239998, 0.035829056054353714, -0.059546906501054764, -0.030871495604515076, 0.01418681163340807, -0.03527987003326416, 0.008289474993944168, -0.009095827117562294, 0.05433402583003044, 0.00424498924985528, 0.00913961511105299, -0.025723032653331757, 0.034720562398433685, -0.008360618725419044, 0.02864672802388668, 0.029975377023220062, -0.045585379004478455, 0.024819493293762207, 0.01173695269972086, 0.02649109996855259, 0.01910807378590107, -0.023171601817011833, -0.020230473950505257, -0.042454589158296585, 0.04232899844646454, -0.02020213194191456, 0.0076517462730407715, -0.008339877240359783, -0.013006634078919888, 0.0255805104970932, -0.029035933315753937, -0.008084789849817753, -0.08907874673604965, -0.002188761020079255, -0.015761425718665123, -0.035045869648456573, 0.010310300625860691, 0.007522869855165482, -0.02623332105576992, 0.03586413711309433, 0.062212880700826645, 0.029175788164138794, 0.05457942932844162, -0.012690815143287182, -0.03750050812959671, 0.0023519997484982014, 0.09481639415025711, -0.015553396195173264, 0.0015254805330187082, -0.015964863821864128, -0.027293279767036438, -0.010607044212520123, -0.0032489467412233353, 0.03426789492368698, 0.03941319137811661, 0.023564228788018227, -0.021548759192228317, -0.05815963074564934, 0.07042106986045837, -0.010333916172385216, -0.026862461119890213, -0.01220686361193657, 0.0016862177290022373, -0.024984106421470642, 0.027242017909884453, 0.03400065377354622, 0.005591258406639099, -0.010633694007992744, 0.020738577470183372, 0.04602492228150368, 0.034867063164711, -0.006265148054808378, 0.01122528687119484, 0.02705291472375393, 0.014139392413198948, -0.01061571016907692, 0.003925770055502653, 0.018845563754439354, 0.05086649954319, -0.04631035774946213, 0.03231241554021835, 0.009373797103762627, 0.017880436033010483, -0.0725627914071083, -0.024818778038024902, 0.0001050960345310159, 0.016198042780160904, 0.020653096958994865, -0.031491152942180634, -0.022024016827344894, 0.014689337462186813, -0.05467916652560234, 0.01562117412686348, 0.005190872121602297, -0.056235410273075104, -0.017678162083029747, 0.01475580595433712, -0.016768986359238625, 0.02113994210958481, 0.01216067187488079, 0.028325466439127922, -0.0014573353109881282, 0.029744978994131088, 0.028448941186070442, -0.03925701603293419, -0.010417833924293518, -0.021277956664562225, 0.01828799583017826, -0.05679821968078613, -0.00411973986774683, -0.032679785043001175, -0.050799209624528885, 0.023420995101332664, 0.0004873019934166223, 0.0033328132703900337, 0.02452581189572811, 0.028435444459319115, 0.015156787820160389, 0.042910560965538025, 0.05643690004944801, 0.006448541302233934, 0.0025839286390691996, -0.0018068307545036077, 0.029897646978497505, 0.030195295810699463, -0.009068197570741177, 0.03336605057120323, 0.019162796437740326, -0.005761272739619017, -0.03959151729941368, 0.010641636326909065, -0.03546170890331268, -0.03215835243463516, -0.0032524350099265575, -0.0029190953355282545, -0.015517945401370525, -0.0008904595160856843, -0.014650904573500156, -0.03454230725765228, -0.006578792817890644, 0.030117211863398552, 0.005039822775870562, -0.024873901158571243, -0.01226928923279047, -0.0012919623404741287, -0.026676012203097343, 0.021681396290659904, 0.03293287009000778, -0.006541061215102673, -0.0689096674323082, 0.030926942825317383, 0.016031397506594658, -0.03391324356198311, -0.015936216339468956, -0.027132323011755943, -0.011903535574674606, 0.017697211354970932, -0.011226189322769642, 0.013566135428845882, -0.017674116417765617, 0.004137048497796059, -0.0209297277033329, -0.0926026850938797, 0.0390641875565052, 0.0234184879809618, -0.02476278878748417, -0.05339571833610535, 0.0283864364027977, -0.019811362028121948, 0.057547677308321, 0.06453580409288406, 0.00426380755379796, 0.030113818123936653, -0.016568725928664207, 0.029622724279761314, 0.015301330015063286, -0.029004555195569992, 0.06658011674880981, 0.0028150638099759817, -0.02810795046389103, 0.003606868674978614, 0.00879924651235342, -0.012433011084794998, 0.01958599127829075, 0.0071939220651984215, -0.019773177802562714, 0.04470830410718918, 0.0033241449855268, -0.009644070640206337, 0.05176038667559624, 0.024201320484280586, -0.02923925593495369, 0.029286349192261696, -0.012695887126028538, 0.0011672821128740907, 0.030553234741091728, 0.011717278510332108, -0.05733785405755043, 0.010755176655948162, -0.045665815472602844, -0.04791780561208725, -0.015547895804047585, 0.03137397766113281, -0.015268659219145775, -0.05428309738636017, 0.03544006869196892, 0.03473271057009697, -0.053314484655857086, -0.02373487502336502, 0.025842905044555664, 0.018660154193639755, 0.026056770235300064, -0.017232077196240425, 0.05021822452545166, 0.031744398176670074, -0.029186446219682693, 0.03208186477422714, 0.02520369365811348, 0.04049180448055267, 0.0209753829985857, -0.024041354656219482, 0.01582922413945198, 0.00531837297603488, 0.01299426332116127, -0.0059080421924591064, 0.018483571708202362, -0.057004522532224655, -0.0012478146236389875, 0.00030488945776596665, -0.02678055129945278, 0.06429708749055862, -0.0051325540989637375, 0.01873508095741272, 0.029093990102410316, -0.05999523401260376, -0.017058657482266426, -0.03831539303064346, -0.013686900027096272, -0.03110663592815399, -0.004122557118535042, 0.011382672935724258, 0.0347256101667881, 0.027264699339866638, 0.006489858031272888, -0.002411429537460208, -0.030800024047493935, 0.03419388085603714, -0.021053684875369072, 0.04048605635762215, -0.0024853688664734364, -0.003998912870883942, -0.018005801364779472, 0.0022552143782377243, -0.053435396403074265, -0.0061169397085905075, 0.027642695233225822, 0.002054635901004076, 0.0311125461012125, -0.029198570176959038, -0.006099388003349304, 0.010515525005757809, 0.038782306015491486, -0.06548576802015305, -0.024471819400787354, -0.018199438229203224, 0.024559741839766502, 0.004054292105138302, 0.002720105927437544 ]
<p>Let us suppose that I have a number of features. I design pdfs for every feature and every class, some of them by smoothing some histogram of training samples, others just by introducing the prior knowledge on how the feature should look like.</p> <p>Now I want to know which is the most likely class for a given observation, based on the pdfs. I can state the following:</p> <p>$$P(p_i\in C_i | F_i) = \displaystyle\frac{P(F_i | p_i\in C_i ) P(p_i\in C_i)}{\displaystyle \sum_{C_j} P(F_i | p_i\in C_j ) P(p_\in C_j)}$$</p> <p>being $p_i$ a particular observation with feature $F_i$, $C_i$ the class I'm assigning to it. What I've doing so far is just replacing $P(\cdot|\cdot)$ by its density function $\delta$ given that $P(\cdot|\cdot)$ is about $2\epsilon \delta(\cdot|\cdot) $ for a neighborhood $[F_i-\epsilon,F_i+\epsilon]$ and I can cancel out the $2\epsilon$, so I suppose it's just legitimate to directly take the value at the density function.</p> <p>Now, there's one feature in particular in which I want to convey that I just don't care about its value in a very wide range, for one of the classes. It's an area, so say the area can be between zero and a large value. In other words, in this class we can find any area. In another class, there is a shorter dynamic range of the values the feature should take. The problem that I find is that the result of the formula before is always lower for the 'don't care' class because the uniform distribution extends far away and hence the value of the pdf is low at every point. My desired behavior would be that since I don't care much about the area, there should be a more fair competition among the two classes, and probably some other features in the classification process will make the final decision, but this way I just say that the problematic class is very unlikely for any input of this feature.</p> <p>I could tune $P(p\in C_i)$ to be higher for the problematic class. However, in other features this is not what I expect. Any clues on how to handle this or pose this problem?</p>
74,337
[ -0.0066159386187791824, -0.0013381451135501266, 0.06401140987873077, -0.007558101788163185, 0.011151961982250214, 0.01961800456047058, 0.007202661596238613, -0.011518089100718498, 0.02430654503405094, -0.04872302711009979, 0.005989771336317062, 0.021379655227065086, 0.05706392228603363, 0.023111972957849503, 0.020341090857982635, 0.00799028854817152, -0.02016935683786869, 0.014366601593792439, -0.03299610689282417, -0.0500168614089489, 0.015726318582892418, 0.04769410565495491, 0.05326602980494499, -0.01045074313879013, -0.04039055109024048, 0.050550371408462524, 0.00860645156353712, -0.03862026333808899, -0.005407785531133413, 0.08536045253276825, -0.045872513204813004, -0.027393603697419167, -0.008546804077923298, 0.04232045263051987, 0.033959586173295975, 0.03314536437392235, 0.008187204599380493, -0.020811937749385834, 0.0011226703645661473, 0.02129906229674816, -0.05729658529162407, -0.004451639950275421, 0.014661985449492931, 0.021490316838026047, -0.034043338149785995, 0.038941070437431335, 0.0009325600112788379, -0.04694872349500656, 0.004976102616637945, -0.04787450656294823, 0.03981150686740875, 0.01646694354712963, 0.015030116774141788, 0.0734887421131134, -0.03822064399719238, -0.05140407383441925, 0.03980616480112076, 0.06574687361717224, -0.0027567839715629816, -0.03662184625864029, -0.023515969514846802, -0.039105020463466644, -0.007062755990773439, -0.04851168021559715, -0.007968924008309841, 0.01565546728670597, -0.014922830276191235, -0.01188441552221775, 0.005418587476015091, -0.03413989394903183, 0.022807585075497627, 0.014463299885392189, 0.012000682763755322, -0.018928052857518196, 0.055930446833372116, 0.029898613691329956, -0.009152903221547604, 0.04152659699320793, 0.022966371849179268, -0.001372937927953899, 0.023876922205090523, -0.010614647530019283, 0.019250933080911636, 0.05577726662158966, 0.009246669709682465, 0.004802738782018423, 0.05368794500827789, -0.01844366453588009, 0.029816266149282455, 0.020886901766061783, -0.01008203998208046, -0.03181542828679085, 0.033094871789216995, -0.057974737137556076, -0.028263835236430168, 0.05801786854863167, -0.011720019392669201, -0.0340513214468956, 0.004076621029525995, -0.03389459475874901, -0.025835465639829636, -0.052492037415504456, -0.034685634076595306, 0.05402812361717224, -0.024017559364438057, -0.002280200133100152, -0.028231067582964897, -0.04325709864497185, -0.017428820952773094, 0.02002643421292305, -0.03443510830402374, 0.03960290551185608, 0.017673781141638756, -0.006614151410758495, 0.02057644911110401, 0.004502605181187391, -0.011115482077002525, -0.0035759643651545048, 0.02165057137608528, 0.04334624111652374, 0.04861953854560852, -0.0055951932445168495, -0.026312964037060738, -0.0212737824767828, -0.037191275507211685, 0.016062604263424873, 0.062282148748636246, 0.0004261603462509811, -0.0023822684306651354, 0.02324684150516987, 0.006076080724596977, 0.0037278870586305857, 0.04302605241537094, 0.03680701553821564, 0.0018280156655237079, 0.006899358704686165, -0.05643635243177414, -0.025326184928417206, 0.03829933702945709, 0.010167116299271584, 0.013860165141522884, -0.03335674852132797, -0.011818863451480865, 0.054164957255125046, 0.029760301113128662, -0.008912713266909122, 0.009622715413570404, 0.0334690697491169, 0.02749292179942131, 0.01314679253846407, -0.01746777817606926, -0.03355402871966362, -0.03291407600045204, 0.024100959300994873, -0.062433574348688126, -0.06554414331912994, 0.022262034937739372, 0.017475055530667305, -0.02348189800977707, 0.00014467901200987399, 0.03731862083077431, -0.004254316911101341, -0.015968039631843567, -0.032106079161167145, -0.01856720820069313, -0.0028117503970861435, 0.08395019918680191, 0.01194703672081232, 0.045690592378377914, 0.013791748322546482, -0.01978534832596779, 0.02792615070939064, 0.023408057168126106, 0.053465548902750015, 0.07489393651485443, -0.0315513052046299, -0.03539052605628967, -0.03228801116347313, 0.007879321463406086, -0.0047592949122190475, -0.005791427101939917, -0.024280399084091187, -0.03425291180610657, 0.014271735213696957, -0.001232140464708209, 0.025334728881716728, 0.027859196066856384, 0.003507135435938835, 0.046282026916742325, -0.05841986835002899, -0.04344712197780609, -0.08001796901226044, -0.001567502273246646, -0.023749643936753273, -0.04036149010062218, 0.04155287519097328, 0.027193708345294, -0.0016657444648444653, -0.015484023839235306, -0.02574268728494644, -0.03350318223237991, -0.022986317053437233, 0.023976527154445648, -0.04607962816953659, -0.0005597409326583147, 0.07091931253671646, 0.017800472676753998, 0.007792165037244558, 0.03997868672013283, -0.045351628214120865, -0.03850073367357254, -0.009406588971614838, -0.024189941585063934, 0.03598366305232048, -0.014008753933012486, -0.01924620382487774, 0.009254172444343567, -0.010912289842963219, -0.018753990530967712, -0.014135843142867088, -0.05706482380628586, 0.06389423459768295, 0.06708847731351852, -0.007353729102760553, 0.015008598566055298, 0.013357379473745823, -0.021195363253355026, 0.015550559386610985, -0.020685700699687004, 0.008282765746116638, -0.035139478743076324, -0.013192637823522091, 0.04802564159035683, 0.02652115561068058, -0.014491853304207325, -0.012100444175302982, 0.06740633398294449, 0.007971732877194881, 0.034639157354831696, 0.011505234986543655, 0.009369218721985817, 0.003817361779510975, 0.02201140858232975, -0.024831734597682953, -0.011410003527998924, -0.021994784474372864, 0.04075281694531441, 0.013612459413707256, 0.03216772899031639, -0.017467383295297623, -0.0037482823245227337, 0.045306496322155, 0.0348561592400074, -0.011621428653597832, -0.0025600569788366556, 0.018294285982847214, -0.02225644513964653, -0.003194209886714816, 0.0034577115438878536, 0.021194681525230408, -0.025412563234567642, 0.006645398214459419, -0.0315939225256443, -0.06746408343315125, 0.04237986356019974, 0.04136883094906807, -0.01966267079114914, 0.004378488287329674, 0.028975527733564377, -0.05447767302393913, 0.005831792484968901, 0.024962833151221275, -0.040658753365278244, -0.035611413419246674, -0.0013267783215269446, 0.060303159058094025, 0.02054123394191265, -0.02371852658689022, -0.003735713427886367, 0.0011003437684848905, 0.002331601455807686, 0.01940011978149414, 0.06145517900586128, 0.005457716062664986, -0.04861155152320862, -0.04216734692454338, 0.006379739847034216, -0.016099100932478905, 0.018915241584181786, 0.025567833334207535, -0.021414371207356453, 0.013495126739144325, -0.004671778064221144, -0.0334775373339653, -0.007206951268017292, -0.05110993608832359, 0.013369821943342686, -0.04501163959503174, -0.03376093506813049, 0.06862704455852509, 0.016447314992547035, -0.0740082785487175, 0.021964438259601593, 0.0005412830505520105, -0.0408877357840538, -0.07085897028446198, -0.04345138743519783, 0.021151456981897354, 0.0017016062047332525, 0.01184141542762518, 0.021599428728222847, -0.014292517676949501, 0.010380882769823074, -0.05054016038775444, -0.056773729622364044, -0.007594367954879999, -0.041392989456653595, 0.03412533178925514, 0.006346254143863916, 0.0009406256140209734, 0.07807067036628723, 0.05172612518072128, -0.022788725793361664, 0.03152018040418625, 0.009747627191245556, -0.014785628765821457, -0.014772702939808369, 0.003367477096617222, 0.004984772298485041, 0.011802531778812408, 0.008516116999089718, -0.02543552778661251, 0.03385109081864357, 0.06347063928842545, -0.003089850302785635, -0.019999608397483826, 0.025142727419734, -0.028097618371248245, 0.0014005530392751098, 0.0474281869828701, 0.0258030965924263, -0.014296256937086582, 0.0022382265888154507, 0.027269743382930756, 0.02300194278359413, 0.037655286490917206, -0.05241326242685318, 0.008300014771521091, -0.03739964962005615, 0.03417394682765007, -0.026961009949445724, 0.027547454461455345, 0.0011719404719769955, -0.046073127537965775, -0.008181317709386349, 0.016293536871671677, 0.05500975623726845, -0.03435000777244568, 0.001016839873045683, 0.03589995577931404, 0.04255447909235954, 0.010641775093972683, -0.03298927843570709, -0.003810279304161668, -0.009485095739364624, 0.045187100768089294, 0.0009296529460698366, -0.030782869085669518, 0.016061432659626007, 0.031171293929219246, 0.003105678129941225, 0.01655060052871704, -0.02406845986843109, 0.012150081805884838, -0.05100886896252632, -0.0033616020809859037, -0.0038365533109754324, 0.07127613574266434, 0.008698232471942902, 0.01973196677863598, -0.01592014543712139, -0.01148171816021204, 0.009745628573000431, 0.014251425862312317, -0.05855467915534973, 0.018713941797614098, 0.023266268894076347, -0.00017890185699798167, -0.021580928936600685, -0.03023023158311844, 0.0769534632563591, 0.0035900212824344635, 0.011110611259937286, -0.039958417415618896, 0.05204629525542259, -0.03509145230054855, 0.008164321072399616, -0.015017248690128326, -0.0342998132109642, -0.021621854975819588, 0.02236033044755459, 0.050061024725437164, 0.005569940432906151, 0.05241876095533371, 0.011180728673934937, 0.01781591773033142, -0.01418157946318388, -0.007780368439853191, 0.03815028816461563, 0.023997042328119278, 0.029443269595503807, -0.015693331137299538, 0.051176995038986206, -0.02493986114859581, 0.04269326478242874, 0.03768602013587952, 0.08474727720022202, 0.032409001141786575, -0.0023712667170912027, 0.0030147184152156115, -0.03275171294808388, -0.05755746737122536, -0.009624915197491646, 0.057511694729328156, -0.008580513298511505, -0.03628106042742729, 0.026623522862792015, -0.0010676020756363869, -0.0794491171836853, 0.022851375862956047, 0.029307562857866287, -0.013879475183784962, -0.004130802117288113, -0.05414789915084839, -0.02279561758041382, -0.017048027366399765, 0.008253187872469425, 0.012734067626297474, 0.005853915121406317, -0.024537716060876846, -0.029369687661528587, 0.03521772846579552, 0.007227300200611353, -0.032856881618499756, -0.06797616183757782, 0.03249112144112587, 0.000612334581092, -0.016072625294327736, -0.009863424114882946, 0.03744160383939743, 0.02612488530576229, 0.015538495033979416, 0.010713339783251286, 0.04392363876104355, -0.08415484428405762, -0.04344276711344719, 0.030614640563726425, 0.0169793963432312, 0.010759486816823483, -0.00008210025407606736, -0.07404138892889023, -0.012351805344223976, 0.0247284397482872, -0.009241585619747639, 0.02531019039452076, 0.0009133904241025448, -0.005222708452492952, -0.0012635630555450916, -0.02324056811630726, -0.06362277269363403, 0.0283122006803751, -0.017999567091464996, 0.02093295194208622, -0.008439220488071442, -0.02600620687007904, -0.07084768265485764, -0.008955752477049828, -0.009507978335022926, 0.05481468141078949, -0.017849760130047798, -0.03238010033965111, -0.008526727557182312, 0.014228140003979206, 0.006080242805182934, -0.08392277359962463, 0.01375025138258934, -0.0033810811582952738, 0.03289099782705307, 0.01399366743862629, -0.007124947849661112, -0.03527938574552536, 0.023206759244203568, -0.019054364413022995, -0.06779677420854568, 0.015046685934066772, -0.010940635576844215, 0.0666830912232399, 0.049367841333150864, 0.03992315009236336, 0.0531545951962471, 0.04885570704936981, 0.012126399204134941, 0.02301180548965931, -0.04097689688205719, 0.0008122841827571392, -0.01540930476039648, -0.03651832416653633, -0.04656695947051048, 0.006334033794701099, -0.014889501966536045, 0.0029752550181001425, -0.005711976904422045, 0.04754505306482315, -0.0132592199370265, -0.03467366844415665, -0.007373629603534937, -0.007399516645818949, -0.008998125791549683, -0.0032697473652660847, -0.023359151557087898, 0.03318148851394653, 0.03856028616428375, 0.032326482236385345, 0.028198305517435074, -0.002711505861952901, 0.004945434629917145, -0.0005195897538214922, -0.031040288507938385, -0.003860850352793932, -0.058337368071079254, -0.023453662171959877, -0.013625833205878735, -0.016317617148160934, 0.031846292316913605, 0.04801619052886963, 0.038861390203237534, 0.022803256288170815, -0.04017657786607742, -0.019945763051509857, -0.01934472844004631, 0.007472014520317316, 0.009454925544559956, -0.03232404589653015, -0.0067609031684696674, 0.011472891084849834, -0.0044250041246414185, -0.08060057461261749, 0.023313486948609352, 0.00009522191976429895, 0.004842070862650871, -0.04573643207550049, -0.027919843792915344, 0.005017150193452835, 0.014074195176362991, -0.03451034799218178, 0.02046876773238182, 0.027574706822633743, 0.007316519506275654, -0.024978026747703552, 0.01515324879437685, 0.020309777930378914, 0.0743379145860672, -0.009223183616995811, 0.0272528026252985, 0.03820963203907013, -0.028799526393413544, -0.01796019822359085, -0.025583870708942413, 0.03710184991359711, -0.02767394669353962, 0.008754738606512547, -0.04319152235984802, 0.006227309815585613, 0.003615547437220812, -0.0011785286478698254, -0.015939250588417053, -0.014141755178570747, 0.00975730363279581, 0.017103485763072968, -0.0209849551320076, -0.028177710250020027, -0.01937292329967022, -0.019219130277633667, -0.0031153904274106026, 0.011657407507300377, -0.026522226631641388, -0.002326798625290394, 0.007135548163205385, -0.015408817678689957, 0.018862934783101082, -0.0026587361935526133, 0.01850767247378826, -0.014873781241476536, -0.0070809959433972836, 0.010445801541209221, -0.010044069029390812, 0.06221168860793114, 0.014304050244390965, -0.0035622406285256147, 0.025250567123293877, 0.03338512033224106, -0.022839384153485298, 0.010196029208600521, -0.08718615025281906, -0.011323049664497375, 0.06301824748516083, -0.023733440786600113, 0.07191675901412964, 0.038960304111242294, -0.009108618833124638, 0.01498420536518097, -0.03850061818957329, -0.01711362600326538, -0.0230012945830822, -0.01662817783653736, 0.01995786279439926, 0.013263330794870853, 0.007084630895406008, 0.04663734510540962, -0.04452497512102127, 0.007766203489154577, 0.025373024865984917, -0.03826802968978882, 0.05696630850434303, 0.04663347825407982, -0.02929643914103508, -0.017390944063663483, 0.062232956290245056, -0.03483671322464943, -0.007487826980650425, -0.007328956387937069, -0.04519043490290642, 0.01657092012465, 0.02933557890355587, -0.012938066385686398, -0.03847638890147209, -0.011275135912001133, -0.04360804706811905, 0.03780997544527054, 0.004478282295167446, -0.0013134145410731435, 0.05200432613492012, -0.024404918774962425, 0.015797441825270653, -0.03150531277060509, -0.0012531105894595385, -0.05250658094882965, -0.021481061354279518, -0.02650400809943676, -0.035825323313474655, -0.035036515444517136, 0.009707068093121052, -0.0010115588083863258, -0.014906730502843857, 0.026491615921258926, 0.01437349058687687, 0.026940718293190002, 0.01589062251150608, 0.0008923062705434859, 0.021654672920703888, 0.032471247017383575, 0.007300027646124363, 0.03437260165810585, -0.01905203051865101, -0.022157983854413033, 0.1568680703639984, 0.06960010528564453, 0.06344566494226456, -0.058646008372306824, 0.021635044366121292, -0.024802368134260178, -0.004564611241221428, -0.04584826901555061, 0.007222292944788933, 0.03416711837053299, -0.015300401486456394, -0.005017728079110384, 0.020686227828264236, 0.03139776363968849, -0.023710831999778748, 0.04124666377902031, -0.024873290210962296, 0.021995509043335915, 0.01840222254395485, 0.028643744066357613, 0.011189489625394344, 0.007531491108238697, -0.03438279405236244, 0.0002892374759539962, 0.04071858525276184, -0.015838783234357834, -0.012246742844581604, -0.023764220997691154, -0.019962608814239502, -0.023229088634252548, -0.020036114379763603, 0.004869547672569752, 0.036823589354753494, 0.004402647260576487, 0.030544565990567207, -0.002571997232735157, -0.006221052259206772, -0.029399408027529716, -0.016718892380595207, 0.034078650176525116, 0.013965686783194542, 0.03648529201745987, 0.004064435139298439, 0.019549163058400154, -0.03340548276901245, -0.033580951392650604, -0.059875503182411194, 0.04796925187110901, -0.028184542432427406, -0.0033869799226522446, 0.014482074417173862, 0.024228226393461227, 0.0336817167699337, -0.03228417783975601, -0.02240697853267193, 0.013984952121973038, 0.012276675552129745, -0.0028264655265957117, -0.010864324867725372, -0.009094198234379292, 0.06144639849662781, 0.0018840961856767535, 0.01013096421957016, 0.0010447546374052763, -0.02556217461824417, -0.05529073253273964, -0.03384983912110329, 0.04783798009157181, 0.036580875515937805, 0.010763291269540787, -0.028884267434477806, 0.030317597091197968, -0.006618071813136339, -0.022841764613986015, -0.012958703562617302, -0.024404682219028473, 0.01189938373863697, 0.002513148123398423, -0.01251094602048397, -0.028601333498954773, -0.051680468022823334, 0.018828658387064934, -0.037324532866477966, 0.05216946825385094, -0.03913058340549469, -0.011815991252660751, -0.00939946435391903, 0.04983222484588623, 0.05125363916158676, -0.031769730150699615, -0.0016407571965828538, 0.06756748259067535, 0.011760578490793705, -0.030291670933365822, -0.022433696314692497, -0.0021356078796088696, -0.032468281686306, 0.027000635862350464, 0.03863731026649475, 0.09003755450248718, 0.02870316430926323, -0.0008346352842636406, 0.0061935787089169025, 0.020609494298696518, -0.03788073733448982, 0.014392875134944916, 0.005774819757789373, -0.03529772162437439, 0.0062773339450359344, 0.007161079905927181, 0.02535613253712654, -0.011152970604598522, 0.01482381485402584, -0.03381022438406944, -0.028965817764401436, 0.004744923207908869, -0.005757306702435017, -0.006596563849598169, -0.009355375543236732, 0.01153779961168766, 0.02538476698100567, -0.009661083109676838, -0.023062432184815407, -0.030360089614987373, -0.0080125592648983, -0.03323047235608101, 0.019510239362716675, -0.0029067767318338156, 0.002874961355701089, 0.010522999800741673, -0.004879462532699108, 0.012962937355041504, 0.020552566275000572, 0.015111373737454414, -0.020608078688383102, 0.019138332456350327, 0.02074546180665493, 0.03925006464123726, -0.003570271423086524, 0.01497936062514782, 0.05227990821003914, -0.007373402360826731, -0.06182802841067314, 0.011820348910987377, -0.008725541643798351, 0.06375528126955032, 0.01575758494436741, 0.003533876035362482, -0.027921507135033607, 0.002155046910047531, -0.0007717406842857599, -0.013297196477651596, 0.004439574666321278, 0.017005156725645065, 0.02645573578774929, -0.02540760114789009, 0.034396570175886154, -0.021846666932106018, 0.01960260234773159, -0.017833037301898003, 0.007386083249002695, -0.018140610307455063, -0.044416435062885284, 0.016818808391690254, -0.07255399227142334, 0.013803547248244286, -0.03740449249744415, 0.013565176166594028, -0.0017809785204008222, -0.005806498229503632, -0.00029611244099214673, 0.005156079772859812, -0.014158431440591812, -0.006076095625758171, -0.11053435504436493, -0.03520001843571663, 0.049616556614637375, 0.016472384333610535, 0.04963046312332153, -0.035134073346853256, -0.004673077259212732, 0.0026608076877892017, -0.027152646332979202, 0.0448356494307518, -0.02713867276906967, 0.035806238651275635, -0.04295821115374565, 0.044447917491197586, -0.04973617568612099, 0.00805528461933136, 0.015538330189883709, 0.012106885202229023, 0.027962345629930496, 0.019681252539157867, -0.01357924286276102, -0.019354790449142456, -0.02518906630575657, -0.01327507570385933, 0.006564803421497345, -0.06720642745494843, 0.03178882226347923, -0.0546170212328434, -0.012865417636930943, 0.015191109851002693, -0.004878162872046232, -0.038952890783548355, -0.010914378799498081, 0.0009620676864869893, 0.03305807709693909, 0.024604616686701775, 0.04096703603863716, 0.00668063061311841, 0.023703979328274727, -0.022357607260346413, 0.026696711778640747, -0.02511555887758732, -0.04740024358034134, -0.027393542230129242, 0.025258919224143028, -0.0044441819190979, -0.05387008935213089, 0.013933093287050724, -0.008032264187932014, -0.03076297417283058, 0.01337945181876421, 0.019147515296936035, 0.007096456829458475, -0.01813179813325405, 0.006145115941762924, -0.03684248402714729, 0.011471258476376534, 0.017446061596274376, 0.011240270920097828, -0.01997438445687294, -0.002074044430628419, -0.02695947326719761, -0.06353208422660828, 0.03004853054881096, 0.030276168137788773, -0.0023593876976519823, -0.02709183283150196, -0.0021923366002738476, -0.023042401298880577, -0.017459802329540253, -0.020979922264814377, -0.021707607433199883, -0.04704531654715538, -0.01625795103609562, -0.023587817326188087, 0.02064540795981884, -0.03823373466730118, 0.006165417842566967, 0.014634971506893635, -0.10698007792234421, 0.0612429678440094, -0.003862494369968772, -0.00449851481243968, 0.0017418841598555446, -0.008227333426475525, -0.018440095707774162, 0.02460687793791294, 0.04832017049193382, 0.03793077543377876, -0.010924989357590675, -0.03294839337468147, 0.020488549023866653, 0.04113476723432541, -0.04270640015602112, 0.03876141086220741, -0.00249176612123847, -0.007626696489751339, -0.010124968364834785, -0.0028415319975465536, 0.028615623712539673, 0.0183916874229908, 0.024167440831661224, 0.013951396569609642, 0.005476715043187141, 0.03311409801244736, 0.015844574198126793, 0.007601174525916576, -0.009288863278925419, -0.003811575472354889, 0.032614801079034805, -0.008792019449174404, 0.03187921643257141, 0.0007392208790406585, -0.011402728036046028, -0.04248412698507309, -0.03128548339009285, -0.036584313958883286, -0.056508444249629974, -0.01842893846333027, 0.04927303269505501, 0.007708598393946886, -0.053024422377347946, -0.0037173426244407892, 0.029702836647629738, -0.03353646770119667, -0.027271047234535217, 0.03945038467645645, -0.009186746552586555, 0.05415373668074608, 0.011282229796051979, 0.03409137204289436, -0.020728055387735367, -0.02349958010017872, -0.005059987772256136, -0.017695492133498192, 0.04230423644185066, -0.011236721649765968, 0.06662283837795258, 0.02858222834765911, 0.011525196954607964, 0.009554107673466206, -0.008969638496637344, 0.024095388129353523, -0.01075039617717266, 0.022519072517752647, 0.018629813566803932, 0.01591488905251026, -0.016742244362831116, 0.021831657737493515, 0.0058541372418403625, 0.04590917378664017, 0.0033243282232433558, -0.013475329615175724, -0.058730848133563995, -0.006017965264618397, -0.02345144748687744, 0.021821772679686546, 0.021962516009807587, 0.034339215606451035, 0.02844010293483734, 0.03431081399321556, 0.00945549737662077, 0.020274203270673752, 0.006616373546421528, -0.024150803685188293, 0.03915897756814957, 0.03118353709578514, -0.01903516985476017, 0.01875942386686802, 0.0054033054038882256, -0.010099920444190502, -0.026133744046092033, -0.0027562661562114954, 0.03323984518647194, 0.038491688668727875, 0.01524297334253788, -0.030708003789186478, -0.013601385988295078, 0.015212266705930233, -0.05603095144033432, -0.015549369156360626, -0.048780813813209534, 0.0064507960341870785, -0.013155287131667137, -0.03284413367509842 ]
<p>Below is a function I wrote to try and tune the $\lambda$ and $\alpha$ elastic net GLM implemented with <code>cv.glmnet</code>. I've noticed that the qualitative outcome (in terms of the alpha that yields the lowest prediction error score) changes depending on the random seed, and I suspect this is mainly because the random seed determines how the folds are partitioned. In one of my datasets, I have only 598 samples and am fitting a Cox regression. That is where this effect is strongest (and, indeed, where the error bars about the prediction errors on the $\lambda$ search grid are largest). When I fit a binomial regression to a larger data set with about 30K observations, I get less jumping around. The number of folds doesn't seem to matter much.</p> <p>I'm thinking of just choosing $\alpha$ = 0.5 in such cases, because the absolute difference in the cross-validation error scores are often quite small, and elastic net has inferential properties that make it more desirable that LASSO or ridge on their own.</p> <p>Is this the right way of thinking? Thanks.</p> <pre><code>cvglmnet2a &lt;- function(x, y, family, nfolds, seed) { set.seed(seed) cvfit0 &lt;- cv.glmnet(x, y, family = family, alpha = 0, nfolds = nfolds) cvfitp5 &lt;- cv.glmnet(x, y, family = family, alpha = 0.5, nfolds = nfolds) cvfit1 &lt;- cv.glmnet(x, y, family = family, alpha = 1, nfolds = nfolds) plot(cvfit1); plot(cvfitp5); plot(cvfit0) plot(log(cvfit1$lambda), cvfit1$cvm, pch = 19, col = "red", xlab = "log(Lambda)", ylab = cvfit1$name) points(log(cvfitp5$lambda), cvfitp5$cvm, pch = 19, col = "grey") points(log(cvfit0$lambda), cvfit0$cvm, pch = 19, col = "blue") legend("topleft", legend = c("alpha = 1", "alpha = 0.5", "alpha = 0"), pch = 19, col = c("red", "grey", "blue")) mins &lt;- c(alpha1 = min(cvfit1$cvm), alphap5 = min(cvfitp5$cvm), alpha0 = min(cvfit0$cvm)) mins } </code></pre>
37,185
[ 0.0010568201541900635, 0.03955361247062683, -0.0038454376626759768, -0.0352056622505188, 0.008822149597108364, -0.020342258736491203, -0.02854590304195881, -0.054586704820394516, 0.04845668375492096, -0.0317397341132164, 0.031069202348589897, 0.019676797091960907, 0.03892264887690544, 0.02378489077091217, -0.013246577233076096, 0.02497970312833786, -0.0064883846789598465, -0.00946426298469305, -0.026111533865332603, -0.014390135183930397, 0.012310676276683807, 0.026730673387646675, -0.044525451958179474, 0.005197466816753149, 0.02317572943866253, 0.07763589173555374, 0.022383099421858788, -0.017014041543006897, -0.007867015898227692, 0.05307232588529587, -0.08097130060195923, 0.005546411033719778, 0.014645331539213657, 0.04090038314461708, 0.03702444210648537, 0.030654670670628548, 0.02126333676278591, -0.0159221813082695, -0.009374612011015415, 0.029474683105945587, -0.004106711130589247, 0.016185671091079712, -0.012713846750557423, 0.03491659089922905, 0.026965714991092682, 0.017810583114624023, 0.013823408633470535, 0.006430472247302532, 0.05663704499602318, -0.021093865856528282, 0.04471758380532265, -0.00602033082395792, -0.011515149846673012, 0.05809653177857399, -0.02549656666815281, -0.01664132811129093, 0.05826152116060257, 0.04802735894918442, 0.0015007859328761697, -0.0481143519282341, 0.005107001401484013, -0.0435367189347744, -0.006559425964951515, -0.034557756036520004, -0.01735188066959381, 0.016412504017353058, 0.041998472064733505, -0.003540984820574522, 0.02698294259607792, -0.051755934953689575, 0.012714027427136898, -0.0025107248220592737, 0.02861408144235611, -0.04039445519447327, 0.004971892572939396, 0.0035204582381993532, -0.01925421506166458, 0.004769627470523119, 0.019273284822702408, -0.010975499637424946, 0.00000913138319447171, 0.03570914268493652, 0.015032369643449783, 0.008326918818056583, -0.011796687729656696, -0.004009843338280916, 0.05643707141280174, -0.008817138150334358, 0.04805850237607956, 0.03611180931329727, -0.034090496599674225, 0.006890702061355114, 0.05225476250052452, -0.000621408224105835, -0.047808755189180374, 0.014381719753146172, 0.002580966567620635, -0.022377565503120422, 0.025786079466342926, -0.0121401846408844, -0.04231657460331917, -0.02905973792076111, -0.035052236169576645, 0.09845470637083054, -0.014499501325190067, 0.010313221253454685, -0.03216780349612236, -0.0432751439511776, -0.024973131716251373, -0.04950385540723801, -0.0003762989363167435, 0.029659641906619072, 0.016881221905350685, -0.007067746017128229, -0.024959996342658997, -0.038507211953401566, 0.005824332591146231, 0.001453804667107761, 0.05267729237675667, 0.042320869863033295, 0.03721114993095398, -0.01912430115044117, 0.01001672726124525, -0.021754102781414986, -0.027722040191292763, 0.01697053201496601, 0.03271861374378204, 0.0021496079862117767, -0.026925407350063324, 0.04436280205845833, -0.0029896246269345284, -0.036342915147542953, 0.013444662094116211, -0.019870812073349953, 0.0009917920688167214, 0.01120294164866209, -0.10919440537691116, -0.05711809918284416, 0.08469680696725845, 0.020924661308526993, 0.03114219196140766, -0.0162793081253767, 0.002105672610923648, 0.016086585819721222, 0.05243883281946182, 0.008636441081762314, 0.04044007509946823, 0.013470339588820934, 0.017208797857165337, -0.004116468597203493, -0.0180252306163311, -0.02244284562766552, -0.04391472041606903, -0.00784301571547985, -0.04260559752583504, -0.059031419456005096, 0.041113827377557755, -0.000959245371632278, -0.010657005943357944, 0.03932848200201988, 0.003931581042706966, -0.01448779832571745, -0.009740477427840233, -0.04261085018515587, -0.00996395479887724, -0.02078143320977688, 0.017753558233380318, 0.02110648714005947, 0.05712747573852539, 0.04082056134939194, -0.05800241231918335, -0.007591709960252047, 0.02713208645582199, 0.02756078541278839, 0.030351828783750534, 0.022934535518288612, 0.036680031567811966, -0.0444081611931324, 0.027430107817053795, 0.02478533796966076, -0.014925460331141949, -0.021504266187548637, -0.051511913537979126, -0.01584971696138382, 0.012976879253983498, 0.038287822157144547, -0.028570981696248055, -0.035596735775470734, 0.03630803897976875, -0.04484310746192932, -0.0507587306201458, -0.007072594948112965, 0.013779183849692345, 0.03234199434518814, 0.00003522665429045446, 0.04217630624771118, -0.011575049720704556, 0.024618614464998245, 0.004169215448200703, 0.04613485932350159, -0.007788474205881357, 0.00898639764636755, 0.0381634347140789, -0.013405376113951206, -0.02969706431031227, 0.055411096662282944, 0.005521954502910376, -0.002607962815091014, 0.04488639533519745, -0.02972983568906784, -0.008938622660934925, 0.033958252519369125, -0.015284616500139236, 0.00758405914530158, -0.047640230506658554, 0.010227824561297894, -0.015746772289276123, 0.012883617542684078, 0.0011658649891614914, 0.03513038530945778, -0.07608582824468613, 0.037042222917079926, 0.029811063781380653, -0.01767035201191902, 0.028142718598246574, -0.0031654725316911936, -0.04496878758072853, 0.05276673287153244, -0.020559683442115784, -0.031225211918354034, -0.04220321401953697, -0.038970574736595154, 0.055009301751852036, 0.047105297446250916, 0.011163412593305111, -0.009706774726510048, 0.05556131526827812, 0.005450048018246889, 0.020245427265763283, -0.02140044793486595, 0.00002740786840149667, -0.019507061690092087, 0.0303327813744545, 0.050608079880476, 0.033468812704086304, -0.03340869024395943, 0.03648553788661957, -0.057516638189554214, 0.05987532436847687, -0.03859590366482735, -0.014573998749256134, 0.04287857189774513, 0.027689402922987938, -0.04994897171854973, -0.042206693440675735, 0.011981568299233913, 0.0294352900236845, 0.008563805371522903, -0.004487017635256052, 0.04050502926111221, 0.008740554563701153, -0.009292134083807468, -0.024687767028808594, -0.01079405564814806, 0.03272039815783501, 0.058071237057447433, -0.009322690777480602, -0.010179230943322182, 0.025269124656915665, -0.03450716286897659, 0.006132362876087427, -0.05399026349186897, -0.05283159762620926, -0.029271434992551804, 0.03826470300555229, 0.03883076086640358, -0.02577568031847477, -0.02225429378449917, -0.07166139036417007, -0.04021080583333969, 0.03136120364069939, -0.008622322231531143, 0.04818936437368393, -0.010464871302247047, -0.04027586430311203, -0.02995298244059086, -0.06481797248125076, 0.004552051890641451, 0.039474669843912125, -0.015276012010872364, -0.03178418427705765, 0.009286468848586082, -0.004177082795649767, -0.049920596182346344, -0.01940559409558773, -0.04256407544016838, -0.015670131891965866, 0.00148978631477803, -0.03292810544371605, 0.0523788183927536, 0.04244312271475792, -0.04739251732826233, 0.0122059416025877, -0.0313321128487587, 0.022867847234010696, 0.011598668061196804, -0.01559093315154314, 0.007054679561406374, 0.00709520885720849, 0.02581675350666046, 0.038113102316856384, 0.006941990461200476, 0.008281229063868523, -0.046481236815452576, -0.026479624211788177, -0.00103463395498693, -0.036023031920194626, 0.040990058332681656, 0.0012644510716199875, 0.022167235612869263, 0.07445467263460159, 0.0453667975962162, -0.022801682353019714, -0.06023804098367691, 0.0036576094571501017, -0.027431635186076164, -0.006353842094540596, 0.05142226070165634, 0.004968514200299978, 0.036932311952114105, 0.05464009940624237, -0.011167929507791996, 0.01676197163760662, 0.030220825225114822, -0.006519223563373089, -0.01434109266847372, 0.042117394506931305, 0.012827237136662006, -0.00789791438728571, 0.008075716905295849, 0.030615322291851044, 0.0034526330418884754, -0.0006164311780594289, 0.005922145675867796, -0.004053076263517141, -0.03326951339840889, -0.0501626618206501, 0.0071022543124854565, 0.016430648043751717, 0.028632981702685356, -0.04739704728126526, -0.005404927767813206, 0.007757856510579586, -0.05626692995429039, -0.004684722516685724, 0.008240509778261185, 0.045904967933893204, -0.02952667511999607, 0.024843038991093636, 0.009518256410956383, 0.03715932369232178, -0.006143265403807163, -0.02026730217039585, -0.016532158479094505, -0.01583501324057579, 0.011752128601074219, -0.00784184131771326, -0.03602306544780731, 0.011786466464400291, 0.04054156690835953, 0.026207761839032173, -0.04097142070531845, -0.04530801996588707, 0.03565535694360733, -0.019214654341340065, 0.022135386243462563, -0.03398962691426277, 0.031419359147548676, 0.022008873522281647, 0.048512086272239685, -0.016407258808612823, 0.007345797959715128, -0.009034788236021996, 0.0003977517772000283, -0.058753401041030884, -0.0192518662661314, -0.005107176024466753, -0.006567818578332663, -0.002749269362539053, -0.00902185495942831, 0.023992087692022324, 0.002331024268642068, 0.0086950259283185, 0.019723735749721527, 0.03854196146130562, -0.019849460572004318, 0.026236500591039658, -0.009116911329329014, -0.02705143764615059, -0.007123313844203949, -0.009199177846312523, -0.02094721794128418, -0.018274806439876556, 0.020549703389406204, -0.013531814329326153, -0.0017364008817821741, 0.0023727454245090485, -0.022675197571516037, 0.026937564834952354, -0.016938798129558563, 0.05547965317964554, -0.011742336675524712, -0.01771138608455658, -0.03103938326239586, 0.010203725658357143, -0.002133978297933936, 0.027762310579419136, 0.053747136145830154, -0.028978804126381874, 0.010460027493536472, -0.030443774536252022, -0.01679517887532711, -0.021334176883101463, 0.014507562853395939, -0.009567970409989357, -0.021361928433179855, 0.04579426720738411, 0.005416307598352432, -0.016721006482839584, -0.026161642745137215, 0.05176656320691109, 0.01626904308795929, -0.019708214327692986, -0.032623544335365295, -0.030215006321668625, -0.013598098419606686, -0.015418699942529202, 0.021221168339252472, -0.027806036174297333, -0.02142147347331047, -0.011141029186546803, 0.034878768026828766, -0.05816279724240303, -0.040963269770145416, -0.01463946234434843, 0.017020802944898605, 0.04003208503127098, -0.018592996522784233, -0.028053535148501396, -0.024318570271134377, 0.023893211036920547, 0.039715010672807693, 0.031529754400253296, 0.016217323020100594, -0.06355980783700943, -0.051609139889478683, 0.06064595282077789, 0.025098152458667755, -0.0542198047041893, -0.038290854543447495, -0.05219700559973717, -0.027746066451072693, 0.021000457927584648, -0.02645668014883995, 0.033947087824344635, -0.016657279804348946, 0.023015569895505905, -0.0397602841258049, -0.022907232865691185, -0.06078997254371643, -0.011077472940087318, -0.02115977369248867, 0.04655047133564949, -0.045323535799980164, -0.034869566559791565, -0.01570933312177658, 0.02700497955083847, -0.02755221724510193, 0.055089619010686874, -0.0421503484249115, -0.05332605168223381, 0.015290138311684132, -0.006044984329491854, 0.018791310489177704, -0.06346877664327621, 0.01669424958527088, -0.009180332534015179, 0.0065509844571352005, 0.02227872796356678, 0.018409257754683495, -0.04631249979138374, 0.01587037369608879, 0.03855839744210243, -0.010542582720518112, 0.012175037525594234, 0.0015752799808979034, 0.03137394040822983, 0.00991837028414011, -0.006681446451693773, 0.06172769144177437, 0.035322971642017365, -0.033016812056303024, 0.03492698818445206, -0.054903432726860046, 0.005872408393770456, -0.0210963636636734, -0.04531938582658768, -0.028243983164429665, -0.043623507022857666, -0.01565559022128582, 0.02596469596028328, -0.013245108537375927, 0.05072370544075966, -0.01298878900706768, -0.03343396261334419, 0.03437340632081032, 0.031660210341215134, 0.0075127664022147655, 0.006765181198716164, 0.028121385723352432, 0.05266980826854706, 0.017508815973997116, 0.037704773247241974, 0.004529264289885759, 0.01706884801387787, 0.016540508717298508, 0.013307163491845131, -0.039897169917821884, 0.00017863833636511117, -0.008423163555562496, 0.022241849452257156, 0.025737470015883446, -0.0257696732878685, 0.03668212890625, 0.046654194593429565, 0.03532317280769348, -0.020007822662591934, -0.06329707056283951, 0.00896048080176115, -0.0021945619955658913, -0.02646399289369583, 0.03373320773243904, -0.020711300894618034, 0.008251968771219254, -0.0171037670224905, -0.01766946353018284, -0.07159628719091415, -0.0054930588230490685, -0.027738599106669426, -0.02707945741713047, -0.022755149751901627, -0.0292064119130373, 0.024013305082917213, 0.011566057801246643, 0.0295729823410511, 0.0383402444422245, 0.03443877026438713, -0.01234596036374569, 0.026417497545480728, -0.019383246079087257, 0.0016262541757896543, 0.07587365806102753, 0.00542820431292057, 0.02076171152293682, -0.015150733292102814, -0.006532102823257446, -0.010515216737985611, 0.045030076056718826, 0.0028026371728628874, -0.02004505880177021, -0.015573468059301376, 0.003503563581034541, 0.03441552072763443, 0.006645113695412874, 0.0012867333134636283, -0.024809040129184723, -0.01713944599032402, -0.02346961200237274, 0.03212036192417145, -0.026070846244692802, -0.0025714230723679066, -0.0026002111844718456, 0.0008234978886321187, 0.0020165254827588797, -0.0248370673507452, 0.03006964549422264, -0.027666475623846054, 0.024368396028876305, -0.001836661365814507, 0.016922103241086006, 0.02616148814558983, 0.10464518517255783, -0.013180471025407314, -0.0035748162772506475, -0.008441592566668987, -0.03986344113945961, 0.03844736889004707, 0.03916948288679123, -0.011434420943260193, 0.023302726447582245, 0.02623932622373104, -0.03232812136411667, -0.03312528878450394, -0.06641391664743423, 0.011533333919942379, 0.04745439067482948, 0.020620528608560562, 0.04041215032339096, 0.011678224429488182, -0.0235423780977726, 0.03065035678446293, -0.060927048325538635, 0.008870638906955719, -0.022710595279932022, 0.02917439118027687, 0.03371960669755936, -0.0034358103293925524, -0.021527571603655815, 0.04398811236023903, 0.015829365700483322, 0.015708845108747482, 0.019950222223997116, -0.019663536921143532, 0.026339445263147354, 0.018658224493265152, -0.04490075260400772, -0.04530010744929314, 0.030655285343527794, -0.04926734417676926, 0.013690542429685593, -0.00676891440525651, -0.04278776794672012, 0.03973843902349472, 0.04124715179204941, 0.016771120950579643, -0.031382057815790176, -0.023087814450263977, -0.04413925111293793, -0.000935613177716732, 0.002661467529833317, -0.03738740459084511, 0.037139616906642914, 0.015582995489239693, 0.002891264157369733, 0.004361042287200689, 0.0046428171917796135, -0.04342912510037422, -0.08632946014404297, -0.02705109864473343, 0.011841556057333946, -0.047908008098602295, 0.06977515667676926, 0.014863698743283749, -0.05138440430164337, 0.03018149361014366, -0.013710366562008858, 0.02518220618367195, 0.014684636145830154, 0.04936348646879196, 0.031261030584573746, 0.05163166671991348, -0.02283417247235775, 0.00924313347786665, -0.03281712904572487, -0.014103593304753304, 0.16561159491539001, 0.09528284519910812, 0.0433119498193264, -0.04558759927749634, -0.007614230737090111, -0.0014527859166264534, 0.006119217723608017, -0.004114808049052954, -0.023226752877235413, 0.035466596484184265, -0.03970780596137047, 0.04766739159822464, 0.04303611069917679, 0.028599465265870094, -0.0048404172994196415, 0.028265565633773804, -0.056655965745449066, 0.021118659526109695, -0.010953273624181747, -0.004804521333426237, -0.0030677139293402433, -0.0031031956896185875, -0.02380106970667839, 0.006451002322137356, -0.016766073182225227, -0.0009432032820768654, -0.02441721223294735, -0.021514566615223885, 0.01267233956605196, -0.0157509446144104, 0.021635359153151512, -0.010523777455091476, 0.006908270996063948, -0.0077109611593186855, 0.03402307629585266, 0.017492910847067833, 0.0017582534346729517, -0.029015859588980675, 0.04008718207478523, 0.016224108636379242, -0.016747137531638145, 0.023235250264406204, 0.012337845750153065, 0.0024605270009487867, -0.0242251418530941, -0.05397658422589302, -0.02848580852150917, 0.05011991038918495, -0.02721031755208969, 0.004773412831127644, -0.012937740422785282, -0.007820314727723598, 0.04639173671603203, -0.026054540649056435, -0.001254865201190114, 0.005528319627046585, 0.01545509323477745, -0.004018367733806372, -0.010474895127117634, -0.01667456328868866, 0.03469092398881912, 0.02134236879646778, 0.045531321316957474, 0.04111094027757645, -0.029956897720694542, -0.054872240871191025, -0.01092926599085331, 0.05835499241948128, 0.025100406259298325, 0.01309633906930685, 0.037253573536872864, 0.0036273831501603127, -0.005648878403007984, -0.022514618933200836, 0.007597260642796755, 0.008976888842880726, 0.036563847213983536, -0.019172366708517075, -0.03092566505074501, -0.008606400340795517, -0.050772882997989655, -0.02662648819386959, -0.0448983870446682, 0.03433533012866974, -0.03763313964009285, 0.004710034001618624, 0.009262403473258018, 0.020991181954741478, 0.031803008168935776, 0.0017474263440817595, -0.009908374398946762, 0.04101395234465599, 0.01002553105354309, -0.04869163781404495, -0.018155580386519432, 0.018121622502803802, -0.019570549950003624, -0.0376543253660202, -0.008845502510666847, 0.08237846195697784, -0.0022432534024119377, 0.015724394470453262, -0.012365235947072506, 0.05540664121508598, 0.022289082407951355, -0.005498142912983894, 0.0357668437063694, -0.04138004034757614, 0.003592540044337511, -0.009134313091635704, -0.016206717118620872, -0.0280552189797163, -0.03131804242730141, -0.05247143283486366, -0.07492324709892273, 0.023727739229798317, -0.04707696661353111, -0.04878305643796921, 0.01575339026749134, 0.006159525364637375, 0.052658166736364365, -0.04517343267798424, -0.031117180362343788, -0.006203336641192436, -0.0246849674731493, -0.017755582928657532, -0.0325581394135952, -0.0024183408822864294, -0.005771660711616278, -0.027266161516308784, -0.018262218683958054, 0.023046886548399925, -0.007837158627808094, 0.035407740622758865, -0.036415670067071915, 0.039436038583517075, 0.006405888590961695, 0.034877147525548935, -0.011962451972067356, -0.011588163673877716, 0.030713269487023354, -0.026281872764229774, -0.05080614238977432, -0.00271619763225317, -0.028118593618273735, 0.02891780249774456, 0.011937666684389114, -0.01889106072485447, -0.0443209633231163, 0.04299221560359001, -0.006756676826626062, -0.005000196862965822, -0.018826119601726532, -0.016514666378498077, 0.015998078510165215, 0.012860521674156189, -0.011340994387865067, -0.014384523965418339, 0.017448635771870613, 0.008948947302997112, 0.03433588147163391, -0.008197527378797531, -0.03136998787522316, 0.022120380774140358, -0.030056452378630638, -0.005509810522198677, -0.006639780011028051, -0.015265713445842266, 0.04143811762332916, 0.02966499887406826, -0.01379375346004963, 0.01574372686445713, -0.0019197865622118115, 0.029742971062660217, -0.10397498309612274, -0.014115987345576286, -0.00734329828992486, 0.04575720429420471, 0.010681607760488987, -0.03654928132891655, 0.004636544268578291, 0.009812459349632263, -0.01387407723814249, 0.0549735426902771, 0.02247251197695732, 0.00451639061793685, -0.06796573102474213, 0.033114269375801086, -0.013102506287395954, -0.002243420807644725, 0.0426180362701416, -0.010967159643769264, 0.02674802765250206, 0.04690905287861824, -0.0032495318446308374, -0.005681905895471573, -0.04531089588999748, 0.017591996118426323, 0.006537551060318947, -0.030158791691064835, 0.027476252987980843, 0.002263637026771903, -0.018106887117028236, 0.002422094577923417, 0.01724419929087162, 0.030382463708519936, 0.02123374119400978, 0.0251024030148983, 0.027548985555768013, 0.029335830360651016, 0.005714410915970802, 0.026370469480752945, 0.012705142609775066, 0.01634916476905346, 0.021335327997803688, -0.0045927478931844234, -0.013202747330069542, 0.04431528598070145, -0.012016228400170803, 0.01630374975502491, -0.020399393513798714, 0.0035433678422123194, 0.01864135079085827, -0.014883146621286869, -0.013282090425491333, 0.0006917222635820508, -0.026504410430788994, -0.02341635897755623, 0.01857863925397396, -0.02571764588356018, -0.009191764518618584, 0.04189684987068176, 0.035817377269268036, -0.02144271694123745, 0.008434636518359184, -0.009363105520606041, -0.024357439950108528, 0.007920333184301853, -0.020876694470643997, -0.01727837137877941, -0.050215475261211395, -0.027927139773964882, -0.018159443512558937, -0.029097914695739746, -0.022274969145655632, -0.023194925859570503, -0.009337736293673515, 0.05732228606939316, -0.02017291449010372, 0.03048045001924038, 0.009455814957618713, -0.02158035710453987, 0.01784784346818924, -0.0839545950293541, 0.07611113041639328, -0.029607433825731277, -0.030451150611042976, -0.014792079105973244, -0.010311346501111984, 0.0034623825922608376, 0.03622639179229736, 0.0030764425173401833, 0.021662265062332153, 0.01646788790822029, -0.03739103302359581, 0.030999628826975822, 0.0362945981323719, -0.046220436692237854, 0.036458585411310196, -0.00034495670115575194, 0.0030253916047513485, -0.02387554943561554, -0.005508854053914547, 0.01139018777757883, 0.0463436096906662, 0.045756641775369644, -0.009186871349811554, -0.012042952701449394, 0.007442697416990995, -0.022150835022330284, 0.024749523028731346, -0.003248658962547779, 0.000712363631464541, 0.057367488741874695, -0.013393625617027283, -0.008512296713888645, 0.022006789222359657, 0.00996317621320486, -0.0448002815246582, 0.015264545567333698, -0.03732377290725708, -0.0017267568036913872, 0.014339391142129898, 0.026445286348462105, -0.03849942609667778, -0.06296338140964508, -0.005873905029147863, 0.009201306849718094, -0.05102347955107689, 0.000005119953584653558, 0.013564000837504864, 0.019195647910237312, 0.04444317892193794, -0.013273259624838829, 0.050397370010614395, 0.011054917238652706, -0.015786420553922653, 0.016013169661164284, -0.0057099126279354095, 0.016073182225227356, -0.01502075046300888, 0.047519613057374954, 0.01043927576392889, -0.03545341640710831, 0.05099109932780266, 0.010002889670431614, 0.08811955153942108, -0.03449998050928116, -0.018587959930300713, -0.011057096533477306, 0.007095700595527887, -0.01220686174929142, -0.02787712961435318, -0.027258893474936485, 0.06455474346876144, -0.026625946164131165, -0.021238528192043304, -0.01948651112616062, 0.01229833997786045, 0.011416715569794178, 0.02955910749733448, 0.005097240675240755, 0.06768231838941574, 0.018272334709763527, 0.05122017115354538, 0.006279244553297758, -0.019834086298942566, 0.022328807041049004, -0.022366633638739586, 0.02070295624434948, 0.0064850603230297565, 0.004898132756352425, 0.038899343460798264, -0.014872717671096325, 0.005586693529039621, -0.04694778472185135, 0.027394039556384087, 0.05493774637579918, -0.009711509570479393, -0.04830783233046532, -0.06385670602321625, -0.0015306483255699277, 0.0009159408509731293, -0.030687367543578148, -0.012456730008125305, -0.011115827597677708, -0.016909021884202957, 0.026047570630908012, -0.03831002488732338 ]
<p>In many econometrics model, the changes in the response variables in certain intervals are more difficult than other intervals. But I believe this is often not considered when estimating the model. </p> <p>For example, suppose $Y_{st}$ represents the proportion of students in a certain school $s$, passing a standardized test in year $t$. Let $R_{st}$ be the academic resources students (ex. books in library), and $I_{st}$ represent average parental income of the students. In this case $Y_{st} \in [0,1],$ and we would like to estimate effect of $R_{st}$ on $Y_{st}.$</p> <p>We could model this is as follows, </p> <p>$Y_{st} = \alpha_{0} +\alpha_{1}R_{st} + \alpha_{2}I_{st} + \delta_{t}+ u_{st}$, where $u_{st}$ is additive error term, and $\delta_{t}$ are time dummies. In this context of pass rates, intuitively it is more difficult for a school to increase the pass rates from 95% to 100%, then it is for them to go from 45% student passing, to 50% student passing. Consequently, the effect of $R_{st}$ on $Y_{st}$ should be given less weight on the latter situation (45% to 50%), than the former (95% to 100%). Suppose we were comparing two schools in which the same $R_{st}$ increase lead to these results, clearly the 95% to 100% school invested more efficiently. </p> <p>My idea is to use a multiplicative dummy variable with $R_{st}$, $\beta_{t}$, where $\beta_{t}$ takes on different values depending on the initial value of $Y_{st}.$ Is there a standard way to take this into consideration in the model? Are there other additional factors that could improve this model?</p>
74,338
[ -0.010083341039717197, -0.015197210013866425, -0.0075182607397437096, -0.019472584128379822, 0.04422518238425255, 0.042202673852443695, 0.014990679919719696, -0.036562252789735794, 0.04076514393091202, -0.0034105712547898293, 0.03458060696721077, 0.018683386966586113, 0.05773548036813736, -0.007553657982498407, 0.016604037955403328, 0.009899739176034927, -0.015527659095823765, -0.019086869433522224, -0.03310082480311394, 0.025828450918197632, 0.01383430790156126, 0.04912075772881508, -0.004427785985171795, -0.004559430759400129, -0.012276209890842438, 0.00957988016307354, 0.015830939635634422, 0.009189960546791553, -0.05344977602362633, 0.03480250760912895, -0.007547545712441206, 0.004551774822175503, 0.02475718967616558, 0.009122706018388271, 0.014555671252310276, -0.005242572166025639, -0.04353572800755501, -0.050952356308698654, -0.020070631057024002, -0.011030794121325016, -0.06824842840433121, -0.005447771865874529, 0.0045724776573479176, 0.023576924577355385, 0.02166176214814186, 0.02115379460155964, 0.009352256543934345, -0.025892091915011406, 0.022211013361811638, -0.004576144739985466, 0.062363024801015854, 0.04156731441617012, 0.042984943836927414, 0.014898901805281639, -0.014714199118316174, -0.019773805513978004, 0.02486233413219452, 0.07197059690952301, -0.035158220678567886, 0.006082029547542334, -0.02065976895391941, -0.015555336140096188, 0.009658492170274258, -0.0051433974876999855, -0.02209194004535675, 0.011440317146480083, -0.01838090643286705, -0.016572631895542145, 0.04229007661342621, -0.0242360420525074, -0.0031475366558879614, 0.0012139766477048397, 0.06184745579957962, 0.045985180884599686, 0.011197831481695175, -0.062252920120954514, 0.006830680649727583, 0.026738334447145462, 0.05282771959900856, 0.04144702106714249, -0.02757255546748638, -0.02561204321682453, 0.008348333649337292, 0.053194500505924225, 0.02248532325029373, -0.0011118295369669795, 0.04667309299111366, -0.03278298303484917, 0.039827633649110794, 0.02776377834379673, -0.03214474394917488, -0.004986913874745369, 0.0360398106276989, -0.0056915078312158585, -0.03352650627493858, 0.036496106535196304, 0.008731276728212833, 0.016704291105270386, 0.019770827144384384, -0.0020867756102234125, -0.007010387256741524, -0.05048833787441254, 0.006721280049532652, 0.05020361393690109, 0.005641983821988106, -0.028967687860131264, -0.034736163914203644, -0.03613140061497688, -0.02435324899852276, -0.056539036333560944, -0.032721519470214844, 0.03638789430260658, 0.0020401987712830305, 0.01714455336332321, 0.04332909360527992, -0.012540054507553577, -0.016150156036019325, -0.002108294051140547, 0.06236322969198227, 0.0479879193007946, 0.0322011299431324, -0.01794077455997467, 0.03947257250547409, -0.010690007358789444, -0.02053053490817547, 0.02730107679963112, 0.013976670801639557, -0.04871419444680214, -0.059166453778743744, 0.029161037877202034, -0.011899885721504688, -0.014041474089026451, 0.02738955430686474, -0.02949112094938755, 0.06187985837459564, 0.008278618566691875, -0.07800541818141937, -0.07262153178453445, 0.012844076380133629, 0.016427967697381973, 0.00023493566550314426, -0.0491495355963707, -0.01119714230298996, -0.007743142079561949, 0.03411222994327545, 0.025017229840159416, 0.030628591775894165, 0.030769500881433487, 0.03869450464844704, 0.04077234864234924, -0.05119042471051216, 0.00280683021992445, 0.010187855921685696, -0.030737033113837242, 0.0062806252390146255, -0.07347992062568665, 0.019691282883286476, 0.039366092532873154, -0.022471178323030472, -0.032905783504247665, 0.024515751749277115, 0.018234658986330032, -0.05534745007753372, 0.013571269810199738, 0.007885636761784554, -0.020882830023765564, 0.04759630188345909, 0.01307619083672762, 0.04138552024960518, 0.019437795504927635, 0.01950383000075817, 0.019142378121614456, 0.006247290875762701, 0.012324891053140163, 0.017078297212719917, -0.030154669657349586, -0.01392184104770422, -0.00932252500206232, -0.027352027595043182, 0.020079929381608963, -0.03570568934082985, -0.02049543522298336, -0.031148049980401993, 0.00872111413627863, 0.008771508000791073, 0.03625733405351639, 0.01135214138776064, -0.019984809681773186, 0.003908528946340084, -0.009036150760948658, -0.03759312629699707, -0.10011648386716843, 0.03546098619699478, -0.006181534845381975, -0.017407463863492012, 0.06216222420334816, -0.056160490959882736, 0.01790521666407585, 0.016942430287599564, 0.006332840770483017, -0.03346765786409378, -0.008576503954827785, 0.053039778023958206, -0.05836436152458191, 0.01597680151462555, 0.03189050778746605, 0.03471269831061363, -0.0058104791678488255, 0.029836807399988174, -0.0552949458360672, -0.0330658033490181, 0.005854643881320953, -0.04423543065786362, 0.041240669786930084, -0.02479313127696514, 0.0002496617380529642, 0.007201299071311951, -0.06304800510406494, -0.009091089479625225, 0.04359597712755203, -0.09305712580680847, 0.03469258174300194, 0.09689034521579742, -0.0021745688281953335, 0.003792832139879465, 0.03580821305513382, 0.010180050507187843, 0.05092109367251396, -0.014267917722463608, -0.03229302540421486, -0.022575924172997475, 0.01617944799363613, 0.006645415909588337, -0.032094962894916534, -0.038649894297122955, 0.028163500130176544, 0.038298655301332474, -0.004032085184007883, -0.005373033229261637, 0.05978082865476608, 0.012532957829535007, -0.012369310483336449, -0.0033377064391970634, 0.007213066332042217, -0.000976512033957988, 0.020976312458515167, 0.007927171885967255, -0.0006524741183966398, 0.016327446326613426, -0.013592930510640144, 0.04470251500606537, 0.015867002308368683, 0.03385854512453079, 0.025168852880597115, -0.013162331655621529, -0.0016038576140999794, 0.03154498711228371, -0.037920109927654266, 0.013111616484820843, 0.056370995938777924, 0.00642024539411068, 0.007624691817909479, 0.027545390650629997, -0.01526253018528223, 0.02831907384097576, 0.0065338644199073315, -0.010941325686872005, 0.01526286918669939, 0.021379200741648674, -0.032622214406728745, 0.003961638081818819, -0.0005531570641323924, -0.007274166215211153, -0.02653939090669155, -0.00765890022739768, 0.04410307854413986, 0.01759122498333454, 0.00778732355684042, -0.043773066252470016, -0.01006564125418663, 0.023161327466368675, 0.026753466576337814, 0.004070512019097805, -0.0011847318382933736, -0.0338875986635685, 0.02596224471926689, -0.03090319037437439, -0.03106829896569252, 0.01713643968105316, -0.028207480907440186, -0.008059634827077389, 0.01639578491449356, 0.0014048151206225157, -0.01850009150803089, -0.0197382103651762, -0.024610674008727074, -0.015131751075387001, -0.013451323844492435, -0.02199416235089302, 0.043795619159936905, 0.01914675161242485, -0.014846757054328918, 0.011998203583061695, -0.045888759195804596, 0.002015219535678625, -0.024544455111026764, -0.0142738102003932, -0.005326413549482822, -0.008312615565955639, 0.004412708338350058, 0.01353148277848959, 0.006217007525265217, -0.0076826587319374084, -0.0737420991063118, -0.04578600078821182, -0.0011811485746875405, -0.0002186949277529493, 0.052171990275382996, 0.03760521486401558, -0.03171662986278534, 0.08081328123807907, 0.05038844421505928, 0.006260088179260492, -0.02732732519507408, 0.004023841116577387, -0.00024157381267286837, -0.009231949225068092, -0.01734411157667637, 0.04018515720963478, -0.04819708690047264, 0.02088739722967148, -0.0004047804104629904, 0.0018602932104840875, 0.04728938266634941, 0.030685219913721085, 0.017647569999098778, -0.015432261861860752, -0.0061547597870230675, 0.00025400289450772107, 0.01985914446413517, 0.007997136563062668, -0.017580417916178703, 0.003219954203814268, -0.010946906171739101, 0.04433533921837807, 0.03260393068194389, -0.052658144384622574, 0.009641882963478565, -0.03266896307468414, -0.03862375766038895, -0.022389806807041168, 0.019186684861779213, 0.024277810007333755, -0.03534958139061928, -0.002414854709059, 0.010923339985311031, -0.004982145503163338, -0.0030269233975559473, 0.01396695151925087, 0.012987293303012848, 0.026021184399724007, 0.005731484852731228, -0.004918953869491816, -0.04476502910256386, 0.004518810193985701, 0.044810447841882706, -0.04646827653050423, 0.0158719290047884, 0.03379648178815842, 0.044728558510541916, -0.0012818509712815285, -0.020319493487477303, -0.047564949840307236, -0.0002908608003053814, -0.08674944192171097, -0.024635864421725273, -0.02580982819199562, 0.061927877366542816, 0.02616906724870205, 0.005329775623977184, 0.0056851208209991455, -0.017442014068365097, -0.007175898179411888, -0.03521636128425598, -0.08255602419376373, -0.0016647479496896267, -0.006763878278434277, -0.03850988671183586, 0.03190700709819794, 0.010734153911471367, 0.03004216030240059, -0.02851439267396927, -0.0029369473922997713, -0.019826535135507584, 0.007832447066903114, -0.013435132801532745, 0.03874501213431358, -0.007315657567232847, -0.030981771647930145, -0.014631310477852821, 0.016189273446798325, 0.018556971102952957, -0.032061878591775894, 0.02262105606496334, 0.0037894397974014282, -0.0076970732770860195, 0.01330115832388401, -0.06824641674757004, 0.009086653590202332, 0.025645995512604713, 0.061183493584394455, 0.06730781495571136, 0.02627766691148281, -0.0552140474319458, 0.05074385553598404, 0.011573282070457935, 0.02135295607149601, 0.038226716220378876, -0.04198296368122101, -0.03195400536060333, -0.06349419057369232, -0.025321032851934433, 0.009953225962817669, 0.01598665677011013, 0.020092539489269257, -0.005536709446460009, 0.08506990969181061, 0.04035361483693123, -0.03201761469244957, 0.011437037028372288, 0.028245482593774796, 0.009169119410216808, 0.0048315878957509995, -0.0037660994566977024, 0.007806987036019564, -0.03524060174822807, -0.008768950589001179, 0.011338584125041962, -0.0007859351462684572, 0.01217319443821907, 0.010635108686983585, 0.05135186389088631, -0.0061749424785375595, -0.024360742419958115, 0.03162221238017082, 0.027409447357058525, 0.03772420063614845, 0.024219613522291183, -0.053031012415885925, 0.04307105392217636, 0.05576346814632416, 0.051304738968610764, -0.003872104687616229, 0.008503223769366741, -0.05224079638719559, -0.02654687501490116, 0.005980020388960838, 0.0072872331365942955, -0.0540446862578392, -0.02655814401805401, -0.008064906112849712, 0.014942800626158714, -0.00203874078579247, -0.004519802052527666, 0.0262360330671072, 0.008381795138120651, -0.027537770569324493, -0.04032300412654877, -0.07673168927431107, -0.04718656837940216, 0.04690099135041237, -0.012156030163168907, 0.02962948940694332, -0.0005152966477908194, -0.01870398223400116, -0.01972297579050064, -0.01899980753660202, 0.026684829965233803, 0.04403498396277428, -0.029013950377702713, -0.029737083241343498, 0.010760586708784103, 0.009568193927407265, -0.03384384512901306, -0.07060148566961288, 0.014568137004971504, -0.008578182198107243, -0.004005324095487595, 0.0113671338185668, 0.01038512121886015, -0.03100050985813141, 0.0518842376768589, 0.040933169424533844, -0.01127900555729866, 0.0013085927348583937, -0.020525963976979256, 0.03537151589989662, 0.05452340468764305, 0.015429149381816387, 0.06402619928121567, 0.019508011639118195, 0.013690367341041565, -0.0039074313826859, -0.0003342425625305623, 0.0020461149979382753, -0.05257062613964081, -0.0017962565179914236, -0.04323835298418999, -0.010892882011830807, 0.022521842271089554, 0.060543179512023926, -0.0037632700987160206, 0.0446322038769722, -0.042027559131383896, 0.0022259897086769342, 0.011011578142642975, 0.0356961153447628, -0.008292886428534985, -0.0034478940069675446, -0.014885700307786465, 0.02787128835916519, -0.004986853804439306, 0.007802190259099007, -0.00014091632328927517, -0.023039039224386215, 0.011462133377790451, 0.023057712242007256, 0.014622531831264496, 0.03301301971077919, -0.03169906511902809, -0.039049647748470306, -0.006006532348692417, 0.009617467410862446, 0.026036817580461502, -0.035666659474372864, 0.0032883824314922094, -0.019886158406734467, -0.009145401418209076, -0.007146614138036966, 0.021036984398961067, 0.003413306549191475, -0.018046608194708824, -0.00448279595002532, -0.00040234773769043386, 0.0022553957533091307, -0.003690945217385888, -0.08418412506580353, -0.0531306192278862, 0.03058386780321598, -0.01730162277817726, -0.011022688820958138, 0.005548205692321062, 0.01935989037156105, -0.03161861002445221, -0.030373794957995415, -0.014717230573296547, 0.06016485393047333, -0.02095545269548893, -0.007033746223896742, -0.02703331783413887, 0.030535537749528885, 0.05036298930644989, -0.007557451259344816, -0.013623208738863468, 0.00980349350720644, -0.019631674513220787, -0.010333036072552204, 0.019114354625344276, 0.015706369653344154, -0.033032845705747604, -0.0068371971137821674, -0.014232859015464783, -0.03859768435359001, 0.0444694347679615, -0.02480425126850605, -0.02444283850491047, 0.058838751167058945, -0.02454404905438423, 0.01479304488748312, 0.0037872300017625093, -0.0019773642998188734, -0.009411284700036049, 0.0058347322046756744, -0.007557610981166363, 0.003416209015995264, -0.012208794243633747, -0.011022724211215973, 0.06092323735356331, 0.02802583947777748, -0.007563782390207052, -0.0060591683723032475, 0.08605431765317917, -0.04174373298883438, 0.01048081461340189, 0.023250458762049675, -0.02749691531062126, 0.06521527469158173, 0.042616721242666245, -0.0024385645519942045, 0.007575239520519972, -0.01395240519195795, -0.026882288977503777, -0.027218004688620567, -0.04623175784945488, 0.003396029816940427, 0.048817675560712814, -0.024007180705666542, 0.04394106939435005, 0.024726975709199905, -0.013770713470876217, -0.02086605504155159, -0.042476836591959, 0.0071333940140903, -0.032068025320768356, -0.00863819569349289, 0.033268749713897705, 0.00968915969133377, -0.0410582534968853, 0.04462410509586334, 0.030093522742390633, 0.015773456543684006, 0.03393800929188728, 0.011622375808656216, -0.0038097866345196962, 0.04835837334394455, -0.048934683203697205, -0.017326632514595985, 0.028698721900582314, -0.016817227005958557, -0.027424084022641182, -0.03300659358501434, -0.057217661291360855, 0.06101369112730026, 0.03195912763476372, 0.02290523424744606, -0.05766310542821884, -0.007926230318844318, -0.06966932862997055, 0.009393971413373947, 0.012164157815277576, -0.021134095266461372, 0.038868337869644165, 0.025565974414348602, 0.038846228271722794, 0.007881452329456806, 0.081055648624897, -0.014687968418002129, -0.0647159144282341, -0.04756294935941696, -0.019404059275984764, -0.014003243297338486, 0.003418324049562216, -0.022123640403151512, -0.012788803316652775, 0.025839218869805336, -0.027734847739338875, -0.009846911765635014, 0.007173322606831789, 0.006565036717802286, -0.02648938074707985, 0.10753697156906128, 0.018410170450806618, -0.0088739525526762, 0.013618270866572857, 0.011069511994719505, 0.11478690057992935, 0.07241841405630112, 0.04117883741855621, -0.04548729956150055, 0.007007245905697346, 0.0029810448177158833, 0.0009474374237470329, -0.014116217382252216, -0.0027472020592540503, 0.030208487063646317, -0.05304206535220146, 0.04342221841216087, 0.04208218306303024, -0.0001278692070627585, 0.0015348490560427308, 0.045073267072439194, -0.06053886190056801, 0.006893300451338291, 0.02401559054851532, 0.011375525034964085, 0.01703801564872265, -0.0014156283577904105, -0.00252797594293952, 0.021376075223088264, 0.022274788469076157, -0.0018145960057154298, 0.0440220981836319, -0.04629920795559883, -0.007015848532319069, -0.013752480037510395, -0.04163166508078575, 0.03844302147626877, -0.006961942184716463, 0.02937784604728222, -0.018635494634509087, 0.027684932574629784, 0.013438679277896881, -0.009783743880689144, -0.010566368699073792, 0.031202400103211403, -0.008255468681454659, -0.001311308122240007, 0.024590440094470978, 0.06237298622727394, -0.05285169556736946, -0.03230700269341469, -0.03737233579158783, 0.010275927372276783, -0.04279226064682007, -0.023607008159160614, -0.021266447380185127, 0.01760687865316868, 0.006981960963457823, -0.04867478460073471, -0.040723685175180435, 0.04355570673942566, 0.013291595503687859, 0.010736684314906597, 0.008806949481368065, 0.019816068932414055, -0.014545940794050694, 0.0014238241128623486, 0.037091515958309174, 0.0048929136246442795, -0.07213690131902695, -0.013306787237524986, -0.010801464319229126, 0.06151216849684715, -0.013528132811188698, -0.015049285255372524, 0.0302271731197834, 0.014246353879570961, -0.04427217319607735, 0.024778716266155243, 0.017226042225956917, 0.0004436854214873165, 0.01383198518306017, -0.0008759352494962513, -0.010490789078176022, -0.0195523239672184, 0.008332096971571445, -0.016970820724964142, 0.030056094750761986, 0.009558180347084999, -0.08769295364618301, -0.004054402932524681, -0.0142121072858572, 0.030406439676880836, 0.00484092440456152, -0.020308177918195724, -0.009144115261733532, 0.053201284259557724, 0.01337249856442213, -0.06450846791267395, -0.003865474369376898, -0.02738305926322937, -0.04033447429537773, -0.015774620696902275, -0.012160913087427616, 0.04392886161804199, -0.0072805797681212425, 0.0003377670655027032, -0.05482615903019905, 0.04827941954135895, -0.0046028681099414825, 0.05651170760393143, 0.002009647898375988, -0.08593591302633286, -0.0013991417363286018, 0.014076373539865017, 0.023847438395023346, -0.023371506482362747, 0.028903132304549217, -0.02001524344086647, -0.01665857434272766, 0.011984754353761673, -0.04256787523627281, -0.024409515783190727, 0.025736618787050247, -0.03081631474196911, -0.009282149374485016, -0.04549930989742279, 0.01681600697338581, -0.029224708676338196, -0.012858470901846886, -0.019557040184736252, -0.01071564294397831, 0.03313371166586876, -0.0033765961416065693, 0.0043309535831213, 0.003987791948020458, 0.01054021529853344, 0.016190029680728912, 0.010294688865542412, -0.022914161905646324, 0.02363624982535839, 0.024501103907823563, 0.042538147419691086, -0.05380672216415405, -0.02823064476251602, 0.02107192948460579, -0.04585942253470421, -0.021190300583839417, 0.013038821518421173, -0.02260410413146019, 0.04563019797205925, -0.009174209088087082, -0.01458729151636362, -0.045338988304138184, 0.049404703080654144, -0.03171059861779213, -0.03582530841231346, 0.01240636594593525, 0.0018191332928836346, 0.008773818612098694, -0.013057434931397438, -0.021854573860764503, 0.00872673187404871, 0.02252873033285141, 0.025490159168839455, 0.03163722902536392, -0.03268291428685188, 0.020083874464035034, -0.0037454268895089626, -0.0041229440830647945, 0.010568599216639996, -0.009648075327277184, -0.0037813561502844095, 0.036486268043518066, 0.0321703739464283, -0.008459365926682949, 0.05339891090989113, 0.007976463064551353, -0.006884596310555935, -0.05783907324075699, -0.007291246205568314, 0.007080627139657736, 0.024830853566527367, 0.03652840852737427, -0.04147999733686447, 0.03831569477915764, 0.016084684059023857, -0.05451495945453644, 0.04377288743853569, -0.035842981189489365, 0.03782591596245766, -0.04198525473475456, -0.0245587769895792, -0.02729443833231926, -0.004583347123116255, 0.039768412709236145, 0.002453847089782357, -0.00272494088858366, 0.033758021891117096, 0.055066995322704315, -0.03205477446317673, 0.01001698523759842, -0.007211674470454454, -0.010807749815285206, -0.0626634731888771, 0.01272132433950901, -0.01239917054772377, -0.038099732249975204, 0.01205481868237257, 0.01209699921309948, 0.01930978335440159, -0.0022992135491222143, 0.03321002423763275, 0.04492397606372833, 0.03147615119814873, 0.053877197206020355, 0.0007781398599036038, -0.002944295760244131, 0.009394703432917595, -0.001711625955067575, 0.0260857455432415, -0.012891138903796673, 0.0033042619470506907, 0.044211771339178085, -0.009152641519904137, -0.053900737315416336, -0.031233767047524452, 0.009851186536252499, -0.023102892562747, 0.031397297978401184, -0.010039057582616806, 0.027708202600479126, -0.020607830956578255, 0.012910360470414162, -0.048554759472608566, -0.017095837742090225, 0.02172340266406536, 0.0025471714325249195, -0.021620403975248337, 0.009864983148872852, -0.04667679965496063, -0.047510214149951935, -0.005331982858479023, 0.02659325674176216, -0.0003396400425117463, -0.05190934240818024, -0.010492736473679543, 0.010871638543903828, -0.026146164163947105, -0.025945870205760002, 0.006325103808194399, -0.007837907411158085, 0.06866402179002762, -0.022228430956602097, -0.029841288924217224, 0.02512366510927677, 0.023631267249584198, 0.03351074457168579, -0.05620861053466797, 0.07252863794565201, 0.019529948011040688, 0.00008789004641585052, 0.0036577873397618532, 0.005887625273317099, -0.025278298184275627, 0.006128325592726469, 0.07126870006322861, 0.007426920346915722, -0.044609878212213516, 0.029621129855513573, 0.035037361085414886, -0.011868003755807877, 0.0007607531151734293, 0.04381993040442467, -0.028094137087464333, -0.01747455634176731, -0.0173727348446846, -0.0035469909198582172, 0.009198683314025402, 0.021580513566732407, -0.03371327742934227, 0.00919432658702135, 0.011464186012744904, 0.015981240198016167, 0.04024527221918106, 0.025781845673918724, 0.04343581199645996, -0.00951317884027958, 0.04444045573472977, 0.012357881292700768, 0.015210745856165886, 0.004171254578977823, -0.02308865822851658, -0.10254358500242233, 0.0408305749297142, -0.02803957089781761, -0.040046658366918564, -0.01211726013571024, -0.018858687952160835, -0.03822268173098564, -0.05443010479211807, 0.00016095158935058862, 0.02199079841375351, -0.050904281437397, 0.0006430718349292874, 0.04169046878814697, 0.01011123601347208, 0.08312389254570007, -0.010459812358021736, 0.02000526711344719, 0.02071080356836319, -0.03519166260957718, -0.04353082925081253, -0.010006475262343884, 0.048717398196458817, 0.048493608832359314, 0.029963552951812744, 0.014098766259849072, -0.007975264452397823, 0.00030177232110872865, 0.004744522739201784, 0.01438600942492485, 0.002260439330711961, -0.03503045439720154, 0.01585719734430313, -0.009635867550969124, -0.0228933934122324, -0.008486413396894932, 0.009743171744048595, 0.033105235546827316, -0.038560979068279266, 0.01792111247777939, -0.04528547823429108, -0.018430793657898903, -0.03208278864622116, 0.020285382866859436, 0.005187240894883871, 0.024816036224365234, 0.010013003833591938, -0.007817158475518227, -0.02467353083193302, -0.04377247020602226, -0.005777370184659958, 0.011167989112436771, 0.00023118715034797788, -0.008903391659259796, -0.039475955069065094, -0.010143809951841831, -0.03067019209265709, -0.0525420680642128, -0.028707638382911682, 0.03078160621225834, 0.019105255603790283, 0.057588379830121994, -0.026426084339618683, -0.05265195295214653, 0.03365406394004822, 0.08485031872987747, -0.05734490975737572, -0.0035087140277028084, -0.023369522765278816, -0.002179170958697796, -0.0051915948279201984, -0.021452780812978745 ]
<p>I have a list of numbers I need to group by similarity (differences being 1 between each). For example, in a list of [198, 202, 207, 218, 219, 220], 190 would be put into a list, 202 would be put into another list, 207, into a list, and 218 219 220 into another list.</p>
74,339
[ -0.023306896910071373, -0.014945019967854023, -0.02752101607620716, 0.002802663017064333, -0.019462600350379944, -0.032475925981998444, 0.01060636155307293, -0.01292846817523241, 0.020733777433633804, -0.017012469470500946, 0.03918254002928734, 0.02942354790866375, 0.040280576795339584, -0.004855515900999308, 0.011469868011772633, 0.023674376308918, -0.02634963020682335, -0.008811467327177525, 0.03043336607515812, -0.020288515836000443, -0.03832551836967468, 0.010691698640584946, 0.02565172128379345, -0.011491234414279461, -0.03599343076348305, -0.0009584700455889106, 0.03707316890358925, 0.011137687601149082, 0.014900639653205872, 0.03995748981833458, -0.06087391451001167, -0.03875091299414635, 0.04132617637515068, 0.06279747188091278, 0.015155456960201263, -0.00021886933245696127, -0.048329658806324005, -0.009292223490774632, -0.03468039631843567, 0.005937260575592518, -0.03431880101561546, -0.041899412870407104, -0.022041086107492447, 0.02185954712331295, -0.018625758588314056, 0.0422106571495533, -0.010924716480076313, -0.04390624910593033, -0.014178350567817688, -0.04175534471869469, 0.09661123901605606, -0.0009418066474609077, 0.01880139671266079, 0.026922987774014473, 0.0012314998311921954, 0.005624377168715, 0.005998517852276564, 0.07578413933515549, -0.029055310413241386, -0.044821128249168396, -0.04166704788804054, 0.006381148938089609, 0.023024430498480797, -0.02639186382293701, -0.02793797105550766, 0.03000769391655922, -0.030113471671938896, -0.022728586569428444, 0.012745468877255917, -0.027538329362869263, -0.016669772565364838, 0.049748744815588, 0.06477167457342148, -0.04374917969107628, -0.012004484422504902, -0.040008507668972015, 0.011098487302660942, 0.01573449745774269, 0.08344462513923645, 0.04262876138091087, 0.002031100681051612, 0.0072662560269236565, 0.008967439644038677, -0.012471375986933708, 0.025763556361198425, -0.032167647033929825, 0.04827494919300079, -0.039794567972421646, -0.010105515830218792, 0.025059686973690987, -0.03957850858569145, -0.02588248811662197, 0.054667603224515915, 0.03843822330236435, -0.018494002521038055, 0.029413120821118355, 0.01122277695685625, -0.0005445957067422569, -0.008215167559683323, -0.012004789896309376, 0.020131364464759827, -0.004654274322092533, 0.06484463065862656, 0.03799653425812721, -0.04683668538928032, 0.0032397799659520388, -0.06256991624832153, -0.02900242991745472, 0.02436581254005432, 0.03896418586373329, 0.024548808112740517, -0.032686129212379456, -0.002064957283437252, -0.01672585867345333, 0.021435072645545006, 0.0015992507105693221, -0.0098935691639781, 0.00036380806704983115, 0.022308912128210068, 0.07427059859037399, -0.00843244418501854, -0.032293349504470825, 0.07913881540298462, -0.011159841902554035, -0.06417426466941833, 0.006042104214429855, 0.011159081943333149, -0.02921692468225956, -0.020105550065636635, 0.07332973182201385, -0.08375436067581177, -0.008405530825257301, 0.01560945250093937, -0.03873922675848007, 0.05840224027633667, -0.026731420308351517, -0.07622671872377396, -0.012926391325891018, 0.008461372926831245, -0.036330655217170715, 0.0008083626162260771, -0.02874217927455902, 0.045789167284965515, 0.006950472481548786, 0.02777571976184845, 0.046809110790491104, 0.012548534199595451, 0.04017085209488869, 0.0190294049680233, 0.01692105457186699, -0.02261526882648468, -0.006488023325800896, 0.010353823192417622, -0.021028336137533188, -0.01958552561700344, -0.03843361511826515, -0.004413236863911152, 0.02157958596944809, -0.004473729990422726, 0.024577388539910316, -0.011804471723735332, -0.012192211113870144, 0.05167408287525177, -0.013530259020626545, 0.017122073099017143, -0.009967378340661526, 0.05871341750025749, 0.01674601249396801, -0.00875097420066595, 0.0399276502430439, 0.004005103837698698, 0.000015896013792371377, 0.0026226744521409273, 0.01830418035387993, 0.0501784086227417, 0.022595159709453583, -0.021028708666563034, 0.016900263726711273, 0.0018226850079372525, 0.0034439326263964176, 0.0025668165180832148, -0.05827051028609276, 0.019595418125391006, 0.04825570434331894, 0.012246835045516491, 0.03311939164996147, 0.009850122034549713, -0.012492428533732891, 0.02584328129887581, -0.007475435733795166, 0.0015278877690434456, -0.04499904438853264, 0.02279561758041382, 0.022341787815093994, -0.0018573679262772202, 0.01497708447277546, -0.0003227048146072775, 0.021188680082559586, 0.00909399800002575, -0.023295745253562927, -0.0363936573266983, -0.01838066056370735, 0.02085578441619873, -0.027990447357296944, -0.007169490680098534, 0.06974587589502335, 0.041903167963027954, -0.05143769085407257, 0.07621147483587265, -0.01914227195084095, -0.017023595049977303, -0.010102440603077412, -0.023986008018255234, -0.009586567059159279, -0.007055588997900486, 0.029734648764133453, 0.03830892592668533, 0.00841440074145794, -0.019480489194393158, 0.027811674401164055, -0.05077000707387924, 0.07974173128604889, 0.06571126729249954, 0.03901057690382004, -0.02729402855038643, -0.03712828829884529, 0.01335462648421526, 0.029614180326461792, 0.029883110895752907, -0.04870443418622017, -0.049364518374204636, -0.01566566713154316, 0.030829204246401787, 0.0569116584956646, -0.0644526481628418, -0.008952997624874115, 0.050314296036958694, 0.021155985072255135, -0.0012237487826496363, 0.02357393316924572, -0.027643248438835144, 0.02492760308086872, 0.02656738832592964, 0.005066469311714172, 0.03909275680780411, -0.03903159499168396, 0.012055538594722748, 0.04794849827885628, 0.03794243186712265, -0.003962102346122265, 0.005978587549179792, 0.01626371033489704, 0.02540668100118637, 0.022199556231498718, -0.00687358807772398, -0.03454669192433357, 0.022917969152331352, -0.016701314598321915, 0.00405292771756649, 0.017750995233654976, 0.016559651121497154, -0.016701549291610718, 0.01664879359304905, -0.03813768923282623, -0.004033456556499004, 0.06830409169197083, -0.06157597154378891, -0.012362979352474213, 0.021523600444197655, -0.05190521478652954, 0.036630455404520035, 0.00586713245138526, -0.02722547948360443, -0.0445939302444458, 0.05586628615856171, 0.03753912076354027, -0.005885260179638863, 0.02216578647494316, -0.05130792781710625, -0.012105797417461872, -0.02273903228342533, -0.041133202612400055, 0.003934152889996767, -0.02967958152294159, -0.033373430371284485, 0.0017789972480386496, 0.016050441190600395, -0.030592046678066254, 0.026735786348581314, 0.008288128301501274, -0.017948446795344353, 0.017970431596040726, -0.0027251066640019417, -0.053301598876714706, 0.0034300207626074553, -0.044189706444740295, 0.032101090997457504, -0.0075676096603274345, 0.018444783985614777, 0.029947875067591667, -0.005430972203612328, -0.06624361127614975, 0.018323063850402832, -0.032078295946121216, -0.018505217507481575, -0.03785385563969612, 0.014362015761435032, 0.01623164676129818, 0.010912735015153885, -0.03741197660565376, 0.03957018256187439, -0.020671198144555092, 0.015734409913420677, -0.059178389608860016, -0.03589276224374771, -0.0036755832843482494, 0.02958603948354721, 0.05377895385026932, 0.035696841776371, -0.014122364111244678, 0.06199195608496666, -0.013711422681808472, -0.06797336786985397, -0.045922648161649704, -0.004567344207316637, -0.012448643334209919, -0.010236362926661968, 0.04722386598587036, 0.017308317124843597, -0.012700873427093029, -0.0024642760399729013, 0.0446733720600605, 0.043780840933322906, 0.06409864872694016, -0.015985069796442986, -0.017488162964582443, 0.014356742613017559, 0.009242841973900795, -0.012907402589917183, 0.0011330945417284966, -0.014883866533637047, -0.05095849931240082, -0.0033153677359223366, -0.010728656314313412, 0.013820914551615715, 0.014232459478080273, -0.032782625406980515, 0.0025526396930217743, 0.04036661237478256, 0.0008356549078598619, -0.04115545377135277, 0.028489265590906143, -0.018876681104302406, -0.024285515770316124, -0.03821156173944473, 0.05833658203482628, 0.043398261070251465, -0.043050941079854965, -0.0054076355881989, 0.06705886870622635, 0.04218238592147827, -0.07730759680271149, -0.01139056496322155, 0.026122715324163437, -0.02859417349100113, 0.007957406342029572, -0.015500109642744064, 0.02371007204055786, 0.004356815945357084, 0.028396351262927055, 0.01813967525959015, 0.020338743925094604, -0.04258553683757782, 0.044710781425237656, -0.06157307326793671, -0.008894091472029686, -0.018113307654857635, 0.10688482224941254, -0.012109082192182541, 0.05649951100349426, 0.033229339867830276, -0.014290982857346535, 0.022589074447751045, 0.027885019779205322, -0.055474184453487396, 0.019504424184560776, -0.016821105033159256, 0.012929214164614677, -0.017945386469364166, -0.0210510715842247, -0.01579403318464756, 0.015117940492928028, 0.0227427389472723, -0.008383624255657196, -0.0037550253327935934, -0.04010862112045288, -0.02637067437171936, -0.03585007041692734, -0.006332682445645332, 0.010731818154454231, 0.04592294245958328, -0.008782142773270607, 0.0009202896035276353, 0.04150998219847679, 0.004413907881826162, -0.011176631785929203, -0.016833370551466942, -0.023810941725969315, 0.015891652554273605, -0.024167664349079132, 0.022247817367315292, 0.00275320652872324, 0.02285064198076725, -0.024188170209527016, -0.0003909548686351627, -0.004051696974784136, 0.03796236962080002, 0.031151263043284416, -0.012948342598974705, 0.012776242569088936, -0.030517781153321266, -0.0061600832268595695, -0.022924598306417465, 0.021784881129860878, -0.024912260472774506, 0.002646998269483447, -0.008694727905094624, 0.03632551431655884, -0.018633797764778137, -0.006243428681045771, 0.08028686046600342, 0.017942266538739204, -0.0371251255273819, 0.019012242555618286, -0.0074656326323747635, -0.0020066320430487394, -0.035846155136823654, 0.005173541139811277, 0.02582315355539322, -0.014904557727277279, 0.008002358488738537, 0.013252870179712772, 0.0176782738417387, -0.06503313034772873, -0.010412534698843956, 0.0033012479543685913, 0.027330582961440086, -0.029076144099235535, 0.0044876220636069775, 0.07031374424695969, 0.029240848496556282, 0.07119856029748917, 0.0037645224947482347, 0.010405454784631729, -0.10191309452056885, 0.0018800650723278522, 0.03538672626018524, 0.05883526802062988, -0.03773336857557297, -0.020440030843019485, -0.007935352623462677, 0.036366403102874756, 0.06552556902170181, -0.06462650746107101, 0.017916182056069374, -0.01123544666916132, 0.00833459384739399, 0.0016767539782449603, -0.011807109229266644, -0.006930542178452015, 0.043818265199661255, -0.024795319885015488, 0.03790000081062317, 0.012824601493775845, -0.037250861525535583, -0.0349155068397522, 0.0031601162627339363, 0.005891087464988232, 0.061252836138010025, -0.0270389411598444, 0.0037908104714006186, 0.005579500924795866, 0.02938983589410782, -0.020335959270596504, -0.048447754234075546, 0.0011313209543004632, 0.02128334902226925, 0.008829070255160332, 0.06802737712860107, -0.02751167118549347, -0.012577353045344353, 0.027817096561193466, 0.015207233838737011, -0.02309655211865902, -0.0298613328486681, -0.004467014688998461, 0.036744844168424606, 0.0432366207242012, 0.005693001206964254, 0.01030045747756958, 0.06372663378715515, -0.004163996782153845, -0.005467483773827553, -0.0021727823186665773, -0.004613876808434725, -0.04045901075005531, -0.005988670978695154, -0.037078093737363815, -0.008927284739911556, -0.04627128690481186, 0.007631863933056593, -0.030920494347810745, 0.00766846165060997, -0.060149114578962326, 0.0013495703460648656, -0.012452937662601471, 0.025965498760342598, -0.009443426504731178, 0.004980631172657013, 0.0027178043965250254, 0.03734884411096573, -0.018426647409796715, -0.03072197176516056, 0.04487023502588272, -0.030960991978645325, -0.004408109933137894, -0.02212149277329445, -0.029395343735814095, 0.015090038068592548, -0.04837954044342041, -0.0059805382043123245, 0.011453730054199696, -0.009423407725989819, 0.026311878114938736, -0.0006764314603060484, 0.028236139565706253, 0.03354561701416969, -0.05715238302946091, -0.0010895109735429287, 0.02440270595252514, -0.01165472250431776, -0.005827893037348986, -0.04073680192232132, 0.0697256475687027, 0.009266854263842106, -0.03850095346570015, -0.07492878288030624, -0.03355439752340317, -0.000318587408401072, 0.001702102948911488, -0.009969604201614857, -0.08135031163692474, -0.0332072451710701, -0.001237561460584402, -0.022489165887236595, -0.011253316886723042, 0.03288194164633751, 0.031438328325748444, -0.0036773202009499073, -0.011959544382989407, -0.011621971614658833, 0.06079403683543205, 0.04100297763943672, -0.005945818964391947, -0.02175380289554596, 0.016297560185194016, -0.0011588949710130692, -0.00036778172943741083, 0.03987095504999161, -0.03698032721877098, -0.000009320499884779565, 0.012994259595870972, -0.005766828544437885, 0.04737691953778267, -0.05846617743372917, 0.021493440493941307, 0.004677819553762674, -0.006241417955607176, -0.020435281097888947, -0.06673382222652435, 0.008958876132965088, -0.03300422802567482, 0.014190980233252048, -0.07244636118412018, 0.002575086895376444, -0.011465273797512054, -0.015220641158521175, 0.02114180475473404, 0.014995160512626171, 0.017014171928167343, 0.018416503444314003, 0.06514552235603333, -0.0196379367262125, 0.023696647956967354, 0.029188109561800957, -0.024986568838357925, 0.038647059351205826, 0.013329952955245972, -0.02300904132425785, -0.001227753353305161, 0.024586521089076996, -0.025079375132918358, 0.0012719269143417478, -0.00716041075065732, -0.03829001262784004, 0.04075900465250015, 0.0011783362133428454, 0.027763545513153076, 0.05935382470488548, 0.019166219979524612, 0.04491278529167175, 0.00026936735957860947, 0.005282706581056118, -0.014131642878055573, 0.002247014781460166, 0.05356631800532341, -0.00424190005287528, 0.022228308022022247, 0.009330897592008114, 0.04860515519976616, 0.033314380794763565, -0.005710749886929989, 0.0349513478577137, 0.005441734567284584, 0.010433594696223736, 0.005599832162261009, -0.026129793375730515, -0.009324358776211739, -0.027394073083996773, 0.023387352004647255, -0.03958067670464516, -0.015735933557152748, 0.03051559068262577, 0.0006325877620838583, -0.015282302163541317, 0.003168347990140319, -0.05425088480114937, -0.007871893234550953, 0.03080500289797783, 0.052455805242061615, -0.0018552468391135335, 0.006665044464170933, 0.024619819596409798, 0.02195102907717228, 0.025998348370194435, 0.005324421916157007, -0.013596801087260246, -0.04566483572125435, 0.011938958428800106, -0.03260315954685211, -0.041388001292943954, 0.02395782433450222, 0.017174430191516876, -0.03559449315071106, 0.015350734815001488, 0.0015478288987651467, 0.010286079719662666, -0.025089673697948456, -0.007388265337795019, -0.02570454403758049, 0.07377103716135025, 0.03326079249382019, 0.012239762581884861, -0.005602470599114895, 0.009692942723631859, 0.12084413319826126, 0.06592417508363724, 0.0436544269323349, -0.08266381174325943, 0.010969030670821667, 0.0017222438473254442, -0.04328069090843201, -0.016453377902507782, 0.01399520318955183, 0.014788440428674221, 0.0435347706079483, 0.051401589065790176, 0.08186949789524078, 0.018070092424750328, 0.01073280069977045, 0.044610850512981415, -0.014309593476355076, -0.01720438338816166, 0.02014722116291523, -0.001289517036639154, -0.014969587326049805, 0.02076202630996704, -0.08655329048633575, 0.049529068171978, 0.013135748915374279, -0.008428199216723442, -0.05717236176133156, -0.04191866144537926, 0.03216651827096939, 0.015200861729681492, 0.008437048643827438, 0.023490650579333305, 0.011518043465912342, -0.025356704369187355, -0.010744902305305004, -0.011477435939013958, 0.023429933935403824, -0.017034100368618965, 0.0008610615623183548, 0.0032371387351304293, 0.04598168283700943, 0.010614150203764439, -0.06278996169567108, 0.012703047133982182, -0.03751956671476364, -0.007882963865995407, -0.020230572670698166, 0.014727405272424221, -0.01952284574508667, -0.006783186458051205, 0.013178661465644836, 0.03281817212700844, 0.0062576946802437305, -0.06239672377705574, -0.032490573823451996, 0.03231833502650261, 0.02481864020228386, -0.018905969336628914, -0.017277028411626816, -0.02513253502547741, 0.015275180339813232, -0.05871940776705742, -0.010695288889110088, -0.03051215037703514, -0.026114149019122124, -0.029599018394947052, -0.04010388255119324, 0.0037305369041860104, -0.021134017035365105, -0.004398539662361145, -0.016161730512976646, -0.006764646153897047, 0.004951226990669966, -0.016638319939374924, -0.015927033498883247, 0.028864581137895584, 0.01821793243288994, -0.0042062848806381226, -0.02535349130630493, -0.024776361882686615, -0.017474690452218056, 0.03799921274185181, -0.0005240982281975448, -0.017269844189286232, -0.026045160368084908, -0.027554117143154144, 0.051333919167518616, 0.01992548257112503, 0.044583987444639206, 0.011062328703701496, 0.0034242745023220778, 0.02038383111357689, 0.004525686148554087, -0.03799442574381828, -0.004776197485625744, 0.01639495976269245, -0.0745050236582756, 0.026384640485048294, -0.002154954709112644, 0.028436321765184402, 0.04667019844055176, -0.033073313534259796, -0.006045233458280563, 0.022947248071432114, -0.011911760084331036, 0.044750235974788666, -0.0012295212363824248, -0.05776578187942505, -0.012845889665186405, 0.028976403176784515, -0.01620924100279808, -0.023270271718502045, -0.005815993994474411, -0.037283021956682205, -0.0011932365596294403, 0.0028210219461470842, 0.010445053689181805, -0.024898184463381767, 0.025502491742372513, -0.024213239550590515, -0.01738864555954933, -0.038565829396247864, -0.027793750166893005, -0.02596564218401909, -0.018177930265665054, -0.0299071054905653, -0.0077410973608493805, -0.049490902572870255, 0.0009665671968832612, -0.03195978328585625, 0.015130124054849148, 0.056204453110694885, 0.016078807413578033, 0.0040767309255898, 0.011054863221943378, 0.023703156039118767, -0.010556847788393497, 0.03463593125343323, -0.0321381576359272, -0.03102230653166771, 0.033231548964977264, -0.038283903151750565, -0.042228374630212784, 0.03395929932594299, 0.013713212683796883, 0.028206946328282356, 0.02458326891064644, -0.02232448011636734, -0.01705251820385456, 0.08058446645736694, 0.000543298083357513, -0.017285315319895744, 0.008358827792108059, -0.011653859168291092, 0.04149167239665985, -0.011358199641108513, -0.022845184430480003, 0.00991896167397499, -0.041045062243938446, -0.0017832341836765409, 0.03858999162912369, 0.020469143986701965, -0.009240614250302315, -0.02694256603717804, 0.012205486185848713, 0.018346475437283516, 0.004071875941008329, 0.000052921030146535486, 0.05466996878385544, 0.042072102427482605, -0.04743953421711922, 0.0007123416871763766, -0.010115928016602993, 0.011250607669353485, -0.04248515143990517, 0.017353393137454987, -0.005973576568067074, -0.016347818076610565, 0.0403045229613781, -0.049888819456100464, 0.010829955339431763, 0.02324671670794487, -0.03378600627183914, 0.027667740359902382, -0.02727334015071392, -0.014380785636603832, -0.009648838080465794, 0.010740132071077824, -0.022455504164099693, 0.06001945585012436, 0.015002046711742878, 0.039006106555461884, 0.012867490760982037, 0.0155863706022501, 0.025019856169819832, -0.026917554438114166, 0.022410210222005844, 0.013514863327145576, -0.001613031723536551, -0.02456720918416977, 0.008198482915759087, -0.005803012289106846, -0.03879210352897644, 0.020626405254006386, -0.056143321096897125, -0.004064577631652355, 0.05780809745192528, 0.00880558229982853, -0.003567289561033249, 0.04642479866743088, 0.002662061480805278, 0.019097955897450447, -0.06687904894351959, -0.014824683777987957, -0.005255725234746933, 0.020616840571165085, -0.003622861346229911, -0.012845847755670547, 0.05761672183871269, -0.0022367886267602444, -0.018013760447502136, 0.021968666464090347, 0.004492605570703745, 0.0074281538836658, -0.03464744612574577, -0.0018166019581258297, 0.0012537244474515319, -0.015082593075931072, -0.015966208651661873, -0.02063714899122715, 0.0007950365543365479, 0.05848013237118721, -0.03706919401884079, -0.019066063687205315, 0.01645861566066742, 0.01391549501568079, -0.05635649710893631, -0.022655794396996498, 0.03466856852173805, 0.0062237209640443325, -0.04434293136000633, 0.00325195980258286, -0.010535278357565403, -0.007401955779641867, -0.012770036235451698, -0.039791952818632126, 0.027465395629405975, 0.02685406804084778, -0.0006121080368757248, -0.012044455856084824, 0.001904251053929329, -0.013446321710944176, -0.0013702961150556803, -0.04009499400854111, 0.062345560640096664, 0.015054074116051197, -0.015175439417362213, -0.02953431010246277, -0.02472265250980854, -0.048045940697193146, 0.035190608352422714, 0.012972816824913025, -0.004223709926009178, 0.01982818730175495, -0.05488639697432518, 0.006248163990676403, 0.03210722282528877, -0.024430232122540474, 0.010691121220588684, -0.017486050724983215, -0.02254643104970455, 0.0007250802591443062, -0.0314456969499588, -0.005093471147119999, -0.019601069390773773, 0.001929694670252502, -0.0612662211060524, -0.033013008534908295, -0.03571855276823044, -0.035062070935964584, -0.000558112864382565, 0.027118390426039696, 0.008905663155019283, 0.043001070618629456, -0.016648678109049797, -0.02849729172885418, 0.033909790217876434, -0.004478667862713337, -0.056612785905599594, 0.057634368538856506, -0.0625532791018486, 0.021831033751368523, 0.03853217139840126, 0.009537422098219395, 0.019225632771849632, -0.05425553396344185, 0.015333777293562889, -0.0023256835993379354, 0.004244040232151747, -0.006796814035624266, 0.06673518568277359, 0.02162466011941433, 0.010097073391079903, -0.003947944846004248, 0.020604344084858894, 0.007832529954612255, -0.021775435656309128, 0.05610226094722748, 0.01968846656382084, -0.016199789941310883, 0.037234868854284286, -0.011297235265374184, 0.01626479998230934, 0.010994142852723598, 0.024932680651545525, 0.010018132627010345, 0.007423959206789732, -0.0021908581256866455, -0.016071338206529617, 0.0032177367247641087, -0.026100698858499527, 0.056896429508924484, 0.010645183734595776, -0.024810422211885452, 0.06381107866764069, -0.03615297004580498, 0.05016888678073883, -0.05369725823402405, -0.03061952441930771, -0.0626099482178688, -0.02789405919611454, 0.030967308208346367, 0.022140145301818848, -0.008177869953215122, -0.004479385446757078, 0.010081279091536999, 9.119037258642493e-7, -0.008371739648282528, -0.012730194255709648, 0.035932328552007675, -0.02623741328716278, 0.009425538592040539, -0.0009171822457574308, 0.005042798817157745, -0.03943169116973877, 0.024656426161527634, 0.013532557524740696, 0.026966964825987816, 0.06996150314807892, 0.002192554296925664, -0.001369472243823111, -0.022328205406665802, 0.010717813856899738, -0.01897437684237957, -0.011856043711304665, -0.06861338019371033, -0.029255874454975128, 0.0009747135918587446, -0.0033391863107681274 ]
<p>I am struggling already a couple of days with this simple OLS, can you help?</p> <p>Outcome years in function of predictor score, very simple linear model. The residual plot does absolutely not look good though. </p> <p>Is it correct that based on the residual plot versus the outcome variable, to say that "if I predict the outcome to be 12, I most of the time over estimate the years of eduction?"</p> <p>In blue my fitted OLS, in red a LOESS curve. What am I doing wrong or how to improve OLS?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/YNXxI.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I have tried to both transform the predictor and the outcome, no luck. Is there something else you can suggest?</p> <p>The specific problem I have is that I am making wrong predictions when the outcome age is 12 years (ref table below, vertical are my predictions, horizontal the true values). How to solve this issue? </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/IRIKi.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
74,340
[ -0.03326864913105965, -0.03401012718677521, -0.027614427730441093, 0.008783419616520405, 0.05057011544704437, -0.008738484233617783, -0.01713000051677227, -0.0159219428896904, 0.036484941840171814, -0.04816940054297447, 0.04620654508471489, 0.02900630235671997, 0.05163395777344704, -0.002470503095537424, 0.019238851964473724, 0.02634134143590927, 0.001003713347017765, 0.03848995640873909, 0.013887342065572739, 0.01812686398625374, -0.01743747852742672, 0.012095817364752293, -0.019905148074030876, -0.019244026392698288, -0.01521535124629736, 0.05941830575466156, 0.06885305047035217, -0.01908975839614868, 0.01425327081233263, 0.038837749511003494, -0.0039901575073599815, -0.03351479023694992, 0.018808836117386818, 0.039675675332546234, -0.0019496714230626822, -0.02747468464076519, 0.008404715918004513, -0.030020568519830704, 0.021900998428463936, 0.032116178423166275, -0.008688708767294884, -0.025339972227811813, -0.013746451586484909, 0.08219355344772339, -0.0023571562487632036, 0.047541309148073196, -0.02766549400985241, -0.0087286327034235, 0.06361958384513855, -0.01895792968571186, 0.04861833527684212, 0.0005976947722956538, 0.028328513726592064, 0.03999759256839752, -0.021565411239862442, -0.023369932547211647, 0.06231348216533661, 0.07460559159517288, 0.0006137386662885547, -0.02260899916291237, -0.019073940813541412, -0.016718268394470215, -0.0030296738259494305, -0.0034147498663514853, -0.0031192703172564507, -0.005811938550323248, 0.01591085083782673, 0.016146285459399223, 0.04973675310611725, -0.008656235411763191, 0.02848115935921669, 0.0285575482994318, 0.009557201527059078, 0.01564990170300007, 0.012459756806492805, -0.03208804875612259, 0.010789974592626095, 0.009061522781848907, 0.036839984357357025, 0.006727976258844137, 0.007548919878900051, 0.01546663697808981, 0.01934843137860298, 0.052660610526800156, -0.002496107714250684, 0.0021063070744276047, 0.05316227674484253, -0.027967380359768867, 0.0208615530282259, 0.013259769417345524, 0.009603185579180717, 0.011178666725754738, 0.05314817652106285, -0.00554555794224143, -0.026069507002830505, 0.029111545532941818, 0.00026867009000852704, 0.011731068603694439, 0.0171329528093338, 0.03199691325426102, 0.024080632254481316, -0.03526792302727699, 0.0051228743977844715, 0.018587524071335793, -0.015437242574989796, -0.0232230331748724, -0.008106043562293053, -0.031485505402088165, 0.0014097044477239251, -0.07366561144590378, 0.00172362697776407, 0.04517671838402748, -0.002033363562077284, -0.005150668788701296, 0.01508675143122673, -0.05549592152237892, -0.04507980868220329, 0.004153657238930464, 0.02870609052479267, 0.03497753664851189, -0.011362793855369091, -0.01618201844394207, 0.02999001182615757, 0.014304641634225845, -0.05370340868830681, 0.022358696907758713, 0.015949903056025505, -0.014400403946638107, -0.01806744933128357, 0.0645887479186058, 0.006500917486846447, -0.03956048563122749, 0.049409426748752594, 0.00732664717361331, 0.03814850375056267, 0.012327369302511215, -0.06878181546926498, -0.08199261128902435, 0.013590879738330841, -0.0034049300011247396, 0.005203138571232557, -0.06142604351043701, -0.02741278149187565, -0.02260429784655571, 0.07569403946399689, 0.011406022123992443, 0.02488589659333229, 0.040934327989816666, 0.01285190973430872, 0.015484091825783253, -0.0019240541150793433, 0.0026149970944970846, -0.010421467944979668, -0.02060694992542267, -0.009180174209177494, -0.07325415313243866, 0.0036797309294342995, 0.020426401868462563, 0.004539018496870995, -0.03125599026679993, 0.03388114273548126, 0.01696447655558586, -0.04124661907553673, 0.003018806455656886, 0.017508143559098244, -0.047051288187503815, 0.08640537410974503, 0.00675855902954936, 0.02830427698791027, 0.04401106387376785, -0.012721934355795383, 0.023578181862831116, 0.016601894050836563, 0.036749742925167084, 0.02336200885474682, 0.013227758929133415, 0.020193275064229965, -0.017166687175631523, -0.023526206612586975, -0.018062515184283257, -0.0677209198474884, -0.07389216870069504, -0.06515441834926605, -0.021895756945014, 0.010994641110301018, 0.03204517439007759, -0.03154377266764641, 0.0075699640437960625, 0.02511971816420555, -0.03769710659980774, -0.0681079775094986, -0.0627133697271347, 0.04230149835348129, -0.007412099279463291, 0.01000982616096735, -0.011696490459144115, -0.016604995355010033, 0.049462974071502686, -0.01721550151705742, 0.01944040134549141, -0.03636917844414711, 0.0012500673765316606, 0.019306790083646774, -0.013916886411607265, 0.03751741722226143, 0.05743717402219772, 0.052411001175642014, -0.004134656395763159, 0.032114144414663315, -0.05585427209734917, -0.011250318959355354, 0.01371170673519373, -0.04038499295711517, 0.012325762771070004, -0.03754689171910286, -0.016075795516371727, 0.000660143734421581, -0.028478899970650673, 0.0031668480951339006, 0.007652377709746361, -0.060792289674282074, 0.07998822629451752, 0.05656953901052475, 0.004194771405309439, -0.016241442412137985, -0.00045350418076850474, -0.01188537199050188, 0.04387882351875305, -0.05061960965394974, -0.017480406910181046, -0.04482179507613182, 0.001804192317649722, 0.022158749401569366, 0.029196089133620262, -0.022884564474225044, 0.029854441061615944, 0.045422133058309555, -0.02499464899301529, 0.011509505100548267, 0.03321164473891258, 0.003976001869887114, -0.014503175392746925, 0.0010399778839200735, 0.00014050067693460733, -0.010585195384919643, 0.0376615934073925, 0.022534551098942757, 0.02660340629518032, 0.013930471614003181, -0.017512332648038864, 0.021136557683348656, 0.06343366950750351, -0.000573818339034915, -0.003946780227124691, -0.03517268970608711, -0.004681128077208996, 0.0452132448554039, -0.03937561810016632, -0.0072451564483344555, 0.03933047130703926, 0.005659965332597494, -0.006244146265089512, -0.006309937220066786, -0.03908972442150116, 0.012306910939514637, 0.02910829894244671, -0.01717217266559601, -0.005325304809957743, 0.0049043805338442326, -0.019795509055256844, 0.016522087156772614, -0.018282707780599594, -0.018827207386493683, -0.03619534522294998, 0.017234401777386665, 0.025383247062563896, -0.007211044896394014, -0.03482198715209961, -0.028721394017338753, -0.0310067106038332, 0.017662808299064636, 0.0034350689966231585, 0.012708586640655994, 0.03888567164540291, -0.06037098914384842, -0.044342897832393646, -0.023404236882925034, -0.033470481634140015, 0.03574596345424652, 0.016411302611231804, -0.027698969468474388, 0.02685646340250969, -0.01636117324233055, -0.07305411249399185, -0.05650240555405617, -0.03497226908802986, 0.012538720853626728, -0.02657538652420044, -0.04699888452887535, 0.051794786006212234, -0.02070065774023533, 0.017806148156523705, 0.004109971225261688, -0.01730237901210785, 0.014565750025212765, 0.011788958683609962, -0.0007504065870307386, 0.0057374825701117516, 0.03295040875673294, 0.030379747971892357, -0.0002951441565528512, 0.003347991965711117, -0.009586953558027744, -0.07392562925815582, -0.06252378225326538, 0.04670373722910881, 0.004257215186953545, 0.026226665824651718, -0.004602878820151091, -0.016884110867977142, 0.0661703422665596, -0.00283444975502789, 0.02201090194284916, -0.06326556950807571, 0.020048784092068672, -0.012904896400868893, -0.026962710544466972, 0.009903091005980968, 0.006131094880402088, 0.009340181946754456, 0.017525186762213707, -0.05320456624031067, 0.043043579906225204, 0.04665190726518631, -0.0005620121955871582, -0.01001974567770958, -0.0018559896852821112, -0.01869966648519039, -0.02454536035656929, 0.04037001356482506, 0.02542462944984436, -0.018318092450499535, 0.0348014272749424, 0.0011314006987959146, 0.029038170352578163, -0.01769127883017063, -0.08143733441829681, 0.0011071586050093174, -0.034360967576503754, 0.01430039294064045, -0.03627527132630348, 0.020472783595323563, -0.006343635264784098, -0.018231036141514778, -0.02118777111172676, -0.02440859191119671, 0.03847170248627663, 0.01526697725057602, 0.030157405883073807, 0.04490596055984497, 0.011243720538914204, 0.02282397635281086, 0.0005526880850084126, -0.003907248377799988, -0.012540455907583237, 0.043879419565200806, -0.0021221674978733063, 0.008556433953344822, 0.03675970435142517, 0.01870463788509369, 0.0007777220453135669, 0.005481162574142218, -0.053768597543239594, 0.05092810094356537, -0.06575551629066467, 0.02601657621562481, -0.035753391683101654, 0.056894246488809586, 0.01374885719269514, 0.009762010537087917, 0.032333020120859146, -0.012247041799128056, 0.020742766559123993, 0.031061673536896706, -0.0761219933629036, 0.028395675122737885, -0.007647901773452759, -0.009299611672759056, -0.012368707917630672, 0.004112605936825275, 0.020741673186421394, -0.042397838085889816, -0.008894316852092743, 0.020128926262259483, 0.029989974573254585, 0.0003066911012865603, -0.01899070478975773, -0.004999006632715464, 0.010751914232969284, -0.039267223328351974, -0.007892625406384468, -0.028109265491366386, -0.033285487443208694, 0.013912935741245747, 0.06662106513977051, -0.005149771459400654, -0.04394129291176796, -0.04020968824625015, 0.006882138084620237, 0.0376000739634037, 0.045984506607055664, 0.033465541899204254, 0.030032264068722725, -0.053343869745731354, 0.03711208328604698, -0.004982731770724058, 0.018965572118759155, 0.02354246750473976, 0.004097078926861286, -0.022303415462374687, -0.014919470995664597, 0.004211163613945246, 0.018036875873804092, 0.00803406722843647, 0.03009948879480362, 0.0034646661952137947, 0.04417118430137634, 0.02834051288664341, -0.05108536407351494, 0.01747780293226242, 0.05904776230454445, -0.003052403451874852, 0.01595439948141575, -0.01858353801071644, -0.004576963372528553, 0.004313400015234947, 0.005210943054407835, 0.0719042494893074, 0.0005000398377887905, 0.004145600367337465, -0.056786227971315384, 0.08015384525060654, 0.001077976543456316, -0.030035486444830894, 0.025189314037561417, -0.03472345322370529, 0.06945887207984924, 0.01993623562157154, -0.03953222930431366, 0.0021636064630001783, 0.04452336207032204, 0.050360340625047684, 0.025450583547353745, 0.023868421092629433, -0.08814230561256409, -0.032956305891275406, 0.020912649109959602, 0.04856213927268982, -0.036902472376823425, 0.009420819580554962, -0.04660630598664284, -0.03034364804625511, 0.03453340753912926, -0.05470995604991913, 0.026929590851068497, 0.005049082916229963, 0.021444208920001984, -0.012461054138839245, -0.03751564025878906, -0.05242512375116348, 0.004247451201081276, -0.014187430962920189, 0.050961934030056, -0.009889976121485233, -0.04259750247001648, -0.01148355845361948, -0.025529421865940094, 0.008914959616959095, 0.028582019731402397, 0.004551841877400875, -0.024654889479279518, 0.017354659736156464, 0.010912415571510792, -0.03802904859185219, -0.05901819467544556, 0.023189038038253784, -0.01928315870463848, -0.018260665237903595, 0.03343173861503601, 0.018509814515709877, -0.02335253171622753, -0.011155149899423122, 0.04002511501312256, -0.016507981345057487, -0.040732692927122116, -0.04533396661281586, 0.02499736286699772, 0.020498622208833694, -0.00017841211229097098, 0.07297687232494354, 0.045905701816082, 0.006831568665802479, 0.018289750441908836, -0.03505575656890869, -0.0010858330642804503, -0.040584418922662735, -0.03131585940718651, 0.0006928144721314311, -0.018399540334939957, 0.014340300112962723, 0.024035288020968437, -0.012840158306062222, 0.02270260639488697, -0.043875452131032944, -0.030766762793064117, 0.022647976875305176, 0.009662042371928692, -0.013746391981840134, 0.01361963339149952, 0.014681000262498856, 0.011924222111701965, -0.015111180022358894, -0.043120529502630234, 0.01012191642075777, 0.0012153276475146413, 0.01603863015770912, 0.03682722896337509, -0.035866204649209976, 0.0164027102291584, 0.008702771738171577, -0.018107805401086807, -0.007323359604924917, -0.04902229458093643, 0.027672752737998962, -0.03351078927516937, 0.007804022170603275, 0.009009298868477345, -0.029808813706040382, -0.0148593969643116, 0.001622818410396576, -0.0044683609157800674, 0.04346271976828575, -0.003268023720011115, 0.012322812341153622, -0.00825797114521265, -0.014027269557118416, -0.06275387853384018, -0.06542643159627914, -0.011922398582100868, 0.03304922208189964, -0.01637975499033928, -0.003049469320103526, -0.021710138767957687, -0.01362599153071642, -0.018192525953054428, -0.029757635667920113, 0.025557182729244232, -0.04552428424358368, -0.009109837003052235, 0.026179853826761246, 0.020190024748444557, 0.0634472519159317, -0.02048216573894024, -0.0054522426798939705, 0.014236939139664173, -0.054698627442121506, -0.041877929121255875, -0.057328805327415466, 0.034445829689502716, -0.03995542600750923, -0.012701303698122501, -0.022591304033994675, 0.006555676925927401, 0.0672631487250328, -0.006360317580401897, -0.03202638030052185, 0.005800570826977491, 0.0057106297463178635, 0.025169888511300087, -0.0049851336516439915, 0.007131059654057026, -0.046125464141368866, -0.0014312537387013435, -0.0009619663469493389, 0.01648254506289959, -0.04999840632081032, -0.037116795778274536, 0.021931640803813934, 0.005615595728158951, 0.00152146490290761, 0.025782207027077675, 0.06274556368589401, -0.04588339850306511, -0.026305686682462692, -0.013506965711712837, -0.03091912344098091, 0.029791763052344322, 0.03253169730305672, 0.006222466006875038, 0.03190024569630623, 0.020708875730633736, -0.04064902663230896, -0.05365963652729988, -0.046663008630275726, 0.013529693707823753, 0.08388103544712067, -0.04185689613223076, 0.019685717299580574, 0.03253689780831337, 0.0051103997975587845, 0.0158687774091959, -0.04950343444943428, 0.010557567700743675, 0.001490332535468042, -0.02653408795595169, 0.049975790083408356, -0.025550026446580887, -0.020190207287669182, 0.004641787149012089, -0.0010179694509133697, 0.01094219833612442, 0.04190276935696602, 0.011645320802927017, -0.009986753575503826, 0.021841352805495262, -0.011775631457567215, -0.03092513419687748, 0.01478774193674326, -0.02299952320754528, 0.005830753594636917, -0.015472687780857086, 0.0006708204164169729, 0.061351239681243896, 0.0559062622487545, 0.025318937376141548, -0.04058825597167015, -0.020170841366052628, -0.06560254096984863, -0.00697475066408515, 0.013944032602012157, -0.02333509735763073, 0.02662370540201664, 0.027953332290053368, 0.05458531528711319, 0.04684640094637871, 0.013021968305110931, -0.07794912904500961, -0.07587804645299911, -0.007265088614076376, -0.04180653393268585, -0.018251076340675354, 0.009273787029087543, 0.006919147912412882, -0.015060791745781898, 0.025259658694267273, -0.027749236673116684, -0.010316623374819756, 0.026335064321756363, 0.03550627827644348, 0.016420992091298103, 0.04778338596224785, -0.006694237235933542, -0.018734442070126534, -0.005614882335066795, -0.010190206579864025, 0.12123013287782669, 0.11066070944070816, 0.01303113717585802, -0.0883723646402359, 0.03933536633849144, 0.042035140097141266, -0.02417461760342121, 0.006804961245507002, -0.03192947804927826, -0.00466262036934495, -0.034542519599199295, 0.012746548280119896, 0.051470112055540085, 0.03043670393526554, -0.026872213929891586, 0.05590543895959854, -0.02013181336224079, -0.007685641758143902, -0.008718281984329224, -0.0002003246481763199, 0.016904976218938828, -0.016401315107941628, -0.04230421036481857, 0.014377757906913757, -0.00921876635402441, -0.013901125639677048, -0.020024102181196213, -0.020057568326592445, 0.0057841078378260136, -0.02095242589712143, -0.054502349346876144, 0.007236943114548922, -0.00412636948749423, 0.03260122612118721, -0.01759815588593483, 0.0018914779648184776, 0.0147085664793849, -0.01689458265900612, 0.020423684269189835, 0.03828916326165199, -0.026239842176437378, 0.008833371102809906, 0.011806556954979897, -0.008657095953822136, -0.040460288524627686, -0.01786983199417591, -0.02963252365589142, 0.06316006928682327, 0.010523694567382336, -0.0341930165886879, -0.0017360837664455175, 0.005408117547631264, 0.008502931334078312, -0.07340390980243683, -0.005011946428567171, 0.03017464280128479, 0.010958635248243809, -0.009914135560393333, -0.01776961050927639, -0.010657783597707748, -0.016360128298401833, -0.007471147459000349, 0.043556809425354004, 0.028314461931586266, -0.02792719006538391, -0.00011455019557615742, -0.07844690978527069, 0.04456506669521332, 0.0348709411919117, 0.003086175536736846, 0.031897202134132385, 0.00026591841015033424, 0.002373561728745699, 0.02478657104074955, -0.00021107403154019266, 0.0091844592243433, 0.03615988418459892, -0.00039689624099992216, -0.0037493922282010317, -0.04079454392194748, -0.023592380806803703, 0.017739679664373398, -0.021145140752196312, 0.0006107306107878685, -0.04133475199341774, 0.004287377931177616, 0.027046989649534225, 0.05559179186820984, -0.009370818734169006, 0.021113920956850052, -0.034013137221336365, 0.012040035799145699, -0.0039290315471589565, -0.05361932888627052, -0.02145797573029995, 0.007004284765571356, -0.040598008781671524, -0.027576696127653122, -0.01162400096654892, 0.08250460028648376, 0.0053497301414608955, 0.033884912729263306, -0.019989825785160065, 0.05845102667808533, -0.0075515503995120525, 0.02711511217057705, -0.016160884872078896, -0.03534187003970146, 0.026033589616417885, 0.0010945970425382257, -0.014714492484927177, -0.007850226014852524, -0.012635791674256325, -0.018397213891148567, -0.051954563707113266, 0.03420983999967575, -0.028307363390922546, -0.01952032558619976, 0.048394881188869476, -0.020674733445048332, 0.02986011654138565, -0.03734998777508736, -0.020913803949952126, -0.02529081515967846, -0.016884922981262207, 0.008435923606157303, -0.02890765853226185, -0.019866809248924255, 0.04809211567044258, 0.00572470435872674, -0.026070237159729004, 0.03774512559175491, 0.027278698980808258, 0.025754347443580627, -0.025534318760037422, 0.017492646351456642, 0.0077337888069450855, 0.06927544623613358, -0.006121107377111912, -0.013225911185145378, 0.015276622027158737, -0.027833448722958565, -0.015512596815824509, 0.03265513479709625, -0.017556922510266304, 0.042187634855508804, 0.0024012685753405094, 0.015430944971740246, -0.032497745007276535, 0.03228885307908058, 0.01349742989987135, 0.03832205757498741, -0.010018894448876381, -0.0024371733888983727, 0.03414367884397507, 0.023352863267064095, -0.01963917724788189, 0.013517938554286957, -0.032448094338178635, 0.018114278092980385, 0.03284459933638573, -0.015744615346193314, -0.00985779520124197, -0.016595466062426567, 0.006653857883065939, -0.00009781029802979901, 0.011578802019357681, 0.0074316938407719135, 0.004688463639467955, 0.01942306011915207, -0.05340716987848282, 0.030843323096632957, -0.01094022300094366, -0.006013928446918726, -0.06465733051300049, -0.02556760609149933, -0.010865599848330021, 0.028514033183455467, 0.05213741585612297, -0.03504454344511032, -0.023415295407176018, 0.03266523778438568, -0.018312843516469002, -0.012379420921206474, -0.00983857735991478, 0.0075205229222774506, -0.006132571026682854, -0.02443304844200611, 0.000054130028729559854, -0.0022504092194139957, 0.023301851004362106, 0.05504893511533737, 0.0024850047193467617, 0.036471184343099594, -0.006916718557476997, -0.05588284879922867, 0.022854162380099297, 0.0006441838340833783, 0.010894151404500008, -0.045975323766469955, 0.0236128531396389, -0.024761797860264778, 0.005921828560531139, 0.023743176832795143, -0.014565631747245789, 0.03441308066248894, 0.04844727739691734, -0.010893318802118301, 0.011182170361280441, 0.0592016763985157, -0.011569307185709476, -0.04487048462033272, 0.02041364647448063, -0.010830885730683804, 0.006781661417335272, 0.006862098351120949, -0.026433248072862625, -0.0018938042921945453, 0.01084122620522976, -0.004778650123625994, -0.028786567971110344, 0.0008606907213106751, -0.028512146323919296, -0.013364579528570175, 0.0326399989426136, -0.017063377425074577, -0.012744517996907234, -0.05483440309762955, 0.013932286761701107, -0.007110967300832272, -0.00912343617528677, 0.06126609072089195, 0.008790385909378529, -0.0013081104261800647, 0.007999581284821033, -0.023742670193314552, -0.02302614599466324, -0.002466123318299651, -0.005824490450322628, 0.008580083958804607, -0.007216812577098608, 0.020458588376641273, 0.004576816223561764, -0.014807483181357384, -0.020968470722436905, 0.0053868782706558704, -0.04053070396184921, 0.028963053598999977, 0.011904513463377953, 0.015394935384392738, 0.06796859949827194, -0.028013665229082108, 0.009469201788306236, -0.06967386603355408, 0.06781784445047379, 0.000651850423309952, -0.048732940107584, -0.020973993465304375, -0.022129975259304047, -0.026571258902549744, 0.00840724352747202, 0.06183739751577377, -0.011022361926734447, -0.007952641695737839, 0.017790304496884346, 0.011486233212053776, 0.013350626453757286, -0.0016024070791900158, 0.07143894582986832, 0.0018246048130095005, 0.016535459086298943, -0.02019582688808441, 0.007678413297981024, 0.0026432338636368513, 0.015432537533342838, 0.00899784080684185, -0.003544188803061843, 0.0012878917623311281, 0.01744581200182438, 0.004764440935105085, 0.005480644758790731, 0.006532304920256138, -0.0002445111458655447, 0.036380041390657425, 0.01467090006917715, -0.025204947218298912, 0.016505954787135124, 0.006332763470709324, -0.053985174745321274, 0.02547040581703186, -0.027547750622034073, 0.0017464967677369714, -0.006227957084774971, -0.03094283863902092, 0.009545945562422276, -0.07467250525951385, 0.01717681623995304, 0.042257003486156464, 0.008771843276917934, -0.01424011867493391, 0.0532996766269207, 0.024231424555182457, 0.031953003257513046, -0.023520763963460922, 0.013418793678283691, 0.005478648003190756, -0.03226984664797783, 0.019721420481801033, -0.007187447510659695, 0.044555213302373886, -0.0028223402332514524, 0.02363819070160389, 0.06736478954553604, 0.018096864223480225, 0.006168794352561235, 0.007649816107004881, 0.07722591608762741, -0.035154085606336594, 0.0030545180197805166, 0.001835923525504768, 0.0019409824162721634, 0.043130986392498016, 0.008687139488756657, -0.006321076303720474, 0.024793991819024086, -0.056137505918741226, 0.0027038154657930136, -0.04379122704267502, -0.05464792996644974, -0.05671663209795952, 0.0012651780853047967, 0.02627880498766899, 0.016190068796277046, 0.0228378064930439, 0.015422753058373928, -0.026181437075138092, -0.01045583188533783, 0.0366840586066246, -0.006757668685168028, -0.010303732939064503, -0.008319149725139141, -0.0782860517501831, 0.0014283668715506792, -0.014442944899201393, -0.014518680982291698, -0.05538509786128998, 0.02853679470717907, 0.053700048476457596, 0.005771007854491472, -0.034428346902132034, -0.01638556830585003, -0.01034486386924982, 0.03719474375247955, -0.07234558463096619, -0.030639799311757088, -0.021423472091555595, 0.0028240515384823084, 0.012735513038933277, -0.04741036519408226 ]
<p>This question is about three-way interaction and the possibility of applying without second lower terms with keeping the main variables in the equation not like the other questions. In fact the other answers suggest there is possibility of applying . I am not here to find the best solution because I know it and I already included in my question, but to know whether is it possible regardless if it is preferable or not. thank you and please open my question for discussion </p> <p>The widely known regression equation for assessing the three-way interaction is</p> <p>$$ Y= B_1 X+B_2 Z+B_3 W +B_4XZ+B_5XW+B_6ZW+B_7XZW+B_0 $$</p> <p>All lower order terms is included in the regression equation for the B7 coefficient to represent the effect of the three-way interaction on Y. </p> <p>Is there possible way to skip the lower order terms and include only the higher term? as in:</p> <p>$$ Y= B_1 X+B_2 Z+B_3 W +B_4XZW+B_0 $$</p> <p>And how many observations do I need to perform such equation if X &amp; Z are continuous variables and W is dummy variable ?</p> <p>I will be thankful if anyone can provide me with any suggestions </p>
49,556
[ -0.015466575510799885, 0.008805617690086365, -0.019094416871666908, 0.02045125514268875, 0.03695018216967583, 0.031508639454841614, -0.011920314282178879, -0.04817323014140129, 0.04390683397650719, -0.022945662960410118, 0.023370955139398575, 0.017633475363254547, 0.05064493417739868, -0.011404577642679214, 0.02413499541580677, 0.017122823745012283, -0.005234904121607542, 0.011088304221630096, -0.01759895496070385, -0.010687560774385929, -0.02754317782819271, 0.0005307727260515094, 0.017455413937568665, 0.046238332986831665, 0.02234632335603237, 0.03338775411248207, 0.042701732367277145, -0.011796882376074791, 0.041874248534440994, 0.022002922371029854, 0.01238874439150095, -0.04236559569835663, -0.022029802203178406, 0.03967147693037987, -0.0038706709165126085, 0.02763691172003746, -0.02201012149453163, -0.02845596894621849, 0.014713989570736885, 0.008566470816731453, -0.016726801171898842, 0.01715867593884468, -0.0017044817795976996, 0.053983718156814575, 0.006262864917516708, -0.0015751380706205964, -0.003184832399711013, -0.020505234599113464, 0.032914575189352036, -0.013649245724081993, 0.08675369620323181, -0.003377654356881976, 0.025155529379844666, 0.026304660364985466, -0.014242604374885559, -0.052391503006219864, 0.06271696835756302, 0.04297161102294922, 0.025699418038129807, 0.002901598811149597, -0.016803739592432976, -0.028332330286502838, -0.003378658788278699, 0.03779960051178932, -0.011198597028851509, 0.02981659024953842, 0.006531933788210154, 0.0010810374515131116, 0.015247050672769547, -0.02980833500623703, -0.0024596902076154947, -0.03076772764325142, 0.06693904101848602, -0.0033653161954134703, 0.01859792321920395, 0.015897996723651886, 0.00267786649055779, 0.03083462454378605, 0.00713174557313323, 0.003373380983248353, -0.06512761861085892, -0.00912396889179945, 0.01812351681292057, 0.06736134737730026, 0.011644530110061169, -0.011995451524853706, 0.06924484670162201, -0.031386006623506546, 0.0353081151843071, 0.007389915641397238, -0.011012398637831211, 0.012807285413146019, 0.09604290127754211, 0.03410021588206291, -0.014874957501888275, 0.011291708797216415, 0.007949969731271267, 0.05242292210459709, 0.027577584609389305, -0.012718863785266876, 0.0010112265590578318, -0.021086813881993294, -0.01741645857691765, 0.07397426664829254, 0.004586026072502136, -0.004291885066777468, -0.04143977537751198, 0.000686521758325398, -0.025521917268633842, -0.04646427929401398, -0.04131428152322769, 0.00826346967369318, -0.008076845668256283, -0.02877914346754551, -0.003294566413387656, -0.0021059024147689342, 0.0004538937355391681, -0.01920171082019806, 0.07009898126125336, 0.08566179126501083, 0.05022487789392471, -0.061018239706754684, -0.009612360037863255, -0.028047217056155205, -0.045509979128837585, -0.005837534088641405, 0.017024818807840347, 0.00350982416421175, -0.04307083413004875, 0.03991980105638504, 0.03983655944466591, -0.013491501100361347, 0.05449747294187546, -0.013688568957149982, 0.013697589747607708, 0.03362477198243141, -0.062359780073165894, -0.036087293177843094, 0.020332342013716698, -0.03061923384666443, 0.0008843085379339755, -0.06060191988945007, -0.00007280889985850081, 0.02331423945724964, 0.06177034229040146, 0.029830189421772957, 0.005610375199466944, 0.02303158864378929, 0.03934814780950546, 0.026703694835305214, -0.03338957205414772, -0.0009257597848773003, -0.041172124445438385, -0.040301840752363205, 0.012797321192920208, -0.046528223901987076, 0.0396793931722641, -0.002396558178588748, 0.005946723744273186, 0.00006522686453536153, 0.05466746166348457, -0.005060949828475714, -0.04293927922844887, 0.036185599863529205, 0.013213066384196281, -0.017557159066200256, 0.025479743257164955, -0.030956566333770752, 0.06100787594914436, -0.009488415904343128, 0.03009679540991783, 0.011436774395406246, -0.03849106281995773, 0.031190989539027214, 0.002154940040782094, -0.01636631414294243, -0.014536997303366661, -0.028400270268321037, -0.0010890968842431903, 0.005584808997809887, -0.04390595853328705, -0.057265620678663254, -0.011248411610722542, 0.006350731011480093, 0.003528578206896782, 0.02151123806834221, 0.006986654829233885, -0.02904580347239971, 0.05114300176501274, -0.033494193106889725, -0.03208281472325325, -0.06290954351425171, 0.031692445278167725, 0.011461901478469372, -0.0573153980076313, -0.016532136127352715, -0.006870569661259651, 0.005352021660655737, -0.02999277412891388, 0.013292159885168076, 0.017931241542100906, 0.009686149656772614, 0.018313590437173843, -0.02387448213994503, 0.0032103718258440495, 0.03366955742239952, 0.05963107943534851, -0.027929699048399925, 0.05126463994383812, -0.024790160357952118, -0.031065093353390694, 0.016235211864113808, -0.03108682483434677, 0.022289151325821877, -0.02664358727633953, -0.02000354789197445, 0.0457620732486248, -0.03291139751672745, -0.011446225456893444, 0.029001327231526375, -0.06894711405038834, 0.051507968455553055, 0.08374456316232681, 0.01597443036735058, 0.009369129315018654, 0.02956012636423111, 0.01920325867831707, 0.049801308661699295, -0.025854311883449554, -0.0033011112827807665, -0.04301755502820015, -0.012591499835252762, 0.010228672996163368, 0.00589115871116519, -0.06560295075178146, 0.011398511938750744, 0.02320048399269581, 0.018846623599529266, 0.029693331569433212, 0.02400198020040989, -0.00231349840760231, -0.02042321301996708, 0.0378061942756176, 0.018758833408355713, 0.030237866565585136, 0.0027192318812012672, 0.020228911191225052, 0.015574691817164421, 0.027847617864608765, 0.005461310036480427, 0.005636125802993774, 0.018798204138875008, 0.009079081937670708, 0.03556955233216286, -0.03421718627214432, -0.023603258654475212, 0.018491404131054878, -0.06508989632129669, 0.030541030690073967, 0.03567411005496979, 0.030795257538557053, -0.007074229884892702, 0.03821902722120285, -0.014136363752186298, 0.0010739868739619851, 0.024135639891028404, -0.05991112068295479, 0.016918813809752464, 0.025120768696069717, -0.013225804083049297, -0.007018031552433968, -0.03252868726849556, 0.002443626057356596, -0.04135516658425331, -0.027026427909731865, 0.03286413848400116, 0.004337678197771311, 0.032425787299871445, 0.003971386700868607, -0.03337849676609039, -0.00870620645582676, 0.023995159193873405, -0.013460238464176655, -0.006444013211876154, -0.06383521854877472, -0.0190934669226408, -0.03686223179101944, -0.0108720064163208, 0.022040722891688347, 0.017198264598846436, -0.020169151946902275, 0.04917653650045395, -0.014015444554388523, -0.0686311423778534, -0.019767029210925102, 0.005546182859688997, 0.018596939742565155, -0.0015739703085273504, -0.012908068485558033, 0.04655280336737633, 0.028488311916589737, -0.05254434794187546, 0.007481744512915611, -0.020787972956895828, -0.034011110663414, 0.0007263236329890788, -0.009924182668328285, 0.004937850404530764, 0.005201004445552826, 0.04613826423883438, -0.005760296247899532, -0.03427056223154068, 0.010737217031419277, -0.0941895842552185, -0.08040469139814377, 0.011879266239702702, -0.003020795527845621, 0.033319778740406036, -0.03387200087308884, -0.018242213875055313, 0.030901210382580757, 0.025525307282805443, -0.008841282688081264, -0.021059758961200714, -0.007173542398959398, -0.010478680953383446, -0.036916084587574005, 0.006590468809008598, 0.018970323726534843, 0.01208322960883379, 0.011581260710954666, -0.025285039097070694, 0.023700162768363953, 0.028191033750772476, 0.029349416494369507, -0.01033846102654934, 0.02017413266003132, 0.008415967226028442, -0.0004738466814160347, 0.01412126887589693, -0.0031410236842930317, -0.02067227102816105, -0.001052836887538433, -0.0018149161478504539, 0.006952843628823757, 0.02538297511637211, -0.07183253765106201, 0.00437682680785656, -0.009335732087492943, 0.00963686779141426, -0.0058111646212637424, 0.01698698103427887, 0.03620201721787453, -0.044668763875961304, -0.02192716859281063, -0.0021546129137277603, 0.04187623783946037, 0.00009243864769814536, 0.024671468883752823, 0.04558606073260307, 0.02034808322787285, -0.014549835585057735, -0.0033392836339771748, 0.004135779105126858, -0.043423596769571304, -0.0013244437286630273, -0.020518464967608452, -0.011525116860866547, 0.01591183990240097, 0.03361240774393082, 0.002805338939651847, -0.04959267005324364, -0.03843078762292862, 0.0007323403842747211, -0.041289784014225006, 0.011744922958314419, -0.044259265065193176, 0.030375046655535698, -0.00044544434058479965, 0.04258051514625549, -0.0136600062251091, -0.03178858757019043, 0.01800861768424511, -0.02601461298763752, -0.05509423464536667, 0.033721357583999634, 0.006293690763413906, 0.013951608911156654, 0.0253213569521904, -0.0008812498417682946, 0.030125200748443604, -0.030945276841521263, -0.01979914866387844, -0.020810097455978394, 0.03026438131928444, -0.022278394550085068, 0.0024317456409335136, -0.02438882365822792, -0.005133960396051407, 0.024326033890247345, 0.03785623610019684, 0.028585489839315414, -0.052553169429302216, 0.029917597770690918, -0.0014966544695198536, -0.03018977865576744, -0.02339865267276764, -0.06642646342515945, -0.030329544097185135, 0.028713284060359, 0.04080040380358696, 0.010822361335158348, 0.023620998486876488, -0.002758114133030176, -0.017361681908369064, -0.02622419036924839, 0.008890021592378616, 0.04408689960837364, 0.016924353316426277, -0.03508090600371361, -0.02916455641388893, 0.004770399536937475, 0.004443333484232426, 0.06600919365882874, -0.005557742435485125, 0.03526012971997261, 0.05985613167285919, 0.004550367593765259, -0.05146808177232742, 0.034362491220235825, 0.06418778747320175, 0.03249321132898331, -0.03846003860235214, -0.021959912031888962, 0.02578217349946499, -0.001235170173458755, -0.01680063270032406, 0.02986360900104046, 0.024494916200637817, 0.0023253955878317356, -0.026861639693379402, 0.04702490195631981, 0.03156449273228645, -0.016817791387438774, 0.05080060288310051, 0.016153430566191673, 0.050298068672418594, 0.023148804903030396, -0.06870177388191223, 0.017235340550541878, 0.054430898278951645, 0.02050812542438507, -0.0034870558883994818, -0.004609306808561087, -0.05835135281085968, 0.02049601450562477, 0.03850464150309563, 0.06411891430616379, -0.032784681767225266, -0.028922749683260918, -0.041950855404138565, -0.01063484139740467, 0.02001877687871456, -0.030904991552233696, 0.0317259356379509, -0.03773448243737221, 0.014114600606262684, -0.00377034954726696, -0.01775309070944786, -0.04508249834179878, 0.003623494179919362, 0.0031311726197600365, -0.001439928077161312, -0.02846635691821575, 0.027410609647631645, -0.020214172080159187, 0.042251672595739365, 0.05540664494037628, 0.016749780625104904, -0.013793915510177612, -0.010527361184358597, 0.01938849315047264, 0.013826270587742329, -0.027229374274611473, -0.041977863758802414, 0.04710971564054489, 0.023504696786403656, 0.010981542989611626, 0.06336023658514023, -0.0006657353369519114, -0.03872155025601387, 0.004440953955054283, 0.02740618586540222, 0.01842327043414116, 0.0018496812554076314, -0.00906432420015335, 0.07640045136213303, 0.027074892073869705, 0.026500148698687553, 0.0683702751994133, 0.04538184776902199, -0.005543402396142483, -0.0007998835062608123, -0.004931729752570391, -0.017266051843762398, -0.030779235064983368, -0.02809884026646614, -0.030176743865013123, 0.00864835549145937, -0.006891652010381222, 0.03229210153222084, -0.030172498896718025, -0.008993237279355526, -0.05438317731022835, -0.005766541697084904, 0.001356912893243134, -0.0043361554853618145, -0.0357293076813221, -0.01930195465683937, -0.0126567417755723, 0.011719479225575924, -0.014121766202151775, -0.017587624490261078, 0.017760874703526497, -0.03337839990854263, -0.02522895857691765, 0.019995667040348053, -0.03545421361923218, 0.017797507345676422, -0.02544313110411167, -0.014912508428096771, -0.003937762230634689, -0.01850387267768383, 0.020489715039730072, -0.005392654333263636, 0.023379109799861908, -0.04032277688384056, -0.021189887076616287, 0.010349187068641186, 0.02127453126013279, 0.010984761640429497, 0.011128658428788185, -0.0026585909072309732, 0.043760523200035095, -0.0075009530410170555, 0.010389747098088264, -0.0648583471775055, -0.08104803413152695, 0.020107997581362724, -0.023617936298251152, 0.014365136623382568, -0.023829009383916855, 0.009659381583333015, -0.0427614189684391, -0.025226300582289696, -0.0292217917740345, 0.012580323964357376, -0.02398357354104519, 0.0008836028282530606, 0.005784655921161175, 0.04075385630130768, 0.010288354940712452, 0.05360526964068413, -0.027973540127277374, 0.031781647354364395, -0.04400261491537094, 0.01284447219222784, 0.0007471072021871805, -0.016773471608757973, -0.01830470748245716, -0.0016716080717742443, -0.01215643435716629, -0.027522791177034378, 0.022642692551016808, -0.021515248343348503, -0.060581982135772705, 0.0189705528318882, 0.002118651522323489, -0.03295910730957985, -0.05269297957420349, -0.004449773114174604, -0.026883408427238464, -0.009638719260692596, -0.003646318567916751, 0.028681425377726555, -0.03432545065879822, 0.0035658106207847595, -0.002605259884148836, -0.014523927122354507, -0.10032516717910767, -0.03196365013718605, 0.08406508713960648, 0.06410533934831619, 0.013454606756567955, 0.0005374120664782822, -0.009448391385376453, 0.04803479090332985, -0.010171828791499138, -0.006962914485484362, -0.001153843360953033, 0.033744581043720245, -0.04779161512851715, -0.022452522069215775, -0.028965702280402184, 0.039145298302173615, 0.05277129262685776, -0.036554865539073944, 0.0763688012957573, 0.03560120239853859, -0.005117874592542648, -0.041240256279706955, -0.03013983555138111, 0.005649669095873833, 0.029558934271335602, -0.015577052719891071, 0.039719756692647934, 0.02620011568069458, -0.00491239782422781, 0.02961215190589428, 0.019455229863524437, 0.009560825303196907, 0.029415661469101906, -0.008383466862142086, 0.008043884299695492, -0.024438459426164627, -0.007815058343112469, -0.07074428349733353, 0.02084292843937874, -0.025310566648840904, 0.017158618196845055, -0.02357562445104122, -0.037858959287405014, 0.05418376997113228, 0.020429013296961784, -0.001644199131987989, -0.06817866116762161, -0.03704819083213806, -0.04257883504033089, 0.0014118719846010208, 0.03620757907629013, -0.01983022503554821, 0.040496766567230225, -0.0172929298132658, 0.03175695240497589, -0.006469105836004019, 0.035947058349847794, -0.03244926407933235, -0.05545658990740776, -0.012781282886862755, -0.01856159418821335, -0.03845536336302757, 0.028090381994843483, -0.0004803782794624567, -0.03393745422363281, 0.021913394331932068, -0.03877886384725571, 0.0272561963647604, 0.010487980209290981, 0.06055769324302673, 0.016011478379368782, 0.04691385105252266, 0.017461543902754784, -0.01426716335117817, 0.04187518358230591, 0.024891169741749763, 0.10680725425481796, 0.06045537441968918, 0.04211382195353508, -0.05875728651881218, 0.026995202526450157, -0.0018919581780210137, -0.015582405962049961, -0.07303229719400406, 0.026904944330453873, -0.003486864734441042, -0.027027644217014313, 0.015482367016375065, 0.02496561035513878, 0.024271177127957344, 0.004236242268234491, 0.04496721550822258, -0.04303479194641113, -0.05214608833193779, 0.0011805108515545726, 0.033380430191755295, 0.02765057608485222, -0.03185634687542915, -0.02411258965730667, 0.0013774633407592773, -0.010615624487400055, -0.031504519283771515, -0.0010523294331505895, 0.028524812310934067, -0.0075019123032689095, -0.008005902171134949, -0.036249835044145584, 0.03447076678276062, 0.010379385203123093, -0.0002378431090619415, -0.031924836337566376, -0.014009250327944756, 0.03814856708049774, -0.05194656178355217, 0.00166650942992419, -0.006785600911825895, -0.028949785977602005, -0.016796348616480827, 0.027219481766223907, 0.0030994468834251165, -0.04629914090037346, 0.02349586971104145, 0.011552856303751469, 0.055824536830186844, 0.023491621017456055, -0.00913875550031662, -0.025681961327791214, 0.0156021723523736, 0.028828905895352364, -0.036694590002298355, -0.03754480928182602, 0.020422376692295074, 0.032994091510772705, -0.04769865423440933, -0.010527165606617928, 0.001419189153239131, 0.006053459364920855, -0.01700611226260662, 0.011949307285249233, 0.03501658886671066, -0.06440413743257523, -0.0012295925989747047, -0.013228878378868103, 0.06764492392539978, 0.02195814810693264, -0.006815643049776554, 0.0014449472073465586, -0.005378329195082188, -0.019610853865742683, -0.013967158272862434, 0.0231363233178854, -0.001554507645778358, -0.028181875124573708, -0.008576307445764542, -0.007062855176627636, -0.038298968225717545, -0.030017917975783348, -0.021843673661351204, 0.002662220038473606, 0.024704402312636375, -0.05835416913032532, -0.003712969133630395, 0.001723590074107051, 0.04524744674563408, -0.0209234356880188, -0.023779865354299545, -0.026098592206835747, 0.07068850100040436, 0.005820568185299635, -0.04729388281702995, -0.047345612198114395, 0.00902410876005888, -0.01728346012532711, -0.02875400334596634, -0.0004492320877034217, 0.03452194109559059, -0.01308755949139595, 0.049465078860521317, 0.014894106425344944, 0.045125048607587814, -0.04067332297563553, 0.032120294868946075, 0.026224438101053238, -0.05065301060676575, 0.00690173264592886, 0.0488574355840683, 0.01702352613210678, -0.0013675023801624775, -0.0323183611035347, -0.03715943917632103, -0.023017263039946556, -0.014072665944695473, -0.04997903108596802, -0.04253716766834259, -0.02689361199736595, 0.004226852674037218, 0.0013490174897015095, -0.024793926626443863, -0.019487541168928146, -0.03950948640704155, 0.015461704693734646, -0.019990509375929832, -0.04448544606566429, 0.01822184957563877, 0.012951250188052654, 0.005933900363743305, 0.04441968724131584, 0.027003342285752296, -0.008232715539634228, 0.008023460395634174, -0.04518738016486168, -0.00322604738175869, 0.0006554872961714864, 0.060212183743715286, 0.0027460039127618074, -0.037686917930841446, 0.007740096654742956, -0.04728787764906883, 0.002258064690977335, -0.0007071747677400708, -0.025780530646443367, 0.05466781184077263, 0.022645356133580208, 0.0024931933730840683, -0.018540138378739357, 0.08418590575456619, 0.011083253659307957, 0.008975211530923843, 0.01752588525414467, 0.020768320187926292, -0.00627017579972744, -0.004476977977901697, 0.003424412803724408, 0.019042007625102997, -0.021990956738591194, 0.024370821192860603, 0.04609348624944687, -0.00551994051784277, -0.016577912494540215, 0.011732379905879498, -0.006209838204085827, -0.001368544646538794, 0.0020546005107462406, 0.00843526516109705, 0.03358342498540878, 0.07305452227592468, -0.0118706114590168, 0.02819322794675827, 0.007801066618412733, 0.029983045533299446, -0.05443262681365013, -0.017135977745056152, 0.014015564695000648, 0.020861245691776276, 0.033280663192272186, -0.05180606618523598, 0.06310593336820602, -0.0004120350640732795, -0.03903086856007576, -0.013681183569133282, 0.004656374920159578, 0.02531680278480053, -0.03868662565946579, -0.04798891767859459, 0.024284616112709045, 0.0022855845745652914, 0.03639255464076996, 0.020374681800603867, 0.03082874044775963, 0.016918282955884933, -0.043535735458135605, -0.03740952908992767, 0.015497013926506042, -0.007197165861725807, 0.004185647238045931, -0.06782189756631851, 0.029277972877025604, -0.050673652440309525, -0.04864174500107765, 0.02542399801313877, 0.015062868595123291, 0.007209676783531904, -0.016480006277561188, 0.04657349735498428, -0.0033657371532171965, 0.04372710734605789, 0.039707716554403305, 0.00999551359564066, 0.032692279666662216, 0.005679486319422722, 0.017712805420160294, 0.0101116131991148, 0.017706479877233505, 0.002205002587288618, 0.016024896875023842, 0.010233555920422077, -0.054446227848529816, 0.017132265493273735, -0.024520788341760635, 0.03861392289400101, -0.034789346158504486, -0.02096184529364109, 0.021718908101320267, -0.06036176532506943, -0.0015426769386976957, -0.05730624869465828, 0.00023128748580347747, 0.034763019531965256, 0.01833519898355007, -0.02836688794195652, -0.019943758845329285, -0.01508481428027153, -0.031086178496479988, 0.008984256535768509, -0.016041968017816544, 0.04951373115181923, -0.06190263852477074, -0.02281533181667328, 0.006456241011619568, -0.03083152323961258, -0.019411372020840645, 0.019932279363274574, -0.029426276683807373, 0.04478327929973602, -0.05260609835386276, -0.02140970155596733, 0.020284565165638924, -0.02663940191268921, 0.0065531544387340546, -0.07152055948972702, 0.021980296820402145, 0.037696611136198044, -0.009305770508944988, -0.005824838299304247, -0.009061898104846478, -0.04084286466240883, -0.04373715817928314, 0.04473192244768143, 0.01403964776545763, -0.023967664688825607, -0.006112789269536734, 0.08955133706331253, 0.0010860365582630038, -0.0563347153365612, 0.03752809762954712, 0.003509248374029994, 0.013051935471594334, -0.017366722226142883, -0.010035332292318344, 0.016009153798222542, 0.013088553212583065, 0.02790859155356884, -0.01781916432082653, 0.01504960935562849, 0.03973416984081268, -0.015287126414477825, 0.016179034486413002, 0.003708292031660676, -0.029736407101154327, 0.046964339911937714, 0.0014875546330586076, 0.005415024701505899, 0.04293686896562576, 0.013660144992172718, -0.052956800907850266, 0.0058512138202786446, -0.00016726208559703082, 0.008456975221633911, -0.03225608915090561, -0.0007569016306661069, 0.006710019428282976, -0.028451282531023026, 0.011487524025142193, 0.031776197254657745, -0.04960743337869644, 0.03149117901921272, 0.03822574019432068, 0.04812071844935417, 0.03300365060567856, -0.01160592120140791, 0.0018207941902801394, 0.02262960746884346, -0.054838113486766815, 0.029083482921123505, 0.030813533812761307, 0.05372161045670509, -0.0024864140432327986, 0.015393522568047047, 0.033660728484392166, -0.01575756072998047, 0.018261734396219254, -0.011784588918089867, -0.015597842633724213, -0.006747829262167215, 0.009325312450528145, 0.05661844089627266, 0.03296872228384018, 0.018051069229841232, -0.0001699492713669315, 0.03852305933833122, 0.045537069439888, -0.03975478932261467, -0.013033494353294373, -0.03486700728535652, 0.021952148526906967, -0.03372190147638321, 0.04623671993613243, 0.01045035757124424, 0.007709300611168146, -0.008986115455627441, -0.006425372790545225, 0.00212360848672688, -0.04757085070014, -0.012594024650752544, -0.022034388035535812, 0.004305018112063408, -0.023935766890645027, 0.004598876461386681, 0.009022737853229046, -0.04091242328286171, -0.043853599578142166, -0.03169487044215202, 0.033487651497125626, 0.0591149665415287, 0.009203179739415646, -0.04535830393433571, -0.022251179441809654, -0.047565292567014694, 0.0578894168138504, -0.05017338693141937, -0.04459994658827782, -0.030042538419365883, -0.01437830738723278, -0.007370053790509701, -0.017625905573368073 ]
<p>Which statistical tools are best suited for this problem:</p> <p>Team A goes and measures 3 magnitudes in 200 locations (let's imagine the volume of a room, the insulation coefficient and the average temperature outside the room). For each room they calculate the energy this room will consume to keep the desired temperature for a week.</p> <p>So after the measurement campaign they have measured these 3 magnitudes in 200 different rooms (each room is only measured once). So the data looks like:</p> <pre><code> (Room_volume, r_coefficient, T, estimated_energy) </code></pre> <p>Team A is assumed to be very good at getting their results. Now team B measures the same 200 rooms, and calculates all the estimated energies for each room.</p> <p>How should we measure the performance of team B vs team A (where A is assumed to be accurate)? </p> <p>Forgetting the physics, as it's just an illustrative example, how do you compare the accuracy of a measurement campaign measuring 3 values from which a 4th one can be calculated deterministically? Note that none of these values are distributed in any special way among the 200 samples (they don't look gaussian)</p> <p>I started looking at the distribution of errors, so:</p> <pre><code> {Estimated_energy_Ai - Estimated_energy_Bi} with i = 1..200 </code></pre> <p>And seeing how many results are within a standard deviation. What other tools are appropriate?</p>
74,341
[ -0.03679261356592178, -0.001433515571989119, -0.055022966116666794, -0.01900767907500267, 0.05299372971057892, 0.04651724919676781, -0.0013812760589644313, -0.04068545997142792, 0.03143613040447235, 0.011903311125934124, 0.06218590959906578, 0.02422509714961052, 0.03345387056469917, 0.02141011320054531, 0.021558569744229317, -0.027329236268997192, 0.0041574230417609215, -0.0026112571358680725, 0.0011237236903980374, -0.03234618529677391, 0.012334068305790424, 0.020723169669508934, -0.014995362609624863, 0.010825787670910358, -0.045718543231487274, 0.039867497980594635, 0.012131388299167156, -0.03491334989666939, -0.028117677196860313, 0.02150941640138626, -0.07255392521619797, -0.032767511904239655, -0.0015446273609995842, 0.035076454281806946, 0.0254575964063406, 0.005285496357828379, -0.003992665093392134, -0.01833990588784218, -0.04157949984073639, 0.032324254512786865, -0.04435146600008011, 0.0061884718015789986, -0.0028515749145299196, 0.023592138662934303, 0.011480879969894886, 0.01780897192656994, -0.004965370986610651, -0.03995342552661896, 0.01891191117465496, -0.05125918984413147, 0.06301639974117279, 0.020800858736038208, 0.05423251539468765, 0.034906018525362015, -0.02177274227142334, -0.0176700372248888, 0.043223340064287186, 0.06004556640982628, 0.0020239895675331354, -0.06355282664299011, -0.020884845405817032, 0.011711071245372295, 0.014592853374779224, -0.009651350788772106, -0.031898755580186844, 0.0163110438734293, -0.013321484439074993, -0.029994521290063858, 0.04021456465125084, -0.0004940674407407641, 0.03176962956786156, 0.010794190689921379, 0.030055105686187744, 0.003935045562684536, 0.03538552671670914, 0.009996498934924603, -0.028871800750494003, 0.03067515604197979, 0.05002421885728836, 0.03607172518968582, -0.02027510479092598, -0.006294777151197195, 0.008502977900207043, 0.0525951124727726, 0.013500870205461979, -0.011884626932442188, 0.030786313116550446, -0.06373068690299988, 0.009340171702206135, -0.02274351753294468, 0.007383706048130989, 0.010673572309315205, 0.0373271219432354, 0.029087813571095467, 0.0018294042674824595, 0.00882659014314413, -0.018499311059713364, 0.0451575443148613, -0.03165459260344505, -0.003267425112426281, 0.023772601038217545, 0.00009291937749367207, 0.00828611385077238, 0.029414577409625053, -0.04281938076019287, -0.019382432103157043, -0.022904442623257637, 0.015921901911497116, -0.012010626494884491, -0.010557910427451134, -0.04326169565320015, 0.012699106708168983, 0.004338093567639589, 0.02671612612903118, 0.023559900000691414, -0.04052980616688728, 0.005532648414373398, -0.002690443303436041, 0.0703398734331131, 0.05464385822415352, 0.04289032518863678, -0.0038047684356570244, 0.025593265891075134, -0.03847162425518036, -0.04057495668530464, 0.01941029354929924, 0.015423658303916454, -0.015324346721172333, -0.07739309221506119, 0.05313677340745926, -0.011068747378885746, 0.0025590965524315834, 0.03265075385570526, -0.03783280774950981, 0.010892456397414207, -0.028975266963243484, -0.0908893421292305, -0.054524071514606476, 0.027192678302526474, -0.015639526769518852, 0.0025363948661834, -0.06969267129898071, -0.015469925478100777, 0.05210641026496887, 0.03607027605175972, 0.017633946612477303, 0.024488821625709534, 0.000718343653716147, 0.026544764637947083, -0.017259277403354645, -0.03397586569190025, -0.009287496097385883, -0.017524244263768196, 0.002868897747248411, -0.009985861368477345, -0.06071305274963379, 0.03835749998688698, -0.017274726182222366, -0.042953915894031525, 0.010686456225812435, 0.03228503465652466, 0.042757198214530945, -0.012272321619093418, 0.010730423964560032, 0.024760065600275993, -0.0062489896081388, 0.07215402275323868, 0.02876942791044712, 0.033604223281145096, 0.0143912173807621, 0.007403872441500425, 0.0020306939259171486, 0.01690744422376156, -0.023297807201743126, 0.08015725016593933, -0.0394214391708374, 0.019851982593536377, -0.029864728450775146, 0.017039136961102486, 0.02965640276670456, -0.06379389762878418, -0.06697971373796463, 0.030088311061263084, -0.018355872482061386, 0.032426513731479645, 0.013891003094613552, -0.010540940798819065, -0.007287559565156698, 0.08262106776237488, -0.04382389411330223, -0.03992364555597305, -0.07824742794036865, -0.016599835827946663, 0.021951548755168915, -0.03349331021308899, 0.021861262619495392, 0.012140671722590923, 0.007042010314762592, -0.007027335464954376, 0.0021626350935548544, 0.0018310301238670945, -0.00636298069730401, 0.0590386725962162, -0.01970932073891163, 0.05530150607228279, 0.0458952970802784, 0.051965080201625824, -0.03074343316257, 0.06530535966157913, -0.02814609557390213, -0.042459871619939804, -0.02723265253007412, -0.03961554169654846, -0.006823610980063677, 0.04397047683596611, -0.04252360761165619, -0.007120619062334299, -0.010099591687321663, -0.05574799329042435, -0.00727738905698061, -0.03047148510813713, 0.07912571728229523, 0.0624205581843853, -0.02385999821126461, -0.005816493649035692, 0.03598383814096451, 0.00230395351536572, 0.024990137666463852, 0.0020079209934920073, -0.004817635752260685, -0.09449511766433716, 0.003088859375566244, 0.02032591961324215, -0.004657760262489319, -0.03815596550703049, 0.005266985390335321, 0.06001883000135422, 0.008136044256389141, 0.006613319274038076, -0.0008298202883452177, -0.021471139043569565, -0.008465289138257504, 0.055266235023736954, 0.038193438202142715, 0.039262525737285614, 0.03345702961087227, -0.010207416489720345, 0.03208177536725998, -0.0035792915150523186, 0.0009238126804120839, 0.025202933698892593, 0.03675411641597748, -0.026488009840250015, 0.008383039385080338, 0.006378486752510071, -0.01789107546210289, 0.003973518963903189, -0.013863851316273212, 0.0335986465215683, 0.021722935140132904, -0.01501399464905262, 0.0055482275784015656, -0.014390231110155582, -0.032892193645238876, 0.03469308465719223, 0.011276652105152607, -0.00921536237001419, -0.000015271631127689034, 0.03928399085998535, -0.002238580724224448, 0.026733318343758583, -0.017653444781899452, -0.014421120285987854, -0.05365098640322685, 0.0013180231908336282, 0.05431429296731949, -0.007972878403961658, 0.014206700958311558, -0.016131503507494926, -0.013613469898700714, -0.0050637866370379925, -0.008778756484389305, 0.023538589477539062, -0.003946605604141951, -0.030541766434907913, 0.020571673288941383, -0.01571510173380375, -0.015408739447593689, 0.005457024089992046, -0.023170752450823784, -0.04319759085774422, 0.06934945285320282, 0.01319066435098648, -0.04445600137114525, 0.0020391985308378935, -0.012621180154383183, -0.0011592095252126455, -0.010520239360630512, -0.02323189750313759, 0.046316903084516525, -0.0013018798781558871, -0.04582110419869423, 0.060514021664857864, -0.023731280118227005, 0.009646088816225529, -0.007859812118113041, -0.046177010983228683, 0.0012243461096659303, 0.017956577241420746, 0.043954998254776, 0.053286757320165634, -0.035583674907684326, -0.05555757135152817, -0.05660412088036537, -0.06303534656763077, -0.004400067031383514, 0.0014214501716196537, 0.04285532981157303, 0.01011874433606863, -0.005799515638500452, 0.07442606985569, 0.056948110461235046, -0.024406088516116142, 0.019046036526560783, -0.036114826798439026, -0.0057039642706513405, -0.02715304307639599, 0.04087968170642853, -0.00957704707980156, -0.006117168348282576, 0.00004829456520383246, -0.005816000048071146, 0.026148971170186996, 0.029174357652664185, -0.004210499580949545, -0.011775768361985683, -0.0011606111656874418, 0.05491558089852333, -0.004000972956418991, 0.07223094254732132, 0.005260784644633532, -0.004237790126353502, 0.0270317941904068, -0.028713347390294075, 0.00608034897595644, 0.017042744904756546, -0.051082510501146317, 0.004031740128993988, -0.021116942167282104, 0.02108100801706314, -0.05481166020035744, 0.013296227902173996, 0.007526550907641649, -0.030395444482564926, 0.015141771174967289, 0.04014568403363228, 0.03479614108800888, -0.011023662984371185, -0.009400014765560627, 0.03452996909618378, 0.054891444742679596, -0.025658637285232544, -0.026342956349253654, -0.02274896390736103, -0.005738666281104088, 0.007921203039586544, -0.0068709333427250385, -0.06379922479391098, 0.051697928458452225, 0.01551373116672039, 0.03353678807616234, -0.027089593932032585, -0.047032155096530914, -0.027487192302942276, -0.06378011405467987, 0.00020501211110968143, -0.060453563928604126, 0.08685082942247391, 0.011059030890464783, 0.020611880347132683, 0.01759691908955574, -0.02741287834942341, 0.007986940443515778, -0.0208774134516716, -0.032218996435403824, 0.031454894691705704, 0.016342101618647575, -0.013295692391693592, 0.022258883342146873, -0.051559802144765854, 0.025091949850320816, -0.04913247004151344, 0.02070237137377262, 0.00841065589338541, 0.03897447884082794, -0.014862636104226112, -0.01944420114159584, -0.024255352094769478, -0.017147250473499298, 0.0008762011420913041, 0.0010207132436335087, -0.0003480212762951851, -0.008310451172292233, 0.058873485773801804, 0.005130552686750889, -0.01543542742729187, -0.04448733106255531, -0.018698675557971, 0.037609562277793884, -0.005340242758393288, 0.034564536064863205, 0.018680719658732414, 0.04235965013504028, -0.02280183508992195, 0.0059288740158081055, 0.015303757973015308, 0.023655584082007408, 0.02631714753806591, -0.013866215012967587, -0.02383873425424099, -0.016210906207561493, -0.022364763543009758, 0.050605326890945435, 0.013794862665235996, 0.019788391888141632, 0.013464689254760742, -0.004459071904420853, 0.05519698187708855, -0.052670471370220184, 0.019482523202896118, 0.0657973513007164, -0.022772712633013725, 0.014806689694523811, -0.05075117200613022, -0.03713076189160347, 0.01876899227499962, -0.026884708553552628, 0.03046610951423645, 0.003280997509136796, -0.007398671470582485, 0.008350354619324207, 0.031205708160996437, -0.009810356423258781, -0.064213328063488, 0.046161800622940063, 0.04132721573114395, -0.01229671761393547, 0.03887717425823212, -0.032863494008779526, 0.004664251580834389, 0.030702536925673485, 0.026567457243800163, 0.03551408648490906, -0.0073851621709764, -0.07550406455993652, 0.01717226766049862, 0.05500483885407448, 0.026492226868867874, -0.020613614469766617, -0.03335321322083473, -0.033700477331876755, 0.006457101088017225, 0.029315374791622162, -0.03769812360405922, 0.02294228971004486, -0.010452709160745144, 0.03967086970806122, -0.03458615392446518, -0.020877646282315254, -0.011310191825032234, -0.004414692055433989, -0.024226602166891098, 0.06045225262641907, 0.01721273735165596, -0.04326687380671501, -0.022657733410596848, 0.025467121973633766, 0.06050117686390877, 0.08126960694789886, -0.05148061364889145, -0.02127537690103054, -0.003477223915979266, 0.0027168269734829664, -0.003326831851154566, -0.03753669187426567, 0.023862255737185478, -0.0034975148737430573, 0.002323618857190013, 0.05198981240391731, -0.01668226718902588, -0.0653599202632904, 0.004560326226055622, 0.006203102879226208, -0.02666252665221691, -0.024581536650657654, -0.0109556894749403, 0.026310550048947334, 0.050051696598529816, 0.021388279274106026, 0.037364836782217026, 0.0010326210176572204, 0.017575353384017944, 0.018148966133594513, -0.010880893096327782, 0.038229234516620636, 0.00036823932896368206, 0.019873036071658134, -0.07197198271751404, -0.0011024052510038018, -0.008848886936903, 0.007521879393607378, 0.010458105243742466, 0.038443028926849365, -0.023087793961167336, -0.03862743452191353, 0.015013281255960464, 0.02337065152823925, -0.037625640630722046, -0.019433215260505676, -0.010331161320209503, -0.002360793761909008, 0.0027437638491392136, -0.014547844417393208, -0.0015839311527088284, -0.021366529166698456, 0.0038063456304371357, 0.014400710351765156, -0.04504627361893654, 0.051984403282403946, -0.061671819537878036, -0.00868388544768095, 0.013046907261013985, -0.0038228430785238743, -0.0027261143550276756, -0.004855578765273094, 0.036118049174547195, -0.005486592184752226, -0.018845226615667343, -0.045445334166288376, -0.008122715167701244, -0.005176476668566465, 0.005752971861511469, -0.02113560400903225, 0.0001157330407295376, -0.04290182515978813, -0.004765702877193689, -0.07858580350875854, -0.006556986831128597, 0.02164652943611145, 0.009380735456943512, 0.011127112433314323, -0.051209673285484314, -0.004501037765294313, 0.0014772559516131878, -0.009530371986329556, -0.01132444478571415, 0.053019847720861435, -0.002322982531040907, -0.0011259362800046802, -0.001962130656465888, 0.034881360828876495, 0.0639105811715126, -0.014387253671884537, -0.0164145827293396, 0.0033298409543931484, -0.012942974455654621, -0.043455157428979874, 0.020351773127913475, 0.007360379211604595, -0.036977618932724, -0.0004020670603495091, -0.0011113648070022464, 0.02116357907652855, 0.070780448615551, -0.013919752091169357, -0.021381128579378128, 0.0068029798567295074, 0.0034231110475957394, -0.030165525153279305, -0.03758219629526138, 0.03179142624139786, -0.008975252509117126, -0.005081709939986467, -0.02605636976659298, -0.004874187987297773, 0.0044136676006019115, 0.007867427542805672, 0.025121182203292847, 0.042449887841939926, -0.01731015369296074, 0.044998303055763245, 0.06783311814069748, 0.015770433470606804, 0.006315452978014946, 0.030501851812005043, 0.006015132647007704, 0.026317346841096878, 0.0015987650258466601, 0.01538768969476223, 0.018690451979637146, -0.019698869436979294, -0.002504906849935651, 0.009640483185648918, -0.043465506285429, 0.012297950685024261, 0.03689538687467575, -0.013265404850244522, 0.06947947293519974, 0.035464219748973846, 0.03908585384488106, -0.0009128664969466627, -0.061019688844680786, 0.004734349437057972, 0.023008866235613823, -0.008586576208472252, 0.031219452619552612, -0.016046660020947456, -0.03805195912718773, 0.04196684807538986, 0.03161196410655975, 0.016792206093668938, 0.020868835970759392, -0.014999660663306713, 0.04898520186543465, -0.03554666414856911, -0.0593348927795887, -0.0036946034524589777, 0.03143336996436119, -0.04292943701148033, -0.005182881839573383, -0.047760095447301865, 0.007938758470118046, 0.040197741240262985, 0.03857995942234993, -0.05945012345910072, -0.03812842071056366, -0.019886765629053116, -0.11847755312919617, 0.008299920707941055, 0.05244835093617439, 0.00811760313808918, 0.006905818358063698, 0.007023604586720467, 0.027004050090909004, -0.03164547309279442, 0.0270819291472435, -0.02251492440700531, -0.055651936680078506, -0.06385709345340729, 0.0016076730098575354, -0.052778854966163635, 0.06116386875510216, -0.01231016218662262, -0.015173784457147121, 0.0227962639182806, -0.005964669864624739, 0.014828551560640335, 0.023093704134225845, 0.00384786375798285, -0.004064674489200115, 0.03943687304854393, 0.002254331251606345, 0.029151426628232002, 0.009873912669718266, 0.0014373164158314466, 0.1077188029885292, 0.09152945876121521, 0.04947564750909805, -0.0355205237865448, 0.004880843684077263, 0.034534867852926254, -0.019595446065068245, -0.018266957253217697, 0.01888669840991497, 0.0035991559270769358, 0.010293140076100826, 0.009752335026860237, 0.01981128565967083, 0.018659330904483795, 0.008942925371229649, 0.026588337495923042, -0.006083486136049032, -0.007762500550597906, 0.007979345507919788, 0.03314611315727234, 0.018035827204585075, -0.02796110324561596, -0.015148649923503399, 0.015399802476167679, 0.0179506354033947, -0.012354902923107147, -0.0025419616140425205, -0.02809048630297184, -0.01656309887766838, 0.031129732728004456, -0.0168796107172966, 0.05291009321808815, -0.01449162233620882, 0.03691137582063675, 0.02033299021422863, 0.006431438960134983, -0.0018144421046599746, -0.05388765409588814, -0.0034279683604836464, 0.028149902820587158, 0.040086232125759125, -0.021637532860040665, -0.0055257538333535194, 0.043656591325998306, -0.046105124056339264, -0.0524318628013134, -0.056660231202840805, 0.017426500096917152, -0.028194235637784004, -0.03593210503458977, -0.00010376983846072108, -0.005537792574614286, -0.026397570967674255, -0.03795028477907181, 0.012569321319460869, 0.0054686833173036575, 0.005277971737086773, -0.05058206990361214, 0.0007572183385491371, -0.0011354860616847873, 0.04124176874756813, 0.00339276110753417, 0.02454313077032566, 0.04115522280335426, -0.012476800940930843, -0.03001409024000168, -0.004984072409570217, 0.08813530206680298, 0.0015609264373779297, 0.010126599110662937, 0.006389094516634941, -0.03602980822324753, -0.03653543442487717, -0.022443316876888275, 0.011960875242948532, 0.028603436425328255, 0.01829158328473568, -0.01497506070882082, -0.017055712640285492, -0.009871713817119598, -0.03611530363559723, -0.031426891684532166, -0.02714363858103752, -0.007858332246541977, -0.0481933169066906, -0.038510680198669434, 0.015709586441516876, 0.027870578691363335, 0.0264261607080698, 0.0011145363096147776, 0.021429941058158875, 0.04222040995955467, 0.01013860385864973, -0.03568221256136894, -0.02703873999416828, -0.007131020072847605, -0.057642385363578796, -0.011777062900364399, -0.0021665706299245358, 0.055499982088804245, 0.016585420817136765, -0.016256559640169144, 0.01567927747964859, 0.004069812595844269, -0.010246127843856812, -0.0012168402317911386, -0.007992248982191086, -0.049746304750442505, -0.016193430870771408, 0.010254551656544209, -0.025270486250519753, -0.038513656705617905, -0.0020728495437651873, -0.043041083961725235, 0.0030631935223937035, -0.0009137543383985758, 0.007308415602892637, -0.02939283661544323, 0.003218694357201457, 0.0014001225354149938, 0.013346933759748936, -0.007192347198724747, 0.0013752856757491827, 0.007656826172024012, -0.017767349258065224, -0.03944949805736542, -0.005142211448401213, -0.016916049644351006, -0.0012242203811183572, -0.020433947443962097, -0.00008154114766512066, 0.006529717240482569, -0.053861405700445175, 0.00648617185652256, -0.026052309200167656, -0.0013240536209195852, -0.0221911258995533, 0.031183380633592606, -0.026669545099139214, -0.014959837310016155, 0.032754991203546524, -0.008444615639746189, -0.046748772263526917, 0.004359266720712185, 0.009201224893331528, 0.0032290376257151365, 0.012020062655210495, -0.010261868126690388, 0.004587598145008087, 0.04846175014972687, -0.029645143076777458, -0.006008185911923647, -0.026957573369145393, -0.020831486210227013, -0.007091294974088669, -0.008467404171824455, 0.05988514795899391, -0.026387346908450127, 0.004063403233885765, 0.019347211346030235, 0.03784579783678055, -0.007180222310125828, 0.008641126565635204, -0.007770191412419081, -0.032079268246889114, -0.0013315699761733413, 0.014924595132470131, -0.019289067015051842, -0.018030021339654922, 0.06939356029033661, -0.013248415663838387, 0.006921017076820135, -0.006024936679750681, 0.03277991712093353, -0.06322023272514343, -0.03242506459355354, -0.0036040404811501503, -0.0285707525908947, 0.012884100899100304, -0.05633310601115227, 0.04040007293224335, 0.05319255590438843, -0.03210783004760742, 0.04914545267820358, -0.031586065888404846, 0.004604728426784277, -0.04241568595170975, 0.04698379337787628, -0.032720793038606644, 0.010388052091002464, 0.007649525068700314, 0.0143284285441041, 0.012311381287872791, 0.04606519266963005, 0.015983371064066887, -0.027159713208675385, -0.012239793315529823, 0.02349500171840191, 0.01657399721443653, -0.03886185958981514, 0.032010361552238464, 0.00046069445670582354, -0.008151678368449211, 0.009037825278937817, 0.0023699444718658924, 0.00839637778699398, -0.011333775706589222, 0.012623910792171955, -0.03800640255212784, 0.059802111238241196, 0.02984112687408924, -0.0013255415251478553, 0.004880466498434544, 0.0027332131285220385, 0.026353392750024796, 0.033530693501234055, -0.014462155289947987, 0.0291085597127676, 0.039186716079711914, 0.0027197017334401608, -0.017570827156305313, 0.04325366020202637, 0.02485400065779686, -0.0376347154378891, 0.008451118133962154, -0.013846278190612793, 0.02323811873793602, -0.036228928714990616, 0.0054751206189394, -0.044950589537620544, -0.013415488414466381, 0.05321850627660751, 0.034119121730327606, -0.030917678028345108, -0.015330475755035877, -0.019649522379040718, -0.014526118524372578, 0.0027339605148881674, -0.0010091728763654828, -0.014659385196864605, -0.03065563179552555, -0.002112413290888071, -0.0020054099150002003, -0.01329894084483385, -0.01757139526307583, -0.03395560011267662, -0.08190883696079254, 0.03835365176200867, 0.013686619699001312, 0.011032119393348694, 0.023518403992056847, -0.0007795669953338802, 0.010632251389324665, -0.12036784738302231, 0.08045985549688339, -0.026867281645536423, -0.02414541132748127, -0.02227417193353176, 0.003942475188523531, -0.04944175109267235, 0.005663575138896704, 0.07334347069263458, 0.036012597382068634, -0.019784370437264442, 0.009646495804190636, -0.004604943096637726, 0.0020186600740998983, -0.05637244135141373, 0.03465697169303894, -0.011423896998167038, 0.0009179104818031192, -0.047438569366931915, -0.033153463155031204, -0.008218871429562569, -0.007482530549168587, 0.02515534497797489, -0.00539633072912693, 0.021519679576158524, -0.023389354348182678, -0.0071597034111619, 0.016005922108888626, -0.020712200552225113, 0.017260512337088585, 0.0174717977643013, 0.006498340982943773, 0.035276032984256744, 0.04322420433163643, 0.0066091930493712425, -0.04579967260360718, 0.027010899037122726, -0.014506414532661438, -0.01620926521718502, 0.01925002783536911, -0.0023738930467516184, -0.0054461294785141945, -0.061724986881017685, 0.009712113998830318, -0.01142828818410635, -0.08013100177049637, 0.010222358629107475, 0.00472384924069047, 0.0011878248769789934, 0.04399627819657326, -0.023082608357071877, 0.01815984398126602, 0.02173970453441143, 0.02651832066476345, -0.02257572114467621, 0.04798782616853714, 0.026919793337583542, 0.0196300707757473, 0.027583008632063866, 0.03151673078536987, -0.03177092969417572, 0.02584121748805046, 0.008114049211144447, 0.04359660670161247, -0.00895246397703886, -0.01226090732961893, 0.04274684563279152, 0.006398962810635567, -0.06521804630756378, 0.013347217813134193, -0.006220972631126642, 0.03323984891176224, -0.031887251883745193, -0.011840284802019596, -0.03395891934633255, -0.0023319583851844072, -0.020276522263884544, -0.0028692507185041904, -0.008894373662769794, 0.06529627740383148, -0.005295060575008392, 0.038370195776224136, -0.015320091508328915, 0.011242464184761047, -0.015773683786392212, -0.01994108036160469, 0.01329792570322752, -0.00658163707703352, 0.0009937217691913247, -0.0175021942704916, -0.01691104844212532, -0.006891792640089989, -0.010871895588934422, 0.04072241857647896, 0.0521571971476078, 0.03527634218335152, -0.02011415921151638, -0.04846642538905144, 0.005177779123187065, 0.039612025022506714, -0.03680238127708435, -0.011574617587029934, -0.014462033286690712, 0.03848971426486969, 0.010549042373895645, -0.0148389283567667 ]
<p>I want to perform a repeated measures ANOVA in SPSS using the descriptive statistics. So my input is: </p> <pre><code>Descriptive Statistics Mean Std. Deviation N M1MI 3,8000 1,03280 10 M1MA 5,3000 2,16282 10 M2MI 7,0000 1,88562 10 M2MA 2,2000 1,54919 10 M3MI 6,2000 1,03280 10 M3MA 4,2000 1,75119 10 M4MI 4,7000 ,67495 10 M4MA 4,9000 1,19722 10 </code></pre> <p>Does anyone know how I have to adjust my syntax? </p> <p>My design is as follows:</p> <pre><code>Dependent variables: Progress1, Progress2, Progress3, Progress4 Within subject factor 2: M (I/A) </code></pre>
37,190
[ -0.029916666448116302, -0.0036013093777000904, 0.012219846248626709, 0.04509883001446724, 0.03563603386282921, 0.04363338649272919, 0.012062772177159786, -0.05116065964102745, 0.002568477299064398, -0.00813973043113947, 0.05542951822280884, 0.00028006520005874336, 0.05945868045091629, 0.006560005247592926, 0.058843713253736496, -0.0005215417477302253, -0.0008702220511622727, -0.01609245128929615, -0.004454967100173235, 0.02063618414103985, 0.0017885552952066064, 0.01452022697776556, 0.0066133467480540276, 0.0095632029697299, -0.008879146538674831, 0.007571234833449125, 0.043967898935079575, -0.026569249108433723, 0.013412170112133026, 0.028394391760230064, -0.045769598335027695, -0.035194236785173416, 0.03923489525914192, 0.00797602441161871, 0.03924566134810448, -0.012107454240322113, -0.0331159345805645, -0.0115609560161829, 0.004192254040390253, 0.010915623977780342, -0.019914204254746437, 0.007293411530554295, -0.014961402863264084, 0.044408876448869705, -0.004750849213451147, -0.0032839705236256123, 0.003518039593473077, 0.0021393897477537394, 0.022246474400162697, -0.03385321423411369, 0.08608219772577286, -0.014022178016602993, 0.061835240572690964, 0.046339139342308044, -0.02219942770898342, 0.020387979224324226, 0.054657772183418274, 0.047056894749403, 0.013261297717690468, -0.07348321378231049, 0.007593225687742233, -0.026996098458766937, 0.03707094490528107, 0.00019010335381608456, -0.04841142147779465, -0.018899602815508842, -0.03055611066520214, -0.00026585612795315683, 0.07407401502132416, -0.03160440921783447, 0.05477038770914078, 0.009267796762287617, 0.03757012262940407, -0.019608011469244957, -0.00006347105227177963, -0.031059104949235916, 0.020420895889401436, -0.023502442985773087, 0.03861396387219429, 0.04348631203174591, 0.022217418998479843, 0.023904813453555107, 0.012841730378568172, 0.03276260942220688, 0.02353965863585472, -0.038290150463581085, 0.037148747593164444, -0.0040800911374390125, 0.024711109697818756, 0.04025108367204666, 0.0006820334238000214, 0.00521114282310009, 0.06020969897508621, 0.05523906648159027, -0.0039574396796524525, 0.014902728609740734, -0.02911035530269146, 0.05645178258419037, -0.006921438034623861, 0.021624242886900902, -0.01131698302924633, -0.0073357028886675835, 0.029902992770075798, -0.003359839553013444, -0.05993274226784706, 0.030129602178931236, -0.039017170667648315, 0.009357625618577003, 0.01686529628932476, -0.04256941378116608, 0.007522153668105602, -0.01061338372528553, 0.02046906389296055, -0.010421598330140114, 0.013474058359861374, -0.03331029415130615, -0.02538120560348034, 0.04426597058773041, 0.0186013113707304, 0.08918918669223785, 0.031417328864336014, -0.015607624314725399, 0.04761449992656708, -0.011482776142656803, -0.03569581359624863, -0.015032041817903519, 0.03398101404309273, -0.014516892842948437, 0.0030275157187134027, 0.05873746797442436, -0.025132890790700912, 0.01366866659373045, 0.04818001016974449, -0.007537349127233028, 0.02112407237291336, 0.008081614971160889, -0.07121675461530685, -0.07721354067325592, 0.03504283353686333, 0.010588022880256176, -0.013456215150654316, -0.04854876175522804, 0.009853482246398926, 0.025034664198756218, 0.045662637799978256, 0.021856004372239113, 0.005597640760242939, 0.02937258407473564, 0.019264154136180878, 0.028902312740683556, 0.006378088146448135, -0.011653799563646317, -0.007326554972678423, -0.0397011823952198, 0.010198892094194889, -0.05235884711146355, 0.0010319965658709407, -0.004280407913029194, -0.0037425437476485968, 0.010967031121253967, 0.02554122731089592, 0.021415933966636658, 0.006037767510861158, 0.045164044946432114, -0.0033239307813346386, -0.004353582859039307, 0.05496325343847275, -0.015397011302411556, 0.041989512741565704, 0.028750445693731308, 0.006114569958299398, -0.007546905893832445, -0.03218128904700279, 0.03185386210680008, 0.05718553438782692, -0.04237617552280426, -0.015563703142106533, -0.004953589756041765, 0.006661043036729097, 0.033355146646499634, -0.055206116288900375, -0.03635809198021889, -0.040060319006443024, -0.013294827193021774, 0.03716906160116196, 0.019273940473794937, 0.011487864889204502, 0.025005998089909554, 0.015667932108044624, -0.029341738671064377, -0.028952987864613533, -0.06870492547750473, 0.021306274458765984, 0.006527500692754984, -0.04721500724554062, -0.010077496990561485, -0.04324236139655113, -0.0019885955844074488, 0.02593681961297989, -0.023117177188396454, -0.027562137693166733, -0.02827509492635727, 0.025158222764730453, -0.02058371901512146, 0.023601002991199493, 0.02607068233191967, 0.045650579035282135, -0.01892542839050293, 0.06365106999874115, -0.030419593676924706, 0.01764596812427044, 0.015693102031946182, 0.009678661823272705, 0.0014061009278520942, 0.019971976056694984, -0.02842618152499199, 0.0004226428864058107, 0.04091591015458107, -0.044450100511312485, 0.03973987326025963, -0.04609480872750282, 0.06678099185228348, 0.0862196534872055, 0.006300050299614668, 0.015636522322893143, -0.014476374723017216, 0.023047398775815964, 0.052209991961717606, -0.044120267033576965, -0.03278132155537605, -0.01783730834722519, -0.015917912125587463, 0.0022809715010225773, -0.012549521401524544, -0.07246294617652893, 0.013383845798671246, 0.06116252765059471, -0.006813026033341885, 0.00490935705602169, 0.052302297204732895, -0.002691801404580474, -0.02538853883743286, 0.005298529285937548, 0.030550815165042877, 0.019050970673561096, 0.032911960035562515, 0.002405177801847458, 0.012770936824381351, 0.029861124232411385, 0.02605826035141945, 0.04153367131948471, 0.014456961303949356, -0.01445457711815834, -0.007098540663719177, 0.00904496107250452, -0.029235465452075005, 0.021803539246320724, -0.0019365515327081084, 0.005789016839116812, 0.06483995914459229, 0.022130997851490974, -0.02945888228714466, 0.018918734043836594, -0.033483125269412994, 0.0010036599123850465, 0.05106474086642265, 0.0059893811121582985, -0.01622655615210533, 0.002122970763593912, -0.028629571199417114, 0.0307136382907629, -0.01928592100739479, -0.005973306018859148, -0.05188556760549545, 0.01585545390844345, 0.010682414285838604, -0.006819888949394226, 0.015996860340237617, -0.0294389259070158, 0.018890107050538063, -0.002789353486150503, -0.016007212921977043, 0.01583820767700672, -0.02358117140829563, -0.06591419875621796, -0.03326224908232689, -0.008487449027597904, -0.015771890059113503, 0.031594421714544296, -0.014054937288165092, -0.02441049925982952, 0.05334926396608353, 0.01249647792428732, -0.021449606865644455, -0.039269447326660156, -0.02464161068201065, 0.00188582600094378, 0.003163208719342947, -0.012487855739891529, 0.06244594603776932, 0.008487749844789505, -0.043147534132003784, 0.006786899641156197, -0.057729508727788925, -0.00030480194254778326, -0.022632522508502007, 0.007896365597844124, 0.03697055205702782, 0.015584786422550678, 0.02045365236699581, 0.009976087138056755, -0.01196313463151455, 0.006583271082490683, -0.05543927848339081, -0.04600226879119873, -0.007196695543825626, 0.03703819960355759, 0.04565974324941635, -0.007639091461896896, -0.016029488295316696, 0.09264708310365677, 0.021465206518769264, -0.05160614103078842, -0.04532008618116379, -0.017313076183199883, -0.0031673654448240995, -0.07811017334461212, 0.028894180431962013, -0.008207079023122787, -0.02224120870232582, 0.018929172307252884, 0.02750951237976551, 0.016946634277701378, 0.028836717829108238, 0.012064355425536633, -0.008125031366944313, -0.0031292978674173355, 0.026636352762579918, -0.040741726756095886, 0.04340619966387749, 0.015464968979358673, -0.03338737413287163, -0.011523319408297539, -0.00755737442523241, 0.04425738379359245, -0.015526842325925827, -0.04629429057240486, -0.013424169272184372, -0.03573003038764, 0.01730124093592167, -0.03485928103327751, 0.01705671288073063, 0.03755158185958862, -0.04466070979833603, -0.03234868496656418, 0.015911895781755447, 0.014061234891414642, -0.0277336947619915, -0.015788614749908447, 0.02968413569033146, -0.012439568527042866, 0.0020648085046559572, 0.026690127328038216, -0.00806250050663948, -0.0027509136125445366, 0.018112901598215103, -0.0020210854709148407, -0.02058827318251133, 0.04547276720404625, 0.051533352583646774, 0.014895832166075706, 0.003872368950396776, -0.031117187812924385, 0.011168334633111954, -0.09376468509435654, -0.013336987234652042, -0.030553806573152542, 0.05667552351951599, 0.002854341873899102, 0.040435194969177246, 0.04611847922205925, -0.03131252899765968, 0.011934495531022549, -0.008893512189388275, -0.031086880713701248, 0.03839381784200668, -0.014637645334005356, -0.036047548055648804, 0.04742339253425598, -0.04838772863149643, 0.0008587474003434181, -0.05991682782769203, 0.0189626794308424, 0.0667690858244896, 0.0339662991464138, -0.026500340551137924, -0.014997227117419243, -0.004377088043838739, 0.020652472972869873, -0.0327049158513546, 0.0377693809568882, 0.03537564352154732, -0.021871808916330338, 0.047579098492860794, -0.004784299060702324, -0.02791195549070835, -0.04277266561985016, -0.031580422073602676, -0.007663798984140158, 0.0005670090322382748, 0.06260691583156586, 0.01880646124482155, 0.022071944549679756, -0.025822287425398827, 0.024418257176876068, 0.014910679310560226, 0.018624618649482727, 0.04051244258880615, 0.03740427643060684, -0.025184733793139458, 0.02328099124133587, -0.008927215822041035, 0.023527158424258232, 0.02087477594614029, 0.02425633743405342, 0.006341338157653809, -0.0015383715508505702, 0.01443774625658989, -0.0645296648144722, 0.027526436373591423, 0.04569469019770622, 0.0002859093656297773, 0.0029379648622125387, -0.03292933478951454, 0.03584824129939079, -0.004531508777290583, 0.0028316895477473736, 0.010488998144865036, 0.03573988005518913, 0.012952268123626709, 0.019995421171188354, 0.03712669759988785, -0.029010998085141182, -0.03585011884570122, 0.04571229964494705, -0.009655047208070755, 0.0407826267182827, 0.022035477682948112, -0.031771063804626465, -0.006649265997111797, 0.01923515647649765, 0.02291315421462059, 0.007380985654890537, -0.010811672545969486, -0.09903322160243988, -0.019000908359885216, 0.03852604702115059, 0.035272810608148575, -0.01787640154361725, 0.01366637647151947, 0.014719104394316673, 0.010310624726116657, 0.03083162009716034, -0.05121929943561554, 0.015345092862844467, -0.02048374153673649, 0.01557939313352108, -0.02616332285106182, -0.020161978900432587, -0.04247286543250084, 0.027303528040647507, 0.0023607411421835423, 0.02058088406920433, 0.031207339838147163, -0.025204425677657127, -0.06863220781087875, -0.03411862626671791, 0.022358058020472527, 0.06372366100549698, -0.035373006016016006, -0.03955210745334625, 0.025552300736308098, 0.015004806220531464, -0.023081647232174873, -0.042708877474069595, 0.03117247298359871, -0.025331679731607437, -0.021216167137026787, 0.03875314071774483, -0.0099767055362463, -0.02324967458844185, 0.003947373945266008, 0.02049091085791588, -0.0011954775545746088, -0.03957739472389221, -0.03133903816342354, 0.032938867807388306, 0.022649794816970825, -0.01211622729897499, 0.059208307415246964, 0.034307967871427536, 0.00737231457605958, 0.012015243992209435, -0.03339371830224991, -0.010136851109564304, -0.019214410334825516, -0.023962998762726784, -0.06108732521533966, 0.009004791267216206, -0.014475896023213863, 0.017512019723653793, -0.011953064240515232, 0.014428017660975456, -0.04156804084777832, -0.018826212733983994, 0.048693202435970306, 0.027446622028946877, 0.002797464607283473, -0.027494210749864578, 0.027718007564544678, -0.010091694071888924, -0.03133028373122215, -0.05408284813165665, 0.013777445070445538, -0.04109494760632515, -0.021027525886893272, 0.007332830689847469, -0.03295003995299339, -0.0029459148645401, -0.041109610348939896, -0.06505033373832703, 0.009862514212727547, -0.0544012188911438, -0.00021548244694713503, 0.00044349394738674164, 0.022890234366059303, -0.0049271611496806145, -0.0637027844786644, -0.015831394121050835, 0.021700294688344002, -0.0015802817652001977, -0.0017982805147767067, -0.03391431272029877, 0.056718215346336365, -0.033218853175640106, 0.0033593028783798218, -0.07490044087171555, -0.027984824031591415, 0.02111665904521942, 0.0019701786804944277, 0.007338475435972214, 0.032765984535217285, -0.031746190041303635, -0.03425723314285278, -0.011642355471849442, -0.012671620585024357, 0.014159688726067543, -0.06062941998243332, -0.0009048328502103686, 0.003718472318723798, 0.04875316843390465, 0.0818549171090126, -0.023770613595843315, -0.0001501047081546858, -0.012289091013371944, -0.015990568324923515, -0.014278222806751728, -0.011172708123922348, -0.02981506660580635, -0.02991950698196888, -0.03501678258180618, -0.028099866583943367, 0.01959572359919548, 0.04554484039545059, 0.00041133849299512804, 0.008616391569375992, -0.012911110185086727, 0.006197365932166576, 0.011338426731526852, -0.057871732860803604, -0.013387910090386868, -0.03453165292739868, -0.003286628983914852, -0.018352674320340157, 0.006837423890829086, -0.03609063848853111, 0.04079681262373924, 0.011850747279822826, 0.026179606094956398, 0.009569450281560421, 0.0012469575740396976, 0.07331698387861252, -0.011398141272366047, 0.005809447728097439, 0.00908252876251936, -0.011952179484069347, 0.013968192972242832, 0.0465996079146862, 0.004492514301091433, -0.004335217177867889, -0.006000408437103033, -0.011705576442182064, 0.010628525167703629, -0.025510219857096672, -0.023252980783581734, 0.03212527558207512, 0.012741806916892529, 0.04015103355050087, 0.0246806051582098, -0.00757733965292573, 0.013228139840066433, -0.030536208301782608, 0.009770432487130165, -0.007524349261075258, 0.047942984849214554, 0.07356438040733337, -0.002945084823295474, -0.014638596214354038, 0.010937096551060677, 0.0331726111471653, 0.045106932520866394, 0.04625746235251427, 0.009102152660489082, 0.010042116977274418, -0.014476867392659187, 0.0073165930807590485, -0.02825114130973816, 0.02181878127157688, -0.04160347953438759, 0.005694194696843624, -0.0425356887280941, -0.035117026418447495, -0.012465710751712322, 0.033212777227163315, -0.009329642169177532, -0.06575309485197067, 0.0070867640897631645, -0.062581367790699, 0.028159087523818016, 0.013652735389769077, -0.007187736686319113, 0.010494543239474297, -0.010582958348095417, 0.02591639570891857, -0.04336850345134735, 0.02159201353788376, -0.03230385109782219, -0.054058510810136795, -0.03936290740966797, -0.04014173522591591, -0.05336790904402733, 0.04184689372777939, -0.03444106876850128, -0.027526846155524254, -0.013812043704092503, -0.01812475547194481, 0.03228214383125305, -0.021226122975349426, 0.019085360690951347, 0.001438155653886497, 0.04852890968322754, -0.016515836119651794, 0.04166540130972862, 0.0330856628715992, -0.017723171040415764, 0.12725789844989777, 0.07940321415662766, 0.032763879746198654, -0.06640005856752396, 0.06181589141488075, -0.007537179160863161, 0.02307593822479248, -0.025168627500534058, 0.0026559187099337578, 0.018359431996941566, -0.0198593158274889, 0.053210679441690445, 0.06915443390607834, 0.04801243171095848, 0.034081362187862396, 0.04694889113306999, -0.012606981210410595, -0.03630826622247696, 0.018630707636475563, -0.001514360890723765, -0.015045029111206532, -0.004757728427648544, -0.02154468186199665, 0.018725363537669182, 0.0014301174087449908, -0.011325771920382977, -0.04445074126124382, -0.015271923504769802, -0.005468389019370079, 0.026232494041323662, 0.019248902797698975, 0.00028471631230786443, 0.014879811555147171, 0.028017397969961166, -0.03117263875901699, -0.04494388774037361, 0.013723527081310749, -0.04605776444077492, 0.011363975703716278, 0.02273605950176716, -0.015298455022275448, -0.008356082253158092, -0.007921606302261353, -0.012019948102533817, -0.0451662540435791, -0.020773030817508698, 0.002040466060861945, 0.03866247832775116, -0.012846002355217934, -0.061739083379507065, -0.013790803030133247, 0.006126611027866602, -0.016591304913163185, -0.030195532366633415, -0.03625094145536423, 0.021876970306038857, 0.02505018189549446, -0.05744479224085808, -0.016067955642938614, -0.02546844631433487, -0.019133122637867928, -0.01653941720724106, 0.036114320158958435, 0.014832333661615849, 0.01097010262310505, -0.016281772404909134, -0.05756289139389992, 0.036112405359745026, -0.008732359856367111, -0.005153941456228495, 0.018748264759778976, 0.018442222848534584, -0.037544477730989456, -0.02028435468673706, 0.016892068088054657, 0.008451591245830059, -0.0068759070709347725, -0.016159534454345703, 0.014690003357827663, -0.037085626274347305, -0.04273243248462677, 0.011093096807599068, -0.014194052666425705, 0.004050788003951311, -0.021119365468621254, 0.01983465440571308, 0.0463845357298851, 0.061647091060876846, -0.0007017329917289317, 0.006938034202903509, 0.008736148476600647, 0.07050934433937073, 0.026036368682980537, -0.07971352338790894, 0.016285095363855362, 0.007537945173680782, -0.03352704644203186, -0.007195024285465479, -0.017498593777418137, 0.03873132914304733, 0.04750751703977585, -0.0013712221989408135, -0.03159434348344803, 0.030498206615447998, -0.005891993176192045, 0.008731409907341003, 0.019962359219789505, -0.058362722396850586, -0.013049527071416378, 0.008264931850135326, 0.01726287603378296, 0.004245117772370577, -0.008291911333799362, -0.03832670673727989, -0.036857329308986664, 0.002862757071852684, 0.00323578086681664, -0.010339589789509773, 0.004804709460586309, -0.01953882724046707, 0.004491616506129503, -0.020954174920916557, -0.0054924278520047665, -0.05924767628312111, -0.021976038813591003, -0.03322422504425049, 0.009924222715198994, -0.05557034909725189, 0.024471795186400414, -0.02370607852935791, 0.010815124958753586, 0.03818949684500694, -0.0021469115745276213, 0.030181072652339935, -0.002918246202170849, -0.013411649502813816, 0.015719447284936905, 0.06998071819543839, -0.01877180114388466, 0.0019564074464142323, 0.014205622486770153, -0.04883313551545143, -0.013283716514706612, -0.011454536579549313, -0.0018299893708899617, 0.05794789269566536, 0.016939008608460426, 0.022304579615592957, -0.01885361783206463, 0.06379533559083939, -0.012201092205941677, -0.019258780404925346, -0.03822243958711624, -0.03175811842083931, 0.029771694913506508, -0.020137494429945946, 0.016987495124340057, -0.002988095860928297, -0.018082881346344948, 0.0072697605937719345, 0.08070040494203568, 0.03621866926550865, -0.039418768137693405, 0.007752437610179186, -0.009166569449007511, 0.028954006731510162, 0.010753002017736435, 0.026778385043144226, 0.009425261057913303, 0.024978630244731903, -0.02812514640390873, -0.031761135905981064, -0.06651817262172699, 0.011659824289381504, -0.05555497109889984, -0.02260286547243595, -0.023291151970624924, 0.015196828171610832, 0.01350779365748167, -0.018758559599518776, 0.02000236138701439, 0.020792774856090546, -0.01270288322120905, 0.007989511825144291, 0.005470501724630594, -0.037150654941797256, 0.007659767754375935, 0.04159686714410782, 0.00025384195032529533, 0.028934421017766, 0.01125182956457138, 0.006006491836160421, 0.04875938966870308, 0.009074791334569454, 0.006389468442648649, -0.03293665125966072, 0.00418905820697546, 0.012266401201486588, 0.03673946484923363, -0.07485482096672058, -0.004986349493265152, 0.00518844835460186, -0.04169454425573349, 0.021370641887187958, -0.014849841594696045, 0.03363489359617233, 0.036576904356479645, 0.026246149092912674, 0.008241395466029644, 0.06396197527647018, 0.02664220705628395, 0.02788880467414856, -0.009731453843414783, -0.004537200089544058, 0.007954954169690609, -0.031140942126512527, 0.019100697711110115, 0.044682808220386505, 0.03925915062427521, 0.021398333832621574, -0.04204048216342926, 0.024648739024996758, -0.03521331027150154, -0.02563317120075226, -0.017513254657387733, -0.005413589533418417, 0.03280860558152199, -0.056962743401527405, -0.0036546112969517708, -0.02450721524655819, 0.020022554323077202, 0.02690151333808899, -0.019248206168413162, -0.016287339851260185, 0.014769894070923328, 0.013367503881454468, -0.009999795816838741, -0.03357386216521263, -0.020336603745818138, -0.037487998604774475, -0.05468972027301788, 0.0018647345714271069, -0.012984247878193855, -0.008913351222872734, -0.013385436497628689, -0.00289058405905962, -0.005263251252472401, 0.041718851774930954, -0.017788145691156387, -0.018010931089520454, -0.0004426869854796678, -0.017349570989608765, -0.001017024158500135, -0.07767841964960098, 0.0425693579018116, 0.027796875685453415, -0.0413665771484375, -0.06356065720319748, -0.025591537356376648, -0.029615074396133423, 0.02583308331668377, 0.06821747869253159, -0.002854585647583008, 0.017846060916781425, -0.015327917411923409, 0.04262007400393486, 0.007989204488694668, -0.05592723563313484, 0.03788212686777115, 0.028831880539655685, -0.022455239668488503, 0.0023128963075578213, -0.020863784477114677, 0.0013299849815666676, 0.01654728688299656, -0.006503256503492594, -0.030003083869814873, -0.0075762346386909485, 0.04328316077589989, -0.03560391813516617, -0.02523142285645008, -0.01677052676677704, -0.0334610790014267, 0.028640102595090866, -0.044349633157253265, 0.0034325069282203913, 0.06967740505933762, 0.02391137182712555, -0.0311896950006485, 0.00016808898362796754, -0.06090836599469185, -0.011995756067335606, -0.011949068866670132, -0.001868832390755415, 0.007942945696413517, -0.06731650978326797, -0.013213963247835636, -0.0015624912921339273, -0.04771595448255539, -0.037928272038698196, 0.040935415774583817, 0.0322134830057621, 0.028054438531398773, -0.010558407753705978, 0.030688976868987083, -0.008264543488621712, -0.0009016271797008812, 0.030842607840895653, 0.025011127814650536, 0.033311691135168076, -0.0023178462870419025, 0.0020245504565536976, 0.03258839249610901, -0.022996896877884865, 0.049054279923439026, -0.014882711693644524, 0.041592616587877274, 0.010612497106194496, 0.017522530630230904, -0.00015693310706410557, -0.03544701635837555, 0.02166442759335041, 0.02328578382730484, -0.01599683240056038, 0.029582224786281586, -0.04304475337266922, 0.036478932946920395, -0.018887124955654144, -0.010616239160299301, -0.03500741347670555, -0.0063837384805083275, 0.03842475637793541, 0.03293997049331665, 0.010121367871761322, -0.006706254091113806, 0.03351903706789017, -0.0162714384496212, -0.002172184642404318, -0.0288098007440567, -0.003634780878201127, -0.013806937262415886, 0.0006159883341751993, -0.052213750779628754, -0.0027973633259534836, -0.06366264075040817, -0.013523233123123646, 0.06282047182321548, 0.013282109051942825, 0.04581651836633682, -0.04315540939569473, -0.06136283278465271, 0.010639636777341366, 0.03563523665070534, -0.027290483936667442, -0.0232352614402771, -0.03193531557917595, -0.018536491319537163, -0.0030711765866726637, 0.007567247375845909 ]
<p>I am in a situation where I have to compute:</p> <p>$$E(u(x_1)|\bar{X},S^2)$$</p> <p>where $X_1$ is a normally distributed random variable and $u(.)$ some function. I know that by the student's theorem the sample mean and the sample variance are independent and moreover that $\frac{(n-1)S^2}{\sigma^2}\sim \chi^2 (n-1)$. </p> <p>Can I simplify the expectation with the information I possess? Is perhaps the bivariate normal distribution of use here?</p> <p>Thanks.</p> <p><strong>EDIT</strong>: Yes, an iid sample on $X$ is assumed here, hence the subscript $1$ on $u(x_1)$. If the expectation cannot be simplified, what is the conditional distribution of $X_1$ given $\bar{X}$ and $S^2$?</p>
74,342
[ -0.0022455237340182066, -0.03323923796415329, -0.0021343545522540808, -0.004374292213469744, 0.007493465673178434, 0.007153752725571394, -0.004311904776841402, -0.035471294075250626, 0.021067136898636818, -0.08011681586503983, 0.06515789031982422, 0.01606379821896553, 0.09694849699735641, 0.004838795401155949, 0.024530570954084396, 0.03685368224978447, -0.026572516188025475, 0.014570426195859909, -0.017478402704000473, -0.006055098958313465, -0.003979378379881382, -0.0019298444967716932, 0.01586253009736538, -0.026680149137973785, -0.0427979901432991, 0.03225366398692131, 0.01712089031934738, -0.03983580693602562, -0.00884187687188387, 0.10116200894117355, -0.0626748725771904, -0.039835333824157715, 0.028818612918257713, 0.057581327855587006, -0.024379733949899673, 0.004865332506597042, -0.04295865446329117, -0.033288247883319855, -0.006112729199230671, -0.0034411633387207985, -0.03185345605015755, 0.013405716978013515, 0.02590632624924183, 0.04264261946082115, -0.0006733261398039758, 0.02979738637804985, -0.018271546810865402, -0.04399115592241287, 0.0021749441511929035, -0.04949647933244705, 0.10022938996553421, 0.0057626464404165745, 0.04402319714426994, 0.022014731541275978, -0.010489550419151783, -0.00735035166144371, 0.01973813772201538, 0.01716259866952896, 0.03442439064383507, -0.07858889549970627, 0.03198624029755592, -0.011803545989096165, -0.010790076106786728, -0.029166551306843758, -0.027952127158641815, -0.009939019568264484, 0.01902279630303383, -0.012295279651880264, 0.030667530372738838, -0.0022348668426275253, 0.03805612027645111, 0.03978751599788666, 0.017424950376152992, -0.01298079639673233, -0.011683687567710876, -0.00011768093827413395, 0.014911191537976265, 0.01017354242503643, 0.0472157783806324, -0.005688411649316549, 0.011432339437305927, 0.024516243487596512, 0.048922065645456314, 0.041641298681497574, 0.02145037241280079, -0.011370828375220299, 0.07899653166532516, -0.01356508582830429, 0.011118030175566673, 0.008173670619726181, -0.016795504838228226, 0.01697695069015026, 0.043016914278268814, -0.042317382991313934, -0.033849138766527176, 0.02542283944785595, -0.010047527961432934, 0.011245946399867535, -0.018279800191521645, -0.013585315085947514, -0.019148651510477066, -0.05304858088493347, 0.04723566398024559, 0.09111584722995758, -0.009023741818964481, -0.01584046706557274, -0.01990695111453533, 0.015084956772625446, 0.009867677465081215, 0.003756431397050619, -0.023716287687420845, 0.028862886130809784, -0.029909152537584305, 0.017215918749570847, 0.006756546441465616, -0.01639469899237156, -0.019839327782392502, 0.008138047531247139, 0.024474427103996277, 0.046335794031620026, 0.026773087680339813, -0.022865787148475647, 0.029734715819358826, -0.004357513971626759, -0.042635686695575714, 0.053343936800956726, 0.012325518764555454, 0.020427905023097992, -0.04833433777093887, 0.03932500258088112, -0.032116055488586426, 0.014603879302740097, -0.005107332486659288, 0.045433711260557175, -0.0017282349290326238, -0.0011245713103562593, -0.09969985485076904, -0.05022050067782402, 0.0029634779784828424, -0.014272065833210945, 0.01717025600373745, -0.09396868944168091, 0.020748320966959, 0.04510366916656494, 0.030749816447496414, 0.006679695565253496, 0.07021187990903854, 0.004677039571106434, 0.026275983080267906, 0.00865294598042965, -0.01796799898147583, 0.0033446603920310736, -0.05242026224732399, -0.042598430067300797, 0.01840811036527157, -0.07463506609201431, 0.019220121204853058, 0.045140340924263, -0.011379250325262547, -0.05323372036218643, 0.03609876707196236, -0.017228052020072937, 0.0015507759526371956, -0.012936499901115894, 0.01636752299964428, -0.049136269837617874, 0.06846331804990768, -0.011261320672929287, 0.021975994110107422, 0.017644744366407394, 0.00632963003590703, -0.021168287843465805, -0.0032516010105609894, 0.051348548382520676, 0.0685545951128006, -0.016105640679597855, -0.010185964405536652, -0.006234719417989254, 0.01350085437297821, 0.03557262197136879, -0.058276791125535965, 0.007182511501014233, -0.043220143765211105, -0.023583268746733665, 0.0053558372892439365, 0.05419715866446495, 0.023011283949017525, -0.05133959278464317, 0.00008036618964979425, -0.04326903074979782, -0.0023621171712875366, -0.04193458333611488, 0.02211400680243969, 0.01424212846904993, -0.015107834711670876, 0.009366272017359734, 0.03217769414186478, 0.03235853090882301, -0.006211466155946255, 0.002577338833361864, -0.02235589548945427, -0.0017983972793444991, 0.013909496366977692, -0.04552996903657913, 0.026752397418022156, 0.0024092234671115875, 0.05573360621929169, 0.013366473838686943, 0.027728579938411713, -0.03020980954170227, -0.02096731588244438, -0.0056288097985088825, -0.013950055465102196, 0.029019592329859734, -0.012709866277873516, -0.009953922592103481, 0.011774389073252678, -0.04784903675317764, -0.0027599106542766094, 0.023279771208763123, -0.038915082812309265, 0.02785647101700306, 0.02688588574528694, 0.004208344500511885, 0.018921762704849243, 0.00031747709726914763, 0.07902474701404572, 0.00839849654585123, -0.0019227494485676289, -0.03940413147211075, -0.026436034590005875, 0.016097616404294968, 0.04477417469024658, 0.04568035528063774, -0.010587268508970737, 0.02006949670612812, 0.04339572414755821, -0.018897414207458496, 0.005658375099301338, 0.005812619812786579, 0.005673353094607592, -0.019675767049193382, 0.02724316343665123, 0.005648644641041756, 0.027649708092212677, 0.01808280125260353, -0.014551362954080105, 0.011206010356545448, 0.029704447835683823, 0.0018027705373242497, -0.03519764170050621, 0.07001607865095139, -0.023019151762127876, 0.017611784860491753, -0.00301699829287827, -0.0036782051902264357, 0.05150221660733223, 0.0024686488322913647, -0.011228641495108604, 0.0346689336001873, 0.005378108937293291, -0.03241494670510292, 0.01689523458480835, 0.00668938085436821, 0.02626166306436062, -0.007641518022865057, -0.03699752315878868, 0.018689656630158424, 0.03862827271223068, -0.024218561127781868, 0.010519132018089294, 0.0061459667049348354, -0.028746699914336205, 0.007127757184207439, 0.0020391501020640135, 0.02013702690601349, 0.005717460997402668, -0.010685751214623451, -0.017388353124260902, -0.030116092413663864, -0.028425103053450584, 0.018644575029611588, 0.038041967898607254, 0.029712310060858727, -0.028819752857089043, 0.0011503009591251612, -0.039235636591911316, -0.002554564271122217, 0.040014758706092834, -0.024069441482424736, -0.028509529307484627, 0.02035670541226864, -0.0029421087820082903, -0.02649047039449215, -0.008932091295719147, -0.031828854233026505, 0.01230479497462511, -0.036506228148937225, -0.010694273747503757, 0.04384705796837807, -0.006425242405384779, 0.002702385652810335, 0.04891384765505791, 0.011458111926913261, -0.0481502003967762, -0.03340892866253853, 0.028886986896395683, 0.05553601682186127, 0.006939469836652279, 0.043306585401296616, 0.034092579036951065, 0.024221589788794518, -0.02272792160511017, -0.045005228370428085, -0.07963977754116058, 0.02566610462963581, 0.010971701703965664, 0.020655108615756035, 0.02547655999660492, -0.05118237063288689, 0.07730672508478165, -0.022853992879390717, -0.009049985557794571, -0.00027908600168302655, -0.0005206128698773682, 0.006369025446474552, -0.011939415708184242, 0.023280493915081024, -0.009143916890025139, -0.02881653420627117, 0.05108990520238876, -0.00958978570997715, -0.018518829718232155, 0.007435602135956287, 0.022368917241692543, -0.029061803594231606, -0.0009652119479142129, -0.018433503806591034, 0.0017051065806299448, 0.0352233424782753, 0.009760650806128979, 0.010751421563327312, -0.030837763100862503, 0.005911672487854958, 0.025391343981027603, 0.011547602713108063, -0.0010721058351919055, 0.04520874470472336, -0.03450726717710495, 0.015422217547893524, -0.0361645445227623, 0.05913364514708519, 0.0010375085985288024, -0.05624852702021599, 0.005884500220417976, -0.006550604477524757, 0.029639368876814842, 0.003342102747410536, 0.007716058753430843, 0.05451704189181328, 0.06007809937000275, -0.05778893828392029, 0.008343561552464962, -0.032787349075078964, 0.005754477810114622, 0.02473335713148117, -0.034088075160980225, -0.009957927279174328, 0.02170868031680584, 0.0756790041923523, 0.006574736442416906, -0.005046715959906578, -0.038554321974515915, 0.015164056792855263, -0.06759412586688995, 0.030404888093471527, -0.022559266537427902, 0.021273840218782425, 0.016160806640982628, 0.03517764434218407, -0.0029686943162232637, -0.01933887042105198, -0.0017872441094368696, -0.02786511741578579, -0.06679219007492065, 0.010210827924311161, -0.02403733693063259, -0.0013522770022973418, -0.001182759297080338, -0.004054802004247904, 0.0446661077439785, -0.008531199768185616, 0.004413378890603781, -0.010573260486125946, 0.0023448572028428316, -0.0297284834086895, -0.01795295998454094, -0.03558722510933876, -0.02688738703727722, -0.0025939869228750467, 0.041124697774648666, 0.004207949619740248, -0.021942878141999245, -0.01479794830083847, 0.005255648400634527, -0.018825039267539978, -0.002593963872641325, -0.02984032779932022, 0.002423612168058753, -0.033767640590667725, 0.06391636282205582, -0.0279537420719862, 0.01782485842704773, 0.0014705247012898326, -0.011578738689422607, -0.005354918073862791, 0.05133998766541481, 0.0054438794031739235, -0.014263635501265526, 0.017905719578266144, -0.03162336349487305, -0.020457081496715546, 0.016704212874174118, 0.047196969389915466, -0.01358033623546362, 0.0102818813174963, 0.03914498910307884, -0.0003479428414721042, -0.05480901896953583, 0.01505959965288639, 0.06035926192998886, 0.021556749939918518, 0.026689566671848297, -0.03342089429497719, -0.023525971919298172, -0.04412904754281044, -0.03253109008073807, 0.0038020568899810314, 0.020021550357341766, -0.03634142875671387, -0.030781671404838562, 0.005144028924405575, 0.014697897247970104, 0.012023186311125755, -0.007051124237477779, 0.03584723547101021, 0.05535236373543739, 0.024635007604956627, -0.05784252658486366, 0.011750785633921623, 0.037153441458940506, 0.046247925609350204, 0.03283308073878288, 0.00047113181790336967, -0.03452224284410477, 0.010398884303867817, 0.012677825056016445, 0.017624342814087868, -0.028354955837130547, -0.009895293042063713, -0.022884706035256386, 0.007720113731920719, 0.011191015131771564, 0.0011083465069532394, 0.016017843037843704, 0.004269102122634649, 0.01776731200516224, 0.03644038364291191, 0.0050602806732058525, -0.041413187980651855, 0.02423867955803871, -0.013165704905986786, 0.010922543704509735, -0.0006376412929967046, -0.0407080203294754, -0.03886276111006737, 0.011016519740223885, 0.04126088693737984, 0.08230175822973251, 0.005116631276905537, -0.020949669182300568, -0.007768346928060055, 0.05988511070609093, -0.02301938273012638, -0.06679968535900116, 0.041391726583242416, 0.0004226338642183691, -0.0073072961531579494, 0.06687325239181519, -0.02429281361401081, -0.06952237337827682, 0.03052400052547455, 0.00033536393311806023, -0.0003112312115263194, 0.03238600119948387, 0.02150258608162403, 0.03261339291930199, 0.05308852717280388, 0.06595179438591003, 0.03363168239593506, 0.006367503199726343, -0.00918749999254942, -0.01592273823916912, -0.01673167757689953, -0.02114083617925644, -0.020787175744771957, -0.03929109871387482, 0.002430489519611001, -0.013792219571769238, 0.001886457554064691, 0.02395329438149929, -0.02030671015381813, 0.06529802829027176, -0.0302888173609972, -0.043388571590185165, -0.00010417417797725648, 0.01635521836578846, 0.040683384984731674, 0.000397982046706602, -0.0017503189155831933, 0.03145860135555267, 0.01106355432420969, -0.028980113565921783, -0.008222336880862713, -0.015001093968749046, -0.020566899329423904, -0.025234995409846306, -0.016089297831058502, 0.04087412729859352, -0.07706783711910248, -0.06600075215101242, -0.02193167246878147, -0.07118809968233109, 0.022066697478294373, -0.027972178533673286, 0.030810926109552383, 0.015774555504322052, -0.02960628643631935, 0.014037733897566795, 0.02760945074260235, 0.0037406086921691895, 0.014289899729192257, -0.055641334503889084, 0.029335571452975273, 0.046438202261924744, 0.021256927400827408, -0.059670403599739075, -0.026359431445598602, -0.03993953391909599, -0.023964015766978264, 0.030839083716273308, -0.047066181898117065, -0.008782520890235901, -0.03914022445678711, -0.026770910248160362, -0.04646700620651245, 0.024349607527256012, -0.005552561488002539, -0.0030513873789459467, -0.013391443528234959, 0.005160285159945488, 0.05977252870798111, -0.03363717719912529, -0.022506870329380035, 0.04109206795692444, -0.015021493658423424, 0.00018036428082268685, -0.002574554178863764, 0.03744691610336304, -0.02446931228041649, 0.03035813383758068, -0.006867399904876947, -0.02567620761692524, 0.035569965839385986, -0.016704358160495758, -0.00041988451266661286, 0.019105730578303337, -0.0013724949676543474, 0.024461666122078896, 0.004168249201029539, -0.027528958395123482, -0.003954762127250433, 0.03932008892297745, -0.017785513773560524, -0.024644091725349426, -0.016784749925136566, 0.004878634121268988, 0.013429008424282074, -0.008463341742753983, -0.02980184368789196, -0.0031036853324621916, 0.08796469122171402, 0.0008162313024513423, -0.023052668198943138, -0.020094243809580803, -0.009322724305093288, -0.0006476602284237742, 0.02753378637135029, 0.002272365614771843, 0.04945158213376999, 0.005394007544964552, -0.014998748898506165, -0.0315832756459713, -0.050796374678611755, 0.022844206541776657, 0.05897669494152069, -0.00502339843660593, 0.020346852019429207, 0.048826802521944046, 0.022418096661567688, 0.010768772102892399, -0.04988496005535126, 0.004665609914809465, 0.0009473775280639529, 0.003928812686353922, 0.02719157561659813, 0.005902193486690521, -0.043126560747623444, 0.04413590952754021, 0.016675524413585663, -0.020348815247416496, 0.054882895201444626, -0.005829848349094391, 0.017878515645861626, 0.051561277359724045, -0.027213873341679573, -0.05558909475803375, 0.04865608364343643, -0.046315182000398636, -0.006498068571090698, -0.051760125905275345, 0.034806158393621445, 0.03336751088500023, 0.014565604738891125, -0.01774464175105095, -0.039681270718574524, -0.011382310651242733, -0.0035294974222779274, -0.021890245378017426, 0.03275461122393608, -0.019983410835266113, -0.00211209780536592, -0.007072907872498035, 0.01429841574281454, 0.005465245805680752, 0.026373405009508133, -0.01547496858984232, -0.09575459361076355, 0.009368053637444973, -0.009149191901087761, -0.0465218611061573, 0.039746515452861786, -0.004684052895754576, -0.00044731199159286916, 0.007268358953297138, -0.03365040570497513, 0.02499758079648018, -0.014808609150350094, 0.03837687149643898, -0.0006818348774686456, 0.12031803280115128, 0.018514135852456093, 0.039851851761341095, -0.00023172330111265182, 0.024197230115532875, 0.1031917855143547, 0.03577723354101181, 0.018706323578953743, -0.0470263734459877, -0.02080736868083477, -0.027484305202960968, -0.042853474617004395, 0.017533831298351288, -0.01996743492782116, -0.021984076127409935, -0.0112336790189147, 0.036649104207754135, 0.06757239997386932, 0.006557484157383442, -0.05650436133146286, 0.006208705250173807, -0.03464064747095108, 0.006763684097677469, -0.019817816093564034, -0.00402557710185647, -0.07634834200143814, 0.0005012538167648017, -0.07248348742723465, 0.01093530934303999, -0.03473791480064392, -0.015091064386069775, -0.025929082185029984, -0.02089560218155384, 0.010951589792966843, -0.020747940987348557, -0.030575968325138092, 0.010777965188026428, -0.008097900077700615, -0.015000846236944199, -0.02867535687983036, 0.01766391471028328, -0.0002261797635583207, -0.01289146114140749, 0.023547587916254997, 0.02207377552986145, -0.03348598629236221, 0.022933771833777428, 0.02139199711382389, 0.005983644165098667, -0.03789695352315903, -0.035453371703624725, -0.016492726281285286, 0.034476540982723236, -0.03093886934220791, -0.0007753960671834648, -0.023234033957123756, -0.007898191921412945, 0.02901764027774334, -0.024646926671266556, -0.0321601927280426, 0.004341514315456152, 0.028853941708803177, -0.0135935815051198, 0.007997330278158188, -0.030891703441739082, 0.02915908582508564, 0.013085399754345417, 0.04645555838942528, 0.03135941922664642, -0.03348561376333237, -0.00943018589168787, -0.0020253919064998627, 0.03584984317421913, 0.016147641465067863, -0.007343435660004616, -0.005793241783976555, -0.01932486519217491, -0.0013222433626651764, -0.04005912318825722, 0.027732711285352707, -0.02850073203444481, 0.036956869065761566, 0.021878698840737343, -0.010225415229797363, 0.003874812973663211, -0.03434594348073006, 0.01719905249774456, -0.03699590265750885, -0.012550562620162964, -0.011865983717143536, -0.027592144906520844, 0.014317311346530914, 0.005402532406151295, 0.021255668252706528, 0.018788570538163185, 0.030609391629695892, 0.06379178911447525, 0.03394634276628494, -0.0574699267745018, -0.03870915621519089, 0.03467434272170067, 0.005251972936093807, 0.016401885077357292, -0.010123546235263348, -0.01783943735063076, 0.024059336632490158, 0.034683097153902054, -0.03097579814493656, 0.04785849153995514, -0.03792501986026764, 0.0007657825481146574, -0.01308669988065958, -0.07741112262010574, 0.029126416891813278, 0.03226117789745331, 0.01905672997236252, -0.011143602430820465, 0.0010167376603931189, -0.0015957850264385343, -0.023729238659143448, -0.008463790640234947, -0.03824729099869728, -0.012945554219186306, 0.004408858250826597, 0.004140987992286682, -0.001027173944748938, -0.007027586456388235, -0.004027789458632469, 0.021467041224241257, 0.006421051453799009, 0.026091063395142555, 0.005653486121445894, -0.03467191755771637, 0.009527750313282013, -0.015829594805836678, 0.00228312611579895, 0.019088052213191986, -0.013419557362794876, 0.013730456121265888, -0.03769785910844803, 0.0034282593987882137, -0.01627408340573311, 0.02960350550711155, 0.0035275437403470278, -0.014523368328809738, 0.03400564193725586, -0.06532657146453857, -0.019091639667749405, 0.03965834155678749, 0.002369155641645193, 0.04845301806926727, 0.04255318269133568, -0.04903145506978035, -0.02163051813840866, 0.007186812814325094, -0.0363629125058651, 0.011395038105547428, -0.029951253905892372, -0.006332692690193653, 0.0014443639665842056, -0.019327610731124878, -0.024482378736138344, 0.00834415853023529, -0.011271283030509949, 0.043472692370414734, 0.012485364452004433, -0.028242148458957672, -0.013931317254900932, 0.03114750050008297, 0.002545357681810856, 0.004407912027090788, 0.008375895209610462, -0.020155195146799088, 0.0567842572927475, 0.036949463188648224, -0.028138667345046997, 0.03546520322561264, -0.0505865253508091, 0.0028276985976845026, -0.12210137397050858, -0.008615762926638126, 0.054071951657533646, 0.00406385213136673, 0.04045967012643814, -0.0381154902279377, 0.015007185749709606, 0.011041960678994656, -0.020389223471283913, 0.008111901581287384, -0.02325831539928913, -0.04738090932369232, -0.042315125465393066, -0.008377368561923504, -0.019848855212330818, 0.019787171855568886, 0.009927400387823582, 0.02831335924565792, 0.01969301886856556, 0.024765361100435257, -0.017370708286762238, -0.03334583714604378, -0.03193499892950058, 0.026595817878842354, -0.00626341113820672, -0.05330752953886986, 0.033332135528326035, -0.03866643086075783, -0.0037148501724004745, 0.012685760855674744, 0.031173355877399445, 0.005390584003180265, -0.006291980855166912, 0.004229292739182711, 0.01265101321041584, 0.03314654529094696, 0.023797854781150818, -0.0329802930355072, 0.036227986216545105, 0.025513041764497757, 0.01724885031580925, 0.024003133177757263, -0.06299992650747299, -0.037309203296899796, -0.001947744283825159, -0.0020616655237972736, -0.039036285132169724, 0.03235665336251259, -0.009242415428161621, -0.03329262137413025, -0.0325964130461216, -0.04349960386753082, -0.00008960806735558435, -0.061088744550943375, 0.02929081581532955, -0.047416653484106064, -0.00242486409842968, 0.020431388169527054, 0.00787030067294836, 0.023813175037503242, 0.029378363862633705, 0.005957656539976597, -0.05929110571742058, 0.019330082461237907, 0.02157036028802395, -0.02477029711008072, -0.05306699126958847, -0.05886651575565338, -0.003914451226592064, 0.012749312445521355, 0.01855124905705452, -0.03359600529074669, 0.002893064869567752, 0.016977349296212196, 0.029658416286110878, 0.008388138376176357, -0.03744378685951233, -0.0055601345375180244, 0.008025510236620903, -0.036992013454437256, 0.03773893788456917, 0.030492469668388367, -0.027519380673766136, -0.01834588684141636, 0.006632241886109114, -0.03624650835990906, -0.03477964177727699, 0.048171401023864746, 0.026278285309672356, 0.01214125007390976, 0.022515075281262398, 0.039406802505254745, 0.030921952798962593, -0.030702631920576096, 0.00015759481175336987, -0.03919115662574768, -0.0230143740773201, -0.057071465998888016, -0.013123649172484875, 0.04795784875750542, 0.025669559836387634, -0.005902503151446581, -0.006407301872968674, -0.006235575303435326, 0.01885928027331829, 0.0018082172609865665, 0.045144591480493546, 0.001912203966639936, 0.009252609685063362, 0.046686142683029175, 0.014333415776491165, 0.01513136737048626, 0.010711224749684334, -0.01833014003932476, -0.028149861842393875, 0.047473788261413574, -0.026640163734555244, -0.023234974592924118, -0.0017141355201601982, 0.05478585883975029, -0.0020898424554616213, -0.05420015752315521, -0.01735767163336277, 0.02910032868385315, -0.03034433349967003, -0.02029990777373314, 0.03606270253658295, 0.007780951913446188, 0.04688151553273201, 0.014285474084317684, -0.02026539109647274, 0.026873603463172913, 0.008360616862773895, 0.046625345945358276, -0.012630322016775608, 0.013395383022725582, 0.0012309715384617448, -0.0025275314692407846, 0.044749874621629715, -0.05295846611261368, 0.0174888763576746, 0.019057879224419594, 0.04541093856096268, -0.023607447743415833, -0.04280650243163109, 0.035594113171100616, 0.004117321688681841, 0.03149188682436943, 0.01126416027545929, -0.04867546260356903, 0.053790923207998276, -0.007935889065265656, -0.002966994885355234, -0.07371391355991364, 0.026765288785099983, -0.02764110267162323, -0.018190037459135056, 0.05047918111085892, 0.02976427599787712, 0.027671946212649345, 0.0025675720535218716, -0.017541896551847458, -0.03526795655488968, 0.02514287270605564, 0.005920345429331064, 0.03050363063812256, -0.015768568962812424, -0.001176680438220501, -0.0265534408390522, -0.027862463146448135, -0.02587985247373581, -0.017252180725336075, 0.007168704643845558, 0.039375342428684235, 0.022253205999732018, 0.015734989196062088, 0.0072068748995661736, 0.025014415383338928, 0.09768212586641312, -0.05636443942785263, -0.024794287979602814, -0.032886531203985214, 0.00163433444686234, 0.019130365923047066, -0.015116581693291664 ]
<p>I have a data set with ~80 records, with ~8 features. I want to predict one of the features in future records. The feature is numeric and discrete. It ranges between -30 up to 140 with steps of 5. Until now I wanted to predict another feature which is boolean, so I used logistic regression. Which method should I use here? Maybe some kind of particle filter?</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
20,432
[ -0.015734964981675148, -0.0340891070663929, 0.007317124400287867, 0.0024526286870241165, 0.006739770993590355, -0.014179585501551628, 0.025213174521923065, 0.0011232042452320457, 0.04646017774939537, -0.008368190377950668, 0.014883256517350674, 0.040459200739860535, 0.006471259519457817, 0.004559199791401625, 0.010767834261059761, 0.03221116587519646, -0.028818605467677116, -0.01886698417365551, -0.01509628165513277, -0.012835697270929813, -0.008430268615484238, -0.011350523680448532, 0.037445101886987686, 0.009007803164422512, -0.023411279544234276, 0.06874499469995499, 0.04917098954319954, -0.0007081429939717054, -0.026955271139740944, 0.04828803241252899, -0.0009302859543822706, -0.05270298197865486, 0.0008275274303741753, 0.04939001426100731, 0.061945054680109024, -0.009597723372280598, -0.05440225079655647, -0.025126561522483826, -0.021013986319303513, 0.014493183232843876, -0.03441477194428444, -0.027610383927822113, 0.00512783695012331, 0.01572229526937008, -0.018366342410445213, 0.018031448125839233, -0.01890687830746174, -0.022979915142059326, 0.05659456178545952, -0.06066063046455383, 0.07237811386585236, -0.0326177254319191, 0.025471866130828857, 0.047789670526981354, 0.012335165403783321, -0.02201709896326065, 0.04727233946323395, 0.08675232529640198, -0.04716862365603447, -0.05444321036338806, -0.017409151419997215, -0.04528787359595299, -0.03427315875887871, -0.020093904808163643, -0.03847409039735794, 0.016706902533769608, -0.020785829052329063, -0.038178373128175735, -0.008686964400112629, 0.01267988421022892, 0.029230676591396332, -0.008370216004550457, 0.07913024723529816, 0.010276763699948788, 0.034457042813301086, -0.026189981028437614, -0.0219996627420187, 0.025117402896285057, -0.006979623343795538, 0.019708378240466118, -0.018662454560399055, -0.032322484999895096, 0.005857184063643217, 0.06122872978448868, 0.028299713507294655, -0.07345375418663025, 0.03973506763577461, -0.024946466088294983, 0.008210648782551289, 0.012401934713125229, -0.04013974219560623, 0.0038018571212887764, 0.07131164520978928, 0.0026645269244909286, -0.048194777220487595, 0.025338632985949516, 0.0066169993951916695, 0.013454336673021317, 0.05494771525263786, 0.005021367687731981, 0.018057584762573242, -0.03250585123896599, 0.016831979155540466, 0.07582097500562668, -0.04538286477327347, 0.01628292351961136, -0.01603541150689125, -0.04946906492114067, 0.015573907643556595, -0.008335099555552006, 0.00005194179539103061, 0.006205147597938776, 0.010118406265974045, -0.013170503079891205, 0.012338966131210327, -0.013052923604846, -0.02658321149647236, -0.02492847479879856, 0.04143207520246506, 0.051626723259687424, 0.005043181125074625, -0.04141758754849434, 0.01705610565841198, -0.008441926911473274, -0.04913711175322533, -0.0064053782261908054, 0.014880768023431301, -0.022908030077815056, -0.027900882065296173, 0.03896588832139969, -0.0040841070003807545, -0.020364491268992424, 0.0428636334836483, -0.012870201840996742, 0.01433782372623682, 0.04908634349703789, -0.08017820864915848, -0.05595223233103752, 0.010161583311855793, -0.03975285217165947, 0.03871794790029526, -0.02033853903412819, 0.007966071367263794, 0.0559844933450222, 0.05529468134045601, 0.02452162653207779, -0.0003486086498014629, 0.03704673796892166, 0.019486064091324806, -0.016664067283272743, -0.016504714265465736, 0.011549025774002075, -0.045659780502319336, -0.003457325743511319, -0.022406399250030518, -0.07887545973062515, 0.0195610374212265, 0.029300963506102562, 0.009020043537020683, -0.01651383750140667, 0.006464845966547728, -0.0478135421872139, 0.024268675595521927, -0.002180056646466255, 0.0018427851609885693, -0.025160880759358406, 0.09347816556692123, -0.013682776130735874, 0.023072754964232445, 0.022855790331959724, 0.01945095881819725, -0.0069766961969435215, 0.028302980586886406, 0.03849494829773903, 0.05159704387187958, -0.0016866475343704224, 0.0028062446508556604, -0.020098455250263214, -0.002830174518749118, -0.00409339414909482, 0.004936761688441038, -0.034208767116069794, -0.02664794959127903, -0.01275250781327486, -0.017628435045480728, 0.011389493942260742, -0.0033577317371964455, 0.0028865248896181583, 0.05787970870733261, -0.0407678596675396, -0.011916247196495533, -0.05730252340435982, 0.01638735458254814, 0.003064181888476014, 0.012240108102560043, 0.044990912079811096, 0.01812397688627243, 0.013845937326550484, -0.009249931201338768, -0.0005165247130207717, -0.019752908498048782, -0.007396843750029802, 0.03410011902451515, -0.05081167817115784, -0.008852927945554256, 0.036631666123867035, 0.01273488998413086, -0.005725671537220478, 0.07043088227510452, -0.05247395485639572, -0.023595277220010757, 0.006689457222819328, -0.00348220719024539, 0.03065153956413269, -0.03861430287361145, -0.01927720382809639, 0.05799677222967148, 0.0160613302141428, -0.036482807248830795, 0.011341860517859459, -0.08815435320138931, 0.05952853709459305, 0.07376119494438171, 0.0041185119189321995, -0.004102515988051891, -0.04524749889969826, -0.00301442202180624, 0.03247010335326195, -0.02053718827664852, -0.0670398473739624, -0.01864759251475334, -0.019642889499664307, 0.03011542744934559, 0.005148519296199083, 0.004012632183730602, 0.0149253960698843, 0.04464489221572876, -0.0030472278594970703, 0.05243544653058052, 0.011556139215826988, -0.009613980539143085, 0.023563891649246216, 0.03523218631744385, 0.03105272352695465, -0.010165935382246971, 0.0017189244972541928, 0.045341283082962036, 0.03130839765071869, 0.04558974504470825, -0.008444162085652351, -0.05371914431452751, 0.03497476875782013, 0.010878740809857845, 0.005115230567753315, -0.03271671012043953, -0.05003933981060982, 0.035044170916080475, -0.024376412853598595, -0.011695506051182747, 0.0217180997133255, 0.0024200635962188244, 0.0027555753476917744, 0.006955771241337061, -0.03162549436092377, 0.024027662351727486, 0.08971530199050903, -0.05848069116473198, 0.00730206910520792, 0.02600187249481678, -0.08134126663208008, 0.022722531110048294, 0.008674556389451027, -0.017709707841277122, -0.026561187580227852, 0.03155263885855675, 0.04298621416091919, 0.011455553583800793, 0.06422494351863861, -0.03408617153763771, -0.055981677025556564, 0.013080164790153503, -0.009733838029205799, 0.030936243012547493, 0.03753873333334923, -0.05716576799750328, -0.020176921039819717, -0.0061587984673678875, -0.021862050518393517, 0.0457601360976696, -0.0014518668176606297, -0.010149271227419376, 0.02760980650782585, -0.023015813902020454, -0.07109538465738297, -0.03419719263911247, -0.022225752472877502, 0.028789063915610313, 0.007815167307853699, -0.04793389141559601, 0.02816326729953289, 0.040906328707933426, -0.03906906023621559, -0.03936367109417915, -0.03418920934200287, -0.03154074400663376, -0.03084779903292656, -0.02159675396978855, 0.009513109922409058, 0.012687468901276588, 0.009568541310727596, 0.03549918904900551, -0.011979404836893082, 0.02799263969063759, -0.08363907784223557, -0.07336752116680145, 0.021610133349895477, -0.020024936646223068, -0.010204651392996311, -0.014675181359052658, 0.02786867506802082, 0.08318008482456207, 0.04469043388962746, -0.03627276048064232, -0.031192045658826828, -0.012470345012843609, -0.03094089962542057, -0.02874690108001232, 0.0007344940095208585, 0.02813652902841568, 0.05524853989481926, 0.044553350657224655, -0.06573109328746796, 0.007069302257150412, 0.028393052518367767, 0.010456343181431293, -0.015068541280925274, 0.021507784724235535, 0.02843724936246872, -0.004193073604255915, 0.03669062629342079, 0.021120231598615646, -0.06035422533750534, 0.043335556983947754, -0.02983301877975464, 0.019399326294660568, 0.02811376377940178, -0.05049337446689606, -0.009865994565188885, -0.02849639765918255, 0.012606448493897915, -0.013921750709414482, 0.011926254257559776, -0.02653677947819233, -0.04567403346300125, -0.016800906509160995, 0.038791559636592865, 0.026614228263497353, -0.027554700151085854, -0.008971053175628185, 0.024867696687579155, 0.014099495485424995, 0.0033289804123342037, 0.016740674152970314, 0.00711562717333436, 0.008841751143336296, 0.01580009050667286, -0.021364672109484673, -0.013648408465087414, -0.00808078981935978, 0.025282545015215874, 0.03689609467983246, -0.005945899058133364, -0.02843114174902439, 0.02725382149219513, -0.04822266846895218, -0.0019109504064545035, 0.01525089144706726, 0.0771874412894249, 0.029065538197755814, 0.011660221964120865, 0.01181093230843544, 0.01233093161135912, 0.06668419390916824, 0.021004080772399902, -0.06341645121574402, 0.0472194105386734, 0.0016440361505374312, 0.020496830344200134, -0.045164063572883606, -0.027561435475945473, 0.03224964067339897, -0.039569489657878876, -0.013585035689175129, 0.027873022481799126, 0.0592578686773777, -0.008296182379126549, -0.025381911545991898, -0.04138793796300888, -0.01111418567597866, -0.022536825388669968, -0.018685122951865196, -0.0029227095656096935, -0.039253562688827515, 0.03820854052901268, 0.013844383880496025, 0.0033100543078035116, -0.01899934932589531, 0.0002549078199081123, 0.016349535435438156, 0.014045189134776592, 0.04775213077664375, -0.005845509935170412, 0.010022494941949844, -0.058592505753040314, 0.05505853891372681, -0.0033183686900883913, 0.04353950172662735, 0.025893086567521095, -0.0022250297479331493, -0.015818165615200996, -0.0010906443931162357, 0.010715502314269543, 0.0028758510015904903, -0.006668567657470703, 0.03650423139333725, 0.03522907570004463, 0.04758765548467636, 0.001954302890226245, -0.07194077223539352, -0.03082067146897316, 0.0899866372346878, 0.04219977930188179, -0.022599194198846817, -0.021998347714543343, -0.00192502501886338, 0.009213984943926334, 0.01087715569883585, 0.055030401796102524, 0.03281361982226372, -0.01992635242640972, -0.001986308256164193, 0.04109658673405647, 0.016400370746850967, -0.038766324520111084, -0.00853661634027958, 0.009315596893429756, 0.04308728873729706, 0.017354562878608704, -0.050783559679985046, 0.029247790575027466, 0.048800814896821976, 0.010706835426390171, 0.021375156939029694, 0.014082547277212143, -0.11452853679656982, 0.006534692365676165, 0.032329294830560684, 0.027237683534622192, -0.062046315521001816, -0.02660731039941311, -0.05566871166229248, 0.0015855951933190227, 0.01956517994403839, -0.04475052282214165, -0.0010018558241426945, 0.011083211749792099, 0.0014941326808184385, -0.005340416915714741, -0.026494288817048073, -0.05231226980686188, 0.029461171478033066, -0.03685179725289345, 0.0339323915541172, -0.01027738954871893, -0.058778055012226105, -0.03928613290190697, 0.011603799648582935, 0.004660032689571381, 0.07284488528966904, 0.0033960198052227497, -0.0060956161469221115, 0.013635995797812939, -0.005630441475659609, 0.020451698452234268, -0.027505021542310715, 0.015955939888954163, 0.009086801670491695, -0.010974950157105923, 0.04893876239657402, -0.0189988873898983, -0.02823592722415924, -0.006888735573738813, 0.0086098937317729, -0.013863944448530674, -0.03615095838904381, -0.05469278618693352, 0.009455488994717598, -0.0051049827598035336, -0.012948724441230297, 0.009791534394025803, 0.01825241930782795, -0.006191836204379797, 0.0050269379280507565, -0.01959390752017498, 0.008129152469336987, -0.002929036971181631, -0.02521817572414875, 0.013009002432227135, 0.002291688695549965, -0.03316138684749603, 0.033428605645895004, -0.012590650469064713, 0.016311226412653923, -0.02375064231455326, -0.03473136946558952, 0.000608149217441678, 0.020113272592425346, -0.0474684052169323, -0.0156906358897686, 0.006334332749247551, 0.009082624688744545, 0.006785344332456589, -0.015187476761639118, 0.037407610565423965, -0.004793964792042971, 0.012341835536062717, 0.023396603763103485, -0.0386885330080986, 0.006878550164401531, -0.044435352087020874, -0.019452834501862526, 0.032731518149375916, -0.03521497920155525, 0.004802447743713856, 0.004697646014392376, 0.026319364085793495, 0.011233968660235405, -0.036313366144895554, -0.013370770961046219, -0.000523645372595638, 0.01262781023979187, 0.029719382524490356, -0.053393684327602386, 0.03212776407599449, -0.02728262171149254, 0.003837699070572853, -0.06128888204693794, -0.06319686025381088, -0.006558799184858799, 0.012095636688172817, -0.04089610278606415, -0.05615004524588585, 0.008531897328794003, -0.04462963715195656, -0.031398922204971313, 0.01897365041077137, 0.03237384557723999, -0.0066260164603590965, -0.0009236386977136135, 0.0013403181219473481, -0.004345927853137255, 0.034648917615413666, 0.0357956700026989, 0.024422938004136086, -0.011622674763202667, -0.012972462922334671, -0.004883285611867905, 0.031707800924777985, 0.007493484299629927, -0.02912134677171707, 0.005489962641149759, 0.004655320197343826, 0.014012692496180534, 0.02195223979651928, -0.012493325397372246, 0.021340185776352882, -0.01564248837530613, 0.0010958267375826836, -0.013260610401630402, -0.02240115776658058, 0.001988203264772892, -0.000559324340429157, -0.016732696443796158, -0.018490616232156754, -0.006071819923818111, 0.0013114953180775046, -0.013164457865059376, 0.02760542742908001, 0.03446951508522034, 0.0005725942901335657, 0.011478803120553493, 0.04671735316514969, 0.0043036132119596004, -0.021405279636383057, -0.003913327120244503, -0.030436411499977112, 0.04689284786581993, 0.009112660773098469, 0.00989130511879921, 0.025695789605379105, 0.04706694558262825, -0.028382502496242523, -0.03328555077314377, -0.04734409600496292, -0.012718872167170048, 0.033229708671569824, -0.0181173924356699, 0.04514709860086441, 0.024417607113718987, 0.029468348249793053, 0.001633287058211863, 0.00016033370047807693, -0.018269577994942665, 0.03482231870293617, 0.021124785766005516, 0.041824378073215485, -0.00042838879744522274, 0.031005484983325005, -0.02252981998026371, 0.003752791555598378, 0.03446906432509422, 0.05533546581864357, 0.015408693812787533, 0.04331257939338684, 0.004029739648103714, -0.0190949197858572, -0.02927251346409321, 0.01148046925663948, -0.05264953151345253, 0.03634495288133621, -0.046338751912117004, -0.021812254562973976, 0.03264772891998291, 0.042248234152793884, 0.00025634397752583027, -0.0524933747947216, -0.00786402728408575, -0.036330800503492355, -0.002755365101620555, -0.0004680014098994434, 0.0007503528613597155, 0.036174800246953964, 0.019740276038646698, -0.01118303183466196, 0.032564982771873474, 0.014330858364701271, -0.022844532504677773, -0.08279726654291153, 0.021106190979480743, -0.030013803392648697, -0.07150901854038239, 0.015892531722784042, 0.005556618329137564, -0.0000616899851593189, 0.009538459591567516, -0.025677677243947983, 0.019683482125401497, -0.004202686715871096, 0.008890213444828987, 0.00941508635878563, 0.04384278506040573, -0.013145764358341694, 0.004009777680039406, 0.0009577529272064567, 0.0052030254155397415, 0.11191733181476593, 0.09117656946182251, 0.007666901219636202, -0.07967451959848404, -0.0002172175154555589, 0.00448104040697217, -0.008758513256907463, -0.014348262920975685, -0.0020450002048164606, 0.04669133573770523, -0.01741742715239525, 0.04036811366677284, 0.023896904662251472, 0.02796545997262001, 0.01718657650053501, 0.02873603068292141, -0.06012878566980362, 0.02970329485833645, 0.023186713457107544, -0.01317514106631279, -0.004941267427057028, -0.015688706189393997, -0.023399000987410545, 0.046177566051483154, -0.015403179451823235, -0.018224595114588737, -0.020664654672145844, -0.006824922747910023, 0.013757091946899891, 0.021372761577367783, -0.01269611157476902, -0.014325023628771305, 0.023613102734088898, 0.007417423650622368, 0.037120476365089417, 0.003078208304941654, 0.005635021720081568, -0.029378697276115417, 0.0014680547174066305, 0.0325910784304142, 0.0020623470190912485, -0.004519796464592218, -0.0277410876005888, -0.009790458716452122, -0.02616332843899727, -0.02048751339316368, -0.07576005905866623, 0.03258997201919556, -0.021169478073716164, 0.022463427856564522, 0.0037188485730439425, 0.04503794014453888, 0.012127705849707127, -0.04778923839330673, -0.03393923491239548, 0.035884782671928406, -0.0010839845053851604, -0.04910099506378174, -0.04299963265657425, -0.02079913578927517, 0.031194599345326424, 0.03119954839348793, 0.011056291870772839, 0.034308794885873795, -0.021484941244125366, -0.015468253754079342, 0.019368572160601616, 0.036772221326828, -0.02659793011844158, 0.006427171640098095, 0.026733390986919403, -0.007485552225261927, -0.032453056424856186, 0.0298161618411541, 0.03883183002471924, -0.031402476131916046, -0.029319724068045616, -0.026294264942407608, -0.03665575757622719, -0.05295044183731079, -0.03197135031223297, 0.023442383855581284, -0.005505366250872612, 0.02578796073794365, -0.01013822853565216, 0.012461833655834198, 0.014182263053953648, 0.03977537527680397, 0.006658175960183144, 0.015467864461243153, 0.010284626856446266, 0.03542516380548477, -0.011608654633164406, -0.05971359461545944, -0.0158394705504179, -0.010554581880569458, -0.07192074507474899, 0.023740699514746666, -0.015468467026948929, 0.08636900782585144, 0.0066301231272518635, -0.006373472511768341, -0.020054327324032784, 0.029868021607398987, -0.012915494851768017, 0.0135435676202178, 0.01118609867990017, -0.013274306431412697, -0.032156605273485184, 0.004559810273349285, -0.017671864479780197, -0.02138221636414528, -0.03629693016409874, -0.029570357874035835, -0.034934476017951965, 0.03678818792104721, -0.013867557980120182, -0.03331739827990532, 0.011122292838990688, 0.026503050699830055, 0.02141299471259117, -0.018387075513601303, 0.011043757200241089, -0.04806390777230263, 0.004810941405594349, 0.014552056789398193, -0.01926104910671711, -0.03609168156981468, 0.030242158100008965, -0.018479911610484123, -0.0082871587947011, 0.048386652022600174, 0.025404732674360275, 0.04542197659611702, -0.017953548580408096, 0.045220136642456055, -0.025030171498656273, 0.02034584805369377, -0.02078750543296337, -0.022756297141313553, 0.004345281049609184, -0.017584502696990967, -0.01205784548074007, 0.06673397123813629, -0.0007209379109553993, 0.021029341965913773, -0.009521915577352047, 0.01169829722493887, 0.0317462794482708, 0.03549641743302345, 0.010546558536589146, -0.04022304341197014, -0.006067211739718914, 0.034529317170381546, -0.024156352505087852, 0.00013189301535021514, 0.012585612945258617, 0.02874879352748394, -0.02203628420829773, -0.010745787061750889, 0.050232257694005966, 0.06113088130950928, -0.007110903970897198, -0.034895822405815125, -0.03682773560285568, 0.018254827708005905, 0.02794857881963253, -0.024511398747563362, 0.018796974793076515, 0.03035806678235531, -0.004741308279335499, -0.009711536578834057, 0.007789865136146545, -0.0011154557578265667, -0.05217934027314186, -0.01571027748286724, 0.05823216214776039, -0.0048918048851192, 0.004013882018625736, -0.06504599004983902, -0.00984843261539936, 0.05925331264734268, -0.00720572005957365, 0.01097469124943018, -0.004384150262922049, -0.009968727827072144, -0.02345830388367176, 0.0022998503409326077, 0.0036419620737433434, 0.031127937138080597, 0.005229013506323099, -0.009335650131106377, 0.046558864414691925, 0.03429049253463745, -0.025871573016047478, -0.08016937971115112, -0.018829073756933212, 0.026136722415685654, 0.01675838977098465, -0.04416118562221527, 0.0470878966152668, -0.08744964748620987, -0.01499808020889759, 0.04142175242304802, -0.00714515894651413, 0.022217512130737305, 0.026533978059887886, 0.026639562100172043, 0.006738417781889439, 0.04793916642665863, 0.04262032359838486, -0.017663178965449333, 0.0036031841300427914, 0.030373485758900642, 0.005163529887795448, 0.0017633149400353432, -0.02396685630083084, 0.007677676156163216, -0.016143623739480972, 0.019209854304790497, -0.04297766834497452, 0.033736418932676315, 0.004719377961009741, -0.013521109707653522, -0.010214473120868206, -0.017094025388360023, -0.007439194712787867, -0.041957251727581024, -0.016427360475063324, -0.03516370803117752, 0.01493728905916214, 0.021117916330695152, 0.009250955656170845, -0.03517046943306923, -0.017949962988495827, -0.01298745907843113, -0.06353636831045151, -0.006614612881094217, 0.006233668886125088, 0.00928774755448103, -0.03323915973305702, 0.015278136357665062, -0.0008978255791589618, -0.02396303229033947, -0.028009843081235886, -0.029387783259153366, -0.028077343478798866, 0.021832482889294624, -0.011444025672972202, 0.02227677032351494, 0.05173959955573082, -0.01992575265467167, -0.00823018979281187, -0.07498659938573837, 0.06945978105068207, 0.0023450942244380713, -0.010101990774273872, 0.0020813667215406895, 0.009376798756420612, -0.030406732112169266, -0.0066363513469696045, 0.04400463402271271, -0.006898387335240841, 0.015902230516076088, -0.014144852757453918, 0.023647304624319077, 0.036966800689697266, -0.017079032957553864, -0.0010302348528057337, -0.020220313221216202, -0.013324207626283169, -0.015765760093927383, -0.004003106150776148, 0.012806979939341545, 0.021502556279301643, 0.020717285573482513, -0.002688420470803976, -0.012554199434816837, -0.0001424831134499982, -0.00233817077241838, -0.010291796177625656, -0.03840082883834839, 0.03186437860131264, 0.04080848768353462, 0.0012658217456191778, -0.006528907455503941, 0.028531068935990334, 0.01593775674700737, -0.06147016957402229, 0.033102989196777344, -0.02888322062790394, -0.00344440178014338, 0.01864035055041313, 0.018271876499056816, -0.0113070048391819, -0.044650811702013016, 0.030719375237822533, 0.026507358998060226, -0.001960769295692444, 0.050436168909072876, 0.017334163188934326, -0.027595600113272667, 0.016012048348784447, -0.03299665451049805, 0.04645581170916557, 0.012472577393054962, 0.005907237064093351, -0.033236466348171234, -0.005279541946947575, 0.026240650564432144, -0.011881792917847633, 0.04260833561420441, 0.03900504112243652, 0.03552555292844772, 0.039442386478185654, -0.02078494429588318, 0.011880272068083286, 0.01367355976253748, 0.0430254228413105, 0.008196931332349777, -0.001729228999465704, 0.03241860494017601, 0.02645019441843033, 0.004477597773075104, 0.05411231517791748, -0.07009422779083252, -0.02507016621530056, -0.07146516442298889, -0.01853453926742077, -0.024455601349473, 0.013985169120132923, 0.01071028783917427, 0.04773937538266182, 0.04400720074772835, 0.01502921711653471, 0.019853800535202026, 0.009471423923969269, -0.006689769681543112, -0.051112100481987, 0.0017564197769388556, -0.020389419049024582, 0.005928707774728537, 0.014388864859938622, -0.020745743066072464, -0.02793027274310589, -0.018783319741487503, -0.0008083225693553686, 0.051955804228782654, 0.04568488150835037, 0.0016064824303612113, -0.016031917184591293, -0.0023342217318713665, 0.016406260430812836, -0.027806805446743965, -0.0005055093206465244, -0.046063411980867386, 0.006120339501649141, -0.0040145982056856155, -0.026614351198077202 ]
<p>I am looking at a Semivariogram. I know it shows me the relationship between distance and semi-variance. I also know that at the end of the range the distance no longer auto correlates. What I am wondering is, what does the semi-variance tell me at the point where to distance no longer auto correlates (at the sill)? So in my case at about 900 m the distance no longer auto correlates. The sill at this value is about 4300. What does this value tell me?</p>
74,343
[ -0.015883948653936386, -0.006350365001708269, 0.035883400589227676, -0.017318375408649445, 0.05922418460249901, 0.04132046177983284, -0.002144145779311657, -0.010734600946307182, -0.003953724633902311, -0.02131451666355133, 0.015601485967636108, 0.03279022127389908, 0.07230804860591888, 0.020335450768470764, 0.033312879502773285, -0.010175571776926517, -0.03681313246488571, 0.005186701659113169, 0.010984531603753567, -0.032315660268068314, -0.0039776042103767395, -0.02432382106781006, 0.02343817800283432, -0.005362350028008223, -0.016306985169649124, 0.02563023380935192, 0.004465328063815832, -0.01823929138481617, 0.04341956228017807, 0.03922894224524498, -0.04834297299385071, -0.024656912311911583, -0.004664188716560602, 0.0037354121450334787, 0.02571595273911953, 0.002086909720674157, -0.0058417003601789474, -0.024590644985437393, -0.01319063175469637, 0.03693985566496849, -0.027399756014347076, -0.016035431995987892, 0.002076051663607359, 0.04076066240668297, -0.04200083762407303, -0.010510171763598919, 0.0013040939811617136, -0.014459999278187752, 0.06842771172523499, -0.007192033343017101, 0.08758771419525146, 0.011124931275844574, 0.027461988851428032, 0.04883160442113876, 0.005943410564213991, 0.02948124334216118, 0.08478713780641556, 0.020359352231025696, -0.05246560275554657, -0.05970188230276108, -0.05690012872219086, -0.05453062802553177, -0.024335375055670738, -0.026165392249822617, -0.00993646215647459, 0.023936502635478973, -0.01794428937137127, -0.015433120541274548, 0.017594249919056892, 0.009751010686159134, 0.010875305160880089, 0.039884671568870544, 0.036595601588487625, -0.01569269597530365, 0.0020755110308527946, -0.023312492296099663, 0.045440174639225006, 0.002495013177394867, 0.04854923486709595, -0.0005900136311538517, 0.00909364316612482, 0.0031086259987205267, -0.01632111705839634, -0.008385111577808857, 0.021535251289606094, 0.012572268024086952, 0.05094514042139053, -0.03571796417236328, -0.007688040845096111, 0.03334532305598259, -0.00287664495408535, 0.0006803500582464039, 0.03521158546209335, 0.0030495640821754932, -0.06877286732196808, 0.04734263941645622, -0.015705978497862816, 0.044561222195625305, -0.013273295015096664, -0.030092468485236168, -0.058299604803323746, -0.03469430282711983, 0.042465690523386, 0.02834833785891533, 0.0010797001887112856, 0.010422913357615471, -0.022508777678012848, 0.012312840670347214, -0.023439105600118637, 0.002244009403511882, -0.007402738556265831, -0.014736545272171497, 0.04186653345823288, -0.014612109400331974, 0.06271885335445404, -0.02531830221414566, 0.001906194956973195, -0.02876017428934574, 0.03742796555161476, 0.07180845737457275, 0.07609190791845322, -0.007717475760728121, 0.016955459490418434, 0.007140526548027992, -0.06510861217975616, 0.03252182528376579, 0.03234205022454262, -0.044533390551805496, -0.04761005938053131, 0.040253207087516785, -0.01853097602725029, 0.003922922071069479, 0.026765309274196625, -0.06261854618787766, 0.02342553809285164, 0.02695300616323948, -0.07891325652599335, -0.03454793617129326, 0.033916667103767395, 0.024317100644111633, 0.04004646837711334, -0.06019243970513344, 0.016132792457938194, 0.018138570711016655, 0.05455925688147545, 0.02903646044433117, 0.02932964451611042, -0.025626234710216522, -0.021952737122774124, 0.021499309688806534, -0.029898587614297867, -0.014438253827393055, -0.0037419528234750032, -0.05322818085551262, 0.0022747840266674757, -0.05727015435695648, -0.015695471316576004, 0.020347261801362038, -0.00750485947355628, -0.043856143951416016, 0.03522833064198494, -0.01993974670767784, -0.019927700981497765, -0.050232626497745514, -0.031112145632505417, -0.026074811816215515, 0.07150450348854065, -0.011052864603698254, -0.0407949835062027, 0.005089227110147476, 0.0003484864137135446, 0.014697068370878696, 0.038072023540735245, 0.034122567623853683, 0.060204941779375076, 0.03928728774189949, 0.01807112619280815, 0.010513060726225376, -0.01734939031302929, 0.03528545796871185, -0.026825977489352226, -0.05406363308429718, -0.020683355629444122, 0.037106115370988846, 0.019954558461904526, 0.031784914433956146, -0.052587103098630905, -0.006790746469050646, 0.054593492299318314, -0.009709808975458145, -0.026471855118870735, -0.04529426246881485, -0.0035564203280955553, 0.00195451732724905, 0.01665639877319336, 0.01575840450823307, 0.017576947808265686, 0.020552927628159523, -0.008634942583739758, -0.023673059418797493, -0.010241248644888401, -0.009738034568727016, 0.031561579555273056, -0.04482857510447502, 0.029658231884241104, 0.030279355123639107, -0.00343597074970603, 0.027994178235530853, 0.048783283680677414, 0.0030102974269539118, -0.02503249980509281, 0.00016303244046866894, -0.012421321123838425, -0.025606486946344376, -0.013260429725050926, -0.006830201484262943, -0.013755983673036098, 0.011187249794602394, -0.011205143295228481, -0.015126910991966724, -0.03244227543473244, 0.07591097056865692, 0.04634452983736992, 0.0102749178186059, -0.011777703650295734, 0.025915322825312614, 0.007692479062825441, 0.006042024586349726, -0.04053056612610817, -0.04237889125943184, -0.011064657010138035, 0.010581916198134422, 0.034556422382593155, 0.04554956406354904, -0.0004369687521830201, -0.004391435533761978, 0.0036923461593687534, 0.0348278246819973, -0.006774773821234703, 0.025581160560250282, -0.017017243430018425, 0.006063411943614483, 0.026477590203285217, 0.0028608848806470633, 0.03394365310668945, -0.03260870277881622, -0.01879250817000866, -0.0041783656924963, 0.0050443983636796474, -0.032073844224214554, -0.05600137263536453, 0.0503838025033474, -0.012020659632980824, 0.008048033341765404, -0.040044594556093216, 0.0007381929317489266, 0.03592350706458092, -0.005175171419978142, 0.009901003912091255, 0.04655509442090988, -0.011429546400904655, -0.008706879802048206, 0.008791487663984299, -0.028440352529287338, 0.06838589161634445, 0.04477095231413841, -0.0056459479965269566, -0.0008719619945622981, 0.006371015682816505, -0.025299539789557457, 0.007519396487623453, -0.04293746128678322, -0.027818255126476288, -0.029472986236214638, -0.04631366208195686, 0.06300710886716843, 0.01451781764626503, 0.04167672619223595, -0.008341718465089798, -0.06600194424390793, -0.030925622209906578, -0.03111758455634117, 0.012756571173667908, 0.0030665758531540632, -0.04759525507688522, -0.03215019404888153, -0.011813769116997719, 0.022871503606438637, 0.021104125306010246, -0.021596772596240044, -0.005394582636654377, 0.026272928342223167, -0.03576061502099037, -0.034896235913038254, -0.018881645053625107, -0.03902054950594902, -0.00926843099296093, 0.00398004986345768, -0.011093002744019032, 0.04396805912256241, -0.03346436843276024, -0.02370731346309185, 0.011162911541759968, -0.03228200599551201, 0.0005959137924946845, -0.06650138646364212, 0.0045470683835446835, 0.012898506596684456, -0.024980908259749413, 0.029800206422805786, 0.011866268701851368, -0.01991426572203636, -0.01315420214086771, -0.025491004809737206, -0.08313115686178207, 0.011659473180770874, 0.012415972538292408, -0.01437661424279213, -0.01952664740383625, -0.03358685225248337, 0.04832526668906212, 0.01720220036804676, -0.018262051045894623, -0.03593834489583969, 0.0007695929380133748, -0.02466568723320961, -0.0004418259777594358, -0.011559710837900639, -0.024657806381583214, 0.02729363553225994, 0.03416978940367699, 0.003392936894670129, 0.08639121055603027, 0.031237082555890083, 0.0034756511449813843, -0.021683527156710625, 0.037541523575782776, -0.0026853345334529877, 0.009211618453264236, 0.04346989095211029, 0.0345662385225296, -0.051626674830913544, 0.01854846626520157, 0.0026266605127602816, 0.009331682696938515, 0.023337407037615776, -0.061463862657547, 0.0472896508872509, -0.032655712217092514, 0.055593471974134445, -0.05341879278421402, 0.04878978058695793, -0.0041515640914440155, 0.030636221170425415, 0.01333859283477068, 0.008185707032680511, 0.06934724748134613, -0.010917307808995247, -0.008523291908204556, 0.044418029487133026, 0.06379489600658417, -0.01286447886377573, 0.007413859013468027, -0.026149744167923927, -0.017945604398846626, 0.023775514215230942, -0.020615803077816963, -0.0464431531727314, -0.00047742034075781703, 0.01650402508676052, -0.01551598496735096, 0.014442691579461098, -0.05128577724099159, 0.01631109043955803, -0.029074614867568016, -0.004448448307812214, 0.011674553155899048, 0.035251326858997345, 0.002761063864454627, 0.02562800422310829, 0.041355837136507034, 0.010727054439485073, 0.01843392662703991, 0.006129455752670765, -0.03049379214644432, 0.014408517628908157, -0.03714955225586891, -0.025699280202388763, -0.01254023052752018, -0.018171807751059532, -0.0017564435256645083, -0.021172620356082916, 0.02853008173406124, 0.03591290861368179, 0.06753601133823395, -0.04670252650976181, -0.007325638551265001, -0.010617073625326157, 0.018072184175252914, -0.06737872213125229, 0.0024580289609730244, 0.005387059412896633, -0.00031221285462379456, 0.06200890988111496, 0.03813986852765083, -0.010848184116184711, -0.02501031942665577, -0.018795810639858246, 0.012763124890625477, 0.04888475686311722, 0.019406281411647797, 0.023696959018707275, -0.00720500061288476, -0.045231420546770096, 0.013691546395421028, 0.023338064551353455, 0.016688544303178787, 0.017749836668372154, -0.005330298095941544, -0.0015628848923370242, -0.036955755203962326, -0.04297932982444763, 0.0024088160134851933, 0.002186005236580968, -0.018752139061689377, 0.0017157808179035783, 0.05869024246931076, 0.010830612853169441, -0.07571584731340408, 0.059045713394880295, 0.04254238307476044, 0.0073371087200939655, -0.02400963008403778, -0.03664623945951462, -0.039958227425813675, -0.02373739704489708, -0.011405829340219498, 0.04284180700778961, 0.00629646610468626, -0.029212921857833862, -0.013107203878462315, 0.03277921676635742, -0.005069477017968893, -0.022544357925653458, 0.0009813554352149367, 0.022328969091176987, 0.010698535479605198, -0.003502465086057782, -0.030625447630882263, 0.015030127950012684, 0.026988264173269272, 0.04128806293010712, 0.028242917731404305, 0.026008378714323044, -0.08811217546463013, 0.005345516372472048, 0.029778486117720604, 0.005299469921737909, -0.011225092224776745, 0.014009700156748295, -0.054893042892217636, -0.0246894434094429, -0.0013172305189073086, -0.04818806052207947, 0.029505226761102676, -0.01849689520895481, 0.0153685063123703, -0.005253742448985577, -0.04529764503240585, -0.047540098428726196, 0.018970785662531853, 0.028303351253271103, 0.02854830212891102, -0.021556930616497993, -0.04134678840637207, -0.023373283445835114, -0.004229699727147818, 0.007629150524735451, 0.061511896550655365, 0.010462629608809948, -0.007050102576613426, -0.01621503010392189, 0.03161761164665222, 0.011196852661669254, -0.05600903928279877, 0.013616557233035564, -0.003592737717553973, -0.015365157276391983, 0.043420933187007904, 0.011157937347888947, -0.03436233475804329, 0.032983001321554184, 0.02008257433772087, -0.005278031341731548, 0.013583391904830933, -0.002207363024353981, 0.043569743633270264, 0.033900186419487, 0.012312270700931549, 0.03316767141222954, 0.0022312684450298548, -0.02761499583721161, 0.014966758899390697, -0.047331303358078, 0.048418350517749786, -0.012927236966788769, -0.03602664917707443, -0.045631393790245056, -0.02920917421579361, -0.02916504070162773, 0.057654138654470444, -0.025087393820285797, 0.04461172595620155, -0.04857119917869568, -0.014420446939766407, 0.00144234171602875, 0.033070649951696396, 0.01343579962849617, 0.006082125939428806, 0.003564048558473587, 0.011194257996976376, -0.012288786470890045, -0.034091293811798096, -0.0219632126390934, 0.009314068593084812, -0.012547621503472328, 0.01653645560145378, -0.014125929214060307, -0.009835001081228256, -0.036065977066755295, -0.0001263713202206418, -0.0004000196640845388, -0.03938483074307442, 0.024257026612758636, 0.010780179873108864, -0.010757649317383766, 0.056885767728090286, -0.03867217153310776, -0.021579911932349205, 0.021321142092347145, -0.04275140538811684, 0.04833780974149704, -0.05894138291478157, 0.011829598806798458, 0.016791291534900665, 0.016878938302397728, -0.08815346658229828, -0.03379781171679497, 0.003712147707119584, 0.02019830420613289, -0.0472060851752758, -0.017051832750439644, -0.03693723306059837, -0.016940871253609657, -0.04825647175312042, 0.009683546610176563, 0.03491590917110443, -0.0037868639919906855, -0.014549091458320618, -0.030476368963718414, -0.0018192344577983022, 0.06359074264764786, -0.022422127425670624, 0.011030911467969418, 0.02784801833331585, 0.000184895601705648, -0.004823861178010702, 0.009326869621872902, 0.06219033524394035, -0.0463111475110054, 0.0029639285057783127, -0.017970556393265724, -0.015547188930213451, 0.03070773556828499, -0.037619102746248245, -0.0467129722237587, -0.032805975526571274, -0.007416883483529091, 0.03698686137795448, 0.024607457220554352, 0.006808603648096323, 0.0006134210270829499, 0.034408584237098694, -0.014076917432248592, 0.014921801164746284, -0.022177845239639282, -0.018867474049329758, 0.0025853130500763655, 0.0430956706404686, 0.04838621988892555, 0.023719485849142075, 0.041256047785282135, -0.02681775949895382, 0.011289526708424091, 0.000736498914193362, 0.005587480962276459, 0.008214450441300869, 0.007436251733452082, 0.0033913287334144115, 0.016193462535738945, 0.034048907458782196, -0.021094880998134613, -0.01366614829748869, -0.03142823278903961, -0.009070785716176033, 0.10458220541477203, -0.04436773061752319, 0.055489324033260345, 0.04859987646341324, 0.00047595493379049003, 0.00977087952196598, -0.05997737497091293, -0.007635077461600304, -0.016478145495057106, 0.016549251973628998, 0.038327351212501526, -0.037234436720609665, -0.02034790627658367, -0.0015170910628512502, 0.042557492852211, 0.012228206731379032, 0.03627016395330429, 0.006207078229635954, 0.049077101051807404, 0.016384655609726906, -0.026046039536595345, -0.04968390241265297, 0.031926557421684265, 0.012461334466934204, 0.002398731652647257, 0.02455032430589199, 0.034571390599012375, 0.041198015213012695, 0.03533334285020828, 0.03542448952794075, -0.04536932334303856, -0.05635596066713333, -0.02718724124133587, -0.031047483906149864, 0.022033050656318665, -0.033382710069417953, -0.01610720530152321, 0.029268406331539154, 0.012373106554150581, 0.004772626329213381, -0.004798234906047583, -0.012399399653077126, -0.05441370978951454, -0.05768093094229698, -0.004023229703307152, -0.01440575160086155, 0.03957299888134003, -0.01854851096868515, -0.062442339956760406, -0.020589346066117287, -0.013723074458539486, 0.015750441700220108, -0.016678079962730408, -0.04146106168627739, -0.03198254853487015, 0.08496022969484329, 0.04269498959183693, 0.01616918295621872, -0.012044667266309261, 0.01046706736087799, 0.10296113044023514, 0.06603645533323288, 0.010539035312831402, -0.03446578606963158, -0.002782790455967188, -0.007426932454109192, -0.016984006389975548, -0.03461243212223053, 0.00027649966068565845, 0.02519966848194599, -0.017379989847540855, 0.06449885666370392, 0.028512615710496902, -0.004117041360586882, 0.011075794696807861, 0.04985034465789795, -0.020547332242131233, -0.04255776107311249, -0.0026019983924925327, -0.002413769019767642, -0.013301302678883076, -0.025661680847406387, -0.05443767458200455, 0.01809721067547798, -0.003903198055922985, -0.00536010880023241, -0.023140903562307358, -0.023698871955275536, 0.011025219224393368, 0.030562276020646095, -0.04393072426319122, 0.017063234001398087, 0.029384085908532143, 0.03877399489283562, -0.04382416605949402, -0.02442445605993271, 0.008564554154872894, 0.008745137602090836, -0.026218051090836525, 0.040769703686237335, -0.006411188282072544, 0.008459755219519138, -0.03192859888076782, 0.00854363664984703, -0.010437101125717163, -0.0835191011428833, 0.012175786308944225, 0.05375724658370018, 0.04936075955629349, 0.01414269208908081, -0.012177483178675175, 0.045500610023736954, 0.010938107036054134, -0.03814534470438957, 0.01495449524372816, 0.007049385458230972, 0.004527687560766935, -0.02772401086986065, 0.005312639754265547, -0.0007766946800984442, -0.006875057704746723, 0.002129119820892811, 0.0028457476291805506, -0.0025070281699299812, -0.0014275182038545609, -0.02078084833920002, -0.049939800053834915, 0.0725453794002533, -0.01355182845145464, -0.032244887202978134, -0.0175237488001585, 0.0029176315292716026, -0.011232669465243816, -0.02684083767235279, 0.02864120714366436, -0.0012521784519776702, 0.039996061474084854, 0.018119093030691147, -0.0444483608007431, -0.007875914685428143, -0.055095456540584564, 0.027960916981101036, -0.006962446961551905, -0.020076336339116096, -0.024014392867684364, -0.008213410153985023, 0.030408699065446854, 0.041390687227249146, -0.010039479471743107, -0.007470336277037859, -0.017091169953346252, 0.05214133486151695, -0.009122018702328205, -0.03081722930073738, -0.014308850280940533, 0.052396971732378006, -0.010608571581542492, 0.007051731459796429, -0.0033184632193297148, 0.048430174589157104, 0.03020166978240013, 0.04136929288506508, 0.02051781862974167, 0.021535756066441536, -0.004908331204205751, 0.011892196722328663, 0.01961788907647133, -0.05187065526843071, 0.0033397648949176073, -0.02479393593966961, -0.011285686865448952, -0.031496476382017136, -0.012195185758173466, 0.00256784213706851, -0.02520940639078617, 0.021250521764159203, 0.028716355562210083, -0.029416361823678017, 0.017034953460097313, -0.014440571889281273, -0.022686900570988655, -0.032692715525627136, -0.009032998234033585, -0.031481172889471054, 0.024499598890542984, 0.007979356683790684, -0.0285458005964756, 0.01758594438433647, -0.03227551281452179, -0.03290192410349846, -0.008944020606577396, 0.032185960561037064, 0.01537911407649517, 0.04356273636221886, -0.013908474706113338, -0.017133397981524467, 0.014897629618644714, 0.07576020061969757, -0.036181773990392685, 0.005000727251172066, 0.03512146323919296, -0.02855815924704075, -0.041881803423166275, 0.06171033903956413, 0.010544647462666035, 0.0354178212583065, 0.023607991635799408, 0.014757870696485043, -0.0488019697368145, 0.03755694255232811, 0.01683698408305645, -0.010706937871873379, -0.05075973644852638, 0.003870846703648567, 0.014263092540204525, 0.0109206922352314, 0.023150913417339325, 0.004616317339241505, 0.0019544712267816067, 0.015911532565951347, 0.04393141716718674, -0.004913823213428259, 0.02461344562470913, 0.022349482402205467, -0.028342608362436295, -0.055267512798309326, -0.0006558474851772189, -0.020859625190496445, 0.029946226626634598, 0.05987274646759033, -0.013441486284136772, 0.01749780960381031, 0.014381307177245617, -0.0023437095806002617, -0.07093886286020279, -0.014256861992180347, 0.0004620436520781368, 0.024289904162287712, 0.050657860934734344, -0.06888719648122787, 0.00888623297214508, 0.06188611686229706, -0.10274671018123627, 0.009051749482750893, 0.003800832899287343, -0.002877542283385992, -0.027326367795467377, -0.0004582940018735826, -0.0017750251572579145, 0.0627511665225029, 0.03440108150243759, 0.030174557119607925, 0.04022748023271561, 0.027134213596582413, -0.017430879175662994, -0.022681279107928276, -0.025381041690707207, 0.03732055798172951, 0.014937909319996834, -0.015403066761791706, 0.026644976809620857, -0.007272709161043167, -0.008145460858941078, 0.03543899208307266, -0.040489621460437775, -0.011143123731017113, -0.0008207755163311958, 0.021067529916763306, -0.00021750728774350137, 0.031133895739912987, 0.02178872562944889, -0.016378257423639297, 0.006690060719847679, 0.016674133017659187, 0.006210478954017162, 0.05048171430826187, -0.05226123332977295, -0.0049816626124084, -0.0050238557159900665, -0.02342534065246582, -0.026422681286931038, 0.02307400479912758, -0.015773093327879906, -0.0408109650015831, 0.018783820793032646, 0.006039969157427549, 0.008526957593858242, -0.025135526433587074, 0.047036878764629364, -0.014424520544707775, -0.01767777092754841, 0.030759001150727272, 0.018328137695789337, 0.003048705868422985, -0.01742487959563732, -0.02880844846367836, -0.06938602775335312, 0.006296809762716293, 0.02082543447613716, -0.03370096534490585, -0.04788301885128021, -0.030430622398853302, -0.031893230974674225, -0.019330140203237534, 0.012568413279950619, 0.018200606107711792, -0.03948694467544556, 0.04857682064175606, 0.013866250403225422, 0.021211722865700722, 0.008239414542913437, -0.005505884066224098, -0.017745651304721832, -0.08522489666938782, 0.03998659923672676, -0.013202409259974957, -0.028010660782456398, -0.045446451753377914, 0.004992558620870113, -0.026923662051558495, 0.03505087271332741, 0.04147675633430481, 0.00963178277015686, 0.02276684157550335, -0.01431861612945795, -0.01828632317483425, 0.0013971141306683421, -0.0006278150249272585, 0.038868676871061325, 0.02548189088702202, -0.016433194279670715, -0.010065439157187939, -0.032716210931539536, 0.018245737999677658, 0.01081747654825449, 0.021852510049939156, -0.036941707134246826, 0.012689854018390179, 0.0023727677762508392, -0.018949465826153755, -0.0062473532743752, 0.0162050798535347, -0.010954546742141247, 0.04939994961023331, -0.028933970257639885, -0.03307913988828659, 0.03726520761847496, -0.01010231301188469, -0.0508682020008564, 0.028362054377794266, -0.015473771840333939, -0.003367191879078746, 0.027543775737285614, 0.05820780619978905, 0.044655393809080124, -0.04722633585333824, -0.0032400782220065594, 0.014690165407955647, -0.04123784974217415, -0.04000068083405495, 0.05039500817656517, 0.04409855231642723, 0.025036947801709175, -0.005898009520024061, 0.024023322388529778, 0.022337567061185837, -0.0006230590515770018, 0.05379363149404526, 0.03066296875476837, 0.04962410777807236, 0.011177720502018929, 0.00378552358597517, 0.0022191363386809826, -0.01486927643418312, 0.031419847160577774, -0.013379630632698536, 0.061131276190280914, -0.030965568497776985, -0.008312438614666462, 0.0018616730812937021, -0.009761449880897999, 0.04323159530758858, 0.025055216625332832, -0.016000036150217056, 0.051673512905836105, -0.04345965012907982, -0.030171744525432587, -0.037168990820646286, -0.023624921217560768, -0.04288338124752045, 0.012181825004518032, 0.033307403326034546, 0.011629541404545307, 0.0284261517226696, 0.014812564477324486, -0.0071257553063333035, 0.007550088223069906, 0.01441260240972042, -0.014042557217180729, 0.01658448949456215, -0.0318540558218956, -0.011950047686696053, -0.023600956425070763, -0.020491521805524826, -0.04217066615819931, -0.017639579251408577, 0.02132418006658554, 0.040140047669410706, 0.061670929193496704, 0.017949141561985016, -0.035431914031505585, -0.026273125782608986, 0.021164219826459885, -0.06960577517747879, -0.01837567612528801, -0.03138968348503113, 0.03907317295670509, -0.012723234482109547, -0.016335979104042053 ]
<p>I'm trying to estimate how many people visited the farmers market once, twice, thrice, etc. in a given time period, using sampled data. We have interview data from approximately 50% of visitors as they entered the market which lets us identify them uniquely. For the purposes of this analysis, I'm assuming that the interviews randomly captured ~50% of visits; in reality the interviews were not random, but I want to start with a simpler problem first.</p> <p>Within this dataset, I can identify how many people visited once, twice, thrice, etc. But, intuitively, I think the nature of sampling will lead me to underestimate the number of people who visited more than once. I've tested this intuition by randomly cutting the dataset in half a few times - starting from the full dataset (50% of visits), going down to 6.25%, and find that the larger datasets have more multiple-visit people in it (see below).</p> <p>However, I am unsure what happens as I go from 50% of the visits to 100% of the visits. Can you help me come up with a statistical framework to do that projection?</p> <p>PS - I feel that the Birthday Problem is informative here, but I can't think of how to apply it!</p> <pre><code> % of visits from people who visited at most. % of visits sampled once twice thrice 6.25% 83% 96% 99% 12.50% 82% 96% 99% 25% 77% 94% 98% 50% 67% 88% 95% 100% ? ? ? </code></pre> <p>I'm trying to think about how to apply the mark-recapture framework Gael mentioned. I agree that there is a similarity if I simplify it to the percentage of all visits from individuals who visited only once -- in essence, the population size in terms of this framework. What I'm struggling with is how to think about my sampling technique. I know how many total visits there (say, 25,000). I know that out of the 12,500 visits we "marked" in a continuous 50% sampling of visits, there were about 10,000 unique individuals, with 7,000 being marked once, and the remainder being "marked" 2, 3, or more times. I can't fit this into the simple two-stage mark-recapture model, and I'm thinking I need to do some kind of a Poisson regression (based on the wikipedia entry).</p>
48,928
[ -0.0288125891238451, -0.058735497295856476, 0.0322638601064682, 0.004353331867605448, 0.03109406866133213, -0.0015003638109192252, -0.014171633869409561, -0.021652666851878166, -0.003140159882605076, 0.008672654628753662, 0.016854302957654, 0.056560344994068146, 0.02952328324317932, -0.005681718233972788, 0.03470499813556671, -0.008317260071635246, -0.04243650659918785, 0.002962286351248622, -0.027393268421292305, -0.011625922285020351, 0.004484853707253933, 0.029261525720357895, 0.03152994439005852, -0.017245113849639893, -0.07520835101604462, 0.03144107013940811, 0.03240308165550232, -0.027541590854525566, -0.010392587631940842, 0.048862524330616, -0.07064078003168106, -0.04237426817417145, 0.06518727540969849, 0.03273311257362366, 0.05281960591673851, 0.012372060678899288, -0.07077177613973618, -0.003820346901193261, -0.015906693413853645, 0.016742099076509476, -0.06091134622693062, 0.015864236280322075, -0.012305967509746552, 0.01946284808218479, 0.001759805134497583, 0.011255827732384205, -0.022706763818860054, -0.02230948396027088, 0.06757394969463348, -0.021311836317181587, 0.08239936083555222, -0.01745397038757801, -0.014792639762163162, 0.008418587036430836, 0.003645200515165925, -0.025003815069794655, 0.03038701042532921, 0.03860478848218918, 0.002500784583389759, -0.02054428867995739, -0.019040927290916443, -0.014421292580664158, -0.02812066301703453, -0.04544684290885925, -0.010740045458078384, 0.019733289256691933, -0.001053829793818295, -0.02171715348958969, 0.041242580860853195, -0.03114345483481884, 0.040898192673921585, 0.002744103316217661, 0.049625176936388016, 0.005631594453006983, 0.0007040199125185609, 0.014105974696576595, -0.00622695405036211, 0.033101338893175125, 0.06508464366197586, 0.004288507625460625, -0.00819120742380619, -0.004383891820907593, 0.016080748289823532, 0.06908291578292847, 0.07896776497364044, -0.04036574438214302, 0.025381464511156082, -0.05937156081199646, 0.02206064574420452, 0.036899443715810776, -0.00543264439329505, -0.020973287522792816, 0.04758637025952339, -0.013152533210814, -0.061107438057661057, 0.02554706670343876, -0.014832030050456524, 0.04042612016201019, -0.03467947989702225, 0.03893137350678444, -0.05013484135270119, -0.056792162358760834, -0.013791397213935852, 0.03371362015604973, -0.021303264424204826, 0.020207908004522324, -0.022178109735250473, -0.03701161965727806, -0.0039215306751430035, -0.025514042004942894, -0.02115568332374096, 0.011284461244940758, 0.05103590339422226, 0.008645167574286461, 0.0007561906240880489, 0.009894687682390213, -0.01669248379766941, -0.00793648324906826, 0.025572998449206352, 0.06165164336562157, -0.005364013835787773, -0.014978643506765366, 0.0018177760066464543, -0.07149863988161087, -0.0593712143599987, 0.02809135615825653, -0.00045431629405356944, -0.015118843875825405, -0.044803436845541, 0.03157550469040871, 0.02422325499355793, 0.003723334986716509, 0.03819558396935463, -0.02275747060775757, 0.022373195737600327, -0.015889445319771767, -0.07768596708774567, -0.051705315709114075, 0.053164031356573105, -0.01639673113822937, 0.010567164979875088, -0.06681698560714722, 0.0003357585228513926, 0.05945179611444473, 0.03280823305249214, -0.0030546991620212793, 0.012917116284370422, 0.0021492906380444765, 0.00676853209733963, 0.020016077905893326, -0.0421544574201107, -0.012536612339317799, -0.025617223232984543, -0.017466090619564056, -0.05188737064599991, -0.05266270041465759, 0.028355445712804794, 0.021720213815569878, -0.014492664486169815, -0.012477676384150982, 0.02890065126121044, 0.01175844855606556, -0.04309503734111786, -0.02317957766354084, 0.019736038520932198, -0.03067978098988533, 0.09115806221961975, 0.005066881887614727, 0.03614543378353119, 0.03842601925134659, -0.022033434361219406, 0.03871794417500496, -0.0034517189487814903, 0.030924052000045776, 0.053501565009355545, -0.014497644267976284, 0.016100071370601654, -0.0015096014831215143, -0.0007910890271887183, 0.024519653990864754, -0.006188258528709412, -0.02600844018161297, 0.014761742204427719, 0.00021007616305723786, 0.07898121327161789, 0.002757095033302903, 0.008645780384540558, -0.04370187968015671, 0.010331363417208195, -0.05536089837551117, -0.05794890969991684, -0.04905363917350769, -0.021124642342329025, -0.01722724735736847, -0.027448518201708794, 0.006934068165719509, -0.0038664424791932106, -0.0029183877632021904, 0.00005273352871881798, -0.05014244094491005, -0.02272641472518444, -0.015529858879745007, 0.027593981474637985, -0.05191439390182495, -0.0030082352459430695, 0.041358400136232376, 0.03613656386733055, 0.0000034379868338874076, 0.06540612876415253, -0.045137982815504074, -0.009553863666951656, -0.005217155907303095, -0.028539737686514854, 0.013376044109463692, -0.010726654902100563, 0.009557598270475864, 0.02275550365447998, 0.011177248321473598, -0.05729551613330841, 0.025914203375577927, -0.04931877180933952, 0.04763481393456459, 0.04740815609693527, -0.027115831151604652, -0.013380086049437523, -0.0326218381524086, 0.039604153484106064, 0.031849272549152374, -0.015932010486721992, -0.011277507059276104, -0.042115356773138046, -0.028151363134384155, 0.046058207750320435, 0.00600412068888545, -0.00044866817188449204, -0.012116600759327412, 0.07707803696393967, 0.015535463578999043, -0.0030416734516620636, 0.012019145302474499, 0.02444947324693203, 0.019727958366274834, 0.010993343777954578, -0.005451731383800507, 0.038522303104400635, 0.006892223376780748, 0.02449469268321991, -0.02245187945663929, 0.013546242378652096, 0.0066039590165019035, 0.017167018726468086, 0.0020766707602888346, -0.018744220957159996, 0.028090719133615494, -0.03567682206630707, 0.02507365122437477, 0.03633607178926468, -0.04449513182044029, 0.007409694604575634, 0.028547953814268112, 0.006958104204386473, -0.004104572348296642, -0.01985737308859825, -0.04245684668421745, -0.010271546430885792, 0.05067286267876625, -0.023387964814901352, 0.0321827158331871, 0.018528485670685768, -0.044576771557331085, 0.03283991664648056, -0.00738780340179801, -0.053243134170770645, 0.02576637454330921, 0.020906414836645126, 0.0458880290389061, 0.005991934332996607, -0.015091264620423317, -0.05006156861782074, -0.01935240440070629, -0.005836896598339081, 0.017966795712709427, 0.01203775592148304, 0.025152822956442833, -0.0805850476026535, -0.017256960272789, 0.014900327660143375, 0.009836256504058838, 0.013434174470603466, 0.016477689146995544, -0.02217835746705532, 0.015368107706308365, 0.01802411861717701, -0.06691606342792511, -0.013855909928679466, -0.04543071240186691, 0.0033802904654294252, -0.04495393484830856, 0.00844635907560587, 0.06994540244340897, 0.056444887071847916, -0.04099564254283905, 0.011427695862948895, -0.02777441032230854, -0.020032783970236778, -0.027402088046073914, -0.005128335673362017, 0.004014121368527412, -0.006188042461872101, 0.012317917309701443, 0.013169567100703716, 0.027231117710471153, -0.00539004011079669, -0.04216095060110092, -0.08085183799266815, -0.023527557030320168, -0.01389903761446476, 0.01589876413345337, 0.029497720301151276, -0.008076188154518604, 0.07561133801937103, 0.021527964621782303, -0.020888676866889, -0.014925625175237656, -0.0076889777556061745, 0.0003781147825066, -0.008080171421170235, 0.007048555184155703, 0.01526366826146841, -0.05328429862856865, -0.008795885369181633, -0.027146179229021072, 0.03760034963488579, 0.06064135581254959, -0.002395215444266796, 0.018965600058436394, 0.017536237835884094, -0.002578915562480688, 0.009375234134495258, 0.030375521630048752, 0.0013133047614246607, -0.07815347611904144, 0.024365046992897987, -0.027401264756917953, 0.022822042927145958, 0.0309766735881567, -0.02835245057940483, 0.02310694381594658, -0.003415023675188422, -0.003119013039395213, -0.03323447331786156, -0.010393412783741951, 0.01215387973934412, -0.035216011106967926, -0.015690719708800316, -0.01950834132730961, 0.0496949777007103, -0.039114661514759064, -0.028400199487805367, 0.03166661411523819, 0.03767721727490425, 0.0024130234960466623, 0.02471933513879776, -0.02385808154940605, -0.018045006319880486, 0.004256680607795715, -0.03492341935634613, 0.017971955239772797, 0.017026197165250778, 0.057662349194288254, 0.0060392762534320354, -0.00792738888412714, -0.03832104057073593, -0.012941354885697365, -0.026970071718096733, -0.010571788996458054, -0.03399859741330147, 0.038028109818696976, -0.029203109443187714, 0.04103466123342514, -0.008066817186772823, -0.027610212564468384, -0.017088716849684715, 0.026759270578622818, -0.07385389506816864, 0.01264437846839428, 0.007026210892945528, -0.011002309620380402, 0.011359687894582748, -0.061456937342882156, 0.07832075655460358, 0.01748962327837944, 0.028127234429121017, -0.010983486659824848, 0.01738118752837181, -0.024091128259897232, 0.04653090611100197, -0.024867475032806396, -0.01721605472266674, -0.01890457607805729, 0.04436102882027626, 0.0034404646139591932, 0.00810691062361002, 0.010631011798977852, 0.0321684330701828, -0.011938304640352726, -0.021064523607492447, -0.03097449243068695, -0.01486550085246563, 0.020714646205306053, 0.06861863285303116, 0.0011857523350045085, 0.03459662199020386, -0.045094236731529236, -0.02346614934504032, -0.0003617577312979847, 0.037933800369501114, 0.030900301411747932, 0.019941421225667, -0.019036944955587387, -0.03551565483212471, -0.02968834899365902, 0.02092062495648861, 0.02806703932583332, -0.03159119188785553, -0.007976836524903774, 0.05210905522108078, 0.0050230384804308414, -0.03826843574643135, 0.0021877430845052004, 0.029303699731826782, 0.013237719424068928, 0.013904150575399399, -0.010695531964302063, 0.011815277859568596, 0.0133816571906209, 0.00485248351469636, -0.03413829207420349, 0.005804418120533228, 0.027477925643324852, 0.010907506570219994, 0.03257833793759346, -0.0004014348960481584, -0.007850239053368568, 0.03654064983129501, 0.0021066355984658003, 0.03855035826563835, -0.03884277120232582, -0.03612424060702324, 0.01487138494849205, 0.013995393179357052, 0.05529200658202171, 0.05535273626446724, 0.02778151072561741, -0.0937594473361969, -0.039818666875362396, 0.04150071740150452, 0.054241571575403214, -0.05667715519666672, 0.00964708998799324, -0.04583326727151871, -0.009805896319448948, 0.0018365975702181458, -0.03746156767010689, -0.00004313377576181665, -0.007514080498367548, 0.001551461173221469, -0.02874632552266121, -0.036223143339157104, -0.04664155840873718, -0.011250014416873455, -0.04642900824546814, 0.01975122280418873, -0.01857297122478485, 0.004267859738320112, -0.06173151731491089, 0.029198644682765007, -0.005725247785449028, 0.044932544231414795, -0.024353139102458954, -0.018136993050575256, -0.003214879659935832, 0.0172133669257164, -0.04430732876062393, -0.03846266120672226, 0.020069725811481476, 0.012264225631952286, 0.020467888563871384, 0.04871330410242081, -0.006969856563955545, -0.07593981921672821, 0.03170909360051155, 0.028721889480948448, 0.011715544387698174, 0.01021632645279169, -0.06498798727989197, 0.029864680022001266, 0.0003925287164747715, -0.0050993142649531364, 0.05982351675629616, 0.010418830439448357, 0.018388235941529274, 0.04078233987092972, 0.02711407281458378, -0.0028368826024234295, -0.012691350653767586, -0.02839409001171589, -0.044210273772478104, 0.0071740164421498775, -0.036681994795799255, 0.02471630834043026, -0.02448364906013012, 0.043026551604270935, -0.042499542236328125, -0.026115810498595238, 0.019679807126522064, 0.04264901950955391, 0.016204725950956345, 0.0236935056746006, -0.010938819497823715, 0.008571288548409939, 0.0018924081232398748, 0.007172764278948307, 0.027829736471176147, -0.03815365582704544, 0.0009842109866440296, 0.004397125914692879, -0.018249012529850006, 0.01933618076145649, -0.048127368092536926, -0.02578110806643963, 0.048554740846157074, -0.026038652285933495, 0.039351243525743484, -0.059904374182224274, 0.029563572257757187, -0.0019684077706187963, -0.03120817057788372, -0.026754295453429222, 0.03426026180386543, 0.01745229959487915, 0.06331207603216171, 0.001286802114918828, 0.014197173528373241, -0.010812593623995781, -0.00845519918948412, -0.04739703983068466, -0.00453552370890975, 0.04209363833069801, 0.023271890357136726, -0.037610433995723724, -0.022902345284819603, -0.008070683106780052, 0.0017658701399341226, -0.023302078247070312, -0.026195641607046127, 0.04622919484972954, -0.014452017843723297, -0.009195508435368538, -0.0252040084451437, 0.0516432486474514, 0.07698804140090942, 0.021181032061576843, -0.015150441788136959, 0.0036691767163574696, 0.008991706185042858, -0.000139228708576411, -0.008471738547086716, -0.026496388018131256, -0.032540738582611084, -0.0369938425719738, -0.044559378176927567, -0.017701784148812294, 0.031099839136004448, -0.04072706773877144, -0.021713940426707268, 0.00439700111746788, -0.011167975142598152, -0.011004987172782421, -0.018399903550744057, -0.0070699709467589855, 0.02235821634531021, 0.013279548846185207, -0.030199509114027023, 0.049408525228500366, 0.001907405094243586, 0.013626453466713428, 0.05444861203432083, -0.01939844898879528, -0.03938689082860947, -0.01074402779340744, 0.0453733429312706, -0.034673843532800674, 0.0024542687460780144, -0.006046739872545004, -0.01027737557888031, 0.02600090019404888, -0.02626827359199524, 0.010240317322313786, 0.015146506018936634, 0.03472764045000076, -0.02269774302840233, -0.018040986731648445, -0.04424532875418663, -0.000016701324057066813, 0.044802095741033554, 0.021559275686740875, 0.016521112993359566, 0.005846541374921799, 0.013784443959593773, -0.00045946153113618493, 0.02106761932373047, -0.005180160515010357, -0.014769583940505981, -0.007800175342708826, 0.05420110374689102, 0.007484026253223419, -0.01648687571287155, 0.0553932748734951, -0.005550182890146971, 0.041234344244003296, 0.05292739346623421, 0.00899045541882515, 0.02016269974410534, 0.02558605931699276, -0.05950351804494858, -0.0373217798769474, 0.008902132511138916, -0.017174985259771347, 0.011982866562902927, -0.04230566322803497, -0.033870257437229156, 0.06920363754034042, 0.04974224790930748, 0.004670831374824047, -0.030228402465581894, -0.05781424418091774, -0.07687176018953323, 0.008476882241666317, 0.026563450694084167, 0.019825037568807602, 0.02003241889178753, -0.0342874675989151, -0.015866156667470932, -0.014758721925318241, 0.009780654683709145, -0.018552478402853012, -0.021247243508696556, -0.011097314767539501, -0.03680965304374695, -0.05630561336874962, 0.01765117049217224, -0.008509408682584763, 0.00732411677017808, -0.000027374670025892556, -0.031315118074417114, 0.02136075496673584, 0.03435803949832916, 0.025988373905420303, -0.025452081114053726, 0.07104349881410599, 0.04819653555750847, 0.022735295817255974, -0.026956086978316307, 0.02641586773097515, 0.1371309459209442, 0.06681454181671143, -0.0021391601767390966, -0.028469143435359, 0.009708558209240437, 0.028254780918359756, 0.010830195620656013, -0.015417007729411125, 0.006239836569875479, 0.01566414348781109, -0.007151229307055473, 0.0637391209602356, 0.035355497151613235, -0.01902564987540245, 0.017311643809080124, 0.03717902675271034, -0.008497137576341629, 0.011816684156656265, 0.00008282568887807429, 0.015553014352917671, 0.014781102538108826, -0.021724224090576172, -0.03235739469528198, 0.017531931400299072, 0.028913607820868492, 0.01399739645421505, 0.007864977233111858, -0.03333096206188202, -0.05243571102619171, -0.012896486558020115, 0.025041166692972183, 0.01921149343252182, -0.023254308849573135, 0.006556451320648193, -0.004374431911855936, 0.007122065406292677, 0.023311426863074303, -0.04556039348244667, 0.02371044084429741, 0.050741612911224365, -0.014215304516255856, -0.0013239146210253239, -0.014099889434874058, 0.04987277090549469, -0.0339917317032814, -0.043563276529312134, -0.053247708827257156, 0.03766408562660217, -0.016822095960378647, -0.013856269419193268, -0.009986651130020618, -0.01495692040771246, 0.02533688209950924, -0.048294976353645325, -0.019945474341511726, 0.0027644855435937643, 0.004600245971232653, -0.03165574371814728, -0.03719625622034073, -0.0012403636937960982, 0.013686197809875011, 0.031136533245444298, 0.005897797178477049, 0.018342899158596992, -0.039658911526203156, -0.025135736912488937, -0.03196622431278229, 0.020615624263882637, 0.020873671397566795, -0.00018566468497738242, 0.0070500364527106285, -0.0378614105284214, -0.050664544105529785, 0.024534983560442924, -0.0299331396818161, 0.015333164483308792, 0.028109658509492874, -0.021425791084766388, -0.005239404272288084, -0.02106858231127262, 0.02796870656311512, 0.0583350770175457, -0.025356508791446686, -0.015900718048214912, -0.022248342633247375, 0.017303911969065666, 0.010306477546691895, 0.05545617267489433, 0.01409558579325676, 0.04732675477862358, -0.0027725754771381617, 0.08371949195861816, -0.006657180842012167, -0.037955623120069504, 0.005461499094963074, -0.03507298603653908, -0.036486245691776276, 0.014237062074244022, -0.010902149602770805, 0.059176795184612274, 0.03146432340145111, -0.017115915194153786, 0.02380053512752056, 0.027543285861611366, 0.00006308258889475837, 0.03001485951244831, 0.014301588758826256, -0.0607755221426487, -0.0067936875857412815, 0.006581039633601904, -0.0206767525523901, -0.026838203892111778, -0.04080331698060036, -0.009681320749223232, -0.02401411347091198, -0.04672306030988693, -0.030055126175284386, -0.03905933350324631, 0.00958859734237194, -0.010610746219754219, 0.022459102794528008, 0.013835357502102852, -0.03257831186056137, 0.004077292513102293, -0.004180623218417168, -0.0365375392138958, -0.03299367427825928, -0.012533126398921013, 0.010363033972680569, 0.011618339456617832, 0.01944764330983162, 0.02891426533460617, 0.0034760767593979836, 0.0060228947550058365, -0.011490936391055584, 0.039593636989593506, 0.0024479907006025314, -0.011433870531618595, 0.0001314463297603652, -0.009481976740062237, 0.05995342507958412, -0.007476635277271271, -0.043551042675971985, 0.0023962894920259714, 0.008099563419818878, 0.05308696627616882, 0.023169241845607758, -0.0035981901455670595, -0.008699892088770866, 0.027235163375735283, -0.008816736750304699, -0.030919115990400314, -0.03133897855877876, 0.06301666796207428, 0.038965195417404175, -0.03397214785218239, 0.01602471061050892, 0.02478417567908764, -0.013304922729730606, 0.003931534942239523, 0.005377730820327997, -0.03397969529032707, 0.0031896671280264854, 0.009967650286853313, -0.025189395993947983, 0.003245385829359293, -0.017930807545781136, -0.003199513303115964, 0.024656042456626892, 0.04474763944745064, -0.0190290417522192, 0.009507314302027225, -0.03412014991044998, -0.017229966819286346, -0.01807260327041149, -0.01949692703783512, -0.005761354696005583, 0.022903993725776672, 0.041769761592149734, -0.05207478255033493, -0.010767375119030476, 0.045635271817445755, -0.06960132718086243, 0.03589747101068497, 0.014584456570446491, 0.03040136769413948, -0.020260510966181755, 0.020837854593992233, -0.02414778433740139, 0.0021198182366788387, 0.021931985393166542, 0.023694423958659172, 0.03524836152791977, 0.0685635581612587, 0.008043153211474419, -0.04382999241352081, -0.02998037450015545, 0.006863452959805727, 0.005846172571182251, -0.05032211169600487, 0.055838800966739655, -0.056275855749845505, -0.004053936805576086, 0.05520189180970192, -0.019271787256002426, 0.02520936354994774, 0.026915336027741432, 0.02919173613190651, 0.03194249048829079, 0.03881196677684784, 0.05325353145599365, 0.005892022047191858, 0.0003971246478613466, -0.0075800614431500435, 0.00739258574321866, 0.030717086046934128, -0.0005854819901287556, 0.011018129996955395, 0.04708843305706978, 0.020038504153490067, -0.024746138602495193, 0.014113928191363811, 0.0021768829319626093, 0.008613207377493382, 0.008455026894807816, 0.015766913071274757, -0.0027431498747318983, 0.011816652491688728, 0.022663280367851257, -0.05701610818505287, 0.0173600222915411, 0.026501096785068512, -0.0059987329877913, -0.017073165625333786, -0.002156252972781658, -0.024180511012673378, -0.05237419530749321, 0.06713107228279114, -0.0008693187846802175, -0.000696469796821475, -0.06180446222424507, -0.004289289936423302, 0.011529635637998581, 0.01985963061451912, -0.013292214833199978, 0.002511201426386833, -0.02254495583474636, 0.026365727186203003, 0.0025835824199020863, 0.027771320194005966, 0.01648128777742386, 0.006065913941711187, 0.021804925054311752, -0.09932689368724823, 0.07684441655874252, 0.014687977731227875, -0.006427481304854155, -0.06187399476766586, -0.057663727551698685, -0.006377841345965862, 0.021678786724805832, 0.06124154478311539, 0.003867605933919549, 0.012871443293988705, 0.020330293104052544, 0.021338673308491707, 0.019268715754151344, -0.05329226702451706, 0.04113109037280083, -0.04171270877122879, 0.014760923571884632, 0.006647897884249687, -0.025488410145044327, -0.011995497159659863, -0.008283644914627075, 0.007593938615173101, -0.0024144831113517284, -0.025028377771377563, -0.008938689716160297, 0.0019754564855247736, 0.039229609072208405, 0.01815369352698326, -0.0006489201332442462, -0.013589616864919662, 0.01380337867885828, -0.004130367189645767, 0.02915889024734497, -0.03915802389383316, -0.07356034964323044, 0.008398612029850483, -0.06040220335125923, -0.027960212901234627, 0.025488009676337242, 0.005292033776640892, -0.025317393243312836, -0.006571749225258827, 0.0060782236978411674, -0.014584497548639774, -0.0032338895834982395, 0.008205038495361805, 0.03109152801334858, 0.032742153853178024, 0.03669945150613785, 0.011520945467054844, 0.033122092485427856, 0.00021085559274069965, 0.00009482481254963204, -0.018522322177886963, 0.00032545995782129467, -0.008427238091826439, -0.005965249612927437, 0.0016566731501370668, 0.02756183221936226, 0.040409963577985764, 0.01631319709122181, 0.025258293375372887, 0.014483102597296238, -0.04605448991060257, -0.032791271805763245, 0.033491797745227814, -0.010510205291211605, -0.008397562429308891, 0.02501753903925419, -0.007291199639439583, 0.048145756125450134, 0.04203692823648453, 0.0007631343905813992, -0.009901282377541065, 0.00038088540895842016, -0.014261895790696144, 0.012522976845502853, -0.011743873357772827, 0.02857232466340065, -0.04092305898666382, 0.07089776545763016, -0.011240659281611443, 0.019288545474410057, 0.029516145586967468, -0.021800916641950607, 0.0087961470708251, 0.006090573966503143, -0.015339781530201435, -0.03212432190775871, -0.03216724842786789, -0.01922665350139141, -0.021908197551965714, 0.02260255627334118, 0.03424753248691559, 0.01859174855053425, 0.023927778005599976, -0.0009188251569867134, 0.04118356481194496, 0.021771972998976707, -0.061240583658218384, -0.03302443027496338, -0.04273767024278641, 0.015757260844111443, 0.007420704234391451, -0.0484948605298996 ]
<p>It is standard advice to set a random seed so that results can be reproduced. However, since the seed is advanced as pseudo-random numbers are drawn, the results could change if <em>any</em> piece of code draws an additional number.</p> <p>At first glance, version control looks to be a solution to this, as it would at least allow you to go back and reproduce the version extant when you wrote down the results in your notes or paper. However, since it only takes one draw to mess things up, if you update R the results could change as well.</p> <p>I realize that this is probably only problematic in rare cases, but I'm curious if there are any best practices here. This is something I've been struggling with in my own work.</p>
48,930
[ -0.027041489258408546, 0.0087510971352458, -0.025493349879980087, -0.02730764076113701, 0.006501528434455395, 0.0010222990531474352, -0.00023348706599790603, 0.006740223616361618, 0.012223418802022934, -0.02452053129673004, 0.034154221415519714, 0.05024685338139534, 0.03910837322473526, 0.017375068739056587, 0.010752994567155838, -0.011014275252819061, 0.009766070172190666, -0.018548717722296715, -0.015448072925209999, -0.012610018253326416, 0.0030462031718343496, 0.02450750768184662, -0.025131266564130783, -0.02262684516608715, -0.032882656902074814, 0.03058476932346821, 0.05478798225522041, 0.0029685425106436014, 0.010865014046430588, 0.05886349827051163, -0.06170850992202759, -0.030233535915613174, 0.04046307131648064, 0.04913998022675514, 0.041261617094278336, -0.0023591944482177496, 0.00038621932617388666, -0.05296248197555542, -0.015403524041175842, 0.009836459532380104, -0.020762870088219643, 0.04268496111035347, -0.020048465579748154, 0.05472036451101303, 0.002103105653077364, 0.0300698634237051, -0.022237837314605713, -0.017539309337735176, 0.061994023621082306, 0.009796142578125, 0.04230199754238129, 0.01123051531612873, 0.006846166215837002, 0.04953263700008392, -0.0448559895157814, 0.034962788224220276, 0.055421359837055206, 0.04716590791940689, 0.009058591909706593, -0.0205147173255682, 0.012159408070147038, -0.045876383781433105, 0.0015607144450768828, 0.001632253872230649, -0.04061800613999367, 0.01694350503385067, 0.003457677084952593, 0.003530635731294751, 0.008301261812448502, -0.0502794086933136, 0.030828211456537247, 0.04501811042428017, 0.03901798278093338, -0.007223181892186403, 0.03540065512061119, -0.025520045310258865, 0.013506578281521797, -0.0060519445687532425, 0.04897234961390495, 0.03138243779540062, -0.01588481292128563, 0.032485079020261765, 0.0347578190267086, 0.043755125254392624, 0.03490564227104187, -0.021506331861019135, 0.04086616262793541, -0.004792320542037487, 0.05190093442797661, 0.031795650720596313, 0.012216559611260891, -0.024662837386131287, 0.07676000148057938, 0.009790413081645966, -0.05145435035228729, 0.010221724398434162, -0.03368959575891495, 0.027880890294909477, -0.0210228580981493, -0.01967834308743477, 0.010505786165595055, -0.05694347620010376, 0.02708224207162857, 0.04298221692442894, -0.03723699599504471, -0.038042545318603516, -0.03374790772795677, -0.033705566078424454, 0.007652602158486843, -0.018312059342861176, 0.012741929851472378, 0.005397208966314793, -0.0036752955056726933, -0.008900783024728298, 0.0055280206725001335, 0.004934072960168123, 0.011424509808421135, 0.009010378271341324, 0.08395040035247803, 0.04296593740582466, 0.00276961294002831, -0.03689802065491676, 0.07766827940940857, -0.04201500117778778, -0.006872070953249931, 0.010035660117864609, 0.03416358307003975, -0.030830156058073044, -0.05591456592082977, 0.06447263062000275, -0.006032588891685009, -0.006512150168418884, 0.025293679907917976, -0.013159246183931828, 0.026850786060094833, 0.015822211280465126, -0.0955231711268425, -0.08030370622873306, 0.06093088909983635, 0.005583456717431545, 0.007691096980124712, -0.08062732219696045, -0.007943326607346535, 0.02411617338657379, 0.035195279866456985, -0.016561206430196762, 0.00556583097204566, -0.0012246575206518173, 0.022275811061263084, -0.00914639700204134, 0.007978909648954868, -0.016681358218193054, -0.023907748982310295, -0.04475311562418938, -0.043106649070978165, -0.03170613572001457, 0.031120479106903076, 0.01749296300113201, -0.0010269051417708397, -0.009080345742404461, 0.028310345485806465, -0.02350015379488468, 0.033967163413763046, -0.0178522951900959, 0.018124723806977272, -0.04800678789615631, 0.10952157527208328, 0.027778610587120056, 0.00041798624442890286, -0.010816756635904312, -0.019009852781891823, 0.024902919307351112, 0.021232109516859055, 0.02501113899052143, 0.041470516473054886, -0.04316075146198273, 0.05040740594267845, -0.02839418686926365, 0.02410399541258812, 0.004646269138902426, -0.024150487035512924, 0.011930547654628754, 0.01889878325164318, -0.029629496857523918, 0.020200926810503006, 0.01077171228826046, 0.010497781448066235, 0.005798605736345053, 0.03496472164988518, -0.052182383835315704, -0.003996253479272127, -0.0810086652636528, 0.029567087069153786, 0.033245377242565155, 0.003404909046366811, -0.004802231676876545, 0.015994330868124962, 0.049840688705444336, 0.0017165940953418612, -0.01822974719107151, 0.00028392061358317733, 0.011834805831313133, 0.02966190129518509, -0.04376834258437157, -0.03631822392344475, 0.0539579838514328, 0.04103315994143486, -0.0030365856364369392, 0.028339358046650887, -0.014127550646662712, -0.06317242234945297, -0.003945373930037022, -0.04450619965791702, 0.03598283603787422, -0.02470462955534458, -0.004951941315084696, -0.0009581077611073852, 0.016820209100842476, -0.012676839716732502, 0.00998428463935852, -0.023487387225031853, 0.03914899751543999, 0.053970854729413986, 0.034569501876831055, -0.02032794989645481, 0.004857331048697233, 0.012919813394546509, 0.007458520587533712, -0.018363434821367264, -0.029350100085139275, -0.03788328543305397, 0.009660002775490284, 0.042688626796007156, 0.0005281955818645656, -0.031631555408239365, 0.02731780894100666, 0.03718515858054161, 0.01886359602212906, 0.008827246725559235, 0.03687632083892822, 0.00703600887209177, -0.005166333634406328, -0.0017131264321506023, 0.0009173416765406728, 0.06266946345567703, 0.022057142108678818, 0.04997822269797325, 0.01239088550209999, 0.003956484142690897, 0.0030008319299668074, 0.0030283501837402582, -0.012746704742312431, 0.005812615621834993, -0.013695484027266502, -0.03405299410223961, -0.0032755068968981504, 0.03558110073208809, -0.0376945398747921, -0.005890889558941126, 0.006671322509646416, 0.03606066852807999, -0.028721675276756287, 0.004432773683220148, -0.029607513919472694, 0.004910592921078205, 0.021512597799301147, -0.062360141426324844, -0.02724483236670494, 0.01152739580720663, 0.007146256044507027, 0.02878010831773281, -0.054958194494247437, -0.024663258343935013, -0.02947888895869255, 0.04921073466539383, -0.0037641809321939945, -0.02551780641078949, 0.01916099153459072, -0.012275159358978271, -0.014201396144926548, -0.03331073746085167, 0.028001919388771057, 0.013813699595630169, -0.0006597304600290954, -0.04393528401851654, 0.004555224906653166, 0.00396281061694026, -0.0234700758010149, 0.025234481319785118, -0.002147445222362876, -0.016082709655165672, 0.04023183137178421, 0.014456512406468391, -0.05133102089166641, -0.022680997848510742, -0.04755542427301407, -0.01949087344110012, -0.0414576381444931, -0.02768743969500065, 0.055176082998514175, -0.010348599404096603, -0.03483754023909569, 0.05245886743068695, -0.008116427809000015, 0.012385173700749874, 0.010477104224264622, -0.0028583260718733072, 0.029585709795355797, 0.016793616116046906, 0.028731008991599083, 0.03279481455683708, -0.02018595114350319, -0.04141198843717575, -0.058732520788908005, -0.08762552589178085, -0.020802924409508705, -0.03244757279753685, 0.06216753274202347, -0.008192689158022404, 0.018424738198518753, 0.0656549409031868, 0.02809087559580803, -0.005097554996609688, -0.017091693356633186, -0.00020729057723656297, 0.02128496579825878, -0.04016263410449028, 0.0018941729795187712, -0.0021515488624572754, -0.013880876824259758, 0.0006663545500487089, -0.026633700355887413, 0.02442672662436962, 0.06407350301742554, -0.020298393443226814, -0.024970123544335365, 0.002022339263930917, 0.01149111520498991, -0.004335251171141863, -0.006765403784811497, 0.01775083690881729, -0.011993172578513622, 0.005997701548039913, -0.02215990051627159, 0.054405760020017624, -0.006624002009630203, 0.0029637960251420736, 0.00027972974930889904, 0.0015858523547649384, 0.06532124429941177, -0.03324577957391739, 0.045038364827632904, 0.014110955409705639, -0.031007815152406693, -0.000626763969194144, 0.007569241337478161, 0.050590191036462784, -0.02598821558058262, 0.008434818126261234, 0.0020006021950393915, 0.0390503965318203, -0.02407151460647583, 0.015566518530249596, -0.009678938426077366, 0.012790179811418056, 0.019201697781682014, -0.01123468391597271, 0.0286739319562912, 0.040571294724941254, -0.02174658328294754, 0.015720143914222717, -0.016871564090251923, -0.05051690340042114, 0.0046272873878479, -0.05530986189842224, 0.0077930050902068615, -0.02730715461075306, 0.0239118579775095, -0.0008482218836434186, 0.03881087899208069, 0.023165782913565636, -0.006935497745871544, 0.028096431866288185, -0.015255679376423359, -0.0837540328502655, 0.006734974682331085, -0.021559979766607285, -0.009383452124893665, -0.039698101580142975, 0.0026352491695433855, 0.020100915804505348, -0.015139476396143436, -0.013168257661163807, 0.021387554705142975, -0.019590849056839943, -0.004379224963486195, 0.028834430500864983, -0.03384602814912796, -0.017006369307637215, -0.01109751034528017, 0.013902897015213966, 0.03719819337129593, -0.006662861909717321, 0.0501386858522892, 0.020011531189084053, -0.012987246736884117, -0.0446184016764164, -0.0402400828897953, -0.01100381463766098, 0.0022578295320272446, 0.043342817574739456, 0.022267689928412437, 0.012811342254281044, -0.051229022443294525, 0.04244823381304741, 0.018673516809940338, 0.043569378554821014, 0.05969303473830223, -0.0033756818156689405, -0.01246650516986847, -0.024253785610198975, 0.0006086320499889553, 0.019129663705825806, -0.02929345704615116, -0.02311662584543228, 0.029168639332056046, 0.028358617797493935, 0.022320332005620003, -0.03352231904864311, 0.0100772175937891, 0.051253579556941986, -0.015356847085058689, -0.01488849800080061, -0.011336428113281727, 0.022804642096161842, 0.02269737794995308, -0.04096046835184097, -0.03040522336959839, 0.04773944988846779, 0.004403572529554367, -0.007318663410842419, 0.0018661417998373508, -0.03897346183657646, -0.03715640306472778, -0.04344788193702698, -0.016253529116511345, 0.05050935968756676, 0.004497639834880829, 0.0215994194149971, 0.026232410222291946, 0.025246642529964447, -0.00006100984683143906, 0.029037918895483017, -0.03371787816286087, -0.056205980479717255, -0.02948109619319439, 0.06717678159475327, 0.04040269926190376, -0.051232948899269104, 0.0072054131887853146, -0.06920246034860611, -0.022620616480708122, 0.05557878315448761, -0.04995040223002434, 0.006843289826065302, -0.006756881717592478, -0.009709048084914684, -0.012043789029121399, -0.014552785083651543, -0.05632825568318367, 0.028986264020204544, -0.02986374869942665, 0.05810057371854782, -0.022238507866859436, 0.007735635153949261, -0.029635075479745865, 0.0408196747303009, 0.0014966395683586597, 0.0678582563996315, -0.037707287818193436, -0.023053312674164772, -0.027261432260274887, -0.014684855006635189, -0.01455642469227314, -0.04184574633836746, 0.000126553641166538, -0.0037632277235388756, 0.009075872600078583, 0.047861505299806595, -0.02055388316512108, -0.05643871799111366, 0.04237181320786476, 0.020514553412795067, -0.02577185072004795, -0.024231553077697754, -0.018413349986076355, 0.024827484041452408, 0.06028693541884422, 0.01777604967355728, 0.0399201475083828, 0.03653452545404434, 0.039958931505680084, 0.011349153704941273, -0.023336121812462807, 0.0006056975107640028, -0.04768399894237518, 0.001897661597467959, -0.04991956800222397, -0.019569316878914833, -0.02999919466674328, 0.04219542816281319, 0.038862183690071106, 0.017551613971590996, -0.017577562481164932, 0.016216840595006943, 0.025705300271511078, 0.03557715192437172, -0.004680518060922623, 0.0030947551131248474, 0.04298283904790878, -0.006228150799870491, -0.04885302111506462, 0.03423134982585907, 0.02192620187997818, -0.0026495319325476885, 0.0010683657601475716, 0.03750908374786377, -0.06416203826665878, 0.04163765907287598, -0.0026065632700920105, -0.010215508751571178, 0.04042768478393555, -0.02960878051817417, 0.035269979387521744, -0.00438406877219677, 0.03710466995835304, -0.001373524428345263, -0.045285873115062714, 0.010390575043857098, 0.03350629657506943, -0.018200192600488663, -0.012517780065536499, -0.03751300275325775, 0.047620587050914764, -0.020148973912000656, 0.00871950015425682, -0.055628784000873566, -0.041671834886074066, -0.008010475896298885, -0.017733875662088394, -0.018387245014309883, -0.02251296117901802, -0.0016992826713249087, -0.019889499992132187, 0.03565268963575363, -0.019907575100660324, 0.045042477548122406, -0.01569965109229088, -0.045377686619758606, -0.017693674191832542, 0.03692729026079178, 0.10283555835485458, -0.056965433061122894, 0.0010973012540489435, 0.004408081062138081, -0.027288086712360382, -0.0017593152588233352, 0.008868847042322159, 0.018519500270485878, -0.039019498974084854, -0.0009733681799843907, 0.0046521262265741825, 0.012591908685863018, 0.042274098843336105, -0.00678666215389967, -0.022313086315989494, 0.02969764918088913, -0.028702300041913986, 0.0379963293671608, -0.04866190627217293, 0.008298845030367374, -0.009324020706117153, -0.001967795193195343, -0.03219049796462059, -0.0160681139677763, 0.027139734476804733, -0.028193403035402298, -0.023371897637844086, 0.027235927060246468, -0.017558319494128227, 0.005006156861782074, 0.06905137747526169, -0.023326164111495018, -0.007633280009031296, -0.01197850238531828, -0.044998351484537125, 0.018650267273187637, 0.0073227952234447, 0.013207092881202698, -0.014781124889850616, -0.004150324035435915, -0.05068226531147957, -0.019862990826368332, 0.011320398189127445, -0.02162882499396801, 0.0356094166636467, -0.011019420810043812, 0.037364326417446136, 0.04533389210700989, 0.027632031589746475, 0.0048987180925905704, 0.005809993017464876, -0.0311078280210495, -0.03523873910307884, -0.0018673017621040344, 0.052780937403440475, 0.012485054321587086, -0.007587623782455921, -0.013671968132257462, 0.014458372257649899, 0.028992662206292152, 0.04440312087535858, 0.0032599051482975483, -0.0009584079962223768, 0.032890647649765015, -0.039646733552217484, -0.01683865860104561, 0.02048218622803688, -0.043736156076192856, 0.04239298030734062, -0.006975345313549042, -0.009103471413254738, 0.03303767740726471, 0.020522866398096085, -0.013629126362502575, -0.017250381410121918, -0.0124385179951787, -0.043086081743240356, 0.0009897410636767745, 0.011395360343158245, -0.02647247165441513, 0.03767619654536247, -0.033107541501522064, 0.0032045822590589523, 0.0036904700100421906, 0.017840851098299026, -0.05984687805175781, -0.06856556236743927, -0.016658814623951912, -0.049987442791461945, -0.015491249971091747, 0.03891301155090332, 0.036515794694423676, -0.014977234415709972, 0.01211834792047739, -0.018792424350976944, 0.019065774977207184, 0.009556886740028858, 0.05150991678237915, -0.010392396710813046, 0.07137712091207504, -0.0025655089411884546, 0.012320703826844692, -0.0349302813410759, 0.012492246925830841, 0.11542414873838425, 0.09153103828430176, 0.07084479182958603, -0.04188020899891853, 0.02650138922035694, -0.016359029337763786, 0.015411538071930408, 0.006992250680923462, 0.01606491208076477, -0.025496963411569595, -0.005914837587624788, 0.06868753582239151, 0.025217583402991295, -0.020617738366127014, 0.06387758255004883, 0.02365724928677082, -0.06122876703739166, -0.012681053020060062, -0.005251666996628046, 0.027084244415163994, 0.041299983859062195, -0.012002980336546898, -0.055811233818531036, -0.01109106931835413, 0.02898418717086315, -0.0033093125093728304, -0.006390466820448637, -0.04609014466404915, 0.007338783238083124, 0.02207578904926777, -0.005070613231509924, -0.020344847813248634, 0.00210098410025239, 0.0306379571557045, 0.02205068990588188, -0.0021991259418427944, 0.01784282736480236, -0.009521642699837685, 0.01988341473042965, 0.08595240861177444, 0.03464818373322487, 0.005037109367549419, -0.03321973234415054, 0.038010403513908386, -0.028343478217720985, -0.024351248517632484, -0.010331498458981514, 0.004711525980383158, -0.05130466818809509, -0.013665905222296715, -0.03764168173074722, 0.004474142100661993, 0.010857983492314816, -0.052578289061784744, -0.07250991463661194, 0.05049331858754158, -0.008917628787457943, 0.00007923888188088313, -0.009612076915800571, -0.01253561768680811, 0.024595653638243675, -0.023994509130716324, 0.030281146988272667, 0.01861676573753357, -0.05488347262144089, 0.00007158773223636672, -0.024696625769138336, 0.04225721210241318, 0.02343663014471531, 0.014730315655469894, -0.014747955836355686, -0.014570536091923714, -0.01705891452729702, -0.017671359702944756, -0.005532501265406609, 0.008161374367773533, -0.011976177804172039, -0.011622728779911995, 0.03254219889640808, 0.001238346565514803, -0.03100072406232357, 0.02960946224629879, 0.004412385635077953, 0.025062650442123413, -0.04242166876792908, -0.009672451764345169, 0.031489986926317215, 0.039803728461265564, 0.019417934119701385, -0.011501598171889782, -0.0014066915027797222, 0.057559479027986526, 0.018256912007927895, -0.03954707086086273, 0.019681338220834732, 0.0027489273343235254, -0.052360255271196365, -0.030617767944931984, -0.023894427344202995, 0.04402947053313255, -0.005619478411972523, 0.019241297617554665, 0.012782552279531956, 0.03570495545864105, 0.015235617756843567, 0.023366404697299004, 0.002073473297059536, -0.05879057198762894, -0.04280233383178711, -0.02129306271672249, -0.029272237792611122, -0.043086376041173935, -0.02173169143497944, -0.03760037571191788, -0.027452388778328896, -0.016430389136075974, -0.02097349241375923, -0.05064588412642479, 0.017986752092838287, -0.02783460170030594, 0.0023384548258036375, 0.004913656041026115, -0.008464055135846138, -0.011752896010875702, -0.03609732165932655, -0.009335009381175041, -0.05513979494571686, 0.01527395285665989, 0.046811677515506744, 0.0035685370676219463, 0.033416543155908585, 0.019442416727542877, -0.014942743815481663, 0.025383658707141876, -0.007363839540630579, -0.00031770605710335076, 0.00257706712000072, 0.040159616619348526, -0.04574888199567795, -0.059782687574625015, 0.01827680878341198, -0.04382088780403137, -0.033318892121315, -0.002488591941073537, -0.03452868014574051, 0.012358153238892555, 0.016605902463197708, -0.03781743720173836, -0.00615127757191658, 0.04119770601391792, -0.01900886930525303, -0.021726414561271667, -0.001112024299800396, 0.02479422837495804, 0.012318986468017101, 0.030915118753910065, 0.014246758073568344, -0.04591361805796623, -0.006565042305737734, 0.006226962897926569, 0.048415880650281906, 0.01040894165635109, 0.0009243302629329264, 0.018719250336289406, -0.022585008293390274, -0.006875911261886358, -0.004586702678352594, -0.015439465641975403, 0.017412984743714333, 0.04597298055887222, -0.026424391195178032, 0.03142866864800453, 0.012490496970713139, -0.0023166502360254526, -0.10807587206363678, -0.014860415831208229, 0.019774289801716805, -0.021330581977963448, -0.017169835045933723, -0.04698449373245239, -0.01815911941230297, 0.03457631915807724, -0.05379583314061165, 0.025854863226413727, -0.02458776906132698, -0.027190392836928368, -0.042608559131622314, 0.027966247871518135, -0.03759276866912842, 0.04076173156499863, 0.04590660333633423, 0.02747367136180401, 0.03433174267411232, 0.009498024359345436, -0.006861237809062004, -0.01532706432044506, -0.03119286149740219, 0.021088911220431328, -0.002011986216530204, -0.02494286186993122, 0.015903683379292488, -0.02271449752151966, -0.038894880563020706, -0.008561316877603531, -0.03416891396045685, -0.010961678810417652, 0.011451361700892448, 0.028809841722249985, 0.01749727502465248, 0.04978819936513901, 0.03465962037444115, -0.026382287964224815, -0.054677486419677734, -0.02774040214717388, 0.016392942517995834, 0.01553565263748169, -0.018563322722911835, 0.027701381593942642, 0.020952893421053886, 0.004279023502022028, -0.008361871354281902, 0.037263836711645126, -0.049489304423332214, -0.004066471941769123, -0.0027568365912884474, 0.022756565362215042, 0.005772783886641264, 0.005106138065457344, 0.018679464235901833, -0.039713114500045776, 0.014094474725425243, 0.048000503331422806, 0.022070497274398804, -0.010954849421977997, 0.03641189634799957, -0.029374444857239723, -0.01906493306159973, -0.011718104593455791, -0.010193617083132267, -0.027066297829151154, -0.07451863586902618, 0.011028474196791649, 0.008419071324169636, 0.010448209010064602, -0.015178296715021133, -0.05075177550315857, 0.0040710074827075005, 0.040887653827667236, 0.03665079548954964, 0.011876357719302177, 0.013668203726410866, -0.006579731125384569, 0.008531632833182812, -0.06739593297243118, 0.04842410236597061, 0.0002392030437476933, -0.014933190308511257, -0.052021294832229614, -0.012794134207069874, -0.020480768755078316, 0.04796014353632927, 0.05180230736732483, 0.01572313904762268, 0.0005312111461535096, 0.007977105677127838, 0.0120115727186203, 0.015468626283109188, -0.04430364444851875, 0.03287263587117195, 0.004960163030773401, 0.02406933903694153, -0.03462325781583786, -0.020316405221819878, -0.007784496992826462, 0.04611999914050102, 0.0032212950754910707, -0.027331124991178513, 0.02047664113342762, 0.020711472257971764, 0.007843074388802052, 0.046693045645952225, -0.00013177304936107248, -0.03562275692820549, 0.013589904643595219, -0.006729053799062967, -0.02176618203520775, 0.004259822890162468, 0.024073705077171326, -0.04091234877705574, 0.04240018501877785, -0.04169465973973274, -0.029568839818239212, -0.0017891486641019583, -0.023199111223220825, -0.000727901584468782, -0.025677407160401344, -0.01280039083212614, 0.015217239037156105, -0.043815240263938904, 0.015899507328867912, 0.021617218852043152, 0.024448508396744728, 0.040115244686603546, 0.02908170595765114, 0.008253388106822968, -0.008015664294362068, 0.012377277947962284, -0.046236276626586914, -0.018416913226246834, -0.001811978523619473, -0.019184526056051254, 0.023200443014502525, 0.010366997681558132, -0.010902955196797848, 0.02691587060689926, 0.01761736534535885, 0.06981368362903595, -0.04607957974076271, 0.004142349120229483, 0.013809333555400372, -0.05227460339665413, 0.004847581498324871, -0.03126712143421173, -0.006777463015168905, 0.02915412187576294, 0.021669110283255577, 0.026305414736270905, -0.0713961124420166, -0.0070693353191018105, -0.017594750970602036, 0.00330720073543489, -0.005319610238075256, 0.06423017382621765, 0.00490498635917902, 0.008041679859161377, -0.002770855091512203, 0.004206676967442036, 0.06781800091266632, -0.00532295648008585, 0.047358546406030655, -0.029499609023332596, 0.00045847208821214736, -0.03383143991231918, 0.013388210907578468, -0.037729449570178986, -0.009460048750042915, 0.0651305541396141, 0.0022034598514437675, 0.004659599158912897, -0.015033085830509663, -0.06350656598806381, 0.014756984077394009, 0.032785817980766296, -0.03304428979754448, -0.033229418098926544, -0.026148386299610138, 0.080860935151577, -0.014280717819929123, -0.048156075179576874 ]
<p>Given an analysis of every pair of competitors in a race, how may I determine the probability of any given competitor winning the race?</p> <p>For example, what is the probability of competitor 2 winning the following race? P(Cx Win) means the probability of Competitor x winning.</p> <pre> Cx Cy P(Cx Win) P(Cy Win) ---------------------------------- 1 2 0.3 0.7 1 3 0.4 0.6 1 4 0.9 0.1 2 3 0.8 0.2 2 4 0.7 0.3 3 4 0.9 0.1 </pre> <p>I have tried to calculate a 'rating' for each competitor by adding their individual win probabilities. For example the rating for C1 would be 1.6. The rating for C2 would be 2.2 etc. I've tried different ways to use this rating to find the probability of the competitor winning, however my gut feel tells me something is wrong.</p> <p>Is there a mathematical solution to this problem?</p>
5,024
[ -0.02110617607831955, -0.027495184913277626, -0.013882504776120186, -0.004295562393963337, 0.034445177763700485, 0.018540801480412483, -0.024112723767757416, -0.0077687338925898075, 0.02221752144396305, 0.010177485644817352, 0.046237751841545105, 0.05061895027756691, 0.047136399894952774, 0.060602784156799316, 0.04261762276291847, -0.006603334564715624, -0.034290287643671036, -0.030851323157548904, 0.004373414441943169, 0.0007269690977409482, 0.01619666814804077, 0.005029562395066023, 0.04084160178899765, -0.049101658165454865, -0.03535103425383568, 0.045740194618701935, 0.03541287034749985, -0.025580819696187973, 0.030182689428329468, 0.054321542382240295, -0.011790852062404156, -0.04886592552065849, 0.0241952296346426, 0.013618662022054195, 0.022065533325076103, 0.014883149415254593, -0.044973984360694885, -0.027205798774957657, -0.03971736505627632, -0.011416301131248474, -0.020878463983535767, -0.024955764412879944, 0.0030428532045334578, 0.0406513474881649, -0.027508296072483063, 0.0022922286298125982, -0.022098904475569725, -0.047870609909296036, 0.022873811423778534, -0.04601066932082176, 0.10379861295223236, -0.016305528581142426, 0.08026599138975143, -0.02011679671704769, -0.02149135433137417, 0.010585332289338112, 0.05104886367917061, 0.0882313996553421, 0.019006764516234398, -0.014167805202305317, -0.028569869697093964, -0.04055647924542427, -0.006356184370815754, -0.00832976121455431, -0.03466230630874634, 0.020771242678165436, -0.02779262140393257, -0.03891872242093086, 0.032565295696258545, -0.015070680528879166, 0.0027891499921679497, 0.01688719168305397, 0.05135051906108856, -0.02292267046868801, 0.01732165552675724, -0.01699594222009182, 0.027521170675754547, 0.01377666275948286, 0.08317014575004578, 0.009797649458050728, -0.004849069751799107, 0.051160767674446106, 0.0036622232291847467, 0.06365062296390533, 0.0321958065032959, -0.028255583718419075, 0.039672013372182846, -0.017166031524538994, 0.019678961485624313, 0.016118226572871208, -0.0001251215289812535, -0.00552379572764039, 0.046364132314920425, -0.02578149177134037, -0.043921440839767456, 0.03752844035625458, -0.03366149961948395, 0.06951654702425003, 0.016544470563530922, 0.0022837112192064524, -0.0038256316911429167, -0.04504679888486862, 0.010209721513092518, 0.03274006396532059, 0.0011399168288335204, -0.030702456831932068, -0.03427423909306526, -0.005928509868681431, 0.0310905110090971, 0.01616746559739113, -0.007944338023662567, 0.02841976284980774, 0.013806319795548916, 0.03003586456179619, 0.0022649432066828012, -0.040400661528110504, -0.021366044878959656, 0.01626697927713394, 0.07775575667619705, 0.038930244743824005, -0.002451701555401087, -0.026668788865208626, -0.005440939217805862, -0.011226313188672066, -0.01817871816456318, 0.01620352827012539, 0.006668907590210438, -0.002424380974844098, -0.024141430854797363, 0.015149894170463085, -0.031958382576704025, -0.018995970487594604, 0.029357871040701866, -0.0012013572268188, -0.015366395004093647, -0.00419658375903964, -0.07526718825101852, -0.043836962431669235, 0.012373413890600204, -0.02864214964210987, -0.0026342105120420456, -0.08728229254484177, -0.005218073725700378, 0.018741076812148094, 0.07057391852140427, -0.0320855975151062, 0.06304599344730377, 0.01357446052134037, 0.017101667821407318, 0.030601296573877335, -0.01617792434990406, -0.03361376002430916, -0.04963521659374237, -0.028679361566901207, 0.00260619237087667, -0.06258273124694824, -0.007839721627533436, -0.0027339516673237085, -0.001816541189327836, -0.019706057384610176, 0.04503028094768524, -0.013910391367971897, -0.0024650124832987785, 0.00021702046797145158, 0.043832097202539444, -0.004526922013610601, 0.09838084876537323, 0.018635062500834465, 0.034953050315380096, 0.016500307247042656, 0.004187013488262892, 0.02843683771789074, 0.009996123611927032, 0.02520545944571495, 0.05838129296898842, -0.031110914424061775, -0.0015067921485751867, 0.013229891657829285, -0.00041770911775529385, -0.016602637246251106, -0.04884054884314537, -0.02071288228034973, 0.004757893271744251, -0.0014688873197883368, 0.0554739311337471, 0.01859554648399353, 0.019358085468411446, -0.009013820439577103, 0.04355241730809212, -0.0028773886151611805, -0.042771127074956894, -0.09085453301668167, -0.014182090759277344, -0.022364232689142227, -0.007373111322522163, -0.003116787178441882, 0.0183564480394125, 0.03021899238228798, -0.027182526886463165, -0.03514961898326874, -0.038719747215509415, 0.009740332141518593, 0.021930431947112083, -0.037563662976026535, 0.005398278124630451, 0.06368803232908249, 0.04266582056879997, 0.009298776276409626, 0.04078160598874092, -0.02570916712284088, -0.036679450422525406, -0.01544910203665495, -0.04653806984424591, 0.014938312582671642, 0.0015004854649305344, -0.01670638471841812, 0.024237561970949173, 0.020196232944726944, -0.015673335641622543, 0.004824533127248287, -0.021261349320411682, 0.06244473159313202, 0.054159726947546005, 0.021058639511466026, 0.012525376863777637, 0.008954601362347603, 0.009441442787647247, -0.02517656609416008, 0.02278469316661358, -0.020612766966223717, -0.05628117546439171, 0.021720731630921364, 0.03494640067219734, 0.028458889573812485, -0.038597069680690765, -0.02502923458814621, 0.07472580671310425, 0.02258388325572014, 0.015418879687786102, 0.01829749345779419, -0.004372535273432732, 0.020776396617293358, -0.002231863560155034, 0.03906790539622307, 0.028440935537219048, -0.02084798738360405, 0.03785998001694679, 0.03327561169862747, -0.010402271524071693, -0.03768112137913704, -0.04423167556524277, 0.03297442942857742, -0.0020581423304975033, 0.021437279880046844, -0.029182150959968567, -0.012789657339453697, 0.06792271882295609, 0.010335090570151806, 0.03908763825893402, 0.0446707159280777, 0.016435999423265457, 0.0005886907456442714, -0.013623040169477463, -0.047718267887830734, -0.020812293514609337, 0.05201373249292374, -0.05887458473443985, -0.0047782305628061295, 0.017776012420654297, 0.0011341737117618322, 0.011129921302199364, -0.006076544523239136, -0.01713472045958042, -0.022560138255357742, -0.0038205774035304785, 0.023739922791719437, -0.012839455157518387, 0.034963421523571014, -0.02813652902841568, -0.05359869450330734, -0.013684488832950592, -0.008377477526664734, 0.007418970111757517, 0.015358570963144302, -0.09832543134689331, -0.0030971223022788763, -0.013177519664168358, -0.007924670353531837, 0.023849256336688995, -0.003240093821659684, -0.044297296553850174, 0.004275867715477943, -0.021097680553793907, -0.021386217325925827, -0.0386577844619751, -0.03756168484687805, 0.0003364147851243615, -0.05530986934900284, -0.005054887384176254, 0.07289059460163116, -0.007829143665730953, -0.01682370714843273, 0.030696911737322807, -0.04717661440372467, -0.013034006580710411, -0.023925291374325752, 0.007625676225870848, 0.0026865846011787653, 0.00195499905385077, 0.04678826034069061, 0.03319135680794716, -0.013875109143555164, -0.013979599811136723, -0.06010379642248154, -0.08173611015081406, 0.00539950979873538, -0.002639365615323186, -0.004660646431148052, 0.010173995047807693, 0.00415248004719615, 0.06257659196853638, -0.0012043542228639126, -0.004811493214219809, -0.013048668392002583, 0.01884649693965912, -0.029286885634064674, -0.009382120333611965, -0.005339701194316149, 0.019484687596559525, -0.022181382402777672, 0.045487917959690094, 0.009410649538040161, 0.018948456272482872, 0.07842621952295303, -0.016364527866244316, -0.02657269686460495, 0.01714123785495758, 0.006899014115333557, 0.00025293303770013154, 0.02782268635928631, 0.047599539160728455, -0.03223320469260216, 0.05031772330403328, -0.008057922124862671, -0.033117666840553284, -0.026859944686293602, -0.05505254864692688, 0.020730892196297646, -0.017725247889757156, 0.021317295730113983, -0.029591163620352745, 0.03877982869744301, 0.018154863268136978, -0.01179190631955862, 0.05431659519672394, 0.02253141440451145, 0.02243579737842083, -0.022191094234585762, 0.03451307862997055, 0.09409134089946747, 0.012216326780617237, -0.011444935575127602, -0.038720160722732544, -0.022537289187312126, -0.024719206616282463, -0.0058802650310099125, -0.015564500354230404, 0.0021061766892671585, 0.015783635899424553, 0.035376351326704025, 0.06914098560810089, 0.01751130074262619, -0.0282074436545372, -0.007374991197139025, -0.05850587040185928, -0.020906083285808563, -0.022350097075104713, 0.04009109362959862, 0.012316713109612465, 0.050548944622278214, 0.0237972941249609, 0.0085302097722888, 0.027849415317177773, -0.01148297730833292, -0.07831308245658875, 0.05418011546134949, -0.012144539505243301, -0.004569073207676411, -0.005649303086102009, 0.022568894550204277, 0.046666886657476425, -0.0375886894762516, -0.02229662425816059, 0.020989414304494858, 0.008643301203846931, -0.013462533243000507, 0.013493100181221962, -0.004633427131921053, -0.04618498310446739, 0.0187965240329504, -0.0009011094807647169, 0.03552995249629021, 0.00003851487417705357, 0.034728895872831345, 0.04054880887269974, -0.022256644442677498, -0.017529388889670372, -0.03729042038321495, 0.002527521690353751, 0.030050428584218025, 0.006954883690923452, 0.015511877834796906, 0.04220225661993027, -0.02758309803903103, 0.023774420842528343, 0.013402282260358334, 0.03783301264047623, 0.057045578956604004, -0.002793221501633525, 0.0015054061077535152, -0.05861761420965195, -0.01840105839073658, 0.016299907118082047, 0.0037905091885477304, -0.012522048316895962, -0.006281199399381876, 0.03331631422042847, 0.013911169953644276, -0.08080679923295975, 0.03561604022979736, 0.07456640899181366, 0.011007416993379593, -0.008744081482291222, -0.007801693398505449, -0.013991720974445343, -0.025257248431444168, -0.016820229589939117, 0.01623493991792202, 0.021824561059474945, 0.01851663365960121, -0.022385088726878166, 0.05248356983065605, -0.015065737068653107, -0.02791851945221424, 0.019481996074318886, -0.02985692396759987, 0.03589556738734245, 0.02381919138133526, -0.05126141011714935, 0.019674820825457573, 0.029891790822148323, 0.01753743551671505, 0.020283589139580727, -0.010642909444868565, -0.06013865768909454, 0.01120295375585556, 0.034632109105587006, 0.07145349681377411, -0.025415580719709396, -0.02676979824900627, -0.020053446292877197, 0.009817468002438545, 0.025154363363981247, -0.049599193036556244, 0.07349374890327454, 0.0019815810956060886, 0.0047110291197896, -0.011529825627803802, 0.0010325993644073606, -0.0417061410844326, 0.028523126617074013, 0.00815826840698719, 0.036322686821222305, -0.03444412723183632, -0.003289233660325408, -0.034610599279403687, 0.012338300235569477, 0.033189807087183, 0.052540045231580734, -0.015251167118549347, -0.04496220499277115, -0.04037358984351158, 0.030477311462163925, -0.008466164581477642, -0.04922625795006752, 0.0003405529714655131, -0.014253254979848862, 0.017040295526385307, 0.012658664025366306, -0.0019560654181987047, -0.03482581302523613, 0.0057164086028933525, -0.01097199972718954, -0.033124297857284546, 0.009327963925898075, -0.015296462923288345, 0.03437947854399681, 0.05164527893066406, 0.007327163126319647, 0.038471028208732605, 0.0377299040555954, -0.022453896701335907, -0.006756503134965897, -0.02216736227273941, -0.024702630937099457, 0.002504794392734766, -0.014829976484179497, -0.04688425362110138, 0.002925876760855317, -0.014630848541855812, 0.0006326697184704244, 0.0018954351544380188, 0.03535350039601326, -0.03167733922600746, -0.03226335719227791, -0.051558930426836014, 0.00009231302101397887, -0.00817577913403511, -0.01096442062407732, 0.013498651795089245, -0.012094286270439625, 0.020368104800581932, -0.0007150106830522418, 0.017933731898665428, -0.032105594873428345, -0.026972370222210884, -0.023012015968561172, -0.015983695164322853, -0.0033624274656176567, -0.02796381153166294, -0.016585128381848335, -0.012425749562680721, -0.05912117660045624, 0.03864211589097977, -0.040635354816913605, 0.04023869335651398, 0.018669871613383293, -0.03491457924246788, -0.06458041816949844, 0.0263910423964262, 0.006874639540910721, 0.015066021122038364, -0.02647271752357483, 0.02834836207330227, -0.006040800362825394, -0.03740697726607323, -0.06077520176768303, 0.0019801617600023746, 0.024117926135659218, 0.0035483199171721935, -0.043542563915252686, -0.027493689209222794, -0.00942634604871273, 0.01990199275314808, -0.023087317124009132, -0.007783576380461454, 0.017412526533007622, -0.01104909460991621, -0.028299108147621155, 0.0008890562457963824, -0.006357069592922926, 0.061593275517225266, 0.036735910922288895, -0.02996024116873741, 0.03124978393316269, -0.005411050748080015, -0.02672206610441208, -0.00914022233337164, 0.018205532804131508, -0.04292503744363785, -0.0274517685174942, -0.007978430949151516, 0.055495746433734894, 0.044066496193408966, -0.022894911468029022, 0.012945936061441898, -0.0168299563229084, 0.039888896048069, -0.005080467090010643, 0.0002555854443926364, 0.00011442996037658304, -0.00979082752019167, 0.017550501972436905, 0.006121693644672632, 0.031746234744787216, -0.01577693037688732, -0.006490680854767561, 0.01451835036277771, -0.007347377482801676, -0.03171258047223091, -0.021403104066848755, 0.057159118354320526, 0.013760414905846119, -0.04360188543796539, -0.007924296893179417, -0.035536643117666245, 0.012136303819715977, 0.04408068582415581, -0.01043973583728075, 0.03691820055246353, 0.01705693081021309, -0.021891843527555466, -0.0220305398106575, -0.021843688562512398, 0.0065795667469501495, 0.02393721230328083, -0.023783745244145393, 0.013522376306355, 0.059918362647295, 0.03786199167370796, -0.016942955553531647, -0.0023917437065392733, 0.00481162266805768, -0.00847635604441166, 0.04233156144618988, 0.04101545363664627, -0.01633444055914879, 0.007250641472637653, 0.04030865058302879, 0.038811683654785156, 0.03374888375401497, 0.014228560961782932, 0.02394651249051094, -0.004140761680901051, 0.047857947647571564, -0.017510034143924713, -0.019361281767487526, 0.040022578090429306, -0.016479793936014175, 0.01649376191198826, -0.048874709755182266, -0.02650517225265503, 0.08495525270700455, 0.013197428546845913, -0.024967018514871597, -0.03947119042277336, -0.020844848826527596, -0.019022634252905846, -0.006181875243782997, 0.0013588209403678775, -0.01974528469145298, 0.036653149873018265, 0.0464770533144474, 0.017790164798498154, 0.004440090153366327, 0.05060667172074318, -0.04353642463684082, -0.055394094437360764, 0.0017669301014393568, -0.03420333191752434, -0.04703203961253166, 0.0028662867844104767, 0.03438487648963928, -0.02069726586341858, 0.03998924046754837, 0.0013086287071928382, 0.013815355487167835, 0.007579220924526453, 0.03523574769496918, -0.02881929650902748, 0.06705176830291748, 0.022450072690844536, 0.015418522991240025, 0.04640242084860802, -0.017960740253329277, 0.12137368321418762, 0.05334499105811119, 0.024025224149227142, -0.03046325035393238, 0.0073651461862027645, -0.0026973914355039597, -0.0007816092693246901, -0.04083208739757538, 0.025579605251550674, 0.029248015955090523, -0.0009604042861610651, 0.04087873548269272, 0.016272500157356262, 0.037865426391363144, -0.029456736519932747, 0.07111987471580505, -0.027669677510857582, -0.010579093359410763, 0.012544850818812847, 0.023578299209475517, -0.015812218189239502, -0.04338151961565018, -0.010985302738845348, 0.011733472347259521, 0.04579583555459976, 0.009974152781069279, -0.036966897547245026, -0.03434144705533981, 0.003179041435942054, -0.016838019713759422, -0.025319021195173264, 0.0013291758950799704, 0.007214521057903767, 0.004687352105975151, -0.006423619110137224, -0.007662994787096977, 0.027511458843946457, -0.01986101269721985, 0.028378790244460106, 0.019833188503980637, 0.011488447897136211, 0.004184023477137089, 0.017240049317479134, 0.027569377794861794, -0.04426008090376854, -0.029148602858185768, -0.053575966507196426, 0.029241498559713364, -0.029129264876246452, 0.01627596840262413, 0.001930582569912076, -0.009068900719285011, -0.0169945377856493, -0.04248885065317154, -0.02533777616918087, -0.010222434997558594, 0.013947788625955582, -0.03850590065121651, -0.03582579270005226, -0.025493955239653587, 0.010054229758679867, -0.04621271416544914, 0.011414104141294956, 0.05359220877289772, -0.00928443856537342, -0.05753735452890396, -0.07294537872076035, 0.04375557228922844, 0.01434169802814722, -0.0059673418290913105, -0.035670723766088486, -0.021669529378414154, -0.03015364520251751, -0.037837859243154526, -0.018535563722252846, -0.004012699704617262, 0.01741194725036621, 0.02557814121246338, 0.0008113022777251899, 0.027640024200081825, -0.0168724674731493, 0.017794394865632057, -0.037028901278972626, 0.007949259132146835, -0.0463394820690155, 0.014027796685695648, 0.05315738916397095, 0.01382473111152649, -0.029045473784208298, 0.005749708041548729, -0.02498776465654373, 0.01667199283838272, 0.014592074789106846, -0.022105425596237183, -0.027645045891404152, -0.00958982016891241, -0.04744946211576462, -0.012887557968497276, -0.012041372247040272, 0.0736527219414711, 0.01104467362165451, -0.011670826002955437, -0.009185247123241425, -0.016329122707247734, 0.008537867106497288, 0.0014200557488948107, 0.005648765247315168, -0.08196509629487991, -0.014376988634467125, -0.036012157797813416, 0.011847680434584618, -0.01760522834956646, -0.03885979950428009, -0.012833193875849247, -0.02775779366493225, 0.026915306225419044, 0.004335777368396521, -0.05132584273815155, -0.020272208377718925, -0.030594099313020706, -0.004386357497423887, 0.005418600048869848, 0.028503136709332466, 0.007318082731217146, -0.000889485701918602, -0.01890571229159832, -0.016371015459299088, -0.01462379191070795, 0.02890932746231556, 0.04537741467356682, 0.0063444217666983604, 0.007655115332454443, -0.0032348299864679575, -0.0049070450477302074, -0.02446730248630047, 0.01989031583070755, -0.011793442070484161, 0.030039584264159203, -0.031077055260539055, -0.011726424098014832, 0.06576021760702133, -0.056472886353731155, -0.006423015147447586, -0.011288614012300968, -0.01575503870844841, 0.09494949877262115, 0.01664830558001995, -0.020485498011112213, -0.02195332758128643, 0.011595094576478004, -0.01852157898247242, -0.01614305004477501, -0.020939575508236885, 0.053813256323337555, 0.03626880422234535, 0.023745154961943626, -0.006758636329323053, -0.007436654064804316, 0.006594134494662285, 0.011315126903355122, 0.04997938498854637, 0.004956834018230438, 0.01673751138150692, -0.011940985918045044, 0.03875727951526642, 0.011085917241871357, 0.043308839201927185, 0.0013239573454484344, 0.005731290206313133, 0.027676532045006752, -0.005926088429987431, 0.04484972730278969, -0.026532189920544624, 0.015704812481999397, -0.09510554373264313, -0.03364095091819763, -0.0006142316269688308, 0.006496888119727373, 0.05951251834630966, -0.0456169955432415, 0.010415923781692982, 0.02492544800043106, -0.01228711660951376, 0.02109719254076481, 0.004355224780738354, -0.022140849381685257, -0.022668827325105667, 0.03120911866426468, -0.028528565540909767, 0.0377347357571125, 0.04698552191257477, -0.024435587227344513, 0.044409386813640594, -0.008261987939476967, 0.0023918866645544767, -0.016693050041794777, -0.024298038333654404, 0.0020810815040022135, -0.008080052211880684, -0.04051676020026207, 0.03028128854930401, -0.048004381358623505, -0.043641600757837296, 0.02805073745548725, -0.014010058715939522, 0.007904439233243465, 0.025828180834650993, 0.009160119108855724, 0.010999727994203568, 0.054703254252672195, 0.020671755075454712, -0.018190903589129448, -0.01913549192249775, 0.044552356004714966, 0.03404642641544342, 0.01539862621575594, -0.02973933331668377, 0.0028250415343791246, 0.040687378495931625, -0.00766286114230752, -0.038438960909843445, 0.019911784678697586, -0.01669989340007305, 0.021733997389674187, 0.015805572271347046, -0.02184867486357689, 0.022900251671671867, -0.025044048205018044, 0.02300112135708332, -0.028508132323622704, 0.010740449652075768, -0.016013482585549355, -0.01124652847647667, 0.04553523287177086, -0.029057851061224937, -0.012549375183880329, -0.05472397431731224, 0.02165333554148674, -0.0021610355470329523, -0.01110024843364954, -0.03384767100214958, 0.0077518573962152, -0.008981280960142612, -0.014188997447490692, 0.011696144938468933, -0.06294906139373779, -0.03687737137079239, 0.01747654192149639, -0.004059030674397945, 0.012053820304572582, 0.046949200332164764, 0.016530023887753487, 0.00419966597110033, -0.09798706322908401, 0.037968188524246216, 0.01701997220516205, 0.0020996052771806717, -0.04708174988627434, -0.011892366223037243, -0.04334776848554611, 0.00172084616497159, 0.019964737817645073, -0.018561892211437225, -0.030521210283041, -0.007925598882138729, 0.017622198909521103, -0.01727169379591942, -0.050128426402807236, 0.014423031359910965, -0.028101788833737373, -0.01832055300474167, -0.03221378102898598, -0.011787844821810722, 0.0006095350254327059, -0.009371849708259106, -0.0026485922280699015, -0.015546471811830997, -0.0010631028562784195, 0.023345541208982468, -0.002072079572826624, 0.02752981334924698, -0.004869433585554361, -0.0008621519664302468, 0.04256909713149071, 0.010644342750310898, 0.007859374396502972, 0.018840951845049858, 0.00008628716022940353, -0.053095631301403046, 0.0758151188492775, -0.07210001349449158, -0.017695339396595955, -0.008010034449398518, -0.007457389030605555, -0.004585636779665947, -0.07077977806329727, 0.002148284111171961, 0.0193216223269701, -0.03130096569657326, -0.012163462117314339, 0.00008281944610644132, 0.04835151880979538, 0.021893009543418884, -0.027494382113218307, 0.01039537601172924, -0.027757825329899788, -0.016304703429341316, 0.003567279316484928, 0.004769913852214813, 0.06555531173944473, 0.021767813712358475, 0.029463326558470726, 0.005286630243062973, 0.0007482486544176936, 0.022730475291609764, -0.0013283080188557506, 0.01604672521352768, -0.016988389194011688, 0.031229553744196892, 0.038544006645679474, -0.013987540267407894, 0.04950202256441116, -0.00021492151427082717, -0.021902767941355705, 0.049965232610702515, -0.0009327558800578117, 0.017581159248948097, -0.066212497651577, -0.0016096483450382948, -0.03556967154145241, -0.000442101270891726, 0.03183227777481079, 0.022084522992372513, -0.01703088916838169, 0.03395089879631996, 0.023956777527928352, 0.02218475006520748, 0.028803301975131035, -0.023981576785445213, 0.03638315573334694, -0.018122605979442596, -0.0221425648778677, -0.0542156957089901, -0.01637379638850689, -0.019255289807915688, -0.02015243098139763, 0.0011838418431580067, 0.042552363127470016, 0.020213816314935684, 0.023111028596758842, -0.04274234175682068, -0.005073075648397207, 0.047774918377399445, -0.027602486312389374, -0.02493502013385296, -0.07686253637075424, 0.039850011467933655, 0.008588158525526524, -0.037782587110996246 ]
<p>Diallel Analysis using the Griffing and Hayman approach is so common in plant breeding and genetics. I'm wondering if someone can share R worked example on Diallel Analysis. Is there any good referenced book which covered worked examples? Thanks</p> <p>References:</p> <p>Griffing B (1956) Concept of general and specific combining ability in relation to diallel crossing systems. Aust J Biol Sci 9:463-493 [<a href="http://www.publish.csiro.au/?act=view_file&amp;file_id=BI9560463.pdf" rel="nofollow">pdf</a>]</p> <p>Hayman BI (1954) The analysis of variance of diallel tables. Biometrics 10:235-244 [<a href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/3001877" rel="nofollow">JSTOR</a>]</p> <p>Hayman BI (1954) The theory and analysis of diallel crosses. Genetics 39:789-809 [<a href="http://www.genetics.org/content/39/6/789.full.pdf" rel="nofollow">pdf</a>]</p>
37,194
[ -0.028714116662740707, -0.04861156642436981, -0.003922445233911276, 0.03379688784480095, 0.04703247919678688, 0.02159329317510128, -0.028292031958699226, -0.030203640460968018, 0.04023807495832443, -0.0038416848983615637, 0.06660402566194534, -0.0038540612440556288, 0.057883791625499725, 0.012190137058496475, 0.018902860581874847, 0.00022932978754397482, -0.008560293354094028, -0.0272629726678133, -0.011859932914376259, 0.010807146318256855, 0.009748482145369053, 0.008758453652262688, -0.01308333221822977, 0.0052758208476006985, 0.00006599508924409747, 0.02732774242758751, 0.0222163163125515, -0.038798581808805466, 0.024960504844784737, 0.0647195428609848, -0.05261967331171036, -0.0035691317170858383, -0.015864841639995575, 0.028652193024754524, -0.003459614235907793, 0.009449399076402187, -0.0015299066435545683, -0.03663605824112892, -0.029305892065167427, 0.026565877720713615, 0.0014082411071285605, -0.02424715831875801, -0.005963141564279795, 0.02221553958952427, 0.0009130268008448184, 0.0011605187319219112, 0.0265247393399477, -0.003749375231564045, 0.02823255956172943, -0.07579366862773895, 0.07231922447681427, 0.014461655169725418, 0.031335704028606415, 0.03740876913070679, 0.0433695912361145, 0.06736897677183151, 0.044537149369716644, 0.049858707934617996, -0.011228862218558788, -0.047962360084056854, -0.059751830995082855, -0.040414806455373764, 0.012762581929564476, -0.0366743803024292, -0.05235687270760536, 0.013509835116565228, -0.002779026748612523, -0.02714971825480461, 0.006670271512120962, -0.03820550814270973, -0.01916758343577385, 0.047320406883955, 0.0692857950925827, 0.004771454259753227, 0.006221863441169262, -0.015539760701358318, -0.005361589137464762, 0.018119344487786293, 0.04106004908680916, 0.017468992620706558, -0.0032494443003088236, 0.08922136574983597, 0.019507810473442078, 0.011637537740170956, -0.0024015477392822504, -0.021025400608778, 0.060211360454559326, -0.0034648347645998, 0.0027223534416407347, 0.0035180561244487762, -0.015943000093102455, -0.002253166865557432, 0.03311323747038841, 0.006149692926555872, -0.063856340944767, 0.046446189284324646, 0.005461832042783499, 0.028283653780817986, -0.0017369802808389068, -0.0465073436498642, 0.04080910235643387, -0.036295972764492035, 0.007296181749552488, 0.08064869791269302, -0.00859917514026165, -0.061058733612298965, -0.02477073110640049, 0.019466795027256012, 0.01593739353120327, -0.00422132620587945, -0.0022319569252431393, 0.003754053497686982, 0.014563705772161484, -0.013865158893167973, 0.028389183804392815, -0.009490498341619968, -0.00828530266880989, 0.002293796744197607, 0.06169794499874115, 0.05467044934630394, 0.03425697609782219, -0.030448732897639275, 0.02627352625131607, -0.012304560281336308, -0.04918936267495155, 0.04228745773434639, -0.01456472184509039, -0.025835596024990082, -0.04383821040391922, 0.05941685289144516, 0.01188940554857254, 0.018850892782211304, 0.03397645428776741, 0.03244988992810249, 0.0027873313520103693, -0.005447817500680685, -0.0539068765938282, -0.06280383467674255, 0.030740266665816307, -0.04570121690630913, 0.0175775159150362, -0.06361650675535202, 0.005130323581397533, 0.016262363642454147, 0.03392373025417328, 0.013758434914052486, 0.01878504641354084, -0.01725173182785511, 0.02804655395448208, 0.02979365363717079, -0.028425412252545357, -0.011881180107593536, 0.03044269233942032, -0.020938390865921974, -0.00961513165384531, -0.09713369607925415, 0.02384086698293686, 0.00566470343619585, 0.0028567062690854073, -0.026556354016065598, 0.04521368071436882, 0.008297261781990528, -0.019653014838695526, -0.0023947800509631634, -0.04685143381357193, -0.0027149056550115347, 0.08949306607246399, -0.019978269934654236, 0.015525947324931622, 0.02034413069486618, 0.023882433772087097, 0.05268475040793419, -0.0018687198171392083, 0.02902608923614025, 0.03520059585571289, -0.014051775448024273, 0.03915265202522278, 0.010188608430325985, -0.010018757544457912, -0.0004487165133468807, 0.006439052522182465, -0.04209017753601074, 0.012601058930158615, 0.04771466925740242, 0.007213537581264973, 0.04328523948788643, -0.0296889990568161, 0.014924362301826477, 0.0309146698564291, -0.04776754230260849, -0.0069409022107720375, -0.06039784103631973, 0.034495528787374496, -0.00560683524236083, -0.01029803417623043, 0.009498430415987968, 0.0001324430195381865, 0.013990701176226139, -0.0033176604192703962, -0.0536433607339859, -0.016555676236748695, 0.033829014748334885, 0.017810186371207237, -0.0317944698035717, 0.00746956467628479, 0.06429816037416458, 0.043734848499298096, -0.034748561680316925, 0.03312799334526062, -0.03296511247754097, -0.0338246151804924, 0.025982651859521866, -0.019189517945051193, 0.012720581144094467, 0.011981036514043808, 0.0013932535657659173, 0.014781617559492588, 0.028516219928860664, -0.0007038680487312376, 0.01012885756790638, -0.04261365160346031, 0.05154600366950035, 0.04249465838074684, 0.021935878321528435, 0.013406098820269108, 0.0195012167096138, 0.012598497793078423, 0.03398067131638527, 0.011228795163333416, 0.0004395363212097436, -0.009497508406639099, -0.018570588901638985, 0.02409927174448967, 0.025740984827280045, -0.03092719241976738, -0.005814187228679657, 0.03968396037817001, 0.030480006709694862, 0.003808583365753293, 0.03673017770051956, -0.020999345928430557, -0.003844503778964281, 0.002910526003688574, -0.008796541020274162, 0.008559667505323887, 0.054094888269901276, 0.02816769666969776, 0.0166730098426342, 0.0030200874898582697, -0.020366260781884193, -0.035532139241695404, 0.045392561703920364, 0.018980782479047775, 0.01624324731528759, 0.007692127022892237, -0.024526070803403854, 0.04052974656224251, -0.04122024402022362, -0.010684225708246231, 0.046546101570129395, 0.007612472865730524, -0.0031502293422818184, -0.005500045605003834, -0.0324564203619957, 0.04027975723147392, 0.028441252186894417, -0.003483964828774333, 0.003883501747623086, 0.004353063181042671, -0.053340792655944824, 0.06634271889925003, -0.022587204352021217, -0.006812500301748514, -0.026075659319758415, -0.001340000773780048, 0.002663613995537162, 0.007659663911908865, 0.02568293735384941, -0.0043447683565318584, -0.021403837949037552, -0.006864630617201328, -0.03205223008990288, 0.013796504586935043, -0.03889800235629082, -0.06967788189649582, 0.00998722668737173, -0.04590298980474472, -0.00811570230871439, 0.02531946823000908, -0.01613386534154415, -0.03921429440379143, 0.014802745543420315, 0.012988214381039143, -0.02440878562629223, -0.013919252902269363, -0.05170469731092453, -0.013105983845889568, -0.01950136572122574, 0.01147596538066864, 0.011311875656247139, -0.0028665040154010057, -0.007290235720574856, 0.018328117206692696, -0.04816627502441406, -0.03400489315390587, -0.016727421432733536, 0.01066650915890932, -0.003054486121982336, -0.03826430067420006, -0.013953424990177155, -0.010706511326134205, -0.06588892638683319, -0.03817933797836304, -0.08198057115077972, -0.06850683689117432, -0.007478564977645874, 0.013437307439744473, 0.019604438915848732, 0.016868887469172478, -0.048725444823503494, 0.03803613781929016, -0.006461041048169136, -0.06197703629732132, -0.01342409010976553, 0.0193965844810009, -0.0027478053234517574, 0.01266828179359436, 0.03759114816784859, 0.005104295443743467, 0.019137846305966377, 0.03360646963119507, 0.0026868367567658424, 0.008380724117159843, 0.03805118054151535, -0.0006573863793164492, -0.02551964297890663, 0.03616970777511597, -0.04423397406935692, 0.012398889288306236, -0.024114377796649933, 0.03377900272607803, -0.016020379960536957, 0.03530384600162506, 0.026381894946098328, 0.015068801119923592, 0.0037441484164446592, -0.0409419871866703, 0.006804745178669691, -0.037370506674051285, -0.014120552688837051, 0.006378404330462217, 0.021622415632009506, 0.007231059484183788, -0.024084703996777534, 0.03696862608194351, 0.007863531820476055, 0.04256598651409149, -0.01752706803381443, -0.013655774295330048, 0.04829081892967224, 0.027015449479222298, 0.01160440780222416, -0.01665523461997509, 0.005710185505449772, -0.009255153127014637, 0.008628412149846554, -0.023358767852187157, 0.0075914678163826466, 0.0536331869661808, 0.037704817950725555, 0.005321011412888765, -0.014760786667466164, -0.03477315604686737, 0.010828526690602303, -0.05550112575292587, -0.018818223848938942, -0.029532540589571, 0.04128451272845268, -0.0019296889659017324, 0.06560312956571579, -0.005611570551991463, -0.0003181635111104697, 0.025003626942634583, -0.00731759425252676, -0.04048548638820648, 0.003503953805193305, -0.035069577395915985, -0.02113207057118416, -0.0016491587739437819, 0.001973245060071349, 0.005279937293380499, -0.014354768209159374, -0.005607116036117077, -0.030765216797590256, 0.007054147310554981, 0.008653262630105019, 0.004556491505354643, 0.0024446980096399784, -0.04091262444853783, 0.0035622527357190847, 0.02848787233233452, 0.030202990397810936, -0.008395186625421047, -0.008026606403291225, 0.05545703321695328, -0.039273470640182495, -0.033747561275959015, -0.03192155435681343, 0.01170631218701601, 0.025269247591495514, 0.05518409609794617, 0.041983772069215775, 0.04083184152841568, -0.04982377216219902, 0.021447811275720596, 0.00834532268345356, 0.068336620926857, 0.042345985770225525, -0.008632238022983074, -0.0017709339736029506, -0.0021816622465848923, -0.04152539372444153, -0.009581242688000202, 0.0005406452692113817, -0.0015518695581704378, -0.00040488759987056255, 0.019209861755371094, 0.045896802097558975, -0.021262681111693382, 0.04733501747250557, 0.03202182799577713, 0.007162220776081085, -0.030446715652942657, -0.003203887492418289, -0.0293571874499321, -0.008452280424535275, -0.016919054090976715, 0.0415165089070797, 0.020006828010082245, -0.013649106957018375, -0.011880272068083286, 0.05102956295013428, 0.02050718478858471, -0.03646455332636833, 0.010955551639199257, 0.0055919792503118515, 0.02227424643933773, -0.018072089180350304, -0.019656380638480186, 0.004992521367967129, 0.04188472032546997, 0.006729422137141228, 0.011068496853113174, -0.0027256400790065527, -0.06644592434167862, -0.01162049826234579, 0.04094306752085686, 0.02773527055978775, -0.07658101618289948, 0.017977306619286537, -0.04575502127408981, -0.0053262063302099705, 0.004562069661915302, -0.028869809582829475, 0.02958304062485695, -0.03815368190407753, -0.019986242055892944, -0.024883974343538284, 0.008046353235840797, -0.035647496581077576, 0.02690189890563488, -0.004610213916748762, 0.024414291605353355, -0.014065760187804699, 0.00520224217325449, -0.026817768812179565, 0.010036205872893333, 0.024169595912098885, 0.03820829838514328, -0.01243837084621191, -0.0006148290704004467, 0.04901551082730293, 0.039933037012815475, -0.03357792645692825, -0.05759965255856514, 0.02191047929227352, -0.027323709800839424, 0.004130477551370859, 0.03978854417800903, -0.03053309954702854, -0.06343232095241547, 0.024376867339015007, 0.02995958924293518, -0.01093568466603756, -0.004788337741047144, -0.00041843473445624113, -0.0032649729400873184, 0.035847317427396774, -0.02069839835166931, 0.06884804368019104, 0.021443389356136322, -0.053700536489486694, -0.028241757303476334, -0.007857524789869785, 0.017563272267580032, -0.04847584292292595, -0.05556845664978027, -0.020963191986083984, 0.04169250652194023, -0.02215001918375492, 0.010988526977598667, -0.036434222012758255, 0.04484692960977554, -0.03903213143348694, -0.007117788307368755, 0.013996819965541363, 0.0023847015108913183, -0.004319476429373026, 0.015917718410491943, 0.012417925521731377, 0.010123624466359615, 0.012372246012091637, -0.012920265085995197, 0.0291108600795269, -0.011804915964603424, -0.0114870835095644, -0.01832982711493969, 0.0030929921194911003, 0.0022366938646882772, -0.04474201425909996, -0.054939378052949905, -0.021053869277238846, -0.005802730564028025, 0.06612373143434525, -0.019602863118052483, 0.014602265320718288, 0.025468766689300537, -0.07199481874704361, -0.05052080377936363, 0.01019400916993618, 0.029691018164157867, 0.01725148782134056, -0.029575658962130547, -0.010876557789742947, -0.00011103603901574388, -0.01694975234568119, -0.07235236465930939, -0.00926456693559885, 0.04250339791178703, -0.024876737967133522, -0.049216270446777344, -0.056580979377031326, -0.01838197186589241, -0.011834284290671349, -0.018594032153487206, -0.024373915046453476, 0.06890126317739487, -0.04411882162094116, 0.001136987702921033, -0.017855525016784668, -0.0024474812671542168, 0.08495283871889114, 0.012891137972474098, -0.01850537769496441, 0.0028573900926858187, -0.029366910457611084, -0.0014912789920344949, -0.021537061780691147, 0.013666251674294472, -0.024630801752209663, -0.001132661709561944, -0.0016098193591460586, 0.02977798320353031, 0.02636718563735485, -0.029526203870773315, -0.02763129211962223, 0.01390303298830986, 0.00630421144887805, -0.026408448815345764, 0.01693084090948105, -0.01547660119831562, -0.021007323637604713, -0.005104305222630501, -0.04141288250684738, -0.010045844130218029, -0.02190820686519146, -0.019836915656924248, 0.007638486567884684, -0.035125281661748886, -0.030922312289476395, 0.0015698405914008617, 0.07966393977403641, 0.000793576065916568, -0.0030427388846874237, 0.003941345494240522, -0.026526419445872307, 0.031735364347696304, -0.02653290331363678, 0.04905898496508598, 0.03486689552664757, 0.010963255539536476, -0.0014004469849169254, 0.010777131654322147, -0.028354089707136154, 0.003437614068388939, 0.08230652660131454, 0.000659692392218858, 0.03704223781824112, 0.04309352487325668, 0.011062704026699066, 0.021311942487955093, -0.016305647790431976, -0.022704407572746277, -0.017732443287968636, 0.033883847296237946, 0.04963823780417442, 0.0038139401003718376, -0.008739609271287918, 0.04859049245715141, 0.026276880875229836, 0.024195540696382523, 0.04159470647573471, -0.00619118195027113, 0.026512248441576958, -0.02162918634712696, -0.009594155475497246, -0.04836615175008774, 0.07004119455814362, -0.03461356833577156, -0.0006118088494986296, -0.019962651655077934, -0.019084643572568893, 0.03130824491381645, 0.045103251934051514, 0.026418201625347137, -0.06646523624658585, -0.04352036863565445, -0.030102113261818886, 0.061265140771865845, 0.021394774317741394, -0.006047054193913937, 0.027898501604795456, 0.0046906061470508575, 0.024611815810203552, -0.027155926451086998, 0.03731214627623558, -0.04447253420948982, -0.06685889512300491, -0.00934330839663744, -0.017802128568291664, -0.01881358027458191, 0.013508287258446217, 0.012915766797959805, -0.009896348230540752, -0.005759008694440126, -0.0057659875601530075, -0.0018694238970056176, 0.013030579313635826, 0.06041610613465309, 0.0020065358839929104, 0.0979519933462143, -0.032354772090911865, 0.02742939069867134, 0.010204162448644638, -0.027278244495391846, 0.12443208694458008, 0.051021330058574677, 0.019730418920516968, -0.10352180898189545, 0.043157219886779785, -0.00028260445105843246, 0.006577463820576668, -0.05614835396409035, 0.004728088621050119, -0.028543854132294655, 0.009861004538834095, 0.056542664766311646, 0.042240578681230545, -0.0076921903528273106, 0.0007446488016285002, 0.07417497783899307, 0.009194517508149147, -0.02250385470688343, 0.03403566777706146, -0.012570257298648357, -0.05017876997590065, -0.006336416583508253, -0.015370724722743034, -0.011127816513180733, 0.03816967085003853, -0.03567199036478996, -0.06054091826081276, 0.001639154739677906, 0.03898601979017258, 0.028498072177171707, -0.02136925235390663, -0.015507989563047886, 0.02022944577038288, 0.014996044337749481, -0.02452130801975727, -0.0211653895676136, -0.019708015024662018, -0.014062306843698025, -0.0048982310108840466, 0.043944716453552246, 0.006116145756095648, -0.021794529631733894, 0.035285405814647675, 0.03470947965979576, -0.04045426845550537, -0.04975941404700279, -0.023639865219593048, 0.05685635283589363, -0.03743031993508339, -0.012387792579829693, -0.02471337839961052, -0.007215426303446293, 0.010876408778131008, -0.03538551926612854, -0.0062376284040510654, 0.010832580737769604, 0.022608522325754166, -0.038150593638420105, -0.008911311626434326, -0.02877994067966938, 0.049301628023386, -0.02966601960361004, -0.0037603366654366255, -0.019180096685886383, -0.01921864040195942, -0.01694156602025032, -0.0648379996418953, 0.02912507764995098, 0.055052243173122406, -0.035482008010149, -0.062387336045503616, 0.006121764425188303, -0.0323096327483654, -0.00867926049977541, 0.023301666602492332, 0.025996699929237366, 0.01729072630405426, 0.016500432044267654, -0.06592249125242233, 0.003712461329996586, -0.06019623205065727, 0.04641319811344147, 0.015596677549183369, -0.024897603318095207, -0.026372617110610008, 0.019446581602096558, 0.04642584174871445, 0.027895353734493256, 0.00025424835621379316, 0.030498549342155457, -0.051344241946935654, -0.010809456929564476, 0.013828519731760025, -0.040746983140707016, -0.013692664913833141, -0.009952456690371037, -0.01337031926959753, -0.07618030160665512, -0.01611880585551262, 0.03983072564005852, 0.047970980405807495, 0.05120213329792023, -0.034399114549160004, 0.0034586095716804266, 0.015077921561896801, 0.0485975444316864, 0.008360224775969982, -0.05168876796960831, 0.003433956066146493, 0.011812428012490273, 0.033296793699264526, -0.023372052237391472, -0.042691364884376526, 0.0004640468687284738, -0.01916603185236454, 0.030494768172502518, -0.017524736002087593, -0.012221189215779305, -0.0017342749051749706, -0.008874071761965752, -0.01410433929413557, -0.03155945613980293, 0.009632492437958717, -0.03563860058784485, 0.009032363072037697, 0.009249974973499775, 0.01651914231479168, 0.0053271041251719, 0.01022170577198267, 0.036516837775707245, 0.022489910945296288, 0.04679088294506073, 0.034545693546533585, 0.03495151177048683, 0.002540007932111621, 0.011391822248697281, 0.017363768070936203, 0.04167110100388527, 0.008095408789813519, 0.009629352949559689, 0.0288369320333004, -0.04170689359307289, -0.010000752285122871, -0.006682966370135546, 0.0016996439080685377, -0.0072658127173781395, -0.0034545885864645243, -0.005633842665702105, -0.05523508042097092, 0.039762239903211594, 0.015997642651200294, -0.02235756628215313, 0.03581777215003967, 0.03365769609808922, 0.02572076953947544, -0.0004414044669829309, -0.037775781005620956, 0.013189167715609074, -0.005287641659379005, 0.05317463353276253, 0.0306438896805048, 0.0385119691491127, 0.02591388300061226, 0.011404787190258503, -0.023938290774822235, 0.0076522501185536385, -0.03628320246934891, -0.036803074181079865, 0.05402852222323418, 0.06638641655445099, 0.003688344033434987, 0.031252920627593994, -0.019327957183122635, 0.007502805907279253, -0.04877012223005295, 0.004876035265624523, 0.01856955699622631, 0.06059954687952995, 0.07319772988557816, -0.05855123698711395, -0.02283892221748829, 0.001504619256593287, -0.01882012002170086, -0.008472035638988018, 0.03485039994120598, -0.007833895273506641, -0.027491314336657524, -0.04220765456557274, -0.04028771445155144, 0.03617873042821884, 0.015143473632633686, 0.023062098771333694, 0.01707463338971138, 0.003773911390453577, 0.0014982244465500116, -0.02224396914243698, -0.01800827868282795, -0.003999135922640562, -0.02110675908625126, -0.0879564881324768, 0.025538237765431404, -0.01110850740224123, -0.05843794345855713, 0.03107859566807747, -0.054311931133270264, -0.008068309165537357, 0.007730192970484495, 0.006637164857238531, -0.003863913007080555, 0.03428065776824951, 0.0525694340467453, 0.0016162057872861624, -0.03688757121562958, 0.017676878720521927, -0.0035049738362431526, 0.00738076027482748, -0.029446100816130638, 0.019728608429431915, 0.055406603962183, -0.028615057468414307, -0.04404905438423157, 0.03212879225611687, -0.05838749185204506, -0.05925067141652107, 0.00003368495890754275, -0.0038744022604078054, 0.05629587545990944, 0.011651047505438328, 0.012333196587860584, -0.040312882512807846, 0.003523992607370019, -0.0022028775420039892, 0.01645839773118496, 0.03862649202346802, 0.032881319522857666, -0.007708483841270208, -0.013928305357694626, 0.009834423661231995, 0.028352268040180206, -0.012478533200919628, -0.032175056636333466, 0.01716005615890026, 0.00944353174418211, -0.02237827144563198, -0.009301379323005676, -0.021505001932382584, -0.029700735583901405, 0.013945817947387695, -0.02709096483886242, 0.007856201380491257, 0.015439724549651146, -0.009663555771112442, 0.04839830845594406, -0.03264540806412697, 0.07357919216156006, 0.017128171399235725, -0.019117971882224083, -0.02118086628615856, 0.002676487434655428, -0.015573850832879543, -0.023824995383620262, 0.0066168163903057575, -0.040410030633211136, 0.008793504908680916, -0.039372581988573074, 0.028891652822494507, 0.021270526573061943, -0.026351982727646828, 0.03011203370988369, 0.02723756991326809, -0.027620548382401466, -0.007619975600391626, -0.000844423018861562, 0.015723105520009995, 0.008554330095648766, 0.007477403152734041, -0.0028487707022577524, 0.0002460021642036736, 0.021159188821911812, -0.0638427734375, 0.017474113032221794, 0.04617249593138695, -0.025556620210409164, 0.07473897933959961, -0.025221623480319977, -0.01698770374059677, 0.026549046859145164, -0.021996861323714256, -0.030321525409817696, 0.02004031464457512, -0.04141569510102272, -0.018954329192638397, -0.015266882255673409, -0.011237495578825474, -0.011463331058621407, -0.07161037623882294, 0.008060796186327934, -0.0021968705113977194, -0.006732557900249958, -0.002630782313644886, 0.017337778583168983, 0.023923976346850395, 0.0248238705098629, 0.0252701248973608, 0.005111488047987223, -0.0055557237938046455, -0.000711353262886405, 0.007424596231430769, 0.0011905034771189094, 0.02124137431383133, 0.03291580080986023, -0.015430080704391003, 0.012600320391356945, 0.015055201947689056, 0.015252554789185524, -0.01951226219534874, -0.0004605647991411388, -0.030944164842367172, -0.028956308960914612, 0.007041933014988899, -0.023000231012701988, 0.015463968738913536, 0.022039450705051422, -0.008515804074704647, 0.10898425430059433, -0.0377679243683815, -0.005134210456162691, -0.022335998713970184, 0.005531128961592913, -0.0038284428883343935, -0.010865089483559132, 0.0075032347813248634, 0.02623443864285946, -0.022750595584511757, 0.03153873234987259, -0.04181098937988281, 0.00948427990078926, 0.030212262645363808, -0.009567064233124256, 0.023809924721717834, -0.04622247815132141, -0.019907915964722633, -0.001197480014525354, -0.032612383365631104, -0.01940344087779522, -0.01222293172031641, -0.004272591322660446, -0.006444383412599564, 0.04065432399511337, -0.014879859983921051, 0.004634938668459654, 0.020035041496157646, 0.04305334761738777, -0.07765492796897888, -0.04958038404583931, -0.032489363104104996, -0.024705594405531883, -0.01871388964354992, -0.0034526484087109566 ]
<p>I've been aching to get my feet wet with a machine learning project, and I've found one that should be relatively simple, and actually has non-negligible business value for my organization. The marketing guys have to remove bot activity from our tracking data by hand for their metrics. I wanted to pull some data from GA, and have them construct a data set (bot, not-a-bot). There are probably 5-10 (numerical) categories that we have to train the algorithm, and the data set can be made as big as the marketing guys have an appetite for.</p> <p>I've done a bit of reading, and played with RapidMiner/Knime/Weka a bit. I plan to do everything in Python, with <code>scikits-learn</code>, possibly working in R where I have to. My questions:</p> <ol> <li>Is this a "not actually that easy at all" problem?</li> <li>Given the number of categories, about how large should the training set be? </li> <li>Given the problem, what algorithms should I start with? </li> <li>Has anyone else done any learning around bot detection? How did it work? Am I barking up the wrong tree?</li> </ol> <p>Thanks in advance community!</p>
74,344
[ -0.033024128526449203, -0.010403660126030445, 0.008052990771830082, 0.037274766713380814, 0.01738939806818962, 0.005053346510976553, -0.01745646633207798, -0.0032857900951057673, 0.022780362516641617, 0.0006274947081692517, 0.009124401025474072, 0.053625695407390594, 0.03989046812057495, 0.045623112469911575, -0.001316872308962047, -0.006922073662281036, 0.011000244878232479, -0.004197665024548769, 0.024305878207087517, 0.01018301397562027, -0.014628550037741661, 0.014214643277227879, 0.025598539039492607, 0.01912020519375801, -0.05178220197558403, 0.026734981685876846, 0.010061570443212986, -0.0364021360874176, -0.006406167522072792, 0.023631112650036812, -0.02467406913638115, -0.009280594997107983, -0.01828659325838089, 0.018632372841238976, 0.02194579690694809, 0.015585843473672867, -0.03590145334601402, -0.025729719549417496, -0.03522523492574692, 0.0029386451933532953, -0.020081311464309692, 0.0019780683796852827, 0.002483170246705413, 0.00966130942106247, -0.02459053322672844, 0.012030751444399357, -0.04084840416908264, -0.009022470563650131, 0.01896301843225956, -0.027384595945477486, 0.04490963742136955, -0.016662722453475, 0.0012895885156467557, 0.029785629361867905, -0.00794057734310627, -0.023566123098134995, 0.044156547635793686, 0.042218923568725586, -0.001150775351561606, -0.033884480595588684, -0.027801895514130592, -0.018258580937981606, -0.022444287315011024, -0.027624031528830528, -0.03671782463788986, 0.04703504964709282, 0.010916209779679775, 0.04474742338061333, 0.04990047588944435, 0.013044584542512894, 0.048912812024354935, 0.013511976227164268, -0.0014097559032961726, 0.03894011676311493, -0.008915673941373825, -0.0010006127413362265, 0.00639897957444191, 0.033309921622276306, 0.030338268727064133, 0.03559916466474533, 0.0017652228707447648, -0.011569580063223839, 0.03290485590696335, 0.029444027692079544, 0.023915259167551994, -0.0029621473513543606, 0.05539399012923241, -0.026834741234779358, 0.009548780508339405, 0.005460197571665049, -0.006869999226182699, -0.00924307107925415, 0.04024293273687363, 0.05022742971777916, -0.04388665407896042, 0.03863101825118065, -0.03696346655488014, 0.05173209309577942, 0.04340772703289986, 0.01904422603547573, -0.018309807404875755, 0.0008940133266150951, -0.02401536889374256, 0.08796223253011703, -0.05920936539769173, 0.02380490116775036, -0.0025895878206938505, -0.04015539586544037, -0.007315219845622778, -0.007271607872098684, -0.044717058539390564, -0.020041586831212044, 0.02595723234117031, -0.034589335322380066, 0.004099716432392597, -0.009586585685610771, -0.008470580913126469, -0.00713186152279377, 0.026388531550765038, 0.055273860692977905, 0.00009233402670361102, -0.036218296736478806, 0.0014413704629987478, -0.030339667573571205, -0.020326923578977585, 0.032216910272836685, 0.04981693997979164, -0.0336783342063427, -0.04163789004087448, 0.02979923039674759, 0.010417190380394459, -0.024238940328359604, 0.031176289543509483, -0.018469074741005898, 0.015609311871230602, -0.038141001015901566, -0.05102545768022537, -0.04236796125769615, 0.014622270129621029, 0.009558971971273422, 0.03007780946791172, -0.04384463652968407, -0.028361570090055466, -0.001248805085197091, 0.05373226851224899, 0.01450306549668312, 0.050363991409540176, 0.01898549310863018, 0.0036449867766350508, 0.0021986039355397224, -0.02394361048936844, -0.0009078672737814486, -0.059460707008838654, 0.0143198287114501, -0.04369236156344414, -0.07008367776870728, -0.0003945224452763796, -0.021344799548387527, -0.0028170510195195675, -0.0283372662961483, -0.008569351397454739, 0.021014800295233727, -0.028491638600826263, -0.013937302865087986, 0.029236529022455215, -0.0022309094201773405, 0.018308347091078758, 0.019266651943325996, 0.06216235086321831, 0.009491370059549809, -0.011905407533049583, 0.02054573968052864, 0.0643044114112854, -0.009081592783331871, 0.05479669198393822, -0.0007534142932854593, -0.030816657468676567, -0.018354110419750214, 0.053873028606176376, 0.022528227418661118, -0.018394216895103455, -0.0908152237534523, -0.02684069238603115, 0.002026872243732214, -0.0026690128725022078, 0.02308795228600502, 0.01640171743929386, -0.035125527530908585, 0.06345157325267792, -0.04499846324324608, -0.03967978432774544, -0.08038605004549026, 0.019052064046263695, -0.04968211054801941, 0.003948184195905924, -0.015349891036748886, 0.026375489309430122, 0.01696726307272911, -0.01769433356821537, -0.03319032862782478, 0.0008817922207526863, 0.015110835433006287, 0.049825116991996765, -0.030329465866088867, -0.01875676028430462, -0.00017072980699595064, -0.01632518321275711, -0.0353788398206234, 0.03993009403347969, -0.05016244575381279, -0.06429669260978699, -0.01136430911719799, 0.004163386765867472, 0.020192112773656845, -0.010752013884484768, -0.03835881128907204, 0.04415354132652283, 0.010062744840979576, -0.055093180388212204, 0.021324338391423225, -0.04099314287304878, 0.07100097090005875, 0.0607314370572567, 0.018293345347046852, 0.012941091321408749, -0.010183998383581638, 0.005130126141011715, 0.025004124268889427, -0.027244295924901962, -0.001753775984980166, -0.08066879212856293, -0.038071565330028534, 0.06545746326446533, 0.010228418745100498, -0.0025649964809417725, 0.007239948958158493, 0.052169784903526306, 0.05635370314121246, 0.013759438879787922, 0.013333195820450783, -0.03762861713767052, 0.010128184221684933, 0.03085372783243656, 0.06569231301546097, 0.00848802737891674, -0.0033276730682700872, 0.03317103162407875, -0.013457450084388256, 0.024631347507238388, 0.013757267035543919, 0.0010150709422305226, 0.030699579045176506, 0.034255608916282654, 0.003694858169183135, -0.007609343621879816, -0.019638335332274437, 0.06184478849172592, -0.023694297298789024, -0.021984083577990532, 0.01439098920673132, 0.026842311024665833, -0.004971738439053297, -0.012893159873783588, -0.022915834560990334, 0.0017507554730400443, 0.020943844690918922, -0.025166716426610947, 0.002141544595360756, 0.036096908152103424, -0.05495108291506767, 0.019605159759521484, -0.01213754154741764, -0.024392060935497284, -0.05059828981757164, 0.037344012409448624, -0.013252890668809414, -0.0036810366436839104, 0.016327455639839172, -0.00473468191921711, 0.024752220138907433, 0.015078140422701836, 0.007373633794486523, 0.04225039854645729, 0.03451096639037132, -0.03708327189087868, -0.010044034570455551, 0.018568534404039383, -0.02326306886970997, 0.04831385985016823, 0.0008713805582374334, -0.0176961999386549, 0.008052768185734749, 0.005295438226312399, -0.045672908425331116, -0.012599395588040352, -0.03882269561290741, 0.03628511726856232, -0.040650926530361176, -0.014465690590441227, -0.007561130449175835, -0.000581523694563657, -0.06379753351211548, 0.012031021527945995, -0.010210476815700531, 0.015395852737128735, -0.05205981433391571, 0.003582203760743141, -0.00041802978375926614, -0.0037799812853336334, -0.029652034863829613, 0.01804022304713726, 0.017203759402036667, 0.012601523660123348, -0.054152268916368484, -0.04088200628757477, 0.02949003502726555, -0.006309714633971453, 0.015702780336141586, 0.03867326304316521, 0.023199349641799927, 0.08026576787233353, 0.04592456668615341, -0.030936913564801216, -0.04550004377961159, -0.02734973095357418, 0.012985003180801868, -0.0073566194623708725, 0.008474386297166348, 0.032014068216085434, 0.01079661212861538, -0.03150435909628868, -0.01545685064047575, 0.024943767115473747, 0.03724011033773422, 0.007504673674702644, -0.03148450329899788, 0.036102913320064545, 0.01467323862016201, 0.001551467110402882, 0.020242182537913322, 0.07997998595237732, -0.014392622746527195, 0.05701838433742523, -0.03353186324238777, 0.005664001684635878, 0.004020360764116049, -0.03207722678780556, 0.008359755389392376, -0.032792508602142334, 0.0008849991718307137, 0.012662691995501518, 0.002692106179893017, -0.00696798088029027, -0.05694486200809479, 0.0002422741090413183, 0.0009614817681722343, 0.02530524879693985, -0.012705468572676182, -0.00020319074974395335, 0.04990210756659508, 0.018712902441620827, -0.032380200922489166, -0.0397176630795002, -0.05402354896068573, -0.04629933089017868, -0.0098869688808918, 0.016222210600972176, 0.018294354900717735, 0.022634856402873993, 0.011294214986264706, 0.040333837270736694, 0.033109139651060104, -0.03007577545940876, -0.029743237420916557, -0.05966585874557495, 0.008020772598683834, -0.04743930324912071, 0.04306461662054062, 0.0011338010663166642, 0.017780475318431854, -0.006689421832561493, -0.0018784456187859178, 0.010121975094079971, 0.031446222215890884, -0.05364324152469635, 0.018569212406873703, -0.014785019680857658, 0.004253994673490524, 0.027315059676766396, -0.03808624669909477, 0.026790348812937737, 0.004948906600475311, 0.008225995115935802, -0.02900136448442936, 0.010755183175206184, -0.021514082327485085, 0.005319461692124605, -0.015874773263931274, 0.008362759836018085, 0.048600949347019196, -0.019913962110877037, 0.0008904103888198733, 0.02961830422282219, 0.017025243490934372, -0.019819829612970352, 0.011590413749217987, -0.04260103031992912, -0.04395125061273575, -0.010702482424676418, 0.0004319903382565826, 0.029638493433594704, 0.015141833573579788, 0.005889893509447575, -0.034329988062381744, 0.023948494344949722, -0.007969880476593971, 0.021784821525216103, 0.007228442933410406, 0.037409134209156036, -0.022891230881214142, -0.06590736657381058, -0.03545617312192917, 0.05888748541474342, 0.014545931480824947, -0.008166370913386345, 0.018773354589939117, 0.0031218258664011955, 0.014761303551495075, -0.05487143620848656, -0.032821644097566605, 0.08350557833909988, 0.0016680470434948802, -0.02224668301641941, 0.001385270501486957, -0.02707325853407383, 0.013232299126684666, 0.004076731391251087, 0.051133107393980026, 0.008645654655992985, 0.0006450355285778642, 0.003204685403034091, 0.010589661076664925, -0.02473875880241394, -0.04877972602844238, 0.03398352116346359, 0.014198862947523594, 0.061410143971443176, -0.04979513958096504, -0.04618903249502182, -0.015552074648439884, 0.03952309116721153, 0.07163733243942261, 0.024440119042992592, 0.013159395195543766, -0.1435515284538269, 0.008092415519058704, 0.05044514685869217, 0.05791790410876274, -0.025421518832445145, -0.010948330163955688, -0.017337292432785034, -0.03925412520766258, 0.02108394354581833, -0.0360814593732357, 0.026324491947889328, -0.019512362778186798, 0.006934473291039467, -0.0017248564399778843, -0.0035013610031455755, -0.016287535429000854, 0.028585363179445267, -0.04553886502981186, 0.05920421704649925, 0.043936047703027725, -0.044679172337055206, -0.04281146451830864, 0.0005033929483033717, 0.01830963045358658, 0.10035596787929535, 0.008276424370706081, -0.025766542181372643, 0.020320896059274673, -0.013231813907623291, -0.01099186111241579, -0.05893164873123169, -0.02658352628350258, 0.011009934358298779, -0.01709398254752159, 0.07142564654350281, -0.01635998673737049, -0.041792456060647964, 0.03713949769735336, 0.03738625720143318, -0.01589062437415123, -0.0024029365740716457, -0.0375458188354969, 0.0037147013936191797, 0.050693463534116745, 0.004916108213365078, 0.022342192009091377, 0.013007324188947678, 0.0000469686601718422, 0.05026409775018692, -0.02296820469200611, 0.010887039825320244, -0.009256738238036633, -0.001700753578916192, -0.015158994123339653, 0.01957147754728794, -0.02832532674074173, 0.03276389092206955, 0.02739434689283371, 0.02128148078918457, -0.013367847539484501, -0.04508461058139801, -0.022252723574638367, 0.0258925873786211, -0.05557314679026604, -0.0014546538004651666, 0.03799508512020111, 0.020285209640860558, -0.005824707448482513, 0.02005314826965332, -0.011001714505255222, -0.011097744107246399, 0.034060120582580566, -0.0022561675868928432, -0.05562179535627365, 0.006524702999740839, -0.04712630808353424, -0.00032745127100497484, -0.004438231699168682, -0.002520211273804307, 0.07227138429880142, 0.02155204862356186, 0.0019024205394089222, 0.006735334638506174, -0.022325653582811356, -0.00338925514370203, 0.009080878458917141, -0.011370819061994553, 0.021698318421840668, -0.013074793852865696, 0.006701719481498003, -0.05837114155292511, -0.03016378916800022, -0.02546621486544609, -0.025502605363726616, 0.02946232073009014, 0.016313083469867706, -0.037612080574035645, -0.01941692642867565, 0.022234298288822174, 0.008669495582580566, -0.04062389209866524, -0.0008976003155112267, 0.08206917345523834, -0.022446095943450928, 0.007010927423834801, 0.0008069711038842797, 0.006738861091434956, 0.07716424763202667, 0.0354590006172657, 0.009816735051572323, 0.0056553795002400875, 0.03383350372314453, -0.01212715171277523, 0.008746898733079433, 0.02051551826298237, -0.027323944494128227, -0.01528985146433115, -0.055782582610845566, 0.009082859382033348, 0.027400687336921692, -0.038420990109443665, 0.021959122270345688, -0.0020210188813507557, 0.0029318667948246002, -0.0024841076228767633, -0.06032828241586685, 0.009830109775066376, 0.01699591428041458, -0.01784071885049343, 0.012827271595597267, 0.011604717932641506, -0.028767772018909454, -0.004563650581985712, 0.0439271554350853, 0.029364902526140213, 0.018880698829889297, 0.006240447051823139, 0.024510901421308517, -0.02668638899922371, 0.0065498133189976215, -0.005077064502984285, -0.03126000612974167, 0.05140933394432068, -0.02648238278925419, 0.03295959159731865, 0.012939194217324257, 0.0056551857851445675, -0.03547840937972069, -0.0014973657671362162, -0.026662224903702736, 0.00805868860334158, 0.047721583396196365, 0.028541170060634613, 0.04334001988172531, -0.007748966570943594, 0.028610054403543472, 0.002048090798780322, -0.022553062066435814, -0.03177638724446297, 0.009546970017254353, 0.031523048877716064, 0.017453905194997787, 0.046166881918907166, 0.024357616901397705, 0.025394989177584648, -0.005639500916004181, 0.02553698979318142, 0.0034221303649246693, 0.02388373762369156, 0.03528977930545807, -0.001900966977700591, -0.06578820198774338, -0.04253246262669563, -0.013147740624845028, -0.03716141730546951, 0.014019766822457314, -0.0006935483543202281, -0.0383836068212986, 0.07532297819852829, 0.02772212214767933, 0.004459362011402845, -0.03914005309343338, -0.041842419654130936, -0.07227309048175812, 0.018467159941792488, 0.0203477144241333, -0.002440225100144744, 0.008969910442829132, 0.016216840595006943, 0.0010335033293813467, -0.015585695393383503, 0.04338540881872177, 0.0020533015485852957, -0.044601187109947205, -0.033534497022628784, -0.01772930845618248, -0.03713712841272354, 0.0290679894387722, 0.019552942365407944, -0.0426361970603466, 0.002611233852803707, -0.05851684510707855, -0.024261055514216423, 0.02376936562359333, 0.05469946935772896, -0.02654799073934555, 0.03680029511451721, -0.02544817328453064, 0.014594673179090023, 0.022744888439774513, 0.002140544820576906, 0.13060738146305084, 0.10126037895679474, 0.05501917004585266, -0.057946208864450455, -0.0002847307187039405, 0.02371983602643013, -0.037015628069639206, -0.05264265090227127, 0.03190447762608528, -0.03626710921525955, -0.007488925475627184, 0.012404520064592361, 0.002838165033608675, 0.02542695216834545, -0.013945838436484337, 0.06829959154129028, -0.004370518960058689, -0.014825909398496151, 0.01015499047935009, 0.011335334740579128, 0.008128532208502293, -0.01986607164144516, -0.05537334084510803, 0.03126881644129753, 0.0078023215755820274, -0.031524982303380966, -0.01580910198390484, -0.02422812581062317, -0.023314116522669792, 0.0016209421446546912, -0.007896633818745613, 0.002726347418501973, -0.020908767357468605, -0.015274426899850368, 0.012973513454198837, 0.035506173968315125, 0.0007565704872831702, -0.05555568262934685, 0.021404562518000603, 0.03960258886218071, 0.03645312413573265, -0.02057710848748684, 0.007427240256220102, -0.00777801126241684, -0.045860566198825836, -0.03466741740703583, -0.06156199425458908, 0.04168947786092758, -0.04472816362977028, 0.022960033267736435, 0.027553129941225052, -0.010636935010552406, -0.02499457634985447, -0.048439871519804, 0.031270746141672134, 0.02615390159189701, 0.03395134583115578, -0.008679335005581379, -0.007840709760785103, -0.025057721883058548, 0.0336993969976902, 0.017266854643821716, 0.017912715673446655, 0.019931910559535027, 0.010971912182867527, -0.018025992438197136, -0.02494666911661625, 0.03147292137145996, 0.04806935787200928, -0.016972949728369713, -0.005084144417196512, -0.019895140081644058, 0.0006548772798851132, 0.01507878489792347, -0.022603046149015427, 0.030990825966000557, -0.03269628435373306, -0.02382109872996807, -0.005542232189327478, -0.000566406175494194, -0.029943153262138367, -0.019595127552747726, -0.018731899559497833, 0.003688979195430875, -0.026704851537942886, -0.04141661524772644, 0.02934977225959301, 0.02820315770804882, 0.03164200112223625, 0.025877006351947784, -0.0034357106778770685, 0.0509636364877224, 0.005427254363894463, -0.030169159173965454, 0.018689719960093498, 0.0059654610231518745, -0.05653222277760506, 0.01417713612318039, 0.0002441330871079117, 0.07474514842033386, 0.030700599774718285, 0.020560190081596375, 0.0160925704985857, -0.023023411631584167, 0.004357219208031893, 0.028835710138082504, 0.00729750469326973, -0.06704994291067123, -0.011273077689111233, -0.02199135161936283, -0.036911576986312866, -0.09978853166103363, -0.05563518777489662, -0.04287593811750412, -0.0066487728618085384, 0.03019087016582489, -0.016254104673862457, -0.03597470372915268, 0.0074746254831552505, -0.011847155168652534, 0.05257657170295715, -0.047999054193496704, -0.00985802710056305, 0.005644060671329498, 0.0031938129104673862, -0.0305153951048851, -0.010247739963233471, -0.022245444357395172, 0.005968721117824316, 0.00425088033080101, 0.01745782420039177, 0.01390074472874403, 0.0001631891936995089, -0.0014558356488123536, 0.012339239940047264, -0.00382260512560606, -0.04661230742931366, 0.01795441098511219, -0.04989512637257576, -0.024793803691864014, 0.03390384092926979, -0.026270566508173943, -0.03258410841226578, 0.005511409603059292, -0.0053733051754534245, 0.04522433876991272, 0.030182167887687683, -0.047510698437690735, 0.02598237432539463, 0.04174862429499626, 0.02134210430085659, -0.025239689275622368, 0.0007060444913804531, 0.030183127149939537, 0.017271025106310844, 0.021878989413380623, 0.03217897564172745, 0.008306078612804413, 0.017626971006393433, 0.007497182581573725, 0.012611089274287224, -0.007445302791893482, -0.009363871067762375, 0.0034365905448794365, -0.027966110035777092, -0.02002064697444439, 0.014806955121457577, 0.014977365732192993, 0.01760467141866684, 0.018491262570023537, -0.023009128868579865, 0.03709699958562851, -0.0039290329441428185, 0.010232731699943542, -0.1017540767788887, -0.0036372223403304815, -0.0012854390079155564, -0.00010034127626568079, 0.030748240649700165, -0.08193972706794739, 0.028207167983055115, 0.035645075142383575, -0.0848209485411644, 0.004427614621818066, -0.013588955625891685, -0.015356384217739105, -0.011000046506524086, 0.006271747872233391, -0.004517184104770422, -0.011090407148003578, -0.00001910383980430197, 0.03366420790553093, 0.014542700722813606, 0.014697504229843616, -0.019057856872677803, -0.03158583119511604, -0.008141170255839825, 0.04914505034685135, 0.012270682491362095, -0.02222343161702156, 0.06565839797258377, -0.058723945170640945, -0.028292076662182808, 0.05311613157391548, -0.016570253297686577, 0.01870792917907238, 0.06562995910644531, 0.039929989725351334, -0.011959104798734188, 0.046226710081100464, 0.04333757609128952, -0.025999756529927254, -0.004186812788248062, 0.02448456920683384, 0.0003905517514795065, 0.03816702216863632, 0.021535366773605347, 0.04114515334367752, 0.029588352888822556, 0.0001396338630001992, 0.006333406548947096, -0.029093408957123756, -0.0400916263461113, -0.02033613808453083, 0.019324177876114845, -0.010209229774773121, 0.00009589440742274746, -0.026223842054605484, 0.014215877279639244, -0.02962491288781166, 0.033952850848436356, 0.03674544021487236, 0.02325938083231449, -0.010583519004285336, -0.014099021442234516, -0.021822158247232437, -0.012313302606344223, -0.0329354926943779, -0.006149099674075842, 0.009141397662460804, -0.05926384776830673, 0.013841196894645691, 0.014656194485723972, -0.035826653242111206, -0.03184801712632179, 0.01993393898010254, -0.005083709955215454, 0.06961400806903839, -0.01332095917314291, 0.04536481574177742, 0.06320935487747192, 0.0009358103852719069, -0.0019468117970973253, -0.07788661122322083, 0.029606157913804054, 0.028790760785341263, 0.02142442762851715, -0.03632783889770508, -0.012844255194067955, -0.021554889157414436, -0.04263322800397873, 0.02988719753921032, -0.06439624726772308, 0.007085953839123249, -0.010643026791512966, 0.0256044939160347, -0.0369035080075264, -0.03226473182439804, 0.02038903906941414, -0.03451777622103691, -0.014493677765130997, -0.004298239015042782, -0.03821307793259621, 0.017262307927012444, -0.03841102495789528, -0.00033617016742937267, 0.004180975258350372, -0.0260209571570158, 0.01368869747966528, 0.009578377939760685, 0.016947265714406967, 0.014231152832508087, 0.023719124495983124, 0.03207459673285484, 0.04639219865202904, -0.014985408633947372, 0.017843015491962433, -0.029482213780283928, -0.03066178597509861, 0.050224244594573975, -0.022088756784796715, -0.0219037476927042, -0.027822110801935196, 0.02046748623251915, 0.011295712552964687, -0.04648783430457115, -0.004118053242564201, 0.010977561585605145, -0.010268807411193848, 0.04681505635380745, 0.026994045823812485, -0.00449381023645401, 0.02789907716214657, 0.015974540263414383, 0.01406068354845047, -0.002757868729531765, 0.020361585542559624, -0.0019199185771867633, 0.017150649800896645, -0.008508894592523575, 0.00747399078682065, 0.005212785676121712, 0.018124375492334366, -0.011185694485902786, 0.04465389624238014, 0.027995282784104347, 0.020298177376389503, 0.00019862109911628067, 0.02423938550055027, -0.020770801231265068, 0.002901381114497781, -0.00395042821764946, -0.001643280847929418, -0.011522949673235416, 0.04770763963460922, -0.0470101572573185, -0.01481088437139988, -0.060109641402959824, -0.029366038739681244, -0.02736836113035679, 0.0340559147298336, -0.00991892535239458, 0.02481924556195736, 0.015872061252593994, 0.03674842789769173, 0.0067067984491586685, 0.03935785964131355, 0.028547799214720726, -0.014478390105068684, 0.031910546123981476, -0.019201384857296944, -0.009960534051060677, -0.013274583034217358, -0.0451967753469944, -0.017882652580738068, -0.02541566826403141, 0.009525171481072903, 0.060616184026002884, -0.03463168814778328, 0.004214727785438299, 0.018209943547844887, -0.030758041888475418, 0.021893098950386047, -0.03314204514026642, 0.013600921258330345, -0.07247985899448395, 0.0028246960137039423, 0.012973110191524029, -0.041750144213438034 ]
<p>For given cost function $S(\beta) = (Y - X \beta)^T(Y - X \beta) + \lambda \beta^T \beta$, where $\lambda$ is regularization parameter, the $\beta$ that minimizes the given cost function is $\beta = [X^T X + \lambda]^{-1} X^T Y$.</p> <p>is it right? </p>
48,943
[ -0.0518384724855423, 0.013677872717380524, -0.01854226179420948, 0.007506858557462692, 0.021097559481859207, 0.01590200513601303, -0.021899478510022163, 0.008719151839613914, 0.04558312147855759, -0.04150371253490448, 0.051809486001729965, 0.023591160774230957, 0.06959957629442215, -0.006968342233449221, -0.015373469330370426, 0.010953704826533794, -0.0496242493391037, 0.0073892828077077866, -0.02137887477874756, 0.014760416001081467, 0.013755434192717075, 0.03602610155940056, -0.008055396378040314, 0.028040673583745956, -0.018925977870821953, 0.03632192686200142, 0.0028519178740680218, 0.00030110686202533543, -0.03305816277861595, 0.0741349384188652, -0.025079820305109024, -0.01291282195597887, -0.009716473519802094, 0.05752094089984894, 0.03864229843020439, 0.0043597775511443615, -0.05164574831724167, -0.01793842948973179, -0.025005392730236053, 0.045282091945409775, 0.0628010556101799, -0.041642121970653534, 0.02876013144850731, 0.039305709302425385, -0.015719974413514137, 0.047821879386901855, 0.00456317188218236, -0.031418390572071075, -0.008005035109817982, -0.016721466556191444, 0.05801226571202278, -0.023734256625175476, 0.030934713780879974, 0.01922653429210186, -0.029440829530358315, -0.03863902762532234, 0.05172460898756981, 0.058741696178913116, 0.01963970623910427, -0.0298038050532341, 0.0017925178399309516, 0.01528067048639059, 0.01502702571451664, 0.0033324738033115864, -0.02922484651207924, 0.03960689157247543, 0.02396620437502861, 0.02820059470832348, 0.018477672711014748, -0.03206436708569527, 0.0029646395705640316, 0.004912505857646465, 0.006732683163136244, -0.0007222304120659828, 0.00579447764903307, 0.006582025904208422, -0.005220633465796709, 0.058015767484903336, 0.034411054104566574, -0.002353094983845949, 0.06082119420170784, 0.01983913592994213, 0.05074860528111458, 0.022696109488606453, -0.028585948050022125, 0.03074871003627777, 0.07553589344024658, -0.03990533575415611, 0.03382183983922005, 0.04266740754246712, 0.03279763087630272, 0.019515780732035637, 0.03798972815275192, -0.036990273743867874, 0.015418234281241894, 0.06606096774339676, -0.003115862375125289, 0.015484551899135113, 0.032851751893758774, -0.03547568991780281, -0.04488297179341316, -0.05202580988407135, -0.03346933424472809, 0.03556035831570625, -0.03722842410206795, -0.017403582111001015, -0.029661647975444794, 0.036095473915338516, -0.021435750648379326, -0.017145561054348946, -0.0592954196035862, 0.002005657646805048, -0.027079341933131218, -0.013748835772275925, 0.02308036759495735, -0.007397543638944626, 0.029908975586295128, -0.02380678988993168, 0.009068494662642479, 0.04268260300159454, 0.0002977547701448202, -0.031269751489162445, 0.01571502350270748, 0.010593126527965069, -0.0045006475411355495, 0.0026583815924823284, 0.01673431508243084, -0.008541044779121876, -0.04965028911828995, 0.024150727316737175, 0.038512807339429855, -0.036534540355205536, 0.046953894197940826, 0.0006549156387336552, 0.016606701537966728, -0.010623686946928501, -0.05677817016839981, -0.0513070672750473, 0.01193065196275711, -0.00490809790790081, 0.02510165423154831, -0.03249708563089371, -0.028836989775300026, 0.03069894388318062, 0.0481802374124527, 0.010892406105995178, 0.04182460531592369, 0.057929567992687225, 0.007199108600616455, -0.02827749028801918, 0.003125601215288043, 0.00160175038035959, -0.010029826313257217, -0.019952576607465744, -0.03184552118182182, -0.07217974215745926, 0.013966064900159836, 0.016876082867383957, -0.013918392360210419, -0.005753645207732916, 0.02952117659151554, -0.016912836581468582, 0.00008132866059895605, -0.029434774070978165, -0.012789706699550152, -0.0505642369389534, 0.023273171856999397, 0.03595999255776405, 0.028876177966594696, 0.035942334681749344, -0.008008805103600025, 0.019309798255562782, -0.015007073991000652, 0.021844271570444107, 0.036214616149663925, -0.044359005987644196, -0.053309857845306396, -0.0628041923046112, 0.01027296856045723, 0.032476697117090225, -0.04287678375840187, -0.015286928042769432, -0.052123188972473145, 0.049356549978256226, 0.019405342638492584, 0.07705709338188171, 0.022953486070036888, -0.02113858237862587, 0.03214923292398453, -0.04516448825597763, -0.046485479921102524, -0.023758063092827797, 0.00006221256626304239, -0.011946472339332104, -0.018241820856928825, 0.021918784826993942, -0.004406750202178955, 0.013607165776193142, -0.008770979940891266, 0.006152277812361717, 0.010564004071056843, 0.022646650671958923, 0.05412357300519943, -0.006053844932466745, 0.018266212195158005, 0.06534946709871292, 0.04655111953616142, -0.007046428043395281, 0.05783012509346008, -0.0240078903734684, -0.03527023643255234, -0.00702541833743453, -0.00424164580181241, 0.0050636460073292255, -0.015639137476682663, -0.007280134595930576, 0.029132800176739693, -0.03718290477991104, -0.01772596314549446, 0.017173906788229942, -0.06869865953922272, 0.07005912065505981, 0.07488132268190384, 0.009707886725664139, 0.002326554385945201, 0.002360280603170395, 0.0028577258344739676, 0.041211873292922974, -0.03012782335281372, -0.03786015883088112, -0.03876155614852905, -0.03625349700450897, 0.02235010266304016, 0.06611242145299911, -0.02845664508640766, -0.0031127664260566235, 0.026864483952522278, 0.005044763907790184, 0.027343060821294785, 0.005585957318544388, 0.019647428765892982, -0.013709486462175846, 0.023690827190876007, 0.01224329974502325, -0.008505964651703835, 0.011903742328286171, -0.034438926726579666, -0.03680523857474327, 0.03933870047330856, -0.01590917259454727, 0.012716416269540787, 0.028171785175800323, 0.013312513940036297, -0.009969744831323624, 0.01521623507142067, -0.02062629908323288, 0.032592855393886566, -0.015217467211186886, 0.027316443622112274, 0.01415183674544096, 0.00576816126704216, 0.04659716412425041, -0.013278396800160408, 0.014127232134342194, 0.018101096153259277, 0.02175145410001278, -0.03241604566574097, 0.019213499501347542, 0.04146989807486534, -0.054280199110507965, 0.0030784679111093283, -0.008384802378714085, -0.03154565021395683, 0.003214732278138399, -0.014806972816586494, 0.028636496514081955, 0.014884565025568008, 0.010769409127533436, -0.03653178736567497, -0.0013458076864480972, -0.0015304088592529297, -0.0211044754832983, 0.035010889172554016, 0.018253864720463753, -0.03947339579463005, 0.0015768656739965081, -0.07535704225301743, 0.02317781001329422, 0.03211096674203873, -0.0063822027295827866, 0.0037043902557343245, -0.011526085436344147, -0.007680179551243782, -0.07129942625761032, -0.026235971599817276, -0.07588821649551392, 0.043756239116191864, 0.007281355559825897, 0.008618250489234924, 0.047870244830846786, 0.03557627275586128, -0.049436286091804504, 0.014971766620874405, -0.012654910795390606, -0.05554119125008583, -0.037007689476013184, -0.02361425943672657, 0.007067385129630566, -0.00035932002356275916, 0.014373555779457092, 0.023760152980685234, -0.003595232032239437, 0.0016297143884003162, -0.06901238858699799, -0.03436373546719551, 0.04018575698137283, -0.0004233378276694566, 0.017335766926407814, -0.005183096043765545, -0.02268284372985363, 0.109458327293396, 0.05502961203455925, -0.017027687281370163, -0.018394431099295616, 0.038014043122529984, -0.04798115789890289, -0.04117434471845627, 0.016223471611738205, 0.010960688814520836, -0.000801576767116785, 0.05262615159153938, 0.006369198672473431, 0.025272050872445107, 0.030728217214345932, 0.03491150215268135, 0.0023889741860330105, 0.0029655764810740948, 0.013605003245174885, -0.0006690217414870858, 0.05300609767436981, 0.01406844612210989, 0.02663993090391159, 0.03267883509397507, -0.019728729501366615, 0.020535605028271675, -0.015063042752444744, -0.016577286645770073, 0.0016223491402342916, -0.02351026050746441, 0.021267840638756752, -0.02159067615866661, 0.04388546198606491, 0.031919077038764954, 0.013962705619633198, -0.04897936061024666, 0.006367641966789961, 0.010251288302242756, -0.003530095098540187, -0.013029330410063267, 0.021392492577433586, 0.02282029576599598, -0.012679756619036198, -0.011616612784564495, -0.02399650774896145, -0.04325989633798599, -0.006148761138319969, -0.00533361965790391, -0.03266036510467529, -0.007292832247912884, 0.044540077447891235, 0.0009960487950593233, -0.003421911271288991, -0.04858161509037018, -0.015573984012007713, -0.07799141108989716, -0.005728689022362232, -0.002186815021559596, 0.042710959911346436, 0.010554244741797447, 0.014436665922403336, 0.029634766280651093, 0.02458144910633564, 0.001078399713151157, 0.02137838490307331, -0.08395954221487045, 0.03358665108680725, -0.005516565404832363, -0.003114461898803711, -0.006590055767446756, -0.02655978873372078, 0.048430006951093674, -0.021027332171797752, 0.01104707270860672, -0.0023637805134058, 0.010564310476183891, -0.04927996173501015, -0.0011129778577014804, -0.012780713848769665, -0.018016155809164047, 0.0012206572573632002, -0.007954121567308903, 0.03556453064084053, -0.022026970982551575, 0.019872870296239853, 0.031038014218211174, -0.023757902905344963, 0.01367631834000349, -0.026610566303133965, 0.030363017693161964, 0.038667503744363785, 0.022594662383198738, -0.00810001976788044, 0.03653450682759285, -0.041103608906269073, 0.02051030844449997, 0.014583284966647625, -0.007411167025566101, 0.03436984866857529, -0.042211104184389114, -0.0397103987634182, -0.08899152278900146, -0.03901490196585655, 0.01867302879691124, -0.011548206210136414, 0.021776925772428513, -0.0038916440680623055, 0.034771908074617386, 0.016201302409172058, -0.030044933781027794, -0.03305741399526596, 0.058297935873270035, 0.002699528355151415, -0.0329180583357811, -0.04921548813581467, -0.002633725292980671, -0.031942516565322876, 0.0005199678707867861, 0.016035526990890503, -0.02511790581047535, -0.051832787692546844, 0.005086648743599653, 0.007612464018166065, -0.01474285963922739, 0.011171260848641396, 0.01457210537046194, 0.02905653789639473, 0.02599233202636242, -0.017466843128204346, -0.04022235423326492, 0.05109236761927605, 0.04074542596936226, 0.02875058725476265, 0.07210762053728104, 0.003555105999112129, -0.05043055862188339, -0.03408997133374214, -0.010141381062567234, 0.051195792853832245, -0.006249284837394953, -0.004391344264149666, -0.05387982353568077, -0.04526309669017792, 0.028580155223608017, -0.004315630067139864, 0.018627284094691277, -0.00841535720974207, 0.0017373670125380158, 0.0002514327934477478, -0.05190128833055496, -0.04499368369579315, -0.016307014971971512, -0.023642104119062424, 0.03910931572318077, -0.003544916631653905, -0.008144729770720005, -0.02144612744450569, -0.005743212066590786, -0.011995675973594189, 0.07622040808200836, -0.0038322352338582277, -0.026597734540700912, 0.004361401312053204, 0.012271534651517868, -0.022069258615374565, -0.06857454031705856, 0.00810975767672062, 0.017979765310883522, -0.03600957989692688, 0.015626417472958565, 0.02556305006146431, -0.02962401695549488, 0.03639787808060646, 0.049412332475185394, -0.01959536038339138, 0.02154442109167576, -0.019873959943652153, 0.023857826367020607, 0.06081230938434601, 0.01887211762368679, 0.05547310411930084, 0.026567813009023666, 0.004312057048082352, 0.014684001915156841, -0.02994604967534542, -0.007090836763381958, -0.00889742374420166, -0.006688163615763187, -0.015729103237390518, -0.04053439944982529, -0.0005779485800303519, 0.022717684507369995, -0.01783624477684498, 0.0406479574739933, -0.022719424217939377, 0.007309233769774437, -0.018500158563256264, 0.040994297713041306, -0.009474261663854122, -0.018510742112994194, 0.04381592199206352, 0.049012843519449234, 0.03445135056972504, -0.013834184035658836, -0.0035749669186770916, -0.010117007419466972, 0.026745887473225594, 0.06037624180316925, -0.024214962497353554, 0.0007174471393227577, -0.021192658692598343, -0.0381777323782444, 0.010251588188111782, -0.023456813767552376, 0.038321420550346375, 0.00472476938739419, 0.005048847291618586, -0.03537026420235634, -0.030069738626480103, -0.03348275646567345, 0.012823617085814476, -0.029781339690089226, -0.029963960871100426, -0.0811442956328392, -0.024614430963993073, 0.012311454862356186, 0.008105358108878136, -0.05962789058685303, -0.029136499390006065, 0.011971140280365944, 0.024797841906547546, -0.039278239011764526, 0.007122125942260027, 0.009436573833227158, -0.02146153524518013, -0.07702692598104477, -0.034552671015262604, 0.031168056651949883, -0.01549393031746149, -0.01008676178753376, -0.013440589420497417, -0.0075660631991922855, 0.05264517292380333, 0.024078041315078735, 0.02531924843788147, 0.0011310086119920015, -0.007269956171512604, -0.03845515474677086, -0.0047341943718492985, 0.015337325632572174, -0.030047830194234848, 0.0042982762679457664, -0.033163007348775864, 0.017661359161138535, 0.012133322656154633, 0.03585661202669144, -0.041904449462890625, 0.04455499351024628, 0.003067662939429283, -0.013973938301205635, -0.05177408456802368, -0.01016145758330822, 0.036288853734731674, 0.010300609283149242, 0.012728855945169926, -0.009835510514676571, -0.0034927972592413425, -0.025282513350248337, 0.029693663120269775, -0.010836937464773655, 0.015848727896809578, -0.009409372694790363, 0.06536675989627838, -0.0283022690564394, -0.006843081209808588, -0.020816762000322342, 0.01047228742390871, 0.042510200291872025, -0.009777982719242573, 0.015565404668450356, -0.004112655762583017, 0.04411335662007332, -0.06976036727428436, 0.015872621908783913, -0.0380207821726799, 0.05601787567138672, 0.04735977202653885, 0.00220499443821609, 0.05261152982711792, 0.024034250527620316, -0.011165189556777477, -0.015671834349632263, -0.07453048229217529, -0.010966523550450802, -0.003463056171312928, -0.02088197134435177, 0.042022690176963806, 0.0020101286936551332, -0.022476263344287872, 0.03331829980015755, -0.0010149086592718959, -0.03729354962706566, 0.011331751942634583, -0.014253735542297363, -0.010803301818668842, 0.008979368954896927, -0.06502655893564224, -0.060291316360235214, 0.0018096123822033405, -0.017277274280786514, 0.0436527244746685, -0.021468594670295715, -0.04857170581817627, 0.037364695221185684, 0.003489479422569275, 0.01818530261516571, -0.04220284894108772, -0.008709684945642948, -0.019177639856934547, -0.002114521572366357, 0.007025911007076502, 0.008396224118769169, 0.030185582116246223, -0.020967362448573112, 0.023254554718732834, 0.0008908512536436319, 0.07479804754257202, -0.028902163729071617, -0.05323941260576248, -0.01541046891361475, -0.03047460876405239, -0.04497630521655083, 0.03201316297054291, -0.003658168949186802, -0.020008496940135956, -0.007178099360316992, -0.05546972155570984, 0.00906407367438078, 0.03585285693407059, 0.03199474513530731, -0.00491753127425909, 0.04874845966696739, 0.005245264619588852, 0.01849399134516716, -0.024720193818211555, 0.04690953716635704, 0.12939992547035217, 0.12307937443256378, 0.015628334134817123, -0.05464024469256401, 0.012967518530786037, -0.045078571885824203, 0.0011318576289340854, -0.023082448169589043, 0.02456987090408802, -0.003948741126805544, -0.000274956866633147, 0.019489938393235207, 0.014165532775223255, -0.004373752046376467, -0.019249238073825836, 0.0072574191726744175, -0.05314625799655914, -0.01746361330151558, 0.02613154985010624, -0.009274394251406193, 0.005448339972645044, 0.026318848133087158, -0.005865149665623903, 0.003219297155737877, -0.03291458263993263, -0.04692072048783302, -0.024718474596738815, -0.011137537658214569, 0.014463813044130802, -0.035064540803432465, 0.0005306908278726041, 0.00453219935297966, 0.011872922070324421, -0.01897611655294895, -0.009841457940638065, -0.0013132615713402629, -0.00962020456790924, -0.016409292817115784, -0.012913486920297146, 0.03331795707345009, -0.005705384071916342, 0.03119741566479206, -0.00016711163334548473, 0.009165356867015362, -0.04776885360479355, 0.012501847930252552, -0.05446460843086243, 0.0340849906206131, -0.013667323626577854, 0.03295241668820381, 0.012295618653297424, -0.0017448619473725557, -0.001515361713245511, -0.06970523297786713, 0.002714533358812332, 0.03375476226210594, 0.020421819761395454, -0.020387696102261543, -0.0007325602346099913, -0.019040225073695183, 0.0044967131689190865, 0.0033083204180002213, -0.017359117045998573, 0.02026122622191906, -0.0372190997004509, -0.005249183624982834, 0.04067552462220192, 0.03597331419587135, -0.00840700976550579, 0.03128272294998169, 0.0060353269800543785, -0.023874228820204735, -0.009962093085050583, -0.007268163841217756, 0.009858676232397556, -0.004193758126348257, 0.04209918901324272, -0.018045607954263687, 0.00012126339424867183, -0.034758906811475754, -0.06600446254014969, 0.030469978228211403, -0.028225915506482124, 0.0020565513987094164, -0.053081583231687546, 0.010278229601681232, 0.02704913727939129, 0.06000709533691406, 0.009542139247059822, -0.008614699356257915, 0.01997358538210392, 0.028384681791067123, 0.011659402400255203, -0.03654221445322037, -0.02041778340935707, 0.004087384790182114, -0.03647998347878456, 0.02803085930645466, -0.00023480319941882044, 0.06982837617397308, 0.054488226771354675, 0.08347324281930923, -0.0017398488707840443, 0.01778019219636917, 0.01336304284632206, 0.023002425208687782, -0.012686274945735931, -0.06671804189682007, 0.020161278545856476, 0.0020415999460965395, -0.004463325720280409, -0.051744066178798676, -0.0017912785988301039, -0.05107801407575607, 0.02957947738468647, 0.03053559549152851, 0.006413343828171492, -0.052776556462049484, 0.014181647449731827, 0.012859982438385487, 0.03521881625056267, -0.06132807955145836, -0.013314550742506981, -0.002835032995790243, 0.031243398785591125, -0.020531795918941498, -0.04015759378671646, -0.010121581144630909, -0.012139166705310345, -0.008554324507713318, -0.002656792290508747, 0.022728774696588516, 0.0246876273304224, 0.013644805178046227, 0.004570663440972567, 0.02353455312550068, 0.009377307258546352, 0.06173994392156601, -0.0027701961807906628, 0.012547536753118038, 0.022726668044924736, -0.0702243223786354, -0.037151552736759186, 0.013121376745402813, 0.006724268198013306, 0.018368421122431755, 0.04132111743092537, 0.008436339907348156, -0.020466351881623268, 0.02368379756808281, -0.018161684274673462, -0.017560411244630814, -0.0009250395814888179, -0.007933830842375755, 0.05435352399945259, -0.03420179709792137, 0.02066921629011631, -0.012927777133882046, 0.007283699698746204, -0.01839265786111355, -0.0023965523578226566, -0.029834909364581108, -0.022465454414486885, 0.016623884439468384, -0.009487772360444069, 0.028629407286643982, 0.005632193759083748, 0.033267661929130554, 0.020020173862576485, 0.02380511723458767, -0.009249895811080933, 0.02420947700738907, 0.011866697110235691, -0.0020166360773146152, -0.1027299091219902, -0.012391040101647377, 0.01819179765880108, 0.015009697526693344, 0.045063566416502, -0.037816647440195084, 0.05282224714756012, 0.02471844293177128, -0.042340923100709915, 0.024769814684987068, -0.040079161524772644, 0.02585797943174839, -0.05446871742606163, 0.004288400057703257, -0.006618233397603035, 0.03351207450032234, 0.05881933867931366, 0.05799172818660736, 0.016144972294569016, 0.03780779987573624, -0.0070190331898629665, -0.024507589638233185, -0.008128130808472633, 0.03591888025403023, -0.016905365511775017, -0.039245352149009705, 0.03444560617208481, -0.033459074795246124, -0.024141984060406685, 0.02749580517411232, 0.02696293778717518, 0.0007363120676018298, 0.020494207739830017, 0.04763257876038551, 0.023349685594439507, 0.018960537388920784, 0.03372190520167351, -0.020471613854169846, -0.007466573268175125, 0.007736637722700834, 0.008524051867425442, 0.053969066590070724, -0.0033290949650108814, 0.015111381188035011, 0.018012290820479393, -0.03326558321714401, -0.025111868977546692, 0.012968729250133038, -0.008557937107980251, -0.05362832173705101, 0.012891987338662148, -0.02336116135120392, -0.00880647823214531, -0.02892346680164337, -0.009287766180932522, -0.02220452018082142, -0.02075972408056259, 0.04908831790089607, 0.011143499054014683, -0.03038959391415119, -0.03858334571123123, 0.008137830533087254, -0.08203303068876266, 0.023199820891022682, 0.007125216536223888, -0.004443727433681488, -0.05066519230604172, 0.033750563859939575, 0.029529865831136703, -0.017465410754084587, -0.021291084587574005, -0.026623260229825974, 0.0004048648406751454, 0.030624864622950554, 0.007898767478764057, 0.008954029530286789, 0.02219771407544613, -0.02063712850213051, -0.013473459519445896, -0.11043614894151688, 0.06350649148225784, -0.011109501123428345, -0.026634547859430313, -0.01057701651006937, 0.015701385214924812, -0.03058340586721897, -0.017212118953466415, 0.05334998667240143, -0.030542034655809402, -0.00607524486258626, 0.01790684647858143, 0.013773760758340359, 0.010632914490997791, -0.039407696574926376, 0.03294248506426811, 0.000712034699972719, -0.007799139712005854, -0.004926384426653385, 0.0002813358441926539, 0.00883464328944683, 0.022893888875842094, -0.020296968519687653, -0.004950203467160463, 0.006397493649274111, 0.0036334090400487185, 0.003647053148597479, 0.019024308770895004, 0.0198630653321743, -0.013521652668714523, 0.05733964592218399, 0.035889822989702225, 0.022173147648572922, 0.009599000215530396, -0.05553734675049782, -0.05109018459916115, -0.032634131610393524, -0.042480409145355225, -0.035661742091178894, 0.01547598373144865, -0.006636478006839752, -0.015273208729922771, -0.008513965643942356, -0.031169593334197998, 0.04436149075627327, -0.023310916498303413, -0.032612692564725876, 0.03471820801496506, -0.0002508561301510781, 0.04939839243888855, -0.03356151655316353, 0.028739839792251587, 0.041501663625240326, 0.016065729781985283, 0.002338315127417445, 0.038269564509391785, 0.007928303442895412, -0.007414801046252251, -0.014303663745522499, 0.0033183745108544827, -0.011309392750263214, 0.033836424350738525, 0.003541340120136738, 0.0480484776198864, -0.04002098739147186, -0.025721408426761627, 0.009850241243839264, -0.007221217267215252, -0.021261675283312798, -0.0243053175508976, -0.015163334086537361, 0.041421789675951004, -0.021167246624827385, 0.006540690548717976, -0.030147798359394073, 0.007861634716391563, -0.04802333563566208, -0.002922895597293973, 0.006073863711208105, 0.005091628059744835, 0.027268655598163605, -0.0466596744954586, 0.008033580146729946, -0.004202731419354677, 0.03240446373820305, -0.036201588809490204, 0.013510752469301224, -0.024132657796144485, -0.012363994494080544, -0.009391448460519314, -0.025424649938941002, -0.024460546672344208, -0.021298415958881378, 0.03441476449370384, 0.05933770164847374, -0.007274197414517403, 0.015050872229039669, -0.029408782720565796, -0.025228427723050117, 0.0499906912446022, -0.08447562903165817, -0.0006037279963493347, -0.006800128612667322, 0.026291152462363243, 0.043056756258010864, 0.001507480163127184 ]
<p>I'm looking for a dataset (preferably with a story, at any rate a real dataset) where a SVM with a linear kernel performs well...in other words i'm looking for a dataset where the class boundary is likely to be linear. Ideally, there should be between 10-20 continuous variables and not too many discrete ones....</p> <p>It's not really important to me how many classes there are (as long as it's a classification problem). Also, it can't be the iris dataset. </p> <p>Any proposals?</p> <p>P.S.: @modo: i don't think this is a question about obtaining a particular dataset: it's more that i have not read svm/machine learning papers since i was a master student so i'm not familiar with some comon good examples...i'm just sure they exist.</p>
74,345
[ -0.04725388064980507, -0.03022005781531334, 0.0074674510397017, 0.014072759076952934, 0.016229189932346344, 0.015754980966448784, -0.015332367271184921, 0.016530586406588554, 0.005580130498856306, -0.0050289202481508255, 0.023756835609674454, 0.04325550049543381, 0.05720141902565956, 0.036343298852443695, 0.00860523246228695, -0.011790617369115353, -0.015458235517144203, -0.021179042756557465, -0.044782500714063644, 0.024068068712949753, -0.006529017351567745, 0.006402083206921816, 0.03641944006085396, -0.002753147156909108, -0.039009250700473785, 0.016946496441960335, 0.006145905237644911, -0.0053365398198366165, 0.011504833586513996, 0.02881919965147972, -0.06398353725671768, -0.017816150560975075, 0.015386342070996761, 0.032137248665094376, 0.009821681305766106, 0.00816483236849308, -0.029176050797104836, -0.020276006311178207, -0.0067144641652703285, 0.031504418700933456, 0.011629031971096992, -0.008108507841825485, 0.0069960420951247215, 0.08702835440635681, 0.00646947231143713, 0.04882824048399925, 0.0449012815952301, -0.029988858848810196, 0.007116248831152916, -0.040798138827085495, 0.05676931515336037, -0.034399088472127914, 0.026812119409441948, 0.035659175366163254, -0.00039744676905684173, 0.0031437426805496216, 0.05160602554678917, 0.06756538152694702, 0.03463710471987724, -0.023346731439232826, -0.014627468772232533, 0.0009001417201943696, -0.025294939056038857, -0.02687833085656166, -0.027009665966033936, 0.04296857491135597, 0.017840994521975517, -0.014459335245192051, 0.013297428376972675, -0.013549908064305782, -0.015602696686983109, 0.026494137942790985, 0.03424861654639244, 0.03542280197143555, -0.012092739343643188, 0.02214023284614086, -0.002206336474046111, 0.04186093434691429, 0.028911907225847244, -0.02796538546681404, 0.028744632378220558, 0.007566260639578104, 0.021151479333639145, 0.026318605989217758, 0.020578237250447273, -0.021076012402772903, 0.0879569947719574, 0.02222025953233242, 0.015424668788909912, 0.04160730540752411, -0.005270097404718399, -0.028762880712747574, 0.044362086802721024, 0.028137240558862686, -0.08054288476705551, 0.022932499647140503, -0.005084540229290724, 0.035983406007289886, 0.04489612206816673, -0.03299785405397415, -0.013814039528369904, -0.011407025158405304, -0.00016695453086867929, 0.08300228416919708, -0.006716576870530844, -0.019031766802072525, -0.027520332485437393, -0.014307343401014805, -0.040068235248327255, -0.004642042797058821, -0.047297969460487366, 0.008816320449113846, 0.033658914268016815, -0.004942794796079397, -0.014125939458608627, -0.016408532857894897, 0.00513240322470665, -0.04353928565979004, 0.0060051679611206055, 0.051506463438272476, 0.056683044880628586, -0.011571736074984074, 0.005542302038520575, -0.014144791290163994, -0.006246511358767748, 0.04947343468666077, 0.04510379582643509, -0.028532924130558968, -0.028536982834339142, 0.06561927497386932, -0.004868099465966225, 0.005239918828010559, 0.018867360427975655, -0.07066299766302109, 0.03672544285655022, -0.0281501617282629, -0.05398384854197502, -0.06817622482776642, 0.033843956887722015, -0.011326173320412636, -0.022379418835043907, -0.02461339719593525, -0.015738101676106453, 0.039690446108579636, 0.06654999405145645, 0.0037235375493764877, 0.028960086405277252, 0.039873238652944565, 0.03710786625742912, -0.015664521604776382, -0.028855610638856888, 0.002811375306919217, -0.011048639193177223, -0.014132333919405937, -0.019165191799402237, -0.067588672041893, 0.012556594796478748, 0.010265469551086426, 0.004844430834054947, -0.0009476648992858827, 0.006207101978361607, -0.0023763959761708975, -0.003044252749532461, -0.021895062178373337, -0.005541133228689432, -0.027618473395705223, 0.053725436329841614, 0.00011205285409232602, 0.038032613694667816, -0.020713554695248604, -0.014285803772509098, 0.019005902111530304, 0.08671323955059052, 0.03571067750453949, 0.05054764822125435, 0.010724497027695179, 0.01007324643433094, -0.020162247121334076, 0.05211116746068001, 0.025785250589251518, -0.044749774038791656, -0.04873519018292427, -0.009142140857875347, 0.0388786680996418, -0.008457678370177746, 0.04591868817806244, -0.010764061473309994, -0.010333230718970299, 0.027730004861950874, -0.02580244466662407, -0.03884049132466316, -0.003855000715702772, 0.01843658648431301, -0.01673547923564911, -0.02823551371693611, 0.04546177387237549, 0.01743234507739544, -0.0011775462189689279, -0.0482545867562294, -0.028522886335849762, 0.001730973832309246, -0.023750394582748413, 0.031393036246299744, -0.03863384202122688, -0.003954796120524406, 0.0059632533229887486, 0.024801841005682945, -0.04381035268306732, 0.024569926783442497, -0.013779067434370518, -0.050230722874403, 0.010293361730873585, -0.0008041597320698202, 0.024146076291799545, -0.016553562134504318, 0.0019109698478132486, 0.03061000071465969, 0.023679321631789207, -0.038103386759757996, 0.011013456620275974, -0.03795110061764717, 0.02456696517765522, 0.059990838170051575, 0.009596763178706169, -0.01595763862133026, -0.0063100517727434635, -0.031739722937345505, 0.02600986324250698, -0.008723264560103416, 0.0020128129981458187, -0.030204201117157936, -0.0031455070711672306, 0.06821973621845245, 0.009803987108170986, -0.049151711165905, 0.026464717462658882, 0.06886914372444153, 0.0382457971572876, 0.0050856187008321285, -0.018134335055947304, -0.033674802631139755, -0.03341864421963692, 0.0232100710272789, -0.01118396408855915, 0.002248832955956459, 0.0036595878191292286, 0.01266481727361679, 0.006492612883448601, 0.027859900146722794, -0.017735175788402557, -0.02170851081609726, 0.033578433096408844, -0.021271340548992157, 0.003284314414486289, -0.025495169684290886, -0.02371852844953537, 0.04669278487563133, -0.03840288519859314, -0.02587537094950676, 0.02388996258378029, -0.031390655785799026, 0.026216182857751846, -0.020939065143465996, -0.009085693396627903, 0.061143308877944946, 0.026004396378993988, -0.0032422335352748632, 0.021526819095015526, 0.05039830505847931, -0.05235344544053078, -0.0008584789466112852, 0.002387413987889886, -0.011408110149204731, -0.043862245976924896, 0.039309121668338776, 0.058928024023771286, 0.01207374781370163, -0.006379422266036272, 0.014061659574508667, -0.0012529274681583047, 0.007682866882532835, -0.025023236870765686, 0.04170471429824829, 0.008941896259784698, -0.055339936167001724, 0.01213089656084776, -0.017057010903954506, -0.03510402888059616, 0.04992762953042984, -0.00799491349607706, 0.00008604310278315097, 0.029859622940421104, -0.003764298977330327, -0.04171112924814224, -0.02315692976117134, -0.055804867297410965, -0.00041389709804207087, -0.00640857545658946, -0.02417066879570484, 0.017242208123207092, 0.023486198857426643, -0.08806909620761871, 0.005941675044596195, -0.01781107299029827, -0.0265822634100914, -0.026589378714561462, -0.025943197309970856, 0.021395724266767502, -0.026925701647996902, 0.014632325619459152, 0.04246940091252327, 0.010575328953564167, 0.03451387211680412, -0.08109690248966217, -0.029177814722061157, 0.027060283347964287, 0.015159139409661293, 0.02118752896785736, 0.039412640035152435, -0.01705794781446457, 0.09376303106546402, 0.04043873772025108, -0.04173850640654564, -0.034263212233781815, 0.014123108237981796, -0.05749516561627388, 0.0008775327005423605, 0.04305630177259445, -0.010259551927447319, -0.0007633250206708908, 0.006474414840340614, -0.00880042091012001, 0.01567242667078972, 0.005805640481412411, -0.020719345659017563, -0.006809978745877743, 0.019816897809505463, -0.058670349419116974, 0.019668227061629295, 0.04142845422029495, 0.05243116617202759, -0.05403472110629082, 0.028933316469192505, 0.0070864008739590645, -0.024388791993260384, 0.012575140222907066, -0.05121195688843727, 0.021132750436663628, -0.048837896436452866, 0.025840969756245613, -0.004110545385628939, -0.013598301447927952, 0.006416936870664358, -0.04096762090921402, 0.013147559016942978, -0.0015824713045731187, 0.005980329588055611, -0.022418895736336708, 0.010743465274572372, 0.006486622616648674, 0.029709095135331154, 0.010706753470003605, 0.0028477252926677465, -0.030929725617170334, 0.0014992350479587913, -0.005582939833402634, -0.00918175932019949, -0.001131409197114408, 0.03589374199509621, 0.056738074868917465, -0.006546342745423317, -0.013299761340022087, -0.016012443229556084, 0.0341341495513916, -0.06865179538726807, -0.0177827849984169, -0.023057086393237114, 0.01964571326971054, 0.03063444048166275, 0.0211874358355999, -0.011099991388618946, 0.013592517003417015, 0.05022638663649559, 0.026950577273964882, -0.045343391597270966, 0.0005161570734344423, -0.011126956902444363, -0.014825748279690742, 0.0012162690982222557, 0.002240292727947235, 0.0022610046435147524, 0.033536527305841446, 0.01557291578501463, -0.014519776217639446, 0.020157702267169952, -0.04590129107236862, 0.015181268565356731, 0.031372785568237305, -0.01622026413679123, 0.0046691675670444965, -0.03044120967388153, 0.01716819405555725, -0.02647738717496395, -0.01522910874336958, 0.005456124432384968, -0.015858788043260574, -0.01477876864373684, 0.007638126611709595, 0.03830888867378235, 0.028634047135710716, 0.042768750339746475, -0.006643351167440414, 0.015028482303023338, -0.04186683148145676, 0.019213655963540077, -0.012056280858814716, 0.06241275370121002, 0.013778042048215866, 0.01470818929374218, -0.019709106534719467, -0.032304197549819946, -0.028841717168688774, 0.0023617486003786325, 0.0247392188757658, 0.004557959735393524, 0.007088060025125742, 0.04279910400509834, 0.014185065403580666, -0.08631068468093872, -0.0054457830265164375, 0.06659965217113495, -0.017032921314239502, -0.009384150616824627, -0.010088546201586723, -0.02808355912566185, -0.004473282489925623, -0.01488505955785513, 0.02200942113995552, -0.03156077861785889, -0.0026073886547237635, -0.013759211637079716, 0.04980809986591339, -0.020056214183568954, -0.05314246937632561, 0.02833935059607029, 0.006517081521451473, 0.04584129899740219, 0.0017303373897448182, -0.04599848389625549, 0.027857135981321335, 0.052851103246212006, 0.0744592472910881, 0.010453877970576286, 0.004540752153843641, -0.07040128111839294, 0.01969398930668831, 0.06679801642894745, 0.029525570571422577, -0.03047960437834263, -0.0498177669942379, -0.06852652132511139, -0.039201535284519196, 0.0555679015815258, -0.012386709451675415, -0.0023949015885591507, -0.008495415560901165, -0.0067640626803040504, -0.03178362548351288, -0.026312602683901787, -0.05043972283601761, -0.028396230190992355, 0.003239364828914404, 0.0358661450445652, -0.027181562036275864, -0.03977172076702118, -0.06414411962032318, 0.03755126893520355, 0.03562707453966141, 0.045358944684267044, 0.006963558029383421, -0.047846972942352295, -0.01284518837928772, 0.04387402534484863, -0.025617798790335655, -0.05679677799344063, -0.0010066566755995154, 0.01022113673388958, -0.028589749708771706, 0.03910267725586891, -0.007255746982991695, -0.024100719019770622, -0.0040375771932303905, -0.005083891097456217, -0.0131949782371521, -0.018064716830849648, -0.014945139177143574, 0.012554020620882511, 0.019583702087402344, 0.044658251106739044, 0.007848712615668774, 0.04297356307506561, 0.024316417053341866, -0.047797348350286484, -0.04295726865530014, 0.0022410897072404623, -0.0027511371299624443, -0.025031322613358498, -0.01433695387095213, -0.027944844216108322, -0.04345164820551872, 0.010354582220315933, -0.015825355425477028, 0.04807446524500847, -0.01495988667011261, -0.010794139467179775, -0.0016533606685698032, 0.04045975208282471, -0.03471821919083595, -0.04291512072086334, -0.024646293371915817, 0.00862105656415224, -0.023495087400078773, 0.02735704742372036, -0.001533223781734705, 0.00019500854250509292, 0.02369358390569687, 0.06005948781967163, -0.04219987243413925, 0.015566508285701275, -0.03248898312449455, -0.004525440279394388, -0.02073846571147442, -0.0372416116297245, 0.04713541269302368, -0.0036168445367366076, 0.020628394559025764, 0.018739130347967148, -0.03573240339756012, 0.02359878085553646, 0.0061499509029090405, -0.030610859394073486, 0.068674735724926, -0.027350300922989845, 0.032029248774051666, -0.008944986388087273, 0.0159183070063591, -0.06762266159057617, -0.06795907765626907, 0.026907775551080704, 0.008548052981495857, -0.0338643379509449, -0.05596758797764778, 0.01167495921254158, -0.012438195757567883, -0.025945452973246574, -0.0019957623444497585, 0.058122988790273666, -0.020124385133385658, -0.012768931686878204, -0.027719898149371147, -0.026932811364531517, 0.06053250655531883, -0.008682884275913239, 0.013994294218719006, 0.018197938799858093, -0.003163814777508378, -0.009143919683992863, -0.020478827878832817, 0.021576618775725365, -0.02313678339123726, 0.02179836481809616, -0.04708423092961311, 0.006004543974995613, 0.047297343611717224, -0.008698486723005772, -0.004380727652460337, 0.03415466099977493, -0.05244512856006622, 0.028389684855937958, 0.01753917895257473, 0.0023090927861630917, -0.024934757500886917, -0.061551328748464584, -0.027311474084854126, -0.021421559154987335, -0.01198075246065855, -0.015306470915675163, 0.026662450283765793, 0.03658061847090721, 0.010899164713919163, 0.0068950713612139225, 0.07034038752317429, 0.015928713604807854, 0.014767914079129696, 0.011918693780899048, -0.01664787344634533, -0.0015414922963827848, -0.021834690123796463, 0.02572733350098133, -0.02884259819984436, 0.020463109016418457, -0.037373289465904236, 0.007068150211125612, -0.019717227667570114, 0.0006060746381990612, 0.01569300703704357, 0.02283634804189205, 0.05429139733314514, 0.038848672062158585, 0.017602838575839996, 0.002518195193260908, -0.04042203351855278, -0.024790694937109947, 0.013880669139325619, 0.01896885223686695, 0.04618903994560242, -0.01903718337416649, 0.02437722682952881, 0.03255652263760567, 0.01614081859588623, 0.032180558890104294, 0.022437753155827522, -0.01771610975265503, 0.040657222270965576, 0.0661979615688324, -0.028048807755112648, -0.05096122995018959, 0.016110273078083992, -0.017429256811738014, 0.016056586056947708, 0.03204295039176941, -0.009015806019306183, 0.008357121609151363, 0.04470466822385788, 0.029980000108480453, -0.030406996607780457, -0.046649541705846786, -0.0493025965988636, 0.009196585044264793, 0.05447182059288025, -0.008681396022439003, 0.013234584592282772, 0.03889220580458641, 0.010737018659710884, 0.013531988486647606, 0.024109015241265297, -0.04388045519590378, -0.06507888436317444, -0.04617050662636757, -0.05715518817305565, -0.06689411401748657, 0.028358085080981255, 0.04896993190050125, -0.022137140855193138, 0.008641915395855904, -0.0519615076482296, 0.005266475025564432, 0.01892939954996109, 0.04677259176969528, 0.025194479152560234, 0.01019207015633583, -0.03152679279446602, -0.005421541165560484, -0.004565912764519453, -0.01860857382416725, 0.13166646659374237, 0.08629023283720016, 0.03540000692009926, -0.062033988535404205, 0.014648029580712318, -0.018105361610651016, -0.03330729156732559, -0.04216012358665466, 0.01991221494972706, -0.0044743069447577, -0.021478116512298584, 0.03335427865386009, 0.03481965884566307, 0.02569621615111828, -0.00530204875394702, 0.0470607653260231, -0.013534191995859146, 0.033481862396001816, 0.03445885330438614, -0.005098471883684397, -0.022157058119773865, -0.012395446188747883, -0.05954119563102722, 0.032770853489637375, 0.03541360795497894, -0.028358113020658493, -0.03704255446791649, -0.02403835579752922, 0.04255246743559837, -0.009087111800909042, 0.004996400326490402, -0.02104608155786991, -0.0015214887680485845, 0.018057581037282944, -0.011182858608663082, -0.013048113323748112, -0.020524032413959503, 0.004517452325671911, 0.026378458365797997, 0.04207439720630646, -0.0030805401038378477, 0.0068587628193199635, 0.008742433041334152, -0.03048877976834774, -0.03245221823453903, -0.038207124918699265, -0.07882347702980042, 0.05011439323425293, 0.001281531760469079, -0.04043812304735184, 0.025836938992142677, 0.0010093511082231998, 0.003446125192567706, 0.006976135075092316, -0.034324247390031815, -0.02316606603562832, 0.016158366575837135, -0.019355515018105507, -0.01051366701722145, 0.007824554108083248, 0.041673049330711365, -0.010187236592173576, 0.010174294002354145, 0.03686640039086342, -0.044774528592824936, 0.008795839734375477, 0.0036009473260492086, -0.004207191523164511, 0.006187653634697199, -0.0030296738259494305, 0.02066127024590969, -0.02280936948955059, 0.010859173722565174, -0.0017556389793753624, 0.04823009669780731, -0.00439427001401782, 0.010370085015892982, -0.010184784419834614, -0.011098585091531277, -0.0194954015314579, -0.0282631553709507, 0.006262851879000664, -0.0230155847966671, 0.02272392064332962, -0.02257848158478737, 0.03829316794872284, 0.009054982103407383, 0.03559989109635353, -0.012820271775126457, -0.019148392602801323, 0.016993766650557518, 0.013052606023848057, 0.004893554374575615, -0.04090995714068413, -0.01867428608238697, -0.024240856990218163, -0.04030825197696686, 0.047884661704301834, -0.01277090609073639, 0.0721331536769867, 0.035775065422058105, 0.004576852545142174, 0.0016717665130272508, 0.027545969933271408, 0.004881176166236401, 0.006149997003376484, 0.02521204762160778, -0.08937741816043854, -0.002216646447777748, -0.010043003596365452, 0.014116670936346054, -0.04338439181447029, -0.046217698603868484, -0.012300063855946064, -0.01858905889093876, -0.024185003712773323, -0.00455876998603344, -0.037125587463378906, 0.025466423481702805, -0.004129272885620594, 0.04434332251548767, -0.02409243769943714, 0.010751916095614433, -0.015126422978937626, 0.031199444085359573, -0.01872953027486801, 0.00008304303628392518, 0.016649886965751648, -0.04359796270728111, -0.005116565618664026, 0.00020967115415260196, 0.032082319259643555, 0.004418035503476858, -0.013553815893828869, 0.008473269641399384, 0.021519701927900314, 0.00047202850691974163, 0.010203002952039242, -0.017559323459863663, -0.0017474457854405046, 0.03814513981342316, -0.04682193323969841, -0.009352260269224644, 0.02381732687354088, -0.027845527976751328, -0.001678751315921545, -0.012249566614627838, 0.02354813925921917, 0.015329721383750439, 0.05553990975022316, -0.004483779426664114, 0.006193920038640499, 0.010164317674934864, -0.0005880937096662819, -0.01151092629879713, 0.01764748804271221, 0.01619563065469265, -0.021762678399682045, -0.011824562214314938, 0.002511679893359542, 0.027333714067935944, -0.026653144508600235, -0.005121153313666582, -0.016663651913404465, -0.038982320576906204, 0.023397769778966904, 0.00728825107216835, 0.007937991060316563, 0.06512336432933807, 0.007063956931233406, -0.07497201859951019, 0.013824241235852242, 0.02579749934375286, 0.002700263634324074, -0.1060657724738121, -0.0006943342741578817, -0.002747311256825924, 0.03053324669599533, 0.03283655643463135, -0.07872980833053589, 0.011978978291153908, 0.03015063889324665, -0.06019464135169983, -0.003819003701210022, 0.032237857580184937, 0.004940453451126814, -0.038848575204610825, -0.029405491426587105, -0.008340010419487953, 0.035809051245450974, 0.002535771345719695, 0.0384363979101181, 0.030318325385451317, 0.051322102546691895, 0.003049802267923951, -0.022370871156454086, -0.03437322378158569, 0.015609961934387684, -0.01618853397667408, -0.045954734086990356, 0.032309334725141525, -0.024934513494372368, -0.027839800342917442, 0.016256751492619514, -0.009810474701225758, 0.013111640699207783, 0.0669754296541214, 0.0389736033976078, 0.006547880824655294, 0.0840858742594719, 0.03229980543255806, -0.02017897367477417, -0.007208740338683128, -0.010572333820164204, 0.028642868623137474, 0.00454408535733819, -0.026298904791474342, -0.0044540464878082275, 0.03693274036049843, -0.011499105952680111, -0.03333249315619469, -0.012332916259765625, -0.012208986096084118, -0.05393916741013527, -0.00012975781282875687, -0.020737001672387123, 0.017347296699881554, -0.013361006043851376, 0.023151705041527748, -0.027174759656190872, -0.012329897843301296, -0.03688213974237442, 0.025310004130005836, 0.004654936026781797, 0.047154948115348816, -0.028362859040498734, -0.06557562947273254, -0.009094416163861752, 0.0022944165393710136, -0.002358016325160861, -0.0722675621509552, 0.009846082888543606, 0.011659570038318634, -0.0585799366235733, -0.01878693327307701, 0.00908656045794487, -0.01350153237581253, 0.055448196828365326, 0.003421858651563525, 0.03821996599435806, 0.030376631766557693, 0.013045698404312134, -0.0021313715260475874, -0.05050301551818848, 0.05997825413942337, 0.00479897391051054, 0.027646921575069427, 0.010350855998694897, 0.02849111519753933, -0.0405181460082531, -0.043811600655317307, 0.037153150886297226, -0.04962778836488724, 0.005159648135304451, -0.022822072729468346, -0.03462137654423714, 0.0037902584299445152, -0.02927354909479618, 0.04429078847169876, -0.0375879630446434, -0.054061539471149445, -0.00350930611602962, -0.0044764126650989056, -0.020521439611911774, -0.020995020866394043, 0.03852645307779312, -0.007476761005818844, -0.03949582576751709, -0.00207606703042984, 0.010789534077048302, -0.0034100159537047148, 0.07608084380626678, 0.010608415119349957, 0.05098652467131615, 0.006923618260771036, -0.016087599098682404, -0.00045961010619066656, -0.00330613786354661, -0.03238166496157646, 0.01788635365664959, -0.014591037295758724, -0.027072714641690254, -0.04562811926007271, 0.001002489123493433, -0.025641361251473427, -0.048561349511146545, -0.0075583322905004025, 0.007502046413719654, 0.008642997592687607, 0.01843407191336155, 0.018590837717056274, -0.021162372082471848, 0.04200589284300804, 0.018602611497044563, 0.005246399436146021, -0.006004282273352146, 0.0056455908343195915, 0.005473293364048004, -0.014140451326966286, 0.015562118031084538, -0.009860081598162651, -0.02455146238207817, 0.02678404562175274, -0.0041525764390826225, 0.06163303926587105, -0.0006222116062417626, 0.029889950528740883, -0.04133491590619087, -0.015592354349792004, 0.002042571548372507, -0.005325518548488617, 0.01483777817338705, -0.02380327880382538, -0.018250880762934685, 0.06695322692394257, -0.04580047354102135, 0.007006563246250153, -0.07584960013628006, 0.009865057654678822, -0.015152400359511375, 0.00907046813517809, 0.023681465536355972, 0.06453853845596313, -0.01227683387696743, 0.026553664356470108, -0.003080342896282673, 0.00917769130319357, 0.07505962997674942, -0.007120776921510696, 0.014794339425861835, -0.005450449418276548, -0.009210147894918919, 0.01977774128317833, -0.011571732349693775, 0.02576986886560917, -0.016604429110884666, -0.010293591767549515, 0.054085973650217056, 0.012243688106536865, -0.015395776368677616, -0.013554360717535019, 0.0062439171597361565, 0.03698466718196869, -0.06658601760864258, 0.022567538544535637, -0.042493198066949844, 0.01805557683110237, 0.024626582860946655, -0.005350517574697733 ]
<p>I have multiple logistic regression models with all of the same IVs/controls and a variety of DVs (all health outcomes from the same sample). The primary IV is the sum of types of childhood abuse (emotional, physical or sexual). I made dummy variables that represent any one type of experience, any two types of experiences, or all three types of experiences (so each is mutually exclusive). This is the same type of model the CDC uses for their ACEs study which is where I borrowed the method from.</p> <p>Question 1: Can I compare the one experience dummy to the two experience dummy within the same model? That is, talk about the odds ratios in comparison to one another without standardizing the coefficients? My sense is yes and I've seen it done all over the place but I recently was given a dissenting opinion saying that since I am only comparing each IV to the dummy referent of 0 experiences, I can't compare them to one another without standardizing first. </p> <p>Question 2: What's the best method to make comparisons across models (with all the same IVs)? I'm testing the dummy IVs against a variety of physical and mental health outcomes and I'd like to compare the odds ratios for each DV based on any one type of experience, two experiences or three experiences. It would be nice to say, one experience increases the odds of this outcome by 3.2 times, this outcome by 2.1 times, etc. Therefore, I can say that one type of abuse increases the risk of depression more than anxiety disorder or two types of abuse increases the risk of PTSD over depression etc (assuming no overlap in confidence intervals). </p> <p>I've read Menard's 2011 piece on standardized LR coefficients and that makes sense as to what mechanism to use within a single model (as I would apply in question 1 if necessary), but I can't tell if this can be applied across DV models if I'm using all the same IVs/controls from the same sample. If I standardize each IV coefficient, then are they comparable across models? It's a random sample and each model has the same number of valid cases (1073) with no missing data. </p>
48,944
[ -0.08384688943624496, 0.02838815003633499, -0.03303014859557152, 0.00010205760918324813, 0.016551725566387177, -0.0019254435319453478, -0.03484029695391655, -0.0004441670316737145, 0.04845118522644043, -0.029269427061080933, 0.005281473509967327, 0.029096432030200958, 0.033634480088949203, -0.01775410957634449, 0.010656500235199928, 0.007189274299889803, 0.00106242171023041, 0.016226906329393387, 0.01790233701467514, -0.024819470942020416, 0.002515769097954035, 0.024104347452521324, -0.005298294592648745, -0.007676871959120035, 0.0247130636125803, 0.06814071536064148, 0.03789988532662392, -0.04476160928606987, 0.0001038040645653382, 0.017971010878682137, 0.002283897716552019, 0.013433688320219517, -0.03152594715356827, 0.03271643817424774, 0.004892850294709206, 0.010005899704992771, -0.03374224901199341, 0.009640678763389587, -0.009854968637228012, 0.057560164481401443, 0.002272817539051175, -0.025341197848320007, -0.03753487393260002, 0.038091305643320084, -0.027946675196290016, 0.02340093068778515, 0.004487405531108379, -0.03774669021368027, -0.0065396628342568874, -0.03463359549641609, 0.02675318531692028, -0.02144421450793743, 0.030735787004232407, 0.06854428350925446, -0.013177451677620411, -0.0003729585150722414, 0.06993579864501953, 0.03370578587055206, -0.016186628490686417, -0.03835180774331093, -0.04914356395602226, 0.023334771394729614, 0.003690592013299465, -0.012792886234819889, -0.010961215943098068, 0.030940618366003036, 0.02052978239953518, -0.028373712673783302, 0.008673291653394699, -0.04450720548629761, 0.016929233446717262, 0.015343429520726204, 0.03277255594730377, 0.005661150440573692, -0.00195613713003695, -0.00517952349036932, -0.008064278401434422, 0.008830374106764793, 0.03984951600432396, 0.0810571238398552, -0.025192540138959885, 0.00005398706707637757, 0.00918904785066843, 0.0620964877307415, 0.01197375450283289, -0.02183559350669384, 0.062334299087524414, -0.011137484572827816, 0.0086017195135355, 0.007022014353424311, -0.025697704404592514, 0.0026397951878607273, 0.018481144681572914, 0.01450094860047102, -0.05196654424071312, 0.012907077558338642, -0.006942350883036852, 0.05216813459992409, 0.01563270203769207, 0.010433433577418327, -0.026553446426987648, -0.014911300502717495, 0.017294196411967278, 0.03766518831253052, -0.007277979515492916, 0.00614864332601428, -0.02937627211213112, 0.031923502683639526, 0.012213507667183876, -0.05143710598349571, -0.023245472460985184, 0.013080294243991375, -0.010643471032381058, -0.011794659309089184, 0.02223433367908001, -0.02172314189374447, -0.008091983385384083, -0.039802856743335724, 0.06197568029165268, 0.05073932185769081, 0.05316106230020523, -0.06578727811574936, 0.009423408657312393, -0.06330863386392593, -0.04660461097955704, 0.02407163754105568, 0.04651188477873802, 0.006048575975000858, -0.03579486161470413, 0.056397438049316406, 0.014662518166005611, -0.01853897050023079, -0.00526675209403038, -0.00442133005708456, 0.022255301475524902, -0.00789754930883646, -0.08055386692285538, -0.0652669221162796, -0.024133695289492607, 0.008960573934018612, -0.04261002317070961, -0.04859636351466179, -0.016297146677970886, -0.015498761087656021, 0.02934492565691471, -0.0002907165908254683, 0.03074563480913639, 0.03223161771893501, 0.047569844871759415, 0.06430622190237045, -0.014143998734652996, -0.015294019132852554, -0.03429960086941719, -0.02092052437365055, -0.02684672921895981, -0.08970881253480911, 0.030033139511942863, 0.003155348589643836, -0.033515606075525284, 0.017535407096147537, 0.0524202324450016, -0.0342586375772953, -0.03479490056633949, 0.013742349110543728, 0.013305204920470715, -0.019178448244929314, 0.052081599831581116, -0.06391432136297226, 0.050164543092250824, 0.021790409460663795, 0.009241321124136448, 0.017850909382104874, 0.02423483319580555, 0.04559160768985748, 0.00941358134150505, -0.028127171099185944, 0.002716782735660672, -0.020331693813204765, 0.009767545387148857, 0.013262749649584293, -0.03737521916627884, -0.003693759674206376, -0.026957126334309578, -0.0545782744884491, 0.01323894876986742, 0.00409072358161211, 0.017266584560275078, -0.045142605900764465, 0.013264051638543606, -0.012010530568659306, -0.043165020644664764, -0.06443805247545242, 0.014363206923007965, -0.0053249807097017765, -0.021026581525802612, 0.01585744321346283, -0.027114523574709892, 0.06470155715942383, -0.012748814187943935, -0.008173351176083088, -0.01570693403482437, 0.00008346501999767497, 0.03342004492878914, -0.0566587932407856, -0.005097289569675922, 0.038006704300642014, 0.03771905228495598, -0.030821438878774643, 0.041586242616176605, -0.03496326506137848, -0.04337862879037857, 0.021443555131554604, -0.04515894874930382, 0.007553554140031338, 0.007207079790532589, 0.011960559524595737, 0.04410632699728012, -0.02981572411954403, -0.026944324374198914, 0.021897660568356514, -0.06517469882965088, 0.10836238414049149, 0.05447648838162422, 0.0066232141107320786, -0.019010253250598907, 0.005020646844059229, 0.024061495438218117, -0.0007496195612475276, -0.0303445216268301, -0.0037574819289147854, -0.05142506584525108, -0.005076481495052576, 0.04634388908743858, -0.004484560806304216, -0.027426375076174736, 0.02941236086189747, 0.05074083432555199, 0.002740212483331561, -0.013204935006797314, 0.0037010228261351585, 0.020329443737864494, -0.04428256303071976, 0.008781774900853634, 0.05271562561392784, 0.014084525406360626, 0.0037100687623023987, 0.018677012994885445, -0.03471391648054123, 0.024449465796351433, 0.01005477923899889, -0.007739437278360128, 0.06728442758321762, -0.009280173107981682, -0.011971041560173035, -0.024977197870612144, -0.0008925618603825569, 0.022736500948667526, -0.04212340712547302, 0.03259705752134323, 0.048198990523815155, -0.007132618222385645, -0.027494942769408226, 0.04215475916862488, 0.0030130937229841948, 0.042701225727796555, 0.06841346621513367, -0.030178042128682137, 0.04372120276093483, 0.014844855293631554, -0.040992625057697296, 0.014576275832951069, -0.023308685049414635, -0.03329024836421013, -0.02926044724881649, 0.004647902213037014, 0.00970870815217495, -0.024591699242591858, 0.011956017464399338, -0.043414775282144547, 0.0041855513118207455, 0.007092351093888283, 0.008809957653284073, -0.00682460842654109, 0.011206098832190037, -0.06808575987815857, -0.025788797065615654, -0.07176472991704941, 0.010360301472246647, 0.01659199595451355, -0.00905356090515852, -0.03270383179187775, 0.04274808242917061, 0.02549634873867035, -0.04718552529811859, -0.01350810844451189, -0.0013542514061555266, 0.029521945863962173, -0.014659672044217587, -0.01769293285906315, 0.04787754639983177, -0.0061784060671925545, -0.05893518030643463, 0.01796373724937439, 0.01052146963775158, -0.010679184459149837, -0.002570806536823511, -0.017539143562316895, 0.003278769087046385, -0.0016987445997074246, -0.030312422662973404, 0.016800904646515846, -0.031353600323200226, -0.019904660061001778, -0.07522543519735336, -0.05958322063088417, 0.013065346516668797, 0.02638089470565319, 0.029631005600094795, 0.0018900259165093303, -0.00955351535230875, 0.06318129599094391, 0.06074723228812218, -0.017256218940019608, -0.0794430822134018, 0.004194080363959074, -0.050479087978601456, 0.006885039620101452, 0.001479199156165123, 0.04156568646430969, -0.005327422171831131, 0.012358158826828003, -0.004768501501530409, 0.045195382088422775, 0.028072692453861237, 0.03359019383788109, 0.0027376674115657806, 0.02079775743186474, 0.029305603355169296, -0.0434311181306839, 0.036756787449121475, 0.024191908538341522, -0.011941459961235523, -0.015893084928393364, 0.002516611246392131, 0.026467658579349518, -0.019719544798135757, -0.044357508420944214, 0.0250096432864666, 0.013359298929572105, -0.0020244379993528128, -0.028800059109926224, -0.012372847646474838, -0.012522128410637379, -0.03157815337181091, -0.0174850020557642, 0.03643263503909111, 0.02342403493821621, -0.03214056417346001, 0.028383774682879448, 0.0062350062653422356, 0.04676692932844162, -0.007137700449675322, 0.006534603424370289, -0.05395319312810898, -0.011594153940677643, 0.035788342356681824, -0.012074832804501057, 0.013535409234464169, 0.019611096009612083, 0.042989689856767654, 0.013347002677619457, -0.010336107574403286, -0.059171758592128754, 0.027953336015343666, -0.0381658561527729, -0.005815637763589621, -0.008637476712465286, 0.030746540054678917, 0.0013592687901109457, 0.030714083462953568, 0.005992579273879528, -0.03656303882598877, 0.008805440738797188, 0.0007816937286406755, -0.045484837144613266, 0.017644179984927177, -0.009319324977695942, 0.004653352778404951, 0.020924322307109833, -0.001616421272046864, 0.03037620522081852, -0.0038624107837677, 0.00400954857468605, 0.0008340481435880065, 0.005582213401794434, -0.025342948734760284, 0.02778065763413906, -0.02826796844601631, -0.025246992707252502, 0.018203068524599075, 0.04638788849115372, -0.030233975499868393, 0.004294332582503557, 0.002852959791198373, 0.018613141030073166, 0.013007812201976776, 0.012902406975626945, -0.024588817730545998, 0.016195250675082207, 0.027316266670823097, 0.05235906317830086, 0.01015892531722784, 0.011025373823940754, -0.03095223568379879, 0.015831461176276207, -0.029300518333911896, 0.020205574110150337, 0.06457117944955826, -0.027829067781567574, -0.0257971603423357, -0.03209751471877098, -0.014030852355062962, -0.005085395183414221, 0.008012628182768822, 0.017500096932053566, -0.0018695226171985269, 0.03004451096057892, 0.06979890912771225, -0.06578962504863739, -0.0036688456311821938, 0.07044557482004166, -0.0019930691923946142, -0.02450721524655819, -0.047873035073280334, -0.024072302505373955, -0.01386847160756588, -0.022341536357998848, 0.03450259566307068, 0.015529714524745941, 0.0005372149753384292, 0.007361729629337788, 0.03095703199505806, -0.043714020401239395, -0.04614458233118057, 0.011880851350724697, 0.022932754829525948, 0.03542059287428856, -0.009900560602545738, -0.03514488786458969, 0.000044990483729634434, 0.018116328865289688, 0.03676816076040268, 0.037021927535533905, 0.006334281526505947, -0.043121837079524994, 0.03314603865146637, 0.02000374160706997, 0.017643142491579056, -0.020001709461212158, -0.007794141303747892, 0.029844287782907486, -0.02200990356504917, 0.013956725597381592, -0.02077503316104412, 0.018110033124685287, 0.010012841783463955, 0.022267693653702736, -0.03818506747484207, -0.04614594578742981, -0.05526147037744522, 0.04563021659851074, -0.013028912246227264, 0.025876211002469063, 0.001542039797641337, -0.022208496928215027, -0.034089624881744385, 0.03951118513941765, -0.016509925946593285, 0.05806950479745865, -0.031039822846651077, -0.006633926182985306, -0.012661878950893879, 0.01707226224243641, -0.007228202186524868, -0.05754297971725464, -0.02622216008603573, -0.01895330473780632, -0.0022441495675593615, 0.03476125746965408, -0.019631696864962578, -0.034809660166502, 0.009359870105981827, 0.015414564870297909, -0.025138428434729576, 0.04767721891403198, -0.019000185653567314, 0.05615781620144844, 0.0034324165899306536, 0.012046465650200844, 0.03947531804442406, 0.031512897461652756, 0.024887442588806152, 0.028549177572131157, -0.053987544029951096, 0.011985991150140762, -0.030695101246237755, -0.05023635923862457, -0.0710042417049408, -0.010913082398474216, 0.024968311190605164, 0.04101887717843056, -0.017258990556001663, 0.010731219314038754, -0.015200127847492695, -0.015559611842036247, 0.007920850068330765, 0.0003100080357398838, -0.011279393918812275, -0.016214760020375252, 0.014431366696953773, 0.009642243385314941, 0.009008575230836868, -0.021253002807497978, 0.0034879883751273155, -0.031565047800540924, 0.0009493925026617944, 0.03416191786527634, -0.06982273608446121, 0.02484126016497612, -0.015749791637063026, -0.019750874489545822, 0.027207914739847183, -0.034129705280065536, 0.03267887607216835, -0.0019729796331375837, 0.027694813907146454, -0.011401415802538395, -0.020406000316143036, 0.009492491371929646, 0.005572401452809572, -0.01684720069169998, 0.041662681847810745, -0.028887247666716576, 0.010179280303418636, -0.009917299263179302, -0.024149354547262192, -0.07294571399688721, -0.0383722297847271, 0.04000880941748619, -0.0024413494393229485, -0.01761467009782791, -0.0365680567920208, 0.01041898038238287, -0.002150127198547125, -0.019656529650092125, -0.017716441303491592, 0.0887238085269928, -0.04124641418457031, -0.008946875110268593, -0.01519373245537281, 0.032699305564165115, 0.046205490827560425, 0.013524649664759636, 0.001391007797792554, 0.02547159045934677, -0.02987554669380188, 0.022864414379000664, -0.0016110643045976758, 0.00585628068074584, -0.019105102866888046, -0.013270409777760506, -0.04189736768603325, -0.013339640572667122, 0.03619173541665077, -0.020544126629829407, -0.03717067465186119, -0.019575001671910286, -0.04411714896559715, 0.005319938994944096, -0.058056753128767014, 0.010048005729913712, -0.005853492766618729, 0.017808562144637108, -0.028643814846873283, 0.040670279413461685, -0.026929354295134544, -0.0006124688079580665, 0.021237410604953766, -0.004084573592990637, -0.01970452442765236, -0.001655822852626443, 0.04550205171108246, 0.006468235049396753, 0.04713275656104088, -0.017185749486088753, -0.03355828672647476, 0.0468859001994133, -0.01655065082013607, 0.00013692704669665545, 0.003177018603309989, 0.023809870705008507, -0.025063978508114815, -0.034376293420791626, -0.04137289896607399, 0.03704162314534187, 0.0487382747232914, 0.016121968626976013, 0.04907822236418724, 0.0760912150144577, -0.012028937228024006, 0.02152426168322563, -0.040364015847444534, -0.0049512856639921665, 0.027975020930171013, 0.0043027037754654884, 0.08984404802322388, -0.03652225062251091, -0.022042136639356613, 0.042700301855802536, 0.02286631427705288, 0.018326755613088608, 0.06946534663438797, 0.007761027198284864, 0.010485205799341202, 0.012293505482375622, -0.031452592462301254, -0.03279417008161545, 0.040904369205236435, -0.07990352809429169, -0.006300334352999926, -0.04086175933480263, -0.029362265020608902, 0.029670821502804756, 0.020845338702201843, -0.0013420445611700416, -0.05332770198583603, -0.06517881900072098, -0.06226228550076485, 0.025966143235564232, 0.03841855004429817, 0.017160093411803246, 0.03571217134594917, -0.002644740743562579, 0.04689118266105652, -0.02863927185535431, 0.0019994438625872135, -0.03522626310586929, -0.10360091924667358, -0.01962425373494625, 0.016019679605960846, -0.01021564844995737, 0.0036085103638470173, 0.0006937598809599876, -0.00021472966182045639, 0.0025571107398718596, -0.061805929988622665, -0.010220327414572239, -0.02626848593354225, 0.010096992366015911, -0.002287098206579685, 0.07106345146894455, 0.0226335097104311, 0.0075242179445922375, -0.00100535003002733, -0.005408724769949913, 0.13417403399944305, 0.055506158620119095, 0.051010407507419586, -0.0538456104695797, 0.014707135036587715, 0.05117654800415039, 0.028057396411895752, -0.01285515259951353, 0.01986386440694332, 0.028580861166119576, -0.026058441027998924, 0.06345821917057037, 0.04852873086929321, 0.03576605021953583, -0.024881653487682343, 0.08165868371725082, 0.0031744346488267183, -0.006869006436318159, -0.005560991354286671, 0.007229296024888754, 0.019405199214816093, -0.029352976009249687, 0.004109275992959738, 0.020235411822795868, -0.0009102512267418206, 0.021917229518294334, -0.000577241531573236, -0.00022274018556345254, -0.013764606788754463, 0.0005369563004933298, 0.008680727332830429, -0.015904145315289497, 0.0308592040091753, -0.0018968466902151704, -0.004840873181819916, -0.016699986532330513, 0.051319319754838943, -0.016921494156122208, -0.0014622324379161, 0.03663142770528793, -0.021600907668471336, 0.003169293748214841, 0.0194777213037014, 0.00021164723148103803, -0.04680412635207176, -0.043854791671037674, -0.03273184597492218, 0.02426416426897049, 0.015367849729955196, -0.0072074648924171925, -0.025478286668658257, -0.011773010715842247, 0.013876440934836864, -0.019808605313301086, -0.05406975746154785, 0.021420637145638466, 0.03507201746106148, -0.04441389814019203, -0.019901536405086517, -0.01642993837594986, 0.03377228230237961, 0.03581565245985985, 0.0433400422334671, 0.02907928079366684, -0.031239591538906097, -0.03625684231519699, -0.0462925024330616, 0.04853774607181549, 0.027636989951133728, 0.00200814101845026, -0.0008014461491256952, -0.01233838964253664, -0.032673779875040054, -0.015438560396432877, 0.004767014179378748, 0.03255779296159744, 0.048601601272821426, 0.00926027912646532, 0.017245734110474586, -0.018224824219942093, -0.004347160924226046, -0.010127426125109196, -0.012603947892785072, -0.0045260111801326275, -0.03344564139842987, -0.014485090970993042, 0.02311132475733757, 0.023668471723794937, 0.008515726774930954, 0.03087839111685753, 0.018522614613175392, 0.04865407198667526, -0.017021439969539642, -0.04391028359532356, -0.0003911067615263164, -0.02460791915655136, -0.030272651463747025, 0.017579812556505203, -0.022511150687932968, 0.003323194570839405, -0.01382287498563528, 0.008026341907680035, 0.009836450219154358, 0.04754127189517021, 0.017800621688365936, 0.03733378276228905, 0.01877991482615471, -0.06943986564874649, -0.005568761844187975, 0.007810918148607016, 0.02265394851565361, 0.019027424976229668, -0.018456798046827316, -0.08153911679983139, -0.03597536310553551, 0.004027044866234064, -0.05219230800867081, -0.030036354437470436, -0.006061600986868143, -0.018770307302474976, 0.038659270852804184, -0.026812393218278885, -0.027836862951517105, -0.02982315607368946, -0.006082616746425629, 0.025538844987750053, -0.032717082649469376, 0.040348540991544724, 0.03164605796337128, -0.0002736580790951848, 0.0006883192691020668, 0.03105996735394001, -0.014450914226472378, 0.003757488215342164, 0.004721144679933786, 0.010327634401619434, 0.017059331759810448, 0.0649971291422844, -0.014754408039152622, -0.042468465864658356, -0.01572430320084095, -0.006751078646630049, 0.013106301426887512, 0.05363929271697998, 0.0023112662602216005, 0.010611163452267647, 0.03569794073700905, 0.021324818953871727, -0.03126564621925354, 0.07140348851680756, -0.026889260858297348, -0.0059968531131744385, -0.012595084495842457, -0.0008191208471544087, -0.000933209783397615, 0.0110806655138731, 0.009153683669865131, 0.08517299592494965, -0.02619823068380356, 0.022528335452079773, 0.037986986339092255, 0.02734334021806717, 0.02038217894732952, -0.004599813371896744, 0.008290043100714684, 0.01653040200471878, -0.005202047061175108, 0.009567840956151485, 0.05148066207766533, 0.043836742639541626, -0.01365139614790678, 0.06536179780960083, -0.020565280690789223, 0.04561749845743179, -0.07393762469291687, -0.0007064681267365813, -0.02632547914981842, 0.0431804433465004, 0.0018505750922486186, -0.03954837843775749, 0.014070403762161732, 0.011593818664550781, -0.05253049358725548, 0.0019384784391149879, 0.007689803373068571, 0.0010662651620805264, -0.009755835868418217, 0.02033836767077446, -0.034847378730773926, -0.0019989763386547565, 0.008347981609404087, -0.006840130779892206, -0.002656796248629689, 0.039182256907224655, 0.028287597000598907, -0.009608734399080276, -0.03107888624072075, 0.010224714875221252, 0.012998654507100582, -0.02674279175698757, 0.021250661462545395, -0.039817336946725845, -0.05651335418224335, 0.0362117774784565, 0.01862933672964573, 0.017637068405747414, 0.051884688436985016, 0.016430484130978584, 0.00363361369818449, 0.033755041658878326, 0.016681673005223274, 0.016828229650855064, 0.013324443250894547, 0.002296389313414693, -0.0006626919494010508, 0.039965350180864334, -0.021634956821799278, 0.006790015380829573, 0.04821168631315231, -0.01721871830523014, -0.03749338537454605, 0.007727210875600576, 0.000014667864888906479, -0.008585427887737751, -0.040680158883333206, -0.03201201558113098, 0.03528359904885292, -0.004430084954947233, 0.007014688570052385, -0.08317779749631882, 0.012850828468799591, 0.0726434737443924, 0.007262724917382002, -0.010735387913882732, 0.013718891888856888, -0.023631788790225983, -0.027573686093091965, -0.004317303188145161, 0.01547714602202177, 0.009268585592508316, -0.05905970558524132, 0.012850185856223106, -0.016230372712016106, -0.0024587365332990885, -0.030517319217324257, 0.019688820466399193, -0.035697098821401596, 0.033467188477516174, -0.06150657683610916, 0.010347661562263966, 0.03250334784388542, -0.03536149114370346, 0.0006583515787497163, -0.07631536573171616, 0.049345485866069794, 0.004486279562115669, -0.057814307510852814, -0.03672909364104271, 0.012253716588020325, -0.01997733861207962, 0.018323877826333046, 0.04764425382018089, 0.0001350685051875189, 0.006006144918501377, 0.025169678032398224, 0.021261828020215034, 0.009705746546387672, -0.05180776119232178, 0.027406344190239906, 0.0010225288569927216, -0.01646418310701847, -0.020399149507284164, 0.026060907170176506, -0.003263184567913413, 0.010859997011721134, 0.018021611496806145, -0.023453352972865105, -0.004987045656889677, 0.015526669099926949, -0.0010831666877493262, 0.019026394933462143, 0.009926017373800278, 0.0016155369812622666, 0.03998047485947609, 0.0032163967844098806, -0.002257510321214795, 0.0045188856311142445, -0.017807886004447937, -0.029124921187758446, 0.08859003335237503, -0.0015068968059495091, -0.03412038832902908, -0.001463435124605894, 0.015905441716313362, 0.02508726716041565, -0.04482512176036835, 0.0013553277822211385, -0.0031109510455280542, -0.03838669881224632, 0.021768471226096153, 0.022513724863529205, 0.021945727989077568, 0.001143455971032381, -0.018105844035744667, 0.018954524770379066, 0.014128245413303375, -0.01655336283147335, -0.009753470309078693, 0.01474423985928297, 0.05378314107656479, 0.009387968108057976, -0.04627674072980881, 0.016575444489717484, -0.02956496737897396, 0.048542194068431854, 0.007742417976260185, 0.02078506164252758, -0.02486479841172695, -0.01770157366991043, 0.03550400212407112, 0.020363543182611465, -0.01211659237742424, 0.011137856170535088, 0.017519263550639153, 0.021980348974466324, -0.016629427671432495, -0.014613963663578033, -0.04071683809161186, -0.012873371131718159, -0.04869207367300987, 0.012198886834084988, -0.008624204434454441, 0.023051070049405098, 0.005004425533115864, -0.010005469433963299, -0.004268949385732412, -0.03440149873495102, 0.013509104959666729, 0.002236229833215475, 0.03721345216035843, -0.013949738815426826, -0.00879595149308443, -0.047949422150850296, -0.04946206882596016, -0.048819031566381454, -0.043430160731077194, 0.024167604744434357, 0.009173109196126461, 0.010376975871622562, -0.025474824011325836, -0.05394116789102554, 0.006640200968831778, 0.04737304151058197, -0.03834054619073868, -0.0383664071559906, -0.03873571380972862, 0.033342957496643066, 0.04701511189341545, 0.01679653860628605 ]
<p>I'm trying to do a simple scatterplot and trend line in R, but it doesn't look right. Have I messed up something blatantly obvious? Any ideas as to why the line doesn't fit the data?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/AISqZ.png" alt="the trend line does not fit the data"></p> <p>Here is the code I used.</p> <pre><code>&gt; plot(x, y, pch=".") &gt; model &lt;- lm(x ~ y) &gt; summary(model) Call: lm(formula = x ~ y) Residuals: Min 1Q Median 3Q Max -0.23043 -0.04340 -0.00533 0.03761 0.47882 Coefficients: Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(&gt;|t|) (Intercept) 0.051154 0.001384 36.97 &lt;2e-16 *** y 0.462881 0.003739 123.80 &lt;2e-16 *** --- Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 Residual standard error: 0.06365 on 71514 degrees of freedom Multiple R-squared: 0.1765, Adjusted R-squared: 0.1765 F-statistic: 1.533e+04 on 1 and 71514 DF, p-value: &lt; 2.2e-16 &gt; abline(model, col="red") </code></pre>
74,346
[ -0.026018479838967323, 0.027964914217591286, 0.0020819364581257105, 0.014754073694348335, 0.05219759792089462, -0.009536275640130043, -0.0016216790536418557, -0.02138059213757515, 0.022224077954888344, -0.051240090280771255, 0.05958825722336769, 0.03375751152634621, 0.07333806902170181, 0.025999974459409714, 0.04054275527596474, -0.02374422550201416, 0.007786463480442762, 0.01355130597949028, 0.013409802690148354, -0.015391252003610134, -0.009568543173372746, 0.00805252231657505, 0.01230178214609623, -0.007200572174042463, -0.012436840683221817, 0.05862855538725853, 0.05847063288092613, 0.022558007389307022, 0.04080984741449356, 0.034481652081012726, -0.062432773411273956, -0.021892214193940163, 0.0017679124139249325, -0.012182893231511116, 0.028952104970812798, 0.03847740218043327, 0.014535795897245407, -0.018195753917098045, 0.008027207106351852, 0.037044037133455276, -0.022673489525914192, 0.002258491702377796, 0.0036123243626207113, 0.026029858738183975, 0.009621074423193932, -0.01743861846625805, 0.018326710909605026, -0.016131587326526642, 0.11052550375461578, -0.032912444323301315, 0.07498954236507416, -0.0022663006093353033, 0.009208135306835175, 0.04983263090252876, -0.030943622812628746, -0.0039861686527729034, 0.07233361899852753, 0.03350017964839935, -0.019045531749725342, -0.0497213751077652, 0.010336484760046005, -0.032342005521059036, 0.025383641943335533, -0.0054324474185705185, -0.0462530143558979, 0.013837593607604504, 0.012911551631987095, -0.014928438700735569, 0.06188933551311493, -0.023808425292372704, 0.005372150335460901, 0.033884014934301376, 0.007846584543585777, -0.021396484225988388, 0.031174298375844955, -0.005859281402081251, 0.014417542144656181, 0.012569109909236431, 0.00505714351311326, 0.03791891038417816, 0.0033459619153290987, 0.022347018122673035, 0.0018308385042473674, 0.030328670516610146, 0.0005225038039498031, -0.0039358921349048615, 0.06810273975133896, -0.0076132225804030895, 0.004339348990470171, 0.021057672798633575, -0.020805586129426956, 0.04071846604347229, 0.06937700510025024, 0.025067515671253204, -0.0243113711476326, 0.0406048446893692, -0.0026452180463820696, 0.032726433128118515, -0.004834580235183239, -0.019207630306482315, -0.019367245957255363, -0.058517519384622574, 0.03301860764622688, -0.013111970387399197, -0.036378297954797745, -0.013347337022423744, -0.04262804612517357, -0.0054134801030159, 0.013732661493122578, -0.04361092671751976, -0.04133402183651924, 0.0027859951369464397, 0.009988730773329735, 0.0017442235257476568, 0.0037638095673173666, -0.06355784833431244, -0.024481620639562607, 0.014693040400743484, 0.047380998730659485, 0.030834799632430077, 0.03840826824307442, -0.005517841782420874, 0.007309389766305685, -0.02038445696234703, -0.0391550175845623, 0.0027097046840935946, 0.0129763875156641, -0.03630789369344711, -0.03952628746628761, 0.034927111119031906, -0.02500438317656517, -0.028821377083659172, 0.022448355332016945, -0.026609566062688828, 0.045616813004016876, -0.023401251062750816, -0.06907057017087936, -0.06157403811812401, 0.017041152343153954, -0.009338689967989922, 0.0064776926301419735, -0.02592240273952484, -0.030279411002993584, 0.04071829840540886, 0.051965873688459396, -0.013297101482748985, 0.014842694625258446, 0.022269871085882187, 0.026923079043626785, 0.02933596819639206, -0.045905862003564835, 0.01976041868329048, -0.028922341763973236, -0.03648637980222702, -0.006443182937800884, -0.06098688766360283, 0.005107115022838116, 0.0151365976780653, -0.015719212591648102, -0.011136150918900967, 0.029247669503092766, 0.019132522866129875, 0.003935724962502718, -0.010627835057675838, -0.03399409353733063, -0.02751998044550419, 0.06390061229467392, -0.0011206475319340825, 0.030672358348965645, 0.04059109091758728, -0.007973005063831806, 0.01773071102797985, -0.008149740286171436, 0.03824475780129433, 0.03736063838005066, -0.006121516227722168, 0.025112470611929893, -0.011584049090743065, -0.014383731409907341, 0.05175220966339111, -0.10554903745651245, -0.048697084188461304, -0.0061389305628836155, -0.03230663761496544, 0.021099787205457687, 0.050678420811891556, -0.04401485249400139, -0.021348044276237488, 0.061656005680561066, -0.05884977802634239, -0.005550661589950323, -0.053892623633146286, -0.015656592324376106, -0.005635733716189861, -0.01836228370666504, -0.029645927250385284, 0.018858211115002632, 0.037267498672008514, 0.012777408584952354, 0.014128133654594421, -0.0028331296052783728, -0.013423067517578602, 0.044601358473300934, -0.01693928986787796, 0.024812964722514153, 0.05103936791419983, 0.04088875651359558, 0.0005480934050865471, 0.019003799185156822, -0.013761070556938648, 0.0014198028948158026, 0.04524603113532066, -0.025137556716799736, 0.011734540574252605, -0.028868945315480232, -0.028706463053822517, -0.019427821040153503, 0.007076778449118137, -0.02561044879257679, 0.058604560792446136, -0.019412800669670105, 0.04002822935581207, 0.04202927649021149, 0.004945684690028429, -0.02493489347398281, -0.00048626167699694633, 0.03171582520008087, 0.04556646943092346, -0.05050194263458252, 0.025343121960759163, -0.04350091889500618, -0.002030925126746297, 0.0441831536591053, 0.002594843739643693, -0.03410900756716728, -0.019003285095095634, 0.040820106863975525, 0.013265581801533699, 0.013490239158272743, 0.05107299983501434, -0.018884217366576195, -0.008696191012859344, 0.008075162768363953, 0.006378341466188431, 0.014783750288188457, -0.02261313982307911, 0.03929593414068222, -0.015638988465070724, 0.03336965665221214, 0.03481211140751839, -0.0013663253048434854, 0.05112973600625992, -0.045807961374521255, -0.026967192068696022, -0.028357364237308502, 0.010568717494606972, 0.026518363505601883, -0.026191821321845055, -0.005221837665885687, 0.0597434863448143, 0.0051572020165622234, -0.025209372863173485, 0.012805836275219917, -0.008859453722834587, 0.016582878306508064, 0.03444181755185127, 0.009412091225385666, -0.014924070797860622, 0.015349829569458961, 0.010940834879875183, 0.002191398059949279, -0.07568114250898361, -0.04003360494971275, -0.033418551087379456, 0.020732253789901733, 0.027421284466981888, 0.005476773250848055, -0.013560778461396694, -0.04820026084780693, -0.000870773452334106, -0.004698599688708782, -0.006749230902642012, 0.051467765122652054, -0.014014332555234432, -0.04560888186097145, -0.03002973273396492, -0.004102327395230532, 0.008100099861621857, 0.02257533371448517, -0.002526729367673397, -0.021219195798039436, 0.006055353209376335, -0.007687192410230637, -0.02355521358549595, -0.034001950174570084, -0.03928891569375992, -0.003693876089528203, -0.009878290817141533, -0.018760912120342255, 0.03701307997107506, -0.04804198443889618, -0.014301063492894173, 0.03866010904312134, -0.05874689295887947, -0.012018430978059769, -0.015613124705851078, -0.013927369378507137, 0.007634290494024754, 0.022463591769337654, 0.01213890966027975, -0.007398981600999832, -0.043000478297472, -0.028618237003684044, -0.059901755303144455, -0.045688509941101074, 0.0008323205402120948, 0.007623772602528334, -0.0036381615791469812, -0.0016356778796762228, -0.015376506373286247, 0.02668391540646553, 0.02388838678598404, -0.04907802864909172, -0.06505370140075684, 0.010860715992748737, -0.03744882345199585, -0.06447936594486237, 0.001236767158843577, 0.030816994607448578, 0.03696093708276749, 0.02633589133620262, -0.04744066670536995, 0.027307938784360886, 0.021450696513056755, -0.030475648120045662, -0.01504309382289648, 0.03083835355937481, -0.007061285432428122, -0.0114592295140028, 0.045294515788555145, 0.012112094089388847, 0.010787751525640488, 0.027889149263501167, -0.003458934836089611, 0.06739693880081177, -0.01421859860420227, -0.05771789699792862, 0.036433145403862, -0.03819401189684868, 0.0290082897990942, -0.03359359875321388, -0.011738643050193787, 0.03225862979888916, -0.0008057588711380959, -0.01835724338889122, -0.0039381301030516624, 0.034067098051309586, -0.010828986763954163, 0.010430410504341125, 0.044447194784879684, 0.008613900281488895, -0.01187064591795206, 0.022068211808800697, -0.0003220409562345594, -0.00618152879178524, 0.02319612354040146, -0.02253594435751438, -0.004945565015077591, 0.06271196901798248, 0.013467242009937763, 0.035041023045778275, -0.007735160645097494, -0.04481326788663864, 0.01996825821697712, -0.04587893560528755, 0.027486229315400124, -0.043243687599897385, 0.023908492177724838, 0.02995869144797325, 0.03668034449219704, 0.01011334266513586, -0.012984207831323147, 0.000716765527613461, -0.03509737551212311, -0.03946486860513687, 0.06451217830181122, 0.0073506999760866165, -0.0066650016233325005, -0.0015002769650891423, -0.03470645099878311, 0.014803719706833363, -0.044066011905670166, 0.02152571827173233, -0.008584817871451378, -0.004427940584719181, 0.012953500263392925, -0.013140765018761158, -0.03303559124469757, 0.028520923107862473, -0.0077796438708901405, -0.00515370536595583, 0.028515594080090523, -0.03712640330195427, 0.010018137283623219, 0.05742232874035835, -0.01741938106715679, -0.013566652312874794, -0.051458898931741714, 0.011864962056279182, 0.029757585376501083, 0.02955971285700798, 0.06989238411188126, -0.011830988340079784, -0.024555914103984833, 0.02884260192513466, -0.01660250872373581, 0.015547314658761024, 0.06282201409339905, -0.002904884284362197, -0.017915932461619377, -0.033052846789360046, -0.03156483173370361, 0.03044971078634262, 0.011010666377842426, 0.013926775194704533, -0.008292718790471554, 0.04427027702331543, 0.010784243233501911, -0.07008048892021179, 0.04612966626882553, 0.05939123407006264, -0.0007093148888088763, -0.008496888913214207, -0.04699448496103287, -0.022224532440304756, -0.006044021341949701, 0.008261207491159439, 0.05314694717526436, 0.012044896371662617, -0.002406495390459895, -0.024964522570371628, 0.05071389675140381, -0.03478569537401199, -0.014007439836859703, -0.01332339271903038, 0.06443881243467331, 0.040393684059381485, -0.005967939738184214, -0.017574574798345566, -0.006297410000115633, 0.01725134253501892, 0.005696749780327082, 0.026532147079706192, -0.016038544476032257, -0.11002985388040543, -0.003154511796310544, 0.03086354397237301, 0.0528918132185936, -0.0014372352743521333, -0.02493107132613659, -0.0537538044154644, -0.03548638895153999, 0.02460797317326069, -0.030476585030555725, 0.016645971685647964, -0.03528933972120285, 0.007247805595397949, -0.010265110060572624, -0.03251633048057556, -0.06535317748785019, 0.017636854201555252, -0.011313984170556068, 0.04898523539304733, -0.01572955586016178, -0.03577594459056854, -0.034964922815561295, -0.010800521820783615, -0.004910553805530071, 0.03214327245950699, -0.023274684324860573, -0.024442033842206, 0.00770691130310297, 0.026121165603399277, -0.016582023352384567, -0.036070775240659714, -0.0055228471755981445, -0.00888739712536335, -0.0018323526019230485, 0.04103929549455643, 0.012199507094919682, -0.021493075415492058, -0.0032406053505837917, 0.023649493232369423, 0.0025840760208666325, 0.0020887216087430716, -0.016536792740225792, 0.034345246851444244, 0.04484804347157478, -0.013636092655360699, 0.0438297800719738, 0.030039062723517418, -0.004337829537689686, -0.006125283893197775, -0.04475940391421318, 0.017243271693587303, 0.007827883586287498, -0.023345638066530228, -0.05457591265439987, -0.002981946337968111, -0.011966818943619728, 0.005239068530499935, 0.020491642877459526, 0.0002963137230835855, -0.04859364032745361, 0.01618324965238571, 0.0396764799952507, -0.005479481536895037, 0.0031308396719396114, -0.012523839250206947, 0.045314740389585495, 0.022994956001639366, -0.025015773251652718, -0.03067799285054207, -0.007040031254291534, -0.014647132717072964, -0.03958864137530327, 0.019184743985533714, -0.005129207856953144, 0.004770039115101099, 0.004343039821833372, -0.029638247564435005, -0.018458202481269836, -0.029682116582989693, 0.038079358637332916, -0.026264451444149017, 0.019832678139209747, -0.020054295659065247, -0.0349607914686203, -0.019032809883356094, 0.016660209745168686, 0.01476298924535513, 0.0064302412793040276, -0.010888028889894485, 0.028029615059494972, -0.0006604355294257402, -0.007133059203624725, -0.062158066779375076, -0.047463394701480865, 0.031079137697815895, -0.016233166679739952, -0.056568168103694916, -0.006828325800597668, -0.07308047264814377, 0.001033555599860847, 0.005154986400157213, -0.0001281064178328961, 0.02430720068514347, -0.07516524195671082, -0.03729274496436119, -0.01011678297072649, 0.025186674669384956, 0.0706598311662674, -0.03535371646285057, -0.006473076995462179, 0.03298921510577202, -0.03407948091626167, -0.05379067361354828, 0.019273558631539345, 0.00944397784769535, -0.037918660789728165, -0.011034736409783363, -0.023170078173279762, 0.0077330428175628185, 0.03981628268957138, -0.03856215253472328, -0.033120471984148026, 0.012500494718551636, 0.01030960213392973, 0.0389724038541317, -0.03997078537940979, 0.017316127195954323, -0.0330529510974884, 0.007152124773710966, -0.02544722892343998, 0.012703980319201946, 0.01111212745308876, -0.013690521940588951, 0.05794353783130646, -0.0028082553762942553, -0.03954070433974266, 0.032200779765844345, 0.07910739630460739, 0.02019602619111538, -0.00006012378798914142, -0.02497066557407379, -0.017936771735548973, 0.0469135157763958, 0.057461850345134735, 0.0022448746021836996, -0.021586017683148384, 0.01447446458041668, -0.028613779693841934, -0.022042635828256607, -0.037485815584659576, 0.002894649049267173, 0.029712222516536713, -0.018535511568188667, 0.04735327512025833, 0.04187522083520889, -0.0063231284730136395, 0.01855594664812088, -0.025984331965446472, -0.03296675905585289, -0.01399983186274767, 0.005245806649327278, 0.03461435064673424, -0.020631156861782074, -0.015249141491949558, 0.023320579901337624, 0.03899381682276726, 0.025970200076699257, 0.035029489547014236, 0.039153195917606354, 0.0002532433718442917, 0.010423741303384304, 0.018377583473920822, -0.04612208530306816, 0.027681969106197357, -0.0018884451128542423, 0.04013754799962044, -0.027353137731552124, -0.04796965792775154, 0.04030661657452583, -0.004412847105413675, -0.011197458952665329, -0.032855965197086334, -0.019124561920762062, -0.04406951740384102, -0.012714804150164127, 0.021085763350129128, -0.019686060026288033, 0.0034113950096070766, -0.004503711126744747, 0.03283851593732834, -0.012434647418558598, 0.06279631704092026, -0.05291109159588814, -0.06336107105016708, -0.04210226610302925, 0.00010464253136888146, 0.007441043853759766, 0.05506349727511406, 0.01264457032084465, -0.005423801019787788, 0.020411375910043716, -0.06429687887430191, -0.00013167108409106731, 0.0008759554475545883, 0.03022836521267891, 0.0042379628866910934, 0.038224902004003525, -0.012081567198038101, 0.007899615913629532, -0.014413035474717617, -0.04109896346926689, 0.13000747561454773, 0.0781618058681488, 0.05293412506580353, -0.05948793143033981, 0.01426194328814745, 0.0001284165191464126, -0.009915837086737156, 0.009426916018128395, -0.007915175519883633, -0.0025257484521716833, 0.009562447667121887, 0.048758480697870255, 0.0588981918990612, 0.04944268614053726, -0.00792726594954729, 0.017603300511837006, -0.02630440518260002, -0.020216310396790504, -0.004728435538709164, 0.02452956512570381, 0.006716659292578697, -0.011735629290342331, -0.06001861020922661, -0.007877247408032417, -0.002068539848551154, -0.03946104645729065, -0.02548297308385372, 0.0017685395432636142, -0.0288186464458704, 0.025734124705195427, -0.024132823571562767, 0.012263733893632889, 0.0069374688901007175, -0.005291505251079798, -0.002647275570780039, -0.0006588577525690198, 0.01887357234954834, -0.0325607992708683, -0.01024374458938837, 0.03543408587574959, 0.015032908879220486, 0.0014998501865193248, 0.01428217627108097, 0.0017066274303942919, -0.0392993688583374, -0.04466277360916138, -0.005202255677431822, 0.05652042105793953, 0.03143535926938057, -0.019609658047556877, 0.0009471126832067966, 0.0043342518620193005, -0.028427083045244217, -0.00911580491811037, -0.01096030231565237, 0.03206535056233406, 0.013397768139839172, 0.014658409170806408, -0.0005147537449374795, -0.007966228760778904, 0.00016470854461658746, -0.010219953954219818, 0.010833933018147945, 0.053982071578502655, -0.027077142149209976, -0.003126910189166665, -0.052102379500865936, 0.07483236491680145, -0.00825083814561367, 0.028732499107718468, 0.026341339573264122, -0.02622840367257595, -0.026897870004177094, 0.023093240335583687, 0.026888813823461533, 0.010094170458614826, 0.022825736552476883, -0.018943585455417633, -0.0015743235126137733, -0.024892928078770638, -0.04150717332959175, 0.04705677926540375, -0.04009644687175751, -0.04115912318229675, -0.046016544103622437, -0.04314585402607918, 0.056647490710020065, -0.005563162732869387, -0.0067414650693535805, 0.014870209619402885, -0.04142151027917862, 0.04004160687327385, 0.021710319444537163, -0.03927268832921982, -0.021345334127545357, 0.0320444293320179, -0.020454686135053635, -0.005126046482473612, 0.0026688165962696075, 0.06191626936197281, 0.052173953503370285, 0.03497651219367981, 0.021906448528170586, 0.021521709859371185, 0.005955536849796772, -0.011846991255879402, 0.04279652237892151, -0.02978893555700779, 0.048487208783626556, -0.004430368542671204, -0.027915241196751595, -0.019845696166157722, 0.0018846726743504405, -0.05990665405988693, -0.0720503181219101, -0.01487493421882391, 0.012232347391545773, -0.04415494576096535, 0.038051605224609375, -0.020242899656295776, -0.006726490333676338, -0.02910575084388256, 0.000057084580475930125, -0.051478467881679535, -0.035333823412656784, -0.00952149834483862, -0.02382487989962101, -0.018358591943979263, 0.022944139316678047, -0.0027180665638297796, 0.0415358766913414, 0.036864060908555984, -0.00115450459998101, 0.03490142896771431, 0.025039218366146088, 0.01227542757987976, 0.03941516950726509, 0.009087368845939636, -0.02893063798546791, -0.018702318891882896, 0.008679771795868874, 0.001703829038888216, -0.028645183891057968, -0.036528464406728745, 0.002725656609982252, 0.012969758361577988, 0.0044197323732078075, 0.03682324290275574, -0.013537590391933918, 0.057267989963293076, 0.014452505856752396, 0.009120755828917027, -0.009482648223638535, 0.019284171983599663, 0.014332443475723267, -0.0011868694564327598, -0.009239896200597286, -0.0016885304357856512, 0.005471695214509964, 0.028798529878258705, 0.05883900821208954, -0.019840674474835396, 0.009664127603173256, -0.0023848016280680895, -0.06493193656206131, 0.010298693552613258, 0.022462138906121254, 0.0014563428703695536, 0.05215316265821457, 0.021917447447776794, -0.028215937316417694, 0.02370290644466877, -0.0327017717063427, 0.05148458108305931, -0.09045819938182831, 0.0002954840601887554, -0.026547763496637344, 0.038017638027668, 0.016762549057602882, -0.0687689408659935, -0.016430608928203583, 0.04816357046365738, -0.04017943516373634, 0.01091576088219881, -0.014248115010559559, -0.010151333175599575, -0.04263288527727127, 0.02999059110879898, -0.007273686118423939, 0.035557448863983154, 0.006780353840440512, 0.05419478565454483, 0.04826098680496216, -0.00016243506979662925, 0.01223030686378479, -0.01598113402724266, -0.017529098317027092, 0.034148041158914566, 0.024078071117401123, -0.036940108984708786, -0.020376333966851234, -0.028860721737146378, -0.00032709012157283723, 0.010018227621912956, 0.010936632752418518, 0.034750111401081085, 0.023586539551615715, 0.02264273352921009, 0.024071061983704567, 0.05850500240921974, 0.037118349224328995, -0.003211256116628647, -0.005921168718487024, -0.022379398345947266, 0.036656346172094345, 0.016550514847040176, -0.023858176544308662, 0.026851076632738113, -0.01144644059240818, -0.014978650957345963, 0.005191369913518429, 0.033940624445676804, -0.02996751293540001, 0.008673790842294693, -0.013286255300045013, 0.030642976984381676, 0.007923530414700508, -0.05699953809380531, 0.03342292830348015, -0.05934453755617142, -0.019406884908676147, 0.0445701889693737, 0.04819199815392494, -0.0025471539702266455, 0.0005929686594754457, -0.005156665574759245, -0.008046123199164867, -0.02211953140795231, -0.01122262328863144, -0.014932041987776756, -0.052585892379283905, 0.0037606386467814445, -0.0008200170123018324, -0.013762185350060463, -0.013582800514996052, 0.02068173885345459, -0.042379721999168396, 0.027876367792487144, -0.017681635916233063, 0.00865726638585329, 0.043130118399858475, -0.018098292872309685, 0.008903087116777897, -0.1173180565237999, 0.06382159143686295, 0.010188824497163296, -0.015255838632583618, -0.048785168677568436, -0.010179870761930943, -0.05949196591973305, 0.047142863273620605, 0.049103476107120514, 0.01972472108900547, -0.007705306634306908, -0.016603559255599976, 0.016712043434381485, 0.017941102385520935, -0.03640380874276161, 0.058027684688568115, 0.014585686847567558, 0.0002818621869664639, 0.01327497698366642, 0.008313900791108608, 0.011898145079612732, 0.02141028642654419, 0.025654666125774384, -0.008870957419276237, 0.03642094507813454, 0.02673725225031376, -0.06520691514015198, 0.009941868484020233, -0.018668167293071747, -0.048647984862327576, 0.04690808802843094, 0.016908029094338417, 0.016652917489409447, 0.08323530852794647, 0.03023139014840126, -0.06123189255595207, 0.038807593286037445, -0.02138110250234604, -0.01724887825548649, 0.022020023316144943, -0.01465600449591875, 0.0053850323893129826, -0.0859949067234993, 0.012854952365159988, 0.0016731650102883577, -0.03476983308792114, 0.007319302763789892, 0.006879912223666906, 0.03644487261772156, 0.02196473255753517, -0.020309673622250557, 0.013616703450679779, 0.023594163358211517, -0.00905444473028183, 0.0327625535428524, 0.010997951030731201, 0.025407522916793823, 0.009359605610370636, 0.017965596169233322, 0.04718473181128502, -0.04828234016895294, 0.02009199559688568, 0.0017142030410468578, 0.031847428530454636, 0.001656284905038774, -0.0019993972964584827, 0.00813626404851675, 0.018346663564443588, 0.02695716917514801, -0.005556684918701649, -0.007749553769826889, 0.007796204648911953, -0.0630192831158638, 0.03470267355442047, -0.00009390159539179876, -0.03403126075863838, -0.019060300663113594, 0.017778513953089714, 0.006486551836133003, 0.00962716806679964, -0.001865644589997828, 0.004588867072016001, 0.0019647330045700073, -0.012142113409936428, 0.00012187466927571222, -0.006664895452558994, 0.0016967356204986572, -0.03003816492855549, -0.0037159149069339037, -0.017851609736680984, -0.012344243004918098, -0.024098187685012817, -0.036139462143182755, -0.0030906135216355324, 0.04108351841568947, -0.007908295840024948, -0.06316881626844406, -0.018436310812830925, 0.009411473758518696, 0.03640406206250191, -0.06810098886489868, -0.018770284950733185, -0.02726001851260662, 0.025655472651124, 0.022622745484113693, -0.030242860317230225 ]
<p>I am using two-samples paired permutation tests with Matlab. Now I have three within subject steps, forcing me to use a three-samples paired permutation test. Is there anything like that or any permutation test in general, I could use for that?</p>
74,347
[ -0.012191866524517536, -0.0020123689901083708, -0.03343239054083824, 0.0001996143691940233, 0.029546493664383888, -0.010565635748207569, -0.0050559742376208305, -0.010852772742509842, 0.004650973714888096, -0.005586494226008654, 0.03297770768404007, 0.032301243394613266, 0.030786415562033653, -0.008160768076777458, 0.03164834529161453, 0.005424718372523785, -0.005033372901380062, 0.005122297443449497, -0.01922113634645939, 0.004570608958601952, 0.007524853106588125, 0.01703924499452114, 0.020172130316495895, -0.020471448078751564, -0.005542620085179806, 0.030636070296168327, 0.02251370996236801, -0.046261463314294815, 0.02427925169467926, 0.06443148106336594, -0.0750340074300766, -0.036217790096998215, -0.0013977519702166319, 0.012820295058190823, -0.028829511255025864, -0.017429949715733528, -0.0017383655067533255, -0.04698775336146355, -0.022867849096655846, 0.02050415240228176, -0.06693808734416962, -0.00010558849317021668, -0.03664623200893402, 0.02374511957168579, -0.000552317884285003, 0.029401883482933044, -0.0119280144572258, -0.03164637088775635, 0.026432305574417114, -0.037390924990177155, 0.10184188932180405, 0.006059382110834122, 0.0012028755154460669, -0.013013209216296673, 0.009204904548823833, 0.023816414177417755, 0.05528681352734566, 0.04495522752404213, 0.016366716474294662, -0.004259827081114054, -0.015884529799222946, -0.07762524485588074, 0.03175193816423416, -0.03191713988780975, -0.07016463577747345, 0.03997078537940979, -0.0061876364052295685, 0.0021586415823549032, 0.01698164828121662, -0.004878401756286621, 0.000054174332035472617, 0.0013930946588516235, 0.0585310235619545, -0.028585560619831085, -0.005890072789043188, -0.027228550985455513, 0.025903765112161636, -0.010648195631802082, 0.042126987129449844, 0.0339522548019886, -0.021651260554790497, 0.027443965896964073, -0.0071004293859004974, 0.031182006001472473, 0.019391246140003204, -0.03801175206899643, 0.05090348422527313, -0.026281051337718964, -0.02258208952844143, 0.007648380007594824, -0.04176032170653343, -0.03687922656536102, 0.04199698567390442, 0.038342732936143875, -0.031216410920023918, -0.014331856742501259, -0.014689916744828224, 0.03922338783740997, -0.009192340075969696, -0.006953349802643061, -0.0022773167584091425, -0.03198252618312836, 0.0178946852684021, 0.052218422293663025, -0.0014999090926721692, 0.04354376345872879, -0.027727995067834854, 0.004431438632309437, 0.002844202099367976, -0.0019134327303618193, 0.010833943262696266, 0.04648822173476219, -0.006441932171583176, 0.007305374834686518, 0.023884404450654984, 0.0036993268877267838, -0.017037365585565567, -0.010292338207364082, 0.05127863958477974, 0.09507738053798676, 0.041039638221263885, -0.024821938946843147, 0.027915697544813156, -0.04476768895983696, -0.05832269415259361, -0.008117801509797573, -0.02699969708919525, 0.005074100103229284, -0.02984180673956871, 0.08277073502540588, 0.005991190671920776, -0.016557522118091583, 0.0503523088991642, -0.011761984787881374, 0.023087240755558014, -0.05015604570508003, -0.06939844787120819, -0.052277956157922745, 0.005112582352012396, -0.027966277673840523, -0.0319819450378418, -0.03869500011205673, 0.02744165062904358, 0.03312527760863304, 0.05468906834721565, 0.016050217673182487, 0.06127220019698143, 0.0042069754563272, 0.0456480011343956, 0.049042731523513794, -0.033392179757356644, 0.0011987773468717933, -0.05562130734324455, -0.015316548757255077, 0.028523840010166168, -0.06626412272453308, 0.026633892208337784, 0.007519091479480267, 0.015039191581308842, -0.007269690744578838, -0.0076677631586790085, 0.008267895318567753, -0.01591453328728676, -0.024282613769173622, 0.00061222625663504, 0.015820452943444252, 0.087457574903965, -0.019270101562142372, 0.029502691701054573, -0.017999712377786636, 0.0015592550626024604, 0.012649625539779663, 0.020927369594573975, 0.04511658102273941, 0.019566886126995087, -0.021536467596888542, -0.003177155740559101, -0.002136360155418515, 0.05035260692238808, 0.03211231529712677, 0.021804606541991234, -0.0026216020341962576, 0.01562555879354477, -0.0028012883849442005, -0.0024754253681749105, 0.03211893141269684, 0.01286987867206335, -0.0164667796343565, 0.06120024248957634, -0.05665881931781769, -0.0013668109895661473, -0.0687216967344284, 0.00303261517547071, 0.009045095182955265, -0.06405838578939438, 0.03638612478971481, 0.01101674884557724, 0.039304595440626144, 0.01337454468011856, -0.08204524964094162, -0.03938957303762436, -0.012847856618463993, 0.00748287932947278, -0.027298828586935997, -0.021528173238039017, 0.030252309516072273, 0.0427657850086689, -0.0357828214764595, 0.04227520152926445, -0.04059728607535362, 0.009169421158730984, -0.00363758928142488, -0.04394024610519409, 0.03174366056919098, -0.011909919790923595, -0.06087612733244896, -0.014864088967442513, 0.02872912585735321, -0.018917379900813103, 0.056084610521793365, -0.03864581510424614, 0.05089662969112396, 0.07128097862005234, -0.005026461556553841, 0.01911436952650547, -0.014595730230212212, 0.037231557071208954, -0.007805545348674059, -0.024636240676045418, -0.02176452986896038, -0.012452575378119946, 0.0016863900236785412, 0.07437986880540848, 0.004477133508771658, -0.07582150399684906, 0.02609565667808056, 0.039923448115587234, 0.0004387641965877265, -0.007362491451203823, 0.07351426035165787, 0.02207045629620552, -0.025803403928875923, 0.0011030985042452812, 0.030067086219787598, 0.03874322399497032, 0.010195555165410042, 0.02753225713968277, 0.007991926744580269, 0.013751077465713024, 0.029232939705252647, -0.04783209413290024, 0.008914249017834663, -0.013252610340714455, 0.0131479287520051, -0.02094297856092453, -0.024283336475491524, -0.0004518476198427379, -0.007904578931629658, 0.017018998041749, 0.05133776739239693, 0.03620756417512894, 0.006340975873172283, 0.047033458948135376, -0.03699810057878494, 0.00556438323110342, 0.015971606597304344, -0.017493313178420067, -0.00139219022821635, 0.03739811107516289, -0.06082296743988991, 0.009065760299563408, 0.0018212705617770553, 0.008908201940357685, -0.024958133697509766, 0.03880568593740463, 0.012665008194744587, -0.013268043287098408, 0.026439812034368515, -0.018127456307411194, -0.018744608387351036, 0.016775663942098618, 0.01770310290157795, 0.014934876933693886, -0.004879704676568508, -0.07101413607597351, 0.030482741072773933, 0.010517450049519539, -0.04537419602274895, 0.04105257987976074, 0.014397417195141315, -0.005256712902337313, 0.03662435710430145, -0.024343831464648247, -0.026420027017593384, -0.00782519206404686, -0.03978878632187843, 0.015820328146219254, -0.0377969928085804, 0.008429559879004955, 0.05464785918593407, 0.021334078162908554, -0.05105287581682205, 0.0008856623317115009, -0.017226438969373703, -0.0038923120591789484, -0.01916917786002159, 0.011050799861550331, 0.01987166330218315, -0.019560739398002625, -0.01623997651040554, 0.06499936431646347, -0.01127889845520258, -0.012682901695370674, -0.034179769456386566, -0.05294850468635559, 0.009019378572702408, 0.01779817044734955, 0.00853827316313982, 0.02011283114552498, -0.034495409578084946, 0.05647455155849457, 0.011301721446216106, -0.018377292901277542, -0.024535829201340675, -0.03130705654621124, -0.023034101352095604, -0.02864965610206127, 0.042497530579566956, -0.0014885637210682034, -0.006270142737776041, 0.05616668611764908, -0.018496673554182053, 0.0047801039181649685, 0.0586080402135849, -0.0014119241386651993, -0.02919585257768631, 0.024611126631498337, 0.04733220115303993, -0.013588091358542442, 0.03212442621588707, 0.0065389168448746204, -0.02627350203692913, 0.0047259340062737465, 0.008446339517831802, -0.0022870812099426985, -0.00610984256491065, -0.025200804695487022, 0.027727246284484863, -0.04581219702959061, 0.0012766825966536999, -0.020684516057372093, 0.04163205623626709, 0.01686573401093483, -0.022476676851511, -0.012017066590487957, 0.06694119423627853, -0.00717103760689497, -0.006804150063544512, 0.04396173730492592, 0.04880419000983238, 0.03684084489941597, -0.048728592693805695, 0.0010566792916506529, -0.009144744835793972, 0.001880998956039548, 0.04106424003839493, 0.019252995029091835, -0.02275320142507553, 0.05162782594561577, 0.01904720813035965, 0.02812136709690094, 0.013257796876132488, -0.015901165083050728, 0.017743105068802834, -0.03760332241654396, 0.0032317584846168756, -0.024876322597265244, 0.018845830112695694, -0.016374783590435982, 0.04156937822699547, 0.018930012360215187, 0.009937076829373837, -0.007868029177188873, 0.00009148727258434519, -0.03597283363342285, 0.007946721278131008, 0.009797560051083565, -0.012012096121907234, 0.027868159115314484, 0.0025303708389401436, 0.006059565581381321, -0.05721961334347725, -0.0025009887758642435, 0.011267297901213169, 0.019161062315106392, -0.05951753258705139, 0.006052333861589432, -0.028198065236210823, -0.0011931898770853877, 0.00905870832502842, 0.04979589208960533, 0.0031566638499498367, -0.047378089278936386, 0.016672007739543915, -0.017267504706978798, -0.03743915632367134, -0.0038617535028606653, -0.0018040905706584454, 0.03168903663754463, 0.01177909690886736, 0.04599844291806221, 0.013699473813176155, 0.06494135409593582, -0.024125119671225548, 0.052024874836206436, -0.025242183357477188, 0.054272640496492386, 0.023495862260460854, -0.0046662380918860435, -0.019705241546034813, -0.05060088634490967, -0.05427389591932297, -0.025063512846827507, 0.018382254987955093, 0.009925001300871372, 0.015423424541950226, 0.015957333147525787, 0.024194292724132538, -0.07172204554080963, -0.02620886266231537, 0.07695674896240234, 0.024332119151949883, -0.026347247883677483, -0.013270968571305275, -0.007116020657122135, 0.005380716174840927, -0.01903585158288479, 0.011325602419674397, 0.0261093657463789, -0.011666709557175636, 0.005793165881186724, 0.031685877591371536, -0.006717928685247898, -0.0060816272161901, -0.007385547272861004, 0.0068886480294167995, 0.06989584863185883, 0.04072677344083786, -0.014867528341710567, 0.011053582653403282, 0.027800587937235832, 0.009507399052381516, 0.03059551864862442, -0.018951518461108208, -0.06161077320575714, 0.03631371259689331, 0.08374606817960739, 0.038615308701992035, -0.06357818841934204, 0.0010066505055874586, 0.0008228283259086311, -0.001433187397196889, 0.004428829066455364, -0.04527723789215088, 0.027575163170695305, -0.05474575608968735, 0.015340354293584824, -0.06550701707601547, 0.01384202390909195, -0.04216163232922554, 0.0325363352894783, -0.018431132659316063, -0.01912175677716732, -0.01390507910400629, -0.0050794873386621475, -0.0032987319864332676, -0.010979913175106049, 0.06460030376911163, 0.06035047024488449, -0.01674395427107811, -0.020561568439006805, 0.059804677963256836, 0.023819103837013245, -0.05483720824122429, -0.047072406858205795, 0.006880512461066246, 0.014430336654186249, 0.007430023048073053, 0.047863397747278214, -0.05409456789493561, -0.04960867390036583, -0.009551708586513996, -0.029160156846046448, -0.014803432859480381, 0.027282333001494408, 0.01520383358001709, 0.009465442970395088, 0.02805790863931179, 0.008981435559689999, 0.03937307000160217, 0.027974780648946762, 0.025299007073044777, 0.004615803249180317, -0.005816299933940172, 0.028943529352545738, -0.058551594614982605, -0.008163033053278923, -0.020930271595716476, -0.01670883409678936, -0.06808933615684509, 0.05294308811426163, -0.009294256567955017, 0.04832523688673973, -0.0006113658309914172, -0.012715610675513744, -0.012139979749917984, 0.008619444444775581, 0.01575814001262188, 0.02146022394299507, -0.0042511094361543655, 0.00331784226000309, -0.004429382272064686, -0.008933868259191513, 0.017864681780338287, -0.02471332624554634, 0.006074552424252033, 0.014532837085425854, 0.002319325925782323, 0.0068646143190562725, -0.046544089913368225, -0.040243588387966156, -0.016542870551347733, -0.027738643810153008, 0.060883212834596634, -0.043367017060518265, 0.00689862621948123, 0.0013083871454000473, -0.031544677913188934, 0.00727331405505538, 0.05097537115216255, -0.00125024130102247, 0.03149041533470154, -0.046855710446834564, 0.034068215638399124, -0.018067559227347374, -0.002745591104030609, -0.07229580730199814, -0.06573668867349625, 0.023867599666118622, 0.008472480811178684, -0.004358989652246237, -0.05402354523539543, -0.019602980464696884, -0.0222042016685009, -0.0060944510623812675, -0.027085570618510246, 0.07076823711395264, -0.007152820471674204, -0.011540476232767105, -0.019335316494107246, 0.005817401222884655, 0.03656716272234917, -0.0021591477561742067, 0.0010256353998556733, 0.008543774485588074, 0.008377673104405403, 0.0031597879715263844, 0.00919229444116354, -0.012650170363485813, -0.011588024906814098, 0.008569403551518917, -0.01561826467514038, -0.00754709355533123, 0.053236138075590134, -0.041745349764823914, -0.04102639853954315, 0.006731544621288776, -0.026867548003792763, -0.0019288621842861176, -0.05415770784020424, -0.0022839000448584557, -0.009614753536880016, -0.005937518551945686, -0.06127434968948364, 0.020830851048231125, -0.027534350752830505, -0.005208073183894157, 0.02084718644618988, 0.012984336353838444, -0.05729599669575691, -0.001603161683306098, 0.06368715316057205, 0.0230997446924448, -0.018830321729183197, -0.010055135004222393, -0.008653520606458187, -0.0000845667818794027, 0.02206459268927574, 0.017541011795401573, 0.0130779342725873, 0.023338645696640015, -0.02934125065803528, -0.002305265748873353, -0.03502127155661583, -0.0038177375681698322, 0.020880434662103653, -0.028452815487980843, 0.028517616912722588, 0.054120611399412155, 0.011757396161556244, -0.006025811657309532, -0.009272266179323196, -0.007054883986711502, 0.02244644984602928, -0.015227897092700005, 0.07965482026338577, 0.021191639825701714, 0.033457234501838684, 0.005902319215238094, 0.04240952432155609, 0.021761728450655937, 0.059462640434503555, 0.011825882829725742, 0.003340531140565872, 0.019525259733200073, 0.0035044753458350897, -0.03134708106517792, 0.010619845241308212, -0.07248351722955704, 0.01187206245958805, -0.022918980568647385, -0.028879864141345024, 0.040236279368400574, 0.03321164846420288, -0.017485236749053, -0.051545578986406326, -0.02922837994992733, -0.07801147550344467, 0.016390861943364143, 0.0053136455826461315, 0.013969008810818195, 0.029790496453642845, -0.003519444726407528, 0.05855477601289749, 0.012490643188357353, 0.02569093368947506, -0.01647178642451763, -0.05392957478761673, -0.0355011448264122, -0.025336524471640587, -0.030615992844104767, 0.015348914079368114, -0.013705441728234291, -0.012998860329389572, -0.0033880332484841347, -0.0019528709817677736, 0.03773198649287224, 0.011956779286265373, 0.05399787798523903, -0.03734913095831871, 0.06771477311849594, -0.0010103463428094983, 0.02922346629202366, 0.01471213810145855, -0.00692551676183939, 0.12556672096252441, 0.05695005878806114, 0.07382892817258835, -0.12256107479333878, 0.05297461152076721, -0.006234817206859589, -0.014132591895759106, -0.024307454004883766, 0.010820589028298855, 0.03322582691907883, 0.0018001998541876674, -0.010860741138458252, 0.09017433971166611, -0.003540292615070939, -0.005589313339442015, 0.055351074784994125, -0.031914133578538895, -0.026457319036126137, 0.04285930097103119, 0.03327758237719536, 0.008452843874692917, -0.04023326188325882, -0.047407932579517365, 0.004078944679349661, -0.0017581143183633685, 0.012540441937744617, -0.013268756680190563, -0.032893016934394836, 0.04154568165540695, -0.009609815664589405, 0.016768712550401688, 0.0010111229494214058, -0.00011605018517002463, -0.008097023703157902, -0.02365948259830475, -0.00837225653231144, 0.010029313154518604, -0.024711916223168373, 0.031726956367492676, 0.027087505906820297, 0.0182252936065197, 0.005286215804517269, -0.007349655497819185, -0.007057296112179756, -0.03178401663899422, -0.03474568575620651, -0.005940745119005442, 0.02322845719754696, -0.0075903343968093395, -0.02101363055408001, -0.001585484715178609, 0.006549636833369732, 0.0075407554395496845, -0.04559734836220741, -0.02077631652355194, -0.0042603206820786, 0.008058613166213036, -0.03780972957611084, -0.03421243280172348, -0.053041569888591766, 0.011399755254387856, -0.01706027425825596, 0.04451761394739151, 0.009086635895073414, -0.017540311440825462, 0.018290724605321884, -0.01639809086918831, 0.04071872681379318, 0.03522705286741257, -0.04204194247722626, 0.0264360960572958, -0.0029556923545897007, -0.02132796123623848, -0.020389800891280174, 0.022863125428557396, -0.006235800217837095, 0.022369397804141045, -0.021232591941952705, -0.04122697189450264, 0.02265605889260769, 0.004202517215162516, -0.0036563673056662083, -0.04611587896943092, -0.0007707308395765722, -0.04834369570016861, 0.008006634190678596, 0.05455445125699043, 0.017509587109088898, 0.013308621942996979, 0.009150302037596703, -0.0003006838960573077, 0.028521958738565445, 0.008458415046334267, -0.05838651582598686, 0.01697457581758499, -0.0011684506898745894, -0.02502051182091236, 0.0007201501284725964, -0.041131529957056046, 0.045640069991350174, 0.03643747419118881, 0.009761187247931957, -0.033313553780317307, 0.002213694853708148, -0.009055254980921745, 0.0029181973077356815, 0.01003590039908886, -0.02774129994213581, -0.03682056441903114, 0.013321849517524242, -0.014335873536765575, -0.024648506194353104, -0.0277392715215683, -0.04619617015123367, -0.025044281035661697, 0.012368329800665379, -0.004615218378603458, -0.01774362102150917, -0.025926001369953156, -0.007736041210591793, 0.013775309547781944, -0.03266753628849983, 0.010816068388521671, -0.0005670343525707722, -0.007864284329116344, -0.019831644371151924, 0.003964696079492569, -0.046733561903238297, 0.003040874842554331, -0.0295717790722847, -0.009872754104435444, 0.060556020587682724, 0.035836346447467804, 0.02832755260169506, -0.005388355813920498, 0.022326454520225525, 0.01032919343560934, 0.044447626918554306, -0.010210552252829075, 0.0031990057323127985, 0.06709654629230499, -0.08176591992378235, -0.0012300575617700815, 0.01758939027786255, -0.014567630365490913, 0.031094957143068314, 0.03610730543732643, 0.005868795793503523, -0.014318257570266724, 0.02388876862823963, -0.00516524538397789, -0.023505201563239098, -0.013873673975467682, 0.04195554554462433, -0.009401407092809677, 0.002764099510386586, 0.025829298421740532, -0.011207587085664272, -0.032339129596948624, 0.03822987526655197, 0.04724900797009468, 0.013445147313177586, 0.015359755605459213, -0.0021080428268760443, -0.01611054129898548, 0.03816388547420502, 0.02746908739209175, -0.014580611139535904, 0.02854582481086254, 0.05198634788393974, -0.01621943712234497, 0.029476894065737724, -0.02178981527686119, 0.012038107961416245, -0.06143778935074806, 0.005939585622400045, -0.004596022889018059, -0.03292229399085045, 0.047580596059560776, -0.08148864656686783, 0.01799546740949154, 0.015346366912126541, -0.030493026599287987, 0.03043440543115139, -0.010334447957575321, -0.03630257025361061, -0.04051300883293152, 0.0072435783222317696, -0.008668667636811733, 0.027256909757852554, 0.008804517798125744, -0.006520172581076622, 0.02381417527794838, 0.005776433274149895, -0.022195274010300636, -0.021391956135630608, 0.006653349846601486, -0.015625620260834694, 0.005656235385686159, -0.05962042137980461, 0.023823535069823265, -0.024910245090723038, -0.08827509731054306, 0.03269556909799576, -0.009874660521745682, -0.004452453460544348, 0.02285161428153515, 0.04674237594008446, -0.03045518510043621, 0.04029877483844757, 0.03074423223733902, 0.014047440141439438, -0.012808694504201412, 0.0027303046081215143, -0.013497496023774147, 0.024674972519278526, -0.02682976983487606, 0.027606140822172165, 0.049209125339984894, 0.0026013581082224846, -0.017545731738209724, 0.026071039959788322, -0.05178293213248253, -0.008560613729059696, 0.0021477488335222006, -0.033880531787872314, 0.030643418431282043, -0.026481762528419495, 0.0006606316892430186, -0.04906422272324562, 0.013217462226748466, -0.0026364645455032587, 0.004354722797870636, 0.013822157867252827, 0.013432345353066921, -0.03424794226884842, -0.047241583466529846, 0.012573260813951492, -0.0037192124873399734, 0.013019002042710781, -0.08111356198787689, -0.01966295950114727, -0.0004670985508710146, -0.01554777193814516, -0.028551645576953888, -0.007995340041816235, 0.03401012718677521, 0.07210524380207062, -0.013888610526919365, 0.009215736761689186, 0.022385239601135254, 0.030092179775238037, 0.014052321203052998, -0.050103798508644104, 0.043101534247398376, -0.005082604009658098, -0.021656403318047523, -0.042744021862745285, 0.0070876386016607285, -0.047611188143491745, 0.019909603521227837, 0.030061708763241768, -0.017396271228790283, 0.043207455426454544, -0.03227067366242409, 0.01155405305325985, 0.03695516660809517, -0.07440616935491562, 0.04745639115571976, -0.024479784071445465, 0.006889969110488892, -0.016632745042443275, -0.012545705772936344, 0.010065611451864243, 0.0021236571483314037, -0.012065059505403042, -0.015807585790753365, 0.00864783488214016, -0.010793874971568584, 0.01441467646509409, 0.0001471482391934842, -0.002125583356246352, 0.002607000758871436, 0.0002538591797929257, -0.03257490694522858, 0.010556825436651707, -0.01685301586985588, -0.014911537989974022, -0.05356578528881073, 0.03502531722187996, -0.031182309612631798, -0.032330624759197235, -0.003863053396344185, 0.02392008900642395, -0.0018137302249670029, -0.058395400643348694, 0.00882816407829523, -0.004030298907309771, -0.056409802287817, 0.008115067146718502, 0.02062174677848816, 0.03234820440411568, 0.03189225494861603, -0.02921014465391636, 0.04814419150352478, 0.0075769126415252686, -0.017275864258408546, -0.005018370226025581, 0.020712733268737793, -0.006436861120164394, 0.009804877452552319, 0.008205560967326164, -0.005928624887019396, -0.04797442629933357, 0.03328612074255943, 0.020135359838604927, 0.012513689696788788, 0.02891257032752037, -0.00009966379730030894, 0.02870333008468151, -0.023632636293768883, 0.024965744465589523, -0.034046705812215805, 0.0013808895600959659, 0.049497999250888824, -0.04185253381729126, 0.017885250970721245, -0.046578314155340195, -0.002828097902238369, -0.014818786643445492, -0.03810051456093788, 0.027172181755304337, 0.02247108705341816, -0.022947462275624275, 0.006781344301998615, -0.010372347198426723, -0.005278527271002531, 0.022727932780981064, -0.01568528637290001, 0.04351789131760597, -0.01587739586830139, -0.005518733989447355, -0.004893623758107424, -0.04132995754480362, -0.052646614611148834, -0.010481012985110283, 0.01081592496484518, 0.01996399275958538, 0.043171823024749756, -0.038014497607946396, -0.016430355608463287, 0.02458433248102665, 0.027080532163381577, -0.0416950024664402, -0.022691622376441956, -0.03364328667521477, 0.03825097903609276, -0.007688129786401987, 0.03610364720225334 ]
<p>I'm looking to generate a set of 5 random variables and enforce a dependence structure between them and onto a dependent variable Y. I understand how to generate correlated random variables for multivariate normal, but not when mixing different types. Below is a little more than I need, but I'm hoping someone can give me a general way of solving this problem...</p> <ul> <li>X_1 and X_2 need to be highly correlated Bernoulli variables. </li> <li>X3 needs to take one of 5 categorical values, call them "A"..."E". </li> <li>X4 needs to be normal, and negatively correlated with X1, X2. </li> <li>X5 needs to approximate test scores from 0 to 100 with a high skew, so gamma probably. X5 needs to be positively correlated with X1, X2, X4.</li> </ul> <p>Each of these variables must impact a "success/occurrence" Bernoulli distributed variable Y.</p> <p>How would I begin? I would like to enforce correlation both between the values of X, and also between each X and Y. (The categorical correlations seem particularly confusing to me.)</p>
47,462
[ -0.041383374482393265, -0.001224665204063058, 0.030575068667531013, 0.003998118452727795, 0.060857854783535004, 0.024405216798186302, 0.002053673844784498, 0.004584834910929203, 0.047411009669303894, -0.02938729152083397, 0.033015716820955276, 0.05016414448618889, 0.02333965338766575, 0.03894469141960144, 0.040503665804862976, 0.0023334252182394266, 0.00017924912390299141, -0.0009181977366097271, 0.0023866354022175074, -0.024972880259156227, 0.009184623137116432, 0.023434849455952644, 0.04798554629087448, -0.003808947280049324, -0.030265100300312042, 0.05158333107829094, 0.03250535577535629, -0.03480541706085205, -0.0019592526368796825, 0.03872547298669815, -0.058780815452337265, -0.030425438657402992, 0.0017168265767395496, 0.03690408170223236, 0.006621730979532003, -0.0011398295173421502, -0.03749159723520279, 0.0027160109020769596, 0.023240070790052414, 0.005258217919617891, -0.03924492001533508, -0.0144862225279212, -0.019482813775539398, 0.005954190623015165, 0.023263320326805115, -0.0053270854987204075, 0.007339962758123875, -0.038281384855508804, 0.023708801716566086, -0.03916576877236366, 0.08816036581993103, 0.01159583032131195, 0.035233620554208755, 0.06014363467693329, -0.02327263541519642, -0.03557721525430679, 0.04403034225106239, 0.062850721180439, 0.0026358868926763535, -0.036772385239601135, -0.00795370526611805, -0.04580199345946312, 0.001105579431168735, -0.03212418407201767, -0.0291731096804142, 0.009021495468914509, -0.0069598546251654625, -0.012437685392796993, 0.048850659281015396, -0.01930602267384529, 0.03666364401578903, 0.014170357957482338, 0.028295479714870453, -0.03309493511915207, 0.022939445450901985, -0.0036342472303658724, 0.01665278896689415, 0.00341867096722126, 0.04327299818396568, 0.0015290897572413087, 0.0013109721476212144, 0.025711877271533012, 0.020552298054099083, 0.02500663697719574, -0.016313230618834496, -0.004810153506696224, 0.056313298642635345, -0.01345739047974348, -0.009092653170228004, 0.035398129373788834, -0.02599048800766468, -0.015615801326930523, 0.06938747316598892, 0.039975233376026154, -0.0489167720079422, 0.006617455277591944, -0.04048670828342438, 0.04162426292896271, -0.01464819721877575, 0.03515838831663132, 0.0030217752791941166, -0.05980582907795906, 0.007811606861650944, 0.07146675884723663, -0.032902222126722336, -0.033684808760881424, -0.0006103950436227024, 0.010597852058708668, 0.010799846611917019, -0.04138213023543358, 0.0003204601816833019, 0.005092739127576351, -0.008604746311903, -0.025438671931624413, 0.029108209535479546, -0.02396710216999054, -0.024814998731017113, -0.015663670375943184, 0.0326291024684906, 0.04356556385755539, 0.021112553775310516, -0.03661644086241722, 0.031998325139284134, 0.0030316070187836885, -0.04181818664073944, -0.004702024627476931, 0.02078722044825554, -0.011526057496666908, -0.0031361591536551714, 0.058012086898088455, -0.010442483238875866, -0.01764151081442833, 0.02286248281598091, 0.022474832832813263, 0.02666333131492138, -0.029228078201413155, -0.0910012423992157, -0.025058310478925705, 0.01492905430495739, -0.01910059154033661, -0.017876623198390007, -0.044577084481716156, 0.023620977997779846, 0.056510068476200104, 0.08714529126882553, -0.012116963043808937, -0.003907049540430307, -0.010584798641502857, 0.021862290799617767, 0.029810190200805664, -0.007875462993979454, -0.014279467053711414, -0.047521382570266724, -0.0008295756997540593, -0.0497717447578907, -0.06408270448446274, 0.04830525442957878, -0.008111358620226383, -0.011678570881485939, -0.004408408887684345, 0.01046536024659872, 0.022883480414748192, -0.010902080684900284, -0.03844265267252922, 0.0336664654314518, -0.015131599269807339, 0.05567336082458496, 0.0032255733385682106, 0.025205407291650772, 0.020586440339684486, -0.03093789517879486, -0.04746459424495697, 0.02775496058166027, 0.05538846179842949, 0.046639684587717056, -0.013583185151219368, -0.0025140708312392235, -0.011955385096371174, 0.023918265476822853, 0.012673452496528625, -0.03436147794127464, -0.03381846100091934, -0.04132352024316788, -0.014856523834168911, 0.012821052223443985, 0.01868540793657303, 0.01924329809844494, 0.008540550246834755, 0.05377902090549469, -0.0304493997246027, -0.04304126650094986, -0.05879143625497818, -0.0012773387134075165, -0.04428970068693161, -0.029103165492415428, 0.04257340729236603, -0.013454711996018887, 0.026523347944021225, -0.009109781123697758, -0.012239552102982998, -0.0314611941576004, -0.017539391294121742, 0.05535807088017464, 0.005059723276644945, 0.007677899207919836, 0.029422586783766747, 0.053485773503780365, -0.022328924387693405, 0.04035646468400955, -0.018531443551182747, -0.06040295958518982, -0.020839370787143707, -0.024104909971356392, 0.023388490080833435, -0.0004766638739965856, 0.010530710220336914, 0.006317310966551304, 0.0026889992877840996, -0.01721826009452343, 0.0036216487642377615, -0.07624419778585434, 0.05436612293124199, 0.07994971424341202, 0.014060067012906075, 0.020747177302837372, -0.0014880408998578787, 0.006644237320870161, 0.013008183799684048, -0.04487054795026779, -0.028626076877117157, -0.061352405697107315, -0.003412773832678795, -0.000047879762860247865, 0.02774798311293125, -0.05369161069393158, 0.03799391910433769, 0.011628934182226658, 0.036959681659936905, -0.0017259677406400442, 0.05675582215189934, 0.0333704873919487, 0.007948504760861397, 0.003063355339691043, -0.0026636787224560976, 0.03560806065797806, -0.005364615470170975, -0.002888635266572237, 0.003103946102783084, 0.02124449796974659, -0.030701830983161926, -0.017425017431378365, 0.022103825584053993, 0.02240368351340294, 0.009241056628525257, -0.016886312514543533, -0.04642096534371376, 0.041384257376194, 0.008801349438726902, 0.004339234437793493, 0.05901111662387848, 0.0036961177829653025, -0.010281885974109173, 0.020105520263314247, -0.02186575159430504, -0.004179384559392929, 0.06872806698083878, -0.020178083330392838, -0.005305937957018614, -0.0017429981380701065, -0.013189743272960186, 0.0020599772688001394, -0.007274293340742588, -0.02106250450015068, -0.026957429945468903, 0.030412565916776657, 0.02802230603992939, 0.03140313923358917, 0.022352414205670357, -0.02871524915099144, -0.023235896602272987, -0.005693982355296612, 0.00878100749105215, 0.0009265324333682656, 0.012410585768520832, -0.06706702709197998, -0.028949487954378128, -0.03982536867260933, 0.007409190759062767, 0.034267131239175797, -0.013110941275954247, -0.01797390542924404, 0.042406581342220306, -0.00983424298465252, -0.05640575289726257, -0.02163943275809288, -0.02413078211247921, -0.018540242686867714, -0.020127303898334503, -0.03057137317955494, 0.05358317494392395, 0.023958973586559296, -0.05122267082333565, -0.0017353944713249803, -0.033690810203552246, -0.019063642248511314, -0.05490664020180702, 0.0015685602556914091, 0.02956853248178959, 0.008070926181972027, 0.00664974469691515, 0.04837600141763687, -0.018255889415740967, 0.01851658709347248, -0.07910005003213882, -0.06638168543577194, -0.009237689897418022, 0.031173499301075935, 0.04368283599615097, -0.0015106452628970146, 0.013327698223292828, 0.05916380509734154, 0.05124646797776222, -0.03200787305831909, -0.06303174048662186, -0.01765783131122589, 0.0013261542189866304, -0.03790350258350372, 0.024081343784928322, 0.03470711410045624, 0.003892087610438466, 0.0186148788779974, 0.032948680222034454, 0.0071485042572021484, 0.003509439527988434, 0.015332813374698162, 0.00726142106577754, 0.028459008783102036, 0.03320450335741043, 0.012133890762925148, 0.04475284367799759, 0.010664459317922592, -0.0327225923538208, -0.01761525310575962, 0.019574515521526337, 0.007332705892622471, 0.017006766051054, -0.0005076720844954252, -0.02097224071621895, -0.005696848034858704, -0.01690289005637169, -0.05119951069355011, 0.034022167325019836, -0.0037997132167220116, -0.08436010032892227, 0.009823992848396301, 0.04894806072115898, 0.03738558664917946, 0.006079569924622774, 0.0034623071551322937, 0.04459479823708534, 0.02852034568786621, -0.03732980042695999, -0.02104833908379078, -0.014824756421148777, -0.014613404870033264, 0.037281304597854614, -0.06029130518436432, 0.03744573891162872, 0.03340381756424904, 0.009363191202282906, 0.039215099066495895, -0.0011541015701368451, -0.0401776060461998, 0.00569174624979496, -0.049415990710258484, 0.02323773317039013, -0.04652652144432068, 0.04755950719118118, 0.014839183539152145, 0.07367731630802155, -0.008984341286122799, -0.03049641102552414, 0.004218005109578371, 0.0016164828557521105, -0.06927607208490372, 0.011348218657076359, -0.01735091581940651, 0.017943693324923515, 0.015019794926047325, -0.026670556515455246, 0.048380229622125626, -0.005543828941881657, -0.027640236541628838, -0.013096564449369907, 0.01118697039783001, -0.000001880864715531061, -0.019775157794356346, -0.05226597189903259, -0.05286167562007904, 0.01416163332760334, 0.0038861201610416174, -0.015057089738547802, -0.027423031628131866, 0.03870907425880432, 0.014796469360589981, 0.02902664802968502, 0.0021994567941874266, -0.013155731372535229, 0.02675337716937065, 0.015360843390226364, 0.05326352268457413, 0.014222422614693642, 0.06126471236348152, 0.009449148550629616, 0.007116106338799, 0.011166767217218876, 0.04572875052690506, 0.05138068646192551, 0.013554656878113747, 0.004504986573010683, -0.04120367765426636, -0.03459777310490608, 0.013061124831438065, -0.01731101982295513, 0.01664060913026333, 0.002693018177524209, 0.04689963534474373, 0.04404618591070175, -0.08644751459360123, 0.024383297190070152, 0.03878349810838699, 0.02253657393157482, 0.0001131005265051499, 0.013013137504458427, -0.003897407790645957, 0.014739508740603924, 0.0050070383585989475, 0.010467440821230412, 0.027747614309191704, -0.0074532474391162395, 0.03979227691888809, 0.03541691601276398, -0.04048199579119682, -0.007133283652365208, 0.02191581018269062, 0.012521106749773026, 0.052793145179748535, -0.016311394050717354, -0.03787627071142197, 0.02378411591053009, -0.006764497607946396, 0.01199595257639885, 0.02634633146226406, -0.007871638983488083, -0.06827981024980545, 0.011586541309952736, 0.012907125987112522, 0.04943513870239258, -0.028249138966202736, -0.007469534408301115, -0.028004707768559456, -0.01907723769545555, 0.031111055985093117, -0.026291653513908386, 0.011205184273421764, -0.018351485952734947, 0.00875029619783163, -0.006472141481935978, -0.050837986171245575, -0.057128485292196274, 0.04817606136202812, 0.00007463958900189027, 0.04917990043759346, -0.00803447887301445, -0.046998415142297745, -0.061794381588697433, 0.00024714277242310345, 0.031505316495895386, 0.07458844780921936, -0.006165268365293741, -0.02685658447444439, -0.006272286642342806, 0.04026452451944351, 0.005880017299205065, -0.0863858237862587, 0.01206411886960268, 0.012287273071706295, -0.007038035895675421, 0.06760583817958832, -0.02509157732129097, -0.0066897571086883545, 0.0002745528472587466, -0.0008267058292403817, -0.0032904413528740406, 0.023044491186738014, -0.010020758025348186, 0.06707824021577835, 0.02001882903277874, 0.034378454089164734, 0.023976165801286697, 0.0379507839679718, -0.010932457633316517, -0.006611305754631758, -0.0415392629802227, -0.008781207725405693, -0.0017004410037770867, 0.016402190551161766, -0.049756038933992386, 0.011808662675321102, -0.009040245786309242, -0.012629778124392033, -0.0357959121465683, 0.008651433512568474, -0.014013930223882198, -0.0330110527575016, 0.0006770404288545251, 0.028215130791068077, 0.007037692703306675, -0.0033806993160396814, 0.0046953968703746796, -0.00018313834152650088, -0.0018821742851287127, -0.033827394247055054, 0.031890369951725006, 0.010743064805865288, 0.004743191879242659, -0.015757832676172256, -0.03469492867588997, -0.01303713396191597, -0.059652481228113174, -0.003696046769618988, -0.03173009678721428, -0.02041652984917164, 0.03603031486272812, -0.002986389212310314, 0.06150531768798828, -0.0018246958497911692, -0.033683907240629196, 0.019101154059171677, 0.0642571672797203, 0.021536068990826607, 0.01982642151415348, -0.025175755843520164, 0.02605404332280159, -0.031460002064704895, 0.014942441135644913, -0.052103232592344284, -0.032119035720825195, -0.013129244558513165, 0.007488842122256756, 0.024243108928203583, -0.07351616770029068, -0.001562126912176609, -0.02714156173169613, -0.05135069414973259, -0.02411017008125782, 0.04286254942417145, -0.023875541985034943, -0.018183959648013115, -0.004745422396808863, 0.010343324393033981, 0.08073971420526505, -0.02300938218832016, 0.018328526988625526, 0.006007067859172821, 0.008213159628212452, 0.009972895495593548, 0.004325501620769501, -0.028922064229846, 0.0019000583561137319, -0.00770571967586875, 0.0033275659661740065, 0.030513795092701912, 0.025513727217912674, -0.023398030549287796, -0.0029549954924732447, 0.001987994881346822, -0.02222023904323578, -0.005254830699414015, -0.04857766255736351, 0.0015146441292017698, 0.005157753825187683, 0.0027276312466710806, -0.013192524202167988, -0.0003906897618435323, -0.03804020956158638, -0.017414089292287827, 0.04900864511728287, 0.007131349295377731, 0.012314473278820515, 0.03980150818824768, 0.07038190960884094, 0.010448441840708256, 0.015215729363262653, 0.004137739539146423, 0.0014654039405286312, 0.04820239543914795, 0.008023136295378208, -0.022583473473787308, 0.020506925880908966, 0.005769878160208464, -0.0025456822477281094, -0.00931399967521429, -0.0604809895157814, 0.0004953232710249722, 0.05343049392104149, -0.01852354221045971, 0.04314587265253067, 0.05890841409564018, -0.02033066563308239, -0.004934357479214668, -0.024549705907702446, -0.010061458684504032, -0.02440360188484192, -0.0022470869589596987, 0.058116380125284195, -0.011069395579397678, -0.014770576730370522, -0.008089819923043251, 0.02381671778857708, 0.014744982123374939, 0.03477855771780014, 0.02348398230969906, -0.0005766457179561257, 0.013310476206243038, -0.039365511387586594, -0.0469469353556633, 0.038381412625312805, -0.06314513087272644, 0.006169004365801811, -0.019656626507639885, -0.03749026358127594, 0.024111352860927582, 0.043214935809373856, -0.019437020644545555, -0.05329512059688568, -0.03569471091032028, -0.06192336603999138, 0.031540874391794205, 0.015550845302641392, -0.024938330054283142, 0.04398519918322563, 0.027021171525120735, 0.028856342658400536, 0.0011405420955270529, 0.03647361323237419, -0.040123555809259415, -0.05593162775039673, -0.03335125744342804, -0.0350232794880867, -0.014104781672358513, 0.024309756234288216, -0.007524757646024227, -0.014892532490193844, -0.002527067670598626, -0.05646185949444771, -0.0006060466403141618, -0.00267260754480958, 0.033332835882902145, 0.007502641063183546, 0.0367887020111084, 0.007270194124430418, 0.004552820697426796, -0.017542999237775803, 0.0029734575655311346, 0.1147230789065361, 0.07734191417694092, 0.04185982793569565, -0.08980043977499008, -0.0014102947898209095, -0.005565461236983538, -0.0008432240574620664, -0.0168890580534935, -0.0003083301708102226, 0.00024359265808016062, -0.015441841445863247, 0.06572501361370087, 0.04653466120362282, 0.040440354496240616, 0.014944607391953468, 0.08275511860847473, -0.027682675048708916, 0.004045345354825258, 0.0009088005754165351, -0.012210297398269176, -0.023564880713820457, 0.020272456109523773, -0.06477633863687515, -0.01861579902470112, -0.028085745871067047, -0.06410767883062363, -0.011995314620435238, -0.018493102863430977, 0.004506498109549284, 0.012441689148545265, 0.0040307845920324326, -0.0064864265732467175, 0.04235518351197243, 0.015436602756381035, 0.023156464099884033, -0.004976509604603052, 0.02318754233419895, -0.02667597122490406, 0.03673090040683746, -0.019328802824020386, -0.020996099337935448, -0.01395538542419672, 0.006502291653305292, 0.01494596991688013, -0.03133336454629898, -0.06017904356122017, -0.03675450012087822, 0.053033504635095596, -0.013369771651923656, -0.050623711198568344, -0.021980302408337593, -0.0013615468051284552, 0.026280537247657776, -0.004370433744043112, -0.021931659430265427, 0.01599387265741825, 0.048150431364774704, -0.043781254440546036, -0.007966319099068642, 0.008205374702811241, 0.022452382370829582, -0.005056755617260933, 0.04184817150235176, 0.019035452976822853, -0.023531023412942886, -0.003848387161269784, -0.08103684335947037, 0.05613993480801582, 0.018210377544164658, -0.036075763404369354, -0.0059417858719825745, -0.0169900543987751, -0.02477196231484413, 0.00426239799708128, 0.00388195994310081, -0.02007654868066311, 0.008629855699837208, 0.00673629529774189, 0.0145421689376235, -0.008571983315050602, -0.014601543545722961, 0.009232587181031704, -0.009717772714793682, -0.017764300107955933, -0.04375996068120003, -0.0024406963493674994, 0.0031565362587571144, 0.05403963103890419, 0.024726999923586845, -0.010125944390892982, -0.02434210479259491, 0.016076916828751564, 0.03698917478322983, -0.03902304545044899, 0.004795028828084469, -0.008152998052537441, -0.041326865553855896, -0.010048816911876202, 0.0041228304617106915, 0.05788755044341087, 0.04221265763044357, -0.010258187539875507, 0.015705088153481483, 0.032635752111673355, -0.0100209079682827, -0.0002805733820423484, 0.02702544815838337, -0.05378182977437973, -0.0197785422205925, 0.015509963035583496, -0.005030560772866011, -0.022874295711517334, -0.019045870751142502, -0.0416155606508255, -0.03223849833011627, -0.02602081187069416, -0.05813728645443916, -0.014970355667173862, -0.034886494278907776, -0.022778838872909546, 0.01852520927786827, -0.03920822590589523, 0.010488428175449371, -0.03103395365178585, 0.020008321851491928, -0.027243273332715034, -0.0028494687285274267, -0.01044169906526804, 0.016869492828845978, -0.01750713400542736, 0.005279283970594406, 0.02442828379571438, 0.03247072920203209, 0.0449664443731308, -0.009561536833643913, 0.022185053676366806, 0.01394771970808506, 0.030296174809336662, -0.03688660264015198, -0.0007510380237363279, 0.016883084550499916, -0.04343918338418007, 0.010854000225663185, -0.007294736336916685, 0.008973679505288601, 0.028578761965036392, 0.0004456200113054365, -0.029253462329506874, -0.030452676117420197, 0.0644330382347107, -0.007394982036203146, -0.020740536972880363, -0.003325835568830371, 0.024141857400536537, -0.005005820654332638, 0.010153605602681637, 0.02068195305764675, 0.012745397165417671, -0.000034550826967461035, 0.020967403426766396, 0.03944864496588707, 0.013401619158685207, 0.015600836835801601, 0.033100470900535583, 0.018407616764307022, 0.015622083097696304, -0.011965719982981682, -0.013820745050907135, 0.04630812630057335, 0.043797433376312256, -0.055452700704336166, 0.0220181867480278, 0.00046716880751773715, 0.03583293408155441, -0.0908835306763649, -0.03772701695561409, 0.006976768374443054, -0.004148371983319521, 0.05567803233861923, -0.05424714460968971, -0.006856628227978945, -0.004403867293149233, -0.05453208461403847, 0.02234882116317749, -0.0028190258890390396, -0.008762340061366558, -0.039892878383398056, 0.04195580631494522, -0.00630889693275094, 0.020379193127155304, 0.018159251660108566, 0.02877688780426979, 0.014037931337952614, 0.04950294643640518, 0.0006224601529538631, -0.007580901030451059, -0.039465975016355515, -0.027176566421985626, 0.030523007735610008, -0.06945887953042984, 0.040259163826704025, -0.025320563465356827, -0.041354648768901825, 0.038194797933101654, -0.001915245782583952, 0.019419005140662193, 0.02499559335410595, 0.03568539023399353, -0.001970933983102441, 0.052036214619874954, 0.04292226955294609, -0.020960621535778046, 0.023614147678017616, -0.0208271574229002, 0.05420937389135361, 0.012912560254335403, -0.014130421914160252, -0.00841209664940834, 0.04187219217419624, -0.0014848830178380013, -0.025789901614189148, 0.03445955365896225, 0.008387848734855652, -0.01660303585231304, -0.030563561245799065, 0.009417697787284851, -0.007046889513731003, -0.012426504865288734, 0.013826891779899597, -0.049602385610342026, -0.03948500007390976, 0.0662887841463089, 0.007934496738016605, -0.0009812493808567524, -0.007812696509063244, -0.018372779712080956, -0.03432637080550194, -0.029890084639191628, -0.010048151947557926, 0.00949231069535017, -0.05856398493051529, 0.00687911594286561, 0.0011860686354339123, -0.009653531014919281, -0.016766540706157684, -0.031951554119586945, -0.0010612865444272757, 0.03995038941502571, -0.023342190310359, 0.002988949418067932, -0.004865196067839861, -0.018546465784311295, 0.02238134667277336, -0.05203792080283165, 0.06105715036392212, 0.008873164653778076, -0.004119622986763716, -0.0699394941329956, 0.013024711050093174, -0.036259185522794724, 0.013185001909732819, 0.017875509336590767, 0.0021397697273641825, 0.031925469636917114, -0.014222596772015095, 0.07661865651607513, 0.0071679456159472466, -0.0038855532184243202, 0.05176537483930588, -0.02902253158390522, -0.03582845255732536, -0.036509234458208084, 0.0132070854306221, 0.041547082364559174, -0.027279941365122795, -0.010080271400511265, -0.03153630718588829, 0.0060325744561851025, 0.014667969197034836, -0.045185066759586334, 0.023069309070706367, 0.01751747727394104, -0.045681554824113846, 0.03943202644586563, -0.008380514569580555, -0.0035231965593993664, 0.011349745094776154, 0.020018571987748146, -0.062993124127388, 0.0401279479265213, -0.05151780694723129, -0.03709159791469574, 0.003708433359861374, 0.02313772588968277, -0.025131909176707268, -0.0592767670750618, 0.029876740649342537, 0.003958176355808973, -0.0368633046746254, 0.001036441302858293, 0.03473682701587677, -0.005546859465539455, 0.06493674218654633, 0.0036683273501694202, -0.013224479742348194, -0.004593230318278074, -0.01423585880547762, 0.009742219001054764, -0.004635367076843977, 0.009843837469816208, -0.006819389760494232, -0.01837540790438652, 0.056565720587968826, -0.017697548493742943, 0.028336409479379654, 0.017758529633283615, 0.021894993260502815, -0.015384593047201633, 0.0053031714633107185, 0.04443570598959923, 0.005639020819216967, 0.02905408851802349, 0.01525638997554779, -0.015542720444500446, 0.04371992498636246, -0.02388686314225197, 0.013247664086520672, -0.03261912241578102, -0.007289316970854998, -0.03288564458489418, -0.0004841948684770614, -0.0092957504093647, 0.05854078382253647, 0.018805064260959625, 0.02119670808315277, -0.006780202034860849, -0.05292757600545883, -0.02225121296942234, -0.03361468389630318, 0.0187140591442585, -0.0029447514098137617, 0.00728072552010417, 0.01067549642175436, -0.04310024529695511, -0.05724706873297691, -0.026702674105763435, 0.03546573221683502, 0.06007448583841324, -0.010087304748594761, -0.02684999816119671, -0.03781694546341896, -0.008088991977274418, 0.03931029886007309, -0.04855035990476608, -0.006310851778835058, -0.041521940380334854, 0.025891663506627083, 0.008884444832801819, 0.03001502715051174 ]
<p>Let's say I have a sample of "events" done by a certain number of subjects, and some (although not most) of these subjects have underwent more than one event. I'd like to fit a logit model to these data to find out which characteristics contribute to a subject, over the course of an arbitrary period of time, undergoing another event within an arbitrary interval after a preceding event -- let's say three days. </p> <p>The way I see it, I can set my data up in one of two ways:</p> <ul> <li><p>take all of the events underwent by each subject, and define the dependent/indicator variable to be yes/no to "did this subject have another event within 3 days of a preceding event, over the course of the last year (for example)?" In this case, each row of the data for the model would correspond to every subject and be an aggregate of their event history.</p></li> <li><p>partition each subject's event history into pairs and define the dependent variable to be yes/no to "did this subject have another event within 3 days of this particular event?" In this case, each row would correspond to every event in the data. However, there are three outcomes: 1) the subject has another event within 3 days; 2) subject has another event within greater than 3 days; and 3) subject doesn't have any further events. Could I collapse 2) and 3) into one outcome, or would I be better off considering using a multinomial logit model instead?</p></li> </ul> <p>I'm leaning towards going with the latter option, but I'm worried that those subjects who undergo relatively more events will be over-represented in the final model (how would I deal with that, if I should?). However, I do think I gain significantly more information that way. Anyway, with that said, I'd love to hear insights on the pros/cons of each approach to setting up these particular data for a logit model.</p>
74,348
[ -0.02050646021962166, -0.006497688125818968, -0.000545521907042712, 0.006946429144591093, 0.03972620889544487, 0.0032193444203585386, -0.008397374302148819, -0.006675547454506159, 0.05071445554494858, 0.010195182636380196, 0.012134285643696785, 0.017987431958317757, 0.012831219471991062, -0.01835026405751705, 0.05052412673830986, 0.03447631746530533, 0.02970900945365429, 0.01331937126815319, -0.005793864838778973, -0.02368401363492012, -0.02151605859398842, -0.004054470453411341, 0.014424714259803295, -0.014395570382475853, -0.03932083770632744, 0.03963180258870125, 0.009256143122911453, -0.038829296827316284, 0.008340769447386265, 0.05394035205245018, -0.03903559595346451, -0.031918954104185104, 0.013976139947772026, 0.043130457401275635, 0.018511027097702026, 0.006862363778054714, -0.040761418640613556, -0.035383231937885284, 0.01508631557226181, 0.02089443802833557, -0.02049463614821434, -0.004829992074519396, -0.014608643017709255, 0.0034171489533036947, -0.03806211054325104, 0.012781701982021332, -0.028217611834406853, -0.029692845419049263, 0.02527485601603985, -0.03582680970430374, 0.06092563644051552, -0.024188853800296783, 0.02778145670890808, 0.03363775089383125, -0.0359722301363945, -0.021278562024235725, 0.061243508011102676, 0.09118235111236572, 0.0006717013893648982, -0.029620124027132988, -0.0213614571839571, -0.02664044313132763, -0.006020397879183292, -0.029028214514255524, -0.014924160204827785, 0.009761898778378963, 0.006122000515460968, -0.01447832677513361, 0.061845943331718445, -0.045913390815258026, 0.04037929326295853, 0.0034032310359179974, 0.045245006680488586, 0.0022633804474025965, 0.037640608847141266, -0.03766066953539848, 0.040092531591653824, -0.010095585137605667, 0.041015591472387314, 0.00891886930912733, 0.004041376058012247, 0.005604271311312914, 0.02408929541707039, 0.025145336985588074, 0.02138359658420086, -0.05630039796233177, 0.05262959748506546, -0.03583205118775368, -0.026744859293103218, -0.015006176196038723, -0.06949672102928162, 0.014568837359547615, 0.020123885944485664, 0.003201897256076336, -0.04619957506656647, 0.0368008017539978, -0.014816331677138805, 0.04418576881289482, 0.048276398330926895, 0.03418867662549019, -0.04350031539797783, -0.035729847848415375, -0.00276558636687696, 0.042876701802015305, -0.006115658208727837, 0.007911749184131622, -0.01128307357430458, 0.004125334322452545, -0.009291657246649265, -0.0559794083237648, -0.016027413308620453, 0.032828010618686676, 0.0258193276822567, 0.019754765555262566, 0.01458674669265747, -0.021225877106189728, -0.0021880310960114002, -0.03059772215783596, 0.051343705505132675, 0.07078225165605545, 0.026271216571331024, -0.034470830112695694, 0.024068167433142662, -0.058076418936252594, -0.05377523601055145, -0.0013924313243478537, -0.000013550775292969774, -0.010658720508217812, -0.04471579194068909, 0.0359942652285099, -0.011150473728775978, -0.006929832044988871, 0.05385437235236168, -0.021310782060027122, -0.003471419448032975, -0.009873071685433388, -0.06514661759138107, -0.030961470678448677, 0.00388262327760458, 0.00998478103429079, -0.036601144820451736, -0.03212493285536766, -0.014445686712861061, 0.0016687446041032672, 0.06756490468978882, -0.011314955540001392, 0.038204461336135864, 0.03853146731853485, 0.00392967788502574, 0.0386628694832325, -0.04060960188508034, 0.013163486495614052, -0.02464885450899601, -0.01858808472752571, 0.006387873087078333, -0.09802994877099991, 0.03190671652555466, 0.030375562608242035, 0.018234968185424805, 0.0033609592355787754, 0.054203473031520844, 0.016731921583414078, -0.010666622780263424, -0.01281050220131874, -0.0068711997009813786, -0.025030460208654404, 0.07560770958662033, -0.044221315532922745, 0.032396357506513596, 0.016738560050725937, 0.0291266068816185, 0.00790479313582182, 0.025782372802495956, 0.05890880897641182, 0.036084745079278946, -0.020523548126220703, -0.007945524528622627, 0.010848012752830982, 0.004918924067169428, -0.004285804461687803, 0.010845200158655643, -0.026988651603460312, -0.027974870055913925, -0.019505232572555542, 0.008869239129126072, 0.02906735986471176, 0.0512789823114872, -0.04054912552237511, 0.044257547706365585, -0.023229427635669708, -0.05789390206336975, -0.056280482560396194, -0.005283218342810869, -0.0007918184855952859, -0.013856692239642143, 0.04052805155515671, 0.007055788766592741, 0.019713783636689186, 0.02332919090986252, -0.01913308911025524, -0.01850285194814205, -0.008229300379753113, 0.023675840348005295, -0.06209222972393036, -0.028759056702256203, 0.0431329645216465, 0.01775779388844967, -0.01734757609665394, 0.007210438139736652, -0.04866693541407585, -0.010332692414522171, 0.009583656676113605, -0.05950572341680527, 0.011840848252177238, -0.019621467217803, -0.022791611030697823, -0.0014844763791188598, -0.00816712249070406, -0.05912989377975464, 0.03268558531999588, -0.07947796583175659, 0.058793023228645325, 0.07201303541660309, -0.024775683879852295, -0.009373516775667667, -0.006269614677876234, 0.02414851449429989, 0.0011096923844888806, -0.014541985467076302, -0.0168253593146801, -0.07501465082168579, -0.015235423110425472, 0.012098225764930248, 0.003137813648208976, 0.005605256650596857, 0.048728179186582565, 0.02219914272427559, 0.01728963665664196, -0.009895078837871552, 0.04490380734205246, 0.00811670534312725, 0.025487329810857773, 0.005924754310399294, 0.0075857797637581825, 0.016617150977253914, -0.02197408117353916, 0.003948016557842493, -0.008988911285996437, -0.0009009503410197794, -0.020586950704455376, 0.0028431846294552088, 0.02612924575805664, 0.04294850677251816, 0.010656933300197124, -0.016908369958400726, 0.0029569892212748528, 0.03261450678110123, -0.02413242496550083, 0.0038572445046156645, 0.03573927283287048, 0.031924206763505936, -0.021457906812429428, 0.015198327600955963, -0.0393032506108284, 0.02707330323755741, 0.0636003315448761, -0.02021544799208641, 0.00837760791182518, 0.014400103129446507, -0.04114247113466263, 0.0028549013659358025, -0.05020714923739433, -0.0347248800098896, -0.02358783408999443, -0.004395830444991589, 0.027778107672929764, -0.0014205049956217408, 0.04293648898601532, -0.03247522562742233, -0.02500271610915661, 0.0021818799432367086, -0.011418270878493786, 0.03531930223107338, 0.019503170624375343, -0.07467905431985855, -0.019811803475022316, -0.013339188881218433, -0.011351724155247211, 0.02569754049181938, -0.008793793618679047, -0.011191963218152523, 0.006742249708622694, 0.007834555581212044, -0.058096617460250854, -0.03015792928636074, 0.015565811656415462, -0.01616775244474411, -0.03903495892882347, -0.048919253051280975, 0.056382060050964355, 0.029602592810988426, -0.05111235752701759, -0.016493812203407288, -0.06950284540653229, 0.004538548644632101, -0.035212207585573196, 0.011676118709146976, 0.020118720829486847, -0.002533854218199849, -0.012770431116223335, 0.024359557777643204, 0.016050782054662704, 0.001185268280096352, -0.11893665045499802, -0.0497053861618042, -0.011059318669140339, -0.013337697833776474, 0.028714660555124283, 0.009226545691490173, 0.00028292369097471237, 0.04443259537220001, 0.03239491209387779, -0.012127603404223919, -0.04799746349453926, 0.009094113484025002, -0.0035482258535921574, -0.014383811503648758, 0.03785686939954758, 0.01356002688407898, -0.010196687653660774, 0.02332940138876438, 0.011970913968980312, 0.016479354351758957, 0.025907568633556366, 0.05225924775004387, 0.004311019089072943, 0.03555026650428772, 0.034701406955718994, -0.034702252596616745, 0.030000392347574234, 0.022858617827296257, -0.0182424858212471, 0.03579849749803543, -0.06085767224431038, 0.018609944730997086, 0.005030069500207901, -0.05343589931726456, 0.03142140805721283, 0.014327382668852806, -0.003695376683026552, -0.006743506994098425, 0.017381923273205757, 0.008712464943528175, -0.03700077906250954, 0.002957957098260522, 0.046902772039175034, 0.048695605248212814, -0.03016836754977703, 0.03868424892425537, 0.049321290105581284, 0.05506568402051926, -0.047908782958984375, 0.015147329308092594, -0.02506711706519127, 0.007561040110886097, 0.02551506832242012, -0.028255151584744453, 0.03239116817712784, 0.04212792217731476, 0.013531259261071682, 0.013294581323862076, -0.010766439139842987, -0.01790751703083515, -0.002703180303797126, -0.04422962665557861, 0.020007934421300888, -0.0167351383715868, 0.043021440505981445, 0.008931031450629234, 0.03293661028146744, 0.02016029879450798, -0.00816708616912365, 0.030726233497262, 0.02090775966644287, -0.06159146502614021, -0.013514106161892414, 0.003778340993449092, 0.04325925186276436, 0.035640254616737366, -0.005080530885607004, 0.07357004284858704, -0.02410043217241764, -0.011060377582907677, -0.01655205525457859, 0.021785089746117592, -0.035354722291231155, 0.008382108062505722, -0.04667914658784866, -0.00505072483792901, -0.005965651944279671, 0.005958521738648415, 0.01872163452208042, 0.0022753404919058084, 0.0031695759389549494, 0.03496545925736427, 0.020209940150380135, -0.003855435410514474, 0.003881261684000492, 0.005303858779370785, 0.015241708606481552, 0.03407914191484451, -0.03440374881029129, 0.04095754027366638, -0.012626436538994312, 0.057228874415159225, 0.001424835529178381, 0.03354150056838989, 0.03945835307240486, -0.020348230376839638, -0.019015634432435036, -0.022835005074739456, -0.03423991799354553, 0.01905110478401184, 0.013218089938163757, 0.05362990126013756, -0.009920134209096432, 0.02376813068985939, 0.05753631889820099, -0.038091059774160385, -0.0003661162918433547, 0.07079426199197769, -0.011285617016255856, -0.030397647991776466, -0.036282334476709366, 0.016309797763824463, 0.024039575830101967, 0.007369497325271368, -0.0015722389798611403, 0.04908159375190735, -0.007795646321028471, -0.0000877908241818659, 0.030126510187983513, -0.010985583998262882, -0.006671811453998089, 0.02018733322620392, 0.02031426876783371, 0.05425351858139038, 0.04678982496261597, -0.044347818940877914, 0.004501177463680506, 0.03429894894361496, 0.018117036670446396, 0.026252713054418564, 0.023931948468089104, -0.09644904732704163, 0.0014283914351835847, 0.0546039380133152, 0.032301608473062515, -0.03952332213521004, 0.020720895379781723, -0.02074878290295601, -0.042737025767564774, -0.009713360108435154, -0.04658891633152962, -0.010808458551764488, -0.0025409848894923925, 0.02926183119416237, -0.03700771927833557, -0.043374039232730865, -0.05349015071988106, 0.030881959944963455, -0.026206351816654205, 0.028852613642811775, -0.0017393691232427955, -0.01922995038330555, -0.03204713761806488, 0.02693779207766056, 0.017001990228891373, 0.0666479766368866, -0.03868015110492706, -0.04259299114346504, 0.01690554805099964, -0.00702883955091238, -0.05602056533098221, -0.04018339514732361, -0.020271774381399155, 0.009832175448536873, -0.010030525736510754, 0.029534585773944855, 0.008356042206287384, -0.019990224391222, -0.006871803198009729, 0.016989698633551598, -0.021009495481848717, 0.034860704094171524, -0.049665216356515884, 0.03126148134469986, 0.005748819559812546, -0.035793788731098175, 0.048662785440683365, 0.04154931381344795, -0.022129762917757034, 0.031013982370495796, -0.04498347267508507, -0.011050926521420479, 0.005937518086284399, -0.011801844462752342, -0.021727893501520157, -0.014249579049646854, -0.020730840042233467, 0.011790910735726357, -0.02455906569957733, 0.025143982842564583, -0.01329298596829176, -0.011541202664375305, -0.014847379177808762, -0.007580934092402458, 0.020403556525707245, 0.004812059458345175, -0.011373520828783512, 0.023036237806081772, 0.015005884692072868, -0.022547438740730286, -0.001212041126564145, -0.03619905933737755, 0.015894027426838875, 0.028332337737083435, -0.027002548798918724, 0.026034586131572723, -0.0447562113404274, -0.05484975501894951, 0.02300308831036091, -0.0035997803788632154, 0.053963128477334976, -0.011001870036125183, 0.03557642921805382, 0.013631084002554417, -0.025858990848064423, 0.02942863292992115, 0.032812971621751785, 0.014822832308709621, 0.02487589605152607, -0.032152339816093445, 0.02541409432888031, -0.016859641298651695, -0.020582903176546097, -0.06898781657218933, -0.037405792623758316, 0.04016485810279846, -0.01975313387811184, -0.023824136704206467, -0.02405744604766369, -0.00427141273394227, -0.027007494121789932, -0.014232234098017216, -0.024907346814870834, 0.061981845647096634, -0.023395074531435966, -0.0010839053429663181, -0.01940002664923668, 0.05269840732216835, 0.0311063714325428, 0.016250157728791237, 0.00151614542119205, -0.0027394460048526525, -0.009435462765395641, -0.014339695684611797, 0.004153859335929155, -0.0024069047067314386, -0.021042192354798317, -0.021505514159798622, -0.0018192551797255874, 0.01170046254992485, 0.05865645036101341, -0.029500801116228104, -0.0461992509663105, 0.010459977202117443, -0.04297252371907234, -0.00783261377364397, -0.027893787249922752, 0.00905333086848259, 0.027532709762454033, 0.006112135946750641, -0.01685231551527977, 0.029209503903985023, -0.03178463876247406, 0.021320484578609467, 0.030843310058116913, -0.025161530822515488, -0.0039378381334245205, 0.01432119496166706, 0.025376198813319206, 0.014474690891802311, 0.03607010841369629, -0.01779669150710106, 0.002587476745247841, 0.044873133301734924, -0.011072099208831787, -0.02676384150981903, 0.02846251241862774, 0.012873458676040173, -0.037142474204301834, -0.029367132112383842, -0.02251899242401123, 0.005028643179684877, 0.04865759611129761, -0.009488748386502266, 0.00660824216902256, 0.06336676329374313, 0.006269785109907389, 0.017643216997385025, -0.030463647097349167, 0.021747596561908722, -0.02386362850666046, 0.020585231482982635, 0.0628523975610733, -0.0013005551882088184, -0.01614462025463581, -0.003449504030868411, 0.00882356334477663, 0.005257997661828995, 0.014177057892084122, 0.015547936782240868, 0.014676542952656746, 0.040530726313591, -0.03317607194185257, -0.05071369558572769, 0.0030634512659162283, -0.07321327179670334, -0.004642297979444265, -0.04601072147488594, -0.022626757621765137, 0.038765933364629745, 0.027061959728598595, -0.007308320142328739, -0.07154638320207596, -0.02710072509944439, -0.05391225218772888, 0.015288785099983215, 0.030169766396284103, 0.009800164960324764, 0.038612909615039825, -0.01595274731516838, 0.07103404402732849, -0.004364535678178072, -0.024792397394776344, 0.0018998546293005347, -0.1268080323934555, -0.00907045416533947, 0.004515309818089008, -0.03431934490799904, 0.010243553668260574, -0.02389661967754364, -0.009937685914337635, 0.014404908753931522, -0.019245879724621773, -0.0012012106599286199, -0.005401300732046366, 0.03403676301240921, -0.012167868204414845, 0.06760339438915253, -0.012601505033671856, 0.012721216306090355, 0.006917845457792282, 0.005791323725134134, 0.14698158204555511, 0.08575079590082169, 0.03431069478392601, -0.06514940410852432, 0.01033137645572424, 0.05628566816449165, 0.013370836153626442, -0.00852737296372652, -0.00718959653750062, 0.026330480352044106, -0.002061801264062524, 0.045377202332019806, 0.058654189109802246, -0.004569096956402063, -0.014228657819330692, 0.05410416051745415, 0.006264216266572475, -0.024371318519115448, -0.02405259944498539, 0.02365483157336712, 0.0015646509127691388, -0.03132958337664604, -0.026299044489860535, -0.00864501390606165, 0.01881704106926918, -0.01881188340485096, 0.002260948298498988, -0.03231441602110863, -0.0011095544323325157, -0.03224245458841324, 0.00912497378885746, 0.01124846562743187, 0.03993577882647514, 0.032467734068632126, -0.013478457927703857, 0.016211489215493202, 0.02102695219218731, -0.023382648825645447, 0.000305295514408499, 0.021302031353116035, 0.0005375826731324196, -0.011576910503208637, 0.015416746027767658, 0.019555047154426575, -0.05777159333229065, -0.04008163884282112, -0.039048705250024796, 0.02480314113199711, 0.007513632066547871, -0.01466513890773058, -0.027319684624671936, 0.012695957906544209, 0.036563318222761154, -0.02119300700724125, -0.05228680372238159, 0.03371813893318176, 0.008639034815132618, -0.024853454902768135, -0.013499833643436432, -0.0010129964211955667, 0.004422918893396854, 0.004845599643886089, 0.029289931058883667, 0.03568381443619728, -0.018630480393767357, -0.017604611814022064, -0.0397782139480114, 0.028235668316483498, 0.02074682153761387, 0.021990124136209488, -0.03739594295620918, -0.004778644535690546, -0.017554040998220444, -0.022751322016119957, 0.026461105793714523, -0.017874788492918015, 0.023182962089776993, -0.01576314866542816, 0.011364885605871677, -0.04142855852842331, 0.014041795395314693, 0.001354277366772294, -0.002393810311332345, -0.02420751005411148, -0.04840702563524246, 0.03907223418354988, 0.009188503958284855, 0.028036288917064667, 0.0024782700929790735, 0.04281437769532204, -0.014620544388890266, 0.06652320176362991, 0.016782978549599648, -0.03941994905471802, -0.012265462428331375, -0.025715358555316925, -0.04935146123170853, 0.0008540560374967754, 0.0007951827137731016, 0.07772838324308395, -0.018357234075665474, 0.03286051005125046, 0.010045045986771584, 0.03371189907193184, -0.0026025460101664066, -0.0014762358041480184, 0.0410807728767395, -0.07035349309444427, 0.008996788412332535, -0.002725183730944991, 0.0055953445844352245, 0.01639080047607422, -0.019563468173146248, -0.010169715620577335, -0.03807848319411278, 0.01052688155323267, -0.04881444200873375, -0.04122617095708847, 0.028681106865406036, -0.021934062242507935, 0.04861386865377426, -0.02399413101375103, 0.006849776022136211, -0.04944881796836853, -0.01706668548285961, -0.015516682527959347, -0.034346699714660645, 0.016397371888160706, 0.026012539863586426, -0.004700863733887672, -0.01155399065464735, 0.036129601299762726, 0.0070008826442062855, -0.017046522349119186, -0.03140459209680557, 0.035907287150621414, 0.026059219613671303, 0.05502069368958473, -0.0004955239710398018, -0.009426484815776348, 0.043768610805273056, -0.017997607588768005, 0.0016228780150413513, 0.010789414867758751, 0.009589810855686665, 0.05748886987566948, -0.028045041486620903, -0.01799607463181019, -0.011767394840717316, 0.003510822309181094, -0.03393996134400368, -0.03444933146238327, -0.005571021698415279, 0.010239286348223686, 0.0046897148713469505, 0.00407832395285368, -0.019956180825829506, 0.04894765093922615, -0.031615372747182846, 0.053525879979133606, 0.05713644623756409, -0.01763893850147724, -0.011957754381000996, -0.033294208347797394, -0.013179723173379898, 0.03788243979215622, -0.03848939388990402, -0.013053643517196178, 0.025361277163028717, 0.03396588936448097, -0.03575950115919113, 0.03819489851593971, -0.004491765052080154, 0.038810066878795624, -0.0643668845295906, -0.04254686459898949, -0.000019632083422038704, 0.006265462376177311, 0.03366408497095108, -0.035604823380708694, -0.007611274253576994, 0.00017992161156143993, -0.009963661432266235, 0.030217837542295456, 0.015424785204231739, 0.028150029480457306, -0.01922515407204628, 0.02687341906130314, -0.01933654025197029, 0.008221704512834549, 0.013241873122751713, 0.022176438942551613, 0.014934803359210491, 0.019656207412481308, 0.027935661375522614, -0.021743588149547577, -0.03497227281332016, 0.015152525156736374, 0.012648412957787514, -0.057859987020492554, 0.039782121777534485, -0.04242643713951111, -0.03946762531995773, 0.038876473903656006, -0.0017912283074110746, 0.045102160423994064, 0.0366310253739357, 0.017572063952684402, 0.007160046603530645, 0.05208227038383484, 0.031670525670051575, -0.01062606368213892, -0.002892574295401573, 0.03013569489121437, 0.009943715296685696, 0.04945928230881691, -0.031794123351573944, 0.020589467138051987, 0.03444037586450577, -0.012439500540494919, -0.04665281996130943, -0.0006414763629436493, -0.004623572342097759, 0.008434225805103779, -0.03450751304626465, -0.02839004248380661, -0.005459093488752842, -0.011370535008609295, -0.0014981739223003387, -0.036903515458106995, -0.01758510433137417, 0.07301592081785202, 0.044463030993938446, 0.007491954602301121, 0.01188955269753933, -0.019303232431411743, -0.033077485859394073, 0.007846211083233356, 0.006103538908064365, 0.01115497387945652, -0.021329840645194054, -0.010605529882013798, -0.009804658591747284, 0.018491020426154137, -0.04370005801320076, 0.021375887095928192, -0.04660097882151604, 0.033579517155885696, -0.059810418635606766, 0.008592594414949417, 0.07485596090555191, -0.021251967176795006, 0.012178640812635422, -0.09366410970687866, 0.06062522158026695, 0.017107702791690826, -0.008704455569386482, -0.051265932619571686, -0.011243058368563652, -0.02465813048183918, -0.016795489937067032, 0.05729882791638374, -0.012112576514482498, 0.0021388730965554714, -0.003170028096064925, 0.032897885888814926, 0.013402020558714867, -0.014751407317817211, 0.026545414701104164, -0.026527313515543938, 0.04172150045633316, -0.016577614471316338, 0.006423787213861942, -0.0018544229678809643, -0.008844471536576748, 0.027652285993099213, -0.026794960722327232, 0.008769680745899677, -0.02703326940536499, -0.005646727047860622, 0.013602152466773987, -0.005329894367605448, -0.028515763580799103, 0.012375692836940289, -0.0396181158721447, 0.008145233616232872, 0.03947987034916878, -0.02670660987496376, -0.07902831584215164, 0.0359412357211113, -0.054446492344141006, -0.03481947258114815, 0.0021371138282120228, 0.02436516247689724, 0.012858524918556213, -0.048077136278152466, 0.01997876912355423, -0.024361129850149155, -0.02092563360929489, 0.018274394795298576, 0.04242315515875816, 0.032775554805994034, 0.025272348895668983, -0.012360493652522564, 0.020282208919525146, -0.017615629360079765, -0.05769886448979378, 0.005485220346599817, 0.016865037381649017, 0.03762505203485489, 0.005468715913593769, -0.01507710199803114, 0.03426540642976761, 0.011277309618890285, 0.015420213341712952, -0.021433958783745766, 0.04542434215545654, -0.006315869744867086, -0.009035540744662285, 0.04790768772363663, 0.01282285526394844, 0.03772053122520447, 0.01540946215391159, 0.030854640528559685, 0.026476414874196053, 0.002703628037124872, -0.014079089276492596, -0.026386139914393425, -0.06160270422697067, -0.046272162348032, 0.03130178898572922, 0.030011150985956192, 0.02545374445617199, 0.004244851879775524, 0.005333979148417711, -0.00641198456287384, -0.02541116438806057, -0.010192873887717724, -0.013307498767971992, 0.013667530380189419, -0.018325166776776314, -0.01366609986871481, 0.012029393576085567, -0.0706048235297203, -0.03057790733873844, -0.022409508004784584, 0.008528158068656921, 0.04200516641139984, -0.0017796268220990896, -0.009792414493858814, -0.03496651351451874, -0.01816258206963539, 0.034927938133478165, -0.04319711774587631, 0.005078187212347984, -0.08495014160871506, 0.04122744873166084, 0.004008100833743811, -0.010543808341026306 ]
<p>I am trying to use the <code>glmnet</code> MATLAB package to train my elastic net model on some huge data. My features are of size 13200, and I have around 6000 samples of these. I directly tried to use <code>lassoglm</code> in MATLAB with these features and corresponding target taking cross validation to just 3 folds and alpha = 0.5. It's already 6 hours and it hasn't finished. I have to do it for several others as well.</p> <p>Any suggestions what I should do?</p>
37,201
[ -0.04088883101940155, 0.02562863565981388, -0.023127522319555283, -0.025414155796170235, 0.025723453611135483, -0.022657006978988647, -0.051481325179338455, -0.045500826090574265, 0.009692569263279438, -0.019470641389489174, 0.043541308492422104, 0.011999216862022877, 0.0380089208483696, 0.007177405990660191, -0.01342072058469057, -0.008754553273320198, -0.012253372929990292, 0.000047968504077289253, -0.010033901780843735, -0.019010387361049652, -0.010415543802082539, 0.03483235463500023, -0.020116886124014854, -0.00017439023940823972, -0.0016672007041051984, 0.03891674056649208, 0.00012105574569432065, -0.03100661188364029, -0.004712691530585289, 0.02571183070540428, -0.055146582424640656, -0.011939698830246925, -0.0017391135916113853, 0.0036142165772616863, -0.0017951037734746933, 0.030621616169810295, -0.014340870082378387, -0.05201342701911926, -0.0020648506470024586, 0.03477194160223007, -0.00010447641398059204, -0.0017416909104213119, -0.006524496711790562, 0.03645322844386101, -0.006677770521491766, 0.03406976908445358, 0.0017988784238696098, -0.03630552068352699, 0.051304884254932404, 0.011098322458565235, 0.05418822169303894, 0.016976408660411835, 0.041263122111558914, -0.007932859472930431, -0.007114019710570574, -0.007565799169242382, 0.0499231182038784, 0.06031901016831398, -0.0023760327603667974, -0.03255433589220047, 0.014775185845792294, -0.024158289656043053, 0.01098858192563057, -0.05200952664017677, -0.004504125565290451, 0.05798256769776344, -0.004571191966533661, 0.015553447417914867, 0.02267615869641304, -0.014425286091864109, 0.011063567362725735, 0.028966940939426422, 0.03142555058002472, -0.026170531287789345, 0.02699381299316883, -0.008694625459611416, 0.015307648107409477, -0.004245716612786055, 0.03402017056941986, 0.02493705041706562, 0.0026714063715189695, 0.03911656141281128, 0.03550803288817406, 0.02792058140039444, 0.05092263221740723, -0.02749376744031906, 0.04191957786679268, -0.011195112019777298, 0.02412138134241104, 0.006937739439308643, -0.007825258187949657, -0.0036360539961606264, 0.050572022795677185, 0.02620333433151245, -0.025858448818325996, 0.009739665314555168, -0.01184519100934267, 0.013575587421655655, 0.018621373921632767, 0.00992321502417326, -0.016442734748125076, -0.04234670102596283, -0.010080200619995594, 0.04193035513162613, 0.006867508869618177, 0.04543450474739075, -0.02287127822637558, -0.047148432582616806, -0.0069403634406626225, -0.036397118121385574, -0.025799879804253578, 0.02855350263416767, 0.0075263986364007, -0.011361266486346722, -0.00984293594956398, -0.03388044238090515, -0.006425961852073669, -0.00821883138269186, 0.012476758100092411, 0.07576495409011841, 0.029042378067970276, 0.004067243076860905, 0.0417383648455143, -0.04706702008843422, -0.06639298051595688, -0.0010171320755034685, 0.010571558028459549, -0.006750817410647869, -0.041030991822481155, 0.07659857720136642, 0.005722750909626484, -0.04390822350978851, 0.035093486309051514, -0.008762949146330357, 0.04397694393992424, -0.011394364759325981, -0.07122819125652313, -0.06211186945438385, 0.04547989368438721, -0.033172138035297394, 0.03968218341469765, -0.05042116343975067, 0.013067035004496574, -0.01736954227089882, 0.07716193795204163, 0.05148659273982048, 0.07153898477554321, 0.03894592076539993, -0.012242265045642853, -0.029123438522219658, 0.010992388240993023, -0.02360612340271473, -0.04575779289007187, 0.03309688717126846, -0.00034519797191023827, -0.041861642152071, 0.0038243208546191454, -0.01007876917719841, -0.03353189304471016, 0.000003297784360256628, -0.008453180082142353, 0.002297269646078348, -0.0029922581743448973, 0.00009890530782286078, -0.033539772033691406, -0.026058774441480637, 0.055272120982408524, -0.0020770265255123377, 0.058915335685014725, 0.05338705703616142, -0.040291719138622284, -0.05095496401190758, 0.023835720494389534, 0.013629980385303497, 0.020959865301847458, 0.013496302999556065, 0.03207609802484512, -0.032301656901836395, 0.019311247393488884, 0.05202767252922058, 0.011578709818422794, -0.03361192345619202, -0.005748766008764505, -0.005132910795509815, 0.02382657490670681, 0.029634254053235054, 0.017802538350224495, -0.019171051681041718, 0.036652810871601105, -0.020239489153027534, -0.04630002751946449, -0.027559885755181313, 0.04134155437350273, 0.013964863494038582, -0.007463353686034679, 0.002173483371734619, -0.0014529480831697583, 0.022132817655801773, -0.01795285753905773, -0.01682954840362072, 0.012984953820705414, 0.006636030972003937, 0.038309089839458466, -0.014914318919181824, -0.0162696223706007, 0.08507529646158218, 0.0177543256431818, -0.03860412538051605, 0.05634760111570358, -0.01727975532412529, -0.018182387575507164, 0.029700519517064095, -0.01606673002243042, -0.00036336202174425125, -0.028254644945263863, -0.02260872907936573, -0.002824377967044711, 0.002158850897103548, -0.0028913652058690786, 0.014769953675568104, -0.045828577131032944, 0.0669206753373146, 0.06416890770196915, -0.010107826441526413, 0.04937954992055893, 0.00131649908144027, -0.012978579849004745, 0.014051428064703941, 0.014211314730346203, 0.005310640670359135, -0.021773552522063255, -0.016383035108447075, 0.0782223492860794, 0.01580037735402584, -0.008495157584547997, 0.0005079506663605571, 0.07029187679290771, 0.006804067175835371, 0.023833205923438072, 0.028823357075452805, -0.026145223528146744, -0.0274855624884367, 0.010420366190373898, 0.028338605538010597, 0.04406515508890152, -0.01989356242120266, -0.03520336374640465, 0.01082849781960249, 0.032649777829647064, -0.028762197121977806, -0.02029023878276348, 0.05012066289782524, -0.00319192698225379, -0.031675972044467926, 0.0057222056202590466, 0.006057879887521267, 0.023963747546076775, 0.020093023777008057, -0.03276379406452179, 0.05102349445223808, 0.006640467327088118, 0.012064524926245213, 0.01698199100792408, -0.05684899911284447, 0.04339850693941116, 0.022849049419164658, -0.036471303552389145, -0.0443708673119545, 0.009616836905479431, -0.07840365916490555, 0.03783165290951729, -0.026049526408314705, -0.04042921960353851, -0.060587409883737564, 0.040329672396183014, 0.03834027051925659, -0.027956312522292137, 0.008662955835461617, -0.04308684915304184, -0.0493917278945446, 0.03157607838511467, -0.026650136336684227, 0.04314332827925682, 0.008315980434417725, -0.04040870442986488, -0.009745310060679913, -0.0005951669299975038, -0.008340757340192795, 0.04849173501133919, 0.00487715657800436, -0.028413895517587662, 0.02439417503774166, -0.007150906138122082, -0.05257480964064598, -0.029048386961221695, -0.046444643288850784, 0.009650157764554024, 0.02921709045767784, 0.00446294667199254, 0.04342694580554962, 0.0058559151366353035, -0.05713854357600212, 0.028801798820495605, -0.005130426958203316, 0.011349566280841827, -0.03875231742858887, 0.008816656656563282, -0.010327504947781563, 0.010709847323596478, -0.022355876863002777, 0.03045661747455597, -0.0012896384578198195, 0.016672223806381226, -0.051335494965314865, -0.04796092212200165, 0.012721255421638489, -0.009396899491548538, -0.000825967697892338, 0.03128264471888542, 0.015491198748350143, 0.04332250729203224, 0.029372764751315117, -0.033836834132671356, -0.05942804366350174, -0.025179477408528328, -0.0191302839666605, -0.03739801049232483, 0.022417837753891945, -0.016341203823685646, 0.028637249022722244, 0.07044853270053864, 0.006773270200937986, 0.012107211165130138, 0.04519568756222725, 0.0024264990352094173, -0.0033756273332983255, 0.02661602571606636, -0.008797342889010906, 0.02374526485800743, 0.044668350368738174, 0.017876429483294487, -0.005199705250561237, 0.010278230533003807, -0.0065415664575994015, -0.012736613862216473, -0.000493070634547621, -0.053391844034194946, -0.025000333786010742, -0.03848590701818466, 0.03623601049184799, -0.026532821357250214, 0.016097556799650192, -0.018088707700371742, -0.05477433279156685, 0.015942197293043137, 0.022265998646616936, 0.06949327141046524, -0.02888006530702114, 0.013199150562286377, 0.0237058587372303, 0.030228909105062485, -0.038512662053108215, 0.021587688475847244, -0.015687499195337296, 0.012506642378866673, 0.031668633222579956, -0.011798864230513573, -0.0163346566259861, 0.02266714908182621, 0.0402413010597229, 0.018252788111567497, -0.009089243598282337, -0.014041563495993614, -0.00005783936649095267, -0.03938337042927742, 0.010101137682795525, 0.0038532125763595104, 0.03056270070374012, 0.014826108701527119, 0.04767175018787384, 0.03370353952050209, -0.0024963142350316048, 0.019418815150856972, 0.010281382128596306, -0.040917299687862396, 0.010474739596247673, -0.011471104808151722, -0.0077773756347596645, 0.036243975162506104, -0.02320043370127678, -0.010412851348519325, -0.02699739672243595, 0.03087283857166767, 0.016186751425266266, 0.03940577059984207, -0.0421888642013073, 0.019574260339140892, -0.012994836084544659, 0.0008864994160830975, -0.014360683038830757, -0.0013317563571035862, -0.018497997894883156, -0.022887714207172394, 0.0065651340410113335, 0.01235866267234087, -0.022138265892863274, -0.004263374488800764, -0.016979198902845383, 0.02150840125977993, -0.002045324770733714, 0.04790573939681053, 0.007226143963634968, 0.04775386303663254, -0.07545436173677444, 0.007885259576141834, 0.029208669438958168, 0.009320488199591637, 0.04693800210952759, 0.020872104912996292, -0.028660520911216736, -0.0811377465724945, -0.03818966820836067, 0.007161450572311878, 0.03743763640522957, 0.013843291439116001, -0.005381144117563963, 0.016351716592907906, 0.02774459682404995, -0.043441224843263626, -0.007946386933326721, 0.08407896012067795, -0.004943137057125568, -0.02488822117447853, -0.026401294395327568, -0.037086695432662964, -0.03313231095671654, -0.0024766360875219107, 0.054651618003845215, -0.0008455725619569421, -0.010500682517886162, -0.012864000163972378, 0.018657688051462173, -0.04710424691438675, -0.003003146266564727, -0.003065371885895729, 0.053224604576826096, 0.037908852100372314, -0.005122992675751448, -0.015614761970937252, -0.005207990761846304, 0.06383071839809418, 0.05195918679237366, 0.030767055228352547, 0.022337881848216057, -0.08233461529016495, 0.004342859610915184, 0.04069953411817551, 0.04395502060651779, -0.04888593778014183, -0.020328402519226074, -0.04436519742012024, -0.016454385593533516, 0.010849195532500744, -0.06176401302218437, 0.03434455767273903, -0.04451451823115349, 0.009923979640007019, -0.024292832240462303, -0.007673032581806183, -0.017554428428411484, 0.014464545994997025, -0.03836525231599808, 0.030719466507434845, -0.029248684644699097, -0.043807871639728546, -0.010622055269777775, 0.02687828242778778, 0.01782730035483837, 0.010528775863349438, 0.013255035504698753, -0.027459636330604553, 0.02153887413442135, 0.011045485734939575, -0.03783068060874939, -0.05217037349939346, -0.010650787502527237, -0.0017621763981878757, -0.026867052540183067, 0.03827492520213127, -0.03588004410266876, -0.05242985486984253, 0.025698769837617874, 0.05452976003289223, 0.008784265257418156, -0.036454781889915466, -0.05396806821227074, 0.010199111886322498, 0.04927496984601021, -0.028457006439566612, 0.05474232882261276, 0.01493660919368267, 0.0010439279722049832, 0.03704890236258507, -0.03353157266974449, 0.007086273282766342, -0.043244145810604095, -0.07605911791324615, -0.02997574768960476, -0.01469847746193409, -0.0390954352915287, 0.013347855769097805, 0.005019986070692539, 0.028715312480926514, -0.005349332932382822, 0.04172605648636818, -0.004122693091630936, -0.0006800369592383504, 0.022501280531287193, -0.023402012884616852, -0.006781876087188721, 0.05123532563447952, -0.0028244205750524998, 0.016301190480589867, 0.031012387946248055, 0.008132138289511204, 0.014849109575152397, 0.004032091237604618, -0.017639784142374992, -0.022290227934718132, -0.027464555576443672, -0.02736370824277401, -0.026302717626094818, -0.03430982306599617, 0.029535923153162003, 0.004497998859733343, 0.04535473510622978, 0.02544775977730751, -0.04596474766731262, -0.001185329630970955, -0.015216156840324402, -0.00804391410201788, 0.0033237342722713947, -0.07758279889822006, 0.008789626881480217, -0.00196781731210649, 0.008114375174045563, -0.08633945882320404, -0.03883378580212593, 0.010175858624279499, -0.010832741856575012, 0.004884014837443829, -0.023020930588245392, -0.03866039961576462, 0.004567069932818413, 0.03674269840121269, -0.024927223101258278, 0.005730482283979654, -0.03921138495206833, 0.01568731479346752, -0.036919739097356796, 0.01079841423779726, 0.05982699617743492, 0.016279157251119614, 0.03933759406208992, 0.018201017752289772, 0.014928419142961502, -0.035697199404239655, -0.012156148441135883, -0.0056888568215072155, -0.022135253995656967, -0.027715956792235374, -0.035210248082876205, 0.018605012446641922, 0.03345369175076485, -0.018116703256964684, -0.017048027366399765, 0.00311892107129097, 0.005745916627347469, -0.0010311659425497055, -0.062442127615213394, 0.019519668072462082, 0.014415002427995205, -0.01807095669209957, -0.04238776117563248, -0.020075395703315735, -0.0019223463023081422, -0.03242054209113121, 0.04748155549168587, 0.014671307988464832, 0.02134585939347744, -0.001991632394492626, 0.08956440538167953, -0.022661292925477028, 0.014453135430812836, 0.013676394708454609, -0.013976408168673515, 0.0286648441106081, 0.010209322907030582, 0.000012275637345737778, -0.002116671297699213, 0.022169748321175575, -0.061928898096084595, -0.014433424919843674, -0.05612234026193619, -0.012662550434470177, 0.056293293833732605, -0.006142121274024248, 0.008642899803817272, 0.01984621398150921, 0.006942931562662125, 0.027076993137598038, -0.03788509964942932, 0.01415676437318325, 0.007906110025942326, 0.0534258596599102, 0.06131478771567345, 0.03760543465614319, -0.0019954282324761152, 0.01675993762910366, 0.0050500426441431046, 0.017948094755411148, 0.03127633407711983, -0.0005771545693278313, 0.024187687784433365, -0.038920387625694275, -0.040667783468961716, -0.02784728817641735, 0.005457321647554636, -0.06077723950147629, 0.06486707180738449, -0.027349870651960373, -0.006470616441220045, 0.013201883994042873, 0.017293201759457588, 0.023545674979686737, -0.007299055345356464, -0.015239519998431206, -0.05279800295829773, 0.0060770087875425816, 0.006462475750595331, -0.027117712423205376, 0.03610058128833771, -0.003261626698076725, 0.023519214242696762, -0.0022632298059761524, 0.022884324193000793, -0.0532379187643528, -0.06692325323820114, -0.019157301634550095, -0.05609671026468277, -0.06336193531751633, 0.09742703288793564, 0.010747704654932022, -0.024267666041851044, 0.009640535339713097, -0.011986855417490005, 0.003144197165966034, -0.0358414463698864, 0.03304922953248024, 0.02791871316730976, 0.05652984604239464, -0.020400941371917725, 0.011145660653710365, -0.01967977173626423, 0.018805943429470062, 0.1108977273106575, 0.04447983577847481, 0.05853458121418953, -0.06854356825351715, 0.0015693471068516374, -0.0030695530585944653, -0.0298516396433115, -0.03818601742386818, -0.0388004332780838, -0.0336846224963665, -0.023784654214978218, 0.022319026291370392, 0.02237815037369728, 0.040028613060712814, 0.010639124549925327, 0.01883029192686081, -0.02464514598250389, 0.026176076382398605, 0.008441115729510784, 0.018136335536837578, 0.020208869129419327, -0.017890535295009613, -0.034070584923028946, 0.024797899648547173, -0.015392000786960125, -0.04430285096168518, -0.022993050515651703, 0.009134030900895596, 0.03905725106596947, -0.017118794843554497, 0.004505676217377186, -0.01573137566447258, -0.012393689714372158, 0.0021151516120880842, 0.0028077971655875444, 0.010133780539035797, -0.011487266048789024, 0.009548313915729523, -0.0025717751123011112, 0.01885119639337063, 0.011392039246857166, 0.02087964490056038, -0.023271692916750908, -0.010122102685272694, -0.024871451780200005, -0.0570363774895668, -0.026084497570991516, 0.029531674459576607, 0.02382516860961914, -0.010778645984828472, 0.039747171103954315, 0.02996685914695263, 0.03420286625623703, -0.0458817183971405, -0.0015951276291161776, 0.018250243738293648, 0.040329061448574066, -0.026718026027083397, -0.0331854484975338, -0.014222405850887299, 0.04174702614545822, 0.030606508255004883, 0.004819696769118309, 0.030809126794338226, -0.01721126027405262, 0.012004133313894272, -0.04791087657213211, 0.037625234574079514, 0.019070450216531754, 0.006795718800276518, -0.011559877544641495, 0.012953490950167179, 0.017659857869148254, -0.02731970325112343, 0.04831940308213234, -0.006382847670465708, -0.011899997480213642, -0.0484127439558506, -0.029341312125325203, -0.029460113495588303, -0.03795593976974487, -0.0008811532170511782, -0.028554581105709076, -0.00866568461060524, -0.02542324736714363, -0.011907825246453285, -0.005399859044700861, 0.02621549181640148, 0.051402363926172256, 0.02981358766555786, -0.0035550042521208525, 0.02070053480565548, 0.014788771979510784, -0.026766793802380562, -0.017622698098421097, -0.007539687678217888, -0.038250166922807693, 0.057006265968084335, 0.013995850458741188, 0.04769066721200943, 0.01288971584290266, 0.03239356353878975, -0.016223035752773285, 0.0398663654923439, -0.018176527693867683, -0.03058517724275589, 0.0015199133194983006, 0.0032512336038053036, -0.006273968610912561, -0.0035595090594142675, -0.01724354736506939, -0.03305847570300102, -0.035720378160476685, -0.05998455733060837, -0.03045612946152687, 0.05874747410416603, 0.009516418911516666, -0.05706378445029259, 0.051868636161088943, 0.0001913119776872918, 0.06051037460565567, -0.04255548492074013, 0.013732673600316048, -0.02626325935125351, -0.0174226276576519, -0.03527051955461502, -0.05978386476635933, -0.025536898523569107, 0.010676654987037182, -0.020111676305532455, 0.001003654208034277, 0.020376726984977722, 0.00505113136023283, -0.004855909384787083, -0.00039138051215559244, 0.0004720305441878736, -0.033676739782094955, 0.05251215398311615, -0.038997966796159744, 0.008102883584797382, 0.0568588487803936, -0.025985494256019592, -0.01253611408174038, 0.017462316900491714, -0.013995670713484287, 0.04837590828537941, 0.0333128459751606, -0.022724129259586334, -0.013781308196485043, 0.0627075806260109, -0.004460667725652456, -0.012196347117424011, 0.007311524823307991, 0.022278975695371628, 0.023603297770023346, 0.033983658999204636, 0.02066521719098091, -0.0005407269345596433, -0.014726872555911541, 0.006828039884567261, 0.06448422372341156, 0.019615301862359047, -0.012296244502067566, 0.034503914415836334, -0.020612617954611778, 0.016829611733555794, 0.048492927104234695, -0.020984498783946037, 0.027720486745238304, 0.056174032390117645, -0.00360234547406435, -0.009182148613035679, -0.0008663924527354538, 0.030711984261870384, -0.08941364288330078, 0.006269857753068209, -0.0059860763140022755, -0.005502215586602688, 0.06721223145723343, -0.05518939718604088, 0.0015740222297608852, 0.05956639349460602, -0.05058172345161438, 0.014760644175112247, -0.013620550744235516, -0.010482155717909336, -0.03261932358145714, -0.004041540436446667, -0.01789034903049469, -0.008289921097457409, 0.021701551973819733, 0.004771040286868811, 0.05605611577630043, 0.037030696868896484, -0.013758065178990364, -0.015315466560423374, -0.03589791804552078, 0.047858018428087234, 0.031434714794158936, -0.015137541107833385, 0.005505701992660761, -0.029138287529349327, -0.01698799803853035, 0.015253705903887749, -0.03349411487579346, 0.026333222165703773, 0.06971348822116852, 0.023531164973974228, 0.011067935265600681, 0.003924550488591194, 0.04970366507768631, 0.017711365595459938, 0.054276663810014725, -0.0014438788639381528, 0.0007747366325929761, 0.014199933968484402, 0.007157028187066317, 0.053619757294654846, 0.014725293964147568, -0.004229379817843437, -0.030834708362817764, 0.002804586896672845, -0.001530685811303556, -0.01281249150633812, -0.008952341042459011, 0.026069650426506996, 0.014537551440298557, -0.08021634072065353, -0.01748250424861908, -0.023309780284762383, -0.010052220895886421, 0.030191918835043907, -0.008993517607450485, -0.02296428196132183, -0.01197616383433342, -0.032088931649923325, -0.0220112856477499, -0.013935410417616367, -0.008554495871067047, 0.007663971744477749, -0.0685310959815979, 0.00829298421740532, -0.012592806480824947, -0.03352829068899155, -0.004369787871837616, -0.004186895210295916, -0.03043953701853752, 0.07844116538763046, -0.013035869225859642, 0.03180402144789696, 0.007232592441141605, -0.01045036967843771, 0.03894038125872612, -0.1169520914554596, 0.036696452647447586, 0.004782428033649921, -0.021883325651288033, -0.008198319934308529, -0.00019906614033970982, -0.006546844728291035, 0.0273449644446373, 0.01872948370873928, 0.00970685575157404, 0.04119141772389412, -0.02849534898996353, 0.02306940034031868, 0.023654557764530182, -0.024374516680836678, 0.04606381431221962, -0.007785463705658913, 0.007132796570658684, -0.030750883743166924, -0.014651019126176834, -0.0031104683876037598, 0.030280286446213722, 0.059463873505592346, 0.034742072224617004, 0.0014133494114503264, -0.0014689955860376358, -0.0388968400657177, 0.014807031489908695, -0.026089876890182495, -0.03202177584171295, 0.031127402558922768, -0.03679441288113594, -0.03222742676734924, 0.02825610712170601, 0.001858389936387539, -0.07095257937908173, 0.0281431432813406, -0.058415092527866364, -0.019574757665395737, -0.01666325144469738, 0.03424081206321716, 0.0384715273976326, -0.07985667139291763, 0.01236457284539938, -0.005049713887274265, -0.013178556226193905, 0.004843202885240316, 0.017858115956187248, 0.031529463827610016, 0.033375415951013565, -0.03626919537782669, 0.03581288456916809, 0.005153559148311615, 0.006679879501461983, -0.005779903847724199, 0.01902943290770054, 0.015461457893252373, -0.03970741853117943, 0.03213294968008995, 0.03351740539073944, -0.020760109648108482, 0.034789763391017914, 0.007361104711890221, 0.036740951240062714, -0.02894778549671173, -0.028187952935695648, -0.0020169077906757593, 0.02463926374912262, -0.010810607112944126, -0.01973428763449192, 0.005316769704222679, 0.062008608132600784, -0.03666641190648079, -0.010490817949175835, 0.009197845123708248, -0.022320900112390518, -0.021728742867708206, 0.012824992649257183, -0.019591134041547775, 0.023204706609249115, -0.008042430505156517, 0.01853984221816063, 0.001130661810748279, -0.01959044858813286, 0.043378885835409164, 0.013539806008338928, 0.014489365741610527, -0.031475577503442764, 0.003647404722869396, 0.0010616050567477942, -0.05524502322077751, 0.01807280071079731, -0.01822056621313095, 0.024992844089865685, 0.022718768566846848, -0.029479363933205605, -0.047792162746191025, -0.011195670813322067, -0.015610955655574799, 0.009621514938771725, -0.06641209125518799, 0.001116323983296752, -0.0626809149980545, 0.010581937618553638, -0.004995451774448156, 0.0011827046982944012 ]
<p>I am very new to Bayesian inference and can't figure out what may be an elementary problem. Also, please forgive me if I am screwing up the notation -- this is my first foray into Bayesian statistics.</p> <p><strong>Set-up:</strong> At time $i=0$ I start with a random variable $X_0\sim \mathcal{N}(\mu_0,\sigma^2_0)$. Over time I observe the Brownian motion process such that for $j&gt;i$, $X_j-X_i\sim \mathcal{N}(0,(j-i)D)$. Starting at time 0, I collect a sequence of $n$ observations $\{Y_i\}_{i=0}^{n-1}$ of $\{X_i\}_{i=0}^{n-1}$, which are subject to Gaussian noise such that $p(y_i|x_i)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi N_0}}e^{-\frac{(y_i-x_i)^2}{2N_0}}$. Noise is independent from observation to observation. I am interested in the mean and variance (of the estimator) of $X_{n-1}$ given $\{Y_i\}_{i=0}^{n-1}$ in terms of $n$, $\mu_0$, $\sigma^2_0$, $D$, and $N_0$.</p> <p><strong>What I've done:</strong> Using Bayes rule and the properties of Gaussian distribution, I've found that for the first observation ($n=0$):</p> <p>$$p(x_0|y_0)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi S}}e^{-\frac{(x_0-M)^2}{2S}}$$</p> <p>where $M=\frac{y_0\sigma^2_0+\mu_0N_0}{\sigma^2_0+N_0}$ and $S=\frac{\sigma^2_0N_0}{\sigma^2_0+N_0}$. I am not completely sure if the above is correct, but I am pretty confident that it is, as it looks like the mean squared error of the estimate of $X_0$ has decreased with the observation. However, I am having trouble extending this to $n&gt;0$ and would appreciate any guidance.</p> <p><strong>EDIT:</strong> I've misspecified the Brownian motion process. I think it's correct now.</p>
48,959
[ -0.014657430350780487, -0.031789056956768036, 0.021749624982476234, -0.04060825705528259, 0.03306388109922409, 0.022970395162701607, 0.003294043941423297, -0.04623913764953613, 0.00569293275475502, -0.08663434535264969, 0.0526341013610363, 0.0688079297542572, 0.043418604880571365, 0.03931479528546333, 0.025941302999854088, 0.03266157582402229, -0.01995244063436985, -0.00436451705172658, -0.04233269393444061, -0.028424615040421486, 0.0019803401082754135, 0.057792987674474716, 0.02864220179617405, -0.004880968946963549, -0.08908635377883911, 0.019177256152033806, -0.00800966378301382, -0.0038141030818223953, -0.02561207301914692, 0.09671498090028763, -0.03179875761270523, -0.02483231946825981, 0.012829318642616272, 0.024479815736413002, -0.0053033242002129555, -0.019018910825252533, -0.0038596070371568203, -0.03964455425739288, 0.009281647391617298, 0.039277028292417526, -0.01400708593428135, -0.029354261234402657, -0.006136883515864611, 0.01923801563680172, -0.030548593029379845, 0.00998168345540762, 0.0190584659576416, -0.05283787474036217, 0.04701413959264755, -0.033257268369197845, 0.0834793895483017, -0.0016839487943798304, 0.03223429247736931, 0.029081232845783234, 0.012070328928530216, -0.014986804686486721, 0.0460343100130558, 0.05420207604765892, -0.008380936458706856, -0.044111218303442, -0.030175847932696342, -0.026918914169073105, 0.009001461789011955, -0.0404396578669548, -0.007170329801738262, -0.007211184129118919, -0.01891104318201542, -0.03763654828071594, 0.005906770937144756, -0.008074031211435795, 0.04326670244336128, -0.011542754247784615, 0.019343256950378418, 0.009083232842385769, -0.003701323876157403, -0.0023639712017029524, -0.00974045880138874, 0.03925072029232979, 0.0048087527975440025, 0.021790558472275734, 0.024054542183876038, -0.007810002658516169, 0.0022809114307165146, 0.04424441605806351, -0.010230988264083862, -0.024756986647844315, 0.09026508778333664, -0.03427717834711075, 0.03324589505791664, 0.0015835744561627507, -0.029935622587800026, 0.011448400095105171, 0.06482937932014465, -0.04925508797168732, -0.036738403141498566, 0.041511766612529755, -0.015894154086709023, 0.0308303851634264, -0.011128603480756283, -0.0042439596727490425, -0.009396971203386784, -0.06128402799367905, 0.02025548927485943, 0.045533061027526855, -0.04158932343125343, -0.007368433754891157, 0.02287069521844387, 0.023746496066451073, -0.040826886892318726, -0.068180151283741, -0.0325227752327919, 0.052220214158296585, 0.011757345870137215, -0.002355913631618023, 0.01253711711615324, -0.00036222385824657977, -0.01001653540879488, -0.01197708398103714, 0.013059590011835098, 0.05902169272303581, 0.03232666105031967, -0.010426734574139118, 0.011442858725786209, -0.02135368622839451, -0.06701895594596863, 0.014004794880747795, 0.0050006769597530365, -0.010689567774534225, -0.05249418690800667, 0.0513378269970417, 0.016168778762221336, 0.014424379914999008, 0.05950664356350899, 0.014955826103687286, 0.03317522257566452, 0.003234313102439046, -0.07424658536911011, -0.031132452189922333, 0.06642191857099533, -0.04481742903590202, 0.02234312705695629, -0.10095234960317612, -0.0011073397472500801, 0.05337256193161011, 0.01907976344227791, -0.03777075558900833, 0.04852733388543129, 0.03555218130350113, 0.03439396247267723, 0.007879991084337234, -0.04297655075788498, -0.0609687976539135, -0.019109360873699188, -0.03829756751656532, -0.003254916286095977, -0.04978042095899582, 0.026505397632718086, 0.028063535690307617, -0.03984484821557999, -0.029991960152983665, 0.05616588890552521, 0.026017891243100166, 0.00907193124294281, 0.0061288634315133095, 0.016756873577833176, -0.0422021821141243, 0.08194730430841446, 0.05421824008226395, 0.019680175930261612, 0.038438830524683, 0.008161578327417374, 0.02406780607998371, -0.012352913618087769, 0.040021371096372604, 0.02836192399263382, -0.06533073633909225, -0.041811421513557434, 0.004718199372291565, -0.003082220908254385, 0.037540845572948456, -0.0223680529743433, 0.029257236048579216, -0.03471803292632103, -0.008150453679263592, 0.0017914916388690472, 0.025120826438069344, 0.020028283819556236, 0.025745010003447533, -0.02752411738038063, -0.05849408730864525, -0.03463349863886833, -0.058111272752285004, -0.031159766018390656, -0.00019167031859979033, -0.027504481375217438, 0.01604316011071205, -0.027393659576773643, 0.02210746891796589, -0.016014069318771362, -0.027153518050909042, -0.012459496036171913, -0.005967648699879646, 0.01673879288136959, -0.03187256306409836, 0.045001182705163956, 0.0677153468132019, 0.04473821446299553, 0.026513703167438507, 0.020034747198224068, -0.03205465152859688, -0.005371009465306997, -0.020340869203209877, -0.02194291539490223, -0.004184787627309561, 0.021010516211390495, 0.00664851488545537, 0.028515515848994255, -0.056264787912368774, 0.015612279996275902, -0.01950269751250744, -0.061555564403533936, 0.05009477585554123, 0.040852367877960205, -0.015425004996359348, -0.013002648018300533, 0.008910460397601128, 0.01989910379052162, 0.006293958518654108, -0.030277948826551437, 0.013653984293341637, -0.05205567926168442, 0.011021975427865982, 0.01886969618499279, 0.08803211152553558, -0.029149247333407402, 0.007030067965388298, 0.041575003415346146, 0.010192899033427238, 0.0011231009848415852, 0.014256211929023266, -0.003988281358033419, -0.03853784129023552, 0.04364650696516037, -0.017765259370207787, -0.01791536621749401, 0.03447536751627922, 0.019577858969569206, 0.018094951286911964, 0.02614743262529373, -0.021298229694366455, -0.02527490444481373, 0.01636635884642601, -0.011907713487744331, 0.033472757786512375, -0.03059353679418564, -0.02747165970504284, -0.0011172249214723706, -0.006935231387615204, -0.0183775182813406, 0.03662296384572983, -0.010363120585680008, -0.01589251682162285, -0.03483129292726517, 0.0034020026214420795, 0.032213810831308365, 0.004444857127964497, -0.015637699514627457, 0.005129332188516855, 0.006254738196730614, -0.00992452073842287, 0.0009298493387177587, 0.027335917577147484, -0.023439502343535423, 0.00902100745588541, 0.011188268661499023, -0.001192544586956501, 0.012258215807378292, -0.0007825630600564182, -0.043738484382629395, -0.032389990985393524, -0.012263023294508457, 0.02226334810256958, 0.03984566777944565, 0.026348719373345375, -0.04531088471412659, -0.03311147913336754, -0.022786451503634453, 0.026830773800611496, 0.027500592172145844, -0.000013259655133879278, 0.01435938011854887, 0.03815857693552971, 0.002468772931024432, -0.049979258328676224, -0.025487881153821945, -0.00989378709346056, -0.01184284407645464, -0.019167572259902954, -0.034007009118795395, 0.03790290653705597, 0.02511436492204666, -0.005561143159866333, 0.04961562901735306, -0.06292711943387985, -0.042806994169950485, -0.04934723302721977, 0.002267393283545971, 0.025908127427101135, -0.016280993819236755, 0.05261716991662979, 0.033999379724264145, 0.008601224049925804, 0.010602947324514389, -0.0374135822057724, -0.07236050069332123, 0.03219541162252426, -0.001977372681722045, -0.002633738098666072, -0.011095135472714901, -0.028500674292445183, 0.08309577405452728, 0.0026718350127339363, -0.0037600311916321516, 0.016042957082390785, 0.026512810960412025, -0.019744563847780228, -0.024893147870898247, -0.0025057196617126465, 0.022468501701951027, -0.025008725002408028, 0.030176794156432152, -0.003303962294012308, -0.010191510431468487, 0.039378054440021515, -0.019063090905547142, 0.00953723955899477, -0.01678144372999668, -0.027134956791996956, 0.031068341806530952, 0.05457494407892227, 0.01809086836874485, 0.02436889335513115, 0.007695665583014488, 0.013146399520337582, 0.02579323574900627, 0.027219286188483238, -0.038529109209775925, 0.042139336466789246, -0.04025278612971306, -0.01258139405399561, -0.04085169732570648, 0.05648132786154747, 0.004262222908437252, -0.03139225021004677, -0.011572026647627354, -0.0537382997572422, 0.023438697680830956, 0.007061016745865345, 0.010350433178246021, 0.0794876292347908, 0.022076375782489777, 0.037050411105155945, -0.04120337590575218, -0.0484497956931591, -0.012913303449749947, 0.010700253769755363, -0.01660669408738613, -0.0139077827334404, -0.008710360154509544, 0.008813302963972092, 0.013840239495038986, -0.04218660667538643, -0.00900519173592329, -0.021641111001372337, -0.03625481203198433, 0.019939569756388664, -0.02498597651720047, 0.03597337380051613, -0.008407287299633026, 0.05420282110571861, -0.001696277060545981, -0.0362827405333519, 0.009684446267783642, -0.003165651112794876, -0.04683249071240425, -0.004391524009406567, -0.03075099177658558, -0.03508615121245384, -0.018084796145558357, -0.001759675913490355, 0.06188798323273659, -0.02697226032614708, 0.06387442350387573, 0.010955768637359142, 0.036005958914756775, -0.03984646499156952, -0.00738487346097827, -0.05868766829371452, -0.0005470294272527099, -0.027332892641425133, 0.04620010778307915, 0.02287581004202366, -0.028217094019055367, 0.009630726650357246, 0.02140715718269348, 0.008849808014929295, 0.0004207478486932814, -0.0068044355139136314, 0.00299523351714015, 0.02875266782939434, 0.016761628910899162, 0.026894545182585716, 0.02287772111594677, -0.022153295576572418, 0.0255456380546093, 0.00814854260534048, 0.0304845180362463, 0.07211770117282867, -0.0033005671575665474, -0.00012077178689651191, -0.025473708286881447, 0.009044933132827282, 0.02129989117383957, 0.039029572159051895, 0.015365158207714558, 0.0010123744141310453, 0.06185848265886307, 0.006306447088718414, -0.041140105575323105, 0.03265567496418953, 0.042732127010822296, 0.006820232607424259, 0.03619329631328583, -0.036494091153144836, -0.009212125092744827, -0.02932194247841835, 0.037487633526325226, -0.000042603925976436585, -0.008649497292935848, -0.022399945184588432, -0.021230423822999, 0.053319595754146576, 0.020498225465416908, -0.01099864300340414, -0.015293571166694164, 0.031014475971460342, 0.050026778131723404, 0.07147638499736786, 0.009189842268824577, 0.017883526161313057, 0.019692126661539078, 0.009759427979588509, 0.006234724540263414, -0.0051039159297943115, -0.041293833404779434, -0.02364061027765274, 0.0011566720204427838, 0.04204045608639717, -0.007865674793720245, 0.025822199881076813, -0.05949053540825844, -0.025572462007403374, 0.03270076960325241, -0.012273564003407955, 0.01678631640970707, -0.03912585973739624, -0.008862161077558994, 0.02294175699353218, -0.04479397460818291, -0.062069375067949295, -0.006181011907756329, -0.009490983560681343, 0.027525123208761215, -0.037910640239715576, -0.014561387710273266, -0.047990623861551285, -0.024759521707892418, 0.0070719970390200615, 0.06859144568443298, -0.04791542887687683, -0.007132495753467083, 0.0010943012312054634, 0.03529391810297966, 0.0003059324517380446, -0.060031868517398834, 0.056994758546352386, -0.0118784224614501, -0.010561386123299599, 0.03818903863430023, -0.04041392728686333, -0.040588442236185074, 0.03707515448331833, 0.010846181772649288, -0.035903092473745346, 0.01156662032008171, 0.006224321201443672, 0.030268141999840736, 0.020135261118412018, 0.009335274808108807, 0.07631275057792664, 0.007800744380801916, 0.021156087517738342, 0.0020445450209081173, -0.0308429766446352, 0.026951434090733528, -0.05724442005157471, -0.0069677866995334625, -0.044775497168302536, -0.022720254957675934, -0.007155990693718195, 0.06059177219867706, -0.005169779993593693, 0.04238741472363472, -0.02949093095958233, -0.027560049667954445, 0.04974491149187088, 0.039291974157094955, 0.007521397899836302, 0.010888724587857723, -0.027936004102230072, 0.027684291824698448, 0.019549518823623657, -0.019031116738915443, 0.01212386041879654, -0.020557906478643417, 0.005865324288606644, 0.019596120342612267, -0.03226405382156372, -0.00813133455812931, -0.026510020717978477, -0.043157607316970825, 0.013053993694484234, -0.040979430079460144, 0.04107736423611641, 0.0024667836260050535, 0.026684945449233055, 0.028260009363293648, -0.04480833560228348, -0.012606607750058174, -0.013956072740256786, 0.001884743687696755, 0.009076502174139023, -0.024004360660910606, -0.025148389860987663, 0.036465540528297424, 0.01012105867266655, -0.08353141695261002, -0.027556389570236206, 0.007241690997034311, -0.01903289556503296, -0.0022854714188724756, -0.030614333227276802, 0.008722260594367981, 0.015752440318465233, -0.036392562091350555, -0.021140081807971, 0.026187172159552574, 0.00740062166005373, -0.025995666161179543, 0.012298429384827614, 0.02532031573355198, 0.06545199453830719, -0.0368431881070137, -0.023286234587430954, 0.023133564740419388, -0.03203197941184044, -0.03672375902533531, -0.01084566954523325, 0.031854864209890366, 0.003933903761208057, 0.016934936866164207, -0.012886187061667442, -0.011939076706767082, 0.0064033158123493195, -0.05503419041633606, -0.034746237099170685, 0.02487069182097912, 0.021507803350687027, -0.003502301638945937, -0.0026010386645793915, -0.054531924426555634, -0.021347245201468468, -0.010858309455215931, 0.0038297728169709444, -0.021572459489107132, 0.005281153600662947, -0.010200812481343746, 0.030517354607582092, -0.004581562243402004, -0.005253127310425043, 0.04198629409074783, 0.02715388685464859, -0.0024423892609775066, -0.039186395704746246, 0.009082654491066933, 0.005514347460120916, 0.008192764595150948, 0.04218940809369087, 0.007241225801408291, 0.0050331903621554375, -0.025973476469516754, -0.04822893813252449, -0.014723341912031174, -0.059960417449474335, -0.00860357005149126, 0.09848302602767944, 0.00027858911198563874, 0.034689437597990036, -0.0022991462610661983, 0.01001864206045866, 0.012585158459842205, -0.03206922486424446, 0.0010261726565659046, 0.007290213368833065, -0.026306942105293274, 0.009211578406393528, -0.015465958043932915, -0.023599445819854736, 0.03466266393661499, -0.013647989369928837, 0.01961989514529705, 0.025058090686798096, 0.013541343621909618, 0.03672081604599953, 0.01835644245147705, -0.06154695898294449, -0.03426678106188774, 0.05240708962082863, -0.041888974606990814, 0.02569141983985901, -0.040581028908491135, -0.022201931104063988, 0.028874365612864494, 0.053759753704071045, 0.007761836051940918, -0.019354479387402534, -0.001629065489396453, -0.037223346531391144, -0.018634388223290443, 0.040691446512937546, -0.013589534908533096, 0.06317877024412155, 0.010183104313910007, 0.03005211055278778, -0.0224099550396204, 0.04422084987163544, -0.02461967058479786, -0.0762760117650032, -0.03291059657931328, -0.00007204639405244961, -0.020647743716835976, 0.07387697696685791, -0.014719583094120026, -0.01908617839217186, 0.004448347259312868, -0.015879666432738304, 0.035268113017082214, 0.009428591467440128, 0.021255366504192352, -0.04382467642426491, 0.06381522864103317, 0.020573753863573074, 0.025819415226578712, -0.0497400127351284, -0.010999027639627457, 0.11575200408697128, 0.04280877485871315, 0.02191227860748768, -0.0314331129193306, -0.03008701279759407, -0.014859812334179878, 0.002482837997376919, -0.019946856424212456, 0.029818357899785042, 0.06070055440068245, -0.02581370621919632, -0.006189596839249134, 0.047527968883514404, 0.019151270389556885, -0.03280404210090637, 0.022112801671028137, -0.01748226210474968, -0.01738758385181427, -0.00752886850386858, 0.019534563645720482, -0.004892812576144934, 0.015500909648835659, -0.022926270961761475, 0.0443824902176857, -0.03208424523472786, -0.0392046757042408, -0.004588256124407053, 0.0136522576212883, -0.034294214099645615, -0.0015483301831409335, -0.014753445982933044, 0.00847344845533371, 0.0007436479208990932, -0.051828086376190186, -0.005767934489995241, -0.009817610494792461, 0.0017515997169539332, -0.01594156213104725, 0.015984976664185524, 0.02853250503540039, -0.007361076772212982, 0.01762816123664379, 0.04011097177863121, -0.03787992149591446, -0.03361526131629944, -0.07612447440624237, -0.021359017118811607, 0.07163956761360168, 0.005021045450121164, -0.013054654002189636, -0.011164025403559208, 0.0006516691064462066, 0.012528443709015846, -0.07054158300161362, 0.019061585888266563, 0.027619529515504837, 0.030723899602890015, -0.04724773019552231, -0.033047597855329514, 0.004000383894890547, 0.029432347044348717, -0.017119720578193665, 0.01759360358119011, 0.04462336376309395, -0.0244445838034153, -0.08937006443738937, -0.01249553170055151, 0.014956719242036343, 0.015253995545208454, 0.014307846315205097, 0.012133913114666939, -0.018480336293578148, -0.015869908034801483, -0.009657482616603374, 0.015865961089730263, -0.043366916477680206, 0.029443874955177307, -0.0026625385507941246, -0.031666237860918045, 0.0032639463897794485, -0.03043777123093605, 0.015427032485604286, -0.04192619398236275, -0.0016223363345488906, -0.020525775849819183, -0.03168165683746338, 0.05588283762335777, 0.02536211721599102, 0.012493996880948544, 0.025546519085764885, 0.004269542172551155, 0.05866329371929169, 0.01895992085337639, -0.047094788402318954, -0.015358767472207546, 0.02019982412457466, -0.0029642763547599316, -0.017441853880882263, -0.009722821414470673, 0.04973544552922249, 0.02884626016020775, 0.047081951051950455, 0.011763186194002628, 0.043241482228040695, -0.031000971794128418, 0.00954627525061369, -0.0005515401135198772, -0.04397843778133392, 0.005323715973645449, 0.026131147518754005, 0.015134856104850769, -0.015306858345866203, -0.012411219999194145, -0.01672196201980114, 0.005223485175520182, -0.031749311834573746, 0.0028183525428175926, -0.051148876547813416, -0.004018133506178856, -0.01804012432694435, -0.010478060692548752, -0.004978789482265711, 0.003181519452482462, 0.03290848806500435, 0.015339949168264866, -0.03335459902882576, 0.03235679864883423, -0.02311747707426548, 0.02160739339888096, -0.002485483419150114, -0.028586775064468384, 0.027870913967490196, 0.018529092893004417, 0.023401500657200813, -0.03324358910322189, 0.03186680004000664, -0.04352493956685066, 0.03445255756378174, 0.006126988213509321, -0.010924615897238255, 0.023635677993297577, -0.05648272857069969, -0.03721846640110016, 0.05040217190980911, 0.04337050020694733, 0.03149700537323952, -0.0005618217401206493, -0.009474720805883408, -0.034458283334970474, 0.02204076386988163, -0.045033518224954605, -0.0005478732055053115, -0.03168777376413345, -0.010742253623902798, -0.02175014652311802, -0.019184742122888565, 0.03565369173884392, 0.012325253337621689, 0.022460343316197395, 0.02830588072538376, -0.0021459420677274466, -0.009541954845190048, -0.0005379760405048728, 0.02112765423953533, -0.030753491446375847, -0.001392751233652234, -0.00885586254298687, 0.014123523607850075, 0.02003105729818344, 0.0353209562599659, -0.00524278124794364, 0.029286613687872887, -0.025053944438695908, -0.0025258196983486414, -0.07526537030935287, 0.020483210682868958, 0.01692599430680275, 0.05754297971725464, 0.0809967964887619, -0.02703901194036007, -0.01813889481127262, 0.05486515536904335, -0.02261950820684433, -0.021683884784579277, -0.0015159603208303452, -0.0065689836628735065, -0.005811536684632301, -0.010562912560999393, -0.00006313305493677035, 0.025544529780745506, 0.01410409901291132, 0.04219501465559006, 0.055400483310222626, 0.06819874793291092, -0.013732741586863995, -0.025367772206664085, 0.0021422214340418577, 0.026576297357678413, 0.033538080751895905, -0.01599154621362686, 0.029157334938645363, -0.022498218342661858, 0.0035082735121250153, 0.04312263801693916, 0.032202281057834625, 0.0190250426530838, -0.034599900245666504, 0.024059303104877472, 0.01494275126606226, 0.012116472236812115, 0.006889949087053537, 0.0019378705183044076, 0.04625190794467926, -0.014198468066751957, 0.02123699150979519, 0.012273038737475872, -0.010248047299683094, -0.041420210152864456, 0.020337151363492012, 0.0032261302694678307, -0.038517046719789505, 0.01848856545984745, 0.0003147087409161031, -0.023406947031617165, 0.04025197774171829, 0.03153609111905098, 0.002072924980893731, -0.031979192048311234, 0.04087914153933525, -0.02786766178905964, 0.006257047411054373, 0.0483928881585598, 0.05510301887989044, -0.033293403685092926, -0.006615668069571257, 0.01621543988585472, -0.0560549721121788, 0.052789732813835144, -0.006706370040774345, -0.013313164934515953, -0.06385943293571472, -0.020517714321613312, -0.00491523090749979, 0.0032477800268679857, -0.011472169309854507, -0.008658616803586483, -0.044352270662784576, 0.030066853389143944, 0.02106926403939724, -0.005370175000280142, -0.015326500870287418, -0.009557068347930908, -0.022780001163482666, -0.061188165098428726, 0.05540535971522331, -0.0019932107534259558, -0.02278372086584568, -0.008064900524914265, 0.011544842272996902, -0.016670675948262215, 0.0075683691538870335, 0.03772389888763428, 0.02662406675517559, 0.010799582116305828, 0.04307946190237999, 0.025318151339888573, 0.002392177004367113, -0.06531228125095367, 0.03415396809577942, -0.01765231043100357, -0.006563226692378521, -0.034382473677396774, -0.011862445622682571, 0.003998579923063517, 0.036423008888959885, 0.011711124330759048, 0.005711300298571587, 0.027188332751393318, 0.00359421712346375, 0.020231543108820915, 0.01910257525742054, -0.014141357503831387, -0.02122943475842476, 0.03267078101634979, -0.029334556311368942, -0.003139067441225052, 0.050341930240392685, -0.0157158263027668, -0.0751628503203392, -0.01386868953704834, 0.011063008569180965, -0.03478445112705231, 0.015648607164621353, 0.005070503335446119, 0.003511914750561118, -0.03616074472665787, -0.013664891943335533, 0.03874567896127701, -0.05645983666181564, -0.005728967487812042, 0.04773185774683952, 0.014602579176425934, 0.03284227102994919, 0.01092721801251173, 0.022307176142930984, 0.019984392449259758, 0.00465809553861618, 0.03616221994161606, 0.013288820162415504, 0.02159268409013748, -0.027021486312150955, 0.04883311688899994, 0.02235986478626728, -0.004497911315411329, 0.0030623723287135363, -0.018632246181368828, 0.027644921094179153, -0.002675681607797742, 0.002511778147891164, 0.011993663385510445, -0.02341189794242382, -0.045510001480579376, -0.018541956320405006, -0.01209498755633831, 0.03745212405920029, -0.028276676312088966, -0.00863663014024496, 0.010843992233276367, 0.0038568240124732256, -0.0030742399394512177, -0.015564239583909512, -0.01724848710000515, 0.0003982494818046689, -0.0013956815237179399, 0.01785195805132389, -0.016532834619283676, -0.008442350663244724, 0.012379022315144539, -0.058060623705387115, 0.012233143672347069, 0.036674950271844864, 0.01718202792108059, -0.016133155673742294, -0.02224939689040184, -0.028928520157933235, -0.03695942088961601, 0.017673907801508904, 0.025074932724237442, -0.006363690365105867, -0.043738752603530884, -0.024286314845085144, -0.01049452181905508, 0.044618699699640274, -0.046490591019392014, 0.015349010936915874, -0.013048358261585236, -0.011074373498558998, -0.03324766829609871, -0.041097793728113174 ]