question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
int64
0
74.5k
sentence_embeddings
sequencelengths
1.02k
1.02k
<p>I am having some confusion relating to cross-validated deviance of a lasso fit. I am not sure what is being done. </p> <p>Let's say I run lassoglm in Matlab for my dataset having 1000 examples and 15 features with a CV of let's say 100. What does it do?</p> <p>And what does the plot lassoPlot with CV do? </p> <p>I am referring to <a href="http://www.mathworks.com/help/stats/lasso-regularization-of-generalized-linear-models.html#btcoa3h" rel="nofollow">this link</a> </p> <p>I didn't understand what "deviance" means. Can anyone explain, please? </p>
74,237
[ -0.03516701981425285, 0.024868089705705643, 0.017129020765423775, -0.04168856516480446, 0.018142646178603172, 0.01866932213306427, -0.035768501460552216, -0.009926910512149334, 0.07244802266359329, -0.025407150387763977, 0.033324360847473145, 0.022220183163881302, 0.0697004571557045, -0.0091998977586627, 0.002861290704458952, 0.010808016173541546, -0.02047218568623066, -0.0133809270337224, 0.020628875121474266, 0.01098160445690155, 0.01688579097390175, 0.020930703729391098, 0.02124522626399994, -0.008818615227937698, 0.0010389667004346848, 0.050853487104177475, 0.015967143699526787, 0.01755293644964695, 0.01785353571176529, 0.03422534465789795, -0.06995727866888046, -0.03855861350893974, 0.009222645312547684, 0.010639790445566177, -0.005820560734719038, 0.02450227364897728, 0.0002984671446029097, -0.0208863727748394, -0.010177758522331715, 0.061561692506074905, 0.005641313269734383, -0.03454207256436348, 0.000057217574067180976, 0.09052500873804092, -0.02999160625040531, 0.013221947476267815, 0.010705718770623207, -0.05825405567884445, 0.0568825863301754, -0.022273311391472816, 0.07791844010353088, -0.011630699038505554, 0.03570539131760597, 0.019920147955417633, -0.014101020060479641, 0.04916434362530708, 0.048781245946884155, 0.04660627618432045, -0.018579579889774323, -0.0657905638217926, -0.004923957400023937, -0.0682908147573471, 0.021214962005615234, -0.03322678431868553, -0.0056279306299984455, 0.0443338118493557, 0.005053857807070017, -0.006984506268054247, 0.014054627157747746, -0.020710628479719162, -0.002328313887119293, 0.03701356425881386, 0.0012527763610705733, -0.034927528351545334, 0.033177513629198074, -0.02229282259941101, -0.021253101527690887, 0.013663077726960182, 0.040193211287260056, 0.030951453372836113, 0.030867625027894974, 0.03242989256978035, -0.022331494837999344, 0.017548905685544014, 0.002415951807051897, -0.008052600547671318, 0.0806790292263031, -0.036195091903209686, 0.04597155377268791, 0.00470764609053731, -0.0006574892904609442, 0.034408461302518845, 0.04070492088794708, 0.026953553780913353, -0.02356945164501667, 0.026150820776820183, -0.01682729832828045, 0.02295776829123497, -0.006068109069019556, -0.01723174937069416, 0.0007846818771213293, -0.016872217878699303, 0.0009768604068085551, 0.03648512065410614, -0.019160032272338867, 0.002835341729223728, -0.015573316253721714, -0.014613843522965908, -0.02564935013651848, -0.03636132553219795, -0.05390549078583717, 0.022996608167886734, 0.014900604262948036, 0.004920287523418665, 0.03185437247157097, 0.014166860841214657, -0.0021382656414061785, -0.004083022475242615, 0.03084898367524147, 0.042557667940855026, 0.012717465870082378, -0.022579284384846687, 0.043673161417245865, -0.020806772634387016, -0.04624203220009804, 0.000727784470655024, 0.028940115123987198, 0.006731817964464426, -0.010932615026831627, 0.07589957118034363, -0.046575017273426056, -0.05559425801038742, 0.04025253280997276, -0.00004301380613469519, -0.013611108995974064, -0.015677597373723984, -0.10197484493255615, -0.06050863489508629, 0.02074391394853592, 0.010663452558219433, 0.008638567291200161, -0.06973335146903992, -0.023124737665057182, -0.005477060563862324, 0.07747963815927505, 0.012400614097714424, 0.040599796921014786, 0.033569931983947754, -0.006513971369713545, -0.03270022198557854, -0.010105687193572521, -0.02686328813433647, -0.01678497903048992, 0.015439498238265514, -0.034906357526779175, -0.05948704481124878, -0.019490377977490425, 0.01950066164135933, 0.0005306854145601392, 0.0045364852994680405, 0.0035136286169290543, -0.00567045109346509, -0.025521207600831985, 0.015652239322662354, -0.01081919390708208, 0.0034651446621865034, 0.08683178573846817, 0.024729248136281967, 0.011529646813869476, 0.04692290350794792, -0.03420759364962578, -0.022246718406677246, 0.017737476155161858, 0.04605767875909805, 0.018868422135710716, 0.034970127046108246, 0.012546083889901638, -0.04615272209048271, 0.05371038615703583, 0.0075036101043224335, -0.045590125024318695, -0.009144697338342667, -0.0024087876081466675, 0.00953089538961649, 0.019434040412306786, 0.04199937731027603, -0.028776489198207855, -0.006774525158107281, 0.04950692504644394, -0.056040480732917786, -0.03210211172699928, -0.04847969859838486, 0.024544352665543556, 0.00046095490688458085, -0.017013156786561012, 0.02409975789487362, 0.01509727630764246, 0.042301565408706665, -0.026337075978517532, 0.014023645780980587, -0.011402450501918793, -0.009964614175260067, -0.012155645526945591, -0.01152624562382698, 0.009163791313767433, 0.025973325595259666, 0.019410407170653343, -0.01213850174099207, 0.050938744097948074, -0.05033140629529953, -0.035989437252283096, 0.02974238060414791, -0.03746805340051651, 0.0023882228415459394, -0.03416670486330986, -0.02677016146481037, -0.020029572769999504, -0.0005569475470110774, -0.026397814974188805, 0.018776793032884598, -0.010643523186445236, 0.046753011643886566, 0.061887118965387344, 0.011324168182909489, 0.029359616339206696, -0.010100324638187885, 0.016643408685922623, 0.0039054725784808397, -0.05539723113179207, -0.020147500559687614, -0.028623711317777634, -0.03272528573870659, 0.04785534366965294, 0.024931713938713074, -0.008731286972761154, -0.00615308154374361, 0.07645943760871887, 0.02153867855668068, 0.019613485783338547, 0.014059970155358315, -0.01921284757554531, -0.010121370665729046, 0.006046193651854992, 0.024821612983942032, 0.02592471055686474, -0.0019097535405308008, -0.017684537917375565, 0.0038401701021939516, 0.03830531984567642, 0.0036241188645362854, -0.01580829918384552, 0.0782894492149353, -0.033567193895578384, -0.017581406980752945, -0.003850713837891817, 0.007949608378112316, 0.020968640223145485, 0.01989162713289261, -0.004863501992076635, 0.0650746300816536, 0.006127358879894018, 0.015568112954497337, 0.004165496677160263, -0.03127370402216911, 0.03510638326406479, 0.05075892433524132, -0.020416410639882088, 0.021359402686357498, 0.013535321690142155, -0.044812921434640884, 0.03380966931581497, -0.013696348294615746, -0.01759052835404873, -0.06859997659921646, 0.012024201452732086, 0.04170677810907364, 0.016179149970412254, 0.03339150920510292, -0.04108327999711037, -0.07164820283651352, 0.008460283279418945, -0.024423278868198395, 0.026383623480796814, 0.0009307260042987764, -0.02441079169511795, 0.016319051384925842, -0.010937424376606941, 0.009977413341403008, 0.03692011535167694, 0.024656441062688828, -0.006154694594442844, 0.025631243363022804, -0.02652318775653839, -0.05066931992769241, -0.058395467698574066, -0.027468983083963394, 0.037478480488061905, 0.013772021047770977, -0.013880226761102676, 0.05087268352508545, 0.005405754782259464, -0.029322007670998573, 0.03248027712106705, -0.012769713997840881, 0.007709885481745005, -0.020165005698800087, -0.010455495677888393, 0.012891707010567188, 0.013150034472346306, 0.023848772048950195, 0.02355268970131874, -0.04703894630074501, 0.020525235682725906, -0.04552752897143364, -0.04137514904141426, 0.03213735669851303, -0.023126713931560516, -0.029016023501753807, 0.0021763062104582787, -0.035569678992033005, 0.07260343432426453, 0.021547380834817886, -0.011451107449829578, -0.06932895630598068, -0.02283560484647751, -0.020593609660863876, -0.03993593156337738, 0.0021810277830809355, 0.004139373078942299, 0.0196829941123724, 0.04833817854523659, -0.011790766380727291, 0.04447740688920021, 0.04704280197620392, -0.013915607705712318, -0.014017448760569096, 0.0271306149661541, -0.0003713341138791293, -0.007761954329907894, 0.02660650573670864, 0.02563522942364216, -0.029220562428236008, 0.011115559376776218, 0.0016087522963061929, 0.044232260435819626, 0.0018662423826754093, -0.045771997421979904, -0.014871726743876934, -0.00971155147999525, 0.03446141630411148, -0.021358532831072807, 0.028534958139061928, -0.01776651293039322, -0.03937465324997902, 0.013967722654342651, 0.010782979428768158, 0.05130104348063469, -0.039595820009708405, 0.0010854325955733657, 0.009282593615353107, 0.01642024703323841, -0.002309964271262288, -0.015754172578454018, -0.012216801755130291, 0.009016573429107666, 0.009145976044237614, -0.034073978662490845, -0.018875638023018837, 0.03275390341877937, 0.030054394155740738, -0.007897267118096352, -0.012421944178640842, -0.06287796795368195, 0.044027768075466156, -0.03632369637489319, 0.0011234697885811329, 0.003698920365422964, 0.00855867937207222, -0.0075101088732481, 0.027933117002248764, 0.0328022763133049, 0.006165746133774519, 0.008396144025027752, -0.029936516657471657, -0.054418597370386124, 0.027794957160949707, -0.002641192404553294, -0.0009497720166109502, -0.014261211268603802, -0.0059683783911168575, 0.056466661393642426, -0.009744045324623585, 0.017381712794303894, 0.023726152256131172, 0.0395183302462101, -0.06303311884403229, 0.029308095574378967, -0.0024819299578666687, 0.0029074568301439285, -0.04273191839456558, -0.009129748679697514, 0.04986990988254547, -0.015161004848778248, 0.02581431157886982, 0.007876827381551266, -0.033992379903793335, -0.019237780943512917, -0.021329224109649658, 0.01573803834617138, 0.03539823368191719, 0.03327670320868492, 0.037290338426828384, 0.010853453539311886, -0.05476854369044304, 0.03602694347500801, 0.01551147922873497, 0.059901244938373566, 0.04220001772046089, 0.0138780502602458, -0.02427876554429531, -0.045922860503196716, -0.022827446460723877, -0.03261789679527283, 0.006372781936079264, 0.014165842905640602, 0.03770875185728073, 0.01330493576824665, 0.03632879629731178, -0.04567921161651611, 0.004880551248788834, 0.05639692023396492, 0.002360951853916049, -0.0193477813154459, -0.02947269007563591, -0.02408996783196926, -0.003706434043124318, -0.017387427389621735, 0.03518374264240265, -0.015458393841981888, -0.005762350745499134, 0.013375790789723396, 0.06529302150011063, -0.05052350461483002, -0.027330581098794937, -0.03860042244195938, 0.05408569425344467, 0.05650240555405617, -0.02270689234137535, -0.03701040893793106, 0.01126311905682087, 0.029016664251685143, 0.05364000424742699, 0.030690092593431473, 0.005441858898848295, -0.08356377482414246, -0.011716028675436974, 0.037089753895998, 0.03510278835892677, -0.03107421286404133, -0.043074607849121094, -0.04383859783411026, 0.0020446383859962225, 0.04148590564727783, -0.04070641100406647, 0.030320905148983, 0.02436074987053871, 0.03190626576542854, -0.06137724965810776, -0.01127586979418993, -0.03770643472671509, 0.019142039120197296, -0.019720250740647316, 0.04387937858700752, -0.03810295835137367, -0.04772403463721275, -0.030322739854454994, -0.014536402188241482, -0.00011127420293632895, 0.04733332619071007, -0.028739936649799347, -0.01312281470745802, -0.008027383126318455, 0.04247361794114113, -0.0018688865238800645, -0.03909905627369881, 0.024554120376706123, 0.002704557264223695, -0.022277869284152985, 0.09303442388772964, 0.005124405492097139, -0.01029404066503048, -0.018934722989797592, 0.05729193612933159, -0.003874785965308547, 0.01930731162428856, -0.01303339097648859, 0.036561302840709686, 0.04357779026031494, 0.008900784887373447, 0.05954664945602417, -0.009936900809407234, 0.016516447067260742, 0.000044118678488302976, -0.047357216477394104, 0.04884358495473862, -0.03736308962106705, -0.0787147656083107, -0.06015917658805847, -0.03301852568984032, -0.03655638173222542, 0.03213049843907356, 0.0029332649428397417, 0.03059506043791771, -0.007406977470964193, -0.01317331101745367, -0.0010946992551907897, 0.03775487467646599, 0.0012225934769958258, -0.036680955439805984, -0.007735942956060171, 0.023094383999705315, 0.020363669842481613, -0.012002888135612011, -0.0074995579198002815, 0.005650894250720739, 0.004769694060087204, 0.0006666772533208132, -0.048318639397621155, -0.007464194670319557, -0.008675243705511093, -0.005082118324935436, 0.03186266869306564, -0.019230538979172707, 0.013786740601062775, 0.0191967710852623, 0.03602985665202141, -0.05389847606420517, -0.06364839524030685, -0.014662920497357845, -0.015880215913057327, -0.0252399742603302, 0.0368226058781147, -0.0753251239657402, 0.03321104124188423, -0.017545070499181747, -0.01510322093963623, -0.06868588179349899, -0.04461031034588814, 0.01610151119530201, 0.007903927005827427, -0.020330987870693207, -0.0037432671524584293, -0.014990461990237236, 0.015013342723250389, -0.017164355143904686, -0.01982113905251026, 0.045423440635204315, -0.037876445800065994, -0.011029169894754887, -0.0005745388334617019, -0.026729531586170197, 0.04766605421900749, 0.015728916972875595, 0.0340038500726223, -0.017426788806915283, 0.007373438682407141, 0.00898053590208292, -0.010167389176785946, 0.026317117735743523, -0.027449997141957283, -0.02648806944489479, -0.05697645992040634, 0.02538585290312767, 0.009238180704414845, -0.01680704765021801, -0.031619299203157425, -0.04255886748433113, 0.0417385958135128, 0.03082842379808426, -0.04964498430490494, -0.006771198473870754, 0.0067705134861171246, -0.0027003749273717403, -0.0014926177682355046, -0.010317613370716572, -0.03514455258846283, -0.02957720123231411, 0.031697310507297516, 0.014128773473203182, 0.001708009047433734, -0.0021649599075317383, 0.05020366609096527, -0.018891284242272377, 0.020428458228707314, 0.010365554131567478, 0.0005640689632855356, 0.006410714238882065, 0.0077621908858418465, 0.004274353850632906, 0.02269047126173973, 0.02447924204170704, -0.04564347863197327, 0.0038566486909985542, -0.05194583907723427, 0.01369332056492567, 0.06020542234182358, 0.0076462081633508205, 0.019011983647942543, 0.04448578506708145, -0.014212431386113167, 0.014752663671970367, -0.05424939841032028, 0.002560691675171256, 0.0061632865108549595, -0.0041051143780350685, 0.034793488681316376, -0.01757398433983326, -0.0006168571417219937, 0.05800757184624672, 0.0376163013279438, -0.002663696650415659, 0.008902964182198048, 0.005564598832279444, 0.02102775126695633, -0.015096774324774742, 0.004652171395719051, -0.07282704859972, 0.047648802399635315, -0.009729807265102863, -0.000309516181005165, 0.010883302427828312, 0.012886435724794865, 0.019558336585760117, 0.03464627265930176, 0.03369264677166939, -0.03729018196463585, -0.03692011535167694, -0.04159923642873764, 0.04505730792880058, 0.028709936887025833, -0.024357395246624947, 0.005977599415928125, 0.0023544649593532085, 0.02724815532565117, -0.006505852099508047, 0.02196217142045498, -0.05384555831551552, -0.09787026792764664, -0.03848404809832573, -0.0218290314078331, -0.009461787529289722, 0.04023398458957672, -0.001562953577376902, -0.04561271145939827, 0.011186265386641026, -0.04140862077474594, 0.02681678533554077, 0.0035016005858778954, 0.0635249987244606, 0.0009324107086285949, 0.05693582817912102, -0.031108340248465538, 0.023085057735443115, -0.029437629505991936, -0.002409215085208416, 0.12187156826257706, 0.04526478797197342, 0.037827759981155396, -0.06405109912157059, -0.0252541434019804, -0.010643906891345978, 0.011687113903462887, -0.022211486473679543, 0.011649642139673233, 0.006138859782367945, -0.0068421196192502975, 0.030712179839611053, 0.007461783476173878, 0.04217960685491562, 0.01283083762973547, 0.0568927600979805, -0.008470656350255013, 0.00003212302544852719, 0.0027620226610451937, -0.013856526464223862, -0.011190976947546005, -0.017807383090257645, -0.06390201300382614, 0.025238052010536194, -0.004152513109147549, -0.057005926966667175, -0.02115040458738804, -0.010795654729008675, 0.02972579002380371, -0.00032037889468483627, -0.0008248555823229253, -0.024952853098511696, -0.01220809854567051, 0.02138476073741913, -0.04757055267691612, 0.011181524954736233, -0.0020575958769768476, -0.014372394420206547, -0.004674114752560854, 0.01786605268716812, -0.007389090955257416, -0.010755331255495548, -0.016378596425056458, -0.004480848554521799, -0.027876587584614754, -0.0216088704764843, -0.039794113487005234, 0.06328701972961426, 0.008559064008295536, -0.011777408421039581, 0.01843363791704178, 0.036663223057985306, 0.029811469838023186, -0.05324585363268852, -0.0201779343187809, 0.02277405560016632, 0.003601982956752181, -0.016592781990766525, -0.016875486820936203, -0.04556242376565933, 0.021333569660782814, -0.009334375150501728, 0.020967110991477966, 0.03525451570749283, -0.007516318000853062, -0.003714499995112419, -0.02629205211997032, 0.02757716365158558, -0.020557096228003502, -0.01242270227521658, -0.015256551094353199, 0.012555438093841076, -0.019535843282938004, -0.03177333250641823, 0.0367097482085228, 0.02865278348326683, 0.017368171364068985, -0.015823092311620712, -0.0459599532186985, -0.01037975400686264, -0.0644589215517044, 0.008604172617197037, -0.057429615408182144, -0.002545727416872978, -0.02687818557024002, 0.013459197245538235, 0.01743144355714321, 0.038637109100818634, 0.018515173345804214, -0.008085597306489944, -0.004013527650386095, 0.042454976588487625, 0.011504577472805977, -0.03157562389969826, -0.019519979134202003, 0.004331622738391161, -0.03305063024163246, -0.010087777860462666, -0.021999288350343704, 0.08255568891763687, 0.025888683274388313, 0.016301697120070457, -0.027788890525698662, 0.03868204355239868, -0.022046979516744614, 0.006028369534760714, 0.006907318253070116, -0.05013185366988182, 0.030445149168372154, -0.0005144372116774321, -0.013355154544115067, 0.0073171998374164104, -0.03971826657652855, -0.01283788587898016, -0.04177727550268173, 0.07387997210025787, 0.011388429440557957, -0.03890183940529823, -0.01632067933678627, 0.0281034205108881, 0.03052964061498642, -0.029385128989815712, -0.004119152203202248, -0.014527605846524239, 0.04987366497516632, -0.019076969474554062, -0.04874623939394951, 0.035939622670412064, -0.02139025181531906, -0.021923961117863655, 0.018252477049827576, -0.007431017234921455, 0.02069954201579094, 0.03011234849691391, -0.0123851727694273, 0.00779310055077076, -0.0006272798054851592, 0.03718196973204613, -0.019811566919088364, 0.002346623921766877, 0.04767180606722832, -0.05632392317056656, -0.022019701078534126, 0.029703224077820778, -0.008026042021811008, 0.03445398807525635, 0.00007888003892730922, 0.018913332372903824, -0.0360926017165184, 0.05853360518813133, 0.00963475089520216, -0.004808200057595968, 0.01383660826832056, -0.00618007080629468, -0.017619404941797256, 0.016506850719451904, 0.008899575099349022, 0.019144544377923012, -0.00026947143487632275, -0.003018512623384595, 0.05774357542395592, 0.007047597318887711, -0.010856857523322105, 0.029876727610826492, -0.037302348762750626, -0.01351428683847189, 0.006990325171500444, 0.03785470873117447, 0.011477156542241573, 0.06252552568912506, -0.0157524012029171, -0.004729521460831165, 0.0009659266215749085, 0.03637572005391121, -0.11771577596664429, -0.005238580517470837, 0.017149586230516434, 0.024816321209073067, 0.01956922374665737, -0.06437642872333527, -0.008073334582149982, 0.05771315097808838, -0.04306218400597572, 0.02816278301179409, -0.023373262956738472, 0.019840486347675323, -0.03763710707426071, -0.010590801015496254, -0.023693978786468506, 0.02892458252608776, 0.023313939571380615, -0.014028259553015232, 0.04616650193929672, 0.006134502589702606, -0.019888050854206085, -0.0006787016754969954, -0.001531653688289225, 0.03670550137758255, 0.004029820207506418, -0.05905395373702049, 0.0214241910725832, -0.03504357114434242, -0.033647533506155014, 0.011264937929809093, -0.0191463902592659, 0.02453741617500782, 0.04924830049276352, 0.004786614794284105, 0.004305487498641014, 0.0023089845199137926, 0.024981940165162086, 0.004585839807987213, 0.0039167702198028564, -0.003883194411173463, 0.00394447660073638, 0.014619373716413975, 0.01637788861989975, 0.020527362823486328, -0.010354801081120968, -0.05301930755376816, -0.01683342084288597, 0.020644282922148705, 0.015852876007556915, -0.01960098184645176, 0.028363317251205444, 0.019198879599571228, 0.028458479791879654, -0.047825220972299576, 0.017581814900040627, -0.029688436537981033, 0.00357835553586483, 0.029944736510515213, -0.002893812023103237, 0.011183524504303932, 0.002566843992099166, -0.032824624329805374, -0.07484299689531326, 0.023883819580078125, -0.010032404214143753, -0.025702131912112236, -0.05213869735598564, 0.01412290334701538, -0.011806607246398926, -0.030382543802261353, -0.00496229762211442, 0.0345950685441494, -0.021924711763858795, 0.04846358299255371, -0.01528258714824915, 0.011283040046691895, 0.0006140991463325918, -0.03550725430250168, -0.00579729164019227, -0.07955734431743622, 0.1069982498884201, -0.0023087298031896353, -0.0486413799226284, -0.04094614088535309, 0.01473322231322527, -0.04060782864689827, 0.011996656656265259, 0.025084927678108215, 0.01717734895646572, 0.022929757833480835, -0.031109269708395004, -0.0012889653444290161, -0.025648392736911774, -0.04679189622402191, 0.04951946437358856, 0.013243606314063072, -0.011782355606555939, -0.007267519365996122, 0.022781670093536377, -0.0052300309762358665, 0.03839225694537163, 0.0030701435171067715, -0.01937110908329487, 0.006319577805697918, -0.0013437764719128609, -0.02340862527489662, 0.006010540761053562, 0.013003888539969921, 0.0004750529769808054, 0.05297050252556801, -0.0005213930853642523, 0.0071930778212845325, 0.02305997908115387, 0.004537064116448164, -0.041942305862903595, -0.003089341800659895, -0.02650350145995617, -0.016271131113171577, -0.018245922401547432, 0.023048564791679382, 0.019852550700306892, -0.07032518833875656, -0.004405926913022995, 0.0046857199631631374, -0.0234979297965765, 0.004699832759797573, 0.03825937956571579, 0.052079882472753525, 0.036390434950590134, -0.0297826137393713, -0.006488489452749491, -0.005031470209360123, 0.00207438669167459, 0.003339637303724885, 0.02996198832988739, 0.027180638164281845, 0.025412408635020256, 0.02099570259451866, 0.022485045716166496, -0.003981276880949736, 0.04349946975708008, 0.007721866015344858, 0.06389542669057846, -0.02972308360040188, 0.02778499387204647, -0.0007755102124065161, 0.0014197080163285136, 0.012003435753285885, -0.012012721039354801, -0.011494099162518978, 0.031650979071855545, -0.039227478206157684, -0.0439436212182045, -0.008172687143087387, -0.033206161111593246, -0.015004263259470463, 0.002371264388784766, -0.004584331065416336, 0.04178892448544502, 0.007232540287077427, 0.01763920672237873, 0.00398221705108881, -0.0033643480855971575, 0.06293774396181107, -0.020770639181137085, 0.036276496946811676, -0.029864832758903503, -0.021883640438318253, -0.016260702162981033, -0.03270510584115982, 0.022900687530636787, -0.014793941751122475, -0.002532829064875841, 0.02150227501988411, -0.015235823579132557, -0.05024883151054382, -0.039750952273607254, -0.0012700514635071158, 0.017723657190799713, -0.06601515412330627, -0.024331774562597275, -0.04306529462337494, 0.04858560115098953, -0.0015448718331754208, -0.004240802954882383 ]
<p>If I construct a 2-D matrix composed entirely of random data, I would expect the PCA and SVD components to essentially explain nothing.</p> <p>Instead, it seems like the the first SVD column appears to explain 75% of the data. How can this possibly be? What am I doing wrong?</p> <p>Here is the plot:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/QjoYc.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>Here is the R code:</p> <pre><code>set.seed(1) rm(list=ls()) m &lt;- matrix(runif(10000,min=0,max=25), nrow=100,ncol=100) svd1 &lt;- svd(m, LINPACK=T) par(mfrow=c(1,4)) image(t(m)[,nrow(m):1]) plot(svd1$d,cex.lab=2, xlab="SVD Column",ylab="Singluar Value",pch=19) percentVarianceExplained = svd1$d^2/sum(svd1$d^2) * 100 plot(percentVarianceExplained,ylim=c(0,100),cex.lab=2, xlab="SVD Column",ylab="Percent of variance explained",pch=19) cumulativeVarianceExplained = cumsum(svd1$d^2/sum(svd1$d^2)) * 100 plot(cumulativeVarianceExplained,ylim=c(0,100),cex.lab=2, xlab="SVD column",ylab="Cumulative percent of variance explained",pch=19) </code></pre> <p><strong>Update</strong></p> <p>Thankyou @Aaron. The fix, as you noted, was to add scaling to the matrix so that the numbers are centered around 0 (i.e. the mean is 0).</p> <pre><code>m &lt;- scale(m, scale=FALSE) </code></pre> <p>Here is the corrected image, showing for a matrix with random data, the first SVD column is close to 0, as expected.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/n5eBc.png" alt="Corrected image"></p>
74,238
[ -0.022175952792167664, 0.002341225277632475, 0.02339269407093525, -0.0009208134142681956, 0.060535866767168045, -0.031293030828237534, -0.010464204475283623, -0.04032159224152565, 0.0026425805408507586, -0.04724262282252312, 0.06020159646868706, 0.036421991884708405, 0.041605398058891296, 0.04440578818321228, 0.029035720974206924, 0.007722626905888319, -0.012540200725197792, -0.010891719721257687, 0.01636377163231373, 0.005992965307086706, -0.04232398793101311, 0.005233178846538067, -0.007242994382977486, -0.010838733986020088, -0.002178373048081994, 0.05518323928117752, 0.0003863002348225564, -0.0036346823908388615, -0.001990526681765914, 0.08417490124702454, -0.07251986116170883, -0.028102846816182137, 0.04808488115668297, -0.00015564990462735295, 0.050981611013412476, 0.0311840008944273, -0.019580667838454247, -0.008970721624791622, 0.012883246876299381, 0.013113562017679214, 0.005784501321613789, 0.008911206386983395, 0.006805273704230785, 0.048041146248579025, -0.011998316273093224, 0.020234644412994385, 0.04204370081424713, 0.01729997806251049, 0.07372964918613434, -0.027179205790162086, 0.0724891796708107, -0.0023414120078086853, 0.04045522212982178, 0.03074299730360508, -0.05453724041581154, 0.005100158043205738, 0.03295449540019035, 0.0368509516119957, 0.02433476597070694, -0.04582485556602478, 0.024284716695547104, -0.012454153038561344, -0.005944786127656698, -0.009105945006012917, -0.017924368381500244, 0.027392743155360222, 0.01413907203823328, -0.02264728769659996, 0.03553296625614166, -0.02334137074649334, 0.02474098652601242, 0.013786418363451958, -0.002949891611933708, -0.037991560995578766, 0.009159737266600132, -0.005418124608695507, 0.0020226638298481703, 0.007806913927197456, 0.02470100298523903, 0.01712440513074398, 0.018593676388263702, 0.043242089450359344, 0.012593017891049385, -0.008625354617834091, 0.030674180015921593, 0.03640969470143318, 0.060629166662693024, 0.006067376583814621, 0.024849476292729378, 0.03449214994907379, 0.0065467325039207935, 0.03406670317053795, 0.05053931102156639, 0.03239614516496658, -0.017977522686123848, 0.014080229215323925, 0.001962272683158517, 0.04624566063284874, 0.0021663971710950136, -0.023227093741297722, -0.045879803597927094, -0.005434483289718628, 0.0326775461435318, 0.013314689509570599, -0.045500706881284714, -0.010034343227744102, -0.03129054978489876, -0.006884130649268627, -0.012829654850065708, -0.02520744875073433, 0.00166086305398494, 0.050304584205150604, 0.021034685894846916, -0.0261208675801754, 0.02885385975241661, -0.02037830837070942, -0.022569432854652405, 0.05601290985941887, 0.035528477281332016, 0.03651493415236473, 0.0095527870580554, -0.027028221637010574, 0.012736664153635502, -0.029021207243204117, -0.0334380641579628, 0.04344567283987999, 0.03920990228652954, -0.003537107026204467, -0.059601761400699615, 0.05727029964327812, -0.003398883854970336, -0.05266612768173218, 0.01650421693921089, -0.001723465509712696, 0.017964821308851242, -0.032688941806554794, -0.08759705722332001, -0.04118243232369423, 0.04183656722307205, -0.04132157564163208, 0.006570631172508001, -0.049314357340335846, -0.04357517883181572, 0.021960066631436348, 0.05355674773454666, -0.03396296501159668, 0.02627428248524666, 0.0018345055868849158, 0.029567208141088486, 0.012752756476402283, -0.031317297369241714, -0.015536635182797909, -0.029040098190307617, -0.024120546877384186, -0.01731463521718979, -0.044842083007097244, 0.030903302133083344, 0.04991568624973297, -0.010176542215049267, 0.01769113540649414, 0.01928693801164627, 0.018296565860509872, 0.034215714782476425, -0.0003717640647664666, -0.011920354329049587, -0.021399136632680893, 0.057065024971961975, 0.0267817173153162, 0.017744915559887886, 0.041932493448257446, -0.029636647552251816, 0.004392504692077637, -0.012490885332226753, 0.044857628643512726, 0.03046407736837864, 0.002344573615118861, -0.013858580030500889, 0.005634616129100323, 0.017993345856666565, 0.0392085537314415, -0.05485324561595917, -0.037379223853349686, -0.014789733104407787, -0.001328143640421331, 0.04667371138930321, 0.0544511117041111, -0.015047757886350155, -0.06727086007595062, 0.0059747579507529736, -0.03250006586313248, -0.03709283843636513, -0.06475096195936203, -0.003218440106138587, -0.005812968593090773, -0.03217533603310585, -0.0167880617082119, -0.011515609920024872, 0.04006236791610718, 0.0319855734705925, 0.0011490810429677367, -0.021380549296736717, -0.005261104088276625, 0.06454820185899734, -0.025236118584871292, -0.011702066287398338, 0.00045793704339303076, 0.07849179208278656, 0.0026766620576381683, 0.015446600504219532, -0.05578072741627693, -0.034174855798482895, -0.006304287817329168, -0.014066371135413647, 0.02215542085468769, -0.011683933436870575, -0.015868525952100754, -0.012452784925699234, 0.024530449882149696, -0.03501487895846367, 0.027336331084370613, -0.03708742558956146, 0.03650404140353203, 0.06298206001520157, -0.009429375641047955, -0.03142688423395157, 0.02884424664080143, 0.011519178748130798, 0.002078112680464983, -0.024373088032007217, -0.014376964420080185, -0.014724543318152428, 0.0037087900564074516, 0.04297845438122749, 0.0657283216714859, -0.024168547242879868, -0.0032887195702642202, 0.06085050851106644, 0.03369183838367462, 0.015614986419677734, 0.04942071810364723, 0.010415414348244667, -0.008700360544025898, -0.0077588120475411415, -0.0043286290019750595, -0.010708868503570557, 0.00580330565571785, 0.003799892496317625, 0.02073306404054165, 0.051779258996248245, 0.020436957478523254, -0.030739225447177887, 0.01726779341697693, -0.03519458696246147, 0.0010680337436497211, -0.02771676890552044, 0.0033102980814874172, 0.05264557898044586, 0.023182522505521774, 0.0037602437660098076, 0.015196782536804676, -0.0007042704964987934, -0.0037749309558421373, 0.0025579205248504877, -0.03870147094130516, -0.005600867792963982, 0.050612129271030426, -0.03260912746191025, -0.020123107358813286, 0.008509008213877678, 0.0063831559382379055, 0.00011224801710341126, -0.01654793694615364, -0.017022982239723206, -0.03346075117588043, 0.052146345376968384, 0.05962204560637474, 0.03252595663070679, 0.03935341164469719, -0.05123715475201607, -0.037232693284749985, -0.0068786232732236385, -0.005353674292564392, 0.03671087324619293, -0.002933503594249487, -0.05008098855614662, 0.011136097833514214, -0.015499730594456196, -0.005445866845548153, 0.023722972720861435, 0.007727351970970631, -0.034576158970594406, 0.010447109118103981, -0.01153966411948204, -0.06477674096822739, -0.013365122489631176, -0.028467971831560135, 0.02089853584766388, -0.02268347702920437, -0.00919311959296465, 0.017975114285945892, 0.0385136641561985, -0.0332876592874527, 0.0007843725034035742, -0.058887261897325516, 0.01855066977441311, -0.02759900502860546, -0.024482568725943565, 0.023982197046279907, -0.01247111614793539, 0.003332012565806508, 0.024075305089354515, -0.051528722047805786, -0.02541697956621647, -0.04515907168388367, -0.061049871146678925, 0.00892541091889143, 0.009480333887040615, 0.030617859214544296, -0.022815505042672157, -0.0018088012002408504, 0.04578333720564842, 0.025076666846871376, -0.023388035595417023, -0.05598822981119156, -0.012946718372404575, -0.0217764750123024, -0.05487827584147453, 0.020410146564245224, -0.003955507185310125, 0.0007818975718691945, 0.01660587266087532, -0.030776217579841614, 0.013794474303722382, 0.035592883825302124, -0.029734021052718163, -0.008419455029070377, 0.0002870138268917799, 0.003905189223587513, -0.0031771021895110607, 0.04605718329548836, 0.023505331948399544, 0.002130411798134446, 0.014981424435973167, 0.002804378978908062, 0.04759621247649193, -0.006163483019918203, -0.03485001623630524, 0.03036302700638771, -0.030499881133437157, 0.05413735657930374, -0.06826496869325638, 0.031614989042282104, 0.04176011309027672, -0.024212129414081573, -0.020957620814442635, -0.04207981750369072, 0.047874078154563904, -0.03728398308157921, 0.01418299414217472, 0.06856894493103027, 0.022214019671082497, -0.023226115852594376, 0.029036421328783035, 0.009858865290880203, -0.010944755747914314, 0.01862022466957569, -0.05425172671675682, 0.019902000203728676, 0.047458697110414505, 0.036554817110300064, 0.03458721935749054, 0.019245510920882225, -0.04943099990487099, 0.017462506890296936, -0.07136858999729156, 0.022720441222190857, -0.04277072474360466, 0.03741171583533287, 0.017410902306437492, 0.07080245018005371, 0.03183626011013985, 0.004877294879406691, 0.017945528030395508, -0.015776509419083595, -0.07360859215259552, 0.007269892375916243, 0.03111889772117138, 0.013789285905659199, -0.01797403208911419, -0.02868719771504402, 0.022255325689911842, -0.015294458717107773, 0.009222939610481262, -0.0008138307020999491, -0.018198374658823013, -0.06128789111971855, -0.020723609253764153, -0.016907669603824615, 0.010650348849594593, -0.06543218344449997, -0.00725294416770339, 0.046989716589450836, -0.03955177962779999, 0.04131324589252472, 0.017029911279678345, -0.02664818987250328, 0.001797095057554543, -0.027409028261899948, -0.02027939446270466, 0.02298584394156933, 0.04176652804017067, -0.003987958654761314, 0.010907181538641453, -0.022122329100966454, 0.04120073840022087, 0.009805552661418915, 0.07537735998630524, 0.04818776249885559, -0.0014147264882922173, 0.01618172414600849, -0.03660972788929939, -0.01550618652254343, 0.021299250423908234, 0.005563944112509489, -0.0057698823511600494, -0.03080134280025959, 0.03082180581986904, 0.027935700491070747, -0.031307872384786606, 0.010915674269199371, 0.03573092073202133, 0.014740572310984135, 0.024957885965704918, -0.03173481673002243, 0.0027587648946791887, -0.04133961349725723, -0.03474036604166031, 0.007472096476703882, -0.017544493079185486, -0.014383066445589066, -0.035762857645750046, 0.03635665029287338, -0.047057971358299255, 0.0071548717096447945, 0.0076357354409992695, 0.01747884228825569, 0.04318297654390335, -0.010249865241348743, -0.023737912997603416, -0.014767762273550034, 0.003787541063502431, 0.02014978416264057, 0.022273216396570206, 0.002866857685148716, -0.04102908819913864, -0.013538007624447346, 0.037972405552864075, 0.05322811007499695, -0.04722680151462555, -0.004586583003401756, -0.02494070678949356, -0.045017343014478683, 0.02830570377409458, -0.04546738415956497, 0.034676529467105865, -0.010226758196949959, 0.015050297603011131, -0.04354118928313255, -0.05278358608484268, -0.056709520518779755, -0.003487036796286702, -0.056464783847332, 0.044393885880708694, -0.0183169674128294, -0.046762384474277496, -0.04855828359723091, -0.013145416043698788, 0.006292745005339384, 0.027987176552414894, -0.02346867136657238, -0.029791802167892456, 0.00934307649731636, 0.01572054624557495, -0.00748593732714653, -0.06479546427726746, 0.03062480315566063, 0.014033585786819458, -0.006961797829717398, 0.04077623784542084, -0.015183590352535248, -0.006179811432957649, 0.0579678975045681, 0.022065768018364906, -0.0005817825440317392, -0.010529524646699429, 0.0009370835614390671, 0.039559751749038696, 0.043390389531850815, -0.0018107895739376545, 0.047355033457279205, 0.02156153693795204, -0.011906162835657597, 0.03598944470286369, -0.08152071386575699, 0.024435577914118767, -0.017679136246442795, -0.025617126375436783, -0.056345660239458084, -0.01700967364013195, -0.02934490703046322, 0.003641190007328987, -0.005297851748764515, 0.045152947306632996, -0.055465441197156906, -0.00036014043143950403, 0.027690157294273376, 0.0528024360537529, -0.0027526626363396645, -0.0167547557502985, -0.006180344615131617, 0.03008006513118744, 0.005758186802268028, -0.01888524740934372, 0.01525560487061739, -0.00968380831182003, -0.04656554013490677, 0.015505469404160976, -0.03664395585656166, -0.027822546660900116, 0.0068472144193947315, -0.005548812448978424, 0.001799088204279542, -0.024818476289510727, -0.001745815621688962, -0.059622734785079956, 0.024586869403719902, -0.018273698166012764, -0.048451051115989685, 0.00017827680858317763, 0.00903619360178709, 0.004077914636582136, -0.01713520660996437, -0.03082106076180935, 0.022066153585910797, -0.0016361892921850085, 0.01426728442311287, -0.040174052119255066, -0.04103812947869301, 0.00609112624078989, 0.011064224876463413, -0.01288179587572813, -0.049606803804636, -0.04636608064174652, 0.008997379802167416, 0.0008963354048319161, 0.005885198246687651, 0.02953115850687027, -0.022996539250016212, 0.0022478129249066114, 0.007781023625284433, 0.016741570085287094, 0.07420473545789719, -0.03753103315830231, 0.0003561918856576085, 0.014347595162689686, -0.019347872585058212, -0.03184296190738678, 0.015178166329860687, 0.012102054432034492, -0.050283558666706085, -0.006142008118331432, -0.025271186605095863, 0.004544076509773731, 0.043334465473890305, -0.009799937717616558, 0.011637668125331402, 0.006505282130092382, -0.0036744012031704187, 0.04614858701825142, -0.051673419773578644, -0.011585638858377934, -0.01746869459748268, 0.010456467047333717, -0.0008968690526671708, -0.04252636432647705, -0.032507844269275665, -0.011496203951537609, -0.012712761759757996, -0.0025083268992602825, -0.006600081920623779, 0.03280311077833176, 0.0825360119342804, -0.005145482253283262, -0.008761405013501644, -0.013607295230031013, -0.021777234971523285, 0.007035144604742527, 0.05415996536612511, 0.017305340617895126, 0.014468614012002945, 0.0301680825650692, -0.015602529048919678, 0.012017522938549519, -0.047237690538167953, 0.016544081270694733, 0.072409488260746, 0.011845262721180916, 0.0429227352142334, 0.04510807245969772, -0.018447063863277435, -0.021370654925704002, -0.04958484321832657, -0.05360913276672363, -0.002670062705874443, 0.02774757519364357, 0.0057828291319310665, -0.008889621123671532, -0.037385258823633194, 0.03297813609242439, 0.042631302028894424, 0.031113138422369957, 0.03479671850800514, 0.02809830754995346, -0.034534815698862076, 0.03710655868053436, -0.0013936931500211358, -0.026182368397712708, 0.03062528930604458, 0.0013331632362678647, 0.02384130470454693, -0.03134293481707573, -0.018992969766259193, 0.043481647968292236, 0.015040208585560322, -0.0464928075671196, 0.006216539070010185, -0.012242256663739681, -0.04737979173660278, -0.03918895125389099, 0.023155640810728073, -0.015822945162653923, 0.024450145661830902, -0.019125845283269882, 0.019519349560141563, -0.006465571466833353, 0.04555216059088707, -0.031155547127127647, -0.05428793653845787, -0.023560553789138794, 0.018453655764460564, 0.003976963460445404, 0.034090228378772736, 0.009619317948818207, -0.015320153906941414, 0.0075970608741045, -0.04832812026143074, 0.0257544107735157, -0.0027690220158547163, 0.02280481532216072, 0.016002129763364792, 0.01859593391418457, 0.0018644522642716765, 0.009678869508206844, -0.03931888937950134, -0.03165832906961441, 0.11658281832933426, 0.03098960407078266, 0.021388068795204163, -0.051812540739774704, 0.009609785862267017, 0.015776757150888443, 0.03166317567229271, -0.0031631425954401493, -0.002494384301826358, -0.017275625839829445, -0.007528656627982855, 0.03813795745372772, 0.04402565583586693, 0.003219938836991787, 0.04001748934388161, 0.010931957513093948, -0.022423310205340385, -0.04095768928527832, -0.021724490448832512, 0.010963615030050278, -0.03430340066552162, -0.0275654848664999, -0.08095890283584595, 0.0026102561969310045, -0.002714890753850341, -0.0023263143375515938, -0.040994878858327866, -0.013428637757897377, -0.0033111919183284044, 0.01513940654695034, -0.016342295333743095, 0.052772898226976395, 0.028027739375829697, 0.010632011108100414, -0.014078738167881966, 0.00177375681232661, 0.05540068447589874, -0.019058050587773323, 0.009990885853767395, 0.014974933117628098, -0.012518887408077717, -0.00004489213097258471, -0.0158595759421587, 0.03274711221456528, -0.034180741757154465, -0.03729801997542381, -0.046973612159490585, 0.06210336834192276, 0.001973444828763604, -0.039091937243938446, 0.027596715837717056, -0.025585278868675232, -0.07043600082397461, -0.04586518555879593, 0.01369728334248066, 0.006700883619487286, 0.003569152904674411, 0.014936108142137527, -0.01119911763817072, -0.021930918097496033, 0.023006964474916458, -0.02899598516523838, 0.008191603235900402, 0.05133441090583801, -0.014897537417709827, -0.04118850454688072, -0.03695760667324066, 0.07373631000518799, -0.04546242579817772, 0.010406547226011753, 0.04133012145757675, -0.023660004138946533, 0.015408575534820557, -0.03592218458652496, -0.012822775170207024, 0.004417344927787781, 0.04763459786772728, -0.006054494064301252, -0.012784949503839016, -0.01288643479347229, -0.05864981934428215, 0.0380890853703022, 0.00016603093536105007, -0.02952907606959343, -0.04000566527247429, 0.03349931538105011, 0.0110009228810668, 0.01629474386572838, 0.011487900279462337, 0.020088260993361473, -0.015254260040819645, 0.06324028968811035, 0.02316688746213913, -0.024952666833996773, -0.04427241161465645, 0.03741133213043213, 0.008369047194719315, -0.00922774150967598, 0.008659768849611282, 0.0478510819375515, 0.04677419736981392, 0.0040495432913303375, -0.012811258435249329, 0.039159052073955536, -0.0111647117882967, -0.015411964617669582, 0.015673108398914337, -0.05385215952992439, 0.023378074169158936, -0.010144430212676525, -0.01551142893731594, -0.012953185476362705, 0.0159617830067873, -0.048896148800849915, -0.05945651978254318, -0.03849426284432411, 0.03139335662126541, -0.029768094420433044, -0.008310315199196339, 0.004314399790018797, 0.02273203618824482, -0.034523896872997284, -0.03266122192144394, -0.048226747661828995, -0.01860491745173931, -0.010005839169025421, -0.005289625376462936, -0.02360132709145546, 0.009923286736011505, -0.05126919224858284, 0.022272121161222458, 0.0382598415017128, 0.017438014969229698, 0.0034637453500181437, -0.02890131063759327, 0.026125648990273476, -0.014234449714422226, 0.03354150429368019, -0.00953924935311079, -0.007878541946411133, 0.06311970949172974, -0.04748121276497841, -0.03603548929095268, -0.004359834361821413, 0.005185652989894152, 0.029858579859137535, 0.009447927586734295, -0.007308900821954012, -0.04866902530193329, 0.06444431841373444, -0.010297408327460289, 0.012170466594398022, -0.02490714006125927, -0.006597261875867844, 0.014299963600933552, 0.03871000558137894, -0.002823798218742013, -0.019993523135781288, 0.011446014977991581, 0.040264591574668884, 0.03635735809803009, -0.03095685876905918, -0.012648798525333405, -0.005153228994458914, -0.015255761332809925, 0.03210780397057533, 0.024130847305059433, 0.010950976051390171, 0.044748857617378235, 0.031311482191085815, -0.03587786480784416, 0.018535912036895752, -0.031873684376478195, 0.0027862500865012407, -0.08461093157529831, -0.0006401982973329723, -0.018404880538582802, 0.008773423731327057, -0.019771842285990715, -0.03569341078400612, 0.01458572968840599, 0.0637880340218544, -0.051031243056058884, 0.0173910204321146, -0.04141370579600334, -0.011525382287800312, -0.022139931097626686, 0.051176052540540695, -0.006949504371732473, 0.034701380878686905, 0.042289793491363525, 0.015291286632418633, 0.027070391923189163, 0.01681492291390896, 0.04797195643186569, -0.029552122578024864, -0.03679027780890465, 0.02453010529279709, -0.008707773871719837, -0.03599634766578674, 0.01710217259824276, -0.014322556555271149, -0.009339077398180962, 0.023478740826249123, -0.022402508184313774, 0.021324533969163895, 0.025909423828125, 0.04799361526966095, 0.03234539180994034, 0.053858038038015366, 0.0012044995091855526, 0.011089682579040527, 0.006453314330428839, -0.027364742010831833, 0.03230821341276169, 0.02059166133403778, -0.015443803742527962, 0.020219434052705765, 0.04958272725343704, 0.02427256852388382, -0.01010859850794077, 0.0012646735412999988, -0.024272657930850983, -0.00686779385432601, -0.009171525947749615, 0.015634069219231606, 0.015858694911003113, -0.07866652309894562, 0.010861438699066639, -0.035293154418468475, -0.013156534172594547, 0.04996638372540474, 0.007634761277586222, 0.0016432949341833591, 0.0014801559736952186, 0.04630329832434654, -0.016594458371400833, 0.019119450822472572, 0.012315514497458935, -0.02470705471932888, -0.08043066412210464, -0.05850938707590103, -0.0026874118484556675, -0.0008119851700030267, 0.00983549002557993, -0.003377894638106227, -0.04465138912200928, 0.04107041656970978, 0.010129878297448158, 0.02393200807273388, -0.004099064506590366, -0.03177603706717491, 0.0010653580538928509, -0.1092454195022583, 0.05884164199233055, -0.02386445552110672, -0.06931939721107483, -0.020926212891936302, 0.04957100749015808, -0.04497181251645088, 0.06421368569135666, 0.030119989067316055, 0.05212040990591049, 0.013104718178510666, 0.0203561894595623, 0.02215920388698578, 0.03096918761730194, -0.060481712222099304, 0.05473167076706886, 0.0012773387134075165, -0.0254753939807415, 0.03627307713031769, -0.018037840723991394, 0.030467189848423004, 0.043453045189380646, -0.0005964742740616202, -0.027375342324376106, 0.028275342658162117, -0.010600398294627666, -0.030824169516563416, 0.04733071103692055, 0.0009949596133083105, -0.0368182510137558, 0.03751387074589729, -0.018027231097221375, 0.019026754423975945, 0.041453152894973755, -0.0002501423587091267, -0.020276105031371117, -0.0007900517084635794, -0.0060550193302333355, 0.0005411218153312802, 0.03117058426141739, -0.003068885998800397, 0.010568185709416866, -0.06752996146678925, -0.01999356597661972, 0.01966625452041626, -0.008745880797505379, 0.003780903061851859, 0.03386432304978371, 0.013991683721542358, 0.03090083971619606, 0.06428590416908264, 0.03721674904227257, -0.00693464232608676, -0.042812518775463104, 0.019227493554353714, 0.005643527954816818, 0.019545530900359154, 0.0013485715026035905, -0.016806086525321007, 0.014806531369686127, -0.010814680717885494, 0.004287984222173691, -0.020833654329180717, 0.02883266471326351, -0.011025053448975086, -0.01814446598291397, -0.009248585440218449, -0.016977785155177116, 0.02166181616485119, -0.034435126930475235, 0.0030178274028003216, 0.03730272874236107, -0.06429453194141388, 0.007684116717427969, -0.008871139958500862, -0.03891713544726372, -0.01055984478443861, -0.00444002402946353, 0.021866217255592346, 0.04581253603100777, 0.0072373454459011555, 0.011342008598148823, 0.012915706261992455, -0.006728426553308964, 0.01995302550494671, 0.017653942108154297, 0.033265531063079834, -0.03465671092271805, -0.006996122654527426, 0.011254264041781425, 0.02750898338854313, 0.010759247466921806, -0.02638031542301178, 0.039580684155225754, 0.03238210082054138, 0.004029432311654091, -0.06155020743608475, -0.014026308432221413, 0.00506904162466526, 0.010021786205470562, -0.053276754915714264, -0.025013575330376625, -0.025816192850470543, -0.0019502846989780664, 0.0018016784451901913, -0.03977280482649803 ]
<p>I am confused about "parametric" and "non-parametric": Our topic is nonparametric estimators for probability of default. So first of all, we consider the generalized linear models, as an example we have probit and logit:</p> <p>$\pi (x)=G(\beta_0 +\sum \beta_i x_i)$</p> <p>These generalized linear models are parametric models right? They are parametric, since we have parameters beta, which have to be estimated.</p> <p>Next we consider semiparametric credit scoring, the generalized partial linear model:</p> <p>$E(Y|X,T)=G(\beta ' X + m(T))$</p> <p>m(.) is e.g. a Kernel, a smooth function</p> <p>So the parametric term is again the beta ' x and the non-parametric is the kernel, right?</p> <p>Thanks a lot for your help</p>
74,239
[ -0.018904399126768112, -0.0005336453905329108, 0.02627028152346611, -0.0028196589555591345, 0.016485165804624557, 0.013085668906569481, 0.001023693010210991, -0.011729461140930653, 0.0485525019466877, -0.003961403854191303, 0.054139863699674606, 0.009865034371614456, 0.05703249201178551, 0.01091520581394434, 0.01781330071389675, 0.01915937289595604, -0.011396326124668121, 0.00800191331654787, -0.02249886654317379, 0.012825489044189453, 0.0037768883630633354, 0.03651382029056549, -0.02589569054543972, 0.007834517396986485, 0.00004566115603665821, 0.023712066933512688, -0.030201058834791183, -0.01409165933728218, 0.0032694030087441206, 0.07074984908103943, -0.01217102911323309, -0.032670438289642334, -0.008186536841094494, 0.03147944435477257, 0.013400417752563953, 0.014133251272141933, -0.07632405310869217, -0.028965601697564125, -0.014285561628639698, 0.032001372426748276, -0.017814146354794502, -0.053343240171670914, 0.014118129387497902, 0.014280548319220543, -0.0002927334571722895, 0.020703479647636414, 0.016629356890916824, -0.022455371916294098, -0.018849309533834457, -0.033100903034210205, 0.059362784028053284, 0.012279974296689034, 0.030302757397294044, 0.04613828286528587, -0.018378980457782745, 0.015090858563780785, 0.02416330762207508, 0.09930115938186646, -0.0322938933968544, -0.05406792461872101, -0.02164902724325657, -0.03495839983224869, 0.03556918352842331, -0.0500236377120018, -0.058917075395584106, 0.04087074100971222, 0.007503777276724577, -0.028551334515213966, 0.027222545817494392, -0.0509183332324028, -0.0024833146017044783, -0.004912742413580418, 0.023298542946577072, -0.03683625906705856, -0.004220542963594198, -0.01257531438022852, -0.009332702495157719, -0.0035796964075416327, 0.04902656748890877, 0.011155585758388042, 0.030853744596242905, 0.015074511989951134, 0.013119296170771122, 0.0397934764623642, -0.007016903255134821, -0.0010130256414413452, 0.09051621705293655, -0.03401452302932739, 0.044366009533405304, 0.020435918122529984, -0.011095613241195679, -0.007642689161002636, 0.028146794065833092, -0.008943050168454647, -0.05764177814126015, 0.04290873557329178, -0.009533023461699486, 0.025028690695762634, 0.024788260459899902, -0.01175377145409584, -0.004107417538762093, -0.028541287407279015, -0.011235455051064491, 0.02968095801770687, -0.019924327731132507, -0.017887528985738754, 0.01682792603969574, 0.0315866656601429, 0.011423273012042046, -0.016617251560091972, -0.048830822110176086, 0.07058726251125336, 0.008124230429530144, -0.01344438549131155, 0.023753704503178596, -0.006695040035992861, -0.007668064441531897, -0.022149261087179184, 0.014080510474741459, 0.03856538236141205, 0.02072816528379917, -0.043819360435009, 0.022398198023438454, -0.02204902283847332, -0.061004120856523514, 0.031420063227415085, 0.03585674613714218, -0.013646666891872883, -0.06718099862337112, 0.015561017207801342, -0.00878108013421297, -0.004125524777919054, 0.03831468150019646, 0.018065793439745903, 0.024282997474074364, -0.0032348555978387594, -0.07479753345251083, -0.029275652021169662, 0.025776801630854607, 0.02140808291733265, 0.04151405394077301, -0.03448440507054329, -0.004014858976006508, 0.0362507589161396, 0.05606667324900627, -0.007346479222178459, 0.04661336541175842, 0.031668949872255325, 0.024696191772818565, 0.003568595740944147, -0.023178234696388245, -0.041389621794223785, -0.019673457369208336, -0.001849903492256999, -0.015788380056619644, -0.06524841487407684, 0.016425536945462227, 0.02510952390730381, 0.02548081800341606, -0.012591314502060413, 0.024895384907722473, 0.00776250846683979, 0.002145761623978615, -0.018528243526816368, -0.01473145093768835, -0.022527391090989113, 0.034645553678274155, -0.004600950051099062, 0.021153034642338753, 0.04638274013996124, 0.00868548359721899, 0.03501402586698532, 0.008434833027422428, 0.05562292039394379, 0.06371848285198212, -0.049403611570596695, -0.0494283065199852, -0.03528302162885666, 0.01887388713657856, -0.0007894332520663738, -0.05584285780787468, 0.003365802112966776, 0.008784494362771511, 0.007379298098385334, -0.012218590825796127, 0.014898867346346378, 0.020429562777280807, -0.053358662873506546, 0.00763406977057457, -0.00473418552428484, -0.07399814575910568, -0.05170109495520592, 0.026562035083770752, -0.04025873914361, -0.01911832019686699, 0.03663158416748047, 0.012071474455296993, -0.014468416571617126, -0.009296718053519726, -0.009500149637460709, -0.015683546662330627, -0.004992345348000526, 0.02747833915054798, -0.06765376776456833, -0.0027454288210719824, 0.04944419488310814, 0.027660652995109558, 0.008871736004948616, 0.04891999438405037, -0.05089335888624191, -0.040959421545267105, 0.002565747359767556, -0.04239097982645035, 0.010970890522003174, -0.03768477216362953, -0.042529717087745667, 0.01661972887814045, 0.003286079503595829, -0.021161582320928574, 0.023071300238370895, -0.028517242521047592, 0.034813497215509415, 0.07183157652616501, 0.03571081534028053, -0.015413010492920876, -0.022127533331513405, -0.014474954456090927, 0.026831235736608505, -0.05099437013268471, -0.02428848296403885, -0.0411565899848938, -0.014120921492576599, 0.03778189793229103, 0.014970233663916588, -0.032220348715782166, 0.0216432623565197, 0.08209564536809921, 0.046921420842409134, -0.01660793274641037, 0.016287915408611298, -0.0022845210041850805, -0.010824067518115044, 0.030541392043232918, 0.024085713550448418, 0.012594180181622505, -0.01362287625670433, 0.03703218698501587, 0.007620937190949917, 0.05400199443101883, -0.02651546522974968, -0.00435665063560009, 0.08511950075626373, -0.0016945943934842944, 0.01447235606610775, -0.01915287785232067, -0.014252512715756893, 0.06162117049098015, -0.008310076780617237, 0.017454946413636208, 0.03685324266552925, 0.013872010633349419, 0.013713660649955273, 0.0010904966620728374, 0.011653929017484188, 0.0307944156229496, 0.016349541023373604, -0.04990636929869652, -0.0034147684928029776, 0.00955673772841692, -0.04318264126777649, -0.01788884587585926, -0.004433445166796446, -0.028684627264738083, -0.030143296346068382, 0.027234619483351707, 0.0321957990527153, 0.00020909767772536725, 0.036238279193639755, -0.021056612953543663, -0.0357053242623806, 0.024408165365457535, -0.05615774542093277, 0.0468280166387558, 0.01880745030939579, -0.07434264570474625, 0.016975682228803635, -0.04780806601047516, -0.005054321605712175, 0.07930605113506317, -0.014114625751972198, -0.006406009197235107, 0.0037683441769331694, -0.015317385084927082, -0.025276776403188705, -0.03516468033194542, -0.04817938059568405, 0.04001731798052788, -0.06118256598711014, -0.020204702392220497, 0.008126750588417053, 0.020277343690395355, -0.03357931599020958, 0.04424688592553139, -0.04769662767648697, -0.027466004714369774, -0.006780274678021669, -0.001689726603217423, 0.020425954833626747, -0.0018487621564418077, 0.05675026774406433, 0.0041047921404242516, -0.014513635076582432, 0.00035377725725993514, -0.06457924097776413, -0.021408764645457268, 0.020389923825860023, -0.03762345388531685, -0.0018698751227930188, 0.028103455901145935, -0.04162640869617462, 0.04434410482645035, 0.020674021914601326, -0.015773095190525055, -0.021231144666671753, 0.03518536686897278, -0.05962027236819267, 0.00467259157449007, -0.01731828972697258, 0.005170990247279406, 0.015427195467054844, 0.009032688103616238, -0.015815075486898422, 0.006775993388146162, 0.037938982248306274, 0.01712619513273239, 0.010914716869592667, 0.019292406737804413, 0.0012024884345009923, -0.016756579279899597, 0.04005841910839081, 0.008484507910907269, -0.01088758185505867, 0.026765912771224976, 0.007127722259610891, -0.000914374424610287, 0.0077047874219715595, -0.0375516451895237, 0.03149754926562309, -0.012958384118974209, -0.05056227743625641, -0.03140893206000328, 0.03343554958701134, 0.0038391302805393934, -0.06150529161095619, 0.0033120810985565186, 0.0027358706574887037, 0.027978647500276566, -0.034827813506126404, 0.03251851350069046, 0.03575190529227257, 0.05651281774044037, -0.019457368180155754, 0.00814083218574524, -0.030392328277230263, -0.015503661707043648, 0.03412840515375137, -0.017609853297472, -0.03702878579497337, 0.018042774870991707, 0.07663826644420624, -0.02478240430355072, -0.016749307513237, -0.025645781308412552, 0.005610473919659853, -0.07740160822868347, 0.017623916268348694, -0.02755391225218773, 0.08040835708379745, 0.024515358731150627, 0.010627653449773788, 0.03359365835785866, 0.0007980026421137154, 0.04231681674718857, 0.01862838678061962, -0.06033124029636383, 0.03490843251347542, 0.00526783149689436, -0.004592068027704954, 0.008509046398103237, 0.004522997885942459, 0.0540490448474884, 0.005094529129564762, 0.025255072861909866, 0.003100586822256446, 0.014860986731946468, -0.04879659414291382, 0.010572495870292187, -0.023460950702428818, -0.023136891424655914, -0.016142386943101883, -0.016312239691615105, -0.012845720164477825, -0.020961927250027657, 0.030589114874601364, 0.06890371441841125, 0.0015318234218284488, 0.006871075835078955, -0.0006292022299021482, -0.009735607542097569, 0.026513032615184784, 0.02765129879117012, 0.024218574166297913, 0.026946544647216797, -0.03306884318590164, 0.021270491182804108, 0.02666117250919342, 0.0490252859890461, 0.0645972192287445, -0.029828647151589394, -0.021570758894085884, -0.055203743278980255, -0.0037134517915546894, -0.01130558643490076, 0.008372378535568714, 0.018139800056815147, -0.016237998381257057, 0.05003698542714119, 0.03149242699146271, -0.03939899429678917, 0.0008590667275711894, 0.04036729782819748, 0.018830327317118645, -0.025346050038933754, -0.0526031069457531, -0.020281249657273293, -0.01836857944726944, -0.0231003500521183, 0.03771858289837837, 0.018123088404536247, -0.03441412001848221, -0.00748605839908123, 0.04604624584317207, -0.05370621010661125, -0.010361778549849987, -0.028809092938899994, 0.04274167865514755, 0.02094954252243042, 0.03257068246603012, -0.06771188974380493, 0.03024226240813732, 0.03738105297088623, 0.05841410532593727, 0.0020705540664494038, -0.0031878529116511345, -0.08232834190130234, -0.0051405043341219425, 0.03785155713558197, 0.012111796997487545, -0.029530856758356094, -0.031246785074472427, -0.013218564912676811, -0.0026615287642925978, -0.02171301655471325, -0.003696185303851962, -0.018133873119950294, 0.008858295157551765, -0.0034178290516138077, -0.03329705819487572, -0.021630357950925827, -0.047517064958810806, -0.002834455342963338, 0.013872801326215267, 0.02793264202773571, -0.03548912703990936, -0.04309316352009773, -0.04267066717147827, -0.0326477587223053, 0.001795040676370263, 0.0645819902420044, -0.017845267429947853, -0.009491486474871635, 0.02665969729423523, 0.032747671008110046, -0.012052145786583424, -0.051286980509757996, 0.03176907077431679, 0.026479115709662437, -0.029921583831310272, 0.04622364789247513, -0.013750293292105198, -0.04798809438943863, 0.03736857324838638, 0.017952166497707367, -0.012090558186173439, 0.018893912434577942, -0.009174955077469349, 0.012407717294991016, 0.024845898151397705, 0.05302547663450241, 0.053889740258455276, 0.03490583971142769, -0.011564281769096851, -0.017750483006238937, -0.024071011692285538, -0.0015661492943763733, -0.06538350135087967, -0.0041984873823821545, -0.03792094811797142, -0.01609964668750763, -0.030613411217927933, 0.03316900506615639, 0.012739811092615128, 0.03556456044316292, -0.04891391471028328, -0.016183117404580116, 0.00034776690881699324, 0.01241492759436369, 0.009843218140304089, -0.012049694545567036, -0.02488081343472004, 0.015366322360932827, 0.003354172222316265, 0.003356600645929575, -0.024202942848205566, -0.048369526863098145, -0.003793284296989441, -0.0021774619817733765, -0.012691883370280266, -0.001387129770591855, 0.0031620271038264036, -0.01434683334082365, 0.023760590702295303, 0.0063758790493011475, 0.023140333592891693, 0.015028443187475204, 0.023062124848365784, 0.018815958872437477, -0.05751640349626541, -0.019832231104373932, 0.019062625244259834, -0.032066717743873596, 0.03685460984706879, -0.039385680109262466, 0.050516385585069656, 0.02618604153394699, -0.009946447797119617, -0.05972956866025925, -0.03732146695256233, 0.0640684962272644, -0.011202029883861542, -0.06383833289146423, -0.010865421034395695, 0.02615225687623024, -0.024197302758693695, -0.04844527319073677, -0.002412321511656046, 0.02727941982448101, -0.007887106388807297, -0.0016280527925118804, -0.02514984831213951, 0.02854703925549984, 0.05233383551239967, -0.011383919045329094, -0.011952437460422516, -0.005081211216747761, -0.032613810151815414, -0.0318935364484787, -0.00008243322372436523, 0.0061992197297513485, -0.02875019982457161, 0.020988361909985542, -0.026562120765447617, -0.030956342816352844, 0.04364028573036194, 0.00370017415843904, -0.0037457323633134365, 0.029931621626019478, -0.015739766880869865, -0.023622140288352966, -0.010111101903021336, -0.03635917231440544, -0.002156130038201809, -0.0012739613885059953, -0.008241656236350536, -0.022749051451683044, -0.016249945387244225, -0.008389570750296116, 0.05178411304950714, 0.004555281717330217, 0.00512063829228282, 0.02561076730489731, 0.05803300440311432, -0.03196863830089569, 0.03317843750119209, 0.014068616554141045, -0.009984077885746956, 0.05293688923120499, 0.023358941078186035, 0.020157435908913612, 0.018854105845093727, 0.01870058663189411, -0.04049452394247055, -0.012708842754364014, -0.06371188908815384, 0.011368880979716778, 0.03295956552028656, -0.023732390254735947, 0.03568373620510101, 0.05107329785823822, -0.005768029019236565, -0.012046001851558685, -0.024059738963842392, -0.003404509276151657, 0.009545219130814075, 0.02207958698272705, 0.06994972378015518, -0.011536459438502789, 0.011037202551960945, 0.04651573672890663, -0.01725829392671585, 0.041513409465551376, 0.043054141104221344, -0.009871163405478, 0.020478980615735054, 0.008401778526604176, 0.011890199035406113, -0.03705616667866707, 0.06194121390581131, -0.03599797934293747, 0.011233287863433361, -0.003347751684486866, -0.025584619492292404, 0.03484544903039932, 0.03365001827478409, 0.029218878597021103, -0.05802326276898384, -0.024642307311296463, -0.04881404712796211, 0.011441806331276894, 0.03093830868601799, 0.006725752260535955, 0.0419531911611557, 0.00598813546821475, 0.0288228839635849, -0.001960796071216464, 0.040469758212566376, 0.00007400594768114388, -0.09518903493881226, -0.003250313922762871, -0.022936657071113586, -0.017613500356674194, 0.015194873325526714, -0.002275866689160466, -0.029459303244948387, 0.03660915791988373, -0.01663481630384922, -0.0017922957194969058, 0.00593704916536808, 0.045016855001449585, -0.03190625458955765, 0.07732527703046799, -0.003310083644464612, 0.019604574888944626, -0.019137995317578316, -0.030517753213644028, 0.11075413972139359, 0.06531030684709549, 0.03269656002521515, -0.041923608630895615, -0.007076517213135958, -0.027518218383193016, -0.009437726810574532, -0.028918372467160225, -0.012936629354953766, 0.010839470662176609, -0.009620016440749168, 0.05762964114546776, 0.02822086215019226, -0.03403502702713013, -0.0023486383724957705, 0.07549086958169937, -0.05011061951518059, 0.01150285080075264, 0.016843760386109352, -0.008099911734461784, 0.002969712484627962, -0.0013916648458689451, -0.02253258228302002, 0.01914217509329319, 0.030059747397899628, -0.015924088656902313, -0.03373052552342415, -0.03094693273305893, 0.05134868621826172, 0.014605929143726826, 0.0003297388320788741, -0.004477388225495815, 0.003019175725057721, -0.015134637244045734, -0.010331816971302032, 0.001609356957487762, 0.02888842672109604, -0.038634225726127625, 0.002248904202133417, 0.04204249009490013, 0.012182063423097134, -0.04750275984406471, 0.005444382783025503, 0.016976704820990562, -0.06300774961709976, 0.0013909625122323632, -0.016315707936882973, 0.016225170344114304, -0.004742587450891733, -0.00870264321565628, -0.02652675472199917, 0.010726118460297585, 0.0003773821226786822, -0.03949521854519844, -0.033459436148405075, 0.007265880238264799, 0.024782050400972366, -0.03292306140065193, -0.017948675900697708, -0.0283258855342865, -0.019955376163125038, -0.01625516638159752, 0.014224621467292309, -0.0021142989862710238, -0.06372737139463425, -0.02663390524685383, -0.023207074031233788, 0.05730169638991356, -0.03731456771492958, 0.02124273031949997, 0.005635095294564962, -0.0038828677497804165, -0.02016443945467472, -0.042313236743211746, 0.019534973427653313, -0.03756650164723396, 0.026035817340016365, -0.01993010938167572, 0.022575316950678825, -0.003987159114331007, -0.013486413285136223, 0.006126832216978073, -0.013187598437070847, 0.03645939379930496, -0.0797109454870224, 0.018384605646133423, 0.033851541578769684, 0.022409949451684952, 0.0273541621863842, -0.019529806450009346, 0.025715334340929985, -0.009707518853247166, 0.010798502713441849, -0.05343901365995407, -0.009608563035726547, -0.009369765408337116, 0.0042944494634866714, -0.006970219314098358, -0.010472206398844719, 0.04277621954679489, 0.06554941833019257, 0.005693694110959768, -0.02589828334748745, -0.0031492593698203564, 0.008931268006563187, -0.0006339293322525918, 0.003585715079680085, -0.06968212872743607, -0.002049130853265524, -0.020750686526298523, 0.04945376142859459, -0.03509361669421196, 0.01895264908671379, -0.034292783588171005, 0.013110058382153511, 0.04235130921006203, 0.001809717039577663, -0.02738577127456665, 0.01169611420482397, 0.0020127478055655956, 0.0286116860806942, -0.040833376348018646, -0.004480456002056599, -0.010804004967212677, 0.026523733511567116, 0.015682725235819817, 0.0077157774940133095, -0.012771803885698318, -0.016503077000379562, -0.024308569729328156, -0.03882085904479027, 0.05244147405028343, 0.054141566157341, 0.0014763489598408341, 0.010325401090085506, 0.02621086873114109, -0.03573841601610184, 0.029912976548075676, -0.03434738516807556, -0.03642074763774872, 0.06025964021682739, -0.05870286002755165, -0.021720455959439278, 0.027502024546265602, 0.018636181950569153, 0.024560514837503433, 0.013815886341035366, 0.0374530628323555, -0.009473280049860477, 0.0010722096776589751, -0.021898392587900162, 0.00043307425221428275, -0.043913833796978, -0.02252870798110962, -0.01858476921916008, -0.025953209027647972, 0.00424078619107604, -0.013460157439112663, -0.004983819555491209, 0.012268097139894962, 0.02660452574491501, 0.01033017598092556, -0.0018138617742806673, 0.04588181525468826, 0.005539089906960726, -0.008906884118914604, 0.017820065841078758, 0.027731753885746002, 0.012236672453582287, 0.033005230128765106, -0.028806300833821297, 0.044790998101234436, -0.021084051579236984, 0.006999884266406298, -0.08340413123369217, -0.026359476149082184, 0.02026885561645031, -0.017993904650211334, -0.00171669980045408, -0.018077969551086426, -0.002906250534579158, -0.0068753263913095, -0.04187973216176033, -0.005795211065560579, 0.002824797062203288, -0.00771340960636735, -0.029921643435955048, 0.015332021750509739, 0.01605070009827614, 0.046371959149837494, 0.029992643743753433, 0.05147050693631172, 0.04514509439468384, 0.032091476023197174, -0.0018221322679892182, 0.015087203122675419, -0.027135426178574562, -0.001505497028119862, -0.02653583511710167, -0.10512679070234299, 0.05008384957909584, -0.022768322378396988, -0.025098716840147972, 0.039906080812215805, 0.02765430323779583, -0.04054057598114014, 0.02864457666873932, 0.018885286524891853, 0.046087052673101425, 0.031194955110549927, 0.0687604546546936, 0.007746062707155943, -0.0223158560693264, 0.023884471505880356, 0.022686215117573738, 0.016793526709079742, -0.03978709504008293, 0.02172524854540825, 0.021370822563767433, -0.0208490788936615, -0.019767295569181442, -0.015853801742196083, -0.020200956612825394, -0.0386514887213707, -0.008498132228851318, -0.01152657251805067, 0.0016083394875749946, -0.04312269762158394, 0.027487296611070633, -0.002356267301365733, -0.021639881655573845, 0.014181911014020443, 0.038237564265728, -0.002450600266456604, 0.028924643993377686, -0.016999773681163788, -0.06710748374462128, 0.011018873192369938, 0.008138592354953289, 0.019543930888175964, -0.044223885983228683, -0.008108986541628838, 0.007476937025785446, -0.016068166121840477, -0.015023174695670605, -0.007199018262326717, -0.04281098023056984, 0.0343741849064827, -0.03545428439974785, -0.01371396891772747, 0.041698966175317764, -0.0208602137863636, 0.013434908352792263, -0.07990355789661407, 0.060376621782779694, -0.0019850702956318855, 0.00102969107683748, -0.01778351701796055, 0.01603771187365055, -0.044590018689632416, -0.012996276840567589, 0.0727819949388504, -0.005180745851248503, 0.025045190006494522, -0.008891603909432888, -0.012031540274620056, 0.00582603644579649, -0.034374259412288666, -0.0030188162345439196, 0.012700032442808151, -0.04051930829882622, -0.019567104056477547, -0.015447143465280533, 0.0036140992306172848, 0.009333260357379913, 0.07334145158529282, -0.005645341705530882, 0.033940915018320084, -0.011496311984956264, -0.008720620535314083, 0.0024136491119861603, 0.030764387920498848, -0.029854780063033104, 0.06602071970701218, -0.014449169859290123, 0.004693307913839817, 0.0035238226410001516, -0.016014914959669113, -0.06834463775157928, 0.024782773107290268, -0.002759553724899888, -0.005521778017282486, 0.02109522931277752, -0.02469475381076336, -0.012044147588312626, -0.03367253392934799, -0.040054820477962494, 0.045186351984739304, -0.03463093936443329, 0.005052653606981039, 0.05722162500023842, 0.03754967078566551, 0.021550774574279785, -0.026920951902866364, 0.017301473766565323, 0.02229740470647812, -0.033502958714962006, 0.010715234093368053, 0.040738776326179504, 0.0528411865234375, 0.010041516274213791, 0.005028689745813608, -0.008107026107609272, -0.03332043066620827, 0.04020846262574196, 0.008023768663406372, 0.05209881812334061, -0.0376569963991642, -0.05042422562837601, 0.021051567047834396, 0.00593115808442235, 0.006635627243667841, 0.021158654242753983, -0.0338154062628746, 0.09143729507923126, -0.023046132177114487, -0.0031618820503354073, 0.011648868210613728, 0.025902044028043747, -0.052256353199481964, 0.0030381043907254934, -0.006984804291278124, 0.02961292490363121, 0.0411062054336071, -0.008510368876159191, 0.0020621190778911114, -0.008440868929028511, 0.026462098583579063, -0.018005676567554474, 0.015212573111057281, -0.006085749249905348, 0.008756984956562519, -0.02282569743692875, -0.027896853163838387, 0.006233213935047388, -0.01632385142147541, 0.040311671793460846, 0.00487589742988348, 0.037045758217573166, -0.01048912201076746, -0.042342960834503174, 0.012567478232085705, 0.03423597663640976, -0.05848399177193642, 0.0002224025665782392, -0.00981443002820015, -0.015638872981071472, 0.010915383696556091, -0.03998718038201332 ]
<p>I want to understand how I can compute the eigenvectors and the eigenvalues of a matrix using dimensional reduction.I have a Matrix $M$ of dimensions $n$ x $d$ using dimension reduction I can compute the eigenvectors and the eigenvalues of the Covariance matrix $MM^t$. After computing these eigenvectors and eigenvalues how can I compute the eigenvectors of the original matrix? </p>
46,056
[ 0.007184916641563177, 0.027895612642169, -0.02574254758656025, -0.05165674537420273, 0.05959443747997284, 0.012363954447209835, -0.042385026812553406, -0.03552844002842903, 0.027966314926743507, -0.05483859032392502, -0.002248139586299658, 0.00880290288478136, 0.0708184689283371, 0.04850466176867485, 0.05043650045990944, 0.005711641628295183, -0.040725357830524445, -0.020691558718681335, 0.019381461665034294, -0.011267637833952904, 0.004456091672182083, 0.009968345053493977, 0.024968072772026062, -0.0005245794309303164, -0.027585312724113464, 0.05849775671958923, 0.049905892461538315, -0.002356749027967453, 0.036758001893758774, 0.03530896455049515, -0.037557389587163925, 0.003668824676424265, 0.0177138801664114, 0.060325175523757935, -0.016209745779633522, 0.01493041217327118, -0.010748490691184998, 0.002823782619088888, -0.0004590466560330242, 0.009295091964304447, -0.011404822580516338, -0.031184550374746323, 0.012391158379614353, 0.04764450341463089, -0.013172143138945103, 0.01718764193356037, 0.00485222740098834, -0.017352288588881493, 0.0025282420683652163, -0.04250512272119522, 0.12571607530117035, -0.0012103101471439004, 0.032703083008527756, 0.03386859595775604, -0.011131526902318, 0.021242011338472366, 0.046723928302526474, 0.040145665407180786, 0.019966602325439453, -0.03352217748761177, -0.01412323396652937, -0.0331902839243412, 0.0011963589349761605, -0.03464784845709801, -0.020841097459197044, 0.014604303985834122, -0.0120549900457263, 0.005773637909442186, 0.025704508647322655, -0.013875504024326801, -0.02579507790505886, 0.0250873863697052, 0.017722895368933678, -0.025166401639580727, 0.005051098298281431, -0.0370054617524147, 0.0290966983884573, 0.01891499012708664, 0.03825861215591431, 0.006647265050560236, 0.028078651055693626, 0.05625856667757034, 0.0013016217853873968, -0.006005747709423304, 0.00602480536326766, -0.012107670307159424, 0.046283263713121414, -0.018288636580109596, 0.03932233154773712, 0.023946324363350868, -0.00807814858853817, 0.016775008291006088, 0.039292965084314346, -0.006622715387493372, -0.025885654613375664, 0.0001352496474282816, 0.020072154700756073, 0.04749597609043121, 0.0026431672740727663, -0.03747721388936043, -0.029448430985212326, -0.017750831320881844, 0.02680552378296852, 0.010045784525573254, 0.0015522094909101725, 0.01797620765864849, -0.018268130719661713, 0.02254300005733967, -0.01214353833347559, -0.0427146852016449, -0.026969056576490402, 0.004013447090983391, 0.01315233763307333, -0.0008078441023826599, 0.04482756182551384, 0.005830682814121246, -0.008327259682118893, -0.036893170326948166, 0.05973035842180252, 0.07419517636299133, -0.006258893758058548, -0.021650707349181175, 0.042090777307748795, -0.013367476873099804, -0.08254168182611465, 0.02748306840658188, -0.007453666999936104, -0.015064244158565998, -0.01806691288948059, 0.03509550169110298, -0.009889447130262852, -0.07768888771533966, 0.00805669091641903, 0.00537066301330924, 0.035347942262887955, -0.010264020413160324, -0.11449529975652695, -0.039162248373031616, 0.022323716431856155, -0.02978101745247841, -0.0029625052120536566, -0.05746850743889809, 0.024640386924147606, 0.016255000606179237, 0.051698584109544754, 0.01942371018230915, 0.03538620471954346, 0.02867720276117325, 0.02121642790734768, 0.011555911973118782, -0.018160706385970116, -0.04134877026081085, -0.04119783267378807, 0.006882069632411003, -0.0006258104112930596, -0.05931809917092323, 0.009916156530380249, 0.007965111173689365, -0.011247084476053715, -0.007537266239523888, 0.03783565014600754, -0.01899135299026966, -0.05175241827964783, 0.023867832496762276, 0.007582822814583778, -0.030596313998103142, 0.041834644973278046, -0.008823409676551819, 0.022570708766579628, 0.005042321979999542, -0.0008683331543579698, -0.01271472405642271, 0.007145931478589773, 0.08125808089971542, 0.03902618587017059, 0.00808804389089346, -0.018462389707565308, -0.009726839140057564, 0.015055396594107151, -0.0017177077243104577, -0.0200987346470356, -0.053800761699676514, 0.015579485334455967, -0.007736257277429104, 0.01732291281223297, 0.06562982499599457, -0.008960722014307976, -0.0224456824362278, 0.0018659144407138228, -0.008306306786835194, -0.016260452568531036, -0.06601296365261078, 0.035173509269952774, 0.0042744288221001625, -0.017092010006308556, -0.010363033041357994, 0.0216369666159153, 0.03748630732297897, -0.01853259652853012, -0.026563860476017, -0.029782110825181007, 0.0010388713562861085, -0.007428107317537069, -0.05429473891854286, -0.0038157454691827297, 0.00969440583139658, 0.06191464141011238, 0.011439795605838299, 0.08857440203428268, -0.0068481676280498505, -0.00987712386995554, 0.008358309045433998, -0.021148622035980225, -0.023258138447999954, -0.023270782083272934, -0.016284162178635597, 0.006074815057218075, -0.029326461255550385, -0.0033109525684267282, 0.01396181620657444, -0.0119300726801157, 0.051893774420022964, 0.07100183516740799, 0.017668645828962326, -0.008212974295020103, -0.0007017850875854492, 0.005041988100856543, 0.008984931744635105, 0.017077481374144554, -0.013289375230669975, -0.028059549629688263, -0.0064614457078278065, 0.018171275034546852, 0.05006162449717522, -0.06975363940000534, 0.022168032824993134, 0.04027516767382622, 0.04162539914250374, 0.04681095480918884, 0.05129406973719597, -0.023032816126942635, 0.0019223011331632733, 0.019988853484392166, 0.024481985718011856, -0.010989922098815441, -0.019215760752558708, -0.014459362253546715, 0.02945239655673504, 0.03446051478385925, 0.011117289774119854, -0.023621464148163795, 0.06040659174323082, -0.04463699460029602, -0.012927102856338024, -0.011745409108698368, -0.0410161130130291, 0.038979679346084595, -0.0017423185054212809, 0.007406619377434254, 0.031571488827466965, -0.007778550032526255, 0.018825504928827286, -0.004639641847461462, -0.00875876471400261, 0.014916296117007732, 0.023908860981464386, -0.03412313759326935, -0.011771206744015217, 0.02011389657855034, -0.021442754194140434, 0.04763943329453468, -0.0023139198310673237, -0.020334284752607346, -0.024327879771590233, 0.027265582233667374, 0.06502015143632889, -0.003769964911043644, 0.03663187101483345, -0.019963307306170464, -0.03234422579407692, 0.00952630303800106, -0.057838499546051025, 0.021555647253990173, 0.014605745673179626, -0.057936910539865494, 0.015784304589033127, -0.07136667519807816, -0.017017297446727753, 0.016460483893752098, -0.00014966966409701854, 0.006585932336747646, 0.01136031374335289, -0.009282601997256279, -0.0423920676112175, -0.014023113995790482, 0.011351410299539566, 0.02475898340344429, -0.005054406821727753, 0.03116627223789692, 0.020857596769928932, -0.007242343854159117, -0.003405463183298707, -0.007204257883131504, -0.03406418114900589, -0.02265113964676857, -0.044134948402643204, -0.025943642482161522, 0.013760820962488651, -0.02125830575823784, 0.017086980864405632, 0.049885135143995285, -0.01890864595770836, 0.03166072815656662, -0.05701266974210739, -0.03070610761642456, 0.01051163487136364, 0.026447948068380356, 0.03574584424495697, 0.0016265035374090075, -0.02504490502178669, 0.05656999722123146, 0.03428347036242485, -0.03644435852766037, -0.0356525219976902, 0.018179239705204964, -0.010467183776199818, -0.05433470755815506, 0.019774405285716057, 0.0019823818001896143, -0.03157762810587883, 0.0073659527115523815, 0.018803779035806656, -0.011271807365119457, 0.08157553523778915, -0.01744854636490345, 0.00047453338629566133, 0.02251347154378891, -0.011871496215462685, 0.02820274606347084, 0.021239250898361206, -0.034049008041620255, -0.022421251982450485, 0.031675998121500015, 0.02506549097597599, 0.021452782675623894, 0.012563815340399742, -0.03693349286913872, 0.007203471381217241, -0.016565285623073578, 0.021386032924056053, -0.036895327270030975, 0.01935737207531929, 0.03006722591817379, -0.013600646518170834, 0.018782876431941986, 0.013147200457751751, -0.0027070031501352787, -0.03479768708348274, 0.004717970732599497, 0.03843028470873833, -0.008265530690550804, -0.0026714878622442484, 0.0021556979045271873, 0.011529264971613884, -0.02060164324939251, 0.019293420016765594, -0.025099074468016624, -0.0029450873844325542, 0.049409154802560806, 0.015873104333877563, 0.02865936979651451, -0.012901386246085167, -0.02414749562740326, 0.0095395902171731, -0.06316618621349335, 0.00638620788231492, -0.02207987941801548, 0.04309077560901642, -0.024925608187913895, 0.06121481955051422, 0.003803469240665436, 0.0328240692615509, 0.01600273884832859, -0.012542466633021832, -0.05355312302708626, 0.037909675389528275, -0.06090430170297623, -0.01649976521730423, 0.014436431229114532, 0.006145785097032785, 0.03863988816738129, -0.010223343968391418, -0.01723386161029339, 0.02659859135746956, 0.009441489353775978, -0.04359513893723488, 0.012024689465761185, -0.027665048837661743, 0.007778604049235582, -0.02350747026503086, 0.023455820977687836, 0.06066123768687248, -0.031946681439876556, -0.011156341060996056, 0.049264851957559586, -0.01639297977089882, 0.01235415879637003, -0.005765480920672417, -0.015401440672576427, 0.040592826902866364, 0.019151166081428528, 0.03805771842598915, 0.029610978439450264, -0.006877359468489885, 0.02002173289656639, 0.007209517061710358, 0.06085320934653282, 0.014478331431746483, -0.014282116666436195, -0.002596211154013872, -0.020540960133075714, 0.01959194988012314, -0.005760386120527983, 0.06330063194036484, -0.053182266652584076, 0.003829361405223608, 0.030659489333629608, 0.041520316153764725, -0.051146503537893295, 0.044091932475566864, 0.06793168932199478, 0.02329658344388008, -0.03585798293352127, -0.02812284231185913, 0.02521209791302681, -0.029354168102145195, -0.009979739785194397, 0.019802849739789963, -0.024708496406674385, -0.006359238643199205, -0.019295327365398407, 0.03655504807829857, -0.030686471611261368, -0.007158373016864061, 0.02695532515645027, 0.025680692866444588, 0.049674808979034424, 0.02050631120800972, -0.008242041803896427, -0.00019986399274785072, 0.05400510132312775, 0.019182665273547173, -0.001695173908956349, 0.016985978931188583, -0.0661710873246193, 0.013454640284180641, 0.007056478410959244, 0.022601867094635963, -0.04471743851900101, -0.0015311851166188717, -0.044480614364147186, -0.03280606120824814, 0.0399283841252327, -0.02128094807267189, 0.03537745773792267, 0.01939975470304489, -0.00614530174061656, -0.014808899722993374, 0.04587450250983238, -0.019649799913167953, 0.0012200734345242381, -0.003953369800001383, 0.03856726735830307, -0.006423245184123516, -0.02080766297876835, -0.07131073623895645, 0.005428016651421785, 0.01959950663149357, 0.03498856723308563, 0.008637512102723122, 0.001209620269946754, -0.008786767721176147, 0.05926092714071274, -0.015093415044248104, -0.05660305917263031, 0.00915126595646143, 0.06501823663711548, -0.02384539507329464, 0.03444642946124077, -0.02878325805068016, -0.025175534188747406, 0.03867042064666748, 0.024143334478139877, -0.00962744653224945, 0.00005282520214677788, -0.01455344446003437, 0.03920728713274002, 0.01620599441230297, -0.01379204448312521, 0.05617417395114899, -0.01342350710183382, 0.002015765057876706, -0.01213702093809843, -0.026944253593683243, 0.03189797326922417, -0.031199462711811066, -0.0030459731351584196, -0.038653414696455, 0.016014281660318375, -0.007984996773302555, 0.050249308347702026, -0.029389217495918274, 0.03251851722598076, -0.01103184837847948, 0.0004945585387758911, -0.030021000653505325, 0.07006152719259262, -0.027985695749521255, -0.023474449291825294, 0.04309035837650299, 0.04292408004403114, -0.017556549981236458, -0.03849700093269348, 0.01030473317950964, 0.00021765939891338348, -0.010690579190850258, 0.005028924904763699, -0.0331440344452858, -0.01800786703824997, -0.03803941234946251, -0.0014397655613720417, 0.005673154257237911, -0.01833583042025566, 0.0250982828438282, -0.02186884917318821, -0.00035958155058324337, 0.025091690942645073, -0.0613892525434494, -0.021309614181518555, 0.013580355793237686, -0.00046834201202727854, 0.037615735083818436, -0.024171384051442146, 0.034625470638275146, -0.005842988379299641, -0.005175527185201645, -0.0823090597987175, -0.019139695912599564, -0.005517507903277874, 0.0006199990166351199, -0.030116107314825058, -0.02941141277551651, -0.014048987999558449, -0.03673223406076431, -0.028159579262137413, -0.030645886436104774, 0.03391731157898903, -0.003870344255119562, 0.036978043615818024, 0.041317977011203766, 0.024668416008353233, 0.057023096829652786, -0.028315197676420212, 0.011751535348594189, -0.005023769102990627, -0.01789337769150734, -0.014251015149056911, -0.004202281590551138, 0.062010545283555984, -0.017816541716456413, -0.006834912579506636, -0.04688839986920357, 0.01102452166378498, 0.040682531893253326, -0.03705494850873947, 0.0044458722695708275, 0.024257415905594826, 0.021547185257077217, -0.009219535626471043, -0.04582053795456886, -0.011032549664378166, 0.002533174119889736, 0.04988807439804077, 0.015417782589793205, -0.008529716171324253, -0.021518215537071228, -0.016395699232816696, 0.01988408900797367, -0.017871825024485588, 0.013941256329417229, 0.04285623878240585, 0.06709352135658264, -0.03350628912448883, 0.031071674078702927, 0.007338987197726965, -0.013620292767882347, 0.009061469696462154, -0.02198297716677189, 0.019289260730147362, -0.005097115878015757, -0.013943969272077084, -0.05879848077893257, -0.05320393294095993, -0.04912856966257095, 0.018929187208414078, 0.08109743893146515, -0.005629688035696745, 0.051966022700071335, 0.05005189776420593, -0.014125259593129158, 0.017071818932890892, -0.01610562577843666, -0.025837859138846397, 0.021038273349404335, 0.002999757183715701, 0.040943704545497894, 0.0008755765156820416, -0.021820729598402977, 0.041040800511837006, 0.013553624972701073, -0.012447013519704342, 0.0329207107424736, 0.00829444918781519, -0.0036746321711689234, 0.014475077390670776, 0.010431348346173763, -0.026943238452076912, 0.01950684003531933, -0.02908625453710556, -0.009291849099099636, -0.03390822932124138, -0.0035934075713157654, 0.04374116659164429, 0.043216731399297714, 0.005809810943901539, -0.037961747497320175, -0.023230640217661858, -0.04429878294467926, 0.03423323854804039, 0.027820920571684837, 0.02237427793443203, 0.008914594538509846, 0.0379205085337162, 0.03387231007218361, -0.0033785784617066383, 0.007312375120818615, 0.017724208533763885, -0.06036870554089546, -0.047882452607154846, -0.0406808964908123, -0.02785625495016575, 0.016208888962864876, 0.04022281616926193, -0.038612790405750275, 0.004804283380508423, -0.036527249962091446, 0.04120074212551117, 0.00781920924782753, 0.03589941933751106, -0.0320836678147316, 0.05528173968195915, 0.03127869591116905, 0.008698257617652416, 0.03192441537976265, 0.016354000195860863, 0.08556391298770905, 0.07428897172212601, 0.03281975910067558, -0.0926457867026329, 0.008386156521737576, 0.013558097183704376, -0.0471707358956337, -0.05054320767521858, 0.038840316236019135, -0.0021082968451082706, 0.030127620324492455, 0.011651736684143543, 0.031679410487413406, 0.0076598417945206165, 0.00685947434976697, 0.0081070801243186, -0.016015371307730675, -0.05629902333021164, -0.013572203926742077, 0.0032676358241587877, -0.004276108928024769, 0.019249333068728447, -0.07170189917087555, 0.032287366688251495, -0.039613787084817886, -0.029219796881079674, -0.041624605655670166, -0.0020977400708943605, 0.011341315694153309, -0.033453259617090225, -0.03953917697072029, 0.0068437643349170685, 0.028354352340102196, 0.013698793016374111, -0.03889937698841095, 0.04564010351896286, 0.015285897068679333, 0.0018779461970552802, 0.03567095845937729, 0.010036560706794262, -0.004454466048628092, 0.0011831301962956786, 0.007481989450752735, -0.014692559838294983, -0.01835949718952179, -0.0300351120531559, -0.027056898921728134, 0.0671868771314621, 0.009237795136868954, 0.013290846720337868, -0.008420680649578571, 0.0018193550640717149, -0.04017822444438934, -0.05490529537200928, 0.01435637567192316, 0.0002448441809974611, 0.042578089982271194, -0.01915089227259159, 0.0028612257447093725, -0.03911745548248291, 0.024651793763041496, -0.025892991572618484, 0.022940415889024734, 0.0022661916445940733, -0.013802574016153812, 0.0037963942158967257, -0.03909545764327049, 0.028516238555312157, -0.030749758705496788, -0.01750291883945465, -0.01309038233011961, -0.0022845049388706684, -0.001497269026003778, -0.07349992543458939, 0.007467323914170265, 0.013710470870137215, -0.005419974680989981, -0.002536088926717639, -0.011514443904161453, -0.030132805928587914, -0.0806739330291748, -0.01082608476281166, -0.00954426359385252, -0.004253419581800699, -0.018415141850709915, -0.013512120582163334, 0.03228147700428963, 0.04680554196238518, -0.009250795468688011, 0.01779603585600853, -0.025577418506145477, 0.0024142549373209476, 0.006574786733835936, -0.021343274042010307, -0.012435641139745712, 0.017602840438485146, -0.02872183360159397, 0.011109069921076298, -0.025453900918364525, 0.03236563503742218, 0.04064657911658287, 0.01892932690680027, -0.04872244969010353, 0.08368977159261703, -0.04086222127079964, -0.009412943385541439, -0.0053468793630599976, -0.05687333270907402, 0.03676365688443184, 0.02214580960571766, 0.00974323321133852, -0.05298003926873207, -0.015784116461873055, -0.018688762560486794, -0.01777014136314392, 0.010750447399914265, 0.011087153106927872, -0.010041730478405952, -0.012755700387060642, -0.026577303186058998, 0.025708643719553947, -0.03545524179935455, -0.014149155467748642, -0.019430123269557953, 0.02677799202501774, 0.01882448047399521, -0.04136624559760094, -0.030725881457328796, -0.017315464094281197, -0.016452834010124207, 0.009588707238435745, 0.04263682663440704, 0.04521339014172554, 0.012462045066058636, -0.020575478672981262, 0.0034468313679099083, -0.0051717148162424564, 0.07258274406194687, -0.0146219776943326, -0.011972677893936634, 0.02011413499712944, -0.07004082947969437, 0.015839243307709694, 0.029880117624998093, -0.01799360103905201, 0.04117048904299736, 0.018529139459133148, -0.008128181099891663, -0.03545459732413292, 0.02772875502705574, -0.05259542539715767, -0.022668354213237762, -0.020402958616614342, -0.005737641826272011, -0.016389917582273483, 0.017872491851449013, 0.02667044848203659, 0.0022140592336654663, -0.003545316169038415, 0.018325213342905045, 0.012948586605489254, -0.008470668457448483, -0.018874311819672585, 0.05049676448106766, 0.03324814885854721, 0.035576023161411285, 0.04902980476617813, -0.003694001119583845, 0.022077813744544983, 0.09603498131036758, -0.024870209395885468, 0.015920227393507957, 0.024553461000323296, 0.019231978803873062, -0.10970133543014526, 0.021266985684633255, 0.010473035275936127, 0.007174528203904629, 0.06025645509362221, -0.07389859855175018, 0.015014247968792915, 0.04711207002401352, -0.0529131181538105, 0.03789004310965538, -0.010023105889558792, -0.008170095272362232, -0.005746454931795597, 0.030711721628904343, 0.011981884017586708, 0.03195948526263237, 0.05265016481280327, 0.027126053348183632, 0.03671947121620178, 0.027936222031712532, -0.02058342471718788, -0.0039450726471841335, -0.009205903857946396, 0.04577677324414253, -0.011282333172857761, -0.06364423036575317, 0.018078120425343513, -0.03348364681005478, -0.05301952734589577, 0.026031669229269028, -0.027043737471103668, -0.009550489485263824, -0.01017987634986639, 0.022133521735668182, 0.010120309889316559, 0.003832580056041479, 0.027323294430971146, -0.0169812198728323, 0.0000822314468678087, 0.020493775606155396, -0.0035176086239516735, -0.016852956265211105, 0.014171985909342766, 0.03922675922513008, 0.02500370889902115, -0.029289986938238144, 0.0020450600422918797, -0.0034650189336389303, -0.02526453323662281, -0.02426876686513424, -0.009978276677429676, -0.051452357321977615, -0.005730730015784502, -0.05606316402554512, 0.01755833439528942, -0.0409490130841732, -0.02745325304567814, 0.02980733849108219, 0.005529358517378569, -0.011200753040611744, 0.032747782766819, -0.028200602158904076, -0.07079240679740906, 0.03654922544956207, 0.005102282855659723, -0.017359869554638863, -0.08646339178085327, -0.014593558385968208, 0.05326497182250023, -0.04630723595619202, -0.0022673639468848705, -0.039854515343904495, -0.037940509617328644, 0.03953949734568596, -0.009371474385261536, 0.010208282619714737, -0.018501831218600273, -0.05543162301182747, -0.010009532794356346, -0.06008104979991913, 0.012061131186783314, 0.014315351843833923, -0.08214539289474487, -0.020944636315107346, 0.01777132973074913, -0.019129183143377304, 0.010915961116552353, 0.037978604435920715, 0.018024858087301254, 0.018563326448202133, -0.017324525862932205, 0.007428317330777645, 0.02087434008717537, -0.06898520141839981, 0.019262049347162247, -0.018488962203264236, -0.023517761379480362, -0.03750567138195038, -0.02861015684902668, 0.01154114305973053, 0.017552124336361885, 0.0009679549839347601, 0.0009907744824886322, -0.013386959210038185, -0.00984889641404152, -0.0072393473237752914, 0.04159016162157059, -0.0008483259007334709, -0.0011130515486001968, 0.04232529178261757, -0.019639765843749046, -0.0010235364316031337, 0.048958662897348404, 0.0027529324870556593, -0.00784956943243742, 0.007673072628676891, -0.04875794053077698, 0.0015382308047264814, 0.015178032219409943, 0.005729323718696833, 0.026249339804053307, -0.053137801587581635, -0.008356285281479359, 0.06842250376939774, -0.0348505973815918, -0.017075572162866592, 0.04248960688710213, 0.019965218380093575, -0.002485225908458233, 0.012242046184837818, 0.015045872889459133, 0.0398811399936676, -0.03134014457464218, 0.03998776525259018, 0.04283110797405243, 0.009740427136421204, -0.012232202105224133, 0.011953094974160194, -0.00022708169126417488, -0.027781710028648376, 0.01524736825376749, -0.022230124101042747, 0.03762734308838844, -0.060655854642391205, -0.02668696828186512, 0.006453211419284344, -0.05861704424023628, 0.02172360010445118, -0.014188711531460285, -0.0443146787583828, 0.06272497773170471, -0.0637941062450409, -0.0012088853400200605, -0.00972138810902834, -0.024157395586371422, -0.03819887712597847, -0.01427031122148037, 0.0168942678719759, 0.022876141592860222, -0.004451082553714514, 0.01668168045580387, -0.0034922664053738117, -0.015219918452203274, 0.01569497399032116, -0.023528123274445534, 0.03562428429722786, 0.020043425261974335, -0.024218497797846794, -0.018614359200000763, -0.02516309544444084, -0.025514455512166023, -0.017091266810894012, 0.023996969684958458, 0.017370596528053284, 0.02892225794494152, 0.0064516025595366955, -0.025758028030395508, -0.02392636612057686, 0.011970925144851208, -0.08538632094860077, -0.0377352200448513, -0.046928856521844864, -0.0020268093794584274, -0.0003110062680207193, 0.044117894023656845 ]
<p>I have a preliminary study with very small sample size (n=26), and I want to test for differences between males and females and similar things, so I have to divide the sample and make comparisons of 13 vs 13 subjects.</p> <p>Is there a test I can use to give an idea of what the differences might be? Is it possible to use the two-independent-sample t-test even if the sample is this small and the variable is not normally distributed? What can I do otherwise? </p>
74,240
[ -0.03730522468686104, -0.0008208896615542471, -0.02435367926955223, -0.003555542090907693, 0.04526536911725998, -0.023965897038578987, -0.033074405044317245, -0.024311058223247528, 0.008569527417421341, -0.012151159346103668, 0.03903589025139809, 0.03919080272316933, 0.023979170247912407, 0.02600424364209175, -0.0006498289294540882, -0.004379441030323505, -0.04231208935379982, -0.022616276517510414, 0.01085048820823431, -0.007077801041305065, 0.004867322277277708, -0.009831652045249939, 0.0016637133667245507, 0.01531994342803955, -0.038992367684841156, 0.04197870194911957, 0.021576734259724617, -0.0642097070813179, 0.0407852903008461, 0.023537952452898026, -0.02533058077096939, -0.04856850951910019, 0.012132375501096249, 0.011889966204762459, -0.0049208179116249084, 0.0018501253798604012, -0.04242103919386864, -0.00932621955871582, 0.012167337350547314, 0.031171388924121857, -0.040524184703826904, 0.0001151453034253791, -0.009387562051415443, 0.0462370291352272, -0.04700200632214546, 0.018234260380268097, 0.026999589055776596, -0.08661776781082153, 0.057996299117803574, -0.06693151593208313, 0.04829062893986702, 0.02001110464334488, 0.050410471856594086, -0.007142032030969858, -0.0007250412600114942, -0.0019804968032985926, 0.0294311735779047, 0.08105289936065674, -0.028203193098306656, -0.04012613371014595, 0.002841109875589609, -0.0424262136220932, -0.02349497750401497, -0.012477449141442776, -0.04377436265349388, -0.022557517513632774, -0.04044339805841446, -0.017769159749150276, 0.018577950075268745, -0.010844990611076355, 0.03365285322070122, 0.04348825290799141, 0.03969637677073479, 0.010257474146783352, -0.01103965099900961, -0.01720099151134491, 0.049427829682826996, 0.02005740813910961, 0.034242939203977585, 0.029869716614484787, 0.010848294012248516, 0.010510432533919811, 0.013984471559524536, 0.04032714664936066, 0.029356349259614944, -0.0449010506272316, 0.05153176188468933, -0.0009298307122662663, -0.010305325500667095, 0.009233001619577408, -0.04668315127491951, -0.009744967333972454, 0.06348221004009247, 0.015182452276349068, -0.029163038358092308, 0.0002471386396791786, -0.02573838271200657, 0.027344347909092903, -0.03250519931316376, -0.026915527880191803, -0.013263475149869919, -0.04551402106881142, 0.0842071995139122, 0.0594702884554863, -0.03005404584109783, -0.013422345742583275, -0.04063538834452629, -0.010370957665145397, 0.0008342380751855671, -0.01152738556265831, -0.011457494460046291, 0.019939910620450974, 0.01070338673889637, 0.012986485846340656, 0.039757341146469116, 0.01696581393480301, -0.024463053792715073, -0.02597353234887123, 0.07200177013874054, 0.0771072506904602, 0.06951732933521271, -0.016518311575055122, 0.03864192217588425, -0.02723316103219986, -0.037516094744205475, 0.04142627492547035, 0.007337474729865789, -0.005122981034219265, -0.003974307328462601, 0.047699786722660065, -0.006856428924947977, -0.002730214037001133, 0.041009679436683655, -0.0005121438880451024, 0.03585454076528549, 0.005711261183023453, -0.06898068636655807, -0.07537420839071274, 0.039237067103385925, -0.016415797173976898, -0.026920408010482788, -0.06817935407161713, -0.0013358346186578274, 0.00623728334903717, 0.028536023572087288, 0.01590469665825367, 0.052163343876600266, -0.02850664034485817, 0.00787065364420414, 0.03165673092007637, -0.01761668361723423, 0.016331404447555542, -0.024422766640782356, -0.01822580397129059, 0.03572786971926689, -0.07223355770111084, 0.02551167644560337, 0.004558041226118803, 0.002080996986478567, 0.015000341460108757, 0.015454597771167755, 0.020466461777687073, -0.019195757806301117, 0.007804596330970526, 0.038531649857759476, -0.0221868883818388, 0.06656908988952637, -0.014476586133241653, 0.00777952466160059, 0.005120756570249796, -0.020115647464990616, 0.012138795107603073, 0.012875325977802277, 0.033853136003017426, 0.0430159866809845, 0.012203477323055267, -0.035146262496709824, 0.022574083879590034, 0.04158374294638634, 0.005233673844486475, -0.038818370550870895, 0.0020359563641250134, -0.019859950989484787, 0.012743096798658371, 0.014861712232232094, 0.04361540451645851, 0.021136213093996048, -0.025464603677392006, 0.07227768003940582, -0.01350515615195036, -0.05337901413440704, -0.06810954958200455, 0.006168060004711151, -0.0015234050806611776, -0.038617782294750214, 0.013925143517553806, 0.031178882345557213, 0.05136195197701454, -0.020935000851750374, -0.040667574852705, -0.0019501459319144487, -0.0014172079972922802, 0.018678972497582436, -0.03873525932431221, -0.0007456662715412676, 0.0447758249938488, 0.024907836690545082, -0.034328728914260864, 0.03260719031095505, -0.05221368372440338, -0.039035942405462265, 0.0459945984184742, -0.06077990308403969, 0.03350529819726944, 0.001653805491514504, 0.005531312897801399, -0.0066152699291706085, 0.025202510878443718, -0.011858885176479816, 0.044843804091215134, -0.040575798600912094, 0.09473828971385956, 0.036437105387449265, 0.004941833205521107, -0.031406670808792114, -0.03426336869597435, 0.040956512093544006, -0.010596498847007751, -0.0038697069976478815, -0.019915614277124405, -0.06063007935881615, -0.02486526034772396, 0.0578904002904892, -0.004939880222082138, -0.04979550093412399, 0.01175584364682436, 0.06476815044879913, -0.024229202419519424, 0.006647177040576935, 0.003920227754861116, 0.0255214124917984, -0.06188436597585678, -0.0013235227670520544, 0.03272167593240738, 0.0024224757216870785, 0.043052032589912415, 0.03588663786649704, 0.0039884173311293125, 0.04497701674699783, 0.015767032280564308, 0.0002834927581716329, 0.05425745248794556, -0.04152490943670273, 0.009584235958755016, -0.0012695048935711384, -0.04014531895518303, 0.05337728187441826, -0.044968362897634506, -0.015448316931724548, 0.053718451410532, 0.026761798188090324, -0.024404965341091156, 0.00520855700597167, -0.023919101804494858, 0.024040866643190384, 0.040372274816036224, -0.0028283381834626198, 0.012023071758449078, 0.03240577131509781, -0.0273587703704834, 0.0037701656110584736, -0.0023822265211492777, -0.031650472432374954, -0.04941264167428017, -0.023663263767957687, 0.04264026880264282, -0.008763428777456284, 0.03417135402560234, -0.020872080698609352, 0.012186470441520214, 0.0002662311017047614, -0.041090503334999084, 0.002693631686270237, -0.025503864511847496, -0.06312961131334305, 0.008385943248867989, -0.004898061044514179, -0.023426951840519905, 0.013823375105857849, -0.01459991279989481, 0.036745116114616394, 0.01682393252849579, -0.005000169388949871, -0.02971385419368744, -0.009184942580759525, -0.015059433877468109, 0.0030215352308005095, -0.01211570668965578, -0.029738934710621834, 0.026328744366765022, 0.004996006842702627, -0.012708024121820927, 0.020566856488585472, -0.004993263632059097, 0.0026851575821638107, -0.0003306686703581363, 0.016481054946780205, -0.0005285603692755103, -0.00880376249551773, -0.03562415763735771, 0.0332518145442009, -0.02857966162264347, 0.00025791212101466954, -0.07455068081617355, -0.05673997104167938, 0.02832426130771637, 0.03056447207927704, 0.03879772871732712, -0.01593637280166149, -0.012595152482390404, 0.06206698343157768, 0.012414242140948772, -0.017077647149562836, -0.04006338492035866, -0.00504651851952076, -0.05478179454803467, -0.01340581476688385, 0.051220014691352844, 0.024733707308769226, -0.010596133768558502, 0.004049711860716343, 0.025321563705801964, 0.010924378409981728, 0.040855541825294495, -0.018972955644130707, -0.010648436844348907, 0.03705406188964844, 0.020881716161966324, -0.011603649705648422, 0.03479702025651932, 0.0015702624805271626, -0.05377485975623131, -0.010112933814525604, -0.00516052171587944, 0.054712891578674316, 0.011454827152192593, -0.03400487080216408, 0.05271586403250694, 0.0064960359595716, -0.020199935883283615, -0.03267081081867218, -0.005916551221162081, 0.008394979871809483, 0.009793946519494057, 0.014946654438972473, 0.015591648407280445, 0.030246058478951454, -0.05576534569263458, 0.03130810707807541, 0.08300238102674484, 0.05378846079111099, -0.002346842782571912, 0.004938182886689901, -0.012188361957669258, 0.0026978428941220045, 0.011586594395339489, -0.01522788591682911, -0.030973857268691063, 0.07145915180444717, 0.07228249311447144, 0.0391116701066494, -0.008504076860845089, -0.03080594912171364, 0.011374948546290398, -0.0524606816470623, 0.00847740937024355, -0.00951314251869917, 0.029766013845801353, -0.00938474852591753, 0.050816673785448074, 0.01802912726998329, 0.03023235686123371, 0.0005869892775081098, -0.010882621631026268, -0.06472475826740265, 0.007816744968295097, -0.03318695351481438, -0.010716558434069157, 0.05294380709528923, 0.008442162536084652, 0.00886367168277502, -0.024974558502435684, 0.010855205357074738, 0.005067617166787386, 0.0445232167840004, -0.015017125755548477, 0.010239262133836746, -0.006546595133841038, -0.00630935886874795, 0.012359307147562504, 0.0220118910074234, -0.011114892549812794, -0.024584924802184105, -0.012275042943656445, 0.019120441749691963, -0.012291486375033855, -0.05500124394893646, -0.012178588658571243, 0.03300249204039574, 0.0025668630842119455, 0.034935083240270615, 0.01098029874265194, 0.02340523526072502, -0.023226652294397354, 0.014783196151256561, -0.018764670938253403, 0.03929243981838226, 0.02833045832812786, 0.01664239726960659, -0.01554300356656313, -0.02892022579908371, -0.014394129626452923, -0.00884957890957594, 0.018468910828232765, 0.008862178772687912, 0.007446181029081345, 0.04941541701555252, 0.021877005696296692, -0.01934880018234253, -0.0017091401387006044, 0.023145252838730812, 0.007075190544128418, -0.011694954708218575, -0.048927467316389084, -0.012380145490169525, -0.007227421272546053, -0.02372700162231922, 0.01076553761959076, 0.012668957002460957, 0.011446432210505009, -0.02646471932530403, 0.05234260484576225, -0.04258351773023605, -0.04370921105146408, -0.007345163729041815, -0.021069228649139404, 0.048054203391075134, 0.01846969500184059, -0.03488051891326904, 0.017579924315214157, 0.015404253266751766, 0.016159454360604286, 0.035500943660736084, -0.002462357748299837, -0.0372900627553463, 0.020610040053725243, 0.05512119084596634, 0.04937639459967613, -0.03018823079764843, -0.008850720711052418, -0.015202855691313744, 0.006220668088644743, 0.06666914373636246, -0.02592947520315647, -0.001820212695747614, -0.015109015628695488, -0.007931679487228394, -0.04002305865287781, -0.0017042807303369045, -0.019993484020233154, -0.007977096363902092, 0.0007050926215015352, -0.01476914994418621, 0.003642959985882044, -0.02615678496658802, -0.02745816484093666, 0.00023094794596545398, 0.03616141527891159, 0.056398823857307434, -0.031036410480737686, -0.0015823771245777607, 0.02048364095389843, 0.0038319136947393417, -0.010945919901132584, -0.027647634968161583, -0.002574919257313013, 0.020889487117528915, -0.03613806888461113, 0.057500772178173065, -0.03885417804121971, -0.040793873369693756, 0.023171745240688324, 0.0034731030464172363, -0.05427258461713791, 0.019475020468235016, -0.03314518928527832, 0.014698036946356297, 0.015369992703199387, 0.013006540946662426, 0.06612664461135864, 0.03136267140507698, 0.01091023813933134, 0.006343107204884291, -0.010262006893754005, 0.026294702664017677, -0.03853462636470795, -0.022778401151299477, -0.056440625339746475, -0.02057543769478798, 0.025267528370022774, 0.03238663077354431, 0.008653494529426098, 0.027268363162875175, -0.017133453860878944, -0.04208717122673988, 0.003657338907942176, 0.021530408412218094, 0.04505787044763565, 0.024858349934220314, 0.008493279106914997, 0.009029931388795376, -0.005060396622866392, -0.003776692086830735, 0.02790369652211666, -0.016317090019583702, 0.01876138709485531, 0.00013069971464574337, -0.04209957271814346, 0.006093161180615425, -0.05204625800251961, -0.06143350899219513, 0.04333270341157913, -0.018920298665761948, 0.0507410392165184, -0.009639442898333073, 0.025271225720643997, 0.016839325428009033, -0.034707311540842056, 0.007065724581480026, 0.04624508321285248, 0.027369288727641106, 0.06367209553718567, -0.02463374473154545, 0.0524677149951458, 0.003125004470348358, -0.01292338129132986, -0.09307997673749924, -0.035892304033041, 0.014230257831513882, 0.004482951946556568, 0.020265238359570503, -0.024276774376630783, -0.004549623467028141, -0.013102302327752113, 0.0071448758244514465, -0.009832984767854214, 0.0566832572221756, 0.005098818335682154, -0.01476331427693367, 0.00449393829330802, 0.013260960578918457, 0.09660795331001282, 0.03890937566757202, -0.01809031330049038, -0.03263771906495094, -0.047183193266391754, -0.023447653278708458, -0.015507955104112625, 0.017819587141275406, -0.0386737696826458, -0.026252571493387222, -0.009189583361148834, 0.007251495961099863, 0.04587741941213608, -0.05176236853003502, -0.04100210219621658, 0.008430028334259987, -0.013144202530384064, 0.001272445311769843, -0.019607726484537125, 0.001110672834329307, -0.0000578986837354023, 0.01821344718337059, -0.06851672381162643, -0.009786424227058887, -0.0011294091818854213, 0.01049785129725933, 0.039995089173316956, 0.02945389226078987, -0.04362686350941658, 0.006831150967627764, 0.032859593629837036, 0.005219811107963324, -0.0007194252102635801, 0.014018543995916843, -0.020888349041342735, 0.01592337340116501, 0.009471043944358826, -0.012120471335947514, -0.006438808981329203, 0.04533190652728081, -0.059048861265182495, -0.03804006800055504, 0.0035431019496172667, -0.0014645201154053211, 0.026754289865493774, 0.018848394975066185, 0.0281673576682806, 0.07186193764209747, 0.00940755195915699, 0.019938809797167778, 0.008732818067073822, -0.0022679867688566446, -0.008631706237792969, -0.021049929782748222, 0.031664151698350906, -0.007469652220606804, -0.009278599172830582, 0.04233314469456673, 0.03199027106165886, -0.0021326083224266768, 0.06818348169326782, 0.03304613381624222, 0.018698351457715034, 0.042175162583589554, -0.038694582879543304, -0.0512600801885128, 0.020498501136898994, -0.03708209842443466, 0.023345809429883957, -0.0659131333231926, 0.026382900774478912, 0.051524631679058075, 0.024058975279331207, 0.026424290612339973, -0.03847148269414902, -0.01960195228457451, -0.052276067435741425, -0.008620795793831348, 0.045525677502155304, -0.016407757997512817, -0.00031551331630907953, -0.01233533676713705, 0.06933464109897614, -0.015209286473691463, 0.018169663846492767, -0.026569295674562454, -0.0714721828699112, -0.01205439679324627, -0.02599484473466873, -0.037138741463422775, 0.03952319547533989, -0.032475490123033524, -0.0067059132270514965, 0.03281616047024727, -0.005213535390794277, 0.030781347304582596, -0.023065853863954544, 0.005969264544546604, -0.03065917268395424, 0.04438505321741104, -0.04217622056603432, 0.023615889251232147, 0.00418502651154995, 0.022338109090924263, 0.10603699833154678, 0.055295225232839584, 0.02830265834927559, -0.03662717342376709, 0.03886651247739792, -0.01769457384943962, -0.003411258338019252, 0.020311975851655006, 0.008529786951839924, 0.011336207389831543, -0.03150743991136551, 0.052037563174963, 0.05692017450928688, -0.010423705913126469, -0.02325507253408432, 0.07926984131336212, 0.007976015098392963, -0.031537558883428574, -0.002260838868096471, 0.032855212688446045, -0.007091034669429064, -0.034620996564626694, -0.014524235390126705, 0.03412112966179848, 0.008414605632424355, -0.006843442562967539, -0.026731355115771294, 0.006323504727333784, 0.015356805175542831, 0.019198626279830933, -0.04605058953166008, -0.013398237526416779, 0.022059373557567596, 0.031193513423204422, -0.02760579250752926, -0.025128673762083054, -0.007157639600336552, -0.04137735068798065, -0.005394396837800741, 0.04408246651291847, 0.000522077374625951, 0.004394532181322575, 0.017885399982333183, -0.005752855446189642, -0.041502565145492554, -0.028066303580999374, 0.0035324725322425365, 0.03612970933318138, 0.007572943810373545, -0.021121256053447723, -0.036324769258499146, 0.01966593600809574, -0.020601850003004074, -0.029948914423584938, -0.006848766468465328, 0.011786519549787045, -0.0217666644603014, -0.037155333906412125, -0.0035633365623652935, -0.0341302752494812, 0.026663323864340782, 0.005173301789909601, 0.004637292120605707, 0.03659091144800186, -0.0009794017532840371, -0.018265049904584885, -0.001579045201651752, -0.0010936310281977057, 0.010289150290191174, -0.018738053739070892, -0.017657021060585976, -0.001379981404170394, -0.00944453850388527, -0.009106441400945187, -0.02975158579647541, 0.021674437448382378, 0.027436329051852226, 0.03641657903790474, -0.015841437503695488, -0.026876434683799744, -0.01467942539602518, 0.02067861519753933, -0.009817815385758877, 0.010644395835697651, -0.012258798815310001, -0.010281377471983433, 0.023442624136805534, 0.005369760561734438, 0.03520161285996437, -0.002532094717025757, 0.018604474142193794, 0.0468989834189415, 0.027294307947158813, -0.05976905673742294, -0.04457806795835495, -0.03212551772594452, -0.017743702977895737, -0.0010809187078848481, -0.010282357223331928, 0.04138357564806938, -0.011071638204157352, 0.0054641892202198505, 0.008671866729855537, -0.026424886658787727, -0.027477804571390152, 0.022167935967445374, -0.006324598100036383, -0.06820592284202576, -0.04899304732680321, 0.028469499200582504, 0.003563779639080167, -0.018379662185907364, -0.04283667728304863, -0.0368625782430172, -0.029257748275995255, 0.022186627611517906, -0.03803451359272003, -0.014337274245917797, -0.016410233452916145, -0.019617237150669098, 0.020685771480202675, -0.02026224322617054, 0.02075107954442501, -0.010227971710264683, -0.024665942415595055, 0.010394930839538574, 0.024975473061203957, 0.009097008034586906, 0.005208889488130808, -0.015975868329405785, 0.030450018122792244, 0.05849458649754524, 0.0009760037064552307, 0.017970308661460876, 0.046198222786188126, 0.026740089058876038, 0.00950267631560564, 0.01804737187922001, 0.009525884874165058, -0.019359605386853218, 0.03936624154448509, -0.04218152537941933, -0.03306436166167259, 0.008433769457042217, -0.004799914080649614, 0.040503162890672684, 0.026164334267377853, -0.02196718007326126, -0.011237452737987041, 0.04863663762807846, -0.02511034533381462, -0.040580347180366516, 0.008680716156959534, 0.019511209800839424, 0.014945493079721928, -0.011999048292636871, -0.0049104043282568455, -0.005574807990342379, -0.031739242374897, 0.06029767170548439, 0.03364920988678932, 0.014574527740478516, -0.027417467907071114, -0.014878355897963047, 0.020064419135451317, -0.0017218118300661445, -0.03473665937781334, -0.045049358159303665, 0.06654620170593262, 0.05027512460947037, -0.0326097309589386, 0.023121949285268784, -0.01208161935210228, 0.0021122985053807497, -0.08978457748889923, -0.019227778539061546, 0.006914118304848671, -0.0005940113915130496, 0.02886035107076168, -0.054369278252124786, -0.007172977551817894, 0.011487533338367939, -0.034908369183540344, 0.014937865547835827, 0.0036171029787510633, -0.04314148426055908, -0.04666023328900337, -0.00675311079248786, -0.014704613015055656, 0.015288583934307098, -0.023599395528435707, 0.037787601351737976, 0.0052656447514891624, 0.06406853348016739, -0.01613450050354004, -0.04135030508041382, -0.008798732422292233, 0.00139680877327919, 0.03374144807457924, -0.06177458539605141, 0.0037088787648826838, -0.02841896377503872, -0.057712238281965256, 0.03683667257428169, -0.018953964114189148, 0.04801029711961746, 0.008960633538663387, 0.003272001165896654, 0.0024430493358522654, 0.06485289335250854, 0.027258727699518204, -0.02958165481686592, -0.02247920073568821, 0.010706029832363129, -0.042603932321071625, 0.013775452971458435, 0.025539455935359, -0.00706661120057106, 0.05516090989112854, -0.030802709981799126, 0.012953238561749458, 0.001415554783307016, -0.01168121863156557, -0.023015622049570084, -0.010336017236113548, -0.026621047407388687, 0.044635772705078125, 0.006918018683791161, 0.024282965809106827, -0.04037928581237793, -0.02298005111515522, -0.002774077234789729, 0.03281791880726814, -0.05788811296224594, 0.031617049127817154, -0.0074363467283546925, -0.03232250735163689, 0.006832415703684092, 0.021340884268283844, 0.012032724916934967, -0.06248404085636139, 0.01624918170273304, -0.020466836169362068, 0.01055923756211996, -0.0574897825717926, -0.018296312540769577, -0.011289398185908794, 0.0023146222811192274, -0.03990559279918671, 0.02031627856194973, 0.00647297129034996, 0.0055442675948143005, -0.0011140774004161358, -0.07756412774324417, 0.028334204107522964, -0.028755800798535347, -0.01694832742214203, -0.015542984940111637, -0.01141450461000204, -0.04372658580541611, -0.013475967571139336, 0.06780707836151123, 0.030170418322086334, 0.01854918897151947, 0.0030475864186882973, 0.011276942677795887, -0.01841181516647339, -0.082695871591568, 0.030723556876182556, -0.03276735916733742, -0.022658076137304306, -0.0018369454191997647, -0.023139864206314087, 0.02861594222486019, -0.017421375960111618, 0.04960007965564728, -0.02515888772904873, -0.026931939646601677, -0.03424812853336334, 0.019991587847471237, 0.025683466345071793, 0.009051910601556301, -0.03120451234281063, 0.04403156414628029, -0.024283185601234436, 0.025816701352596283, -0.005026301834732294, 0.008736391551792622, -0.04268826171755791, 0.04315678030252457, -0.03348022326827049, 0.002637196099385619, -0.024947186931967735, 0.01489184983074665, 0.015596725046634674, -0.03173665702342987, 0.02217358909547329, -0.01337891910225153, 0.0207460168749094, 0.026047302410006523, 0.014681396074593067, 0.05661730840802193, -0.01642550714313984, -0.01870741695165634, 0.028153926134109497, 0.0333559513092041, -0.046286098659038544, 0.02272922359406948, -0.0003092369297519326, -0.008116098120808601, -0.002713229041546583, -0.0020437673665583134, 0.02424432896077633, -0.04029012843966484, 0.03850545361638069, 0.015977943316102028, -0.009274602867662907, 0.015146332792937756, -0.024754242971539497, 0.03024858981370926, 0.012329558841884136, 0.033382710069417953, -0.006791424471884966, 0.01081156823784113, 0.06008150801062584, -0.017123928293585777, -0.022610846906900406, -0.056559156626462936, 0.022330308333039284, -0.030165288597345352, -0.012135760858654976, 0.0651865303516388, 0.03232596069574356, -0.010479362681508064, 0.003632222069427371, -0.017427723854780197, -0.013151722028851509, 0.013050852343440056, -0.02860063686966896, 0.03387228772044182, -0.0106081273406744, -0.014220834709703922, -0.01955866441130638, -0.005816003307700157, -0.061401572078466415, -0.0418248288333416, 0.04548657312989235, 0.06705113500356674, 0.017595021054148674, -0.01474844291806221, -0.023623134940862656, 0.017917059361934662, 0.06217198818922043, -0.060889486223459244, -0.06691964715719223, -0.046981289982795715, 0.020928358659148216, 0.012899890542030334, -0.045616552233695984 ]
<p>I'm trying to compute ANOVA effect sizes from papers that provide an F value without other information. If I understand correctly, the effect size for a single-factor ANOVA is $$ \eta {2} = \frac{ss_{between}}{ss_{between} + ss_{error}} $$</p> <p>And the F value is: $$ F = \frac{(N-k)ss_{between}}{(k-1)(ss_{between} + ss_{error})} $$ <strong>UPDATE: Nope! the denominator is just [(k-1)*SSerror]. Thus, everything that follows is invalid. Back to first-years stats for me.</strong></p> <p>Where N = number of observations and k = number of groups. </p> <p><strong>Question 1:</strong> Does it follow that you can calculate eta squared as: $$ \eta {2} = \frac{k-1}{N-k}F $$</p> <p><strong>Question 2:</strong> I tried checking this in some output from SPSS. Here's an example with k=4 and N=158:</p> <p><img src="https://dl.dropbox.com/u/5473621/spss_etasq_output2.png" alt="SPSS output with relevant values described below"></p> <p>I'm aware that SPSS gives partial eta squared, but for a single-factor ANOVA that should be the same as eta squared, right? And indeed, the ratio of the sums of squares is $\frac{342.872}{(342.872+6133.519)} = .05294$. But using F, we get $2.870*3/154 = .05591$, which is off by much more than rounding error. </p> <p>Is SPSS subtly adjusting F somehow, or am I confused about how to calculate eta squared?</p>
74,241
[ -0.015321913175284863, -0.025896260514855385, -0.0030374345369637012, 0.04008764773607254, 0.05440429598093033, 0.03336667641997337, -0.006132102105766535, -0.0796148031949997, 0.06128738075494766, -0.03126620873808861, 0.03202369436621666, -0.006442745216190815, 0.04047165438532829, 0.037417732179164886, -0.006322464440017939, 0.023762252181768417, -0.017574908211827278, 0.01224516797810793, -0.0008159804856404662, -0.00016074636369012296, -0.013908314518630505, 0.06176062300801277, -0.04540994390845299, -0.028638197109103203, -0.04616810381412506, 0.03687653690576553, 0.011365086771547794, -0.06977112591266632, 0.010010858066380024, 0.04867890104651451, -0.016755493357777596, -0.0025412882678210735, 0.02004348486661911, 0.03405887261033058, 0.0038462206721305847, -0.009705036878585815, 0.010691468603909016, -0.019819051027297974, -0.0052309418097138405, 0.02769019640982151, -0.03733210265636444, 0.005657282192260027, -0.01583116687834263, 0.015502071008086205, 0.007955596782267094, 0.010629609227180481, -0.027786746621131897, -0.015899458900094032, 0.02191227674484253, -0.05895869806408882, 0.0524175725877285, 0.04795679822564125, 0.05021130293607712, 0.06784932315349579, -0.0018561771139502525, 0.024739818647503853, 0.022025564685463905, 0.022643184289336205, 0.008302775211632252, -0.04115702584385872, -0.03728160634636879, -0.04168512299656868, 0.013423800468444824, -0.008642303757369518, -0.03246447071433067, 0.0069629778154194355, -0.011290458030998707, -0.01446046307682991, 0.03954242542386055, -0.008811453357338905, 0.029054418206214905, 0.0342494398355484, 0.040616292506456375, -0.004627189598977566, 0.029787827283143997, -0.02068469300866127, 0.02669062837958336, -0.029270190745592117, 0.09163373708724976, 0.07895611971616745, -0.005585289094597101, 0.013937050476670265, 0.01935603842139244, 0.018806092441082, 0.029577333480119705, 0.022132663056254387, 0.048774316906929016, -0.01671532541513443, 0.002590135671198368, 0.014031723141670227, -0.038631707429885864, 0.01604609563946724, 0.036698102951049805, 0.0009011305519379675, -0.017619779333472252, 0.05186745151877403, -0.025016548112034798, 0.01896238699555397, -0.00938341673463583, -0.005206969100981951, -0.021754680201411247, -0.06035546213388443, 0.0022494967561215162, 0.04436519742012024, -0.0033939138520509005, -0.001306388177908957, -0.017202554270625114, 0.015372050926089287, -0.014382736757397652, -0.040332403033971786, -0.0209848303347826, 0.010451354086399078, -0.026704050600528717, -0.0015663783997297287, 0.011659996584057808, -0.002336005447432399, -0.04586297646164894, -0.012208692729473114, 0.014902366325259209, 0.06726006418466568, 0.055392783135175705, -0.009666558355093002, 0.019959449768066406, -0.014038071036338806, -0.019870303571224213, 0.05114230886101723, 0.02675608918070793, -0.03250594809651375, -0.041790418326854706, 0.06913547962903976, -0.009855926968157291, 0.006166243460029364, 0.013455482199788094, 0.02537929080426693, -0.019517704844474792, 0.013339165598154068, -0.06366007030010223, -0.08389158546924591, 0.05107339844107628, 0.0012947827344760299, -0.005553311202675104, -0.09587227553129196, -0.023066217079758644, 0.015266122296452522, 0.07289129495620728, -0.0002840801898855716, 0.018386082723736763, -0.028376026079058647, 0.027556346729397774, 0.044015027582645416, -0.04213517904281616, 0.00880805030465126, -0.04547331482172012, -0.03703652322292328, 0.0012864562449976802, -0.06901830434799194, 0.03797387704253197, 0.023247111588716507, 0.04032488167285919, -0.0037307175807654858, 0.0668564885854721, 0.02424663119018078, -0.021265417337417603, 0.02287791296839714, -0.012634801678359509, -0.013990565203130245, 0.05637448653578758, 0.001782106002792716, 0.009824502281844616, 0.01688302494585514, -0.021705688908696175, 0.0007073463639244437, 0.007646089419722557, 0.013348712585866451, 0.04523012042045593, -0.006925993133336306, -0.0060323793441057205, -0.03291408345103264, 0.02452741004526615, -0.010846678167581558, -0.05139586329460144, -0.0056778499856591225, -0.04818965122103691, -0.0002316008321940899, 0.017806420102715492, 0.0468255877494812, -0.006859184708446264, -0.011626659892499447, 0.027441145852208138, -0.043701380491256714, -0.07008777558803558, -0.0644189640879631, 0.029645806178450584, 0.012714928016066551, -0.06050640717148781, -0.000052063540351809934, 0.010282379575073719, 0.017384659498929977, -0.003453007899224758, -0.009674147702753544, -0.0029464703984558582, 0.004884927533566952, 0.03457031771540642, -0.026418762281537056, 0.028195679187774658, 0.06551656126976013, 0.04660695046186447, -0.0006111086113378406, 0.03393063321709633, -0.0461973175406456, -0.02345461957156658, -0.023389039561152458, -0.032969437539577484, 0.01936148852109909, -0.04117252305150032, -0.04601192846894264, 0.01879791170358658, 0.018702514469623566, -0.006665702443569899, 0.03251703083515167, -0.06132291257381439, 0.05746099352836609, 0.05647846683859825, 0.01832420751452446, 0.031758639961481094, -0.006603270303457975, 0.044898390769958496, 0.012660792097449303, -0.025906579568982124, 0.0027666310779750347, -0.042096201330423355, -0.01767648570239544, 0.027748899534344673, -0.03990447521209717, -0.013766885735094547, 0.019143620505928993, 0.06482498347759247, -0.030535368248820305, -0.0020122681744396687, 0.004772865679115057, 0.004632893484085798, -0.01340677309781313, -0.00795657467097044, 0.04815461114048958, 0.034603301435709, 0.02967626228928566, -0.013390811160206795, 0.024897975847125053, 0.040496982634067535, 0.04353324696421623, 0.012087828479707241, 0.04228733852505684, -0.018353980034589767, 0.013398638926446438, -0.009839855134487152, 0.016470598056912422, 0.05015348643064499, -0.02633180469274521, -0.012776931747794151, 0.017561664804816246, -0.023315325379371643, -0.01298542320728302, -0.03336659446358681, -0.029045257717370987, 0.044611360877752304, 0.0028310935012996197, -0.010010156780481339, 0.0003412718651816249, -0.019839823246002197, -0.028995009139180183, 0.042464107275009155, -0.022910431027412415, -0.05364219471812248, -0.013192503713071346, 0.025485873222351074, 0.029956240206956863, 0.005656735971570015, 0.0038805981166660786, -0.021057717502117157, 0.030675621703267097, 0.026463249698281288, 0.005862910766154528, 0.013489674776792526, 0.009992772713303566, -0.05621417984366417, -0.007771170232445002, -0.013859379105269909, 0.016458366066217422, 0.005794820375740528, -0.0140524348244071, -0.0347297377884388, 0.025243647396564484, 0.024855194613337517, -0.03451831266283989, -0.02312157116830349, -0.011558489874005318, -0.025838108733296394, -0.0322205126285553, 0.005599036347121, -0.010489351116120815, -0.010348666459321976, -0.0169511865824461, 0.03891180828213692, 0.004226905759423971, 0.006721039302647114, -0.016483129933476448, 0.0060523077845573425, 0.006879398133605719, -0.015081292018294334, -0.01759934239089489, 0.015206385403871536, -0.019125109538435936, -0.033759694546461105, -0.05691039562225342, -0.05115946754813194, -0.001749835442751646, -0.008775259368121624, 0.042458027601242065, 0.005835384130477905, -0.032256465405225754, 0.09082875400781631, 0.004576793406158686, 0.006383033469319344, -0.05873248353600502, -0.017504790797829628, -0.020403845235705376, -0.057723287492990494, -0.010782510042190552, 0.0021349929738789797, 0.006341147236526012, 0.019455252215266228, -0.03525833040475845, 0.0046115415170788765, 0.04946940019726753, -0.011193457990884781, -0.006131227593868971, 0.006931804120540619, -0.021680055186152458, -0.04167313128709793, 0.055278729647397995, 0.029541926458477974, -0.0002602336462587118, 0.007707055192440748, 0.02981366217136383, 0.04071402549743652, -0.004925187677145004, -0.029971878975629807, 0.038375698029994965, -0.03585640341043472, -0.006855254992842674, -0.023981502279639244, 0.029106810688972473, 0.024493465200066566, -0.026602940633893013, -0.016269680112600327, 0.010808293707668781, 0.020826278254389763, -0.029091939330101013, 0.014901680871844292, 0.01328419428318739, 0.029983578249812126, -0.0007118918001651764, -0.03719552606344223, -0.026694729924201965, -0.020783614367246628, 0.017239734530448914, 0.0010724844178184867, 0.016361908987164497, 0.05381340533494949, 0.06816931813955307, 0.037530653178691864, -0.018603920936584473, -0.022545646876096725, 0.00457186670973897, -0.07009854167699814, -0.009297827258706093, -0.059996120631694794, 0.03610585257411003, 0.02051231451332569, 0.030435848981142044, -0.0005645428318530321, -0.030262410640716553, -0.026766467839479446, -0.02132560685276985, -0.05534587800502777, 0.015780694782733917, -0.003200958715751767, -0.04436900466680527, 0.033151775598526, -0.00813252478837967, 0.031174559146165848, -0.020463716238737106, -0.0030661250930279493, -0.013874919153749943, 0.028860583901405334, 0.026024356484413147, 0.00033949693897739053, -0.0021545712370425463, -0.005340913310647011, -0.039133090525865555, -0.00413628201931715, 0.009476752951741219, -0.019199427217245102, 0.01528309565037489, 0.0333169624209404, -0.019043413922190666, -0.010870753787457943, -0.03704792261123657, 0.026972074061632156, 0.028450828045606613, 0.03212955594062805, 0.04037731885910034, 0.0033178788144141436, -0.052008263766765594, 0.04246136173605919, 0.000883079890627414, 0.015630438923835754, 0.06309761106967926, -0.0137055404484272, -0.034843795001506805, -0.006760978139936924, -0.021538948640227318, 0.0052223606035113335, 0.022930238395929337, -0.00010905002272920683, 0.005572483409196138, 0.023925555869936943, 0.025123726576566696, -0.024887684732675552, 0.029733017086982727, 0.05217023938894272, -0.01784251630306244, -0.0019193122861906886, -0.05878483131527901, 0.0016182481776922941, -0.008728987537324429, -0.014783937484025955, 0.04087114334106445, 0.0409429669380188, 0.021326741203665733, -0.004547333810478449, 0.027640758082270622, -0.01722653955221176, -0.03866998851299286, 0.028820224106311798, -0.008067265152931213, 0.009683212265372276, 0.009870246984064579, -0.012711399234831333, -0.0018176761223003268, 0.05937289446592331, 0.07287977635860443, -0.004121766425669193, 0.013310495764017105, -0.09100385755300522, -0.02000368945300579, 0.01876610331237316, 0.05943555384874344, -0.033917952328920364, 0.018407803028821945, 0.018158087506890297, -0.00972886011004448, -0.008824939839541912, -0.024971961975097656, 0.06647048145532608, 0.005027133505791426, 0.024595456197857857, -0.02690982259809971, -0.023740125820040703, -0.014673128724098206, 0.04192399978637695, -0.022241687402129173, 0.034298405051231384, 0.030718300491571426, -0.017474696040153503, -0.04698144271969795, -0.01760605350136757, -0.00547368498519063, 0.045617904514074326, 0.005476727150380611, -0.04662707820534706, 0.020931189879775047, 0.0415327288210392, -0.04597608372569084, -0.06552378088235855, 0.03931194171309471, -0.037562672048807144, -0.01672024093568325, 0.057895272970199585, -0.026300672441720963, -0.0406329445540905, 0.017622847110033035, 0.01295505091547966, -0.03404334932565689, -0.01958486996591091, -0.03636464104056358, 0.05189135670661926, 0.06116452068090439, 0.0014406676637008786, 0.06885359436273575, 0.043343886733055115, 0.005926167126744986, 0.027174364775419235, -0.046173784881830215, 0.023481357842683792, -0.005130481906235218, -0.025909019634127617, -0.02503846026957035, 0.0005260431789793074, -0.012902535498142242, 0.018591661006212234, -0.006154172588139772, 0.05747518315911293, -0.036729294806718826, -0.019217215478420258, 0.023549120873212814, -0.007626763079315424, 0.01866014488041401, 0.02473105862736702, -0.007133249193429947, 0.03602714464068413, 0.013440747745335102, -0.007023859303444624, 0.008477958850562572, -0.023292846977710724, 0.007566975429654121, -0.006944842636585236, -0.035772133618593216, 0.027557505294680595, -0.03097420744597912, -0.02376403473317623, -0.011326048523187637, -0.035188380628824234, 0.03916636481881142, -0.05499076098203659, -0.011543831788003445, -0.021559348329901695, -0.02539384365081787, -0.02151714637875557, -0.004753943998366594, 0.0007340827723965049, 0.024918558076024055, -0.03035404346883297, 0.0357372984290123, -0.010808118619024754, -0.03130747750401497, -0.06792990118265152, 0.01261573564261198, 0.018486907705664635, 0.01169149111956358, -0.022177180275321007, 0.005598563235253096, -0.029645908623933792, -0.012999852187931538, -0.016834503039717674, -0.028564026579260826, 0.0790126696228981, -0.03238905221223831, -0.019172655418515205, -0.02036879025399685, 0.03572201728820801, 0.057088665664196014, -0.041180338710546494, 0.03365904465317726, -0.0046483906917274, -0.015635956078767776, -0.019653255119919777, 0.027997130528092384, 0.01977216638624668, -0.04926412180066109, -0.00494729308411479, -0.01581031084060669, -0.016916340216994286, 0.03449388965964317, -0.009776604361832142, -0.023348422721028328, 0.02723841369152069, -0.00008631431410321966, 0.04505278542637825, -0.03810868039727211, 0.018392743542790413, -0.0024173972196877003, 0.014321901835501194, -0.017368504777550697, 0.005824747029691935, -0.004004644230008125, 0.04843407869338989, 0.004902506712824106, -0.024160560220479965, -0.014380299486219883, -0.02234584093093872, 0.09556182473897934, -0.03660346567630768, 0.004471176769584417, -0.002763001248240471, 0.006516311317682266, 0.03884846344590187, 0.043612290173769, 0.008808458223938942, 0.02828231453895569, 0.00872873142361641, -0.02196846529841423, -0.010623968206346035, -0.06134244427084923, 0.0038266100455075502, 0.09401772171258926, -0.04159782454371452, -0.012245147489011288, 0.033024948090314865, -0.023426689207553864, -0.013524453155696392, -0.03854677081108093, 0.006021765060722828, -0.047928307205438614, 0.01931649260222912, 0.0389941968023777, -0.028684724122285843, -0.01495477557182312, 0.029195519164204597, 0.020961185917258263, -0.02181999944150448, 0.03611261025071144, 0.025286894291639328, 0.009689578786492348, -0.021411385387182236, -0.014432324096560478, -0.03703608363866806, 0.025557130575180054, -0.03575344756245613, -0.01990123651921749, -0.009701032191514969, -0.007908524014055729, 0.06386234611272812, 0.04773426428437233, 0.005312138702720404, -0.047571953386068344, -0.00652372557669878, -0.0337153822183609, -0.0075568524189293385, 0.011041241697967052, -0.04464992135763168, 0.011286299675703049, -0.022755714133381844, 0.030090585350990295, 0.011648847721517086, 0.0063259173184633255, -0.03982149064540863, -0.07581218332052231, -0.003782503539696336, 0.013983112759888172, -0.03862110152840614, 0.03246403858065605, -0.05018644407391548, -0.03740634396672249, 0.021096015349030495, -0.015252677723765373, 0.01616770774126053, -0.00281113525852561, 0.028133289888501167, -0.009524572640657425, 0.022970370948314667, -0.021985026076436043, 0.027330541983246803, 0.004836099687963724, 0.029923317953944206, 0.15545211732387543, 0.04901696741580963, 0.010434946976602077, -0.02830829657614231, 0.00955975241959095, -0.01827278733253479, -0.003310471773147583, 0.007105326279997826, -0.007005543913692236, -0.014377543702721596, -0.020086459815502167, 0.027853453531861305, 0.10713028907775879, 0.031067678704857826, 0.0037792474031448364, 0.02130003087222576, -0.023085525259375572, -0.02694517746567726, 0.0018964267801493406, -0.0026133821811527014, 0.04307990148663521, -0.03343052417039871, -0.01403716579079628, -0.009332583285868168, 0.024352822452783585, 0.004256850574165583, -0.036043886095285416, 0.0065934667363762856, -0.008643727749586105, -0.00628243712708354, -0.023126646876335144, 0.009350360371172428, 0.01611446775496006, 0.028308570384979248, -0.031475719064474106, 0.020766789093613625, 0.03493897616863251, -0.06462731212377548, 0.004831967409700155, 0.028099967166781425, 0.0014283047057688236, 0.002775219501927495, 0.031064828857779503, 0.02268342114984989, -0.02337675914168358, -0.06321597099304199, -0.02581142820417881, 0.055800195783376694, 0.006796807516366243, -0.038570284843444824, -0.04424947500228882, -0.016491767019033432, 0.010989884845912457, -0.03096579760313034, -0.009296443313360214, 0.031012877821922302, 0.010410737246274948, -0.029972650110721588, -0.02029305323958397, -0.0028675205539911985, 0.0074763051234185696, -0.0008172644302248955, 0.02351117692887783, 0.056885916739702225, -0.011876806616783142, 0.01186175737529993, -0.02431045100092888, 0.03570851683616638, 0.02972554974257946, 0.004403732251375914, 0.0072046914137899876, 0.0062334476970136166, -0.019493039697408676, -0.007363687269389629, -0.002200235379859805, 0.05732879415154457, 0.04653211310505867, -0.01589195430278778, 0.008165587671101093, -0.03550438955426216, -0.07427672296762466, 0.016320031136274338, -0.036285579204559326, -0.009856203570961952, -0.05374448373913765, -0.006115414667874575, 0.01276753842830658, -0.009416365064680576, -0.011704753153026104, 0.03672989457845688, -0.0001415274600731209, 0.07135618478059769, 0.016895867884159088, -0.02143966220319271, -0.005295801442116499, 0.009055630303919315, -0.03125859051942825, -0.01856456883251667, -0.023282090201973915, 0.05131007730960846, 0.013167131692171097, 0.03199474886059761, 0.02936042658984661, 0.05188091844320297, -0.013801682740449905, 0.013592969626188278, 0.012953989207744598, -0.04096255451440811, 0.01472537312656641, 0.012507019564509392, -0.0038363568019121885, -0.025951119139790535, -0.021087152883410454, -0.03447612375020981, -0.048700712621212006, 0.021962275728583336, -0.007940155453979969, -0.03989386558532715, 0.020696641877293587, -0.023943832144141197, -0.020867282524704933, -0.013392073102295399, -0.0018703651148825884, -0.02076455019414425, -0.006452309899032116, -0.015337551943957806, -0.007743482943624258, 0.012953749857842922, 0.0180670153349638, 0.005893286317586899, 0.017827631905674934, 0.05761069059371948, -0.05534174293279648, 0.036713000386953354, -0.0483948290348053, -0.018154768273234367, 0.01891915127635002, 0.037468072026968, -0.007125267293304205, -0.021112412214279175, 0.03649232164025307, -0.04848344996571541, -0.07819633930921555, 0.0016173562034964561, -0.0015222858637571335, 0.01339613739401102, 0.02986421063542366, 0.011478304862976074, -0.04000311344861984, 0.0574587918817997, -0.03235674276947975, -0.016913745552301407, -0.022683605551719666, -0.004799616988748312, 0.001883643213659525, -0.032124072313308716, -0.01611899957060814, 0.0006537720328196883, 0.016891714185476303, 0.013539904728531837, 0.01129869930446148, 0.0034354410599917173, -0.007501790765672922, 0.02699987217783928, -0.043001409620046616, -0.0011765992967411876, 0.0051140678115189075, 0.00002236305044789333, 0.01757546328008175, 0.0214241836220026, -0.003826233558356762, 0.005824545864015818, -0.021705519407987595, 0.03251102566719055, -0.108943410217762, -0.024059411138296127, -0.001155903097242117, 0.0433475598692894, -0.016650930047035217, -0.07229186594486237, 0.021369123831391335, 0.04763243347406387, -0.044225867837667465, 0.00966576486825943, -0.012462298385798931, -0.026260927319526672, -0.03651072084903717, 0.01411888562142849, -0.025975270196795464, 0.029138559475541115, 0.000529836630448699, -0.005876606795936823, -0.009718066081404686, -0.00507123488932848, 0.013618245720863342, -0.05228913202881813, 0.0036813935730606318, 0.024513453245162964, 0.03827285394072533, -0.06703847646713257, 0.05571450665593147, -0.003935710527002811, -0.02369363233447075, 0.03430363908410072, -0.028202926740050316, 0.01812141388654709, 0.038796424865722656, 0.009532325901091099, 0.003980185370892286, 0.0325360968708992, 0.026836343109607697, 0.029477978125214577, -0.004321498330682516, -0.013465788215398788, -0.017779866233468056, 0.032064493745565414, -0.048038698732852936, 0.023555859923362732, 0.05834582820534706, -0.02145478129386902, -0.031697891652584076, -0.0026837459299713373, -0.06140546500682831, -0.02220463939011097, 0.006218767259269953, -0.038586657494306564, -0.0009598261676728725, -0.014907781034708023, 0.039112985134124756, -0.01799478568136692, -0.014311770908534527, 0.038690343499183655, 0.02439328096807003, 0.0020201350562274456, 0.046663492918014526, -0.04736962169408798, -0.007606904022395611, -0.003279352094978094, 0.0034560509957373142, -0.0008946378948166966, -0.020305149257183075, -0.013798774220049381, 0.012430360540747643, -0.021918466314673424, -0.015792053192853928, 0.02126353420317173, -0.0317804329097271, 0.053099628537893295, 0.02034805528819561, -0.007664130534976721, 0.004056198056787252, 0.0003812396607827395, 0.009674185886979103, -0.095335453748703, 0.05007694661617279, 0.019940372556447983, -0.04461129382252693, -0.0008216880960389972, 0.028970101848244667, -0.025790609419345856, 0.005356904119253159, 0.03893915191292763, 0.015458202920854092, 0.015474246814846992, 0.007847536355257034, 0.01881902851164341, -0.0008272472769021988, -0.04573198780417442, 0.024446677416563034, -0.008794233202934265, 0.011379128322005272, -0.02891591563820839, 0.0008152206428349018, -0.022333672270178795, -0.011933963745832443, 0.018656916916370392, -0.01723385788500309, 0.03157702460885048, 0.0046355389058589935, 0.0041734399273991585, 0.053428102284669876, 0.016001509502530098, -0.037452954798936844, 0.02991342544555664, 0.005821363069117069, -0.00026588988839648664, 0.03230956569314003, 0.006358850281685591, -0.04914170131087303, 0.016994237899780273, -0.06339110434055328, -0.019578760489821434, -0.020833514630794525, -0.005068688187748194, 0.006044573616236448, -0.07346240431070328, 0.019354311749339104, 0.048314474523067474, -0.03991217166185379, 0.01685536466538906, 0.031338438391685486, 0.04324508085846901, -0.023129455745220184, 0.028565308079123497, 0.009415673092007637, 0.023338710889220238, -0.01426335796713829, 0.02436993271112442, 0.007670565042644739, 0.007483306340873241, 0.019952643662691116, 0.01517383474856615, 0.03792962804436684, -0.045237358659505844, 0.016416950151324272, 0.0005425079143606126, 0.019554059952497482, -0.007293407339602709, -0.006002808455377817, -0.006934748031198978, -0.0008595904801040888, 0.010516286827623844, 0.0053704166784882545, 0.005768436007201672, 0.07212021946907043, -0.011512511409819126, -0.0008133522933349013, -0.014208351261913776, -0.0010366856586188078, -0.02506502903997898, -0.02089555561542511, 0.009593035094439983, 0.06186565384268761, -0.009033327922224998, -0.011632028967142105, 0.01702543906867504, -0.02091512456536293, 0.008067991584539413, -0.008327954448759556, 0.011015278287231922, 0.019244205206632614, -0.008618448860943317, -0.05852564051747322, -0.011411665007472038, -0.007988058030605316, -0.020905517041683197, 0.0671057254076004, -0.003023954341188073, 0.0003993951831944287, -0.01427961140871048, -0.04478617385029793, 0.0583074726164341, 0.07210922986268997, -0.02387886866927147, -0.013910786248743534, -0.02905385196208954, 0.020962975919246674, -0.002929160837084055, -0.029068995267152786 ]
<p>I am classifying different texts and I wondering about some features that are highly correlated. I have 49 features. Some features are absolute counters (integers) but most features are relative counters(float between 0-1). I am running F-score (univariate) and I am getting the following three features with the highest scores: 1-fourth root of number of word forms, 2- number of word forms and 3-number of sentences. I am running a feature ranking based on extremely randomized trees (scikit-learn ensemble forests) and I am getting exactly the same three features as the highest ranking features. The ranking based on randomized trees is using bootstrapping and GINI. In the F-scores results I can understand that highly correlated features may have the highest ranking because it is univariate based (measure only one feature at the time). In the random tree ranking I was expecting that only one of features related to the "length of the text" should have a high rank and the others should have a lower and the correlation problem should be solved. But the results are not according to my expectations. I must be doing something wrong! Could it be realted to the fact that all three features are integer counters (values in 1000-range) and the other features are relative counters(0-1). But as I undertand ranking based on random trees should be able to handle large discrepancies between the features. My question is how should I handle this issue. Should I discard some features? How can I find out the best feature that characterizes the text length??? Any help here is appreciated! </p>
36,997
[ -0.030031243339180946, 0.005523878615349531, 0.011222695000469685, -0.004347128327935934, 0.04167834296822548, 0.018350765109062195, 0.006199563853442669, -0.030431607738137245, 0.026149092242121696, -0.028209781274199486, 0.046566978096961975, 0.027949068695306778, 0.02688930183649063, 0.027075476944446564, 0.012156627140939236, -0.035038676112890244, 0.03400864452123642, 0.0028300569392740726, 0.0007783942273817956, -0.03327050432562828, -0.027823839336633682, 0.026146776974201202, 0.040561169385910034, -0.0075524006970226765, -0.05392540246248245, 0.06557390093803406, -0.013036798685789108, -0.013699796982109547, 0.01691550202667713, 0.014121044427156448, -0.029001852497458458, 0.013475548475980759, 0.0016311726067215204, 0.03988301381468773, 0.015854323282837868, 0.017201591283082962, -0.025220561772584915, -0.022942746058106422, -0.018832387402653694, 0.02574722282588482, -0.026914024725556374, -0.03142393380403519, -0.0032470207661390305, 0.005270490422844887, -0.04578150063753128, 0.033756073564291, -0.0066116792149841785, -0.017152702435851097, 0.0445418544113636, -0.049284856766462326, 0.05831693112850189, 0.03899144008755684, 0.0701526328921318, 0.06717131286859512, 0.009423944167792797, 0.0007824942586012185, 0.02347990684211254, 0.07415083050727844, -0.02200094610452652, -0.00589841278269887, -0.030437897890806198, -0.05716588348150253, 0.02572496235370636, 0.011695846915245056, -0.03635677695274353, 0.08054016530513763, -0.0028239600360393524, -0.0072439489886164665, 0.0440833754837513, 0.040376849472522736, 0.003258541924878955, 0.010635319165885448, 0.047154076397418976, 0.004678112454712391, 0.03191336244344711, 0.002744165016338229, 0.04058266431093216, -0.005734655540436506, 0.039618343114852905, -0.0007426306256093085, -0.009373635984957218, -0.03037186898291111, -0.026361117139458656, 0.031584229320287704, 0.03410092368721962, -0.028844399377703667, 0.020817577838897705, -0.008585049770772457, 0.011058986186981201, 0.041090868413448334, -0.00922027975320816, 0.0016476119635626674, 0.048533618450164795, 0.018616236746311188, -0.03272586315870285, 0.0628332570195198, -0.009559906087815762, 0.003901340300217271, 0.012285703793168068, 0.05162569135427475, -0.026571696624159813, -0.06027581915259361, 0.008203824050724506, 0.038654178380966187, -0.028701961040496826, -0.005764960777014494, -0.07587374001741409, -0.010441327467560768, -0.027501359581947327, 0.026302171871066093, -0.02864915505051613, -0.001361424452625215, -0.023707550019025803, -0.008247369900345802, 0.03535856306552887, 0.0098998649045825, 0.0016078088665381074, -0.04156701639294624, 0.06058061495423317, 0.05444025620818138, -0.014246559701859951, -0.030402744188904762, 0.03008720651268959, -0.03611265495419502, -0.006906028836965561, 0.0008659563609398901, 0.044045720249414444, -0.012183360755443573, -0.01688736118376255, 0.08568809181451797, 0.00901036523282528, -0.016741689294576645, 0.043578144162893295, -0.03502039611339569, 0.040671348571777344, 0.05360766872763634, -0.06382758170366287, -0.06398680806159973, 0.03371070697903633, -0.013490972109138966, 0.00873408280313015, -0.05043807625770569, -0.002051819581538439, 0.029637711122632027, 0.03366289287805557, -0.0010692819487303495, 0.06488202512264252, 0.016257110983133316, 0.01787061057984829, 0.038363564759492874, -0.014922892674803734, -0.002482393756508827, -0.008190439082682133, 0.0276156198233366, -0.007450622506439686, -0.05253810063004494, 0.009072799235582352, -0.011724824085831642, 0.0030407048761844635, -0.02091207727789879, -0.01051801536232233, -0.0025229272432625294, -0.003778426442295313, -0.0018955416744574904, 0.01121964119374752, -0.014354466460645199, 0.08745462447404861, 0.00547293433919549, 0.043291669338941574, 0.012456261552870274, 0.0010353517718613148, -0.008322261273860931, 0.043604567646980286, 0.008646653033792973, 0.03746804594993591, 0.015340466052293777, 0.017492186278104782, -0.011386830359697342, 0.006785458419471979, 0.01472182385623455, -0.007517782039940357, -0.08120520412921906, -0.05254101753234863, 0.025652555748820305, 0.00041780591709539294, 0.015422915108501911, -0.02271195314824581, -0.023057667538523674, 0.04203994199633598, -0.056745052337646484, -0.016700422391295433, -0.05721806362271309, 0.0049596549943089485, -0.050215791910886765, -0.009944339282810688, 0.05963052064180374, -0.013099685311317444, 0.007003856357187033, -0.026214981451630592, 0.01792006939649582, -0.04261612147092819, -0.0024840449914336205, 0.06462668627500534, -0.03740563988685608, 0.028588339686393738, 0.024684404954314232, -0.02864430844783783, -0.01273731142282486, 0.007228129543364048, 0.006747880019247532, -0.0905468687415123, 0.03329514339566231, 0.0018150307005271316, -0.026403438299894333, -0.03811746835708618, -0.03933238238096237, 0.03974283114075661, 0.01805225759744644, 0.0033310626167804003, -0.014010246843099594, -0.036874156445264816, 0.07082125544548035, 0.0469592921435833, -0.00021221366478130221, 0.003963002469390631, 0.016366619616746902, 0.02015567570924759, -0.011149195022881031, -0.02202470786869526, -0.0164114311337471, -0.022481156513094902, -0.012990327551960945, 0.02861245907843113, 0.03416338190436363, 0.0049477871507406235, -0.011279754340648651, 0.08154446631669998, 0.02177109569311142, 0.049932725727558136, 0.018813634291291237, -0.017898105084896088, -0.007688523735851049, 0.029670458287000656, 0.03628271445631981, 0.015741078183054924, -0.019343949854373932, -0.03023717552423477, 0.002154149115085602, -0.010394047014415264, -0.005814963951706886, -0.02231665514409542, -0.017462991178035736, 0.03407500311732292, 0.003616592613980174, -0.041351113468408585, -0.025801556184887886, -0.004124513361603022, -0.038240253925323486, -0.010006713680922985, 0.07238296419382095, -0.013041777536273003, 0.03933798894286156, -0.009736240841448307, -0.03558528050780296, 0.054611045867204666, 0.015801386907696724, -0.04275737702846527, -0.0037745824083685875, 0.021690478548407555, -0.06707651168107986, 0.03968748077750206, -0.020540008321404457, -0.05325303226709366, -0.03691272437572479, 0.04341009259223938, 0.04167598485946655, -0.021438853815197945, 0.024559054523706436, -0.008341937325894833, -0.000566400121897459, -0.005443518050014973, 0.00479858135804534, -0.0029292923863977194, -0.004313974175602198, -0.05575927346944809, 0.018034759908914566, -0.01019060518592596, -0.032449498772621155, 0.02979900874197483, -0.00948981661349535, 0.008325212635099888, -0.008145678788423538, -0.02208297699689865, -0.016890019178390503, -0.04127722233533859, -0.006902502384036779, 0.049968328326940536, 0.009064254350960255, -0.02894553355872631, 0.05577217787504196, -0.022296160459518433, -0.049674343317747116, 0.009564044885337353, -0.022319121286273003, -0.04493109881877899, 0.0074558802880346775, 0.006599563639611006, 0.005156842991709709, 0.002853836165741086, 0.003742773784324527, 0.03338095545768738, -0.01768454909324646, -0.008513211272656918, -0.03953976556658745, -0.05702369660139084, 0.005232489667832851, 0.0051416996866464615, 0.04236353561282158, -0.0018764941487461329, 0.0013826811918988824, 0.03694463148713112, 0.02945983223617077, -0.05797456577420235, -0.01451148372143507, 0.0031165168620646, -0.022935230284929276, -0.0010615653591230512, -0.02742997743189335, 0.031700778752565384, 0.035649269819259644, 0.04159361124038696, 0.020172011107206345, 0.0291714146733284, 0.03056102618575096, -0.03518100455403328, 0.0001868715917225927, 0.03744225576519966, 0.017785856500267982, -0.01340037863701582, 0.048239000141620636, 0.04484707489609718, -0.03842061012983322, -0.0008359818602912128, 0.035202816128730774, 0.016510801389813423, 0.018314646556973457, -0.0463145412504673, 0.015593962743878365, -0.011868634261190891, 0.03551958501338959, -0.013899851590394974, -0.015338550321757793, 0.017980339005589485, -0.03756937384605408, -0.0314013808965683, 0.009588759392499924, 0.05620386824011803, -0.03037026710808277, 0.013525507412850857, 0.06291883438825607, 0.05820693448185921, 0.02204148843884468, -0.03029029071331024, -0.040350012481212616, -0.026183957234025, 0.012542078271508217, -0.011325845494866371, -0.0037131118588149548, 0.03218555450439453, 0.05208176001906395, 0.02606607973575592, 0.004188961815088987, -0.0675419270992279, 0.030091553926467896, -0.0022614505141973495, -0.008737613447010517, -0.03650481626391411, 0.03767700120806694, -0.008029078133404255, 0.035343434661626816, 0.00975735578685999, -0.027158362790942192, -0.008866759017109871, 0.029625628143548965, -0.050869956612586975, 0.009129314683377743, -0.024251848459243774, 0.01036853902041912, -0.013898463919758797, -0.009164506569504738, -0.0018508023349568248, -0.04167810082435608, 0.0003069343219976872, 0.013101056218147278, 0.03815249726176262, -0.021464332938194275, -0.005164520815014839, -0.03109923005104065, 0.016140274703502655, 0.007244653534144163, 0.02942357212305069, -0.024015534669160843, -0.034405507147312164, 0.05535293370485306, 0.04666515439748764, 0.0196651853621006, 0.0004414791183080524, -0.027753613889217377, 0.037244830280542374, 0.0031495201401412487, 0.032848432660102844, 0.023725921288132668, 0.008341693319380283, -0.05180815979838371, 0.04174550995230675, 0.017622744664549828, 0.032583288848400116, 0.01992434822022915, -0.009183422662317753, 0.01718870736658573, -0.019385075196623802, -0.032982878386974335, 0.028048034757375717, 0.01635698229074478, 0.027520248666405678, -0.019079109653830528, 0.05425840616226196, 0.03762044757604599, -0.08012763410806656, 0.0179506354033947, 0.05186687037348747, 0.007866729982197285, -0.035906724631786346, -0.017900101840496063, -0.005007128231227398, 0.028783101588487625, 0.024885892868041992, 0.030368724837899208, 0.03972596675157547, -0.007880465127527714, -0.05917171761393547, 0.04250284656882286, -0.03485645726323128, -0.08048482239246368, 0.0009628181578591466, 0.017228268086910248, 0.035039957612752914, -0.0321706086397171, -0.025511065497994423, 0.020792951807379723, -0.009499458596110344, -0.01590839773416519, 0.03485715389251709, 0.0003644871758297086, -0.06182136386632919, -0.009973089210689068, 0.029948079958558083, 0.01013410184532404, -0.04125610738992691, -0.008987346664071083, -0.027935972437262535, 0.0008946215966716409, -0.0003168527618981898, -0.031158708035945892, -0.013634995557367802, 0.02055475115776062, -0.010587330907583237, 0.02361881732940674, -0.025136861950159073, 0.02033080905675888, 0.04697651043534279, 0.005261853337287903, 0.03899255767464638, -0.0177348330616951, -0.04228543862700462, -0.0215853750705719, 0.0014573154039680958, -0.016868557780981064, 0.013083058409392834, -0.017795559018850327, 0.006940257735550404, 0.015805376693606377, 0.010235967114567757, 0.002747554564848542, -0.05601334944367409, -0.011454842984676361, -0.003299813251942396, -0.0035707987844944, 0.04088970273733139, -0.03631947189569473, -0.055872056633234024, -0.003212954616174102, 0.020321812480688095, -0.007075511384755373, -0.009857716970145702, 0.012130982242524624, 0.03402819111943245, 0.01760351099073887, -0.013534900732338428, 0.051613159477710724, 0.028550976887345314, 0.013588096015155315, -0.006066471338272095, 0.006628416944295168, 0.038548629730939865, -0.04091489687561989, 0.005766833666712046, -0.05520555004477501, 0.02807183563709259, -0.05906238779425621, 0.03730909898877144, 0.04265923053026199, 0.04250814765691757, -0.029863234609365463, 0.022254707291722298, -0.011124326847493649, 0.03371121361851692, -0.015628192573785782, -0.016898581758141518, -0.02044290490448475, 0.013662735000252724, 0.0006172156427055597, 0.028532985597848892, 0.026257067918777466, -0.0016845990903675556, 0.009775777347385883, 0.030157845467329025, 0.003811044152826071, 0.0010116188786923885, -0.02512332983314991, -0.026898493990302086, -0.02933952398598194, -0.005346860736608505, 0.05356627330183983, 0.021810833364725113, -0.0014559298288077116, -0.008473272435367107, -0.007475715130567551, -0.046442124992609024, 0.01730397716164589, 0.0007194341160356998, 0.061257656663656235, -0.047173872590065, 0.035993218421936035, -0.04741738364100456, -0.012451596558094025, -0.061220988631248474, 0.0014404889661818743, 0.002665684325620532, 0.03203559294342995, -0.029037373140454292, -0.015549331903457642, 0.013880489394068718, 0.008514593355357647, 0.0066873012110590935, -0.03793782740831375, 0.03804076835513115, -0.023843316361308098, -0.03371860831975937, -0.010809524916112423, 0.019746214151382446, 0.05623980611562729, -0.05140100046992302, -0.0015001302817836404, 0.02233688160777092, 0.013903666287660599, -0.003938815090805292, -0.015712562948465347, 0.002676289761438966, -0.020444422960281372, -0.016336575150489807, -0.04331401735544205, 0.03390492498874664, 0.015180244110524654, -0.02921115979552269, 0.02435843087732792, -0.032943230122327805, -0.0009153493447229266, 0.009379533119499683, 0.008621282875537872, -0.010974832810461521, 0.018444830551743507, 0.00714432168751955, -0.034065984189510345, 0.03617536276578903, -0.023331662639975548, -0.005838216748088598, 0.008733309805393219, 0.0009516715654172003, -0.0014523770660161972, 0.008918961510062218, 0.0774528756737709, 0.0008230944513343275, 0.006616201717406511, -0.02721412479877472, -0.017218029126524925, 0.046140678226947784, 0.027647728100419044, 0.0000071077120082918555, 0.021290218457579613, 0.029785946011543274, -0.03467077389359474, -0.016328269615769386, -0.012999489903450012, 0.005039602052420378, 0.05986049026250839, -0.002073094481602311, 0.038391705602407455, 0.047329504042863846, -0.007151655852794647, 0.04158984497189522, -0.025710010901093483, -0.034339915961027145, -0.004487253725528717, 0.011601890437304974, 0.022873923182487488, 0.00312042492441833, -0.0033062316942960024, 0.048260923475027084, -0.008435987867414951, 0.03706558048725128, 0.06989120692014694, 0.04633850231766701, 0.018591629341244698, 0.010433446615934372, -0.04259772226214409, -0.016962392255663872, 0.02546709217131138, -0.04567857086658478, -0.00878424383699894, 0.006191345863044262, -0.03654581680893898, 0.0569143071770668, 0.05643085390329361, -0.005430413875728846, -0.06079595908522606, -0.02712329290807247, -0.05522837117314339, 0.016762658953666687, -0.007936042733490467, -0.040339477360248566, -0.006798500660806894, 0.01810217648744583, -0.003320450661703944, 0.004784513730555773, 0.020352886989712715, -0.041479095816612244, -0.08987540006637573, -0.04230548441410065, -0.033433206379413605, -0.05185474827885628, 0.02081484906375408, -0.021623732522130013, -0.054863784462213516, 0.05124320834875107, -0.02769860439002514, 0.03136585280299187, -0.022057531401515007, 0.00883575901389122, -0.036961205303668976, 0.035567305982112885, 0.02353050746023655, 0.05900748819112778, 0.01532346848398447, 0.008374255150556564, 0.1044624075293541, 0.08284009248018265, 0.08413410931825638, -0.051759473979473114, 0.009136420674622059, 0.04638751596212387, -0.015768952667713165, -0.049376945942640305, 0.009022104553878307, 0.00831286609172821, -0.017431320622563362, 0.03448040783405304, -0.010397939011454582, 0.01938900537788868, -0.02377365715801716, 0.03175172582268715, -0.008654111996293068, -0.0032346213702112436, 0.018846958875656128, 0.02895006723701954, 0.06556278467178345, -0.03292695805430412, -0.05893348157405853, 0.018760662525892258, 0.013689159415662289, -0.018557680770754814, -0.005108165554702282, 0.013529360294342041, 0.010782663710415363, 0.015396352857351303, 0.006283210124820471, -0.009345064871013165, 0.05636851117014885, 0.015548717230558395, 0.02546430379152298, 0.0242127887904644, 0.003980807960033417, -0.01657119207084179, -0.030210427939891815, 0.03028048574924469, 0.014793039299547672, 0.013734214939177036, 0.03752867504954338, 0.03963284194469452, -0.05028886720538139, -0.03727053105831146, -0.04286905750632286, -0.0011508659226819873, 0.011166730895638466, -0.008747181855142117, 0.008563436567783356, 0.020038189366459846, -0.01031090971082449, -0.038394395262002945, -0.014698644168674946, -0.005352057050913572, 0.027295298874378204, -0.012770014815032482, -0.030225705355405807, -0.026667237281799316, 0.04026319086551666, -0.010868063196539879, 0.019334126263856888, -0.0006289078737609088, -0.01405091118067503, -0.0017164890887215734, -0.033159367740154266, 0.0017644645413383842, 0.014842992648482323, 0.00672635342925787, -0.024590207263827324, -0.007377137895673513, -0.02306031994521618, -0.022128190845251083, -0.009907814674079418, -0.013772096484899521, 0.014158803038299084, -0.007481250911951065, -0.02652931399643421, -0.09970714896917343, -0.02276705764234066, 0.013727875426411629, -0.003120212582871318, -0.005627575796097517, -0.04534187912940979, -0.02464267425239086, -0.00513088284060359, 0.016535038128495216, 0.023796750232577324, 0.02359631657600403, 0.0013417818117886782, 0.03146049752831459, 0.01181012112647295, -0.05528965964913368, 0.0033867545425891876, -0.06971817463636398, -0.013033954426646233, -0.0073441993445158005, -0.0025862266775220633, 0.05790338292717934, 0.016842909157276154, 0.013393950648605824, 0.0026048258878290653, 0.059252720326185226, -0.036007244139909744, -0.00037323584547266364, 0.023279042914509773, -0.04544764384627342, 0.008879730477929115, 0.030129795894026756, -0.015225575305521488, -0.03477729856967926, -0.04745275527238846, 0.0016179665690287948, -0.018510794267058372, 0.008226871490478516, 0.01131605077534914, -0.05908334255218506, -0.040557861328125, -0.008083608001470566, 0.01947261206805706, -0.01872052624821663, -0.032857101410627365, -0.05087162181735039, 0.020749583840370178, 0.01966446079313755, -0.04644134268164635, -0.008588487282395363, 0.005811406299471855, 0.015214742161333561, -0.00543199572712183, 0.005519462283700705, 0.012109845876693726, 0.00282770162448287, -0.03974494710564613, 0.015530281700193882, -0.01081340853124857, 0.04038878157734871, -0.04794866964221001, -0.006864520721137524, 0.0006814876105636358, -0.03518645092844963, -0.013676001690328121, 0.019909793511033058, -0.04706242308020592, 0.014556748792529106, -0.011728808283805847, -0.019127005711197853, -0.023083914071321487, 0.059572331607341766, -0.023596931248903275, -0.0249533262103796, -0.007220531348139048, 0.014110909774899483, 0.013006010092794895, 0.0074164364486932755, -0.000038153095374582335, -0.01831151731312275, -0.03741868957877159, 0.014855872839689255, 0.09372176229953766, 0.024395529180765152, -0.006568359676748514, 0.009761172346770763, -0.026014160364866257, 0.015985842794179916, 0.006415946874767542, -0.022098036482930183, -0.016122713685035706, 0.051890306174755096, -0.04915586858987808, 0.032022614032030106, 0.007247063796967268, 0.02535189874470234, -0.023749951273202896, 0.0034416751004755497, 0.036321960389614105, -0.033409424126148224, 0.0027776143979281187, -0.033029813319444656, -0.03442665934562683, 0.0324348583817482, -0.027982749044895172, 0.014788522385060787, -0.023775862529873848, 0.016376325860619545, -0.03817791864275932, -0.015113580040633678, -0.03142179548740387, -0.016219353303313255, 0.014819725416600704, 0.0011460608802735806, 0.035341449081897736, 0.04436635971069336, -0.026697326451539993, -0.03703605383634567, -0.035322681069374084, 0.024730568751692772, -0.013791163451969624, -0.05730348825454712, 0.008135820738971233, -0.03798895701766014, -0.05923180282115936, 0.06868377327919006, -0.004983851686120033, 0.0014846792910248041, 0.058817457407712936, 0.001012712251394987, 0.013598217628896236, 0.03383413329720497, 0.035837024450302124, -0.033952005207538605, 0.018428878858685493, -0.022116396576166153, 0.000025706158339744434, 0.004259529057890177, -0.020987659692764282, 0.03420868143439293, -0.002658652840182185, -0.017566632479429245, -0.006983609404414892, 0.042330868542194366, -0.046846818178892136, -0.0008652604301460087, -0.02026972360908985, 0.027372611686587334, 0.04337198659777641, -0.029464740306138992, -0.007628732360899448, -0.0483107827603817, 0.02147524617612362, 0.01280850637704134, 0.03531021624803543, 0.018187755718827248, -0.015493270009756088, -0.030994918197393417, -0.04750918596982956, -0.022113656625151634, 0.01248567458242178, 0.004845094867050648, -0.027136756107211113, -0.011615797877311707, 0.005776633974164724, -0.0033075432293117046, -0.0033107190392911434, -0.05303995683789253, -0.010772822424769402, 0.06970568001270294, -0.03406423330307007, 0.010536634363234043, -0.03409668430685997, -0.017725497484207153, 0.037929970771074295, -0.11111418902873993, 0.010947895236313343, -0.007884802296757698, -0.011345971375703812, -0.013905966654419899, 0.010242669843137264, -0.01976753957569599, 0.013993030413985252, 0.04258779063820839, -0.024959374219179153, 0.047751035541296005, 0.00029319210443645716, -0.0013351941015571356, 0.04210878908634186, -0.023156484588980675, 0.00859710294753313, 0.006400137208402157, -0.0036181341856718063, -0.027562415227293968, -0.043092623353004456, 0.03999313712120056, -0.025532176718115807, 0.012084455229341984, -0.009814281016588211, -0.0182089414447546, 0.04749220237135887, 0.014457298442721367, 0.026612553745508194, -0.03183992952108383, -0.0028633365873247385, 0.02783277817070484, 0.0344541110098362, -0.000025214623747160658, 0.03351356089115143, 0.012035691179335117, -0.0521981306374073, 0.018310578539967537, -0.0017381816869601607, -0.04662979021668434, -0.00806545838713646, 0.07894162833690643, 0.006872489582747221, -0.0922044962644577, -0.007187867537140846, 0.0452994778752327, -0.052267514169216156, 0.008544249460101128, 0.04897744581103325, 0.005807849112898111, 0.033684149384498596, -0.024335630238056183, 0.0377810075879097, 0.01998198591172695, -0.03211952745914459, 0.00009740281529957429, -0.010427013039588928, 0.009234844706952572, 0.024533536285161972, 0.028153425082564354, -0.0256255604326725, -0.05465702712535858, 0.053828731179237366, -0.026827262714505196, 0.044608648866415024, -0.02051677741110325, -0.0010111831361427903, 0.038100291043519974, -0.006308582611382008, 0.018236463889479637, 0.012811535969376564, 0.005588544998317957, 0.04646138846874237, -0.021215196698904037, 0.0057322364300489426, -0.06845634430646896, -0.040030427277088165, -0.025028930976986885, 0.010309155099093914, -0.033794380724430084, 0.007143172901123762, 0.002948997775092721, 0.015165694057941437, -0.021309979259967804, 0.0035806773230433464, 0.04941004887223244, -0.009971716441214085, -0.010743720456957817, -0.020242925733327866, -0.02606036514043808, 0.03264882043004036, -0.02721518464386463, -0.02365478314459324, 0.001119854743592441, 0.023638714104890823, 0.01579331047832966, 0.04961058124899864, -0.02491239458322525, -0.04084494337439537, 0.014325851574540138, 0.05168594792485237, -0.021401604637503624, -0.014573742635548115, -0.05153222009539604, 0.014645031653344631, -0.003142021596431732, -0.010835827328264713 ]
<p>I have a data set of a bag of words. I randomly choose some points and use them for testing and the others are used for training.</p> <ul> <li>case (1) I just take each data-point from the test set and classify it as having the same class label as its nearest point from the train set.</li> <li>case (2) I do the classification using any known supervised classifier.</li> </ul> <p>I always get better recognition rate in case (1). That is, not doing any learning at all, is better than using any supervised learning, for this data set (and others) ! Is that a frequent situation ?</p>
36,998
[ -0.038048308342695236, -0.041001953184604645, -0.016002483665943146, -0.0106321657076478, -0.015173052437603474, 0.028670232743024826, -0.025175031274557114, 0.0006140470504760742, 0.003868246218189597, -0.001104814582504332, 0.045143019407987595, 0.03414660692214966, 0.03557807579636574, 0.03233003243803978, -0.011006757616996765, 0.012437318451702595, -0.041474826633930206, 0.011802330613136292, -0.013007386587560177, 0.0021888785995543003, -0.04668426513671875, 0.031221291050314903, 0.03044530190527439, -0.02167801931500435, -0.023431850597262383, 0.024886159226298332, -0.0336635522544384, -0.01710239239037037, 0.01534940768033266, 0.012265539728105068, -0.019757673144340515, -0.024281080812215805, -0.0011047518346458673, 0.043782006949186325, 0.023847438395023346, 0.016261670738458633, -0.026966143399477005, -0.021936645731329918, 0.007206159643828869, 0.014457959681749344, -0.014977339655160904, -0.03258345648646355, 0.036684948951005936, 0.048540033400058746, -0.009490379132330418, 0.035514622926712036, -0.008255861699581146, -0.0013530573341995478, -0.0003376896493136883, -0.0461767241358757, 0.03631755709648132, -0.0016188712324947119, 0.0016680842963978648, 0.051646888256073, 0.022059189155697823, -0.03619054704904556, 0.04378464072942734, 0.07774356752634048, -0.04264286905527115, -0.03512916713953018, 0.013458246365189552, -0.018733631819486618, 0.004572348203510046, -0.00881223101168871, -0.018010659143328667, 0.06082609295845032, 0.030479058623313904, -0.006257402710616589, 0.052071597427129745, 0.002733611734583974, 0.0019676703959703445, 0.030840789899230003, 0.041912391781806946, -0.03938242048025131, 0.022880742326378822, 0.020979855209589005, 0.02200820855796337, 0.05923469364643097, 0.041556455194950104, 0.000711462867911905, 0.04947090521454811, 0.009264939464628696, 0.03548390045762062, 0.028264328837394714, 0.03215564042329788, -0.02297472208738327, 0.04838626831769943, 0.0021407390013337135, 0.023017093539237976, 0.01710112765431404, 0.021106364205479622, -0.00882045179605484, 0.0502312108874321, -0.015482991933822632, -0.039696551859378815, 0.05174652114510536, 0.00865198578685522, 0.010429647751152515, 0.025866206735372543, -0.016313623636960983, -0.018134983256459236, -0.034160517156124115, 0.0026210977230221033, 0.040736399590969086, -0.02984161116182804, -0.043292466551065445, -0.022463610395789146, -0.010035082697868347, -0.04456409811973572, 0.015679942443966866, -0.05375996604561806, 0.032670438289642334, 0.026813780888915062, 0.03288978710770607, 0.016868310049176216, -0.0005160626606084406, -0.02619941532611847, 0.021664658561348915, 0.028773436322808266, 0.059536412358284, 0.024380171671509743, -0.05234415456652641, -0.0003210765135008842, -0.04468318074941635, -0.01825564354658127, 0.016043536365032196, 0.02468164637684822, -0.03218552842736244, -0.042361631989479065, 0.04512256383895874, -0.04371865093708038, 0.018643492832779884, 0.03384917974472046, 0.0008068275637924671, 0.030345819890499115, 0.004123184364289045, -0.08061332255601883, -0.038204822689294815, 0.028698399662971497, -0.015104355290532112, 0.01660796068608761, -0.03439531475305557, -0.01172051765024662, 0.03138139098882675, 0.053537044674158096, 0.018918484449386597, 0.03414160758256912, 0.013384826481342316, 0.026898426935076714, 0.0012153486022725701, 0.023630304262042046, -0.010851322673261166, 0.007670579943805933, -0.03879354149103165, -0.03351869434118271, -0.06142290681600571, 0.020885488018393517, 0.006788861006498337, -0.01931406557559967, -0.027082839980721474, 0.0069731008261442184, -0.0003617933834902942, -0.008625438436865807, -0.008799835108220577, 0.008217422291636467, -0.02731090784072876, 0.061833757907152176, 0.02669009566307068, 0.057705726474523544, 0.02279522828757763, 0.008403082378208637, 0.04549339413642883, 0.00591783644631505, 0.03283862769603729, 0.05056856572628021, -0.04057085141539574, -0.0036661974154412746, -0.02015863172709942, 0.024420466274023056, -0.018679918721318245, -0.00822974182665348, -0.031012369319796562, -0.029377009719610214, 0.03277021646499634, -0.005966444965451956, 0.04251787066459656, 0.014888189733028412, -0.012144455686211586, 0.028244679793715477, -0.04304300621151924, -0.04683259502053261, -0.043024078011512756, -0.012109652161598206, -0.07201117277145386, -0.03424418345093727, 0.02767222747206688, 0.02786635421216488, 0.004514398518949747, -0.023683687672019005, -0.007965627126395702, -0.034029003232717514, -0.011572228744626045, 0.0029039436485618353, -0.04210745170712471, -0.0003465334593784064, 0.06746768951416016, -0.007746607065200806, -0.0188670065253973, 0.05521664023399353, -0.0479937382042408, -0.08103789389133453, 0.009683361276984215, -0.03112572804093361, 0.004613732453435659, 0.004774102475494146, 0.005017971154302359, 0.034370940178632736, 0.01570693776011467, -0.05682908371090889, 0.03293810784816742, -0.06695782393217087, 0.07392280548810959, 0.07203488796949387, -0.031210530549287796, -0.0175505168735981, -0.0023603946901857853, 0.0020289390813559294, 0.03936973214149475, 0.009539873339235783, -0.00511683477088809, -0.08149483054876328, -0.007419981528073549, 0.06267113238573074, 0.011249395087361336, -0.01134243793785572, 0.011871443130075932, 0.04937142878770828, 0.027060288935899734, -0.006068639922887087, 0.018356580287218094, -0.004405338782817125, 0.0011586908949539065, 0.022074196487665176, 0.06840420514345169, 0.00009276925266021863, 0.017195917665958405, 0.041410502046346664, -0.032675132155418396, 0.06452424824237823, 0.00883273221552372, -0.013543466106057167, 0.06406951695680618, -0.004766636062413454, 0.002687071915715933, 0.01166567299515009, -0.016421694308519363, 0.020362699404358864, -0.030335821211338043, 0.005842685699462891, 0.02827499248087406, 0.015312192030251026, 0.00663446681573987, 0.005496553611010313, -0.02109568379819393, 0.050865162163972855, 0.03188776597380638, -0.02461833879351616, 0.013643080368638039, 0.04158264026045799, -0.06700469553470612, 0.01709473505616188, -0.001030867570079863, -0.046061351895332336, -0.03179633989930153, 0.04251006245613098, 0.028504977002739906, -0.011318099685013294, 0.03884401544928551, -0.05788527801632881, 0.009349421598017216, 0.009899910539388657, -0.01963215135037899, 0.03783237561583519, 0.030167652294039726, -0.03732234612107277, 0.003528246423229575, -0.036036811769008636, -0.01411092933267355, 0.026655638590455055, -0.021188588812947273, -0.015266979113221169, -0.002270763274282217, -0.010826674290001392, -0.049933530390262604, -0.03354832902550697, -0.05374865606427193, 0.04271974042057991, -0.022475169971585274, -0.013383210636675358, 0.033695098012685776, 0.004984716884791851, -0.0708356723189354, -0.0022380175068974495, -0.014481469057500362, -0.040981657803058624, 0.003777139587327838, -0.023253370076417923, 0.026339413598179817, -0.028250841423869133, -0.01671575754880905, 0.038932476192712784, -0.0007675461820326746, -0.024066001176834106, -0.044239938259124756, -0.047021329402923584, 0.019689740613102913, -0.02622372843325138, 0.0126543203368783, -0.021948963403701782, 0.003916725981980562, 0.0776178389787674, 0.0637754499912262, -0.038034167140722275, -0.008462412282824516, 0.019954761490225792, -0.06813929229974747, -0.016391299664974213, -0.012893365696072578, 0.032107628881931305, -0.02145429700613022, -0.006851521786302328, 0.001487905508838594, 0.04751981049776077, 0.05436563491821289, -0.01695542223751545, 0.010485625825822353, 0.001158747123554349, 0.025329751893877983, -0.046341266483068466, 0.03928661346435547, 0.030364884063601494, -0.06809546798467636, -0.007071272470057011, -0.009928458370268345, 0.0030176558066159487, 0.045845236629247665, -0.030814139172434807, 0.044350516051054, -0.021719612181186676, 0.03102639690041542, -0.001960508758202195, 0.010578678920865059, 0.026593593880534172, -0.012729069218039513, -0.014738748781383038, -0.000967346946708858, 0.022101256996393204, -0.005349857732653618, 0.019007042050361633, 0.02079116925597191, 0.05724749341607094, 0.0000830145800136961, -0.03847602382302284, -0.004217397887259722, 0.0010670748306438327, 0.030164150521159172, -0.013141888193786144, 0.019929884001612663, 0.009827540256083012, 0.07550305873155594, 0.021368326619267464, 0.03548939526081085, -0.050518713891506195, 0.013671604916453362, -0.06356604397296906, 0.01382190641015768, -0.017822593450546265, 0.0658758357167244, 0.021789228543639183, 0.01446857675909996, -0.0014777756296098232, -0.022870054468512535, 0.031708914786577225, 0.018264619633555412, -0.0709029957652092, 0.014727244153618813, -0.008129147812724113, -0.029240677133202553, -0.01579860970377922, -0.039498668164014816, 0.028786784037947655, -0.03655749186873436, -0.009705661796033382, 0.002335217548534274, 0.02078298293054104, -0.04682961478829384, -0.0021160352043807507, -0.018077027052640915, -0.011229084804654121, -0.026679573580622673, -0.00883682630956173, -0.017891626805067062, -0.015131132677197456, 0.01322921458631754, 0.04656412824988365, 0.01975782960653305, 0.01744108274579048, -0.021473780274391174, 0.00028966215904802084, 0.03941892087459564, 0.023259125649929047, 0.00807445403188467, 0.0553128644824028, -0.056525819003582, 0.03191158547997475, -0.0003383703005965799, 0.03877101093530655, 0.02654140628874302, -0.02926110476255417, -0.020530590787529945, -0.05135452747344971, -0.06059588864445686, 0.031413592398166656, 0.04226755350828171, -0.0029529964085668325, -0.04429865628480911, 0.031070774421095848, 0.021677829325199127, -0.027844948694109917, -0.020725030452013016, 0.05297750607132912, 0.0025002514012157917, -0.017131267115473747, -0.02615908533334732, 0.006580237299203873, 0.023864086717367172, 0.005709209945052862, 0.04480017349123955, 0.007511871866881847, -0.0059671769849956036, -0.028982853516936302, 0.023285944014787674, 0.005138389300554991, -0.02213686890900135, -0.009009374305605888, 0.025013532489538193, 0.02314787171781063, 0.012273082509636879, -0.015599575825035572, 0.0153695959597826, 0.023089956492185593, 0.048600565642118454, 0.0008528501493856311, 0.0017680319724604487, -0.07027406990528107, -0.015624944120645523, 0.07299603521823883, 0.03073207288980484, -0.03814782202243805, -0.02224321849644184, -0.02828526310622692, -0.013949381187558174, -0.000507112592458725, -0.02652978152036667, 0.012758210301399231, -0.00715069891884923, -0.01742950826883316, -0.057560645043849945, -0.018068838864564896, -0.06673397123813629, -0.01928502507507801, -0.03687169775366783, 0.05810355395078659, -0.02510477416217327, -0.02899966388940811, -0.030903665348887444, -0.0019777691923081875, -0.013500683009624481, 0.05768020078539848, -0.026053275913000107, -0.02341196872293949, 0.038063839077949524, 0.024853672832250595, -0.04386339336633682, -0.05469774454832077, -0.017077775672078133, 0.017798343673348427, -0.03157438337802887, 0.004209293518215418, -0.02302071452140808, -0.05178642272949219, 0.004253486171364784, -0.017111843451857567, -0.05031038448214531, -0.010610943660140038, -0.007387081626802683, 0.00009736011998029426, 0.04321565851569176, 0.017887089401483536, 0.06629268825054169, 0.022052066400647163, 0.0338655486702919, 0.019256388768553734, -0.02547844685614109, 0.02592417597770691, -0.03433629497885704, -0.005243608262389898, -0.025504378601908684, -0.0015952561516314745, -0.015029131434857845, 0.03966831415891647, 0.006819139234721661, 0.04544634371995926, -0.01575591415166855, -0.015270249918103218, -0.04182933270931244, 0.011858522891998291, -0.007699227426201105, -0.03276444226503372, -0.007137782871723175, 0.040474310517311096, -0.018694184720516205, 0.02948882058262825, 0.010110042989253998, -0.0014017686480656266, 0.008657194674015045, 0.03481679782271385, -0.023670198395848274, -0.0031627113930881023, -0.013231824152171612, 0.024065673351287842, 0.0233608465641737, -0.0546325147151947, 0.027741026133298874, 0.016763104125857353, 0.02626723237335682, 0.018135016784071922, -0.0189194418489933, -0.028742142021656036, 0.010262423194944859, 0.013876590877771378, 0.02636767365038395, -0.04875631257891655, 0.04187707602977753, -0.02417811006307602, 0.0071891723200678825, -0.015427114441990852, -0.04631960764527321, 0.023248979821801186, 0.00015143732889555395, -0.0247180238366127, -0.04153620824217796, 0.008419028483331203, 0.012368394061923027, -0.019762475043535233, -0.011794636957347393, 0.07204636186361313, -0.026074577122926712, -0.03972065448760986, 0.017446542158722878, 0.01552902814000845, 0.08536521345376968, -0.0036723704542964697, -0.010120095685124397, 0.034063514322042465, -0.004114808980375528, 0.001296810107305646, 0.0016567213460803032, 0.029451314359903336, -0.030037449672818184, -0.046254877001047134, -0.05706324055790901, 0.03823736310005188, 0.039732206612825394, -0.006159537471830845, 0.016793152317404747, 0.04395066946744919, 0.00572911836206913, -0.011633464135229588, -0.026773924008011818, 0.0036678018514066935, 0.0039354790933430195, -0.025024892762303352, -0.03103623352944851, 0.03458158299326897, 0.0016644260613247752, -0.014203110709786415, 0.03548629209399223, 0.015360039658844471, -0.012938734143972397, 0.0007344083278439939, 0.05372561886906624, -0.04697006195783615, 0.012752304784953594, -0.03549904003739357, -0.04265998303890228, 0.024211516603827477, -0.0008718465105630457, 0.03178315609693527, -0.010401974432170391, 0.05093825235962868, -0.0663435310125351, 0.04310097172856331, -0.03833552822470665, -0.035658031702041626, 0.08921097964048386, 0.026168551295995712, 0.07609795033931732, 0.08209384977817535, 0.012588857673108578, 0.030462471768260002, -0.05419253185391426, -0.01137116365134716, -0.05612282454967499, -0.026222199201583862, 0.05150323733687401, 0.014392102137207985, -0.0031842647586017847, 0.034360550343990326, -0.020015446469187737, 0.022641276940703392, 0.03950566425919533, 0.021536076441407204, 0.012778538279235363, 0.05081600695848465, -0.03964768350124359, -0.02142050862312317, 0.016538504511117935, -0.04132923111319542, -0.0020493469201028347, -0.0015206353273242712, -0.029940834268927574, 0.039975423365831375, 0.024783970788121223, 0.038354288786649704, -0.027302144095301628, -0.008650696836411953, -0.07715195417404175, 0.04143346846103668, -0.015294430777430534, -0.015814194455742836, 0.03792540356516838, -0.0050528692081570625, 0.020565921440720558, 0.003857979318127036, 0.022946815937757492, -0.029554316774010658, -0.09924571216106415, -0.017492830753326416, -0.01005610078573227, -0.029223818331956863, 0.024925993755459785, -0.0033829621970653534, -0.04130486026406288, 0.027195768430829048, -0.041152555495500565, 0.06041601300239563, 0.011751759797334671, 0.02926727943122387, -0.014676453545689583, 0.03844151645898819, 0.019984209910035133, 0.04137560352683067, 0.009154376573860645, 0.007277537137269974, 0.1427355855703354, 0.039642076939344406, 0.04381735622882843, -0.03261222317814827, -0.000493385421577841, 0.0022242998238652945, -0.00829819031059742, -0.004610423929989338, -0.014507349580526352, 0.018658678978681564, 0.024127185344696045, 0.028236813843250275, -0.00401642918586731, 0.010838158428668976, -0.03835371509194374, 0.051268015056848526, -0.06252893805503845, -0.019496500492095947, 0.029361097142100334, 0.006847669370472431, 0.026410715654492378, -0.009463471360504627, -0.03224870190024376, 0.004886713810265064, -0.009783132933080196, -0.007583426311612129, 0.0106894476339221, -0.051321279257535934, 0.03644241765141487, 0.006727814674377441, -0.007619952782988548, 0.010403521358966827, 0.030084434896707535, -0.01687007211148739, 0.0027603860944509506, 0.021615782752633095, 0.0013865022920072079, -0.020877420902252197, -0.01604234054684639, 0.010831145569682121, -0.002651515882462263, -0.013122729025781155, 0.006357783451676369, -0.02092297002673149, -0.04597451537847519, -0.008505662903189659, -0.05480076000094414, 0.07100333273410797, -0.018649181351065636, -0.014440538361668587, 0.011730662547051907, 0.006367124617099762, 0.02216367796063423, -0.049334779381752014, -0.029246119782328606, 0.023313038051128387, 0.003279943484812975, 0.009557587094604969, -0.03435075283050537, -0.04239051789045334, 0.042817939072847366, -0.012716448865830898, 0.008936162106692791, -0.005154935177415609, 0.0025785728357732296, -0.006789513863623142, 0.0031466027721762657, 0.009915472008287907, 0.024384383112192154, 0.036098089069128036, -0.016839003190398216, -0.019598085433244705, -0.005690143909305334, -0.03089863620698452, -0.008290167897939682, 0.0006724486011080444, 0.02659127302467823, -0.0007214754587039351, -0.030532822012901306, -0.026509255170822144, -0.05357358977198601, -0.007610468193888664, -0.021664775907993317, 0.007679814472794533, -0.048462215811014175, -0.005502181593328714, -0.015081299468874931, 0.024857614189386368, 0.032821204513311386, -0.01086664479225874, 0.04786663502454758, 0.05695445090532303, -0.017597192898392677, -0.01860182173550129, -0.028525376692414284, -0.024349598214030266, -0.020672958344221115, 0.025642845779657364, 0.022242771461606026, 0.05230585113167763, 0.037918590009212494, 0.007222828920930624, -0.01862420327961445, 0.027034128084778786, -0.009860764257609844, 0.01923747919499874, 0.005011094268411398, -0.009457655251026154, -0.000661203230265528, 0.028368448838591576, -0.01147208921611309, -0.0674578920006752, -0.03585829585790634, -0.01932627707719803, -0.030731534585356712, -0.012399476952850819, -0.019623074680566788, -0.04135224223136902, 0.018441857770085335, -0.013982918113470078, 0.06345691531896591, -0.020955801010131836, -0.0221933051943779, -0.05369657650589943, -0.02464848756790161, -0.03614656627178192, -0.00979642290621996, -0.008321141824126244, 0.005770951043814421, 0.01720401830971241, 0.029854072257876396, 0.04018562659621239, 0.012221185490489006, -0.013761564157903194, 0.008374329656362534, 0.004934654571115971, -0.031186314299702644, 0.04469016566872597, -0.0318717435002327, 0.0017875535413622856, 0.03335516154766083, -0.0297615434974432, -0.011304100975394249, 0.037763215601444244, -0.0003158913168590516, 0.031399182975292206, 0.0005290746921673417, -0.016604958102107048, -0.007376125548034906, 0.040997132658958435, -0.008992830291390419, -0.030565669760107994, -0.0032277374994009733, -0.0067979684099555016, 0.017313141375780106, 0.03377310559153557, 0.024576708674430847, 0.02152525633573532, -0.017691122367978096, -0.011456537991762161, 0.019833846017718315, 0.015664296224713326, 0.018236355856060982, 0.03000061959028244, -0.035111550241708755, 0.04564255475997925, 0.01437570434063673, 0.016495833173394203, 0.013917596079409122, 0.00911102443933487, -0.016210470348596573, 0.05276133492588997, 0.004964868538081646, -0.009551391005516052, -0.06855496019124985, -0.042537886649370193, 0.023673811927437782, -0.009610135108232498, 0.01872476562857628, -0.054365865886211395, -0.004038631916046143, 0.00555603438988328, -0.05025006830692291, 0.017208753153681755, 0.008846635930240154, -0.021322917193174362, -0.049404311925172806, 0.039741795510053635, -0.008083460852503777, -0.0024121226742863655, 0.038418397307395935, 0.02159210667014122, 0.029993079602718353, 0.05052086338400841, -0.0022804797627031803, -0.008637998253107071, -0.02717619575560093, 0.022835660725831985, -0.0028516945894807577, -0.03319684788584709, 0.01016140729188919, -0.02071395516395569, -0.021301476284861565, 0.00012228604464326054, -0.013700411655008793, -0.009405913762748241, 0.056625332683324814, 0.015364967286586761, 0.002506922697648406, 0.023450195789337158, 0.04004543274641037, -0.012150139547884464, -0.03716317191720009, 0.015373793430626392, 0.01788821443915367, 0.01952229253947735, -0.016496101394295692, -0.0007837985176593065, -0.019222769886255264, -0.035361528396606445, -0.014934094622731209, 0.010861613787710667, -0.02520238608121872, -0.01889672689139843, 0.004264463670551777, -0.0006252125022001565, -0.0008980752318166196, 0.011847860179841518, -0.01325224619358778, -0.031904492527246475, 0.02344650961458683, 0.009402343071997166, 0.008659768849611282, -0.021071070805191994, 0.012209000065922737, -0.018256723880767822, -0.06263777613639832, -0.019058385863900185, 0.031899575144052505, -0.01005509402602911, -0.05406051129102707, 0.007581977639347315, 0.03238973021507263, -0.01715484820306301, -0.021696213632822037, -0.027203720062971115, -0.011320274323225021, 0.053202103823423386, -0.02778051421046257, 0.041572242975234985, 0.018759071826934814, -0.000737509923055768, -0.02985084056854248, -0.10368729382753372, 0.08290551602840424, 0.0008854554616846144, -0.052719373255968094, -0.029205529019236565, -0.003922576084733009, -0.054117560386657715, 0.01789001189172268, 0.06027569994330406, 0.017520004883408546, 0.022648857906460762, -0.014003667049109936, -0.03370487689971924, 0.0029955152422189713, -0.045485612004995346, 0.01814841665327549, -0.02161971852183342, -0.021579395979642868, 0.005952597130089998, -0.03658751770853996, -0.013235414400696754, 0.02482585795223713, 0.046927791088819504, -0.019350752234458923, 0.016444945707917213, -0.014193247072398663, -0.014152336865663528, 0.05063766613602638, 0.009632430970668793, 0.027701986953616142, 0.02455952763557434, 0.007850672118365765, -0.0032014218159019947, 0.009057022631168365, -0.032425571233034134, -0.0720190778374672, 0.03504704684019089, -0.03097587078809738, -0.027834204956889153, 0.0021760144736617804, 0.030750740319490433, -0.003750518197193742, -0.04389512166380882, 0.004396147560328245, 0.0230406541377306, -0.005622849799692631, 0.00015975213318597525, 0.0012118351878598332, 0.01750771887600422, 0.020766153931617737, -0.015117637813091278, 0.048159949481487274, -0.03057330660521984, 0.011969524435698986, 0.02507811225950718, 0.00019903318025171757, 0.0040962654165923595, -0.016135642305016518, 0.057730045169591904, 0.019762925803661346, -0.020901210606098175, -0.009310626424849033, -0.007157411426305771, 0.07611165195703506, -0.05375431105494499, -0.010298370383679867, 0.04195590689778328, 0.0029634765814989805, 0.009919079951941967, 0.0149691728875041, 0.013013999909162521, 0.06779178977012634, -0.032642874866724014, -0.009873459115624428, -0.0485682412981987, -0.013072594068944454, 0.013580813072621822, -0.021986421197652817, 0.00048318287008441985, 0.023797860369086266, 0.02820674702525139, -0.012998709455132484, -0.044477201998233795, -0.002071139169856906, 0.02865491434931755, -0.023251421749591827, 0.022763323038816452, -0.013758087530732155, -0.017860664054751396, -0.013622043654322624, -0.02242416702210903, -0.005670200102031231, -0.011321690864861012, 0.022978199645876884, 0.05157007649540901, 0.01770677976310253, -0.020519495010375977, -0.03348787873983383, -0.0002821895759552717, 0.042585339397192, -0.06694072484970093, 0.009609176777303219, -0.048609230667352676, 0.02452394925057888, -0.006802077405154705, -0.050171975046396255 ]
<p>I have a continuous random variable $X$ (positive). I want to simulate its distribution with a discrete distribution and calculate $E[X]$ from that discrete distribution. So, the obvious approach is to divide the range of the random variable into step size of $h$; let the CDF values at the points $0,h,2h,\ldots,Nh$ be $P_0,P_1,P_2,\ldots,P_N$.</p> <p>Thus, $\text{Prob}(0 &lt; X \leq h)=P_1-P_0$, $\text{Prob}(h &lt; X \leq 2h)=P2-P1$ and so on.</p> <p>Now these probability masses are associated with a interval. We need to find a representative point of each interval, and here lays my problem.<br> For an interval $(a,b]$ which point should we take as the representative point? Leftmost point, rightmost point, the mid point?</p> <p>Basically, given the following relation F'(t)=P(X&lt;=t)=$1-(1-F(t))^{n}$ I need to find the expectation of X i.e E[X] where F(t) is CDF of some other random variable Y. The expression for F(t) is not known to me. I have only access to a black box that gives me a value of F(t) as output when I give a value of t as input. That's why the question of "approximating" the continuous distribution with a discrete distribution comes.</p> <p>Another question is how to choose an appropriate h value (step size) given an error bound "epsilon" on the expected value. Is there any standard method already?</p>
40,272
[ 0.00396316172555089, -0.03914032131433487, 0.025402430444955826, -0.017516503110527992, 0.012305494397878647, -0.008834253996610641, 0.01097162626683712, -0.031163671985268593, 0.021081550046801567, -0.00474031176418066, 0.062051597982645035, 0.045200031250715256, 0.05888209491968155, 0.016408298164606094, 0.04529156535863876, -0.00406866567209363, -0.03137432038784027, -0.0029033345635980368, -0.022840721532702446, -0.02103058248758316, 0.03190526366233826, 0.019071299582719803, 0.043192245066165924, -0.034168705344200134, -0.03605851158499718, 0.022893253713846207, 0.06571915000677109, -0.018047507852315903, 0.002488870872184634, 0.12866637110710144, -0.05595354735851288, -0.03602682054042816, 0.004398168530315161, 0.0762527734041214, -0.016537675634026527, 0.02387123741209507, -0.02572820708155632, -0.05773662030696869, -0.0017028518486768007, -0.007962668314576149, -0.05479728803038597, 0.01765318401157856, 0.009035695344209671, 0.009031166322529316, 0.01630549505352974, 0.018464133143424988, -0.0036532138474285603, -0.04862719401717186, 0.024476775899529457, -0.051099713891744614, 0.07250132411718369, -0.007870067842304707, 0.02238100953400135, 0.020433446392416954, -0.019224153831601143, -0.04028917849063873, 0.037566374987363815, 0.06948211789131165, -0.02588023617863655, -0.028088247403502464, -0.010510248132050037, -0.055291518568992615, 0.0002428936422802508, -0.018195418640971184, -0.0018763152183964849, 0.019144749268889427, -0.013129034079611301, -0.020260892808437347, -0.00671808049082756, -0.009516353718936443, 0.0012264922261238098, 0.03248303011059761, 0.038422729820013046, 0.010168885812163353, 0.0498344711959362, -0.006125292740762234, 0.027011780068278313, 0.0012722145766019821, 0.04570727422833443, 0.053075939416885376, -0.01820329762995243, -0.001936339889653027, 0.028145913034677505, 0.031068425625562668, 0.002988154534250498, -0.005172143690288067, 0.054361145943403244, -0.01177978701889515, 0.015374189242720604, -0.006589467637240887, -0.03609631210565567, -0.010119225829839706, 0.04689687490463257, -0.049210574477910995, -0.03717901557683945, 0.022167885676026344, -0.025275662541389465, 0.012117557227611542, 0.004911045078188181, -0.01696399413049221, -0.0059222388081252575, -0.07142423838376999, 0.03674463927745819, 0.075188048183918, -0.01681566797196865, 0.018503038212656975, -0.010377374477684498, -0.028484616428613663, 0.022396551445126534, -0.016976092010736465, -0.026464294642210007, 0.022832317277789116, 0.03223404288291931, 0.04204073175787926, 0.04048174247145653, 0.01668706163764, -0.013640900142490864, -0.03429528698325157, 0.055353160947561264, 0.042675089091062546, 0.0690770074725151, -0.02729988470673561, 0.045425936579704285, -0.026841364800930023, -0.050588034093379974, -0.013174566440284252, -0.00492142653092742, -0.014368362724781036, -0.028290215879678726, 0.033266376703977585, 0.01638355664908886, -0.029373405501246452, 0.0544111467897892, 0.03958410397171974, 0.039738357067108154, 0.005691145546734333, -0.0620836466550827, -0.05410822480916977, -0.01232294924557209, -0.03199758380651474, -0.016629347577691078, -0.045801714062690735, 0.01375728938728571, 0.05794884264469147, -0.0015429096529260278, 0.042540669441223145, 0.023685244843363762, -0.012521580792963505, 0.03727759048342705, 0.017354827374219894, -0.015093596652150154, 0.015948783606290817, -0.030487122014164925, -0.007106734439730644, -0.026790384203195572, -0.03573973849415779, 0.04655059054493904, 0.020242951810359955, -0.02850707806646824, -0.039325762540102005, 0.06411605328321457, -0.006893085781484842, -0.03709380701184273, -0.014764094725251198, 0.001433300320059061, -0.02569534443318844, 0.08050698786973953, -0.005989111959934235, 0.009458132088184357, -0.008004693314433098, 0.004017481580376625, -0.007346977945417166, 0.021536607295274734, 0.022215019911527634, 0.04000251367688179, -0.05347081646323204, -0.03756578266620636, -0.01688525080680847, 0.01568104326725006, 0.0279072318226099, -0.0019258204847574234, -0.011961875483393669, -0.009315423667430878, -0.005724161863327026, -0.011884203180670738, 0.022892717272043228, 0.024105791002511978, -0.004151666071265936, 0.019373131915926933, -0.049883343279361725, -0.034353796392679214, -0.05965999513864517, 0.037563808262348175, 0.04295233637094498, 0.01442595012485981, 0.024890277534723282, -0.002941716695204377, 0.0021625952795147896, -0.004646085202693939, -0.00977240689098835, -0.03200991451740265, -0.020966915413737297, 0.037550780922174454, -0.05098991096019745, 0.0094071039929986, 0.06888607144355774, 0.04109939560294151, -0.017097359523177147, 0.05341939628124237, -0.01194922998547554, -0.0502234622836113, -0.04017793387174606, -0.053788721561431885, 0.006408201530575752, -0.014348899945616722, -0.036825187504291534, 0.01159270666539669, -0.04467340186238289, -0.006491519045084715, 0.006693330593407154, -0.06328415870666504, 0.046007346361875534, 0.10025086253881454, 0.01678365468978882, -0.0052223531529307365, -0.005120878107845783, 0.009896653704345226, 0.015848368406295776, -0.0189020074903965, -0.03381044790148735, -0.015747785568237305, -0.027145525440573692, 0.05136512964963913, 0.03563932701945305, -0.023086659610271454, -0.00865837000310421, 0.06758556514978409, -0.023063169792294502, 0.03821311518549919, 0.059368036687374115, -0.0007234259974211454, 0.030421854928135872, 0.03427322208881378, 0.021944602951407433, 0.04107590764760971, -0.00021641823695972562, 0.006782188080251217, 0.01752372458577156, 0.03220292180776596, -0.005272840149700642, -0.004051092080771923, 0.024564869701862335, 0.004212111700326204, 0.0211768951267004, -0.011214633472263813, 0.003258246462792158, 0.005376684945076704, -0.04395363852381706, -0.015290425159037113, 0.007634985260665417, -0.0308797899633646, 0.004074615892022848, 0.015344765968620777, -0.019494714215397835, 0.03822625055909157, 0.044360145926475525, -0.047519903630018234, -0.019914021715521812, 0.02547985315322876, -0.02210978791117668, 0.040284089744091034, -0.03481999412178993, -0.02980154938995838, -0.031210334971547127, -0.0021270341239869595, 0.0034051823895424604, 0.008335614576935768, -0.0011871111346408725, -0.028240563347935677, 0.03245105966925621, -0.02798791602253914, -0.017852870747447014, 0.025670748203992844, -0.013887409120798111, -0.04137597605586052, -0.052245914936065674, -0.012965031899511814, -0.03297809511423111, 0.031320568174123764, -0.0021872897632420063, -0.02487962879240513, -0.006568980868905783, -0.005164735484868288, -0.05482044070959091, -0.012091757729649544, -0.04087924212217331, -0.0019559944048523903, -0.02992238663136959, -0.008398722857236862, 0.036015111953020096, 0.017792126163840294, -0.030622001737356186, 0.05403929203748703, 0.014570463448762894, -0.0330130010843277, -0.07760801911354065, 0.009312213398516178, 0.018281396478414536, 0.008442942053079605, 0.00448687793686986, 0.008001252077519894, 0.028950471431016922, -0.011680670082569122, -0.06081134453415871, -0.041663918644189835, -0.00812450423836708, 0.021239979192614555, 0.040409475564956665, 0.02605244144797325, -0.014820649288594723, 0.08208102732896805, 0.038699015974998474, -0.06164196506142616, 0.0071416618302464485, 0.008558768779039383, 0.011069909669458866, 0.004837896209210157, 0.006752036511898041, 0.04013353958725929, -0.036553218960762024, 0.022972622886300087, -0.017797792330384254, 0.003109106793999672, 0.04161185026168823, 0.0024708423297852278, 0.00526813417673111, -0.018684683367609978, -0.03237001597881317, -0.012771710753440857, 0.04926114156842232, 0.0076224845834076405, -0.026226965710520744, 0.020120469853281975, -0.0011635477421805263, 0.0026252998504787683, 0.046600304543972015, -0.033262383192777634, 0.02258801832795143, -0.018564628437161446, -0.005457296967506409, -0.023461775854229927, 0.04139736294746399, 0.010408175177872181, -0.05703458935022354, -0.0027389833703637123, 0.051176898181438446, 0.03137567266821861, -0.013756033964455128, -0.008047216571867466, 0.03218824416399002, 0.0474143885076046, -0.0179107915610075, -0.01277882605791092, 0.019458452239632607, -0.01193985901772976, 0.004860084503889084, -0.01819777674973011, -0.029635773971676826, 0.033441800624132156, 0.061751287430524826, 0.012593376450240612, -0.0010662905406206846, -0.0014223989564925432, -0.013729775324463844, -0.025001252070069313, -0.0032574734650552273, -0.013112910091876984, 0.06427054107189178, 0.024896472692489624, 0.05660361424088478, 0.0126592256128788, -0.018603898584842682, 0.0006492443499155343, 0.0017694620182737708, -0.0813470184803009, 0.0316314622759819, -0.018059853464365005, -0.004558432847261429, -0.05180301144719124, 0.000289381219772622, 0.06640680879354477, -0.0021377941593527794, 0.0010640700347721577, -0.012404756620526314, 0.0305574182420969, -0.023632347583770752, -0.031311944127082825, -0.03374028578400612, -0.045863330364227295, -0.027530962601304054, 0.01478518545627594, 0.03228508681058884, -0.013405217789113522, 0.03307323530316353, 0.018228990957140923, -0.033304400742053986, -0.033485688269138336, -0.009289766661822796, 0.019180458039045334, -0.017190370708703995, 0.052689798176288605, 0.03951343894004822, 0.02244662679731846, 0.015049736015498638, 0.030773498117923737, -0.016891317442059517, 0.084303118288517, 0.04686608165502548, -0.0369597002863884, 0.030106978490948677, -0.015480272471904755, -0.012595409527420998, 0.00006466501508839428, 0.014727598056197166, -0.039252810180187225, 0.00588656309992075, 0.07695996016263962, -0.01206615287810564, -0.030954008921980858, 0.01312343031167984, 0.05841157212853432, -0.0013741127913817763, 0.01746790111064911, -0.05815788730978966, -0.02674052119255066, -0.0009321266552433372, 0.01070421002805233, 0.003208871465176344, -0.0010686428286135197, 0.0189921073615551, 0.0038495794869959354, 0.07405839115381241, 0.025583775714039803, -0.004378053825348616, 0.015615270473062992, 0.019286269322037697, 0.049472518265247345, -0.008015445433557034, -0.0009798036189749837, 0.03526079282164574, -0.02495379000902176, 0.02567041665315628, -0.0046578943729400635, -0.0057316552847623825, -0.09661794453859329, 0.0001268507621716708, 0.028350012376904488, 0.029051002115011215, -0.011416386812925339, 0.025482283905148506, -0.05916653200984001, -0.008048365823924541, 0.06461504101753235, -0.03216936066746712, 0.00885753519833088, -0.022807469591498375, -0.0021751527674496174, 0.0034584044478833675, -0.02278093993663788, -0.04000000283122063, 0.008545471355319023, -0.008827663026750088, 0.0285702683031559, -0.061044640839099884, -0.00018439500126987696, -0.021360863000154495, 0.02952561154961586, 0.03906179219484329, 0.11288779228925705, -0.008874950930476189, -0.019434260204434395, 0.00775617640465498, 0.01394124235957861, 0.009802631102502346, -0.047654978930950165, -0.007344219833612442, 0.007938775233924389, -0.009324484504759312, 0.003955475520342588, -0.017302479594945908, -0.03309829160571098, 0.04606432095170021, -0.026766257360577583, -0.01057550311088562, 0.019589530304074287, -0.0044054556638002396, 0.05025540292263031, 0.005454028490930796, 0.003609658218920231, 0.03576214239001274, 0.04343651235103607, 0.02661892957985401, -0.012388180010020733, -0.010932877659797668, 0.0016243421705439687, -0.00483295600861311, 0.000721862306818366, -0.05831512436270714, -0.014552981592714787, -0.01477748528122902, 0.03459440544247627, 0.029713084921240807, 0.03855647146701813, -0.014267430640757084, -0.019275503233075142, 0.028184188529849052, 0.011191613972187042, 0.011209349147975445, 0.0037316209636628628, -0.026988765224814415, 0.03766603395342827, 0.008002955466508865, -0.01946546882390976, 0.004535038024187088, 0.018112488090991974, 0.027173962444067, 0.03664339333772659, -0.03639599308371544, 0.021775880828499794, -0.06992549449205399, -0.028923770412802696, 0.011000673286616802, -0.061391424387693405, 0.02779402956366539, -0.003089779755100608, 0.009579342789947987, 0.014518591575324535, -0.01002880372107029, -0.02029995247721672, -0.004232947714626789, 0.027956852689385414, 0.029437271878123283, -0.04481229931116104, 0.013093048706650734, -0.01232221256941557, 0.0036341834347695112, -0.05917736142873764, -0.04438777640461922, -0.004346565343439579, 0.011422611773014069, -0.0025176256895065308, -0.0798049047589302, 0.01823541335761547, -0.020218810066580772, -0.02706790715456009, -0.011488478630781174, 0.044791579246520996, 0.033941902220249176, 0.006604112219065428, -0.01568964123725891, 0.023312605917453766, 0.07045901566743851, 0.026957839727401733, -0.005715582985430956, 0.05437478423118591, 0.010874167084693909, -0.03734700009226799, 0.0024162367917597294, 0.024727148935198784, -0.0403011292219162, 0.01272066030651331, -0.008219939656555653, -0.002373186871409416, 0.023949703201651573, -0.021654663607478142, -0.02935277670621872, 0.03463823348283768, 0.019194630905985832, -0.01239591185003519, -0.005972014740109444, -0.027353765442967415, -0.006718754768371582, -0.001119193504564464, -0.0108286552131176, -0.00530241010710597, -0.015543383546173573, 0.013002905063331127, -0.014203655533492565, -0.010346019640564919, -0.0058487229980528355, -0.018576450645923615, 0.06288881599903107, -0.02327728271484375, 0.00699125649407506, 0.018969351425766945, -0.02252284251153469, 0.04601959139108658, -0.04443207383155823, -0.03675035014748573, 0.027194205671548843, 0.03185174986720085, -0.023878592997789383, -0.012211944907903671, -0.06553902477025986, 0.001722147106193006, 0.022327015176415443, 0.005935377441346645, 0.06603513658046722, 0.007362931501120329, 0.03002540022134781, -0.01847192645072937, 0.009946128353476524, -0.020701603963971138, -0.03631707653403282, 0.000872512930072844, 0.032102070748806, -0.0007111557642929256, -0.011541107669472694, 0.014382069930434227, -0.007880184799432755, -0.0019031902775168419, 0.06681807339191437, -0.005585925187915564, 0.014517865143716335, 0.038291942328214645, -0.040581900626420975, 0.01811791956424713, -0.00848374143242836, -0.03984668850898743, 0.017176691442728043, -0.04087554290890694, -0.014773307368159294, 0.03690379858016968, 0.02885323576629162, -0.023564046248793602, -0.03118833526968956, 0.0005336605827324092, -0.0416138581931591, 0.013923796825110912, -0.0022365055046975613, -0.019477279856801033, 0.0437626950442791, 0.008727575652301311, 0.0029874457977712154, 0.009140903130173683, 0.03438807651400566, -0.014550645835697651, -0.0635240375995636, -0.023683849722146988, -0.04814069718122482, -0.08046022057533264, 0.0062000444158911705, 0.013194615952670574, -0.05513579770922661, 0.042110808193683624, -0.02928171493113041, 0.034786466509103775, -0.03283993899822235, 0.030210789293050766, -0.05494901165366173, 0.0883679911494255, -0.020916037261486053, 0.030894562602043152, -0.004005294758826494, 0.004932456649839878, 0.12270142883062363, 0.07590921223163605, 0.030485743656754494, -0.08074195683002472, 0.0018692485755309463, -0.02248324081301689, 0.007402941584587097, -0.03783145546913147, 0.003522781189531088, 0.038476668298244476, -0.020817629992961884, -0.00970118585973978, 0.0360206663608551, 0.031084701418876648, 0.015525302849709988, 0.028032636269927025, -0.01654801331460476, -0.019717413932085037, 0.009665858931839466, 0.035148702561855316, -0.010433757677674294, -0.01555552240461111, -0.03409991413354874, -0.0015914575196802616, -0.022095350548624992, 0.010172820650041103, -0.040333811193704605, -0.021251792088150978, -0.017775682732462883, 0.005906697828322649, -0.02495339885354042, 0.0006455612601712346, 0.03190768510103226, -0.04310639947652817, 0.005881873425096273, -0.0014411740703508258, -0.016577765345573425, -0.007737087085843086, -0.011060948483645916, 0.028164878487586975, 0.021106049418449402, 0.024175899103283882, -0.02765391208231449, -0.022618021816015244, -0.019956544041633606, -0.05771331861615181, -0.06637463718652725, 0.05132808908820152, 0.01954786106944084, -0.008447134867310524, -0.008197641000151634, -0.019859924912452698, -0.011881963349878788, -0.028501614928245544, 0.0032082984689623117, 0.015281221829354763, 0.03945043683052063, -0.01610356755554676, -0.019152866676449776, -0.020510300993919373, 0.04037008062005043, -0.04081534966826439, 0.007943783886730671, 0.014847389422357082, -0.06510523706674576, 0.0074788471683859825, 0.005157801788300276, 0.03539036586880684, 0.00002405608211120125, -0.015034050680696964, 0.006797168869525194, -0.030747875571250916, -0.03311866894364357, -0.01212479081004858, 0.023454995825886726, -0.031212620437145233, 0.022869734093546867, 0.021420104429125786, 0.02606007270514965, -0.006467833649367094, -0.043520230799913406, 0.03443923592567444, -0.03712226450443268, -0.012036513537168503, -0.023265408352017403, -0.042446598410606384, 0.004847256001085043, 0.018085289746522903, 0.024574678391218185, -0.01581086777150631, 0.0006979831377975643, 0.02467830665409565, 0.025780322030186653, -0.05784313380718231, -0.0021997597068548203, 0.04237506166100502, -0.015227178111672401, 0.01991935819387436, 0.011525559239089489, 0.08096832782030106, 0.010367567650973797, 0.013864507898688316, -0.011057519353926182, 0.025401366874575615, -0.02724785916507244, 0.03278291970491409, -0.02492649294435978, -0.04741186276078224, 0.002969434717670083, 0.02875666879117489, -0.01411005761474371, -0.05563695728778839, -0.015385950915515423, -0.027448883280158043, -0.026513945311307907, -0.011705447919666767, 0.010479536838829517, -0.016560208052396774, 0.007210429757833481, -0.030205372720956802, 0.015612823888659477, -0.029257776215672493, -0.0007706602336838841, 0.010238965041935444, -0.009214361198246479, -0.02247839979827404, -0.010481470264494419, -0.025985492393374443, -0.010373572818934917, 0.003508949186652899, -0.002388698048889637, 0.032227519899606705, 0.03428508713841438, 0.03132685646414757, -0.007215529680252075, 0.017942067235708237, -0.012791263870894909, 0.018460119143128395, -0.040272705256938934, -0.004105119965970516, 0.038201138377189636, -0.052142977714538574, -0.01577586866915226, 0.010702593252062798, 0.029119061306118965, 0.033897921442985535, 0.02709062024950981, -0.004357765894383192, -0.007664683740586042, 0.02559465728700161, -0.040290042757987976, -0.0004624930734280497, 0.013358954340219498, 0.019521599635481834, 0.0002213047700934112, -0.01751338131725788, 0.0192619189620018, -0.0021789136808365583, 0.02474411018192768, 0.0007558474317193031, 0.006422582548111677, -0.00410141795873642, 0.003429137635976076, 0.05003499984741211, 0.00706774415448308, 0.0058239237405359745, 0.0005244745407253504, -0.015621327795088291, 0.009436020627617836, 0.029815373942255974, -0.030396539717912674, 0.05159179866313934, 0.0017909504240378737, 0.015930872410535812, -0.05439453572034836, -0.013558754697442055, 0.009601064957678318, 0.0038601995911449194, 0.032649632543325424, -0.02834797091782093, -0.017766455188393593, 0.02223183587193489, -0.027084320783615112, 0.015758752822875977, -0.00673531461507082, 0.007074776105582714, -0.0010085725225508213, -0.014020527713000774, -0.050425127148628235, 0.002444747369736433, 0.024224231019616127, 0.008545094169676304, 0.03415869548916817, 0.005415883380919695, -0.005900320131331682, -0.05890766158699989, 0.013906296342611313, 0.01883700303733349, 0.01206626370549202, -0.043168436735868454, 0.037511225789785385, -0.028184497728943825, -0.04065948352217674, 0.027522552758455276, -0.01122824102640152, 0.016447043046355247, -0.01618235372006893, 0.008976425975561142, -0.0008698275196366012, 0.07495120167732239, 0.037334833294153214, 0.000412590365158394, 0.011237883009016514, -0.005259154364466667, 0.017919350415468216, -0.025628920644521713, -0.006857051979750395, 0.0036439155228435993, 0.06139475852251053, 0.022624846547842026, -0.049304377287626266, 0.04795335233211517, 0.028029900044202805, -0.020420415326952934, -0.005128278862684965, -0.00278043863363564, -0.008580148220062256, -0.0110800014808774, 0.029588745906949043, -0.0035665223840624094, 0.0040475125424563885, 0.033666811883449554, 0.007305651903152466, -0.01521340012550354, 0.0076021007262170315, -0.030977169051766396, -0.06904049962759018, 0.012961388565599918, 0.024053985252976418, -0.03133862465620041, -0.0832652598619461, -0.016871381551027298, -0.002950003370642662, 0.03796040639281273, -0.013818295672535896, -0.041698381304740906, -0.03422260284423828, 0.01243728306144476, -0.04355063661932945, 0.0171396154910326, -0.005252795293927193, 0.008160306140780449, -0.03655872493982315, -0.08896850794553757, 0.06732708215713501, -0.012921344488859177, -0.03236795589327812, -0.02671578899025917, 0.019203485921025276, -0.034459251910448074, -0.03167029842734337, 0.03912871330976486, 0.04187478497624397, -0.019292404875159264, -0.00757910031825304, 0.008252328261733055, 0.02256246656179428, -0.058733489364385605, -0.011759298853576183, -0.03700076416134834, -0.014777818694710732, 0.00286363554187119, -0.017544180154800415, 0.028967592865228653, 0.01974821463227272, 0.011169202625751495, -0.0009866267209872603, 0.0059799388982355595, -0.0015334277413785458, 0.021651489660143852, 0.014147882349789143, -0.0020154903177171946, 0.010265967808663845, 0.044402994215488434, 0.02584274299442768, 0.016066774725914, -0.015194370411336422, 0.013296620920300484, -0.03104313649237156, 0.017162425443530083, -0.04488043114542961, -0.05665002018213272, -0.011637803167104721, 0.0394071526825428, -0.017125247046351433, -0.088990718126297, -0.005062947049736977, 0.029289815574884415, -0.01603461615741253, 0.015432934276759624, 0.020266955718398094, 0.02895396202802658, 0.025035671889781952, 0.009058703668415546, 0.031061112880706787, 0.008955124765634537, 0.011679896153509617, -0.010724782012403011, -0.007728153839707375, 0.01888655684888363, -0.07135424017906189, 0.0399913489818573, 0.03390929102897644, -0.04968825727701187, 0.04919976368546486, 0.024021774530410767, 0.016614919528365135, 0.004382038954645395, -0.01906481757760048, 0.020235775038599968, -0.023440059274435043, -0.01652906835079193, 0.0011322438949719071, -0.04190908744931221, 0.08125720918178558, -0.0007586808642372489, 0.02528940699994564, -0.04115479066967964, 0.009010281413793564, 0.005750352516770363, 0.004353731870651245, 0.0129481116309762, -0.0029972316697239876, -0.012510094791650772, 0.01637832261621952, -0.0005731314886361361, 0.0241587832570076, -0.0010500913485884666, -0.026077358052134514, 0.020405318588018417, 0.004263662733137608, -0.018988383933901787, -0.012009699828922749, -0.040394920855760574, -0.00914950855076313, -0.016086233779788017, -0.00017368966655340046, 0.05495447665452957, 0.038729362189769745, 0.01358016487210989, -0.039854083210229874, 0.03862489387392998, 0.05414119362831116, -0.08541827648878098, 0.009576383046805859, -0.022420145571231842, -0.004247486125677824, -0.0092841275036335, -0.017070461064577103 ]
<p>I got an example calculation for multiplicative model, which is shown as follows:</p> <pre><code>Quarter 1 2 3 4 Average 0.866 1.0005 1.403 0.660 -------------------------------------------------- Adjustment 0.0176 0.0176 0.0176 0.0176 Seasonal factor 0.884 1.018 1.421 0.678 </code></pre> <p>Then there is a note below:</p> <blockquote> <p>Sum of averages = 3.9295. These should sum to 4, 4-3.9295=0.0705. Adding 0.0705/4=0.0176 to each average, to obtain the seasonal factors.</p> </blockquote> <p>I saw from other resources that they are using "seasonal index" instead of "seasonal factor" by normalizing the values. Besides that, they also mentioned about X11, X12, ARIMA, and so on. I would like to know is, based on the example above, what is the method called?</p>
74,242
[ 0.010827600955963135, -0.02093610353767872, -0.03890301287174225, 0.01746927946805954, 0.0636809766292572, 0.019898556172847748, -0.00016810582019388676, -0.01168759260326624, 0.038813523948192596, -0.012987947091460228, 0.04534446820616722, 0.023640869185328484, 0.06670594960451126, 0.03773428872227669, 0.010867401957511902, -0.0068208216689527035, -0.017445292323827744, 0.01802501268684864, 0.02349006198346615, 0.0015921256272122264, -0.002178225666284561, 0.02082773484289646, -0.006858225911855698, -0.00869693048298359, -0.011469216085970402, 0.03602156788110733, 0.02057022973895073, 0.016803760081529617, 0.0038700064178556204, 0.02259029448032379, 0.006482747383415699, -0.035993792116642, 0.023307709023356438, 0.02405724674463272, 0.014521120116114616, 0.004642198793590069, 0.0033727027475833893, -0.03048831783235073, -0.038399018347263336, 0.020714029669761658, -0.030771324411034584, 0.0008809417486190796, -0.013101262971758842, -0.012945882976055145, -0.03567676618695259, 0.014436034485697746, -0.008698283694684505, 0.012885546311736107, 0.06478769332170486, -0.040755875408649445, 0.06409913301467896, 0.014353573322296143, 0.054769448935985565, -0.006005695089697838, -0.017891760915517807, -0.009978515096008778, 0.04057749733328819, 0.053253114223480225, 0.004479201976209879, -0.04133186489343643, -0.017559198662638664, -0.011213362216949463, 0.0031465482898056507, -0.030610427260398865, -0.018712444230914116, 0.006485641002655029, -0.00689123896881938, -0.05212406814098358, 0.03497620299458504, 0.00036003225250169635, 0.002993864705786109, -0.020968569442629814, 0.0500657819211483, -0.044667862355709076, 0.011708145961165428, -0.036987483501434326, 0.011729860678315163, -0.012835714034736156, 0.015492730773985386, 0.03184201940894127, -0.0011865575797855854, 0.02547474205493927, -0.02592519484460354, -0.006967622321099043, 0.028426911681890488, 0.010449136607348919, 0.06352508813142776, -0.0041555361822247505, 0.012189873494207859, 0.05792291834950447, -0.026837782934308052, 0.040573395788669586, 0.034114718437194824, -0.0038594596553593874, -0.06955704092979431, 0.06576554477214813, 0.022498685866594315, -0.008021771907806396, 0.0029072684701532125, 0.0029495980124920607, 0.028454018756747246, -0.004710662644356489, 0.00405791075900197, 0.029420318081974983, -0.05023685097694397, 0.001448612893000245, -0.04373784735798836, 0.012875163927674294, -0.0003119582252111286, -0.009381028823554516, -0.019702591001987457, -0.02999896928668022, -0.001349523663520813, -0.04773084819316864, 0.0358356349170208, 0.000020133533325861208, -0.01571536995470524, 0.011464857496321201, 0.04866316542029381, 0.0484529547393322, 0.03507878631353378, 0.0132330022752285, 0.054216399788856506, -0.029660508036613464, -0.05558549612760544, -0.011198845691978931, -0.04266945272684097, -0.051572807133197784, -0.04456248879432678, 0.05770977959036827, 0.04119494557380676, -0.05786512792110443, 0.06156723573803902, 0.022138703614473343, 0.021271390840411186, 0.00794352125376463, -0.04016264155507088, -0.04023589566349983, 0.04234516620635986, -0.03968462347984314, 0.03407342731952667, -0.039353977888822556, 0.018187901005148888, 0.018861955031752586, 0.060484569519758224, 0.053436633199453354, 0.019941169768571854, 0.008369551040232182, 0.020710837095975876, 0.014392937533557415, -0.04045841097831726, -0.029515227302908897, -0.028484879061579704, -0.04129152372479439, -0.02413962222635746, -0.0925990492105484, 0.013377673923969269, 0.0356590561568737, -0.031530529260635376, -0.004095922224223614, 0.05065499618649483, 0.037189070135354996, -0.03258475288748741, 0.05118424817919731, -0.0066457041539251804, -0.03633366897702217, 0.07335825264453888, -0.009310525842010975, 0.005484788212925196, 0.021333208307623863, -0.004469993524253368, 0.01617855206131935, 0.004620090126991272, 0.031429167836904526, 0.03366267681121826, -0.009702706709504128, -0.0210769921541214, -0.04869093745946884, 0.016704754903912544, 0.02308725379407406, -0.06760378181934357, -0.03242234140634537, -0.01896054670214653, -0.016740089282393456, 0.04807120934128761, 0.04901326820254326, 0.008756010793149471, 0.005023033358156681, 0.0660412460565567, -0.07627544552087784, -0.01822206936776638, -0.06135305389761925, -0.01454823836684227, -0.02911311388015747, -0.005949921440333128, -0.00098252238240093, -0.004150256048887968, 0.03611356392502785, 0.00914932880550623, -0.007203846238553524, -0.01874038204550743, -0.02285946160554886, 0.05878064036369324, -0.024377906695008278, -0.007084541022777557, 0.018270175904035568, 0.005320716183632612, -0.02059912122786045, 0.024123290553689003, -0.05762559548020363, -0.014893866144120693, -0.031228389590978622, -0.046860210597515106, 0.034387361258268356, -0.030421731993556023, -0.06334641575813293, 0.03842687979340553, 0.007405091542750597, -0.005918644834309816, 0.04795151948928833, -0.055804964154958725, 0.01652870513498783, 0.0919601321220398, 0.010359174571931362, 0.009752185083925724, 0.0012712879106402397, 0.020492538809776306, 0.04998687282204628, 0.026233408600091934, -0.01600373350083828, -0.051795244216918945, -0.018607694655656815, 0.03712642192840576, -0.014562324620783329, -0.03867201879620552, 0.020189505070447922, 0.07304295152425766, 0.017440609633922577, 0.006095536053180695, 0.0472564660012722, 0.004060191567987204, 0.05869726836681366, -0.00220721703954041, 0.029325401410460472, 0.01677732914686203, 0.017161725088953972, 0.03441174700856209, -0.008192646317183971, 0.015005451627075672, 0.019771061837673187, -0.020637664943933487, 0.04571015015244484, 0.01308864913880825, 0.02533489651978016, -0.027628229930996895, -0.016422966495156288, 0.01866166479885578, -0.03546877205371857, 0.010246656835079193, 0.050506774336099625, 0.01570635288953781, -0.019936876371502876, 0.023920388892292976, -0.008195013739168644, -0.030435064807534218, 0.03427983075380325, -0.05445408821105957, -0.05646626278758049, 0.017171785235404968, -0.009808671660721302, 0.025793014094233513, -0.023727446794509888, -0.0030529838986694813, -0.06202631816267967, 0.016894355416297913, 0.06251119822263718, 0.042735181748867035, 0.02343289740383625, -0.001097609056159854, -0.02708347886800766, -0.004432749468833208, -0.018840648233890533, 0.02008388377726078, 0.011095483787357807, -0.019909627735614777, 0.015759391710162163, 0.010085847228765488, -0.027554357424378395, 0.05135681480169296, -0.018774675205349922, -0.02927243895828724, 0.014705988578498363, 0.02119770646095276, -0.013054744340479374, -0.014836019836366177, -0.042751915752887726, -0.002826146548613906, -0.05551975965499878, -0.013475421816110611, 0.05434408411383629, 0.014944246038794518, -0.012859071604907513, -0.014264197088778019, -0.07338372617959976, -0.0018879483686760068, -0.03956359997391701, -0.04055687412619591, -0.02717316709458828, -0.016086896881461143, 0.004001211374998093, 0.0018035053508356214, 0.005978927947580814, 0.015058872289955616, -0.06277044117450714, -0.05613621324300766, 0.003384942188858986, -0.020669000223279, 0.029174091294407845, 0.03770718723535538, -0.021645385771989822, 0.07408571243286133, 0.01840807870030403, -0.047795459628105164, -0.05825577676296234, 0.0036520143039524555, -0.02148839645087719, -0.01843198761343956, 0.0011450237361714244, 0.05641232803463936, 0.007587479893118143, 0.020737117156386375, -0.00414534006267786, -0.008956090547144413, 0.08143466711044312, 0.035430509597063065, 0.00522987125441432, 0.014223549515008926, -0.026226580142974854, -0.006040289532393217, 0.05272962525486946, 0.01623412035405636, 0.024857047945261, 0.009737350046634674, -0.008582217618823051, 0.0020344879012554884, 0.027995876967906952, -0.041370369493961334, 0.011167782358825207, 0.010328175500035286, -0.007977551780641079, -0.050514306873083115, 0.012052610516548157, 0.029043247923254967, -0.007008262909948826, -0.02687394805252552, 0.02127482369542122, -0.03149760141968727, -0.002960439305752516, -0.006296774838119745, 0.0428774431347847, 0.04585584998130798, -0.04320400580763817, -0.00994197465479374, -0.012395561672747135, -0.007418567314743996, 0.035398416221141815, -0.03603610023856163, 0.006308421492576599, 0.07019515335559845, 0.039256684482097626, 0.007303500548005104, -0.004166475962847471, -0.038417086005210876, 0.0003406185132917017, -0.10777013748884201, -0.008202716708183289, -0.034511860460042953, 0.047234468162059784, 0.02486068569123745, 0.01713409274816513, -0.0055082207545638084, -0.01644999533891678, 0.05259178578853607, -0.03597300127148628, -0.061099227517843246, 0.015507458709180355, 0.030284015461802483, -0.029908152297139168, 0.028026871383190155, -0.009825590997934341, 0.025489332154393196, -0.010235357098281384, 0.010964515618979931, 0.0016434898134320974, -0.01084071397781372, -0.03349711373448372, 0.015410241670906544, 0.012393566779792309, -0.003313313238322735, -0.04100595414638519, 0.0020542778074741364, 0.06566905975341797, -0.01155126839876175, 0.019551917910575867, 0.011638004332780838, 0.001486593740992248, 0.005681226495653391, -0.03655381128191948, 0.011737327091395855, 0.04779895022511482, 0.009848779067397118, 0.02828327752649784, 0.027316778898239136, -0.06017448008060455, 0.03347756713628769, 0.019578587263822556, 0.032484475523233414, 0.004102391190826893, -0.0187895055860281, -0.011624746024608612, 0.003913092892616987, -0.0011891663307324052, 0.0105734309181571, -0.014557242393493652, 0.041257936507463455, 0.0276279766112566, 0.030010942369699478, 0.02650582231581211, -0.06653398275375366, 0.006171157583594322, 0.11043351888656616, -0.025810059159994125, 0.039431240409612656, -0.016541050747036934, 0.024385033175349236, 0.0070974803529679775, -0.0010706164175644517, 0.030339546501636505, 0.00022136763436719775, 0.007510343566536903, 0.02554565854370594, 0.0219775028526783, -0.030320728197693825, 0.0034938184544444084, 0.030579933896660805, 0.027596566826105118, 0.06916356086730957, 0.011005162261426449, -0.019006382673978806, 0.036105282604694366, 0.06332618743181229, 0.011587674729526043, 0.020069943740963936, -0.020986253395676613, -0.10789472609758377, 0.026050088927149773, 0.010893501341342926, 0.047890473157167435, -0.027355223894119263, -0.0051202294416725636, -0.053223833441734314, 0.0019351338269189, 0.023041479289531708, -0.0028986281249672174, 0.041406892240047455, -0.008008213713765144, 0.025374745950102806, 0.0005145057220943272, 0.0008200542652048171, -0.014713939279317856, 0.032698988914489746, -0.036859676241874695, 0.01041631679981947, 0.01126635167747736, -0.014080073684453964, -0.04409220814704895, 0.017291558906435966, -0.016698310151696205, 0.023862309753894806, -0.04042698070406914, -0.010071074590086937, -0.01944216527044773, 0.030463729053735733, -0.01773538440465927, -0.07068797945976257, 0.013353219255805016, 0.02048362046480179, -0.022516431286931038, -0.005225293803960085, -0.026575304567813873, -0.012045063078403473, 0.0026778015308082104, -0.00379245076328516, 0.0029558758251369, -0.031696390360593796, -0.017690712586045265, 0.033242158591747284, 0.04162386804819107, -0.01588369719684124, 0.07857080549001694, 0.049257032573223114, -0.028729291632771492, -0.02835461124777794, -0.02024347521364689, 0.011379039846360683, -0.010422182269394398, -0.027738923206925392, -0.02590666338801384, 0.03162861242890358, -0.01591646671295166, 0.010161135345697403, -0.0002658852899912745, 0.07815329730510712, -0.04745424538850784, 0.0035280724987387657, -0.007326748222112656, -0.007035553455352783, -0.010876893997192383, -0.029561582952737808, 0.020594391971826553, 0.013419522903859615, -0.013164060190320015, -0.03618113324046135, 0.0062430002726614475, -0.005065708886831999, -0.00913919135928154, 0.027578391134738922, -0.000360305595677346, 0.002574068959802389, -0.011418621987104416, -0.014006014913320541, -0.0036952609661966562, -0.003235721029341221, 0.01026296429336071, -0.05449080094695091, 0.016697587445378304, 0.02683834731578827, -0.04445646330714226, -0.018549397587776184, -0.005083995871245861, 0.031014442443847656, 0.03050270862877369, -0.020173322409391403, 0.02700764127075672, 0.0036627172958105803, -0.02981405146420002, -0.04457198455929756, -0.0728045105934143, 0.05602841451764107, -0.01571657694876194, -0.05358533561229706, -0.04079491272568703, -0.01482359878718853, -0.03004017286002636, -0.03354320675134659, -0.012134769931435585, 0.013705935329198837, -0.02741534449160099, -0.02173887938261032, 0.014749131165444851, 0.02296546660363674, 0.037423908710479736, 0.02758093923330307, -0.01755138859152794, 0.03525994345545769, 0.01863701082766056, -0.025885118171572685, 0.00099843367934227, -0.00594740966334939, -0.06005105376243591, -0.0017064179992303252, -0.03174564614892006, -0.037814971059560776, 0.04131343588232994, -0.0027909448835998774, 0.001367516117170453, 0.02975628897547722, 0.0524003840982914, 0.0075673931278288364, -0.04139482229948044, -0.0018974080448970199, -0.005511878523975611, 0.027972135692834854, -0.037224218249320984, -0.02553163468837738, -0.024405188858509064, 0.007840514183044434, -0.0010142028331756592, -0.034163668751716614, -0.016906719654798508, 0.02625981718301773, 0.07517699152231216, 0.017911525443196297, 0.02169598825275898, 0.03481479361653328, -0.012947932817041874, -0.01393088884651661, 0.016133880242705345, 0.027408940717577934, 0.021921155974268913, 0.013159919530153275, -0.0030890991911292076, -0.03632169961929321, -0.030841266736388206, 0.02367841824889183, 0.05856853723526001, -0.05172436684370041, 0.01223563402891159, 0.06821487098932266, -0.004110691137611866, -0.01463103387504816, -0.03599359840154648, -0.05670155584812164, -0.007161291316151619, 0.009661306627094746, 0.10206965357065201, -0.016320981085300446, -0.01797347329556942, 0.013005795888602734, 0.015871042385697365, 0.021256273612380028, 0.04792331904172897, 0.004846191965043545, -0.0039005540311336517, -0.010110169649124146, -0.002954421564936638, -0.027620680630207062, 0.05379815772175789, 0.00016082172805909067, 0.03283238410949707, -0.006614619866013527, -0.035365939140319824, 0.050762422382831573, 0.02807982824742794, -0.034323517233133316, -0.09098580479621887, -0.011877939105033875, -0.0057955593802034855, -0.012829356826841831, 0.04049982875585556, -0.05172243341803551, 0.029903706163167953, 0.010707526467740536, 0.036941297352313995, 0.030775589868426323, 0.04865317419171333, -0.0014282460324466228, -0.05999532714486122, -0.016012046486139297, -0.015156981535255909, -0.03803158923983574, 0.030350182205438614, 0.0014123471919447184, -0.01397958304733038, -0.01938381977379322, -0.028013821691274643, 0.004902592860162258, -0.007207873277366161, 0.036374665796756744, 0.0180765800178051, 0.0869254544377327, 0.0023511461913585663, 0.002487843856215477, 0.02110910788178444, 0.007662210147827864, 0.11115097999572754, 0.05629025399684906, 0.012935689650475979, -0.06016784906387329, -0.029497703537344933, -0.014920474961400032, 0.012032084167003632, -0.024528928101062775, 0.01967030018568039, 0.0016433261334896088, 0.00649834331125021, 0.07266557216644287, 0.07251699268817902, 0.0020066171418875456, 0.013265520334243774, 0.02055288851261139, -0.012588584795594215, -0.029182422906160355, 0.009590834379196167, 0.015321046113967896, 0.015498872846364975, -0.008141763508319855, -0.06813854724168777, 0.025106491521000862, 0.04262658581137657, -0.024355627596378326, -0.021377164870500565, -0.02224854752421379, -0.023670105263590813, 0.038566429167985916, -0.014313679188489914, 0.05759803205728531, 0.02550293132662773, 0.0010681290877982974, 0.011399534530937672, -0.0323907732963562, -0.0011578750563785434, -0.02802414633333683, 0.033608321100473404, 0.03046562150120735, 0.0398360900580883, -0.02157485857605934, -0.008471790701150894, 0.014957238920032978, -0.026576397940516472, 0.004929267801344395, -0.05229949951171875, 0.02442975714802742, -0.019333891570568085, -0.0046983081847429276, -0.031188255175948143, 0.020131947472691536, -0.002930751536041498, -0.028407936915755272, -0.018691783770918846, 0.01018561888486147, 0.04342440888285637, -0.030877215787768364, -0.015010738745331764, -0.005606639198958874, 0.018410656601190567, -0.03688714653253555, 0.013898158445954323, 0.0298028402030468, -0.016055051237344742, -0.005945143289864063, -0.027125900611281395, 0.04357049614191055, -0.027509938925504684, -0.01347673311829567, 0.01237558014690876, -0.011292275041341782, -0.03562391176819801, -0.028290538117289543, -0.015541529282927513, -0.008495587855577469, 0.012248973362147808, -0.009646909311413765, 0.011033408343791962, 0.008082197047770023, -0.002924099564552307, -0.0026404173113405704, 0.007948937825858593, -0.001362384995445609, -0.03536839410662651, 0.0007067256956361234, 0.006881984882056713, -0.0006541833281517029, -0.01822059042751789, 0.003993103746324778, -0.012375256046652794, 0.05584423616528511, 0.025745684280991554, -0.06525278091430664, -0.03868706896901131, 0.009465731680393219, 0.00662902370095253, -0.0051996828988194466, -0.029690425843000412, 0.037291835993528366, 0.0340133011341095, -0.02998264692723751, -0.03709981590509415, 0.032576337456703186, -0.01026118267327547, -0.0010402660118415952, -0.01640462689101696, -0.03187187761068344, 0.039716240018606186, 0.008446096442639828, -0.004692851100116968, -0.03924066573381424, 0.005202132277190685, -0.01571520045399666, -0.016747677698731422, -0.0015616386663168669, 0.07264276593923569, -0.07434464246034622, 0.009893436916172504, -0.011095422320067883, 0.018808161839842796, -0.014873652718961239, 0.0032027787528932095, -0.007918352261185646, -0.0016617057844996452, -0.009971873834729195, -0.014423411339521408, -0.012990284711122513, 0.008318795822560787, -0.011352336034178734, 0.012069696560502052, 0.056272588670253754, -0.0006175193702802062, -0.0058517009019851685, -0.007214429788291454, -0.0048515647649765015, -0.03184720128774643, 0.028785688802599907, -0.02805614471435547, -0.0382600873708725, 0.024624988436698914, -0.04740015044808388, -0.024342605844140053, 0.007407846860587597, 0.02853786014020443, 0.042755864560604095, 0.008667506277561188, 0.01990532875061035, 0.010094475001096725, 0.03223321586847305, -0.021896913647651672, -0.016873326152563095, -0.043191663920879364, -0.005138032604008913, 0.03692324087023735, -0.019363775849342346, -0.037404194474220276, -0.0005962307914160192, -0.012521106749773026, 0.01965450868010521, 0.051784448325634, 0.0014190473593771458, 0.0008993266965262592, 0.006976782809942961, -0.01690884679555893, -0.039001528173685074, 0.011108443140983582, -0.0015315039781853557, 0.03621041402220726, -0.0031697596423327923, 0.007476993836462498, 0.013402819633483887, -0.0486912839114666, -0.01924661174416542, -0.0015610693953931332, -0.04637919366359711, 0.014515569433569908, -0.005425338167697191, 0.01919870264828205, -0.0309588760137558, 0.026065094396471977, 0.014035719446837902, -0.02460871823132038, 0.02298365905880928, -0.007553108502179384, -0.03326747193932533, -0.0152336610481143, 0.01442748960107565, 0.01931999810039997, 0.022969895973801613, 0.044519323855638504, -0.008281759917736053, 0.02402326464653015, 0.012149081565439701, 0.0006565144867636263, -0.04861192777752876, -0.012191479094326496, -0.013062444515526295, 0.039177048951387405, -0.03602074459195137, 0.03380560874938965, -0.05962386354804039, -0.02439224161207676, 0.026416664943099022, -0.010974888689815998, 0.014161701314151287, 0.01719345711171627, 0.019220774993300438, -0.01249014399945736, 0.03363935276865959, 0.036620624363422394, 0.0124210799112916, -0.026501402258872986, 0.014149345457553864, 0.04311376065015793, 0.044175367802381516, 0.004832928534597158, 0.017618482932448387, 0.013033068738877773, 0.010466735810041428, -0.03988899663090706, 0.02077510766685009, 0.018825776875019073, -0.014220145530998707, -0.007714924402534962, -0.028419381007552147, 0.004806687124073505, -0.028490789234638214, 0.011494158767163754, -0.026582902297377586, 0.008493407629430294, 0.034813132137060165, -0.01076682098209858, -0.024374503642320633, -0.009468631818890572, 0.015149455517530441, -0.021161865442991257, 0.04351741448044777, 0.021770581603050232, -0.0021617321763187647, -0.02233947068452835, -0.01900652050971985, 0.024290133267641068, -0.0326339453458786, -0.025661051273345947, -0.043235719203948975, -0.04068658500909805, 0.02644261345267296, -0.014738282188773155, -0.014101402834057808, 0.02773236483335495, -0.026726804673671722, 0.04624835401773453, -0.08852319419384003, 0.0642436295747757, 0.030944960191845894, -0.00844114925712347, -0.0007124576368369162, -0.019164981320500374, -0.05860547348856926, -0.01451389491558075, 0.05236548185348511, 0.026115233078598976, 0.009189092554152012, -0.008177919313311577, 0.025033190846443176, -0.0019327746704220772, -0.04927007853984833, 0.026902025565505028, -0.0022388736251741648, -0.03135361149907112, -0.011464889161288738, -0.032660409808158875, -0.020698493346571922, -0.0645684003829956, -0.01027363259345293, 0.008003356866538525, 0.014834227971732616, 0.010286828503012657, -0.03941326588392258, -0.0004348456859588623, 0.024063322693109512, -0.013391961343586445, 0.05662786588072777, -0.010214782319962978, 0.014357720501720905, 0.057373739778995514, 0.007256805896759033, -0.04843878746032715, 0.019363099709153175, -0.07055503129959106, -0.00044220240670256317, -0.009609349071979523, 0.017107151448726654, 0.013495066203176975, -0.07858997583389282, -0.009828922338783741, 0.06961818784475327, -0.03864995390176773, 0.005806855391710997, 0.03173809498548508, -0.009640833362936974, 0.05867328122258186, 0.009825211949646473, 0.018248671665787697, -0.0069326902739703655, -0.023726439103484154, -0.00559883052483201, 0.009652999229729176, 0.005241780541837215, 0.0047749546356499195, -0.0064735920168459415, 0.021874897181987762, 0.033979617059230804, 0.024941258132457733, -0.013951868750154972, 0.03321841359138489, -0.03399224951863289, -0.03980566933751106, -0.011042017489671707, -0.03879965469241142, 0.033122655004262924, 0.018344806507229805, -0.018188271671533585, 0.040125615894794464, -0.06401821225881577, 0.01840340532362461, -0.007002643775194883, 0.03165558725595474, -0.036010321229696274, -0.006992510985583067, -0.017862381413578987, 0.0410744771361351, -0.03126730024814606, -0.007688829209655523, 0.029209326952695847, 0.004144246224313974, -0.00581120140850544, -0.01064272504299879, 0.0007853847346268594, -0.029382340610027313, -0.009871799498796463, 0.012456798925995827, -0.015399614349007607, -0.059016499668359756, -0.035263463854789734, 0.03821101039648056, 0.011878602206707, 0.02927953377366066, 0.00967329926788807, -0.0335363931953907, -0.002445108024403453, 0.024523569270968437, -0.07399535924196243, -0.0006222396623343229, -0.03627970442175865, 0.0005294633447192609, -0.018188823014497757, -0.028878148645162582 ]
<p>I have zero inflated response variable I am trying to predict. I am facing few issues applying different regression models that should correct for this.</p> <p>This is my 10,000 obs dataframe</p> <pre><code> e_weight left_size right_size time_diff Min. :0.000 Min. : 1.000 Min. : 1.000 Min. : 737 1st Qu.:0.000 1st Qu.: 1.000 1st Qu.: 1.000 1st Qu.: 4669275 Median :0.000 Median : 3.000 Median : 3.000 Median : 12263474 Mean :0.022 Mean : 6.194 Mean : 5.469 Mean : 21000288 3rd Qu.:0.000 3rd Qu.: 5.000 3rd Qu.: 5.000 3rd Qu.: 25420278 Max. :3.000 Max. :792.000 Max. :792.000 Max. :155291532 </code></pre> <p>Here the frequency count for my 3 variables <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/1yIvx.jpg" alt="enter image description here"> Indeed I have a problem with zeros...</p> <p>I tried respectively a Zero-Inflated Negative Binomial Regression and a Zero-inflated Poisson Regression</p> <pre><code>library(pscl) m1 &lt;- zeroinfl(e_weight ~ left_size*right_size | time_diff, data = s) summary(m1) # Call: # zeroinfl(formula = e_weight ~ left_size * right_size | time_diff, data = s) # # Pearson residuals: # Min 1Q Median 3Q Max # -1.4286 -0.1460 -0.1449 -0.1444 19.6054 # # Count model coefficients (poisson with log link): # Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(&gt;|z|) # (Intercept) -3.8826386 0.0696970 -55.707 &lt; 2e-16 *** # left_size 0.0022261 0.0006195 3.594 0.000326 *** # right_size 0.0033622 NA NA NA # left_size:right_size 0.0001715 NA NA NA # # Zero-inflation model coefficients (binomial with logit link): # Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(&gt;|z|) # (Intercept) 1.753e+01 6.011e+00 2.916 0.00354 ** # time_diff -3.342e-04 1.059e-06 -315.773 &lt; 2e-16 *** # --- # Signif. codes: 0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1 # # Number of iterations in BFGS optimization: 28 # Log-likelihood: -1053 on 6 Df # Warning message: # In sqrt(diag(object$vcov)) : NaNs produced </code></pre> <p>and </p> <pre><code>library(MASS) m2 &lt;- glm.nb(e_weight ~ left_size*right_size + time_diff, data = s) </code></pre> <p>which gives</p> <pre><code>There were 22 warnings (use warnings() to see them) warnings() Warning messages: 1: glm.fit: algorithm did not converge ... 21: glm.fit: algorithm did not converge 22: In glm.nb(e_weight ~ left_size * right_size + time_diff, ... : alternation limit reached </code></pre> <p>If I ask a summary for the second model </p> <pre><code>summary(m2) # Call: # glm.nb(formula = e_weight ~ left_size * right_size + time_diff, # data = s, init.theta = 0.1372733321, link = log) # # Deviance Residuals: # Min 1Q Median 3Q Max # -3.4645 -0.2331 -0.1885 -0.1266 2.7669 # # Coefficients: # Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(&gt;|z|) # (Intercept) -3.239e+00 1.090e-01 -29.699 &lt; 2e-16 *** # left_size -4.462e-03 1.835e-03 -2.431 0.015047 * # right_size -7.144e-03 2.118e-03 -3.374 0.000742 *** # time_diff -6.013e-08 8.584e-09 -7.005 2.48e-12 *** # left_size:right_size 4.691e-03 2.749e-04 17.068 &lt; 2e-16 *** # --- # Signif. codes: 0 ‘***’ 0.001 ‘**’ 0.01 ‘*’ 0.05 ‘.’ 0.1 ‘ ’ 1 # # (Dispersion parameter for Negative Binomial(0.1374) family taken to be 1) # # Null deviance: 1106.5 on 9999 degrees of freedom # Residual deviance: 958.5 on 9995 degrees of freedom # AIC: 1967.2 # # Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 12 # # # Theta: 0.1373 # Std. Err.: 0.0223 # Warning while fitting theta: alternation limit reached # # # 2 x log-likelihood: -1955.2260 </code></pre> <p>Also both models have very low p-values for heteroskedasticity </p> <pre><code>bptest(m1) # # studentized Breusch-Pagan test # # data: m1 # BP = 244.832, df = 3, p-value &lt; 2.2e-16 # bptest(m2) # # studentized Breusch-Pagan test # # data: m2 # BP = 277.2589, df = 4, p-value &lt; 2.2e-16 </code></pre> <p>How should I approach this regression. Would make sense to simply add 1 to all my dataframe before running any regression?</p>
74,243
[ 0.004697174299508333, -0.006708583794534206, -0.009304314851760864, 0.017033375799655914, 0.03689621761441231, -0.035479139536619186, 0.004714352544397116, -0.01063815038651228, 0.03540721908211708, -0.017806852236390114, 0.014395292848348618, 0.03813404589891434, 0.020887453109025955, -0.001888810656964779, 0.0025161714293062687, -0.0014660818269476295, -0.005963851697742939, 0.031806766986846924, 0.04243111610412598, 0.004924075677990913, 0.007563605438917875, 0.019503653049468994, 0.04709874466061592, 0.035671915858983994, -0.020212506875395775, 0.04254544898867607, 0.052800025790929794, -0.006954120006412268, 0.011348467320203781, 0.04312925785779953, -0.05917808413505554, -0.006246811244636774, -0.009665773250162601, 0.016117174178361893, 0.04495757073163986, 0.021167093887925148, -0.025383638218045235, -0.026280317455530167, -0.03845994174480438, 0.026389379054307938, 0.019195500761270523, 0.00844349805265665, 0.019158516079187393, -0.0026464234106242657, -0.004561156965792179, 0.023393241688609123, -0.009843735024333, -0.0227509718388319, 0.06380117684602737, -0.027704479172825813, 0.051687419414520264, -0.009283727966248989, 0.053471993654966354, 0.016696181148290634, 0.002534099854528904, -0.031808920204639435, 0.05355320870876312, 0.0691150426864624, -0.033506833016872406, -0.06130782142281532, 0.002116743940860033, -0.01877831108868122, 0.007670878432691097, -0.015820160508155823, 0.007451910991221666, 0.021887637674808502, 0.008181224577128887, -0.01768594980239868, 0.014680836349725723, -0.045871514827013016, 0.008216843008995056, 0.008987444452941418, 0.037260159850120544, -0.003400069195777178, 0.004743125289678574, -0.054436199367046356, 0.005108949262648821, 0.002489757724106312, 0.054158952087163925, 0.05878182128071785, -0.020371146500110626, -0.0008105309098027647, -0.011322996579110622, 0.012136917561292648, 0.03706475719809532, -0.028334660455584526, 0.04613719880580902, -0.01112975925207138, 0.023117579519748688, 0.00481607299298048, -0.03793031722307205, 0.04131559655070305, 0.07871706783771515, -0.02646690420806408, -0.01128235924988985, 0.05141774192452431, 0.004055125638842583, 0.022982006892561913, -0.011701634153723717, -0.00012898756540380418, -0.038162458688020706, -0.05296720564365387, -0.012014727108180523, 0.029206272214651108, -0.04022008180618286, 0.019024860113859177, -0.060700710862874985, -0.015786252915859222, 0.008280365727841854, -0.06253917515277863, 0.0015224734088405967, 0.010578076355159283, 0.0013803119072690606, -0.02584207057952881, -0.04436902701854706, -0.04639804735779762, 0.004427660256624222, -0.012228824198246002, 0.035495903342962265, 0.02690734714269638, -0.0054799714125692844, -0.02814018353819847, 0.039553847163915634, -0.001674738246947527, -0.04775519296526909, -0.003196009201928973, 0.009828844107687473, 0.00904527772217989, -0.04042397812008858, 0.05936960130929947, 0.031115563586354256, -0.03871942684054375, 0.06870518624782562, 0.006831718143075705, 0.013557201251387596, -0.0017973603680729866, -0.058495718985795975, -0.010801845230162144, 0.03173700347542763, -0.03493773564696312, 0.022888287901878357, -0.026750024408102036, -0.026189161464571953, 0.01674434170126915, 0.01936637982726097, 0.04662591218948364, 0.039797570556402206, -0.002864021109417081, 0.02886253036558628, 0.006116913631558418, -0.01241444144397974, 0.013104155659675598, -0.04186667501926422, -0.004376623779535294, 0.0005824688705615699, -0.0706992968916893, 0.0432032085955143, -0.014522782526910305, -0.011512160301208496, 0.019930148497223854, 0.04662935808300972, 0.010565448552370071, -0.01025706622749567, -0.02569437399506569, -0.0006770374602638185, -0.014966766349971294, 0.029230250045657158, 0.005625585559755564, -0.00828853901475668, 0.03210265561938286, -0.01836916245520115, 0.005754034500569105, -0.006241141818463802, 0.04685910791158676, 0.01284884475171566, -0.019766533747315407, 0.014478262513875961, -0.054176900535821915, 0.02841648831963539, 0.04345197230577469, -0.04857886955142021, 0.003324751043692231, -0.032302871346473694, -0.0212933961302042, 0.01248897798359394, 0.041139211505651474, 0.010333110578358173, -0.009859604761004448, 0.04788188263773918, -0.014506792649626732, -0.05338399484753609, -0.02470625564455986, -0.009007357992231846, 0.05736146867275238, -0.023199250921607018, 0.055914971977472305, 0.0013237091479822993, 0.01489079836755991, 0.00407837238162756, 0.02927720546722412, -0.022186655551195145, 0.014648078940808773, 0.0521206371486187, -0.038491904735565186, 0.049919962882995605, 0.04425879195332527, 0.04939712584018707, -0.026468604803085327, 0.033572133630514145, -0.014995423145592213, -0.011396373622119427, 0.04223456233739853, -0.01491979043930769, 0.021183514967560768, -0.007336552254855633, 0.0003009142819792032, 0.05903679132461548, -0.018186401575803757, -0.011114239692687988, 0.016068309545516968, -0.04714282229542732, 0.03966560214757919, 0.07511776685714722, -0.008717850781977177, 0.024721935391426086, -0.011079571209847927, -0.0229831263422966, 0.0345742404460907, -0.0378282256424427, -0.025342147797346115, -0.051955848932266235, -0.0440063551068306, 0.02062869817018509, 0.02274329587817192, -0.01109084952622652, -0.01076387520879507, 0.0320388600230217, -0.023769542574882507, 0.023774782195687294, 0.028952592983841896, -0.012714055366814137, -0.005334403365850449, 0.04402230679988861, 0.04034408554434776, 0.042292866855859756, -0.007071043364703655, 0.022731861099600792, -0.005022087600082159, 0.08239245414733887, -0.024478772655129433, -0.001267809304408729, 0.006247975397855043, -0.005539459642022848, 0.01172136515378952, -0.01871289126574993, -0.005293499678373337, 0.030876049771904945, -0.006844370625913143, -0.0029813977889716625, 0.056518882513046265, -0.010526228696107864, 0.018283413723111153, 0.004414717201143503, -0.027984846383333206, -0.03433851897716522, 0.07537747919559479, -0.025883840397000313, -0.023018835112452507, 0.007106828037649393, -0.03608153760433197, 0.018874257802963257, -0.00021086113702040166, -0.07827362418174744, -0.030119288712739944, 0.024268606677651405, 0.018411599099636078, 0.03002113103866577, -0.02741704322397709, -0.038420170545578, -0.03513028845191002, 0.011334769427776337, 0.012341270223259926, 0.04803796857595444, 0.011198921129107475, -0.05778352543711662, -0.025434985756874084, -0.026785776019096375, -0.022776329889893532, 0.0031136777251958847, 0.011994391679763794, -0.041024740785360336, 0.020930152386426926, -0.040507957339286804, -0.0015901316655799747, -0.033791907131671906, -0.00023349816910922527, -0.028608594089746475, -0.003666388336569071, -0.011977499350905418, 0.08038312196731567, 0.003981226589530706, -0.06400181353092194, -0.00816265121102333, -0.039724282920360565, -0.002683966886252165, -0.0424923337996006, -0.004293346777558327, -0.006146726664155722, -0.016414403915405273, 0.022153200581669807, 0.003148659598082304, -0.003782155690714717, -0.005176318343728781, -0.06163766235113144, -0.03017480857670307, -0.020888764411211014, -0.015069236047565937, 0.012539510615170002, -0.015384114347398281, -0.006624806206673384, 0.040716953575611115, 0.0234747976064682, 0.03909171000123024, -0.03172258660197258, 0.024829445406794548, -0.05900096893310547, -0.02568928711116314, 0.04112030565738678, 0.004953758325427771, 0.046762190759181976, -0.004732909612357616, -0.014811969362199306, 0.02307177148759365, 0.00039154707337729633, 0.015038469806313515, 0.01101551204919815, 0.02960984781384468, 0.007494326680898666, -0.024548742920160294, 0.019656071439385414, 0.011316055431962013, 0.03585108742117882, 0.03773047402501106, -0.009630155749619007, 0.01351885125041008, -0.023526685312390327, -0.058919716626405716, -0.016439206898212433, 0.0073552243411540985, 0.03646314889192581, -0.020572345703840256, 0.01444554515182972, 0.024190567433834076, -0.07411368936300278, -0.02598153054714203, -0.010288389399647713, 0.06152227148413658, -0.033061832189559937, 0.013726530596613884, 0.04762854799628258, 0.023158160969614983, -0.019573476165533066, -0.017982767894864082, -0.025041256099939346, -0.02832581289112568, 0.03357423096895218, -0.016254590824246407, 0.017954561859369278, 0.04691687598824501, 0.03269084170460701, 0.04074397683143616, -0.051041796803474426, -0.010549670085310936, 0.005381431430578232, -0.0016148369759321213, 0.00978454016149044, 0.009065495803952217, 0.039765603840351105, 0.032261986285448074, 0.023497410118579865, 0.009304556995630264, -0.0022403609473258257, -0.01409151405096054, 0.004018469713628292, -0.07940542697906494, 0.03375880792737007, 0.004364038351923227, 0.0007334965048357844, 0.0029520203825086355, -0.022875454276800156, 0.021890763193368912, -0.058809854090213776, 0.022924164310097694, 0.014082242734730244, 0.026226015761494637, 0.015156478621065617, 0.00549632403999567, 0.01049134973436594, 0.023511063307523727, -0.0011390902800485492, 0.008768700063228607, -0.008010088466107845, 0.012686880305409431, 0.03386043757200241, 0.047813642770051956, -0.023090267553925514, -0.0014338323380798101, -0.049768947064876556, 0.015284553170204163, 0.015253261663019657, 0.05716328322887421, 0.01776384375989437, 0.02930098958313465, -0.047675807029008865, 0.015729708597064018, -0.033299770206213, -0.024365773424506187, 0.06096133589744568, -0.003285595215857029, -0.04165998101234436, -0.04891132563352585, -0.016466055065393448, -0.013334999792277813, 0.0384681299328804, 0.002560497261583805, -0.0021751809399574995, 0.05613231286406517, -0.0031346133910119534, 0.006152169778943062, 0.023921005427837372, 0.05582180991768837, 0.015478895977139473, 0.035998955368995667, -0.01195457298308611, -0.009647173807024956, -0.012479024939239025, -0.00396483251824975, 0.03132078796625137, 0.027267135679721832, 0.026998599991202354, -0.029663214460015297, 0.03233193978667259, -0.027460940182209015, -0.01158542837947607, 0.008439597673714161, 0.0428440198302269, 0.021182319149374962, -0.0264760572463274, -0.04050087928771973, 0.0023020657245069742, 0.020954657346010208, 0.03124765306711197, 0.001872277818620205, -0.006629021838307381, -0.09507617354393005, -0.027238117530941963, 0.032499562948942184, 0.04662765935063362, -0.021782997995615005, -0.0346628874540329, -0.05748458579182625, -0.03394853323698044, -0.011472991667687893, -0.04733498394489288, 0.02435031346976757, -0.015504029579460621, 0.021100785583257675, 0.001568698906339705, -0.01828937605023384, -0.07816683501005173, 0.02071797475218773, -0.052786681801080704, -0.00755130173638463, -0.013917376287281513, -0.01746043749153614, -0.025973236188292503, 0.024429451674222946, 0.01976933144032955, 0.02708657830953598, -0.048449158668518066, -0.03275832533836365, 0.04667167365550995, -0.002432547975331545, -0.00789623986929655, -0.08481676131486893, 0.007022568490356207, -0.0344427190721035, 0.034993138164281845, 0.038082875311374664, -0.006760994903743267, -0.023104585707187653, -0.001390055171214044, 0.027568863704800606, -0.021753795444965363, 0.0036419264506548643, -0.03925479203462601, -0.019344337284564972, -0.0016061573987826705, -0.022728480398654938, 0.04911460727453232, 0.058226097375154495, -0.011836184188723564, 0.021560078486800194, -0.06277496367692947, -0.021600952371954918, -0.01315238419920206, -0.026135528460144997, -0.058481164276599884, 0.03706979751586914, 0.010097024030983448, 0.004273910541087389, -0.03170832619071007, -0.0017456554342061281, -0.016727682203054428, 0.009865214116871357, 0.04952007159590721, 0.015629751607775688, -0.0383419394493103, 0.015178674831986427, -0.0293046236038208, 0.007334721274673939, -0.014361348003149033, 0.014979849569499493, 0.00021451489010360092, -0.00026748713571578264, -0.008343569003045559, -0.0037273212801665068, -0.04108142480254173, 0.009062503464519978, 0.003652445040643215, -0.015321962535381317, 0.021508561447262764, -0.016736740246415138, 0.015147416852414608, 0.030147958546876907, -0.0034564242232590914, -0.01368322130292654, -0.019232453778386116, -0.021550189703702927, 0.0036939671263098717, -0.011377517133951187, 0.02697906643152237, -0.037076566368341446, 0.026268523186445236, 0.0001571899192640558, -0.01646171323955059, -0.09712336212396622, -0.02873127907514572, -0.00043998510227538645, 0.005975525360554457, -0.021872056648135185, -0.043776120990514755, -0.053817059844732285, 0.026930786669254303, -0.0018199256155639887, 0.0056304228492081165, 0.04832886904478073, -0.0630224198102951, 0.013758012093603611, -0.015925714746117592, 0.004298324231058359, 0.0814562737941742, 0.0011632030364125967, -0.01799747906625271, 0.020186077803373337, -0.01293247751891613, -0.03937653452157974, 0.022781644016504288, 0.0051109264604747295, -0.020328698679804802, -0.028389668092131615, -0.009923921898007393, -0.02647380717098713, -0.003373218234628439, -0.008650735020637512, -0.05373667925596237, -0.025525294244289398, 0.038552284240722656, 0.04009026288986206, -0.04226049780845642, 0.013340788893401623, 0.0048524849116802216, -0.008521481417119503, -0.034498196095228195, -0.032915275543928146, 0.00009788065653992817, -0.004093380644917488, 0.02123164013028145, -0.01846558228135109, -0.025419987738132477, 0.007114867214113474, 0.08741753548383713, 0.02810334600508213, 0.03910589963197708, -0.0211515873670578, -0.028383247554302216, 0.05094616860151291, -0.013126472942531109, 0.0015824862057343125, 0.0295193362981081, 0.03275822475552559, -0.03552260994911194, -0.006276222877204418, -0.059860412031412125, -0.006391231436282396, 0.015101886354386806, 0.010814209468662739, 0.05562004819512367, -0.029469287022948265, -0.015521503984928131, 0.025791585445404053, -0.052439309656620026, -0.0037023979239165783, -0.011399940587580204, 0.016462896019220352, 0.0478825643658638, -0.023395251482725143, 0.024790283292531967, 0.09824006259441376, 0.020376989617943764, 0.05038655921816826, 0.053073156625032425, -0.011823376640677452, -0.01723523624241352, 0.04091430455446243, -0.01730937696993351, -0.03967820852994919, 0.039904285222291946, -0.011517751961946487, 0.004661773797124624, -0.009891858324408531, -0.059502217918634415, 0.039311621338129044, 0.029344923794269562, 0.035937655717134476, -0.04130227118730545, -0.019042974337935448, -0.036330871284008026, 0.017704013735055923, -0.0036268867552280426, -0.042335331439971924, 0.027563411742448807, -0.010554547421634197, 0.02161688543856144, 0.015355691313743591, 0.06589967012405396, -0.017413709312677383, -0.08246277272701263, 0.00036006109439767897, -0.014786128886044025, -0.011503396555781364, 0.03827113285660744, -0.023881113156676292, -0.007517469581216574, 0.03519759327173233, -0.023286333307623863, 0.02790530025959015, -0.0038853127043694258, 0.01479558926075697, -0.017126096412539482, 0.001363695482723415, 0.007580699399113655, 0.001573982764966786, -0.016618497669696808, 0.0018883139127865434, 0.15455962717533112, 0.07644563168287277, 0.01776474341750145, -0.05331365019083023, -0.00035070203011855483, 0.02616290934383869, -0.0043601891957223415, -0.06352579593658447, -0.02870766818523407, -0.0013508059782907367, -0.010618070140480995, 0.05329712852835655, 0.044819705188274384, 0.027741655707359314, -0.02666562609374523, 0.03575798496603966, -0.008537047542631626, -0.014261816628277302, -0.03239864483475685, 0.02935820445418358, 0.011665832251310349, -0.015273750759661198, -0.04689859598875046, 0.04369615390896797, 0.0051643154583871365, 0.008053703233599663, -0.03823911026120186, 0.0028420817106962204, -0.0289001427590847, -0.002561600413173437, -0.0227078665047884, 0.017159350216388702, -0.0038582789711654186, -0.004662567283958197, 0.029388530179858208, -0.0018808803288266063, -0.009421286173164845, -0.03595426306128502, 0.021179907023906708, 0.05041909217834473, -0.011537457816302776, -0.004114230629056692, 0.027212532237172127, 0.01016924623399973, -0.04909805953502655, -0.003478558035567403, -0.04261066019535065, 0.056939538568258286, 0.017410660162568092, -0.0018134055426344275, 0.013980798423290253, -0.03451814129948616, -0.012607299722731113, -0.038621146231889725, -0.016814429312944412, 0.01123814843595028, 0.010261906310915947, -0.010497448965907097, 0.008569382131099701, -0.005776276346296072, -0.005531179718673229, 0.039664074778556824, 0.022473270073533058, 0.05515975505113602, -0.007059921510517597, -0.02905917540192604, -0.03236900269985199, 0.05961059778928757, 0.011369488202035427, 0.025118645280599594, 0.0526924654841423, -0.02676786482334137, -0.013232482597231865, -0.004749401938170195, 0.027759023010730743, 0.006788316182792187, 0.03200335428118706, -0.015570542775094509, 0.003444767789915204, -0.06442722678184509, -0.008206243626773357, -0.002329250331968069, -0.020692473277449608, 0.010514992289245129, -0.04016600176692009, -0.02904459461569786, 0.0010112341260537505, 0.04712856933474541, 0.006379420403391123, 0.02912699431180954, 0.011856283992528915, 0.07504866272211075, -0.014118117280304432, -0.05885238200426102, -0.00885801948606968, 0.017863918095827103, -0.025199132040143013, 0.016762562096118927, -0.010341539047658443, 0.04956963285803795, -0.0031174246687442064, 0.03764205798506737, 0.027234898880124092, 0.010857218876481056, -0.03167249634861946, 0.0009680021903477609, 0.03066161274909973, -0.018766896799206734, 0.01030531246215105, -0.020966272801160812, 0.013260021805763245, -0.02279648929834366, 0.003985794726759195, -0.031046031042933464, -0.03920009359717369, -0.0061263348907232285, -0.009596560150384903, -0.05239254981279373, 0.02068076655268669, -0.036134492605924606, -0.01986805908381939, 0.009523119777441025, -0.03671752288937569, -0.06163058057427406, -0.001611010287888348, -0.041709184646606445, -0.05743853747844696, 0.0019551615696400404, -0.007933156564831734, -0.022321326658129692, 0.009103180840611458, 0.055843234062194824, -0.02460373006761074, 0.01966046914458275, -0.005555960815399885, 0.043222665786743164, 0.056404221802949905, 0.06477168202400208, -0.019165610894560814, 0.00021746833226643503, 0.03404409438371658, -0.019693229347467422, -0.0781213715672493, 0.03534965589642525, 0.006283578462898731, 0.008283020928502083, -0.006878888700157404, -0.024158645421266556, -0.03885269910097122, 0.0663798451423645, -0.016127755865454674, -0.016938382759690285, -0.05997199937701225, -0.0007142174290493131, 0.0227253008633852, 0.019870635122060776, -0.00987911131232977, 0.0011709084501489997, -0.02541739121079445, 0.015766000375151634, 0.08415365219116211, 0.017279457300901413, 0.009507710114121437, -0.00935280416160822, -0.01254107803106308, 0.025481240823864937, 0.019169652834534645, -0.01744243875145912, -0.012740985490381718, 0.045197803527116776, -0.027071112766861916, 0.014578809961676598, -0.031203754246234894, 0.019461190328001976, -0.09541498869657516, -0.01375406514853239, -0.0027067202609032393, 0.023444510996341705, 0.0035958769731223583, -0.03479566425085068, 0.004611684940755367, 0.030358510091900826, -0.009918333031237125, 0.025880012661218643, -0.019364647567272186, 0.0012908587232232094, -0.012109268456697464, -0.016142139211297035, -0.030529232695698738, 0.011016934178769588, 0.0439017117023468, 0.01297696027904749, 0.04923886060714722, 0.03344690427184105, -0.038407906889915466, -0.006104040890932083, -0.027484772726893425, 0.027902740985155106, 0.015586411580443382, -0.06638998538255692, 0.04901935160160065, -0.04880727455019951, 0.016724303364753723, 0.008553776890039444, -0.005336752627044916, 0.01783755235373974, 0.012134823948144913, 0.03538158908486366, 0.009507430717349052, 0.07172223925590515, 0.026978114619851112, -0.005596558563411236, 0.016469968482851982, -0.015201271511614323, 0.004805232398211956, 0.0012711250456050038, -0.029577618464827538, 0.05853836238384247, -0.0017116062808781862, -0.022776588797569275, -0.0024921081494539976, 0.036607012152671814, 0.019557837396860123, 0.010209175758063793, -0.01763291098177433, 0.03462414816021919, 0.004960674326866865, -0.02052304707467556, 0.02076747454702854, -0.04054868966341019, -0.00943066831678152, 0.03463293984532356, 0.0453016459941864, -0.04437992721796036, 0.015395883470773697, 0.0047201425768435, -0.024579929187893867, 0.00003508286317810416, -0.019809408113360405, -0.03354111313819885, -0.03322229161858559, -0.00111242919228971, -0.02281409315764904, 0.006404366809874773, -0.02780567668378353, -0.006069451104849577, -0.0693545714020729, 0.02919337898492813, -0.05299558863043785, 0.011803830973803997, 0.0665443167090416, 0.021729007363319397, 0.01749751903116703, -0.13190871477127075, 0.03398609161376953, -0.032502856105566025, 0.010003184899687767, -0.022716065868735313, -0.032074350863695145, -0.03196774795651436, 0.03613175451755524, 0.038982242345809937, 0.02598436363041401, -0.005751457065343857, -0.01606455259025097, 0.04459302872419357, 0.024706866592168808, -0.05645911768078804, 0.025525769218802452, 0.018558431416749954, -0.03318885713815689, -0.0006298350053839386, 0.006689139641821384, -0.014128319919109344, 0.014248352497816086, 0.007051476743072271, 0.010274183005094528, 0.006015412043780088, 0.01870833709836006, -0.05749350041151047, 0.05993354693055153, 0.006804809905588627, -0.008788784965872765, 0.04821391776204109, 0.01393586304038763, 0.027177369222044945, 0.028823615983128548, 0.025346508249640465, -0.0725555345416069, 0.021239005029201508, -0.02683086507022381, -0.022835854440927505, 0.00214301235973835, -0.020157620310783386, 0.032780714333057404, -0.05116530507802963, 0.026504749432206154, -0.004808537662029266, -0.025630658492445946, 0.01186657976359129, 0.003459251020103693, 0.0063348147086799145, 0.047906432300806046, -0.007253620773553848, 0.041598960757255554, -0.002750314772129059, -0.044690974056720734, 0.04417187720537186, 0.013672946020960808, -0.009754550643265247, -0.0055457716807723045, 0.02080138586461544, 0.047906000167131424, -0.005749857984483242, 0.03039293922483921, 0.009454639628529549, 0.03992540389299393, 0.002460104413330555, -0.022539878264069557, 0.020791903138160706, -0.004678900353610516, 0.016165195032954216, 0.006602368783205748, 0.016219070181250572, 0.0211862251162529, -0.0228118859231472, 0.01275199931114912, -0.0030971697997301817, -0.022083884105086327, -0.01818043738603592, -0.005314816255122423, -0.013295436277985573, 0.010837788693606853, -0.014832958579063416, 0.003402415197342634, 0.03174973279237747, -0.028926653787493706, -0.000670148350764066, -0.031346261501312256, -0.002012399723753333, 0.03495708853006363, -0.015030431561172009, -0.0012900420697405934, -0.02442694827914238, -0.014819461852312088, -0.01673814281821251, 0.005300899501889944, 0.021347397938370705, 0.0034282109700143337, -0.06009385362267494, 0.011186701245605946, -0.012610639445483685, 0.019192785024642944, -0.044354330748319626, -0.018361225724220276, -0.011686442419886589, -0.0015685425605624914, -0.002504346426576376, -0.041661545634269714 ]
<p>Is there a way I can model a discrete time random walk with random variance? The stochastic vol models I have found all seem to be continuous and assume vol is normal.</p>
74,244
[ -0.0032745548523962498, -0.028412951156497, -0.007615506183356047, -0.02867913246154785, 0.04791171848773956, -0.009606615640223026, -0.005298354662954807, -0.00365873659029603, 0.04045465588569641, -0.04795045778155327, 0.022815605625510216, 0.041389353573322296, 0.05590718984603882, 0.04312899708747864, 0.015154983848333359, -0.005874125752598047, 0.0020402339287102222, -0.04098968952894211, -0.010203797370195389, -0.008086093701422215, -0.025000805035233498, 0.008101754821836948, 0.023657919839024544, -0.003619251074269414, -0.03313044458627701, 0.010597672313451767, 0.04336349666118622, 0.031003693118691444, -0.012576141394674778, 0.04222893342375755, -0.06484043598175049, -0.005390577018260956, 0.008937904611229897, 0.07075651735067368, -0.009020318277180195, 0.03140480816364288, -0.0364561565220356, -0.03900410607457161, -0.04515570402145386, -0.00035341078182682395, -0.03140068054199219, 0.012316539883613586, 0.010748621076345444, 0.03214495629072189, 0.00593240512534976, 0.018232624977827072, 0.00649544782936573, 0.0020253630355000496, 0.06051918491721153, -0.06203257665038109, 0.10231100022792816, -0.027247143909335136, 0.05882006883621216, 0.03863116353750229, 0.011215239763259888, 0.00801083818078041, 0.06496032327413559, 0.08172137290239334, 0.009855926968157291, -0.03589526563882828, -0.01750251092016697, -0.04207928851246834, 0.008914845995604992, -0.056480202823877335, 0.0007917028851807117, -0.018143201246857643, 0.013551315292716026, -0.05124253034591675, 0.015794746577739716, -0.019636211916804314, 0.02286100573837757, -0.005164493806660175, 0.04075082018971443, 0.003947343677282333, 0.021880775690078735, 0.030760040506720543, -0.0002840060624293983, 0.02270030975341797, 0.025424377992749214, 0.03365251421928406, -0.013342181220650673, -0.021653708070516586, 0.007978099398314953, 0.0034758923575282097, -0.004597120452672243, -0.040303900837898254, 0.03775864094495773, 0.0007448471733368933, -0.0030498113483190536, 0.035507816821336746, -0.037247929722070694, -0.02854718267917633, 0.044907096773386, -0.0014900998212397099, -0.06473461538553238, 0.03552636504173279, 0.01659558154642582, 0.029954880475997925, 0.022435741499066353, -0.007771376054733992, -0.0046868640929460526, -0.04912104830145836, -0.002176189562305808, 0.04888138175010681, -0.05374811589717865, -0.024931874126195908, 0.026299087330698967, 0.023039814084768295, -0.00997278094291687, -0.019191844388842583, -0.05609164759516716, -0.004913665354251862, 0.0121614383533597, 0.005420382600277662, 0.02937745302915573, -0.005056194961071014, -0.04235660284757614, -0.03663575276732445, 0.0345599539577961, 0.10077973455190659, 0.010919329710304737, -0.040957625955343246, 0.022350884974002838, -0.048912931233644485, -0.07484401762485504, -0.0034078580792993307, 0.026095177978277206, -0.022723132744431496, -0.0411243662238121, 0.05139967054128647, -0.009748796001076698, -0.0302226934581995, 0.06005249172449112, -0.031702302396297455, 0.07559195905923843, -0.037617310881614685, -0.08874939382076263, -0.03669316694140434, 0.0024231758434325457, -0.04929346591234207, 0.01602642424404621, -0.06354106217622757, -0.01044030487537384, 0.0169806107878685, 0.033277206122875214, 0.046704161912202835, 0.051402684301137924, 0.01236952655017376, 0.015391535125672817, -0.0069047543220222, -0.033324018120765686, -0.0004542949900496751, 0.008894248865544796, 0.019277198240160942, 0.027200594544410706, -0.06614842265844345, 0.023818377405405045, 0.013286523520946503, -0.013276123441755772, -0.0024363293778151274, 0.010813227854669094, 0.00803310889750719, -0.010872953571379185, 0.006449790205806494, 0.02242608554661274, -0.029307274147868156, 0.059014201164245605, 0.002083439379930496, 0.02804196998476982, -0.00975266844034195, 0.020063884556293488, 0.006255007814615965, 0.002557029714807868, 0.034896284341812134, 0.049904853105545044, -0.020205829292535782, -0.01377014722675085, 0.005092588718980551, 0.019705265760421753, 0.04186597093939781, -0.001090634730644524, -0.019197750836610794, -0.002005561487749219, -0.008912534452974796, -0.05868079885840416, 0.03926945477724075, -0.016308793798089027, 0.021957509219646454, 0.031050877645611763, -0.04832965135574341, -0.04012525454163551, -0.06108042225241661, 0.016977382823824883, -0.022246547043323517, 0.023077599704265594, 0.02532561495900154, 0.01022468414157629, 0.04852437227964401, -0.026982255280017853, -0.04873261973261833, -0.028540946543216705, -0.005389846861362457, 0.02803025394678116, -0.043600305914878845, 0.003704353701323271, 0.04835936427116394, 0.055657144635915756, -0.014173577539622784, 0.045699842274188995, 0.010646355338394642, -0.02005932293832302, -0.03066091053187847, -0.07066470384597778, 0.03761972114443779, -0.00005496977973962203, -0.0198038462549448, 0.01495587918907404, -0.006212248466908932, -0.0024336869828402996, 0.021549483761191368, 0.002277534222230315, 0.04286188259720802, 0.06923255324363708, 0.022568155080080032, -0.02974100410938263, 0.03540729358792305, 0.03192290663719177, -0.0026649171486496925, -0.0334603451192379, -0.0488584041595459, -0.0014698157319799066, 0.016997478902339935, 0.06244221329689026, 0.03736410662531853, -0.02580839768052101, 0.015309473499655724, 0.040251120924949646, 0.04761219024658203, 0.03620836138725281, 0.04051273316144943, -0.03620126470923424, -0.000051868762966478243, 0.0033437516540288925, -0.005994172301143408, 0.020539116114377975, 0.013867936097085476, 0.006252697203308344, -0.00384106719866395, 0.01380887906998396, -0.008736714720726013, -0.03670340031385422, -0.0030170264653861523, -0.004481665324419737, -0.018055621534585953, 0.005560858175158501, -0.054199133068323135, 0.05023638531565666, -0.0038326075300574303, 0.014934511855244637, 0.036562368273735046, -0.015890242531895638, 0.003363734809681773, -0.00007964944961713627, -0.04039594903588295, 0.021995503455400467, 0.05892603099346161, -0.010623624548316002, -0.02048729732632637, 0.03070254623889923, 0.008592307567596436, 0.01256620418280363, -0.029154803603887558, -0.00679539842531085, -0.033985916525125504, 0.01452543493360281, 0.012645316310226917, 0.004733874928206205, 0.0032074733171612024, -0.0060004317201673985, -0.03971889987587929, -0.0015900351572781801, 0.0052321902476251125, -0.0016187874134629965, 0.004296598490327597, -0.04891747608780861, 0.018263831734657288, 0.014771396294236183, -0.00805289950221777, 0.013012721203267574, 0.0355181023478508, 0.03627544268965721, 0.026395460590720177, -0.02690235897898674, -0.06544875353574753, -0.008143981918692589, -0.033234961330890656, 0.017767466604709625, -0.022464843466877937, 0.01853499747812748, 0.01351260393857956, 0.03251858428120613, -0.05962523818016052, 0.029210969805717468, -0.056781474500894547, -0.019139941781759262, -0.04987546056509018, -0.00736626610159874, 0.01776636391878128, -0.018192265182733536, 0.05107783153653145, 0.043652962893247604, -0.04775319620966911, 0.012599768117070198, -0.0783807635307312, -0.02149696834385395, 0.022527161985635757, -0.003256614785641432, 0.000020960820620530285, 0.0009993819985538721, -0.02791416458785534, 0.059648897498846054, 0.0559176430106163, -0.03379448130726814, -0.016596967354416847, -0.005812671966850758, -0.025985397398471832, -0.062302347272634506, 0.017624506726861, 0.010399715043604374, -0.007165930699557066, 0.008573327213525772, -0.011659522540867329, 0.01098780520260334, 0.04128719121217728, 0.008142376318573952, -0.03127945214509964, 0.022452693432569504, -0.00928267277777195, 0.0012226493563503027, 0.026202037930488586, 0.01602119766175747, -0.02588196098804474, -0.009648836217820644, -0.015955256298184395, 0.0392683744430542, 0.004620529245585203, -0.03864670172333717, 0.042070530354976654, -0.002578544896095991, -0.009294884279370308, -0.06489445269107819, 0.04109374061226845, -0.0035350529942661524, -0.022789068520069122, -0.03883102536201477, 0.0277564637362957, 0.023462612181901932, 0.038139708340168, 0.02538404054939747, 0.03353210166096687, 0.03564547002315521, -0.00827243085950613, -0.032997287809848785, -0.01790093444287777, 0.008197191171348095, 0.017088690772652626, 0.016826873645186424, 0.009724171832203865, 0.03278576582670212, 0.021841872483491898, 0.03598722442984581, -0.028685469180345535, -0.02852451615035534, -0.03441722318530083, -0.04651965945959091, 0.04369625821709633, -0.01678498275578022, 0.05537236109375954, 0.011782737448811531, 0.025163115933537483, -0.005029766820371151, -0.016427472233772278, 0.042766280472278595, -0.012326658703386784, -0.06567893922328949, 0.030902322381734848, -0.03230418637394905, -0.03185146674513817, -0.01905250735580921, -0.01641976833343506, 0.013570914044976234, -0.028044434264302254, 0.000941394770052284, -0.0019280092092230916, -0.007139566354453564, -0.05151016265153885, 0.007504946552217007, -0.026677589863538742, -0.011631309986114502, -0.011957711540162563, 0.008273132145404816, 0.02090005949139595, -0.04674047231674194, -0.0022396277636289597, 0.008860248140990734, 0.0029101946856826544, -0.00928796548396349, -0.030498506501317024, 0.015424942597746849, 0.016949810087680817, 0.03080488182604313, 0.019497226923704147, 0.008970431983470917, -0.00835355743765831, 0.03494179993867874, -0.012447803281247616, 0.030595995485782623, 0.054448843002319336, 0.024915527552366257, -0.022569390013813972, -0.05992759019136429, -0.020027590915560722, 0.022038115188479424, -0.0070027136243879795, 0.017340581864118576, 0.021861447021365166, 0.07351695746183395, 0.020689891651272774, -0.048806436359882355, -0.012546723708510399, 0.05613400787115097, 0.01495903730392456, -0.022054828703403473, 0.007434566505253315, 0.015206776559352875, 0.02777804061770439, -0.008118405006825924, 0.017720581963658333, -0.0014627526979893446, -0.01348055712878704, 0.05032370984554291, 0.011555951088666916, -0.015845298767089844, -0.01419941894710064, 0.008744983933866024, 0.017351970076560974, 0.035824768245220184, 0.002775748260319233, -0.028930841013789177, 0.02321656420826912, 0.023021358996629715, 0.009757615625858307, 0.0574849508702755, 0.01484495960175991, -0.1106230765581131, -0.004270519595593214, 0.01789419911801815, 0.016001809388399124, -0.03801479563117027, -0.006701802834868431, -0.013732338324189186, -0.00812307745218277, 0.065323606133461, -0.02303130552172661, -0.00528364721685648, -0.014133764430880547, -0.02948182262480259, 0.007390615530312061, -0.03955138102173805, -0.03410283848643303, 0.022871604189276695, -0.011697058565914631, -0.0122598335146904, -0.03365296125411987, -0.022908657789230347, -0.02262362651526928, 0.02469933032989502, 0.03184166178107262, 0.0995904952287674, -0.017689378932118416, 0.037173349410295486, 0.0041762362234294415, 0.04940512031316757, -0.04464739188551903, -0.09012129157781601, 0.006789171602576971, 0.02031753771007061, 0.007955405861139297, 0.02208426222205162, 0.014454547315835953, -0.039682477712631226, 0.027869313955307007, -0.018859870731830597, 0.00022524157247971743, 0.01329012867063284, -0.013990298844873905, 0.01607450842857361, 0.026033906266093254, -0.0002446622238494456, 0.05850806459784508, 0.04645499214529991, 0.012767201289534569, -0.016817690804600716, -0.012992610223591328, 0.071762315928936, -0.020989330485463142, -0.013058056123554707, -0.034518297761678696, -0.006946078967303038, 0.0009499619482085109, 0.03533642366528511, -0.014300057664513588, 0.044941361993551254, 0.011619659140706062, -0.018278617411851883, -0.022245973348617554, 0.06729245185852051, 0.016435762867331505, -0.02505081333220005, -0.00489124795421958, 0.009563311003148556, -0.028830168768763542, -0.030271334573626518, 0.006300137843936682, -0.018451740965247154, 0.0009739347733557224, 0.01197141781449318, -0.040835484862327576, -0.04077858105301857, -0.03320630267262459, -0.015579607337713242, -0.008942789398133755, -0.013781819492578506, 0.05747314915060997, -0.028805222362279892, 0.0005063270800746977, -0.022303638979792595, -0.05525637045502663, -0.010547427460551262, 0.012995400466024876, 0.019171155989170074, 0.01930902525782585, -0.031359586864709854, 0.03351949527859688, 0.007113002706319094, -0.002768418285995722, -0.08229226619005203, -0.0663270652294159, 0.03217412903904915, -0.018894078209996223, -0.01774071902036667, -0.05195602774620056, 0.015231983736157417, -0.013665570877492428, -0.04581817612051964, -0.029720719903707504, 0.06564509123563766, 0.0024103429168462753, 0.024340223520994186, -0.0006289960583671927, 0.04049365967512131, 0.0982983261346817, 0.03420904278755188, -0.013194713741540909, 0.040236927568912506, -0.008986598812043667, -0.0210123173892498, 0.0034311600029468536, 0.04673878848552704, -0.04670199006795883, 0.02570076286792755, 0.012839293107390404, -0.019244061782956123, 0.07586386799812317, -0.037466004490852356, 0.00010177901276620105, 0.015594654716551304, -0.005480527877807617, 0.0050064814276993275, -0.03107563965022564, 0.020534100010991096, 0.003186232643201947, 0.018793592229485512, -0.0210388395935297, 0.0067160241305828094, -0.011622481979429722, 0.018595894798636436, 0.0238752830773592, 0.011912239715456963, 0.015282146632671356, 0.022235004231333733, 0.034608274698257446, -0.009526311419904232, -0.05024348571896553, 0.01955077238380909, -0.008333703503012657, 0.02697072923183441, -0.019706230610609055, 0.016248246654868126, 0.04682454094290733, 0.0013155440101400018, -0.06509354710578918, -0.06501834839582443, -0.01943618431687355, -0.013732858002185822, 0.04740231856703758, -0.017068445682525635, 0.049229174852371216, 0.009304764680564404, -0.00655930582433939, -0.015227623283863068, -0.010875488631427288, -0.0367346927523613, 0.027414843440055847, -0.005591179709881544, 0.04163787513971329, 0.015211734920740128, 0.033198948949575424, 0.01601504161953926, 0.004740998148918152, 0.05332041531801224, 0.0639602392911911, 0.011479184962809086, 0.0014668783405795693, -0.0038044489920139313, 0.031041093170642853, -0.0376068614423275, 0.01782861538231373, -0.0511883944272995, 0.02458794042468071, -0.03432384878396988, -0.017920557409524918, 0.046577051281929016, 0.021990742534399033, 0.009864937514066696, -0.009480657055974007, -0.020777033641934395, -0.06562428921461105, 0.020615849643945694, 0.022422462701797485, 0.013154725544154644, 0.033217400312423706, -0.001689314260147512, 0.03921673446893692, -0.028030628338456154, 0.03162968531250954, -0.026146192103624344, -0.08136630058288574, 0.008644256740808487, 0.005578756332397461, -0.0350411981344223, 0.04685114696621895, 0.005461463704705238, -0.014261377044022083, -0.01814400590956211, -0.02627074159681797, 0.004286463372409344, 0.021177740767598152, 0.001005596132017672, -0.012104501947760582, 0.09548927843570709, 0.02409173920750618, 0.0080567616969347, -0.04803093150258064, 0.012922706082463264, 0.12007191777229309, 0.06822751462459564, 0.03214667737483978, -0.060350701212882996, -0.010737719014286995, -0.02302384190261364, 0.013385383412241936, -0.034437138587236404, 0.05296889692544937, 0.04675920680165291, -0.015589900314807892, 0.02191007509827614, 0.04207524657249451, 0.0034474781714379787, -0.023660585284233093, 0.042185720056295395, -0.03809657320380211, -0.03435734286904335, 0.012653037905693054, -0.012473649345338345, -0.009512423537671566, 0.0021504536271095276, -0.043530866503715515, 0.0496722012758255, -0.002355044474825263, -0.04456605017185211, -0.03349762037396431, 0.010904531925916672, -0.007837241515517235, 0.025865158066153526, -0.035830020904541016, -0.019399942830204964, 0.03172184154391289, 0.0077504427172243595, -0.005001416429877281, -0.03239358216524124, 0.0017604469321668148, 0.012481315061450005, 0.02875051647424698, 0.029886314645409584, 0.025607071816921234, 0.00012617318134289235, 0.015943653881549835, -0.019595568999648094, -0.03419075906276703, -0.02131502702832222, -0.023196052759885788, 0.02201201394200325, -0.04319728910923004, 0.03499140962958336, 0.007837045006453991, 0.01764480210840702, -0.027069078758358955, -0.05322902277112007, -0.013119610957801342, -0.0026427984703332186, 0.022877147421240807, -0.020123710855841637, -0.01889551244676113, -0.04447772353887558, 0.0032630038913339376, -0.028721487149596214, 0.010801057331264019, 0.007964794524013996, -0.037092238664627075, -0.008481496013700962, -0.062505342066288, 0.0551157146692276, -0.023667655885219574, -0.02320924587547779, 0.02458452433347702, -0.024382302537560463, -0.0335439071059227, -0.005142184905707836, 0.008065786212682724, -0.025691112503409386, 0.015295472927391529, -0.0008741714991629124, -0.02296832948923111, 0.010885428637266159, -0.07362425327301025, 0.005172083154320717, -0.018165500834584236, -0.027061212807893753, -0.0337284691631794, 0.022777922451496124, 0.03345080837607384, 0.013148369267582893, 0.010777362622320652, 0.0352628268301487, -0.05118706822395325, 0.06088196486234665, -0.004682042635977268, -0.04952418431639671, -0.0010191458277404308, -0.009423387236893177, -0.028877966105937958, 0.005822387989610434, 0.012877844274044037, 0.009802723303437233, 0.04871247708797455, 0.005893445108085871, -0.04256900027394295, 0.031958937644958496, 0.015383872203528881, 0.03803001344203949, 0.03497428447008133, -0.08676926791667938, 0.015448152087628841, 0.030248818919062614, 0.0007490555290132761, -0.010065744630992413, -0.049677181988954544, -0.01516786403954029, -0.011800107546150684, -0.008197829127311707, 0.0017733089625835419, -0.02418973110616207, -0.0013653397327288985, -0.06077240779995918, 0.025943094864487648, -0.04386722296476364, 0.00796896405518055, -0.00834601279348135, 0.015628736466169357, -0.018406275659799576, 0.01542495284229517, -0.015955550596117973, 0.0044160271063447, 0.027791887521743774, -0.0033921459689736366, 0.035614676773548126, 0.04354671388864517, 0.03006775490939617, 0.004592027515172958, 0.0033906251192092896, 0.015764206647872925, 0.03401670604944229, -0.025234505534172058, -0.04570939764380455, 0.05646679550409317, -0.018859758973121643, -0.03164533153176308, 0.010285784490406513, -0.002227768301963806, 0.037612032145261765, 0.011226366274058819, -0.026633037254214287, 0.010153990238904953, 0.039168719202280045, -0.014724412001669407, -0.02792167291045189, -0.004683608654886484, 0.0005461447290144861, 0.005189885385334492, -0.04077744483947754, 0.028720399364829063, 0.017755720764398575, -0.01189712155610323, 0.003744508372619748, 0.02606501430273056, -0.010191081091761589, 0.020113589242100716, 0.034716542810201645, -0.01465563103556633, 0.025665169581770897, 0.022558430209755898, 0.005268936976790428, 0.012058469466865063, 0.025454308837652206, -0.030882347375154495, 0.021085068583488464, -0.012149891816079617, 0.017704740166664124, -0.05490153282880783, -0.010904165916144848, 0.01696629263460636, -0.013956974260509014, 0.03338535502552986, -0.08159279078245163, -0.01842060685157776, 0.03587007522583008, -0.0499250590801239, -0.048621904104948044, 0.01787368580698967, -0.026534168049693108, -0.0316200777888298, -0.00938054546713829, -0.02547859586775303, 0.017104091122746468, -0.0036546497140079737, 0.05228003114461899, 0.009418572299182415, 0.016296932473778725, -0.008149814791977406, -0.01871619001030922, -0.0014331428101286292, -0.0019086895044893026, 0.012316339649260044, -0.023197416216135025, 0.02923642285168171, -0.06056547909975052, -0.018250755965709686, 0.015533906407654285, -0.0010874686995521188, 0.03486442565917969, -0.002375643700361252, 0.02753015235066414, 0.011485331691801548, 0.05124526843428612, 0.03460117056965828, 0.03156699612736702, 0.025937704369425774, -0.02693881094455719, 0.0024726034607738256, 0.00876620039343834, -0.025757893919944763, 0.0028132975567132235, 0.031224185600876808, -0.014528900384902954, -0.022338084876537323, 0.04598453640937805, -0.01577397622168064, -0.019009722396731377, -0.014119700528681278, -0.04542810842394829, 0.006713030859827995, -0.03344881534576416, 0.02282237447798252, -0.03287866339087486, -0.011881554499268532, 0.028083136305212975, -0.00696401996538043, -0.017822833731770515, -0.016613535583019257, -0.014477105811238289, -0.044156260788440704, 0.02321236953139305, 0.025001397356390953, -0.04342985898256302, -0.05543820932507515, -0.018787067383527756, 0.019655173644423485, 0.006374399643391371, -0.008312797173857689, -0.018398387357592583, 0.013860234059393406, 0.02353406511247158, 0.007850305177271366, 0.03538934513926506, 0.023332446813583374, -0.017316320911049843, -0.011470533907413483, -0.05807408317923546, 0.06369299441576004, 0.004602476023137569, -0.018674999475479126, -0.02036123163998127, 0.0025237854570150375, -0.026543887332081795, -0.0006432136287912726, 0.041184019297361374, -0.021518796682357788, -0.0031476470176130533, 0.03663991391658783, 0.050177279859781265, 0.035734377801418304, -0.045031677931547165, 0.0053400578908622265, -0.05347667261958122, -0.00040865648770704865, -0.0034958336036652327, -0.016469968482851982, -0.004380072001367807, 0.026488233357667923, -0.01031674537807703, -0.013244394212961197, -0.04580553621053696, 0.00454377755522728, -0.0373573862016201, 0.02277281880378723, 0.032244134694337845, -0.010327082127332687, 0.0306702833622694, -0.02975340560078621, -0.00795864500105381, 0.025494877249002457, 0.00876526813954115, -0.024916404858231544, 0.016942564398050308, -0.05592787265777588, -0.013925696723163128, 0.009559898637235165, 0.024662792682647705, -0.004321411717683077, -0.029646489769220352, 0.00947712454944849, 0.025758331641554832, -0.02936592698097229, 0.03414076194167137, 0.014954760670661926, 0.021520188078284264, 0.03666912764310837, 0.010003010742366314, 0.002594941295683384, 0.024061691015958786, 0.02639821358025074, -0.007608694024384022, 0.00834670476615429, 0.04659949988126755, -0.0409398153424263, 0.020446768030524254, 0.016472090035676956, -0.025566034018993378, 0.053980693221092224, -0.002287565963342786, -0.003865346312522888, -0.02260875329375267, -0.01615576259791851, 0.02745552733540535, -0.001268039457499981, -0.0006241172668524086, -0.0052460432052612305, -0.016140323132276535, 0.0539001002907753, -0.035787973552942276, 0.02188035473227501, -0.010084850713610649, -0.015918893739581108, 0.011455819942057133, -0.008490660227835178, 0.03236354887485504, 0.007090074475854635, -0.0007759098662063479, 0.006536668166518211, -0.017616571858525276, 0.04055170342326164, -0.00001948337012436241, -0.07889561355113983, 0.0019333121599629521, 0.004164954647421837, -0.013738321140408516, -0.058878641575574875, -0.03302443400025368, -0.04367760568857193, -0.022703807801008224, 0.007755332626402378, 0.0458013191819191, 0.03044125810265541, 0.0016875305445864797, 0.007828893139958382, 0.005003576632589102, 0.05562957748770714, -0.08108014613389969, -0.006903678644448519, -0.043620869517326355, -0.005144248716533184, -0.016365280374884605, 0.015113206580281258 ]
<p>I am looking at setting up some website load testing scripts and need some help in finding a formula to estimate how many concurrent users are browsing a website at peak times, based on common metrics such as visits, average page views per visit, and average visit duration.</p> <p>For example:</p> <p>Peak visitors per hour: 1,000</p> <p>Average page views per visitor: 3</p> <p>Average time per visit: 5 minutes</p> <p>Should I be considering at any other stats? Thanks in advance!</p>
37,001
[ -0.030939992517232895, -0.03683270141482353, 0.01454668678343296, 0.011672679334878922, 0.05677302926778793, -0.019644027575850487, -0.005068829283118248, -0.017562564462423325, 0.016928328201174736, 0.017018169164657593, 0.04707525670528412, 0.07108691334724426, 0.0019610042218118906, 0.02687896601855755, 0.02646941877901554, 0.02050545997917652, 0.0001707968913251534, 0.010337870568037033, 0.020745903253555298, -0.025338660925626755, 0.01248110830783844, -0.018932035192847252, 0.03301288187503815, -0.014247837476432323, -0.02317161113023758, 0.03126882389187813, 0.02486378327012062, -0.030334968119859695, 0.013087679632008076, 0.015555715188384056, -0.0470333993434906, -0.020033063367009163, 0.04221094399690628, 0.06145679950714111, 0.007076550740748644, 0.015161896124482155, -0.07191967964172363, -0.01743030734360218, -0.037140704691410065, 0.029463231563568115, -0.009784916415810585, 0.011098096147179604, 0.012866894714534283, 0.005219354294240475, -0.03120316192507744, -0.006011322606354952, -0.008539152331650257, -0.0323571115732193, 0.013536493293941021, -0.058965668082237244, 0.08599038422107697, -0.010152773931622505, 0.07230135053396225, -0.02498244121670723, -0.03061680682003498, 0.01367412693798542, 0.054947659373283386, 0.05869754031300545, -0.01979733072221279, -0.06694874912500381, -0.0003172586439177394, -0.0370551273226738, 0.016746733337640762, -0.05437904968857765, -0.03341402858495712, 0.0639433041214943, -0.01187037117779255, 0.0049451678059995174, 0.05154215544462204, -0.013149586506187916, 0.011047374457120895, -0.006321024615317583, 0.046615779399871826, 0.00018080622248817235, 0.011543461121618748, -0.053669318556785583, 0.03646271675825119, 0.028319064527750015, 0.05710179731249809, 0.05844096094369888, -0.024213895201683044, 0.0008448786102235317, 0.022587314248085022, 0.05498179420828819, 0.034307029098272324, -0.002150799846276641, 0.08542367070913315, 0.0009908705251291394, 0.0015722534153610468, 0.01797686703503132, -0.02780267223715782, 0.006353897508233786, 0.06036675348877907, 0.02461191453039646, -0.012514112517237663, 0.051292818039655685, -0.01915518008172512, 0.03330539911985397, 0.010556824505329132, 0.020950207486748695, 0.006676195189356804, -0.04225214198231697, 0.0032561032567173243, 0.045545581728219986, -0.02428276650607586, -0.001462017884477973, -0.030365005135536194, -0.03593271225690842, -0.023658309131860733, -0.02744218334555626, -0.032203786075115204, 0.0041099837981164455, 0.027334358543157578, 0.011398936621844769, -0.007262340281158686, 0.004902794491499662, 0.018394658342003822, -0.008272950537502766, 0.04935704171657562, 0.037762485444545746, 0.0516740158200264, -0.020107200369238853, 0.021182017400860786, -0.01928723230957985, -0.047451552003622055, 0.014922389760613441, -0.0067114257253706455, -0.010271682403981686, -0.043422773480415344, 0.05284523591399193, -0.03807936608791351, 0.004581994377076626, 0.03916742652654648, -0.021745197474956512, 0.04104385897517204, 0.012308106757700443, -0.07603923231363297, -0.03193726763129234, 0.017342859879136086, -0.02257833629846573, 0.00003464404653641395, -0.02895677648484707, 0.006052793003618717, 0.028171343728899956, 0.03457086905837059, 0.003819307079538703, 0.029031019657850266, 0.012393900193274021, -0.01924426108598709, -0.01511309389024973, -0.07030875235795975, -0.028013359755277634, 0.010464273393154144, -0.005005749873816967, 0.012893741019070148, -0.06950582563877106, -0.013218563981354237, 0.023215191438794136, 0.0024439028929919004, 0.0022864844650030136, 0.0250800009816885, 0.01883576065301895, -0.03196054324507713, -0.010685468092560768, 0.044641658663749695, -0.02422099933028221, 0.09713350981473923, -0.02205546386539936, 0.028581958264112473, 0.0016394074773415923, -0.004727643448859453, -0.017177872359752655, -0.0034320789854973555, 0.010783477686345577, 0.011307657696306705, -0.0027564370539039373, -0.002677795011550188, -0.025991089642047882, -0.0026861238293349743, 0.02423902042210102, -0.01622748374938965, -0.04528576880693436, -0.008594058454036713, 0.023476198315620422, 0.031451720744371414, 0.048680342733860016, 0.007948155514895916, -0.009653786197304726, 0.010665779933333397, -0.009669817052781582, -0.04183430224657059, -0.07620855420827866, 0.02632877603173256, -0.0023588426411151886, 0.014196409843862057, 0.0030968631617724895, -0.0014417613856494427, 0.000512376194819808, -0.018914010375738144, -0.014102967455983162, -0.012205839157104492, 0.01597716473042965, 0.036049045622348785, -0.04958094283938408, -0.014000355266034603, 0.06123466044664383, 0.015447148121893406, -0.03779817372560501, 0.02902838960289955, -0.034897658973932266, -0.053988464176654816, -0.04708460345864296, -0.0674380213022232, 0.07145607471466064, -0.00823513325303793, -0.02232283540070057, 0.025846730917692184, 0.0523504875600338, -0.0058684987016022205, 0.018462421372532845, -0.03265082463622093, 0.04897339642047882, 0.048396214842796326, 0.012169094756245613, 0.007627306506037712, -0.05201934278011322, -0.017569754272699356, -0.03292600437998772, -0.019064636901021004, -0.0023643772583454847, -0.05067184567451477, 0.001803237129934132, 0.08445516973733902, -0.027686113491654396, -0.009970423765480518, -0.009180695749819279, 0.08191902190446854, 0.011794289574027061, 0.006370109505951405, 0.026756418868899345, -0.03451123088598251, -0.017181653529405594, 0.030535485595464706, 0.047875214368104935, 0.0008292938582599163, 0.019874941557645798, 0.009208173491060734, 0.022165827453136444, 0.009170725010335445, 0.023928025737404823, -0.005481216590851545, 0.012807713821530342, -0.007856245152652264, 0.03266013786196709, -0.014673463068902493, -0.02076147124171257, 0.07129625976085663, -0.008929877541959286, 0.017180250957608223, 0.018173526972532272, 0.0032392339780926704, 0.007158736698329449, 0.004705391358584166, -0.05002425238490105, 0.005838823039084673, 0.009572427719831467, -0.06033656746149063, -0.0509825125336647, 0.002175298286601901, -0.028341619297862053, 0.03926799073815346, -0.00680864043533802, -0.017389273270964622, -0.03377331793308258, -0.007251842878758907, 0.0140834990888834, 0.017089663073420525, 0.05207241699099541, -0.03455410525202751, -0.043652381747961044, 0.01937418431043625, -0.04555520787835121, -0.016732022166252136, -0.03470020368695259, -0.04526132717728615, -0.03270499035716057, 0.01273864135146141, -0.04478494077920914, 0.043766606599092484, -0.01711898110806942, 0.006059382576495409, 0.019938351586461067, -0.02563297748565674, -0.049917638301849365, -0.004508312791585922, -0.021200910210609436, 0.012825362384319305, -0.0361204594373703, -0.022165536880493164, 0.036054130643606186, -0.022483130916953087, -0.05501542240381241, 0.04116368293762207, -0.035220708698034286, -0.04216834902763367, -0.037473149597644806, 0.004384993109852076, -0.02717946469783783, -0.028759833425283432, -0.0084502212703228, -0.00004645051740226336, 0.022003021091222763, 0.014944275841116905, -0.044965073466300964, -0.052421558648347855, 0.023079434409737587, -0.013005544431507587, 0.04126426950097084, 0.01362497266381979, -0.06510674953460693, 0.04790281131863594, 0.005669844802469015, -0.033458076417446136, -0.030562549829483032, -0.03031754679977894, -0.0014792777365073562, 0.02029293216764927, 0.007386412937194109, 0.020292770117521286, -0.02376210317015648, -0.00007495538739021868, -0.009755449369549751, 0.003637796500697732, 0.053132351487874985, 0.06374221295118332, 0.022834209725260735, 0.0024595153518021107, -0.026907185092568398, 0.01605025865137577, 0.011777217499911785, 0.03782745078206062, -0.04774053394794464, 0.01571902073919773, -0.03075675293803215, 0.014417368918657303, 0.01372474618256092, -0.03441063314676285, 0.03238501772284508, -0.009874407202005386, -0.019165879115462303, -0.012350333854556084, 0.00844237208366394, -0.012680900283157825, -0.0077481879852712154, -0.04890689626336098, 0.06538577377796173, 0.017833514139056206, -0.019847245886921883, 0.0016194937052205205, 0.054546281695365906, 0.049740493297576904, -0.04804200306534767, -0.037660181522369385, -0.023386036977171898, -0.048481784760951996, -0.00035719547304324806, -0.008864184841513634, -0.05328666418790817, 0.022011352702975273, 0.00911157950758934, 0.016504332423210144, 0.024215463548898697, -0.02478673867881298, -0.03286042809486389, -0.11716592311859131, 0.005284765735268593, -0.027856938540935516, 0.06111383065581322, 0.0012807640014216304, 0.028290312737226486, 0.015254081226885319, -0.03789801150560379, 0.037541404366493225, 0.03295336663722992, -0.039902932941913605, 0.02223687432706356, -0.04104507341980934, -0.0050016287714242935, 0.01743396185338497, -0.0376557819545269, 0.01649048551917076, -0.02613782323896885, -0.0067991213873028755, 0.012597779743373394, 0.0049850670620799065, -0.0531652495265007, 0.0035116784274578094, 0.011221889406442642, 0.01523652859032154, 0.011590704321861267, 0.027651572600007057, -0.01451170165091753, 0.019042057916522026, 0.04614722728729248, 0.04140879586338997, -0.02676837146282196, -0.021422702819108963, -0.022074148058891296, -0.021992700174450874, -0.005696750711649656, 0.029687942937016487, 0.03177332878112793, 0.031741607934236526, -0.023563552647829056, 0.023418789729475975, -0.06119103729724884, 0.0019400330493226647, 0.05102074146270752, -0.0032598727848380804, -0.02598324976861477, -0.048681266605854034, 0.0014595775865018368, 0.02639787830412388, 0.004250126890838146, -0.024687539786100388, 0.021069133654236794, 0.03957367688417435, 0.012105539441108704, -0.027486369013786316, 0.03067770227789879, 0.07687244564294815, 0.038202814757823944, 0.0044575100764632225, -0.013461021706461906, 0.011559468694031239, -0.00219948822632432, -0.0001576529029989615, -0.021325524896383286, 0.03371208533644676, 0.030777981504797935, 0.028664030134677887, -0.011571686714887619, -0.02540741115808487, -0.009827797301113605, 0.03269832208752632, 0.007598584983497858, 0.01529376395046711, -0.0015411553904414177, -0.052111368626356125, 0.01144066359847784, 0.056511349976062775, 0.015001404099166393, -0.028488893061876297, -0.03328755497932434, -0.08865994960069656, 0.0063851019367575645, 0.059936270117759705, 0.04066893458366394, -0.05435812845826149, -0.02556326985359192, 0.005135072395205498, 0.012128617614507675, 0.0365133099257946, -0.020674122497439384, 0.03162556141614914, 0.0286321472376585, 0.026701664552092552, 0.0005972874932922423, -0.031119568273425102, -0.025994842872023582, 0.01428161934018135, -0.028477322310209274, 0.025646420195698738, -0.029474738985300064, 0.015304256230592728, -0.009067283943295479, 0.02569424919784069, 0.04360925778746605, 0.021319443359971046, -0.006099372636526823, -0.0009697190253064036, -0.0009410242200829089, 0.004209349397569895, -0.0365145206451416, -0.037746258080005646, 0.031506527215242386, -0.0056253718212246895, 0.003983588889241219, 0.047325342893600464, -0.0059180790558457375, -0.017909135669469833, 0.016537146642804146, 0.016723893582820892, -0.0009525283821858466, -0.0126825962215662, -0.05147140100598335, 0.020424751564860344, 0.0437903106212616, -0.003233930328860879, 0.042072948068380356, -0.00391616253182292, -0.014782819896936417, -0.012510072439908981, 0.0444897897541523, 0.04150218516588211, -0.011645951308310032, -0.023324087262153625, 0.005634512286633253, -0.016161153092980385, -0.04606527090072632, 0.02876218408346176, -0.039843201637268066, 0.010817405767738819, -0.057620588690042496, -0.011178932152688503, -0.03070560097694397, 0.009361505508422852, 0.04084446281194687, 0.014034182764589787, -0.0033984179608523846, -0.023009011521935463, -0.014377322047948837, 0.0004985425621271133, 0.0066059953533113, -0.05500178784132004, 0.012398847378790379, 0.007688530720770359, 0.005713446997106075, -0.006526590324938297, -0.031376518309116364, -0.013374635018408298, 0.031712088733911514, -0.008969973772764206, 0.038992881774902344, -0.01475162710994482, 0.0346316397190094, 0.03113570250570774, -0.013416174799203873, -0.017819728702306747, 0.04275495558977127, -0.00002223142837465275, 0.026101727038621902, -0.0064805615693330765, 0.06939442455768585, -0.0492204986512661, -0.014159580692648888, -0.06687986105680466, -0.034551218152046204, 0.06878868490457535, 0.016650235280394554, -0.00999213196337223, -0.01938711479306221, 0.006187666207551956, -0.027422111481428146, -0.02482696622610092, -0.0008541317656636238, 0.01431966945528984, 0.02000812254846096, -0.00629274919629097, -0.026180202141404152, -0.008781400509178638, 0.052675504237413406, 0.04335121810436249, -0.01979242078959942, -0.0020454905461519957, 0.04612050950527191, -0.04256632551550865, -0.031556930392980576, 0.012474829331040382, -0.01715450920164585, -0.021161334589123726, -0.017805399373173714, -0.031080197542905807, 0.05726737901568413, -0.04307137429714203, 0.019584234803915024, -0.014154667034745216, 0.012578098103404045, -0.023894043639302254, -0.055188752710819244, 0.042453180998563766, 0.034198589622974396, 0.006731412839144468, -0.014261124655604362, 0.0013382236938923597, -0.04479040578007698, 0.03884749487042427, 0.0075470744632184505, 0.022405214607715607, -0.0009459270513616502, 0.0008338509942404926, 0.06522722542285919, 0.02006928063929081, -0.003000259632244706, -0.03246366232633591, -0.010892671532928944, 0.0027013507205992937, -0.006669891066849232, -0.009088548831641674, -0.010222244076430798, -0.0013343296013772488, -0.02924647554755211, -0.0225607231259346, -0.03293737769126892, -0.028428977355360985, 0.05452050268650055, -0.06509771198034286, 0.03339830040931702, 0.0037695723585784435, 0.02665919065475464, 0.010486042127013206, 0.005319110583513975, -0.017100060358643532, -0.012050490826368332, 0.0393892303109169, 0.039358071982860565, 0.0008547228644602001, 0.018949847668409348, 0.03875439614057541, -0.010755614377558231, 0.028874600306153297, 0.07166939228773117, 0.02067958377301693, 0.006058002356439829, 0.014621039852499962, -0.01994199864566326, -0.02115318924188614, 0.029498346149921417, -0.016258710995316505, 0.002292659832164645, -0.006130632013082504, -0.01965668983757496, 0.0556330643594265, 0.0052258227951824665, -0.01271742768585682, 0.01299403514713049, -0.002028136281296611, -0.019517606124281883, 0.007325427606701851, -0.012542051263153553, -0.0015886669280007482, 0.009884919039905071, 0.05209767818450928, 0.016776105388998985, 0.006691866088658571, 0.0789712443947792, 0.03564715385437012, -0.06450920552015305, 0.0119492681697011, -0.025518786162137985, -0.09492707997560501, 0.034662872552871704, 0.011050153523683548, -0.03369356319308281, 0.012922636233270168, -0.017333069816231728, -0.017151907086372375, -0.011844843626022339, 0.05812454968690872, 0.009903226979076862, 0.08426636457443237, 0.02203972078859806, -0.0131397545337677, -0.02338499017059803, 0.0006400385173037648, 0.09124746918678284, 0.10236780345439911, 0.018987037241458893, -0.07216096669435501, 0.01218467392027378, -0.015924889594316483, 0.016798323020339012, -0.06360042095184326, 0.004357325378805399, -0.005776397418230772, -0.007620957214385271, 0.09818339347839355, 0.026457378640770912, 0.002514042891561985, -0.007121369242668152, 0.030955517664551735, -0.0022201696410775185, -0.02108617126941681, 0.011207668110728264, 0.022564832121133804, -0.013743382878601551, -0.029459550976753235, -0.03746231272816658, 0.046406157314777374, -0.00456871185451746, -0.025240760296583176, 0.016001228243112564, -0.03027058020234108, -0.002190166851505637, -0.013272926211357117, -0.02193652093410492, 0.03866271302103996, 0.0332665890455246, -0.03954533115029335, 0.0003389714693184942, -0.025452101603150368, 0.004716141149401665, -0.030616240575909615, 0.020627234131097794, 0.08707020431756973, 0.005657604895532131, -0.01936778612434864, -0.0030258705373853445, 0.05965697392821312, -0.027483737096190453, -0.032292671501636505, -0.03401455655694008, -0.003471702104434371, 0.0035589695908129215, 0.0397363156080246, -0.024544011801481247, -0.020597068592905998, -0.02907310426235199, -0.023521816357970238, -0.0064720590598881245, -0.0033653874415904284, 0.034636422991752625, -0.06343784183263779, -0.003107299329712987, -0.08320304751396179, 0.015368013642728329, -0.00990953017026186, 0.028756452724337578, 0.03827482834458351, -0.028099173679947853, -0.02508116327226162, -0.050144948065280914, 0.05098631605505943, -0.015257992781698704, 0.0001469326816732064, 0.0011570967035368085, -0.01602199114859104, -0.03259798139333725, 0.006260610185563564, 0.008319459855556488, -0.022583121433854103, -0.00016201242397073656, -0.012158425524830818, 0.005396002437919378, -0.04760941490530968, -0.022412681952118874, 0.02248270995914936, 0.0033610130194574594, -0.02203182317316532, -0.007655085530132055, 0.005689496640115976, 0.04996856674551964, -0.0031600510701537132, 0.03735895827412605, 0.011201906017959118, -0.036966726183891296, 0.030361199751496315, 0.0355970524251461, -0.05474871024489403, 0.006056095939129591, 0.0017449097940698266, -0.02025485411286354, -0.022931549698114395, -0.0034850784577429295, 0.04013655334711075, -0.004191301763057709, -0.04729949310421944, -0.009837483055889606, -0.012587844394147396, 0.008850736543536186, 0.005411629565060139, -0.013732777908444405, -0.045556169003248215, 0.005638668779283762, -0.01634245365858078, 0.010648134164512157, -0.005417945329099894, -0.04122471064329147, -0.04250430688261986, 0.010729682631790638, 0.008702258579432964, -0.022007528692483902, -0.018758956342935562, 0.03618238866329193, -0.01585930958390236, 0.01998094841837883, -0.019607486203312874, -0.01922498643398285, -0.026056455448269844, -0.007113884203135967, -0.008930386044085026, 0.015137393027544022, -0.00542363990098238, -0.020846329629421234, 0.02266315370798111, -0.018718106672167778, 0.030689595267176628, 0.03870220482349396, 0.01410103403031826, -0.022348172962665558, -0.0020646785851567984, -0.012750117108225822, 0.046895723789930344, -0.05587507411837578, -0.026104958727955818, 0.061528220772743225, -0.04365497827529907, -0.020690876990556717, 0.029009990394115448, -0.00975005328655243, 0.03719104826450348, 0.0002876339422073215, -0.012974214740097523, 0.0025052169803529978, 0.02970775030553341, -0.005004186183214188, -0.03009544126689434, 0.005805463995784521, 0.02372054196894169, 0.05553066357970238, 0.008334764279425144, -0.0037244006525725126, 0.018824707716703415, -0.010629083961248398, 0.004543819930404425, 0.05300895497202873, -0.015953240916132927, 0.018137939274311066, 0.006390588358044624, 0.014294244349002838, 0.031108690425753593, 0.025973660871386528, -0.036427225917577744, 0.040853165090084076, 0.022190338000655174, -0.039924975484609604, -0.019009627401828766, -0.041782014071941376, -0.0013698781840503216, -0.06523019075393677, -0.005360410548746586, -0.01640688069164753, -0.0004772125103045255, 0.03244798257946968, -0.03906133770942688, -0.006185760721564293, 0.04249570146203041, -0.057651497423648834, 0.005116623360663652, 0.023272804915905, -0.0034374885726720095, -0.01975001022219658, 0.001080276328139007, 0.015338395722210407, 0.014679457060992718, 0.03239487484097481, 0.004769560415297747, 0.02604239247739315, 0.0288343857973814, -0.010105590336024761, -0.04173058643937111, 0.01054836343973875, 0.009080723859369755, 0.009401398710906506, -0.04294062778353691, 0.0400606133043766, -0.0388660803437233, -0.026697387918829918, 0.056511636823415756, -0.0257487203925848, 0.052506521344184875, 0.012047214433550835, 0.013352444395422935, 0.021355170756578445, 0.025220172479748726, 0.06541305780410767, -0.008947237394750118, -0.015603849664330482, 0.027707939967513084, 0.010857616551220417, 0.04626033082604408, -0.022428546100854874, 0.028256552293896675, 0.013896186836063862, 0.01593363843858242, -0.04503156989812851, 0.06575609743595123, 0.005194325465708971, -0.021042002364993095, -0.0007754678372293711, -0.009966429322957993, 0.03398428484797478, -0.015458537265658379, 0.009666571393609047, -0.050726067274808884, 0.02941790781915188, 0.06282266229391098, -0.042351510375738144, -0.0007124270778149366, 0.0036237940657883883, -0.010430661961436272, -0.01564589887857437, 0.03237701952457428, -0.009345166385173798, -0.005284356418997049, -0.06444984674453735, -0.014928972348570824, -0.006603793241083622, -0.022686457261443138, 0.0049679456278681755, -0.007244626991450787, 0.017111381515860558, 0.04906437173485756, 0.0030853538773953915, -0.016343096271157265, 0.045069169253110886, 0.010655875317752361, 0.016674034297466278, -0.03962598741054535, 0.05318344756960869, 0.03191394731402397, 0.021456623449921608, -0.018942950293421745, -0.03997063636779785, 0.002324093133211136, -0.011139088310301304, 0.06788162142038345, -0.032028015702962875, -0.009382703341543674, -0.035568270832300186, 0.013218448497354984, -0.026031119748950005, -0.0756756141781807, -0.012850772589445114, -0.014589210972189903, -0.06057172641158104, -0.019350528717041016, -0.00716904504224658, 0.03641374781727791, -0.02154460921883583, 0.015687987208366394, -0.00825560837984085, 0.0008373273303732276, -0.018331849947571754, -0.010927875526249409, 0.015137569978833199, 0.028493303805589676, 0.013646786101162434, 0.03874056041240692, -0.00034066461375914514, 0.022267023101449013, 0.03527731075882912, 0.03018045797944069, -0.04401650279760361, 0.03450944647192955, -0.03662989288568497, -0.007274957839399576, -0.007732913829386234, -0.0044056568294763565, -0.03144097700715065, -0.06022941693663597, 0.0034534854348748922, 0.007234992925077677, -0.020552508533000946, -0.026814136654138565, 0.01146717183291912, -0.0032658835407346487, 0.04628840088844299, -0.03183966875076294, 0.053376276046037674, 0.007771949749439955, -0.03824156895279884, -0.015879806131124496, 0.0424380749464035, 0.01337145920842886, -0.015933901071548462, 0.017764054238796234, 0.04680522903800011, 0.014509756118059158, 0.05276625230908394, 0.010449978522956371, 0.035601962357759476, -0.018574358895421028, -0.0036739110946655273, 0.004944176413118839, -0.03035961650311947, 0.01123399380594492, 0.04886519908905029, -0.013344059698283672, 0.04443233460187912, -0.011600890196859837, 0.019490445032715797, -0.0461752712726593, -0.014488433487713337, -0.027263252064585686, 0.00389006151817739, 0.020356399938464165, 0.021517781540751457, -0.02877640537917614, -0.0024051081854850054, 0.038497909903526306, 0.03320510685443878, 0.0069778356701135635, -0.031070133671164513, 0.020354172214865685, -0.02793513424694538, 0.010675893165171146, -0.0101924492046237, -0.023048903793096542, -0.01632399670779705, 0.0023223089519888163, 0.03154192119836807, 0.041965264827013016, 0.009667105972766876, -0.006758487783372402, 0.020591609179973602, 0.0007035091402940452, 0.04791140928864479, -0.0698685273528099, -0.007231877185404301, -0.027973638847470284, -0.008669012226164341, -0.006927447859197855, -0.022488221526145935 ]
<p>I'm using <code>heatmap.2</code> to cluster my data, using the centroid method for clustering and the maximum method for calculating the distance matrix:</p> <pre><code>library("gplots") library("RColorBrewer") test &lt;- matrix(c(0.96, 0.07, 0.97, 0.98, 0.50, 0.28, 0.29, 0.77, 0.08, 0.96, 0.51, 0.51, 0.14, 0.19, 0.41, 0.51), ncol=4, byrow=TRUE) colnames(test) &lt;- c("Exp1","Exp2","Exp3","Exp4") rownames(test) &lt;- c("Gene1","Gene2","Gene3", "Gene4") test &lt;- as.table(test) mat &lt;- data.matrix(test) heatmap.2(mat, dendrogram="row", Rowv=TRUE, Colv=FALSE, distfun=function(x) dist(x, method='maximum'), hclustfun=function(x) hclust(x, method='centroid'), xlab=NULL, ylab=NULL, key=TRUE, keysize=1, trace="none", density.info=c("none"), margins=c(6, 12), col=bluered) </code></pre> <p>This gives a heatmap with inversions in the cluster tree, which is inherent to the centroid method. A solution to avoid inversions is to use the Euclidean or the city-block distance, and indeed if you change maximum to Euclidean in the above example the inversions are gone (for reference see chapter 4.1.1 in <a href="http://bonsai.hgc.jp/~mdehoon/software/cluster/manual/Hierarchical.html" rel="nofollow">this link</a>).</p> <p>Now as for my problem, when I use my actual data instead of this example table the inversions are still there when I change to Euclidean. The R code is exactly the same as in this example, only the data is different. When I use <code>cluster 3.0</code> and <code>java treeview</code> with the Euclidean and centroid method there are no inversions in my data as expected. So why does R give inversions? The theory and other software says it shouldn't.</p> <p><em><strong>Update:</em></strong> This is an example were changing maximum to Euclidean does not fix inversions (as opposed to the above example were it did fix it)</p> <pre><code>library("gplots") library("RColorBrewer") test &lt;- matrix(c(0.96, 0.07, 0.97, 0.98, 0.99, 0.50, 0.28, 0.29, 0.77, 0.78, 0.08, 0.96, 0.51, 0.51, 0.55, 0.14, 0.19, 0.41, 0.51, 0.40, 0.97, 0.98, 0.99, 0.50, 0.28 ), ncol=6, byrow=TRUE) colnames(test) &lt;- c("Exp1", "Exp2", "Exp3", "Exp4", "Exp5", "Exp6") rownames(test) &lt;- c("Gene1", "Gene2", "Gene3", "Gene4") test &lt;- as.table(test) mat &lt;- data.matrix(test) heatmap.2(mat, dendrogram="row", Rowv=TRUE, Colv=FALSE, distfun=function(x) dist(x, method='maximum'), hclustfun=function(x) hclust(x, method='centroid'), xlab=NULL, ylab=NULL, key=TRUE, keysize=1, trace="none", density.info=c("none"), margins=c(6, 12), col=bluered) </code></pre>
74,245
[ -0.03265615925192833, 0.047962866723537445, 0.03596460074186325, -0.017734887078404427, 0.017217526212334633, 0.008965977467596531, -0.0408930778503418, -0.014364734292030334, -0.006395420059561729, -0.037026096135377884, 0.056386832147836685, 0.049467407166957855, 0.07347822189331055, 0.016879700124263763, 0.027287805452942848, -0.004889346193522215, -0.01771242916584015, 0.04902399703860283, 0.007154002320021391, -0.008865936659276485, -0.0016731420764699578, 0.019994284957647324, -0.0028614785987883806, -0.04576247185468674, -0.03781789913773537, 0.05299653112888336, -0.001551578869111836, -0.014887875877320766, -0.01453261636197567, 0.05591064691543579, -0.05609077960252762, -0.02690240368247032, 0.024871692061424255, -0.0407058484852314, 0.015045912005007267, 0.02214096486568451, -0.005705562885850668, -0.00877051055431366, -0.024275973439216614, 0.014633416198194027, -0.016909081488847733, -0.02856919728219509, 0.0015556096332147717, 0.04800291731953621, -0.0034420262090861797, 0.02220996655523777, 0.020039813593029976, 0.04636397957801819, 0.0655006691813469, -0.023538310080766678, 0.07679609209299088, -0.0008790861465968192, 0.016288012266159058, 0.03956054151058197, -0.0533783994615078, -0.0007698996923863888, 0.026217633858323097, 0.040460363030433655, -0.00833655521273613, -0.06023962423205376, -0.01709483191370964, 0.003373887622728944, -0.0230500940233469, -0.07384179532527924, -0.05212308466434479, 0.00515594519674778, 0.001022254815325141, 0.001488286186940968, 0.034899499267339706, 0.00003236308475607075, 0.003093992592766881, 0.014537617564201355, 0.001879362273029983, -0.027240298688411713, 0.0398128442466259, -0.01242080982774496, -0.028376609086990356, 0.01560428086668253, 0.026672303676605225, -0.008161958307027817, 0.0017680085729807615, 0.041991692036390305, 0.004936159122735262, 0.0027016091626137495, 0.04009292274713516, -0.001847617095336318, 0.047825511544942856, -0.03046751394867897, -0.0010074046440422535, 0.06682503968477249, -0.01672864332795143, -0.003486314555630088, 0.05359366163611412, 0.023403868079185486, -0.02003292925655842, 0.012428974732756615, -0.03565884381532669, 0.01152877602726221, -0.025301536545157433, 0.015752896666526794, -0.05204806104302406, -0.02260385826230049, 0.021737856790423393, 0.03718730807304382, -0.02220681495964527, -0.03272358328104019, -0.05381053686141968, -0.029133494943380356, -0.019180895760655403, 0.021874824538826942, -0.02071194536983967, 0.02965504303574562, -0.03456248715519905, -0.010645936243236065, 0.05250416323542595, -0.04951343685388565, -0.004664027597755194, 0.018498273566365242, 0.027662962675094604, 0.05060204863548279, 0.02388010174036026, -0.003354497719556093, 0.02269498072564602, -0.03738328069448471, -0.038221124559640884, -0.0030696974135935307, 0.010849997401237488, -0.005801062099635601, -0.0026539016980677843, 0.020505405962467194, 0.034622978419065475, -0.0027080934960395098, 0.044765401631593704, -0.016484633088111877, 0.015442735515534878, -0.0248578991740942, -0.0763164684176445, -0.053469255566596985, 0.020930655300617218, -0.032644495368003845, 0.04151833429932594, -0.07928082346916199, -0.029482215642929077, 0.01168547011911869, 0.046015288680791855, -0.013476678170263767, 0.025075005367398262, 0.009692543186247349, 0.04906432703137398, -0.020567744970321655, 0.0007598104421049356, -0.019439036026597023, -0.017925158143043518, -0.02471964992582798, -0.004777544178068638, -0.05830717086791992, 0.013722858391702175, 0.030881989747285843, -0.05061086267232895, 0.03426080569624901, 0.017537496984004974, -0.002263669390231371, 0.007110052276402712, -0.00951877050101757, -0.019034218043088913, -0.016596926376223564, 0.09433014690876007, 0.008093040436506271, 0.025886699557304382, 0.032680317759513855, -0.05508618801832199, 0.016186820343136787, -0.0196742694824934, 0.04050156846642494, 0.027025973424315453, 0.016052121296525, 0.017468106001615524, 0.0015535319689661264, 0.025149215012788773, 0.03854270279407501, -0.05107764154672623, -0.009453154169023037, 0.028400449082255363, -0.016902422532439232, 0.04696193337440491, 0.0311138778924942, -0.02360396459698677, -0.042584843933582306, 0.057221874594688416, -0.025416452437639236, -0.031193139031529427, -0.053966108709573746, -0.024615658447146416, 0.0012169663095846772, -0.022787505760788918, 0.013646448031067848, 0.006938644219189882, 0.0059683420695364475, 0.05241043493151665, 0.01355217956006527, -0.04434091970324516, 0.009808884002268314, 0.05518436059355736, -0.03210647031664848, -0.01845822110772133, 0.027184847742319107, 0.054550349712371826, 0.0007580136880278587, 0.0342070572078228, -0.05150263011455536, -0.009610269218683243, 0.03680191561579704, -0.022637221962213516, -0.011594929732382298, -0.01142223458737135, -0.003520621219649911, 0.0029097863007336855, 0.04585767537355423, -0.001065107760950923, 0.03073607012629509, -0.047239866107702255, 0.03477222099900246, 0.053019873797893524, 0.024556420743465424, 0.013991150073707104, -0.012914794497191906, -0.052314843982458115, 0.03409808874130249, -0.01963980495929718, 0.01991298608481884, -0.05109982565045357, -0.0011209540534764528, 0.032394759356975555, 0.032027341425418854, -0.044169832020998, -0.0005623584729619324, 0.04459657520055771, -0.02015412598848343, -0.018441589549183846, 0.018509618937969208, 0.008323733694851398, -0.01462489552795887, 0.06679750233888626, 0.013558580540120602, 0.0017983430298045278, 0.03306073695421219, 0.05670322850346565, -0.02313532866537571, 0.033973220735788345, -0.033078208565711975, -0.015083854086697102, 0.05322356894612312, 0.004029668867588043, -0.023224633187055588, -0.020147036761045456, 0.01246397290378809, 0.011947531253099442, 0.016117125749588013, 0.006500836927443743, 0.045177020132541656, 0.01578478515148163, 0.028936054557561874, -0.023015055805444717, -0.02089371718466282, 0.007565171457827091, 0.08278170228004456, -0.04006556048989296, -0.02189691551029682, 0.019933076575398445, -0.06590300053358078, 0.029117269441485405, -0.0560203455388546, -0.03915724158287048, -0.019341161474585533, 0.010178593918681145, 0.015444459393620491, 0.01861736550927162, 0.02343890629708767, -0.029056770727038383, -0.002437375718727708, 0.00471155159175396, -0.03697383403778076, 0.04427145794034004, 0.012068269774317741, -0.013931773602962494, -0.0326051339507103, -0.04848387464880943, 0.024834048002958298, -0.0007822841871529818, 0.015690600499510765, -0.03501592203974724, -0.019920486956834793, 0.03625687211751938, -0.02126854658126831, -0.030247295275330544, -0.026322273537516594, 0.00009767395386006683, -0.029830625280737877, -0.0034529513213783503, 0.03889985755085945, -0.015433005057275295, -0.04648466035723686, 0.030142413452267647, -0.029662925750017166, 0.009761902503669262, -0.013456007465720177, -0.009297394193708897, -0.009382741525769234, 0.03980877622961998, 0.021120956167578697, 0.03586412966251373, -0.021057981997728348, -0.012624058872461319, -0.05248548090457916, -0.043912336230278015, 0.020613081753253937, -0.007535148411989212, -0.0025457534939050674, 0.005404902622103691, -0.007731008809059858, 0.061081431806087494, 0.04356319084763527, -0.03590727224946022, -0.052276406437158585, 0.018393246456980705, -0.05291007459163666, -0.02095884270966053, 0.03342778608202934, 0.022517193108797073, 0.018685923889279366, 0.004736931994557381, 0.0013323173625394702, 0.056373391300439835, 0.05648484453558922, -0.05946839600801468, -0.005874568596482277, 0.030666207894682884, -0.002693834016099572, -0.02372789941728115, 0.060925405472517014, 0.012031817808747292, 0.0304737389087677, 0.04511716961860657, -0.005958138033747673, -0.006482368800789118, -0.01974695548415184, -0.04928765445947647, 0.0005119141424074769, -0.026372039690613747, 0.041221003979444504, -0.044846806675195694, 0.0011133587686344981, 0.04823099449276924, -0.013468264602124691, 0.014569485560059547, -0.0050229476764798164, 0.07846080511808395, -0.023283451795578003, -0.035975269973278046, 0.060507882386446, 0.04789530485868454, 0.0002278363099321723, 0.04423036798834801, 0.036719515919685364, -0.013235767371952534, 0.00527583435177803, -0.012532747350633144, -0.004051504656672478, 0.007286617532372475, 0.05832850560545921, -0.024492422118782997, 0.026630962267518044, -0.03540608286857605, 0.032410260289907455, -0.01353380549699068, 0.036343034356832504, -0.04571766033768654, 0.03315981850028038, 0.005927087273448706, 0.009457833133637905, 0.043930649757385254, 0.011217943392693996, 0.0015560644678771496, 0.013338727876543999, -0.08698158711194992, -0.002595210913568735, 0.015203455463051796, 0.007052725646644831, -0.05694195628166199, -0.04884445294737816, 0.02281326986849308, -0.007656590547412634, 0.010957417078316212, 0.051007162779569626, -0.010196194052696228, -0.055993545800447464, -0.006734812632203102, 0.009710977785289288, 0.017320526763796806, -0.036851346492767334, 0.03376729413866997, 0.0528855174779892, 0.0004617526719812304, -0.0002142728044418618, 0.0365135483443737, -0.00682816794142127, 0.03304991498589516, -0.016385039314627647, 0.02180856466293335, 0.055185429751873016, 0.04348672553896904, -0.01193336583673954, 0.0239680428057909, -0.029069820418953896, -0.016282174736261368, 0.033899206668138504, 0.014831220731139183, 0.031002096831798553, -0.0353127121925354, -0.009955056011676788, 0.01425809133797884, -0.027718691155314445, -0.0022886721417307854, -0.010391810908913612, -0.008132962509989738, 0.017843253910541534, 0.026218898594379425, 0.033739496022462845, 0.0035236477851867676, 0.005485919304192066, 0.039313893765211105, 0.030557114630937576, -0.026228036731481552, -0.03322421759366989, -0.05343601107597351, -0.02521943300962448, -0.03241276368498802, 0.00389063055627048, -0.0018923765746876597, -0.003368051489815116, 0.013878963887691498, 0.028289256617426872, -0.013549037277698517, -0.009542527608573437, 0.015211558900773525, 0.017639292404055595, 0.05158286169171333, -0.025574322789907455, -0.0005236758152022958, -0.0017982005374506116, -0.020328057929873466, 0.02946341224014759, 0.014227503910660744, -0.006587253883481026, -0.08322668820619583, -0.03595896437764168, 0.004931753966957331, 0.032870855182409286, 0.016222914680838585, -0.020580561831593513, -0.05823254957795143, -0.01724858582019806, -0.015048053115606308, -0.02333756908774376, 0.039893731474876404, -0.03167765587568283, -0.008924305438995361, -0.02147071063518524, -0.013830112293362617, -0.04778819531202316, -0.007773688528686762, -0.046595245599746704, 0.02133847214281559, -0.05027208849787712, 0.002665566047653556, -0.043965794146060944, 0.0340576246380806, -0.025101976469159126, 0.00883400533348322, -0.06387431919574738, -0.04456155747175217, 0.012705283239483833, 0.011108801700174809, -0.02494787983596325, -0.018695376813411713, 0.01231043878942728, 0.022297875955700874, 0.029440540820360184, 0.06326910108327866, 0.0060485731810331345, 0.010260733775794506, 0.017580682411789894, 0.011512876488268375, 0.019823744893074036, 0.016955541446805, 0.032467857003211975, 0.0345882773399353, 0.026947980746626854, -0.00477986503392458, 0.046715881675481796, 0.026644382625818253, -0.015336548909544945, 0.03564567118883133, -0.07814186811447144, -0.014527983963489532, -0.044721148908138275, -0.040195953100919724, -0.043738652020692825, -0.020219003781676292, -0.015832457691431046, 0.007387666963040829, -0.026611967012286186, 0.04259958490729332, -0.01638195663690567, -0.005551002454012632, 0.04388120397925377, 0.03468795865774155, -0.023835066705942154, 0.007296284660696983, -0.02442287839949131, 0.028815533965826035, -0.006701997946947813, -0.009139793924987316, 0.02908700704574585, 0.01756916008889675, -0.011525852605700493, -0.0033799512311816216, -0.04161953926086426, 0.016381215304136276, 0.03692861273884773, 0.003223937004804611, 0.01926090195775032, -0.0055237687192857265, -0.005094796419143677, -0.04233356937766075, 0.018665563315153122, 0.004173931200057268, -0.020714202895760536, -0.0036632658448070288, 0.02502107433974743, -0.05900830402970314, -0.013151964172720909, -0.015648188069462776, 0.020156078040599823, -0.0003977458400186151, 0.013569165952503681, -0.02489219233393669, 0.003981204703450203, -0.0029607133474200964, -0.007213766220957041, -0.055460117757320404, -0.06492298096418381, -0.027876950800418854, 0.0018620332702994347, -0.043614666908979416, -0.0171951986849308, 0.03469005599617958, -0.008850939571857452, 0.014383033849298954, -0.001951096928678453, 0.0014888333389535546, 0.05778370797634125, 0.007303953170776367, -0.006801882293075323, 0.06350244581699371, 0.01745632477104664, 0.008783361874520779, 0.0021363217383623123, 0.00812495406717062, -0.015800993889570236, 0.031351834535598755, 0.004325622692704201, 0.003994413185864687, 0.02743690274655819, 0.026180462911725044, -0.04202805832028389, -0.0009420817950740457, 0.0362570621073246, 0.01678605005145073, -0.04065287113189697, 0.018515562638640404, -0.04609978571534157, 0.00018598476890474558, -0.049596868455410004, -0.014046361669898033, -0.0010290932841598988, -0.01684737205505371, 0.004003457259386778, -0.06019061803817749, 0.005108589306473732, 0.005168226081877947, 0.13171076774597168, -0.007088339887559414, 0.0028546126559376717, -0.016284553334116936, -0.03978930413722992, 0.022437255829572678, 0.026931243017315865, -0.016980718821287155, -0.024191413074731827, 0.034372828900814056, 0.01324559934437275, 0.006613793782889843, -0.031308483332395554, 0.03186121955513954, 0.06305726617574692, 0.02287820354104042, 0.04441303387284279, 0.03260941058397293, -0.0040689026936888695, 0.03303077071905136, -0.05048380792140961, -0.02395913004875183, -0.00654688710346818, 0.024809321388602257, 0.08126850426197052, -0.0003076078719459474, -0.02169400081038475, 0.07842537015676498, 0.020824894309043884, -0.04272054508328438, 0.03377272188663483, -0.01181393675506115, -0.006316399201750755, -0.016553139314055443, -0.03568074852228165, -0.03267644718289375, 0.001805317122489214, -0.03244520351290703, 0.06004181504249573, -0.03907977417111397, -0.02598029375076294, -0.008406524546444416, 0.016546225175261497, -0.005085237789899111, -0.013392828404903412, -0.03599349409341812, -0.030735313892364502, 0.0036864520516246557, -0.016939176246523857, -0.036501023918390274, 0.012690793722867966, 0.0181751511991024, 0.03265324980020523, -0.011132375337183475, 0.02492627687752247, -0.051808007061481476, -0.05261455848813057, -0.018934987485408783, -0.03544880449771881, -0.06235150247812271, 0.0423608273267746, 0.011080962605774403, -0.03930545225739479, 0.04220953583717346, 0.00019430421525612473, 0.019050750881433487, 0.01020333543419838, 0.030772263184189796, 0.020928774029016495, 0.03337951749563217, 0.01060743723064661, 0.014848221093416214, -0.014949988573789597, -0.033644549548625946, 0.1543867290019989, 0.0880659744143486, 0.01822778210043907, -0.055164504796266556, 0.022433141246438026, -0.0125422403216362, 0.01311564538627863, -0.03583933785557747, -0.026976674795150757, 0.008898931555449963, -0.016995657235383987, 0.06126071885228157, 0.06369593739509583, 0.023309342563152313, 0.006207332015037537, 0.012482685036957264, -0.029101742431521416, -0.03399825841188431, -0.004954157397150993, 0.01736612617969513, -0.05549556016921997, -0.04077957198023796, -0.057494159787893295, -0.008195520378649235, 0.041391342878341675, 0.028934510424733162, -0.07024499773979187, -0.016475465148687363, 0.009416591376066208, 0.009114091284573078, -0.02632516622543335, -0.0012798457173630595, 0.009313351474702358, -0.023638710379600525, -0.012045038864016533, -0.030882252380251884, 0.0007203408167697489, -0.036973655223846436, 0.01222313567996025, 0.02112259343266487, 0.016827866435050964, 0.03159947320818901, -0.0015507853822782636, 0.007136972155421972, -0.025751831009984016, -0.017543748021125793, -0.015217786654829979, 0.031102782115340233, -0.0163869708776474, -0.030122198164463043, 0.02181401662528515, 0.012039381079375744, -0.0059214490465819836, -0.018985433503985405, 0.020246239379048347, 0.0008749961270950735, 0.046009715646505356, 0.021414104849100113, -0.027237456291913986, -0.03484571725130081, 0.051451925188302994, -0.011629322543740273, 0.01984783634543419, 0.02520781196653843, -0.009597189724445343, -0.01327491458505392, -0.03815601021051407, 0.07005088776350021, -0.046053122729063034, 0.016229897737503052, 0.016740355640649796, -0.012685246765613556, -0.025890404358506203, -0.039763692766427994, -0.0005528953624889255, -0.0023667514324188232, 0.01752401888370514, 0.026665644720196724, -0.03540680184960365, -0.006613750476390123, -0.025816278532147408, -0.009208844974637032, -0.03273468837141991, -0.03284195810556412, -0.009568991139531136, -0.0018527554348111153, 0.04463556408882141, 0.0376877635717392, 0.02990681305527687, 0.012714841403067112, -0.02138417772948742, 0.01974933221936226, 0.023203106597065926, -0.021043140441179276, -0.04392731934785843, -0.016665391623973846, -0.036138445138931274, -0.014090883545577526, 0.0018602878553792834, 0.042646750807762146, 0.011179544031620026, 0.005643628537654877, -0.000008590625839133281, 0.006971445865929127, 0.012328426353633404, 0.00017490390746388584, 0.024276278913021088, -0.05065726488828659, 0.04302274063229561, -0.0032103562261909246, -0.03182448074221611, -0.056280460208654404, -0.03678512200713158, -0.03665252402424812, -0.06905359774827957, 0.013531371019780636, 0.0012423566076904535, -0.047549281269311905, -0.03858531266450882, -0.010284637100994587, 0.026844248175621033, 0.022725122049450874, -0.028870945796370506, -0.035708826035261154, -0.005787479691207409, -0.029946133494377136, -0.03840535134077072, -0.010209692642092705, 0.008182485587894917, -0.05014045909047127, 0.008750041015446186, 0.047586631029844284, 0.025578396394848824, 0.04392634332180023, -0.005676743574440479, -0.008573990315198898, 0.021891100332140923, 0.03360169008374214, 0.026840124279260635, 0.010443508625030518, 0.030078228563070297, -0.06464175134897232, -0.04855138063430786, -0.0175241157412529, -0.002042190171778202, -0.0032731383107602596, 0.018572093918919563, 0.013625243678689003, -0.03334922716021538, 0.0784902274608612, -0.02295224368572235, -0.00718318996950984, -0.009154010564088821, -0.004558459855616093, 0.05304786190390587, 0.01339779980480671, -0.011490444652736187, -0.007542373146861792, -0.012873416766524315, -0.000008160664947354235, 0.018111608922481537, 0.0018129950622096658, -0.01237217802554369, 0.021761342883110046, -0.03722717985510826, 0.019497547298669815, -0.02753352001309395, -0.02125636301934719, 0.04138138145208359, 0.044975150376558304, -0.05472002550959587, 0.014545625075697899, 0.00008976498065749183, 0.02980964258313179, -0.08804617077112198, -0.029117783531546593, 0.005486992187798023, 0.017892351374030113, 0.0012078072177246213, -0.01787065714597702, 0.013422676362097263, 0.026604855433106422, -0.06316756457090378, 0.06279603391885757, 0.006643062457442284, 0.001786225475370884, -0.03205478563904762, 0.02033364400267601, -0.03838232159614563, 0.030510511249303818, 0.054935354739427567, 0.03925442323088646, 0.03570523485541344, 0.0007524752290919423, -0.024227596819400787, -0.024955060333013535, 0.0065048919059336185, -0.010492372326552868, 0.0023893273901194334, -0.01606995053589344, -0.008010422810912132, -0.010506248101592064, 0.01047721691429615, 0.008731349371373653, -0.04490550979971886, 0.01035408116877079, 0.047337863594293594, -0.007130748592317104, 0.02034761570394039, 0.025747081264853477, 0.010871986858546734, -0.017644530162215233, -0.01978025957942009, -0.002990622306242585, -0.011587003245949745, 0.010074898600578308, -0.026940954849123955, 0.03138797730207443, 0.02448767051100731, 0.008063948713243008, -0.006385621149092913, 0.04603813588619232, -0.029747532680630684, 0.02395535446703434, -0.03142502158880234, -0.007543619256466627, 0.016113562509417534, 0.003957636654376984, 0.022224437445402145, 0.0043944730423390865, 0.0060966662131249905, 0.043466463685035706, 0.062106743454933167, -0.00356912799179554, 0.029747381806373596, -0.0023388166446238756, -0.04007592052221298, -0.024187123402953148, -0.006993573158979416, -0.0410328209400177, -0.016074534505605698, -0.020219774916768074, -0.0285023283213377, 0.021445851773023605, -0.017626944929361343, -0.00032252934761345387, -0.014860127121210098, 0.06416967511177063, -0.0149055952206254, 0.013537079095840454, 0.027134563773870468, 0.015643050894141197, 0.02174919843673706, -0.08686643838882446, 0.026476271450519562, 0.009736137464642525, -0.019526392221450806, -0.024610469117760658, 0.017635202035307884, -0.022275013849139214, 0.03875729814171791, 0.05511510744690895, 0.04512173682451248, 0.021041447296738625, -0.0009870717767626047, 0.04336890950798988, 0.018316926434636116, -0.05244974046945572, 0.03881858289241791, 0.009817290119826794, 0.015797242522239685, 0.018944714218378067, 0.00996076874434948, 0.02160182222723961, 0.03192952275276184, -0.051418472081422806, -0.011787207797169685, -0.012305043637752533, 0.016891667619347572, 0.007790453732013702, 0.005858591292053461, -0.030506525188684464, -0.04829780012369156, 0.030385375022888184, 0.0009075762354768813, -0.012673930265009403, 0.07605569064617157, 0.00823291763663292, -0.010249326936900616, 0.018961992114782333, -0.03792519494891167, -0.04932212829589844, 0.03639928996562958, -0.0017786304233595729, -0.002914076903834939, -0.0342298224568367, 0.013338988646864891, -0.016858018934726715, -0.011247940361499786, -0.046576134860515594, -0.009774618782103062, 0.00951653067022562, 0.04613729566335678, 0.014110369607806206, 0.011164671741425991, -0.006837024353444576, -0.02057793363928795, 0.04183732345700264, 0.02268325723707676, -0.029394520446658134, 0.00010885217488976195, -0.008053387515246868, 0.013684062287211418, -0.02491680346429348, 0.0017957633826881647, -0.025834249332547188, 0.0430956706404686, -0.005058124661445618, -0.01266810018569231, 0.006027495488524437, -0.06942494213581085, 0.012854875065386295, 0.02783038653433323, -0.003747824113816023, 0.036539699882268906, -0.01465184148401022, 0.020999494940042496, -0.0049750166945159435, -0.05785601958632469, -0.0008179354481399059, 0.01020630169659853, -0.004524121526628733, 0.05517767742276192, -0.04016898572444916, 0.014876817353069782, 0.013641390018165112, -0.009885793551802635, 0.011579000391066074, 0.008030284196138382, 0.04230288043618202, -0.032727502286434174, -0.001901952549815178, 0.02951427735388279, 0.011164476163685322, -0.03235570341348648, -0.006435577291995287, -0.023082368075847626, 0.04135645553469658, 0.0042550163343548775, -0.00025339596322737634, -0.022390658035874367, -0.0005705635412596166, 0.0012315454659983516, -0.0486094132065773, -0.019313089549541473, -0.007933158427476883, 0.027171745896339417, -0.0026513407938182354, -0.00819497462362051 ]
<p>When finding the maximum margin separator in the primal form we have the quadratic program</p> <p>$$min\frac{1}{2}||\theta||^2$$ $$\text{ subject to: } y^{(t)}(\theta \cdot x^{(t)} + \theta_0) \geq 1, \ t=1,...,n,$$</p> <p>saying basically to find the maximum margin separator. The margin size will be:</p> <p>$$\frac{1}{||\theta||}.$$</p> <p>Does the size of the margin change if we change the constants of the constraint?</p> <p>That is, if we have</p> <p>$$\text{ subject to: } y^{(t)}(\theta \cdot x^{(t)} + \theta_0) \geq k, \ t=1,...,n,$$</p> <p>instead of 1?</p> <p>If it does not matter, why doesn't this matter? How is it an equivalent formulation regardless of the exact constants for the constraint?</p>
74,246
[ -0.030664514750242233, 0.020048240199685097, 0.003256671130657196, -0.01994294300675392, 0.005039407406002283, 0.02097133733332157, -0.005927297752350569, -0.01565503142774105, 0.0333050899207592, -0.019111575558781624, 0.016808418557047844, 0.017205430194735527, 0.06750398129224777, 0.019559629261493683, 0.0240828488022089, 0.011817741207778454, -0.034941740334033966, 0.00182671460788697, 0.019504541531205177, 0.02007405087351799, -0.03604144975543022, 0.030857278034090996, 0.005248199682682753, -0.030627530068159103, -0.02789177931845188, 0.0230976864695549, 0.026306459680199623, 0.00591225316748023, 0.003253229660913348, 0.06960399448871613, -0.01749558001756668, -0.010362214408814907, 0.01065997127443552, 0.06023314595222473, 0.026123501360416412, 0.011634159833192825, -0.03146447241306305, -0.038350872695446014, 0.01684725470840931, 0.005965203978121281, -0.01711854338645935, -0.02432817593216896, -0.009926007129251957, 0.01849762722849846, -0.004125332459807396, 0.05755917355418205, -0.003346365410834551, -0.03670850396156311, 0.02111053839325905, -0.015807589516043663, 0.026331935077905655, 0.018607979640364647, 0.013947846367955208, 0.032642245292663574, -0.015783090144395828, 0.009227803908288479, 0.041918281465768814, 0.0792471170425415, -0.02540697157382965, -0.033195726573467255, -0.009425675496459007, -0.02671007812023163, 0.026743322610855103, -0.0044198669493198395, -0.02401566691696644, 0.03987933695316315, 0.014488240703940392, -0.004578493535518646, -0.006430518813431263, -0.022128164768218994, -0.026917124167084694, 0.009347465820610523, 0.0269993357360363, -0.00268872594460845, -0.013870958238840103, -0.019128361716866493, 0.01397336833178997, 0.038650430738925934, 0.04056935012340546, 0.005731338635087013, 0.01259434875100851, -0.0033938230480998755, 0.041564371436834335, 0.02684967964887619, -0.022604964673519135, 0.05222131311893463, 0.0815110132098198, -0.022021185606718063, 0.028838474303483963, 0.05642329901456833, 0.0176584143191576, 0.03502702713012695, 0.0531926192343235, -0.05207538604736328, 0.007364457938820124, 0.02336248941719532, -0.008455093950033188, -0.0051473770290613174, 0.016770990565419197, 0.0029444352257996798, -0.017843138426542282, -0.060068704187870026, -0.02688607946038246, 0.03993513062596321, -0.027267789468169212, -0.0001666222233325243, -0.024286305531859398, 0.00037422089371830225, 0.00267859292216599, -0.02585161291062832, -0.03250681608915329, 0.007123828865587711, -0.019298722967505455, 0.01653842069208622, 0.005143398884683847, -0.012217788957059383, -0.01714833453297615, -0.020324960350990295, 0.04588973894715309, 0.05333079770207405, 0.05098949745297432, -0.005898071452975273, 0.05480799451470375, -0.0254271999001503, -0.05697130784392357, 0.046372197568416595, -0.01773754134774208, -0.01514064148068428, -0.06839419156312943, -0.013875066302716732, -0.014109172858297825, -0.008016767911612988, 0.0106634721159935, 0.0005459127714857459, 0.00010313757957192138, -0.01668907329440117, -0.07419831305742264, -0.03524528816342354, 0.034805454313755035, 0.004721061326563358, 0.017683085054159164, -0.06805480271577835, 0.00604918273165822, 0.007285524625331163, 0.05206897109746933, -0.0019007243681699038, 0.055341728031635284, 0.06882796436548233, -0.011797641403973103, 0.02148476615548134, -0.05443347617983818, 0.026655441150069237, -0.003337888279929757, -0.016651952639222145, -0.009168094955384731, -0.05758131295442581, -0.028500445187091827, 0.06224290281534195, -0.001316639012657106, -0.012012102641165257, 0.046543341130018234, -0.011494316160678864, -0.041082918643951416, -0.034043312072753906, -0.007473430596292019, 0.0007599482196383178, 0.051993899047374725, -0.014318959787487984, 0.03509451448917389, 0.011816730722784996, 0.0027220172341912985, -0.019835053011775017, -0.017884450033307076, -0.0001647166209295392, 0.048332784324884415, -0.05039970576763153, -0.01597094163298607, -0.048642486333847046, 0.0027272694278508425, 0.030710535123944283, -0.05242231488227844, -0.021942758932709694, -0.06535375863313675, 0.03348221257328987, 0.0008110125781968236, 0.0864715725183487, -0.01465387549251318, -0.009668851271271706, -0.007177483290433884, -0.010629946365952492, -0.017201753333210945, -0.04610595479607582, 0.06934581696987152, -0.0018226825632154942, -0.02399294264614582, 0.03570699319243431, -0.03259691596031189, 0.019426288083195686, 0.005182281602174044, -0.008827990852296352, 0.013065820559859276, 0.03866784647107124, 0.0095534548163414, -0.03248359262943268, 0.030539631843566895, 0.06333436816930771, 0.031000712886452675, 0.012361457571387291, 0.032823596149683, -0.03031434491276741, -0.04453805088996887, 0.03309936076402664, -0.02112293802201748, 0.02295650541782379, -0.020564641803503036, -0.004209090024232864, 0.0033299641218036413, -0.052647531032562256, -0.01596055179834366, 0.054070845246315, -0.08438067138195038, 0.062081363052129745, 0.06204318627715111, 0.0001402938214596361, 0.011314287781715393, 0.016230769455432892, 0.01255765464156866, 0.020112834870815277, 0.0056432802230119705, 0.02012457139790058, -0.032530903816223145, -0.005079582799226046, 0.05962499603629112, 0.05470482259988785, -0.042755648493766785, -0.004785028286278248, 0.07500915974378586, -0.005554994568228722, -0.001956345746293664, 0.009030567482113838, -0.017060905694961548, 0.0030473184306174517, 0.06545721739530563, 0.03754454851150513, -0.01387792732566595, 0.0062147825956344604, -0.02982371672987938, -0.01031424105167389, 0.027243344113230705, -0.014242512173950672, -0.028733616694808006, 0.06274726986885071, 0.024996085092425346, -0.01674049347639084, -0.00008000611705938354, -0.016043592244386673, 0.0433182492852211, -0.033701568841934204, 0.03394022956490517, 0.02910797856748104, 0.012577950023114681, 0.011468544602394104, -0.012404189445078373, -0.00524900434538722, 0.01192215085029602, -0.025090910494327545, -0.03705563023686409, 0.004004759714007378, 0.021940497681498528, -0.024849019944667816, -0.021053344011306763, -0.05857563763856888, -0.07024947553873062, -0.010983980260789394, -0.02436111494898796, 0.030851593241095543, -0.025492031127214432, 0.017137154936790466, -0.04688982293009758, 0.03263365849852562, 0.002271181670948863, -0.04481581971049309, 0.015546848066151142, -0.011698387563228607, -0.03197545185685158, -0.015007722191512585, -0.0169350728392601, -0.008837422356009483, 0.03413457050919533, 0.02275954745709896, 0.046656325459480286, 0.006774837151169777, -0.014292476698756218, -0.0519101656973362, -0.009660734795033932, -0.026714447885751724, -0.004706093575805426, -0.014219865202903748, -0.04164421930909157, 0.04759549722075462, 0.022547708824276924, -0.025220297276973724, 0.006772963795810938, -0.011969356797635555, -0.014356398023664951, -0.04139022156596184, 0.03151753172278404, 0.03265981376171112, -0.02683936432003975, 0.01864851638674736, 0.055335454642772675, -0.013976185582578182, -0.003926581237465143, -0.07002348452806473, -0.0221907626837492, -0.01788841001689434, -0.022797998040914536, 0.020843900740146637, -0.018384449183940887, -0.02299889177083969, 0.1229165717959404, 0.05840763822197914, -0.04477148875594139, -0.06563112139701843, 0.011815562844276428, 0.0014718037564307451, -0.04811752215027809, -0.005496031139045954, 0.03211668133735657, -0.007222998887300491, 0.008556566201150417, -0.003776033641770482, 0.01938740350306034, 0.037995703518390656, 0.005819185171276331, 0.010885611176490784, -0.009842867963016033, 0.016071541234850883, -0.029454605653882027, 0.029512327164411545, 0.05030940845608711, -0.00026442011585459113, 0.010132106021046638, 0.02732345089316368, 0.05640527978539467, 0.023874517530202866, -0.0685466080904007, 0.0292021743953228, -0.02301650680601597, 0.014295240864157677, -0.005905075464397669, 0.034300871193408966, 0.02773384191095829, -0.014591250568628311, -0.021654773503541946, -0.012149042449891567, 0.008482351899147034, -0.023797903209924698, -0.03577730432152748, 0.02148210071027279, 0.026593489572405815, -0.014875728636980057, 0.027395034208893776, -0.00040390563663095236, 0.0038554570637643337, 0.017124619334936142, 0.008631329983472824, -0.042034752666950226, 0.012465385720133781, -0.004629175644367933, -0.0027537301648408175, 0.022547392174601555, -0.005080400034785271, -0.03945343568921089, -0.06555363535881042, -0.005661382339894772, -0.010508349165320396, 0.04291282594203949, 0.020569834858179092, 0.04703959822654724, 0.003162151901051402, -0.011232314631342888, 0.0006595422746613622, 0.03728390485048294, -0.09354598820209503, -0.023932751268148422, -0.028623294085264206, -0.017388762906193733, 0.019345885142683983, -0.012930481694638729, 0.011018998920917511, -0.027511894702911377, 0.006201806012541056, 0.015266705304384232, 0.039784032851457596, -0.058872293680906296, 0.04256607964634895, -0.019239068031311035, 0.014954909682273865, 0.014952982775866985, 0.03596355766057968, 0.05246800556778908, -0.021627699956297874, 0.018855085596442223, 0.06093842163681984, -0.007335186470299959, 0.0011844822438433766, -0.03139779344201088, 0.046520788222551346, -0.003025891724973917, 0.03314254432916641, 0.01976707950234413, 0.027825472876429558, 0.014142168685793877, 0.015087655745446682, -0.015732022002339363, 0.009337829425930977, 0.019014999270439148, 0.0075317141599953175, -0.03394869342446327, -0.055801212787628174, -0.013281813822686672, -0.006204082164913416, 0.020710675045847893, -0.023683156818151474, -0.002610893454402685, 0.06482790410518646, 0.008644483983516693, -0.021515028551220894, -0.0289335735142231, 0.049619533121585846, 0.014580299146473408, -0.036280348896980286, -0.04536446928977966, 0.0074865627102553844, -0.00045134007814340293, 0.019765593111515045, -0.018336424604058266, -0.019796568900346756, -0.017848003655672073, 0.0014841967495158315, 0.03707529976963997, -0.022584283724427223, 0.018624044954776764, 0.011390557512640953, 0.05355039983987808, 0.04660183563828468, -0.0158880352973938, -0.009189710952341557, 0.0032224564347416162, 0.03006737492978573, 0.017472343519330025, 0.031200921162962914, 0.015710905194282532, -0.05073893815279007, -0.022290466353297234, -0.011617989279329777, 0.044556908309459686, 0.009630846790969372, -0.03470096364617348, -0.032145898789167404, -0.022358760237693787, 0.030176063999533653, -0.017899492755532265, 0.035496845841407776, -0.01075691170990467, -0.027720505371689796, -0.024558275938034058, -0.04213475063443184, -0.03421463444828987, -0.02096421644091606, -0.010778791271150112, 0.07325761765241623, 0.022113211452960968, -0.017782293260097504, 0.00012925968621857464, 0.02194799669086933, 0.006469757296144962, 0.059403955936431885, -0.00795956514775753, -0.027065645903348923, -0.002093224786221981, 0.03406355530023575, -0.04208364337682724, -0.06029898300766945, 0.003497162600979209, 0.03299536928534508, -0.028286073356866837, 0.0036272695288062096, -0.026554295793175697, -0.05825457349419594, 0.002246338641270995, 0.028138505294919014, -0.03879505768418312, 0.028679165989160538, 0.022019019350409508, 0.06905676424503326, 0.053484171628952026, 0.00209636683575809, 0.0520782396197319, 0.024578962475061417, 0.03155410289764404, -0.0244897548109293, -0.04695854336023331, 0.012759769335389137, -0.025937315076589584, -0.01475218590348959, -0.036624472588300705, 0.003109855344519019, -0.01926792412996292, 0.054076120257377625, 0.00017116959497798234, 0.025997160002589226, -0.0658326968550682, -0.00009501143358647823, -0.025770483538508415, 0.03411513939499855, 0.010357645340263844, -0.026900775730609894, 0.02420906536281109, 0.05440984666347504, 0.013044717721641064, -0.002421405166387558, 0.009362485259771347, -0.04560783505439758, -0.006639197468757629, 0.033672090619802475, 0.016433490440249443, -0.0008508365717716515, -0.019188372418284416, -0.03966734930872917, 0.011331877671182156, -0.0339391864836216, 0.05852691829204559, -0.0043065110221505165, 0.0448170006275177, 0.0042490363121032715, -0.020664768293499947, -0.02487899549305439, -0.009931450709700584, -0.021643688902258873, 0.003761623753234744, -0.050693437457084656, 0.02382594160735607, 0.01759221777319908, 0.007373718079179525, -0.0612434521317482, -0.031657587736845016, 0.0021631051786243916, -0.007661130279302597, -0.00224041729234159, 0.0007708788034506142, -0.005340347066521645, -0.014098071493208408, -0.052899014204740524, -0.02090994082391262, 0.06214058771729469, 0.0041808029636740685, -0.03362664207816124, -0.023186666890978813, 0.06956943869590759, 0.03870971128344536, 0.007031950168311596, 0.002947860164567828, -0.0016857946757227182, -0.02000422589480877, -0.02055293880403042, -0.014212616719305515, 0.04107491672039032, -0.03606163710355759, -0.00555215822532773, -0.030613334849476814, -0.007879051379859447, 0.025122983381152153, 0.0017645236803218722, 0.012543019838631153, 0.02001802623271942, 0.003650564467534423, -0.005937446374446154, -0.03977653756737709, -0.03197060152888298, 0.02103900909423828, 0.033030636608600616, 0.0533195324242115, -0.027762172743678093, -0.022516045719385147, -0.03537306934595108, 0.027066625654697418, -0.006957710720598698, -0.006599812768399715, -0.004694103728979826, 0.1102570965886116, -0.043315790593624115, -0.023561714217066765, -0.015101964585483074, -0.0045802174136042595, 0.07085441797971725, 0.006322396453469992, 0.017018282786011696, -0.004710772540420294, 0.008041857741773129, -0.04901103675365448, -0.014620053581893444, -0.03163265436887741, 0.05051141232252121, 0.05895334109663963, 0.0010672714561223984, 0.028902504593133926, 0.002826930955052376, -0.021239155903458595, 0.004596870392560959, -0.08671848475933075, 0.00193504907656461, -0.03400847315788269, -0.009329626336693764, 0.06601957231760025, -0.002289334312081337, -0.04555022716522217, 0.05980035290122032, 0.015964163467288017, 0.019096944481134415, -0.015562997199594975, 0.03530685231089592, -0.0023852044250816107, 0.028160639107227325, -0.03927622362971306, -0.026660513132810593, 0.029495779424905777, -0.0307692252099514, 0.01822723262012005, -0.037883467972278595, -0.023584065958857536, 0.05979109928011894, 0.011215305887162685, 0.005511234048753977, -0.02688286267220974, -0.025625048205256462, 0.00004152813562541269, 0.038078755140304565, -0.0005011202301830053, -0.02866349369287491, 0.014578239060938358, 0.02590945176780224, 0.016826774924993515, 0.01782340742647648, 0.02827725186944008, 0.03237403184175491, -0.05687664821743965, -0.057854000478982925, -0.04992973059415817, -0.04074511304497719, 0.03583022579550743, 0.04188373312354088, -0.018994729965925217, 0.021660735830664635, -0.04255492985248566, 0.016781741753220558, 0.010160135105252266, 0.030037889257073402, -0.0019809389486908913, 0.05981490761041641, 0.004039139952510595, 0.04145612195134163, -0.040338873863220215, -0.021354008466005325, 0.11676418036222458, 0.0846124216914177, 0.00789415929466486, -0.06277893483638763, 0.03043716587126255, 0.00965555664151907, -0.024996520951390266, -0.01630742847919464, -0.005412581376731396, 0.014269108884036541, -0.026578975841403008, 0.03826940432190895, 0.04120158031582832, 0.004201624076813459, -0.02741198241710663, 0.03325846418738365, -0.048222802579402924, -0.015349254943430424, 0.01627519354224205, 0.024871589615941048, 0.009197061881422997, 0.019329549744725227, -0.020420745015144348, 0.0019084061495959759, -0.02820856124162674, -0.02787301316857338, -0.03834700956940651, -0.03802470117807388, 0.026775874197483063, -0.03906431049108505, -0.00016557994240429252, 0.0012381250271573663, 0.0337008573114872, -0.026592647656798363, -0.020445162430405617, -0.0030929772183299065, -0.009366106241941452, -0.026246171444654465, -0.012473874725401402, 0.0407753512263298, 0.0011397312628105283, -0.014587127603590488, 0.013292093761265278, -0.03270070627331734, -0.04829508811235428, -0.007237604819238186, -0.041781723499298096, 0.012353833764791489, 0.018675221130251884, -0.0011425280245020986, 0.015317823737859726, -0.005952471401542425, -0.007009176537394524, -0.05133586376905441, -0.009332461282610893, 0.025851376354694366, 0.035589393228292465, -0.005116409622132778, 0.01960681565105915, 0.014158451929688454, -0.006963940337300301, 0.04962395876646042, 0.008151060901582241, -0.004157943185418844, -0.035095617175102234, -0.013142881914973259, 0.0014042445691302419, 0.042808644473552704, 0.0018117523286491632, -0.016927065327763557, -0.017632899805903435, -0.022962598130106926, -0.04683506488800049, -0.06680858135223389, -0.005946043878793716, 0.008359846659004688, 0.028475692495703697, -0.010164341889321804, 0.014818660914897919, -0.028905756771564484, -0.07521185278892517, 0.02715775929391384, 0.015582103282213211, 0.010622627101838589, -0.027982370927929878, -0.0008230041130445898, 0.012080203741788864, 0.014593392610549927, 0.02426319755613804, -0.007736096624284983, -0.010372557677328587, 0.035901881754398346, -0.0005044421413913369, 0.03162277489900589, -0.04000851511955261, 0.01268642395734787, -0.013678225688636303, 0.017320195212960243, 0.0054242657497525215, 0.05472704395651817, 0.03779760003089905, 0.020192138850688934, -0.022233041003346443, 0.03101082518696785, -0.009424582123756409, 0.02708505466580391, 0.02862846851348877, -0.052747588604688644, 0.008172990754246712, 0.04824899882078171, 0.018994001671671867, -0.019767988473176956, -0.01802985742688179, -0.03960312530398369, -0.0035123524721711874, 0.023498430848121643, 0.0039024304132908583, -0.031198322772979736, 0.015122373588383198, -0.041240423917770386, 0.040692638605833054, -0.025024836882948875, -0.04017551615834236, 0.013686252757906914, 0.02852085418999195, -0.009361902251839638, -0.005055704619735479, -0.005065377335995436, 0.0060556624084711075, -0.025975825265049934, 0.0007740791770629585, 0.011094841174781322, 0.05758476257324219, 0.013197144493460655, -0.03719404712319374, -0.018674176186323166, 0.016386598348617554, 0.060050662606954575, -0.05069931596517563, -0.04230766370892525, 0.004802928771823645, -0.0487494021654129, -0.04669102281332016, 0.010347266681492329, -0.006689011584967375, 0.01396219339221716, -0.000026703288313001394, -0.008926170878112316, -0.02800322324037552, 0.02404618076980114, -0.009598982520401478, -0.017420625314116478, 0.01238442026078701, -0.022240715101361275, 0.0014699610183015466, -0.06810718029737473, 0.02219238504767418, 0.008493136614561081, -0.02813667245209217, 0.022936882451176643, 0.006167640443891287, -0.0010309708304703236, -0.039342250674963, 0.013318825513124466, 0.007497105281800032, 0.04566681757569313, 0.012832637876272202, 0.004246571566909552, 0.028976820409297943, 0.013916844502091408, -0.013082196936011314, 0.0037286144215613604, 0.01568441279232502, 0.04527844116091728, -0.11101801693439484, -0.02499440126121044, 0.023652808740735054, 0.03988570719957352, 0.01852148398756981, -0.07056090235710144, 0.007928984239697456, 0.02488926611840725, -0.06401301175355911, 0.016510771587491035, -0.0020167871844023466, 0.012984277680516243, -0.04874575883150101, 0.021427178755402565, -0.01593821868300438, 0.03937942162156105, 0.05145709216594696, 0.0015360380057245493, 0.01674502156674862, -0.0047693755477666855, -0.030024997889995575, -0.039564233273267746, 0.01658715307712555, -0.01560606062412262, -0.0389084629714489, -0.03919493407011032, 0.023760046809911728, -0.003966722171753645, -0.05082859843969345, -0.0011306668166071177, 0.012076811864972115, -0.02840324118733406, 0.012811918742954731, 0.03519471362233162, 0.028633104637265205, 0.03553325682878494, 0.035283688455820084, 0.011520582251250744, 0.03371918946504593, -0.009744848124682903, -0.030417321249842644, 0.018604479730129242, 0.02675071731209755, -0.007172024343162775, 0.021958623081445694, -0.03360437601804733, -0.02773432433605194, 0.020258227363228798, -0.022266093641519547, -0.017901752144098282, -0.0193584393709898, -0.00225666887126863, 0.0041819349862635136, -0.040048856288194656, 0.016877830028533936, -0.020136399194598198, -0.045406777411699295, 0.03646457940340042, 0.02784973941743374, 0.024301020428538322, -0.013692852109670639, 0.021609794348478317, -0.032986268401145935, 0.008470042608678341, 0.01275955606251955, 0.007755870930850506, -0.06010633334517479, 0.01049385778605938, 0.02061060257256031, -0.015597421675920486, 0.0038369607646018267, -0.0007056570611894131, -0.0020225453190505505, -0.0156573373824358, -0.012392254546284676, 0.008495463989675045, -0.0321795791387558, -0.006450865417718887, 0.007404639385640621, -0.10140224546194077, 0.026539644226431847, -0.00174521969165653, -0.03504304587841034, -0.0006568371900357306, -0.011292101815342903, -0.033828798681497574, 0.00925005879253149, 0.06332279741764069, 0.0013574124313890934, 0.005179852247238159, 0.011043517850339413, -0.003737812163308263, 0.0027045635506510735, -0.01874544844031334, 0.001810217509046197, -0.011688475497066975, 0.012192820198833942, 0.000260398315731436, -0.017490338534116745, 0.023309864103794098, 0.03735833987593651, 0.012056799605488777, 0.02213398367166519, -0.014493708498775959, 0.008799784816801548, 0.018571456894278526, 0.031897611916065216, -0.02459234930574894, -0.0059357499703764915, 0.06813564896583557, 0.016413021832704544, 0.0218063797801733, 0.02476036548614502, -0.036575086414813995, -0.07884246855974197, 0.00927410926669836, -0.08449919521808624, -0.029441537335515022, -0.011894771829247475, 0.013979930430650711, 0.04385242238640785, -0.027225175872445107, -0.0121002783998847, 0.05613431707024574, -0.035693008452653885, -0.018877411261200905, 0.02873566560447216, 0.03445691987872124, 0.04998375102877617, 0.0002784896350931376, 0.0069977599196136, 0.025271708145737648, 0.001173056080006063, 0.027908552438020706, -0.0020034692715853453, 0.01285779569298029, 0.010798901319503784, 0.009792144410312176, 0.0163973830640316, -0.029824478551745415, 0.02538772113621235, 0.03411245718598366, 0.027150658890604973, -0.020451730117201805, -0.055967528373003006, 0.04130185395479202, -0.01013594027608633, -0.014987302012741566, 0.0024259223137050867, -0.03372809290885925, 0.058481328189373016, -0.00365080195479095, -0.018003234639763832, -0.03609032556414604, 0.02782350406050682, -0.005364508368074894, -0.0015866855392232537, 0.012404030188918114, 0.0404309444129467, -0.015734689310193062, -0.015854546800255775, 0.017948614433407784, -0.012902135029435158, 0.010873719118535519, -0.030553171411156654, 0.04591359570622444, -0.00408073328435421, 0.002477515023201704, -0.030681641772389412, -0.038326796144247055, -0.06217328459024429, -0.008865500800311565, 0.037152256816625595, 0.0335703007876873, 0.016936561092734337, 0.0003121805493719876, -0.023077258840203285, -0.02206650748848915, 0.05987080931663513, -0.06293578445911407, -0.028706364333629608, 0.008709627203643322, -0.015434949658811092, 0.018092535436153412, -0.01716679520905018 ]
<p>This is not a question about implementation:</p> <p>I have a GLMER model with a significant three way interaction. Neither of the two way interactions or main effects are significant. I accept this model and leave all lower order effects in the model, but want to plot this three way interaction: x, y, and then z as colour in a ggplot. I predict responses of y based on data I generate for y and z using said model, but only using the significant fixed effects (the intercept and three way interaction), and plot x, y, z. Does this seem like an alright thing to do in order to communicate what the interaction means assuming I keep the lower order, non significant effects in the model? </p> <p>Thanks!</p>
74,247
[ -0.041560325771570206, 0.030686525627970695, 0.0011809997959062457, 0.034693725407123566, 0.048171453177928925, 0.030705982819199562, -0.015446179546415806, -0.010272108018398285, 0.03098653070628643, -0.012331584468483925, 0.03126015141606331, 0.008831631392240524, 0.08760224282741547, -0.004876481834799051, 0.015052816830575466, 0.012730737216770649, -0.0019059199839830399, -0.01814907230436802, -0.004717907402664423, -0.018790816888213158, -0.04151302948594093, 0.016019809991121292, -0.004451914224773645, 0.027314675971865654, -0.024683857336640358, 0.06308361887931824, 0.036910589784383774, 0.010869493708014488, 0.013965830206871033, 0.02109229378402233, -0.021211059764027596, -0.019823649898171425, -0.020742496475577354, 0.06541623920202255, 0.024442583322525024, -0.0035450768191367388, -0.02180069498717785, -0.016061151400208473, 0.0343635156750679, 0.005932016763836145, -0.018111782148480415, 0.009394639171659946, 0.007842406630516052, 0.04319555312395096, -0.005242189858108759, 0.0014999037375673652, -0.048321645706892014, -0.011284803040325642, 0.084980808198452, -0.020674429833889008, 0.05880262330174446, 0.002187115140259266, 0.02486562728881836, 0.027632012963294983, -0.03221948817372322, -0.00753895565867424, 0.06550213694572449, 0.06668895483016968, 0.005049918778240681, -0.003913821652531624, 0.004716240800917149, -0.039693683385849, 0.0021654574666172266, 0.0001162764965556562, -0.033602021634578705, 0.0017137560062110424, 0.020117344334721565, 0.0002009079762501642, 0.034892138093709946, -0.012829648330807686, -0.010894068516790867, -0.001149671501480043, 0.049471404403448105, -0.018600253388285637, 0.00690876180306077, -0.03508076071739197, 0.03353253751993179, -0.022698385640978813, 0.019310161471366882, 0.013783449307084084, -0.06945081055164337, -0.002938666846603155, -0.015560445375740528, 0.03492818772792816, -0.019527794793248177, -0.01126476563513279, 0.045774366706609726, -0.023103663697838783, 0.03261665254831314, 0.016630979254841805, -0.03080582246184349, 0.012980809435248375, 0.09398789703845978, 0.028242047876119614, -0.047264207154512405, 0.003484141081571579, -0.012840895913541317, 0.024709314107894897, 0.013869894668459892, 0.012184533290565014, -0.028797077015042305, -0.026699746027588844, -0.013704740442335606, 0.0533272847533226, -0.014119317755103111, -0.0057267844676971436, -0.04267266020178795, -0.02612883783876896, 0.01689275912940502, -0.053655922412872314, 0.008867880329489708, -0.016064170747995377, -0.013411370106041431, -0.0071445489302277565, 0.005673529114574194, -0.05784035101532936, 0.025711864233016968, 0.0026251040399074554, 0.059263795614242554, 0.05662781745195389, 0.0536343939602375, -0.02633587084710598, 0.023750966414809227, -0.01662513241171837, -0.044470932334661484, -0.001723271794617176, 0.018427293747663498, -0.022581296041607857, -0.050751276314258575, 0.05220165476202965, 0.03749716281890869, -0.02752930298447609, 0.004832088947296143, -0.02701953984797001, 0.006648552604019642, -0.023410242050886154, -0.0566730834543705, -0.03217856213450432, -0.00012038007116643712, -0.02792561799287796, 0.007438869681209326, -0.037345193326473236, -0.053626663982868195, 0.021717596799135208, 0.05341333895921707, 0.0058894832618534565, -0.0037544709630310535, -0.00036463479045778513, 0.06424935907125473, -0.0009643915691412985, -0.046031404286623, 0.0069312904961407185, -0.036550696939229965, -0.05007145181298256, -0.022427193820476532, -0.04768185690045357, 0.040108080953359604, 0.010923721827566624, 0.0021659457124769688, 0.009035196155309677, 0.047481242567300797, -0.00915539264678955, 0.04581036791205406, 0.023182036355137825, 0.004924586974084377, 0.0023763717617839575, 0.08155489712953568, -0.03430410102009773, 0.04796470329165459, -0.0038853853475302458, 0.0063882009126245975, 0.041417691856622696, 0.0026749635580927134, 0.07419134676456451, 0.004668510518968105, -0.016600893810391426, 0.015492049045860767, -0.03649592027068138, 0.023800481110811234, -0.004586745053529739, -0.016298845410346985, -0.044548045843839645, -0.021464359015226364, -0.021044118329882622, 0.009614108130335808, 0.015660466626286507, -0.018627630546689034, -0.03775717318058014, 0.08207310736179352, -0.04802209511399269, -0.04155086353421211, -0.05120578780770302, 0.005619253497570753, -0.006064021959900856, -0.035182151943445206, 0.004738290794193745, 0.01372057106345892, 0.04716849327087402, -0.001149489195086062, -0.007026392500847578, -0.0050568655133247375, 0.008653738535940647, 0.03650309517979622, -0.019958823919296265, -0.025576667860150337, 0.013549884781241417, 0.046800412237644196, -0.026999114081263542, 0.043094418942928314, -0.04208685830235481, -0.0201241597533226, 0.04080643877387047, 0.0038802267517894506, -0.004650536924600601, -0.005274500697851181, -0.03564123064279556, 0.000020503028281382285, 0.01730746403336525, -0.035784393548965454, 0.06551627069711685, -0.079275943338871, 0.07603857666254044, 0.07781672477722168, -0.031019190326333046, 0.014899952337145805, 0.007717377971857786, 0.011608910746872425, 0.020518075674772263, -0.007145442999899387, 0.0026480667293071747, -0.03837846219539642, -0.04750583693385124, 0.06774385273456573, 0.007074424531310797, -0.044089868664741516, 0.012361984699964523, 0.04486727714538574, -0.02130662277340889, 0.04363687336444855, 0.050792112946510315, 0.018312394618988037, 0.013212933205068111, 0.019963646307587624, 0.03669089078903198, 0.04175058379769325, -0.02971985749900341, 0.03672831133008003, -0.0058544594794511795, 0.033473946154117584, -0.01424447912722826, -0.04470600187778473, 0.05142434686422348, -0.009203198365867138, 0.010931001976132393, -0.013501929119229317, -0.003911889623850584, 0.02449807897210121, -0.029192926362156868, 0.04097793996334076, 0.05385372042655945, 0.005401740316301584, -0.021115461364388466, 0.04487261921167374, -0.0009276694618165493, -0.004720880649983883, 0.04269281402230263, -0.08782699704170227, -0.012394825927913189, 0.03576884791254997, -0.009232623502612114, 0.016530420631170273, -0.022020826116204262, -0.031054634600877762, -0.05283183604478836, 0.021474139764904976, -0.002136710798367858, -0.0041184574365615845, 0.0194587092846632, -0.04605470970273018, -0.06453254073858261, 0.0137751130387187, 0.029670586809515953, 0.030501458793878555, 0.03382452204823494, -0.03944316506385803, 0.018204350024461746, -0.0489199236035347, -0.06837201863527298, -0.006084608379751444, -0.014932049438357353, -0.021142490208148956, -0.02155681513249874, -0.02626938931643963, -0.060227908194065094, -0.040693845599889755, -0.0344824455678463, 0.01567261293530464, -0.00628865510225296, -0.047873079776763916, 0.026982588693499565, 0.026577722281217575, -0.03318939357995987, -0.014059544540941715, -0.017590442672371864, -0.025707021355628967, 0.03289787843823433, -0.0027687218971550465, 0.007111118640750647, -0.007060659117996693, 0.03806176409125328, 0.010234472341835499, -0.08250434696674347, -0.016115307807922363, -0.05508939549326897, -0.059148408472537994, 0.014231202192604542, 0.02935222163796425, 0.03698566555976868, -0.024276897311210632, 0.013654516078531742, 0.0399395190179348, 0.008680282160639763, 0.001817120355553925, -0.018352124840021133, -0.05381679907441139, -0.03681140020489693, -0.052837830036878586, 0.007561773061752319, 0.005779068451374769, 0.02940984070301056, 0.008502129465341568, -0.03909582272171974, 0.013287972658872604, 0.020322024822235107, 0.03339608758687973, -0.029501205310225487, 0.031808555126190186, 0.01626678742468357, 0.006261094007641077, 0.018950046971440315, 0.029961617663502693, -0.0264218021184206, 0.02693154849112034, 0.007555045187473297, 0.015605789609253407, -0.00031621329253539443, -0.028098346665501595, 0.015665272250771523, -0.011045677587389946, 0.05362313240766525, 0.027442580088973045, 0.019550900906324387, 0.057058122009038925, -0.02596982941031456, -0.01806279644370079, -0.012252438813447952, 0.07448548823595047, -0.015343564562499523, 0.012337329797446728, 0.041072994470596313, -0.0026911962777376175, -0.020201681181788445, 0.04288400337100029, -0.0015674564056098461, -0.023354193195700645, 0.015007664449512959, 0.011564861983060837, -0.003955191001296043, 0.03522999584674835, -0.0008230886305682361, -0.0399007648229599, -0.014445760287344456, -0.01644679717719555, 0.006632524076849222, -0.052074432373046875, -0.009658421389758587, -0.03482097014784813, 0.01921379379928112, 0.024812856689095497, 0.0381266251206398, 0.0065049235709011555, 0.005305240862071514, -0.031828898936510086, 0.003928679041564465, -0.06279244273900986, 0.03797811642289162, -0.0007497109472751617, 0.019078277051448822, 0.004374295473098755, -0.0036354451440274715, -0.001044776407070458, -0.03290518745779991, -0.005397480446845293, -0.0011852090246975422, -0.0030381858814507723, -0.01715664379298687, -0.01176853571087122, -0.012234553694725037, -0.015393721871078014, 0.007552823983132839, 0.026859929785132408, 0.02725415676832199, -0.0014105436857789755, 0.025537338107824326, 0.032592251896858215, -0.04339483007788658, -0.03226156160235405, -0.022694462910294533, -0.01738811656832695, 0.036269739270210266, 0.03192542493343353, 0.015683218836784363, 0.03266238421201706, -0.04408056288957596, 0.025209560990333557, 0.019001562148332596, 0.04871834069490433, -0.01926768384873867, -0.0008060393738560379, -0.007437109015882015, -0.040087662637233734, -0.019699200987815857, 0.02789120003581047, 0.0443279966711998, -0.00860646553337574, 0.020911334082484245, 0.05003117024898529, 0.006007571239024401, -0.024202831089496613, 0.016939297318458557, 0.05734099820256233, 0.022709980607032776, -0.03934231400489807, -0.02647571638226509, 0.032425422221422195, -0.009998404420912266, -0.004672240000218153, 0.010927130468189716, 0.035151246935129166, 0.020560845732688904, 0.011665771715342999, -0.013567102141678333, -0.00901887658983469, -0.0045415791682899, 0.013060043565928936, 0.02228357456624508, 0.03676358237862587, -0.010119927115738392, -0.04390527307987213, 0.015471292659640312, 0.04777199402451515, -0.0186937116086483, -0.002503554802387953, -0.020322751253843307, -0.06964659690856934, 0.02244117297232151, 0.06299299001693726, 0.02734542079269886, -0.00948941521346569, -0.03690484166145325, -0.058177292346954346, -0.02645193599164486, 0.01032993197441101, -0.029495973140001297, 0.007658005226403475, -0.059784986078739166, -0.0013569872826337814, -0.034934330731630325, 0.009611431509256363, -0.067496158182621, 0.033573102205991745, -0.03145608305931091, -0.004453483037650585, 0.017559217289090157, -0.011581499129533768, -0.03773268684744835, 0.03810529410839081, 0.020285680890083313, 0.014251261949539185, -0.0039923228323459625, 0.001247742329724133, 0.04356175661087036, 0.00035602558637037873, -0.029747942462563515, -0.07101967930793762, 0.02647135779261589, 0.002752043306827545, 0.030822357162833214, 0.07078411430120468, -0.008794446475803852, -0.022055387496948242, 0.022202031686902046, 0.04776371642947197, 0.04270284250378609, -0.009030481800436974, -0.015549173578619957, 0.04781511425971985, 0.04113771766424179, -0.0020526021253317595, 0.05095943063497543, 0.07500699907541275, 0.008114403113722801, -0.008127995766699314, -0.008620298467576504, 0.02163979783654213, -0.0548972450196743, -0.01513169426470995, -0.026385005563497543, -0.005477840546518564, -0.03224639222025871, 0.017218273133039474, 0.0004954304895363748, 0.016937050968408585, -0.05121593177318573, -0.01073396299034357, 0.009104009717702866, -0.0017538412939757109, -0.006346890702843666, -0.03931901603937149, -0.033323515206575394, 0.008169999346137047, -0.029939400032162666, 0.006211381871253252, 0.001052425941452384, -0.02681831829249859, -0.017799513414502144, -0.011610188521444798, -0.03574976697564125, 0.017641499638557434, -0.018098218366503716, -0.006405974272638559, -0.0037616074550896883, -0.03781041502952576, -0.018499495461583138, -0.013820843771100044, 0.04117361828684807, -0.0330331027507782, -0.04513147100806236, 0.0015082117170095444, 0.04846850782632828, 0.012802433222532272, -0.006024067755788565, -0.044366031885147095, 0.06871900707483292, -0.01955605484545231, 0.016803395003080368, -0.04969869554042816, -0.03903825953602791, 0.003142010886222124, 0.009172755293548107, 0.03113781288266182, -0.017349563539028168, -0.0022256786469370127, -0.021654171869158745, 0.012991233728826046, -0.0016736252000555396, 0.012190856039524078, -0.03728574141860008, 0.0028098642360419035, -0.009669799357652664, -0.001906486926600337, 0.040273819118738174, 0.004388474393635988, 0.0071962554939091206, 0.0351116806268692, -0.0353112630546093, -0.025869231671094894, -0.004271123092621565, -0.004879244137555361, -0.014964105561375618, 0.015094004571437836, -0.02929355576634407, -0.004352688789367676, 0.036596041172742844, 0.0042855339124798775, -0.03161724656820297, -0.006771162152290344, 0.006642788182944059, 0.004172283690422773, -0.03854701668024063, -0.0162641704082489, -0.013417857699096203, -0.0022236667573451996, -0.04190688580274582, 0.010196751914918423, 0.00094972102669999, 0.019723761826753616, 0.039677225053310394, -0.019818168133497238, -0.03844625875353813, -0.000022289767002803273, 0.04734637588262558, 0.03797737881541252, 0.014716073870658875, -0.03117324225604534, -0.0045554847456514835, 0.009079650044441223, -0.041321344673633575, -0.009760918095707893, 0.009905019775032997, 0.047116149216890335, -0.013098853640258312, -0.03008774295449257, -0.00892348401248455, 0.004446592181921005, 0.03419199213385582, -0.04084862396121025, 0.047608524560928345, 0.011959994211792946, -0.02248048409819603, -0.01214179303497076, -0.04391954839229584, -0.016786323860287666, -0.00040360871935263276, 0.0078027518466115, 0.041682470589876175, 0.00030063060694374144, 0.016701094806194305, 0.016310475766658783, -0.007363368757069111, 0.018345512449741364, 0.04059875011444092, 0.030414294451475143, -0.019991198554635048, 0.018973305821418762, 0.002470420440658927, -0.08020465075969696, 0.04048047959804535, -0.03973614051938057, 0.04361635446548462, -0.011293106712400913, -0.02764618955552578, 0.028438150882720947, 0.05425206944346428, -0.009818279184401035, -0.05753493681550026, -0.03242313861846924, -0.04989498853683472, 0.023769136518239975, 0.03329712525010109, -0.024052442982792854, 0.015260995365679264, -0.002370900008827448, 0.056445326656103134, -0.03162045776844025, 0.010448319837450981, -0.013344576582312584, -0.09638937562704086, -0.01766621693968773, -0.0315772220492363, 0.0097197275608778, 0.03888456150889397, -0.00848439522087574, -0.010733014903962612, 0.0025222899857908487, -0.034299906343221664, -0.00491975387558341, -0.02160806581377983, 0.05665774270892143, 0.01594596728682518, 0.033224064856767654, 0.0022459474857896566, -0.012750466354191303, 0.019964376464486122, -0.0017558274557814002, 0.12707573175430298, 0.07362355291843414, 0.02065489999949932, -0.0962907001376152, 0.05743066221475601, -0.01885319873690605, -0.02734111249446869, -0.027942724525928497, 0.019874917343258858, 0.011972572654485703, -0.012637382373213768, 0.0014915051870048046, 0.04933036118745804, 0.01843562163412571, 0.015915410593152046, 0.0533239021897316, -0.04448267072439194, -0.02929464355111122, 0.007206708658486605, 0.036235760897397995, -0.03024098090827465, -0.007449320983141661, -0.0768960565328598, 0.0011016711359843612, -0.030129708349704742, -0.005789805669337511, -0.01205886248499155, -0.00510436249896884, 0.016784805804491043, 0.043490633368492126, -0.01435688603669405, 0.009304805658757687, 0.0021445320453494787, 0.02105659991502762, 0.003347547724843025, 0.0017444489058107138, 0.028151914477348328, -0.014861696399748325, 0.04338231310248375, 0.02335144393146038, -0.033317361027002335, -0.023871848359704018, -0.027175556868314743, -0.011212674900889397, -0.045708950608968735, -0.03213777020573616, 0.0035377410240471363, 0.027567755430936813, 0.013970727100968361, -0.05559201538562775, -0.022470323368906975, -0.002411698689684272, 0.030213268473744392, -0.033852141350507736, -0.04117970913648605, 0.012017537839710712, 0.020462917163968086, -0.029990239068865776, 0.004921155050396919, -0.004925645887851715, 0.0077981362119317055, -0.0001312139502260834, 0.02885064110159874, 0.05850335210561752, -0.028941530734300613, 0.01230408251285553, -0.034400422126054764, 0.0476321205496788, 0.044676173478364944, -0.04664392024278641, 0.04802080988883972, -0.017794732004404068, -0.03494752570986748, -0.03208540752530098, -0.002830987563356757, 0.03637321665883064, -0.02943853661417961, -0.009147395379841328, 0.021159352734684944, -0.048178188502788544, -0.012910776771605015, 0.024439938366413116, 0.021521322429180145, -0.00940991472452879, -0.02707207389175892, 0.0010773373069241643, 0.02620193548500538, 0.0405956506729126, 0.005261767655611038, -0.01873859204351902, -0.012642880901694298, 0.04565301910042763, 0.021670449525117874, -0.05159338191151619, -0.036292627453804016, 0.03607407584786415, -0.04868912324309349, -0.016533616930246353, -0.0074632251635193825, 0.07747277617454529, 0.002995213260874152, 0.02968803234398365, -0.012625804170966148, 0.0540589764714241, -0.01072245929390192, 0.019589463248848915, 0.042496610432863235, -0.04975920915603638, 0.031231451779603958, -0.01783573254942894, 0.0025591040030121803, -0.005922223441302776, -0.04397174343466759, -0.015257768332958221, -0.024680178612470627, -0.004661159124225378, -0.004037962295114994, -0.019750310108065605, -0.002263006055727601, -0.0010563090909272432, 0.006325938273221254, -0.03959106281399727, -0.022025519981980324, -0.07251527160406113, -0.024511782452464104, 0.016683591529726982, -0.030479826033115387, 0.02890809439122677, 0.015147222205996513, -0.02253975346684456, 0.031203126534819603, 0.010102534666657448, -0.0006659173523075879, 0.0016878660535439849, -0.04703554883599281, 0.021809445694088936, 0.004809919279068708, 0.05593404546380043, -0.0029864937532693148, -0.0271400585770607, 0.03694567829370499, -0.028263168409466743, -0.01598551496863365, -0.0017005191184580326, -0.033955883234739304, 0.04599359259009361, 0.015557963401079178, -0.0058984034694731236, -0.021298907697200775, 0.033109817653894424, -0.011884300969541073, 0.0016171698225662112, 0.007791389245539904, 0.011444376781582832, -0.00011528336472110823, -0.017879286780953407, 0.02515331096947193, 0.002082700375467539, 0.00873967632651329, 0.0379561111330986, 0.044881466776132584, 0.0378638431429863, -0.027106450870633125, -0.0005267244996502995, 0.007659483700990677, 0.020446717739105225, -0.00942123681306839, -0.01991110108792782, 0.03184669464826584, 0.05647497996687889, -0.04595623537898064, 0.043673183768987656, -0.004085594322532415, 0.01901080086827278, -0.07123337686061859, -0.019704287871718407, 0.014882761053740978, 0.01395129133015871, 0.026952508836984634, -0.06664982438087463, 0.04664681479334831, -0.010918105021119118, -0.043532587587833405, -0.00033714668825268745, -0.018024947494268417, -0.025118954479694366, -0.03807352855801582, 0.006045119371265173, -0.021652769297361374, -0.009886998683214188, 0.03448280692100525, 0.0013050055131316185, 0.022395767271518707, 0.004552144557237625, -0.0034503573551774025, 0.003239820711314678, 0.03853807970881462, 0.014411785639822483, -0.01888951100409031, -0.07815048098564148, 0.037951160222291946, -0.011339130811393261, -0.031024741008877754, 0.025969579815864563, 0.015483759343624115, 0.004464349243789911, 0.0010716380784288049, 0.03269128128886223, 0.013427750207483768, 0.06587348878383636, 0.021311862394213676, 0.012333384715020657, -0.01205032505095005, 0.001143162720836699, 0.04417417198419571, 0.034809891134500504, -0.012186267413198948, 0.014456181786954403, -0.03768625110387802, -0.029718203470110893, -0.03464382514357567, -0.009748142212629318, -0.030035361647605896, 0.008666809648275375, -0.036897920072078705, -0.017657682299613953, -0.007480998989194632, -0.04172537103295326, 0.02427661418914795, 0.004950938280671835, -0.012721700593829155, 0.020184196531772614, 0.05274864286184311, -0.014856526628136635, -0.03600355610251427, -0.01870431937277317, -0.058732032775878906, -0.015359656885266304, -0.028728099539875984, 0.016206087544560432, -0.010307309217751026, -0.008274221792817116, -0.005591602995991707, -0.0058383578434586525, -0.026449576020240784, 0.019327452406287193, -0.06479977816343307, 0.039161209017038345, -0.044983599334955215, 0.01635548658668995, 0.011363125406205654, -0.03782157227396965, 0.02866906113922596, -0.08586785942316055, 0.0341150127351284, 0.04214992746710777, 0.019632305949926376, -0.045738689601421356, 0.0102682551369071, -0.05278666317462921, 0.0092025026679039, 0.03806766867637634, -0.015043660067021847, -0.005890109576284885, -0.030327295884490013, 0.0687805786728859, 0.02785586193203926, -0.027092838659882545, 0.03152045980095863, 0.02407461404800415, -0.02070247195661068, -0.018499398604035378, -0.004575205035507679, 0.008845880627632141, 0.027130357921123505, 0.046690233051776886, 0.008949747309088707, 0.0069869766011834145, 0.0058166938833892345, -0.0374552458524704, 0.05185294151306152, 0.009643088094890118, -0.015615633688867092, 0.04663259908556938, 0.007357012014836073, 0.02650579810142517, 0.04808082431554794, 0.01846604235470295, -0.03504312410950661, 0.044051676988601685, -0.021260833367705345, -0.01823042519390583, 0.018051179125905037, 0.0021734938491135836, 0.010341070592403412, -0.0647021010518074, 0.0089495200663805, -0.011572806164622307, -0.023989927023649216, 0.0259399451315403, 0.03573371097445488, 0.019160626456141472, 0.05327848345041275, 0.024511566385626793, -0.017064768821001053, -0.011781398206949234, 0.02076641097664833, 0.028456978499889374, 0.02036844752728939, 0.0033571082167327404, 0.017959216609597206, -0.00013986043632030487, 0.03616924583911896, -0.005076806992292404, -0.0027572333347052336, 0.022563891485333443, 0.04651520028710365, 0.027162492275238037, -0.00509748887270689, 0.03225855529308319, 0.02359473519027233, 0.04500202834606171, 0.004536316264420748, 0.03009425289928913, 0.03363515064120293, -0.08612772077322006, 0.001226358930580318, -0.02677597478032112, -0.010017085820436478, -0.04566728696227074, 0.016714872792363167, 0.013397790491580963, 0.015690498054027557, -0.01301652379333973, 0.0024729056749492884, 0.007234164979308844, -0.04441958665847778, 0.008977883495390415, -0.0023916559293866158, 0.04024092108011246, -0.043633271008729935, -0.00661848857998848, 0.019683310762047768, 0.006787317339330912, -0.03400846943259239, -0.022299960255622864, 0.051610589027404785, 0.036299753934144974, 0.03170391172170639, -0.03925180807709694, 0.0035414097364991903, -0.008689329028129578, 0.010514024645090103, -0.05745048075914383, -0.028747033327817917, -0.01807839423418045, 0.022964488714933395, 0.02064981497824192, 0.005464460700750351 ]
<p>Is it possible to fit a data curve to another data curve?</p> <p>Please see this plot</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/2iHKM.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I do not have the model for the black data curve or I don't want to model it. But I want to see how the red data curve fits/matches with the black one. Is it possible? I am looking for a non-parametric solution or a solution that can be arrived at even without plotting the two curves.</p>
74,248
[ -0.0374431274831295, 0.004943205509334803, -0.011561664752662182, 0.013189881108701229, 0.010272030718624592, 0.02053917944431305, -0.02222057618200779, -0.033944375813007355, 0.023416239768266678, -0.010268015787005424, 0.033881232142448425, 0.03110308200120926, 0.06020162254571915, 0.00759518425911665, 0.019981155171990395, 0.009563268162310123, -0.0077307154424488544, 0.03102058731019497, 0.009603399783372879, -0.008004232309758663, 0.021996714174747467, 0.018102973699569702, 0.010218184441328049, 0.011111922562122345, -0.010430928319692612, 0.021409563720226288, 0.057772424072027206, -0.012790735810995102, -0.030864236876368523, 0.06568395346403122, -0.041049759835004807, -0.037638310343027115, -0.0011841143714264035, 0.09953341633081436, 0.027669435366988182, 0.0040910616517066956, -0.020640380680561066, -0.047984834760427475, -0.006128925364464521, 0.01391681469976902, -0.03452273830771446, -0.023267950862646103, 0.022352153435349464, 0.047676220536231995, 0.004796299617737532, 0.015540932305157185, -0.006828834768384695, -0.046276871114969254, 0.03998693451285362, -0.037511344999074936, 0.09702522307634354, -0.019592922180891037, 0.042230404913425446, 0.07232535630464554, -0.024162139743566513, -0.026292357593774796, 0.07013928145170212, 0.08818326890468597, -0.047324132174253464, -0.03387654572725296, -0.0012389926705509424, -0.0013806609204038978, -0.0025295240338891745, 0.016383660957217216, -0.03796301409602165, 0.04358899965882301, -0.02134108915925026, -0.0015093295369297266, 0.0009930861415341496, -0.030998406931757927, 0.02534891478717327, 0.02658519521355629, 0.04368746653199196, -0.024537084624171257, 0.0046221474185585976, -0.03504202887415886, -0.01181751023977995, 0.02580554224550724, 0.05583696439862251, 0.04374424368143082, -0.029355978593230247, 0.007935328409075737, 0.019094185903668404, 0.020355885848402977, 0.012953259982168674, -0.012509329244494438, 0.05354541540145874, -0.016124986112117767, 0.01787358894944191, 0.011789018288254738, 0.010217138566076756, 0.00564894825220108, 0.028852401301264763, -0.01290810015052557, 0.008491311222314835, 0.007801825646311045, 0.0035564186982810497, 0.03905481472611427, 0.02206762321293354, -0.02842140756547451, -0.0022726517636328936, -0.034654401242733, -0.0023804318625479937, 0.040297504514455795, 0.004473570268601179, -0.002662111772224307, 0.023485319688916206, 0.027127737179398537, 0.0015792035264894366, -0.0003944326308555901, -0.03485677391290665, 0.002456173300743103, 0.036663029342889786, -0.02672841027379036, 0.020864177495241165, -0.015225687995553017, -0.04110756888985634, -0.013080443255603313, 0.06900376826524734, 0.046626877039670944, 0.0550680011510849, -0.03274080157279968, 0.020421801134943962, -0.00932314433157444, -0.01619832031428814, -0.020220402628183365, 0.006330240983515978, -0.010578115470707417, -0.029231708496809006, 0.0173956286162138, -0.02230721153318882, -0.013401500880718231, 0.01861933432519436, -0.009003271348774433, 0.02851298823952675, -0.0016714558005332947, -0.07414699345827103, -0.048062749207019806, -0.005713135469704866, 0.011299182660877705, 0.02763686329126358, -0.040230847895145416, 0.0070799412205815315, 0.03567854315042496, 0.06076826527714729, 0.011514205485582352, 0.01971040479838848, -0.00030366238206624985, 0.014252834022045135, -0.034501392394304276, 0.017602480947971344, -0.002594913821667433, 0.0032403944060206413, -0.010432492010295391, -0.023859934881329536, -0.07788682729005814, -0.003838189644739032, 0.033958613872528076, -0.022816451266407967, -0.008716931566596031, 0.04938763007521629, 0.03574775531888008, -0.019411858171224594, 0.012407446280121803, 0.021075597032904625, 0.006490145344287157, 0.0560944490134716, -0.023698991164565086, -0.01934225670993328, -0.010282186791300774, 0.0000825970564619638, 0.03471760079264641, 0.0022549424320459366, 0.03456512466073036, 0.037208523601293564, -0.006624981295317411, -0.006892413832247257, -0.011264321394264698, 0.007654631044715643, 0.020263707265257835, -0.04267031326889992, -0.03891181945800781, -0.030306540429592133, -0.005626593250781298, 0.027976900339126587, 0.05903978645801544, 0.018814224749803543, -0.012126835994422436, 0.06521971523761749, -0.0596342571079731, -0.02927681803703308, -0.04357511177659035, 0.013810518197715282, -0.014406273141503334, -0.02708691731095314, 0.0008097733953036368, 0.030881527811288834, 0.004181430209428072, -0.012252848595380783, -0.024370288476347923, -0.0016880995826795697, -0.005869061686098576, 0.032678473740816116, -0.01763463206589222, -0.004940004553645849, 0.06534251570701599, 0.03897721692919731, -0.023705866187810898, 0.03398844227194786, -0.0728355124592781, -0.03228618577122688, 0.03191560134291649, -0.02948439121246338, 0.002932392992079258, -0.03651369735598564, 0.012366383336484432, 0.03133586049079895, 0.04720301181077957, -0.007167253643274307, 0.035344719886779785, -0.012977950274944305, 0.07799718528985977, 0.046196211129426956, 0.020962750539183617, -0.009587445296347141, 0.009125860407948494, 0.017742706462740898, 0.03699110448360443, -0.04022601619362831, -0.008781194686889648, -0.03474486991763115, -0.0015516115818172693, -0.015867838636040688, 0.018415240570902824, -0.049491703510284424, -0.013122890144586563, 0.06520797312259674, 0.019979864358901978, 0.001373626058921218, 0.01254953257739544, -0.006040827836841345, -0.011532247066497803, -0.001862900797277689, -0.00032563626882620156, 0.014804303646087646, -0.003217753255739808, 0.004606333561241627, -0.004192917142063379, 0.05866068974137306, -0.03542818874120712, -0.009559981524944305, 0.046797461807727814, -0.004475772380828857, 0.0045417058281600475, 0.01556845661252737, 0.009482433088123798, 0.0426364541053772, -0.04369410499930382, 0.01666872203350067, 0.059789273887872696, -0.0027354524936527014, -0.02003214694559574, 0.0375186912715435, 0.005335220135748386, 0.006833644583821297, 0.035982463508844376, 0.021519020199775696, -0.008623206987977028, 0.014619027264416218, -0.02437199279665947, -0.00033002212876453996, -0.006637506186962128, -0.03772702440619469, -0.049739737063646317, 0.01790894754230976, -0.00566326268017292, 0.034828681498765945, 0.02421916276216507, -0.03711986541748047, -0.0589689165353775, 0.012313701212406158, 0.009509038180112839, 0.010271911509335041, 0.010261163115501404, -0.033182207494974136, 0.004122172482311726, -0.02857128158211708, -0.0159690510481596, 0.019105609506368637, -0.002733861096203327, 0.012792897410690784, 0.029935359954833984, -0.033108364790678024, -0.04380890354514122, -0.02400125376880169, -0.03347892686724663, 0.002750660525634885, -0.026319436728954315, -0.027489785104990005, 0.022059233859181404, -0.011014992371201515, -0.0695435032248497, 0.03603770211338997, -0.031108787283301353, -0.00900561735033989, -0.022402657195925713, 0.03807811439037323, 0.025183409452438354, 0.0006654942408204079, 0.04789906367659569, 0.02454543299973011, -0.027154406532645226, 0.007864231243729591, -0.054474812000989914, -0.02598971500992775, 0.032948654145002365, 0.003884068690240383, 0.026640424504876137, 0.008724757470190525, -0.011281724087893963, 0.058183565735816956, 0.005416860803961754, -0.03691152483224869, -0.07893100380897522, -0.012056555598974228, -0.06232808530330658, -0.013926621526479721, 0.01865903101861477, 0.031940579414367676, -0.009081289172172546, 0.005599617026746273, -0.005627653561532497, 0.03259683772921562, 0.06450100988149643, 0.004965602420270443, -0.0012110235402360559, 0.020032813772559166, 0.044657256454229355, 0.0021943259052932262, 0.032102540135383606, -0.0003086016804445535, -0.02414112351834774, 0.03713628277182579, -0.001193499774672091, 0.025447357445955276, 0.03972815349698067, -0.04745111241936684, 0.0006585842929780483, 0.006359586957842112, -0.0004908715491183102, -0.041616860777139664, 0.008632082492113113, 0.021181318908929825, -0.024981174618005753, -0.01572335883975029, 0.03891391679644585, 0.07262025028467178, 0.021487995982170105, -0.008658232167363167, 0.07171902060508728, 0.004638021346181631, -0.018115654587745667, -0.006261011119931936, -0.03385711461305618, -0.01237402018159628, 0.03278253600001335, -0.009884398430585861, -0.043038953095674515, 0.04371149465441704, 0.032030485570430756, 0.02687045745551586, -0.015816334635019302, -0.03005090355873108, 0.028194740414619446, -0.07041067630052567, -0.025200074538588524, -0.036640334874391556, 0.05476030707359314, 0.009523522108793259, 0.032770365476608276, 0.034138023853302, -0.0008771317079663277, 0.048469558358192444, -0.017128832638263702, -0.07289601862430573, 0.05282065272331238, -0.011418198235332966, -0.014243271201848984, 0.01641496829688549, -0.016913671046495438, 0.0306021049618721, -0.03552138805389404, 0.022476371377706528, -0.004229843616485596, 0.023385468870401382, -0.048446495085954666, -0.0010440930491313338, -0.015764499083161354, -0.020846378058195114, 0.01443643867969513, 0.011464904993772507, 0.005547665990889072, -0.011226046830415726, 0.037147291004657745, 0.037796955555677414, 0.013066921383142471, -0.024795006960630417, -0.030732478946447372, 0.021438032388687134, 0.01996094547212124, 0.04421624913811684, 0.019579190760850906, 0.033473651856184006, -0.04067576304078102, 0.006241356022655964, -0.002770692575722933, 0.042851414531469345, 0.041196245700120926, -0.028559936210513115, -0.02066839300096035, -0.04278087615966797, -0.032187942415475845, -0.0337010882794857, 0.058969154953956604, -0.015713242813944817, -0.00386459706351161, 0.033950433135032654, 0.02680680714547634, -0.015309722162783146, -0.013640332967042923, 0.05069595202803612, 0.050107959657907486, 0.022757038474082947, -0.05928051099181175, -0.03555895388126373, -0.049765199422836304, 0.014096460305154324, -0.0002448402519803494, 0.011219307780265808, -0.006192658096551895, 0.0312730148434639, 0.053024522960186005, 0.03260286897420883, -0.014049394056200981, -0.026142645627260208, 0.013718239031732082, 0.04044058918952942, -0.0047180261462926865, -0.029576733708381653, 0.05154913291335106, 0.061310138553380966, 0.026476407423615456, -0.003023554338142276, -0.011484012939035892, -0.14107216894626617, -0.026008211076259613, 0.03674982860684395, 0.010439267382025719, -0.024436011910438538, -0.021221576258540154, -0.050457511097192764, -0.0025017396546900272, 0.04298904165625572, -0.022131001576781273, 0.02435184270143509, -0.0012593967840075493, 0.030442984774708748, -0.022631123661994934, -0.026161035522818565, -0.03802734985947609, 0.043949343264102936, -0.009867100976407528, -0.039991505444049835, -0.027269069105386734, -0.03898857906460762, -0.015132221393287182, 0.030887257307767868, 0.03370043262839317, 0.06090126931667328, -0.016093185171484947, -0.01862526312470436, -0.0034605031833052635, 0.023639341816306114, -0.010321731679141521, -0.07722053676843643, 0.033866964280605316, -0.005391428247094154, -0.031021926552057266, 0.025895513594150543, 0.002169023733586073, -0.0076920753344893456, 0.024504676461219788, -0.014219275675714016, -0.022949522361159325, 0.021955709904432297, -0.04117079824209213, 0.040288008749485016, 0.05236436054110527, 0.005796580575406551, 0.030405180528759956, 0.046799276024103165, 0.0038426807150244713, -0.043606605380773544, -0.03151023015379906, 0.02991119772195816, -0.02962421625852585, -0.050406187772750854, -0.028036542236804962, -0.009483159519731998, -0.004235391970723867, 0.011361772194504738, 0.0032580785918980837, 0.024758275598287582, -0.049797289073467255, -0.030869241803884506, 0.002632643561810255, 0.012905973941087723, -0.0022086522076278925, 0.013238380663096905, -0.01960659585893154, 0.010656130500137806, 0.021255580708384514, -0.04515741765499115, 0.008057520724833012, 0.01604877971112728, -0.020855257287621498, 0.02573218010365963, -0.03821422904729843, 0.02787836082279682, -0.0342269204556942, -0.01272539421916008, 0.008864903822541237, -0.035277415066957474, -0.014183051884174347, -0.017008092254400253, 0.028157953172922134, 0.0022896023001521826, -0.02032698132097721, 0.02719900757074356, 0.006298058666288853, -0.010978629812598228, 0.028761789202690125, -0.054121386259794235, 0.03846953436732292, -0.00022161126253195107, -0.0313304141163826, -0.06346888095140457, -0.03985615074634552, 0.021425889804959297, -0.017197860404849052, -0.03237022086977959, -0.03544573485851288, 0.0008391258306801319, -0.016012415289878845, -0.017891131341457367, 0.004651604685932398, 0.029192905873060226, -0.011114378459751606, -0.01806456595659256, -0.024708028882741928, -0.01967039331793785, 0.03553413972258568, 0.0011735346633940935, -0.0034203927498310804, 0.0064412374049425125, -0.024838460609316826, -0.03637179732322693, 0.005123041570186615, 0.04117013141512871, -0.057739220559597015, 0.00966711901128292, -0.03441259637475014, -0.018329564481973648, 0.04939569905400276, -0.01481917779892683, -0.014081139117479324, 0.003919205162674189, 0.03247213736176491, 0.006773577071726322, -0.03690607100725174, 0.0056742713786661625, -0.005519113037735224, 0.005664607044309378, -0.012492348439991474, 0.013066473416984081, -0.03439688682556152, -0.0019054370932281017, 0.03191450610756874, -0.009593715891242027, -0.04506232589483261, 0.01138354279100895, 0.09911832213401794, 0.011498195119202137, -0.004382420796900988, -0.036940645426511765, -0.012749658897519112, 0.019123973324894905, -0.031193440780043602, -0.013077598065137863, 0.02233298122882843, 0.03006150759756565, -0.05850241333246231, -0.010846768505871296, -0.017664602026343346, -0.029817134141921997, 0.06510529667139053, -0.014681966975331306, 0.09462801367044449, 0.04332776740193367, -0.013037467375397682, -0.015025138854980469, -0.023367740213871002, 0.012197110801935196, -0.024117905646562576, 0.0005640640156343579, 0.061828482896089554, -0.003329805564135313, -0.005641882307827473, 0.038505494594573975, 0.004715088754892349, 0.03541542589664459, 0.03527260571718216, 0.009576212614774704, 0.03216545656323433, 0.04726032912731171, 0.019699325785040855, -0.02932693436741829, 0.03056863136589527, -0.021026430651545525, 0.02291271649301052, -0.03146157041192055, -0.001980507979169488, 0.020973410457372665, 0.0628969818353653, 0.013502013869583607, -0.023043150082230568, -0.027886681258678436, -0.05480955168604851, 0.027721215039491653, 0.012643775902688503, 0.01773533597588539, 0.041556891053915024, 0.0026025983970612288, 0.016253584995865822, 0.01288154348731041, 0.00782603956758976, -0.04931330308318138, -0.055402666330337524, -0.040499746799468994, -0.028794974088668823, -0.007439025677740574, 0.033739518374204636, 0.0008333866717293859, -0.017958132550120354, 0.025805797427892685, -0.028138449415564537, 0.001386160496622324, -0.008933519013226032, 0.013848272152245045, 0.00643912935629487, 0.05987557768821716, -0.01624964363873005, 0.02934802882373333, -0.00011877165525220335, -0.023959560319781303, 0.1103789210319519, 0.0835852324962616, 0.02260124310851097, -0.05614738166332245, 0.02360030636191368, -0.017077406868338585, -0.028438592329621315, -0.0362665131688118, 0.031031224876642227, 0.01533504854887724, -0.013952239416539669, 0.013094237074255943, 0.0434015728533268, 0.020005472004413605, -0.004470903426408768, 0.06965088844299316, -0.020160794258117676, -0.0016266003949567676, -0.0022782976739108562, -0.014264365658164024, -0.010032986290752888, 0.008773408830165863, -0.0192312840372324, -0.00014832087617833167, -0.0528838112950325, -0.030744940042495728, -0.06549342721700668, -0.02992628887295723, -0.0023823720403015614, -0.0022039012983441353, -0.038533180952072144, 0.03183465823531151, 0.01884300634264946, 0.031126253306865692, -0.010138552635908127, -0.01023571752011776, 0.013272801414132118, -0.02670619636774063, 0.0005394615000113845, 0.029341286048293114, 0.011044969782233238, -0.023547649383544922, -0.01415307354182005, -0.008921746164560318, -0.04319176822900772, -0.004943836014717817, -0.03150099888443947, 0.03361587971448898, -0.00869929138571024, -0.0237576924264431, -0.004778330679982901, 0.021808119490742683, 0.001456711208447814, -0.04845166951417923, -0.044705796986818314, 0.01856415532529354, 0.01549910381436348, -0.02910829707980156, -0.0024276431649923325, -0.04524916782975197, -0.00020726436923723668, 0.01853855326771736, 0.021043194457888603, 0.013189234770834446, -0.018766848370432854, -0.0028152428567409515, -0.006012259051203728, 0.12233155220746994, -0.01129134837538004, -0.023081764578819275, 0.008378430269658566, -0.017210643738508224, -0.026003804057836533, -0.008671090006828308, 0.01743410900235176, 0.035938333719968796, 0.01033150777220726, 0.0037322258576750755, -0.03415071591734886, -0.014018699526786804, -0.06673173606395721, 0.01425518374890089, -0.0017962513957172632, 0.021467335522174835, -0.04063734412193298, -0.017475733533501625, 0.07026007771492004, 0.05209160968661308, 0.025603199377655983, 0.01192050613462925, -0.01071871817111969, 0.04434690251946449, 0.0396244153380394, -0.07302669435739517, -0.006735076662153006, 0.01171436533331871, -0.0702550858259201, 0.0019474242581054568, -0.009293035604059696, 0.03206240385770798, -0.004644723143428564, 0.05558231472969055, -0.015605430118739605, 0.007296641357243061, -0.027098875492811203, -0.004776801913976669, -0.020904622972011566, -0.04497939720749855, 0.02234533242881298, -0.026159418746829033, 0.02819543145596981, -0.04120988771319389, 0.024608934298157692, -0.02734706550836563, -0.026556167751550674, 0.017464542761445045, -0.02363636903464794, -0.03384872153401375, 0.014826900325715542, 0.006610584445297718, 0.010484401136636734, -0.029583284631371498, 0.007784044370055199, -0.04156440868973732, -0.024584682658314705, 0.003580021671950817, -0.019247673451900482, 0.0007901345961727202, -0.0018611743580549955, -0.012705877423286438, 0.011183535680174828, 0.056868042796850204, 0.031205778941512108, -0.0015870973002165556, 0.009446129202842712, 0.016484122723340988, 0.018919600173830986, 0.03059493936598301, -0.03251795843243599, -0.05122629553079605, 0.048199575394392014, -0.03932591527700424, -0.026805870234966278, 0.019364533945918083, -0.0014364997623488307, 0.04245488718152046, -0.004177991766482592, -0.01747698336839676, 0.016285043209791183, 0.03641241416335106, 0.0009337835945188999, -0.016036352142691612, -0.010287313722074032, -0.03127605468034744, 0.015937374904751778, 0.011191397905349731, 0.03652440011501312, -0.004231985192745924, -0.010154428891837597, 0.032981619238853455, 0.0390956811606884, 0.010720434598624706, -0.021419167518615723, 0.018798360601067543, -0.005376849789172411, 0.03092632256448269, 0.0037875277921557426, -0.010467025451362133, 0.07508328557014465, 0.0567440390586853, -0.005530528258532286, 0.03415295109152794, 0.020156843587756157, 0.011676779016852379, -0.08447755128145218, -0.002115305047482252, 0.04547105357050896, -0.005678707733750343, 0.012094883248209953, -0.06302322447299957, 0.0205406341701746, -0.010574216954410076, -0.049249228090047836, -0.012746178545057774, -0.010717863216996193, -0.024681759998202324, -0.026189591735601425, 0.009890870191156864, -0.035364795476198196, 0.005600471515208483, 0.0671098604798317, 0.07488328218460083, 0.03989304602146149, 0.004909236449748278, -0.01141954306513071, -0.009931503795087337, -0.047876808792352676, -0.008254953660070896, 0.024992631748318672, -0.068793885409832, 0.008561328984797001, -0.037661757320165634, -0.006885973736643791, 0.012094714678823948, -0.03335026279091835, 0.028207147493958473, -0.014955248683691025, -0.00006835928797954693, 0.01648450642824173, -0.003990387078374624, 0.030667901039123535, 0.02217497117817402, -0.04282933846116066, -0.025615602731704712, 0.008411304093897343, 0.013652006164193153, -0.034985948354005814, 0.029103470966219902, 0.02312897890806198, -0.025376658886671066, -0.020817670971155167, 0.023415062576532364, -0.03187204524874687, -0.03456537052989006, 0.0019143858226016164, 0.005247822497040033, 0.014649189077317715, -0.010494162328541279, 0.0039016196969896555, -0.017880825325846672, 0.0018992878030985594, 0.026909371837973595, 0.027885593473911285, -0.03907328099012375, -0.0019190354505553842, -0.04753550887107849, -0.03946110978722572, 0.016248034313321114, -0.016362164169549942, -0.013389011844992638, -0.023619676008820534, -0.011404337361454964, -0.028689885511994362, -0.021196799352765083, -0.025297585874795914, -0.003875790163874626, 0.0025189807638525963, 0.04024818167090416, -0.032444484531879425, 0.007170108612626791, 0.04668821394443512, -0.016118112951517105, -0.022597786039114, -0.07796698063611984, 0.06123785302042961, -0.03791652247309685, -0.04281366989016533, -0.03752930834889412, -0.004932735580950975, -0.041846733540296555, 0.0003821339923888445, 0.056506089866161346, -0.03011709824204445, 0.007953555323183537, -0.0037764410953968763, 0.02946293354034424, 0.0137858334928751, -0.029055871069431305, 0.028351249173283577, 0.005068026017397642, -0.010264095850288868, 0.019778957590460777, -0.0046045552007853985, -0.004296369384974241, 0.035702548921108246, 0.005964018404483795, -0.024604791775345802, 0.0341755636036396, 0.033571820706129074, -0.011321675963699818, 0.008455658331513405, -0.00998728722333908, -0.019332656636834145, 0.04746919125318527, 0.03164564073085785, -0.0007293713861145079, 0.02750512771308422, -0.008219410665333271, -0.08287744969129562, 0.025419490411877632, -0.05712726712226868, -0.04013385251164436, -0.02349143661558628, -0.013888493180274963, -0.0015534613048657775, -0.050339747220277786, 0.006927205249667168, 0.01924043335020542, -0.013793126679956913, -0.014328714460134506, 0.034437116235494614, 0.008263970725238323, 0.013923391699790955, -0.02398180402815342, 0.00887279398739338, 0.000511124380864203, -0.0008119330741465092, 0.026454435661435127, -0.018623268231749535, 0.046865660697221756, 0.0004999310476705432, 0.004630724899470806, 0.03425225615501404, -0.0012861206196248531, 0.004649180918931961, -0.027935801073908806, 0.030509160831570625, -0.00040842965245246887, -0.04632430896162987, 0.016023170202970505, 0.030620152130723, 0.030148712918162346, 0.025114737451076508, -0.028957610949873924, 0.07779189944267273, -0.06227043643593788, 0.010406077839434147, -0.027956470847129822, 0.0009695920743979514, -0.029348621144890785, 0.030391942709684372, 0.013568596914410591, 0.0011816795449703932, 0.005023511592298746, 0.00423880061134696, 0.008600578643381596, 0.005499724298715591, 0.023398034274578094, -0.015711700543761253, 0.016414130106568336, -0.03298202529549599, -0.001351702492684126, -0.01892196573317051, -0.020521143451333046, -0.02420618385076523, -0.031803593039512634, 0.0570860430598259, 0.03174571692943573, 0.0041456520557403564, -0.011279853992164135, -0.0006575167062692344, -0.01500953733921051, 0.07216468453407288, -0.08666495978832245, -0.05524107813835144, -0.017558222636580467, -0.0036009277682751417, 0.0007143868715502322, -0.06245122849941254 ]
<p>The final theorem in Chapter 19 of Meyn and Tweedie's <a href="http://probability.ca/MT/" rel="nofollow">Markov Chains and Stochastic Stability</a> tells us that if the mean inter-arrival time $\lambda$ of a GI/G/1 queue is greater than its mean service time $\mu$, then the queue is positive Harris recurrent.</p> <blockquote> <b>Question</b>: What stability results are known for a continuous-time GI/G/1 queue for which $\lambda=\mu$, and in which the variances of the inter-arrival time and service time random variables are positive? Is it known that such a queue cannot be positive Harris recurrent? Regular? </blockquote> <p>The Lyapunov function used in Meyn-Tweedie, which is an expected hitting time, is not going to work for $\lambda=\mu$.</p> <p>I searched in Morozov and Delgado's <a href="http://link.springer.com/article/10.1134%2FS0005117909120066#page-1" rel="nofollow">survey paper</a>, which claims that "stability conditions of the classical GI/G/m queue are well known", and in other surveys, but found no mention of the $\lambda=\mu$ case there. </p>
37,006
[ -0.02113419957458973, -0.05250607430934906, 0.04134022071957588, -0.029783299192786217, 0.041307345032691956, 0.02137991040945053, -0.024296702817082405, -0.011479705572128296, 0.02439795807003975, -0.039085645228624344, 0.0513349287211895, 0.05400412529706955, 0.053855329751968384, 0.03937682881951332, 0.014435190707445145, -0.008242122828960419, -0.023132547736167908, -0.0046799383126199245, -0.019341565668582916, 0.019276849925518036, 0.0040947734378278255, 0.017507821321487427, 0.01524131279438734, -0.011559722945094109, -0.02765531651675701, 0.001273871399462223, 0.014366842806339264, 0.013916492462158203, 0.0061159017495810986, 0.056245021522045135, -0.07879847288131714, 0.014466471038758755, -0.005969913210719824, 0.03759868070483208, -0.0013918920885771513, 0.038164444267749786, -0.05356523394584656, -0.027844034135341644, -0.014824753627181053, 0.0024173115380108356, -0.03199848532676697, -0.008109187707304955, -0.015143049880862236, 0.014296156354248524, -0.03272377699613571, 0.01565667986869812, -0.008881166577339172, -0.023341361433267593, 0.054226793348789215, -0.03970350697636604, 0.061964113265275955, -0.04227786138653755, 0.01713007315993309, 0.010431909002363682, 0.009089807979762554, 0.011348225176334381, 0.06392388045787811, 0.06648880988359451, 0.02340669184923172, -0.011121445335447788, 0.026361780241131783, -0.03624024614691734, 0.022475551813840866, 0.004419705364853144, -0.013447904027998447, 0.05014608055353165, 0.0024886508472263813, -0.04404035583138466, 0.049691855907440186, -0.022326340898871422, -0.014510015025734901, -0.00484038982540369, 0.024990856647491455, -0.00011363810335751623, 0.029033685103058815, 0.014373142272233963, 0.01684592477977276, 0.04419192671775818, 0.020822301506996155, 0.011657731607556343, 0.009140334092080593, 0.030520062893629074, 0.03140692785382271, 0.03561519458889961, 0.00892684143036604, -0.032538801431655884, 0.08302060514688492, -0.0061974916607141495, 0.027664868161082268, 0.031166093423962593, 0.01735527440905571, -0.01022681687027216, 0.01777140609920025, -0.01581902801990509, -0.060248419642448425, 0.024219481274485588, 0.00787262711673975, 0.027335120365023613, 0.0006264562252908945, -0.008694058284163475, 0.008634095080196857, -0.05178175866603851, 0.023044388741254807, 0.04793088883161545, 0.012925351038575172, -0.004820507485419512, -0.02064189314842224, 0.0025437558069825172, -0.01828625798225403, -0.025584829971194267, -0.025014687329530716, -0.005028906743973494, 0.007449006661772728, -0.013769224286079407, -0.01014026626944542, -0.002361271996051073, 0.02405208721756935, -0.03855167701840401, 0.06285258382558823, 0.09128276258707047, 0.022115902975201607, 0.0021469034254550934, 0.012836765497922897, -0.06559670716524124, -0.06263875961303711, 0.0128638269379735, 0.02815384417772293, -0.011537880636751652, -0.0859123021364212, 0.03640960901975632, 0.01613694801926613, -0.009935003705322742, 0.02745693549513817, 0.04427560046315193, 0.033059004694223404, -0.008541722781956196, -0.06911364197731018, -0.024870608001947403, 0.07447963207960129, -0.015943001955747604, 0.005328942555934191, -0.06315421313047409, -0.037858474999666214, 0.04684606194496155, 0.04131750389933586, -0.023372681811451912, 0.049125004559755325, -0.01690083183348179, 0.028595753014087677, 0.013527553528547287, -0.04046556353569031, -0.011158345267176628, 0.01191510260105133, -0.02173125557601452, -0.009676160290837288, -0.0627783015370369, 0.004651299212127924, 0.008892752230167389, 0.014949781820178032, -0.030993230640888214, 0.054975833743810654, 0.003008113009855151, -0.03764268383383751, -0.05869503319263458, -0.01574588194489479, -0.01944102719426155, 0.0708535760641098, 0.01694050244987011, 0.019646603614091873, -0.022301193326711655, 0.02351197972893715, 0.007224090863019228, -0.01900843344628811, 0.04773619771003723, 0.02961622178554535, -0.05443863198161125, -0.027730202302336693, 0.010114663280546665, 0.02157638408243656, -0.011338833719491959, -0.00024152142577804625, -0.007847125642001629, -0.03403284773230553, 0.025168081745505333, 0.0007848513778299093, 0.03218596801161766, -0.021712040528655052, 0.06260339915752411, 0.032769825309515, -0.018141599372029305, -0.05268929898738861, -0.03001866117119789, 0.030404962599277496, 0.013363227248191833, -0.01884501799941063, 0.0271449014544487, -0.00035172529169358313, -0.009445048868656158, -0.05024471506476402, -0.005197115708142519, -0.027949033305048943, -0.020996909588575363, 0.028953220695257187, -0.02230622060596943, -0.011455962434411049, 0.054612480103969574, 0.02935582958161831, -0.020957445725798607, 0.0060699936002492905, -0.016363823786377907, -0.08312119543552399, -0.0018209917470812798, -0.010025407187640667, 0.05426723137497902, -0.010943210683763027, -0.008726568892598152, 0.018662186339497566, -0.006094334647059441, 0.02306257002055645, 0.00589401600882411, -0.06707083433866501, -0.018617428839206696, 0.050653889775276184, 0.0398726649582386, 0.023351220414042473, 0.029978545382618904, 0.005977523513138294, -0.0032581111881881952, 0.0025854106061160564, -0.019209040328860283, -0.02525930479168892, -0.02195831760764122, 0.03331229090690613, 0.0674818679690361, 0.028674259781837463, 0.01604965701699257, 0.007471613120287657, 0.057507239282131195, 0.0219184011220932, 0.03333037346601486, -0.00843505747616291, -0.07809776812791824, 0.03431319072842598, 0.03196301311254501, 0.01640511304140091, 0.017523836344480515, -0.0001736399863148108, -0.037912093102931976, -0.011354535818099976, -0.004589173011481762, -0.020924914628267288, 0.01211515162140131, -0.0002718093164730817, -0.01901686005294323, -0.005896380171179771, -0.04152963310480118, 0.060511648654937744, -0.050796497613191605, -0.011165816336870193, 0.04498326778411865, 0.0032853586599230766, 0.03278673440217972, -0.010539849288761616, -0.030106298625469208, -0.004668069537729025, -0.007358103524893522, -0.022398479282855988, -0.027168212458491325, 0.028250398114323616, -0.036115437746047974, 0.04823698848485947, -0.023982737213373184, -0.023469017818570137, -0.0065758503042161465, 0.000879505299963057, 0.0032722523901611567, 0.00032560108229517937, 0.003057820023968816, -0.03673017770051956, -0.013257837854325771, 0.02045784704387188, -0.018318770453333855, 0.017440253868699074, 0.013255985453724861, 0.001731927040964365, -0.02606043592095375, -0.002647135406732559, 0.005016927141696215, 0.02524806372821331, 0.0075914086773991585, 0.020259061828255653, 0.008352055214345455, -0.001567030674777925, -0.05552060157060623, -0.0119562279433012, -0.027724238112568855, 0.011948862113058567, -0.009798779152333736, -0.005754751153290272, 0.045333877205848694, 0.020525338128209114, -0.03408215567469597, 0.03948810324072838, -0.035271499305963516, -0.05167704448103905, -0.048641934990882874, 0.00219351495616138, 0.040752869099378586, -0.015732521191239357, 0.039275553077459335, 0.03315725177526474, -0.0049415472894907, 0.014216361567378044, -0.05425259843468666, -0.06232225522398949, 0.02724400907754898, -0.04125556722283363, 0.05501848831772804, -0.0071943518705666065, -0.031373657286167145, 0.04308640956878662, 0.03327351063489914, -0.020694416016340256, 0.0015033360105007887, -0.003027192782610655, -0.029660681262612343, -0.03988642245531082, 0.02324995957314968, -0.016267072409391403, -0.006905330810695887, 0.03954611346125603, 0.022996889427304268, 0.02809099107980728, 0.044638779014348984, 0.012537139467895031, -0.017929410561919212, 0.014845317229628563, -0.02014857903122902, 0.0006932289688847959, 0.03216040879487991, 0.03673258423805237, 0.012630008161067963, -0.011029943823814392, 0.0176760945469141, 0.0429888591170311, -0.02432214468717575, -0.016876906156539917, 0.04940353333950043, 0.000023828872144804336, -0.021382000297307968, -0.021531783044338226, 0.04498812556266785, -0.011411719024181366, -0.044717974960803986, -0.0034811554942280054, 0.020827174186706543, 0.022760145366191864, -0.0366995669901371, -0.005246290937066078, 0.04428776353597641, 0.015651656314730644, -0.008407686837017536, 0.019880089908838272, 0.00785690639168024, -0.0383828803896904, 0.05282377824187279, -0.06667797267436981, -0.01620560884475708, 0.013392255641520023, 0.05802680552005768, -0.005340911913663149, -0.019201776012778282, -0.03567143902182579, -0.023778874427080154, -0.061568837612867355, 0.018199419602751732, 0.004959107376635075, 0.03001031093299389, 0.004652904812246561, 0.02926216833293438, -0.009202679619193077, -0.017476122826337814, 0.002994424430653453, 0.0007529868744313717, -0.0936378613114357, 0.0038707272615283728, -0.02187935635447502, -0.01511096116155386, 0.03005533665418625, 0.009811261668801308, 0.016714738681912422, -0.008324354887008667, 0.005514415446668863, -0.007961559109389782, 0.01575213484466076, -0.05383406952023506, 0.025135019794106483, -0.06644731014966965, -0.05322283133864403, -0.003364408854395151, -0.023267261683940887, 0.03476788103580475, -0.03598294034600258, 0.000012118866834498476, -0.002026424277573824, -0.03792663291096687, -0.007238884922116995, -0.013909158296883106, 0.003443144029006362, 0.0379900261759758, 0.013729916885495186, 0.03765013441443443, 0.04616668447852135, -0.004504418931901455, 0.02819834090769291, 0.054288964718580246, 0.049890145659446716, 0.023890910670161247, 0.006978912279009819, 0.011034269817173481, -0.03111244924366474, -0.03639696165919304, 0.04064977169036865, 0.04379315674304962, 0.027576250955462456, -0.028338145464658737, 0.05116836726665497, 0.02145371213555336, -0.023038683459162712, 0.05286890268325806, 0.07545896619558334, 0.027008511126041412, -0.008598843589425087, 0.008800728246569633, 0.002593251410871744, -0.0028908702079206705, -0.0056576854549348354, 0.04507173225283623, -0.004433576017618179, 0.011011194437742233, -0.006564259063452482, 0.023172881454229355, -0.004760056734085083, -0.021438807249069214, -0.02142900787293911, 0.023912737146019936, 0.01737152971327305, 0.007809111382812262, -0.0013110351283103228, 0.0013404779601842165, 0.04523634910583496, 0.06415890902280807, -0.005236044991761446, -0.0007980430382303894, -0.06658267974853516, -0.012204942293465137, 0.04695069417357445, 0.01071841735392809, -0.008989745751023293, -0.02337799407541752, -0.04471583664417267, -0.0015828011091798544, 0.01998879760503769, -0.012390417978167534, 0.06843497604131699, 0.01769963838160038, -0.03540264442563057, -0.01597595028579235, -0.04782740771770477, 0.007008775603026152, 0.002021325984969735, 0.030033817514777184, 0.04305116832256317, -0.01001050416380167, -0.007172958925366402, -0.0245598703622818, -0.014663330279290676, 0.011687803082168102, 0.05440627411007881, -0.009192584082484245, 0.03047938644886017, -0.010330945253372192, 0.036535028368234634, -0.04496869072318077, -0.08658929169178009, 0.01176284160465002, -0.024727527052164078, 0.0023635688703507185, 0.034165896475315094, -0.030636003240942955, -0.023570312187075615, 0.005530316382646561, 0.08217273652553558, -0.01315414346754551, 0.006693702656775713, 0.006590462289750576, 0.02243388257920742, 0.037647705525159836, -0.00698130764067173, 0.04027058556675911, 0.007579056080430746, -0.010481549426913261, -0.03607046976685524, 0.017724819481372833, 0.018945300951600075, -0.039837874472141266, -0.016915837302803993, 0.00150458759162575, 0.01924392767250538, -0.04860023409128189, 0.05099383369088173, 0.05599783733487129, 0.00025786436162889004, 0.0005076293600723147, 0.004893332254141569, -0.02192561700940132, 0.02866421267390251, -0.006126285996288061, 0.003795905038714409, 0.02179218828678131, 0.023724427446722984, -0.013753038831055164, 0.012979179620742798, 0.09219925850629807, -0.0088826147839427, 0.00511156627908349, 0.03344893082976341, -0.023896759375929832, 0.02446344867348671, -0.05818506330251694, 0.0113754877820611, -0.00535115459933877, 0.01297435536980629, 0.0647188127040863, 0.010049541480839252, 0.03223056718707085, 0.064879409968853, -0.03801595792174339, -0.006027828436344862, 0.03552524000406265, -0.03568413853645325, -0.006412683520466089, -0.01592322811484337, 0.02512187883257866, 0.0479695200920105, 0.012677506543695927, -0.09960106760263443, -0.015333919785916805, 0.04189511761069298, -0.010503663681447506, -0.04251040518283844, -0.04285372048616409, -0.02323039248585701, -0.04932261258363724, -0.01950216107070446, -0.009938386268913746, 0.02966158278286457, -0.013270626775920391, -0.01517312228679657, 0.004815438762307167, 0.03429146111011505, 0.07022356986999512, 0.016715923324227333, -0.00027747961576096714, 0.01150206383317709, -0.026559509336948395, 0.014167027547955513, 0.005439779255539179, 0.06547598540782928, -0.018505744636058807, -0.009974977001547813, 0.01974770799279213, -0.010006693191826344, -0.001991311786696315, -0.018004970625042915, -0.055778972804546356, 0.04050802066922188, -0.03135319799184799, 0.029379092156887054, 0.0029364617075771093, 0.023629382252693176, -0.010896706953644753, 0.028602316975593567, -0.009479817934334278, 0.0030778127256780863, 0.0038744688499718904, 0.007457315921783447, 0.058360323309898376, 0.0003672070160973817, -0.005534053314477205, 0.00796960387378931, 0.06961928308010101, -0.024770982563495636, -0.013978250324726105, 0.024873919785022736, -0.014592830091714859, 0.03019472397863865, -0.047133300453424454, -0.022843534126877785, 0.007352469488978386, -0.03498246148228645, -0.05347483977675438, -0.057290125638246536, -0.026075202971696854, 0.04618503525853157, 0.01406537089496851, 0.009057621471583843, 0.04371587932109833, -0.0245023462921381, -0.03435714170336723, -0.02117045223712921, -0.013569644652307034, -0.00672663189470768, 0.0038231168873608112, -0.01296477671712637, 0.0293990820646286, -0.03015739470720291, 0.03359324857592583, 0.031974658370018005, 0.014866279438138008, 0.025528136640787125, -0.012304621748626232, 0.020350487902760506, 0.007442582864314318, 0.01444885041564703, -0.018818339332938194, -0.03704452887177467, 0.04794015362858772, -0.06815727055072784, 0.001107558491639793, -0.004947257228195667, -0.04729960486292839, 0.039914533495903015, 0.015347817912697792, 0.040770843625068665, -0.002182446187362075, 0.009820733219385147, -0.0659000352025032, 0.04784113168716431, -0.013675238005816936, -0.0008511351188644767, 0.020418310537934303, -0.008827016688883305, 0.04003865644335747, -0.011140425689518452, 0.012422925792634487, -0.014499583281576633, -0.04608531668782234, -0.014593536965548992, -0.024112487211823463, -0.0696948990225792, 0.04553580656647682, 0.013612593524158001, -0.0284934863448143, -0.004812715575098991, -0.018664279952645302, -0.018875040113925934, 0.010410113260149956, 0.023988444358110428, -0.02108868584036827, 0.09535060822963715, -0.042870450764894485, 0.017639443278312683, -0.017591454088687897, 0.00708201015368104, 0.11844006180763245, 0.036669664084911346, 0.01300728414207697, -0.050397105515003204, 0.014839762821793556, -0.029241440817713737, -0.014220076613128185, -0.039235662668943405, 0.019245358183979988, 0.009667550213634968, -0.05067192763090134, 0.048060089349746704, 0.003981697838753462, 0.0040295361541211605, -0.02657327428460121, 0.031126588582992554, -0.027533067390322685, -0.020532501861453056, -0.007305428851395845, -0.012062379159033298, -0.0020111827179789543, 0.0025117737241089344, -0.021499240770936012, 0.029569309204816818, -0.011167594231665134, -0.005668018013238907, 0.019428430125117302, -0.01275080069899559, 0.0030644978396594524, 0.020922239869832993, 0.0032718153670430183, -0.005924834404140711, 0.030995093286037445, -0.010311566293239594, -0.013364954851567745, -0.016129732131958008, -0.02007891982793808, -0.004821466747671366, 0.023419059813022614, 0.04159535467624664, -0.012831246480345726, -0.020198730751872063, 0.024898074567317963, 0.035669393837451935, -0.029707232490181923, -0.010085505433380604, -0.00430683558806777, 0.01889500394463539, -0.012868311256170273, 0.03331344574689865, 0.019194556400179863, -0.04990746080875397, -0.016277914866805077, -0.03264174237847328, -0.032081104815006256, -0.021512335166335106, 0.023370463401079178, -0.04960675910115242, -0.01776287332177162, -0.05488887056708336, -0.009076847694814205, -0.005294226575642824, 0.007746397517621517, 0.007859161123633385, -0.06862401217222214, -0.003907442558556795, -0.026626044884324074, 0.03263716772198677, -0.03466642275452614, -0.00621673883870244, -0.0425889678299427, -0.010832658037543297, -0.026567749679088593, -0.0007774793775752187, -0.01313292421400547, -0.021081088110804558, 0.0252069104462862, 0.011571762152016163, -0.03352952376008034, 0.0049894279800355434, -0.07724682986736298, 0.01571854203939438, -0.0238562673330307, -0.0243872981518507, -0.015858465805649757, -0.06254877150058746, 0.02112993597984314, 0.008279969915747643, -0.01281911414116621, -0.009773468598723412, -0.04067486524581909, 0.03572913631796837, 0.0031289418693631887, -0.029270270839333534, -0.008279774338006973, -0.03209911286830902, -0.031976811587810516, -0.004368126858025789, -0.02843628078699112, 0.025777392089366913, 0.015484324656426907, 0.04070596024394035, -0.010540255345404148, -0.002170707331970334, 0.033231642097234726, -0.004896990489214659, 0.043272264301776886, -0.021068349480628967, 0.019020015373826027, 0.019874297082424164, 0.070815309882164, -0.019312195479869843, -0.04849858209490776, -0.0003956437867600471, -0.002421189332380891, -0.011020445264875889, 0.002103478880599141, -0.017871906980872154, 0.0008862176327966154, -0.011536207050085068, 0.02853313460946083, -0.05319537967443466, -0.043120648711919785, -0.01031508855521679, -0.021066656336188316, -0.03482640162110329, 0.012651849538087845, -0.0006677413475699723, 0.0008736522868275642, 0.036391936242580414, -0.0362718366086483, 0.013237508945167065, 0.04377128556370735, -0.037033695727586746, 0.02317996509373188, 0.014472093433141708, 0.0025623971596360207, 0.056650105863809586, -0.02131757326424122, -0.04965643957257271, 0.05798133462667465, -0.0038685635663568974, 0.014960045926272869, -0.004399818368256092, -0.014863946475088596, 0.008339131250977516, 0.00024461402790620923, -0.04580694064497948, -0.012214732356369495, 0.020582271739840508, -0.003999420441687107, 0.0238089170306921, 0.009189642034471035, 0.010966157540678978, 0.02864071913063526, -0.0016753291711211205, -0.013057616539299488, 0.023039570078253746, -0.008465345948934555, -0.020869210362434387, 0.06295964866876602, -0.011219087988138199, -0.007995056919753551, 0.0008623739704489708, -0.009130848571658134, 0.006057730410248041, -0.004775747191160917, 0.016944298520684242, 0.02883867174386978, 0.061578813940286636, -0.04956499859690666, 0.011324853636324406, -0.02358541265130043, 0.006219574250280857, -0.043781913816928864, 0.0019657008815556765, 0.020179077982902527, 0.00476800324395299, 0.06500905007123947, -0.02624521031975746, -0.015983855351805687, 0.023693440482020378, -0.05536489188671112, -0.03212612122297287, 0.026555266231298447, -0.014866199344396591, -0.06767518818378448, -0.036259789019823074, -0.056299466639757156, 0.010944181121885777, -0.0024598108138889074, -0.007458540610969067, -0.003694217884913087, 0.041150618344545364, -0.014697127044200897, 0.0030571576207876205, -0.017141511663794518, 0.03301524370908737, -0.004729690961539745, -0.0074544684030115604, 0.030663635581731796, -0.03493385389447212, -0.007941847667098045, 0.04488002508878708, -0.011957785114645958, 0.002821620786562562, 0.01953558623790741, -0.0003124430950265378, -0.004490372259169817, 0.047083135694265366, 0.05068254470825195, -0.0002948411856777966, 0.037523530423641205, -0.013151422142982483, -0.007465792819857597, 0.05095471069216728, -0.00009573036368237808, 0.014510642737150192, 0.047418177127838135, -0.032271482050418854, -0.0216388963162899, 0.006857097614556551, -0.046170689165592194, -0.031890664249658585, 0.01105633843690157, -0.004037842620164156, 0.0013985598925501108, 0.008549610152840614, 0.09002824127674103, -0.008973050862550735, -0.031934577971696854, 0.03186090663075447, 0.031107012182474136, 0.024823525920510292, 0.006913477089256048, -0.0017281811451539397, -0.0143782589584589, 0.03228863328695297, -0.011140111833810806, -0.02837309241294861, -0.05007562413811684, -0.014630690217018127, -0.02317582443356514, 0.013011184521019459, -0.02851325273513794, -0.03715040534734726, -0.03965028375387192, 0.07532421499490738, -0.015554215759038925, 0.010357297956943512, 0.008538676425814629, -0.01034459937363863, 0.04215100035071373, -0.049382615834474564, 0.029376644641160965, 0.01772221177816391, 0.006604054942727089, -0.025017108768224716, -0.06665027141571045, -0.03562006726861, -0.05303250253200531, 0.07516410201787949, -0.009541145525872707, -0.017195777967572212, 0.04713445529341698, 0.030876431614160538, 0.01665220782160759, -0.0015679813222959638, 0.004611768294125795, -0.0623810701072216, -0.007940075360238552, -0.015836946666240692, -0.05824464559555054, 0.03094605728983879, 0.01141836866736412, 0.02166089601814747, -0.02025626413524151, -0.007479984778910875, 0.03161507472395897, -0.028993606567382812, 0.05434398725628853, 0.0382397323846817, -0.026941554620862007, 0.059785448014736176, -0.0206796545535326, 0.012678656727075577, -0.016205409541726112, -0.0026420955546200275, -0.058226075023412704, -0.0066142757423222065, -0.009810256771743298, 0.010250312276184559, -0.00021774998458568007, 0.015393360517919064, -0.008638870902359486, -0.05069837346673012, -0.022472327575087547, 0.027264775708317757, -0.03333640843629837, -0.01797233335673809, 0.05548698455095291, 0.039898183196783066, 0.05227436125278473, -0.025291284546256065, -0.027349457144737244, 0.028196929022669792, -0.007996720261871815, -0.022762853652238846, 0.060052406042814255, -0.005430752411484718, -0.033036969602108, -0.018884986639022827, 0.005988180637359619, -0.025965679436922073, 0.031968068331480026, -0.012230678461492062, 0.02646050602197647, -0.02047518454492092, -0.03797207027673721, 0.04456309601664543, -0.0019981972873210907, -0.01737583614885807, 0.008322656154632568, -0.013115483336150646, 0.06285053491592407, -0.008603673428297043, 0.011326304636895657, -0.013411806896328926, -0.005135697778314352, -0.015883632004261017, 0.005352369509637356, 0.0018304027616977692, 0.0206844974309206, 0.010475114919245243, 0.03441793471574783, -0.010161226615309715, 0.00927417166531086, 0.013048645108938217, -0.05430693179368973, -0.023559022694826126, 0.03168308362364769, 0.01830224320292473, -0.02455359324812889, -0.04869615659117699, 0.01360764354467392, -0.028155969455838203, 0.005779980681836605, 0.03418236970901489, 0.012180165387690067, -0.017536556348204613, -0.016770929098129272, -0.06518028676509857, 0.0573740229010582, -0.05684975907206535, 0.011638126336038113, -0.06939885765314102, -0.011095850728452206, 0.0023704320192337036, 0.01253462117165327 ]
<p>I have done an AMOVA analysis on mtDNA sequences, partitioned on 14 populations (with a variable number of individuals in each populations), and I insert all the population in the same group.</p> <p>From the AMOVA analysis I have obtained significant value for Fst among populations, but when i try to compute pairwise Fst between the populations I obtaine only 3 significant pair and the other are not significant.</p> <p>Is it possible? May the problem is that i have to redefine my populations?</p> <p>Thank you</p>
34,791
[ -0.049955833703279495, -0.008812349289655685, -0.0004874136939179152, 0.007715770974755287, 0.024480648338794708, 0.0073084705509245396, -0.012844454497098923, -0.0096746776252985, 0.01950579509139061, -0.03981829062104225, 0.057252269238233566, -0.007748871576040983, 0.05077601969242096, 0.019633786752820015, -0.01579129323363304, -0.024463346228003502, -0.040425293147563934, 0.0075230379588902, -0.0025926311500370502, 0.01314698625355959, 0.005891310051083565, 0.06449159234762192, 0.03199933096766472, -0.03964284062385559, -0.012391707859933376, 0.04646668955683708, 0.03826339915394783, -0.0131376963108778, 0.02573336474597454, 0.06658952683210373, -0.03237215802073479, -0.03283367678523064, 0.023428762331604958, 0.030748780816793442, 0.04615702107548714, 0.025030765682458878, -0.04514193534851074, 0.0020222545135766268, 0.015078077092766762, 0.017445813864469528, -0.04898151010274887, 0.002546917414292693, 0.0048258076421916485, 0.027804821729660034, -0.016736280173063278, 0.03416723385453224, -0.0045228679664433, -0.03433418273925781, 0.02280128188431263, -0.05435224249958992, 0.07979203015565872, 0.020863475278019905, 0.008851083926856518, 0.029660619795322418, 0.011004679836332798, 0.0013922679936513305, 0.025024913251399994, 0.0653713271021843, 0.015137114562094212, -0.04662845656275749, 0.0017075436189770699, -0.05834953486919403, -0.0008004968403838575, 0.00004251776772434823, -0.07181254029273987, 0.018789563328027725, 0.024085775017738342, -0.013420617207884789, 0.08674516528844833, 0.0011645908234640956, 0.012852666899561882, 0.00781297404319048, 0.02414623647928238, -0.02719712071120739, 0.013692837208509445, -0.0050813304260373116, 0.021153010427951813, -0.027913570404052734, 0.039815016090869904, 0.012462880462408066, 0.00116475869435817, 0.019899427890777588, 0.010140962898731232, 0.028283245861530304, 0.014439412392675877, -0.007016448769718409, 0.0214308500289917, -0.04134167358279228, 0.006952628027647734, 0.051353711634874344, 0.012855960056185722, -0.020258089527487755, 0.09355314075946808, 0.009076676331460476, -0.02569952793419361, 0.04593340680003166, 0.010977541096508503, 0.01870521530508995, 0.0009423455921933055, 0.013328531756997108, -0.014867057092487812, -0.031811412423849106, 0.036719899624586105, 0.03749774396419525, -0.04064527526497841, 0.02756562829017639, -0.04550029709935188, -0.017587557435035706, -0.009923450648784637, 0.013938629999756813, 0.026592189446091652, 0.0095915412530303, -0.018522873520851135, 0.020617136731743813, 0.02978157065808773, -0.0213009025901556, -0.02107202634215355, -0.022098183631896973, 0.09913033992052078, 0.05273161083459854, 0.003212480340152979, -0.005757984239608049, 0.011492785066366196, -0.034949421882629395, -0.03520485758781433, 0.025953087955713272, -0.0023864477407187223, -0.012607992626726627, -0.007517652120441198, 0.06443877518177032, 0.022371191531419754, -0.013583465479314327, 0.031003812327980995, -0.010684270411729813, -0.010047334246337414, -0.0038810609839856625, -0.033206477761268616, -0.05358506739139557, 0.037252314388751984, -0.04214390367269516, 0.010834196582436562, -0.04705600440502167, -0.005333258770406246, 0.028077879920601845, 0.03605837747454643, -0.01617046818137169, 0.039432041347026825, 0.010332819074392319, 0.03171981871128082, 0.0530191995203495, -0.0052726976573467255, -0.03477555513381958, -0.02825535275042057, -0.01480045635253191, -0.03317936882376671, -0.07880091667175293, 0.030472148209810257, 0.032815124839544296, 0.022819627076387405, 0.0072373454459011555, -0.0025055587757378817, 0.02791251614689827, -0.0271853469312191, -0.027130253612995148, 0.0003653608146123588, 0.019153336063027382, 0.056036561727523804, -0.026884743943810463, 0.04100842773914337, 0.0052763246931135654, -0.01475775707513094, -0.0008653959375806153, -0.01312345266342163, 0.020797284319996834, 0.03243551403284073, -0.0266116950660944, 0.013472205027937889, 0.007074774242937565, 0.008758123964071274, 0.04226771742105484, -0.023511340841650963, -0.015733718872070312, -0.06974317878484726, -0.02338983304798603, 0.032775670289993286, 0.044113095849752426, -0.013914495706558228, 0.014722970314323902, 0.048650484532117844, -0.06530357152223587, -0.052439138293266296, -0.03534267842769623, -0.005667750723659992, 0.0112508749589324, -0.049758180975914, -0.03392582759261131, 0.007526892237365246, 0.029291639104485512, -0.021463939920067787, -0.029292358085513115, -0.00983944907784462, 0.0057973493821918964, 0.03368883952498436, -0.014893662184476852, 0.019303886219859123, 0.04301464185118675, 0.05142075940966606, -0.03471764177083969, 0.05567116662859917, -0.022218819707632065, -0.03199057653546333, 0.031537171453237534, -0.014297515153884888, 0.005421822424978018, -0.020801067352294922, 0.001084742252714932, -0.012605463154613972, 0.023807551711797714, -0.012302872724831104, 0.07147882878780365, -0.03723398223519325, 0.0873764380812645, 0.05492411553859711, -0.010260581970214844, 0.012822653166949749, 0.001338033122010529, 0.00655671302229166, 0.00043168722186237574, -0.031229544430971146, -0.010124805383384228, -0.08792998641729355, -0.02718380093574524, 0.023815372958779335, 0.04796820133924484, -0.03853410854935646, -0.024045202881097794, 0.07427296787500381, 0.030284568667411804, 0.039399754256010056, 0.026303565129637718, -0.009306262247264385, -0.011172011494636536, 0.05738390237092972, 0.04556643217802048, 0.014424948021769524, 0.011304480955004692, 0.04951620101928711, -0.04244042932987213, 0.0505557507276535, -0.03808584064245224, 0.010048968717455864, 0.04939086735248566, 0.024089576676487923, -0.012347872368991375, -0.0562710203230381, 0.004972439259290695, -0.00022200483363121748, -0.04147683456540108, -0.002147034276276827, 0.019982842728495598, 0.015028099529445171, -0.04008893668651581, -0.0068546864204108715, -0.026884322986006737, -0.019516801461577415, 0.008900174871087074, -0.0018621733179315925, -0.0005512187490239739, 0.03647392988204956, -0.012661335989832878, -0.005572750233113766, -0.02786283567547798, -0.01979018747806549, 0.001034618471749127, 0.02853633463382721, 0.044711802154779434, -0.020713014528155327, 0.02040986157953739, -0.04234219342470169, 0.01289235521107912, -0.02333083003759384, -0.009089105762541294, 0.02588333934545517, -0.008060554042458534, -0.07608821243047714, -0.010765326209366322, -0.023592563346028328, -0.03033417835831642, -0.022812407463788986, -0.0018664649687707424, 0.0022643916308879852, 0.04096759855747223, 0.010284939780831337, -0.06438750773668289, -0.033778510987758636, -0.02212303690612316, 0.008479234762489796, -0.03301823139190674, 0.03440370410680771, 0.03527384623885155, 0.03468463942408562, -0.009324045851826668, 0.026080064475536346, -0.030500825494527817, 0.002440821612253785, -0.022204585373401642, -0.032586563378572464, -0.006832203362137079, -0.01567736268043518, 0.03879569098353386, 0.03417539969086647, -0.03866267204284668, -0.0574653297662735, -0.053024642169475555, -0.06426801532506943, 0.025222793221473694, 0.012296360917389393, 0.050485070794820786, -0.01778620295226574, -0.0373537540435791, 0.03466399386525154, 0.028788724914193153, -0.030181027948856354, -0.01514214277267456, 0.017469026148319244, -0.02542717196047306, -0.028954533860087395, 0.0324304923415184, 0.008568414486944675, -0.039593879133462906, 0.017922844737768173, -0.004142371937632561, 0.040416158735752106, 0.07302553206682205, 0.009177803993225098, -0.05077743902802467, 0.0296869408339262, -0.009289521723985672, 0.0013891678536310792, 0.04079175367951393, -0.003521471982821822, -0.05581438168883324, 0.015617559663951397, -0.007215352263301611, -0.007826014421880245, 0.01168821007013321, -0.04557185620069504, 0.0021722253877669573, 0.01468581985682249, -0.008519618771970272, -0.057974644005298615, 0.02281014993786812, -0.0013544999528676271, -0.02453634701669216, -0.03968974947929382, 0.02383662387728691, 0.0465962253510952, -0.03006344847381115, -0.00307298987172544, 0.07667279988527298, 0.03888891264796257, -0.00703754648566246, 0.004877945873886347, -0.007010786794126034, 0.01139327883720398, -0.017165185883641243, -0.014842919073998928, -0.01856357604265213, -0.028839949518442154, 0.039838917553424835, 0.027313880622386932, -0.004348038695752621, -0.01789798215031624, 0.013140608556568623, -0.014742844738066196, 0.019372563809156418, -0.04170342907309532, 0.07791969180107117, 0.013899382203817368, 0.03787233680486679, -0.004881053231656551, -0.03327959030866623, -0.0393315851688385, 0.005649465601891279, -0.0528048537671566, 0.034191831946372986, 0.03741934522986412, -0.051428135484457016, 0.0216846764087677, -0.045333828777074814, -0.028851890936493874, -0.008910950273275375, -0.016152096912264824, -0.037235282361507416, 0.059105660766363144, -0.023830028250813484, 0.0008600422297604382, -0.034327324479818344, -0.0169699564576149, -0.00005094040170661174, 0.05544058606028557, 0.05830494686961174, -0.04130902141332626, 0.03296240419149399, 0.004637526348233223, -0.006346614565700293, -0.03368766978383064, -0.023707032203674316, 0.04728954657912254, 0.025996163487434387, 0.037370920181274414, 0.023814283311367035, 0.03735077753663063, -0.05088145658373833, 0.011339453049004078, 0.005591277498751879, 0.03056633658707142, 0.03480414301156998, 0.022007271647453308, -0.008315459825098515, -0.0030238269828259945, -0.04819429665803909, 0.01609928160905838, 0.01424980629235506, -0.01000670064240694, 0.009467237628996372, 0.013629545457661152, 0.0028451757971197367, -0.06403673440217972, -0.0019447411177679896, 0.024525150656700134, 0.00012052470265189186, -0.01326359435915947, -0.027067633345723152, -0.015933116897940636, -0.016916166990995407, -0.000751441577449441, 0.0392170287668705, 0.04383225739002228, -0.0070131937973201275, 0.0021936302073299885, 0.020701875910162926, 0.03232656791806221, -0.017623702064156532, -0.004800207447260618, 0.01210207398980856, 0.02672661654651165, -0.014145689085125923, 0.0027842947747558355, 0.006864806637167931, -0.008466522209346294, -0.028826462104916573, 0.034554220736026764, 0.022467922419309616, -0.08206440508365631, 0.0265214703977108, 0.007322170305997133, 0.050987452268600464, -0.02399248257279396, 0.02393706701695919, -0.033147722482681274, 0.05292632803320885, 0.028998352587223053, -0.02032177709043026, 0.06759626418352127, -0.01603819988667965, 0.0038481089286506176, -0.008188127540051937, -0.002968242159113288, -0.06186746060848236, 0.023456035181879997, -0.04744916036725044, 0.031822480261325836, -0.032985445111989975, -0.04094964265823364, -0.021541573107242584, 0.05264918878674507, 0.011037170886993408, 0.05730244144797325, -0.03335665166378021, -0.003887609578669071, 0.011275031603872776, 0.0479547455906868, -0.013876055367290974, -0.03339694067835808, 0.02540845423936844, -0.00024731416488066316, 0.017078792676329613, 0.003498737933114171, -0.02693759836256504, -0.035953693091869354, 0.002082877792418003, 0.018051933497190475, 0.004027977120131254, -0.01595085859298706, -0.01584489271044731, 0.013434262946248055, 0.004152103327214718, -0.02008211985230446, 0.07937876135110855, 0.04850577935576439, -0.018206452950835228, -0.0006295745843090117, -0.03036634810268879, 0.030737610533833504, -0.040780168026685715, -0.009246131405234337, -0.035351306200027466, -0.0014604757307097316, 0.019485510885715485, 0.008924620226025581, 0.0017831490840762854, 0.044310927391052246, -0.021313203498721123, -0.003302059369161725, 0.0004528156132437289, -0.020912514999508858, -0.028376761823892593, 0.02947276271879673, -0.0007963510579429567, 0.04990411177277565, -0.04197291284799576, -0.017586495727300644, 0.013964831829071045, -0.037084322422742844, -0.01106121577322483, -0.012743065133690834, -0.009764143265783787, 0.004453262779861689, -0.030431466177105904, -0.015750788152217865, 0.026422807946801186, -0.02217937633395195, 0.029907844960689545, -0.008922697976231575, 0.046705178916454315, -0.003626424353569746, -0.04202982783317566, -0.01409380417317152, 0.051403485238552094, 0.0015997466398403049, 0.03022473305463791, -0.011584687978029251, 0.0497039332985878, 0.010154357179999352, 0.02243204414844513, -0.0601942352950573, -0.013975193724036217, -0.003822005819529295, 0.0011035144561901689, -0.0031523979268968105, -0.026603667065501213, -0.028299100697040558, 0.009550733491778374, 0.004377762787044048, 0.018179142847657204, 0.0778423473238945, -0.027849573642015457, -0.046822600066661835, -0.0362275168299675, -0.012215920723974705, 0.028950536623597145, -0.018345922231674194, 0.0011776367900893092, 0.0076559060253202915, 0.008946675807237625, -0.019530579447746277, -0.024124303832650185, -0.0003063218609895557, -0.03496035188436508, -0.03922843933105469, -0.020192747935652733, 0.01431785523891449, 0.03890753537416458, 0.011178304441273212, -0.009241377003490925, -0.02510586380958557, -0.030573880299925804, 0.025766270235180855, -0.029138648882508278, 0.013298765756189823, -0.011535149067640305, 0.008117150515317917, -0.064915731549263, 0.024358442053198814, 0.0026716911233961582, -0.018479393795132637, 0.015038512647151947, -0.028134897351264954, -0.017506064847111702, -0.03357008472084999, 0.03143337741494179, -0.00845628883689642, -0.02237033285200596, 0.010284515097737312, -0.042408499866724014, 0.07255710661411285, 0.01798763871192932, -0.04311617463827133, -0.031429585069417953, 0.04917630925774574, -0.06229181960225105, 0.001997249433770776, -0.026942992582917213, -0.0049080755561590195, 0.04871535301208496, -0.0150088369846344, 0.05506529286503792, 0.08099742233753204, -0.02006484381854534, 0.012834922410547733, -0.02358962781727314, 0.0035327207297086716, 0.0537230409681797, 0.024209806695580482, 0.05276210233569145, 0.007319664116948843, 0.028739148750901222, 0.042793575674295425, 0.0391574464738369, 0.024060698226094246, 0.04722888395190239, 0.012862681411206722, 0.001786830835044384, 0.046522993594408035, -0.00994065310806036, -0.0538325197994709, 0.02265324257314205, -0.05475311353802681, 0.004009027034044266, 0.0040911040268838406, 0.02613615058362484, 0.058406539261341095, 0.02993018738925457, 0.001517369644716382, -0.05450856313109398, -0.0049113198183476925, -0.024090763181447983, 0.02639974281191826, -0.013627690263092518, -0.012645077891647816, 0.022620534524321556, 0.011879262514412403, 0.06793639063835144, -0.0009222774533554912, -0.0185858067125082, -0.024398351088166237, -0.04756950959563255, 0.00889439508318901, -0.004059686791151762, -0.044998813420534134, 0.04611271992325783, 0.004802045878022909, -0.030013399198651314, 0.03751075267791748, -0.02260545827448368, 0.013587886467576027, -0.013938672840595245, 0.025304581969976425, -0.033456381410360336, 0.06841899454593658, 0.0012312447652220726, 0.04378703609108925, 0.019361691549420357, -0.013678791001439095, 0.12199784070253372, 0.04278715327382088, 0.017605392262339592, -0.05004994571208954, 0.052521441131830215, -0.03118688240647316, -0.0383334718644619, -0.007194788195192814, -0.007886495441198349, 0.004695892799645662, -0.014348382130265236, 0.01242741197347641, 0.024372169747948647, 0.0027089063078165054, -0.022059274837374687, 0.03293007239699364, -0.05051761493086815, -0.02105766162276268, 0.03960181027650833, 0.012437291443347931, -0.004272963386029005, -0.012164060026407242, -0.020036185160279274, -0.001082920702174306, 0.003301057731732726, -0.013903114013373852, -0.03409772366285324, -0.013253570534288883, -0.00026885682018473744, -0.008681235834956169, -0.007811153773218393, 0.020132122561335564, 0.030728280544281006, -0.0028220347594469786, -0.02506662905216217, -0.020411528646945953, 0.02422647923231125, -0.052108149975538254, 0.021050257608294487, 0.0516047328710556, -0.01858009211719036, 0.0011059318203479052, 0.025077641010284424, 0.005691851489245892, -0.056744180619716644, 0.012135427445173264, -0.01675053872168064, 0.05048716813325882, -0.009946651756763458, -0.029560089111328125, -0.030154889449477196, 0.004561548586934805, 0.025205103680491447, -0.060481101274490356, -0.01012114156037569, 0.024438908323645592, 0.01672443002462387, -0.027002401649951935, -0.029257139191031456, -0.0278638806194067, -0.02685885690152645, 0.0024700467474758625, 0.004886339884251356, 0.020825959742069244, 0.00846504233777523, -0.018268784508109093, -0.03215417265892029, 0.011834869161248207, -0.015416374430060387, -0.014222905039787292, -0.01791861094534397, -0.02856115996837616, -0.027254650369286537, -0.019178200513124466, -0.002189311431720853, 0.023296551778912544, 0.014543791301548481, 0.004830893129110336, -0.04039058834314346, -0.013398048467934132, -0.040978558361530304, 0.012789017520844936, -0.03173256665468216, -0.03617590665817261, 0.0015224908711388707, -0.023055236786603928, 0.002710821805521846, 0.03292819485068321, 0.01955680176615715, 0.019990647211670876, -0.02026134729385376, 0.001489630900323391, 0.006552431266754866, -0.05335898697376251, -0.025890108197927475, 0.0186366755515337, -0.02684689871966839, -0.029324971139431, -0.047347165644168854, 0.053255412727594376, 0.027444269508123398, 0.0035289479419589043, -0.033333852887153625, 0.017110370099544525, 0.029227489605545998, 0.02229013852775097, 0.014223643578588963, -0.020607778802514076, 0.0019272303907200694, 0.00724355224519968, -0.013480556197464466, -0.03408044949173927, -0.009638912975788116, -0.013188615441322327, -0.0027661786880344152, 0.013646837323904037, -0.06002640351653099, -0.04021794721484184, -0.0014965202426537871, -0.06277792155742645, 0.03869233652949333, -0.015320919454097748, 0.00879054144024849, -0.028617819771170616, -0.02549462392926216, 0.0031028601806610823, 0.029571911320090294, -0.03503536805510521, 0.00871623121201992, -0.005956380628049374, 0.033357322216033936, 0.04261278361082077, 0.007695652078837156, 0.036871373653411865, -0.05056552588939667, 0.01011741068214178, 0.02703944407403469, 0.0796244740486145, -0.0023518099915236235, -0.0016701470594853163, 0.043352458626031876, -0.06424415856599808, -0.02315031737089157, 0.021706480532884598, 0.009244846180081367, 0.04753951355814934, 0.00741288298740983, 0.012044384144246578, -0.04489594325423241, 0.0602654404938221, -0.01900630071759224, 0.0041995239444077015, -0.014889907091856003, 0.015490463003516197, 0.022571377456188202, 0.01882581040263176, -0.057560138404369354, 0.008242660202085972, 0.0041327509097754955, 0.01547311246395111, 0.036154430359601974, -0.0019095580792054534, -0.04412513226270676, -0.05069116875529289, -0.008310141041874886, 0.01751897856593132, 0.0002963375300168991, -0.03431670367717743, 0.041544586420059204, 0.028792286291718483, 0.019362786784768105, 0.0019334153039380908, -0.05993777886033058, 0.001918489346280694, -0.051621243357658386, -0.0338592454791069, -0.030290676280856133, -0.006733857560902834, 0.05585026741027832, -0.05915233492851257, -0.011503979563713074, -0.002465846249833703, -0.05525742471218109, 0.036320604383945465, 0.02002284862101078, -0.02999071776866913, -0.0743137076497078, 0.022303996607661247, -0.02243776060640812, 0.015683773905038834, -0.013385060243308544, 0.03829265013337135, 0.03578658029437065, 0.010956177487969398, 0.01988169178366661, -0.055067118257284164, -0.032670531421899796, -0.004291532561182976, 0.013512162491679192, -0.089948371052742, 0.027528394013643265, -0.008139028213918209, -0.049252837896347046, 0.02185414731502533, -0.060689590871334076, 0.01671542227268219, 0.018192097544670105, 0.0352613665163517, 0.02605373226106167, 0.08181075006723404, 0.012748058885335922, 0.005982277449220419, 0.055712658911943436, 0.002267124829813838, -0.0036475227680057287, 0.0173186007887125, -0.03222965449094772, -0.001141927670687437, 0.04227575659751892, 0.0017661857418715954, -0.0003285702259745449, 0.03606385737657547, -0.03568567335605621, -0.022445231676101685, 0.02533782832324505, -0.01668752171099186, -0.009851370938122272, -0.028583569452166557, 0.011800436303019524, -0.0361395925283432, 0.015674883499741554, 0.044404562562704086, 0.024036452174186707, 0.010281829163432121, 0.0060752397403120995, -0.011025105603039265, -0.024563245475292206, 0.0006330896867439151, -0.012494312599301338, 0.0041722641326487064, -0.026225807145237923, -0.051464490592479706, 0.009566828608512878, 0.008195221424102783, -0.051202211529016495, -0.010395895689725876, -0.02129298821091652, 0.026605447754263878, -0.01998175121843815, 0.006140386685729027, -0.014184823259711266, 0.016873346641659737, 0.0169044341892004, -0.08286087960004807, 0.04318886622786522, 0.02710074931383133, 0.0015823821304365993, -0.048561159521341324, -0.04723171517252922, -0.04978177323937416, 0.008289840072393417, 0.027948500588536263, -0.010661084204912186, 0.032229579985141754, -0.013884642161428928, 0.002146076178178191, 0.03815792500972748, -0.021486667916178703, 0.06133883446455002, -0.0033127067144960165, 0.008064539171755314, 0.013734704814851284, 0.0011659438023343682, -0.009914624504745007, 0.006933122873306274, -0.0054733348079025745, -0.04588470980525017, 0.010959476232528687, 0.015357064083218575, 0.01573832333087921, 0.018410496413707733, -0.001550054526887834, 0.010489513166248798, -0.00905941054224968, 0.003324666293337941, 0.02764693647623062, 0.044061336666345596, 0.0013348542852327228, -0.041916053742170334, 0.022133074700832367, -0.04973245784640312, -0.014688977040350437, 0.0186714269220829, 0.0025691338814795017, 0.015178832225501537, -0.03187428414821625, -0.00461307680234313, 0.02238384261727333, -0.022512007504701614, 0.01945026032626629, 0.07402589172124863, 0.048470206558704376, 0.018211103975772858, 0.003705034963786602, 0.03881560266017914, -0.03548382595181465, -0.06775489449501038, 0.007382246665656567, 0.010829956270754337, -0.0038144104182720184, -0.01457899808883667, 0.0023339479230344296, 0.002592367585748434, -0.0270705409348011, 0.03491569682955742, 0.033110298216342926, 0.0036575100384652615, 0.0016064764931797981, -0.000898132857400924, 0.024294577538967133, -0.0053458730690181255, 0.028708985075354576, -0.013603409752249718, 0.011840403079986572, 0.06630121916532516, -0.03059524856507778, 0.01679377630352974, -0.0370662659406662, -0.015042376704514027, -0.013440272770822048, -0.006767543498426676, 0.017175300046801567, 0.022870425134897232, 0.008173110894858837, 0.0251516941934824, 0.0044588069431483746, 0.015437468886375427, 0.023910904303193092, -0.062093622982501984, 0.016405455768108368, -0.012352865189313889, -0.007633367087692022, 0.024969834834337234, -0.00013165344716981053, -0.011250902898609638, 0.0019269568147137761, 0.03805626556277275, 0.03400956466794014, 0.03960387036204338, -0.017786143347620964, -0.027629265561699867, 0.006479593459516764, 0.034669652581214905, -0.049410492181777954, -0.05766179412603378, -0.042988162487745285, 0.02052653767168522, 0.010706892237067223, -0.011615434661507607 ]
<p>I have a situation where we are detecting anomalies based on data implied from the table data. </p> <p>As an example, I have data on registered individuals spending time on the portal. Based on this, I have some logic driven by the interval between successive login-ins/ activity on portal. We have used arbitrary duration as the interval and it seems to work for us. There are a bunch of other user demographics(age, location, interests etc) that have been ignored </p> <p>I tried various ML algorithms(NB, Decision tree etc) but am getting error rates in excess of 40% in spite of large training data. </p> <p>I wanted to check a) should I explicitly create variables like "interval between logins"; "number of activities per hr" so that they can be used for the algorithms b) should I create class variables- like ">2 hrs" "1-2 hrs" for login-interval and number of activities per login-hr as '&lt;5', '5-15' etc.</p> <p>Broadly should I provide (a) and (b) explicitly... and likewise do I signal on a few other variables that I believe should be used </p>
74,249
[ -0.008863111026585102, -0.008378386497497559, 0.00592634966596961, 0.02794547565281391, 0.06918256729841232, 0.0014310465194284916, -0.0241258405148983, -0.021793991327285767, 0.041678983718156815, 0.04349934682250023, 0.03831636533141136, 0.025808274745941162, 0.03796645998954773, 0.037911493331193924, 0.04106598347425461, -0.022931914776563644, 0.024815697222948074, -0.0019762811716645956, -0.000900211394764483, 0.012380781583487988, 0.0005048170569352806, -0.003155208658427, 0.007287492975592613, -0.03749588504433632, -0.02235730178654194, 0.06563880294561386, -0.0032454587053507566, -0.01177558209747076, -0.026565739884972572, 0.01475451048463583, -0.01415256503969431, -0.024957334622740746, 0.017025303095579147, 0.04143991321325302, 0.0014020486269146204, 0.009976468980312347, -0.06813947856426239, -0.028142079710960388, -0.007524640765041113, 0.015996070578694344, -0.04574139788746834, 0.0011289436370134354, 0.0497138649225235, 0.05958439037203789, 0.0038870261050760746, -0.0169999860227108, -0.0009839613921940327, 0.038463134318590164, 0.0148911839351058, -0.017356831580400467, 0.05514116212725639, -0.011112109757959843, 0.03263375908136368, 0.013630351983010769, -0.012746094726026058, -0.03489675372838974, 0.036002978682518005, 0.047631073743104935, -0.018259843811392784, -0.06136636063456535, -0.026529699563980103, 0.0025784142781049013, -0.021079353988170624, -0.03567070886492729, 0.003482445143163204, 0.016153307631611824, -0.021037176251411438, 0.005517296027392149, 0.022626934573054314, -0.03030354157090187, 0.02602984756231308, -0.026462307199835777, 0.033171068876981735, 0.009031511843204498, 0.020712057128548622, -0.006354786455631256, -0.0019002127228304744, 0.004706065636128187, 0.02553737536072731, 0.04552283138036728, -0.00046091011608950794, -0.014381407760083675, 0.01948757842183113, 0.023883264511823654, -0.008136953227221966, -0.005013502202928066, 0.04672885686159134, -0.03942014276981354, 0.0027385144494473934, 0.012556883506476879, -0.05436241626739502, 0.013832559809088707, 0.06383066624403, 0.044873256236314774, -0.0684196799993515, 0.03252055123448372, -0.02512405812740326, 0.0072377752512693405, 0.011249878443777561, 0.009682691656053066, -0.044082507491111755, -0.04732697829604149, -0.00001580842217663303, 0.04612448066473007, -0.04884719103574753, 0.018274109810590744, -0.02634558640420437, -0.04152434691786766, -0.043212540447711945, -0.02199079841375351, -0.03022049181163311, 0.02059933915734291, -0.012609966099262238, 0.03888404741883278, 0.010096419602632523, -0.008880696259438992, -0.022255944088101387, -0.020898407325148582, 0.050471801310777664, 0.03965991362929344, 0.03667672723531723, -0.03066345676779747, 0.0362212136387825, -0.011702100746333599, -0.03975173085927963, 0.021914971992373466, 0.01038188487291336, -0.005643852986395359, -0.07501941174268723, 0.028929205611348152, 0.00653858482837677, -0.032886769622564316, 0.03542991355061531, 0.00038943049730733037, 0.027076303958892822, -0.009164572693407536, -0.07546323537826538, -0.08007657527923584, 0.01681573875248432, -0.010508295148611069, 0.010687894187867641, -0.055267564952373505, -0.02056819573044777, 0.032668255269527435, 0.058214426040649414, 0.007545465137809515, 0.0089833103120327, 0.0059584034606814384, -0.022425001487135887, 0.0011949609033763409, -0.05103995278477669, 0.006982061080634594, -0.03474811837077141, -0.0023327970411628485, -0.008981970138847828, -0.060181766748428345, 0.0025604874826967716, 0.022042613476514816, -0.016509786248207092, -0.001962922513484955, 0.028840258717536926, 0.009091244079172611, -0.01677663065493107, 0.015631362795829773, 0.03620253503322601, -0.033696431666612625, 0.07499267905950546, -0.02764110267162323, 0.07701343297958374, 0.04260417819023132, -0.007867850363254547, 0.03430284187197685, 0.009679820388555527, 0.03844514861702919, 0.06313353776931763, 0.01370910368859768, -0.006529351230710745, -0.010623017325997353, 0.01187228038907051, 0.018602745607495308, -0.04565955698490143, -0.043674223124980927, -0.03384353965520859, -0.006494647357612848, -0.008545737713575363, -0.006023291032761335, 0.0020540079567581415, -0.021241197362542152, 0.06424353271722794, -0.022504057735204697, -0.024680253118276596, -0.06266371160745621, 0.005372122395783663, -0.01801789551973343, -0.0244565699249506, 0.051711685955524445, -0.03417186811566353, -0.012819411233067513, -0.026010535657405853, -0.018494943156838417, -0.035903822630643845, -0.019262081012129784, 0.054505206644535065, -0.08002965152263641, 0.0057492912746965885, 0.019981469959020615, -0.02211860939860344, -0.020359091460704803, 0.02505522221326828, -0.044786833226680756, -0.045410413295030594, -0.011513152159750462, -0.0288824662566185, 0.05875245854258537, -0.002379366895183921, -0.004720782395452261, 0.022762443870306015, 0.00455615995451808, -0.04035825654864311, 0.025261521339416504, -0.05745083466172218, 0.03347263112664223, 0.08851566165685654, 0.015991346910595894, 0.010856934823095798, -0.009889294393360615, 0.015307072550058365, 0.012262692674994469, 0.0014306791126728058, -0.01539456658065319, -0.05963697284460068, -0.010888168588280678, 0.024110499769449234, -0.006204208824783564, 0.007340705953538418, 0.04095924273133278, 0.03682691231369972, 0.016302427276968956, -0.012625036761164665, 0.036518778651952744, 0.007362973876297474, -0.004724736325442791, 0.018559519201517105, 0.022454291582107544, 0.007703006267547607, -0.0010607766453176737, 0.0002109056804329157, -0.01754814386367798, 0.007719904184341431, 0.022899437695741653, 0.032117608934640884, -0.017277831211686134, 0.004360103979706764, 0.04923059418797493, -0.027098219841718674, -0.009826435707509518, 0.04407448321580887, -0.017535187304019928, -0.03350960090756416, 0.048933032900094986, -0.006768812425434589, -0.04418693110346794, 0.01584397815167904, -0.01566808670759201, -0.008241168223321438, 0.050997596234083176, -0.02151285856962204, -0.02266940474510193, 0.03172307461500168, -0.019536862149834633, -0.013406816869974136, 0.0034765659365803003, -0.07353843003511429, -0.023527489975094795, 0.012850550934672356, 0.07566569745540619, -0.005846110172569752, 0.022444121539592743, 0.015767740085721016, 0.02601407654583454, 0.0512612946331501, 0.005234344396740198, 0.03274019807577133, -0.012040208093822002, -0.06515775620937347, -0.012181229889392853, 0.025665946304798126, -0.03060622327029705, 0.012016144581139088, -0.03272099420428276, -0.005964739713817835, -0.004079828038811684, 0.018418965861201286, -0.032649051398038864, -0.044141508638858795, -0.013209168799221516, 0.002621474675834179, 0.021681446582078934, -0.043671634048223495, 0.018138499930500984, 0.001171922660432756, -0.05944761633872986, 0.014458606950938702, -0.010591422207653522, -0.0062052714638412, -0.04481455683708191, -0.020723719149827957, -0.023793533444404602, 0.008064358495175838, -0.007851686328649521, 0.013630799017846584, 0.01352533046156168, 0.004494206048548222, -0.08177956193685532, -0.07966599613428116, -0.012753278017044067, 0.011342287994921207, 0.03662323206663132, 0.025308974087238312, 0.01525381114333868, 0.09072607010602951, 0.02139507420361042, -0.04027915745973587, -0.03129805624485016, -0.07187692821025848, -0.0038997256197035313, -0.03699742630124092, 0.02865307219326496, 0.06358978152275085, 0.02894151397049427, 0.0006523033953271806, -0.024290792644023895, 0.016295157372951508, 0.07303846627473831, 0.01358991488814354, -0.008874699473381042, 0.021268103271722794, 0.021931452676653862, 0.011570912785828114, 0.03500678390264511, 0.030718259513378143, -0.027332790195941925, -0.013390758074820042, 0.004979334305971861, 0.007135829422622919, 0.04539879038929939, -0.02310846373438835, -0.011873194947838783, -0.08411113917827606, 0.04799889773130417, 0.02058776281774044, 0.005638620350509882, -0.0018013895023614168, -0.03193097934126854, -0.026940451934933662, 0.040201690047979355, 0.024010686203837395, -0.07410741597414017, 0.02500244975090027, 0.09667834639549255, 0.052577462047338486, 0.005616862326860428, -0.026693254709243774, -0.005299645941704512, -0.021282052621245384, 0.03434240072965622, -0.048517193645238876, 0.0008638121071271598, 0.03884225711226463, 0.035657260566949844, 0.0091039277613163, 0.02708585001528263, -0.04768655076622963, -0.03062201850116253, -0.06583196669816971, 0.0030964764300733805, -0.03204589709639549, 0.06076280027627945, 0.008491787128150463, -0.02749910019338131, 0.0242085512727499, -0.020951110869646072, -0.0033538080751895905, -0.002907108049839735, -0.02905876934528351, -0.014042085967957973, 0.004001711495220661, 0.0007866279338486493, 0.010198064148426056, -0.048853714019060135, 0.017902085557579994, -0.03384607285261154, 0.00633801706135273, 0.005832594353705645, 0.005286586005240679, -0.021955078467726707, 0.000623904459644109, -0.010568165220320225, -0.0054670399986207485, -0.015067004598677158, 0.002330387244001031, -0.011165379546582699, 0.015488513745367527, 0.026884591206908226, 0.02157759666442871, 0.0475175715982914, -0.027918478474020958, 0.011859474703669548, -0.0008422352257184684, 0.010263605043292046, 0.038696471601724625, 0.044428952038288116, 0.009203039109706879, -0.07247117161750793, 0.026472212746739388, -0.034694597125053406, 0.041904911398887634, 0.000874117249622941, 0.00758901983499527, -0.038363173604011536, -0.02859327383339405, -0.03170565888285637, 0.0379529632627964, 0.03934137150645256, 0.022458890452980995, 0.0002224759809905663, 0.00814117956906557, -0.017342770472168922, -0.03921230882406235, 0.022916154935956, 0.1022377535700798, 0.005010916385799646, -0.043583277612924576, 0.012956211343407631, 0.007024241611361504, 0.03482672944664955, -0.017268534749746323, 0.01130012795329094, 0.0032366570085287094, 0.020137034356594086, -0.01886892132461071, 0.02379734069108963, -0.01605273224413395, -0.03535540774464607, 0.047676295042037964, 0.03468223288655281, 0.010883301496505737, 0.026606351137161255, -0.03671830892562866, 0.011793850921094418, 0.01841629482805729, 0.058776434510946274, 0.036445386707782745, -0.013041687197983265, -0.10423002392053604, -0.0015955830458551645, 0.05506731569766998, 0.06255347281694412, -0.0018992467084899545, -0.03221752494573593, -0.006680627819150686, -0.04369735345244408, 0.01343935914337635, -0.0035425073001533747, 0.008985994383692741, -0.007832570932805538, 0.016043759882450104, -0.05577157065272331, -0.023809000849723816, -0.036229901015758514, 0.011482411995530128, 0.003214285708963871, 0.09190160781145096, -0.02603955753147602, -0.059327349066734314, -0.011697523295879364, 0.01371124479919672, 0.00913818646222353, 0.013251248747110367, 0.0015207055257633328, -0.03392401710152626, 0.007447745185345411, 0.0030994764529168606, -0.022800281643867493, -0.0685347393155098, 0.0012023862218484282, 0.014824464917182922, 0.00939567293971777, 0.027003679424524307, 0.008381848223507404, -0.06238021329045296, -0.04571559652686119, 0.051742590963840485, 0.026475505903363228, -0.02779332734644413, -0.017868440598249435, 0.0333390049636364, 0.00002592223245301284, 0.02429267205297947, 0.007784881163388491, 0.03802943602204323, 0.005722873844206333, 0.012435991317033768, -0.01556595228612423, -0.014077212661504745, -0.03365422785282135, -0.00007923466910142452, -0.030006101354956627, -0.011539283208549023, -0.017408734187483788, 0.05602414533495903, 0.023458119481801987, 0.0386117547750473, -0.04176439717411995, -0.03458981215953827, 0.003845561295747757, 0.021635770797729492, 0.00428121630102396, -0.014905659481883049, -0.011858398094773293, -0.004109077155590057, -0.0007447234238497913, 0.03685560077428818, 0.01588365063071251, -0.06355631351470947, 0.014174158684909344, 0.02950960025191307, 0.012650671415030956, 0.02615770697593689, -0.013712472282350063, -0.017379337921738625, 0.009431717917323112, -0.010606418363749981, 0.013466615229845047, 0.01277381181716919, 0.04837062582373619, -0.012370087206363678, -0.003019266529008746, 0.012479021213948727, 0.034302908927202225, 0.021603483706712723, 0.0720631331205368, -0.03286419436335564, 0.05210769549012184, -0.04280421510338783, 0.00028237648075446486, -0.0760241150856018, -0.024521764367818832, 0.021488215774297714, 0.00645202724263072, -0.048722513020038605, -0.012091617099940777, 0.0049890801310539246, -0.007601314689964056, -0.038832537829875946, -0.00523282028734684, 0.061652086675167084, -0.03849859908223152, -0.03590724617242813, -0.001649579731747508, 0.017345119267702103, 0.08423594385385513, 0.040853701531887054, 0.04088910296559334, 0.006278828717768192, 0.01651262678205967, -0.024491701275110245, 0.005210251081734896, 0.015121148899197578, -0.0305269006639719, -0.026332801207900047, -0.04512913152575493, -0.007516693323850632, 0.02007780782878399, -0.011516052298247814, 0.015469363890588284, 0.020197363570332527, -0.024609524756669998, 0.041861750185489655, -0.008152284659445286, 0.014459257014095783, -0.014866070821881294, -0.015864986926317215, -0.00011254776472924277, 0.010746757499873638, -0.013893747702240944, 0.03200346231460571, 0.010260539129376411, 0.01152181439101696, -0.007197122555226088, -0.003824968123808503, 0.03522046282887459, -0.0010656678350642323, 0.03396596387028694, -0.009463820606470108, -0.004131811670958996, 0.0735531896352768, -0.008482025004923344, -0.005556473974138498, 0.00885668396949768, 0.0001804557687137276, -0.019492996856570244, -0.048453718423843384, -0.03328479081392288, -0.006951604038476944, 0.036111053079366684, 0.0027367197908461094, 0.04842622950673103, 0.025741824880242348, 0.02925732359290123, -0.008085072971880436, -0.023311229422688484, -0.008628001436591148, -0.016580473631620407, 0.026779696345329285, 0.024291779845952988, -0.015439283102750778, 0.00415321160107851, 0.0061749545857310295, -0.0007860976620577276, 0.025520741939544678, 0.025100866332650185, 0.01943446695804596, 0.03203943744301796, 0.01409979723393917, -0.01658693328499794, -0.04886423796415329, 0.013397387228906155, -0.03712020069360733, -0.006254810374230146, -0.007828584872186184, -0.0076696183532476425, 0.010167250409722328, 0.05048582702875137, -0.013366848230361938, -0.03058711811900139, 0.012721219100058079, -0.06515748798847198, -0.0231339018791914, 0.023397551849484444, -0.01753353700041771, 0.028197625651955605, -0.009105502627789974, 0.036261480301618576, -0.04670159891247749, 0.004303645808249712, -0.02404843457043171, -0.06740259379148483, -0.02818606235086918, -0.019609486684203148, -0.05766311660408974, 0.05341847613453865, -0.008053770288825035, -0.02537628635764122, -0.025823216885328293, 0.002280609915032983, 0.0266704298555851, -0.0037473018746823072, 0.052301861345767975, -0.007651475723832846, 0.04047558829188347, -0.03181224688887596, 0.013570336624979973, -0.034330904483795166, 0.014229324646294117, 0.13658829033374786, 0.07883618026971817, 0.051772452890872955, -0.0666562020778656, 0.050246138125658035, 0.02011657878756523, 0.01077483594417572, -0.019523413851857185, 0.00679980730637908, 0.00595452357083559, 0.0020500156097114086, 0.04007549211382866, -0.0010048432741314173, 0.02513948641717434, -0.013070179149508476, 0.03699887543916702, -0.015660760924220085, 0.0008005548152141273, 0.03854658827185631, 0.033411670476198196, 0.001879204879514873, -0.016334669664502144, -0.0321149043738842, -0.014879257418215275, 0.051961272954940796, -0.0008085338049568236, 0.0270085372030735, 0.01663200743496418, 0.004532241728156805, -0.01789098046720028, -0.0223738644272089, 0.05554866045713425, -0.014271387830376625, 0.027803920209407806, 0.00650916388258338, -0.017492622137069702, -0.03693075478076935, -0.036998990923166275, 0.013008015230298042, 0.06083616986870766, 0.03661783039569855, -0.04431149363517761, -0.002782489638775587, 0.016958732157945633, -0.036520473659038544, -0.03956793621182442, -0.03497777879238129, 0.05274467542767525, -0.007013448979705572, -0.02551024779677391, -0.006861611735075712, -0.0062739066779613495, -0.025814559310674667, -0.0490737222135067, 0.01418424490839243, 0.016780924052000046, 0.0282308217138052, -0.008665753528475761, -0.015367384999990463, -0.005186060443520546, 0.032950349152088165, 0.012205079197883606, 0.02983066998422146, 0.021635200828313828, 0.007606547325849533, -0.006794617976993322, -0.0223198514431715, 0.015568501316010952, -0.012255225330591202, 0.03390895575284958, 0.0003619756316766143, -0.024407116696238518, -0.042436521500349045, -0.005273411516100168, 0.00506261782720685, 0.019609155133366585, -0.022110553458333015, 0.006968246772885323, -0.012630508281290531, -0.019734986126422882, 0.007180298678576946, 0.023065917193889618, -0.007031952030956745, -0.015342194586992264, -0.006023787893354893, 0.008267545141279697, -0.01952129602432251, 0.001341770519502461, 0.031838029623031616, -0.004277641884982586, 0.009262620471417904, 0.05258912593126297, 0.023064732551574707, -0.045069385319948196, 0.010071584954857826, -0.05395713821053505, -0.031634893268346786, 0.015496954321861267, -0.011510180309414864, 0.043672114610672, 0.0021641040220856667, 0.013640052638947964, 0.00023536532535217702, 0.02444051206111908, 0.0026516797952353954, -0.01264345832169056, 0.00020072163897566497, -0.049442585557699203, 0.010781585238873959, 0.008401486091315746, 0.01675174944102764, -0.04129323363304138, -0.06121966615319252, -0.019672203809022903, 0.002395087154582143, 0.025379246100783348, -0.03646540269255638, -0.00004204152719466947, 0.017054352909326553, 0.017536696046590805, -0.008403036743402481, -0.023815274238586426, 0.030455145984888077, -0.03452752158045769, -0.008104365319013596, -0.008542250841856003, -0.027709824964404106, -0.0071740178391337395, 0.00864405743777752, -0.003913359250873327, -0.025652006268501282, 0.032185621559619904, -0.01275661587715149, 0.01548823993653059, -0.026354584842920303, 0.019185040146112442, -0.02772446721792221, 0.025515515357255936, -0.022075319662690163, -0.009909537620842457, 0.026959266513586044, -0.009188927710056305, 0.003936563618481159, 0.01797894388437271, -0.00012159351172158495, 0.02445412054657936, 0.0026547524612396955, 0.00619321595877409, 0.006097113247960806, 0.056968409568071365, -0.037489794194698334, -0.034482039511203766, -0.00530329579487443, 0.02864319272339344, -0.0070022959262132645, -0.022462090477347374, -0.005784645210951567, 0.020975716412067413, -0.006391576025635004, -0.013841931708157063, 0.04342431202530861, 0.011703344993293285, -0.029591573402285576, -0.010763919912278652, 0.009629510343074799, 0.046675339341163635, -0.026497093960642815, -0.023754486814141273, 0.024643925949931145, 0.01362590305507183, -0.031947750598192215, 0.018093157559633255, -0.02178972400724888, 0.024939578026533127, -0.054372407495975494, -0.034555062651634216, 0.056842368096113205, 0.059439945966005325, 0.01734764128923416, -0.06679968535900116, 0.006920504383742809, 0.023208748549222946, -0.04391815513372421, 0.014603917486965656, 0.001748669776134193, -0.00043467056821100414, -0.019576385617256165, 0.029919512569904327, -0.025091739371418953, -0.02285267785191536, 0.01070268452167511, -0.013997922651469707, 0.02510601468384266, -0.003182066837325692, -0.0014550965279340744, -0.0730808675289154, -0.008486635982990265, 0.016033262014389038, 0.04272938892245293, -0.06838313490152359, 0.03537070006132126, -0.01881697028875351, 0.0025509032420814037, 0.03524024784564972, -0.05158242955803871, 0.017380917444825172, 0.03213785961270332, 0.03350956737995148, 0.0011847878340631723, 0.056311801075935364, 0.04579198360443115, -0.06921377778053284, -0.009284691885113716, 0.012573420070111752, -0.018278703093528748, 0.05000939220190048, 0.022621983662247658, -0.00782173965126276, -0.010483887046575546, -0.006300635170191526, -0.013352608308196068, 0.0029464776162058115, 0.001921612536534667, -0.026900535449385643, -0.0015035721007734537, -0.05331132188439369, 0.007276876363903284, -0.03402933105826378, -0.0017068033339455724, -0.028683185577392578, 0.02134774439036846, 0.03173200786113739, 0.04575534164905548, 0.0026521331164985895, -0.03112764097750187, -0.034521717578172684, -0.0625540241599083, -0.005047184880822897, 0.01928248070180416, -0.027095146477222443, -0.035858914256095886, -0.008123043924570084, -0.01886524260044098, -0.02610662765800953, 0.0072877658531069756, 0.01586519554257393, 0.007716230116784573, 0.04687236249446869, -0.010324043221771717, 0.022037925198674202, 0.05922861397266388, 0.02942194789648056, -0.01250458788126707, -0.06845822185277939, 0.09820391237735748, -0.0016092410078272223, 0.02937905676662922, -0.02666354738175869, 0.006054186262190342, -0.05871046707034111, 0.016980860382318497, 0.05655798316001892, 0.030049828812479973, -0.006115464493632317, -0.014251946471631527, 0.00970036443322897, -0.07579708099365234, -0.030894311144948006, 0.04721149057149887, -0.010871266014873981, -0.02383382059633732, 0.021122070029377937, -0.020919131115078926, 0.01265917532145977, -0.02350112609565258, 0.00001360930036753416, 0.03536371886730194, 0.012528174556791782, 0.0548926517367363, -0.008132636547088623, 0.003926742356270552, 0.02549690753221512, 0.015963800251483917, -0.007340617943555117, 0.049799513071775436, -0.014573573134839535, 0.01353492122143507, -0.017628703266382217, -0.05323052406311035, 0.02968679368495941, -0.019046498462557793, -0.0018545249477028847, -0.011031463742256165, 0.0255607757717371, -0.02316715009510517, -0.05745885148644447, -0.005127128213644028, 0.02662057802081108, 0.0034249178133904934, 0.02838585525751114, -0.009517387486994267, 0.004097615368664265, 0.035901058465242386, -0.00906634982675314, 0.04028748348355293, 0.00860014371573925, -0.006440883968025446, -0.019378449767827988, 0.003829845692962408, -0.00589318061247468, 0.012823191471397877, 0.01188680250197649, 0.04524858668446541, -0.007311745081096888, 0.0419074185192585, -0.002992530120536685, 0.035900700837373734, 0.0032769241370260715, 0.0034113219007849693, 0.03419332206249237, -0.010686413384974003, -0.038548462092876434, 0.051543593406677246, -0.0111208101734519, 0.025695977732539177, -0.06224469467997551, -0.002583681605756283, -0.09863705188035965, -0.02239939756691456, 0.003141800407320261, 0.012674637138843536, 0.017638685181736946, 0.019223853945732117, 0.024901539087295532, 0.012515006586909294, 0.02239532396197319, -0.02011914551258087, -0.0016010345425456762, -0.02783532813191414, 0.013697695918381214, -0.018744179978966713, -0.007812656462192535, 0.020830996334552765, -0.0303652361035347, -0.049136657267808914, -0.03118273615837097, 0.02350689470767975, 0.061596378684043884, 0.03692934289574623, -0.04349381476640701, -0.03577478602528572, -0.013449243269860744, 0.0182226300239563, -0.030508095398545265, -0.001199629157781601, -0.035145290195941925, 0.011319772340357304, -0.004719219170510769, -0.013147318735718727 ]
<blockquote> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/BX2wm.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> </blockquote> <p><strong>My attempt at making sense of the problem:</strong><br> The problem provides us with the sum of squares (SS; I believe that's the $18.1$). We can use the SS along with the number of samples $(21)$ to get the standard error. Then somehow use this information to find the probability of having a worse fit?<br> After more research I believe the value given as $18.1$ is mean square deviation or sample variance and not the sum of squares. If this is true, then an <em>F</em>-test certainly makes sense for part <strong>b</strong>. </p> <p>Could someone guide me in the right direction and show me how to attempt this question?<br> Any help would be appreciated.</p>
74,250
[ -0.005256298463791609, -0.026968033984303474, -0.012133920565247536, 0.006044447887688875, 0.025649240240454674, 0.015635564923286438, 0.018338439986109734, -0.04372250288724899, 0.012020004913210869, 0.004365153610706329, 0.049378685653209686, 0.04116063565015793, 0.0436004213988781, 0.027142107486724854, 0.0011466534342616796, -0.015806134790182114, -0.028996147215366364, 0.0016101010842248797, 0.022915195673704147, -0.006147338543087244, 0.011362224817276001, 0.033084072172641754, -0.005341053940355778, -0.006460108328610659, -0.023019779473543167, 0.030054301023483276, 0.05145798996090889, -0.025477388873696327, 0.005667214281857014, 0.07764378190040588, -0.05216669291257858, -0.06621883809566498, 0.002643012208864093, 0.04164672642946243, 0.020251264795660973, -0.007295326329767704, -0.0028029396198689938, -0.003496900899335742, -0.042421724647283554, 0.04855712503194809, -0.04895319044589996, -0.02739153988659382, 0.006773767527192831, 0.02845093049108982, -0.012715011835098267, 0.03116323985159397, -0.01941973716020584, -0.046155158430337906, 0.014628331176936626, -0.029791254550218582, 0.0827362984418869, -0.0005910417530685663, 0.02312103658914566, 0.016185959801077843, -0.025023769587278366, -0.0485391765832901, 0.027511099353432655, 0.08337969332933426, -0.01675761118531227, -0.07109788060188293, 0.0020104278810322285, -0.03365437686443329, 0.01543571799993515, 0.004957580007612705, -0.026663370430469513, 0.016824834048748016, -0.05584847927093506, -0.025563711300492287, 0.027881769463419914, -0.025515222921967506, -0.00044111264287494123, 0.04461289197206497, 0.034787219017744064, -0.018237831071019173, 0.0019753617234528065, -0.002331098774448037, 0.02529687061905861, 0.05822834372520447, 0.040081221610307693, 0.007365171331912279, -0.01043790578842163, 0.008757894858717918, 0.02944788709282875, 0.035795655101537704, 0.02809130772948265, 0.000765244651120156, 0.057675912976264954, 0.004251949023455381, 0.016861578449606895, -0.006655212491750717, -0.0019408522639423609, 0.009401352144777775, 0.07040853798389435, 0.007034193258732557, -0.050497762858867645, 0.019026802852749825, -0.013491767458617687, 0.011325854808092117, 0.02820638380944729, -0.021534068509936333, -0.011993661522865295, -0.03844797611236572, 0.03016713075339794, 0.07483422011137009, -0.00009031571971718222, -0.0027233355212956667, -0.012790607288479805, -0.008657018654048443, 0.03492826595902443, -0.008975769393146038, 0.018820682540535927, 0.05567493662238121, 0.01709606684744358, -0.013262095861136913, -0.002171909436583519, 0.01935017667710781, -0.07681062072515488, -0.018872926011681557, 0.04113980010151863, 0.028705641627311707, 0.04556325450539589, -0.04769692197442055, 0.007474871817976236, -0.03461107239127159, -0.047062043100595474, 0.011672193184494972, -0.0019510019337758422, -0.012332175858318806, -0.024535883218050003, 0.05168192833662033, 0.009563698433339596, -0.018422076478600502, 0.03041141852736473, 0.03211667388677597, 0.017164669930934906, 0.029131684452295303, -0.0667625218629837, -0.09037729352712631, 0.05726584792137146, -0.039985645562410355, -0.022202210500836372, -0.03714602440595627, -0.03896990790963173, 0.010814121924340725, 0.07339280843734741, 0.0173608660697937, 0.04126501828432083, 0.0012164758518338203, 0.07153695821762085, 0.05317364260554314, 0.009666905738413334, -0.004475248046219349, -0.062482800334692, -0.04138454422354698, -0.03517746552824974, -0.06073009967803955, -0.011997914873063564, 0.006581333465874195, -0.013977959752082825, -0.04165783151984215, 0.004462975077331066, 0.028167352080345154, -0.012968478724360466, 0.014809120446443558, 0.001416312181390822, -0.002842127811163664, 0.07392513751983643, 0.050841864198446274, -0.01047835499048233, 0.0039023603312671185, 0.006801205221563578, 0.012268787249922752, 0.01858910545706749, -0.00010037953325081617, 0.034279778599739075, -0.03580714389681816, 0.019239360466599464, -0.015457844361662865, 0.010370402596890926, -0.003129132091999054, -0.039968930184841156, -0.04648912325501442, -0.020955035462975502, -0.007546177599579096, 0.02085822820663452, 0.047234904021024704, -0.0025457257870584726, -0.014055284671485424, 0.03730359673500061, -0.04494969919323921, -0.06093502417206764, -0.0739457756280899, -0.005683132912963629, 0.024696609005331993, -0.05212875455617905, 0.01835303008556366, 0.0020780719351023436, 0.04549813270568848, -0.024539213627576828, 0.03393634781241417, 0.0012211514404043555, -0.012593114748597145, 0.003351778257638216, -0.026925459504127502, 0.020665394142270088, 0.06250838190317154, 0.05242156982421875, 0.006219131406396627, 0.0452890507876873, -0.02954309619963169, -0.04869025573134422, -0.01279801968485117, -0.0832507535815239, 0.007088623475283384, -0.021199015900492668, -0.03511010482907295, 0.02394324168562889, 0.006142609752714634, 0.025385016575455666, 0.03308999165892601, -0.050228748470544815, 0.06635057926177979, 0.02172457054257393, 0.02123040333390236, 0.0011722121853381395, 0.01833319664001465, 0.042330849915742874, 0.014459270052611828, -0.024885445833206177, 0.0028977941256016493, -0.031232353299856186, -0.007549453992396593, 0.03382937237620354, -0.0035342895425856113, -0.02710329182446003, -0.009517352096736431, 0.0736672431230545, -0.016282156109809875, -0.002814228180795908, 0.05101339519023895, 0.022268852218985558, -0.01442937646061182, -0.018527785316109657, 0.014221863821148872, 0.0016561090014874935, 0.016662683337926865, -0.01649886555969715, 0.021865248680114746, 0.037207674235105515, 0.0027093396056443453, 0.011582517996430397, 0.011316449381411076, -0.024424627423286438, 0.024871597066521645, -0.03177950531244278, 0.0012626616517081857, 0.024556411430239677, -0.029206397011876106, -0.011467191390693188, 0.0263653714209795, -0.002724891062825918, 0.006180895492434502, -0.028830580413341522, -0.0493963249027729, 0.026142649352550507, 0.01568521186709404, -0.014530651271343231, -0.01009231898933649, 0.03840615972876549, -0.020905988290905952, 0.006888907868415117, 0.007029975298792124, -0.014162169769406319, -0.0029788780957460403, -0.034100066870450974, 0.011119277216494083, -0.01119955163449049, 0.015167484991252422, -0.029924696311354637, -0.015054745599627495, -0.045458149164915085, -0.0055170245468616486, 0.012128842994570732, 0.004025100264698267, -0.05980854481458664, -0.0050617847591638565, -0.02775464951992035, 0.004653443582355976, 0.018749181181192398, 0.004887943156063557, -0.008925550617277622, 0.0404975488781929, 0.017282068729400635, -0.02196950651705265, -0.002772395731881261, 0.000589826435316354, -0.038583312183618546, -0.05883974954485893, -0.04958618804812431, 0.04499182477593422, -0.011551184579730034, -0.020333129912614822, 0.0632748007774353, -0.05104243382811546, 0.00528751453384757, -0.03412585332989693, 0.002790225902572274, 0.01169976033270359, -0.0063435169868171215, 0.020775865763425827, -0.029663728550076485, 0.02004346065223217, -0.01976233720779419, -0.0460018552839756, -0.06894829124212265, 0.01369533408433199, 0.026024432852864265, 0.0544036403298378, 0.005605492275208235, -0.004389094654470682, 0.07421889156103134, 0.04751823842525482, -0.00895120669156313, -0.013332177884876728, 0.03473497927188873, -0.03125090152025223, -0.03671843186020851, 0.01658276468515396, 0.03156600892543793, 0.009655533358454704, 0.03375531733036041, -0.013044900260865688, 0.018097499385476112, 0.07108630239963531, -0.02546735107898712, -0.020224278792738914, 0.024150263518095016, -0.011512058787047863, -0.030050035566091537, 0.04742937907576561, -0.004595798905938864, 0.0005406687851063907, 0.013525698333978653, -0.02152397111058235, -0.003918168134987354, 0.04202237352728844, -0.041002724319696426, 0.0023594610393047333, -0.004309311509132385, 0.026714937761425972, -0.018554355949163437, 0.03247455880045891, -0.00900273397564888, -0.0005936074303463101, -0.015147218480706215, 0.00023440887161996216, 0.02792380191385746, -0.018921205773949623, 0.017360420897603035, 0.07411663979291916, 0.017949026077985764, -0.005411561578512192, -0.05484551191329956, 0.001434048404917121, -0.018453063443303108, 0.011782107874751091, 0.00496806763112545, -0.051626503467559814, 0.027168596163392067, 0.05647816136479378, 0.04325327277183533, -0.03257213905453682, -0.04005410522222519, -0.0030641593039035797, -0.03059026226401329, -0.04360916092991829, -0.03773721307516098, 0.028815647587180138, 0.0039062274154275656, 0.004914346616715193, -0.015697140246629715, -0.011094629764556885, 0.004457448609173298, 0.01944422535598278, -0.08092375099658966, 0.0524262860417366, 0.014752727001905441, 0.009270302020013332, -0.006758907809853554, -0.005493663251399994, 0.015637695789337158, -0.033075518906116486, 0.05781390517950058, 0.009859162382781506, 0.04557904601097107, -0.022037047892808914, 0.015086754225194454, -0.01775304041802883, 0.05327809229493141, -0.013996724970638752, 0.030240369960665703, 0.006346996407955885, -0.015242360532283783, -0.003054029541090131, 0.006830357015132904, -0.038100842386484146, -0.02366233803331852, -0.028911249712109566, 0.027705566957592964, 0.02720041573047638, 0.027483848854899406, -0.00759181147441268, 0.028449291363358498, -0.027392631396651268, 0.013551025651395321, -0.009798772633075714, 0.03157111629843712, 0.02534325048327446, -0.011655747890472412, 0.002254574093967676, -0.038394298404455185, -0.035461634397506714, 0.009663200937211514, 0.025291331112384796, 0.0004669865593314171, -0.003482429776340723, 0.03646210953593254, 0.006457758601754904, -0.0288369320333004, 0.013197969645261765, 0.06682726740837097, 0.014086655341088772, 0.013931718654930592, -0.058614637702703476, -0.013177506625652313, -0.019658682867884636, -0.029816148802638054, 0.021388793364167213, 0.007364993914961815, -0.009742521680891514, -0.029555048793554306, 0.051571886986494064, -0.0329054556787014, -0.05132515728473663, 0.012531294487416744, -0.04341430962085724, -0.004727299325168133, 0.026844128966331482, -0.05539359897375107, 0.01014542207121849, 0.07068464159965515, 0.04449792206287384, 0.019378332421183586, 0.02633136697113514, -0.03753672540187836, -0.019860412925481796, 0.060980524867773056, 0.05567113682627678, -0.004834563937038183, 0.027047445997595787, -0.045446205884218216, -0.025584153831005096, 0.02634783647954464, -0.020809434354305267, 0.033524610102176666, -0.014356652274727821, 0.012357343919575214, -0.05126943811774254, -0.048188626766204834, -0.06087641045451164, -0.017498204484581947, -0.012977044098079205, 0.024551941081881523, -0.021453483030200005, -0.03532339259982109, -0.004640312399715185, -0.006668854039162397, 0.043063901364803314, 0.06641348451375961, -0.03342446684837341, -0.015145385637879372, 0.014176937751471996, 0.041515983641147614, -0.05137116089463234, -0.05161101371049881, 0.032343585044145584, -0.013992640189826488, -0.006728735286742449, 0.03085191175341606, -0.07201181352138519, -0.044019244611263275, 0.06037644296884537, -0.013083530589938164, 0.015047905035316944, 0.015492661856114864, -0.02550235018134117, 0.0034120657946914434, 0.06040291488170624, 0.017364289611577988, 0.05158795416355133, 0.014898066408932209, 0.015875916928052902, 0.0351356603205204, -0.005016055889427662, -0.020579762756824493, -0.023578159511089325, -0.04452592879533768, -0.038398630917072296, -0.01925116591155529, -0.011868058703839779, 0.03643117472529411, 0.008899429813027382, 0.025054190307855606, -0.024876561015844345, -0.03187086060643196, 0.006033905781805515, -0.009964118711650372, -0.006445737089961767, 0.023306721821427345, 0.024471964687108994, 0.037327446043491364, 0.0018515243427827954, -0.017991527915000916, 0.02177610993385315, -0.0014243111945688725, 0.025067804381251335, 0.004546146374195814, -0.057161133736371994, 0.005534627940505743, -0.04676528647542, -0.014912618324160576, 0.021512338891625404, -0.053377289324998856, 0.04721704497933388, -0.03315998986363411, 0.001131154946051538, 0.0042937262915074825, -0.0165353175252676, 0.004652383737266064, -0.008842308074235916, -0.010254945605993271, 0.0515870526432991, -0.02882852964103222, 0.01741243340075016, 0.03777533769607544, -0.002538787666708231, -0.08790502697229385, -0.048907943069934845, -0.004324988462030888, 0.029372967779636383, -0.046228379011154175, -0.01141823548823595, 0.023133957758545876, -0.013356493785977364, -0.008128521032631397, -0.030672594904899597, 0.03925427421927452, 0.009062248282134533, -0.038629356771707535, -0.0018246157560497522, 0.039684563875198364, 0.07944843173027039, -0.024167660623788834, -0.01565626636147499, 0.022795813158154488, -0.038749560713768005, -0.04015051946043968, -0.0007387324585579336, -0.006517097819596529, -0.06279288977384567, -0.0061596655286848545, 0.0010010182159021497, 0.008770177140831947, 0.04264073446393013, 0.013269576244056225, -0.04720679298043251, -0.017333997413516045, 0.0014210542431101203, 0.024792799726128578, -0.014551728963851929, 0.051055554300546646, 0.007483280263841152, -0.0019637029618024826, -0.016453314572572708, 0.013092602603137493, 0.01587827503681183, -0.027848778292536736, 0.012006998993456364, 0.0013358849100768566, -0.05885469168424606, -0.006966637913137674, 0.08007671684026718, -0.0005978415138088167, -0.007061756681650877, 0.02561681903898716, -0.025645893067121506, 0.04332609474658966, 0.02578112483024597, 0.0576273538172245, 0.06206119433045387, 0.05395166575908661, -0.04818807169795036, -0.010772372595965862, -0.0370304249227047, -0.004847197327762842, 0.07363761216402054, -0.023922916501760483, 0.012015566229820251, 0.04653734713792801, -0.0053873187862336636, 0.02694367617368698, -0.0262135099619627, -0.023019835352897644, -0.0026532381307333708, 0.014708289876580238, 0.03843484818935394, 0.006604531779885292, 0.005389802623540163, 0.0235936027020216, -0.011842337436974049, 0.013312065973877907, 0.03324015066027641, 0.04174790531396866, 0.00961485505104065, 0.0473119392991066, -0.019173506647348404, -0.05203140899538994, 0.0446561761200428, -0.026532065123319626, 0.01757851615548134, -0.027256909757852554, 0.012543500401079655, 0.061874084174633026, 0.006172584369778633, 0.022038044407963753, -0.02118406817317009, -0.031462833285331726, -0.04272156208753586, -0.01631063036620617, 0.02254599705338478, -0.03537055477499962, 0.04822211340069771, 0.0032258215360343456, 0.02308066375553608, 0.006539303343743086, 0.03936852887272835, -0.040850214660167694, -0.05382484570145607, -0.020788569003343582, 0.01128597091883421, -0.05279521644115448, 0.045377932488918304, -0.0269046351313591, -0.011453251354396343, 0.028749892488121986, -0.03301423788070679, 0.01671982929110527, 0.0035289630759507418, 0.04289153963327408, -0.03554186224937439, 0.046497248113155365, 0.007814723066985607, -0.0028589079156517982, -0.0009732308681122959, 0.0073537095449864864, 0.11541834473609924, 0.038537900894880295, 0.052012111991643906, -0.041074346750974655, 0.04261216148734093, -0.00442490354180336, -0.03663187101483345, -0.006212559994310141, -0.01627604477107525, -0.006849818397313356, 0.012686062604188919, 0.0397227481007576, 0.06404271721839905, 0.015702733770012856, -0.007381546776741743, 0.022805817425251007, -0.04427019879221916, -0.023355990648269653, -0.013083784841001034, -0.008849188685417175, 0.004857854917645454, 0.000350494752638042, -0.025661202147603035, -0.0073689548298716545, 0.02550312876701355, -0.0029426368419080973, -0.01096488256007433, 0.005581340286880732, -0.03250851109623909, -0.008049000054597855, -0.02344154752790928, 0.017762480303645134, 0.003499815706163645, 0.006272032391279936, -0.060127198696136475, 0.01233227364718914, -0.004333887714892626, -0.04235704988241196, 0.021694038063287735, 0.010860378853976727, 0.010217917151749134, -0.003913732245564461, 0.0023021886590868235, 0.018693726509809494, -0.039482783526182175, -0.0048807524144649506, -0.04353788495063782, 0.024157702922821045, 0.029147882014513016, -0.02574339509010315, -0.0035777990706264973, -0.007723403163254261, -0.008459125645458698, -0.04764677584171295, 0.030415203422307968, -0.012317484244704247, 0.012980799190700054, -0.009080200456082821, -0.03822316601872444, -0.03187574818730354, 0.020259838551282883, -0.018372630700469017, -0.011468191631138325, 0.05939735099673271, -0.007643513847142458, -0.007952450774610043, 0.03137119114398956, 0.03438040241599083, 0.025487130507826805, 0.01606302335858345, -0.021252507343888283, -0.009245125576853752, -0.008252435363829136, 0.010381750762462616, 0.012538542971014977, -0.0017177030676975846, 0.055659517645835876, 0.013068290427327156, 0.011586173437535763, -0.039207763969898224, -0.07058434188365936, 0.012614642269909382, -0.04828300699591637, 0.023195603862404823, -0.03210387006402016, 0.0009106734651140869, 0.00543492566794157, 0.026726925745606422, 0.024987731128931046, 0.012124525383114815, 0.03808242082595825, 0.05734260007739067, 0.020153207704424858, -0.05118897557258606, -0.018053896725177765, -0.011714138090610504, -0.009119231253862381, 0.015167994424700737, 0.02406778186559677, 0.04636554792523384, 0.010126347653567791, 0.03823684900999069, 0.010591804049909115, 0.02052133157849312, -0.020395157858729362, -0.010532292537391186, -0.003371637314558029, -0.05923834443092346, -0.011093338020145893, 0.008238749578595161, 0.004962180741131306, -0.022169815376400948, 0.004980633035302162, -0.0355563648045063, -0.04924069717526436, 0.020349737256765366, -0.01801634021103382, -0.0365527980029583, 0.01680235005915165, -0.007130678277462721, -0.03554311394691467, -0.017638737335801125, 0.008713124319911003, -0.016781380400061607, -0.04627448320388794, -0.004364672116935253, -0.005393686704337597, -0.012425792403519154, 0.012942010536789894, -0.0023006070405244827, 0.0036949594505131245, 0.040788665413856506, -0.005957622546702623, 0.03304101899266243, 0.0029790299013257027, 0.02590412274003029, 0.021206311881542206, 0.0755087360739708, -0.022832464426755905, -0.0017854872858151793, 0.04634449630975723, -0.046355973929166794, -0.020653538405895233, 0.02957591786980629, -0.012102157808840275, -0.00020494974160101265, -0.008895167149603367, 0.007088885642588139, 0.004016438499093056, 0.031462617218494415, -0.029334811493754387, -0.004675658885389566, -0.03203556314110756, -0.009342051111161709, 0.0118844173848629, -0.0070720543153584, 0.009696579538285732, 0.02590898983180523, 0.016189435496926308, 0.0016349435318261385, 0.02830074541270733, -0.05253511667251587, 0.022293666377663612, 0.014740793034434319, -0.022065041586756706, 0.030556853860616684, -0.026141954585909843, 0.014572515152394772, 0.01847616769373417, 0.017818359658122063, -0.014622604474425316, 0.02993057668209076, -0.036566540598869324, -0.022833306342363358, -0.08608312159776688, -0.03223872557282448, 0.007463906891644001, 0.02901756763458252, 0.02078988403081894, -0.06279066205024719, -0.022683044895529747, 0.05110669508576393, -0.041637517511844635, -0.002410717075690627, 0.02829582616686821, -0.02810567058622837, -0.04538470506668091, -0.010941287502646446, -0.03934631124138832, 0.03191370517015457, 0.0029380740597844124, 0.039867106825113297, 0.043755993247032166, 0.053368158638477325, -0.041269365698099136, -0.031009169295430183, 0.008722346276044846, 0.03428046777844429, 0.02103397250175476, -0.08031083643436432, 0.021766575053334236, 0.004386238753795624, -0.03062904253602028, 0.03827566280961037, -0.00688306475058198, 0.04590864107012749, -0.012060240842401981, -0.012412109412252903, -0.025388598442077637, 0.029604632407426834, 0.040796540677547455, 0.011873076669871807, 0.017466643825173378, -0.0029723590705543756, 0.005590534768998623, 0.04154203087091446, -0.04561387374997139, -0.00020615661924239248, 0.03614651784300804, -0.020457837730646133, -0.045898258686065674, -0.044360678642988205, -0.021272102370858192, 0.007926221005618572, -0.013425013981759548, -0.009521602652966976, 0.017424538731575012, -0.05447250232100487, 0.01205467525869608, -0.0222763754427433, 0.01184784434735775, 0.05647649988532066, 0.02526070736348629, -0.011088426224887371, 0.021695507690310478, 0.024973807856440544, -0.020070785656571388, 0.002105533145368099, 0.012090419419109821, -0.005857435520738363, -0.03573613986372948, -0.017496466636657715, -0.01482806820422411, -0.010704487562179565, -0.018433108925819397, -0.015939580276608467, -0.02234088070690632, 0.029908999800682068, -0.011265858076512814, 0.010688305832445621, 0.008959109894931316, -0.026211895048618317, 0.012601960450410843, -0.11533817648887634, 0.048350539058446884, -0.009334739297628403, -0.026656968519091606, 0.007447920739650726, -0.006610231474041939, -0.0032920530065894127, -0.017424145713448524, 0.03279615938663483, 0.017193090170621872, 0.015131461434066296, 0.011609621345996857, 0.029425647109746933, 0.024338865652680397, -0.0461266003549099, 0.057287149131298065, -0.03306695073843002, 0.004848945420235395, 0.00833903905004263, -0.01615075208246708, 0.03265955671668053, -0.01014454010874033, -0.0012786505976691842, -0.0004942003288306296, 0.0005014027119614184, -0.034630317240953445, 0.005775324068963528, 0.04672456532716751, -0.010702153667807579, -0.02142864651978016, 0.07030287384986877, -0.0030384159181267023, 0.025768812745809555, 0.012378680519759655, -0.024208471179008484, -0.06667404621839523, 0.0031347316689789295, -0.031162776052951813, -0.01672632247209549, 0.014013375155627728, 0.01783047430217266, 0.0037921443581581116, -0.0573602095246315, -0.044709350913763046, 0.032381124794483185, -0.031531061977148056, 0.02627832628786564, 0.026471149176359177, 0.02728954516351223, 0.000001369017013530538, 0.0054427203722298145, 0.0007505755056627095, 0.0032289393711835146, -0.04220160096883774, 0.0011024991981685162, -0.02312135137617588, 0.057260967791080475, -0.010331321507692337, 0.004843271337449551, 0.033658090978860855, -0.02520792931318283, 0.011621049605309963, -0.008316253311932087, 0.030309462919831276, -0.031735859811306, 0.011990752071142197, 0.01861167885363102, 0.022124985232949257, 0.0057598077692091465, -0.02713439241051674, -0.0024082970339804888, 0.08006081730127335, -0.03323020786046982, 0.004237250424921513, -0.0298375952988863, -0.0017527691088616848, 0.00006890811346238479, -0.015549988485872746, 0.07008384168148041, 0.01056869886815548, 0.020306237041950226, 0.011337896808981895, -0.00565580278635025, 0.01215363759547472, 0.04046732932329178, -0.012076950632035732, 0.00708225229755044, -0.0012127315858379006, -0.009963530115783215, -0.028496524319052696, -0.014497017487883568, -0.012038186192512512, -0.014520113356411457, -0.004632153082638979, 0.028355062007904053, -0.012443489395081997, -0.01846044883131981, -0.013137434609234333, -0.01352336723357439, 0.07418692111968994, -0.029165446758270264, -0.00307105528190732, -0.05105001851916313, 0.008668538182973862, -0.048202794045209885, -0.054708682000637054 ]
<p>To check if unilateral pairs (defined below*) are coordinated (i.e. move together) in a flock of N coordinated individuals, we generate hypothetical (null) distribution of a certain focal parameter of our system (the frequency that 2 individuals are nearest neighbors along a track). The null model is simulated by shuffling the empirical data in a way that should break down coordination among pairs (changing the initial conditions and the fluctuations from the mean path along the track), repeated 5000 times. We then calculate the very same parameter for all N(N-1) unilateral pairs in the empirical data. For each unilateral pair, the null distribution should indicate the probability of getting the empirical value (or higher) of the focal parameter if the flock moves without coordination among pairs. But since we check all possible N(N-1) unilateral pairs, we engage multiple comparisons. We would greatly appreciate suggestions how to correct for multiple comparisons in this case.</p> <ul> <li>unilateral pairs - (A->B) or (B->A) but not necessarily A&lt;->B (this is a bilateral pair)</li> </ul> <p>Best wishes,</p> <p>Ran</p>
37,011
[ -0.05224447697401047, -0.01468673162162304, 0.00704979756847024, 0.01851052977144718, 0.05068323016166687, -0.014366352930665016, 0.007537988945841789, -0.036489829421043396, -0.007098620291799307, -0.016991065815091133, 0.04126133769750595, 0.05199065059423447, 0.02638906240463257, 0.04687526822090149, -0.017934437841176987, -0.012360760010778904, -0.036711424589157104, 0.0046250405721366405, -0.012236475013196468, -0.029623715206980705, -0.027601171284914017, -0.010610305704176426, 0.02980158105492592, -0.02305440418422222, -0.016144078224897385, 0.02965792827308178, 0.021422799676656723, -0.036763451993465424, -0.016383863985538483, 0.0668092668056488, -0.0781494677066803, 0.0021299594081938267, 0.03213461488485336, 0.04840392991900444, 0.041875164955854416, 0.048140160739421844, -0.038815051317214966, 0.001018125331029296, -0.054898492991924286, 0.014486288651823997, 0.007771970704197884, -0.007274842355400324, -0.02836395427584648, 0.03785787522792816, -0.016045134514570236, 0.0022157947532832623, 0.010078905150294304, 0.012226713821291924, 0.03435128182172775, -0.04539528861641884, 0.0766257494688034, 0.017295382916927338, 0.003974133636802435, -0.009711114689707756, -0.005616443697363138, -0.020538218319416046, 0.05540198087692261, 0.06665154546499252, 0.0176236629486084, -0.08547807484865189, -0.0094130365177989, -0.056984297931194305, -0.004588027019053698, -0.031001616269350052, -0.026159795001149178, 0.02003554068505764, -0.0018574678106233478, -0.022332023829221725, 0.030947286635637283, 0.003409154247492552, 0.014078875072300434, -0.0002849549346137792, 0.04314767196774483, -0.01468205451965332, 0.0011681296164169908, -0.02150050178170204, 0.009071812964975834, 0.028317492455244064, 0.04024694859981537, 0.03652256727218628, -0.012397349812090397, 0.01820608414709568, 0.03247014805674553, 0.009061873890459538, 0.032919514924287796, -0.06142257899045944, 0.06103143468499184, 0.0019365160260349512, 0.006360951345413923, -0.04051634296774864, 0.002757962327450514, -0.031035728752613068, 0.04798649251461029, -0.029074644669890404, -0.05714152380824089, 0.029204996302723885, 0.00698950607329607, 0.0027073505334556103, -0.013231340795755386, -0.016766659915447235, -0.0117189921438694, -0.07363803684711456, 0.0033214956056326628, 0.03443736955523491, -0.005298220086842775, 0.01507076621055603, -0.05528534948825836, 0.012019864283502102, -0.03282574191689491, -0.014113633893430233, -0.053484220057725906, 0.02029862068593502, 0.011463494971394539, 0.026817617937922478, 0.025973891839385033, 0.01754545047879219, -0.01532645896077156, 0.01782381162047386, 0.057695817202329636, 0.06093936413526535, 0.0472320020198822, -0.009461934678256512, 0.020210828632116318, -0.04172762110829353, -0.04118127003312111, 0.02184116281569004, -0.023191777989268303, 0.0007626094738952816, -0.023434001952409744, 0.07511782646179199, 0.026689641177654266, -0.00059679796686396, 0.026134606450796127, -0.009405598044395447, 0.03257427364587784, 0.025741979479789734, -0.06625189632177353, -0.0664716586470604, 0.038841571658849716, -0.030811168253421783, 0.03886627405881882, -0.05278956890106201, -0.014011889696121216, 0.010159110650420189, 0.06585823744535446, -0.028546271845698357, 0.033815834671258926, -0.017861654981970787, 0.034276921302080154, 0.042116470634937286, 0.008524427190423012, -0.0052620344795286655, -0.05961716175079346, -0.04919353127479553, -0.019109169021248817, -0.057713832706213, 0.022107992321252823, -0.001225868472829461, -0.0028200142551213503, 0.002602211432531476, 0.031913213431835175, 0.01695217192173004, -0.00034884203341789544, 0.0014333019498735666, 0.011873187497258186, -0.01902242749929428, 0.06409156322479248, 0.012878114357590675, -0.017322856932878494, 0.012203252874314785, 0.010011738166213036, 0.029382597655057907, -0.011430282145738602, 0.02776685543358326, 0.054863616824150085, -0.03664097934961319, 0.02370712347328663, -0.01649213768541813, -0.004134633112698793, 0.0058858743868768215, 0.005029145162552595, -0.018531663343310356, -0.05224931612610817, -0.016350599005818367, -0.0001474123855587095, 0.03376194089651108, -0.021476255729794502, -0.01763991452753544, 0.0227348655462265, -0.053503792732954025, -0.054130129516124725, -0.05366260185837746, -0.03260282427072525, 0.004123516380786896, -0.040740467607975006, 0.06729252636432648, -0.010811001993715763, 0.044857047498226166, -0.02390468679368496, -0.015998682007193565, -0.027164965867996216, 0.00916075985878706, 0.06752420961856842, -0.024295419454574585, 0.02256370522081852, 0.07708223164081573, 0.03659337759017944, -0.0048694610595703125, 0.05126446858048439, -0.010800214484333992, -0.016330536454916, -0.008653748780488968, -0.045030105859041214, -0.006600317545235157, 0.03907233104109764, -0.008490197360515594, 0.0016890001716092229, 0.025451702997088432, 0.009754963219165802, -0.0016344583127647638, -0.02513755112886429, 0.02979320101439953, 0.04071757197380066, -0.0179213248193264, 0.028725340962409973, 0.04427085816860199, 0.020576920360326767, -0.016532190144062042, 0.0002152317319996655, -0.04043899476528168, -0.07259394228458405, -0.0045888349413871765, 0.0362970344722271, 0.007972984574735165, -0.02199852652847767, 0.011553194373846054, 0.04466348886489868, 0.02072903886437416, 0.007600446697324514, 0.01443660631775856, -0.038488924503326416, -0.01890713907778263, 0.016222739592194557, 0.030954349786043167, 0.0238961149007082, 0.004605267662554979, 0.02046329900622368, -0.02323843538761139, 0.01590014062821865, -0.012988858856260777, -0.036118537187576294, -0.005362385418266058, 0.010829804465174675, 0.0018629690166562796, -0.00014170353824738413, -0.00988593976944685, 0.028344932943582535, 0.046360962092876434, 0.03929806128144264, 0.058597464114427567, -0.006564459763467312, -0.02197909541428089, 0.025153247639536858, -0.008767133578658104, 0.02214796654880047, -0.005692126229405403, -0.03320707008242607, -0.008224465884268284, 0.02589748054742813, -0.03143979609012604, 0.007956799119710922, -0.03539435565471649, -0.036410924047231674, -0.02484152838587761, -0.025175215676426888, 0.028308076784014702, 0.022166727110743523, 0.006299578119069338, -0.0429435633122921, -0.02069249376654625, -0.0037832611706107855, 0.030515111982822418, 0.022738728672266006, 0.03584420308470726, -0.0590394102036953, 0.010524407029151917, 0.001232579699717462, -0.014263087883591652, 0.009718633256852627, -0.0025626581627875566, -0.022308457642793655, 0.03612946718931198, -0.014958116225898266, -0.06660358607769012, -0.03346467763185501, -0.044894132763147354, -0.008143916726112366, -0.04039660841226578, 0.011914025992155075, 0.034931205213069916, -0.01175736915320158, -0.05757801607251167, 0.03068179078400135, -0.03678149729967117, -0.009992287494242191, 0.0005531481001526117, -0.020297527313232422, 0.0171795841306448, -0.002681051380932331, -0.003581716911867261, 0.00624079629778862, -0.009267322719097137, -0.005493014119565487, -0.0838983878493309, -0.062182746827602386, 0.0025981583166867495, -0.006099341437220573, 0.07338245958089828, -0.0019988729618489742, -0.010539539158344269, 0.05138290300965309, 0.034863926470279694, -0.02641538716852665, -0.021664999425411224, 0.055136244744062424, -0.04195036366581917, 0.014048022218048573, 0.02290305122733116, 0.015554096549749374, 0.029921507462859154, 0.010872195474803448, 0.03031824715435505, 0.019153902307152748, 0.08102457970380783, -0.0003424677415750921, -0.014399882405996323, 0.013980761170387268, 0.019418176263570786, -0.012742314487695694, 0.008639277890324593, 0.026620404794812202, -0.019780198112130165, 0.03450419753789902, 0.03329479694366455, -0.03336040675640106, -0.004970827605575323, -0.0472211018204689, 0.026088546961545944, 0.013392610475420952, 0.01330192293971777, -0.012741899117827415, 0.012785403989255428, 0.041794389486312866, -0.03314602002501488, -0.010937638580799103, 0.030471913516521454, 0.06000038981437683, 0.02623404935002327, -0.01811734214425087, 0.06842663884162903, 0.023048140108585358, -0.026342719793319702, -0.032700881361961365, -0.014973669312894344, -0.00034824584145098925, -0.020356792956590652, 0.003927635960280895, -0.03250950574874878, 0.029170503839850426, 0.020386073738336563, 0.01616307906806469, 0.025600453838706017, -0.02672176994383335, -0.01704396866261959, -0.026430359110236168, 0.036137886345386505, -0.0852501317858696, 0.023935489356517792, -0.0008894552011042833, -0.01488867774605751, 0.011958283372223377, 0.003836052492260933, -0.026886694133281708, 0.03762252256274223, -0.048781752586364746, 0.0368223637342453, 0.004050057847052813, -0.030310746282339096, 0.022902073338627815, -0.020618783310055733, -0.006801717448979616, -0.05794239416718483, 0.034747183322906494, 0.0314384363591671, 0.02193063125014305, -0.036328308284282684, 0.00427491869777441, -0.05207698047161102, -0.01995105855166912, -0.010976049117743969, 0.0025673892814666033, 0.04326149821281433, -0.03496336564421654, 0.07172787934541702, 0.03001014143228531, -0.0015091156819835305, 0.00588493887335062, -0.05147579312324524, 0.0077507677488029, -0.02668684907257557, 0.03837436065077782, 0.011539368890225887, 0.030134230852127075, -0.02483297884464264, -0.00401587737724185, 0.001989801647141576, 0.03309227526187897, 0.06224299594759941, 0.03280666097998619, 0.008682643063366413, -0.06386567652225494, -0.03967924416065216, 0.017660092562437057, 0.004544134717434645, 0.02063954435288906, 0.005315100774168968, 0.03973294794559479, 0.04917880892753601, -0.003283326281234622, 0.008934264071285725, 0.06101429462432861, 0.015370547771453857, -0.01499191578477621, -0.024092568084597588, -0.060512788593769073, 0.05775732174515724, 0.017571402713656425, 0.04523191228508949, 0.019805822521448135, -0.014260290190577507, -0.01288451999425888, 0.00994564127177, 0.03393952548503876, -0.023216143250465393, 0.009123561903834343, -0.05033328756690025, 0.054706547409296036, -0.01243154052644968, 0.0023491322062909603, -0.011447670869529247, 0.007049475330859423, 0.0042649866081774235, 0.03259306401014328, -0.014343805611133575, -0.07606454938650131, -0.011279614642262459, 0.054023850709199905, 0.033355534076690674, -0.03710281476378441, 0.020972536876797676, -0.025231916457414627, -0.029034467414021492, 0.0192436370998621, -0.01764475367963314, 0.009656775742769241, -0.0018695307662710547, -0.009850596077740192, -0.0071613965556025505, -0.019384214654564857, -0.047805435955524445, 0.024680012837052345, -0.009375450201332569, 0.046531420201063156, -0.045264746993780136, -0.001982053043320775, -0.02973410300910473, 0.010773536749184132, 0.0015136536676436663, 0.047809358686208725, 0.02013164944946766, -0.018131425604224205, 0.008146433159708977, -0.019896507263183594, 0.005308535415679216, -0.08177857846021652, 0.04128647595643997, 0.01521422527730465, -0.006926254369318485, 0.04266512021422386, -0.01681016944348812, -0.012190482579171658, 0.015094407834112644, -0.02449241280555725, -0.03762942552566528, -0.008143958635628223, -0.0147376274690032, 0.0504545234143734, 0.023853724822402, 0.024964334443211555, 0.049368150532245636, -0.00422061700373888, -0.017111506313085556, 0.0167611725628376, -0.02129938267171383, 0.008476102724671364, -0.002106433967128396, 0.04216233640909195, -0.031024018302559853, 0.012431610375642776, -0.030533215031027794, 0.05169503018260002, -0.016142001375555992, 0.03524123132228851, 0.03148718178272247, 0.02140173874795437, -0.03624051436781883, 0.0065219830721616745, 0.018717985600233078, 0.013609896413981915, 0.029712172225117683, 0.023998497053980827, -0.022131696343421936, -0.003754247911274433, -0.00405571423470974, -0.05895622447133064, -0.008065962232649326, 0.008340478874742985, -0.051404137164354324, 0.000006219635451998329, -0.011662148870527744, -0.013669575564563274, 0.0046051908284425735, -0.049630820751190186, 0.03604986518621445, 0.004198347683995962, 0.028425222262740135, 0.030453937128186226, -0.02932543121278286, -0.04891622066497803, 0.024931684136390686, 0.002911297371610999, 0.011447727680206299, -0.041084013879299164, 0.014038310386240482, -0.028467731550335884, 0.002234150655567646, -0.03382309898734093, 0.019015710800886154, 0.034165628254413605, 0.018003372475504875, 0.0009517709841020405, -0.047715406864881516, -0.017898453399538994, -0.005084095522761345, 0.004123346414417028, -0.009700869210064411, 0.049512315541505814, -0.021886106580495834, -0.03483692929148674, -0.01050194539129734, 0.016777800396084785, 0.0736285001039505, 0.0008019029628485441, 0.008230944164097309, 0.03565393015742302, -0.022687476128339767, -0.010716203600168228, 0.0007321191369555891, 0.03612345829606056, -0.03598494082689285, -0.05428364500403404, 0.0029997210949659348, -0.01526925340294838, 0.03655954822897911, -0.056225087493658066, -0.022718079388141632, 0.0016402420587837696, -0.04623761400580406, -0.006031854543834925, -0.01083640567958355, -0.03420586138963699, -0.012816146947443485, -0.005659079644829035, 0.001705774338915944, 0.019835883751511574, 0.010367220267653465, -0.02693902514874935, 0.008969618938863277, 0.03259965777397156, -0.04427992179989815, 0.016417400911450386, 0.04908360540866852, 0.02432841621339321, -0.019641732797026634, -0.001769657013937831, -0.03353845328092575, 0.06046786159276962, -0.016508527100086212, -0.017780371010303497, 0.014093741774559021, 0.025466732680797577, -0.06314608454704285, 0.02255598083138466, -0.0013855670113116503, -0.013609891757369041, 0.07674156129360199, -0.02164202183485031, 0.016251027584075928, 0.02514495700597763, 0.023129049688577652, 0.010154170915484428, -0.01249087043106556, 0.007521904073655605, -0.01768764853477478, 0.05775716155767441, 0.010494756512343884, -0.0175163671374321, -0.007928322069346905, 0.045780401676893234, 0.04459257423877716, 0.05401894450187683, 0.024857178330421448, 0.04304806515574455, 0.025415807962417603, 0.04730185493826866, -0.04098817706108093, -0.027246875688433647, 0.04809039831161499, -0.08474081754684448, 0.010762129910290241, -0.021447010338306427, -0.038704145699739456, 0.027510033920407295, 0.027361949905753136, -0.011519093066453934, -0.011354171670973301, -0.02861299179494381, -0.04643012210726738, 0.046729836612939835, 0.022617796435952187, -0.020430775359272957, 0.019813092425465584, -0.003075698623433709, 0.06133699789643288, -0.008343348279595375, 0.020047016441822052, -0.031147921457886696, -0.06379131972789764, -0.0074164713732898235, -0.010870925150811672, -0.00604766421020031, 0.013768131844699383, -0.017573969438672066, -0.0014930851757526398, 0.03237554430961609, 0.015319476835429668, 0.004047548398375511, -0.015577693469822407, 0.02756069414317608, -0.026101863011717796, 0.08662714809179306, 0.019207969307899475, 0.0234458539634943, -0.013368235900998116, -0.022173656150698662, 0.12507890164852142, 0.01883431151509285, 0.029336538165807724, -0.03469860181212425, 0.0250382199883461, 0.019376616925001144, 0.01187894307076931, -0.018725598230957985, -0.015385321341454983, 0.038662172853946686, 0.022996334359049797, 0.017959780991077423, 0.03263581916689873, 0.03580266982316971, -0.03649437054991722, 0.04938304051756859, -0.03184765577316284, -0.06979966163635254, 0.004876797553151846, -0.01753919944167137, 0.028187736868858337, -0.031753119081258774, -0.019734496250748634, 0.013334711082279682, 0.019551550969481468, 0.01588604785501957, -0.0207060556858778, 0.02256244234740734, 0.012148326262831688, 0.04569332301616669, 0.006624510977417231, 0.011876426637172699, 0.03250942751765251, 0.02879343368113041, 0.009773213416337967, -0.005973299033939838, -0.017138289287686348, -0.028952201828360558, 0.03712188079953194, 0.02587064914405346, 0.006422050297260284, 0.029589513316750526, 0.0416981503367424, -0.030299175530672073, -0.012245780788362026, -0.023735640570521355, -0.019569922238588333, 0.04069463908672333, -0.008004292845726013, -0.016285354271531105, 0.0032717622816562653, -0.012324688024818897, 0.006126471795141697, -0.01821635290980339, -0.012977038510143757, -0.02741285227239132, 0.010188312269747257, -0.026858804747462273, -0.005117094609886408, -0.012062336318194866, 0.008553272113204002, 0.01076890155673027, 0.030092688277363777, 0.03751736879348755, -0.010845336131751537, -0.07753638178110123, -0.02218039706349373, 0.12477342039346695, 0.02426486648619175, 0.01588473841547966, -0.056328609585762024, -0.0161827951669693, -0.03249543905258179, -0.016173426061868668, 0.024390453472733498, 0.006489650346338749, 0.03101613186299801, 0.0029454538598656654, 0.0039397249929606915, -0.0005864888662472367, -0.04083068668842316, -0.0408751405775547, -0.004696349147707224, -0.02108405902981758, -0.03650679811835289, -0.008761619217693806, 0.028032807633280754, -0.0031001369934529066, 0.004558119457215071, 0.016551751643419266, -0.0376180075109005, 0.038575179874897, -0.006618761457502842, -0.024395756423473358, -0.06376871466636658, -0.02694520726799965, -0.00977424718439579, 0.010272866114974022, -0.008693905547261238, 0.06271330267190933, 0.020850785076618195, 0.04217394068837166, 0.0033542870078235865, 0.012888754718005657, -0.001719892956316471, -0.022636225447058678, 0.017895888537168503, -0.06561056524515152, -0.0300095546990633, 0.039726316928863525, -0.033507052809000015, -0.04434584453701973, -0.02792816236615181, -0.030809497460722923, -0.046951793134212494, 0.011199974454939365, -0.003003874095156789, -0.04873531684279442, -0.014491396024823189, -0.03264553099870682, 0.0448821522295475, -0.03151378408074379, 0.04301048070192337, 0.00842839851975441, -0.018410880118608475, -0.04833315685391426, 0.0012065230403095484, -0.01585773192346096, -0.009232367388904095, 0.011705227196216583, 0.006206931546330452, 0.01096542552113533, -0.02190159633755684, 0.04107077419757843, 0.011922899633646011, -0.006093455012887716, -0.0024944308679550886, 0.06441579759120941, -0.009951937012374401, -0.02974982187151909, 0.038249533623456955, -0.01513991691172123, -0.02831745520234108, -0.015770655125379562, 0.030965372920036316, 0.05534433200955391, -0.017432890832424164, -0.03415367752313614, 0.0031691717449575663, 0.025818347930908203, -0.06801111996173859, -0.009556702338159084, -0.017839765176177025, 0.03451922908425331, 0.0013224093709141016, -0.0011036301730200648, 0.007178677245974541, -0.025853734463453293, -0.010701355524361134, 0.023222055286169052, 0.032755687832832336, 0.009161313064396381, 0.004336728248745203, 0.0037560586351901293, -0.01728174462914467, 0.026792502030730247, 0.01247505284845829, 0.011287068948149681, -0.008262506686151028, 0.038629692047834396, 0.012486331164836884, 0.024020148441195488, -0.03950677812099457, 0.01142194028943777, -0.06312292814254761, -0.01722300611436367, 0.013943372294306755, -0.022402165457606316, 0.039242424070835114, -0.04182957485318184, 0.020730799064040184, 0.028914788737893105, -0.040120549499988556, 0.031384292989969254, -0.006825871765613556, -0.040892407298088074, -0.07240661978721619, 0.010266848839819431, -0.04681248962879181, 0.005212424788624048, -0.000917198252864182, 0.021023837849497795, 0.006231199484318495, -0.005212244112044573, -0.006150569301098585, -0.026262033730745316, 0.00483944034203887, -0.012304279021918774, -0.01178794540464878, -0.0637204498052597, 0.007218543440103531, -0.031625352799892426, -0.03624631091952324, 0.03211827203631401, -0.05356786027550697, -0.002207808429375291, -0.023810975253582, 0.0342148058116436, 0.0229925736784935, 0.05134683847427368, -0.007301483768969774, 0.008097060024738312, 0.017453644424676895, 0.020623305812478065, 0.013111315667629242, 0.035093337297439575, -0.04130478575825691, 0.013337504118680954, 0.0026483144611120224, 0.011721901595592499, -0.017048528417944908, 0.028214087709784508, -0.030328495427966118, -0.016371849924325943, 0.014607507735490799, -0.01404179260134697, 0.0074189649894833565, -0.01858067326247692, -0.01409203466027975, 0.008733521215617657, 0.008612950332462788, 0.02707674913108349, 0.04914340004324913, -0.010914983227849007, 0.011955012567341328, -0.021346010267734528, -0.02356613241136074, 0.0064207809045910835, -0.01559770293533802, 0.006867830641567707, -0.03529347479343414, 0.0030136366840451956, -0.03326917067170143, 0.01235375925898552, -0.0321359783411026, -0.020657692104578018, -0.01967756077647209, 0.041236646473407745, -0.04450816661119461, 0.017688609659671783, 0.02593253366649151, -0.008583290502429008, -0.011939067393541336, -0.07922038435935974, 0.045630838721990585, 0.02001836709678173, 0.019160376861691475, -0.027506941929459572, -0.014175629243254662, -0.021936966106295586, 0.05099405720829964, 0.025128541514277458, 0.006359931081533432, 0.012943103909492493, 0.036984823644161224, 0.017409279942512512, 0.02562336064875126, -0.05228939652442932, 0.003152154851704836, -0.04837232828140259, -0.00611078878864646, -0.000286232796497643, -0.06512390822172165, -0.021612269803881645, 0.007326385006308556, 0.021420270204544067, -0.0029413446318358183, 0.0191945917904377, 0.037258245050907135, -0.03297131881117821, 0.005429642274975777, 0.009302375838160515, 0.011611678637564182, 0.043701525777578354, 0.03691958636045456, 0.01403079554438591, -0.0035393384750932455, 0.005211326293647289, -0.04965290427207947, 0.041143812239170074, -0.09069200605154037, -0.05738486722111702, 0.007459054701030254, 0.034915000200271606, 0.023276984691619873, -0.0658915787935257, 0.015193702653050423, 0.024257652461528778, -0.030510377138853073, 0.011226317845284939, -0.008904256857931614, 0.03195314109325409, 0.028184063732624054, -0.012590265832841396, 0.02789473719894886, -0.012421770952641964, -0.019100071862339973, -0.0015303329564630985, 0.025810083374381065, -0.0003278506628703326, 0.006309265270829201, 0.0059458729811012745, 0.03038313239812851, -0.04857347160577774, 0.04410169646143913, -0.017300747334957123, 0.041653405874967575, -0.02821624092757702, -0.033112235367298126, 0.0468205101788044, 0.009540412575006485, 0.006260931491851807, -0.01940627582371235, 0.02400929667055607, 0.06737436354160309, -0.03698926791548729, 0.018827002495527267, 0.004412978887557983, 0.016979625448584557, -0.007660286501049995, 0.023554064333438873, 0.032840460538864136, 0.002615115372464061, -0.0073927100747823715, -0.0002211749815614894, -0.031212761998176575, -0.02876683510839939, 0.07127591222524643, -0.05763307958841324, 0.026869960129261017, -0.008902586065232754, -0.014707936905324459, 0.03576185181736946, -0.010425400920212269, -0.04783511161804199, -0.015174441039562225, 0.013431038707494736, 0.035199135541915894, -0.004061264451593161, -0.0039831423200666904, -0.026644650846719742, 0.0008490611216984689, 0.05860530585050583, -0.06188872829079628, -0.02020835317671299, -0.04354139789938927, 0.012207620777189732, -0.017961153760552406, -0.01370544359087944 ]
<p>I have been using JAGS but I am not quite sure how it actually simulates it values. I need to know in a general sense what's going on in the background. </p> <p>Thanks for the help</p>
37,013
[ 0.008368224836885929, -0.05861710011959076, 0.02872431091964245, 0.012145145796239376, 0.041888151317834854, 0.024227943271398544, 0.028734564781188965, -0.019006315618753433, 0.0023634969256818295, -0.02129841037094593, 0.03768976777791977, 0.047080881893634796, 0.0015974495327100158, 0.05227156728506088, -0.02127785235643387, -0.004750560969114304, -0.004427633713930845, -0.017671510577201843, -0.0029951774049550295, -0.022648094221949577, -0.009794673882424831, -0.012578115798532963, -0.010135948657989502, -0.0332874171435833, -0.010141758248209953, 0.0018297035712748766, 0.024291757494211197, -0.054891135543584824, 0.0010557236382737756, 0.07066553831100464, -0.046918295323848724, -0.010840075090527534, -0.028081009164452553, 0.0481887012720108, 0.012297254055738449, 0.013873310759663582, -0.020707974210381508, -0.06842071563005447, 0.005012090317904949, 0.06156882643699646, -0.03231058269739151, -0.009602440521121025, -0.030843697488307953, 0.016619663685560226, 0.00326411216519773, 0.010441030375659466, 0.0035955628845840693, -0.0014395153848454356, 0.022404098883271217, -0.0407397635281086, 0.07745712250471115, 0.0022290002088993788, 0.007101020310074091, 0.02776932902634144, -0.0037967993412166834, -0.011262028478085995, 0.0776975154876709, 0.024083608761429787, 0.013264968059957027, -0.05161706730723381, 0.01173174474388361, -0.01330629363656044, -0.03572031483054161, -0.009011736139655113, 0.0038296966813504696, -0.002518674358725548, 0.01737842708826065, -0.036384690552949905, 0.03497970476746559, 0.017067890614271164, -0.0010026355739682913, 0.035940464586019516, 0.035557638853788376, 0.019025471061468124, 0.07500259578227997, -0.047136642038822174, 0.07073178142309189, 0.03764265030622482, 0.03980768844485283, 0.01984606683254242, 0.02446240372955799, 0.00931144505739212, 0.01060451753437519, 0.042106322944164276, 0.03843080997467041, -0.0025066379457712173, 0.05285966396331787, -0.04166288301348686, 0.03984156996011734, 0.019711272791028023, -0.05419260263442993, 0.0009641780634410679, 0.029170770198106766, 0.02935943752527237, -0.044922783970832825, -0.011637276969850063, -0.01467137597501278, 0.06682102382183075, 0.012729054316878319, 0.006486330647021532, -0.0005203539622016251, -0.046229179948568344, 0.0005994081730023026, 0.026199817657470703, -0.010405032895505428, -0.0003428410564083606, 0.011307597160339355, -0.052203189581632614, 0.008891504257917404, -0.00045438698725774884, -0.05603793263435364, -0.002476207911968231, -0.004961560945957899, -0.018045058473944664, 0.05467284843325615, -0.0263485349714756, -0.010085413232445717, -0.026489194482564926, 0.017310108989477158, 0.028929613530635834, 0.07117105275392532, -0.009589003399014473, 0.03245765343308449, -0.028029464185237885, -0.06178180128335953, 0.020950166508555412, -0.004648310132324696, -0.01809394545853138, -0.07755108922719955, 0.058856453746557236, -0.05863868072628975, -0.052765410393476486, 0.05036452040076256, 0.013404101133346558, 0.025641916319727898, 0.008292106911540031, -0.05796253681182861, -0.06325002759695053, 0.041461773216724396, -0.033451102674007416, 0.04082362353801727, -0.09741844981908798, -0.0009911854285746813, 0.025862526148557663, -0.003910196013748646, 0.024333691224455833, -0.006423694547265768, 0.021612020209431648, -0.015612447634339333, 0.028314201161265373, -0.008876310661435127, -0.011557061225175858, -0.02353818155825138, -0.010922728106379509, 0.015802429988980293, -0.05354815348982811, 0.033027928322553635, 0.04328335076570511, -0.04586293548345566, -0.03240551799535751, 0.016946105286478996, 0.006282525602728128, -0.015581023879349232, 0.013166148215532303, -0.035391390323638916, -0.02885831519961357, 0.06854697316884995, -0.0185322854667902, -0.01927046664059162, -0.018842685967683792, 0.007730923593044281, 0.02769399806857109, 0.018997570499777794, 0.04991757124662399, 0.0428490974009037, 0.0032810247503221035, -0.0261392742395401, -0.036873623728752136, -0.009977687150239944, -0.004356857854872942, -0.04727118834853172, -0.02265382558107376, -0.010265136137604713, 0.016426630318164825, -0.006004955153912306, 0.002637584460899234, -0.027449127286672592, 0.000639364414382726, 0.019621647894382477, -0.05544154718518257, -0.03570924326777458, -0.03995044529438019, 0.03081652522087097, -0.02004306949675083, -0.0148145891726017, -0.025721728801727295, 0.02077898569405079, 0.01570666953921318, -0.02058570273220539, -0.05456619709730148, -0.03638652712106705, 0.018708830699324608, 0.06500032544136047, -0.032490454614162445, -0.0030324175022542477, 0.051773156970739365, 0.011486845090985298, -0.025164877995848656, 0.03347845748066902, -0.052018508315086365, -0.02501348964869976, -0.0491657555103302, -0.021488705649971962, 0.017937401309609413, -0.004299844149500132, 0.018473239615559578, -0.0033885666634887457, -0.02990381047129631, 0.0482393354177475, -0.00032047912827692926, -0.04796508327126503, 0.049759119749069214, 0.07051332294940948, 0.0016340446891263127, -0.002853191690519452, 0.005581801291555166, -0.04175965115427971, 0.0299583338201046, 0.013543205335736275, -0.0009066604543477297, -0.0634373351931572, 0.01171992439776659, 0.02568552829325199, -0.017779456451535225, -0.020463427528738976, 0.03183067589998245, 0.06697197258472443, 0.010411136783659458, 0.01996455155313015, 0.012868276797235012, -0.005359078757464886, 0.0506693497300148, -0.016233913600444794, 0.030068296939134598, 0.04356562718749046, -0.009376972913742065, 0.039607711136341095, 0.03326774388551712, 0.038763318210840225, -0.029809439554810524, -0.03941946476697922, 0.02934490516781807, 0.017797136679291725, 0.030319904908537865, -0.06030271574854851, -0.06523092091083527, 0.01795155182480812, -0.0067602586932480335, -0.014145957306027412, 0.034232400357723236, 0.02286684140563011, -0.015548710711300373, 0.02058582939207554, -0.03555869683623314, 0.0037337748799473047, -0.008273791521787643, -0.015040871687233448, -0.015334908850491047, 0.02767641842365265, 0.005006558261811733, 0.06365665048360825, -0.03538377210497856, 0.01851050555706024, -0.05758685618638992, -0.004786609206348658, 0.0335904061794281, 0.010990707203745842, 0.028404446318745613, -0.03764967992901802, -0.03936351463198662, -0.011097206734120846, -0.006491603329777718, 0.025138216093182564, 0.03374277055263519, -0.035113293677568436, 0.027299968525767326, 0.01133904792368412, 0.0036171413958072662, 0.01850302517414093, 0.012833491899073124, -0.04038941115140915, 0.02844218537211418, -0.03516973555088043, -0.007402472198009491, -0.017521437257528305, -0.0190453939139843, -0.03277230262756348, -0.012888236902654171, 0.019625116139650345, 0.045040030032396317, 0.006020399276167154, -0.04398884251713753, 0.04933248087763786, -0.05301610752940178, 0.010333079844713211, -0.06298502534627914, -0.01073164027184248, -0.011021099984645844, -0.035073235630989075, -0.00941536482423544, 0.017248012125492096, -0.017103437334299088, 0.0485236756503582, -0.023908330127596855, -0.05093581601977348, -0.02762834168970585, 0.01291511207818985, 0.01727822981774807, -0.006531000602990389, -0.01609484851360321, 0.0815238431096077, -0.022058123722672462, -0.05719592422246933, -0.04782212898135185, 0.006201567128300667, -0.006346893962472677, -0.048376988619565964, -0.0031884624622762203, 0.0376836434006691, -0.02634533867239952, 0.018328018486499786, -0.02414814755320549, 0.028115762397646904, 0.06720568984746933, -0.00025956323952414095, 0.016167715191841125, 0.004979436285793781, -0.041188549250364304, -0.0055494303815066814, 0.07453113794326782, 0.05714430660009384, -0.042261917144060135, -0.01831171289086342, 0.011229170486330986, 0.029121950268745422, 0.009771058335900307, -0.033391647040843964, 0.008187692612409592, 0.03397562727332115, 0.019060010090470314, -0.0064450884237885475, 0.036128930747509, -0.00706168869510293, -0.015203689225018024, -0.07011595368385315, 0.02736588381230831, 0.0664956346154213, -0.023751359432935715, -0.020389458164572716, 0.04005652666091919, 0.03429160639643669, -0.039551619440317154, -0.029615115374326706, -0.013745704665780067, -0.025681370869278908, 0.0022571892477571964, -0.04899998754262924, -0.012450946494936943, 0.05359269306063652, 0.0019268183968961239, 0.038327910006046295, 0.030023647472262383, -0.05383320152759552, 0.000022587246348848566, -0.07249589264392853, -0.011463800445199013, -0.012653691694140434, 0.02713935263454914, 0.006518295034766197, 0.059921830892562866, 0.005495067220181227, 0.006791763007640839, 0.009342719800770283, 0.00795989390462637, -0.060510892421007156, 0.054350197315216064, -0.008007916621863842, 0.0019001540495082736, 0.0152110131457448, -0.02422221004962921, 0.01383691281080246, -0.027186235412955284, 0.015014119446277618, 0.003192101139575243, -0.009284842759370804, -0.0196906216442585, -0.017798971384763718, -0.004106554202735424, -0.009115503169596195, -0.025892313569784164, 0.04044964537024498, 0.03421908989548683, -0.016418704763054848, 0.012631318531930447, 0.025164486840367317, 0.017954591661691666, -0.0032678719144314528, -0.0010112745221704245, 0.0321010984480381, 0.033359594643116, 0.020077910274267197, 0.07900553941726685, 0.031232042238116264, -0.04159186780452728, -0.01236259751021862, 0.00375372520647943, 0.06122179701924324, 0.06725502759218216, -0.04997105523943901, -0.011839676648378372, 0.0006606712122447789, -0.02273274026811123, -0.0029090289026498795, 0.03061363473534584, -0.017959734424948692, 0.023418983444571495, 0.03231586143374443, 0.06628195941448212, -0.008729890920221806, 0.019524816423654556, 0.07645072788000107, 0.02639290690422058, -0.026061750948429108, -0.03739682212471962, -0.009976374916732311, 0.014507519081234932, 0.006055926438421011, 0.01947603188455105, 0.026382025331258774, 0.038986027240753174, 0.00696030305698514, 0.0011899247765541077, -0.03944951295852661, -0.008821496739983559, -0.0033934295643121004, -0.01121873501688242, 0.024870580062270164, -0.0025145045947283506, 0.012998704798519611, 0.03967397287487984, 0.052592262625694275, 0.03492916002869606, 0.00786686036735773, -0.025437520816922188, -0.0866369903087616, -0.00036173348780721426, 0.04780460149049759, 0.015557192265987396, -0.002178278984501958, 0.008245492354035378, -0.032296545803546906, -0.011667470447719097, 0.009655140340328217, -0.04481596127152443, 0.061208419501781464, 0.025241073220968246, 0.012133371084928513, 0.010605099610984325, 0.030275583267211914, -0.001257679658010602, 0.026660621166229248, -0.07711660116910934, 0.04518616944551468, -0.030899683013558388, -0.018789205700159073, -0.03963473066687584, 0.03894839063286781, -0.0035036427434533834, 0.021441876888275146, -0.03183194249868393, 0.01833510771393776, 0.0016714524244889617, 0.028733495622873306, -0.02005528099834919, -0.06365685909986496, 0.034344837069511414, -0.0043756477534770966, -0.009751913137733936, 0.04758237674832344, 0.025053618475794792, -0.015623770654201508, -0.024327360093593597, -0.0035770090762525797, 0.005442098248749971, -0.014086064882576466, -0.02648450806736946, 0.022015919908881187, -0.006592237390577793, 0.0383182168006897, 0.018264194950461388, 0.011693380773067474, -0.023829715326428413, -0.027305250987410545, 0.04065078869462013, 0.048500217497348785, -0.028516210615634918, 0.000009554608368489426, -0.02821194939315319, -0.006512550171464682, -0.027718035504221916, 0.029218345880508423, -0.00357296341098845, 0.030117418617010117, -0.028395721688866615, -0.00012419940321706235, 0.043593261390924454, 0.012522241100668907, -0.007896286435425282, -0.011130259372293949, -0.034218862652778625, 0.01107435580343008, -0.02571088634431362, -0.016369476914405823, 0.05850275605916977, -0.06465224921703339, -0.00846050400286913, 0.03521014377474785, -0.02703947015106678, 0.016346845775842667, -0.03692115843296051, 0.01289767399430275, 0.0029026579577475786, -0.00821375660598278, 0.0216399896889925, -0.013174590654671192, 0.03729451447725296, 0.026694240048527718, -0.055332109332084656, 0.014613975770771503, -0.026839392259716988, -0.016896041110157967, 0.027812620624899864, -0.015065481886267662, 0.04437359794974327, -0.005548293702304363, 0.010578622110188007, -0.05975980684161186, -0.07338502258062363, 0.034083712846040726, 0.01775434985756874, -0.04399503394961357, -0.00697091082111001, -0.0208283718675375, 0.017848137766122818, -0.04134269431233406, -0.013037366792559624, -0.019848668947815895, -0.030101535841822624, 0.013574277982115746, -0.007752051576972008, -0.0018095134291797876, 0.03798060119152069, 0.044061001390218735, 0.0077858660370111465, 0.017294438555836678, -0.019825436174869537, -0.023299532011151314, -0.005431493744254112, 0.00014186611224431545, -0.020548174157738686, 0.0306125245988369, -0.012332883663475513, 0.021172812208533287, 0.0764484852552414, -0.005966028664261103, 0.011195688508450985, 0.0013680801494047046, 0.024610552936792374, 0.027849042788147926, -0.034669145941734314, 0.007852810434997082, -0.00825812853872776, 0.016596950590610504, -0.005347138736397028, -0.0050110481679439545, 0.026956776157021523, 0.006019477266818285, -0.013627790845930576, 0.03210355341434479, 0.022212523967027664, -0.0012103327317163348, 0.07200518250465393, -0.008092015981674194, -0.0065539320930838585, 0.019444696605205536, 0.004608975723385811, 0.024178894236683846, 0.007575059309601784, 0.0070306989364326, 0.034049928188323975, 0.02226036600768566, -0.02064790204167366, -0.030967293307185173, -0.055018261075019836, 0.019771095365285873, 0.04992079362273216, -0.042454399168491364, 0.046446915715932846, 0.04652038961648941, 0.04725409671664238, 0.0034035425633192062, -0.023510174825787544, -0.01677379570901394, -0.008050274103879929, -0.010275276377797127, 0.02384720928966999, -0.014933723025023937, -0.010662768967449665, 0.008421086706221104, 0.03379490599036217, 0.01377044152468443, 0.004987072665244341, 0.052342064678668976, 0.012123062275350094, 0.00870700366795063, -0.016285490244627, -0.014926048927009106, 0.0037892053369432688, -0.022435186430811882, 0.01274894643574953, -0.019465239718556404, -0.01234608143568039, 0.027388067916035652, 0.03530647233128548, 0.007388454396277666, -0.059566620737314224, -0.015301743522286415, -0.02977633662521839, 0.008183790370821953, 0.0204806886613369, 0.006977349519729614, -0.01788053661584854, 0.030476955696940422, 0.02460365742444992, -0.04265519231557846, 0.030827898532152176, -0.029116299003362656, -0.059106480330228806, 0.0007076615584082901, 0.0018718655919656157, -0.07415182143449783, 0.062015313655138016, 0.023297850042581558, -0.0025328011251986027, 0.0398382693529129, -0.02859681472182274, 0.03290284425020218, -0.03877725824713707, 0.05901215597987175, 0.027748318389058113, 0.1110469326376915, 0.018229026347398758, 0.02120562270283699, -0.02589615434408188, 0.01438989769667387, 0.13586153090000153, 0.019891439005732536, -0.005514053162187338, -0.08212501555681229, -0.06261148303747177, -0.014313874766230583, 0.006742226425558329, 0.03428133577108383, 0.004428924527019262, 0.029977623373270035, -0.005005250684916973, 0.048737671226263046, 0.02040339820086956, 0.003239711280912161, 0.04517552629113197, 0.035877496004104614, -0.005530050024390221, 0.00601420272141695, 0.012610316276550293, 0.011635622940957546, -0.013146459124982357, 0.007056255359202623, -0.06604724377393723, -0.00456381356343627, 0.03126981854438782, -0.0028915032744407654, 0.008939947932958603, -0.06011895462870598, 0.0215213093906641, 0.045858580619096756, -0.049579307436943054, 0.005430268123745918, 0.004411660600453615, 0.04746713861823082, -0.0210559219121933, 0.03185560926795006, 0.0292234905064106, -0.011743256822228432, -0.012385199777781963, 0.03302955999970436, 0.005027526058256626, -0.012024730443954468, -0.018184494227170944, -0.02175877057015896, -0.04117332398891449, -0.04395904764533043, -0.04989934712648392, 0.035234756767749786, -0.014812301844358444, -0.015942908823490143, -0.03912438824772835, 0.011845411732792854, 0.011444767005741596, -0.04129204899072647, -0.05595581978559494, 0.034043632447719574, -0.01575191132724285, -0.03580525517463684, -0.012957804836332798, -0.01637241058051586, 0.023587200790643692, -0.01806272566318512, 0.0021614697761833668, 0.0022740766871720552, -0.026457106694579124, -0.023958008736371994, -0.03706751763820648, 0.03478943556547165, -0.0217763539403677, -0.00777765829116106, 0.018775977194309235, -0.013065793551504612, -0.0067794471979141235, -0.002953812712803483, -0.0003879426803905517, 0.04070047661662102, -0.011748690158128738, -0.0006017153500579298, -0.019977886229753494, 0.0006656821933574975, -0.009117739275097847, -0.014256158843636513, -0.03350830078125, -0.0005733744474127889, -0.06670865416526794, -0.052071452140808105, 0.020904378965497017, 0.020495396107435226, 0.01105363480746746, 0.032261744141578674, -0.04704079404473305, 0.04279593005776405, -0.01734241470694542, -0.05061427876353264, -0.054443296045064926, 0.07505451142787933, -0.05732659995555878, 0.04390241950750351, -0.014141572639346123, 0.04480353742837906, -0.0011731622507795691, -0.0190733689814806, -0.03477265685796738, 0.006316794082522392, -0.025592034682631493, 0.029037198051810265, 0.004565957002341747, -0.04986094310879707, -0.0010307778138667345, -0.018104644492268562, 0.016480371356010437, 0.009169982746243477, 0.025890665128827095, -0.0012564664939418435, -0.0041823494248092175, -0.017498383298516273, 0.027728039771318436, -0.016648225486278534, 0.02006973884999752, -0.01507278997451067, 0.019501764327287674, -0.03096468187868595, 0.03580281510949135, -0.020382804796099663, -0.0036843251436948776, 0.03702576085925102, 0.01601996272802353, -0.012942992150783539, -0.00005419615990831517, -0.03222094103693962, -0.014958776533603668, 0.0549609437584877, -0.011817273683845997, 0.026248307898640633, -0.010601677000522614, 0.020769808441400528, 0.03272782638669014, 0.06443808227777481, -0.011497302912175655, -0.035307176411151886, 0.022959832102060318, -0.05095344036817551, -0.009022574871778488, 0.025713790208101273, -0.0049256617203354836, 0.027364185079932213, 0.02466733567416668, -0.02442975901067257, -0.008489451371133327, 0.03175119683146477, -0.005571451503783464, -0.015215624123811722, 0.017786866053938866, 0.0008913677302189171, 0.0464957095682621, 0.043251268565654755, -0.007103228010237217, -0.043860096484422684, -0.008286795578897, 0.01623963564634323, 0.002201774390414357, -0.009464866481721401, 0.0004724578175228089, 0.0019030524417757988, 0.039961911737918854, -0.03808550536632538, 0.016778798773884773, -0.014338008128106594, -0.02880232222378254, 0.025784356519579887, 0.007329472340643406, 0.03346802294254303, -0.005398184061050415, 0.008199564181268215, -0.047511402517557144, 0.003636486129835248, -0.008638999424874783, -0.041901908814907074, 0.03569194674491882, -0.03954624384641647, -0.0017022258834913373, 0.01824052631855011, -0.0757674053311348, -0.013136366382241249, -0.013546681962907314, -0.034481097012758255, -0.02464822493493557, -0.02951156720519066, -0.01769932545721531, 0.0005006736028008163, 0.005030953790992498, 0.004127988591790199, 0.02089596353471279, -0.020347218960523605, 0.02688881754875183, -0.010072433389723301, -0.013099581934511662, -0.004620296880602837, 0.025829628109931946, 0.003855984890833497, 0.019341422244906425, -0.05510411411523819, -0.057252123951911926, 0.0287511944770813, -0.0285685732960701, 0.03672216087579727, -0.05056839436292648, 0.036593981087207794, 0.007502936292439699, 0.05402857065200806, 0.006431201007217169, -0.005917316768318415, 0.03168873488903046, -0.006402965169399977, -0.02884501777589321, 0.029424605891108513, 0.021857919171452522, -0.0008331015706062317, 0.048478905111551285, -0.03590794652700424, -0.010061708278954029, 0.021243669092655182, -0.015218283049762249, -0.024047663435339928, -0.0011498224921524525, 0.0000304972636513412, 0.031675517559051514, -0.017050256952643394, 0.02167690359055996, -0.06611258536577225, 0.029200565069913864, 0.02475791610777378, 0.003660806454718113, 0.003738831728696823, -0.01182854175567627, -0.03936752304434776, 0.0036682644858956337, -0.0074771554209291935, 0.017267398536205292, -0.03166576474905014, -0.04888204485177994, -0.01802009902894497, -0.0041695949621498585, 0.031085988506674767, -0.025059539824724197, 0.02180117927491665, -0.033822860568761826, 0.05152377113699913, 0.021035784855484962, 0.006186055485159159, -0.010021013207733631, -0.05593514069914818, 0.022201957181096077, -0.05624084919691086, 0.07659982144832611, -0.003819008357822895, -0.01938422955572605, -0.02653971128165722, -0.017621595412492752, -0.022637339308857918, 0.014052985236048698, 0.04732730984687805, -0.045309729874134064, -0.006863400340080261, -0.036878377199172974, -0.009859160520136356, 0.008740771561861038, -0.017850074917078018, 0.005425283685326576, 0.002768329344689846, -0.015057659707963467, 0.002806809963658452, -0.018534239381551743, -0.007086588069796562, 0.010723045095801353, -0.00014854753680992872, -0.011289931833744049, -0.004865389782935381, -0.024811476469039917, -0.02532954141497612, -0.009692944586277008, -0.006856483407318592, 0.008779408410191536, 0.06281869113445282, 0.045345231890678406, -0.013954794965684414, 0.03379451483488083, 0.0034084010403603315, -0.032914262264966965, 0.07381538301706314, -0.0032968127634376287, 0.004626018926501274, -0.0016911724815145135, 0.0034743023570626974, 0.011063809506595135, -0.04557187110185623, 0.006537758745253086, 0.045951779931783676, -0.014061455614864826, 0.017364531755447388, 0.0321563258767128, 0.010086046531796455, 0.02055295556783676, -0.024353116750717163, 0.03866149112582207, 0.0009764032438397408, -0.03703087940812111, 0.009190567769110203, -0.0183405838906765, 0.01475431490689516, -0.004371894057840109, 0.03985003009438515, 0.04190119728446007, -0.02687719091773033, 0.04380099102854729, -0.017524532973766327, 0.018177658319473267, 0.006403811275959015, -0.026714244857430458, 0.03585058078169823, -0.039568379521369934, -0.00831974670290947, 0.018734578043222427, 0.019801467657089233, 0.05319574475288391, -0.042548488825559616, -0.010715204291045666, -0.03799222782254219, -0.0028058476746082306, -0.0037249592132866383, -0.04011516645550728, 0.01754947006702423, -0.02661622315645218, -0.006918418686836958, -0.032419364899396896, 0.0030209796968847513, -0.01871846243739128, 0.02613765560090542, -0.03304234892129898, 0.003670703386887908, -0.01739290915429592, -0.00015965400962159038, 0.012717005796730518, -0.002785999095067382, -0.024411514401435852, 0.005415625404566526, 0.01753353886306286, -0.03237657994031906, 0.005425645038485527, -0.020368941128253937, -0.03317438066005707, 0.01245533674955368, 0.04266303405165672, -0.0568491593003273, -0.01707937754690647, -0.04060781002044678, 0.037399306893348694, 0.008132429793477058, 0.0013508694246411324 ]
<p>This is my attempt to find the discrepancy in the matching process for <code>R</code> package <code>"Matching"</code> and user written function <code>"psmatch2"</code> in <code>Stata</code><a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/52889/matching-results-completely-different-in-r-and-stata"> [Details]</a>. </p> <p>I am trying to find out how the Mahalanobis distance is computed in <code>psmatch2</code> (user written function for <code>Stata</code>) and whether it is consistent with the Mahalanobis distance computed in <code>R</code> and that computed using matrix in <code>Stata</code> [Details for Stata is available <a href="http://www.stata.com/statalist/archive/2010-10/msg01294.html" rel="nofollow">here]</a>.</p> <p>Following is the code for computing <a href="http://stat.ethz.ch/R-manual/R-patched/library/stats/html/mahalanobis.html" rel="nofollow">Mahalanobis</a> distance in R. The data I used is nuclearplants data from <code>optmatch (R package)</code>. </p> <pre><code> library (optmatch)# for the dataset nuclearplants data(nuclearplants) # pr is a treatment variable head(nuclearplants) cost date t1 t2 cap pr ne ct bw cum.n pt H 460.05 68.58 14 46 687 0 1 0 0 14 0 I 452.99 67.33 10 73 1065 0 0 1 0 1 0 A 443.22 67.33 10 85 1065 1 0 1 0 1 0 J 652.32 68.00 11 67 1065 0 1 1 0 12 0 B 642.23 68.00 11 78 1065 1 1 1 0 12 0 K 345.39 67.92 13 51 514 0 1 1 0 3 0 library(foreign) write.dta(nuclearplants,"datanp.dta") covar&lt;-cbind(nuclearplants$t1,nuclearplants$t2) #co-variates t1 and t2 X&lt;-covar #compute Mahalanobis distance for the treatment (pr=1) in row 7 and control (pr=0) in row 3 kk&lt;-solve(cov(X)) kk [,1] [,2] [1,] 0.11362947 0.01747102 [2,] 0.01747102 0.01194136 mahalanobis(X[7,], center=X[3,], cov=kk, inverted=TRUE) [1] 12.63674 #compute Mahalanobis distance for the treatment (pr=1) in row 2 and control (pr=0) in row 3 mahalanobis(X[2,], center=X[3,], cov=cov(X)) [1] 1.719555 </code></pre> <p>###########<code>Perform above steps in Stata using matrix</code>############</p> <pre><code>I computed the covariance matrix in Stata as follows: mat accum cov = t1 t2, dev noc mat covinv=inv(cov/(r(N)-2)) # psmatch2 function divides by N-2 mat list covinv symmetric covinv[2,2] t1 t2 t1 .10996401 t2 .01690744 .01155615 #This is different from the inverse of covariance matrix compute above in R. However, dividing by N-1 gives the same answer (I am not sure why we have to divide by N-2 in psmatch2) mat covinv=inv(cov/(r(N)-1)) mat list covinv symmetric covinv[2,2] t1 t2 t1 .11362947 t2 .01747102 .01194136 # For now I stick to one with N-1 mean(t1) mean(t2) Next for the treatment 3 we have X[3,]:-3.75 22.625 {this is obtained as 10-mean(t1) and 85 minus mean(t2)) and for the control X[7,]: -1.75 -12.375 {this is obtained as 12-mean(t1) and 50 minus mean(t2)) Now Mahalanobis Distance: (X[7,]-X[3,]) *covinv*(X[7,]-X[3,]) =12.2291 (This will be the same as in R if we use N-1 in variance computation in psmatch22) Similarly, for the treatment 3 and control 2 this is (X2[2,]-X2[3,])*covinv* (X2[2,]-X2[3,])=1.664086 (This will be same as in R if we use N-1 in variance computation in psmatch2. </code></pre> <p>So, up to now, I showed that results from <code>R</code> and <code>Stata</code> matches if we stick to computing using variance with N-1 instead of N-2 (as in psmatch2). However, when I run the <code>psmatch2</code> </p> <pre><code>psmatch2 pr, mahalanobis(t1 t2) </code></pre> <p>and obtain the Mahalanobis distance (This is given as <code>_mdif</code> in <code>psmatch 2</code> : <code>_mdif</code> In the case of one-to-one Mahalanobis matching, for every treatment observation it stores the absolute distance to its matched control in terms of the Mahalanobis metric). </p> <pre><code>Mahalanobis distance for the treatment (pr=1) in row 7 and control (pr=0) in row 3 2.26469 </code></pre> <p>Note: It doesn't provides Mahalanobis distance for the treatment (pr=1) in row 2 and control (pr=0) in row 3 because it provides the distance only for the matched observation.</p> <p>My question is why Mahalanobis distance (2.26469) computed using <code>psmatch2</code> is different than that computed using <code>R</code> (12.63674) and matrix function in <code>Stata</code> (12.63674 for variance computed using N-1)?</p>
74,251
[ -0.04792441055178642, -0.0060640606097877026, -0.03792191669344902, -0.0045841531828045845, 0.021359572187066078, -0.01248242612928152, 0.013536703772842884, -0.02921307645738125, 0.015953602269291878, -0.0010275087552145123, 0.060634564608335495, 0.010039524175226688, 0.05687323585152626, 0.01211537979543209, 0.018236378207802773, 0.028477182611823082, -0.011890019290149212, 0.020508266985416412, 0.013417811132967472, 0.019539015367627144, 0.040579162538051605, 0.0024011468049138784, 0.016497960314154625, -0.04247042164206505, -0.013161182403564453, 0.059468016028404236, -0.030769579112529755, -0.024444252252578735, -0.029317429289221764, 0.022009139880537987, -0.048824016004800797, -0.037744298577308655, 0.04248899221420288, -0.000991256209090352, 0.02401692606508732, 0.03571965545415878, 0.01578081026673317, -0.03264033421874046, -0.006741893012076616, 0.036390192806720734, 0.0008993979427032173, -0.026611052453517914, -0.017322763800621033, 0.019377626478672028, 0.004871274344623089, 0.020764600485563278, -0.016718953847885132, 0.02928687445819378, 0.03268192335963249, 0.0037273468915373087, 0.062113210558891296, 0.005302032455801964, 0.006587357260286808, -0.0032796773593872786, -0.08552201837301254, -0.01280094776302576, 0.021642426028847694, 0.0848846361041069, -0.005660404451191425, -0.0641583651304245, -0.0172769483178854, -0.045064497739076614, 0.018004536628723145, -0.01257878914475441, -0.03209151700139046, 0.056573789566755295, 0.029993224889039993, -0.023050252348184586, 0.04853079840540886, -0.028816120699048042, 0.008092722855508327, -0.0014511665794998407, 0.015592939220368862, -0.023184923455119133, 0.03865066543221474, -0.00013662561832461506, 0.006381795275956392, 0.014167305082082748, 0.021583708003163338, 0.005503361113369465, 0.007984488271176815, -0.012353942729532719, 0.0027376424986869097, 0.004132519941776991, 0.02798134833574295, 0.0045323446393013, 0.02499450370669365, -0.03624594211578369, 0.027933325618505478, 0.018344445154070854, 0.00012805154256056994, 0.02684764377772808, 0.04859164357185364, 0.054349057376384735, 0.01792450249195099, 0.03287656232714653, -0.003182271495461464, 0.030753035098314285, -0.01518330443650484, -0.003880125470459461, 0.012742821127176285, -0.024668078869581223, 0.023059871047735214, 0.03133082017302513, 0.0063300589099526405, -0.011692477390170097, -0.036981914192438126, 0.0015938602155074477, -0.01970759779214859, -0.007929954677820206, -0.04377035051584244, 0.04625502601265907, 0.017923103645443916, -0.02312973514199257, 0.0320616140961647, -0.007441761437803507, -0.03912385180592537, 0.013948704116046429, 0.04985551908612251, 0.04369025304913521, 0.02401314117014408, -0.015813682228326797, 0.005233523435890675, -0.056394703686237335, -0.019980022683739662, 0.002048713155090809, 0.021273279562592506, -0.015883563086390495, -0.05246034637093544, 0.012923337519168854, 0.007032657507807016, -0.032274696975946426, 0.011499899439513683, -0.008258453570306301, -0.01167698297649622, 0.004071782808750868, -0.08661970496177673, -0.03806130215525627, 0.031501371413469315, 0.00016513920854777098, 0.010244159027934074, -0.04079566150903702, -0.02466656267642975, -0.027357468381524086, 0.055205266922712326, 0.004431793000549078, 0.022739078849554062, 0.06081791967153549, 0.028016353026032448, 0.02710673399269581, -0.020904287695884705, 0.01631949469447136, -0.03736896440386772, -0.027726981788873672, -0.026720348745584488, -0.058706726878881454, -0.011525063775479794, 0.033432066440582275, -0.027178626507520676, -0.021099945530295372, 0.029768098145723343, 0.04001152887940407, -0.006207629106938839, -0.03218170627951622, -0.010339739732444286, -0.04280316084623337, 0.06354527920484543, 0.04054531827569008, -0.04046463966369629, 0.043436937034130096, -0.049245450645685196, 0.034096699208021164, -0.02642233297228813, 0.032833680510520935, 0.009666219353675842, -0.015297029167413712, -0.006790445651859045, -0.001229297136887908, 0.00014583188749384135, 0.021777598187327385, -0.055395036935806274, -0.004819488152861595, -0.011863918043673038, -0.016062095761299133, 0.04055975750088692, 0.02764247916638851, -0.0013283486478030682, 0.009694043546915054, 0.0303686261177063, -0.03188369795680046, -0.05645811930298805, -0.037091296166181564, 0.01632542721927166, -0.03540806844830513, -0.06284665316343307, 0.006096576806157827, 0.002031869487836957, -0.011245766654610634, 0.04609111696481705, 0.005721867550164461, 0.002556735184043646, 0.002636430086567998, 0.04232311621308327, 0.01627592369914055, -0.0284748412668705, 0.06004311889410019, 0.08173152804374695, -0.004060747567564249, 0.02524360828101635, -0.0610361248254776, -0.03280613571405411, 0.0059564062394201756, -0.03858591988682747, -0.01713545061647892, 0.017070451751351357, 0.03451402485370636, 0.010619682259857655, -0.03722141683101654, -0.0196701530367136, 0.026747290045022964, -0.0540938638150692, 0.03761264309287071, 0.05469631031155586, 0.006873372010886669, 0.02709844894707203, -0.02202604152262211, -0.015506131574511528, 0.049468476325273514, 0.0004986706771887839, -0.020693138241767883, -0.027867577970027924, -0.055273547768592834, 0.023272480815649033, 0.00972423329949379, -0.04417417198419571, 0.00617589196190238, 0.021346617490053177, -0.03144454210996628, -0.030161214992403984, 0.006172058638185263, -0.013521549291908741, -0.05603674426674843, 0.027069540694355965, -0.014515858143568039, -0.02483220584690571, 0.026287147775292397, 0.008485403843224049, 0.006177165545523167, 0.04971461743116379, 0.0004635943041648716, 0.008555294014513493, 0.04724988713860512, 0.007062545977532864, -0.015948235988616943, -0.0020631062798202038, -0.03651725873351097, 0.05807013809680939, 0.014560583047568798, 0.012392229400575161, 0.061489615589380264, -0.011913987807929516, 0.000042593168473104015, -0.017633909359574318, -0.03531855717301369, -0.009910117834806442, 0.05727231875061989, -0.01974787563085556, 0.01798783428966999, -0.009492848068475723, -0.011833788827061653, 0.04066719487309456, -0.006131826899945736, -0.02236086130142212, 0.009816709905862808, -0.013705750927329063, 0.0325310118496418, 0.036908574402332306, 0.03774265944957733, -0.02960941381752491, 0.025716757401823997, 0.010834021493792534, -0.04087754338979721, 0.02478741854429245, -0.015173164196312428, -0.021962855011224747, -0.012567324563860893, -0.03213677182793617, 0.008503159508109093, 0.002106871223077178, 0.007056389469653368, -0.028071215376257896, 0.060129277408123016, -0.0009229212300851941, -0.06774171441793442, -0.01327181700617075, 0.0061982800252735615, -0.003878493094816804, -0.023833230137825012, -0.008106410503387451, 0.021819086745381355, 0.02976948954164982, -0.04567895084619522, -0.017848793417215347, -0.019834032282233238, -0.03347628191113472, -0.022650182247161865, -0.007525802589952946, -0.002799984533339739, -0.0024339770898222923, -0.014186425134539604, 0.017406685277819633, -0.0034483543131500483, -0.014980637468397617, -0.047136060893535614, -0.032674290239810944, 0.027734771370887756, 0.011823487468063831, 0.03212234005331993, 0.006079962942749262, -0.011627744883298874, 0.05852580815553665, 0.062093090265989304, -0.011559170670807362, -0.03692746162414551, 0.030754048377275467, -0.03103238344192505, 0.009389486163854599, 0.04474242404103279, 0.014040306210517883, 0.037517447024583817, 0.011744960211217403, -0.02709127403795719, 0.03870563581585884, 0.07160129398107529, -0.046221837401390076, 0.019940583035349846, 0.0020934874191880226, -0.015162508003413677, -0.024100707843899727, 0.04348370060324669, -0.023354625329375267, -0.045609209686517715, 0.022098535671830177, 0.005754666868597269, 0.013101071119308472, -0.04625168815255165, -0.06209944561123848, 0.014783254824578762, 0.02743368037045002, 0.01719948649406433, -0.058009762316942215, 0.022174423560500145, 0.010910222306847572, 0.016806868836283684, -0.017024271190166473, -0.0022247140295803547, 0.05190546065568924, -0.03067575767636299, -0.011317048221826553, 0.04568047448992729, 0.027325060218572617, 0.020221751183271408, 0.04777926579117775, -0.016146261245012283, -0.03784174099564552, 0.01078484021127224, -0.028918258845806122, -0.03161473572254181, 0.021135052666068077, 0.028136547654867172, 0.019999699667096138, 0.04603465273976326, -0.031063633039593697, -0.0025428514927625656, -0.056326087564229965, 0.007800723891705275, -0.06407104432582855, 0.0396152026951313, -0.011182906106114388, 0.01986035145819187, 0.007822235114872456, 0.0034863429609686136, -0.028419729322195053, -0.03884207829833031, -0.02252267301082611, 0.011076669208705425, 0.004119354300200939, -0.011681034229695797, 0.016213366761803627, -0.08393491804599762, -0.010159476660192013, -0.021023383364081383, 0.01202660333365202, -0.003575611859560013, 0.03320968523621559, -0.04465428367257118, 0.028629550710320473, -0.021988200023770332, -0.0190738532692194, 0.005554824601858854, 0.028476987034082413, 0.03629416972398758, 0.005131006706506014, 0.045109543949365616, 0.037752676755189896, -0.02933901734650135, -0.015629561617970467, -0.04234883561730385, 0.021519819274544716, 0.021630140021443367, 0.038414038717746735, 0.03145762160420418, 0.043863438069820404, -0.007058571092784405, 0.01715923845767975, -0.01719883270561695, 0.014491676352918148, 0.05987093970179558, -0.0333336740732193, -0.035795826464891434, -0.03039654530584812, -0.015597982332110405, -0.016495170071721077, 0.00995362363755703, -0.0005678679444827139, -0.01822582446038723, 0.045262645930051804, 0.028195835649967194, -0.03485283628106117, -0.018905034288764, 0.04777912795543671, 0.030266284942626953, 0.015678144991397858, -0.03363385051488876, -0.015698213130235672, -0.006738306954503059, 0.0013981156516820192, 0.010790513828396797, -0.011274328455328941, 0.0077881887555122375, -0.005135060753673315, 0.05227293819189072, -0.0024769268929958344, -0.027801115065813065, -0.0010752095840871334, 0.013649359345436096, 0.007801428437232971, -0.003473348915576935, -0.015792617574334145, 0.021005818620324135, 0.03901532292366028, 0.03160783275961876, -0.00447052950039506, 0.0446547195315361, -0.06960254907608032, -0.0006221294752322137, 0.04406902566552162, 0.021660001948475838, -0.0585193894803524, -0.029856441542506218, -0.0413241907954216, 0.00912680383771658, 0.018987467512488365, 0.014635423198342323, 0.06280788034200668, -0.002604047767817974, 0.002358819358050823, -0.018405890092253685, -0.04544156417250633, -0.05243756249547005, 0.011172248981893063, -0.00851332675665617, 0.025092657655477524, -0.024303941056132317, -0.05962483212351799, -0.013353665359318256, -0.010513168759644032, 0.03197428584098816, 0.017781883478164673, -0.05313112214207649, -0.0030633904971182346, 0.03934516757726669, 0.030265875160694122, -0.017475951462984085, -0.04646483436226845, 0.040419213473796844, -0.02352922409772873, -0.028143029659986496, 0.03599544242024422, -0.03381681442260742, 0.012224297039210796, 0.007021709810942411, 0.021965233609080315, -0.0015674806199967861, -0.03195047751069069, -0.0055447351187467575, 0.017026741057634354, 0.03972955793142319, -0.04877039045095444, 0.05054505914449692, 0.009859561920166016, -0.010819892399013042, 0.0069761816412210464, -0.06265386939048767, -0.0033886502496898174, 0.0034039097372442484, -0.04240133613348007, -0.02080714888870716, -0.03876877203583717, -0.021075574681162834, 0.008039947599172592, 0.01365129929035902, 0.04179307445883751, -0.04476642236113548, 0.01947048492729664, -0.003957504406571388, 0.03693205863237381, -0.08583000302314758, 0.00805894285440445, 0.0005431118770502508, 0.050908420234918594, 0.03335658833384514, -0.010869292542338371, 0.042953405529260635, -0.014967035502195358, -0.02423809841275215, 0.024570543318986893, -0.029307806864380836, -0.00007959170761751011, 0.000301301886793226, -0.05260895937681198, 0.031341180205345154, 0.01909065991640091, 0.013523331843316555, -0.016305439174175262, 0.019418319687247276, 0.01974729634821415, -0.017172954976558685, -0.02568097412586212, 0.02642861008644104, 0.010771788656711578, -0.017764300107955933, -0.01415075920522213, 0.008495533838868141, 0.02336912415921688, -0.01443320419639349, -0.0468287467956543, -0.0022807724308222532, -0.0025065764784812927, 0.016917267814278603, -0.0484803132712841, -0.03714919835329056, -0.013763776049017906, 0.033072199672460556, -0.02141074649989605, -0.008613178506493568, 0.04413178190588951, -0.031300827860832214, 0.00005864246122655459, -0.04580871760845184, -0.0004552850150503218, 0.04265613481402397, -0.0324225015938282, -0.0017719777533784509, 0.007434353232383728, -0.002477784175425768, 0.014269624836742878, -0.01650412753224373, 0.029844412580132484, -0.012983190827071667, -0.03726799041032791, -0.04293759539723396, 0.006315678358078003, 0.05295226722955704, 0.004919677507132292, -0.0261240191757679, -0.03119392693042755, -0.04062746465206146, 0.02227376587688923, -0.02965099923312664, -0.005378006957471371, -0.021657105535268784, 0.005671117454767227, -0.02640056237578392, -0.0058601428754627705, -0.006290340330451727, -0.023371154442429543, 0.012178869917988777, -0.046818263828754425, -0.0029411613941192627, 0.0033330454025417566, 0.07730241864919662, -0.03494270518422127, 0.021564960479736328, 0.020435987040400505, -0.01615862175822258, 0.06008076295256615, -0.0003319218521937728, -0.003979070112109184, -0.03759872913360596, 0.013048368506133556, -0.0515083484351635, -0.011903337202966213, -0.07952739298343658, 0.02618066966533661, 0.06724002957344055, 0.00799489114433527, 0.039909131824970245, 0.04134197160601616, -0.012971751391887665, 0.003392252139747143, -0.06855130195617676, 0.015671972185373306, -0.01456470973789692, 0.03947726637125015, 0.05567684769630432, 0.000722903641872108, -0.007292161695659161, 0.11094272136688232, 0.059930238872766495, -0.0008594865212216973, 0.005141948815435171, 0.00037635525222867727, -0.0037069295067340136, -0.008849719539284706, -0.052202850580215454, -0.017719537019729614, 0.019183002412319183, -0.03174860030412674, 0.03669578209519386, -0.028705766424536705, -0.05156760290265083, 0.020246099680662155, 0.06372997909784317, -0.012493097223341465, -0.052151378244161606, -0.028054311871528625, -0.05313490703701973, 0.016900908201932907, 0.03139256313443184, -0.016618136316537857, 0.06601782143115997, 0.021616600453853607, 0.03742913529276848, 0.011103522032499313, 0.04475643113255501, -0.04472506791353226, -0.031107306480407715, 0.004472414962947369, -0.005520035978406668, -0.05776283144950867, 0.03690569847822189, -0.009650666266679764, -0.0015738795045763254, 0.013545828871428967, -0.00980911310762167, -0.025070255622267723, 0.021488549187779427, 0.009983409196138382, 0.00721944821998477, 0.06706703454256058, -0.0022504220250993967, 0.013707744888961315, -0.03613044321537018, -0.011892463080585003, 0.14072583615779877, 0.02952924743294716, 0.05399153009057045, -0.0381917841732502, 0.030951475724577904, 0.04381782189011574, -0.0010714759118855, -0.02700510248541832, 0.009743541479110718, -0.006717628333717585, -0.04341771453619003, 0.045217208564281464, 0.05015904828906059, 0.046389371156692505, 0.02587127313017845, 0.01788977161049843, -0.02330990880727768, -0.036502618342638016, 0.03747217357158661, -0.03534897416830063, 0.03162042051553726, -0.03171470761299133, 0.008365882560610771, 0.03794389218091965, 0.04389297217130661, -0.016696665436029434, -0.018722515553236008, 0.0038654832169413567, 0.014822909608483315, 0.01188872754573822, -0.006475137546658516, 0.0496462881565094, -0.011377360671758652, 0.044104933738708496, 0.018244272097945213, 0.0002524791634641588, 0.04206716641783714, -0.05184568092226982, -0.0038313334807753563, -0.006823588628321886, 0.0052313432097435, -0.006469264626502991, -0.006331938318908215, 0.008180812932550907, -0.05720377340912819, -0.004171679727733135, -0.05114499852061272, 0.04464405030012131, -0.0065022786147892475, -0.016390031203627586, -0.008161516860127449, -0.0182272270321846, 0.011624417267739773, -0.047214288264513016, 0.035816386342048645, 0.04617055878043175, 0.027808500453829765, 0.00009217081969836727, 0.006337315775454044, -0.0183208417147398, 0.020485101267695427, -0.015264797955751419, 0.021660394966602325, 0.011929078958928585, 0.0055218711495399475, -0.014175865799188614, -0.00636920565739274, 0.035817474126815796, -0.03901989012956619, 0.02270413190126419, -0.03297971561551094, -0.02092934399843216, 0.012552685104310513, -0.04234439879655838, 0.000619742670096457, -0.0010447129607200623, 0.03251294419169426, 0.0010727207409217954, -0.05309230834245682, -0.07127553969621658, -0.0690884217619896, 0.0001494269527029246, -0.026140110567212105, -0.023324429988861084, -0.04862654581665993, -0.03697489574551582, 0.07056751847267151, 0.02294105850160122, 0.028111331164836884, 0.02404285967350006, -0.03018510714173317, 0.047556813806295395, -0.0050653754733502865, -0.05961674079298973, -0.019120771437883377, 0.002291735028848052, -0.01578620634973049, -0.03274882212281227, -0.028248092159628868, 0.025822307914495468, 0.04615084081888199, 0.04267808794975281, 0.0024847667664289474, 0.007537534460425377, -0.011565487831830978, 0.020334072411060333, 0.02341143786907196, -0.07389950752258301, 0.02573590725660324, 0.0004918195772916079, -0.014499136246740818, -0.031366977840662, 0.014271021820604801, -0.02903316542506218, -0.031032437458634377, -0.00007824047497706488, -0.01585276797413826, -0.027102159336209297, 0.012115462683141232, 0.00556579977273941, -0.023163774982094765, 0.0044177984818816185, -0.010430709458887577, -0.027106860652565956, -0.0188888069242239, -0.015248452313244343, -0.007280723657459021, -0.001966607989743352, 0.020310234278440475, -0.009863091632723808, 0.026739193126559258, 0.05043835937976837, 0.03661290556192398, 0.003323889337480068, 0.01910950243473053, 0.02644186094403267, 0.027889681980013847, 0.05992265045642853, -0.0033564320765435696, 0.018016263842582703, -0.02674196846783161, -0.03084593266248703, -0.043167900294065475, 0.006286010146141052, -0.010681611485779285, 0.03890381008386612, 0.029160700738430023, 0.026886746287345886, 0.001290519954636693, 0.08173748850822449, -0.05728772655129433, 0.007935801520943642, -0.024613166227936745, 0.014957031235098839, 0.034050364047288895, -0.02631443925201893, -0.02148267813026905, 0.019741790369153023, -0.05215713381767273, 0.0482151135802269, 0.024985438212752342, -0.03119288571178913, -0.003741332795470953, -0.015654657036066055, -0.019161371514201164, -0.021188579499721527, -0.006454111076891422, -0.002832303289324045, 0.0123763931915164, 0.06496009975671768, 0.007612945977598429, 0.04799119383096695, 0.0036987941712141037, 0.05424031987786293, -0.039021365344524384, -0.01276801060885191, -0.016611088067293167, 0.0222150981426239, 0.02742667868733406, -0.06478571146726608, 0.024788986891508102, 0.029576662927865982, -0.03988048806786537, 0.009034979157149792, 0.007685459218919277, -0.0024241888895630836, -0.018337024375796318, 0.0336618535220623, -0.009365768171846867, 0.012176868505775928, 0.024908166378736496, 0.004220558330416679, 0.032564401626586914, 0.027306288480758667, -0.006788327824324369, -0.03531799092888832, -0.053545109927654266, -0.021812358871102333, 0.018713168799877167, -0.05460480600595474, 0.009286073967814445, -0.010720820166170597, -0.030619671568274498, 0.03758280724287033, -0.04271208494901657, 0.03213978558778763, 0.008221122436225414, 0.042988650500774384, 0.008108729496598244, 0.03948408365249634, 0.030627459287643433, 0.04132719337940216, -0.005534613970667124, -0.04452311992645264, 0.0030382100958377123, 0.02691064588725567, -0.02694893255829811, 0.03989877924323082, 0.006660201586782932, 0.0027566952630877495, -0.04864193871617317, 0.007158981636166573, -0.011239930056035519, -0.012421324849128723, -0.03724822402000427, 0.009599621407687664, 0.03472274914383888, -0.01626807637512684, 0.00527978828176856, 0.0015326569555327296, 0.023994527757167816, 0.06617040932178497, 0.07298731803894043, 0.005365406163036823, 0.012873315252363682, -0.008293045684695244, -0.021464765071868896, 0.0561399906873703, 0.027523910626769066, -0.02831919677555561, -0.027046456933021545, -0.02366204559803009, -0.00927010364830494, 0.008596162311732769, -0.008884851820766926, 0.04316915571689606, -0.034476928412914276, 0.02973846159875393, -0.03904943913221359, -0.01373069267719984, 0.017426567152142525, 0.003473062999546528, 0.021664220839738846, -0.09103737771511078, 0.05473659932613373, -0.02574429288506508, -0.01827160082757473, -0.04214651137590408, -0.022745462134480476, -0.05854035168886185, 0.015183400362730026, 0.049639202654361725, 0.012677378952503204, -0.0133877694606781, -0.014747578650712967, -0.005247810855507851, 0.015528281219303608, -0.03673544153571129, 0.0697232335805893, 0.015007144771516323, 0.02068173699080944, 0.016866788268089294, -0.0039896839298307896, 0.012647612020373344, 0.04732334986329079, -0.013261262327432632, -0.027480538934469223, -0.023230023682117462, 0.03380553796887398, -0.028386296704411507, 0.015445989556610584, -0.009355584159493446, -0.01310640573501587, 0.006871332414448261, 0.029000423848628998, 0.012992762960493565, 0.06508727371692657, -0.03225083649158478, -0.04909485951066017, 0.00011504705616971478, -0.0129280686378479, -0.05679130181670189, 0.025854408740997314, -0.005923155229538679, -0.0003289038722869009, -0.034202270209789276, 0.010881844907999039, 0.04019339382648468, 0.014489683322608471, -0.00475452421233058, 0.022392062470316887, 0.02443920075893402, 0.006648941896855831, 0.024267250671982765, 0.05025266110897064, -0.01752333715558052, -0.014613911509513855, 0.05568379536271095, 0.0053437743335962296, 0.011335823684930801, -0.004262967966496944, -0.031450364738702774, 0.021981248632073402, 0.017699945718050003, -0.020643921568989754, -0.015656007453799248, 0.04849140718579292, 0.018160579726099968, -0.04239079728722572, 0.017626069486141205, 0.02311922423541546, -0.0037836923729628325, 0.01704445481300354, 0.0006845726165920496, 0.01903577335178852, -0.013148123398423195, 0.04031587764620781, -0.03323141112923622, 0.0066398694179952145, -0.006771640852093697, -0.01628677174448967, -0.006889781914651394, -0.05007431283593178, -0.022185862064361572, 0.0007334914989769459, 0.041155457496643066, -0.013315440155565739, 0.030606528744101524, -0.007240184582769871, 0.001963350223377347, 0.0018375269137322903, 0.02027873881161213, -0.029164504259824753, -0.0019645472057163715, 0.01782575063407421, -0.037897419184446335, 0.01395645271986723, 0.04177548736333847, 0.0008547024917788804, -0.05748050659894943, -0.013047229498624802, -0.027797741815447807, 0.07789825648069382, -0.06200437247753143, -0.062312040477991104, -0.023852908983826637, -0.01843060739338398, -0.030828135088086128, -0.010257279500365257 ]
<p>A student's t distributed rv $X$ has characteristic function but no moment generating function. I wonder if cf(X)=$E[e^{itX}]$, why we cannot take $t=-iu$ to get the mgf $E[e^{uX}]$? (This question may be very silly...)</p> <p>If we cannot know mgf of $X$, is there some accurate numerical way to evaluate $E[e^{X}]$, i.e., the value of the mgf at $u=1$?</p>
37,015
[ -0.018971139565110207, -0.026536276564002037, 0.020918557420372963, -0.032813891768455505, 0.018547073006629944, -0.001790143083781004, -0.0466301329433918, -0.00632048025727272, 0.041108038276433945, -0.05153018981218338, 0.04334017261862755, 0.03881165757775307, 0.05629739910364151, 0.028749581426382065, 0.008379395119845867, 0.022966589778661728, -0.031210975721478462, 0.013779430650174618, 0.0004135826020501554, -0.019649378955364227, 0.004222578834742308, 0.01894327439367771, -0.002714302856475115, 0.005786248482763767, -0.03207935765385628, 0.006172985769808292, 0.04277048259973526, -0.011295028030872345, 0.009273349307477474, 0.0719275176525116, -0.07091981172561646, -0.03612852469086647, 0.027137503027915955, -0.004417645279318094, 0.024415109306573868, 0.027397766709327698, -0.05073412507772446, -0.04106852784752846, -0.021279137581586838, 0.01708689145743847, -0.026908617466688156, -0.03467836230993271, 0.0015094326809048653, 0.032892752438783646, -0.0009933331748470664, 0.03659747913479805, 0.001954970182850957, -0.03613174334168434, 0.055010970681905746, -0.053124383091926575, 0.05851880833506584, 0.01636076532304287, 0.04004715010523796, -0.0036059413105249405, -0.029930466786026955, -0.005201178137212992, 0.02016976661980152, 0.0332234725356102, 0.004481277894228697, -0.01952381059527397, 0.014662155881524086, -0.03586668521165848, 0.011644786223769188, -0.05731065943837166, -0.00666049774736166, -0.022920846939086914, 0.0276540145277977, -0.021766941994428635, 0.05408346280455589, -0.03606152907013893, 0.028581688180565834, 0.03408375754952431, 0.008826586417853832, -0.004609451629221439, 0.004737135022878647, -0.02593293786048889, 0.03955148160457611, 0.0022068966645747423, 0.05714920535683632, 0.007411312311887741, 0.0033701027277857065, 0.004836872685700655, 0.020377416163682938, 0.014518335461616516, 0.033458709716796875, -0.0034841212909668684, 0.05742821469902992, 0.00504724308848381, 0.06834229081869125, 0.032470107078552246, -0.02564876712858677, -0.029285814613103867, 0.06615551561117172, -0.04301489517092705, -0.00005854945629835129, 0.03582291305065155, 0.0067726378329098225, 0.03528410196304321, -0.010534612461924553, -0.0071459682658314705, -0.008662449195981026, -0.039943184703588486, 0.04609029367566109, 0.0858006700873375, 0.011293817311525345, -0.04512504115700722, -0.011735181324183941, -0.03710893914103508, 0.00149156479164958, 0.006372613832354546, -0.03448569029569626, -0.020659223198890686, 0.010842825286090374, 0.01689321920275688, 0.029290614649653435, 0.02003394439816475, 0.025956057012081146, -0.058227285742759705, 0.053156208246946335, 0.05625870078802109, 0.03196786344051361, -0.027516135945916176, 0.00837707705795765, -0.022038104012608528, -0.05205173417925835, 0.014542432501912117, 0.01638474129140377, 0.014086252078413963, -0.03814474865794182, -0.0012320622336119413, -0.01623634621500969, -0.021265821531414986, 0.03987310454249382, 0.011195055209100246, -0.0029071818571537733, -0.0265508946031332, -0.053684722632169724, -0.07163362950086594, 0.027306698262691498, -0.027360055595636368, -0.05670270323753357, -0.08973858505487442, -0.005719595123082399, 0.06096884608268738, 0.0038846677634865046, 0.009864920750260353, 0.05828898400068283, -0.03477533534169197, 0.05447336658835411, 0.02564295381307602, -0.012996342033147812, -0.015991192311048508, -0.025831717997789383, -0.028127295896410942, -0.01669720932841301, -0.022855211049318314, 0.026837658137083054, 0.0025956369936466217, -0.010792461223900318, -0.0307221207767725, 0.055683862417936325, -0.0004955208860337734, -0.009756112471222878, -0.00753745436668396, 0.005820609629154205, -0.01918892189860344, 0.08715245127677917, 0.002598643535748124, 0.013726096600294113, -0.02557332254946232, -0.003838416887447238, 0.006082009989768267, -0.008370031602680683, 0.0504157580435276, 0.029933664947748184, -0.045724619179964066, -0.029492303729057312, -0.04402179643511772, 0.02897382155060768, -0.013245546258985996, -0.01875157840549946, -0.008965185843408108, 0.0031275032088160515, -0.01998615264892578, 0.023462660610675812, 0.04950900375843048, -0.010610293596982956, 0.01647202856838703, 0.06062014028429985, -0.02585870958864689, -0.0230088010430336, -0.0209853146225214, 0.004975584801286459, 0.009779626503586769, -0.013492158614099026, 0.009559310972690582, -0.03928742557764053, 0.05128633230924606, 0.016529519110918045, -0.019405275583267212, -0.023837612941861153, -0.04057738184928894, 0.009857731871306896, -0.008620304986834526, 0.012722166255116463, 0.0015359708340838552, 0.0483342744410038, -0.017105689272284508, 0.059880562126636505, -0.03678565472364426, -0.05098358914256096, -0.006947494577616453, -0.047965068370103836, 0.046874940395355225, -0.008371258154511452, -0.045133642852306366, -0.0007905439124442637, -0.03357347846031189, -0.01810307241976261, 0.017478112131357193, -0.012257703579962254, 0.05327389016747475, 0.07982123643159866, 0.017009187489748, 0.017728984355926514, 0.05486081540584564, 0.0338270366191864, 0.0013028602115809917, -0.015941545367240906, -0.061727218329906464, -0.05614364892244339, -0.05053514987230301, 0.030739881098270416, 0.03256785497069359, -0.007067160680890083, 0.02015424519777298, 0.05720025673508644, 0.013193021528422832, 0.053599268198013306, 0.035082537680864334, 0.016542894765734673, -0.02324751392006874, 0.03640752285718918, 0.05467052757740021, 0.017996771261096, -0.019128160551190376, 0.02798652835190296, 0.031233111396431923, 0.021275989711284637, 0.00849119946360588, -0.0246286503970623, 0.03342099487781525, 0.004954819101840258, -0.03493078798055649, -0.031150463968515396, 0.006496570538729429, 0.031972333788871765, -0.0610601082444191, 0.02119796723127365, 0.03169820457696915, -0.008076239377260208, 0.008218791335821152, 0.028766777366399765, -0.04651719331741333, 0.026198262348771095, 0.018155453726649284, -0.021390125155448914, -0.03120344690978527, 0.027175983414053917, -0.03526277467608452, 0.011307400651276112, 0.008735062554478645, -0.018203487619757652, 0.011720225214958191, 0.005331856198608875, 0.06572093814611435, -0.015457894653081894, -0.014503552578389645, -0.020547354593873024, -0.05345377326011658, 0.006443033926188946, -0.026546496897935867, -0.01106189750134945, -0.0033666735980659723, -0.058538466691970825, 0.0018937155837193131, -0.018027953803539276, -0.02203146554529667, -0.004704914055764675, -0.027045557275414467, -0.010817920789122581, 0.002734934212639928, -0.02738674357533455, -0.04040498286485672, -0.0041282218880951405, -0.016660625115036964, -0.048326633870601654, -0.007381036877632141, 0.013204533606767654, 0.040553487837314606, -0.03089101053774357, -0.032045815140008926, 0.016343574970960617, -0.034176621586084366, -0.04594286531209946, -0.03221895918250084, 0.00970292929559946, 0.039737433195114136, -0.016437049955129623, 0.03150235861539841, -0.023279322311282158, -0.0007344739860855043, -0.02622249163687229, -0.052802734076976776, -0.02917620725929737, 0.0031850573141127825, 0.006069512106478214, 0.06662847846746445, 0.038145650178194046, -0.039038658142089844, 0.02526426687836647, 0.00956424605101347, -0.0184563547372818, 0.009883934631943703, -0.02190566249191761, -0.003223831532523036, -0.03545895963907242, 0.012684669345617294, -0.02256453037261963, -0.027229346334934235, 0.018514256924390793, -0.005425364710390568, -0.026463493704795837, 0.0648416057229042, 0.002932407660409808, -0.00014008383732289076, 0.010722239501774311, -0.015759630128741264, 0.01134494785219431, 0.053637195378541946, -0.010321070440113544, 0.021398287266492844, -0.0007810548995621502, -0.015127536840736866, 0.05671469122171402, 0.031007468700408936, -0.04431528225541115, 0.05417613685131073, -0.010907916352152824, 0.026899807155132294, -0.06689527630805969, 0.03085973858833313, -0.009125590324401855, -0.004462322685867548, -0.017378048971295357, 0.028436308726668358, 0.0024296175688505173, -0.01656816154718399, 0.021469518542289734, 0.060819197446107864, 0.0068403384648263454, -0.008730114437639713, 0.004655192140489817, -0.016780974343419075, 0.009430421516299248, 0.024927640333771706, -0.032696593552827835, -0.020845606923103333, 0.02364182658493519, 0.04743554815649986, 0.023681210353970528, -0.009608650580048561, -0.025281809270381927, -0.07149927318096161, -0.042624685913324356, -0.018434038385748863, -0.022040484473109245, 0.03733515739440918, 0.038518134504556656, 0.009473749436438084, 0.006065935827791691, 0.0673876404762268, -0.018724029883742332, -0.02847389690577984, -0.0952061340212822, 0.02068588137626648, -0.029131852090358734, -0.01178637146949768, -0.03751559183001518, 0.02496892772614956, 0.06291788816452026, 0.018469475209712982, -0.004921203013509512, -0.013881316408514977, -0.004879564978182316, -0.03209717944264412, -0.007410378195345402, 0.0049116830341517925, -0.03508884459733963, -0.03785125911235809, 0.030340442433953285, 0.03836184740066528, -0.024547601118683815, 0.04156037047505379, 0.008651740849018097, -0.013532844372093678, -0.00675242580473423, -0.029424579814076424, 0.019679471850395203, 0.017023636028170586, 0.02339630201458931, 0.019532477483153343, 0.036717865616083145, -0.015529957599937916, 0.029240325093269348, 0.04650985449552536, 0.08476580679416656, 0.05491180717945099, -0.011404185555875301, -0.04107941314578056, -0.024846922606229782, -0.02577744983136654, 0.01788705587387085, 0.02716410532593727, -0.014382228255271912, 0.007436299696564674, 0.05851384624838829, 0.02127029560506344, 0.004532658960670233, 0.028023695573210716, 0.027991317212581635, 0.03128528594970703, 0.019744999706745148, -0.024236513301730156, 0.03789215162396431, -0.016480762511491776, -0.018634699285030365, -0.01165386475622654, 0.026954272761940956, -0.013103575445711613, 0.0011623403988778591, 0.04049438238143921, -0.019236214458942413, 0.020141324028372765, -0.023975282907485962, -0.010774905793368816, 0.05089122802019119, 0.013408223167061806, -0.04045531153678894, 0.03424739092588425, 0.020542440935969353, 0.021689223125576973, -0.002890995005145669, 0.01241165492683649, -0.052669595927000046, 0.01564939133822918, 0.0525633879005909, 0.041804924607276917, -0.02461674064397812, -0.01651357300579548, -0.06701724231243134, -0.0036623135674744844, 0.026293842121958733, -0.033456359058618546, -0.005063281394541264, -0.04274647310376167, 0.004493542946875095, 0.013555583544075489, -0.053385891020298004, -0.06390918046236038, 0.01874600350856781, 0.0003333078930154443, 0.017626706510782242, -0.041367825120687485, -0.02379150688648224, 0.007749313488602638, -0.004263441544026136, 0.03382091224193573, 0.048814382404088974, -0.015290357172489166, -0.01199884433299303, 0.017290396615862846, 0.02808401919901371, -0.0031940648332238197, -0.06327807903289795, -0.0011970463674515486, 0.0018225542735308409, 0.0032933601178228855, 0.04566717520356178, -0.02593148499727249, -0.08017144352197647, 0.05487906187772751, 0.03544474020600319, 0.017926091328263283, 0.017552969977259636, -0.01404563058167696, 0.02831658162176609, 0.04255993291735649, -0.008212811313569546, 0.04564174264669418, 0.050115834921598434, 0.042996786534786224, -0.0056938291527330875, -0.02833370864391327, 0.003583167912438512, -0.04381144046783447, -0.016700614243745804, -0.01776234433054924, -0.023435307666659355, 0.011218438856303692, 0.014925653114914894, 0.021808549761772156, 0.03670718893408775, -0.04987373948097229, 0.005126718431711197, 0.03229757025837898, 0.030289525166153908, 0.008697381243109703, 0.006755208596587181, -0.020589618012309074, 0.033345162868499756, -0.013324675150215626, -0.025467058643698692, 0.0024828382302075624, 0.005043043289333582, 0.01364537887275219, 0.01739836111664772, 0.002758431015536189, 0.026038583368062973, -0.023431560024619102, -0.0060094185173511505, -0.0068907602690160275, -0.026250388473272324, 0.041364215314388275, -0.03778328001499176, 0.026516076177358627, 0.030993180349469185, -0.0033957338891923428, -0.009011340327560902, 0.019282404333353043, -0.004076431971043348, 0.02034432254731655, -0.015280413441359997, 0.04008112847805023, -0.016583796590566635, -0.037595879286527634, -0.09374283254146576, -0.041756242513656616, -0.03118840418756008, 0.018048079684376717, -0.02158656157553196, -0.0476716011762619, -0.01620585471391678, 0.005783203523606062, -0.02042229287326336, -0.017568295821547508, 0.0012281016679480672, 0.05053418129682541, 0.008427409455180168, 0.008705358020961285, 0.002713874913752079, 0.0750073716044426, 0.00114526622928679, 0.010723059996962547, 0.04579446092247963, -0.03164423257112503, -0.06306687742471695, 0.02046515792608261, 0.026634329929947853, -0.019624093547463417, 0.0020354606676846743, 0.053031038492918015, 0.008079130202531815, 0.013936953619122505, -0.0036772892344743013, -0.03724539652466774, 0.06811890006065369, 0.015731243416666985, 0.015387186780571938, -0.03868731111288071, 0.008230290375649929, 0.006328274495899677, -0.012866218574345112, -0.03912070021033287, -0.009466114453971386, -0.02677544392645359, -0.01640911027789116, 0.03160940483212471, -0.03244359791278839, 0.015912843868136406, -0.007181430235505104, 0.027518948540091515, -0.044992510229349136, -0.0012943677138537169, 0.011239251121878624, 0.007666218560189009, 0.015537654049694538, 0.024899078533053398, -0.029816847294569016, 0.010149416513741016, 0.015889093279838562, -0.023013019934296608, -0.04308977350592613, -0.08227582275867462, 0.050887446850538254, 0.05672148987650871, 0.013859828002750874, 0.04923811927437782, 0.033547982573509216, -0.006978007964789867, -0.02240367792546749, 0.01562558300793171, -0.017607389017939568, 0.011237532831728458, -0.02464953251183033, -0.00041160357068292797, -0.03723236918449402, 0.022103816270828247, -0.025779269635677338, 0.017635470256209373, 0.002978612668812275, 0.04077920690178871, 0.005271820351481438, -0.009635639376938343, 0.055932313203811646, -0.025355642661452293, -0.030888225883245468, 0.0007734255632385612, 0.0017622122541069984, 0.022256838157773018, -0.036743976175785065, -0.039412710815668106, 0.003521303180605173, 0.02059120498597622, 0.0006089432281441987, -0.059332869946956635, -0.0244069192558527, -0.03468572348356247, 0.01657610572874546, 0.06005752459168434, 0.00022748243645764887, 0.058425575494766235, 0.03434067219495773, -0.0022149397991597652, -0.013220380991697311, 0.05277416482567787, -0.019114883616566658, -0.04747174680233002, -0.005815830547362566, -0.03621300309896469, -0.055602241307497025, 0.04339323192834854, -0.007557332515716553, -0.025774694979190826, 0.015492180362343788, -0.029585348442196846, 0.026502730324864388, -0.031186508014798164, 0.04714401066303253, -0.012987766414880753, 0.07451741397380829, 0.02049359865486622, 0.03446872904896736, 0.01275657955557108, 0.025603242218494415, 0.11804147809743881, 0.026176990941166878, 0.007389795035123825, -0.020290527492761612, -0.060369595885276794, -0.07338004559278488, -0.0026767298113554716, -0.03345301002264023, -0.0053169094026088715, -0.011825324036180973, 0.00454764673486352, 0.04840372875332832, 0.04250044375658035, -0.0037239089142531157, -0.0007007638341747224, 0.011411805637180805, -0.023204931989312172, -0.018631458282470703, 0.0019559345673769712, -0.005298221949487925, -0.0006243739044293761, -0.0032480647787451744, -0.05703268200159073, 0.002281735884025693, -0.038883090019226074, 0.009904472157359123, -0.019512761384248734, -0.023633724078536034, 0.006805409211665392, -0.009643612429499626, -0.04607689008116722, 0.015564335510134697, 0.03267688304185867, 0.011695046909153461, 0.0014142468571662903, 0.0065381452441215515, 0.018082505092024803, -0.0026951762847602367, 0.03254825994372368, 0.016137100756168365, -0.009539661929011345, -0.016489695757627487, 0.01235787570476532, 0.011613589711487293, -0.006926293019205332, -0.028591003268957138, -0.01763126254081726, 0.04556756094098091, -0.013809417374432087, 0.023071017116308212, -0.0034356664400547743, -0.0029662312008440495, -0.016088685020804405, -0.027765464037656784, -0.031876612454652786, -0.048659276217222214, 0.015066581778228283, -0.056527551263570786, -0.007685326971113682, -0.04076208546757698, 0.013978893868625164, -0.01619119383394718, 0.026497958227992058, 0.010954828932881355, -0.059637684375047684, 0.0014193590031936765, -0.015079030767083168, 0.0522710420191288, 0.01106050331145525, -0.04842367768287659, -0.00038067641435191035, -0.024413149803876877, -0.00828166026622057, -0.05622684955596924, -0.0070082033053040504, -0.006625664886087179, 0.04731946438550949, 0.02584773674607277, 0.035941168665885925, -0.006063458044081926, -0.03936713933944702, 0.005579730961471796, -0.004675756674259901, -0.0070987846702337265, -0.023114241659641266, -0.007879716344177723, -0.0117258932441473, 0.043902166187763214, 0.010378479957580566, -0.02400088869035244, 0.01014542207121849, 0.03469409421086311, 0.0006377931567840278, -0.0167386457324028, -0.00806455034762621, -0.020429423078894615, -0.02025519870221615, 0.008460655808448792, -0.0007325181504711509, 0.01737070083618164, 0.015948602929711342, 0.04090510681271553, -0.018957361578941345, 0.0115293487906456, 0.0020081133116036654, -0.031481023877859116, -0.013941384851932526, -0.03366183117032051, 0.01500931940972805, 0.008071609772741795, -0.015564949251711369, -0.03844938054680824, -0.021946299821138382, -0.018896182999014854, 0.028018411248922348, 0.01959645003080368, 0.039820700883865356, -0.07515813410282135, 0.002289373194798827, 0.011724700219929218, 0.02501092664897442, -0.029667755588889122, 0.00867864117026329, 0.005043159704655409, 0.006393625866621733, 0.004744004923850298, 0.016573108732700348, -0.01254502683877945, 0.03623388707637787, -0.023925870656967163, 0.026621272787451744, 0.04220322147011757, 0.04670020192861557, -0.005472691264003515, -0.02796567976474762, 0.024032587185502052, 0.010000189766287804, 0.053551267832517624, 0.023909717798233032, 0.03291638568043709, 0.0808199867606163, -0.06123436614871025, -0.015322359278798103, 0.017289306968450546, 0.007909640669822693, 0.012701640836894512, 0.007708074524998665, -0.013284111395478249, -0.013937421143054962, 0.034575220197439194, -0.02979331463575363, 0.03645995631814003, -0.010759378783404827, 0.007579379249364138, 0.01009460724890232, -0.05155410245060921, -0.008342737331986427, -0.015029377304017544, -0.014910888858139515, 0.02073138765990734, 0.026170071214437485, -0.0053058890625834465, 0.00429927185177803, 0.02681204117834568, -0.002761093433946371, 0.010699635371565819, 0.013979456387460232, 0.007192067336291075, 0.016221927478909492, 0.08078213036060333, 0.0020050364546477795, 0.009519313462078571, -0.034816570580005646, 0.006167462561279535, -0.10660065710544586, -0.05284678936004639, 0.03839326649904251, -0.00925343856215477, 0.04462962597608566, 0.009641488082706928, -0.04773736000061035, 0.02599615976214409, -0.0477580726146698, 0.0011168703204020858, -0.026804089546203613, -0.03160613402724266, -0.014567696489393711, 0.013271843083202839, -0.000924239051528275, -0.017509251832962036, 0.03619980067014694, 0.02320556528866291, 0.029642876237630844, 0.04913979768753052, -0.008367217145860195, -0.006034656427800655, -0.024069469422101974, 0.0064790938049554825, -0.01361986342817545, -0.04254809767007828, 0.05895010009407997, -0.012304610572755337, 0.014568975195288658, -0.028632918372750282, 0.008499996736645699, -0.011093118228018284, -0.014567576348781586, 0.027332058176398277, 0.012925950810313225, 0.056672465056180954, 0.07642389088869095, -0.05256117507815361, 0.006807231344282627, 0.030217695981264114, -0.003135386621579528, 0.007864176295697689, 0.006146738305687904, 0.004799410700798035, -0.0000012815308991775964, 0.0031055707950145006, -0.010155525989830494, 0.004977669101208448, -0.018863307312130928, -0.03331608697772026, -0.0001972587633645162, -0.01507304422557354, -0.032309915870428085, -0.02275475487112999, 0.030748611316084862, -0.05401597172021866, -0.012346932664513588, 0.027253365144133568, 0.003845460247248411, -0.003531663678586483, -0.01959899067878723, -0.013489349745213985, -0.05537906289100647, 0.0498659610748291, 0.01978045515716076, -0.03873700276017189, -0.0650055781006813, 0.007244307082146406, 0.021544836461544037, 0.004918990656733513, 0.013093268498778343, -0.04561997950077057, -0.06317014247179031, 0.021191857755184174, 0.02429920993745327, 0.012899575755000114, -0.006895031780004501, -0.028184453025460243, 0.019291521981358528, -0.042378541082143784, 0.029330085963010788, -0.01512110698968172, -0.018562395125627518, -0.01316420454531908, -0.01670100912451744, -0.028435396030545235, -0.007514966651797295, 0.07599996775388718, -0.009767682291567326, -0.01584354043006897, 0.029619606211781502, 0.00361437164247036, 0.008029039017856121, -0.03793259337544441, 0.0077585019171237946, -0.03148221969604492, -0.01288804691284895, 0.00996965542435646, 0.026829753071069717, -0.0234763715416193, 0.04426126554608345, -0.003977530635893345, -0.033529385924339294, -0.001089209341444075, 0.008892860263586044, -0.012961594387888908, 0.05910198390483856, 0.042045708745718, -0.014739458449184895, 0.06290965527296066, 0.024823496118187904, 0.02377423644065857, -0.014631655067205429, -0.013126428239047527, -0.04243537783622742, 0.03241673484444618, -0.019921191036701202, -0.02366427145898342, 0.0018568262457847595, 0.02945723943412304, 0.006690317764878273, -0.04302418604493141, -0.015745362266898155, 0.03177303075790405, -0.040408872067928314, -0.01891481503844261, 0.024065418168902397, 0.01223518792539835, 0.03072861209511757, 0.021772921085357666, -0.01964610069990158, 0.031880203634500504, -0.0006920871674083173, 0.034306593239307404, 0.04398559778928757, 0.014715821482241154, -0.04242563247680664, 0.03391794115304947, 0.008160887286067009, -0.0487770140171051, 0.0054222457110881805, 0.010532337240874767, 0.0137531328946352, -0.04419369250535965, -0.02205941453576088, 0.02840815670788288, -0.006892223842442036, 0.02281312830746174, 0.0055153327994048595, -0.06540107727050781, 0.07937424629926682, -0.005220392718911171, 0.014154432341456413, -0.03265700861811638, 0.01707284525036812, -0.0355861596763134, 0.027499446645379066, 0.01684940606355667, 0.050597287714481354, 0.008738107047975063, 0.005808500573039055, -0.03139802813529968, -0.014897583983838558, 0.028771886602044106, -0.030492110177874565, 0.005857790820300579, -0.037743352353572845, 0.006714395247399807, 0.018005523830652237, -0.017630597576498985, -0.020930130034685135, -0.04102115333080292, 0.0019887415692210197, 0.04160832241177559, 0.06139325350522995, -0.012847231701016426, -0.02641664259135723, 0.04625143110752106, 0.06405818462371826, -0.07948103547096252, -0.005014747381210327, -0.0365644209086895, 0.008413693867623806, -0.010886557400226593, -0.028141507878899574 ]
<p>From <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Completeness_%28statistics%29" rel="nofollow">Wikipedia</a>:</p> <blockquote> <p>The statistic $s$ is said to be complete for the distribution of $X$ if for every measurable function $g$ (which must be independent of parameter $θ$) the following implication holds: $$ E(g(s(X))) = 0, \forallθ \text{ implies that }P_θ(g(s(X)) = 0) = 1, \forall θ. $$ The statistic $s$ is said to be boundedly complete if the implication holds for all bounded functions $g$.</p> </blockquote> <p>I read and agree with <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/a/44135/1005">xi'an and phaneron</a> on that a complete statistic means that "there can only be one unbiased estimator based on it"</p> <ol> <li><p>But i don't understand what Wikiedia says at the beginning of the same article:</p> <blockquote> <p>In essence, it (completeness is a property of a statistic) is a condition which ensures that the parameters of the probability distribution representing the model can all be estimated on the basis of the statistic: it ensures that <strong>the distributions</strong> corresponding to different values of the parameters are distinct.</p> </blockquote> <ul> <li><p>in what sense (and why) does completeness "ensures that the distributions corresponding to different values of the parameters are distinct"? is "the distributions" the distributions of a complete statistic?</p></li> <li><p>in what sense (and why) does completeness "ensures that the parameters of the probability distribution representing the model can all be estimated on the basis of the statistic"?</p></li> </ul></li> <li><p>[optional: What does "bounded completeness" mean, compared to completeness?]</p></li> </ol> <p>Thanks and regards!</p>
74,252
[ -0.043047819286584854, -0.02175315096974373, 0.04592461138963699, -0.005106783472001553, 0.00387705210596323, 0.00345589523203671, -0.029384920373558998, 0.0067803943529725075, 0.035758569836616516, -0.038673289120197296, 0.06609679013490677, -0.004981774836778641, 0.034847185015678406, 0.008513085544109344, 0.041544266045093536, 0.01041889563202858, -0.0121269840747118, 0.036868881434202194, 0.00400508614256978, 0.011039319448173046, -0.025217851623892784, 0.043136823922395706, 0.014524799771606922, 0.004092047922313213, -0.009867653250694275, 0.005389932543039322, 0.025631893426179886, -0.017139114439487457, 0.017965884879231453, 0.08323399722576141, -0.06300466507673264, -0.012927772477269173, -0.0072874948382377625, 0.0527273565530777, 0.0011970589403063059, -0.012751421891152859, -0.035913944244384766, 0.01409192569553852, 0.01679842919111252, 0.031399574130773544, -0.06702131032943726, -0.01177279558032751, 0.004825871903449297, 0.014413365162909031, -0.038564328104257584, 0.03209767863154411, -0.007719398941844702, -0.041484881192445755, 0.009807870723307133, 0.001987805822864175, 0.0691361054778099, -0.017570840194821358, 0.07059111446142197, 0.01543830893933773, 0.006250203121453524, -0.0034469396341592073, 0.06771130859851837, 0.055920857936143875, -0.005087052471935749, -0.08362668007612228, -0.010309907607734203, 0.011188579723238945, 0.03040412813425064, -0.014341936446726322, -0.015014723874628544, 0.07304428517818451, 0.03252096474170685, -0.0273020938038826, 0.027595175430178642, 0.003829151624813676, 0.02090153470635414, 0.016491716727614403, 0.0004124534607399255, -0.008834109641611576, 0.007847961038351059, -0.011233260855078697, -0.012096243910491467, 0.016248628497123718, 0.03905855119228363, 0.015486344695091248, -0.008411046117544174, 0.023953134194016457, 0.03926723450422287, 0.014477157033979893, 0.031299274414777756, 0.004153645597398281, 0.10087959468364716, 0.010627963580191135, 0.015529758296906948, 0.006892388220876455, -0.014868536964058876, -0.005518544930964708, 0.03409934416413307, -0.020197482779622078, -0.012717091478407383, 0.05336526408791542, -0.016227662563323975, 0.011574041098356247, -0.04043339937925339, 0.004665149841457605, 0.008506343699991703, -0.04161033779382706, -0.011830789037048817, 0.04961483180522919, -0.023595033213496208, 0.021743277087807655, -0.00002310724084964022, -0.0258720014244318, -0.01738065853714943, -0.021630965173244476, -0.029226509854197502, 0.050004176795482635, 0.023160545155405998, 0.021356545388698578, -0.03954654559493065, 0.028974929824471474, 0.026430556550621986, -0.0009871843503788114, 0.036724451929330826, 0.06655362993478775, 0.04048876464366913, 0.0042058322578668594, -0.014567162841558456, -0.042770955711603165, -0.07184559851884842, -0.008534470573067665, -0.00044238826376385987, -0.013222260400652885, -0.04831603541970253, 0.04878712818026543, 0.017226241528987885, 0.005690305028110743, 0.03825077414512634, 0.04677759110927582, 0.01852274127304554, -0.014833034947514534, -0.09129398316144943, -0.017888691276311874, 0.015375806018710136, -0.004726208746433258, 0.014303898438811302, -0.031652696430683136, 0.004333863966166973, 0.01875891722738743, 0.03159860521554947, -0.018807435408234596, 0.07333383709192276, -0.01784309186041355, 0.017940033227205276, 0.0033781430684030056, -0.018091807141900063, 0.00697438046336174, 0.007163157220929861, -0.00408716406673193, -0.03970731422305107, -0.0688951388001442, 0.009964854456484318, 0.01445069257169962, -0.04070201888680458, -0.04669360816478729, 0.057839229702949524, -0.008539639413356781, -0.012496476992964745, -0.025700228288769722, 0.012808525934815407, 0.0031506898812949657, 0.036085519939661026, -0.007841036655008793, 0.0056854840368032455, 0.021817559376358986, -0.041581667959690094, 0.0063399518840014935, 0.007595026399940252, 0.014854897744953632, 0.03749027103185654, -0.03250793740153313, -0.0219340231269598, -0.04435746371746063, 0.009904969483613968, 0.019101399928331375, -0.031217239797115326, 0.02330799028277397, 0.0016908121760934591, 0.0014282569754868746, 0.0389057993888855, 0.05731885880231857, 0.03248579800128937, -0.01275379117578268, 0.013459400273859501, -0.036425139755010605, -0.029875287786126137, -0.04540523886680603, -0.009735068306326866, -0.025813529267907143, -0.02965543605387211, 0.04876522347331047, 0.0005360590294003487, -0.03902461752295494, 0.013444355688989162, 0.018970495089888573, -0.03602796047925949, -0.02159302309155464, 0.04216817766427994, -0.018077941611409187, 0.014135422185063362, 0.05201682448387146, 0.06503954529762268, 0.025572530925273895, 0.020081885159015656, 0.004558743443340063, -0.09013280272483826, 0.022909319028258324, -0.020764021202921867, 0.03366094455122948, 0.007449731230735779, -0.0018277043709531426, 0.031985703855752945, 0.019692884758114815, -0.027436524629592896, 0.025261979550123215, -0.07948651164770126, 0.0016915409360080957, 0.050753019750118256, -0.005047312006354332, -0.009796136058866978, -0.009087027050554752, 0.024828771129250526, 0.0060296147130429745, -0.03367074951529503, 0.008314757607877254, -0.020898353308439255, 0.0026918218936771154, 0.029720835387706757, 0.0355849415063858, -0.02104203775525093, 0.007388398516923189, 0.04759186878800392, 0.014487884938716888, -0.007507693953812122, 0.009274628013372421, -0.020916977897286415, -0.010188869200646877, 0.022868696600198746, -0.025937605649232864, 0.01057647168636322, 0.008454615250229836, 0.005659731570631266, -0.0006102822371758521, 0.04222714155912399, 0.017594074830412865, -0.015240946784615517, 0.09045611321926117, 0.01749519072473049, -0.024208614602684975, -0.008656383492052555, 0.021980999037623405, 0.03003138303756714, -0.018258828669786453, -0.003710164688527584, 0.012723647058010101, 0.012890868820250034, -0.007390583399683237, -0.021494418382644653, -0.002836646279320121, 0.04896778240799904, 0.00025067379465326667, -0.0193336084485054, -0.0254675205796957, 0.006377268582582474, -0.05934368073940277, -0.01771451160311699, -0.04563367739319801, -0.040439706295728683, -0.0005497613456100225, -0.013222686015069485, 0.0579531230032444, 0.012769830413162708, -0.015579115599393845, -0.029981311410665512, -0.026755157858133316, 0.004854967352002859, -0.0047132945619523525, 0.04584573954343796, 0.034423504024744034, -0.04406334087252617, 0.0010383145418018103, -0.03329199180006981, 0.005450930912047625, 0.005978397559374571, -0.0423910915851593, -0.003970783669501543, 0.016570238396525383, 0.004193257540464401, -0.024486271664500237, -0.024714043363928795, -0.04465426877140999, 0.0394379086792469, -0.04429272934794426, -0.004345607943832874, 0.02918361686170101, 0.004408748354762793, -0.08579897880554199, -0.018335796892642975, -0.06390237808227539, -0.05364042893052101, -0.042165014892816544, -0.04303603246808052, 0.028311530128121376, -0.004768578801304102, 0.00023648759815841913, 0.026906080543994904, -0.0018447639886289835, -0.008805775083601475, -0.04476054385304451, -0.07370561361312866, -0.0006108414381742477, 0.009294770658016205, 0.041320014744997025, 0.01414632797241211, -0.00971204787492752, 0.10594204068183899, 0.019886644557118416, -0.02693430706858635, -0.03525441884994507, 0.016688788309693336, -0.03594353049993515, 0.0019709833431988955, -0.01947428658604622, -0.0014246414648368955, 0.025303924456238747, 0.02383631095290184, -0.009289185516536236, 0.05743664503097534, 0.016826927661895752, 0.018100865185260773, 0.01593298465013504, 0.04095504805445671, 0.030555816367268562, -0.02090228721499443, 0.00703002791851759, 0.04475342109799385, -0.0036119830328971148, 0.007208526600152254, -0.027963101863861084, 0.052789006382226944, -0.0015679592033848166, -0.0526442788541317, 0.033780068159103394, -0.016443051397800446, -0.009238900616765022, -0.06057070195674896, 0.056172627955675125, 0.023218251764774323, -0.04267645999789238, 0.006098481826484203, 0.008754057809710503, 0.020018326118588448, -0.006311354227364063, -0.05808239430189133, 0.0254841186106205, 0.008139846846461296, -0.05579015612602234, 0.003012328874319792, -0.030446456745266914, -0.03314436227083206, 0.029653411358594894, 0.010783767327666283, -0.02014181762933731, 0.012108960188925266, 0.03588001802563667, -0.0046296329237520695, 0.0068814693950116634, -0.03666405752301216, -0.033895209431648254, -0.04987000674009323, 0.007243577390909195, 0.021456727758049965, 0.048333510756492615, 0.016951095312833786, 0.033627476543188095, -0.00019305360910948366, 0.007839270867407322, -0.04709036648273468, 0.016065072268247604, -0.07255911827087402, 0.012512177228927612, 0.016864720731973648, -0.0052392752841115, 0.028342386707663536, -0.02310563437640667, 0.013814682140946388, -0.03958768770098686, 0.0027754458133131266, -0.04479200392961502, 0.03454383462667465, -0.051651980727910995, -0.011936350725591183, -0.009974757209420204, -0.0408259741961956, -0.0063376459293067455, 0.028646033257246017, 0.016832564026117325, -0.026621127501130104, 0.028639381751418114, 0.040329985320568085, -0.01575680822134018, -0.029339300468564034, -0.006768921855837107, 0.002379796002060175, 0.033736731857061386, 0.019804272800683975, 0.022394144907593727, 0.06239673122763634, -0.007196405436843634, 0.012653482146561146, 0.016149431467056274, 0.07888584583997726, 0.07244325429201126, -0.03775230422616005, 0.005999724846333265, -0.026910454034805298, -0.007317915093153715, 0.020999476313591003, 0.033913251012563705, -0.003230087924748659, 0.0008081323467195034, 0.08972794562578201, 0.0040158554911613464, -0.031165659427642822, 0.025520727038383484, 0.023367375135421753, -0.011889186687767506, 0.007744689472019672, -0.020186271518468857, -0.018390126526355743, -0.025944707915186882, 0.031860195100307465, 0.00008954133954830468, 0.015574694611132145, -0.007162552326917648, 0.014101359993219376, 0.02652459591627121, -0.010245275683701038, -0.08317410945892334, -0.022823764011263847, 0.04487919434905052, 0.02379150688648224, -0.021353593096137047, -0.03587223216891289, -0.009164231829345226, 0.03532373532652855, 0.0322980172932148, 0.010042225010693073, 0.007559390272945166, -0.026094680652022362, -0.03010115586221218, 0.023062290623784065, -0.0054397014901041985, 0.020588887855410576, 0.03014720417559147, -0.009636876173317432, -0.015912462025880814, -0.025601482018828392, 0.017671335488557816, 0.03198646381497383, -0.0199009757488966, 0.013390460051596165, -0.014381837099790573, -0.09838838875293732, -0.004393657669425011, 0.00490971002727747, -0.01917148567736149, -0.00832557212561369, -0.029190806671977043, 0.00849144347012043, -0.03304971754550934, -0.02019307017326355, -0.0031779152341187, 0.06845386326313019, 0.0019159972434863448, -0.0012052981182932854, 0.03608616441488266, 0.0348866768181324, -0.016189100220799446, -0.0810292437672615, 0.015649886801838875, -0.02921225130558014, -0.01681622304022312, 0.02332930639386177, -0.03949746489524841, -0.06157988682389259, 0.047714658081531525, -0.004617678467184305, -0.061373788863420486, 0.02836606651544571, -0.03133044391870499, 0.05815490335226059, 0.024048104882240295, 0.017501262947916985, 0.0409422405064106, 0.021051539108157158, -0.012421428225934505, 0.017729591578245163, -0.0383964478969574, -0.007350190542638302, -0.057704344391822815, -0.009207375347614288, -0.0726180225610733, -0.013865167275071144, -0.053268227726221085, 0.012011157348752022, 0.02013017050921917, 0.013929598033428192, -0.007992677390575409, -0.013238000683486462, 0.029130738228559494, 0.02695279009640217, -0.0063539063557982445, 0.005642562638968229, -0.013370492495596409, 0.05349621921777725, 0.009061985649168491, -0.005777914077043533, 0.005831939168274403, -0.01015500258654356, 0.02144426666200161, -0.0008618438150733709, -0.004720223136246204, 0.013528240844607353, -0.035086389631032944, -0.05844131112098694, 0.004224809352308512, 0.0033484138548374176, 0.03478711098432541, -0.026251884177327156, 0.03799781948328018, 0.002855600556358695, -0.06664367765188217, -0.03621590882539749, 0.043233759701251984, 0.005262513644993305, 0.02346857823431492, -0.029924845322966576, 0.005284521728754044, -0.004954576026648283, -0.01936197280883789, -0.056247975677251816, 0.017032897099852562, 0.035413555800914764, 0.01753656193614006, -0.05878663435578346, -0.018119947984814644, 0.006175791844725609, -0.014940415509045124, -0.06027092784643173, -0.012551101855933666, 0.016261141747236252, 0.005863657686859369, -0.014813649468123913, -0.021510077640414238, 0.018333766609430313, 0.03167376294732094, 0.014557444490492344, -0.028254801407456398, 0.026044785976409912, -0.03863487392663956, -0.019166558980941772, 0.01105294656008482, -0.013317951001226902, -0.043095167726278305, 0.014961546286940575, -0.004074903670698404, 0.02639114484190941, -0.0007319156429730356, -0.017969129607081413, -0.04031966254115105, -0.011297422461211681, -0.02619512379169464, -0.0012269096914678812, -0.030714718624949455, -0.018642818555235863, 0.017714397981762886, 0.03048682026565075, -0.0067822993732988834, -0.000737134600058198, -0.012812748551368713, -0.05089480057358742, 0.006953046191483736, -0.02254881151020527, -0.02246183343231678, -0.0029113066848367453, 0.05312781408429146, 0.017642784863710403, 0.030750347301363945, -0.018898306414484978, 0.005406849551945925, 0.02758253738284111, -0.0077217696234583855, 0.025094153359532356, -0.020305734127759933, 0.012535365298390388, -0.016982916742563248, 0.0169988926500082, -0.06057606264948845, 0.023522716015577316, 0.02021254040300846, 0.017555048689246178, 0.027039680629968643, 0.040007952600717545, -0.04027104750275612, -0.016227807849645615, -0.050408411771059036, 0.005950960796326399, -0.04059440270066261, 0.015633972361683846, 0.03410593420267105, 0.014353711158037186, -0.03602069243788719, 0.054414600133895874, 0.011079869233071804, -0.008649050258100033, -0.003382110968232155, 0.010884827934205532, -0.017881600186228752, 0.014344004914164543, -0.044095564633607864, -0.031225822865962982, 0.06455788016319275, -0.01731244847178459, 0.0013674142537638545, -0.008335718885064125, -0.02400370128452778, 0.014894332736730576, 0.026783404871821404, 0.04792562127113342, -0.06858644634485245, -0.0019049975089728832, -0.06565575301647186, 0.054267480969429016, 0.00917498953640461, -0.0003313080233056098, 0.016652368009090424, -0.03445000573992729, -0.0336480475962162, 0.003140464425086975, 0.05566299706697464, -0.020987369120121002, -0.05675792694091797, -0.02389119565486908, -0.02163136936724186, -0.02420920506119728, 0.040309593081474304, -0.0019084351370111108, -0.03805617615580559, -0.017353182658553123, -0.026469456031918526, 0.03667914867401123, 0.010898593813180923, 0.031065935268998146, -0.04481010138988495, 0.07886490970849991, -0.0012443080777302384, 0.07335834205150604, -0.006096881814301014, -0.011536367237567902, 0.13337251543998718, 0.04722960665822029, 0.05897238105535507, -0.027246125042438507, 0.015949269756674767, 0.03554847463965416, 0.022531792521476746, 0.01643778756260872, -0.01751634292304516, 0.02311386726796627, 0.019202619791030884, 0.01000932790338993, 0.04111719876527786, -0.0011515638325363398, -0.024706877768039703, 0.029073623940348625, -0.0455976277589798, -0.043382298201322556, -0.022412052378058434, 0.0439474917948246, -0.0068237436935305595, 0.0036745001561939716, -0.05805036053061485, -0.017942514270544052, 0.018056314438581467, -0.0016494435258209705, 0.006184038706123829, -0.015260436572134495, 0.003212863113731146, 0.015172602608799934, -0.0240066796541214, -0.015204700641334057, 0.03821225464344025, -0.024285513907670975, -0.039104461669921875, -0.0010906349634751678, 0.0024220249615609646, -0.03140565752983093, 0.0077179172076284885, 0.050022535026073456, -0.014221134595572948, -0.03393249213695526, 0.004456019029021263, 0.009785324335098267, -0.012044170871376991, -0.02587347850203514, -0.04119034856557846, 0.02705271728336811, -0.009136083535850048, 0.010907339863479137, -0.02194693125784397, 0.017556825652718544, -0.026192907243967056, -0.034817807376384735, -0.016968704760074615, 0.011539246886968613, 0.04469708353281021, -0.048357315361499786, -0.0523599274456501, -0.017725838348269463, -0.00483193201944232, -0.029676135629415512, 0.03789385408163071, -0.01286572590470314, -0.08862166106700897, -0.012014283798635006, -0.02432182803750038, 0.04466306045651436, 0.010868396610021591, 0.03726844862103462, 0.009968706406652927, 0.0017553942743688822, -0.01962817646563053, -0.009212587028741837, 0.02996356226503849, -0.0056105186231434345, 0.04367174953222275, -0.005006742663681507, 0.026120183989405632, -0.025240527465939522, -0.04043968394398689, 0.010916473343968391, -0.050263263285160065, -0.04577246680855751, -0.03940810263156891, -0.013903630897402763, 0.007004322484135628, 0.05039217695593834, 0.028155747801065445, 0.02409094199538231, -0.003028327599167824, 0.047914352267980576, 0.03139543905854225, -0.062253694981336594, -0.01497519388794899, 0.03410808742046356, -0.04157174751162529, 0.02548125386238098, 0.01558216754347086, 0.0260104238986969, 0.05770488455891609, 0.059335846453905106, -0.020295104011893272, 0.017914561554789543, 0.007254622410982847, -0.0029858506750315428, -0.0018655532039701939, -0.019299574196338654, 0.008370453491806984, 0.05255277454853058, 0.011293708346784115, -0.02225726656615734, -0.03354496508836746, -0.0010877223685383797, -0.007741529960185289, 0.03956419974565506, -0.023408960551023483, -0.05710279569029808, 0.01815059594810009, 0.02149929292500019, 0.018785765394568443, 0.013653363101184368, -0.029310192912817, -0.01698106713593006, -0.016757065430283546, -0.008340725675225258, -0.024904023855924606, 0.02538733184337616, 0.010806582868099213, 0.004693407565355301, -0.01501681562513113, 0.042312998324632645, 0.00406204117462039, -0.017118407413363457, -0.01590535044670105, 0.03626582771539688, -0.018151264637708664, 0.04602761194109917, 0.012340512126684189, 0.00914729479700327, 0.03356524929404259, -0.04421713948249817, -0.03717456012964249, 0.015331516042351723, 0.01436631754040718, 0.019119486212730408, 0.018027888610959053, 0.03586994856595993, -0.04121284559369087, -0.00680436659604311, -0.022281795740127563, -0.00741962343454361, 0.01817348785698414, 0.02118794620037079, 0.004629636649042368, -0.0020975663792341948, 0.017238305881619453, 0.028887048363685608, -0.009003788232803345, 0.01976051740348339, 0.034742508083581924, -0.0063424804247915745, -0.04077916964888573, 0.031006211414933205, -0.012220029719173908, 0.008833013474941254, 0.003996118437498808, 0.01973871886730194, 0.01659250818192959, 0.05370079725980759, -0.030993370339274406, 0.045968521386384964, -0.012604206800460815, 0.008425663225352764, -0.10043502599000931, -0.017255675047636032, 0.010992441326379776, 0.023748749867081642, 0.020517565310001373, -0.03971339389681816, -0.01014890056103468, 0.01734950952231884, -0.055366724729537964, -0.022588854655623436, 0.02048386260867119, -0.00260126288048923, -0.05781172215938568, -0.010330777615308762, -0.040665656328201294, 0.03813580051064491, 0.04406363517045975, 0.023899398744106293, 0.0028850880917161703, 0.04584544524550438, 0.0005641114548780024, -0.0009907206986099482, -0.04492383450269699, 0.018152959644794464, -0.012452283874154091, -0.0372895747423172, 0.0478566437959671, -0.020785575732588768, -0.008976786397397518, 0.056134793907403946, 0.011409148573875427, 0.02814965881407261, -0.00028460827888920903, 0.03445624187588692, 0.04550537094473839, 0.006794095505028963, 0.023124460130929947, 0.029188279062509537, -0.028709253296256065, 0.026400994509458542, -0.006475367583334446, 0.031482987105846405, -0.02027655765414238, -0.013378482311964035, 0.03645748645067215, -0.04149096831679344, -0.01357887964695692, 0.008611727505922318, -0.023155953735113144, -0.004076062235981226, 0.028687646612524986, -0.010559388436377048, -0.0166899636387825, -0.0024809669703245163, 0.014872049912810326, -0.03335205838084221, -0.010526209138333797, 0.0363922193646431, 0.015515116974711418, -0.026339249685406685, 0.017739474773406982, -0.02802838571369648, -0.04907068610191345, 0.049099475145339966, -0.017659766599535942, -0.020122159272432327, -0.025199174880981445, -0.005982456728816032, 0.012205563485622406, 0.015588663518428802, -0.020200205966830254, 0.00647167069837451, -0.038059301674366, 0.017290417104959488, -0.016673047095537186, -0.02807963825762272, -0.013880917802453041, -0.026066608726978302, -0.014061304740607738, -0.07474416494369507, 0.057876814156770706, 0.016177676618099213, 0.012328434735536575, -0.031142162159085274, 0.011319892480969429, -0.0006013682577759027, -0.009447437711060047, 0.052919335663318634, 0.013401445932686329, 0.003824859857559204, 0.01867537386715412, 0.03131362050771713, 0.01259701605886221, -0.03181285038590431, -0.013328163884580135, -0.021241433918476105, -0.002445570193231106, -0.048174213618040085, -0.033958353102207184, -0.0166778527200222, -0.006921584252268076, 0.01646614447236061, -0.011703944765031338, 0.026366932317614555, 0.01370119396597147, 0.006348319351673126, 0.07641761004924774, 0.021848982200026512, -0.003324095392599702, 0.07119952887296677, -0.017171824350953102, 0.03498512879014015, -0.0036633398849517107, 0.005446598865091801, -0.07819326967000961, 0.005701673682779074, -0.01414167694747448, -0.03208421915769577, 0.01701200008392334, 0.00984154548496008, -0.007208704948425293, -0.0030516793485730886, -0.03168107569217682, 0.04709563031792641, -0.01309413556009531, -0.021159447729587555, 0.025712788105010986, 0.05328897014260292, 0.06003456935286522, -0.018031487241387367, -0.037619199603796005, 0.015002202242612839, -0.033352214843034744, 0.010278056375682354, 0.044828128069639206, 0.05729895830154419, 0.027195613831281662, -0.006324359681457281, 0.018548544496297836, -0.022474290803074837, 0.013961108401417732, 0.019465414807200432, 0.03544298931956291, -0.04381975531578064, -0.023282214999198914, -0.014476100914180279, 0.016856513917446136, 0.020267538726329803, 0.02639421820640564, -0.024426423013210297, 0.07299403846263885, -0.025894084945321083, 0.009573842398822308, 0.0010538584319874644, 0.007155824918299913, -0.038002513349056244, -0.014393470250070095, 0.03486669436097145, 0.012327494099736214, -0.005654874723404646, 0.008210710249841213, -0.023436563089489937, -0.006468034815043211, 0.047581858932971954, -0.015113316476345062, 0.002678799908608198, 0.043938226997852325, 0.00012234934547450393, -0.03647246211767197, -0.007472796831279993, 0.00006291532918112352, -0.021133514121174812, 0.009352583438158035, 0.02552199363708496, 0.006905987858772278, -0.013535978272557259, -0.03859909251332283, -0.021298592910170555, 0.0746089294552803, -0.06905106455087662, 0.009713583625853062, -0.03895841911435127, 0.018616273999214172, 0.00018793833442032337, -0.00028782483423128724 ]
<p>I have a R data frame like this:</p> <pre><code>structure(list(Mash_pear = c(0.328239947270445, 0.752207607551684, 0.812118104861163, 0.640824971449627, 0.615568052052443, 0.546635339103089, 0.557460706464288, 0.650480192893698, 0.418044504894929, 0.52962586938499 ), tRap_pear = c(0.0350096175177328, 0.234255507711743, 0.23714999195134, 0.185536020521134, 0.191585098617356, 0.201402054387186, 0.220911538536031, 0.216072802572045, 0.132247101763063, 0.172753098431029), Beeml_pear = c(0.179209909971615, 0.79129167285928, 0.856908302056589, 0.729078080521886, 0.709346164378725, 0.669599784720647, 0.585348196746785, 0.639355942917055, 0.544909349368496, 0.794652394149651), Mash_pear50 = c(0.192474082559755, 0.679726904159742, 0.778564545349054, 0.573745352397321, 0.56633658385284, 0.472559997318901, 0.462635414367878, 0.562128414492567, 0.354624921832056, 0.64532681437697 ), labels = c("Aft1", "Alx3", "Alx4", "Arid3a", "Arid3a", "Arid3a", "Arid3a", "Arid5a", "Arid5a", "Aro80"), fam = c("AFT", "Homeo", "Homeo", "BRIGHT", "BRIGHT", "BRIGHT", "BRIGHT", "BRIGHT", "BRIGHT", "Zn2Cys6"), pwmlength = c("21", "17", "17", "17", "17", "17", "17", "14", "14", "21")), .Names = c("Mash_pear", "tRap_pear", "Beeml_pear", "Mash_pear50", "labels", "fam", "pwmlength"), row.names = c("Aft1", "Alx3_3418.2", "Alx4_1744.1", "Arid3a_3875.1_v1_primary", "Arid3a_3875.1_v2_primary", "Arid3a_3875.2_v1_primary", "Arid3a_3875.2_v2_primary", "Arid5a_3770.2_v1_primary", "Arid5a_3770.2_v2_primary", "Aro80"), class = "data.frame") </code></pre> <p>The first 4 columns are my correlations which i want to test for significant differences. These 4 columns are methods to estimate transcription factor binding to the DNA. Now i want to know which method performs best? I tried a paired t-test and unpaired t-test which seems the most suitable to me. Now i am wondering on how to interpret the test and are there other ways to test which method is better. </p> <p>Data.frame for readability:</p> <pre><code> Mash_pear tRap_pear Beeml_pear Mash_pear50 labels fam pwmlength Aft1 0.3282399 0.03500962 0.1792099 0.1924741 Aft1 AFT 21 Alx3_3418.2 0.7522076 0.23425551 0.7912917 0.6797269 Alx3 Homeo 17 Alx4_1744.1 0.8121181 0.23714999 0.8569083 0.7785645 Alx4 Homeo 17 Arid3a_3875.1_v1_primary 0.6408250 0.18553602 0.7290781 0.5737454 Arid3a BRIGHT 17 Arid3a_3875.1_v2_primary 0.6155681 0.19158510 0.7093462 0.5663366 Arid3a BRIGHT 17 Arid3a_3875.2_v1_primary 0.5466353 0.20140205 0.6695998 0.4725600 Arid3a BRIGHT 17 Arid3a_3875.2_v2_primary 0.5574607 0.22091154 0.5853482 0.4626354 Arid3a BRIGHT 17 Arid5a_3770.2_v1_primary 0.6504802 0.21607280 0.6393559 0.5621284 Arid5a BRIGHT 14 Arid5a_3770.2_v2_primary 0.4180445 0.13224710 0.5449093 0.3546249 Arid5a BRIGHT 14 Aro80 0.5296259 0.17275310 0.7946524 0.6453268 Aro80 Zn2Cys6 21 </code></pre>
74,253
[ -0.04073678329586983, 0.00029998880927450955, 0.009246268309652805, -0.01678825169801712, 0.0023703817278146744, 0.024612577632069588, -0.007214815821498632, -0.05347675830125809, -0.009296296164393425, -0.04323270171880722, 0.05990905314683914, 0.04482525214552879, 0.03627773001790047, 0.04076530039310455, 0.01627446711063385, -0.0025900446344166994, 0.016114704310894012, -0.008187294006347656, -0.0036935138050466776, -0.023126007989048958, 0.005152243655174971, 0.012188595719635487, 0.011075194925069809, -0.03114412911236286, -0.01339662168174982, 0.05264175683259964, 0.04318640008568764, -0.01448633149266243, 0.00763275008648634, 0.05946134030818939, -0.05291198566555977, -0.020121952518820763, 0.022635748609900475, 0.01458838488906622, 0.0414964035153389, 0.03694487363100052, -0.008331304416060448, -0.026926835998892784, -0.04644162952899933, 0.031359318643808365, -0.012102828361093998, 0.012192192487418652, 0.016893630847334862, 0.015312490053474903, -0.004767485894262791, 0.010746939107775688, -0.0005985136958770454, 0.04000001773238182, 0.043335046619176865, -0.0003942380135413259, 0.08378612250089645, -0.018431367352604866, 0.010268814861774445, 0.01626002974808216, -0.036460842937231064, 0.0001329611404798925, 0.05598026514053345, 0.04671049490571022, -0.010823342949151993, -0.04513249918818474, -0.004731317982077599, -0.02665555663406849, -0.014699551276862621, -0.014075766317546368, -0.035670116543769836, 0.01815849542617798, -0.017199279740452766, -0.004616776946932077, -0.030192501842975616, -0.03871624171733856, -0.026013147085905075, -0.010965907014906406, 0.010399822145700455, -0.04377847537398338, 0.02893756330013275, 0.0002454993373248726, 0.04177848622202873, 0.025716833770275116, 0.0353308729827404, 0.0079576401039958, 0.021643996238708496, 0.011535708792507648, 0.03267890214920044, 0.029665507376194, 0.029112346470355988, -0.0052753956988453865, 0.037731919437646866, -0.03957372531294823, 0.020692501217126846, 0.023491309955716133, 0.011907312087714672, 0.03752175346016884, 0.06057991087436676, 0.007912381552159786, -0.01370417233556509, 0.012014755979180336, 0.04106806218624115, 0.02362646535038948, -0.007822341285645962, -0.055724553763866425, -0.008437197655439377, -0.04803682863712311, 0.002645823173224926, 0.0422733798623085, -0.022785965353250504, -0.02467980608344078, -0.04875630512833595, -0.03357484191656113, -0.050565097481012344, -0.012348027899861336, 0.010680352337658405, -0.018049612641334534, -0.005847586784511805, -0.038868650794029236, 0.026341285556554794, -0.06911659985780716, -0.006910125259310007, -0.0011481662513688207, 0.026609189808368683, 0.011396673507988453, 0.041281841695308685, -0.002829240635037422, 0.053762562572956085, -0.025957904756069183, -0.05730274319648743, -0.006722832564264536, 0.0016451969277113676, -0.00552735710516572, -0.015465442091226578, 0.0015026156324893236, 0.003641164395958185, -0.02549625188112259, 0.07446594536304474, -0.011744758114218712, 0.009085285477340221, 0.01153878029435873, -0.05542523041367531, -0.06075354292988777, 0.013596962206065655, -0.028194008395075798, 0.018395600840449333, -0.028160519897937775, -0.008305219933390617, 0.01960141398012638, 0.01837536133825779, -0.021892327815294266, 0.013926705345511436, 0.05729493871331215, 0.051626864820718765, 0.04114890843629837, -0.04693547636270523, -0.044092632830142975, -0.020314525812864304, 0.00377144874073565, 0.00602588290348649, -0.06973125040531158, 0.0029909955337643623, -0.02141055278480053, -0.029521681368350983, 0.010520704090595245, 0.03031488135457039, -0.03271203488111496, -0.004472031723707914, -0.05137525126338005, -0.04591289535164833, -0.008175707422196865, 0.04062589630484581, 0.05369262397289276, 0.02537817694246769, 0.04852882772684097, -0.04080852493643761, -0.018941326066851616, -0.023527681827545166, 0.01753578521311283, 0.038666270673274994, -0.03205067664384842, 0.05871381238102913, -0.021135540679097176, -0.01832623779773712, 0.06692050397396088, -0.0429501049220562, -0.041758231818675995, 0.014825458638370037, 0.003666448639705777, 0.03593669831752777, 0.026528887450695038, 0.02574748732149601, -0.007312500849366188, 0.052439264953136444, -0.0814819410443306, -0.03148515895009041, -0.06343965232372284, 0.008517134003341198, 0.0017888523871079087, -0.06461140513420105, -0.02513313852250576, 0.040279947221279144, 0.026149393990635872, -0.01852995902299881, -0.03248313069343567, -0.020993512123823166, 0.06106201559305191, 0.05511535704135895, -0.036752715706825256, -0.035439230501651764, 0.028674636036157608, 0.04374559223651886, -0.03449982777237892, 0.04465753585100174, -0.0044169663451612, 0.0035043430980294943, 0.017691737040877342, -0.01979977637529373, 0.0015097149880602956, -0.01207374595105648, -0.018490292131900787, 0.025913234800100327, 0.01403042022138834, 0.003960179630666971, 0.03924823924899101, -0.05488768592476845, 0.0005379776121117175, 0.055535297840833664, 0.05117170885205269, 0.029309991747140884, -0.02755260281264782, 0.014568605460226536, 0.08913183212280273, -0.041336532682180405, 0.004358803387731314, 0.014539368450641632, 0.012038493528962135, 0.022524788975715637, 0.04044155031442642, -0.02853616699576378, -0.010637495666742325, 0.05569063127040863, -0.02288869582116604, 0.010174340568482876, 0.0645759329199791, 0.010289180092513561, -0.027143286541104317, 0.05698497220873833, 0.0016974495956674218, 0.0373004674911499, 0.015486742369830608, 0.034913599491119385, -0.004772361367940903, 0.0718650370836258, -0.00625044759362936, 0.010366920381784439, -0.004336911253631115, 0.012174833565950394, -0.018624356016516685, -0.004603126551955938, -0.042745403945446014, 0.04503480717539787, -0.001293432665988803, 0.0013252748176455498, 0.040249697864055634, 0.04712638258934021, -0.01223181001842022, -0.018411953002214432, -0.015135343186557293, -0.020962899550795555, 0.05329973250627518, -0.03833948075771332, -0.019428038969635963, 0.0015399729600176215, -0.047465115785598755, 0.05176938697695732, 0.021683990955352783, -0.024637749418616295, -0.04555032029747963, 0.039178553968667984, 0.012082855217158794, 0.009924359619617462, 0.02153562381863594, -0.02219756692647934, -0.03288688138127327, 0.015935635194182396, 0.012173125520348549, 0.05868569388985634, -0.0406925305724144, -0.03839365392923355, 0.02275419794023037, -0.016872942447662354, 0.016634972766041756, 0.047678593546152115, 0.0150000536814332, -0.08605870604515076, -0.007429733406752348, 0.006140819285064936, -0.0007077924092300236, -0.01605982519686222, -0.04592478647828102, 0.017328768968582153, -0.040406592190265656, -0.04018649458885193, 0.05026201158761978, 0.01145370863378048, -0.07985828071832657, 0.0009193668374791741, -0.042435064911842346, -0.002407829975709319, -0.0358130969107151, -0.02008897066116333, -0.0127320047467947, 0.008327173069119453, 0.02684086561203003, -0.026421455666422844, -0.02689920738339424, 0.03259797394275665, -0.05450868606567383, -0.03530600294470787, -0.04290486127138138, -0.00735850352793932, 0.033330127596855164, 0.0032624450977891684, -0.04303211718797684, 0.060426078736782074, 0.004946758504956961, -0.03571062535047531, -0.040978290140628815, 0.0000027996115932182875, -0.022451451048254967, -0.032599419355392456, 0.01973787508904934, 0.0364435613155365, 0.016297047957777977, -0.008855888620018959, -0.01900549605488777, 0.06581579893827438, 0.028867624700069427, -0.022601045668125153, 0.011756951920688152, 0.035176582634449005, -0.015319012105464935, -0.03270702436566353, 0.01894131302833557, 0.020432287827134132, -0.008010085672140121, 0.05281703546643257, -0.019427422434091568, -0.06189706176519394, -0.0071915253065526485, -0.046805109828710556, -0.013699027709662914, 0.009903919883072376, 0.05383504927158356, -0.03048785775899887, 0.007607729639858007, -0.0109905069693923, -0.027801761403679848, 0.020755602046847343, 0.0028851130045950413, 0.016210181638598442, -0.022834280505776405, 0.0010219616815447807, 0.0460873581469059, 0.013476173393428326, 0.005572015885263681, 0.042464543133974075, 0.013804808259010315, -0.037934694439172745, 0.008857985027134418, -0.012612382881343365, -0.04463764280080795, 0.013049676083028316, 0.014019354246556759, 0.045341476798057556, 0.03224259987473488, -0.0017766956007108092, 0.029122283682227135, -0.01467809733003378, -0.01445805188268423, -0.045138996094465256, 0.04395926371216774, 0.013138358481228352, 0.08351478725671768, -0.004174458794295788, 0.02166609838604927, 0.006783241871744394, -0.035556063055992126, -0.05232543498277664, 0.04397924244403839, 0.02727576717734337, 0.017930330708622932, -0.04050817713141441, -0.03220793604850769, -0.015805598348379135, -0.0085405632853508, 0.025485722348093987, 0.02659425139427185, -0.0015425663441419601, -0.016790878027677536, 0.02151603065431118, 0.0021452063228935003, 0.013741821981966496, -0.01464932318776846, -0.004139467142522335, 0.07303721457719803, -0.00711585721001029, 0.03330954164266586, 0.028762642294168472, -0.0318421795964241, 0.009281320497393608, -0.03611886501312256, 0.027524396777153015, 0.020776642486453056, 0.029248351231217384, 0.040010303258895874, -0.005181445740163326, -0.01651265099644661, 0.011824025772511959, 0.013522859662771225, 0.005816054064780474, 0.062051545828580856, -0.012081912718713284, 0.022138988599181175, -0.0003773307253140956, -0.00922272726893425, 0.006247885525226593, 0.024294298142194748, -0.004644170869141817, 0.03581295534968376, 0.020035365596413612, -0.02103983424603939, -0.004107888787984848, 0.00983789935708046, 0.0346168577671051, -0.0037874539848417044, 0.013361435383558273, -0.07395180314779282, -0.032005392014980316, 0.018831033259630203, 0.03091529570519924, 0.01585954613983631, 0.016296055167913437, 0.028983980417251587, 0.02325143851339817, -0.008062610402703285, 0.013451025821268559, -0.011861373670399189, 0.011166266165673733, 0.04388025775551796, 0.008519269526004791, -0.04502446576952934, -0.027315396815538406, 0.03193384408950806, 0.03577159717679024, 0.01772407628595829, -0.024760279804468155, -0.0009203947265632451, -0.10019005835056305, -0.0050614336505532265, 0.026561643928289413, 0.05894719809293747, -0.04011245444417, -0.026168186217546463, -0.07560016959905624, -0.008576001971960068, 0.06307124346494675, -0.029207149520516396, 0.04279974848031998, 0.014628453180193901, 0.020473923534154892, -0.016237817704677582, -0.047733113169670105, -0.06776606291532516, -0.007842428050935268, -0.04965033382177353, 0.02693200670182705, -0.04433362931013107, -0.041531752794981, -0.015078513883054256, 0.0017980353441089392, -0.020390981808304787, 0.01249532587826252, -0.02746853046119213, 0.001506164437159896, -0.0054333084262907505, 0.01980704441666603, -0.021759290248155594, -0.03258468583226204, 0.000615956261754036, -0.009874619543552399, -0.00405548419803381, 0.06545043736696243, -0.01685456559062004, -0.023543264716863632, 0.021478373557329178, 0.011989488266408443, 0.03178391233086586, 0.0043359436094760895, -0.006967522203922272, 0.04381212964653969, 0.04350114241242409, -0.004157430492341518, 0.04720607399940491, 0.026858903467655182, -0.009738541208207607, 0.008078044280409813, -0.04481078311800957, 0.000004861123670707457, -0.02488509565591812, -0.03738119453191757, -0.05128950998187065, 0.021527616307139397, -0.01805676333606243, 0.056917496025562286, -0.02996489219367504, 0.039585404098033905, -0.009051487781107426, 0.008652265183627605, 0.05797224119305611, 0.04842609912157059, -0.08098003268241882, -0.049596063792705536, -0.000021054021999589168, 0.004976966883987188, 0.01927288994193077, -0.0031196153722703457, 0.03336198627948761, -0.018284054473042488, 0.01641608588397503, -0.01088009774684906, -0.03133584186434746, 0.010408131405711174, -0.002892203163355589, -0.015173797495663166, 0.016724474728107452, -0.005437362473458052, -0.0014831935986876488, 0.0029661227017641068, 0.029563939198851585, 0.020701777189970016, -0.06578480452299118, 0.0034611423034220934, 0.018545901402831078, 0.03386782482266426, -0.013796552084386349, -0.0331939235329628, 0.015841368585824966, -0.021810879930853844, -0.01531673502177, -0.0538775734603405, -0.033680401742458344, 0.03076627478003502, -0.008253144100308418, -0.057481441646814346, -0.02447745017707348, -0.026790423318743706, 0.008649964816868305, -0.021959379315376282, -0.027367500588297844, 0.026866862550377846, -0.04823312163352966, 0.026713475584983826, -0.013426169753074646, 0.007750296499580145, 0.07624541223049164, 0.023867014795541763, 0.027260594069957733, 0.025340428575873375, -0.021110698580741882, -0.01874481700360775, 0.03497632220387459, -0.03317125141620636, -0.020831286907196045, -0.012783943675458431, 0.015199879184365273, 0.005455391947180033, 0.03626030310988426, 0.0075114574283361435, -0.012628002092242241, -0.025970127433538437, 0.013552209362387657, 0.006215482018887997, -0.04528254643082619, -0.011935766786336899, -0.012133764103055, -0.008961185812950134, -0.02691793628036976, 0.012694512493908405, -0.0008005803101696074, -0.02046157419681549, 0.0018644678639248013, -0.020802650600671768, -0.049697794020175934, 0.0034422820899635553, 0.06296852976083755, -0.0059856995940208435, -0.010044786147773266, 0.01376427710056305, -0.021379757672548294, 0.02043047361075878, 0.0018833255162462592, 0.009151371195912361, 0.004269940312951803, 0.029438255354762077, -0.017963040620088577, -0.015188178978860378, -0.042527198791503906, -0.0013442892814055085, 0.06665163487195969, 0.016042055562138557, 0.030223997309803963, -0.001331821666099131, 0.008555559441447258, 0.0026880952063947916, -0.011812948621809483, 0.0142868896946311, 0.02593414857983589, 0.02319246530532837, 0.06121933087706566, -0.0021996444556862116, -0.0016940422356128693, 0.044474970549345016, -0.003917235881090164, 0.03208332881331444, 0.037923913449048996, -0.026605743914842606, -0.023067744448781013, 0.010751835070550442, -0.032543230801820755, -0.0018905553733929992, 0.033011823892593384, -0.04989422485232353, 0.024963771924376488, -0.05366576090455055, -0.032638221979141235, 0.04775437340140343, 0.03459985926747322, -0.005373311694711447, -0.0577847994863987, -0.05407086759805679, -0.020237939432263374, -0.010874615050852299, 0.04368380084633827, -0.0477781780064106, 0.024372845888137817, -0.0098977480083704, 0.04659196734428406, -0.05660749226808548, 0.052639495581388474, -0.05692843720316887, -0.061417993158102036, -0.016821594908833504, -0.014691296964883804, -0.007837159559130669, 0.02768723852932453, 0.01115735899657011, -0.008423571474850178, 0.02440601773560047, -0.036131590604782104, 0.008115510456264019, -0.010332557372748852, -0.006523752585053444, 0.014615225605666637, 0.058287519961595535, -0.033956319093704224, -0.001062885276041925, -0.015047069638967514, -0.046677593141794205, 0.1516750007867813, 0.049786269664764404, 0.04418441280722618, -0.07210727035999298, 0.02910151518881321, 0.0673210620880127, -0.005806345026940107, -0.031162893399596214, -0.029921559616923332, 0.0015231647994369268, -0.025639763101935387, 0.06704571843147278, 0.018067698925733566, 0.030478080734610558, 0.019897107034921646, 0.017832063138484955, -0.030824346467852592, 0.023425374180078506, 0.03516881912946701, 0.011245818808674812, -0.002875717356801033, 0.0018419900443404913, -0.06168319657444954, 0.024571457877755165, 0.000370145367924124, -0.023612936958670616, -0.06335074454545975, -0.0028557335026562214, -0.03350984305143356, 0.01629185490310192, 0.020248116925358772, 0.010779625736176968, -0.024064287543296814, -0.01095837727189064, 0.029536090791225433, 0.008083770982921124, 0.0024822549894452095, -0.03689464554190636, 0.03912705183029175, 0.035939596593379974, 0.00874675065279007, 0.002866551512852311, -0.0178599264472723, 0.014702504500746727, -0.013854648917913437, -0.008175458759069443, -0.03622913360595703, 0.027526985853910446, 0.00245184195227921, -0.007972611114382744, 0.026513133198022842, 0.007091081701219082, 0.024575745686888695, -0.051174573600292206, -0.023458711802959442, 0.032163556665182114, 0.007459525018930435, -0.003104928182438016, 0.006220431532710791, 0.017077339813113213, -0.002783688250929117, 0.026374762877821922, 0.045678623020648956, 0.0011433186009526253, -0.02840280905365944, -0.025661662220954895, -0.01938444934785366, 0.03441682085394859, -0.017771849408745766, 0.03205078840255737, -0.0020190041977912188, -0.035690221935510635, -0.01835326850414276, -0.01688353717327118, 0.029703792184591293, -0.009697971865534782, -0.013013225980103016, -0.01252598874270916, -0.05344757065176964, -0.011661753058433533, -0.020144226029515266, 0.044523049145936966, -0.046559274196624756, 0.0014410532312467694, -0.0007658844697289169, -0.01217010710388422, 0.04062728211283684, 0.05107813701033592, 0.025383535772562027, 0.006091780960559845, -0.04183100908994675, 0.0857023224234581, -0.009207438677549362, -0.03676045313477516, -0.008910451084375381, 0.030493710190057755, 0.0011529517360031605, 0.032500822097063065, -0.02249929867684841, 0.06361285597085953, 0.02332034707069397, 0.01030976977199316, -0.011521635577082634, 0.001366285141557455, 0.007947295904159546, -0.026185831055045128, -0.0024384665302932262, -0.0018502742750570178, 0.006898914463818073, 0.02672063559293747, -0.013846502639353275, -0.04762313887476921, -0.006761589553207159, -0.001461621723137796, -0.08332934975624084, 0.016585994511842728, -0.03220488876104355, -0.04141584783792496, 0.015780378133058548, -0.02520177699625492, -0.033340007066726685, -0.00485912524163723, -0.007764752954244614, -0.027497364208102226, -0.015321599319577217, -0.03482765704393387, -0.01671746000647545, 0.007478275801986456, 0.01602272316813469, -0.02927733212709427, 0.018143421038985252, 0.020503191277384758, 0.009481715969741344, 0.009434680454432964, 0.007708217483013868, 0.025579897686839104, 0.022902294993400574, 0.02184741385281086, -0.0016179727390408516, -0.004952633287757635, 0.00705688213929534, -0.07861778885126114, -0.022649282589554787, 0.016148213297128677, -0.008818507194519043, 0.018973151221871376, -0.0058615198358893394, 0.03543857857584953, 0.009436430409550667, 0.044306520372629166, -0.006159051321446896, 0.02752606011927128, 0.018655264750123024, 0.0228820089250803, 0.031126055866479874, 0.011533882468938828, 0.007879974320530891, -0.008747702464461327, -0.008048768155276775, 0.012828461825847626, 0.055934928357601166, 0.006654778961092234, 0.00583262974396348, 0.02396971359848976, -0.02150411158800125, -0.005705087445676327, -0.007096626330167055, 0.012569391168653965, 0.03283211961388588, 0.03637508675456047, 0.0008727142121642828, 0.009802062064409256, -0.01581164076924324, -0.03132106736302376, -0.06029617041349411, -0.007687292527407408, 0.015419467352330685, -0.016104113310575485, 0.08165059983730316, -0.02796419896185398, -0.012406272813677788, -0.002003076719120145, -0.02918791025876999, 0.02620970644056797, -0.0005516349337995052, 0.021687351167201996, -0.02280235104262829, 0.025075426325201988, -0.055059127509593964, 0.02627485804259777, 0.05225898325443268, -0.0027618063613772392, 0.08369388431310654, -0.004901341162621975, 0.007384933065623045, -0.04723341763019562, -0.028541069477796555, -0.013003285974264145, 0.014507431536912918, -0.06059502810239792, 0.03190205618739128, -0.02883971855044365, 0.0025502832140773535, -0.001520407386124134, -0.017411045730113983, -0.0174096692353487, -0.0027232682332396507, 0.021814951673150063, 0.010550310835242271, 0.05033509060740471, 0.020176265388727188, 0.005659991409629583, -0.015911472961306572, 0.01081241387873888, -0.02096552588045597, 0.008725123479962349, -0.017288681119680405, 0.032439906150102615, -0.0350748710334301, 0.009271111339330673, 0.0072756377048790455, 0.012721632607281208, -0.002908569760620594, 0.005121962167322636, -0.02901541255414486, 0.028266333043575287, -0.0004523473035078496, -0.05524473264813423, -0.012461238540709019, -0.019704950973391533, 0.06147964298725128, 0.05551259592175484, 0.03257584199309349, -0.0011105034500360489, 0.01119149662554264, 0.003947795834392309, -0.05618167668581009, -0.00928143784403801, 0.013122188858687878, -0.02803925611078739, -0.027689313516020775, -0.022932130843400955, -0.0042537967674434185, -0.040968313813209534, -0.018391676247119904, 0.040683645755052567, -0.05115480348467827, 0.06830928474664688, -0.024481182917952538, 0.007982661947607994, 0.016632240265607834, -0.010063624009490013, 0.02186974510550499, -0.08232695609331131, 0.03911370784044266, 0.007378988899290562, 0.03589121997356415, -0.025229834020137787, -0.05364782735705376, -0.009105890989303589, 0.04396441578865051, 0.030761167407035828, 0.037586748600006104, 0.00033394122147001326, 0.0015538190491497517, 0.016141874715685844, 0.011855926364660263, -0.06059655547142029, 0.057408083230257034, 0.017094384878873825, 0.004512859974056482, -0.0052184234373271465, -0.007422653492540121, 0.01949514076113701, 0.02256765402853489, 0.009890895336866379, -0.008046437986195087, -0.032421182841062546, 0.015848392620682716, -0.04509074240922928, -0.00418044300749898, -0.03642839565873146, 0.008504441007971764, -0.007633316330611706, 0.03476114571094513, 0.006032361648976803, 0.0671091377735138, -0.011871467344462872, -0.07392636686563492, -0.003512572031468153, -0.04543032497167587, -0.03527772054076195, 0.0022706484887748957, -0.010517016053199768, -0.0061750514432787895, -0.04681171849370003, 0.025325121358036995, -0.008021309040486813, -0.06560303270816803, -0.0005054912180639803, 0.012810220010578632, -0.01639193668961525, 0.03319087624549866, -0.025617819279432297, 0.011289023794233799, -0.022174594923853874, -0.02017267979681492, 0.02062932588160038, -0.018542492762207985, 0.002431335626170039, -0.004348516929894686, -0.01771833375096321, 0.000571364420466125, -0.015458834357559681, 0.02742001600563526, -0.009936858899891376, 0.05416923761367798, -0.020534571260213852, -0.015591369941830635, 0.04661880433559418, -0.04485758766531944, 0.0145849185064435, -0.0008650525705888867, -0.009573587216436863, 0.040838878601789474, -0.033922869712114334, 0.013549904339015484, 0.0181577205657959, -0.006750565953552723, -0.023371348157525063, 0.0019622959662228823, -0.01580231823027134, 0.00596624193713069, -0.0335366316139698, 0.014203283004462719, 0.02385004237294197, -0.0042656222358345985, 0.007993189617991447, 0.033086396753787994, 0.03935620188713074, 0.011231332086026669, -0.009525293484330177, 0.00577826052904129, -0.02176414243876934, -0.02267496846616268, -0.04081926494836807, -0.009085149504244328, -0.005928629077970982, 0.011916931718587875, -0.029951078817248344, 0.010778574272990227, 0.026104610413312912, 0.018178297206759453, -0.017444901168346405, -0.02359345741569996, 0.008643894456326962, 0.035071052610874176, 0.03590460494160652, -0.008752536959946156 ]
<p>My project is about purchasing power parity (PPP). I am checking whether the real exchange rate of Canadian dollar(CAD)/US dollar(USD), Japanese Yen(JPY)/USD and Great Britain Pound(GBP)/USD has a unit root with Augmented Dickey Fuller (ADF). </p> <ul> <li>H0 is - there is a unit root for the series and real ex. rate will follow the random walk and is non-stationary </li> <li>H1 is - there is no unit root and the real exchange rate is stationary and PPP holds. </li> </ul> <p>I have created a diagram of the real exchange rates over the sample period, unfortunately I can not attach photos, due to the site regulations (I don't have 10 reputation yet) Anyways my JPY ex rate is highly volatile, fluctuates between 1.7 and 2.3 over the period; GBP is giving similar line, only it fluctuates between -0.3 and 0.1; CAD is the one that seems to have stationarity, it is relatively flat, moves between -0.1 and 0.3. </p> <p>All the critical values are the same for all three results, and only t-statistic and the p-values are different. 1% -3.442; 5% -2.871; 10% -2.570</p> <p>In Cad/USD t-stat is -1.568 and p-value 0.4997; in JPY/USD t-stat -2.551 and p-value 0.1036; in GBP/USD t-stat is -3.410 and p-value 0.0106</p> <p>It seems that with the rise of the t-stat result, p-value decreases; moreover my H0 is rejected at 5 and 10% for GBP and is not rejected at 1%. I am really puzzled at how to give the interpretation for that. (Maybe it's because it fluctuates under zero?)</p> <p>My supervisor wants me to explain what is the connection between t-stat and the p-value. and if possible could you please explain in simple English what is the unit root, mathematical explanations were of no help. I have also read the article <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/29121/intuitive-explanation-of-unit-root">Intuitive explanation of unit root</a> already, unfortunately I still could not get the main idea of the unit root</p>
37,018
[ 0.022150496020913124, -0.04244118928909302, 0.0013432538835331798, -0.013136967085301876, 0.09045375883579254, 0.031057676300406456, -0.007327024359256029, -0.023426692932844162, 0.01341485045850277, -0.06600398570299149, 0.048965808004140854, 0.032634492963552475, 0.026492832228541374, 0.014504866674542427, -0.030746987089514732, -0.009319430217146873, -0.001402165973559022, 0.0028158582281321287, 0.0114423967897892, -0.027597445994615555, 0.03959602862596512, 0.010892141610383987, -0.013163420371711254, 0.01351955160498619, -0.03997218236327171, 0.03710777312517166, 0.02527022548019886, 0.0006207047263160348, -0.008461900986731052, 0.0752081498503685, -0.040332432836294174, 0.015955545008182526, -0.0035027589183300734, -0.018923984840512276, 0.03167276456952095, 0.05960526689887047, -0.02929968200623989, -0.03221298009157181, -0.011621027253568172, 0.04498171806335449, -0.03835803642868996, -0.01089287456125021, 0.035145897418260574, 0.00966598466038704, 0.008656604215502739, 0.024440739303827286, 0.03770714998245239, 0.011219517327845097, 0.04223509505391121, -0.05026347190141678, 0.027159957215189934, 0.0046513997949659824, 0.00501698674634099, 0.004876450169831514, -0.005559336394071579, -0.04521207883954048, 0.06064464896917343, 0.02402474172413349, -0.04504826292395592, -0.0536343939602375, -0.001874294364824891, -0.020699257031083107, 0.0031438451260328293, -0.025209622457623482, -0.019611502066254616, 0.03040142171084881, 0.0002258241001982242, -0.015382629819214344, 0.004068573471158743, -0.027641208842396736, 0.04916207492351532, -0.005316415335983038, 0.02643600106239319, -0.01714213564991951, 0.004557769279927015, -0.0265636146068573, 0.012114906683564186, 0.06767295300960541, 0.02970709279179573, 0.052002377808094025, 0.025829127058386803, 0.034087713807821274, -0.005969473626464605, 0.039331190288066864, 0.030853083357214928, -0.010144495405256748, 0.04843270033597946, -0.017992816865444183, 0.0011866895947605371, 0.05351739004254341, -0.027738139033317566, -0.04937664046883583, 0.05195879191160202, 0.0025603303220123053, -0.030794590711593628, 0.022479400038719177, -0.017980147153139114, 0.054584138095378876, 0.0048737963661551476, 0.010979958809912205, -0.024918992072343826, -0.055478863418102264, 0.014284627512097359, 0.0349566824734211, 0.008997109718620777, -0.015632811933755875, -0.003304295241832733, -0.028455644845962524, -0.01465865969657898, -0.019985869526863098, -0.03857040777802467, 0.03869256004691124, -0.0008341890061274171, -0.020123064517974854, -0.004189042374491692, -0.006291708443313837, -0.01006461400538683, -0.0525912269949913, 0.055880073457956314, 0.0016617121873423457, 0.02594996988773346, -0.018001103773713112, 0.02232237346470356, 0.005466464441269636, -0.08374479413032532, 0.015527823939919472, 0.00833235401660204, -0.012675195932388306, -0.038663942366838455, 0.045363668352365494, 0.015008917078375816, -0.0133771738037467, 0.012893524952232838, 0.0015186662785708904, 0.054292161017656326, 0.011004136875271797, -0.10467520356178284, -0.05690323933959007, 0.07086116820573807, -0.013462355360388756, 0.00019361794693395495, -0.04608813300728798, -0.014608759433031082, 0.02264253981411457, 0.054586540907621384, -0.007564557250589132, 0.006252294406294823, 0.0067945849150419235, 0.028766250237822533, 0.01844288781285286, -0.019261790439486504, -0.02217777818441391, -0.01932745985686779, -0.0074141258373856544, 0.0018798792734742165, -0.07007082551717758, -0.006556434091180563, 0.06609433144330978, -0.007245036773383617, -0.002882867818698287, 0.03608410805463791, 0.0032912357710301876, -0.021120082587003708, 0.010592710226774216, -0.015450690872967243, -0.022601468488574028, 0.05018279328942299, 0.003945597447454929, 0.021159334108233452, -0.008125953376293182, 0.013833967037498951, 0.018138719722628593, -0.023568691685795784, 0.035668835043907166, 0.0029437618795782328, -0.052023839205503464, -0.007829123176634312, -0.028075292706489563, -0.0187478456646204, -0.028432060033082962, -0.06878909468650818, -0.014591838233172894, -0.041259925812482834, -0.025619162246584892, 0.00314778252504766, 0.042059849947690964, -0.0016102802474051714, 0.014047075994312763, 0.03462158143520355, -0.07846193015575409, -0.08505169302225113, -0.04323946312069893, 0.0031188554130494595, -0.015732480213046074, -0.02194962650537491, -0.01320594921708107, -0.005320474039763212, -0.010719647631049156, -0.008728171698749065, 0.024689054116606712, 0.010570636950433254, 0.0015602725325152278, 0.025751588866114616, -0.023351632058620453, 0.018991323187947273, 0.0316627211868763, 0.035309430211782455, 0.0169847272336483, 0.014597808942198753, -0.025425555184483528, -0.03038855455815792, 0.020635537803173065, -0.03836950659751892, 0.020948151126503944, -0.008234052918851376, -0.042167939245700836, -0.003062888514250517, 0.011867553927004337, -0.005277760326862335, 0.036400675773620605, -0.020263906568288803, 0.05292409658432007, 0.038662828505039215, -0.03422212228178978, 0.007780034095048904, 0.03433271124958992, 0.009435245767235756, 0.042115554213523865, -0.05507289990782738, 0.027612904086709023, -0.053031258285045624, -0.03668857738375664, 0.04252689331769943, 0.06302371621131897, -0.030339468270540237, 0.009670032188296318, 0.08587703108787537, 0.001918204827234149, 0.011904649436473846, 0.022785108536481857, -0.008727701380848885, -0.058477506041526794, -0.00830148532986641, 0.004711923189461231, -0.0018328528385609388, 0.018333101645112038, 0.009587600827217102, -0.004126156214624643, 0.05936281010508537, -0.019297156482934952, 0.0025619943626224995, 0.04232020676136017, 0.021502964198589325, 0.02090631052851677, 0.014384564943611622, -0.016979163512587547, 0.034373294562101364, -0.045029692351818085, -0.019308263435959816, 0.006028435658663511, -0.0010939047206193209, -0.013628196902573109, 0.0028124952223151922, -0.03205801174044609, -0.0114298015832901, -0.014998824335634708, 0.028948506340384483, -0.010676735080778599, 0.01571827568113804, -0.042764533311128616, -0.01911265030503273, -0.04284996911883354, -0.018460197374224663, -0.04306338354945183, -0.0347265861928463, 0.03709864616394043, 0.040795717388391495, 0.026959054172039032, -0.022213416174054146, -0.02169271744787693, -0.003610573709011078, 0.017527570948004723, 0.005453755147755146, -0.019520409405231476, -0.038685500621795654, 0.012309395708143711, 0.004651779308915138, 0.0122104212641716, 0.03047923929989338, 0.009784646332263947, 0.0186130553483963, 0.045577071607112885, 0.010347693227231503, -0.014230672270059586, -0.038330961018800735, -0.024782540276646614, 0.014578340575098991, -0.055769018828868866, -0.009325815364718437, 0.07592979073524475, 0.002909379079937935, -0.007248958107084036, 0.03861332684755325, -0.04871368035674095, -0.02508634515106678, -0.02505006641149521, -0.026040751487016678, -0.02026667445898056, -0.020599227398633957, -0.005070475395768881, 0.0025749015621840954, -0.01842588745057583, 0.014743140898644924, -0.03628458455204964, -0.039477355778217316, 0.0320209376513958, 0.0026278174482285976, 0.02069982886314392, -0.05040793865919113, -0.01904170587658882, 0.055270589888095856, 0.031935591250658035, -0.02833026461303234, -0.04208223149180412, -0.007612784393131733, -0.04117944836616516, -0.038331594318151474, 0.04176069051027298, 0.05204952880740166, -0.0032806373201310635, 0.02390490099787712, -0.0119559895247221, 0.037678126245737076, 0.029018959030508995, 0.018579188734292984, -0.006789280101656914, 0.021216046065092087, -0.03917429596185684, -0.022676123306155205, 0.05681542679667473, 0.01310791540890932, -0.04233717918395996, 0.007747357245534658, -0.0058000716380774975, 0.02502298913896084, 0.04009092599153519, -0.04836255684494972, 0.05520873889327049, -0.00030099062132649124, -0.011529719457030296, -0.06692053377628326, 0.0317559614777565, -0.00044962603715248406, -0.017862625420093536, -0.03783867880702019, -0.01046905480325222, 0.014610914513468742, 0.005854382179677486, 0.014205114915966988, 0.07732255756855011, 0.04123812913894653, 0.02703813649713993, -0.002269154880195856, -0.02794651873409748, -0.005623501259833574, 0.021028265357017517, -0.012006925418972969, -0.0266302227973938, 0.02725381590425968, 0.0535358265042305, 0.022304987534880638, -0.007124622352421284, -0.03008344955742359, -0.024950608611106873, -0.06371843069791794, 0.02443866804242134, -0.0219777449965477, 0.07964149117469788, 0.01906839944422245, 0.04909557104110718, 0.024167846888303757, -0.0013815679121762514, 0.012951801531016827, 0.0007233810028992593, -0.04337194561958313, 0.07352116703987122, 0.0069330716505646706, -0.017334841191768646, 0.013604003004729748, -0.008246534503996372, 0.006166503299027681, -0.04411621019244194, 0.012265094555914402, -0.013429246842861176, 0.01456625759601593, -0.01652185432612896, 0.031150925904512405, -0.002789535094052553, 0.007509463932365179, -0.02268371917307377, -0.005781711079180241, 0.05906762182712555, -0.0037872607354074717, 0.05337746813893318, 0.06977096199989319, -0.015074768103659153, 0.03944651037454605, -0.0075508588925004005, 0.03218645229935646, 0.08612101525068283, 0.050057996064424515, 0.038168735802173615, 0.0077979424968361855, -0.03730498254299164, 0.026235802099108696, 0.029710419476032257, 0.01359448954463005, 0.057340726256370544, -0.019327376037836075, -0.015168468467891216, -0.014194468036293983, 0.01726466231048107, 0.01844944804906845, 0.000977440970018506, -0.005998420529067516, -0.0006992690614424646, 0.042877957224845886, 0.013376615941524506, 0.00708371726796031, -0.0014998395927250385, 0.07763542234897614, 0.009040809236466885, 0.041375089436769485, -0.046931326389312744, -0.059325821697711945, -0.007385037373751402, -0.002441809745505452, 0.0361197255551815, 0.03312661126255989, -0.01296019647270441, 0.006888494361191988, 0.041933875530958176, 0.02498467266559601, -0.03555244952440262, -0.015217243693768978, 0.033727988600730896, 0.045298025012016296, 0.026555901393294334, -0.02160431258380413, 0.04774579405784607, 0.006945973262190819, 0.015130463056266308, 0.019141435623168945, -0.010309025645256042, -0.09695248305797577, -0.018864145502448082, 0.0348772369325161, 0.046541351824998856, -0.026071757078170776, -0.028977634385228157, -0.06299705058336258, 0.01698148250579834, 0.005924370605498552, -0.0515570193529129, 0.04616359621286392, 0.008381144143640995, 0.013519220054149628, -0.011742145754396915, -0.028935937210917473, -0.04670724645256996, 0.027133580297231674, -0.005098613444715738, -0.0007542958483099937, -0.07306428253650665, -0.012992141768336296, -0.026393987238407135, -0.0030586854554712772, -0.0013109087012708187, 0.013948606327176094, -0.04522723704576492, 0.00557576771825552, 0.000978986732661724, 0.004680311307311058, 0.025300780311226845, -0.08861224353313446, 0.011658833362162113, 0.012689398601651192, 0.05689595267176628, 0.05791238322854042, -0.0030050533823668957, -0.011150248348712921, 0.011304101906716824, -0.012449786998331547, -0.010964775457978249, 0.011356166563928127, -0.04058866575360298, 0.05868823453783989, 0.02476114220917225, -0.024915162473917007, 0.050797875970602036, 0.025794850662350655, 0.011886749416589737, -0.017488066107034683, -0.01685308665037155, 0.0016388538060709834, -0.039867155253887177, 0.023084474727511406, -0.04243548959493637, -0.004442153964191675, -0.032929692417383194, 0.014548900537192822, 0.025184722617268562, 0.027068650349974632, -0.04590323194861412, 0.043929021805524826, 0.019186096265912056, 0.00472159031778574, -0.0074657560326159, -0.03229273483157158, -0.036188870668411255, -0.03702080249786377, 0.00011038520460715517, -0.0028469148091971874, 0.017122725024819374, -0.051199980080127716, -0.023999828845262527, 0.020572509616613388, 0.002230808837339282, -0.010464305058121681, 0.0053688036277890205, -0.02238149382174015, -0.04948560148477554, -0.027810556814074516, 0.024329308420419693, -0.025709643959999084, 0.05630131810903549, 0.012980986386537552, 0.018719220533967018, -0.026672188192605972, 0.03309771791100502, 0.0573243647813797, 0.023998312652111053, -0.06919598579406738, 0.04294074699282646, -0.021141603589057922, -0.018455062061548233, -0.05999990552663803, -0.04524657130241394, 0.052393313497304916, 0.024738945066928864, -0.07664096355438232, 0.029611961916089058, -0.03921501711010933, 0.022621693089604378, -0.02478153258562088, -0.012233387678861618, 0.05381126329302788, -0.035432301461696625, -0.014666094444692135, 0.02113136276602745, 0.022787142544984818, 0.0914614200592041, -0.055752407759428024, -0.004475850146263838, 0.0057655200362205505, 0.006646075751632452, -0.029254460707306862, -0.014496362768113613, 0.029728300869464874, -0.03625620901584625, -0.026970764622092247, -0.028146473690867424, 0.01727609522640705, 0.016802359372377396, -0.01435148622840643, 0.0004391638794913888, 0.025859935209155083, 0.011529148556292057, -0.0030135049019008875, -0.00017497745284345, 0.06498483568429947, 0.02418128214776516, -0.033532436937093735, -0.0025120216887444258, 0.018220558762550354, -0.044735074043273926, -0.03974812105298042, 0.007916421629488468, -0.03643736243247986, -0.026535073295235634, 0.026732536032795906, 0.027621138840913773, -0.020376238971948624, -0.0023222877644002438, 0.011590566486120224, -0.019032668322324753, 0.010596967302262783, -0.014366128481924534, -0.0056807296350598335, 0.003041262272745371, -0.0182208064943552, -0.06547661870718002, -0.010564695112407207, -0.008822478353977203, 0.006208591628819704, 0.04081755131483078, 0.03190270811319351, 0.055604107677936554, 0.009413124993443489, 0.021339379251003265, -0.011148510500788689, -0.01947719231247902, -0.02168174460530281, 0.0355200357735157, 0.016576968133449554, 0.03904862701892853, -0.009716780856251717, -0.011288207024335861, 0.0472228042781353, 0.04266633838415146, 0.03467228263616562, 0.011439437046647072, 0.02509508654475212, 0.0005641771713271737, -0.01239496748894453, -0.027262799441814423, -0.05922061204910278, 0.01747213304042816, -0.010388769209384918, 0.07959428429603577, -0.022308234125375748, -0.02320290356874466, 0.03197415918111801, 0.05421954393386841, 0.011490298435091972, -0.05525428056716919, 0.009019630961120129, -0.0452411063015461, 0.007389972452074289, 0.022929180413484573, -0.015714775770902634, 0.021476589143276215, 0.01284060999751091, 0.027675775811076164, -0.013459130190312862, 0.04254956170916557, -0.02967263199388981, -0.055817194283008575, -0.013959836214780807, -0.019385693594813347, -0.025781603530049324, 0.0373256616294384, -0.06985197216272354, -0.013142511248588562, 0.019615720957517624, -0.0580446682870388, 0.008305893279612064, -0.008227448910474777, 0.018092485144734383, -0.017371900379657745, 0.06399974972009659, 0.011185037903487682, 0.03346439078450203, -0.050831492990255356, -0.025701474398374557, 0.13310550153255463, 0.04143581911921501, 0.0027144374325871468, -0.017081163823604584, -0.011745842173695564, 0.006928163580596447, 0.03647106513381004, -0.012434870935976505, 0.02029716596007347, 0.023206807672977448, -0.0425974540412426, 0.03538323938846588, 0.030117319896817207, 0.00673667062073946, -0.021789219230413437, 0.052566368132829666, -0.033431775867938995, -0.004168149083852768, -0.01973538286983967, 0.03994371369481087, 0.004417396616190672, -0.026023631915450096, -0.045259974896907806, 0.004999840632081032, -0.02594786509871483, -0.03302455693483353, -0.022929973900318146, -0.013144114054739475, 0.014965048991143703, 0.007682408206164837, -0.005513245239853859, -0.022936047986149788, 0.033177271485328674, 0.0021395795047283173, -0.016374114900827408, -0.02627933770418167, 0.005542875733226538, -0.03169306740164757, 0.0349908322095871, 0.027455901727080345, 0.01146369893103838, -0.03994248807430267, 0.022222522646188736, 0.01731269434094429, -0.06454972177743912, -0.020726166665554047, -0.004107301123440266, 0.0390407033264637, -0.001729841809719801, -0.04348579794168472, -0.033455196768045425, 0.010004906915128231, 0.0007262699655257165, -0.011505702510476112, -0.0102090984582901, 0.004315852653235197, -0.009178562089800835, -0.017226625233888626, -0.05857960879802704, -0.028042173013091087, -0.0158504880964756, -0.03463910147547722, 0.007788247428834438, 0.003607094055041671, -0.012904801405966282, -0.03993188217282295, -0.004581836983561516, 0.04136611893773079, -0.05775858461856842, 0.012783816084265709, 0.03071722388267517, 0.0060961307026445866, -0.01653483510017395, 0.035625655204057693, -0.00942039955407381, 0.031352970749139786, 0.03094526194036007, -0.0006963859777897596, 0.0158455241471529, -0.05977392941713333, -0.01634787581861019, 0.07559053599834442, -0.05661780387163162, -0.04101547598838806, -0.04156579449772835, -0.016078446060419083, 0.005308498162776232, 0.0315038301050663, -0.008618081919848919, 0.01954546570777893, -0.017164254561066628, 0.02290048822760582, 0.03767795488238335, -0.05474722012877464, -0.006206281017512083, -0.0011778702028095722, -0.03664097189903259, -0.02964814007282257, -0.013580193743109703, 0.04401322826743126, 0.03802644461393356, 0.03476693853735924, -0.0007013035356067121, 0.030822759494185448, -0.012444447726011276, -0.017477773129940033, 0.010996446013450623, -0.008827785961329937, -0.0329369492828846, 0.012589514255523682, -0.014991940930485725, -0.025456443428993225, 0.014672684483230114, 0.0016146203270182014, -0.010977335274219513, -0.023185143247246742, 0.00655272975564003, 0.001252802205272019, -0.008836237713694572, -0.019715406000614166, 0.03632264584302902, -0.055015262216329575, 0.015517610125243664, -0.028341494500637054, -0.0027251013088971376, 0.0220769252628088, 0.0002915200893767178, -0.03234259411692619, 0.003307639854028821, 0.03426334634423256, 0.014938326552510262, 0.04549846425652504, -0.0037119814660400152, 0.0005862872349098325, -0.037150684744119644, 0.014236154034733772, 0.012351736426353455, 0.028418496251106262, 0.006198702845722437, -0.03769566863775253, 0.01699698716402054, 0.004317732062190771, -0.014767864719033241, 0.02385004796087742, 0.032769810408353806, 0.016602875664830208, -0.02164863422513008, 0.026981620118021965, -0.008144973777234554, 0.0551387183368206, 0.0007596221985295415, -0.02162451483309269, 0.017776958644390106, -0.004291308578103781, 0.034308336675167084, 0.0007251079077832401, -0.014042439870536327, 0.011460576206445694, 0.00854600127786398, 0.03955438360571861, 0.017389053478837013, -0.016371045261621475, 0.05181649327278137, -0.015446461737155914, -0.03412444517016411, 0.0053154099732637405, 0.009526273235678673, -0.008375030010938644, 0.00374595052562654, 0.026865236461162567, -0.01996964029967785, 0.037148039788007736, -0.015076703391969204, 0.005913453176617622, -0.039435796439647675, -0.00983340758830309, -0.002734471345320344, -0.01602526195347309, 0.045671042054891586, -0.006296095438301563, 0.017289888113737106, 0.010081600397825241, -0.02794698067009449, 0.0355219841003418, -0.003954852465540171, -0.027802761644124985, -0.010404274798929691, -0.05424755811691284, 0.000052891020459355786, 0.04323302581906319, 0.022648412734270096, 0.04381994903087616, 0.02522696927189827, 0.03470394015312195, -0.009693147614598274, 0.014330458827316761, -0.01502213068306446, 0.003911938518285751, -0.006525825709104538, -0.03590897470712662, 0.04836791381239891, -0.024555157870054245, -0.012170965783298016, 0.027414826676249504, -0.03487306833267212, -0.0034737768582999706, -0.060211583971977234, 0.03244659677147865, 0.03714391589164734, 0.020754408091306686, 0.04888064041733742, 0.021407829597592354, -0.00667736679315567, -0.05246306210756302, 0.025846553966403008, 0.02895553968846798, 0.0008449450833722949, 0.025699546560645103, -0.007404799107462168, -0.04534095153212547, 0.007218324579298496, 0.019772537052631378, -0.004751281347125769, 0.006696678698062897, 0.020477155223488808, 0.00265949172899127, -0.0016321531729772687, -0.003423640737310052, -0.00518399802967906, -0.044106028974056244, -0.003218819387257099, 0.020338762551546097, 0.03271621838212013, -0.05571379512548447, 0.00974010955542326, -0.013400902971625328, -0.015863589942455292, 0.054700203239917755, -0.018715739250183105, -0.005261532962322235, -0.05168131738901138, -0.02816128358244896, 0.016187455505132675, -0.00006287279393291101, -0.035505298525094986, -0.0034967076499015093, -0.049243517220020294, 0.015265285968780518, 0.006930772680789232, 0.0004695285751949996, 0.02507532387971878, -0.018507620319724083, -0.010436169803142548, -0.0951179713010788, 0.050999097526073456, 0.012016003020107746, -0.02475741133093834, 0.002796354005113244, -0.026182040572166443, -0.06013183295726776, 0.035370633006095886, 0.05087552219629288, 0.019270826131105423, 0.028965294361114502, -0.004518200643360615, -0.010127885267138481, -0.003330388106405735, -0.07176569849252701, 0.0462828204035759, -0.0009690607548691332, 0.010876165702939034, 0.024683084338903427, -0.03319273516535759, 0.01987818256020546, 0.0005362347001209855, 0.02279970422387123, -0.01521484088152647, 0.03598377853631973, 0.00647494662553072, -0.024570412933826447, 0.02152426354587078, -0.0011705384822562337, -0.04991410672664642, 0.07528212666511536, 0.0012438178528100252, 0.01670275256037712, 0.008563751354813576, -0.022553041577339172, -0.0774582177400589, 0.005092587787657976, 0.008043757639825344, -0.006874716375023127, -0.02044079452753067, -0.020581210032105446, 0.009070812724530697, -0.061037808656692505, 0.03308369964361191, 0.0588235929608345, -0.02636815421283245, -0.002593913348391652, 0.03846820816397667, 0.04552867263555527, -0.0009496213751845062, -0.02091582491993904, 0.03831351920962334, -0.008470323868095875, -0.02981749176979065, 0.028830653056502342, -0.009473197162151337, -0.0019040459301322699, -0.0378863625228405, 0.0031320953276008368, 0.01037454605102539, -0.022886281833052635, 0.012171714566648006, -0.011810602620244026, 0.016042537987232208, -0.08416781574487686, -0.022206531837582588, 0.047594618052244186, 0.007832522504031658, -0.0018598830793052912, 0.021600350737571716, 0.00011991748760920018, 0.07722938805818558, -0.02553909458220005, -0.00043301971163600683, 0.008445002138614655, 0.01302612666040659, -0.00838317908346653, 0.003009562846273184, 0.01945045031607151, -0.002287965500727296, -0.028410369530320168, 0.0024189117830246687, -0.027255414053797722, 0.012352980673313141, 0.014188410714268684, -0.017270730808377266, -0.03456796333193779, -0.008915092796087265, -0.01896432414650917, 0.0031640338711440563, 0.006274988874793053, -0.018569277599453926, 0.019755998626351357, 0.03887072205543518, -0.019322192296385765, -0.023617003113031387, -0.0172779131680727, -0.004106943961232901, 0.031019967049360275, 0.0220652986317873, -0.05714063346385956, 0.0020401915535330772, -0.001292518456466496, 0.019521556794643402, 0.007839719764888287, -0.013386392965912819 ]
<p>Statistical semi-novice question:</p> <p>Just following up <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/53432/can-ancova-disagree-with-multiple-regression">this question</a>, the fact that the three types of ANOVA exist with an unbalanced design, and that (presumably) you don't necessarily know a priori which one is suitable for your data (because, say, you do not know whether an interaction is present), my understanding is that a comparison between the types may be necessary.</p> <p>Isn't this equivalent to stepwise regression - and therefore problematic?</p> <p>I'm wondering whether a better approach for an unbalanced design would be to use a mixed model?</p>
37,019
[ -0.031079690903425217, 0.013304364867508411, -0.005526525434106588, -0.009875195100903511, 0.030425656586885452, 0.024360427632927895, -0.008388422429561615, -0.02957836352288723, 0.03363848477602005, -0.009079580195248127, 0.01991856098175049, 0.002433087443932891, 0.05164600536227226, 0.006397649180144072, 0.025523604825139046, 0.001131772412918508, -0.008764141239225864, -0.01859203912317753, 0.024020347744226456, -0.021125540137290955, -0.03282169625163078, -0.018090466037392616, 0.02226312831044197, -0.005155353341251612, -0.036694157868623734, 0.02074500545859337, 0.029449839144945145, -0.04502435773611069, -0.0019363532774150372, 0.024850474670529366, -0.020147163420915604, -0.020679092034697533, 0.012648326344788074, 0.047288063913583755, 0.0281843189150095, 0.0037744208239018917, -0.006830955855548382, -0.024963144212961197, 0.0008189540239982307, 0.05876225605607033, -0.013708156533539295, -0.01148832868784666, -0.019524933770298958, 0.025134461000561714, 0.006207332946360111, 0.022954273968935013, 0.009343798272311687, -0.010097958147525787, 0.02519453689455986, -0.08218353241682053, 0.05014727637171745, -0.028988098725676537, 0.03682350367307663, 0.07258065789937973, -0.005129070021212101, -0.005544910207390785, 0.06053566560149193, 0.044140759855508804, -0.01946210488677025, -0.06994536519050598, -0.000847040384542197, -0.014657530002295971, 0.01885087415575981, 0.008846676908433437, -0.052543461322784424, 0.01768695004284382, -0.00360598461702466, -0.022284911945462227, 0.05095086246728897, -0.025445932522416115, 0.01968383602797985, -0.026358172297477722, 0.031485479325056076, 0.002177596790716052, -0.010847794823348522, -0.03042319044470787, 0.020157141610980034, 0.023351753130555153, 0.08551966398954391, 0.030103575438261032, -0.0016304422169923782, 0.044273220002651215, 0.02429843693971634, 0.04588569700717926, 0.02869221195578575, -0.017741164192557335, 0.08312071114778519, -0.035125914961099625, 0.0040928698144853115, 0.01691671833395958, -0.011927804909646511, 0.003114033257588744, 0.05351738631725311, -0.00812034122645855, -0.04140885919332504, 0.031409550458192825, -0.008162620477378368, 0.04545387253165245, 0.02008369006216526, -0.036710310727357864, 0.001157569233328104, 0.005771077238023281, 0.0350620411336422, 0.019449155777692795, 0.00567755987867713, 0.01649266853928566, -0.019706035032868385, 0.04549800232052803, -0.0085894875228405, -0.030836008489131927, -0.04025401175022125, 0.03601515293121338, -0.023310227319598198, 0.023089490830898285, 0.02169007621705532, -0.016300121322274208, 0.0027310915756970644, -0.0098641412332654, 0.040741242468357086, 0.057466257363557816, 0.06032655015587807, -0.07409034669399261, 0.013936631381511688, -0.016588488593697548, -0.0478074848651886, -0.035747136920690536, -0.007299898657947779, -0.004922382067888975, -0.04489678889513016, 0.07345864921808243, -0.0078055476769804955, -0.0035735247656702995, 0.017937535420060158, -0.013941871002316475, 0.026168907061219215, 0.028538957238197327, -0.08959536999464035, -0.07996202260255814, 0.0265972837805748, -0.0017935301875695586, 0.005837112665176392, -0.05991015210747719, -0.006428837776184082, 0.0442819744348526, 0.07032880187034607, -0.0008966790046542883, 0.01671718806028366, 0.018910512328147888, 0.05451996996998787, 0.017910033464431763, 0.009379303082823753, -0.00033005725708790123, -0.028025146573781967, -0.021853258833289146, -0.00995469931513071, -0.09456698596477509, 0.04039797931909561, -0.03577617555856705, 0.0010115407640114427, 0.013922173529863358, 0.005127778742462397, 0.0022896097507327795, -0.0036750617437064648, 0.021867530420422554, 0.014562282711267471, 0.01182759553194046, 0.07482805848121643, -0.024604372680187225, 0.056359678506851196, 0.010022614151239395, -0.017293399199843407, 0.03260310739278793, -0.001988144824281335, 0.03677467629313469, 0.058052074164152145, 0.0017069163732230663, -0.0071814656257629395, -0.023974837735295296, 0.022153012454509735, 0.02671535685658455, -0.05919647961854935, -0.034033507108688354, -0.026554105803370476, 0.009597038850188255, 0.011098046787083149, 0.05494290217757225, 0.009565537795424461, 0.03200380504131317, 0.04881226271390915, -0.033650875091552734, -0.04453713446855545, -0.06421369314193726, 0.008501504547894001, 0.017664290964603424, -0.03977706655859947, 0.04317589849233627, -0.012173456139862537, -0.015162410214543343, -0.04002733901143074, -0.04360629618167877, -0.011512845754623413, -0.008106379769742489, 0.05104943737387657, -0.04955015331506729, 0.036188311874866486, 0.031194308772683144, 0.052136220037937164, -0.03462635725736618, 0.05149461701512337, -0.034007295966148376, -0.044015172868967056, -0.0049492488615214825, -0.027200672775506973, 0.015197577886283398, -0.0074628922156989574, -0.01921101287007332, 0.004240244626998901, -0.0022560791112482548, -0.030477240681648254, 0.049590978771448135, -0.06644988059997559, 0.05344169959425926, 0.07500818371772766, -0.005318817216902971, 0.012426404282450676, 0.05770685896277428, 0.020836563780903816, 0.01566511020064354, -0.003175614634528756, 0.006944929249584675, -0.025334589183330536, -0.011294238269329071, 0.04617825895547867, -0.009700704365968704, -0.04783114790916443, 0.031365927308797836, 0.033035047352313995, 0.023313138633966446, 0.01034468226134777, 0.004859609063714743, 0.0119697917252779, -0.037328124046325684, 0.010696835815906525, 0.04174124822020531, 0.014066542498767376, 0.006587620824575424, 0.01501335110515356, -0.017300382256507874, 0.03760310634970665, 0.02789309248328209, 0.0040382263250648975, 0.04558520391583443, 0.01717836782336235, 0.043464723974466324, -0.0153808007016778, 0.002811858430504799, 0.029829418286681175, -0.011043205857276917, 0.040738124400377274, 0.013310149312019348, 0.001978751039132476, -0.026077209040522575, 0.01944670081138611, 0.007974437437951565, 0.0234565157443285, 0.008840009570121765, -0.034121327102184296, 0.003172904020175338, 0.02050948143005371, -0.013937384821474552, 0.011073268949985504, -0.03246307000517845, -0.017841001972556114, -0.032463010400533676, -0.0040914746932685375, 0.0029891410376876593, -0.03172885254025459, 0.04564038664102554, -0.04515057057142258, -0.002030570525676012, -0.006349825765937567, -0.02316746674478054, 0.033675990998744965, 0.010927806608378887, -0.05714375898241997, 0.017798524349927902, -0.05939723178744316, -0.0054153199307620525, 0.020783355459570885, 0.007490728981792927, -0.0036393809132277966, 0.02904086746275425, -0.01105880830436945, -0.0442066416144371, -0.0650998055934906, 0.003362797200679779, 0.012023086659610271, 0.028665339574217796, -0.04784660413861275, 0.007613020017743111, -0.024153171107172966, -0.03175322338938713, 0.013719737529754639, -0.014650792814791203, -0.014820357784628868, 0.0075590782798826694, 0.012973264791071415, 0.014139821752905846, 0.016955886036157608, 0.014509671367704868, 0.031121883541345596, -0.027467703446745872, -0.0025790631771087646, -0.045626040548086166, -0.05938886106014252, 0.01510647777467966, 0.0011974041117355227, 0.023344682529568672, 0.0010942727094516158, -0.019373701885342598, 0.06563206762075424, 0.026124682277441025, -0.05707782879471779, -0.04059214890003204, -0.025425249710679054, -0.045790355652570724, -0.03237001970410347, 0.013880343176424503, -0.004068050999194384, -0.014691434800624847, 0.03071298822760582, -0.028987804427742958, 0.0008003956754691899, 0.045295849442481995, 0.03270180895924568, -0.01286389771848917, 0.01903560757637024, 0.020082145929336548, 0.0034603371750563383, 0.003021531505510211, 0.0002026603469857946, -0.006509655155241489, -0.012286823242902756, -0.0034776257816702127, 0.03161164000630379, -0.0028987510595470667, -0.03987677022814751, 0.04169773310422897, -0.03467952832579613, 0.012959450483322144, -0.04198003187775612, 0.016710534691810608, 0.020565517246723175, -0.0039763497188687325, -0.006674353964626789, 0.0298044141381979, 0.021024061366915703, -0.028942646458745003, 0.006732721347361803, 0.03557463362812996, 0.0348210334777832, -0.0173888448625803, 0.0002485434233676642, -0.004495202098041773, -0.02021811529994011, 0.004253076855093241, -0.004035319201648235, 0.002106352709233761, 0.03809771686792374, 0.016330381855368614, 0.024131467565894127, 0.026623765006661415, -0.08102576434612274, 0.031141186133027077, -0.05200563743710518, 0.012571842409670353, -0.06718357652425766, 0.00327611924149096, -0.0164960827678442, 0.0016514287563040853, -0.0018890821374952793, -0.04974553361535072, -0.028937928378582, -0.01595519855618477, -0.04975895956158638, 0.042235732078552246, -0.013238347135484219, 0.02647389844059944, -0.0065760831348598, -0.01673649623990059, -0.010549169965088367, -0.038233108818531036, 0.011527983471751213, -0.016715597361326218, 0.023393431678414345, 0.011502984911203384, 0.011419839225709438, -0.051183294504880905, -0.012432308867573738, -0.031193185597658157, 0.004395745694637299, -0.0039696828462183475, -0.03242819756269455, 0.02242528647184372, 0.0032865917310118675, 0.007833651266992092, -0.0255148783326149, -0.01665208302438259, 0.005234399810433388, 0.007235667202621698, 0.029993046075105667, 0.028346244245767593, 0.03454390540719032, -0.04880732670426369, 0.03752540051937103, 0.018522033467888832, 0.04366108030080795, 0.01034761592745781, -0.01965978741645813, -0.0253116674721241, -0.029488293454051018, -0.05233914032578468, 0.02337801828980446, 0.01632927730679512, 0.024286245927214622, 0.020324911922216415, 0.020493198186159134, 0.005726961884647608, -0.06672661751508713, 0.04197150096297264, 0.05509066581726074, 0.010457147844135761, 0.0021981489844620228, -0.023639166727662086, 0.011880770325660706, -0.02689177542924881, -0.017150942236185074, 0.055373113602399826, 0.026309886947274208, 0.02131698653101921, 0.0035642446018755436, 0.04374251514673233, -0.014565670862793922, -0.0290793739259243, 0.024162352085113525, 0.025890808552503586, 0.03754590079188347, 0.00854578148573637, -0.0434345081448555, 0.020961791276931763, 0.020954972133040428, 0.03755990415811539, 0.0033774094190448523, 0.006449598353356123, -0.10668250173330307, 0.009666993282735348, 0.06417571753263474, 0.04680464044213295, -0.03145049139857292, 0.014772105030715466, 0.012271508574485779, -0.005346979014575481, -0.01777874492108822, -0.00825018621981144, 0.02812509424984455, -0.03633208945393562, 0.01474506501108408, -0.04184144735336304, -0.03795359283685684, -0.03578883036971092, 0.02066480927169323, -0.0057172514498233795, -0.0003655785694718361, 0.001263084588572383, -0.017029080539941788, -0.03128780052065849, -0.006072275340557098, 0.0029951068572700024, 0.017174996435642242, -0.0371008962392807, -0.0030489161144942045, 0.041854020208120346, 0.04425530880689621, -0.010651365853846073, -0.030759569257497787, 0.025796901434659958, -0.015304592438042164, -0.045117322355508804, 0.03406664356589317, -0.02492702007293701, -0.0394878089427948, 0.027637546882033348, 0.02363002672791481, -0.022467726841568947, 0.01387134101241827, -0.011971182189881802, 0.05367879569530487, 0.02926119603216648, 0.018213292583823204, 0.07719270139932632, 0.017288878560066223, 0.0408269502222538, -0.01218484342098236, -0.0032551572658121586, 0.026194659993052483, -0.028548963367938995, -0.04063158109784126, -0.07678762823343277, -0.03473198413848877, 0.003243701532483101, 0.059136178344488144, 0.032491691410541534, 0.03315345570445061, 0.0038882875815033913, -0.028172563761472702, 0.010290754958987236, -0.009903986006975174, 0.000562091707251966, -0.048705004155635834, 0.011699235066771507, -0.013754107058048248, -0.01643102802336216, -0.014838364906609058, 0.006208302918821573, -0.018837740644812584, 0.018677063286304474, 0.025495514273643494, -0.05081745237112045, 0.037791717797517776, -0.027413083240389824, -0.0329505130648613, -0.00808982364833355, -0.023607926443219185, 0.043462492525577545, 0.008113193325698376, 0.040031660348176956, -0.020347710698843002, -0.06217624992132187, -0.01743602380156517, 0.035473693162202835, 0.0036328528076410294, 0.024588948115706444, -0.041659947484731674, 0.06144353002309799, -0.008991161361336708, -0.007336617447435856, -0.052961647510528564, -0.02265954203903675, 0.0035315072163939476, 0.013096521608531475, 0.016415797173976898, 0.01752159185707569, 0.0003763024287763983, -0.028815271332859993, -0.0224686861038208, -0.015119627118110657, 0.052788179367780685, -0.037180136889219284, -0.01734589971601963, -0.0015722350217401981, 0.005312690045684576, 0.0527447834610939, -0.028844216838479042, 0.007380356080830097, 0.023171432316303253, -0.01793893799185753, -0.026752393692731857, 0.001994140911847353, 0.0540693923830986, -0.030910786241292953, 0.028474420309066772, -0.022721972316503525, -0.006031322292983532, 0.07112676650285721, -0.015462894923985004, 0.007257819641381502, 0.0356961153447628, -0.00489030359312892, 0.012101092375814915, -0.029640108346939087, 0.014263646677136421, 0.003147078910842538, -0.00011775999882956967, -0.02041512168943882, 0.031194474548101425, 0.0030609651003032923, 0.015876445919275284, 0.06488807499408722, -0.0049336934462189674, -0.04797349125146866, 0.0018906856421381235, 0.0790814682841301, 0.0011159467976540327, 0.009891674853861332, 0.013142736628651619, -0.021349363029003143, 0.004564643371850252, -0.016185443848371506, 0.02302985079586506, 0.021946975961327553, 0.044320136308670044, -0.029059024527668953, -0.04105333238840103, -0.028413401916623116, 0.018844695761799812, 0.07992193847894669, -0.01739444024860859, 0.03083701990544796, 0.07550767809152603, -0.014005577191710472, -0.03876227140426636, -0.028272168710827827, -0.03843819350004196, -0.005580282770097256, 0.02140429988503456, 0.04382621496915817, -0.01574174501001835, 0.010225371457636356, -0.004680640529841185, 0.009902647696435452, 0.01422598771750927, 0.043461382389068604, 0.03254175931215286, 0.04490154981613159, 0.043194856494665146, 0.031169967725872993, -0.03417427837848663, 0.04293554648756981, -0.06083884835243225, 0.023813076317310333, -0.056952789425849915, -0.02707934007048607, 0.03841434419155121, 0.05202145501971245, 0.04162522405385971, -0.08451339602470398, -0.017293483018875122, -0.062166016548871994, 0.024221060797572136, -0.01945554092526436, -0.007614164613187313, 0.04304308816790581, 0.022305423393845558, 0.03311210870742798, -0.028429502621293068, 0.005181406624615192, -0.03216489031910896, -0.09963502734899521, -0.03853393346071243, -0.026299837976694107, 0.007119934540241957, 0.017185073345899582, -0.004453263245522976, -0.07030817866325378, 0.0058242445811629295, -0.0258887130767107, 0.0053866864182055, -0.0469193309545517, 0.033229220658540726, -0.015879057347774506, 0.028622837737202644, -0.01000268291682005, 0.013413837179541588, 0.03166396543383598, 0.021057767793536186, 0.09651418775320053, 0.033573031425476074, 0.044391244649887085, -0.07992193847894669, 0.03833194449543953, -0.010855105705559254, 0.010516306385397911, 0.01143445074558258, 0.018754832446575165, 0.01342164445668459, -0.004844805225729942, 0.03452492505311966, 0.04402393102645874, 0.01283443532884121, -0.005098109599202871, 0.04595749452710152, -0.02522350288927555, -0.014898153021931648, 0.010031518526375294, 0.0147139523178339, 0.007984975352883339, -0.01147717796266079, 0.0035860813222825527, 0.027091743424534798, 0.0022505810484290123, 0.005673671141266823, 0.020897388458251953, -0.03162940591573715, 0.0036700863856822252, 0.02768395096063614, 0.007786656264215708, 0.027432268485426903, -0.009202036075294018, 0.004427330102771521, -0.039526455104351044, -0.010084643959999084, 0.039039332419633865, -0.054486021399497986, 0.008337528444826603, 0.048871591687202454, -0.012888195924460888, -0.023798033595085144, 0.017187586054205894, -0.0008175369584932923, -0.047295860946178436, 0.00671493960544467, 0.004912103526294231, 0.029269712045788765, 0.015574177727103233, -0.029352612793445587, -0.018642917275428772, -0.023354776203632355, -0.02495083212852478, -0.03989719599485397, -0.04793397709727287, 0.0014982634456828237, 0.04956863075494766, -0.035489924252033234, -0.029295075684785843, -0.054431747645139694, -0.0075414725579321384, -0.005290178116410971, 0.02749607153236866, 0.020348230376839638, -0.05191174894571304, -0.03855913504958153, -0.01594953052699566, 0.03213490918278694, 0.04538405314087868, 0.01742779091000557, -0.0011331485584378242, -0.022964200004935265, -0.018883097916841507, 0.013126816600561142, 0.0041649602353572845, 0.027828190475702286, 0.030225737020373344, -0.00484057841822505, -0.0066803982481360435, -0.018072426319122314, -0.06099213287234306, -0.005356276407837868, -0.04445023089647293, 0.0005474538775160909, -0.03806387633085251, -0.004247867036610842, 0.0529143251478672, 0.028203416615724564, 0.012846536003053188, 0.02985251322388649, 0.017263438552618027, 0.04901932179927826, 0.011591271497309208, -0.06754577159881592, -0.008225982077419758, 0.00543204927816987, -0.03837000951170921, -0.0077022891491651535, -0.005783173255622387, 0.0414033941924572, 0.02123725600540638, 0.038870640099048615, -0.0314423069357872, 0.027365457266569138, -0.01690421998500824, 0.01718856766819954, 0.017808852717280388, -0.07021419703960419, -0.017183464020490646, 0.0003442081215325743, 0.004463589284569025, -0.03234777972102165, -0.033748142421245575, -0.03951234742999077, -0.04112088680267334, 0.026056770235300064, 0.015510598197579384, 0.0029032528400421143, 0.012541324831545353, -0.017951419577002525, 0.020335424691438675, -0.03705509006977081, -0.022048702463507652, -0.054369982331991196, -0.00824110396206379, 0.006093277595937252, -0.021557888016104698, 0.016623225063085556, 0.0012676973128691316, -0.01723930798470974, 0.0071740406565368176, 0.029826223850250244, -0.0037997972685843706, 0.03383822366595268, 0.004281863570213318, -0.0025366805493831635, 0.0029549880418926477, 0.05222945660352707, -0.009697751142084599, -0.01570003479719162, -0.0020815907046198845, -0.03197120130062103, -0.02807801216840744, -0.002228948287665844, 0.026118192821741104, 0.008903313428163528, 0.005563667044043541, -0.004935106262564659, -0.03213687241077423, 0.04247411713004112, -0.017417440190911293, -0.02800333872437477, -0.021036431193351746, -0.03253830224275589, -0.009475256316363811, -0.03924698382616043, -0.00916516687721014, 0.031563982367515564, -0.0075036692433059216, 0.06617923080921173, 0.06700409203767776, 0.0387280099093914, -0.029505113139748573, -0.006873042322695255, 0.018140552565455437, 0.02216866984963417, -0.004165077582001686, -0.006460276432335377, 0.01878949999809265, 0.028198296204209328, -0.0559195838868618, 0.028068114072084427, 0.007608862593770027, -0.00005367928315536119, -0.0729658380150795, -0.03576763719320297, 0.011310053989291191, 0.032952625304460526, 0.01958935707807541, -0.07618679851293564, -0.014537910930812359, 0.06014354154467583, -0.062023039907217026, -0.025238212198019028, 0.008906837552785873, -0.042650263756513596, -0.020368270576000214, 0.00250259623862803, -0.029448943212628365, -0.030212873592972755, -0.03495614230632782, 0.029778998345136642, 0.012964134104549885, 0.0239549670368433, -0.003355804132297635, -0.02011256292462349, -0.002214353531599045, 0.00034129558480344713, 0.006778096314519644, -0.08411826938390732, 0.037370357662439346, -0.04515336453914642, -0.05691505968570709, 0.05768425762653351, 0.006137664429843426, 0.033205144107341766, 0.013117915019392967, 0.04531196877360344, 0.01317061111330986, 0.006451136898249388, 0.02764601819217205, 0.04025274142622948, 0.004824738018214703, 0.008052212186157703, 0.013596706092357635, 0.058006297796964645, 0.0005857098731212318, 0.039086565375328064, 0.009609508328139782, 0.02560805156826973, -0.022025443613529205, 0.012153048068284988, -0.025691548362374306, -0.025042960420250893, -0.027999574318528175, -0.014586064964532852, 0.019943781197071075, -0.009590952657163143, -0.015897439792752266, -0.062436867505311966, 0.003164414782077074, 0.025437427684664726, 0.014168395660817623, -0.036004602909088135, 0.0014748862013220787, -0.05022509768605232, -0.02606857940554619, 0.026316894218325615, -0.0186435729265213, -0.011483125388622284, -0.0499698668718338, 0.013240794651210308, 0.030792798846960068, -0.04006475210189819, -0.019285427406430244, -0.015654969960451126, -0.01731962151825428, 0.039510514587163925, -0.008191696368157864, -0.02608123980462551, -0.0013280526036396623, -0.03261490538716316, -0.006760298740118742, -0.08126988261938095, 0.07407234609127045, 0.033759068697690964, -0.019853241741657257, -0.03753776475787163, -0.006198596674948931, -0.0092927860096097, 0.02014489658176899, 0.0546267032623291, 0.003434455255046487, 0.008486472070217133, -0.0016026166267693043, 0.025936411693692207, -0.005344869568943977, -0.02970164455473423, 0.030154841020703316, -0.00471443310379982, -0.011094855144619942, 0.00901454221457243, -0.016718007624149323, -0.007968875579535961, -0.00293313548900187, 0.0196080319583416, -0.026200871914625168, 0.022478094324469566, 0.0114986477419734, 0.001543823629617691, 0.019857581704854965, -0.004389969632029533, -0.020001651719212532, 0.032904788851737976, -0.006689461879432201, 0.010172232985496521, 0.03161128610372543, 0.027963614091277122, -0.045227646827697754, 0.030077042058110237, -0.024963809177279472, 0.01493696216493845, -0.01625896990299225, -0.03415387123823166, -0.016369013115763664, -0.06684619933366776, 0.0008632929529994726, 0.021043051034212112, -0.0401124432682991, 0.02808094397187233, 0.018038220703601837, 0.03163114935159683, 0.05258938670158386, -0.01507893018424511, 0.0221951212733984, 0.026712579652667046, -0.004350332077592611, 0.02233879268169403, 0.03380386158823967, 0.017027711495757103, 0.007803871762007475, -0.034788113087415695, 0.02883957326412201, -0.029821664094924927, 0.02168530784547329, -0.020756088197231293, 0.011338137090206146, -0.009437423199415207, -0.009674588218331337, -0.0024431422352790833, 0.005355745553970337, 0.02449454739689827, 0.022194184362888336, 0.003627987578511238, 0.06872285157442093, -0.0446636788547039, 0.03028692491352558, -0.031351033598184586, 0.012627842836081982, -0.005409651901572943, -0.03470144420862198, 0.01892821490764618, -0.006369461305439472, 0.017485221847891808, 0.0061736642383039, -0.008563822135329247, -0.00942898541688919, 0.05859297141432762, 0.0013351589441299438, 0.043492380529642105, -0.029851626604795456, -0.020488537847995758, -0.0043598348274827, -0.04479600861668587, -0.010027521289885044, -0.04559433087706566, 0.02949693612754345, 0.023293986916542053, 0.03557847812771797, -0.03448837623000145, -0.055539265275001526, 0.0040377178229391575, 0.03498903289437294, -0.06331875920295715, -0.038656339049339294, -0.019174903631210327, 0.016949212178587914, 0.005389177706092596, -0.024250028654932976 ]
<p>I devised a distance function similar to this form</p> <p>$d(x,y) = \sum_{i = 1}^{n-1} b(x_i, y_i,x_{i+1}, y_{i+1}) $ </p> <p>with</p> <p>$b(x_i, y_i,x_{i+1}, y_{i+1}) = 0 \mbox{ if } x_i \leq 0 \vee y_i \leq 0 \vee x_{i+1} \leq 0 \vee y_{i+1} \leq 0$<br> $b(x_i, y_i,x_{i+1}, y_{i+1}) = \alpha \cdot \frac{x_{i+1}}{y_{i+1}} + (x_i - y_i)^2 \mbox{ else } $<br> where $\alpha$ is a real number > 0.</p> <p>And now I want to prove (or disprove) that $e^{-d(x,y)}$ is a kernel which I for example could use in SVMs. </p> <p>I have read about Mercer's condition, positive semi definiteness and about constructing kernels from existing kernels, but I can't transfer it to this kind of function. Especially, how do I deal with the if-cases in my definition of b?</p> <p>Any help would be greatly appreciated :)</p>
74,254
[ -0.022926079109311104, 0.0036480925045907497, 0.031777042895555496, -0.027785737067461014, -0.005988479591906071, 0.003849644912406802, -0.0054736933670938015, -0.0279012992978096, 0.037038546055555344, -0.03426038473844528, 0.01319783367216587, 0.03225317224860191, 0.06669911742210388, 0.0327562615275383, 0.02756861411035061, 0.0038333211559802294, -0.03609322011470795, 0.009875440038740635, -0.03825831413269043, -0.015934087336063385, 0.007111404091119766, 0.0415666438639164, 0.03367896005511284, -0.008192441426217556, -0.010413968935608864, 0.02687578834593296, -0.016856776550412178, -0.033440086990594864, 0.013885997235774994, 0.06737784296274185, -0.01590711995959282, -0.01568562537431717, 0.011397055350244045, 0.054499272257089615, 0.0029787092935293913, 0.008051369339227676, -0.055905118584632874, -0.01222813781350851, -0.009933741763234138, 0.00416489876806736, -0.029217200353741646, -0.05621171370148659, -0.0011447177967056632, 0.09915377199649811, 0.0011602503946051002, -0.002932012313976884, 0.05881373956799507, -0.045623529702425, 0.008278417401015759, -0.043755773454904556, 0.09419170767068863, -0.029845034703612328, 0.028644373640418053, 0.026304757222533226, -0.004872091114521027, -0.027340443804860115, 0.021087322384119034, 0.05866158753633499, 0.013708552345633507, -0.04135153815150261, -0.01896466128528118, 0.001405835268087685, 0.03196863457560539, -0.010348842479288578, -0.030433736741542816, 0.04945359006524086, 0.02103455178439617, -0.01784500479698181, -0.010503483936190605, -0.050622180104255676, 0.0032283600885421038, 0.015394553542137146, 0.025618886575102806, -0.030743800103664398, 0.008304709568619728, -0.0238184854388237, 0.03429466485977173, 0.016836661845445633, 0.04050348699092865, 0.03130268305540085, -0.02018134295940399, 0.020324543118476868, 0.03965357318520546, 0.02024550549685955, 0.03093278780579567, 0.011381358839571476, 0.06545601785182953, -0.013611195608973503, 0.03644194453954697, 0.03162192925810814, -0.0027272109873592854, 0.011766334995627403, 0.03478805720806122, -0.027813630178570747, -0.051470350474119186, 0.03769296780228615, -0.007219236809760332, -0.0012928410433232784, 0.03371730446815491, -0.06172872334718704, -0.012808650732040405, -0.04503615200519562, 0.023942209780216217, 0.05579947307705879, -0.013320214115083218, -0.00036813467158935964, -0.041311874985694885, 0.032743483781814575, -0.011407983489334583, -0.002491045044735074, -0.039755091071128845, 0.029650399461388588, -0.0031130018178373575, 0.024982281029224396, 0.04461389780044556, -0.018105344846844673, -0.016582725569605827, -0.0039144218899309635, -0.011238085106015205, 0.0750117227435112, 0.0428822822868824, -0.02260521799325943, 0.02798091247677803, -0.045416247099637985, -0.046026963740587234, 0.0135791702196002, 0.03147377446293831, -0.023510964587330818, -0.039266884326934814, 0.055077921599149704, 0.0037888779770582914, -0.03032231144607067, 0.028713807463645935, -0.012919926084578037, 0.03516116365790367, 0.03822295367717743, -0.05826341360807419, -0.05894618481397629, 0.06535782665014267, -0.007063416764140129, 0.034830912947654724, -0.059780240058898926, -0.007681115996092558, 0.03646431490778923, 0.04154880717396736, -0.011988711543381214, 0.02844257280230522, 0.008931701071560383, 0.05329824239015579, -0.006457245908677578, -0.027717281132936478, -0.03755203261971474, -0.0044897785410285, -0.005460540298372507, -0.02904447168111801, -0.054810382425785065, 0.029984204098582268, 0.021358326077461243, -0.04124477505683899, -0.004209319595247507, 0.07855741679668427, 0.003727757139131427, -0.043311554938554764, -0.009167991578578949, 0.0011346550891175866, -0.018779737874865532, 0.04847196489572525, 0.06291776895523071, 0.02132187783718109, 0.007225526962429285, -0.008720609359443188, 0.03244875743985176, 0.030276671051979065, 0.03790418058633804, 0.05605931952595711, -0.03487308323383331, -0.03566261753439903, -0.017509611323475838, 0.030939461663365364, 0.040260832756757736, -0.046873703598976135, -0.03313831612467766, -0.04907732456922531, 0.003987549338489771, -0.008839219808578491, 0.06811973452568054, -0.005857471376657486, 0.005264273378998041, 0.04277241230010986, -0.006043397355824709, -0.03465519845485687, -0.05575700104236603, -0.0014846852282062173, 0.027447767555713654, -0.01059722900390625, 0.034339383244514465, 0.007616931106895208, 0.015476362779736519, -0.03205182030797005, 0.012345582246780396, -0.01157381571829319, -0.020251480862498283, 0.05900469049811363, -0.036355845630168915, -0.014964486472308636, 0.01847054250538349, 0.04911462962627411, -0.0048729185946285725, 0.04481276869773865, -0.046246521174907684, -0.02150537073612213, -0.029900940135121346, -0.012273397296667099, 0.02826358936727047, -0.015688426792621613, 0.0005723213544115424, 0.017736107110977173, -0.018094943836331367, -0.004919196479022503, -0.007553099188953638, -0.08744920045137405, 0.02181515470147133, 0.06695780158042908, 0.020344659686088562, 0.017711929976940155, -0.005601984448730946, 0.06006837636232376, 0.03714005649089813, -0.03803299367427826, -0.00947338342666626, -0.03148527070879936, 0.002660018391907215, 0.014212008565664291, 0.041911009699106216, -0.03893186151981354, 0.02450789138674736, 0.01900813728570938, 0.034341633319854736, 0.0020706409122794867, -0.021729974076151848, -0.02099512331187725, -0.014399618841707706, 0.022275516763329506, 0.006063931621611118, 0.00375468865968287, 0.01504215132445097, -0.02005401812493801, -0.0014543253928422928, 0.03957556188106537, -0.007817166857421398, -0.008408747613430023, 0.046889930963516235, 0.007506375201046467, -0.00707413861528039, 0.0035530850291252136, -0.0019436500733718276, 0.05027513578534126, -0.015255081467330456, -0.03836933523416519, 0.021505380049347878, -0.018601050600409508, 0.007565828040242195, -0.004619572311639786, -0.012236738577485085, 0.03048017807304859, 0.04555399715900421, -0.012537759728729725, -0.012773155234754086, 0.029464466497302055, -0.04942820593714714, 0.02718023769557476, -0.004923465196043253, -0.0576806478202343, -0.01991656795144081, 0.010608706623315811, 0.04362558200955391, 0.03323473781347275, 0.008046112023293972, -0.02935432828962803, -0.006063181906938553, -0.0043726530857384205, -0.0384090282022953, 0.04123782739043236, 0.0038946024142205715, -0.04554544761776924, 0.0197610966861248, -0.031911496073007584, 0.006425081752240658, 0.06648357212543488, -0.02093331888318062, -0.017512785270810127, 0.012005251832306385, 0.005322483368217945, -0.019191579893231392, -0.023876288905739784, -0.0695100650191307, 0.011267201043665409, -0.0433606393635273, -0.045694608241319656, 0.037178825587034225, -0.011264237575232983, -0.03030211664736271, 0.029265612363815308, -0.042784273624420166, -0.014926857315003872, -0.027820279821753502, -0.02709220163524151, 0.0112752141430974, 0.0046256002970039845, 0.03012651391327381, 0.028990525752305984, -0.021207286044955254, 0.010129180736839771, -0.09278149157762527, -0.07873706519603729, 0.037992529571056366, 0.021564632654190063, 0.03077131137251854, 0.01066102646291256, -0.017672695219516754, 0.09396856278181076, 0.07137003540992737, -0.021102257072925568, -0.04520338773727417, -0.008382719941437244, -0.03741331398487091, -0.003402275498956442, 0.010401337407529354, 0.012657011859118938, -0.002833290258422494, 0.025986425578594208, -0.017570598050951958, 0.030438300222158432, 0.05123695731163025, -0.0804176852107048, -0.04066004604101181, 0.044024065136909485, -0.030744582414627075, -0.004743512719869614, 0.025956153869628906, 0.04094552993774414, -0.022315729409456253, 0.02265622466802597, 0.024430742487311363, -0.00025617098435759544, -0.008972952142357826, -0.0364968404173851, 0.0018758681835606694, -0.004490982741117477, 0.0137854078784585, -0.03441363573074341, 0.03286759927868843, 0.01939430832862854, -0.04414888843894005, -0.032504528760910034, 0.0004892016877420247, 0.0449240580201149, -0.0381278358399868, 0.00394246494397521, 0.04462868720293045, 0.030453480780124664, -0.0077888816595077515, -0.007068409584462643, -0.028558382764458656, -0.030512196943163872, 0.03114684484899044, -0.0062918453477323055, -0.018262121826410294, 0.02606000192463398, 0.018963880836963654, -0.00989760085940361, -0.02167249657213688, -0.025487391278147697, 0.000348916306393221, -0.04774947836995125, -0.01671288162469864, -0.023217929527163506, 0.05806303769350052, 0.023447303101420403, 0.026412276551127434, 0.027627112343907356, -0.029435746371746063, 0.02697147987782955, 0.0037130184937268496, -0.05372076854109764, -0.011824761517345905, -0.006441382225602865, -0.0064395722001791, -0.006727687083184719, -0.0009883923921734095, 0.041333045810461044, -0.0448802150785923, 0.01020850706845522, 0.016550205647945404, 0.03912412002682686, -0.055895499885082245, -0.03211722895503044, -0.03304332122206688, -0.03360610455274582, -0.00895078293979168, 0.014979195781052113, -0.008076145313680172, -0.025155657902359962, 0.008288196288049221, 0.03973638266324997, -0.02463568188250065, -0.002276105573400855, -0.029840506613254547, -0.015460110269486904, 0.03498906269669533, 0.0013939411146566272, 0.005278477445244789, 0.045147523283958435, -0.020488180220127106, 0.014314894564449787, -0.029126470908522606, 0.02973059192299843, 0.04948792979121208, -0.02952989563345909, -0.00446887593716383, -0.015030469745397568, -0.0366104431450367, -0.008679002523422241, 0.043289780616760254, 0.006353605072945356, 0.0204551350325346, 0.02755211479961872, 0.030466420575976372, -0.06101187318563461, 0.010716033168137074, 0.07069031894207001, 0.021944856271147728, -0.015953103080391884, -0.060100242495536804, -0.016507240012288094, -0.0087359007447958, 0.007653761655092239, 0.008966037072241306, -0.008624749258160591, -0.02876574732363224, -0.01450373325496912, 0.04847832769155502, -0.0017708840314298868, 0.0001816779258660972, -0.019752372056245804, 0.04439295455813408, 0.033418912440538406, -0.012593983672559261, -0.023493751883506775, 0.013443747535347939, 0.03578982502222061, 0.06162000074982643, 0.0286392904818058, 0.010830509476363659, -0.05317530781030655, -0.006837631110101938, 0.07176747918128967, 0.05478795990347862, 0.011571601033210754, 0.00831554550677538, -0.03323798254132271, -0.028676185756921768, 0.04579808935523033, -0.0009805553127080202, 0.041029226034879684, 0.0008834050968289375, 0.001220838399603963, -0.0296108890324831, -0.03355284035205841, -0.057055190205574036, 0.012667846865952015, -0.01002973411232233, 0.055011630058288574, -0.022311720997095108, -0.04364921152591705, -0.06343483924865723, 0.003971642814576626, 0.017467064782977104, 0.0852312445640564, 0.00421155896037817, -0.03449619188904762, 0.0015545620117336512, 0.015884390100836754, 0.0005243286723271012, -0.050571560859680176, 0.050850603729486465, 0.03127864748239517, -0.022676147520542145, 0.03576493635773659, -0.030195176601409912, -0.048590246587991714, 0.0028813714161515236, 0.011415919288992882, -0.04418156296014786, 0.026264572516083717, 0.012262594886124134, 0.03967168182134628, 0.03288111835718155, 0.023886922746896744, -0.0012169041438028216, 0.024925796315073967, -0.015931475907564163, -0.001900963601656258, -0.03388817235827446, 0.0038439028430730104, -0.02488190121948719, -0.02827885001897812, -0.033358458429574966, -0.028163045644760132, -0.00023383104417007416, -0.009264985099434853, -0.0019945367239415646, 0.03996222838759422, -0.006939382757991552, -0.007040888536721468, 0.010799129493534565, 0.017582938075065613, -0.020125454291701317, -0.023620354011654854, -0.0012368427123874426, 0.030034098774194717, 0.010561744682490826, -0.021106937900185585, 0.018778664991259575, 0.012728989124298096, 0.031551629304885864, 0.01648188754916191, -0.03660925105214119, -0.008409789763391018, -0.019053133204579353, -0.0048046354204416275, 0.014928975142538548, -0.011003649793565273, 0.03488583117723465, -0.015935011208057404, 0.01848861761391163, 0.03251265361905098, -0.0339309386909008, -0.0008902809931896627, 0.01929435133934021, -0.033953163772821426, 0.032085537910461426, -0.05572408065199852, -0.00795381236821413, 0.0001462339423596859, -0.009969091042876244, -0.06949625164270401, -0.030330920591950417, 0.027336277067661285, -0.015687022358179092, -0.01429964043200016, -0.06157408654689789, -0.005180440377444029, -0.011115574277937412, -0.018496043980121613, 0.0075472816824913025, 0.0687934160232544, -0.019545895978808403, -0.013886697590351105, 0.012645872309803963, -0.00517643615603447, 0.06494402885437012, -0.0068545215763151646, 0.01217296440154314, 0.007853041402995586, 0.0065332078374922276, -0.013611054047942162, 0.019672341644763947, 0.05915756896138191, -0.03697627782821655, 0.012938544154167175, -0.022167064249515533, 0.006357494276016951, 0.045411545783281326, -0.034924764186143875, -0.058602020144462585, -0.009519177488982677, -0.017946096137166023, 0.02518276497721672, -0.017859432846307755, 0.014766157604753971, -0.0027395107317715883, -0.023811480030417442, -0.023880014196038246, -0.01636488549411297, -0.024361655116081238, -0.038951437920331955, 0.021134860813617706, 0.009571426548063755, -0.013205244205892086, 0.008693181909620762, 0.03885025903582573, 0.006200100295245647, 0.025404728949069977, 0.026926759630441666, -0.007850956171751022, 0.04674384742975235, 0.004072926472872496, -0.0010848089586943388, -0.015983644872903824, 0.0017358469776809216, -0.0659472793340683, -0.03417378291487694, -0.0664491131901741, 0.008988937363028526, 0.06561162322759628, -0.0029570898041129112, 0.059676237404346466, 0.03901873528957367, 0.01641460321843624, 0.018095629289746284, 0.0004431754059623927, -0.008248037658631802, -0.008745272643864155, -0.02378283254802227, 0.0118581997230649, -0.010365146212279797, -0.023465368896722794, 0.019449612125754356, 0.008443200029432774, 0.0010466913226991892, 0.009261473082005978, -0.026869360357522964, -0.0018384442664682865, 0.0639796033501625, -0.023723088204860687, -0.04134221002459526, 0.02765478380024433, -0.019096272066235542, -0.013129124417901039, 0.014447813853621483, -0.05230492725968361, 0.06617877632379532, 0.0471295528113842, 0.02983328513801098, -0.020049015060067177, -0.04399700462818146, -0.04796610400080681, 0.0037663253024220467, 0.06653507053852081, -0.023195944726467133, 0.05125296488404274, -0.0011993343941867352, 0.0050430092960596085, -0.017185356467962265, -0.0051725031808018684, -0.009391674771904945, -0.058187518268823624, -0.00016325668548233807, -0.06842850148677826, -0.036764103919267654, 0.008224209770560265, 0.014855075627565384, -0.044771842658519745, -0.026582030579447746, 0.020482158288359642, 0.010884112678468227, 0.033628206700086594, 0.005545466206967831, 0.021815098822116852, 0.05305813252925873, 0.016572432592511177, 0.020175697281956673, -0.0010175530333071947, -0.02038189396262169, 0.11246879398822784, 0.030167700722813606, 0.03021281771361828, -0.0392736978828907, 0.000893952208571136, 0.011853921227157116, -0.028946807608008385, -0.02674775756895542, 0.027805853635072708, -0.02549315243959427, -0.012247842736542225, 0.004566218238323927, 0.021154575049877167, 0.04929957538843155, 0.0014104591682553291, 0.06858528405427933, -0.053142208606004715, -0.025161726400256157, 0.02778763696551323, 0.011775124818086624, -0.00947690661996603, -0.030758177861571312, -0.0430634580552578, 0.01601797342300415, 0.0039980350993573666, -0.023450123146176338, -0.03421090915799141, -0.010912477970123291, 0.019272254779934883, 0.02026059478521347, -0.006075321231037378, 0.00712705310434103, 0.022222280502319336, -0.013013066723942757, -0.004354748874902725, 0.0015540296444669366, 0.022109730169177055, -0.01639082282781601, 0.016865672543644905, 0.051958464086055756, 0.012258361093699932, -0.011636773124337196, 0.025978680700063705, -0.01858149655163288, -0.014795062132179737, -0.03294185549020767, -0.028029169887304306, 0.06866758316755295, -0.00806096475571394, -0.006445482838898897, 0.007003761827945709, -0.015880201011896133, -0.022017383947968483, -0.06688686460256577, -0.00041432928992435336, 0.0045492807403206825, 0.04342471435666084, -0.018106359988451004, 0.0009316778741776943, 0.004123737569898367, 0.022895080968737602, -0.005066875368356705, 0.02581271529197693, 0.00666022626683116, -0.054018959403038025, -0.007633502129465342, 0.006163034122437239, 0.050057023763656616, -0.008010739460587502, -0.0024950033985078335, -0.02676493674516678, -0.005657806992530823, -0.019536573439836502, -0.012949278578162193, 0.021365337073802948, -0.0025858203880488873, 0.033209603279829025, 0.01620257832109928, -0.03776007145643234, -0.01684354431927204, -0.04439685493707657, -0.024341201409697533, -0.038858890533447266, -0.005362979136407375, -0.0412755161523819, -0.012532972730696201, 0.03941919282078743, 0.037010617554187775, 0.004462000913918018, -0.038936082273721695, 0.006685273256152868, 0.06096336618065834, 0.002244376577436924, -0.02833401970565319, -0.04246774688363075, -0.0035815781448036432, -0.012315930798649788, 0.027895476669073105, -0.013195970095694065, 0.018325146287679672, 0.0407235287129879, 0.013598843477666378, -0.02570883184671402, 0.0306792501360178, -0.028312960639595985, 0.013630930334329605, -0.04227586090564728, -0.05328966677188873, 0.014775458723306656, 0.011699482798576355, -0.012434284202754498, -0.05943902209401131, 0.0008347984403371811, -0.03499024733901024, -0.008168201893568039, -0.0013074666494503617, -0.016623811796307564, -0.022549984976649284, -0.018892569467425346, 0.0012593264691531658, 0.0035784593783318996, -0.025812726467847824, 0.01674867607653141, -0.005368089769035578, 0.004627663176506758, -0.03825729712843895, 0.0039640567265450954, -0.019785938784480095, 0.013433259911835194, 0.0015413350192829967, 0.011845104396343231, 0.032278839498758316, 0.0005631591193377972, 0.015141429379582405, -0.00286130141466856, 0.004843101371079683, -0.029413528740406036, 0.06197158992290497, -0.00399966211989522, -0.01432193722575903, 0.038734596222639084, -0.032217372208833694, -0.007825224660336971, 0.03463964909315109, 0.0015185974771156907, 0.03251217305660248, 0.008610522374510765, -0.009175616316497326, -0.007447437848895788, 0.03300336003303528, 0.02885677106678486, 0.015329921618103981, -0.002815498970448971, -0.02865784615278244, -0.00599323445931077, -0.010905859991908073, 0.029058635234832764, -0.00925588607788086, -0.01180309895426035, -0.025619827210903168, 0.009524278342723846, -0.002303503919392824, -0.007515773177146912, 0.01031958032399416, 0.015123718418180943, -0.021897541359066963, -0.0001777165016392246, 0.008797752670943737, 0.06055648997426033, 0.028390921652317047, -0.029329504817724228, 0.03265971690416336, -0.00821236427873373, -0.023894237354397774, -0.09998365491628647, -0.008972540497779846, 0.009481019340455532, 0.024230804294347763, 0.041666798293590546, -0.06639885902404785, 0.019584113731980324, 0.01481854822486639, -0.060425758361816406, 0.0388980507850647, 0.009509874507784843, 0.011598690412938595, -0.0297862496227026, 0.04039788991212845, -0.024198466911911964, 0.019491836428642273, 0.03757385164499283, 0.08304594457149506, 0.02602955512702465, 0.031713906675577164, -0.016049297526478767, -0.011248994618654251, -0.02749011665582657, 0.011600691825151443, 0.011263548396527767, -0.07100868970155716, 0.04508849233388901, -0.025355618447065353, 0.013140715658664703, 0.03696426749229431, -0.017044078558683395, -0.0015634748851880431, 0.04200131073594093, 0.02585650235414505, 0.02058277279138565, 0.06909719854593277, 0.0403817854821682, -0.009901057928800583, -0.008677687495946884, -0.02647128514945507, 0.0004802520270459354, 0.0032186878379434347, -0.03619466722011566, 0.020148927345871925, 0.020569495856761932, 0.003445236012339592, -0.05955183506011963, 0.0052279760129749775, 0.00983994361013174, -0.031588077545166016, 0.01791202649474144, -0.02211778424680233, -0.010791927576065063, -0.04163240268826485, 0.02134203165769577, -0.010115186683833599, -0.03243961185216904, 0.009609503671526909, 0.024461377412080765, -0.02795487456023693, 0.008145144209265709, -0.01938626356422901, -0.10129852592945099, 0.0007474584272131324, 0.016295287758111954, -0.004608945455402136, -0.052693724632263184, 0.028347846120595932, -0.0018823028076440096, -0.01939207874238491, -0.027927260845899582, -0.009995914995670319, -0.04351913556456566, 0.051004402339458466, -0.0025177861098200083, 0.00844395998865366, 0.044806428253650665, 0.00010813084372784942, -0.009702236391603947, -0.07407458126544952, 0.061596546322107315, 0.0514356829226017, -0.050790537148714066, 0.006505792029201984, -0.005361716262996197, -0.006811294239014387, -0.05074794217944145, 0.07263098657131195, -0.015699701383709908, 0.006757976487278938, 0.01899537816643715, 0.004027483984827995, 0.02590969391167164, -0.03182552382349968, 0.016992483288049698, -0.024837758392095566, -0.02287619560956955, -0.006648486014455557, 0.01309328991919756, -0.030215222388505936, 0.0013469724217429757, 0.029297195374965668, 0.002738417824730277, -0.001384195638820529, 0.01580706425011158, -0.027814149856567383, 0.02136402204632759, 0.02489171363413334, -0.009227164089679718, 0.03917955234646797, -0.02553394064307213, -0.009479970671236515, -0.012181860394775867, -0.021013040095567703, -0.07092847675085068, 0.018461626023054123, -0.0019807955250144005, -0.03242817893624306, -0.002097223186865449, 0.0234582107514143, 0.006399975623935461, -0.03181008994579315, -0.028535393998026848, 0.08158913254737854, -0.017911579459905624, -0.019815461710095406, 0.031009025871753693, 0.030108561739325523, 0.04557884484529495, 0.004077143035829067, -0.00528882397338748, 0.016064763069152832, -0.0310717411339283, 0.015551220625638962, -0.022662827745079994, 0.0022144103422760963, -0.020748984068632126, -0.005592418368905783, 0.014141645282506943, -0.013424522243440151, 0.03680179640650749, 0.02202349714934826, 0.02816723845899105, -0.016297221183776855, -0.025767378509044647, 0.0473036915063858, 0.0022004065103828907, -0.022169841453433037, -0.002097353572025895, -0.003994707018136978, 0.08553420752286911, -0.019428100436925888, 0.012717780657112598, -0.010613078251481056, -0.018789194524288177, -0.05140741169452667, 0.02914634346961975, 0.015438833273947239, 0.013617276214063168, 0.012263195589184761, 0.01316487044095993, -0.01060792151838541, -0.04670006036758423, 0.02462943270802498, -0.021757330745458603, 0.022626230493187904, -0.0015621924540027976, -0.004032420925796032, 0.03922121971845627, 0.0003455344995018095, 0.0021110197994858027, 0.005711113568395376, 0.04322338476777077, 0.08145078271627426, 0.05049337446689606, -0.01724683865904808, 0.01552657037973404, -0.004955055192112923, 0.03132958337664604, -0.07613622397184372, -0.024975113570690155, -0.040389109402894974, -0.012708038091659546, 0.034169554710388184, -0.01579328067600727 ]
<p>I hope that this question does not get marked "as too general" and hope a discussion gets started that benefits all.</p> <p>In statistics, we spend a lot of time learning large sample theories. We are deeply interested in assessing asymptotic properties of our estimators including whether they are asymptotically unbiased, asymptotically efficient, their asymptotic distribution and so on. The word asymptotic is strongly tied with the assumption that $n \rightarrow \infty$. </p> <p>In reality, however, we always deal with finite $n$. My questions are:</p> <p>1) what do we mean by large sample? How can we distinguish between small and large samples?</p> <p>2) When we say $n \rightarrow \infty$, do we literally mean that $n$ should go to $\infty$?</p> <p>e.x. for binomial distribution, $\bar{X}$ needs about n = 30 to converge to normal distribution under CLT. Should we have $n \rightarrow \infty$ or in this case by $\infty$ we mean 30 or more?!</p> <p>3) Suppose we have a finite sample and suppose that We know everything about asymptotic behavior of our estimators. So what? suppose that our estimators are asymptotically unbiased, then do we have an unbiased estimate for our parameter of interest in our finite sample or it means that if we had $n \rightarrow \infty$, then we would have an unbiased one?</p> <p>As you can see from the questions above, I'm trying to understand the philosophy behind "Large Sample Asymptotics" and to learn why we care? I need to get some intuitions for the theorems I'm learning.</p> <p>Your help is greatly appreciated. Thanks.</p>
37,021
[ -0.02859416790306568, -0.01031982060521841, -0.006460961885750294, 0.0024524403270334005, 0.04367457330226898, 0.01002032682299614, -0.0166314784437418, -0.016227243468165398, 0.015736142173409462, -0.0526704341173172, 0.02943958342075348, -0.002106312895193696, 0.029036041349172592, 0.029192853718996048, 0.03998829796910286, 0.011205818504095078, -0.04132971167564392, -0.016704222187399864, -0.003163854591548443, -0.004278202541172504, 0.017118435353040695, 0.07292907685041428, 0.032541148364543915, -0.0040067569352686405, -0.05104901269078255, 0.00678470591083169, 0.022189322859048843, 0.005249341484159231, 0.029987266287207603, 0.08245310932397842, 0.0037660938687622547, -0.029558531939983368, 0.02213888429105282, 0.057581089437007904, 0.019096966832876205, -0.006589031312614679, -0.021030906587839127, -0.051282186061143875, 0.03700704872608185, 0.022816244512796402, -0.06300164014101028, -0.028670616447925568, -0.008124422281980515, -0.0011963677825406194, 0.005182285327464342, 0.02454657107591629, -0.009959119372069836, -0.0639222115278244, 0.010038928128778934, -0.05037954822182655, 0.060199394822120667, 0.001028439262881875, 0.023487862199544907, 0.01648581400513649, -0.005154753569513559, -0.03020630031824112, 0.04535453021526337, 0.06197148934006691, -0.006858194712549448, -0.05989145487546921, -0.0037352973595261574, -0.05150764435529709, 0.019826171919703484, -0.011747511103749275, -0.03979252651333809, 0.022422971203923225, -0.021318411454558372, -0.020616253837943077, 0.026901930570602417, -0.024606522172689438, 0.02400928921997547, 0.03440213203430176, 0.017470678314566612, 0.03532710298895836, 0.010470928624272346, 0.004949816036969423, 0.0022705134470015764, -0.011899681761860847, 0.05435770004987717, 0.046716753393411636, -0.001999353291466832, 0.018600547686219215, 0.037100955843925476, 0.05386899784207344, 0.02839014120399952, -0.023340949788689613, 0.0653356984257698, -0.00024102104362100363, 0.04511098191142082, 0.00799876544624567, -0.00889225397258997, -0.02451419271528721, 0.04801429063081741, -0.02577197179198265, -0.03793271631002426, 0.04362201318144798, -0.019560882821679115, 0.029298020526766777, 0.04150791093707085, -0.011368864215910435, -0.0061319610103964806, -0.05047867074608803, 0.0000634544703643769, 0.062204502522945404, -0.028216399252414703, -0.013543694280087948, -0.010304276831448078, 0.018673421815037727, 0.009911976754665375, -0.02215568721294403, -0.013432108797132969, 0.03651296719908714, -0.02700875885784626, 0.007561840116977692, -0.003764890134334564, 0.006271819584071636, 0.03376684710383415, -0.030199062079191208, 0.03328980877995491, 0.08434485644102097, 0.05561801418662071, -0.015661049634218216, 0.024806547909975052, -0.01619275100529194, -0.030329328030347824, 0.008050814270973206, 0.021922517567873, -0.01870674639940262, -0.036662034690380096, 0.027655648067593575, 0.024268241599202156, 0.0022694591898471117, -0.000225515803322196, 0.02053118869662285, 0.06224316731095314, 0.006599118001759052, -0.0780852884054184, -0.062334079295396805, 0.06672938913106918, 0.00306637748144567, 0.0025320190470665693, -0.07973805069923401, 0.010067632421851158, 0.03294797241687775, 0.04052305221557617, -0.006767309736460447, 0.026715217158198357, 0.01447702944278717, 0.01616005413234234, 0.029076647013425827, -0.06282184273004532, -0.0015511785168200731, -0.02276138961315155, -0.0065934802405536175, -0.010536028072237968, -0.08487474918365479, 0.023093687370419502, 0.018099892884492874, 0.011743049137294292, -0.05429553613066673, 0.052009761333465576, -0.022476311773061752, -0.005854014772921801, -0.045627422630786896, 0.029430894181132317, -0.009110135957598686, 0.09716436266899109, 0.01259299274533987, 0.08667410165071487, 0.02457238920032978, 0.00828020740300417, 0.04678098112344742, 0.04770709574222565, 0.04290449619293213, 0.036337945610284805, -0.02747398614883423, -0.0077591571025550365, -0.04401712864637375, 0.0010200716787949204, 0.007465574890375137, -0.03828716650605202, -0.020701618865132332, 0.013645224273204803, 0.004999776836484671, 0.006346651818603277, 0.05604182928800583, -0.013302359730005264, -0.001116313156671822, 0.03267989307641983, -0.04732048138976097, -0.027052344754338264, -0.10037002712488174, -0.0024625100195407867, -0.023288413882255554, 0.01412570383399725, 0.036861684173345566, -0.006187863182276487, -0.012789731845259666, -0.014292740263044834, -0.007500794250518084, -0.04187128692865372, 0.023254327476024628, 0.035464443266391754, -0.031200630590319633, 0.01625741273164749, 0.03265516087412834, 0.035831518471241, 0.0037505191285163164, 0.04974019527435303, -0.05239596217870712, -0.06468475610017776, 0.041456375271081924, -0.01675098016858101, 0.032227955758571625, -0.006317041348665953, -0.0023414583411067724, -0.0019439347088336945, -0.024626919999718666, -0.020191654562950134, 0.03393464908003807, -0.026872927322983742, 0.09450163692235947, 0.04845810309052467, 0.006755497772246599, -0.005535584408789873, -0.008666743524372578, 0.016325945034623146, -0.026236576959490776, -0.0031716921366751194, -0.02261156402528286, -0.07674027979373932, -0.0060320207849144936, 0.05184724181890488, 0.02663440629839897, -0.036520324647426605, 0.021692844107747078, 0.03810657560825348, 0.016238626092672348, 0.015549974516034126, -0.01525878719985485, -0.01178716029971838, -0.010461573489010334, -0.009876207448542118, 0.02911658026278019, -0.019227076321840286, 0.006795946508646011, 0.015296723693609238, -0.0002676110598258674, 0.0405048243701458, 0.019698569551110268, 0.010059716179966927, 0.051305271685123444, -0.012374774552881718, -0.0027191576082259417, -0.025703195482492447, -0.00872330367565155, 0.00485150795429945, -0.04568514972925186, -0.032935403287410736, 0.012765888124704361, 0.003860629163682461, 0.0347016304731369, -0.0425993986427784, -0.011334992945194244, 0.038428857922554016, 0.004641684703528881, -0.05116783455014229, -0.004359154962003231, 0.020560622215270996, -0.03307775408029556, 0.011457376182079315, -0.047556716948747635, -0.04616028815507889, -0.012289983220398426, 0.04183133691549301, 0.02214454673230648, 0.014285719022154808, 0.0036473418585956097, -0.025516429916024208, -0.03052779659628868, 0.023017656058073044, -0.01103129331022501, 0.03266533091664314, 0.007245501969009638, -0.03290984779596329, 0.020651720464229584, -0.024911917746067047, -0.0423615500330925, 0.03787337616086006, -0.022136084735393524, 0.013915781863033772, -0.005457780789583921, -0.016599534079432487, -0.04267018288373947, 0.000507744203787297, -0.0036104656755924225, 0.03645883873105049, -0.025348789989948273, -0.03836613893508911, 0.058994945138692856, -0.019499583169817924, 0.010194743983447552, 0.019542492926120758, -0.05273881554603577, -0.02810363844037056, -0.01518272701650858, -0.014652960002422333, 0.004833586513996124, -0.005075729917734861, 0.022605210542678833, -0.003573920112103224, -0.002932473085820675, -0.03562108054757118, -0.04852782562375069, -0.05187366530299187, 0.014029907993972301, 0.001571310800500214, 0.048915453255176544, 0.01715276762843132, -0.03129064664244652, 0.06430649757385254, 0.04076218232512474, -0.047391943633556366, -0.00827141385525465, -0.00001703550515230745, -0.02337959222495556, 0.002943967003375292, 0.023928679525852203, -0.011749654076993465, 0.011939511634409428, -0.0026563217397779226, 0.0033526597544550896, 0.01050277054309845, 0.0055177402682602406, 0.022317644208669662, 0.008783932775259018, -0.000471175299026072, 0.029190512374043465, 0.020518871024250984, 0.020723294466733932, 0.026143210008740425, -0.03135749697685242, -0.014308124780654907, 0.007651766762137413, 0.008928575552999973, 0.005074179265648127, -0.020475052297115326, 0.05209197849035263, -0.007698829751461744, -0.01267153024673462, -0.001667445874772966, 0.04282986372709274, 0.009732554666697979, -0.025815414264798164, -0.015276254154741764, 0.02510523796081543, 0.012072679586708546, -0.02711625210940838, 0.022569071501493454, 0.027687963098287582, 0.040315352380275726, -0.05843956023454666, -0.014730662107467651, -0.012456248514354229, -0.0403042696416378, 0.00358231901191175, 0.0033602004405111074, -0.016440672799944878, 0.017503486946225166, 0.08155250549316406, 0.0035539581440389156, -0.02147538773715496, -0.030801523476839066, 0.007154538761824369, -0.04179561883211136, -0.01214549783617258, -0.018455617129802704, 0.04967709258198738, -0.00017243449110537767, 0.030282694846391678, 0.006882908754050732, 0.011424828320741653, 0.013582907617092133, 0.03689190372824669, -0.09587657451629639, 0.03071524202823639, -0.01545563992112875, -0.0034553254954516888, -0.007364945486187935, -0.0003725292335730046, 0.05959756299853325, 0.02329421415925026, 0.009414873085916042, -0.040153320878744125, 0.010833078064024448, -0.015303032472729683, -0.01387344766408205, -0.04142983257770538, -0.019276419654488564, -0.01136864349246025, 0.021819746121764183, -0.005711340345442295, -0.03687555342912674, 0.004998310934752226, 0.031237196177244186, -0.01712193340063095, -0.0379214882850647, -0.011443481780588627, 0.011087379418313503, 0.00826989859342575, 0.028619004413485527, 0.04029839485883713, 0.02938714064657688, -0.04182063043117523, 0.010839063674211502, 0.036206845194101334, 0.059759654104709625, 0.021802814677357674, -0.0029673774261027575, 0.018891170620918274, -0.05113573744893074, -0.014989407733082771, -0.004153427667915821, 0.02713720127940178, 0.03428807854652405, -0.0020948273595422506, 0.097751185297966, -0.019470734521746635, -0.04273504018783569, -0.014911169186234474, 0.03818938136100769, 0.014762512408196926, 0.008410359732806683, -0.02453242987394333, 0.0009547077934257686, 0.009171932935714722, 0.02808772213757038, 0.008225704543292522, -0.004776603542268276, -0.0021500415168702602, -0.003417741972953081, 0.03541165962815285, -0.0010352928657084703, -0.03555963188409805, -0.012038419023156166, 0.02688741497695446, 0.048534199595451355, 0.019079169258475304, -0.044717270880937576, 0.021117206662893295, 0.04432104155421257, 0.04678076505661011, 0.013235567137598991, -0.026465920731425285, -0.054489102214574814, 0.01764894835650921, 0.01557868905365467, 0.043948475271463394, -0.040656644850969315, 0.003166031325235963, -0.04152192547917366, -0.017319314181804657, -0.00497520063072443, -0.017681540921330452, -0.01638408564031124, -0.023111863061785698, -0.010263442993164062, -0.008588035590946674, -0.024895161390304565, -0.05968846008181572, -0.03006094880402088, 0.00019246390729676932, 0.029960881918668747, -0.03862478584051132, -0.02623773366212845, -0.051699042320251465, 0.014676453545689583, 0.026920989155769348, 0.06402241438627243, -0.018126118928194046, -0.001396529609337449, 0.0260145366191864, 0.02543947845697403, 0.020798033103346825, -0.05652913451194763, 0.04782253876328468, 0.01995980739593506, -0.026944121345877647, 0.03858508914709091, -0.026024486869573593, -0.0916278287768364, 0.02688802033662796, -0.019457314163446426, -0.05402736738324165, -0.011131096631288528, -0.055710166692733765, 0.018470801413059235, -0.00851235818117857, 0.029678868129849434, 0.039174992591142654, 0.022323481738567352, 0.0008922037668526173, 0.01600572280585766, -0.009466626681387424, 0.014979015104472637, -0.02171660214662552, 0.014014096930623055, -0.03323672339320183, -0.047825783491134644, -0.023411767557263374, 0.023198409005999565, -0.004039132501929998, 0.01844388246536255, -0.03844410553574562, -0.02367451600730419, 0.01026652380824089, 0.06291286647319794, 0.04696863144636154, 0.05069039389491081, 0.007501381915062666, 0.029049638658761978, 0.02895386330783367, -0.011302758008241653, 0.01918914169073105, -0.02090523950755596, 0.02137589454650879, 0.037277620285749435, -0.010215532034635544, 0.008019216358661652, -0.05308161675930023, -0.031237900257110596, 0.01909979060292244, -0.02165166474878788, 0.040761593729257584, 0.0019872451666742563, 0.02760380692780018, -0.014458202756941319, -0.03693839907646179, -0.02401353232562542, 0.01370326243340969, -0.01870621368288994, 0.0417446568608284, -0.03477270156145096, 0.011832858435809612, 0.003524645697325468, 0.02368481643497944, -0.06911676377058029, -0.043337322771549225, 0.013210883364081383, 0.00953663233667612, -0.024116504937410355, -0.02236000820994377, 0.014980691485106945, -0.02468778006732464, -0.04933096095919609, -0.01746630109846592, 0.07186175137758255, 0.01746971346437931, -0.0476672500371933, -0.006577870808541775, 0.019920099526643753, 0.07470938563346863, -0.000288077600998804, -0.029374631121754646, 0.03672907128930092, -0.007939386181533337, -0.03732302784919739, 0.007236222270876169, 0.019038571044802666, -0.017947334796190262, -0.002350518712773919, -0.016776330769062042, -0.015532314777374268, 0.023515716195106506, -0.03618980571627617, -0.02923763357102871, -0.0028091806452721357, -0.02493671514093876, -0.005696247797459364, 0.0011085672304034233, -0.029970979318022728, 0.003983074799180031, 0.03335468843579292, -0.016076279804110527, -0.01926298625767231, 0.01745467819273472, -0.04672583192586899, 0.04437531903386116, 0.02286081202328205, -0.0026417665649205446, 0.020291248336434364, 0.03490256145596504, -0.01775525137782097, -0.005580013617873192, -0.0012334637576714158, -0.019256221130490303, 0.034818135201931, 0.03728209435939789, 0.0010667915921658278, 0.0195815060287714, 0.010856257751584053, -0.004275225102901459, -0.046327244490385056, -0.04188920557498932, 0.03762474283576012, 0.03965068981051445, -0.00388647080399096, 0.042587026953697205, 0.027414722368121147, 0.006142177153378725, -0.018272722139954567, -0.014634428545832634, -0.017076663672924042, 0.0003100087633356452, -0.01048204954713583, 0.02052263543009758, -0.0011408322025090456, 0.007843720726668835, 0.013468396849930286, 0.0071189869195222855, 0.020894892513751984, 0.02375459112226963, 0.033922914415597916, 0.00498276948928833, 0.027541767805814743, -0.018781473860144615, -0.01629622094333172, 0.07032033056020737, -0.06850391626358032, 0.0005491212359629571, -0.033540934324264526, -0.023694898933172226, 0.022899633273482323, 0.04532879963517189, 0.01829351857304573, -0.04525690898299217, -0.014721697196364403, -0.05837084725499153, 0.006777801085263491, 0.02633945271372795, 0.0010067319963127375, 0.03942534700036049, -0.016945477575063705, -0.007632023189216852, 0.0038673493545502424, 0.034303780645132065, -0.015826299786567688, -0.09880565851926804, -0.048430074006319046, -0.022017762064933777, -0.07204993814229965, 0.017157094553112984, -0.005933261476457119, -0.03289856016635895, 0.012450790964066982, -0.04249196872115135, 0.04696410149335861, -0.0003296872309874743, 0.027870120480656624, -0.028232315555214882, 0.05351865664124489, 0.023779265582561493, 0.04067835211753845, 0.02680939808487892, -0.004355296958237886, 0.08622078597545624, 0.09072047472000122, 0.004802897572517395, -0.05219903960824013, 0.02872070111334324, -0.005247544031590223, 0.004308709874749184, -0.014759574085474014, -0.007353352382779121, 0.018103102222085, 0.03084774687886238, 0.027537036687135696, 0.027155118063092232, -0.02179693803191185, 0.0017424760153517127, 0.03956490382552147, -0.053971439599990845, -0.01804949901998043, 0.025896422564983368, 0.040179189294576645, 0.006437027361243963, 0.008932056836783886, -0.018775155767798424, 0.011610974557697773, 0.036089710891246796, 0.014319381676614285, -0.020108571276068687, -0.01423534844070673, 0.004662755876779556, -0.012111350893974304, -0.008699464611709118, -0.016092758625745773, -0.004633701406419277, -0.027049973607063293, -0.05007825046777725, 0.0030446883756667376, 0.007428246084600687, -0.020129824057221413, 0.008247352205216885, 0.05198723077774048, -0.020876700058579445, -0.009505154564976692, 0.011372421868145466, 0.028567034751176834, -0.039574213325977325, -0.06479904800653458, -0.0050806268118321896, 0.02268015407025814, -0.04494240880012512, 0.008490976877510548, -0.01029004342854023, 0.01680794358253479, 0.01630343124270439, -0.023040279746055603, 0.0056336442939937115, 0.02762417495250702, 0.02486962452530861, -0.05852653086185455, -0.03415335714817047, -0.04412379488348961, -0.004020149819552898, 0.012292771600186825, 0.019702930003404617, 0.005834465846419334, -0.03635936602950096, -0.0066834972240030766, 0.03372989594936371, 0.004972807597368956, 0.010384825058281422, 0.0057756053283810616, 0.012024876661598682, -0.0048590535297989845, -0.03930261731147766, 0.008124926127493382, 0.027876272797584534, -0.035681720823049545, 0.050417330116033554, -0.0014925110153853893, 0.010396420024335384, 0.005988406948745251, -0.03825270012021065, 0.011296060867607594, -0.03283362463116646, -0.015091851353645325, -0.05746954306960106, 0.005928942002356052, -0.012203427031636238, 0.03324979171156883, 0.02777557633817196, 0.0006159446784295142, 0.0004986796993762255, 0.03366675227880478, 0.0100961122661829, -0.034046564251184464, -0.013560299761593342, -0.01807807758450508, -0.034775614738464355, 0.009246361441910267, -0.02680394798517227, 0.038310594856739044, 0.037262365221977234, 0.008772040717303753, 0.015254003927111626, 0.016608161851763725, -0.019258074462413788, 0.026590919122099876, -0.01171273272484541, -0.06461130827665329, 0.02679932862520218, 0.044938359409570694, 0.03003186360001564, -0.041801873594522476, -0.05157990753650665, -0.03347127139568329, -0.004535835236310959, -0.001934514380991459, -0.031840767711400986, -0.03711984306573868, 0.011713195592164993, -0.0035966159775853157, 0.025107724592089653, -0.030785145238041878, -0.022287670522928238, -0.011378375813364983, -0.012015779502689838, -0.0018282918026670814, -0.01762576960027218, -0.00298985349945724, 0.006759369280189276, -0.01114773191511631, -0.05916217714548111, 0.04413054510951042, 0.002438023453578353, -0.0088456766679883, 0.00047632455243729055, 0.0090884268283844, -0.01395225990563631, 0.012997240759432316, 0.007344037294387817, -0.026654833927750587, 0.07365000247955322, -0.05979928746819496, -0.053206149488687515, 0.02812308445572853, -0.005696983076632023, 0.033926259726285934, 0.03792402148246765, 0.005134903360158205, -0.028239158913493156, -0.0039015295915305614, -0.06215467303991318, 0.006565303076058626, -0.022960618138313293, -0.01148067694157362, -0.01754787564277649, -0.005204567685723305, 0.002215046202763915, -0.013659526593983173, -0.004239978268742561, 0.024666188284754753, 0.05833646282553673, 0.027418222278356552, -0.007794113364070654, 0.03303901106119156, 0.011678141541779041, -0.004323488567024469, -0.002028802875429392, 0.016280340030789375, -0.003516067285090685, 0.06598775833845139, -0.05140938609838486, 0.04067101329565048, -0.05034144967794418, 0.008936663158237934, -0.09889496862888336, -0.02026848867535591, 0.023160796612501144, 0.009210258722305298, 0.0387193001806736, -0.050135038793087006, -0.03006475418806076, 0.025920318439602852, -0.04606185108423233, 0.037690144032239914, -0.020944727584719658, -0.04131772741675377, -0.05167858675122261, -0.027995074167847633, -0.028893325477838516, 0.01372686866670847, 0.0008936453959904611, 0.02896760404109955, 0.03772994503378868, 0.019666921347379684, 0.0068434844724833965, -0.0366891473531723, -0.042396705597639084, 0.021391449496150017, -0.007588522508740425, -0.03886111453175545, 0.05261508375406265, -0.030188797041773796, -0.0327376164495945, 0.04573531076312065, 0.0015742577379569411, 0.012763691134750843, 0.04798178747296333, 0.0010811613174155354, -0.015247224830091, 0.0394088551402092, 0.031868066638708115, 0.0018264467362314463, 0.00000513553413838963, 0.029689963907003403, 0.009980320930480957, 0.0023353633005172014, -0.03280918672680855, 0.021995732560753822, 0.05100056901574135, -0.02583686262369156, -0.002880116691812873, 0.03476991876959801, 0.005032229237258434, -0.029885917901992798, 0.019319379702210426, -0.003484046086668968, -0.021992584690451622, -0.018880803138017654, 0.030322110280394554, -0.011594811454415321, -0.03781682997941971, 0.014671378768980503, 0.044968221336603165, 0.008627854287624359, 0.03717240318655968, -0.00812680833041668, -0.026844041422009468, 0.024192627519369125, 0.02049899660050869, -0.019743802025914192, -0.05180022120475769, -0.012348570860922337, 0.01564605161547661, -0.00014765879313927144, -0.01405816338956356, -0.005735422018915415, -0.0294614490121603, 0.026422739028930664, -0.035948146134614944, 0.033440325409173965, -0.00988736655563116, -0.010500225238502026, -0.02545144408941269, -0.07865772396326065, 0.055112872272729874, -0.029807409271597862, 0.026815053075551987, -0.05481906607747078, -0.000788260658737272, -0.01571735367178917, -0.021885432302951813, 0.0697370246052742, 0.010066935792565346, 0.01827862858772278, 0.015726519748568535, 0.033778589218854904, 0.016815900802612305, -0.04707377403974533, -0.0009222094085998833, -0.02452210523188114, -0.002605488756671548, -0.03974459320306778, -0.037766583263874054, 0.010027777403593063, 0.007005683146417141, 0.01738594099879265, 0.0007262298604473472, 0.02815256640315056, 0.016180213540792465, -0.0115768788382411, 0.04939204454421997, -0.005996410734951496, 0.03670046851038933, 0.04952499270439148, -0.0030982166063040495, 0.029907461255788803, 0.028012380003929138, -0.03337550163269043, -0.06120303273200989, 0.017102984711527824, -0.029625143855810165, -0.021122515201568604, 0.0030492942314594984, 0.024115093052387238, -0.03664752468466759, -0.05842537805438042, -0.006907510105520487, 0.05252092704176903, -0.02529575303196907, 0.014346619136631489, 0.02813205122947693, 0.01254924014210701, 0.04542294517159462, -0.043453946709632874, -0.011982187628746033, 0.024631114676594734, 0.006472830194979906, -0.014687017537653446, 0.036157991737127304, 0.026556944474577904, -0.017892183735966682, 0.07124616205692291, 0.015859318897128105, -0.015628358349204063, 0.020527491346001625, 0.015001808293163776, 0.043129537254571915, -0.06278012692928314, -0.038110800087451935, 0.025729671120643616, -0.017223186790943146, -0.0132712097838521, 0.0058646355755627155, -0.01972273178398609, 0.057170793414115906, 0.0005586538463830948, 0.0036740293726325035, 0.002595964353531599, -0.00995226763188839, -0.03199794143438339, -0.011538070626556873, -0.032146137207746506, 0.02400190383195877, 0.007462076377123594, 0.02500193938612938, -0.006716285832226276, 0.003839361947029829, 0.05125090479850769, -0.017462095245718956, 0.009309913963079453, -0.00967452209442854, -0.030459804460406303, -0.03743051737546921, -0.0142980283126235, -0.026578264310956, -0.0019396876450628042, 0.01941462606191635, 0.04455461725592613, 0.03145945444703102, 0.020942557603120804, -0.01489216648042202, 0.03422422334551811, 0.07532862573862076, -0.06427333503961563, 0.015012877993285656, -0.027033984661102295, -0.024238213896751404, 0.0005313681322149932, -0.03716609999537468 ]
<p>Does anyone know of a good compendium or catalog of compound distributions, or finite mixture representations of those distributions? </p> <p>I am trying to find out to what extent the common multi-parameter distributions and their generalized forms can be built up from single parameter distributions through compounding. The ones I have found so far cover only 10 or 15 distributions, and I still can not tell if it is possible to build up e.g. most four parameter distributions from one parameter distributions by successive steps of compounding.</p>
38,773
[ -0.02215545065701008, -0.02172875590622425, 0.026618553325533867, -0.013676149770617485, 0.040585484355688095, 0.00694291852414608, -0.019816746935248375, -0.005801923107355833, 0.01759125106036663, -0.06700024008750916, 0.010832303203642368, 0.01580880768597126, 0.05636642500758171, -0.016425617039203644, 0.013060217723250389, 0.015934184193611145, -0.002233424922451377, 0.01590608060359955, -0.019404157996177673, -0.011446082964539528, 0.020836668089032173, 0.01293279230594635, 0.01257194485515356, -0.02398429997265339, 0.016933022066950798, 0.03306359052658081, 0.007065901532769203, -0.04913663491606712, 0.025647608563303947, 0.08718857914209366, -0.0600237175822258, -0.020602460950613022, -0.021517479792237282, 0.0664781928062439, -0.025216666981577873, -0.014612176455557346, -0.0168494563549757, -0.04286558926105499, -0.04238925501704216, 0.021404551342129707, -0.061788130551576614, -0.02039356343448162, -0.016320815309882164, 0.0022094263695180416, 0.0017997237155213952, 0.010306751355528831, -0.008485647849738598, -0.06044194474816322, -0.0032664346508681774, -0.05850762501358986, 0.08935131877660751, 0.03261537477374077, 0.027700275182724, 0.037073418498039246, 0.002133638598024845, 0.029823103919625282, 0.0557989627122879, 0.09990429878234863, 0.03377793729305267, -0.06369643658399582, 0.032592788338661194, -0.008233577944338322, 0.03615135699510574, -0.04474978521466255, -0.037175100296735764, 0.04470647871494293, 0.02260625548660755, -0.04779677093029022, 0.012484663166105747, 0.000737002061214298, 0.027555245906114578, 0.024011310189962387, 0.04171580821275711, -0.0007972777239046991, -0.016300814226269722, 0.0026122904382646084, 0.04516437277197838, 0.004545128904283047, 0.06663510203361511, -0.012361962348222733, -0.013810787349939346, 0.05986000970005989, -0.014148872345685959, -0.01503573264926672, -0.001495808595791459, -0.015222540125250816, 0.08732067793607712, -0.01498574297875166, 0.008018399588763714, 0.01944812200963497, -0.039655525237321854, -0.01904389075934887, 0.03365647420287132, -0.004317956510931253, -0.07244469225406647, 0.04121130332350731, 0.006343785207718611, 0.026189349591732025, -0.012829914689064026, -0.010035159066319466, -0.012064164504408836, -0.016546031460165977, -0.016603248193860054, 0.04799684137105942, -0.0013287282781675458, 0.01115809753537178, -0.025998573750257492, -0.01885204203426838, -0.011877547949552536, 0.013500374741852283, 0.004879071842879057, 0.04487171024084091, -0.013409119099378586, 0.0038597595412284136, -0.03851449862122536, -0.006968681700527668, 0.004449015017598867, -0.028273530304431915, 0.05405891314148903, 0.055604781955480576, 0.0322631411254406, -0.05060511454939842, 0.03781542181968689, -0.01584726572036743, -0.07687743008136749, -0.013855102472007275, -0.011192506179213524, -0.009597561322152615, -0.023804640397429466, 0.0542285218834877, 0.01610534079372883, -0.03159521520137787, 0.0849611759185791, 0.020762460306286812, 0.028719674795866013, -0.016104884445667267, -0.032510288059711456, -0.05143813416361809, 0.010635683313012123, -0.02726946584880352, 0.01640848070383072, -0.03143025562167168, 0.030238613486289978, 0.023850813508033752, 0.016147084534168243, -0.019466571509838104, 0.039946187287569046, -0.01911081001162529, 0.06204693391919136, 0.03459834307432175, -0.024159155786037445, -0.022088199853897095, 0.011417625471949577, 0.01187763549387455, -0.008816149085760117, -0.08951135724782944, 0.04370316490530968, 0.0059837219305336475, 0.011729820631444454, 0.005881239660084248, 0.05333147197961807, 0.0020615067332983017, -0.01860004849731922, -0.015186823904514313, 0.05598156154155731, -0.01840614341199398, 0.06339438259601593, -0.006814937572926283, 0.02695777267217636, 0.0032088267616927624, -0.0024590776301920414, 0.009017295204102993, 0.030901189893484116, 0.034361179918050766, 0.022797299548983574, -0.03004308044910431, -0.00011516369704622775, -0.027340855449438095, 0.010672914795577526, 0.021603899076581, -0.02284889668226242, -0.016307203099131584, -0.018137700855731964, -0.005567832384258509, 0.037160761654376984, 0.0048231445252895355, 0.030248358845710754, -0.04206518456339836, 0.03461143746972084, -0.05610465258359909, -0.012768521904945374, -0.02189612202346325, -0.0294876080006361, -0.06186065450310707, -0.018119201064109802, 0.042253680527210236, -0.00533057888969779, 0.009724662639200687, -0.007732012774795294, -0.06325168907642365, -0.03187556937336922, -0.0007314158137887716, 0.022074222564697266, -0.029549522325396538, -0.02873089723289013, 0.04498886317014694, 0.04061072692275047, -0.03354538604617119, 0.03850824013352394, -0.024032358080148697, -0.08034282922744751, -0.00667367409914732, -0.037014320492744446, 0.03162585198879242, -0.025604430586099625, -0.00608897814527154, -0.022447684779763222, 0.002729856176301837, -0.00501560652628541, -0.0037860111333429813, -0.05792069807648659, 0.0430876761674881, 0.09475573152303696, 0.01975017413496971, -0.02099325880408287, 0.003901145653799176, 0.021785996854305267, -0.004454866051673889, -0.0015699779614806175, 0.02214161492884159, -0.04425694793462753, 0.0048535349778831005, 0.04831840470433235, -0.0018441141583025455, -0.04944096505641937, 0.03283628821372986, 0.034043729305267334, 0.053912803530693054, 0.0339706651866436, 0.01747788116335869, -0.016447732225060463, -0.027450861409306526, 0.018007643520832062, 0.027453703805804253, 0.026512285694479942, 0.010471518151462078, 0.012873883359134197, -0.021754195913672447, 0.012703238055109978, -0.031751155853271484, -0.011401145718991756, 0.01787376031279564, -0.0011881085811182857, -0.015833107754588127, -0.01719338446855545, -0.033575817942619324, 0.03989962115883827, -0.032389864325523376, -0.000578095845412463, 0.02104157954454422, 0.006695913150906563, 0.006134860683232546, 0.00698599498718977, -0.005502860993146896, 0.02940666861832142, 0.002021622844040394, -0.026006562635302544, 0.010835233144462109, 0.02172824740409851, -0.02633620798587799, 0.006360441911965609, -0.042907509952783585, 0.003861208213493228, -0.027728907763957977, 0.03581027314066887, 0.02332422323524952, 0.004511141683906317, 0.024548564106225967, -0.020070865750312805, -0.047511834651231766, 0.009504241868853569, -0.018252136185765266, 0.008199689909815788, -0.005329398903995752, -0.07304294407367706, 0.03042755275964737, -0.046192798763513565, -0.06156254559755325, 0.047072116285562515, 0.002258703811094165, -0.028762808069586754, -0.000478892819955945, 0.0013583345571532845, -0.048229463398456573, -0.048655249178409576, 0.009757592342793941, 0.0007622002740390599, -0.06221013888716698, 0.014211340807378292, 0.037732794880867004, -0.011300069279968739, -0.01688101328909397, 0.012836883775889874, -0.0352155864238739, -0.04457470402121544, -0.03560356795787811, -0.022708026692271233, 0.013774272985756397, 0.002612294163554907, -0.03147073835134506, 0.06721692532300949, -0.028509384021162987, -0.014117764309048653, -0.044119831174612045, -0.04557359963655472, -0.0055408780463039875, 0.03913388401269913, 0.05495313182473183, 0.03246722370386124, -0.031010979786515236, 0.0665513277053833, -0.011673054657876492, -0.02542211301624775, 0.012296351604163647, 0.05730918049812317, -0.016711197793483734, -0.00044189702020958066, 0.0012563993223011494, 0.004487237893044949, -0.007120832335203886, 0.008049435913562775, 0.03810017183423042, 0.0166583601385355, 0.06696347147226334, 0.0170940812677145, -0.005644131917506456, 0.04328783228993416, 0.011282269842922688, -0.002596424426883459, 0.005580154247581959, 0.028520777821540833, 0.0008216997375711799, 0.003323420649394393, -0.016672441735863686, 0.017018912360072136, -0.0007490669377148151, -0.007496471516788006, 0.01792517490684986, -0.0012668692506849766, -0.02728678472340107, -0.034164827316999435, 0.020375274121761322, 0.015838541090488434, -0.05262262746691704, 0.0018603678327053785, 0.026003601029515266, 0.034858353435993195, -0.03911594673991203, 0.03031390905380249, 0.018962595611810684, 0.051796797662973404, -0.04352109879255295, -0.03707804158329964, 0.01500626839697361, -0.006474575027823448, -0.02442806586623192, -0.0046266173012554646, 0.0044180480763316154, 0.03832673653960228, 0.011810112744569778, 0.026446769014000893, -0.026023266837000847, -0.00594051368534565, 0.026661749929189682, -0.08003836125135422, 0.00613745953887701, -0.0430004708468914, 0.014390171505510807, 0.007621262222528458, 0.08618124574422836, -0.023213045671582222, -0.025613872334361076, 0.01945933885872364, 0.024822881445288658, -0.06761394441127777, 0.02300594188272953, 0.007987014017999172, -0.0009451822843402624, 0.00009939546725945547, -0.008274827152490616, 0.0031190530862659216, -0.016222387552261353, -0.036028727889060974, 0.0005083517753519118, 0.008609883487224579, -0.03491860255599022, 0.002723962301388383, -0.017354527488350868, -0.08443272113800049, -0.029733944684267044, 0.009806493297219276, -0.011646921746432781, -0.006749733351171017, 0.010530641302466393, 0.0325157456099987, -0.00038883689558133483, -0.0177136342972517, -0.03654717653989792, 0.034530192613601685, 0.026659902185201645, 0.003974341321736574, 0.001076791901141405, 0.04381508752703667, -0.0140976058319211, 0.05446571111679077, 0.00843663141131401, 0.10490280389785767, 0.04659588634967804, -0.029311751946806908, 0.0018327139550819993, -0.02812858298420906, -0.037096522748470306, 0.019979435950517654, -0.01146158017218113, 0.028885286301374435, -0.0010550079168751836, 0.0414593331515789, 0.033267684280872345, -0.03857477754354477, -0.004616489168256521, 0.04378095269203186, -0.029668662697076797, -0.039770253002643585, -0.004051100928336382, -0.002483439166098833, 0.004542298149317503, 0.028899041935801506, -0.0022612870670855045, 0.025706911459565163, -0.018881723284721375, 0.027731794863939285, 0.009291999973356724, 0.00194748945068568, -0.020718149840831757, -0.017725827172398567, -0.0025951946154236794, 0.026858381927013397, 0.012182963080704212, -0.019770687445998192, 0.03209970146417618, 0.013161804527044296, 0.03342711552977562, 0.024900635704398155, -0.004140983801335096, -0.05828835442662239, 0.047061264514923096, 0.06323498487472534, 0.02449137158691883, -0.027233527973294258, 0.02158300392329693, -0.03114418499171734, -0.023060819134116173, 0.021682338789105415, 0.006204246077686548, -0.01050960086286068, -0.0020277441944926977, -0.037178587168455124, -0.02442711964249611, -0.022732140496373177, -0.013568405993282795, 0.018025141209363937, -0.0034827219787985086, -0.006076063960790634, 0.0027922973968088627, 0.03720769286155701, -0.03790535777807236, 0.03340126946568489, 0.009044480510056019, 0.07576034218072891, 0.01820964552462101, -0.05750298127532005, 0.02546190842986107, 0.019489267840981483, 0.0022375984117388725, -0.06844444572925568, -0.008757890202105045, -0.010114404372870922, -0.02272680029273033, 0.02919316478073597, -0.029372449964284897, -0.04014162719249725, 0.054922252893447876, -0.004798237234354019, -0.026545526459813118, 0.016920458525419235, 0.0105452761054039, 0.020499544218182564, -0.004335952922701836, 0.009233716875314713, 0.06258483976125717, 0.021576672792434692, -0.021942805498838425, -0.01036579068750143, -0.03163456171751022, 0.03645187243819237, -0.03202233463525772, 0.00782791431993246, -0.042610052973032, -0.004645926877856255, -0.021820681169629097, 0.034482069313526154, -0.0028975079767405987, 0.03414154797792435, -0.014631510712206364, -0.030599096789956093, -0.015736255794763565, 0.021238159388303757, 0.010281287133693695, -0.0011630490189418197, 0.04226146265864372, 0.040194787085056305, -0.003126170253381133, 0.01680210418999195, 0.01705867238342762, -0.009427444078028202, 0.02210026979446411, 0.026796521618962288, -0.037424761801958084, 0.015270788222551346, -0.0558309331536293, -0.02112007886171341, 0.02073778584599495, -0.019941655918955803, 0.04386890307068825, 0.00022808057838119566, 0.018186699599027634, 0.065266914665699, -0.06851502507925034, -0.0191534124314785, 0.010418133810162544, 0.02722812630236149, 0.0338125117123127, -0.03692037984728813, -0.005989462602883577, -0.028546253219246864, 0.003224932821467519, -0.052586592733860016, -0.020287426188588142, 0.05392618104815483, -0.007182199042290449, -0.03194679319858551, -0.0689154714345932, 0.015529676340520382, -0.013216807506978512, -0.042781442403793335, 0.01790434680879116, 0.08203156292438507, -0.005629510618746281, 0.0009437919361516833, -0.005414015147835016, 0.029571298509836197, 0.05764857679605484, 0.018033800646662712, 0.029264137148857117, 0.04338207468390465, 0.006407516077160835, 0.007758982479572296, 0.02512330375611782, -0.015323178842663765, -0.04737497493624687, 0.028709543868899345, 0.017021290957927704, -0.003445250215008855, 0.04954079911112785, -0.02531619556248188, -0.0005405842093750834, 0.00008611263911006972, -0.014592454768717289, -0.011474310420453548, -0.008979465812444687, -0.014661465771496296, -0.014996778219938278, -0.0057531120255589485, -0.03400455787777901, 0.012806982733309269, -0.015693776309490204, -0.009791865013539791, 0.019821997731924057, -0.043034207075834274, -0.02112792618572712, 0.017425917088985443, 0.047378215938806534, 0.030002545565366745, 0.007945815101265907, 0.007981839589774609, -0.017255378887057304, 0.003777674864977598, -0.01694241538643837, -0.01706157810986042, 0.04007053002715111, -0.01106514036655426, -0.009833256714046001, -0.013041019439697266, -0.03181254863739014, -0.0056224786676466465, 0.0350063219666481, -0.010980569757521152, 0.029714077711105347, 0.04134209826588631, -0.00027416361263021827, -0.01906188391149044, -0.006384753622114658, -0.02908189594745636, 0.009594370611011982, 0.008683828637003899, 0.06112333759665489, -0.01250246912240982, -0.03360781818628311, 0.005323369055986404, -0.012247421778738499, -0.006797731388360262, 0.02910010889172554, -0.008753271773457527, -0.007268948946148157, 0.030788959935307503, -0.03193265572190285, -0.02666221372783184, 0.06127534806728363, -0.03433807194232941, -0.008787828497588634, -0.0008449031156487763, -0.046427883207798004, 0.03046412207186222, 0.03352969139814377, -0.006427806336432695, -0.027932466939091682, -0.03147820383310318, -0.028050124645233154, 0.048893336206674576, 0.034134119749069214, 0.011570604518055916, 0.022255664691329002, 0.01171448640525341, 0.04692498594522476, 0.0082263657823205, 0.023617835715413094, 0.0007451809360645711, -0.06320039182901382, -0.019879037514328957, 0.006899715401232243, -0.06560055166482925, -0.00007009065302554518, -0.006247777491807938, -0.0017331027192994952, 0.0014981713611632586, -0.02340460941195488, 0.02331901714205742, -0.024942414835095406, 0.025189250707626343, 0.001946229487657547, 0.06476565450429916, -0.0035438379272818565, 0.007387000136077404, 0.02219885215163231, -0.016410518437623978, 0.11528095602989197, 0.045312270522117615, 0.03511180356144905, -0.06656157225370407, -0.007903806865215302, 0.007750168442726135, 0.0043558827601373196, -0.028201032429933548, 0.028748847544193268, 0.025827227160334587, 0.018657471984624863, 0.024952365085482597, 0.03575526922941208, -0.0398617722094059, 0.01944914273917675, 0.05228441208600998, -0.010120010003447533, -0.04678669199347496, -0.011854966171085835, 0.023981589823961258, -0.013118491508066654, 0.01335565559566021, -0.05902493745088577, -0.013234314508736134, -0.00025028595700860023, 0.014474214985966682, -0.058424971997737885, -0.0404561348259449, 0.033050235360860825, -0.005044824443757534, -0.016576405614614487, -0.028858305886387825, 0.015200899913907051, -0.012509611435234547, 0.047636911273002625, 0.009951302781701088, 0.01943795382976532, -0.004306748043745756, -0.002490455750375986, 0.06628355383872986, 0.017222022637724876, 0.019194046035408974, 0.01795119233429432, 0.013084886595606804, -0.021986722946166992, -0.020721467211842537, -0.023131290450692177, 0.025080498307943344, -0.04462631419301033, 0.030154161155223846, -0.0218900628387928, -0.007774882949888706, 0.0028661375399678946, -0.009478848427534103, -0.03176294267177582, -0.00034257062361575663, 0.054050397127866745, -0.02761705592274666, -0.014035957865417004, -0.0338507741689682, 0.025572000071406364, -0.010085724294185638, 0.04921015724539757, -0.009818509221076965, -0.034845687448978424, -0.01297252532094717, -0.048210661858320236, 0.01778007298707962, 0.03592249006032944, -0.021735653281211853, 0.006300557404756546, 0.03040463663637638, -0.0034643695689737797, -0.03681612387299538, 0.029483627527952194, 0.0057044196873903275, 0.05112782120704651, 0.008711952716112137, 0.01861502416431904, 0.016081947833299637, -0.026593759655952454, -0.004853672813624144, -0.026529746130108833, 0.0015942510217428207, -0.045806314796209335, -0.00209407159127295, 0.0369468554854393, 0.031879495829343796, -0.022025728598237038, 0.030442165210843086, -0.07681169360876083, 0.036576006561517715, 0.02737579122185707, -0.04501115530729294, -0.014932754449546337, 0.03566337376832962, 0.0008708513923920691, -0.007937416434288025, -0.02803202159702778, 0.04623386636376381, 0.00928828027099371, 0.034328147768974304, -0.016216019168496132, 0.03416144847869873, 0.035085417330265045, 0.009198352694511414, 0.02350100316107273, -0.04895659536123276, 0.0036448780447244644, 0.007466928102076054, 0.018469901755452156, -0.0035943228285759687, -0.0319274365901947, -0.00666041998192668, -0.030070649459958076, -0.015197197906672955, -0.0037413628306239843, -0.04195087403059006, -0.026413310319185257, -0.021472005173563957, -0.021106889471411705, -0.013859599828720093, 0.041767045855522156, 0.0007216775557026267, 0.007244881242513657, -0.029050743207335472, -0.005589009262621403, 0.007611754350364208, -0.011117583140730858, -0.05303395912051201, -0.007890013046562672, 0.0441729873418808, 0.01602780818939209, 0.009690545499324799, -0.008526063524186611, 0.02980475313961506, -0.0009436426917091012, 0.05394924432039261, -0.009197031147778034, 0.014468003064393997, 0.04872995615005493, -0.054367583245038986, -0.045375268906354904, -0.024342510849237442, 0.021811166778206825, 0.03802340477705002, 0.014682208187878132, -0.0007460426422767341, -0.04433458670973778, 0.037864286452531815, -0.03319528326392174, -0.006399445701390505, 0.005028798710554838, 0.025280827656388283, 0.012096050195395947, 0.004136661533266306, 0.005678314249962568, -0.007319403346627951, -0.015777958557009697, 0.013140091672539711, 0.0065151420421898365, 0.0008051165495999157, 0.03407404571771622, 0.055963803082704544, 0.004646738059818745, 0.04810710251331329, 0.012842876836657524, 0.006217821966856718, 0.04784589260816574, 0.05249461531639099, -0.01385634858161211, 0.0616496317088604, -0.009746759198606014, 0.020753255113959312, -0.07125143706798553, 0.0002185432385886088, 0.008541002869606018, -0.006103426683694124, 0.04071821644902229, -0.05373920127749443, -0.02958369441330433, -0.0037553850561380386, -0.04796549677848816, -0.010122321546077728, -0.006117675919085741, -0.012112652882933617, -0.02489815279841423, -0.021991066634655, -0.02196676842868328, 0.058931220322847366, 0.021211767569184303, 0.047260724008083344, 0.031682152301073074, 0.02235955372452736, 0.011841922998428345, -0.012279476970434189, -0.04051748290657997, 0.005659956019371748, 0.018647219985723495, -0.05601239204406738, 0.034980323165655136, -0.01874672994017601, -0.04381955415010452, 0.043722864240407944, 0.027624480426311493, 0.007049905601888895, 0.003829952096566558, 0.03805645927786827, 0.023447899147868156, 0.05905881151556969, 0.021830229088664055, 0.014480242505669594, 0.003178049810230732, 0.030034011229872704, 0.02664429508149624, 0.017075780779123306, -0.07450280338525772, -0.0005390928126871586, 0.029685696586966515, -0.0140836825594306, -0.0303951408714056, 0.029119396582245827, -0.030647628009319305, -0.03071991540491581, -0.015993621200323105, -0.048856012523174286, 0.013559965416789055, 0.008723567239940166, 0.03981054946780205, -0.04886138066649437, -0.029079191386699677, 0.007805265486240387, 0.012915236875414848, 0.021892793476581573, 0.051125552505254745, 0.0008802652009762824, -0.025255315005779266, -0.01891273818910122, -0.002623375039547682, -0.00311096478253603, -0.03292538598179817, 0.01944521814584732, 0.027033179998397827, -0.0037734860088676214, -0.022135738283395767, -0.015013657510280609, -0.015739690512418747, 0.026313209906220436, -0.024284489452838898, 0.011676067486405373, 0.025490520521998405, -0.012382094748318195, 0.03153679519891739, -0.06935872882604599, 0.04391986504197121, -0.00673481822013855, -0.011959237977862358, -0.05565821751952171, -0.0017555301310494542, -0.007401975337415934, 0.008105933666229248, 0.02967222034931183, -0.03069310262799263, -0.00492057716473937, -0.02035296894609928, 0.04750809445977211, 0.022757379338145256, -0.08459227532148361, 0.03348573297262192, -0.008919758722186089, -0.056855350732803345, -0.03582291677594185, 0.022575033828616142, 0.017688879743218422, -0.014558095484972, 0.0303102545440197, -0.027664950117468834, -0.020718388259410858, -0.02903204970061779, -0.022299937903881073, 0.04645363241434097, 0.01823142170906067, -0.03227349370718002, 0.03228917717933655, -0.046516116708517075, 0.004554751329123974, -0.009036177769303322, 0.009181010536849499, -0.0717480331659317, 0.015784718096256256, -0.0021462966687977314, -0.0285950880497694, -0.03194175660610199, -0.008372766897082329, 0.00504568824544549, -0.05118982121348381, -0.0005045010475441813, -0.007704700343310833, -0.05659060552716255, -0.011557148769497871, 0.0587187334895134, 0.04169915243983269, 0.08129356056451797, 0.022173389792442322, -0.012914706952869892, 0.010936450213193893, -0.011018341407179832, -0.010438120923936367, 0.003064788179472089, 0.003875572234392166, -0.012126371264457703, -0.024307509884238243, -0.014123700559139252, -0.057130977511405945, 0.026907021179795265, -0.020668674260377884, 0.0401870422065258, -0.07060901075601578, -0.0027001923881471157, 0.0310046523809433, -0.013038848526775837, 0.0056472704745829105, -0.009434466250240803, -0.0509067140519619, 0.0562158040702343, -0.007365809287875891, -0.009256466291844845, -0.0488777682185173, 0.033004093915224075, 0.002211770974099636, -0.029428984969854355, 0.00028896224102936685, 0.02283158153295517, 0.009602239355444908, 0.018474942073225975, -0.05173838511109352, -0.005297799129039049, 0.05398807302117348, -0.05724629759788513, 0.02937793917953968, -0.015190334059298038, 0.008470996282994747, -0.019281065091490746, -0.023099660873413086, -0.021505339071154594, -0.03870205208659172, 0.009876057505607605, 0.02682318538427353, 0.03031127154827118, -0.025197938084602356, -0.0077607654966413975, -0.0016648739110678434, 0.06432465463876724, -0.03807983174920082, -0.009492920711636543, -0.0447133406996727, 0.007431492209434509, 0.01232233177870512, 0.0025910832919180393 ]
<p>I came across a study in which patients, who were all over 50, were pseudo-randomized by birth year. If birth year were an even number, usual care, if an odd number, intervention.</p> <p>It's easier to implement, it's harder to subvert (it's easy to check what treatment a patient should have received), it's easy to remember (the assignment went on for several years). But still, I don't like it, I feel like proper randomization would have been better. But I can't explain why. </p> <p>Am I wrong for feeling that, or is there a good reason to prefer 'real' randomization?</p>
74,255
[ -0.02513277530670166, -0.03182432800531387, -0.04193386808037758, -0.08936405181884766, 0.058553360402584076, -0.016254253685474396, -0.018197350203990936, -0.008498023264110088, 0.03868938609957695, 0.0032887952402234077, 0.05331413820385933, 0.03431876003742218, -0.009825633838772774, -0.029464328661561012, 0.005568920634686947, 0.029362354427576065, 0.0071997446939349174, 0.010363347828388214, -0.03490198403596878, -0.010735297575592995, -0.002258375519886613, 0.0020311293192207813, -0.028728339821100235, -0.004231395199894905, -0.051503900438547134, 0.03337171673774719, 0.006700919941067696, -0.036872100085020065, -0.022630564868450165, 0.06061505526304245, -0.037991274148225784, 0.01171074341982603, 0.010992654599249363, 0.00686999736353755, 0.055265601724386215, -0.018188143149018288, -0.02750655636191368, 0.0007391575491055846, 0.007380882743746042, 0.03584831953048706, -0.02262071892619133, 0.008635979145765305, -0.033367179334163666, -0.0061235735192894936, -0.021623117849230766, 0.07051212340593338, -0.013947684317827225, 0.011466341093182564, 0.06039690971374512, -0.03258896246552467, 0.035092491656541824, -0.009197114035487175, 0.03444309160113335, 0.01964149810373783, -0.03206220641732216, 0.013785199262201786, 0.02352607063949108, 0.0647762194275856, 0.009415758773684502, -0.03517947718501091, -0.04608552157878876, -0.022417597472667694, 0.01990402862429619, 0.01866542175412178, -0.005508463364094496, -0.005858822260051966, 0.045367531478405, -0.02155998907983303, 0.01014314591884613, -0.024818502366542816, 0.010337145067751408, -0.004886359442025423, 0.026184868067502975, 0.020148834213614464, 0.0058196233585476875, -0.030093038454651833, 0.009461848996579647, -0.018276257440447807, 0.041916899383068085, -0.021562375128269196, 0.0001511338195996359, -0.006997725460678339, 0.027670545503497124, 0.05819612368941307, -0.030311860144138336, -0.020446503534913063, 0.061498574912548065, -0.014412795193493366, 0.02590077742934227, 0.038583092391490936, -0.031964510679244995, 0.017760714516043663, 0.043172407895326614, 0.009673649445176125, -0.04754115268588066, 0.036308422684669495, -0.010683305561542511, 0.06177084520459175, 0.0010916026076301932, 0.03491824120283127, -0.010764176957309246, -0.03718123957514763, -0.005026387516409159, 0.027736082673072815, -0.032788317650556564, -0.04324182868003845, -0.04838100075721741, 0.019232988357543945, 0.01689024642109871, 0.005755809135735035, -0.009394247084856033, -0.00019474353757686913, 0.01211064588278532, 0.018184898421168327, 0.04798294976353645, 0.0013635564828291535, -0.021032292395830154, -0.02362401783466339, 0.05293833091855049, 0.03490111231803894, 0.008918250910937786, -0.02588794380426407, 0.0582098662853241, -0.040225088596343994, -0.002837204607203603, -0.0003585296799428761, 0.019808603450655937, 0.009043237194418907, -0.002700820565223694, 0.03580878674983978, 0.020423244684934616, -0.05195734649896622, 0.040311601012945175, 0.01405224110931158, 0.024399861693382263, 0.006250117439776659, -0.06680212169885635, -0.05784403905272484, 0.028070181608200073, 0.044710610061883926, 0.015657905489206314, -0.058343157172203064, 0.01134507916867733, 0.004496827255934477, 0.02652573585510254, 0.024387074634432793, 0.031434565782547, 0.012274817563593388, 0.03249497339129448, 0.013345255516469479, 0.03847573325037956, 0.006743855774402618, -0.01959860324859619, 0.000875504279974848, -0.02720426581799984, -0.0797252506017685, 0.031838126480579376, 0.012099419720470905, 0.013194077648222446, -0.023483091965317726, 0.01490760501474142, -0.023302389308810234, -0.008672287687659264, 0.013662409037351608, -0.0052983579225838184, -0.029181895777583122, 0.0836128294467926, 0.008840247057378292, 0.010597266256809235, 0.04923415556550026, -0.017769861966371536, 0.037591852247714996, 0.046717096120119095, 0.05473383143544197, -0.008329504169523716, -0.010642820037901402, 0.024984249845147133, -0.03180195018649101, 0.001421967870555818, -0.006036789156496525, -0.0275025125592947, -0.003563256235793233, -0.016420098021626472, -0.010952094569802284, 0.017722617834806442, 0.009945545345544815, 0.014270404353737831, 0.025953954085707664, 0.06155398115515709, -0.03844744339585304, -0.06286801397800446, -0.08590815961360931, 0.0031234112102538347, 0.01577061414718628, -0.01250541303306818, -0.008488894440233707, -0.003901407588273287, 0.04186319187283516, -0.03536659851670265, -0.03139795735478401, -0.0018050448270514607, 0.01840701699256897, 0.04380675405263901, -0.03102288581430912, -0.008392076008021832, 0.0427369624376297, 0.020387692376971245, -0.03892676532268524, 0.05249002203345299, -0.0217463169246912, -0.05677167326211929, -0.021901080384850502, -0.00019055108714383096, 0.029020069167017937, -0.007287174928933382, -0.01489964034408331, -0.031740862876176834, -0.028154727071523666, -0.022699937224388123, 0.03690366446971893, -0.07001499831676483, 0.10679499059915543, 0.03982669115066528, -0.025807490572333336, 0.004941995721310377, 0.0286113228648901, 0.0526815690100193, 0.008908205665647984, 0.027007952332496643, -0.04329429566860199, -0.007170958910137415, -0.034309811890125275, 0.06550668179988861, 0.030993415042757988, 0.015413784421980381, 0.0023570340126752853, 0.036630481481552124, 0.04993443936109543, 0.02288360334932804, 0.027091991156339645, 0.013528356328606606, -0.009347567334771156, 0.01633632183074951, 0.022921385243535042, -0.013352078385651112, 0.07213351130485535, 0.03422345221042633, -0.04113827645778656, 0.0068847122602164745, 0.012033558450639248, -0.03459756821393967, 0.0066163609735667706, -0.011499295011162758, 0.030324626713991165, 0.012487495318055153, -0.03655662760138512, 0.009254124015569687, -0.053694628179073334, 0.02659926749765873, 0.010896001942455769, 0.0047200643457472324, 0.01267585065215826, -0.024872753769159317, -0.03616528958082199, -0.00934880692511797, 0.04644067585468292, -0.07044384628534317, -0.0006483012111857533, 0.02851831167936325, 0.0070595876313745975, 0.028264444321393967, -0.0539374053478241, -0.03379145264625549, -0.03570938855409622, -0.002054465003311634, 0.0005254899733699858, 0.0100214509293437, 0.00897062849253416, -0.013027237728238106, -0.011515799909830093, 0.006395026110112667, -0.00496683781966567, 0.03461330756545067, 0.051015373319387436, -0.04340207576751709, 0.0048922025598585606, -0.0398176908493042, 0.006239841692149639, 0.03603329882025719, 0.005177855957299471, 0.004464165307581425, 0.010875850915908813, 0.01117496658116579, -0.05221592262387276, -0.040391623973846436, -0.04504762217402458, 0.006810425780713558, 0.01993328146636486, -0.0009276386117562652, 0.04139325022697449, 0.032430242747068405, -0.041193053126335144, -0.0014353005681186914, -0.007589844521135092, -0.05185433849692345, 0.016894754022359848, -0.02733989618718624, -0.0036255791783332825, -0.0351572148501873, 0.008525582030415535, 0.049349330365657806, -0.05236075818538666, -0.013385049998760223, -0.03220871463418007, -0.07443800568580627, 0.04045679792761803, -0.023958608508110046, 0.042356617748737335, -0.0033539319410920143, 0.031248699873685837, 0.06263074278831482, 0.037087250500917435, 0.030038736760616302, -0.040083661675453186, 0.0023540020920336246, 0.008606983348727226, -0.020797844976186752, 0.057007573544979095, 0.0495227575302124, -0.040499020367860794, 0.0057892631739377975, -0.016447817906737328, 0.029819142073392868, 0.041061729192733765, 0.008196316659450531, -0.00623729033395648, -0.00038568026502616704, 0.03235563635826111, -0.004711026791483164, 0.025148680433630943, 0.01697765290737152, -0.04630104452371597, -0.030930012464523315, -0.004621335305273533, 0.02586313523352146, 0.01782464049756527, -0.028636593371629715, 0.04817108437418938, -0.028226083144545555, 0.04091284051537514, 0.00972574669867754, 0.009846076369285583, 0.0085923932492733, 0.004331040661782026, -0.027735896408557892, 0.015065642073750496, -0.001779883517883718, -0.029452810063958168, -0.005718804895877838, 0.034829799085855484, 0.04140074551105499, 0.011213957332074642, 0.04880277067422867, 0.024865280836820602, -0.03434573858976364, 0.050054822117090225, -0.02336859330534935, -0.0031755934469401836, 0.02413819544017315, 0.045864805579185486, 0.01815159246325493, -0.013473703525960445, -0.0560617633163929, 0.010027160868048668, -0.042043544352054596, 0.012442747130990028, -0.015683714300394058, 0.036053501069545746, 0.008296285755932331, 0.019467990845441818, -0.022562552243471146, -0.013537932187318802, -0.04011743143200874, -0.013441468589007854, -0.06129540503025055, 0.012825291603803635, -0.014963211491703987, 0.0014396582264453173, -0.03229372203350067, -0.009045422077178955, 0.02948886714875698, -0.0059461635537445545, -0.02457263506948948, -0.008834322914481163, 0.015521194785833359, 0.018352750688791275, -0.0029516201466321945, -0.02655716985464096, -0.021946800872683525, 0.002595514291897416, -0.013456796295940876, 0.025216691195964813, 0.010096720419824123, 0.020836051553487778, -0.014452089555561543, 0.023787986487150192, -0.0572349950671196, -0.04191429913043976, -0.0072861844673752785, 0.06227285787463188, 0.020838765427470207, 0.004888519179075956, 0.009586095809936523, -0.05639515817165375, 0.00625592190772295, 0.014278043992817402, 0.008042741566896439, 0.03310171514749527, -0.008597294799983501, -0.01035306602716446, 0.0017481865361332893, -0.026321731507778168, 0.04622042179107666, 0.0036465947050601244, 0.01427178829908371, 0.01128578744828701, 0.049522511661052704, 0.004743278492242098, -0.03052915632724762, -0.03886336088180542, 0.06093326583504677, -0.02312435954809189, -0.011191668920218945, -0.0645713061094284, -0.024110089987516403, -0.0062791043892502785, 0.023247448727488518, 0.02401833049952984, 0.029914619401097298, 0.00999422837048769, -0.025754889473319054, 0.06171189993619919, -0.022815801203250885, -0.007516804616898298, 0.017076149582862854, -0.028103334829211235, 0.040690165013074875, 0.020550621673464775, 0.011724238283932209, 0.06758385896682739, 0.05049758777022362, 0.03565923124551773, 0.06517769396305084, 0.003788570174947381, -0.05372437462210655, -0.02122635394334793, 0.03910351172089577, 0.05636484920978546, -0.061099499464035034, -0.017304137349128723, -0.02627410925924778, -0.020386703312397003, 0.06450675427913666, -0.015228868462145329, -0.02639329619705677, -0.05131806433200836, -0.015264098532497883, -0.018053019419312477, -0.05695732310414314, -0.021543655544519424, 0.022496530786156654, -0.003387819742783904, 0.012344740331172943, 0.013575328513979912, -0.0193947721272707, -0.05904107540845871, -0.015402731485664845, 0.007905093021690845, 0.07734378427267075, -0.05014887452125549, -0.020358489826321602, 0.013437262736260891, 0.00957548338919878, -0.024102983996272087, -0.08883576095104218, 0.030977580696344376, 0.01913263276219368, 0.016537517309188843, 0.052196308970451355, -0.006007946562021971, -0.021843692287802696, 0.00022774763056077063, -0.009706901386380196, -0.00823931209743023, 0.00203444785438478, -0.02466949261724949, 0.04425157606601715, 0.0022666151635348797, 0.013909975066781044, 0.05727169290184975, 0.04192197695374489, -0.03499896079301834, 0.012386210262775421, -0.015028020367026329, -0.0005155515391379595, -0.03769088163971901, -0.0014190713409334421, -0.054553061723709106, -0.04387741535902023, 0.01779874600470066, 0.012650093995034695, 0.0282275527715683, 0.015970665961503983, -0.011915482580661774, 0.0014071391196921468, 0.020063256844878197, 0.025813082233071327, 0.034436505287885666, -0.02351844310760498, 0.008938798680901527, -0.010330943390727043, 0.007789552211761475, -0.00037615379551425576, 0.025373777374625206, -0.011009075678884983, 0.01627168618142605, 0.034550733864307404, -0.052036941051483154, -0.015587080270051956, -0.012083781883120537, -0.056235529482364655, 0.024433912709355354, -0.0347394198179245, 0.0015334944473579526, -0.01951952651143074, -0.004771631211042404, -0.025214985013008118, -0.04264348745346069, 0.012382110580801964, 0.006405329797416925, -0.024376243352890015, 0.016672872006893158, -0.027286836877465248, -0.004752518143504858, 0.003914822358638048, 0.007971753366291523, -0.05552813410758972, -0.01942315511405468, 0.01474375557154417, -0.0016018643509596586, -0.029134973883628845, -0.026204412803053856, 0.0015828380128368735, -0.00044994393829256296, -0.029026329517364502, -0.013753843493759632, 0.07661709189414978, -0.009861796163022518, -0.00606749439612031, -0.023948488757014275, 0.007296056021004915, 0.07866998761892319, -0.034645307809114456, 0.01235022209584713, -0.0031137894839048386, -0.04191925749182701, 0.002571027260273695, -0.025409013032913208, -0.006351095158606768, -0.02112683840095997, -0.013617117889225483, -0.03256114572286606, 0.017672842368483543, -0.008408870548009872, -0.004075157921761274, -0.027560241520404816, 0.046910565346479416, -0.028551330789923668, 0.006940879859030247, -0.035515643656253815, 0.017274025827646255, 0.014980560168623924, 0.006766007747501135, -0.024487975984811783, 0.03997106850147247, 0.017984667792916298, -0.013474387116730213, 0.03271239623427391, 0.0027936515398323536, -0.03355823829770088, 0.022038718685507774, 0.019185299053788185, -0.029887394979596138, -0.014530161395668983, -0.01012180931866169, -0.036837924271821976, -0.006243967916816473, 0.030453423038125038, -0.010120628401637077, 0.011173627339303493, 0.001146018272265792, -0.015926554799079895, -0.004793139640241861, 0.006943580694496632, 0.04101124033331871, 0.055284060537815094, 0.02549760416150093, 0.06668966263532639, 0.06500805169343948, -0.021977458149194717, -0.011905219405889511, -0.003446335671469569, -0.0031142637599259615, 0.004868403077125549, -0.028856579214334488, 0.023109424859285355, -0.05167098715901375, -0.01312608364969492, 0.04184933006763458, 0.02656048908829689, 0.027360443025827408, 0.03948574140667915, 0.02611786499619484, 0.003677788656204939, 0.039822667837142944, -0.03355437517166138, -0.03406666964292526, 0.038410428911447525, -0.06584635376930237, -0.0010029833065345883, -0.03690309822559357, -0.02294333092868328, 0.0522533655166626, -0.020845938473939896, -0.027693361043930054, -0.018070852383971214, 0.010276696644723415, -0.01025424525141716, -0.005235224962234497, 0.04280490055680275, -0.009859209880232811, 0.04232155159115791, -0.058432843536138535, 0.011644227430224419, 0.005022536963224411, 0.006424950901418924, -0.003015169408172369, -0.06860633194446564, -0.061353228986263275, -0.047241535037755966, -0.05522696301341057, 0.028700686991214752, 0.009761781431734562, 0.0015802260022610426, -0.016524402424693108, -0.054229382425546646, -0.03213340789079666, -0.00044394040014594793, 0.0022777807898819447, 0.005957765970379114, 0.06773730367422104, 0.0569584034383297, 0.01654486544430256, 0.012589707970619202, -0.020789403468370438, 0.14893367886543274, 0.06404908746480942, 0.018575308844447136, -0.06032024696469307, 0.04501422122120857, -0.024899937212467194, 0.02020197920501232, 0.03178879991173744, 0.035672951489686966, -0.005010213702917099, -0.04402630031108856, 0.03562004119157791, 0.007424596697092056, 0.03505565598607063, -0.012208429165184498, 0.06437674909830093, -0.04130921512842178, -0.03500363230705261, -0.0027791878674179316, -0.018717661499977112, 0.019691096618771553, -0.011895453557372093, -0.027359075844287872, 0.004426180385053158, -0.0030741295777261257, -0.009347955696284771, -0.0031948192045092583, -0.0036736847832798958, -0.013216366060078144, 0.03745284676551819, -0.019541867077350616, -0.0031694089993834496, 0.020568784326314926, -0.030938366428017616, -0.020471036434173584, -0.015355551615357399, 0.006625020876526833, -0.024907724931836128, 0.010181015357375145, 0.029469531029462814, -0.010211802087724209, -0.02225499413907528, -0.015462378971278667, 0.03304319083690643, -0.05984625592827797, -0.011782133020460606, 0.009416205808520317, 0.0381338931620121, -0.028878815472126007, -0.02197088859975338, -0.024628812447190285, -0.04905160516500473, 0.018007321283221245, -0.05834503099322319, -0.019433867186307907, 0.028592994436621666, 0.04171270877122879, -0.01523213367909193, -0.0012432640651240945, 0.013504015281796455, 0.012922312133014202, -0.027881499379873276, 0.06399194151163101, 0.03523380681872368, -0.04064635559916496, -0.011144586838781834, -0.025933096185326576, -0.013522694818675518, 0.030458834022283554, -0.021897628903388977, 0.025891324505209923, 0.03673577308654785, -0.048454709351062775, 0.021780405193567276, -0.01578269526362419, -0.019182221964001656, 0.059868521988391876, -0.0204484760761261, -0.012331143021583557, -0.012666487134993076, -0.032114069908857346, 0.022750206291675568, -0.006230347324162722, 0.012527949176728725, -0.025547737255692482, -0.00961292628198862, 0.025830520316958427, 0.04705891013145447, -0.020256025716662407, 0.03375685214996338, 0.011471115052700043, 0.03047461248934269, 0.01134154200553894, -0.03083939477801323, -0.024351146072149277, -0.02834591455757618, -0.03739755228161812, -0.0238766148686409, -0.022833168506622314, 0.027698678895831108, -0.016111169010400772, 0.009985343553125858, 0.03374475613236427, 0.03999214619398117, -0.0032630241475999355, 0.01074235700070858, 0.016694065183401108, -0.0857396349310875, -0.009288367815315723, -0.006953269708901644, 0.015100239776074886, -0.05505868420004845, -0.03705338016152382, -0.06644242256879807, 0.007814978249371052, -0.023397007957100868, -0.0059685008600354195, 0.014191522262990475, -0.0013141946401447058, -0.013861195184290409, 0.007027719169855118, -0.028966398909687996, -0.010020323097705841, -0.047817278653383255, 0.001579112489707768, -0.02035394497215748, -0.029298581182956696, -0.016382934525609016, 0.006613312754780054, 0.025939539074897766, 0.02951645664870739, 0.010557294823229313, 0.002040679333731532, -0.03636154904961586, 0.01461572665721178, 0.03631679341197014, 0.009969277307391167, 0.00038556879735551775, -0.032344140112400055, -0.02725338749587536, 0.008435603231191635, -0.04040968418121338, -0.06830485910177231, -0.0130062410607934, -0.0064598917961120605, 0.004195897839963436, 0.013354349881410599, -0.023068351671099663, -0.021792924031615257, 0.04921736940741539, -0.026519592851400375, -0.053080808371305466, -0.02065632864832878, 0.021807126700878143, 0.018748054280877113, -0.009302005171775818, -0.01828584633767605, -0.013005527667701244, -0.03570600599050522, 0.03993728756904602, 0.01890486665070057, 0.034260254353284836, 0.0028352034278213978, -0.009881137870252132, 0.014313846826553345, 0.011680790223181248, 0.0029452452436089516, 0.01614784449338913, 0.024424608796834946, 0.04871664568781853, -0.04375176876783371, 0.06390909850597382, -0.004119224846363068, -0.0010246318997815251, -0.0692349374294281, -0.0012715866323560476, -0.006527386140078306, 0.007911975495517254, 0.02046641893684864, -0.03990117460489273, -0.01058642752468586, -0.005182016175240278, -0.05332360416650772, 0.046002842485904694, -0.013602386228740215, -0.01975950226187706, -0.06703882664442062, 0.002565588103607297, -0.03040100634098053, 0.034641508013010025, 0.016162250190973282, 0.011328956112265587, 0.01616944931447506, 0.011356653645634651, 0.012455152347683907, -0.04882597178220749, -0.008453117683529854, 0.011394047178328037, -0.007164929062128067, -0.028005948290228844, 0.006582207046449184, -0.03357778862118721, -0.04945940896868706, 0.030065657570958138, -0.003193349577486515, 0.03305160999298096, 0.01523527316749096, 0.061382029205560684, 0.003353154519572854, 0.03278200700879097, 0.051975805312395096, -0.009329454973340034, -0.011979622766375542, -0.025614451617002487, 0.03107980266213417, 0.054905422031879425, 0.0014703113120049238, 0.029947087168693542, 0.04021070525050163, -0.00017846317496150732, -0.004718977026641369, 0.004514392931014299, 0.021771907806396484, -0.025623539462685585, -0.019959263503551483, -0.04590995982289314, 0.000021468244085554034, 0.017378389835357666, 0.02228427119553089, -0.022686300799250603, 0.005541170481592417, 0.06304551661014557, 0.030423974618315697, 0.006740865297615528, 0.030421636998653412, -0.03014058992266655, 0.0010675884550437331, 0.012253385968506336, -0.003130513709038496, 0.03179800137877464, -0.046071700751781464, 0.015977246686816216, -0.005086916033178568, 0.003263618564233184, -0.02421475015580654, -0.019013280048966408, 0.008921278640627861, 0.0052350605838000774, 0.00024889741325750947, 0.001035935478284955, 0.01717340387403965, 0.018926694989204407, 0.019868502393364906, -0.04149262234568596, 0.06482971459627151, -0.009580650366842747, 0.012495043687522411, -0.05593118071556091, -0.02834274433553219, -0.04918403550982475, 0.03959807753562927, 0.055610403418540955, 0.02761644870042801, 0.0153719587251544, -0.01199751440435648, 0.022334406152367592, 0.025879118591547012, -0.0410236194729805, 0.05291520059108734, -0.011303250677883625, -0.007712312042713165, -0.011232574470341206, 0.025188621133565903, -0.015773706138134003, 0.028911981731653214, 0.008028686977922916, -0.00836105551570654, 0.0033941229339689016, 0.035543620586395264, 0.0005067500751465559, 0.028825270012021065, 0.023719942197203636, -0.007603599689900875, 0.010863560251891613, 0.002041053958237171, 0.023013509809970856, 0.03050323761999607, -0.024054475128650665, -0.07421672344207764, -0.020284559577703476, -0.03830451890826225, -0.002691814675927162, -0.00202258862555027, 0.0008972277864813805, -0.01609056629240513, -0.03861710801720619, 0.002187122590839863, 0.04094741865992546, -0.060584913939237595, -0.0003944766358472407, 0.02748481184244156, 0.05751067027449608, 0.017243055626749992, -0.005457755643874407, 0.02499404363334179, -0.02781476452946663, -0.006656745448708534, -0.027446553111076355, -0.012291479855775833, -0.017605546861886978, -0.03199424594640732, 0.04398491978645325, 0.03760302811861038, 0.01061143260449171, 0.024405715987086296, 0.037990085780620575, 0.09422653168439865, -0.017253205180168152, 0.021227490156888962, 0.010295683518052101, -0.008600444532930851, 0.036221642047166824, 0.00336642237380147, 0.02332298643887043, 0.03963969275355339, -0.0007265862077474594, -0.004512348212301731, -0.024478599429130554, -0.04657847806811333, -0.03096361830830574, -0.02859458141028881, 0.050179075449705124, 0.04086033254861832, -0.019505523145198822, -0.047994013875722885, -0.04277898371219635, -0.00727138901129365, 0.08368194103240967, 0.002807355485856533, 0.03400212526321411, -0.03570627421140671, -0.02231775037944317, -0.006007080432027578, -0.029021909460425377, -0.044901181012392044, -0.043941281735897064, -0.0017903964035212994, 0.008420169353485107, 0.054578036069869995, 0.006530755199491978, -0.017409304156899452, -0.0036070060450583696, 0.012488876469433308, -0.06521070748567581, -0.0010960707440972328, -0.01415353175252676, 0.0336378738284111, 0.030057288706302643, 0.0018548057414591312 ]
<p>The question states: </p> <blockquote> <p>Consider a set of random variables $X_i$, where $i=1,...n$. Each $X_i$ is normally distributed with mean $0$ and variance $1$, i.e. $X_i$ are $\mathcal N(0,1)$. What is the mean and the variance of the random variable $Y$, where $Y=X_1+...+X_n$.</p> </blockquote> <p>How do I do this?</p>
37,023
[ -0.04174622893333435, 0.004161412362009287, -0.023130562156438828, -0.025250550359487534, 0.026167837902903557, 0.013244321569800377, -0.017774047330021858, -0.025170395150780678, 0.0203980915248394, -0.020215364173054695, 0.05240330845117569, 0.0465414859354496, 0.08422094583511353, 0.030458500608801842, 0.0309174582362175, 0.010708513669669628, -0.03081733174622059, 0.026474667713046074, 0.00493956170976162, -0.02031409554183483, -0.0050367810763418674, 0.024432331323623657, 0.05417785421013832, -0.012343399226665497, -0.014498449862003326, 0.056594233959913254, 0.0318128876388073, -0.016523510217666626, 0.017931941896677017, 0.07378185540437698, 0.007913636043667793, -0.04373743757605553, 0.029154539108276367, 0.05052453279495239, -0.013038534671068192, -0.011901319026947021, -0.019305560737848282, -0.035768307745456696, 0.020644674077630043, 0.025451811030507088, -0.04875345528125763, -0.03505989909172058, 0.03109917975962162, 0.027003543451428413, -0.03324337303638458, 0.01733480393886566, -0.02504745125770569, -0.03404558077454567, 0.009853015653789043, -0.041034094989299774, 0.09143522381782532, -0.007110698148608208, 0.07662828266620636, 0.03572794795036316, -0.016387660056352615, 0.0053609199821949005, 0.032180432230234146, 0.05803500488400459, 0.022528113797307014, -0.05247671157121658, -0.0063301753252744675, -0.01665586233139038, -0.008673573844134808, -0.021278100088238716, -0.056000519543886185, 0.0011941727716475725, -0.010069215670228004, -0.03663332387804985, 0.01818651705980301, -0.0080683259293437, 0.015075745061039925, 0.0505746454000473, 0.04036685824394226, -0.017294924706220627, -0.019313154742121696, -0.01738779805600643, 0.019332803785800934, 0.01579444110393524, 0.038844238966703415, 0.038250040262937546, 0.023534156382083893, 0.017937997356057167, 0.0504138246178627, 0.0023445168044418097, -0.024513419717550278, -0.007952003739774227, 0.10008766502141953, 0.035062275826931, 0.014448831789195538, 0.01568494364619255, 0.020117640495300293, 0.000376663520000875, 0.04844578355550766, -0.025364305824041367, -0.0612255297601223, 0.0445307157933712, -0.02408626303076744, 0.027301043272018433, 0.0390508659183979, -0.01659584604203701, 0.002654808107763529, -0.037425484508275986, 0.04288876801729202, 0.05484262481331825, -0.0279814712703228, 0.013996707275509834, -0.0014045420102775097, 0.017017873004078865, -0.015420978888869286, -0.006127478554844856, 0.008313743397593498, 0.014878720976412296, -0.018079061061143875, -0.015374040231108665, 0.022949276491999626, 0.020746663212776184, -0.0040256548672914505, -0.004502971190959215, 0.029738575220108032, 0.057198040187358856, 0.03714198246598244, -0.014683608897030354, 0.03778785094618797, 0.0006469454965554178, -0.050451476126909256, -0.0041618044488132, 0.004983132239431143, 0.004443303216248751, -0.04838050901889801, 0.06338100880384445, -0.008337927982211113, -0.026154890656471252, 0.008436011150479317, 0.0007006973028182983, 0.0511428564786911, 0.012474979273974895, -0.07190034538507462, -0.058151744306087494, 0.032783620059490204, -0.03843194991350174, -0.011443870142102242, -0.06580626219511032, 0.018593771383166313, 0.047319211065769196, 0.0300845205783844, -0.0031629668083041906, 0.049458179622888565, 0.03862214833498001, 0.012719327583909035, 0.008255081251263618, -0.0076860771514475346, -0.031985919922590256, -0.009209432639181614, -0.025762181729078293, -0.01914040371775627, -0.05866880714893341, 0.02762388437986374, 0.02493877522647381, -0.024271193891763687, -0.03714611753821373, 0.034889668226242065, -0.019254466518759727, 0.029795177280902863, -0.007108656223863363, 0.014726676978170872, -0.023459648713469505, 0.07243859767913818, 0.03516096621751785, 0.0035751427058130503, 0.039062418043613434, 0.0010800478048622608, 0.012771951965987682, 0.0030540996231138706, 0.03218686953186989, 0.07324369996786118, -0.03299107402563095, -0.017581915482878685, -0.014906151220202446, -0.007102471776306629, 0.049474745988845825, -0.015314494259655476, -0.005698245484381914, -0.0126161715015769, -0.011541363783180714, 0.03307977318763733, 0.03783878684043884, 0.017181815579533577, -0.00916146021336317, -0.01543239876627922, -0.0043155294843018055, -0.019637390971183777, -0.09222331643104553, 0.004526297561824322, -0.0226553063839674, -0.03541935980319977, 0.008248627185821533, 0.009278514422476292, 0.02469211257994175, -0.004633041564375162, -0.037156250327825546, 0.0009797143284231424, 0.00574319064617157, 0.04381829872727394, -0.04283097758889198, -0.0042122043669223785, 0.062465619295835495, 0.062108516693115234, -0.005299412179738283, 0.04476049542427063, -0.011026252061128616, -0.011900010518729687, -0.0045969667844474316, -0.020624054595828056, -0.000145276659168303, 0.010606260970234871, -0.009333005174994469, 0.025497183203697205, 0.002513360232114792, 0.021916743367910385, 0.025079715996980667, -0.03275679424405098, 0.04133923724293709, 0.062051355838775635, 0.016162127256393433, -0.010694419965147972, 0.01056468952447176, 0.03308399021625519, 0.001286545768380165, -0.015803087502717972, -0.02113720215857029, -0.030412951484322548, 0.0045578801073133945, 0.01945115067064762, 0.036102987825870514, -0.04599124565720558, -0.001715460093691945, 0.08462300896644592, 0.03381875902414322, 0.008627025410532951, 0.032435305416584015, -0.014512722380459309, 0.0021834003273397684, -0.012329960241913795, 0.026912659406661987, 0.00801258534193039, 0.017013125121593475, -0.018779559060931206, 0.0029715956188738346, 0.018258094787597656, 0.039135027676820755, -0.009212552569806576, 0.04105471819639206, 0.011216683313250542, 0.02551962621510029, -0.026535673066973686, -0.02805010788142681, 0.030629033222794533, 0.005145106930285692, 0.008052610792219639, 0.01062805950641632, 0.006294875871390104, -0.01764562353491783, 0.0013604812556877732, -0.0046420325525105, 0.008486094884574413, 0.023850202560424805, -0.03377394378185272, -0.006997597869485617, 0.02010956220328808, -0.020341675728559494, 0.03427022323012352, -0.013743738643825054, -0.0566997155547142, -0.005679896101355553, -0.0272210780531168, 0.0014120963169261813, 0.0005480503896251321, -0.006578412372618914, -0.038179147988557816, -0.01724601536989212, -0.0364132784307003, -0.03542850539088249, 0.004496158100664616, -0.004641343839466572, -0.07163255661725998, 0.01779387891292572, -0.04441417381167412, -0.01072006206959486, 0.015263593755662441, -0.010671465657651424, 0.005808929447084665, 0.06785714626312256, -0.011332599446177483, -0.04809640347957611, -0.01874346099793911, -0.0750676617026329, 0.03534741699695587, -0.0472588911652565, -0.036000560969114304, 0.02410702407360077, 0.002180499490350485, -0.04573865607380867, 0.027958186343312263, -0.04678376764059067, -0.05588376522064209, -0.059668391942977905, -0.018909331411123276, 0.02689606323838234, 0.0004051878349855542, 0.029858099296689034, 0.032140761613845825, -0.047320328652858734, -0.007296586409211159, -0.06457693129777908, -0.06443941593170166, 0.002957466058433056, -0.007049081847071648, 0.031481195241212845, 0.0049672843888401985, -0.03303814306855202, 0.06679733842611313, 0.016880422830581665, -0.004712623078376055, -0.04038997367024422, 0.02797693945467472, 0.021830786019563675, -0.0482182502746582, 0.05046916753053665, 0.020536093041300774, -0.011410471983253956, 0.032916851341724396, 0.02492198720574379, 0.016707994043827057, 0.06808651983737946, 0.006223582196980715, -0.0039917840622365475, -0.022568129003047943, -0.003901296528056264, 0.0328768789768219, 0.045379772782325745, 0.006704247090965509, -0.010548795573413372, -0.002241723705083132, -0.004029921721667051, 0.03769199922680855, 0.005629791412502527, -0.019802868366241455, 0.04453659430146217, -0.011358180083334446, 0.00974228885024786, -0.04081135615706444, 0.07805933803319931, 0.015545469708740711, -0.0017693685367703438, -0.008220735937356949, 0.00782726239413023, -0.0068700904957950115, -0.04476165398955345, 0.025244195014238358, 0.03839986398816109, 0.04380906745791435, -0.04093759134411812, -0.055347587913274765, -0.009560584090650082, -0.025140417739748955, 0.020787522196769714, -0.016520334407687187, -0.02240661531686783, 0.023063449189066887, 0.038267310708761215, -0.01925886981189251, -0.015408080071210861, -0.020881135016679764, 0.007081118877977133, -0.07318434864282608, 0.012597420252859592, -0.004376727156341076, 0.01943797990679741, 0.012610440142452717, 0.07263453304767609, 0.010050148703157902, -0.011993580497801304, 0.02778199128806591, -0.018450215458869934, -0.0625506192445755, 0.023911837488412857, -0.01402661856263876, -0.035089027136564255, -0.019414842128753662, -0.018952401354908943, 0.04188152030110359, -0.028084464371204376, 0.03892135992646217, 0.01192058902233839, -0.006709900218993425, -0.04263249784708023, -0.002461810130625963, -0.02378852479159832, -0.02419389598071575, 0.020512109622359276, 0.04636606201529503, 0.029946668073534966, -0.03545145317912102, 0.029871778562664986, 0.026896169409155846, 0.019497232511639595, -0.03704706206917763, -0.02136722020804882, -0.0004044039233122021, 0.0053391233086586, 0.02450900711119175, 0.012356864288449287, 0.03431769087910652, -0.019198859110474586, 0.05250975117087364, -0.017249297350645065, 0.04460621997714043, 0.027442287653684616, 0.006804376840591431, -0.0016210094327107072, -0.0319913886487484, -0.005217279773205519, 0.0014451270690187812, 0.004299538675695658, 0.011317858472466469, 0.007870800793170929, 0.06742559373378754, 0.05239362269639969, -0.05695958435535431, 0.016580237075686455, 0.0582004077732563, 0.01401678379625082, 0.007162027060985565, -0.01647593453526497, 0.021611543372273445, -0.05713583528995514, -0.012004245072603226, 0.039634350687265396, -0.004853542894124985, -0.020299766212701797, 0.014623832888901234, 0.059711817651987076, -0.025342116132378578, -0.005996964406222105, -0.014194963499903679, 0.001275892835110426, 0.04494428262114525, 0.026290053501725197, -0.04181664437055588, -0.006868257187306881, 0.04415405914187431, 0.017152821645140648, 0.014503230340778828, -0.029886651784181595, -0.0425102598965168, -0.02872442454099655, 0.02746516652405262, 0.04333503171801567, -0.02095477283000946, 0.021055903285741806, -0.026222702115774155, -0.007841541431844234, 0.05423577502369881, -0.04099784418940544, 0.03306369483470917, -0.03662995621562004, -0.003449643263593316, 0.030922504141926765, -0.015688348561525345, -0.07935774326324463, 0.011907655745744705, 0.01212385669350624, 0.04291169345378876, -0.009804108180105686, 0.000714294845238328, -0.029039233922958374, -0.0010993138421326876, 0.0031210328452289104, 0.09907474368810654, -0.021365830674767494, 0.011211730539798737, 0.0011767609976232052, 0.042318299412727356, 0.004285203758627176, -0.08351275324821472, 0.043665166944265366, 0.047232478857040405, -0.018407631665468216, 0.035939812660217285, -0.03908681124448776, -0.06903506815433502, 0.03711603954434395, -0.007724524009972811, -0.01449949573725462, 0.03778741881251335, -0.011845202185213566, 0.06923791766166687, 0.06474940478801727, 0.02366785891354084, 0.08139461278915405, 0.014817234128713608, 0.0010447270469740033, -0.0064268228597939014, -0.012955708429217339, -0.0007857551681809127, -0.02899896167218685, -0.037948913872241974, -0.02933686040341854, -0.014159775339066982, 0.008369402028620243, 0.032313764095306396, -0.018352454528212547, 0.023236382752656937, 0.012870494276285172, -0.018816564232110977, 0.003747037146240473, 0.006001110654324293, 0.0012261412339285016, -0.0259518064558506, 0.007244584616273642, 0.01868567056953907, 0.026649335399270058, -0.030677707865834236, 0.024868497624993324, -0.031017275527119637, -0.002267143689095974, 0.015425555408000946, -0.021655559539794922, -0.014686799608170986, -0.026671605184674263, -0.03422729671001434, -0.013452336192131042, -0.03297022357583046, 0.04876580834388733, -0.020636234432458878, 0.03800224885344505, 0.0076197292655706406, -0.04550737142562866, -0.013998695649206638, -0.001953864935785532, 0.0140985744073987, 0.0077703264541924, -0.048621971160173416, 0.02473149076104164, -0.014700530096888542, 0.0012425485765561461, -0.06465218216180801, -0.03675699234008789, 0.008623507805168629, 0.012142677791416645, 0.025340823456645012, -0.04745929688215256, 0.021921547129750252, -0.002811402315273881, -0.02127288654446602, -0.020155159756541252, 0.004634350072592497, -0.02835245430469513, -0.027975594624876976, 0.01400698535144329, 0.015196672640740871, 0.0727868303656578, -0.026069192215800285, 0.01073681004345417, 0.025719139724969864, -0.030517831444740295, -0.02780112251639366, -0.002740570344030857, 0.003631524508818984, -0.035056404769420624, -0.0005195616977289319, -0.021002162247896194, -0.022228719666600227, 0.04185980185866356, -0.039736900478601456, -0.0031777757685631514, 0.0116856899112463, -0.006800021976232529, -0.017167212441563606, -0.03709394484758377, 0.003501231549307704, 0.006109890528023243, 0.011936970055103302, -0.01190846785902977, 0.002978747943416238, -0.004118837416172028, 0.008668050169944763, 0.03195290267467499, 0.015388929285109043, 0.007721594534814358, 0.014101491309702396, 0.07657947391271591, 0.0033025601878762245, -0.026711268350481987, 0.0060417805798351765, 0.006232381798326969, 0.04164033383131027, 0.015503416769206524, -0.006344316061586142, 0.015972137451171875, -0.004550564102828503, -0.020957492291927338, -0.03005223348736763, -0.029339410364627838, -0.011441961862146854, 0.06888376176357269, -0.03207865357398987, 0.04431005194783211, 0.027977079153060913, 0.010118095204234123, 0.00422639399766922, -0.00487513467669487, 0.003921641036868095, -0.0021817905362695456, 0.0024408374447375536, 0.06541961431503296, -0.007525267079472542, 0.012297012843191624, 0.02446054480969906, 0.019147126004099846, 0.010163112543523312, 0.0203921627253294, -0.011106683872640133, -0.021379349753260612, 0.02403632365167141, -0.00674602622166276, -0.03607729449868202, 0.020127829164266586, -0.04869681969285011, 0.002517098793759942, -0.021977530792355537, -0.046079255640506744, 0.04172921180725098, 0.004905806854367256, -0.007508089765906334, -0.02192012220621109, -0.014211263507604599, -0.035016018897295, -0.023017602041363716, -0.0010227147722616792, -0.008314050734043121, 0.019803188741207123, 0.02162305638194084, 0.001243291306309402, -0.03246581181883812, 0.01127995178103447, -0.039070893079042435, -0.10159359127283096, -0.01038008090108633, 0.0065515311434865, -0.03317807614803314, 0.01621459424495697, 0.0124976160004735, -0.004802142735570669, 0.0358128622174263, -0.02307859994471073, 0.0074684275314211845, -0.015232497826218605, 0.016235919669270515, -0.041818223893642426, 0.08158306777477264, 0.010426364839076996, 0.058909229934215546, 0.009285418316721916, 0.01984313502907753, 0.08562708646059036, 0.04005466774106026, 0.04091385006904602, -0.08380421996116638, 0.01534831989556551, -0.014184637926518917, -0.026474136859178543, -0.014858313836157322, 0.018160380423069, 0.028757698833942413, 0.02584710717201233, 0.01790955848991871, 0.05013483390212059, 0.006784231401979923, -0.015359166078269482, 0.03379451483488083, -0.044438477605581284, -0.03352256119251251, 0.0028958884067833424, 0.0076262447983026505, 0.021929476410150528, 0.01974634639918804, -0.06599868834018707, 0.039917752146720886, -0.014468423090875149, -0.029675835743546486, -0.049956247210502625, -0.015537397935986519, 0.015011019073426723, 0.015198067761957645, 0.022651448845863342, 0.00393970962613821, 0.021598713472485542, -0.03917161375284195, -0.024231543764472008, -0.028317853808403015, 0.025444747880101204, -0.023527618497610092, 0.017125103622674942, 0.01981179043650627, 0.016809063032269478, 0.014886394143104553, 0.017141854390501976, -0.023546013981103897, -0.05667674541473389, -0.009265749715268612, -0.016224194318056107, 0.028989316895604134, -0.03403005376458168, 0.030755940824747086, -0.017215050756931305, 0.00822871271520853, -0.012755089439451694, -0.060088347643613815, -0.022032547742128372, 0.05253467708826065, 0.04462060332298279, -0.0344998836517334, -0.006901177577674389, -0.027036692947149277, 0.014076595194637775, -0.03412213176488876, 0.05494385212659836, 0.01791675016283989, -0.049336936324834824, -0.004795981105417013, -0.04076698049902916, 0.038473449647426605, 0.008040240034461021, -0.018541913479566574, -0.016851579770445824, -0.053386639803647995, -0.0030798122752457857, 0.0017758040921762586, 0.029281649738550186, -0.033446054905653, 0.020109103992581367, 0.015180611051619053, 0.007307042367756367, 0.015214111655950546, -0.04605371877551079, 0.004492275882512331, -0.02347988449037075, 0.005576987285166979, -0.050892870873212814, -0.007558607030659914, 0.018703291192650795, 0.041635990142822266, 0.010915101505815983, -0.013753952458500862, 0.022083893418312073, 0.07544511556625366, 0.026268424466252327, -0.027823131531476974, -0.011266498826444149, -0.008546460419893265, -0.02004757709801197, 0.006711548659950495, -0.021742867305874825, 0.06235218420624733, 0.03240373358130455, 0.021089158952236176, 0.010768621228635311, 0.0448286347091198, -0.026792651042342186, -0.007710771169513464, 0.002506461227312684, -0.05495346710085869, 0.020161285996437073, 0.02053438313305378, 0.039763204753398895, -0.016820570454001427, -0.005843683145940304, 0.002867785282433033, -0.010896633379161358, 0.04583355039358139, -0.003827315289527178, -0.03477570414543152, -0.01097925379872322, 0.0003197108453605324, 0.030167385935783386, -0.025925830006599426, -0.0048426976427435875, -0.010574812069535255, 0.0026711816899478436, 0.010514270514249802, -0.01630009151995182, -0.029540972784161568, 0.023130815476179123, -0.013087879866361618, -0.0049065109342336655, 0.05470971390604973, 0.01745007187128067, 0.04463600367307663, -0.019202571362257004, -0.021519070491194725, -0.013754142448306084, 0.04831073433160782, -0.03952034190297127, -0.01840820722281933, 0.07780713587999344, -0.0494927316904068, 0.017196007072925568, 0.011053605936467648, 0.0479363277554512, 0.03474074602127075, 0.0169752836227417, -0.021444503217935562, -0.061888985335826874, 0.033044908195734024, -0.034100696444511414, 0.00464889220893383, -0.03380127623677254, 0.01185059454292059, 0.00027479109121486545, -0.019085697829723358, 0.005465562455356121, 0.026426341384649277, 0.00690711522474885, -0.003368109930306673, 0.04949675127863884, -0.03833256661891937, -0.0056207929737865925, 0.025653276592493057, 0.02561391331255436, 0.0006184648373164237, 0.008187630213797092, -0.006574121303856373, 0.010597803629934788, 0.041891757398843765, -0.04032991826534271, 0.0032588925678282976, -0.0489729568362236, -0.019373362883925438, -0.07129141688346863, -0.014161510393023491, 0.02532842569053173, -0.02156919613480568, 0.03026389516890049, -0.06474202126264572, 0.012318458408117294, 0.012798558920621872, -0.04105668142437935, -0.0018783705309033394, 0.003888104110956192, -0.03419942408800125, -0.04096706211566925, 0.04171670973300934, 0.0006849319906905293, 0.0025215991772711277, -0.00039126185583882034, 0.06289027631282806, 0.025152290239930153, 0.022640112787485123, -0.001489934278652072, -0.019108997657895088, -0.011235632002353668, -0.031887345016002655, 0.01949363946914673, -0.04458123445510864, 0.020310353487730026, -0.043984465301036835, -0.03363523632287979, 0.03164294734597206, -0.007003181613981724, 0.005501310341060162, 0.0054855975322425365, 0.02099132537841797, -0.0022211147006601095, 0.03540438786149025, -0.008701651357114315, 0.012660746462643147, -0.002465059282258153, -0.011264694854617119, 0.04385301098227501, 0.0059494697488844395, -0.008735591545701027, -0.038471318781375885, 0.03431734815239906, 0.011724605225026608, -0.041568636894226074, 0.023848632350564003, 0.002000422216951847, -0.041419874876737595, 0.02662503905594349, -0.019978223368525505, 0.0037460632156580687, -0.07637152075767517, 0.005315342918038368, -0.022987017408013344, -0.020292578265070915, 0.013829740695655346, 0.02972538396716118, -0.04436461627483368, -0.01623663119971752, 0.011843512766063213, -0.032449427992105484, -0.013313503935933113, -0.009187632240355015, -0.016360213980078697, -0.06909297406673431, -0.009452352300286293, 0.044018879532814026, 0.01691736839711666, -0.007425315212458372, -0.07090569287538528, -0.03208895027637482, -0.00022005129721947014, 0.0028755066450685263, 0.05118895322084427, -0.013177253305912018, -0.0356595404446125, -0.02004111558198929, -0.07550796866416931, 0.03430292010307312, 0.05162734165787697, -0.007813685573637486, -0.050330642610788345, 0.0002569007920101285, -0.055968109518289566, -0.01945536397397518, 0.06088096648454666, -0.004640933591872454, -0.013728128746151924, 0.010671351104974747, 0.046222228556871414, 0.020555546507239342, -0.023820623755455017, 0.03653143718838692, -0.043712884187698364, -0.05643637105822563, -0.024450983852148056, -0.024425895884633064, 0.02279442362487316, 0.020607780665159225, 0.02377818152308464, -0.004763592034578323, -0.014462062157690525, -0.03011326864361763, 0.004296815954148769, 0.008939866907894611, 0.00347714452072978, -0.013608008623123169, 0.02937239222228527, -0.023860357701778412, -0.02519828826189041, 0.02667180262506008, 0.01514322217553854, -0.06450936198234558, -0.019630368798971176, -0.05366818606853485, -0.015513181686401367, -0.028628427535295486, 0.010416778735816479, 0.010163947939872742, -0.058277592062950134, -0.029751254245638847, 0.040990199893713, -0.02873370796442032, -0.0192573219537735, 0.056767065078020096, 0.03389973193407059, 0.053815826773643494, 0.004634078126400709, -0.007047244347631931, 0.01776139624416828, -0.013030552305281162, 0.0011680256575345993, 0.03528451919555664, 0.012430605478584766, -0.030865419656038284, 0.00442147022113204, 0.014732449315488338, -0.0024006443563848734, 0.05488032102584839, -0.009528445079922676, 0.033448778092861176, -0.020471971482038498, -0.01768864504992962, -0.007713099475950003, -0.03217606619000435, -0.009758963249623775, -0.007770373485982418, -0.014105887152254581, 0.0845765471458435, -0.025839881971478462, 0.018716484308242798, -0.009252135641872883, 0.007135647814720869, -0.0053817820735275745, -0.021347563713788986, -0.011227724142372608, 0.015900352969765663, -0.014422852545976639, -0.029074646532535553, -0.009723830036818981, -0.030590664595365524, 0.037555012851953506, -0.04064565151929855, 0.031276408582925797, -0.015020293183624744, 0.02911175787448883, -0.013222158886492252, -0.024082092568278313, -0.03946489468216896, -0.01702757738530636, 0.022808292880654335, 0.042584095150232315, 0.001466602785512805, -0.017858870327472687, 0.005988840013742447, -0.014447474852204323, 0.05303197354078293, -0.052626173943281174, -0.02033667266368866, -0.03855612128973007, -0.006756365764886141, 0.006110035814344883, -0.0430181585252285 ]
<p>This is a pretty basic question, but I can't find an answer by searching for different statements of the same problem.</p> <p>Is there a straightforward way to test if a regression parameter is different from a non-zero value in (non-) linear regression? I can only think of one way, but it seems too roundabout. Here's an example:</p> <pre><code>INPUT PROGRAM. LOOP #I = 1 TO 10. COMPUTE X = #I. COMPUTE Y = RV.NORMAL(5,1)+x*RV.NORMAL(4,1.5). END CASE. END LOOP. END FILE. END INPUT PROGRAM. dataset name exampleData WINDOW=front. EXECUTE. </code></pre> <p>Say I want to test if the slope from linear regression deviates from 3. The only way I know how in SPSS is NLR:</p> <pre><code>MODEL PROGRAM b0=5 b1=0. COMPUTE PRED_=b0 + (3+b1)*x. NLR Y /OUTFILE='C:\temp\SPSSFNLR.TMP' /PRED PRED_ /CRITERIA SSCONVERGENCE 1E-8 PCON 1E-8. </code></pre> <p>This will give you an estimate, std. error, and 95% CI for b1, but <em>no p value</em>. I also get a weird feeling that this method isn't statistically "correct". Does SPSS have a built-in test for this without resorting to NLR? Is there one that gives a p value?</p> <p>What if my regression model is non-linear? I suppose I can use the same approach as above, but how can I get a p value?</p> <p>EDIT: I would like to clarify that I am asking about more than just SPSS methodology. Although I'd love to get an SPSS-specific answer, I am also looking for a more general statistical method to a) get a p value from regression parameters from the estimate, std. error, and degrees of freedom and b) if there's a statistical test designed to test deviation of a regression parameter from a non-zero constant.</p>
44,244
[ -0.048747468739748, 0.0133457500487566, -0.028175193816423416, 0.022356603294610977, 0.007930107414722443, 0.026631485670804977, 0.00971917062997818, -0.027465250343084335, 0.02876736968755722, -0.02437468245625496, 0.028577974066138268, 0.04622790962457657, 0.038822513073682785, 0.002977381693199277, 0.029587076976895332, 0.019430791959166527, -0.008980931714177132, 0.02077377215027809, 0.023774009197950363, -0.007050962187349796, 0.012049129232764244, 0.017806561663746834, 0.02285703830420971, -0.004851402249187231, 0.005689921788871288, 0.0433482863008976, 0.015818661078810692, -0.024551181122660637, 0.01579606905579567, 0.04433242976665497, -0.004040890838950872, -0.038650110363960266, 0.02088526077568531, 0.018236465752124786, 0.0377272367477417, 0.012808497063815594, 0.005976391490548849, -0.021646110340952873, -0.019628487527370453, 0.0296216681599617, 0.016645876690745354, 0.017483338713645935, 0.03813615441322327, 0.0297977477312088, -0.00045376786147244275, 0.004635101184248924, -0.012602387927472591, 0.0007631659973412752, 0.058321841061115265, -0.05110348016023636, 0.05295731499791145, 0.004343990236520767, 0.023385463282465935, -0.011323009617626667, -0.0021328567527234554, 0.003026271006092429, 0.028289007022976875, 0.01624632626771927, -0.042121533304452896, -0.07192167639732361, -0.023029237985610962, -0.044951677322387695, 0.0023965477012097836, -0.0030056617688387632, -0.06595232337713242, -0.012032675556838512, -0.01757509633898735, -0.035244788974523544, 0.07306551188230515, 0.0015276967315003276, -0.009492408484220505, 0.0052809626795351505, 0.03534485772252083, -0.003086026757955551, 0.0020817636977881193, -0.036474015563726425, -0.022290516644716263, 0.013648610562086105, 0.018613139167428017, 0.07254737615585327, -0.023052698001265526, 0.00315734650939703, -0.004716141615062952, 0.05733443424105644, 0.03340195491909981, 0.009390786290168762, 0.06327124685049057, -0.0017912896582856774, 0.025023626163601875, 0.03467729687690735, 0.007568741217255592, -0.01106273103505373, 0.06865579634904861, 0.0005465249414555728, -0.030794836580753326, 0.03110722452402115, -0.008699897676706314, 0.06774257868528366, 0.007510767318308353, -0.012441237457096577, 0.013499586842954159, -0.03492235764861107, 0.017870619893074036, 0.024290962144732475, -0.026883073151111603, -0.0096729202196002, 0.0027703791856765747, 0.007556923199445009, -0.010455416515469551, -0.05603419244289398, -0.011560766957700253, 0.016266539692878723, 0.008289454504847527, -0.022486036643385887, 0.012071998789906502, -0.039830517023801804, -0.009610733948647976, -0.025707773864269257, 0.024569831788539886, 0.02920628897845745, 0.03467328101396561, -0.02863381803035736, 0.0005511006456799805, 0.0030389707535505295, -0.023028722032904625, 0.004200373776257038, 0.002081299666315317, -0.01585962437093258, -0.032779939472675323, 0.03315338119864464, 0.008363934233784676, -0.029704775661230087, 0.05401136726140976, 0.009171534329652786, 0.024259090423583984, 0.014459984377026558, -0.06861208379268646, -0.0815172791481018, 0.0030464394949376583, -0.002928687958046794, 0.008633812889456749, -0.05131809413433075, 0.001630609855055809, 0.029807906597852707, 0.06858452409505844, -0.008039421401917934, 0.03952054679393768, 0.004374296870082617, -0.0102261733263731, 0.01121572032570839, -0.039486274123191833, -0.020910294726490974, -0.003064626595005393, -0.05496961623430252, -0.029615117236971855, -0.0911201611161232, -0.003690076293423772, 0.0018918906571343541, -0.04115622118115425, -0.014727174304425716, 0.022672763094305992, 0.014785601757466793, -0.022155914455652237, 0.006068055983632803, 0.01946781948208809, -0.01691485568881035, 0.08759050816297531, 0.003731528762727976, 0.00419357605278492, 0.009532505646348, 0.002924001310020685, 0.011024273000657558, -0.009427573531866074, 0.025089658796787262, 0.055741507560014725, -0.029954399913549423, -0.010284911841154099, -0.007797068450599909, 0.02694944106042385, -0.00013159529771655798, -0.062296196818351746, -0.012984794564545155, -0.020291734486818314, 0.01403541024774313, 0.003426210954785347, 0.06515428423881531, -0.007521508261561394, -0.0007692711078561842, 0.05726257711648941, -0.050625842064619064, -0.039757177233695984, -0.0605141744017601, 0.02047255076467991, 0.05159406736493111, -0.02778862975537777, 0.014819221571087837, 0.0036948148626834154, 0.02491624653339386, 0.013514264486730099, -0.010852334089577198, -0.04659898579120636, -0.016316821798682213, 0.04066900908946991, -0.04950246214866638, 0.001992924837395549, 0.04080628976225853, 0.052962712943553925, -0.02582424506545067, 0.02104203961789608, -0.0324985608458519, -0.022793538868427277, 0.024257842451334, -0.0329090915620327, 0.0013044527731835842, -0.007221756968647242, -0.06884090602397919, 0.002115041483193636, 0.0026560937985777855, -0.01262822188436985, 0.026987159624695778, -0.02853980101644993, 0.060884371399879456, 0.04443728178739548, 0.023882513865828514, 0.003165904665365815, -0.029149748384952545, 0.039808034896850586, 0.016428034752607346, -0.02832239679992199, 0.030559515580534935, -0.03465895354747772, -0.013039466924965382, -0.016088364645838737, 0.02494129352271557, -0.039302315562963486, -0.0003009234496857971, 0.08539683371782303, 0.0026693404652178288, 0.026522133499383926, 0.032176945358514786, -0.01163976639509201, -0.013586415909230709, 0.014894837513566017, 0.037378229200839996, 0.04956600442528725, 0.04683258384466171, -0.004187655169516802, 0.06334910541772842, 0.06245750933885574, 0.012278301641345024, 0.0034917450975626707, 0.018638430163264275, 0.011135940439999104, -0.015540983527898788, 0.00008378689381061122, -0.007045522797852755, 0.026641566306352615, -0.0074165440164506435, -0.005352333653718233, 0.05021669715642929, -0.024283617734909058, -0.009736419655382633, -0.022333089262247086, -0.02489357255399227, 0.03720255196094513, 0.013236363418400288, -0.04450614005327225, -0.007557358127087355, 0.03799380734562874, -0.02978350594639778, 0.011316697113215923, -0.023911766707897186, -0.006367661524564028, -0.07255803048610687, 0.028004691004753113, 0.021237928420305252, 0.011634977534413338, 0.029896656051278114, -0.017998171970248222, 0.002960558282211423, 0.0018250985303893685, -0.02698732726275921, 0.012873122468590736, -0.04629077389836311, -0.05402528867125511, -0.01817960850894451, 0.011863132007420063, -0.03096526674926281, 0.02891954779624939, -0.02609187737107277, -0.00676801847293973, 0.05029419809579849, -0.02866467833518982, -0.03954010829329491, -0.015507894568145275, -0.04231029376387596, -0.011134501546621323, -0.001355753163807094, -0.026148827746510506, -0.010408046655356884, -0.010329823940992355, -0.04837704077363014, 0.04551178589463234, -0.038439903408288956, -0.011538691818714142, -0.02532763034105301, 0.008883511647582054, -0.01647954434156418, -0.02106204256415367, 0.033512961119413376, 0.010031769052147865, -0.0295037142932415, -0.007630756590515375, -0.052757710218429565, -0.040107931941747665, 0.008026110008358955, 0.039470329880714417, -0.00042711058631539345, -0.041049402207136154, -0.001701802364550531, 0.06660905480384827, 0.01476298738270998, -0.04031746834516525, -0.05926242470741272, 0.03381982445716858, -0.021489955484867096, 0.0018167906673625112, 0.014889807440340519, 0.0006913400138728321, 0.007662908174097538, -0.011265971697866917, -0.02929796278476715, 0.05493506044149399, 0.04870547354221344, 0.008661377243697643, 0.019022684544324875, 0.001255443668924272, -0.009339489042758942, -0.012961587868630886, 0.018275287002325058, 0.023158518597483635, 0.011533129960298538, 0.043420497328042984, 0.007990572601556778, 0.056739505380392075, 0.004569460637867451, -0.04170277714729309, 0.023629777133464813, -0.019920513033866882, 0.032376572489738464, -0.011653361842036247, 0.027434634044766426, -0.010218155570328236, -0.025565987452864647, 0.006614182610064745, 0.0016092336736619473, -0.011325797066092491, 0.002657284727320075, -0.01840703748166561, 0.04815756157040596, 0.00822922307997942, 0.0439198799431324, -0.0036283908411860466, -0.029279612004756927, -0.027648447081446648, -0.002687732456251979, -0.015344458632171154, -0.022012587636709213, 0.06650181859731674, 0.07352247834205627, 0.01621423289179802, -0.0015410068444907665, -0.051980894058942795, 0.0011632901150733232, -0.05842011421918869, -0.017297806218266487, -0.01660332828760147, 0.042629748582839966, 0.008908025920391083, 0.020546073094010353, -0.002201790688559413, 0.0017832615412771702, 0.022370005026459694, 0.01412904728204012, -0.08693049103021622, 0.04321299493312836, -0.002366142114624381, -0.029909783974289894, 0.008801108226180077, 0.013931244611740112, 0.008028163574635983, -0.07696036249399185, 0.023841965943574905, 0.029554301872849464, 0.0217390526086092, -0.03922704979777336, -0.005340938922017813, 0.0015334426425397396, 0.01773596927523613, -0.013396034017205238, 0.002342102350667119, 0.004633964970707893, -0.019757632166147232, 0.025950919836759567, 0.0380919873714447, -0.017537949606776237, -0.02120702713727951, -0.02230522222816944, 0.013972686603665352, -0.02239663153886795, 0.04874970018863678, 0.04986236244440079, 0.020683931186795235, -0.06351713836193085, 0.028948131948709488, -0.01801750436425209, 0.04297759383916855, 0.06270307302474976, 0.03431934118270874, -0.03909343481063843, -0.009509718976914883, 0.02323392778635025, -0.002265367191284895, 0.0006767176673747599, 0.008599470369517803, 0.020179400220513344, 0.046188030391931534, 0.029839182272553444, -0.04024858772754669, 0.04877149313688278, 0.0981329083442688, 0.017316732555627823, -0.017972072586417198, -0.0027631097473204136, -0.01210452988743782, 0.003939819056540728, -0.0030702517833560705, 0.009724191389977932, 0.013585724867880344, 0.019717399030923843, -0.020065568387508392, 0.04808128625154495, -0.012158416211605072, -0.018827926367521286, -0.010379532352089882, 0.024296658113598824, 0.0680827796459198, 0.040348123759031296, -0.05668913573026657, 0.036891110241413116, 0.03553834930062294, 0.02388087660074234, 0.03742779791355133, 0.007293959613889456, -0.09056007117033005, 0.011112300679087639, 0.056496746838092804, 0.024893734604120255, -0.03127936273813248, -0.027297966182231903, 0.00712095620110631, -0.018180960789322853, 0.0421464741230011, -0.0336514376103878, -0.0008298354805447161, -0.019763872027397156, 0.061913520097732544, -0.020671991631388664, -0.0036132747773081064, -0.060118112713098526, -0.00022364253527484834, -0.01767176017165184, 0.020783407613635063, -0.03991540148854256, -0.029017822816967964, -0.04919131472706795, -0.013863377273082733, 0.031074034050107002, 0.05078783631324768, -0.039920955896377563, -0.015148905105888844, 0.01774822734296322, 0.05659179762005806, -0.014501177705824375, -0.03899222984910011, 0.00542228389531374, -0.0034162516240030527, -0.022862864658236504, 0.03198321908712387, 0.01367984525859356, -0.037337526679039, 0.025401465594768524, -0.01976756751537323, -0.03134112060070038, 0.017788682132959366, -0.004531480837613344, 0.0406399704515934, 0.010110508650541306, 0.004687067586928606, 0.052160803228616714, 0.01933538168668747, 0.008092965930700302, -0.0393705777823925, -0.030195195227861404, 0.0008865703130140901, -0.004355747718364, -0.05491037294268608, -0.05004842206835747, 0.009020021185278893, -0.011684446595609188, 0.049973372370004654, 0.03550788760185242, -0.022564448416233063, -0.02735619619488716, 0.004665658809244633, -0.010964903049170971, 0.05011998116970062, 0.017263194546103477, 0.01434318907558918, -0.009484151378273964, -0.00008688195521244779, -0.0052891261875629425, -0.036188725382089615, 0.011508358642458916, 0.0029136252123862505, -0.012561864219605923, 0.033108700066804886, -0.05594264715909958, 0.0005622906028293073, 0.007347161415964365, -0.0195463914424181, -0.01683933474123478, -0.05782345309853554, -0.005847745109349489, 0.009212351404130459, 0.004505259916186333, -0.01611414924263954, -0.015119721181690693, 0.0128555279225111, 0.03637029975652695, 0.022547442466020584, 0.01082002092152834, -0.042873382568359375, 0.015324260108172894, -0.009523489512503147, -0.005868840496987104, -0.06865423917770386, -0.07711858302354813, 0.04728880897164345, 0.042664043605327606, -0.05157361924648285, -0.02210526540875435, -0.06428107619285583, 0.0035704681649804115, -0.02725408598780632, -0.02638598158955574, 0.06042562797665596, -0.016662530601024628, 0.008443409577012062, -0.0038031998556107283, 0.0039471471682190895, 0.06232482194900513, -0.007410770282149315, -0.01736188679933548, -0.004486922174692154, -0.00048577095731161535, -0.011140345595777035, 0.007309318520128727, -0.003719219472259283, -0.02988274022936821, 0.005349210929125547, -0.0317210890352726, -0.03326293081045151, 0.060571592301130295, 0.03316919878125191, -0.01538629550486803, -0.008720592595636845, -0.022781968116760254, -0.0006352582131512463, 0.008899467997252941, 0.00769776850938797, -0.07019871473312378, 0.005929283332079649, -0.0008108156034722924, -0.00914588663727045, 0.0013095746980980039, -0.0009770187316462398, 0.021642139181494713, 0.00949869304895401, -0.039249178022146225, 0.012784776277840137, 0.0869050845503807, 0.03578190505504608, 0.011287660337984562, -0.025524040684103966, 0.0016951271099969745, 0.03517215698957443, 0.06619689613580704, 0.008577417582273483, -0.011176631785929203, 0.01029062271118164, -0.019633585587143898, -0.014021818526089191, -0.009376264177262783, -0.017704658210277557, 0.06631375104188919, -0.009868131950497627, 0.05131377652287483, 0.03185037896037102, 0.013883682899177074, -0.033546704798936844, -0.027236102148890495, 0.009626518003642559, 0.010502837598323822, 0.017062325030565262, 0.0551825612783432, -0.005287150386720896, -0.024612771347165108, 0.037619780749082565, 0.035504672676324844, 0.021674837917089462, 0.05010904744267464, -0.00034849296207539737, 0.014523693360388279, 0.03916024789214134, -0.042420387268066406, -0.03747457638382912, 0.04567551612854004, -0.03951190412044525, 0.010392394848167896, -0.03830615058541298, -0.03861909732222557, 0.0020750868134200573, 0.03451913222670555, 0.019544607028365135, -0.04533298313617706, -0.03118474781513214, -0.047992024570703506, -0.002925973618403077, -0.004340586252510548, -0.029101205989718437, 0.01508447714149952, 0.020805498585104942, -0.0037036926951259375, -0.007430262863636017, 0.035675033926963806, -0.06707889586687088, -0.0531584657728672, -0.029110554605722427, -0.02810489386320114, 0.00306210876442492, 0.05347943305969238, 0.014397773891687393, -0.01616215892136097, 0.017559971660375595, -0.02730986289680004, 0.027136435732245445, 0.03154868260025978, 0.04953031614422798, 0.02617584355175495, 0.057012125849723816, -0.02339639700949192, -0.013535151258111, -0.01270807534456253, -0.005968995857983828, 0.12181244790554047, 0.10212579369544983, 0.030755404382944107, -0.05540643259882927, 0.008833673782646656, -0.0028188368305563927, -0.014133072458207607, -0.017896754667162895, 0.0027237790636718273, 0.034274421632289886, -0.03063780628144741, 0.055467694997787476, 0.06421628594398499, 0.025367822498083115, -0.012271416373550892, 0.05375105142593384, -0.015006151050329208, -0.005047922488301992, 0.019176211208105087, 0.009021958336234093, 0.012776194140315056, -0.047117650508880615, -0.04866987466812134, 0.002323210472241044, 0.0024099675938487053, 0.0033639553003013134, -0.05954942852258682, -0.01733190007507801, -0.0016631041653454304, -0.02431335300207138, -0.010144541971385479, -0.009190081618726254, -0.005869860295206308, 0.0014358420157805085, -0.03805943578481674, -0.02550884522497654, 0.02779274247586727, -0.04293559491634369, 0.02033105306327343, 0.03831826150417328, -0.014556008391082287, -0.009408063255250454, -0.01202202495187521, 0.02325304225087166, -0.03750060126185417, -0.010566863231360912, -0.044232189655303955, 0.06195174902677536, 0.006555731408298016, -0.05374371260404587, 0.008554943837225437, -0.013796504586935043, -0.020323676988482475, -0.04243655875325203, -0.02642723172903061, -0.026273854076862335, 0.004316173959523439, -0.0008043891284614801, -0.007888851687312126, -0.004524996504187584, -0.02218959853053093, 0.004216155037283897, 0.004595765843987465, 0.0488174706697464, -0.045486532151699066, -0.010063056834042072, 0.004676304291933775, 0.05198686569929123, -0.01529975701123476, -0.004264965187758207, 0.022778192535042763, -0.009100777097046375, -0.04279406741261482, -0.007903831079602242, 0.026162443682551384, 0.009926386177539825, 0.033589769154787064, -0.010536318644881248, -0.008711026981472969, -0.029197247698903084, -0.040935348719358444, 0.017822524532675743, -0.02151060849428177, 0.03149431198835373, -0.06535427272319794, 0.009561560116708279, 0.08264865726232529, 0.019800661131739616, 0.01858256384730339, 0.003279787953943014, -0.017668208107352257, 0.06647498905658722, -0.019725635647773743, -0.0703156515955925, -0.041538335382938385, 0.003603568533435464, -0.0555841401219368, 0.02934969589114189, -0.03230513259768486, 0.06085716933012009, -0.005550827365368605, 0.030852776020765305, -0.041325025260448456, 0.025387074798345566, 0.007136215455830097, 0.026047036051750183, -0.015010794624686241, -0.044836316257715225, -0.011583555489778519, 0.003967904020100832, 0.00025749928317964077, -0.00286867655813694, 0.027861764654517174, -0.0679580420255661, -0.017965709790587425, 0.039709288626909256, -0.0102744922041893, -0.028616109862923622, 0.04006974771618843, 0.0214029960334301, -0.030783722177147865, -0.03792886063456535, 0.0093571487814188, -0.025493275374174118, 0.00038157860399223864, 0.011801352724432945, -0.022552818059921265, -0.030677320435643196, -0.012577231973409653, -0.02348516136407852, -0.013559207320213318, 0.02386646904051304, 0.024948909878730774, 0.04063725471496582, 0.0012749115703627467, 0.01945560798048973, 0.011329712346196175, 0.04387250170111656, -0.025347374379634857, -0.01591586507856846, 0.01120908372104168, -0.05202404409646988, -0.0899529829621315, 0.041247524321079254, -0.0025094475131481886, 0.017256179824471474, -0.00423998199403286, 0.025320978835225105, -0.016825295984745026, 0.061153046786785126, 0.001026165671646595, -0.0016609299927949905, -0.03536404296755791, 0.012193678878247738, -0.02678016386926174, -0.015297004021704197, -0.006216114386916161, -0.008965532295405865, -0.023715129122138023, 0.02638142742216587, 0.03829490393400192, -0.04368910193443298, 0.026795439422130585, -0.0023045872803777456, -0.022016607224941254, -0.015372795052826405, 0.022143416106700897, -0.0016167234862223268, 0.012840844690799713, 0.00795014202594757, -0.013518387451767921, 0.010536886751651764, -0.011514926329255104, 0.02657490409910679, -0.07180343568325043, -0.019918296486139297, -0.014175190590322018, 0.03400483727455139, 0.0023692715913057327, -0.05192688852548599, 0.03052358515560627, 0.031148063018918037, -0.04378865659236908, -0.04619938135147095, -0.007382987067103386, 0.011008569970726967, -0.021851349622011185, 0.011684096418321133, -0.02749984711408615, 0.03464295715093613, 0.03164353221654892, 0.025369852781295776, 0.020167291164398193, 0.015930110588669777, 0.01646539755165577, -0.011018729768693447, 0.007960336282849312, 0.006901543587446213, 0.024631790816783905, -0.05527295172214508, 0.0005066745798103511, -0.03241867199540138, -0.02561071887612343, 0.022012853994965553, -0.024380957707762718, 0.03849105164408684, -0.0018332829931750894, 0.028271812945604324, -0.0036148643121123314, 0.06452862918376923, 0.029799217358231544, 0.0019630338065326214, -0.03528758883476257, 0.011824414134025574, -0.0036914178635925055, 0.03421739861369133, -0.06081555783748627, 0.015035376884043217, 0.00236686272546649, -0.007081327494233847, -0.03228401392698288, -0.011545296758413315, -0.023389562964439392, -0.029267996549606323, -0.0007843028870411217, -0.01072386372834444, 0.009960067458450794, -0.031126955524086952, 0.04628319665789604, -0.062087688595056534, 0.012740244157612324, 0.00010768223000923172, 0.04374207183718681, -0.05081627890467644, 0.0026709383819252253, 0.009740856476128101, -0.026446212083101273, 0.018550170585513115, -0.007635520305484533, -0.012546179816126823, -0.03975624591112137, -0.009996636770665646, -0.0028259626124054193, -0.031639114022254944, -0.0059487042017281055, -0.03115258552134037, -0.001760356593877077, 0.05101083591580391, -0.005861691199243069, -0.0017245111521333456, 0.022291067987680435, 0.004373652394860983, 0.03192823380231857, -0.0435069315135479, 0.08190152794122696, -0.008843392133712769, -0.009081030264496803, -0.03067859262228012, 0.018636465072631836, -0.0504128523170948, 0.0030347479041665792, 0.032266151160001755, -0.042451754212379456, 0.023242255672812462, 0.01077544130384922, 0.035531964153051376, -0.025253377854824066, -0.06098896637558937, 0.02040383592247963, 0.03424862027168274, -0.05209529027342796, -0.037279315292835236, -0.006786815822124481, 0.0018253021407872438, 0.0011947641614824533, 0.04510039836168289, 0.019678909331560135, 0.017419278621673584, 0.02639174647629261, 0.0016699968837201595, 0.039695385843515396, 0.046754565089941025, -0.017839845269918442, 0.031846627593040466, -0.00930114183574915, -0.0033265601377934217, 0.04434739053249359, 0.01751011610031128, -0.03813047707080841, 0.03744632005691528, 0.004303231369704008, -0.022733641788363457, 0.006400025449693203, 0.0243446733802557, -0.010686872527003288, -0.06390583515167236, 0.01166809257119894, 0.0007622603443451226, -0.07139700651168823, -0.012836356647312641, 0.0039825355634093285, -0.0011690196115523577, 0.025103185325860977, -0.007823523133993149, 0.004787071608006954, 0.02091820538043976, 0.008921809494495392, 0.03595951572060585, 0.006430611480027437, 0.04591074213385582, -0.007730644661933184, 0.013794643804430962, 0.03565512225031853, -0.037817973643541336, 0.060426317155361176, -0.03783697634935379, 0.016827266663312912, -0.002681445563212037, -0.008784578181803226, 0.06003555655479431, 0.003400033339858055, 0.02224644087255001, 0.006883220747113228, -0.03572181612253189, 0.042523521929979324, -0.03172709792852402, -0.00012790969049092382, -0.013885031454265118, 0.01162401307374239, -0.0016596061177551746, -0.024338362738490105, 0.0042261527851223946, 0.017345545813441277, 0.006750133819878101, -0.015326461754739285, 0.01763465441763401, -0.0014302012277767062, 0.038971032947301865, -0.012111146934330463, -0.0169945377856493, -0.020312458276748657, 0.011887862347066402, -0.028524603694677353, -0.005720161367207766, -0.03260764107108116, 0.034881703555583954, 0.030720053240656853, 0.0019309392664581537, 0.03407109156250954, -0.055121805518865585, -0.010109190829098225, 0.03282850235700607, 0.07372245192527771, -0.037278663367033005, -0.036992721259593964, -0.01824915036559105, 0.0017484317068010569, -0.03265142813324928, -0.032806407660245895 ]
<p>I've done an experiment where I recorded a positive or negative result from a cell. My data is set in tables of counts of events and trials, but I don't know how to do statistical analysis on binary data, I need to test the significance between the groups I tested. Can I convert to percentage and do a stats test on that, converting it to continuous data?</p>
37,024
[ -0.009503359906375408, -0.009379048831760883, -0.03941287845373154, 0.004434388596564531, 0.03198062628507614, 0.02480979636311531, -0.012278562411665916, -0.011195030994713306, 0.02013293094933033, 0.01646685227751732, 0.06341401487588882, 0.03598589450120926, -0.0008748360560275614, 0.014132894575595856, 0.020262768492102623, 0.02788764238357544, -0.023420710116624832, 0.006065696012228727, -0.01873568259179592, 0.01297630276530981, 0.009853819385170937, 0.0014582551084458828, 0.024552877992391586, -0.000035334516724105924, -0.007932652719318867, 0.02508319355547428, 0.010992170311510563, -0.04311100393533707, 0.0027235611341893673, 0.04343410208821297, -0.03907915949821472, -0.04106622934341431, 0.005262012593448162, 0.04159907251596451, 0.008191653527319431, 0.00958295352756977, -0.03319498151540756, -0.00808736216276884, 0.016451478004455566, 0.010787852108478546, -0.02549847960472107, 0.0018967859214171767, 0.018330249935388565, 0.020996935665607452, -0.009174978360533714, 0.0015004245797172189, 0.006262944079935551, -0.04948048293590546, 0.012269415892660618, -0.049749165773391724, 0.07675725966691971, -0.023694319650530815, 0.07121747732162476, 0.03787583112716675, 0.006388022564351559, 0.0201828982681036, 0.02813287079334259, 0.023941440507769585, 0.004768858663737774, -0.023374713957309723, 0.01193460077047348, -0.04434908926486969, -0.0272779930382967, -0.025996260344982147, -0.020161816850304604, -0.004022147040814161, -0.034972336143255234, -0.039824724197387695, 0.06086600199341774, 0.007950851693749428, -0.0015441254945471883, 0.022029124200344086, 0.04740269482135773, -0.030711142346262932, 0.004230836406350136, -0.023661619052290916, 0.03568987175822258, 0.0007205603760667145, 0.014479424804449081, 0.07745812833309174, -0.03840574622154236, 0.003170790383592248, 0.020419159904122353, 0.0490509569644928, 0.030762773007154465, -0.0702400878071785, 0.03331764414906502, -0.03414120897650719, 0.024425633251667023, 0.012152845971286297, -0.02990749664604664, -0.04353689029812813, 0.011522882618010044, 0.036780908703804016, -0.04322216659784317, 0.006972527131438255, -0.013351493515074253, 0.060157548636198044, 0.030254732817411423, -0.02212088368833065, 0.009528162889182568, 0.01579023338854313, 0.03940155357122421, 0.045694127678871155, -0.07547196745872498, -0.01058877445757389, -0.005331278778612614, 0.0026879296638071537, 0.0008398526115342975, 0.022011805325746536, -0.006813581567257643, -0.011224915273487568, 0.05559178814291954, 0.01134458277374506, 0.04468049108982086, -0.027729567140340805, -0.024288179352879524, -0.029305491596460342, 0.06907627731561661, 0.031817495822906494, 0.0643535852432251, -0.044374871999025345, 0.02294698916375637, -0.036327820271253586, -0.016432713717222214, 0.03276938945055008, -0.025842206552624702, -0.013871186412870884, -0.021939674392342567, 0.04508039355278015, -0.007191519718617201, -0.014543202705681324, 0.009493734687566757, -0.026694675907492638, 0.03985881805419922, -0.010323194786906242, -0.06874483078718185, -0.036195795983076096, 0.01024650689214468, -0.008309012278914452, -0.038333404809236526, -0.036182302981615067, 0.005717235151678324, 0.03888307139277458, 0.026136090978980064, 0.010436993092298508, 0.026413757354021072, -0.027058936655521393, 0.023638704791665077, 0.02537200227379799, -0.008859696798026562, 0.004668110515922308, -0.018290553241968155, -0.01033634040504694, -0.0080025689676404, -0.06172410026192665, 0.037707723677158356, -0.006228442769497633, 0.006288706790655851, -0.0332646444439888, 0.005569180473685265, -0.0073371040634810925, -0.019598715007305145, 0.015761759132146835, 0.012004006654024124, -0.004757850430905819, 0.0810554027557373, -0.027464408427476883, -0.00275363284163177, 0.020502032712101936, -0.00023528019664809108, 0.022254984825849533, 0.03857612982392311, 0.02780064381659031, 0.0513521246612072, -0.0134701207280159, -0.02011651173233986, -0.023938635364174843, 0.033976033329963684, -0.0013355709379538894, -0.030413003638386726, -0.0008724493673071265, -0.019470851868391037, -0.002187892561778426, 0.04225253313779831, 0.020858407020568848, 0.019628897309303284, -0.03724825009703636, 0.0452749989926815, -0.02659139595925808, -0.04305661842226982, -0.057942479848861694, 0.00022388799698092043, -0.013952769339084625, -0.0355636291205883, -0.007952313870191574, 0.04435396194458008, 0.025318656116724014, -0.046894919127225876, -0.024042533710598946, -0.04357565566897392, -0.021488375961780548, 0.019279101863503456, -0.05099387466907501, 0.007434197701513767, 0.04589327797293663, 0.03633745387196541, -0.017588241025805473, 0.05949291214346886, -0.010612745769321918, -0.028942791745066643, -0.021443985402584076, -0.03452581167221069, 0.01892864517867565, 0.021385887637734413, -0.026544848456978798, 0.009810536168515682, 0.01576896943151951, -0.013540768064558506, 0.039688590914011, -0.03697844594717026, 0.09102388471364975, 0.06895097345113754, -0.017251143231987953, 0.018649043515324593, -0.045356426388025284, 0.04722534492611885, 0.015622217208147049, 0.01646299473941326, 0.009441075846552849, -0.058464210480451584, 0.024522462859749794, 0.025069709867239, -0.04779406636953354, -0.04332049936056137, 0.001930529484525323, 0.04762827232480049, -0.027490051463246346, 0.03857666999101639, 0.02261062152683735, -0.019884124398231506, -0.016250062733888626, 0.001173410564661026, 0.02182414010167122, 0.00937642715871334, -0.00686302874237299, 0.026672599837183952, 0.015774304047226906, 0.04972650483250618, 0.01801873743534088, -0.0003590224077925086, 0.012467116117477417, -0.0002005613496294245, 0.008690545335412025, -0.03835606575012207, -0.03348371386528015, 0.0465722531080246, -0.013501065783202648, 0.00937800295650959, 0.0162041112780571, 0.029442938044667244, 0.0025698423851281404, 0.023596063256263733, -0.025901176035404205, -0.014724992215633392, 0.049247197806835175, -0.03643115982413292, -0.008843213319778442, 0.025337157770991325, -0.028154922649264336, 0.02439042739570141, -0.005911446176469326, -0.025327960029244423, -0.04521872103214264, -0.002113749971613288, 0.027212709188461304, 0.009169908240437508, 0.062183819711208344, 0.006203106604516506, -0.017912331968545914, 0.012537837959825993, -0.0267884973436594, 0.02222365513443947, 0.003339206101372838, -0.038779448717832565, -0.0077165584079921246, -0.030861062929034233, -0.03617284819483757, 0.023331210017204285, 0.008671965450048447, -0.018650062382221222, 0.012528588995337486, 0.014938699081540108, -0.025490526109933853, -0.00008792409062152728, -0.012000750750303268, 0.0189898032695055, -0.027325589209794998, 0.009918730705976486, 0.04170554503798485, 0.017427492886781693, -0.03264664486050606, 0.027750855311751366, -0.04347069934010506, 0.011528910137712955, -0.032152704894542694, 0.028294093906879425, -0.00030165089992806315, -0.008506765589118004, 0.02594376541674137, -0.005487751215696335, -0.049875397235155106, 0.02372233010828495, -0.07694394886493683, -0.034935127943754196, 0.004945849068462849, 0.013626990839838982, 0.03618309274315834, 0.006375599652528763, 0.011583712883293629, 0.034362971782684326, 0.041342709213495255, -0.043782997876405716, -0.019988717511296272, -0.006954969372600317, -0.0475168377161026, 0.004069535527378321, 0.03383735939860344, 0.0013254351215437055, -0.018055498600006104, -0.014204938896000385, -0.0013419539900496602, 0.022226253524422646, 0.048305340111255646, 0.028386158868670464, -0.012961027212440968, 0.027207424864172935, 0.018469594419002533, -0.002292556455358863, 0.031028715893626213, 0.007443987298756838, -0.038822825998067856, 0.023323222994804382, -0.007458908017724752, 0.016521813347935677, 0.039155784994363785, -0.06591199338436127, 0.007567384280264378, 0.018089544028043747, 0.01210765726864338, -0.01650002785027027, 0.013282225467264652, -0.007519188802689314, -0.01361593697220087, 0.031178850680589676, 0.021788079291582108, 0.021676575765013695, 0.0006034289253875613, -0.01889808289706707, 0.03405493497848511, 0.04253152012825012, -0.02325686439871788, -0.06214413046836853, 0.011342211626470089, -0.013692624866962433, 0.037736859172582626, -0.02505209483206272, -0.012515357695519924, 0.026469314470887184, 0.03314962983131409, 0.011414337903261185, -0.011448144912719727, -0.02645242214202881, -0.012511714361608028, -0.02807529829442501, -0.010965819470584393, -0.019129762426018715, 0.0034056829754263163, -0.028556445613503456, 0.04942697659134865, 0.004803642630577087, -0.02136315032839775, 0.014205175451934338, -0.027373500168323517, -0.05533308535814285, 0.032656870782375336, 0.01789170503616333, -0.02385627292096615, 0.011098790913820267, -0.009351905435323715, 0.035812992602586746, -0.03344077244400978, -0.019279535859823227, 0.0057131629437208176, -0.0005046934238635004, -0.006979186553508043, -0.0007472191355191171, -0.019424786791205406, -0.00934535451233387, 0.002782864961773157, 0.014434227719902992, 0.0014650840312242508, 0.010764844715595245, 0.0043236976489424706, 0.005221012979745865, 0.020092559978365898, -0.01503205019980669, 0.01499878242611885, -0.004227133002132177, 0.026475533843040466, 0.06305672973394394, 0.04642988368868828, 0.03301021456718445, -0.04291915521025658, 0.03275527432560921, -0.005378030240535736, 0.03161989524960518, 0.035891298204660416, -0.02102801389992237, -0.04547049477696419, -0.043458323925733566, -0.0259085763245821, -0.023825032636523247, 0.019547877833247185, 0.03993172571063042, -0.029238339513540268, 0.03402133658528328, 0.042542602866888046, -0.05719953775405884, 0.03519335389137268, 0.085459403693676, 0.018868347629904747, -0.0005675200372934341, -0.04431235417723656, -0.009635167196393013, -0.005568726919591427, -0.03668108582496643, 0.0379423126578331, 0.05885281413793564, 0.005808037240058184, -0.0092723174020648, 0.07224074751138687, 0.019352223724126816, -0.044871699064970016, 0.015312964096665382, -0.00585955660790205, 0.03285318613052368, 0.013680070638656616, -0.02239169180393219, 0.04966749995946884, 0.0310574471950531, 0.017766013741493225, 0.016266167163848877, -0.007491802331060171, -0.12794700264930725, 0.034126732498407364, 0.030479267239570618, 0.03887331485748291, -0.020951401442289352, 0.006615627557039261, -0.015379644930362701, -0.0011989022605121136, 0.03835899755358696, -0.031190460547804832, -0.006855877116322517, -0.011674625799059868, 0.04535004496574402, -0.02465585246682167, 0.022856563329696655, -0.05774674564599991, -0.006447714287787676, -0.042248908430337906, 0.011599407531321049, -0.028216181322932243, -0.04699954763054848, -0.027504783123731613, 0.02561238408088684, 0.011067901737987995, 0.07167164981365204, -0.02566872164607048, -0.0038433729205280542, 0.017766982316970825, 0.0016100314678624272, -0.031241219490766525, -0.052548572421073914, 0.01780005171895027, -0.006168420892208815, 0.042569320648908615, 0.03673797473311424, 0.018773339688777924, -0.031039247289299965, 0.011617109179496765, 0.007355104200541973, -0.043961554765701294, -0.00459958054125309, -0.0626719519495964, 0.015497736632823944, 0.02209378406405449, -0.012305966578423977, 0.05776418745517731, -0.005630671977996826, -0.027292629703879356, 0.004166680853813887, -0.04076329618692398, 0.03569154068827629, 0.007234657648950815, 0.0026821813080459833, -0.02700532227754593, 0.0032711008097976446, 0.006125431042164564, 0.003100953297689557, 0.01242787390947342, 0.033467765897512436, 0.006801933515816927, -0.026597818359732628, 0.012096905149519444, 0.009134347550570965, 0.03428848832845688, -0.03477448597550392, -0.003367962082847953, -0.011072930879890919, -0.00514173461124301, -0.06207903474569321, 0.029708510264754295, -0.01812072843313217, 0.013666903600096703, -0.022970572113990784, -0.05922391265630722, 0.004550918936729431, -0.05198560282588005, -0.016051413491368294, 0.03272731229662895, -0.04173046350479126, 0.018270893022418022, -0.02587803080677986, 0.01986764743924141, -0.03932402655482292, -0.010226337239146233, -0.04996354877948761, 0.04160458967089653, 0.02833426184952259, 0.0434391088783741, -0.06297773867845535, 0.037886518985033035, -0.0461309477686882, 0.014384637586772442, -0.07919378578662872, -0.05614011734724045, 0.0026569801848381758, 0.0014468611916527152, -0.007935553789138794, -0.05923556536436081, -0.0135202556848526, 0.01905876025557518, -0.017935173586010933, 0.00561290979385376, 0.02382398210465908, -0.021483445540070534, -0.004050333518534899, 0.009882820770144463, -0.0014130810741335154, 0.09155317395925522, -0.0008708738023415208, -0.02703016996383667, 0.013424886390566826, 0.006072966381907463, -0.030873063951730728, -0.00922476127743721, -0.005430686287581921, -0.04619165509939194, 0.016265960410237312, -0.010786883533000946, -0.03285767510533333, 0.027986126020550728, -0.060298118740320206, -0.008913026191294193, 0.012603617273271084, 0.03635293245315552, 0.02170785330235958, -0.056381259113550186, 0.03178666532039642, 0.008641300722956657, -0.02258087322115898, -0.03538307175040245, 0.0025777274277061224, -0.02563624456524849, 0.02112497016787529, 0.020091498270630836, -0.00010434784780954942, -0.0166336577385664, 0.025055116042494774, 0.05853862687945366, -0.004588314797729254, -0.0006472659879364073, 0.023379208520054817, -0.0055922153405845165, 0.02980935573577881, 0.002313960110768676, -0.032700445502996445, 0.015235248021781445, 0.004552583210170269, -0.0378582589328289, 0.020417535677552223, -0.061146270483732224, -0.03315066918730736, 0.037687137722969055, 0.030568355694413185, 0.029078714549541473, 0.04538080841302872, 0.012998240999877453, 0.00028988084523007274, -0.013098325580358505, 0.017840871587395668, -0.01769978553056717, 0.035112157464027405, 0.01948331482708454, 0.01366532314568758, -0.013490244746208191, 0.012300279922783375, 0.04179682955145836, -0.014747291803359985, 0.07033487409353256, 0.05258531868457794, 0.0014434984186664224, 0.04347631707787514, 0.016397817060351372, -0.021737178787589073, 0.015478943474590778, -0.061140432953834534, 0.04155468940734863, -0.07286372780799866, -0.025529609993100166, 0.06725633144378662, 0.06316392123699188, -0.014012273401021957, -0.02383321151137352, -0.027675284072756767, -0.049612175673246384, 0.027432149276137352, -0.01717739924788475, -0.013065816834568977, 0.03279922530055046, 0.006452125031501055, 0.061981961131095886, -0.04244368523359299, 0.02944931574165821, -0.019893217831850052, -0.043760694563388824, -0.016635112464427948, -0.044990140944719315, -0.049080125987529755, 0.034687407314777374, -0.0035414905287325382, -0.019575946033000946, 0.010278269648551941, 0.0004352327960077673, 0.02397368662059307, -0.005826475098729134, 0.08691705018281937, -0.019392993301153183, 0.04112127050757408, -0.006057119462639093, -0.017139432951807976, 0.022310011088848114, -0.020700041204690933, 0.1185261607170105, 0.07791377604007721, 0.010090341791510582, -0.05960599333047867, 0.05067940801382065, 0.011091240681707859, 0.03177984058856964, -0.016521669924259186, -0.010018663480877876, -0.013160929083824158, -0.011393586173653603, 0.049345359206199646, 0.06145409122109413, -0.0164294745773077, 0.015728911384940147, 0.05914420634508133, 0.015031425282359123, -0.07693269103765488, 0.026079371571540833, -0.000710069842170924, -0.0334317684173584, -0.010403771884739399, -0.02542528510093689, 0.021098647266626358, 0.011852942407131195, -0.0424429252743721, -0.024152683094143867, -0.01780962198972702, -0.01953081041574478, 0.014361122623085976, -0.03174995258450508, -0.0007103347452357411, 0.04715840891003609, 0.020833594724535942, -0.02717120386660099, -0.051888223737478256, 0.023004384711384773, -0.011895879171788692, -0.0227728970348835, 0.018721140921115875, 0.019509801641106606, -0.018260378390550613, -0.020968448370695114, 0.013189634308218956, -0.06308436393737793, -0.003882067743688822, -0.025014804676175117, 0.03272625431418419, 0.021897759288549423, -0.018776647746562958, 0.004704694263637066, -0.0021545211784541607, -0.042662981897592545, -0.01730223000049591, -0.02965497225522995, 0.041478466242551804, 0.02720750868320465, -0.03515167906880379, -0.03583918511867523, -0.040234073996543884, 0.019540686160326004, -0.025436803698539734, -0.00036566000198945403, 0.07123493403196335, -0.003965975251048803, -0.02807307243347168, -0.02302367612719536, 0.045808903872966766, -0.008528518490493298, -0.018720917403697968, 0.03322477638721466, -0.03606278449296951, -0.004581820219755173, 0.03373617306351662, -0.021864209324121475, 0.024729324504733086, -0.01803910918533802, 0.002675072755664587, -0.03385785222053528, 0.035029053688049316, -0.027753503993153572, 0.04681115224957466, -0.016330597922205925, -0.023375073447823524, -0.03248487412929535, 0.04080705717206001, 0.03271312639117241, 0.02684902772307396, 0.003353468142449856, 0.002373596653342247, -0.015268378891050816, 0.03783946484327316, 0.03717193007469177, -0.04892941191792488, -0.030063418671488762, -0.016635213047266006, -0.0033153784461319447, -0.0011604217579588294, -0.02293342538177967, 0.0626438707113266, 0.017618894577026367, -0.002257020678371191, 0.01059606485068798, -0.01584114320576191, -0.005592800676822662, 0.03516588732600212, -0.019730785861611366, -0.07216444611549377, 0.009673673659563065, -0.003527519293129444, 0.015371186658740044, -0.01802544854581356, -0.042684830725193024, -0.05567287281155586, 0.019636079668998718, -0.007974053733050823, -0.028644241392612457, -0.0017145414603874087, -0.007213059812784195, -0.008200420066714287, -0.011448567733168602, -0.011185670271515846, -0.027651578187942505, -0.02459944598376751, -0.03998484089970589, 0.018002569675445557, 0.005137031432241201, -0.001260097837075591, -0.0028619503136724234, 0.004980410449206829, 0.036317404359579086, 0.05094306543469429, 0.0104460334405303, 0.014204781502485275, -0.015041233971714973, 0.04050612077116966, 0.006864345166832209, 0.03070046380162239, -0.039823271334171295, 0.00569763733074069, 0.05679231509566307, -0.042804937809705734, 0.01240046788007021, 0.05609150230884552, -0.02541460283100605, 0.03406701236963272, -0.010382118634879589, -0.0007100366055965424, 0.03225325793027878, 0.048762112855911255, -0.0484185628592968, -0.04058026894927025, -0.027119062840938568, -0.018930362537503242, -0.008303897455334663, 0.029040757566690445, 0.0010223131394013762, 0.023917924612760544, -0.02054883912205696, 0.028231441974639893, 0.0180874802172184, 0.0258726067841053, 0.031602371484041214, -0.006738549564033747, 0.016955558210611343, 0.006655286531895399, 0.019031107425689697, -0.013761739246547222, 0.017749350517988205, 0.07122769206762314, -0.022532735019922256, 0.02826186828315258, -0.006320084445178509, 0.024873074144124985, -0.06502275168895721, -0.057144008576869965, -0.0028994770254939795, 0.018459713086485863, 0.00956096313893795, -0.07460668683052063, 0.009989394806325436, 0.03637068718671799, -0.02897130697965622, 0.019485188648104668, 0.010888523422181606, -0.05413522198796272, -0.03860551863908768, 0.006311932113021612, -0.009249004535377026, 0.011275863274931908, 0.0196478683501482, 0.042993176728487015, 0.03192516043782234, 0.007994678802788258, -0.0004761114250868559, 0.006243649870157242, 0.011292845010757446, -0.005648139398545027, 0.03858926519751549, -0.046945177018642426, 0.038074616342782974, -0.058942221105098724, -0.04916269704699516, 0.03798285499215126, -0.02785240113735199, 0.01168153714388609, 0.041502129286527634, 0.02195073664188385, 0.005042054690420628, 0.0645279511809349, 0.01573788747191429, -0.005724866408854723, -0.017890259623527527, -0.02254696749150753, 0.018834462389349937, 0.05119221657514572, -0.0428452305495739, 0.028169844299554825, 0.06475409120321274, -0.006000943947583437, -0.02081681415438652, 0.03040335141122341, -0.019749494269490242, 0.011947793886065483, 0.0025650167372077703, -0.007907796651124954, 0.026526596397161484, -0.04084993153810501, 0.02174963615834713, -0.06234995275735855, 0.009771136566996574, 0.024395043030381203, 0.0037894556298851967, 0.0054198638536036015, -0.005703782197088003, 0.017397165298461914, -0.027502385899424553, -0.031195590272545815, -0.000326980312820524, -0.035923995077610016, -0.05511784180998802, -0.0062108831480145454, 0.013514095917344093, 0.020539935678243637, -0.019359903410077095, 0.007431006524711847, -0.03895803168416023, 0.05609085410833359, -0.02621813304722309, 0.025915134698152542, 0.05119024217128754, 0.010809460654854774, -0.006522181909531355, -0.11072501540184021, 0.028039434924721718, 0.04698767513036728, -0.008002050220966339, -0.04228662699460983, -0.009388033300638199, -0.04827471822500229, -0.007213101256638765, 0.05183079093694687, 0.024997137486934662, 0.014228727668523788, -0.03735785931348801, -0.0016069599660113454, -0.014132183976471424, -0.05516841635107994, 0.008798878639936447, -0.06069638207554817, -0.05949820578098297, -0.030897561460733414, -0.0014194371178746223, 0.008054090663790703, -0.010718473233282566, -0.0031553935259580612, -0.022103989496827126, -0.001717896549962461, -0.021216534078121185, -0.021115602925419807, 0.06306145340204239, 0.008771466091275215, -0.029778871685266495, 0.044768355786800385, -0.005901295691728592, -0.0011118135880678892, 0.04183513671159744, -0.006442624144256115, -0.05262603610754013, 0.05792056396603584, -0.03405199944972992, -0.0294759813696146, 0.022964654490351677, -0.0034185447730123997, -0.03209852799773216, -0.04705671966075897, 0.023284921422600746, 0.01737356372177601, -0.04536815732717514, 0.055959392338991165, 0.01515250839293003, 0.022557172924280167, 0.018288064748048782, -0.008901447057723999, 0.016973551362752914, 0.010954954661428928, -0.00672500254586339, 0.03544726222753525, 0.027903171256184578, 0.00686429999768734, -0.019544389098882675, 0.012601697817444801, 0.028480779379606247, -0.019194478169083595, 0.01925482042133808, 0.024693001061677933, -0.006893787533044815, -0.007772152777761221, 0.010428894311189651, 0.0034266149159520864, -0.03250512853264809, 0.044859565794467926, 0.02546766772866249, 0.0009544832282699645, 0.05338654667139053, -0.03362932428717613, 0.010900992900133133, -0.03356008231639862, -0.024117054417729378, -0.03639256954193115, -0.017673181369900703, 0.04131825640797615, 0.014008933678269386, -0.0028356006368994713, 0.018509991466999054, -0.004654412157833576, -0.0038019216153770685, 0.023977912962436676, -0.047452762722969055, 0.033448971807956696, -0.019742468371987343, -0.002518855035305023, 0.028912603855133057, -0.007496083155274391, -0.017793932929635048, -0.019183015450835228, -0.004840587265789509, 0.007413147948682308, -0.011135386303067207, -0.007083442062139511, -0.024607591331005096, 0.018914131447672844, 0.015726715326309204, -0.036936718970537186, -0.06112153083086014, -0.04871470481157303, 0.03346943482756615, 0.0021594243589788675, -0.007157813757658005 ]
<p>So the question states that I'm trying something with an 85% chance of success, if I don't succeed I try again until I do. What is the mean and variance of the number of tries necessary until I succeed?</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
46,169
[ -0.02603846602141857, -0.028461668640375137, 0.00720062805339694, -0.005246431566774845, 0.045899614691734314, -0.003768439404666424, -0.00428647268563509, -0.04839637503027916, -0.0024325144477188587, -0.01019876729696989, 0.04240598902106285, 0.055440012365579605, 0.039480067789554596, 0.02532857283949852, 0.0036191982217133045, 0.011003545485436916, -0.05121725797653198, -0.003246559528633952, -0.02261407859623432, -0.016133315861225128, -0.006562067661434412, -0.01826540380716324, 0.008824107237160206, -0.003049904014915228, -0.045886240899562836, -0.004361794330179691, 0.021392429247498512, -0.026074983179569244, 0.021542822942137718, 0.0688011422753334, -0.04667949676513672, -0.024336853995919228, 0.011384312063455582, 0.02497975528240204, 0.04428062215447426, 0.003184581408277154, -0.03514786437153816, -0.019047392532229424, -0.023993631824851036, 0.021991373971104622, -0.027334969490766525, 0.011597179807722569, -0.027287177741527557, 0.02248210832476616, -0.00849941000342369, 0.026338178664445877, -0.02107938565313816, -0.04342684522271156, 0.03848416730761528, -0.02705611288547516, 0.11037424206733704, -0.006575606297701597, 0.0373288169503212, 0.0015761031536385417, 0.010538717731833458, 0.0028484740760177374, 0.07606703788042068, 0.013488120399415493, 0.0030747083947062492, -0.03541966527700424, -0.02783326245844364, -0.03264383599162102, -0.014366605319082737, -0.013883762992918491, -0.053877051919698715, 0.000652934075333178, -0.037687063217163086, -0.047765448689460754, 0.05259007215499878, 0.023245982825756073, 0.025241669267416, 0.028092119842767715, 0.06811513751745224, 0.013542870990931988, -0.0018635049927979708, -0.03101629763841629, 0.021338732913136482, -0.0038262822199612856, -0.006410444155335426, 0.04452921450138092, 0.04175085946917534, 0.004125981591641903, 0.02381845749914646, 0.013566835783421993, 0.02533496357500553, -0.029070938006043434, 0.08799091726541519, -0.004747293423861265, 0.024405360221862793, 0.02440035715699196, 0.0014623847091570497, -0.028753168880939484, 0.04850521311163902, -0.008366202004253864, -0.04818573594093323, 0.014177096076309681, 0.0043829046189785, 0.04126672074198723, 0.0003040070296265185, -0.003555228700861335, -0.019242065027356148, -0.0536634735763073, 0.045815229415893555, 0.05202678218483925, -0.02466478943824768, 0.007802254986017942, -0.013180974870920181, 0.0147298164665699, -0.011651301756501198, -0.02054210938513279, 0.0382763035595417, 0.035511184483766556, -0.00048059606342576444, 0.01872672513127327, 0.020319998264312744, 0.003994287457317114, -0.04012482240796089, 0.005599077790975571, 0.03056192584335804, 0.05800235643982887, 0.028528066352009773, -0.01111188717186451, 0.06558592617511749, -0.03038027696311474, -0.02289125882089138, 0.01592409797012806, 0.019443141296505928, -0.03745392709970474, -0.019606370478868484, 0.053476348519325256, -0.018789976835250854, -0.022890981286764145, 0.041369564831256866, 0.006291795987635851, 0.025452977046370506, -0.030205311253666878, -0.07301754504442215, -0.053735166788101196, 0.02332121506333351, -0.03838410601019859, -0.022316675633192062, -0.08200067281723022, 0.0352972187101841, 0.03519647195935249, 0.049438562244176865, 0.009802109561860561, 0.06030923128128052, -0.015225108712911606, 0.0022523445077240467, 0.03512918949127197, -0.04024793207645416, 0.0061686052940785885, 0.010497481562197208, -0.037829700857400894, 0.019747937098145485, -0.07225968688726425, 0.024206075817346573, 0.0006522902403958142, -0.01498730480670929, -0.026151226833462715, 0.007675158325582743, -0.015030432492494583, -0.0053898910991847515, -0.005028603132814169, 0.014898225665092468, -0.02386332117021084, 0.06611262261867523, 0.02417365275323391, 0.02736288495361805, 0.03616388514637947, 0.014216955751180649, -0.012045168317854404, 0.013363691978156567, 0.019114388152956963, 0.07522711157798767, -0.04918794706463814, 0.0021802482660859823, 0.01655164361000061, -0.008719963021576405, 0.001442482229322195, -0.013602238148450851, 0.03569663316011429, 0.004872453864663839, 0.00726944487541914, 0.019207827746868134, 0.0299590602517128, -0.004339875187724829, -0.0070840525440871716, -0.010108479298651218, 0.025518739596009254, -0.014700247906148434, -0.09621722251176834, -0.008295333944261074, -0.01089706365019083, -0.026505962014198303, 0.021364834159612656, 0.001019138959236443, 0.03441847488284111, -0.029960928484797478, -0.016604557633399963, -0.02321140095591545, -0.013219194486737251, 0.0394996702671051, -0.03561526536941528, 0.007679441943764687, 0.08607888966798782, 0.04522555693984032, -0.003779890714213252, 0.04467998072504997, -0.057260144501924515, -0.011479120701551437, -0.049471937119960785, 0.00954954233020544, 0.011328098364174366, 0.02243558131158352, 0.0119358841329813, 0.012010814622044563, 0.018007729202508926, 0.0022005662322044373, 0.018370388075709343, -0.04231574758887291, 0.0602976493537426, 0.07251879572868347, 0.03521580994129181, -0.006997126620262861, 0.03209872543811798, 0.013311423361301422, 0.022601010277867317, 0.0028247705195099115, -0.05384624004364014, 0.004656114615499973, 0.0064013805240392685, 0.002892871620133519, -0.008882762864232063, -0.01828799769282341, 0.025964872911572456, 0.05787090212106705, 0.015824588015675545, -0.0003164054942317307, 0.060458965599536896, -0.027909794822335243, -0.008256557397544384, -0.026269255205988884, 0.02957618050277233, 0.010416490025818348, 0.03003895841538906, -0.030648251995444298, 0.010398562066257, 0.0034773836378008127, 0.033554770052433014, -0.030367586761713028, 0.0249986220151186, 0.008976412005722523, 0.004940354730933905, -0.01265005860477686, -0.03542136773467064, 0.03964885324239731, -0.007878067903220654, -0.027981845661997795, 0.05947163701057434, 0.01140130776911974, 0.007590871304273605, -0.021275049075484276, -0.01397863682359457, 0.0185295008122921, -0.0009048228384926915, -0.014133518561720848, -0.011928820051252842, 0.02628636546432972, -0.020262060686945915, 0.023195335641503334, -0.009136918932199478, -0.0006360255647450686, -0.013962794095277786, 0.006164801772683859, 0.018039649352431297, 0.008582687936723232, 0.048635344952344894, -0.007716774009168148, -0.03393423929810524, -0.03467211127281189, -0.022544516250491142, -0.013976016081869602, -0.01924160309135914, -0.04829961061477661, 0.011887973174452782, 0.004641922656446695, 0.0005620605079457164, -0.0025649943854659796, -0.016626589000225067, 0.010412095114588737, 0.058670200407505035, 0.023382870480418205, -0.021526958793401718, 0.007783039472997189, -0.050407521426677704, 0.013080110773444176, -0.011638927273452282, -0.004385720007121563, 0.014972604811191559, 0.011416341178119183, -0.029809746891260147, 0.05646193027496338, -0.04144948720932007, -0.05307268723845482, -0.07318123430013657, 0.014564146287739277, 0.01197078637778759, -0.030575187876820564, 0.028765492141246796, 0.014718879014253616, -0.025890883058309555, 0.023953447118401527, -0.08655340224504471, -0.08020065724849701, -0.036628883332014084, 0.00825627613812685, 0.021475154906511307, 0.01324807945638895, -0.0354439839720726, 0.09557241201400757, 0.03486568108201027, -0.01231370773166418, -0.019521603360772133, 0.0036820631939917803, -0.003526792861521244, -0.05672268196940422, 0.018406448885798454, 0.027335751801729202, -0.04917171597480774, -0.0003708785225171596, 0.01120676938444376, 0.026544839143753052, 0.03731760010123253, -0.011162855662405491, -0.0013319894205778837, -0.01101106870919466, 0.02849428541958332, -0.013120404444634914, 0.03745737299323082, 0.022254442796111107, -0.022150887176394463, 0.007445711176842451, -0.011193790473043919, 0.03243988752365112, 0.010468360967934132, -0.03368841111660004, 0.006376056466251612, -0.026354189962148666, 0.02080724388360977, -0.0666273757815361, 0.06462448835372925, -0.0073899091221392155, -0.017714690417051315, 0.015228787437081337, -0.016420187428593636, 0.0452258437871933, -0.0300914254039526, -0.0008395673357881606, 0.0435975007712841, 0.03643283620476723, -0.012450453825294971, -0.04087129980325699, -0.020482487976551056, -0.012882132083177567, 0.008785144425928593, -0.008697869256138802, -0.03277803212404251, 0.020340560004115105, 0.05285719409584999, 0.04242100566625595, -0.012027619406580925, -0.037891894578933716, -0.003272996749728918, -0.04790949821472168, 0.006290883291512728, -0.005065190605819225, 0.00937054306268692, -0.02762329950928688, 0.027675291523337364, 0.03209477290511131, -0.026402592658996582, -0.004460154101252556, -0.016918011009693146, -0.05010503903031349, 0.05024135485291481, -0.014053850434720516, -0.028993353247642517, -0.02282889373600483, -0.02675638347864151, 0.018886681646108627, -0.032009925693273544, 0.03973926976323128, 0.03443627804517746, 0.05049978196620941, -0.020247481763362885, 0.0055695497430861, -0.007369272410869598, 0.009567528031766415, 0.012540854513645172, -0.018944095820188522, -0.007539318408817053, 0.0064893485978245735, 0.0663023367524147, 0.032533347606658936, -0.0403735414147377, -0.019812654703855515, 0.01993299089372158, -0.003124155104160309, 0.0017734849825501442, 0.022221798077225685, 0.025688091292977333, 0.027075236663222313, -0.020345384255051613, 0.03315439820289612, 0.008298824541270733, 0.053987693041563034, 0.05185922235250473, 0.037564102560281754, -0.02365809865295887, -0.037727851420640945, -0.04239994287490845, -0.002863326109945774, -0.010580413974821568, 0.0012278816429898143, 0.0074636139906942844, 0.03161225467920303, -0.004969135858118534, -0.06195906549692154, 0.014620441943407059, 0.0696142166852951, 0.006423358805477619, 0.00806723814457655, -0.060654107481241226, 0.008358004502952099, -0.02772079035639763, -0.03094193898141384, 0.01071192603558302, 0.03353901952505112, -0.02657856047153473, 0.01944393292069435, 0.023083698004484177, -0.005432825535535812, -0.018750987946987152, 0.03139602765440941, -0.00757145369425416, 0.013439842499792576, 0.005042736884206533, -0.0005733954021707177, 0.010050268843770027, 0.03814774379134178, 0.022298229858279228, 0.018692195415496826, 0.0018014614470303059, -0.027976950630545616, -0.000052535164286382496, 0.04314988851547241, 0.06383020430803299, -0.03161729872226715, 0.024147700518369675, -0.034209154546260834, 0.008942840620875359, 0.0252794548869133, -0.040256619453430176, 0.03347988426685333, 0.00925134215503931, 0.012597301043570042, -0.009058783762156963, -0.04159654304385185, -0.010315079241991043, -0.001237800344824791, 0.0011297684395685792, 0.037659939378499985, 0.021949991583824158, -0.023584896698594093, -0.0417625792324543, -0.024484708905220032, 0.01668807864189148, 0.07709120959043503, -0.024217279627919197, 0.00901336781680584, -0.021138790994882584, 0.015960916876792908, -0.028835438191890717, -0.07214698195457458, 0.0008069153409451246, 0.014279990456998348, -0.009212219156324863, 0.025585712864995003, -0.03371473774313927, -0.035891979932785034, 0.04977143928408623, 0.005314957350492477, -0.02871578186750412, -0.01969992369413376, -0.030192939564585686, 0.048516515642404556, 0.045839350670576096, 0.04314113035798073, 0.06415028870105743, 0.0003371983766555786, 0.006700536701828241, 0.013893094845116138, 0.0053874109871685505, 0.03701836243271828, -0.01782279461622238, -0.025750787928700447, -0.05123446509242058, -0.024238035082817078, -0.010217281058430672, 0.04135109484195709, -0.009961598552763462, 0.028497470542788506, -0.026466576382517815, -0.005215502809733152, 0.0035102516412734985, 0.017830239608883858, 0.0355897881090641, -0.025366785004734993, 0.015912672504782677, 0.0036612828262150288, -0.017180224880576134, -0.03341954946517944, 0.011525694280862808, -0.04307963326573372, 0.011807150207459927, 0.028493763878941536, -0.026794100180268288, -0.01793016493320465, -0.03884964436292648, -0.043078500777482986, 0.012297024019062519, -0.03992144390940666, 0.01567714475095272, -0.04294218495488167, 0.0068605802953243256, 0.006067045032978058, -0.044618602842092514, -0.048599839210510254, 0.0020963961724191904, -0.03289950266480446, 0.0411757156252861, -0.026372049003839493, 0.03858695551753044, -0.028173226863145828, 0.013895242474973202, -0.08593270182609558, -0.05202196165919304, 0.02324834279716015, 0.01771751418709755, -0.009250739589333534, -0.01637229509651661, -0.009965621866285801, -0.021683376282453537, -0.05450784042477608, -0.04003916680812836, 0.019527046009898186, -0.0017128684557974339, -0.016541235148906708, -0.025724805891513824, 0.006049681454896927, 0.07706732302904129, 0.008030233904719353, 0.014063797891139984, 0.011528666131198406, -0.03944382071495056, -0.030380744487047195, -0.00503414636477828, 0.021987874060869217, -0.05297286435961723, -0.004425765480846167, -0.011452778242528439, 0.003464581212028861, 0.03806888684630394, -0.04203690215945244, 0.006998240016400814, 0.017757179215550423, 0.017512019723653793, 0.0065612648613750935, -0.03779447823762894, 0.008207039907574654, 0.04837365448474884, 0.028065213933587074, 0.017202051356434822, 0.0432099811732769, -0.024187853559851646, 0.021283552050590515, 0.02977374568581581, 0.007524722255766392, 0.01074181217700243, 0.019100261852145195, 0.0659300908446312, -0.020193271338939667, 0.01250083651393652, -0.001402123598381877, -0.013548019342124462, 0.0014276235597208142, 0.031552355736494064, -0.020448828116059303, 0.05958113074302673, -0.01891225390136242, -0.048155415803194046, -0.03819800168275833, -0.03589627519249916, 0.013667509891092777, 0.05231117084622383, -0.025387097150087357, 0.060113418847322464, 0.02351980283856392, -0.005797992460429668, 0.0012374300276860595, -0.009093509055674076, 0.006369353737682104, -0.0012024465249851346, 0.037760525941848755, 0.03978931903839111, 0.014497093856334686, 0.03764333203434944, 0.06372381001710892, 0.014264758676290512, 0.03788135573267937, 0.04695698991417885, 0.018809165805578232, 0.01511428877711296, 0.015734754502773285, -0.00043951591942459345, -0.04682660475373268, 0.00908003281801939, -0.04731280729174614, 0.034338660538196564, -0.048330485820770264, -0.022118983790278435, 0.032887380570173264, 0.020184697583317757, -0.013804563321173191, -0.029818100854754448, -0.015259915962815285, -0.030738236382603645, -0.03300322964787483, 0.001395127852447331, -0.026943393051624298, 0.04328327253460884, -0.010301469825208187, 0.021177202463150024, 0.004356543533504009, 0.0426156185567379, -0.005450551863759756, -0.07696220278739929, -0.0003570126718841493, 0.014704600907862186, -0.0511244460940361, 0.04178154841065407, -0.0007587916334159672, -0.017083361744880676, -0.006456795614212751, -0.045120544731616974, 0.018319381400942802, -0.006758809555321932, 0.01399007998406887, -0.030810939148068428, 0.07825203239917755, 0.03523631393909454, 0.0385097861289978, -0.015879033133387566, 0.02001131698489189, 0.08076857775449753, 0.035094138234853745, 0.017684347927570343, -0.04659440368413925, 0.018585635349154472, -0.030618935823440552, -0.0018915453692898154, 0.009372626431286335, 0.016989998519420624, 0.01789972558617592, 0.014521783217787743, 0.056285448372364044, 0.01692752167582512, 0.019943853840231895, -0.0017634100513532758, 0.022863855585455894, -0.05661170557141304, -0.044722720980644226, 0.009291628375649452, -0.019988032057881355, 0.00488319480791688, 0.015235344879329205, -0.0025147818960249424, 0.029525047168135643, -0.03110586479306221, -0.014453954994678497, -0.017050381749868393, -0.010116701014339924, 0.024989379569888115, 0.026385359466075897, 0.010114642791450024, 0.012641802430152893, 0.03205742686986923, -0.011133081279695034, -0.036891236901283264, -0.013607424683868885, 0.040457360446453094, -0.023362623527646065, 0.0021307009737938643, 0.02877797745168209, 0.011133351363241673, 0.017566749826073647, -0.011751564219594002, -0.012343687005341053, -0.05508154630661011, -0.015532329678535461, -0.00867829006165266, 0.020732086151838303, -0.02501148357987404, 0.024270424619317055, -0.011361855082213879, 0.008315250277519226, 0.005809881258755922, -0.06739125400781631, 0.015609240159392357, 0.0037764161825180054, 0.025481419637799263, -0.055186718702316284, -0.034360818564891815, -0.004668002482503653, -0.004875280894339085, -0.03801324591040611, 0.04528618976473808, 0.01223183423280716, -0.02677217498421669, -0.021647820249199867, -0.05081094801425934, 0.03948395699262619, -0.03378752991557121, -0.029893580824136734, -0.008940017782151699, -0.01310443039983511, -0.03214046731591225, 0.03834058344364166, 0.003501251805573702, -0.012397676706314087, 0.021983753889799118, 0.0019145325059071183, -0.024174649268388748, -0.01197145227342844, -0.04906027019023895, 0.021417738869786263, -0.0067517077550292015, -0.019002556800842285, -0.0326676219701767, -0.005922531243413687, 0.03769945353269577, 0.04946558550000191, -0.027071412652730942, 0.019963711500167847, 0.03210318833589554, 0.017310788854956627, 0.013149748556315899, -0.04989391565322876, 0.011872651055455208, -0.006118662189692259, -0.04195812717080116, -0.0036511532962322235, -0.037017688155174255, 0.06290590763092041, 0.03554380312561989, 0.04871204122900963, 0.01280274149030447, 0.021464748308062553, -0.013838748447597027, 0.012455262243747711, -0.02699672430753708, -0.04783282428979874, -0.0035413538571447134, 0.008847709745168686, -0.016379311680793762, -0.021977322176098824, 0.011896044947206974, -0.019288796931505203, -0.010280640795826912, 0.010010208003222942, -0.020316818729043007, -0.02214580588042736, 0.013378757052123547, -0.009333498775959015, 0.0012746230931952596, -0.016118602827191353, 0.002723993267863989, -0.019157327711582184, 0.01587233692407608, 0.0317370668053627, 0.016926415264606476, -0.036025065928697586, 0.016596181318163872, 0.005827273707836866, 0.003952153958380222, 0.02077971026301384, 0.03051241673529148, 0.031067349016666412, -0.028013477101922035, 0.008042421191930771, -0.017900971695780754, 0.0482880137860775, -0.05731838196516037, 0.01036545354872942, 0.06560321152210236, -0.0862281322479248, -0.03006468154489994, 0.044992946088314056, 0.011036695912480354, 0.0468706339597702, 0.039800334721803665, -0.03013882040977478, -0.026571376249194145, 0.05806594714522362, -0.026021063327789307, -0.04482271522283554, -0.02542010135948658, 0.009739154949784279, 0.017847999930381775, -0.01832752488553524, -0.01188710518181324, 0.0016533239977434278, -0.0164596326649189, -0.026741698384284973, 0.04526884853839874, -0.008225277997553349, 0.019460003823041916, 0.004715695511549711, 0.014962317422032356, -0.020465444773435593, 0.020041441544890404, -0.028061384335160255, 0.020479200407862663, 0.0608898364007473, -0.003035403788089752, 0.010540075600147247, -0.044001709669828415, -0.0020283751655369997, -0.11309969425201416, -0.015542278997600079, 0.001340491697192192, 0.0025181190576404333, 0.059765271842479706, -0.041207198053598404, -0.014639551751315594, 0.05701880902051926, -0.0484994612634182, -0.01596859097480774, 0.0077704633586108685, -0.04261073097586632, -0.03845587372779846, 0.04432101175189018, -0.008594936691224575, 0.010976767167448997, -0.014906189404428005, 0.0076793101616203785, 0.06594721972942352, -0.013288123533129692, -0.032142963260412216, -0.024371150881052017, 0.012023567222058773, 0.04504317790269852, 0.009490725584328175, -0.009205370210111141, 0.0280208308249712, -0.038772862404584885, -0.04206925258040428, 0.023013310506939888, -0.0006412334041669965, 0.020986318588256836, 0.00485710334032774, 0.017061907798051834, -0.0027332131285220385, 0.04412578418850899, 0.013896781019866467, 0.006592379417270422, -0.016634797677397728, -0.017357729375362396, -0.0031165089458227158, 0.016361868008971214, 0.0054389010183513165, -0.0034013157710433006, 0.0638689398765564, 0.013361155055463314, -0.05921391770243645, 0.007890277542173862, -0.02006583847105503, -0.04155265912413597, 0.03499520570039749, -0.006165295373648405, 0.0003429921343922615, -0.04905819892883301, -0.0009932321263477206, -0.02617444470524788, -0.0001562341203680262, 0.04289209097623825, -0.021951036527752876, -0.03844616189599037, -0.0018714491743594408, -0.005247427616268396, -0.015446349047124386, -0.007661120034754276, -0.006461001932621002, -0.03984476253390312, -0.051664672791957855, 0.011564996093511581, -0.021615395322442055, 0.0022150431759655476, 0.03678407520055771, -0.02923477254807949, -0.01823471114039421, 0.022276023402810097, 0.010135868564248085, -0.002194677945226431, -0.016728080809116364, -0.04578696936368942, -0.01245071180164814, -0.10367248952388763, 0.0700678899884224, 0.0010193577036261559, -0.01642460562288761, -0.08491691201925278, -0.023500246927142143, -0.007996981032192707, 0.014535483904182911, 0.0498054213821888, -0.000003906879555870546, -0.0016109616262838244, 0.009031938388943672, 0.037073634564876556, 0.021864568814635277, -0.05115922912955284, 0.04671304300427437, -0.01697966456413269, -0.034789714962244034, -0.022688183933496475, 0.00077081035124138, 0.027822673320770264, -0.02660139836370945, -0.00962642952799797, -0.012920904904603958, 0.011852622963488102, 0.009154490195214748, -0.016814785078167915, 0.04571596905589104, 0.028502386063337326, -0.011929708532989025, 0.025122487917542458, -0.024314746260643005, -0.009421218186616898, 0.012512469664216042, -0.019961489364504814, -0.060408998280763626, 0.03143850713968277, -0.029491819441318512, 0.009869414381682873, -0.00627921475097537, 0.028848204761743546, 0.009263747371733189, -0.04406500607728958, 0.012172045186161995, 0.0343148373067379, -0.04377209395170212, -0.008393965661525726, 0.05265765264630318, 0.027548987418413162, 0.05834117531776428, -0.04644563049077988, 0.012838544324040413, 0.018752681091427803, -0.00923234224319458, -0.017711348831653595, 0.012991015799343586, 0.02258649840950966, -0.018340565264225006, 0.01869191974401474, 0.007348685059696436, -0.003804875770583749, 0.07815472781658173, 0.0010038177715614438, 0.033949095755815506, -0.04249074310064316, -0.009615953080356121, 0.02607525698840618, -0.016708124428987503, -0.02848474681377411, -0.006890215910971165, -0.019351458176970482, 0.08204438537359238, -0.019665459170937538, 0.038822345435619354, -0.0029512178152799606, 0.006146978586912155, -0.05154314264655113, -0.034589365124702454, 0.026729172095656395, 0.022450005635619164, -0.006030226591974497, 0.005565731320530176, -0.007369705941528082, 0.04649879038333893, 0.05284007638692856, -0.028277790173888206, 0.028851553797721863, -0.010667752474546432, -0.01244184747338295, -0.05737968161702156, 0.013163959607481956, -0.041158225387334824, -0.016110874712467194, 0.011677238158881664, 0.02553560957312584, 0.015777194872498512, 0.00833474937826395, -0.0012073019752278924, 0.004030297044664621, 0.07760936766862869, -0.03910031169652939, -0.005710108671337366, -0.07791663706302643, 0.021838635206222534, -0.0384734608232975, 0.0017925439169630408 ]
<p>As a programmer, I am used to a vibrant documentation system with exhaustive references and tutorials online. Does such a system exist for Stata? Where do people go for quick stata questions (besides Cross Validated)? How did people here learn Stata?</p>
48,738
[ -0.03232651948928833, 0.005391893442720175, -0.0051652537658810616, -0.0020293802954256535, 0.03568378835916519, 0.018600167706608772, 0.0126101765781641, -0.0055349902249872684, 0.038969650864601135, -0.0200791135430336, 0.008706753142178059, 0.04584624990820885, 0.06737342476844788, 0.011622239835560322, 0.009247235022485256, -0.029620708897709846, -0.023747187107801437, -0.004327787086367607, -0.029492134228348732, 0.013064957223832607, 0.0032082092948257923, -0.019260821864008904, -0.010915961116552353, -0.0022891063708812, 0.028184736147522926, 0.00583101250231266, -0.010463074781000614, 0.013786166906356812, -0.01706782914698124, 0.06487885862588882, -0.01111004501581192, -0.011998796835541725, -0.017631949856877327, -0.007897121831774712, 0.022744102403521538, -0.016336722299456596, 0.006911047734320164, -0.04198798909783363, 0.01063717994838953, 0.024332799017429352, -0.05498690903186798, 0.007596224080771208, -0.0075353700667619705, 0.009747890755534172, -0.01052603218704462, 0.0062729534693062305, -0.01658804714679718, 0.008504068478941917, 0.029815828427672386, -0.05296405777335167, 0.01595492474734783, 0.004210570827126503, 0.031142855063080788, 0.06579989939928055, -0.01525107678025961, 0.035310883074998856, 0.04810577258467674, 0.032492585480213165, -0.035217560827732086, -0.017914973199367523, -0.02937336079776287, -0.02748098224401474, 0.02209310233592987, -0.07802899926900864, -0.0495140440762043, 0.0489274263381958, 0.0035606184974312782, -0.003988412208855152, 0.05440667271614075, -0.030805116519331932, -0.007380240596830845, 0.04617123305797577, 0.03681197762489319, 0.010277034714818, -0.010136429220438004, -0.02901461347937584, 0.026338642463088036, -0.0221885833889246, 0.040538739413022995, 0.06357331573963165, 0.01024338137358427, 0.0291637871414423, -0.00407435791566968, 0.036385633051395416, 0.01044947188347578, -0.014101549983024597, 0.09659243375062943, 0.00433626864105463, -0.016550038009881973, -0.00597283523529768, 0.017034415155649185, 0.01794361136853695, 0.029893599450588226, -0.01445714756846428, 0.006875304039567709, 0.025925489142537117, -0.00014542588905896991, 0.02498623915016651, 0.02112450636923313, -0.005566881969571114, 0.008703374303877354, -0.03889937326312065, 0.014183511957526207, 0.028462495654821396, -0.035189226269721985, 0.0167677141726017, -0.035478681325912476, -0.03811781108379364, -0.017162783071398735, -0.03541335463523865, -0.046460822224617004, 0.012178164906799793, -0.0156941507011652, 0.008319628424942493, 0.0021589514799416065, -0.030161116272211075, 0.023329298943281174, -0.004933284129947424, 0.045612603425979614, 0.08075674623250961, 0.02790256403386593, -0.04053588584065437, 0.03367439657449722, -0.010099817998707294, -0.05053503066301346, 0.03963317722082138, 0.02014189213514328, -0.04617234691977501, -0.04702881723642349, 0.05058923736214638, 0.016271162778139114, -0.06015067547559738, 0.031761422753334045, 0.03255479782819748, -0.004474787972867489, -0.005570434033870697, -0.05749111622571945, -0.08232954889535904, 0.018997563049197197, 0.01778852567076683, 0.003281058743596077, -0.0534357912838459, 0.00872996635735035, -0.030939221382141113, 0.03966282308101654, 0.027732037007808685, 0.049985386431217194, 0.05522334203124046, -0.0012873078230768442, -0.009663579985499382, -0.054003458470106125, -0.023103630170226097, -0.016459519043564796, 0.0037641345988959074, 0.003992019686847925, -0.038547538220882416, 0.014925140887498856, -0.004303093533962965, -0.014221591874957085, -0.04524124413728714, 0.048797063529491425, 0.03282605856657028, -0.03387948125600815, 0.01926537975668907, -0.016048789024353027, -0.04736115783452988, 0.07155660539865494, -0.0024038066621869802, 0.013458396308124065, 0.0033493118826299906, -0.010531386360526085, -0.024179555475711823, 0.013759776018559933, 0.0020409799180924892, 0.04973696172237396, -0.008624892681837082, -0.028264110907912254, 0.002437691669911146, -0.004686638247221708, 0.0016309632919728756, -0.049922071397304535, -0.024230288341641426, 0.035365331918001175, -0.01619565859436989, -0.00006896153354318812, 0.01941435970366001, 0.018344778567552567, -0.0033153078984469175, 0.011508150957524776, -0.03357315808534622, -0.06504946202039719, -0.05560162290930748, 0.017168359830975533, -0.024394772946834564, -0.015696587041020393, 0.036895837634801865, 0.01719745248556137, 0.0172154251486063, 0.009800275787711143, -0.014904179610311985, -0.023876043036580086, 0.024079717695713043, 0.032557547092437744, -0.025759529322385788, 0.0011952307540923357, 0.0033404934220016003, 0.016431178897619247, -0.028163153678178787, 0.062328096479177475, -0.05916954576969147, -0.05658258497714996, 0.032189566642045975, -0.01860758662223816, 0.05158872529864311, -0.026892628520727158, -0.010681482963263988, -0.03973127156496048, -0.009513706900179386, -0.02382858842611313, 0.010431414470076561, -0.03961755707859993, 0.01695900224149227, 0.06605535000562668, 0.026737507432699203, 0.016113463789224625, 0.017358098179101944, 0.018252363428473473, 0.029266903176903725, 0.02949797362089157, -0.026572687551379204, -0.029597416520118713, -0.01603277213871479, 0.059014931321144104, 0.03669453784823418, -0.025518735870718956, 0.005266902968287468, 0.045409075915813446, -0.0020403123926371336, 0.017103062942624092, 0.0059397220611572266, -0.022931460291147232, -0.019565533846616745, -0.005102101713418961, 0.014848560094833374, 0.005701511632651091, 0.05913131311535835, -0.01857699640095234, 0.04203866794705391, 0.03005046583712101, 0.0729627013206482, 0.00020825822139158845, 0.06979052722454071, -0.0012250327272340655, -0.01871791109442711, 0.03031848929822445, -0.004461705219000578, 0.07224635034799576, 0.005185544490814209, 0.018870996311306953, 0.020154977217316628, 0.01792125776410103, 0.019576948136091232, 0.012752071022987366, -0.0032915608026087284, 0.01008233055472374, 0.01439150795340538, -0.02107390947639942, -0.0035950227174907923, 0.028029128909111023, -0.0402102954685688, 0.06280067563056946, -0.04583361744880676, -0.025758566334843636, -0.03376058116555214, -0.026697564870119095, 0.01882803626358509, -0.007204366382211447, 0.002146937418729067, -0.015423395670950413, 0.00900198519229889, 0.024809757247567177, -0.007847050204873085, 0.024316631257534027, -0.0005146573530510068, -0.019853519275784492, -0.010789982043206692, -0.012449683621525764, -0.02975868619978428, 0.03728203848004341, -0.009896860457956791, -0.018978996202349663, 0.033045992255210876, -0.004242416936904192, -0.05224805325269699, -0.017082948237657547, 0.0034828700590878725, 0.0042019071988761425, -0.03289809823036194, -0.008648394607007504, -0.0019046427914872766, -0.04482297971844673, -0.04424794390797615, -0.0063668289221823215, -0.022841408848762512, -0.008401600643992424, -0.04121711850166321, 0.036385707557201385, 0.011155418120324612, -0.007049420848488808, -0.021169593557715416, 0.06032509356737137, -0.0541846789419651, -0.007109975442290306, -0.02828795276582241, -0.004921347834169865, 0.004453388042747974, 0.019129756838083267, 0.02474359981715679, -0.014495693147182465, 0.00019106062245555222, 0.05190997198224068, -0.013571850024163723, -0.04388722777366638, -0.060786131769418716, -0.03533758968114853, -0.02645338512957096, -0.011034201830625534, 0.011632257141172886, -0.002308770315721631, -0.007494968827813864, -0.011691822670400143, 0.006866674404591322, 0.04308949038386345, 0.04597444459795952, 0.024921603500843048, 0.011044135317206383, 0.011997755616903305, -0.00720657454803586, -0.018632153049111366, 0.022523604333400726, 0.04582925885915756, -0.04471203312277794, 0.0018363031558692455, -0.011114059947431087, 0.04687841981649399, 0.020706336945295334, 0.00401312205940485, 0.017904920503497124, 0.013807209208607674, -0.010631387121975422, -0.09127254039049149, 0.00396689772605896, -0.0025636327918618917, -0.008133144117891788, 0.013599095866084099, -0.003940219525247812, 0.01825817860662937, -0.024042123928666115, -0.0073731886222958565, 0.02150760032236576, 0.006480698008090258, 0.001829518936574459, 0.004261653870344162, -0.03886895999312401, -0.0026569035835564137, -0.022594820708036423, 0.020701946690678596, 0.005147650837898254, 0.06473523378372192, 0.06011306494474411, 0.02280869148671627, 0.0060112266801297665, -0.06256327033042908, 0.04079919680953026, -0.06666217744350433, -0.029821183532476425, -0.017974592745304108, 0.03512579947710037, -0.0038202458526939154, 0.018408389762043953, -0.003318388480693102, 0.0028343393933027983, -0.012491804547607899, 0.020942168310284615, -0.03340813145041466, -0.0013786404160782695, -0.04237912595272064, -0.012929240241646767, 0.014681263826787472, 0.04096365347504616, 0.030235348269343376, 0.008241643197834492, -0.04995668679475784, -0.029199572280049324, 0.015485234558582306, -0.033915381878614426, 0.027484653517603874, -0.019055699929594994, -0.019125832244753838, 0.0026753630954772234, 0.0028598401695489883, -0.006760720629245043, -0.01923641748726368, 0.003410385688766837, 0.025133514776825905, -0.008744733408093452, 0.013225174508988857, -0.029832808300852776, -0.004550478421151638, -0.011104554869234562, 0.009724115021526814, 0.012897529639303684, 0.028679274022579193, -0.03357881307601929, 0.011805720627307892, 0.005294855684041977, 0.06444396078586578, 0.045096319168806076, -0.012507145293056965, -0.01885022036731243, -0.024811958894133568, -0.002270434983074665, -0.011195247992873192, -0.024407481774687767, -0.013639485463500023, 0.03483225032687187, 0.048899587243795395, 0.005324476398527622, -0.09645401686429977, 0.027621816843748093, 0.062054529786109924, -0.006806575693190098, -0.021530156955122948, -0.024070993065834045, -0.011741630733013153, 0.004890069365501404, 0.007379668299108744, 0.03893518075346947, 0.031947262585163116, 0.00709093501791358, 0.020498501136898994, 0.02682744339108467, -0.03420291468501091, -0.024276699870824814, -0.003358287736773491, 0.07038337737321854, 0.05944996327161789, 0.00737215019762516, -0.01716563105583191, 0.0371028408408165, 0.01056702435016632, 0.03212935850024223, 0.023678641766309738, 0.015079773031175137, -0.08976911753416061, -0.010620316490530968, 0.042252931743860245, -0.0009407793986611068, -0.024815913289785385, -0.012510727159678936, -0.03550419583916664, -0.04795023426413536, 0.08180534839630127, -0.03910878673195839, -0.012821316719055176, -0.04827817529439926, -0.00902644731104374, -0.029852505773305893, 0.029390426352620125, -0.002213891362771392, 0.024499300867319107, 0.00006110603135311976, 0.033107366412878036, 0.0058125280775129795, 0.012954780831933022, -0.06935484707355499, 0.05798250436782837, -0.022080080583691597, 0.06396308541297913, -0.003276731353253126, -0.01483302190899849, -0.011427905410528183, 0.015488711185753345, -0.05968271195888519, -0.05528705194592476, -0.022746490314602852, 0.007101297844201326, -0.028663944453001022, 0.03176429867744446, -0.017274444922804832, -0.035444632172584534, -0.02510065771639347, 0.021677833050489426, -0.039004553109407425, 0.02741517871618271, -0.022732025012373924, 0.011887450702488422, 0.012044254690408707, 0.022702183574438095, 0.04612373188138008, 0.01985078491270542, -0.02940218523144722, -0.0017241864698007703, 0.020875243470072746, 0.004834613297134638, -0.04848726838827133, -0.04078865796327591, -0.017029987648129463, -0.0023967642337083817, -0.01431402936577797, 0.011316421441733837, -0.009173792786896229, 0.03296803683042526, -0.03457796946167946, -0.009550796821713448, -0.02030148357152939, 0.07208054512739182, 0.001922787050716579, -0.0334964320063591, 0.014824523590505123, 0.047991156578063965, -0.031047528609633446, -0.049192462116479874, 0.0420018807053566, -0.019848879426717758, -0.005466478876769543, 0.006486519705504179, -0.017168186604976654, 0.027483398094773293, -0.034061647951602936, -0.03170326352119446, 0.005894718691706657, -0.027877654880285263, 0.0755254253745079, 0.007514014840126038, 0.02467227540910244, -0.027255911380052567, -0.0712815672159195, -0.011913862079381943, 0.030491389334201813, 0.007835051976144314, 0.017885610461235046, -0.04146465286612511, 0.05556869134306908, -0.007207030430436134, -0.05177009105682373, -0.06714849174022675, -0.031367190182209015, 0.026018498465418816, -0.016296599060297012, -0.03756218031048775, -0.05061626434326172, 0.018141645938158035, 0.009429576806724072, 0.010943250730633736, 0.013245071284472942, 0.03205832839012146, -0.03873000666499138, 0.0020463343244045973, -0.014996815472841263, 0.03170116990804672, 0.037634193897247314, -0.026563694700598717, 0.029499471187591553, 0.01192517764866352, 0.01198743749409914, -0.013521035201847553, -0.026219602674245834, 0.01195604633539915, -0.01999352127313614, 0.003202032297849655, -0.06591621041297913, 0.01401474978774786, 0.006108604371547699, 0.0011467511067166924, 0.020035112276673317, -0.0021300839725881815, -0.027300367131829262, 0.012810329906642437, -0.04151928052306175, 0.0077862790785729885, -0.006037244573235512, 0.027525397017598152, -0.0759548544883728, -0.000806802068836987, -0.006859197281301022, 0.02023574896156788, 0.04157818481326103, -0.009478666819632053, 0.04316214472055435, -0.0013568674912676215, 0.03149842098355293, -0.0088040791451931, 0.03571684658527374, 0.047706905752420425, -0.003284402657300234, 0.018867485225200653, -0.005371913779526949, 0.006039778236299753, 0.010915307328104973, 0.0029762473423033953, -0.011915985494852066, -0.06137004494667053, -0.0046604108065366745, 0.0005339336930774152, 0.04829953983426094, 0.004152445122599602, 0.014454185031354427, 0.03363762050867081, -0.006672959309071302, 0.00726229976862669, -0.03590041399002075, -0.03564899042248726, -0.024565769359469414, 0.03514580801129341, 0.05701112747192383, 0.012506620958447456, 0.009428403340280056, 0.05234101787209511, 0.0608757883310318, 0.003323387121781707, 0.052375487983226776, -0.004890389274805784, 0.004222503863275051, -0.0016724892193451524, -0.005825752392411232, -0.026881523430347443, 0.02479575201869011, -0.016220584511756897, 0.00023335653531830758, -0.006531248800456524, -0.07303451001644135, 0.02864677459001541, 0.016336018219590187, 0.0023826141841709614, -0.05392182990908623, -0.0262876208871603, -0.044762227684259415, 0.025448810309171677, 0.006303693167865276, -0.01352789718657732, 0.04229411855340004, -0.022085469216108322, 0.021398786455392838, -0.008947734721004963, 0.028086137026548386, -0.009478569030761719, -0.07986611872911453, -0.03878387436270714, -0.019610190764069557, -0.03730544075369835, 0.04700438305735588, 0.0004407480882946402, -0.034212809056043625, 0.02285236120223999, -0.02555634267628193, 0.011610873974859715, -0.004794103559106588, 0.02978580817580223, -0.021753940731287003, 0.08932434767484665, -0.0356643982231617, 0.011194519698619843, -0.01894085481762886, -0.009937683120369911, 0.12374348193407059, 0.0861361175775528, 0.03319575637578964, -0.10436677932739258, 0.014604120515286922, 0.04088645428419113, 0.02531113661825657, -0.01682242937386036, 0.022905390709638596, 0.035259537398815155, -0.02212970145046711, 0.03338026627898216, 0.10534124076366425, 0.018930429592728615, 0.047396764159202576, 0.048287972807884216, -0.011084840632975101, -0.021238554269075394, -0.0008794475579634309, 0.029867518693208694, 0.014026317745447159, -0.000133941211970523, -0.048137255012989044, -0.00836912076920271, 0.007779370062053204, -0.004432739224284887, -0.03699547052383423, -0.019002486020326614, 0.00821702554821968, 0.01730808988213539, -0.023305384442210197, 0.003081247676163912, 0.03495781123638153, 0.028378216549754143, -0.013868306763470173, -0.02764819748699665, 0.025505410507321358, 0.014282295480370522, -0.014872826635837555, 0.0181247778236866, -0.02069845236837864, 0.035271406173706055, -0.015226836316287518, -0.01378793828189373, -0.017102815210819244, -0.007334538269788027, -0.017598377540707588, 0.006813387386500835, -0.011063740588724613, 0.015073957853019238, -0.022555820643901825, 0.0031191676389425993, 0.012536656111478806, 0.0016168669098988175, -0.0038340934552252293, 0.04148181155323982, 0.06483900547027588, -0.04602143540978432, -0.040422890335321426, -0.014118057675659657, 0.020263195037841797, -0.047766346484422684, 0.021224884316325188, -0.018199216574430466, -0.04702640324831009, 0.022573448717594147, -0.01850963942706585, -0.04272341728210449, -0.023169375956058502, -0.00791947916150093, -0.010536346584558487, -0.004326375667005777, -0.04558184742927551, -0.028502194210886955, 0.030958756804466248, -0.00043980026384815574, 0.0071236751973629, 0.0163030494004488, 0.008656851015985012, -0.040531404316425323, -0.06691808998584747, -0.018163062632083893, -0.029115961864590645, -0.010185368359088898, -0.007312283385545015, -0.0043062311597168446, 0.042274173349142075, 0.009388023056089878, 0.031209075823426247, 0.030997032299637794, -0.015109207481145859, 0.004895349964499474, 0.006339273881167173, -0.05600505694746971, 0.029108189046382904, -0.00011076089140260592, -0.054451003670692444, -0.002587523777037859, -0.033036064356565475, 0.02524946816265583, 0.005814171861857176, 0.057180240750312805, -0.017524706199765205, 0.04334452748298645, -0.006245465017855167, 0.029893863946199417, 0.02321752905845642, -0.057959217578172684, -0.01508971769362688, 0.019173268228769302, 0.012235647067427635, -0.041530899703502655, -0.01961243338882923, -0.05369938537478447, -0.028729412704706192, 0.01591476984322071, 0.0339789092540741, -0.04077880084514618, 0.0476941280066967, -0.0019459258764982224, 0.01685025542974472, -0.04748346656560898, 0.021589631214737892, -0.016021564602851868, -0.009829350747168064, 0.004503448493778706, -0.06719757616519928, 0.030958181247115135, -0.004827121738344431, 0.016852175816893578, 0.0038713933899998665, 0.003724733367562294, -0.00022486341185867786, -0.002737897215411067, 0.004896015394479036, 0.0007908627740107477, -0.004709659144282341, 0.046436965465545654, -0.020802950486540794, -0.0034630950540304184, 0.03836717829108238, -0.00965724978595972, -0.04728570580482483, 0.0060644811019301414, -0.008932908996939659, 0.043531667441129684, 0.02384583093225956, -0.021310778334736824, 0.016696341335773468, 0.06648790091276169, -0.019463198259472847, -0.0026289387606084347, -0.000469266960863024, 0.008071116171777248, 0.03829145431518555, -0.0009238453931175172, 0.018209483474493027, 0.0067391954362392426, -0.05340103432536125, 0.024187486618757248, 0.04069497808814049, 0.009575187228620052, -0.022342771291732788, 0.024784693494439125, -0.028455551713705063, 0.031514447182416916, 0.012997889891266823, 0.0019436802249401808, 0.021180029958486557, 0.020435549318790436, -0.012210214510560036, 0.02863958664238453, 0.01113327406346798, 0.03153420612215996, -0.054681528359651566, 0.0054522412829101086, -0.0028148016426712275, -0.0022057436872273684, 0.028150999918580055, -0.01924704760313034, -0.003083477495238185, 0.055786777287721634, -0.06251976639032364, 0.02641887217760086, -0.006141001358628273, -0.027349507436156273, -0.015630686655640602, 0.024647464975714684, -0.015531478449702263, 0.031951963901519775, 0.02755836769938469, -0.005147748161107302, 0.0057751950807869434, 0.027735713869333267, -0.009532563388347626, -0.010753887705504894, -0.023131778463721275, 0.048749882727861404, 0.009399443864822388, -0.045851707458496094, 0.043771445751190186, -0.04522310569882393, -0.020363731309771538, 0.049514591693878174, -0.008846101351082325, 0.04903259873390198, 0.009649144485592842, 0.010483551770448685, -0.05245190113782883, 0.026310868561267853, 0.0341687835752964, 0.011969180777668953, -0.027141408994793892, -0.013875014148652554, 0.000787014898378402, 0.03566655516624451, -0.005830107722431421, 0.032190628349781036, 0.019435124471783638, 0.0002615945995785296, -0.04497162252664566, 0.06032105162739754, -0.012919713743031025, -0.01752099022269249, -0.0015685490798205137, 0.010406180284917355, 0.026351340115070343, -0.03098617121577263, 0.0526568703353405, -0.031673967838287354, 0.004556380677968264, 0.025536904111504555, 0.039583709090948105, 0.02391865663230419, 0.011218919418752193, -0.0205790214240551, -0.02917167916893959, 0.04135546088218689, -0.013339758850634098, -0.013154659420251846, -0.047153886407613754, -0.023713717237114906, -0.004576564766466618, 0.001955985324457288, -0.04486452043056488, 0.025733912363648415, 0.022234756499528885, 0.046996694058179855, 0.017317691817879677, -0.018705571070313454, 0.03250705823302269, -0.03843274340033531, 0.0028369685169309378, -0.07707928866147995, 0.05976417660713196, 0.012053738348186016, -0.013147296383976936, -0.0405583530664444, -0.0143912797793746, -0.002632960444316268, -0.02565351128578186, 0.025899918749928474, -0.02731904573738575, 0.036007508635520935, -0.024727236479520798, 0.021234944462776184, 0.024541622027754784, 0.01165436115115881, 0.028400644659996033, 0.014014874584972858, 0.00165497325360775, -0.022123342379927635, -0.03583676367998123, 0.004830522462725639, 0.016468998044729233, 0.030372709035873413, 0.008309905417263508, -0.008969612419605255, 0.017258573323488235, -0.038421615958213806, 0.027847308665513992, 0.04078628495335579, -0.008418532088398933, 0.026224199682474136, -0.022766148671507835, -0.004581511951982975, 0.0762522742152214, -0.013889499939978123, -0.011823930777609348, 0.02172790840268135, -0.04575250297784805, -0.045073501765728, -0.01134482305496931, -0.0028351275250315666, -0.021488940343260765, -0.05805612727999687, 0.0171810332685709, 0.026340318843722343, -0.012977120466530323, 0.015580917708575726, -0.0005512312054634094, 0.045431625097990036, 0.050091806799173355, 0.020218433812260628, -0.01354183629155159, 0.05356504023075104, -0.015736408531665802, -0.0043121762573719025, 0.013609107583761215, 0.06302547454833984, 0.0010112676536664367, -0.011155434884130955, 0.010508961044251919, -0.03162137791514397, 0.05547741800546646, -0.04374399781227112, 0.05763574317097664, -0.054180391132831573, -0.056663159281015396, 0.008681712672114372, 0.025789786130189896, 0.009484912268817425, 0.0366782546043396, -0.05881848558783531, 0.06596849113702774, -0.029153097420930862, 0.003925099968910217, -0.03611920773983002, 0.03444388508796692, -0.054101645946502686, -0.04387433081865311, -0.015766063705086708, 0.02684902586042881, -0.03499920293688774, 0.013120917603373528, -0.01900695450603962, -0.013630238361656666, 0.049371954053640366, 0.009499688632786274, 0.007758049294352531, 0.020549597218632698, 0.01807892508804798, -0.027411984279751778, -0.035451944917440414, -0.006561031099408865, 0.0063046058639883995, 0.03702714666724205, 0.01749165914952755, -0.003485356690362096, -0.04479794576764107, -0.04195817559957504, -0.06335360556840897, 0.04434040188789368, -0.06008446216583252, 0.0003199299389962107, -0.024452462792396545, -0.009876598604023457, -0.03587343916296959, -0.015674851834774017 ]
<p>This may be a very simple question, but I am not sure about my logic.</p> <p>I have a standard point hypothesis testing scenario, where I collect a sequence of $n$ independent observations $\{x_1,\ldots,x_n\}$ and attempt to classify them as either generated from the distribution $P(x_1,\ldots,x_n;\theta=\theta_0)$ or $P(x_1,\ldots,x_n;\theta=\theta_1)$, where $\theta_0$ and $\theta_1$ are known. Using the knowledge of the joint probability density function $f(x_1,\ldots,x_n;\theta)$, I can construct a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Likelihood-ratio_test" rel="nofollow">likelihood ratio test</a>, which is optimal in the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neyman%E2%80%93Pearson_lemma" rel="nofollow">Neyman-Pearson</a> sense. Let's denote the likelihood ratio test statistic by $\Lambda(x_1,\ldots,x_n)$.</p> <p>However, when either hypothesis $H_0$ or $H_1$ is true, the test statistic converges in probability to the same constant, i.e. $\Lambda(x_1,\ldots,x_n)\xrightarrow{\mathcal{P}}\lambda$. Formally, for any $\epsilon&gt;0$, $\delta&gt;0$, there exists $n_0$ such that for all $n\geq n_0$, the following equations hold: </p> <p>$$\tag{1}P(|\Lambda(x_1,\ldots,x_n)-\lambda|&gt;\epsilon|\theta=\theta_0)&lt;\delta$$ $$\tag{2}P(|\Lambda(x_1,\ldots,x_n)-\lambda|&gt;\epsilon|\theta=\theta_1)&lt;\delta$$</p> <p>with $\lambda$ a known constant.</p> <p>Does this mean that it's impossible to classify between $H_0$ and $H_1$, even as one obtains increasing number of observations? I think it is and here is my logic. Fix $\epsilon$ and $\delta$. Suppose our $n\geq n_0$ and suppose we would like to upper bound the probability of Type I error by $\delta$. We thus select a threshold $t$ for the test such that</p> <p>$$P(\Lambda(x_1,\ldots,x_n)&gt;t|\theta=\theta_0)&lt;\delta$$</p> <p>By $(1)$ this implies that $t\geq\lambda+\epsilon$. However, by $(2)$, this also implies that</p> <p>$$P(\Lambda(x_1,\ldots,x_n)\leq t|\theta=\theta_1)\geq 1-\delta$$</p> <p>resulting in the probability of Type II error being lower-bounded close to one. I think means that no matter how you set your threshold, the best test is as good as deciding between the two hypothesis by flipping a coin (biased coin if there are unequal priors).</p> <p>Is that correct?</p>
74,256
[ -0.04519309103488922, -0.027451572939753532, 0.032968729734420776, -0.018589291721582413, -0.02372557669878006, 0.011962275952100754, 0.015348139218986034, -0.013870649971067905, 0.045640718191862106, -0.025035923346877098, 0.018256014212965965, 0.051590219140052795, 0.047140587121248245, 0.03485594317317009, 0.027170967310667038, 0.02913934737443924, -0.02253315970301628, 0.07102931290864944, -0.022615408524870872, -0.01905605010688305, 0.018501169979572296, 0.007066085934638977, 0.04137363284826279, -0.02154485695064068, -0.03669263795018196, 0.0018938364228233695, 0.017136860638856888, -0.005407511722296476, -0.0014944609720259905, 0.10764209926128387, -0.03920132666826248, -0.02487572282552719, 0.011870875023305416, 0.06488123536109924, -0.018425947055220604, 0.021181825548410416, 0.014814265072345734, 0.013929922133684158, -0.006384202744811773, 0.03151294216513634, -0.062421444803476334, -0.020927535369992256, 0.048263028264045715, 0.04146895185112953, 0.0018605745863169432, 0.03208938241004944, -0.012437278404831886, -0.07631205022335052, -0.00911699142307043, -0.03636186197400093, 0.05584077909588814, 0.01283179223537445, 0.00871302466839552, 0.04520471766591072, 0.0018775511998683214, -0.02888641320168972, 0.03203631937503815, 0.06222494691610336, -0.037257902324199677, -0.055121030658483505, -0.027487197890877724, -0.06096656993031502, 0.008352534845471382, -0.007326857186853886, -0.03747401386499405, 0.03623596578836441, -0.022460155189037323, -0.00615305919200182, 0.0050910040736198425, -0.03648306801915169, 0.02131476253271103, 0.0033940330613404512, 0.039618633687496185, -0.019076624885201454, -0.010411165654659271, -0.023861059918999672, -0.006911004893481731, 0.035876333713531494, 0.030701015144586563, 0.04321969300508499, 0.013899223878979683, -0.00038343234336934984, 0.04480167478322983, 0.05190455541014671, 0.016828838735818863, -0.002345991088077426, 0.07919015735387802, -0.02685525268316269, -0.013243911787867546, 0.02829725481569767, -0.007193020544946194, -0.016238471493124962, 0.021610522642731667, -0.057159338146448135, -0.02539462223649025, 0.054869145154953, -0.032466210424900055, 0.006183710414916277, 0.00019869890820700675, -0.03083018586039543, -0.03154611960053444, -0.03960307314991951, 0.006927000358700752, 0.03289858624339104, -0.006543080788105726, -0.023856135085225105, -0.015312430448830128, -0.001045378390699625, -0.026464039459824562, -0.01282714307308197, -0.014326376840472221, 0.06666073948144913, 0.0049038054421544075, 0.05092873051762581, -0.03975362703204155, 0.0004409763205330819, 0.0012145355576649308, -0.050623342394828796, 0.06620162725448608, 0.05895978957414627, 0.060591910034418106, -0.0026494539342820644, 0.012016115710139275, -0.004886331036686897, -0.02787657640874386, 0.0002477151283528656, -0.008980153128504753, -0.01594661921262741, -0.019417857751250267, 0.024733899161219597, -0.017151573672890663, 0.016230089589953423, 0.06779202818870544, 0.07084684073925018, 0.013973300345242023, 0.01653219945728779, -0.0815676599740982, -0.015383104793727398, 0.04457911103963852, -0.0007154868799261749, 0.015841269865632057, -0.054421085864305496, 0.009567451663315296, 0.055725205689668655, 0.015586989931762218, -0.007138820365071297, 0.07100541144609451, 0.0016408334486186504, 0.03811623156070709, 0.03152844309806824, -0.02741401083767414, -0.02769657038152218, -0.018411964178085327, -0.020357562229037285, -0.04795034974813461, -0.06943195313215256, -0.0009825844317674637, -0.01369186770170927, -0.02074573002755642, -0.01594528742134571, 0.05047883093357086, 0.0002636133576743305, -0.03139564394950867, -0.06430798768997192, 0.031232347711920738, -0.009436318650841713, 0.051153577864170074, 0.008741254918277264, 0.025314422324299812, 0.03092440776526928, -0.010952199809253216, 0.038628414273262024, 0.0038441987708210945, 0.036297526210546494, 0.03318504989147186, -0.06726142764091492, -0.04922211170196533, -0.04768845811486244, 0.03014502488076687, 0.041268184781074524, -0.010727586224675179, 0.023523440584540367, -0.035392072051763535, 0.007134842686355114, 0.04805140197277069, 0.03503577038645744, -0.0007042833603918552, -0.0036748943384736776, 0.020606422796845436, -0.047220662236213684, -0.007731247693300247, -0.03754480928182602, -0.029220767319202423, 0.022496480494737625, -0.03307221829891205, 0.08877716213464737, 0.00005965200034552254, -0.01785123534500599, -0.030445672571659088, -0.001744980225339532, -0.062021296471357346, -0.0042270272970199585, 0.02072792500257492, -0.04494655132293701, 0.0139310946688056, 0.044343214482069016, 0.05181804671883583, 0.008519774302840233, 0.041065514087677, -0.0334269218146801, -0.037557557225227356, 0.02591610699892044, -0.03141026943922043, 0.004536211024969816, -0.005021686665713787, 0.037594910711050034, -0.013317531906068325, -0.009822580963373184, -0.007193191442638636, 0.03557838872075081, -0.07491845637559891, 0.028504375368356705, 0.04943433031439781, 0.006525042466819286, 0.0296156108379364, -0.02487691305577755, -0.016501346603035927, 0.00405100779607892, -0.04282010346651077, 0.023259416222572327, -0.05857708677649498, 0.03002120368182659, 0.04585351049900055, 0.05297737941145897, -0.04972454532980919, 0.022966405376791954, 0.053270358592271805, 0.022404469549655914, -0.012399586848914623, 0.04887327924370766, 0.011458266526460648, -0.018868010491132736, 0.003014711895957589, 0.012742050923407078, -0.021163711324334145, 0.015925271436572075, 0.04155528172850609, -0.0073309303261339664, 0.0678589791059494, -0.01479275617748499, -0.031675104051828384, 0.07117673009634018, 0.010596781969070435, 0.009588819928467274, 0.006104334257543087, 0.015973908826708794, -0.0029792916029691696, -0.005517907906323671, 0.0050082579255104065, 0.022860633209347725, 0.008624054491519928, 0.005968071985989809, -0.018633868545293808, 0.010530351661145687, 0.04031338915228844, 0.041569773107767105, -0.01197830867022276, 0.02498565800487995, 0.012366886250674725, -0.04164145141839981, -0.024474162608385086, -0.02505749650299549, -0.03688337653875351, 0.007548332214355469, -0.006327962502837181, 0.0007604997372254729, 0.009843909181654453, -0.01819879375398159, -0.03736486658453941, -0.03501182422041893, 0.017111752182245255, -0.011888793669641018, 0.054967205971479416, -0.013110793195664883, -0.02969959005713463, -0.03433343768119812, -0.006210717372596264, -0.049899209290742874, 0.014731020666658878, -0.005511107854545116, -0.001135986065492034, -0.012341603636741638, -0.005703114904463291, -0.06601026654243469, -0.03336529806256294, -0.04800156131386757, -0.01589616946876049, -0.0585072785615921, -0.018909402191638947, 0.04501819610595703, 0.015533698722720146, -0.06386810541152954, 0.01367951650172472, -0.026830380782485008, -0.04066857695579529, -0.019866326823830605, -0.0002167996863136068, 0.019238222390413284, -0.004199556540697813, 0.03754148259758949, 0.03331780061125755, -0.017074821516871452, -0.005330552812665701, -0.06855320930480957, -0.05623278766870499, 0.00017919213860295713, -0.00755248311907053, 0.05246925726532936, 0.0045365989208221436, -0.019774040207266808, 0.06171896681189537, 0.031348343938589096, -0.01113828830420971, -0.023843394592404366, 0.051470547914505005, -0.012921572662889957, 0.002177366055548191, 0.02147444151341915, 0.013228672556579113, -0.000028965656383661553, 0.028697609901428223, -0.004585179500281811, 0.03655823692679405, 0.05497968941926956, -0.0008019424276426435, 0.025050774216651917, 0.061642635613679886, 0.06361422687768936, -0.008804243989288807, 0.03780641779303551, 0.03513380512595177, -0.03184749558568001, 0.0043776920065283775, 0.009930972941219807, 0.03897272050380707, 0.006052152719348669, -0.029191549867391586, 0.03278832882642746, -0.003119770437479019, 0.009817068465054035, 0.004601681604981422, 0.024609480053186417, 0.05634337663650513, -0.04286724328994751, -0.023464085534214973, 0.0020288238301873207, 0.03759446740150452, -0.04336053505539894, -0.006913085468113422, 0.05632338672876358, 0.062049899250268936, -0.01099733542650938, -0.033178891986608505, 0.005090124439448118, -0.03141993656754494, 0.0293506421148777, -0.020067470148205757, -0.024230625480413437, 0.022806767374277115, 0.03155720233917236, 0.014365200884640217, -0.017507636919617653, -0.00037761201383545995, 0.012228252366185188, -0.034603219479322433, 0.01926891878247261, 0.0020035922061651945, 0.03370354697108269, -0.002285113325342536, 0.04249010235071182, 0.045239903032779694, -0.03789406269788742, -0.0024484465830028057, -0.003639667062088847, -0.055039260536432266, 0.022993458434939384, -0.011234955862164497, -0.01955222897231579, 0.005523428786545992, -0.018526898697018623, 0.03516331687569618, -0.04653553292155266, 0.031109213829040527, -0.013550461269915104, 0.041315559297800064, -0.03750156983733177, 0.050445523113012314, -0.013336720876395702, -0.025582168251276016, 0.013940646313130856, 0.051949393004179, -0.011186797171831131, 0.01312855165451765, 0.01857776753604412, 0.06474167853593826, -0.0029387411195784807, 0.02589859440922737, 0.01394989900290966, 0.016643740236759186, -0.005216648336499929, 0.02591230347752571, 0.012157636694610119, 0.0638701394200325, -0.02015613578259945, 0.02924618311226368, -0.018181703984737396, 0.03338795527815819, 0.027920039370656013, -0.03396850451827049, 0.0060141501016914845, -0.016025783494114876, -0.029307812452316284, -0.013019075617194176, 0.0336897075176239, 0.055347345769405365, -0.01932237111032009, 0.04393544793128967, 0.02901989035308361, 0.002303115790709853, -0.0018059491412714124, 0.042245879769325256, 0.010972808115184307, 0.01493494026362896, -0.01923021487891674, -0.0051143295131623745, -0.015447566285729408, 0.03389574959874153, -0.002549602882936597, 0.02128623239696026, -0.009389338083565235, -0.029075348749756813, 0.03454820439219475, 0.01482019480317831, -0.02865862101316452, -0.019191764295101166, -0.00440204469487071, 0.031319547444581985, 0.01756655052304268, -0.004217188805341721, 0.03537790849804878, 0.004977378528565168, 0.03483082354068756, 0.005510514136403799, 0.01078950148075819, -0.058675628155469894, -0.014576154761016369, 0.026951409876346588, 0.0312931165099144, -0.019815944135189056, -0.013941671699285507, -0.03734053298830986, -0.011921591125428677, 0.012975272722542286, -0.00434507429599762, 0.029377462342381477, 0.023648757487535477, -0.013978932052850723, -0.011370647698640823, -0.01244913786649704, -0.07562537491321564, 0.012941488064825535, -0.01223014760762453, -0.002047332003712654, -0.032241035252809525, 0.019094636663794518, -0.043309736996889114, 0.007544549647718668, 0.01616937853395939, 0.06824775040149689, -0.020673606544733047, -0.04389697313308716, -0.004373560659587383, 0.005983245559036732, 0.005219155922532082, -0.046132512390613556, 0.036904431879520416, 0.002484358847141266, 0.0324317142367363, -0.005004912614822388, -0.026973510161042213, -0.0607895627617836, 0.02763318456709385, -0.026915209367871284, -0.05112117528915405, 0.06084189563989639, 0.009773056022822857, 0.038948383182287216, 0.006420564372092485, 0.019390970468521118, 0.041576310992240906, 0.04072335362434387, 0.0011005393462255597, 0.007984239608049393, -0.047328636050224304, -0.023325137794017792, -0.05821612477302551, 0.006777486298233271, -0.06913916766643524, 0.012988511472940445, -0.03490824997425079, 0.025153646245598793, -0.007453614845871925, 0.03689932823181152, 0.014588569290935993, 0.00578815583139658, -0.015602379105985165, 0.012610137462615967, -0.00833015888929367, 0.012777387164533138, -0.02961728163063526, 0.012264220044016838, 0.03335604816675186, 0.028059106320142746, 0.012619199231266975, -0.03971521928906441, 0.016183188185095787, 0.03464449569582939, -0.036011021584272385, 0.01758989505469799, -0.019518662244081497, -0.0028975936584174633, 0.003868426661938429, -0.028530726209282875, 0.025232503190636635, 0.028675595298409462, 0.019894378259778023, 0.006534762680530548, -0.03878642991185188, -0.020437875762581825, 0.012996649369597435, 0.0003848900378216058, 0.04158119112253189, 0.0009021673467941582, -0.02785787172615528, 0.002233220497146249, -0.013256784528493881, -0.06676196306943893, 0.017555680125951767, -0.0123291015625, -0.006508717313408852, -0.009196196682751179, -0.026045868173241615, 0.0010053549194708467, 0.05334026366472244, -0.02561873570084572, -0.013133740983903408, 0.08285404741764069, -0.010616876184940338, -0.060129232704639435, -0.011096032336354256, 0.041230395436286926, 0.07052382826805115, -0.0035440309438854456, 0.0029967022128403187, 0.00505740474909544, -0.017622796818614006, -0.007586839608848095, 0.034288741648197174, 0.0010119650978595018, -0.03008403815329075, -0.018340127542614937, -0.029599210247397423, -0.010661468841135502, 0.015406801365315914, -0.01567937061190605, -0.03398929536342621, -0.003535742172971368, 0.000527349766343832, -0.008957354351878166, -0.013992498628795147, -0.035252876579761505, -0.03408006578683853, 0.018224159255623817, 0.010825756005942822, 0.004615354351699352, -0.016584910452365875, -0.010919555090367794, 0.020947417244315147, -0.02019764482975006, -0.005356896668672562, 0.011993719264864922, 0.04016264155507088, -0.030249256640672684, -0.022437185049057007, 0.0013936490286141634, 0.005961677525192499, 0.011107933707535267, 0.014803188852965832, 0.009638123214244843, 0.007861369289457798, 0.01067679189145565, -0.052775461226701736, 0.012493201531469822, -0.04891083762049675, 0.0008057532249949872, 0.05526037514209747, 0.026118891313672066, 0.045878760516643524, -0.0018880994757637382, 0.011724043637514114, 0.0021859165281057358, -0.03211039677262306, 0.0019706229213625193, -0.04339374601840973, -0.0017411495791748166, -0.0015676612965762615, -0.027104977518320084, -0.026511242613196373, 0.08811364322900772, 0.017134565860033035, 0.004629978444427252, 0.0038230956997722387, -0.0052830870263278484, 0.03389197587966919, 0.04034917801618576, -0.03633471950888634, -0.033387016505002975, 0.048067402094602585, -0.0723198875784874, 0.00009190027049044147, -0.02044898085296154, -0.05134133994579315, 0.003987394738942385, 0.017863113433122635, 0.007252637296915054, -0.033182598650455475, -0.02412203513085842, -0.07411814481019974, 0.03932720050215721, -0.016485314816236496, 0.012231143191456795, 0.045578353106975555, 0.015140282921493053, 0.040539100766181946, 0.0004190139879938215, 0.0002946966851595789, -0.01347188651561737, -0.07706276327371597, -0.023135017603635788, 0.0029348856769502163, -0.04187709465622902, 0.013829370960593224, -0.026302514597773552, -0.05305982008576393, 0.029611743986606598, 0.006462548393756151, 0.030052974820137024, 0.005081712268292904, 0.02013210579752922, -0.06341058760881424, 0.06826844066381454, -0.008985323831439018, 0.029514314606785774, -0.025171808898448944, -0.024002740159630775, 0.13229651749134064, 0.03810993954539299, 0.04815710335969925, -0.05880500748753548, 0.01019881758838892, 0.00893665011972189, 0.000450215011369437, -0.03576008602976799, 0.013960910961031914, 0.03915126249194145, -0.016713086515665054, 0.01450084988027811, 0.04455103352665901, 0.0123829310759902, -0.025351963937282562, 0.07751869410276413, -0.010357173159718513, -0.0046500167809426785, -0.0007383035845123231, 0.03380163013935089, -0.0033764399122446775, 0.006721718702465296, 0.00799122266471386, -0.013508479110896587, -0.006954117212444544, 0.0037123055662959814, -0.027047041803598404, -0.010010856203734875, -0.021355798467993736, -0.015971621498465538, -0.01892830617725849, -0.03520910441875458, 0.024086996912956238, 0.001476090052165091, -0.005509990733116865, 0.0009934833506122231, -0.012615155428647995, -0.025252535939216614, 0.016756867989897728, 0.053191058337688446, 0.02098034881055355, 0.002896289573982358, 0.031799789518117905, -0.0017270745011046529, -0.03239569440484047, -0.01506491843611002, -0.038405075669288635, 0.03786224126815796, -0.0101981395855546, -0.0014261354226619005, 0.005278677213937044, -0.031219080090522766, -0.002190147992223501, -0.021807782351970673, -0.009547688066959381, 0.011289765127003193, 0.027043107897043228, 0.015105025842785835, -0.020932339131832123, -0.026624182239174843, 0.04139871150255203, -0.02238406054675579, 0.06481000781059265, 0.008578279986977577, -0.03347980976104736, -0.05420241504907608, -0.028531517833471298, 0.024038566276431084, 0.01612098328769207, 0.015226232819259167, -0.010787572711706161, -0.02147100307047367, -0.010867884382605553, -0.021384580060839653, 0.009037657640874386, -0.03263938054442406, 0.05159736052155495, 0.027477415278553963, -0.014857783913612366, 0.0024378744419664145, -0.052499208599328995, 0.002736662980169058, -0.03206250071525574, -0.0029960910324007273, -0.019111264497041702, -0.028449323028326035, 0.01524708978831768, 0.0574895516037941, 0.028143692761659622, -0.020727094262838364, 0.028925037011504173, 0.07248444855213165, 0.01164535153657198, -0.06053991988301277, -0.05659107491374016, -0.008048213087022305, -0.00666187284514308, 0.015277396887540817, -0.040500618517398834, 0.04524204507470131, 0.027242468670010567, 0.0655612200498581, 0.03283410146832466, -0.022911760956048965, -0.03530002757906914, 0.03339662775397301, -0.032783765345811844, -0.00008094350778264925, -0.011982257477939129, 0.02338266931474209, 0.029117735102772713, -0.015942174941301346, -0.04080135375261307, -0.02049991302192211, 0.0019434815039858222, 0.023362549021840096, -0.021940752863883972, -0.022448314353823662, -0.014385577291250229, -0.009876853786408901, 0.020374245941638947, -0.020138513296842575, -0.008923155255615711, 0.018333394080400467, -0.020889826118946075, -0.014017891138792038, 0.025904424488544464, 0.001966443844139576, 0.022127926349639893, -0.0009874325478449464, -0.015307625755667686, 0.03916240856051445, 0.002351559465751052, -0.00031271378975361586, -0.00874333642423153, 0.003713675308972597, -0.002169596031308174, -0.001987047027796507, -0.0013183437986299396, 0.010289187543094158, 0.059726644307374954, -0.049257680773735046, -0.04457365348935127, 0.03133761137723923, 0.04010418802499771, 0.02869303524494171, 0.004114249721169472, -0.017927851527929306, -0.027259614318609238, 0.00820560660213232, -0.029584096744656563, -0.014918697066605091, 0.0021928504575043917, 0.003891034983098507, -0.007806137204170227, -0.005206309258937836, -0.008615316823124886, 0.001325940596871078, 0.02588524855673313, 0.02056257054209709, 0.03912770003080368, -0.00679273484274745, -0.002964413957670331, 0.03218283876776695, -0.017032423987984657, 0.031225813552737236, -0.016296764835715294, -0.01106930524110794, 0.023221874609589577, 0.030090896412730217, -0.041524920612573624, 0.026769381016492844, 0.0032401655334979296, 0.011582505889236927, -0.0862727165222168, -0.019474849104881287, 0.034514352679252625, 0.015688972547650337, 0.02006623148918152, -0.029575485736131668, -0.0024560659658163786, 0.02639196254312992, -0.016440927982330322, 0.007354213390499353, 0.025410819798707962, -0.008244462311267853, -0.07109703123569489, 0.002800813177600503, -0.03829580545425415, 0.008024066686630249, 0.037470992654561996, 0.029684672132134438, 0.03658303618431091, 0.027551194652915, 0.003794301301240921, -0.010570981539785862, -0.03196470066905022, -0.012300306931138039, 0.016829123720526695, -0.07568668574094772, 0.02942989207804203, -0.027722474187612534, -0.02465563639998436, 0.013075802475214005, 0.038626257330179214, 0.00011032303154934198, 0.010567051358520985, 0.022738948464393616, 0.005446157418191433, 0.005846173036843538, 0.018912265077233315, -0.017637550830841064, 0.007198034785687923, -0.004649942275136709, -0.0015650636050850153, 0.015214880928397179, -0.052730727940797806, -0.05797318369150162, 0.01385361049324274, -0.04363035783171654, -0.06222754344344139, -0.001332107582129538, 0.0036307000555098057, -0.014573798514902592, 0.01099466998130083, -0.007405342999845743, -0.007848028093576431, 0.005643780343234539, 0.02371181547641754, -0.045155350118875504, -0.02705243229866028, 0.036904025822877884, 0.0613616406917572, -0.040989235043525696, 0.00587162422016263, -0.02871311642229557, -0.03971255570650101, -0.013845313340425491, -0.003762892447412014, -0.009959753602743149, -0.06904146075248718, -0.03853943571448326, -0.027654584497213364, 0.02573242224752903, -0.025162646546959877, -0.00008161926962202415, -0.038735613226890564, 0.02526010014116764, -0.03548463433980942, 0.001518081990070641, 0.0001897259644465521, -0.0028333356603980064, -0.0136281568557024, -0.07103963196277618, 0.061509303748607635, 0.017066726461052895, -0.005422959104180336, -0.036123886704444885, -0.06031402572989464, -0.029790306463837624, 0.0033793309703469276, 0.0640927106142044, 0.025343282148241997, 0.0019437172450125217, -0.024358434602618217, -0.0007851160480640829, 0.018598241731524467, -0.06705255061388016, 0.019088435918092728, -0.027257170528173447, -0.018705980852246284, -0.010572896338999271, -0.022091969847679138, 0.04956185445189476, -0.007571391761302948, 0.05161053687334061, 0.005731647834181786, -0.011071146465837955, -0.00964268483221531, -0.0007456180173903704, 0.015598260797560215, -0.013005491346120834, 0.0026938659138977528, 0.04577713459730148, -0.026436807587742805, 0.01935412548482418, -0.017555106431245804, -0.004340668208897114, -0.09968931972980499, -0.01839148811995983, -0.030629729852080345, -0.0498805046081543, 0.014788912609219551, 0.03888995572924614, -0.0022322069853544235, -0.0420609749853611, -0.02481406182050705, 0.0423184297978878, -0.047075752168893814, -0.01749899983406067, -0.0028396989218890667, 0.005104062147438526, 0.0474836640059948, -0.012558309361338615, 0.02106446586549282, 0.014751674607396126, -0.004428809508681297, 0.037318531423807144, -0.0047976234927773476, 0.027521943673491478, -0.027694638818502426, 0.021522952243685722, -0.00012051868543494493, 0.013462461531162262, 0.007516572717577219, -0.02079666033387184, 0.044687461107969284, 0.000346524640917778, -0.04071900621056557, 0.04319039732217789, -0.030332492664456367, -0.008653766475617886, 0.010086956433951855, -0.005917275324463844, 0.06636384129524231, -0.009112311527132988, 0.007953624241054058, -0.024354279041290283, 0.00977776013314724, 0.0074744923040270805, 0.01277025043964386, 0.007294015493243933, 0.002005665097385645, -0.006953851319849491, 0.0348663330078125, 0.039836615324020386, -0.03307830169796944, 0.02833673730492592, -0.03433426842093468, 0.01615179143846035, 0.045087046921253204, -0.002029088092967868, -0.03724820911884308, -0.031331248581409454, -0.021779481321573257, -0.00868409313261509, 0.0034970215056091547, 0.021785391494631767, 0.020090913400053978, -0.042438965290784836, -0.018072886392474174, -0.013381832279264927, 0.034874871373176575, -0.034521907567977905, -0.03316755220293999, -0.017173442989587784, -0.025239473208785057, 0.04197829216718674, -0.04890204593539238 ]
<p>I have the survival dataset of a population with a special disease. I´d like to compare this population with the general population to see whether this population has a decreased life-expectancy overall. What I had in mind was to create a control for each patient in the dataset and enter the age, sex and cohort specific life-expectancy from the national statistics databank and just run a Kaplan-Meier analysis. </p> <p>However, I´m unsure as to how I should deal with the censoring issue. Should I just censor the control if the life-expectancy for the x-aged, y-sexed, z-cohort exceeds todays date, i.e.: a 50 year old male in 2000 was expected to live 28 years in the general population? My take is that he should enter with 11 years and a censoring status.</p> <p>Or is there some other more mathematically savvy way of doing this taking into account the uncertainty with the projected life-expectancy for the population?</p>
74,257
[ -0.023380376398563385, -0.07435182482004166, 0.030007250607013702, 0.0027190193068236113, 0.021038971841335297, 0.006465560290962458, -0.02294769696891308, -0.0019675802905112505, 0.02275839075446129, -0.006231177132576704, 0.016966773197054863, 0.03783291578292847, 0.06661159545183182, 0.03592953830957413, 0.018522515892982483, 0.0325559601187706, -0.02483374997973442, -0.027684861794114113, -0.030745165422558784, -0.005566622596234083, 0.007380498107522726, 0.0360744334757328, -0.014936963096261024, 0.013235818594694138, -0.035331062972545624, 0.0393395870923996, 0.01999024488031864, -0.04680803418159485, -0.02534632198512554, 0.05444668233394623, -0.05177675560116768, -0.06377687305212021, 0.026076501235365868, 0.022496968507766724, 0.053652893751859665, 0.0241988692432642, -0.031940534710884094, -0.07775461673736572, -0.01808162033557892, 0.02273562364280224, -0.0419611930847168, -0.020070528611540794, 0.011487855575978756, 0.04264754056930542, -0.022854885086417198, 0.05037357658147812, -0.03889207914471626, -0.02481728047132492, 0.03604641929268837, -0.033518657088279724, 0.02575904317200184, -0.008658709935843945, 0.042635586112737656, 0.022202756255865097, -0.03641466423869133, -0.010051262564957142, 0.051289357244968414, 0.062143366783857346, 0.019012009724974632, -0.050335511565208435, -0.028943711891770363, -0.015076824463903904, 0.012630119919776917, 0.0033891103230416775, -0.008980883285403252, -0.03774271160364151, -0.004753567278385162, -0.012435759417712688, -0.02223845385015011, -0.039531197398900986, -0.0001850915577961132, 0.00784880667924881, -0.009880254045128822, 0.003962475806474686, 0.04122656583786011, 0.0035245204344391823, -0.0084487060084939, 0.0314776711165905, 0.04909303039312363, 0.011223291978240013, -0.024994611740112305, -0.01991896517574787, 0.0312887467443943, 0.03670639172196388, -0.008993109688162804, 0.009996422566473484, 0.07157574594020844, -0.03359517827630043, 0.02211770974099636, 0.032862599939107895, -0.033730536699295044, -0.00889954436570406, 0.045508261770009995, -0.004745584446936846, -0.06245804950594902, 0.03468095138669014, -0.02449730969965458, 0.06352411210536957, -0.011579724960029125, 0.03952816128730774, 0.01134396530687809, -0.059092678129673004, 0.013886021450161934, 0.01991930790245533, 0.00010328098142053932, 0.017688272520899773, -0.029084913432598114, -0.06156224012374878, 0.006709306966513395, -0.03379815071821213, -0.03142917528748512, 0.02428356558084488, 0.020980823785066605, -0.006155223120003939, -0.002958988305181265, 0.008595488965511322, -0.019914761185646057, -0.007868857122957706, 0.05456731095910072, 0.043372079730033875, 0.045244697481393814, -0.01205726433545351, 0.04293474555015564, 0.007685686461627483, -0.06358940154314041, 0.01725650765001774, 0.023055043071508408, -0.026240844279527664, -0.0479411780834198, 0.020647384226322174, -0.0020429850555956364, -0.03286675736308098, 0.06996025890111923, -0.004764502868056297, 0.06137686222791672, -0.036643195897340775, -0.09566431492567062, -0.02129344455897808, 0.005476856604218483, 0.005464903078973293, -0.02213073894381523, -0.03864555060863495, -0.009129825979471207, 0.023470589891076088, 0.05347475782036781, 0.01769440434873104, 0.04445095732808113, 0.01285497471690178, 0.007904750294983387, -0.007649285718798637, 0.009302159771323204, -0.01770598068833351, 0.027455901727080345, 0.007145265117287636, -0.04038756713271141, -0.06899955123662949, 0.0029669858049601316, 0.022273356094956398, 0.012408079579472542, -0.012488623149693012, 0.054244264960289, 0.0034863674081861973, -0.030829768627882004, -0.007616760674864054, 0.01538797002285719, -0.04959996044635773, 0.10158646106719971, 0.047574326395988464, 0.036072906106710434, 0.01718967594206333, 0.03252740949392319, 0.04973546415567398, 0.01929938979446888, 0.042513407766819, 0.05249953269958496, -0.019136538729071617, 0.03149280324578285, -0.013840160332620144, 0.0317109078168869, 0.018352758139371872, -0.04417300596833229, 0.008103928528726101, -0.03802258521318436, -0.012597266584634781, 0.047963742166757584, -0.009107484482228756, 0.01325024850666523, -0.020393377169966698, 0.054299887269735336, -0.03971381485462189, -0.04141334816813469, -0.06146086007356644, -0.016680609434843063, 0.01672440767288208, 0.011992274783551693, -0.012545714154839516, -0.005297992378473282, 0.02718389965593815, -0.013001251965761185, -0.005948228761553764, -0.030161231756210327, -0.0006889788201078773, 0.03564447537064552, -0.06353684514760971, 0.008960301987826824, 0.03875359147787094, 0.05413927137851715, -0.008172372356057167, 0.057238902896642685, -0.04494591802358627, -0.037256669253110886, 0.0016067784745246172, -0.05337641015648842, 0.023067044094204903, 0.061796024441719055, 0.001956867752596736, 0.007703098002821207, -0.008496608585119247, -0.009949984028935432, 0.013575073331594467, -0.03777590021491051, 0.08582223951816559, 0.06930790096521378, -0.020070938393473625, -0.003914547152817249, -0.008468673564493656, 0.029994433745741844, 0.001844409853219986, -0.006941149011254311, -0.06282809376716614, -0.029883360490202904, 0.015726272016763687, 0.02431510016322136, -0.02087913639843464, -0.008590047247707844, 0.023627594113349915, 0.05689758062362671, -0.014085689559578896, 0.0311044342815876, 0.016113512217998505, -0.0049897790886461735, 0.0017709112726151943, 0.006560639478266239, 0.02925698086619377, -0.011993984691798687, -0.005923804361373186, 0.027283253148198128, -0.024433474987745285, 0.03347250446677208, -0.03345927968621254, 0.02751889079809189, 0.02795456349849701, -0.009550493210554123, -0.004643234424293041, 0.007194626610726118, -0.04908064380288124, 0.0022030810359865427, -0.012944166548550129, 0.008338437415659428, 0.018375864252448082, -0.0005171338561922312, 0.003546742955222726, 0.017342619597911835, -0.01910649798810482, 0.00922017078846693, 0.06550096720457077, -0.0440085306763649, 0.035670530050992966, 0.013453594408929348, -0.002928417641669512, -0.01644391193985939, -0.00188166624866426, -0.06820027530193329, -0.015536660328507423, 0.00035206504981033504, 0.03117605485022068, -0.022198617458343506, 0.0253145694732666, -0.012774460017681122, -0.04617232456803322, 0.000011910829016414937, 0.0030992350075393915, 0.03629998490214348, 0.036379117518663406, -0.08026245981454849, -0.020336223766207695, 0.028813639655709267, -0.06804361194372177, 0.05197462812066078, -0.013762935996055603, 0.016688428819179535, 0.019212869927287102, -0.010172651149332523, -0.024027392268180847, -0.02497871033847332, -0.025247354060411453, -0.03682414069771767, 0.002420772099867463, -0.04126133397221565, 0.047169506549835205, 0.020066166296601295, -0.03448011726140976, 0.03448369726538658, -0.020723016932606697, -0.02722337283194065, -0.026368342339992523, 0.029842598363757133, -0.012027634307742119, -0.00703452667221427, 0.004545297939330339, 0.009938902221620083, -0.013838031329214573, -0.00774634862318635, -0.06190922111272812, -0.052344415336847305, 0.06522022187709808, -0.023572556674480438, 0.022412095218896866, 0.010742307640612125, 0.010407304391264915, 0.04231007397174835, 0.03838858753442764, 0.030964026227593422, -0.005481303669512272, 0.008176945149898529, -0.022281229496002197, -0.03908609226346016, 0.00936244148761034, 0.004655778408050537, 0.0013906144304201007, 0.01644184999167919, 0.0010099781211465597, 0.013288328424096107, 0.007485512178391218, 0.0008654900593683124, -0.02525956742465496, 0.01989990472793579, 0.03096260502934456, 0.006030420772731304, 0.07441414892673492, 0.0545397587120533, -0.02000141516327858, 0.02321576699614525, -0.03421016037464142, 0.03951331600546837, 0.026033788919448853, -0.0992308184504509, 0.0062928288243710995, -0.015183348208665848, -0.019967904314398766, -0.005049815401434898, 0.017789527773857117, 0.012071390636265278, -0.038464147597551346, 0.00890329573303461, 0.00023545059957541525, 0.037588298320770264, -0.013546556234359741, 0.009607646614313126, 0.01617683470249176, 0.057721950113773346, 0.012248929589986801, 0.02123541571199894, 0.005473298020660877, 0.008638299070298672, 0.027796044945716858, -0.026139603927731514, -0.03244558721780777, 0.026230337098240852, 0.03190019726753235, 0.0025898520834743977, -0.04173297807574272, -0.01875368133187294, -0.025678124278783798, -0.10083907097578049, 0.003291017608717084, 0.0016867927042767406, 0.0769478976726532, 0.045646362006664276, 0.007424859795719385, 0.04296184331178665, -0.004328334704041481, -0.0009129350073635578, 0.020085012540221214, -0.059456583112478256, 0.041537538170814514, -0.021063175052404404, -0.010527689941227436, -0.011384761892259121, -0.04415888339281082, 0.044813577085733414, 0.013753586448729038, -0.01161978766322136, -0.04284597560763359, 0.016999028623104095, -0.04424167796969414, -0.005123258102685213, -0.04311559349298477, 0.002805084688588977, -0.004355712328106165, 0.00529410969465971, 0.01172788254916668, 0.01799006201326847, -0.021485712379217148, 0.02096496894955635, 0.006426922045648098, -0.01635126583278179, 0.0028131359722465277, 0.02025873214006424, 0.03294796124100685, 0.030081694945693016, 0.010840163566172123, 0.01652528904378414, -0.06088682636618614, 0.020258823409676552, -0.005566460080444813, 0.02393231727182865, 0.017421862110495567, 0.00512781273573637, 0.005648389458656311, -0.008677205070853233, 0.00585958594456315, 0.013597158715128899, -0.0011006477288901806, -0.010997043922543526, -0.010500054806470871, 0.08823894709348679, 0.014345843344926834, -0.07669942826032639, -0.006339098326861858, 0.027409259229898453, 0.003201728919520974, 0.01751982606947422, -0.02083202451467514, -0.023815002292394638, -0.016322989016771317, -0.01568945124745369, 0.020306382328271866, 0.04500389099121094, -0.005168167408555746, 0.0021189015824347734, 0.041757386177778244, -0.023360295221209526, -0.04036036133766174, -0.011234289966523647, 0.04077768325805664, 0.060200080275535583, 0.012082839384675026, -0.04227813333272934, 0.05988528952002525, 0.015759402886033058, 0.009661017917096615, 0.04700153321027756, 0.05449686944484711, -0.08563324064016342, -0.002359100617468357, 0.048710066825151443, 0.03027942217886448, -0.015897460281848907, -0.024783967062830925, -0.04870034009218216, -0.005033225752413273, 0.07355628162622452, -0.021865228191018105, -0.006220022216439247, -0.011934595182538033, -0.021179327741265297, 0.004721550736576319, -0.020598499104380608, -0.011335673741996288, 0.006027635652571917, -0.0143031757324934, 0.02542097307741642, 0.017950713634490967, -0.00869213417172432, -0.005916225723922253, -0.022892361506819725, 0.0050899796187877655, 0.06530142575502396, 0.0005736773600801826, -0.04855060577392578, 0.0365227609872818, -0.015025733970105648, -0.019155379384756088, -0.07366948574781418, -0.004270114004611969, 0.005324762314558029, 0.030604152008891106, 0.03781220689415932, 0.0008213625987991691, 0.009067138656973839, 0.031391311436891556, 0.013326073065400124, 0.0046190740540623665, 0.009284947998821735, 0.003930696751922369, 0.03273917734622955, 0.010145701467990875, -0.0033127719070762396, 0.030594822019338608, 0.036177437752485275, 0.015994537621736526, 0.0033720911014825106, -0.023741763085126877, -0.047862373292446136, -0.02086077257990837, -0.006813082844018936, -0.03352811187505722, 0.003829320427030325, -0.025992659851908684, 0.01035003736615181, -0.01649910770356655, 0.014147443696856499, -0.025402605533599854, -0.013112328946590424, 0.03960913047194481, 0.032849088311195374, -0.037067312747240067, 0.0009249590802937746, -0.017592860385775566, -0.006810973398387432, 0.03076137602329254, -0.02307475544512272, 0.020363014191389084, 0.0014491965994238853, 0.002264311769977212, -0.008586606942117214, -0.06202027574181557, -0.007226725574582815, -0.02107861079275608, -0.06778436154127121, 0.009694253094494343, -0.02279176190495491, 0.010458631440997124, 0.0017338069155812263, 0.03673313558101654, 0.0013184788404032588, 0.012464472092688084, 0.020365320146083832, 0.018536901101469994, -0.011662006378173828, 0.034192539751529694, -0.04642445966601372, 0.03686554729938507, 0.025087522342801094, -0.014633242040872574, -0.10430122911930084, -0.018705736845731735, 0.021186277270317078, 0.01685957983136177, -0.05330264940857887, -0.011688345111906528, 0.002980494871735573, -0.024428589269518852, -0.030036987736821175, -0.005435048136860132, 0.038022447377443314, -0.020955657586455345, -0.012593032792210579, -0.04476674646139145, 0.02457328513264656, 0.0713830515742302, -0.03246209770441055, 0.026136934757232666, -0.0038955144118517637, -0.03664829209446907, -0.007459006737917662, -0.00789760984480381, -0.005541440099477768, -0.021128596737980843, -0.006403708830475807, -0.03173161670565605, 0.02627318724989891, 0.03672764450311661, 0.007245183922350407, 0.0029833540320396423, 0.023403512313961983, 0.010184871032834053, 0.02102024480700493, -0.00319188111461699, -0.0052192010916769505, -0.05596291273832321, 0.017594270408153534, -0.011821134947240353, -0.003475749399513006, 0.009689344093203545, -0.03242329880595207, 0.03261460363864899, 0.016478871926665306, -0.03526296466588974, 0.030488960444927216, 0.03297201171517372, 0.0027744995895773172, 0.0018026070902124047, -0.01928068697452545, -0.04065452516078949, 0.009987167082726955, 0.0007077286718413234, -0.013401106931269169, 0.01862630993127823, 0.006053886841982603, -0.02599676139652729, -0.005025860387831926, -0.04847805202007294, -0.00020512565970420837, 0.032560259103775024, -0.014600198715925217, 0.013882782310247421, 0.03884994238615036, 0.03921250253915787, 0.012239889241755009, -0.035325389355421066, -0.031894486397504807, 0.014616904780268669, 0.00011862786777783185, 0.023562757298350334, -0.009569688700139523, 0.032707177102565765, 0.04318329691886902, 0.009647969156503677, 0.0022394226398319006, 0.043777190148830414, 0.02105814591050148, 0.00590561656281352, 0.03327859938144684, -0.026340462267398834, -0.041891660541296005, 0.02385249175131321, -0.04979566112160683, 0.014151904731988907, -0.04362718388438225, -0.02082321234047413, -0.022242330014705658, 0.043890953063964844, -0.0035458949860185385, -0.024352416396141052, -0.032904937863349915, -0.05294705182313919, 0.023559879511594772, -0.0063965958543121815, -0.013454783707857132, 0.05550069361925125, 0.001517101307399571, 0.03526891767978668, 0.01847643032670021, -0.010182003490626812, -0.025342527776956558, -0.05252404883503914, -0.024549897760152817, -0.041991014033555984, -0.04426060989499092, 0.007388775702565908, 0.024847017601132393, -0.0032651179935783148, -0.021074144169688225, -0.032706119120121, 0.01718929037451744, 0.004961870610713959, 0.0500226654112339, 0.00359153444878757, 0.06395100802183151, 0.007019380107522011, -0.005956217180937529, 0.00687694875523448, 0.0037589799612760544, 0.11579941213130951, 0.08793194591999054, 0.026352353394031525, -0.07810935378074646, 0.01583121344447136, -0.0036345168482512236, -0.012948601506650448, 0.017718490213155746, 0.01967618614435196, 0.036299966275691986, -0.019161906093358994, 0.0393216572701931, 0.001954857259988785, -0.017433293163776398, 0.0009246208937838674, 0.06909505277872086, -0.05218172445893288, -0.005787983536720276, 0.011093957349658012, -0.00011819865176221356, 0.011475316248834133, -0.047355685383081436, -0.05399613454937935, 0.050391729921102524, 0.007606917526572943, -0.043798983097076416, -0.04833587259054184, -0.004573504906147718, -0.0018299324437975883, 0.001487856381572783, -0.051287271082401276, 0.015198962762951851, 0.021046556532382965, 0.005603009834885597, -0.018717007711529732, -0.029352009296417236, -0.02710302732884884, 0.014838319271802902, 0.038726478815078735, 0.041546255350112915, -0.028931327164173126, -0.012084056623280048, -0.0177385862916708, 0.005899591837078333, -0.048109639436006546, -0.023374134674668312, -0.04796430096030235, 0.0360240712761879, 0.00474773021414876, -0.000823041598778218, -0.00638170400634408, -0.010425512678921223, 0.019772188737988472, -0.01807132549583912, -0.01032146718353033, -0.0036313137970864773, 0.02156103402376175, -0.014542150311172009, 0.005777717102319002, 0.019007552415132523, -0.027822788804769516, -0.010394234210252762, 0.005040494725108147, 0.06657474488019943, -0.04604112356901169, -0.01912214420735836, -0.02258455380797386, 0.0053680106066167355, -0.020199868828058243, -0.006530867889523506, 0.028398636728525162, -0.000004299481133784866, -0.028690490871667862, -0.007100848946720362, 0.00962548516690731, 0.029658814892172813, -0.000056580953241791576, -0.022983334958553314, 0.020705871284008026, 0.0002961397694889456, -0.02389541082084179, 0.025743816047906876, -0.008764936588704586, 0.02300141751766205, -0.04088149219751358, -0.018882617354393005, 0.019816577434539795, 0.035234902054071426, -0.03406498208642006, 0.04877014085650444, -0.01388003583997488, 0.05521855130791664, 0.01364989299327135, -0.05157957598567009, -0.029426591470837593, 0.024687647819519043, -0.06548801064491272, 0.02554163709282875, -0.01706637628376484, 0.07590918987989426, 0.012499873526394367, 0.011443443596363068, 0.021074624732136726, 0.014032443054020405, 0.007481830660253763, 0.017845064401626587, -0.0058784824796020985, -0.08053289353847504, 0.010570584796369076, 0.004960204940289259, 0.05357586592435837, -0.03958219662308693, -0.010598628781735897, -0.01348229218274355, -0.0266168974339962, 0.01203741692006588, -0.03014322929084301, 0.024347038939595222, 0.007507195696234703, -0.007561495993286371, -0.006265548523515463, -0.028013665229082108, 0.01598970964550972, -0.07375781983137131, -0.008449629880487919, -0.025225713849067688, 0.02357758954167366, -0.02424352988600731, -0.014380396343767643, -0.008654982782900333, 0.037300873547792435, 0.020924102514982224, 0.0031536039896309376, -0.04076312109827995, 0.030242158100008965, -0.005905376747250557, 0.026890233159065247, 0.01920105144381523, -0.0006495888228528202, -0.022702328860759735, 0.009010936133563519, -0.03363177925348282, -0.015721984207630157, 0.04772092401981354, 0.01897675357758999, 0.008799267001450062, -0.0009687026613391936, -0.0048146434128284454, 0.005803578998893499, 0.06161382794380188, -0.020285381004214287, -0.04526272788643837, -0.010574419051408768, 0.00817397702485323, -0.016352789476513863, 0.010478483512997627, -0.004966539330780506, 0.04022016003727913, -0.005502395797520876, 0.026006098836660385, 0.030489396303892136, -0.0068883891217410564, 0.008886585012078285, -0.0013396480353549123, 0.00873644184321165, 0.007316000759601593, -0.01330096460878849, 0.026260776445269585, 0.04146904498338699, 0.06727210432291031, -0.0225052610039711, 0.016828207299113274, 0.015583565458655357, -0.031100759282708168, -0.10925285518169403, -0.005668180994689465, -0.009932694025337696, 0.00814258772879839, 0.03762444853782654, -0.040442075580358505, -0.009535971097648144, 0.014461131766438484, 0.0031055654399096966, 0.045414309948682785, -0.009294246323406696, -0.011118440888822079, -0.05585082992911339, 0.011190737597644329, -0.004958221223205328, 0.05325598642230034, -0.00026905996492132545, 0.030551742762327194, 0.04520215839147568, 0.0015664021484553814, -0.02370886318385601, -0.04090602695941925, 0.009305325336754322, 0.000353530835127458, 0.0010178707307204604, -0.05519391596317291, 0.0243645329028368, -0.029186461120843887, -0.05892820656299591, 0.024984294548630714, -0.020390594378113747, 0.02851804345846176, 0.014319445937871933, 0.01473666075617075, 0.0007688115583732724, 0.03146526962518692, 0.0636228695511818, -0.010295616462826729, 0.036000147461891174, -0.018638866022229195, 0.007839711382985115, 0.030365537852048874, -0.03982140123844147, 0.03549112379550934, 0.025176692754030228, -0.017566582188010216, -0.0056672669015824795, 0.004835836123675108, 0.032318416982889175, 0.010098588652908802, -0.014827744103968143, -0.0016537746414542198, -0.022128578275442123, -0.032704710960388184, 0.023878877982497215, -0.007702119182795286, 0.016258087009191513, 0.05104172229766846, 0.05435846745967865, 0.024461910128593445, -0.011400462128221989, -0.06628613919019699, -0.044047605246305466, -0.00893040094524622, 0.021856175735592842, 0.0020309400279074907, -0.03485981747508049, -0.010806674137711525, -0.04454391077160835, 0.001580489450134337, -0.02777199074625969, 0.004464601632207632, -0.056276749819517136, 0.01848624087870121, -0.012939805164933205, 0.012488612905144691, 0.046236127614974976, 0.0085753807798028, 0.011486822739243507, -0.06342258304357529, 0.028421444818377495, 0.012800187803804874, 0.028963789343833923, -0.005762707442045212, -0.02672644704580307, -0.0017347262473776937, -0.025294553488492966, 0.07221411168575287, 0.037097685039043427, 0.01703588478267193, 0.013859404250979424, -0.002927239518612623, -0.027749694883823395, -0.04314904287457466, 0.05203195661306381, -0.01532211247831583, -0.02187534049153328, -0.01646036095917225, 0.019767703488469124, 0.0004734050889965147, 0.006115677300840616, 0.03472093865275383, 0.01539894100278616, 0.02218230441212654, 0.06713685393333435, -0.017022380605340004, -0.0056003364734351635, -0.00360280554741621, -0.01755213737487793, 0.020661260932683945, 0.0012428555637598038, 0.017267122864723206, 0.02656753920018673, 0.0019225712167099118, -0.05277468264102936, 0.058758120983839035, -0.025639811530709267, -0.022263402119278908, -0.0020711517427116632, -0.04492910951375961, -0.02326575107872486, -0.03939594328403473, -0.03481949865818024, 0.024088971316814423, -0.029971672222018242, 0.031146813184022903, 0.014861566945910454, 0.017114689573645592, 0.031165791675448418, -0.03006969764828682, 0.01545483898371458, 0.017440829426050186, -0.009577054530382156, 0.015984391793608665, -0.03219307214021683, -0.0010783948237076402, -0.028428854420781136, 0.02517111413180828, 0.01899246871471405, 0.014697697944939137, 0.010921343229711056, -0.005130949895828962, 0.05190056934952736, -0.017454681918025017, -0.01498530525714159, -0.013993753120303154, 0.008566356264054775, -0.0010582313407212496, -0.023526431992650032, -0.005962067283689976, 0.03887356072664261, -0.013301575556397438, -0.020269423723220825, -0.0472349151968956, -0.05257800593972206, -0.06569372117519379, -0.012228055857121944, 0.034493640065193176, 0.01765851117670536, 0.024674152955412865, 0.03991635516285896, -0.03454018011689186, 0.002944096690043807, 0.05324842408299446, -0.03100809082388878, 0.04571641609072685, 0.020972508937120438, -0.005355835426598787, -0.019081396982073784, -0.03163917735219002, -0.034132543951272964, -0.038591302931308746, 0.0241676215082407, 0.03760920837521553, 0.024748090654611588, 0.01321297138929367, -0.017476212233304977, -0.026057451963424683, 0.008725477382540703, -0.04942838475108147, -0.060492582619190216, -0.04676513746380806, 0.007173001300543547, 0.0003626262187026441, 0.01878449134528637 ]
<p>I have a set of 40 subjects that performed a task while the variables of interest were being recorded at regular time intervals (0, 1, 2,.... 10 seconds). The task was performed twice, once with and once without the aid of computer feedback. </p> <p>For most of the variables, the distribution across subjects at each time point is a normal distribution. But for a few, they are heavily skewed. </p> <p>I'd like to know if the variance of the collected variables between the subjects was significantly different during the feedback-assisted task. </p> <p>What is the best way to do this?</p>
74,258
[ -0.05785825103521347, 0.012521743774414062, 0.011417881585657597, -0.019780246540904045, 0.04601825401186943, -0.009116270579397678, 0.007177176885306835, -0.0075643048621714115, 0.01132806297391653, 0.010038735345005989, 0.04487195238471031, 0.013542323373258114, 0.04694822058081627, 0.05009307339787483, 0.027790697291493416, -0.023943161591887474, -0.024826304987072945, -0.0038630920462310314, -0.018528049811720848, -0.0048975637182593346, -0.03985712304711342, 0.02369527518749237, -0.004364847205579281, -0.02378709614276886, -0.04625532031059265, 0.032217852771282196, 0.03030748851597309, -0.06747888028621674, -0.012769514694809914, 0.04987359046936035, -0.056007109582424164, -0.021217795088887215, -0.0024044723249971867, 0.030630087479948997, 0.03901563957333565, -0.018295275047421455, -0.04971669986844063, -0.01623895950615406, 0.005282663740217686, 0.037717897444963455, -0.04939104616641998, 0.021636493504047394, -0.015610026195645332, 0.006153416354209185, 0.007309461012482643, -0.01129844132810831, -0.027389438822865486, -0.008511855266988277, 0.040314897894859314, -0.052235979586839676, 0.08894634246826172, -0.034659493714571, 0.07825648784637451, 0.01959274522960186, -0.006032827775925398, 0.0230576004832983, 0.04924095794558525, 0.07946451008319855, -0.0011259785387665033, -0.025631265714764595, -0.016605887562036514, -0.023541443049907684, -0.01248936913907528, -0.012547006830573082, -0.0329141691327095, -0.009479395113885403, 0.005631999112665653, -0.021485449746251106, 0.015551897697150707, -0.015453563071787357, 0.024402737617492676, 0.037972111254930496, 0.041404034942388535, -0.016052838414907455, 0.012892946600914001, -0.05590226501226425, 0.047767411917448044, 0.007347887847572565, 0.023520611226558685, 0.04160503298044205, 0.04615265130996704, -0.0044568972662091255, 0.0292744692414999, 0.04540161043405533, 0.04260706529021263, -0.05015743151307106, 0.07814227044582367, -0.03055748902261257, -0.004446039441972971, 0.029083075001835823, -0.03935058042407036, 0.022495504468679428, 0.021470947191119194, 0.02783653326332569, -0.0811130627989769, 0.022099493071436882, -0.021327337250113487, 0.07849624752998352, -0.0036780601367354393, -0.03527966886758804, -0.001175661338493228, -0.04370664060115814, 0.010940460488200188, 0.0548679456114769, -0.05126451700925827, 0.0033253817819058895, 0.006022325716912746, 0.021904263645410538, -0.017247937619686127, -0.014455263502895832, -0.028518781065940857, -0.01643550954759121, 0.00010637257219059393, 0.012159936130046844, 0.06008407101035118, 0.013002564199268818, -0.034566860646009445, -0.0173801276832819, 0.06580499559640884, 0.07859066128730774, 0.02528565563261509, -0.052328769117593765, 0.03496480733156204, -0.01722797192633152, 0.023032531142234802, 0.02596832811832428, 0.025453777983784676, -0.010370858013629913, -0.05201831832528114, 0.046148303896188736, -0.0034217643551528454, -0.01761455088853836, 0.03635943681001663, -0.029020870104432106, -0.002074264921247959, 0.035350024700164795, -0.0833105593919754, -0.045388106256723404, 0.04368777573108673, -0.04270537570118904, -0.01155878696590662, -0.05968201160430908, -0.029173757880926132, 0.016569670289754868, 0.03850257396697998, -0.018360208719968796, 0.02400539442896843, -0.00752606987953186, 0.027085144072771072, 0.005703790113329887, -0.01370136346668005, -0.019083991646766663, 0.012721509672701359, -0.02559024840593338, 0.00099271594081074, -0.07620330899953842, 0.0015531359240412712, 0.018487680703401566, 0.0020801816135644913, 0.0334048829972744, -0.02992984466254711, 0.009178698994219303, -0.021671267226338387, -0.0021179935429245234, 0.057083841413259506, -0.03225685656070709, 0.07319624722003937, 0.020463379099965096, -0.012681830674409866, -0.010936773382127285, -0.003099032212048769, -0.003338891314342618, 0.015018844045698643, 0.02770884335041046, 0.04825771972537041, -0.036144159734249115, -0.009686467237770557, 0.02655637450516224, -0.009317893534898758, 0.004495692905038595, -0.015660330653190613, 0.024467946961522102, -0.015187432989478111, 0.01563842222094536, 0.008976493030786514, 0.06838163733482361, -0.00783615279942751, 0.020214075222611427, 0.022483645007014275, -0.016275916248559952, -0.0399695448577404, -0.06169945374131203, -0.0012741967802867293, -0.00867706723511219, -0.033298783004283905, 0.03248828649520874, 0.00635893177241087, 0.05537011846899986, -0.011385929770767689, -0.05929135903716087, -0.010598169639706612, -0.011677437461912632, 0.07053013145923615, -0.03360043093562126, 0.00015726099081803113, 0.03614722192287445, 0.02486664615571499, 0.00018753233598545194, 0.04475504904985428, -0.007611460518091917, -0.0506361648440361, -0.015233698301017284, -0.05418773368000984, 0.026251232251524925, 0.013677267357707024, -0.00956160482019186, 0.00409331638365984, 0.030153581872582436, -0.01851104013621807, -0.007008521817624569, -0.018902115523815155, 0.05122670158743858, 0.04890851676464081, -0.019919469952583313, 0.00949916709214449, -0.00013133334869053215, 0.02638230100274086, 0.000944244209676981, -0.01600080542266369, -0.033282700926065445, -0.05611003562808037, -0.02022591605782509, 0.0031271083280444145, 0.03806858882308006, -0.0305453073233366, 0.029740214347839355, 0.04912067577242851, 0.00661193672567606, 0.021008562296628952, 0.008725573308765888, 0.019851095974445343, -0.039380718022584915, 0.03522462025284767, 0.01832115650177002, 0.03184465318918228, 0.019256439059972763, -0.00420752726495266, 0.002150237560272217, -0.01785453036427498, 0.03118303418159485, 0.007699545007199049, -0.014882831834256649, 0.008276412263512611, 0.009678772650659084, -0.0124976746737957, -0.04241163656115532, 0.04109502211213112, 0.011300445534288883, -0.003212992800399661, 0.07906108349561691, 0.003898839233443141, -0.03651256486773491, 0.01795567385852337, -0.024932866916060448, 0.04340299963951111, 0.03695732727646828, -0.0489511638879776, -0.022931508719921112, 0.021931570023298264, -0.015361024998128414, 0.027140315622091293, -0.007274567615240812, -0.012216896750032902, -0.006125738378614187, 0.00455619627609849, 0.022120967507362366, 0.01414449978619814, 0.03450244665145874, -0.035017792135477066, 0.01645989716053009, 0.007016660645604134, -0.005038983654230833, 0.027843210846185684, -0.0011885592248290777, -0.042965371161699295, -0.010042069479823112, -0.012894503772258759, 0.006448672618716955, 0.023280063644051552, 0.0016526241088286042, 0.006107330787926912, 0.05586953088641167, 0.014990672469139099, -0.05228324234485626, 0.012896203435957432, -0.021705877035856247, 0.016940973699092865, 0.0016203363193199039, -0.036188941448926926, 0.03900410979986191, 0.021852903068065643, -0.048650577664375305, 0.02414960227906704, -0.032479628920555115, -0.03306715562939644, -0.014127164147794247, -0.0013590047601610422, 0.0069914311170578, -0.013598957099020481, 0.0015329044545069337, 0.0223774965852499, -0.008111662231385708, -0.03583277389407158, -0.059943147003650665, -0.07765193283557892, 0.009195119142532349, -0.007039399351924658, 0.03524644672870636, -0.02767852135002613, -0.017612172290682793, 0.07689587026834488, 0.019874297082424164, -0.02922605350613594, -0.027117732912302017, -0.02670891396701336, -0.021197570487856865, -0.026220133528113365, 0.039656344801187515, 0.0017015861812978983, -0.025510035455226898, 0.03718845173716545, 0.0011765523813664913, 0.016574425622820854, 0.03208054602146149, 0.026561537757515907, -0.013649575412273407, -0.003797665936872363, -0.00624083960428834, -0.01537438202649355, 0.01485675759613514, -0.004490342456847429, -0.04033126309514046, -0.05507434159517288, -0.012901064939796925, 0.011485742405056953, 0.02136382646858692, -0.024565935134887695, 0.007431558798998594, -0.022376088425517082, 0.01743249222636223, -0.03736833110451698, 0.01994602009654045, 0.012269840575754642, -0.036464445292949677, -0.009249547496438026, 0.05513204261660576, 0.036967262625694275, -0.013448236510157585, 0.020031796768307686, 0.08079376071691513, 0.03931112587451935, 0.021391145884990692, -0.0429062657058239, -0.023973580449819565, 0.0015954533591866493, 0.02521187625825405, -0.04965254291892052, -0.004323175642639399, 0.01886673830449581, 0.029260169714689255, 0.02019515261054039, 0.0036356316413730383, -0.04030180349946022, 0.005284866318106651, -0.051490090787410736, 0.010817593894898891, 0.001251536887139082, 0.03340493515133858, 0.0024906089529395103, 0.047563452273607254, 0.0405532568693161, -0.0038118346128612757, 0.014407203532755375, -0.03480030596256256, -0.037136174738407135, 0.027117114514112473, -0.021607359871268272, 0.008182276040315628, 0.01689741015434265, -0.008497814647853374, 0.07127641886472702, -0.012981686741113663, 0.02613133192062378, 0.012592506594955921, 0.039403513073921204, -0.02689743973314762, -0.0039702728390693665, -0.04618354141712189, -0.018732573837041855, -0.022477978840470314, 0.023598508909344673, 0.011608048342168331, -0.038658324629068375, 0.03717459738254547, 0.007044100668281317, 0.01799185201525688, 0.024888820946216583, -0.030475543811917305, -0.023298688232898712, 0.003353388514369726, 0.045475106686353683, 0.023752667009830475, 0.01858442835509777, -0.014277744106948376, 0.062114570289850235, -0.0011328159598633647, 0.043017785996198654, 0.06403296440839767, 0.004498806782066822, -0.04929058998823166, -0.020680636167526245, -0.016690704971551895, 0.007246844470500946, 0.00034036586293950677, -0.0006338756647892296, 0.012348816730082035, 0.034182559698820114, 0.04171552509069443, -0.07189229130744934, 0.010907627642154694, 0.05168847739696503, 0.02317812107503414, 0.011205384507775307, -0.010538441129028797, 0.0056947339326143265, 0.024205531924962997, -0.011690258048474789, 0.013839472085237503, 0.04166804254055023, 0.014633964747190475, 0.013684947043657303, 0.06376829743385315, 0.0005226273788139224, -0.03768063709139824, 0.00012506754137575626, 0.017216138541698456, 0.05640428885817528, 0.02184859663248062, -0.030866345390677452, 0.029100505635142326, 0.05262875184416771, 0.023308491334319115, 0.03308282047510147, -0.010069494135677814, -0.08631376922130585, -0.018620077520608902, 0.025512253865599632, 0.0022010772954672575, -0.03884245082736015, 0.01026872918009758, -0.03627258539199829, 0.012444516643881798, 0.03663687780499458, -0.02695653587579727, 0.01566147990524769, -0.014138641767203808, -0.003322656499221921, -0.027918387204408646, -0.016343945637345314, -0.03934459015727043, 0.013885967433452606, 0.01673278585076332, 0.015540353953838348, 0.00002906385634560138, -0.0674898698925972, -0.027546124532818794, 0.018303338438272476, 0.01909547671675682, 0.08647317439317703, 0.025953827425837517, -0.0007254445808939636, 0.01043243333697319, 0.02148030512034893, -0.033941593021154404, -0.05441315099596977, 0.026790602132678032, 0.02854565717279911, -0.0036672591231763363, 0.06728917360305786, -0.013622445985674858, -0.024302219972014427, 0.008902193047106266, -0.02832682617008686, -0.021976668387651443, -0.009126565419137478, -0.01617705076932907, 0.044087834656238556, 0.007552372291684151, 0.023579932749271393, 0.06784868985414505, 0.028273947536945343, 0.014061007648706436, -0.018084799870848656, 0.008681931532919407, 0.008775905705988407, -0.02509121596813202, -0.013846216723322868, -0.021761499345302582, -0.018395205959677696, -0.020942479372024536, 0.026181066408753395, 0.004991266410797834, 0.04962717741727829, -0.017630506306886673, 0.010645180009305477, 0.028868351131677628, 0.01785890944302082, 0.006847995799034834, -0.009447062388062477, 0.013863926753401756, 0.011541835963726044, -0.033701326698064804, 0.011092307977378368, 0.017888080328702927, -0.03678377345204353, 0.002047301735728979, 0.009564508683979511, -0.028116021305322647, -0.015348220244050026, -0.07496272772550583, -0.032317858189344406, -0.008388430811464787, -0.0029190275818109512, 0.016863685101270676, 0.01271693967282772, 0.07568623870611191, 0.00850778166204691, -0.015354233793914318, -0.010299596935510635, 0.033274538815021515, -0.021073732525110245, 0.04110673442482948, -0.06519525498151779, 0.044751234352588654, -0.0355905145406723, 0.019499344751238823, -0.0815349817276001, -0.018421834334731102, 0.021495996043086052, 0.012736430391669273, 0.004485593177378178, -0.04850216209888458, -0.027494609355926514, 0.003660615999251604, -0.022028516978025436, -0.011319109238684177, 0.015010260976850986, 0.0031575970351696014, 0.01040858868509531, -0.008637643419206142, -0.007258700672537088, 0.06199000030755997, 0.0038894221652299166, -0.010435983538627625, 0.0038931400049477816, -0.02347879856824875, -0.036681167781353, -0.006027539726346731, -0.0031942070927470922, -0.01878734864294529, -0.028931621462106705, -0.02236218936741352, 0.048424508422613144, 0.028367873281240463, -0.048630740493535995, 0.020229995250701904, 0.025055374950170517, -0.043150894343853, -0.009941364638507366, -0.0472230538725853, -0.001615517190657556, -0.025308413431048393, -0.0009864344028756022, -0.028505554422736168, -0.016467222943902016, -0.021904291585087776, 0.020212756469845772, 0.03933117911219597, 0.016639821231365204, -0.024020902812480927, 0.01214474905282259, 0.058321550488471985, 0.004713503178209066, -0.04127473011612892, 0.0052567170932888985, -0.028100643306970596, 0.006541619077324867, -0.0180218368768692, -0.006243107840418816, -0.014831486158072948, 0.009352394379675388, -0.018191546201705933, -0.029811007902026176, -0.004679715260863304, -0.02957635000348091, 0.07968208938837051, 0.006194266490638256, 0.06465119868516922, 0.08576317876577377, 0.032052259892225266, 0.0017740176990628242, -0.045591823756694794, 0.023679478093981743, -0.03850273787975311, 0.02415819838643074, 0.057310912758111954, 0.0024779655504971743, -0.0223745945841074, 0.009044344536960125, 0.008015456609427929, 0.03678051754832268, 0.06248968094587326, 0.0035612324718385935, 0.02739354595541954, 0.0738738402724266, -0.04254823923110962, -0.050981588661670685, -0.021856477484107018, -0.07464666664600372, 0.025484874844551086, -0.05277947336435318, -0.017062200233340263, 0.03126957640051842, 0.06162296235561371, -0.007242143154144287, -0.03607526049017906, -0.02817690744996071, -0.06247570365667343, -0.011068207211792469, 0.017731064930558205, -0.01933768391609192, 0.011419330723583698, -0.004022468347102404, 0.0674973875284195, -0.03171420097351074, -0.010395694524049759, -0.04200683534145355, -0.08739952743053436, -0.008065862581133842, -0.007719011045992374, -0.020230187103152275, 0.05434945225715637, -0.015600844286382198, -0.017518632113933563, 0.008540531620383263, 0.00901913084089756, 0.0037627220153808594, -0.015494076535105705, 0.0016153769101947546, -0.036567218601703644, 0.048585981130599976, -0.010814818553626537, 0.007294400129467249, -0.012752952054142952, -0.006887221708893776, 0.11922524124383926, 0.08541232347488403, 0.014288339763879776, -0.04181063175201416, 0.027044041082262993, -0.018678227439522743, 0.010067708790302277, 0.0026077108923345804, 0.02892136573791504, -0.011955161578953266, -0.021427096799016, 0.06270609050989151, 0.009077639319002628, 0.03555077686905861, -0.0015666084364056587, 0.06324979662895203, -0.0062326653860509396, 0.005550089757889509, 0.01178801991045475, 0.006170776207000017, 0.011366008780896664, -0.007134397514164448, -0.04230934754014015, 0.013324792496860027, -0.014283701777458191, -0.01205424964427948, 0.004622857552021742, -0.0066639394499361515, 0.0033367520663887262, -0.007935062982141972, -0.031316399574279785, 0.03180934116244316, 0.017754150554537773, 0.0085256677120924, -0.005820635240525007, -0.010740323923528194, 0.022002406418323517, -0.008941806852817535, 0.023899728432297707, 0.03257536143064499, -0.01806161366403103, -0.008813508786261082, 0.0010134362382814288, 0.024448564276099205, -0.02403031475841999, -0.05547716096043587, -0.022813010960817337, 0.05060981586575508, -0.034327611327171326, -0.043243952095508575, -0.03427407890558243, -0.021957436576485634, -0.031215501949191093, -0.03680026903748512, -0.03234677016735077, 0.013706722296774387, 0.014581096358597279, -0.050559163093566895, -0.011373081244528294, -0.009989988058805466, -0.0009638400515541434, -0.027418622747063637, 0.014564212411642075, 0.037223197519779205, -0.025520043447613716, -0.012428081594407558, -0.007852599024772644, 0.038538314402103424, 0.01860034093260765, 0.008699399419128895, -0.01813969947397709, -0.04896422475576401, -0.018758848309516907, 0.012868136167526245, -0.0010191532783210278, -0.024198181927204132, 0.0007283215527422726, 0.012508387677371502, -0.00812129583209753, -0.012723627500236034, -0.04636711999773979, -0.005592761095613241, 0.01627187244594097, 0.014761824160814285, -0.03804553672671318, -0.025341928005218506, 0.04101166874170303, 0.03255016356706619, 0.05812279134988785, 0.007856101728975773, 0.001041077310219407, 0.04439743608236313, 0.02658006362617016, -0.02272316999733448, 0.0007319663418456912, 0.0008784853853285313, -0.025589440017938614, -0.014647219330072403, -0.058181602507829666, 0.06070913374423981, 0.009719641879200935, -0.010175819508731365, -0.025285135954618454, 0.024659371003508568, -0.0065643819980323315, 0.01629834622144699, 0.028166206553578377, -0.07366357743740082, -0.005849236156791449, 0.0015517467400059104, 0.019446494057774544, -0.05546518415212631, 0.010058946907520294, -0.014633125625550747, -0.032379940152168274, -0.0034279406536370516, -0.008542821742594242, -0.031199870631098747, -0.018936462700366974, -0.039565350860357285, -0.011498589999973774, -0.03259459137916565, 0.03301452100276947, -0.008598211221396923, 0.03152209147810936, -0.009680252522230148, 0.016917679458856583, 0.0077134487219154835, 0.0038859928026795387, 0.010172822512686253, 0.0033386172726750374, 0.04681691527366638, -0.024555904790759087, 0.03580695763230324, 0.0033300239592790604, 0.0005206316127441823, 0.015709497034549713, 0.03447898477315903, -0.009885731153190136, -0.018404586240649223, 0.06553685665130615, -0.0362112857401371, -0.031181611120700836, 0.043993670493364334, 0.018015803769230843, 0.02608487568795681, 0.013097696006298065, -0.036776140332221985, 0.01062682829797268, 0.02953331172466278, -0.036030735820531845, -0.03208213299512863, -0.004235723055899143, 0.03217163681983948, -0.014903581701219082, -0.01528798509389162, 0.05511393025517464, 0.03833793103694916, -0.02650802955031395, 0.04075748845934868, 0.022396491840481758, -0.0065595596097409725, 0.022405428811907768, 0.015056991018354893, -0.008049898780882359, 0.026560980826616287, 0.013364558108150959, -0.004773738328367472, 0.005737863946706057, 0.0339014045894146, -0.04288211092352867, 0.0025907536037266254, -0.03433665260672569, -0.0007092677406035364, -0.08529061079025269, -0.008551551029086113, 0.017258087173104286, 0.002290771109983325, 0.010813470929861069, -0.04596085101366043, -0.009328559041023254, 0.04941023886203766, -0.05128465220332146, 0.01982986554503441, -0.007332044653594494, -0.01094062626361847, -0.01952417381107807, 0.03377402573823929, -0.04709436371922493, 0.013845820911228657, 0.002779136411845684, 0.008072786033153534, 0.041224412620067596, 0.02992408350110054, 0.03751121833920479, -0.002547686453908682, -0.03976820036768913, 0.003613922046497464, 0.05837279558181763, -0.030458342283964157, 0.034919094294309616, -0.03970465809106827, -0.031631551682949066, 0.0236415546387434, -0.003317188937216997, 0.03161967173218727, -0.020195063203573227, 0.011926617473363876, -0.0210481695830822, 0.05596379190683365, 0.006317005027085543, -0.021492991596460342, -0.008876806125044823, -0.0011953487992286682, 0.032121285796165466, 0.04663108289241791, -0.03149222955107689, 0.016034027561545372, 0.023070015013217926, 0.004307283088564873, -0.037757594138383865, 0.03189726173877716, 0.0206917617470026, -0.04798732325434685, 0.012926134280860424, 0.0002910952898673713, 0.022880665957927704, -0.02344449609518051, 0.024853749200701714, -0.044913627207279205, -0.02579750306904316, 0.04061346873641014, 0.03462235629558563, -0.04151466488838196, 0.015058929100632668, -0.034914057701826096, -0.03297620266675949, 0.0017021283274516463, 0.004317029844969511, -0.03220069408416748, -0.08501726388931274, -0.00895457062870264, -0.008623837493360043, -0.008188538253307343, -0.03287367522716522, -0.025030124932527542, -0.0025891191326081753, 0.053112976253032684, -0.021461863070726395, -0.004490968771278858, -0.007840810343623161, -0.02665993943810463, -0.01846017688512802, -0.07396303117275238, 0.01938742771744728, 0.036747127771377563, -0.030280036851763725, -0.03487010672688484, 0.016023816540837288, -0.0560983344912529, 0.014489329420030117, 0.020906876772642136, 0.04023880884051323, -0.018191862851381302, 0.0014796715695410967, 0.009947309270501137, -0.0013574998592957854, -0.06522147357463837, 0.05925839766860008, -0.012199812568724155, -0.001175794517621398, -0.0007381351315416396, -0.0327146016061306, 0.002581111853942275, 0.0015070964582264423, 0.016833199188113213, -0.04376116394996643, 0.016758136451244354, 0.015312114730477333, 0.003340751165524125, 0.022798996418714523, 0.008654437027871609, -0.012815390713512897, 0.015546395443379879, -0.028337934985756874, -0.010649043135344982, 0.014128388836979866, 0.023953162133693695, -0.07859832793474197, 0.019170338287949562, -0.014144509099423885, 0.013777545653283596, -0.015785880386829376, 0.006575781852006912, -0.03334009647369385, -0.06820971518754959, 0.02283804677426815, 0.01081802137196064, -0.04296446964144707, 0.020926307886838913, 0.030629776418209076, 0.009164633229374886, -0.000355795695213601, 0.006239599082618952, 0.011769414879381657, -0.011529800482094288, 0.00011240636376896873, -0.006542184855788946, 0.0024003591388463974, 0.003271690336987376, -0.020577630028128624, -0.01901932805776596, 0.05222029238939285, -0.02250831201672554, 0.06499987095594406, 0.009577237069606781, -0.0002356716722715646, -0.031082728877663612, -0.016238365322351456, 0.018711885437369347, -0.017443612217903137, 0.0036869056057184935, -0.0018541060853749514, -0.02041427418589592, 0.02416030876338482, -0.026192419230937958, -0.0386270172894001, -0.043981872498989105, -0.007006134372204542, -0.00827538687735796, -0.001571987522765994, 0.024511586874723434, 0.053725115954875946, 0.01472632959485054, 0.0043763285502791405, -0.012939244508743286, -0.02555045671761036, 0.0035767394583672285, -0.0233012605458498, 0.02858162671327591, -0.00679961871355772, 0.03703458607196808, 0.000008011529644136317, 0.0019631837494671345, -0.04102626070380211, -0.03948451578617096, 0.02606542594730854, 0.055612415075302124, 0.04019356146454811, -0.01705445721745491, -0.05105920881032944, -0.03026897832751274, 0.056451331824064255, -0.03137337043881416, -0.008777817711234093, -0.04602519050240517, 0.06918683648109436, 0.016518041491508484, -0.002625721273943782 ]
<p>Using the Stata <code>graph twoway</code> command, I have created a scatterplot with a quadratic best fit line, using the <code>qfit</code> command. How can I get the equation of the best fit line? </p> <p>Example: </p> <pre><code>graph tw (scatter y x) (qfit y x) </code></pre>
992
[ -0.022662973031401634, 0.00517664011567831, 0.0018634709995239973, -0.008924953639507294, 0.011631254106760025, -0.0010609956225380301, 0.012476479634642601, 0.007549738045781851, 0.05703231319785118, -0.029712961986660957, 0.03731776773929596, 0.0511423721909523, 0.10090868175029755, 0.03787391260266304, -0.012105352245271206, -0.007882864214479923, -0.015884745866060257, 0.009442385286092758, -0.009913338348269463, -0.03255302086472511, -0.0006837783148512244, -0.008389346301555634, -0.023497845977544785, 0.012619134970009327, 0.006732587236911058, 0.04433877766132355, 0.04262107238173485, 0.022982008755207062, 0.02376226708292961, 0.045324306935071945, -0.0013126551639288664, -0.056365273892879486, -0.0168153103441, 0.030216500163078308, 0.05784425884485245, 0.0275734793394804, 0.03550374135375023, -0.003118326421827078, 0.01674325205385685, 0.02643946371972561, -0.029270851984620094, -0.00485449843108654, -0.0009816791862249374, 0.03503724932670593, -0.00582079729065299, 0.03418312221765518, 0.00663705775514245, -0.005859082564711571, 0.058114565908908844, -0.042996298521757126, 0.06048562005162239, -0.0026138799730688334, 0.013010133989155293, 0.022172914817929268, -0.03459650278091431, -0.01065739057958126, 0.020227236673235893, 0.060127127915620804, 0.003553743939846754, -0.04569314047694206, 0.004573554266244173, -0.020344899967312813, 0.0003678934299387038, -0.032353028655052185, -0.08268275111913681, 0.037419643253088, 0.003063538111746311, -0.02554788812994957, 0.031122226268053055, -0.032099977135658264, -0.017675794661045074, 0.027025511488318443, 0.0731113851070404, -0.02556375414133072, 0.01958884671330452, -0.018529247492551804, 0.03681298717856407, 0.03480090945959091, 0.01646626740694046, 0.008711791597306728, 0.02883290685713291, 0.04506127908825874, 0.0035254498943686485, 0.04650862142443657, -0.022403962910175323, 0.009726439602673054, 0.048034220933914185, -0.01230641920119524, 0.02285485528409481, 0.026329055428504944, -0.007306137587875128, 0.025409622117877007, 0.06785976141691208, 0.0026496073696762323, 0.022188950330018997, 0.03493918105959892, 0.0008000214002095163, 0.0364559181034565, 0.002414932707324624, -0.04456004500389099, 0.016047505661845207, -0.037564173340797424, -0.01711639203131199, 0.03147478774189949, -0.00964969489723444, -0.00591655820608139, -0.003128614043816924, -0.024192430078983307, 0.00426942715421319, -0.0185481458902359, -0.008750037290155888, 0.013405404053628445, 0.008928188122808933, 0.02103647217154503, -0.006093678995966911, -0.029231799766421318, -0.024028269574046135, 0.0015455539105460048, 0.057610467076301575, 0.06058546155691147, 0.011203629896044731, -0.05671750381588936, 0.007249831221997738, -0.03504135459661484, -0.026820508763194084, 0.03265015408396721, -0.025570573285222054, -0.035130053758621216, -0.04276316612958908, 0.02894315868616104, -0.009194696322083473, -0.016137292608618736, 0.019712815061211586, 0.0020193520467728376, 0.008310751058161259, -0.004317907616496086, -0.08714957535266876, -0.0723617672920227, 0.011881120502948761, 0.0035459878854453564, 0.028247062116861343, -0.04545194283127785, 0.023752689361572266, 0.03214024379849434, 0.08339159935712814, -0.003143692621961236, 0.035858966410160065, 0.025692254304885864, 0.018960053101181984, 0.0035821457859128714, -0.05226825922727585, -0.03041071631014347, 0.008182537741959095, -0.03369620442390442, 0.01968468725681305, -0.04703588783740997, -0.01377343013882637, 0.0044127097353339195, -0.05741800740361214, -0.015791593119502068, 0.031868889927864075, -0.0005892383633181453, -0.05870915949344635, 0.029083959758281708, -0.023923303931951523, -0.03938606008887291, 0.0921049416065216, 0.020512381568551064, -0.03035174496471882, 0.029650188982486725, -0.014417147263884544, -0.0037641979288309813, -0.0080312080681324, 0.011737030930817127, 0.028178073465824127, -0.018842175602912903, -0.013751506805419922, -0.010906258597970009, 0.009161730296909809, 0.009212339296936989, -0.007825465872883797, -0.0319291390478611, -0.021055255085229874, 0.022185683250427246, 0.012463581748306751, 0.050783175975084305, -0.016096536070108414, 0.024186156690120697, 0.054737288504838943, -0.06592326611280441, -0.0656532496213913, -0.030043235048651695, -0.008191526867449284, 0.04070644825696945, -0.009704199619591236, -0.020163940265774727, 0.005058299750089645, 0.020831260830163956, 0.014792178757488728, -0.0017353500006720424, 0.0035861011128872633, 0.002063508378341794, 0.026216143742203712, -0.011846347711980343, 0.003052724525332451, 0.05807828903198242, 0.07157620787620544, -0.030150897800922394, 0.042488351464271545, -0.05105237290263176, 0.0008483948768116534, 0.012175634503364563, -0.045143406838178635, 0.020505767315626144, -0.05391692742705345, -0.003004011232405901, -0.04309987276792526, 0.00835554488003254, 0.0015560314059257507, 0.0113123944029212, -0.034210070967674255, 0.04157295078039169, 0.09439574182033539, 0.024329490959644318, -0.010334462858736515, 0.006896903272718191, -0.027867699041962624, 0.03859950602054596, -0.007901904173195362, -0.01448681391775608, -0.023778028786182404, -0.007504085544496775, 0.006939781829714775, 0.0179279875010252, -0.04301410913467407, -0.004896515980362892, 0.06182882562279701, -0.029550159350037575, -0.01152968592941761, 0.021140405908226967, -0.04602997377514839, -0.000836431048810482, 0.022993074730038643, 0.00837037991732359, 0.013626733794808388, -0.01977815292775631, 0.01452879048883915, 0.015875492244958878, -0.006227399688214064, 0.04294535517692566, -0.007947668433189392, 0.05978366360068321, -0.006191023625433445, -0.02783266454935074, 0.03572709858417511, -0.04710882157087326, 0.05445379763841629, -0.02106102928519249, 0.021438544616103172, 0.07009236514568329, -0.01348120253533125, -0.0378500334918499, 0.0430956706404686, 0.02168906293809414, 0.023018889129161835, 0.03840191662311554, -0.011912974528968334, -0.00846017338335514, 0.010204833000898361, 0.00112387933768332, 0.01729271188378334, -0.016344787552952766, -0.020168500021100044, -0.029053984209895134, -0.02388058975338936, 0.019673887640237808, 0.020589791238307953, 0.0054013472981750965, -0.024465398862957954, -0.0439271442592144, 0.01058809645473957, -0.03514149785041809, 0.026919692754745483, -0.0006115569267421961, -0.022603588178753853, -0.00931504461914301, -0.04857607185840607, -0.016349097713828087, -0.013730496168136597, 0.009736414067447186, -0.005188142415136099, 0.019752591848373413, -0.020214149728417397, -0.025352127850055695, -0.012678776867687702, -0.01597331278026104, -0.0051247538067400455, -0.004507451318204403, 0.015114554204046726, -0.0020095687359571457, 0.033700838685035706, -0.021215949207544327, 0.003124567912891507, -0.07812917977571487, -0.03441568836569786, -0.016045400872826576, 0.006805777549743652, 0.0389026440680027, 0.03246261551976204, 0.04848378524184227, -0.0020806232932955027, -0.0302411001175642, -0.0041694724932312965, -0.07082454115152359, -0.014811118133366108, 0.039378393441438675, 0.036842893809080124, 0.0157655980437994, -0.023219943046569824, -0.01262311078608036, 0.040652140974998474, 0.002638478996232152, -0.04852185398340225, -0.06631483137607574, -0.021732889115810394, -0.013222502544522285, -0.03404296189546585, 0.03194805979728699, -0.01710653118789196, 0.018754255026578903, 0.020913444459438324, -0.006413052324205637, 0.05258675292134285, 0.07957884669303894, -0.03393804281949997, -0.021043194457888603, 0.016415681689977646, -0.0008024890557862818, -0.01639784686267376, 0.0054617347195744514, 0.01672537811100483, -0.017954805865883827, 0.05695014446973801, 0.0027063407469540834, 0.012714669108390808, -0.01635279878973961, -0.0408695824444294, -0.02052435278892517, -0.003195046680048108, 0.011536852456629276, -0.08554140478372574, 0.009298417717218399, 0.013311375863850117, 0.013364613987505436, 0.02020150050520897, 0.015670081600546837, 0.03183821216225624, -0.03015894815325737, 0.01698284037411213, 0.021079115569591522, 0.015311883762478828, 0.027591180056333542, -0.007062018383294344, -0.017446886748075485, -0.02497257851064205, 0.01118492428213358, -0.007560761645436287, -0.02272544428706169, 0.031741850078105927, 0.027476761490106583, 0.024107763543725014, -0.009280147030949593, -0.01932707615196705, 0.03652530908584595, -0.06995268911123276, -0.040242116898298264, -0.02446119859814644, 0.08209996670484543, 0.026812845841050148, 0.027939658612012863, -0.021139446645975113, 0.017533669248223305, 0.0008463797275908291, -0.02105380780994892, -0.04713553562760353, 0.04158636927604675, 0.010510345920920372, 0.011531347408890724, 0.03320515155792236, -0.030734296888113022, 0.03323344513773918, -0.019041763618588448, -0.0063558779656887054, 0.0008118873811326921, 0.030239854007959366, -0.03489303216338158, 0.008885704912245274, -0.016733156517148018, 0.013571391813457012, -0.022651273757219315, 0.03688777983188629, 0.0022298982366919518, -0.05793914198875427, 0.0061560082249343395, 0.04765346646308899, -0.005560358986258507, -0.014487547799944878, -0.02420441061258316, -0.013213739730417728, 0.04649225249886513, 0.011621694080531597, 0.016642143949866295, -0.021056046709418297, -0.03656873479485512, 0.024749811738729477, -0.03885615989565849, 0.034308288246393204, 0.055490266531705856, -0.009923575446009636, -0.0009372862405143678, -0.017960263416171074, 0.01329959649592638, -0.04894623905420303, 0.009762175381183624, 0.000792295322753489, -0.008021303452551365, 0.032416652888059616, 0.0254023689776659, -0.07003011554479599, 0.052378010004758835, 0.07084288448095322, 0.04079226776957512, -0.0010137934004887938, 0.009453384205698967, -0.007148050237447023, 0.005713292863219976, 0.0008663141052238643, 0.01594979502260685, 0.012892927043139935, -0.017324276268482208, 0.005169366020709276, 0.034859709441661835, 0.007402919698506594, -0.04993876442313194, 0.007096454501152039, 0.03647208958864212, 0.047556642442941666, 0.010761278681457043, -0.04684906825423241, -0.003288275795057416, 0.0446094274520874, -0.0266901683062315, 0.03420494124293327, -0.00008530430204700679, -0.08067826926708221, -0.031484317034482956, 0.02547384798526764, 0.023045146837830544, -0.013526436872780323, -0.06542572379112244, -0.019860684871673584, -0.009299982339143753, 0.018164996057748795, -0.029866687953472137, 0.02045726403594017, -0.011642870493233204, 0.03709021583199501, -0.03802681341767311, -0.014782008714973927, -0.06577888131141663, 0.011617904528975487, 0.012711535207927227, 0.005670635960996151, 0.020487729460000992, -0.0250131543725729, -0.025303080677986145, 0.01975075714290142, -0.03810502961277962, 0.024317601695656776, -0.039950646460056305, -0.018214458599686623, 0.015489901416003704, 0.02217235043644905, -0.06242154538631439, -0.04679861664772034, -0.01723366603255272, -0.010930556803941727, 0.004246511962264776, 0.04390804097056389, -0.01014256663620472, -0.00510894600301981, -0.01913977973163128, -0.008290160447359085, -0.009539254009723663, -0.00016740671708248556, -0.028285225853323936, -0.0007360283634625375, 0.022190097719430923, 0.012205487117171288, 0.07127229124307632, 0.04998064786195755, -0.005961896385997534, -0.041064273566007614, -0.04565209895372391, 0.01702137477695942, -0.011042941361665726, -0.029348354786634445, -0.01108669675886631, 0.008542138151824474, -0.02325776405632496, -0.008557133376598358, -0.009428159333765507, 0.026552656665444374, -0.07234274595975876, -0.0038162479177117348, -0.027085762470960617, 0.03665874898433685, -0.019972706213593483, -0.011697771959006786, 0.04468131437897682, 0.05713534355163574, 0.021062813699245453, -0.05204106867313385, 0.0024479080457240343, 0.00012817711103707552, -0.01930936984717846, 0.007527994457632303, -0.0043337056413292885, 0.03431430086493492, -0.00918847881257534, -0.029795048758387566, -0.010937000624835491, -0.017298003658652306, 0.0019182979594916105, -0.030663056299090385, 0.016418607905507088, -0.013447826728224754, -0.02409340813755989, -0.0349140390753746, 0.04282093048095703, 0.03153863921761513, -0.006510717328637838, -0.028942173346877098, 0.0341707319021225, 0.01396382786333561, 0.00884728878736496, -0.0645386278629303, -0.047923654317855835, 0.028421316295862198, -0.012035120278596878, -0.038274284452199936, 0.0077508194372057915, -0.02798311784863472, 0.00116110616363585, -0.00550266494974494, 0.008633719757199287, 0.013622668571770191, -0.01934817247092724, -0.016670769080519676, -0.005894261412322521, 0.02645878866314888, 0.02540753036737442, 0.025821562856435776, 0.0011174066457897425, -0.002484143478795886, -0.023583311587572098, -0.023468350991606712, 0.04190906509757042, 0.007077200338244438, -0.018945973366498947, -0.0008861829992383718, -0.03535321727395058, 0.030800240114331245, -0.00747060077264905, -0.00387403997592628, 0.01669497974216938, -0.01104629784822464, 0.007290227338671684, -0.013007081113755703, -0.050105247646570206, -0.020364398136734962, -0.04188501462340355, 0.006591094192117453, 0.0048408955335617065, -0.0009342731791548431, -0.0104373162612319, 0.01900807023048401, 0.027119576930999756, -0.01833239197731018, -0.04431930184364319, -0.016859419643878937, 0.07625366002321243, 0.02773003838956356, 0.0012216371251270175, 0.01906876638531685, -0.02322250045835972, 0.027706289663910866, 0.01681847684085369, -0.011747500859200954, 0.004745212849229574, 0.009918113239109516, -0.040311139076948166, -0.009803739376366138, -0.01516728661954403, 0.017786556854844093, 0.06758812069892883, -0.009138822555541992, 0.05488215759396553, 0.042728204280138016, -0.020687133073806763, 0.003431360237300396, -0.06778449565172195, -0.014509301632642746, -0.0056589525192976, 0.03082835115492344, 0.0760231763124466, 0.018716799095273018, -0.011921565979719162, 0.03940103203058243, 0.04751146584749222, 0.002223515883088112, 0.020248854532837868, 0.03397621586918831, 0.04620734974741936, 0.007831226103007793, -0.015678850933909416, -0.07399515062570572, -0.004743694327771664, -0.010979264043271542, 0.02222522534430027, -0.020808538421988487, -0.0350627638399601, 0.014694885350763798, 0.006832796148955822, 0.0021492433734238148, -0.03668403625488281, -0.00662654172629118, -0.04565568268299103, 0.016677696257829666, 0.039612893015146255, -0.01905723102390766, 0.05754440650343895, 0.04179474711418152, 0.04345392435789108, -0.015486864373087883, 0.04891834035515785, -0.04676166921854019, -0.03881443664431572, -0.019350402057170868, -0.03501443192362785, -0.013594279997050762, 0.01315505150705576, -0.007678484544157982, -0.030827391892671585, 0.030650582164525986, -0.036872394382953644, 0.0018477329285815358, -0.0000821453650132753, 0.04027437046170235, 0.01802554540336132, 0.06337091326713562, -0.016557324677705765, 0.013436238281428814, -0.012720109894871712, -0.04544014856219292, 0.12841859459877014, 0.10660863667726517, 0.048837270587682724, -0.07767399400472641, -0.001733422395773232, 0.006005541887134314, -0.02293693646788597, -0.004788768012076616, -2.2423253653869324e-7, 0.0013357787393033504, -0.03319775313138962, 0.07611197233200073, 0.06466561555862427, 0.0055477130226790905, 0.05138631537556648, 0.04392269253730774, -0.05200692638754845, -0.03716684877872467, 0.024256525561213493, 0.011116093024611473, 0.00032864214153960347, 0.017209786921739578, -0.05499695986509323, 0.0136933084577322, -0.0022411339450627565, 0.002615273231640458, -0.0062060169875621796, 0.012271087616682053, -0.01025783084332943, 0.010942311957478523, -0.012281263247132301, 0.042689573019742966, 0.034199170768260956, 0.052168041467666626, -0.031480804085731506, -0.028168145567178726, 0.0020059694070369005, -0.025009235367178917, -0.027783479541540146, 0.024027470499277115, 0.006958490237593651, 0.025586837902665138, -0.020157895982265472, -0.0002512962091714144, -0.03272993117570877, -0.0026494073681533337, 0.005700558889657259, -0.0024195846635848284, 0.00958926323801279, 0.004100476391613483, -0.029137320816516876, 0.029380517080426216, -0.005040477495640516, 0.013614657334983349, -0.042174000293016434, -0.008046616800129414, 0.0483236089348793, -0.04421808570623398, -0.005958367604762316, -0.02757004275918007, -0.02215978503227234, -0.0338868610560894, 0.024257004261016846, 0.04554155096411705, 0.012762833386659622, 0.020258717238903046, -0.02300328202545643, 0.051193371415138245, 0.0062311929650604725, -0.014018370769917965, 0.021904682740569115, -0.06561475992202759, -0.020312558859586716, -0.04497307538986206, 0.03160890191793442, 0.03532189130783081, 0.01909884437918663, -0.009770386852324009, -0.021325351670384407, -0.06536293029785156, -0.05484653264284134, 0.002072857692837715, -0.05285609886050224, -0.0030776108615100384, -0.038402259349823, -0.029697759076952934, 0.05930960923433304, 0.047437634319067, -0.009622783400118351, 0.01172192394733429, 0.00009804080764297396, 0.007568158209323883, 0.01781449280679226, -0.06419432163238525, -0.03971181809902191, 0.023844461888074875, -0.01885206252336502, -0.04716965928673744, -0.017738020047545433, 0.0619087740778923, 0.062312208116054535, 0.059993769973516464, -0.0031740390695631504, 0.03417776897549629, -0.0040092263370752335, 0.014097402803599834, 0.032435037195682526, -0.04912850633263588, 0.027648109942674637, -0.02206057496368885, -0.02249589003622532, -0.03104490414261818, -0.004327630158513784, -0.05789920315146446, -0.036835793405771255, 0.04557635635137558, 0.029984349384903908, -0.08405674993991852, 0.052427083253860474, -0.01004334632307291, -0.007865285500884056, -0.0605655163526535, 0.019412396475672722, -0.03356404975056648, 0.000010533001841395162, -0.002756713191047311, -0.023582275956869125, -0.014571767300367355, 0.028560474514961243, -0.0038938417565077543, 0.026824595406651497, 0.007195374462753534, 0.02455192059278488, 0.006650217343121767, 0.03152824938297272, 0.0044616577215492725, 0.018824346363544464, 0.06011096015572548, -0.021730393171310425, -0.0014860267983749509, -0.01019859779626131, -0.06103908643126488, -0.018492894247174263, 0.017291702330112457, -0.01432926394045353, 0.030451271682977676, 0.022392423823475838, -0.008308601565659046, -0.037610672414302826, 0.034230928868055344, -0.014151114970445633, -0.006636177189648151, -0.009045058861374855, -0.022120701149106026, 0.021800365298986435, 0.03799159824848175, -0.027517706155776978, 0.021759560331702232, -0.027719493955373764, 0.05160798132419586, 0.04628321900963783, -0.009575635194778442, -0.024796143174171448, 0.007645549718290567, -0.017577439546585083, 0.024337025359272957, 0.023477142676711082, -0.005853904411196709, 0.04268788918852806, 0.04939557984471321, -0.01606805995106697, -0.011407781392335892, -0.03340236842632294, 0.0400274284183979, -0.05782487988471985, -0.005114282947033644, -0.028243862092494965, 0.009619344025850296, 0.030198590829968452, -0.04662938788533211, 0.026759052649140358, 0.058447860181331635, -0.007627608720213175, 0.018196336925029755, -0.011229450814425945, 0.016833296045660973, -0.044590506702661514, 0.010954528115689754, -0.007666943594813347, 0.0541832260787487, 0.04706631973385811, 0.020262839272618294, 0.03575333207845688, 0.004679990466684103, -0.007527503650635481, -0.014979569241404533, -0.0026544667780399323, 0.008700942620635033, 0.026448583230376244, -0.057810693979263306, 0.02259327657520771, -0.029319049790501595, -0.0035559027455747128, 0.02687913179397583, -0.014630677178502083, 0.04899556562304497, -0.010381847620010376, 0.006865371484309435, -0.034317221492528915, 0.06054803356528282, 0.023509232327342033, -0.01650177873671055, -0.003910313360393047, -0.014731453731656075, 0.01652815006673336, 0.0361739806830883, -0.013853673823177814, 0.023068122565746307, -0.016730189323425293, -0.009337295778095722, -0.04980736970901489, 0.028084106743335724, -7.928732657092041e-7, -0.0018509906949475408, 0.004111514892429113, -0.027803268283605576, -0.0076299263164401054, -0.028050120919942856, 0.01628774218261242, -0.002545163268223405, -0.003334545763209462, 0.0478060208261013, 0.010730769485235214, 0.014158885926008224, -0.0372505821287632, -0.008065523579716682, -0.052361954003572464, 0.02358369342982769, -0.0006732094334438443, -0.0080419247969985, -0.05092189460992813, -0.014864840544760227, -0.017950255423784256, -0.006559646222740412, -0.021862709894776344, 0.0029094114433974028, 0.020042169839143753, 0.04924388974905014, -0.026100309565663338, -0.04572593793272972, 0.031291138380765915, -0.03226417303085327, 0.021540764719247818, -0.07387708127498627, 0.04154210910201073, -0.0009867270709946752, -0.05104891210794449, -0.014916072599589825, 0.020788073539733887, -0.01932276412844658, -0.012725085951387882, 0.030067093670368195, -0.00817087385803461, -0.03083307109773159, -0.042598940432071686, 0.03801234811544418, 0.010708851739764214, -0.038320571184158325, 0.013595761731266975, -0.0017081069527193904, -0.0006113194394856691, 0.00011597150296438485, 0.01810288615524769, 0.02673530764877796, 0.04037385433912277, 0.025595538318157196, 0.00004817107765120454, 0.015776654705405235, 0.01784929260611534, -0.025724072009325027, -0.0022029380779713392, -0.015224101021885872, -0.0004427440871950239, 0.04710208624601364, -0.002099128207191825, -0.031233787536621094, 0.08039546012878418, -0.00010038874461315572, -0.03604419529438019, 0.04189806431531906, -0.014322792179882526, -0.013056792318820953, -0.0191822312772274, -0.02889445796608925, 0.006490219850093126, -0.057134535163640976, 0.008266246877610683, 0.022405274212360382, -0.019480358809232712, -0.0017205523326992989, 0.021947460249066353, 0.018178526312112808, 0.04002950340509415, -0.015410217456519604, -0.005991026293486357, -0.012110398150980473, -0.009542534127831459, 0.020296171307563782, 0.017613811418414116, 0.022623900324106216, 0.030261781066656113, 0.0023490211460739374, 0.038582637906074524, -0.01589532382786274, 0.03920844942331314, -0.01642271876335144, 0.03258439153432846, -0.01698330231010914, -0.047557927668094635, 0.02218424528837204, 0.027650129050016403, 0.04104401543736458, 0.006928629707545042, -0.05397607758641243, 0.02351992018520832, -0.05495987460017204, 0.02190268412232399, -0.0319053940474987, -0.004577377811074257, -0.08297421038150787, -0.001518410281278193, -0.007838078774511814, 0.0030629064422100782, 0.006568189710378647, 0.013436732813715935, 0.03343787416815758, -0.013610857538878918, 0.019091462716460228, 0.003577848430722952, 0.0079851308837533, 0.009416286833584309, 0.029483214020729065, -0.04245952144265175, -0.01367542240768671, -0.010686282999813557, -0.007108921185135841, 0.02325131744146347, 0.025410130620002747, -0.01428802777081728, -0.037595849484205246, -0.03968207165598869, -0.041566409170627594, 0.029288286343216896, -0.05491907522082329, -0.03993815556168556, -0.004489688202738762, -0.010848025791347027, -0.006914097815752029, -0.042130935937166214 ]
<p>Proportion, ratio, and percentage data is very common in ecology (eg, % of flowers pollinated, male:female sex ratio, % mortality in response to a treatment, % of leaf eaten by an herbivore). An article was recently published by some applied statisticians in the journal <em>Ecology</em> titled "<a href="http://www.esajournals.org/doi/abs/10.1890/10-0340.1" rel="nofollow">The arcsine is asinine: the analysis of proportions in ecology</a>." They noted that the arcsine transformation has been promoted by long-running texts like Zar's "Biostatistical Analysis" and Sokal and Rohlf's "Biometry" (both in their 3rd or 4th eds.) but this technique has been outmoded by generalized linear models and better computing.</p> <p>I was wondering how common proportion data is in other fields (psych? medicine?) if the arsine is still commonly used in other fields or if ecologists are exceptional in their use of this (or other) outmoded or less than optimal techniques. Have there been papers in other fields that highlight the need to use more advanced techniques?</p>
74,259
[ 0.008360444568097591, -0.014885787852108479, 0.03114342875778675, -0.011706406250596046, 0.004192689433693886, -0.0023531008046120405, -0.02404576539993286, -0.02647605910897255, 0.027781691402196884, -0.030771251767873764, 0.018506554886698723, 0.012123814783990383, 0.020281901583075523, 0.031018313020467758, 0.03779928386211395, 0.0029455763287842274, -0.016876479610800743, 0.020737435668706894, 0.0213987547904253, 0.010297094471752644, 0.01727672666311264, -0.006496783345937729, 0.00487271323800087, -0.0664394423365593, -0.0010277715045958757, 0.025528768077492714, -0.005104678217321634, -0.02990715764462948, 0.01138799637556076, 0.06441293656826019, -0.029816390946507454, -0.0007194692734628916, 0.042520634829998016, 0.01745186187326908, 0.04568316787481308, -0.02622058056294918, -0.004357697907835245, -0.027654046192765236, 0.025586184114217758, 0.0880359411239624, -0.056733354926109314, -0.039878081530332565, 0.024198582395911217, -0.0019316766411066055, -0.027886683121323586, 0.035196296870708466, 0.004324284382164478, -0.03806111216545105, 0.006939822807908058, -0.01024957187473774, 0.10271167755126953, 0.005858290940523148, 0.02156694047152996, 0.014929366298019886, 0.00020008592400699854, 0.0324157290160656, 0.04297342896461487, 0.019767168909311295, 0.006149422377347946, -0.07056090980768204, -0.01146521233022213, -0.02521369233727455, -0.030472034588456154, 0.01464000716805458, 0.0038100178353488445, 0.0053510828875005245, -0.01910674199461937, -0.03139388561248779, 0.03287234157323837, -0.002720506861805916, 0.013228225521743298, 0.023695338517427444, 0.05102236941456795, 0.0006267998251132667, -0.06339248269796371, -0.005787864327430725, 0.011589530855417252, -0.006077914033085108, 0.06850232183933258, 0.027471015229821205, -0.006126800552010536, 0.02274234965443611, 0.003680533031001687, 0.03205350413918495, 0.02480027824640274, -0.027285611256957054, 0.0765950158238411, -0.05209344998002052, -0.00254987389780581, -0.0018498662393540144, -0.019997920840978622, 0.0278666689991951, 0.04373740777373314, -0.010766223073005676, -0.07218107581138611, 0.048279549926519394, 0.012420027516782284, 0.03963358327746391, -0.022902237251400948, -0.002383410930633545, -0.016550058498978615, -0.01564102992415428, 0.01068259496241808, 0.0484660305082798, -0.03890620917081833, -0.01554530393332243, -0.03401178866624832, 0.005106315482407808, -0.006119253113865852, -0.011368470266461372, -0.011739330366253853, 0.030033638700842857, 0.04140442982316017, 0.05130726099014282, 0.008104483596980572, 0.001144871232099831, 0.018022658303380013, 0.000661503872834146, 0.09447227418422699, 0.07897859811782837, 0.020298147574067116, 0.005806553177535534, 0.0283283032476902, -0.007545464672148228, -0.030596444383263588, 0.021184828132390976, 0.010725886560976505, -0.035822201520204544, -0.06553377956151962, 0.05378343164920807, -0.006574386265128851, -0.016742704436182976, 0.043951358646154404, -0.016324300318956375, 0.0007016005110926926, -0.0062347035855054855, -0.05342823266983032, -0.03515515848994255, -0.0051560900174081326, 0.022869249805808067, 0.021620139479637146, -0.05647401511669159, 0.023217560723423958, 0.017600931227207184, 0.0386577732861042, 0.039320893585681915, 0.054733436554670334, -0.00743595277890563, 0.03710264340043068, 0.024262553080916405, 0.001025442499667406, -0.02388569340109825, 0.022704103961586952, -0.058447010815143585, -0.011970443651080132, -0.07368635386228561, 0.010127385146915913, -0.008982282131910324, 0.01699524186551571, 0.0310524869710207, 0.0611332543194294, 0.009442858397960663, -0.03933379054069519, 0.021655302494764328, -0.0022966463584452868, -0.003428326454013586, 0.05544847622513771, -0.021048324182629585, 0.02730502001941204, 0.010790047235786915, -0.004487687721848488, 0.04578520357608795, 0.026682594791054726, 0.007111405022442341, 0.06283745914697647, -0.040912505239248276, 0.02048150636255741, -0.006021706387400627, -0.02975345216691494, 0.05832010135054588, -0.05903785675764084, -0.0013582839164882898, 0.016929779201745987, 0.016641955822706223, 0.03718765452504158, 0.02614460699260235, -0.012179294601082802, -0.06737621873617172, 0.06443580240011215, -0.059813402593135834, -0.024569181725382805, -0.05428004637360573, 0.006822760216891766, -0.018935181200504303, -0.006977899465709925, 0.03592347726225853, -0.004622085019946098, -0.02407589554786682, -0.005884082522243261, -0.008476708084344864, 0.02127586118876934, -0.0007655008812434971, 0.07496389001607895, -0.05236925184726715, -0.009295661002397537, 0.03352096676826477, -0.010126225650310516, -0.011812575161457062, 0.02990701049566269, -0.056482940912246704, -0.09491266310214996, -0.02732846885919571, -0.039481110870838165, 0.013759426772594452, 0.01292913593351841, -0.04154259338974953, 0.0066167498007416725, 0.007413459476083517, -0.06445149332284927, 0.049873724579811096, -0.06269880384206772, 0.06915793567895889, 0.052813030779361725, 0.010278553701937199, 0.0007146313437260687, 0.03766343742609024, 0.015866832807660103, 0.0007555620977655053, 0.0073785907588899136, -0.041664399206638336, -0.07692501693964005, 0.047546956688165665, 0.042607638984918594, -0.0077926162630319595, -0.0006412581424228847, 0.041838470846414566, 0.04321104660630226, 0.051740214228630066, -0.003523395163938403, 0.017494548112154007, -0.0012048312928527594, -0.03967256098985672, -0.02007729932665825, -0.004900399595499039, 0.030538322404026985, 0.004068606533110142, 0.005964923650026321, -0.015693295747041702, 0.04349788278341293, 0.028422821313142776, -0.008618689142167568, 0.008227371610701084, 0.02242221124470234, -0.0003821887366939336, 0.010251784697175026, 0.02666623517870903, 0.033810168504714966, -0.07092433422803879, -0.014942559413611889, 0.04741690680384636, 0.008150257170200348, -0.01272735558450222, 0.02364952303469181, -0.016770584508776665, 0.011575187556445599, -0.007283299695700407, -0.06312646716833115, 0.02271590381860733, -0.000003986152023571776, -0.03365200757980347, 0.004605650436133146, -0.07601132988929749, -0.05378476902842522, -0.0749274343252182, 0.01127502229064703, 0.034518517553806305, 0.013105913996696472, 0.03129967302083969, 0.00673404335975647, 0.02060638554394245, -0.015927812084555626, 0.0058839935809373856, -0.022498125210404396, 0.025712376460433006, -0.05228746682405472, -0.001629781792871654, 0.0014152181101962924, -0.02475345879793167, 0.0038439943455159664, -0.029249370098114014, -0.007921813987195492, 0.010363243520259857, 0.028050541877746582, -0.0350700244307518, -0.014186689630150795, 0.003468354232609272, -0.00803835317492485, 0.0019291779026389122, -0.005290411412715912, 0.008841035887598991, 0.006607563700526953, -0.0065296851098537445, 0.017274705693125725, 0.009303982369601727, -0.005819201003760099, -0.04755374416708946, 0.028961479663848877, -0.01885361596941948, 0.0016766393091529608, 0.009306318126618862, 0.007922320626676083, -0.055169012397527695, -0.024370582774281502, -0.06824776530265808, -0.05840523913502693, -0.032286517322063446, 0.04182633012533188, 0.041834842413663864, 0.03396061435341835, -0.007447125855833292, 0.05030984431505203, 0.0008375953184440732, -0.01318850927054882, -0.02784714847803116, -0.0025614683981984854, -0.005109595600515604, 0.047771379351615906, 0.024361401796340942, 0.010960843414068222, 0.042714159935712814, 0.02095484547317028, -0.023143159225583076, 0.03486669436097145, 0.04521111771464348, 0.005049907602369785, -0.020467152819037437, 0.02165098674595356, 0.02019231952726841, 0.005110932048410177, 0.00376284122467041, 0.05432518944144249, -0.01521453820168972, 0.04183482378721237, -0.01553956139832735, 0.027245447039604187, 0.03575218841433525, -0.047864459455013275, 0.0012048553908243775, -0.0065041035413742065, -0.017782295122742653, 0.011169455014169216, -0.0012693159515038133, 0.03638613969087601, 0.01445046253502369, 0.007321592886000872, 0.033275291323661804, 0.028627101331949234, -0.02629964053630829, -0.003129718592390418, 0.04357506334781647, 0.05015696585178375, -0.0516241118311882, 0.01164060365408659, -0.010597090236842632, -0.004830864258110523, 0.01151724997907877, -0.00911843590438366, -0.018218940123915672, 0.012322700582444668, 0.038046859204769135, -0.004685142543166876, -0.039249978959560394, -0.02685745805501938, 0.004926803521811962, -0.06707892566919327, -0.014480090700089931, -0.05773289501667023, 0.017260773107409477, -0.02589225396513939, 0.03929213434457779, -0.001203913358040154, -0.035654451698064804, 0.010429495014250278, -0.011909621767699718, -0.04327849671244621, -0.003016037866473198, 0.014054193161427975, 0.01380462758243084, 0.02876650169491768, -0.018246665596961975, 0.0330704003572464, -0.012049435637891293, -0.0042448812164366245, -0.03444373607635498, 0.0007696878165006638, -0.0037869878578931093, 0.020407697185873985, -0.014660913497209549, -0.0538192056119442, -0.017902415245771408, 0.0017720783362165093, -0.00602911738678813, -0.0403633713722229, 0.02882476896047592, 0.0251596812158823, 0.02834288962185383, -0.04033156856894493, -0.05421646311879158, 0.03280474245548248, 0.0497223436832428, 0.033665839582681656, 0.012386498972773552, 0.0012431680224835873, -0.09159283339977264, 0.0343000628054142, 0.00742475688457489, 0.06365558505058289, -0.001963893650099635, -0.013591740280389786, -0.017454909160733223, -0.0016853674314916134, -0.023205725476145744, 0.005695649888366461, 0.0016687304014340043, 0.052827320992946625, -0.005811057053506374, 0.033177848905324936, 0.024249931797385216, -0.024158407002687454, 0.03877904638648033, -0.00046586673124693334, -0.029181592166423798, 0.008075256831943989, -0.024835562333464622, -0.002061333041638136, 0.0250085536390543, -0.010517092421650887, 0.033391620963811874, 0.017207395285367966, 0.003300219075754285, -0.0011226646602153778, 0.02318575046956539, 0.0034752856008708477, -0.029517611488699913, 0.003964419476687908, 0.0020545260049402714, 0.00869713257998228, -0.03773290291428566, -0.02685178816318512, 0.01382182165980339, 0.02487042173743248, 0.09527229517698288, 0.013932312838733196, 0.00735972635447979, -0.04717158526182175, 0.03274243324995041, 0.03135634958744049, 0.015482570976018906, -0.03792085126042366, 0.020553477108478546, -0.009885162115097046, -0.006485130172222853, 0.012128505855798721, -0.015611886978149414, 0.002214173786342144, -0.04860873147845268, 0.0025976458564400673, -0.04491783306002617, -0.05990615114569664, -0.0010977438651025295, 0.002605424029752612, -0.003883236087858677, -0.010095426812767982, -0.009922517463564873, -0.003343168878927827, -0.03899678960442543, 0.010761203244328499, -0.006052461452782154, 0.0341002456843853, 0.00937877967953682, -0.03056364133954048, 0.029207026585936546, 0.012640230357646942, -0.02181899920105934, -0.05489800497889519, 0.03014959767460823, 0.0007762077730149031, 0.0010349081130698323, 0.0362594909965992, -0.02418210543692112, -0.02377510443329811, 0.05004415661096573, 0.014066539704799652, -0.04133579879999161, -0.01900232397019863, -0.031668707728385925, 0.038881391286849976, 0.03812365606427193, 0.01767861098051071, 0.07503363490104675, 0.047883469611406326, -0.01927288994193077, -0.0034586109686642885, -0.04836583510041237, 0.017063288018107414, -0.017543518915772438, -0.01713004894554615, -0.011701969429850578, 0.017343463376164436, 0.014929921366274357, 0.029289092868566513, 0.03795889392495155, 0.03285186365246773, 0.0015943781472742558, -0.025583015754818916, 0.025694696232676506, -0.018532507121562958, -0.040890879929065704, -0.007120049092918634, 0.03511466830968857, 0.04784499853849411, -0.002397816861048341, 0.013718816451728344, 0.01557179819792509, -0.04183613881468773, -0.03699628636240959, 0.006151085719466209, -0.03310469165444374, 0.0023157387040555477, -0.0630195364356041, -0.034108277410268784, 0.03426097705960274, -0.04546590894460678, 0.043673187494277954, -0.024401452392339706, 0.036417290568351746, -0.00753733841702342, -0.044319991022348404, -0.03914908692240715, 0.03215470165014267, 0.021966995671391487, 0.03826097026467323, -0.0293030496686697, 0.004915910307317972, -0.02773803472518921, 0.04802514985203743, -0.06203749403357506, -0.026168756186962128, 0.02826514095067978, 0.012369324453175068, -0.03403070196509361, -0.05757657065987587, -0.00477567920461297, -0.004780764225870371, -0.03203364089131355, 0.03495071828365326, 0.030390189960598946, -0.04862646758556366, -0.02411099523305893, -0.016917677596211433, 0.018113216385245323, 0.07155082374811172, -0.02081545628607273, -0.007406577933579683, 0.023236684501171112, 0.004060849547386169, 0.02540583722293377, -0.012439380399882793, 0.002781582297757268, -0.03391360864043236, 0.01543507631868124, 0.008759219199419022, -0.02050497941672802, 0.020580768585205078, 0.005836048163473606, -0.031135229393839836, 0.024494986981153488, 0.013911276124417782, 0.008587079122662544, -0.020130963996052742, 0.024957900866866112, -0.013183074072003365, 0.01583937741816044, -0.03410792723298073, 0.011447916738688946, -0.013069228269159794, -0.01152417715638876, 0.03038596734404564, 0.02385241538286209, -0.006540825590491295, 0.02158261276781559, 0.048030152916908264, -0.019120218232274055, 0.005951307713985443, 0.022135106846690178, -0.05640214681625366, 0.043651092797517776, 0.024250896647572517, 0.02705945074558258, 0.022839581593871117, 0.04545297101140022, -0.026220574975013733, -0.012699684128165245, -0.03469952940940857, -0.0029307662043720484, 0.03343607112765312, 0.014445352368056774, 0.006937545258551836, 0.03246451914310455, -0.008034424856305122, 0.009352902881801128, -0.01881367713212967, 0.009671524167060852, -0.03626051917672157, -0.02110711671411991, 0.026639262214303017, -0.056014370173215866, 0.003893776098266244, 0.03222639113664627, 0.03481527790427208, -0.01694021373987198, 0.053347084671258926, -0.020129987969994545, 0.04541419446468353, 0.04100744426250458, -0.02614603191614151, -0.06247567757964134, 0.06707896292209625, -0.03731174394488335, 0.00041626239544712007, -0.0119595592841506, -0.028013506904244423, 0.061897870153188705, 0.005899482406675816, 0.002857270883396268, -0.05373523756861687, -0.03140582889318466, -0.026208220049738884, 0.001455301302485168, -0.011690271086990833, -0.024838322773575783, 0.009563643485307693, -0.009791601449251175, 0.06259192526340485, -0.024977080523967743, 0.016697753220796585, -0.002410703571513295, -0.07766111940145493, 0.0174248069524765, -0.01663358323276043, -0.03648419305682182, 0.009546625427901745, 0.0003041462041437626, -0.03268101066350937, 0.004901246167719364, -0.019663754850625992, -0.003582721808925271, -0.005112891085445881, 0.03738321736454964, 0.007427312899380922, 0.043562907725572586, -0.012099619023501873, -0.0157262422144413, -0.023236921057105064, -0.007167089264839888, 0.16022439301013947, 0.03209991380572319, 0.025119176134467125, -0.025551240891218185, 0.054100796580314636, -0.06109863147139549, 0.025344118475914, 0.03513219207525253, -0.03961151838302612, -0.005722865462303162, -0.008091962896287441, 0.018326524645090103, 0.06278108805418015, 0.028526943176984787, -0.028277425095438957, 0.07016471028327942, -0.002333743730559945, -0.04163380339741707, 0.009570220485329628, -0.0033186934888362885, -0.026837294921278954, -0.016381163150072098, -0.0216467697173357, -0.03895021602511406, 0.02371622994542122, -0.007379170041531324, -0.03336334601044655, -0.038229890167713165, -0.023356085643172264, 0.03098582662642002, -0.028517860919237137, -0.011788101866841316, 0.01649480313062668, 0.023850515484809875, -0.013908437453210354, -0.054379284381866455, 0.03027382493019104, -0.019056236371397972, -0.013024143874645233, 0.03095303289592266, 0.03308293968439102, 0.01632400043308735, -0.013905763626098633, 0.05663059651851654, -0.030355684459209442, -0.009446303360164165, -0.013257180340588093, 0.019496837630867958, -0.010912456549704075, 0.019039690494537354, -0.026885977014899254, -0.00913345068693161, -0.0001118865839089267, -0.022803621366620064, -0.0006312245386652648, 0.025443032383918762, 0.03802219033241272, -0.027521831914782524, -0.04160905256867409, -0.025285156443715096, -0.01821977272629738, -0.02175871469080448, 0.03803115338087082, 0.07289330661296844, -0.03874225914478302, -0.05379445478320122, -0.024379244074225426, 0.028495576232671738, 0.0014173475792631507, -0.0059667471796274185, -0.049565814435482025, 0.0045820060186088085, -0.007976767607033253, 0.018307654187083244, -0.012703290209174156, -0.010716700926423073, 0.0179726704955101, -0.03496644273400307, -0.012890221551060677, -0.007673040498048067, -0.06587588787078857, 0.03208227828145027, -0.010731492191553116, 0.023584850132465363, -0.008706667460501194, -0.013590930961072445, 0.020541643723845482, 0.005441785790026188, -0.03612079843878746, 0.030845124274492264, -0.024119045585393906, 0.028743695467710495, -0.0029773276764899492, -0.024642473086714745, 0.002621933352202177, -0.03738688677549362, -0.006793577689677477, -0.005164437461644411, -0.012521781027317047, 0.025820091366767883, 0.023473123088479042, 0.027142725884914398, -0.02442539483308792, 0.03814145550131798, 0.029810437932610512, 0.0170856062322855, 0.02280149608850479, -0.058909423649311066, 0.005187337286770344, 0.019629891961812973, 0.015208219178020954, -0.06032659113407135, -0.042097195982933044, -0.06261246651411057, -0.022478504106402397, -0.02388881891965866, -0.02323903515934944, -0.03060169890522957, 0.003771859919652343, -0.027918243780732155, -0.010827071033418179, -0.01714266650378704, -0.02663378417491913, -0.03284492343664169, -0.045292649418115616, -0.017920132726430893, -0.028069356456398964, -0.0033315028995275497, 0.001604902558028698, 0.016646159812808037, 0.014051924459636211, 0.025226498022675514, -0.016476845368742943, -0.017232438549399376, -0.01227643247693777, 0.012112833559513092, 0.01494502555578947, 0.041302070021629333, -0.0411628857254982, 0.00749652786180377, 0.013702643103897572, -0.039132196456193924, -0.03703145682811737, 0.0467701330780983, -0.011919357813894749, 0.01055710855871439, -0.020427295938134193, 0.019364574924111366, -0.011909247376024723, 0.03924957290291786, -0.012307637371122837, 0.0033031506463885307, 0.0049064792692661285, 0.019671792164444923, 0.009515509009361267, 0.009369098581373692, -0.03300550952553749, 0.011622383259236813, -0.047059960663318634, 0.0317201092839241, 0.02416410855948925, 0.0010008681565523148, 0.035112980753183365, 0.019533079117536545, -0.02713584154844284, 0.023006197065114975, 0.004881530534476042, -0.0018198626348748803, 0.06019602343440056, 0.04558664560317993, -0.046944137662649155, 0.031105658039450645, -0.008867762982845306, 0.017152095213532448, -0.06688234955072403, -0.0018521414604038, -0.004892445169389248, 0.03385671228170395, 0.0038348762318491936, -0.057141851633787155, -0.0010614919010549784, 0.009685970842838287, -0.08421312272548676, 0.033586107194423676, -0.025095049291849136, -0.027256572619080544, -0.04896252229809761, -0.023528294637799263, -0.026253717020154, 0.007210674695670605, 0.02663061022758484, -0.005726365838199854, -0.005617428105324507, -0.003630595048889518, 0.022950569167733192, -0.008820989169180393, -0.018002048134803772, 0.014347917400300503, -0.011966200545430183, -0.04776099696755409, 0.012250657193362713, -0.014615269377827644, -0.018832121044397354, 0.02258400060236454, -0.024152912199497223, 0.04133588448166847, 0.04629405960440636, 0.028926225379109383, -0.018120774999260902, 0.04581563547253609, 0.060417432337999344, -0.006058530882000923, -0.030361726880073547, -0.014999334700405598, -0.013605010695755482, 0.024063950404524803, -0.045398589223623276, 0.029413890093564987, 0.05517658591270447, 0.004969924222677946, -0.035518039017915726, 0.004904879257082939, -0.008605382405221462, -0.04023543372750282, 0.04347677156329155, 0.017833173274993896, 0.004350497853010893, 0.01227178517729044, 0.03355153277516365, -0.029878269881010056, -0.000843184650875628, 0.007113403175026178, -0.000948599015828222, 0.0015542622422799468, 0.03428255766630173, -0.02518063224852085, -0.010473339818418026, -0.05685720965266228, 0.02243685908615589, 0.02303202450275421, -0.023175600916147232, 0.010119765996932983, -0.02748742699623108, 0.017516493797302246, 0.00030791369499638677, -0.014998349361121655, -0.056171827018260956, 0.07184138149023056, -0.014058127999305725, 0.008426500484347343, 0.024190567433834076, 0.03029354102909565, 0.0316166914999485, -0.047143906354904175, 0.08548397570848465, 0.00863247737288475, 0.02008599229156971, -0.030717758461833, -0.008801269344985485, 0.028618594631552696, -0.01669468730688095, 0.06290452182292938, 0.012190778739750385, 0.02150057628750801, -0.015842732042074203, 0.04963495954871178, -0.035945676267147064, -0.016488738358020782, 0.01017077174037695, -0.008751059882342815, -0.016408760100603104, -0.02130422182381153, -0.01172229927033186, -0.014107637107372284, -0.016525499522686005, 0.009393672458827496, 0.0043108235113322735, 0.024198617786169052, -0.018979886546730995, -0.0009062341996468604, 0.05068528279662132, 0.007201768457889557, -0.04086460918188095, 0.026158662512898445, -0.020764460787177086, -0.009774277918040752, -0.0018078432185575366, -0.045059651136398315, -0.07109956443309784, 0.010321468114852905, -0.05117212235927582, -0.004498124588280916, -0.01760246977210045, 0.0027876091189682484, 0.012501376681029797, -0.0383017361164093, 0.01296413503587246, -0.010908271186053753, -0.01560420636087656, -0.007784391287714243, 0.007433067075908184, 0.01774311065673828, 0.06659252196550369, 0.01565161719918251, 0.02658422850072384, 0.011382725089788437, -0.015210702084004879, -0.023508435115218163, 0.028622876852750778, 0.02546396665275097, 0.04021192714571953, -0.03744226321578026, 0.014837411232292652, 0.0037249778397381306, 0.03977801278233528, 0.020154036581516266, 0.025862718001008034, -0.02001090720295906, 0.02239987440407276, 0.03851226344704628, -0.01668958179652691, 0.04921089857816696, 0.0022747255861759186, -0.008364323526620865, 0.07673701643943787, 0.008854364976286888, -0.016680264845490456, -0.02894696220755577, -0.04835880547761917, -0.015722235664725304, -0.02314443700015545, 0.006669964641332626, 0.03741322085261345, -0.0041795773431658745, 0.0061782533302903175, -0.017211008816957474, 0.022218257188796997, 0.047102827578783035, 0.00782628171145916, 0.02386379800736904, -0.03869227319955826, -0.008272388949990273, -0.008148936554789543, 0.0007900845375843346, -0.018912315368652344, 0.0021022693254053593, 0.039276424795389175, 0.016897642984986305, 0.027789894491434097, 0.01651640050113201, -0.02860516496002674, -0.015419193543493748, 0.04122016578912735, -0.03218935430049896, -0.052521947771310806, -0.038743846118450165, 0.0005817246856167912, 0.013544067740440369, -0.06236419081687927 ]
<p>I am trying to use a function from the <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/forecast/index.html" rel="nofollow">forecast</a> package, <code>seasonaldummy()</code>, which requires a time series object as input, but I have an <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/xts/index.html" rel="nofollow">xts</a> object, call it <code>x</code>. So first, is it correct that <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/xts/index.html" rel="nofollow">xts</a> objects can not be directly passed to functions that require a <code>ts</code> object?</p> <p>I then tried to coerce it to a <code>ts</code> object. I tried this by <code>as.ts(x)</code>. The function still produces an error.</p> <p>I looked at the <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/xts/index.html" rel="nofollow">xts</a> vignette, and in particular the <code>reclass</code> function, but all I could understand from that was how to coerce non xts objects to xts. It appears I have to do the opposite, and that <code>as.ts(x)</code> does not work.</p> <p>I have put a MWE below, where the last two lines generate an error.</p> <pre><code>&gt; a = rnorm(20) &gt; dt = seq(as.POSIXct("2010-03-24"),by="days",len=20) &gt; library(xts) &gt; a = xts(a,dt) &gt; library(forecast) &gt; seasonaldummy(a) Error in seasonaldummy(a) : Not a time series &gt; seasonaldummy(as.ts(a)) Error in seasonaldummy(as.ts(a)) : subscript out of bounds </code></pre>
74,260
[ -0.001067065168172121, -0.002838178537786007, 0.004872704390436411, -0.008067482151091099, -0.021903224289417267, 0.008132182992994785, -0.04123760387301445, -0.022504327818751335, 0.026075685396790504, 0.001234260038472712, 0.055969297885894775, 0.07405046373605728, 0.04358565807342529, 0.04524241015315056, 0.030844302847981453, 0.004109727218747139, -0.02153787389397621, 0.0034827792551368475, 0.006945223547518253, 0.008651605807244778, 0.00896220188587904, 0.0008893301710486412, -0.029267000034451485, 0.022436827421188354, 0.03988705947995186, -0.001544095342978835, -0.028425293043255806, 0.0210430771112442, 0.015435741282999516, 0.03419969603419304, -0.057329729199409485, -0.024022303521633148, 0.0008259455789811909, 0.0074991947039961815, 0.0055074142292141914, 0.02853494882583618, -0.006943626329302788, -0.001899115857668221, 0.0014704624190926552, 0.0070945401675999165, 0.011832320131361485, 0.007330023217946291, 0.0036874874494969845, 0.046558257192373276, 0.017756016924977303, 0.040289200842380524, 0.012030700221657753, 0.05891388654708862, 0.06076252833008766, 0.0034857250284403563, 0.05292791128158569, -0.027612052857875824, -0.00313419196754694, 0.04253925755620003, -0.027272136881947517, 0.0031613660976290703, 0.059419430792331696, 0.01893899403512478, -0.007806491106748581, -0.025897203013300896, -0.017548440024256706, -0.04344934970140457, -0.029767276719212532, -0.059764161705970764, -0.03028104081749916, -0.013682223856449127, 0.02027640864253044, -0.01635907217860222, 0.02773938700556755, -0.05648108944296837, 0.015616965480148792, -0.01405844371765852, -0.04073568060994148, 0.006916567217558622, 0.0007484456873498857, -0.019488302990794182, 0.030225122347474098, -0.012149007990956306, 0.03733176365494728, 0.022395040839910507, -0.0051689245738089085, 0.02819046750664711, 0.0008948106551542878, 0.0014084457652643323, 0.050555117428302765, 0.038497235625982285, 0.025348637253046036, -0.034533679485321045, 0.0011887867003679276, 0.06849708408117294, 0.006321515887975693, -0.019300585612654686, 0.07537411898374557, 0.049519676715135574, 0.021281760185956955, 0.08543132245540619, 0.01980394497513771, 0.013421516865491867, -0.006303354166448116, -0.017026517540216446, -0.029156628996133804, -0.027936143800616264, 0.03229810670018196, 0.03997110202908516, -0.04521958529949188, -0.020575392991304398, 0.0023097700905054808, -0.028422297909855843, -0.04778209701180458, -0.06113583222031593, -0.026515260338783264, 0.012286223471164703, -0.05586729198694229, 0.0013668379979208112, -0.004645081236958504, -0.03542633354663849, 0.0034419302828609943, 0.04250124841928482, 0.0358320027589798, 0.04523157328367233, 0.07381542026996613, 0.008926638402044773, 0.03818223997950554, -0.036583248525857925, -0.03549646586179733, 0.01167000737041235, -0.011731323786079884, 0.008888468146324158, 0.00833849236369133, 0.011562647297978401, -0.003923017997294664, -0.05986500903964043, 0.02996928058564663, 0.03235272690653801, 0.04197562113404274, -0.029448825865983963, -0.05847699195146561, -0.05110893398523331, 0.02015005052089691, 0.006998209748417139, 0.020580140873789787, -0.07649222016334534, 0.028408702462911606, -0.026319066062569618, 0.03625643253326416, 0.007234770804643631, 0.028056683018803596, 0.04787842556834221, 0.015156648121774197, -0.01634935662150383, -0.033813074231147766, -0.006869965232908726, -0.004758130759000778, -0.046645890921354294, -0.023442741483449936, -0.03530317544937134, 0.01907103881239891, 0.04025041311979294, 0.009470473974943161, 0.013411346822977066, 0.019430769607424736, -0.01990893855690956, -0.02447865717113018, -0.02752908132970333, 0.004514812491834164, -0.08088184148073196, 0.07545578479766846, 0.007780040148645639, 0.022623956203460693, 0.0406450517475605, -0.053092386573553085, 0.018664922565221786, -0.0021002194844186306, 0.020365925505757332, 0.022788619622588158, 0.0036022698041051626, -0.007866639643907547, -0.02781142294406891, -0.004012549761682749, -0.011737309396266937, -0.018659941852092743, -0.006666000932455063, -0.006269629113376141, -0.02417605184018612, 0.029991531744599342, 0.03140053153038025, -0.017448535189032555, -0.02239135280251503, 0.0390922985970974, -0.09410222619771957, -0.03166178613901138, -0.012290243990719318, -0.035326939076185226, -0.05307533219456673, -0.01060881931334734, -0.004921994172036648, -0.03590025380253792, 0.011411504819989204, 0.02005220204591751, -0.006436485331505537, -0.04252037778496742, 0.027258247137069702, 0.0400097593665123, -0.016760850325226784, -0.027787722647190094, 0.010734431445598602, 0.06447812169790268, 0.012610552832484245, 0.039642397314310074, -0.03583558648824692, -0.019504711031913757, 0.036717575043439865, -0.02621609717607498, 0.01034404244273901, -0.01822277158498764, -0.015019528567790985, 0.04324665293097496, 0.009701555594801903, -0.049588825553655624, 0.07656706869602203, -0.05506063625216484, 0.013435821048915386, 0.0691857635974884, 0.04276499152183533, 0.00834711641073227, -0.004414177034050226, 0.026181327179074287, 0.07130270451307297, -0.01866171695291996, 0.031099705025553703, -0.042843833565711975, -0.022365931421518326, 0.05696049705147743, 0.01790212094783783, -0.018509075045585632, -0.015557949431240559, 0.05885833501815796, -0.019923102110624313, -0.007836147211492062, 0.07601835578680038, -0.012230752035975456, 0.010234870947897434, 0.01670125499367714, -0.05166975408792496, 0.03864870220422745, 0.026809679344296455, 0.0312671922147274, -0.03590354695916176, 0.027516432106494904, 0.035509075969457626, 0.001220249105244875, 0.06423599272966385, 0.002299811225384474, -0.01373201422393322, -0.007466585375368595, -0.007127663120627403, 0.058056335896253586, -0.007089712657034397, -0.023924563080072403, 0.038828421384096146, 0.02289707213640213, -0.004411083180457354, 0.014769455417990685, -0.006308124400675297, 0.017332326620817184, 0.04742203280329704, -0.05522933974862099, -0.01320276316255331, 0.01083320751786232, -0.0070482101291418076, -0.015208277851343155, -0.03499980643391609, -0.0223985742777586, -0.05259513109922409, 0.04606904834508896, 0.011972811073064804, 0.018057290464639664, 0.04423044994473457, -0.01861155964434147, -0.008007205091416836, 0.025327302515506744, -0.0241282619535923, -0.024186313152313232, 0.007346672005951405, -0.005403170362114906, 0.03168275207281113, -0.008842386305332184, -0.02705996297299862, 0.043425071984529495, 0.0071693304926157, -0.04915492609143257, 0.005981679540127516, -0.016341833397746086, -0.028165524825453758, 0.00446503097191453, -0.019891679286956787, -0.007791013456881046, -0.013122751377522945, 0.019877761602401733, 0.052824247628450394, 0.0024210461415350437, -0.05163042992353439, -0.0010001882910728455, -0.048016950488090515, -0.011832289397716522, -0.01291927695274353, -0.03293154388666153, -0.03202207013964653, -0.004765769001096487, 0.015234421007335186, -0.0026952314656227827, 0.0054507069289684296, 0.04169707000255585, -0.050113894045352936, -0.04184981435537338, -0.013427951373159885, 0.03573320806026459, 0.006868441589176655, 0.010907781310379505, 0.00860623363405466, 0.05529216304421425, 0.03188689053058624, -0.059230610728263855, -0.03827809914946556, -0.0004527885466814041, -0.010127569548785686, -0.04197349026799202, 0.026868151500821114, 0.022882387042045593, 0.01278309803456068, -0.027014805004000664, 0.02614736557006836, 0.029168758541345596, 0.05425509065389633, -0.034314099699258804, 0.006747577339410782, -0.02581086941063404, 0.014372073113918304, 0.016111526638269424, 0.026390807703137398, 0.021207420155405998, -0.004966091830283403, 0.0021601023618131876, -0.04752001538872719, 0.00892644189298153, 0.006289125885814428, -0.019865792244672775, -0.02414972335100174, 0.0007319635478779674, 0.04676352068781853, -0.018546830862760544, 0.029303235933184624, -0.002161977346986532, -0.027825789526104927, -0.03447350859642029, 0.03054584376513958, 0.05439481511712074, -0.04910774901509285, -0.04792097583413124, 0.06446181982755661, 0.06989382207393646, -0.031497128307819366, 0.011878792196512222, -0.007113094907253981, 0.01982332393527031, -0.007033766712993383, 0.00954777654260397, 0.0010148705914616585, 0.07350596785545349, 0.025454333052039146, 0.005193255376070738, 0.031631603837013245, -0.021122422069311142, 0.031484536826610565, -0.052198633551597595, -0.012770229950547218, -0.027540525421500206, 0.05067740008234978, 0.01682138815522194, 0.023566659539937973, 0.004152728710323572, 0.0004932867595925927, -0.007672241888940334, -0.005962257273495197, -0.06867538392543793, 0.011317652650177479, -0.001725031528621912, -0.016602082177996635, -0.009171738289296627, -0.0333661250770092, 0.0217521283775568, -0.007349976804107428, 0.010858114808797836, -0.016027254983782768, -0.0005881110555492342, -0.020235978066921234, 0.017321033403277397, 0.007552795577794313, -0.004343627952039242, -0.03487301245331764, 0.022798581048846245, 0.06538768112659454, -0.007141022942960262, 0.033077336847782135, 0.011120910756289959, 0.006709286477416754, 0.004713338799774647, -0.018994837999343872, -0.0007797021535225213, 0.010325578972697258, 0.0027368415612727404, 0.004230421967804432, 0.024833878502249718, -0.05498811975121498, -0.01676417887210846, -0.010140271857380867, 0.020550144836306572, 0.0135431457310915, -0.021328898146748543, -0.04612768813967705, -0.01143676321953535, -0.010606078431010246, 0.03435869142413139, 0.022702708840370178, 0.0012547620572149754, 0.0036531726364046335, 0.050459735095500946, 0.008091026917099953, 0.011024567298591137, 0.019967583939433098, 0.04832873120903969, -0.011567524634301662, -0.004188204184174538, -0.0016832115361467004, -0.009324545972049236, -0.017231881618499756, 0.017673132941126823, 0.03369349613785744, 0.027791110798716545, 0.010990750975906849, 0.029229391366243362, -0.006242267321795225, -0.004345979541540146, -0.02857358008623123, 0.012673424556851387, -0.005272023379802704, 0.049349937587976456, -0.030664818361401558, -0.04083263501524925, 0.012310400605201721, 0.052468668669462204, 0.01524192001670599, -0.013890879228711128, -0.005021283403038979, -0.10075072199106216, -0.04155384749174118, 0.027711456641554832, 0.04157451540231705, -0.05396992713212967, -0.062032945454120636, -0.05221123248338699, 0.0027737964410334826, 0.03255748376250267, -0.03662903979420662, 0.02439716085791588, -0.019062746316194534, 0.04141661897301674, -0.030082227662205696, -0.04709462448954582, -0.02086242474615574, -0.020112399011850357, -0.044000428169965744, 0.020649230107665062, 0.00684446981176734, -0.0499456450343132, -0.03869206830859184, 0.03902120143175125, -0.001965041970834136, -0.0038438155315816402, -0.0610697865486145, -0.031458426266908646, 0.04387500509619713, 0.021230194717645645, -0.004506274592131376, -0.03420334681868553, 0.0052569094114005566, 0.012386643327772617, 0.010546622797846794, 0.013061103411018848, -0.005320386495441198, -0.000149388681165874, 0.01328268088400364, 0.0035396087914705276, -0.023560596629977226, 0.018700486049056053, -0.05108488351106644, 0.02326526679098606, 0.017452701926231384, -0.02799561619758606, 0.032624751329422, 0.04230736196041107, -0.0002902912092395127, 0.01328386552631855, -0.0683884248137474, -0.005970487371087074, -0.03443384915590286, -0.0015530727105215192, -0.06270740181207657, -0.02915569767355919, -0.027648035436868668, 0.032172538340091705, 0.019748594611883163, -0.013532334007322788, -0.03854501619935036, 0.0042844172567129135, 0.010537524707615376, 0.026507869362831116, -0.03168472275137901, 0.011014618910849094, 0.02601335011422634, 0.018351126462221146, -0.07362600415945053, -0.013982925564050674, 0.033668287098407745, -0.03672638535499573, -0.0150040527805686, 0.026128903031349182, -0.04005656763911247, 0.0136691490188241, 0.008249553851783276, -0.029486505314707756, -0.009495100006461143, -0.026873985305428505, 0.013057704083621502, -0.023448385298252106, 0.024507425725460052, -0.016887634992599487, -0.019382277503609657, -0.0029761327896267176, 0.009339513257145882, -0.0005039418465457857, -0.02485417202115059, -0.04038101062178612, 0.019410913810133934, 0.024226270616054535, -0.016184663400053978, -0.042015619575977325, -0.02905138023197651, -0.014686236158013344, -0.018036682158708572, -0.03141381964087486, -0.027197398245334625, -0.031313683837652206, -0.010262364521622658, -0.0065038325265049934, -0.030744539573788643, 0.011061698198318481, -0.06498350948095322, 0.010171286761760712, -0.019784821197390556, -0.0010472049470990896, 0.04601399600505829, 0.035023774951696396, 0.004679771140217781, 0.043027304112911224, 0.003427752759307623, 0.005704631097614765, -0.012617445550858974, -0.010219961404800415, -0.026393728330731392, 0.0025239211972802877, 0.011712153442203999, -0.026556694880127907, 0.03130397945642471, 0.010023240931332111, -0.012903109192848206, 0.04018648713827133, -0.0009730192250572145, 0.024396352469921112, -0.10625573247671127, 0.04555397853255272, -0.01380809023976326, 0.005180543288588524, -0.06717607378959656, 0.017147375270724297, -0.00899067148566246, -0.0041227685287594795, -0.0068083531223237514, -0.03093351237475872, 0.010375624522566795, 0.0440114326775074, 0.07516741007566452, -0.0240912064909935, 0.030712947249412537, -0.006760840769857168, 0.017240295186638832, -0.0031512160785496235, 0.03523726016283035, 0.026094060391187668, -0.029742436483502388, -0.007301152218133211, 0.009976598434150219, -0.045834481716156006, -0.01363594364374876, 0.006089460104703903, 0.05968252196907997, -0.022750794887542725, 0.0271777231246233, 0.039112918078899384, -0.018763907253742218, 0.00898989662528038, -0.03912615031003952, -0.012286467477679253, -0.017833208665251732, 0.04445065185427666, 0.05590202659368515, -0.02199542708694935, 0.002496557543054223, 0.02615286037325859, 0.00354505842551589, 0.031090393662452698, 0.012015276588499546, 0.002556235995143652, 0.005349933169782162, -0.04171087592840195, -0.011209913529455662, -0.03555288910865784, -0.01897399313747883, 0.023004477843642235, 0.01235821470618248, -0.008450082503259182, 0.01745479553937912, -0.0351274311542511, 0.021215390413999557, -0.01338379830121994, -0.016982467845082283, -0.04523325338959694, -0.04014638438820839, -0.00008416845957981423, 0.03653598949313164, -0.009793916717171669, 0.017869731411337852, 0.0011239597806707025, 0.05114004760980606, 0.008812055923044682, 0.02200782671570778, -0.05610112100839615, -0.03528721630573273, 0.02272775210440159, -0.052241794764995575, -0.018109513446688652, 0.07829950749874115, 0.027807801961898804, -0.019136972725391388, -0.02560521848499775, -0.04349448159337044, 0.05215766280889511, 0.016657955944538116, 0.03444286063313484, 0.056548990309238434, 0.05405572056770325, -0.0011506882729008794, 0.01806706376373768, -0.05354706943035126, -0.019755525514483452, 0.13946452736854553, 0.036293212324380875, 0.07458168268203735, -0.048836883157491684, -0.0006644976092502475, 0.010237469337880611, 0.028925597667694092, -0.0023499405942857265, -0.006098857149481773, 0.017173657193779945, -0.00028978672344237566, 0.03968583047389984, 0.04938582703471184, 0.010637642815709114, -0.021831901744008064, 0.030384263023734093, -0.056110285222530365, 0.006181742064654827, -0.006165869068354368, 0.0016930371057242155, 0.023270918056368828, -0.013192526064813137, -0.07290659844875336, 0.0008381964289583266, 0.006048443727195263, 0.0014522201381623745, -0.0528637059032917, 0.0019842623732984066, -0.03633558377623558, -0.012307248078286648, -0.030198346823453903, 0.015096950344741344, 0.019329654052853584, 0.014005087316036224, 0.03997744619846344, 0.0025375287514179945, 0.018118245527148247, -0.03374939039349556, 0.044119883328676224, 0.06621497124433517, 0.0460357703268528, 0.001175765646621585, 0.012056498788297176, 0.000506565673276782, -0.042519714683294296, -0.015888098627328873, -0.011763852089643478, -0.009892544709146023, -0.02639525942504406, 0.01764388009905815, -0.0030943620949983597, 0.02697896957397461, -0.009915517643094063, -0.04182930663228035, 0.006363215856254101, -0.0017716048751026392, 0.048634834587574005, 0.02149066887795925, -0.01643098145723343, -0.005893621128052473, 0.05620696768164635, 0.0011011738097295165, 0.04281856492161751, 0.03760639950633049, -0.032840222120285034, 0.012204403057694435, -0.007835336960852146, 0.03770612180233002, -0.017024707049131393, 0.0035648357588797808, 0.006582972593605518, 0.014451407827436924, -0.01525470893830061, -0.041850969195365906, -0.013887298293411732, -0.01649581454694271, -0.0010916624451056123, -0.015028427354991436, 0.01604560576379299, -0.016124539077281952, -0.019489577040076256, -0.005633943248540163, -0.008806400932371616, -0.047287844121456146, 0.018812214955687523, 0.010634692385792732, 0.024552401155233383, 0.02207440882921219, 0.020438561215996742, 0.03216021507978439, 0.006609564181417227, 0.04694453254342079, -0.004320218227803707, -0.0222623310983181, -0.04629671946167946, 0.05088753625750542, -0.018272917717695236, -0.026074418798089027, 0.003746866015717387, 0.034704502671957016, 0.0747232437133789, 0.018339728936553, -0.042308785021305084, -0.004324927926063538, 0.0037672845646739006, -0.004382167011499405, 0.0568549782037735, -0.03670283779501915, 0.020796654745936394, 0.00344124436378479, 0.004118305630981922, -0.05671600624918938, -0.027257105335593224, -0.021362612023949623, -0.04191884770989418, 0.027109283953905106, -0.011924403719604015, -0.04586494714021683, 0.020748354494571686, 0.009491383098065853, -0.0007717498228885233, -0.03139154240489006, -0.014276738278567791, -0.03762126713991165, -0.034598756581544876, 0.006966013461351395, -0.050410233438014984, -0.022265013307332993, 0.01844264566898346, -0.04930182546377182, -0.030255883932113647, 0.038285642862319946, 0.010257117450237274, -0.004103040788322687, -0.03420181944966316, -0.013032501563429832, -0.010312172584235668, 0.05808218941092491, 0.006843446753919125, -0.011562618426978588, 0.01908697560429573, -0.026341978460550308, -0.016274308785796165, 0.014100128784775734, -0.0046483054757118225, 0.011616550385951996, -0.01374383457005024, -0.013662269338965416, -0.03802359849214554, 0.06436226516962051, -0.026517653837800026, 0.01809474267065525, 0.009023020043969154, -0.03304983302950859, 0.04714430868625641, -0.007139897905290127, -0.020699428394436836, 0.015345328487455845, 0.008228026330471039, 0.03022056072950363, 0.06827639788389206, 0.02374049462378025, -0.04930802434682846, -0.0020487240981310606, -0.010152218863368034, -0.016780780628323555, -0.017408067360520363, 0.010219399817287922, 0.021910125389695168, 0.023884784430265427, -0.043642282485961914, 0.03794869780540466, -0.0135186230763793, 0.02732621505856514, -0.09809819608926773, 0.025272542610764503, 0.0035996458027511835, 0.039371851831674576, 0.02787337824702263, -0.048795003443956375, 0.00019957884796895087, -0.015865672379732132, -0.011857913807034492, -0.005803850479424, 0.017958175390958786, -0.011703627184033394, -0.021612007170915604, -0.00006121370097389445, -0.051603224128484726, -0.012362029403448105, 0.04957753047347069, 0.02371302992105484, 0.009415268898010254, -0.01418573409318924, 0.016466772183775902, -0.049429260194301605, -0.06815998256206512, 0.018008029088377953, 0.029358884319663048, -0.03765242546796799, 0.0592513345181942, -0.027728719636797905, 0.029390720650553703, 0.03828202933073044, -0.022128574550151825, 0.00949994195252657, 0.000860718369949609, -0.0056920829229056835, 0.014176631346344948, 0.015423381701111794, 0.023404637351632118, 0.021346839144825935, -0.0075112939812242985, 0.04418615624308586, 0.016343284398317337, 0.04930708929896355, -0.023415476083755493, -0.0443953275680542, -0.01915678195655346, -0.0305296890437603, -0.026905778795480728, 0.024786239489912987, -0.024212650954723358, -0.0005154100945219398, -0.04525745287537575, -0.0200460534542799, 0.028768125921487808, -0.003349204547703266, 0.00005859993689227849, -0.012288397178053856, 0.028304124251008034, 0.08093639463186264, 0.008762800134718418, -0.002880619838833809, -0.009172660298645496, -0.007223234977573156, -0.07540272176265717, 0.01274705771356821, -0.014569949358701706, -0.023694925010204315, -0.02114851586520672, 0.0013228894677013159, 0.03319636359810829, -0.0065855844877660275, 0.004901395179331303, 0.06801611930131912, -0.0038603274151682854, 0.07893705368041992, 0.031321894377470016, 0.03599199652671814, -0.015138152986764908, 0.006529868580400944, 0.0409897156059742, -0.0629216805100441, 0.03899295628070831, -0.007237133104354143, -0.009208416566252708, -0.02375991828739643, -0.015027176588773727, -0.04828323423862457, 0.03185956925153732, 0.010985112749040127, -0.0002867110015358776, 0.0315694622695446, -0.019845742732286453, 0.047685083001852036, -0.026347171515226364, -0.05155037343502045, 0.07844841480255127, -0.0060218521393835545, 0.0071618459187448025, 0.02937503159046173, -0.021824004128575325, -0.005820075049996376, 0.04254492372274399, 0.0070411888882517815, 0.02128191664814949, 0.010140195488929749, 0.018259713426232338, -0.04468134790658951, -0.00033204216742888093, 0.011643053032457829, 0.021803729236125946, 0.003787752240896225, 0.03275199234485626, -0.010120254941284657, 0.042684879153966904, 0.008512039668858051, -0.011093657463788986, 0.03937040641903877, -0.07403619587421417, -0.012565981596708298, 0.03756512701511383, -0.05197921767830849, -0.008618840016424656, -0.04115314036607742, -0.018098529428243637, 0.03216905891895294, 0.03352019935846329, -0.003471100702881813, 0.017740748822689056, 0.004628919064998627, 0.025866543874144554, -0.01742715761065483, 0.009022921323776245, -0.005795694421976805, -0.027257481589913368, -0.022219201549887657, -0.023727599531412125, -0.0064760977402329445, -0.012263048440217972, -0.026381848379969597, 0.04498052969574928, -0.0014600043650716543, 0.0016774118412286043, 0.02016856148838997, 0.07770146429538727, -0.005379415582865477, -0.010955545119941235, 0.025743719190359116, -0.03181519731879234, -0.006766584236174822, 0.024044062942266464, -0.03201150521636009, 0.010649703443050385, -0.007130534388124943, 0.03935810923576355, -0.042118657380342484, -0.0068158917129039764, 0.013068290427327156, 0.026675008237361908, -0.02988302893936634, 0.01766894944012165, -0.03498522564768791, 0.029791811481118202, 0.04562756046652794, -0.03258558735251427, -0.020808793604373932, -0.005408569239079952, 0.0322626531124115, 0.001775003969669342, -0.0007379497401416302, -0.005340238101780415, 0.005144563037902117, 0.003640493843704462, -0.038145896047353745, 0.010190481320023537, 0.04808634892106056, -0.02951737307012081, -0.05233290418982506, 0.010152994655072689, -0.02122938446700573, 0.009560531005263329, -0.0518370158970356, -0.023502876982092857, -0.014390392228960991, 0.03975555673241615, 0.01360401976853609, -0.046090636402368546 ]
<p>I have several data sets of frequency values (See Fig. 1 for an example).</p> <p>I'm interested in those tighter clusters (marked by green rectangles) and am using hierarchical clustering in MATLAB (with unweighted average distance method) to separate them. (*)</p> <p>The spread of these clusters increases with frequency (the standard deviation is positively correlated with the frequency, while the coefficient of variation is not).</p> <p><strong>So here's my question</strong>: Is there a way for the clustering to factor in this relationship, so that the average distance a point has to have to the points of the nearest cluster to be included in that cluster is also dependent on - for example - the mean of that cluster?</p> <p>I'm thinking that the cutoff would have to be different for each point, but I don't think this is possible in this method. I would also be open to alternative clustering methods, but not k-means, because I don't want to specify the number of clusters in advance.</p> <p>Also, if you have suggestions on rephrasing my question so that it may be more useful to others I would be grateful.</p> <p>Thank you for your time!</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/FgARe.png" alt="Frequency cluster example"></p> <p>(*) I'm following this example for the clustering procedure: <a href="http://www.mathworks.de/de/help/stats/examples/cluster-analysis.html" rel="nofollow">http://www.mathworks.de/de/help/stats/examples/cluster-analysis.html</a></p>
37,040
[ -0.0681968703866005, -0.003749558934941888, 0.017124077305197716, -0.00695875845849514, 0.005007583182305098, 0.001970425946637988, 0.011002599261701107, -0.01882074400782585, 0.008195296861231327, -0.06784496456384659, 0.014958332292735577, 0.04501019045710564, 0.07428004592657089, 0.05793111398816109, 0.015889139845967293, -0.03089248575270176, -0.02175847999751568, -0.017752811312675476, -0.025623470544815063, -0.0025841807946562767, -0.009693457745015621, 0.01004836242645979, -0.0087329326197505, -0.02253119833767414, -0.025566400960087776, 0.026040270924568176, 0.002054730663076043, -0.015124772675335407, 0.03545352816581726, 0.051223378628492355, -0.024173174053430557, -0.049518853425979614, 0.0246132705360651, 0.023434512317180634, 0.0004296315892133862, -0.005485982168465853, -0.018139880150556564, 0.010121109895408154, -0.014257514849305153, 0.006624054629355669, -0.04183078557252884, -0.02778463251888752, -0.0221907626837492, 0.0408816821873188, -0.02022455260157585, 0.0021488505881279707, 0.027005404233932495, -0.03419739753007889, 0.05213088542222977, -0.009911945089697838, 0.09319660067558289, -0.004786085337400436, 0.013471310026943684, 0.016134263947606087, -0.05532658472657204, 0.005634554196149111, 0.037277817726135254, 0.051989175379276276, -0.0058464608155190945, -0.01699621044099331, 0.000778976536821574, -0.011461468413472176, -0.0005464998539537191, -0.025591937825083733, -0.030053526163101196, 0.04191547632217407, -0.036612268537282944, -0.032004546374082565, 0.05947170779109001, 0.016458112746477127, 0.007927191443741322, 0.01919766142964363, 0.052886124700307846, -0.03563988208770752, 0.02058856002986431, -0.04749885946512222, 0.013499990105628967, 0.00566045893356204, 0.026597075164318085, 0.03743087872862816, -0.0011318112956359982, 0.01326937135308981, 0.02154211886227131, 0.007428361568599939, 0.040012262761592865, -0.0031321453861892223, 0.04905446991324425, -0.03973572328686714, -0.008163686841726303, 0.044906701892614365, -0.024669192731380463, -0.018290473148226738, 0.04906567931175232, 0.03059948980808258, -0.040833376348018646, 0.04174158722162247, -0.007789059076458216, 0.020518289878964424, 0.024794941768050194, 0.025841454043984413, -0.003949352074414492, -0.04426294565200806, -0.0012764717685058713, 0.026890521869063377, -0.007977155037224293, -0.008160950616002083, -0.05166987329721451, -0.012688469141721725, -0.016411909833550453, 0.005794670432806015, 0.007694984320551157, 0.011832460761070251, 0.01693102903664112, -0.023702027276158333, 0.057350561022758484, -0.009974253363907337, -0.00887521356344223, -0.01594124548137188, 0.03684965893626213, 0.07586150616407394, 0.0317436084151268, -0.052947185933589935, 0.03657504543662071, -0.019279038533568382, -0.02054482325911522, 0.008535348810255527, 0.016503209248185158, -0.007013329770416021, -0.013083034195005894, 0.06619458645582199, 0.003967204596847296, 0.027307486161589622, 0.04228398576378822, -0.031033121049404144, 0.010361580178141594, -0.012840227223932743, -0.049068257212638855, -0.04338345304131508, 0.016519738361239433, -0.012576405890285969, 0.01881399005651474, -0.054536204785108566, 0.008806669153273106, 0.02600524015724659, 0.030832817777991295, 0.046319276094436646, 0.016343217343091965, -0.017877060920000076, 0.040806517004966736, 0.029855219647288322, -0.0044685304164886475, 0.0007949888822622597, -0.014316104352474213, -0.029661651700735092, -0.005954045336693525, -0.10353109985589981, 0.008199527859687805, 0.012838628143072128, -0.008458194322884083, 0.007885877974331379, 0.048878058791160583, 0.02009577676653862, 0.004512254614382982, -0.015784626826643944, 0.04367072507739067, 0.01533523853868246, 0.057283397763967514, -0.0040622008964419365, 0.0077497512102127075, 0.006273682229220867, -0.010668516159057617, 0.01692492514848709, 0.015239626169204712, 0.018049802631139755, 0.03798764571547508, 0.017998458817601204, -0.0148761086165905, 0.01513361744582653, 0.027296334505081177, 0.01585841178894043, -0.013319971971213818, -0.06416782736778259, -0.03837795928120613, -0.007098517846316099, 0.02454451471567154, 0.04692905396223068, -0.008671494200825691, -0.03568141907453537, 0.015568799339234829, -0.022775448858737946, -0.04261696711182594, -0.08361463993787766, 0.015123932622373104, -0.03183642402291298, -0.03629186376929283, 0.04163091629743576, -0.02165292575955391, 0.005079676862806082, 0.0034258642699569464, -0.026231655851006508, -0.04196907579898834, -0.05374569073319435, 0.010678298771381378, -0.06197480857372284, -0.017370115965604782, 0.03981592506170273, 0.04051654413342476, -0.0026096864603459835, 0.049141380935907364, -0.030930152162909508, -0.05222279205918312, 0.005506089422851801, -0.057282499969005585, -0.01101174857467413, -0.007147985510528088, -0.0006247286219149828, 0.02154100313782692, -0.01625565066933632, -0.02130286395549774, -0.0039679850451648235, -0.028820127248764038, 0.08780872821807861, 0.05855412036180496, -0.011987083591520786, 0.01734095811843872, 0.04526786133646965, 0.02011038549244404, 0.008956755511462688, -0.04657645896077156, -0.03782382979989052, -0.08154905587434769, 0.006996112409979105, 0.05301720276474953, 0.0008094263030216098, -0.05226501077413559, 0.0009238158818334341, 0.05428946390748024, 0.0229970570653677, 0.0006863034795969725, 0.04315554350614548, -0.0015309785958379507, -0.008741127327084541, 0.010728196240961552, 0.04583479091525078, -0.015769703313708305, -0.006971844006329775, 0.008859729394316673, 0.03991168364882469, 0.033708833158016205, -0.0009729480370879173, -0.002673363545909524, 0.02723083645105362, -0.025249281898140907, 0.024620365351438522, 0.0060651046223938465, 0.006371211260557175, 0.03445801883935928, -0.009566416963934898, -0.016109446063637733, 0.04933227226138115, 0.01191079244017601, -0.0010709118796512485, 0.018024208024144173, -0.050555940717458725, 0.024052228778600693, 0.02651168406009674, -0.04053322225809097, 0.03049132414162159, -0.009690348990261555, -0.005318664480000734, 0.00719204917550087, -0.005994069389998913, -0.03830503299832344, -0.010969148948788643, 0.009026135317981243, 0.05345938727259636, 0.006173160392791033, -0.004799854941666126, -0.009674444794654846, -0.013338535092771053, -0.022848770022392273, -0.01798727549612522, 0.003017738228663802, -0.01455386821180582, -0.027549415826797485, -0.009980146773159504, -0.00131299311760813, -0.02189253643155098, -0.00402683624997735, -0.0023565790615975857, -0.032826222479343414, 0.015037796460092068, 0.008014682680368423, -0.05853837728500366, 0.005484140478074551, -0.03372988477349281, 0.034714508801698685, -0.01743171364068985, 0.004152906127274036, 0.014309510588645935, 0.0026500846724957228, -0.03993077576160431, 0.044901732355356216, -0.01486027892678976, -0.03584921732544899, -0.03897363319993019, 0.014780502766370773, 0.02063075825572014, -0.005925388541072607, -0.008067276328802109, 0.038296524435281754, -0.03263600915670395, 0.013300319202244282, -0.03531870245933533, -0.07405935227870941, 0.023250456899404526, -0.0177114587277174, 0.04382183030247688, 0.007011729758232832, -0.010891595855355263, 0.06470244377851486, 0.04853455349802971, -0.029651174321770668, -0.05339087173342705, -0.011818474158644676, -0.0207884032279253, 0.013515372760593891, 0.025012778118252754, 0.02374817430973053, -0.006033448968082666, -0.0005215293494984508, 0.03348773345351219, 0.016744442284107208, 0.07210870832204819, -0.01659093052148819, -0.0013353864196687937, -0.007956557907164097, -0.0065259491093456745, -0.021147554740309715, 0.045183729380369186, 0.03436248376965523, -0.03576287254691124, 0.00535937212407589, 0.013504120521247387, 0.02125231735408306, -0.002593446522951126, -0.01960606500506401, -0.008061084896326065, -0.003754174802452326, -0.005462250672280788, -0.02856777235865593, 0.01544945128262043, 0.009630311280488968, -0.00923618208616972, 0.00851050578057766, 0.01574554294347763, 0.045488666743040085, -0.003277597250416875, -0.008440359495580196, 0.08531840145587921, 0.06725029647350311, -0.005112577695399523, -0.014658362604677677, 0.009261541068553925, 0.003411500481888652, 0.013926171697676182, -0.03576207160949707, -0.033604636788368225, 0.027825895696878433, 0.03252927213907242, 0.039405230432748795, 0.018633294850587845, -0.05639515817165375, 0.0603490024805069, -0.06496307998895645, -0.015390376560389996, -0.04171769320964813, 0.055332817137241364, 0.0025038986932486296, 0.01574169285595417, 0.028650691732764244, -0.006582348607480526, 0.022310873493552208, 0.020694736391305923, -0.06431242823600769, -0.003947681747376919, 0.00035743138869293034, -0.024247540161013603, -0.003947136458009481, -0.03164731711149216, 0.01841651275753975, 0.0025817016139626503, 0.029413094744086266, 0.012847937643527985, 0.035924408584833145, -0.04412272945046425, -0.019925817847251892, -0.008160093799233437, 0.013655990362167358, -0.030787261202931404, -0.014004793018102646, 0.01800142414867878, -0.009161981754004955, 0.0410880520939827, 0.017651323229074478, -0.008662744425237179, -0.003611599560827017, -0.037757035344839096, 0.004108375404030085, 0.012079043313860893, 0.027664760127663612, 0.018125997856259346, 0.03459028899669647, -0.02096446603536606, -0.013793257996439934, -0.02157457545399666, 0.04077482968568802, 0.051259756088256836, 0.0003141375782433897, 0.016554463654756546, -0.04227648302912712, -0.03212940692901611, 0.019080612808465958, 0.03217596560716629, -0.048696119338274, -0.005372298881411552, 0.041528813540935516, 0.0019026990048587322, -0.07764774560928345, 0.020459206774830818, 0.04474710300564766, 0.03221755847334862, 0.0031917751766741276, -0.06040211021900177, -0.0340622253715992, 0.020862970501184464, -0.016123099252581596, 0.03187824413180351, 0.02278962731361389, -0.006840236485004425, -0.0043489267118275166, 0.042175132781267166, 0.004545168485492468, -0.04282112047076225, 0.0016595413908362389, 0.020757056772708893, 0.06044306233525276, -0.01638651452958584, -0.04743938893079758, -0.006642292719334364, 0.03165052831172943, 0.043060190975666046, 0.018957924097776413, -0.03212859854102135, -0.09458665549755096, -0.02378138154745102, 0.026188403367996216, 0.03768600896000862, 0.005059742834419012, 0.02117244340479374, -0.012829858809709549, -0.01613757200539112, 0.05240755155682564, -0.04296286776661873, 0.010179197415709496, -0.011191037483513355, -0.01359367836266756, -0.0013883959036320448, -0.021501557901501656, -0.046622470021247864, -0.002279456239193678, -0.008022232912480831, 0.03494155779480934, -0.04054165259003639, -0.03326448053121567, -0.050069913268089294, 0.03569197282195091, 0.022367289289832115, 0.05182701721787453, -0.0170217826962471, -0.0272356066852808, 0.0022750115022063255, 0.017552848905324936, -0.020131127908825874, -0.0793454572558403, 0.0298500694334507, 0.04681694880127907, -0.007833424024283886, 0.06630513817071915, -0.02106027863919735, 0.006506539415568113, -0.0070632454007864, 0.022313101217150688, -0.025383204221725464, 0.006699306890368462, 0.0036174538545310497, 0.0646214410662651, 0.038934048265218735, 0.025778906419873238, 0.041311461478471756, 0.024235643446445465, 0.01841762848198414, 0.020418742671608925, -0.03136419132351875, 0.002251123310998082, -0.030313905328512192, -0.013608206994831562, -0.03442661464214325, -0.0028377133421599865, -0.015573037788271904, 0.0169976819306612, -0.004374140873551369, 0.040782343596220016, -0.03865078091621399, -0.010554617270827293, 0.00140744773671031, 0.02126985602080822, -0.009733498096466064, 0.02705552615225315, 0.003911535255610943, 0.055687110871076584, 0.008627920411527157, -0.00521348649635911, 0.01872216910123825, -0.01984066143631935, -0.000770580256357789, -0.01892085000872612, -0.039639927446842194, -0.01438536960631609, -0.03674715757369995, -0.01942971907556057, 0.025557149201631546, -0.029387779533863068, 0.04588598757982254, -0.024949001148343086, 0.04651956260204315, 0.00884479284286499, -0.026893621310591698, -0.00276678754016757, 0.005891828797757626, -0.042117003351449966, 0.06122935190796852, -0.028106996789574623, 0.04399966821074486, -0.004310078453272581, -0.02878474071621895, -0.06685437262058258, -0.05062175169587135, -0.0014246838400140405, 0.029030170291662216, -0.012012778781354427, -0.05666673183441162, -0.0029577927198261023, -0.036871619522571564, -0.005880423355847597, -0.0015923577593639493, 0.052339646965265274, -0.003237294964492321, -0.029128536581993103, 0.01776186376810074, 0.00045661727199330926, 0.08532219380140305, 0.012139597907662392, -0.013752369210124016, 0.02630441263318062, 0.041277553886175156, -0.008006656542420387, -0.006097545847296715, 0.006441883742809296, -0.02836938202381134, -0.018632978200912476, -0.03291211277246475, 0.011979058384895325, 0.039941463619470596, -0.029033113270998, -0.02175736054778099, -0.019726235419511795, 0.019172120839357376, 0.0456928014755249, -0.04728905111551285, 0.018231753259897232, 0.0010771139059215784, -0.01182718575000763, -0.04838414117693901, 0.020208828151226044, -0.029929231852293015, -0.017330141738057137, 0.022726712748408318, 0.010606994852423668, -0.021578265354037285, 0.011527138762176037, 0.064472496509552, -0.010326694697141647, -0.0007022055215202272, -0.00022862099285703152, -0.02557610161602497, 0.07350236177444458, -0.001269083353690803, -0.024423323571681976, 0.015830224379897118, 0.01894162781536579, -0.0035101219546049833, -0.011672933585941792, -0.03496187925338745, -0.012125522829592228, 0.06839074939489365, -0.008543661795556545, 0.03100801818072796, 0.04572967067360878, -0.004414868541061878, 0.012128110975027084, -0.01800946332514286, -0.0242310781031847, -0.009553654119372368, 0.0042305015958845615, 0.05161484703421593, -0.011426570825278759, 0.0120015824213624, 0.037746213376522064, 0.026586152613162994, -0.017632221803069115, 0.04977821186184883, 0.014972567558288574, 0.04474448412656784, 0.01759754866361618, -0.043921999633312225, -0.05578821524977684, -0.0047799027524888515, -0.049898289144039154, 0.04152143374085426, -0.051034584641456604, -0.05137825757265091, 0.025043440982699394, 0.052977658808231354, -0.006513737142086029, -0.008506766520440578, -0.03097490407526493, -0.037769220769405365, 0.029326684772968292, 0.00040317390812560916, 0.004405271261930466, 0.02378779835999012, -0.026301823556423187, 0.014470391906797886, 0.032650601118803024, -0.013989579863846302, -0.02801324985921383, -0.02448071725666523, -0.024179823696613312, -0.06946209073066711, -0.035098254680633545, 0.029582595452666283, 0.017255252227187157, -0.0507461279630661, 0.05265781655907631, -0.028945470228791237, 0.014765147119760513, 0.02435004897415638, 0.031713053584098816, 0.01336453203111887, 0.07562275975942612, 0.017135197296738625, 0.02153686434030533, 0.014088067226111889, 0.002643254352733493, 0.11317460238933563, 0.07795128226280212, 0.028413541615009308, -0.04247783496975899, 0.0483032688498497, 0.00841150525957346, -0.03939073905348778, -0.050063297152519226, 0.019036991521716118, -0.006933477707207203, -0.008589514531195164, 0.03317530080676079, 0.06004592776298523, -0.005297284107655287, 0.013152253814041615, 0.07379695028066635, -0.030817929655313492, -0.007495965342968702, -0.0021644507069140673, 0.017492573708295822, 0.006291847676038742, -0.009391778148710728, -0.0571216382086277, 0.03238161653280258, 0.022912999615073204, -0.021903013810515404, -0.03339272737503052, 0.006003380753099918, -0.0020016636699438095, -0.018544912338256836, -0.02214348316192627, 0.021849874407052994, 0.031365830451250076, -0.026637215167284012, -0.038327302783727646, -0.017209487035870552, 0.02661411091685295, -0.018793180584907532, -0.01840534247457981, -0.01605667546391487, -0.01936969719827175, -0.04497593641281128, -0.01771189272403717, -0.006559203378856182, -0.033151112496852875, -0.014667843468487263, -0.05168910324573517, 0.014159495942294598, 0.005997967906296253, 0.012684269808232784, 0.033426135778427124, 0.029914310202002525, 0.029003996402025223, -0.03225846216082573, 0.021283866837620735, 0.0006005949107930064, 0.05506637319922447, -0.0008139157434925437, -0.02109568379819393, -0.05429140850901604, 0.005440365523099899, 0.0009484302718192339, -0.002988917753100395, 0.02211078442633152, -0.006451438181102276, -0.026413846760988235, -0.043408818542957306, 0.03356321528553963, -0.0027524642646312714, -0.06481728702783585, 0.014938472770154476, -0.005826523061841726, -0.021155476570129395, 0.002208780962973833, -0.0034596314653754234, -0.010457099415361881, 0.05109558627009392, 0.04057000204920769, -0.032840434461832047, 0.02150888741016388, -0.014331797137856483, -0.009275396354496479, -0.011414479464292526, -0.029985422268509865, -0.01354680210351944, 0.009088413789868355, 0.019463874399662018, 0.014260119758546352, 0.004628131166100502, 0.026902008801698685, -0.04008225351572037, 0.03231634572148323, 0.027504146099090576, -0.05754108354449272, -0.02948657050728798, -0.00818591844290495, -0.019454052671790123, 0.010844028554856777, 0.020114019513130188, 0.049403756856918335, -0.015127107501029968, -0.022803829982876778, 0.018829472362995148, 0.03446071967482567, 0.0009887255728244781, 0.02515782229602337, -0.012026705779135227, -0.04180343449115753, -0.0034792202059179544, 0.005942351184785366, -0.04049450159072876, -0.02009289339184761, -0.0015318016521632671, -0.007569998502731323, -0.04717065021395683, 0.010084394365549088, 0.015295161865651608, -0.013665921054780483, 0.015325206331908703, -0.032790035009384155, 0.001297110109589994, -0.03567637503147125, -0.00847067404538393, -0.03422648832201958, -0.01918751560151577, -0.029217109084129333, -0.011105441488325596, -0.009549514390528202, 0.017286168411374092, -0.023457413539290428, 0.0269174762070179, 0.06399288773536682, 0.06659839302301407, 0.04587825387716293, 0.017529960721731186, -0.012294108048081398, -0.05831830948591232, 0.05969488248229027, -0.0517922043800354, -0.006301707122474909, 0.04409220442175865, -0.055697716772556305, -0.02689036726951599, -0.009067445062100887, -0.04781930893659592, 0.01082849595695734, 0.037554606795310974, -0.005456856917589903, -0.010700765065848827, 0.053643640130758286, -0.012308252044022083, -0.042912498116493225, 0.006574379280209541, -0.00037436638376675546, 0.00022202904801815748, 0.0015953641850501299, 0.009313639253377914, 0.02609385922551155, -0.037292808294296265, 0.043345898389816284, 0.04482372850179672, -0.008355437777936459, -0.023555509746074677, 0.02199762873351574, -0.04060906544327736, 0.026292217895388603, -0.016713201999664307, -0.01678750291466713, 0.08567541837692261, 0.0400431863963604, -0.03281092271208763, 0.018289534375071526, -0.006020821165293455, 0.010309740900993347, -0.0986512303352356, -0.02770869992673397, -0.005785113200545311, 0.02227957174181938, 0.015731416642665863, -0.08010463416576385, -0.02126406319439411, -0.0022509261034429073, -0.048881981521844864, 0.028345979750156403, 0.010359333828091621, 0.00044739479199051857, -0.03832003474235535, 0.004377027973532677, -0.054698724299669266, 0.006865082308650017, 0.014460193924605846, 0.05717649683356285, 0.020701559260487556, 0.033182643353939056, -0.011622903868556023, -0.01342632994055748, -0.01837249845266342, -0.014763787388801575, 0.037151847034692764, -0.07024180144071579, 0.031203854829072952, -0.0003344812139403075, -0.03153136372566223, 0.024761641398072243, -0.02203763835132122, -0.0008414220064878464, 0.05209013819694519, -0.013006310909986496, -0.02133791707456112, 0.045984771102666855, -0.007514407392591238, -0.023482540622353554, 0.03308667987585068, -0.012782956473529339, 0.01895827427506447, 0.015863943845033646, -0.0019487969111651182, 0.028081513941287994, 0.0414963960647583, 0.0027708904817700386, -0.038154736161231995, 0.009488417766988277, -0.030469035729765892, -0.0036209053359925747, -0.008602957241237164, -0.00595857435837388, 0.02570263110101223, -0.0253505427390337, 0.013784956187009811, -0.03073618747293949, 0.002970306435599923, 0.05522756278514862, 0.030633902177214622, 0.010422741062939167, 0.02721889317035675, -0.010771443136036396, -0.06350084394216537, -0.03125380352139473, 0.0036114677786827087, -0.028880096971988678, -0.022593483328819275, -0.0017035322962328792, -0.0028835132252424955, 0.016702963039278984, -0.010853174142539501, -0.01033186074346304, 0.008788419887423515, 0.05636434629559517, -0.05164987966418266, -0.025670640170574188, 0.017744868993759155, -0.01783394254744053, 0.02589707262814045, -0.07300499826669693, 0.029752476140856743, 0.01549065113067627, -0.00020110553305130452, -0.02992936596274376, -0.01623065210878849, -0.053729258477687836, 0.029519911855459213, 0.06320498883724213, 0.019963815808296204, 0.020790942013263702, 0.023634890094399452, 0.009622979909181595, 0.01271945983171463, -0.04605633020401001, 0.07209347188472748, -0.02340121567249298, 0.005434642545878887, 0.019212832674384117, -0.023631997406482697, 0.002992555731907487, 0.007591854780912399, 0.008182347752153873, -0.025652805343270302, 0.00656024320051074, 0.004617565311491489, -0.010331563651561737, 0.02198612503707409, 0.024176601320505142, -0.03226388618350029, 0.033071789890527725, -0.0028691634070128202, 0.0005188371287658811, 0.045274779200553894, -0.018036246299743652, -0.02257293090224266, 0.015525516122579575, -0.040312450379133224, -0.0477953664958477, 0.028222760185599327, 0.026405975222587585, -0.004680668469518423, -0.07380186766386032, -0.0057840230874717236, 0.023391781374812126, -0.04593231528997421, -0.02542208880186081, 0.041626978665590286, 0.03992469236254692, 0.04402844235301018, 0.003933788742870092, 0.027793657034635544, 0.002152792876586318, -0.03949429839849472, 0.037153780460357666, 0.030475059524178505, 0.024770673364400864, 0.013306616805493832, 0.01632501557469368, -0.0022603797260671854, 0.0026165898889303207, 0.017090654000639915, -0.025692323222756386, 0.02642304077744484, -0.01811012253165245, -0.04711168259382248, 0.013651423156261444, -0.007545904256403446, 0.02583545446395874, 0.02218800224363804, 0.010383842512965202, 0.03439904749393463, -0.007916852831840515, -0.0004616775258909911, -0.043158214539289474, -0.010617421939969063, -0.021601518616080284, 0.01361116673797369, 0.0034706774167716503, 0.04967552796006203, -0.015770426020026207, 0.017088761553168297, 0.007731236983090639, -0.0005553621449507773, 0.05576455220580101, -0.013253685086965561, 0.05183623358607292, -0.02934347465634346, -0.017154697328805923, -0.012790298089385033, -0.012127990834414959, -0.054351139813661575, -0.009510901756584644, 0.031787846237421036, 0.06398724764585495, 0.01108691655099392, -0.003144749440252781, -0.03122066706418991, -0.009976830333471298, 0.03224549815058708, -0.06806652992963791, -0.041051726788282394, -0.060998789966106415, -0.019213611260056496, -0.009473675861954689, -0.0026087358128279448 ]
<p>I'm having trouble showing that the 2nd central moment is finite. I have $X_1,\ldots,X_n \overset{iid}{\sim} f(x)$ with $E[X_1]=\mu$ and $E[X_1^k]$ exists and is finite for any integer $k \geq 1$. </p> <p>I would like to use Law of Large Numbers, so I need to show that either $E[|X_1|]$ is finite or that $E[(X_1-\mu)^2]$ is finite. I tried proving the first one with Jensen's but got stuck since absolute value is convex, not concave. </p> <p>So now I'm stuck trying to show second central moment is finite. </p>
40,091
[ -0.05303554609417915, -0.011335802264511585, 0.03096437267959118, -0.005230494774878025, 0.03208880126476288, 0.031380053609609604, -0.012472046539187431, -0.03985137864947319, -0.01995374821126461, -0.06031489372253418, 0.059116180986166, 0.04561228305101395, 0.04181313514709473, 0.01011575572192669, 0.04202538728713989, 0.0034047230146825314, -0.05071927607059479, -0.010401048697531223, -0.027413981035351753, 0.00783214345574379, -0.04601038247346878, 0.030777867883443832, 0.030289947986602783, -0.01872921548783779, -0.05105626583099365, -0.005373251158744097, 0.014027291908860207, 0.009771124459803104, 0.005497668404132128, 0.09936998039484024, -0.030133770778775215, -0.020499004051089287, -0.006629655137658119, 0.01714896969497204, -0.006696120835840702, 0.022874677553772926, -0.016801457852125168, 0.009382250718772411, 0.030597956851124763, 0.019206585362553596, -0.037410929799079895, 0.010577705688774586, 0.02361670695245266, 0.013873093761503696, -0.0032084062695503235, 0.01882886327803135, -0.005065053701400757, -0.03294066712260246, 0.01384663674980402, -0.04189086705446243, 0.10049591958522797, -0.025979140773415565, 0.04758305847644806, 0.04255680739879608, 0.017860358580946922, -0.005137492436915636, 0.005370317026972771, 0.07100201398134232, 0.04265037178993225, -0.028495272621512413, -0.0005891803884878755, -0.02601267397403717, 0.0009427630575373769, -0.024626286700367928, -0.011814621277153492, 0.0019999071955680847, -0.007881943136453629, -0.028550975024700165, 0.006189556792378426, -0.005008487496525049, -0.0064465198665857315, 0.02173149399459362, 0.041288185864686966, -0.02169249765574932, -0.024107251316308975, 0.0124891372397542, 0.03518100082874298, 0.01668901927769184, 0.03110756352543831, 0.006007214076817036, -0.025707246735692024, 0.027845941483974457, 0.04192451015114784, 0.013906423933804035, 0.003229814115911722, -0.016727233305573463, 0.06604237109422684, 0.013435328379273415, 0.047185156494379044, 0.029110819101333618, -0.015521164052188396, -0.018351584672927856, 0.05998321622610092, -0.03669202700257301, -0.03223009780049324, 0.04133358970284462, -0.01879354938864708, 0.04587075486779213, -0.007840625010430813, 0.016648126766085625, -0.028919115662574768, -0.018290970474481583, 0.018433362245559692, 0.032923802733421326, -0.01503574475646019, -0.023917894810438156, -0.02157967910170555, 0.023362131789326668, -0.001915900968015194, 0.012199352495372295, -0.024942880496382713, 0.04759065434336662, -0.03347308561205864, 0.006465997081249952, 0.047216493636369705, -0.009325817227363586, 0.032535701990127563, 0.026537351310253143, 0.032868996262550354, 0.07890040427446365, 0.059073399752378464, -0.033864282071590424, 0.015726884827017784, -0.057601507753133774, -0.08351422101259232, 0.006189742591232061, 0.023940684273838997, 0.0017699308227747679, -0.08324214071035385, 0.025529859587550163, -0.0007476597675122321, 0.008548498153686523, -0.017099199816584587, 0.03157627582550049, 0.01995236799120903, -0.029135070741176605, -0.04327193647623062, -0.06688292324542999, 0.03949572145938873, -0.04413224756717682, -0.008827566169202328, -0.08491600304841995, 0.03794368728995323, 0.06790681183338165, 0.06792912632226944, 0.0222807377576828, 0.05147668346762657, 0.009185968898236752, 0.022099247202277184, 0.00980614684522152, -0.026605214923620224, -0.018820133060216904, 0.0028088511899113655, 0.003181019565090537, 0.0025980945210903883, -0.0704871341586113, 0.019594227895140648, 0.011813981458544731, -0.0007951169391162694, -0.037001363933086395, 0.047200758010149, -0.021562911570072174, -0.0027026678435504436, -0.02853526547551155, 0.0019396065035834908, -0.031707603484392166, 0.0690314769744873, 0.02252158336341381, 0.015342929400503635, 0.0018053886014968157, 0.005049914121627808, 0.03195633739233017, 0.02815967984497547, 0.0436483733355999, 0.0558609813451767, -0.007710952311754227, -0.011477264575660229, -0.03582286834716797, 0.016696013510227203, 0.03960065916180611, -0.004776590503752232, 0.02006952092051506, -0.04776519164443016, -0.0045878407545387745, -0.04036489129066467, 0.04996105283498764, -0.009636171162128448, -0.009455488994717598, 0.0409432053565979, -0.047396641224622726, 0.016589192673563957, -0.016347402706742287, 0.017808521166443825, 0.027463054284453392, -0.026465874165296555, 0.013820297084748745, -0.023425014689564705, 0.011864992789924145, -0.005256678909063339, -0.016665248200297356, -0.023243818432092667, -0.011755712330341339, 0.049646832048892975, -0.03536490723490715, 0.02099468559026718, 0.006180836819112301, 0.07322032749652863, 0.011246955953538418, 0.041151341050863266, -0.015003225766122341, -0.03393818065524101, 0.026906052604317665, -0.023530244827270508, 0.031058067455887794, -0.04353867471218109, 0.02269376441836357, -0.010761084035038948, 0.02039344608783722, -0.0107234176248312, 0.017651446163654327, -0.03732311725616455, 0.04508565366268158, 0.033133503049612045, 0.024616258218884468, 0.0037862975150346756, -0.01148694846779108, 0.03703025355935097, -0.04102258384227753, -0.012281705625355244, -0.027399197220802307, -0.016564447432756424, 0.017704376950860023, 0.012269324623048306, 0.04029487445950508, -0.03639237955212593, 0.028959691524505615, 0.06289929896593094, 0.003725361777469516, 0.0351669117808342, 0.030776049941778183, -0.0210148636251688, 0.002588678849861026, -0.01004970446228981, 0.012529848143458366, 0.029117200523614883, 0.0026352894492447376, -0.0059721143916249275, 0.009558123536407948, 0.04355073347687721, 0.002891228999942541, -0.003655462758615613, 0.016321871429681778, -0.01498127169907093, -0.023442870005965233, -0.01260831207036972, 0.0075687626376748085, 0.02650158293545246, 0.022938145324587822, -0.014373082667589188, 0.04416860640048981, -0.02272370271384716, 0.007337251212447882, -0.014732975512742996, -0.013134063221514225, 0.029218340292572975, 0.014785127714276314, -0.05261572450399399, -0.012401603162288666, 0.0244298093020916, -0.03187569975852966, 0.028790796175599098, -0.007596110925078392, -0.025047846138477325, -0.00783678237348795, 0.0016219442477449775, 0.005870535969734192, -0.03727832809090614, -0.03015713021159172, 0.002806810662150383, 0.008986828848719597, -0.009527817368507385, -0.009564182721078396, 0.03145496919751167, -0.020653825253248215, -0.043285395950078964, 0.014550367370247841, -0.02637358568608761, -0.02113201655447483, 0.04150751605629921, 0.009107343852519989, 0.025800487026572227, 0.038283977657556534, 0.012111486867070198, -0.03584190458059311, -0.008872698992490768, -0.026114696636795998, 0.00826428271830082, -0.019405733793973923, -0.012817812152206898, 0.04851977527141571, 0.00902502704411745, -0.02512492425739765, 0.022358644753694534, -0.016416914761066437, -0.04692859575152397, -0.07572819292545319, -0.0053832028061151505, 0.03432761877775192, 0.00021113247203174978, 0.027771973982453346, 0.007340688724070787, -0.0006608465919271111, 0.003979918546974659, -0.042978569865226746, -0.03834765776991844, 0.013704730197787285, -0.0032335740979760885, 0.017076386138796806, 0.0004124522674828768, -0.025822395458817482, 0.05299017205834389, 0.042194388806819916, -0.01378218736499548, -0.02902674488723278, -0.007836151868104935, 0.0009850072674453259, -0.023574307560920715, -0.024357648566365242, 0.006911599077284336, -0.026616649702191353, 0.02486293762922287, 0.04349237680435181, -0.01986139640212059, 0.04232407733798027, -0.035992443561553955, -0.0007392172701656818, 0.01846204325556755, -0.01692270301282406, -0.00022565954714082181, 0.05213569849729538, 0.024531180039048195, 0.014352977275848389, 0.011450347490608692, 0.03687397018074989, 0.033056046813726425, -0.028557006269693375, -0.03430924192070961, 0.025608964264392853, -0.05153471976518631, 0.02235940471291542, -0.04325919970870018, 0.03394725173711777, 0.032974474132061005, -0.027502743527293205, -0.0005501476698555052, -0.02025829814374447, -0.015665559098124504, -0.044631510972976685, 0.03462337702512741, 0.019865095615386963, 0.011780444532632828, -0.006663723383098841, -0.002400169614702463, -0.039477936923503876, -0.004166268277913332, 0.007069549057632685, -0.030298547819256783, -0.049598079174757004, 0.02417151629924774, 0.021459413692355156, 0.0306538213044405, -0.009866919368505478, 0.004203013144433498, -0.021067390218377113, -0.011453955434262753, 0.0028745417948812246, -0.0055365292355418205, 0.01776585727930069, 0.014653035439550877, 0.01442794967442751, 0.04562228173017502, -0.01771419495344162, 0.008684544824063778, 0.00326760346069932, -0.06680890917778015, 0.010506872087717056, -0.02938501164317131, 0.017595632001757622, -0.03741751238703728, -0.034334227442741394, 0.018461836501955986, -0.02467171847820282, 0.02612042799592018, -0.008452147245407104, -0.016049811616539955, -0.030224042013287544, -0.004527726676315069, -0.04568662494421005, -0.010513552464544773, -0.004206439480185509, 0.05719644948840141, 0.027954531833529472, -0.030902760103344917, 0.06447949260473251, -0.005247035995125771, -0.029195968061685562, -0.006079136393964291, -0.03888542950153351, 0.043574851006269455, 0.02112482488155365, 0.011231810785830021, 0.03906073793768883, 0.006363407708704472, 0.021614285185933113, -0.005159913562238216, 0.024923179298639297, 0.06751073151826859, 0.044746994972229004, 0.0033645369112491608, -0.01204557716846466, -0.02681075595319271, -0.030113475397229195, -0.007706946227699518, 0.004605501424521208, 0.005693105049431324, 0.006429102271795273, 0.058150067925453186, 0.012764541432261467, -0.05601063370704651, 0.0415770523250103, 0.03275841847062111, 0.01588928885757923, -0.029976630583405495, -0.022242849692702293, -0.02290358766913414, -0.009542419575154781, 0.016097038984298706, 0.017774829640984535, -0.025487728416919708, 0.021708045154809952, -0.02664874494075775, 0.03684268519282341, -0.022565752267837524, 0.005776433274149895, 0.007506119552999735, 0.02774549275636673, 0.012533659115433693, 0.006521929986774921, -0.03771185502409935, 0.025526590645313263, 0.007062728051096201, 0.034735243767499924, 0.020415393635630608, 0.022919010370969772, -0.0010681090643629432, 0.013174217194318771, 0.029538273811340332, 0.028604241088032722, -0.008391709066927433, -0.002826347481459379, -0.023601915687322617, 0.028867388144135475, 0.01170571893453598, -0.030155956745147705, 0.0884893387556076, -0.00020506168948486447, -0.0014811961445957422, 0.014489136636257172, -0.03845560550689697, -0.04708035662770271, -0.011116432026028633, 0.006897130515426397, 0.030524931848049164, -0.04162489250302315, -0.044484686106443405, -0.053551360964775085, -0.034156691282987595, 0.025455864146351814, 0.07692188024520874, -0.010628479532897472, 0.006996044423431158, 0.01402042992413044, 0.03789953514933586, 0.008047289215028286, -0.055615585297346115, 0.032508980482816696, -0.02350546419620514, -0.03152953460812569, 0.03279970958828926, -0.03944985195994377, -0.04504167661070824, 0.059851471334695816, -0.008265240117907524, -0.03671972081065178, 0.052310384809970856, 0.00255321292206645, 0.01326670590788126, 0.012163028120994568, 0.013691241852939129, 0.05453440919518471, 0.027506643906235695, 0.03344622254371643, -0.001727873575873673, -0.019231436774134636, 0.007323445286601782, -0.02706909365952015, -0.02765110321342945, -0.01944890432059765, 0.0012305004056543112, -0.030026491731405258, -0.005282736383378506, 0.0037013599649071693, 0.03168689087033272, -0.035574525594711304, 0.026501880958676338, 0.004140208940953016, 0.06168186664581299, 0.015026353299617767, -0.0015784732531756163, -0.008528459817171097, 0.0208674855530262, -0.03093530982732773, -0.02014065720140934, 0.028847040608525276, -0.028890511021018028, 0.011474003084003925, 0.006126981228590012, -0.04750858247280121, 0.02014944888651371, -0.06565982103347778, -0.011292776092886925, -0.056720998138189316, -0.012882696464657784, 0.017041489481925964, -0.023257693275809288, 0.01748582534492016, -0.00727099971845746, -0.018958602100610733, -0.038492243736982346, 0.02854512631893158, 0.027074825018644333, 0.047893039882183075, -0.05927857756614685, 0.004053126089274883, 0.05502546206116676, -0.014712060801684856, -0.07293883711099625, -0.03515544906258583, 0.006067344918847084, 0.02997853420674801, -0.012367663905024529, -0.04650082439184189, -0.0043651931919157505, 0.004702341742813587, -0.059649158269166946, -0.00684668542817235, 0.021625487133860588, 0.028505941852927208, 0.010260716080665588, -0.037752244621515274, 0.0031097708269953728, 0.037797972559928894, 0.0048642223700881, -0.015136400237679482, 0.02810046263039112, 0.001389920711517334, -0.045276399701833725, 0.022624973207712173, 0.0335090346634388, -0.012416897341609001, 0.0373394601047039, 0.03431594371795654, -0.01557584386318922, 0.012320746667683125, 0.0009530311799608171, -0.03620659187436104, 0.006021328270435333, 0.030698027461767197, 0.006606213748455048, -0.0057273912243545055, -0.04685996100306511, 0.004656103905290365, 0.008493402041494846, -0.010966416448354721, -0.022167744114995003, 0.009701558388769627, -0.0500410795211792, -0.010396714322268963, -0.001009488827548921, 0.04217097908258438, -0.0047292644158005714, 0.0851987823843956, 0.004264873918145895, -0.009801095351576805, -0.030085347592830658, 0.011350483633577824, 0.022019194439053535, -0.028166087344288826, -0.007804228458553553, 0.007780250161886215, 0.04390141740441322, -0.02424423024058342, -0.01016490999609232, -0.03315485641360283, 0.05997217074036598, 0.06441663205623627, -0.00532545056194067, 0.018703673034906387, 0.010597365908324718, 0.003947598394006491, -0.016612615436315536, 0.0015310040907934308, -0.015497260726988316, -0.014624309726059437, 0.012851404957473278, 0.02363421581685543, -0.03140498697757721, 0.00674868980422616, 0.032196030020713806, 0.001153081189841032, 0.0043811374343931675, 0.02134077250957489, 0.018611932173371315, 0.015631619840860367, -0.00413082679733634, -0.014974027872085571, -0.04082756116986275, 0.05048389732837677, -0.035857006907463074, 0.030195146799087524, -0.024599513038992882, -0.02150626666843891, -0.009634160436689854, 0.01772281527519226, 0.006279486231505871, -0.020465794950723648, -0.0433405376970768, -0.04870498925447464, 0.013243970461189747, 0.01276618055999279, -0.003665262134745717, 0.011242957785725594, -0.005782132036983967, 0.025004446506500244, 0.012293214909732342, 0.023436401039361954, -0.03508688881993294, -0.01722734048962593, 0.024660518392920494, -0.051730599254369736, -0.06461326777935028, 0.018968330696225166, -0.0126581946387887, -0.02955498732626438, 0.050604261457920074, -0.02042658068239689, -0.005548842716962099, 0.018114157021045685, 0.005868161097168922, -0.008096413686871529, 0.0775810182094574, 0.03239082917571068, 0.04153084754943848, 0.0007308501517400146, -0.035922907292842865, 0.09811648726463318, 0.041977401822805405, 0.02934877760708332, -0.03750808909535408, 0.010897704400122166, -0.03160500526428223, 0.009328492917120457, -0.05567100644111633, 0.028144659474492073, 0.005833112169057131, -0.01177071500569582, 0.018831811845302582, 0.03900378197431564, 0.02535872533917427, -0.03304465860128403, 0.019358040764927864, -0.02468673139810562, -0.06309806555509567, 0.0006449116044677794, 0.012441843748092651, -0.05135514214634895, -0.018841983750462532, -0.0530107319355011, 0.039599645882844925, -0.04473399743437767, -0.007954216562211514, -0.035945598036050797, -0.009818478487432003, -0.006925242021679878, 0.009830745868384838, -0.01940733753144741, -0.03269641473889351, 0.02499311789870262, -0.0228007510304451, -0.04363008588552475, 0.0027016382664442062, 0.012331073172390461, -0.021090585738420486, 0.009936438873410225, 0.009411747567355633, 0.011750036850571632, 0.008008844219148159, 0.04704263061285019, -0.0014678511070087552, -0.06586775183677673, -0.04879909008741379, -0.06150687858462334, 0.013767373748123646, -0.01117722224444151, 0.010831642895936966, 0.025098340585827827, 0.01190194208174944, -0.02114594727754593, -0.015253234654664993, -0.029766801744699478, 0.02134811133146286, 0.03221181780099869, -0.030414875596761703, 0.003267367370426655, -0.006624304689466953, 0.03702357038855553, -0.000634842028375715, 0.01202902477234602, 0.003859585849568248, -0.04655284434556961, -0.0315001979470253, -0.017302105203270912, 0.02032659202814102, -0.01320336852222681, -0.042458970099687576, -0.03770459070801735, -0.04556812345981598, -0.03579259291291237, -0.03464004024863243, -0.014244155026972294, -0.06363904476165771, 0.04721571505069733, 0.007134116720408201, -0.008137485943734646, -0.00292156427167356, -0.05093894526362419, -0.015022889710962772, -0.030576037243008614, -0.02054474502801895, -0.05106048285961151, -0.0010683864820748568, 0.038999222218990326, 0.015961630269885063, 0.021149255335330963, -0.03037887066602707, 0.0025584104005247355, 0.051631223410367966, 0.015166519209742546, -0.06595925241708755, -0.030148541554808617, -0.02848733775317669, -0.027275556698441505, 0.003689609467983246, -0.029330795630812645, 0.060135047882795334, 0.04151458665728569, 0.03192152827978134, 0.026067258790135384, -0.03285487741231918, -0.0498206801712513, 0.03218013048171997, 0.007528860587626696, -0.048463452607393265, 0.02468743734061718, 0.05079778656363487, 0.021245812997221947, -0.052514079958200455, -0.05670185759663582, -0.0013493300648406148, -0.008777671493589878, 0.03150754049420357, 0.010147340595722198, -0.04869202524423599, -0.02772478200495243, -0.01104037370532751, 0.024461450055241585, -0.0024928096681833267, -0.027904542163014412, -0.008418308570981026, 0.01357555016875267, 0.019895244389772415, -0.034341972321271896, -0.03571869432926178, 0.01992584764957428, -0.011452567763626575, -0.05293317884206772, 0.04559507966041565, 0.02550249919295311, 0.007529726251959801, -0.009748362936079502, 0.026950160041451454, -0.03656170889735222, 0.06341580301523209, -0.0238086748868227, 0.01986488327383995, 0.06364499032497406, -0.05195925384759903, -0.0006973735871724784, -0.005376946181058884, 0.0323757566511631, 0.015697510913014412, 0.009992671199142933, -0.01703556440770626, -0.020725272595882416, 0.028600381687283516, -0.035832930356264114, -0.01608242280781269, 0.005926402285695076, -0.01603240892291069, -0.017336247488856316, -0.0034222444519400597, -0.013335985131561756, -0.022797930985689163, -0.0188413355499506, 0.021530795842409134, 0.04084043949842453, 0.01505640335381031, -0.04190206155180931, 0.01658458821475506, 0.003468035953119397, 0.0038220284041017294, 0.01163018960505724, 0.01975182257592678, 0.05015748739242554, 0.035437002778053284, -0.05300046503543854, 0.031400419771671295, -0.05429248884320259, -0.006277432199567556, -0.08902032673358917, -0.02010519802570343, 0.025900285691022873, 0.015241223387420177, 0.05765688419342041, -0.034225400537252426, 0.013844331726431847, 0.05983957275748253, -0.05837693437933922, -0.036226607859134674, 0.0033726573456078768, -0.027502190321683884, -0.04507024213671684, -0.002647675573825836, -0.01598656363785267, 0.0030721467919647694, -0.0044393534772098064, 0.037337757647037506, 0.049751486629247665, 0.042927321046590805, -0.006524692289531231, -0.03575409576296806, 0.0041464208625257015, 0.007633811794221401, -0.0043127029202878475, -0.038688842207193375, 0.029758339747786522, -0.011826425790786743, -0.037475328892469406, 0.05485788732767105, -0.027007581666111946, -0.01903892308473587, 0.020473722368478775, 0.05118914693593979, 0.03379329293966293, 0.051895398646593094, 0.01947559230029583, -0.001731051248498261, 0.06401431560516357, -0.019716979935765266, 0.02087954804301262, 0.013096817769110203, -0.025053845718503, -0.012684832327067852, 0.06643424183130264, -0.011216634884476662, 0.0007262844010256231, 0.031197218224406242, 0.01872210018336773, -0.041351065039634705, 0.0003649905265774578, -0.029866984114050865, 0.014567011035978794, -0.031708698719739914, 0.05788912996649742, -0.01606283336877823, -0.02285075932741165, 0.04522590711712837, 0.0549839548766613, -0.020463071763515472, -0.021280372515320778, 0.035499244928359985, -0.0555608831346035, 0.026972491294145584, 0.044216446578502655, -0.015196519903838634, -0.020201323553919792, -0.04976038634777069, 0.03292820602655411, -0.0057094162330031395, -0.01108077447861433, -0.055168647319078445, -0.07509571313858032, 0.01855783723294735, -0.0024368457961827517, 0.022743534296751022, -0.015982309356331825, 0.0034406662452965975, -0.02091577649116516, -0.07984668016433716, 0.03547646850347519, -0.029453817754983902, 0.04085448756814003, -0.015309241600334644, 0.027247680351138115, -0.03638949617743492, -0.02893688529729843, 0.055372729897499084, 0.0015221127541735768, 0.005556343588978052, -0.020332753658294678, 0.052089475095272064, 0.042842987924814224, -0.06756171584129333, 0.01906571350991726, -0.002779007190838456, -0.011951160617172718, -0.037560708820819855, -0.02606249786913395, 0.009558534249663353, 0.018279941752552986, 0.0137875871732831, -0.007414538413286209, -0.014778422191739082, 0.014410723000764847, -0.0009301012032665312, 0.029375199228525162, -0.015118507668375969, -0.009246530011296272, 0.08819454908370972, -0.010388465598225594, 0.03676595911383629, 0.017603885382413864, -0.005602929275482893, -0.042894598096609116, 0.008086997084319592, -0.053509004414081573, -0.02562672272324562, -0.0216989666223526, 0.03303226828575134, 0.02483629435300827, -0.06489188224077225, -0.04816377907991409, 0.04507818818092346, -0.03138456866145134, -0.03448038920760155, 0.05097248777747154, 0.031661905348300934, 0.06460018455982208, 0.03936446085572243, 0.028255658224225044, -0.013910634443163872, 0.00957673229277134, 0.02967602200806141, -0.002795447828248143, 0.0332191102206707, -0.026177093386650085, 0.022333601489663124, 0.03644337132573128, -0.025142943486571312, 0.017811143770813942, -0.04729321226477623, 0.0461139902472496, -0.02237791009247303, -0.05869831517338753, 0.016483968123793602, 0.0007488991832360625, 0.011390342377126217, -0.040650416165590286, -0.0035396758466959, 0.03285711258649826, -0.01219446025788784, 0.018776455894112587, -0.02388080395758152, -0.009111711755394936, -0.0026902067475020885, -0.010211136192083359, 0.047627925872802734, 0.009884662926197052, 0.009762183763086796, -0.005128378048539162, 0.0033210664987564087, 0.022099722176790237, 0.016873441636562347, -0.014765054918825626, 0.020182248204946518, 0.04042908921837807, 0.024626191705465317, -0.045098837465047836, -0.014055315405130386, 0.022241825237870216, -0.038842812180519104, 0.005893023684620857, 0.0681934580206871, 0.026877518743276596, 0.0060816374607384205, -0.009171507321298122, 0.0007809613598510623, 0.07474253326654434, -0.046457819640636444, 0.01614009588956833, -0.044325415045022964, -0.022231776267290115, -0.00433523440733552, -0.01655353233218193 ]
<p>I have a regression in which I try to understand how much variance of the metric dependent variable each of the regressors explains. I use the package R <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/relaimpo/index.html" rel="nofollow">relaimpo</a> (Grömping, 2006) for that purpose, that allocates $R^2$ shares to each regressor using the LMG metric. The hypothesis is that the regressors differ drastically in their $R^2$ contribution. </p> <p>If I had a cross-sectional sample of $N=6000$, things would be dandy. Unfortunately, I only have $N=2000$, but 3 measurement points (weeks 0, 6, 12). Both the dependent variable and regressors are time-varying, that is, they are assessed at each measurement point. </p> <p>Currently I run the analyses separately for each measurement point and find large differences between relative importance estimates between regressors (0% to 25%), and I find that the ranking of regressors and the explained variance is surprisingly stable over time (at least from a qualitative perspective, plotting the explained variance of each of the 14 regressors for each measurement point). </p> <p>For a scientific paper, there are two reasons why I want to do this in one regression instead of 3. (1) 3 different analyses take up a lot of space in the paper and obfuscate the main message a bit (regressors differ drastically in their relative importance). (2) $N=2000$ isn't all that much when disentangling the relative contributions of 14 correlated regressors (the CIs are rather large). </p> <p>Therefore, I wondered whether there are ways to "pool" all subjects into one regression that would not lead to an outcry of anybody with some statistical background ("you severely violated the assumption of statistical independence!!"). In the best case I would simply have one regression that covers all 3 time points.</p> <p>The method has to be a regression (ie., not using NLE or LME packages), because that is what the <code>relaimpo</code> package uses as baseline model to then calculate unique $R^2$ contributions of regressors. </p> <p>What are my options?</p>
37,046
[ -0.041399311274290085, 0.019871294498443604, 0.02374217100441456, -0.0374111607670784, 0.024410298094153404, 0.007432474289089441, -0.032915618270635605, -0.01599535346031189, 0.03464435413479805, -0.03541291505098343, 0.0274960957467556, 0.029788825660943985, 0.0701553151011467, -0.009599048644304276, 0.004895522724837065, 0.008114337921142578, 0.012645616196095943, 0.02538255788385868, 0.008009747602045536, -0.027085013687610626, -0.006667156238108873, 0.03266475349664688, -0.007797883357852697, -0.03332323580980301, -0.033471979200839996, 0.04531388357281685, 0.0086379274725914, -0.05737783759832382, -0.009008657187223434, 0.04135633260011673, -0.053040601313114166, -0.012228813953697681, -0.017374536022543907, 0.0014777705073356628, -0.01745978556573391, -0.02145565114915371, 0.006580407731235027, -0.025975869968533516, 0.014315227046608925, 0.04554203525185585, -0.02665306255221367, -0.025195052847266197, -0.023562265560030937, 0.03270024061203003, -0.02204468660056591, 0.011389539577066898, 0.009853390976786613, 0.006146010011434555, 0.05266068875789642, -0.02178170159459114, 0.07926055788993835, 0.007174102123826742, 0.012546004727482796, 0.014390322379767895, -0.04136748984456062, -0.005657577887177467, 0.06087328493595123, 0.07362350821495056, 0.01638386771082878, -0.04034282639622688, -0.023001473397016525, -0.0060262116603553295, 0.027586087584495544, 0.015032161958515644, -0.009013068862259388, 0.0051763299852609634, 0.03504050895571709, 0.048180244863033295, 0.04256920889019966, -0.047035377472639084, 0.012509599328041077, -0.004649157635867596, 0.05225971341133118, 0.0030286002438515425, 0.0018221193458884954, 0.010197087191045284, 0.028338434174656868, 0.00978773832321167, 0.03677530959248543, 0.03993454948067665, -0.008397742174565792, 0.013895903714001179, 0.022534681484103203, 0.022216305136680603, 0.005464476998895407, -0.0030610545072704554, 0.04116624593734741, -0.04422604665160179, 0.02087351307272911, 0.03738973289728165, -0.036424670368433, 0.021667562425136566, 0.03459390625357628, 0.06202884018421173, -0.02333848737180233, 0.024247534573078156, -0.016413304954767227, 0.016768623143434525, 0.022923516109585762, 0.01676352508366108, -0.05318012088537216, -0.053552500903606415, -0.012499726377427578, 0.050616759806871414, -0.015813780948519707, 0.0005161805893294513, -0.014239410869777203, -0.011957619339227676, -0.005621384363621473, -0.0335395373404026, -0.020711412653326988, -0.0007533495663665235, -0.01864793710410595, -0.00414299126714468, 0.042144596576690674, -0.02860753796994686, -0.00715941097587347, -0.0007531422306783497, 0.07843295484781265, 0.0698157548904419, 0.00006393063085852191, -0.014217534102499485, -0.017977576702833176, -0.012009850703179836, -0.01606602407991886, 0.04716169089078903, 0.0345260389149189, -0.024764206260442734, -0.02560981921851635, 0.027597174048423767, 0.022056203335523605, -0.02234278805553913, 0.02957393042743206, 0.012576976791024208, 0.018848495557904243, 0.0036980872973799706, -0.12470671534538269, -0.08098641037940979, 0.055253203958272934, -0.012386275455355644, 0.019903862848877907, -0.054011452943086624, -0.016149278730154037, -0.010752111673355103, 0.0667596086859703, 0.011690612882375717, 0.050395794212818146, 0.04821864143013954, 0.04331168159842491, 0.024255525320768356, -0.0011237601283937693, -0.0001718713901937008, -0.02204142138361931, -0.030000749975442886, -0.016871051862835884, -0.06628864258527756, 0.011329669505357742, 0.030848303809762, -0.013669712468981743, 0.06771054863929749, 0.024941880255937576, 0.034259773790836334, -0.02640143595635891, -0.024448560550808907, 0.000027185000362806022, 0.004288059659302235, 0.0604463592171669, -0.0027850617188960314, 0.0182082150131464, -0.0005664515774697065, 0.028718838468194008, 0.0423562228679657, 0.0020482237450778484, 0.059243276715278625, 0.026914866641163826, -0.006714852061122656, 0.033864542841911316, 0.01473445538431406, -0.009512299671769142, 0.012734869495034218, -0.07693106681108475, -0.053779467940330505, -0.03365090489387512, -0.02246999368071556, 0.024266304448246956, 0.04814257472753525, -0.008503848686814308, 0.00818580761551857, 0.04049750044941902, -0.022167446091771126, -0.032765068113803864, -0.023230066522955894, 0.008364236913621426, -0.029758669435977936, -0.01393957994878292, 0.010840029455721378, 0.011111714877188206, 0.028598878532648087, -0.017657682299613953, -0.02001217007637024, 0.005454737693071365, 0.019580896943807602, 0.05034298449754715, -0.014268103986978531, -0.0005706350784748793, 0.009323938749730587, 0.034388598054647446, -0.013072430156171322, 0.046427831053733826, -0.05920620635151863, -0.014770084992051125, 0.04973204806447029, -0.01173701323568821, 0.03548496961593628, -0.033977724611759186, -0.0135506521910429, 0.03667937591671944, 0.012467779219150543, -0.03188970685005188, 0.01087338849902153, -0.06850702315568924, 0.043605122715234756, 0.0014582922449335456, -0.005809007678180933, -0.042822640389204025, 0.028343472629785538, 0.010652243159711361, 0.020152995362877846, -0.04008810594677925, -0.0015669807326048613, -0.03717648237943649, -0.02311866730451584, 0.057491403073072433, 0.04790714383125305, -0.01340530440211296, 0.00013712604413740337, 0.04285794124007225, 0.044999852776527405, 0.01440347358584404, -0.009732028469443321, -0.008916445076465607, -0.017456213012337685, 0.008594236336648464, 0.017590397968888283, 0.0035305297933518887, -0.007969396188855171, 0.011533300392329693, -0.002246812218800187, 0.0381704717874527, -0.002264108508825302, 0.022093897685408592, 0.02928464114665985, 0.001222069375216961, -0.016431080177426338, 0.0007461553323082626, -0.02366325445473194, 0.06533324718475342, -0.01831437461078167, 0.028008075430989265, 0.04390954598784447, 0.03596736490726471, 0.0033601131290197372, 0.015102870762348175, -0.0634121522307396, 0.03441299498081207, 0.04686299338936806, -0.04071517288684845, 0.021026141941547394, 0.00363848521374166, -0.025286128744482994, 0.012143169529736042, -0.04785788804292679, -0.015025186352431774, -0.0360431894659996, 0.0305253267288208, 0.0000806967364042066, 0.015116029419004917, -0.02027207240462303, -0.023720653727650642, 0.015146058052778244, 0.0193659458309412, 0.02481186017394066, 0.047022972255945206, -0.018129976466298103, -0.03890850394964218, 0.004677391145378351, -0.001492006704211235, -0.010432698763906956, 0.017669251188635826, 0.0029778119642287493, -0.032596904784440994, 0.031486015766859055, -0.004700102843344212, -0.09929481893777847, -0.02746567688882351, -0.04041607677936554, -0.007976680062711239, -0.0490841381251812, -0.001470091170631349, 0.055049773305654526, -0.007107199169695377, -0.07490306347608566, -0.01237635500729084, -0.04915418103337288, -0.01041510421782732, 0.005723700858652592, -0.0010759435826912522, 0.012791774235665798, -0.009330197237432003, -0.02190985344350338, 0.004921283107250929, -0.02967163547873497, -0.05902479961514473, -0.03502616286277771, -0.06073977053165436, 0.010934022255241871, 0.005662303417921066, 0.061982713639736176, -0.02653507888317108, 0.017192427068948746, 0.0783509761095047, 0.021120481193065643, -0.03354332223534584, -0.05621510371565819, 0.014650669880211353, -0.0009754433413036168, -0.013735023327171803, 0.03093067929148674, 0.014595335349440575, 0.012524928897619247, -0.008663644082844257, -0.010525072924792767, 0.060467250645160675, 0.03516693040728569, -0.004980386234819889, 0.006856544874608517, 0.024693911895155907, 0.012884058989584446, -0.016844438388943672, -0.005363245494663715, 0.04522937908768654, -0.013090623542666435, -0.026322126388549805, 0.020877448841929436, 0.021357761695981026, -0.00036992612876929343, -0.045774441212415695, 0.00026213700766675174, -0.023693542927503586, -0.0010372777469456196, -0.016845619305968285, -0.005131566897034645, 0.015938615426421165, -0.04684748873114586, -0.020547769963741302, -0.007734356448054314, 0.016245843842625618, -0.01760101690888405, 0.009309851564466953, 0.04519077390432358, 0.05468607321381569, -0.006686809938400984, -0.0033931389916688204, -0.03162973001599312, 0.009982336312532425, 0.02321125939488411, -0.050857070833444595, -0.005502203945070505, 0.04175926744937897, 0.011600484140217304, -0.004078944679349661, 0.0048549119383096695, -0.05195997655391693, -0.005907354410737753, -0.07286986708641052, 0.01653382182121277, -0.024981118738651276, 0.034980300813913345, 0.0012882539303973317, 0.025131139904260635, -0.002373037626966834, -0.021788250654935837, -0.030010145157575607, 0.027844492346048355, -0.05735243856906891, 0.002533839549869299, -0.05636841058731079, 0.03269064798951149, 0.03649383783340454, -0.010061563923954964, 0.023521563038229942, -0.02529352344572544, -0.005951342172920704, -0.01775381714105606, 0.07764177769422531, -0.024686334654688835, 0.016810299828648567, -0.008550919592380524, -0.03377852961421013, 0.0023315392900258303, 0.049442410469055176, 0.009085522964596748, -0.015033803880214691, 0.022958215326070786, 0.02636725828051567, 0.01500055193901062, 0.0035624252632260323, -0.052606143057346344, 0.00020740271429531276, 0.0065270112827420235, 0.0472259595990181, 0.012562157586216927, 0.01574740745127201, 0.005581462290138006, 0.001675532548688352, -0.010965182445943356, -0.018573720008134842, 0.01692710816860199, 0.0017215366242453456, 0.002720349468290806, 0.01606876403093338, -0.006099200341850519, 0.028188524767756462, 0.018756959587335587, -0.023885320872068405, -0.0012339610839262605, 0.04912729188799858, 0.00715831620618701, -0.015949172899127007, -0.012743343599140644, 0.001486078486777842, 0.00622202642261982, -0.010747678577899933, -0.02070486731827259, -0.01715763285756111, 0.03654506430029869, 0.026873290538787842, -0.0022936402820050716, 0.0275401808321476, 0.01565716601908207, -0.026640184223651886, 0.01908956468105316, -0.024038882926106453, -0.012052658945322037, -0.02243901416659355, 0.051375288516283035, 0.011331554502248764, -0.04134994372725487, -0.020624851807951927, -0.021502193063497543, 0.02380235679447651, 0.008002040907740593, 0.028474364429712296, -0.00015947598149068654, -0.07703077048063278, -0.022510092705488205, 0.013350284658372402, 0.019010962918400764, -0.05253396928310394, -0.011026518419384956, -0.009792541153728962, -0.013568714261054993, 0.04385813698172569, -0.025637825950980186, 0.024055426940321922, 0.009283234365284443, 0.026197971776127815, -0.025719067081809044, -0.030707992613315582, -0.03531595319509506, 0.011991115286946297, -0.03421255573630333, 0.017293354496359825, -0.03746075555682182, -0.019619490951299667, -0.02470793016254902, 0.025713851675391197, 0.03754352033138275, 0.041477832943201065, -0.011747945100069046, 0.0055463300086557865, 0.020850375294685364, 0.02577281929552555, -0.01188733708113432, -0.0621047280728817, 0.010389462113380432, 0.03551153093576431, 0.012840511277318, 0.06399266421794891, -0.026537863537669182, -0.023427056148648262, 0.007958591915667057, 0.02771696075797081, -0.010268554091453552, 0.022070908918976784, -0.009887443855404854, 0.0730755627155304, 0.032364774495363235, -0.003162694163620472, 0.04106822982430458, 0.043432462960481644, 0.030834117904305458, 0.02754834294319153, -0.023490069434046745, 0.014256458729505539, -0.011222145520150661, -0.03362898901104927, -0.00019839874585159123, -0.023529913276433945, -0.029999341815710068, 0.028774941340088844, -0.0538582019507885, 0.00421504583209753, -0.020568322390317917, -0.009293056093156338, -0.0027462958823889494, 0.0007287234766408801, -0.014711692929267883, 0.00935500767081976, 0.03680906444787979, 0.03138786181807518, -0.0077666123397648335, -0.0030263415537774563, 0.0051230210810899734, -0.030489206314086914, -0.013319320045411587, 0.012287947349250317, -0.03287091478705406, 0.034233056008815765, -0.024158168584108353, 0.010702047497034073, -0.026909492909908295, -0.009208496659994125, 0.045007895678281784, 0.01028155442327261, 0.0400884784758091, -0.014459749683737755, -0.026776453480124474, -0.024280766025185585, 0.027174418792128563, 0.0027545704506337643, 0.05861307680606842, -0.026977570727467537, -0.013473848812282085, -0.024517443031072617, -0.018188832327723503, -0.07264666259288788, -0.007382818963378668, 0.019410796463489532, -0.011782132089138031, 0.0014656300190836191, -0.04724442958831787, -0.012277981266379356, 0.006882585119456053, -0.011810386553406715, 0.003953055012971163, 0.035680852830410004, -0.015925273299217224, -0.026514556258916855, -0.037185195833444595, 0.02957265079021454, 0.06522010266780853, -0.03410584479570389, -0.013706651516258717, 0.023838210850954056, 0.014068188145756721, -0.03466207906603813, -0.00665412750095129, -0.00023610464995726943, -0.034707728773355484, -0.009098028764128685, -0.04859282076358795, 0.009039395488798618, 0.026585452258586884, -0.02096620202064514, -0.015660423785448074, 0.03150397166609764, -0.002078690566122532, 0.029620429500937462, -0.028575770556926727, 0.019274014979600906, -0.008484067395329475, 0.03716472163796425, -0.03887893259525299, 0.01662791520357132, -0.006258506793528795, -0.013201302848756313, 0.014856016263365746, -0.042722754180431366, -0.018574491143226624, 0.024148117750883102, 0.05745157599449158, 0.015144551172852516, -0.01245555467903614, -0.0024948078207671642, -0.021106595173478127, 0.04198861122131348, -0.000243158865487203, 0.0010441322810947895, -0.017888594418764114, 0.017741691321134567, -0.04397708550095558, -0.0623747892677784, -0.029303735122084618, -0.01342713087797165, 0.06282525509595871, -0.010834864340722561, 0.01861015520989895, 0.06863437592983246, -0.016614561900496483, 0.0349874421954155, -0.06172674521803856, -0.018823916092514992, -0.007255952339619398, 0.005208803340792656, 0.07308053225278854, -0.023554367944598198, -0.020047692582011223, 0.0597190223634243, 0.004904477391391993, 0.001459733466617763, 0.03344982489943504, -0.03684373199939728, 0.025898797437548637, 0.034113723784685135, -0.04132057726383209, -0.06090940162539482, 0.03085772506892681, -0.0281280018389225, 0.0001756617275532335, -0.023552630096673965, -0.01532093994319439, 0.009214533492922783, 0.028171593323349953, 0.0037939532194286585, -0.059846535325050354, -0.04262440279126167, -0.07473903894424438, 0.00941837951540947, 0.023838883265852928, 0.002568933181464672, -0.008690914139151573, 0.013471773825585842, 0.029154473915696144, -0.01702711172401905, -0.00788106769323349, -0.061234645545482635, -0.06877024471759796, -0.016392366960644722, -0.017321361228823662, -0.029726944863796234, 0.04934534430503845, -0.010200354270637035, -0.06256284564733505, 0.011307219043374062, -0.014007600024342537, 0.016010994091629982, 0.012827171012759209, 0.03523539751768112, -0.007057863753288984, 0.05723986402153969, 0.00030524531030096114, 0.005420070607215166, -0.02486475557088852, -0.03939715772867203, 0.13353551924228668, 0.10031487047672272, 0.05416771396994591, -0.060278329998254776, 0.0359952375292778, 0.03622002899646759, -0.0041437880136072636, 0.004534780979156494, -0.015613178722560406, -0.005154798272997141, -0.01463437732309103, 0.06355791538953781, 0.04165514558553696, 0.023478195071220398, -0.025135168805718422, 0.04961178079247475, -0.005520699545741081, 0.012234877794981003, -0.008307728916406631, 0.019430844113230705, 0.031035933643579483, -0.03416815027594566, 0.0025955946184694767, 0.034169748425483704, -0.0014177130069583654, -0.020556043833494186, -0.03340134397149086, -0.02341662347316742, -0.024563198909163475, -0.015889592468738556, -0.0045657288283109665, 0.023288818076252937, 0.02020241506397724, 0.02934802882373333, -0.003165686037391424, 0.031904011964797974, 0.04133906587958336, -0.03638368099927902, 0.0382336862385273, 0.023318814113736153, 0.011610167101025581, 0.02391507290303707, 0.01929430291056633, 0.005203380715101957, -0.04392834007740021, -0.03518727794289589, -0.009557095356285572, 0.033973079174757004, -0.006400633603334427, -0.07385364919900894, -0.028779160231351852, -0.018768295645713806, 0.01939208246767521, -0.010994679294526577, -0.0295766219496727, 0.03947921097278595, -0.003966451156884432, -0.007959415204823017, 0.03719159960746765, 0.02696235105395317, 0.014465020038187504, -0.0011581962462514639, 0.04970908537507057, 0.022860530763864517, -0.025851579383015633, -0.04096945375204086, -0.04247342050075531, 0.016505034640431404, 0.00805969163775444, 0.02041417732834816, -0.03963766619563103, -0.021058235317468643, 0.0033985585905611515, -0.029381537809967995, -0.011982844211161137, 0.04346439614892006, 0.007939417846500874, -0.023467307910323143, 0.016413724049925804, -0.05880742892622948, -0.031073549762368202, 0.013679885305464268, -0.024489164352416992, -0.01032367255538702, -0.03921600431203842, 0.0045932745561003685, 0.024313198402523994, 0.016614701598882675, 0.016968758776783943, -0.013273161835968494, 0.0017554615624248981, 0.0615365095436573, -0.00009731478348840028, -0.03422307223081589, 0.01710117794573307, -0.01892605610191822, -0.009344358928501606, 0.0053220223635435104, -0.0011031513568013906, 0.05637086555361748, 0.025982648134231567, -0.003216878743842244, -0.009357256814837456, 0.045381806790828705, -0.036778513342142105, -0.001332874409854412, 0.06652841717004776, -0.03803006559610367, -0.00021249291603453457, -0.006237465888261795, 0.007831357419490814, -0.03193070366978645, 0.0004929646383970976, -0.018992941826581955, -0.03334469348192215, -0.020512346178293228, -0.031215850263834, -0.046351995319128036, 0.02439112775027752, -0.0023253289982676506, 0.019473569467663765, -0.024198133498430252, 0.005983310751616955, -0.0401744619011879, -0.022600775584578514, -0.010921958833932877, 0.014345010742545128, 0.01830756850540638, 0.023392556235194206, 0.013720924034714699, -0.009867379441857338, 0.039564166218042374, -0.011629845015704632, 0.015089492313563824, -0.021286828443408012, 0.005707896314561367, 0.007699955720454454, 0.01594696380198002, -0.014111368916928768, -0.012585093267261982, 0.01525453757494688, -0.010335490107536316, -0.0196613110601902, 0.045812442898750305, -0.012841903604567051, 0.014729877933859825, 0.04768673703074455, -0.0003811917267739773, -0.021864503622055054, 0.038925834000110626, -0.01744832471013069, -0.013765097595751286, -0.0033300425857305527, 0.018350724130868912, 0.03527424857020378, -0.019767260178923607, -0.011411313898861408, 0.003947712946683168, 0.013970010913908482, 0.02566804550588131, 0.03672344982624054, -0.019811023026704788, -0.012320061214268208, 0.016670813784003258, -0.016074929386377335, 0.043038610368967056, -0.03599580377340317, -0.008800344541668892, 0.058930471539497375, 0.05478518828749657, -0.06248680502176285, 0.03064228594303131, 0.006136386655271053, 0.005980540532618761, -0.10485988110303879, -0.028245603665709496, -0.023827416822314262, 0.031026579439640045, 0.0216529443860054, -0.04388443008065224, 0.009405368007719517, 0.017169255763292313, -0.0557674802839756, 0.03245264291763306, -0.021652163937687874, 0.020317787304520607, -0.03356620669364929, 0.0017145955935120583, -0.04631475731730461, -0.003937659319490194, 0.01440014224499464, 0.00916542299091816, 0.008477039635181427, 0.010507521219551563, -0.009884740225970745, -0.06063035875558853, -0.03325023502111435, -0.013394064269959927, 0.025503529235720634, -0.043099429458379745, 0.04036415368318558, -0.04958454892039299, -0.03879975154995918, 0.034401390701532364, -0.048547547310590744, 0.015399143099784851, -0.008794408291578293, 0.016100719571113586, 0.02061445638537407, 0.07257283478975296, -0.010897507891058922, 0.013347508385777473, 0.04062555357813835, -0.048374202102422714, 0.01286637969315052, 0.0007797400467097759, -0.013017486780881882, 0.03537936136126518, 0.009259373880922794, -0.01713572070002556, 0.01744859293103218, -0.011189999990165234, 0.004340098239481449, -0.034209903329610825, 0.010371364653110504, -0.007812539115548134, 0.0087733780965209, 0.011921520344913006, -0.0032756782602518797, -0.044805653393268585, -0.003709698561578989, 0.056166164577007294, 0.052158065140247345, -0.03462115675210953, 0.008449897170066833, -0.05375341325998306, -0.02180691622197628, 0.001979174092411995, -0.0066566769964993, -0.006770199164748192, -0.06140457093715668, -0.05398304760456085, 0.002498102840036154, -0.007846028544008732, -0.060084667056798935, 0.04014971852302551, -0.03325267136096954, 0.020330538973212242, -0.028766052797436714, -0.016751762479543686, -0.04066058248281479, -0.009034290909767151, 0.05708251893520355, -0.10813459753990173, 0.03299495205283165, 0.06099323183298111, 0.009429171681404114, -0.03783167898654938, -0.029085516929626465, -0.03604384511709213, 0.034330420196056366, 0.0435141995549202, 0.015058044344186783, 0.04384473338723183, -0.01265407633036375, 0.05258742719888687, 0.02406315691769123, -0.03801128268241882, 0.022906312718987465, -0.005342292599380016, 0.018016906455159187, -0.02325328253209591, -0.015440463088452816, 0.004141726531088352, -0.020828237757086754, 0.024091295897960663, -0.007932809181511402, -0.009719312191009521, 0.013707091100513935, 0.004601438529789448, 0.006072723772376776, -0.020950261503458023, -0.0345921590924263, 0.009494530037045479, 0.022044220939278603, 0.0605834536254406, 0.04383410885930061, -0.007408878766000271, -0.05619536712765694, -0.00007236675446620211, -0.005686789285391569, -0.05039682239294052, 0.021850815042853355, 0.03738419711589813, -0.008839327841997147, -0.07524756342172623, 0.03432973474264145, 0.011349787004292011, 0.00348661164753139, -0.013374571688473225, 0.050273023545742035, 0.05338000878691673, 0.0370887890458107, 0.04053119942545891, 0.017551716417074203, 0.025984162464737892, -0.009624110534787178, 0.02627154439687729, -0.03187568485736847, 0.028846606612205505, 0.01739896833896637, -0.015297004953026772, 0.042588043957948685, -0.02198014222085476, 0.03329881653189659, 0.008013212122023106, 0.009974639862775803, -0.025819264352321625, -0.0050520882941782475, 0.03944553807377815, -0.0006863087182864547, 0.005249364767223597, 0.007611392065882683, -0.019711878150701523, 0.053559351712465286, -0.03080086223781109, 0.0023223382886499166, -0.030302762985229492, -0.008191191591322422, 0.02778165601193905, 0.008927633985877037, -0.005827736109495163, 0.04678131639957428, -0.009090530686080456, 0.0193951316177845, 0.00018631332204677165, -0.028874773532152176, -0.047415029257535934, -0.01662926748394966, 0.04556705802679062, -0.007586711086332798, 0.019268488511443138, -0.03364630416035652, -0.04025664180517197, -0.030304964631795883, -0.060138389468193054, 0.03709839656949043, 0.014718734659254551, 0.02684921585023403, -0.04456421360373497, -0.02223692648112774, -0.019102897495031357, 0.0778018906712532, -0.035843756049871445, -0.05197833478450775, -0.014208128675818443, 0.028994189575314522, -0.008502566255629063, -0.000549218209926039 ]
<p>It is known that odds ratios enjoy a certain symmetry. For example, the odds ratio of outcome $Y$ is the inverse of the odds ratio of outcome $\neg Y$. Risk ratios, on the other hand, do not enjoy this symmetry. However, risk ratios have the property of collapsibility. So adjusting for a covariate that is not a confounder does not change the magnitude of the risk ratio. Consider the more formal definition of collapsibility:</p> <blockquote> <p><em><strong>Definition</em></strong>. Let $g[P(x,y)]$ be any functional that measures the association between $Y$ and $X$ in the joint distribution $P(x,y)$. Then $g$ is collapsibile on a variable $Z$ if $$E_{z}g[P(x,y|z)] = g[P(x,y)]$$</p> </blockquote> <p>So in the case of the risk ratio, $g[P(x,y)]$ would be the risk ratio? What if we don't know $P(x,y)$? A risk ratio is the ratio of two incidence densities which doesn't seem to depend on any probability distribution.</p>
74,261
[ -0.03204459697008133, 0.0026757449377328157, 0.03453046828508377, -0.010204660706222057, 0.03206315636634827, 0.057680338621139526, -0.025234388187527657, -0.013180438429117203, 0.040566232055425644, -0.0260083619505167, 0.04637371003627777, 0.02172393538057804, 0.07377692312002182, 0.05171341076493263, 0.023536749184131622, 0.021990640088915825, -0.011646510101854801, 0.0597965307533741, -0.011991842649877071, 0.014339934103190899, 0.010075489059090614, 0.02597186528146267, -0.006301413755863905, 0.005491579882800579, -0.012363462708890438, 0.026661492884159088, 0.004755218047648668, -0.030017603188753128, 0.002755588386207819, 0.06797099858522415, -0.007617202587425709, -0.047275789082050323, 0.0072751776315271854, 0.03545314818620682, -0.003716025734320283, 0.012568180449306965, -0.025439219549298286, 0.009333601221442223, -0.026392444968223572, 0.021026229485869408, -0.029257213696837425, -0.023142999038100243, 0.01744951121509075, 0.05321454256772995, -0.03311115875840187, 0.024511344730854034, -0.011805761605501175, -0.014415647834539413, -0.015267807990312576, -0.04088761284947395, 0.039969634264707565, -0.029008345678448677, 0.07701391726732254, 0.044950343668460846, -0.036825597286224365, -0.01808531954884529, 0.03779458627104759, 0.059418197721242905, 0.00846486259251833, -0.05015011131763458, -0.028943955898284912, -0.057450875639915466, 0.01980980671942234, 0.0342603474855423, -0.022016940638422966, 0.009365499950945377, -0.0036399196833372116, -0.03710043430328369, 0.015661681070923805, -0.006021115928888321, -0.03752320259809494, 0.04614214971661568, 0.004967161454260349, -0.017383569851517677, 0.008417105302214622, -0.015536610037088394, -0.015149268321692944, 0.02833443507552147, 0.06146677955985069, 0.0033874199725687504, 0.019789347425103188, -0.008478006348013878, 0.017997905611991882, 0.01875576563179493, 0.031743209809064865, 0.0021583540365099907, 0.07545334100723267, -0.020550834015011787, 0.049450017511844635, 0.005462033208459616, -0.012251733802258968, 0.009470327757298946, 0.029844462871551514, -0.041514456272125244, -0.06501719355583191, 0.032379284501075745, -0.005363430827856064, -0.00483567314222455, -0.005120881367474794, 0.006025221664458513, -0.021557409316301346, -0.0333641953766346, -0.004719289485365152, 0.04113036394119263, -0.018634816631674767, -0.0037132594734430313, -0.048515208065509796, -0.015482067130506039, 0.009639861062169075, -0.017817294225096703, 0.02152102068066597, 0.02302372455596924, -0.012168715707957745, -0.009986497461795807, 0.016226859763264656, 0.024373317137360573, -0.03144783899188042, 0.001239872188307345, 0.043979838490486145, 0.050568945705890656, 0.0648403912782669, 0.007265395950525999, 0.03230708837509155, -0.026477301493287086, -0.06047922000288963, 0.021711859852075577, 0.04368164390325546, 0.0013406206853687763, -0.045975618064403534, 0.05827827379107475, -0.004027592018246651, -0.017670083791017532, 0.009346985258162022, 0.01378826703876257, 0.013120603747665882, 0.016438350081443787, -0.05347757413983345, -0.04875585436820984, 0.03518684580922127, 0.034888897091150284, -0.006722776219248772, -0.06115612015128136, -0.0015713059110566974, 0.018324198201298714, 0.06433587521314621, 0.015678999945521355, 0.0818575918674469, -0.010999963618814945, 0.036772798746824265, 0.014622926712036133, -0.02167017012834549, -0.026491763070225716, -0.0032403136137872934, -0.04204021021723747, -0.02706053853034973, -0.08513061702251434, 0.029895389452576637, 0.003561533521860838, -0.01776934787631035, 0.0007830523536540568, 0.05995809659361839, -0.03763950988650322, -0.034399036318063736, -0.02079574391245842, 0.00413481006398797, -0.04722553864121437, 0.05093105137348175, 0.004031328018754721, 0.0009107854566536844, 0.045037511736154556, -0.022824136540293694, 0.04312280938029289, 0.005356911104172468, 0.04559081420302391, 0.03740391880273819, -0.05010225996375084, -0.02994757704436779, -0.006379679776728153, -0.036258354783058167, 0.03181976079940796, -0.0006155972369015217, -0.010029042139649391, -0.021883409470319748, -0.003877299139276147, 0.017651429399847984, 0.01005252543836832, -0.010544870980083942, -0.03130701556801796, 0.06901717185974121, -0.04248036816716194, -0.07609142363071442, -0.0721210166811943, -0.012619227170944214, 0.008080869913101196, -0.05980228632688522, 0.023395953699946404, 0.03463103249669075, 0.006378884892910719, 0.00442240945994854, -0.008508231490850449, 0.020895536988973618, -0.013819222338497639, 0.01766854152083397, -0.019670814275741577, -0.0038804279174655676, 0.029111267998814583, 0.030028387904167175, -0.015425316989421844, 0.06238690763711929, -0.00046669624862261117, -0.06487710773944855, 0.00890333205461502, -0.02008829079568386, -0.013356010429561138, 0.011317200027406216, -0.013148073107004166, 0.0012548933736979961, -0.05026066303253174, -0.019633449614048004, 0.032154008746147156, -0.07201523333787918, 0.023610778152942657, 0.09459614008665085, -0.011454211547970772, 0.009088147431612015, -0.0018238213378936052, 0.02016695775091648, 0.030156299471855164, 0.004739169031381607, -0.009204440750181675, -0.07740684598684311, -0.0018296928610652685, -0.002516609150916338, 0.02462620660662651, -0.038587719202041626, 0.004672221839427948, 0.04343746602535248, 0.007549378555268049, 0.011964431032538414, 0.03794395923614502, 0.004675144795328379, -0.04044212028384209, 0.0025542201474308968, 0.03894786536693573, 0.04001609608530998, -0.0061487602069973946, -0.013054745271801949, -0.003974776715040207, 0.02199731208384037, 0.009345445781946182, -0.03474077582359314, 0.028981594368815422, 0.007981286384165287, 0.013758455403149128, 0.0016732848016545177, 0.006464359816163778, 0.03168712556362152, -0.03482290729880333, 0.024118458852171898, 0.017013538628816605, -0.01232234202325344, 0.0016145086847245693, 0.008426412008702755, -0.02989586628973484, 0.016006747260689735, 0.03246564418077469, -0.09168394654989243, 0.007063420955091715, 0.01616218313574791, -0.015181655995547771, -0.029195155948400497, -0.006034052465111017, -0.023486420512199402, -0.04125099629163742, -0.033353786915540695, -0.006369554903358221, -0.017069369554519653, 0.023444952443242073, -0.00706168869510293, -0.04626385122537613, 0.060040730983018875, -0.006288906559348106, 0.0010887234238907695, 0.004295590333640575, -0.02630520798265934, -0.009539477527141571, -0.043643850833177567, 0.0025742959696799517, -0.0024917421396821737, -0.013149121776223183, 0.010532530024647713, -0.025456301867961884, 0.025845056399703026, -0.03327631577849388, -0.022026704624295235, -0.026631556451320648, 0.03466440364718437, -0.022235818207263947, -0.0348961316049099, 0.0327620804309845, -0.030472859740257263, -0.035403333604335785, 0.009724852629005909, 0.0031611481681466103, -0.008102339692413807, -0.029752515256404877, -0.014692023396492004, 0.016286294907331467, -0.0025880602188408375, -0.020708713680505753, 0.01029930543154478, -0.01797863468527794, -0.03695506975054741, -0.08048549294471741, -0.05464750900864601, 0.0034586077090352774, 0.010412373580038548, 0.0055939070880413055, 0.01868097111582756, -0.021253567188978195, 0.05642108619213104, 0.03758447617292404, 0.008935066871345043, -0.02178768627345562, 0.018743734806776047, -0.014538316056132317, -0.011952077969908714, -0.013167604804039001, 0.034986712038517, 0.031013580039143562, 0.0658719465136528, -0.004714436363428831, 0.03998159244656563, 0.07836159318685532, 0.011235984973609447, -0.01689412258565426, 0.010423599742352962, 0.014444668777287006, 0.004444074351340532, 0.008918947540223598, 0.013098801486194134, 0.0005438061780296266, 0.008940176106989384, 0.043612122535705566, 0.019102469086647034, 0.010228313505649567, -0.07468281686306, 0.004035999532788992, -0.001994475955143571, 0.0290914848446846, 0.007851054891943932, 0.05029108747839928, 0.036645349115133286, -0.01376311294734478, -0.023381995037198067, 0.01610410399734974, 0.036460984498262405, -0.05305229872465134, 0.009979194961488247, 0.019526870921254158, 0.058949798345565796, -0.0323152095079422, -0.0013980978401377797, -0.018457816913723946, 0.002787684090435505, 0.01870201900601387, -0.041323982179164886, -0.0019218922825530171, 0.028856081888079643, 0.04239621013402939, 0.01120278611779213, -0.048391979187726974, -0.049834296107292175, 0.020048735663294792, -0.06008752062916756, 0.020817864686250687, -0.02147907391190529, 0.02959229052066803, 0.05445430427789688, 0.02623680792748928, 0.021073834970593452, -0.02718443237245083, -0.02859511226415634, -0.011461606249213219, -0.08938439190387726, 0.017336618155241013, -0.012605017982423306, 0.02250497415661812, 0.00295921484939754, -0.008240182884037495, 0.03648780286312103, -0.015915166586637497, -0.029526786878705025, -0.03291628882288933, 0.032781146466732025, -0.024671554565429688, 0.021748319268226624, -0.03835951164364815, -0.05573921278119087, 0.014865223318338394, -0.0011629309738054872, 0.03136785700917244, -0.023862501606345177, 0.036689642816782, 0.05680212005972862, 0.013661359436810017, -0.005055414512753487, -0.02735116332769394, -0.0038845909293740988, 0.03833308815956116, 0.04440202936530113, 0.009974468499422073, 0.01549606304615736, -0.008665943518280983, -0.006566305179148912, 0.0069628008641302586, 0.033793799579143524, 0.036259349435567856, -0.02733290009200573, 0.006925136316567659, -0.02617683634161949, -0.04375024512410164, -0.0068072848953306675, 0.0196792371571064, 0.013164812698960304, -0.019298896193504333, 0.08117474615573883, 0.03570343181490898, -0.04210575670003891, 0.006278329994529486, 0.055851295590400696, 0.053872112184762955, -0.01160878874361515, -0.037587326020002365, -0.02224915102124214, -0.017069382593035698, -0.03933396562933922, 0.06087103486061096, 0.020099159330129623, -0.011299421079456806, -0.0003351412306074053, 0.06128093972802162, -0.030544279143214226, -0.0016034406144171953, -0.009166587144136429, 0.02501678839325905, 0.01368700060993433, 0.03535401076078415, -0.016243329271674156, -0.005388223100453615, 0.0522308312356472, 0.046947821974754333, 0.01763571798801422, -0.02446061559021473, -0.04625110328197479, 0.05237485468387604, 0.023688707500696182, 0.043727245181798935, -0.03609175235033035, -0.01508087757974863, -0.01345255970954895, 0.006861608941107988, 0.043471165001392365, -0.029221635311841965, 0.02078198827803135, -0.021065831184387207, -0.0010203648125752807, 0.005264736711978912, -0.04281586408615112, -0.08627381920814514, 0.0240807943046093, 0.005029914900660515, 0.00802047923207283, -0.0024879751726984978, -0.0035832971334457397, -0.03983898088335991, -0.023398755118250847, -0.029606029391288757, 0.051955126225948334, -0.0025507579557597637, -0.009263448417186737, -0.026864880695939064, 0.007189279887825251, 0.005240938160568476, -0.0966988354921341, 0.013202386908233166, 0.005413054022938013, 0.020935121923685074, 0.0458378903567791, 0.01209593378007412, -0.017356026917696, 0.004628864116966724, 0.0069302646443247795, -0.02434859238564968, 0.050329044461250305, -0.006427009589970112, 0.02683609165251255, 0.041970495134592056, 0.03403225913643837, 0.06523943692445755, -0.012388167902827263, 0.025048280134797096, -0.01019300427287817, -0.05343657359480858, 0.02219504863023758, -0.030155381187796593, 0.010588039644062519, -0.021764088422060013, -0.0033256097231060266, -0.0018412744393572211, 0.023320186883211136, 0.0017814768943935633, 0.008768673986196518, -0.010338322259485722, -0.01670517586171627, -0.010844239965081215, 0.0040600975044071674, -0.01726612076163292, -0.02666512504220009, 0.0020973868668079376, 0.026501799002289772, 0.024574637413024902, 0.011779752559959888, 0.0020259954035282135, -0.04870501905679703, 0.017871515825390816, 0.007178361527621746, -0.023670081049203873, 0.006014351733028889, -0.0329587422311306, -0.011571085080504417, -0.005219705402851105, -0.024786772206425667, 0.04053998365998268, -0.012109359726309776, 0.020414303988218307, 0.003245491534471512, -0.03765137121081352, -0.00115727330558002, 0.030901003628969193, 0.032842006534338, 0.011791388504207134, -0.02196248061954975, 0.022446159273386, 0.0016129363793879747, -0.026957359164953232, -0.08100081980228424, -0.011378731578588486, 0.00550999166443944, 0.01605464331805706, -0.0374315120279789, -0.009483261965215206, 0.03187830001115799, -0.013651082292199135, -0.03166532516479492, 0.004622417967766523, 0.058816246688365936, -0.016094259917736053, -0.033201057463884354, -0.015243835747241974, 0.005252219270914793, 0.06414677947759628, -0.03860783576965332, -0.0013042747741565108, 0.051208220422267914, -0.022679463028907776, 0.051428183913230896, -0.017240090295672417, 0.002086321357637644, -0.03284003585577011, -0.004663582891225815, -0.029097435995936394, -0.06817875057458878, 0.021288134157657623, -0.008617354556918144, -0.027430228888988495, 0.03404552489519119, -0.017373569309711456, 0.005513157229870558, -0.0006069483933970332, -0.02625010721385479, -0.023375168442726135, 0.03523761034011841, -0.02226085029542446, 0.01261025108397007, 0.02605651505291462, 0.029886500909924507, 0.040385518223047256, 0.0368988998234272, -0.01934404857456684, 0.02593964710831642, 0.06172802671790123, -0.03070887364447117, -0.0011601726291701198, -0.024699728935956955, -0.003232801565900445, 0.02164348214864731, 0.004436868708580732, -0.004582264926284552, 0.02653679810464382, 0.009335719980299473, -0.05083618685603142, -0.027059845626354218, -0.02837011031806469, 0.03006695955991745, 0.0856417715549469, -0.034161780029535294, 0.03602205216884613, 0.03415435180068016, -0.020881926640868187, -0.001106061739847064, 0.007521764375269413, 0.022647766396403313, -0.008429721929132938, -0.04433067515492439, 0.03565173223614693, -0.023835716769099236, -0.02544151246547699, 0.0797000378370285, 0.05382318049669266, -0.005631024483591318, 0.018428146839141846, -0.00829127337783575, 0.012285375036299229, 0.03760538995265961, -0.012199213728308678, -0.03127291053533554, 0.07671234011650085, -0.015964629128575325, 0.011402374133467674, -0.025378359481692314, -0.04136013612151146, 0.03844468668103218, 0.0028574438765645027, 0.009268217720091343, -0.028424352407455444, -0.014829239808022976, -0.03518407791852951, 0.029011599719524384, 0.03304431214928627, -0.008937260136008263, 0.048335716128349304, -0.01920107752084732, 0.014508278109133244, -0.01460083294659853, 0.008715197443962097, -0.035554468631744385, -0.10679878294467926, 0.014665217138826847, 0.0005817547789774835, -0.027719590812921524, -0.014655262231826782, 0.012280414812266827, -0.04434190317988396, 0.04223053529858589, -0.013062580488622189, -0.009181773290038109, 0.014495516195893288, 0.02554120309650898, -0.02130214124917984, 0.0647006630897522, 0.03965083137154579, 0.02837694250047207, 0.032278336584568024, -0.00552355544641614, 0.14936505258083344, 0.07660696655511856, 0.048429861664772034, -0.012845991179347038, 0.05626662075519562, 0.013874150812625885, -0.017745772376656532, 0.010649370960891247, 0.004597168881446123, -0.0017683162586763501, 0.012143122032284737, 0.027659408748149872, 0.055803101509809494, 0.00929412990808487, -0.05216224864125252, 0.05646968260407448, -0.07484804093837738, 0.008474372327327728, -0.01635061204433441, -0.014867282472550869, 0.015966735780239105, -0.023362629115581512, -0.012605879455804825, -0.019749239087104797, 0.016373535618185997, 0.01993982121348381, -0.014187495224177837, -0.02289726957678795, -0.02528941072523594, 0.027601832523941994, 0.007661961484700441, -0.01822338066995144, 0.05318845808506012, -0.00223514623939991, -0.012233990244567394, 0.01934458687901497, 0.022328780964016914, -0.015931470319628716, -0.018594276160001755, 0.03310530632734299, -0.00843000691384077, 0.008960220031440258, 0.014605165459215641, 0.02840193547308445, -0.03549866005778313, -0.043297212570905685, 0.0019542970694601536, 0.041299473494291306, -0.04502761736512184, 0.03406842425465584, -0.034322142601013184, -0.027491116896271706, 0.026320144534111023, -0.030328793451189995, -0.02157457545399666, -0.014297754503786564, 0.020945362746715546, -0.005423585884273052, -0.016475889831781387, -0.020165875554084778, 0.005935384891927242, -0.04564746469259262, 0.06583088636398315, 0.033047866076231, -0.0405920147895813, -0.01004416961222887, -0.013525121845304966, 0.048296649008989334, -0.014348618686199188, -0.0018011300126090646, -0.010657936334609985, -0.028766170144081116, -0.010476567782461643, -0.03446314111351967, 0.01485504861921072, -0.004672324284911156, 0.0190732441842556, 0.023773470893502235, -0.028549635782837868, -0.01343164499849081, -0.042675912380218506, 0.015929467976093292, -0.020228175446391106, 0.03575848788022995, -0.06423468887805939, 0.017616037279367447, 0.013407090678811073, 0.036064691841602325, -0.0028280161786824465, -0.015078216791152954, -0.03314929082989693, 0.06563856452703476, -0.00545861478894949, -0.0051111988723278046, -0.04600364714860916, -0.036288708448410034, 0.014131397940218449, -0.03349084407091141, 0.03306953236460686, 0.030108556151390076, 0.017330771312117577, 0.058993011713027954, 0.012875385582447052, 0.0027388809248805046, -0.023752499371767044, 0.0132370600476861, 0.03196386992931366, -0.04456188157200813, 0.0032553905621170998, -0.009326133877038956, 0.002339291153475642, -0.0008550528436899185, -0.006608488503843546, 0.0028037363663315773, -0.07177076488733292, 0.0025457299780100584, -0.016349125653505325, -0.047774914652109146, -0.042350489646196365, -0.011468688026070595, 0.012188529595732689, 0.008100658655166626, -0.0638582855463028, -0.025614146143198013, -0.011549757793545723, 0.024607980623841286, -0.023774972185492516, 0.03102799877524376, -0.009484675712883472, 0.010276531800627708, -0.015052059665322304, 0.022517096251249313, 0.011579731479287148, 0.030152568593621254, 0.0027996785938739777, -0.0004839890752919018, -0.016108501702547073, 0.055351898074150085, -0.02235451526939869, -0.03188734129071236, 0.055428240448236465, -0.054923441261053085, -0.00057493761414662, 0.027023540809750557, 0.0029267710633575916, 0.016753310337662697, 0.010864056646823883, 0.039272431284189224, -0.0014180234866216779, -0.01219187956303358, -0.029288120567798615, -0.02814515307545662, -0.01967911794781685, -0.0016462820349261165, 0.00771798100322485, -0.04676275700330734, -0.0011784477392211556, -0.02560168318450451, 0.014572981745004654, 0.010522536933422089, 0.04792824387550354, 0.008739021606743336, 0.018203480169177055, 0.05769307538866997, 0.022455641999840736, -0.0026901732198894024, -0.001155983773060143, 0.015382830053567886, 0.025407887995243073, 0.03347240760922432, 0.019133849069476128, 0.01597769372165203, -0.002954238560050726, 0.03234218433499336, -0.08539295941591263, -0.018054615706205368, 0.027597516775131226, -0.05245951563119888, 0.013566709123551846, -0.06152758747339249, 0.011815979145467281, -0.043976616114377975, -0.04676683247089386, 0.025285590440034866, -0.004675942473113537, -0.032584305852651596, -0.04041685909032822, 0.013672936707735062, -0.01904640905559063, 0.04501662775874138, 0.028705431148409843, 0.014909337274730206, 0.03177362680435181, -0.00723650585860014, -0.011732008308172226, -0.016029125079512596, -0.011819466948509216, -0.021349187940359116, -0.0027043167501688004, -0.07131345570087433, 0.025716891512274742, -0.0020976681262254715, -0.026519054546952248, -0.0013355881674215198, -0.0025458175223320723, -0.005574921146035194, 0.0323336198925972, -0.015367783606052399, 0.007444764953106642, 0.04464661702513695, 0.010446800850331783, 0.0269990935921669, -0.0503075048327446, -0.007837439887225628, 0.0013974953908473253, 0.007136023137718439, -0.01031661406159401, 0.015436197631061077, 0.03219617158174515, -0.023905836045742035, -0.027129165828227997, 0.009009627625346184, -0.004052586853504181, -0.04021865501999855, 0.011190884746611118, -0.027212252840399742, 0.00554704712703824, -0.012970407493412495, 0.08629505336284637, -0.03455211594700813, -0.00982790905982256, 0.054922353476285934, 0.003685551229864359, -0.013364097103476524, -0.015838520601391792, -0.006995172239840031, -0.0483396016061306, 0.013055844232439995, 0.005115441977977753, -0.011119229719042778, -0.030421994626522064, 0.021073589101433754, -0.026051966473460197, -0.005041004624217749, -0.026192007586359978, 0.01737935282289982, -0.025788482278585434, 0.053460344672203064, -0.029925482347607613, 0.002914064796641469, 0.02666238136589527, 0.018443278968334198, 0.019901741296052933, -0.06709127873182297, 0.050563275814056396, 0.014631169848144054, -0.019347013905644417, -0.04744597524404526, 0.004678294528275728, -0.02658117190003395, -0.024566493928432465, 0.0815681740641594, 0.03425021842122078, 0.011125482618808746, -0.010176808573305607, 0.08778472989797592, -0.00788282509893179, -0.022069666534662247, -0.018033763393759727, -0.02070225216448307, -0.019599847495555878, -0.025481708347797394, 0.023885345086455345, -0.01002557948231697, 0.019696304574608803, 0.014543375931680202, -0.053955405950546265, 0.0018411405617371202, 0.016937239095568657, -0.0016619708621874452, 0.0004854986327700317, -0.005311613902449608, -0.03398017957806587, 0.043314091861248016, -0.008833491243422031, 0.004697232972830534, -0.0016747696790844202, -0.014781035482883453, -0.051946233958005905, 0.042128439992666245, -0.022334225475788116, -0.044838450849056244, 0.009037475101649761, 0.007025944069027901, -0.004906291142106056, -0.0003021775046363473, -0.022727297618985176, 0.030938517302274704, -0.06748542189598083, -0.015311919152736664, 0.03520606458187103, 0.02847093529999256, 0.022556478157639503, -0.02465653233230114, 0.009254717268049717, 0.014178115874528885, -0.01586678996682167, 0.010728100314736366, 0.02117602340877056, 0.038190387189388275, -0.007037738338112831, -0.014020442962646484, -0.0003794581862166524, -0.0054207150824368, -0.0004829567624256015, 0.015098332427442074, 0.026426095515489578, -0.026415903121232986, -0.011577294208109379, -0.015593910589814186, 0.01739388518035412, 0.019998567178845406, -0.011014338582754135, 0.015468509867787361, 0.029235461726784706, 0.0019530483987182379, -0.0013579740189015865, -0.02185937389731407, -0.04818325862288475, -0.052503783255815506, 0.01444406807422638, 0.04509309306740761, 0.008335567079484463, 0.007279493380337954, -0.0020119629334658384, -0.01212365459650755, -0.031964678317308426, 0.014683756045997143, -0.0021146477665752172, 0.027479760348796844, 0.02602425031363964, -0.03387441486120224, 0.009178350679576397, -0.022401712834835052, -0.02450859546661377, -0.03202307969331741, 0.0008358439663425088, 0.028581079095602036, 0.03656874597072601, -0.01548714842647314, -0.040963057428598404, 0.005920258816331625, 0.02409541606903076, -0.04701275750994682, -0.04644027352333069, -0.0458986833691597, -0.0007958940113894641, 0.008355076424777508, -0.0065776933915913105 ]
<p>Having recently run an experiment, I have been left with a dataset that I don't quite know how best to handle, I think simply due to the number of independent variables to consider.</p> <h2>Setup</h2> <p>I have implemented 4 new approaches to solve a problem, which I wish to compare to an existing approach and to each other, based on their execution time, which prior to the experiment is expected to be an improvement.</p> <p>To compare these approaches, they are each tested with a set of 6 case studies. Each combination of approach-casestudy is repeated 30 times, to ensure the results are representative. </p> <p>All of the above is repeated for two different libraries which are used as part of the approach.</p> <h2>Results</h2> <p>In total, I am left with a total of 1800 rows (calculated as...</p> <pre><code>= (Approaches * Case Studies * Trials * Libraries) = 5 * 6 * 30 * 2 = 1800 </code></pre> <p>I believe I could validly compare the results of two approaches for a specific library and case study using the non-parametric Wilcoxon rank-sum test. However, I don't know of a testing approach I could use to determine, overall, whether one approach is better than another, or which (for the given case studies and libraries) is 'best'.</p> <p>Is there some approach I could use to validly summarise the results, and therefore conclude to some level of significance which is 'best'?</p> <p>Thanks, and apologies for any missing important details- I will edit whenever necessary!</p>
37,049
[ -0.04524115473031998, -0.017335955053567886, -0.036911625415086746, 0.007633892819285393, 0.03001922369003296, 0.007171430625021458, 0.024834852665662766, -0.03354616463184357, 0.03142467886209488, 0.015621746890246868, 0.022769730538129807, 0.040528491139411926, 0.04923933371901512, -0.018845735117793083, 0.0021175448782742023, -0.005026144441217184, -0.032020293176174164, -0.0022456294391304255, 0.008848723955452442, -0.0009313266491517425, -0.008160760626196861, 0.02371753565967083, 0.011548648588359356, -0.0025161118246614933, -0.011763717979192734, 0.02262246422469616, -0.005486507434397936, -0.0576368011534214, -0.011740580201148987, 0.0010606249561533332, -0.07700492441654205, -0.01099651399999857, 0.0012039500288665295, 0.03487410396337509, 0.025814948603510857, 0.013955934904515743, -0.008725276216864586, -0.04713606461882591, -0.004835763480514288, 0.010604532435536385, -0.008621029555797577, -0.03405776619911194, 0.002704004989936948, 0.010287380777299404, -0.02428485080599785, 0.04394121468067169, -0.018573978915810585, -0.011288548819720745, 0.007896355353295803, -0.04148295149207115, 0.06247580796480179, -0.006368507165461779, 0.027205785736441612, 0.014388037845492363, -0.041098274290561676, 0.0016684518195688725, -0.008014807477593422, 0.018771372735500336, -0.007630267646163702, -0.03624117746949196, -0.027729852125048637, -0.005789273884147406, 0.003047138685360551, 0.008215905167162418, -0.03805369883775711, 0.05547981336712837, -0.007060564123094082, -0.007285078056156635, 0.027449917048215866, -0.011804601177573204, 0.029878145083785057, -0.028828848153352737, 0.06413692235946655, -0.023462630808353424, -0.0030074433889240026, -0.0023634745739400387, 0.005062414798885584, 0.016745904460549355, 0.044157616794109344, 0.04698152095079422, -0.04770790785551071, -0.008088519796729088, 0.00006950054375920445, 0.03698860853910446, 0.03525417670607567, 0.001706603798083961, 0.02239365689456463, -0.026263218373060226, -0.017524197697639465, 0.030441245064139366, 0.011445178650319576, -0.00987021904438734, 0.042832743376493454, 0.04745190963149071, -0.02754541113972664, -0.005603952333331108, 0.006181506440043449, 0.030609862878918648, -0.04009811580181122, -0.0044588432647287846, 0.006788542494177818, -0.03457074612379074, -0.0001727016206132248, 0.05271788686513901, -0.01250501163303852, -0.001303272438235581, -0.01263034250587225, 0.012867270037531853, -0.02602110616862774, -0.01350359246134758, -0.01473529264330864, 0.005143983755260706, 0.022652313113212585, 0.009469945915043354, -0.0033303822856396437, -0.014154421165585518, -0.032820940017700195, -0.015084348618984222, 0.05305824801325798, 0.07330186665058136, 0.059044644236564636, -0.03437962755560875, 0.018976980820298195, -0.047211144119501114, -0.022364715114235878, -0.019095072522759438, -0.01433907262980938, -0.026782969012856483, -0.006929751019924879, 0.054199133068323135, 0.028522498905658722, -0.005367669276893139, 0.03728194534778595, -0.006217011250555515, 0.0216468945145607, -0.019288314506411552, -0.0940321534872055, -0.03704254329204559, 0.03129656985402107, -0.028177432715892792, 0.03775155916810036, -0.026662077754735947, -0.004657942336052656, -0.002193424617871642, 0.06191633641719818, 0.00004046669710078277, 0.013963673263788223, 0.01525370217859745, 0.011013953015208244, -0.008050543256103992, -0.0037832087837159634, -0.025867316871881485, -0.021533610299229622, -0.003500112099573016, -0.001580751151777804, -0.07584743946790695, 0.0139936413615942, 0.015037868171930313, 0.008506234735250473, 0.03875954449176788, 0.03280457481741905, 0.0338623970746994, 0.013644471764564514, -0.022993046790361404, 0.02693021111190319, 0.024424737319350243, 0.050317294895648956, -0.005595674738287926, 0.015942305326461792, 0.017362888902425766, -0.02692754752933979, 0.005533069837838411, 0.04300760477781296, -0.008631899021565914, 0.028474178165197372, -0.016938481479883194, 0.027855761349201202, -0.02349201776087284, 0.026201415807008743, -0.01982375606894493, -0.032016221433877945, -0.04067753627896309, -0.01724408008158207, -0.023488057777285576, 0.06338236480951309, 0.04895993322134018, 0.015837715938687325, -0.03446762636303902, 0.056947946548461914, -0.033183321356773376, -0.057165876030921936, -0.08985301107168198, 0.022878063842654228, 0.016699036583304405, -0.05537803843617439, 0.010402588173747063, -0.0017711102264001966, 0.04170757904648781, 0.005795621778815985, -0.005399611312896013, -0.04812806099653244, -0.012415382079780102, 0.030527865514159203, -0.020235376432538033, 0.005617642309516668, 0.03141304478049278, 0.03672237694263458, -0.061032358556985855, 0.023890774697065353, -0.047175582498311996, -0.05409844592213631, -0.000344189495081082, -0.04701578617095947, -0.010561618953943253, 0.027740774676203728, -0.0059417132288217545, 0.004016226623207331, -0.00405689375475049, 0.002334956545382738, 0.044196054339408875, -0.0593862421810627, 0.09150291979312897, 0.05403248965740204, -0.018281353637576103, 0.011223040521144867, 0.000783787399996072, -0.01724078319966793, 0.0012366310693323612, -0.0028591896407306194, 0.03811822086572647, -0.04638393968343735, 0.010483219288289547, 0.04871075972914696, -0.012506522238254547, -0.06319468468427658, -0.01733226329088211, 0.08981743454933167, 0.0075273397378623486, 0.002791342558339238, 0.056348130106925964, 0.023581238463521004, -0.03615446016192436, 0.0401899591088295, 0.07882406562566757, 0.034123506397008896, -0.004957300145179033, 0.017410222440958023, -0.008625845424830914, 0.037010107189416885, 0.030397217720746994, 0.005337979644536972, 0.03209875524044037, 0.004128358792513609, -0.00003952520637540147, -0.03277863189578056, -0.0461861789226532, 0.04940043389797211, -0.015551150776445866, 0.002740586409345269, 0.03283644840121269, -0.024098481982946396, 0.033395860344171524, -0.02580828033387661, -0.02250812016427517, 0.03867843374609947, -0.011724620126187801, -0.051033809781074524, -0.023423267528414726, 0.016889123246073723, -0.04550844430923462, 0.015560355968773365, -0.06199081242084503, -0.039911944419145584, -0.06810444593429565, 0.0020000843796879053, 0.019122345373034477, -0.02708783559501171, 0.04014962166547775, -0.015667682513594627, -0.011186696588993073, -0.020919758826494217, -0.022584188729524612, -0.004637745209038258, -0.0030684503726661205, -0.033796072006225586, -0.010987809859216213, -0.014426021836698055, -0.0038063430693000555, 0.03446324169635773, -0.018059244379401207, -0.04957878962159157, 0.048199571669101715, 0.020492101088166237, -0.02763606607913971, -0.00596066378057003, -0.05432484671473503, 0.03268072009086609, -0.014924728311598301, -0.016885779798030853, 0.020928669720888138, -0.007047558669000864, -0.047050658613443375, 0.04965915158390999, 0.004388150293380022, 0.003920622635632753, 0.05531541258096695, -0.0028073303401470184, -0.011245002038776875, 0.01029145997017622, -0.04478868097066879, 0.0006856959080323577, -0.007760654669255018, -0.0269599799066782, -0.06633195281028748, -0.04359845072031021, 0.032749880105257034, 0.0038882773369550705, 0.03378137946128845, 0.00825423188507557, -0.010460318997502327, 0.0736313909292221, 0.0363563634455204, -0.04092051461338997, -0.06023995578289032, -0.03119366243481636, -0.01538208220154047, 0.028098804876208305, 0.03019975684583187, 0.0190130528062582, -0.02970595844089985, 0.004342598840594292, -0.0033956088591367006, 0.026836084201931953, 0.022800812497735023, 0.006588889751583338, 0.020748503506183624, 0.025154033675789833, 0.03812423348426819, -0.05417294427752495, 0.05710846558213234, 0.035513851791620255, -0.038290008902549744, 0.02193763479590416, 0.011324242688715458, -0.018872609362006187, 0.007073617540299892, -0.06074247509241104, 0.009995723143219948, 0.007207172457128763, -0.002297591883689165, -0.05337943881750107, 0.02892160974442959, 0.00172366201877594, -0.030738841742277145, -0.02477412112057209, 0.017362715676426888, 0.001304621808230877, -0.03102760761976242, 0.03446730226278305, 0.023877792060375214, 0.06650534272193909, -0.015453312546014786, -0.0041736108250916, -0.011664859019219875, -0.04390190541744232, 0.02368166483938694, -0.0029985883738845587, -0.010645234026014805, 0.02020919881761074, 0.039548393338918686, 0.0033065469469875097, -0.015120373107492924, -0.0445103645324707, 0.030029062181711197, -0.09610392898321152, 0.02833012118935585, -0.06885890662670135, 0.07584838569164276, 0.005910587962716818, 0.015598566271364689, 0.003517608856782317, -0.007513833697885275, -0.03301244229078293, -0.031567905098199844, -0.04399247094988823, 0.02097986452281475, -0.004754341207444668, -0.0005861560930497944, 0.01793842576444149, -0.015538900159299374, 0.0114881107583642, 0.017225652933120728, 0.01844707317650318, 0.01617133617401123, 0.04888444021344185, -0.030765477567911148, 0.028784863650798798, 0.011581957340240479, -0.002202779520303011, 0.027543311938643456, 0.01141496654599905, 0.008209985680878162, -0.01188951637595892, 0.01849527284502983, 0.016568219289183617, -0.0027786181308329105, -0.027927447110414505, 0.00615496514365077, 0.03388611599802971, -0.003909584134817123, 0.010325703769922256, 0.018153853714466095, 0.037567220628261566, -0.056157492101192474, 0.03843601793050766, -0.012249326333403587, 0.014284640550613403, 0.024021292105317116, -0.010815506801009178, -0.0012767742155119777, -0.0064109936356544495, 0.00896541215479374, 0.0015297068748623133, -0.00014081064728088677, 0.019066782668232918, -0.03569050505757332, 0.01203711424022913, 0.03552035242319107, -0.009979579597711563, -0.00943001452833414, 0.05534368008375168, -0.0010364772751927376, 0.01740683987736702, -0.04734541103243828, -0.044441815465688705, -0.004007832147181034, -0.02598467469215393, 0.05115015059709549, 0.013708303682506084, 0.028860267251729965, -0.009143137373030186, 0.04165015369653702, -0.015662288293242455, -0.04290454089641571, 0.031042952090501785, 0.0200921893119812, 0.059758905321359634, 0.0035378437023609877, -0.016147853806614876, 0.0157668087631464, 0.04435348138213158, 0.042239993810653687, 0.04624774679541588, 0.0031720262486487627, -0.07560966163873672, 0.004520586226135492, 0.07945910096168518, 0.03733960911631584, -0.03895153850317001, -0.008130487985908985, 0.01263729203492403, 0.003222228027880192, 0.021908922120928764, -0.024739805608987808, 0.04057084023952484, 0.013173193670809269, -0.00036726079997606575, -0.05555790290236473, -0.03017198108136654, -0.03638782724738121, -0.006950732320547104, -0.05161025747656822, 0.00935230404138565, -0.02177707478404045, -0.029983768239617348, -0.018949272111058235, 0.014615911990404129, -0.007753229700028896, 0.02220745012164116, -0.027078283950686455, -0.011883171275258064, 0.016658637672662735, 0.01749633066356182, -0.031816236674785614, -0.07193555682897568, 0.04013869911432266, 0.016911959275603294, 0.0013396390713751316, 0.04038146138191223, -0.025016391649842262, -0.030379293486475945, 0.03089815005660057, 0.010372260585427284, -0.046409059315919876, -0.01277568843215704, -0.02243839018046856, -0.01897907815873623, 0.050166089087724686, 0.015224707312881947, 0.0398438423871994, -0.0019726462196558714, 0.002048416528850794, -0.009481985121965408, -0.00421123718842864, -0.023065192624926567, -0.05924007296562195, -0.017593510448932648, -0.049568090587854385, -0.011281098239123821, -0.029837435111403465, 0.005756927654147148, -0.026817740872502327, 0.07146167010068893, -0.024168673902750015, 0.027302199974656105, 0.02219165302813053, 0.015044496394693851, 0.005623179953545332, -0.016134601086378098, 0.00013763029710389674, 0.0023180213756859303, 0.023263027891516685, -0.006342619191855192, 0.0071856798604130745, -0.018814241513609886, -0.013310901820659637, 0.021807562559843063, -0.024474872276186943, 0.01742103137075901, -0.014248126186430454, 0.004297671373933554, 0.02316981367766857, -0.003452869364991784, 0.01682119630277157, 0.006480185780674219, 0.02968151681125164, 0.02763134054839611, -0.02886825241148472, -0.004769480787217617, 0.027958717197179794, 0.003813293529674411, 0.02366042695939541, -0.0472051165997982, 0.023016223683953285, -0.01282026618719101, -0.02327246218919754, -0.0747029185295105, -0.046442579478025436, 0.01619221456348896, 0.038310106843709946, -0.013520325534045696, -0.05465023219585419, 0.011025927029550076, -0.010382488369941711, 0.016470393165946007, -0.0022725078742951155, 0.04813339188694954, -0.04484156146645546, -0.006783482618629932, -0.00141216313932091, 0.03662709891796112, 0.043725088238716125, -0.004060990177094936, -0.006867589894682169, 0.0004132996837142855, -0.011800384148955345, -0.02552858367562294, -0.015207801945507526, 0.013782637193799019, -0.04045410081744194, -0.010145601816475391, -0.06686665117740631, 0.011074887588620186, 0.07080163806676865, 0.0067998734302818775, 0.009515183046460152, 0.02622140571475029, -0.019177116453647614, 0.0038386948872357607, -0.0414104200899601, -0.0026050624437630177, 0.001305841258727014, 0.018753843382000923, 0.0026491808239370584, 0.011785379610955715, -0.028425127267837524, -0.021737627685070038, -0.006899900734424591, 0.027023252099752426, -0.03348247706890106, 0.006538738962262869, 0.05272682383656502, 0.009324516169726849, -0.0006315538776107132, 0.0004417309246491641, -0.04151829332113266, 0.024732118472456932, -0.005969392601400614, 0.02813369780778885, -0.01216429565101862, 0.012899591587483883, -0.010950705967843533, -0.015216514468193054, -0.016901524737477303, -0.02543564699590206, 0.08348666876554489, -0.02036435715854168, 0.03501294553279877, 0.10773850977420807, 0.011119608767330647, -0.005271150264889002, -0.031816598027944565, 0.0016584364930167794, 0.017120594158768654, 0.03461884334683418, 0.09812550246715546, -0.0016189927700906992, -0.042365480214357376, 0.0782550573348999, 0.019183997064828873, 0.042648158967494965, 0.03948262333869934, 0.02779485285282135, -0.004469374194741249, 0.01783973164856434, -0.0400688461959362, -0.030104050412774086, 0.002623227657750249, -0.07339205592870712, 0.015003836713731289, -0.046921662986278534, -0.012332811020314693, 0.02070719748735428, 0.05744755640625954, -0.0032309861853718758, -0.033545516431331635, -0.026308361440896988, -0.07254861295223236, -0.0068789031356573105, -0.007708595134317875, -0.0012072178069502115, 0.032617684453725815, 0.01882944256067276, 0.03236043080687523, 0.005392085760831833, 0.04543572664260864, -0.03990704566240311, -0.04099027067422867, -0.0451054684817791, 0.018680797889828682, -0.03166952356696129, 0.035305608063936234, 0.0050783525221049786, -0.0027317237108945847, 0.015736181288957596, -0.03312520310282707, 0.020212925970554352, 0.0075581129640340805, 0.030661625787615776, 0.02770908735692501, 0.07181446999311447, 0.009036015719175339, 0.021782873198390007, -0.01511435303837061, 0.016245944425463676, 0.1274528205394745, 0.08259653300046921, 0.03877919912338257, -0.0686035081744194, 0.009767326526343822, 0.037988465279340744, 0.009709698148071766, -0.022529322654008865, -0.0065963007509708405, 0.023186350241303444, -0.011822276748716831, 0.04478509724140167, 0.04251255467534065, 0.025267114862799644, 0.003756687045097351, 0.06052391603589058, -0.037180934101343155, -0.024408048018813133, 0.01884288154542446, 0.012424344196915627, 0.02020156942307949, -0.045170433819293976, -0.05068431422114372, 0.01996275596320629, 0.028413765132427216, 0.0009003987070173025, 0.0009145492222160101, -0.027437929064035416, -0.019701004028320312, 0.023796597495675087, 0.0293365940451622, 0.014368370175361633, -0.004741440527141094, 0.0027412576600909233, -0.027856171131134033, 0.002154796151444316, 0.003472560318186879, -0.048595279455184937, 0.035152338445186615, 0.07456686347723007, 0.03880971297621727, -0.034505750983953476, 0.0055529456585645676, 0.03430098667740822, -0.0747867152094841, -0.0003223329840693623, -0.053131431341171265, 0.01896653324365616, -0.028027670457959175, -0.014066609553992748, -0.03201151639223099, -0.006778188515454531, 0.0042286887764930725, -0.07044239342212677, -0.03550289571285248, 0.016533659771084785, 0.031522877514362335, 0.00813652016222477, -0.0156730804592371, -0.015230027958750725, 0.009015634655952454, -0.011573942378163338, 0.016688236966729164, 0.04679553955793381, 0.010106476955115795, -0.03960929065942764, -0.016883129253983498, 0.027562936767935753, 0.0028389340732246637, 0.0019733014050871134, 0.0035087778232991695, -0.020972266793251038, 0.005404199473559856, 0.019309422001242638, 0.03622964769601822, 0.01687670685350895, 0.034484632313251495, -0.028144940733909607, -0.0032089264132082462, -0.034134261310100555, -0.041498735547065735, -0.0030242090579122305, 0.001992530655115843, 0.01722625270485878, -0.005102523136883974, 0.001756274956278503, 0.021654650568962097, 0.025127535685896873, 0.05784839391708374, 0.04282914102077484, -0.004190312698483467, 0.06450200080871582, 0.010229435749351978, -0.04863610118627548, -0.030528629198670387, -0.027387958019971848, -0.016482729464769363, -0.01364715676754713, -0.02077835611999035, 0.07600057870149612, 0.0035073852632194757, -0.013410470448434353, 0.005110546015202999, 0.006877456791698933, -0.0010962237138301134, 0.01184583269059658, 0.00811582151800394, -0.053153760731220245, -0.028895223513245583, -0.030385371297597885, 0.0033871836494654417, -0.021863527595996857, -0.033760540187358856, -0.010680003091692924, -0.026738863438367844, 0.006708898581564426, -0.0333404466509819, -0.01991967484354973, 0.018981311470270157, -0.011768435128033161, 0.01328993123024702, -0.012095409445464611, 0.018916994333267212, -0.03913241624832153, -0.029161887243390083, -0.03753932937979698, 0.019297055900096893, -0.007826877757906914, 0.015006731264293194, -0.019237041473388672, -0.012384927831590176, 0.0144615164026618, 0.031691305339336395, -0.010111208073794842, -0.012876823544502258, -0.03728175535798073, -0.0017166764009743929, 0.026621578261256218, -0.025606326758861542, -0.0031183373648673296, 0.030896753072738647, -0.05957232415676117, -0.03222917392849922, 0.007956704124808311, -0.02157779410481453, 0.03918316587805748, -0.000680458964779973, 0.004032711498439312, 0.007624581456184387, 0.055249445140361786, -0.03787104785442352, -0.036416199058294296, 0.0160212405025959, 0.011018398217856884, 0.01682133972644806, -0.02639956958591938, 0.010233568027615547, -0.027021991088986397, -0.01602209359407425, 0.001527722692117095, 0.04353206977248192, 0.004269306547939777, 0.016572406515479088, 0.034999385476112366, 0.012891188263893127, 0.03002474084496498, 0.001691209152340889, -0.03591075539588928, 0.05069524794816971, 0.06196685880422592, -0.03741981461644173, 0.027839509770274162, -0.05071599408984184, 0.02433071844279766, -0.04152921587228775, 0.0023954343050718307, -0.024884013459086418, 0.008613631129264832, -0.009000752121210098, -0.05480111017823219, 0.02650170959532261, 0.05067687854170799, -0.034431543201208115, 0.05671512708067894, -0.003604494733735919, -0.0010667676106095314, -0.019281215965747833, 0.04647888243198395, -0.007181414868682623, 0.005473045166581869, 0.04184708744287491, 0.01436223741620779, 0.04467260465025902, 0.0360935777425766, 0.03063361532986164, -0.01740904338657856, -0.020617511123418808, 0.0010623977286741138, 0.011762553825974464, -0.06574257463216782, 0.013592871837317944, -0.020046992227435112, -0.046981409192085266, 0.028442231938242912, -0.024810176342725754, 0.03968555107712746, 0.01246232446283102, 0.024294830858707428, -0.01370144635438919, 0.029703211039304733, 0.014247736893594265, -0.01955314166843891, -0.016491688787937164, -0.047789059579372406, 0.013604605570435524, 0.03668610379099846, -0.028169870376586914, 0.0413910336792469, 0.06502941995859146, -0.0025407590437680483, -0.042477335780858994, 0.0067125605419278145, -0.024802491068840027, -0.02437717840075493, -0.017342982813715935, 0.018675053492188454, 0.05824306234717369, -0.014934993349015713, -0.007411835715174675, -0.03704128414392471, -0.0027577669825404882, 0.03512010723352432, 0.029749665409326553, -0.01722898706793785, 0.027272194623947144, -0.01637321338057518, -0.004089754074811935, -0.044864755123853683, -0.0027409333270043135, 0.029329990968108177, -0.04930383712053299, -0.03157583251595497, 0.003336173016577959, 0.00871940329670906, -0.03134746477007866, -0.02469613403081894, -0.0003754790814127773, 0.025072168558835983, -0.04721108824014664, 0.016697121784090996, 0.041976138949394226, 0.005145009607076645, 0.013027457520365715, -0.07694239169359207, 0.070614755153656, 0.03432341292500496, -0.006904032547026873, -0.024744495749473572, -0.03654014691710472, -0.02795996330678463, 0.007090980652719736, 0.07037012279033661, 0.014340214431285858, 0.0024939039722085, -0.041411735117435455, 0.0028751848731189966, -0.022061403840780258, -0.06022185459733009, 0.027058107778429985, -0.021539079025387764, -0.01739710569381714, -0.02221301756799221, -0.017381807789206505, 0.02951168455183506, -0.012787820771336555, 0.02059427835047245, -0.014604847878217697, -0.005631196312606335, -0.008975338190793991, -0.005162151530385017, 0.04140975698828697, 0.002547582145780325, -0.028168650344014168, 0.03624355420470238, 0.019359244033694267, 0.030704306438565254, 0.03002157062292099, -0.01637163758277893, -0.039030637592077255, 0.08390243351459503, -0.013961194083094597, -0.010021433234214783, 0.0072839511558413506, -0.017705518752336502, 0.006670128554105759, -0.05270829051733017, 0.013646306470036507, 0.004982695449143648, -0.03881848230957985, 0.03813464939594269, 0.021496016532182693, -0.0034182420931756496, 0.015390802174806595, -0.021526912227272987, 0.01872461847960949, 0.03213852271437645, 0.004748108331114054, -0.00817430205643177, -0.0016908437246456742, 0.001580578275024891, 0.04137691855430603, -0.027158686891198158, 0.0465480275452137, -0.032229043543338776, 0.053772058337926865, -0.01860235445201397, 0.022459276020526886, -0.025978732854127884, -0.024465087801218033, 0.006069370545446873, -0.010281357914209366, -0.02134283259510994, 0.006290070246905088, -0.005950209219008684, 0.04054655134677887, -0.04032089561223984, 0.02629917487502098, -0.047133367508649826, -0.004218284972012043, -0.006491786800324917, 0.008437022566795349, -0.03492036834359169, 0.048871468752622604, -0.042743973433971405, 0.013282203115522861, 0.0107515137642622, -0.0382617749273777, 0.02866273559629917, -0.009546373970806599, 0.04864010214805603, -0.05005835369229317, -0.009139479137957096, -0.017765354365110397, -0.024275610223412514, -0.022168127819895744, -0.02496412768959999, 0.022199219092726707, 0.024249713867902756, 0.04126059636473656, -0.03924607113003731, -0.03265586867928505, 0.023290961980819702, 0.03141012787818909, -0.028594568371772766, -0.016943374648690224, -0.030682498589158058, 0.012146089226007462, 0.020757943391799927, -0.007699028588831425 ]
<p>Suppose I have a python function using scipy that returns the expectation $E\left[ X \right]$ for some data assuming it is gamma distributed:</p> <pre><code>def expectation(data): shape,loc,scale=scipy.stats.gamma.fit(data) expected_value = shape * scale return expected_value </code></pre> <p>(My understanding is that scipy's parameterization of the gamma leaves us with $E\left[ X \right] = shape \cdot scale$.) However, I would like to generalize my code so I can drop in different distributions in place of the gamma -- for example, the log-normal distribution. Is there a way to write that code in a general way? In other words, how do I finish this function:</p> <pre><code>def expectation(data, dist=scipy.stats.gamma): ??? </code></pre> <p>I see a few possible approaches:</p> <ol> <li><p>Use the <code>scipy.stats.*.expect</code> method. Thus far I haven't been able to figure out how to use it. How would I parameterize the method given the <code>shape,loc,scale</code> parameters above?</p></li> <li><p>Use the <code>mean</code> method of a "frozen" random variable object. In scipy-speak, is "mean" equivalent to $E\left[ X \right]$?</p></li> <li><p>Give up on writing general code and just compute $E\left[ X \right]$ directly for each distribution. I don't want to do this if I can avoid it.</p></li> </ol> <p>Additionally, please address whether under your suggested method I would pay any performance penalty, i.e. because it uses a numerical rather than analytical approach to the integral in evaluating the expectation.</p>
74,262
[ -0.045029863715171814, 0.012209588661789894, -0.009216845966875553, -0.019024929031729698, -0.007222216576337814, 0.05703282356262207, -0.035816580057144165, -0.014306722208857536, 0.008519141003489494, -0.036968812346458435, 0.031230898573994637, 0.04350179433822632, 0.06541791558265686, -0.016046874225139618, 0.053775981068611145, -0.022361645475029945, -0.009524312801659107, -0.015240668319165707, -0.02066967263817787, -0.057098403573036194, 0.027613766491413116, 0.021144775673747063, 0.018199456855654716, -0.009152579121291637, -0.014864231459796429, 0.025037074461579323, 0.02895713970065117, -0.029904035851359367, 0.03227745369076729, 0.08512607216835022, -0.060689669102430344, -0.053120117634534836, 0.004619935993105173, 0.009720745496451855, -0.014731235802173615, 0.03140570595860481, -0.028361672535538673, -0.03195175155997276, 0.009451049380004406, 0.010560897178947926, -0.03357771039009094, 0.01791449449956417, 0.017865298315882683, -0.0047491202130913734, 0.04257114976644516, 0.052713681012392044, -0.025455795228481293, -0.005248420871794224, 0.011471075937151909, -0.012832105159759521, 0.07274448871612549, -0.009502185508608818, 0.02981562353670597, 0.033649493008852005, -0.028668858110904694, -0.0038256077095866203, 0.030760232359170914, 0.021268432959914207, -0.01328450720757246, -0.07526151835918427, -0.007679744623601437, -0.04581563174724579, 0.014362085610628128, -0.003564105834811926, 0.024656889960169792, 0.007977940142154694, -0.03188140690326691, -0.0064148749224841595, 0.011925866827368736, -0.0034143507946282625, 0.01335770171135664, 0.030973561108112335, 0.017198842018842697, 0.007848001085221767, 0.025358842685818672, 0.0013826672220602632, -0.0124729685485363, 0.010163647122681141, 0.039861518889665604, 0.027277899906039238, -0.00616454565897584, 0.029273563995957375, 0.020657101646065712, 0.03008926846086979, 0.015909159556031227, 0.01813235878944397, 0.0795467421412468, -0.028836483135819435, 0.02190321311354637, 0.028789490461349487, 0.007232161704450846, 0.021045828238129616, 0.06271447986364365, -0.012285301461815834, -0.03723037615418434, 0.0492544025182724, 0.00014554199879057705, 0.04174959287047386, -0.023704243823885918, -0.019077427685260773, -0.0005822456441819668, -0.03703663498163223, -0.01860596053302288, 0.05567405745387077, 0.0017312626587226987, -0.02527807280421257, -0.04777919873595238, 0.0034175023902207613, -0.00789284985512495, -0.06746263056993484, 0.019039500504732132, 0.022033190354704857, -0.015727628022432327, -0.009245263412594795, 0.025779012590646744, -0.02191842719912529, -0.02329254150390625, -0.010832293890416622, 0.025653814896941185, 0.02174612693488598, 0.035486310720443726, -0.003266884246841073, 0.029180806130170822, -0.005969977006316185, -0.0700632631778717, 0.02074720524251461, 0.030206438153982162, 0.010094991885125637, -0.07821807265281677, -0.0002064437430817634, -0.005005039740353823, -0.003232459770515561, 0.05746874213218689, 0.04155923053622246, 0.0112200528383255, 0.01633274182677269, -0.05522710457444191, -0.08895495533943176, -0.005454948637634516, -0.012733286246657372, 0.004404248669743538, -0.0569864884018898, -0.007234123535454273, 0.02320476807653904, 0.03833521902561188, 0.013683650642633438, -0.004619237035512924, 0.006083678919821978, 0.002505590207874775, -0.027541086077690125, -0.028787825256586075, -0.023201435804367065, -0.03801941126585007, -0.009867077693343163, -0.004585213493555784, -0.06413214653730392, 0.019831227138638496, 0.008718647062778473, -0.03946810960769653, -0.0038987467996776104, 0.03686250373721123, -0.04170221835374832, -0.018065989017486572, -0.018321920186281204, 0.014049074612557888, -0.05223310738801956, 0.059509094804525375, 0.02628299966454506, 0.054088469594717026, 0.003941305913031101, 0.003439018502831459, 0.004301480483263731, -0.02717558480799198, 0.004401781130582094, 0.08540329337120056, -0.04929943010210991, 0.007307318039238453, 0.0004344697517808527, 0.04901694133877754, 0.024953478947281837, -0.017476309090852737, -0.028670169413089752, 0.011539174243807793, -0.013263138011097908, -0.012739552184939384, 0.03184977173805237, 0.0420546792447567, 0.009005310013890266, 0.020903661847114563, -0.08724825084209442, -0.051678918302059174, -0.07561521977186203, 0.012370013631880283, -0.01239651907235384, 0.02272380329668522, 0.022221477702260017, -0.0017185099422931671, 0.031466588377952576, 0.026583826169371605, -0.023741045966744423, 0.003271480556577444, -0.00360179808922112, 0.07113224267959595, -0.01593811996281147, 0.00003017847666342277, 0.06525635719299316, 0.05936160683631897, -0.028402136638760567, 0.035675715655088425, -0.00025924775400198996, -0.030988899990916252, 0.009247852489352226, -0.0633421540260315, -0.0008073378121480346, 0.01795181818306446, -0.02601979300379753, 0.009295166470110416, -0.0012675260659307241, -0.0040053511038422585, 0.02264975942671299, -0.05874791368842125, 0.09201758354902267, 0.046016499400138855, 0.012664110399782658, 0.0011742358328774571, 0.03234836459159851, 0.010368512012064457, 0.03695929795503616, -0.029896678403019905, -0.03814836964011192, -0.029928015545010567, -0.03032075986266136, 0.05155716463923454, 0.04126901924610138, -0.03700845316052437, -0.0212220698595047, 0.06233802065253258, -0.02780075930058956, 0.03718925267457962, 0.03968401253223419, -0.03142733871936798, 0.023770155385136604, 0.01434188149869442, 0.020862344652414322, 0.026438051834702492, -0.00805306900292635, -0.006792498752474785, -0.002732733031734824, 0.0010212648194283247, 0.009510444477200508, 0.021501336246728897, 0.019344136118888855, -0.0004293809470254928, -0.0027170428074896336, -0.0006910922820679843, -0.008351504802703857, 0.020926285535097122, -0.009598291479051113, 0.0020174600649625063, -0.011495272628962994, -0.007184700574725866, -0.03539910167455673, -0.05553242191672325, -0.01373978704214096, 0.013508476316928864, 0.041245490312576294, -0.030865876004099846, 0.018354160711169243, 0.008294980973005295, -0.01408323273062706, 0.028496498242020607, -0.006468776147812605, -0.030370283871889114, -0.03383014351129532, 0.06208174303174019, 0.01895514503121376, 0.0029369329567998648, 0.004951746203005314, -0.0323624312877655, -0.021728642284870148, -0.034782201051712036, 0.010078348219394684, 0.016167625784873962, 0.030757810920476913, -0.0373837910592556, 0.001675802981480956, -0.03511812537908554, -0.03481505066156387, 0.00889997836202383, -0.020852016285061836, -0.006142398342490196, 0.025502001866698265, -0.0003242480452172458, -0.05152110755443573, 0.00018103988259099424, 0.0007852650014683604, 0.03287457674741745, -0.010789033025503159, -0.006054372061043978, 0.07257571071386337, -0.010017757304012775, -0.04054496809840202, 0.02860979177057743, -0.02070273458957672, -0.05258219316601753, -0.05041288956999779, -0.03076174668967724, 0.0165735874325037, 0.007513430900871754, 0.029891664162278175, 0.033205579966306686, -0.05362671613693237, 0.00922855082899332, -0.06701460480690002, -0.026602113619446754, 0.008499701507389545, 0.010064583271741867, 0.01888323202729225, -0.0019865534268319607, -0.001870200503617525, 0.06438001990318298, 0.03915612772107124, -0.02891542762517929, -0.030806196853518486, 0.032463785260915756, -0.02330988086760044, -0.008632095530629158, -0.008487775921821594, 0.007625768892467022, -0.03521716222167015, 0.0012251256266608834, 0.016505669802427292, 0.029319554567337036, 0.015617712400853634, 0.0054233744740486145, 0.007911008782684803, -0.012604844756424427, 0.04112054407596588, -0.029384205117821693, 0.04187215492129326, 0.033964987844228745, 0.015365282073616982, 0.0062979282811284065, 0.004297202453017235, -0.00017188485071528703, 0.021762827411293983, -0.020094923675060272, 0.040414292365312576, -0.028232663869857788, 0.011376271024346352, -0.034432895481586456, 0.029227880761027336, 0.005059103015810251, -0.08734128624200821, 0.03182270750403404, 0.04241504892706871, 0.001866555423475802, -0.023041468113660812, -0.0019024042412638664, 0.04325871914625168, 0.08079058676958084, -0.01831291802227497, -0.02455194853246212, -0.02205835096538067, -0.06133291497826576, -0.020500019192695618, -0.011690867133438587, -0.03719897195696831, 0.01999225839972496, 0.05918851122260094, 0.053930241614580154, 0.0015040688449516892, -0.04418625682592392, 0.014532883651554585, -0.07445599138736725, -0.0034333779476583004, -0.008685829117894173, 0.028431890532374382, 0.0640791803598404, 0.01602940261363983, 0.031021153554320335, -0.015975920483469963, 0.01013596449047327, 0.03940880298614502, -0.10057871788740158, 0.033228881657123566, -0.018587641417980194, -0.006462531629949808, -0.03769540414214134, -0.003819464473053813, 0.05198802426457405, -0.005857848562300205, 0.016490956768393517, 0.010232464410364628, 0.0004465388774406165, -0.03170100972056389, -0.009409740567207336, -0.020547663792967796, -0.04481543228030205, -0.02464723028242588, 0.0307761300355196, 0.029233256354928017, -0.0075767431408166885, 0.008806806989014149, 0.01619410514831543, -0.008989823050796986, -0.048280879855155945, -0.012782247737050056, 0.024092793464660645, -0.024867380037903786, 0.025509662926197052, 0.021575430408120155, 0.03239549696445465, -0.03593388572335243, 0.01747996173799038, 0.0029520641546696424, 0.07139154523611069, 0.025693224743008614, -0.047214340418577194, 0.024822402745485306, -0.03875105828046799, 0.008398735895752907, 0.023625817149877548, 0.0060155014507472515, 0.002868065144866705, 0.000924652093090117, 0.028642557561397552, 0.012280663475394249, -0.02246079035103321, 0.024848904460668564, 0.07791260629892349, 0.002286340808495879, -0.024830207228660583, -0.03782534971833229, -0.030907245352864265, -0.001053084502927959, -0.0054077100940048695, 0.017080701887607574, 0.014921816065907478, 0.006161560770124197, 0.039097655564546585, 0.03613664582371712, -0.03716115653514862, -0.01750902831554413, -0.026313085108995438, 0.04401767998933792, 0.040738120675086975, -0.009087484329938889, -0.044981274753808975, 0.013910629786550999, 0.021411903202533722, -0.0015552450204268098, 0.02720092609524727, -0.022935472428798676, -0.09765459597110748, 0.0029764471109956503, 0.05001666024327278, 0.05562702938914299, -0.018606923520565033, -0.032200124114751816, -0.014702826738357544, 0.021182559430599213, 0.04013840854167938, -0.03921586275100708, -0.002753032837063074, -0.052211642265319824, -0.026007801294326782, -0.01720922254025936, -0.0028650967869907618, -0.05202005058526993, 0.05065082013607025, -0.02022799663245678, 0.02262813225388527, -0.03552883490920067, -0.053296469151973724, -0.057336922734975815, 0.008660552091896534, 0.0032514045014977455, 0.07988704741001129, -0.02159232459962368, -0.01252088975161314, 0.001666574040427804, 0.037200864404439926, 0.014402133412659168, -0.04924914985895157, -0.014299211092293262, 0.008055448532104492, 0.004505581688135862, 0.03264996409416199, 0.0056182085536420345, -0.03231784701347351, 0.031246865168213844, -0.020600518211722374, -0.006911924574524164, 0.016446271911263466, -0.01093667559325695, 0.06999212503433228, 0.026689602062106133, 0.022382237017154694, 0.056294284760951996, 0.043284785002470016, -0.03293406590819359, -0.004777718335390091, -0.04756952077150345, -0.008048530668020248, -0.031165532767772675, 0.00277654267847538, -0.06760262697935104, 0.01164925005286932, -0.020704293623566628, 0.006723689381033182, 0.02722860872745514, 0.0207939725369215, 0.0005481790867634118, -0.02740684151649475, 0.0015344959683716297, 0.030681613832712173, -0.018541371449828148, -0.023404942825436592, 0.00678257504478097, 0.016681738197803497, -0.0006510174134746194, -0.024740729480981827, 0.003552040085196495, 0.006277105305343866, 0.007737463340163231, 0.021288661286234856, -0.048044465482234955, 0.004297677427530289, -0.043477583676576614, -0.024280592799186707, 0.03813463822007179, -0.026092873886227608, 0.0010272598592564464, -0.03343798965215683, -0.005119435489177704, 0.003017305163666606, -0.020042408257722855, 0.02644846774637699, -0.006428488530218601, 0.001285566366277635, 0.0023144131992012262, -0.028128454461693764, 0.024446768686175346, -0.006633279379457235, -0.011200793087482452, -0.07689862698316574, -0.025746677070856094, 0.036859769374132156, 0.008601038716733456, -0.020881380885839462, -0.052925173193216324, -0.013564021326601505, -0.02627856656908989, -0.012923777103424072, -0.006335519719868898, 0.07027312368154526, -0.003461511107161641, 0.0025587216950953007, -0.023701712489128113, 0.045191679149866104, 0.0982140377163887, -0.006152527406811714, -0.007745393551886082, 0.07102159410715103, 0.0008294554427266121, -0.009728189557790756, 0.010689043439924717, 0.03487524017691612, -0.03406870737671852, -0.008710930123925209, -0.017750198021531105, 0.019493522122502327, 0.034484587609767914, 0.04085290804505348, -0.03519829362630844, 0.030098922550678253, 0.0276864655315876, 0.01359646301716566, -0.02766549028456211, -0.01871682144701481, -0.0023178423289209604, 0.0368187315762043, 0.01283970382064581, -0.0001333539985353127, -0.030371805652976036, -0.03820459172129631, 0.03915541619062424, 0.01214162539690733, -0.013065713457763195, 0.006686067674309015, 0.060276228934526443, 0.02540825866162777, 0.0020761610940098763, 0.005534142255783081, -0.00805685855448246, 0.03834494203329086, 0.01139709260314703, -0.002154203364625573, 0.020911356434226036, -0.012496563605964184, -0.018138285726308823, -0.040685031563043594, -0.06606359779834747, -0.028911743313074112, 0.04696515202522278, 0.005105635151267052, 0.0669865757226944, 0.031855106353759766, 0.011009464040398598, -0.008106676861643791, -0.019455088302493095, -0.054236121475696564, -0.024714699015021324, 0.0074601867236196995, 0.05492439121007919, 0.024019796401262283, 0.007253746502101421, 0.04165435954928398, 0.01010806579142809, 0.02008403092622757, 0.06628400087356567, -0.008387025445699692, 0.026569418609142303, -0.008306003175675869, -0.047754909843206406, -0.00038030691212043166, 0.023692067712545395, -0.05522162839770317, 0.02033722959458828, -0.0424870066344738, -0.015076279640197754, 0.02887398563325405, 0.046037379652261734, 0.00188772554975003, -0.031040892004966736, 0.018126539885997772, -0.07982111722230911, 0.008566825650632381, 0.04549933597445488, -0.011202294379472733, 0.05403848737478256, -0.004098044708371162, 0.012132076546549797, -0.01845960132777691, 0.03404182568192482, -0.0393783263862133, -0.044295232743024826, -0.0375060997903347, -0.0017221943708136678, -0.02883482165634632, 0.03706149011850357, 0.05230367183685303, 0.02753671631217003, -0.011715861968696117, -0.0407993420958519, 0.05185064300894737, 0.03300159424543381, 0.030707739293575287, -0.03867156431078911, 0.10050350427627563, 0.002065507462248206, -0.04017132893204689, -0.03462100028991699, -0.024535341188311577, 0.11769888550043106, 0.07803796976804733, 0.04186325520277023, -0.06966393440961838, -0.0010526800760999322, -0.018593553453683853, -0.013895642943680286, -0.021447408944368362, -0.009690692648291588, 0.004119888413697481, -0.006744613405317068, 0.012131285853683949, 0.017324073240160942, 0.021514419466257095, 0.0003587696119211614, 0.047534599900245667, -0.037719614803791046, -0.01178608275949955, 0.03232263773679733, 0.026835454627871513, 0.010369621217250824, -0.01669900305569172, -0.0907122939825058, 0.021597115322947502, -0.005500492639839649, 0.020619966089725494, -0.01813902147114277, -0.02683800831437111, -0.023715676739811897, 0.013444316573441029, -0.019814779981970787, 0.013076926581561565, -0.008373675867915154, -0.02472255937755108, 0.011189351789653301, 0.003980349283665419, 0.035004157572984695, -0.006460063625127077, 0.019879799336194992, 0.03396512567996979, 0.030040083453059196, 0.014126937836408615, -0.02483786828815937, 0.04011380672454834, -0.02955794520676136, -0.048137467354536057, -0.029227418825030327, 0.062272947281599045, -0.010494248010218143, -0.013036821037530899, -0.0046445997431874275, -0.005634252447634935, -0.01766079291701317, -0.05251799896359444, 0.023745253682136536, -0.009400030598044395, 0.02735309861600399, 0.0008489679894410074, -0.008758027106523514, 0.00526442751288414, 0.015331470407545567, -0.0026095437351614237, 0.034350086003541946, 0.033752813935279846, -0.03266381099820137, -0.012321115471422672, -0.026922130957245827, 0.0458080880343914, 0.0026748329401016235, -0.01092348899692297, 0.0012307715369388461, -0.02480183355510235, -0.029504626989364624, 0.009244696237146854, 0.01953737996518612, -0.021762637421488762, 0.02639274299144745, -0.035867203027009964, 0.025366416200995445, -0.020908668637275696, -0.02807186171412468, 0.015978163108229637, -0.007311980705708265, -0.017634660005569458, -0.033035457134246826, 0.02004566416144371, 0.0069083101116120815, 0.015753058716654778, 0.007619735784828663, -0.020060567185282707, -0.024999311193823814, 0.06414642930030823, 0.004377854056656361, -0.02412199042737484, -0.04828266054391861, 0.0059895990416407585, -0.030724577605724335, 0.0055123595520854, -0.008610837161540985, 0.04762493446469307, -0.00413106195628643, 0.01608227752149105, -0.017023321241140366, 0.03664524480700493, -0.008121863007545471, 0.008180147036910057, -0.009017339907586575, -0.03716115280985832, -0.017766432836651802, -0.010297656059265137, -0.034440189599990845, -0.03377603366971016, -0.003951803781092167, -0.035921383649110794, -0.051716968417167664, 0.010470693930983543, 0.005129300989210606, -0.05317520722746849, 0.009238861501216888, -0.03138279169797897, 0.0027055912651121616, -0.01835976541042328, 0.01891878992319107, -0.01698206178843975, -0.008345047011971474, -0.023891620337963104, -0.04726450890302658, -0.009260350838303566, 0.011816782876849174, -0.02981598488986492, -0.050002679228782654, 0.02147814817726612, 0.031060902401804924, 0.03009251318871975, -0.008444981649518013, 0.005738138221204281, -0.02494652196764946, 0.007222712971270084, -0.02217091992497444, 0.0008942062268033624, 0.0016584399854764342, -0.019074728712439537, -0.014665760099887848, 0.00903466809540987, -0.011660389602184296, 0.02988661453127861, 0.024584513157606125, -0.03177591785788536, -0.015044363215565681, 0.05879742652177811, -0.007768744602799416, -0.010379243642091751, -0.02240242250263691, -0.022542178630828857, -0.019977807998657227, -0.01133548840880394, 0.004827563650906086, -0.004015660844743252, 0.0039040767587721348, 0.020016591995954514, 0.00008681196050019935, -0.004335699137300253, 0.015370067209005356, 0.03976689651608467, 0.01693376898765564, 0.008274306543171406, -0.0023510612081736326, -0.005947915371507406, 0.026467904448509216, 0.06234933063387871, -0.03460710495710373, 0.014709854498505592, -0.03162415325641632, 0.007263169623911381, -0.07283253967761993, -0.0004563287948258221, 0.018962865695357323, 0.002415197668597102, 0.04156307503581047, -0.055305223912000656, -0.0053649963811039925, -0.0063668168149888515, -0.01402951404452324, -0.014005388133227825, -0.039657868444919586, -0.007596485782414675, -0.027239862829446793, 0.034986842423677444, -0.021564733237028122, 0.00833853054791689, 0.045066606253385544, 0.01941523887217045, 0.01133368257433176, 0.0031866731587797403, 0.030300917103886604, -0.034239500761032104, -0.01363534014672041, 0.031243862584233284, 0.031002122908830643, -0.03127331659197807, 0.053084153681993484, -0.024363040924072266, -0.012274968437850475, 0.03148858621716499, 0.009963165037333965, 0.018989024683833122, 0.015704184770584106, 0.024202076718211174, -0.009000333957374096, 0.06387476623058319, 0.05282558500766754, -0.004520054906606674, -0.01378923375159502, 0.01510679442435503, 0.03584581986069679, 0.015285128727555275, -0.02400493435561657, 0.014733913354575634, 0.00017484958516433835, 0.014164876192808151, -0.022193461656570435, 0.020688073709607124, 0.0016384124755859375, -0.053665291517972946, -0.023007448762655258, -0.015207837335765362, 0.029836568981409073, -0.011660215444862843, 0.027866223827004433, -0.016060685738921165, 0.012602756731212139, 0.037525709718465805, -0.0011606384068727493, 0.018988896161317825, -0.006786732468754053, -0.00951453112065792, -0.026411844417452812, -0.0319698266685009, 0.020016003400087357, -0.012694691307842731, -0.017034277319908142, -0.013310858979821205, 0.03205939009785652, -0.015744507312774658, 0.016411781311035156, -0.0358649305999279, -0.047337450087070465, 0.028197692707180977, -0.012384331785142422, 0.046671923249959946, 0.017127782106399536, 0.004568536300212145, 0.0010423524072393775, -0.06878335773944855, 0.05555078759789467, -0.01704619638621807, -0.007871353067457676, -0.040198564529418945, 0.021508125588297844, -0.0018739913357421756, 0.006393118761479855, 0.07268274575471878, 0.0020188409835100174, -0.01839672029018402, -0.00787333957850933, 0.06588701903820038, 0.040987737476825714, -0.04281339794397354, 0.007824231870472431, -0.03346829116344452, -0.018925003707408905, -0.004295703023672104, -0.009037433192133904, 0.004530770238488913, 0.01636708527803421, 0.03866498917341232, 0.005093932151794434, 0.024561379104852676, 0.012813881039619446, -0.04300687462091446, 0.035045843571424484, 0.010897483676671982, -0.017203982919454575, 0.03644334897398949, -0.007651852443814278, -0.008151466026902199, -0.03571968525648117, 0.0015234471065923572, -0.01529734954237938, 0.0439053550362587, -0.029699772596359253, -0.05623430386185646, -0.032454557716846466, 0.01603948511183262, 0.031597405672073364, -0.07893335819244385, 0.00048239558236673474, 0.025320610031485558, -0.035136669874191284, -0.014247854240238667, -0.00016884486831258982, 0.02110343798995018, 0.04647475853562355, 0.021082047373056412, -0.0012215515598654747, 0.03857775032520294, -0.007818487472832203, -0.03309612348675728, -0.013515236787497997, 0.03921839967370033, 0.003344716737046838, -0.008917717263102531, 0.020231928676366806, -0.0022718124091625214, 0.020588310435414314, -0.00226413132622838, 0.07860356569290161, -0.020687265321612358, -0.01788972318172455, 0.03168348968029022, 0.024819090962409973, -0.0035233590751886368, -0.02684195153415203, -0.0140253696590662, 0.06346115469932556, -0.009626707062125206, -0.013177625834941864, -0.06414142996072769, -0.04216644540429115, -0.03614349290728569, 0.009171274490654469, 0.02760058268904686, 0.01919114775955677, -0.0027134816627949476, 0.018040943890810013, -0.024251235648989677, -0.0038391519337892532, 0.05231417715549469, -0.01829717867076397, 0.005859854631125927, -0.0351991280913353, -0.017375770956277847, -0.01781589910387993, -0.01566080003976822, -0.039981164038181305, -0.02380356192588806, 0.023665718734264374, 0.03755750134587288, 0.04072720929980278, 0.00021927795023657382, 0.009491571225225925, 0.0038130220491439104, 0.05190979689359665, -0.05287530645728111, 0.0024625351652503014, -0.02938145212829113, 0.01883275993168354, 0.029393916949629784, -0.006073593627661467 ]
<p>I'd like to test the hypothesis that there is a monotonic relationship between two variables, without assuming a specific model. What is the most robust (i.e. lowest probability of type-II error) way to do this?</p> <p>I can think of a few options:</p> <ul> <li><p>use a linear model of untransformed data. It'll be robust enough, even if I don't think the true relationship is linear.</p></li> <li><p>look at rank-transformed data, e.g. with Spearman's rank correlation coefficient</p></li> <li><p>use some kind of resampling approach, in which the order of the dependent variable is randomly shuffled. I'm not sure what statistic to compare in this approach.</p></li> </ul> <p>Is there a fairly standard approach to this problem?</p>
48,761
[ -0.04953799769282341, -0.00879483763128519, 0.023271594196558, -0.010468809865415096, 0.02098294533789158, 0.016161620616912842, 0.02159847691655159, 0.002678669523447752, 0.05267701297998428, -0.0268520750105381, 0.03131771460175514, 0.009118487127125263, 0.04690730199217796, 0.013790316879749298, 0.01590152643620968, -0.0042904955334961414, -0.011939402669668198, 0.0003234282194171101, -0.00011302028724458069, 0.025006458163261414, -0.01111927255988121, -0.011162463575601578, -0.009499267674982548, -0.013224832713603973, -0.010902613401412964, 0.040967684239149094, 0.0292434711009264, -0.040580861270427704, -0.03048066422343254, 0.07311581820249557, -0.0634869858622551, -0.023079412057995796, 0.023071354255080223, 0.07750443369150162, 0.02183946780860424, 0.025915516540408134, 0.008108731359243393, -0.009450314566493034, -0.01997552439570427, 0.055010970681905746, -0.03463621065020561, -0.000207595105166547, -0.014202364720404148, 0.018420428037643433, -0.008065230213105679, 0.061557117849588394, 0.008860011585056782, -0.018514418974518776, 0.02152220346033573, -0.02677864208817482, 0.07914557307958603, -0.03811641037464142, 0.021833889186382294, 0.028812775388360023, -0.038010433316230774, -0.025328340008854866, 0.0433814637362957, 0.056600723415613174, 0.006686536129564047, -0.04706549644470215, -0.02274131588637829, -0.02019784413278103, -0.0060821822844445705, 0.007873562164604664, -0.0414503812789917, 0.0391528345644474, 0.012542624026536942, -0.05218912288546562, 0.027313334867358208, -0.007232669275254011, -0.04041373357176781, 0.00009878546552499756, 0.03735107555985451, 0.0016546916449442506, -0.0008334667654708028, -0.029958702623844147, 0.005968828219920397, 0.004208109807223082, 0.06145346909761429, 0.03286612406373024, -0.003580456832423806, 0.015069842338562012, -0.007529388647526503, 0.06120489537715912, 0.007632006891071796, -0.0239824540913105, 0.04455509036779404, 0.006729142274707556, 0.0026536223012953997, 0.017028313130140305, -0.03323551267385483, -0.02954789251089096, 0.02373265102505684, -0.023358894512057304, -0.021992282941937447, -0.0292199719697237, -0.018982909619808197, 0.03734370693564415, -0.015198782086372375, -0.002263472881168127, -0.018365738913416862, 0.009837344288825989, -0.018711863085627556, 0.05370067059993744, 0.013132382184267044, -0.0073439511470496655, 0.0004468765982892364, 0.035665854811668396, -0.01058882474899292, -0.01832156628370285, -0.009618266485631466, 0.025415295735001564, 0.020308008417487144, 0.022545022889971733, 0.02124813012778759, -0.03993814066052437, -0.008203883655369282, -0.012529528699815273, 0.0737348198890686, 0.06425532698631287, 0.041378289461135864, -0.04837106168270111, 0.03763524815440178, -0.010868985205888748, 0.008657464757561684, 0.01130134891718626, 0.02261641062796116, -0.009340964257717133, -0.016699256375432014, 0.05460323393344879, 0.03320740535855293, -0.021870264783501625, 0.04579640179872513, -0.005853474605828524, 0.023872312158346176, 0.025427652522921562, -0.10293036699295044, -0.05885268375277519, 0.042941752821207047, 0.037586260586977005, 0.011191628873348236, -0.04981018230319023, 0.0064849392510950565, 0.046111367642879486, 0.05618186667561531, -0.004651288967579603, 0.028444044291973114, 0.011871405877172947, 0.0013968697749078274, 0.030326727777719498, 0.005525195971131325, -0.0277885589748621, -0.004244942218065262, -0.01563946157693863, 0.0029182718135416508, -0.08690142631530762, 0.0007302985177375376, -0.009046371094882488, -0.0021915773395448923, 0.015097158960998058, 0.06246660277247429, 0.029513971880078316, -0.022042958065867424, -0.02310681901872158, 0.040943458676338196, -0.002167599042877555, 0.05976651981472969, -0.03101518377661705, 0.010670443065464497, -0.03851023316383362, -0.033919237554073334, 0.022560913115739822, 0.031487397849559784, 0.050932686775922775, 0.040469080209732056, -0.03439936414361, 0.006630814168602228, -0.05964475870132446, -0.010399851016700268, 0.006056690122932196, -0.02079610712826252, -0.023103056475520134, -0.043691396713256836, -0.004255740903317928, 0.0100196348503232, 0.036903053522109985, 0.02159823477268219, 0.001891933847218752, 0.04717550054192543, -0.029187610372900963, -0.05204618349671364, -0.04666575416922569, -0.01785690151154995, 0.01392628438770771, -0.028145629912614822, 0.028291448950767517, 0.005735121201723814, 0.022664587944746017, -0.01332448236644268, -0.02116093970835209, -0.004209192469716072, -0.013596665114164352, 0.054157648235559464, -0.04113581031560898, 0.045438382774591446, 0.04084845632314682, 0.06916406750679016, -0.025805437937378883, 0.012903554365038872, -0.029162244871258736, -0.0641571506857872, 0.029534397646784782, -0.02294180728495121, 0.0047691864892840385, -0.013909928500652313, 0.012164322659373283, 0.00910219270735979, -0.01309613324701786, -0.04649558290839195, 0.02843896858394146, -0.0344008132815361, 0.07414907217025757, 0.05522267147898674, 0.03375538811087608, 0.011851766146719456, 0.016335828229784966, 0.03784666210412979, 0.020557718351483345, -0.035554878413677216, 0.006305880844593048, -0.04074588790535927, 0.0003966239164583385, 0.018972471356391907, 0.004105027299374342, -0.034489016979932785, 0.011333249509334564, 0.04951540380716324, 0.03574049100279808, -0.013445553369820118, 0.016152994707226753, -0.028210299089550972, -0.040410567075014114, -0.01580299623310566, -0.009320945478975773, 0.01985730417072773, 0.02217053435742855, 0.01503270585089922, -0.006675766780972481, 0.03338969871401787, -0.004383966792374849, 0.004657664801925421, -0.016737090423703194, 0.02097335271537304, 0.008204747922718525, -0.03829957917332649, -0.023754095658659935, 0.06730183959007263, 0.012541176751255989, 0.0027585274074226618, 0.0375291183590889, -0.019623246043920517, -0.001648508827202022, 0.024590803310275078, -0.010448579676449299, 0.02845221571624279, 0.005288632120937109, -0.03129011020064354, 0.01865466870367527, 0.04592904821038246, -0.056056711822748184, -0.03086298331618309, -0.051974859088659286, -0.05550355836749077, -0.04451362416148186, -0.004252460319548845, 0.019961945712566376, -0.012617462314665318, 0.03597554937005043, -0.016072770580649376, 0.016105296090245247, 0.007128164172172546, -0.032444387674331665, 0.00969453901052475, 0.011275377124547958, -0.04762247949838638, -0.009605803526937962, -0.02270704135298729, 0.0004478693881537765, 0.01729864440858364, 0.013991234824061394, 0.017875703051686287, 0.032162368297576904, 0.02047927863895893, -0.06456877291202545, -0.05312034487724304, -0.027866417542099953, -0.04265888035297394, -0.04827464371919632, -0.0419023260474205, 0.007791930343955755, 0.004659264348447323, -0.05858372151851654, 0.03185972943902016, -0.03532523289322853, -0.018342936411499977, -0.001920725917443633, -0.011930359527468681, 0.009331339038908482, -0.006623981520533562, 0.017627239227294922, 0.0022396703716367483, 0.010724418796598911, 0.01578761637210846, -0.07421285659074783, -0.0672370046377182, 0.01767572946846485, -0.02158820629119873, 0.008593178354203701, 0.030328456312417984, -0.03329073637723923, 0.06367746740579605, 0.008533257059752941, 0.03695197403430939, -0.05552271008491516, -0.028949948027729988, -0.01531758438795805, -0.025179943069815636, 0.02563094161450863, 0.024435343220829964, 0.06961936503648758, 0.00889163464307785, -0.017347972840070724, 0.011803332716226578, 0.016290739178657532, 0.0356622152030468, 0.0026980354450643063, 0.010079462081193924, 0.0049047707580029964, -0.04420265182852745, 0.04414347559213638, 0.03975706174969673, -0.048344168812036514, 0.048470452427864075, 0.01866709254682064, 0.005084081087261438, 0.01898769661784172, -0.0458543598651886, 0.01775137521326542, -0.019288593903183937, 0.005364405922591686, -0.034201428294181824, 0.04040108621120453, 0.033526573330163956, -0.00034524680813774467, 0.0064927623607218266, -0.01286914013326168, 0.03924156725406647, 0.03323299437761307, 0.036158252507448196, 0.0398373045027256, 0.04900689050555229, -0.010291291400790215, 0.0030688035767525434, -0.021943489089608192, -0.02954118326306343, 0.014223085716366768, -0.026095859706401825, -0.024651451036334038, 0.04591485112905502, 0.019785014912486076, 0.014945446513593197, 0.016393564641475677, -0.013161743991076946, -0.001932922168634832, -0.05232982710003853, 0.01521240547299385, -0.06739527732133865, 0.049616340547800064, 0.02216867171227932, 0.03928354009985924, 0.02349822223186493, -0.00823577307164669, 0.006466615479439497, -0.020872119814157486, -0.04349841549992561, 0.05148789659142494, -0.027638908475637436, 0.01451067253947258, 0.03938886895775795, -0.022700494155287743, 0.012674081139266491, -0.04081020504236221, -0.006504843942821026, -0.027415039017796516, 0.06669953465461731, -0.014026068150997162, 0.007585486862808466, -0.03874469920992851, -0.06361508369445801, -0.004285863600671291, 0.0010615220526233315, -0.004436722490936518, -0.04938172549009323, 0.044477298855781555, 0.041637059301137924, 0.012647702358663082, -0.006355160381644964, -0.029619941487908363, 0.018876217305660248, 0.04603220894932747, 0.04007837176322937, -0.017506366595625877, 0.002050484297797084, -0.049587711691856384, 0.04264961928129196, -0.005919527728110552, 0.039136070758104324, 0.021956752985715866, -0.0015795640647411346, 0.010467339307069778, 0.009378503076732159, -0.03528256341814995, -0.031865473836660385, 0.036517880856990814, 0.010497476905584335, 0.0141496192663908, 0.0212210975587368, 0.012884074822068214, -0.04445670172572136, 0.023690592497587204, 0.06632848083972931, 0.022629475221037865, 0.019750725477933884, -0.0394887775182724, -0.052507564425468445, -0.006686188746243715, 0.02297033555805683, 0.014125552959740162, -0.007458433508872986, -0.017825597897171974, -0.016034472733736038, 0.04764857888221741, 0.03978040814399719, -0.032584745436906815, -0.01056257076561451, -0.004685156047344208, 0.04855715110898018, -0.032991357147693634, -0.043784208595752716, 0.023501215502619743, 0.01804380677640438, 0.036234404891729355, 0.06471392512321472, 0.013330262154340744, -0.08803004771471024, -0.003720175940543413, 0.041581448167562485, 0.0309551153331995, -0.049644749611616135, -0.0276144128292799, -0.018439017236232758, -0.021232739090919495, 0.04039585962891579, -0.012750660069286823, 0.007540975697338581, 0.025723161175847054, 0.006278528366237879, -0.05164366587996483, -0.03252356871962547, -0.04572990536689758, 0.004520604852586985, -0.012760180048644543, 0.011954192072153091, -0.01041353028267622, -0.04624155908823013, -0.08343127369880676, 0.002448334125801921, -0.017556576058268547, 0.03851789981126785, -0.040243543684482574, -0.02727700211107731, -0.007902399636805058, -0.012880745343863964, -0.034621160477399826, -0.077124685049057, 0.03362629935145378, -0.010477415286004543, -0.022715633735060692, 0.03301991894841194, -0.003105976851657033, -0.023324711248278618, -0.018055567517876625, -0.03998098894953728, -0.02279258519411087, 0.013747140765190125, -0.0003657718771137297, -0.0024114837870001793, -0.004981172736734152, 0.01305111963301897, 0.057421520352363586, 0.037001390010118484, 0.017047623172402382, -0.03581004962325096, -0.004798345733433962, 0.03437872976064682, -0.06407008320093155, -0.010204506106674671, -0.0454556904733181, -0.028517793864011765, -0.05628082901239395, 0.029766526073217392, 0.02211647294461727, 0.05330093950033188, 0.050735682249069214, 0.019420046359300613, -0.01701490394771099, 0.03303627669811249, -0.025766680017113686, -0.005227603483945131, 0.009509320370852947, 0.025602763518691063, -0.02480653114616871, -0.018415726721286774, 0.030667521059513092, -0.018871750682592392, -0.03732884302735329, -0.013172987848520279, -0.04463260620832443, 0.010437725111842155, -0.011807786300778389, -0.04820127412676811, -0.015736283734440804, -0.021854296326637268, 0.05479826033115387, -0.007043447345495224, -0.001959828892722726, -0.006141010671854019, -0.016202077269554138, -0.0037745628505945206, 0.07001928985118866, 0.024296771734952927, 0.02355746179819107, -0.044565193355083466, 0.024811048060655594, 0.016215987503528595, -0.036621060222387314, -0.027741946280002594, -0.06016246974468231, 0.03363819420337677, 0.015067800879478455, -0.01834319531917572, -0.043789174407720566, 0.02269783616065979, 0.028674086555838585, 0.01203127484768629, -0.024667317047715187, 0.06982190161943436, -0.015120914205908775, -0.013082991354167461, -0.032800231128931046, 0.008668103255331516, 0.032717496156692505, -0.030299602076411247, -0.03364451974630356, 0.007197159342467785, -0.01571195013821125, 0.005584010388702154, -0.03133627399802208, -0.0060928864404559135, -0.05278686434030533, -0.011680361814796925, -0.0592893585562706, -0.03268604725599289, 0.024200184270739555, -0.01856459677219391, -0.022288842126727104, 0.02568921633064747, -0.007831131108105183, 0.010791064240038395, -0.030762873589992523, 0.009596914052963257, -0.012879624031484127, 0.0011817007325589657, 0.005946813616901636, 0.021950123831629753, 0.0023924782872200012, -0.008975053206086159, 0.028035646304488182, 0.032542821019887924, -0.05468728020787239, 0.016749732196331024, 0.05230261757969856, 0.029123950749635696, -0.00044906901894137263, -0.010008841753005981, -0.003527904860675335, 0.014976494014263153, 0.008440939709544182, 0.007566272746771574, -0.017660919576883316, 0.04903094097971916, -0.05421653017401695, -0.03255956992506981, -0.008530855178833008, -0.038819607347249985, 0.08616821467876434, 0.0016183804254978895, 0.04806334152817726, 0.08345503360033035, 0.01858215034008026, 0.010461323894560337, 0.01688346266746521, -0.00040287565207108855, -0.0036358823999762535, 0.006751689128577709, 0.020119942724704742, -0.03660640865564346, 0.01849330961704254, 0.05259951949119568, 0.015538511797785759, 0.0018807650776579976, 0.03328141197562218, 0.027315376326441765, 0.021273713558912277, 0.08706457912921906, -0.03851652890443802, -0.033027756959199905, 0.024424193426966667, -0.0561056062579155, 0.02322688326239586, -0.05881237983703613, -0.010950346477329731, 0.020718788728117943, 0.032983895391225815, 0.01529932115226984, -0.04133390262722969, -0.012497816234827042, -0.0466175340116024, -0.0033671122509986162, 0.009093179367482662, -0.007062016986310482, 0.025169480592012405, 0.013384920544922352, 0.030799617990851402, -0.015557351522147655, 0.03450203314423561, -0.06991995126008987, -0.09419406205415726, -0.0007611768669448793, 0.024747176095843315, -0.02475692704319954, 0.03376266732811928, -0.0191164780408144, -0.029617466032505035, 0.008981850929558277, -0.041321638971567154, -0.016196200624108315, 0.025948254391551018, -0.004280497785657644, -0.016297509893774986, 0.029064679518342018, 0.013046744279563427, -0.014057912863790989, -0.0052117835730314255, -0.025475287809967995, 0.12425553798675537, 0.06218795105814934, 0.05081782117486, -0.04226220026612282, 0.05269705131649971, 0.0014241576427593827, -0.006651114672422409, -0.01679498329758644, 0.009163323789834976, 0.014147532172501087, -0.006325339898467064, 0.04089059308171272, 0.045022763311862946, 0.030606599524617195, 0.0031145934481173754, 0.05639557167887688, -0.03038894757628441, -0.0037193328607827425, -0.013149157166481018, 0.01861456222832203, 0.014172916300594807, -0.0021455653477460146, 0.013238318264484406, 0.015944885089993477, -0.005925822537392378, -0.011799536645412445, -0.02230558730661869, 0.003942881245166063, -0.012268919497728348, 0.005731099285185337, -0.02840096317231655, 0.0055455840192735195, 0.037943024188280106, 0.023393522948026657, 0.015948940068483353, 0.03694433718919754, 0.02934764139354229, -0.033731166273355484, 0.01643906906247139, 0.00940894428640604, -0.026769965887069702, 0.00740135507658124, -0.011744112707674503, -0.009561723098158836, -0.049296893179416656, -0.007964104413986206, -0.04867718741297722, 0.019839586690068245, 0.0007038604817353189, -0.03745882585644722, -0.025165295228362083, 0.020772501826286316, 0.0010391122195869684, -0.019523877650499344, -0.03417918086051941, 0.05426860973238945, 0.033203236758708954, -0.06232704594731331, -0.03548841178417206, -0.0009355804068036377, -0.010936981067061424, -0.02699863165616989, 0.022699790075421333, 0.03394938260316849, -0.037413425743579865, -0.03196067735552788, 0.00006250339356483892, 0.05426352843642235, 0.04325474426150322, -0.005762557499110699, -0.014276150614023209, -0.026376187801361084, -0.020921729505062103, 0.01031071599572897, 0.003483604406937957, 0.010702100582420826, 0.03852083161473274, -0.001893386710435152, -0.016035208478569984, -0.04535069316625595, -0.019067706540226936, 0.014423748478293419, -0.035531263798475266, 0.006477740127593279, -0.059409864246845245, 0.01557615865021944, 0.026264211162924767, 0.023324089124798775, 0.012114751152694225, 0.011876448057591915, 0.027891166508197784, 0.03312902897596359, 0.03379348665475845, -0.07522764801979065, -0.023879870772361755, -0.002584449015557766, -0.022536905482411385, -0.02761221118271351, 0.011237536557018757, 0.036898158490657806, 0.078303761780262, 0.021254466846585274, -0.006906389258801937, -0.016803601756691933, -0.01839672215282917, 0.008786514401435852, 0.07227231562137604, -0.07345717400312424, -0.030373647809028625, -0.006700769532471895, -0.005315030459314585, -0.012677879072725773, -0.007330665364861488, -0.0376754067838192, -0.034593529999256134, -0.01729602925479412, -0.020182909443974495, 0.005341431591659784, -0.005768117029219866, -0.013194973580539227, 0.03605455160140991, -0.011769793927669525, -0.010275310836732388, -0.021244831383228302, -0.03113771602511406, -0.01899225264787674, 0.020685186609625816, -0.019307099282741547, 0.03698043152689934, -0.025981685146689415, 0.014902103692293167, 0.04122838377952576, -0.00007960700168041512, -0.011476111598312855, 0.03080611675977707, 0.04249610751867294, 0.007665114011615515, 0.046906620264053345, -0.00278509221971035, 0.003849983913823962, 0.0378587581217289, -0.023996617645025253, 0.02025231346487999, 0.021270856261253357, 0.003198517020791769, 0.024927757680416107, -0.010634726844727993, -0.012733614072203636, 0.007665264420211315, 0.007767936214804649, -0.023985527455806732, -0.010344099253416061, -0.01946309022605419, -0.01853109337389469, 0.013322069309651852, 0.00470160273835063, -0.010104076936841011, 0.0027145708445459604, -0.009223480708897114, 0.036856718361377716, 0.06013896316289902, 0.0052726916037499905, -0.016983170062303543, 0.03015436790883541, -0.011461361311376095, 0.03010079823434353, 0.013825844042003155, -0.014246854931116104, 0.01806517317891121, 0.05827261880040169, -0.027162956073880196, 0.03445196896791458, -0.0006696372292935848, 0.01105488184839487, -0.07110676169395447, 0.016144823282957077, 0.0018025301396846771, 0.011824941262602806, 0.04629695788025856, -0.07352178543806076, -0.01707369275391102, 0.029485538601875305, -0.04788200184702873, 0.01094688381999731, -0.01195767242461443, -0.00678370101377368, -0.025040576234459877, -0.013671860098838806, -0.02771064080297947, 0.04354448989033699, 0.000806561263743788, 0.0293231513351202, 0.011662487871944904, 0.02689962275326252, -0.01585390232503414, -0.02501600794494152, -0.011905326507985592, 0.0015005847672000527, 0.027478598058223724, -0.06725539267063141, 0.02452247589826584, -0.024539224803447723, -0.006744226906448603, 0.0450703389942646, -0.027150114998221397, 0.06838997453451157, -0.008887577801942825, 0.026786118745803833, -0.016335194930434227, 0.030947702005505562, 0.0003981563204433769, -0.0022975043393671513, -0.024946589022874832, -0.009422735311090946, 0.026619166135787964, 0.062227390706539154, -0.04227543994784355, -0.003644042182713747, 0.015303874388337135, 0.0014796715695410967, -0.012951943092048168, 0.019306518137454987, -0.021365592256188393, 0.03272364288568497, -0.01045430637896061, -0.021691614761948586, -0.022515397518873215, -0.009745229966938496, 0.024319415912032127, -0.025629734620451927, 0.004037153907120228, 0.046726543456315994, 0.02269960381090641, -0.04879556596279144, 0.01108216680586338, -0.018303340300917625, -0.01061161607503891, 0.0018509855726733804, -0.03134208917617798, 0.00478351628407836, -0.0649387314915657, -0.017641959711909294, -0.019878806546330452, -0.006051651667803526, -0.022354591637849808, -0.038325950503349304, 0.0015055506955832243, 0.055521123111248016, -0.012819399125874043, -0.0007054354064166546, 0.02633845806121826, -0.03938983380794525, 0.0335155688226223, -0.06439018249511719, 0.08191735297441483, 0.02639109641313553, 0.028697729110717773, -0.004067208152264357, -0.01401862408965826, -0.02963467501103878, -0.03726976737380028, 0.08446039259433746, 0.02271958440542221, -0.0025978100020438433, -0.001125262351706624, 0.021344058215618134, -0.014199349097907543, -0.01814320869743824, 0.0019869054667651653, 0.008094976656138897, -0.0043958136811852455, 0.03012789413332939, 0.006264412309974432, 0.020255811512470245, -0.010648262687027454, 0.014857216738164425, -0.04972776398062706, 0.027093488723039627, 0.010153333656489849, -0.006469729822129011, 0.022631971165537834, -0.027659256011247635, -0.026395216584205627, 0.05050036683678627, 0.012000429444015026, 0.0043950919061899185, 0.0318448580801487, 0.001800978323444724, -0.06471213698387146, 0.04010704532265663, -0.035691093653440475, -0.021945403888821602, -0.007602805271744728, 0.015144792385399342, -0.01389198750257492, -0.031032003462314606, 0.014425089582800865, -0.009944713674485683, -0.04913529008626938, 0.006062595639377832, 0.012845850549638271, 0.00935868639498949, 0.02077489160001278, 0.014539008028805256, 0.006218773778527975, -0.011796796694397926, -0.011142811737954617, 0.022637536749243736, 0.016374496743083, 0.02125946432352066, 0.0054639712907373905, 0.008758054114878178, 0.0213229451328516, -0.014552528038620949, 0.017936762422323227, -0.024790169671177864, 0.04059573635458946, -0.02457631751894951, -0.018985889852046967, 0.02166411280632019, -0.005125389900058508, 0.025588354095816612, 0.0000775423613958992, 0.004551897756755352, 0.04969574883580208, -0.016000859439373016, -0.002871589967980981, -0.0475689098238945, 0.004635023418813944, -0.025039441883563995, 0.022845963016152382, 0.004854856990277767, -0.02703164890408516, 0.004298067651689053, 0.028550641611218452, -0.03301762416958809, -0.013395347632467747, 0.027308855205774307, 0.011211276054382324, 0.025816014036536217, 0.0007929656421765685, 0.009999788366258144, -0.035246893763542175, -0.0547737218439579, -0.03498368337750435, -0.03549773618578911, 0.04363540560007095, -0.020534025505185127, 0.029095040634274483, -0.021637415513396263, 0.01564251445233822, -0.005517520010471344, 0.04541145637631416, -0.05935562774538994, -0.0278941560536623, -0.07043812423944473, 0.014316635206341743, 0.006281556561589241, -0.008885969407856464 ]
<p>I'm trying to measure the impact that rainfall causes in the number of incoming calls in a insurance-company. I have 4 years of daily data.</p> <p>The plots below shown the correlation plot for each year: <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/KTdSX.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>The same plots as above, but now taken the weekly-mean for each variable: <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/0iZnQ.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>The rainfall has a <strong>yearly</strong> seasonality and the call-center data has a <strong>weekly pattern</strong>. The idea is to come up with a <em>weekly-based model</em>, so that i can measure the impact that a <em>weekly mean rainfall forecast</em> will cause.</p> <p>Plotting the whole dataset, taken weekly-means (image below): <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/CrSb9.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>I'd like some suggestions on how to measure this variable 'impact' - i can try to split the rainfall data into 3 categories (low, normal, high), then build some model.</p> <p>Thanks for any help! (i'm using R for analysis).</p>
37,051
[ -0.06422410905361176, -0.010003670118749142, -0.015311148948967457, 0.02216801419854164, 0.053826943039894104, -0.012424193322658539, -0.0016594651388004422, -0.0353047139942646, 0.03037705458700657, -0.002979439217597246, 0.03790385276079178, 0.06032071262598038, 0.031655557453632355, 0.0404047854244709, -0.004108068533241749, 0.004275210667401552, -0.032403890043497086, 0.0011507668532431126, 0.01926756091415882, 0.004990247078239918, -0.0418936088681221, -0.004734367597848177, 0.0069264634512364864, -0.011335168033838272, -0.02799210511147976, 0.056979015469551086, 0.03471848741173744, -0.015797222033143044, 0.019233962520956993, 0.02236226573586464, -0.042303312569856644, -0.057344090193510056, 0.019589776173233986, 0.038698431104421616, 0.032697275280952454, 0.028907228261232376, -0.02177034132182598, -0.014676323160529137, 0.017054758965969086, 0.031004877761006355, -0.00938495434820652, 0.00978294387459755, 0.030208300799131393, 0.01480015367269516, -0.0489027164876461, -0.00015536071441601962, 0.009110663086175919, -0.016376690939068794, 0.06855029612779617, -0.010733291506767273, 0.08187741786241531, -0.011316315270960331, 0.03945210948586464, 0.007395398803055286, -0.0196915902197361, -0.029698006808757782, 0.05941450595855713, 0.03615623340010643, -0.010558030568063259, -0.038298558443784714, -0.0010708239860832691, -0.020068593323230743, 0.00791995134204626, -0.006681522354483604, -0.029131416231393814, 0.029856767505407333, -0.003666355274617672, -0.015571443364024162, 0.06216967850923538, 0.019124243408441544, -0.014865505509078503, -0.010032527148723602, 0.020101526752114296, 0.023786012083292007, 0.012849527411162853, -0.01325988583266735, 0.014370855875313282, 0.0009520775056444108, 0.040544506162405014, 0.02615881897509098, -0.0252226609736681, 0.030253753066062927, -0.01364608108997345, 0.029017949476838112, 0.012097107246518135, 0.008714920841157436, 0.10741182416677475, -0.003950216341763735, 0.01884373649954796, 0.02010050229728222, 0.007104932330548763, -0.016473202034831047, 0.02605072595179081, 0.0451350212097168, -0.05441819876432419, 0.04497964680194855, -0.029050767421722412, 0.024865124374628067, 0.028508642688393593, 0.018739400431513786, -0.0003505873610265553, -0.04038979485630989, 0.029863746836781502, 0.050937674939632416, -0.009663214907050133, -0.012993546202778816, -0.014478428289294243, -0.011099562048912048, -0.0010116478661075234, -0.016968263313174248, -0.0224020816385746, -0.019038107246160507, 0.0037661143578588963, -0.0342460572719574, 0.03455356881022453, -0.03998345509171486, 0.010023894719779491, 0.017187941819429398, 0.03584757447242737, 0.07418951392173767, 0.04650945961475372, -0.054571762681007385, 0.012249290011823177, -0.043042752891778946, -0.04987696185708046, 0.012289871461689472, -0.0023492814507335424, -0.043768610805273056, 0.01222339179366827, 0.04099000617861748, 0.003811201546341181, 0.004768157843500376, 0.029635442420840263, -0.028396079316735268, 0.03982804715633392, -0.02201811969280243, -0.0690750777721405, -0.013669867999851704, 0.028416818007826805, -0.011477692984044552, 0.009458938613533974, -0.032819777727127075, -0.016928641125559807, 0.007975299842655659, 0.044096335768699646, -0.014355557039380074, 0.04687117040157318, 0.02774101309478283, 0.015603101812303066, 0.021623048931360245, -0.015315011143684387, -0.006625976413488388, -0.014273229986429214, 0.015332127921283245, -0.0314946286380291, -0.0550667829811573, 0.00961084384471178, 0.026024512946605682, 0.005080964881926775, -0.021089864894747734, 0.06150541082024574, 0.030848000198602676, -0.005168258212506771, -0.010924848727881908, 0.03078610450029373, -0.01033908873796463, 0.047784168273210526, -0.005518276244401932, -0.0005697672022506595, 0.0010271912906318903, -0.01098373532295227, 0.013862473890185356, 0.03685910999774933, 0.04862014204263687, 0.052335526794195175, -0.026497773826122284, 0.021865425631403923, -0.028085533529520035, 0.000001499856693953916, -0.027718355879187584, -0.014154971577227116, -0.018813706934452057, -0.04105953127145767, -0.03386347368359566, 0.012250146828591824, 0.02564828097820282, -0.010774698108434677, -0.031922221183776855, 0.03217912092804909, -0.021513735875487328, -0.058659277856349945, -0.03456574305891991, 0.04510306194424629, -0.042422402650117874, -0.009940720163285732, 0.00642195250838995, -0.0164988674223423, 0.04534519836306572, 0.026007607579231262, -0.014293194748461246, -0.017645318061113358, -0.022163931280374527, 0.040441203862428665, -0.004287421237677336, -0.009715850464999676, 0.01177828386425972, 0.05023077130317688, -0.0067865136079490185, -0.02146965079009533, -0.03290524333715439, -0.027384987100958824, -0.004958131816238165, -0.0297902449965477, 0.010246077552437782, -0.0296833086758852, -0.0013132650637999177, 0.025951309129595757, -0.004397063981741667, -0.015567135997116566, 0.018801763653755188, -0.03523768112063408, 0.04844800755381584, 0.0797329768538475, 0.0018387335585430264, 0.012634641490876675, 0.0075200339779257774, 0.02991328202188015, 0.02857251837849617, -0.0173556599766016, 0.007877876982092857, -0.03045875020325184, 0.002688964596018195, 0.03362742066383362, 0.007577709387987852, -0.012077358551323414, -0.024159129709005356, 0.05769766867160797, -0.001567924628034234, 0.020313430577516556, 0.027749449014663696, 0.0386645570397377, 0.03725271299481392, 0.017990903928875923, 0.012799054384231567, -0.00020595946989487857, -0.03955847769975662, 0.03222053125500679, -0.02258285880088806, 0.04772885888814926, -0.012142335064709187, 0.0014193482929840684, 0.06041107699275017, -0.01073677558451891, 0.04030604287981987, -0.026709692552685738, -0.018678782507777214, 0.07456724345684052, -0.04215224087238312, -0.02794608287513256, 0.04579997807741165, 0.033841948956251144, -0.017274782061576843, 0.01566995121538639, -0.00569660821929574, 0.02115187980234623, 0.021206410601735115, -0.01499316468834877, -0.01073489896953106, 0.016720330342650414, -0.036381497979164124, 0.030093878507614136, 0.016646960750222206, -0.0238668080419302, -0.03540154546499252, 0.03629491105675697, 0.04674874246120453, -0.007988587953150272, 0.017372800037264824, -0.0018450217321515083, -0.030862897634506226, 0.012809609062969685, 0.0013558469945564866, -0.016224974766373634, -0.02004173956811428, -0.045089494436979294, -0.02525075152516365, -0.006194191053509712, 0.0025669687893241644, 0.021536506712436676, -0.006713660899549723, -0.032200366258621216, 0.030091386288404465, 0.018590275198221207, -0.004395115189254284, -0.008464690297842026, -0.03337312117218971, 0.03757624328136444, -0.03803802281618118, -0.03782876580953598, 0.04299060255289078, 0.008532674983143806, -0.015789808705449104, -0.06367834657430649, -0.0442129448056221, 0.005663637071847916, -0.019341135397553444, -0.02732553519308567, -0.013933726586401463, 0.009221118874847889, 0.0023939169477671385, -0.008253687061369419, -0.054525356739759445, 0.009446561336517334, -0.06738007068634033, -0.058643635362386703, 0.014645902439951897, -0.025054054334759712, 0.04160803183913231, -0.022980423644185066, -0.010728862136602402, 0.0244014672935009, 0.05061819776892662, -0.028573529794812202, -0.06362510472536087, -0.026443812996149063, -0.022825531661510468, -0.024773908779025078, 0.016527501866221428, 0.037351544946432114, 0.02220243774354458, 0.026048658415675163, 0.017810851335525513, 0.019553104415535927, 0.0105520561337471, 0.027577944099903107, -0.004206537734717131, 0.009774481877684593, -0.036047663539648056, 0.000866802001837641, 0.027503786608576775, 0.03722932189702988, -0.043366484344005585, -0.0033383765257894993, -0.03278017044067383, -0.0004555828927550465, 0.02216593734920025, -0.04310130700469017, -0.01616995595395565, 0.020658932626247406, 0.0010035509476438165, -0.050879497081041336, 0.0050323158502578735, 0.006731695029884577, -0.046888262033462524, -0.03248462453484535, 0.008333721198141575, 0.05798656865954399, 0.008615363389253616, -0.013620439916849136, 0.06843411177396774, 0.03855122998356819, -0.011330118402838707, -0.027342140674591064, -0.026180369779467583, -0.000001580930984346196, 0.043057870119810104, -0.014915084466338158, 0.0005978827830404043, 0.03957875072956085, -0.0053656864911317825, 0.008819816634058952, -0.020584208890795708, -0.0445588156580925, 0.0014746750239282846, -0.026510749012231827, -0.019926130771636963, -0.024876907467842102, 0.04596013203263283, 0.030831295996904373, 0.039899613708257675, 0.023568419739603996, -0.03665803745388985, 0.024196673184633255, -0.029411669820547104, -0.061161693185567856, 0.023766102269291878, 0.015088554471731186, 0.007444501388818026, 0.02370448410511017, -0.0034876232966780663, 0.007345498539507389, -0.05973481386899948, 0.006743416655808687, 0.007671314291656017, 0.022310661152005196, -0.0074699982069432735, -0.019736334681510925, -0.02108016423881054, -0.027769068256020546, -0.015145909041166306, -0.01699669286608696, 0.05909326300024986, 0.015516193583607674, 0.02297106385231018, 0.0116810854524374, 0.02912750653922558, -0.05201511085033417, -0.017341356724500656, -0.01674438826739788, 0.014379269443452358, 0.03208461403846741, 0.03225953131914139, 0.01217308733612299, 0.005219392944127321, 0.023684067651629448, 0.01947011798620224, -0.0036028658505529165, 0.05210885778069496, 0.013416685163974762, -0.03679465502500534, -0.04939029738306999, -0.01076454482972622, 0.003909171558916569, 0.000934337847866118, 0.005162443034350872, -0.00145768653601408, 0.045412760227918625, -0.016382329165935516, -0.04568022862076759, -0.014830218628048897, 0.027294233441352844, 0.010884486138820648, -0.014450372196733952, -0.011994373984634876, -0.0037457228172570467, -0.008930674754083157, -0.0037379427812993526, 0.028162691742181778, 0.031537652015686035, 0.010920241475105286, 0.03105667605996132, 0.06716395169496536, -0.05175192281603813, -0.03938828408718109, 0.005749514326453209, 0.036959823220968246, 0.03525516390800476, -0.015796326100826263, -0.03992471843957901, 0.029887698590755463, 0.054351404309272766, 0.007069725543260574, 0.014187672175467014, 0.0025635850615799427, -0.10781113058328629, -0.015615304931998253, 0.073370061814785, 0.03968255594372749, -0.0017553888028487563, -0.0345766618847847, -0.023202281445264816, -0.007450960110872984, 0.046215496957302094, -0.02800171636044979, -0.020272407680749893, -0.0006451350636780262, 0.04889514297246933, -0.011350891552865505, -0.06131209433078766, -0.06423104554414749, 0.04978771135210991, -0.02022971585392952, 0.017101624980568886, -0.013513530604541302, -0.06590965390205383, -0.035640817135572433, 0.031950414180755615, 0.015692826360464096, 0.02562795951962471, -0.020480206236243248, -0.012120800092816353, 0.0020071198232471943, 0.010117688216269016, 0.01360571663826704, -0.05858331546187401, 0.009106872603297234, 0.006550529506057501, -0.014332424849271774, 0.04831726476550102, -0.02213536947965622, 0.005844540428370237, 0.017608361318707466, 0.038564763963222504, -0.03934863582253456, -0.003365971613675356, -0.05662287026643753, 0.06250332295894623, 0.03973650559782982, 0.00660162977874279, 0.031003642827272415, 0.025087876245379448, 0.011378336697816849, 0.040156006813049316, -0.031097358092665672, 0.027227886021137238, 0.03517375886440277, -0.053897302597761154, -0.036484718322753906, -0.014915741048753262, 0.0019015992293134332, 0.004238294903188944, 0.00854091439396143, 0.027204817160964012, -0.05589466169476509, 0.01672528311610222, -0.027139514684677124, 0.007360364310443401, -0.0074692461639642715, -0.008546390570700169, 0.017355741932988167, 0.021953798830509186, 0.0012840648414567113, -0.016002798452973366, -0.024604499340057373, -0.02912454679608345, 0.02004408836364746, 0.01964809000492096, -0.03771919012069702, 0.012783014215528965, -0.008441353216767311, -0.01376190036535263, 0.02304580993950367, -0.0007723928429186344, 0.029764516279101372, -0.02722577378153801, 0.0426986962556839, 0.00014635399566031992, -0.03605186566710472, 0.015688838437199593, 0.048024289309978485, 0.0002820259833242744, 0.020128348842263222, -0.018496543169021606, 0.028458282351493835, -0.01589152403175831, -0.023645037785172462, -0.04149256646633148, -0.060157857835292816, 0.02889896370470524, 0.0012421883875504136, -0.031195780262351036, -0.029661307111382484, -0.003536864649504423, -0.021748699247837067, -0.016785044223070145, 0.005947702098637819, 0.015520353801548481, -0.046021461486816406, -0.012396132573485374, -0.0017322886269539595, 0.001672700047492981, 0.08943819254636765, -0.028319930657744408, 0.024252431467175484, 0.006633146665990353, -0.03986970707774162, -0.020137222483754158, -0.04601823166012764, -0.007098855450749397, -0.036160778254270554, -0.014222381636500359, -0.012920639477670193, -0.03902942314743996, 0.05149451270699501, -0.05480874329805374, -0.004010023549199104, -0.007194447331130505, 0.020661991089582443, 0.00552202295511961, -0.031323932111263275, -0.02287965454161167, 0.020348837599158287, 0.004253892228007317, -0.044676341116428375, 0.008168982341885567, -0.04350815340876579, 0.006473411340266466, -0.002051175571978092, -0.007384691387414932, -0.03220062702894211, 0.0212212223559618, 0.056020546704530716, 0.010456073097884655, 0.011261318810284138, -0.008093781769275665, -0.017682569101452827, 0.03040316328406334, -0.021905912086367607, -0.027863748371601105, -0.009702053852379322, 0.03134949505329132, -0.009164162911474705, -0.046540889889001846, -0.056627411395311356, -0.021468205377459526, 0.06660616397857666, -0.012815775349736214, 0.06631609052419662, 0.07139408588409424, 0.00803395826369524, -0.010194004513323307, -0.03674425184726715, -0.007685255259275436, -0.0018360624089837074, -0.0036728219129145145, 0.02342265471816063, -0.008219052106142044, 0.023183798417448997, -0.006326012313365936, -0.01691039837896824, 0.0023005313705652952, 0.03842899203300476, -0.0035219830460846424, 0.006398959085345268, 0.03404634818434715, -0.0354030542075634, -0.04183221608400345, -0.0003290178719907999, -0.01979995146393776, 0.0037515845615416765, -0.020778553560376167, -0.016331929713487625, 0.043826375156641006, 0.05235741287469864, -0.03799906373023987, -0.03161396458745003, 0.02750370278954506, -0.057607684284448624, -0.03802565857768059, 0.023890018463134766, -0.01291870977729559, 0.04401314631104469, 0.03432969003915787, 0.06325406581163406, 0.0020763282664120197, 0.02093995176255703, -0.04683757945895195, -0.05421290919184685, 0.00001186731878988212, -0.028907783329486847, -0.026112517341971397, 0.05447192117571831, 0.01008137408643961, -0.009418725036084652, 0.013100044801831245, -0.051958926022052765, 0.0041323453187942505, 0.00878711137920618, 0.030232751742005348, 0.01572614535689354, 0.061803508549928665, 0.01291872002184391, -0.009830356575548649, 0.008303340524435043, -0.012057870626449585, 0.1364401876926422, 0.07552560418844223, 0.03686125949025154, -0.05079502984881401, 0.004494565539062023, 0.031959645450115204, 0.008282038383185863, -0.06652605533599854, 0.005060340277850628, 0.018565190955996513, 0.014304144307971, 0.06521207094192505, 0.04272929206490517, 0.007775409612804651, 0.01064891554415226, 0.0636301264166832, -0.004114044830203056, -0.004001135937869549, -0.0005781547515653074, 0.006876953411847353, -0.005456826649606228, -0.00009674745524534956, -0.06031426414847374, 0.06626102328300476, -0.0042710620909929276, -0.04716840386390686, -0.030946286395192146, 0.007503050845116377, 0.015551610849797726, -0.014723548665642738, -0.008409601636230946, 0.026002895087003708, 0.03310251608490944, 0.01015087403357029, 0.020951148122549057, -0.018418360501527786, 0.051800087094306946, -0.054278742522001266, 0.010057508945465088, 0.013135829009115696, -0.02521044760942459, -0.04902445897459984, -0.015814894810318947, 0.01115439459681511, -0.05504870414733887, -0.0309772826731205, -0.05290590226650238, 0.021327102556824684, 0.023286668583750725, -0.006452823057770729, -0.03240817040205002, 0.0433184839785099, 0.01759416237473488, -0.026407824829220772, -0.007879416458308697, 0.017931880429387093, 0.04346130043268204, -0.026550063863396645, -0.01132554467767477, -0.01386264618486166, -0.005155235528945923, -0.024645453318953514, 0.03379276394844055, 0.030297135934233665, -0.04708011820912361, -0.059122782200574875, -0.05429667979478836, 0.038088176399469376, 0.025234689936041832, -0.023170607164502144, 0.0009456967818550766, -0.019297247752547264, -0.016951581463217735, 0.012353801168501377, -0.009083532728254795, 0.013753926381468773, 0.01523556374013424, 0.018099235370755196, 0.012412779033184052, 0.0031242803670465946, -0.031066875904798508, 0.013931281864643097, 0.00627818563953042, -0.030883271247148514, -0.04250117391347885, -0.015070726163685322, 0.022854873910546303, 0.005771105643361807, 0.06275411695241928, 0.0031491629779338837, -0.0013789989752694964, 0.0628846064209938, 0.04407007619738579, -0.07397499680519104, -0.04299144446849823, 0.003634530119597912, -0.022600246593356133, 0.022210365161299706, 0.018391035497188568, 0.06541735678911209, -0.00034314600634388626, -0.016904182732105255, 0.013823864981532097, 0.03416057303547859, -0.040046848356723785, 0.013284105807542801, 0.026339078322052956, -0.06167414411902428, 0.02501623146235943, -0.04078793525695801, 0.006695915944874287, -0.02177615277469158, -0.0007912028813734651, -0.008609957061707973, -0.01952572911977768, 0.000905583961866796, -0.021696163341403008, -0.04502853751182556, 0.04813041538000107, -0.010225449688732624, 0.04643728956580162, -0.03614402562379837, 0.0021351370960474014, -0.050589073449373245, -0.04244644194841385, -0.01747475378215313, -0.03480654954910278, 0.0014598272973671556, 0.04573659226298332, -0.031183939427137375, -0.021004365757107735, 0.054867710918188095, 0.006861919537186623, 0.026105979457497597, 0.00353961531072855, 0.01148739643394947, -0.008079093880951405, 0.04721962660551071, -0.020655224099755287, 0.0067955502308905125, 0.06990627199411392, -0.044316936284303665, -0.017818840220570564, 0.009310050867497921, -0.024126529693603516, 0.05995528772473335, 0.03017163835465908, 0.000059979491197736934, -0.03155362233519554, 0.06661444902420044, -0.003615864785388112, 0.005862150341272354, -0.03351804241538048, 0.01267020683735609, 0.021151486784219742, -0.0002494499203749001, -0.02328554540872574, 0.008373591117560863, -0.00799499824643135, 0.006973079405725002, 0.07836868613958359, 0.04207521677017212, 0.002625075401738286, 0.0047193896025419235, -0.03863787651062012, -0.026592440903186798, -0.006481875199824572, -0.03244682401418686, 0.05649979040026665, 0.030318474397063255, -0.03685794398188591, 0.026310870423913002, -0.025717517361044884, -0.0027619434986263514, -0.07335905730724335, -0.009221596643328667, 0.006771055981516838, -0.0036994614638388157, 0.037334032356739044, -0.052963193506002426, 0.0003459334548097104, -0.002213945845142007, 0.005111765582114458, 0.010507876053452492, -0.006309918127954006, 0.01636885665357113, -0.0076561239548027515, 0.022416895255446434, -0.020201418548822403, -0.003962962422519922, 0.01449931412935257, 0.03713851794600487, 0.019420476630330086, 0.041494276374578476, 0.00479760579764843, -0.012083835899829865, -0.01684127189218998, -0.008155550807714462, 0.029892953112721443, -0.027144452556967735, 0.06114606186747551, -0.043182071298360825, -0.00887882336974144, 0.043288879096508026, -0.043841537088155746, 0.052832018584012985, 0.018453240394592285, 0.005310643929988146, 0.013223888352513313, 0.04688280075788498, 0.059193942695856094, -0.015211277641355991, 0.01886795274913311, -0.022159678861498833, 0.025931887328624725, 0.012177277356386185, 0.013215535320341587, -0.0076065463945269585, 0.013655395247042179, 0.0019850062672048807, -0.02736586518585682, -0.026982596144080162, -0.030583633109927177, -0.002028442919254303, -0.016675148159265518, 0.0019978538621217012, -0.00085328338900581, -0.01534621138125658, -0.0075965397991240025, -0.014335068874061108, -0.014019628055393696, 0.0671234056353569, 0.0596950426697731, -0.024882353842258453, -0.0011213982943445444, 0.014662893489003181, -0.06368068605661392, -0.03322833031415939, -0.015544573776423931, -0.03188285976648331, -0.04045531153678894, -0.005861984565854073, -0.02145441062748432, 0.014704561792314053, -0.04148849844932556, 0.02221895009279251, -0.04216179996728897, 0.025561776012182236, -0.05073849856853485, -0.007330968510359526, 0.0341096930205822, -0.022403134033083916, 0.042458146810531616, -0.11590444296598434, 0.07423944771289825, 0.040947917848825455, 0.00941131729632616, -0.039039500057697296, -0.051885515451431274, -0.03927582502365112, 0.016724899411201477, 0.0641326978802681, -0.009475908242166042, -0.0021455842070281506, 0.014632807113230228, 0.028584489598870277, 0.027088509872555733, -0.04797980189323425, 0.03168802708387375, -0.017997121438384056, -0.013968834653496742, -0.011052892543375492, -0.022230612114071846, 0.04943642392754555, -0.01701822318136692, -0.01677170768380165, -0.00712974090129137, -0.0011100585106760263, 0.003909076098352671, -0.048431042581796646, 0.008328171446919441, 0.01194742601364851, -0.04800794646143913, 0.049185387790203094, 0.0011231963289901614, -0.023523839190602303, 0.019214333966374397, -0.02180791087448597, -0.015683133155107498, 0.058574654161930084, -0.027332216501235962, 0.006447670049965382, 0.005808437243103981, 0.01433092076331377, 0.0067605203948915005, -0.06922046840190887, -0.00459872605279088, 0.022857071831822395, -0.009901946410536766, -0.013080370612442493, 0.078399159014225, 0.0089063486084342, 0.010230743326246738, 0.04152284935116768, -0.005114874802529812, 0.002978069242089987, -0.000258279440458864, -0.02405925840139389, 0.0058107273653149605, 0.029517192393541336, -0.001988700358197093, -0.019291138276457787, 0.02090454287827015, -0.015806712210178375, 0.0118666747584939, -0.021957919001579285, 0.02233387902379036, -0.037832316011190414, -0.040446702390909195, -0.0035749641247093678, 0.0048255715519189835, 0.018176104873418808, 0.006624165456742048, 0.029267238453030586, 0.041370078921318054, -0.013318613171577454, 0.004638505168259144, -0.039246566593647, -0.0231544878333807, -0.033083125948905945, 0.009287891909480095, 0.02229105867445469, 0.009405788034200668, -0.0016682001296430826, 0.0308085884898901, 0.004993961192667484, -0.0016421630280092359, -0.0007662730058655143, -0.020194705575704575, 0.036449629813432693, -0.02716425061225891, 0.006864693481475115, -0.012615755200386047, -0.0030621427576988935, -0.03861980512738228, -0.024351535364985466, 0.0391366221010685, 0.044233690947294235, -0.002389265689998865, -0.011780958622694016, -0.010790404863655567, -0.004955297335982323, 0.040803033858537674, -0.09677499532699585, -0.0304429791867733, -0.05975053831934929, -0.004412857815623283, 0.015871407464146614, -0.0161034744232893 ]
<p>I'm having difficulty understanding one or two aspects of the cluster package. I'm following the example from <a href="http://www.statmethods.net/advstats/cluster.html">Quick-R</a> closely, but don't understand one or two aspects of the analysis. I've included the code that I am using for this particular example.</p> <pre><code>## Libraries library(stats) library(fpc) ## Data mydata = structure(list(a = c(461.4210925, 1549.524107, 936.42856, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 131.4349206, 0, 762.6110846, 3837.850406), b = c(19578.64174, 2233.308842, 4714.514274, 0, 2760.510002, 1225.392118, 3706.428246, 2693.353714, 2674.126613, 592.7384164, 1820.976961, 1318.654162, 1075.854792, 1211.248996, 1851.363623, 3245.540062, 1711.817955, 2127.285272, 2186.671242 ), c = c(1101.899095, 3.166506463, 0, 0, 0, 1130.890295, 0, 654.5054857, 100.9491289, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 789.091922, 0, 0, 0, 0), d = c(33184.53871, 11777.47447, 15961.71874, 10951.32402, 12840.14983, 13305.26424, 12193.16597, 14873.26461, 11129.10269, 11642.93146, 9684.238583, 15946.48195, 11025.08607, 11686.32213, 10608.82649, 8635.844964, 10837.96219, 10772.53223, 14844.76478), e = c(13252.50358, 2509.5037, 1418.364947, 2217.952853, 166.92007, 3585.488983, 1776.410835, 3445.14319, 1675.722506, 1902.396338, 945.5376228, 1205.456943, 2048.880329, 2883.497101, 1253.020175, 1507.442736, 0, 1686.548559, 5662.704559), f = c(44.24828759, 0, 485.9617601, 372.108855, 0, 509.4916263, 0, 0, 0, 212.9541122, 80.62920455, 0, 0, 30.16525587, 135.0501384, 68.38023073, 0, 21.9317122, 65.09052886), g = c(415.8909649, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 637.2629479, 0, 0, 0), h = c(583.2213618, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0), i = c(68206.47387, 18072.97762, 23516.98828, 13541.38572, 15767.5799, 19756.52726, 17676.00505, 21666.267, 15579.90094, 14351.02033, 12531.38237, 18470.59306, 14149.82119, 15811.23348, 14637.35235, 13588.64291, 12549.78014, 15370.90886, 26597.08152)), .Names = c("a", "b", "c", "d", "e", "f", "g", "h", "i"), row.names = c(NA, -19L), class = "data.frame") </code></pre> <p>Then I standardize the variables:</p> <pre><code># standardize variables mydata &lt;- scale(mydata) ## K-means Clustering # Determine number of clusters wss &lt;- (nrow(mydata)-1)*sum(apply(mydata,2,var)) for (i in 2:15) wss[i] &lt;- sum(kmeans(mydata, centers=i)$withinss) # Q1 plot(1:15, wss, type="b", xlab="Number of Clusters", ylab="Within groups sum of squares") # K-Means Cluster Analysis fit &lt;- kmeans(mydata, 3) # number of values in cluster solution # get cluster means aggregate(mydata,by=list(fit$cluster),FUN=mean) # append cluster assignment mydata &lt;- data.frame(mydata, cluster = fit$cluster) # Cluster Plot against 1st 2 principal components - vary parameters for most readable graph clusplot(mydata, fit$cluster, color=TRUE, shade=TRUE, labels=0, lines=0) # Q2 # Centroid Plot against 1st 2 discriminant functions plotcluster(mydata, fit$cluster) </code></pre> <p>My question is, how can the plot which shows the number of clusters (marked <code>Q1</code> in my code) be related to the actual values (cluster number and variable name) ? </p> <p>Update: I now understand that the <code>clusplot()</code> function is a bivariate plot, with PCA1 and PCA2. However, I don't understand the link between the PCA components and the cluster groups. What is the relationship between the PCA values and the clustering groups? I've read elsewhere about the link between kmeans and PCA, but I still don't understand how they can be displayed on the same bivariate graph. </p>
37,052
[ 0.002129411557689309, -0.0007548751309514046, 0.017888708040118217, -0.04598673805594444, 0.026204150170087814, 0.010214240290224552, -0.0037230828311294317, -0.025366807356476784, -0.021379876881837845, -0.026314225047826767, 0.034676045179367065, 0.057227496057748795, -0.002934725722298026, 0.009480848908424377, 0.007614737376570702, 0.008703782223165035, 0.006687505170702934, 0.015047266148030758, 0.013037172146141529, -0.011550391092896461, -0.0021361960098147392, -0.005334196612238884, 0.026446014642715454, -0.03163754567503929, 0.006981734186410904, 0.034430231899023056, 0.0230451300740242, 0.017811689525842667, 0.008860847912728786, 0.03955818712711334, -0.0504629872739315, -0.018553631380200386, -0.019566936418414116, 0.010453877039253712, -0.02441049925982952, 0.03852648660540581, -0.010387999936938286, -0.02237003482878208, -0.005696593783795834, 0.0202922523021698, -0.050808265805244446, -0.016124561429023743, 0.010955567471683025, 0.04167797043919563, -0.0053474572487175465, 0.012939371168613434, 0.021407349035143852, 0.005578183569014072, 0.037819597870111465, 0.02022414281964302, 0.07536078244447708, 0.020038655027747154, 0.03585819527506828, 0.02809382788836956, -0.022548185661435127, -0.015689313411712646, 0.03388713672757149, 0.039682235568761826, -0.018078003078699112, -0.07515610009431839, -0.004986976273357868, 0.018821390345692635, 0.021302273496985435, -0.031012650579214096, 0.0026646670885384083, 0.015313335694372654, -0.0006057461723685265, -0.011474679224193096, 0.018033036962151527, -0.0038173524662852287, 0.04253383353352547, -0.01331958919763565, 0.0038341996259987354, -0.05722713842988014, 0.013442426919937134, -0.0020637139678001404, -0.018408870324492455, -0.005810560658574104, 0.04268883541226387, 0.0045349253341555595, 0.005575631745159626, 0.033086325973272324, 0.033374905586242676, -0.01100245676934719, 0.03376085311174393, 0.024681759998202324, 0.04379189759492874, -0.04125863313674927, 0.035697292536497116, 0.004836677573621273, 0.019905822351574898, 0.02774813584983349, 0.046040114015340805, 0.023619575425982475, -0.01101447083055973, 0.030806170776486397, 0.010849264450371265, 0.026634076610207558, -0.018519168719649315, -0.0113440603017807, -0.04198051244020462, -0.024020740762352943, -0.027184681966900826, 0.046324122697114944, -0.03771965205669403, -0.005059498827904463, -0.04183487594127655, 0.0023455379996448755, -0.061177510768175125, -0.00415579229593277, -0.015230342745780945, 0.026173818856477737, 0.010362927801907063, 0.010394311510026455, 0.04811554774641991, -0.06560489535331726, -0.017966395244002342, 0.01565178483724594, 0.04037545621395111, 0.020497657358646393, 0.04418063908815384, 0.0034410255029797554, -0.006180034019052982, -0.01671220175921917, -0.05034478008747101, -0.025254469364881516, 0.01989859715104103, -0.005675945896655321, -0.010884858667850494, 0.021392131224274635, -0.004244477488100529, -0.0021730081643909216, 0.0019270366756245494, 0.01717006415128708, 0.013975629583001137, 0.019493458792567253, -0.07381616532802582, -0.039608847349882126, 0.04952051863074303, -0.0015409013722091913, 0.03662790358066559, -0.01963387243449688, 0.008673281408846378, -0.013941089622676373, 0.04490813612937927, -0.005948555655777454, 0.008518459275364876, 0.013287334702908993, 0.03284699097275734, 0.01280207373201847, -0.04254056513309479, 0.009881788864731789, -0.04008910059928894, -0.012858613394200802, -0.007589248940348625, -0.05578207969665527, 0.007455454673618078, 0.010843674652278423, 0.00913973804563284, 0.0045503973960876465, -0.00021278750500641763, -0.012922546826303005, -0.021730585023760796, -0.01811923272907734, -0.04387036710977554, 0.03211161866784096, 0.03494730964303017, 0.006109262350946665, 0.022747736424207687, 0.0398617684841156, -0.038165636360645294, 0.024243690073490143, 0.010306919924914837, 0.026724545285105705, 0.06184384599328041, 0.020819032564759254, 0.00752096576616168, -0.02356543205678463, 0.023318713530898094, 0.023224225267767906, -0.06315211206674576, -0.052839212119579315, 0.0016200573882088065, -0.020221620798110962, 0.028229940682649612, 0.05090389400720596, 0.01074086781591177, -0.025019757449626923, 0.04020458832383156, -0.0497857928276062, -0.050902221351861954, -0.07377736270427704, -0.010944537818431854, -0.02710779942572117, -0.060522112995386124, -0.013363286852836609, 0.0035352311097085476, -0.002353015122935176, 0.003462451510131359, -0.015199904330074787, -0.025906197726726532, 0.001065840944647789, 0.0654899850487709, -0.03679133206605911, -0.012008807621896267, 0.028966959565877914, 0.04727783799171448, 0.03661143779754639, 0.03741859644651413, -0.013400329276919365, -0.012513933703303337, 0.020307665690779686, -0.02323872782289982, 0.0076606301590800285, -0.006263503339141607, -0.016001436859369278, 0.022720910608768463, 0.03787023201584816, -0.02675424888730049, -0.00499171856790781, -0.06307446956634521, 0.01051764190196991, 0.07307359576225281, 0.030634474009275436, -0.0005456515355035663, 0.016432879492640495, -0.02749633602797985, 0.026179421693086624, -0.03918842226266861, -0.00027955041150562465, -0.03907649591565132, -0.01847914233803749, 0.010026778094470501, 0.021982433274388313, 0.0015122262993827462, -0.019684581086039543, 0.08639604598283768, 0.024448439478874207, -0.004675102885812521, 0.03849053755402565, -0.04429538547992706, -0.029513569548726082, 0.049229200929403305, -0.0033453674986958504, 0.010244753211736679, -0.019822459667921066, -0.0016463962383568287, 0.009709514677524567, 0.057083435356616974, -0.020258847624063492, 0.012265361845493317, 0.08653900027275085, 0.007306395098567009, -0.03719302639365196, -0.00025152898160740733, 0.008226275444030762, 0.05584707111120224, -0.002532950369641185, -0.0006315568462014198, 0.034532781690359116, 0.018971553072333336, 0.015972526744008064, -0.004577707964926958, -0.0400710292160511, 0.002951103262603283, 0.0494907908141613, -0.029408911243081093, -0.010348605923354626, 0.008961191400885582, -0.01385735534131527, 0.04189550504088402, -0.03823935240507126, -0.04713589698076248, -0.04545987769961357, -0.03246099501848221, 0.04307124763727188, 0.0388561449944973, -0.011092908680438995, -0.02176726423203945, -0.018286878243088722, -0.005336747504770756, 0.0037126331590116024, 0.014456109143793583, 0.025283560156822205, -0.006848169956356287, 0.010592902079224586, -0.010511297732591629, 0.02333655394613743, 0.013185135088860989, 0.04133688658475876, -0.06370220333337784, 0.010224344208836555, 0.015231670811772346, -0.004731253255158663, -0.025669259950518608, 0.009146085008978844, 0.02098899334669113, -0.06025894731283188, -0.017685407772660255, 0.03540623188018799, 0.0017971720080822706, -0.041127998381853104, -0.00048105529276654124, -0.04527638480067253, 0.03164825588464737, -0.023692570626735687, -0.013515856117010117, 0.00874471664428711, 0.016103392466902733, -0.018734168261289597, -0.006449669133871794, -0.04264931380748749, 0.005438476800918579, -0.0423373244702816, -0.08078848570585251, -0.02640555053949356, -0.005833371076732874, -0.024655325338244438, -0.05120463669300079, -0.024877844378352165, 0.07422763854265213, 0.029640013352036476, -0.03810083121061325, -0.0464768260717392, 0.0026244025211781263, -0.02875589020550251, 0.00912563968449831, 0.025494057685136795, 0.05593018978834152, 0.009343545883893967, -0.02336937189102173, -0.016228098422288895, 0.06942330300807953, 0.06626369804143906, -0.03659352660179138, 0.0075714061968028545, 0.05341286584734917, 0.007897631265223026, -0.01414418499916792, 0.021221870556473732, -0.003299981588497758, 0.02049834467470646, 0.008425947278738022, -0.004504583775997162, -0.007261267863214016, -0.00414291163906455, -0.03709624707698822, 0.003353789681568742, 0.008770225569605827, 0.023196101188659668, -0.0642944723367691, 0.01898961327970028, -0.007130074314773083, -0.05957193300127983, 0.016291102394461632, -0.00993638951331377, 0.04014599323272705, -0.017216846346855164, -0.03820295259356499, 0.05252479761838913, 0.048551056534051895, -0.030399074777960777, 0.006197684910148382, -0.004668785259127617, -0.012883687391877174, 0.008899061009287834, -0.01952819526195526, -0.03379609435796738, 0.025217197835445404, 0.0562126487493515, -0.004547132179141045, -0.003270318266004324, -0.005599981639534235, 0.030531877651810646, -0.03653945028781891, 0.016990255564451218, -0.03197013586759567, 0.02511562965810299, 0.001542476238682866, 0.040772415697574615, -0.01643875241279602, 0.020513171330094337, -0.010641904547810555, -0.01080077700316906, -0.04649065434932709, 0.04504434019327164, 0.030771730467677116, 0.014954257756471634, -0.033874765038490295, -0.06425095349550247, 0.022664355114102364, -0.022061698138713837, 0.009374928660690784, 0.02368101105093956, 0.024180732667446136, -0.026075946167111397, -0.0005085616139695048, 0.007046547718346119, 0.03201519325375557, -0.03379572555422783, 0.0008641734602861106, 0.04985955357551575, 0.005082898773252964, 0.04003969952464104, 0.009728770703077316, -0.01663646660745144, -0.0006271517486311495, 0.012834289111196995, 0.0004252423532307148, 0.03833867609500885, 0.014195334166288376, 0.03628525882959366, 0.02085326611995697, -0.007734550163149834, -0.011187726631760597, -0.007625333499163389, 0.03970984369516373, 0.04737922176718712, -0.019118735566735268, -0.02319910377264023, -0.013114252127707005, -0.0024286694824695587, -0.023703983053565025, 0.03262866660952568, -0.018853969871997833, 0.01654076762497425, 0.05265115201473236, 0.024287715554237366, -0.03152034804224968, 0.04829808697104454, 0.052388742566108704, 0.01737642101943493, -0.03507363796234131, -0.04177702218294144, -0.00462743267416954, -0.0246138796210289, -0.002621609019115567, 0.06921666115522385, 0.005001481622457504, 0.019024496898055077, 0.04024425148963928, 0.021988900378346443, -0.02586974762380123, -0.05576089769601822, 0.02294391207396984, 0.023338977247476578, 0.015173837542533875, -0.017305053770542145, -0.03341297805309296, 0.03057103417813778, 0.04130322486162186, 0.020173758268356323, 0.017801128327846527, 0.004348199814558029, -0.0893707349896431, -0.007333175744861364, 0.03591412678360939, 0.03391708806157112, -0.015023497864603996, 0.012602769769728184, -0.07725270092487335, 0.017747431993484497, -0.013095755130052567, -0.02385377138853073, 0.04794467240571976, -0.008679383434355259, 0.01966937631368637, -0.04568083584308624, -0.034997954964637756, -0.06380496174097061, 0.000237672429648228, -0.053866539150476456, -0.014968495815992355, -0.015641750767827034, -0.029161222279071808, -0.038724251091480255, 0.018843121826648712, -0.025268472731113434, 0.014156141318380833, -0.050728291273117065, -0.03180352598428726, 0.03457779437303543, 0.01104721613228321, -0.007879788056015968, -0.02978852391242981, 0.006917089689522982, 0.019088301807641983, 0.038812026381492615, 0.07820679247379303, -0.015244330279529095, 0.00005863220212631859, 0.026934638619422913, 0.03192795813083649, -0.00361050246283412, 0.03021037019789219, 0.013297597877681255, 0.04402834549546242, 0.058137521147727966, -0.009889474138617516, 0.028487158939242363, 0.00008262140181614086, -0.021312935277819633, 0.051189932972192764, -0.09846051782369614, 0.011241041123867035, -0.01662016473710537, -0.03645140677690506, -0.07811064273118973, -0.005316962953656912, -0.010327908210456371, 0.006140358746051788, -0.02147352509200573, 0.022024985402822495, -0.01512187346816063, 0.01454194076359272, 0.03953709825873375, 0.018074465915560722, -0.006179431453347206, 0.007882029749453068, -0.023765040561556816, 0.03067305125296116, 0.01574946753680706, -0.01149145606905222, -0.0073912316001951694, -0.042701248079538345, 0.006839976646006107, 0.005079956725239754, -0.03769967705011368, -0.020030874758958817, 0.002032981486991048, 0.008905417285859585, 0.039805684238672256, -0.025855660438537598, 0.007727391552180052, -0.00036305500543676317, 0.043229151517152786, 0.011528384871780872, -0.040285028517246246, -0.03732017055153847, 0.011427448131144047, 0.005914490669965744, 0.02680809795856476, -0.05076579004526138, 0.049441300332546234, -0.0022248432505875826, -0.0400673970580101, -0.04454198107123375, -0.014948016963899136, 0.01834147237241268, -0.003990859724581242, -0.09757019579410553, -0.07872121781110764, -0.008046306669712067, 0.004262659233063459, -0.00687013566493988, 0.014853977598249912, 0.011714296415448189, -0.07370131462812424, -0.0194222554564476, 0.015175732783973217, -0.02625194378197193, 0.0653567686676979, -0.017270686104893684, 0.04385008662939072, 0.04800272360444069, -0.006332972552627325, -0.018785979598760605, 0.022777309641242027, -0.007096320856362581, -0.021967845037579536, 0.004851659294217825, -0.022345228120684624, 0.000549358141142875, 0.008355197496712208, -0.02626534178853035, -0.011826032772660255, -0.05251574143767357, 0.038223423063755035, 0.032711200416088104, -0.02149619162082672, 0.0001644547883188352, -0.012466859072446823, 0.05183475837111473, -0.03598591685295105, 0.0014920945977792144, -0.016671311110258102, 0.011329814791679382, 0.019292544573545456, -0.010303515009582043, -0.031865183264017105, 0.016597401350736618, 0.08447542041540146, -0.0036359881050884724, 0.020900286734104156, 0.0012098844163119793, -0.032761480659246445, 0.01917501725256443, -0.018884118646383286, 0.025195442140102386, 0.015708522871136665, 0.00529751181602478, -0.00960257463157177, -0.018238605931401253, -0.06524833291769028, 0.026931460946798325, 0.04761335253715515, 0.015920152887701988, 0.0616229809820652, 0.05917607620358467, -0.01999312825500965, 0.008743321523070335, -0.07581831514835358, -0.02253381907939911, -0.024068553000688553, 0.02401280216872692, 0.04110069200396538, 0.00012076226994395256, -0.030792981386184692, 0.046639733016490936, -0.024521641433238983, -0.002851645927876234, 0.009534292854368687, 0.01088808849453926, 0.003861034056171775, -0.0021818922832608223, 0.007097152993083, -0.03669912740588188, 0.012460661120712757, -0.0117029445245862, 0.023325566202402115, -0.020400987938046455, -0.025300288572907448, 0.04437137767672539, 0.05813819169998169, 0.03928058594465256, -0.02704775519669056, -0.010315857827663422, -0.06618423014879227, 0.00571037083864212, 0.04842348396778107, -0.015433559194207191, 0.0334448516368866, 0.015937138348817825, -0.001100742956623435, -0.006259500049054623, 0.013093949295580387, -0.03419980779290199, -0.015055770054459572, -0.07417093962430954, -0.0037767330650240183, -0.04866389185190201, 0.05971807613968849, -0.029450714588165283, -0.034637272357940674, 0.03771546483039856, -0.019757704809308052, 0.01063387468457222, 0.023068398237228394, 0.010621029883623123, -0.0021365603897720575, 0.08038170635700226, -0.0007348610670305789, 0.004898849409073591, -0.019635023549199104, -0.03638748452067375, 0.12798775732517242, 0.03787008300423622, 0.03006705455482006, -0.07222726196050644, -0.000046021788875805214, 0.06369417905807495, 0.013999623246490955, -0.02301124669611454, -0.0077621787786483765, 0.0216983649879694, 0.01828443817794323, 0.07223086059093475, 0.024780703708529472, 0.056979041546583176, 0.02119043469429016, 0.02102745696902275, 0.022340387105941772, -0.035746555775403976, 0.011033314280211926, 0.026736538857221603, -0.02966810204088688, 0.010152137838304043, -0.11108613014221191, -0.010152136906981468, 0.014822982251644135, 0.006561181508004665, -0.031224649399518967, -0.00047919212374836206, -0.04768100380897522, -0.00048605422489345074, -0.013570951297879219, 0.0037566940300166607, 0.026712005957961082, 0.005415189079940319, -0.030616039410233498, -0.003143643494695425, 0.01157928816974163, -0.038275834172964096, 0.016111746430397034, 0.0173603855073452, -0.000906978384591639, -0.027762891724705696, -0.0016570258885622025, 0.0009614843293093145, -0.027774997055530548, -0.03003038465976715, 0.0015910431975498796, 0.04092923551797867, 0.024778960272669792, -0.01570092886686325, -0.0005218036822043359, 0.009830564260482788, 0.004558573476970196, -0.02826998010277748, 0.02215532585978508, 0.01520173717290163, 0.01217829342931509, -0.013458753935992718, -0.014682669192552567, -0.05355249345302582, -0.020670492202043533, -0.014665260910987854, -0.01077065709978342, 0.008580341935157776, -0.005441559478640556, -0.012512966059148312, -0.05552239343523979, 0.07419534027576447, -0.040415409952402115, 0.018035003915429115, 0.023015469312667847, 0.011738190427422523, -0.014561579562723637, -0.028480589389801025, -0.015669191256165504, -0.022573715075850487, 0.04923863708972931, 0.02045462466776371, 0.013575777411460876, -0.02304425649344921, -0.0482228621840477, 0.005286641418933868, -0.039041657000780106, -0.022243203595280647, -0.028709281235933304, -0.0026216974947601557, 0.01599280908703804, 0.07519274950027466, 0.017358113080263138, 0.028444495052099228, -0.05411748215556145, 0.044054098427295685, -0.014613764360547066, -0.03504331409931183, -0.005070513114333153, 0.023354612290859222, -0.013922302983701229, 0.0064365798607468605, -0.042332686483860016, 0.06616005301475525, 0.014150856994092464, -0.026175307109951973, -0.005169297568500042, 0.03337918221950531, -0.01723562739789486, -0.00038620101986452937, -0.007985861971974373, -0.04085558280348778, 0.02700682356953621, 0.006118824705481529, -0.032571569085121155, -0.059145402163267136, -0.014333765022456646, 0.00569891557097435, -0.028779497370123863, -0.004475031979382038, -0.032393407076597214, -0.035515256226062775, -0.002850148594006896, 0.01283988542854786, -0.014926825650036335, -0.0028691603802144527, -0.008158553391695023, -0.04341889172792435, -0.009550103917717934, -0.053400639444589615, 0.011057788506150246, 0.014517939649522305, 0.012708161026239395, -0.0159829780459404, 0.00657881423830986, 0.03898830711841583, -0.0057180277071893215, 0.031904637813568115, 0.026758644729852676, 0.027640843763947487, 0.004411941859871149, 0.04040162265300751, 0.00417605834081769, -0.01326698623597622, 0.03289381414651871, -0.04590243473649025, -0.05973966419696808, -0.011648222804069519, 0.0010130527662113309, 0.04809180647134781, -0.012042492628097534, -0.00482645258307457, -0.02272658795118332, 0.08429910242557526, -0.03508282080292702, 0.01695466972887516, -0.021697036921977997, -0.03297241032123566, 0.052418775856494904, 0.029800275340676308, -0.0024091678205877542, 0.024287162348628044, -0.017204008996486664, -0.004884033463895321, 0.022140420973300934, -0.04615391418337822, -0.009018500335514545, 0.0184987373650074, -0.023180628195405006, -0.0011670727981254458, -0.03280266001820564, 0.02112663723528385, 0.03093794174492359, 0.030159277841448784, -0.03370855003595352, 0.026848115026950836, -0.025329837575554848, 0.03268615901470184, -0.08147458732128143, -0.01220293715596199, 0.00495221046730876, -0.002946909749880433, 0.04407069832086563, -0.06099675968289375, -0.02514776773750782, 0.026843024417757988, -0.03952014818787575, 0.007895764894783497, -0.02206321246922016, 0.028058933094143867, -0.04214910790324211, 0.010211433283984661, -0.018887903541326523, 0.03375973179936409, 0.05715120956301689, 0.02666754275560379, 0.06256059557199478, -0.01134747639298439, -0.020585978403687477, 0.008270285092294216, 0.010129613801836967, 0.01087809819728136, 0.029797552153468132, -0.05433474853634834, 0.034030620008707047, -0.029468195512890816, 0.006008893251419067, 0.0305721927434206, -0.047990832477808, -0.014440159313380718, 0.06943193823099136, 0.021117517724633217, 0.010200274176895618, 0.03588288277387619, -0.010203083977103233, 0.02736026421189308, -0.026562867686152458, -0.034867580980062485, -0.00928560271859169, 0.012530204840004444, -0.014196827076375484, 0.008525995537638664, -0.020273635163903236, -0.002723607001826167, 0.003244605381041765, -0.0016606297576799989, -0.02600010856986046, 0.018536720424890518, 0.007189973257482052, 0.008803820237517357, 0.0006315542268566787, -0.047878291457891464, 0.010924742557108402, -0.01746572181582451, 0.022104892879724503, 0.06635390967130661, 0.03661521524190903, 0.000147247250424698, 0.04352200776338577, -0.02491173893213272, -0.0594753660261631, 0.02542288228869438, -0.01636766456067562, -0.035450529307127, -0.034780241549015045, -0.004469471517950296, -0.003283506026491523, 0.0066102175042033195, -0.040128953754901886, 0.05085314065217972, -0.026680676266551018, 0.0387246236205101, -0.008665950037539005, -0.007514855824410915, -0.010318239219486713, -0.029712455347180367, 0.027544453740119934, -0.11533595621585846, 0.03049141727387905, 0.007598425727337599, -0.00926742423325777, -0.03344232589006424, -0.010120255872607231, -0.02963051199913025, 0.030016452074050903, 0.009960608556866646, 0.02749205008149147, 0.01797335036098957, -0.00746947480365634, 0.019412614405155182, 0.02897285856306553, -0.05033634230494499, 0.05392347648739815, 0.00006971306720515713, -0.0032665892504155636, 0.0068242354318499565, -0.008027122355997562, 0.01630396954715252, 0.032282453030347824, -0.02152557112276554, 0.0065131052397191525, 0.019105330109596252, 0.011217166669666767, -0.03316294401884079, 0.03383832052350044, -0.008196244016289711, -0.017186621204018593, 0.033360980451107025, -0.028340570628643036, 0.007591277826577425, 0.05574030801653862, -0.010757147334516048, -0.019370635971426964, 0.04369577392935753, -0.011997399851679802, -0.018780071288347244, 0.018977196887135506, -0.03264104574918747, 0.03918934613466263, -0.06367246806621552, -0.014656520448625088, -0.020851677283644676, -0.013996914029121399, -0.011024711653590202, 0.077549509704113, 0.020032081753015518, 0.05737920105457306, 0.0247325636446476, 0.029377302154898643, -0.021985560655593872, -0.038747768849134445, 0.04120191931724548, 0.014029107987880707, 0.0014842802193015814, 0.026118120178580284, 0.006960819475352764, 0.016257883980870247, -0.018792452290654182, 0.006257873494178057, -0.020283136516809464, 0.05909309163689613, -0.046546947211027145, -0.014590127393603325, 0.01459263451397419, -0.017785068601369858, 0.014863274991512299, 0.0648258849978447, 0.021536994725465775, 0.04110388457775116, -0.05060381814837456, 0.010204056277871132, -0.013216960243880749, -0.01130016427487135, -0.015252950601279736, -0.0038883581291884184, 0.011461218819022179, 0.010370326228439808, -0.008751001209020615, 0.023424571380019188, 0.01699008047580719, 0.022107334807515144, -0.004918641410768032, 0.009589022025465965, 0.03649996221065521, 0.00511112529784441, -0.017087819054722786, 0.005154007114470005, 0.01678372360765934, -0.0017402375815436244, -0.032868921756744385, 0.026354674249887466, 0.04104888066649437, -0.023644255474209785, -0.01168685033917427, 0.014343137852847576, 0.005540495738387108, 0.031317222863435745, -0.05947743356227875, -0.03757074102759361, -0.04872671887278557, 0.021632129326462746, -0.02312859520316124, -0.028186744078993797 ]
<p><strong>Framework.</strong> Fix $\alpha\in ]0,1[$. Imagine you have $n$ $\alpha$-quantile forecast methodologies that give you, at time $t$ for look ahead time $t+h$, an estimation of the quantile of wind power. Formally, for $i=1,\dots,n$, you know how to produce $\hat{q}_{t+h|t}^{(i)}$ at time $t$ for look ahead time $t+h$ an estimation. Each methodology is based on a different modeling+estimation and can have performance that depend, for example, on the weather situation. </p> <p><strong>Question.</strong> How do you construct a weighting scheme to combine quantile estimation (say with a linear combination) that can adapt along time $t$? Formally, how to best construct weights $\lambda_1(t,h),\dots,\lambda_n(t,h)$ such that </p> <p>$$\hat{q}_{t+h|t}=\sum_{i=1}^n \lambda_i(t,h) \hat{q}_{t+h|t}^{(i)}$$</p> <p>is a very good quantile forecast. </p> <p><strong>Side Note.</strong> For Msc students interested in proposing and elaborating their ideas with the real data, I propose an internship on that subject for summer 2011 (see <a href="http://www-cep.cma.fr/Public/recrutement/proposition_de_stage/stage_prevision_eol/" rel="nofollow">here</a>, it's in french but I can translate to those interested). </p>
37,053
[ -0.033451031893491745, -0.030418064445257187, 0.01078610960394144, 0.011699117720127106, 0.04073663428425789, 0.027977019548416138, 0.003880128264427185, -0.00030158416484482586, 0.014482603408396244, -0.012746468186378479, 0.011066528037190437, 0.05366869270801544, 0.06721436232328415, 0.014724216423928738, 0.02812390774488449, 0.011353235691785812, -0.0011063589481636882, -0.019214151427149773, -0.03206436336040497, 0.009678203612565994, 0.0272538959980011, 0.05807990953326225, -0.04001249372959137, 0.036985836923122406, -0.02284219302237034, 0.04254372790455818, -0.003343818476423621, -0.004999776370823383, -0.018975187093019485, 0.05591301620006561, -0.015452584251761436, -0.021493958309292793, 0.03134584799408913, 0.039784111082553864, 0.00328254047781229, 0.018724646419286728, -0.01603536121547222, -0.04070571810007095, -0.017726900056004524, 0.00835537537932396, -0.07257791608572006, -0.022159839048981667, -0.010306337848305702, -0.006754172500222921, -0.011348968371748924, 0.024722378700971603, -0.01004235539585352, -0.06032085418701172, 0.027180153876543045, -0.06209924817085266, 0.06138451397418976, 0.020817028358578682, 0.018031403422355652, 0.05806189775466919, -0.024505872279405594, -0.03134843707084656, 0.03809305280447006, 0.08349132537841797, -0.0020675358828157187, -0.03305914252996445, -0.008201247081160545, -0.011727035976946354, 0.014316563494503498, -0.003838435746729374, -0.05087282508611679, 0.04345504939556122, -0.014697999693453312, -0.003437740495428443, -0.028114711865782738, -0.03831518813967705, 0.008494311012327671, 0.007938595488667488, 0.020512042567133904, 0.05518130213022232, 0.007764879614114761, -0.01750216819345951, -0.019849713891744614, 0.021628113463521004, 0.08253446966409683, 0.034188784658908844, -0.0036091653164476156, 0.0009838608093559742, 0.0405263714492321, 0.0341908298432827, 0.013709376566112041, 0.001654737046919763, 0.06963735073804855, -0.05153665319085121, 0.00843706913292408, 0.003071920247748494, -0.03455761447548866, -0.019631419330835342, 0.009123985655605793, -0.06207839772105217, -0.010362179949879646, 0.00011219826410524547, -0.0036450917832553387, -0.0006016580737195909, -0.006195120979100466, -0.024492597207427025, -0.006939150858670473, -0.047886211425065994, 0.004979474935680628, 0.02390037290751934, 0.0236277524381876, -0.0013148706639185548, -0.011471070349216461, -0.027424637228250504, -0.036340173333883286, -0.027659770101308823, -0.03986554965376854, 0.03394868224859238, 0.007817507721483707, -0.01892946846783161, -0.02467103861272335, -0.030755845829844475, 0.048622824251651764, -0.015861013904213905, 0.0394427590072155, 0.0433005765080452, 0.024773890152573586, -0.005061923060566187, 0.04721461981534958, -0.046987712383270264, -0.07750578969717026, 0.026401806622743607, 0.02311229147017002, -0.04105889052152634, -0.04896931350231171, 0.02698417752981186, 0.017639733850955963, -0.005217145662754774, 0.007359503302723169, 0.02375548891723156, 0.04520592838525772, 0.014504044316709042, -0.09834758192300797, -0.0576271153986454, 0.02600730210542679, -0.031138064339756966, 0.016169138252735138, -0.023760676383972168, -0.007338785566389561, 0.036312490701675415, 0.03632562607526779, 0.0027157659642398357, 0.05203332379460335, 0.01581387035548687, 0.013010567054152489, -0.0074276975356042385, -0.04238177463412285, -0.035516709089279175, -0.01992110162973404, -0.022388501092791557, -0.01946314424276352, -0.07781889289617538, 0.03280939906835556, 0.028994061052799225, -0.010216815397143364, 0.0187978595495224, 0.0818505510687828, 0.02808569371700287, -0.012357956729829311, -0.025459226220846176, 0.01425910834223032, -0.01898276060819626, 0.026268457993865013, 0.008016044273972511, 0.048143964260816574, 0.006303801666945219, 0.021546699106693268, 0.005367666482925415, 0.024040810763835907, 0.022108640521764755, 0.05341712385416031, -0.0031919176690280437, 0.018759161233901978, -0.03828812390565872, -0.011810719966888428, 0.014131004922091961, -0.027708623558282852, -0.02090897411108017, -0.014041071757674217, 0.01077636145055294, -0.011735383421182632, 0.09340152144432068, -0.007573532406240702, -0.0040130093693733215, 0.04185543209314346, -0.03109937347471714, -0.07370078563690186, -0.02499626949429512, 0.006207064725458622, -0.026567986235022545, 0.015319876372814178, 0.06891091167926788, -0.04160156846046448, 0.01608663611114025, 0.015050753951072693, 0.0009785180445760489, 0.01684286631643772, 0.03130733594298363, 0.038622334599494934, -0.03791981190443039, 0.008502457290887833, 0.053112294524908066, 0.02699768729507923, -0.006250937469303608, 0.03887806087732315, -0.03349614515900612, -0.06662942469120026, -0.011663339100778103, -0.023492878302931786, 0.017766794189810753, -0.008036975748836994, -0.013284713961184025, 0.004433910828083754, 0.006134841125458479, 0.010538161732256413, 0.011250623501837254, -0.029839279130101204, 0.03655899316072464, 0.08064574003219604, -0.004450259264558554, -0.00014046391879674047, 0.04657213017344475, 0.006928180810064077, 0.03611896187067032, -0.008891727775335312, -0.021757394075393677, -0.008253599517047405, 0.00868931319564581, 0.050960931926965714, 0.04319261386990547, -0.03154207020998001, 0.02258196473121643, 0.04639693722128868, 0.03989947959780693, 0.02570822462439537, 0.040242139250040054, -0.010245105251669884, 0.021831726655364037, 0.004941276274621487, -0.03463858738541603, 0.02177615463733673, -0.026757624000310898, -0.019259262830018997, 0.014109662733972073, 0.015556193888187408, -0.004948505200445652, 0.023330578580498695, 0.054521288722753525, -0.019371403381228447, 0.0016476392047479749, -0.018346639350056648, -0.029632387682795525, 0.056758832186460495, -0.0524529293179512, 0.0278178658336401, 0.021657656878232956, -0.010586242191493511, -0.005552742164582014, 0.018513910472393036, -0.031625933945178986, 0.020445769652724266, 0.009394406341016293, 0.01747402735054493, 0.01611418090760708, 0.0236935056746006, -0.03963151574134827, 0.02698172628879547, -0.036277737468481064, -0.04822542145848274, -0.01139404159039259, 0.024186501279473305, 0.002835324499756098, 0.018002593889832497, -0.010256514884531498, -0.03184238821268082, -0.06318078935146332, -0.00694842217490077, 0.012862752191722393, 0.012909271754324436, 0.029564032331109047, -0.008497681468725204, 0.004098144359886646, -0.03493916988372803, -0.013839295133948326, 0.07761727273464203, -0.02090323343873024, -0.019444243982434273, -0.004738058429211378, -0.006247769575566053, 0.010043996386229992, -0.017471807077527046, -0.05040505900979042, -0.019051287323236465, -0.028936704620718956, -0.042119063436985016, 0.0542176328599453, 0.0011422504903748631, -0.04487384855747223, 0.03305584564805031, -0.029501555487513542, -0.0323968380689621, -0.027267388999462128, 0.01394632551819086, 0.0019311667419970036, -0.008704941719770432, 0.031296275556087494, 0.031101088970899582, 0.004990810994058847, 0.02744077704846859, -0.056680917739868164, -0.04472629725933075, 0.022241966798901558, 0.004257601220160723, 0.06629718095064163, 0.04055655375123024, -0.037917088717222214, 0.08881174027919769, 0.005433543119579554, -0.008762470446527004, -0.029617566615343094, 0.0018783720443025231, 0.006663224659860134, -0.008208515122532845, 0.0038803089410066605, -0.00001811116271710489, -0.005271973554044962, 0.03605364263057709, 0.011789137497544289, 0.017156880348920822, 0.047429945319890976, 0.022599831223487854, 0.0009810609044507146, 0.006218163296580315, 0.003295342670753598, 0.0219119843095541, 0.03424690291285515, 0.003862459911033511, 0.016669107601046562, 0.01473443303257227, -0.019929133355617523, -0.01091892458498478, 0.014061394147574902, -0.03566550090909004, 0.032025646418333054, -0.016163384541869164, -0.004476688802242279, -0.07172520458698273, 0.06861072778701782, -0.0017539183609187603, -0.0422213077545166, -0.031174179166555405, -0.0023242970928549767, 0.02151591330766678, -0.04226946458220482, 0.03440043702721596, 0.05154281482100487, 0.052434761077165604, -0.0177935641258955, -0.017001112923026085, -0.018909122794866562, -0.0002671270340215415, 0.027378514409065247, -0.049547869712114334, -0.024846013635396957, 0.029374219477176666, 0.029705829918384552, 0.011972245760262012, 0.0028718868270516396, -0.0026252183597534895, -0.011934765614569187, -0.08068570494651794, -0.021038589999079704, -0.030164241790771484, 0.07280482351779938, -0.021667538210749626, 0.06161560118198395, -0.006313761230558157, 0.02277732826769352, 0.0038641991559416056, -0.008038787171244621, -0.03656543791294098, 0.027818677946925163, 0.02892480231821537, 0.002739796880632639, 0.007783995009958744, 0.0033688973635435104, 0.028048638254404068, -0.00043064862256869674, 0.018104523420333862, -0.031255293637514114, 0.012275042943656445, -0.013294601812958717, 0.02759571559727192, -0.037620168179273605, -0.03063582070171833, -0.022155169397592545, -0.011498418636620045, 0.02034675143659115, -0.06104574725031853, 0.05202467739582062, 0.041064582765102386, -0.03686954453587532, 0.01597209833562374, -0.01568419113755226, 0.02072574384510517, -0.021168626844882965, -0.006784515921026468, 0.04261336103081703, 0.024726711213588715, -0.034720927476882935, 0.01917719841003418, 0.03631104156374931, 0.023486986756324768, 0.04746507853269577, 0.0019482567440718412, 0.024329395964741707, -0.03032529540359974, -0.03389258310198784, 0.01531386561691761, -0.039706867188215256, -0.003561982186511159, 0.004156357608735561, 0.03984106704592705, -0.0158686563372612, -0.05840000510215759, 0.0049274517223238945, 0.033298201858997345, 0.013287674635648727, 0.020511165261268616, -0.03336269408464432, 0.0050928485579788685, -0.00573046924546361, -0.006192984990775585, 0.024247100576758385, -0.00297733792103827, 0.0010605102870613337, 0.013574951328337193, 0.03401311859488487, -0.010038210079073906, -0.027169182896614075, 0.0015511163510382175, 0.0208282433450222, 0.011096108704805374, 0.030269285663962364, -0.022870082408189774, 0.01272736769169569, 0.03275446221232414, 0.037607479840517044, -0.0015315781347453594, -0.011257462203502655, -0.10534465312957764, -0.006451213266700506, 0.033289048820734024, 0.032940033823251724, -0.03436925634741783, -0.019824327901005745, -0.06610275059938431, -0.018124977126717567, 0.016011614352464676, -0.05855407565832138, 0.025643223896622658, -0.014142154715955257, 0.013577955774962902, -0.0030103581957519054, -0.03880533203482628, -0.03764767944812775, 0.047035571187734604, 0.004176794551312923, 0.03509804233908653, 0.005242810118943453, -0.011909780092537403, -0.014191687107086182, 0.0040309494361281395, 0.023847641423344612, 0.03232835233211517, -0.006287768017500639, -0.05317562073469162, -0.04652780666947365, 0.005786192137748003, -0.010424092411994934, -0.08585721254348755, -0.01269777026027441, 0.033896349370479584, -0.010529248043894768, 0.023046264424920082, -0.04417760670185089, -0.06614643335342407, 0.002324415370821953, 0.04344967380166054, -0.014306162483990192, -0.020900463685393333, -0.027811288833618164, 0.04807107523083687, 0.01929456740617752, 0.029483046382665634, 0.013014703057706356, 0.03854009881615639, -0.022922221571207047, 0.013587734661996365, -0.02207767590880394, -0.008923065848648548, 0.008360153995454311, -0.00047737263957969844, -0.019394217059016228, -0.01908174715936184, -0.022614967077970505, 0.01920277625322342, -0.013794283382594585, 0.03415292501449585, -0.023323960602283478, -0.02193322218954563, -0.02055547758936882, 0.0424480065703392, 0.00457958597689867, -0.05814492329955101, -0.008958136662840843, -0.007087670732289553, 0.010249145328998566, -0.006376612465828657, 0.013866518624126911, -0.0043544345535337925, 0.025561321526765823, 0.02720586769282818, -0.054465893656015396, 0.019247518852353096, -0.04463840276002884, 0.008678286336362362, 0.022646116092801094, -0.0018145497888326645, 0.024718211963772774, -0.004787311889231205, 0.030828215181827545, 0.04006505012512207, -0.04638080298900604, -0.007433359976857901, 0.007577914744615555, 0.016320643946528435, 0.024356314912438393, -0.02590981125831604, -0.003451104275882244, 0.031111013144254684, -0.017088573426008224, -0.03786367177963257, 0.0013339932775124907, 0.024996554479002953, 0.04206778481602669, -0.02128458581864834, -0.025906024500727654, 0.029317904263734818, 0.004568931646645069, -0.03318832814693451, -0.02755272015929222, 0.04278458654880524, -0.03796995058655739, -0.025684909895062447, -0.024414312094449997, 0.040134403854608536, 0.09531500190496445, -0.027047201991081238, 0.04071018099784851, 0.022815655916929245, -0.013680528849363327, -0.010468811728060246, -0.008906901814043522, -0.005566631909459829, -0.03958896920084953, 0.018985019996762276, -0.045438773930072784, -0.0310404933989048, -0.0026363604702055454, -0.008666924200952053, -0.006473493296653032, 0.03765280544757843, 0.01567794941365719, -0.00958216842263937, -0.03047562763094902, 0.00020994067017454654, -0.023733772337436676, -0.0030511391814798117, -0.018719231709837914, -0.014308847486972809, 0.014687605202198029, -0.0034678932279348373, 0.043979983776807785, -0.009104873985052109, -0.03155187889933586, -0.010068770498037338, 0.038463838398456573, -0.014903423376381397, 0.04749961569905281, 0.015519312582910061, -0.0057940115220844746, 0.04439385607838631, 0.03806325048208237, -0.02866007201373577, 0.026348603889346123, 0.00821072980761528, -0.014553149230778217, -0.03829243779182434, -0.05439507216215134, -0.022421758621931076, 0.04192032665014267, -0.010961238294839859, 0.03156157582998276, -0.004584464244544506, -0.015555650927126408, -0.010923166759312153, -0.013998465612530708, 0.005030858796089888, -0.01918499544262886, -0.020879173651337624, 0.03809652477502823, 0.03205408900976181, 0.009665143676102161, 0.00878312811255455, 0.02433067373931408, 0.032627712935209274, 0.003990773111581802, -0.00689219543710351, 0.07280929386615753, 0.006304038688540459, -0.025804715231060982, -0.015888608992099762, 0.0582626536488533, -0.04698323830962181, 0.0025727495085448027, -0.036109354346990585, -0.05289053916931152, 0.005234225187450647, 0.03672146797180176, 0.018100768327713013, -0.059378694742918015, -0.021892119199037552, -0.04897313937544823, 0.008248037658631802, 0.004938828758895397, -0.022997451946139336, 0.020461376756429672, 0.022149724885821342, 0.017410587519407272, 0.004067898727953434, 0.021901633590459824, -0.036344584077596664, -0.041221633553504944, -0.014765649102628231, -0.021956833079457283, -0.049395300447940826, 0.05145137012004852, 0.02114568091928959, -0.0283980630338192, 0.05271808058023453, -0.023236267268657684, 0.020720958709716797, 0.0003224572283215821, 0.002727660583332181, 0.004233349114656448, 0.09613417088985443, 0.0016921279020607471, -0.009209048934280872, -0.019464192911982536, -0.010882661677896976, 0.13003754615783691, 0.085847869515419, 0.044869448989629745, -0.05786256864666939, 0.01698891818523407, 0.028742235153913498, 0.004216564819216728, -0.016558777540922165, -0.021947680041193962, 0.012070889584720135, -0.02048613131046295, 0.013747862540185452, 0.0887746661901474, 0.0022968139965087175, 0.018331406638026237, 0.061177656054496765, -0.04294096305966377, -0.0016577339265495539, 0.001575032714754343, 0.008724820800125599, 0.025769798085093498, 0.00744925020262599, -0.06304417550563812, 0.02326463907957077, -0.014913937076926231, 0.0173320434987545, -0.021433303132653236, -0.03015110082924366, 0.013840504921972752, -0.0009493874968029559, -0.023911943659186363, 0.0058732712641358376, 0.024044224992394447, -0.008348621428012848, 0.01784978061914444, 0.011633669957518578, -0.008419611491262913, -0.021668745204806328, 0.032031867653131485, 0.009242603555321693, -0.0010836493456736207, -0.004247581586241722, -0.009869066998362541, -0.0076963333413004875, -0.030154261738061905, -0.038656048476696014, -0.03948529437184334, 0.019086461514234543, -0.015500078909099102, -0.017430296167731285, -0.02978823147714138, -0.023663988336920738, 0.02523142099380493, -0.014493581838905811, -0.023601138964295387, 0.02087334915995598, 0.034297581762075424, -0.05505465343594551, -0.00748083833605051, -0.01915767602622509, -0.015747589990496635, -0.00357424677349627, 0.051224369555711746, 0.025029519572854042, -0.08052684366703033, -0.028632784262299538, -0.00787227600812912, 0.04593484848737717, 0.0032761075999587774, -0.025209492072463036, -0.010449404828250408, -0.02397194877266884, -0.028687885031104088, -0.028496364131569862, 0.027432898059487343, -0.0200202539563179, 0.07705718278884888, -0.02690550498664379, 0.014976712875068188, -0.057861875742673874, -0.054571669548749924, 0.03385449945926666, -0.009047829546034336, 0.004407260101288557, -0.03141109645366669, -0.009603717364370823, -0.00166502152569592, 0.029657728970050812, 0.021090026944875717, -0.005693091079592705, -0.000987559207715094, 0.05144519358873367, 0.009463002905249596, -0.05544150248169899, -0.005782305262982845, -0.01860039308667183, -0.03806997463107109, -0.00004244458978064358, -0.004545589443296194, 0.050207316875457764, 0.026773324236273766, 0.0028469085227698088, -0.009602162055671215, 0.047669753432273865, 0.002453250577673316, 0.01638013683259487, -0.004702556878328323, -0.03965163603425026, 0.00701376236975193, 0.010972472839057446, 0.019369976595044136, -0.050177186727523804, 0.014283537864685059, -0.02294016443192959, -0.012785295024514198, 0.004125417210161686, -0.028600702062249184, -0.03990941494703293, 0.04200238734483719, -0.00003073092011618428, 0.03459059074521065, -0.04573124274611473, 0.02581576257944107, 0.005075405817478895, 0.0005037717637605965, -0.04865469038486481, -0.003966443240642548, -0.03064221329987049, 0.011182713322341442, -0.03550201654434204, -0.035760097205638885, 0.020028317347168922, 0.0007142741233110428, 0.012753891758620739, -0.019188931211829185, -0.009390556253492832, -0.00855855830013752, -0.0060768392868340015, -0.04700577259063721, -0.05882933735847473, 0.04539411887526512, 0.01576327532529831, -0.02096865512430668, 0.013563592918217182, 0.02139020338654518, 0.04604513943195343, 0.029080117121338844, 0.0008404494146816432, 0.0019778625573962927, 0.01091485284268856, -0.006160480435937643, -0.012313975021243095, 0.006215205881744623, -0.00044650238123722374, 0.0015581741463392973, -0.028602220118045807, 0.003095074789598584, -0.0006466797203756869, 0.037575289607048035, -0.028329957276582718, 0.08369702100753784, 0.006037824787199497, 0.037148818373680115, 0.008272348903119564, 0.0011221608147025108, 0.039220813661813736, -0.00005750702621298842, 0.005340479779988527, 0.03119909204542637, 0.05923084542155266, -0.05841338634490967, 0.014413867145776749, -0.02417980320751667, -0.03141646459698677, -0.07997702062129974, -0.023152697831392288, 0.06888255476951599, -0.01894525997340679, 0.05144154280424118, -0.04082290083169937, 0.03305112570524216, 0.037780970335006714, -0.03747163712978363, 0.05333656445145607, -0.003496452933177352, 0.013951968401670456, -0.0008605492766946554, 0.028848592191934586, -0.022620895877480507, 0.0249793641269207, 0.027408985421061516, 0.03723263368010521, 0.019853826612234116, 0.04481162130832672, 0.04513129964470863, -0.018338948488235474, -0.012173844501376152, 0.02028007060289383, 0.03203331679105759, -0.031145010143518448, 0.07125373184680939, -0.03609282895922661, -0.03677775338292122, 0.013817341066896915, -0.025430360808968544, 0.018874451518058777, -0.01215402502566576, 0.028438303619623184, 0.004895860329270363, 0.03718194738030434, 0.04637701436877251, 0.006551881320774555, 0.0020455613266676664, -0.013591625727713108, 0.04579083248972893, -0.01476665586233139, -0.01186874695122242, 0.050213947892189026, 0.0335557647049427, -0.01639007218182087, -0.05659981071949005, 0.0221200380474329, 0.02099488489329815, -0.012884876690804958, 0.03966505825519562, 0.003201176878064871, -0.007689904421567917, -0.02347588539123535, -0.018195372074842453, -0.0200782623142004, -0.0037044005002826452, 0.027409855276346207, 0.003745185909792781, -0.0021956481505185366, -0.004138520453125238, -0.04374588653445244, -0.07122008502483368, 0.02478434145450592, -0.015005765482783318, -0.011272197589278221, -0.09321277588605881, 0.006995488423854113, 0.004545478615909815, 0.0029967601876705885, -0.07878319919109344, -0.0011542768916115165, 0.003368884325027466, 0.0305438544601202, -0.017392871901392937, 0.0077185737900435925, 0.018798895180225372, -0.023932775482535362, 0.004918397404253483, -0.06276405602693558, 0.08521101623773575, 0.027275273576378822, 0.00019307652837596834, -0.008294162340462208, -0.0365971177816391, -0.008951183408498764, 0.0012335904175415635, 0.017541848123073578, -0.0020331996493041515, -0.023609286174178123, 0.024855025112628937, -0.008641990832984447, -0.03278288617730141, -0.030515210703015327, 0.005267878994345665, -0.030159691348671913, -0.009089519269764423, -0.0017267301445826888, -0.02262311428785324, 0.00987257156521082, -0.0034916880540549755, 0.04400387406349182, -0.007865832187235355, 0.022846980020403862, 0.04435338079929352, -0.008045469410717487, 0.027592798694968224, 0.004134845454245806, 0.01037665456533432, 0.03991873562335968, -0.0033616742584854364, 0.0005507373716682196, -0.0007347999489866197, -0.006513000465929508, -0.06777748465538025, 0.044741202145814896, -0.03539102151989937, -0.02174355834722519, -0.0189558956772089, -0.01871609129011631, 0.015254033729434013, -0.06842049211263657, -0.040592532604932785, 0.024039745330810547, 0.005034382920712233, -0.008284161798655987, 0.03102397732436657, 0.015400854870676994, 0.044840987771749496, -0.005263082217425108, -0.014428017660975456, 0.021788492798805237, -0.004134480841457844, -0.02247636765241623, 0.029331734403967857, 0.06219414621591568, -0.010193697176873684, 0.03784015774726868, 0.022432206198573112, 0.003516259603202343, 0.02455238811671734, 0.004906838294118643, 0.04355647414922714, -0.0017750528641045094, -0.06296578049659729, 0.0007280006539076567, -0.006975715979933739, -0.036747898906469345, -0.015789063647389412, -0.013539022766053677, 0.04177664592862129, -0.010078971274197102, -0.009688455611467361, -0.0034121719654649496, -0.0009581116028130054, -0.03638315573334694, 0.005087133496999741, -0.03392064571380615, 0.05670898035168648, -0.01165912114083767, 0.013102316297590733, -0.002695938106626272, -0.017719347029924393, 0.0009083321201615036, -0.0010362452594563365, 0.03204603120684624, -0.0013712240615859628, -0.015926510095596313, 0.0021915524266660213, -0.04323301836848259, -0.021927788853645325, -0.04522552341222763, 0.008818099275231361, 0.006757939700037241, 0.025983599945902824, -0.019347969442605972, -0.03546527773141861, -0.016973629593849182, 0.015700187534093857, -0.06289131939411163, 0.036651138216257095, -0.017905011773109436, -0.04431958496570587, 0.027339860796928406, -0.0314016193151474 ]
<p>I have an odd problem which can be phrased in a general way, and a more specific way. I'm curious about the answers to both. Although, really, it's the k=0 case that I'm really interested in - deriving the answer with respect to some properties of the distribution of m.</p> <p>These may be totally basic, so, apologies if they are.</p> <p>1) I have several different <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypergeometric_distribution" rel="nofollow">hypergeometric distributions</a>, H(k; N, m, n) where k is the number of 'success' draws, N is the population size, m is the number of possible success draws, and n is the total number of draws. Each distribution has a different value for m, but all else is the same. Is there an easy way to either sum them up or provide a more compact notation for them?</p> <p>Or, to phrase it as a ball and urn question, I have many boxes, each with N balls. In each urn i, m(i) balls are white and the rest are black. If I take n draws from each urn in turn, what is the average probability of k white balls drawn in each urn? (indeed, is there a distribution for this - there must be)</p> <p>2) More specifically, I'm interested in the case where k=0. This actually reduced quite nicely to </p> <p>$\binom{N-m}{n}/\binom{N}{n}$</p> <p>But...again, I want to sum over a lot of different values of m from different members of a population. Is there a way to get at this with, say, an average value of m or otherwise?</p> <p>Again, in box urn terms, this would be the average probability of drawing NO white balls from any of the urns.</p> <p>p.s. I have actually always wondered a similar thing for the binomial distribution and suspect the answers may be related. Sure, B(a,p)+B(b,p) = B(a+b,p) where a and b are the number of trials and p is the probability of success. But what about B(a,p1)+B(a,p2)?</p>
74,263
[ -0.07785812020301819, -0.0507865771651268, -0.00003980120527558029, -0.03964192420244217, 0.06750574707984924, -0.008653835393488407, -0.015989024192094803, -0.011049802415072918, 0.012232408858835697, -0.0438971221446991, 0.05403035506606102, 0.05072690173983574, 0.030675891786813736, 0.023520957678556442, 0.001420854008756578, 0.010980073362588882, -0.02195826545357704, -0.006173732690513134, 0.02315746620297432, -0.00844915397465229, 0.051932547241449356, 0.02024519443511963, 0.01812400482594967, 0.006562179885804653, -0.032885801047086716, 0.016000822186470032, 0.04161706939339638, -0.041802454739809036, 0.04305528104305267, 0.06581346690654755, -0.02602405659854412, 0.00592616805806756, 0.024995412677526474, 0.07089255005121231, -0.007978937588632107, 0.02109954133629799, 0.0006765855941921473, -0.02903747372329235, -0.01444757729768753, 0.008489211089909077, -0.022731715813279152, -0.053155697882175446, -0.03221093490719795, -0.01984918676316738, -0.050009485334157944, 0.005526023451238871, 0.022157523781061172, -0.04550342261791229, 0.00611618859693408, -0.08296782523393631, 0.08193420618772507, -0.0013732605148106813, 0.02008834108710289, 0.0031253311317414045, -0.02127199061214924, 0.0015993978595361114, 0.05023496598005295, 0.07970251888036728, 0.03762669488787651, -0.041301023215055466, 0.016739027574658394, -0.01342296414077282, 0.0036294199526309967, -0.00802493654191494, -0.01462377980351448, 0.025977106764912605, -0.01023672241717577, 0.011767464689910412, -0.0008239218732342124, -0.017564335837960243, 0.04539741575717926, 0.0403338186442852, 0.05703585594892502, -0.015790745615959167, -0.0039430586621165276, -0.007381081115454435, 0.014871549792587757, 0.0005752429133281112, 0.04187159612774849, 0.007816079072654247, -0.010268916375935078, -0.014419402927160263, 0.044676344841718674, 0.03007086180150509, 0.03182368725538254, -0.02860628254711628, 0.0348188653588295, 0.020099885761737823, 0.02454337663948536, -0.0023016699124127626, 0.02091917023062706, -0.011409799568355083, 0.07872886210680008, -0.003187993774190545, -0.05322330817580223, 0.03782599791884422, -0.028945280238986015, 0.03296224772930145, 0.0025799167342483997, -0.02615293860435486, -0.020665353164076805, -0.060376059263944626, 0.017794162034988403, 0.10545989871025085, -0.025349093601107597, -0.014866698533296585, -0.054050467908382416, 0.008212522603571415, -0.010165073908865452, 0.011263747699558735, -0.002163397613912821, 0.029588930308818817, 0.020619984716176987, -0.00932465773075819, -0.007023776415735483, 0.00017767658573575318, -0.018991194665431976, 0.0021196831949055195, 0.05037428066134453, 0.06631727516651154, 0.03525036945939064, 0.005465938244014978, 0.0013292724033817649, -0.040140021592378616, -0.044461190700531006, -0.020035117864608765, 0.01941332407295704, -0.017782310023903847, -0.0467451810836792, 0.04094483330845833, 0.0018500156002119184, -0.010793807916343212, 0.05798884108662605, 0.00829654186964035, -0.005479683168232441, -0.03997998684644699, -0.0485667809844017, -0.052226122468709946, 0.011624405160546303, -0.036368321627378464, -0.03785353899002075, -0.011935667134821415, 0.0048241144977509975, 0.047681841999292374, 0.06453799456357956, 0.025822525843977928, 0.036325275897979736, -0.01969842053949833, 0.044714055955410004, 0.02782140113413334, -0.020504213869571686, -0.005265352316200733, -0.006021908484399319, -0.04200787842273712, 0.006894661113619804, -0.08108656108379364, 0.04944354295730591, 0.018337927758693695, -0.010830529034137726, -0.004031895659863949, 0.050016433000564575, 0.03473310545086861, -0.018347440287470818, -0.017570292577147484, -0.009284596890211105, -0.004860547371208668, 0.062629833817482, 0.007821250706911087, 0.04806266352534294, -0.007295960560441017, -0.005717286374419928, 0.023946698755025864, 0.010746568441390991, 0.04557044059038162, 0.01167325023561716, -0.020713821053504944, 0.020832013338804245, -0.001072732382453978, 0.020844075828790665, 0.018250523135066032, -0.03289053589105606, 0.021111944690346718, -0.008606682531535625, -0.01208855677396059, 0.014410211704671383, 0.013060255907475948, 0.024893278256058693, -0.007453986443579197, 0.0002180957089876756, -0.012544605880975723, -0.04504901170730591, -0.08796791732311249, -0.03310619294643402, -0.022611357271671295, 0.0038569490425288677, 0.01647217385470867, 0.014231088571250439, 0.003591416869312525, 0.013155622407793999, -0.009504389949142933, -0.03165578097105026, -0.01158497016876936, 0.010313838720321655, -0.07676326483488083, -0.03722238913178444, 0.042325153946876526, 0.02068912796676159, -0.04001516103744507, 0.015579033643007278, -0.05762747675180435, -0.03276624530553818, -0.04245632514357567, -0.025134271010756493, 0.009961278177797794, 0.010868583805859089, 0.024286627769470215, 0.03492889925837517, 0.007853028364479542, 0.021483013406395912, 0.0020557448733597994, -0.06498213112354279, 0.05437130481004715, 0.04340151697397232, 0.020714174956083298, -0.007960609160363674, 0.041338179260492325, -0.011815555393695831, 0.016561437398195267, 0.028189321979880333, -0.027741536498069763, -0.04668678715825081, 0.015845131129026413, 0.024722926318645477, -0.008202523924410343, -0.04558495059609413, 0.03610965609550476, 0.03047388419508934, 0.01023172214627266, -0.02851691283285618, 0.009822619147598743, 0.005261096637696028, 0.004746555350720882, -0.022436965256929398, 0.03608495369553566, 0.0042438022792339325, 0.03966625779867172, -0.00936790183186531, -0.03918272629380226, 0.008772519417107105, -0.02127450332045555, -0.04664914682507515, 0.015090277418494225, -0.021993661299347878, -0.008142359554767609, -0.05337729677557945, -0.0069427466951310635, 0.04090379551053047, -0.0290149487555027, -0.055460210889577866, 0.024006277322769165, 0.03308449313044548, 0.03307122737169266, -0.01342279277741909, -0.056141432374715805, -0.009438144974410534, -0.016569994390010834, -0.032728131860494614, -0.02034708671271801, 0.0010258465772494674, -0.012243758887052536, 0.012921970337629318, -0.021874358877539635, -0.024117765948176384, 0.0014597458066418767, 0.020548304542899132, -0.04064084216952324, 0.009154042229056358, 0.014252022840082645, 0.0012687616981565952, -0.04238498583436012, -0.011426137760281563, 0.011993546970188618, 0.007873870432376862, 0.00027616898296400905, -0.08688787370920181, 0.007148764096200466, -0.04630301520228386, -0.04631165415048599, 0.04760100692510605, -0.002355203265324235, -0.03906497359275818, 0.060049090534448624, 0.02546488121151924, -0.05020824074745178, -0.0037208995781838894, -0.02100416272878647, -0.0009280994418077171, -0.07929076254367828, 0.018820183351635933, 0.05350499600172043, 0.011741582304239273, -0.04249832034111023, 0.05208730697631836, -0.023846866562962532, -0.056859180331230164, -0.07083312422037125, 0.002679685363546014, 0.02553750015795231, -0.027996525168418884, -0.02678142674267292, -0.005529339425265789, 0.0019701130222529173, -0.026294978335499763, -0.07249712944030762, -0.042704734951257706, 0.0018076268024742603, -0.020091893151402473, 0.07025228440761566, 0.028928007930517197, -0.017590444535017014, 0.05825277417898178, 0.049391426146030426, -0.0056656417436897755, -0.023901300504803658, -0.0076020266860723495, 0.008662311360239983, -0.03472898155450821, 0.018261658027768135, 0.02083963342010975, -0.02635994553565979, 0.017347561195492744, 0.024380531162023544, 0.021619584411382675, 0.03808509558439255, -0.03565117344260216, -0.00497489282861352, 0.017046989873051643, 0.001921223709359765, -0.03269672393798828, 0.04068852588534355, 0.031248413026332855, -0.01021738164126873, 0.014795885421335697, -0.010091232135891914, -0.008546324446797371, 0.005896891932934523, -0.034395504742860794, 0.02543293498456478, 0.0010723598534241319, 0.014169304631650448, -0.014437591657042503, 0.0594063438475132, -0.00929865799844265, -0.05137895792722702, 0.008946716785430908, 0.0006575326551683247, 0.055827654898166656, -0.04333236441016197, 0.006128652486950159, 0.04439409077167511, 0.09409843385219574, -0.03840988129377365, -0.0033764613326638937, 0.008634583093225956, 0.01863969676196575, 0.0036003156565129757, 0.003885912010446191, 0.04750100150704384, 0.0036239863839000463, 0.05402934551239014, 0.012326198630034924, -0.010774492286145687, -0.013131665997207165, 0.006272648461163044, -0.056017354130744934, -0.030985821038484573, -0.025982052087783813, 0.025564098730683327, -0.009649429470300674, 0.04374416545033455, -0.012698669917881489, -0.029898706823587418, -0.012756513431668282, 0.01083218865096569, -0.047626592218875885, 0.004545893985778093, -0.023105472326278687, -0.002472911262884736, -0.0335526168346405, -0.04713348299264908, 0.01327908132225275, 0.015556344762444496, 0.003727867966517806, -0.00039145752089098096, 0.04443102702498436, -0.014207723550498486, 0.034575097262859344, 0.003603407647460699, -0.02356395311653614, 0.0375792570412159, 0.04840727150440216, -0.01175947766751051, 0.031247464939951897, 0.023897361010313034, 0.02096754126250744, 0.013429742306470871, -0.024441776797175407, -0.013379888609051704, 0.03412783518433571, 0.024766264483332634, 0.026249896734952927, 0.022752627730369568, 0.07691973447799683, -0.050003282725811005, -0.015682468190789223, -0.007157325744628906, 0.04841900244355202, 0.03229556605219841, -0.021631352603435516, 0.04691353812813759, -0.04628468677401543, -0.014523032121360302, 0.007105033379048109, 0.019678832963109016, -0.029249157756567, 0.012009571306407452, 0.0341009758412838, 0.01115165650844574, -0.017359675839543343, 0.00789876189082861, 0.019466588273644447, -0.01270994357764721, 0.016825241968035698, -0.02621997706592083, 0.029930338263511658, -0.016333211213350296, 0.03269267827272415, -0.03171243891119957, 0.004794864449650049, 0.009392684325575829, -0.012348590418696404, 0.03580360859632492, 0.02350248396396637, -0.028206538408994675, 0.003839445998892188, 0.03221837058663368, 0.024946384131908417, -0.01715259626507759, -0.04266395792365074, 0.01745803840458393, 0.08019252121448517, -0.019586456939578056, -0.002099915873259306, -0.013862239196896553, -0.04630555957555771, -0.010873082093894482, 0.04506845399737358, 0.035906579345464706, -0.009376932866871357, -0.0025794983375817537, -0.043919697403907776, 0.0032761706970632076, 0.014606880024075508, -0.002092518378049135, 0.011541756801307201, 0.01227579452097416, 0.030014922842383385, -0.01082643587142229, -0.021014142781496048, -0.05529438331723213, 0.012396413832902908, -0.020216356962919235, 0.03192182257771492, -0.038587167859077454, 0.02166673168540001, -0.024581179022789, 0.044844429939985275, 0.04680050164461136, 0.051807064563035965, -0.030885610729455948, -0.009119215421378613, 0.004534473642706871, 0.007330745458602905, 0.01523726899176836, -0.07895452529191971, 0.03875718638300896, -0.012319812551140785, -0.01622251234948635, 0.05643836781382561, -0.02904617041349411, -0.022319091483950615, 0.035657960921525955, -0.03305118903517723, -0.023603146895766258, 0.041017334908246994, -0.05886951461434364, 0.015334252268075943, 0.0364123210310936, 0.004885254427790642, 0.051533374935388565, -0.004341051913797855, -0.01732509210705757, -0.003444577567279339, -0.041914548724889755, 0.0018720431253314018, -0.02166053093969822, -0.004291595425456762, -0.051816873252391815, -0.005009449552744627, 0.0027431047055870295, 0.0297306627035141, -0.008832480758428574, -0.00040690082823857665, -0.013558533042669296, -0.03327382728457451, 0.011228405870497227, -0.0014924925053492188, -0.0014737341552972794, 0.04954187944531441, 0.031939130276441574, -0.004195401445031166, 0.011998319998383522, -0.01244051568210125, 0.06453175097703934, 0.011005543172359467, 0.01001620665192604, 0.04458026587963104, -0.021567128598690033, 0.0025251300539821386, -0.06809025257825851, -0.03375621512532234, 0.016927801072597504, 0.001980541041120887, 0.05321148410439491, -0.0028930045664310455, 0.055607929825782776, 0.038641829043626785, -0.034248050302267075, -0.017910854890942574, 0.00286312703974545, -0.013156700879335403, 0.012056555598974228, -0.037132471799850464, 0.029388055205345154, 0.018865058198571205, -0.0036085357423871756, -0.08147862553596497, -0.022716796025633812, 0.013039791025221348, -0.034908875823020935, -0.020699700340628624, -0.0306237880140543, -0.018747203052043915, -0.01580728031694889, -0.04705512523651123, 0.026551920920610428, 0.058975279331207275, -0.023973403498530388, -0.011226844973862171, -0.014616014435887337, 0.005746459122747183, 0.06276889890432358, 0.015353528782725334, -0.014747588895261288, 0.023240365087985992, -0.018180983141064644, -0.008021467365324497, 0.012205105274915695, 0.02896317094564438, -0.039198655635118484, -0.00603558449074626, -0.009714670479297638, 0.00832205731421709, 0.051360610872507095, -0.0357988215982914, -0.047160301357507706, 0.03023023158311844, 0.0070938062854111195, 0.0018261584918946028, -0.011198763735592365, 0.015879889950156212, -0.0033115146216005087, -0.00808180682361126, -0.02569602057337761, -0.0316309779882431, -0.01456329133361578, -0.01093587651848793, 0.022432560101151466, 0.0033010293263942003, -0.022843720391392708, 0.00841965526342392, 0.08808211982250214, -0.005877342075109482, -0.028694365173578262, -0.01620705984532833, -0.006022901274263859, 0.03775031119585037, -0.011152430437505245, -0.02590727061033249, 0.0073965974152088165, -0.0019118372583761811, 0.008955874480307102, -0.007921532727777958, -0.04708104580640793, -0.011118164286017418, 0.02003418654203415, -0.009362781420350075, 0.044021692126989365, -0.005250927992165089, 0.008682440035045147, 0.02068895846605301, -0.0037607888225466013, 0.013427026569843292, -0.009803850203752518, 0.03801592439413071, 0.05158642679452896, -0.028320036828517914, -0.004875638522207737, 0.041708219796419144, 0.042838551104068756, 0.015733491629362106, 0.02928091213107109, -0.0044799731113016605, -0.02413828670978546, 0.05318215861916542, -0.047887884080410004, -0.06419681012630463, 0.057577576488256454, -0.04133075475692749, 0.02879299968481064, -0.02822946198284626, -0.03783441707491875, 0.02916211448609829, 0.04626604914665222, -0.01879190281033516, -0.056245457381010056, -0.015068111009895802, -0.0060309055261313915, 0.0009453131933696568, 0.02245395816862583, -0.017107397317886353, 0.03894734010100365, -0.05548902228474617, 0.022086719051003456, -0.00209885835647583, 0.01211523823440075, -0.008955979719758034, -0.05124962329864502, -0.002412954578176141, -0.03905100002884865, -0.09362916648387909, -0.010861734859645367, -0.0006816511740908027, 0.025106601417064667, 0.007042257115244865, -0.011387585662305355, 0.029053131118416786, 0.009346489794552326, 0.021643808111548424, -0.00478149950504303, 0.06712812930345535, -0.002475772053003311, 0.039496779441833496, -0.004545842297375202, -0.024687932804226875, 0.1353902369737625, 0.05173709616065025, 0.03676299750804901, -0.059962689876556396, -0.00978734903037548, -0.005497967824339867, -0.0016354438848793507, -0.019883112981915474, -0.018308980390429497, -0.008469555526971817, -0.007654972840100527, 0.059807658195495605, 0.045111995190382004, -0.026997415348887444, -0.026829136535525322, 0.03712066635489464, -0.024919945746660233, -0.03269496560096741, 0.01551870722323656, 0.03603341057896614, 0.010856261476874352, 0.015710845589637756, -0.04066668450832367, 0.04251682013273239, 0.016161920502781868, -0.022649815306067467, -0.03649751842021942, -0.028805486857891083, 0.00947430357336998, 0.005428090691566467, -0.017465865239501, 0.03595636785030365, 0.02985323965549469, -0.029289385303854942, -0.01894419454038143, 0.009122845716774464, 0.022343426942825317, -0.06947217136621475, 0.03141845762729645, 0.039070285856723785, 0.027524512261152267, 0.0028934055007994175, 0.02661738358438015, 0.007710591424256563, -0.08416767418384552, -0.024720018729567528, -0.05427679046988487, 0.024787820875644684, -0.009942219592630863, -0.0074698724783957005, -0.03384391963481903, -0.016179917380213737, 0.003481740364804864, -0.053652845323085785, 0.003853384405374527, 0.007754165679216385, 0.03929709643125534, -0.04910843446850777, -0.02178960293531418, 0.0045918249525129795, 0.03311147913336754, 0.044108737260103226, -0.0037747619207948446, -0.0027607812080532312, -0.014168900437653065, -0.015188602730631828, -0.018233533948659897, 0.01861324906349182, 0.02676825225353241, -0.03985920175909996, -0.03338976949453354, -0.023205475881695747, -0.02016710676252842, 0.018600918352603912, -0.007822361774742603, 0.01140506099909544, 0.03767460584640503, 0.01875709928572178, -0.006881786976009607, 0.018995698541402817, -0.04802890121936798, 0.0170797947794199, -0.015268842689692974, -0.004164956044405699, -0.012353354133665562, 0.004583634436130524, -0.011997745372354984, 0.025568440556526184, 0.022601770237088203, -0.004197688307613134, 0.0101840291172266, 0.05828764662146568, 0.016224699094891548, -0.00006232944724615663, 0.0034419831354171038, 0.0034627029672265053, -0.0166887529194355, -0.01839025504887104, -0.0159760694950819, 0.002085137413814664, 0.0038344557397067547, 0.0177620779722929, -0.0028493173886090517, 0.00023965505533851683, 0.019855646416544914, -0.002724983263760805, -0.050142399966716766, -0.07258804142475128, 0.007056940346956253, 0.0010825727367773652, -0.004159706179052591, -0.022950876504182816, -0.05115516111254692, 0.005136406049132347, -0.025828098878264427, 0.044924017041921616, -0.034829556941986084, -0.023421378806233406, -0.025448422878980637, -0.04401011019945145, 0.00669066933915019, 0.03606110066175461, -0.009230103343725204, -0.0007961631054058671, -0.01704922877252102, -0.018266858533024788, 0.012161286547780037, 0.005860855802893639, 0.0203928891569376, 0.00854111835360527, 0.005676649510860443, 0.04158153012394905, 0.038830406963825226, 0.032990191131830215, -0.006716905627399683, 0.026702404022216797, 0.001364996307529509, 0.03472338989377022, 0.003143471898511052, -0.023816784843802452, 0.04213736578822136, -0.04673999547958374, -0.017917601391673088, 0.021557535976171494, 0.012382468208670616, 0.0216068048030138, 0.02964031510055065, -0.020709315314888954, -0.04622061923146248, 0.06096392869949341, -0.059482138603925705, -0.012593761086463928, 0.012825108133256435, -0.02330290526151657, 0.03410625457763672, -0.008505258709192276, -0.015989551320672035, 0.004411966539919376, -0.022791927680373192, 0.01878391206264496, 0.004789688158780336, -0.008900515735149384, -0.00003458775609033182, 0.014834795147180557, 0.0016492909053340554, -0.019321024417877197, -0.029008157551288605, 0.000611046445555985, 0.026603763923048973, 0.034968119114637375, -0.027429280802607536, 0.04306556284427643, -0.018872981891036034, -0.006343052256852388, -0.08054541051387787, 0.0046224878169596195, 0.03461442515254021, 0.011068263091146946, 0.07699250429868698, -0.040755514055490494, -0.018515339121222496, 0.016810273751616478, -0.05238940194249153, 0.028867516666650772, -0.014292613603174686, -0.0035631530918180943, -0.04719455912709236, 0.03774192929267883, -0.011875521391630173, 0.02326999604701996, 0.03383416682481766, 0.03660261258482933, 0.04268239438533783, 0.02335761860013008, -0.04113108664751053, -0.02564069628715515, -0.009342472068965435, 0.02080376446247101, -0.0009332710178568959, -0.020478494465351105, 0.04978788271546364, -0.01286501344293356, -0.031618617475032806, 0.02683807536959648, -0.011250457726418972, -0.007084248587489128, 0.004831003490835428, 0.006932710763067007, 0.02468196302652359, 0.025342365726828575, -0.009723197668790817, -0.008084007538855076, -0.01087390910834074, -0.00039814942283555865, 0.05378950387239456, 0.006184395868331194, -0.04235468804836273, 0.03048151545226574, 0.06225614622235298, -0.011371491476893425, -0.04354720562696457, 0.006830123718827963, 0.009068298153579235, -0.06008457764983177, 0.0006251329323276877, -0.03301740437746048, 0.03629930317401886, 0.02840254083275795, 0.04531056806445122, -0.02413332648575306, -0.0011338384356349707, 0.02356303110718727, 0.00014742478379048407, -0.003575031878426671, 0.021900592371821404, -0.014365773648023605, -0.047858595848083496, 0.010553762316703796, 0.015060587786138058, -0.01934048905968666, -0.016275733709335327, -0.01489808689802885, -0.02717674896121025, 0.07074625790119171, -0.004664722364395857, -0.013894257135689259, -0.03394274413585663, 0.014119153842329979, -0.004135246388614178, 0.0198625847697258, 0.0012982963817194104, -0.014296908862888813, -0.01986665651202202, -0.04753373563289642, 0.038506653159856796, 0.040252529084682465, 0.011847574263811111, -0.040820006281137466, 0.000393200054531917, 0.01736815832555294, -0.023897211998701096, 0.04714871197938919, 0.001985268434509635, 0.006987702567130327, 0.003069076919928193, 0.02504335530102253, 0.041443973779678345, -0.06386277079582214, 0.030960075557231903, -0.02857062965631485, -0.02408602461218834, -0.05784614756703377, 0.013804877176880836, 0.009605132043361664, 0.028569228947162628, 0.01756417565047741, -0.05585256218910217, -0.02435990422964096, -0.006716437172144651, 0.0010486473329365253, 0.0372401624917984, 0.014468523673713207, -0.03522486239671707, 0.029651585966348648, -0.011828942224383354, 0.02365099824965, 0.019507883116602898, 0.010530714876949787, -0.03274132311344147, 0.029696481302380562, -0.0352298766374588, -0.04007440432906151, -0.010408768430352211, 0.008698459714651108, 0.016529254615306854, -0.040483273565769196, 0.015834657475352287, 0.02878914400935173, -0.02185722626745701, -0.05176481232047081, 0.033212073147296906, 0.016873979941010475, 0.05271805822849274, 0.004129731561988592, 0.02295357547700405, -0.023179084062576294, -0.02144927904009819, 0.014475198462605476, 0.021583903580904007, 0.00860108993947506, -0.004957267083227634, 0.006199339870363474, -0.012050713412463665, 0.030401987954974174, 0.0451941154897213, 0.009134973399341106, 0.03770741820335388, -0.019252290949225426, -0.03113485313951969, 0.025755371898412704, -0.041587959975004196, 0.019242940470576286, -0.00828753411769867, -0.002958684228360653, 0.06370946019887924, 0.02009354904294014, 0.011684737168252468, -0.05650736391544342, -0.02718956768512726, -0.025475936010479927, -0.014928772114217281, -0.016808701679110527, 0.022686460986733437, -0.013708194717764854, 0.021412109956145287, 0.018535850569605827, 0.03143139183521271, 0.06963556259870529, -0.028409242630004883, 0.04206989333033562, -0.0015028280904516578, -0.012021118775010109, -0.013704221695661545, -0.05223226547241211, -0.012331375852227211, -0.0175965316593647, 0.033830609172582626, 0.033891987055540085, 0.003222122322767973, 0.014806779101490974, 0.03738614544272423, -0.009187483228743076, 0.06290380656719208, -0.04293062910437584, -0.0033853226341307163, -0.04981992766261101, 0.0019515648018568754, 0.020013485103845596, -0.01564706489443779 ]
<p>As I have written in my question "<a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/7209/how-much-undersampling-should-be-done">How much undersampling should be done?</a>", I want to predict defaults, where a default is per se really unlikely (average ~ 0.3 percent). My models are not affected by the unequal distribution: It's all about saving computing time.</p> <p>Undersampling the majority class to a ratio [defaulting/non-defaulting examples] of 1:1 is the same as expressing the believe that I think examples are equally important in increasing the prediction quality.</p> <p>Does anyone know a reason why/when equal importance could <strong>not</strong> be the case? Is there literature on this specific topic (I could not find sampling-literature that modeling/computation-oriented)?</p> <p>Thanks a lot for your help!</p>
48,763
[ -0.033298783004283905, -0.013433409854769707, 0.03483803942799568, -0.035826705396175385, 0.0194863248616457, 0.01230555772781372, -0.019988341256976128, -0.03046642430126667, 0.041856300085783005, -0.02574404515326023, 0.049566905945539474, 0.020980164408683777, 0.08901731669902802, 0.03366825357079506, 0.0008969858172349632, 0.020529361441731453, 0.010188998654484749, -0.021128080785274506, -0.013738205656409264, 0.007727612741291523, -0.03860488906502724, 0.012434293515980244, 0.033751752227544785, -0.012947694398462772, -0.02628304436802864, 0.05918242037296295, 0.02753116376698017, -0.003949546255171299, 0.012973269447684288, 0.04667886719107628, -0.023509085178375244, -0.009087923914194107, 0.04068870097398758, 0.07252202183008194, 0.03382360190153122, 0.02935163676738739, -0.006801860872656107, -0.0017299148021265864, -0.0016340664587914944, 0.03603997454047203, 0.0025224455166608095, -0.020758438855409622, -0.008187766186892986, 0.0018218206241726875, -0.013559236191213131, -0.00002715857590374071, 0.00426403246819973, -0.05322912707924843, 0.024986369535326958, -0.04090515524148941, 0.04066853225231171, 0.012097674421966076, 0.03151773288846016, 0.0543961375951767, -0.02708761766552925, -0.010550512000918388, 0.06375685334205627, 0.08483774960041046, 0.011703893542289734, -0.07023464888334274, 0.012646659277379513, -0.03766193613409996, 0.002900660503655672, -0.004057975020259619, -0.0180768221616745, 0.05836689844727516, 0.006069505121558905, -0.037211284041404724, 0.03300725668668747, 0.0005297362804412842, 0.016158660873770714, 0.006984723266214132, 0.008748266845941544, -0.028078852221369743, -0.0057372404262423515, 0.018576931208372116, 0.009064078330993652, 0.042945340275764465, 0.03593221679329872, 0.039710406213998795, -0.010243752971291542, 0.02394217438995838, 0.04899297654628754, -0.003359841648489237, -0.0010117191122844815, 0.01911637745797634, 0.07064037024974823, -0.032031118869781494, 0.007268117740750313, 0.014901861548423767, -0.03843405470252037, -0.0012772302143275738, 0.019026705995202065, -0.00713482266291976, -0.04369732737541199, 0.03467283770442009, 0.01142009999603033, 0.007581614423543215, 0.010268389247357845, 0.011627545580267906, -0.046649448573589325, -0.056525178253650665, 0.01537300180643797, 0.05926631763577461, -0.024622345343232155, -0.010225758887827396, -0.038221023976802826, 0.0013781314482912421, -0.017971519380807877, -0.0328395701944828, -0.006867550313472748, 0.033320847898721695, -0.008468948304653168, -0.02228965237736702, -0.011794540099799633, 0.007553684525191784, 0.02299741841852665, -0.003990559838712215, 0.02104468271136284, 0.037660058587789536, 0.04709872230887413, -0.018342403694987297, 0.0017324091168120503, -0.03686557337641716, -0.028441809117794037, 0.0037886870559304953, 0.008177599869668484, -0.008018621243536472, -0.06574324518442154, 0.06728585064411163, -0.020618978887796402, -0.00517635652795434, 0.04144297167658806, -0.008921350352466106, 0.05346014350652695, 0.014690176583826542, -0.08230942487716675, -0.07223885506391525, 0.02722734585404396, -0.0365937277674675, 0.0071672098711133, -0.054843656718730927, -0.015413610264658928, 0.043648574501276016, 0.022356944158673286, -0.005606234539300203, 0.07322732359170914, 0.00792202539741993, 0.007589160464704037, 0.039836663752794266, -0.020240630954504013, -0.004147260915488005, -0.034146759659051895, -0.004622554872184992, -0.031120318919420242, -0.087088942527771, 0.021302776411175728, 0.005861910525709391, -0.02275620959699154, 0.004063698463141918, 0.017461571842432022, -0.01352648064494133, -0.004629392642527819, -0.020633472129702568, 0.005748838651925325, -0.03320341557264328, 0.04452712461352348, 0.01394271943718195, 0.045004453510046005, 0.021585889160633087, -0.04127068072557449, 0.018187444657087326, 0.019228650256991386, 0.014051423408091068, 0.03815867006778717, -0.008744298480451107, 0.010631835088133812, -0.02669849433004856, 0.026016805320978165, 0.008813468739390373, -0.0439777635037899, -0.025531908497214317, -0.021917348727583885, 0.017625493928790092, -0.020181989297270775, 0.03390372171998024, -0.00014088682655710727, -0.035497039556503296, 0.02071143500506878, -0.044398412108421326, -0.08393725752830505, -0.045549724251031876, -0.028475942090153694, -0.024528032168745995, -0.03386402502655983, 0.03027576208114624, -0.013326214626431465, 0.001456337166018784, -0.005054709501564503, 0.0012743457918986678, -0.03799166530370712, -0.036842621862888336, 0.04247269779443741, -0.06605003029108047, 0.020778441801667213, 0.020625604316592216, -0.02688087336719036, -0.0264397282153368, 0.04897036403417587, -0.04728902131319046, -0.07905644923448563, 0.02985168993473053, -0.05447925254702568, -0.008477906696498394, -0.017185186967253685, -0.01717383973300457, 0.05916915088891983, -0.015199607238173485, -0.030496563762426376, 0.011412272229790688, -0.057871263474226, 0.06015649810433388, 0.03939031809568405, -0.023848963901400566, -0.033482324331998825, 0.021833067759871483, 0.021666593849658966, 0.006069754250347614, -0.04933974891901016, 0.019208639860153198, -0.06967146694660187, 0.0286987517029047, 0.05205899849534035, 0.014306614175438881, -0.053667157888412476, -0.004504829179495573, 0.033273447304964066, 0.013496873900294304, 0.037700992077589035, 0.01933121122419834, 0.0017121394630521536, -0.04116066172719002, -0.005945323035120964, 0.01858816295862198, 0.032020628452301025, -0.009251733310520649, 0.0005952070350758731, -0.0029302146285772324, 0.003924368415027857, 0.023660073056817055, -0.034456878900527954, 0.05641111731529236, 0.010623959824442863, 0.0071542286314070225, -0.014934524893760681, -0.005333255045115948, 0.031017282977700233, -0.03413088619709015, -0.007866046391427517, 0.03934517502784729, -0.004846754018217325, 0.018388697877526283, 0.019997669383883476, -0.02902578003704548, 0.03512793034315109, 0.047662559896707535, -0.02390584722161293, 0.03956298157572746, 0.018509384244680405, -0.014575927518308163, -0.01680651120841503, -0.031790055334568024, -0.032882992178201675, -0.03196179121732712, -0.002274955390021205, 0.08173075318336487, 0.0002724924997892231, 0.012389326468110085, -0.030326955020427704, -0.012013707309961319, -0.02096547745168209, 0.007370303850620985, 0.02292766608297825, 0.01338016614317894, -0.048842962831258774, -0.014160488732159138, -0.02157229743897915, -0.027438722550868988, 0.04598885402083397, -0.005406620446592569, -0.04431883245706558, -0.016469761729240417, 0.0032491583842784166, -0.03358294442296028, -0.05411260202527046, -0.04158388450741768, 0.037783414125442505, -0.025148479267954826, -0.05820504203438759, 0.04019109904766083, -0.0071832602843642235, -0.04999565705657005, 0.011334778741002083, -0.006588843185454607, -0.03198196366429329, -0.002324712695553899, -0.0019840190652757883, 0.025184782221913338, -0.0034507347736507654, 0.011297292076051235, -0.004644292872399092, -0.0007272974471561611, 0.00018506257038097829, -0.07037604600191116, -0.04116125404834747, 0.03421396017074585, -0.002623873995617032, 0.05786851793527603, 0.033009789884090424, 0.00628451444208622, 0.08766429871320724, 0.06098813936114311, -0.01962714083492756, -0.026599660515785217, -0.0325130820274353, -0.009948555380105972, -0.015022948384284973, 0.009115545079112053, 0.012646060436964035, -0.004618083592504263, 0.005976279266178608, 0.00776341138407588, 0.039338819682598114, 0.02515675686299801, -0.00592588447034359, 0.01526849064975977, 0.030680418014526367, -0.03391744941473007, 0.023678209632635117, 0.011532602831721306, 0.044975705444812775, -0.018886644393205643, -0.010596764273941517, -0.02517750672996044, 0.05841432884335518, 0.015373210422694683, -0.011389569379389286, 0.030052194371819496, -0.012041859328746796, 0.014889275655150414, -0.02951202355325222, 0.03970663249492645, 0.005939585156738758, -0.02202816680073738, -0.03545814007520676, 0.0072840740904212, -0.0018323136027902365, -0.01976798288524151, -0.0296259056776762, 0.07839805632829666, 0.05940626189112663, -0.009081264957785606, -0.023948989808559418, -0.02303127758204937, 0.012922612950205803, 0.024076778441667557, -0.02017631009221077, -0.0075334287248551846, 0.03782801702618599, 0.08163401484489441, -0.014612734317779541, 0.016710957512259483, -0.06900300830602646, -0.005399992223829031, -0.05901947245001793, -0.004818677436560392, -0.040863391011953354, 0.08601244539022446, 0.026228992268443108, 0.045197758823633194, 0.01662367954850197, -0.0011560717830434442, -0.016194183379411697, 0.02572377771139145, -0.05429786816239357, 0.015676120296120644, 0.008777541108429432, -0.019298803061246872, 0.01766561158001423, -0.01860545016825199, 0.019059032201766968, -0.03722754865884781, -0.016528569161891937, -0.025108208879828453, 0.047010164707899094, -0.030791768804192543, 0.03381865471601486, 0.004364122170954943, 0.01589796133339405, -0.04792691394686699, 0.011288287118077278, -0.016532761976122856, -0.010479831136763096, 0.031109748408198357, 0.005794658325612545, -0.017054731026291847, -0.007933126762509346, -0.05084317922592163, 0.03798433020710945, 0.011554552242159843, 0.056568972766399384, 0.0240489449352026, 0.03916625678539276, -0.06872978806495667, -0.009574292227625847, 0.032537560909986496, 0.060635071247816086, 0.033827587962150574, 0.007783530279994011, -0.027184011414647102, -0.04236399382352829, -0.04179913550615311, 0.02972719818353653, 0.05021173134446144, -0.02409704029560089, -0.020678985863924026, 0.05371919274330139, 0.011837806552648544, -0.0402170866727829, 0.03540665656328201, 0.03406718745827675, 0.00982380285859108, 0.008256279863417149, -0.0501953586935997, -0.002796788699924946, -0.008658986538648605, 0.022237129509449005, 0.005410733632743359, 0.028312694281339645, -0.0037162895314395428, -0.027186904102563858, 0.0032085170969367027, -0.028854545205831528, -0.014721688814461231, -0.008432344533503056, 0.016070563346147537, 0.03520994260907173, 0.00896554533392191, -0.0520918183028698, -0.001583265489898622, 0.02463432401418686, 0.03767399862408638, 0.041054867208004, 0.0323086716234684, -0.0631764605641365, -0.03485671058297157, 0.06803637742996216, 0.04536058381199837, -0.03273385018110275, 0.002775119850412011, -0.02667924389243126, 0.005504385102540255, 0.01961613819003105, -0.022620730102062225, 0.016074489802122116, 0.006085858214646578, -0.009307002648711205, -0.005801433697342873, -0.044253792613744736, -0.03336815536022186, 0.03371855616569519, -0.028861552476882935, 0.07796816527843475, -0.005334370769560337, -0.04314002767205238, -0.06024399399757385, 0.007809856440871954, 0.0007903616642579436, 0.048428911715745926, -0.05420076474547386, -0.0003900214796885848, -0.016677547246217728, 0.03490518778562546, -0.006502449978142977, -0.07723535597324371, -0.022594839334487915, -0.013693777844309807, 0.002744529163464904, 0.029884498566389084, -0.05306055024266243, -0.02775234915316105, 0.03181494027376175, 0.027924252673983574, -0.015566369518637657, 0.005363729782402515, -0.014790993183851242, 0.04079201817512512, -0.013786807656288147, -0.004998661577701569, 0.02641439065337181, 0.0036736384499818087, 0.005066043231636286, 0.0013649665052071214, -0.04817638546228409, -0.03231139853596687, -0.04463847354054451, -0.022465046495199203, -0.04802386462688446, -0.027098169550299644, -0.03596476465463638, 0.028416572138667107, 0.02618853561580181, 0.07129817456007004, -0.013341679237782955, -0.013148755766451359, -0.025786714628338814, 0.007217202801257372, 0.044634342193603516, -0.008402827195823193, -0.02606979012489319, 0.024181116372346878, -0.031469445675611496, 0.028086954727768898, 0.027408501133322716, -0.04786621779203415, 0.0013379951706156135, 0.03172719106078148, -0.07146888971328735, 0.0022838234435766935, -0.027493230998516083, -0.023959273472428322, -0.014437013305723667, -0.00725553510710597, 0.019972434267401695, 0.007494035176932812, 0.06844914704561234, -0.008622282184660435, -0.026194259524345398, -0.019006943330168724, 0.041904136538505554, -0.009080832824110985, 0.054749805480241776, -0.018732113763689995, 0.03960259258747101, -0.003942337352782488, 0.010829905048012733, -0.04168946295976639, -0.02448348142206669, 0.022795645520091057, 0.013860308565199375, -0.002000536536797881, -0.01974577270448208, -0.015515836887061596, -0.011857891455292702, -0.017035558819770813, -0.0059221903793513775, 0.041724611073732376, 0.0070436811074614525, -0.02994566410779953, -0.008522667922079563, -0.01795211061835289, 0.07924952358007431, -0.033093176782131195, 0.007235764525830746, 0.028230788186192513, -0.013609351590275764, -0.05174988880753517, -0.01888837106525898, 0.01883542165160179, -0.051354046911001205, -0.03659261018037796, -0.027748534455895424, -0.008485209196805954, 0.03808761388063431, -0.030066009610891342, 0.015034903772175312, 0.023073941469192505, -0.014551694504916668, 0.0064069838263094425, -0.01833660714328289, -0.013312654569745064, 0.0031268387101590633, -0.0031089908443391323, -0.018241900950670242, 0.006600795313715935, -0.001100876135751605, -0.008086180314421654, 0.00808713212609291, 0.022471854463219643, -0.02436571940779686, 0.004241857212036848, 0.0637020394206047, -0.01141389925032854, 0.010659205727279186, -0.008468135260045528, -0.0645708441734314, 0.05232061445713043, 0.04888657107949257, 0.013039575889706612, 0.005809740163385868, 0.03903352469205856, -0.015433918684720993, -0.007594035007059574, -0.010427500121295452, 0.013163532130420208, 0.026501130312681198, -0.004548295401036739, 0.04859405755996704, 0.05241858959197998, -0.03888678923249245, -0.014305449090898037, -0.03782699257135391, -0.010914003476500511, -0.032155752182006836, -0.004246789962053299, 0.005513820331543684, -0.0014834953472018242, 0.003719290718436241, 0.05173244699835777, -0.018536780029535294, 0.03293362259864807, 0.029615677893161774, 0.002324444241821766, 0.028198914602398872, 0.027365082874894142, -0.025800859555602074, -0.03232939541339874, 0.05637244135141373, -0.039580315351486206, -0.010034113191068172, -0.012018180452287197, -0.02483515255153179, 0.02612222544848919, 0.02189367637038231, 0.013145367614924908, -0.03525509685277939, -0.015125625766813755, -0.04457801952958107, 0.025280378758907318, 0.014106636866927147, -0.004295865073800087, 0.025434836745262146, 0.019010426476597786, 0.016053972765803337, -0.005101850721985102, 0.026279175654053688, -0.03806859254837036, -0.1037524938583374, -0.009028999134898186, 0.00036464311415329576, -0.01988006941974163, 0.012037406675517559, 0.018300682306289673, -0.021548401564359665, 0.04409550130367279, -0.01751968264579773, 0.0335773229598999, 0.0064116185531020164, 0.020971190184354782, -0.027763158082962036, 0.06188041716814041, 0.01093476265668869, 0.06534481793642044, -0.017895733937621117, -0.0019341561710461974, 0.13467004895210266, 0.05848800390958786, 0.052251629531383514, -0.040372561663389206, 0.0215863436460495, 0.0309943575412035, 0.0019374502589926124, 0.019172601401805878, -0.03311346843838692, 0.011493529193103313, 0.013311725109815598, 0.017872145399451256, 0.04589422419667244, 0.0027023013681173325, -0.030713779851794243, 0.04180457442998886, -0.03052099235355854, 0.012118651531636715, 0.025623371824622154, 0.05145751312375069, 0.03218318894505501, -0.03534381464123726, -0.04711417108774185, 0.027934644371271133, -0.01451477874070406, -0.03147147595882416, -0.0006829873891547322, -0.022770477458834648, -0.002580360509455204, -0.0328281931579113, 0.009055466391146183, -0.00942113995552063, 0.02253899723291397, -0.01023310236632824, -0.01439101342111826, -0.019965192303061485, 0.009401461109519005, -0.04214058816432953, 0.0111457584425807, 0.02587064728140831, -0.004128230735659599, -0.0006633301381953061, -0.005646616220474243, 0.04393193870782852, -0.025616122409701347, -0.00802470650523901, -0.06902867555618286, 0.0041857436299324036, 0.019519170746207237, -0.003247597021982074, -0.009637348353862762, 0.013842850923538208, 0.03697500750422478, -0.03932029381394386, -0.03837011754512787, 0.006098076701164246, 0.04571611061692238, -0.026708535850048065, -0.047046959400177, -0.007879220880568027, 0.004676175769418478, 0.007066662423312664, 0.004451463930308819, -0.01148719247430563, -0.04701080173254013, -0.07667665928602219, -0.03151135519146919, 0.02211400680243969, 0.022778986021876335, 0.025479324162006378, 0.0007007112726569176, -0.01276817824691534, -0.036014534533023834, -0.0010593925835564733, -0.0030605439096689224, -0.02311718836426735, 0.06144014000892639, -0.022923201322555542, 0.005933631677180529, -0.03984735906124115, -0.014155388809740543, 0.009376744739711285, -0.017794087529182434, 0.015562145970761776, -0.016732538118958473, -0.03266304358839989, 0.00499669648706913, -0.015632539987564087, 0.030927639454603195, -0.0036994689144194126, 0.0523592010140419, 0.057498250156641006, 0.004987638909369707, -0.03403055667877197, -0.02116427570581436, -0.03793400898575783, -0.041446078568696976, 0.033279042690992355, 0.01889238879084587, 0.04723615199327469, 0.0023177049588412046, 0.011823375709354877, -0.015622936189174652, 0.015287565998733044, 0.014902891591191292, -0.01044483296573162, 0.008045153692364693, -0.06038672477006912, -0.008138005621731281, 0.03285980597138405, -0.007043361198157072, -0.03302788734436035, 0.0007330438238568604, -0.012095984071493149, -0.0057636285200715065, 0.006126419175416231, -0.0141231007874012, -0.03149003908038139, 0.02094588242471218, 0.02986879274249077, 0.03927312046289444, -0.0005494546494446695, -0.03869755193591118, -0.006373483221977949, -0.010347583331167698, -0.019013406708836555, -0.03461566939949989, 0.022082751616835594, -0.02027476392686367, 0.03756579011678696, -0.00032811769051477313, -0.0055902558378875256, 0.0025685965083539486, 0.0071446457877755165, -0.002717445371672511, 0.014239360578358173, -0.017007363960146904, 0.03486635163426399, -0.014963699504733086, -0.006594614125788212, 0.03345956280827522, -0.04118748754262924, -0.00034975470043718815, 0.017095360904932022, -0.008026586845517159, 0.02160557545721531, 0.013078698888421059, -0.02415074221789837, -0.02246163971722126, 0.052776407450437546, -0.02809414267539978, 0.0004242272116243839, 0.006019939202815294, 0.03566635027527809, 0.01718251034617424, -0.010157622396945953, -0.03544805198907852, 0.00773364445194602, -0.0014791951980441809, 0.04180307686328888, 0.03814709559082985, 0.0118572311475873, -0.047133613377809525, 0.034092649817466736, 0.01221822015941143, 0.03302551805973053, -0.013865797780454159, 0.03695191070437431, 0.02863328903913498, 0.03907288238406181, -0.04644559323787689, 0.017396477982401848, -0.03479478880763054, 0.0002316203317604959, -0.1032082661986351, -0.05110599473118782, 0.020904457196593285, -0.006861213129013777, 0.012707899324595928, -0.047405727207660675, -0.005751790013164282, 0.03762802481651306, -0.034295663237571716, 0.015427161008119583, 0.005586965475231409, 0.02095136046409607, -0.05971350148320198, -0.013293322175741196, -0.05260585620999336, -0.010747373104095459, 0.0065132025629282, -0.010398426093161106, 0.011659015901386738, 0.03735470399260521, 0.03534342721104622, -0.009057683870196342, -0.04151866212487221, 0.024408232420682907, -0.028223128989338875, -0.05643277242779732, 0.017541950568556786, 0.009019525721669197, -0.00953349657356739, 0.050772957503795624, -0.0007897492032498121, -0.0006161284982226789, 0.04350893571972847, 0.02500445581972599, 0.020944582298398018, 0.005375181324779987, 0.030000509694218636, -0.001392426434904337, 0.0287198256701231, 0.0011253054253757, 0.01829841546714306, 0.0035589172039180994, -0.00917794555425644, 0.02877800352871418, 0.043822452425956726, -0.0004912002477794886, -0.007921813987195492, 0.010960051789879799, -0.03279759734869003, 0.004606348928064108, -0.002545739058405161, 0.029600204899907112, -0.004531283862888813, -0.031056879088282585, 0.019215388223528862, -0.02462531439960003, 0.017858030274510384, 0.04319280385971069, 0.019389163702726364, 0.005366828758269548, 0.016693521291017532, -0.021182185038924217, -0.05310933664441109, 0.009423126466572285, -0.0017785379895940423, -0.007637660484761, -0.027228601276874542, 0.030130699276924133, 0.009548046626150608, 0.027579402551054955, -0.012183085083961487, -0.026765162125229836, -0.07142636179924011, 0.02986110746860504, -0.02882394567131996, 0.026425307616591454, -0.020720304921269417, -0.020849725231528282, -0.0010222394485026598, -0.0812334269285202, 0.06485476344823837, 0.03535107523202896, -0.010312964208424091, -0.015015299431979656, 0.010181581601500511, -0.0197637639939785, 0.029791753739118576, 0.04434070363640785, 0.028554387390613556, 0.025439033284783363, 0.005511246621608734, -0.003931381739675999, -0.01322209183126688, -0.0218881294131279, 0.036141641438007355, 0.0028530850540846586, -0.02018475905060768, -0.018119273707270622, -0.022149596363306046, 0.024325091391801834, 0.024949507787823677, 0.015273179858922958, -0.025113433599472046, 0.03448433801531792, 0.032382532954216, 0.013634899631142616, 0.05469914898276329, -0.01419413648545742, 0.021229829639196396, 0.04989975690841675, 0.0047754570841789246, 0.026730364188551903, -0.0015952371759340167, -0.018450336530804634, -0.06074419617652893, -0.003819652833044529, -0.02553999237716198, -0.02634972333908081, 0.024144014343619347, 0.018338166177272797, 0.002191143808886409, -0.044921476393938065, -0.022500041872262955, 0.03618873283267021, -0.043657850474119186, 0.0332891084253788, 0.023633213713765144, 0.025070752948522568, 0.07200825214385986, -0.02879057265818119, 0.026109494268894196, -0.016519512981176376, -0.004072614014148712, 0.02190675586462021, -0.015528055839240551, 0.015038360841572285, 0.03645271435379982, 0.0166311152279377, 0.00842518825083971, -0.009128042496740818, 0.008195709437131882, -0.004282629583030939, 0.008737937547266483, -0.054335303604602814, -0.03950551152229309, 0.04559793323278427, 0.008171763271093369, 0.037862375378608704, 0.023358572274446487, 0.006604892201721668, 0.03669663146138191, 0.008838579058647156, 0.00042240729089826345, -0.017109563574194908, -0.021242864429950714, -0.007183212321251631, -0.0185873880982399, -0.012135349214076996, 0.03354864940047264, 0.02041689306497574, 0.0007439790642820299, 0.013677702285349369, -0.016137652099132538, 0.03386532515287399, -0.025133173912763596, 0.017918530851602554, 0.017780084162950516, 0.001191077521070838, -0.0038890258874744177, -0.01820325292646885, 0.004557457752525806, -0.00901736132800579, -0.003151100128889084, 0.02354736067354679, 0.0396922305226326, -0.05283954367041588, -0.05944863334298134, 0.041355300694704056, 0.06820245832204819, -0.047114331275224686, -0.012233201414346695, -0.04156794399023056, 0.008851385675370693, -0.0433448925614357, -0.031268879771232605 ]
<p>My data consists of three groups (A,B,C -independent of each other) and each group consists of 1000 correlation coefficients (generated using a stochastic simulation with 1000 iterations, correlating X and Y of the respective groups in each iteration). </p> <p>Case 1: I would like to test each group whether significantly different from a threshold value, say 0.5. </p> <p>Case 2: I would also like to test whether groups significantly differ from each other? </p> <p>Does it make sense to use a hypothesis test for mean (mean=0.5) in the first case and ANOVA for the second case?</p>
74,264
[ -0.02090805396437645, 0.021291458979249, -0.0048160795122385025, 0.0185423381626606, 0.0356614775955677, 0.007403705269098282, 0.016695799306035042, -0.02976827695965767, 0.02602224051952362, 0.00245015905238688, 0.04127940535545349, 0.01784050650894642, 0.026238664984703064, 0.022447679191827774, 0.051540471613407135, -0.0071418737061321735, -0.011941655538976192, -0.025768611580133438, 0.023178793489933014, -0.022381717339158058, -0.044752124696969986, 0.014019515365362167, 0.016712520271539688, -0.013748746365308762, -0.014764436520636082, 0.028612583875656128, 0.02021285891532898, -0.029496096074581146, 0.011682170443236828, 0.041642218828201294, -0.09235137701034546, -0.03870569169521332, -0.0010880891932174563, 0.01909218356013298, 0.014643661677837372, 0.003644208889454603, -0.002516494831070304, -0.001184500171802938, -0.000835387734696269, 0.027467122301459312, -0.01795872673392296, -0.0021298828069120646, 0.02780400775372982, 0.05630146712064743, 0.016871362924575806, 0.015631113201379776, 0.018350912258028984, -0.022840972989797592, 0.010571755468845367, -0.03532623127102852, 0.04727616533637047, -0.023565353825688362, 0.029378311708569527, 0.032044101506471634, -0.01628464087843895, -0.009678220376372337, 0.03589561581611633, 0.039487745612859726, -0.027127129957079887, -0.06569350510835648, -0.00285623618401587, -0.0368872731924057, 0.016999170184135437, 0.012991725467145443, -0.06109929829835892, -0.00024069064238574356, -0.025963759049773216, -0.04865366965532303, 0.030786098912358284, -0.0014929515309631824, 0.02323170378804207, 0.02538423053920269, 0.046738918870687485, -0.0238322876393795, 0.02955727092921734, -0.012559015303850174, 0.001535205403342843, 0.006007337011396885, 0.05054039880633354, 0.07338398694992065, -0.0065592085011303425, 0.03076229616999626, 0.00228900252841413, 0.05262281000614166, 0.041333723813295364, -0.02961280196905136, 0.08441302925348282, -0.050356391817331314, -0.008888861164450645, 0.001551350113004446, -0.03566070273518562, -0.03143314644694328, 0.0713040828704834, 0.05253905430436134, -0.025989994406700134, 0.00003019379437319003, -0.04192902147769928, 0.018782658502459526, 0.0004581032262649387, 0.006513076368719339, -0.03411997854709625, -0.00964976754039526, 0.03459969907999039, 0.03781943768262863, -0.004160769749432802, 0.03706848993897438, -0.03161614388227463, 0.02651486173272133, -0.011969923041760921, -0.014967278577387333, -0.0006187402759678662, 0.013196012005209923, 0.006980434991419315, 0.02253965102136135, 0.03684070706367493, 0.031457822769880295, -0.026401743292808533, -0.04197254404425621, 0.05453594774007797, 0.038316138088703156, 0.06929445266723633, -0.029742952436208725, 0.02082282118499279, -0.011046103201806545, -0.010169221088290215, -0.004609893541783094, -0.017523087561130524, -0.0031634108163416386, -0.04514765739440918, 0.07404029369354248, -0.024128880351781845, -0.0070588309317827225, 0.005486059933900833, -0.031489886343479156, 0.014798525720834732, 0.007235723547637463, -0.06480366736650467, -0.0708528459072113, 0.03591879457235336, -0.014349527657032013, -0.012101596221327782, -0.05183785408735275, 0.0012842895230278373, 0.02824256382882595, 0.06858110427856445, 0.012554424814879894, 0.02059110999107361, -0.03378712013363838, 0.02634110487997532, 0.03403986990451813, -0.020991098135709763, -0.029719997197389603, -0.02956150285899639, -0.028557701036334038, -0.009750173427164555, -0.09971339255571365, -0.006340607535094023, -0.015588301233947277, -0.0049726106226444244, -0.007923664525151253, 0.01829504407942295, 0.01364990696310997, -0.012867573648691177, 0.0021126396022737026, 0.04949144273996353, 0.02713146060705185, 0.0585382916033268, -0.022426262497901917, 0.053102780133485794, 0.01917967200279236, 0.0005116602405905724, 0.030855581164360046, 0.008007710799574852, 0.041408587247133255, 0.046464599668979645, -0.04478704184293747, 0.019571805372834206, -0.01182009931653738, 0.0439983531832695, 0.011304013431072235, -0.036968205124139786, -0.008016525767743587, -0.031208287924528122, -0.028961965814232826, 0.020011231303215027, 0.051530588418245316, -0.0003634585009422153, -0.033312201499938965, 0.018920425325632095, -0.0363943912088871, -0.060753028839826584, -0.08975658565759659, -0.013523440808057785, 0.022176094353199005, -0.0475960448384285, 0.04469333216547966, 0.009545029141008854, 0.019636385142803192, -0.011761784553527832, -0.016516970470547676, -0.06563088297843933, -0.0029429488349705935, 0.039224591106176376, -0.04164811596274376, 0.04922373592853546, 0.054840557277202606, 0.062031593173742294, -0.030449513345956802, 0.04819269850850105, -0.027648329734802246, -0.053495995700359344, 0.021350819617509842, -0.035602305084466934, -0.009584064595401287, 0.02876199036836624, 0.011644399724900723, 0.006215869914740324, 0.012671666219830513, -0.02195465750992298, 0.06333010643720627, -0.04832115024328232, 0.07641889154911041, 0.04506950452923775, -0.0005462765111587942, 0.012843272648751736, -0.01059701107442379, -0.009524131193757057, 0.004600548651069403, -0.010915983468294144, -0.010626045055687428, -0.08767837285995483, 0.0027313583996146917, 0.037306200712919235, 0.0029958346858620644, -0.029391251504421234, 0.007563372608274221, 0.05551142618060112, -0.015574225224554539, 0.004095687996596098, 0.021539082750678062, 0.04992421716451645, -0.0063045453280210495, 0.031115317717194557, 0.044108688831329346, 0.039440516382455826, -0.0023085339926183224, 0.026372822001576424, 0.00802280567586422, 0.07043550163507462, 0.01136660948395729, 0.011279899626970291, 0.020191000774502754, 0.012254148721694946, 0.014844135381281376, -0.01942192204296589, 0.014460936188697815, 0.03642133250832558, -0.00912634190171957, -0.016196073964238167, 0.02574925683438778, 0.0011978379916399717, -0.019267866387963295, -0.014098397456109524, -0.0181532334536314, 0.012876782566308975, 0.020343540236353874, -0.01743561215698719, 0.00713888555765152, 0.0162452794611454, -0.019929707050323486, 0.023137874901294708, -0.004660752136260271, -0.02199815772473812, -0.04099096730351448, 0.01109948381781578, 0.0385243184864521, -0.00536323944106698, 0.0716785341501236, -0.04845792427659035, -0.015862952917814255, 0.007093349471688271, -0.008587175980210304, 0.013514595106244087, -0.0070007252506911755, -0.049216583371162415, 0.0051131295040249825, -0.03172726556658745, -0.016580894589424133, -0.008131548762321472, -0.04731002449989319, 0.012021912261843681, 0.04640486091375351, -0.0009122343035414815, -0.04165320843458176, -0.01378887239843607, -0.019690096378326416, 0.011734358966350555, 0.0001740107691148296, -0.03630995750427246, 0.034679900854825974, -0.02373182214796543, -0.022456498816609383, 0.031050940975546837, -0.03767356276512146, 0.00583146046847105, -0.00016065359523054212, 0.010268587619066238, -0.000788558681961149, -0.017571527510881424, 0.018886907026171684, 0.0032489944715052843, -0.03786814585328102, -0.02129315212368965, -0.045660775154829025, -0.07377713173627853, 0.015695663169026375, 0.0019418871961534023, 0.015144423581659794, -0.03362363204360008, -0.023508520796895027, 0.056906167417764664, 0.05254200100898743, -0.03389951214194298, -0.028863955289125443, -0.03209961950778961, -0.03986150398850441, -0.029300937429070473, 0.03857247531414032, 0.013694407418370247, -0.005724459420889616, 0.0032803078647702932, 0.00686659524217248, 0.028971213847398758, 0.03854803740978241, 0.017016207799315453, 0.0005927281454205513, 0.02406504563987255, 0.04885032773017883, -0.02873065136373043, 0.0408286415040493, 0.0140986368060112, -0.03953950107097626, 0.010246137157082558, -0.007246285676956177, 0.0022603513207286596, 0.030017714947462082, -0.00856697466224432, 0.02490580454468727, 0.000053564981499221176, 0.03934827819466591, -0.036456551402807236, 0.009961903095245361, 0.028438512235879898, -0.0006176379392854869, 0.004224104806780815, 0.008154523558914661, -0.007066695485264063, 0.004303603898733854, -0.024964485317468643, 0.015353607013821602, 0.038999758660793304, -0.007002884987741709, -0.01943337544798851, -0.008779945783317089, -0.032058801501989365, 0.0073728240095078945, -0.02617151103913784, -0.03275490924715996, 0.05434316769242287, 0.00916353426873684, 0.004330168012529612, -0.006705067586153746, -0.04297442361712456, 0.0024385617580264807, -0.07633030414581299, 0.036253076046705246, -0.049319274723529816, 0.053951047360897064, -0.004003844223916531, 0.029757292941212654, 0.027134696021676064, -0.01778773032128811, -0.012134147807955742, -0.026424821466207504, -0.0633898600935936, 0.0363025963306427, -0.00374604226090014, -0.008246134035289288, 0.020001385360956192, -0.029097681865096092, 0.03892938792705536, -0.008852091617882252, 0.05013802647590637, 0.00005344209057511762, 0.05221032723784447, -0.003214455209672451, -0.0010688055772334337, -0.024980882182717323, -0.019400902092456818, 0.007462774869054556, 0.01184388343244791, 0.001148919458501041, -0.001992938807234168, 0.04263972118496895, 0.031836219131946564, -0.01850230246782303, -0.000429437292041257, 0.019976556301116943, 0.0039129615761339664, 0.006007099989801645, 0.04414379596710205, 0.04393347352743149, 0.022731488570570946, -0.0288630872964859, 0.015348978340625763, 0.01057710312306881, 0.043829645961523056, 0.037197425961494446, 0.005100577138364315, -0.008158369921147823, -0.04028303548693657, -0.024930143728852272, -0.012277593836188316, 0.01225132867693901, 0.006926394999027252, -0.005229252856224775, 0.008332112804055214, 0.03360750153660774, -0.06786160916090012, 0.02288132719695568, 0.05291213095188141, 0.00692176166921854, -0.032794076949357986, -0.02347000315785408, -0.03025856800377369, -0.002846301766112447, -0.027705118060112, 0.026069920510053635, 0.028579803183674812, -0.022092565894126892, 0.01849365420639515, 0.0500313974916935, 0.00824030116200447, -0.03584536164999008, 0.006647509057074785, 0.02840231917798519, 0.034887466579675674, -0.0092932702973485, -0.02519065886735916, 0.007601777091622353, 0.026824727654457092, -0.014520003460347652, 0.015544826164841652, -0.027669215574860573, -0.065496064722538, 0.012295668944716454, 0.04225362837314606, 0.061123330146074295, -0.04000067710876465, -0.005865630693733692, -0.005552280228585005, -0.004271367099136114, 0.03329552710056305, -0.033817924559116364, 0.01432475633919239, -0.03196985274553299, 0.022855477407574654, -0.023621443659067154, -0.005333499982953072, -0.06792006641626358, 0.02664492279291153, -0.01218955684453249, 0.011280142702162266, -0.021348044276237488, -0.040158629417419434, -0.055129602551460266, -0.019205141812562943, 0.02759406343102455, 0.06382551044225693, -0.05348352715373039, 0.014632824808359146, 0.03278428316116333, 0.015978973358869553, 0.019377870485186577, -0.026987960562109947, 0.02048376388847828, -0.03154079243540764, -0.0015250936849042773, 0.052263543009757996, -0.00663883239030838, -0.05107520893216133, 0.00014104439469520003, -0.0022704184520989656, 0.0031886606011539698, -0.009409910067915916, -0.013856537640094757, 0.058999501168727875, 0.03616428002715111, 0.018687142059206963, 0.052122004330158234, 0.020252784714102745, 0.0049417829141020775, 0.009213171899318695, -0.033424366265535355, 0.003200888866558671, -0.02186482585966587, -0.001464000204578042, -0.020577527582645416, -0.037434205412864685, -0.01834019646048546, 0.03455645591020584, 0.0032765164505690336, 0.0309719480574131, -0.022498706355690956, -0.0027533394750207663, 0.030226435512304306, 0.005540752317756414, 0.02165949158370495, -0.003276354633271694, 0.01878965273499489, -0.017963755875825882, -0.0038672611117362976, -0.028136031702160835, 0.0024968860670924187, -0.029441583901643753, -0.00546040665358305, -0.008291554637253284, -0.046137046068906784, -0.005634352099150419, -0.05030146241188049, -0.020178116858005524, 0.003561038291081786, -0.061276040971279144, 0.03603991121053696, 0.01306239515542984, 0.06370460242033005, -0.014422796666622162, -0.02134493738412857, 0.007440706714987755, 0.025023827329277992, -0.00825402420014143, 0.02215593121945858, -0.03305384889245033, 0.05234474316239357, -0.04926959052681923, -0.010175188072025776, -0.06228190287947655, -0.056266266852617264, -0.007864942774176598, 0.027443483471870422, 0.004199008457362652, -0.029593974351882935, 0.007668673060834408, -0.0314081646502018, 0.012802084907889366, -0.0341154970228672, 0.09335380792617798, -0.004194376524537802, -0.02117934264242649, 0.003744907211512327, 0.009543858468532562, 0.0859200730919838, -0.022082911804318428, -0.015515463426709175, 0.010253897868096828, 0.005805932451039553, -0.038030508905649185, -0.015436824411153793, 0.025408579036593437, -0.027051931247115135, -0.03604738786816597, -0.01785603165626526, -0.0070348880253732204, 0.06063826382160187, -0.026910608634352684, -0.027054766193032265, 0.03156343474984169, -0.0024837565142661333, 0.0053548370487987995, -0.056381162256002426, 0.011770517565310001, -0.024461783468723297, 0.011904148384928703, -0.0027861534617841244, 0.015591432340443134, -0.03266962617635727, -0.012217219918966293, 0.05260436609387398, 0.05204084515571594, -0.05646741762757301, -0.0010786728234961629, 0.08446410298347473, 0.0059111290611326694, 0.01875200681388378, -0.03557565063238144, -0.008197394199669361, 0.03325335308909416, -0.02768014557659626, -0.024776851758360863, 0.014740442857146263, 0.04046102240681648, -0.04192448407411575, 0.00562317855656147, -0.03260117024183273, -0.018698247149586678, 0.047004055231809616, -0.0003447140334174037, 0.0720013976097107, 0.08350735902786255, 0.010864404030144215, -0.010485049337148666, -0.04352250695228577, -0.0279739648103714, 0.01488919835537672, 0.02756803296506405, 0.02569834515452385, -0.038110215216875076, -0.0021510932128876448, 0.04923466593027115, -0.006853619124740362, 0.004161277785897255, 0.043141454458236694, 0.02158353291451931, 0.022394707426428795, 0.03939249739050865, -0.030261125415563583, -0.026984749361872673, 0.058291129767894745, -0.07552085071802139, 0.019575148820877075, -0.056936826556921005, -0.003239045152440667, 0.026453305035829544, 0.042246147990226746, -0.013318279758095741, -0.05701534450054169, 0.010145868174731731, -0.07012027502059937, -0.00701472582295537, 0.03841885179281235, -0.0201320368796587, 0.0383305698633194, 0.0014025074196979403, 0.04259401187300682, -0.027460765093564987, 0.01295336801558733, -0.016492793336510658, -0.10492578148841858, -0.04280924052000046, -0.006333534140139818, -0.022395148873329163, 0.01653520204126835, 0.018809910863637924, -0.03721887990832329, 0.029978644102811813, -0.05282667651772499, 0.028353754431009293, -0.011639176867902279, 0.049918293952941895, -0.023023316636681557, 0.05166640132665634, -0.021961964666843414, 0.02593882381916046, 0.010330312885344028, 0.007646788377314806, 0.10831651836633682, 0.05205081030726433, 0.01568199135363102, -0.0452628992497921, 0.0650956854224205, -0.006504870019853115, 0.014025659300386906, -0.008425653912127018, 0.019243711605668068, 0.01586885191500187, -0.0026486206334084272, 0.04961676895618439, 0.0720488578081131, -0.011329341679811478, 0.020660294219851494, 0.04258344694972038, -0.0013876796001568437, -0.01648396998643875, 0.03832206875085831, 0.029364587739109993, 0.019991539418697357, -0.037601228803396225, 0.007060218136757612, -0.013351039960980415, -0.03564255312085152, -0.0020575395319610834, -0.020738178864121437, -0.013633903115987778, 0.02922518365085125, 0.021917345002293587, -0.015100672841072083, 0.004697904922068119, 0.0105597460642457, -0.012088706716895103, -0.041485223919153214, -0.01843726448714733, 0.01733970083296299, -0.0724988579750061, 0.014120013453066349, 0.0300969909876585, -0.027981234714388847, -0.040360063314437866, -0.02800394408404827, 0.002065203618258238, -0.04565785825252533, -0.05681012198328972, -0.017497580498456955, 0.054585039615631104, 0.01264373678714037, -0.0384037084877491, -0.015945136547088623, 0.0005508634494617581, -0.015603384003043175, -0.025855936110019684, -0.013288627378642559, 0.016878118738532066, 0.021804234012961388, -0.03557766228914261, 0.001962431240826845, -0.07156451046466827, -0.00031229405431076884, -0.017814552411437035, 0.03720644861459732, 0.024007737636566162, -0.03489362820982933, 0.012431242503225803, -0.0049526686780154705, 0.0407610684633255, -0.01667928509414196, 0.0025000236928462982, 0.05214020237326622, -0.026963919401168823, -0.031734175980091095, -0.0021608686074614525, 0.005131060723215342, 0.024780789390206337, 0.012435976415872574, 0.0014718478778377175, -0.021617494523525238, -0.0027170788962394, -0.032683927565813065, 0.010334807448089123, -0.01735655590891838, 0.0028313547372817993, -0.019023427739739418, -0.007659252732992172, 0.042859189212322235, 0.018574222922325134, 0.059276264160871506, -0.004870097618550062, 0.024080926552414894, 0.04878925532102585, 0.02770151011645794, -0.03951726108789444, -0.028645040467381477, -0.022322550415992737, -0.013460173271596432, 0.02041521482169628, -0.026829928159713745, 0.0672425925731659, 0.018186867237091064, -0.00015713412722107023, -0.0020875614136457443, 0.015346063300967216, -0.03496389091014862, 0.021323906257748604, 0.022331751883029938, -0.035356905311346054, -0.01312995608896017, 0.024377495050430298, -0.004541898146271706, 0.002884137211367488, -0.023608852177858353, -0.048944100737571716, -0.011476841755211353, -0.006659630686044693, -0.025493623688817024, -0.03780952841043472, 0.010201527737081051, -0.00378399551846087, 0.001776586752384901, -0.04755926877260208, -0.005898624658584595, -0.05418616160750389, -0.010066593065857887, 0.02060519903898239, -0.0054814754985272884, -0.016958190128207207, 0.02280465140938759, -0.02115989662706852, 0.02392861433327198, 0.04708326980471611, 0.004924730397760868, 0.036786068230867386, 0.017651105299592018, -0.03507145121693611, -0.0006518209702335298, 0.025388039648532867, 0.007567103486508131, -0.006893012207001448, 0.04600959271192551, -0.0219417791813612, -0.031903594732284546, 0.017471907660365105, 0.006192190572619438, 0.04315483570098877, -0.009217528626322746, -0.0066201514564454556, -0.02691212296485901, 0.06451732665300369, -0.04167519137263298, -0.03762100636959076, -0.02456924319267273, -0.00885978527367115, -0.0013917424948886037, 0.009316532872617245, 0.016475234180688858, -0.006458687596023083, -0.022572480142116547, 0.029013164341449738, 0.03121396340429783, 0.009457041509449482, -0.023171303793787956, -0.003963583614677191, -0.0014967789174988866, 0.022799167782068253, 0.007951526902616024, -0.025737609714269638, 0.034073732793331146, 0.06503792852163315, -0.029097314924001694, 0.012735994532704353, -0.04292534664273262, 0.026929615065455437, -0.06665478646755219, -0.05306436866521835, -0.00022091275604907423, -0.008794741705060005, 0.03671615570783615, -0.06962282955646515, 0.006517828907817602, 0.06373254954814911, -0.027102546766400337, 0.03345942869782448, -0.0196496844291687, -0.04296484962105751, -0.06245965138077736, 0.00683372700586915, -0.005883152596652508, 0.031971145421266556, 0.01528471615165472, -0.007694047875702381, 0.027171999216079712, 0.004894720856100321, 0.002729805652052164, -0.03979741409420967, -0.0014406898990273476, 0.003996840212494135, 0.018832828849554062, -0.09103523939847946, -0.0015609681140631437, -0.021296381950378418, -0.03210074454545975, 0.006964534055441618, -0.049971211701631546, 0.008892769925296307, 0.026365576311945915, 0.02093311958014965, -0.011459430679678917, 0.05389440432190895, 0.030457153916358948, -0.005229484755545855, -0.012704112567007542, -0.015694230794906616, -0.005060762166976929, 0.017389722168445587, 0.00967780128121376, 0.0056345099583268166, 0.019804704934358597, 0.016037479043006897, -0.022578446194529533, 0.015810471028089523, -0.01723450981080532, -0.019254418089985847, -0.01688811182975769, -0.00308417365886271, -0.001547937048599124, -0.01676374115049839, -0.010601378045976162, -0.030962219461798668, 0.029364677146077156, 0.01226864941418171, 0.025675108656287193, -0.04455125331878662, 0.0015040304278954864, -0.027326615527272224, -0.002309963572770357, -0.005926954559981823, -0.006212946493178606, -0.014288453385233879, -0.05092187225818634, -0.013830361887812614, -0.02769766002893448, 0.00004230704143992625, -0.016943641006946564, -0.008395936340093613, 0.018999401479959488, 0.03948991745710373, -0.023114431649446487, 0.0026079171802848577, 0.020027942955493927, 0.009588717482984066, -0.023084944114089012, -0.0724274143576622, 0.06259166449308395, 0.018323712050914764, -0.008450191468000412, -0.05892636999487877, -0.01741940900683403, -0.07120455801486969, 0.0005814348114654422, 0.055128175765275955, 0.019363075494766235, 0.02980569191277027, -0.007866188883781433, 0.014194759540259838, 0.004618989769369364, -0.05160020664334297, 0.032791100442409515, -0.025877779349684715, -0.021319178864359856, 0.002430287655442953, 0.003997801803052425, 0.02495117485523224, -0.0019335236866027117, 0.019130971282720566, -0.03223082423210144, 0.055124763399362564, -0.005699790548533201, 0.008555195294320583, 0.030006062239408493, -0.007890468463301659, -0.016740426421165466, 0.0415048711001873, -0.027858814224600792, 0.016072221100330353, 0.02851126529276371, 0.010684593580663204, -0.037115853279829025, 0.038907915353775024, -0.035183899104595184, -0.037202879786491394, 0.022008927538990974, 0.010299690067768097, -0.05416662618517876, -0.06982569396495819, 0.017568767070770264, -0.0033549347426742315, -0.04299016669392586, 0.01795937493443489, 0.03171597793698311, 0.029219094663858414, 0.024179326370358467, -0.030604487285017967, 0.03889154642820358, 0.009012840688228607, -0.009112958796322346, 0.03051096387207508, 0.025875359773635864, 0.016863524913787842, 0.029125282540917397, 0.013545316644012928, 0.031912222504615784, -0.019968587905168533, 0.008740939199924469, -0.015166085213422775, 0.024720890447497368, 0.002690028166398406, 0.011522060260176659, 0.03865531459450722, -0.00946851260960102, 0.03582984581589699, 0.04298488795757294, 0.023365642875432968, 0.05082570016384125, -0.07096745818853378, -0.007018508389592171, -0.023660115897655487, -0.018573621287941933, -0.008968178182840347, 0.012585369870066643, 0.04905179142951965, 0.023656019940972328, 0.012529474683105946, 0.006101078819483519, 0.022088954225182533, -0.012183557264506817, 0.01804308034479618, -0.02000570483505726, 0.023078059777617455, -0.03366846963763237, -0.033939044922590256, -0.008543608710169792, -0.008992692455649376, -0.03831179440021515, -0.01860111765563488, 0.0076114702969789505, 0.044571541249752045, 0.022377874702215195, -0.03214135020971298, -0.019907280802726746, 0.0013118598144501448, 0.022675398737192154, -0.026505906134843826, -0.01411166600883007, -0.028327766805887222, 0.02936398796737194, -0.00032793378341011703, -0.03082476183772087 ]
<p>First off, I'm not trying to crowd source a personal printing press (i.e., not doing this: "I'm using strategies $x$, $y$, $z$ in the stock market and..."). Instead, I'm looking for feedback on research design. </p> <p>The situation: Many equity/currency/futures traders use technical analysis as part of their trading approach. Technical analysis uses past price patterns to make predictions about future prices. Technical indicators quantify that past movement. Lots of practitioners swear by the techniques. Many academics and others call <a href="http://rads.stackoverflow.com/amzn/click/0812975219" rel="nofollow">BS</a>. </p> <p>So, I want to test whether various technical indicators have predictive value: Do asset prices move as these indicators predict? I'd like to be very focused and just use independent t-tests as follows: </p> <ol> <li>Select an indicator (e.g., <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MACD" rel="nofollow">MACD</a>—moving average convergence/divergence).</li> <li>Review the claims about the indicator's predictive value (e.g., MACD bullish cross indicates imminent upward trend). </li> <li>Collect the price movement of an asset (stock/future/currency/etc.) and subset that data based on the indicator's value prior to the price movement. (e.g., IV: price movement following a bullish cross vs. price movement at times not following a bullish cross). </li> <li>If we have a significantly unequal number of observations for each group (this will almost always happen), randomly select data from the larger population so that our number of observations are equal. </li> <li>Run an independent samples t-test to compare the means of each group. (I'll also Shapiro-Wilks and Levene test the data, and adjust as necessary.) We'll test the null that the sample means are not significantly different. </li> <li>If we reject the null, look at the effect size, etc.</li> <li>Repeat 1-6 for the most popular indicators (or until my wife asks me to come watch <em>Dancing with the Stars</em> with her (and I pretend it's a favor even though it's not that bad)). </li> </ol> <p>Now, I know technical indicators are used in combinations, and some kind of moderating effect could be going on. But I wanted to start simple. Thoughts on how reliable this approach would be? Potential pitfalls?</p> <p>Also, full disclosure on the axe I may be grinding: I'm leery of the very fat tails and their unmitigated positions for/against technical analysis. I think brokerages and hucksters use them as noisy, noisy bells and whistles as they compete for clients. For most clients, the indicators do nothing. On the other hand, I also think there's value, but what value technical indicators have is likely greatest on short time frames and perhaps better for currencies.</p>
48,773
[ -0.020186016336083412, -0.022857096046209335, 0.017274601384997368, -0.005864836275577545, 0.05893522873520851, 0.012528814375400543, -0.024936873465776443, -0.00909225270152092, 0.00018230565183330327, -0.04173794016242027, 0.020094124600291252, 0.014778288081288338, 0.03077222779393196, 0.027570372447371483, -0.004143760073930025, -0.01506985817104578, -0.040139853954315186, -0.01969827339053154, 0.006338971201330423, -0.0361461266875267, 0.0172532070428133, 0.011582581326365471, 0.010829724371433258, 0.03362752124667168, -0.043099578469991684, 0.0412495918571949, -0.008511128835380077, -0.028893835842609406, 0.028504732996225357, 0.015058123506605625, -0.06574656814336777, -0.015543009154498577, 0.025163672864437103, 0.01883353665471077, 0.021629659458994865, 0.03449942544102669, 0.013925408013164997, -0.016231916844844818, -0.025784650817513466, 0.022475335747003555, 0.0002287167590111494, -0.0276250671595335, -0.024870583787560463, 0.02020997740328312, 0.002802284900099039, -0.012035590596497059, -0.011698611080646515, -0.024182135239243507, 0.035498738288879395, -0.033611975610256195, 0.041159696877002716, -0.01725170761346817, -0.025277839973568916, 0.02976825274527073, -0.036725860089063644, 0.008165325969457626, 0.05270359665155411, 0.025506187230348587, -0.011009142734110355, -0.06093442440032959, -0.0029662507586181164, -0.028032083064317703, 0.009372292086482048, 0.025951676070690155, -0.0034720404073596, 0.04260161146521568, -0.007710099220275879, 0.00884509738534689, 0.026027165353298187, -0.05617472901940346, 0.0479925163090229, -0.016717439517378807, 0.029396099969744682, 0.000690775690600276, 0.0066454303450882435, -0.019679894670844078, 0.018931545317173004, 0.056434571743011475, 0.06985609978437424, 0.04358191788196564, 0.012798000127077103, -0.012132449075579643, 0.02534417249262333, 0.053099922835826874, 0.028303882107138634, 0.0205488670617342, 0.0522417277097702, -0.035758137702941895, 0.02414986491203308, 0.03328024223446846, 0.009198223240673542, -0.031409475952386856, 0.052427370101213455, -0.012954803183674812, -0.03024836629629135, 0.015412602573633194, -0.007371969986706972, -0.0009272939059883356, -0.013079916127026081, -0.03440684825181961, -0.02000696212053299, -0.06521441042423248, 0.009341840632259846, 0.03662373870611191, 0.009304426610469818, 0.014781271107494831, -0.020825516432523727, -0.01939934492111206, -0.021612366661429405, -0.038597285747528076, -0.03200089558959007, 0.01427212730050087, 0.002931447932496667, -0.029295742511749268, -0.005038260016590357, 0.024027053266763687, 0.00842344481498003, -0.03359391167759895, 0.037059564143419266, 0.04085312411189079, 0.054533835500478745, 0.0037090315017849207, 0.010824184864759445, -0.03927873447537422, -0.05102485045790672, 0.02146863006055355, 0.023324932903051376, -0.000727788545191288, -0.023731382563710213, 0.06663309037685394, 0.01852201484143734, 0.0030511324293911457, 0.006957140751183033, -0.01598556526005268, 0.01970861107110977, 0.0230641458183527, -0.10663242638111115, -0.0593477226793766, 0.05260305106639862, -0.030311686918139458, -0.012523015029728413, -0.061939552426338196, -0.056121353060007095, 0.04416758194565773, 0.04015282914042473, -0.032309260219335556, 0.03434322774410248, 0.0008866204880177975, 0.033274922519922256, 0.027460049837827682, -0.07520650327205658, 0.0034443673212081194, -0.008011759258806705, -0.022293714806437492, 0.0029740496538579464, -0.0786561369895935, -0.005040705669671297, 0.037934109568595886, -0.042788878083229065, 0.010751067660748959, 0.02851978875696659, 0.029511677101254463, -0.005417590960860252, -0.016312045976519585, -0.003945113625377417, -0.03871467709541321, 0.050532326102256775, 0.01250123605132103, 0.02166994847357273, 0.0063646044582128525, 0.017933007329702377, 0.01883799396455288, 0.0006225035758689046, 0.009890712797641754, 0.015269484370946884, -0.05274992436170578, -0.008449189364910126, -0.0174853652715683, -0.01753205433487892, 0.0062866308726370335, -0.056064337491989136, -0.0293112900108099, -0.03161152824759483, -0.014637073501944542, 0.0229050125926733, 0.013931510969996452, -0.005029358435422182, 0.024766208603978157, 0.04802097752690315, -0.06145217642188072, -0.041270773857831955, -0.03903751075267792, 0.0004560846136882901, -0.02513173595070839, -0.01424206979572773, 0.03959503397345543, -0.030635327100753784, 0.016434447839856148, -0.0022845985367894173, -0.020264193415641785, 0.005751765798777342, 0.03173007816076279, 0.04391603544354439, -0.08143114298582077, 0.03850111365318298, 0.0355089046061039, -0.0013789425138384104, -0.00828639604151249, -0.00033788991277106106, -0.04967391490936279, -0.04471539333462715, 0.0005878796800971031, -0.026783853769302368, 0.03627784177660942, -0.0016364773036912084, -0.021766966208815575, 0.01602361723780632, -0.011893619783222675, -0.021364424377679825, 0.034781619906425476, -0.06472132354974747, 0.037429165095090866, 0.03690995275974274, -0.020005472004413605, -0.028019750490784645, 0.022082583978772163, 0.012447289191186428, 0.03550603613257408, -0.011887936852872372, -0.0018447765614837408, -0.06653204560279846, -0.028182141482830048, 0.01902897283434868, 0.03965464234352112, -0.04641110450029373, 0.0323767215013504, 0.08268444240093231, 0.012425185181200504, -0.03627263009548187, 0.052463728934526443, 0.014436827041208744, -0.05182080715894699, -0.022248348221182823, 0.022852212190628052, 0.01775490492582321, 0.004972720518708229, 0.05167620629072189, -0.021657250821590424, 0.046713974326848984, 0.023623839020729065, 0.05953874811530113, 0.022198442369699478, 0.02868845872581005, -0.0019464194774627686, 0.0023520621471107006, -0.03136748448014259, 0.02924865297973156, 0.009617824107408524, -0.013030585832893848, 0.01845407485961914, 0.027583090588450432, 0.02685418725013733, 0.014144981279969215, -0.01671312376856804, -0.0042008464224636555, 0.011769961565732956, -0.035198960453271866, 0.03357498347759247, 0.018658457323908806, -0.06347513943910599, 0.013132307678461075, 0.00659219129011035, -0.0030136178247630596, -0.0031629486475139856, -0.019339919090270996, -0.0119971027597785, 0.03242284432053566, 0.0055829426273703575, -0.04310951381921768, 0.0005913634086027741, 0.0008950878982432187, 0.02729145810008049, 0.0271773599088192, -0.017871655523777008, -0.04083855077624321, 0.04521447792649269, -0.017540218308568, -0.009105831384658813, 0.028712622821331024, 0.010366525501012802, 0.0014660479500889778, 0.040085624903440475, 0.020337844267487526, -0.07528724521398544, -0.022654488682746887, 0.0028716917149722576, -0.03769387677311897, -0.05451912432909012, -0.01694340631365776, 0.060155853629112244, -0.009506311267614365, -0.04612337425351143, 0.0013341284357011318, -0.056581687182188034, -0.0011349135311320424, -0.03223225101828575, -0.0073167928494513035, 0.014846277423202991, -0.013534311205148697, 0.031064683571457863, -0.00534236803650856, -0.0015315305208787322, -0.0018775768112391233, -0.0922013446688652, -0.09030148386955261, 0.020382648333907127, 0.022438939660787582, 0.043342225253582, 0.006729590706527233, -0.02450431138277054, 0.05725807696580887, 0.018865784630179405, -0.04575381055474281, -0.0656924918293953, -0.004799515474587679, -0.047457318753004074, -0.03284567594528198, 0.032371874898672104, 0.02967112325131893, 0.015560842119157314, -0.00246687070466578, -0.0024641193449497223, 0.03634430468082428, 0.057258911430835724, 0.01797673851251602, 0.04124026373028755, 0.01225481741130352, 0.002552928403019905, -0.01810622029006481, 0.04099123552441597, -0.013239084742963314, 0.002652944065630436, 0.004531760234385729, 0.026305312290787697, -0.006246231496334076, 0.008390937000513077, -0.04924147576093674, 0.016325319185853004, 0.00776255689561367, 0.0017510224133729935, -0.014503727667033672, 0.026212984696030617, 0.004304313100874424, -0.0194687619805336, -0.022631585597991943, -0.02446596324443817, 0.030942274257540703, 0.04416869208216667, 0.029973817989230156, 0.07249350100755692, -0.003245165105909109, -0.00785575620830059, 0.01410803385078907, -0.03061811625957489, -0.0035967824514955282, -0.0014394118916243315, -0.05666617676615715, 0.03165104612708092, 0.017883215099573135, 0.03489876538515091, 0.017750611528754234, 0.012110392563045025, -0.03854227066040039, -0.004193900618702173, -0.04122321307659149, 0.01837470941245556, -0.03646595776081085, 0.06625927984714508, 0.019710050895810127, 0.06559432297945023, 0.019184842705726624, 0.009155724197626114, -0.002551635727286339, -0.02311517484486103, -0.03533897548913956, 0.0206148661673069, -0.01580662466585636, 0.0012784702703356743, 0.013755027204751968, -0.017744075506925583, 0.016339454799890518, 0.00019403848273213953, 0.009479166008532047, -0.015283994376659393, 0.028068413957953453, -0.027931327000260353, 0.0024800472892820835, -0.03629559651017189, -0.03795108199119568, 0.025275198742747307, 0.02825777232646942, 0.029270775616168976, -0.014715972356498241, 0.04898400232195854, 0.044634513556957245, 0.006096665281802416, -0.016082048416137695, -0.01560075394809246, -0.0034245681017637253, 0.012515629641711712, 0.02905525267124176, 0.04964657127857208, 0.03030308336019516, -0.08181092888116837, 0.0321165956556797, 0.04210691526532173, 0.05194901302456856, -0.013259484432637691, -0.020106665790081024, -0.007317706942558289, -0.017794087529182434, -0.02131693810224533, 0.04324325546622276, -0.008695347234606743, -0.00644834665581584, -0.005858203396201134, 0.05794433131814003, -0.017514090985059738, 0.003852223977446556, 0.008735268376767635, 0.032728180289268494, 0.023868048563599586, 0.03551414608955383, -0.00805235281586647, -0.028325270861387253, 0.025797871872782707, -0.032671988010406494, 0.03282760828733444, 0.013893300667405128, -0.0038366636727005243, -0.020360998809337616, 0.007857760414481163, 0.020502081140875816, -0.02480204589664936, -0.006236904766410589, 0.005411138292402029, 0.0448453314602375, -0.0029534806963056326, -0.030581945553421974, 0.02750958502292633, 0.0019528568955138326, 0.03024001605808735, 0.024139922112226486, 0.02531139738857746, -0.10996270179748535, -0.02301422692835331, 0.024418756365776062, 0.06373009830713272, -0.03224841132760048, 0.002097985241562128, -0.051455046981573105, -0.004725354257971048, 0.01511000283062458, -0.02206858992576599, 0.018791059032082558, -0.0026400054339319468, 0.0434466190636158, -0.048865288496017456, -0.0065286788158118725, -0.03154480457305908, -0.006659304723143578, 0.011663874611258507, -0.0198067519813776, -0.03845599666237831, -0.01789550669491291, -0.026435650885105133, -0.02112242765724659, 0.010506704449653625, 0.03803296014666557, -0.03229057416319847, 0.02389325015246868, 0.007854660041630268, 0.005996391177177429, 0.0006402968429028988, -0.051323771476745605, 0.0308871790766716, 0.0009667027625255287, 0.008653949946165085, 0.05026905983686447, 0.01868450827896595, -0.060011811554431915, 0.04553678631782532, 0.007147885859012604, -0.010599486529827118, 0.005656286608427763, -0.049410849809646606, 0.03325586020946503, 0.03723369911313057, 0.030669590458273888, 0.04077937453985214, 0.04196339473128319, 0.02755429595708847, 0.03760379180312157, -0.0012604715302586555, 0.008022467605769634, -0.005088126286864281, 0.0190095417201519, -0.013093719258904457, -0.013867164961993694, -0.03796061500906944, 0.04276202619075775, -0.02468654327094555, 0.01975521445274353, -0.03979038819670677, 0.0009051050292328, 0.008483869954943657, -0.015649419277906418, -0.00538182957097888, 0.017856230959296227, 0.001504076411947608, -0.015765545889735222, -0.03798684477806091, -0.009797991253435612, 0.028045715764164925, -0.03786524012684822, 0.011527768336236477, 0.024831892922520638, -0.03460691496729851, -0.02562144212424755, -0.02479623630642891, 0.03223595395684242, -0.0031541066709905863, 0.010550606064498425, 0.06052236258983612, 0.038822535425424576, 0.030406329780817032, 0.0007141219102777541, -0.00956198014318943, -0.005860203877091408, 0.05480967089533806, 0.04221416264772415, 0.02026517316699028, 0.009527736343443394, 0.02307746931910515, -0.005880600307136774, -0.025313498452305794, -0.0568702258169651, -0.00008579153654864058, 0.0074394624680280685, 0.02258465439081192, -0.04374562203884125, -0.01672462932765484, 0.07007112354040146, -0.019291440024971962, 0.004264694172888994, -0.03612403944134712, 0.010582798160612583, -0.02754903957247734, -0.04934948310256004, 0.008247407153248787, 0.0025091669522225857, 0.06854091584682465, -0.02965434268116951, -0.0379793606698513, 0.010359172709286213, 0.004704756662249565, 0.011082419194281101, -0.012967541813850403, -0.006914820987731218, -0.027600161731243134, -0.013460611924529076, -0.03500271588563919, -0.014130034483969212, 0.02894570864737034, -0.016617467626929283, -0.039004698395729065, 0.006382834166288376, 0.007262366358190775, -0.0011373453307896852, -0.0006939764134585857, -0.0029871577862650156, -0.008512240834534168, 0.0003504036576487124, -0.008198406547307968, 0.026217326521873474, 0.023829281330108643, -0.030132858082652092, -0.0006745043210685253, 0.003996540326625109, -0.02871371991932392, 0.03367314487695694, 0.05652139335870743, 0.004171967972069979, 0.017427213490009308, -0.01388533879071474, -0.03201571851968765, 0.043335266411304474, -0.005492315161973238, 0.036416228860616684, -0.01887669414281845, -0.0051522329449653625, -0.017544731497764587, -0.03837912157177925, -0.01451717410236597, -0.010999474674463272, 0.05841460078954697, 0.025720013305544853, 0.03451484441757202, 0.039807211607694626, 0.018283074721693993, 0.014337655156850815, -0.028670435771346092, -0.013458143919706345, -0.030584359541535378, -0.009205746464431286, 0.03159322962164879, -0.01805036887526512, 0.0053222267888486385, 0.043661780655384064, 0.020094485953450203, 0.01396770030260086, 0.026980437338352203, 0.026647990569472313, 0.03550200164318085, 0.03752123937010765, -0.04618590325117111, -0.0669378712773323, 0.029293790459632874, -0.07490647584199905, 0.02634269930422306, -0.0497773177921772, -0.007897824980318546, 0.032579462975263596, 0.046791452914476395, -0.0437563955783844, -0.049917031079530716, -0.024724889546632767, -0.08628837764263153, 0.005237921606749296, -0.003515699878334999, -0.01679346151649952, 0.02078367955982685, 0.014367842115461826, 0.0366787314414978, -0.018943872302770615, 0.03981294482946396, -0.03151695057749748, -0.05437322333455086, -0.015655944123864174, -0.018289871513843536, -0.04510553553700447, 0.0522274374961853, 0.004234773572534323, -0.024347081780433655, -0.006201671902090311, -0.06083909049630165, 0.018104976043105125, -0.010463686659932137, 0.016394710168242455, -0.011079458519816399, 0.08385951817035675, -0.03252619877457619, 0.02268308773636818, -0.005203371401876211, -0.014374026097357273, 0.1462867707014084, 0.06538494676351547, 0.03413858637213707, -0.06286683678627014, 0.023789063096046448, -0.016725225374102592, 0.02138645574450493, -0.03629697486758232, 0.018881026655435562, -0.02477646991610527, 0.016465457156300545, 0.029608789831399918, 0.06643043458461761, -0.011362362653017044, -0.02361239306628704, 0.05953540652990341, -0.05215369164943695, 0.027846690267324448, 0.01607494242489338, 0.04466468095779419, 0.0230687465518713, -0.026437658816576004, -0.026110172271728516, 0.02062089368700981, -0.010521785356104374, 0.007090131286531687, -0.014831307344138622, -0.043674979358911514, 0.005775460973381996, 0.027652889490127563, -0.033952660858631134, -0.001363698742352426, 0.02057395689189434, -0.0002979031123686582, -0.03313763439655304, -0.005981779191643, 0.04323321580886841, -0.05213424563407898, 0.03679184243083, 0.03809641674160957, -0.016633814200758934, -0.04131701961159706, -0.01683533936738968, 0.006427645683288574, -0.034450434148311615, -0.0156642347574234, -0.06125450134277344, 0.013285382650792599, -0.013410411775112152, -0.0234611164778471, -0.05495256185531616, -0.0008104324224404991, 0.0029521898832172155, -0.02141781896352768, -0.02850446105003357, 0.0029090126045048237, 0.014110520482063293, -0.04055674001574516, 0.006999674718827009, -0.030304061248898506, 0.01653367094695568, -0.007414872292429209, 0.017452051863074303, 0.029813287779688835, -0.04483810067176819, -0.04270603507757187, -0.018187183886766434, 0.04623829945921898, 0.00041524588596075773, -0.0034228318836539984, 0.0010590754682198167, 0.030615556985139847, -0.04956918582320213, 0.015516383573412895, -0.01780916005373001, 0.004394161980599165, -0.0009674406610429287, 0.02170177549123764, 0.003719846485182643, -0.007234387565404177, -0.033424969762563705, 0.07339067757129669, -0.021372990682721138, -0.00013659079559147358, -0.041683703660964966, 0.022179020568728447, 0.038020290434360504, 0.04503697156906128, 0.03210685774683952, 0.012992474250495434, 0.004163927398622036, 0.044128213077783585, 0.031227897852659225, -0.057759858667850494, -0.02740226499736309, 0.015225602313876152, -0.024598238989710808, -0.014258140698075294, -0.026547353714704514, 0.04146305471658707, 0.0411587618291378, -0.007729314733296633, -0.0010007262462750077, -0.020016929134726524, -0.027205808088183403, 0.02988765574991703, -0.0024553793482482433, -0.06659028679132462, -0.010570072568953037, 0.03474879637360573, -0.00648884940892458, -0.03590371459722519, -0.00015948692453093827, -0.03273387625813484, 0.0064683700911700726, -0.004784680902957916, -0.00027953635435551405, -0.018238689750432968, 0.018660685047507286, 0.006310478784143925, 0.069182388484478, -0.042515188455581665, 0.00714513985440135, -0.007030098233371973, -0.019726956263184547, -0.033089593052864075, 0.016856584697961807, -0.0629490539431572, 0.03265886753797531, -0.044754575937986374, -0.013713947497308254, 0.08453759551048279, 0.011923063546419144, 0.015396866016089916, 0.018681436777114868, 0.010141773149371147, -0.022210171446204185, -0.009973679669201374, 0.013778197579085827, -0.027630480006337166, 0.0041486104018986225, -0.024846835061907768, -0.012952139601111412, 0.014308732934296131, 0.019508808851242065, 0.023441476747393608, -0.02701372466981411, 0.000378511322196573, -0.042214419692754745, 0.010328995063900948, -0.043078985065221786, 0.0045559038408100605, 0.0275103822350502, -0.0016171640018001199, 0.025618931278586388, -0.002567518036812544, 0.02622336708009243, 0.034452810883522034, 0.01405674684792757, -0.0014292013365775347, 0.023081662133336067, -0.0007881312631070614, 0.010073261335492134, 0.0016729788621887565, -0.03207826614379883, -0.020582232624292374, -0.0005159656284376979, -0.002167245140299201, 0.05895001068711281, 0.061748962849378586, 0.010499410331249237, 0.05272095277905464, -0.03487793356180191, -0.004526355769485235, -0.09345466643571854, 0.008861374109983444, 0.003581369761377573, 0.016905784606933594, 0.04316713660955429, -0.007517979014664888, -0.021800749003887177, 0.009769092313945293, -0.04376313090324402, 0.04305687174201012, 0.0034838130231946707, 0.0013666155282408, -0.01886356621980667, -0.02527332678437233, -0.028922773897647858, 0.023259425535798073, 0.020595349371433258, 0.011552593670785427, 0.04217468947172165, 0.04484320431947708, -0.05356184393167496, 0.010584321804344654, 0.006390328053385019, -0.01631026715040207, 0.021994970738887787, -0.0647573247551918, 0.022125519812107086, -0.029273875057697296, -0.03175157308578491, 0.02770868130028248, 0.03621498867869377, 0.024674557149410248, -0.02190549485385418, 0.013549597933888435, -0.0028984136879444122, 0.0440632663667202, 0.02870761603116989, 0.03610551357269287, -0.016176516190171242, 0.0020045549608767033, -0.01169569231569767, 0.01109715923666954, 0.009320814162492752, 0.007555747404694557, 0.037920862436294556, -0.03703645244240761, -0.005279961042106152, -0.0015722709940746427, -0.02610830031335354, -0.03296931833028793, 0.009555954486131668, 0.03511272743344307, -0.0005048950552009046, -0.00818563625216484, -0.006596312392503023, 0.010833736509084702, -0.008263377472758293, 0.04358763247728348, 0.03953193873167038, -0.011991305276751518, 0.004519852809607983, -0.0074314698576927185, -0.04820180684328079, 0.05737149715423584, 0.006232026964426041, 0.017211368307471275, -0.06586595624685287, -0.019506050273776054, 0.008164804428815842, -0.013013940304517746, -0.07070465385913849, 0.005328366532921791, -0.010057053528726101, 0.01839415729045868, -0.021097930148243904, 0.03983192890882492, -0.0012819304829463363, -0.013818631879985332, 0.017255913466215134, -0.07915733009576797, 0.0558401383459568, -0.028553087264299393, -0.022907691076397896, -0.022970782592892647, -0.038992106914520264, -0.042420804500579834, 0.0015866196481510997, 0.03565581142902374, -0.02226959355175495, 0.015428590588271618, 0.026685621589422226, -0.006572113372385502, -0.006223909556865692, -0.054407864809036255, 0.06885439902544022, -0.022036241367459297, 0.010046917013823986, 0.031732019037008286, -0.031055759638547897, 0.016059566289186478, 0.02617393434047699, 0.06758097559213638, -0.033057454973459244, -0.010763043537735939, 0.030322439968585968, -0.005639937706291676, 0.03142201155424118, 0.024444378912448883, -0.03377732262015343, 0.046310216188430786, 0.03319907560944557, 0.012594000436365604, -0.0011062383418902755, -0.02755732089281082, -0.06929613649845123, 0.058827392756938934, -0.018971595913171768, -0.026716575026512146, -0.003225157968699932, 0.006018055137246847, -0.0017896727658808231, -0.02299612946808338, 0.010748488828539848, 0.016185395419597626, -0.024177858605980873, 0.022132374346256256, 0.05795662850141525, 0.025253670290112495, 0.00543475616723299, -0.006939809303730726, 0.03038923069834709, 0.00153188721742481, -0.018213577568531036, -0.0162920244038105, -0.03701270744204521, 0.0420064851641655, -0.0051986235193908215, -0.01057146955281496, 0.02147979848086834, -0.0020341172348707914, 0.029375391080975533, -0.012013360857963562, -0.010972009040415287, 0.00042035881779156625, -0.019039934501051903, 0.019903872162103653, 0.0014336182503029704, 0.015715017914772034, 0.027457140386104584, -0.011074094101786613, 0.06955579668283463, -0.03322390094399452, -0.002894168021157384, -0.024352047592401505, 0.015293456614017487, -0.0026940256357192993, 0.03857613727450371, 0.008537615649402142, 0.016955982893705368, -0.022865701466798782, 0.035958778113126755, 0.028675410896539688, -0.008602200075984001, 0.024876318871974945, 0.003100248984992504, -0.00006519775342894718, -0.017783211544156075, -0.011121057905256748, 0.011368166655302048, -0.004795589949935675, -0.07686928659677505, -0.006696405820548534, 0.0001327364589087665, -0.00236582406796515, 0.006463929079473019, -0.018348034471273422, -0.05015711858868599, -0.024629326537251472, 0.047646522521972656, -0.06665319949388504, 0.013858864083886147, -0.0434093251824379, -0.006266965996474028, 0.0386447012424469, -0.02824414148926735 ]
<p>I've been looking at mixed effects modelling using the lme4 package in R. I'm primarily using the <code>lmer</code> command so I'll pose my question through code that uses that syntax. I suppose a general easy question might be, is it OK to compare any two models constructed in <code>lmer</code> using likelihood ratios based on identical datasets? I believe the answer to that must be, "no", but I could be incorrect. I've read conflicting information on whether the random effects have to be the same or not, and what component of the random effects is meant by that? So, I'll present a few examples. I'll take them from repeated measures data using word stimuli, perhaps something like <a href="http://www.ualberta.ca/~baayen/publications/baayenCUPstats.pdf">Baayen (2008)</a> would be useful in interpreting.</p> <p>Let's say I have a model where there are two fixed effects predictors, we'll call them A, and B, and some random effects... words and subjects that perceived them. I might construct a model like the following. </p> <pre><code>m &lt;- lmer( y ~ A + B + (1|words) + (1|subjects) ) </code></pre> <p>(note that I've intentionally left out <code>data =</code> and we'll assume I always mean <code>REML = FALSE</code> for clarity's sake)</p> <p>Now, of the following models, which are OK to compare with a likelihood ratio test to the one above and which are not?</p> <pre><code>m1 &lt;- lmer( y ~ A + B + (A+B|words) + (1|subjects) ) m2 &lt;- lmer( y ~ A + B + (1|subjects) ) m3 &lt;- lmer( y ~ A + B + (C|words) + (A+B|subjects) ) m4 &lt;- lmer( y ~ A + B + (1|words) ) m5 &lt;- lmer( y ~ A * B + (1|subjects) ) </code></pre> <p>I acknowledge that the interpretation of some of these differences may be difficult, or impossible. But let's put that aside for a second. I just want to know if there's something fundamental in the changes here that precludes the possibility of comparing. I also want to know whether, if LR tests are OK AIC, comparisons are as well.</p>
74,265
[ -0.042593833059072495, -0.02982119284570217, 0.012065157294273376, -0.03692178428173065, 0.012736153788864613, 0.058237142860889435, 0.004501362331211567, -0.021726572886109352, 0.04699334129691124, -0.002392355352640152, 0.027278777211904526, 0.052622273564338684, 0.05993490666151047, 0.018014278262853622, 0.029695281758904457, -0.006838943809270859, -0.011351460590958595, 0.024248085916042328, -0.0034408296924084425, 0.019923260435461998, 0.0036367487628012896, 0.0036910795606672764, 0.018454885110259056, 0.0029837118927389383, 0.0036766293924301863, 0.04536900296807289, 0.04052170366048813, -0.04336082935333252, 0.017988411709666252, 0.013398028910160065, 0.007910904474556446, -0.03197703883051872, 0.0040680114179849625, 0.011113789863884449, -0.0020228023640811443, -0.014804182574152946, -0.006140832789242268, 0.0017934201750904322, 0.007380524184554815, 0.039837464690208435, -0.01484254002571106, 0.005366412922739983, 0.016123242676258087, 0.050097331404685974, -0.03769573196768761, 0.0003893166722264141, -0.0451982319355011, 0.004126598127186298, 0.03542562946677208, -0.031732480973005295, 0.09760193526744843, -0.00978715531527996, 0.02912728674709797, 0.03485582396388054, -0.013684529811143875, -0.0029067029245197773, 0.053197845816612244, 0.08303943276405334, -0.01932551898062229, -0.0612444132566452, -0.018809238448739052, -0.03174092620611191, 0.019766757264733315, 0.006524339783936739, -0.046455901116132736, 0.005259109660983086, 0.0319104939699173, -0.004970332141965628, 0.08460608869791031, -0.010376867838203907, 0.01735597848892212, -0.0014746022643521428, 0.07410834729671478, 0.0005897835944779217, 0.014375399798154831, -0.0184427909553051, 0.006916904356330633, -0.0007368389633484185, 0.034331146627664566, 0.036051273345947266, -0.022291844710707664, -0.015467122197151184, -0.014361580833792686, 0.04369322210550308, 0.01049599889665842, -0.029990270733833313, 0.04310273379087448, -0.017176199704408646, 0.02572818286716938, 0.012956677936017513, -0.01854083687067032, 0.00874221883714199, 0.03144140541553497, 0.01269895862787962, -0.06926675140857697, 0.05507277697324753, 0.004532364662736654, 0.025815220549702644, 0.02766457013785839, 0.00784887745976448, -0.04567272216081619, -0.05837947502732277, 0.0059551820158958435, 0.055510297417640686, -0.030260693281888962, -0.018569020554423332, -0.00726027088239789, 0.012172066606581211, -0.016463885083794594, -0.015577622689306736, -0.013830166310071945, 0.045589327812194824, -0.0003046528436243534, 0.006572732701897621, -0.0011324778897687793, -0.06190406158566475, -0.007168298587203026, -0.016432572156190872, 0.07568889856338501, 0.056741099804639816, 0.04230494797229767, -0.03372896462678909, 0.022373855113983154, -0.029881959781050682, -0.0034041875042021275, -0.022537942975759506, -0.01187752652913332, -0.012509573251008987, -0.02614654414355755, 0.051322825253009796, 0.016831647604703903, -0.011509295552968979, 0.05359740927815437, 0.01687788777053356, 0.03623005747795105, 0.0073805577121675014, -0.0882091298699379, -0.04139471799135208, 0.024608271196484566, -0.03194456547498703, 0.0242514256387949, -0.054781876504421234, -0.0262028519064188, -0.004789627157151699, 0.04469643905758858, 0.008487219922244549, 0.047525130212306976, 0.02011754922568798, 0.028601113706827164, 0.02782347798347473, -0.048876553773880005, -0.010441071353852749, -0.026318121701478958, -0.015599114820361137, -0.038516897708177567, -0.08802111446857452, -0.013097979128360748, 0.012325376272201538, -0.024385157972574234, 0.02161703072488308, 0.016532810404896736, 0.01073055062443018, -0.009493675082921982, -0.01307782530784607, 0.020074745640158653, 0.0002348387788515538, 0.049311041831970215, 0.0010700722923502326, 0.042081866413354874, 0.033007483929395676, 0.00044876965694129467, 0.015723615884780884, 0.0028616723138839006, 0.0300458874553442, 0.030667008832097054, -0.02990918606519699, 0.029263529926538467, -0.004326228983700275, 0.03641742095351219, 0.036475248634815216, -0.06828965991735458, 0.014356833882629871, -0.05333999544382095, -0.018369881436228752, 0.017559267580509186, 0.032475754618644714, 0.0246138758957386, -0.0003940865572076291, 0.05296951159834862, -0.029285334050655365, -0.04083549976348877, -0.07830556482076645, -0.02285885624587536, -0.02046496421098709, -0.02350669726729393, 0.030612776055932045, -0.014166467823088169, 0.057157572358846664, -0.011526338756084442, 0.005969418212771416, -0.07532630115747452, 0.011472244746983051, 0.0022684698924422264, 0.0033301583025604486, 0.010258019901812077, 0.021556144580245018, 0.018037939444184303, -0.01686042547225952, 0.05479668080806732, -0.02307957410812378, -0.051368799060583115, 0.01452080998569727, -0.0034512036945670843, 0.002178576309233904, 0.005811572540551424, -0.021376870572566986, 0.02161591686308384, -0.012352229095995426, -0.04800852760672569, 0.010411291383206844, -0.06895057111978531, 0.05080970376729965, 0.027137018740177155, -0.0013866669032722712, -0.019205478951334953, 0.012593126855790615, 0.04658781737089157, 0.03113909438252449, -0.03244427219033241, -0.00922137126326561, -0.04598216712474823, -0.0025794683024287224, 0.060215916484594345, 0.008957469835877419, -0.0491529256105423, 0.0398600697517395, 0.044528380036354065, -0.00886533036828041, 0.004279139917343855, 0.03357832506299019, -0.009375547990202904, -0.04374398663640022, 0.02124888449907303, 0.040957044810056686, 0.008894003927707672, 0.02793276309967041, 0.02365696057677269, -0.0459330715239048, 0.030016828328371048, 0.0007929163402877748, 0.010033336468040943, 0.029009079560637474, 0.002525501186028123, 0.008754700422286987, -0.03224112465977669, -0.028098274022340775, 0.02728242613375187, -0.01677890680730343, 0.010431021451950073, 0.01891312189400196, 0.02692430466413498, -0.022584140300750732, -0.00042220429168082774, -0.0001818442833609879, 0.010193675756454468, 0.03438980504870415, -0.021687325090169907, -0.009682071395218372, 0.02436342090368271, -0.022977491840720177, -0.009344124235212803, -0.004568776115775108, -0.02690349705517292, -0.07118991017341614, 0.024332977831363678, 0.013270230032503605, -0.023658065125346184, 0.018871519714593887, -0.05044462904334068, -0.019802987575531006, 0.020968694239854813, -0.015298026613891125, 0.029202036559581757, -0.05455078184604645, -0.059903860092163086, 0.009044722653925419, -0.03189956396818161, -0.008402218110859394, 0.008436162956058979, 0.004982601385563612, -0.032401636242866516, 0.0502341128885746, -0.0016632972983643413, -0.060172710567712784, -0.04565036669373512, -0.016710713505744934, 0.01551351509988308, -0.0029801675118505955, -0.023063722997903824, 0.03122803196310997, 0.01184853445738554, -0.04575109854340553, -0.004891593009233475, -0.02994084358215332, -0.010816925205290318, 0.007203002460300922, -0.018674936145544052, 0.003020856762304902, 0.004067735746502876, 0.020004311576485634, 0.01710948906838894, -0.02050221525132656, -0.03388161212205887, -0.0657724067568779, -0.04567677900195122, 0.031543929129838943, -0.002023550681769848, 0.06219464913010597, 0.032484520226716995, 0.00570288673043251, 0.07392839342355728, 0.05152840539813042, -0.016490673646330833, -0.07665929198265076, -0.003069664351642132, -0.020843736827373505, -0.023315120488405228, 0.008914805017411709, 0.021221378818154335, 0.01376937422901392, 0.028866123408079147, 0.011969266459345818, 0.0019619145896285772, 0.02734101004898548, 0.009621155448257923, 0.004595206584781408, 0.04119689762592316, 0.03490997478365898, -0.048324353992938995, 0.03555857390165329, 0.03080715239048004, -0.019795048981904984, 0.004326394759118557, 0.012951081618666649, 0.0059620654210448265, -0.027313876897096634, -0.032271578907966614, 0.02302028052508831, -0.006437617354094982, -0.008161401376128197, -0.013105272315442562, 0.031108127906918526, -0.0036595119163393974, -0.05153479427099228, 0.0014596201945096254, -0.00916479155421257, 0.01829073578119278, 0.012352150864899158, 0.01125428918749094, 0.04178212210536003, 0.03175855800509453, -0.009488143026828766, 0.005770775489509106, -0.01090500969439745, -0.005313364323228598, 0.04214172437787056, -0.033449217677116394, 0.011315659619867802, 0.02847394347190857, 0.03037969395518303, -0.004873722791671753, -0.005466483533382416, -0.022958338260650635, -0.009276005439460278, -0.05094063654541969, 0.011216669343411922, -0.04935035482048988, 0.036368682980537415, 0.01574575901031494, 0.05688314512372017, -0.00557011179625988, -0.06675578653812408, 0.011662088334560394, 0.0018167755333706737, -0.047368258237838745, 0.02944757416844368, -0.01400232408195734, 0.0013409230159595609, 0.001533574890345335, -0.007290543522685766, 0.02972785383462906, -0.04435676336288452, -0.04248276725411415, -0.015423789620399475, 0.016707004979252815, -0.04187532886862755, 0.024936320260167122, -0.023429591208696365, -0.04038270562887192, -0.011914785951375961, 0.033903248608112335, -0.002582195680588484, 0.0056214528158307076, 0.01179121620953083, 0.049315448850393295, -0.008700516074895859, 0.00890157651156187, -0.01760660484433174, -0.021830683574080467, 0.027397876605391502, 0.027656128630042076, 0.03682528808712959, 0.0075191110372543335, -0.05825056880712509, 0.04195432364940643, 0.0317101888358593, 0.018107600510120392, 0.04354202747344971, -0.003750985488295555, -0.023502644151449203, -0.02417740225791931, -0.0037536139134317636, 0.017442958429455757, 0.020740307867527008, 0.00988570787012577, -0.00549476919695735, 0.055938802659511566, 0.035028181970119476, 0.006284981966018677, 0.004372394643723965, 0.04187038913369179, 0.005259508732706308, 0.0074529447592794895, -0.03693796694278717, 0.026278918609023094, -0.0036589554511010647, 0.011075649410486221, 0.043889522552490234, -0.023165354505181313, 0.02989017777144909, -0.0042997561395168304, 0.029032506048679352, -0.020258164033293724, -0.06212541088461876, 0.02442878484725952, 0.02891932986676693, 0.0044737509451806545, 0.02724446728825569, -0.054318301379680634, -0.005449248012155294, 0.03623786196112633, 0.018189644441008568, 0.016461078077554703, -0.006653164979070425, -0.09455427527427673, 0.008031727746129036, 0.05947553366422653, 0.04498079791665077, -0.03385152667760849, 0.01820685714483261, -0.02176126092672348, 0.009455555118620396, -0.02831767313182354, -0.010511220432817936, 0.012331721372902393, 0.0072456542402505875, 0.024099616333842278, -0.021116644144058228, -0.03493683412671089, -0.04352639615535736, 0.031309742480516434, -0.008509685285389423, 0.0011610068613663316, 0.0007941891672089696, -0.03851731866598129, 0.003983034286648035, -0.007867907173931599, 0.003513835836201906, 0.04794942960143089, -0.06611362844705582, -0.031329140067100525, 0.051238760352134705, 0.00120337656699121, -0.027420317754149437, -0.04238079860806465, 0.03723718225955963, 0.004417407792061567, -0.00785532034933567, 0.044098976999521255, -0.01795206032693386, -0.01064322143793106, 0.023907607421278954, 0.015089698135852814, -0.003736455226317048, 0.0020383091177791357, -0.013740234076976776, 0.038727886974811554, 0.019161207601428032, 0.0336797833442688, 0.0511845238506794, -0.008824952878057957, 0.041793495416641235, 0.017406905069947243, -0.03998352214694023, -0.0036727217957377434, -0.0304400771856308, -0.017574671655893326, -0.07833749055862427, -0.011466563679277897, -0.03037252277135849, 0.048914771527051926, 0.015777472406625748, -0.004795393906533718, -0.04746334254741669, -0.022948458790779114, -0.006716868374496698, 0.02185557596385479, -0.008260196074843407, -0.0036883510183542967, 0.012275672517716885, -0.01940072886645794, -0.017811059951782227, 0.030834343284368515, 0.028892353177070618, -0.0682496652007103, -0.002746822312474251, -0.0021389753092080355, -0.045809969305992126, -0.001611071638762951, 0.03910363093018532, -0.006293026730418205, 0.022997958585619926, 0.009420040994882584, 0.02610107511281967, 0.04370138794183731, 0.033352673053741455, -0.013141818344593048, -0.03338201344013214, 0.0009026980842463672, 0.0320865698158741, 0.0012314299819990993, 0.027851922437548637, 0.014594358392059803, 0.01158105954527855, -0.013568767346441746, -0.025018438696861267, -0.05791975185275078, -0.031049620360136032, -0.0004737724084407091, -0.042253732681274414, -0.007066517136991024, -0.02800118736922741, -0.036998048424720764, -0.02584531530737877, -0.018624741584062576, 0.0031592079903930426, 0.08828898519277573, -0.04384339973330498, 0.029734821990132332, 0.004485006909817457, 0.020987918600440025, 0.07726609706878662, 0.02214527502655983, -0.03313786908984184, 0.018525127321481705, -0.02256990782916546, 0.0109970448538661, 0.016202909871935844, -0.026800932362675667, -0.049486465752124786, -0.01067331898957491, -0.06366818398237228, 0.013577496632933617, 0.06712710112333298, -0.03433099389076233, -0.02635813318192959, 0.025085415691137314, -0.00143104896415025, 0.04413895681500435, -0.06026219576597214, -0.02771943435072899, -0.05509024113416672, 0.011369395069777966, -0.0242014117538929, 0.04660746827721596, -0.01733124442398548, 0.013601962476968765, 0.04086687043309212, -0.02344091422855854, -0.018456509336829185, 0.0025502291973680258, 0.09535582363605499, -0.02129283733665943, 0.018609533086419106, -0.018479978665709496, 0.011165453121066093, 0.06308263540267944, -0.0029649909120053053, 0.04288027808070183, 0.012202112935483456, 0.013917619362473488, -0.029073605313897133, -0.03047582507133484, -0.034597575664520264, -0.03102198801934719, 0.08214274048805237, 0.03040292114019394, 0.036800313740968704, 0.07466248422861099, -0.05398423969745636, 0.017872245982289314, -0.025040382519364357, -0.0025348514318466187, 0.0072885300032794476, -0.02808837592601776, 0.06126488745212555, -0.04502525553107262, -0.018041953444480896, 0.023661216720938683, -0.008322102949023247, 0.041678305715322495, 0.032676052302122116, 0.03796202316880226, 0.013238322921097279, 0.04736119136214256, -0.01699789986014366, -0.02683406136929989, 0.047554243355989456, -0.05647828429937363, 0.017196938395500183, -0.04434235394001007, -0.03468235209584236, 0.03103519417345524, 0.08659586310386658, -0.017767341807484627, -0.0791076049208641, -0.008958203718066216, -0.046304937452077866, 0.026326622813940048, 0.029652290046215057, -0.0142727205529809, 0.034870292991399765, -0.02005043439567089, 0.028876163065433502, 0.02140762470662594, 0.0444982647895813, -0.013957315124571323, -0.12640798091888428, 0.004664082080125809, 0.004405273590236902, -0.0032068430446088314, 0.02213064394891262, -0.011375281028449535, -0.01293450128287077, -0.009838868863880634, -0.06124049052596092, 0.01817205734550953, 0.010202622972428799, 0.024744970723986626, -0.01754526048898697, 0.012333790771663189, -0.034250739961862564, 0.03333941474556923, -0.027570601552724838, -0.036467764526605606, 0.13661311566829681, 0.0683097392320633, 0.030272454023361206, -0.06513489782810211, 0.055719707161188126, 0.04890929535031319, -0.0040958840399980545, 0.005604126024991274, -0.03148278594017029, 0.02683149091899395, 0.0008426482090726495, 0.03667815029621124, 0.03775228187441826, 0.008857068605720997, -0.011463907547295094, 0.05740799382328987, -0.0365322045981884, -0.028666727244853973, 0.0051797907799482346, -0.004024467431008816, 0.014062520116567612, -0.003972527105361223, -0.060305625200271606, -0.04620989412069321, 0.008366934023797512, -0.011429165489971638, -0.010427122004330158, -0.001357442932203412, -0.005794009659439325, 0.03576654940843582, -0.0028626644052565098, 0.009623231366276741, -0.005740203894674778, -0.005596074741333723, 0.041383374482393265, -0.03393171355128288, 0.03380177542567253, -0.016671255230903625, 0.030091779306530952, 0.07968667149543762, -0.004764430224895477, -0.02184152789413929, 0.008617439307272434, 0.04196278378367424, -0.02193605899810791, -0.03240916132926941, -0.03454878181219101, 0.04371493309736252, -0.017746472731232643, -0.028578395023941994, 0.00867505557835102, 0.00016262555436696857, -0.02395150624215603, -0.005064731929451227, -0.03279515355825424, 0.030306082218885422, 0.01911143586039543, -0.027440259233117104, 0.0037656195927411318, -0.04440648481249809, 0.03921886906027794, -0.022512780502438545, 0.032851845026016235, 0.03419982269406319, -0.014250279404222965, 0.005693337880074978, -0.030808795243501663, 0.022296098992228508, -0.00035572846536524594, 0.01721116527915001, -0.002863123081624508, -0.014580043964087963, -0.03767881169915199, -0.018611911684274673, -0.004153955727815628, 0.04411323741078377, 0.021253317594528198, 0.00612016161903739, -0.008298809640109539, -0.03240589424967766, -0.005695073399692774, -0.004766514059156179, 0.012705286033451557, -0.030893009155988693, -0.04025860130786896, -0.010774202644824982, 0.046047765761613846, 0.018615730106830597, -0.01456053089350462, -0.012614280916750431, 0.000006323380603134865, 0.06391983479261398, -0.00634347926825285, -0.04960889741778374, -0.04066391661763191, 0.002192953834310174, -0.00337421428412199, -0.02507738023996353, -0.0016275686211884022, 0.03147251904010773, 0.03830690681934357, 0.001452924800105393, -0.0297887921333313, 0.042689982801675797, -0.012212616391479969, -0.015475519001483917, 0.0059517184272408485, -0.02253987081348896, -0.02050495706498623, 0.010094054974615574, -0.002912083873525262, 0.002755670342594385, -0.00971039105206728, -0.04448343440890312, -0.012777090072631836, 0.006653959862887859, -0.07202886044979095, -0.016873478889465332, -0.012316371314227581, 0.010553832165896893, 0.004046940710395575, -0.021883148699998856, -0.023680370301008224, -0.012480814009904861, -0.048043143004179, 0.00659800972789526, 0.006904649082571268, 0.003720279783010483, 0.01325151789933443, -0.0009128766250796616, -0.005666736513376236, 0.0017760877963155508, 0.01402955036610365, -0.008123344741761684, -0.0069143990986049175, 0.013688151724636555, 0.015071626752614975, 0.0371614433825016, -0.0018953335238620639, -0.02766578271985054, 0.009081191383302212, -0.04246246814727783, -0.025232216343283653, 0.001383405178785324, -0.009427088312804699, 0.00931662879884243, 0.0385679192841053, 0.034071169793605804, 0.0014308295212686062, 0.06521106511354446, -0.01957714930176735, -0.014008701778948307, -0.026806194335222244, -0.003824829589575529, 0.019065044820308685, -0.022646639496088028, 0.007014581933617592, 0.02755807712674141, 0.0008556975517421961, 0.036893751472234726, 0.04379883036017418, 0.0064796325750648975, -0.0043791355565190315, 0.01664775237441063, -0.03269107639789581, 0.03474870324134827, 0.012757238000631332, -0.021640129387378693, 0.000059254729421809316, 0.01435228530317545, -0.03041262924671173, 0.04111725464463234, -0.008799009025096893, 0.0007037982577458024, -0.06892556697130203, -0.027367377653717995, 0.03077120892703533, 0.015742100775241852, 0.0038159219548106194, -0.0369420163333416, -0.007990923710167408, 0.015071759931743145, -0.020609842613339424, -0.04331720620393753, 0.017713865265250206, -0.009842903353273869, -0.020345833152532578, 0.029862375929951668, -0.03013782575726509, 0.009860863909125328, 0.013825364410877228, 0.013668161816895008, 0.010702761821448803, 0.0063774725422263145, -0.0008246016222983599, -0.022357162088155746, -0.012027405202388763, 0.0022481679916381836, 0.041679948568344116, -0.027873774990439415, 0.062187310308218, -0.027937399223446846, -0.04116804897785187, 0.012781777419149876, 0.028467360883951187, 0.07174970209598541, 0.004623739048838615, 0.031890712678432465, 0.0361785888671875, 0.0324750617146492, 0.02673579379916191, 0.006575533654540777, -0.022018415853381157, -0.014960130676627159, 0.023248722776770592, 0.03365961089730263, -0.054879043251276016, -0.013454196974635124, -0.01118661928921938, 0.010331147350370884, -0.016646111384034157, 0.012632063589990139, -0.04540220648050308, -0.05834149196743965, -0.0309627465903759, -0.03645697236061096, -0.00914025492966175, -0.016981851309537888, -0.0015042045852169394, -0.03619028627872467, 0.0012094461126253009, 0.04669499769806862, 0.0379597507417202, -0.027795346453785896, 0.03392956405878067, -0.010383215732872486, -0.006294258404523134, -0.006916745100170374, 0.010680405423045158, -0.017542121931910515, -0.04813447594642639, -0.0013273401418700814, 0.008324706926941872, 0.0074937604367733, -0.0335007980465889, 0.02282021753489971, -0.0381450317800045, 0.01956012099981308, -0.0159075278788805, -0.006940525956451893, -0.020985381677746773, 0.011653845198452473, 0.020678682252764702, -0.07041632384061813, 0.05160849168896675, 0.03023780882358551, 0.0000027112125735584414, -0.062401365488767624, -0.017081350088119507, -0.014509442262351513, 0.03911375626921654, 0.04660952091217041, 0.027363216504454613, -0.012484553270041943, 0.01985771767795086, 0.03242672607302666, -0.004480328876525164, -0.06630942225456238, 0.024421071633696556, 0.006887238938361406, 0.004079462960362434, -0.03269005939364433, -0.01518655102699995, -0.015066509135067463, -0.0049205501563847065, 0.04136381670832634, -0.019131816923618317, -0.011596604250371456, -0.02819836139678955, 0.002633902011439204, 0.034894030541181564, 0.025246841832995415, -0.023976949974894524, 0.009873084723949432, -0.02055039256811142, 0.03543727844953537, 0.011105909943580627, 0.018740355968475342, -0.04306112974882126, 0.04419364780187607, -0.02347879856824875, -0.01218995451927185, 0.027926065027713776, 0.008605532348155975, 0.013051178306341171, -0.031586240977048874, -0.0028026991058140993, 0.021602261811494827, -0.03045789711177349, -0.030985459685325623, 0.028617771342396736, 0.01574958674609661, 0.01777232252061367, 0.0018450821517035365, 0.017416615039110184, -0.014989443123340607, -0.02916785143315792, 0.012004698626697063, -0.03121470846235752, 0.019859356805682182, -0.0015363022685050964, -0.01196353044360876, 0.023281894624233246, -0.038973450660705566, 0.010142253711819649, -0.020891571417450905, 0.050602156668901443, -0.03639070317149162, -0.015118630602955818, 0.04158398136496544, -0.006590064615011215, 0.006601665634661913, 0.017279690131545067, 0.007552293129265308, 0.06115853786468506, -0.05847732350230217, 0.0023265567142516375, -0.025629177689552307, -0.012180156074464321, -0.01493398193269968, 0.03142977133393288, 0.006190522573888302, -0.017830587923526764, 0.053086888045072556, 0.014649172313511372, -0.013625222258269787, -0.06938831508159637, 0.020162370055913925, -0.01857496052980423, -0.02565661631524563, 0.006835300475358963, -0.026234827935695648, -0.0019361472222954035, -0.021964600309729576, -0.03745214268565178, -0.016018200665712357, 0.04737163335084915, 0.02445642091333866, 0.026545820757746696, -0.07238338887691498, -0.0319569855928421, 0.013700978830456734, 0.03366604447364807, -0.05285843834280968, -0.02682533673942089, -0.012765713036060333, 0.005827565211802721, 0.009195071645081043, -0.0052675530314445496 ]
<p>How would I interpret a transformed dependent variable (4th root) with some of its predictor variables transformed as well? In our study, we transformed our dependent variable to 4th root, $Y^\frac{1}{4}$, and one of our predictor variables to $\ln(X)$. How would I interpret that?</p>
49,681
[ -0.014338445849716663, 0.015470970422029495, -0.00549344765022397, 0.005026646889746189, 0.050655122846364975, 0.020282264798879623, -0.003745320485904813, -0.018270425498485565, 0.02105235494673252, -0.04650626331567764, 0.039684899151325226, -0.007841497659683228, 0.025951649993658066, -0.024678340181708336, 0.017426375299692154, 0.015577565878629684, -0.018064042553305626, 0.01419652346521616, 0.0003656635817606002, -0.0018281448865309358, 0.0091036232188344, 0.013050631619989872, -0.004114254377782345, 0.016229504719376564, -0.01945439726114273, 0.028120456263422966, -0.011559552513062954, -0.00002822818532877136, -0.006381679326295853, 0.024233438074588776, 0.01862388104200363, -0.036093566566705704, -0.010390588082373142, 0.050548944622278214, -0.015815909951925278, 0.017529616132378578, -0.016835182905197144, 0.005407382734119892, 0.0062839495949447155, 0.09378425776958466, -0.035930436104536057, -0.034802716225385666, 0.011403555981814861, 0.0213722363114357, -0.004418640397489071, 0.010285979136824608, -0.011550930328667164, -0.03136617690324783, 0.05930011346936226, 0.009452532045543194, 0.13473688066005707, 0.004769161809235811, -0.005911270156502724, 0.030285602435469627, -0.010999293066561222, -0.00027209179825149477, 0.08355773240327835, 0.06069552153348923, -0.030836807563900948, -0.052950169891119, -0.052354149520397186, -0.04596075415611267, -0.008840306662023067, 0.005749535746872425, -0.010770518332719803, -0.0037399660795927048, 0.013200714252889156, -0.014681835658848286, 0.020395249128341675, -0.04238347336649895, 0.00811388622969389, 0.025797581300139427, 0.058478765189647675, 0.01798056811094284, 0.008334334008395672, 0.02040356770157814, 0.004534414503723383, 0.02303650975227356, 0.029538262635469437, -0.0025128917768597603, 0.011839651502668858, 0.012284476310014725, -0.030776359140872955, 0.023739945143461227, -0.027149969711899757, 0.026100793853402138, 0.028743373230099678, -0.012134449556469917, 0.06376470625400543, 0.028686322271823883, 0.015426409430801868, 0.014360257424414158, 0.05011807754635811, -0.04030144214630127, -0.03438511863350868, 0.007864582352340221, -0.019040394574403763, 0.03540922328829765, 0.027925197035074234, 0.02139945887029171, -0.01491987518966198, -0.030304430052638054, 0.010229439474642277, 0.02473999746143818, -0.013628076761960983, -0.008982560597360134, -0.015887586399912834, 0.017373112961649895, 0.026929611340165138, -0.05500100925564766, -0.015301157720386982, 0.011962502263486385, 0.020101474598050117, 0.019909819588065147, 0.024350635707378387, -0.008619970642030239, -0.02306375652551651, -0.0033088824711740017, 0.049470312893390656, 0.022850092500448227, -0.0006880881846882403, -0.027219394221901894, 0.06615255773067474, 0.0361291766166687, -0.05289917066693306, 0.01772809959948063, 0.01996096409857273, -0.012839721515774727, -0.004414658527821302, 0.02905140072107315, 0.0203388798981905, -0.014619477093219757, -0.023392783477902412, 0.04594868794083595, 0.031119389459490776, -0.01892564259469509, -0.09877756983041763, -0.035678040236234665, 0.02952989749610424, 0.00427039572969079, 0.018971940502524376, -0.0946827232837677, -0.0018784975400194526, 0.03534862399101257, 0.06050854176282883, -0.020775923505425453, -0.0011728716781362891, 0.06069505587220192, 0.016521597281098366, 0.03923599421977997, -0.018753038719296455, 0.009138810448348522, -0.061783820390701294, -0.04438132420182228, 0.0016814982518553734, -0.03674989193677902, -0.010012027807533741, 0.03885553404688835, -0.031267277896404266, 0.002800916088744998, 0.04426198825240135, 0.006508096121251583, -0.020315159112215042, 0.043329980224370956, 0.0011918115196749568, 0.002894860692322254, 0.047936003655195236, -0.019701987504959106, 0.011999368667602539, 0.02945655770599842, 0.03845240920782089, 0.052329421043395996, -0.017489437013864517, 0.10114186257123947, 0.031035779044032097, -0.00839950330555439, 0.000679470191244036, -0.0431550033390522, 0.031077958643436432, -0.025299053639173508, -0.047773268073797226, -0.05078747496008873, -0.011971347033977509, -0.01006274577230215, -0.019357580691576004, 0.04870640113949776, -0.0055981785990297794, -0.018766237422823906, 0.0447128526866436, -0.04279208183288574, -0.034504521638154984, -0.02365798130631447, 0.007741469424217939, -0.01363313477486372, -0.018018104135990143, 0.004558879882097244, 0.016645926982164383, 0.04284648969769478, -0.011357341893017292, 0.01988610439002514, 0.0010371056850999594, 0.020701952278614044, 0.03685273975133896, 0.0077760713174939156, 0.015564355067908764, 0.03900031000375748, 0.008422575891017914, 0.025652095675468445, 0.026760771870613098, -0.05657368153333664, 0.001378266722895205, 0.017678765580058098, -0.0187327042222023, 0.0036857719533145428, -0.027708249166607857, -0.03178538382053375, -0.0025692349299788475, -0.030986780300736427, -0.022224603220820427, 0.04991443082690239, -0.045661572366952896, 0.061658892780542374, 0.03513411432504654, -0.030875394120812416, 0.0009895911207422614, 0.024128375574946404, 0.007798674050718546, 0.04296308755874634, -0.0681060180068016, -0.03943030536174774, -0.03687681630253792, -0.023475730791687965, 0.015649694949388504, 0.03751054406166077, -0.04479992762207985, -0.007325022481381893, 0.053931038826704025, -0.006234958302229643, 0.005702710710465908, 0.02992936037480831, 0.0037097367458045483, -0.011854265816509724, -0.004914567805826664, 0.012308611534535885, -0.0051487889140844345, -0.016165796667337418, -0.038817670196294785, 0.03498668596148491, 0.029056264087557793, -0.00990636833012104, -0.01589466817677021, 0.04702312871813774, -0.03463638201355934, 0.03834536671638489, -0.017084699124097824, -0.0002675660070963204, 0.028740989044308662, -0.04047173261642456, 0.02807653695344925, 0.01586601696908474, 0.005486082751303911, -0.016919132322072983, -0.00838370993733406, -0.006441124714910984, 0.03708765283226967, 0.03499084338545799, -0.038901593536138535, 0.0014911863254383206, 0.030765708535909653, -0.029993899166584015, 0.03217115253210068, -0.010204843245446682, -0.05897075682878494, -0.008996358141303062, -0.004361831117421389, 0.01799725741147995, 0.01899060793220997, 0.04091784730553627, -0.02010154537856579, -0.06493667513132095, 0.020474491640925407, 0.001178664737381041, 0.011607642285525799, 0.009918694384396076, -0.05068986490368843, -0.02203957922756672, -0.053573127835989, -0.01257770974189043, 0.020895550027489662, -0.01887446455657482, -0.008746765553951263, 0.01168428361415863, -0.013655032031238079, -0.05604632571339607, -0.03619267791509628, 0.013044244609773159, 0.02729775570333004, -0.026484711095690727, -0.032435785979032516, 0.060554880648851395, -0.02555123344063759, 0.009009363129734993, -0.018537087365984917, -0.048133764415979385, 0.002998884068801999, -0.018240952864289284, -0.02676214650273323, 0.00978124514222145, 0.03672867640852928, 0.06925167888402939, -0.012323185801506042, -0.020866302773356438, -0.020730650052428246, -0.057068832218647, -0.07205424457788467, 0.036580756306648254, 0.018338879570364952, 0.03402617946267128, -0.009446946904063225, -0.01851385086774826, 0.10567938536405563, 0.025715861469507217, -0.019615327939391136, -0.07102546095848083, -0.007507966365665197, -0.05095767229795456, -0.020808836445212364, 0.016710009425878525, 0.03441190347075462, 0.031205302104353905, 0.061533983796834946, -0.009114375337958336, 0.04406131058931351, 0.041848719120025635, 0.028926577419042587, -0.022598233073949814, 0.03592329099774361, 0.007755395956337452, 0.004348915070295334, 0.022257432341575623, 0.004790403880178928, 0.019760778173804283, 0.024960273876786232, -0.005610802210867405, 0.01601279154419899, 0.03125043958425522, -0.02386183850467205, 0.031756334006786346, 0.01098659262061119, -0.010456857271492481, -0.0069482531398534775, 0.027441883459687233, 0.03989233076572418, -0.04234370216727257, -0.02635720744729042, 0.007817667908966541, 0.02688688412308693, 0.01538932230323553, 0.033834539353847504, 0.02261807955801487, 0.030302664265036583, -0.011607499793171883, 0.0026631418149918318, 0.014900712296366692, -0.022589752450585365, 0.05082365497946739, 0.007424534298479557, -0.008233283646404743, 0.04431639984250069, 0.001833051792345941, -0.015535273589193821, -0.01023807842284441, -0.047230497002601624, 0.018034854903817177, -0.045495450496673584, 0.010967410169541836, -0.011669347994029522, 0.02441772073507309, 0.005281923338770866, 0.035415325313806534, 0.0319991260766983, -0.006119137164205313, 0.025407979264855385, 0.029947437345981598, -0.041638974100351334, 0.03481908515095711, -0.030769119039177895, 0.03217918053269386, -0.027298947796225548, 0.012740988284349442, 0.07121147960424423, -0.03539761155843735, -0.005185120273381472, 0.00143581279553473, 0.0023959532845765352, -0.03625643253326416, 0.0046468982473015785, -0.012228566221892834, -0.01261470839381218, -0.034044355154037476, 0.03249093517661095, 0.06179417669773102, -0.003697771579027176, 0.028986508026719093, 0.06337056308984756, -0.007241636049002409, 0.01632697507739067, -0.04643736034631729, -0.03167946636676788, 0.036440104246139526, 0.03775310888886452, 0.03852079436182976, -0.002451206324622035, -0.018129656091332436, 0.025536049157381058, 0.015337563119828701, 0.04980836808681488, 0.0317026749253273, -0.0258207805454731, -0.017994849011301994, -0.030653487890958786, 0.002720400458201766, 0.009268254972994328, 0.015214787796139717, 0.005128192715346813, 0.02676817961037159, 0.06475620716810226, 0.030227305367588997, -0.018890559673309326, 0.011273394338786602, 0.05214005336165428, 0.014205560088157654, -0.02864309959113598, -0.007974271662533283, 0.03209206461906433, 0.028889520093798637, 0.017218036577105522, 0.0034144490491598845, -0.023282762616872787, -0.029501231387257576, -0.01381466630846262, 0.055076714605093, 0.013462834991514683, -0.02394886501133442, 0.020229170098900795, 0.002701761433854699, 0.05417320877313614, 0.0067078606225550175, -0.06555081903934479, 0.017199130728840828, 0.03265298902988434, 0.019372086971998215, 0.014261738397181034, -0.020984355360269547, -0.09334603697061539, 0.010394441895186901, 0.02285410463809967, 0.03229533135890961, -0.027946053072810173, 0.006252523511648178, -0.006693514063954353, 0.00858503207564354, 0.00796672236174345, -0.029380325227975845, 0.02349701151251793, -0.004419546574354172, -0.009634182788431644, -0.01756553165614605, -0.05152767524123192, -0.06577537953853607, 0.02129857800900936, -0.013089298270642757, 0.006522482261061668, -0.009789137169718742, -0.03634948655962944, -0.016451431438326836, 0.001711563440039754, -0.033661335706710815, 0.05515186861157417, -0.0028698216192424297, -0.001729372190311551, -0.03075285628437996, 0.0492221862077713, 0.007709647063165903, -0.047755248844623566, 0.037299126386642456, 0.050955627113580704, -0.02164791338145733, 0.04793103411793709, -0.0023021611850708723, -0.07202772796154022, 0.01608758233487606, 0.0005414274055510759, -0.006127974484115839, -0.006938132457435131, -0.04929511249065399, 0.0017183657037094235, 0.039004914462566376, -0.009574458003044128, 0.038581594824790955, 0.04782584682106972, 0.015576688572764397, -0.011966779828071594, -0.03313511610031128, 0.03697771579027176, -0.03089827112853527, -0.0008834342006593943, 0.006910525728017092, -0.02690909244120121, -0.016814762726426125, 0.03548704460263252, 0.0012786062434315681, 0.039603475481271744, -0.05401023477315903, -0.022781243547797203, -0.0009349670726805925, -0.015818964689970016, -0.010482031852006912, -0.038905225694179535, -0.028832728043198586, 0.02536776289343834, -0.006709123495966196, -0.033000003546476364, -0.005907886661589146, -0.020284974947571754, 0.02752666361629963, 0.03466730937361717, -0.012917677871882915, -0.015857303515076637, 0.0089023532345891, -0.022307682782411575, 0.0449860617518425, -0.0450882762670517, 0.02043059468269348, 0.0007740905275568366, -0.004548455588519573, -0.008528737351298332, -0.03374582901597023, -0.027281487360596657, -0.0011333830188959837, 0.01019078679382801, 0.046536628156900406, -0.04561707377433777, -0.0005653973203152418, -0.03638158366084099, -0.007443437818437815, -0.03393342345952988, -0.04012850299477577, 0.0021019061096012592, -0.016376443207263947, -0.009462407790124416, -0.012476101517677307, -0.032668761909008026, -0.04039139300584793, -0.04996385797858238, 0.0004890564596280456, 0.024353422224521637, -0.02000678889453411, -0.008813558146357536, -0.0004220952687319368, 0.03774384409189224, 0.03860420361161232, -0.04174512252211571, -0.00137989385984838, 0.02573215216398239, -0.01173482183367014, -0.023122485727071762, 0.029526565223932266, -0.005351053085178137, -0.03918496519327164, -0.0074066901579499245, -0.03287883102893829, -0.014680060558021069, 0.019320636987686157, -0.04874906316399574, -0.03966328129172325, -0.003942163195461035, 0.06112874671816826, 0.00017481474787928164, -0.005920088849961758, -0.00986968819051981, 0.01903865486383438, 0.030795469880104065, 0.0363876149058342, 0.014870432205498219, -0.01471608318388462, -0.028330765664577484, 0.031283117830753326, 0.002946282271295786, 0.007211912423372269, 0.05251296982169151, 0.07903490215539932, -0.0035825201775878668, 0.00652291951701045, -0.016153033822774887, -0.011222509667277336, 0.013672673143446445, 0.025003401562571526, 0.031946856528520584, 0.006070811301469803, 0.02918851003050804, -0.052644599229097366, -0.04708196222782135, -0.03130258619785309, -0.019079076126217842, 0.06522797793149948, -0.04307178780436516, 0.024709930643439293, 0.06519844383001328, -0.020450487732887268, -0.0001239611447090283, -0.014187075197696686, -0.010440812446177006, 0.04526077210903168, -0.0284376610070467, 0.039403676986694336, -0.00970776192843914, -0.0022422971669584513, 0.01086095068603754, 0.03881336748600006, -0.03218845650553703, 0.029201606288552284, 0.03767407312989235, 0.016587156802415848, 0.015534048900008202, -0.004442034754902124, -0.0345802828669548, 0.02490440383553505, -0.014226105064153671, -0.00015284214168787003, -0.03304765000939369, 0.02165580727159977, 0.05674650892615318, 0.04940268024802208, 0.028716346248984337, -0.06798682361841202, -0.012000341899693012, -0.03609573096036911, -0.03647572919726372, 0.019670842215418816, 0.009391803294420242, 0.041940249502658844, 0.016330502927303314, 0.023102613165974617, 0.00043730001198127866, 0.049778833985328674, -0.02137201651930809, -0.07425913214683533, -0.038485776633024216, -0.007259243633598089, -0.01827150210738182, 0.020222969353199005, -0.02155199833214283, -0.04146111011505127, -0.00485753919929266, -0.06485522538423538, -0.01501496508717537, 0.018058886751532555, 0.008451309986412525, -0.0016160816885530949, 0.06472399085760117, 0.03863911330699921, -0.014829943887889385, 0.007717832922935486, 0.016362786293029785, 0.08246830850839615, 0.11709258705377579, 0.004502818454056978, -0.08065538853406906, 0.01594376191496849, -0.024064205586910248, 0.025476541370153427, -0.028403164818882942, -0.016268150880932808, 0.02051173523068428, 0.009619908407330513, -0.009182772599160671, 0.023565243929624557, -0.008768917992711067, 0.018606560304760933, 0.02727600373327732, -0.007423334755003452, 0.0015719409566372633, 0.014390412718057632, -0.01114965882152319, -0.003285225946456194, 0.003263738937675953, -0.06337901949882507, -0.0016625354764983058, -0.03448696807026863, -0.02118293195962906, -0.002374187810346484, -0.0067888470366597176, 0.010574273765087128, -0.0217501949518919, -0.01589861512184143, 0.004975205287337303, 0.04640915244817734, 0.027989523485302925, -0.026399580761790276, 0.0028058544266968966, 0.006165681406855583, -0.008893841877579689, -0.0021419203840196133, 0.049067314714193344, -0.004678406752645969, -0.014243615791201591, 0.024191197007894516, 0.00895948987454176, -0.038502033799886703, -0.03760716691613197, -0.013709362596273422, 0.004358354955911636, 0.027320321649312973, -0.010334717109799385, -0.04301035776734352, -0.0006027399795129895, -0.009569072164595127, -0.045671019703149796, -0.0038839823100715876, 0.05477377399802208, 0.01973572000861168, -0.03602764010429382, -0.04596454277634621, 0.0040174187161028385, -0.023601731285452843, -0.018678836524486542, 0.03624867647886276, -0.005959531292319298, -0.022433916106820107, -0.009539534337818623, -0.02611774392426014, 0.016346000134944916, -0.03953249752521515, -0.004056545905768871, -0.005557600408792496, 0.0030714331660419703, -0.0133820166811347, -0.016359539702534676, 0.00638866750523448, -0.0034151382278651, 0.010162608698010445, -0.021564530208706856, 0.013882724568247795, -0.06533133238554001, -0.029815224930644035, 0.03575405105948448, -0.02541535161435604, 0.0031576233450323343, -0.050971560180187225, -0.009513969533145428, -0.0018645034870132804, 0.053125303238630295, -0.015871353447437286, -0.03808368369936943, -0.03271331638097763, 0.024975309148430824, 0.017696665599942207, -0.052597835659980774, -0.004527682904154062, 0.04828178137540817, -0.03488404303789139, -0.043226100504398346, -0.019643813371658325, 0.0692373588681221, 0.02918103151023388, -0.008556071668863297, -0.031577710062265396, 0.06539303809404373, -0.031267184764146805, 0.008728055283427238, 0.020746704190969467, -0.03126521036028862, 0.00924211461097002, 0.018739694729447365, -0.008995234966278076, -0.02200460061430931, -0.00516108563169837, -0.0194505974650383, -0.05611760541796684, 0.014538693241775036, -0.013635771349072456, -0.016340844333171844, 0.009032342582941055, -0.025980498641729355, 0.047789040952920914, 0.009150802157819271, 0.00470673106610775, -0.0429438054561615, -0.009511089883744717, 0.009291027672588825, -0.0678456723690033, -0.018065614625811577, 0.0126704853028059, 0.004972241353243589, -0.02492007054388523, 0.02392338030040264, 0.01715899258852005, 0.010101595893502235, -0.03472011536359787, -0.01599333994090557, 0.005471459589898586, 0.013435798697173595, -0.014675667509436607, -0.0003796044329646975, 0.004111941903829575, -0.037294063717126846, 0.012295219115912914, 0.044236376881599426, 0.019494544714689255, 0.055251095443964005, 0.006674514152109623, 0.038281504064798355, -0.045040976256132126, 0.02238384634256363, -0.03128295764327049, 0.028581097722053528, -0.002766880439594388, -0.0272007267922163, 0.004309090320020914, 0.019936874508857727, 0.01572304777801037, 0.024485254660248756, -0.0018948217621073127, -0.0043073613196611404, 0.049901265650987625, 0.0011993313673883677, -0.004500317852944136, 0.028653208166360855, 0.011569270864129066, 0.056689947843551636, -0.01415717788040638, 0.013744383119046688, 0.0430903397500515, 0.053764648735523224, 0.009566710330545902, 0.0480872206389904, -0.004390178248286247, 0.022034915164113045, -0.06989043205976486, -0.025312457233667374, 0.02570318803191185, 0.001312451553530991, 0.03846333548426628, -0.06385092437267303, 0.0030528418719768524, 0.022971119731664658, -0.027196571230888367, -0.00801813043653965, -0.007037575356662273, -0.01855081506073475, -0.0010361408349126577, -0.03398607671260834, 0.0015632595168426633, 0.0510617271065712, 0.07156877219676971, -0.009480929933488369, -0.00984140858054161, -0.0016141595551744103, -0.02111963741481304, -0.002832392929121852, 0.03351859748363495, 0.016359712928533554, 0.0428144596517086, -0.03539402037858963, 0.014545848593115807, -0.02491580881178379, -0.04199719429016113, 0.0642581582069397, -0.001696055755019188, 0.0316840261220932, 0.01663762889802456, -0.017873840406537056, 0.030398283153772354, 0.04459073394536972, -0.0042503816075623035, -0.015340663492679596, -0.02365323156118393, 0.012817553244531155, 0.023204775527119637, 0.011579989455640316, 0.012203830294311047, -0.01687455363571644, -0.010183083824813366, -0.042118653655052185, -0.00796933937817812, -0.005116062704473734, -0.034801460802555084, 0.017148230224847794, -0.006321168038994074, -0.033756233751773834, -0.026107871904969215, -0.04861905798316002, 0.03552808240056038, -0.02503826469182968, -0.054482389241456985, 0.03405388072133064, 0.036099035292863846, -0.0002270510740345344, 0.0034544572699815035, -0.03621123358607292, -0.03317657858133316, 0.003331472398713231, -0.005041200201958418, -0.03967779502272606, -0.06484820693731308, 0.01172325573861599, -0.00015886100300122052, -0.06767440587282181, -0.031215554103255272, 0.00851824413985014, -0.04526158422231674, 0.02049580030143261, -0.006111547816544771, 0.01456468179821968, 0.0001371577673126012, -0.046904921531677246, 0.0038720876909792423, -0.0903724804520607, 0.06975952535867691, 0.006183910183608532, -0.03743818402290344, -0.027941817417740822, 0.022675836458802223, -0.03161924332380295, -0.03142743185162544, 0.050072140991687775, 0.02115238644182682, -0.011594410054385662, 0.021849069744348526, 0.022267334163188934, -0.021066542714834213, -0.05407512187957764, 0.009632357396185398, 0.009512854740023613, 0.06122404336929321, -0.03211289271712303, 0.006607512943446636, -0.005368930287659168, 0.010774725116789341, -0.01050143875181675, 0.0038860670756548643, -0.0027169715613126755, 0.014718539081513882, -0.005929044913500547, 0.02646394446492195, -0.014345696195960045, -0.02358010970056057, 0.008081413805484772, 0.009389614686369896, -0.01975833810865879, 0.03664996102452278, -0.029975440353155136, -0.06779998540878296, 0.006354987621307373, -0.03727317601442337, -0.021769003942608833, 0.0034665255807340145, -0.014123649336397648, 0.042403195053339005, -0.032782603055238724, -0.023689711466431618, 0.022190548479557037, -0.03200112655758858, -0.025184884667396545, 0.048138439655303955, 0.05333206057548523, 0.027967210859060287, 0.002612183103337884, -0.020474473014473915, 0.0005060723633505404, -0.013835561461746693, 0.0028518850449472666, -0.03197161853313446, 0.02550600841641426, 0.014416694641113281, -0.013415845111012459, -0.007531522773206234, -0.014966978691518307, 0.017355142161250114, -0.0063349115662276745, 0.06129782646894455, -0.05498203635215759, 0.013117439113557339, 0.013105284422636032, -0.005591996945440769, 0.026487944647669792, -0.0025640514213591814, 0.007937927730381489, 0.04965931549668312, -0.03382091224193573, 0.00728455139324069, -0.04668048396706581, -0.03034152090549469, -0.03281974792480469, 0.01809750311076641, 0.009614289738237858, 0.0038882014341652393, -0.009958190843462944, 0.023867523297667503, -0.04167192429304123, -0.026677871122956276, -0.007950538769364357, -0.016657983884215355, -0.008286288008093834, -0.027506334707140923, -0.0010316139087080956, 0.019772639498114586, -0.05076188966631889, -0.056821104139089584, -0.022251861169934273, 0.013074581511318684, 0.07048393785953522, 0.05676400661468506, -0.005948026664555073, -0.020660188049077988, -0.011577259749174118, 0.07603532075881958, -0.04485563188791275, -0.05084364116191864, -0.027280732989311218, 0.029663320630788803, 0.08271336555480957, -0.03558400645852089 ]
<p>When calculating Adjusted $R^2$ the formula is $1-(1-R^2)\frac{n-1}{n-k-1}$ with $k$ being how many predictors you have. If I am using a model with a single variable but that variable has been put to the 4th, 3rd, and 2nd power like the following, </p> <p>$\hat{Y}=-0.0162x^4+0.2239x^3-1.0941x^2+2.0972x-0.9513$</p> <p>would I have a single predictor or would I count each powered term as a predictor? Also if you could give short reasoning so I can try and grasp the concept as to why or why not to.</p> <p>Thanks in advance.</p>
37,064
[ -0.031158562749624252, 0.0012108574155718088, 0.005694818217307329, -0.001766959554515779, 0.022123221307992935, -0.02042761817574501, 0.002551355632022023, -0.02028658799827099, 0.01638045907020569, -0.02652803808450699, 0.019102370366454124, 0.02810528874397278, 0.06874636560678482, -0.012319340370595455, 0.0024634539149701595, 0.004670414142310619, -0.028322529047727585, 0.031618647277355194, 0.030929425731301308, -0.01259499043226242, -0.009206629358232021, 0.016675084829330444, 0.00029536234796978533, -0.006853491999208927, -0.01221511047333479, 0.08470091968774796, 0.047988392412662506, -0.007296633441001177, 0.01659134030342102, -0.00818889494985342, 0.015085597522556782, -0.02879830077290535, 0.029335400089621544, 0.08575716614723206, 0.02090216614305973, -0.0024911705404520035, -0.01637166365981102, -0.059082139283418655, -0.012842428870499134, 0.03871157392859459, -0.019164731726050377, -0.05122258514165878, 0.00724593224003911, -0.008994262665510178, -0.011541158892214298, 0.03853283077478409, -0.013123963959515095, -0.03379916772246361, 0.047299984842538834, -0.05119100585579872, 0.0899939015507698, 0.02188429981470108, 0.05686956271529198, 0.02677527442574501, -0.031486012041568756, -0.009992755018174648, 0.07267258316278458, 0.08602938801050186, -0.020123939961194992, -0.03585336357355118, -0.009335190057754517, 0.002227209275588393, 0.010312126018106937, 0.017520220950245857, -0.017145266756415367, 0.025724785402417183, 0.011127175763249397, -0.002152233850210905, 0.021559474989771843, -0.022036965936422348, 0.044204216450452805, -0.006641695741564035, 0.022414060309529305, -0.003584653604775667, 0.01075650192797184, -0.004997672978788614, 0.01680268533527851, 0.03478280454874039, 0.0653396025300026, 0.020442187786102295, 0.0025501460768282413, -0.005585441365838051, 0.01812322624027729, 0.05773993209004402, 0.005676038097590208, 0.034644223749637604, 0.022669866681098938, 0.004490961786359549, 0.04817117750644684, 0.039308495819568634, -0.022639336064457893, 0.003846945008262992, 0.06608964502811432, -0.0532667376101017, -0.04072313383221626, 0.025852520018815994, -0.025574425235390663, 0.03325328975915909, 0.011990820057690144, 0.014382455497980118, 0.008024361915886402, -0.025869309902191162, -0.003186775604262948, 0.03597790747880936, -0.009021447971463203, -0.02210661582648754, -0.03471822664141655, -0.0046263765543699265, 0.03473493456840515, -0.03459705412387848, -0.03265935927629471, 0.028446504846215248, -0.018656212836503983, -0.023875929415225983, 0.010556360706686974, -0.02601906657218933, -0.019915735349059105, 0.015588587149977684, 0.05310588330030441, 0.05296266824007034, 0.014668294228613377, -0.04092417657375336, 0.030043864622712135, -0.013217808678746223, -0.022931966930627823, 0.027921967208385468, 0.009699069894850254, -0.03016583062708378, -0.04324224218726158, 0.008629567921161652, 0.04242921248078346, -0.03661395609378815, 0.020202375948429108, 0.00029081484535709023, 0.0277735386043787, 0.015626803040504456, -0.0961417630314827, -0.03615966811776161, 0.019397178664803505, -0.052177272737026215, 0.025665873661637306, -0.054749853909015656, -0.007424913812428713, 0.054944708943367004, 0.08240532875061035, -0.002365496475249529, 0.03702099993824959, 0.04689916595816612, 0.030749013647437096, 0.0042533245868980885, -0.027388719841837883, -0.00017139142437372357, -0.040946219116449356, -0.0654071718454361, -0.024274403229355812, -0.05793774500489235, 0.012601488269865513, 0.03395842760801315, -0.012591269798576832, 0.011895853094756603, 0.04574207589030266, 0.018508292734622955, 0.004376620519906282, 0.01829647831618786, -0.015171904116868973, -0.00022849450760986656, 0.07681114226579666, -0.0007040022755973041, 0.06814150512218475, 0.025739969685673714, 0.01694890670478344, 0.039236586540937424, -0.006404569372534752, 0.056530654430389404, 0.04692322760820389, 0.02286076545715332, -0.015209745615720749, -0.07379647344350815, 0.023596592247486115, -0.002436900744214654, -0.11237835139036179, -0.03438429906964302, 0.026835184544324875, -0.0037556965835392475, 0.0016325151082128286, 0.02589435502886772, 0.013852028176188469, -0.0325133353471756, 0.044751472771167755, -0.03572912886738777, -0.022262243553996086, -0.046398576349020004, 0.012009788304567337, -0.008085143752396107, -0.01684902235865593, 0.023470580577850342, 0.009024395607411861, 0.0197531096637249, 0.015693705528974533, 0.026754876598715782, -0.01969011314213276, 0.02857932448387146, 0.0388212576508522, -0.05588052421808243, 0.033058520406484604, 0.04183884710073471, 0.046857643872499466, -0.009300231002271175, 0.03364667668938637, -0.034595590084791183, -0.022577563300728798, -0.004923787899315357, -0.03887365013360977, 0.007886658422648907, -0.025230534374713898, -0.019444597885012627, 0.00747908977791667, -0.01152586005628109, -0.00043944621575064957, 0.050470490008592606, -0.046029042452573776, 0.05939212813973427, 0.05294928327202797, 0.016483256593346596, 0.013700836338102818, 0.005001235753297806, -0.027666736394166946, 0.006998627912253141, -0.03488664701581001, 0.0012658643536269665, -0.06108454614877701, 0.005791828036308289, 0.013839139603078365, 0.007717937231063843, -0.061995234340429306, 0.0169454924762249, 0.08753511309623718, 0.024706551805138588, 0.003921522758901119, 0.033747196197509766, 0.006343017797917128, -0.006406809203326702, 0.001884122029878199, 0.0052792467176914215, 0.0023464560508728027, 0.013143966905772686, 0.01163545809686184, 0.020511630922555923, 0.017380479723215103, 0.023388376459479332, 0.008725600317120552, 0.03475010767579079, -0.008612454868853092, 0.014377315528690815, 0.0071440874598920345, -0.013590098358690739, 0.03108573704957962, -0.030393850058317184, 0.042009007185697556, 0.03761879727244377, 0.004778273869305849, -0.007297462783753872, -0.028630545362830162, -0.023083819076418877, 0.03418688103556633, 0.024985115975141525, -0.059550799429416656, -0.03653448447585106, 0.011934679001569748, -0.04174671322107315, 0.006789457984268665, 0.0008251161780208349, -0.025082938373088837, -0.02219405211508274, 0.012450309470295906, 0.023566728457808495, 0.017716920003294945, 0.054664719849824905, -0.010600087232887745, -0.031905364245176315, -0.011059126816689968, -0.018778853118419647, 0.03380922973155975, -0.014893993735313416, -0.06577294319868088, -0.04435163736343384, -0.05181188881397247, -0.008780810050666332, 0.04214315116405487, 0.014192650094628334, -0.04649971425533295, 0.019874904304742813, -0.01787477172911167, -0.05524294078350067, -0.035273872315883636, -0.02231397107243538, 0.013872875832021236, -0.0664026066660881, -0.05807099491357803, 0.059064436703920364, 0.0039043633732944727, -0.02723044715821743, 0.00513799162581563, -0.05530668422579765, 0.0014965857844799757, 0.014230778440833092, -0.0058184037916362286, 0.027600590139627457, 0.022415749728679657, 0.03170850872993469, 0.021208714693784714, -0.03957843407988548, -0.008849500678479671, -0.04593763127923012, -0.0689956322312355, 0.019055869430303574, -0.004596735816448927, 0.04161138832569122, 0.007771786767989397, -0.0251384899020195, 0.061000924557447433, 0.014075142331421375, -0.003129183081910014, -0.022946184501051903, -0.0022212923504412174, -0.037539079785346985, -0.024741586297750473, 0.012632524594664574, 0.007884965278208256, 0.03083665855228901, 0.004488739650696516, -0.006484381388872862, 0.019461462274193764, 0.05130353569984436, 0.006217383313924074, -0.006694038398563862, 0.018996765837073326, 0.0079253064468503, -0.029006870463490486, 0.045117128640413284, 0.010682030580937862, 0.005600514821708202, 0.019937722012400627, -0.03455349802970886, -0.0017294620629400015, 0.027185868471860886, -0.00024677091278135777, -0.012553529813885689, -0.0403636135160923, 0.022843599319458008, 0.0071470895782113075, 0.01594969630241394, 0.0192152950912714, -0.04133684188127518, -0.037072133272886276, 0.03267309442162514, 0.058646298944950104, -0.030566900968551636, 0.027456851676106453, 0.020577987655997276, 0.04142071306705475, -0.01438079308718443, 0.007044502068310976, 0.007998930290341377, -0.007694657891988754, 0.03692065179347992, -0.005253973882645369, 0.0006898429710417986, 0.060231272131204605, -0.011735665611922741, 0.005702247843146324, 0.002434024354442954, -0.015729133039712906, 0.01173420250415802, -0.052343640476465225, 0.0005822043749503791, -0.07530437409877777, 0.03932026028633118, -0.009523379616439342, 0.024422336369752884, 0.004477277863770723, -0.04494589567184448, 0.03962855041027069, 0.034077975898981094, -0.03583861142396927, 0.04162244126200676, 0.00943476241081953, -0.0039046434685587883, -0.00901245977729559, 0.005059598945081234, 0.005771506577730179, -0.05617263540625572, -0.002047165995463729, 0.004813156556338072, -0.016094118356704712, -0.029670806601643562, 0.01592918671667576, -0.007129798177629709, -0.015582793392241001, -0.010251238942146301, 0.05011019855737686, 0.045345697551965714, -0.043106406927108765, -0.00002028774360951502, 0.054198287427425385, -0.014995237812399864, 0.010968548245728016, -0.0397745780646801, -0.00696236826479435, 0.0048600309528410435, 0.03797862306237221, 0.04818112403154373, 0.0016984742833301425, -0.026851117610931396, 0.00903316494077444, 0.021940503269433975, 0.020761212334036827, 0.04169255867600441, -0.019193565472960472, -0.017133571207523346, -0.04285351559519768, -0.026041371747851372, -0.025004398077726364, 0.016921930015087128, 0.02100205235183239, -0.00046209487481974065, 0.04775788635015488, -0.011392267420887947, -0.030289283022284508, -0.02692311629652977, 0.07948306202888489, -0.020787283778190613, -0.002749595558270812, -0.05147258937358856, 0.05016770213842392, 0.006923244800418615, 0.015442665666341782, 0.00824738573282957, -0.003050853731110692, -0.03023267164826393, 0.004617586266249418, 0.023506391793489456, -0.005089398007839918, -0.014495953917503357, 0.010452494025230408, 0.05400015786290169, 0.050908565521240234, -0.017267415300011635, -0.04291059821844101, 0.0244784913957119, 0.05607471242547035, -0.010000716894865036, 0.004116142634302378, -0.025420289486646652, -0.08223609626293182, 0.018049702048301697, 0.032869573682546616, 0.02688351273536682, -0.047174904495477676, -0.015810109674930573, -0.005232673138380051, 0.011004301719367504, 0.043993499130010605, -0.04379475116729736, 0.016251584514975548, -0.01363926287740469, -0.011326105333864689, -0.011300014331936836, -0.024544676765799522, -0.07081462442874908, -0.0077673704363405704, -0.03314956650137901, 0.053860295563936234, -0.012791616842150688, 0.008783139288425446, -0.0244655292481184, -0.005490240175276995, 0.004548277705907822, 0.06263308972120285, -0.008593345060944557, -0.03503115102648735, -0.00878466572612524, 0.03581317514181137, 0.010513480752706528, -0.05763067305088043, 0.02523551508784294, -0.011208596639335155, -0.013015000149607658, 0.044683851301670074, -0.04292809218168259, -0.04795542359352112, 0.007383108604699373, 0.014151354320347309, -0.03023286908864975, -0.019478045403957367, -0.030088316649198532, 0.012093912810087204, 0.020235706120729446, -0.012575854547321796, 0.057399287819862366, 0.032779645174741745, 0.004430374596267939, -0.018206654116511345, -0.002997400937601924, -0.0034674121998250484, -0.004288135562092066, -0.05679994821548462, -0.010482546873390675, -0.022572319954633713, -0.01661428064107895, 0.028037069365382195, -0.00017887803551275283, 0.06657504290342331, -0.03613471984863281, -0.00738132931292057, 0.0012482608435675502, 0.022378353402018547, 0.016988905146718025, 0.0047952597960829735, -0.022720996290445328, 0.0445585660636425, 0.004280733410269022, -0.029778681695461273, -0.01856062188744545, -0.004312497563660145, 0.02040249854326248, 0.02424311824142933, -0.004740122240036726, 0.024899054318666458, 0.014637349173426628, -0.007650179788470268, 0.003409297438338399, -0.020511692389845848, 0.03946615755558014, 0.009439517743885517, 0.03692145645618439, -0.022962482646107674, -0.0648220106959343, -0.032972536981105804, 0.009872940368950367, -0.003619714640080929, 0.0351502001285553, -0.017612669616937637, 0.008689883165061474, -0.018698642030358315, -0.010856710374355316, -0.0638883039355278, -0.030022986233234406, -0.010118222795426846, 0.011205310001969337, 0.0002208389196312055, 0.009533082135021687, 0.012456199154257774, -0.04190385341644287, -0.042698267847299576, -0.011428103782236576, 0.03319618105888367, -0.006292418111115694, -0.037436045706272125, 0.00023605556634720415, -0.0037432610988616943, 0.04251351207494736, 0.0008206713246181607, -0.03966306895017624, 0.032623082399368286, -0.0200617965310812, 0.013313887640833855, 0.017454640939831734, -0.0006283891852945089, -0.03865344077348709, -0.0035038390196859837, -0.04577740654349327, -0.03904002159833908, 0.02355421520769596, -0.004094304982572794, -0.023522956296801567, -0.009206202812492847, 0.033746130764484406, 0.0014057958032935858, -0.04062914848327637, -0.005405924748629332, -0.04268653690814972, -0.005463127046823502, 0.016917722299695015, -0.030130678787827492, -0.015022956766188145, 0.002738923765718937, -0.008354967460036278, 0.005010643042623997, 0.0099142761901021, 0.014652681536972523, 0.07018212229013443, 0.0130483228713274, -0.002031039446592331, -0.020822402089834213, -0.06243384629487991, 0.021303610876202583, 0.025943594053387642, -0.011399002745747566, -0.019362227991223335, 0.004529265686869621, -0.023113952949643135, -0.032259102910757065, -0.045965999364852905, 0.02365672029554844, 0.07848740369081497, -0.02404654026031494, 0.01435251347720623, 0.03434149920940399, 0.017940908670425415, 0.010764683596789837, -0.04576674476265907, 0.00727621978148818, -0.02043941430747509, -0.0059720310382544994, 0.055031511932611465, -0.010750316083431244, 0.014598038047552109, 0.01986021175980568, 0.004335478413850069, 0.04091503843665123, 0.04205034300684929, 0.025142299011349678, 0.027653111144900322, 0.02009434439241886, -0.027719033882021904, -0.029736235737800598, 0.02315540425479412, -0.020977787673473358, -0.019919155165553093, -0.017329711467027664, 0.0038693337701261044, 0.03064023144543171, 0.034765563905239105, -0.0037167605478316545, -0.06488727778196335, -0.03328563645482063, -0.02142239920794964, -0.025630047544836998, -0.005441472865641117, -0.02912978082895279, 0.022914426401257515, 0.011860407888889313, 0.017291655763983727, 0.010511000640690327, 0.05709649249911308, -0.027445655316114426, -0.0868266299366951, -0.061242952942848206, -0.012488659471273422, -0.030207272619009018, 0.013409544713795185, 0.011065141297876835, -0.053366873413324356, 0.011410096660256386, -0.03865571692585945, 0.0034083020873367786, -0.0008381432853639126, 0.038794875144958496, 0.013788947835564613, 0.049028657376766205, 0.004093937575817108, -0.0318358838558197, 0.0029415651224553585, 0.003722206223756075, 0.11170799285173416, 0.1271999627351761, 0.04319492727518082, -0.03514755517244339, 0.007667034398764372, -0.04439552128314972, 0.012319739907979965, -0.046663206070661545, 0.0020121242851018906, -0.030568484216928482, -0.024827759712934494, 0.011488010175526142, 0.05893668904900551, 0.028201226145029068, 0.03047781065106392, 0.041827041655778885, -0.038570232689380646, -0.003666879842057824, 0.004728582222014666, -0.016079409047961235, 0.015227260068058968, 0.010612200014293194, -0.010408315807580948, 0.021242065355181694, -0.008644422516226768, -0.012747521512210369, -0.020532580092549324, 0.03096179850399494, 0.011095250025391579, 0.01481319684535265, -0.03483050689101219, 0.04682416096329689, -0.02888970449566841, 0.016878848895430565, -0.024332575500011444, 0.026668770238757133, 0.02503851242363453, -0.03680325672030449, 0.0033689585980027914, 0.021425580605864525, -0.020146019756793976, -0.0007518259226344526, 0.04879403114318848, -0.0033349308650940657, -0.05941815301775932, -0.01910526677966118, -0.023246701806783676, 0.025384295731782913, 0.03124917484819889, -0.019217435270547867, 0.019912991672754288, 0.034145671874284744, -0.0009535775752738118, -0.06257651001214981, -0.03645574674010277, 0.05373048409819603, 0.04076176881790161, -0.053925469517707825, -0.03567349165678024, -0.032558031380176544, 0.0039004359859973192, 0.0014148636255413294, 0.019664548337459564, 0.0045663826167583466, -0.045441728085279465, -0.037054527550935745, -0.011775227263569832, 0.03461313247680664, 0.027241872623562813, -0.002051296643912792, 0.011266750283539295, 0.013242666609585285, -0.042547017335891724, -0.01992443948984146, 0.043223652988672256, 0.026052827015519142, 0.02414942905306816, -0.02587740309536457, 0.01354178972542286, -0.04316876828670502, -0.041952479630708694, 0.006641041487455368, -0.02037949487566948, 0.0007601740071550012, -0.018217142671346664, -0.020657150074839592, 0.017278386279940605, 0.04586607217788696, 0.013351019471883774, -0.004550179932266474, -0.006739689502865076, 0.027653655037283897, 0.033426277339458466, -0.07043114304542542, -0.0041970144957304, 0.0285554938018322, -0.05532821640372276, 0.009430953301489353, -0.029581280425190926, 0.06274096667766571, 0.006968057714402676, -0.00019091811554972082, -0.024270305410027504, 0.03157802298665047, -0.015556315891444683, 0.005261903163045645, 0.003813647199422121, -0.052869390696287155, 0.04365213215351105, -0.0006115419673733413, -0.006971630267798901, -0.03000982664525509, -0.02049509435892105, -0.028103657066822052, -0.03107888624072075, -0.0184798501431942, -0.001480915118008852, -0.0412110798060894, 0.02772139199078083, -0.012793154455721378, 0.0143797742202878, -0.003031984670087695, -0.016370417550206184, -0.04496541991829872, 0.017078449949622154, -0.00023932629846967757, -0.0308829415589571, 0.02092156745493412, 0.01641291193664074, -0.016666725277900696, -0.018908057361841202, 0.03854294493794441, -0.00258410582318902, 0.021247463300824165, -0.018698465079069138, -0.028258228674530983, 0.00039854436181485653, 0.045547965914011, -0.030812885612249374, -0.03857941925525665, 0.024354711174964905, -0.046061236411333084, -0.04717263579368591, 0.012614194303750992, 0.032744769006967545, 0.060342948883771896, 0.04302601143717766, 0.03447158262133598, -0.035660695284605026, 0.043457213789224625, -0.02914438024163246, 0.02075270377099514, -0.0027945858892053366, 0.004846114665269852, 0.007636319380253553, 0.0028071762062609196, 0.00797570962458849, -0.007607609964907169, 0.014615071006119251, 0.04121033474802971, 0.05882309749722481, 0.016489876434206963, -0.00277598574757576, 0.023522458970546722, 0.011249097064137459, 0.026852291077375412, -0.0074800713919103146, 0.017419876530766487, 0.03043803945183754, 0.010115277953445911, -0.040066998451948166, 0.05072970315814018, -0.00801762193441391, 0.04172070696949959, -0.0917845293879509, -0.0686403140425682, 0.0063074929639697075, 0.006672338582575321, 0.023232121020555496, -0.04609503969550133, -0.005487312562763691, 0.02355251833796501, -0.03372728452086449, 0.01073539350181818, -0.010537369176745415, 0.025041652843356133, -0.01865355484187603, 0.010945386253297329, -0.0257399994879961, 0.007263904437422752, 0.05367599055171013, 0.02165674790740013, -0.00023511776817031205, -0.00712481839582324, -0.013235996477305889, -0.029061978682875633, 0.0022072559222579002, 0.011558528058230877, -0.0002587559574749321, -0.06142812967300415, 0.030051374807953835, -0.02363932505249977, -0.020653117448091507, 0.03893986716866493, -0.025187579914927483, 0.026052996516227722, 0.0028247274458408356, 0.003073976142331958, -0.006658987142145634, 0.06448408961296082, 0.033785901963710785, -0.040594857186079025, -0.026398343965411186, 0.00008214506669901311, 0.04417954385280609, 0.02965565025806427, -0.008967991918325424, -0.008592840284109116, 0.010587899945676327, -0.017433103173971176, -0.020052608102560043, 0.014004411175847054, 0.012495149858295918, -0.02283291518688202, 0.0066984291188418865, 0.02044263668358326, -0.014182350598275661, -0.029362261295318604, 0.009875395335257053, -0.04916718602180481, 0.0021371732000261545, 0.012399733997881413, 0.020722124725580215, -0.013610228896141052, -0.02344503067433834, -0.028606537729501724, -0.05219746753573418, 0.020321575924754143, 0.008504129946231842, -0.01478160172700882, -0.0617365688085556, -0.010761935263872147, 0.018790122121572495, -0.015066154301166534, -0.013996744528412819, -0.03205966576933861, -0.03417922556400299, 0.011388071812689304, -0.00817028060555458, -0.0052870712243020535, 0.05870979651808739, -0.013599115423858166, 0.013357991352677345, -0.09383238852024078, 0.06900394707918167, 0.019130395725369453, -0.005745551083236933, -0.0011961637064814568, -0.000011529024959600065, -0.0031173464376479387, -0.01816326566040516, 0.07330283522605896, 0.014615291729569435, -0.016797039657831192, -0.016954323276877403, 0.020606528967618942, -0.020616203546524048, -0.07003042846918106, 0.01571798138320446, 0.04461614415049553, -0.00009867629705695435, -0.045698825269937515, 0.0031046681106090546, 0.02199886552989483, 0.03575042635202408, -0.0009486529161222279, -0.009369856677949429, 0.030912544578313828, -0.013240624219179153, -0.00017005071276798844, 0.009421156719326973, -0.003566988743841648, 0.005394437815994024, 0.07219056040048599, 0.021030183881521225, 0.010433041490614414, 0.04066905379295349, -0.03134697675704956, -0.03395853191614151, -0.0021269212011247873, -0.02378508262336254, -0.01699754409492016, -0.017107127234339714, -0.008394578471779823, 0.021587003022432327, -0.033565279096364975, -0.017163870856165886, 0.04866429790854454, -0.032208919525146484, -0.01011588703840971, 0.04735611006617546, 0.02710133045911789, 0.02788540907204151, 0.010603752918541431, -0.028913242742419243, -0.0019890987314283848, -0.017355309799313545, 0.010110058821737766, 0.008493329398334026, 0.03771350160241127, 0.044523246586322784, 0.011172843165695667, 0.03674573078751564, -0.018548864871263504, 0.015194645151495934, -0.009038341231644154, 0.042753688991069794, -0.038191262632608414, -0.014987337402999401, -0.017470315098762512, -0.020494837313890457, 0.046495527029037476, -0.02607051283121109, -0.016521785408258438, 0.04250803217291832, -0.02872125804424286, -0.03371360898017883, -0.043627671897411346, -0.021223481744527817, -0.023784218356013298, -0.0016287276521325111, -0.006871486082673073, 0.023960629478096962, 0.011913933791220188, 0.0043740649707615376, -0.00882725976407528, -0.028224147856235504, 0.047451626509428024, -0.028263576328754425, 0.02086324617266655, -0.022132107987999916, -0.014642201364040375, -0.020947908982634544, -0.02915181592106819, -0.01566326804459095, -0.024880563840270042, 0.05637442320585251, 0.05147717520594597, 0.03071950376033783, -0.022633695974946022, -0.02452101744711399, 0.005840921774506569, 0.05665343627333641, -0.050311580300331116, -0.039386749267578125, -0.00771363265812397, 0.01935727149248123, 0.01494977343827486, -0.04737085476517677 ]
<p>If s1 is the variance of a small sample, and s2 is the variance of a larger sample from the same population. Is s1 an unbiased estimator for s2?</p> <p>I am thinking since a sample variance is an unbiased estimator of the population variance, then s1 and s2 are both unbiased estimators for sigma^2, so s1 and s2 should also be unbiased estimators for each other.</p> <p>But all the observations in a sample are part of the population, yet the observations between samples doesn't necessarily include each other. Does this make their variances biased?</p>
37,065
[ -0.03999442979693413, -0.00544398557394743, -0.03802238404750824, 0.00046665617264807224, 0.020781653001904488, 0.02037285640835762, -0.013001621700823307, -0.017585529014468193, -0.004565001465380192, -0.06203698739409447, 0.032736971974372864, 0.029825910925865173, 0.07124991714954376, 0.0002546653850004077, 0.040696099400520325, -0.009543334133923054, -0.02434985712170601, 0.0077625904232263565, 0.014469743706285954, -0.00017694893176667392, 0.008360621519386768, 0.03132665902376175, 0.0360933393239975, -0.0005957961548119783, -0.06835396587848663, 0.029974645003676414, 0.032635804265737534, 0.01348988339304924, 0.030157767236232758, 0.034415457397699356, -0.037561528384685516, -0.03586370125412941, 0.012798510491847992, 0.05499139800667763, 0.02972937934100628, 0.004326845519244671, -0.045165035873651505, -0.018086237832903862, -0.002811059355735779, 0.02580397203564644, -0.07714274525642395, 0.0039859130047261715, -0.03373604267835617, 0.009179766289889812, -0.025744380429387093, 0.03368319943547249, -0.018070580437779427, -0.023020632565021515, 0.014525766484439373, -0.03883562237024307, 0.08684606850147247, 0.007425027899444103, 0.05048425495624542, 0.040736518800258636, -0.025587139651179314, 0.037274353206157684, 0.03842945769429207, 0.04789507016539574, -0.015004102140665054, -0.024546293541789055, -0.021685972809791565, -0.017108839005231857, 0.013640138320624828, -0.011647820472717285, -0.027895404025912285, -0.007296474184840918, -0.0006686555570922792, -0.023028196766972542, 0.026164863258600235, -0.006095030810683966, 0.018106093630194664, 0.003560529323294759, 0.030488651245832443, 0.0009831321658566594, 0.008728018961846828, -0.02210131287574768, 0.005882638040930033, -0.0013692276552319527, 0.03907780349254608, 0.009353342466056347, 0.02727813832461834, 0.02288483828306198, 0.06052981689572334, 0.028657224029302597, 0.04082746431231499, 0.0037546127568930387, 0.06048247963190079, 0.002496618079021573, 0.011275744065642357, 0.03464307636022568, 0.002939482219517231, -0.0025723653379827738, 0.04386211186647415, -0.010523063130676746, -0.030178191140294075, 0.05146314576268196, -0.009307382628321648, 0.054095957428216934, 0.0015893251402303576, -0.006688075140118599, -0.01565767265856266, -0.041715893894433975, 0.05931719020009041, 0.06278684735298157, -0.017070835456252098, -0.027968354523181915, -0.019326617941260338, 0.036044906824827194, -0.009133950807154179, -0.02488693594932556, -0.013399362564086914, -0.016607720404863358, -0.00033214999712072313, -0.013653108850121498, 0.02790192700922489, 0.02677154913544655, 0.005606547929346561, 0.01127233263105154, 0.032056812196969986, 0.06679819524288177, 0.05481492727994919, -0.018588433042168617, -0.0039014508947730064, -0.0006569537217728794, -0.05176085978746414, 0.05398640036582947, 0.021566148847341537, -0.04486067220568657, -0.07102357596158981, 0.05338374897837639, 0.005423640366643667, -0.014405213296413422, 0.003787814639508724, 0.01787208952009678, 0.05003993585705757, -0.003163272514939308, -0.11252351105213165, -0.06753730773925781, 0.013895784504711628, -0.027937786653637886, 0.023872248828411102, -0.07773149013519287, 0.019217059016227722, 0.0076542990282177925, 0.05105733126401901, 0.0027337507344782352, 0.03075254149734974, 0.015756726264953613, 0.024054283276200294, 0.045926544815301895, -0.012960522435605526, 0.013999047689139843, -0.020582212135195732, -0.029700089246034622, 0.002746667480096221, -0.06818658858537674, 0.007209182251244783, 0.011970757506787777, -0.009138674475252628, -0.048561204224824905, 0.011848772875964642, 0.016973081976175308, 0.038632314652204514, -0.015218190848827362, 0.0421181283891201, -0.012763801030814648, 0.07955653220415115, 0.0015309422742575407, 0.03265361487865448, 0.01601468026638031, -0.0016940428176894784, 0.002455830341205001, 0.003941998817026615, 0.04283642768859863, 0.03628503531217575, -0.04800848662853241, -0.019790953025221825, -0.011369126848876476, 0.002828506287187338, 0.023882919922471046, -0.06748826056718826, -0.015945835039019585, -0.004376279190182686, 0.015179340727627277, 0.0065412865951657295, 0.05369112268090248, 0.014912211336195469, 0.0014468661975115538, 0.014620929025113583, -0.046370621770620346, -0.023748619481921196, -0.06797070801258087, -0.011140146292746067, -0.025713615119457245, -0.042308177798986435, 0.017915543168783188, 0.036139704287052155, 0.019962457939982414, -0.046544041484594345, -0.037097278982400894, -0.02819596417248249, 0.006569792050868273, 0.03734086826443672, -0.03469403460621834, 0.02266772836446762, 0.05717051774263382, 0.043047450482845306, 0.005428296979516745, 0.07199538499116898, -0.0161601435393095, -0.06010667234659195, 0.03490787744522095, -0.014448791742324829, 0.03145346790552139, 0.010494152083992958, -0.000391815701732412, -7.432539916862879e-9, 0.010814635083079338, -0.010029833763837814, 0.04789020121097565, -0.031210411339998245, 0.06339827179908752, 0.025776317343115807, 0.00794296059757471, -0.011469167657196522, 0.013880259357392788, 0.04444162920117378, 0.0025340677239000797, -0.036913543939590454, -0.015318828634917736, -0.04107531160116196, 0.008760166354477406, 0.027522532269358635, 0.04340556263923645, -0.031694211065769196, -0.02189370058476925, 0.022333072498440742, 0.014320632442831993, -0.0033132059033960104, -0.000028043941711075604, -0.0009400799171999097, -0.02642982080578804, -0.012484240345656872, -0.004484185948967934, 0.01617593877017498, 0.031476933509111404, 0.016621673479676247, -0.014429694972932339, 0.04432239383459091, 0.021296244114637375, -0.007559936959296465, 0.0639837235212326, -0.007043477147817612, 0.014837177470326424, 0.025424165651202202, -0.04461243376135826, 0.00735745532438159, -0.00587898725643754, 0.032015711069107056, 0.059580590575933456, -0.009707026183605194, -0.0046050879172980785, 0.0020809255074709654, -0.028342746198177338, 0.03110373765230179, -0.014332037419080734, -0.04424133151769638, 0.010254071094095707, 0.024734122678637505, -0.03429793566465378, -0.017634332180023193, -0.018431546166539192, -0.02509540505707264, -0.01847059652209282, 0.02559395506978035, 0.031784139573574066, -0.01961078867316246, 0.007838547229766846, -0.03370470181107521, -0.0452919602394104, -0.04794405400753021, -0.012650611810386181, -0.011976787820458412, -0.005279537755995989, -0.08213731646537781, 0.02387506328523159, -0.0007586260326206684, -0.031102973967790604, 0.0325479619204998, 0.014092063531279564, 0.010645332746207714, 0.03902798146009445, -0.008317705243825912, -0.03204731270670891, -0.019317572936415672, -0.020602503791451454, 0.018794098868966103, -0.003617893671616912, -0.013211766257882118, 0.029468953609466553, 0.022924672812223434, -0.02780630812048912, 0.03406441584229469, -0.040835682302713394, -0.05171829089522362, -0.044719576835632324, -0.0012858898844569921, 0.02331921085715294, -0.008074494078755379, 0.025091132149100304, 0.03907868638634682, -0.019165560603141785, -0.03914117068052292, -0.019234897568821907, -0.08047278970479965, 0.019746722653508186, 0.009271038696169853, 0.041043721139431, 0.01778932847082615, -0.03670253977179527, 0.07491356879472733, 0.0071283732540905476, -0.014536094851791859, 0.009854812175035477, -0.01400440838187933, -0.021973636001348495, -0.027741946280002594, 0.031994860619306564, -0.00735480897128582, -0.004595387727022171, 0.026680173352360725, 0.02587738260626793, -0.006052406970411539, 0.024027658626437187, -0.0004208596656098962, -0.028091387823224068, -0.022716624662280083, 0.01055711880326271, -0.01608060859143734, 0.03807688504457474, 0.0004668349865823984, -0.002817292930558324, -0.01807323470711708, 0.012928749434649944, 0.04852984845638275, 0.005949424579739571, -0.013793189078569412, 0.027099739760160446, -0.03226292133331299, 0.008969505317509174, -0.07200112193822861, 0.05653592571616173, 0.04488782957196236, -0.0051674749702215195, -0.014694894663989544, -0.007288374938070774, 0.024775482714176178, -0.012361699715256691, -0.01487784180790186, 0.07551015913486481, 0.018751908093690872, -0.022512422874569893, -0.010834532789885998, -0.006644492037594318, 0.014220388606190681, 0.027946712449193, -0.01620134711265564, -0.047592587769031525, 0.03981805965304375, 0.06300248950719833, -0.0029876588378101587, 0.0011899740202352405, -0.056518543511629105, 0.0068156104534864426, -0.08447400480508804, 0.026569660753011703, -0.010722238570451736, 0.03889140114188194, -0.021402155980467796, 0.06025566905736923, 0.029842190444469452, 0.0025703110732138157, -0.02245030552148819, -0.005847680848091841, -0.030779939144849777, 0.01805759221315384, -0.020126357674598694, -0.04931376874446869, -0.014809434302151203, -0.02883053570985794, 0.019399838522076607, -0.02919609658420086, 0.02609439380466938, -0.02318124659359455, -0.025851231068372726, -0.024958616122603416, -0.012317400425672531, -0.04044628143310547, -0.0063056801445782185, 0.029077135026454926, 0.042952392250299454, -0.012130054645240307, -0.03561633452773094, 0.054696932435035706, 0.03127149119973183, -0.003037078073248267, -0.0014829145511612296, -0.03810064494609833, 0.019337516278028488, 0.017750941216945648, 0.055068742483854294, 0.03516067937016487, 0.017127858474850655, -0.03158259019255638, 0.018930349498987198, 0.024529889225959778, 0.0521484836935997, 0.015790332108736038, -0.01421598345041275, -0.019967008382081985, -0.03078829124569893, -0.05304998904466629, -0.02029506117105484, 0.010595924220979214, 0.0020618890412151814, -0.019855517894029617, 0.07812395691871643, 0.01483101211488247, -0.06784998625516891, 0.015734804794192314, 0.05341604724526405, 0.025717752054333687, 0.020225415006279945, -0.021458962932229042, -0.012465713545680046, -0.013857272453606129, -0.005531206727027893, 0.025873670354485512, 0.005742420442402363, -0.015172092244029045, 0.001664013834670186, 0.03176264837384224, -0.014676055870950222, -0.03491882607340813, 0.010768270120024681, 0.02456989325582981, 0.06629477441310883, 0.010773827321827412, -0.02974829263985157, 0.04381144791841507, 0.02465185523033142, 0.03038947843015194, 0.023545917123556137, -0.017368752509355545, -0.08683174848556519, -0.0028806424234062433, 0.007765252608805895, 0.01975168101489544, -0.04766818881034851, 0.007151572499424219, -0.032303761690855026, 0.0015691914595663548, 0.0057981801219284534, -0.03936618193984032, 0.0288771353662014, -0.016841502860188484, 0.0035868582781404257, -0.0024557996075600386, -0.03193308785557747, -0.031994812190532684, 0.013444390147924423, -0.01271110400557518, 0.010041266679763794, -0.024036049842834473, -0.033448368310928345, -0.042511846870183945, -0.02335445210337639, 0.034759391099214554, 0.08897341787815094, -0.007748796604573727, 0.008322018198668957, 0.003836439922451973, 0.10892954468727112, -0.018611565232276917, -0.08194034546613693, 0.036062344908714294, -0.024018779397010803, -0.035659607499837875, 0.04705587029457092, -0.029910152778029442, -0.032846421003341675, 0.018450960516929626, 0.010841862298548222, 0.0011121295392513275, -0.019779669120907784, 0.0071412622928619385, 0.021590476855635643, 0.05466596782207489, 0.027613602578639984, 0.06381731480360031, 0.025390418246388435, 0.010862494818866253, -0.014367450959980488, -0.025996407493948936, 0.022758077830076218, -0.043909694999456406, -0.03451647236943245, -0.05164971575140953, -0.02486078068614006, -0.024561412632465363, 0.009466036222875118, 0.012167937122285366, 0.050699058920145035, -0.01660001091659069, -0.023770680651068687, 0.005773687735199928, 0.014678455889225006, 0.03825093060731888, 0.016688909381628036, -0.02061249129474163, 0.04444151744246483, -0.012203523889183998, -0.039537057280540466, -0.0018999229650944471, -0.02043195813894272, -0.0032632197253406048, -0.012586311437189579, -0.035970114171504974, 0.009887554682791233, -0.049556877464056015, -0.06523846834897995, -0.02035396732389927, -0.014247635379433632, 0.02556147612631321, -0.03079935535788536, 0.03970073536038399, 0.000780753733124584, -0.03540739789605141, -0.002675066003575921, 0.05512894317507744, -0.0032251470256596804, 0.023401396349072456, -0.03747217729687691, 0.06938237696886063, 0.029515068978071213, 0.005528442561626434, -0.09406378120183945, -0.017893683165311813, -0.022739563137292862, 0.030482234433293343, 0.012356356717646122, -0.027304885908961296, 0.012047996744513512, -0.0298802200704813, -0.03204820677638054, -0.02822650782763958, 0.02466903068125248, -0.008670813404023647, -0.03337492421269417, -0.0029610609635710716, 0.006285993382334709, 0.09886468201875687, -0.017035556957125664, 0.010974274948239326, 0.011631505563855171, -0.02459859289228916, -0.01465674489736557, 0.01644672080874443, 0.03515757992863655, -0.008413956500589848, 0.014884024858474731, -0.004419384058564901, -0.011493376456201077, 0.015598583035171032, -0.019116008654236794, -0.009985924698412418, 0.017233435064554214, -0.009188319556415081, 0.03858890384435654, -0.009731614962220192, -0.027825843542814255, -0.000060798593040090054, 0.022710762917995453, -0.03643311560153961, 0.025704186409711838, 0.011469385586678982, -0.014760776422917843, 0.027779102325439453, 0.03316548466682434, -0.02773486264050007, 0.020715223625302315, 0.07712392508983612, -0.028656814247369766, 0.009959845803678036, 0.00033423639251850545, -0.020463673397898674, 0.04890719801187515, 0.024556424468755722, 0.005544279236346483, 0.03119724430143833, 0.04743719473481178, -0.004008595831692219, -0.006348226219415665, -0.002619144506752491, -0.0043230364099144936, 0.07699840515851974, -0.02019593119621277, 0.016688857227563858, 0.07362240552902222, -0.011308407410979271, 0.006889651995152235, -0.07205850630998611, 0.004423803649842739, -0.008573339320719242, -0.03299633041024208, 0.048644378781318665, -0.003088129684329033, 0.009788209572434425, 0.03136183321475983, 0.00771995959803462, 0.012778270058333874, 0.014958839863538742, 0.01118425652384758, 0.04121438413858414, 0.0017379900673404336, 0.027648530900478363, -0.036942027509212494, 0.0413200743496418, -0.05488996580243111, -0.006720032077282667, -0.030547603964805603, -0.02702498435974121, 0.03129858896136284, 0.010834666900336742, 0.033418089151382446, -0.0298948734998703, -0.031313858926296234, -0.0435163639485836, 0.023338329046964645, -0.02004828490316868, 0.02442171797156334, 0.017379270866513252, -0.024418020620942116, 0.011644306592643261, 0.010846661403775215, 0.007325565442442894, -0.05593355745077133, -0.09172540158033371, -0.06090346723794937, -0.03879382461309433, -0.02509816735982895, 0.030874116346240044, 0.008912506513297558, -0.03093876875936985, 0.030870860442519188, -0.0032565526198595762, 0.012542414478957653, -0.013522109016776085, 0.0418478399515152, -0.029930682852864265, 0.057367127388715744, 0.022158527746796608, 0.059237368404865265, 0.012070217169821262, -0.0012875880347564816, 0.0684533566236496, 0.052059706300497055, 0.005083657801151276, -0.028819190338253975, 0.008139568381011486, -0.039139170199632645, -0.0009637580951675773, 0.01571047678589821, 0.00974836852401495, -0.01534003671258688, 0.006088435184210539, 0.04641710966825485, 0.025851698592305183, 0.04211099445819855, -0.05329189822077751, 0.06802302598953247, -0.03779720515012741, 0.007761516608297825, -0.016358643770217896, 0.0147898830473423, -0.03775772079825401, 0.004208380822092295, -0.032139915972948074, 0.025258218869566917, 0.002386493142694235, -0.011170226149260998, -0.02726777270436287, 0.01784108392894268, -0.023693755269050598, -0.002471157116815448, -0.0200625229626894, 0.010882017202675343, -0.007986513897776604, -0.02336791530251503, -0.04610243812203407, -0.012645374983549118, 0.015684274956583977, -0.04765501618385315, 0.018331628292798996, 0.003979871049523354, -0.01779918745160103, 0.012094331905245781, 0.016096197068691254, 0.02215792052447796, -0.05044419690966606, 0.00997789017856121, -0.0067521375603973866, 0.031695764511823654, -0.032986756414175034, 0.018008561804890633, -0.01008661463856697, -0.009144634939730167, 0.019137924537062645, -0.047505274415016174, -0.017092198133468628, -0.0001435226877219975, 0.0010800815653055906, -0.040430665016174316, -0.025717584416270256, -0.04926084354519844, 0.04855479300022125, -0.034364860504865646, 0.0014716529985889792, 0.016628077253699303, -0.06538517028093338, -0.022947875782847404, 0.006485193967819214, 0.024942565709352493, -0.017348404973745346, -0.007146823685616255, 0.01459548994898796, -0.001341094495728612, -0.05295715108513832, 0.013331848196685314, 0.01787979155778885, -0.0008113188669085503, 0.05231142044067383, -0.005401441361755133, 0.004061559215188026, -0.014597475528717041, -0.0732034370303154, 0.03632286190986633, -0.00798728596419096, -0.019703321158885956, -0.041694846004247665, -0.007189681753516197, 0.07076633721590042, 0.01915641501545906, -0.0057741571217775345, 0.00959805864840746, 0.019425010308623314, 0.029585277661681175, 0.005987759213894606, -0.04992298781871796, -0.003009690437465906, 0.022482536733150482, -0.03135157749056816, -0.005840500351041555, -0.023241739720106125, 0.05523108318448067, 0.050442326813936234, 0.029458800330758095, -0.018419502303004265, 0.023625090718269348, -0.0020416802726686, 0.041927631944417953, 0.019285790622234344, -0.05641092732548714, -0.0025827595964074135, 0.044810157269239426, -0.0025659999810159206, -0.026040321215987206, -0.017034074291586876, -0.01944827102124691, -0.015195412561297417, 0.0012272985186427832, -0.0228857584297657, -0.03234488517045975, -0.003753465600311756, -0.025436224415898323, 0.004478706046938896, -0.02356519177556038, -0.012343411333858967, -0.020173005759716034, -0.0350249744951725, -0.0019256372470408678, 0.014292411506175995, -0.008523741737008095, 0.0019467677921056747, -0.012479327619075775, -0.010113021358847618, 0.050390586256980896, 0.006944159511476755, 0.006730662193149328, 0.014038225635886192, 0.02559163048863411, -0.009871822781860828, 0.029587585479021072, -0.04091056436300278, -0.011867295950651169, 0.05729438737034798, -0.040938086807727814, -0.03307827562093735, 0.028486289083957672, -0.0027393405325710773, 0.04137483611702919, 0.021021755412220955, -0.019362330436706543, -0.026316171512007713, 0.04308798536658287, -0.03173812851309776, 0.000838074367493391, -0.03462306037545204, -0.01320658065378666, 0.012608268298208714, -0.05551580712199211, 0.01901780068874359, 0.002240935806185007, -0.021429946646094322, 0.05723848566412926, 0.032142359763383865, -0.012453979812562466, -0.011167348362505436, -0.007860885001718998, 0.03585664927959442, -0.0010552103631198406, 0.020411459729075432, 0.007638958282768726, 0.02603745646774769, 0.040566813200712204, -0.043602511286735535, 0.043765515089035034, -0.023705918341875076, 0.0003241472295485437, -0.08184422552585602, -0.018417153507471085, 0.020563501864671707, -0.002779525937512517, 0.02146647684276104, -0.028885915875434875, -0.017634890973567963, 0.025527920573949814, -0.03206763043999672, -0.016636570915579796, 0.0027991309762001038, -0.03273305669426918, -0.04785708338022232, 0.0151952113956213, -0.004395246040076017, 0.0025946362875401974, -0.02242978848516941, 0.02345387265086174, 0.0039362492971122265, 0.012791911140084267, 0.013163275085389614, -0.02164640463888645, -0.06842418015003204, -0.024626653641462326, -0.008539249189198017, -0.07243704795837402, 0.003981480374932289, -0.042695023119449615, -0.01969970017671585, 0.0506943054497242, 0.0011424632975831628, 0.010474222712218761, 0.026760317385196686, 0.014936521649360657, 0.012661751359701157, 0.014490772970020771, 0.012531858868896961, 0.001433513592928648, -0.01999257691204548, 0.016067564487457275, 0.004896680358797312, 0.03574957698583603, -0.02800760604441166, -0.00856074970215559, 0.014895071275532246, -0.019200343638658524, -0.003322059754282236, 0.025395043194293976, -0.025783075019717216, -0.04314255714416504, -0.004839413333684206, 0.009396563284099102, -0.009768716059625149, -0.023004548624157906, 0.049935732036828995, -0.028036028146743774, 0.0038480085786432028, 0.05482487380504608, 0.01572614535689354, -0.012128369882702827, 0.010575907304883003, 0.008770297281444073, -0.012126394547522068, 0.03657770901918411, 0.042125266045331955, -0.017557742074131966, -0.05259616672992706, -0.0036100700963288546, 0.02487693913280964, -0.03220714256167412, 0.00046151166316121817, -0.03801014646887779, -0.014184227213263512, 0.027966173365712166, 0.015405133366584778, 0.008751674555242062, 0.013467397540807724, -0.006533984560519457, -0.006491699256002903, -0.06290171295404434, 0.05301126465201378, -0.0038173426873981953, 0.03576056286692619, -0.06966178119182587, -0.0065921819768846035, -0.048985037952661514, 0.02036920376121998, 0.01605898328125477, 0.026146674528717995, 0.02845015376806259, 0.02956368960440159, 0.024453889578580856, 0.033893197774887085, -0.02338455803692341, 0.05726055055856705, -0.013572012074291706, -0.02119271270930767, -0.0043410928919911385, -0.04439913108944893, -0.018920568749308586, 0.003910293336957693, -0.03457923233509064, -0.015803074464201927, 0.0361761599779129, 0.03711579367518425, -0.008704783394932747, 0.040389273315668106, 0.013735695742070675, -0.005761947948485613, 0.056333933025598526, -0.030511759221553802, 0.00933135487139225, 0.02904677577316761, -0.020957516506314278, -0.0374642051756382, 0.03711818903684616, -0.03324558585882187, -0.021631183102726936, -0.013232449069619179, 0.02414141222834587, 0.026039861142635345, -0.042246438562870026, 0.018271220847964287, 0.004642338026314974, -0.05111699178814888, -0.0031781746074557304, 0.029826611280441284, 0.022186575457453728, 0.009474244900047779, -0.04778510332107544, 0.019190777093172073, 0.023507412523031235, -0.01735905185341835, 0.019760625436902046, 0.05360889062285423, 0.005153249949216843, -0.0000841566507006064, 0.011940346099436283, 0.051461897790431976, 0.014388496056199074, 0.012220902368426323, -0.00800265371799469, 0.021273739635944366, -0.035867542028427124, -0.021683765575289726, 0.0011727757519111037, 0.013456420041620731, 0.03088347800076008, 0.008352778851985931, -0.023984219878911972, 0.030598733574151993, -0.0330841951072216, 0.014965437352657318, -0.03688523918390274, -0.006356731057167053, 0.007412503007799387, -0.02683515101671219, 0.029617834836244583, 0.018141476437449455, 0.01579173654317856, -0.01118861511349678, -0.0052431547082960606, 0.012677514925599098, 0.03658213093876839, -0.040978580713272095, 0.05193807929754257, -0.02918648160994053, -0.009236491285264492, -0.06284070760011673, 0.011662507429718971, 0.002709828782826662, -0.01628076285123825, 0.04506537690758705, 0.05377819016575813, 0.029611391946673393, -0.0045903692953288555, -0.062484726309776306, 0.0071861897595226765, 0.02227303571999073, -0.07068357616662979, -0.010861784219741821, -0.036869823932647705, 0.012475891970098019, -0.009724895469844341, -0.029434775933623314 ]
<p>I am experimenting with neural network package in R nnet and i have some questions.</p> <ol> <li>The regulatory environment i am working on requires me to reproduce my results to show them to the auditors. How can i reproduce my model results after few months/years ? Can i use a seed value to control the model output ?</li> <li>How can i validate a neural network model ? are there any goodness of fit tests ?</li> <li>How do i choose the number of hidden layers i need ? I have 18500 observations in my training dataset and 8 variables. Does that help in identifying hidden layers required in anyway?</li> <li>Many times the model stops after 100 iterations. I have used maxiter option but sometimes you see the output and it says converged and sometimes it says stopped after 100 iterations. When it says stopped after 100 iterations does that mean i have a bad model ? and it did not converge ?</li> </ol> <p>Thank you</p>
37,067
[ -0.02651819959282875, 0.0012138476595282555, -0.008057111874222755, 0.014931168407201767, 0.0520508848130703, -0.03894192725419998, -0.018671482801437378, -0.04664864018559456, 0.021768970414996147, -0.023738421499729156, 0.03309949114918709, 0.04412400349974632, -0.0040605864487588406, 0.022844582796096802, -0.024089155718684196, -0.00038735216367058456, -0.02707049995660782, -0.015198763459920883, -0.005162292625755072, 0.006410787347704172, -0.03097447380423546, 0.023740867152810097, 0.0005350199644453824, -0.027424857020378113, -0.037587739527225494, 0.044728685170412064, 0.000013448750905808993, 0.015115692280232906, 0.012012639082968235, 0.03999514505267143, -0.03808393329381943, -0.032799459993839264, 0.021069742739200592, 0.045264869928359985, 0.01211980078369379, 0.019414281472563744, -0.02058788761496544, -0.04029242694377899, -0.009122640825808048, 0.009144024923443794, 0.012684756889939308, -0.007492165546864271, 0.02978149801492691, 0.03899917006492615, 0.011598248034715652, 0.011369159445166588, -0.003923008684068918, -0.007328714244067669, 0.04686020314693451, -0.01655249483883381, 0.06897499412298203, 0.014503715559840202, 0.009790527634322643, 0.0396576002240181, 0.013202466070652008, -0.03821823000907898, 0.0601259246468544, 0.058985333889722824, -0.02742808312177658, -0.04366946965456009, -0.003966178745031357, -0.01804264262318611, -0.017785754054784775, -0.01476337295025587, -0.02429875358939171, 0.03919724375009537, 0.024234097450971603, 0.005169170442968607, 0.029632337391376495, -0.022782152518630028, 0.0238970834761858, -0.0011720005422830582, -0.005685985554009676, -0.028478320688009262, -0.021499760448932648, -0.0171684417873621, -0.011144546791911125, 0.0035059666261076927, 0.05669885501265526, 0.045168858021497726, -0.02392416261136532, -0.009515934623777866, -0.02053740620613098, -0.00043230585288256407, 0.016863500699400902, 0.0011623051250353456, 0.08302962779998779, 0.006257766857743263, 0.05025036260485649, -0.00339235900901258, -0.01710512489080429, 0.007476084399968386, 0.07208064943552017, 0.021112142130732536, -0.007198461797088385, -0.005755396094173193, -0.012404393404722214, 0.03296073526144028, 0.02060508355498314, -0.022188914939761162, -0.028681060299277306, -0.04019001126289368, 0.00036098973941989243, 0.023016929626464844, -0.04421883448958397, -0.008312683552503586, -0.0048179225996136665, -0.021745385602116585, -0.038852863013744354, -0.0018807356245815754, -0.013630843721330166, 0.029366185888648033, -0.0071727256290614605, 0.024486038833856583, 0.004505186807364225, -0.02831599861383438, -0.01693505048751831, -0.01223051268607378, 0.008382930420339108, 0.06944768875837326, -0.004742578137665987, -0.028673088178038597, 0.03805544972419739, -0.04339176416397095, -0.039775025099515915, 0.005185685586184263, 0.04791609197854996, -0.0005775776808150113, -0.037342388182878494, 0.04367273673415184, 0.008611761964857578, -0.07251019775867462, -0.01547110453248024, -0.009853924624621868, 0.03855224326252937, -0.011836554855108261, -0.08890234678983688, -0.07256613671779633, 0.04846957325935364, -0.06782069802284241, 0.015761984512209892, -0.04381301626563072, 0.02322700433433056, 0.027888357639312744, 0.05386507883667946, -0.004196199122816324, 0.020682016387581825, 0.03970840200781822, -0.010200751014053822, -0.01141566876322031, -0.03342844173312187, 0.005974233150482178, -0.02049943059682846, 0.009648661129176617, -0.04015728458762169, -0.056250475347042084, 0.046416185796260834, 0.005995134357362986, 0.014031212776899338, -0.03630698844790459, 0.018766259774565697, -0.008534254506230354, 0.013686124235391617, -0.01169398333877325, 0.0006366033921949565, -0.058432552963495255, 0.10443106293678284, -0.0014079021057114005, 0.07634635269641876, 0.02751392126083374, -0.05300837382674217, 0.01989266462624073, 0.01883174292743206, 0.029050679877400398, 0.018691642209887505, 0.013741602189838886, 0.008726685307919979, -0.04824477434158325, 0.010090545751154423, 0.047057684510946274, -0.029999911785125732, 0.005195325240492821, 0.001560056465677917, -0.030069423839449883, 0.011678682640194893, -0.019958706572651863, 0.015753159299492836, -0.015770409256219864, 0.04263602942228317, -0.02375343255698681, -0.032997388392686844, -0.06034154072403908, 0.05002313479781151, -0.04493510723114014, -0.005974734202027321, -0.007900078780949116, -0.024440888315439224, 0.002151983557268977, 0.01762501895427704, -0.012967941351234913, -0.048949234187603, 0.04292182996869087, 0.015056190080940723, -0.0053308154456317425, 0.0024677806068211794, 0.03360409289598465, 0.014714738354086876, 0.0029414091259241104, 0.04551157355308533, -0.052579186856746674, -0.04723608121275902, -0.002565257716923952, -0.021491408348083496, -0.014766937121748924, -0.03249702975153923, -0.01811770722270012, 0.017894284799695015, -0.005263527389615774, -0.030030881986021996, 0.007835506461560726, -0.05922245234251022, 0.09448539465665817, 0.06061554327607155, -0.009634728543460369, -0.0007065298268571496, -0.013907982967793941, -0.017186375334858894, 0.02035880833864212, -0.0316094346344471, 0.006102016195654869, -0.08361686766147614, -0.028684621676802635, 0.010164320468902588, 0.019322769716382027, -0.01961926743388176, 0.04120822623372078, 0.01181500032544136, -0.017137063667178154, 0.007305355276912451, -0.02880466729402542, -0.01176545675843954, -0.012989368289709091, 0.004571923054754734, -0.004289843607693911, 0.01844874396920204, 0.028661759570240974, 0.02652270905673504, -0.01835234835743904, 0.029816171154379845, 0.004215145017951727, 0.01650925911962986, 0.06265287846326828, -0.021477503702044487, -0.011241370812058449, -0.0007557778735645115, -0.03574560582637787, 0.046194180846214294, 0.004465146921575069, -0.03699815645813942, 0.03379397466778755, 0.01486005075275898, 0.007953369989991188, 0.0035502801183611155, 0.021095886826515198, 0.021795276552438736, 0.050113338977098465, -0.030575476586818695, -0.029724685475230217, 0.023827088996767998, -0.03602811321616173, 0.022302817553281784, -0.05499996617436409, -0.01912495866417885, -0.05234482139348984, 0.05503835901618004, 0.03300442174077034, -0.03348630666732788, 0.0005574495880864561, -0.03557848930358887, 0.015073990449309349, 0.027715854346752167, -0.011673379689455032, 0.02996879257261753, 0.012325446121394634, -0.027536531910300255, -0.005574315320700407, 0.002938697813078761, -0.007297533098608255, 0.033019132912158966, -0.006069411523640156, -0.009787379764020443, 0.04123668372631073, -0.0020459690131247044, -0.023496517911553383, -0.0437968373298645, -0.06521201133728027, -0.015875404700636864, -0.017676902934908867, -0.026641562581062317, 0.030860427767038345, 0.009575027972459793, 0.0013671237975358963, 0.03311356157064438, -0.036627478897571564, 0.03957725688815117, -0.007758294232189655, 0.011074680835008621, 0.008338360115885735, 0.015156282112002373, -0.016909070312976837, 0.040284376591444016, -0.026649922132492065, -0.02261071279644966, -0.07483446598052979, -0.04778263345360756, -0.0013672740897163749, 0.02202705480158329, 0.023576797917485237, 0.017623068764805794, 0.03554030880331993, 0.07219377160072327, 0.06016242504119873, -0.03343232348561287, -0.03768429160118103, -0.0347466804087162, -0.03165355697274208, -0.049493785947561264, 0.019027046859264374, -0.005697948392480612, 0.008024538867175579, -0.006652760319411755, -0.04323656111955643, 0.034148216247558594, 0.04044418781995773, 0.00023022707318887115, 0.013035113923251629, 0.03352000191807747, 0.01186392828822136, -0.03362672030925751, 0.0164888184517622, 0.03212294355034828, -0.02502412535250187, 0.005494590848684311, 0.0009064304758794606, 0.04158320277929306, 0.01954885944724083, -0.04130825772881508, 0.019116483628749847, -0.005731960292905569, 0.0044686137698590755, -0.02617112174630165, 0.03714920952916145, -0.020763177424669266, 0.0036391925532370806, -0.022722402587532997, 0.00688360957428813, 0.05030415579676628, -0.01068701222538948, -0.008231299929320812, 0.027970552444458008, -0.0025987119879573584, -0.006754557602107525, 0.005707653239369392, -0.029926760122179985, 0.004142182879149914, -0.00765615701675415, -0.030882326886057854, 0.03896409645676613, 0.019099317491054535, 0.019612260162830353, 0.02519415318965912, 0.020637474954128265, -0.013841048814356327, -0.01205448992550373, -0.025355421006679535, -0.004473221488296986, -0.06617183238267899, 0.06415292620658875, 0.005672244820743799, 0.007835873402655125, -0.015638791024684906, -0.004659108351916075, 0.0366838164627552, -0.011480405926704407, -0.050729021430015564, 0.026491081342101097, 0.007148231379687786, -0.009380405768752098, 0.01744132861495018, -0.031108157709240913, 0.040355414152145386, -0.03657613694667816, 0.01347957644611597, 0.00017019220103975385, 0.02704496495425701, -0.028319010511040688, 0.013155569322407246, -0.03042617067694664, -0.005835376214236021, -0.014483011327683926, -0.011272510513663292, 0.020944105461239815, -0.005722514353692532, 0.0019109862623736262, 0.0397816002368927, 0.003497027326375246, -0.016940327361226082, -0.020695684477686882, -0.0320211797952652, 0.00018452457152307034, 0.06118616834282875, 0.042982734739780426, 0.020794209092855453, -0.057448215782642365, 0.028678201138973236, 0.0020287649240344763, 0.0610734261572361, 0.04511956870555878, 0.030947070568799973, -0.030573096126317978, -0.07304787635803223, -0.019362617284059525, 0.02173325978219509, 0.0035903938114643097, 0.004132565576583147, 0.006720207165926695, 0.0539105199277401, -0.015327215194702148, -0.026733385398983955, 0.024943120777606964, 0.03405864164233208, -0.0029477307107299566, 0.00587775744497776, 0.008824579417705536, -0.0056303637102246284, 0.001867189654149115, 0.03561609983444214, 0.0018205733504146338, 0.004552227910608053, 0.002360462909564376, -0.006749211344867945, 0.01808464713394642, -0.02823035605251789, -0.019907575100660324, -0.015660660341382027, 0.036309074610471725, 0.06912773102521896, -0.02568536438047886, 0.014305036514997482, -0.013204766437411308, 0.04067179933190346, 0.03396463021636009, 0.011939609423279762, -0.01894397847354412, -0.06936126947402954, -0.016054533421993256, 0.0805196613073349, 0.030204283073544502, -0.040569305419921875, -0.036510203033685684, -0.0669342502951622, -0.055889490991830826, 0.017608290538191795, -0.03703945502638817, 0.03507804498076439, -0.019335081800818443, 0.014097095467150211, -0.03932506963610649, -0.045495662838220596, 0.022270772606134415, -0.006063842214643955, -0.012225046753883362, 0.0412268228828907, -0.017059287056326866, -0.027458297088742256, -0.02249380201101303, 0.029694844037294388, -0.012596962973475456, 0.0762261226773262, -0.035115305334329605, -0.015326016582548618, 0.04076550900936127, -0.01683545857667923, -0.010059943422675133, -0.0704260766506195, 0.01102627906948328, -0.0041088443249464035, -0.015337037853896618, -0.009775109589099884, -0.018173865973949432, -0.05242665484547615, 0.03464457392692566, 0.05126339569687843, -0.06035064160823822, -0.03538705036044121, -0.0833890438079834, 0.05021611973643303, 0.008123359642922878, 0.020287713035941124, 0.03584817424416542, 0.003964920062571764, 0.032256487756967545, 0.025746069848537445, -0.04637940600514412, 0.002686033956706524, -0.028736401349306107, -0.03192533180117607, -0.05112960562109947, -0.0314815454185009, -0.022060517221689224, 0.05315759405493736, 0.024874035269021988, 0.0536709800362587, -0.041749920696020126, 0.00948176346719265, 0.0366024449467659, 0.04510120302438736, 0.004807393532246351, -0.020123764872550964, 0.01853513903915882, 0.008543392643332481, 0.015535037033259869, 0.0011606764746829867, 0.010763782076537609, -0.02442835457623005, 0.013891556300222874, 0.05155741050839424, -0.04052630439400673, 0.0022753686644136906, -0.01563323475420475, -0.012804046273231506, 0.038669705390930176, -0.004619982559233904, 0.06250081211328506, 0.016460170969367027, 0.0036909794434905052, 0.008910284377634525, -0.017282649874687195, -0.011315652169287205, 0.013283918611705303, -0.012089396826922894, 0.007624223828315735, -0.044862374663352966, 0.03699418902397156, -0.005419609136879444, -0.012876716442406178, -0.05053211748600006, -0.051145147532224655, 0.04125821962952614, -0.01254781149327755, -0.04170496016740799, -0.027186354622244835, 0.01790483109652996, 0.012831911444664001, -0.0018030150095000863, -0.02997305430471897, 0.03448708355426788, -0.04671864956617355, 0.023625444620847702, 0.0021834569051861763, 0.005023954436182976, 0.06971586495637894, 0.0007992028258740902, -0.0037470257375389338, -0.0012552731204777956, -0.03875795006752014, -0.02849269099533558, -0.007756108418107033, 0.021821150556206703, -0.01616756059229374, -0.01527828723192215, -0.026512976735830307, -0.001065620919689536, 0.07338225096464157, 0.001485714572481811, -0.0030615178402513266, 0.030236754566431046, -0.015174174681305885, -0.019415542483329773, -0.04786023497581482, -0.018543992191553116, 0.0016441618790850043, 0.015363208018243313, -0.01216451171785593, -0.009788424707949162, -0.002772807376459241, -0.04749024286866188, 0.052062731236219406, -0.02721010148525238, 0.04441729187965393, 0.0009026751504279673, 0.07090161740779877, -0.01469641737639904, 0.00939641147851944, -0.048324212431907654, -0.03318056836724281, 0.02749328687787056, -0.004208431113511324, 0.010741415433585644, -0.02282322570681572, 0.023920530453324318, -0.06602952629327774, -0.07869143038988113, -0.0248944703489542, -0.02710791863501072, 0.05133546516299248, 0.0118947122246027, 0.02864549681544304, 0.01393815316259861, -0.012093962170183659, 0.025733904913067818, -0.053802382200956345, 0.01025504618883133, -0.01331640500575304, 0.036422185599803925, 0.06303670257329941, 0.007726278156042099, -0.016816239804029465, 0.023479094728827477, 0.03279396519064903, 0.05237109586596489, 0.034363001585006714, -0.013423209078609943, -0.017013730481266975, 0.00478314608335495, -0.031380798667669296, -0.046504486352205276, 0.02214774116873741, -0.04072033613920212, 0.02504977025091648, -0.01180536299943924, 0.017042307183146477, 0.03637363761663437, 0.03921127691864967, 0.025591444224119186, -0.03645781800150871, -0.003059784881770611, -0.06604816019535065, -0.004295083694159985, 0.02384910359978676, -0.019728153944015503, 0.012502032332122326, 0.0234548170119524, 0.032541535794734955, -0.009237052872776985, 0.0459107831120491, -0.03273611143231392, -0.07376018911600113, -0.029750414192676544, -0.021315040066838264, -0.032269302755594254, 0.020765893161296844, 0.0001439724728697911, -0.0036907114554196596, 0.001542693586088717, -0.02355354279279709, 0.037213679403066635, -0.01171900238841772, 0.041699524968862534, 0.0028628564905375242, 0.037136260420084, -0.002386786276474595, 0.0033930253703147173, 0.006288750562816858, 0.04329298809170723, 0.12199952453374863, 0.11156247556209564, 0.027000298723578453, -0.08335360884666443, 0.014585642144083977, -0.0041973283514380455, -0.029150785878300667, 0.0036720014177262783, 0.006526306737214327, 0.02486043982207775, -0.002576967002823949, 0.0399923250079155, 0.015739036723971367, -0.020599499344825745, 0.01755264401435852, 0.0578414723277092, -0.002866744063794613, -0.03023539111018181, 0.0030363278929144144, 0.0004822780902031809, -0.03833955526351929, -0.002745186910033226, -0.035782527178525925, 0.03573860973119736, 0.016819676384329796, -0.0429224856197834, -0.02364886738359928, -0.010974666103720665, 0.05476002022624016, 0.0028357203118503094, -0.00712219625711441, -0.014187315478920937, -0.021317878738045692, -0.0049193925224244595, 0.03592687472701073, 0.006696369498968124, -0.00002037367084994912, -0.013933731243014336, 0.0264089647680521, 0.08458200842142105, -0.014070834033191204, -0.0008396378252655268, -0.029155366122722626, -0.011783702298998833, -0.019311649724841118, -0.03005152754485607, -0.03848414495587349, 0.052250936627388, -0.016504516825079918, -0.026941366493701935, 0.011928333900868893, 0.022451350465416908, 0.03988894447684288, -0.04183497279882431, 0.011342997662723064, 0.05852926895022392, -0.0011106627061963081, -0.027706407010555267, -0.03914796933531761, -0.017605967819690704, 0.004733202047646046, -0.030190221965312958, 0.002055563498288393, 0.015281123109161854, -0.024189943447709084, -0.01880747266113758, -0.04560478776693344, 0.03327004984021187, 0.006537333130836487, 0.05784420296549797, -0.01588541455566883, -0.04544205218553543, -0.01690826751291752, -0.004717526491731405, 0.0035602443385869265, 0.04406892508268356, -0.0015732888132333755, -0.0007146366406232119, 0.006310648284852505, -0.043373920023441315, -0.010267427191138268, 0.01639612764120102, 0.015573481097817421, 0.00009157742169918492, -0.03842698782682419, -0.016913462430238724, 0.010749701410531998, 0.04700141400098801, 0.03420593589544296, 0.029972920194268227, 0.035071682184934616, 0.01398354023694992, 0.034211304038763046, -0.06054181233048439, -0.01456975657492876, 0.0014273767592385411, -0.060486748814582825, -0.0033798564691096544, -0.019113540649414062, 0.06707098335027695, 0.03715919330716133, 0.025171173736453056, 0.008236227557063103, 0.02577001042664051, -0.006773691158741713, 0.00042584730545058846, -0.0010320150759071112, -0.06926218420267105, 0.04645412415266037, -0.0336347371339798, 0.03857423737645149, -0.04424900561571121, -0.019514501094818115, -0.01801394857466221, -0.027687545865774155, -0.0035297065041959286, -0.01799014024436474, -0.01912449486553669, 0.038360051810741425, 0.013571813702583313, 0.023427624255418777, -0.03881708160042763, 0.0061242845840752125, -0.005054710898548365, 0.005751829594373703, 0.014282711781561375, -0.03096276894211769, -0.01965012215077877, 0.011027470231056213, 0.016764895990490913, -0.029387831687927246, 0.04522828385233879, -0.0029230117797851562, 0.029771504923701286, -0.02266138233244419, 0.010713832452893257, 0.024134987965226173, 0.04317762330174446, -0.01872093230485916, -0.0028167874552309513, 0.05258016660809517, -0.02786456234753132, -0.032636575400829315, -0.024350816383957863, -0.016609368845820427, 0.029446549713611603, 0.0009444248280487955, -0.01889205537736416, -0.0077352458611130714, 0.027132607996463776, -0.011447779834270477, 0.011546589434146881, -0.005170316435396671, 0.018475009128451347, 0.022424394264817238, 0.03448546305298805, 0.00722120376303792, -0.002934026764705777, 0.009386148303747177, -0.004820095840841532, 0.03085092455148697, 0.024964652955532074, -0.015125595964491367, -0.0009660853538662195, -0.026851847767829895, -0.01759721152484417, -0.0002611802483443171, 0.021222775802016258, -0.006114254705607891, 0.03262403607368469, 0.0014476677170023322, 0.039523541927337646, -0.03618582710623741, 0.009200356900691986, -0.07930677384138107, -0.01841117814183235, -0.017459232360124588, -0.000941598555073142, 0.044161319732666016, -0.05693741515278816, 0.01627468131482601, 0.018818078562617302, -0.044540002942085266, 0.041430506855249405, 0.0032307349611073732, -0.011741220019757748, 0.00029988514143042266, 0.040742382407188416, -0.019350945949554443, 0.0007001109188422561, 0.01076564285904169, 0.029673416167497635, 0.004334620200097561, -0.005216869059950113, 0.020323889330029488, -0.003911896608769894, -0.03614770621061325, 0.015427058562636375, 0.007915562950074673, -0.0361967496573925, 0.03888425603508949, -0.04474177956581116, -0.02965010143816471, 0.04802411422133446, -0.00467350659891963, 0.04203556850552559, 0.01822921447455883, 0.01166043896228075, 0.026558998972177505, 0.06380504369735718, 0.04599278047680855, 0.028876107186079025, 0.005163958761841059, -0.017275739461183548, 0.02776024304330349, -0.0016695406520739198, -0.010471598245203495, 0.043686557561159134, 0.03715983405709267, -0.009005371481180191, -0.020474668592214584, 0.039361372590065, -0.02303583174943924, 0.0021603144705295563, -0.008341659791767597, -0.00892613735049963, -0.013043410144746304, -0.023863831534981728, 0.00428178021684289, -0.02204696461558342, 0.008560864254832268, 0.04534007981419563, 0.04555313289165497, -0.030118165537714958, 0.02451125904917717, 0.005304175429046154, -0.04121946915984154, -0.0014235092094168067, 0.014553184621036053, -0.024806663393974304, -0.035900719463825226, 0.02385573647916317, 0.0065629431046545506, 0.011605439707636833, -0.014386584982275963, -0.026981471106410027, -0.036381762474775314, 0.06155301630496979, -0.008659777231514454, 0.002116380725055933, 0.04556572437286377, -0.046815913170576096, -0.02313258871436119, -0.08942164480686188, 0.04841164872050285, -0.021122535690665245, -0.02254422754049301, -0.04981851577758789, -0.0034803077578544617, -0.012297932989895344, 0.008239432238042355, 0.047114934772253036, 0.00661769462749362, 0.007422654889523983, -0.010536432266235352, 0.017699236050248146, 0.03705689311027527, -0.05223749205470085, 0.08318732678890228, -0.012691263109445572, 0.0005290658446028829, -0.036400388926267624, -0.009881239384412766, -0.0084602115675807, 0.018715934827923775, 0.010447868146002293, 0.014794052578508854, 0.008980220183730125, 0.007445380091667175, -0.009190590120851994, 0.05212938413023949, -0.022939523681998253, -0.010058344341814518, 0.05636056885123253, -0.029350265860557556, -0.019886845722794533, 0.03135835379362106, 0.008342122659087181, -0.035881172865629196, 0.01046653464436531, -0.021613096818327904, -0.012006496079266071, -0.004121533129364252, 0.01008923165500164, 0.01943202316761017, -0.06138957664370537, -0.008167427964508533, 0.045695964246988297, 0.0024448770564049482, 0.013623862527310848, 0.07292845100164413, 0.025493236258625984, 0.004201455507427454, -0.012848789803683758, 0.015164723619818687, -0.0004255910462234169, 0.013451483100652695, -0.009045260027050972, 0.02914554253220558, 0.0060610901564359665, -0.038529008626937866, 0.050426285713911057, 0.028119979426264763, -0.024038728326559067, 0.07541464269161224, -0.030938800424337387, 0.07481461763381958, -0.04906753823161125, -0.012256613001227379, 0.02951381728053093, -0.010313077829778194, 0.0012450257781893015, -0.012327657081186771, -0.008536932989954948, 0.046407487243413925, -0.03889358416199684, 0.013600661419332027, -0.026294192299246788, -0.045312561094760895, -0.04380592703819275, 0.03514811024069786, -0.004722023848444223, 0.04965948686003685, 0.01300541590899229, 0.03396625071763992, -0.021592751145362854, 0.004797613248229027, 0.032778702676296234, -0.03532745689153671, 0.00908737350255251, -0.007591527421027422, -0.005865334998816252, -0.02403939701616764, -0.005411440506577492, -0.030908236280083656, -0.020437978208065033, 0.015179092064499855, 0.015780009329319, 0.009086656384170055, -0.025829477235674858, -0.01668798178434372, 0.02893521822988987, 0.01681751012802124, -0.06337021291255951, -0.0036698526237159967, -0.029176980257034302, -0.01300579309463501, -0.017194708809256554, -0.03522628918290138 ]
<p>In "Elements of Bayesian Statistics" (1990), Florens, Mouchart and Rolin describe two basic forms of reduction of a Bayesian experiment: Marginalization and Conditioning (Ch. 1). I don't understand the conditioning reduction. More precisely, i struggle with the definition of a <em>regular</em> conditional experiment. I would appreciate an explanation, if possible in measure-theoretic terms. Thanks</p>
74,266
[ -0.004016063176095486, -0.021288735792040825, 0.0015582991763949394, -0.012095833197236061, 0.02430287003517151, 0.016196303069591522, 0.003979996312409639, -0.01684013195335865, 0.03151005506515503, -0.020703013986349106, 0.014605606906116009, 0.04563820734620094, 0.05277087911963463, -0.0004371224495116621, 0.016498923301696777, 0.024218572303652763, -0.039456743746995926, 0.0008841307135298848, -0.021879877895116806, -0.005614283960312605, 0.008318282663822174, 0.017803790047764778, 0.019162002950906754, -0.020973488688468933, -0.007402398623526096, 0.013453561812639236, 0.027768168598413467, 0.0009149041725322604, 0.024874212220311165, 0.07516835629940033, -0.031925421208143234, -0.02181720733642578, -0.021931733936071396, 0.016317160800099373, -0.028108472004532814, -0.03587406873703003, 0.0009202120127156377, 0.000601922336500138, 0.003906498197466135, 0.019589275121688843, -0.008273478597402573, -0.02040829323232174, -0.01043049804866314, 0.03054852783679962, -0.046871088445186615, 0.001514953444711864, 0.023588569834828377, -0.028663165867328644, 0.028121041133999825, -0.04254746064543724, 0.05318886414170265, -0.0034960759803652763, 0.02017284370958805, 0.027812834829092026, 0.024575475603342056, 0.010304865427315235, 0.03248810023069382, 0.060530126094818115, -0.021777305752038956, -0.052960801869630814, -0.04806787148118019, -0.06942861527204514, 0.015008172020316124, -0.0004080419603269547, -0.04807887226343155, 0.014686482027173042, 0.00453536119312048, -0.02194581739604473, 0.02703920751810074, 0.01673177257180214, -0.007163839414715767, 0.02673974633216858, 0.006738356780260801, -0.010040584951639175, 0.016344375908374786, 0.009274573996663094, 0.009993715211749077, 0.040610335767269135, 0.021449338644742966, 0.037914928048849106, 0.0007101027294993401, 0.003507455810904503, 0.0026024074759334326, 0.061557263135910034, -0.00573737733066082, -0.07286688685417175, 0.07571517676115036, -0.034696295857429504, 0.01734101213514805, -0.004344625398516655, -0.04901176318526268, 0.013569478876888752, -0.0037903646007180214, -0.039835430681705475, -0.052484672516584396, 0.04759688302874565, 0.004172565881162882, 0.05677506700158119, -0.04906701669096947, -0.029616404324769974, -0.0032029657159000635, -0.03686273843050003, 0.008962403051555157, 0.01036020927131176, -0.04078518971800804, 0.01810871995985508, -0.027138782665133476, 0.06316442042589188, -0.019804244861006737, -0.019783219322562218, -0.024975674226880074, 0.03090733103454113, -0.0024670190177857876, 0.03853904828429222, 0.025781111791729927, -0.018486278131604195, -0.009521078318357468, -0.016197722405195236, 0.06178645044565201, 0.06300034373998642, 0.05733773484826088, -0.031093714758753777, 0.03412419557571411, -0.02725849859416485, -0.07486932724714279, 0.004265099763870239, 0.0014532578643411398, 0.0060126096941530704, 0.014630158431828022, 0.0504600927233696, -0.013677529990673065, -0.03620012477040291, 0.04118054360151291, 0.03745470196008682, 0.007857236079871655, -0.04343289136886597, -0.08278311043977737, -0.032042693346738815, 0.05577914044260979, 0.001422140863724053, 0.0080804955214262, -0.06783834099769592, 0.00714564323425293, 0.04144228994846344, 0.03466273099184036, -0.0030027444008737803, 0.054137278348207474, 0.014293837361037731, 0.029265237972140312, 0.022480923682451248, -0.02239968441426754, -0.05413063243031502, -0.02554645575582981, 0.01046850997954607, -0.04290153458714485, -0.07954604178667068, 0.001115509425289929, 0.03801674023270607, -0.01925307884812355, -0.003913659602403641, 0.03489028662443161, -0.05374174937605858, -0.06489690393209457, 0.030176380649209023, 0.0007438645116053522, -0.015354136005043983, 0.0822497308254242, -0.0017131274798884988, -0.012009686790406704, 0.047614339739084244, 0.009554979391396046, -0.006368529982864857, 0.0038971519097685814, 0.07790619879961014, 0.04341161251068115, -0.020986463874578476, -0.024775421246886253, -0.003068583318963647, 0.02492082118988037, 0.004279629327356815, 0.0063857766799628735, 0.06013995409011841, -0.024779940024018288, -0.009062898345291615, 0.024063603952527046, 0.03398207575082779, 0.011889282613992691, -0.025139247998595238, 0.025556428357958794, -0.07161588966846466, -0.05301341414451599, -0.09839155524969101, 0.0076328059658408165, -0.000329127098666504, -0.01878483220934868, 0.02886452153325081, 0.018411321565508842, 0.020823294296860695, -0.013013768009841442, -0.037582263350486755, -0.029992423951625824, -0.012028495781123638, -0.013649321161210537, -0.029502075165510178, 0.022110268473625183, 0.03860274329781532, 0.053524844348430634, -0.006202330347150564, 0.044427718967199326, -0.028777819126844406, -0.05036965012550354, -0.01970459520816803, -0.00918543990701437, -0.01319920364767313, -0.024926550686359406, -0.021606534719467163, 0.017803668975830078, -0.044990573078393936, -0.012878689914941788, 0.0320674367249012, -0.07395391911268234, 0.04295167699456215, 0.06439262628555298, 0.012760084122419357, 0.008845596574246883, 0.039489470422267914, 0.03485631197690964, 0.006092679221183062, -0.020640650764107704, 0.006731628905981779, -0.01510551106184721, -0.016647404059767723, 0.05445261672139168, 0.00795028917491436, -0.022722536697983742, 0.020943637937307358, 0.03581296280026436, 0.03710448369383812, 0.043809037655591965, 0.053281672298908234, 0.017866551876068115, -0.008304339833557606, 0.02068743109703064, 0.017410345375537872, 0.02062673680484295, -0.022508062422275543, 0.020034173503518105, 0.00965126883238554, 0.02697906270623207, 0.015214254148304462, -0.01580367051064968, 0.029743501916527748, -0.022598017007112503, 0.020802060142159462, -0.029040515422821045, -0.016454504802823067, 0.024324456229805946, 0.007150270044803619, 0.012155048549175262, -0.008988894522190094, 0.018249668180942535, -0.011981843970716, -0.025264058262109756, 0.017772382125258446, 0.04333853721618652, 0.023513542488217354, -0.013604851439595222, -0.014308007434010506, 0.025325631722807884, -0.037436846643686295, 0.029165003448724747, -0.01137299183756113, -0.01618458889424801, -0.05978347361087799, 0.0053316690027713776, 0.02684999816119671, -0.020678134635090828, 0.02159975841641426, -0.049078818410634995, -0.046787507832050323, -0.018119899556040764, -0.04897451773285866, 0.022087877616286278, 0.006606921553611755, -0.018914589658379555, 0.019616922363638878, -0.03371008113026619, -0.015958692878484726, 0.03517298400402069, -0.016932209953665733, 0.021131210029125214, 0.022065769881010056, -0.011952861212193966, -0.01711116172373295, -0.054641012102365494, -0.03626387193799019, 0.005630476400256157, 0.006064549554139376, -0.005335607565939426, 0.05354082211852074, 0.04864257574081421, -0.004386927001178265, -0.012240035459399223, -0.030734717845916748, -0.01411718875169754, -0.05150754377245903, -0.04260258004069328, 0.010757477022707462, -0.017968030646443367, 0.040943827480077744, 0.0483655110001564, -0.0659649446606636, 0.00993487611413002, -0.04668150469660759, -0.0668521374464035, 0.01690344326198101, 0.004681487567722797, 0.00238420395180583, 0.01983042061328888, -0.031956229358911514, 0.07192837446928024, 0.013936616480350494, -0.024821102619171143, -0.03416917845606804, 0.026530668139457703, -0.010951667092740536, -0.007163385860621929, -0.03263167664408684, 0.01442412193864584, -0.010860702954232693, 0.06856784969568253, 0.012875307351350784, 0.05147126689553261, -0.011380964890122414, 0.029260532930493355, 0.006523446179926395, 0.032827846705913544, 0.012052906677126884, 0.014911415055394173, -0.009029101580381393, 0.04442637413740158, -0.03642106428742409, -0.006739092990756035, -0.028617754578590393, 0.04450065270066261, 0.009069675579667091, -0.052128925919532776, 0.004057979676872492, 0.005424255505204201, 0.02420738711953163, -0.024053094908595085, 0.05024866759777069, -0.009313159622251987, -0.044512681663036346, 0.028767935931682587, -0.010068371891975403, -0.003002470126375556, -0.052821170538663864, 0.02230336330831051, 0.024228539317846298, 0.06109920144081116, -0.06298571825027466, -0.019807269796729088, 0.00111368577927351, -0.030557790771126747, 0.013040169142186642, 0.0018439058912917972, -0.033880721777677536, 0.04656298831105232, 0.012282207608222961, 0.030238382518291473, -0.012892249040305614, -0.03758249059319496, 0.0213204063475132, -0.02478300780057907, -0.003128514625132084, 0.01926470547914505, 0.020704399794340134, 0.0059895808808505535, 0.033648207783699036, -0.01626359298825264, 0.008615083992481232, 0.006963858846575022, -0.006490903906524181, -0.08612944185733795, 0.018873021006584167, -0.02564903348684311, -0.008700475096702576, -0.0022390440572053194, 0.03863127902150154, 0.0629386380314827, -0.023092588409781456, -0.010876213200390339, -0.019302411004900932, 0.0073553044348955154, -0.06507417559623718, -0.00819298718124628, -0.027811678126454353, -0.03620467334985733, -0.02242354117333889, -0.00796473678201437, 0.05252760276198387, -0.007941225543618202, -0.0012161361519247293, 0.03881300985813141, -0.02775265835225582, -0.0014247325016185641, 0.010072540491819382, 0.0401318222284317, 0.028455041348934174, 0.03972820192575455, 0.044366203248500824, 0.0686822161078453, -0.037527550011873245, 0.04494700953364372, 0.059320785105228424, 0.07681213319301605, 0.01766197197139263, -0.04135147109627724, -0.01744868792593479, -0.03228570148348808, -0.0065833572298288345, -0.015846915543079376, 0.01779819279909134, 0.0437353253364563, 0.007535877637565136, 0.029899919405579567, 0.030980290845036507, -0.03905181214213371, 0.03805793449282646, 0.05741326883435249, 0.004535634070634842, -0.019487330690026283, -0.037676047533750534, 0.0054586585611104965, -0.04299541935324669, 0.011187413707375526, 0.05184558406472206, 0.005395402200520039, -0.00010357118298998103, 0.016811545938253403, 0.04211731627583504, -0.033688321709632874, 0.005458154249936342, -0.01726418361067772, 0.006752930115908384, 0.015136657282710075, 0.017274068668484688, -0.0333719328045845, 0.008206059224903584, 0.04833599179983139, 0.030249036848545074, 0.031182803213596344, -0.009647673927247524, -0.0442676767706871, -0.00019324904133100063, 0.013842261396348476, 0.0174114853143692, -0.024537574499845505, 0.004820774309337139, -0.036343082785606384, -0.0348014160990715, 0.04517646133899689, -0.02888565883040428, -0.010451486334204674, -0.02806541509926319, 0.026667164638638496, -0.006154404953122139, 0.017214225605130196, -0.014444287866353989, 0.015995701774954796, -0.027125602588057518, 0.03785989433526993, 0.030464675277471542, -0.023255297914147377, -0.045223817229270935, -0.020211489871144295, 0.00036300893407315016, 0.04879847913980484, -0.0041742464527487755, -0.0025971797294914722, 0.003980070352554321, -0.013187521137297153, -0.011850123293697834, -0.06407919526100159, 0.021741822361946106, 0.012709792703390121, 0.008275439962744713, 0.051655787974596024, -0.015078793279826641, -0.05056380480527878, 0.005852701608091593, 0.022585982456803322, -0.0204831063747406, 0.019169272854924202, -0.040623560547828674, 0.036104995757341385, -0.0012289016740396619, -0.00969767477363348, 0.06449016183614731, -0.009386190213263035, 0.00394450593739748, 0.00020739698084071279, -0.025930432602763176, 0.015407541766762733, -0.059841882437467575, 0.019490739330649376, -0.06018204241991043, -0.016930336132645607, 0.008132845163345337, 0.046975307166576385, 0.019043896347284317, 0.016158437356352806, 0.011368975043296814, -0.05596364662051201, -0.01733100414276123, 0.03553943708539009, 0.02448122948408127, -0.03249103203415871, -0.006661666557192802, 0.0027033500373363495, 0.004835679195821285, -0.04133789613842964, 0.004384920001029968, -0.03402375057339668, 0.03062797337770462, -0.019668836146593094, -0.04322529211640358, 0.02959199622273445, -0.02224755473434925, -0.01721298135817051, 0.039563171565532684, -0.031020620837807655, 0.028853798285126686, -0.0027156444266438484, 0.01037587784230709, 0.00014588914928026497, -0.044050801545381546, -0.013722477480769157, -0.03142233565449715, -0.007607234176248312, 0.037134602665901184, -0.0891452208161354, 0.03313802555203438, 0.004345380701124668, 0.0020161475986242294, -0.06587580591440201, -0.03236191347241402, -0.011871015653014183, -0.015356787480413914, -0.010401683859527111, -0.046602580696344376, -0.022631265223026276, -0.03948010131716728, -0.04078322649002075, -0.02768535166978836, 0.051587507128715515, -0.02083083987236023, 0.005205369088798761, 0.002384991617873311, 0.013258461840450764, 0.044887978583574295, 0.02408025786280632, -0.027958447113633156, 0.006819917354732752, -0.022716093808412552, -0.009674139320850372, 0.0014283366035670042, 0.023527907207608223, -0.040910765528678894, -0.004594242200255394, -0.04561634361743927, 0.00011585048923734576, 0.000614053220488131, -0.021650901064276695, 0.002348823007196188, -0.0064918105490505695, -0.005252684000879526, 0.008656554855406284, -0.018183404579758644, -0.022067667916417122, -0.004820242058485746, 0.045086611062288284, -0.024398522451519966, 0.011843117885291576, 0.01298421248793602, -0.05225628241896629, 0.052233122289180756, -0.0029831682331860065, 0.0008149011409841478, 0.04161786660552025, 0.028181537985801697, 0.0037354337982833385, 0.014031700789928436, 0.00004146559149376117, -0.0076255458407104015, 0.022250862792134285, -0.0064764441922307014, -0.0012714059557765722, 0.03363729640841484, -0.027517016977071762, -0.023985782638192177, 0.025699807330965996, -0.07952872663736343, -0.01339212991297245, 0.06645988672971725, -0.00902912300080061, 0.07197515666484833, 0.043011490255594254, -0.014444337226450443, -0.005960792303085327, -0.03953409194946289, 0.033971332013607025, -0.0012522470206022263, 0.01943848840892315, 0.05425102263689041, -0.06313363462686539, -0.025428632274270058, 0.03808686137199402, 0.004945831373333931, -0.012109831906855106, 0.01626594364643097, 0.006054378114640713, 0.06262003630399704, 0.030354583635926247, -0.04942307621240616, -0.026107782498002052, 0.04348748177289963, -0.038884762674570084, 0.005712345242500305, -0.023846058174967766, -0.008866732008755207, 0.024942049756646156, 0.028954235836863518, -0.0036904781591147184, -0.060657862573862076, -0.009483981877565384, -0.02824743650853634, 0.03695333003997803, 0.010141760110855103, 0.004886595997959375, 0.038839247077703476, -0.01577940583229065, 0.013758748769760132, -0.01978529803454876, -0.0019722729921340942, -0.007518482394516468, -0.049917206168174744, -0.03406544029712677, -0.03670027479529381, -0.014112317934632301, 0.00465512415394187, 0.004470746498554945, 0.003590930951759219, 0.006947203539311886, -0.062406472861766815, 0.0037630631122738123, 0.03575843572616577, 0.01772916689515114, -0.008812847547233105, 0.05569932609796524, 0.007011310663074255, 0.015772098675370216, -0.026887187734246254, -0.009427947923541069, 0.12961986660957336, 0.07950630784034729, 0.014999696053564548, -0.11803064495325089, 0.029617231339216232, 0.011697318404912949, 0.01126585528254509, -0.015723204240202904, 0.011936947703361511, 0.03473709523677826, -0.028177138417959213, -0.001630430924706161, 0.06474369764328003, 0.006286972668021917, -0.0019205843564122915, 0.03230753913521767, -0.042591359466314316, -0.04529879242181778, 0.012222805991768837, 0.0027359239757061005, -0.0007237516110762954, 0.011211220175027847, -0.05952690541744232, 0.0006658282363787293, 0.010929405689239502, -0.05277317762374878, -0.026171864941716194, -0.010162734426558018, -0.013562350533902645, 0.010061672888696194, 0.020931221544742584, -0.022569315508008003, 0.014304815791547298, -0.03198188543319702, -0.033825092017650604, 0.012918507680296898, 0.02253136783838272, -0.007625269237905741, -0.008032423444092274, 0.01807156205177307, -0.0033319606445729733, -0.020359324291348457, 0.008239494636654854, 0.009285646490752697, -0.037658680230379105, -0.02793985977768898, 0.0034285227302461863, 0.05091182887554169, -0.005168695468455553, -0.02624617889523506, -0.007332134991884232, 0.009878493845462799, -0.000988844782114029, -0.054979775100946426, -0.026753222569823265, 0.019403262063860893, 0.035420071333646774, -0.015233899466693401, -0.044801756739616394, 0.009021761827170849, 0.039205968379974365, -0.04263225942850113, 0.06616020202636719, 0.007944738492369652, -0.013664751313626766, -0.018181784078478813, -0.002869137329980731, 0.041170500218868256, 0.015809962525963783, -0.019935132935643196, -0.0003334834473207593, 0.01328253373503685, -0.010359816253185272, -0.028610259294509888, 0.023656483739614487, -0.007572666741907597, 0.016768259927630424, -0.04414375498890877, 0.002376307500526309, 0.0230014156550169, -0.025235170498490334, -0.008316663093864918, -0.05681975185871124, -0.03653765097260475, -0.010599062778055668, -0.011331493966281414, 0.0086958147585392, 0.05260120704770088, -0.008616240695118904, -0.0012395248049870133, 0.012161435559391975, 0.02309965156018734, 0.03402251377701759, -0.037475571036338806, -0.01892245188355446, 0.005166712682694197, -0.021570218726992607, -0.016774019226431847, -0.0008353753364644945, 0.03189026936888695, 0.025680478662252426, 0.019763413816690445, -0.010652048513293266, 0.019815418869256973, -0.021297825500369072, 0.004699185024946928, 0.0022993613965809345, -0.04566807672381401, 0.04042541980743408, 0.027932435274124146, 0.013327069580554962, -0.032054733484983444, -0.032069794833660126, -0.009786154143512249, 0.023798059672117233, 0.021914981305599213, -0.028980711475014687, -0.0381077416241169, 0.008511197753250599, 0.022709917277097702, 0.05926677584648132, 0.002000468550249934, -0.014134586788713932, -0.006981431506574154, 0.0338914692401886, 0.01295506302267313, 0.009217902086675167, -0.001503251027315855, -0.0011655241250991821, -0.03179515525698662, -0.016421202570199966, 0.024457039311528206, 0.01563725620508194, -0.002497130772098899, -0.024595817551016808, 0.027413424104452133, 0.013884808868169785, 0.03816438466310501, -0.016879452392458916, -0.03579360991716385, 0.043985605239868164, -0.07869553565979004, -0.021409351378679276, 0.02435179054737091, 0.009561588987708092, 0.03397418186068535, 0.019847197458148003, -0.0016452247509732842, -0.03026464395225048, 0.03668992221355438, -0.01638764515519142, -0.011080288328230381, 0.026132503524422646, -0.008900105953216553, -0.025433363392949104, -0.026554791256785393, 0.023190533742308617, 0.03494110330939293, -0.014749694615602493, 0.03286443278193474, 0.03677886351943016, 0.01935148425400257, 0.012837923131883144, -0.015232683159410954, -0.012794042937457561, 0.018822669982910156, 0.005908085498958826, -0.012317901477217674, 0.014111224561929703, 0.08380851149559021, -0.028280960395932198, 0.03549899905920029, -0.020200874656438828, -0.015797412022948265, -0.09330197423696518, 0.0018550099339336157, 0.02020641602575779, 0.018248476088047028, 0.043228451162576675, -0.02974284067749977, 0.039903540164232254, 0.01976437121629715, -0.030847711488604546, -0.018478410318493843, -0.014753111638128757, 0.00257490505464375, -0.030125370249152184, -0.027833295986056328, -0.012751054018735886, 0.05445609241724014, 0.03160181641578674, 0.013204527087509632, 0.03177579492330551, -0.015348372049629688, -0.004013705532997847, -0.01920231059193611, 0.00022672151681035757, 0.028991883620619774, -0.0069132642820477486, -0.028297921642661095, 0.05152147635817528, -0.012395632453262806, -0.02945590578019619, 0.02498621866106987, 0.049366243183612823, 0.024744661524891853, -0.010222998447716236, 0.020003316923975945, 0.024301176890730858, 0.02280060201883316, 0.009196560829877853, 0.017786869779229164, 0.019769441336393356, 0.012130705639719963, 0.037179816514253616, 0.01620696671307087, 0.009525755420327187, -0.02473025768995285, 0.038477323949337006, -0.024649320170283318, -0.024968646466732025, 0.02079334482550621, 0.016074858605861664, -0.03973347321152687, 0.009824217297136784, -0.029220689088106155, 0.03713493049144745, -0.0034410597290843725, 0.02021404169499874, -0.03244306519627571, 0.0002365371910855174, 0.0475347563624382, -0.011960452422499657, -0.007855270989239216, 0.02372698485851288, -0.02130085788667202, -0.04437638819217682, 0.015679990872740746, 0.010336814448237419, -0.02912476845085621, -0.060981202870607376, -0.00380714307539165, -0.006945466622710228, -0.023281654343008995, -0.032761868089437485, -0.008559389039874077, -0.04416831210255623, -0.0084396256133914, -0.01834329590201378, 0.015922464430332184, -0.0606469064950943, -0.00954804290086031, -0.001569335930980742, -0.0883321538567543, 0.0864809900522232, 0.04040006175637245, -0.0021983387414366007, -0.0597512386739254, 0.003072833875194192, -0.0516875721514225, 0.002989392727613449, 0.05315088853240013, 0.04547897353768349, -0.007407726254314184, -0.008138531818985939, 0.02188686467707157, 0.02342860773205757, -0.03963341936469078, 0.012367455288767815, -0.01716233417391777, 0.0005881913239136338, -0.0233494620770216, -0.03729567304253578, 0.01871286705136299, 0.018337665125727654, -0.008407551795244217, 0.02456381730735302, -0.010081248357892036, -0.026222165673971176, -0.009539201855659485, 0.04356427863240242, 0.013083718717098236, 0.0077987415716052055, 0.05642444267868996, -0.0324208028614521, 0.03952812775969505, 0.006840012036263943, -0.023368623107671738, -0.0639849603176117, 0.013425617478787899, -0.042150404304265976, 0.003129070159047842, 0.010325712151825428, 0.013887863606214523, 0.005862395744770765, -0.02197287045419216, -0.018444720655679703, 0.04140966013073921, -0.028644105419516563, 0.016106124967336655, 0.03381114453077316, 0.04188390448689461, 0.07416453957557678, -0.0178755484521389, -0.013853233307600021, 0.006998296361416578, 0.06168656051158905, 0.020318221300840378, 0.026683567091822624, 0.04579576849937439, 0.014798777177929878, -0.003192789852619171, 0.033911313861608505, -0.04264283552765846, 0.010528145357966423, 0.012797052972018719, 0.03603498265147209, -0.009082396514713764, -0.014490345492959023, -0.010624140501022339, -0.029887378215789795, 0.0017441295785829425, -0.012277682311832905, 0.02010306715965271, 0.0543147474527359, 0.011123325675725937, -0.020008904859423637, -0.013311435468494892, 0.022990083321928978, -0.030957859009504318, 0.02088039368391037, 0.015904610976576805, 0.03367583826184273, 0.00019915300072170794, 0.007087001111358404, -0.01973722130060196, -0.020971424877643585, 0.02945958822965622, -0.0017691984539851546, 0.011369290761649609, 0.024775546044111252, -0.04727545008063316, -0.006560826674103737, 0.005935030989348888, -0.012892287224531174, 0.025585491210222244, -0.0479443334043026, 0.011101637035608292, 0.04251164197921753, -0.004782543517649174, 0.012281310744583607, 0.0005834330804646015, 0.014832169748842716, -0.08072913438081741, -0.02211601287126541, -0.05637339875102043, 0.0214241910725832, 0.01250961422920227, 0.017717450857162476 ]
<p>I'm interested in testing a sequence of numbers for randomness. I've done some searching and come across <a href="http://www.stat.fsu.edu/pub/diehard/" rel="nofollow">die hard</a> and <a href="http://www.phy.duke.edu/~rgb/General/dieharder.php" rel="nofollow">die harder</a>. However these tests seem to require some expertise to apply, or at least aren't as well documented or easy to use as R, say. Also die harder require a *nix platform.</p> <p>I'm working on windows platform, and although it would be possible to generate a csv file at work and send it home where I could process the file on linux using die harder, that would be a pain, and likely a lot of work. So I've looked at what's available in R, and come up with the <a href="http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/lawstat/index.html" rel="nofollow">lawstat package</a>, which implements <code>bartels.test</code> and <code>runs.test</code>. It was pretty straightforward to get those tests going on my data.</p> <p>I'm wondering, are there other tests that I could reasonably be running that wouldn't require much time, or should I just leave it there? There's no reason to suspect that the number I'm seeing aren't reasonably random: the main focus of the testing I need to do is to look at whether several vectors of random numbers are correlated according to some parameters that have been set up. So I'm looking at measures of correlation between sequences, but I also also want to test that each sequence is random, just to be sure that the process of introducing correlations hasn't introduced some problem in the marginal distributions.</p> <p>What I suspect is that there might be a 90/10 rule here -- the final 10% of applying all the tests, in die hard, say, might be a disproportionate amount of effort, and if I can get 90% of the way there in R or similar, that would be good.</p>
74,267
[ -0.03666926920413971, -0.006665466818958521, 0.001456636586226523, -0.02336348220705986, 0.035064805299043655, 0.0077780368737876415, 0.012497142888605595, -0.03275641053915024, 0.018052613362669945, 0.006334275938570499, 0.05646523833274841, 0.03378706052899361, 0.021598272025585175, 0.0751628503203392, 0.0482405424118042, 0.010971976444125175, -0.010708017274737358, 0.016481615602970123, -0.017814408987760544, -0.03126049414277077, 0.019296737387776375, -0.006297006271779537, 0.032984405755996704, -0.0027276824694126844, -0.01776246912777424, 0.01041534636169672, -0.0020749366376549006, -0.05503902956843376, -0.00003310472675366327, 0.014353458769619465, -0.07560001313686371, -0.022976810112595558, -0.0034637581557035446, 0.01885059103369713, 0.039075348526239395, 0.022712387144565582, 0.0019851578399538994, -0.01815049909055233, 0.0015729431761428714, 0.025861160829663277, -0.03540689870715141, -0.017954248934984207, -0.017940271645784378, 0.013891001231968403, 0.02027912624180317, 0.005050412379205227, 0.0029375674203038216, -0.0007333260145969689, 0.05830288678407669, -0.015141327865421772, 0.043651822954416275, -0.0027237178292125463, 0.011146415956318378, 0.037799328565597534, -0.0000576884594920557, -0.03148041293025017, 0.04695866256952286, 0.0647595152258873, -0.027087271213531494, -0.04850342124700546, 0.022304831072688103, -0.058134280145168304, -0.015503661707043648, -0.015989644452929497, -0.022172294557094574, 0.013621353544294834, 0.02260286919772625, -0.011852850206196308, 0.02035466767847538, -0.020008644089102745, 0.01631532609462738, 0.010789074003696442, 0.02200678363442421, -0.023415185511112213, -0.0010674288496375084, 0.0027831229381263256, 0.03806654363870621, -0.007298107724636793, 0.005598581861704588, 0.07442888617515564, -0.03434888273477554, -0.011084957048296928, 0.024351302534341812, 0.03770900145173073, 0.07276155799627304, -0.018990010023117065, 0.05907612666487694, -0.04556797817349434, 0.009754864498972893, 0.04351299628615379, -0.002655706135556102, -0.01659248396754265, 0.0354747548699379, 0.0567685067653656, -0.024438468739390373, 0.03247975930571556, -0.03371106833219528, 0.03842354565858841, -0.055537689477205276, 0.0013347239000722766, -0.023549914360046387, -0.031060688197612762, -0.0009256416233256459, 0.028645891696214676, -0.04734140634536743, -0.042762190103530884, -0.021264808252453804, -0.028434285894036293, -0.02245469018816948, -0.006661045365035534, -0.045083560049533844, 0.03447626903653145, -0.029805844649672508, -0.008722729980945587, 0.020748320966959, -0.022366482764482498, -0.028490977361798286, -0.011757650412619114, 0.05036771669983864, 0.08278403431177139, 0.046219877898693085, -0.02231556922197342, 0.008622393012046814, -0.05679216608405113, 0.001689557684585452, -0.004178193397819996, 0.024737244471907616, -0.007336525246500969, -0.008519694209098816, 0.054797060787677765, -0.006858782842755318, -0.021530330181121826, 0.028370432555675507, 0.010989258997142315, 0.04626113176345825, 0.0020539325196295977, -0.0782955065369606, -0.05909426510334015, 0.058599453419446945, -0.03346622362732887, 0.0007200812106020749, -0.03729211539030075, 0.012620247900485992, -0.04667704924941063, 0.02250972017645836, 0.0167619027197361, 0.0698792114853859, -0.026104724034667015, 0.0040991222485899925, 0.004142369143664837, -0.010075387544929981, 0.019138360396027565, -0.013273730874061584, -0.007548332680016756, -0.014912995509803295, -0.047112833708524704, 0.04194479435682297, -0.023548800498247147, -0.005933024920523167, -0.016733432188630104, -0.004298887215554714, 0.01854298636317253, -0.014341240748763084, -0.019048502668738365, 0.013489525765180588, -0.025363637134432793, 0.05870446562767029, 0.002077673561871052, 0.029139602556824684, 0.011196600273251534, -0.053920526057481766, -0.009954781271517277, 0.030639342963695526, 0.005082018673419952, 0.044265151023864746, -0.04149089381098747, 0.014947597868740559, -0.03952047973871231, -0.02242753654718399, 0.027369648218154907, -0.031949616968631744, -0.004094554111361504, -0.014794929884374142, -0.035705164074897766, 0.037680964916944504, 0.012537944130599499, 0.021205801516771317, -0.007917078211903572, 0.06094688922166824, -0.06703576445579529, -0.03126892074942589, -0.06042446941137314, 0.013146672397851944, -0.006616215221583843, -0.051794737577438354, 0.02328246459364891, 0.006910027004778385, 0.033526115119457245, 0.005446154624223709, -0.019745441153645515, -0.015055036172270775, 0.013839803636074066, 0.028546681627631187, -0.008985708467662334, -0.015351466834545135, 0.04436628520488739, 0.035526540130376816, -0.05452461913228035, 0.01446384098380804, -0.03595415875315666, -0.07941833883523941, 0.017854835838079453, -0.04895710200071335, -0.005807964596897364, 0.014281190000474453, 0.019832780584692955, 0.029026120901107788, -0.000986472237855196, -0.024930592626333237, 0.009122457355260849, -0.016149766743183136, 0.0389375202357769, 0.08241159468889236, 0.053768340498209, 0.006246041040867567, -0.023050617426633835, 0.0351615808904171, -0.036010075360536575, -0.02879985049366951, 0.01142790075391531, -0.042014434933662415, -0.004048232454806566, 0.047187503427267075, 0.018321482464671135, -0.030731214210391045, 0.022557636722922325, 0.09364243596792221, 0.006502265110611916, -0.008749128319323063, 0.06816597282886505, -0.009286785498261452, -0.023385055363178253, -0.00474004028365016, -0.00926162675023079, 0.021815067157149315, -0.0026250872761011124, 0.008616662584245205, -0.0004270075587555766, 0.051798973232507706, 0.009984125383198261, -0.020265020430088043, 0.005255553405731916, 0.02883071079850197, 0.0061067212373018265, 0.01581578701734543, -0.02505049668252468, 0.030743930488824844, -0.004823409020900726, 0.007067420519888401, 0.056704673916101456, 0.024279914796352386, 0.031874772161245346, 0.0119363684207201, -0.06776595115661621, -0.005647775251418352, 0.061190683394670486, -0.06492183357477188, -0.010000879876315594, 0.022709548473358154, -0.02563144825398922, 0.006202999036759138, -0.005196761339902878, -0.03689931705594063, -0.05775100737810135, 0.03223083168268204, 0.019535543397068977, 0.019761089235544205, 0.007153234910219908, -0.054891347885131836, -0.003877951530739665, 0.018629759550094604, -0.03143217787146568, -0.0028611256275326014, -0.0011508818715810776, -0.04765979200601578, -0.004520290531218052, 0.006369385402649641, -0.020843015983700752, 0.020287180319428444, -0.012652328237891197, -0.023175561800599098, 0.04364939033985138, 0.01617615669965744, -0.04844963550567627, -0.005654021631926298, 0.0016458036843687296, -0.02399158477783203, -0.03638262301683426, -0.026922771707177162, 0.06501172482967377, 0.014371165074408054, -0.08084830641746521, 0.01237139105796814, -0.030171668156981468, -0.009205654263496399, -0.023084310814738274, 0.02205677703022957, 0.0031336667016148567, -0.009684336371719837, -0.012155910022556782, 0.031079094856977463, 0.0018342117546126246, -0.04642866551876068, -0.05381172150373459, -0.07027509808540344, 0.0045204171910882, -0.0006353844073601067, 0.0029993534553796053, -0.016391411423683167, -0.00042399231460876763, 0.03406766057014465, 0.028488818556070328, -0.02797153778374195, -0.04956886172294617, -0.02501419559121132, -0.007650073152035475, -0.02804335579276085, 0.005533531773835421, 0.02490856498479843, 0.012185536324977875, 0.003682888112962246, -0.006390911061316729, 0.0529157854616642, 0.006705954670906067, -0.012160087004303932, 0.03846253827214241, 0.04924976825714111, -0.00878467969596386, -0.03058306872844696, 0.03601318970322609, 0.008655915036797523, -0.04696660116314888, -0.03896353766322136, 0.001518326229415834, 0.03021259978413582, 0.03431117162108421, -0.07213442027568817, 0.017119016498327255, 0.004948075395077467, 0.01823119819164276, -0.03458051756024361, -0.0023529392201453447, 0.016196154057979584, -0.04318280145525932, -0.0070692203007638454, 0.019441887736320496, 0.05173777788877487, -0.010876751504838467, -0.006747379433363676, 0.021372642368078232, 0.048099927604198456, -0.003153875470161438, 0.018131500110030174, -0.041607558727264404, -0.022624559700489044, 0.013210630044341087, -0.0331033356487751, 0.02802252769470215, 0.04368247091770172, 0.0378587543964386, 0.04138427972793579, -0.01616285741329193, -0.025320375338196754, -0.003175937570631504, -0.05248227342963219, 0.008215663023293018, -0.0453120619058609, 0.008710491470992565, 0.013581954874098301, 0.04690942540764809, -0.01481057982891798, -0.031337372958660126, -0.0007599132368341088, -0.027180295437574387, -0.028717070817947388, -0.0027090529911220074, -0.019387701526284218, -0.010049326345324516, -0.022390518337488174, -0.03098716214299202, 0.0004474532324820757, 0.00471627339720726, 0.009045782499015331, -0.003790473099797964, 0.04184412956237793, -0.016906224191188812, -0.01201017014682293, -0.04335763677954674, -0.04022086784243584, 0.022238126024603844, 0.030137648805975914, 0.025181444361805916, 0.002278914675116539, 0.016111986711621284, 0.013739455491304398, 0.022531090304255486, -0.018672099336981773, 0.01554174069315195, 0.009252284653484821, -0.003559995209798217, 0.04191453009843826, -0.002081221668049693, 0.03957889974117279, -0.015294293873012066, -0.0015172044513747096, -0.014437040314078331, 0.02988496422767639, 0.05605381354689598, -0.019107643514871597, 0.004064985550940037, -0.03402518853545189, -0.009700005874037743, 0.01520560309290886, 0.0012065625051036477, 0.01520510297268629, -0.008158857002854347, 0.06549183279275894, 0.01208653673529625, -0.008380797691643238, 0.005525238811969757, 0.020599525421857834, -0.005622742231935263, 0.026844795793294907, -0.01233912818133831, -0.027979543432593346, 0.009667287580668926, -0.011908452026546001, 0.003776090918108821, 0.04545440897345543, 0.025023017078638077, -0.0074343495070934296, 0.005946581717580557, -0.033961810171604156, 0.002298924373462796, 0.004582303110510111, -0.01150487456470728, 0.040601640939712524, -0.031472980976104736, -0.02344912476837635, 0.0029917580541223288, 0.03408413752913475, -0.0005212227697484195, 0.0231500081717968, -0.001997817773371935, -0.05210170894861221, -0.0006793398060835898, 0.08467341214418411, 0.047564826905727386, -0.04434316232800484, -0.01282108947634697, -0.05327634513378143, -0.01801954209804535, 0.04593086615204811, -0.060092389583587646, -0.008622054941952229, 0.005055103451013565, 0.0036764841061085463, -0.055342450737953186, -0.054588668048381805, -0.0593404620885849, 0.04710671678185463, -0.0013986987760290504, 0.028131088241934776, -0.03127995505928993, -0.03850660100579262, -0.033293794840574265, 0.03914525359869003, 0.03451663628220558, 0.04836694151163101, -0.05305711179971695, -0.0026496918871998787, 0.022360678762197495, -0.02490384690463543, 0.007149948738515377, -0.03385317325592041, 0.015565752983093262, 0.0011993013322353363, 0.03722744435071945, 0.06448952108621597, -0.007651539519429207, -0.048054952174425125, 0.02805177867412567, -0.013147498480975628, 0.0013155342312529683, 0.034594688564538956, 0.008500413037836552, 0.05444265529513359, 0.025013428181409836, 0.021977074444293976, 0.03843620792031288, 0.025478029623627663, 0.008370197378098965, 0.009884122759103775, -0.03177940472960472, -0.01582222990691662, -0.039553020149469376, -0.002382181817665696, -0.03934544697403908, -0.03764801099896431, -0.02170543558895588, -0.00409088097512722, -0.00402986491099, 0.009442356415092945, -0.04520295932888985, 0.049090515822172165, -0.0016619589878246188, 0.007299524266272783, -0.012610679492354393, -0.006939736194908619, -0.00753354886546731, 0.008604561910033226, -0.03291564807295799, 0.012154812924563885, 0.040158726274967194, 0.019335735589265823, -0.015148377977311611, 0.013282475993037224, -0.05934251472353935, -0.0023749247193336487, -0.04665412753820419, 0.0005068907048553228, -0.01737244613468647, 0.002261838875710964, 0.06297539174556732, 0.02776496112346649, 0.02412976510822773, 0.01155842188745737, -0.021704023703932762, -0.018097570165991783, 0.0048838104121387005, -0.005170529242604971, 0.022749274969100952, -0.021029068157076836, 0.03595002740621567, -0.04926937073469162, 0.004541678354144096, -0.026281757280230522, -0.04094421863555908, -0.009384597651660442, -0.0022910526022315025, -0.019026851281523705, -0.04489220306277275, -0.022185910493135452, -0.004480931907892227, 0.04784819856286049, -0.016729889437556267, 0.034110065549612045, -0.017000216990709305, 0.025408824905753136, -0.018425581976771355, 0.012461403384804726, 0.06888613849878311, -0.00571591779589653, -0.004508961923420429, 0.045463766902685165, 0.007695995271205902, -0.016030754894018173, -0.0018623452633619308, -0.05092952400445938, -0.016429303213953972, -0.00776115944609046, -0.01791733130812645, 0.016744449734687805, 0.04632853344082832, -0.011273329146206379, -0.0026252081152051687, 0.007975460030138493, -0.016922757029533386, 0.011544577777385712, -0.056700482964515686, 0.013779059052467346, 0.0007835165597498417, -0.006562225054949522, -0.036786384880542755, -0.037768326699733734, -0.014008884318172932, -0.013505685143172741, 0.028665324673056602, -0.004600289277732372, 0.006918111350387335, 0.018430348485708237, 0.06168436259031296, 0.026248367503285408, 0.01218267623335123, 0.034926436841487885, -0.0018236123723909259, 0.018764754757285118, 0.010271241888403893, 0.00572781078517437, -0.00921332836151123, 0.019966229796409607, -0.0033575573470443487, -0.02912767231464386, -0.01778513938188553, -0.021803807467222214, 0.05825703963637352, 0.03719603270292282, 0.052823301404714584, 0.032301027327775955, -0.009828032925724983, 0.03226102143526077, -0.03239140287041664, -0.005467940121889114, -0.0325738862156868, 0.052639733999967575, 0.017091456800699234, -0.000029562279451056384, -0.010112298652529716, 0.058465126901865005, 0.025160685181617737, 0.02443026751279831, 0.04461909458041191, 0.018095476552844048, -0.010348867624998093, 0.04259229078888893, -0.032942838966846466, -0.033433154225349426, 0.015531188808381557, -0.04742991924285889, 0.017204444855451584, -0.032574910670518875, -0.01746310293674469, 0.040076807141304016, 0.037896741181612015, -0.022473527118563652, -0.0416984036564827, -0.019392043352127075, -0.055776651948690414, 0.02572142705321312, 0.012574030086398125, -0.052444398403167725, 0.03297389671206474, 0.0004727190244011581, 0.03859740495681763, -0.0027333765756338835, 0.05851249024271965, -0.03895401954650879, -0.0906059741973877, 0.022723449394106865, -0.004336643032729626, -0.06318142265081406, 0.08946771919727325, 0.026156792417168617, -0.02452823705971241, -0.003388204611837864, -0.029499176889657974, 0.033241961151361465, 0.015267823822796345, 0.0205106008797884, -0.030125383287668228, 0.09070524573326111, -0.0013491286663338542, 0.006263210903853178, -0.000306585687212646, -0.02689267322421074, 0.1304832249879837, 0.05585906654596329, 0.0700809434056282, -0.049942802637815475, -0.02371630072593689, -0.009802005253732204, 0.038670361042022705, -0.017963893711566925, -0.029087895527482033, 0.009765185415744781, -0.011086949147284031, 0.060689106583595276, 0.04865722730755806, -0.0007673592772334814, 0.0061220345087349415, 0.04845312610268593, -0.012620274908840656, -0.0006069617811590433, -0.0003190487332176417, 0.022512389346957207, 0.04637765511870384, -0.003808858571574092, -0.039275478571653366, -0.009453498758375645, 0.020522478967905045, -0.04416866600513458, -0.013925697654485703, -0.006889576558023691, 0.022743744775652885, 0.010263263247907162, -0.02567136473953724, -0.029752319678664207, 0.0496947355568409, 0.012949841096997261, 0.012637480162084103, -0.02099713310599327, 0.0401838980615139, -0.025875233113765717, 0.03632921725511551, 0.016765860840678215, -0.005769792478531599, 0.010864147916436195, -0.011116627603769302, 0.017752472311258316, -0.04148036614060402, -0.008805266581475735, -0.0705866888165474, 0.040224261581897736, -0.03495814651250839, -0.031600285321474075, -0.009393713437020779, -0.0025779367424547672, 0.005117322783917189, -0.0513676255941391, -0.012098398990929127, -0.018933210521936417, 0.03593989089131355, -0.01750657707452774, 0.012864773161709309, -0.03903742879629135, 0.01778273843228817, -0.027361737564206123, 0.049228768795728683, 0.01003233715891838, -0.026464836671948433, -0.012666299939155579, -0.035738829523324966, 0.06828422844409943, 0.004750409163534641, -0.020057758316397667, -0.01916692405939102, 0.007487810216844082, -0.032046522945165634, 0.004949518945068121, 0.005451628938317299, -0.0029943124391138554, 0.018859252333641052, 0.022348325699567795, -0.01677294820547104, -0.024681847542524338, -0.023505598306655884, 0.01839638501405716, -0.028759600594639778, -0.017252357676625252, -0.04543600603938103, -0.028830235823988914, 0.024287089705467224, 0.03266559913754463, 0.06177358329296112, 0.007942619733512402, -0.013935077004134655, 0.08029002696275711, 0.028803132474422455, -0.03156594559550285, -0.006772794760763645, -0.032880932092666626, -0.026192331686615944, -0.0020447736606001854, -0.03513950854539871, 0.021543031558394432, -0.009373674169182777, 0.01683688350021839, 0.022726453840732574, -0.012792488560080528, -0.030332546681165695, -0.005068638827651739, 0.007228981703519821, -0.07781465351581573, -0.011901664547622204, 0.022137094289064407, 0.0001480928185628727, -0.05288320779800415, -0.010116228833794594, -0.04587508738040924, -0.03509993478655815, -0.004818562418222427, -0.021679941564798355, -0.06356590986251831, 0.01109031680971384, -0.021859612315893173, -0.0178618635982275, -0.024842368438839912, 0.001996274571865797, -0.012045019306242466, 0.015446714125573635, -0.021725989878177643, 0.014446261338889599, -0.006176033057272434, 0.02338629961013794, -0.0007719622808508575, 0.034074608236551285, 0.07320293039083481, 0.036467261612415314, 0.030970539897680283, -0.0061517697758972645, 0.00744660384953022, -0.013071464374661446, -0.007986634038388729, -0.03282538056373596, -0.025255603715777397, 0.04370231553912163, -0.03381716459989548, -0.04017258435487747, -0.0008040712564252317, 0.009815302677452564, -0.0012742552207782865, -0.030025126412510872, -0.042289845645427704, -0.0036621305625885725, 0.06063201650977135, -0.024205129593610764, -0.016672903671860695, -0.01926800236105919, 0.02737550251185894, 0.02165978215634823, 0.01581883244216442, 0.02287750318646431, 0.003038939321413636, -0.022348197177052498, 0.02879885397851467, 0.04160616174340248, -0.020271804183721542, 0.010013165883719921, 0.01214930322021246, -0.01847732812166214, -0.013505595736205578, -0.02463076077401638, -0.03924722969532013, 0.006505263969302177, 0.061257850378751755, -0.014391997829079628, 0.04281133413314819, 0.0041791340336203575, 0.001049263053573668, -0.09157031029462814, -0.007641846779733896, 0.022721031680703163, 0.0006531468243338168, 0.042819537222385406, -0.033746909350156784, -0.015137551352381706, 0.00913661066442728, -0.07580249011516571, 0.017700733616948128, -0.002234111540019512, -0.010491838678717613, -0.061285413801670074, 0.024828022345900536, -0.010226949118077755, 0.0339994803071022, 0.01634141430258751, 0.011799105443060398, 0.07328420132398605, 0.03422503545880318, -0.0047858357429504395, -0.005723161157220602, 0.007064029574394226, 0.027807699516415596, 0.01624041423201561, -0.03197005018591881, 0.02236752398312092, -0.0210354533046484, -0.02498747780919075, 0.006125277373939753, 0.029306087642908096, 0.06099323183298111, 0.0032446631230413914, 0.0444059856235981, -0.00653824070468545, 0.03640966862440109, 0.05476254224777222, -0.010676605626940727, -0.00351098645478487, -0.02747860737144947, 0.026051180437207222, 0.00026529317256063223, -0.015106191858649254, 0.025080012157559395, 0.024028318002820015, 0.012965860776603222, -0.0000959154567681253, 0.0336465910077095, -0.007456210907548666, -0.007465630304068327, 0.014521440491080284, 0.015188326127827168, 0.021051740273833275, 0.023655718192458153, 0.029142849147319794, -0.049814749509096146, -0.0009749280870892107, 0.05110599100589752, 0.05203327164053917, -0.02841917984187603, 0.007293448783457279, -0.00369030493311584, -0.03182358294725418, -0.01387084648013115, -0.021424267441034317, 0.010918596759438515, -0.06509748101234436, -0.0038456006441265345, -0.019664283841848373, 0.002509873826056719, -0.042219098657369614, 0.003700320143252611, 0.029343273490667343, 0.03208375722169876, -0.014568114653229713, 0.002550604986026883, -0.014202255755662918, -0.007266666740179062, 0.05056515708565712, -0.07965023070573807, 0.04504625126719475, -0.0010615569772198796, -0.014038940891623497, -0.06302529573440552, 0.0175014641135931, -0.03327763080596924, 0.010805407539010048, 0.05942637473344803, -0.023740261793136597, 0.0237427968531847, -0.034486766904592514, 0.03417159244418144, -0.0034027297515422106, -0.03752067685127258, 0.06626718491315842, -0.04090036824345589, -0.006246599368751049, 0.000901176652405411, 0.022045616060495377, 0.03467598930001259, -0.03475622460246086, 0.0030657933093607426, -0.02376997284591198, -0.023140251636505127, 0.026641644537448883, -0.05042130872607231, 0.049816787242889404, -0.005103613715618849, -0.013368107378482819, 0.014095624908804893, -0.021416151896119118, 0.013559618033468723, 0.02544381655752659, 0.006250838283449411, -0.02084970660507679, 0.05799756571650505, -0.04213443771004677, -0.04454399272799492, 0.01593269221484661, 0.022640304639935493, -0.035592831671237946, -0.003875765949487686, 0.002183387288823724, 0.023577995598316193, -0.013488151133060455, -0.014721816405653954, 0.004634741693735123, -0.007472387980669737, 0.05043793097138405, 0.014302688650786877, 0.015510880388319492, -0.027356039732694626, 0.0029305333737283945, -0.007309837266802788, -0.011633197776973248, 0.03524807468056679, -0.041821591556072235, -0.002105766674503684, 0.03226303681731224, -0.0334557443857193, 0.03709802031517029, 0.0170586034655571, 0.03366023674607277, -0.010391820222139359, 0.010787724517285824, 0.032730694860219955, 0.0021180161274969578, -0.009388246573507786, 0.014067680574953556, -0.013299813494086266, 0.03690166771411896, -0.036798685789108276, 0.006673375144600868, -0.03376458212733269, -0.025306308642029762, -0.0054397606290876865, 0.02821134403347969, -0.030318519100546837, -0.010269786231219769, -0.015207278542220592, 0.03960779681801796, 0.0017412888118997216, 0.011188752949237823, 0.06812839955091476, -0.02814106084406376, 0.024019328877329826, -0.0036260720808058977, 0.03202961012721062, 0.035741984844207764, 0.021412018686532974, -0.03830745071172714, -0.020962990820407867, 0.028514323756098747, 0.04006105661392212, -0.00973832793533802, -0.07632733881473541, -0.014783262275159359, 0.033922791481018066, 0.06107933074235916, -0.0425635389983654, -0.023258857429027557, -0.046236198395490646, 0.045501161366701126, 0.020057210698723793, 0.004788255784660578 ]
<p>I am trying to generate confidence intervals for estimates of numbers of fish observed with a very small number of surveys. Most of the numbers of fish observed are very small as well. The estimate is based upon the ratio of the number of adult fish and redds (fish nests) observed during the observation season.</p> <p>example</p> <p>estimate 12.5 fish</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/XxcC7.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>Thanks for the help.</p>
74,268
[ -0.014340383000671864, -0.027026847004890442, 0.00018296189955435693, 0.021138695999979973, -0.0022402387112379074, -0.00784268043935299, -0.019191177561879158, -0.020393481478095055, 0.02845466136932373, -0.024624446406960487, 0.05877386033535004, 0.06794988363981247, -0.00142553704790771, 0.030279502272605896, 0.016902213916182518, 0.018866926431655884, -0.010845364071428776, 0.013105406425893307, 0.03158991411328316, -0.016556695103645325, 0.006091696675866842, 0.02381516993045807, 0.03133174404501915, -0.02497754991054535, -0.006211829837411642, 0.032402124255895615, 0.03555678203701973, -0.008686749264597893, 0.0034027574583888054, 0.056905269622802734, -0.04370721057057381, -0.07184632867574692, 0.0076710982248187065, 0.06713791936635971, 0.011812101118266582, 0.006693579256534576, -0.019271614030003548, -0.03549960255622864, 0.004744370933622122, 0.017071852460503578, -0.03616984561085701, 0.009404243901371956, 0.027000192552804947, -0.012537222355604172, 0.0017557874089106917, 0.012352514080703259, 0.0032001188956201077, -0.06240049749612808, 0.010954617522656918, -0.019114376977086067, 0.06081639975309372, 0.03466256707906723, 0.05395442992448807, 0.020549330860376358, -0.02173602022230625, 0.03000449761748314, 0.018416063860058784, 0.0993141308426857, -0.019934240728616714, -0.038773443549871445, 0.015916405245661736, -0.038922399282455444, -0.0177745558321476, -0.012018974870443344, -0.020208094269037247, 0.025676997378468513, -0.011640811339020729, -0.0009218810591846704, 0.025413360446691513, -0.008743470534682274, 0.030823716893792152, -0.008028816431760788, 0.040271081030368805, -0.00025430109235458076, -0.009310685098171234, -0.03807838261127472, 0.01444227620959282, 0.0215835552662611, 0.0306865181773901, 0.03465990722179413, -0.005363724660128355, 0.030954008921980858, 0.01632619835436344, 0.026153942570090294, 0.042805466800928116, -0.011264163069427013, 0.05758834630250931, -0.01668493263423443, 0.021829672157764435, 0.017192624509334564, -0.00314280204474926, -0.003588247811421752, 0.05313195288181305, 0.012148141860961914, -0.02195199765264988, 0.03864455223083496, -0.009685945697128773, 0.04333961009979248, -0.04467003419995308, -0.02514464780688286, 0.00945636909455061, -0.030754823237657547, 0.02073843590915203, 0.026505418121814728, -0.049885060638189316, -0.010934543795883656, -0.023108407855033875, -0.017328692600131035, -0.03128810226917267, -0.04221387580037117, 0.021202407777309418, 0.04723816737532616, 0.016494063660502434, 0.012407428584992886, -0.0012720257509499788, -0.030009247362613678, -0.008223024196922779, -0.00354573130607605, 0.034503065049648285, 0.010181067511439323, 0.027552997693419456, -0.02398628182709217, 0.029782341793179512, -0.02790294587612152, -0.05017837882041931, 0.010319790802896023, -0.00663808872923255, -0.007329500745981932, -0.03690560907125473, 0.07351929694414139, -0.0414370596408844, -0.01691030152142048, 0.05641881003975868, 0.028216347098350525, 0.045408058911561966, -0.01988178864121437, -0.060880616307258606, -0.07249251753091812, 0.013620580546557903, -0.02918832004070282, 0.01522302906960249, -0.06454784423112869, 0.05222101882100105, 0.03723733127117157, 0.008065471425652504, -0.006880699656903744, 0.03096049651503563, 0.01777457259595394, 0.00956724863499403, -0.012677437625825405, -0.008476754650473595, -0.011655150912702084, -0.005733344238251448, 0.010762277990579605, -0.019331710413098335, -0.048084765672683716, 0.035994499921798706, -0.008349809795618057, 0.00018463691230863333, -0.008814734406769276, 0.023716220632195473, 0.026380939409136772, -0.03891146928071976, 0.004329879768192768, 0.04180002957582474, -0.045267123728990555, 0.08632225543260574, -0.015725361183285713, -0.01007769349962473, 0.011981260031461716, 0.0030111561063677073, -0.01857032999396324, 0.014570134691894054, 0.024827755987644196, 0.062429409474134445, -0.033325668424367905, -0.005443916656076908, -0.016819026321172714, 0.009219522587954998, 0.04196998476982117, -0.03289191052317619, -0.019224386662244797, 0.0036272366996854544, -0.00984895695000887, 0.07646932452917099, 0.015840847045183182, 0.013156036846339703, -0.044884730130434036, 0.013857421465218067, -0.053851883858442307, -0.020411517471075058, -0.06581180542707443, -0.011738939210772514, -0.0015569524839520454, -0.00324054597876966, -0.027966883033514023, -0.003744868328794837, -0.006582953501492739, -0.009470207616686821, -0.03853046894073486, -0.04211141914129257, 0.004504911135882139, 0.0354645699262619, -0.05121292546391487, -0.003146896604448557, 0.058057382702827454, 0.04349306598305702, -0.016444774344563484, 0.06785169988870621, -0.028942404314875603, -0.028743546456098557, -0.016616392880678177, -0.04801752790808678, -0.004985176958143711, 0.02964620292186737, -0.014083870686590672, 0.02540595643222332, 0.001643605064600706, -0.028687940910458565, 0.018735753372311592, -0.019493605941534042, 0.049785371869802475, 0.019130738452076912, 0.0015230021672323346, 0.001652510603889823, -0.010500578209757805, 0.020502472296357155, 0.028264231979846954, -0.042891182005405426, 0.004569242242723703, -0.09500031918287277, 0.05070279911160469, 0.049646664410829544, 0.0034736969973891973, -0.027419209480285645, 0.029317641630768776, 0.0960087776184082, -0.00007832331903045997, -0.004783262498676777, 0.051370151340961456, -0.00661455886438489, 0.0037030447274446487, 0.015239874832332134, 0.04233330860733986, 0.033445969223976135, 0.008049647323787212, 0.010217826813459396, 0.013014989905059338, 0.05032339692115784, 0.016503548249602318, 0.008111358620226383, 0.048296719789505005, 0.0024918299168348312, 0.0017113129142671824, -0.01629016362130642, -0.0011279169702902436, 0.04598260298371315, -0.034210413694381714, -0.011379396542906761, 0.03125815838575363, 0.015874292701482773, 0.01747692935168743, 0.013142511248588562, -0.0011153514496982098, 0.02239999920129776, 0.023588933050632477, -0.06556740403175354, 0.002120629185810685, 0.003167008748278022, -0.019319184124469757, 0.00964287482202053, -0.053118906915187836, -0.0357154943048954, -0.03570860996842384, -0.013896752148866653, 0.04179751127958298, -0.02469940111041069, 0.045519012957811356, -0.003948163241147995, -0.0011327324900776148, 0.0007132433238439262, 0.007021041586995125, 0.02159132994711399, 0.00255371630191803, -0.053551893681287766, -0.0371064618229866, -0.00043103285133838654, -0.03273480013012886, 0.008411930873990059, 0.006079744081944227, -0.030924508348107338, 0.03133348748087883, 0.000881480926182121, -0.030727826058864594, -0.02580641582608223, -0.022078130394220352, 0.007259530480951071, -0.029768502339720726, -0.00223388709127903, 0.0466579832136631, 0.01000158954411745, -0.00818267185240984, 0.015867704525589943, -0.04066234081983566, 0.002579720690846443, -0.058064308017492294, 0.00651438208296895, 0.004508285317569971, -0.006209750659763813, -0.0028346111066639423, 0.021946994587779045, 0.015696780756115913, -0.006023740861564875, -0.07709193229675293, -0.04708826541900635, 0.005074476823210716, 0.04478757083415985, 0.04363102465867996, -0.0031876203138381243, -0.019611675292253494, 0.070490762591362, 0.006159786134958267, -0.041921790689229965, -0.026318738237023354, -0.00048626275383867323, -0.043839577585458755, -0.015673493966460228, -0.001520320656709373, 0.007763801142573357, -0.03522977977991104, 0.018523065373301506, -0.0011511575430631638, 0.01677415706217289, 0.023219989612698555, -0.01906733587384224, 0.01975599117577076, 0.01219455897808075, 0.0237937793135643, 0.008482413366436958, 0.06938029825687408, 0.019820107147097588, -0.009095232002437115, 0.004036043304949999, -0.0523131787776947, 0.006718709133565426, 0.01719243824481964, -0.07445357739925385, -0.019770363345742226, -0.036282047629356384, -0.006657757330685854, -0.0230372566729784, 0.031089236959815025, 0.04784277081489563, -0.008964297361671925, -0.017914922907948494, -0.0016491796122863889, 0.06871891766786575, -0.019486814737319946, -0.03509585186839104, 0.05926055461168289, 0.021452676504850388, -0.001349054742604494, 0.008972769603133202, -0.020094837993383408, -0.006425153464078903, 0.0013203523121774197, -0.01134602352976799, 0.00875952746719122, 0.04915512725710869, 0.07079042494297028, 0.005478987470269203, -0.01819973811507225, -0.05223378166556358, 0.028938254341483116, -0.07254400849342346, -0.00146727345418185, -0.0072969961911439896, 0.05053170397877693, -0.004865177907049656, 0.06568130850791931, 0.0259287990629673, -0.019684575498104095, 0.04482368379831314, 0.013278109021484852, -0.06161890923976898, 0.011271447874605656, 0.00544335413724184, -0.021363958716392517, 0.01895817555487156, -0.04812292754650116, 0.023644015192985535, -0.0246726181358099, 0.006264073774218559, -0.008956820704042912, -0.0013400360476225615, -0.02572646178305149, 0.023177500814199448, -0.004462753422558308, 0.011561278253793716, -0.0003449000068940222, -0.0023232323583215475, -0.007328977808356285, -0.02770429663360119, 0.021695831790566444, 0.019984597340226173, 0.024086013436317444, -0.03452451154589653, -0.03592006489634514, 0.0039623999036848545, 0.03067092038691044, 0.024143418297171593, 0.04214800149202347, 0.05044213682413101, -0.05724535509943962, 0.023208683356642723, -0.029261868447065353, 0.04607870802283287, 0.026694627478718758, 0.004447967279702425, -0.015952041372656822, -0.033968400210142136, 0.03296376019716263, 0.03260749951004982, 0.010641137138009071, -0.031354378908872604, -0.0021008960902690887, 0.058530792593955994, 0.006446726620197296, -0.03868156298995018, 0.0028388744685798883, 0.04081655293703079, 0.017537105828523636, 0.02347995713353157, -0.029272248968482018, 0.005642061121761799, -0.016917850822210312, -0.01640813611447811, 0.021671369671821594, 0.04921295866370201, 0.03573954850435257, 0.0028792794328182936, 0.051531512290239334, -0.02797802723944187, -0.019549338147044182, 0.00401937635615468, -0.019260698929429054, 0.045658692717552185, -0.012057313695549965, -0.014720235019922256, 0.034865036606788635, 0.014004972763359547, 0.05955660715699196, -0.0019529659766703844, 0.02022717148065567, -0.1012851893901825, 0.011288403533399105, 0.060832709074020386, 0.029001208022236824, -0.026589764282107353, -0.00921466201543808, -0.06587439030408859, -0.013136704452335835, 0.03471054881811142, -0.06245553493499756, 0.0016525026876479387, -0.02906612679362297, -0.015651946887373924, 0.030538024380803108, -0.016748784109950066, -0.021910343319177628, -0.009281070902943611, -0.04614666849374771, 0.009620684199035168, -0.03353891894221306, -0.022793378680944443, -0.026939457282423973, 0.01750004291534424, 0.056352779269218445, 0.06577791273593903, -0.02563691884279251, -0.025036687031388283, 0.008930005133152008, 0.006745147984474897, -0.041409291326999664, -0.01506860088557005, 0.03866293653845787, 0.0010564248077571392, 0.025266133248806, 0.028922468423843384, -0.011800353415310383, -0.028848448768258095, 0.012050887569785118, 0.010955910198390484, -0.05006486922502518, -0.01935274712741375, -0.03290219232439995, -0.003695145482197404, 0.030533993616700172, 0.034318629652261734, 0.08062915503978729, 0.046428512781858444, -0.0165378600358963, 0.003981931135058403, -0.05994172394275665, 0.008318381384015083, -0.015760282054543495, -0.0476178303360939, -0.02659178338944912, 0.010635792277753353, -0.01313608419150114, -0.021898850798606873, -0.007493406999856234, 0.01369751151651144, -0.0038353700656443834, -0.008343376219272614, 0.03183726593852043, 0.023773690685629845, 0.017750529572367668, 0.019669968634843826, -0.01601274497807026, 0.01330494973808527, -0.005881012417376041, -0.013927949592471123, 0.019799018278717995, -0.015770146623253822, -0.0025240581016987562, -0.011767695657908916, -0.06764551997184753, 0.012903635390102863, -0.03582152724266052, -0.034841716289520264, 0.027819396927952766, -0.05749893561005592, 0.019995734095573425, -0.05701455473899841, 0.0050641018897295, -0.009490122087299824, -0.03518751263618469, -0.020590921863913536, 0.003907637670636177, -0.001728166127577424, 0.048801079392433167, -0.023371772840619087, 0.03897141292691231, 0.014416747726500034, -0.008382648229598999, -0.060925111174583435, -0.06294918060302734, 0.04840070381760597, 0.05711188167333603, -0.016019828617572784, -0.042502906173467636, -0.031198065727949142, 0.016334034502506256, -0.006612286437302828, -0.031913235783576965, 0.030723517760634422, -0.03748239949345589, -0.013822694309055805, -0.02393886260688305, 0.030043654143810272, 0.03713654354214668, -0.0006712076719850302, 0.03445272892713547, 0.0417325384914875, -0.059969570487737656, -0.03736400976777077, -0.0015918625285848975, -0.009392909705638885, -0.027107127010822296, -0.023223595693707466, -0.02853902243077755, 0.020784346386790276, 0.04720282554626465, -0.00782689731568098, -0.0025107425171881914, 0.0048177409917116165, 0.04418186843395233, 0.02277033030986786, -0.02955860085785389, -0.012565645389258862, -0.031195374205708504, -0.012258277274668217, -0.052703607827425, 0.033373698592185974, -0.0292145237326622, -0.000355276046320796, 0.02083713561296463, -0.019168734550476074, 0.013179803267121315, -0.011704848147928715, 0.08749384433031082, -0.02928316965699196, 0.004963746760040522, 0.008942829445004463, -0.009595032781362534, -0.000489922589622438, 0.012514444999396801, 0.015351828187704086, 0.03709123283624649, 0.03563075512647629, -0.04682084918022156, -0.005700039677321911, -0.03434297442436218, -0.007419725880026817, 0.05932018905878067, -0.02227422595024109, 0.06325756758451462, 0.011712132953107357, -0.004202651791274548, 0.0218519140034914, -0.013148361817002296, -0.01960640773177147, -0.007495368830859661, 0.00489400327205658, 0.07042407989501953, -0.010886579751968384, -0.015046507120132446, 0.011266111396253109, 0.013516436330974102, 0.052852973341941833, 0.07327262312173843, 0.015603190287947655, 0.023645464330911636, -0.025907743722200394, -0.015071514062583447, -0.027666408568620682, 0.004803805612027645, -0.04542864114046097, 0.019486455246806145, -0.038401611149311066, 0.0028168372809886932, 0.06784319877624512, 0.021309323608875275, -0.01431258860975504, -0.01632077619433403, -0.014510003849864006, 0.0012913427781313658, 0.038078200072050095, -0.013703538104891777, 0.010727453045547009, 0.008170079439878464, 0.03586830571293831, 0.015435285866260529, -0.04422737658023834, 0.049363456666469574, -0.06530340760946274, -0.06523195654153824, 0.016402870416641235, -0.04783043637871742, -0.05284285172820091, 0.03569749742746353, 0.007205173838883638, -0.00863934587687254, 0.019109899178147316, 0.025101790204644203, -0.003503169398754835, 0.012904632836580276, 0.01872725412249565, -0.01965283788740635, 0.07773327082395554, 0.06021568179130554, 0.010669396258890629, 0.009912045672535896, -0.006353321950882673, 0.12383348494768143, 0.07794952392578125, 0.018854137510061264, -0.0645977035164833, 0.011066948994994164, 0.015684230253100395, 0.0016260301927104592, 0.0038255034014582634, -0.016187867149710655, 0.01001622062176466, -0.016415338963270187, 0.03523637726902962, 0.026952169835567474, -0.017452610656619072, -0.03316681087017059, 0.04907618463039398, 0.009556770324707031, -0.027536431327462196, -0.009022710844874382, 0.009514694102108479, -0.0009019774151965976, -0.014385613612830639, -0.03738046810030937, 0.007975572720170021, 0.010812083259224892, 0.007640097755938768, -0.019892601296305656, -0.03775430843234062, -0.024510573595762253, 0.010692785494029522, -0.060536712408065796, 0.0018912975210696459, 0.025976359844207764, -0.0012287684949114919, -0.0003782755811698735, -0.037930458784103394, 0.02789703942835331, -0.006395156495273113, -0.021630510687828064, 0.03183244541287422, -0.013052905909717083, 0.017606856301426888, -0.020882243290543556, 0.035711321979761124, -0.03667864203453064, -0.03959835693240166, -0.05456702038645744, 0.06619288772344589, -0.011283308267593384, -0.0002221985487267375, -0.04701066017150879, 0.0005706506199203432, -0.0319356694817543, -0.0422508642077446, 0.010628467425704002, 0.015638256445527077, 0.0018276238115504384, -0.03877779468894005, -0.06922636181116104, -0.04470466822385788, 0.02603721246123314, -0.02880757302045822, 0.009314063936471939, 0.07258245348930359, -0.031166283413767815, -0.022974515333771706, -0.04052022472023964, 0.050123181194067, 0.011422639712691307, 0.029250646010041237, 0.030612654983997345, -0.02717003785073757, -0.0031848049256950617, -0.008681333623826504, -0.00833139754831791, -0.0064107817597687244, 0.04252839833498001, -0.025351466611027718, 0.003790860762819648, 0.009566005319356918, -0.06411247700452805, 0.015821481123566628, -0.016855385154485703, -0.03288848698139191, -0.04284331202507019, -0.0022161256056278944, -0.005801133345812559, 0.02296190895140171, -0.009784086607396603, 0.04478704184293747, -0.017342839390039444, 0.027121055871248245, 0.013869423419237137, -0.05372500419616699, -0.044034045189619064, -0.010473077185451984, -0.033441971987485886, -0.02043839357793331, -0.0032722593750804663, 0.027453497052192688, 0.023482050746679306, 0.014271652325987816, 0.030856242403388023, -0.0015040149446576834, 0.015678327530622482, 0.020773688331246376, -0.017114683985710144, -0.044746968895196915, 0.005270764697343111, -0.008218294940888882, -0.00516866659745574, -0.034523483365774155, 0.020685508847236633, -0.03482517600059509, -0.04066920280456543, 0.021648896858096123, -0.031086621806025505, -0.07467784732580185, 0.008189800195395947, -0.02636675164103508, 0.009778972715139389, 0.027794521301984787, -0.004722381476312876, -0.04767994210124016, -0.0431838296353817, -0.00995300617069006, 0.001695278799161315, -0.020005352795124054, 0.006681513506919146, -0.028117245063185692, -0.00399970356374979, 0.05936489626765251, -0.020740998908877373, 0.021764712408185005, 0.032203588634729385, 0.03906175121665001, 0.020614242181181908, 0.05071674659848213, -0.028530936688184738, -0.04312129691243172, 0.012695522047579288, -0.05119454860687256, 0.006369725801050663, 0.0083632105961442, 0.005301847588270903, 0.05732077732682228, 0.023899827152490616, -0.011633808724582195, -0.030663369223475456, 0.026944315060973167, -0.008060207590460777, -0.00402448233217001, -0.03296452760696411, 0.024414416402578354, 0.0425589345395565, 0.0013627849984914064, -0.0025822266470640898, 0.009807545691728592, -0.02208181843161583, 0.0014849260915070772, 0.029013095423579216, -0.0032552515622228384, -0.01878010854125023, 0.018792591989040375, 0.026115339249372482, 0.003187379101291299, 0.011552452109754086, 0.010828440077602863, 0.005128823686391115, 0.03617849200963974, -0.04054352268576622, 0.04328024387359619, -0.02111060731112957, -0.004005073104053736, -0.05892037972807884, -0.002271199831739068, -0.03386397659778595, 0.00667685316875577, 0.010683149099349976, -0.04226859658956528, 0.00420103594660759, 0.04585669934749603, -0.012834442779421806, 0.015808425843715668, -0.0025767702609300613, -0.005295888986438513, -0.029831713065505028, -0.025652792304754257, 0.0007109753787517548, -0.005529613234102726, 0.016512177884578705, 0.011268828064203262, 0.027756962925195694, 0.024434734135866165, -0.0043844496831297874, -0.05184321850538254, -0.045199476182460785, 0.02167086862027645, 0.05185608193278313, -0.05395263060927391, 0.0019166517304256558, -0.020824531093239784, 0.016197962686419487, 0.03529714047908783, 0.0006046989583410323, 0.0239415243268013, 0.03855302184820175, 0.04320836067199707, -0.003733104793354869, 0.04872962459921837, 0.03428744897246361, 0.009522084146738052, -0.01304219476878643, 0.001291818916797638, 0.0017460845410823822, -0.004786168225109577, -0.010193984024226665, 0.016826480627059937, 0.06739368289709091, -0.023957649245858192, -0.02703201025724411, 0.05367514118552208, -0.023520711809396744, 0.017945079132914543, 0.024919424206018448, -0.018014276400208473, -0.008174832910299301, -0.040464431047439575, 0.018535198643803596, -0.024752940982580185, 0.037117499858140945, 0.039289690554142, 0.0024380723480135202, -0.041294097900390625, -0.004589346703141928, 0.010738005861639977, -0.003733285004273057, -0.035791803151369095, -0.008528223261237144, 0.0007843960192985833, -0.053985677659511566, 0.023324131965637207, 0.02387245185673237, 0.03560267388820648, -0.0036920420825481415, 0.0325450636446476, -0.062173765152692795, 0.07076981663703918, 0.0057977912947535515, -0.02331516519188881, 0.013410847634077072, 0.010626740753650665, -0.00889021810144186, -0.07224500179290771, 0.06600247323513031, 0.016929704695940018, -0.02520349994301796, -0.028171541169285774, -0.00696684792637825, -0.013299103826284409, 0.003947453107684851, 0.04220237955451012, 0.016151487827301025, 0.004241215065121651, 0.00892926100641489, 0.04215381294488907, 0.010044020600616932, -0.05987124517560005, 0.06389836221933365, -0.02303660847246647, -0.013714982196688652, -0.0029160939157009125, -0.02106749638915062, 0.013852445408701897, -0.001522333943285048, -0.007425455376505852, 0.013094468973577023, 0.026773355901241302, 0.006881233770400286, -0.01548937801271677, 0.02161058597266674, -0.013794810511171818, -0.003779871156439185, 0.03319749981164932, -0.010247471742331982, -0.018776893615722656, -0.01142768282443285, 0.027352960780262947, -0.0449008084833622, 0.025015387684106827, -0.06429808586835861, -0.002434548456221819, -0.0073687974363565445, -0.0027461976278573275, 0.003515724092721939, -0.07939397543668747, 0.003889158135280013, -0.0030844255816191435, -0.037426404654979706, -0.020813006907701492, 0.03725650906562805, 0.002919914899393916, 0.04598166048526764, -0.04194111377000809, 0.04068072512745857, 0.009210293181240559, -0.049580734223127365, 0.00839936826378107, 0.022281484678387642, -0.01171846129000187, -0.036058202385902405, 0.038808323442935944, 0.037796501070261, 0.004513786174356937, 0.06449368596076965, 0.004513352178037167, 0.02689938247203827, 0.003831958631053567, -0.03385220840573311, 0.028701618313789368, -0.02741006389260292, 0.02149275504052639, 0.030423590913414955, -0.015360317192971706, 0.046504803001880646, -0.00912804901599884, -0.0075113968923687935, -0.0421319454908371, -0.017044655978679657, -0.012690817005932331, -0.0007435851730406284, 0.005200018174946308, 0.0028766505420207977, 0.009907170198857784, 0.04443492367863655, 0.007038272451609373, 0.011814625933766365, 0.03308805078268051, -0.029595525935292244, 0.01641141064465046, 0.011798573657870293, -0.008548500016331673, -0.016850369051098824, 0.0061952052637934685, 0.017032941803336143, -0.013769744895398617, 0.027145523577928543, 0.04514695703983307, -0.010433733463287354, -0.02098482847213745, -0.037975382059812546, -0.0002468903549015522, 0.021238209679722786, -0.061454083770513535, -0.030634958297014236, -0.04273378476500511, -0.011166094802320004, 0.0018210666021332145, -0.05700765177607536 ]
<p>Could you please shed some lights about how to interpret linear regresssion results (2-stage vs. 1 stage)?</p> <p>For example, I have the following:</p> <pre><code>lmStage1 &lt;- lm(y~x1) lmStage2 &lt;- lm(residuals(lmStage1)~x2) summary(lmStage2) </code></pre> <p>vs.</p> <pre><code>lmAll &lt;- lm(y~x1+x2) summary(lmAll) </code></pre> <hr> <p>How do I interpret and compare the coefficients/t-stats, etc. of the above two models?</p> <p>And how do I compare the two approaches and what observations/diagnosis/studies shall I draw from the above two models?</p> <p>In general, I feel that I am quite weak in drawing observations and obtaining intuitions from regression studies... are there books focusing on these interpretations and intuitions?</p> <p>Thanks a lot!</p>
74,269
[ -0.021499859169125557, -0.011625786311924458, -0.027560744434595108, 0.020482908934354782, 0.006051342934370041, 0.012844894081354141, -0.001077291090041399, -0.03496132418513298, 0.033823203295469284, -0.002489076228812337, 0.025128010660409927, 0.033759988844394684, 0.04102493077516556, -0.004704947583377361, 0.020718500018119812, 0.02772321179509163, 0.006617150269448757, -0.009739171713590622, -0.01468911487609148, 0.01396033726632595, 0.0040897186845541, -0.002573637757450342, -0.004552529659122229, 0.01647225022315979, -0.03779366984963417, 0.05684947595000267, 0.026827244088053703, 0.013664011843502522, 0.003039090195670724, 0.04047706723213196, -0.009217826649546623, -0.009233001619577408, -0.03163381665945053, 0.002796824788674712, -0.010734391398727894, -0.037857674062252045, -0.011141765862703323, -0.030614573508501053, 0.0033921885769814253, 0.043724216520786285, -0.016970748081803322, -0.0236368291079998, -0.021853776648640633, 0.03223765641450882, -0.006842603906989098, 0.003901482792571187, -0.018184732645750046, -0.02407345548272133, 0.04003371298313141, -0.04751580208539963, 0.07792593538761139, 0.01950973831117153, 0.033028632402420044, 0.03163130208849907, -0.01441072579473257, 0.019295357167720795, 0.04225572198629379, 0.07099104672670364, 0.0031133368611335754, -0.05211704969406128, -0.006144884042441845, -0.012601629830896854, 0.00924708042293787, 0.016059454530477524, -0.042304281145334244, 0.010775932110846043, 0.008864492177963257, -0.016494864597916603, 0.041911531239748, -0.013657107017934322, 0.017430465668439865, 0.004978046752512455, 0.02773662842810154, -0.013756693340837955, 0.02117365226149559, -0.0032485616393387318, 0.01365608349442482, -0.000027395608412916772, 0.04637596383690834, 0.036353226751089096, 0.01240788958966732, 0.007570635061711073, 0.034289389848709106, 0.03206772357225418, 0.0011962630087509751, -0.003427420975640416, 0.08326923102140427, 0.007792579475790262, 0.025108175352215767, 0.03492673113942146, -0.019879817962646484, -0.013266850262880325, 0.04750343784689903, 0.011863749474287033, -0.037450745701789856, 0.03346000984311104, -0.036088526248931885, 0.034036699682474136, 0.027516020461916924, 0.007955490611493587, -0.023112494498491287, -0.008611494675278664, 0.0352928526699543, 0.01151049043983221, -0.0293403510004282, -0.018298177048563957, -0.02351267635822296, 0.036811791360378265, -0.006823995150625706, -0.04314708337187767, 0.020322278141975403, 0.040411341935396194, 0.013958027586340904, 0.013738230802118778, 0.033225081861019135, -0.02823493629693985, -0.028236228972673416, 0.011912533082067966, 0.037354905158281326, 0.06545031070709229, 0.04523079842329025, -0.032602086663246155, 0.019787218421697617, 0.028040720149874687, -0.034716300666332245, 0.008232231251895428, 0.011314239352941513, -0.03273101523518562, -0.013147509656846523, 0.06284305453300476, -0.0005531008937396109, -0.030605565756559372, 0.017060661688447, 0.013263069093227386, 0.04768441244959831, 0.009426718577742577, -0.07587241381406784, -0.07685636729001999, 0.0413849800825119, 0.00847627967596054, 0.0039910790510475636, 0.0006398473051376641, 0.0010483077494427562, 0.027585148811340332, 0.07748310267925262, 0.0002039129176409915, 0.02603696472942829, 0.0019168202998116612, -0.0042818402871489525, 0.017650341615080833, -0.04406052455306053, -0.01109399925917387, -0.03170020133256912, -0.021906664595007896, -0.0029969571623951197, -0.08562778681516647, 0.004469012375921011, 0.05253840237855911, -0.009050663560628891, -0.005726619157940149, 0.03826155886054039, 0.006875848863273859, -0.01388427522033453, 0.00954250618815422, 0.0059266118332743645, 0.012228203937411308, 0.07648193836212158, -0.01242357213050127, 0.040280893445014954, 0.053463347256183624, 0.014045197516679764, 0.016283651813864708, 0.011602542363107204, 0.05003475770354271, 0.007502638269215822, -0.004774409346282482, -0.01701669581234455, -0.01975354179739952, -0.006160412915050983, 0.003313025226816535, -0.04984666779637337, -0.03488832339644432, -0.04301214963197708, -0.02853860892355442, -0.008038626052439213, 0.05314602702856064, -0.019412811845541, -0.01314846146851778, 0.04618877172470093, -0.03421708568930626, -0.05014171451330185, -0.062068626284599304, -0.006030167918652296, -0.01893668994307518, -0.00683909747749567, 0.029091572389006615, -0.005894412752240896, 0.03898370638489723, -0.022635549306869507, -0.014804663136601448, -0.01404433511197567, 0.008067079819738865, 0.03108382597565651, 0.0020229301881045103, -0.008092572912573814, 0.04641320928931236, 0.028883501887321472, -0.009485644288361073, 0.03359616547822952, -0.0844217836856842, -0.023107193410396576, 0.06300012022256851, -0.028093984350562096, 0.01212493609637022, -0.013058659620583057, -0.008118385449051857, 0.016550101339817047, 0.004564487840980291, -0.03950362652540207, 0.04646195471286774, -0.09074532240629196, 0.054452233016490936, 0.07363180816173553, 0.0366072803735733, -0.016998035833239555, 0.019492682069540024, -0.02802268974483013, 0.014238907024264336, -0.04624854400753975, -0.002978299045935273, -0.017309099435806274, -0.04105667024850845, 0.033469509333372116, -0.01651175320148468, 0.0006398223340511322, 0.03740594536066055, 0.0409829318523407, -0.006336826831102371, 0.02052128314971924, 0.028456810861825943, -0.008194857276976109, -0.01835445687174797, -0.032064616680145264, 0.011370603926479816, -0.00452258437871933, 0.00010789982479764149, 0.028312532231211662, -0.01611850969493389, 0.02723020873963833, 0.03553599864244461, 0.0029912616591900587, 0.06424475461244583, -0.02856576070189476, -0.004790299106389284, -0.023692859336733818, -0.06271693110466003, 0.051023442298173904, -0.011599930003285408, -0.012213943526148796, 0.025026662275195122, 0.008515131659805775, -0.00600707670673728, -0.020089952275156975, -0.0020043987315148115, 0.001722613931633532, 0.032546721398830414, -0.0037968831602483988, -0.02263505756855011, 0.00754525326192379, -0.02125449664890766, 0.033081360161304474, -0.03664403781294823, -0.029595280066132545, -0.060368359088897705, 0.0033706179820001125, -0.003943142015486956, -0.0006854533567093313, 0.021619746461510658, -0.03730195015668869, -0.02398117631673813, 0.005727124400436878, -0.01834271103143692, 0.03143826127052307, -0.028220664709806442, -0.03538118675351143, -0.01816502772271633, -0.0524381622672081, -0.00011540955165401101, 0.03514476865530014, 0.001481359824538231, -0.03405981883406639, -0.00018682396330405027, -0.004866770468652248, -0.07989559322595596, -0.048147011548280716, -0.036420535296201706, 0.006564299575984478, 0.020091626793146133, -0.035800594836473465, 0.05127975717186928, -0.0008429160225205123, -0.03404657170176506, 0.011131012812256813, -0.022823860868811607, 0.0013688361505046487, -0.012708129361271858, -0.01601780205965042, -0.0032343706116080284, 0.013832862488925457, -0.002269853837788105, 0.02460629679262638, -0.05027143284678459, -0.009164785034954548, -0.08284396678209305, -0.036326758563518524, 0.027777746319770813, 0.012778145261108875, 0.01737757958471775, 0.0035976499784737825, -0.014075757935643196, 0.05560942739248276, 0.016993645578622818, 0.003522730665281415, -0.04359326884150505, 0.0235143955796957, 0.007941356860101223, -0.01445747446268797, 0.01794002205133438, 0.03898082301020622, -0.01150871068239212, 0.015080020762979984, -0.008042504079639912, 0.038529276847839355, 0.05797934904694557, 0.025057537481188774, 0.0166361965239048, 0.0009321044199168682, -0.0019473028369247913, -0.011905083432793617, 0.022490695118904114, -0.0033119197469204664, -0.027960296720266342, 0.007939618080854416, 0.023060038685798645, 0.01039468590170145, 0.01635962910950184, -0.05452127754688263, 0.0054457890801131725, -0.015443066135048866, -0.027723679319024086, -0.04059619829058647, 0.005187392234802246, 0.009019574150443077, -0.03950737416744232, 0.019138414412736893, 0.00006509264494525269, -0.010554535314440727, -0.02001871168613434, -0.014237704686820507, 0.02686302736401558, 0.04724478721618652, -0.014392410404980183, 0.0031027973163872957, 0.000701543758623302, -0.013498556800186634, 0.04755421355366707, -0.015933237969875336, 0.020110810175538063, 0.05535382777452469, 0.028179001063108444, 0.000770794169511646, -0.0187943484634161, -0.03188291937112808, 0.018679680302739143, -0.08076346665620804, -0.003126680850982666, -0.012451319955289364, 0.0549255907535553, 0.0009444940369576216, 0.01740363799035549, 0.008674885146319866, -0.010039602406322956, 0.03550302982330322, -0.027757707983255386, -0.07010576128959656, 0.024201545864343643, -0.02141028270125389, 0.0088227279484272, 0.03980308771133423, 0.0232355035841465, 0.010538681410253048, -0.03336562588810921, -0.014413120225071907, -0.004686781205236912, 0.04788044095039368, -0.021852318197488785, 0.02999800071120262, -0.014623245224356651, -0.025435112416744232, -0.025418465957045555, -0.00037797255208715796, -0.010886825621128082, -0.0047844527289271355, -0.0026812469586730003, 0.0463334396481514, -0.01708429679274559, 0.0027374138589948416, -0.021803243085741997, -0.008834656327962875, 0.060564495623111725, 0.029800713062286377, 0.07690229266881943, 0.008700276724994183, -0.02184230275452137, 0.05639515444636345, 0.01772146299481392, 0.03471703827381134, 0.009707414545118809, 0.008568594232201576, -0.022286834195256233, -0.007089749909937382, -0.02053160034120083, -0.017440173774957657, -0.0041313134133815765, 0.029556555673480034, -0.006642450578510761, 0.0739559605717659, 0.009549915790557861, -0.017095746472477913, 0.021595679223537445, 0.0463268980383873, -0.009230873547494411, 0.02666926570236683, -0.031204091385006905, -0.007837120443582535, -0.007187986746430397, 0.005859195254743099, 0.06822545826435089, -0.006169295869767666, 0.022633608430624008, 0.0033701215870678425, 0.03339224308729172, -0.029059015214443207, -0.02609696052968502, -0.023692453280091286, 0.014575221575796604, 0.027666538953781128, 0.029033735394477844, -0.04383755847811699, 0.05496000126004219, 0.04524047672748566, 0.044388048350811005, 0.021702289581298828, -0.013467352837324142, -0.08284750580787659, 0.023848699405789375, 0.020426485687494278, 0.03280630335211754, -0.07761632651090622, -0.014501948840916157, -0.021523481234908104, -0.02223377302289009, 0.021246029064059258, -0.026469895616173744, 0.008121161721646786, -0.020302986726164818, 0.015178898349404335, -0.057370323687791824, -0.01915437914431095, -0.03745264187455177, 0.0018493353854864836, -0.013943898491561413, 0.0520954392850399, -0.022131893783807755, -0.031164834275841713, -0.04238509386777878, -0.005537460558116436, -0.009528991766273975, 0.015634769573807716, -0.042344603687524796, -0.007353303954005241, 0.01229369081556797, 0.0377228744328022, -0.015239202417433262, -0.06798265129327774, -0.0003020015428774059, -0.002906863112002611, 0.0018961020978167653, 0.053196635097265244, -0.009178406558930874, -0.0432342104613781, 0.003794092917814851, 0.01687210239470005, -0.034461118280887604, -0.02154896967113018, -0.03806084394454956, 0.04165470972657204, 0.02251780591905117, 0.007212874945253134, 0.04598664119839668, 0.012146987952291965, 0.005393600091338158, -0.033278774470090866, -0.014689532108604908, 0.00920080952346325, -0.005317037925124168, -0.026510385796427727, -0.05717247724533081, -0.04345354065299034, -0.002578027080744505, 0.04949554055929184, 0.0014047629665583372, 0.0333876758813858, -0.04342076927423477, -0.024650555104017258, 0.01692044362425804, 0.042932502925395966, 0.014243632555007935, -0.01699705608189106, 0.0020273171830922365, -0.004556015133857727, -0.03463244438171387, -0.024162480607628822, 0.01954437419772148, -0.04206357151269913, 0.022860771045088768, 0.0315212719142437, -0.019154122099280357, 0.01954764686524868, -0.025999058037996292, -0.026399152353405952, 0.05043439567089081, -0.011351724155247211, 0.045577291399240494, -0.019209161400794983, 0.04388343542814255, -0.029307397082448006, -0.01762351393699646, -0.01926998421549797, 0.03828021511435509, -0.011375478468835354, 0.01637675240635872, -0.021684816107153893, 0.03346981108188629, -0.00009019790741149336, -0.014569604769349098, -0.0711105540394783, -0.046820130199193954, 0.021877869963645935, -0.004227206576615572, -0.0480504184961319, -0.014423578977584839, -0.012474646791815758, -0.03451012447476387, -0.031972263008356094, 0.005149099510163069, 0.0595313161611557, -0.03930969536304474, -0.03364130109548569, -0.003613963257521391, 0.016419095918536186, 0.09152013808488846, 0.007732763420790434, -0.025109361857175827, -0.013195780105888844, -0.014452369883656502, -0.027781689539551735, -0.011732631362974644, 0.012523801997303963, -0.016638407483696938, -0.01399605255573988, -0.062493909150362015, 0.02216394804418087, 0.07675435394048691, -0.011324389837682247, -0.018062975257635117, 0.020440535619854927, -0.023787090554833412, 0.010064336471259594, -0.0382402166724205, -0.009602325968444347, -0.03621198236942291, 0.019412606954574585, -0.00501477625221014, -0.014403149485588074, 0.011639491654932499, -0.0020121217239648104, 0.031958144158124924, -0.011521299369633198, -0.00016421933833044022, 0.027163689956068993, 0.05120786651968956, 0.00964424293488264, 0.04526880383491516, 0.002870374359190464, -0.026035504415631294, 0.023761313408613205, -0.0029212285298854113, 0.019443199038505554, 0.021582745015621185, 0.052205536514520645, -0.016101200133562088, -0.042420219630002975, -0.009869339875876904, 0.02704392932355404, 0.041997723281383514, -0.012280534021556377, 0.038148682564496994, 0.05423055589199066, -0.00825163722038269, 0.01020880974829197, -0.026628712192177773, -0.010855243541300297, -0.01617521606385708, 0.006417678203433752, 0.07381734997034073, -0.04036112502217293, -0.019280342385172844, 0.04691178351640701, -0.011822660453617573, 0.01093106996268034, -0.002240440808236599, 0.018924053758382797, -0.009974137879908085, 0.046055156737565994, -0.0017430996522307396, -0.038331303745508194, 0.03311065211892128, -0.04012378677725792, -0.004201106261461973, -0.043015021830797195, 0.01746051013469696, 0.049431513994932175, 0.06326871365308762, 0.005376726854592562, -0.06521593034267426, -0.00924508087337017, -0.06237006559967995, -0.012953801080584526, 0.016030920669436455, -0.011219896376132965, 0.035134561359882355, 0.03531548008322716, 0.03075861558318138, -0.020550375804305077, 0.021632777526974678, 0.0010569122387096286, -0.08217291533946991, -0.019926471635699272, -0.007410046178847551, -0.015310199931263924, 0.004976958967745304, 0.004144924692809582, -0.003497757948935032, 0.034341905266046524, -0.07505855709314346, 0.02083567902445793, 0.00929765123873949, 0.043417833745479584, -0.012976263649761677, 0.03471571207046509, 0.00048512202920392156, -0.0368608683347702, -0.009291472844779491, -0.035063449293375015, 0.10660125315189362, 0.09432472288608551, 0.020939404144883156, -0.10900886356830597, 0.06475719064474106, 0.02449044957756996, 0.027877259999513626, 0.01157164666801691, 0.003066136036068201, 0.012635202147066593, -0.0074021765030920506, 0.06041739881038666, 0.07278678566217422, -0.008940271101891994, -0.006326503586024046, 0.04469775781035423, -0.030354470014572144, -0.025653939694166183, -0.009279067628085613, -0.014966216869652271, -0.02179255522787571, 0.011217731982469559, -0.05625850334763527, 0.038724638521671295, -0.0012753052869811654, -0.006968759931623936, -0.023901162669062614, -0.0363607332110405, 0.004001673776656389, -0.03296230733394623, -0.020475832745432854, -0.013203447684645653, 0.00963108241558075, 0.01020902395248413, -0.0024016720708459616, 0.01428645197302103, 0.039205364882946014, -0.015896841883659363, 0.02879655919969082, 0.04404968395829201, 0.012920350767672062, 0.006791170220822096, -0.003938562236726284, 0.033539820462465286, -0.04012305662035942, -0.004629621747881174, -0.02476230263710022, 0.06484631448984146, -0.005827735178172588, -0.017560770735144615, -0.04135908931493759, -0.011280357837677002, 0.009266920387744904, -0.03332580626010895, -0.02797061949968338, 0.05266936123371124, 0.01840091682970524, -0.03299515321850777, 0.002812669612467289, -0.02361324243247509, 0.019272204488515854, -0.0059078773483633995, 0.03973282128572464, 0.00926437508314848, -0.06120137870311737, 0.027987774461507797, -0.040322739630937576, 0.03404479846358299, -0.004850814118981361, 0.026234827935695648, -0.019009483978152275, 0.01114015281200409, -0.014444896951317787, -0.006154708098620176, 0.010773953050374985, 0.009363804943859577, 0.03559190779924393, -0.0011992021463811398, -0.008632931858301163, -0.022208984941244125, -0.03148968145251274, 0.009151755832135677, -0.00876910611987114, 0.012640188448131084, -0.05121341347694397, 0.012009858153760433, 0.036716390401124954, 0.029713531956076622, -0.017927464097738266, -0.025198940187692642, 0.01565878465771675, 0.047144439071416855, -0.021869812160730362, -0.04913632571697235, 0.0043198238126933575, 0.01562551036477089, -0.014760447666049004, -0.02338215336203575, -0.040776051580905914, 0.09075313806533813, 0.02637302130460739, 0.0060530188493430614, -0.012923751026391983, 0.02306547947227955, -0.004340381361544132, -0.018526893109083176, -0.000839712331071496, -0.055943701416254044, -0.0029920150991529226, 0.0015875600511208177, 0.01812838762998581, -0.020500708371400833, -0.012363245710730553, -0.028224004432559013, -0.04524170979857445, 0.012737637385725975, -0.05239061266183853, -0.04296451807022095, 0.045850589871406555, -0.007173791527748108, 0.01066579855978489, -0.02525300718843937, -0.006202535703778267, -0.03631597012281418, -0.03686674311757088, -0.005988751072436571, -0.05307872220873833, -0.009557649493217468, 0.017215976491570473, -0.018457569181919098, 0.007313896436244249, 0.013034755364060402, 0.028545642271637917, -0.020312804728746414, -0.009863006882369518, 0.023041827604174614, -0.023778719827532768, 0.007165409158915281, -0.029690055176615715, 0.0001147723596659489, 0.007373923435807228, -0.0028019999153912067, -0.022498782724142075, 0.015292876400053501, 0.0034138872288167477, 0.0547395758330822, -0.0012463413877412677, -0.004692298360168934, -0.01682026870548725, 0.03192954137921333, -0.014941244386136532, 0.0054796002805233, -0.02015700750052929, 0.00002205434429924935, -0.005966580472886562, -0.02265872061252594, 0.00857885554432869, -0.01951303333044052, -0.02862880751490593, 0.013097386807203293, 0.05164804309606552, -0.00846363976597786, 0.01939181610941887, -0.0020254990085959435, -0.005426734685897827, 0.054316192865371704, -0.007411682512611151, -0.04064038768410683, 0.04464706405997276, 0.021424464881420135, -0.01396244578063488, 0.05893738195300102, -0.015851600095629692, 0.0030036428943276405, -0.07340522110462189, -0.011021098122000694, -0.01606222242116928, 0.03797364607453346, 0.03272511065006256, -0.0642496645450592, -0.023502951487898827, 0.032038792967796326, -0.015280908904969692, -0.017746642231941223, 0.0030636603478342295, -0.027943851426243782, -0.0052411556243896484, -0.014596458524465561, 0.03241831064224243, 0.04204213619232178, 0.017306888476014137, 0.007521533407270908, -0.00022358153364621103, 0.0064836423844099045, 0.03985649719834328, -0.022474657744169235, -0.009152824059128761, -0.01932821422815323, 0.002019754145294428, -0.05714859440922737, 0.03978307917714119, -0.05262797325849533, -0.007788394577801228, 0.03244457766413689, -0.023801075294613838, 0.03751515597105026, 0.04056793451309204, 0.011628828942775726, 0.0032669829670339823, 0.03886406496167183, 0.022796431556344032, 0.003916354849934578, -0.022931454703211784, -0.0017210518708452582, 0.018767936155200005, 0.007967587560415268, -0.03309986740350723, 0.007873407565057278, 0.019418157637119293, -0.02888587862253189, 0.023998454213142395, 0.016214890405535698, -0.01196727342903614, -0.01792772486805916, 0.01848747208714485, -0.011614568531513214, 0.0193440280854702, -0.024891356006264687, 0.044218432158231735, -0.023259185254573822, -0.020618176087737083, 0.02913244254887104, 0.04392426833510399, -0.04330739751458168, 0.03984420374035835, 0.016215525567531586, -0.021597594022750854, 0.01963401585817337, -0.0032469616271555424, 0.010981534607708454, -0.08840954303741455, 0.005607325118035078, -0.003252878552302718, -0.016977323219180107, -0.054395560175180435, -0.01089490670710802, -0.01237520668655634, 0.03448495641350746, -0.04749381169676781, 0.006972701754420996, 0.026783911511301994, -0.009674498811364174, 0.04089560732245445, -0.10937356948852539, 0.0742708295583725, 0.015421519987285137, -0.03368917480111122, -0.03856559842824936, -0.006619979627430439, -0.04988928511738777, 0.019676079973578453, 0.09208234399557114, 0.01863074116408825, 0.007360741496086121, -0.0036488324403762817, 0.060053735971450806, -0.00852671917527914, -0.038093529641628265, 0.038097675889730453, 0.0022653695195913315, -0.01807209849357605, 0.004240388981997967, -0.0002000251697609201, 0.020113544538617134, 0.03606269881129265, 0.06670796126127243, 0.021044496446847916, 0.01742163859307766, -0.024881236255168915, 0.023595476523041725, 0.028636768460273743, -0.02873539738357067, -0.007489544339478016, 0.058697767555713654, -0.04247403144836426, 0.023545803502202034, 0.029125163331627846, -0.013744926080107689, -0.0581817701458931, 0.04382660612463951, -0.023975616320967674, 0.010141025297343731, -0.0038401607889682055, -0.045264389365911484, 0.01111276913434267, -0.07204890251159668, -0.00917745940387249, -0.020936481654644012, -0.0069899726659059525, -0.005278707016259432, 0.04808930680155754, 0.04298129677772522, 0.03820531442761421, -0.02426641620695591, 0.005017748102545738, 0.005491854622960091, -0.006481389980763197, -0.0009695473709143698, 0.021330932155251503, 0.06737211346626282, 0.022940892726182938, -0.025343632325530052, 0.026796922087669373, -0.010566568933427334, 0.017111599445343018, -0.0169124323874712, 0.05925207585096359, -0.034198787063360214, -0.0318131297826767, -0.007863667793571949, -0.006003673188388348, -0.001658910303376615, -0.027205700054764748, -0.018134720623493195, 0.028102850541472435, -0.04903264343738556, 0.0201022420078516, -0.026553351432085037, -0.010164065286517143, -0.017448684200644493, 0.00716181006282568, 0.015904804691672325, 0.033361028879880905, 0.009057262912392616, 0.007792474702000618, -0.0012329189339652658, -0.008918954990804195, 0.022214757278561592, 0.005239902064204216, 0.029744135215878487, -0.03775555267930031, -0.03788689151406288, -0.02331443689763546, -0.029702333733439445, -0.021646922454237938, -0.0509759746491909, 0.0458734966814518, 0.07147854566574097, 0.042277414351701736, -0.033446796238422394, -0.03310786932706833, -0.01225887332111597, 0.0585019625723362, -0.08424065262079239, -0.019252410158514977, -0.01532200537621975, -0.021487494930624962, -0.0017245238414034247, -0.02506965957581997 ]
<p>I am trying to make predictions using a random forest model in R.</p> <p>However I get errors since some factors have different values in the test set than in the training set. For example, a factor <code>Cat_2</code> has values <code>34, 68, 76</code>, etc., in the test set that do not appear in the training set. Unfortunately, I do not have control over the Test set... I must use it as-is.</p> <p>My only workaround was to convert the problematic factors back to numerical values, using <code>as.numeric()</code>. It <em>works</em> but I am not very satisfied, since these values are codes that have no numerical sense...</p> <p>Do you think there would be another solution, to drop the new values from the test set? But without removing all the other factor values (let say values <code>1, 2, 14, 32</code>, etc.) which are in both training and test, and contains information potentially useful for predictions.</p>
74,270
[ -0.012225665152072906, -0.010135374031960964, -0.02298455312848091, 0.027574572712183, -0.00040123669896274805, -0.0064100646413862705, -0.044194355607032776, -0.01964571885764599, 0.03121006488800049, -0.03287772089242935, 0.04493549466133118, 0.03037663921713829, 0.036133330315351486, 0.032116539776325226, 0.015870023518800735, -0.007639261428266764, -0.006065669935196638, 0.018641704693436623, -0.01303777750581503, -0.03394462168216705, -0.019534248858690262, 0.02836986631155014, 0.025765880942344666, 0.0027501459699124098, 0.0013253350043669343, 0.05333209037780762, 0.029767895117402077, -0.02177661471068859, 0.00653931125998497, 0.009244853630661964, -0.02802904322743416, -0.04452206939458847, -0.0027837587986141443, 0.010470946319401264, 0.012506778351962566, 0.016980675980448723, -0.00541035458445549, -0.012135795317590237, -0.04104308411478996, -0.0117600467056036, -0.01711811125278473, 0.016425134614109993, -0.01768343709409237, 0.05944283679127693, 0.00941841583698988, 0.014258534647524357, 0.00655331090092659, -0.0003294361231382936, 0.014680348336696625, -0.03334689885377884, 0.07693915069103241, -0.017897408455610275, 0.03650587052106857, 0.06006329134106636, -0.019812067970633507, -0.029038624837994576, 0.03491780906915665, 0.07576475292444229, -0.0379403680562973, -0.026326561346650124, -0.037708133459091187, -0.05778863653540611, 0.02765829488635063, 0.02047768607735634, -0.046234458684921265, 0.04142603650689125, 0.00836839061230421, -0.03261804208159447, -0.009282279759645462, -0.0529923215508461, 0.03806242346763611, 0.005145922768861055, 0.019139612093567848, 0.005830718204379082, 0.03809727728366852, -0.023405836895108223, 0.04588018357753754, 0.016645127907395363, 0.04385426267981529, 0.021469907835125923, -0.014101126231253147, 0.030102446675300598, 0.029572976753115654, 0.01063758134841919, 0.03691868111491203, -0.014911334030330181, 0.0537281408905983, -0.024254921823740005, 0.00960790365934372, 0.027345100417733192, -0.00794784165918827, -0.0003873929672408849, 0.0665736272931099, -0.002199839800596237, -0.03595167398452759, 0.03167892247438431, -0.016894148662686348, 0.02778753452003002, -0.006712935399264097, -0.004951148759573698, -0.02544940635561943, -0.012942247092723846, 0.0445416197180748, 0.041960444301366806, -0.07351621240377426, -0.0019327080808579922, -0.0332990400493145, -0.04468487948179245, -0.025535808876156807, -0.001135476166382432, 0.008534662425518036, 0.01044181827455759, -0.011565952561795712, -0.02758755348622799, 0.054135922342538834, -0.029673131182789803, -0.06496448814868927, -0.010540003888309002, 0.037975095212459564, 0.04590562731027603, 0.03755103051662445, -0.0348244272172451, 0.024958042427897453, 0.018906600773334503, -0.02050928771495819, -0.00024806056171655655, 0.0250959862023592, -0.01331266202032566, -0.03868701308965683, 0.0204178374260664, -0.021666694432497025, -0.01362319104373455, 0.04726617410778999, -0.004195000045001507, 0.017993198707699776, -0.01609448529779911, -0.07719387859106064, -0.07543614506721497, 0.013370087370276451, -0.05454520136117935, -0.0052564553916454315, -0.05618349090218544, -0.009221035987138748, 0.008948717266321182, 0.04341067746281624, 0.01975911296904087, 0.013060785830020905, 0.025420669466257095, 0.019550548866391182, 0.01781296730041504, 0.023481201380491257, -0.022547272965312004, -0.04700563848018646, -0.007175533566623926, -0.06414336711168289, -0.06248113885521889, 0.03324407339096069, 0.023833246901631355, -0.014068016782402992, -0.005429718177765608, -0.019802676513791084, -0.05215880647301674, -0.015768935903906822, 0.011638118885457516, -0.007979059591889381, -0.039493925869464874, 0.06358465552330017, -0.0019468507962301373, 0.04239518195390701, 0.043656300753355026, -0.01074122916907072, 0.02960437536239624, 0.03406532481312752, 0.040773358196020126, 0.02962675131857395, 0.022693786770105362, 0.001755395089276135, -0.007763327565044165, 0.05458064377307892, -0.004332549870014191, -0.016332773491740227, -0.03689691424369812, -0.010233169421553612, -0.0023585690651088953, 0.03859582170844078, 0.01751706562936306, -0.006478026509284973, -0.0062240189872682095, 0.0683949664235115, -0.05667928606271744, -0.00801320094615221, -0.03282271325588226, 0.0005248849629424512, -0.030707569792866707, 0.010640700347721577, 0.014242528937757015, -0.011662019416689873, 0.03543464094400406, 0.013718979433178902, -0.01264540757983923, -0.03602319955825806, -0.0013916301541030407, 0.04726053401827812, -0.027785945683717728, 0.0017824089154601097, 0.017151201143860817, 0.022822489961981773, -0.01915496028959751, 0.05225098133087158, -0.019948754459619522, -0.0759611502289772, 0.009953663684427738, -0.05251007899641991, 0.021948430687189102, -0.037401653826236725, -0.01589234545826912, 0.015150523744523525, 0.016748787835240364, -0.031025877222418785, 0.03423190489411354, -0.06770843267440796, 0.05592406168580055, 0.048531703650951385, -0.00529051385819912, -0.004922748077660799, -0.018312817439436913, -0.010210320353507996, 0.033815573900938034, -0.05355321243405342, -0.012018059380352497, -0.04436756297945976, -0.05461225286126137, 0.05889923870563507, 0.0018753085751086473, -0.032978128641843796, -0.010508082807064056, 0.057591330260038376, -0.0010116975754499435, 0.024117158725857735, 0.03686298429965973, 0.02680887281894684, -0.001409107935614884, 0.03471784666180611, -0.0015828263713046908, 0.01832069270312786, -0.02231999672949314, 0.04754771292209625, -0.01892765797674656, 0.029506199061870575, -0.016271939501166344, 0.0008577698608860373, 0.034843381494283676, 0.008487747982144356, 0.0064792572520673275, -0.024095656350255013, -0.04623904451727867, 0.016480999067425728, -0.014191066846251488, -0.0030676221940666437, 0.04003952816128731, 0.0347125418484211, -0.027708884328603745, 0.013993753120303154, 0.0038841909263283014, 0.02258298546075821, 0.06850410997867584, -0.04104471951723099, 0.001767372596077621, 0.016610773280262947, -0.0747760534286499, -0.0019591443706303835, 0.006035753060132265, -0.02786758728325367, -0.034896910190582275, 0.05614675581455231, 0.0064343358390033245, 0.007105337455868721, 0.03788452968001366, -0.0036744694225490093, -0.004591105040162802, -0.018108272925019264, -0.060775332152843475, 0.005459595005959272, 0.015990914776921272, -0.008135342970490456, -0.010174539871513844, -0.018547745421528816, -0.022296462208032608, 0.03204663470387459, -0.014743656851351261, -0.03452731668949127, 0.02656797133386135, -0.026600925251841545, -0.023830780759453773, -0.010569235309958458, -0.06582081317901611, 0.039107248187065125, -0.014882730320096016, -0.033551860600709915, 0.035246592015028, 0.013720591552555561, -0.027511462569236755, 0.010622353293001652, 0.0026704815682023764, 0.00808896403759718, -0.02473038248717785, -0.04228469356894493, 0.025427764281630516, -0.007401980459690094, 0.01703066937625408, 0.03584504872560501, -0.013941056095063686, 0.010758006945252419, -0.06544946134090424, -0.08735612779855728, -0.014275792986154556, 0.01771003194153309, 0.01445226464420557, 0.020881816744804382, 0.024092167615890503, 0.10626745223999023, 0.02892834134399891, -0.039829544723033905, -0.021654311567544937, -0.01300116442143917, -0.029142064973711967, -0.04524490609765053, 0.011231119744479656, 0.02452242560684681, 0.05067959800362587, 0.03004312328994274, -0.02760208025574684, 0.0406440906226635, 0.0215541273355484, -0.014962862245738506, -0.035991914570331573, 0.028893787413835526, 0.02880236506462097, -0.023108065128326416, 0.04234057292342186, 0.01892327144742012, -0.01985037326812744, 0.028645314276218414, -0.015101149678230286, 0.01908843219280243, -0.0005631725653074682, -0.061924081295728683, 0.018117932602763176, -0.033050332218408585, 0.08055111765861511, -0.0012951069511473179, 0.03965426981449127, -0.008440044708549976, -0.047998908907175064, -0.01898455247282982, 0.01804373599588871, 0.07379666715860367, -0.03147672116756439, -0.0046255700290203094, 0.036511510610580444, 0.05053723230957985, -0.006561783608049154, 0.028118355199694633, -0.02353781834244728, -0.01587958075106144, 0.07414393872022629, -0.005259354133158922, 0.02581799030303955, 0.05445873737335205, 0.01083443220704794, 0.04979013651609421, 0.014004521071910858, -0.014451941475272179, 0.038599688559770584, -0.04383557662367821, 0.02017919346690178, -0.020928896963596344, 0.033515606075525284, 0.026310203596949577, 0.025425229221582413, 0.05225967988371849, -0.015408357605338097, 0.022411227226257324, 0.0043003917671740055, -0.0752195194363594, -0.01386717613786459, 0.04332468658685684, -0.01127831544727087, 0.001182441832497716, -0.021365098655223846, 0.0014865563716739416, -0.012448216788470745, 0.0032014090102165937, 0.028022432699799538, 0.011808903887867928, -0.03957236185669899, -0.006004965864121914, -0.0015051944646984339, -0.0026799486950039864, -0.00749825406819582, 0.014949584379792213, 0.016977395862340927, -0.031193897128105164, -0.0044049713760614395, 0.02201155386865139, -0.0009862651349976659, 0.0022800841834396124, -0.038188107311725616, -0.018290171399712563, 0.028462039306759834, 0.04968872293829918, 0.03812680020928383, 0.028512509539723396, -0.051945120096206665, 0.055043067783117294, 0.005922869313508272, 0.02863668091595173, 0.04976490139961243, -0.00042365016997791827, -0.016212912276387215, -0.01998896710574627, -0.039011336863040924, -0.025069668889045715, 0.013551297597587109, 0.009907707571983337, -0.018844706937670708, 0.046931192278862, 0.05730104818940163, -0.024340568110346794, 0.012204737402498722, 0.0690217837691307, 0.0359765961766243, 0.010616078972816467, -0.009068652987480164, -0.0031643789261579514, -0.006224298384040594, -0.017437594011425972, 0.04078112170100212, 0.008970892056822777, 0.0031488474924117327, -0.007558817509561777, 0.038674235343933105, -0.01323116384446621, -0.039638593792915344, 0.004675081465393305, 0.0288371741771698, 0.04548526555299759, -0.017244474962353706, 0.0072486866265535355, 0.003204365959390998, 0.02015594020485878, 0.01374959759414196, -0.006313245743513107, -0.008448014967143536, -0.08956950157880783, 0.020997904241085052, 0.04990468919277191, 0.047795746475458145, -0.03108142875134945, -0.0020291823893785477, -0.03961927816271782, 0.013210074976086617, -0.012888791039586067, -0.022239087149500847, 0.012199978344142437, 0.0010594180785119534, 0.026477262377738953, 0.013265388086438179, -0.030231086537241936, -0.019380703568458557, 0.005814053118228912, -0.06501412391662598, 0.05943058058619499, 0.009815888479351997, -0.054115183651447296, -0.029229607433080673, 0.02081485092639923, 0.00867018848657608, 0.07812701910734177, -0.02882496453821659, -0.016355490311980247, 0.03132966160774231, -0.03950423374772072, -0.009091256186366081, -0.05444260314106941, 0.014939035288989544, 0.02696727216243744, 0.027621740475296974, 0.019327234476804733, -0.018439847975969315, -0.06481420993804932, -0.016975494101643562, 0.021072985604405403, -0.0016359201399609447, -0.01000010222196579, -0.038335300981998444, 0.021045582368969917, 0.027167318388819695, -0.019737429916858673, 0.04658006504178047, 0.05442722141742706, 0.001237887074239552, 0.018211213871836662, -0.031244296580553055, 0.014424357563257217, -0.040751125663518906, -0.0049738273955881596, -0.05057545751333237, -0.0016729453345760703, 0.030109385028481483, 0.012225925922393799, -0.0105021046474576, 0.05928397178649902, -0.00754068698734045, -0.003015604568645358, -0.004330076742917299, 0.02422858402132988, -0.030788227915763855, -0.020554009824991226, -0.014451581984758377, 0.013021181337535381, -0.05020090937614441, 0.022513648495078087, -0.017015956342220306, 0.010449309833347797, 0.028313087299466133, -0.004768800921738148, -0.016444869339466095, 0.001976027386263013, -0.04365604743361473, -0.027940422296524048, -0.009563942439854145, -0.026717310771346092, 0.011369041167199612, -0.007471607532352209, 0.03601320460438728, -0.022701555863022804, -0.020220257341861725, 0.007879908196628094, 0.03711559623479843, -0.017099812626838684, 0.008439116179943085, -0.03580767661333084, 0.03379785269498825, -0.023800479248166084, 0.009845035150647163, -0.037075839936733246, -0.053418707102537155, -0.016263868659734726, 0.010199278593063354, -0.020223455503582954, -0.040553923696279526, -0.0029341764748096466, -0.03850581496953964, 0.0222853384912014, -0.027003813534975052, 0.07478029280900955, -0.0198055487126112, -0.023289071395993233, -0.0074050696566700935, 0.019018633291125298, 0.06543096154928207, 0.012184437364339828, -0.008183080703020096, 0.019598260521888733, 0.017573321238160133, -0.013637776486575603, 0.0025012337137013674, -0.012383634224534035, -0.020236488431692123, -0.011159314773976803, -0.006865426432341337, 0.008627621456980705, 0.03668234869837761, 0.024735793471336365, 0.02196553535759449, -0.006727172993123531, -0.01565088890492916, 0.019117023795843124, -0.02955957129597664, 0.0005282610072754323, -0.0012210560962557793, -0.0024116993881762028, -0.03158384561538696, 0.057357072830200195, -0.02096915990114212, -0.00042736087925732136, 0.014582820236682892, -0.021087640896439552, -0.01101506408303976, 0.04339396581053734, 0.05310667306184769, -0.008435125462710857, 0.021145109087228775, -0.025150848552584648, -0.028079485520720482, 0.04146801307797432, 0.024529006332159042, 0.05416193604469299, -0.035283371806144714, 0.0526285395026207, -0.012795621529221535, -0.01925756223499775, -0.02882579155266285, -0.033300165086984634, 0.04349744692444801, -0.00848417729139328, 0.03010571002960205, 0.013714281842112541, 0.009558388032019138, 0.011340664699673653, -0.043717775493860245, -0.007878521457314491, 0.022518349811434746, 0.044886961579322815, 0.05812046304345131, 0.05760377645492554, 0.028605753555893898, 0.009343479759991169, -0.008006028831005096, 0.05061081424355507, 0.06095761060714722, -0.0005119297420606017, 0.03805892914533615, 0.025782784447073936, -0.037707604467868805, -0.007946635596454144, -0.015424403361976147, -0.019414562731981277, 0.01189540233463049, -0.005322987213730812, -0.0018571697873994708, 0.05025304853916168, 0.008154145441949368, 0.016348963603377342, -0.02773359976708889, -0.03976987674832344, -0.04627399891614914, 0.002096934011206031, -0.005585191771388054, -0.02123194746673107, 0.05112433433532715, -0.00004088796049472876, 0.008495221845805645, -0.0025367545895278454, 0.036492787301540375, -0.04466893523931503, -0.07977309823036194, -0.02231241762638092, -0.04940899461507797, -0.02784246765077114, 0.04677432030439377, -0.007252838462591171, -0.01497213076800108, 0.01404966227710247, -0.030819589272141457, 0.00927471648901701, 0.005507348105311394, 0.006934516131877899, -0.01033454667776823, 0.02495134249329567, -0.0004168763116467744, 0.009997142478823662, -0.011089032515883446, -0.013763243332505226, 0.11200782656669617, 0.07328928261995316, 0.043962057679891586, -0.0632701888680458, -0.03141321241855621, -0.0006252709426917136, -0.00298642017878592, -0.021707024425268173, -0.03261757642030716, -0.008249388076364994, 0.01482006162405014, 0.045582134276628494, 0.027920106425881386, 0.024106089025735855, -0.012814955785870552, 0.0042039258405566216, -0.003977819345891476, 0.014260872267186642, 0.01319592259824276, 0.03195592015981674, 0.02090030163526535, -0.013447419740259647, -0.05540851131081581, 0.00919902604073286, 0.028751032426953316, 0.005481123924255371, -0.018963441252708435, 0.015472600236535072, -0.005573416128754616, 0.023184720426797867, -0.0005138415726833045, -0.006521157920360565, -0.0004125925188418478, 0.012194016017019749, 0.060000933706760406, 0.02877262607216835, 0.0038034124299883842, -0.008119172416627407, -0.009330256842076778, 0.01812022179365158, 0.013256457634270191, -0.023900752887129784, -0.0038353248964995146, 0.01200098916888237, -0.06764793395996094, -0.05733700096607208, -0.036287277936935425, 0.02041846700012684, -0.05883786454796791, -0.05216779559850693, 0.006020596716552973, 0.002863485598936677, -0.008526084944605827, -0.07081033289432526, -0.026880063116550446, 0.04674492031335831, 0.009043177589774132, -0.00665010791271925, -0.01599777676165104, -0.008292275480926037, 0.05733722075819969, 0.013824544847011566, 0.017359944060444832, 0.006011806894093752, -0.029477519914507866, 0.018725616857409477, -0.05260731652379036, 0.07304965704679489, 0.007014347705990076, 0.0029732873663306236, 0.014314637519419193, 0.00043671991443261504, 0.003787897527217865, -0.028034985065460205, 0.019561611115932465, 0.00851360335946083, 0.010767621919512749, -0.02364378049969673, -0.005494370125234127, -0.035029347985982895, -0.03265101835131645, -0.008095775730907917, -0.03737339377403259, -0.006561569403856993, -0.02407383918762207, -0.0031629884615540504, -0.01793024130165577, 0.040946103632450104, 0.0461542122066021, -0.0062065632082521915, -0.012084996327757835, 0.02301773428916931, -0.004221626557409763, -0.06841076910495758, -0.032600585371255875, 0.000042043022403959185, -0.03713518753647804, 0.012299575842916965, -0.002372393850237131, 0.09243807196617126, 0.03751637414097786, -0.02185652032494545, 0.003991179633885622, 0.027869245037436485, 0.0067052217200398445, 0.013739287853240967, 0.007727143354713917, -0.02456090971827507, -0.029662668704986572, 0.011632252484560013, 0.01171702891588211, -0.04355374351143837, -0.03321100026369095, -0.0533602200448513, -0.07675047963857651, 0.02579493261873722, 0.006227392703294754, -0.04615204408764839, 0.01234506443142891, -0.022939292713999748, 0.010504784062504768, -0.02520899288356304, -0.005262536928057671, -0.01753736101090908, -0.021184319630265236, -0.034511588513851166, -0.06112557649612427, -0.02500041387975216, 0.006084197200834751, -0.04094376042485237, 0.03644270822405815, 0.030698347836732864, -0.014943164773285389, 0.002290854463353753, 0.007698909845203161, -0.03129400312900543, 0.011822599917650223, 0.047813426703214645, -0.030640756711363792, -0.023100851103663445, 0.01987728476524353, -0.03941638767719269, -0.015058395452797413, 0.04563717916607857, -0.0332203172147274, 0.05136067047715187, 0.021419232711195946, 0.008848527446389198, -0.013926301151514053, 0.05773017928004265, -0.0017008889699354768, 0.0024595654103904963, -0.01149999350309372, 0.014515108428895473, 0.008134023286402225, 0.005210625473409891, 0.010021941736340523, 0.00617167679592967, -0.002582087880000472, 0.02358286827802658, 0.05466698482632637, 0.04841085523366928, -0.002240910427644849, 0.02810048684477806, -0.021582262590527534, 0.0074215843342244625, 0.010398083366453648, -0.00041482667438685894, 0.0050768181681632996, 0.017102057114243507, -0.0034221354871988297, 0.0538845919072628, -0.02842474915087223, -0.005320772062987089, -0.10669364780187607, -0.03407897427678108, 0.04544854164123535, -0.009387413039803505, 0.003655017353594303, -0.014819520525634289, 0.027740659192204475, -0.0004462052311282605, -0.057947929948568344, 0.021358149126172066, -0.002495445543900132, -0.03295912966132164, -0.011947610415518284, -0.017088614404201508, -0.028014525771141052, -0.019326062873005867, 0.05412030965089798, 0.0008454422932118177, 0.008811429142951965, -0.0021704414393752813, 0.01680174097418785, -0.06265145540237427, -0.014293519780039787, -0.01295697782188654, -0.0043576727621257305, -0.05748630687594414, 0.015948783606290817, -0.020240791141986847, -0.013010204769670963, -0.004892442841082811, -0.017607789486646652, -0.0005002300022169948, 0.05791996791958809, 0.02493433468043804, 0.02870655059814453, 0.05645275115966797, 0.009836639277637005, -0.005294657777994871, -0.03009684756398201, -0.023675812408328056, -0.040847476571798325, 0.00414839806035161, -0.0234935712069273, 0.028584716841578484, 0.008812356740236282, -0.0014784950762987137, -0.029798362404108047, 0.021882617846131325, -0.043751224875450134, -0.00010404305066913366, -0.01613140106201172, 0.019320638850331306, -0.01069937739521265, -0.04004272446036339, -0.03266696259379387, -0.026835916563868523, 0.009408594109117985, 0.056489843875169754, -0.014298728667199612, 0.015839578583836555, 0.0060499380342662334, -0.03670397400856018, -0.048344533890485764, -0.018109658733010292, 0.030807150527834892, -0.007108351681381464, -0.08470862358808517, -0.004988398868590593, -0.011063662357628345, -0.03273293748497963, -0.032547224313020706, -0.007681635674089193, 0.0005481791449710727, 0.06324625760316849, 0.011584335006773472, 0.005455159582197666, -0.018709631636738777, -0.012016847729682922, 0.025088313966989517, -0.11676853895187378, 0.030731135979294777, 0.03038415126502514, -0.016101311892271042, -0.0061870538629591465, 0.03735651448369026, -0.048540081828832626, 0.01214202493429184, 0.049210283905267715, 0.04047173634171486, 0.026653628796339035, -0.008129122667014599, 0.016435028985142708, 0.0069655911065638065, -0.05889773741364479, 0.05000094696879387, -0.0012098775478079915, -0.027058463543653488, -0.013598745688796043, -0.02019479125738144, 0.03773782402276993, 0.00186455762013793, -0.0012370548211038113, -0.002144950209185481, -0.023689506575465202, 0.014305883087217808, 0.008635076694190502, 0.04795656353235245, -0.029781488701701164, 0.028575528413057327, 0.017625562846660614, -0.020909495651721954, 0.01946486346423626, 0.02103728987276554, 0.02136576548218727, -0.04162278026342392, 0.017855284735560417, -0.004439405631273985, -0.0026534078642725945, 0.00368320569396019, 0.029746446758508682, 0.04557541012763977, -0.02951863594353199, 0.017350245267152786, 0.024541834369301796, -0.007990650832653046, 0.0221732035279274, 0.02286544442176819, 0.029682889580726624, 0.056558188050985336, 0.03365300968289375, 0.011508346535265446, 0.0007563353865407407, -0.04739002883434296, 0.0320688858628273, -0.005235444754362106, -0.018206657841801643, -0.009085931815207005, 0.01880774088203907, 0.02510683983564377, -0.014836493879556656, -0.008399425074458122, 0.01352175883948803, 0.06231020390987396, 0.007570434827357531, 0.009663083590567112, 0.017178235575556755, -0.004933816380798817, 0.025972038507461548, -0.023932183161377907, -0.006192884873598814, 0.0317046083509922, -0.0439574234187603, -0.01646288111805916, -0.0755096971988678, -0.03758686035871506, -0.012092660181224346, 0.016945863142609596, -0.004999734461307526, 0.037345800548791885, 0.005231143906712532, -0.006926086265593767, 0.02941572666168213, -0.015434104949235916, 0.022167570888996124, -0.032991841435432434, 0.018566641956567764, -0.0415780134499073, -0.029231660068035126, 0.011798348277807236, 0.008436869829893112, -0.049991194158792496, -0.026257308200001717, 0.018417082726955414, 0.06786979734897614, 0.02336367964744568, -0.04897468909621239, -0.0037915746215730906, 0.03295003995299339, 0.0027813061606138945, -0.0158853679895401, 0.004496365319937468, -0.03305947408080101, 0.033860038965940475, -0.008000457659363747, -0.04601121321320534 ]
<p>Let's say there's one DV (<code>Y</code>) and three IVs (<code>X1</code>, <code>X2</code>, <code>X3</code>), and among IVs, <code>X1</code> is a dummy variable. In the regression model without interaction terms, the results can be represented like this:</p> <pre><code>Y ~ X1 + X2 + X3 X1 : non-significant X2 : significant X3 : significant </code></pre> <p>In this case, is it meaningful to check some interaction terms (e.g. <code>X1</code> $\cdot$ <code>X2</code> or <code>X1</code> $\cdot$ <code>X3</code>)? At first I thought I don't have to because the main effect of <code>X1</code> indicates non-significance. But I'm afraid I'm missing something important.</p>
49,515
[ -0.027345117181539536, 0.03162016347050667, -0.03773670271039009, 0.029329225420951843, 0.01843373477458954, 0.05230726674199104, -0.0317365899682045, -0.013840550556778908, 0.04310739412903786, -0.021049829199910164, 0.024559950456023216, -0.00031159757054410875, 0.07043526321649551, -0.022884996607899666, 0.021007122471928596, 0.016813872382044792, -0.008098531514406204, 0.005469621624797583, 0.026459574699401855, -0.027559397742152214, -0.04918977990746498, 0.019445903599262238, 0.02094338834285736, -0.007162607274949551, 0.03919368237257004, 0.056344978511333466, 0.014921342954039574, -0.012492744252085686, 0.03255792334675789, 0.010673629119992256, -0.012605317868292332, -0.012395821511745453, 0.003186003537848592, 0.035748109221458435, 0.025892484933137894, 0.03243720903992653, -0.007539454847574234, -0.027114788070321083, 0.0406549908220768, 0.01885347254574299, -0.019750798121094704, 0.012169656343758106, 0.010117935948073864, 0.03946799412369728, -0.011914349161088467, 0.03607732802629471, -0.004404344130307436, -0.011646557599306107, 0.03354854881763458, -0.037931133061647415, 0.05913437902927399, -0.0038262351881712675, 0.040298666805028915, 0.04530046880245209, -0.030678875744342804, -0.02150730974972248, 0.03785797208547592, 0.04963591322302818, -0.02230902947485447, -0.03590114414691925, -0.04611363261938095, -0.04144784435629845, 0.016092069447040558, -0.0017722035991027951, -0.04895957559347153, 0.05331072211265564, 0.007371091283857822, -0.014118682593107224, 0.04604574292898178, -0.04067075997591019, -0.013495937921106815, -0.00840845424681902, 0.015973877161741257, -0.009306651540100574, -0.009372544474899769, 0.008614222519099712, 0.02420201525092125, 0.015088983811438084, 0.02228197269141674, 0.060464728623628616, -0.018802868202328682, 0.005532042123377323, 0.007982498966157436, 0.0313386395573616, 0.026113547384738922, 0.023250777274370193, 0.018070058897137642, -0.0529465526342392, 0.036927539855241776, 0.021316928789019585, -0.019421029835939407, 0.015080706216394901, 0.05380840599536896, -0.0077318777330219746, -0.03917587921023369, -0.0012034042738378048, -0.03276340663433075, 0.023870063945651054, 0.01526642870157957, -0.006482393015176058, -0.053702618926763535, -0.029890915378928185, 0.015059825964272022, 0.03544522449374199, -0.02378660999238491, -0.02687983028590679, -0.05721607804298401, 0.02121664583683014, -0.006936258170753717, -0.04857710003852844, -0.015504204668104649, 0.00135995470918715, -0.023137608543038368, 0.02454504556953907, 0.01961284875869751, -0.04517429694533348, -0.011973685584962368, -0.004769043065607548, 0.06630800664424896, 0.04768587648868561, 0.060039494186639786, -0.0358847975730896, 0.00954196136444807, -0.019249791279435158, -0.0355851836502552, 0.02485714666545391, 0.043240468949079514, 0.0036347368732094765, -0.035529155284166336, 0.03478490188717842, -0.0022036926820874214, -0.0056754848919808865, 0.008293909020721912, -0.0001893409207696095, 0.02644595131278038, 0.021373430266976357, -0.05626635625958443, -0.02813364937901497, 0.021558091044425964, -0.01207087840884924, -0.012465415522456169, -0.05786227434873581, -0.03140236809849739, 0.04216862469911575, 0.07995747029781342, -0.00868985801935196, -0.00046873901737853885, 0.013648802414536476, 0.020626476034522057, 0.026549337431788445, -0.017986947670578957, -0.019562652334570885, -0.023325903341174126, -0.052077773958444595, -0.029159916564822197, -0.07296483218669891, 0.040181513875722885, 0.047168344259262085, -0.007119655609130859, 0.005388944409787655, 0.06164298579096794, -0.000030013443392817862, -0.025461431592702866, 0.00596181396394968, -0.024283314123749733, -0.0265993382781744, 0.037144944071769714, -0.02929767593741417, 0.05854896456003189, 0.020047226920723915, 0.037732452154159546, 0.05298277363181114, 0.0064397999085485935, 0.06217028573155403, 0.04650067538022995, -0.0116432448849082, 0.0059193396009504795, -0.048118315637111664, 0.009337669238448143, -0.008843020536005497, -0.05697712302207947, -0.07060791552066803, -0.04638168588280678, -0.0033088414929807186, 0.0016143879620358348, 0.042886313050985336, 0.01271064579486847, -0.009181015193462372, 0.06793446838855743, -0.03368395194411278, -0.03480369225144386, -0.07216229289770126, 0.0204637311398983, -0.0008980875718407333, -0.0878266841173172, 0.0004908423288725317, 0.02713998593389988, 0.011648384854197502, 0.021596098318696022, -0.006965103093534708, -0.010443953797221184, 0.020624421536922455, 0.04048343002796173, -0.05688975006341934, 0.02371215634047985, 0.01868301071226597, 0.06278636306524277, -0.01993473805487156, 0.031787656247615814, -0.04760999605059624, -0.02845155820250511, 0.03185339272022247, -0.01691104657948017, -0.008767915889620781, -0.030652042478322983, -0.022191202268004417, 0.011830039322376251, -0.019600363448262215, -0.02185261994600296, 0.027290571480989456, -0.07938119769096375, 0.09726498275995255, 0.06980288773775101, -0.006993349641561508, 0.01702449470758438, -0.023743830621242523, 0.032933831214904785, 0.03584332764148712, -0.018541501834988594, -0.0004154114576522261, -0.08146391063928604, -0.06617504358291626, 0.05090002343058586, 0.002029094845056534, -0.04274161532521248, 0.014659101143479347, 0.06088918447494507, -0.006807746831327677, 0.018969928845763206, 0.013392599299550056, 0.00039892925997264683, -0.020634150132536888, 0.034619469195604324, 0.044108811765909195, 0.02023741416633129, 0.0008737370953895152, 0.029238397255539894, 0.04413147270679474, 0.016095634549856186, 0.0009281403035856783, 0.00909576565027237, 0.034861400723457336, -0.00668824277818203, 0.014798913151025772, -0.022502072155475616, -0.010826894082129002, 0.03468788042664528, -0.037669822573661804, 0.039035867899656296, 0.0480145663022995, 0.020589038729667664, -0.03301632031798363, 0.03377072513103485, -0.021568289026618004, 0.01691248081624508, 0.03808564320206642, -0.05965308099985123, 0.015530874952673912, 0.018351737409830093, -0.044088009744882584, 0.024585938081145287, -0.032555293291807175, -0.03343762457370758, -0.024408113211393356, 0.007558681070804596, 0.02512434311211109, -0.0067956410348415375, 0.03262995928525925, -0.01469638291746378, 0.0071625723503530025, -0.01217896118760109, -0.03443020209670067, -0.01000483799725771, 0.013386722654104233, -0.054277077317237854, -0.01984979212284088, -0.04043855145573616, -0.03862180933356285, 0.005664794705808163, -0.01704394444823265, 0.000021162404664210044, 0.040825966745615005, -0.019365277141332626, -0.042252592742443085, -0.0356537401676178, -0.023588811978697777, 0.007753943558782339, -0.022062040865421295, -0.045143306255340576, 0.037860773503780365, -0.022084658965468407, -0.05153454467654228, 0.012087894603610039, 0.007167505100369453, -0.0307414922863245, -0.018104786053299904, -0.011453771032392979, 0.03320998325943947, -0.017408913001418114, 0.033410102128982544, 0.016429457813501358, -0.053475335240364075, -0.0260789655148983, -0.07191488891839981, -0.060450222343206406, 0.0033395460341125727, 0.02714747004210949, 0.016950666904449463, -0.03262399509549141, -0.034983545541763306, 0.028269322589039803, 0.022610438987612724, -0.024371953681111336, -0.04879222437739372, -0.01035221479833126, -0.0402677021920681, -0.03532387316226959, 0.006467676255851984, 0.000936766853556037, 0.03212612494826317, 0.01608884334564209, 0.016367007046937943, 0.04040208458900452, 0.0023517441004514694, 0.03872748836874962, -0.007325362879782915, 0.04201149567961693, 0.027987657114863396, -0.006337627302855253, 0.02657821588218212, 0.028110530227422714, 0.018353592604398727, 0.002158957766368985, 0.024630878120660782, 0.05008484423160553, -0.001424135291017592, -0.017003647983074188, 0.03644513711333275, -0.02928205020725727, 0.00041691301157698035, 0.01062485296279192, -0.00030984755721874535, 0.02105926163494587, -0.016743315383791924, -0.033727679401636124, 0.019834306091070175, 0.030970172956585884, -0.02949821576476097, 0.01920109987258911, 0.029384670779109, 0.021670587360858917, -0.008005502633750439, 0.00481474120169878, -0.0068412963300943375, -0.03250085934996605, 0.0010835047578439116, -0.02834014594554901, -0.02923952043056488, 0.04448828101158142, 0.04328262805938721, -0.009649655781686306, -0.019664986059069633, -0.03769407421350479, -0.00795498862862587, -0.04407835751771927, -0.0018329250160604715, -0.0526009164750576, 0.0008714564028196037, -0.02126486599445343, 0.04645240679383278, 0.006493976339697838, -0.024502482265233994, -0.008866106159985065, -0.012034301646053791, -0.054144132882356644, 0.02184007689356804, -0.005709406919777393, -0.025859497487545013, 0.009631910361349583, 0.017171287909150124, 0.029352065175771713, -0.05819449573755264, 0.030497251078486443, 0.00017497764201834798, 0.016089795157313347, -0.000019796005290118046, 0.021739646792411804, -0.009048552252352238, -0.03223457559943199, 0.016426973044872284, 0.03579878434538841, 0.022237438708543777, 0.01004534400999546, 0.020313797518610954, 0.04751278832554817, -0.03859300911426544, 0.004381015431135893, -0.05186491087079048, -0.013945947401225567, 0.05074682459235191, 0.037109341472387314, 0.04763929173350334, 0.01317211240530014, -0.024019965901970863, 0.007279952988028526, 0.007051555439829826, 0.015173365361988544, 0.04136926308274269, -0.025992317125201225, -0.03337696194648743, -0.006804941687732935, -0.007046201266348362, 0.0019487213576212525, 0.03621570020914078, -0.009847447276115417, 0.008888921700417995, 0.0605502724647522, 0.03804045915603638, -0.029698872938752174, 0.021292198449373245, 0.09644301980733871, 0.010627694427967072, -0.031230082735419273, -0.0687137320637703, 0.020588723942637444, -0.012422152794897556, 0.0031434183474630117, 0.013831761665642262, 0.022000791504979134, -0.0011019647354260087, 0.005480289924889803, 0.018911603838205338, -0.0069698309525847435, -0.010383890941739082, 0.0033814706839621067, 0.0022324537858366966, 0.044449158012866974, -0.0045893085189163685, -0.047730814665555954, 0.03767215460538864, 0.028186140581965446, -0.0038654913660138845, 0.017509959638118744, 0.016879800707101822, -0.11134025454521179, 0.034614186733961105, 0.05701841413974762, 0.07762587815523148, -0.04840916022658348, -0.03394816443324089, -0.007786143105477095, 0.003733182093128562, 0.02132512256503105, -0.02993878908455372, 0.02210167609155178, -0.0174747034907341, 0.002193327061831951, -0.030931085348129272, -0.01698997989296913, -0.07711568474769592, 0.024571208283305168, -0.0224162507802248, 0.00922343134880066, -0.04596608132123947, -0.022970743477344513, -0.05554144084453583, 0.018384700641036034, -0.014624517410993576, 0.026277966797351837, -0.03684835135936737, -0.018123915418982506, -0.014978247694671154, 0.02592199482023716, -0.004768304526805878, -0.058206211775541306, 0.02554723061621189, 0.014640521258115768, -0.025205625221133232, 0.06062987446784973, -0.020019402727484703, -0.04976065829396248, 0.014369859360158443, 0.05240460857748985, -0.001839646603912115, 0.0034245378337800503, 0.006081586237996817, 0.06403549015522003, 0.02156050130724907, 0.0044491589069366455, 0.041277192533016205, 0.01588602550327778, 0.028011122718453407, -0.010216052643954754, -0.011864297091960907, -0.013525200076401234, -0.02026928961277008, -0.010741920210421085, -0.04256123676896095, 0.004049661103636026, -0.01529772486537695, 0.015257359482347965, -0.016175024211406708, -0.004753950983285904, -0.03631575033068657, -0.0052145011723041534, -0.0068602110259234905, 0.028440801426768303, -0.014737477526068687, -0.013490745797753334, -0.0050546759739518166, -0.013564269989728928, -0.01184766087681055, -0.015210606157779694, 0.010547531768679619, -0.011617923155426979, 0.0007560185622423887, 0.028637941926717758, -0.021285690367221832, 0.026707077398896217, -0.008852423168718815, -0.02324453555047512, -0.014700829982757568, -0.023022131994366646, -0.025438591837882996, 0.003465940710157156, 0.017846064642071724, -0.02179786004126072, -0.004193434491753578, 0.010564418509602547, 0.026986615732312202, 0.007042525336146355, 0.03078661672770977, -0.023953840136528015, 0.020265957340598106, -0.04525457322597504, 0.010243565775454044, -0.03920647129416466, -0.046842195093631744, 0.021945081651210785, -0.009580755606293678, -0.010269301943480968, -0.0035322196781635284, 0.005122993141412735, -0.017908619716763496, -0.03247255086898804, -0.023142259567975998, 0.04199622943997383, -0.049397267401218414, -0.017630288377404213, 0.0032664998434484005, 0.025463545694947243, 0.08337493985891342, -0.008598940446972847, -0.010119184851646423, 0.0212673582136631, -0.00988373626023531, -0.009203611873090267, 0.015548726543784142, -0.009185951203107834, -0.023577898740768433, -0.016341309994459152, -0.05214249715209007, -0.0100826071575284, 0.044824741780757904, -0.012630713172256947, -0.06672973185777664, 0.0006405132007785141, -0.021471010521054268, 0.00691609364002943, -0.02109573408961296, 0.011142877861857414, 0.005475956480950117, 0.012102431617677212, 0.017424773424863815, 0.047459717839956284, 0.002967841224744916, 0.01826002635061741, 0.011591964401304722, -0.01743021048605442, -0.04109124094247818, -0.0020056080538779497, 0.06910557299852371, 0.04214323312044144, 0.05587361752986908, -0.01453033834695816, -0.010204611346125603, 0.04735835641622543, -0.010398045182228088, -0.0070446147583425045, 0.004655870143324137, 0.05589050054550171, -0.06659211218357086, -0.020709749311208725, -0.042023446410894394, 0.007417143788188696, 0.0580085851252079, -0.023877441883087158, 0.03868340700864792, 0.06004508212208748, 0.008617325685918331, 0.0029839782509952784, -0.037668704986572266, -0.013904418796300888, -0.009229317307472229, -0.00139238394331187, 0.061512481421232224, -0.02634420618414879, 0.0012614622246474028, 0.055446796119213104, -0.0013998085632920265, 0.01873708702623844, 0.027418915182352066, 0.0031117177568376064, 0.0007886996027082205, 0.013075887225568295, -0.008119352161884308, -0.04982283338904381, 0.04533667862415314, -0.05782022699713707, -0.025254113599658012, -0.04435624182224274, -0.025391893461346626, 0.036860063672065735, 0.029964450746774673, 0.028804749250411987, -0.046080924570560455, -0.048295699059963226, -0.042071305215358734, 0.011220104061067104, 0.02009674347937107, -0.025670384988188744, 0.02039039134979248, -0.0011808301787823439, 0.048246532678604126, -0.0047349222004413605, 0.031146738678216934, -0.014509206637740135, -0.08022104948759079, -0.03223881125450134, -0.017830900847911835, 0.00439470587298274, 0.031630828976631165, -0.0031751682981848717, -0.02912922017276287, 0.01499978918582201, -0.051385972648859024, 0.006163385696709156, 0.00436702836304903, 0.043233517557382584, -0.0023602580185979605, 0.05335981398820877, -0.02517043612897396, 0.010074985213577747, 0.04307039454579353, -0.02670634351670742, 0.1202588900923729, 0.04832568019628525, 0.0037720485124737024, -0.057181648910045624, 0.015342527069151402, -0.007205568719655275, 0.0032185306772589684, -0.022852016612887383, -0.00319849094375968, 0.020356519147753716, -0.02357056364417076, 0.030890468508005142, 0.03325474634766579, 0.012299993075430393, -0.007046839222311974, 0.06052839383482933, -0.04140255227684975, -0.06236201524734497, 0.010510575957596302, 0.012539693154394627, -0.013549682684242725, -0.03213893249630928, -0.033122625201940536, 0.0017613446107134223, 0.021546751260757446, -0.007893156260251999, 0.00609202217310667, 0.017270155251026154, 0.014935564249753952, 0.004976559896022081, -0.028426097705960274, 0.003766408422961831, 0.005114772357046604, 0.04340951517224312, -0.023208145052194595, -0.010842249728739262, 0.020927613601088524, -0.03288489580154419, 0.006102961488068104, 0.02844950184226036, -0.024661539122462273, -0.0016897619934752584, 0.01866168901324272, 0.022354861721396446, -0.06113554164767265, -0.018714116886258125, 0.0032835735473781824, 0.06984668225049973, 0.02999517321586609, -0.01698092557489872, -0.02651485614478588, -0.008786915801465511, 0.030528344213962555, -0.03239739313721657, -0.04628533124923706, 0.029903298243880272, 0.04184602573513985, -0.033091720193624496, 0.014580472372472286, -0.02105945535004139, -0.0011463429545983672, 0.022107910364866257, 0.04212863743305206, 0.03732164204120636, -0.05134708806872368, 0.0025913577992469072, -0.026790810748934746, 0.05002082884311676, -0.003430568613111973, -0.011762470006942749, 0.007099027279764414, -0.012474152259528637, -0.02538400888442993, 0.002408354775980115, 0.01291526760905981, 0.02853481099009514, 0.029948564246296883, 0.00009022561425808817, -0.002193103078752756, -0.0005080382688902318, -0.02989101968705654, 0.004682387690991163, -0.04013371467590332, 0.01135067269206047, -0.07361481338739395, 0.009179786778986454, 0.04480244219303131, 0.022880174219608307, 0.026960009709000587, 0.022416977211833, 0.017661506310105324, 0.07274825125932693, -0.007826421409845352, -0.030705507844686508, -0.051633454859256744, 0.017915837466716766, -0.01752673089504242, -0.015687095001339912, -0.01812892220914364, 0.03053334169089794, -0.01200891938060522, 0.04016418382525444, 0.0032300371676683426, 0.032190050929784775, -0.026025276631116867, 0.03808828443288803, 0.024692146107554436, -0.042218588292598724, 0.00725297536700964, 0.022648697718977928, 0.0015681268414482474, -0.014750020578503609, -0.009271729737520218, -0.043272361159324646, 0.001309525570832193, 0.026339469477534294, -0.04007754847407341, -0.03817472979426384, -0.010091353207826614, -0.016223840415477753, 0.051731232553720474, -0.03661557659506798, -0.02885305881500244, -0.05651435628533363, 0.0023281050380319357, 0.03035128302872181, -0.04254269227385521, 0.027574807405471802, 0.014204215258359909, -0.034746203571558, 0.03219650685787201, 0.011085313744843006, 0.027537913993000984, -0.00672843586653471, -0.033218227326869965, -0.013809502124786377, 0.006122419144958258, 0.06146390736103058, -0.029421739280223846, -0.04180176928639412, 0.023252267390489578, -0.02762410044670105, -0.030146969482302666, 0.009381681680679321, 0.011632156558334827, 0.0506725050508976, 0.023810597136616707, 0.0013836328871548176, -0.0316254086792469, 0.049849607050418854, -0.020015964284539223, 0.020069077610969543, 0.012058674357831478, -0.009779293090105057, 0.00048787484411150217, -0.00836652796715498, -0.008283611387014389, 0.015881309285759926, -0.020225832238793373, 0.034010082483291626, 0.06705431640148163, 0.015855656936764717, -0.0042190225794911385, 0.028931036591529846, 0.010095336474478245, 0.05614545941352844, 0.00046550255501642823, -0.006822187919169664, 0.028338592499494553, 0.06730880588293076, -0.023565026000142097, 0.050554096698760986, -0.013529826886951923, 0.04655914753675461, -0.07570759952068329, -0.03846777603030205, -0.020775558426976204, 0.04998445510864258, 0.008563384413719177, -0.07369311898946762, 0.00328697613440454, 0.00016258624964393675, -0.03676557540893555, 0.030650198459625244, -0.017398973926901817, -0.021118346601724625, -0.047658585011959076, 0.016554562374949455, -0.032374732196331024, 0.0029164894949644804, 0.026661425828933716, 0.014828471466898918, 0.032399993389844894, 0.02179240994155407, 0.006115628406405449, -0.01652747020125389, -0.003240755759179592, 0.013076039031147957, -0.011215012520551682, -0.05236144736409187, 0.05175104737281799, -0.03664635494351387, -0.04022076725959778, 0.00212147762067616, -0.0016190260648727417, 0.02325085736811161, 0.039105042815208435, 0.026092244312167168, 0.007778019178658724, 0.052760470658540726, 0.051487263292074203, -0.007600550074130297, 0.0029259095899760723, 0.0008805442485027015, 0.01156641822308302, 0.04234704002737999, -0.021185968071222305, 0.013287664391100407, 0.019015830010175705, -0.005835691466927528, -0.023151608183979988, 0.010183624923229218, -0.004364649765193462, -0.015120833180844784, -0.034213513135910034, 0.003772147698327899, 0.004137539304792881, -0.012494955211877823, 0.022022556513547897, -0.08900626748800278, -0.016237584874033928, 0.022213386371731758, 0.026314064860343933, -0.01879235915839672, -0.013390452601015568, -0.03420471400022507, -0.02574259601533413, 0.009162782691419125, 0.013361004181206226, 0.024272562935948372, -0.05731622874736786, 0.015649640932679176, 0.01865248940885067, -0.006317202001810074, -0.039525315165519714, 0.004212002269923687, -0.022703003138303757, 0.047126222401857376, -0.026103541254997253, -0.00008018121297936887, 0.01605929248034954, -0.05714283138513565, 0.010787255130708218, -0.08783523738384247, 0.04056999087333679, 0.03492548316717148, -0.03959131985902786, -0.0440143421292305, 0.001290883868932724, -0.08142262697219849, 0.010132872499525547, 0.03456953540444374, -0.0008672708063386381, 0.0016669450560584664, 0.003384094685316086, 0.027923129498958588, 0.01150386594235897, -0.04013217240571976, 0.03523346036672592, -0.009798401966691017, 0.018354764208197594, 0.0014830655418336391, 0.009278629906475544, 0.019548697397112846, 0.02010362409055233, 0.041244253516197205, -0.012757248245179653, -0.021824799478054047, 0.014061227440834045, 0.0011771413264796138, 0.03632678464055061, 0.020406587049365044, -0.0030730178114026785, 0.044363465160131454, 0.00427071051672101, 0.037073470652103424, 0.059412699192762375, 0.008719302713871002, -0.05197706073522568, 0.026158057153224945, -0.02860301360487938, -0.022082842886447906, -0.011917486786842346, 0.02123233675956726, -0.005466039292514324, -0.007998509332537651, 0.0214360523968935, 0.010150137357413769, -0.02740509621798992, -0.008123164065182209, -0.0000678109863656573, 0.03281749412417412, 0.042127978056669235, 0.008700116537511349, 0.02989443764090538, 0.03967754915356636, -0.015987029299139977, 0.011439899913966656, 0.0412716306746006, 0.03736649453639984, 0.01194466557353735, -0.022009752690792084, 0.03009519912302494, -0.046934012323617935, 0.004718808922916651, 0.0019791023805737495, 0.025883909314870834, -0.0031097803730517626, -0.0011852658353745937, 0.008977821096777916, -0.020962132140994072, 0.006773872766643763, -0.005892473738640547, 0.02555396594107151, 0.025358710438013077, -0.03646772727370262, -0.0020473445765674114, -0.030731400474905968, 0.0015295372577384114, -0.010371238924562931, 0.016693811863660812, -0.007659550756216049, -0.00773282628506422, -0.0300503671169281, 0.003948803525418043, 0.006894061807543039, -0.028875842690467834, -0.004981483332812786, -0.03058699145913124, 0.011962546035647392, -0.030076202005147934, -0.0031882678158581257, -0.020940689370036125, -0.019066521897912025, -0.04095771908760071, -0.04800587147474289, 0.044158775359392166, 0.03493580222129822, 0.014071427285671234, -0.04004741460084915, -0.029749255627393723, -0.026761310175061226, 0.04152695834636688, -0.043936554342508316, -0.028407827019691467, -0.03037266805768013, 0.030165886506438255, 0.051083799451589584, -0.016836043447256088 ]
<p>I'm very new to SAS, so please keep that in mind with any responses.</p> <p>I've been running the following code in SAS:</p> <pre><code>FILENAME fishfile URL "http://www.amstat.org/publications/jse/datasets/fishcatch.dat"; PROC FORMAT; VALUE sexfmt 0="female" 1="male"; VALUE speciesfmt 1="common bream" 2="whitefish" 3="roach" 4="silver bream" 5="smelt" 6="pike" 7="perch"; INVALUE misscode "NA"=. ; RUN; DATA fish; INFILE fishfile; INPUT obs species weight length1 length2 length3 hgtpct widpct sex; INFORMAT weight sex misscode.; LABEL length1="Nose to tail beginning length" length2="Nose to tail notch length" length3="Nose to tail end length"; FORMAT species speciesfmt. sex sexfmt.; RUN; </code></pre> <p>All of the above code runs without any errors. The following code gives me errors:</p> <pre><code>TITLE "Finnish Fish: Species distribution"; PROC SGPLOT DATA=fish; VBAR species; RUN; TITLE "Finnish Fish: Weight in grams"; PROC SGPLOT DATA=fish; HISTOGRAM weight; RUN; </code></pre> <p>I can't access the data right now so I don't have the specific error, but it says something along the lines of "Insufficient authorization" when I try to view the resulting plots. I will post the actual error message when I can access the data again, but until then I'm hoping that someone has encountered this error and found a solution.</p>
37,079
[ -0.012849166989326477, -0.05740375444293022, 0.004913410171866417, -0.02233889512717724, 0.009688937105238438, 0.002003350993618369, -0.015445138327777386, 0.008050091564655304, 0.021813271567225456, 0.0013807915383949876, 0.07504801452159882, 0.06742049008607864, 0.07772569358348846, 0.027340969070792198, 0.02571764402091503, -0.010862164199352264, -0.013331647962331772, -0.01847011037170887, -0.018026959151029587, 0.0010990564478561282, 0.031073447316884995, 0.031249267980456352, 0.00024159764871001244, -0.015190605074167252, 0.009221991524100304, 0.013234954327344894, 0.024750718846917152, -0.0029981606639921665, 0.028874926269054413, 0.046733032912015915, -0.026173368096351624, -0.026508349925279617, 0.0025151630397886038, -0.015249342657625675, 0.02067471668124199, -0.028217390179634094, -0.05543223395943642, -0.01652122288942337, -0.038547154515981674, 0.014331549406051636, -0.032785408198833466, 0.010521476157009602, 0.02223936840891838, 0.0611039474606514, 0.01172293908894062, -0.018203558400273323, 0.020512240007519722, 0.02087637223303318, 0.037130530923604965, -0.015338280238211155, 0.06904421746730804, -0.00013466582458931953, 0.0491592139005661, 0.006234240718185902, -0.033368583768606186, 0.021061765030026436, 0.03873231261968613, 0.06678280979394913, -0.006629369221627712, -0.03827905282378197, 0.017975939437747, -0.008453933522105217, -0.01048976369202137, -0.027990935370326042, -0.05996207520365715, -0.004425103776156902, -0.05079949274659157, -0.0661701038479805, 0.015001548454165459, 0.024855589494109154, 0.008731554262340069, 0.03166242688894272, -0.001286724698729813, -0.03340933099389076, 0.03901350125670433, -0.03179888799786568, 0.030830400064587593, -0.0013458776520565152, 0.04964205250144005, 0.010723724961280823, 0.006774577312171459, 0.06347860395908356, 0.00870583951473236, 0.024991890415549278, 0.06256338953971863, -0.007243095897138119, 0.06091219186782837, -0.011735633946955204, 0.028286458924412727, 0.024589279666543007, -0.011827769689261913, 0.0068599083460867405, 0.06387215107679367, 0.018510984256863594, -0.022597940638661385, 0.028396792709827423, -0.0027938999701291323, 0.07070819288492203, -0.04376831278204918, -0.004896081052720547, 0.03592536598443985, -0.03405804559588432, 0.06134467199444771, 0.017878767102956772, -0.029663456603884697, -0.0435720793902874, -0.034438855946063995, -0.00877404771745205, -0.011586395092308521, -0.0297564510256052, 0.005014276131987572, 0.03818131238222122, 0.025463426485657692, -0.030333414673805237, -0.00037619206705130637, -0.03130340948700905, -0.004528173711150885, 0.0715777650475502, 0.04993263632059097, 0.013086534105241299, 0.051985081285238266, -0.008621439337730408, 0.020220443606376648, -0.028524786233901978, -0.09295386075973511, -0.009373181499540806, -0.02711871825158596, -0.018825311213731766, -0.022678514942526817, 0.0817144513130188, -0.016071733087301254, -0.019124262034893036, 0.07235527783632278, -0.037589821964502335, 0.01855112425982952, -0.04478582739830017, -0.09245240688323975, -0.09317872673273087, 0.0015711280284449458, 0.012072638608515263, 0.044363152235746384, -0.06411775201559067, 0.025642303749918938, 0.044500283896923065, 0.03522917255759239, 0.010068926960229874, 0.004354448523372412, 0.0032325247302651405, 0.017014112323522568, -0.035234563052654266, 0.010066580958664417, -0.03154716640710831, -0.01958831399679184, -0.013120020739734173, -0.001340884598903358, -0.037425778806209564, 0.00756344199180603, 0.021609263494610786, -0.003718285821378231, -0.02011146768927574, 0.030320314690470695, 0.0029177754186093807, 0.031744472682476044, -0.04757794365286827, -0.02940899319946766, -0.042264845222234726, 0.09632021933794022, 0.016438020393252373, -0.006849763449281454, 0.039397578686475754, -0.00530181685462594, 0.0003227395936846733, -0.012635079212486744, 0.031111031770706177, 0.08544674515724182, 0.0026300351601094007, 0.001177552854642272, 0.0106098223477602, 0.0027073659002780914, 0.01394836138933897, 0.03785160928964615, -0.01781812496483326, -0.0017737947637215257, 0.002958492375910282, 0.06463155895471573, -0.0064964317716658115, 0.02270336262881756, -0.015351095236837864, 0.011063537560403347, -0.0706750825047493, -0.023715399205684662, -0.04372072592377663, -0.029684478417038918, -0.06335427612066269, -0.03690115734934807, -0.018997663632035255, 0.0003663724346552044, -0.00033483761944808066, 0.025095101445913315, -0.07419142127037048, -0.035228900611400604, -0.015898874029517174, 0.07303835451602936, -0.021658465266227722, -0.023442629724740982, 0.031195489689707756, -0.016300443559885025, -0.02496076002717018, 0.02310706302523613, -0.037386808544397354, -0.03723868355154991, 0.03485499322414398, -0.020883895456790924, -0.0015161634655669332, 0.029202867299318314, -0.0010439091129228473, -0.02784448117017746, 0.011258385144174099, -0.030619410797953606, 0.03494489938020706, -0.015047113411128521, 0.035012438893318176, 0.06465764343738556, 0.020163070410490036, -0.03517173230648041, -0.015203041955828667, 0.018992966040968895, -0.021124154329299927, -0.013643617741763592, -0.003126571187749505, -0.03455997630953789, 0.011004709638655186, 0.03666877746582031, -0.006471656262874603, -0.035501401871442795, -0.021314097568392754, 0.06050095334649086, -0.025932470336556435, -0.008518281392753124, 0.03571347892284393, -0.013912584632635117, -0.009361185133457184, 0.005573369096964598, 0.0200724545866251, 0.024747531861066818, 0.03857980668544769, 0.02763536386191845, 0.036395199596881866, 0.030511928722262383, 0.017810184508562088, -0.017880000174045563, 0.05691472440958023, -0.04656055197119713, -0.059005171060562134, -0.0031529448460787535, -0.018414417281746864, 0.0639783963561058, -0.02968287281692028, 0.014103647321462631, 0.05879446864128113, 0.005496213212609291, -0.004904796369373798, 0.00959835946559906, 0.01335588376969099, 0.00908130593597889, 0.03179258853197098, 0.01363444235175848, -0.021764039993286133, 0.005911659449338913, -0.03982952982187271, -0.0006585654336959124, -0.022953873500227928, -0.021853921934962273, -0.05403266102075577, 0.024360839277505875, 0.033115655183792114, -0.018830372020602226, 0.05091164633631706, -0.01772429421544075, -0.028541043400764465, -0.022278066724538803, -0.02228996530175209, -0.007245450280606747, -0.011868278495967388, -0.054626669734716415, 0.01787017658352852, 0.021191241219639778, 0.01777387224137783, -0.0008541205315850675, -0.011677108705043793, -0.046373482793569565, 0.021855078637599945, -0.028085576370358467, -0.02274269051849842, -0.04304438829421997, -0.00844624638557434, 0.008200899697840214, -0.025583872571587563, 0.010562896728515625, 0.04880978912115097, 0.02258242666721344, 0.024609366431832314, 0.028218422085046768, -0.03124156966805458, 0.007129127625375986, -0.022901810705661774, 0.06302628666162491, -0.02067192643880844, 0.004556674975901842, -0.024915728718042374, 0.004702819511294365, -0.018498199060559273, -0.022603711113333702, -0.016517767682671547, -0.06456194072961807, 0.005189986899495125, 0.04516337811946869, 0.012551406398415565, -0.00934270117431879, -0.0047433883883059025, 0.022931192070245743, 0.005007946863770485, -0.041405946016311646, -0.034724339842796326, -0.03689277917146683, -0.022759228944778442, 0.002974763046950102, 0.006752643268555403, -0.01350138895213604, 0.007126637268811464, 0.017831867560744286, -0.0002588058414403349, 0.0476682148873806, 0.046250611543655396, -0.022904912009835243, -0.04180089756846428, 0.01920204982161522, -0.007267805282026529, -0.023631388321518898, 0.04744172841310501, 0.04484320431947708, -0.0211278535425663, 0.002034791512414813, -0.031000608578324318, 0.007841880433261395, 0.0402994267642498, -0.05518901348114014, 0.009215219877660275, -0.016719942912459373, 0.07319821417331696, -0.03678378090262413, 0.005618969444185495, 0.021341392770409584, -0.0023868782445788383, 0.012828200124204159, 0.014887499623000622, 0.039397355169057846, -0.03623715043067932, -0.03551122173666954, 0.057482633739709854, 0.0018264570971950889, -0.005597603507339954, -0.010714472271502018, -0.022002171725034714, 0.01133336964994669, 0.016556883230805397, -0.01790173351764679, 0.005639469716697931, 0.01922287605702877, 0.05111243203282356, 0.007615267764776945, -0.008877209387719631, -0.04333998262882233, 0.032450102269649506, -0.047075532376766205, -0.03022157959640026, -0.013614737428724766, 0.022922182455658913, 0.01220642402768135, 0.006876286119222641, 0.040096208453178406, 0.021976642310619354, -0.008171597495675087, -0.012690412811934948, -0.0486283078789711, -0.017119625583291054, 0.0030459007248282433, 0.016795499250292778, 0.03320208191871643, -0.035624269396066666, 0.018451474606990814, -0.04761017486453056, 0.005023187026381493, 0.02714390680193901, 0.020617756992578506, -0.0408979170024395, 0.034206416457891464, 0.016778653487563133, 0.04497869312763214, -0.035678550601005554, 0.03144785761833191, 0.04362260922789574, -0.0073581174947321415, 0.025570128113031387, 0.04699026420712471, -0.0059773484244942665, -0.05270886421203613, -0.04842274636030197, 0.006386180408298969, 0.033562012016773224, 0.038186151534318924, 0.02679685316979885, 0.03327028453350067, -0.05313941463828087, 0.0022147023119032383, -0.03141425922513008, 0.05374755710363388, 0.02433585748076439, 0.02667519636452198, 0.005345421377569437, -0.022961167618632317, 0.008500262163579464, -0.004453882575035095, 0.017942916601896286, -0.012260941788554192, 0.012101175263524055, -0.02384505420923233, 0.01155367773026228, -0.05781126022338867, 0.02783174067735672, 0.052567992359399796, 0.0288537610322237, 0.03581918403506279, -0.013158051297068596, -0.03403541445732117, -0.03961971402168274, -0.02474861405789852, 0.019244736060500145, 0.02177380584180355, 0.020143870264291763, -0.018623825162649155, 0.011722775176167488, -0.03493031859397888, 0.013522274792194366, 0.023499349132180214, -0.010829015634953976, 0.012048531323671341, -0.009976562112569809, -0.004541777539998293, 0.058519989252090454, -0.007462697569280863, 0.019424092024564743, 0.02810557931661606, 0.012259450741112232, -0.0757141262292862, -0.03390013799071312, 0.05161513015627861, 0.0410442128777504, -0.026934245601296425, -0.011979836039245129, -0.017563508823513985, 0.005714085418730974, 0.025000721216201782, -0.052680909633636475, 0.020709669217467308, -0.034890905022621155, 0.026071473956108093, 0.0005914970533922315, -0.03586196154356003, -0.027258755639195442, -0.013305606320500374, -0.02565228007733822, 0.018267709761857986, -0.030677706003189087, -0.011431901715695858, 0.010027563199400902, 0.030861208215355873, 0.0036572145763784647, 0.017980169504880905, -0.024424299597740173, -0.05702539160847664, 0.013697420246899128, 0.006761801894754171, -0.048753347247838974, -0.009938010945916176, -0.008038664236664772, -0.018061650916934013, 0.023843619972467422, 0.059087853878736496, -0.0385112538933754, -0.04158425331115723, 0.02995608001947403, 0.004280945286154747, -0.023589449003338814, -0.0352623425424099, -0.012797129340469837, 0.02427157200872898, 0.043187566101551056, 0.009647514671087265, 0.0413733571767807, 0.04987344145774841, 0.0045589255169034, -0.0178708303719759, -0.08883404731750488, 0.007732008118182421, -0.04067111760377884, -0.0336516797542572, -0.06102849543094635, 0.03381539508700371, 0.017195338383316994, 0.029462164267897606, -0.016486577689647675, -0.009028797037899494, -0.08618530631065369, 0.01338065043091774, 0.03984890133142471, 0.028214076533913612, 0.0073207225650548935, -0.008828116580843925, 0.007118172012269497, 0.0030522828456014395, -0.0431099571287632, -0.02697289176285267, 0.0011353717418387532, -0.01851443387567997, -0.010783489793539047, 0.021019211038947105, 0.000835691811516881, 0.0013771605445072055, -0.007857472635805607, -0.025454973801970482, 0.013150437735021114, -0.05942307785153389, 0.0021554469130933285, -0.03829912096261978, 0.012095378711819649, 0.002483028220012784, -0.03494644537568092, -0.016270367428660393, -0.01347237080335617, 0.010259807109832764, -0.0029134200885891914, -0.003470060648396611, 0.06035054102540016, 0.006130022928118706, 0.04165220633149147, -0.03171375393867493, -0.06114654988050461, -0.007793908007442951, 0.017006956040859222, -0.024686254560947418, -0.010688855312764645, -0.0554693341255188, 0.02353758178651333, 0.015898318961262703, -0.011122168973088264, 0.020162098109722137, -0.006339797750115395, -0.00648540211841464, 0.011844444088637829, 0.01934320293366909, 0.061003170907497406, -0.01033987756818533, 0.04361634701490402, 0.024109765887260437, 0.01229541003704071, -0.06705950200557709, 0.026470424607396126, 0.00801540445536375, -0.028315193951129913, -0.04409576579928398, 0.007651118561625481, 0.009327225387096405, 0.02131437137722969, 0.0297761932015419, 0.00968557596206665, -0.03434430807828903, -0.01145756896585226, 0.0053064399398863316, 0.003693433478474617, 0.0072632525116205215, -0.033245597034692764, 0.0071993558667600155, -0.053386084735393524, -0.007952247746288776, -0.027000457048416138, 0.02108539454638958, -0.015213100239634514, 0.018117574974894524, 0.025888660922646523, 0.04401296749711037, 0.033763594925403595, -0.03006582334637642, 0.02334493212401867, -0.011083053424954414, -0.006984656676650047, 0.0025756130926311016, 0.018666407093405724, 0.015018448233604431, 0.002527570119127631, 0.04212802276015282, -0.02695106714963913, -0.00905795767903328, -0.016061915084719658, 0.0022110785357654095, 0.04572223871946335, -0.014666467905044556, -0.0005241056205704808, -0.013428309932351112, -0.02377953566610813, 0.026642490178346634, -0.05947994440793991, -0.04661809653043747, -0.0007371943793259561, 0.026671109721064568, 0.07851792126893997, 0.043267957866191864, -0.006506273057311773, 0.004368705675005913, 0.010899361222982407, 0.04490092769265175, 0.046752672642469406, 0.024290135130286217, -0.0032079422380775213, -0.014309840276837349, -0.033659428358078, -0.08640682697296143, 0.0327509306371212, 0.00857960432767868, 0.05169108510017395, -0.011298918165266514, 0.00037288866587914526, 0.029691707342863083, 0.016956914216279984, 0.010035363957285881, -0.050297971814870834, -0.016555018723011017, -0.002898005535826087, 0.019302284345030785, -0.031516484916210175, -0.044227465987205505, -0.0069749560207128525, -0.01453938614577055, 0.008549369871616364, -0.015794504433870316, 0.039177022874355316, -0.00010577869397820905, -0.05521564185619354, -0.008817417547106743, -0.02637258544564247, -0.008946128189563751, 0.06010271608829498, -0.00012664590030908585, -0.0017338792094960809, 0.014326270669698715, -0.02517925389111042, 0.044451095163822174, -0.013950576074421406, 0.05084804445505142, 0.043356336653232574, 0.0952557623386383, -0.005770932883024216, 0.02128153294324875, -0.009437834843993187, 0.013391386717557907, 0.13581667840480804, 0.06256890296936035, 0.03713751956820488, -0.050090789794921875, 0.02310906909406185, -0.022487832233309746, -0.005333703476935625, -0.016574954614043236, -0.004279673099517822, 0.01900448277592659, 0.009713667444884777, 0.06648781150579453, -0.019184578210115433, -0.003306569065898657, 0.03141890838742256, 0.057417526841163635, -0.06183115020394325, -0.05443893000483513, -0.014370168559253216, -0.010976145043969154, -0.02766626700758934, -0.0006107172230258584, -0.0640399158000946, 0.0019565755501389503, 0.045737091451883316, -0.029882129281759262, -0.01494556199759245, -0.021237539127469063, -0.010334865190088749, 0.027761245146393776, -0.005789199844002724, -0.01858607679605484, 0.007485193200409412, 0.04952291026711464, 0.017870144918560982, -0.025015192106366158, 0.011939127929508686, -0.01353742741048336, -0.004359624348580837, 0.028519926592707634, 0.009245894849300385, 0.020663568750023842, -0.015524444170296192, 0.018053971230983734, -0.021074337884783745, -0.003624227363616228, 0.024401700124144554, 0.029469963163137436, 0.013573911972343922, 0.01115277037024498, -0.03362429514527321, 0.017760496586561203, 0.044807687401771545, -0.04664194956421852, -0.034295786172151566, -0.01769312284886837, 0.01139265950769186, 0.021788164973258972, 0.000569405616261065, -0.027420945465564728, 0.029528921470046043, -0.03873061388731003, 0.01705976389348507, 0.014345594681799412, 0.021791016682982445, 0.026333147659897804, -0.0646224394440651, 0.014459821395576, -0.0054994490928947926, 0.005488245747983456, 0.03017222322523594, -0.0035227874759584665, -0.013847501017153263, -0.017752166837453842, -0.010049349628388882, 0.010463662445545197, 0.02057233825325966, 0.0005139483255334198, -0.03261859714984894, -0.023252464830875397, -0.05129539966583252, 0.016595754772424698, -0.0429176390171051, -0.03768598660826683, -0.027433088049292564, 0.023189159110188484, 0.010957970283925533, 0.028604663908481598, -0.0009024484315887094, 0.032616958022117615, -0.017872583121061325, 0.07206481695175171, 0.03208943083882332, -0.028882669284939766, -0.03595276176929474, 0.04766654223203659, -0.05098284035921097, 0.005271990317851305, 0.005265703424811363, 0.04447795823216438, 0.01063747238367796, 0.05309036001563072, -0.03421301022171974, -0.012471993453800678, 0.0520140714943409, -0.014015639200806618, 0.02457674965262413, -0.015158482827246189, 0.025380302220582962, -0.018772372975945473, 0.02553737163543701, -0.040894538164138794, -0.035362470895051956, -0.021177222952246666, -0.024915792047977448, 0.011050251312553883, 0.007097485009580851, -0.04526009038090706, 0.004370889626443386, -0.015027616173028946, -0.01573123224079609, 0.01548558659851551, 0.03436523303389549, -0.04842838644981384, -0.027675854042172432, 0.003585905535146594, 0.003762589767575264, -0.048674557358026505, 0.0035929165314882994, -0.04813114181160927, 0.028340190649032593, -0.007154644466936588, 0.015610286965966225, 0.025955386459827423, 0.004085812717676163, -0.009955725632607937, 0.014028255827724934, 0.05341575667262077, 0.007104094605892897, -0.002417885698378086, 0.034022022038698196, -0.05593273043632507, -0.013033842667937279, -0.03010197915136814, -0.0132294287905097, 0.007951281033456326, 0.0004329047806095332, -0.0037774236407130957, -0.034599900245666504, 0.06359609961509705, 0.011373922228813171, -0.01231416966766119, 0.01596757397055626, -0.020707160234451294, 0.004163614008575678, 0.07412716001272202, -0.0011714485008269548, 0.02571970783174038, -0.02786216326057911, 0.0319787859916687, 0.047196563333272934, 0.022754689678549767, 0.002677413634955883, -0.021736472845077515, 0.011166438460350037, -0.019299151375889778, -0.009757927618920803, -0.029700778424739838, 0.04126378893852234, 0.06950113922357559, -0.04501033201813698, 0.018160635605454445, -0.018371280282735825, 0.030839772894978523, -0.06189228594303131, -0.008505400270223618, -0.025493107736110687, 0.009512826800346375, -0.006508608348667622, -0.02350965142250061, 0.032494910061359406, 0.028873372822999954, -0.04822047799825668, -0.008208023384213448, -0.010613946244120598, -0.031237104907631874, -0.04139158874750137, 0.012397830374538898, -0.027332505211234093, -0.007264100946485996, 0.02640586905181408, 0.0021432770881801844, 0.04763990268111229, -0.0005768549162894487, 0.018064133822917938, -0.006985314656049013, -0.04095867648720741, 0.06171005591750145, 0.03288339450955391, -0.047224752604961395, -0.013143916614353657, -0.04490763321518898, 0.002899902407079935, -0.009106889367103577, -0.050409842282533646, -0.0024527767673134804, 0.030545711517333984, -0.02070518396794796, 0.01655147783458233, 0.03779882937669754, 0.0026476297061890364, 0.0016352713573724031, -0.036839570850133896, -0.0016698914114385843, -0.022562747821211815, 0.011417009867727757, -0.00023226234770845622, 0.013269220478832722, 0.01653665117919445, -0.01818723790347576, -0.0068163941614329815, -0.005612959153950214, -0.05317355692386627, -0.012809480540454388, -0.021107131615281105, -0.03040243126451969, 0.04864528402686119, -0.030816536396741867, -0.004868245683610439, -0.028882412239909172, -0.005069687496870756, 0.03265225142240524, -0.02255810983479023, 0.005554688163101673, 0.0072347018867731094, 0.03143260255455971, -0.028327330946922302, -0.01439125370234251, 0.033139247447252274, -0.009771381504833698, 0.021018581464886665, -0.014203173108398914, -0.005385718774050474, 0.010384846478700638, 0.0350826159119606, 0.023725861683487892, -0.009957960806787014, 0.0663042962551117, -0.027654604986310005, -0.004614273086190224, 0.03328821063041687, 0.020020488649606705, 0.01614098809659481, -0.07875415682792664, 0.054130516946315765, 0.019142352044582367, -0.0003402766305953264, -0.06381440907716751, -0.00903309229761362, -0.0037441132590174675, 0.028616318479180336, 0.009937320835888386, 0.010819952003657818, 0.010943307541310787, -0.05804066359996796, 0.026667490601539612, -0.037049971520900726, -0.055016666650772095, 0.06200243532657623, 0.013112487271428108, -0.013661018572747707, 0.011528901755809784, -0.009142793715000153, 0.012531889602541924, 0.01375198271125555, -0.027343139052391052, -0.0020589679479599, 0.01321400422602892, 0.017094934359192848, -0.002946982393041253, -0.0024866422172635794, -0.018642965704202652, -0.034423939883708954, 0.045371733605861664, 0.021323898807168007, -0.022058915346860886, 0.02794247306883335, 0.025117473676800728, -0.018648840487003326, 0.04813137277960777, -0.0462290421128273, -0.00673561030998826, 0.004365523345768452, 0.0025027566589415073, 0.007675427012145519, -0.09308093041181564, 0.04063382372260094, -0.041797567158937454, -0.024614527821540833, -0.0018803400453180075, 0.014104442670941353, 0.022564388811588287, 0.030081074684858322, -0.016527261584997177, 0.00736813060939312, -0.04281013458967209, 0.0010156183270737529, 0.031312476843595505, 0.031279951333999634, -0.006219410803169012, 0.0017720649484544992, 0.02534373663365841, 0.04010945186018944, -0.004281335044652224, 0.03922401741147041, 0.013989420607686043, 0.051905740052461624, 0.014203211292624474, -0.03693957254290581, 0.006175662856549025, -0.006020329426974058, -0.009968903847038746, 0.009611380286514759, -0.03071538545191288, 0.05042433738708496, -0.025302624329924583, 0.0023853008169680834, -0.028474140912294388, -0.025598449632525444, -0.0028447345830500126, 0.008287781849503517, 0.00930884387344122, 0.005601301323622465, -0.00536999711766839, 0.00863285455852747, -0.037598393857479095, -0.011501344852149487, 0.047123026102781296, -0.02080867625772953, -0.0017210881924256682, -0.0007815585704520345, 0.03166709467768669, 0.008396279066801071, -0.041159700602293015, 0.008973725140094757, 0.024013198912143707, 0.029519766569137573, 0.025212468579411507, -0.017696235328912735, -0.04439926519989967, -0.009652841836214066, 0.03045244701206684, 0.03719112277030945, -0.039343781769275665, -0.043921779841184616, -0.00527624785900116, -0.0007385965436697006, -0.001156303915195167, -0.020807979628443718 ]
<p>When I perform a linear regression in some software packages (for example Mathematica), I get p-values associated with the individual parameters in the model. For, instance the results of a linear regression that produces a result $ax+b$ will have a p-value associated with $a$ and one with $b$.</p> <ol> <li><p>What do these p-values mean individually about those parameters? </p></li> <li><p>Is there a general way to compute parameters for any regression model?</p></li> <li><p>Can the p-value associated with each parameter be combined into a p-value for the whole model?</p></li> </ol> <p>To keep this question mathematical in nature, I am seeking only the interpretation of p-values in terms of probabilities. </p>
48,796
[ -0.04028664901852608, -0.025933219119906425, -0.012893332168459892, -0.026002448052167892, 0.030258968472480774, 0.05150377005338669, -0.028704293072223663, -0.012783801183104515, 0.02718055248260498, -0.05694672092795372, 0.04259580001235008, 0.024074144661426544, 0.04548558592796326, -0.006739581469446421, 0.015064439736306667, 0.02914140187203884, -0.011369247920811176, -0.0022754755336791277, -0.005483642686158419, 0.004775033798068762, 0.039876680821180344, 0.03640886768698692, 0.019393129274249077, -0.005477824714034796, -0.00408460758626461, 0.07297319918870926, 0.04568169265985489, -0.021944427862763405, 0.03872636333107948, 0.090674489736557, -0.006325450725853443, -0.031221622601151466, 0.021849531680345535, 0.04380495101213455, 0.010862616822123528, -0.01719278283417225, 0.00898913387209177, -0.012137576937675476, -0.0009718385408632457, 0.04802590236067772, -0.018081683665513992, -0.04816393181681633, 0.015670768916606903, 0.019224531948566437, 0.000164565906743519, 0.003768300637602806, 0.005385528784245253, -0.04342006519436836, 0.006152926478534937, -0.05349064990878105, 0.06798119843006134, -0.0021679983474314213, 0.034642525017261505, 0.023819224908947945, -0.02033633179962635, -0.0023129559122025967, 0.04502513259649277, 0.0695725828409195, -0.03148159384727478, -0.09120436757802963, 0.017759481444954872, -0.01028770487755537, 0.03353765606880188, -0.023087482899427414, -0.056989286094903946, 0.030913926661014557, 0.003655144479125738, -0.018507935106754303, 0.03485853597521782, -0.00858304463326931, 0.0044744727201759815, 0.00554750207811594, 0.013647344894707203, -0.04324646294116974, 0.019446516409516335, -0.02057037502527237, 0.011249739676713943, 0.02086024358868599, 0.07829581201076508, 0.05234066769480705, 0.027710672467947006, 0.005112907383590937, 0.022661207243800163, 0.012797924689948559, 0.04645523428916931, -0.023509610444307327, 0.05366811156272888, -0.008831726387143135, 0.020230425521731377, -0.02498258836567402, -0.024396253749728203, -0.0001541741075925529, 0.025555018335580826, -0.03456009179353714, -0.05796721950173378, 0.0452396385371685, -0.011267571710050106, 0.04877057671546936, 0.023790283128619194, 0.001222264370881021, -0.0037136762402951717, -0.02942470647394657, -0.0026884127873927355, 0.051083821803331375, -0.05241173878312111, -0.0009023244492709637, 0.000970238063018769, -0.0002465256839059293, -0.005011564586311579, -0.029593423008918762, -0.005762671586126089, 0.06415155529975891, 0.0014643068425357342, -0.012013445608317852, 0.01588744856417179, -0.04663288593292236, 0.005538769997656345, -0.02502530813217163, 0.03391863405704498, 0.03374695032835007, 0.02596922032535076, -0.03220725059509277, 0.007046656683087349, -0.0027111133094877005, -0.03033294901251793, -0.012718668207526207, 0.02050192840397358, -0.0016972345765680075, -0.02697431854903698, 0.04891747981309891, 0.02239852398633957, -0.05416732281446457, 0.0339120589196682, 0.02280934900045395, 0.034087929874658585, -0.007781197316944599, -0.07153822481632233, -0.04648097604513168, 0.04222411662340164, -0.017542075365781784, -0.02108011581003666, -0.04536449536681175, -0.0038658049888908863, 0.025470424443483353, 0.06447373330593109, 0.0066914488561451435, 0.03329586610198021, 0.04791112616658211, 0.04234854504466057, 0.02081582322716713, -0.01166031789034605, -0.002048259833827615, -0.01708642765879631, -0.012551813386380672, -0.002462242729961872, -0.11588649451732635, -0.00036046875175088644, 0.018759306520223618, 0.007870202884078026, 0.021072808653116226, 0.046657975763082504, -0.02697424590587616, -0.01921962760388851, 0.012248416431248188, 0.001730201649479568, -0.005167053546756506, 0.07876107096672058, 0.01444285362958908, 0.01646677404642105, 0.05665048584342003, 0.0058077191933989525, 0.017475677654147148, 0.0218421071767807, 0.07889491319656372, 0.035550136119127274, -0.008039028383791447, -0.02051525190472603, -0.01702849194407463, 0.008019578643143177, 0.014280153438448906, -0.07881289720535278, -0.009560629725456238, -0.019266005605459213, 0.0003532730625011027, 0.025988250970840454, 0.028123801574110985, 0.029732393100857735, -0.04719442501664162, 0.027147432789206505, -0.04570883885025978, -0.04344315454363823, -0.08655235916376114, 0.028039805591106415, -0.02014526166021824, -0.014997543767094612, 0.01609625481069088, 0.026294805109500885, 0.007780697662383318, -0.019916493445634842, -0.012593247927725315, -0.03930995613336563, 0.027041083201766014, 0.04263132065534592, -0.05406883731484413, -0.0054933191277086735, 0.07615246623754501, 0.06726545095443726, -0.0234620850533247, 0.040870171040296555, -0.026393061503767967, -0.03945968672633171, 0.02064475230872631, -0.05779103562235832, -0.010319134220480919, -0.034943073987960815, -0.02783922292292118, -0.007337052840739489, -0.02434774488210678, 0.0015764711424708366, 0.014879860915243626, -0.04241527244448662, 0.06338826566934586, 0.060637183487415314, 0.012058776803314686, -0.009347106330096722, -0.0060095335356891155, 0.02493283338844776, 0.002241981215775013, -0.04687757417559624, -0.009375590831041336, -0.04530800133943558, -0.017306044697761536, 0.04218482971191406, 0.03780274838209152, -0.046678025275468826, 0.027625400573015213, 0.04166725277900696, 0.03352055698633194, 0.004942866042256355, 0.036742113530635834, -0.025636522099375725, -0.014758218079805374, -0.012441114522516727, -0.00954337976872921, 0.007593359332531691, 0.01769414357841015, 0.001000747550278902, 0.004645853769034147, 0.045845236629247665, -0.027871781960129738, -0.01380176842212677, 0.04216732829809189, -0.026071669533848763, -0.00277810450643301, -0.022616349160671234, -0.019195957109332085, 0.016116775572299957, -0.03687318414449692, 0.0050776018761098385, -0.0021811099722981453, 0.009815742261707783, 0.004034518264234066, -0.008795195259153843, -0.019517820328474045, -0.0027160472236573696, 0.032238174229860306, -0.04970569908618927, 0.002559124492108822, 0.010970212519168854, -0.027013614773750305, 0.019237715750932693, -0.03780221939086914, -0.029508063569664955, -0.026990976184606552, 0.014912068843841553, 0.0032148726750165224, -0.0064275735057890415, 0.03603905066847801, -0.024969568476080894, -0.04043101146817207, -0.011062944307923317, -0.04143740236759186, -0.004827521275728941, -0.030876150354743004, -0.058772701770067215, 0.012148957699537277, -0.0522395521402359, -0.03457779809832573, 0.05855102837085724, -0.011247090063989162, -0.012013260275125504, 0.01334929559379816, -0.025294940918684006, -0.028184447437524796, -0.05400199070572853, -0.033843446522951126, -0.001916860812343657, -0.044395871460437775, -0.007531160954385996, 0.02430593967437744, -0.04429343342781067, -0.032081179320812225, 0.028380582109093666, -0.03048648312687874, -0.006817665882408619, -0.027156036347150803, -0.016769396141171455, 0.003019496565684676, -0.007643946446478367, 0.007807152811437845, 0.02222936972975731, -0.04413106292486191, 0.0030138783622533083, -0.05570417270064354, -0.041010789573192596, 0.020958956331014633, -0.01726735197007656, 0.006278785411268473, 0.0018040413269773126, -0.026612168177962303, 0.09648096561431885, 0.034193798899650574, -0.026353051885962486, -0.025148941203951836, 0.026778217405080795, -0.022798234596848488, 0.010947038419544697, 0.024191277101635933, 0.02263852208852768, -0.0009921211749315262, 0.06450895965099335, -0.011002189479768276, 0.005648448131978512, 0.03983735293149948, 0.02369830198585987, -0.003117718268185854, 0.02090052329003811, 0.0028920175973325968, -0.02087457664310932, 0.024204064160585403, 0.02398974634706974, -0.010978213511407375, 0.04418397322297096, -0.005980828311294317, 0.013292479328811169, 0.02145170420408249, -0.02761523611843586, 0.03569844365119934, -0.00256120297126472, -0.005632474087178707, -0.04178406298160553, 0.05046170949935913, 0.004918767139315605, 0.003523426130414009, -0.00932452641427517, -0.0007661897107027471, 0.020937442779541016, -0.014812028966844082, -0.00007821818871889263, 0.02253037877380848, 0.03572147339582443, -0.04412192478775978, -0.019661156460642815, -0.016740020364522934, -0.0034088371321558952, 0.019469410181045532, -0.014502654783427715, -0.0003387699543964118, 0.053386855870485306, 0.04877675697207451, -0.0032345352228730917, 0.013939578086137772, -0.04255692660808563, 0.0005437219515442848, -0.06185036525130272, -0.014660881832242012, -0.01501118391752243, 0.02655710279941559, -0.011339882388710976, 0.054603204131126404, -0.019317572936415672, -0.0339178591966629, 0.04029714688658714, -0.005011401139199734, -0.0638718381524086, 0.04131220281124115, 0.005400662310421467, -0.028117816895246506, -0.018027588725090027, -0.033113304525613785, 0.027730422094464302, -0.04218326508998871, -0.00473804771900177, -0.019396472722291946, 0.0304578710347414, -0.04138818010687828, 0.00227184290997684, -0.005058630835264921, -0.04178160801529884, -0.025647060945630074, 0.005102807655930519, 0.02973560057580471, -0.033627789467573166, 0.00973015557974577, 0.05367044359445572, -0.028100794181227684, -0.019038008525967598, -0.01929088495671749, -0.003949168138206005, 0.04315156117081642, 0.04645637422800064, 0.03258911147713661, 0.0029022458475083113, -0.03115217201411724, 0.045154307037591934, -0.013271333649754524, 0.049549225717782974, 0.08733699470758438, -0.01608649268746376, -0.00992334634065628, -0.0403776578605175, -0.005628119222819805, 0.0022647478617727757, -0.022599561139941216, -0.01990089938044548, -0.012219890020787716, 0.07666017860174179, 0.023818911984562874, -0.03354008123278618, 0.038344334810972214, 0.04240462929010391, 0.01108480803668499, 0.002426477847620845, -0.029880233108997345, -0.025069307535886765, -0.03098994679749012, -0.002247982658445835, 0.003996836021542549, -0.0023321995977312326, 0.008994667790830135, -0.001780452555976808, 0.036221638321876526, -0.008922267705202103, -0.04014141857624054, -0.051279451698064804, 0.04037577658891678, 0.03835484758019447, -0.0009286527638323605, -0.03163748234510422, 0.02602338418364525, 0.06510480493307114, 0.03186330199241638, 0.03405880555510521, 0.0037530814297497272, -0.0711933970451355, 0.018780721351504326, 0.03813169524073601, 0.055677056312561035, -0.04129967838525772, 0.014519298449158669, -0.015063666738569736, 0.018930135294795036, 0.02248774841427803, -0.01303143985569477, 0.02377742901444435, 0.006309259682893753, 0.01551100704818964, -0.01580408774316311, -0.025082401931285858, -0.05221384018659592, 0.004742296412587166, 0.007932547479867935, 0.013976803049445152, -0.08100840449333191, -0.025610769167542458, -0.05499701574444771, 0.025607209652662277, 0.0179473664611578, 0.0504777655005455, -0.04186849668622017, -0.0019321659347042441, 0.008551221340894699, 0.008791441097855568, 0.02761351875960827, -0.0743759423494339, 0.0008609180222265422, 0.02068692445755005, -0.007427752483636141, 0.047738827764987946, -0.0251583494246006, -0.019626401364803314, 0.015256581827998161, 0.0013956233160570264, -0.015115130692720413, 0.0004484942473936826, -0.009520365856587887, 0.02684052102267742, 0.0346858911216259, 0.016838211566209793, 0.08350180089473724, 0.01860501803457737, -0.018030263483524323, -0.047764647752046585, -0.05062825232744217, 0.010046256706118584, 0.007636656519025564, -0.030812295153737068, -0.05529330298304558, 0.005267853382974863, -0.008874225430190563, 0.03690245747566223, 0.018103770911693573, -0.015666279941797256, -0.004679427482187748, -0.017114179208874702, -0.04776422306895256, 0.04484692960977554, 0.02043548785150051, -0.00671972194686532, 0.005394996143877506, 0.020128436386585236, 0.008964824490249157, -0.013327432796359062, 0.03081163763999939, -0.008951647207140923, 0.033950261771678925, -0.0017618213314563036, -0.047345325350761414, 0.02701139822602272, -0.009210682474076748, -0.03859136998653412, 0.006062082014977932, -0.034200236201286316, 0.03482063114643097, 0.005457696039229631, 0.017769830301404, 0.007367896381765604, -0.04618401452898979, -0.03913979232311249, 0.03715904429554939, 0.02614716999232769, 0.03802722692489624, -0.040251873433589935, 0.030908234417438507, -0.019812798127532005, 0.002555012935772538, -0.037975434213876724, -0.029102858155965805, 0.03324872627854347, 0.011648505926132202, -0.047204598784446716, -0.02887292578816414, -0.006836852058768272, -0.011789575219154358, -0.03536910191178322, 0.013369899243116379, 0.0739501565694809, -0.05413905531167984, -0.00999362114816904, -0.007488428149372339, 0.014523486606776714, 0.07118314504623413, 0.007541159633547068, -0.013554509729146957, 0.016437891870737076, -0.03456168249249458, -0.001472874660976231, 0.010730599984526634, -0.0047223842702806, -0.03303080424666405, -0.015706054866313934, -0.023986073210835457, -0.006488143932074308, 0.03122079186141491, -0.004494840279221535, -0.016344178467988968, 0.0049562458880245686, 0.023546511307358742, 0.009358200244605541, 0.014133607968688011, 0.014401187188923359, -0.011053723283112049, 0.005877973511815071, 0.012796117924153805, 0.011135517619550228, -0.007799162063747644, -0.014252695254981518, 0.04075455293059349, 0.01189623586833477, -0.02871973253786564, 0.0049816095270216465, 0.05792800709605217, 0.006571343634277582, 0.020542588084936142, -0.033036865293979645, -0.026666203513741493, 0.043541450053453445, 0.03431340306997299, -0.016133088618516922, 0.005209026858210564, 0.017829816788434982, -0.03537391498684883, -0.03270481899380684, -0.046018775552511215, -0.04302467033267021, 0.0383969210088253, -0.02975384332239628, 0.04841509461402893, 0.057590335607528687, 0.02342761680483818, -0.005911874584853649, -0.02770894207060337, 0.016898661851882935, -0.0032736314460635185, 0.015033863484859467, 0.029765723273158073, -0.008823495358228683, -0.013048051856458187, 0.04222151264548302, 0.036471981555223465, -0.0012029624776914716, 0.0027051379438489676, 0.007605045568197966, 0.004089570604264736, 0.0073280311189591885, -0.03919663652777672, -0.047986991703510284, 0.0722620040178299, -0.03609176352620125, 0.0022124762181192636, -0.03345854952931404, -0.04274187237024307, 0.03811758756637573, 0.036687154322862625, 0.007884589023888111, -0.03338184207677841, 0.005986182950437069, -0.0323178693652153, 0.012761012651026249, 0.00811084732413292, -0.0174906887114048, 0.04236395284533501, 0.0035872547887265682, 0.03429986536502838, 0.0008199313306249678, 0.025520194321870804, -0.007829099893569946, -0.07034015655517578, -0.016957493498921394, -0.03344189375638962, -0.035327691584825516, 0.02243589051067829, 0.0009859985439106822, -0.022992338985204697, 0.001893205102533102, -0.041520603001117706, 0.023362403735518456, 0.01034459751099348, 0.06534136086702347, -0.032544154673814774, 0.061569757759571075, -0.015810372307896614, -0.020868996158242226, -0.0032921077217906713, -0.033400099724531174, 0.10656406730413437, 0.08296405524015427, 0.03306864947080612, -0.06986814737319946, 0.029822584241628647, -0.014845718629658222, 0.0028592636808753014, -0.009233503602445126, 0.007175535429269075, 0.011719620786607265, 0.004858458414673805, 0.03278501331806183, 0.03473600745201111, -0.01434700284153223, -0.020507214590907097, 0.04131251946091652, -0.04615167900919914, -0.02222912572324276, -0.026542291045188904, 0.01145187858492136, -0.009721948765218258, 0.0014764325460419059, -0.04717925190925598, -0.014821819961071014, -0.005345798097550869, -0.0045723095536231995, -0.014611229300498962, -0.03874649479985237, -0.004599250853061676, -0.03300006315112114, -0.028888026252388954, -0.015495221130549908, 0.033889297395944595, 0.027758073061704636, -0.013793234713375568, 0.00963201280683279, -0.002979168202728033, -0.0027347763534635305, -0.010852931998670101, 0.02023634873330593, -0.026923520490527153, 0.01071936171501875, 0.0021669045090675354, 0.018010323867201805, -0.05568427965044975, -0.04894917458295822, -0.016671957448124886, 0.04552283510565758, -0.008631665259599686, -0.0268599521368742, -0.017796292901039124, 0.023366538807749748, -0.003833690658211708, -0.025027578696608543, -0.030055686831474304, 0.023380881175398827, 0.012823549099266529, -0.026265515014529228, -0.017797762528061867, -0.01921185664832592, -0.0036024516448378563, -0.01837281323969364, 0.027260279282927513, 0.046754781156778336, -0.055374015122652054, -0.009859906509518623, -0.03014196641743183, 0.02579290047287941, 0.009533322416245937, 0.034100670367479324, 0.003960525617003441, 0.001305404002778232, -0.024620531126856804, -0.014334391802549362, 0.025257539004087448, -0.0049166022799909115, 0.0020668923389166594, 0.010904178023338318, 0.006750228814780712, -0.01411321572959423, -0.03586577624082565, 0.02602277882397175, -0.04342062398791313, 0.01323959045112133, -0.07614120841026306, 0.005125193856656551, 0.051714424043893814, 0.02136986516416073, 0.012108945287764072, 0.003371794708073139, -0.028714796528220177, 0.03755451366305351, 0.0018002177821472287, -0.03871811553835869, -0.0037448869552463293, 0.003500879742205143, -0.009625102393329144, -0.00037447077920660377, 0.01164138875901699, 0.08142885565757751, 0.023674065247178078, 0.02036348730325699, -0.01239050179719925, 0.03562084957957268, -0.00129757693503052, -0.011983622796833515, 0.01347898505628109, -0.05027977377176285, 0.005247735884040594, 0.030369766056537628, 0.008687539957463741, -0.0019334094831719995, -0.006202941760420799, -0.015962950885295868, -0.044263340532779694, 0.061206597834825516, -0.03196569159626961, -0.04454897716641426, 0.016288727521896362, -0.0152945751324296, 0.004299744497984648, -0.028023378923535347, -0.005001728422939777, -0.02480205148458481, 0.016375498846173286, 0.008401754312217236, -0.03813812881708145, 0.006158905103802681, -0.01193558145314455, -0.009328990243375301, 0.002767347963526845, 0.054704003036022186, 0.02890336699783802, 0.005581454373896122, 0.0028706486336886883, 0.04170236364006996, -0.008037407882511616, 0.05124777555465698, 0.007788119837641716, -0.05339673161506653, 0.04813263565301895, -0.0520462803542614, -0.004938632715493441, 0.042748596519231796, -0.012651056982576847, 0.03426628187298775, 0.04405076429247856, -0.0023914200719445944, -0.019581468775868416, 0.026189662516117096, -0.026892786845564842, -0.021820660680532455, -0.03492104262113571, 0.0052162520587444305, -0.0204402357339859, 0.00024942096206359565, 0.005141658708453178, -0.002825003582984209, -0.006520254537463188, -0.0074970112182199955, 0.06942339241504669, -0.016624178737401962, 0.015869591385126114, 0.01235655415803194, -0.009069832973182201, 0.03875923529267311, 0.01762070134282112, -0.025836540386080742, 0.0034950487315654755, 0.030351078137755394, 0.013791334815323353, 0.047619905322790146, 0.015410605818033218, 0.019153844565153122, -0.1037665382027626, -0.026526469737291336, 0.012082611210644245, 0.016008777543902397, 0.028155403211712837, -0.06329571455717087, 0.003733620513230562, 0.04031146690249443, -0.03418632224202156, 0.005343261640518904, 0.002242475049570203, -0.005724708084017038, -0.020598458126187325, -0.000941856240388006, -0.012124640867114067, 0.07060001790523529, 0.018977275118231773, 0.023547548800706863, 0.042255934327840805, 0.014086613431572914, 0.017022470012307167, -0.021890919655561447, -0.01580234244465828, 0.008833217434585094, -0.023473648354411125, -0.04367939755320549, 0.041622452437877655, -0.03165515512228012, -0.03841828927397728, 0.03816971927881241, 0.012002544477581978, 0.01845940575003624, 0.02702230028808117, 0.022913824766874313, 0.015609060414135456, 0.0635562464594841, 0.033077873289585114, 0.013671623542904854, -0.05025652423501015, 0.011189865879714489, 0.011496945284307003, 0.020378807559609413, -0.0385250560939312, 0.01747772842645645, 0.004394644871354103, -0.00364362052641809, -0.03645723685622215, -0.002037560101598501, -0.006000426597893238, -0.004333141725510359, 0.019737517461180687, 0.011873940005898476, -0.01776413805782795, -0.04375864192843437, 0.029024669900536537, -0.03750268369913101, -0.02534324862062931, 0.035302866250276566, 0.02133340761065483, -0.022802304476499557, 0.018180863931775093, 0.003187359543517232, -0.03554403781890869, 0.06223881617188454, -0.0011544257868081331, -0.016933880746364594, -0.07495775073766708, 0.0071645923890173435, 0.032940350472927094, -0.03418637439608574, -0.034432560205459595, -0.011758199892938137, -0.040024325251579285, 0.010196481831371784, -0.023340854793787003, 0.013169889338314533, 0.007925686426460743, -0.02521984837949276, -0.0171471256762743, -0.08252708613872528, 0.07520172744989395, 0.00042132081580348313, 0.009666542522609234, -0.05490176007151604, 0.016821343451738358, -0.025865955278277397, 0.008449827320873737, 0.02942843921482563, 0.019804947078227997, 0.018123909831047058, 0.0199604369699955, 0.04639211669564247, 0.03247822821140289, -0.05465415492653847, 0.025600850582122803, -0.01003686711192131, -0.016469428315758705, -0.06069570407271385, -0.01618899777531624, 0.021070342510938644, 0.015397248789668083, 0.05012527480721474, -0.03372128680348396, 0.03017844632267952, 0.01767905056476593, 0.03157839551568031, 0.087839275598526, 0.031092161312699318, -0.017580892890691757, 0.061946310102939606, 0.01831776089966297, 0.028719864785671234, 0.03089507855474949, -0.011173349805176258, -0.03155329450964928, 0.012816756032407284, -0.001821215613745153, -0.03964231535792351, 0.006928757298737764, 0.02148004062473774, -0.017967266961932182, -0.05184431001543999, 0.016561562195420265, 0.012933799996972084, -0.033267196267843246, -0.0163892712444067, 0.03701208904385567, 0.008011695928871632, 0.05078750103712082, -0.013670013286173344, 0.022427381947636604, 0.013854319229722023, -0.036486923694610596, -0.011256052181124687, -0.0010505738900974393, 0.05344748497009277, 0.004921705462038517, 0.02039208635687828, 0.014420391991734505, 0.008249604143202305, 0.019177675247192383, 0.00582516985014081, 0.013428091071546078, -0.061733540147542953, -0.0033239249605685472, 0.008812285959720612, -0.024463627487421036, 0.03061939962208271, -0.03374809771776199, -0.002901555737480521, 0.07057732343673706, -0.052228089421987534, -0.008650575764477253, -0.041136886924505234, -0.005713091231882572, -0.0036271826829761267, -0.024810565635561943, 0.008945469744503498, 0.015650633722543716, 0.0001078411951311864, 0.022309627383947372, -0.018499178811907768, 0.0021925438195466995, 0.04184497147798538, -0.003187399823218584, 0.0248683150857687, -0.008850333280861378, -0.02712807059288025, -0.03328138217329979, 0.0062544685788452625, -0.008402835577726364, -0.007708400953561068, 0.016696346923708916, 0.02795163355767727, -0.01304623857140541, -0.02551000379025936, -0.010807626880705357, -0.008272293955087662, 0.04165685176849365, -0.042258527129888535, -0.019395330920815468, -0.04439998045563698, 0.034113168716430664, -0.005101822316646576, -0.03763975948095322 ]
<p>I have a data set with multiple y values per x value. Using Excel the scatter plot and the regression line tools, I wish to apply regression on the data to determine if there is any connection between the data points.</p> <p>If I just pick the regression trend line (Layout 3) in Excel, it gives me a line with an R² value of 0.02, but if I pick the average y-values for each x-value, and use the trend line on them, I get a trend line with an R² value of 0,963 which, pardon my phrasing, looks correct.</p> <p>My question is; Is it safe to use a set of averaged y-values in order to limit it to a single y-value per x-value?</p>
74,271
[ -0.02701496332883835, -0.007174559403210878, 0.0030121193267405033, 0.009232490323483944, 0.017181087285280228, 0.00560411810874939, 0.005929662846028805, -0.03361620008945465, 0.03338932991027832, -0.03173131123185158, 0.04031731188297272, 0.03282526135444641, 0.06218685582280159, 0.013014251366257668, 0.03844137489795685, -0.006410537753254175, -0.021904785186052322, 0.033442653715610504, 0.0059420038014650345, -0.046630408614873886, -0.027432532981038094, 0.005863543599843979, 0.03566797077655792, -0.00997734721750021, -0.00968976505100727, 0.05085061863064766, 0.04131495952606201, -0.013348415493965149, -0.0033504620660096407, 0.04773256927728653, -0.004498457070440054, -0.025727858766913414, 0.01822611317038536, 0.033772680908441544, 0.06291397660970688, 0.0017524762079119682, -0.011779527179896832, -0.036639392375946045, -0.008019473403692245, 0.026971442624926567, -0.024679984897375107, -0.027525292709469795, 0.024722883477807045, 0.018902068957686424, -0.013975999318063259, 0.0021171942353248596, -0.0015032977098599076, -0.046308569610118866, 0.04039343446493149, -0.024315081536769867, 0.08371353149414062, -0.037140313535928726, 0.040517475455999374, 0.05732078477740288, -0.018940895795822144, 0.022796235978603363, 0.03888057917356491, 0.05189705267548561, -0.024947891011834145, -0.03568250313401222, 0.04200100153684616, 0.009824790991842747, -0.007173426914960146, -0.006763898767530918, -0.054911330342292786, 0.011272537522017956, -0.02974126860499382, -0.008611875586211681, 0.013889736495912075, -0.012244532816112041, 0.02971186302602291, 0.017071183770895004, 0.027815163135528564, -0.05114414542913437, 0.026152318343520164, -0.0026599273551255465, 0.03504540026187897, 0.02046118676662445, 0.051555268466472626, 0.050154171884059906, 0.04037368297576904, 0.029936982318758965, 0.025725070387125015, 0.04432689771056175, 0.0023219091817736626, 0.017408229410648346, 0.06736164540052414, -0.021442627534270287, 0.011423558928072453, 0.06222178414463997, 0.02547489106655121, 0.011791149154305458, 0.04257718101143837, 0.031146032735705376, -0.036369744688272476, 0.062089238315820694, -0.02380179613828659, 0.028092704713344574, -0.03802276402711868, 0.01252033468335867, 0.030923595651984215, -0.01861579902470112, -0.006552552338689566, 0.019512975588440895, -0.028830382972955704, -0.032443102449178696, -0.01177067682147026, -0.000022298678231891245, 0.03015829063951969, -0.022748203948140144, -0.008637478575110435, 0.008569075725972652, -0.018075112253427505, -0.009912419132888317, 0.04547813534736633, 0.011244320310652256, -0.032594285905361176, 0.022055020555853844, 0.03510865196585655, 0.04977541044354439, 0.049499526619911194, -0.03630062937736511, 0.02572977915406227, 0.013943145051598549, 0.005593889392912388, 0.026266977190971375, -0.014872408472001553, -0.017514405772089958, -0.07421165704727173, 0.053885072469711304, 0.029486725106835365, -0.02830328792333603, 0.008142499253153801, -0.02167413756251335, 0.061719559133052826, -0.002233991865068674, -0.07105136662721634, -0.04892880469560623, 0.029063420370221138, -0.007559779100120068, 0.013347945176064968, -0.045152273029088974, -0.017840851098299026, 0.04163750261068344, 0.06834664195775986, 0.0027467634063214064, -0.0031404439359903336, 0.011483407579362392, 0.012568960897624493, 0.017874501645565033, -0.03580520302057266, -0.022050490602850914, 0.02038944512605667, -0.06284582614898682, -0.009836820885539055, -0.08028803020715714, 0.016527840867638588, 0.016583910211920738, -0.006076005753129721, -0.0036526406183838844, 0.01708703488111496, 0.0036484019365161657, 0.005245494656264782, 0.01900564692914486, 0.004818276967853308, -0.02158932574093342, 0.09287095069885254, 0.0025783427990972996, 0.045156367123126984, 0.026845451444387436, -0.009088548831641674, 0.044129449874162674, 0.012779930606484413, 0.04422101005911827, 0.04969368129968643, -0.012212635949254036, -0.010674132965505123, -0.035458557307720184, 0.012126761488616467, -0.0017696197610348463, -0.07398723065853119, -0.039728377014398575, -0.01793539524078369, -0.008721338585019112, 0.006380967330187559, 0.0704018622636795, -0.01102131512016058, -0.03715488314628601, -0.00840725377202034, -0.06320181488990784, -0.009972402825951576, -0.05339259281754494, 0.0002224986528744921, -0.004281506408005953, -0.0012270949082449079, -0.023546826094388962, 0.0016499870689585805, 0.029612651094794273, -0.012500311248004436, -0.002334945136681199, -0.03277059644460678, 0.00838527549058199, 0.021604780107736588, -0.0393083319067955, 0.018102778121829033, 0.08713023364543915, 0.018755782395601273, -0.0367831289768219, -0.003229624591767788, -0.04442663863301277, -0.009726830758154392, 0.028090063482522964, -0.0681072548031807, 0.006941116414964199, -0.013326264917850494, -0.016569390892982483, -0.013720547780394554, -0.005802486091852188, -0.04017751291394234, 0.03814766928553581, -0.0485081821680069, 0.04150589928030968, 0.03651446849107742, 0.004089967347681522, -0.016281841322779655, -0.018232503905892372, -0.000080520570918452, 0.009528563357889652, -0.012701320461928844, -0.026848094537854195, -0.04568776115775108, 0.04046338424086571, 0.025591697543859482, 0.023150768131017685, -0.05980252847075462, -0.0020991454366594553, 0.09278709441423416, 0.0076352450996637344, 0.006206269841641188, 0.03475799411535263, 0.022591978311538696, 0.016074776649475098, -0.011916452087461948, 0.026335595175623894, 0.0375792533159256, -0.01417816523462534, 0.0026065281126648188, -0.009237824007868767, 0.005748629570007324, 0.017040077596902847, 0.010832973755896091, 0.005700876470655203, 0.018634939566254616, -0.003974414896219969, 0.0026556572411209345, 0.0024637538008391857, 0.02252904698252678, -0.03959181532263756, 0.002357020741328597, 0.026125216856598854, 0.032257817685604095, -0.0553993321955204, 0.03652695193886757, -0.011963523924350739, 0.012683887034654617, 0.05662323907017708, -0.050430383533239365, -0.018627813085913658, 0.008045060560107231, -0.015824127942323685, 0.0023152579087764025, -0.04769919440150261, -0.024468839168548584, -0.040089067071676254, 0.018938608467578888, 0.029278554022312164, -0.010093745775520802, 0.025077570229768753, -0.04821896180510521, -0.010536318644881248, -0.02975919283926487, -0.026788806542754173, -0.010083620436489582, -0.03125081956386566, -0.02890927717089653, -0.01736307702958584, -0.01550082303583622, -0.025134621188044548, 0.03894319757819176, -0.017039623111486435, -0.01840534247457981, 0.04601248353719711, 0.008034641854465008, -0.06915447860956192, -0.03794877231121063, -0.03555280342698097, -0.006683889776468277, -0.00674448162317276, -0.025510717183351517, 0.045750007033348083, -0.019082525745034218, -0.0389535017311573, 0.037262335419654846, -0.049988534301519394, 0.008668419905006886, -0.030286157503724098, -0.007690425496548414, -0.004741339944303036, 0.0297468863427639, 0.024821726605296135, 0.01627485081553459, -0.03841768205165863, -0.02600407786667347, -0.03422892093658447, -0.06751611083745956, 0.02416233718395233, -0.008881103247404099, 0.0031612457241863012, 0.0032165523152798414, -0.016398180276155472, 0.05317458510398865, 0.03950268030166626, -0.04633330553770065, -0.05814419314265251, -0.008171549998223782, -0.006208259612321854, -0.06338024139404297, 0.04797695204615593, 0.009533194825053215, 0.005581325851380825, 0.019653504714369774, 0.0005941536510363221, 0.05454369634389877, 0.04340282455086708, -0.01969056762754917, 0.004756477661430836, -0.01636463589966297, 0.023059632629156113, 0.001564809470437467, 0.029194297268986702, 0.04107372835278511, -0.011675453744828701, -0.021149229258298874, -0.0022377113346010447, 0.05510598421096802, 0.010065236128866673, -0.04524480551481247, 0.027306832373142242, -0.04007314518094063, 0.04223388060927391, 0.001261094119399786, -0.0026227603666484356, 0.04098888114094734, 0.013076388277113438, -0.007328204810619354, 0.011191644705832005, 0.04176997020840645, -0.005133193917572498, 0.024418314918875694, 0.05198865756392479, 0.02695517987012863, -0.000589932082220912, -0.0006191341672092676, 0.021530918776988983, 0.019365759566426277, 0.04991156980395317, -0.011173485778272152, -0.03052603080868721, 0.029430020600557327, 0.025738367810845375, 0.0007316127885133028, 0.00587511109188199, -0.025701861828565598, 0.039022769778966904, -0.08618563413619995, -0.0182968657463789, -0.011915055103600025, 0.043700505048036575, 0.042069170624017715, 0.02850542590022087, 0.013671678490936756, -0.044073812663555145, 0.050497621297836304, -0.02350623533129692, -0.05255943909287453, 0.04427775368094444, -0.006990718189626932, -0.003861855249851942, -0.010001231916248798, -0.016050653532147408, -0.0008695377036929131, -0.04711538925766945, 0.026219811290502548, -0.006145623978227377, -0.003702763933688402, -0.021020516753196716, -0.02123364992439747, -0.02351853810250759, 0.010871822945773602, -0.037355296313762665, 0.031079154461622238, -0.003478782717138529, -0.05573105812072754, 0.03745007887482643, 0.010642269626259804, -0.04292386770248413, -0.03519753739237785, -0.023651443421840668, 0.02821650169789791, 0.006913422141224146, 0.023322226479649544, -0.0010033462895080447, 0.0011738314060494304, 0.0051668379455804825, 0.009628004394471645, 0.013416221365332603, 0.010426733642816544, 0.059110984206199646, -0.0007374397828243673, -0.019538430497050285, -0.01762283779680729, -0.0032202189322561026, 0.025303268805146217, 0.019026726484298706, 0.03196970000863075, -0.0069755143485963345, 0.02606808766722679, 0.016023756936192513, -0.055931106209754944, 0.018054526299238205, 0.053119730204343796, -0.005393336992710829, 0.017635567113757133, -0.029893338680267334, -0.0032475264742970467, -0.0038603940047323704, -0.012969305738806725, 0.014559376053512096, -0.001846167491748929, -0.018702147528529167, -0.014975528232753277, 0.030005721375346184, 0.00044092844473198056, -0.03487597405910492, -0.025161368772387505, 0.03908690810203552, 0.05906366556882858, -0.016177352517843246, -0.034556128084659576, 0.012544292956590652, 0.04416997730731964, 0.0006751972250640392, 0.05457182601094246, 0.017318962141871452, -0.07918205112218857, -0.0020821113139390945, 0.04149102792143822, 0.02560618333518505, -0.023723706603050232, -0.027397986501455307, -0.00937139056622982, -0.013079007156193256, 0.05034054070711136, -0.015265215188264847, 0.0017993721412494779, -0.04240439087152481, -0.017491767182946205, -0.0030606586951762438, -0.009526289068162441, -0.059824537485837936, -0.008995424024760723, -0.007929041981697083, 0.03958607465028763, -0.014132373966276646, -0.0374467559158802, -0.041320160031318665, 0.01596643775701523, -0.024944938719272614, 0.04393823444843292, -0.02269446849822998, -0.02008766494691372, 0.02054186351597309, 0.045620955526828766, 0.0030919304117560387, -0.04421936720609665, -0.010116999968886375, 0.01964566856622696, 0.015348673798143864, 0.05931193381547928, 0.008665934205055237, -0.015841586515307426, 0.012838250026106834, 0.004252760671079159, 0.0011271062539890409, -0.02940531261265278, -0.0023570815101265907, 0.03760633245110512, 0.07444611936807632, 0.0033346267882734537, 0.04177131876349449, 0.03376849740743637, 0.00908760167658329, -0.024471784010529518, -0.020399753004312515, -0.01388024352490902, -0.024746565148234367, -0.020933661609888077, -0.05461769178509712, -0.00973832793533802, 0.003693609032779932, 0.02118241973221302, -0.0010382644832134247, -0.007955064065754414, -0.05521753802895546, -0.009944855235517025, 0.021704968065023422, 0.03072209656238556, 0.005502556916326284, -0.016947871074080467, -0.010506969876587391, 0.021151378750801086, -0.0479559563100338, -0.0016704058507457376, 0.004543188959360123, -0.031054414808750153, 0.016827665269374847, 0.04228920117020607, -0.02409491501748562, 0.011160227470099926, -0.004752842243760824, -0.015079614706337452, -0.018817871809005737, -0.0385061576962471, 0.04323914274573326, -0.006343861576169729, 0.03306017443537712, 0.02974819950759411, -0.01994488760828972, 0.01508249994367361, 0.02504737302660942, -0.0051724351942539215, 0.034267865121364594, -0.03646715730428696, 0.07082049548625946, -0.0343182273209095, 0.0222950279712677, -0.03598390519618988, -0.04485422745347023, 0.0023299658205360174, -0.012027354910969734, -0.02100505493581295, 0.0038465838879346848, -0.03543678671121597, -0.011968125589191914, -0.009807444177567959, -0.03355570137500763, 0.02477250061929226, -0.052724439650774, -0.06734495609998703, 0.031200584024190903, 0.02821808122098446, 0.08184318989515305, -0.03476312384009361, -0.006897533778101206, 0.02753978595137596, -0.011622428894042969, -0.0005905501893721521, -0.02243688702583313, 0.006998347118496895, -0.03466419130563736, -0.014355051331222057, -0.025883909314870834, -0.026686202734708786, 0.042324990034103394, -0.04068243131041527, 0.020432360470294952, 0.03576098382472992, 0.02971053309738636, -0.004475207533687353, -0.03543337807059288, 0.014724444597959518, -0.029155274853110313, -0.013665847480297089, 0.0036588909570127726, -0.009374823421239853, -0.025316840037703514, 0.006239110603928566, 0.0312715619802475, 0.032194364815950394, -0.03048534318804741, 0.028453459963202477, 0.06565903127193451, 0.00480997608974576, -0.016895869746804237, -0.05685555189847946, -0.03619702160358429, 0.04304727166891098, 0.016232358291745186, -0.0041989474557340145, -0.010280860587954521, 0.01090757641941309, -0.03934405371546745, -0.026456886902451515, -0.03817243129014969, -0.01326955296099186, 0.05114397034049034, -0.04154127463698387, 0.06238769739866257, 0.04775227978825569, 0.023414231836795807, -0.008404525928199291, -0.07987898588180542, 0.00713961711153388, -0.04728002846240997, -0.007273918949067593, 0.04497857764363289, -0.001790544018149376, -0.022312665358185768, 0.016976123675704002, -0.005124707240611315, 0.015478904359042645, 0.057859696447849274, 0.011840919964015484, 0.013216785155236721, 0.03224489465355873, 0.023844551295042038, -0.041001416742801666, 0.012704611755907536, -0.0201653391122818, 0.01120292954146862, -0.02887958660721779, -0.044251471757888794, 0.011793551966547966, 0.028720673173666, -0.036983903497457504, -0.047854695469141006, -0.02616364136338234, -0.020751450210809708, 0.017458075657486916, -0.034975823014974594, -0.01948455348610878, 0.03610933572053909, 0.04404277354478836, 0.028242669999599457, 0.00933828018605709, -0.0074270302429795265, -0.04974193871021271, -0.07255592197179794, -0.007189548574388027, -0.009700280614197254, -0.010315555147826672, 0.02958548255264759, 0.008388681337237358, -0.027351969853043556, -0.005871116183698177, -0.05707709491252899, 0.009055022150278091, 0.003819049336016178, 0.05783636122941971, 0.011390691623091698, 0.04874471575021744, -0.01241325493901968, -0.0039160288870334625, -0.01623738929629326, -0.007725651375949383, 0.12486902624368668, 0.08294203132390976, 0.026172058656811714, -0.06423312425613403, -0.013219630345702171, -0.01539938896894455, -0.020782530307769775, -0.05308829993009567, -0.002406706102192402, 0.000459604780189693, 0.021573659032583237, 0.039232660084962845, 0.07376213371753693, -0.009365561418235302, 0.0025135630276054144, 0.06826496869325638, -0.005439094267785549, 0.015145155601203442, 0.019476743414998055, 0.03012675978243351, 0.008521707728505135, 0.012492084875702858, -0.07238065451383591, 0.010275352746248245, 0.003621108131483197, -0.013858038000762463, -0.010568954050540924, -0.041912637650966644, 0.01779465563595295, 0.013394245877861977, -0.021892715245485306, 0.012604382820427418, 0.035873714834451675, -0.016618210822343826, -0.025080887600779533, 0.004073924385011196, 0.01742037944495678, -0.04836373031139374, 0.003952688537538052, 0.03011391870677471, -0.014487646520137787, 0.003566055791452527, 0.023876642808318138, -0.011278564110398293, -0.0452694334089756, -0.017671721056103706, -0.01829153299331665, 0.02133377268910408, 0.018301699310541153, -0.0624551996588707, -0.0022850220557302237, 0.03725237771868706, -0.006181265227496624, -0.04406392201781273, -0.031827718019485474, 0.018140194937586784, 0.028242390602827072, 0.0006152165005914867, 0.0033029739279299974, -0.011443273164331913, 0.019531255587935448, -0.0218073558062315, 0.015109480358660221, 0.04380333423614502, -0.041133344173431396, -0.009244662709534168, -0.0492723323404789, 0.06708662211894989, 0.010609759017825127, -0.001964313443750143, -0.021897226572036743, -0.008236270397901535, -0.009785529226064682, -0.0197043064981699, 0.027992811053991318, -0.006116388365626335, 0.008172293193638325, 0.01556453388184309, 0.012430073693394661, 0.01297109853476286, -0.03869009017944336, 0.041842542588710785, -0.011167635209858418, -0.004357431083917618, -0.026704439893364906, -0.021904004737734795, 0.05788285285234451, 0.03659972921013832, 0.010285325348377228, 0.0013890110421925783, -0.01870996691286564, 0.05186798423528671, 0.04744169861078262, -0.035523515194654465, -0.025534415617585182, 0.00879727490246296, -0.0314326286315918, 0.008866425603628159, -0.009540793485939503, 0.08217871934175491, -0.0035608038306236267, 0.03685023635625839, -0.013964381068944931, 0.03003908134996891, -0.005003407597541809, 0.009633480571210384, 0.010559516958892345, -0.0733085423707962, 0.030006831511855125, -0.0002656780416145921, -0.02092202566564083, -0.04244508594274521, -0.025085486471652985, -0.05059447139501572, -0.0134168965741992, 0.007050692569464445, -0.010286589153110981, -0.04781978577375412, 0.03256799653172493, -0.026582740247249603, -0.0015747692668810487, -0.015234132297337055, -0.013859729282557964, -0.06088078022003174, -0.010601636953651905, -0.00863099005073309, -0.017702864482998848, -0.012108786962926388, 0.0398600809276104, -0.001041231444105506, 0.053665585815906525, 0.07294683903455734, 0.03627323731780052, 0.012770336121320724, -0.0029886967968195677, 0.00797359924763441, -0.009839263744652271, 0.03734694793820381, -0.06285063922405243, -0.020274564623832703, 0.01713849976658821, -0.021618084982037544, -0.003414799692109227, -0.012014162726700306, -0.017978765070438385, 0.018136005848646164, 0.01071910560131073, 0.0002192409592680633, -0.06971704214811325, 0.06034328415989876, 0.02643483504652977, 0.006920516490936279, -0.006218321155756712, 0.010922461748123169, 0.008952292613685131, 0.0336432121694088, 0.008479436859488487, -0.012099635787308216, 0.013171561062335968, -0.0007045752136036754, 0.05055306479334831, -0.004348126705735922, 0.006268098950386047, -0.02281077951192856, 0.005964440759271383, 0.03192858397960663, -0.010393284261226654, -0.00991932675242424, 0.07134871184825897, 0.008311528712511063, -0.045748885720968246, 0.0017423552926629782, 0.017589515075087547, 0.01750025898218155, -0.06976885348558426, -0.004701223690062761, -0.011392490938305855, 0.003444000845775008, -0.04804466292262077, -0.03590495139360428, -0.004041406791657209, 0.05887158215045929, -0.018612394109368324, -0.0016608547884970903, 0.004094117321074009, -0.016898375004529953, -0.03401584178209305, 0.04017515480518341, -0.007531983777880669, 0.00101653637830168, 0.0479607991874218, 0.050566162914037704, 0.015622190199792385, 0.016240568831562996, 0.0044981795363128185, -0.019192876294255257, -0.024041691794991493, 0.018132755532860756, -0.0021156067959964275, -0.006763659417629242, 0.021431444212794304, -0.036063387989997864, -0.0218503437936306, 0.027499046176671982, -0.020234394818544388, 0.0333278626203537, 0.03160552307963371, 0.01254536584019661, 0.010678079910576344, 0.019648894667625427, 0.03130090609192848, -0.022720100358128548, 0.0019089749548584223, -0.017431501299142838, 0.013988022692501545, 0.03672521933913231, -0.023050328716635704, 0.009101060219109058, 0.015486771240830421, -0.009407754056155682, -0.03634245693683624, 0.0031103240326046944, -0.000850111769977957, 0.002629244700074196, 0.012663817964494228, 0.026910971850156784, 0.003205737331882119, -0.022660840302705765, 0.02205469273030758, -0.020618684589862823, -0.02136244624853134, 0.05586964637041092, 0.009207714349031448, 0.0028827269561588764, 0.00925617478787899, 0.003548869164660573, -0.0382208488881588, -0.0008964478620328009, -0.006344176828861237, -0.01105565670877695, -0.07351195812225342, 0.030764475464820862, -0.013120890595018864, -0.051299165934324265, -0.029060784727334976, -0.028477592393755913, -0.0012368415482342243, 0.03276776522397995, -0.002150146057829261, -0.004190568812191486, 0.03235321864485741, 0.0023137032985687256, -0.013342311605811119, -0.10129190981388092, 0.07248130440711975, 0.02840568870306015, -0.03431253135204315, -0.0329238660633564, -0.0005360656650736928, -0.049635522067546844, -0.00781992543488741, 0.043978944420814514, -0.015307366847991943, 0.05318037420511246, -0.023740675300359726, 0.05482197925448418, -0.00882101058959961, -0.038869116455316544, 0.030955884605646133, 0.01500539667904377, -0.007606430444866419, -0.013785242103040218, -0.023526079952716827, 0.03388174995779991, -0.006308808457106352, 0.01360001228749752, -0.01962287910282612, 0.03956780955195427, 0.024021796882152557, -0.030588315799832344, 0.01220790483057499, 0.02226223796606064, -0.04654587060213089, 0.07033903896808624, 0.005219035781919956, -0.010456756688654423, 0.02919136732816696, -0.013431626372039318, -0.054855458438396454, 0.060840196907520294, -0.025602392852306366, -0.014044384472072124, -0.015365762636065483, -0.0021328136790543795, -0.02649424783885479, -0.06609565019607544, -0.0018607142847031355, 0.014568780548870564, -0.04287716746330261, -0.009376447647809982, 0.053083620965480804, 0.004926097113639116, 0.03014649637043476, 0.009746265597641468, 0.05393598601222038, -0.009884385392069817, 0.0011546353343874216, 0.026924755424261093, -0.023905299603939056, 0.015033462084829807, 0.012992138974368572, 0.003961488604545593, 0.05516964569687843, 0.007420820649713278, 0.020677968859672546, 0.009085679426789284, 0.023733574897050858, -0.004852170590311289, -0.006351795047521591, 0.003333583939820528, -0.02003183402121067, 0.03024139627814293, -0.025590604171156883, -0.002403502818197012, 0.012922107242047787, -0.07767222076654434, -0.016418328508734703, -0.034230317920446396, -0.04618778079748154, -0.0039393482729792595, 0.004811553284525871, 0.009442628361284733, -0.008463995531201363, -0.005814996547996998, 0.009364490397274494, 0.0030222460627555847, 0.014717609621584415, 0.03435970097780228, -0.019327718764543533, 0.025288239121437073, -0.050562746822834015, -0.0017714293207973242, 0.004996303468942642, 0.0037937781307846308, -0.02058095671236515, -0.011161085218191147, 0.010352573357522488, 0.0425092838704586, 0.004430578555911779, -0.0379202701151371, -0.012676427140831947, 0.02083316072821617, 0.032445549964904785, -0.09205859154462814, -0.046972472220659256, -0.031692784279584885, 0.017303036525845528, 0.03377416729927063, -0.06465519219636917 ]
<p>How to estimate probability density function when we have set of feature vectors, but we don't know their statistical distribution?</p>
74,272
[ -0.03896937146782875, 0.011079588904976845, 0.025829939171671867, 0.00785279180854559, 0.027067245915532112, -0.015431618317961693, -0.031339943408966064, 0.00003932426989194937, 0.038286589086055756, -0.024121884256601334, 0.0407426618039608, 0.0328439362347126, 0.038263432681560516, 0.02573348954319954, 0.0027379775419831276, -0.001880705007351935, -0.012989780865609646, 0.0011284692445769906, -0.019460782408714294, -0.034661270678043365, -0.005061175208538771, 0.04321938753128052, 0.05077417939901352, -0.02823527902364731, -0.013136785477399826, 0.07936757057905197, 0.019069159403443336, -0.03933735564351082, 0.030745740979909897, 0.06363888829946518, -0.03201639652252197, -0.03684968128800392, 0.01205680426210165, 0.056864481419324875, 0.020052161067724228, -0.00760301947593689, -0.033717911690473557, -0.005503964144736528, -0.026300329715013504, 0.01098981499671936, -0.04752777889370918, -0.02308477647602558, 0.028858965262770653, 0.06192924827337265, -0.03747493028640747, 0.02262689173221588, 0.031494807451963425, -0.04618118703365326, 0.02541758120059967, -0.04562252387404442, 0.07063127309083939, 0.00883428379893303, 0.05186624825000763, 0.034095730632543564, -0.022969836369156837, -0.010524493642151356, 0.050259724259376526, 0.09320169687271118, -0.019581494852900505, -0.046051427721977234, 0.0020605120807886124, -0.03764227405190468, -0.022123388946056366, -0.04814852029085159, -0.021191712468862534, 0.04177282378077507, -0.009583808481693268, -0.01390138640999794, 0.00849824957549572, -0.008311688899993896, -0.0007641935953870416, 0.013826489448547363, 0.009471019729971886, -0.009966240264475346, 0.02247977815568447, -0.002449881285429001, 0.013293239288032055, 0.015117104165256023, 0.04410084709525108, 0.020711231976747513, 0.05322565883398056, 0.012275495566427708, 0.0001119806693168357, 0.006128358654677868, 0.0366286039352417, -0.03466895595192909, 0.04989365488290787, -0.004683994222432375, 0.0043400963768363, 0.014261279255151749, -0.028606079518795013, -0.01982888951897621, 0.0457361564040184, -0.010365168564021587, -0.0516110397875309, 0.020872551947832108, -0.018485480919480324, 0.03133014589548111, 0.01791975274682045, -0.03973913565278053, 0.023531710729002953, -0.030937237665057182, 0.00854804553091526, 0.04420095309615135, -0.028115741908550262, 0.010063300840556622, -0.03237788379192352, -0.011854692362248898, -0.03469570353627205, 0.02843674272298813, -0.0025967140682041645, 0.03055836632847786, 0.0013018703320994973, 0.004489026498049498, 0.023073162883520126, 0.02669544890522957, -0.03253399580717087, -0.03558770567178726, 0.0341121144592762, 0.09425180405378342, -0.004634331911802292, -0.024068297818303108, 0.010487628169357777, -0.017785120755434036, -0.032514337450265884, 0.011279553174972534, 0.022957807406783104, -0.02564583532512188, -0.00795300304889679, 0.025015676394104958, -0.020488815382122993, -0.019080013036727905, 0.044989775866270065, 0.011726773343980312, -0.028391622006893158, 0.03578425198793411, -0.08366192877292633, -0.02989121526479721, 0.019067933782935143, -0.012405837886035442, 0.011958432383835316, -0.05625872686505318, 0.006622717250138521, 0.024818092584609985, 0.007897291332483292, -0.007003333419561386, 0.03310680389404297, 0.04053843766450882, 0.035384368151426315, -0.02834746427834034, -0.01446281187236309, -0.017394963651895523, -0.05197522044181824, 0.009375812485814095, -0.015011666342616081, -0.07397054135799408, 0.05894191563129425, -0.006234466563910246, -0.014725914224982262, -0.030422791838645935, -0.004528396297246218, 0.011011996306478977, -0.026421941816806793, 0.005433611571788788, 0.02819979190826416, -0.04551107436418533, 0.04279422387480736, 0.003115338273346424, 0.05386598780751228, 0.026249820366501808, -0.03016706369817257, -0.0016144771361723542, 0.010899486020207405, 0.044411662966012955, 0.06339940428733826, -0.0034966382663697004, -0.014836391434073448, 0.010397477075457573, 0.03191663697361946, -0.008981889113783836, -0.008700097911059856, -0.03377138823270798, 0.013574274256825447, 0.004946667701005936, 0.035749662667512894, 0.03976717218756676, 0.021470164880156517, -0.05453576147556305, 0.005461052991449833, -0.03784504905343056, -0.01973426714539528, -0.06252171844244003, 0.03423142805695534, -0.007053977344185114, -0.03479958698153496, 0.008957309648394585, 0.026592828333377838, 0.019244903698563576, -0.037667226046323776, 0.0025834040716290474, -0.035430990159511566, -0.03608066961169243, 0.016649998724460602, -0.05126938223838806, -0.022374719381332397, 0.04417457804083824, 0.0714610144495964, 0.0048707094974815845, 0.03958713263273239, -0.041214752942323685, -0.06536810845136642, 0.017837751656770706, -0.04510045424103737, 0.02291206084191799, -0.02054409123957157, -0.03308364748954773, 0.01472767349332571, 0.006195289082825184, -0.03224562481045723, 0.0010302760638296604, -0.017597099766135216, 0.034241847693920135, 0.053080782294273376, 0.009933813475072384, 0.02640850841999054, 0.007926041260361671, 0.001178871258161962, -0.030610069632530212, -0.008689198642969131, -0.0030939034186303616, -0.06414084136486053, -0.034883566200733185, 0.06943066418170929, 0.005783483386039734, -0.023572096601128578, 0.027953607961535454, 0.04323693364858627, 0.015868645161390305, 0.039410460740327835, 0.005203532986342907, -0.012566009536385536, -0.008511480875313282, 0.03979717567563057, 0.007181644439697266, -0.007946857251226902, -0.0071440874598920345, 0.011608228087425232, 0.044919341802597046, 0.010717397555708885, -0.01337234303355217, -0.027687810361385345, 0.0594673752784729, -0.019410474225878716, 0.007501969579607248, -0.02446998842060566, -0.01567785069346428, 0.028767747804522514, 0.0039066532626748085, -0.010879362002015114, -0.00907700415700674, -0.000477939989650622, 0.0217746589332819, 0.024344472214579582, -0.044385846704244614, 0.05509607121348381, 0.03746417909860611, -0.06154588237404823, 0.00246031628921628, 0.03262103348970413, -0.035784292966127396, 0.008781868033111095, -0.0031590035650879145, -0.06670583784580231, -0.010854762978851795, 0.01253962330520153, 0.056859780102968216, -0.020489828661084175, 0.021889610216021538, -0.03271133452653885, -0.010569578036665916, 0.03306165337562561, -0.015372072346508503, 0.02023850381374359, 0.017800787463784218, -0.042419325560331345, -0.012537498027086258, -0.017239481210708618, -0.05476703122258186, 0.00912505853921175, -0.002069505862891674, -0.030610065907239914, 0.012551991268992424, -0.0056628878228366375, -0.03454004228115082, 0.003162511857226491, -0.036630257964134216, 0.037927187979221344, -0.02719591185450554, -0.02149350941181183, 0.015275486744940281, -0.008366950787603855, -0.04202267527580261, 0.029216919094324112, -0.006582448724657297, -0.03223136439919472, -0.019884860143065453, -0.015498679131269455, 0.019274171441793442, -0.03632240369915962, 0.020221052691340446, 0.031122302636504173, -0.028913551941514015, -0.00197881693020463, -0.06338220089673996, -0.06269071996212006, 0.006632838863879442, -0.0016256006201729178, 0.02373747155070305, 0.013776988722383976, -0.016246406361460686, 0.053626351058483124, 0.01664368249475956, -0.046749502420425415, 0.0007440126501023769, -0.012961655855178833, -0.0237880926579237, -0.01812163181602955, -0.011707757599651814, 0.01675630547106266, 0.027200493961572647, 0.02951538749039173, -0.010945949703454971, -0.03223356977105141, 0.07338518649339676, 0.007846642285585403, -0.01786009594798088, 0.030598346143960953, 0.011564325541257858, 0.01497661229223013, 0.040032535791397095, -0.004328085109591484, -0.02044440619647503, 0.02672950178384781, 0.011202113702893257, 0.022032199427485466, 0.02639847993850708, -0.02380521036684513, 0.026838192716240883, -0.04664690047502518, -0.005787592381238937, -0.03892599418759346, 0.006030280143022537, 0.020689276978373528, 0.01429159939289093, -0.008569818921387196, 0.015680985525250435, 0.06247798725962639, -0.028085388243198395, 0.0001551191380713135, 0.04120219126343727, 0.00972458440810442, -0.0009892660891637206, -0.038055989891290665, -0.02639632858335972, -0.03460818529129028, -0.0072450716979801655, 0.0002288288960698992, -0.027975834906101227, 0.02634624019265175, 0.05633101984858513, 0.030023623257875443, 0.029805202037096024, -0.0228510070592165, 0.004011905286461115, -0.04259277880191803, 0.00459189061075449, -0.009145323187112808, 0.027953015640378, 0.017856331542134285, 0.044708240777254105, 0.038663193583488464, 0.00302197877317667, -0.022999392822384834, 0.014958685263991356, -0.08307769149541855, 0.01991933584213257, 0.006682363338768482, 0.011538196355104446, -0.04007822275161743, -0.020359039306640625, 0.07377844303846359, -0.01332310400903225, -0.010437010787427425, -0.007797590922564268, 0.02681286633014679, -0.046517837792634964, 0.007050447165966034, -0.005581374745815992, -0.02505873702466488, -0.009868431836366653, 0.0026171854697167873, 0.035587117075920105, 0.0019751410000026226, 0.0413227304816246, 0.04358956217765808, 0.018121009692549706, 0.0038131107576191425, -0.01912187784910202, 0.014148291200399399, -0.02480441704392433, 0.05246967077255249, -0.004400127567350864, 0.041695352643728256, -0.04384089633822441, 0.023479361087083817, -0.0046851481311023235, 0.09656700491905212, 0.07708099484443665, -0.023058759048581123, -0.019669147208333015, -0.03633122518658638, -0.022406384348869324, 0.0009157896274700761, 0.015683865174651146, -0.04386906698346138, 0.008778179995715618, 0.05956115946173668, -0.0024022459983825684, -0.054493363946676254, -0.009879477322101593, 0.04708223044872284, 0.044571924954652786, -0.018634909763932228, -0.04608673229813576, 0.022380582988262177, -0.03186112642288208, -0.020496545359492302, 0.009263199754059315, 0.02606397308409214, -0.008727849461138248, -0.004226265475153923, 0.027316313236951828, -0.0060515087097883224, -0.03562161698937416, -0.04692491516470909, 0.01773434691131115, 0.03408978879451752, -0.003989331424236298, -0.025865525007247925, 0.029449641704559326, 0.08168479055166245, 0.025559313595294952, 0.009309453889727592, -0.004929117392748594, -0.10004519671201706, -0.010963420383632183, 0.03260181471705437, 0.005863254889845848, -0.01659858226776123, -0.027386266738176346, -0.07708221673965454, -0.009098881855607033, 0.05666828155517578, -0.015172300860285759, 0.004148207604885101, -0.016538556665182114, -0.0032049291767179966, -0.018655218183994293, -0.029233340173959732, -0.05063600838184357, 0.009666504338383675, -0.03580636903643608, 0.03522515296936035, -0.007964390330016613, 0.00815021712332964, -0.011898561380803585, 0.016545170918107033, 0.017617056146264076, 0.06534529477357864, 0.0262148417532444, -0.007840153761208057, -0.035184115171432495, 0.014529208652675152, -0.0008886890136636794, -0.04522252082824707, 0.0009117851732298732, -0.0011932030320167542, -0.01589640974998474, 0.04384823516011238, -0.019915049895644188, -0.05523326247930527, 0.014075213111937046, -0.02942086197435856, -0.019518496468663216, -0.012636082246899605, -0.018317298963665962, 0.028644965961575508, 0.034608982503414154, 0.031294893473386765, 0.06851687282323837, -0.00705031119287014, 0.00653828214854002, 0.0219267588108778, -0.03474471718072891, 0.023048490285873413, -0.04469200223684311, -0.03491602838039398, -0.011018416844308376, 0.014205805957317352, 0.00860813818871975, 0.021590061485767365, 0.0015375969232991338, 0.03282414376735687, -0.001162951230071485, -0.006671711802482605, -0.0040036351419985294, 0.018503772094845772, 0.007034119218587875, -0.00993258599191904, -0.014170834794640541, 0.029416939243674278, 0.011274305172264576, 0.028107816353440285, 0.013145411387085915, -0.013485775329172611, 0.012695195153355598, -0.0008403208339586854, -0.041095685213804245, -0.013605762273073196, -0.06391371041536331, -0.008720999583601952, 0.009085392579436302, -0.03719306364655495, 0.04508694261312485, -0.0025522096548229456, 0.03894738852977753, 0.020917830988764763, -0.03919646143913269, -0.006667738314718008, -0.018763883039355278, 0.013428048230707645, 0.044821154326200485, -0.04438260570168495, 0.03419506549835205, -0.04160169139504433, -0.0000018971135204992606, -0.06520403176546097, -0.00971149280667305, 0.015034315176308155, 0.04648950323462486, -0.04017999768257141, -0.04462720826268196, 0.05222759023308754, 0.006423787213861942, -0.00435039633885026, -0.013773716986179352, 0.0347091443836689, -0.0060636443085968494, -0.012380262836813927, 0.0008187001221813262, 0.0004470135609153658, 0.05130114033818245, -0.0293179452419281, 0.004173168446868658, 0.06662895530462265, -0.004939273931086063, -0.005463856738060713, -0.009918130934238434, -0.007108641322702169, -0.04027210921049118, 0.009252144023776054, -0.02160368114709854, 0.011038835160434246, 0.01822470873594284, -0.0325266495347023, 0.0210519190877676, 0.00048643769696354866, 0.014341580681502819, -0.030889321118593216, -0.009320980869233608, 0.010802669450640678, 0.002900785766541958, -0.0027007453609257936, -0.02373223565518856, 0.014538674615323544, -0.02275029942393303, 0.028612380847334862, 0.0536029078066349, -0.011414740234613419, -0.008925290778279305, 0.003686697920784354, 0.06160406395792961, -0.009188265539705753, 0.009954269975423813, -0.0009196259197779, -0.001032135565765202, 0.042049456387758255, 0.007930670864880085, 0.012131277471780777, 0.01533281709998846, 0.05653148889541626, -0.04418942704796791, 0.01659632846713066, -0.08163248002529144, -0.006379765924066305, 0.06378824263811111, -0.008672493509948254, 0.07810354232788086, 0.04392353072762489, 0.0207136832177639, 0.011001436971127987, -0.016023855656385422, -0.012938777916133404, 0.0027370646130293608, -0.011971195228397846, 0.044504400342702866, 0.02268061228096485, 0.004092357587069273, 0.05713358148932457, -0.0023887506686151028, -0.01431944314390421, 0.06605859845876694, -0.02650892734527588, 0.029684079810976982, 0.05243603512644768, -0.02544785663485527, -0.0380980558693409, 0.01426425576210022, -0.05415545776486397, 0.008605405688285828, -0.03214292228221893, -0.026821449398994446, 0.058056555688381195, 0.008708542212843895, -0.003913909196853638, -0.013135728426277637, -0.012628361582756042, 0.0043936180882155895, 0.01584763638675213, 0.007024184335023165, -0.003510833950713277, 0.01669888012111187, 0.01938866265118122, -0.0028885521460324526, -0.034828510135412216, -0.0048933629877865314, 0.001301051233895123, -0.0823960080742836, -0.007465333212167025, -0.045949213206768036, -0.03914346545934677, 0.02220241166651249, 0.031180599704384804, -0.027949536219239235, 0.010079284198582172, 0.014458036050200462, 0.025365112349390984, -0.006622363813221455, 0.017350226640701294, -0.006509010214358568, 0.04906679317355156, -0.0023888901341706514, 0.03619435057044029, -0.009589102119207382, -0.00046796846436336637, 0.1253395974636078, 0.06678823381662369, 0.06203277409076691, -0.05504792928695679, -0.020210018381476402, -0.03478959947824478, -0.01758233830332756, -0.03156658262014389, 0.036655113101005554, 0.016224568709731102, 0.006450542248785496, -0.006572321522980928, 0.02724369987845421, 0.01564832404255867, 0.007382899522781372, 0.03403909504413605, -0.04754485562443733, -0.009571515955030918, 0.009364847093820572, 0.014418289996683598, 0.01760408654808998, -0.006711561698466539, -0.0487016886472702, 0.018868574872612953, 0.014192668721079826, -0.01473318226635456, -0.04176238179206848, -0.015822861343622208, 0.007498816587030888, -0.040702663362026215, -0.015430611558258533, -0.003362194634974003, 0.06766769289970398, 0.030667301267385483, 0.01193337794393301, 0.011420737020671368, 0.0170891135931015, -0.022502029314637184, 0.00942059513181448, -0.010384823195636272, -0.01301814429461956, -0.003952621482312679, -0.007707981858402491, -0.0037047748919576406, -0.020369602367281914, -0.017258644104003906, -0.07898297160863876, 0.0622270442545414, -0.03717757388949394, 0.01924094930291176, 0.0029636770486831665, 0.004221763461828232, -0.01203590352088213, -0.051196347922086716, -0.0031462772749364376, -0.012408282607793808, 0.024195363745093346, 0.006965484470129013, -0.042289119213819504, -0.04772236943244934, 0.01466373074799776, -0.01278422400355339, 0.05843565613031387, -0.0074782767333090305, -0.0064484416507184505, -0.007618115283548832, 0.0205977950245142, 0.04493025690317154, -0.011206330731511116, -0.0010879909386858344, -0.03322499245405197, -0.04392575845122337, -0.005390984937548637, -0.037346675992012024, 0.0132686672732234, -0.02047080174088478, 0.0033876493107527494, -0.0014137839898467064, -0.023577578365802765, -0.002022186992689967, -0.056721366941928864, 0.003984423819929361, -0.03779996186494827, -0.0003105620853602886, -0.04011322185397148, 0.0321643128991127, 0.02180437743663788, 0.05466705560684204, 0.058462128043174744, 0.015384390018880367, 0.02278485894203186, 0.031546175479888916, 0.014597675763070583, -0.0292383823543787, -0.014087028801441193, -0.02318171039223671, 0.0060110255144536495, 0.015241850167512894, -0.005486677400767803, 0.037237945944070816, 0.030897581949830055, 0.0164056196808815, -0.008524269796907902, 0.040430620312690735, -0.01701691374182701, 0.01101579237729311, -0.03995320200920105, -0.04235369339585304, -0.014163094572722912, 0.00014531603665091097, 0.03491188585758209, -0.05710752308368683, -0.03408405929803848, -0.004319311585277319, -0.06613286584615707, 0.04007994756102562, 0.0028996909968554974, -0.036253202706575394, -0.029925616458058357, 0.022360362112522125, 0.0518563911318779, 0.028510460630059242, 0.012681897729635239, -0.011213719844818115, 0.015975380316376686, -0.02794473059475422, -0.01751415617763996, -0.021880080923438072, 0.020225783810019493, -0.008873213082551956, 0.018898455426096916, 0.006934002041816711, -0.00024889412452466786, 0.010753092356026173, 0.012896102853119373, 0.001858111354522407, 0.02001003548502922, 0.03514730557799339, -0.002818246139213443, 0.0020205574110150337, 0.019469233229756355, -0.045643772929906845, -0.00824673380702734, 0.02394452877342701, 0.010938034392893314, 0.08470631390810013, 0.030140487477183342, -0.005936861038208008, -0.002535460749641061, 0.012299306690692902, -0.02638004720211029, -0.018240785226225853, 0.007169088814407587, 0.027858110144734383, -0.006249305792152882, 0.019300146028399467, 0.01627938076853752, -0.0010676123201847076, -0.005700534209609032, 0.00029840366914868355, 0.030995741486549377, 0.0007511473377235234, -0.028362521901726723, 0.056314826011657715, -0.022039705887436867, 0.03555496409535408, 0.022211024537682533, -0.012742238119244576, 0.0017313362332060933, 0.03551114723086357, 0.0005520274862647057, 0.02846193127334118, 0.008966896682977676, 0.013566591776907444, -0.10693245381116867, -0.029467718675732613, 0.038148652762174606, -0.02920679561793804, 0.04627930372953415, -0.058487508445978165, -0.013270546682178974, 0.05171678587794304, -0.05213446915149689, 0.04395223781466484, 0.015446783043444157, -0.03800111636519432, -0.028682198375463486, 0.040169090032577515, -0.026327358558773994, 0.020809335634112358, 0.027356449514627457, 0.009552018716931343, 0.04011056572198868, 0.03974606841802597, -0.013702369295060635, -0.043023478239774704, -0.03236047923564911, 0.021853862330317497, 0.03875931352376938, -0.056977659463882446, 0.04613488167524338, -0.044798098504543304, -0.014264097437262535, 0.023125499486923218, 0.03774991258978844, 0.015496943145990372, 0.02779003046452999, 0.00978950597345829, 0.01443322841078043, 0.040343932807445526, 0.033261027187108994, -0.03626120090484619, 0.006455987226217985, -0.006220750976353884, 0.005692198406904936, 0.011279291473329067, -0.05564974620938301, 0.011809811927378178, -0.0024003286380320787, -0.004378021229058504, -0.0393209271132946, 0.0363471545279026, -0.047237858176231384, -0.03518829867243767, 0.005481770262122154, -0.01025195699185133, -0.005184023175388575, -0.02322065271437168, 0.018866444006562233, -0.0791466012597084, -0.0012755984207615256, 0.01973283849656582, -0.004143098369240761, -0.031202109530568123, 0.03171533718705177, -0.04033908247947693, -0.05866565182805061, 0.015280313789844513, -0.003916753921657801, -0.010449373163282871, -0.07437534630298615, 0.021929847076535225, -0.018113698810338974, 0.000317183235893026, -0.0011709018144756556, -0.03816475719213486, -0.060114938765764236, 0.035954102873802185, 0.015359651297330856, 0.024840304628014565, 0.019218094646930695, -0.030341940000653267, -0.034950751811265945, -0.09927954524755478, 0.03324604034423828, 0.009890039451420307, -0.06513421982526779, 0.0033489230554550886, -0.015602486208081245, -0.016213973984122276, -0.015178538858890533, 0.046241071075201035, 0.01963004469871521, 0.006983979605138302, -0.006181156262755394, 0.02932228334248066, 0.017915960401296616, -0.03048831596970558, 0.02033250220119953, -0.017748232930898666, -0.033949241042137146, -0.007500230334699154, -0.009481823071837425, 0.028845176100730896, 0.0007154226186685264, 0.012338574975728989, 0.007135789375752211, 0.011355883441865444, 0.030095666646957397, 0.009437584318220615, 0.03709426149725914, 0.03734897822141647, -0.009425448253750801, 0.021177347749471664, -0.020474785938858986, 0.02034103497862816, 0.0017329681431874633, 0.003581052413210273, -0.06327397376298904, 0.0025687972083687782, -0.024387819692492485, -0.0361299067735672, 0.014374058693647385, 0.03539983183145523, -0.0007195208454504609, -0.0487876795232296, -0.019438153132796288, 0.03662068024277687, -0.04300779476761818, 0.009820903651416302, 0.04435405135154724, -0.029019078239798546, 0.027684109285473824, 0.0006758790113963187, 0.04262718930840492, 0.003050069324672222, -0.015762632712721825, 0.00792594812810421, -0.013724700547754765, 0.023456720635294914, -0.04900083690881729, 0.02938217483460903, 0.034268878400325775, -0.03495766967535019, 0.005203083157539368, -0.03604773432016373, 0.03742104768753052, -0.033017124980688095, 0.002594267250970006, 0.003970913123339415, -0.029913008213043213, 0.0016664423746988177, -0.01163950189948082, -0.01722581684589386, 0.10010740906000137, -0.02156250923871994, -0.013675272464752197, -0.05711129307746887, -0.03354039788246155, -0.04623305797576904, 0.01748385652899742, 0.01870121993124485, 0.02049163542687893, 0.022153325378894806, 0.0458982028067112, -0.01639099419116974, -0.00043648784048855305, 0.02169315703213215, -0.0027912999503314495, 0.013947910629212856, -0.014242586679756641, 0.013762219808995724, 0.015457413159310818, -0.004309155512601137, -0.01735830307006836, 0.005498063750565052, -0.0061159683391451836, 0.03370765969157219, 0.04009614512324333, -0.001826467108912766, -0.020033052191138268, -0.02187167853116989, 0.035400062799453735, -0.0737239345908165, -0.008273816667497158, -0.03882187604904175, 0.014273877255618572, 0.010847087949514389, -0.05141645297408104 ]
<p>I have done many 1-sample T-tests before, but I can't figure out if I am able to use one in this situation. In our experiment, we took 12 individual insects and placed them in a chamber where they could choose to be on whatever side they pleased (One side had sugar in it and the other did not). We recorded the number of insects on each side <em>at 30 second intervals</em> for 20 minutes.</p> <p>Is it possible to use a 1-sample T test here? It seems the data wouldn't be random, violating one of the fundamental assumptions for the test. The number of insects on one side at any time strongly influences the number that will be there at the time of the next reading.</p> <p>What exactly is data like this called? How can I analyze it and potentially reject the null hypothesis that the insects have no preference to the side with sugar vs. the side without?</p>
48,276
[ -0.015075714327394962, -0.05092988908290863, 0.01243255753070116, -0.0034052946139127016, 0.03312993049621582, 0.017136627808213234, -0.01625617779791355, 0.03813773766160011, -0.02818925864994526, 0.0013011278351768851, 0.04225008934736252, 0.04899592697620392, 0.03820190578699112, 0.02100919373333454, 0.025136232376098633, 0.011118976399302483, -0.02411683462560177, 0.005952408071607351, -0.016378508880734444, -0.03871779888868332, 0.010787645354866982, -0.0033353783655911684, 0.006260030437260866, -0.022895678877830505, -0.028306806460022926, 0.012433763593435287, 0.0168425515294075, -0.004717766307294369, -0.009395312517881393, 0.045138273388147354, -0.06334027647972107, -0.03930012881755829, -0.01269960030913353, 0.008330480195581913, 0.008199191652238369, -0.02690674364566803, -0.023681098595261574, -0.026598850265145302, 0.006213616579771042, 0.00864412635564804, -0.03719199821352959, -0.019221728667616844, -0.006404691841453314, 0.02405366115272045, -0.032656703144311905, 0.028427232056856155, -0.0046280561946332455, -0.016290344297885895, 0.05428444966673851, -0.04463263601064682, 0.06315170228481293, -0.0018074522959068418, 0.04738295450806618, 0.036814816296100616, 0.03194678574800491, 0.004864294081926346, 0.044885165989398956, 0.04196717590093613, -0.004843059461563826, -0.04327850416302681, -0.02479209378361702, -0.0530535914003849, -0.0008204107289202511, -0.0014150395290926099, -0.028812071308493614, -0.016082197427749634, 0.012615310959517956, 0.007924950681626797, 0.02855406515300274, -0.03332691267132759, 0.04692615941166878, 0.015551517717540264, 0.04013299569487572, 0.026809940114617348, -0.039408162236213684, -0.020919721573591232, 0.04249478876590729, 0.01748298481106758, 0.06374774128198624, 0.04976292699575424, 0.014480522833764553, 0.0009808179456740618, 0.04009104147553444, 0.05652594938874245, 0.03505077585577965, -0.050564829260110855, 0.058392517268657684, -0.02345278114080429, -0.023553265258669853, 0.023125603795051575, -0.02168246917426586, 0.010843881405889988, 0.0398113839328289, 0.029975922778248787, -0.06114929914474487, 0.034280117601156235, -0.006179637275636196, 0.017603091895580292, -0.020050613209605217, -0.02472587861120701, -0.01049873512238264, -0.03295520693063736, 0.04459846019744873, 0.027677634730935097, -0.04777396842837334, 0.012967987917363644, -0.007759675849229097, 0.043810125440359116, 0.02992655336856842, 0.024011757224798203, -0.03266854211688042, 0.021361585706472397, 0.032432831823825836, -0.0014125020243227482, 0.029074037447571754, 0.00009327819861937314, -0.0012978153536096215, 0.003597380593419075, 0.06232089176774025, 0.07216142117977142, 0.061325348913669586, -0.028076041489839554, 0.01906006969511509, 0.0035316739231348038, -0.04437585547566414, 0.03294919803738594, 0.0033142268657684326, -0.0005230542155914009, -0.020540134981274605, 0.07427091151475906, -0.008109440095722675, -0.020225144922733307, 0.07840989530086517, -0.00401265686377883, 0.048443976789712906, -0.011938816867768764, -0.0761253759264946, -0.07771878689527512, 0.06249011680483818, -0.040827903896570206, -0.01846134662628174, -0.07529791444540024, -0.003918209578841925, 0.00591023126617074, 0.04937067627906799, 0.032409705221652985, 0.05044867843389511, -0.003974772524088621, 0.01877630688250065, 0.0389011949300766, -0.027768805623054504, -0.026437468826770782, 0.012594019062817097, -0.01631098799407482, -0.011009009554982185, -0.0642121434211731, 0.021797791123390198, 0.006225208751857281, 0.010817475616931915, -0.009475164115428925, 0.014401125721633434, -0.03390652686357498, -0.01601213961839676, 0.0171425212174654, -0.011067193932831287, -0.035696934908628464, 0.08163512498140335, -0.008848636411130428, 0.00915268063545227, -0.021814975887537003, 0.015033982694149017, 0.013538584113121033, 0.013601774349808693, 0.03365003690123558, 0.011740333400666714, -0.01845853589475155, 0.004397520329803228, -0.00233725574798882, 0.03262944892048836, -0.016795167699456215, -0.0026670112274587154, -0.005697503220289946, 0.016647176817059517, 0.024045756086707115, 0.020021144300699234, 0.022697938606142998, -0.014929698780179024, -0.013861063867807388, 0.035768378525972366, -0.05066729336977005, -0.07602588087320328, -0.07575932145118713, -0.024771442636847496, -0.020830344408750534, -0.019223593175411224, 0.018551787361502647, 0.02402510866522789, 0.036005448549985886, -0.0105561763048172, -0.02542910724878311, -0.015223571099340916, 0.0090675363317132, 0.04152045026421547, -0.04039132595062256, -0.007257226854562759, 0.04599513113498688, 0.030494283884763718, -0.040175627917051315, 0.02280862256884575, -0.02368456870317459, 0.0005301085766404867, -0.0015256947372108698, -0.06106233224272728, 0.051055315881967545, 0.01668591983616352, -0.010262256488204002, 0.029733167961239815, 0.021013379096984863, -0.030053989961743355, 0.04602415859699249, -0.03195147588849068, 0.04157320037484169, 0.04298178851604462, 0.01264406181871891, -0.007746432907879353, 0.0016050143167376518, 0.03205236420035362, 0.01379143912345171, 0.00039044718141667545, -0.015373877249658108, -0.0689244493842125, 0.011698493734002113, 0.05631231144070625, -0.014110428281128407, 0.0007334022666327655, -0.00024995309649966657, 0.05542067065834999, 0.013315523974597454, 0.00734627665951848, 0.06276000291109085, 0.002045570407062769, -0.028428060933947563, 0.011742888949811459, 0.012944290414452553, 0.04217394068837166, 0.0002207056386396289, 0.02921028807759285, -0.053698357194662094, 0.032232824712991714, 0.04731457680463791, -0.01423818338662386, 0.04675096645951271, -0.006690809037536383, -0.0058307405561208725, 0.007654484827071428, -0.03452258184552193, 0.03158392012119293, -0.036260202527046204, 0.02943362668156624, 0.02978850156068802, 0.030411988496780396, 0.030608678236603737, -0.010634188540279865, -0.0010493637528270483, -0.010023454204201698, 0.02669624052941799, 0.004765993449836969, 0.0005900050746276975, 0.02745499089360237, -0.03990747779607773, 0.01685154438018799, 0.01039477065205574, -0.05465630441904068, -0.0040511698462069035, -0.01625293865799904, 0.010470593348145485, 0.023261122405529022, 0.03530193865299225, -0.033826794475317, -0.033502448350191116, 0.00832300167530775, -0.022268086671829224, 0.014341149479150772, 0.021259909495711327, -0.060344148427248, 0.013732165098190308, -0.025665728375315666, -0.02334701269865036, 0.02640574984252453, 0.006234318949282169, -0.007689503487199545, 0.014213403686881065, -0.0017606336623430252, -0.049447201192379, -0.0475207157433033, -0.025799697265028954, -0.020126374438405037, -0.056010518223047256, -0.02350575663149357, 0.04056854918599129, 0.013865988701581955, -0.029351895675063133, 0.034212786704301834, -0.04910595715045929, -0.016488846391439438, -0.010160583071410656, 0.0010205007856711745, 0.007277309894561768, -0.01681993156671524, -0.012043175287544727, 0.005250993650406599, -0.037601202726364136, -0.013642797246575356, -0.04411294683814049, -0.08592355996370316, -0.00004270067438483238, -0.024259455502033234, 0.05168402940034866, 0.020140228793025017, -0.009353484958410263, 0.10157062858343124, 0.014698520302772522, -0.03243473544716835, -0.01893889345228672, -0.015653038397431374, -0.027087362483143806, -0.040509503334760666, 0.07608259469270706, 0.03923114016652107, -0.0038531022146344185, -0.00894149113446474, 0.03526490181684494, 0.058624930679798126, 0.0548161119222641, 0.005860922392457724, -0.019335664808750153, -0.007219292689114809, -0.01348799467086792, -0.008419189602136612, 0.026043176651000977, 0.029623959213495255, -0.021334780380129814, 0.02337760105729103, -0.035334378480911255, 0.017372537404298782, 0.030495963990688324, -0.05971911922097206, 0.008652176707983017, -0.010755212046205997, 0.036407120525836945, -0.02937505394220352, 0.05851033329963684, 0.011592215858399868, -0.008023173548281193, -0.008561691269278526, 0.04951100051403046, 0.03339404612779617, -0.03741370141506195, -0.013413731008768082, 0.07536043226718903, 0.03812417760491371, -0.03944692760705948, -0.02482515759766102, -0.0018246746622025967, 0.011479868553578854, 0.019761234521865845, -0.0037839170545339584, -0.025505846366286278, 0.02828104980289936, 0.055226270109415054, 0.061347875744104385, -0.010619611479341984, -0.055313535034656525, 0.019567308947443962, -0.03582385182380676, 0.010477231815457344, -0.025155112147331238, 0.03257894515991211, -0.02530387043952942, 0.05736764520406723, 0.01150913629680872, 0.003591720014810562, 0.04478980600833893, 0.00674422038719058, -0.0463644415140152, 0.020162688568234444, 0.0048361606895923615, -0.014464323408901691, 0.009523836895823479, 0.00970324594527483, 0.030973419547080994, -0.02401592954993248, 0.014477713964879513, 0.005627501290291548, -0.011151810176670551, -0.03818883001804352, 0.028309399262070656, -0.0066253854893147945, -0.005394872277975082, -0.0358525775372982, 0.04587709903717041, 0.011226232163608074, -0.0334165096282959, 0.006439406890422106, 0.036063071340322495, -0.003853778587654233, -0.014960729517042637, -0.003005446633324027, -0.010755769908428192, 0.0315060131251812, 0.058546192944049835, 0.0021986770443618298, 0.016517749056220055, -0.034902654588222504, 0.014012434519827366, 0.011088307946920395, 0.05991426110267639, 0.03603691607713699, 0.027550091966986656, -0.027619343250989914, -0.04427081719040871, -0.02302546426653862, -0.009405757300555706, 0.038381434977054596, 0.007046609651297331, -0.02904926799237728, 0.057336945086717606, 0.028181666508316994, -0.0617707185447216, 0.021282745525240898, 0.015207485295832157, 0.03358858451247215, -0.01951945200562477, -0.06185629218816757, -0.040978386998176575, -0.0035069878213107586, 0.016044598072767258, 0.01921319216489792, -0.0069929007440805435, -0.008491633459925652, 0.02199518121778965, 0.019999757409095764, 0.0070440443232655525, -0.02702813595533371, -0.010962446220219135, -0.04529685899615288, 0.04527350887656212, -0.0021869537886232138, -0.03152313083410263, 0.021695824339985847, 0.04516036808490753, 0.010866189375519753, 0.037442903965711594, 0.014277110807597637, -0.06645320355892181, 0.002803622977808118, 0.028506284579634666, 0.008548625744879246, -0.04007798060774803, 0.014345444738864899, -0.01708415150642395, 0.008320559747517109, 0.0017468406585976481, -0.05619081109762192, 0.007540714927017689, -0.01031498983502388, 0.007873238064348698, -0.032757654786109924, 0.005470894277095795, -0.05029682070016861, -0.018197303637862206, -0.052712488919496536, 0.021996868774294853, -0.0016697171377018094, -0.024929700419306755, -0.02426775172352791, 0.009530243463814259, 0.012572442181408405, 0.02578408271074295, -0.06727520376443863, -0.0018923020688816905, 0.022866256535053253, -0.016149362549185753, 0.006751662585884333, -0.05927971377968788, 0.021205490455031395, -0.011774991638958454, 0.030154680833220482, 0.05670900642871857, -0.03997107222676277, -0.05766531080007553, 0.014400675892829895, 0.017546819522976875, -0.042006343603134155, -0.016792243346571922, -0.02368517965078354, 0.00682753324508667, 0.028358301147818565, -0.012789363041520119, 0.0517101064324379, 0.050997909158468246, 0.03610987588763237, 0.013167811557650566, -0.0133310342207551, 0.02987593226134777, -0.04457507282495499, 0.016908347606658936, -0.034397371113300323, -0.03438397869467735, -0.04230145364999771, 0.01830420456826687, 0.024213282391428947, 0.011206387542188168, 0.00627831369638443, -0.02903822250664234, -0.015559487044811249, 0.03089338168501854, 0.01785939931869507, 0.0050331284292042255, -0.0007602269179187715, 0.001726064714603126, 0.0018733515171334147, -0.004328059032559395, -0.002279842272400856, -0.06813997775316238, 0.018008965998888016, 0.006614500656723976, -0.01999741420149803, 0.02527318336069584, -0.07203079015016556, -0.02089388482272625, 0.03306381031870842, -0.05013374611735344, 0.04078724607825279, -0.03589104115962982, 0.0344347208738327, -0.015930375084280968, -0.039824362844228745, -0.03775569051504135, 0.03932683914899826, 0.03297629579901695, 0.03401847183704376, -0.049263209104537964, 0.03696545213460922, -0.015066140331327915, 0.022995298728346825, -0.07343409955501556, -0.012946270406246185, 0.008353271521627903, 0.015815623104572296, -0.04679451882839203, -0.03445129096508026, -0.01816389709711075, 0.0033012970816344023, 0.005286477506160736, -0.01343581173568964, 0.016124626621603966, 0.007537943311035633, -0.024922555312514305, 0.013758144341409206, 0.009202939458191395, 0.06625288724899292, 0.026360629126429558, -0.04301206022500992, -0.0022695802617818117, -0.014779351651668549, -0.015299305319786072, 0.0052296314388513565, -0.012397360056638718, -0.03594061732292175, 0.027560614049434662, -0.01942886970937252, 0.02554383873939514, -0.006841755472123623, -0.03241627290844917, -0.021687520667910576, 0.004562597721815109, -0.04037807509303093, -0.0030540726147592068, -0.04237828031182289, 0.015584663487970829, 0.0034981523640453815, -0.03305864706635475, -0.029273835942149162, 0.012727194465696812, -0.019932609051465988, -0.022534003481268883, 0.04541601240634918, 0.01690780557692051, -0.037153344601392746, 0.04913349077105522, 0.06867340952157974, 0.007289277855306864, -0.023434815928339958, -0.007721146568655968, -0.049216367304325104, -0.0017716148868203163, 0.0071593523025512695, -0.008154182694852352, 0.005844687111675739, 0.01712040975689888, -0.026464851573109627, -0.007111262530088425, 0.017187608405947685, 0.01618053950369358, 0.04889078810811043, 0.0020256226416677237, 0.030664343386888504, 0.07053698599338531, 0.012889837846159935, -0.01746540144085884, 0.008268876932561398, 0.026149019598960876, 0.011133674532175064, 0.017935821786522865, 0.010444771498441696, -0.004318046383559704, -0.01543780229985714, 0.018617374822497368, 0.03704453632235527, -0.019604114815592766, 0.021846851333975792, 0.037996139377355576, -0.012472867034375668, 0.03835728019475937, -0.0008812604355625808, -0.034846700727939606, 0.012558957561850548, -0.03443244844675064, 0.0412319153547287, -0.04038004204630852, 0.0022486206144094467, 0.025098325684666634, 0.05336194485425949, 0.0006490522646345198, -0.05251236632466316, -0.027634253725409508, -0.060139138251543045, 0.021249789744615555, 0.031624265015125275, 0.010827772319316864, 0.03762156516313553, 0.010697150602936745, 0.02729525789618492, -0.014690996147692204, -0.013722443953156471, -0.024511931464076042, -0.01935560815036297, -0.04251190274953842, -0.05239193141460419, -0.031710896641016006, 0.05533500015735626, -0.035459451377391815, 0.00011942119454033673, 0.0038588859606534243, -0.03675638139247894, 0.006539320573210716, 0.011946580372750759, 0.035771001130342484, -0.02516677975654602, 0.08973000943660736, 0.00314367120154202, 0.04365415871143341, -0.025012874975800514, -0.00274073937907815, 0.11147696524858475, 0.057945989072322845, 0.02134714089334011, -0.04962637275457382, 0.004842626396566629, -0.007566413376480341, -0.011886697262525558, -0.028170190751552582, -0.012296613305807114, 0.019614072516560555, 0.01036071591079235, 0.04792186617851257, 0.04722951725125313, 0.0020839315839111805, -0.03121897019445896, 0.08807162195444107, -0.005806211847811937, -0.04183873534202576, 0.0022019552998244762, -0.012917999178171158, 0.014076021499931812, -0.07361329346895218, -0.020943935960531235, 0.009678403846919537, 0.018914755433797836, -0.028707141056656837, -0.004649695940315723, -0.05082765966653824, -0.013634759932756424, 0.010616638697683811, -0.005672720726579428, -0.02319447509944439, -0.004486008081585169, 0.04893535375595093, -0.06329817324876785, 0.0004382789193186909, -0.00887008011341095, -0.0446515791118145, 0.02236662246286869, 0.07857252657413483, 0.01414243783801794, 0.009954306297004223, 0.03419792652130127, 0.038222674280405045, -0.03802965208888054, -0.025683321058750153, -0.011243587359786034, 0.019880717620253563, -0.03258753940463066, -0.006229346618056297, -0.016254130750894547, 0.022622883319854736, 0.006915377918630838, -0.034879397600889206, -0.006174216512590647, 0.018994541838765144, 0.017711039632558823, -0.04700542986392975, -0.023137535899877548, -0.039907220751047134, -0.00531752547249198, -0.01965261623263359, 0.016221992671489716, 0.023897169157862663, -0.002142620738595724, 0.02133873850107193, -0.011907781474292278, 0.0537591427564621, 0.003234256524592638, -0.03459735959768295, 0.001383764436468482, -0.031796980649232864, -0.04650349169969559, 0.07130314409732819, 0.0015523690963163972, -0.006332945078611374, 0.0009793411009013653, -0.009569752030074596, -0.04832734167575836, 0.002346945693716407, -0.010231740772724152, -0.005306558683514595, -0.053294990211725235, -0.01947822794318199, -0.007676289416849613, -0.01486453041434288, 0.01648859679698944, 0.04795871302485466, 0.020058108493685722, 0.004010151140391827, 0.019318219274282455, 0.031747691333293915, 0.0236834604293108, -0.06391515582799911, -0.015505088493227959, -0.015451264567673206, -0.050906952470541, -0.007822461426258087, -0.005803282372653484, 0.06883136183023453, 0.02274814248085022, 0.006586768664419651, -0.015889082103967667, -0.018149860203266144, -0.0004883076762780547, 0.00023924364359118044, -0.023342760279774666, -0.050565455108881, -0.0011180988512933254, 0.005691364407539368, 0.016029365360736847, -0.04155202955007553, -0.0766589492559433, -0.033152591437101364, 0.010996054857969284, 0.016534147784113884, 0.006358946207910776, -0.01357120182365179, -0.001447705551981926, -0.002289597177878022, 0.00292322039604187, -0.007418331224471331, 0.02938131056725979, -0.038784511387348175, -0.04451374337077141, 0.015089338645339012, 0.007093819323927164, -0.012591765262186527, -0.010280837304890156, -0.016825083643198013, 0.026975449174642563, 0.06304091960191727, -0.018724365159869194, 0.015928227454423904, 0.015202629379928112, 0.03657766059041023, 0.00504304887726903, 0.029950911179184914, -0.004888591356575489, -0.016637880355119705, 0.07697805017232895, -0.043792374432086945, -0.03379949554800987, 0.009393769316375256, 0.02303495816886425, 0.03436111658811569, 0.023437514901161194, -0.024143008515238762, 0.009621718898415565, -0.003624472301453352, -0.044603556394577026, -0.019095629453659058, 0.010961390100419521, -0.041969697922468185, 0.009312923066318035, -0.033885132521390915, 0.00018362024275120348, 0.03654896840453148, 0.0010712223593145609, 0.02972925454378128, 0.05100226029753685, 0.005376224871724844, -0.024199293926358223, -0.01289709284901619, 0.012076255865395069, 0.02506890520453453, -0.01108572632074356, -0.031092995777726173, -0.00454754289239645, 0.09362882375717163, -0.03464364632964134, 0.029162876307964325, -0.004532209597527981, -0.020128333941102028, -0.08185771107673645, 0.007502863649278879, 0.0030827741138637066, 0.00959091167896986, 0.027173858135938644, -0.0372258685529232, -0.009835365228354931, 0.01576208509504795, -0.026117658242583275, 0.019634000957012177, -0.007242737337946892, -0.030185436829924583, -0.04772379249334335, -0.018825704231858253, -0.0008116438984870911, 0.00026985176373273134, 0.02478981576859951, -0.0052444711327552795, 0.020180050283670425, 0.03319524601101875, -0.01450944785028696, -0.02422136254608631, 0.029224874451756477, 0.05885777994990349, -0.00167614605743438, -0.03397908806800842, 0.017619017511606216, -0.05812785401940346, -0.04393864795565605, 0.0381791889667511, 0.0007754471153020859, 0.012662825174629688, 0.021778034046292305, 0.015449565835297108, -0.026030641049146652, 0.03744008392095566, 0.05770731344819069, -0.020363830029964447, -0.06231413036584854, 0.023489056155085564, 0.010245364159345627, 0.01766418106853962, 0.005368060898035765, -0.029023664072155952, 0.0244489386677742, -0.024651549756526947, 0.00022690306650474668, 0.044707950204610825, -0.028305908665060997, -0.033288296312093735, 0.04391134902834892, -0.014437077566981316, 0.021936729550361633, -0.012621359899640083, -0.00422246940433979, -0.043837882578372955, 0.009187377989292145, 0.04107429459691048, 0.028201717883348465, -0.04863925650715828, -0.013981729745864868, -0.02723466232419014, -0.026621010154485703, 0.04011566936969757, 0.023776572197675705, -0.03866560384631157, -0.0453832745552063, -0.008949760347604752, -0.044773247092962265, -0.02419997751712799, -0.06060817092657089, 0.02310698665678501, -0.002425365149974823, 0.0308190006762743, 0.005713514983654022, 0.014581605792045593, 0.020894981920719147, -0.027761006727814674, 0.02729223668575287, -0.06285644322633743, 0.08287930488586426, -0.004103111103177071, 0.012341370806097984, -0.013069093227386475, -0.026406239718198776, -0.04746720567345619, -0.027964694425463676, 0.06238505244255066, 0.02779226377606392, 0.025582842528820038, 0.017796548083424568, 0.005493314005434513, 0.0002283843932673335, -0.04741870239377022, 0.04377537593245506, -0.0132917994633317, -0.0008180855656974018, -0.023496203124523163, -0.015061809681355953, 0.011267426423728466, 0.005028638057410717, 0.008714203722774982, -0.01814405247569084, 0.004639472812414169, -0.03248155117034912, -0.006979087367653847, 0.039932213723659515, 0.010591399855911732, -0.00015534876729361713, 0.03598015382885933, 0.012354194186627865, 0.0048123192973434925, 0.005348921753466129, -0.05021267011761665, -0.04912450909614563, 0.023303713649511337, -0.05700422078371048, -0.011856988072395325, -0.0072943950071930885, 0.03701286017894745, 0.018385449424386024, -0.044699233025312424, -0.00558712612837553, -0.03171287104487419, -0.0008529662736691535, 0.040059350430965424, 0.016162598505616188, 0.016106195747852325, 0.026369929313659668, -0.046576593071222305, 0.013688130304217339, -0.014072207733988762, 0.011180410161614418, 0.024881012737751007, 0.03785284608602524, -0.006723088212311268, 0.004921763204038143, 0.007116347085684538, 0.022765813395380974, -0.015215587802231312, 0.00935774203389883, -0.013722752220928669, 0.024496499449014664, 0.014331360347568989, -0.01586480811238289, 0.025322584435343742, 0.00443290313705802, 0.01725073903799057, 0.010234307497739792, 0.011406556703150272, 0.07726383209228516, -0.018394872546195984, 0.004515509586781263, -0.03309905156493187, -0.029740164056420326, -0.007597686722874641, -0.004290266428142786, 0.0422767736017704, 0.019080443307757378, -0.00390343158505857, -0.003233223920688033, 0.0008854570332914591, 0.004613187164068222, 0.011565515771508217, -0.04027913510799408, 0.02028871886432171, 0.0030315397307276726, -0.02589513547718525, -0.032169584184885025, 0.012990022078156471, -0.0019649460446089506, -0.03106473945081234, 0.012495861388742924, 0.013173057697713375, 0.01102694682776928, -0.03604654222726822, -0.023789161816239357, -0.007415301166474819, 0.04884306713938713, -0.02336932346224785, -0.047391440719366074, -0.03330494463443756, 0.055165935307741165, 0.012087146751582623, -0.004419984295964241 ]
<p>This question has two parts, as I do not understand whether my problem is theoretical (identification of the parameters) or practical (insufficient R skills).</p> <ul> <li>Econometrics</li> </ul> <p>Most "probit" style models are identified through a normalization of the standard error to one. In my case, I would argue that this is not necessary as the order of magnitude is already set by fixing one coefficient to 1. More specifically, for each observation there is a dummy variable equal to one if the latent index is above a (observation-specific and observed) threshold :</p> <p>$$d_i=1 \text{ iff } K_i &gt; X_i \beta + \epsilon_i$$</p> <p>The error term is assumed $\epsilon_i \thicksim \mathcal{N}(0, \sigma)$. In my naive understanding, the likelihood of this problem should somehow look like (where $\Phi$ is the standard normal cdf):</p> <p>$$L= \prod_{i=1}^N \Phi \left(\frac{K_i - X_i \beta}{\sigma} \right)^{d_i} \Phi \left(\frac{X_i \beta -K_i}{\sigma} \right)^{1-d_i} $$</p> <p>Is it possible to estimate $\sigma$ without further normalization? </p> <ul> <li>Estimation</li> </ul> <p>If the answer to previous part is "yes" -- then why does my R implementation not work? </p> <pre><code>### simulate data set.seed(5849) N &lt;- 2000 b.cons &lt;- 8 b.x &lt;- 10 sig &lt;- 2 x &lt;- cbind(rep(1, N), runif(N)) #"observed variables" e &lt;- rnorm(N, sig) # "unobserved error" k &lt;- runif(N)*10+8 # threshold: something random, but high enough to guarantee some variation in i t &lt;- x%*%c(b.cons, b.x)+e i &lt;- 1*(k&gt;t) #participation dummy ### likelihood function probit.sim &lt;- function(params, I, K, X) { params[1:2] -&gt; b params[3] -&gt; s z= (K-X%*%b)/s pr.1 = pnorm(z) pr.1[pr.1==0] &lt;- 0.001 #seems somehow weird to me, but how is this problem usually treated?? pr.1[pr.1==1] &lt;- 0.999 pr.0 = 1-pr.1 llik = t(I)%*%log(pr.1) + t(1-I)%*%log(pr.0) -llik } ### maximize likelihood optim(c(1,1,1), probit.sim, I = i, K = k, X = x) #using a random starting vector st &lt;- coef(lm(k*(1-i) ~ x-1)) #searching for better standard values optim(c(st, 1), probit.sim, I = i, K = k, X = x) </code></pre> <p>The estimated parameters are clearly not c(8, 10, 2) as they should be.</p> <p>I asked a related question on already on stack overflow, and the answer was "take better starting values", but this does not seem to do the trick here. Or maybe I don't know how to do it right.</p> <p>Any ideas?</p> <ul> <li>Alternative approach</li> </ul> <p>My alternative was to use standard statistical software and estimate a probit (needs a bit of twisting but should be possible to make it equivalent). This estimates a coefficient for K, which should be equal to $-1/\sigma$; how about taking this $\sigma$ and computing the "non-normalized"/"true" values of the other coefficients?</p> <p>Many thanks in advance for any suggestion on any of these 3 parts.</p>
37,083
[ -0.03245050832629204, -0.011108435690402985, -0.01750824600458145, -0.018231602385640144, 0.02985253557562828, -0.018287701532244682, -0.032673370093107224, -0.014771638438105583, 0.03187882900238037, -0.05258522555232048, 0.023783057928085327, 0.01475932914763689, 0.05852804705500603, 0.051284175366163254, 0.05013245344161987, 0.0013418644666671753, -0.00918725784868002, 0.012532013468444347, -0.02179301716387272, -0.013800029642879963, 0.04770869389176369, 0.022801807150244713, -0.010612850077450275, 0.027299867942929268, -0.014208122156560421, 0.04109257459640503, 0.01282303873449564, -0.03487876057624817, -0.03542506322264671, 0.041617803275585175, -0.021048223599791527, -0.03639918565750122, 0.04968057572841644, 0.023092538118362427, -0.012446328997612, 0.030539032071828842, 0.01903529465198517, -0.03121996857225895, -0.01221836544573307, 0.025751451030373573, -0.02362637408077717, 0.0010937104234471917, 0.017010880634188652, 0.03940797224640846, -0.004920775070786476, 0.0464685894548893, 0.01077747531235218, -0.04937993362545967, 0.04262324050068855, -0.025017211213707924, 0.08238490670919418, 0.010674342513084412, 0.006367672700434923, 0.04778702184557915, -0.0327538400888443, -0.04165538772940636, 0.0508604571223259, 0.10043569654226303, -0.036316853016614914, -0.06655827164649963, -0.04093662649393082, -0.02028755471110344, 0.00516135198995471, -0.012831897474825382, -0.017675485461950302, -0.020179560407996178, 0.03608867898583412, 0.005255401600152254, 0.0385180339217186, -0.015478720888495445, 0.02837778441607952, 0.007207014597952366, 0.047438014298677444, 0.030738465487957, 0.013374769128859043, -0.01960062049329281, -0.03349350392818451, -0.0067952959798276424, 0.028680900111794472, 0.050786253064870834, -0.00008876882930053398, 0.0056116534397006035, 0.03607335314154625, 0.06003952398896217, 0.0010634100763127208, -0.02915412001311779, 0.04958193376660347, -0.05341811850667, 0.05862726643681526, 0.012391439639031887, -0.05546928942203522, 0.017734209075570107, 0.07619321346282959, 0.003232054878026247, -0.04826098307967186, 0.0701587051153183, -0.0026186048053205013, 0.02243177220225334, 0.008945932611823082, -0.01863022707402706, -0.0505518801510334, -0.05410686507821083, 0.005214297212660313, 0.08383023738861084, -0.02107355371117592, 0.012457497417926788, -0.003734199795871973, 0.0020007342100143433, -0.018677907064557076, -0.0386170893907547, -0.02895551733672619, 0.03040207363665104, -0.0036058477126061916, -0.03558533266186714, 0.0014774854062125087, -0.01619010977447033, -0.02403799630701542, -0.03558232635259628, 0.04763508588075638, 0.05864115431904793, 0.00947200134396553, -0.0093004135414958, -0.0006990359979681671, -0.002440645359456539, -0.04094608128070831, 0.02385237254202366, 0.043276097625494, -0.02429095096886158, -0.027739401906728745, 0.01725504733622074, 0.0024071545340120792, -0.015483046881854534, 0.024352753534913063, 0.037515200674533844, 0.04922468960285187, 0.013359996490180492, -0.0768914446234703, -0.04572204872965813, 0.03184008225798607, 0.007161877118051052, -0.007158677093684673, -0.08076164126396179, -0.0038676282856613398, 0.038954008370637894, 0.020518606528639793, 0.018164562061429024, 0.045059483498334885, 0.056470468640327454, -0.002319629769772291, 0.03452107682824135, -0.020747823640704155, -0.028368210420012474, -0.04056435078382492, -0.03063426911830902, -0.04758834466338158, -0.05932658538222313, 0.02168288454413414, 0.014106964692473412, -0.027121340855956078, -0.004870311822742224, 0.016165608540177345, 0.022340236231684685, -0.0107576297596097, 0.008455300703644753, 0.01758061908185482, -0.010755040682852268, 0.03920134902000427, -0.0012210770510137081, 0.03529559448361397, 0.00550877396017313, -0.021780459210276604, -0.0111510856077075, -0.008164389990270138, 0.0699954405426979, 0.04030345752835274, -0.03900829330086708, 0.006412323098629713, -0.05861205235123634, 0.012260167859494686, 0.003331126645207405, -0.05256440490484238, -0.013345330953598022, -0.023398617282509804, -0.012236729264259338, 0.027121825143694878, 0.01964203082025051, 0.028688648715615273, -0.017359808087348938, 0.0377580001950264, -0.04093319922685623, -0.05659177526831627, -0.08273571729660034, -0.015514137223362923, -0.00565517321228981, -0.019198700785636902, 0.016207236796617508, -0.010015038773417473, 0.020363392308354378, -0.0071977656334638596, 0.0039205304346978664, -0.03954853489995003, -0.0017187418416142464, 0.07177964597940445, -0.06822730600833893, -0.0007910531130619347, 0.021213583648204803, 0.09425327181816101, -0.02712167799472809, 0.07404101639986038, -0.05137477442622185, -0.04801667109131813, 0.007798901759088039, -0.033264145255088806, 0.0057886396534740925, 0.011092370375990868, -0.02770697884261608, 0.041092269122600555, -0.00769503228366375, 0.001287464750930667, 0.03454697132110596, -0.07526901364326477, 0.03344503790140152, 0.06266274303197861, -0.002154978923499584, -0.037524521350860596, -0.015322759747505188, 0.016983114182949066, 0.004155315458774567, -0.04693150147795677, -0.002428889274597168, -0.014196954667568207, -0.02561291866004467, 0.059170156717300415, 0.03900892660021782, -0.02694249153137207, 0.00048394876648671925, 0.06087949499487877, -0.007948054932057858, 0.01997266337275505, -0.002616958925500512, -0.011124061420559883, -0.023045428097248077, 0.005792960058897734, -0.041423071175813675, 0.007519776467233896, 0.033182401210069656, 0.057242315262556076, -0.008617687970399857, 0.03338584303855896, -0.01812526397407055, 0.04399323835968971, 0.04466613009572029, 0.010371793061494827, 0.024779031053185463, -0.026367926970124245, 0.0014586234465241432, 0.08573177456855774, 0.01817682944238186, -0.004968157969415188, 0.02474788948893547, -0.001705016940832138, 0.03622743487358093, 0.02037975564599037, 0.005424158181995153, 0.025612754747271538, 0.03873245418071747, -0.02807231806218624, -0.0017931925831362605, 0.007841084152460098, -0.019218888133764267, 0.02417631633579731, -0.02086622267961502, -0.014661045745015144, 0.001953239319846034, 0.008711067028343678, 0.023599717766046524, -0.016968190670013428, -0.006476662587374449, -0.037708524614572525, 0.004812334198504686, -0.0023000517394393682, 0.03086334466934204, 0.04915555939078331, 0.0039208438247442245, -0.049522798508405685, -0.019589148461818695, -0.02116725966334343, -0.007143163122236729, -0.007160090375691652, -0.01769893988966942, -0.01744668185710907, 0.038832616060972214, 0.008099292404949665, -0.02576257660984993, -0.008079834282398224, -0.028877509757876396, -0.01341366209089756, -0.02938934788107872, -0.0233676228672266, 0.036584317684173584, 0.035050053149461746, -0.04443671181797981, 0.05940178781747818, -0.04266944155097008, -0.0348224900662899, -0.0515286885201931, -0.029788514599204063, -0.004510871600359678, -0.014214661903679371, 0.03325793892145157, -0.006407511420547962, 0.00609431229531765, -0.006461255252361298, -0.04070382937788963, -0.07214193791151047, 0.007742261979728937, -0.00010810435196617618, 0.01264326274394989, 0.009400826878845692, -0.002002403372898698, 0.06429832428693771, -0.0022171540185809135, -0.004234469495713711, -0.052552152425050735, -0.0003315512149129063, -0.03536318242549896, -0.022130437195301056, 0.03387340158224106, 0.004237544257193804, 0.013658970594406128, 0.034628551453351974, -0.04795072600245476, 0.013849155977368355, 0.03756580501794815, 0.02569403685629368, -0.006113187409937382, 0.020903360098600388, -0.042418815195560455, -0.016657765954732895, 0.034737877547740936, 0.0007545582484453917, 0.019471554085612297, 0.0011724955402314663, 0.008117902092635632, 0.029367374256253242, 0.0689578652381897, -0.03463888168334961, 0.014229623600840569, -0.04150106757879257, -0.011160043999552727, -0.027907878160476685, 0.015512341633439064, -0.007233563810586929, -0.0824175775051117, -0.03748081624507904, -0.026538439095020294, 0.03491172567009926, -0.014108906500041485, 0.00006679179205093533, 0.022569382563233376, -0.006325670052319765, 0.00501411035656929, 0.009805646724998951, -0.010054598562419415, -0.019639335572719574, -0.005666476208716631, -0.05168522894382477, -0.0069893826730549335, 0.024895304813981056, 0.06498028337955475, -0.010362866334617138, -0.029147585853934288, -0.013020648621022701, -0.002296730875968933, -0.029426001012325287, -0.001891039777547121, -0.04373247176408768, 0.028586238622665405, 0.027972441166639328, 0.04518473148345947, -0.03721838444471359, -0.03292086720466614, 0.002563640708103776, 0.002574596554040909, -0.04290906712412834, 0.014187979511916637, -0.008312451653182507, -0.00763100478798151, -0.009598947130143642, -0.04178358614444733, 0.054615579545497894, -0.01306619867682457, 0.010145602747797966, 0.011517563834786415, 0.046817101538181305, -0.036217235028743744, 0.012318565510213375, 0.0026349781546741724, -0.006803325843065977, 0.0021453136578202248, 0.011240893974900246, 0.011188659816980362, -0.0029097136575728655, 0.021298963576555252, 0.026678767055273056, 0.01749461330473423, -0.0023934191558510065, -0.040062714368104935, 0.010363046079874039, 0.01446438580751419, 0.047671906650066376, 0.014212355948984623, -0.020363083109259605, -0.03585692122578621, 0.014137733727693558, 0.02521548606455326, 0.072407566010952, 0.061671242117881775, 0.015702005475759506, -0.02745455875992775, -0.004380876664072275, -0.0016337865963578224, 0.008623026311397552, 0.016971591860055923, -0.004406698513776064, 0.033118993043899536, 0.08120407164096832, 0.02209566719830036, -0.037904709577560425, -0.0031358860433101654, 0.03318646177649498, -0.007921501994132996, 0.003502361010760069, -0.01783803664147854, -0.019223377108573914, -0.036871787160634995, 0.008546100929379463, 0.009455699473619461, -0.014366235584020615, 0.022227533161640167, 0.017059747129678726, 0.055461425334215164, -0.015081881545484066, -0.005401161033660173, 0.0038396529853343964, 0.027525437995791435, 0.01938055083155632, -0.011450638063251972, -0.035074684768915176, 0.014446049928665161, 0.026257887482643127, 0.03798562288284302, 0.02108842507004738, -0.003281465033069253, -0.08784899860620499, -0.008253086358308792, 0.04202796518802643, 0.030468331649899483, -0.03992665931582451, -0.01903759501874447, -0.06627172231674194, -0.000999288633465767, 0.012135258875787258, -0.05117892846465111, -0.0021481646690517664, -0.012414876371622086, 0.0544198639690876, 0.006410292815417051, -0.0534370131790638, -0.05868124961853027, -0.006353955715894699, -0.03518817201256752, 0.01931489259004593, -0.00925424974411726, -0.016432147473096848, -0.026397662237286568, 0.015224569477140903, 0.007741972804069519, 0.06797181814908981, -0.042044878005981445, -0.039379410445690155, 0.026209941133856773, -0.004054658114910126, -0.01573575660586357, -0.03526907041668892, 0.0294627845287323, -0.007280352059751749, 0.015573342330753803, 0.038868583738803864, -0.00644186045974493, -0.05017264559864998, 0.025457868352532387, 0.027151647955179214, 0.0009770208271220326, 0.004021724220365286, -0.0256552305072546, 0.04357577860355377, 0.036846764385700226, 0.020181918516755104, 0.04723809286952019, 0.007913357578217983, -0.010835455730557442, 0.000056614753702888265, -0.058775849640369415, -0.026287149637937546, -0.01217410247772932, -0.017451545223593712, -0.03732159733772278, 0.026426244527101517, 0.01123187504708767, 0.045718852430582047, 0.010521996766328812, 0.054108742624521255, -0.014810738153755665, -0.040439754724502563, 0.00041994015919044614, 0.018797824159264565, -0.023788928985595703, -0.009758245199918747, 0.01739705353975296, 0.005804360378533602, -0.00481251860037446, -0.004639878403395414, 0.013642032630741596, -0.024105513468384743, -0.011099745519459248, 0.021625850349664688, -0.05016463249921799, 0.01548274140805006, 0.005080729257315397, -0.02199411764740944, -0.006979112513363361, -0.017971539869904518, 0.019121959805488586, 0.01036569569259882, 0.013477890752255917, -0.012539527378976345, -0.03290067985653877, 0.004485952202230692, 0.011622263118624687, -0.0016001848271116614, 0.015668947249650955, -0.01746893674135208, 0.008695426397025585, 0.017149580642580986, 0.007169218733906746, -0.051203079521656036, -0.025811025872826576, -0.0015170567203313112, -0.025899503380060196, -0.014037933200597763, -0.033154867589473724, -0.002961724065244198, 0.016991026699543, -0.03647226467728615, 0.012889965437352657, 0.07646135240793228, -0.03476719558238983, 0.020130349323153496, -0.04088006913661957, 0.024586856365203857, 0.058314982801675797, -0.00780437421053648, -0.016275474801659584, -0.0007379112066701055, -0.041204024106264114, -0.02921145409345627, 0.010345706716179848, -0.006280558183789253, -0.028880972415208817, 0.0193608608096838, -0.030830183997750282, -0.02710343338549137, 0.025943728163838387, -0.0060362061485648155, -0.04426027834415436, 0.026971135288476944, 0.005326249171048403, 0.011299687437713146, -0.021045047789812088, -0.026744918897747993, -0.00982259213924408, 0.022114843130111694, -0.016142407432198524, -0.019911790266633034, -0.012510405853390694, 0.013753946870565414, 0.05738505348563194, 0.012525173835456371, 0.003764023073017597, 0.012052655220031738, 0.07242510467767715, 0.011258920654654503, 0.017352482303977013, -0.010430831462144852, -0.013359121978282928, 0.042696233838796616, 0.01943519152700901, 0.004006160888820887, -0.008065805770456791, 0.023265818133950233, -0.04540634900331497, -0.02209039218723774, -0.02870640531182289, 0.0009231189033016562, 0.028232306241989136, 0.025942176580429077, -0.003351715160533786, -0.004643628839403391, 0.003808265086263418, -0.004446929786354303, -0.00880417414009571, 0.006887958385050297, 0.01923062652349472, 0.016357576474547386, 0.054203130304813385, -0.006851696874946356, -0.014456633478403091, 0.04059097543358803, 0.011484763585031033, 0.020197052508592606, 0.04545558616518974, 0.011421327479183674, 0.017967090010643005, -0.008315598592162132, -0.06222838908433914, -0.03993159160017967, 0.051017168909311295, -0.054436467587947845, 0.032121263444423676, -0.043933238834142685, -0.024980628862977028, 0.032441940158605576, 0.022043395787477493, 0.01065074559301138, -0.017963198944926262, -0.016460634768009186, -0.03618009388446808, -0.015463410876691341, 0.025650179013609886, -0.03470708429813385, 0.08257083594799042, 0.011072804220020771, 0.030064769089221954, -0.008975280448794365, 0.03426707535982132, -0.041544679552316666, -0.12836845219135284, -0.00824611447751522, -0.023524483665823936, -0.0385453999042511, 0.053136229515075684, 0.00896728876978159, -0.0395929329097271, 0.01293797604739666, -0.08635784685611725, 0.036482278257608414, -0.017277946695685387, 0.002142296638339758, 0.003317250870168209, 0.03204143047332764, -0.020460782572627068, 0.015922734513878822, -0.027355298399925232, -0.0024845879524946213, 0.14023253321647644, 0.09052567183971405, 0.018887963145971298, -0.038915690034627914, -0.01820700243115425, 0.01093353983014822, 0.014654879458248615, -0.0070467605255544186, 0.012903078459203243, 0.009357397444546223, -0.05906513333320618, 0.023325541988015175, 0.04053422808647156, -0.00623391242697835, 0.013217209838330746, 0.0065554422326385975, -0.025591667741537094, -0.008632979355752468, 0.011452109552919865, 0.021021800115704536, 0.005551651585847139, -0.03589526563882828, 0.02175568975508213, 0.010281477123498917, -0.004821450915187597, -0.028639113530516624, -0.030978994444012642, 0.017845815047621727, -0.017324788495898247, -0.008983660489320755, -0.0098114013671875, -0.0012544108321890235, -0.0019159961957484484, -0.02015477605164051, 0.027389857918024063, -0.012436405755579472, 0.020354563370347023, -0.032030411064624786, 0.032476332038640976, 0.012661032378673553, -0.050172772258520126, 0.03278796374797821, 0.020544495433568954, 0.010547544807195663, -0.04263880103826523, -0.05955840274691582, -0.04955289140343666, 0.05441641807556152, -0.03204283490777016, -0.02082367055118084, 0.016130130738019943, 0.01561764720827341, -0.0014827288687229156, -0.01295342668890953, -0.02022380754351616, 0.044538527727127075, 0.004248782526701689, -0.04101623222231865, -0.015358362346887589, -0.019695945084095, 0.02028854936361313, 0.005335516296327114, 0.060740478336811066, 0.009253056719899178, -0.07226835191249847, -0.05311257392168045, 0.021473074331879616, 0.04624895006418228, 0.00994862336665392, 0.022201621904969215, 0.03406723588705063, -0.003870587330311537, -0.010631771758198738, 0.004804079886525869, 0.007294282782822847, -0.007991793565452099, 0.009916162118315697, -0.013952665030956268, 0.031196577474474907, -0.05867050588130951, -0.0015596204902976751, 0.014378598891198635, -0.02658470906317234, 0.0076286327093839645, -0.04892081394791603, -0.008471339009702206, 0.023439522832632065, 0.03383772447705269, 0.021616166457533836, -0.009275535121560097, 0.013070213608443737, 0.07878953218460083, 0.030090250074863434, -0.04566535726189613, -0.0317998006939888, -0.013651820831000805, -0.02660384029150009, 0.04269682243466377, 0.004655563272535801, 0.04485096409916878, -0.007633713074028492, 0.03339754045009613, -0.0006643293891102076, 0.047747161239385605, -0.026102351024746895, 0.004763712640851736, 0.010797330178320408, -0.05211295187473297, 0.006741303950548172, -0.005276319105178118, 0.008386129513382912, -0.015436495654284954, -0.028615474700927734, -0.00600967463105917, -0.04034237191081047, -0.01596185937523842, -0.02997029945254326, -0.02528337761759758, 0.022393755614757538, -0.024946829304099083, 0.002295947400853038, -0.018354985862970352, -0.012617365457117558, 0.009183637797832489, -0.0012137664016336203, -0.036560315638780594, 0.022990558296442032, 0.02715364843606949, 0.034080151468515396, -0.019418900832533836, 0.004988795146346092, 0.015572909265756607, 0.008771185763180256, -0.007892526686191559, 0.005321095231920481, 0.007339117582887411, -0.005202595144510269, 0.018508536741137505, -0.02590462565422058, -0.05704474449157715, -0.007270623464137316, -0.03959553688764572, -0.04305295646190643, 0.006459969561547041, 0.03223588690161705, 0.032439082860946655, 0.006511346437036991, 0.00297054392285645, -0.03411824628710747, 0.002358765574172139, -0.029902039095759392, 0.010917749255895615, -0.007428120356053114, 0.01733049377799034, 0.02442956157028675, -0.032889947295188904, -0.012206356041133404, 0.012295534834265709, 0.009451562538743019, 0.020608235150575638, 0.02194603532552719, -0.010762974619865417, -0.02662847563624382, 0.03564853221178055, 0.0007580947130918503, -0.010830145329236984, 0.014343098737299442, 0.036299899220466614, -0.014857403934001923, 0.012297078035771847, -0.04681936651468277, 0.0539170578122139, -0.03953618183732033, -0.01274452917277813, -0.08498948067426682, -0.004500690381973982, 0.023474058136343956, 0.022140508517622948, 0.04028471186757088, -0.029302919283509254, 0.01069923210889101, 0.006478211376816034, -0.018436551094055176, 0.010596046224236488, 0.0014134416123852134, 0.006195747759193182, -0.009821468964219093, 0.01615058071911335, -0.024172401055693626, -0.006650522351264954, 0.008154718205332756, 0.023641562089323997, 0.0497104711830616, 0.03271613270044327, 0.02469448186457157, -0.0201027262955904, -0.002418476389721036, -0.007523189298808575, 0.025441870093345642, -0.05803700163960457, 0.03857162967324257, -0.054530806839466095, 0.006726371124386787, 0.03340833634138107, 0.03133058920502663, 0.027061687782406807, 0.008461442776024342, 0.035069748759269714, 0.03202236443758011, 0.08399373292922974, 0.03159438446164131, 0.005749146454036236, 0.015443027950823307, 0.026938825845718384, 0.022613048553466797, 0.017769228667020798, -0.019168607890605927, -0.027720671147108078, 0.037649206817150116, 0.0014815744943916798, -0.034784652292728424, 0.0036092535592615604, -0.001478085177950561, -0.009997948072850704, -0.006129683461040258, -0.012383230030536652, -0.03457467257976532, -0.06812544167041779, 0.021071186289191246, -0.050102148205041885, -0.010656855069100857, 0.037468988448381424, 0.04716445133090019, -0.02484336867928505, 0.027256187051534653, -0.035347457975149155, -0.03210439905524254, 0.03206313028931618, 0.014579410664737225, 0.006446226499974728, -0.08719305694103241, -0.031494058668613434, 0.014001182280480862, -0.016057075932621956, -0.02730759046971798, 0.00999810453504324, -0.036709677428007126, 0.04675722122192383, -0.016439499333500862, 0.06598714739084244, 0.018928145989775658, -0.009368960745632648, 0.007945239543914795, -0.10770739614963531, 0.06873960793018341, 0.001267323037609458, 0.04484435170888901, -0.005783272907137871, -0.007611933164298534, -0.057775966823101044, 0.005793331190943718, 0.047073256224393845, 0.016203586012125015, -0.036060310900211334, -0.006898501422256231, 0.006071093026548624, -0.00773906335234642, -0.06139150634407997, 0.0315215103328228, -0.02128138393163681, -0.014458275400102139, -0.021059909835457802, -0.01611305959522724, 0.002474450971931219, 0.02590746060013771, 0.02584276907145977, -0.0007369855302385986, -0.013565512374043465, 0.021072184666991234, -0.0007230007904581726, 0.018412623554468155, -0.0022608977742493153, -0.005940120667219162, 0.05362561345100403, 0.003541002981364727, 0.021977486088871956, 0.04916088283061981, 0.0037014258559793234, -0.038177646696567535, 0.04274526983499527, 0.0027260594069957733, -0.03759763389825821, -0.006363686174154282, -0.01461070030927658, -0.002462000586092472, -0.03104238584637642, 0.000587896560318768, 0.015243380330502987, -0.03455648198723793, 0.012899252586066723, 0.03629450872540474, 0.006282085552811623, 0.037223123013973236, 0.0003864475293084979, 0.019675878807902336, -0.0004393740091472864, -0.00039712191210128367, 0.03430161997675896, -0.010489530861377716, 0.048879362642765045, -0.03285237401723862, -0.013510499149560928, 0.015523684211075306, -0.021968355402350426, 0.02205934189260006, -0.056284621357917786, 0.04905193671584129, -0.020815828815102577, -0.029286058619618416, 0.02699216641485691, -0.017522426322102547, -0.017825165763497353, -0.028513656929135323, -0.015573190525174141, 0.04486917704343796, -0.013030813075602055, 0.0022852844558656216, 0.023177288472652435, 0.005552347283810377, -0.006895247846841812, 0.03141465038061142, -0.009768238291144371, 0.03006581962108612, 0.024880629032850266, 0.009878075681626797, 0.007701126858592033, 0.0034902971237897873, 0.025466876104474068, -0.0051966174505651, -0.00017970544286072254, 0.0030078862328082323, 0.006024816073477268, 0.014227613806724548, -0.021028783172369003, -0.011665195226669312, -0.056025199592113495, 0.04415947198867798, -0.0017403941601514816, -0.013629627414047718, -0.03566169738769531, 0.005288966931402683, 0.05358070507645607, 0.04476216807961464, -0.014931803569197655, 0.02271338365972042, -0.020017066970467567, -0.01241331361234188, -0.02916277013719082, -0.02268838882446289 ]
<p>I have a dataset that comprises several instances for different patients, with multiple instances per patient. I need to perform some classification tasks and I was using cross-validation, but this way I may have instances for the same patient in the training and the test folds. I would like to perform "leave one patient out" cross validation, this is, ensure that the test fold contains always all the instances from a patient. This way I could evaluate better how the classifier would perform with data from new subjects. Is this possible in Weka? </p>
74,273
[ -0.03917217627167702, 0.012693292461335659, -0.010104830376803875, 0.018736526370048523, -0.004733716137707233, -0.0025674651842564344, -0.04279954731464386, 0.0021748458966612816, 0.023378804326057434, -0.03884175419807434, 0.0352376364171505, -0.0016752734081819654, 0.03462401032447815, -0.006695264484733343, -0.01197567954659462, -0.0023117426317185163, -0.033926788717508316, -0.021514346823096275, -0.01305667869746685, -0.009904836304485798, -0.018547002226114273, 0.011680490337312222, 0.0159528236836195, -0.0170173067599535, 0.008309145458042622, 0.04438271000981331, 0.00250767869874835, -0.039514582604169846, 0.04157797992229462, 0.04278218746185303, -0.036385923624038696, -0.041477516293525696, -0.012874330393970013, 0.04414266720414162, 0.013857299461960793, -0.012495381757616997, -0.031758714467287064, -0.032138027250766754, -0.022118158638477325, 0.013801547698676586, 0.02947460114955902, 0.009545095264911652, -0.017170416191220284, 0.044545307755470276, -0.004400383681058884, 0.02575441636145115, -0.02407730557024479, -0.019232794642448425, 0.02093476802110672, -0.04755689203739166, 0.04817895591259003, -0.0010575612541288137, 0.04557722434401512, 0.03097579814493656, 0.0017289279494434595, 0.04635360464453697, 0.01962382160127163, 0.05209611356258392, 0.004029019270092249, -0.004443707875907421, -0.07188843190670013, -0.02621448040008545, 0.03483373671770096, -0.02715100347995758, -0.023069322109222412, 0.034863922744989395, -0.0179671011865139, -0.0026256791315972805, -0.006993281655013561, -0.01718820258975029, 0.014387502335011959, -0.012171240523457527, 0.038606781512498856, -0.023797648027539253, -0.0021682686638087034, 0.003523510415107012, 0.009384776465594769, 0.026751292869448662, 0.05444963276386261, 0.02159031294286251, -0.005369148217141628, 0.0029889221768826246, -0.005692962557077408, -0.01815994642674923, 0.03376920521259308, -0.013567515648901463, 0.03480863943696022, 0.0003249546862207353, -0.0026926493737846613, 0.05418394133448601, -0.023531559854745865, -0.018829001113772392, 0.05594130977988243, 0.02576303668320179, -0.04204028844833374, 0.017642924562096596, 0.02026103436946869, 0.04737866297364235, 0.002897548722103238, -0.006835613399744034, 0.01737712137401104, -0.015037351287901402, 0.0004375539720058441, 0.055263932794332504, -0.031352266669273376, -0.013053672388195992, -0.023807279765605927, -0.0399734303355217, 0.004874809179455042, 0.01863003708422184, -0.03437759354710579, -0.007225727662444115, 0.03085273690521717, -0.012753959745168686, 0.04184619337320328, 0.040609750896692276, -0.02953561395406723, -0.008750995621085167, -0.0018693923484534025, 0.06486557424068451, 0.05644881725311279, -0.025531664490699768, 0.006902249529957771, -0.03346472978591919, -0.01506589725613594, 0.005704965908080339, -0.02719258703291416, -0.000998933333903551, -0.026289204135537148, 0.049789074808359146, -0.028766974806785583, -0.0307094044983387, 0.028293892741203308, -0.009153087623417377, 0.03278365731239319, -0.015493994578719139, -0.08778440207242966, -0.028868939727544785, -0.028818989172577858, -0.0455503836274147, 0.038149405270814896, -0.015168235637247562, -0.010085520334541798, 0.006684938445687294, 0.06256265193223953, 0.022434817627072334, 0.013795305974781513, 0.043890584260225296, 0.01240847073495388, -0.009606999345123768, -0.014411392621695995, -0.043488696217536926, -0.05198213458061218, 0.027696894481778145, -0.05680767819285393, -0.09030988067388535, -0.009436365216970444, 0.0021541237365454435, 0.0025383138563483953, -0.03221571072936058, 0.018236516043543816, -0.03884093090891838, 0.00775899738073349, -0.0321086086332798, -0.0143992705270648, -0.04171282425522804, 0.06056855991482735, -0.023740297183394432, 0.05803675577044487, 0.021743735298514366, 0.010088279843330383, -0.0003581130877137184, 0.02761438861489296, 0.038741253316402435, -0.0033337257336825132, 0.015998415648937225, 0.002244572388008237, -0.01766338385641575, 0.057529814541339874, 0.03260998800396919, 0.005357741378247738, -0.022504379972815514, 0.02703745663166046, 0.015133306384086609, -0.030635107308626175, 0.042221128940582275, 0.008766277693212032, -0.026740632951259613, 0.03410881757736206, -0.037364210933446884, -0.013707565143704414, -0.045703351497650146, 0.03106662631034851, 0.00937697570770979, -0.01790166273713112, 0.019360145553946495, 0.02428046427667141, -0.018924763426184654, -0.00501421419903636, -0.03916565701365471, -0.039287228137254715, 0.016371402889490128, 0.021078241989016533, -0.06379755586385727, -0.010460931807756424, 0.009950388222932816, 0.009540816769003868, -0.019679388031363487, 0.0692201554775238, -0.015312562696635723, -0.04693766310811043, 0.00993454921990633, -0.030031893402338028, -0.024792874231934547, -0.01171922218054533, 0.0014973414363339543, 0.0384124219417572, 0.00883830338716507, -0.025202671065926552, 0.02734825573861599, -0.03331305831670761, 0.053129374980926514, 0.06361758708953857, -0.009700004011392593, 0.014867587015032768, -0.02373354136943817, 0.019064072519540787, -0.00898437388241291, -0.020850494503974915, -0.036560945212841034, -0.043541353195905685, -0.0286778025329113, 0.04059844836592674, -0.007225103210657835, -0.04028141871094704, -0.0035664483439177275, 0.04441465064883232, 0.00880346167832613, 0.031981460750103, -0.007621350232511759, 0.008721672929823399, 0.01767914369702339, 0.027554744854569435, 0.041770998388528824, 0.01583258993923664, -0.01168989297002554, 0.02823006547987461, -0.0061738560907542706, 0.040025584399700165, 0.021163171157240868, -0.00034548473195172846, 0.01564156822860241, 0.026412710547447205, 0.021732762455940247, -0.007410252466797829, -0.06897029280662537, 0.008457976393401623, -0.008351458236575127, 0.06719645112752914, 0.01964719034731388, 0.00878568273037672, -0.03157029673457146, 0.005740105640143156, -0.0004753148532472551, 0.023825474083423615, 0.03245306387543678, -0.0007318286807276309, 0.021237019449472427, 0.0165911503136158, -0.09657329320907593, -0.0044942013919353485, 0.0011550766648724675, -0.0059652179479599, -0.03971773386001587, 0.04837833344936371, 0.05750421807169914, 0.013822748325765133, 0.015892012044787407, -0.043569404631853104, -0.01007020566612482, 0.02208728715777397, -0.04828295111656189, 0.029694296419620514, 0.007925800047814846, -0.04543012008070946, 0.030042748898267746, 0.008866718970239162, -0.010551556944847107, 0.054403435438871384, 0.005457998253405094, -0.018654974177479744, 0.020408524200320244, -0.011722494848072529, -0.03490249440073967, -0.03202059492468834, -0.06831954419612885, 0.03838064521551132, 0.013908266089856625, 0.025765258818864822, 0.02948421984910965, 0.017393505200743675, -0.06423523277044296, 0.01060938835144043, 0.02401922270655632, -0.016437092795968056, 0.0014379292260855436, -0.04259025305509567, 0.03320317715406418, -0.016946639865636826, 0.011041852645576, 0.05427145957946777, -0.03668701648712158, 0.0386335551738739, -0.07609648257493973, -0.049190640449523926, 0.0387582890689373, 0.01331360824406147, 0.014350876212120056, 0.04097643122076988, -0.014183231629431248, 0.07849293947219849, 0.022511420771479607, -0.027386263012886047, -0.027831334620714188, 0.027401989325881004, -0.027028106153011322, -0.04487573355436325, 0.026410400867462158, -0.01146615855395794, 0.0003508656518533826, 0.006533441599458456, -0.011653473600745201, 0.00910841953009367, 0.05823718383908272, 0.014667215757071972, -0.028956955298781395, -0.029874267056584358, 0.009708546102046967, 0.013528679497539997, 0.04264985769987106, -0.004522299859672785, 0.00642519211396575, 0.023641312494874, -0.014924037270247936, 0.02829550951719284, 0.0026220413856208324, -0.026733746752142906, 0.039229344576597214, -0.039572861045598984, 0.019524522125720978, -0.025179807096719742, 0.0024362874682992697, -0.00390597153455019, -0.021072261035442352, 0.0010543490061536431, 0.0008588659111410379, 0.07382634282112122, -0.02722940966486931, 0.010403257794678211, 0.04160687327384949, 0.01986207813024521, -0.018972590565681458, -0.00923526007682085, -0.018277715891599655, 0.01928538829088211, 0.028804967179894447, 0.02201627939939499, -0.03115311823785305, 0.03337159380316734, 0.03848353773355484, 0.0234232060611248, 0.017750952392816544, -0.009774991311132908, 0.0072591956704854965, -0.036846451461315155, -0.012493731454014778, 0.012878342531621456, 0.040380753576755524, 0.0072011337615549564, -0.020199602469801903, 0.019174357876181602, -0.005562431178987026, -0.042599186301231384, 0.03786527365446091, -0.026608292013406754, -0.004721926059573889, 0.022916633635759354, 0.0001566602586535737, 0.005129525437951088, -0.015607645735144615, -0.006695826072245836, -0.030727168545126915, 0.006814762484282255, -0.0074553294107317924, 0.0029284560587257147, -0.005338854622095823, 0.011665871366858482, 0.008193748071789742, -0.019528178498148918, -0.01790683902800083, 0.03144749253988266, 0.012863597832620144, -0.009535693563520908, -0.013911173678934574, 0.007914246059954166, 0.018274476751685143, 0.002100196434184909, -0.023441188037395477, 0.006547900848090649, -0.021962052211165428, 0.022001348435878754, 0.019216451793909073, 0.029816310852766037, -0.07590682059526443, 0.0040363105945289135, -0.019773799926042557, 0.004918854217976332, 0.05160454288125038, -0.0014421252999454737, -0.009398378431797028, -0.047449931502342224, -0.04336826875805855, -0.026292668655514717, 0.0557309091091156, -0.023500367999076843, -0.013984798453748226, 0.028864143416285515, 0.020559510216116905, -0.06944633275270462, -0.013238921761512756, 0.1151403933763504, 0.03652025759220123, -0.022729815915226936, -0.04738861694931984, 0.01641147956252098, 0.02879280038177967, -0.014575718902051449, 0.03269583359360695, 0.005726346746087074, -0.027964860200881958, -0.004417812917381525, 0.004455820191651583, -0.014130779542028904, -0.008932357653975487, 0.0055880555883049965, 0.01921023428440094, 0.056767791509628296, -0.00946990679949522, -0.004750222899019718, 0.0072403824888169765, 0.06061597168445587, 0.026709601283073425, 0.018496429547667503, 0.01733173429965973, -0.09569933265447617, -0.034671757370233536, 0.046047065407037735, 0.01521982066333294, 0.0008773020235821605, -0.0012885980540886521, -0.013832754455506802, 0.008067568764090538, 0.024694116786122322, -0.0030264658853411674, -0.009346256963908672, 0.012530971318483353, -0.0027615868020802736, -0.006292239297181368, 0.021964356303215027, -0.023823538795113564, 0.021403539925813675, -0.04308996722102165, 0.019312411546707153, -0.023829234763979912, 0.014231751672923565, -0.017229799181222916, 0.01279168576002121, 0.015756232663989067, 0.07870949059724808, -0.019984252750873566, 0.0037348780315369368, 0.016284532845020294, 0.0005186994094401598, -0.04183335602283478, -0.07448005676269531, -0.0035513839684426785, -0.01896675117313862, -0.01102826651185751, 0.049037255346775055, -0.001950154546648264, -0.025973409414291382, -0.010819608345627785, 0.042455535382032394, -0.016073888167738914, -0.02249535359442234, -0.012576410546898842, 0.03307582810521126, 0.0007771280943416059, 0.004127667285501957, 0.04829089343547821, 0.03560246154665947, 0.021915074437856674, -0.026069598272442818, -0.025684311985969543, -0.0016380723100155592, -0.04561864584684372, -0.002915652934461832, -0.03222253546118736, -0.031135395169258118, -0.03394981473684311, 0.026512041687965393, -0.03196774050593376, 0.05774710327386856, -0.004141989629715681, -0.05552772432565689, 0.006800161674618721, 0.04466066509485245, 0.013178601861000061, -0.02650790847837925, -0.010611891746520996, 0.03250501677393913, -0.026406845077872276, -0.01107783243060112, -0.011814391240477562, -0.03162083402276039, 0.005540078971534967, 0.021061338484287262, -0.024442452937364578, 0.0269768126308918, -0.02117389254271984, -0.04231790453195572, -0.012349141761660576, -0.04109099507331848, 0.010172650218009949, -0.004712508525699377, 0.05351049453020096, -0.017759835347533226, -0.039384737610816956, 0.0002511510392650962, 0.017484555020928383, -0.001093266997486353, 0.0029516033828258514, -0.024982860311865807, 0.05448831990361214, 0.006873222533613443, -0.011704130098223686, -0.07566327601671219, -0.000023872551537351683, 0.007211958523839712, 0.021094098687171936, -0.02757273241877556, -0.027204442769289017, 0.004631277173757553, -0.011545911431312561, 0.0053984918631613255, -0.024189909920096397, 0.027018142864108086, -0.022452741861343384, 0.050829410552978516, -0.01612563244998455, 0.033865854144096375, 0.05208747833967209, 0.029536172747612, 0.01617722027003765, -0.02412770316004753, -0.04363221302628517, 0.000043727097363444045, 0.04355119913816452, 0.010470852255821228, -0.019731620326638222, 0.01059880293905735, -0.045291971415281296, -0.002433722373098135, 0.007881387136876583, -0.0053640613332390785, -0.019008692353963852, -0.006897037383168936, -0.014938614331185818, 0.0010467537213116884, -0.0020308508537709713, 0.008725497871637344, 0.03331271931529045, -0.008721282705664635, 0.0051782866939902306, 0.05861331894993782, 0.02234824374318123, -0.020445218309760094, 0.03608915954828262, 0.0006919208681210876, -0.02384825237095356, -0.009273621253669262, 0.06670398265123367, -0.04866313189268112, -0.01596747152507305, -0.0017307556699961424, -0.05076823756098747, 0.04044005647301674, 0.005634065251797438, -0.009801776148378849, -0.025567110627889633, 0.012397738173604012, -0.052897341549396515, 0.02180003933608532, -0.007665144745260477, -0.010275603272020817, 0.011144167743623257, 0.025999905541539192, 0.048687294125556946, 0.0680464506149292, 0.037606131285429, -0.011105037294328213, -0.04047822579741478, -0.012531761080026627, 0.003467585425823927, -0.001117369974963367, 0.060828160494565964, 0.04933585599064827, 0.01650148071348667, 0.03741282969713211, 0.032251112163066864, 0.038645412772893906, 0.03495302423834801, -0.007555465679615736, 0.04536895453929901, 0.02532564103603363, 0.01794488914310932, -0.021525023505091667, 0.015816552564501762, -0.05672605708241463, -0.031744323670864105, -0.0029635438695549965, -0.02574489824473858, -0.00804925337433815, 0.014294094406068325, 0.030720140784978867, -0.018370987847447395, -0.054101210087537766, -0.0601910799741745, 0.05379217863082886, 0.017050592228770256, 0.025302328169345856, 0.06875001639127731, 0.004863717593252659, 0.026718750596046448, 0.016449877992272377, 0.011781379580497742, -0.06233778968453407, -0.04474392905831337, -0.051414795219898224, -0.03804320842027664, 0.009374620392918587, 0.032151687890291214, 0.017559198662638664, -0.04002472013235092, 0.0055308095179498196, 0.014087487012147903, 0.07588789612054825, 0.016525695100426674, 0.05694838985800743, 0.030453508719801903, 0.016066811978816986, 0.01972128637135029, 0.03185879439115524, 0.013503278605639935, 0.0430961512029171, 0.1520545482635498, 0.1055377647280693, 0.04614028334617615, -0.06308694928884506, -0.02390131913125515, -0.0073867556639015675, -0.05241069570183754, -0.04961365461349487, 0.021639473736286163, 0.02509717456996441, -0.01565922051668167, 0.013936828821897507, 0.008893067017197609, 0.04414261877536774, -0.05579229071736336, 0.07452937215566635, -0.014253897592425346, 0.003981863148510456, 0.03706153854727745, 0.011147930286824703, 0.01637836918234825, -0.025300754234194756, -0.05615159496665001, 0.01647505909204483, 0.023934785276651382, -0.042516808956861496, -0.004991152789443731, -0.020550226792693138, 0.022522661834955215, -0.021135035902261734, 0.007145289331674576, 0.00934996735304594, -0.02606930024921894, -0.02222616970539093, 0.002849467331543565, 0.007566708140075207, -0.011185267940163612, 0.010138359852135181, 0.020189549773931503, -0.013995430432260036, 0.049175653606653214, -0.033285632729530334, 0.009959452785551548, 0.03432517871260643, -0.00992667954415083, -0.04693244770169258, -0.02489721216261387, 0.05570525303483009, -0.021682707592844963, -0.025006698444485664, -0.02760852314531803, -0.021596252918243408, 0.015675077214837074, -0.06984658539295197, -0.039914388209581375, 0.012301556766033173, -0.010132464580237865, -0.0006918811704963446, -0.035551540553569794, -0.022893214598298073, 0.024149561300873756, 0.008381285704672337, 0.03829916939139366, -0.012785284779965878, -0.004930648487061262, -0.004785601980984211, -0.028643207624554634, -0.007437504827976227, 0.01789821870625019, 0.016569066792726517, 0.01401571836322546, -0.03931412100791931, -0.003981797024607658, -0.034401219338178635, 0.04649724066257477, -0.012223306111991405, 0.010772183537483215, -0.03560785949230194, -0.013688336126506329, -0.0386512316763401, -0.022491035982966423, -0.04193710535764694, -0.008836011402308941, -0.032981399446725845, -0.030955614522099495, -0.00004300229193177074, -0.01196873839944601, 0.051497895270586014, -0.013480393216013908, -0.017544465139508247, 0.006358593236654997, 0.04010593146085739, -0.033655859529972076, -0.047535110265016556, -0.03453349322080612, -0.0013388445368036628, -0.051620062440633774, 0.026883672922849655, -0.01517544500529766, 0.066819928586483, 0.023505883291363716, -0.00045096411486156285, -0.018146928399801254, 0.03844700753688812, -0.002755172550678253, 0.01645919494330883, 0.00723212119191885, -0.05379042401909828, 0.00023801477800589055, 0.006387846544384956, -0.016469886526465416, -0.01890457421541214, -0.031947061419487, -0.0416930690407753, -0.03717523813247681, 0.039933811873197556, 0.0027200779877603054, -0.01638934388756752, 0.028685839846730232, 0.006435038987547159, 0.031202463433146477, -0.02601240761578083, 0.01033916138112545, -0.055955495685338974, -0.022355083376169205, -0.004835701081901789, -0.0521424226462841, 0.013631105422973633, -0.009427882730960846, 0.002139628864824772, -0.01954035274684429, 0.031508106738328934, 0.020279599353671074, 0.0034746357705444098, 0.014890010468661785, 0.0019204000709578395, -0.01145264133810997, 0.03545822203159332, -0.01817728951573372, -0.008448309265077114, 0.048820652067661285, -0.06689601391553879, 0.004499500617384911, 0.028915027156472206, -0.0012064510956406593, 0.03855866938829422, 0.07112044095993042, -0.003979540895670652, 0.006718416698276997, 0.016570160165429115, -0.014440084807574749, -0.024490073323249817, 0.015303252264857292, 0.04429209232330322, -0.021200142800807953, 0.012928839772939682, 0.004987854510545731, 0.019540565088391304, -0.015547295100986958, 0.00807690154761076, 0.039418984204530716, 0.042031701654195786, -0.08256226032972336, 0.011159174144268036, 0.0005410088342614472, 0.06367365270853043, 0.012517803348600864, 0.035731371492147446, 0.00875973328948021, 0.05266301706433296, -0.01524792704731226, 0.04725691303610802, -0.014180859550833702, 0.027669979259371758, -0.10448495298624039, -0.033368971198797226, -0.0013512717559933662, 0.0275567639619112, 0.03213217854499817, -0.01189978513866663, 0.0034825685434043407, 0.034865714609622955, -0.051027052104473114, 0.026399238035082817, -0.03332224115729332, 0.011833228170871735, -0.06581256538629532, 0.008158016949892044, -0.03478497266769409, 0.004041700623929501, 0.04857560247182846, -0.001954934559762478, -0.014519976451992989, 0.01940363645553589, -0.005915551446378231, -0.0384272038936615, -0.05917976796627045, 0.03853228688240051, 0.0072650667279958725, -0.06803036481142044, 0.02734685130417347, -0.001041708281263709, -0.06786136329174042, -0.011583044193685055, -0.047661419957876205, -0.02697206474840641, 0.05740632489323616, 0.029636912047863007, 0.02388455718755722, 0.021615833044052124, 0.03258969634771347, -0.018762806430459023, 0.006559387780725956, 0.01824885606765747, -0.0004230729246046394, 0.003415164304897189, -0.03264828026294708, 0.037883687764406204, 0.047167859971523285, 0.02471693605184555, -0.009568765759468079, 0.02449127845466137, -0.031769637018442154, -0.014352028258144855, -0.04684203490614891, 0.006687438581138849, 0.009492740035057068, -0.03602810204029083, -0.041035737842321396, -0.027631700038909912, 0.04964172840118408, 0.04274202510714531, 0.006074266973882914, 0.004338539205491543, 0.010523408651351929, -0.03464102745056152, -0.05260075628757477, 0.014363085851073265, 0.01202874630689621, -0.03772442042827606, -0.03917308896780014, 0.020927198231220245, -0.022326655685901642, -0.030751243233680725, -0.002542206784710288, -0.02383861131966114, 0.021313035860657692, 0.026268303394317627, -0.05051375553011894, 0.008496535010635853, 0.019448477774858475, 0.012162365950644016, -0.007201877422630787, -0.05395476147532463, 0.040747351944446564, 0.001721863867715001, -0.01790027692914009, -0.02092825621366501, -0.022062992677092552, -0.03752768784761429, 0.0025942474603652954, 0.020922530442476273, 0.027490884065628052, 0.042494259774684906, -0.015584527514874935, 0.019337959587574005, -0.03751770406961441, -0.026366833597421646, 0.05554497241973877, -0.0439557321369648, 0.010974942706525326, -0.004563214257359505, 0.02907661162316799, 0.007932300679385662, 0.017806246876716614, 0.009207934141159058, -0.006822267547249794, 0.012430264614522457, 0.015008133836090565, -0.023985790088772774, 0.017364751547574997, 0.00410144729539752, 0.026295717805624008, 0.02495943196117878, -0.009505740366876125, -0.0055078729055821896, -0.014163853600621223, 0.0011475052451714873, -0.03182629868388176, 0.01955794356763363, -0.05756815895438194, -0.0013569971779361367, -0.017129475250840187, 0.052227314561605453, 0.004707450047135353, -0.041373126208782196, 0.008738437667489052, 0.0024448682088404894, -0.025757689028978348, 0.014573547057807446, 0.038266345858573914, 0.03507377579808235, 0.017294224351644516, -0.00526037672534585, -0.017993684858083725, -0.0047330064699053764, -0.01963811367750168, 0.007353787776082754, 0.02293064258992672, -0.04619692638516426, 0.022079557180404663, 0.06253012269735336, 0.026118632405996323, 0.008959724567830563, 0.023299841210246086, -0.0016193445771932602, 0.07905545085668564, -0.012466379441320896, 0.002139464719220996, -0.00810750387609005, 0.011650823056697845, -0.0027443943545222282, -0.05421211197972298, -0.018497304990887642, 0.05852930620312691, -0.045647166669368744, -0.023466145619750023, -0.07801421731710434, -0.021995268762111664, 0.01982082426548004, 0.021563690155744553, 0.022539250552654266, 0.05230855569243431, -0.025125570595264435, -0.048825230449438095, -0.023690378293395042, -0.004792920313775539, -0.014667565003037453, -0.038206569850444794, 0.0252060703933239, -0.0028082996141165495, -0.03253047168254852, -0.0044767544604837894, -0.025876207277178764, -0.025061067193746567, -0.0056291501969099045, -0.021898794919252396, 0.049898408353328705, 0.0365380123257637, -0.01660003699362278, -0.04893145337700844, -0.01811879314482212, 0.033582791686058044, -0.03174116834998131, -0.00673917680978775, -0.016492396593093872, 0.07082292437553406, 0.0017403328092768788, 0.021959716454148293 ]
<p>This is a homework problem. I have figured out part (a) but I need help with part (b). I include part (a) for completion. </p> <p>Suppose $X_1,\ldots,X_n$ are iid Poisson random variables. Furthermore, let $Z_n$ be the proportion of zeroes observed i.e. $Z_n = n^{-1}\sum_{i=1}^n 1\{X_j=0\}$. </p> <p>$(a)$ Find the joint asymptotic distribution of $\left(\bar{X}_n,Z_n\right)$</p> <p>Since $\text{E}[X_1]=\theta$ and $\text{Var}[X_1]=\theta$, by the central limit theorem we have $$\sqrt{n}(\bar{X}_n-\theta) \overset{D}{\longrightarrow} Z_1,\quad Z_1\sim N(0,\theta)$$ and since $\text{E}[1\{X_1=0\}] = P(X_1=0) = e^{-\theta}$ and $$\text{Var}[1\{X_1=0\}] = \text{E}[1\{X_1=0\}^2] - \text{E}[1\{X_1=0\}]^2=e^{-\theta}-e^{-2\theta}=e^{-\theta}(1-e^{-\theta})$$ by the central limit theorem we have $$\sqrt{n}(Z_n-e^{-\theta}) \overset{D}{\longrightarrow} Z_2,\quad Z_2\sim N(0,e^{-\theta}(1-e^{-\theta}))$$ Furthermore we have $$\text{Cov}[X_1,1\{X_1=0\}] = 0 - \theta e^{-\theta}$$ Therefore, by the multivariate central limit theorem $$\sqrt{n}\begin{pmatrix} \bar{X}_n-\theta \\ Z_n - e^{-\theta}\end{pmatrix} \overset{D}{\longrightarrow} \mathbf{Y}, \quad \mathbf{Y} \sim \text{MVN}\left( \begin{pmatrix} 0 \\ 0 \end{pmatrix}, \begin{pmatrix} \theta &amp; -\theta e^{-\theta}\\-\theta e^{-\theta} &amp; e^{-\theta}(1-e^{-\theta})\end{pmatrix}\right)$$</p> <p>$(b)$ Based on your answer in (a), find the asymptotic distribution of $\sum_{i=1}^n X_i \big/ \sum_{i=1}^n 1\{X_i&gt;0\}$. This is an estimate of the mean $\text{E}[X|X\geq 1]$ from a truncated Poisson.</p> <p>We have $$\dfrac{\sum_{i=1}^n X_i}{\sum_{i=1}^n 1\{X_i&gt;0\}}=\dfrac{n\bar{X}_n}{n-nZ_n} = \dfrac{\bar{X}_n}{1-Z_n}$$ I do not know how to proceed from here! I have a ratio of two normal distributions (marginal normal, and jointly normal). </p> <p>$(c)$ Compute the exact mean and variance from a truncated Poisson$(\theta)$ with zero values truncated; i.e. $X\sim \text{Poisson}(\theta)$, compute $\text{E}[X|X\geq 1]$ and $\text{Var}[X|X\geq 1]$. Compare this to the asymptotic result in (b).</p>
74,274
[ 0.013342488557100296, -0.0010056850733235478, 0.037004973739385605, 0.0005519152618944645, 0.046374671161174774, -0.006621339358389378, 0.012018599547445774, -0.023753033950924873, 0.03896535933017731, -0.007152776699513197, 0.05055530369281769, 0.022015569731593132, 0.05105505883693695, 0.033152900636196136, 0.024607770144939423, 0.02578103356063366, -0.034552689641714096, 0.007795405108481646, -0.025251630693674088, 0.0021378551609814167, -0.04382629320025444, 0.05208123102784157, 0.04816356301307678, -0.007732416968792677, -0.03163440525531769, 0.04342019557952881, -0.003558433847501874, -0.011997051537036896, -0.02152000553905964, 0.09178263694047928, -0.0640828087925911, -0.030193347483873367, -0.012388430535793304, 0.04029088839888573, 0.001533120172098279, 0.011807430535554886, -0.03829161077737808, -0.06581210345029831, 0.025062469765543938, 0.03177152946591377, -0.01919456012547016, -0.015640201047062874, -0.022899361327290535, 0.017957676202058792, 0.004412867594510317, 0.012823415920138359, -0.010964320972561836, -0.02617555297911167, 0.04635823890566826, -0.04665767773985863, 0.06630627810955048, -0.0036185081116855145, 0.05145130679011345, 0.021566541865468025, -0.0010293970117345452, -0.055730175226926804, 0.027945874258875847, 0.07553756982088089, 0.033680178225040436, -0.06249014288187027, -0.010467338375747204, -0.006270033773034811, -0.0012146658264100552, -0.05784178152680397, -0.007216721773147583, -0.001910568680614233, 0.01953432336449623, -0.003127884119749069, -0.013435931876301765, -0.0360020287334919, 0.05737313628196716, 0.03164615109562874, 0.011996852234005928, -0.02301989123225212, 0.0014529022155329585, -0.01025879755616188, -0.005987890996038914, 0.03874163329601288, 0.022060712799429893, 0.02100555971264839, 0.009353360161185265, 0.036268141120672226, 0.0322134755551815, 0.02314118854701519, 0.03327668458223343, 0.005387815646827221, 0.09376399219036102, 0.027216246351599693, 0.029185457155108452, 0.017351428046822548, -0.0013708549086004496, -0.00128458091057837, 0.04539515823125839, -0.047850873321294785, -0.04100126773118973, 0.04603405296802521, -0.03449814394116402, 0.02970907650887966, 0.018753208220005035, 0.00041673771920613945, -0.022800838574767113, -0.034505899995565414, 0.02494175359606743, 0.057295359671115875, -0.046525515615940094, 0.015397751703858376, -0.014225630089640617, 0.0011446933494880795, -0.018097637221217155, -0.00961980689316988, -0.020601434633135796, 0.05557998642325401, -0.004112571012228727, 0.003608595347031951, -0.01576584205031395, 0.03013371303677559, -0.01261612493544817, 0.014625639654695988, -0.00409859512001276, 0.04644927382469177, 0.03855196759104729, 0.0014160412829369307, 0.011589374393224716, -0.015144862234592438, -0.06884074211120605, 0.00022493272263091058, 0.024680940434336662, 0.006773469503968954, -0.04792724549770355, 0.04448637738823891, -0.02213382162153721, 0.008150498382747173, 0.014820415526628494, 0.015073435381054878, 0.0525529719889164, 0.014211778528988361, -0.08502902090549469, -0.021774785593152046, 0.028831684961915016, -0.03483376279473305, 0.04548172280192375, -0.054734665900468826, -0.015764381736516953, 0.026151280850172043, 0.05091485753655434, 0.008168579079210758, 0.05407518893480301, 0.001944046700373292, 0.01849832944571972, 0.019672535359859467, -0.0074609434232115746, -0.020685069262981415, -0.009016858413815498, 0.00789599772542715, -0.008662143722176552, -0.0561402253806591, 0.04228665679693222, 0.03694910556077957, -0.0028000592719763517, -0.030795279890298843, 0.008464791812002659, -0.02059653215110302, 0.012171327136456966, -0.02109398879110813, 0.01083195861428976, -0.04653463140130043, 0.07122954726219177, 0.019587116315960884, 0.023244917392730713, 0.029626375064253807, -0.011295787990093231, 0.001025536679662764, -0.021213321015238762, 0.049868565052747726, 0.03715309873223305, -0.046413157135248184, -0.022438963875174522, -0.05168744549155235, 0.003003705060109496, 0.028574703261256218, -0.028068916872143745, -0.021601766347885132, -0.042405229061841965, 0.002513442188501358, 0.010609673336148262, 0.04188687726855278, 0.04473840072751045, -0.015510163269937038, 0.018330717459321022, -0.013616888783872128, -0.02149132639169693, -0.03610498458147049, 0.000706400431226939, 0.01710083708167076, -0.036774005740880966, 0.0263997633010149, -0.018258966505527496, 0.009963542222976685, 0.0041434005834162235, -0.026496464386582375, 0.007193033583462238, 0.007007662672549486, 0.006477792747318745, -0.04324570670723915, 0.04186670482158661, 0.05688972771167755, 0.05761462077498436, 0.004617460072040558, 0.04731914773583412, -0.02214084565639496, -0.02449486404657364, 0.0009519869345240295, -0.01706504262983799, 0.05330440402030945, -0.009422797709703445, 0.02228163182735443, 0.04886415973305702, 0.021647591143846512, -0.00207948824390769, -0.011215879581868649, -0.05220571905374527, 0.025595955550670624, 0.06773634999990463, -0.0018594261491671205, -0.0036655201110988855, 0.006107839290052652, 0.025897862389683723, 0.03527302294969559, -0.008829747326672077, -0.0023948797024786472, -0.04881538078188896, 0.014764124527573586, 0.0759427472949028, 0.035244811326265335, -0.009674549102783203, 0.014248398132622242, 0.06638330221176147, 0.016332430765032768, 0.034042585641145706, 0.02080990932881832, -0.0295567624270916, -0.029593804851174355, 0.019674943760037422, -0.004469456151127815, 0.013425865210592747, 0.02009698376059532, 0.007952437736093998, -0.031927336007356644, 0.05195968225598335, -0.024429796263575554, -0.04539883881807327, 0.05624140053987503, -0.007504690904170275, 0.015939101576805115, -0.03324442729353905, -0.008738036267459393, 0.051510438323020935, -0.011874470859766006, 0.006694713141769171, 0.030963847413659096, 0.013476449064910412, 0.015658248215913773, -0.004005323629826307, -0.02670302800834179, 0.01938088797032833, 0.027361810207366943, -0.005654904991388321, -0.017237311229109764, 0.011686190962791443, -0.019323648884892464, 0.021820010617375374, -0.01351915206760168, -0.0792170986533165, -0.00019397724827285856, -0.02305026724934578, 0.047951988875865936, 0.0017293685814365745, -0.010824060067534447, -0.0028950378764420748, 0.00807558186352253, -0.0021947582717984915, 0.005236995872110128, 0.03759312629699707, 0.026187608018517494, -0.04327778145670891, -0.026945924386382103, -0.0018732416210696101, 0.011676588095724583, 0.033658478409051895, 0.02416319213807583, 0.0009509137598797679, 0.022970987483859062, -0.01953285001218319, -0.03494919836521149, -0.02437651716172695, -0.0066940151154994965, 0.01767302304506302, -0.044136837124824524, -0.042877212166786194, 0.058942634612321854, 0.035789843648672104, -0.0389423705637455, -0.004874912090599537, -0.010237088426947594, -0.03877079859375954, -0.03127928823232651, 0.0035941172391176224, 0.03432445973157883, -0.023224642500281334, 0.034862443804740906, 0.0021069603972136974, 0.04156486317515373, 0.007623240351676941, -0.07888062298297882, -0.06866762042045593, -0.011923755519092083, 0.010094140656292439, -0.010178963653743267, -0.013906686566770077, -0.04272741824388504, 0.08045950531959534, 0.014498427510261536, 0.015763279050588608, 0.008951577357947826, 0.05520923063158989, -0.016254179179668427, -0.010454206727445126, 0.043831974267959595, -0.011501770466566086, -0.030352214351296425, 0.0015593830030411482, 0.008950355462729931, 0.02677588351070881, 0.029330948367714882, 0.01956285536289215, 0.04204364866018295, 0.02826860547065735, 0.020218372344970703, 0.0004889309057034552, 0.030112342908978462, 0.00619894964620471, 0.00798676535487175, 0.011467007920145988, 0.003995983395725489, -0.00022414306295104325, 0.0242391899228096, -0.046459633857011795, 0.011852587573230267, -0.04409000650048256, 0.004006507340818644, -0.008315515704452991, 0.04561542347073555, 0.03940233960747719, -0.034832581877708435, -0.005827512126415968, -0.019412150606513023, 0.06126685440540314, -0.029814153909683228, -0.017716823145747185, 0.05114457383751869, 0.053461600095033646, -0.006425073835998774, -0.03303935006260872, -0.03134005144238472, 0.026750000193715096, 0.00931665487587452, -0.06282929331064224, 0.0005240904283709824, 0.007735223509371281, 0.04442911595106125, -0.02369762770831585, -0.03786920756101608, -0.0102321095764637, -0.03364172950387001, -0.04517870023846626, 0.03509340062737465, -0.03358631208539009, 0.03976443037390709, -0.0006318997475318611, 0.058638229966163635, -0.02146807685494423, -0.003659644862636924, 0.007202614564448595, 0.041002631187438965, -0.08744481205940247, 0.029636891558766365, -0.015648361295461655, -0.01055136602371931, -0.010355237871408463, -0.011857870034873486, 0.03330119699239731, 0.013503710739314556, 0.010913101956248283, 0.00612746411934495, -0.0019767596386373043, -0.045322269201278687, 0.006414109840989113, -0.05913056805729866, -0.021141836419701576, -0.008466336876153946, 0.053427405655384064, -0.000046986231609480456, -0.015618747100234032, 0.025073783472180367, 0.05027671530842781, 0.007176563143730164, 0.010573017410933971, -0.04428543150424957, -0.005645022261887789, 0.04794693738222122, 0.04836706072092056, -0.0014868053840473294, 0.00855484139174223, 0.01597345806658268, 0.0030612912960350513, -0.005835249088704586, 0.029834121465682983, 0.03634963929653168, 0.005977974738925695, -0.02083498425781727, -0.04345120117068291, -0.030218102037906647, -0.02835693024098873, 0.029322512447834015, 0.015510700643062592, 0.03461845591664314, 0.05984880402684212, 0.029845446348190308, -0.006642729975283146, 0.007668199483305216, 0.05952117219567299, 0.013652864843606949, -0.0037146294489502907, -0.036281488835811615, 0.006292435340583324, -0.011822513304650784, 0.015781523659825325, 0.031681258231401443, -0.0244921762496233, -0.03164954483509064, -0.02677692286670208, 0.07193867862224579, 0.03991609066724777, -0.005793682299554348, 0.025933898985385895, 0.02267797477543354, 0.028849517926573753, 0.01023118570446968, -0.04311094433069229, -0.005614509806036949, 0.030778463929891586, 0.03601009398698807, 0.015140687115490437, -0.01636498235166073, -0.02431556023657322, 0.006636579986661673, 0.03345955163240433, 0.051840707659721375, -0.022491252049803734, 0.007703615352511406, -0.07871929556131363, -0.04198311269283295, 0.025894951075315475, -0.0255174171179533, 0.031001301482319832, -0.03865496814250946, -0.004074860364198685, 0.0064656841568648815, -0.06815392524003983, -0.06796950101852417, -0.017910661175847054, -0.036715153604745865, 0.02562045119702816, -0.027452697977423668, -0.026162439957261086, -0.0373530387878418, 0.006038360763341188, 0.04833558201789856, 0.07100749760866165, -0.012127130292356014, -0.016314905136823654, -0.014177510514855385, 0.022909214720129967, 0.004306858871132135, -0.07450443506240845, 0.06536399573087692, -0.021417204290628433, -0.0238462146371603, 0.034719958901405334, -0.04900886490941048, -0.05265350639820099, 0.06107407808303833, 0.004744913429021835, -0.0012833893997594714, 0.0020835320465266705, -0.01040299329906702, 0.04721425473690033, 0.03804050758481026, -0.024668626487255096, 0.06546702235937119, 0.012466562911868095, -0.0037378626875579357, 0.029377635568380356, -0.024787655100226402, -0.026585441082715988, -0.006638634018599987, 0.002957179443910718, -0.02933802269399166, 0.0064267925918102264, -0.021802425384521484, 0.008590280078351498, -0.034743230789899826, 0.011759252287447453, -0.04754529148340225, -0.027504393830895424, 0.03338189050555229, 0.0397932268679142, -0.016178080812096596, 0.020345378667116165, 0.005429568700492382, 0.011391950771212578, 0.012771137990057468, -0.024426955729722977, 0.04818376153707504, -0.0053269038908183575, -0.019577881321310997, 0.006735662464052439, -0.04294569417834282, -0.02374013513326645, -0.05743776261806488, -0.01912999339401722, -0.018468651920557022, -0.055048324167728424, 0.009370564483106136, -0.028923416510224342, 0.04401959478855133, 0.03937339782714844, -0.044840097427368164, -0.04657391086220741, 0.039834678173065186, 0.010724910534918308, 0.007012477144598961, -0.04846710339188576, -0.012937651947140694, 0.008122303523123264, -0.03418388590216637, -0.09074464440345764, -0.02285376377403736, 0.013909544795751572, -0.008518369868397713, -0.010208469815552235, -0.04438817873597145, -0.014409888535737991, 0.005701992195099592, -0.04076039418578148, -0.027984512969851494, 0.017190756276249886, -0.0043565984815359116, 0.001971801510080695, -0.005761257838457823, 0.025821631774306297, 0.058097559958696365, -0.002675842260941863, -0.012502219527959824, 0.02648499794304371, -0.02360432781279087, -0.021617606282234192, 0.010207275860011578, 0.02668316848576069, 0.007117343135178089, -0.014039992354810238, -0.003227287670597434, 0.006211595609784126, -0.017084013670682907, -0.00047376015572808683, -0.04297136142849922, -0.00003666841075755656, 0.020689018070697784, 0.0023285525385290384, -0.029389647766947746, -0.061211954802274704, 0.05487555265426636, 0.010494712740182877, -0.015221268869936466, -0.016191335394978523, -0.007604074664413929, -0.02088967151939869, -0.005058076232671738, -0.0036259691696614027, 0.025632457807660103, 0.018042411655187607, 0.08729968965053558, 0.009924747049808502, -0.041732482612133026, 0.028999844565987587, 0.02778877690434456, 0.04061252996325493, -0.025861339643597603, 0.003676517168059945, 0.013567911460995674, 0.026847442612051964, -0.042895764112472534, 0.0019475036533549428, -0.02471906691789627, -0.001999826868996024, 0.04547254368662834, 0.05390195921063423, 0.04260101914405823, 0.0316612683236599, 0.035991448909044266, -0.0011239158920943737, -0.04529547318816185, -0.02594800293445587, -0.006008423864841461, -0.009890816174447536, -0.006488224491477013, -0.040071550756692886, -0.016556933522224426, 0.027093270793557167, 0.008041049353778362, 0.006677991710603237, 0.04701254889369011, -0.010721402242779732, -0.022416533902287483, 0.013910629786550999, -0.006236621644347906, -0.036941032856702805, 0.025394855067133904, -0.05608758330345154, 0.015856647863984108, -0.03808750584721565, -0.03369209170341492, 0.022683745250105858, 0.03848811611533165, 0.0076798368245363235, -0.0223322045058012, -0.06727803498506546, -0.05973898991942406, 0.048890817910432816, 0.02142360992729664, 0.006385346874594688, 0.02084227465093136, 0.01701582968235016, 0.04282780736684799, -0.006284696515649557, 0.023419970646500587, -0.03238065168261528, -0.0629664957523346, -0.007421558722853661, -0.02146824076771736, -0.05781564489006996, 0.03205936774611473, -0.007387475110590458, 0.011210363358259201, 0.019224487245082855, -0.03605838865041733, 0.012813832610845566, 0.0009216965991072357, -0.0070738401263952255, -0.03485725820064545, 0.04358489066362381, 0.016443083062767982, 0.04656439647078514, -0.009111864492297173, 0.017986875027418137, 0.11576835811138153, 0.040044091641902924, 0.03337927162647247, -0.02616274170577526, 0.004831674974411726, 0.02023063413798809, 0.0386471189558506, -0.04128965735435486, -0.006722025107592344, 0.030508900061249733, -0.008929746225476265, 0.05319778993725777, 0.0265507735311985, 0.015183953568339348, -0.02824719063937664, -0.0036188492085784674, -0.016241688281297684, -0.05756201222538948, -0.04885466769337654, 0.017120832577347755, -0.044182002544403076, 0.01294966135174036, -0.04742681607604027, 0.012566592544317245, -0.05910952389240265, -0.035920124500989914, -0.0655442476272583, -0.005483179818838835, -0.02250579558312893, -0.019856952130794525, -0.02158283442258835, -0.010905303992331028, 0.025469990447163582, -0.007352525368332863, -0.012978613376617432, -0.006587619427591562, -0.028030358254909515, -0.016391003504395485, 0.043393079191446304, 0.03696497157216072, -0.022021515294909477, 0.017724277451634407, 0.030760768800973892, -0.015086175873875618, -0.07560982555150986, -0.02256934717297554, -0.04607575759291649, 0.06584062427282333, 0.007154981605708599, -0.014632172882556915, 0.01932990923523903, -0.02588793821632862, 0.01981823518872261, -0.014707946218550205, -0.0014028524747118354, 0.01364011038094759, 0.014307121746242046, -0.05017746239900589, -0.010496099479496479, -0.016779612749814987, 0.014821067452430725, 0.046297721564769745, 0.036788880825042725, 0.010443820618093014, -0.03927454724907875, -0.029929999262094498, 0.00691387802362442, 0.045594897121191025, 0.01706598326563835, 0.008275514468550682, 0.0003101122274529189, -0.015238525345921516, -0.00847382191568613, -0.016391033306717873, -0.000898434896953404, -0.037574585527181625, 0.03597218170762062, 0.016870692372322083, 0.014842349104583263, 0.014380315318703651, -0.008093630895018578, 0.0006188324769027531, -0.014436889439821243, -0.0007504824316129088, -0.020301833748817444, -0.019134972244501114, -0.006431799381971359, 0.031839095056056976, -0.006531361490488052, -0.007363323122262955, 0.035774435847997665, 0.06218137964606285, 0.027615463361144066, -0.02866353653371334, -0.014568290673196316, -0.02718043141067028, -0.010327964089810848, 0.0238353218883276, -0.01506104413419962, 0.03595324605703354, 0.016393156722187996, 0.0441092886030674, -0.02635016106069088, 0.0007393365958705544, -0.052178241312503815, 0.004611460957676172, 0.01747068203985691, -0.028666658326983452, 0.0109636802226305, 0.03795553743839264, 0.017588412389159203, -0.03311309590935707, 0.00542624294757843, -0.013510234653949738, -0.0007347934297285974, -0.02803194895386696, -0.025171034038066864, -0.05125216022133827, -0.020286809653043747, -0.008975369855761528, 0.006838330067694187, 0.0030646445229649544, 0.0024155057035386562, -0.011281904764473438, -0.004617808852344751, 0.01129189319908619, 0.0070145102217793465, 0.0008859367808327079, 0.010301453061401844, 0.018313618376851082, -0.004524861462414265, 0.02940208464860916, 0.032713789492845535, 0.011752400547266006, -0.011861702427268028, -0.01187335979193449, -0.018347034230828285, 0.03472446650266647, 0.018594607710838318, -0.016134675592184067, 0.031041806563735008, -0.049879398196935654, -0.03520628809928894, 0.07097809761762619, 0.06392182409763336, 0.03961872681975365, -0.012790536507964134, -0.04143131151795387, -0.024400418624281883, 0.018295712769031525, -0.04162465035915375, -0.029720528051257133, -0.06819237768650055, -0.018359165638685226, 0.005227326415479183, 0.006110358517616987, 0.013453103601932526, 0.031528010964393616, 0.026406293734908104, 0.027318740263581276, 0.039856020361185074, -0.01019297819584608, -0.0001156246944447048, 0.015547716058790684, -0.013180041685700417, 0.01629273034632206, 0.021717309951782227, 0.008785253390669823, 0.024265406653285027, 0.05299064517021179, -0.034612786024808884, 0.008507780730724335, -0.04372715577483177, -0.0032636455725878477, -0.054269757121801376, -0.05128499120473862, 0.03637857735157013, 0.0030217706225812435, 0.03337951749563217, -0.028100859373807907, -0.04346108436584473, 0.022366320714354515, -0.03289027512073517, 0.027807027101516724, 0.03165651485323906, -0.029234683141112328, -0.03601941838860512, 0.02483157254755497, -0.026679009199142456, 0.006095364689826965, 0.004934129770845175, 0.022271273657679558, 0.03467905521392822, 0.07525183260440826, -0.02775799110531807, -0.054420918226242065, -0.029319269582629204, 0.0017100784461945295, 0.008805867284536362, -0.08502782136201859, 0.03421502187848091, -0.06058463454246521, 0.03973491117358208, 0.0417395681142807, -0.015098687261343002, -0.0479363389313221, -0.003698458196595311, 0.014218714088201523, -0.020889805629849434, 0.03856483846902847, 0.013434981927275658, 0.023417048156261444, 0.037452422082424164, -0.0192485973238945, 0.04028307646512985, 0.012306079268455505, -0.03489616885781288, 0.01972372643649578, 0.04133129119873047, 0.002481397008523345, -0.02762102708220482, 0.03253895789384842, 0.00923160370439291, -0.029911966994404793, 0.015349633060395718, 0.025768427178263664, -0.005535412579774857, -0.03563137352466583, 0.03867753967642784, -0.059511568397283554, -0.027392631396651268, 0.031870052218437195, 0.007316840812563896, -0.025163907557725906, 0.005478682927787304, 0.02698005735874176, -0.052865222096443176, 0.01607462950050831, 0.008518018759787083, -0.038706354796886444, -0.03548373654484749, -0.032978303730487823, -0.007447268348187208, 0.02555871196091175, -0.034610625356435776, -0.01809721812605858, -0.0553789921104908, -0.012616773135960102, -0.024512413889169693, 0.010633347555994987, -0.058170147240161896, 0.015794435515999794, -0.0072691976092755795, -0.07385950535535812, 0.013271179981529713, -0.024282339960336685, -0.04196588322520256, -0.04538165405392647, -0.00752027053385973, -0.021598733961582184, 0.006435747258365154, 0.0481385737657547, 0.03161460533738136, -0.0032340993639081717, 0.012639911845326424, 0.041599687188863754, 0.04264301061630249, -0.07410119473934174, 0.025483401492238045, -0.03305618464946747, -0.021321993321180344, -0.016163699328899384, -0.01720072515308857, 0.01759752444922924, 0.01026350911706686, -0.006936953403055668, -0.012603425420820713, 0.03153208643198013, -0.011492084711790085, -0.027972934767603874, 0.011915234848856926, -0.04514666274189949, -0.012468734756112099, 0.059759438037872314, -0.02072898857295513, 0.024044785648584366, 0.03169805556535721, 0.0030405018478631973, -0.03514133021235466, 0.0011761493515223265, -0.03926142305135727, -0.026967767626047134, -0.01184001937508583, 0.029931742697954178, 0.003770621260628104, -0.060983359813690186, -0.0017354818992316723, 0.025293532758951187, -0.01201802957803011, 0.0017427005805075169, 0.02090592123568058, 0.013959580101072788, 0.03306569531559944, -0.015987176448106766, -0.00030407303711399436, -0.0025434794370085, -0.0004284638853278011, 0.04680859297513962, 0.02026277221739292, 0.007428368553519249, -0.030225064605474472, 0.002928674453869462, 0.012369025498628616, -0.02210673876106739, 0.029041294008493423, 0.010426970198750496, 0.030800333246588707, -0.01617106795310974, 0.009775138460099697, 0.03910873457789421, -0.02567346766591072, -0.024699214845895767, 0.03937998041510582, -0.015894867479801178, 0.03730682283639908, -0.029923245310783386, 0.026061274111270905, 0.00788329541683197, -0.020372139289975166, -0.025605978444218636, -0.0053718434646725655, 0.01550712063908577, 0.019514264538884163, -0.006495847832411528, -0.011906588450074196, -0.0003753049240913242, -0.03474418446421623, -0.01694626547396183, -0.03873181715607643, 0.02507440559566021, 0.021186407655477524, 0.007489202078431845, -0.023835230618715286, -0.036938853561878204, -0.009814824908971786, -0.029529044404625893, 0.03466658294200897, 0.024674758315086365, -0.016691062599420547, -0.00039928682963363826, -0.004087659530341625, -0.00838464219123125, 0.0495479479432106, -0.051273323595523834, -0.021221136674284935, 0.009600682184100151, 0.02121896855533123, -0.001672917976975441, -0.028770480304956436 ]
<p>An <strong>interim analysis</strong> is an analysis of the data at one or more time points prior the official close of the study with the intention of, e.g., possibly terminating the study early.</p> <p>According to Piantadosi, S. (<a href="http://eu.wiley.com/WileyCDA/WileyTitle/productCd-0471727814.html">Clinical trials - a methodologic perspective</a>): "<em>The estimate of a treatment effect will be biased when a trial is terminated at an early stage. The earlier the decision, the larger the bias.</em>"</p> <p>Can you explain me this claim. I can easily understand that the accuracy is going to be affected, but the claim about the bias is not obvious to me...</p>
38,207
[ -0.0197915006428957, -0.021945243701338768, -0.01964482106268406, -0.011055623181164265, 0.04698654264211655, 0.0561700202524662, -0.014197118580341339, -0.0245275367051363, -0.006086429581046104, -0.027269486337900162, 0.06975433230400085, 0.04644206166267395, 0.033415812999010086, 0.023237233981490135, 0.004372301045805216, 0.017364030703902245, 0.030403215438127518, 0.0005995764513500035, -0.006880506873130798, 0.0007157396175898612, 0.00265325466170907, 0.002729968633502722, -0.03059368021786213, 0.020116977393627167, -0.06411143392324448, 0.020738016813993454, 0.01131357904523611, -0.03389996662735939, 0.013537775725126266, 0.056248486042022705, -0.06827978789806366, -0.006552757229655981, 0.003860659431666136, -0.006596878170967102, -0.0029578423127532005, -0.027347726747393608, -0.034407492727041245, -0.02810419350862503, 0.01748870313167572, 0.04689066857099533, -0.019854838028550148, -0.012146007269620895, -0.019687971100211143, 0.02078752964735031, -0.02864811010658741, 0.004077701363712549, 0.009710469283163548, -0.04164266213774681, 0.03270392492413521, 0.003352124709635973, 0.029866600409150124, -0.00975500512868166, 0.06204520910978317, 0.004370551090687513, -0.015319287776947021, -0.010141427628695965, 0.03190483897924423, 0.04771299287676811, 0.013701708987355232, -0.05270026624202728, -0.013227016665041447, -0.02936171181499958, 0.01424193475395441, 0.014187476597726345, -0.014248869381844997, 0.033702924847602844, 0.014923366717994213, -0.061991821974515915, 0.025198690593242645, -0.028618857264518738, -0.0005530121852643788, -0.006276343017816544, -0.003918320406228304, -0.025788787752389908, 0.0085541857406497, -0.03518277406692505, 0.014910878613591194, 0.05149579420685768, 0.03361586853861809, 0.01547150406986475, 0.0002234066923847422, 0.008303431794047356, 0.07041459530591965, 0.046523481607437134, -0.010557128116488457, 0.03291226178407669, 0.05678064748644829, 0.002423148136585951, 0.048398613929748535, 0.020945651456713676, 0.012773068621754646, 0.029531940817832947, 0.008526844903826714, -0.020662853494286537, -0.02251950465142727, 0.04498157277703285, 0.008939364925026894, 0.0849313959479332, 0.01831928826868534, -0.004010227508842945, 0.021681154146790504, -0.04179804399609566, 0.012056420557200909, 0.025016263127326965, -0.0005186776397749782, -0.04580962285399437, -0.048960573971271515, 0.01795593462884426, -0.025834644213318825, -0.02797568030655384, 0.000611529394518584, -0.014729601331055164, 0.006174302659928799, 0.0031610678415745497, -0.012890990823507309, -0.0027391216717660427, -0.0014903066912665963, 0.014166939072310925, 0.05817478150129318, 0.06383654475212097, 0.056412287056446075, -0.014074597507715225, 0.013760795816779137, -0.036644432693719864, -0.054939769208431244, -0.008604222908616066, 0.03553248941898346, -0.06341371685266495, -0.062024954706430435, 0.018946407362818718, 0.0375562384724617, 0.007577922660857439, 0.057290781289339066, -0.03549550473690033, 0.05311404913663864, 0.0012320417445152998, -0.07044106721878052, -0.04027821868658066, 0.05898584797978401, 0.025622742250561714, 0.008609007112681866, -0.07493036985397339, -0.032222680747509, 0.025669779628515244, 0.07231617718935013, -0.014168660156428814, 0.05577421188354492, 0.0002670896064955741, 0.011752098798751831, 0.00045773794408887625, -0.02124609984457493, 0.028751814737915993, -0.02134791947901249, -0.00952088925987482, -0.01973125897347927, -0.09350253641605377, 0.028565775603055954, 0.02327078953385353, 0.012810098938643932, -0.04747069254517555, 0.009470182470977306, -0.02504611946642399, -0.011410696431994438, -0.017355404794216156, -0.005834711249917746, 0.009070122614502907, 0.07898355275392532, 0.02070324309170246, -0.014173690229654312, 0.03877639397978783, 0.01927916891872883, 0.03983539715409279, 0.017797494307160378, 0.03980705514550209, 0.012559289112687111, -0.014897839166224003, 0.011403444223105907, -0.014161841943860054, -0.012845215387642384, -0.009098643437027931, -0.03548022359609604, -0.024801164865493774, -0.026733871549367905, -0.002470118924975395, 0.023469002917408943, 0.03365655988454819, -0.023882577195763588, 0.034737929701805115, 0.016486575827002525, -0.045266877859830856, -0.047278400510549545, -0.11479989439249039, 0.010567765682935715, 0.0008168816566467285, -0.04470163211226463, 0.0035927516873925924, -0.038606807589530945, 0.02018960751593113, -0.015879401937127113, -0.0066629876382648945, -0.026019075885415077, -0.03798959031701088, 0.059990156441926956, -0.026696329936385155, 0.0033728291746228933, 0.07287906855344772, 0.002138622337952256, -0.009798525832593441, -0.01525876484811306, -0.0009231112780980766, -0.058766696602106094, 0.010850691236555576, -0.015523719601333141, 0.010320527479052544, -0.0011023120023310184, -0.04228930547833443, 0.02525639906525612, -0.012464301660656929, -0.0026229373179376125, 0.02023531310260296, -0.042392827570438385, 0.07017649710178375, 0.05340571328997612, -0.003317733993753791, 0.013197406195104122, 0.038708336651325226, 0.040719300508499146, 0.020296147093176842, 0.01499860268086195, -0.005034230183809996, -0.006539781577885151, -0.022417020052671432, 0.022406216710805893, 0.0015859868144616485, 0.0037730736657977104, 0.02561832405626774, 0.052578285336494446, -0.0000634461102890782, 0.0029933303594589233, 0.026056716218590736, 0.014456701464951038, -0.029493188485503197, 0.0047127255238592625, 0.010138832032680511, -0.0066892062313854694, 0.01048407331109047, -0.006487503182142973, -0.005455464124679565, 0.04651571810245514, 0.01576882414519787, 0.002714867237955332, 0.03740139305591583, -0.011285564862191677, 0.00781701598316431, 0.012579565867781639, -0.026606839150190353, 0.033624645322561264, -0.022587763145565987, 0.0437706857919693, -0.013448708690702915, 0.005112695042043924, 0.0026619145646691322, -0.007957938127219677, -0.012647346593439579, 0.035537272691726685, 0.006313996855169535, -0.036157235503196716, 0.012814642861485481, 0.018974609673023224, -0.03362102806568146, -0.012331931851804256, -0.03058158978819847, -0.04020601511001587, -0.007241358514875174, -0.022335436195135117, 0.03959003463387489, 0.0024255828466266394, 0.0064413417130708694, 0.010759061202406883, -0.01977543719112873, -0.02002570964396, -0.014343878254294395, 0.040790654718875885, 0.010233359411358833, -0.02578856237232685, 0.01429670862853527, -0.01747892051935196, -0.0010279937414452434, 0.04453352466225624, 0.007661525625735521, -0.009562045335769653, 0.041409287601709366, 0.025298841297626495, -0.015742575749754906, -0.0433371402323246, 0.0025987927801907063, 0.020936856046319008, 0.007352212909609079, -0.05226649343967438, 0.050952620804309845, 0.01866273395717144, -0.010542134754359722, 0.04438058286905289, -0.016287697479128838, -0.0078422324731946, -0.003461152547970414, 0.027871375903487206, 0.001991670811548829, 0.004243084229528904, 0.015736443921923637, 0.026494372636079788, -0.004880690481513739, -0.018549641594290733, -0.10646867752075195, -0.07770363986492157, 0.049873631447553635, -0.017507033422589302, 0.01892690546810627, -0.013783961534500122, -0.01278727501630783, 0.09060068428516388, -0.0014188303612172604, -0.0019153682515025139, 0.0008834364707581699, 0.008652551099658012, -0.04963935539126396, 0.010007677599787712, -0.04080168157815933, -0.012986596673727036, 0.0017904333071783185, 0.031312014907598495, -0.028102582320570946, 0.02463519014418125, 0.016916174441576004, 0.026304563507437706, -0.03462829068303108, -0.008009224198758602, 0.03562835976481438, 0.026368193328380585, -0.013464106246829033, 0.0453387126326561, 0.007449586410075426, -0.0007136136409826577, -0.012581156566739082, 0.044856444001197815, -0.016494132578372955, -0.06245558708906174, 0.024567952379584312, -0.013670754618942738, -0.0016518619377166033, -0.02368021197617054, 0.07106170803308487, -0.010785174556076527, 0.02157694287598133, -0.01582317054271698, -0.02728065848350525, 0.016900816932320595, -0.03922048211097717, 0.004581983666867018, 0.03585425764322281, 0.01926336996257305, -0.04756847023963928, -0.029341936111450195, -0.012892086990177631, -0.004081962630152702, 0.015443149022758007, -0.047680482268333435, -0.023195723071694374, 0.0061622606590390205, 0.051932819187641144, -0.004064137581735849, 0.0007496490143239498, -0.0499204620718956, -0.009737465530633926, -0.0649246871471405, 0.01932748593389988, 0.013224650174379349, 0.03908558562397957, -0.016678519546985626, 0.03892996534705162, 0.017176011577248573, -0.003974649589508772, -0.02507413551211357, -0.002341225976124406, -0.06557845324277878, 0.006583914160728455, -0.0006826326716691256, -0.02852759137749672, 0.008050850592553616, -0.01612364687025547, 0.007845503278076649, 0.010869997553527355, -0.0151554886251688, -0.028615450486540794, 0.0012559574097394943, -0.015151186846196651, 0.0063742343336343765, -0.028563514351844788, 0.020531199872493744, -0.019493022933602333, -0.015474071726202965, 0.03752175718545914, -0.018218692392110825, 0.033154528588056564, 0.016276316717267036, -0.013884332031011581, -0.024067603051662445, -0.044850412756204605, 0.022441640496253967, 0.034631069749593735, 0.022793691605329514, 0.038098935037851334, 0.02950209565460682, -0.05430389568209648, 0.05114753916859627, 0.023821504786610603, 0.05147551745176315, 0.03653481975197792, -0.015218919143080711, -0.023629916831851006, -0.0381990484893322, -0.0018512462265789509, 0.04743766784667969, 0.011960342526435852, 0.029569827020168304, -0.018817562609910965, 0.06073611602187157, 0.008397701196372509, -0.026177160441875458, 0.04230084270238876, 0.041542746126651764, 0.04169134050607681, 0.036027319729328156, -0.035362839698791504, 0.012803633697330952, -0.017682360485196114, -0.054470814764499664, 0.027417916804552078, 0.005392985884100199, 0.014063690789043903, -0.0449737049639225, 0.028607405722141266, -0.03235623240470886, -0.06485158205032349, -0.0014005363918840885, -0.03886079788208008, 0.019042029976844788, 0.07179610431194305, -0.001740934676490724, 0.04337693378329277, 0.04732928052544594, 0.030036788433790207, 0.03951358050107956, 0.017753081396222115, -0.09531725198030472, 0.03127478435635567, 0.017472071573138237, 0.06862089782953262, -0.025320574641227722, -0.010877435095608234, -0.06845379620790482, -0.0043718572705984116, 0.033127252012491226, -0.029648803174495697, 0.025824517011642456, -0.03591840714216232, 0.01031365618109703, -0.023643633350729942, -0.03661894053220749, -0.04957092925906181, 0.012830039486289024, 0.0004814465355593711, 0.02909412793815136, 0.020338840782642365, -0.026381269097328186, -0.003172866301611066, -0.02937163971364498, 0.005134152248501778, 0.03204311430454254, -0.02446000464260578, -0.0033914775121957064, 0.04044321924448013, -0.00010282165021635592, -0.04017792269587517, -0.09235785156488419, 0.03153848648071289, -0.02186470665037632, -0.02264583669602871, 0.040845390409231186, -0.05762912333011627, -0.0033477453980594873, 0.007509949151426554, -0.010926439426839352, -0.031969185918569565, -0.018087996169924736, -0.06456409394741058, 0.03291083127260208, 0.0330873541533947, -0.0051003796979784966, 0.06045759096741676, 0.014968900941312313, -0.01636488363146782, 0.006506897043436766, -0.02219618484377861, -0.0028516987804323435, -0.024080323055386543, 0.017759621143341064, -0.03922206535935402, -0.027777619659900665, -0.03572826832532883, 0.023127481341362, 0.03514563664793968, 0.0171962957829237, 0.011152153834700584, 0.007265611086040735, 0.012103148736059666, 0.005082980263978243, -0.0062989890575408936, 0.002121733035892248, -0.0272047258913517, -0.0352458693087101, -0.014919687062501907, -0.00680525740608573, 0.0393153615295887, -0.015106326900422573, 0.02828403003513813, 0.01782292127609253, -0.0462295338511467, -0.018116122111678123, -0.007716813590377569, -0.04874635115265846, -0.008023509755730629, -0.02229970507323742, 0.008172347210347652, 0.004670209717005491, 0.02964157424867153, 0.008111325092613697, -0.02206612564623356, -0.026578938588500023, 0.018896443769335747, -0.04023316875100136, 0.0021506568882614374, -0.031369756907224655, 0.035083457827568054, 0.05499909073114395, 0.00987799372524023, -0.09529472887516022, -0.019836636260151863, 0.03278360888361931, 0.003275953931733966, -0.055591411888599396, 0.00023400790814775974, 0.022468501701951027, -0.020879510790109634, -0.0401250422000885, -0.009109171107411385, 0.01630665548145771, -0.014433566480875015, -0.03437851741909981, 0.0026598910335451365, 0.016621312126517296, 0.05571341514587402, -0.0350680872797966, -0.005384202580899, 0.019741447642445564, -0.042087819427251816, -0.0025100528728216887, 0.016620200127363205, 0.0016319857677444816, -0.026952803134918213, 0.002385033294558525, -0.0324871763586998, 0.032989464700222015, -0.005538089666515589, 0.030850209295749664, -0.024142514914274216, 0.009330919943749905, -0.011092685163021088, 0.030441652983427048, -0.020036516711115837, -0.036927759647369385, -0.01947256363928318, 0.028297610580921173, -0.021632814779877663, 0.028073322027921677, 0.04113981872797012, -0.01242261566221714, 0.018555885180830956, 0.017106961458921432, -0.054353002458810806, 0.014460771344602108, 0.04975053668022156, -0.04540892690420151, 0.014894649386405945, 0.0027433617506176233, 0.001057016896083951, 0.018282756209373474, 0.022941622883081436, 0.0012137527810409665, 0.004924472887068987, -0.019404176622629166, -0.023865800350904465, -0.005624581594020128, -0.026446325704455376, 0.027160203084349632, 0.033580586314201355, -0.006397122051566839, 0.043918438255786896, 0.03349883854389191, -0.02098342776298523, -0.02811587229371071, -0.037730276584625244, -0.0016926227835938334, -0.0038804837968200445, -0.004791924264281988, 0.042124174535274506, 0.001883672084659338, 0.006694420240819454, 0.05413004755973816, 0.02210479974746704, 0.0042458996176719666, 0.02010546624660492, 0.018392445519566536, 0.016358908265829086, 0.015426168218255043, 0.003697602543979883, -0.03222429379820824, 0.009018059819936752, -0.04259234294295311, 0.02115870639681816, -0.026007648557424545, -0.02202625572681427, 0.04434366524219513, 0.009725607000291348, 0.013641406781971455, -0.05077104642987251, -0.012301960028707981, -0.049377404153347015, -0.007575348950922489, 0.01869165152311325, 0.0010950984433293343, 0.04936312511563301, -0.012510080821812153, 0.0032937200739979744, 0.005745436530560255, 0.039298851042985916, -0.020567208528518677, 0.00615913700312376, -0.03652903810143471, -0.007817476987838745, -0.01612859033048153, 0.040288280695676804, -0.03720525652170181, -0.007937999442219734, 0.01996069960296154, -0.0023718909360468388, -0.00171732681337744, 0.008857266046106815, 0.028095657005906105, 0.011132554151117802, 0.06127649545669556, 0.03775591403245926, 0.024608653038740158, 0.005624635145068169, -0.007555761374533176, 0.12477608770132065, 0.07527656853199005, 0.04323021322488785, -0.03711515665054321, 0.05282400920987129, 0.009803462773561478, 0.014869390055537224, -0.013404843397438526, 0.021979112178087234, 0.014680868946015835, -0.03346678614616394, 0.06324106454849243, 0.0466248020529747, -0.001824178616516292, -0.033869754523038864, 0.016429906710982323, -0.0354107990860939, -0.03844017535448074, 0.01283210702240467, -0.03359389305114746, -0.03593418747186661, -0.05978520214557648, -0.03280627727508545, 0.023981129750609398, 0.028893860056996346, -0.07941289991140366, 0.006774304434657097, 0.006589523516595364, -0.0049471380189061165, 0.03602108359336853, -0.01581871323287487, -0.01686912029981613, 0.011538702063262463, -0.008549015037715435, -0.040474969893693924, -0.05203331634402275, 0.02427530102431774, -0.011030029505491257, 0.010172522626817226, 0.029986759647727013, 0.03622371330857277, -0.029497377574443817, 0.005676256492733955, 0.07125815004110336, -0.02661621943116188, -0.012501264922320843, -0.010147430002689362, 0.06505875289440155, 0.014974378049373627, 0.008620589971542358, -0.05413023382425308, 0.007033494766801596, 0.011117897927761078, -0.05816124379634857, -0.005912865046411753, 0.029755597934126854, -0.02518203668296337, -0.056872084736824036, -0.020548341795802116, -0.014805781655013561, -0.026864446699619293, 0.011348350904881954, 0.003792282659560442, 0.010798276402056217, -0.07451179623603821, -0.03475295379757881, -0.027113649994134903, 0.023150460794568062, 0.019274046644568443, -0.009054656140506268, 0.011008496396243572, -0.013394644483923912, -0.05960148200392723, 0.006356698460876942, -0.004053914453834295, -0.014794482849538326, 0.07116547971963882, 0.005064359400421381, -0.001624417258426547, -0.015535403043031693, -0.0447208434343338, 0.04530572518706322, -0.04061971977353096, -0.0029164887964725494, -0.024647794663906097, 0.014354138635098934, 0.02220389060676098, 0.00024906659382395446, -0.011200014501810074, 0.03790785372257233, -0.020100682973861694, 0.03822345286607742, -0.010545711033046246, -0.04728122055530548, -0.049172475934028625, -0.013476381078362465, -0.030927641317248344, -0.008923343382775784, -0.028101082891225815, 0.06048968806862831, 0.020464571192860603, 0.004826679360121489, 0.037673622369766235, 0.006102037616074085, 0.013544886372983456, -0.0039846329018473625, -0.014011217281222343, -0.053148053586483, -0.013719983398914337, 0.007099410053342581, 0.008505244739353657, -0.03882130980491638, 0.007348579820245504, -0.03309837356209755, 0.002028094371780753, 0.029252421110868454, -0.011310724541544914, -0.024051612243056297, 0.024534419178962708, 0.014436887577176094, 0.014645038172602654, -0.02414797805249691, 0.004003164824098349, -0.035954549908638, -0.021636229008436203, -0.03960336744785309, 0.009976254776120186, 0.03782635182142258, 0.007923786528408527, -0.018504338338971138, -0.03263094648718834, 0.02871890179812908, -0.010897614061832428, -0.02666863612830639, -0.013989406637847424, 0.013090440072119236, 0.03407248854637146, 0.009457606822252274, 0.03012991137802601, -0.034556932747364044, 0.018749067559838295, -0.04981069266796112, -0.05417526513338089, 0.011405537836253643, 0.0005286111263558269, -0.006640544626861811, 0.04166727885603905, 0.010743667371571064, 0.0015298423822969198, 0.025703178718686104, -0.02324168011546135, -0.06767101585865021, 0.007186053786426783, -0.018978750333189964, 0.013401249423623085, -0.042948488146066666, 0.008689025416970253, 0.022815782576799393, -0.019657742232084274, 0.037462037056684494, 0.06098003685474396, 0.02558552473783493, -0.01702439785003662, 0.007774231489747763, 0.013557166792452335, -0.02439333312213421, -0.0016480342019349337, -0.017899369820952415, 0.033251725137233734, 0.06539066135883331, -0.004095378331840038, 0.05295635387301445, -0.0033648198004812002, -0.0033210120163857937, -0.08331567049026489, -0.014405469410121441, 0.0030029253102838993, 0.03982790559530258, 0.005282919853925705, -0.031982775777578354, 0.07112422585487366, 0.03979276120662689, -0.034291822463274, 0.0001603739510755986, -0.010912424884736538, -0.014733138494193554, -0.03388184681534767, 0.004785110242664814, -0.04758991301059723, 0.01102736871689558, 0.03865993395447731, 0.010487132705748081, 0.010156822390854359, 0.0006130312685854733, 0.03544216230511665, -0.01622755452990532, -0.022330205887556076, 0.038056232035160065, -0.020373491570353508, -0.05752408131957054, 0.02195768803358078, -0.04293927177786827, -0.04682028666138649, 0.03362704813480377, 0.014901728369295597, 0.035994138568639755, 0.025235798209905624, 0.02708798460662365, -0.02754288725554943, -0.015136048197746277, 0.015130392275750637, 0.039680030196905136, 0.012998201884329319, -0.007917695678770542, 0.012528257444500923, 0.06013796851038933, 0.004964856430888176, 0.0654701367020607, 0.0047850534319877625, -0.009806683287024498, 0.007552134804427624, 0.048506710678339005, -0.03136789798736572, -0.007107516750693321, -0.01789889484643936, -0.015457739122211933, 0.01254329551011324, -0.028634697198867798, 0.01101311482489109, -0.022487927228212357, -0.027209699153900146, 0.03730586916208267, -0.007597575895488262, 0.005070836748927832, 0.04954114556312561, -0.01749006099998951, -0.014286323450505733, 0.024682000279426575, 0.003679311368614435, 0.011262746527791023, -0.08701888471841812, 0.03081628493964672, 0.0069909896701574326, -0.03150724992156029, -0.03489769995212555, 0.0043653687462210655, -0.022776611149311066, 0.046493105590343475, 0.0009056336130015552, -0.03969760611653328, -0.01624331809580326, -0.005256194621324539, 0.049672093242406845, -0.12512288987636566, 0.06125534698367119, -0.014374447055161, -0.025067297741770744, -0.051103152334690094, -0.027741476893424988, -0.015128402970731258, 0.005788342095911503, 0.042759958654642105, 0.016784990206360817, -0.04428538307547569, 0.024613678455352783, 0.01563294045627117, -0.03921465575695038, -0.0027584051713347435, 0.07564342021942139, -0.002112029120326042, 0.0021031778305768967, -0.0009121660841628909, -0.0033687888644635677, 0.00006244132237043232, 0.026804573833942413, 0.002701509278267622, -0.009715531021356583, 0.03870367631316185, 0.014979453757405281, 0.0010350804077461362, 0.04807940125465393, 0.009230515919625759, -0.014241927303373814, 0.07020460814237595, 0.015797153115272522, 0.03434159606695175, 0.04711682349443436, -0.01270698569715023, -0.05513281002640724, 0.019696464762091637, -0.020527446642518044, -0.0028588473796844482, 0.012736556120216846, 0.0025451313704252243, -0.01911700889468193, -0.03916315361857414, -0.021436965093016624, -0.0020957859233021736, -0.04714931547641754, 0.031008291989564896, 0.014774898998439312, 0.02667379193007946, 0.01707695983350277, -0.016979869455099106, -0.0092377420514822, -0.005517784506082535, -0.011563862673938274, 0.014804545789957047, 0.020528575405478477, 0.0312479380518198, 0.016771864145994186, 0.04407621547579765, 0.005109651014208794, -0.015806589275598526, -0.008637426421046257, 0.011179092340171337, 0.05615446716547012, -0.022883951663970947, 0.005964076146483421, -0.04226338118314743, 0.0019049386028200388, 0.005009396467357874, -0.014317268505692482, -0.007916736416518688, 0.04576077312231064, -0.002418017713353038, 0.022554734721779823, -0.019207078963518143, 0.007435000501573086, -0.015639103949069977, 0.019529568031430244, 0.03253821283578873, -0.0006217024056240916, 0.04512901231646538, -0.003464255714789033, 0.022026631981134415, -0.0002861941757146269, 0.011775930412113667, -0.015844756737351418, 0.012882222421467304, 0.005370164755731821, -0.0095030777156353, -0.050818733870983124, -0.009126790799200535, 0.01235516183078289, -0.016505545005202293, 0.029938016086816788, 0.032585009932518005, 0.026803981512784958, -0.040095992386341095, -0.026404084637761116, 0.0031387759372591972, 0.05732144042849541, -0.06729879230260849, -0.013995813205838203, -0.03568394482135773, 0.014437582343816757, -0.010661976411938667, -0.007415486965328455 ]
<p>I have some data to analyze where $y$ is dependent of $x$ - a linear regression was used.</p> <p>It's a question from an exam, so I think it should be solvable. The regression was used to estimate the mean <em>miles per gallon</em> (response) from the <em>amount of miles driven</em> (predictor).</p> <p>I have the following statistics available:</p> <ul> <li>Correlation coefficient (0.117)</li> <li>Standard deviation (0.482)</li> <li>Number of observations (101)</li> </ul> <p>An ANOVA of this regression yields (Regression and residuals, respectively):</p> <ul> <li>df: 1, 99</li> <li>SS: 0.319, 22.96</li> <li>MS: 0.319, 0.232</li> <li>F-value: 1.374, critical F-value: 0.244</li> </ul> <p>The regression itself (Intercept and Slope, respectively):</p> <ul> <li>Coefficients: 6.51, -0.00024</li> <li>Standard deviations: 0.186, 0.0002</li> <li>t-Values: 34.90, -1.17</li> <li>p-Values: 1.93E-57, 0.2439</li> </ul> <p>Also, the "upper and lower 95% and 99%" are given for the above regression (although I'm not sure what that means).</p> <p>Now, I am asked to calculate the mean $y$ for several values $x$, that's relatively easy, I just use the coefficients. So for example, I can calculate the mean miles per gallon for 500 miles driven.</p> <p>Part where I'm stuck: <strong>I need to calculate the 99% confidence interval for the mean of $y$.</strong>. Obviously, this is what the example is all about - the introduction states that the mileage of a car should be estimated.</p> <p>My question: How can I find out the mean of $y$ using the data provided above? (And, subsequently, the 99% confidence interval, although I seem to have the standard deviation, so that shouldn't be the problem)</p>
37,085
[ -0.005675137508660555, -0.004055102821439505, 0.029563628137111664, 0.060570742934942245, 0.027030350640416145, 0.03554844483733177, 0.0004712708469014615, -0.03118780255317688, 0.024655913934111595, -0.011917555704712868, 0.050058018416166306, 0.03492949157953262, 0.010569070465862751, 0.009571931324899197, 0.03033808059990406, 0.03629643842577934, -0.002553551224991679, 0.022807160392403603, 0.022622931748628616, -0.023375626653432846, -0.028179334476590157, -0.027422644197940826, -0.0057105086743831635, -0.011002416722476482, -0.025643203407526016, 0.033757284283638, 0.026178382337093353, -0.027165507897734642, -0.010728674940764904, 0.05342394858598709, -0.023954568430781364, -0.0468386709690094, 0.009273190051317215, 0.02419501170516014, 0.0004764818586409092, 0.024046801030635834, -0.010851254686713219, -0.018384382128715515, 0.02497178502380848, 0.028008561581373215, -0.016985081136226654, -0.016071222722530365, 0.027625588700175285, 0.05437128245830536, 0.015477917157113552, 0.008099743165075779, 0.02210931107401848, -0.038879092782735825, 0.050823718309402466, -0.022667594254016876, 0.08247023075819016, -0.016806263476610184, 0.04504752159118652, 0.036015983670949936, -0.019751951098442078, -0.009278720244765282, 0.03157569095492363, 0.043062642216682434, -0.025079671293497086, -0.06793978810310364, 0.009408276528120041, -0.01918206550180912, -0.015574932098388672, -0.0027728858403861523, -0.05551429092884064, -0.02069857157766819, -0.0019687244202941656, -0.007850276306271553, 0.04349270090460777, -0.008842617273330688, 0.03178378939628601, 0.025038402527570724, 0.03712043538689613, -0.019189387559890747, 0.0008560232236050069, -0.03435248136520386, 0.02510455623269081, 0.021786505356431007, 0.04594462364912033, 0.047135669738054276, 0.004169838968664408, 0.01750432327389717, 0.008476068265736103, 0.01194816455245018, -0.025557130575180054, -0.0036542166490107775, 0.07583054900169373, -0.01016443781554699, 0.05127214267849922, 0.027315080165863037, 0.009894060902297497, -0.010538819245994091, 0.05220276862382889, 0.0030904337763786316, -0.02303621545433998, 0.04838588461279869, -0.008759558200836182, 0.006341093685477972, 0.038976408541202545, 0.0016738600097596645, 0.004814466927200556, -0.04333029314875603, 0.005900944117456675, 0.03830946981906891, -0.01010087225586176, -0.024760238826274872, -0.008447405882179737, 0.020132508128881454, 0.01577135920524597, -0.04672466963529587, 0.011438675224781036, 0.031687259674072266, -0.007171811070293188, 0.007908230647444725, -0.005637025460600853, -0.00888113398104906, -0.029310081154108047, -0.05305595323443413, 0.031009873375296593, 0.03371728956699371, 0.04260963574051857, -0.05549253523349762, -0.019627045840024948, 0.00009709956066217273, -0.014945510774850845, 0.00955056119710207, 0.019024303182959557, 0.0231853649020195, 0.018851403146982193, 0.049533795565366745, -0.005617239512503147, -0.02942730113863945, 0.018222900107502937, 0.004075700417160988, 0.0024153271224349737, -0.00287845591083169, -0.06495513767004013, -0.09625930339097977, 0.014785864390432835, 0.004429577384144068, 0.007952464744448662, -0.027370071038603783, -0.007793193217366934, 0.06599005311727524, 0.039774585515260696, 0.006753100082278252, 0.03817093372344971, 0.004509613383561373, 0.019276734441518784, 0.009460968896746635, -0.016091657802462578, -0.005765581503510475, -0.04195515066385269, -0.039724498987197876, 0.030369039624929428, -0.04208587855100632, 0.014505676925182343, -0.010376573540270329, -0.011104515753686428, 0.006754748057574034, 0.024028724059462547, -0.003396873362362385, -0.02138628251850605, 0.01754998043179512, -0.003784440690651536, -0.011722867377102375, 0.058783452957868576, 0.003914423752576113, 0.020160730928182602, 0.014848623424768448, -0.013009983114898205, 0.009807097725570202, -0.006387889385223389, 0.01694374717772007, 0.0670773833990097, -0.03449075669050217, -0.005713116377592087, -0.03246431425213814, -0.010670037940144539, 0.005977690685540438, -0.08308330178260803, -0.02601691707968712, -0.01631634682416916, 0.005774821154773235, 0.011652538552880287, 0.052445411682128906, 0.01571100950241089, -0.024785242974758148, 0.041307155042886734, -0.04695964604616165, -0.05452338606119156, -0.041227761656045914, -0.006805894896388054, -0.010682600550353527, -0.0360446535050869, 0.007427060976624489, -0.01990945264697075, 0.009376917034387589, -0.00932598952203989, 0.011969571001827717, -0.005273828748613596, 0.017894389107823372, 0.05717642232775688, -0.04072420671582222, 0.03009430505335331, 0.03879848122596741, 0.07041478157043457, -0.031883787363767624, 0.021932920441031456, -0.036593854427337646, -0.02042737416923046, -0.03104143589735031, -0.04701946675777435, 0.0022315667010843754, -0.019468484446406364, -0.04433630406856537, -0.0026824031956493855, -0.0351642444729805, -0.018110159784555435, 0.013333095237612724, -0.08534149080514908, 0.055560801178216934, 0.06758251041173935, 0.008629879914224148, -0.009190820157527924, 0.013703248463571072, 0.007329199928790331, 0.026220301166176796, -0.03249799832701683, 0.008653437718749046, -0.048914600163698196, -0.033183466643095016, 0.023602724075317383, 0.025601394474506378, -0.026036757975816727, 0.008735225535929203, 0.07794934511184692, -0.0046011218801140785, 0.009568887762725353, 0.03789037838578224, -0.02847851812839508, -0.007345349062234163, -0.00931854359805584, -0.002851204015314579, 0.03386331722140312, 0.011268394999206066, -0.01027983520179987, 0.03191376477479935, 0.02658950351178646, 0.00906108133494854, 0.018509648740291595, 0.04356199875473976, 0.018387136980891228, -0.03823380917310715, -0.006708522792905569, 0.017282040789723396, 0.06322599202394485, -0.02526775933802128, -0.015274460427463055, 0.03969794511795044, -0.0075773135758936405, 0.020664991810917854, 0.010495899245142937, -0.007294286508113146, 0.02798055112361908, 0.04526466876268387, -0.024902427569031715, 0.011807912960648537, 0.016728634014725685, -0.005250303540378809, 0.0398348905146122, -0.05463027581572533, -0.01734124682843685, -0.016343597322702408, 0.0010760161094367504, 0.015228422358632088, 0.016688989475369453, -0.008725578896701336, -0.014007463119924068, 0.016616765409708023, -0.024437647312879562, -0.0012987004593014717, 0.01244670432060957, -0.0002567544870544225, -0.05460190027952194, -0.028659701347351074, -0.03651152923703194, -0.008889726363122463, 0.014708892442286015, 0.02553914487361908, -0.04110749065876007, 0.03287721797823906, -0.025343533605337143, -0.09448752552270889, -0.06722725182771683, -0.009956106543540955, 0.0065283942967653275, -0.03978285565972328, -0.000013528834642784204, 0.05132555216550827, -0.0197762381285429, -0.02892255410552025, 0.01560464221984148, -0.03780099377036095, 0.012664686888456345, -0.04318850487470627, 0.004715941846370697, -0.0025035894941538572, 0.02829870581626892, 0.021634060889482498, -0.01798323169350624, -0.0006888892967253923, -0.012926825322210789, -0.08098006248474121, -0.03682800382375717, -0.0006253584870137274, 0.017079636454582214, 0.03376389294862747, -0.016803661361336708, -0.008532406762242317, 0.07008573412895203, 0.03694074600934982, -0.048833444714546204, -0.042287569493055344, -0.017542943358421326, -0.04075203835964203, -0.04229725897312164, -0.0030470979399979115, 0.01750095561146736, 0.013128714635968208, 0.02868087962269783, -0.002598714316263795, 0.04628228768706322, 0.01213741209357977, -0.010685721412301064, 0.008770043961703777, 0.0018796813674271107, -0.016477834433317184, 0.0074899690225720406, 0.0515582375228405, 0.03237689286470413, -0.024754105135798454, 0.022889360785484314, -0.018407147377729416, 0.04279981926083565, 0.01191719714552164, -0.060870736837387085, 0.021172011271119118, -0.009250376373529434, 0.00019618669466581196, -0.048482198268175125, 0.011396482586860657, 0.0203473549336195, -0.009286262094974518, -0.01755087450146675, -0.0004079524369444698, 0.026111718267202377, -0.004879579413682222, 0.003889077343046665, 0.03390923887491226, 0.05688312277197838, -0.01988808810710907, -0.0527711845934391, -0.0024465862661600113, -0.029012741521000862, 0.0055066864006221294, -0.04750298708677292, -0.01229830365628004, 0.0444503016769886, 0.04346490278840065, 0.007482246961444616, 0.005695038475096226, -0.018961478024721146, -0.0006525305798277259, -0.04392293840646744, -0.008205867372453213, -0.021976759657263756, 0.045445650815963745, -0.004125196952372789, 0.04960034415125847, -0.02303967997431755, -0.03278695046901703, -0.007531247101724148, -0.019385818392038345, -0.058760009706020355, 0.049168266355991364, -0.0031781557481735945, -0.06688785552978516, -0.0033423909917473793, -0.008833242580294609, 0.06518382579088211, -0.08914359658956528, 0.04549308866262436, -0.019419053569436073, 0.03154437616467476, 0.0006135500152595341, 0.008047228679060936, -0.0023127030581235886, -0.04419972747564316, -0.02507167123258114, -0.006843280047178268, 0.026018880307674408, -0.01344264019280672, 0.016361169517040253, 0.018581373617053032, -0.009790424257516861, 0.0004485860117711127, -0.0334748700261116, 0.003976087085902691, 0.04730372130870819, 0.03988352417945862, 0.021415187045931816, 0.007789004594087601, -0.028205281123518944, 0.01635310798883438, 0.0009928602958098054, 0.039389949291944504, 0.06443754583597183, 0.0030740133952349424, -0.030614763498306274, -0.004332603421062231, -0.019058246165513992, 0.014377866871654987, -0.008630105294287205, -0.0069406465627253056, 0.00030796939972788095, 0.06086831912398338, 0.015120688825845718, -0.05153850466012955, 0.05930893495678902, 0.01062097866088152, 0.01662195846438408, 0.030787454918026924, -0.020425261929631233, 0.0016645548166707158, -0.007201802916824818, 0.024176156148314476, 0.013998382724821568, 0.024291159585118294, 0.036324214190244675, -0.03569191321730614, 0.03187616169452667, 0.008183717727661133, -0.03893687576055527, 0.007137009408324957, 0.03523135557770729, 0.05089300498366356, -0.020068803802132607, -0.020615801215171814, -0.002428527921438217, 0.009359763003885746, 0.0267384834587574, -0.020091524347662926, 0.014285972341895103, -0.09775225818157196, -0.026520367711782455, 0.019348477944731712, 0.06653348356485367, -0.030918659642338753, -0.006817762274295092, -0.009061667136847973, -0.018936770036816597, 0.04439923167228699, -0.0274967011064291, 0.03137622028589249, 0.0014529715990647674, 0.004463471006602049, 0.002607761649414897, -0.03570261597633362, -0.09069327265024185, 0.004281619563698769, -0.009816139936447144, 0.016933705657720566, -0.05483796074986458, -0.041635263711214066, -0.030529409646987915, -0.009634492918848991, 0.014292914420366287, 0.05107169225811958, -0.012420406565070152, -0.010621723718941212, 0.013844609260559082, 0.0383731834590435, 0.004485011100769043, -0.05463951453566551, 0.015018035657703876, 0.006297908257693052, 0.0065289456397295, 0.02805403806269169, -0.013527226634323597, -0.02792915515601635, 0.0461583249270916, 0.02287028543651104, -0.009340989403426647, -0.012743426486849785, -0.026529401540756226, 0.018491342663764954, 0.04007447138428688, 0.0203580129891634, 0.06588613241910934, 0.017831692472100258, 0.001662170747295022, 0.006885686423629522, -0.04854605719447136, 0.0020479101222008467, -0.01466117613017559, -0.056563157588243484, -0.03167237341403961, -0.024431001394987106, -0.013600927777588367, 0.004911365453153849, -0.016738470643758774, 0.011629818938672543, -0.0745692104101181, -0.01581057347357273, 0.02873028628528118, 0.000803867937065661, -0.021605780348181725, -0.01173401903361082, 0.01612122915685177, 0.010606394149363041, -0.029088079929351807, -0.027137931436300278, 0.0007187126902863383, 0.006892332341521978, -0.0048507703468203545, -0.005152399186044931, -0.05873963609337807, 0.0006169025436975062, 0.017470387741923332, -0.014301403425633907, -0.018118813633918762, -0.033581897616386414, 0.0430903322994709, -0.012184289284050465, 0.005997793283313513, -0.016653843224048615, -0.031185749918222427, -0.006349412724375725, 0.04181424528360367, 0.015112047083675861, 0.022217415273189545, 0.0014319847105070949, 0.03946797177195549, -0.00753203546628356, -0.018217789009213448, -0.04328230395913124, -0.03830898553133011, 0.008578518405556679, 0.01698208600282669, -0.03454224020242691, -0.0050091249868273735, -0.042411889880895615, -0.017673037946224213, -0.014234194532036781, -0.005548235960304737, 0.02406831830739975, -0.024036671966314316, -0.005709439516067505, -0.0010212035849690437, 0.024255041033029556, 0.04080721363425255, -0.033186767250299454, 0.007156874053180218, 0.03414809703826904, -0.011719869449734688, -0.0488218329846859, 0.00829500611871481, -0.016537966206669807, -0.035312049090862274, -0.016234762966632843, -0.007514168508350849, 0.0027491776272654533, 0.034551024436950684, -0.012912582606077194, -0.04053650051355362, 0.031786706298589706, 0.02375279925763607, -0.018933206796646118, -0.030763428658246994, 0.018925685435533524, 0.020690741017460823, -0.01899535581469536, -0.0107348021119833, 0.007202499080449343, -0.007201403379440308, 0.006142751779407263, 0.03306965157389641, -0.02774902619421482, -0.02818109653890133, -0.0029901217203587294, 0.08257830142974854, 0.02485247142612934, 0.01972811110317707, 0.0068552931770682335, -0.03140149638056755, 0.04899825155735016, 0.0335177518427372, 0.004912327043712139, 0.025408774614334106, -0.016132857650518417, -0.0460858978331089, -0.029835259541869164, -0.03853502497076988, -0.02933831699192524, 0.05551343411207199, 0.0049221026711165905, 0.0403442345559597, 0.04525407776236534, 0.005768967792391777, -0.007684045471251011, -0.046468060463666916, -0.057442858815193176, 0.006242135539650917, 0.03554290905594826, 0.06609703600406647, 0.006416160147637129, -0.018200630322098732, 0.04327775910496712, -0.019639374688267708, 0.011961628682911396, 0.038748618215322495, -0.014477488584816456, 0.004402056336402893, 0.017137110233306885, -0.00010979836224578321, -0.04083845019340515, 0.002584411995485425, 0.01448274776339531, -0.006844711024314165, -0.058247655630111694, 0.001674713334068656, 0.04817982763051987, 0.04822792857885361, 0.019288940355181694, -0.03835320472717285, -0.0017474202904850245, -0.08189060539007187, 0.017726408317685127, 0.008926937356591225, -0.02940192259848118, 0.025489002466201782, 0.007467745337635279, 0.02343476191163063, -0.039885085076093674, 0.06845360994338989, -0.04209769889712334, -0.04973810911178589, -0.0020409636199474335, 0.00829915888607502, -0.024410828948020935, 0.061955858021974564, -0.006723536644130945, -0.018342820927500725, 0.03994916006922722, -0.06793873012065887, 0.010525372810661793, 0.029056189581751823, 0.025436200201511383, 0.01094674039632082, 0.06623955816030502, -0.004272827412933111, 0.015018806792795658, -0.012704731896519661, -0.019496597349643707, 0.10389090329408646, 0.05243925005197525, 0.04028864577412605, -0.04486975446343422, -0.008079814724624157, -0.013452492654323578, -0.011510200798511505, -0.027314230799674988, -0.006133692339062691, 0.013605761341750622, 0.0019401153549551964, 0.05155414342880249, 0.04502347484230995, 0.016243962571024895, -0.01323525421321392, 0.04727631434798241, -0.022901982069015503, 0.006276644300669432, -0.022279758006334305, 0.01878429390490055, -0.010363040491938591, -0.00241752527654171, -0.035152237862348557, -0.008151303976774216, -0.02635839581489563, -0.011881041340529919, -0.04751195013523102, -0.029363391920924187, 0.02071102149784565, -0.019456638023257256, -0.04630164057016373, 0.028519878163933754, 0.002550943288952112, 0.004323114175349474, -0.0378740020096302, 0.008389720693230629, 0.054759666323661804, -0.008823909796774387, -0.0268496572971344, 0.025173960253596306, -0.008847936987876892, -0.002209907863289118, 0.0113889891654253, 0.014825002290308475, -0.050482377409935, -0.017275754362344742, -0.05342453345656395, 0.05407571792602539, 0.021993866190314293, -0.043218791484832764, -0.013062341138720512, 0.013287773355841637, 0.010101075284183025, -0.0029950898606330156, 0.02471872605383396, 0.032894909381866455, 0.021285274997353554, -0.03416544571518898, -0.030186371877789497, -0.015302998945116997, 0.00672386446967721, -0.007664570584893227, -0.004505396354943514, 0.060116495937108994, -0.001196604804135859, -0.03577618673443794, -0.03562718257308006, 0.045326266437768936, 0.0035410095006227493, 0.017042815685272217, -0.008498662151396275, -0.013903398998081684, -0.013130925595760345, 0.007066909223794937, 0.04185650870203972, -0.005928572732955217, 0.0049124304205179214, 0.002848217263817787, 0.011432516388595104, -0.040813248604536057, -0.04292836785316467, 0.02858683280646801, -0.031261030584573746, -0.003518862882629037, -0.037728726863861084, -0.01684819906949997, -0.00970001146197319, 0.02604253590106964, 0.02419431135058403, 0.006558358669281006, 0.022078415378928185, 0.05444609001278877, 0.03154563903808594, -0.0467446893453598, -0.009008532389998436, 0.019004110246896744, -0.04143465682864189, -0.01185621041804552, 0.014528799802064896, 0.07102009654045105, 0.035164836794137955, 0.036399006843566895, -0.004396421369165182, 0.02263767085969448, -0.017685208469629288, 0.0076618739403784275, 0.033147383481264114, -0.03897099196910858, -0.018876098096370697, 0.026550574228167534, 0.018206361681222916, -0.004074253141880035, 0.0038959651719778776, -0.038812849670648575, -0.06811080873012543, 0.006868959870189428, 0.0017072672490030527, -0.006412875838577747, 0.04220641776919365, -0.01685178279876709, 0.0029394160956144333, -0.03928188607096672, 0.003448037663474679, -0.05792047083377838, 0.01328703761100769, 0.0037534029688686132, -0.012154602445662022, -0.01523134857416153, -0.005528734531253576, -0.016355376690626144, 0.03488533943891525, 0.04862820357084274, 0.03638429939746857, 0.04260874167084694, -0.03342878445982933, 0.040955256670713425, -0.008487203158438206, 0.04831995815038681, -0.03615451231598854, 0.005080807022750378, 0.04431472718715668, -0.03562912717461586, -0.016994593665003777, -0.002919208724051714, 0.012256667017936707, 0.04206596314907074, 0.008775091730058193, -0.005249106325209141, -0.045130472630262375, 0.052517119795084, -0.016879674047231674, -0.0010154988849535584, -0.01386489812284708, -0.00520057138055563, 0.01247877161949873, -0.04145638272166252, 0.01950222998857498, -0.0010569693986326456, -0.0028763709124177694, 0.008797094225883484, 0.06074457988142967, -0.030135663226246834, 0.04867556691169739, 0.014837943017482758, 0.0005592352245002985, 0.03495998680591583, -0.004593537654727697, -0.004769984167069197, 0.023282695561647415, 0.03341836854815483, -0.02549474686384201, 0.04605313390493393, -0.0069465646520257, 0.0408819206058979, -0.08629202097654343, -0.04378686845302582, -0.009356869384646416, 0.021395863965153694, 0.04930459335446358, -0.04430566728115082, -0.022322004660964012, 0.035880327224731445, -0.03389173001050949, -0.0018688454292714596, -0.014906025491654873, 0.005579072050750256, -0.011893090792000294, -0.0024471008218824863, -0.0037825950421392918, 0.010244847275316715, 0.03377600759267807, 0.03436679393053055, 0.03973937779664993, 0.06150120496749878, 0.02299809828400612, -0.035359129309654236, -0.001693817786872387, 0.0043438030406832695, 0.025933733209967613, -0.052718665450811386, 0.03738844394683838, -0.03781888261437416, 0.001429824042133987, 0.0019035378936678171, 0.001504532527178526, 0.04578177630901337, 0.023908937349915504, 0.020152591168880463, 0.019223380833864212, 0.0543876513838768, 0.017126895487308502, 0.039814967662096024, -0.023145604878664017, -0.002629491500556469, 0.024301249533891678, 0.02306729555130005, -0.007346753496676683, -0.00529404217377305, 0.017693959176540375, 0.019051527604460716, -0.03372384235262871, 0.04312639310956001, -0.011878209188580513, -0.0035442078951746225, 0.044699616730213165, 0.012950215488672256, -0.03793474659323692, -0.041284412145614624, -0.010117853060364723, -0.055731553584337234, -0.024019546806812286, 0.02689419314265251, 0.03678348660469055, -0.019385041669011116, 0.026539407670497894, -0.020952552556991577, -0.04292738437652588, 0.0464455746114254, -0.04964755102992058, -0.004579052794724703, -0.0653059333562851, 0.02648478001356125, -0.005400759633630514, -0.028392368927598, -0.0009391623316332698, -0.006471655331552029, -0.06837567687034607, 0.015976350754499435, 0.007281267549842596, -0.03161638230085373, 0.007041549775749445, -0.012792467139661312, 0.039987120777368546, -0.11839238554239273, 0.029721762984991074, 0.02078183740377426, -0.04572637006640434, -0.02742757461965084, -0.00898333452641964, -0.029743827879428864, 0.024829233065247536, 0.034830592572689056, 0.026960859075188637, -0.0053239804692566395, 0.009110338054597378, 0.04416896775364876, 0.00705945398658514, -0.04675497114658356, 0.07052507996559143, -0.011301831342279911, -0.006732997950166464, -0.005865947809070349, 0.00604018522426486, -0.00011523764987941831, 0.026296226307749748, 0.04583323001861572, 0.01660340651869774, 0.04073036089539528, 0.018719617277383804, -0.003933225758373737, 0.041316647082567215, 0.015072791837155819, -0.026478394865989685, 0.04796946421265602, 0.006531084887683392, 0.01594531536102295, 0.05836565047502518, -0.003239241661503911, -0.06892441213130951, -0.03825122490525246, -0.03385317698121071, -0.027514860033988953, 0.0024567339569330215, -0.0008501719566993415, -0.00893053226172924, -0.06686944514513016, 0.02552131563425064, 0.02361433580517769, -0.013661624863743782, -0.011186586692929268, 0.04136550426483154, 0.056042686104774475, 0.02972985990345478, 0.013609984889626503, 0.024039484560489655, -0.021444112062454224, -0.05092219263315201, 0.009752742946147919, -0.007331723812967539, 0.05441827327013016, -0.01802920550107956, 0.01510431058704853, 0.04316949099302292, -0.007953437976539135, 0.022582417353987694, -0.003993496298789978, 0.007235580123960972, -0.03340592607855797, 0.005716335028409958, 0.011682721786201, -0.022521641105413437, 0.03743380308151245, 0.0028894981369376183, 0.019842449575662613, 0.06320863217115402, -0.07979731261730194, 0.00042817997746169567, -0.02545808255672455, -0.009849783033132553, -0.03610089048743248, 0.015729665756225586, -0.01776309683918953, -0.002578267827630043, 0.016645854339003563, 0.019641011953353882, 0.0022960787173360586, 0.005570958834141493, 0.009141534566879272, 0.02287554368376732, 0.002266035648062825, -0.012261655181646347, -0.030458591878414154, -0.04129793867468834, -0.04338596388697624, 0.00748916482552886, -0.04889237880706787, -0.004023325629532337, 0.06311231106519699, 0.00034985950333066285, -0.07323484122753143, -0.030818846076726913, -0.02825191617012024, 0.07704479992389679, -0.054235536605119705, -0.02806662581861019, -0.005350523628294468, 0.03496331721544266, -0.014030929654836655, -0.06815963238477707 ]
<p>If I have an arima object like <code>a</code>:</p> <pre><code>set.seed(100) x1 &lt;- cumsum(runif(100)) x2 &lt;- c(rnorm(25, 20), rep(0, 75)) x3 &lt;- x1 + x2 dummy = c(rep(1, 25), rep(0, 75)) a &lt;- arima(x3, order=c(0, 1, 0), xreg=dummy) print(a) </code></pre> <p>.</p> <pre><code>Series: x3 ARIMA(0,1,0) Call: arima(x = x3, order = c(0, 1, 0), xreg = dummy) Coefficients: dummy 17.7665 s.e. 1.1434 sigma^2 estimated as 1.307: log likelihood = -153.74 AIC = 311.48 AICc = 311.6 BIC = 316.67 </code></pre> <p>How do calculate the R squared of this regression?</p>
74,275
[ -0.0020767957903444767, 0.01219111867249012, -0.03799210861325264, -0.012129595503211021, 0.00985816027969122, 0.017042633146047592, -0.006586879026144743, -0.016943374648690224, 0.026616211980581284, -0.02883221209049225, 0.026942195370793343, 0.025257466360926628, 0.0646427646279335, -0.01680476777255535, 0.046855226159095764, -0.0024570273235440254, 0.007893195375800133, 0.0028119338676333427, 0.018911857157945633, -0.002560108434408903, 0.010902675800025463, -0.0086903665214777, 0.013351015746593475, 0.0029212450608611107, -0.006884684320539236, 0.050355419516563416, 0.04135263338685036, -0.010884830728173256, 0.0012119626626372337, 0.07768597453832626, -0.048819780349731445, -0.016926787793636322, 0.035124655812978745, 0.019212836399674416, 0.03165268898010254, 0.04073508456349373, 0.03302589803934097, -0.019232667982578278, -0.014107998460531235, 0.03119417279958725, 0.016336515545845032, -0.01326325535774231, 0.02977984957396984, 0.043172165751457214, -0.011569248512387276, 0.01106875017285347, -0.006309843622148037, 0.00496523967012763, 0.059865277260541916, -0.03811631351709366, 0.05961219221353531, -0.02212853729724884, 0.049654196947813034, 0.03874080255627632, -0.043558213859796524, 0.015583492815494537, 0.06764940172433853, 0.04348738491535187, -0.039722125977277756, -0.06991364061832428, -0.016776543110609055, -0.03565086051821709, 0.00010653991921572015, -0.034169163554906845, -0.04660497233271599, -0.00828845240175724, -0.0013210793258622289, -0.024778852239251137, 0.030558740720152855, -0.01277304906398058, 0.03866654634475708, 0.01711307093501091, 0.02531789429485798, -0.02457309514284134, 0.01629558578133583, -0.03499574959278107, -0.00864946749061346, -0.0016033598221838474, 0.04348091036081314, 0.017906902357935905, -0.00833811890333891, 0.03148538991808891, 0.029894918203353882, 0.0109718544408679, 0.04406564310193062, 0.035260166972875595, 0.05280861631035805, -0.0168557520955801, 0.03534640371799469, 0.015766965225338936, 0.0012469965731725097, 0.0037451896350830793, 0.02104661799967289, 0.009515331126749516, -0.035840269178152084, 0.030221406370401382, -0.015113956294953823, 0.0500013493001461, -0.0012227384140715003, -0.013532426208257675, -0.04560624435544014, -0.031142938882112503, 0.00673068268224597, 0.016932008787989616, -0.021864475682377815, 0.008593232370913029, -0.025977255776524544, -0.000021725092665292323, 0.02849675342440605, -0.07621977478265762, -0.03385671228170395, 0.008298438973724842, -0.029844434931874275, -0.023885995149612427, -0.006262804381549358, -0.032836686819791794, -0.04388696327805519, 0.0170430950820446, 0.03984025865793228, 0.03347928076982498, 0.02745727263391018, 0.006006163544952869, 0.019650466740131378, -0.029463468119502068, -0.027539055794477463, 0.019987598061561584, -0.025697413831949234, -0.01857181452214718, -0.05279301851987839, 0.041297562420368195, -0.030409075319767, -0.03893867880105972, 0.007936432026326656, 0.0006733483169227839, 0.02401016093790531, -0.000039032402128214017, -0.06535002589225769, -0.04186031222343445, 0.030749592930078506, -0.015059255994856358, 0.012331307865679264, -0.04032376408576965, 0.04209209606051445, 0.05622265860438347, 0.06097482144832611, 0.01874585449695587, 0.02130732499063015, 0.02469714917242527, 0.008546932600438595, 0.0038690126966685057, -0.04356715455651283, -0.01386768277734518, -0.04379463195800781, -0.018770596012473106, -0.0028416593559086323, -0.06299623101949692, -0.0042126071639359, 0.0017357656033709645, -0.023653924465179443, -0.015839746221899986, 0.06004547327756882, 0.023089617490768433, -0.023821832612156868, 0.021957620978355408, -0.05338062718510628, -0.023348933085799217, 0.09242180734872818, 0.032933592796325684, -0.02126484364271164, 0.012104635126888752, -0.01259579136967659, 0.005561262834817171, -0.016717268154025078, 0.050742123275995255, 0.09168241173028946, -0.030037598684430122, 0.014544738456606865, -0.011101530864834785, 0.033972859382629395, 0.029316628351807594, -0.08830706775188446, -0.004170786589384079, -0.03265415132045746, -0.02582152560353279, 0.0005746436072513461, 0.03269195184111595, -0.014776626601815224, -0.014900140464305878, 0.06518904864788055, -0.07412534207105637, 0.0022178597282618284, -0.0616387203335762, 0.006856725551187992, 0.016438523307442665, -0.008768100291490555, -0.028597867116332054, 0.03645762801170349, 0.03600439056754112, 0.028495369479060173, -0.03167196735739708, -0.013446016237139702, -0.005446505267173052, 0.05416174605488777, -0.019883356988430023, -0.008346240036189556, 0.030507005751132965, 0.053618572652339935, -0.02368748001754284, 0.06377989053726196, -0.024575185030698776, 0.0006465960759669542, 0.030957000330090523, -0.037324920296669006, -0.011863707564771175, -0.021949656307697296, -0.017039434984326363, -0.011984029784798622, -0.0040824622847139835, 0.015704737976193428, 0.0363745242357254, -0.05591796711087227, 0.031379926949739456, 0.04697413370013237, 0.041597187519073486, -0.00957751926034689, -0.01005730964243412, 0.002057956298813224, 0.020089851692318916, -0.036032576113939285, -0.008418135344982147, -0.02234470285475254, -0.006096310913562775, 0.019403494894504547, 0.0074800667352974415, -0.01657344400882721, 0.004022281151264906, 0.06254144012928009, 0.012765509076416492, 0.0070259906351566315, 0.06943373382091522, 0.008911040611565113, -0.003973670303821564, 0.027276339009404182, -0.01688847877085209, -0.003982711583375931, 0.008305414579808712, 0.028160415589809418, 0.0409022681415081, 0.025651728734374046, 0.024637693539261818, -0.016030754894018173, 0.049244873225688934, -0.010085519403219223, -0.02077498473227024, -0.03394879400730133, -0.002994644222781062, 0.0631549209356308, -0.02334050089120865, -0.00424679322168231, 0.011042916215956211, 0.020838171243667603, -0.022822752594947815, -0.003954646177589893, 0.001266571693122387, 0.0058007314801216125, 0.030461298301815987, -0.03397436439990997, -0.009715377353131771, 0.00620597368106246, -0.02157711237668991, 0.008541297167539597, -0.019546987488865852, 0.0001429446565452963, -0.0700148269534111, 0.03116217814385891, 0.007385267876088619, 0.005879765842109919, 0.027892397716641426, 0.0034229985903948545, -0.03425601124763489, -0.003340298542752862, -0.009181850589811802, 0.014276477508246899, -0.002995552960783243, -0.03651285916566849, 0.021728798747062683, -0.006828325800597668, -0.037383660674095154, -0.006988431327044964, -0.02089945413172245, -0.03513440117239952, 0.029173390939831734, -0.03506546467542648, -0.021839648485183716, -0.02178068831562996, -0.009406758472323418, -0.0060203648172318935, -0.016380934044718742, -0.012135944329202175, 0.03896792605519295, -0.02320876717567444, -0.01686766743659973, 0.0017038100631907582, -0.06601161509752274, 0.022901449352502823, -0.006235701963305473, 0.005881276912987232, 0.0210624597966671, -0.00006506906356662512, 0.04452516511082649, 0.029673360288143158, -0.0369398295879364, -0.0038401540368795395, -0.04014696180820465, -0.051067110151052475, -0.008107547648251057, 0.02336045168340206, -0.021670697256922722, 0.004724148660898209, -0.03410974144935608, 0.046239349991083145, 0.03820822015404701, -0.04083177074790001, -0.068247951567173, -0.010803049430251122, -0.01345800794661045, -0.055769842118024826, 0.019503064453601837, 0.012650123797357082, -0.013167145662009716, 0.03244369477033615, 0.0018329215236008167, 0.021322760730981827, 0.004588923882693052, -0.007283337414264679, 0.0029558937530964613, 0.01802201382815838, 0.006782774347811937, -0.01830780878663063, 0.03650250658392906, -0.009996765293180943, -0.00926880817860365, 0.02150786854326725, -0.012773867696523666, 0.034479692578315735, 0.009292620234191418, -0.019747523590922356, -0.010186370462179184, -0.011697550304234028, 0.01734175905585289, -0.0185611080378294, 0.046456094831228256, 0.003629880491644144, -0.043755557388067245, 0.009085276164114475, -0.005471623968333006, 0.035022247582674026, -0.024002600461244583, 0.0007528556743636727, 0.030999721959233284, 0.04245823249220848, -0.02258061058819294, -0.011726352386176586, 0.0028454079292714596, 0.003999641630798578, -0.001306392950937152, -0.06198843941092491, -0.018515272065997124, 0.052118394523859024, 0.0032885579857975245, 0.00905996561050415, -0.016159210354089737, -0.026951275765895844, -0.005279531702399254, -0.06591662764549255, 0.015336361713707447, -0.03319849073886871, 0.08000385761260986, 0.005924990866333246, 0.04687322676181793, 0.014280927367508411, -0.0360184945166111, 0.034957997500896454, -0.009218066930770874, -0.07288801670074463, 0.055724311619997025, -0.004813475999981165, -0.05600334703922272, 0.015367439016699791, -0.0012415689416229725, 0.038872357457876205, -0.06892716139554977, 0.01609717682003975, -0.010196004994213581, -0.03161141648888588, -0.031290143728256226, 0.029604045674204826, 0.0029877310153096914, 0.010127900168299675, 0.0030296549666672945, 0.005157787818461657, 0.03532078489661217, -0.005673242267221212, 0.056942202150821686, 0.04987810179591179, -0.02055499702692032, 0.03100729174911976, -0.03824983537197113, 0.017309265211224556, 0.0022747789043933153, 0.03170601278543472, 0.06630745530128479, 0.0012356993975117803, -0.02806147187948227, 0.0376991331577301, -0.012384607456624508, 0.01912352815270424, 0.04095831140875816, 0.0008052809862419963, -0.038568735122680664, 0.010276587679982185, -0.010316072963178158, 0.005316862370818853, -0.009655416011810303, -0.011021772399544716, 0.015751998871564865, 0.0695066899061203, 0.01230909675359726, -0.02075629122555256, 0.010014447383582592, 0.06518639624118805, 0.004747356753796339, -0.02554755099117756, -0.04786452651023865, 0.00402254331856966, 0.015192677266895771, 0.017061175778508186, 0.006324758753180504, -0.0037495179567486048, -0.029227394610643387, -0.012070870958268642, 0.0370776541531086, -0.051512688398361206, -0.012263087555766106, -0.010506734251976013, 0.05554991215467453, 0.05439450591802597, 0.002612479729577899, -0.03275446221232414, 0.0001282852899748832, 0.060446031391620636, 0.015440010465681553, 0.018498821184039116, -0.013223433867096901, -0.07817183434963226, 0.007946755737066269, 0.008998963981866837, 0.026915406808257103, -0.006954489275813103, -0.04639410227537155, -0.040663592517375946, 0.003775024553760886, 0.03090791590511799, -0.04279831051826477, 0.04515335336327553, -0.015281236730515957, 0.041747622191905975, 0.00013614770432468504, -0.028820930048823357, -0.06646586209535599, 0.052963048219680786, -0.03535826504230499, 0.01864430494606495, -0.03127274289727211, -0.03911934047937393, -0.035430729389190674, 0.015139664523303509, -0.002810330595821142, 0.03196655586361885, -0.039650678634643555, -0.011507541872560978, -0.00015699269715696573, 0.047360993921756744, 0.03001324087381363, -0.0030817685183137655, 0.012418903410434723, -0.02027186192572117, -0.03862384334206581, 0.0493670254945755, -0.003999111242592335, -0.005053055938333273, 0.0017168499762192369, 0.01794414035975933, -0.011471365578472614, 0.0067930021323263645, -0.03418013080954552, 0.03621815890073776, 0.04755866900086403, -0.004008217714726925, 0.0713314563035965, 0.021700475364923477, -0.0007870194385759532, -0.01741815358400345, -0.04073604196310043, -0.004397282376885414, 0.0049036419950425625, -0.047307442873716354, -0.03190767392516136, 0.025069814175367355, -0.004365451633930206, 0.022554785013198853, 0.0071135456673800945, 0.01564100757241249, -0.024012284353375435, 0.004250987898558378, 0.006763428449630737, 0.058140356093645096, -0.03624683991074562, -0.018904129043221474, 0.0192254725843668, 0.023135729134082794, -0.02487346902489662, -0.03210444003343582, -0.009181729517877102, -0.025109782814979553, 0.0005048375460319221, 0.010045441798865795, -0.04072680324316025, 0.054877329617738724, 0.028225066140294075, -0.0292194914072752, -0.006712851580232382, -0.03870176896452904, -0.020331917330622673, -0.011156571097671986, 0.01421875786036253, -0.008619527332484722, -0.031656183302402496, 0.014830994419753551, -0.008825207129120827, 0.0020447548013180494, 0.02098994329571724, -0.06235692650079727, 0.045574091374874115, 0.004493622574955225, -0.00910236220806837, -0.07755998522043228, -0.03949122503399849, 0.0081748953089118, -0.005169087555259466, -0.03827371448278427, -0.00976096373051405, 0.010011616162955761, -0.021264268085360527, -0.009119484573602676, -0.022824883460998535, 0.030656076967716217, -0.05404037609696388, -0.001154411002062261, 0.012640438973903656, 0.011718598194420338, 0.059879809617996216, -0.007703191135078669, -0.01730719394981861, 0.031339045614004135, -0.010391498915851116, -0.03087461180984974, 0.059401147067546844, 0.01361841056495905, -0.029185764491558075, 0.017382651567459106, -0.0048124659806489944, -0.027039913460612297, 0.02470811828970909, 0.019680581986904144, -0.026109207421541214, -0.011460955254733562, 0.03662177920341492, 0.01527521200478077, -0.0526643767952919, 0.007696342188864946, 0.005137160420417786, 0.010412226431071758, -0.012261363677680492, -0.026401931419968605, -0.01810290291905403, -0.000646785250864923, -0.01388148870319128, 0.026334308087825775, -0.017324943095445633, 0.028631100431084633, 0.08015836775302887, 0.011516187340021133, -0.010862424038350582, -0.017811041325330734, -0.0020697135478258133, 0.046889420598745346, 0.02220546454191208, 0.010997909121215343, 0.008214524015784264, 0.00672850850969553, -0.027784690260887146, -0.02377333864569664, -0.04133826121687889, 0.0006653069867752492, 0.07923637330532074, -0.051366474479436874, 0.050801072269678116, 0.04561531916260719, 0.017244920134544373, -0.0004226699529681355, -0.017051441594958305, -0.021416788920760155, -0.01933148130774498, 0.002314826939254999, 0.06613118946552277, -0.027645647525787354, -0.006846171338111162, 0.017141344025731087, -0.008367913775146008, -0.00549629470333457, 0.041949499398469925, -0.025319483131170273, 0.022586259990930557, 0.01668311469256878, -0.0012288427678868175, 0.006211286876350641, 0.008153674192726612, -0.006291674915701151, 0.01461709849536419, -0.042114950716495514, -0.00662741856649518, 0.044096317142248154, 0.020281609147787094, 0.022920014336705208, -0.04037892818450928, -0.03859762102365494, -0.04181361198425293, -0.02098376303911209, 0.01691764034330845, -0.012413565069437027, 0.028101211413741112, 0.018388181924819946, 0.010294661857187748, -0.0034886018838733435, 0.058901138603687286, -0.031996894627809525, -0.08314487338066101, -0.050226300954818726, -0.010105515830218792, -0.002824522787705064, 0.06850695610046387, 0.01248979289084673, -0.03045857511460781, 0.021996276453137398, -0.0555393248796463, 0.038870152086019516, 0.009091232903301716, 0.03944579139351845, 0.017526263371109962, 0.10333381593227386, -0.02078964002430439, 0.017569785937666893, -0.012739479541778564, -0.011983772739768028, 0.09153013676404953, 0.08171384036540985, 0.027734333649277687, -0.06511026620864868, 0.015497478656470776, 0.007565806154161692, -0.0017875180346891284, -0.010919173248112202, -0.03247712552547455, 0.021943435072898865, 0.013801181688904762, 0.07545030862092972, 0.055582109838724136, 0.014629805460572243, 0.00943036563694477, 0.014955525286495686, -0.051823634654283524, -0.025107726454734802, -0.03185752406716347, 0.041070710867643356, 0.01323856133967638, -0.017043227329850197, -0.07295886427164078, 0.006372436881065369, -0.009838879108428955, -0.03839399293065071, -0.039967671036720276, 0.023229986429214478, -0.028690766543149948, -0.012200528755784035, -0.02888362668454647, 0.03190828114748001, 0.017647337168455124, 0.021480072289705276, 0.011822665110230446, 0.017175478860735893, 0.029027752578258514, 0.003862570971250534, -0.008526242338120937, 0.039511583745479584, 0.002930769929662347, -0.008509604260325432, 0.016055351123213768, 0.022499553859233856, -0.05323876440525055, -0.01871800795197487, -0.019545644521713257, 0.024336978793144226, -0.04006398096680641, -0.022622624412178993, -0.009909453801810741, 0.03608321771025658, -0.0025586734991520643, -0.02059435471892357, -0.0035120167303830385, 0.04219580814242363, -0.0002517958637326956, -0.022921010851860046, -0.04223980754613876, 0.013710605911910534, 0.01977616176009178, -0.010506104677915573, 0.05402370169758797, 0.0227548535913229, -0.06819703429937363, -0.024797724559903145, -0.044771116226911545, 0.05441432073712349, -0.04803326353430748, 0.0027587288059294224, 0.0333983339369297, -0.01516502071171999, -0.041589152067899704, -0.02123533934354782, 0.04100193455815315, -0.005059345159679651, -0.0001670197962084785, -0.016202427446842194, -0.0006005102186463773, 0.003713504644110799, -0.003069733502343297, -0.016181079670786858, -0.07228893786668777, 0.01104586198925972, -0.05180545523762703, -0.026846101507544518, 0.06324376910924911, 0.014524783939123154, 0.047995805740356445, 0.010955392383038998, -0.02401021495461464, 0.05117043852806091, 0.015276221558451653, -0.04684724286198616, -0.019601549953222275, 0.04265735670924187, -0.05235766991972923, -0.025792429223656654, 0.010623013600707054, 0.06662743538618088, 0.029346538707613945, 0.011819247156381607, -0.02885896898806095, 0.028269486501812935, -0.04596225172281265, 0.008841457776725292, 0.02308361418545246, -0.011762889102101326, 0.005402697715908289, 0.023090127855539322, -0.00998667348176241, -0.054033663123846054, 0.0010125162079930305, -0.053177330642938614, -0.057301633059978485, 0.0100470632314682, 0.015515783801674843, -0.05124669522047043, 0.05459725111722946, 0.0001699325512163341, 0.010532533749938011, -0.03166339546442032, 0.024357376620173454, -0.035497039556503296, -0.023035800084471703, -0.006671962793916464, -0.03724149987101555, -0.016198312863707542, 0.010740264318883419, -0.05499737337231636, -0.0016350490041077137, 0.040437206625938416, -0.008834163658320904, 0.015492971986532211, -0.012465634383261204, 0.008073057979345322, -0.023348573595285416, 0.04948519542813301, -0.032753005623817444, -0.041004300117492676, -0.001352572231553495, -0.055431559681892395, -0.02313099056482315, 0.026517048478126526, -0.011400027200579643, 0.06095476448535919, 0.006361526437103748, -0.010497331619262695, -0.018250368535518646, 0.049965839833021164, -0.009549522772431374, -0.00021929752256255597, -0.017074337229132652, 0.002732250140979886, 0.014492733404040337, -0.010751673020422459, 0.005804453976452351, -0.023607870563864708, 0.0010735277319326997, 0.037401217967271805, 0.09139496088027954, -0.017236879095435143, 0.03058771602809429, 0.01014846470206976, 0.018732905387878418, -0.007475704420357943, 0.012582413852214813, -0.014924339950084686, 0.03060142882168293, 0.015027512796223164, -0.01741686277091503, 0.04513780400156975, -0.028246983885765076, 0.029493506997823715, -0.0597718171775341, -0.019235795363783836, 0.0034455859567970037, 0.0010811310494318604, 0.04581812769174576, -0.05308964103460312, 0.0024592436384409666, 0.00570349907502532, -0.012092757038772106, 0.015419668518006802, -0.001997358165681362, 0.010655075311660767, -0.011437936685979366, 0.03439818322658539, 0.022334299981594086, 0.02373809926211834, 0.04044555500149727, 0.025390036404132843, 0.057886507362127304, -0.0036769008729606867, 0.021919313818216324, -0.008437717333436012, 0.0030017737299203873, 0.008030064404010773, -0.0014477736549451947, -0.047943614423274994, 0.05606875196099281, -0.042234789580106735, -0.000775927328504622, 0.02532530017197132, -0.0324939526617527, 0.04121805727481842, 0.016845116391777992, 0.03349287062883377, 0.013723470270633698, 0.017708778381347656, 0.007330600172281265, -0.020837944000959396, -0.014836486428976059, 0.021673498675227165, 0.026387788355350494, 0.03216219320893288, -0.04079177975654602, 0.02017235942184925, -0.005263672675937414, 0.029904523864388466, -0.002767140045762062, 0.01974358968436718, -0.013725373893976212, -0.004842862486839294, -0.027124084532260895, 0.003499483224004507, -0.028622254729270935, -0.0291233379393816, 0.005716299172490835, -0.03387818858027458, 0.04380880296230316, 0.023888159543275833, 0.05024757608771324, -0.031161988154053688, 0.005227849818766117, -0.034382596611976624, -0.03662079572677612, 0.033672209829092026, -0.02068696916103363, -0.0032650092616677284, -0.04293188825249672, -0.042218949645757675, 0.03884465619921684, -0.015185113996267319, -0.020953012630343437, -0.0058282907120883465, -0.038170769810676575, 0.009879792109131813, 0.0059056770987808704, -0.01111643947660923, 0.04425215348601341, 0.00458822725340724, 0.03598051518201828, -0.10037373006343842, 0.04007668048143387, 0.011228565126657486, -0.017128851264715195, -0.021816985681653023, -0.0015799750108271837, -0.03890255093574524, 0.02373311296105385, 0.041159119457006454, 0.019345028325915337, 0.0019284182926639915, -0.007327882573008537, 0.03973015397787094, -0.011495111510157585, -0.004271695856004953, 0.044453658163547516, 0.030198337510228157, -0.016920998692512512, -0.03265714272856712, -0.021389219909906387, 0.021605027839541435, 0.008020810782909393, 0.010904727503657341, 0.02085951529443264, 0.014642665162682533, -0.012468405067920685, -0.036423761397600174, 0.028448637574911118, -0.03148037940263748, -0.0012203743681311607, 0.053338244557380676, 0.004116951022297144, -0.018049485981464386, 0.08982867002487183, 0.010517393238842487, -0.05117921531200409, 0.03507488965988159, -0.005955013446509838, -0.005275172647088766, 0.021731726825237274, -0.03209713473916054, 0.02432829886674881, -0.030383054167032242, 0.013459436595439911, 0.030808236449956894, -0.037069112062454224, -0.00837576761841774, 0.03200095519423485, 0.012182896956801414, 0.035050179809331894, -0.009741349145770073, 0.019750749692320824, 0.009740300476551056, -0.016335153952240944, -0.018466155976057053, -0.0019265508744865656, 0.023747066035866737, -0.02496873214840889, 0.014194177463650703, 0.020001031458377838, -0.05086545646190643, 0.012462090700864792, -0.04092792421579361, 0.05672642961144447, -0.036611516028642654, -0.017869733273983, 0.020814107730984688, -0.03307823836803436, 0.0548974834382534, -0.01127191074192524, 0.0049042548052966595, 0.053300678730010986, -0.03829383850097656, -0.03051399439573288, -0.0047552925534546375, -0.008119053207337856, -0.047678712755441666, 0.0013045610394328833, 0.017341308295726776, 0.022852394729852676, -0.016203993931412697, 0.020650288090109825, 0.005240225233137608, -0.04226835444569588, 0.008326463401317596, -0.016821201890707016, -0.02018710970878601, -0.009316994808614254, 0.006800288800150156, -0.05812137946486473, -0.02937289886176586, 0.015211384743452072, -0.05071453005075455, 0.03018970787525177, 0.026135416701436043, 0.029389172792434692, -0.05130074918270111, -0.04308628290891647, -0.029141591861844063, 0.044040579348802567, -0.06718872487545013, -0.01427198015153408, -0.007095347624272108, 0.03219533711671829, -0.015620262362062931, -0.05293537303805351 ]
<p>I want to perform quadrat count analysis on several point processes (or one marked point process), to then apply some dimensionality reduction techniques.</p> <p>The marks are not identically distributed, i.e. some marks are appearing quite often, and some are pretty rare. Thus, I cannot simply divide my 2D space in a regular grid, because the more frequent marks will "overwhelm" the lesser frequent ones, masking their appearance.</p> <p>Thus, I tried to build my grid such that each cell has at most N points in it (to do so, I simply divide each cell in four smaller (and equally sized) cells, recursively, until no cell has more than N points in it). </p> <p>What do you think of this "normalization" technique ? Is there a standard way to do such things ?</p>
37,087
[ 0.006659303791821003, -0.020012466236948967, 0.011168398894369602, -0.028777526691555977, 0.03396265581250191, -0.003619652008637786, -0.01484537310898304, -0.03960306942462921, 0.03457554429769516, -0.010580181144177914, 0.04590890556573868, 0.011302455328404903, 0.0581846609711647, 0.014940713532269001, 0.03778431937098503, -0.03605636954307556, -0.004149732645601034, -0.022069478407502174, -0.01974462904036045, -0.07328268885612488, -0.01706688664853573, 0.0388115718960762, 0.03972122445702553, -0.02116374857723713, -0.03824640437960625, 0.03195884823799133, 0.028994480147957802, 0.02112424373626709, 0.01081366278231144, 0.059533920139074326, -0.035560790449380875, 0.0008662189356982708, 0.015172330662608147, 0.043496228754520416, 0.03300980478525162, 0.00597189599648118, -0.009033944457769394, -0.014628689736127853, 0.014353339560329914, 0.02496456727385521, -0.010271558538079262, -0.013348943553864956, -0.013234070502221584, 0.04197324067354202, 0.014492087997496128, 0.016158483922481537, -0.005231167655438185, -0.01893237791955471, 0.054749857634305954, -0.034373536705970764, 0.07885638624429703, 0.002858964493498206, 0.025959938764572144, 0.012500187382102013, 0.012118658982217312, -0.011949721723794937, 0.043351881206035614, 0.05254184454679489, -0.014193231239914894, -0.033021021634340286, 0.008024112321436405, -0.030258862301707268, -0.028811829164624214, -0.010707393288612366, -0.0058182114735245705, -0.0001822576450649649, -0.026822015643119812, -0.021964769810438156, 0.02547033689916134, -0.040553897619247437, 0.001043436350300908, 0.01991371624171734, 0.02901843748986721, -0.049619682133197784, -0.00425409572198987, -0.010344772599637508, 0.04490488022565842, 0.019567200914025307, 0.017979783937335014, -0.0035149389877915382, 0.05257458612322807, 0.03247978910803795, 0.0020482309628278017, 0.006499514915049076, 0.013375537469983101, -0.021537378430366516, 0.042088259011507034, -0.05766706541180611, 0.010089431889355183, 0.04606456682085991, -0.01641419529914856, -0.005331802181899548, 0.06704771518707275, 0.00945201888680458, -0.06712882965803146, 0.010823282413184643, 0.009183233603835106, 0.022711316123604774, -0.008097113110125065, -0.009459691122174263, -0.06336543709039688, -0.052805379033088684, -0.0009422069997526705, 0.03380707651376724, -0.030849026516079903, 0.025295093655586243, -0.02799837663769722, 0.01719721034169197, -0.02488766238093376, 0.0012729009613394737, -0.021687215194106102, 0.03272077441215515, 0.019662003964185715, -0.015483002178370953, 0.026659907773137093, -0.0005475438665598631, 0.003911749925464392, -0.011659580282866955, 0.0235501267015934, 0.09229724109172821, 0.01822889782488346, -0.0428144671022892, 0.04260068014264107, -0.05990232527256012, -0.08434494584798813, 0.03964579850435257, 0.0059044542722404, -0.00026412279112264514, -0.042642347514629364, 0.0471484437584877, -0.0031235534697771072, 0.01795072667300701, 0.04408524930477142, -0.03685406595468521, 0.041104160249233246, -0.0014341234927996993, -0.0624849870800972, -0.027464309707283974, 0.07004307955503464, -0.011467491276562214, 0.005657440051436424, -0.05973707512021065, -0.00746313389390707, 0.013052597641944885, 0.06041312962770462, 0.005656386259943247, 0.00384900183416903, 0.03081781044602394, 0.030451184138655663, 0.011325721628963947, -0.03423164412379265, -0.0024784293491393328, -0.015260358341038227, -0.047578372061252594, -0.007006005849689245, -0.05306839197874069, 0.04094886779785156, 0.017993614077568054, -0.010400793515145779, 0.018239710479974747, 0.014833210036158562, 0.03442179411649704, -0.01846401020884514, 0.003449736861512065, 0.02261482924222946, -0.01042222511023283, 0.05932922288775444, -0.032214052975177765, 0.04645368456840515, 0.01243041455745697, -0.014561738818883896, 0.03916708752512932, 0.02475116215646267, 0.05427004024386406, 0.03909939154982567, -0.016751611605286598, 0.015670740976929665, -0.00043337969691492617, 0.00940662994980812, 0.011562274768948555, -0.03772997111082077, -0.019253045320510864, -0.016618898138403893, 0.042087946087121964, 0.05218794569373131, 0.02130698785185814, 0.024547645822167397, -0.026909014210104942, 0.027132945135235786, -0.05241537466645241, -0.0614660307765007, -0.05144750699400902, -0.0036735401954501867, -0.0149476183578372, -0.020347045734524727, 0.007803060580044985, -0.03983168303966522, -0.0128520792350173, -0.003958872985094786, -0.07651382684707642, -0.034550223499536514, -0.006832720246165991, 0.007951311767101288, -0.09954126179218292, -0.026037417352199554, 0.0661231279373169, 0.021243996918201447, -0.00962098315358162, 0.067584328353405, -0.041446998715400696, -0.009344852529466152, -0.049534086138010025, -0.02419210597872734, 0.026548558846116066, -0.035840120166540146, -0.013319713994860649, 0.028512295335531235, 0.03222665563225746, -0.03410734981298447, 0.014932336285710335, -0.08315529674291611, 0.05213168263435364, 0.056240811944007874, -0.028326017782092094, -0.028575126081705093, -0.025881672278046608, 0.006016595289111137, -0.013465330936014652, -0.009768093936145306, -0.021573081612586975, -0.05258990451693535, 0.013951306231319904, 0.05530213937163353, 0.0200513806194067, -0.026988830417394638, 0.0007980511290952563, 0.0712481215596199, 0.033761557191610336, 0.007487923838198185, 0.030677275732159615, -0.006942646577954292, 0.008257501758635044, 0.013641146942973137, -0.002162318443879485, 0.03890429064631462, -0.003160137217491865, -0.0015131314285099506, -0.01607832871377468, -0.02330820821225643, -0.021247604861855507, -0.047743648290634155, 0.007053477689623833, 0.012181207537651062, 0.040404364466667175, -0.011537420563399792, -0.012444188818335533, 0.026963885873556137, 0.0011122998548671603, 0.00938976090401411, 0.04089023917913437, -0.004675663076341152, 0.006048739887773991, -0.0018289957661181688, -0.022146206349134445, -0.009581691585481167, 0.04293985664844513, -0.017384901642799377, 0.01728484034538269, 0.02463354356586933, -0.0209870096296072, 0.031759630888700485, -0.056069958955049515, -0.043761853128671646, -0.03392701596021652, 0.003972466103732586, 0.05126699432730675, 0.019053606316447258, 0.05094985291361809, -0.07826399058103561, -0.013558348640799522, 0.0050944010727107525, -0.0034916284494102, 0.02324214205145836, 0.03703013062477112, -0.03492157533764839, -0.008752341382205486, -0.008320683613419533, -0.03579389676451683, 0.033147428184747696, 0.020163631066679955, -0.014276576228439808, -0.0015118737937882543, -0.02403920702636242, -0.029647188261151314, -0.002432707929983735, -0.027845051139593124, 0.02892042137682438, -0.018612850457429886, -0.007343347650021315, 0.06046797335147858, 0.06122373044490814, -0.0583464540541172, 0.0053047253750264645, -0.03449534252285957, -0.02342907525599003, -0.06981156021356583, -0.005056767724454403, 0.02282443642616272, -0.01906510628759861, -0.008922400884330273, 0.050859738141298294, -0.044367093592882156, 0.015118169598281384, -0.006479223258793354, -0.04997193440794945, -0.005296363495290279, -0.031193198636174202, 0.041851360350847244, 0.00449724867939949, -0.030008463189005852, 0.0677899718284607, 0.02328811213374138, -0.02234070748090744, -0.03731726482510567, -0.005715387407690287, -0.04821579158306122, 0.005200236104428768, 0.02909117378294468, -0.013193703256547451, -0.022477297112345695, 0.00939802173525095, 0.006541654001921415, 0.04433606564998627, 0.06509831547737122, -0.02111419104039669, -0.024897485971450806, 0.004064369015395641, 0.013458055444061756, 0.009975611232221127, 0.020549021661281586, 0.01914423331618309, -0.014161289669573307, -0.009690425358712673, -0.01502087153494358, -0.005342262797057629, 0.06533109396696091, -0.037488680332899094, -0.017594024538993835, -0.04116896167397499, 0.04096677154302597, -0.005088494624942541, 0.006327393464744091, 0.008454062044620514, -0.034015387296676636, -0.015056109987199306, 0.034192755818367004, 0.049595579504966736, -0.008605667389929295, -0.012558385729789734, 0.023838864639401436, 0.07915680855512619, -0.003681366564705968, 0.034631457179784775, -0.020621350035071373, 0.005211954470723867, 0.012370255775749683, -0.04018128290772438, -0.03844066709280014, 0.03068062849342823, 0.03983321040868759, 0.016146894544363022, 0.01930919848382473, -0.02997407130897045, 0.012997156009078026, -0.03857409954071045, -0.009593253955245018, -0.03988700360059738, 0.04364248737692833, 0.01682334765791893, 0.021082350984215736, 0.005576616618782282, -0.04897519573569298, -0.005372230429202318, 0.01960619166493416, -0.09775912016630173, -0.027957528829574585, 0.00013801129534840584, 0.018739724531769753, 0.008780548349022865, -0.022326475009322166, 0.003963865805417299, 0.0028552606236189604, -0.00572959054261446, 0.016449658200144768, 0.02855423465371132, -0.08017957955598831, 0.010360080748796463, -0.0419287383556366, -0.0008208724320866168, -0.040905121713876724, 0.021365799009799957, 0.03859477490186691, -0.020925553515553474, 0.016728825867176056, 0.014902928844094276, -0.02743089385330677, -0.02487782947719097, -0.02150978147983551, 0.008187757804989815, 0.05476895719766617, 0.011278223246335983, -0.03833608329296112, 0.031030338257551193, -0.029887238517403603, 0.0003231002192478627, -0.007993160746991634, 0.061212703585624695, 0.016617588698863983, 0.004669138230383396, 0.021780280396342278, -0.04908223822712898, -0.019232163205742836, 0.014542280696332455, 0.05159527063369751, 0.0008005061536096036, 0.009926614351570606, -0.0014010550221428275, 0.018623383715748787, -0.07535484433174133, -0.008699352853000164, 0.07464168220758438, 0.018176889047026634, 0.010371612384915352, -0.04576695337891579, 0.006635595578700304, 0.030415348708629608, 0.018517807126045227, 0.003639630042016506, 0.005765470210462809, 0.024584032595157623, 0.0033168320078402758, 0.028101319447159767, -0.013207637704908848, -0.02060660533607006, 0.005946409422904253, -0.01885000430047512, 0.006522182375192642, -0.05931255593895912, 0.009470305405557156, 0.039400484412908554, -0.005856954026967287, 0.023637166246771812, 0.060608163475990295, -0.02347736433148384, -0.10335248708724976, -0.009442855603992939, 0.053627271205186844, 0.04661305993795395, 0.03306523710489273, -0.019998444244265556, -0.006147971376776695, -0.05600438266992569, 0.054145604372024536, -0.02563067153096199, -0.029958494007587433, -0.010022756643593311, 0.0020170763600617647, -0.04205578938126564, 0.0051225717179477215, -0.030908754095435143, -0.016380157321691513, -0.011799594387412071, 0.06567851454019547, 0.01758299022912979, -0.030381686985492706, -0.06299670785665512, 0.037787944078445435, -0.007559265475720167, 0.027560481801629066, -0.008956363424658775, -0.025182213634252548, -0.015968525782227516, 0.0028006997890770435, -0.04199139028787613, -0.05123760551214218, -0.007270835805684328, 0.04612065106630325, 0.0264434777200222, 0.06139659136533737, 0.006857072934508324, -0.0320223793387413, -0.00015278089267667383, -0.004844160750508308, -0.01958371140062809, -0.013853083364665508, 0.002787374658510089, 0.03779863938689232, 0.027614004909992218, -0.0017061012331396341, 0.04709409922361374, 0.019986921921372414, -0.009738541208207607, 0.02190052531659603, -0.032047878950834274, 0.020248841494321823, -0.02369551919400692, 0.012086695060133934, -0.05092243105173111, 0.011434618383646011, 0.004554594401270151, -0.003873493056744337, -0.0003282236575614661, 0.02691742032766342, -0.03257382661104202, -0.029724834486842155, -0.023850059136748314, 0.017648769542574883, 0.017461780458688736, 0.008395879529416561, -0.02667466551065445, 0.05610667169094086, 0.02827003411948681, -0.023322248831391335, 0.006142770871520042, -0.013511434197425842, -0.007255564909428358, -0.006386128719896078, -0.0027479780837893486, -0.013311023823916912, -0.0585363432765007, -0.00012511319073382765, 0.015210093930363655, -0.04508676379919052, 0.0692698061466217, -0.0033304113894701004, 0.05055265501141548, 0.00111724017187953, -0.042031459510326385, -0.006170936860144138, 0.005792980547994375, -0.0005450734752230346, 0.0393688939511776, -0.04110713675618172, 0.041567977517843246, -0.03592464327812195, 0.06115226447582245, -0.07881215959787369, -0.04194899648427963, 0.028965771198272705, 0.0035091943573206663, 0.005188888404518366, -0.04418976604938507, -0.02516775019466877, -0.00682849483564496, -0.05409296602010727, -0.002552023623138666, 0.04487389326095581, -0.034002635627985, -0.03193050995469093, 0.03274714946746826, 0.024150868877768517, 0.054758284240961075, -0.00595859857276082, -0.006504432763904333, 0.0389808788895607, -0.01599643938243389, -0.023899728432297707, -0.028215253725647926, 0.0035752705298364162, -0.05532795935869217, -0.027707016095519066, -0.04853207990527153, 0.010909893549978733, -0.019446419551968575, -0.04148552939295769, 0.020020250231027603, -0.00529464753344655, 0.030925845727324486, 0.018452541902661324, -0.03903249278664589, -0.01710519567131996, -0.006134871859103441, -0.023569995537400246, -0.013146638870239258, 0.01582115888595581, 0.023916399106383324, 0.004670273046940565, 0.04602838307619095, -0.0049773771315813065, 0.025332478806376457, -0.026691455394029617, 0.024717940017580986, -0.031400129199028015, -0.016383789479732513, 0.02128567174077034, -0.05910522863268852, 0.05438753589987755, -0.00003515636853990145, -0.030282238498330116, 0.037150345742702484, 0.012025964446365833, -0.016685346141457558, -0.019646277651190758, -0.04818727448582649, -0.012573404237627983, 0.029910463839769363, 0.008665129542350769, 0.026860052719712257, 0.025474950671195984, -0.008919497020542622, 0.002999772084876895, -0.007634307723492384, 0.0021947056520730257, 0.007745637092739344, -0.010650902055203915, 0.04759732261300087, -0.009967103600502014, 0.0031632957980036736, 0.002075811382383108, 0.04131343588232994, 0.01492063608020544, 0.05516364052891731, 0.0030974391847848892, 0.05890681594610214, 0.015756996348500252, -0.027734795585274696, -0.044274572283029556, 0.04344712570309639, -0.04914957657456398, 0.0014439122751355171, -0.024191860109567642, -0.007601482328027487, 0.0570533387362957, 0.03607689589262009, -0.003840358229354024, -0.018945744261145592, -0.02052312158048153, -0.05492458865046501, 0.028498904779553413, 0.0009181652567349374, -0.007482466753572226, 0.018298791721463203, -0.005981176160275936, 0.04614445939660072, 0.002790836151689291, -0.027229085564613342, -0.03433674946427345, -0.04181157425045967, -0.01038496196269989, -0.037425391376018524, -0.06312496960163116, 0.01933171972632408, 0.023351561278104782, -0.006178184878081083, 0.0019637702498584986, -0.01705383136868477, 0.03191053122282028, 0.008703279308974743, 0.06575224548578262, -0.03578833118081093, 0.04016457498073578, 0.020220370963215828, 0.013602005317807198, -0.018892845138907433, 0.014089172706007957, 0.13323058187961578, 0.07237141579389572, 0.029099391773343086, -0.043025508522987366, 0.04379895329475403, 0.022326212376356125, -0.0015430442290380597, -0.022825513035058975, 0.005621723830699921, -0.003873915411531925, -0.015230427496135235, 0.009991073980927467, 0.0652398094534874, -0.03394749388098717, 0.014572078362107277, 0.048479992896318436, -0.00218954193405807, -0.021388525143265724, 0.006972390227019787, 0.021508818492293358, -0.009034453891217709, 0.030479969456791878, -0.04411887004971504, 0.040068794041872025, 0.00613940367475152, -0.0014191230293363333, -0.029111644253134727, -0.005564823746681213, -0.04769814759492874, -0.004169619642198086, 0.004577609710395336, 0.010942686349153519, 0.027632784098386765, 0.0047436547465622425, -0.014474299736320972, 0.01582317240536213, -0.004585565067827702, -0.008985788561403751, 0.014357252046465874, 0.024195214733481407, -0.01875387132167816, -0.0069369361735880375, -0.005940781440585852, 0.008512875065207481, -0.02850445918738842, -0.02508765272796154, -0.034957095980644226, 0.04907504841685295, -0.029984774067997932, -0.0008473962661810219, 0.004464183934032917, 0.020604951307177544, 0.04508375748991966, -0.037230633199214935, -0.01929531805217266, 0.005695954896509647, 0.029438845813274384, 0.023652009665966034, -0.01189163513481617, 0.019797995686531067, 0.05727560445666313, 0.026539191603660583, 0.004544213879853487, 0.011535502970218658, 0.0007741880835965276, -0.03712429851293564, -0.020567692816257477, 0.052857208997011185, 0.03312830999493599, 0.018023721873760223, -0.020105764269828796, -0.0064623733051121235, -0.013944354839622974, -0.03478485345840454, -0.011366360820829868, 0.015131866559386253, 0.07722651958465576, -0.0023032119497656822, -0.025437941774725914, -0.01360511314123869, -0.028001083061099052, 0.010108321905136108, -0.016330279409885406, -0.018478861078619957, -0.011687947437167168, 0.016670331358909607, -0.0003998371830675751, 0.06338133662939072, -0.0027030149940401316, 0.021118508651852608, -0.00966116227209568, 0.05031045526266098, 0.02971459925174713, -0.036692168563604355, -0.004734206013381481, -0.051285408437252045, -0.0004617735685314983, 0.03311603516340256, -0.005300365854054689, 0.038561295717954636, 0.011708111502230167, 0.0076486701145768166, 0.026679210364818573, 0.07463622838258743, -0.009725782088935375, -0.01471511647105217, -0.0035574098583310843, -0.04868251085281372, 0.020501337945461273, 0.0012217751936987042, 0.004411558620631695, -0.019101420417428017, -0.024258313700556755, -0.0012903817696496844, -0.02244846150279045, -0.0331064835190773, 0.017765292897820473, -0.04293595254421234, -0.009755408391356468, -0.04822478070855141, 0.02838842384517193, -0.0018355885986238718, -0.005512635223567486, 0.005592238623648882, 0.003907427191734314, -0.021169234067201614, 0.007215407211333513, -0.012712188065052032, -0.016232145950198174, 0.007288157008588314, 0.01594007946550846, -0.00777201633900404, 0.004902583081275225, 0.010411346331238747, -0.009281951002776623, -0.00411895290017128, 0.0056774066761136055, 0.014621628448367119, -0.013278133235871792, -0.0023317544255405664, 0.03278030455112457, -0.01205245777964592, -0.04814433678984642, -0.005811543669551611, -0.02823542058467865, 0.056262433528900146, 0.028582248836755753, -0.00748302461579442, -0.04637706279754639, 0.04450829327106476, 0.019183315336704254, -0.060071010142564774, -0.03008519671857357, 0.021975891664624214, 0.030353233218193054, 0.0030644217040389776, 0.009643684141337872, 0.003823644947260618, -0.018347999081015587, -0.0007942491210997105, 0.019276732578873634, -0.009280146099627018, -0.00442454032599926, 0.008694099262356758, -0.031807538121938705, 0.0191059373319149, -0.0063048843294382095, 0.003312649903818965, 0.05662520229816437, 0.04501388221979141, -0.01868070848286152, -0.030966894701123238, -0.033703215420246124, -0.008554861880838871, -0.038205455988645554, -0.009836132638156414, 0.016881056129932404, -0.008496621623635292, 0.027575243264436722, -0.05046334117650986, -0.015527484938502312, 0.05270523950457573, -0.06609505414962769, 0.028357472270727158, 0.019326524809002876, -0.0035803718492388725, -0.05579334869980812, 0.00248541496694088, -0.03354468196630478, 0.00823305081576109, 0.018669279292225838, 0.013469953089952469, 0.017617709934711456, 0.027816249057650566, -0.00011435049236752093, -0.045357972383499146, -0.0016212512273341417, -0.035852257162332535, -0.003254077397286892, -0.02925587259232998, 0.014554458670318127, -0.046284496784210205, -0.006596807856112719, 0.03111574985086918, -0.01967291720211506, -0.006649197544902563, 0.0023496339563280344, 0.021636424586176872, 0.029294481500983238, 0.06517912447452545, 0.0020131238270550966, -0.0250879917293787, 0.046111349016427994, -0.016207430511713028, 0.024132847785949707, 0.015134348534047604, 0.00010720708087319508, 0.038967687636613846, 0.0596262589097023, 0.016894714906811714, -0.0514218844473362, 0.024833183735609055, -0.012470271438360214, 0.0011398997157812119, -0.015058131888508797, 0.01593262329697609, 0.027564670890569687, 0.00955973844975233, 0.03610970452427864, -0.00740952929481864, 0.036435551941394806, -0.0034609984140843153, -0.018256964161992073, 0.002130597596988082, 0.01241758931428194, 0.016520507633686066, -0.03610413521528244, -0.015111198648810387, -0.004991212859749794, -0.025304757058620453, -0.05883941799402237, 0.010821276344358921, 0.001817383337765932, 0.007319771684706211, -0.0164983868598938, -0.015478995628654957, -0.03280658274888992, 0.023761345073580742, -0.03435705602169037, 0.02250826731324196, -0.0019720373675227165, 0.009296739473938942, 0.0016258463729172945, -0.0899428054690361, 0.06545291841030121, -0.0022103399969637394, -0.023239722475409508, -0.03716019168496132, -0.020769920200109482, -0.00398631114512682, 0.04933156818151474, 0.046380333602428436, 0.024629663676023483, 0.03911838307976723, -0.04223538935184479, 0.03486322611570358, 0.03545299917459488, -0.054813940078020096, 0.019427835941314697, -0.030274134129285812, -0.004874563775956631, 0.010162471793591976, -0.023834500461816788, 0.027420230209827423, 0.015301582403481007, 0.012390092946588993, -0.0023479771334677935, -0.01990087330341339, -0.01530702505260706, -0.028457822278141975, 0.0331508032977581, -0.005571652669459581, -0.02934821881353855, 0.04893450811505318, -0.010067173279821873, 0.0037549445405602455, 0.018710291013121605, -0.0373702347278595, -0.031124189496040344, 0.022702807560563087, -0.06478642672300339, -0.04393550381064415, -0.006099991966038942, 0.04615733399987221, 0.009477880783379078, -0.05302439257502556, 0.007056932896375656, 0.005092280451208353, -0.03415222838521004, -0.019548803567886353, 0.023744484409689903, 0.04132853075861931, 0.06194710731506348, 0.006381176877766848, 0.0339386910200119, -0.004350168164819479, 0.01757284812629223, 0.04144212231040001, 0.006278633140027523, 0.009257416240870953, 0.02173101156949997, -0.01021955069154501, 0.0052910055965185165, -0.015822799876332283, 0.009930059313774109, -0.0051509602926671505, 0.027997683733701706, 0.0023642280139029026, -0.01201749499887228, 0.05158870294690132, -0.034275781363248825, 0.05138511210680008, 0.020029278472065926, -0.006942858919501305, 0.05410230904817581, 0.02204367145895958, -0.03753751143813133, -0.060068629682064056, -0.0499693863093853, -0.007161484099924564, -0.00727372569963336, 0.02301609329879284, 0.05575614050030708, -0.01936611905694008, -0.000716257025487721, -0.032720666378736496, -0.0004754981491714716, 0.02806803211569786, -0.054199375212192535, 0.03421591594815254, -0.010775826871395111, 0.009168192744255066, 0.03960983082652092, -0.0003198837803211063, -0.0385199673473835, 0.0337461456656456, 0.036701325327157974, 0.054407935589551926, 0.010849816724658012, 0.01010841690003872, -0.013999680057168007, -0.0020621304865926504, -0.008853319101035595, -0.027430888265371323, -0.029447561129927635, -0.051847781985998154, 0.006288173142820597, 0.0013846586225554347, -0.012340867891907692 ]
<p>I have a small question about a small research that I wanted to do regarding stock symbol similarities and their abnormal returns. I have about a sample of 10 000 stocks and I calculate how much they differ from each other (which gives a matrix of 10K x 10K with their "difference measure").</p> <p>Now I was planning to test this by first grouping those stocks with a distance less than a certain threshold into a group and dropping those that have a larger threshold and then check whether these stocks have a similar return even though they are not in the same industry.</p> <p>I have a few questions, is this a good method to test for this? Or should I use the matrix of 10K x 10K? Because I need to check for totally unsimilar stocks too right?</p> <p>Furthermore am I forgetting something? I am trying to replicate the study done by Rashes (2001) on a larger scale. </p>
37,088
[ -0.006166758015751839, 0.013052976690232754, -0.021010128781199455, -0.007394689600914717, 0.048407264053821564, -0.00650288350880146, -0.030475234612822533, -0.02617073245346546, 0.011002457700669765, -0.03872459754347801, 0.027863340452313423, 0.02868075668811798, 0.04175123572349548, 0.03314248472452164, 0.036384958773851395, 0.018310127779841423, -0.03609428554773331, -0.02182566188275814, 0.03375617787241936, -0.006740737706422806, 0.015858372673392296, 0.0010288087651133537, 0.010602694936096668, -0.012493491172790527, -0.020912742242217064, 0.03408540412783623, 0.009407449513673782, -0.023484710603952408, 0.010609667748212814, 0.014846487902104855, -0.03660106658935547, -0.03772225230932236, 0.03656981512904167, 0.03312615305185318, 0.0015390043845400214, -0.0009381423587910831, 0.01737711764872074, -0.015967974439263344, -0.06763782352209091, 0.04116516187787056, -0.008654030039906502, -0.03672616928815842, 0.008065911941230297, 0.04790273681282997, -0.006160704884678125, -0.012540741823613644, 0.009285779669880867, -0.04410889372229576, 0.019379427656531334, -0.0478828027844429, 0.06921972334384918, 0.0010504769161343575, 0.027031810954213142, 0.024376532062888145, -0.00801630225032568, 0.020574087277054787, 0.025710029527544975, 0.04080457240343094, -0.0353337861597538, -0.04576124623417854, -0.0046811155043542385, 0.00843899603933096, 0.0031312548089772463, -0.017147734761238098, -0.04059959575533867, 0.03649657964706421, -0.02260337583720684, -0.023282308131456375, 0.04576168581843376, -0.0615154430270195, 0.0075370436534285545, 0.02350214682519436, 0.02363128773868084, -0.001323028584010899, 0.020318707451224327, -0.03557291626930237, -0.002337752841413021, 0.04475428909063339, 0.0755530595779419, 0.03636771813035011, 0.012670462019741535, 0.030342966318130493, 0.009412751533091068, 0.03655906021595001, 0.07616543769836426, -0.014871509745717049, 0.06161370873451233, -0.06709461659193039, 0.017261963337659836, 0.046808723360300064, 0.00396189047023654, 0.0020802959334105253, 0.05243587866425514, 0.06866876035928726, -0.029261333867907524, 0.019026391208171844, -0.024818839505314827, 0.0301300548017025, -0.016829414293169975, -0.006268564611673355, -0.0256057009100914, -0.05452108383178711, 0.024218406528234482, 0.02447112463414669, 0.010127446614205837, 0.018402760848402977, -0.013890075497329235, 0.01426302082836628, -0.04129772260785103, -0.011225108057260513, -0.014787894673645496, 0.03046358749270439, 0.012463764287531376, -0.026462633162736893, 0.022077247500419617, 0.005355122033506632, 0.03157404437661171, -0.01373452041298151, 0.040133628994226456, 0.046265967190265656, 0.007000393699854612, 0.01356390118598938, 0.013536142185330391, -0.02865108847618103, -0.031994275748729706, 0.052146073430776596, 0.015124915167689323, -0.01876157894730568, -0.06684929132461548, 0.04041006788611412, -0.018502885475754738, -0.023615140467882156, 0.016153773292899132, -0.05094439908862114, 0.04890261963009834, 0.010522848926484585, -0.0766410082578659, -0.016441790387034416, 0.056456729769706726, 0.013490569777786732, 0.0031301628332585096, -0.05760381743311882, -0.02803822234272957, 0.026716532185673714, 0.035106729716062546, 0.024513719603419304, 0.03590181842446327, 0.004200000315904617, 0.029824020341038704, 0.029481874778866768, -0.01012943871319294, -0.02419131062924862, -0.02613954246044159, -0.026370931416749954, 0.02339915931224823, -0.06790344417095184, -0.012623053044080734, 0.0284977238625288, -0.05911334976553917, 0.009147558361291885, 0.0004284641472622752, 0.03217912092804909, 0.0065873474813997746, 0.011973747052252293, 0.012686929665505886, 0.008304933086037636, 0.05291542783379555, -0.013541062362492085, 0.026451291516423225, 0.006196882575750351, -0.0134458988904953, 0.01761118695139885, 0.003570767818018794, 0.02520965039730072, 0.045430172234773636, -0.02262992039322853, 0.022904107347130775, -0.023848477751016617, 0.01502670906484127, 0.012725746259093285, -0.04556397721171379, -0.02796979807317257, -0.021355804055929184, -0.010571794584393501, 0.03317559137940407, 0.043629538267850876, -0.03370635583996773, -0.04005465656518936, 0.04540809243917465, -0.042999718338251114, -0.06460224092006683, -0.05098867416381836, -0.0018471170915290713, -0.05856160447001457, -0.048369694501161575, 0.019734272733330727, -0.006556066684424877, 0.02495446987450123, 0.003909217659384012, -0.03568003326654434, -0.028307456523180008, -0.02671399898827076, 0.045617762953042984, -0.022336039692163467, 0.016684675589203835, 0.03440475091338158, 0.0351199135184288, -0.009569467045366764, 0.03046012669801712, -0.04642065241932869, -0.0796232670545578, 0.010715360753238201, -0.03081827238202095, 0.011261997744441032, 0.049699973315000534, 0.009621525183320045, 0.08335224539041519, 0.0030816220678389072, -0.017471913248300552, 0.040350768715143204, -0.03268902376294136, 0.054234545677900314, 0.00910225696861744, 0.009282026439905167, 0.009594754315912724, -0.01790395751595497, 0.03467347472906113, 0.016669102013111115, 0.009460428729653358, -0.025001980364322662, -0.04613116383552551, 0.006507196929305792, 0.03360951319336891, 0.026359504088759422, -0.03313319385051727, 0.027691366150975227, 0.07751534879207611, -0.006233357824385166, -0.024640245363116264, 0.019109567627310753, -0.00400959188118577, -0.02513635903596878, -0.0005968615296296775, 0.02668164111673832, -0.014350972138345242, -0.02621273882687092, 0.031311050057411194, -0.0077347527258098125, 0.05083860084414482, -0.008467942476272583, 0.019265510141849518, 0.021665215492248535, -0.027750831097364426, 0.028106458485126495, -0.01262367982417345, -0.019171342253684998, 0.054998863488435745, 0.005450809840112925, -0.023882895708084106, 0.06304509192705154, 0.00197075167670846, -0.012302547693252563, 0.003555108094587922, -0.024401141330599785, 0.021019117906689644, 0.05035405978560448, -0.04214274510741234, 0.010942783206701279, 0.006608260329812765, -0.06311587989330292, 0.029896872118115425, -0.01497782301157713, -0.001732059521600604, -0.03334737569093704, 0.03508199006319046, 0.04706175997853279, 0.01753442920744419, 0.02481343224644661, -0.008669515140354633, -0.018181025981903076, -0.011303769424557686, -0.017253290861845016, 0.005123287905007601, -0.020600374788045883, -0.04536949470639229, 0.023962344974279404, -0.041388701647520065, -0.022564256563782692, 0.01316064689308405, -0.03499622270464897, 0.009205497801303864, 0.015664871782064438, 0.0012726165587082505, -0.02423466183245182, -0.019937649369239807, -0.03572029247879982, 0.00539191160351038, -0.009038981981575489, -0.02354324422776699, 0.037967339158058167, 0.019540099427103996, -0.050490714609622955, 0.020348267629742622, -0.030822837725281715, -0.010041169822216034, -0.02027728408575058, -0.012138975784182549, 0.015679046511650085, -0.04639638960361481, 0.005644011311233044, 0.021483423188328743, -0.01719723641872406, -0.010335260070860386, -0.07019506394863129, -0.0627465546131134, 0.0074634249322116375, 0.014924228191375732, 0.0197957381606102, 0.009463966824114323, -0.020537056028842926, 0.06418909877538681, 0.028485311195254326, -0.009585999883711338, -0.05547086521983147, 0.017609426751732826, -0.0654359757900238, -0.050924330949783325, 0.01074852142482996, 0.038224101066589355, 0.042846113443374634, -0.028351491317152977, 0.020378757268190384, 0.07120632380247116, 0.06858087331056595, -0.011943374760448933, -0.024304784834384918, 0.0065696099773049355, -0.016206394881010056, -0.011133591644465923, 0.03483998775482178, -0.01249893568456173, -0.03988831490278244, 0.004870354197919369, 0.03866906091570854, 0.04502347856760025, 0.015816424041986465, -0.072503000497818, 0.037475403398275375, -0.034408729523420334, -0.0020447249989956617, 0.013053585775196552, 0.001668976154178381, -0.002019535982981324, -0.00016132932796608657, 0.024689365178346634, 0.0021778875961899757, -0.004249229561537504, 0.013487876392900944, -0.011763550341129303, 0.045097220689058304, 0.016597043722867966, -0.025753168389201164, 0.008656182326376438, -0.03354175016283989, -0.019918793812394142, 0.003543865866959095, -0.05364714190363884, -0.04292763024568558, 0.016646672040224075, 0.039999932050704956, 0.035552769899368286, -0.014155030250549316, -0.05630560219287872, -0.0005379029316827655, -0.046397656202316284, -0.007480451837182045, -0.03271438926458359, 0.03560412675142288, 0.0045063691213727, 0.03574357554316521, 0.027133962139487267, -0.00992810633033514, 0.028713149949908257, -0.02528870292007923, -0.03601912781596184, 0.018338099122047424, -0.039684802293777466, -0.015926579013466835, 0.013827950693666935, -0.017470937222242355, 0.002853847574442625, 0.01594993844628334, 0.021157123148441315, 0.02428266406059265, 0.03326110914349556, -0.0760834738612175, 0.003460187464952469, -0.024444932118058205, -0.012233424931764603, -0.0027139796875417233, 0.019121984019875526, 0.01258868258446455, 0.03626932576298714, 0.024716705083847046, 0.006027585826814175, -0.014206704683601856, -0.0026141975540667772, 0.010127195157110691, 0.04842933639883995, 0.05398278310894966, 0.04018329456448555, 0.03665996715426445, 0.013443374074995518, -0.033179834485054016, 0.03034532628953457, 0.0045943669974803925, 0.039474014192819595, 0.01740163192152977, -0.012455955147743225, -0.021342679858207703, -0.06651563942432404, -0.03378996253013611, -0.010278561152517796, 0.021615413948893547, -0.022424783557653427, -0.014927640557289124, 0.039197009056806564, 0.047462623566389084, -0.030198685824871063, 0.006777886301279068, 0.07199708372354507, 0.041709091514348984, -0.033089783042669296, -0.013313890434801579, -0.004889142233878374, -0.006745230872184038, -0.009870598092675209, 0.020443281158804893, 0.005089399870485067, -0.024530572816729546, -0.012669634073972702, 0.04663848131895065, -0.020790090784430504, -0.06463878601789474, -0.028269963338971138, 0.0032046244014054537, 0.020869936794042587, -0.04964584484696388, -0.01823333464562893, 0.0415625125169754, 0.01073539163917303, 0.016882803291082382, 0.019594119861721992, 0.017023133113980293, -0.08210501074790955, 0.03261987119913101, 0.053538721054792404, 0.039505355060100555, -0.023049956187605858, -0.018596213310956955, -0.06072361022233963, -0.0059204017743468285, 0.007361954543739557, -0.02376445010304451, 0.0474698469042778, -0.025777852162718773, 0.043382976204156876, -0.03536663576960564, 0.011912291869521141, 0.02242937870323658, 0.030491884797811508, 0.006769966334104538, 0.018110262230038643, -0.02595314383506775, -0.026980765163898468, -0.030087504535913467, -0.008912628516554832, 0.029367581009864807, 0.04181753844022751, -0.04799748584628105, 0.007217817939817905, 0.014500285498797894, 0.0008323468500748277, -0.016519710421562195, -0.08542048186063766, 0.02010323666036129, -0.005338857416063547, 0.0015921498415991664, 0.084880530834198, -0.02426951751112938, -0.032488878816366196, 0.02002507820725441, 0.007360773626714945, 0.001292312634177506, -0.0020600834395736456, -0.01209965255111456, 0.03910575062036514, 0.04228588938713074, 0.00015532152610830963, 0.030799463391304016, 0.0014239830197766423, 0.04083208739757538, 0.03947198763489723, -0.006627933122217655, 0.0043477448634803295, -0.0471162348985672, -0.016084223985671997, -0.038719113916158676, -0.006505031604319811, -0.03893505409359932, 0.03984638676047325, -0.04215559363365173, 0.046602293848991394, -0.027795758098363876, 0.01428318116813898, 0.006577807012945414, 0.027109580114483833, -0.02328791469335556, -0.003295157803222537, 0.03421397879719734, 0.029289206489920616, -0.04703482612967491, 0.007541547529399395, 0.03216935321688652, -0.009024985134601593, -0.01214565895497799, -0.027655472978949547, -0.010381982661783695, -0.006159364711493254, -0.03284544497728348, -0.02410612255334854, 0.019125841557979584, -0.006443816237151623, 0.08128023892641068, -0.02490498498082161, 0.03175445646047592, 0.013963176868855953, -0.007220988627523184, 0.005378505680710077, 0.020051030442118645, -0.0037735351361334324, 0.05289575457572937, -0.03967089205980301, 0.04260389134287834, -0.028076080605387688, -0.022547312080860138, -0.060512296855449677, -0.06601082533597946, 0.02826893888413906, 0.04673922434449196, -0.034621983766555786, -0.03360668942332268, 0.0008433798793703318, -0.020619787275791168, -0.00009266323468182236, -0.03580223023891449, 0.03964665159583092, 0.0016465202206745744, -0.05505702272057533, -0.010817459784448147, -0.006157511845231056, 0.11520975083112717, -0.0037448005750775337, -0.05174066126346588, 0.025621382519602776, 0.017790861427783966, 0.031134387478232384, -0.016163669526576996, 0.02851114608347416, -0.051146943122148514, -0.03260594978928566, -0.059812914580106735, 0.004645299632102251, 0.04539592191576958, -0.08050026744604111, -0.0001911416184157133, 0.008746701292693615, -0.0032484515104442835, 0.05679739639163017, -0.017050916329026222, 0.019108032807707787, -0.04678037390112877, -0.026588398963212967, -0.02331453002989292, -0.017474552616477013, 0.010081647895276546, -0.0336284413933754, 0.030009696260094643, 0.004138342570513487, -0.029526162892580032, 0.02098272554576397, 0.0685657188296318, -0.014512945897877216, -0.0055727362632751465, -0.007864410057663918, -0.01216473150998354, 0.04991958290338516, -0.027723075821995735, 0.00704661151394248, -0.005844177212566137, 0.04359627515077591, -0.02257639169692993, -0.03796599432826042, -0.030262766405940056, 0.0319870188832283, 0.05664658546447754, 0.020175639539957047, 0.015457101166248322, 0.049060989171266556, 0.02057488076388836, 0.005864263977855444, -0.02849680557847023, -0.01338167954236269, -0.007281709928065538, 0.00721023790538311, 0.04196534305810928, -0.02226896397769451, 0.0013530038995668292, 0.03785516694188118, 0.03541884198784828, 0.015266087837517262, 0.019658928737044334, 0.023905666545033455, 0.02981829270720482, 0.019561566412448883, -0.00043201944208703935, -0.04261171072721481, 0.022993775084614754, -0.05586981400847435, 0.051557756960392, -0.057987913489341736, -0.00810152292251587, 0.0493907667696476, 0.06129658967256546, 0.008943218737840652, -0.013179317116737366, -0.01887669786810875, -0.022078227251768112, 0.02314256690442562, 0.022591479122638702, 0.00687407935038209, 0.03610878437757492, 0.03399324044585228, 0.03697258606553078, 0.005800883751362562, 0.01930910535156727, -0.0018818920943886042, -0.04996400699019432, -0.02433859556913376, -0.03526676073670387, -0.052021726965904236, 0.00027915454120375216, -0.007773751858621836, -0.04756930470466614, 0.01321697048842907, -0.056636687368154526, -0.02173040620982647, -0.011029389686882496, 0.00026227202033624053, -0.00957702100276947, 0.07666054368019104, 0.029298337176442146, 0.04728532209992409, 0.027720991522073746, -0.025847947224974632, 0.10510976612567902, 0.04763319715857506, 0.006051680073142052, -0.04309782385826111, 0.03895019367337227, -0.024655470624566078, 0.034324098378419876, -0.04978720471262932, 0.06851452589035034, -0.021338798105716705, 0.02252369560301304, 0.03662336245179176, 0.08568821102380753, -0.018567798659205437, -0.026508091017603874, 0.04272127151489258, -0.048961091786623, 0.0007992394384928048, 0.007168164476752281, 0.04332895576953888, -0.005064218770712614, -0.01777876354753971, -0.04074246808886528, 0.057507604360580444, 0.021786602213978767, 0.019781656563282013, -0.011620361357927322, 0.016689246520400047, 0.020361000671982765, 0.0005879050586372614, 0.01665131002664566, -0.0036778650246560574, 0.004676926881074905, -0.0007589737069793046, -0.016447028145194054, 0.004416193347424269, 0.03865564614534378, -0.05865757167339325, 0.008919364772737026, -0.008932875469326973, -0.011387130245566368, -0.03320401534438133, -0.030436832457780838, -0.026125255972146988, -0.01840903051197529, -0.018295055255293846, -0.03190000727772713, 0.05526421591639519, 0.03283726051449776, -0.017251286655664444, -0.030749931931495667, 0.005531964357942343, -0.011319039389491081, -0.05748460069298744, -0.026190530508756638, 0.01789827272295952, 0.01481905672699213, -0.0049713412299752235, -0.004985579755157232, -0.03539291024208069, 0.04024115949869156, 0.004175786394625902, 0.0269966758787632, -0.0030220511835068464, -0.042432915419340134, -0.01935199648141861, 0.0067330277524888515, 0.03715745359659195, -0.019284596666693687, 0.013649916276335716, -0.030629413202404976, 0.0009652774315327406, -0.028413543477654457, -0.02560928277671337, -0.029263101518154144, 0.04061164706945419, 0.019507231190800667, 0.03374895080924034, -0.01752299629151821, 0.015677861869335175, -0.04344021528959274, 0.020260795950889587, -0.004754291381686926, -0.02745971456170082, -0.0365794412791729, -0.006367149762809277, 0.05656517669558525, 0.02401208132505417, 0.023782998323440552, -0.006263541989028454, -0.00032485267729498446, 0.06055751442909241, 0.0001636248198337853, -0.017276644706726074, -0.020351475104689598, -0.010225679725408554, -0.037772540003061295, 0.011041542515158653, -0.02456791140139103, 0.04315934702754021, 0.05254509299993515, -0.03478638082742691, 0.004715317860245705, 0.0074424841441214085, -0.01661217026412487, 0.035435616970062256, 0.0072615561075508595, -0.077957883477211, 0.010404715314507484, 0.017919009551405907, -0.04978668689727783, -0.052946433424949646, -0.018252689391374588, -0.02559790015220642, -0.007063372991979122, 0.0136406309902668, 0.005089608021080494, -0.03832563757896423, -0.01193314790725708, -0.0235428586602211, 0.027649059891700745, -0.0312807522714138, -0.018994176760315895, -0.03024297207593918, -0.0019517141627147794, -0.03287184610962868, -0.03509875014424324, -0.021956585347652435, 0.0037208939902484417, -0.019052771851420403, 0.020839562639594078, 0.05238332971930504, 0.031312454491853714, -0.012758169323205948, 0.00038407224928960204, -0.024205485358834267, -0.025963686406612396, 0.029278861358761787, -0.0258187185972929, -0.0001286077604163438, 0.0323299802839756, -0.020643889904022217, -0.03770003095269203, 0.05015433579683304, 0.006560818757861853, 0.024524368345737457, 0.01385082583874464, 0.017880795523524284, -0.02921180985867977, 0.0303203072398901, -0.008575884625315666, -0.011549200862646103, 0.01730939745903015, 0.036682628095149994, 0.021149426698684692, -0.01571325585246086, 0.024393359199166298, 0.001826134161092341, -0.012298173271119595, 0.012415239587426186, 0.032669998705387115, -0.024568459019064903, -0.0026942179538309574, 0.006691058166325092, -0.019837461411952972, 0.004969073925167322, -0.006250246427953243, -0.024030696600675583, 0.06064000353217125, 0.03295298293232918, -0.006088604684919119, 0.018985729664564133, -0.04744420200586319, 0.0025872362311929464, -0.06842026114463806, -0.003334142966195941, 0.02285853959619999, 0.020108990371227264, 0.02044103480875492, -0.03819121792912483, 0.024652237072587013, 0.019838832318782806, -0.07590694725513458, 0.041746385395526886, -0.004045980516821146, -0.012349788099527359, -0.053275030106306076, -0.021744048222899437, -0.0039442311972379684, 0.04165441542863846, -0.0031836023554205894, -0.007706953678280115, 0.026230713352560997, 0.015354686416685581, -0.01023613940924406, -0.009576087817549706, 0.00008615906699560583, 0.009230918250977993, 0.003082997864112258, -0.027360742911696434, 0.006965945474803448, -0.022936169058084488, -0.04679371416568756, 0.006202017888426781, -0.04688245430588722, 0.021679922938346863, 0.025202741846442223, 0.02138572186231613, 0.008795409463346004, 0.03961922973394394, 0.028479455038905144, 0.024326974526047707, -0.013443219475448132, -0.03733476996421814, -0.004107788670808077, 0.011221214197576046, 0.017923347651958466, 0.016603002324700356, 0.0483318530023098, -0.04245750606060028, -0.003087045857682824, -0.030444450676441193, -0.013671722263097763, 0.002048031659796834, -0.03367239609360695, 0.008212999440729618, 0.015058359131217003, -0.01644386723637581, 0.025340775027871132, -0.015508520416915417, -0.020778071135282516, 0.04481825605034828, 0.03792676702141762, -0.01232763659209013, 0.04146110638976097, -0.019420454278588295, -0.06264188140630722, 0.03264559432864189, -0.010346714407205582, -0.007428992073982954, -0.04507686570286751, -0.026821820065379143, 0.001583630102686584, -0.003024131990969181, -0.028933564200997353, -0.0006629676790907979, 0.0024253292940557003, 0.06296940892934799, -0.040475502610206604, 0.003444734960794449, 0.028306202962994576, -0.005162033252418041, 0.02039695903658867, -0.0813952088356018, 0.0607634074985981, -0.004790575709193945, -0.017337298020720482, -0.016550717875361443, 0.013720802031457424, -0.04795020818710327, -0.001828363398090005, 0.03531312569975853, 0.013427124358713627, 0.01731814257800579, -0.008429675363004208, 0.020947447046637535, -0.012112668715417385, -0.05758918076753616, 0.012679255567491055, -0.006507592741400003, -0.031061209738254547, -0.012619761750102043, -0.03438779339194298, 0.029864171519875526, -0.009839328937232494, 0.019173545762896538, -0.04247865453362465, -0.04061201214790344, 0.003537853015586734, -0.007991954684257507, 0.04338705912232399, 0.0013871222035959363, -0.023562882095575333, 0.015056099742650986, 0.009670455008745193, 0.025213737040758133, 0.03322705626487732, -0.016394048929214478, -0.062403567135334015, 0.06537433713674545, -0.034218139946460724, -0.02570050209760666, 0.004485306330025196, -0.014264426194131374, 0.019896475598216057, -0.04994027689099312, -0.0059252153150737286, 0.018632391467690468, 0.004687084350734949, 0.022708307951688766, 0.06742008030414581, 0.034472912549972534, -0.020357739180326462, -0.005076128989458084, 0.04388270154595375, 0.03121308796107769, 0.014232780784368515, -0.004526874050498009, -0.01182745024561882, 0.021752193570137024, 0.017517786473035812, 0.002171688713133335, 0.013166671618819237, -0.01902875117957592, 0.011164141818881035, 0.004128573462367058, 0.01210197526961565, -0.009955743327736855, 0.008555484935641289, 0.01726757548749447, -0.025414224714040756, 0.02031097188591957, 0.041336964815855026, -0.01693953387439251, 0.03900602087378502, -0.02623637206852436, 0.000836301886010915, -0.006349335424602032, -0.01517466176301241, -0.019863668829202652, 0.006330085918307304, 0.027638843283057213, 0.00039867512532509863, -0.02499636635184288, 0.010101448744535446, -0.008501206524670124, 0.02143765613436699, 0.04061272367835045, -0.038008011877536774, 0.046472132205963135, -0.03869668021798134, 0.010837987996637821, 0.007023863960057497, -0.008309154771268368, -0.03640193119645119, -0.014372581616044044, 0.017260653898119926, 0.025479942560195923, 0.014928855933248997, 0.019797546789050102, -0.03724825754761696, 0.02674291841685772, 0.01613522134721279, -0.06369195878505707, -0.020895183086395264, -0.05671791359782219, 0.013390259817242622, -0.009743721224367619, -0.02489064447581768 ]
<p>According to Wikipedia:</p> <blockquote> <p>Although in practice [Fisher's exact test] is employed when sample sizes are small, it is valid for all sample sizes.</p> </blockquote> <p>If Fisher's exact test can provide the exact p-values in lieu of the approximation that is given by the chi squared, what is the reason to ever use the $\chi^2$ test?</p>
49,928
[ -0.013480445370078087, -0.03640524297952652, -0.0022045644000172615, -0.017033567652106285, 0.05922737345099449, 0.00397351011633873, 0.0005496477824635804, -0.017104336991906166, -0.018034422770142555, -0.02703489549458027, 0.01678767055273056, 0.030854690819978714, 0.02631804719567299, 0.016834402456879616, 0.0306628979742527, 0.009104161523282528, -0.0463569238781929, -0.00027235038578510284, -0.01352390181273222, 0.01367806177586317, 0.015682844445109367, 0.03543179854750633, 0.010088994167745113, -0.023731324821710587, -0.0411863811314106, 0.03194466233253479, 0.026510225608944893, -0.027891656383872032, 0.01811266876757145, 0.0663238912820816, -0.050821997225284576, -0.007762671913951635, 0.052887968719005585, 0.031860243529081345, 0.011667300947010517, -0.022902950644493103, -0.016002286225557327, -0.023623989894986153, 0.032740529626607895, 0.022496044635772705, -0.048512931913137436, 0.00412321463227272, 0.03129339590668678, 0.010403549298644066, -0.015265628695487976, 0.03966248407959938, -0.010111960582435131, -0.052190035581588745, 0.007826613262295723, -0.026706762611865997, 0.06184697896242142, -0.00034748113830573857, 0.02596891112625599, -0.01266059186309576, 0.010809757746756077, -0.026445873081684113, 0.025241250172257423, 0.028838830068707466, -0.03961598873138428, -0.05370831862092018, -0.002178402151912451, -0.015123854391276836, 0.026438316330313683, -0.03339800983667374, -0.03216641768813133, 0.023505859076976776, 0.0014597888803109527, -0.027827052399516106, -0.005288268905133009, -0.01167642418295145, -0.00986481737345457, 0.046775996685028076, 0.02686811424791813, -0.013380258344113827, 0.004879985935986042, -0.0335732027888298, 0.01534285955131054, 0.0579049251973629, 0.03518044948577881, 0.02496533840894699, 0.02108015865087509, 0.0033870406914502382, 0.046584103256464005, 0.06529543548822403, 0.04223080724477768, 0.00447748601436615, 0.055520299822092056, -0.021061105653643608, 0.0007197369704954326, 0.020567692816257477, -0.009119123220443726, 0.008801847696304321, 0.03763241693377495, -0.00019119417993351817, -0.04138580709695816, 0.029686661437153816, -0.038896236568689346, 0.041492681950330734, -0.017293859273195267, -0.0007308974745683372, -0.017599444836378098, -0.0392116904258728, 0.040412236005067825, 0.03719722852110863, -0.03933822736144066, -0.014121860265731812, -0.037242915481328964, 0.008520307950675488, -0.010834085755050182, -0.022249314934015274, 0.007588325068354607, 0.031058399006724358, 0.006604129448533058, 0.024504778906702995, 0.02686239220201969, -0.008608076721429825, -0.005803397390991449, -0.03166331350803375, 0.05679501220583916, 0.05764850974082947, 0.04052973911166191, -0.018328223377466202, -0.006201540119946003, -0.03313857689499855, -0.014452737756073475, 0.04330262914299965, -0.00230320799164474, -0.011400852352380753, -0.0661843940615654, 0.021338416263461113, 0.0058378842659294605, 0.005055777728557587, -0.008229203522205353, 0.014228112995624542, 0.011285954155027866, -0.00046685460256412625, -0.09857943654060364, -0.04803217947483063, 0.03568839281797409, -0.003898751689121127, -0.004776433110237122, -0.11123308539390564, 0.005102993920445442, 0.043654125183820724, 0.053433146327733994, -0.0037879832088947296, 0.035736843943595886, -0.01108077634125948, 0.03926088288426399, 0.012296970933675766, -0.039289698004722595, -0.014742288738489151, -0.0037542458157986403, -0.012992531061172485, 0.009317779913544655, -0.08881698548793793, 0.006379737518727779, 0.03072243742644787, -0.0007504879613406956, -0.02669684775173664, 0.04306156188249588, -0.012274933978915215, -0.01963099278509617, -0.024115242063999176, 0.007485445588827133, -0.019214535132050514, 0.0845092236995697, 0.014618165791034698, 0.01628674939274788, 0.020774556323885918, -0.024237317964434624, 0.03020806610584259, 0.028711805120110512, 0.02958768792450428, 0.04628936946392059, -0.009775402955710888, -0.0043762908317148685, -0.021343694999814034, 0.05477923899888992, 0.0015249429270625114, -0.0788380354642868, 0.031079687178134918, -0.002775116590783, 0.013535689562559128, 0.018067076802253723, 0.05501790717244148, 0.007477778475731611, -0.0411895327270031, 0.0294344462454319, -0.07431791722774506, -0.047114867717027664, -0.05954531207680702, 0.027205727994441986, 0.016356201842427254, -0.02405419573187828, 0.0010967155685648322, 0.046182092279195786, 0.0026315650902688503, 0.011267160065472126, -0.019888268783688545, -0.037512052804231644, 0.0018304665572941303, 0.01807827316224575, -0.04288741201162338, 0.0033327769488096237, 0.06129434332251549, 0.03698742762207985, -0.018152596428990364, 0.036754824221134186, -0.023503918200731277, -0.0535949170589447, 0.028263339772820473, -0.019970962777733803, 0.036580417305231094, -0.010972199961543083, -0.00046048907097429037, 0.010546494275331497, -0.02271316759288311, -0.017910027876496315, 0.07169625163078308, -0.059815239161252975, 0.08780348300933838, 0.03666801378130913, 0.022759463638067245, 0.017787404358386993, 0.00587296299636364, 0.028824949637055397, -0.01656929776072502, -0.0024790398310869932, -0.014630586840212345, -0.07017770409584045, 0.008553835563361645, 0.03822168707847595, 0.018253181129693985, -0.0461573526263237, 0.024363020434975624, 0.014555025845766068, 0.01738794334232807, -0.006042457185685635, 0.026572538539767265, -0.01724928431212902, -0.04228321090340614, 0.03391815349459648, 0.027728591114282608, -0.024085836485028267, 0.01100623793900013, 0.04247575253248215, -0.005049862898886204, 0.01645364798605442, 0.01285005547106266, -0.02587069571018219, 0.058740902692079544, -0.04187391325831413, 0.0003785242442972958, 0.019281283020973206, -0.020633988082408905, 0.02774697355926037, -0.03204092010855675, 0.01354327891021967, 0.012181335128843784, 0.008826825767755508, 0.01338375173509121, -0.020087074488401413, -0.021566428244113922, 0.03997102007269859, 0.025474300608038902, -0.045689333230257034, 0.017550496384501457, 0.018541675060987473, -0.036592748016119, -0.005935325752943754, -0.0569213442504406, -0.04138191416859627, -0.029405811801552773, 0.015889445319771767, 0.037166777998209, -0.011048573069274426, 0.019696274772286415, -0.0011791156139224768, -0.05260804295539856, -0.02133610099554062, -0.03047192469239235, 0.01656927540898323, 0.004646522458642721, -0.010339250788092613, -0.017998598515987396, -0.005605957005172968, -0.017946932464838028, -0.0032990642357617617, 0.00022308944608084857, 0.03632217273116112, -0.0047797467559576035, -0.0031470602843910456, -0.02469182014465332, 0.01144540123641491, -0.006094309035688639, -0.01585932821035385, -0.007301650010049343, -0.032474685460329056, 0.02321171574294567, 0.007945932447910309, -0.024972567334771156, 0.06206966191530228, -0.01696625165641308, -0.028465745970606804, -0.009414730593562126, 0.00185966189019382, 0.03380724787712097, -0.04887664318084717, 0.010680168867111206, 0.02564539760351181, -0.040428947657346725, -0.018926113843917847, -0.036496568471193314, -0.05901612341403961, 0.0074139791540801525, -0.01395091600716114, 0.027470411732792854, 0.021227624267339706, -0.011866208165884018, 0.07820098847150803, 0.012755582109093666, -0.00560213765129447, -0.021548915654420853, -0.0022866511717438698, -0.060150712728500366, -0.04369878023862839, 0.009246915578842163, 0.019651655107736588, -0.01282135583460331, 0.03229329362511635, -0.006030149757862091, 0.02614668570458889, 0.03319759666919708, 0.023946186527609825, 0.007986201904714108, 0.0011056085349991918, 0.021381601691246033, -0.03662700206041336, -0.0006609476404264569, 0.010299300774931908, -0.03275864198803902, -0.01415693573653698, 0.023712513968348503, 0.021399743854999542, 0.010689779184758663, -0.02649048902094364, 0.027508368715643883, -0.041802436113357544, 0.007611647713929415, -0.052972983568906784, 0.04999178275465965, 0.01458499301224947, -0.016143377870321274, -0.014985181391239166, 0.007079649716615677, -0.005356550216674805, -0.03158964216709137, 0.013440077193081379, 0.03343315050005913, 0.02159474603831768, -0.005626262165606022, 0.019394593313336372, 0.017538007348775864, 0.007836055010557175, 0.038591135293245316, -0.025938473641872406, 0.005327363032847643, 0.04516397789120674, 0.08582546561956406, 0.030684631317853928, 0.003623147262260318, 0.0033756070770323277, 0.025261059403419495, -0.06560194492340088, -0.017907803878188133, -0.028481781482696533, 0.05319312959909439, -0.0022659956011921167, 0.05154341086745262, 0.03619427978992462, -0.01779160648584366, -0.01097810361534357, 0.010557095520198345, -0.0762660875916481, -0.0037289101164788008, -0.013114191591739655, 0.002139794873073697, -0.006559825502336025, -0.02633609250187874, 0.023377565667033195, -0.007147186901420355, 0.010647526010870934, -0.009553487412631512, 0.03339399769902229, -0.00036417055525816977, 0.02922271564602852, 0.000014605402611778118, -0.015359042212367058, -0.013313124887645245, 0.036965686827898026, 0.028419137001037598, -0.006522644776850939, 0.00592454057186842, 0.061214614659547806, -0.022602587938308716, -0.00862773135304451, 0.003188316710293293, 0.006704227067530155, 0.01886662095785141, 0.037439558655023575, 0.016132989898324013, 0.028066368773579597, -0.03337753564119339, -0.0001146103604696691, -0.0027418588288128376, 0.02477192133665085, 0.04209732636809349, 0.00858271960169077, 0.012270455248653889, -0.026602692902088165, -0.0019637057557702065, -0.014236634597182274, 0.033923353999853134, 0.01560435350984335, -0.02047250047326088, 0.06170377507805824, -0.003189144656062126, -0.027185773476958275, 0.022137820720672607, 0.036310549825429916, -0.011324618943035603, -0.006423867307603359, -0.03461017087101936, -0.013716664165258408, -0.033405691385269165, -0.023775136098265648, 0.0029799439944326878, 0.002796476474031806, -0.005918193142861128, 0.000668118882458657, 0.03495825454592705, -0.009578916244208813, -0.03707025945186615, -0.013238782063126564, 0.05795327574014664, 0.042604368180036545, 0.0033688745461404324, -0.004757166374474764, -0.0037604314275085926, 0.06374496966600418, 0.06593670696020126, 0.026550792157649994, -0.000059055724705103785, -0.05556486174464226, 0.014017132110893726, 0.03210591897368431, 0.044679466634988785, -0.043745387345552444, 0.002633613534271717, -0.030665423721075058, 0.018074864521622658, -0.003237788798287511, -0.046077292412519455, -0.002431954722851515, -0.037614401429891586, -0.0025071059353649616, -0.04332994669675827, -0.00757628446444869, -0.030308527871966362, 0.002977329073473811, -0.0056715975515544415, 0.003416278399527073, -0.03815547376871109, -0.028112279251217842, -0.04296501725912094, -0.027747072279453278, 0.013883432373404503, 0.04227449744939804, -0.013046585954725742, -0.01934102550148964, 0.02566068060696125, 0.03007902018725872, -0.045846082270145416, -0.04360242560505867, -0.0008940605912357569, -0.006257627159357071, 0.01478172093629837, 0.01570889912545681, -0.03360826149582863, -0.029912171885371208, -0.0001229988265549764, -0.006592730060219765, -0.05437351390719414, -0.02094447985291481, -0.02639717422425747, 0.02582290582358837, 0.012370998971164227, 0.01426638849079609, 0.0821998119354248, 0.03221788629889488, -0.0270129032433033, -0.00925939716398716, -0.03640660271048546, -0.01678977906703949, -0.0299819465726614, -0.01708022691309452, -0.042052946984767914, -0.01126912422478199, -0.034662745893001556, 0.012077649123966694, 0.006625967100262642, 0.042863570153713226, -0.025724103674292564, -0.01315069105476141, -0.005498065613210201, 0.0299067422747612, 0.0076415869407355785, 0.017638826742768288, -0.009750662371516228, 0.05384722352027893, 0.042031578719615936, -0.0010277754627168179, 0.04310287907719612, 0.010334200225770473, 0.0214154664427042, 0.014062133617699146, -0.002259358298033476, 0.041721828281879425, -0.02645222097635269, -0.03336484357714653, 0.025977419689297676, -0.03342097997665405, 0.02373596839606762, -0.05932530760765076, 0.007961200550198555, 0.006621017120778561, -0.04887900501489639, -0.009902037680149078, 0.03174319118261337, -0.003842396894469857, 0.05145132914185524, -0.03444673493504524, 0.03724461793899536, 0.014997041784226894, 0.0013755031395703554, -0.0541536919772625, 0.001914971275255084, 0.021556034684181213, -0.0067835296504199505, -0.011046351864933968, -0.009451799094676971, -0.0401526540517807, -0.005595795810222626, -0.013106540776789188, -0.017945358529686928, 0.06261715292930603, 0.05562791973352432, -0.005448366980999708, -0.004441551864147186, 0.01258013490587473, 0.05892431363463402, 0.015220706351101398, -0.004089352209120989, 0.014253256842494011, -0.03034611977636814, 0.0009544513304717839, 0.02211323007941246, 0.03018045984208584, -0.03394279256463051, -0.014510293491184711, 0.019513558596372604, -0.011828630231320858, -0.0194492656737566, 0.0047321137972176075, -0.015066755935549736, 0.006574376951903105, -0.00467359134927392, -0.0032677357085049152, -0.01753658801317215, -0.0032100575044751167, -0.02255350910127163, 0.0390462800860405, -0.018581705167889595, 0.02435123920440674, -0.02105054259300232, 0.00778240105137229, 0.013570799492299557, -0.006226787343621254, -0.04000396281480789, 0.002668802160769701, 0.05616671219468117, -0.04418576508760452, -0.0005234944401308894, -0.02695460058748722, -0.029450323432683945, 0.012622205540537834, 0.025443773716688156, -0.02687934972345829, 0.006429995410144329, 0.06314807385206223, -0.0051333243027329445, 0.005435483064502478, -0.016807550564408302, 0.014931383542716503, 0.045958954840898514, 0.00698702922090888, 0.03505527973175049, 0.011594912968575954, 0.004256988409906626, -0.03327282518148422, -0.03387942165136337, -0.014272958040237427, -0.049463897943496704, 0.011974998749792576, 0.029007229954004288, 0.010140607133507729, -0.00726047158241272, 0.045159924775362015, 0.01074147317558527, 0.016438808292150497, 0.028111008927226067, 0.05164099484682083, 0.022960973903536797, 0.014410446397960186, -0.039201464504003525, -0.016802843660116196, 0.05727381259202957, -0.028502020984888077, 0.019125215709209442, -0.03469743952155113, -0.023343143984675407, 0.059005964547395706, -0.0002686559164430946, 0.010060667991638184, -0.05159253627061844, 0.014242688193917274, -0.00861257966607809, -0.0007552350289188325, -0.005451894365251064, -0.01766609400510788, 0.00891580805182457, -0.019658051431179047, 0.004382843617349863, 0.014034655876457691, 0.03280133381485939, 0.011338954791426659, -0.06861822307109833, -0.051253411918878555, 0.006477556191384792, -0.03536287322640419, 0.006000405177474022, -0.0026138147804886103, -0.06225467100739479, -0.008092302829027176, -0.03821786493062973, 0.020565660670399666, -0.021638819947838783, 0.039469968527555466, -0.04077973961830139, 0.03163016587495804, 0.016726208850741386, 0.00141437747515738, 0.013101219199597836, -0.03714069351553917, 0.12273971736431122, 0.05786577984690666, 0.002473780419677496, -0.07078371942043304, 0.049849528819322586, -0.04927440360188484, 0.01617329567670822, 0.002250228775665164, -0.012016473338007927, 0.01327753160148859, -0.01888391375541687, 0.05982011929154396, 0.0643688440322876, 0.007378523703664541, -0.0133217116817832, 0.058789514005184174, -0.02942047268152237, -0.0593179315328598, -0.027372004464268684, 0.0352921299636364, -0.009046997874975204, -0.034934476017951965, 0.019370464608073235, -0.018681440502405167, 0.00923599861562252, -0.018512576818466187, -0.0025983136147260666, -0.04454750195145607, -0.01974182203412056, -0.0044152685441076756, -0.08689305931329727, -0.0017248248914256692, 0.04361671954393387, -0.015450350008904934, -0.06180531531572342, -0.032711781561374664, -0.020450400188565254, -0.02942650020122528, 0.0032425259705632925, 0.055516380816698074, -0.01338027324527502, -0.004763020668178797, 0.022198887541890144, 0.02659541182219982, -0.026803456246852875, -0.035417020320892334, -0.03412698954343796, 0.047223128378391266, -0.012290481477975845, -0.0029894625768065453, -0.007497536484152079, -0.030221140012145042, 0.003002334386110306, -0.02677682600915432, -0.01724351942539215, 0.01580221578478813, 0.0396168977022171, -0.03441878408193588, -0.02056282013654709, -0.03245290368795395, 0.03005354106426239, -0.007820473052561283, 0.05782076343894005, 0.024542532861232758, -0.03997926041483879, -0.03411336615681648, 0.001306957914493978, 0.02835615538060665, -0.022388124838471413, 0.009747863747179508, 0.030806295573711395, -0.01818486861884594, -0.05187423154711723, 0.001249041873961687, -0.011869465932250023, 0.022255774587392807, 0.0519968643784523, -0.026389585807919502, -0.011857711710035801, -0.00171887397300452, -0.05485117807984352, 0.04757838323712349, -0.03806828707456589, -0.02425536699593067, -0.06184588745236397, -0.017074383795261383, 0.03896071016788483, 0.024930251762270927, -0.010790000669658184, 0.02415122464299202, -0.03258117660880089, 0.03805795684456825, 0.010228979401290417, -0.026899129152297974, -0.026133202016353607, -0.013903781771659851, -0.0232646856456995, 0.026605399325489998, -0.002931735012680292, 0.021957989782094955, 0.015925010666251183, 0.03162084147334099, 0.001711218967102468, 0.021589137613773346, -0.003891744650900364, 0.011708158068358898, 0.021179717034101486, -0.04618482664227486, -0.0054371971637010574, 0.0243349801748991, -0.00929224956780672, -0.008771708235144615, -0.04991074278950691, -0.08309812098741531, -0.024761255830526352, 0.0035328019876033068, -0.015789616852998734, -0.04132593795657158, 0.002533010905608535, -0.04691049084067345, -0.019202323630452156, -0.036297544836997986, -0.02086157724261284, -0.03419896215200424, -0.006053741089999676, 0.004371794406324625, -0.008705425076186657, 0.00469887163490057, -0.004020879976451397, -0.027452046051621437, 0.007724539376795292, 0.0599171407520771, 0.002285867230966687, -0.021415628492832184, 0.02208029106259346, -0.014580800198018551, 0.01750580593943596, 0.029285261407494545, -0.025380706414580345, 0.003737138584256172, 0.07265184819698334, -0.07479306310415268, -0.0531621053814888, 0.024807514622807503, -0.01565871201455593, 0.02870669960975647, 0.028940659016370773, 0.028555186465382576, -0.004845640156418085, -0.0166036244481802, -0.02551501989364624, -0.024941595271229744, -0.006590064615011215, 0.008243134245276451, 0.006369405426084995, -0.005510766990482807, -0.038471560925245285, -0.012171595357358456, -0.004174271132797003, 0.02611420303583145, 0.024720463901758194, 0.030061064288020134, 0.013495412655174732, 0.013199732638895512, 0.019771486520767212, 0.0336923711001873, 0.027556275948882103, -0.002627941779792309, -0.00483480142429471, 0.06712991744279861, -0.016970645636320114, 0.03803955763578415, -0.026776008307933807, -0.010587727651000023, -0.1341620534658432, 0.0012157447636127472, 0.015595642849802971, 0.03399452939629555, -0.010802963748574257, -0.046426381915807724, 0.03516438603401184, 0.007546267006546259, -0.07760641723871231, 0.04372061416506767, -0.03775407373905182, -0.017136970534920692, -0.012144329957664013, -0.020234016701579094, -0.01375349797308445, 0.034608468413352966, 0.04649604111909866, -0.015778416767716408, 0.025140125304460526, -0.040885038673877716, 0.011100062169134617, 0.017213765531778336, 0.03297807648777962, 0.04393085464835167, -0.03786451369524002, -0.03970881178975105, 0.03378443419933319, 0.008139321580529213, -0.03714681416749954, 0.02132151648402214, 0.010493436828255653, 0.04648969694972038, 0.014834186993539333, 0.03649625554680824, 0.02864341251552105, 0.028482668101787567, 0.06698626279830933, -0.000005806522949569626, -0.06688292324542999, 0.020883016288280487, 0.0019472320564091206, 0.038787227123975754, -0.030680140480399132, -0.007246293127536774, 0.002314135665073991, -0.025379998609423637, -0.019856099039316177, 0.0315360501408577, -0.007751476485282183, -0.027044208720326424, 0.011147568002343178, -0.0005707608652301133, -0.009866615757346153, 0.00970199890434742, 0.050415217876434326, -0.03609864413738251, -0.0054378267377614975, -0.0050536771304905415, 0.044123172760009766, -0.006614489480853081, 0.0505959577858448, 0.013374692760407925, -0.034707047045230865, 0.0451359748840332, 0.010341212153434753, 0.00044970421004109085, -0.05693395435810089, -0.029561609029769897, 0.0276584941893816, 0.03173724561929703, 0.009657678194344044, -0.01116155181080103, -0.04797378554940224, 0.025070061907172203, -0.00655064033344388, 0.010427098721265793, 0.003838134231045842, 0.001150858704932034, 0.014424486085772514, -0.07349858433008194, 0.0912037342786789, -0.010787109844386578, -0.012395728379487991, -0.030237190425395966, -0.020576436072587967, -0.03860985115170479, 0.009650463238358498, 0.08891413360834122, 0.035483259707689285, 0.00440623564645648, -0.002182458294555545, 0.050474654883146286, 0.0027535781264305115, -0.057364288717508316, 0.005236439872533083, -0.036415692418813705, -0.021819915622472763, -0.032608624547719955, 0.0055513400584459305, -0.002425351645797491, 0.021935362368822098, 0.011185004375874996, -0.022807803004980087, 0.02686973102390766, 0.006340214516967535, -0.02637721598148346, 0.08395276963710785, 0.01459970511496067, -0.007668464910238981, 0.04521383345127106, -0.014128466136753559, 0.036600906401872635, 0.002136450493708253, -0.03572515398263931, -0.04881557077169418, 0.04802348464727402, -0.02161119505763054, -0.04303554445505142, -0.007835842669010162, 0.032122790813446045, -0.014402047730982304, -0.04730769246816635, 0.008425773121416569, 0.02114543505012989, -0.043252695351839066, -0.019990531727671623, 0.026288433000445366, 0.06437631696462631, 0.017393404617905617, 0.016986848786473274, 0.020869433879852295, 0.010417540557682514, -0.016302572563290596, 0.013295788317918777, 0.027472490444779396, 0.006787903141230345, -0.0018008722690865397, 0.01060996763408184, 0.04370011389255524, -0.030259985476732254, 0.011233219876885414, 0.007052377797663212, 0.04895363748073578, -0.027536513283848763, -0.029768288135528564, 0.02826308086514473, -0.00883830152451992, 0.05412440001964569, 0.003739098319783807, -0.05234640836715698, 0.0908343493938446, -0.01871349662542343, 0.021033912897109985, -0.0010039631742984056, -0.027933306992053986, -0.029175838455557823, -0.020004315301775932, 0.007385565433651209, 0.023513050749897957, -0.01751311682164669, 0.027225889265537262, -0.009781904518604279, 0.005265968386083841, 0.04439970850944519, -0.011972789652645588, 0.004384390078485012, -0.004394135903567076, -0.02205311879515648, -0.04262284189462662, -0.01871027611196041, 0.0006202328368090093, -0.032415226101875305, 0.04042515903711319, 0.05361035838723183, 0.026387764140963554, 0.0028675643261522055, -0.014329939149320126, 0.016503041610121727, 0.05179715156555176, -0.07117899507284164, 0.011902231723070145, -0.027826230973005295, 0.028614327311515808, 0.0011741032358258963, -0.02175406739115715 ]
<p>I have a set of density plots that contain the distribution of stock prices. Each graph has 5 density plots as follows that shows the distribution of monthly returns based on their ratings - a,b,c,d,e. A is the lowest rank while E is the highest rank. I need to come up with a score that tells me how different/away the 'A' plot is from the 'E' plot. i.e. </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/IuwrX.png" alt="Stock price distribution across different ranks"></p> <p>Though the plots don't look very different, they are slightly different in the magnified version. I need to come up with a measure that can compare A's plot with E's plot. Although, mean, median, mode, skewness, kurtosis give the different aspects of a plot, I need one value that summarizes their differences. Any idea on what can be used?</p> <p>Thanks in advance!</p>
74,276
[ -0.05893278121948242, 0.018678482621908188, 0.010935001075267792, 0.017915477976202965, 0.03694945573806763, 0.013996511697769165, -0.02885403297841549, 0.0006184810772538185, 0.02066962979733944, -0.026483304798603058, 0.030723942443728447, 0.027801616117358208, 0.061903901398181915, 0.0638086348772049, 0.0011544774752110243, -0.03268279507756233, -0.03506380692124367, -0.0038941814564168453, -0.0067903874441981316, -0.05051733925938606, 0.007738492451608181, -0.008558009751141071, 0.027926169335842133, 0.0066583724692463875, -0.03981730341911316, 0.05892880633473396, 0.036851510405540466, -0.027836808934807777, 0.008116068318486214, 0.04469810798764229, -0.03877073898911476, -0.046860404312610626, 0.03875647857785225, 0.054194629192352295, 0.05306032672524452, 0.021830148994922638, 0.0015836721286177635, -0.001437068684026599, -0.04285572096705437, 0.009281535632908344, 0.007675092201679945, -0.027020396664738655, -0.021054668352007866, 0.006749945692718029, -0.015257383696734905, -0.021360604092478752, 0.030377347022294998, -0.03714814782142639, 0.020559944212436676, -0.05347352474927902, 0.08885502070188522, 0.0006249623838812113, 0.018003644421696663, 0.027684619650244713, -0.032309625297784805, 0.0007715983083471656, 0.02070564217865467, 0.08788774907588959, 0.010102559812366962, -0.06585382670164108, -0.0236881822347641, -0.028036678209900856, 0.007899053394794464, -0.01648183912038803, -0.03768731281161308, 0.04863680526614189, 0.002367306500673294, -0.0013011310948058963, 0.03159556910395622, 0.010007115080952644, -0.02648170106112957, 0.025750286877155304, 0.05954238399863243, -0.027180057018995285, 0.04116112366318703, -0.04992825165390968, 0.023487171158194542, 0.00854804739356041, 0.07111650705337524, 0.025283774361014366, -0.022465530782938004, 0.017859401181340218, 0.014189774170517921, 0.041590046137571335, 0.03154199570417404, 0.016102267429232597, 0.06274502724409103, -0.02933003567159176, 0.005739941727370024, 0.040792278945446014, -0.019117923453450203, -0.026348082348704338, 0.0512055866420269, -0.009425192140042782, -0.03911089152097702, 0.017747415229678154, -0.00026392043218947947, 0.007528027053922415, -0.012760603800415993, -0.03128845617175102, -0.010194613598287106, -0.050237178802490234, 0.026064228266477585, 0.03229798004031181, 0.018516797572374344, -0.0016802367754280567, -0.03811792656779289, -0.026512904092669487, 0.010671070776879787, 0.01716608554124832, -0.020484555512666702, 0.030603474006056786, 0.023266073316335678, -0.010248493403196335, 0.029392600059509277, -0.021939879283308983, -0.012382240034639835, -0.004723942372947931, 0.020024852827191353, 0.035436276346445084, 0.025552723556756973, -0.021377824246883392, -0.011117725633084774, -0.008182089775800705, -0.04799356311559677, 0.021892685443162918, 0.03340790420770645, -0.00220727501437068, -0.011426676996052265, 0.08168955892324448, -0.036226458847522736, 0.01689726859331131, 0.04907890781760216, -0.031366221606731415, 0.02173573523759842, 0.0011171972146257758, -0.0801490843296051, -0.05596330016851425, 0.023744843900203705, -0.005582663230597973, 0.017138510942459106, -0.03597288206219673, -0.03997967392206192, 0.027082227170467377, 0.00512651028111577, 0.041279491037130356, 0.02945629134774208, -0.023322459310293198, 0.04407879337668419, 0.008816815912723541, -0.010181092657148838, 0.0010644106660038233, -0.02335665002465248, -0.030854597687721252, 0.01238321978598833, -0.039436426013708115, -0.025282885879278183, 0.005948612932115793, -0.041604891419410706, 0.02465093322098255, 0.02921612560749054, 0.0063770972192287445, -0.011785507202148438, -0.009989336133003235, 0.030382942408323288, -0.00595827354118228, 0.054625336080789566, 0.0023407621774822474, 0.020076433196663857, 0.006489706225693226, -0.05825971066951752, -0.0030909839551895857, -0.01728176325559616, 0.011155335232615471, 0.07935134321451187, -0.005880711600184441, -0.01810944266617298, -0.03627863526344299, 0.005073518492281437, -0.011027155444025993, 0.004553142003715038, -0.05026925355195999, -0.051144011318683624, 0.01628282479941845, 0.02252516895532608, 0.017142467200756073, -0.018645823001861572, -0.03753313422203064, 0.04640430957078934, -0.04675379395484924, -0.07097236067056656, -0.06327788531780243, 0.002032408956438303, -0.03578365966677666, -0.054249417036771774, 0.017978845164179802, -0.000384813902201131, 0.01385903637856245, -0.019803684204816818, -0.008931665681302547, 0.0012599286856129766, -0.013571998104453087, 0.04062136635184288, -0.03154148906469345, -0.002860260894522071, 0.03436928242444992, 0.056507375091314316, -0.03934822604060173, 0.025460151955485344, -0.036832451820373535, -0.03206412121653557, 0.003024724079295993, -0.027218671515583992, 0.004227885976433754, 0.009983709082007408, -0.014629777520895004, 0.02859262377023697, 0.04255839064717293, -0.010394052602350712, -0.007813548669219017, -0.029971592128276825, 0.05618106201291084, 0.06407485902309418, -0.010717716999351978, 0.02355683408677578, -0.010823456570506096, 0.0398062989115715, 0.07341029495000839, -0.02686876244843006, -0.001650308258831501, -0.018515191972255707, 0.02143031358718872, 0.029341325163841248, 0.006494615226984024, -0.045339059084653854, 0.02408425882458687, 0.06659957766532898, -0.017511673271656036, 0.038661446422338486, 0.038432829082012177, -0.023330207914114, 0.0054896376095712185, 0.003996225539594889, 0.00461604492738843, 0.0005388975841924548, -0.026237666606903076, 0.047465238720178604, 0.00473850267007947, 0.04698725417256355, -0.029453925788402557, 0.04567465931177139, 0.02515561506152153, -0.018403641879558563, 0.017940081655979156, -0.027116475626826286, -0.03475499898195267, 0.03854922205209732, -0.020479567348957062, 0.0006910875090397894, 0.048182014375925064, -0.021430324763059616, 0.008367226459085941, 0.011678819544613361, -0.04041646048426628, 0.014543844386935234, 0.06342624127864838, -0.026359880343079567, -0.04020436853170395, -0.001162771717645228, -0.02866228297352791, 0.02188028208911419, 0.013040315359830856, 0.0019433236448094249, -0.03822511062026024, 0.017966628074645996, 0.05458444356918335, -0.006727531086653471, 0.01518746092915535, -0.0058862147852778435, -0.05141645297408104, 0.007614952977746725, -0.02042379602789879, -0.01001791749149561, -0.010512777604162693, -0.05246615782380104, -0.002980056218802929, 0.013772189617156982, -0.0019266287563368678, 0.009667315520346165, 0.017875952646136284, -0.0076318588107824326, 0.0042162504978477955, 0.011157991364598274, -0.044263433665037155, -0.009320121258497238, -0.03205135837197304, 0.03928229212760925, -0.017073575407266617, -0.0185120590031147, 0.064217209815979, -0.024700772017240524, -0.008977333083748817, 0.030189771205186844, -0.024748383089900017, -0.013119155541062355, 0.02664562128484249, -0.01586901769042015, 0.018386023119091988, -0.00278933672234416, -0.005840687081217766, 0.03001967817544937, -0.023106124252080917, -0.011953257024288177, -0.06814113259315491, -0.055498428642749786, 0.013054050505161285, 0.0058281864039599895, 0.04133235663175583, -0.000393266644096002, -0.02730407938361168, 0.032591864466667175, 0.04889210686087608, -0.053395647555589676, -0.06474132090806961, -0.009525956586003304, -0.03272997587919235, 0.007303033955395222, 0.03037021867930889, 0.006182233337312937, 0.02592325769364834, -0.014469542540609837, 0.008411774411797523, 0.03712109476327896, 0.025935010984539986, -0.02604915015399456, -0.01626313477754593, 0.042814478278160095, 0.009975040331482887, -0.018207287415862083, 0.046834271401166916, 0.031842030584812164, -0.04477638006210327, -0.005840656813234091, 0.0255599208176136, 0.009275534190237522, -0.02419329434633255, -0.041756656020879745, 0.02222616784274578, 0.0013654045760631561, -0.0010301516158506274, -0.03761330246925354, 0.01484015304595232, 0.03433499485254288, -0.01506548747420311, -0.025121530517935753, 0.008899996988475323, 0.0019887140952050686, 0.006928757764399052, 0.0073097385466098785, 0.09034008532762527, 0.02910691127181053, -0.02154434844851494, -0.01789529249072075, -0.012256317771971226, -0.0023993432987481356, 0.0026960622053593397, -0.028096120804548264, -0.013964585028588772, 0.0511351116001606, -0.006568345706909895, 0.05604265630245209, 0.025262100622057915, -0.08414632827043533, 0.027454271912574768, -0.054892074316740036, -0.005387144163250923, -0.002819337649270892, 0.08980432897806168, 0.01488775946199894, 0.06687399744987488, 0.03656267374753952, 0.005759869236499071, 0.0010759932920336723, -0.004231189843267202, -0.05031026154756546, 0.03174251690506935, -0.009712567552924156, 0.019512305036187172, -0.01698976755142212, 0.001306764897890389, 0.009595023468136787, -0.026856301352381706, 0.02156909368932247, 0.011517445556819439, 0.07002922147512436, -0.033582497388124466, -0.02832401916384697, -0.03286885470151901, 0.0024223430082201958, -0.008960314095020294, 0.00210930104367435, -0.02686314657330513, -0.024317126721143723, 0.05400582775473595, 0.03353504091501236, -0.007839866913855076, 0.0033626805525273085, 0.01382348034530878, 0.010469417087733746, 0.006307648960500956, 0.04190921038389206, -0.0034379956778138876, 0.018955552950501442, 0.0063848961144685745, 0.03246312215924263, 0.00945575162768364, 0.05413845553994179, 0.03833619877696037, -0.010740789584815502, 0.008275850676000118, 0.0068718260154128075, -0.05630696937441826, -0.013189472258090973, 0.022281935438513756, -0.02611590176820755, -0.004534140694886446, -0.0009443647577427328, 0.018430175259709358, -0.054816510528326035, 0.03313739225268364, 0.05390777066349983, 0.03708503767848015, 0.0010469540720805526, -0.013706753961741924, -0.012951860204339027, -0.023716311901807785, -0.029974816367030144, 0.009046345949172974, 0.03484134376049042, -0.004654061049222946, 0.023406513035297394, 0.04496723785996437, -0.02400890365242958, -0.03201167657971382, -0.0269315242767334, 0.0031500121112912893, 0.016307031735777855, -0.03309587389230728, -0.00918219331651926, 0.003348611993715167, 0.00810805894434452, 0.04341614246368408, 0.018213709816336632, -0.0026645746547728777, -0.10184502601623535, -0.009506432339549065, 0.04617927968502045, 0.0283475574105978, -0.002258715685456991, -0.029050549492239952, -0.04640769585967064, -0.008956841193139553, 0.02502070553600788, -0.05493704974651337, 0.003821160877123475, 0.004921909887343645, 0.02593260444700718, -0.019575422629714012, -0.02671060711145401, -0.030964374542236328, 0.05476462468504906, 0.0006964115309529006, 0.017937391996383667, -0.019931238144636154, -0.016631217673420906, -0.04539697617292404, -0.013161365874111652, 0.005017236806452274, 0.044720619916915894, -0.00862391758710146, -0.01879415661096573, -0.012846698984503746, -0.0005126658361405134, -0.021471960470080376, -0.06809108704328537, 0.033939629793167114, -0.011568672023713589, -0.02611374855041504, 0.02351505123078823, -0.02097158506512642, -0.012271630577743053, 0.008531919680535793, -0.002172911772504449, -0.010133503004908562, 0.0005670437822118402, -0.007963009178638458, 0.051099881529808044, 0.0668514221906662, 0.021521085873246193, 0.025783054530620575, 0.026530271396040916, 0.012665117159485817, 0.01761285588145256, -0.014956801198422909, 0.03611880540847778, -0.01907447911798954, -0.01728197932243347, -0.04966701567173004, -0.024938499554991722, -0.04959051311016083, 0.027176162227988243, -0.013832214288413525, 0.05331609398126602, -0.036716755479574203, -0.022927001118659973, 0.0019130560103803873, -0.015308556146919727, -0.005312781780958176, -0.022479267790913582, 0.034366425126791, -0.003911405801773071, -0.011470419354736805, -0.0006510856910608709, 0.055216338485479355, -0.0024457445833832026, -0.019755208864808083, 0.005422473885118961, -0.06172893941402435, 0.012984385713934898, -0.006977426819503307, 0.007460938300937414, -0.01441333070397377, -0.04685341939330101, 0.04247496649622917, -0.020254258066415787, 0.022066807374358177, 0.048034630715847015, -0.029669106006622314, -0.026686612516641617, 0.02532275766134262, 0.01139410212635994, 0.018100611865520477, -0.03712182864546776, 0.01230091042816639, -0.033732712268829346, -0.055727388709783554, -0.05653151869773865, -0.015228603035211563, 0.009766198694705963, 0.03367874398827553, -0.019535807892680168, -0.04699891805648804, -0.01477745920419693, 0.026990674436092377, 0.008253581821918488, -0.010747216641902924, 0.012010185979306698, 0.015871794894337654, -0.008053378202021122, -0.006461636628955603, -0.00382330478169024, 0.11080717295408249, 0.0043921442702412605, 0.009918580763041973, -0.010364657267928123, 0.010035327635705471, -0.011287903413176537, 0.002230939920991659, 0.06592059135437012, -0.021763788536190987, -0.01200910098850727, -0.0008707771194167435, -0.006045502610504627, 0.006898362189531326, -0.017825515940785408, 0.022915417328476906, -0.010609535500407219, -0.0030231771524995565, 0.0037865913473069668, -0.060645218938589096, -0.008510282263159752, -0.03973831236362457, -0.013127582147717476, -0.05678251385688782, 0.010147091932594776, -0.025706697255373, -0.02246166579425335, -0.004024210851639509, 0.026481784880161285, -0.01814562827348709, 0.005863265134394169, 0.08767051994800568, 0.017634853720664978, -0.015899335965514183, 0.029972244054079056, -0.014797153882682323, 0.018341582268476486, -0.021133314818143845, -0.013409259729087353, 0.018784236162900925, 0.02533908374607563, -0.023069994524121284, 0.0016063916264101863, -0.04176168143749237, -0.016768591478466988, 0.046776141971349716, 0.004587954841554165, 0.056061893701553345, 0.03297373279929161, 0.0061168489046394825, -0.022065775468945503, -0.02882298082113266, -0.03082682378590107, -0.008105063810944557, 0.026044052094221115, 0.0619673952460289, -0.016709106042981148, 0.006423745770007372, 0.02044048346579075, 0.03568728268146515, 0.002040119841694832, 0.08256914466619492, 0.031776923686265945, 0.04038672894239426, 0.023289330303668976, -0.007160873617976904, -0.049635034054517746, 0.027171464636921883, -0.016891639679670334, 0.04732203483581543, -0.050881098955869675, -0.03700106218457222, 0.03194817900657654, 0.07212500274181366, -0.033479634672403336, -0.04652227461338043, -0.04374998062849045, -0.04441051557660103, 0.035957835614681244, 0.028831811621785164, -0.04411759227514267, 0.01162533089518547, 0.01765645295381546, 0.04131408780813217, -0.009437520056962967, 0.04262981191277504, -0.032338302582502365, -0.0313994474709034, 0.004844232928007841, -0.04507981985807419, -0.05244600027799606, -0.004400868900120258, -0.0268537737429142, -0.015699241310358047, 0.013676967471837997, -0.014323526062071323, 0.013008136302232742, -0.012861451134085655, -0.0011842494131997228, 0.00011627277854131535, 0.06321508437395096, 0.00008616421109763905, 0.0034699237439781427, -0.0018974534468725324, -0.03336429223418236, 0.12039254605770111, 0.06553249806165695, 0.023232223466038704, -0.03782721981406212, 0.011268247850239277, 0.023271575570106506, 0.019429413601756096, -0.03461705520749092, 0.02172388881444931, 0.009279102087020874, 0.017162121832370758, 0.051853448152542114, 0.06854818016290665, 0.021626317873597145, 0.006323071662336588, 0.06517523527145386, -0.02287617139518261, 0.014177558943629265, -0.010110408999025822, 0.019826151430606842, 0.022520186379551888, 0.0013140204828232527, -0.09787437319755554, 0.013893074356019497, 0.01292767096310854, -0.006394239142537117, -0.05525005981326103, -0.01564338058233261, -0.006821377202868462, 0.02810775674879551, -0.0054697515442967415, 0.04059942811727524, 0.0352368988096714, 0.012893535196781158, -0.001810855115763843, 0.016548460349440575, 0.03120763786137104, -0.030120588839054108, -0.0013026914093643427, -0.009892446920275688, 0.006637750193476677, -0.015519165433943272, -0.014630960300564766, -0.00773696880787611, -0.013964501209557056, -0.02779168076813221, -0.018726153299212456, 0.009332464076578617, 0.006838041823357344, 0.004717264790087938, -0.023524263873696327, 0.014447025023400784, -0.03999946638941765, -0.04287627711892128, -0.036769427359104156, -0.01259689312428236, 0.023178542032837868, 0.010028515011072159, -0.021634578704833984, -0.02548694796860218, 0.007263943087309599, -0.023596150800585747, 0.04307326301932335, -0.009907640516757965, -0.019793814048171043, -0.03709802404046059, -0.05338733643293381, 0.04965026304125786, 0.00004348728180048056, -0.03779691085219383, -0.020092228427529335, -0.020140623673796654, 0.0013849050737917423, -0.012652318924665451, -0.03322150558233261, 0.020395195111632347, -0.0021318027283996344, 0.03412666916847229, -0.01011308841407299, -0.01883595809340477, -0.03290777653455734, 0.039830032736063004, -0.01726158708333969, -0.013815639540553093, -0.0379757285118103, -0.008315893821418285, 0.06493966281414032, 0.04806910455226898, 0.041348282247781754, 0.001110536279156804, -0.01666010171175003, 0.05626850202679634, 0.038640331476926804, -0.04491806402802467, 0.030964286997914314, 0.03396140784025192, -0.04128982126712799, -0.01244343351572752, 0.0013521808432415128, 0.08228202909231186, 0.038199640810489655, -0.011641701683402061, 0.007157223764806986, 0.01930771768093109, -0.03230592608451843, 0.009038691408932209, -0.04134354740381241, -0.05357886850833893, 0.008591425605118275, 0.020874347537755966, -0.04852835461497307, -0.014310206286609173, -0.024718744680285454, -0.024285847321152687, -0.024285685271024704, -0.0025505470111966133, 0.005121189169585705, -0.002455732086673379, -0.025579839944839478, 0.00024956371635198593, 0.0197176281362772, -0.029383251443505287, 0.02492334321141243, -0.026578236371278763, -0.008035514503717422, -0.017972536385059357, 0.013943633995950222, -0.009701231494545937, 0.03542955592274666, 0.0007019173353910446, 0.01989811100065708, 0.028856737539172173, 0.04237375408411026, 0.048180483281612396, -0.010244123637676239, -0.0112143000587821, 0.021252507343888283, 0.06276388466358185, 0.012021608650684357, -0.010106380097568035, 0.04233945533633232, -0.04824371635913849, -0.03668216988444328, 0.011648229323327541, -0.009924729354679585, 0.020813770592212677, 0.010193713009357452, -0.0003599583578761667, -0.026739303022623062, 0.03487967699766159, 0.005242589861154556, -0.01636407896876335, -0.04363476485013962, -0.022846968844532967, 0.0195635873824358, -0.016658848151564598, -0.003583309007808566, -0.022335520014166832, -0.0122441491112113, 0.002048898721113801, 0.024715716019272804, 0.01108501385897398, -0.0008077656384557486, 0.0058289263397455215, 0.013916363939642906, -0.00505834398791194, 0.016797687858343124, -0.01687520369887352, 0.07769465446472168, 0.015480395406484604, -0.046174079179763794, -0.005603015888482332, -0.027287062257528305, 0.013218065723776817, -0.05793410912156105, -0.0060173398815095425, 0.00868495274335146, -0.013448718935251236, 0.02921171858906746, -0.061156366020441055, 0.0016246349550783634, 0.03346262499690056, -0.05338090658187866, 0.06651484221220016, 0.015106439590454102, -0.012602005153894424, -0.025527024641633034, 0.019142519682645798, -0.0013685266021639109, 0.047123491764068604, 0.009678828530013561, 0.027089016512036324, 0.03421981632709503, 0.008923448622226715, 0.0004980217781849205, -0.011444289237260818, 0.007094807457178831, 0.05936635658144951, 0.03132240101695061, -0.08815747499465942, 0.05444822460412979, -0.057517532259225845, -0.02610045112669468, 0.05189335718750954, -0.03541038930416107, 0.017418526113033295, 0.014886082150042057, -0.007705726660788059, 0.035794030874967575, 0.04333707317709923, 0.020624222233891487, 0.009378418326377869, -0.07758867740631104, -0.0043640402145683765, 0.024116691201925278, 0.0060554682277143, -0.02749187871813774, 0.027812743559479713, 0.04963715746998787, -0.01471204124391079, -0.02071186900138855, 0.01534181647002697, -0.02687322348356247, -0.017489373683929443, -0.030501434579491615, -3.865995381602261e-7, 0.03780469298362732, -0.007942572236061096, -0.006792326923459768, -0.032555509358644485, -0.010696242563426495, 0.017505912110209465, -0.010913383215665817, -0.002331347204744816, 0.003772019175812602, 0.02340075746178627, -0.0853194147348404, 0.0027420928236097097, 0.005041718482971191, -0.017144840210676193, -0.030793776735663414, -0.022384408861398697, -0.0020687291398644447, 0.011619902215898037, -0.008120285347104073, -0.02576901577413082, 0.0007450631819665432, 0.022946836426854134, -0.041110798716545105, -0.030171191319823265, 0.014296823181211948, 0.0007790887029841542, -0.0017774871084839106, -0.10047714412212372, 0.0284162275493145, 0.004216842819005251, -0.04116230085492134, -0.02954602800309658, 0.010654955171048641, -0.037276506423950195, 0.02993006445467472, 0.030042966827750206, 0.018840519711375237, 0.016423482447862625, -0.015049700625240803, 0.016227375715970993, 0.03478202596306801, -0.09676080197095871, 0.022694747895002365, -0.011806339025497437, -0.03318195044994354, -0.009940048679709435, 0.02180812507867813, 0.013098210096359253, 0.0064744772389531136, 0.03487664833664894, -0.011926645413041115, -0.02521022967994213, 0.0130591606721282, -0.02398366667330265, 0.0424138642847538, -0.01545580755919218, -0.0531422384083271, 0.036573901772499084, -0.007975608110427856, -0.0027128984220325947, 0.0038435752503573895, 0.01664535142481327, -0.034306637942790985, 0.05297652259469032, -0.027526915073394775, -0.03891339153051376, 0.015450874343514442, -0.008259064517915249, 0.0030780748929828405, -0.05706222727894783, -0.006624091882258654, 0.02419080212712288, -0.034372441470623016, 0.00016564202087465674, 0.03372745215892792, -0.00770092336460948, 0.044232264161109924, -0.02627868950366974, 0.013560403138399124, 0.009662148542702198, -0.03313900902867317, 0.004071336705237627, -0.006651649717241526, 0.043004997074604034, 0.0055282386019825935, 0.023299891501665115, 0.004810999147593975, -0.042234405875205994, 0.01482438761740923, -0.0038569997996091843, 0.01738751120865345, -0.007782681379467249, -0.014369821175932884, 0.03971977159380913, -0.008235802873969078, 0.01476582232862711, 0.00735281128436327, -0.019983530044555664, 0.034127380698919296, -0.023212479427456856, 0.0033615175634622574, -0.019061174243688583, 0.020202526822686195, -0.056733112782239914, 0.034684691578149796, 0.03207207843661308, 0.001927945762872696, 0.01694713532924652, 0.029198983684182167, 0.0049745733849704266, 0.013262234628200531, 0.03016538918018341, -0.02138100564479828, 0.05939428508281708, -0.02279740758240223, 0.0005798338097520173, 0.038243357092142105, -0.014112134464085102, -0.051692791283130646, -0.03843140974640846, 0.02690798230469227, -0.007690710481256247, 0.006090870592743158, 0.003983041737228632, -0.04362746328115463, -0.0008318630279973149, 0.05672283470630646, -0.033724404871463776, -0.0377243347465992, -0.02322048880159855, 0.00699312798678875, 0.0043905023485422134, -0.018256105482578278 ]
<p>This is data cleaning and preparation stage question for me. I apologize if the question is basic, but I am a beginner. I have a dataset of a bit less than 4500 records. This is a survey and <code>year of birth</code> is an important field. Now 670 records do not have this information. I am inclined to think that I should treat this field as 'unknown' but I wanted to ask you a question: Does it ever make sense to impute year of birth? </p> <p>Perhaps you could also point me to any readings about whether demographic data can or should be imputed? Many thanks for your thoughts.</p>
37,090
[ -0.037049297243356705, -0.0429479144513607, 0.003763296641409397, 0.005266264081001282, 0.02730102278292179, -0.030382370576262474, -0.022126728668808937, 0.0010674387449398637, -0.023415900766849518, -0.010427713394165039, 0.023196173831820488, 0.017005449160933495, 0.04041854292154312, -0.03365278244018555, -0.0021507630590349436, 0.03011617809534073, 0.0012099677696824074, -0.0005026169819757342, -0.02483198419213295, 0.0237303227186203, 0.005323191173374653, 0.027734186500310898, 0.001924464013427496, -0.021105654537677765, -0.04573560878634453, 0.033942848443984985, 0.008420746773481369, -0.04370448365807533, -0.010395077988505363, 0.03401314839720726, -0.032917656004428864, -0.033859677612781525, -0.004471936728805304, -0.0015055673429742455, 0.06103993207216263, 0.016058417037129402, -0.04784317687153816, -0.03892800211906433, 0.00333894370123744, 0.04493202641606331, -0.05607606843113899, 0.02809067629277706, 0.034537624567747116, 0.032730646431446075, 0.006126009859144688, 0.027360284700989723, -0.013911746442317963, 0.034354884177446365, 0.01684131659567356, -0.03563384339213371, 0.012976083904504776, -0.03539090231060982, 0.02893727831542492, 0.05203152075409889, -0.023303449153900146, -0.014061844907701015, 0.04356389865279198, 0.05499767139554024, -0.002072921022772789, -0.03282257169485092, -0.03429175168275833, -0.016709135845303535, -0.02331291139125824, 0.004532751627266407, 0.004260930232703686, 0.012100700289011002, -0.004350543487817049, -0.025161005556583405, 0.047614723443984985, -0.033810023218393326, 0.039118051528930664, -0.005417513195425272, 0.041760094463825226, 0.006645450834184885, 0.040067579597234726, -0.04904913529753685, 0.033960096538066864, 0.011687860824167728, 0.0052054887637495995, 0.019352227449417114, -0.04308559373021126, 0.0027813424821943045, 0.049823109060525894, 0.007116718217730522, -0.0077269477769732475, -0.0013119123177602887, 0.06319760531187057, -0.04588667303323746, -0.003796783508732915, -0.009819149039685726, -0.025936435908079147, -0.008291400969028473, 0.030063172802329063, -0.009236055426299572, -0.01620727777481079, 0.021564653143286705, -0.04430544376373291, 0.06781994551420212, -0.014333409257233143, -0.003574464237317443, -0.0014801020734012127, -0.0062392293475568295, 0.033507708460092545, 0.05412834510207176, -0.053693320602178574, -0.0031187378335744143, -0.03404741361737251, -0.012158723548054695, -0.010284488089382648, -0.044084757566452026, 0.0033563929609954357, -0.005601589102298021, 0.011361452750861645, -0.00861359853297472, 0.03332541510462761, -0.008036119863390923, -0.02654671110212803, -0.008144348859786987, 0.06200822815299034, 0.01670634187757969, 0.031575094908475876, -0.042841553688049316, 0.06513287872076035, -0.021497024223208427, -0.03606294468045235, -0.020915644243359566, 0.011523617431521416, -0.006307884119451046, -0.018117863684892654, 0.04925768822431564, -0.0019344822503626347, -0.03978601098060608, 0.04703136533498764, -0.024361636489629745, 0.05752398818731308, 0.030282169580459595, -0.07419547438621521, -0.060728102922439575, -0.006652052979916334, -0.012440256774425507, 0.012301175855100155, -0.04013528302311897, 0.012746972031891346, -0.0015414230292662978, 0.01591417007148266, -0.01360243558883667, 0.02735777199268341, 0.02428797446191311, 0.035490598529577255, 0.030453579500317574, -0.006506378296762705, -0.04747982323169708, -0.005252195056527853, -0.017443731427192688, -0.011756790801882744, -0.06258656084537506, 0.03998517245054245, 0.011407975107431412, 0.015228438191115856, -0.03763347119092941, 0.04274463281035423, 0.047763027250766754, 0.017623092979192734, 0.04196082055568695, 0.05261749029159546, -0.05228886380791664, 0.0866934210062027, 0.016700325533747673, 0.018882591277360916, 0.037094272673130035, -0.008185152895748615, 0.0756269171833992, 0.05891257897019386, 0.02093212679028511, 0.06023791432380676, -0.02694086916744709, -0.020770497620105743, 0.0008582133450545371, 0.03666790574789047, -0.01019223127514124, -0.04059555009007454, -0.0379985049366951, 0.006397377233952284, -0.02700098603963852, 0.04023028537631035, 0.014877796173095703, -0.0005446635186672211, -0.038262661546468735, 0.05581130087375641, -0.041426170617341995, -0.033654145896434784, -0.05845021829009056, 0.018962141126394272, 0.011091318912804127, -0.005697425454854965, 0.032537806779146194, -0.008065124973654747, -0.0000012216531786179985, -0.04616687446832657, -0.03720206767320633, -0.022661101073026657, -0.03125627711415291, 0.053532298654317856, -0.035862017422914505, -0.02069930173456669, 0.00481964647769928, 0.024274293333292007, -0.00526229664683342, 0.05832508206367493, -0.055126335471868515, -0.025134360417723656, 0.011438299901783466, -0.027718741446733475, 0.02867722325026989, -0.03745533153414726, -0.0010196119546890259, -0.02589368261396885, 0.005082030314952135, -0.02217109315097332, 0.02892381325364113, -0.046754151582717896, 0.07624775171279907, 0.06441324949264526, -0.024676872417330742, -0.03088110126554966, 0.031726110726594925, 0.0186648927628994, 0.017932884395122528, -0.008218493312597275, -0.016253236681222916, -0.06565641611814499, -0.019813109189271927, 0.02980881556868553, -0.028132643550634384, -0.03287910297513008, -0.027537349611520767, 0.04756542667746544, 0.03807816281914711, 0.011927534826099873, -0.005381453316658735, -0.010692212730646133, -0.021928947418928146, 0.018676457926630974, -0.002743061166256666, -0.009466422721743584, 0.05016476660966873, 0.015491299331188202, -0.011411773040890694, 0.03677888214588165, -0.002745233941823244, 0.019424039870500565, 0.037296272814273834, 0.008598522283136845, -0.01844756305217743, -0.023557046428322792, 0.01614820584654808, 0.020401522517204285, -0.042053308337926865, 0.025078866630792618, 0.0266847126185894, -0.018153702840209007, 0.00005316975148161873, 0.011645101942121983, -0.0005287257372401655, 0.006907631643116474, 0.0018981288885697722, -0.044096216559410095, 0.028975939378142357, 0.015479483641684055, -0.053830087184906006, 0.002240765606984496, 0.01503700576722622, -0.037531670182943344, -0.027471477165818214, 0.012533956207334995, 0.06336656957864761, 0.01343059167265892, 0.027576684951782227, -0.04438420385122299, -0.023643627762794495, -0.022784018889069557, -0.0006340950494632125, 0.03356970101594925, 0.055157020688056946, -0.05350663512945175, -0.03280659392476082, 0.014185307547450066, -0.01752464845776558, 0.05820063129067421, -0.02578437700867653, -0.03285994380712509, 0.015814900398254395, 0.016118623316287994, -0.019460761919617653, -0.03281515836715698, -0.037311725318431854, -0.000379745673853904, -0.0005202427855692804, 0.011149734258651733, 0.005883269477635622, 0.021506963297724724, 0.01791330799460411, -0.012204683385789394, -0.039986174553632736, -0.03812730312347412, -0.015089478343725204, -0.0230767410248518, 0.025648783892393112, -0.0257097277790308, 0.010604293085634708, 0.008962510153651237, -0.003937366884201765, 0.0020602091681212187, -0.0406765341758728, -0.07665819674730301, 0.06482227891683578, -0.01241868082433939, 0.012772821821272373, 0.023912349715828896, 0.011906420812010765, 0.06860901415348053, 0.043280478566884995, -0.0480186864733696, -0.0198860764503479, -0.04007353261113167, 0.005011151544749737, 0.003402064787223935, 0.02806936390697956, 0.017706716433167458, 0.01298630889505148, -0.009964969009160995, -0.014613384380936623, 0.01978551410138607, 0.038833994418382645, -0.001075737178325653, 0.04513084515929222, 0.013354683294892311, -0.017544865608215332, 0.000048644400521880016, 0.03945440426468849, 0.024865178391337395, -0.058210477232933044, 0.03322073817253113, -0.04634806141257286, 0.06451955437660217, 0.036791812628507614, -0.04470895603299141, -0.00933458749204874, -0.021984081715345383, 0.02416282705962658, -0.03830872103571892, 0.01939959079027176, 0.017101021483540535, -0.006758725270628929, -0.00018508886569179595, -0.025329619646072388, 0.009725969284772873, -0.013104628771543503, -0.027634115889668465, 0.06635862588882446, -0.007424829062074423, 0.009153003804385662, 0.03859835863113403, -0.015388884581625462, -0.00975674856454134, 0.03568820282816887, -0.00251721846871078, 0.0077094123698771, 0.0350382924079895, 0.07034320384263992, -0.0034400157164782286, -0.013734402135014534, -0.043271005153656006, 0.03663092851638794, -0.06994561851024628, -0.015361580066382885, -0.012621449306607246, 0.025532269850373268, 0.0023807110264897346, 0.033641453832387924, 0.035131294280290604, 0.03232262283563614, -0.018697766587138176, 0.03148750588297844, -0.017043616622686386, -0.027485352009534836, -0.0056038107722997665, 0.006333753000944853, -0.023541880771517754, -0.005239582154899836, 0.033629730343818665, -0.022849606350064278, -0.037095941603183746, 0.005624179262667894, 0.015991846099495888, -0.062408383935689926, 0.025202104821801186, -0.0029637364204972982, 0.021731985732913017, -0.024768611416220665, 0.00981336273252964, 0.027621759101748466, 0.014280008152127266, 0.014815573580563068, 0.04163133725523949, 0.04969518631696701, -0.07595378905534744, -0.06373636424541473, -0.04060766473412514, 0.002064387546852231, 0.07571815699338913, 0.005698114633560181, 0.015277392230927944, -0.08176087588071823, 0.027356363832950592, 0.009844264946877956, 0.00006525382923427969, 0.03204086050391197, 0.006942339241504669, -0.0359521247446537, -0.04164179041981697, -0.003948251251131296, -0.01678498461842537, 0.008865103125572205, 0.007210779469460249, 0.038008663803339005, 0.03017488680779934, 0.010859943926334381, -0.05968223139643669, 0.012794607318937778, 0.10547304898500443, 0.008570563979446888, 0.02243351936340332, -0.024648591876029968, 0.01684672012925148, -0.026533987373113632, -0.018167367205023766, 0.0054972912184894085, 0.0564093254506588, 0.01765061728656292, -0.015284116379916668, 0.03966304287314415, -0.029784616082906723, -0.011008820496499538, 0.03737161308526993, 0.02434903010725975, 0.06687691807746887, 0.01027253270149231, -0.02212674729526043, 0.07307978719472885, 0.04805364832282066, 0.06834302097558975, 0.011581899598240852, 0.027538878843188286, -0.10394778847694397, -0.030977658927440643, 0.02344106137752533, 0.036635033786296844, -0.04865669831633568, -0.011185566894710064, -0.04636741429567337, -0.026423683390021324, 0.03811459243297577, -0.01929197832942009, -0.016339050605893135, -0.01539827510714531, -0.024258194491267204, -0.007352154236286879, -0.018407870084047318, 0.01107857283204794, 0.00751798739656806, 0.014913494698703289, 0.024831445887684822, 0.0066012307070195675, -0.025158610194921494, -0.03082159534096718, 0.009807435795664787, 0.01824028231203556, 0.04628470540046692, 0.000713169458322227, -0.032031308859586716, 0.01959460787475109, 0.03857489675283432, -0.03401874378323555, -0.019808143377304077, 0.01940276101231575, -0.01948048733174801, 0.011506355367600918, 0.05439736321568489, -0.00628605205565691, -0.036338746547698975, 0.005498746410012245, 0.006568952929228544, -0.026935391128063202, 0.010170560330152512, -0.028066525235772133, 0.015797412022948265, -0.0020321812480688095, 0.007218474987894297, 0.04175085946917534, 0.059110306203365326, 0.0016845491481944919, 0.05243286117911339, -0.0474725216627121, -0.013739832676947117, -0.03266116604208946, -0.015164906159043312, -0.04652826860547066, 0.012583752162754536, -0.004350528120994568, 0.023045837879180908, 0.003912489861249924, 0.035528115928173065, -0.03618638217449188, -0.004694699309766293, 0.029387500137090683, 0.01812751777470112, 0.005116085056215525, 0.04530269652605057, -0.03345895931124687, -0.01673535443842411, -0.009420687332749367, -0.024541016668081284, 0.005834946408867836, 0.015338601544499397, -0.0007398303132504225, -0.021272234618663788, -0.015854766592383385, 0.025742020457983017, -0.03060513734817505, -0.05099988356232643, 0.04194335639476776, -0.016372675076127052, 0.04737846925854683, 0.023245863616466522, 0.015718242153525352, -0.023468762636184692, -0.045308150351047516, 0.002043018816038966, -0.00037151537253521383, -0.0118772117421031, 0.06802135705947876, -0.04444655776023865, 0.021627848967909813, -0.009518621489405632, 0.021701646968722343, -0.06621036678552628, -0.03664024919271469, 0.0078054154291749, 0.02819012477993965, -0.03531194105744362, -0.005574379116296768, 0.03384267911314964, 0.021658867597579956, -0.005304550286382437, 0.019272170960903168, 0.0891992375254631, 0.009624547325074673, -0.03445403650403023, -0.017242461442947388, 0.022284988313913345, 0.0995730310678482, -0.021854477003216743, 0.036386772990226746, 0.024128714576363564, -0.04336371272802353, 0.015520409680902958, -0.011984651908278465, 0.027447883039712906, -0.016390683129429817, -0.043858274817466736, -0.023205529898405075, -0.0174111220985651, 0.04307203367352486, -0.015132125467061996, -0.00027421285631135106, 0.01328390184789896, -0.005675976164638996, -0.015220319852232933, -0.011151687242090702, 0.003497430356219411, -0.05833430960774422, -0.01988331414759159, -0.02559221349656582, 0.03430965542793274, 0.0068141501396894455, 0.0038335092831403017, 0.029325494542717934, -0.020903708413243294, -0.03194153308868408, 0.02664337120950222, 0.007553831208497286, -0.025515608489513397, -0.004462612792849541, -0.0008429196896031499, -0.033236950635910034, 0.009796413592994213, 0.02281045727431774, 0.00833000335842371, -0.0041559175588190556, 0.03156773000955582, -0.052287306636571884, -0.03993633762001991, -0.02270575799047947, -0.04399005323648453, 0.06100078299641609, -0.019878964871168137, 0.017680611461400986, 0.019303422421216965, 0.0002685965446289629, 0.005192532669752836, 0.0034441223833709955, -0.01700669154524803, 0.00788064207881689, -0.04145926237106323, 0.015789838507771492, 0.008287199772894382, -0.003440442495048046, 0.03370735049247742, -0.038844525814056396, 0.033186979591846466, 0.03363414853811264, 0.005424902308732271, 0.04511261731386185, 0.021212154999375343, -0.019076474010944366, -0.02753291092813015, -0.011131778359413147, -0.019813172519207, 0.004853297024965286, -0.008871899917721748, -0.021806715056300163, 0.03869781270623207, -0.0037875697016716003, 0.0070681143552064896, -0.02265651524066925, -0.02606745809316635, -0.0331956148147583, -0.016222679987549782, 0.03175292909145355, 0.01576520875096321, 0.027387728914618492, -0.010407127439975739, 0.04562480375170708, -0.0032328194938600063, 0.01778416521847248, 0.00704444432631135, -0.05101964622735977, -0.0639888197183609, -0.04900389164686203, -0.048340871930122375, 0.026435833424329758, -0.005641367752104998, 0.01588604971766472, 0.0008773932349868119, -0.018865328282117844, -0.005640017334371805, -0.029279088601469994, 0.05356156826019287, -0.03213663771748543, 0.06294965744018555, 0.026608070358633995, 0.02735527604818344, -0.008623192086815834, 0.04208960384130478, 0.12342852354049683, 0.09127666056156158, 0.07527834177017212, -0.06314247101545334, 0.023832838982343674, 0.02264585718512535, -0.023354727774858475, -0.0022298938129097223, 0.019126644358038902, -0.029877139255404472, -0.03944694995880127, 0.042319249361753464, 0.01842917874455452, 0.020690573379397392, 0.025047877803444862, 0.03539581969380379, -0.018138661980628967, -0.027312442660331726, -0.012257033959031105, 0.027367813512682915, 0.005789769347757101, -0.027171650901436806, -0.018932346254587173, -0.02318083681166172, 0.043237678706645966, 0.009641651064157486, -0.013489291071891785, -0.003937022760510445, -0.006225057411938906, 0.006977415177971125, -0.02610253356397152, 0.04121507331728935, 0.021314134821295738, 0.011743846349418163, -0.018012767657637596, -0.05452249199151993, -0.022126350551843643, -0.034209735691547394, -0.015977852046489716, 0.03026958741247654, -0.044634804129600525, -0.0065847234800457954, 0.01660541072487831, 0.03208380937576294, -0.05695780739188194, -0.016334224492311478, 0.01454051211476326, -0.013007375411689281, -0.03354254364967346, -0.019412828609347343, -0.03094954416155815, -0.010266613215208054, -0.021930627524852753, -0.03468979895114899, -0.013835026882588863, 0.03609726205468178, 0.03926895931363106, 0.022211367264389992, -0.03822406008839607, -0.00719279982149601, 0.014398095197975636, 0.0018319074297323823, 0.01028631441295147, 0.030077479779720306, -0.03562045842409134, -0.007650316227227449, -0.038695354014635086, 0.04179295152425766, 0.016425440087914467, -0.015557718463242054, 0.004404662176966667, -0.018099403008818626, -0.03415989503264427, 0.008964736945927143, 0.013111225329339504, 0.00730988010764122, 0.03263799846172333, -0.04689224809408188, 0.004332134034484625, -0.01946909725666046, -0.049344856292009354, 0.004288438241928816, 0.023540029302239418, 0.004457702860236168, -0.07051647454500198, 0.025159649550914764, 0.002465230645611882, 0.002543500391766429, -0.01868838630616665, 0.05207126960158348, 0.0069327880628407, 0.065849170088768, -0.006961548235267401, -0.04691217839717865, -0.005590167827904224, 0.003648424753919244, -0.053024906665086746, 0.031574636697769165, -0.011147642508149147, 0.04564584419131279, 0.008029229938983917, 0.024440107867121696, 0.041088007390499115, 0.029919948428869247, 0.008083997294306755, 0.037323303520679474, -0.0001352684193989262, -0.08755936473608017, 0.0003592957800719887, -0.04067787528038025, 0.02915942668914795, -0.04049774259328842, -0.04128427803516388, -0.016373058781027794, 0.008045564405620098, 0.0029649261850863695, -0.02097475714981556, -0.05084991082549095, 0.02136673405766487, -0.02071598544716835, -0.03468210995197296, -0.03154244273900986, 0.02177884615957737, -0.058091334998607635, -0.024076351895928383, 0.00214783544652164, -0.049597132951021194, 0.01267409510910511, -0.0057882461696863174, -0.0038957977667450905, 0.01697656884789467, 0.0076221078634262085, -0.012940618209540844, -0.012391746044158936, 0.019339825958013535, -0.004436188843101263, -0.017043469473719597, 0.03477688878774643, -0.048801153898239136, 0.002030928386375308, 0.010527507402002811, -0.05135292932391167, -0.04864215850830078, 0.06433054804801941, 0.02327604964375496, 0.0186508446931839, -0.001572960871271789, 0.006119427736848593, -0.002926841378211975, 0.06413775682449341, -0.01909923553466797, -0.008088921196758747, -0.03550323098897934, 0.023099888116121292, 0.004695102106779814, 0.0019150006119161844, -0.008126492612063885, 0.0294785313308239, -0.021184468641877174, 0.04580783471465111, 0.012037775479257107, 0.022079475224018097, -0.044515036046504974, 0.019706936553120613, 0.015267479233443737, 0.0017484509153291583, 0.02453380450606346, -0.019068989902734756, 0.03563684970140457, 0.03601578250527382, -0.020718887448310852, 0.022730248048901558, 0.02870018035173416, -0.026740659028291702, -0.06437209248542786, -0.004585613030940294, 0.04050500690937042, 0.03196705877780914, 0.031237997114658356, -0.027417806908488274, -0.011315634474158287, 0.010993018746376038, -0.058578647673130035, 0.01848219707608223, -0.00405058404430747, 0.02573538012802601, -0.01157552283257246, 0.009038668125867844, -0.01061313133686781, -0.026057053357362747, 0.02872164361178875, 0.03418852388858795, 0.012464643456041813, 0.018073298037052155, -0.004110611043870449, -0.02611689269542694, -0.04295135661959648, 0.025487516075372696, 0.015056201256811619, -0.06527037173509598, 0.026744602248072624, -0.05143411457538605, -0.0029298835434019566, 0.030978761613368988, -0.03860387206077576, 0.028734058141708374, 0.03131665661931038, 0.013594426214694977, -0.009228812530636787, 0.012410499155521393, 0.0541217178106308, -0.0492662712931633, -0.0074384575709700584, 0.06087842211127281, 0.015531686134636402, 0.04688305780291557, -0.016937976703047752, 0.025599079206585884, -0.005365744233131409, -0.04189518839120865, 0.009409853257238865, 0.023463860154151917, -0.029925433918833733, 0.03603138402104378, 0.008649144321680069, -0.013128533959388733, -0.010480181314051151, 0.015272264368832111, 0.02501974254846573, -0.019739659503102303, 0.021320249885320663, 0.04255538433790207, 0.03865700960159302, 0.0025694635696709156, 0.013487815856933594, -0.017475029453635216, -0.05150391906499863, 0.011557557620108128, 0.016476726159453392, -0.01792954094707966, -0.010035024024546146, 0.003112742444500327, 0.006858294364064932, 0.000465118937427178, -0.002620050683617592, -0.014438889920711517, -0.031351614743471146, 0.07597395777702332, -0.02327066659927368, -0.01875028945505619, 0.031002255156636238, -0.03616541251540184, 0.006882586516439915, -0.056393954902887344, 0.05146821215748787, 0.010740862227976322, 0.01407383382320404, -0.016040125861763954, -0.025139009580016136, -0.01941167376935482, 0.0015592240961268544, 0.04967007040977478, -0.006696586962789297, -0.01341168861836195, -0.02169107273221016, -0.020908931270241737, 0.0006305045098997653, -0.019356362521648407, 0.046780817210674286, 0.00007527657726313919, -0.007714501116424799, 0.010984241031110287, -0.0020272776018828154, -0.02209385484457016, -0.0028990500140935183, -0.0111774243414402, 0.008377909660339355, 0.013071256689727306, 0.03777999430894852, -0.00912351906299591, 0.010442199185490608, 0.02340320125222206, 0.0005508811445906758, 0.026847578585147858, -0.007989414967596531, -0.0016166934510692954, 0.06856399774551392, 0.02190622128546238, -0.07610155642032623, 0.0332312248647213, -0.04600806534290314, -0.025160344317555428, 0.008838864974677563, 0.03030507080256939, -0.03078637272119522, -0.028051311150193214, 0.011207295581698418, 0.03696439415216446, -0.02539725974202156, -0.0060821883380413055, 0.0006789450417272747, 0.017984377220273018, 0.05214463174343109, 0.019602442160248756, 0.015444760210812092, 0.02916267141699791, -0.04201851412653923, 0.008586086332798004, -0.004584708251059055, 0.0024967873468995094, 0.029419410973787308, 0.012197169475257397, 0.017353398725390434, 0.043911173939704895, 0.0032146619632840157, 0.011273189447820187, 0.04317665100097656, -0.03770723193883896, -0.027555370703339577, -0.01957608573138714, 0.03472741320729256, 0.008756633847951889, 0.04297671094536781, -0.01617700420320034, 0.018207291141152382, -0.018306100741028786, 0.008645456284284592, -0.04574571177363396, -0.011755448766052723, -0.042546436190605164, -0.012157506309449673, 0.011818059720098972, 0.018973013386130333, 0.001992386532947421, -0.030825212597846985, -0.007885079830884933, -0.0034961975179612637, 0.039024267345666885, -0.06388767808675766, -0.005737082101404667, -0.017161808907985687, -0.02279779128730297, -0.03536103293299675, -0.027974046766757965, -0.039484281092882156, -0.006017593201249838, 0.030957292765378952, 0.03234422206878662, 0.04054725170135498, -0.0008055528160184622, -0.029149547219276428, 0.0013103284873068333, -0.007842961698770523, -0.041644129902124405, 0.0008295794250443578, -0.03923792764544487, -0.0019008833914995193, 0.007043797522783279, -0.05223511904478073 ]
<p>Take this example:</p> <pre><code>data &lt;-matrix(c(227,751,193,541), ncol=2) column1 &lt;- c(227, 751) probabilities &lt;- c( 193/(193+541), 541/(193+541) ) chisq.test(data) chisq.test(column1, p= probabilities) </code></pre> <p>when i apply the chi-squared test providing a matrix the results says that this is a</p> <blockquote> <p>Pearson's Chi-squared test with Yates' continuity correction</p> </blockquote> <p>and provides a p-value of 0.158.</p> <p>when i perform the second chi-squared, providing the first column of the matrix and the probabilities calculated from the second column the both the results and the name of the test change dramatically:</p> <blockquote> <p>Chi-squared test for given probabilities</p> </blockquote> <p>the reported p-value is 0.028.</p> <p>considering that i am trying to determine if the two datasets i have (columns in the matrix) are <strong>NOT</strong> different from each other:</p> <p><strong>what is the difference between these two tests? which one should i use?</strong></p>
74,277
[ -0.04109198972582817, -0.0016249219188466668, -0.018287640064954758, -0.021808303892612457, 0.018429908901453018, 0.020436692982912064, 0.023375293239951134, -0.020179808139801025, 0.004674082156270742, -0.003944010473787785, 0.053489234298467636, 0.05593347176909447, 0.05106658488512039, 0.01319491770118475, 0.036011550575494766, 0.046198222786188126, 0.010626851581037045, 0.011418484151363373, -0.0100365299731493, 0.015224206261336803, -0.007640632800757885, -0.0002494004147592932, 0.003003904363140464, -0.003847160842269659, -0.018261266872286797, 0.07573974132537842, 0.006068599876016378, -0.02908131293952465, -0.0035170793998986483, 0.06198406592011452, -0.0668657124042511, -0.02372366189956665, 0.007501353044062853, -0.007513039745390415, -0.012231015600264072, -0.017742576077580452, -0.006922129541635513, -0.013747011311352253, 0.0010177827207371593, 0.03490355238318443, -0.025030512362718582, 0.0031569821294397116, 0.009153202176094055, 0.05542663857340813, -0.015827063471078873, 0.012408677488565445, 0.019370246678590775, -0.030592143535614014, -0.0016414299607276917, -0.028706703335046768, 0.06991533190011978, -0.008374002762138844, 0.06337007880210876, 0.03724833205342293, -0.05017561838030815, -0.016202103346586227, 0.02713838592171669, 0.06167192757129669, -0.026226801797747612, -0.082278773188591, -0.004754336550831795, -0.027619292959570885, 0.021677939221262932, -0.030899187549948692, -0.05334910377860069, 0.02518485113978386, -0.02292785607278347, -0.04873742535710335, 0.023458926007151604, -0.03129364550113678, -0.0029940526001155376, 0.046999216079711914, 0.028255579993128777, -0.03832069784402847, 0.03928900510072708, -0.03833526000380516, -0.011493459343910217, 0.03558977693319321, 0.03608512505888939, 0.03393550589680672, 0.004599298816174269, 0.019231636077165604, 0.011629047803580761, 0.02852555364370346, 0.02962547354400158, -0.02325708605349064, 0.03436895087361336, -0.04262443259358406, -0.02014443837106228, 0.02808896079659462, -0.009723198600113392, 0.018697818741202354, 0.042633652687072754, 0.03752058744430542, -0.02209617756307125, 0.04594636335968971, -0.02907690964639187, 0.034802019596099854, -0.02583344280719757, -0.013921824283897877, -0.007071461528539658, -0.035242825746536255, 0.04956062138080597, 0.025552643463015556, -0.055350810289382935, 0.00029866493423469365, -0.023480359464883804, 0.00915538053959608, -0.0019431686960160732, -0.01497589610517025, 0.0013693360378965735, 0.0677521601319313, -0.030997471883893013, 0.0314486026763916, 0.01202938798815012, -0.048096995800733566, -0.03588588908314705, 0.008607127703726292, 0.05628274008631706, 0.07926160842180252, 0.05557956546545029, -0.03386849910020828, -0.010664877481758595, -0.05035564303398132, -0.043637655675411224, 0.01471354253590107, 0.01453110110014677, 0.014056769199669361, -0.06500526517629623, 0.027802567929029465, -0.016693999990820885, -0.020534265786409378, 0.011459526605904102, -0.004851462785154581, 0.033408649265766144, -0.002476655412465334, -0.09094603359699249, -0.04444148764014244, 0.03542442247271538, -0.02364812046289444, -0.01903005689382553, -0.04667492210865021, 0.018508249893784523, 0.016822293400764465, 0.06279910355806351, 0.007461084984242916, 0.04904095456004143, -0.018093857914209366, 0.01587090641260147, 0.014584803022444248, -0.025465019047260284, 0.013775262050330639, -0.03604119271039963, -0.016725197434425354, -0.0030868761241436005, -0.03475548326969147, 0.03347313776612282, 0.022786855697631836, -0.004939015954732895, 0.01507127657532692, 0.007017735857516527, -0.010223554447293282, 0.02446058578789234, -0.005882074125111103, 0.015633469447493553, -0.028650464490056038, 0.07770285755395889, 0.026437005028128624, 0.02040639892220497, 0.04286806285381317, -0.03508443757891655, 0.021189222112298012, -0.007662531919777393, 0.06293754279613495, 0.05641794204711914, -0.014630918391048908, -0.011537538841366768, 0.0368986614048481, 0.030910419300198555, 0.00423266738653183, -0.060896143317222595, -0.021505599841475487, -0.018122807145118713, -0.02688925340771675, 0.02135658450424671, 0.06463261693716049, 0.014835561625659466, -0.0352814644575119, 0.06503558903932571, -0.048729605972766876, -0.0386294461786747, -0.06740038841962814, 0.02491467446088791, 0.004065851215273142, -0.048231855034828186, 0.0023350866977125406, 0.008591250516474247, 0.018224356696009636, 0.01373363845050335, -0.005622196942567825, -0.037860579788684845, 0.0013211967889219522, 0.024475719779729843, -0.05385024845600128, -0.01987207494676113, 0.04731530323624611, 0.014638775028288364, -0.020458418875932693, 0.04387984797358513, -0.020991887897253036, -0.0553770512342453, 0.035639043897390366, -0.04501069709658623, 0.0038482192903757095, 0.004291126038879156, -0.026646649464964867, 0.013271602801978588, -0.002281209686771035, -0.022710153833031654, 0.03320378437638283, -0.0604315921664238, 0.05054159462451935, 0.03931288421154022, 0.013175422325730324, -0.003834288800135255, -0.014234843663871288, -0.009896960109472275, 0.020180514082312584, -0.015217822045087814, 0.023709511384367943, -0.047712769359350204, 0.0116306496784091, 0.036165814846754074, 0.017055340111255646, -0.05729689449071884, 0.01757354848086834, 0.0378098338842392, -0.02455255202949047, 0.003512621158733964, 0.04122794792056084, 0.0021494252141565084, -0.04221433401107788, 0.008068021386861801, 0.019167594611644745, -0.005954494699835777, 0.008435838855803013, 0.027098892256617546, -0.006208677310496569, 0.034453123807907104, -0.015255708247423172, -0.018893176689743996, 0.05249549075961113, -0.039805565029382706, -0.019337499514222145, -0.03149290010333061, -0.03792349249124527, 0.035478487610816956, 0.010721486993134022, 0.001345966593362391, 0.014115698635578156, -0.007879926823079586, -0.03531996160745621, -0.02617238461971283, -0.029381077736616135, 0.04061855748295784, 0.03505591303110123, -0.05057475343346596, 0.01515292376279831, 0.018384946510195732, -0.021143555641174316, 0.029103128239512444, -0.0323074609041214, -0.0044730352237820625, -0.037736766040325165, 0.039708975702524185, 0.03338102251291275, -0.003128248732537031, 0.045089732855558395, -0.003176841652020812, -0.019745968282222748, -0.012483418919146061, -0.043228909373283386, -0.001564021105878055, -0.013751409016549587, -0.039793163537979126, -0.017795125022530556, -0.06549446284770966, -0.02060520648956299, 0.023892076686024666, 0.002924228087067604, -0.033600639551877975, 0.02654057927429676, -0.004113764967769384, 0.0019928920082747936, 0.001849282649345696, -0.04598540440201759, 0.013641227968037128, 0.010161792859435081, -0.023030169308185577, 0.04121948778629303, -0.02179381251335144, -0.031636182218790054, 0.0486830398440361, -0.039884451776742935, -0.0036063455045223236, -0.002282052068039775, -0.008057991974055767, 0.022288916632533073, -0.006999894045293331, -0.015583926811814308, 0.03229747712612152, -0.01590004190802574, -0.005485369358211756, -0.06426610052585602, -0.029263319447636604, 0.004487913567572832, -0.014142166823148727, 0.016301438212394714, 0.03312789276242256, 0.010321867652237415, 0.0742197185754776, 0.04282733425498009, -0.02743525430560112, -0.03616105765104294, 0.01630587689578533, -0.09294240921735764, -0.03472980856895447, 0.009003394283354282, 0.011389926075935364, 0.015261530876159668, 0.01975828967988491, -0.012309105135500431, 0.046688735485076904, 0.04378756880760193, 0.0039001714903861284, -0.007530601229518652, 0.010664127767086029, -0.0023182511795312166, -0.057907216250896454, 0.03024301864206791, -0.015887700021266937, -0.023260056972503662, -0.012321911752223969, 0.013851124793291092, 0.020329199731349945, -0.01903904788196087, -0.02952846698462963, -0.0036676533054560423, -0.010633699595928192, 0.0362725630402565, -0.024232802912592888, 0.05622345209121704, 0.01605219952762127, -0.018447190523147583, 0.00979252252727747, 0.03690554201602936, -0.0015472607919946313, -0.025893470272421837, 0.004435470327734947, 0.058619141578674316, 0.016369659453630447, -0.0407743938267231, 0.019938522949814796, 0.0011635690461844206, -0.024382075294852257, 0.03373289108276367, -0.05819447338581085, -0.03810780122876167, 0.05696503072977066, 0.0272842925041914, 0.03983238339424133, 0.032989513128995895, -0.05033387243747711, 0.03327879309654236, -0.05546753108501434, 0.021696792915463448, -0.010090606287121773, 0.049347829073667526, 0.005990010220557451, 0.07542328536510468, 0.034378230571746826, -0.0040289256721735, 0.014431541785597801, -0.006878562271595001, -0.060379479080438614, 0.029615972191095352, 0.019130706787109375, -0.03179178014397621, 0.007601824123412371, -0.028791023418307304, 0.011716246604919434, -0.026401281356811523, 0.02958604320883751, 0.030306106433272362, 0.00026632644585333765, -0.06741984188556671, 0.051012951880693436, -0.02422894723713398, 0.029881132766604424, -0.01092820055782795, -0.007435905747115612, 0.023779088631272316, 0.005031929817050695, 0.05064472556114197, 0.03150646388530731, -0.015460129827260971, 0.04205750674009323, 0.022089067846536636, 0.025279520079493523, 0.04100508242845535, 0.03789210319519043, 0.02639061212539673, 0.04378815367817879, -0.03048512153327465, 0.004090263973921537, -0.005467170383781195, 0.013044405728578568, 0.04958268254995346, -0.0159593615680933, -0.002105092164129019, -0.05394069105386734, 0.004540847148746252, 0.014136097393929958, 0.02521250583231449, 0.011335991322994232, -0.009920674376189709, 0.03475283086299896, 0.04874617978930473, -0.029412178322672844, 0.027097957208752632, 0.05674178525805473, 0.04146936163306236, -0.012987726368010044, -0.013990594074130058, -0.011523648165166378, -0.038923535495996475, -0.05085402727127075, 0.012567905709147453, 0.01874077133834362, 0.011382183991372585, -0.005273180082440376, 0.035468898713588715, -0.031087391078472137, -0.05020866543054581, -0.010436039417982101, 0.0122368847951293, 0.013736104592680931, -0.007995338179171085, -0.0217619426548481, 0.01246175728738308, 0.04761728644371033, 0.008185509592294693, 0.02551909349858761, -0.0018633382860571146, -0.0673828274011612, 0.009255625307559967, 0.06672683358192444, 0.020702654495835304, -0.03607555851340294, -0.03422512859106064, -0.04151465743780136, -0.016189202666282654, 0.023135604336857796, -0.043795567005872726, 0.06170925870537758, -0.02329697087407112, 0.006442796438932419, -0.01793655939400196, 0.007078405935317278, -0.057344935834407806, 0.008392680436372757, -0.01063954085111618, 0.048849575221538544, -0.01840364933013916, -0.04783444106578827, -0.043504748493433, 0.00029366626404225826, 0.02419288642704487, 0.01986611820757389, -0.046296436339616776, -0.015864567831158638, 0.012009440921247005, 0.03002096153795719, 0.001125627662986517, -0.05567391589283943, 0.012773524038493633, -0.006001340691000223, 0.0020690332166850567, 0.04702271148562431, 0.008320590481162071, -0.00973688904196024, -0.0021008960902690887, -0.02741927281022072, -0.03555869311094284, 0.014257565140724182, 0.006351875141263008, 0.024518372491002083, 0.027785079553723335, 0.013435048051178455, 0.05500150844454765, 0.011605012230575085, -0.004649856127798557, 0.017038444057106972, -0.060780901461839676, -0.002942530205473304, -0.034581508487463, -0.023942381143569946, -0.06951835006475449, 0.016642263159155846, -0.028648726642131805, 0.01306616235524416, 0.018986696377396584, 0.02012820728123188, -0.0314914807677269, 0.01531051192432642, 0.023451749235391617, 0.03377169370651245, -0.011951470747590065, -0.0038936324417591095, 0.028509890660643578, 0.011072445660829544, -0.022805722430348396, 0.0175612885504961, 0.0394921600818634, -0.012846896424889565, -0.02126113325357437, 0.008467262610793114, -0.035128477960824966, 0.024528633803129196, 0.0014119569677859545, -0.002414155285805464, 0.015249984338879585, -0.018054954707622528, 0.010756751522421837, -0.0019808390643447638, 0.04695219174027443, -0.0022909799590706825, -0.047297678887844086, -0.01833113096654415, 0.034980978816747665, -0.016886001452803612, -0.007966993376612663, -0.044433385133743286, 0.07568638026714325, 0.010019611567258835, -0.004531169310212135, -0.04889412969350815, -0.04655657708644867, -0.01503912266343832, 0.04078885167837143, -0.03958487510681152, -0.05143800005316734, -0.038323402404785156, -0.011411063373088837, -0.015064514242112637, -0.02819102071225643, 0.032475546002388, 0.0020286361686885357, -0.02418096736073494, 0.002892198506742716, 0.01667853444814682, 0.06240454688668251, 0.010845433920621872, 0.001566183753311634, -0.00017165072495117784, -0.01709028147161007, 0.008645214140415192, 0.011954969726502895, -0.009387446567416191, -0.018189040943980217, -0.029365014284849167, -0.028330713510513306, 0.01897956058382988, 0.053080663084983826, -0.011122838594019413, -0.014192907139658928, 0.024400796741247177, -0.03530624881386757, 0.01524457149207592, -0.02257802151143551, 0.020062627270817757, -0.06004464998841286, 0.010464133694767952, -0.01127498596906662, -0.02188594453036785, -0.007308891974389553, -0.024806879460811615, 0.010335809551179409, -0.0008502835989929736, -0.03834640234708786, 0.01781873032450676, 0.04618195444345474, -0.03842473402619362, 0.010842987336218357, -0.027249962091445923, 0.01419813558459282, 0.03532594069838524, 0.02631431818008423, 0.001817208481952548, -0.009779182262718678, 0.02535981684923172, 0.005409629549831152, -0.010559200309216976, -0.01995106227695942, 0.009295310825109482, 0.021893108263611794, -0.0007435714942403138, 0.04955625906586647, 0.06575599312782288, 0.008569439873099327, 0.02177920565009117, -0.01286233589053154, -0.006609225180000067, -0.039295900613069534, 0.00766204996034503, 0.056717399507761, -0.009310934692621231, -0.023607715964317322, 0.06113673374056816, 0.036876458674669266, 0.011094226501882076, 0.029999636113643646, 0.0176214799284935, -0.00428207591176033, 0.024031203240156174, -0.0020886349957436323, -0.011221141554415226, 0.04022188484668732, -0.04199111461639404, 0.040461815893650055, -0.04603017866611481, 0.0007632279885001481, 0.058821409940719604, 0.041693080216646194, -0.01115398295223713, -0.008154847659170628, 0.005549371708184481, -0.035972654819488525, 0.002116334391757846, 0.01872856169939041, -0.01927981898188591, 0.004217749461531639, 0.000244895345531404, 0.04106549918651581, -0.0016131269512698054, 0.017866022884845734, -0.03311431035399437, -0.05389373004436493, -0.046273667365312576, -0.015892302617430687, -0.012203356251120567, 0.04865698516368866, 0.007964166812598705, -0.046146925538778305, 0.006777196191251278, -0.04689853638410568, 0.029355552047491074, 0.024189770221710205, 0.04859303683042526, -0.030723828822374344, 0.03624607250094414, -0.025903083384037018, 0.01532182190567255, 0.021562892943620682, -0.04041549563407898, 0.1069856584072113, 0.0940527394413948, 0.03083817847073078, -0.06316862255334854, 0.037901800125837326, 0.01477100420743227, 0.023181231692433357, -0.020574189722537994, -0.009463426657021046, 0.002777337795123458, 0.028204122558236122, 0.06258437037467957, 0.06763816624879837, 0.04730627313256264, -0.004837356973439455, 0.037406545132398605, -0.032198403030633926, -0.036168422549963, 0.006048531271517277, 0.018883880227804184, -0.03386666253209114, -0.05595465376973152, -0.01987643539905548, 0.002769269747659564, 0.05039595067501068, 0.003225709544494748, -0.010144254192709923, -0.023302428424358368, 0.0009154420113191009, 0.01627715490758419, -0.021896444261074066, 0.013309190049767494, 0.025544408708810806, 0.0173158198595047, -0.013385677710175514, 0.010834094136953354, 0.008772734552621841, -0.015450096689164639, 0.012049146927893162, 0.03449976071715355, -0.0038344687782227993, -0.024901116266846657, 0.023255014792084694, 0.05391953885555267, -0.04788557067513466, -0.015873907133936882, -0.056871697306632996, 0.053698521107435226, -0.002803545445203781, -0.052755698561668396, -0.003702682675793767, -0.003998382482677698, -0.02767959237098694, -0.0473535917699337, -0.013826394453644753, 0.01951083168387413, -0.00686619384214282, 0.00310700130648911, -0.012306107208132744, -0.04105331748723984, 0.05590305104851723, -0.0095108887180686, 0.01835663616657257, 0.02952094003558159, -0.04996885731816292, -0.021027816459536552, -0.01944255456328392, 0.06691788882017136, -0.048554427921772, 0.021202582865953445, 0.02279416099190712, -0.004349249880760908, -0.04139925539493561, -0.009811473079025745, 0.013745954260230064, 0.016665363684296608, 0.020428117364645004, -0.004302740562707186, -0.004150921944528818, -0.007228691130876541, -0.04385640472173691, 0.01371732261031866, 0.002594174351543188, -0.009819796308875084, -0.03605744615197182, -0.01768888719379902, 0.04402937740087509, 0.0170174241065979, 0.012635631486773491, 0.0039128768257796764, -0.019095906987786293, 0.049099814146757126, 0.00176135019864887, -0.04547516629099846, -0.04665932431817055, -0.020373189821839333, -0.014535590074956417, -0.012476380914449692, -0.029490554705262184, 0.04160288721323013, 0.0269766878336668, 0.00829064566642046, -0.042007602751255035, 0.01903069019317627, -0.004103620070964098, -0.00849427841603756, 0.021231237798929214, -0.01951240934431553, -0.021739289164543152, 0.02647627331316471, -0.01788494922220707, -0.01899980567395687, -0.023414306342601776, -0.06987110525369644, -0.04647468402981758, 0.03442556411027908, -0.020484954118728638, -0.02406853251159191, -0.029922373592853546, -0.014976396225392818, -0.015376242808997631, -0.015165562741458416, -0.0023456949274986982, -0.061016786843538284, 0.0021213351283222437, -0.0011524638393893838, -0.039442263543605804, -0.011212526820600033, 0.0203436017036438, -0.024685697630047798, 0.004961845465004444, 0.028970958665013313, 0.008442950434982777, -0.007023399230092764, 0.0031345875468105078, 0.005143419839441776, 0.004263621289283037, 0.038349200040102005, -0.00494352774694562, -0.0071931560523808, 0.043073318898677826, -0.06345852464437485, -0.04342995584011078, 0.016223391517996788, -0.022517995908856392, 0.031031636521220207, 0.0014830866130068898, -0.005739359185099602, 0.02746569737792015, 0.05273720994591713, -0.03569812327623367, -0.03133298456668854, -0.010230889543890953, -0.009066320955753326, -0.022358233109116554, -0.014370239339768887, 0.006664683111011982, -0.0033958149142563343, -0.02191789634525776, 0.046287793666124344, 0.060695961117744446, 0.0021682686638087034, -0.0021518066059798002, -0.04059603810310364, 0.022062998265028, 0.0410311184823513, 0.040121812373399734, -0.030615927651524544, 0.023537835106253624, 0.033534254878759384, -0.03556746616959572, 0.006962413899600506, -0.012598590925335884, 0.023671548813581467, -0.09641330689191818, -0.02164696343243122, 0.01724124141037464, 0.004998854361474514, 0.013512719422578812, -0.07412835955619812, 0.06071688234806061, 0.03876177594065666, -0.04197188839316368, -0.013967832550406456, -0.013937548734247684, 0.012367233633995056, -0.00988628901541233, 0.06241566315293312, -0.01365822833031416, 0.03323647007346153, 0.06049685180187225, -0.0006862127338536084, 0.0407162643969059, -0.0038892587181180716, 0.011121346615254879, 0.009126193821430206, -0.00045128524652682245, 0.009129585698246956, -0.0025086121167987585, -0.06585299968719482, 0.003147508017718792, -0.01644284278154373, -0.04980175569653511, 0.04727189242839813, -0.011278132908046246, 0.02298799529671669, 0.0312860868871212, 0.02799157053232193, 0.03844169154763222, 0.02871536836028099, 0.032231371849775314, 0.007495683152228594, -0.025002121925354004, 0.016353704035282135, 0.0031076231971383095, 0.02055836282670498, -0.011667746119201183, -0.0018637166358530521, 0.033657219260931015, -0.03406606614589691, -0.00003202242805855349, 0.015666784718632698, -0.037600066512823105, 0.006439962424337864, -0.04614201560616493, 0.023042183369398117, 0.026914574205875397, -0.016388682648539543, 0.027302227914333344, -0.05227059870958328, 0.007857179269194603, 0.030665989965200424, 0.048856306821107864, -0.01405998133122921, 0.030610933899879456, -0.002827888820320368, -0.034023530781269073, 0.03748566657304764, -0.004072383511811495, 0.013957870192825794, -0.03181285411119461, -0.05219385772943497, -0.007886840030550957, -0.005121382884681225, 0.0042484356090426445, -0.018739143386483192, -0.04622853174805641, 0.04277316853404045, -0.010208605788648129, 0.016766857355833054, 0.017430348321795464, 0.029966015368700027, 0.034839414060115814, -0.1085495725274086, 0.021349145099520683, 0.011037744581699371, -0.04221015051007271, -0.02566056326031685, 0.02222197689116001, -0.08910048007965088, 0.021147213876247406, 0.048901427537202835, 0.046997878700494766, 0.00792484451085329, -0.006145636551082134, 0.017937546595931053, -0.0237971730530262, -0.04760679975152016, 0.022343577817082405, -0.009501968510448933, -0.023175420239567757, -0.02101634070277214, -0.01286219246685505, 0.05057363957166672, 0.03391972556710243, -0.025839662179350853, -0.017573172226548195, -0.021585868671536446, 0.025091692805290222, -0.0060884119011461735, 0.056107550859451294, -0.007588978391140699, -0.03073394112288952, 0.03164035454392433, -0.031830862164497375, 0.03303349390625954, 0.04247830808162689, -0.0035583029966801405, -0.023722372949123383, 0.05199214816093445, -0.007828609086573124, -0.03721793368458748, 0.042277853935956955, -0.0024929719511419535, -0.03243856877088547, -0.04833902418613434, -0.011735852807760239, 0.02267654798924923, -0.04090719297528267, -0.0066040935926139355, 0.013964222744107246, 0.03912053629755974, 0.01818065345287323, 0.014882773160934448, 0.01999473385512829, 0.011043957434594631, -0.021442288532853127, -0.002343082567676902, 0.012066567316651344, 0.019174041226506233, -0.003241524565964937, 0.008307565934956074, 0.02628832682967186, -0.02189926616847515, 0.0021979704033583403, -0.013811266981065273, 0.03580597788095474, -0.009958227165043354, 0.004090314265340567, -0.01656310074031353, -0.03228345885872841, 0.011419803835451603, -0.00045536443940363824, -0.03201458975672722, 0.027575574815273285, -0.029029428958892822, 0.001964617520570755, -0.019334232434630394, -0.008087560534477234, -0.01512006763368845, -0.008718463592231274, 0.032421477138996124, 0.024228908121585846, -0.0036609871312975883, 0.00878339447081089, 0.016897939145565033, -0.03788232430815697, -0.0003423334565013647, -0.04166239872574806, -0.003642408875748515, -0.03527042642235756, 0.014977699145674706, -0.04063151404261589, 0.017498327419161797, 0.00023596834216732532, 0.001162261702120304, 0.04886199161410332, 0.026267159730196, 0.01828082650899887, -0.06659896671772003, -0.019370753318071365, 0.013576588593423367, 0.010401757434010506, -0.05146150290966034, -0.013322221115231514, -0.019718768075108528, 0.03548845648765564, -0.004949462134391069, -0.030141431838274002 ]
<p>In my project, one of my objectives is to find outliers in aeronautical engine data and chose to use the Replicator Neural Network to do so and read the following report on it (<a href="http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.12.3366&amp;rep=rep1&amp;type=pdf" rel="nofollow">http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.12.3366&amp;rep=rep1&amp;type=pdf</a>) and am having a slight understanding issue with the step-wise function (page 4, figure 3) and the prediction values due to it.</p> <p>The explanation of a replicator neural network is best described in the above report but as a background the replicator neural network I have built works by having the same number of outputs as inputs and having 3 hidden layers with the following activation functions:</p> <ul> <li>Hidden layer 1 = tanh sigmoid S1(θ) = tanh, </li> <li>Hidden layer 2 = step-wise, S2(θ) = 1/2 + 1/(2(k − 1)) {summation each variable j} tanh[a3(θ −j/N)] </li> <li>Hidden Layer 3 = tanh sigmoid S1(θ) = tanh, </li> <li>Output Layer 4 = normal sigmoid S3(θ) = 1/1+e^-θ</li> </ul> <p>I have implemented the algorithm and it seems to be training (since the mean squared error decreases steadily during training). The only thing I don't understand is how the predictions are made when the middle layer with the step-wise activation function is applied since it causes the 3 middle nodes' activations to be become specific discrete values (e.g. my last activations on the 3 middle were 1.0, -1.0, 2.0 ) , this causes these values to be forward propagated and me getting very similar or exactly the same predictions every time.</p> <p>The section in the report on page 3-4 best describes the algorithm but i have no idea what i have to do to fix this, i don't have much time either :(</p> <p>Any help would be greatly appreciated. </p> <p>Thank you</p>
74,278
[ -0.02773233875632286, -0.0350850448012352, -0.017073312774300575, 0.016861625015735626, 0.04681747406721115, -0.013585139065980911, 0.006245065480470657, -0.025813689455389977, 0.008616813458502293, -0.0703575387597084, 0.04335379973053932, 0.01570850983262062, 0.03143369406461716, 0.037450678646564484, -0.0017353720031678677, -0.0345747210085392, -0.024670757353305817, 0.01199911255389452, 0.03521457314491272, -0.028289129957556725, 0.010550985112786293, 0.06373198330402374, -0.03888632357120514, -0.0465538427233696, -0.006201024632900953, 0.02946767583489418, -0.00464820209890604, -0.0068818735890090466, 0.017334500327706337, 0.0384313128888607, -0.041105274111032486, 0.0037622221279889345, 0.0031261914409697056, 0.04931075498461723, -0.00797144416719675, 0.02593148685991764, -0.009712593629956245, -0.002751856343820691, -0.01099320687353611, 0.0035510454326868057, -0.00881730392575264, -0.01319139078259468, -0.017283234745264053, 0.05703742802143097, 0.005584036000072956, 0.002107290318235755, -0.013758031651377678, -0.003797344397753477, 0.03335077688097954, -0.03598586469888687, 0.10328004509210587, 0.001708103809505701, 0.0067428965121507645, 0.04643312469124794, -0.016583774238824844, 0.001971376594156027, 0.05410948395729065, 0.058338504284620285, 0.023590466007590294, -0.02386697567999363, -0.008997648023068905, -0.020535459741950035, -0.021709024906158447, 0.0107957748696208, -0.008489876054227352, 0.022823452949523926, -0.002311339136213064, -0.032706547528505325, -0.0031247592996805906, -0.040224868804216385, 0.019145412370562553, -0.01982497237622738, 0.01631450094282627, 0.01986554078757763, -0.001339346170425415, 0.024450769647955894, -0.011491958983242512, 0.007886569947004318, 0.057339996099472046, 0.03675561398267746, 0.01746242679655552, -0.0033257389441132545, -0.013049203902482986, 0.02552499808371067, 0.022441554814577103, 0.009950052946805954, 0.06748607009649277, -0.010033836588263512, 0.0015907807974144816, 0.03048105165362358, -0.009758129715919495, 0.03323132172226906, 0.022715499624609947, -0.019124025478959084, -0.014445791952311993, 0.005200355313718319, -0.003753894241526723, 0.000029889475626987405, 0.016532648354768753, -0.01175996195524931, -0.0047570280730724335, -0.0698920264840126, -0.025053203105926514, 0.018373390659689903, -0.03292302042245865, -0.023301199078559875, -0.030238168314099312, -0.018257997930049896, -0.028528887778520584, -0.029203034937381744, -0.029192669317126274, 0.017898114398121834, -0.002671667607501149, 0.009728369303047657, -0.008431384339928627, 0.020380910485982895, -0.014013340696692467, -0.03277752548456192, -0.009384081698954105, 0.04790683463215828, 0.04192749410867691, -0.014197736978530884, 0.04749421030282974, -0.018512561917304993, -0.042654313147068024, 0.0013200620887801051, 0.018541069701313972, -0.049980685114860535, -0.014887805096805096, 0.05116556957364082, 0.04023446887731552, -0.03587879613041878, 0.016896013170480728, 0.022446006536483765, 0.024144722148776054, -0.007638296112418175, -0.058897245675325394, -0.05918534845113754, 0.033447880297899246, -0.04607373848557472, 0.04588931426405907, -0.05993444845080376, 0.004030114505439997, 0.058281753212213516, 0.05164886638522148, 0.025355560705065727, -0.018029620870947838, 0.031871043145656586, 0.0431530624628067, 0.03621095046401024, -0.024361884221434593, -0.005843237042427063, -0.04716533049941063, -0.010870377533137798, -0.08790390938520432, -0.04492689296603203, 0.01687019318342209, 0.008944110944867134, -0.024770794436335564, 0.003862261539325118, 0.0333334319293499, 0.012083028443157673, 0.013773651793599129, -0.006110398564487696, -0.013550006784498692, -0.018798718228936195, 0.0891277939081192, 0.034159764647483826, 0.018353717401623726, 0.017034465447068214, -0.03711886331439018, -0.01760290190577507, -0.021646806970238686, 0.050312869250774384, 0.016197796911001205, 0.00042543598101474345, -0.0007447134703397751, -0.03742547333240509, 0.006929576862603426, -0.0073971981182694435, -0.0235440693795681, -0.03849449381232262, -0.006663609761744738, -0.008803513832390308, 0.001500180922448635, 0.035966381430625916, 0.003039640374481678, 0.008939501829445362, 0.03866196051239967, -0.027678389102220535, -0.05796277895569801, -0.02282324992120266, 0.026909276843070984, -0.04728946089744568, -0.026328785344958305, -0.009045357815921307, -0.03799375891685486, 0.05049357935786247, -0.003940089605748653, 0.005528662819415331, -0.04248881712555885, 0.005507669877260923, 0.024302871897816658, 0.02545006386935711, 0.04274668172001839, 0.04376313090324402, -0.010698726400732994, 0.020765041932463646, 0.04658811539411545, -0.02215161919593811, -0.013454954139888287, 0.005360330455005169, -0.04681655019521713, -0.017810408025979996, -0.024651097133755684, -0.02931123971939087, 0.048504091799259186, -0.0017274690326303244, 0.025436680763959885, 0.008373548276722431, -0.07026541978120804, 0.03327033296227455, 0.04351327195763588, 0.0026776459999382496, 0.007159794215112925, 0.046861402690410614, -0.03645419701933861, 0.039614927023649216, -0.021152593195438385, -0.021694064140319824, -0.047323308885097504, -0.05635984614491463, 0.009265029802918434, 0.04097921401262283, -0.014186755754053593, 0.01912292279303074, 0.05238060653209686, -0.006062681786715984, 0.02643970586359501, -0.0022379164583981037, -0.0069830999709665775, -0.00708251865580678, 0.038962360471487045, -0.016995830461382866, 0.016095472499728203, 0.025659602135419846, -0.005342593416571617, -0.0034733593929558992, 0.024479493498802185, 0.006208128295838833, -0.012343144044280052, 0.034676339477300644, 0.009360585361719131, -0.011539558880031109, -0.03516365587711334, 0.017355775460600853, 0.014810658991336823, -0.014997335150837898, -0.0019410306122153997, 0.03598965331912041, -0.004665804095566273, -0.003700758097693324, -0.01788795366883278, -0.0350666418671608, 0.0028000189922749996, 0.04743995517492294, 0.01031877938657999, -0.0024703308008611202, 0.015362714417278767, -0.02961057983338833, 0.01141095720231533, -0.05056853964924812, -0.0029616302344948053, 0.010129842907190323, 0.03178883343935013, 0.04938682168722153, -0.0010925279930233955, 0.0039598350413143635, -0.021363480016589165, 0.0064913504756987095, 0.002995953895151615, -0.0012712357565760612, 0.03879178687930107, 0.002799669746309519, -0.034020040184259415, 0.00011784490197896957, -0.00014619420107919723, 0.017527451738715172, 0.019701266661286354, 0.023497680202126503, -0.026499703526496887, 0.02035483717918396, -0.03651472553610802, -0.06702128797769547, -0.002919930499047041, -0.06977783888578415, -0.0009287671418860555, 0.0012458298588171601, -0.03167014569044113, 0.03605376183986664, 0.012940853834152222, -0.03352085500955582, 0.03682926669716835, -0.020340939983725548, -0.01054180134087801, -0.01657879166305065, -0.008327752351760864, -0.0025391438975930214, -0.022455208003520966, 0.016436705365777016, 0.017957881093025208, -0.021473625674843788, 0.001274149282835424, -0.07673582434654236, -0.03142384812235832, -0.006554705556482077, -0.0033835002686828375, 0.01868567056953907, 0.0008062411798164248, 0.023405862972140312, 0.07902207970619202, -0.015884317457675934, -0.02761983498930931, -0.01641874387860298, 0.025250069797039032, -0.020971352234482765, -0.06940697133541107, 0.023025210946798325, 0.014588936232030392, 0.02517147734761238, 0.006054635159671307, -0.047541070729494095, 0.05082743242383003, 0.07136731594800949, -0.04955659061670303, -0.025661125779151917, 0.04660165682435036, 0.0181577168405056, -0.01322118565440178, 0.06152834743261337, 0.07476063072681427, 0.006022328976541758, 0.01906406506896019, -0.0049232421442866325, 0.004828364588320255, 0.005568870808929205, -0.041388027369976044, 0.027749089524149895, 0.01823277212679386, -0.008543256670236588, -0.06021834537386894, 0.03213023021817207, 0.010595855303108692, -0.06458456814289093, -0.040546152740716934, 0.03933996707201004, 0.07261301577091217, 0.010053493082523346, 0.017397267743945122, 0.05560339614748955, 0.008698062971234322, -0.003912003710865974, 0.0002927228342741728, -0.04994378983974457, -0.013495545834302902, -0.01875998079776764, -0.019751152023673058, 0.014434877783060074, 0.0423717200756073, 0.022193249315023422, -0.01063308585435152, 0.030864117667078972, -0.041208215057849884, -0.0006992213311605155, -0.05634045600891113, -0.03521433472633362, -0.03642124682664871, 0.07081162929534912, 0.01809883303940296, 0.0512860082089901, 0.006497922819107771, 0.0031916399020701647, 0.006896818056702614, 0.002143427962437272, -0.09331265836954117, 0.0008105979068204761, 0.018610022962093353, -0.01753644458949566, 0.011339792050421238, -0.028317997232079506, -0.003180992091074586, -0.03141889348626137, 0.006976249162107706, -0.0013691140338778496, 0.021206537261605263, -0.03921876847743988, 0.03960585594177246, -0.03227172791957855, -0.007899395190179348, -0.06480363756418228, 0.01979781873524189, 0.04992542415857315, -0.03824769705533981, 0.04558950290083885, 0.025560548529028893, -0.03217950463294983, -0.012185496278107166, -0.05321575701236725, -0.0011071867775171995, 0.02764633297920227, 0.035691484808921814, 0.0037410748191177845, 0.01568046398460865, -0.057478759437799454, 0.0035447885747998953, 0.021229615435004234, 0.028881436213850975, 0.0561240054666996, 0.03978747874498367, -0.017162170261144638, -0.05408044159412384, -0.024189883843064308, 0.058268554508686066, 0.0332225076854229, -0.012430465780198574, 0.04043859243392944, 0.029701048508286476, 0.010613319464027882, -0.024558991193771362, -0.006350857205688953, 0.03112323395907879, -0.016986537724733353, 0.020286111161112785, -0.01983269490301609, -0.04672876372933388, -0.017464566975831985, 0.005964470095932484, 0.04914421960711479, -0.01810562238097191, -0.0059229289181530476, 0.009873746894299984, 0.00761548662558198, -0.012890415266156197, -0.024989023804664612, -0.006819756235927343, 0.02684284932911396, 0.004267536569386721, -0.020910048857331276, -0.011218927800655365, -0.004559458699077368, 0.03816164657473564, 0.025643493980169296, 0.014757371507585049, 0.014319302514195442, -0.08101064711809158, -0.015262307599186897, 0.047153372317552567, 0.051350466907024384, -0.022717561572790146, -0.002186758443713188, -0.03278454765677452, -0.03630658611655235, 0.022181738168001175, -0.04024253413081169, 0.05831633135676384, -0.019810853525996208, -0.010454768314957619, -0.0025169013533741236, -0.022627467289566994, -0.010687479749321938, 0.019224924966692924, -0.027940962463617325, 0.038612931966781616, -0.05448846146464348, 0.007908396422863007, -0.015017160214483738, 0.014132835902273655, -0.02754215896129608, 0.042757485061883926, -0.010088082402944565, -0.043698567897081375, 0.00818458292633295, -0.020144039765000343, 0.04906630516052246, -0.043440502136945724, -0.014939357526600361, 0.010578702203929424, -0.011804274283349514, 0.016794759780168533, -0.030693119391798973, -0.01877538487315178, 0.0208579171448946, 0.006840254180133343, -0.03352708742022514, -0.04096239432692528, -0.02598067745566368, 0.03393173590302467, 0.04096144437789917, -0.05128242447972298, 0.04642830416560173, 0.014720363542437553, -0.014211184345185757, 0.028136294335126877, -0.028776569291949272, -0.003302016295492649, -0.021968821063637733, -0.03980357199907303, -0.03592999279499054, -0.01630234718322754, 0.000963937200140208, 0.019540302455425262, -0.005551162641495466, 0.0469936728477478, -0.0787511020898819, 0.005268287379294634, 0.03649769723415375, 0.01564032770693302, -0.022607246413826942, 0.015652354806661606, 0.012751319445669651, 0.05586551874876022, 0.008520002476871014, -0.0024204005021601915, 0.00008421019447268918, -0.010635795071721077, 0.02123844064772129, 0.05451862886548042, -0.03540134057402611, -0.023958662524819374, -0.04804208129644394, -0.020815540105104446, 0.025561846792697906, 0.002485710196197033, 0.034915145486593246, -0.009815651923418045, 0.03217073529958725, 0.023601142689585686, -0.03306463733315468, -0.026949701830744743, 0.0024579267483204603, -0.01129263173788786, 0.021232714876532555, -0.013215169310569763, 0.007288923487067223, 0.0055142114870250225, 0.014460803009569645, -0.05242706835269928, 0.006297835614532232, -0.008098913356661797, 0.016546405851840973, -0.0442282110452652, -0.024316035211086273, -0.04958886280655861, -0.03194133937358856, -0.039630673825740814, -0.008894914761185646, 0.05196578800678253, -0.04443218931555748, 0.010205008089542389, 0.01523386500775814, 0.0025817258283495903, 0.05035032331943512, -0.025157641619443893, 0.03312118351459503, 0.0149920005351305, -0.01810346730053425, -0.031310081481933594, -0.010177316144108772, 0.00006846536416560411, -0.035107679665088654, 0.00689791701734066, -0.021215416491031647, 0.027022160589694977, 0.02215641364455223, -0.02438947558403015, 0.009523745626211166, 0.012145129032433033, -0.0005497144884429872, 0.027371138334274292, -0.03622303158044815, -0.006022757850587368, 0.031022582203149796, -0.024454602971673012, -0.00938030518591404, 0.020469214767217636, -0.03162137046456337, 0.0096898153424263, 0.02686011604964733, -0.03233353793621063, -0.022861728444695473, -0.011155342683196068, 0.04805515334010124, -0.004924055654555559, -0.007274729665368795, -0.043111078441143036, -0.04446722939610481, 0.033659860491752625, 0.003096763975918293, 0.05726904049515724, 0.007856503129005432, 0.01894913613796234, -0.049286097288131714, -0.015625260770320892, -0.05879940092563629, 0.014563002623617649, 0.06015894189476967, -0.013771550729870796, 0.04199627414345741, -0.006747193168848753, 0.035861775279045105, 0.011605048552155495, -0.0378863662481308, -0.038944609463214874, -0.007177513558417559, 0.0004657803219743073, 0.03258994221687317, 0.0001596252986928448, -0.02667921595275402, 0.020766552537679672, 0.027239924296736717, 0.024724313989281654, 0.019249875098466873, -0.0018891189247369766, -0.005220924504101276, -0.026863327249884605, -0.027944132685661316, -0.028641419485211372, 0.01866813935339451, -0.042533114552497864, 0.04639621451497078, 0.009241672232747078, 0.0014460963429883122, 0.05410980060696602, 0.08940555900335312, 0.02925717830657959, -0.10912197828292847, 0.025738518685102463, -0.058698367327451706, -0.008508794009685516, 0.01903035119175911, -0.0036307619884610176, -0.009052261710166931, 0.044829025864601135, 0.012134320102632046, 0.0028751094359904528, 0.0006801671115681529, -0.06393100321292877, -0.03793128579854965, -0.02339935302734375, 0.005495487712323666, -0.02326752431690693, 0.026156412437558174, -0.0037595899775624275, -0.08952917158603668, 0.050076499581336975, -0.003710020100697875, 0.07719064503908157, -0.01029762253165245, 0.03181274235248566, 0.03356672823429108, 0.05751923844218254, 0.0015127835795283318, 0.010473903268575668, -0.0013179570669308305, 0.031108852475881577, 0.1543852984905243, 0.04991532862186432, -0.01916687563061714, -0.08673139661550522, -0.002354838652536273, 0.023328587412834167, 0.013328652828931808, -0.02710677869617939, -0.020849032327532768, 0.02515866421163082, -0.013132992200553417, 0.01860892027616501, 0.005952509585767984, 0.0017622155137360096, 0.010845138691365719, 0.022667188197374344, -0.03416542336344719, -0.04273959994316101, 0.029871856793761253, 0.040396180003881454, 0.013002647086977959, -0.010346314869821072, -0.03778277710080147, 0.00955287553369999, -0.013454504311084747, 0.01769973896443844, -0.002534925239160657, -0.0058121709153056145, 0.016483189538121223, 0.006616922095417976, -0.026333609595894814, 0.024710088968276978, 0.01399348583072424, 0.010717879049479961, 0.03757748752832413, -0.008042371831834316, -0.01178984995931387, -0.03631507232785225, 0.02140163630247116, 0.053580623120069504, 0.038205087184906006, 0.02192661166191101, 0.003927148878574371, 0.0065832193940877914, -0.03387047350406647, -0.057745225727558136, -0.04999757558107376, 0.057645268738269806, 0.009307857602834702, -0.04298388957977295, -0.007962875999510288, -0.002146432874724269, 0.015716152265667915, -0.0418175533413887, -0.0030544160399585962, 0.017661597579717636, -0.026451298967003822, -0.042264293879270554, -0.019020086154341698, 0.005263666156679392, 0.032732389867305756, -0.0071943942457437515, 0.011095116846263409, 0.006046424154192209, -0.03399597853422165, -0.004973193630576134, -0.045400142669677734, 0.033488694578409195, 0.004896834492683411, 0.009336864575743675, 0.005410578101873398, -0.042047496885061264, -0.030573105439543724, 0.012446610257029533, -0.0022254162468016148, 0.006784121040254831, 0.028823232278227806, -0.0008638231665827334, -0.007568384520709515, -0.040107548236846924, -0.043408021330833435, 0.01961822248995304, -0.01455541793256998, 0.014818001538515091, -0.020720185711979866, -0.0020384418312460184, 0.017206594347953796, 0.022784246131777763, 0.05694393068552017, 0.0022780306171625853, 0.00539620453491807, 0.023979689925909042, 0.013552680611610413, -0.04459283873438835, -0.044782303273677826, 0.02063695713877678, -0.04453468322753906, -0.02391083538532257, -0.028522903099656105, 0.031311485916376114, 0.03950771316885948, 0.01210078876465559, -0.006336575374007225, 0.06390716135501862, -0.009492027573287487, 0.011682392098009586, 0.0161232091486454, -0.03651031479239464, 0.019615672528743744, -0.025011159479618073, -0.006461987271904945, -0.031082598492503166, -0.0077192396856844425, -0.011909600347280502, -0.014164349995553493, -0.02661779895424843, 0.007923201657831669, -0.009914944879710674, 0.012446554377675056, 0.008495507761836052, 0.021348467096686363, 0.006056110840290785, -0.011820788495242596, 0.0014680253807455301, 0.01494714617729187, -0.04404767230153084, -0.006552381440997124, -0.017300892621278763, 0.026163049042224884, 0.021274732425808907, 0.01194088812917471, 0.02330666035413742, 0.008709103800356388, 0.015609261579811573, -0.04949234798550606, 0.022190380841493607, -0.019634230062365532, 0.03430701792240143, -0.0047540320083498955, -0.04191158711910248, 0.012634722515940666, 0.01939789019525051, -0.037542879581451416, 0.04041445627808571, 0.0068460432812571526, 0.02511141449213028, 0.044498346745967865, -0.013821686618030071, -0.013154181651771069, 0.042851462960243225, -0.01597968116402626, -0.00007503454253310338, 0.00454143900424242, 0.017471401020884514, 0.05059172213077545, 0.00133092375472188, 0.038990166038274765, 0.016151990741491318, 0.033026788383722305, -0.009900521486997604, 0.03657487407326698, 0.027800772339105606, -0.015437828376889229, 0.008858234621584415, 0.011787534691393375, -0.008698243647813797, -0.03214476257562637, 0.017474010586738586, 0.012917178682982922, 0.036611828953027725, -0.018337564542889595, 0.060194890946149826, 0.004180902615189552, -0.014631375670433044, -0.0843646302819252, -0.019239516928792, -0.015427270904183388, 0.0010186932049691677, 0.043549545109272, -0.04692443460226059, 0.03973216935992241, 0.0389421321451664, -0.03518342599272728, 0.0373234786093235, -0.03489239513874054, -0.039691563695669174, -0.0059951054863631725, -0.001232937560416758, 0.011730401776731014, 0.008959340862929821, 0.04912688955664635, 0.016905445605516434, 0.002751157386228442, 0.01208823174238205, -0.027464721351861954, -0.021978776901960373, -0.04877505451440811, 0.028889844194054604, 0.023515677079558372, 0.00274870079010725, 0.01765993796288967, -0.05869683250784874, -0.049036573618650436, 0.044473640620708466, -0.02394905686378479, -0.012199890799820423, -0.028234319761395454, 0.03270673006772995, 0.03175779804587364, 0.07475074380636215, 0.006845617201179266, 0.021229175850749016, 0.03169713541865349, -0.01618081144988537, 0.01967875473201275, -0.012785994447767735, -0.007075433619320393, -0.015848618000745773, 0.022922981530427933, 0.008393184281885624, -0.045325376093387604, 0.036388568580150604, -0.0006154673174023628, -0.00028189312433823943, 0.0033571317326277494, -0.00801034178584814, -0.010212459601461887, -0.045616015791893005, -0.023392003029584885, -0.005140178836882114, 0.02397601120173931, 0.0011575488606467843, 0.056533534079790115, -0.008747149258852005, -0.009912851266562939, -0.032657768577337265, -0.03426191210746765, 0.011915055103600025, -0.01766262948513031, -0.03924916684627533, -0.01711239479482174, -0.013190677389502525, -0.019417908042669296, -0.008558202534914017, -0.010200140066444874, -0.009673436172306538, -0.03227996826171875, 0.04749707505106926, -0.011339307762682438, 0.043146803975105286, 0.02958497405052185, -0.044243182986974716, -0.035775262862443924, -0.10796581208705902, 0.03149789571762085, 0.005595023278146982, -0.06666146963834763, -0.0333998017013073, -0.017100712284445763, -0.01605270802974701, 0.046651821583509445, 0.04333207383751869, 0.002069405745714903, -0.008824887685477734, 0.003889762796461582, -0.0006308521842584014, 0.05186446011066437, -0.013936582952737808, 0.03546226769685745, -0.020671529695391655, -0.009481197223067284, 0.0033259945921599865, -0.02110372483730316, -0.013450425118207932, 0.037741780281066895, -0.003308928804472089, -0.03232969716191292, 0.014104490168392658, 0.05023457109928131, -0.013481208123266697, 0.020738529041409492, -0.011408563703298569, 0.0009057329734787345, 0.04212468862533569, 0.006472203880548477, -0.030515121296048164, 0.014155566692352295, 0.005426391959190369, -0.05906981602311134, 0.038457706570625305, -0.008508894592523575, -0.016850946471095085, 0.004537343978881836, 0.022912578657269478, 0.06960158795118332, -0.0669391006231308, -0.006700809113681316, 0.04586455971002579, 0.023442342877388, 0.005841377191245556, 0.05643661692738533, 0.03131382539868355, 0.00824128370732069, -0.016113055869936943, 0.056113313883543015, -0.018726713955402374, 0.009414803236722946, 0.012058189138770103, 0.0016560161020606756, 0.0057000648230314255, 0.0023104369174689054, 0.02232491225004196, 0.026370929554104805, -0.05921172723174095, 0.05727248266339302, -0.04980086162686348, 0.03297801315784454, -0.031449344009160995, 0.0054754894226789474, 0.019996877759695053, -0.049631427973508835, 0.03231401741504669, 0.009901421144604683, -0.0056634219363331795, 0.09727942943572998, -0.042300935834646225, 0.023805633187294006, -0.029776424169540405, -0.009531230665743351, -0.0024977601133286953, 0.0012658732011914253, 0.020969834178686142, 0.03052988089621067, 0.010293404571712017, -0.03018251806497574, 0.040845077484846115, 0.02464180812239647, -0.000892944517545402, -0.011849626898765564, 0.028429964557290077, -0.01648116670548916, 0.005819195415824652, -0.010571679100394249, -0.013784127309918404, -0.06416814029216766, -0.02677283249795437, 0.009521529078483582, 0.07675714045763016, 0.030768459662795067, 0.005741188768297434, -0.03509107977151871, -0.015374189242720604, 0.032410312443971634, -0.04886487126350403, -0.013367976993322372, -0.02824055217206478, 0.05424538627266884, 0.02120533026754856, -0.030426135286688805 ]
<p>I have performed an experiment on plants and have some trouble analysing the data. For the experiment, we have three replicates (in time), two species and three treatments. In each experiment, we recorded the height of the plants. The dataset looks like this:</p> <pre><code> replicate | treatment | species | height </code></pre> <p>I assume <code>treatment</code> and <code>species</code> are fixed factors while <code>replicate</code> is a random one. </p> <p>For the analysis, I have used the procedure <a href="http://www.r-bloggers.com/linear-mixed-models-in-r/" rel="nofollow">described here</a>, so the code looks like this:</p> <pre><code>library(nlme) rs &lt;- read.table('mydata.txt', header=T) rs$plot &lt;- rs$species m1.nlme = lme(height ~ species*traitement, random = ~ 1|replicate, data = rs) summary(m1.nlme) </code></pre> <p>I got these results:</p> <pre><code>Linear mixed-effects model fit by REML Data: rs AIC BIC logLik -326.2813 -310.415 169.1407 Random effects: Formula: ~1 | replicate (Intercept) Residual StdDev: 0.03603131 0.04329552 Fixed effects: height ~ species * traitement Value Std.Error DF t-value p-value (Intercept) 0.31546667 0.02225388 102 14.175806 0.0000 speciesmaize 0.01645839 0.01127669 102 1.459506 0.1475 traitementtemoin 0.21213868 0.01178502 102 18.000707 0.0000 speciesmaize:traitementtemoin -0.04794414 0.01686908 102 -2.842131 0.0054 Correlation: (Intr) gnF2F353 trtmnt speciesmaize -0.249 traitementtemoin -0.238 0.472 speciesmaize:traitementtemoin 0.166 -0.670 -0.702 Standardized Within-Group Residuals: Min Q1 Med Q3 Max -4.7398461 -0.3546214 0.1025950 0.6297446 1.6118499 Number of Observations: 108 Number of Groups: 3 </code></pre> <p>The way I interpret this is that I have a <code>treatment</code> effect, as well as a <code>treatment*species</code> effect, but no effect of the <code>species</code> in itself. </p> <p>Is this correct?</p>
74,279
[ -0.021689262241125107, -0.0012637177715077996, 0.004454832524061203, 0.020611265674233437, -0.0022741183638572693, 0.010542972944676876, -0.0006631639553233981, -0.020249994471669197, 0.011653142981231213, -0.0633615255355835, 0.0354275219142437, 0.06937085837125778, 0.05799873173236847, 0.011078095063567162, 0.010750999674201012, -0.0029883338138461113, -0.019627034664154053, 0.005368935875594616, 0.019025083631277084, -0.0037300109397619963, -0.010840521194040775, 0.01831621676683426, -0.010134773328900337, -0.015498493798077106, 0.00392299797385931, 0.04245440661907196, 0.0380144938826561, -0.023618757724761963, 0.025791175663471222, 0.0274045467376709, -0.058535926043987274, -0.012815019115805626, 0.014960641041398048, -0.021063148975372314, 0.03278536722064018, 0.02185889706015587, 0.00042012069025076926, -0.022074541077017784, -0.0056948354467749596, 0.032256096601486206, -0.00011937218368984759, -0.001741741201840341, 0.018182896077632904, 0.03715629503130913, 0.0037203843239694834, 0.0237332321703434, 0.012758533470332623, 0.018415654078125954, 0.08782225102186203, -0.010934129357337952, 0.0641249418258667, 0.002943910425528884, 0.029338832944631577, 0.02154950052499771, -0.03051985800266266, 0.02510879933834076, 0.055829353630542755, 0.045966170728206635, -0.013401479460299015, -0.05243362486362457, 0.01775205507874489, -0.04221303388476372, 0.009304242208600044, 0.0025541058275848627, -0.02472301758825779, -0.020362623035907745, 0.03943675756454468, -0.0023808616679161787, 0.04417780414223671, -0.035451147705316544, 0.015999915078282356, 0.009951222687959671, 0.03171816095709801, 0.01128390058875084, 0.012100446037948132, -0.006690858397632837, 0.011294824071228504, -0.016335655003786087, 0.03535497933626175, 0.006403086706995964, 0.005282372236251831, 0.05130666494369507, -0.01923431269824505, 0.010062609799206257, 0.017579132691025734, -0.02975703589618206, 0.04115893319249153, -0.01979011856019497, 0.04510669410228729, 0.0003284508129581809, -0.0056000701151788235, 0.03844042122364044, 0.05723201856017113, 0.04052441939711571, -0.035844460129737854, 0.0620589405298233, 0.010058486834168434, 0.02508426457643509, 0.0063554951921105385, 0.001954836305230856, -0.037833716720342636, -0.051852837204933167, 0.0131962476298213, 0.022653529420495033, -0.031649865210056305, -0.03389493376016617, -0.017240241169929504, -0.01744481362402439, -0.010192470625042915, -0.05319497361779213, 0.014587701298296452, 0.018352366983890533, 0.0049107810482382774, -0.035069871693849564, 0.002280557295307517, -0.0611911341547966, -0.010007612407207489, 0.012141416780650616, 0.09091393649578094, 0.04346879944205284, 0.006620064843446016, 0.0008647390641272068, 0.038896024227142334, 0.0005974722444079816, -0.027948828414082527, 0.02023681439459324, 0.01389828510582447, -0.02842024341225624, -0.0375760942697525, 0.06686311215162277, 0.016915995627641678, -0.005726996343582869, 0.03183629363775253, -0.007701379247009754, -0.008948205038905144, -0.01586645096540451, -0.07330094277858734, -0.04687407612800598, 0.025786899030208588, -0.027234874665737152, 0.01528069656342268, -0.052370887249708176, -0.0024329933803528547, 0.04397076368331909, 0.017265141010284424, 0.0050658369436860085, 0.017023613676428795, 0.008260490372776985, 0.021634284406900406, 0.013996144756674767, -0.016306927427649498, 0.0011664232006296515, -0.03348053991794586, -0.010788497515022755, -0.045620888471603394, -0.0647912323474884, 0.028017820790410042, 0.005009359680116177, -0.0008895699284039438, 0.02913557179272175, 0.029281102120876312, 0.004366263281553984, 0.008786546066403389, 0.004044642206281424, -0.04173436760902405, -0.004415465053170919, 0.04888453334569931, -0.03449711948633194, 0.04247547686100006, 0.05033113434910774, -0.014987904578447342, -0.00007998970249900594, -0.009182079695165157, 0.04266899824142456, 0.041975852102041245, -0.02169952169060707, 0.04582201689481735, -0.007407077122479677, 0.025399792939424515, 0.042364757508039474, -0.056128330528736115, 0.00914046447724104, -0.03968394920229912, -0.031795699149370193, 0.029736429452896118, 0.03167256340384483, -0.024074606597423553, 0.015559908002614975, 0.051961638033390045, -0.023083804175257683, -0.03856417164206505, -0.06954262405633926, -0.020853281021118164, 0.015853017568588257, -0.025784101337194443, -0.006352993659675121, 0.01273165550082922, 0.004389295354485512, 0.01668042130768299, 0.004338112194091082, -0.04508627951145172, 0.01201314851641655, 0.05812221020460129, -0.005972540471702814, 0.013752974569797516, 0.025098983198404312, 0.06905432790517807, 0.01114939246326685, 0.04009668901562691, -0.01315921638160944, 0.013005662709474564, 0.020073171705007553, -0.018300922587513924, -0.011221005581319332, 0.011472239159047604, -0.011008395813405514, 0.012191926129162312, 0.011230381205677986, -0.02297898940742016, 0.024975238367915154, -0.04398440942168236, 0.029438432306051254, 0.053893283009529114, -0.013311048038303852, 0.008364911191165447, -0.02096925675868988, 0.004369847010821104, 0.019447633996605873, -0.06774035096168518, 0.00007246680615935475, -0.04152948036789894, -0.03362715616822243, 0.009534142911434174, 0.05094088986515999, -0.0001309723884332925, -0.01152587216347456, 0.041668668389320374, -0.013483621180057526, 0.04001878947019577, 0.06080358847975731, -0.024829167872667313, -0.010051692835986614, 0.027559084817767143, 0.03808712214231491, 0.004951081704348326, -0.00489402562379837, 0.01741277426481247, -0.037460844963788986, 0.04226680472493172, -0.020818712189793587, -0.005643301177769899, 0.028668822720646858, 0.010822289623320103, -0.014402677305042744, -0.02247696742415428, -0.006446846295148134, 0.030899452045559883, -0.003956082742661238, 0.006215792149305344, 0.0513400100171566, 0.02565779909491539, 0.010124468244612217, -0.02473592944443226, 0.020684244111180305, 0.05388755351305008, 0.039286691695451736, -0.025622352957725525, -0.05966942012310028, 0.004424538463354111, -0.0038054543547332287, 0.019865337759256363, -0.011523065157234669, -0.027345024049282074, -0.020055271685123444, 0.029765404760837555, -0.004099101293832064, 0.004179720766842365, 0.002153996145352721, -0.03959048166871071, -0.002253871876746416, 0.009002670645713806, -0.0013442843919619918, 0.03745245561003685, -0.02783026732504368, -0.05696432664990425, -0.0015298411017283797, -0.04181580990552902, 0.008627847768366337, -0.018562227487564087, 0.018850605934858322, -0.04216320067644119, 0.03252207860350609, -0.008302469737827778, -0.040343061089515686, -0.046594779938459396, 0.0006311217439360917, -0.007464359048753977, -0.027950745075941086, 0.01493874192237854, 0.049514248967170715, 0.0007853702991269529, -0.012938389554619789, 0.011525940150022507, -0.06714365631341934, 0.02302248403429985, 0.011591861955821514, 0.016760127618908882, -0.021908750757575035, 0.007277596741914749, 0.010429684072732925, -0.00692819245159626, -0.017405299469828606, 0.0011743424693122506, -0.07435036450624466, -0.05260930210351944, 0.013428613543510437, 0.054749537259340286, 0.005517618265002966, 0.0026594046503305435, -0.022531332448124886, 0.04171924665570259, 0.01878540590405464, -0.04021491855382919, -0.061758652329444885, 0.011642726138234138, -0.009939983487129211, -0.01778104342520237, 0.06817805767059326, -0.0025301631540060043, 0.00922501552850008, 0.04810185357928276, 0.01402867678552866, 0.02192312479019165, 0.025118215009570122, 0.03538040071725845, 0.009856585413217545, 0.030483288690447807, -0.012893530540168285, -0.014211637899279594, 0.0011622970923781395, 0.04355680197477341, 0.021757982671260834, 0.005051664542406797, 0.020779669284820557, 0.013110310770571232, -0.019406897947192192, -0.06625371426343918, -0.01463598757982254, -0.0053255255334079266, 0.04445180296897888, -0.025940924882888794, 0.023321162909269333, 0.013438699766993523, -0.020263688638806343, 0.026909757405519485, -0.027230821549892426, 0.04531135410070419, -0.025861969217658043, -0.00047262906446121633, 0.06343038380146027, 0.055197227746248245, -0.0287178847938776, 0.005856859032064676, 0.010034962557256222, -0.0022311112843453884, -0.0014127293834462762, -0.03969450294971466, 0.022530417889356613, 0.04916460067033768, 0.018204141408205032, -0.02654450573027134, -0.019607888534665108, -0.010624517686665058, -0.0030574549455195665, -0.025179417803883553, 0.02204521745443344, -0.028350848704576492, 0.03618917241692543, 0.01057814247906208, 0.03757813945412636, -0.01845335029065609, -0.023284366354346275, -0.003756660735234618, -0.03723263368010521, -0.007773646153509617, 0.032005395740270615, 0.019074993208050728, -0.027264906093478203, 0.029175080358982086, -0.020400598645210266, 0.019582441076636314, -0.026803160086274147, 0.00969664379954338, 0.013492472469806671, -0.009150993078947067, -0.004461960401386023, 0.0075537594966590405, 0.0023307965602725744, -0.039398983120918274, -0.008479880169034004, 0.025191592052578926, 0.013086066581308842, -0.026655981317162514, 0.015831347554922104, 0.037946343421936035, -0.021172845736145973, -0.013310890644788742, -0.016727421432733536, -0.03102593868970871, 0.021322567015886307, 0.040778469294309616, 0.02567814104259014, -0.006064179819077253, -0.031145449727773666, 0.038654785603284836, 0.034996211528778076, 0.03221958130598068, 0.055294252932071686, 0.02249826304614544, -0.0040006195195019245, 0.015647293999791145, 0.018629316240549088, 0.019022047519683838, 0.0009150172700174153, -0.0030480867717415094, -0.02643810771405697, 0.033918432891368866, 0.03791458159685135, -0.012845203280448914, 0.04758939892053604, 0.04082218557596207, 0.009818711318075657, 0.024342503398656845, -0.029176605865359306, -0.02102810889482498, -0.019974131137132645, 0.038380760699510574, 0.05669863149523735, 0.020696554332971573, 0.008319443091750145, -0.02272675186395645, 0.08089100569486618, -0.040638189762830734, -0.041931960731744766, 0.037323664873838425, 0.007685082033276558, 0.011337164789438248, -0.013154085725545883, -0.034457530826330185, -0.020427124574780464, 0.04383888095617294, 0.0021997366566210985, 0.012894035317003727, 0.008514521643519402, -0.07920658588409424, -0.018323030322790146, 0.010455803945660591, 0.02452482283115387, -0.03721461072564125, 0.0296137947589159, -0.06016828864812851, 0.002725214697420597, -0.029054468497633934, -0.013933457434177399, 0.02362775057554245, -0.02317971922457218, 0.03698575124144554, -0.004482596646994352, -0.047004759311676025, -0.07133403420448303, -0.006058655213564634, -0.02778605930507183, 0.01640217751264572, -0.028902938589453697, -0.04882876202464104, -0.0021531181409955025, -0.0076194205321371555, -0.005355220288038254, 0.025583943352103233, -0.0401337556540966, -0.014507483690977097, 0.06295102089643478, 0.004578230436891317, 0.008978414349257946, -0.04176328703761101, 0.050686851143836975, -0.0246090330183506, 0.030935652554035187, 0.04929523542523384, -0.0189132671803236, -0.015270698815584183, 0.03402002528309822, 0.040626153349876404, 0.011190393008291721, -0.03399414196610451, -0.013486490584909916, 0.019505146890878677, 0.03982412815093994, -0.0009913307148963213, 0.06452787667512894, 0.01842670887708664, -0.011226693168282509, 0.0005959746777079999, -0.05810173973441124, 0.012798276729881763, -0.005978941917419434, -0.07328809797763824, -0.07445071637630463, -0.005148054100573063, 0.01985686831176281, 0.040658291429281235, -0.005848561879247427, 0.015333768911659718, -0.05957365781068802, -0.011505301110446453, 0.05273573473095894, 0.00010452751303091645, -0.03115064464509487, -0.005247092805802822, 0.026035180315375328, -0.0013517955085262656, 0.01035398244857788, -0.0132526233792305, -0.017489710822701454, -0.034254636615514755, -0.007221082225441933, 0.009989786893129349, -0.040174130350351334, 0.0044308872893452644, 0.02047460339963436, -0.02535298280417919, -0.004414531402289867, -0.014298239722847939, -0.015259027481079102, 0.006752008572220802, 0.021100681275129318, -0.007011232431977987, -0.02548799104988575, -0.012800674885511398, 0.033910807222127914, -0.009567775763571262, 0.032482072710990906, 0.002041763626039028, -0.0021496566478163004, 0.008450189605355263, -0.01850094273686409, -0.06730055063962936, -0.0468895360827446, -0.0053298575803637505, -0.02008000761270523, -0.030178122222423553, -0.022227510809898376, -0.08218365162611008, 0.02240496315062046, 0.018193043768405914, 0.014589095488190651, 0.023673754185438156, -0.06058422848582268, 0.00999013613909483, -0.049529485404491425, -0.014970701187849045, 0.05555987358093262, -0.04257854074239731, -0.014690899290144444, 0.023240718990564346, -0.02082221210002899, -0.02825922518968582, 0.018538203090429306, -0.016758214682340622, -0.025773704051971436, 0.0007256303797475994, -0.03767968341708183, -0.0019583641551434994, 0.037258926779031754, 0.006781228352338076, -0.012458860874176025, 0.014758558012545109, 0.009114401414990425, 0.004629381466656923, -0.03518572449684143, 0.016527963802218437, 0.027061888948082924, -0.00046189266140572727, -0.0274269450455904, -0.011050151661038399, -0.01628732867538929, -0.01233294140547514, 0.01031387597322464, -0.05458097532391548, -0.026373211294412613, 0.011530444957315922, 0.07977446168661118, -0.002250226680189371, 0.01931110769510269, -0.020182952284812927, -0.01823846809566021, 0.022012826055288315, -0.005610196851193905, -0.014867146499454975, 0.02179984375834465, 0.006560314446687698, -0.04044562578201294, -0.009192821569740772, -0.02233666554093361, 0.007627726532518864, 0.04960505664348602, -0.0063585201278328896, 0.04591457545757294, 0.05603561922907829, -0.03351149335503578, 0.020442739129066467, -0.05240645632147789, -0.028789831325411797, 0.009128289297223091, 0.02694937214255333, 0.06157951056957245, -0.040346309542655945, -0.007626587990671396, 0.05699440464377403, 0.012876580469310284, 0.00500641530379653, 0.057744503021240234, -0.02464330941438675, -0.006561498623341322, 0.022158240899443626, -0.014949623495340347, -0.02111285738646984, 0.010362307541072369, -0.021046379581093788, 0.016248155385255814, -0.041106343269348145, -0.0298187043517828, 0.03649021312594414, 0.08339057117700577, 0.00021080172155052423, -0.045066285878419876, -0.02738839015364647, -0.08354059606790543, 0.002516971668228507, 0.007126206997781992, -0.010715540498495102, 0.03292202576994896, 0.03097672201693058, 0.05573708191514015, -0.01796511933207512, 0.038878265768289566, -0.027151284739375114, -0.06279546767473221, -0.026797549799084663, 0.0017922109691426158, 0.01581796258687973, 0.037695933133363724, -0.0009418660774827003, -0.02523055486381054, 0.005034520756453276, -0.06966925412416458, 0.013880695216357708, 0.00010169323650188744, 0.04720233380794525, -0.002099642064422369, 0.06258118152618408, -0.006055443547666073, -0.009450632147490978, -0.020531676709651947, -0.03695002943277359, 0.13992628455162048, 0.0776885524392128, 0.05639980360865593, -0.09536027908325195, 0.02819173038005829, 0.03874341771006584, -0.002084761392325163, -0.00222830381244421, -0.04123161360621452, 0.0026790504343807697, -0.02815704606473446, 0.06383487582206726, 0.04074680805206299, 0.00810173898935318, -0.02730616182088852, 0.0202497411519289, -0.013086199760437012, -0.02328973263502121, 0.004969460424035788, -0.0054011051543056965, -0.001217333017848432, -0.0020846270490437746, -0.06012856587767601, 0.0006325768772512674, 0.01838068850338459, -0.02413817308843136, -0.030325088649988174, -0.0011819885112345219, -0.008439507335424423, 0.03070717491209507, 0.004277335479855537, 0.02275259792804718, -0.006815069355070591, 0.016332563012838364, -0.007882945239543915, -0.019382350146770477, 0.017731670290231705, 0.012845143675804138, -0.003228834131732583, 0.06995481252670288, -0.0010639249812811613, -0.014913537539541721, 0.02039778232574463, 0.016190947964787483, -0.015353569760918617, -0.06216166913509369, -0.017434395849704742, 0.05702609568834305, 0.001957598840817809, -0.044115521013736725, 0.00677292887121439, -0.028713546693325043, 0.012944762594997883, -0.034904204308986664, -0.015427283942699432, 0.04825175181031227, -0.030549226328730583, -0.018882660195231438, -0.004196882247924805, 0.013651465997099876, 0.024624843150377274, -0.01611042581498623, 0.016623886302113533, 0.058731164783239365, -0.005143648944795132, -0.0056052436120808125, -0.062027450650930405, 0.06706373393535614, 0.027928965166211128, 0.03371669352054596, 0.022284336388111115, -0.03677843138575554, -0.010253720916807652, 0.007160614710301161, 0.03420834243297577, 0.06080898642539978, 0.008706996217370033, -0.02977345511317253, -0.01135671604424715, -0.02274368144571781, -0.044402170926332474, 0.024203933775424957, -0.011900562793016434, -0.015481272712349892, -0.022181311622262, -0.02624537982046604, 0.0009513878612779081, 0.05318145826458931, 0.005366748198866844, 0.029966168105602264, -0.019134294241666794, 0.0647207573056221, -0.0010985851986333728, -0.09264732152223587, -0.018441123887896538, 0.048027511686086655, -0.03426291048526764, -0.05486302822828293, -0.01464373804628849, 0.03681883588433266, 0.052249711006879807, 0.02452533319592476, -0.012089489959180355, 0.04472511261701584, -0.01107450108975172, 0.0066665527410805225, 0.04809945821762085, -0.012275701388716698, 0.02249269001185894, -0.000842892739456147, -0.010568960569798946, -0.014510766603052616, -0.01340646855533123, -0.025066016241908073, -0.05532944202423096, -0.01356622762978077, -0.007976124063134193, -0.03365093469619751, 0.011432318948209286, -0.004612988326698542, -0.03524089232087135, -0.030188443139195442, -0.0012732003815472126, -0.0457514263689518, -0.00827768910676241, 0.015718119218945503, -0.018831292167305946, -0.00876582134515047, 0.032345108687877655, -0.02682957984507084, -0.00233986834064126, 0.042066071182489395, -0.013807535171508789, -0.009793695993721485, -0.03825943544507027, 0.025930514559149742, 0.021213822066783905, 0.05480187386274338, 0.013204066082835197, 0.0049879117868840694, -0.0026674168184399605, -0.038365576416254044, -0.004935289267450571, -0.0030449109617620707, 0.000372650712961331, 0.01633196882903576, 0.009119194000959396, 0.0454576276242733, -0.05274542048573494, 0.05285600572824478, -0.02704615518450737, -0.0071061234921216965, -0.03346984460949898, -0.01964767649769783, 0.02880222722887993, 0.010902868583798409, -0.015533811412751675, -0.01939161866903305, -0.01512848399579525, 0.05916733294725418, 0.04664529860019684, -0.03084041364490986, 0.023105556145310402, 0.010736323893070221, -0.03177481144666672, 0.002564907306805253, 0.01995696686208248, -0.01418212614953518, 0.017343083396553993, 0.08472452312707901, -0.010986692272126675, 0.04255243018269539, -0.010242790915071964, 0.026993529871106148, -0.09156190603971481, -0.020056795328855515, 0.003130117431282997, 0.02856532670557499, 0.0165298692882061, -0.037015724927186966, -0.046065568923950195, 0.020542990416288376, -0.019538111984729767, 0.0019081702921539545, -0.003756210906431079, -0.0085902139544487, -0.03675706312060356, 0.014853536151349545, -0.015980858355760574, -0.0035580953117460012, 0.019429577514529228, 0.033370696008205414, 0.02398400381207466, -0.01366865262389183, 0.006114024668931961, -0.038292158395051956, -0.003355342196300626, 0.019770629703998566, 0.036643482744693756, -0.08003546297550201, 0.02185302972793579, -0.03478749468922615, 0.0022461330518126488, -0.007887625135481358, -0.009571214206516743, 0.05552805960178375, 0.02373344823718071, 0.002112223533913493, -0.016140781342983246, 0.05553654581308365, -0.005167784169316292, 0.015068380162119865, -0.006395552773028612, -0.021580984815955162, 0.002941709943115711, -0.014910335652530193, -0.02924138680100441, 0.004717372357845306, -0.014279091730713844, 0.016133440658450127, -0.009976246394217014, 0.026257608085870743, -0.006336099933832884, -0.03544984012842178, 0.007452892139554024, 0.008890007622539997, -0.009538926184177399, -0.019105002284049988, -0.03307359665632248, -0.021644361317157745, 0.06252451986074448, 0.058235783129930496, 0.042848825454711914, -0.01943458616733551, 0.01644456759095192, -0.036204010248184204, -0.012922949157655239, -0.014284081757068634, 0.01876663975417614, -0.03980443254113197, -0.044657498598098755, 0.004230320919305086, 0.01677325926721096, -0.027851920574903488, -0.004662918858230114, 0.05581848695874214, -0.07064700871706009, 0.01940079778432846, 0.009812124073505402, 0.016375157982110977, -0.01654502935707569, -0.0067337751388549805, 0.031887490302324295, -0.10863464325666428, 0.05247946083545685, 0.00018955569248646498, -0.02707556262612343, -0.06456582993268967, -0.010534094646573067, -0.04299897328019142, 0.04515210539102554, -0.011025817133486271, 0.021465662866830826, 0.015334565192461014, -0.03805281221866608, 0.05546101927757263, -0.0020962348207831383, -0.0914241299033165, 0.0696493536233902, 0.020981313660740852, 0.021523043513298035, -0.003517888020724058, -0.04707232862710953, 0.0018768145237118006, 0.02674984373152256, -0.00285164313390851, -0.03083707019686699, 0.004028655588626862, 0.0035287232603877783, -0.02657049521803856, 0.01391583401709795, 0.007770545780658722, -0.01015729084610939, 0.018089883029460907, 0.007575390860438347, -0.00929423701018095, 0.0508316271007061, 0.007303688209503889, -0.039946384727954865, 0.014176717028021812, -0.03952907770872116, 0.0025714931543916464, 0.006626779679208994, -0.029035629704594612, 0.007953033782541752, -0.08793733268976212, 0.05027266591787338, -0.006302243564277887, -0.005582177545875311, -0.03552883118391037, 0.014580202288925648, 0.014814132824540138, 0.04934839531779289, 0.017831934615969658, 0.014573258347809315, -0.025551795959472656, -0.010322075337171555, 0.014169203117489815, -0.0021888550836592913, 0.03438802435994148, -0.022929273545742035, -0.014442609623074532, 0.021272597834467888, -0.0165462177246809, -0.0012047168565914035, -0.02413790673017502, 0.060782674700021744, -0.016806015744805336, -0.015845224261283875, 0.014330952428281307, -0.035078320652246475, 0.044450629502534866, -0.020797723904252052, 0.0025069359689950943, 0.05113484337925911, -0.06077861785888672, 0.015976432710886, -0.022185690701007843, -0.025922657921910286, 0.008337714709341526, 0.01730967126786709, 0.017423368990421295, 0.02883640117943287, -0.018954653292894363, 0.022805560380220413, 0.004320953972637653, -0.019517801702022552, 0.01816200278699398, -0.01789974234998226, -0.008836822584271431, -0.027058906853199005, -0.016834698617458344, -0.03215424716472626, -0.039824195206165314, -0.019862499088048935, -0.05367046222090721, 0.001357156434096396, -0.011341841891407967, -0.009781995788216591, -0.0389617457985878, -0.0399855375289917, 0.016573404893279076, 0.030856521800160408, -0.04681536555290222, -0.042296528816223145, -0.020536867901682854, 0.02802669256925583, 0.027312302961945534, 0.00461086630821228 ]
<p>Disclaimer: Statistics is not my strong side, so if my question is nonsense I apologize. I'm a beginner, but really wanting to understand this.</p> <p>My question is: why do I get so widely different parameter estimates when using different transformations on my data in a non-linear regression ?</p> <p>I'm trying to do a nonlinear regression and to estimate the uncertainty of the fit (confidence interval) using linear approximation. From my understanding the more linear-like the shape of the nonlinear function, the more accurate will the confidence interval calculation by linear approximation be. I therefore want to transform the data to make it as linear as possible. The errors in $y$ can be assumed to be log-normal. My data is monotonic and assumed to follow a power function in most cases.</p> <p>$$ y = a*(x-x_0)^b $$</p> <p>where $y$ is river discharge, $x$ is an arbitrary water level in the river and $x_0$ is the water level where where discharge $y$ is 0. This can be rewritten as log transformed, and nice and linear $$ log(y) = a + b \times log(x-x_0) $$.</p> <p>I need to estimate the parameters $a$, $b$ and $x_0$, so to do so simultaneously I use nonlinear regression. I also have some data that follows quadratic functions, so I would like to set up (and understand) a non-linear method.</p> <p>I use r and <code>nlsLM()</code> from <code>minpack.lm</code> to carry out the non-linear regression. Here is some example code:</p> <pre><code>library(minpack.lm) xdata &lt;- c(19, 21, 24, 25, 29, 34, 35, 40, 40, 46, 48, 48, 52, 56, 57, 65, 65, 68) ydata &lt;- c(10, 11, 14, 20, 24, 50, 42, 96, 89, 134, 135, 161, 171, 218, 261, 371, 347, 393) df&lt;-data.frame(x=xdata, y=ydata) #weights applied in the case of no transformation (relative error assumed to be the same for all y data) W&lt;-1/ydata # NLS regression with weights, no transformation nlsmodel1&lt;-nlsLM(y ~ a*(x-x0)^b,data=df,start=list(a=0.1, b=2.5,x0=0)) # log transformed nlsmodel2&lt;-nlsLM(log(y) ~ a+b*(log(x-x0)),data=df,start=list(a=0.1, b=2.5,x0=0)) &gt; coef(nlsmodel1) a b x0 0.005158377 2.719693093 4.896772931 &gt; coef(nlsmodel2) a b x0 -8.683758 3.445699 -4.139127 &gt; exp(-8.683758) [1] 0.0001693136 </code></pre> <p>I understand that the weights are very important, and can have a say in the differences here, but not by this much? My judgement of the two parameter sets is that <code>nlsmodel1</code> performs "better", and that the <code>b</code> coefficient is too high in the fit from <code>nlsmodel2</code>. <code>nlsmodel2</code> does a poor job in the upper end of the data, with large residuals there. But why are they so different? I feel like I'm doing something very silly here, and is unable to see the error. I have tried some other transformations, for example only transforming LHS as <code>log(y)</code>, but the problem remains.</p> <p>I appreciate any tips that can help me improve, and not the least understand, the transformed fit.</p> <p>Cheers</p> <p>Related <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/58928/nonlinear-regression-confidence-intervals-on-transformed-or-untransformed-param">post #1</a> and <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/69524/on-nonlinear-regression-fits-and-transformations">post #2</a></p>
74,280
[ -0.02981552854180336, 0.006152528338134289, -0.007869372144341469, 0.006686859764158726, 0.014664377085864544, 0.008850839920341969, -0.03725721314549446, -0.03748440369963646, 0.029832858592271805, -0.025025593116879463, 0.02652345411479473, 0.039805397391319275, -0.007650105282664299, -0.02773470990359783, 0.0510193333029747, 0.05211445689201355, -0.011265954002737999, 0.018953504040837288, 0.022075122222304344, -0.010862347669899464, -0.003180993488058448, 0.019196996465325356, 0.02688360959291458, -0.005481954663991928, 0.0006193426670506597, 0.04322214052081108, 0.0009631658322177827, -0.010206998325884342, -0.02840259112417698, 0.10246781259775162, 0.007127727847546339, -0.04665851220488548, -0.006798539310693741, 0.021166816353797913, 0.02139267884194851, 0.0467110313475132, -0.02146952413022518, -0.0069208694621920586, -0.01051151379942894, 0.05759996175765991, -0.027398275211453438, 0.004757335875183344, 0.031397413462400436, 0.013566894456744194, 0.021606935188174248, 0.05579197406768799, -0.007012988906353712, -0.03361528739333153, 0.018329190090298653, -0.007041903678327799, 0.06916778534650803, 0.024515202268958092, 0.010878266766667366, 0.0139895835891366, -0.0019336424302309752, -0.021602099761366844, 0.08196302503347397, 0.09741412103176117, -0.04796857014298439, -0.0481799952685833, -0.0017434271285310388, -0.024171285331249237, -0.025929339230060577, -0.007314819842576981, 0.0020468132570385933, -0.013614831492304802, 0.0241913590580225, 0.028378142043948174, 0.03368941321969032, -0.04761699214577675, -0.017517821863293648, -0.03409067168831825, 0.037274040281772614, -0.049184177070856094, 0.01868332549929619, -0.02695353887975216, -0.014462927356362343, 0.029176441952586174, 0.025221161544322968, 0.049501072615385056, -0.012086848728358746, 0.02960469201207161, 0.014605258591473103, -0.007152304518967867, -0.004397490061819553, -0.013535871170461178, 0.04227921739220619, -0.003048087004572153, 0.05557689443230629, 0.04021233320236206, 0.0040292888879776, 0.030458807945251465, 0.033680714666843414, 0.008199256844818592, -0.006791895255446434, 0.05511954054236412, 0.007219032384455204, 0.004836718551814556, 0.04174646735191345, -0.016207745298743248, 0.018428046256303787, -0.046096935868263245, 0.017921146005392075, 0.07213959842920303, -0.020384950563311577, 0.007117862347513437, -0.020164133980870247, 0.011195194907486439, -0.014244712889194489, -0.056634824723005295, 0.010483869351446629, 0.008876867592334747, -0.008903834037482738, 0.02005063369870186, 0.01921512745320797, -0.05023010075092316, 0.00941887404769659, -0.010941402055323124, 0.03570980951189995, 0.0012503591133281589, 0.02640135958790779, -0.0237435232847929, 0.01237389538437128, 0.018787050619721413, -0.007930918596684933, -0.004220533184707165, -0.016116760671138763, -0.013216974213719368, -0.05144574120640755, 0.02053677663207054, 0.009258104488253593, -0.02282854914665222, 0.03352579101920128, 0.024925023317337036, 0.029239563271403313, 0.005756543483585119, -0.08912795782089233, -0.04002700373530388, 0.04278067871928215, -0.019374022260308266, -0.009196138009428978, -0.04198648780584335, -0.015891654416918755, 0.0038492002058774233, 0.02994553931057453, -0.007900217548012733, 0.032753463834524155, 0.06379394233226776, 0.023955458775162697, -0.010701512917876244, -0.017794912680983543, 0.011204524897038937, -0.027289824560284615, -0.029145365580916405, -0.009338906966149807, -0.06546489894390106, 0.0016197063960134983, 0.003849628148600459, -0.011728158220648766, -0.001705286093056202, 0.037817612290382385, -0.00507198553532362, -0.027371732518076897, 0.0007210286566987634, 0.02870764397084713, -0.017006801441311836, 0.07134639471769333, 0.014712966047227383, 0.0315074659883976, 0.02343156933784485, -0.036028631031513214, 0.004646604415029287, 0.007453379686921835, 0.05593922734260559, 0.09320671856403351, -0.014446154236793518, -0.004013873171061277, -0.043637678027153015, 0.011958823539316654, 0.021024659276008606, -0.05331148952245712, 0.004910122137516737, -0.011305691674351692, 0.002023461041972041, 0.04901203140616417, 0.045402590185403824, 0.0013751272344961762, -0.03091568499803543, 0.020172882825136185, -0.06862445175647736, -0.010630200617015362, -0.04040800780057907, -0.008927137590944767, -0.01053809467703104, -0.014656394720077515, 0.010437038727104664, -0.024895554408431053, 0.008741052821278572, -0.0015543996123597026, -0.0035708588548004627, 0.027885645627975464, 0.03403806686401367, 0.05053138732910156, -0.018945787101984024, 0.020984569564461708, 0.03541423752903938, 0.04753534123301506, -0.013561522588133812, 0.021226564422249794, -0.011989999562501907, -0.025523213669657707, 0.01484714075922966, -0.04784490540623665, -0.0025070097763091326, -0.034322962164878845, -0.013188478536903858, 0.003907112404704094, -0.028840871527791023, -0.013369237072765827, 0.02166958898305893, -0.0663113072514534, 0.03820621594786644, 0.05727952718734741, -0.011183095164597034, -0.04375651106238365, -0.007121598813682795, 0.004145465325564146, 0.05467010661959648, -0.0320432186126709, -0.017154037952423096, -0.06765921413898468, -0.0007200985564850271, -0.00486946664750576, 0.043280281126499176, -0.005906045902520418, 0.015933016315102577, 0.06637763231992722, -0.020361602306365967, -0.013329187408089638, 0.009764892980456352, -0.0001131193494074978, -0.013450155034661293, 0.002126651117578149, 0.008856656029820442, 0.024547046050429344, 0.016141286119818687, 0.033085744827985764, 0.020999424159526825, 0.049953676760196686, -0.005328363738954067, -0.0017550477059558034, 0.035276465117931366, 0.002836964325979352, 0.008634678088128567, -0.05151481181383133, 0.004234578926116228, 0.05162849277257919, -0.040327925235033035, -0.010449650697410107, 0.06567556411027908, 0.009579112753272057, 0.015203948132693768, -0.002344821346923709, 0.0026497605722397566, -0.006662074942141771, 0.03545285016298294, -0.017699744552373886, -0.010251504369080067, 0.010888788849115372, -0.04408169537782669, -0.006316747050732374, -0.05508779361844063, -0.03470242768526077, -0.02815193124115467, 0.015746211633086205, 0.022714272141456604, 0.027778124436736107, 0.03834037482738495, -0.045422643423080444, -0.017563218250870705, 0.002510625869035721, 0.0194917730987072, -0.0015158017631620169, -0.0217828880995512, -0.01815410889685154, -0.012067850679159164, -0.0417894683778286, 0.018609916791319847, 0.021134713664650917, -0.003687972202897072, 0.00915526319295168, 0.01726149581372738, -0.01856529340147972, -0.05338050052523613, -0.053035885095596313, -0.024086857214570045, -0.0076688253320753574, 0.0058813090436160564, -0.028241047635674477, 0.0483536534011364, 0.0046478863805532455, -0.038200318813323975, 0.03406733274459839, -0.03305479884147644, -0.012304507195949554, -0.02139873243868351, 0.01642196625471115, -0.031508419662714005, 0.023679150268435478, 0.0016927301185205579, -0.027921609580516815, -0.02475355751812458, -0.02095038630068302, -0.05885421857237816, -0.05200423672795296, -0.017730535939335823, -0.0014847468119114637, 0.007056225556880236, -0.014712315052747726, -0.02477109432220459, 0.0718817412853241, 0.028570204973220825, -0.04540953040122986, -0.04781389981508255, 0.020925844088196754, -0.027715830132365227, -0.008657448925077915, 0.03310739994049072, 0.05971791222691536, 0.025181779637932777, 0.02280866727232933, -0.030539635568857193, 0.027999870479106903, 0.044114820659160614, -0.026981573551893234, 0.033392518758773804, 0.00318166078068316, 0.009549099020659924, 0.004742469172924757, 0.03816724568605423, -0.001496350159868598, 0.003240216290578246, 0.011574500240385532, -0.03018621914088726, -0.019931752234697342, 0.033357881009578705, -0.06200030446052551, 0.03113732859492302, 0.0041083381511271, -0.0000745779398130253, -0.024024290964007378, 0.0030717598274350166, 0.004542049020528793, -0.051580850034952164, 0.009687875397503376, -0.009522945620119572, 0.03653712198138237, -0.005386888515204191, -0.032635558396577835, 0.014882929623126984, 0.0468226782977581, -0.013661074452102184, -0.017870420590043068, 0.013004505075514317, 0.0054144603200256824, 0.026367822661995888, -0.011689317412674427, 0.003997038118541241, 0.04131537675857544, 0.0431843176484108, -0.0322691947221756, -0.02443673275411129, -0.011106699705123901, 0.022073853760957718, -0.04537520557641983, -0.03227100148797035, -0.0130523182451725, 0.05228570103645325, 0.013134501874446869, 0.025505302473902702, -0.006360013037919998, -0.005457496736198664, 0.0018337909132242203, -0.00683071231469512, -0.06921733915805817, 0.04855404049158096, -0.01719135232269764, -0.02570073865354061, 0.0024784584529697895, -0.03131427615880966, 0.05755442753434181, -0.03008207306265831, 0.0024820442777127028, 0.0038856850005686283, 0.043520282953977585, -0.01777912862598896, 0.02749450132250786, -0.0043487842194736, -0.01951688528060913, -0.042912304401397705, 0.014847821556031704, -0.003984115086495876, -0.035149842500686646, 0.02699458785355091, 0.026363149285316467, 0.004345941822975874, -0.009689218364655972, -0.019562266767024994, 0.020716385915875435, 0.04568372666835785, 0.039167001843452454, 0.0121444221585989, 0.018758956342935562, -0.04347040131688118, -0.0002102857833961025, -0.014544980600476265, 0.031476106494665146, 0.021736545488238335, -0.005418848246335983, -0.03396068885922432, -0.007351506967097521, 0.03065812960267067, 0.018650507554411888, 0.0232818853110075, 0.006978430785238743, 0.027595356106758118, 0.05645953491330147, 0.014092971570789814, -0.03277275338768959, 0.01532704196870327, 0.017727648839354515, -0.011354963295161724, 0.0026334652211517096, -0.03483826667070389, -0.012965564616024494, -0.0034074869472533464, 0.02659265324473381, 0.012980279512703419, -0.01437433622777462, 0.005951233673840761, -0.03956152871251106, 0.10633255541324615, -0.0033919168636202812, -0.027103595435619354, -0.00507537554949522, 0.05750550702214241, 0.043607909232378006, -0.011275422759354115, -0.004289279691874981, 0.000023810773200239055, 0.0014794471208006144, 0.0606028214097023, -0.023719867691397667, 0.03830918297171593, -0.06566110253334045, -0.01670185476541519, 0.04152834042906761, 0.05435514077544212, -0.026143882423639297, -0.028614960610866547, -0.05466591194272041, -0.03183336928486824, 0.003391921054571867, -0.008160783909261227, 0.002724665217101574, 0.02382466569542885, 0.03032812848687172, -0.03773689642548561, -0.04791106656193733, -0.076482854783535, -0.03647409752011299, -0.014463940635323524, 0.017802294343709946, -0.05497434735298157, -0.018959006294608116, -0.032543767243623734, 0.009528127498924732, 0.013731412589550018, 0.07705099135637283, -0.09272991120815277, -0.052754539996385574, 0.018990717828273773, 0.03259032964706421, 0.007094721309840679, -0.0343637578189373, 0.04041612520813942, 0.004836374428123236, -0.015856929123401642, 0.03471851721405983, 0.04765685275197029, -0.02939734421670437, 0.007231718860566616, -0.007357435300946236, -0.0016781676094979048, 0.006421912461519241, -0.015241280198097229, 0.046075545251369476, 0.0024295111652463675, 0.005024465266615152, 0.0567953959107399, -0.0025179211515933275, -0.03498876467347145, -0.03867897018790245, -0.09835610538721085, 0.027072511613368988, -0.0269148126244545, -0.056303489953279495, -0.03590887039899826, -0.010970836505293846, 0.008116787299513817, 0.03873312100768089, -0.001370078301988542, 0.009780014865100384, -0.01521051675081253, -0.009440886788070202, 0.025928333401679993, 0.04046296700835228, -0.0321594662964344, 0.012597213499248028, 0.03898676484823227, 0.007006530184298754, -0.006757170427590609, -0.0010693572694435716, -0.005060282070189714, -0.008790838532149792, 0.00065977917984128, 0.04092038422822952, -0.05990525707602501, -0.011704391799867153, 0.026672182604670525, -0.013940206728875637, 0.03105093166232109, -0.0196711253374815, 0.015084555372595787, 0.029705578461289406, -0.0027724734973162413, -0.0049211750738322735, -0.043017033487558365, 0.013521355576813221, 0.02353830635547638, -0.010937162674963474, 0.028037909418344498, -0.04235147684812546, -0.001474343822337687, 0.007508902344852686, 0.0060659367591142654, -0.03561500459909439, -0.05799563601613045, 0.0202686358243227, -0.022832689806818962, -0.017963377758860588, -0.025121081620454788, -0.00929777231067419, -0.00437233317643404, -0.011331028304994106, -0.02754133939743042, 0.04289234057068825, -0.030616244301199913, -0.021886765956878662, -0.044202059507369995, 0.0296893622726202, 0.07244494557380676, -0.003459305502474308, 0.001754382741637528, 0.01648094318807125, -0.027515171095728874, -0.03386472538113594, 0.02163158915936947, -0.01117859035730362, -0.009274245239794254, 0.001885614707134664, 0.007874630391597748, -0.0186590775847435, 0.04167182743549347, -0.006361431907862425, -0.01573716290295124, 0.009862449020147324, 0.03943505883216858, -0.018350105732679367, 0.019920142367482185, -0.03065589629113674, -0.02186635509133339, 0.00893706176429987, -0.0066387406550347805, -0.010969806462526321, -0.012433838099241257, -0.025378679856657982, 0.0379086472094059, -0.021955186501145363, -0.05745355784893036, 0.030745066702365875, 0.06820940226316452, 0.024656401947140694, 0.006020812783390284, 0.0029611047357320786, -0.013889719732105732, 0.04861561208963394, 0.032082121819257736, -0.006141819525510073, 0.020082563161849976, 0.024737592786550522, -0.04131925478577614, -0.0579385906457901, -0.02666928619146347, 0.023689525201916695, 0.052506525069475174, 0.0036206103395670652, 0.04293438419699669, 0.007783850189298391, 0.0007351685198955238, 0.04023972153663635, -0.03334624320268631, -0.0277063250541687, -0.008970259688794613, -0.0040166741237044334, 0.046590838581323624, -0.007747840601950884, -0.02945856750011444, -0.008016787469387054, -0.02192160300910473, 0.010891765356063843, 0.03939646854996681, -0.00419835839420557, 0.0030095018446445465, -0.020289180800318718, 0.004809631500393152, -0.07911238819360733, 0.021662265062332153, -0.02251788228750229, 0.019955473020672798, -0.020824503153562546, -0.024207623675465584, 0.03946833685040474, 0.026939626783132553, 0.006589782889932394, -0.047339048236608505, -0.018742192536592484, -0.06115736439824104, -0.028196554630994797, 0.028889529407024384, -0.012071030214428902, 0.02912444807589054, 0.05111290514469147, -0.00003563859354471788, -0.01644943654537201, 0.041237641125917435, -0.026722421869635582, -0.06528984010219574, 0.00026185030583292246, -0.011997584253549576, -0.05348816141486168, 0.06806474924087524, -0.03951391950249672, -0.031651124358177185, 0.010182829573750496, -0.08424653857946396, 0.033274564892053604, 0.02105058915913105, 0.032603077590465546, 0.015140627510845661, 0.03922401741147041, -0.001528882305137813, -0.023173028603196144, -0.04431406781077385, -0.010658424347639084, 0.14219534397125244, 0.038387320935726166, 0.051812585443258286, -0.0639851838350296, -0.017896220088005066, 0.020683500915765762, 0.0031852175015956163, -0.007853368297219276, -0.04040554538369179, 0.05872846394777298, -0.01905619166791439, 0.013363629579544067, 0.02245602384209633, 0.012315813452005386, 0.004209667909890413, 0.036429841071367264, -0.028360549360513687, -0.006242131814360619, 0.012797852046787739, -0.025456253439188004, 0.005952215753495693, -0.018846727907657623, -0.04527134448289871, 0.025152523070573807, 0.005027657374739647, 0.0037711726035922766, -0.02077845297753811, -0.013668560422956944, -0.007900073193013668, -0.021511664614081383, -0.05979098752140999, 0.026802554726600647, 0.03620066121220589, -0.007283458951860666, 0.02825981378555298, 0.02317364141345024, 0.02356579527258873, -0.04212282598018646, 0.0058238310739398, 0.018750984221696854, 0.0021762901451438665, -0.01746840961277485, -0.005967907607555389, -0.019322490319609642, -0.03131379932165146, -0.02668447047472, -0.03866976499557495, 0.019913960248231888, 0.007547352928668261, -0.014296941459178925, 0.016127806156873703, -0.0009173467988148332, -0.011123194359242916, -0.034169431775808334, 0.021274307742714882, 0.041081201285123825, 0.0410136952996254, -0.00997602567076683, -0.03694292902946472, 0.009817243553698063, 0.019269587472081184, -0.02174348384141922, -0.005887405481189489, 0.060105908662080765, -0.023957207798957825, -0.011264540255069733, 0.007450445089489222, 0.039698243141174316, -0.025250717997550964, 0.029486216604709625, 0.027581337839365005, 0.01916101761162281, -0.04048680141568184, -0.035794492810964584, 0.014315431006252766, -0.050813328474760056, 0.049870289862155914, 0.024271303787827492, -0.006246690172702074, -0.012217503041028976, -0.052721958607435226, 0.025372764095664024, -0.020934678614139557, 0.041506923735141754, -0.04623744636774063, 0.012742132879793644, 0.023262159898877144, 0.017318764701485634, 0.018002081662416458, 0.009622556157410145, -0.01779901422560215, 0.029430916532874107, -0.005021028686314821, -0.05684663727879524, -0.04037472605705261, 0.011199516244232655, -0.009690331295132637, -0.022444695234298706, -0.011407699435949326, 0.06642797589302063, 0.037246640771627426, 0.042158085852861404, -0.011292972601950169, 0.01185078825801611, 0.008083637803792953, 0.003853829577565193, 0.03592318296432495, -0.02825702540576458, 0.0009614616283215582, 0.03137001022696495, -0.00709765637293458, -0.024591222405433655, 0.014241899363696575, -0.04059296101331711, -0.04937401041388512, 0.004103380721062422, -0.036706987768411636, -0.012616846710443497, -0.0003452288801781833, -0.004767167381942272, -0.01897648721933365, -0.014208354987204075, -0.02364381030201912, -0.0019371196394786239, -0.004931686911731958, -0.04644071310758591, -0.01306591834872961, -0.012922548688948154, 0.017293380573391914, -0.043003495782613754, -0.025931930169463158, 0.05352429673075676, 0.0021243139635771513, 0.036271970719099045, -0.03295649215579033, 0.03142757713794708, 0.005914685782045126, 0.056503813713788986, 0.0003803555155172944, -0.030210556462407112, 0.04689249023795128, -0.020312881097197533, -0.037122201174497604, 0.024929556995630264, 0.013155906461179256, 0.00731884827837348, 0.008756186813116074, 0.03581409156322479, -0.04066818952560425, 0.04749874025583267, -0.03457547351717949, 0.029900461435317993, -0.03692302480340004, -0.015803854912519455, 0.02138976939022541, -0.01346438005566597, 0.018390027806162834, 0.00306427082978189, 0.01027835626155138, 0.022618602961301804, 0.03574993833899498, -0.038027118891477585, 0.015720874071121216, 0.015431133098900318, 0.004430138971656561, 0.03948007524013519, -0.016721287742257118, -0.009046316146850586, 0.01300431415438652, 0.048490408807992935, -0.029080377891659737, 0.013423836790025234, -0.004378609824925661, 0.021746957674622536, -0.06394417583942413, -0.002284002723172307, -0.01568968966603279, 0.03576916828751564, 0.022357720881700516, -0.06531842052936554, -0.02506912499666214, 0.04737880453467369, -0.0019512297585606575, -0.04600531980395317, 0.007376024965196848, -0.0174593236297369, 0.00262892572209239, -0.00484272837638855, -0.030039630830287933, -0.0011869192821905017, 0.06288117915391922, 0.03472669795155525, 0.0551777109503746, -0.00551981944590807, -0.00143905368167907, 0.0005955213564448059, -0.018904011696577072, 0.0162141602486372, 0.03580503538250923, -0.05494498461484909, 0.01807381771504879, -0.04108313471078873, -0.005376915447413921, 0.061882175505161285, -0.0115636195987463, 0.03683123737573624, 0.008958530612289906, 0.0491783507168293, 0.011123559437692165, 0.08636412769556046, 0.036971256136894226, 0.011498309671878815, -0.023425579071044922, 0.0027947225607931614, 0.051861826330423355, 0.03744053840637207, -0.015240966342389584, 0.005883554462343454, -0.009018207900226116, 0.004912328906357288, -0.01981429010629654, 0.02313052862882614, -0.003652285784482956, -0.0033476396929472685, -0.006386018358170986, 0.002209531608968973, -0.037612732499837875, -0.0465848371386528, -0.0007641749107278883, -0.006894235964864492, 0.009097311645746231, 0.04756360873579979, 0.04653600603342056, -0.030408596619963646, 0.017719635739922523, 0.012039974331855774, -0.02784772962331772, 0.0036269945558160543, -0.013463502749800682, 0.008221874944865704, -0.052692022174596786, -0.001065882039256394, -0.0315607488155365, -0.017308242619037628, -0.027186676859855652, 0.00980844534933567, -0.07751518487930298, 0.047939375042915344, -0.013872254639863968, -0.0001421113993274048, -0.000007889985681686085, -0.03385172411799431, 0.013646517880260944, -0.11304990947246552, 0.10121282190084457, 0.009942950680851936, 0.02864775061607361, -0.030899664387106895, 0.01952504552900791, 0.0044777109287679195, 0.01697552390396595, 0.0704282596707344, 0.04017749801278114, 0.002243638504296541, 0.023829858750104904, 0.03758605569601059, -0.00015473215898964554, -0.01660846173763275, 0.01039787009358406, -0.02141749858856201, -0.018906554207205772, 0.017733823508024216, -0.023227257654070854, 0.015407055616378784, 0.03180098906159401, 0.010355411097407341, -0.01619642972946167, -0.012714742682874203, -0.018116675317287445, 0.013487978838384151, 0.028771713376045227, 0.014072977006435394, -0.037794895470142365, 0.034848403185606, 0.028851082548499107, -0.0036631282418966293, 0.020033102482557297, 0.037828486412763596, -0.06094285845756531, -0.011430647224187851, 0.008108101785182953, -0.021539825946092606, 0.009773247875273228, -0.017074795439839363, 0.0028454000130295753, -0.04951317235827446, 0.011843814514577389, 0.034708503633737564, 0.000006507812031486537, -0.006666532251983881, 0.07053416222333908, 0.020626941695809364, 0.025293497368693352, -0.006882739253342152, 0.006029699929058552, -0.0031652417965233326, 0.005894678179174662, 0.003248330671340227, -0.015380462631583214, 0.00398728484287858, -0.012359431013464928, -0.033333584666252136, 0.012035674415528774, -0.02799111418426037, 0.03645913675427437, -0.009479752741754055, 0.07576444745063782, -0.01946283131837845, -0.03566749021410942, 0.05454651266336441, -0.0282395388931036, 0.0003705587878357619, -0.03272947669029236, -0.007510948460549116, 0.03926701098680496, -0.056066084653139114, 0.006529280450195074, -0.03031170554459095, -0.0002239211171399802, 0.025482608005404472, -0.014688913710415363, -0.01765141822397709, -0.01130689773708582, 0.02391190268099308, 0.008161441422998905, -0.0012751449830830097, -0.029436644166707993, 0.022174954414367676, -0.0181280430406332, 0.01937718875706196, -0.0006300677778199315, -0.0012091416865587234, -0.002220549387857318, -0.04865334928035736, -0.008259089663624763, -0.057516343891620636, 0.0231027714908123, 0.039038341492414474, -0.004855690989643335, -0.0033895603846758604, -0.05360167846083641, 0.0005342332297004759, 0.064827561378479, -0.0647115409374237, -0.04045679047703743, -0.016421545296907425, -0.03166179731488228, 0.007284820079803467, -0.06766890734434128 ]
<p>I wanted to find out if there are any implications to using OLS when i have cardinal data as dependent variables. So my dependent variables are counts of a certain outcome and they exist as natural numbers 0,1,2,3,...N</p> <p>My independent variable is a series of realized volatility.</p> <p>Is there a better way such data could be described?</p>
74,281
[ -0.01238590944558382, -0.012624002993106842, -0.005445029120892286, -0.018296999856829643, 0.032159384340047836, 0.008284194394946098, -0.012035692110657692, -0.004584727343171835, 0.05440237745642662, -0.026750335469841957, 0.00942565780133009, 0.03738168254494667, 0.05612698569893837, 0.005096869543194771, 0.015671199187636375, 0.00424474710598588, -0.03305412828922272, 0.03259095549583435, -0.002277257852256298, -0.008063741959631443, -0.007416821550577879, 0.034898195415735245, 0.027630850672721863, 0.01817294768989086, -0.022689910605549812, 0.038091763854026794, 0.020738687366247177, -0.018723854795098305, 0.006509638391435146, 0.04520316421985626, -0.008164278231561184, -0.010142180137336254, 0.020872747525572777, 0.03297271206974983, 0.04554862529039383, 0.03229574114084244, -0.05259780213236809, -0.028976501896977425, 0.02095182053744793, 0.02337629534304142, -0.026043850928544998, -0.035851482301950455, -0.01982601173222065, 0.025183245539665222, 0.016586964949965477, 0.0019026541849598289, 0.0006645703688263893, -0.03695657476782799, 0.024620484560728073, -0.017529981210827827, 0.10662436485290527, -0.018422678112983704, 0.007544731255620718, 0.05977514386177063, -0.0006646132678724825, -0.0019513641018420458, 0.05380508303642273, 0.05798771604895592, 0.0067113894037902355, -0.017495816573500633, -0.02110482007265091, 0.0005403094692155719, -0.013877492398023605, -0.04051923379302025, -0.015150959603488445, 0.01699947752058506, -0.0020453885663300753, -0.020363640040159225, 0.02167300507426262, 0.005137299653142691, 0.022403500974178314, 0.025394408032298088, 0.011899439617991447, 0.009464049711823463, 0.038587674498558044, 0.01893964223563671, 0.019261199980974197, 0.001006779377348721, 0.048089709132909775, 0.008888030424714088, -0.0007551924791187048, -0.0001575153728481382, 0.0417412593960762, 0.03417445346713066, 0.002868091454729438, 0.009697414934635162, 0.016495775431394577, -0.025262780487537384, 0.006879960186779499, 0.02554982341825962, 0.011010218411684036, 0.008236478082835674, 0.0764409527182579, 0.020732609555125237, -0.06464731693267822, 0.022826727479696274, -0.017823154106736183, 0.003801985178142786, -0.0007182013941928744, -0.0016372199170291424, 0.0023278058506548405, -0.046138957142829895, -0.003432591212913394, 0.027969781309366226, -0.022748149931430817, -0.022320259362459183, -0.005677240900695324, -0.01912449300289154, 0.009397882036864758, -0.07044217735528946, -0.018767835572361946, 0.022420596331357956, 0.015981771051883698, 0.04846509173512459, -0.016275277361273766, -0.009858425706624985, -0.039043277502059937, 0.00937750842422247, 0.024866243824362755, 0.09401090443134308, -0.0023126627784222364, 0.0056241839192807674, 0.021314015612006187, -0.00002987862899317406, -0.05984422564506531, 0.030242329463362694, 0.018022535368800163, -0.009166315197944641, -0.05460137873888016, 0.043393369764089584, 0.00638216407969594, -0.006296906620264053, 0.030769558623433113, -0.032023776322603226, 0.03441443666815758, -0.005329849198460579, -0.08298924565315247, -0.03893524780869484, 0.007931414060294628, -0.03508960083127022, -0.006509347353130579, -0.035855382680892944, -0.008223343640565872, 0.032651081681251526, 0.050809793174266815, -0.009589731693267822, 0.04167493060231209, 0.023365626111626625, 0.036788877099752426, 0.029252896085381508, -0.023557906970381737, -0.01149140577763319, -0.020596086978912354, -0.06356577575206757, -0.014626257121562958, -0.03483382612466812, 0.0376824289560318, 0.02173994667828083, 0.005387385841459036, -0.016287336125969887, 0.04663112759590149, 0.007518160622566938, -0.005308862309902906, 0.0038796430453658104, 0.0055526853539049625, -0.05309537053108215, 0.05164258927106857, -0.005077999085187912, 0.004602956119924784, 0.035605914890766144, -0.007304803002625704, 0.02755402773618698, 0.03354991227388382, 0.0514252632856369, 0.026589782908558846, -0.011238554492592812, 0.012325961142778397, -0.05945350229740143, 0.02953691966831684, 0.0066227782517671585, -0.027075275778770447, -0.012065998278558254, -0.01739153265953064, -0.03035455010831356, 0.002500363392755389, 0.04327986016869545, 0.026365848258137703, -0.027340121567249298, 0.04937633499503136, -0.057101063430309296, -0.048465389758348465, -0.06499525904655457, 0.023773152381181717, 0.009175099432468414, -0.013003818690776825, -0.0032330425456166267, 0.014304820448160172, 0.0036804252304136753, -0.010880077257752419, 0.005481272470206022, -0.02355700172483921, -0.010905524715781212, 0.014835827052593231, -0.04696802422404289, 0.025918282568454742, 0.06897848844528198, 0.03613072633743286, -0.009774514473974705, 0.021189948543906212, -0.043286148458719254, -0.022800859063863754, -0.030435219407081604, -0.03919445723295212, 0.0369163379073143, 0.025286441668868065, -0.002072995761409402, -0.007306699641048908, 0.0026679611764848232, -0.03456347435712814, 0.0355151891708374, -0.06320945918560028, 0.049042556434869766, 0.09510152041912079, 0.020687395706772804, 0.015905655920505524, 0.005584471859037876, 0.03410361334681511, -0.027217350900173187, -0.010917126201093197, -0.011581961996853352, -0.059586700052022934, 0.03441658616065979, 0.04670359194278717, 0.0449642576277256, -0.023983832448720932, 0.01626048982143402, 0.058244138956069946, 0.018736843019723892, -0.029922183603048325, 0.0076706670224666595, -0.018140841275453568, -0.025133488699793816, -0.004955115728080273, -0.036278292536735535, 0.05347015708684921, 0.029974445700645447, 0.03556742146611214, 0.01156798005104065, 0.028329193592071533, -0.032963380217552185, -0.011892762035131454, 0.03194086253643036, -0.028986653313040733, -0.030825132504105568, 0.005912202876061201, -0.005359104834496975, 0.04660186916589737, -0.01174626499414444, 0.008313771337270737, 0.045482467859983444, 0.02275950089097023, -0.010717596858739853, -0.005505062639713287, 0.014295992441475391, 0.034081343561410904, 0.03241325542330742, -0.0704701617360115, -0.0076882606372237206, 0.00883268192410469, -0.029903991147875786, 0.003693095874041319, 0.007116697262972593, -0.05257019028067589, -0.020488208159804344, 0.0005043186247348785, 0.03471217676997185, -0.007858382537961006, 0.015806930139660835, -0.003869731444865465, -0.05615071952342987, 0.017679696902632713, -0.020685773342847824, 0.018988819792866707, 0.01947772316634655, -0.07236956804990768, -0.012380451895296574, -0.008024792186915874, -0.02457377314567566, 0.010898830369114876, -0.009358701296150684, -0.02494693361222744, 0.03421773388981819, -0.0406225211918354, -0.050050098448991776, -0.041430823504924774, -0.021338414400815964, -0.021898988634347916, -0.0368431881070137, -0.01433326955884695, 0.03979828208684921, -0.0015301640378311276, 0.0019032484851777554, -0.05837969109416008, -0.041365958750247955, -0.013750618323683739, -0.028399070724844933, -0.00029779874603264034, 0.009342999197542667, 0.025200294330716133, 0.008488839492201805, -0.008269434794783592, -0.017955226823687553, -0.004856664687395096, -0.06491880118846893, -0.07875728607177734, -0.0057509723119437695, -0.02945779263973236, 0.014600136317312717, -0.009498064406216145, -0.021747365593910217, 0.03991681709885597, 0.03400221839547157, -0.035203833132982254, -0.027819141745567322, -0.0194998886436224, -0.018654046580195427, -0.025950631126761436, 0.04616143926978111, -0.019388675689697266, -0.006228843238204718, 0.010641422122716904, -0.017757168039679527, 0.04294883832335472, 0.02599126100540161, 0.0005023572593927383, -0.011819074861705303, 0.06856342405080795, -0.005809821654111147, 0.010240082629024982, 0.0022623741533607244, 0.02044595032930374, -0.042471837252378464, 0.009511359967291355, 0.008729850873351097, 0.014940807595849037, 0.03257187455892563, -0.061281055212020874, 0.018140461295843124, 0.011171312071383, -0.013572770170867443, -0.0012704613618552685, 0.03395450487732887, 0.043950870633125305, -0.011804190464317799, -0.060563549399375916, 0.012295909225940704, 0.018016885966062546, -0.04703591763973236, 0.02628396451473236, 0.0236190315335989, 0.015333881601691246, 0.006515119690448046, -0.022196169942617416, 0.02464907616376877, -0.006929304916411638, 0.035962674766778946, -0.031311675906181335, 0.02255418337881565, 0.0045305779203772545, 0.0447910912334919, 0.04771548509597778, -0.02955595590174198, -0.04214590787887573, -0.01180935651063919, -0.02452205680310726, 0.012198178097605705, -0.030448567122220993, 0.04374241456389427, 0.008753218688070774, 0.03933750092983246, -0.0007429316756315529, -0.007835634984076023, -0.00923540536314249, 0.022621626034379005, -0.0660645067691803, -0.026699503883719444, -0.053172800689935684, 0.028657767921686172, 0.0043902467004954815, -0.007902261801064014, 0.05768753960728645, -0.04258687049150467, -0.006667205598205328, -0.01155976764857769, -0.013283978216350079, -0.030766725540161133, -0.02875063754618168, 0.006100869737565517, 0.0011770910350605845, 0.022058090195059776, 0.003270765533670783, -0.029545830562710762, 0.0025841323658823967, 0.0373384915292263, 0.059582918882369995, 0.003008820815011859, -0.030730590224266052, -0.039293475449085236, 0.013261094689369202, -0.0026319867465645075, 0.016835223883390427, 0.011510893702507019, 0.02899414487183094, -0.05319370701909065, 0.0866398960351944, 0.013418802991509438, 0.04457830637693405, 0.0775003731250763, 0.009909472428262234, -0.03725794702768326, -0.04910857602953911, -0.035130344331264496, 0.015751076862215996, 0.017834216356277466, 0.046882446855306625, -0.01945727877318859, 0.1143624484539032, -0.004494030028581619, -0.025867648422718048, -0.016937360167503357, 0.0626554787158966, 0.016290780156850815, 0.033346958458423615, -0.0002004441776080057, 0.015679553151130676, -0.005389115773141384, 0.014279834926128387, 0.011776133440434933, 0.011679493822157383, -0.012135454453527927, 0.012866824865341187, 0.04522908478975296, 0.005871013272553682, -0.03299979865550995, 0.027543267235159874, -0.00717461621388793, 0.01120157539844513, -0.042584024369716644, -0.07837312668561935, 0.03927992284297943, 0.06044682487845421, 0.036538124084472656, 0.03556407615542412, 0.008565987460315228, -0.09513623267412186, 0.004484888166189194, 0.032169003039598465, 0.02749232016503811, -0.03057732619345188, 0.013270916417241096, -0.0018074805848300457, -0.025432929396629333, 0.03874479979276657, -0.042367979884147644, 0.024748997762799263, -0.013421457260847092, -0.005531861446797848, -0.031441062688827515, -0.025307655334472656, -0.03837212547659874, -0.006449982989579439, -0.029278121888637543, 0.0575534850358963, -0.017076749354600906, -0.004517527297139168, -0.03632289171218872, 0.03677298128604889, 0.019445037469267845, 0.03894592821598053, 0.009853167459368706, -0.021262390539050102, -0.017904018983244896, 0.01374785602092743, -0.018373239785432816, -0.05769108980894089, 0.06220760568976402, 0.01379940565675497, 0.018435949459671974, 0.04768829792737961, 0.02917247638106346, -0.05852100998163223, 0.0019985418766736984, 0.0014189701760187745, -0.005322238430380821, -0.00521031953394413, -0.00926015805453062, 0.06489714980125427, 0.02620820701122284, -0.009014775045216084, 0.035894524306058884, 0.029614143073558807, 0.01602829620242119, 0.03284815698862076, -0.03134846314787865, 0.019119806587696075, -0.04268056899309158, -0.010389036498963833, -0.01807832531630993, -0.009343143552541733, -0.001591843320056796, 0.029978210106492043, 0.022759592160582542, 0.036095622926950455, -0.043324533849954605, 0.00007775553967803717, 0.008983827196061611, 0.009076283313333988, 0.018882935866713524, -0.00813722051680088, -0.035338230431079865, -0.011596622876822948, -0.007000700570642948, -0.00902849156409502, -0.012855442240834236, -0.04049874469637871, 0.013716037385165691, -0.0018191124545410275, -0.029304150491952896, -0.0035587328020483255, -0.02776605263352394, -0.04521290212869644, 0.03373943641781807, -0.01101173646748066, 0.0293712355196476, 0.01596674881875515, 0.017433948814868927, 0.00030549976509064436, -0.049902040511369705, -0.019896600395441055, 0.00023445350234396756, -0.012613166123628616, 0.039497122168540955, -0.049320902675390244, 0.017793621867895126, -0.025722481310367584, 0.006862353067845106, -0.06474030762910843, -0.026840971782803535, -0.020492397248744965, -0.017012158408761024, -0.0020712646655738354, 0.0024965887423604727, 0.0017088445601984859, -0.013723747804760933, -0.04844406992197037, -0.012106434442102909, 0.03147966414690018, -0.041409265249967575, -0.029675282537937164, -0.026235083118081093, -0.007211665157228708, 0.06648468971252441, -0.023165235295891762, -0.032336220145225525, 0.017926866188645363, -0.02655274048447609, 0.010345892049372196, 0.00850557629019022, 0.022741399705410004, -0.022090263664722443, -0.02803833782672882, -0.03552964702248573, -0.025205424055457115, 0.0181295033544302, -0.047915395349264145, -0.0058367750607430935, -0.01026537548750639, 0.013068065978586674, 0.01897883228957653, -0.00344415963627398, -0.001183404354378581, 0.006030513439327478, 0.021641450002789497, 0.008604343049228191, -0.003387690056115389, -0.0026299257297068834, -0.0003919096488971263, 0.006143746431916952, -0.0013822567416355014, -0.015953905880451202, 0.07700198888778687, 0.047921936959028244, 0.014354371465742588, -0.024990860372781754, 0.009294606745243073, -0.017272168770432472, 0.0176373403519392, -0.01510957907885313, -0.017445703968405724, 0.021063687279820442, 0.06656988710165024, -0.04524862393736839, -0.06503274291753769, -0.04376799240708351, 0.013857964426279068, 0.04038754105567932, -0.034967925399541855, 0.009846133179962635, 0.014077520929276943, -0.007762869819998741, -0.008078549057245255, -0.05673705041408539, 0.014407224021852016, -0.007131475023925304, 0.009210998192429543, 0.019250908866524696, -0.03760040923953056, 0.012163974344730377, 0.005971895530819893, 0.012340215966105461, -0.015389755368232727, 0.026500854641199112, 0.03409791737794876, -0.012197896838188171, 0.029797406867146492, -0.031390778720378876, -0.04501524195075035, 0.026656582951545715, -0.061098288744688034, 0.023348111659288406, -0.060355622321367264, -0.03344908729195595, 0.026976535096764565, 0.0390891470015049, 0.020005784928798676, -0.05927953124046326, -0.027927013114094734, -0.0518089234828949, 0.029150066897273064, 0.0475485660135746, 0.00621193228289485, 0.05081956833600998, -0.0162324458360672, 0.05017993971705437, 0.01707378588616848, 0.0010477456962689757, 0.025532789528369904, -0.09392407536506653, -0.026020247489213943, -0.005017929244786501, -0.04994288459420204, 0.014413886703550816, -0.015018345788121223, 0.006244241259992123, 0.019520167261362076, -0.024603208526968956, 0.03456612676382065, 0.003153627971187234, 0.027280081063508987, 0.013905094936490059, 0.10493841022253036, 0.0072127231396734715, 0.009990350343286991, -0.03761821240186691, 0.03557974100112915, 0.1177554652094841, 0.0876016765832901, 0.03107054904103279, -0.053149424493312836, -0.014605134725570679, 0.013967960141599178, 0.01844630017876625, -0.03538662940263748, -0.015986235812306404, 0.005084842909127474, -0.006921694613993168, -0.0010430625407025218, 0.057441189885139465, -0.014831173233687878, -0.029012437909841537, 0.05172203108668327, -0.04075424000620842, -0.027513783425092697, -0.01823359727859497, 0.003207059344276786, -0.024120358750224113, -0.0050404551438987255, -0.08734527975320816, -0.0015666910912841558, 0.011720326729118824, -0.03819657489657402, 0.022115375846624374, 0.01051978301256895, 0.013483839109539986, 0.04721146821975708, -0.022802216932177544, -0.02901533804833889, 0.08326447755098343, 0.019667042419314384, -0.018210286274552345, 0.005822174716740847, 0.013619372621178627, -0.023342382162809372, 0.021328788250684738, 0.033886898308992386, -0.01627524569630623, -0.022815575823187828, 0.007861616089940071, 0.0019575566984713078, -0.06353483349084854, 0.002384959254413843, -0.04547521099448204, 0.00994690228253603, 0.011453363113105297, 0.030280277132987976, -0.06661952286958694, 0.004090898670256138, 0.004456024616956711, -0.05458260327577591, -0.011506937444210052, 0.03278927505016327, 0.04955798387527466, -0.056893281638622284, -0.05823511630296707, -0.04620775207877159, -0.018557609990239143, -0.02063944935798645, 0.02821263112127781, 0.015521282330155373, -0.03832767903804779, -0.02094256319105625, -0.023718414828181267, 0.01960734650492668, 0.002647641347721219, 0.006046710070222616, -0.0005226367502473295, 0.009321817196905613, -0.017108967527747154, -0.014754447154700756, 0.001159677398391068, -0.02099009044468403, 0.01534290611743927, 0.0009144197101704776, -0.0005002014804631472, -0.016949322074651718, -0.006183861289173365, 0.0387432686984539, -0.01979151740670204, -0.03040873073041439, -0.006692661438137293, 0.010965326800942421, -0.011866954155266285, 0.005094061605632305, 0.012781315483152866, 0.038919076323509216, 0.02710884064435959, 0.0457615852355957, 0.025530654937028885, -0.06591439992189407, -0.0328894779086113, 0.015709631145000458, -0.03668572008609772, -0.03015889786183834, -0.004935183562338352, 0.047431692481040955, -0.0026099528186023235, 0.01671350747346878, 0.01765013113617897, 0.05304877087473869, 0.011767696589231491, 0.030819809064269066, 0.013196800835430622, -0.04708670824766159, 0.026460908353328705, 0.02510368637740612, 0.010177068412303925, -0.012930704280734062, -0.05479089543223381, -0.04248339682817459, -0.014397579245269299, -0.04606692120432854, -0.03270668163895607, -0.06960798054933548, 0.03645426407456398, -0.01577557437121868, 0.014296846464276314, 0.0004015822778455913, -0.0057939100079238415, -0.0038062480743974447, -0.020272018387913704, -0.03355806693434715, -0.02627658285200596, 0.026425709947943687, 0.02078668400645256, 0.005712007638067007, 0.010768033564090729, 0.056054648011922836, 0.013966175727546215, 0.041381318122148514, -0.05351951718330383, 0.022437717765569687, -0.018525252118706703, 0.05120100826025009, -0.04068788141012192, -0.013190900906920433, 0.03180762007832527, 0.004793008789420128, 0.008349726907908916, 0.020640885457396507, -0.003125940216705203, 0.06108694523572922, 0.01448920276015997, -0.0010281753493472934, -0.07082857936620712, -0.0006434262613765895, -0.02449120208621025, 0.017573291435837746, -0.00011097090464318171, 0.021229058504104614, -0.004938620608299971, 0.006844895426183939, -0.005594534333795309, 0.026482360437512398, -0.00041216585668735206, 0.017174512147903442, 0.04477400332689285, 0.030185934156179428, -0.009318201802670956, 0.025980915874242783, -0.02528018318116665, -0.0192385446280241, -0.012510874308645725, 0.01653268188238144, 0.01904774084687233, 0.034731581807136536, -0.05217520520091057, 0.01255367137491703, 0.0029369909316301346, 0.01834232360124588, -0.07362028956413269, -0.02476106397807598, 0.022127874195575714, 0.03868876025080681, 0.0399758443236351, -0.02879258804023266, 0.025710076093673706, -0.015280402265489101, -0.00952074769884348, -0.0007165197166614234, 0.020509593188762665, -0.001016444992274046, -0.030085032805800438, 0.00828648917376995, -0.043009839951992035, 0.02808719128370285, 0.021470269188284874, 0.026059065014123917, 0.023548366501927376, 0.041162170469760895, 0.013723183423280716, -0.036247193813323975, 0.007494890131056309, -0.0017721628537401557, -0.010438326746225357, -0.09451048821210861, 0.03291859105229378, -0.05416727811098099, -0.019532378762960434, 0.06546194851398468, -0.010194809176027775, 0.030361680313944817, 0.04587870091199875, 0.017903782427310944, 0.00874335691332817, 0.04893910512328148, -0.0012278795475140214, 0.002672892063856125, 0.0020981919951736927, -0.022940635681152344, 0.03583876043558121, 0.00292295147664845, -0.011190005578100681, 0.003989589866250753, 0.05153312161564827, -0.009415912441909313, -0.0028209472075104713, 0.02799093723297119, 0.003794947871938348, 0.012519735842943192, -0.038065649569034576, -0.023665955290198326, 0.0017950451001524925, -0.0007332751993089914, 0.06636666506528854, -0.024783294647932053, -0.05598653852939606, 0.029124177992343903, -0.009573355317115784, -0.014168400317430496, -0.0013607008149847388, 0.0010914420709013939, -0.04782881960272789, 0.00003912475585821085, 0.044753581285476685, 0.007516724988818169, -0.0355362743139267, -0.015943488106131554, 0.01265186257660389, -0.0031368229538202286, -0.011272014118731022, 0.009740951471030712, -0.0195084810256958, 0.004042373038828373, -0.03481537848711014, 0.011702069081366062, 0.03743518143892288, -0.004876923747360706, 0.004259675275534391, -0.09087475389242172, 0.06676225364208221, 0.035312723368406296, 0.008173531852662563, 0.0012162632774561644, 0.02260597236454487, -0.030603814870119095, 0.012944241054356098, 0.05305369570851326, 0.002482503419741988, 0.005987714976072311, 0.005893046967685223, 0.029643958434462547, 0.004473281558603048, -0.04010471701622009, 0.011251519434154034, 0.0005067907040938735, 0.00885917991399765, -0.02504727430641651, -0.03178052231669426, 0.029032932594418526, -0.014021930284798145, -0.003531378461048007, -0.0046067009679973125, -0.007691111881285906, -0.004444289021193981, -0.03844067081809044, 0.021309958770871162, -0.018726659938693047, -0.01014445535838604, 0.05013233423233032, 0.004638406913727522, -0.009587621316313744, 0.0025632164906710386, -0.0318782813847065, -0.04918097332119942, 0.03163082152605057, -0.03968445584177971, 0.004573426209390163, -0.02002710849046707, -0.018420951440930367, -0.005806697532534599, -0.03549809753894806, -0.02186489850282669, 0.02040666714310646, -0.01693468727171421, -0.012233586050570011, 0.017808450385928154, 0.003925761207938194, 0.02155042439699173, 0.01680092141032219, 0.004774637054651976, 0.024258766323328018, -0.02094307169318199, 0.029907533898949623, 0.01779804565012455, 0.04549577459692955, 0.022005002945661545, 0.011228895746171474, 0.041829757392406464, -0.013667312450706959, 0.048571061342954636, 0.03788726404309273, 0.02544415555894375, -0.05828245356678963, -0.004445256199687719, 0.00814943015575409, 0.019095223397016525, 0.02122291922569275, 0.01328239869326353, 0.02363983914256096, 0.09206514060497284, -0.02617296762764454, 0.016007179394364357, -0.024746285751461983, 0.010814851149916649, -0.04139552637934685, -0.018068484961986542, -0.009559636004269123, 0.015596317127346992, -0.019662613049149513, 0.040182191878557205, -0.006667131558060646, -0.018980473279953003, 0.02548169530928135, -0.05072144791483879, -0.007126769050955772, -0.014138084836304188, -0.023094747215509415, 0.009044685401022434, -0.013693227432668209, -0.033370502293109894, -0.005102335475385189, 0.055060822516679764, 0.03051387146115303, 0.018645351752638817, -0.019860761240124702, -0.01930244080722332, 0.012775403447449207, 0.020404383540153503, -0.06506386399269104, -0.039124809205532074, -0.022324953228235245, 0.02039240300655365, -0.00714750774204731, -0.023495033383369446 ]
<p>I have a background in computer programming and elementary number theory, but no real statistics training, and have recently "discovered" that the amazing world of a whole range of techniques is actually a statistical world. It seems that matrix factorizations, matrix completion, high dimensional tensors, embeddings, density estimation, Bayesian inference, Markov partitions, eigenvector computation, PageRank are all highly statistical techniques, and that the machine learning algorithms that use such things, use a lot of statistics. </p> <p>My goal is to be able to read papers that discuss such things, and implement or create the algorithms, while understanding the notation, "proofs" and statistical arguments used. I guess the hardest thing is to follow all the proofs that involve matrices. </p> <p>What basic papers can get me started? Or a good textbook with exercises that are worth working through ? </p> <p>Specifically, some papers I would like to understand completely are :</p> <ol> <li><a href="http://www-stat.stanford.edu/~candes/papers/MatrixCompletion.pdf" rel="nofollow">Exact Matrix Completion via Convex Optimization, Candes, Recht, 2008</a></li> <li><a href="http://arxiv.org/pdf/1207.4684.pdf" rel="nofollow">The Fast Cauchy Transform and Faster Robust Linear Regression, Clarkson et al, 2013</a></li> <li><a href="http://arxiv.org/pdf/1211.6085.pdf" rel="nofollow">Random Projections for Support Vector Machines, Paul et al, 2013</a></li> <li><a href="http://arxiv.org/pdf/1302.5125.pdf" rel="nofollow">High-Dimensional Probability Estimation with Deep Density Models, Rippel, Adams, 2013</a></li> <li><a href="http://arxiv.org/pdf/1302.5337.pdf" rel="nofollow">Obtaining Error-Minimizing Estimates and Universal Entry-Wise Error Bounds for Low-Rank Matrix Completion, Király, Theran, 2013</a></li> </ol>
45,474
[ -0.027605775743722916, -0.037265222519636154, 0.02033822238445282, -0.030080106109380722, 0.051401760429143906, 0.003341446164995432, -0.041751060634851456, -0.027306878939270973, 0.013441511429846287, -0.05979356914758682, 0.05298016592860222, 0.014907903969287872, 0.03928988426923752, 0.04197589308023453, -0.001071477890945971, 0.012025345116853714, -0.008619263768196106, 0.006375647149980068, -0.038640014827251434, 0.03303615748882294, 0.0009682991076260805, 0.025980819016695023, 0.0015612756833434105, 0.022835444658994675, -0.032573942095041275, 0.029360396787524223, -0.003498686011880636, -0.0074666813015937805, -0.01816454716026783, 0.030044015496969223, -0.05649485066533089, 0.007602999452501535, -0.004435139708220959, 0.030434969812631607, 0.009724968113005161, 0.020155683159828186, 0.0015342417173087597, 0.018953872844576836, 0.05016349256038666, 0.012030801735818386, -0.05959165096282959, -0.0013272261712700129, 0.015732532367110252, 0.015135892666876316, -0.025990957394242287, 0.04016920551657677, 0.01928994432091713, -0.03442860767245293, 0.014484813436865807, -0.0260807853192091, 0.08022145181894302, 0.029455281794071198, 0.02835327759385109, 0.04576142132282257, -0.005304598715156317, 0.012946583330631256, 0.011389105580747128, 0.05201651528477669, 0.013321462087333202, -0.051049478352069855, 0.01164239551872015, -0.009485074318945408, 0.004839289002120495, -0.06520048528909683, -0.031650979071855545, 0.0409327857196331, -0.00613369420170784, -0.003923078533262014, 0.04507505148649216, -0.016393419355154037, -0.013281350024044514, 0.006988044828176498, 0.017053896561264992, 0.003946833778172731, 0.024197112768888474, -0.01508000772446394, 0.004101756028831005, 0.024920184165239334, 0.03888130187988281, 0.015223318710923195, 0.03739891201257706, -0.007542009465396404, -0.01535790879279375, 0.01448812521994114, 0.011692674830555916, -0.0075915963388979435, 0.0758291557431221, -0.02345862053334713, -0.009528456255793571, 0.007972289808094501, -0.012079275213181973, -0.04160144180059433, 0.03237039968371391, 0.007067853584885597, -0.020960528403520584, 0.01904260367155075, 0.008213605731725693, 0.03742234781384468, -0.0017068256856873631, -0.02419060468673706, -0.043099623173475266, -0.017391227185726166, 0.0006339696701616049, 0.04589739814400673, -0.050129085779190063, -0.012783854268491268, -0.0016505693783983588, 0.0067670466378331184, -0.03255711868405342, -0.012360339052975178, -0.05546106770634651, 0.043914783746004105, 0.0017870041774585843, -0.0005335533060133457, -0.009425889700651169, -0.02353047952055931, 0.007925603538751602, -0.030061088502407074, 0.019959431141614914, 0.10097098350524902, 0.010057608596980572, -0.014094507321715355, 0.008143572136759758, -0.03984919562935829, -0.07252424955368042, -0.0013793015386909246, 0.05568838492035866, -0.020245712250471115, -0.0316893644630909, 0.062190596014261246, -0.02321949414908886, -0.02470044605433941, 0.030385440215468407, 0.017885422334074974, 0.033414896577596664, 0.012416096404194832, -0.07736146450042725, -0.04140932485461235, 0.04210741072893143, -0.021702632308006287, -0.013077785260975361, -0.0010998339857906103, 0.012988747097551823, -0.004536360036581755, 0.029015718027949333, 0.007747265510261059, 0.07689149677753448, 0.0030367362778633833, 0.028180450201034546, 0.008880912326276302, -0.018546219915151596, -0.015063006430864334, -0.00484096584841609, 0.01968136802315712, -0.023565001785755157, -0.0448056235909462, 0.06282241642475128, -0.0005891204345971346, 0.021449871361255646, 0.023528240621089935, 0.010361460968852043, 0.04461062327027321, -0.039062295109033585, -0.006021605804562569, -0.02278432436287403, -0.014956784434616566, 0.046779610216617584, 0.014278268441557884, 0.05321895331144333, 0.02941504865884781, -0.05732293426990509, 0.01745154708623886, 0.011155116371810436, 0.02604438178241253, 0.05933191627264023, -0.0036136540584266186, -0.003864648286253214, -0.0024655915331095457, -0.02714054472744465, -0.00611582025885582, -0.0311833918094635, -0.04609870910644531, 0.012664776295423508, -0.0048588961362838745, -0.0166073776781559, 0.014699449762701988, 0.025063887238502502, -0.009778372012078762, 0.02130013145506382, -0.0071935695596039295, -0.01940166763961315, -0.036111198365688324, 0.013032861985266209, -0.04707661271095276, -0.02207735925912857, 0.04981449618935585, -0.0015603499487042427, 0.0004814004059880972, 0.010403129272162914, -0.020597171038389206, -0.013768654316663742, 0.00033879795228131115, 0.03287449851632118, -0.020831165835261345, 0.005460183136165142, 0.04411042481660843, 0.04046575352549553, -0.02881382219493389, 0.030895261093974113, -0.04650638997554779, -0.06430092453956604, -0.02493233047425747, -0.005903496406972408, -0.004139079246670008, 0.008387172594666481, -0.02226046472787857, 0.021794911473989487, 0.0015889343339949846, -0.04447311908006668, 0.0058685350231826305, -0.022678568959236145, 0.035814009606838226, 0.028824113309383392, 0.01856916770339012, -0.0017304470529779792, 0.033160250633955, 0.0187078770250082, 0.01761004328727722, -0.0005978214321658015, 0.014906461350619793, -0.04146372154355049, 0.001163218286819756, 0.044744160026311874, 0.04199720546603203, -0.02229354903101921, -0.0072454726323485374, 0.04758003354072571, 0.04220082238316536, 0.009406927041709423, 0.029583953320980072, -0.044925253838300705, -0.04704587161540985, 0.016337092965841293, -0.020015116780996323, -0.031168537214398384, 0.0064019071869552135, -0.01091644074767828, -0.023407509550452232, 0.058713436126708984, 0.021337639540433884, -0.03192048519849777, 0.014178424142301083, -0.004516784101724625, -0.024754200130701065, -0.013272271491587162, -0.011445125564932823, 0.03580567613244057, 0.012410200200974941, -0.008963151834905148, 0.01691840961575508, 0.0016357137355953455, 0.008074641227722168, 0.0035820347256958485, -0.031044932082295418, -0.015465891920030117, 0.01137692853808403, -0.022385746240615845, 0.016911976039409637, 0.03230738639831543, -0.04004526510834694, 0.03240340203046799, 0.0037098589818924665, -0.0196301881223917, -0.03352130949497223, 0.012686106376349926, 0.002835820661857724, -0.017581332474946976, 0.027010174468159676, -0.018928205594420433, -0.012077100574970245, 0.029474319890141487, -0.028547540307044983, 0.04345843568444252, 0.01056749653071165, -0.06246538832783699, 0.006468640640377998, -0.07871656119823456, -0.014981767162680626, 0.04159906506538391, 0.006966264918446541, -0.0019218242960050702, -0.014772380702197552, -0.01820972003042698, -0.08311066776514053, -0.021975848823785782, -0.007188424933701754, 0.016995929181575775, -0.04192880913615227, 0.013390809297561646, 0.029805351048707962, -0.016424251720309258, -0.06459543108940125, 0.0425984151661396, -0.0025279265828430653, -0.02893773652613163, -0.03697168827056885, -0.027035193517804146, 0.0018253173911944032, -0.028601201251149178, 0.0022991718724370003, 0.03883638605475426, 0.001813874812796712, 0.011501562781631947, -0.08151000738143921, -0.033529628068208694, 0.004531660582870245, 0.032772988080978394, 0.03209282085299492, 0.02565114200115204, 0.010199177078902721, 0.07301530241966248, 0.03140532970428467, -0.04684387892484665, -0.017334071919322014, 0.02002710849046707, -0.00434476463124156, -0.024467546492815018, 0.04149699583649635, 0.004184722434729338, -0.007255011238157749, -0.0033421299885958433, -0.0015833922661840916, 0.004189933650195599, 0.04764971509575844, 0.010941441170871258, 0.03206542879343033, 0.015590998344123363, -0.015628544613718987, -0.006312920246273279, 0.04692523926496506, 0.0024060672149062157, -0.022082654759287834, 0.009890645742416382, 0.004762156866490841, 0.00991789810359478, 0.03545099496841431, -0.06831630319356918, 0.02209141105413437, -0.016250979155302048, -0.013788272626698017, -0.0509883351624012, 0.036838170140981674, 0.01698577217757702, -0.057385995984077454, 0.02880396693944931, -0.0038601458072662354, 0.007963327690958977, -0.0035712113603949547, -0.0008508115424774587, 0.048593487590551376, 0.05753945931792259, -0.018147552385926247, 0.02754373848438263, -0.04167991504073143, -0.02362469956278801, 0.02776300720870495, -0.030911196023225784, 0.004351865034550428, 0.04905596747994423, 0.041870761662721634, -0.0234347116202116, 0.0011844489490613341, -0.014568080194294453, 0.011107739061117172, -0.07498308271169662, 0.03490448743104935, -0.04009738564491272, 0.05411379784345627, -0.01382407732307911, 0.04530865699052811, -0.012186297215521336, -0.010111218318343163, 0.01692470721900463, 0.013303148560225964, -0.07632467895746231, -0.0018350793980062008, 0.015905315056443214, -0.0006511518731713295, 0.003208841197192669, -0.025168880820274353, 0.044912487268447876, -0.006657793652266264, -0.014081734232604504, -0.058095239102840424, 0.05560070276260376, -0.038151662796735764, 0.029202602803707123, -0.012457985430955887, -0.04756670817732811, 0.009584476239979267, -0.016179976984858513, 0.03980318829417229, -0.012947367504239082, 0.035286735743284225, 0.02347220480442047, -0.012442605569958687, -0.03154749423265457, 0.022645480930805206, 0.05579542741179466, 0.04501050338149071, 0.025273989886045456, 0.0033460180275142193, 0.06697732955217361, -0.026782725006341934, 0.031805090606212616, -0.009806566871702671, 0.05351177975535393, 0.023619363084435463, -0.01607641391456127, 0.02175651118159294, -0.051164060831069946, -0.023205701261758804, 0.027344755828380585, 0.03202946484088898, -0.018392663449048996, -0.025287138298153877, 0.03412298858165741, 0.011842633597552776, -0.044246893376111984, 0.002632466610521078, 0.0343133807182312, -0.0004156248760409653, 0.024637019261717796, -0.047759126871824265, -0.03110104613006115, -0.0005758490297012031, 0.003144304733723402, 0.04321780800819397, 0.0017968835309147835, 0.005366698373109102, -0.016365837305784225, 0.010550820268690586, 0.0017016440397128463, -0.043616052716970444, -0.017821267247200012, 0.038089316338300705, 0.026525020599365234, -0.05304013565182686, -0.03648748993873596, 0.018338868394494057, 0.06739433854818344, 0.04876738041639328, 0.015811583027243614, 0.03339998424053192, -0.08421996235847473, -0.004291090182960033, 0.0566580630838871, 0.05165619030594826, -0.017423534765839577, 0.0270027257502079, -0.04445771127939224, -0.056840930134058, 0.03667518496513367, 0.02849517948925495, 0.0236420426517725, -0.008736923336982727, -0.029370587319135666, -0.007438047789037228, -0.014926793053746223, -0.03726283088326454, -0.03162158653140068, -0.012203339487314224, 0.032344941049814224, -0.01893315650522709, -0.023617031052708626, -0.04539575055241585, 0.013998130336403847, 0.017767511308193207, 0.012170156463980675, -0.012108873575925827, 0.03039463423192501, 0.026405880227684975, 0.0016799599397927523, -0.01145685650408268, -0.07510153204202652, 0.008233478292822838, 0.019253047183156013, -0.028728608042001724, 0.030208777636289597, -0.0031913218554109335, -0.059959761798381805, 0.018552705645561218, -0.020341506227850914, -0.07180668413639069, 0.028903257101774216, -0.008189430460333824, 0.02645806036889553, 0.03186163306236267, 0.013136564753949642, 0.06025175750255585, 0.0031606797128915787, -0.0033613224513828754, 0.018582280725240707, -0.04543580859899521, 0.03631613776087761, -0.0030846241861581802, 0.01136847771704197, -0.059781983494758606, -0.03764009103178978, -0.0052662985399365425, 0.016432927921414375, -0.003891976550221443, 0.018174350261688232, -0.008885221555829048, -0.0012639625929296017, -0.008316156454384327, 0.03000720590353012, -0.013373824767768383, -0.01243449654430151, 0.012442553415894508, 0.013661563396453857, -0.012907611206173897, 0.007598335854709148, 0.020876707509160042, 0.011320884339511395, 0.006899436004459858, 0.012381590902805328, -0.008780192583799362, -0.0008353037410415709, -0.06706313043832779, -0.02479536458849907, 0.029327886179089546, -0.02645922265946865, 0.07850955426692963, -0.004773311782628298, 0.07051079720258713, 0.011918731033802032, -0.007066968362778425, -0.04642515257000923, 0.0050268033519387245, -0.010393948294222355, 0.0017289422685280442, -0.030966777354478836, -0.0025553733576089144, -0.02306462451815605, -0.036196012049913406, -0.021359916776418686, -0.038472793996334076, 0.004165894817560911, 0.000982771860435605, -0.08530285209417343, -0.05587004870176315, 0.024222999811172485, 0.008226333186030388, -0.03199761360883713, -0.017351893708109856, 0.004679464269429445, -0.04091047868132591, -0.016842473298311234, 0.0002005009155254811, 0.0135416891425848, 0.0682915672659874, -0.002175332745537162, -0.006655928213149309, 0.009661480784416199, 0.02830159105360508, 0.000374025636119768, -0.022671110928058624, 0.017551876604557037, -0.032379865646362305, -0.0074766031466424465, -0.0631045550107956, -0.0010785593185573816, 0.03128419071435928, -0.03828456997871399, 0.005416828207671642, 0.05359060689806938, 0.02695435844361782, 0.016866974532604218, -0.05349430814385414, -0.009888779371976852, 0.003933276515454054, -0.008567986078560352, 0.0015102291945368052, -0.0011481118854135275, 0.024209173396229744, -0.0026284283958375454, 0.03677472472190857, -0.028489090502262115, 0.005188147071748972, 0.010508587583899498, 0.04035715386271477, -0.008509493432939053, 0.033155739307403564, 0.035528864711523056, -0.0038941644597798586, 0.012676590122282505, -0.019097013399004936, 0.013983560726046562, 0.029592469334602356, -0.0186445415019989, -0.04467833414673805, -0.04587600380182266, -0.06886504590511322, -0.0066426717676222324, 0.031087208539247513, 0.03679193928837776, 0.03228950500488281, 0.06438587605953217, -0.0410117506980896, 0.0024113974068313837, -0.03753608837723732, -0.024221953004598618, -0.0277257040143013, 0.032954271882772446, 0.03001834824681282, -0.0014403949026018381, -0.0034352364018559456, 0.050905924290418625, 0.024364955723285675, -0.01989489234983921, 0.032093215733766556, 0.011112656444311142, 0.014983151108026505, 0.05769452825188637, -0.04729315638542175, -0.028040854260325432, 0.044606804847717285, -0.048242516815662384, 0.0470922477543354, -0.024056846275925636, -0.006810138002038002, 0.04572916030883789, 0.0226080771535635, 0.023822452872991562, -0.016733985394239426, -0.028599627315998077, -0.05955694243311882, 0.04706161469221115, 0.010717371478676796, -0.016495145857334137, 0.013407631777226925, -0.020720073953270912, 0.05738704279065132, -0.029401302337646484, 0.04079088568687439, -0.024370089173316956, -0.05339956283569336, -0.01798142120242119, -0.03666219115257263, -0.025353802368044853, 0.020809853449463844, 0.018793361261487007, -0.050580043345689774, 0.018587155267596245, -0.011231157928705215, 0.07443579286336899, 0.03871598467230797, 0.038907989859580994, -0.04186872020363808, 0.01840394176542759, 0.00646044360473752, -0.01637122593820095, -0.01442965492606163, -0.05820188671350479, 0.13270828127861023, 0.04808284714818001, 0.06452196836471558, -0.06043235585093498, 0.011607668362557888, 0.010497239418327808, 0.026618726551532745, -0.03537523373961449, -0.0248540211468935, -0.040370162576436996, -0.010711103677749634, 0.013747257180511951, 0.024645531550049782, -0.006832770071923733, -0.026672832667827606, 0.038102563470602036, -0.045494649559259415, -0.004366060718894005, -0.03667208179831505, -0.012752027250826359, 0.013657289557158947, 0.01840127445757389, -0.06476549059152603, -0.0009175109444186091, -0.005302580539137125, -0.05143876373767853, -0.06553857028484344, -0.04089262709021568, 0.0011947894236072898, -0.008757476694881916, 0.01226111501455307, 0.01110142283141613, 0.03459855169057846, 0.01392434537410736, 0.015029890462756157, 0.010447205044329166, 0.020395848900079727, -0.023504573851823807, 0.00566172506660223, 0.01193978451192379, 0.024573983624577522, 0.007299192249774933, 0.008262624964118004, -0.021565258502960205, -0.04339945316314697, -0.024299681186676025, -0.028355496004223824, 0.06415563076734543, -0.026645362377166748, 0.017363090068101883, -0.0187176913022995, -0.015564118511974812, 0.0026374489534646273, -0.02252599038183689, 0.009277445264160633, 0.036577027291059494, 0.058460865169763565, -0.0009041698649525642, 0.013785707764327526, -0.024953411892056465, 0.0019317452097311616, -0.010915576480329037, 0.0329928882420063, 0.006799258757382631, -0.017345912754535675, -0.044932324439287186, -0.060384612530469894, 0.04328642413020134, -0.028654249384999275, 0.009130556136369705, -0.04127056524157524, 0.017991578206419945, -0.00497322715818882, -0.04658062383532524, 0.002939680591225624, -0.025348342955112457, 0.020450109615921974, 0.018745245411992073, -0.02344120666384697, 0.004284692462533712, -0.04864024743437767, 0.019656894728541374, -0.018417300656437874, -0.009915442205965519, -0.011801841668784618, 0.0035823516082018614, 0.013916821219027042, 0.026574023067951202, 0.04450492933392525, -0.007084882818162441, 0.01724368892610073, 0.014409308321774006, 0.028728431090712547, -0.007306149695068598, -0.015825802460312843, -0.021673956885933876, -0.0021878057159483433, -0.005073779262602329, 0.01304917223751545, 0.020542610436677933, 0.05235693231225014, 0.015792241320014, -0.005599826108664274, 0.009135698899626732, -0.004420122597366571, -0.03768356144428253, -0.015005862340331078, -0.05908923223614693, 0.006839437410235405, 0.009538018144667149, 0.03363053500652313, -0.05735984817147255, -0.01784985326230526, 0.0018396583618596196, -0.003063775133341551, -0.007568365428596735, -0.020211149007081985, -0.0149606354534626, 0.0014356737956404686, 0.020363887771964073, 0.04789883270859718, -0.021363023668527603, -0.025237727910280228, -0.024375850334763527, 0.011459351517260075, -0.013393942266702652, -0.006329187657684088, -0.012352592311799526, 0.012580103240907192, 0.0008120062411762774, -0.005050263367593288, 0.03536287322640419, -0.020692963153123856, 0.0011242529144510627, 0.0019178808433935046, 0.020955713465809822, -0.031718652695417404, 0.04498952627182007, -0.030514350160956383, -0.013369464315474033, 0.049644649028778076, -0.044293757528066635, -0.046961039304733276, 0.019353250041604042, -0.008859500288963318, 0.005282287485897541, 0.02136382833123207, -0.006640154402703047, -0.03626608848571777, 0.0007300707511603832, -0.009951261803507805, 0.001740701962262392, -0.03931812569499016, -0.0012180947232991457, 0.0027270817663520575, 0.029583508148789406, 0.03898198530077934, -0.01749783381819725, -0.008995525538921356, -0.003520507598295808, 0.03366677090525627, 0.0028345356695353985, 0.012211175635457039, 0.05153535678982735, -0.03200041502714157, 0.02486674301326275, -0.028542697429656982, -0.001119836582802236, 0.02911190129816532, 0.03931141644716263, -0.010325937531888485, 0.06629294157028198, 0.02583492547273636, 0.01677354797720909, -0.11730027943849564, 0.006417153403162956, 0.02169204317033291, 0.01728993095457554, 0.07566548883914948, -0.08085301518440247, 0.0046366192400455475, 0.03238070756196976, -0.05664961412549019, 0.04936628043651581, 0.016859252005815506, -0.03175278380513191, -0.00868759024888277, 0.005547021050006151, -0.013301694765686989, 0.020222045481204987, 0.022827649489045143, 0.03688871115446091, 0.03656388074159622, 0.028075294569134712, -0.003042171709239483, -0.037558577954769135, -0.012681752443313599, 0.03156604245305061, 0.01549826841801405, -0.03429451584815979, 0.0327543243765831, -0.024953849613666534, -0.005883428268134594, 0.03925079107284546, 0.023945722728967667, 0.007201333995908499, 0.015791097655892372, 0.02852572500705719, -0.015503725036978722, 0.03474598750472069, 0.02727881446480751, -0.006372869946062565, 0.033609870821237564, -0.031800344586372375, 0.010017345659434795, 0.03714541718363762, 0.004082914907485247, 0.04041865095496178, 0.03496167063713074, -0.047990988940000534, -0.027776775881648064, 0.05258239433169365, -0.010596264153718948, 0.01289291400462389, 0.03713236376643181, 0.002265667775645852, 0.0007992726168595254, -0.006435796152800322, 0.044967833906412125, -0.024152429774403572, -0.0038300766609609127, 0.016185641288757324, 0.0252755768597126, -0.05130624398589134, 0.037305958569049835, -0.015818176791071892, -0.025932347401976585, 0.04325980320572853, -0.02694457769393921, -0.003786967135965824, -0.07089776545763016, -0.015236924402415752, 0.041733190417289734, 0.003947020508348942, -0.030934251844882965, -0.031037015840411186, -0.04366817697882652, 0.03567858412861824, 0.0020461264066398144, 0.02894875779747963, -0.02174351178109646, -0.008496838621795177, 0.015921110287308693, -0.10149993747472763, 0.05768299847841263, 0.02422182448208332, -0.011290558613836765, -0.007918622344732285, 0.04939064756035805, 0.017064277082681656, -0.010396473109722137, 0.031960051506757736, 0.015175728127360344, 0.04550584405660629, -0.011003473773598671, -0.021447667852044106, 0.05032818019390106, -0.046918757259845734, 0.0390908308327198, -0.024185722693800926, -0.007401765789836645, -0.01423996314406395, 0.0026338365860283375, 0.01388588361442089, 0.010921917855739594, 0.05237656086683273, 0.0010508450213819742, 0.009616960771381855, 0.012075760401785374, -0.04747387766838074, 0.05952126532793045, 0.034439049661159515, 0.005163618363440037, 0.00391811691224575, -0.03268025442957878, 0.009950901381671429, 0.019008178263902664, -0.04003928229212761, -0.03070218302309513, 0.012368375435471535, -0.032033082097768784, -0.06427577137947083, -0.021153276786208153, -0.020410586148500443, 0.014426197856664658, -0.03401576355099678, -0.009000810794532299, 0.049280233681201935, 0.0012846986064687371, 0.002861585235223174, 0.04972393438220024, 0.015095841139554977, 0.05022343620657921, -0.014592842198908329, 0.030976012349128723, 0.016221890226006508, -0.052762117236852646, -0.024627292528748512, -0.0094705605879426, 0.026421839371323586, -0.009197448380291462, 0.023623056709766388, 0.01847737841308117, -0.017153428867459297, 0.013747136108577251, -0.004795393906533718, 0.03461100906133652, -0.04024435579776764, -0.008602142333984375, -0.01592516526579857, -0.014499550685286522, -0.030209142714738846, -0.0036542643792927265, -0.002448600484058261, 0.07726239413022995, -0.033473335206508636, -0.024728858843445778, -0.013596936129033566, 0.0003694542683660984, -0.02689496986567974, -0.017801087349653244, -0.037109483033418655, 0.0304447989910841, 0.008228020742535591, 0.011334173381328583, -0.014086117967963219, 0.021770603954792023, 0.03463714197278023, -0.02081109769642353, 0.0704713836312294, 0.03441191837191582, -0.026784580200910568, 0.02844035066664219, -0.039286527782678604, -0.024219609797000885, -0.02484654076397419, 0.024254774674773216, 0.04998435825109482, -0.020971372723579407, -0.029068365693092346, -0.004032049793750048, -0.026498429477214813, 0.03551876172423363, -0.04663063585758209, 0.011874660849571228, -0.05763369798660278, -0.001667842618189752, -0.010967058129608631, -0.010542678646743298 ]
<p>Given two multivariate gaussian (say in 2D with mean $\mu$ as a 2D point and convariance marix $\Sigma$ as $2$x$2$ Matrix) $N_1(\mu_1,\Sigma_1)$ and $N_2(\mu_2,\Sigma_1)$, I would like to derive the pdf of $N_1+N_2$. </p> <p>Can any one point me to the reference where i can find the pdf derivation of $N_1 + N_2$.</p> <p>Thanks in advance</p>
74,282
[ -0.010834986343979836, -0.009567114524543285, 0.010818254202604294, -0.01644943468272686, 0.034288227558135986, 0.031570568680763245, -0.014376224018633366, -0.045364901423454285, 0.01327014621347189, -0.07800494134426117, 0.03328125923871994, 0.05760413780808449, 0.09415169805288315, 0.01013319380581379, 0.009803930297493935, 0.00353009975515306, -0.009788202121853828, 0.012304096482694149, 0.004880171734839678, -0.025454921647906303, 0.008220018818974495, 0.02621304802596569, 0.022365080192685127, -0.02014964446425438, -0.01761421374976635, 0.0717228502035141, 0.03234759718179703, -0.022268498316407204, 0.00941108725965023, 0.08841530978679657, -0.034139618277549744, -0.04887878894805908, 0.046797990798950195, 0.06526773422956467, -0.020862873643636703, -0.012111776508390903, -0.032648079097270966, -0.01879642903804779, 0.009123241528868675, 0.013409140519797802, -0.06567665934562683, -0.03293510526418686, 0.012921690009534359, 0.04061189293861389, -0.03634170815348625, 0.007827331312000751, 0.013937996700406075, -0.023924438282847404, 0.02623962052166462, -0.05518423393368721, 0.10051552951335907, -0.00008257610170403495, 0.05900276452302933, 0.0213368721306324, -0.027634747326374054, 0.037392713129520416, 0.035921525210142136, 0.0859718844294548, 0.03226026892662048, -0.05326114594936371, -0.011410296894609928, -0.04955803602933884, 0.008670786395668983, -0.03465037792921066, -0.040375761687755585, 0.003333264496177435, -0.019407974556088448, -0.046143218874931335, 0.006556628737598658, -0.01729065366089344, 0.011716064065694809, 0.036822061985731125, 0.06302091479301453, -0.04802262410521507, -0.008814861066639423, -0.0061621651984751225, 0.01752779446542263, 0.015268114395439625, 0.03870471194386482, -0.010076587088406086, 0.0320521704852581, 0.03191809356212616, 0.024796262383461, 0.010972648859024048, 0.006988308858126402, 0.0006014776881784201, 0.08311320841312408, -0.008480535820126534, 0.020610805600881577, 0.006638876628130674, -0.0058982050977647305, 0.007039001677185297, 0.02746880054473877, 0.018491366878151894, -0.03778338059782982, 0.05502965301275253, 0.014460957609117031, 0.04393434524536133, -0.02588675729930401, -0.011601117439568043, -0.023910289630293846, -0.042418450117111206, 0.0324830636382103, 0.05054476857185364, -0.013947841711342335, 0.010238222777843475, -0.012765059247612953, 0.014562798663973808, -0.04621163383126259, -0.00804857350885868, -0.03283071517944336, 0.02175888419151306, 0.00535995839163661, -0.036753322929143906, 0.010803082026541233, -0.03502009063959122, -0.009494069032371044, -0.00569872697815299, 0.050146736204624176, 0.08245518803596497, 0.04628608748316765, -0.020883535966277122, 0.0016874249558895826, -0.017538635060191154, -0.064189612865448, 0.03716808557510376, 0.010190296918153763, -0.010490501299500465, -0.04830874130129814, 0.06365068256855011, -0.016535097733139992, -0.03264210745692253, 0.010269264690577984, 0.0197792686522007, -0.003430004231631756, -0.002195801353082061, -0.06096353381872177, -0.041930731385946274, 0.03332715108990669, -0.03517932444810867, 0.02248389460146427, -0.06939700990915298, 0.015552518889307976, 0.06086484342813492, 0.07629472017288208, -0.0028471483383327723, 0.05137495696544647, -0.010566651821136475, 0.040688879787921906, 0.006537454202771187, -0.001097820233553648, -0.047351423650979996, -0.03095717914402485, -0.02764388918876648, -0.018492205068469048, -0.0688382238149643, 0.01808784157037735, 0.022187253460288048, -0.01985437050461769, -0.017975954338908195, 0.03783663734793663, 0.030486280098557472, 0.008345779031515121, -0.023620817810297012, 0.035253699868917465, -0.025150634348392487, 0.06600325554609299, 0.030900783836841583, 0.004192927852272987, 0.014104424975812435, -0.03966797888278961, 0.03154188022017479, 0.000028807000489905477, 0.06201831251382828, 0.051662858575582504, -0.010577987879514694, -0.02317519299685955, 0.032742273062467575, 0.012644439935684204, 0.015500915236771107, -0.0190146341919899, -0.022814057767391205, -0.019324488937854767, -0.021129455417394638, 0.008366391062736511, 0.01950671896338463, 0.014304839074611664, -0.010521555319428444, -0.0027043670415878296, -0.03909553587436676, -0.0015150387771427631, -0.06854234635829926, 0.009542238898575306, 0.007935701869428158, -0.051943808794021606, 0.025632817298173904, -0.001100103254429996, 0.03826010972261429, 0.012781145051121712, -0.07350047677755356, -0.026728317141532898, -0.028435636311769485, 0.021920017898082733, -0.03779327869415283, -0.022238714620471, 0.038090988993644714, 0.06393226981163025, 0.02005661278963089, 0.05165112018585205, -0.02715705707669258, -0.030982298776507378, 0.007439912296831608, -0.016538333147764206, -0.000306467292830348, -0.0066482606343925, -0.02124479040503502, 0.0016630985774099827, 0.01599360816180706, -0.022617680951952934, -0.0028968218248337507, -0.05278468504548073, 0.03508242964744568, 0.07387491315603256, 0.022606685757637024, -0.02404884621500969, 0.018399879336357117, 0.02240411564707756, -0.01672995463013649, -0.00856623612344265, -0.05499562993645668, -0.018323760479688644, 0.004262368660420179, 0.024390757083892822, 0.04328417405486107, -0.040125735104084015, -0.009310142137110233, 0.023093128576874733, 0.033367689698934555, 0.007504082750529051, 0.04946546256542206, 0.006580546032637358, -0.03000733256340027, -0.015245158225297928, 0.005904397461563349, -0.01623489521443844, 0.002054760931059718, 0.027409346774220467, 0.006837842054665089, 0.03626783564686775, 0.03414835035800934, -0.06518308818340302, 0.057306014001369476, -0.007842931896448135, -0.007007649168372154, -0.024278294295072556, -0.005735559854656458, 0.02449166774749756, -0.007198365870863199, 0.02479991689324379, 0.042964328080415726, -0.006824383046478033, -0.01774192601442337, 0.0023343500215560198, -0.005395297426730394, 0.010182623751461506, 0.0029022202361375093, -0.028966791927814484, 0.0033637559972703457, 0.007521665655076504, -0.029291201382875443, 0.022751810029149055, 0.004940606653690338, -0.014335979707539082, -0.0018543304177001119, -0.012219361029565334, -0.01633899286389351, -0.007154770195484161, 0.005050670821219683, 0.0035224976018071175, -0.07234206050634384, -0.006170621141791344, -0.02346360683441162, 0.0033728263806551695, 0.009268835186958313, -0.05406204238533974, 0.029595298692584038, -0.04732781648635864, 0.014071516692638397, 0.02872621826827526, -0.012182502076029778, 0.006941023748368025, 0.014915981329977512, -0.006644335109740496, -0.06235160678625107, -0.0004922806983813643, 0.008424370549619198, 0.02869783341884613, -0.027444632723927498, -0.0014390262076631188, 0.006701731123030186, 0.002281517954543233, -0.0414680540561676, 0.02372855693101883, -0.011569672264158726, -0.042497988790273666, -0.016636520624160767, -0.003688032506033778, 0.02536996267735958, -0.01567864418029785, 0.03252946585416794, 0.048939965665340424, -0.02762601338326931, -0.026088770478963852, -0.060406818985939026, -0.054857976734638214, 0.01858353614807129, -0.004009768832474947, 0.030786313116550446, -0.013754099607467651, -0.04882790148258209, 0.043580103665590286, 0.02391284704208374, -0.02005872130393982, -0.006309091113507748, 0.004119367338716984, -0.0009311161702498794, -0.03067229501903057, 0.041422709822654724, -0.0019192268373444676, -0.007296891417354345, 0.055315371602773666, 0.005831296555697918, -0.041381508111953735, 0.08855821192264557, -0.027358582243323326, -0.01506115309894085, -0.005323848687112331, -0.02234337292611599, 0.00686189578846097, 0.020172031596302986, 0.0005816181073896587, -0.03286094218492508, 0.010548892430961132, 0.034056536853313446, 0.026805289089679718, 0.0018562626792117953, -0.01995285414159298, 0.018918393179774284, -0.01580209657549858, 0.0017825799295678735, -0.05468850955367088, 0.038519542664289474, 0.027241507545113564, -0.029566697776317596, -0.004222264513373375, 0.0457066185772419, 0.01643514819443226, -0.03755462169647217, 0.03194308653473854, 0.03756100684404373, -0.0018486336339265108, -0.005972476676106453, -0.010081364773213863, -0.027092240750789642, 0.02324659936130047, 0.02356678992509842, -0.028983470052480698, -0.040335141122341156, 0.03078361228108406, 0.019834306091070175, -0.003956613130867481, -0.011203547939658165, -0.020872965455055237, 0.01700209267437458, -0.07488332688808441, 0.020140377804636955, -0.0019910915289074183, 0.027378056198358536, 0.005583643447607756, 0.06314340233802795, -0.012991057708859444, 0.004107605665922165, 0.036132749170064926, -0.03379015997052193, -0.05778327211737633, -0.010258592665195465, -0.007653370033949614, -0.03204686567187309, 0.022041989490389824, -0.0342588871717453, 0.028181442990899086, 0.003793376497924328, -0.0022247484885156155, -0.016949143260717392, 0.006222081836313009, -0.05212431028485298, 0.010759805329144001, -0.06175975874066353, -0.03237171471118927, 0.0029987930320203304, 0.019863536581397057, 0.03340410441160202, -0.01640348695218563, 0.014195344410836697, 0.010166894644498825, -0.007345819380134344, -0.02602062001824379, 0.0030140685848891735, 0.011591380462050438, 0.004426100291311741, 0.013377253897488117, 0.014416624791920185, 0.03872424364089966, 0.0015506939962506294, 0.05881083011627197, -0.010890807025134563, 0.08071275055408478, 0.024831464514136314, 0.007652229629456997, 0.007769283372908831, -0.03211832046508789, -0.019449034705758095, -0.031034523621201515, 0.0489448606967926, -0.01571262814104557, 0.0007975490880198777, 0.040861520916223526, 0.02692553959786892, -0.029647335410118103, 0.024133674800395966, 0.06012296304106712, 0.03188721835613251, 0.001757224672473967, -0.017161354422569275, 0.01720729097723961, -0.010113977827131748, -0.02104686200618744, 0.029116762802004814, -0.0006139938486739993, -0.05466488376259804, -0.02840721420943737, 0.02874370664358139, 0.005456558428704739, 0.006751901004463434, -0.02138459123671055, 0.026460526511073112, 0.0322115495800972, 0.0032048760913312435, -0.04008321836590767, -0.012877936474978924, 0.05926137790083885, 0.034821104258298874, 0.040846578776836395, -0.006014020182192326, -0.06515879929065704, 0.005131141282618046, 0.038113079965114594, 0.01588716357946396, -0.01755949668586254, 0.0013773468090221286, -0.024743590503931046, 0.0016735094832256436, 0.04126805067062378, -0.003570189233869314, 0.018163640052080154, 0.01273504737764597, 0.016443908214569092, 0.008789247833192348, 0.012912480160593987, -0.04568086564540863, 0.032300036400556564, 0.0030360377859324217, 0.024682307615876198, -0.010345791466534138, -0.010842685587704182, -0.03356851264834404, 0.012317783199250698, 0.03522181510925293, 0.07338577508926392, 0.012604537419974804, -0.025848515331745148, -0.005749050062149763, 0.07735799998044968, 0.009325741790235043, -0.04868200793862343, 0.033044010400772095, 0.014392387121915817, -0.04294972866773605, 0.047052785754203796, -0.04883028194308281, 0.018892865628004074, 0.001445285277441144, 0.008561772294342518, 0.0014451544266194105, 0.023293593898415565, 0.01706409454345703, 0.04230537265539169, 0.046005573123693466, 0.01658121682703495, 0.06687214970588684, 0.009298734366893768, 0.02059173583984375, -0.010921445675194263, -0.04721119999885559, 0.03520815819501877, -0.021747030317783356, -0.0329645499587059, -0.05222758278250694, -0.004345690831542015, -0.01954076997935772, 0.012761883437633514, -0.022738207131624222, 0.05774058774113655, -0.020291643217206, -0.032521020621061325, -0.007879524491727352, 0.05291682481765747, -0.003896519774571061, 0.02036381885409355, -0.0015199430054053664, 0.02009248360991478, 0.014164909720420837, -0.022387869656085968, 0.015545903705060482, -0.031023021787405014, -0.005834429059177637, -0.02629600651562214, -0.0280687864869833, 0.00063470343593508, -0.030066009610891342, -0.011697674170136452, -0.004501817747950554, -0.04469149932265282, 0.04049035906791687, -0.018448609858751297, 0.04288234934210777, 0.036019664257764816, -0.052300356328487396, -0.014922112226486206, 0.04252023249864578, -0.004829613957554102, 0.02061883918941021, -0.039043817669153214, 0.03462648019194603, -0.015635930001735687, 0.01693802699446678, -0.06228235736489296, -0.050524212419986725, 0.017474139109253883, -0.03002065047621727, -0.011944621801376343, -0.06609031558036804, -0.0016301491996273398, -0.05561370775103569, -0.01389163825660944, -0.0031527141109108925, 0.03771728277206421, -0.008062358014285564, -0.03577689081430435, 0.026192814111709595, 0.012712274678051472, 0.05212562531232834, -0.023860275745391846, 0.016961408779025078, 0.025733981281518936, -0.011053177528083324, -0.01682397723197937, 0.00007669005572097376, 0.04179012402892113, -0.018424322828650475, -0.00005491873889695853, -0.024308420717716217, -0.004486881662160158, 0.0355963408946991, -0.04129134491086006, -0.0011597794946283102, 0.011221960186958313, 0.029292825609445572, 0.011782716028392315, -0.034952376037836075, -0.028885694220662117, -0.013357974588871002, -0.004269566386938095, -0.036186520010232925, 0.0021254131570458412, -0.002424644771963358, 0.0028718977700918913, 0.027487125247716904, 0.04274445399641991, -0.008394154720008373, -0.0016713261138647795, 0.07374368607997894, 0.011964446865022182, -0.007852028124034405, 0.02669714018702507, 0.01988774724304676, 0.0290520042181015, 0.010238703340291977, -0.014061943627893925, 0.04981331527233124, 0.02124524861574173, -0.04811519384384155, -0.022946180775761604, -0.0313282310962677, 0.01333444844931364, 0.07102154195308685, -0.051465004682540894, 0.05134386941790581, 0.030110783874988556, -0.003899423871189356, -0.023038635030388832, -0.003815741976723075, -0.00846317782998085, 0.01285519264638424, -0.01649213209748268, 0.04080761969089508, -0.013572811149060726, -0.002502479823306203, 0.023411616683006287, 0.015277083963155746, -0.02079956978559494, 0.029435893520712852, -0.023862654343247414, 0.023034486919641495, 0.04810507595539093, 0.0074056098237633705, -0.01407366432249546, 0.055319901555776596, -0.043329693377017975, -0.0009433632949367166, -0.03318984434008598, -0.038005780428647995, 0.03231009468436241, 0.02569758892059326, -0.027407338842749596, -0.024903101846575737, -0.027072221040725708, -0.01796705648303032, 0.0061162435449659824, 0.021851321682333946, -0.00919346883893013, 0.03128737211227417, 0.017667479813098907, 0.035670503973960876, -0.006211105268448591, 0.011724616400897503, -0.05054110661149025, -0.07016170769929886, -0.0028990774881094694, -0.05247530713677406, -0.02931184507906437, 0.018657559528946877, 0.016932429745793343, -0.021247921511530876, 0.0365561880171299, -0.005628344137221575, 0.01362192165106535, -0.009158231317996979, 0.03150790557265282, -0.013641919009387493, 0.10648806393146515, 0.010884195566177368, 0.0174148790538311, -0.0027498684357851744, -0.01806321181356907, 0.09205111861228943, 0.04238750785589218, 0.04564351215958595, -0.08602634072303772, 0.02876536175608635, -0.016857437789440155, -0.046381350606679916, -0.04874955490231514, 0.023181773722171783, -0.008298834785819054, -0.00669664004817605, 0.048693638294935226, 0.05495345965027809, 0.010729598812758923, -0.02008247934281826, 0.01676078513264656, -0.02209308184683323, -0.04341508075594902, 0.006503672804683447, -0.0076688556000590324, -0.0019658044911921024, -0.0060381414368748665, -0.07798657566308975, 0.040692370384931564, -0.003607196267694235, -0.009553026407957077, -0.04003828018903732, -0.019408103078603745, 0.01300191693007946, 0.0018139458261430264, 0.00919429026544094, -0.00624792231246829, 0.03072124905884266, 0.03334213048219681, 0.0005917521775700152, 0.004034681245684624, 0.03378688916563988, -0.03748586028814316, 0.005787493195384741, 0.029949435964226723, 0.026554206386208534, 0.016697334125638008, 0.004929389338940382, 0.009975193068385124, -0.04965018108487129, -0.021638423204421997, -0.029513420537114143, 0.047698941081762314, -0.03707060217857361, -0.0046510882675647736, 0.015531635843217373, 0.014360279776155949, 0.015592062845826149, -0.032760631293058395, -0.020482592284679413, -0.013866902329027653, 0.04993152618408203, 0.0013989785220474005, 0.021988311782479286, -0.018878469243645668, 0.055089592933654785, 0.01857900060713291, 0.04207582771778107, -0.009259269572794437, -0.015351342037320137, 0.0005958477850072086, -0.010772457346320152, 0.042335301637649536, 0.0053635211661458015, -0.021373290568590164, -0.025920022279024124, 0.0097874216735363, -0.014187103137373924, -0.03121325559914112, 0.01152851153165102, -0.017446842044591904, 0.0017848818097263575, 0.014117313548922539, -0.009706133045256138, 0.012693545781075954, -0.06102464348077774, 0.0021571172401309013, -0.030942115932703018, 0.013334408402442932, -0.006018634885549545, -0.008318261243402958, 0.05355578288435936, 0.03503879904747009, 0.0034798188135027885, -0.018905268982052803, -0.017569702118635178, 0.0371643602848053, 0.041003867983818054, -0.0418040007352829, 0.00983811728656292, -0.02154938317835331, -0.005189452785998583, -0.03919394314289093, -0.05643223971128464, 0.018848160281777382, 0.022503044456243515, 0.050075333565473557, -0.0030155936256051064, 0.03458380326628685, -0.056899718940258026, -0.03358808904886246, 0.00028003822080790997, -0.0430106595158577, 0.007489923387765884, -0.010914305225014687, 0.010983387008309364, -0.004597736522555351, 0.008097032085061073, 0.003022534539923072, -0.004674685187637806, 0.010139594785869122, -0.012419127859175205, -0.052226461470127106, -0.04393508657813072, -0.004246904980391264, -0.017973879352211952, 0.008946506306529045, 0.008777537383139133, -0.0026985572185367346, 0.013719095848500729, 0.01739826425909996, -0.01702638901770115, -0.018221700564026833, 0.010048530995845795, -0.04759170487523079, 0.002757468493655324, 0.047202110290527344, 0.02688060700893402, 0.017334090545773506, 0.010004947893321514, 0.022669609636068344, -0.046100862324237823, 0.06415127962827682, -0.02091708779335022, -0.0044189803302288055, 0.030906211584806442, -0.053205136209726334, -0.009587172418832779, 0.002876836573705077, 0.009280639700591564, 0.020494310185313225, -0.009988199919462204, -0.017666779458522797, -0.05354493856430054, 0.04017568379640579, -0.016898438334465027, -0.004943838343024254, -0.01224060170352459, -0.004289305303245783, -0.046530868858098984, -0.02700936421751976, 0.032311130315065384, -0.01651030033826828, 0.008117002435028553, 0.02848903089761734, 0.01380860898643732, -0.026346223428845406, -0.017289387062191963, 0.023049484938383102, -0.008361113257706165, 0.0068452670238912106, 0.013117266818881035, -0.028025414794683456, 0.06443490087985992, 0.06141655892133713, -0.013598974794149399, -0.005713050719350576, -0.028911735862493515, 0.010987785644829273, -0.10970092564821243, 0.0018286361591890454, 0.05910949781537056, -0.0034709477331489325, 0.03508290275931358, -0.06807500869035721, -0.006450022105127573, 0.04565607011318207, -0.057038065046072006, -0.011532437056303024, 0.0021239323541522026, -0.05399962514638901, -0.026019873097538948, 0.03779811039566994, 0.0028537260368466377, 0.024382976815104485, 0.004954742733389139, 0.02506420947611332, 0.028976967558264732, 0.03327077254652977, -0.007140969391912222, -0.022814206779003143, -0.03153632953763008, -0.00944620743393898, 0.02702099084854126, -0.0415438711643219, 0.020115137100219727, -0.00918610766530037, -0.035044554620981216, 0.027089456096291542, -0.022136880084872246, -0.014531566761434078, -0.012570107355713844, 0.03816961869597435, 0.019132837653160095, 0.028383001685142517, -0.004591077566146851, 0.011565303429961205, 0.041044946759939194, -0.044900525361299515, 0.023116424679756165, -0.007223039865493774, -0.057282447814941406, -0.0028407364152371883, 0.014916172251105309, 0.0034057374577969313, -0.036693934351205826, 0.05204024910926819, 0.0072314846329391, -0.03615601360797882, -0.008441818878054619, -0.025529755279421806, 0.03409745916724205, -0.04546725004911423, 0.04810682684183121, -0.04793326556682587, 0.006367282941937447, 0.016464175656437874, -0.001908188802190125, -0.0447159968316555, 0.028260618448257446, 0.01624760776758194, -0.05931568518280983, 0.03174211084842682, 0.013500455766916275, -0.005057995673269033, -0.05951189994812012, -0.018378309905529022, 0.016460157930850983, -0.01127799041569233, 0.0041534919291734695, -0.030684716999530792, -0.05141575261950493, 0.0056762611493468285, 0.002729135798290372, 0.032455895096063614, 0.002920675789937377, 0.0015074250986799598, 0.008337331004440784, -0.06340549141168594, 0.011609591543674469, 0.02985275909304619, -0.02549472637474537, -0.035030242055654526, -0.0005149150965735316, -0.01771090179681778, 0.0036650248803198338, 0.05395280569791794, -0.005067811347544193, -0.002457947703078389, -0.016539862379431725, 0.03998486325144768, 0.019491732120513916, -0.04693774878978729, 0.024067828431725502, -0.011989254504442215, -0.047907330095767975, -0.045198820531368256, -0.02523127757012844, 0.004176512826234102, 0.045879047363996506, 0.006170622538775206, -0.007738347165286541, 0.007828389294445515, 0.011676373891532421, 0.0023038166109472513, 0.01143003161996603, 0.025669418275356293, -0.022086484357714653, 0.061557941138744354, -0.04903167486190796, -0.015635525807738304, 0.009550108574330807, -0.011895690113306046, -0.03030451387166977, 0.01442599669098854, -0.015861712396144867, -0.032993100583553314, -0.019257323816418648, 0.0035266352351754904, 0.017202049493789673, -0.08542212843894958, -0.0027661635540425777, 0.03177330642938614, -0.07254405319690704, -0.01329959649592638, 0.040778983384370804, 0.049864791333675385, 0.03926629200577736, -0.0019460932817310095, 0.025785304605960846, 0.02678559347987175, 0.004039072897285223, 0.022724570706486702, 0.04004921019077301, 0.00982678309082985, -0.007870008237659931, 0.007163064554333687, 0.017880301922559738, -0.020697345957159996, 0.03549524396657944, -0.042057063430547714, 0.023343421518802643, -0.02187976986169815, -0.007656487170606852, 0.004274176433682442, -0.010272189974784851, 0.04597804322838783, -0.0027836961671710014, -0.04427565634250641, 0.0695534348487854, -0.043785545974969864, 0.0063801975920796394, -0.020800283178687096, 0.023037629202008247, -0.024940522387623787, -0.025398720055818558, 0.02604595385491848, 0.05205317959189415, 0.026094501838088036, 0.010159256868064404, 0.02269737608730793, -0.033152587711811066, -0.0014905540738254786, -0.01982245221734047, 0.054917313158512115, -0.0360356867313385, 0.01376949343830347, -0.026825355365872383, -0.0042252326384186745, -0.0012736887438222766, -0.007061686832457781, 0.002916310913860798, 0.018373005092144012, 0.014780882745981216, -0.008735422044992447, -0.016380567103624344, -0.008844499476253986, 0.04570399597287178, -0.056297145783901215, -0.01516586635261774, -0.027977354824543, 0.0017834893660619855, -0.01406247541308403, -0.014789978042244911 ]
<p>Good day all,</p> <p>Suppose that I am conducting a questionnaire study that is trying to measure level of awareness of subjects about a programming language and find the relation of those level of awareness to working conditions and methods etc.</p> <p>To improve my precision I decided to go with stratified sampling. If I have 1 criteria for stratification such as geo-distribution (to make sure I don't over represent subjects from areas that have less programmers), then I end up with 6 distinct strata (country provinces).</p> <p>I know how to go about analysing these to find margin error, standard error etc but I realised that is not good enough and I need to introduce more criteria's for stratification, such as level of education (so i don't over represent a group who are not very present between programmers based on their education), level of seniority etc.</p> <p>I have the proportion (%) for all these criteria's but I don't know how I go about sampling when I have more than one criteria?</p> <p>Thanks for your help :) </p>
37,106
[ -0.04293419048190117, -0.011914359405636787, 0.005588626489043236, 0.028259361162781715, 0.028943004086613655, 0.004182120319455862, 0.010880077257752419, -0.02121363766491413, 0.01174901332706213, -0.024162456393241882, 0.03322949633002281, 0.03295112028717995, 0.052176330238580704, 0.02002820186316967, 0.0278738122433424, -0.015416109003126621, -0.02601579762995243, 0.04523443430662155, 0.005978352390229702, -0.029463065788149834, -0.0395711250603199, 0.008190048858523369, -0.0032417643815279007, -0.019286686554551125, -0.01903621107339859, 0.01702287793159485, 0.039755042642354965, -0.01680288091301918, -0.005785612389445305, 0.0381566546857357, -0.009348158724606037, 0.004897539038211107, 0.02313029207289219, 0.005021323449909687, 0.028647910803556442, 0.01005944050848484, -0.03745897486805916, -0.00210836180485785, -0.04081932455301285, 0.02328154817223549, -0.041639313101768494, 0.01187167875468731, 0.0040798066183924675, 0.006191645748913288, 0.004630269482731819, 0.028628474101424217, -0.016381679102778435, -0.03347502648830414, 0.036242857575416565, -0.03452964127063751, 0.04232364892959595, -0.016051046550273895, 0.02122695930302143, 0.022432532161474228, -0.007619812153279781, 0.015966694802045822, 0.045571234077215195, 0.05781541019678116, 0.011646619997918606, -0.014076979830861092, -0.017455754801630974, 0.000492218357976526, -0.011312528513371944, -0.02279294654726982, -0.01899060793220997, 0.0313265435397625, -0.047155581414699554, 0.011652522720396519, 0.04986892640590668, -0.006273805629462004, 0.01584446057677269, -0.0057641551829874516, 0.00979310367256403, -0.012446708045899868, -0.007035757880657911, -0.06129961460828781, 0.00004056038960698061, 0.057276494801044464, 0.03572718799114227, 0.007914036512374878, 0.0023557767271995544, 0.03180652856826782, -0.00692394794896245, 0.01558114867657423, 0.03809857740998268, 0.0007967021665535867, 0.07825980335474014, -0.04758547246456146, 0.030270365998148918, 0.038857899606227875, -0.014887278899550438, -0.014807003550231457, 0.06176930293440819, 0.0027244421653449535, -0.05353374406695366, -0.010208561085164547, -0.022736037150025368, 0.03423384204506874, -0.012033732607960701, 0.032725341618061066, 0.0036013699136674404, -0.03976151719689369, 0.04407063499093056, 0.04692225158214569, -0.03986290469765663, 0.02170214056968689, -0.025226885452866554, -0.015044786036014557, 0.010034332983195782, -0.04993690177798271, 0.010344665497541428, -0.0007101950468495488, 0.014336333610117435, -0.007960873655974865, 0.01059512048959732, 0.02074468322098255, -0.00770576810464263, -0.007086681202054024, 0.07619057595729828, 0.061619833111763, 0.044379353523254395, -0.04350781440734863, 0.08007721602916718, -0.0023181859869509935, -0.10409345477819443, 0.02665749564766884, -0.0075375656597316265, 0.0032726528588682413, -0.020408669486641884, 0.03174649924039841, -0.019889723509550095, -0.030992010608315468, 0.0649443194270134, 0.021648069843649864, 0.045038677752017975, 0.0057268873788416386, -0.09518550336360931, -0.06363993883132935, 0.022236764430999756, 0.015143195167183876, 0.027247535064816475, -0.05325973778963089, 0.019235333427786827, 0.017837276682257652, 0.06603141874074936, 0.028625767678022385, 0.019392598420381546, 0.0046554976142942905, 0.013183584436774254, 0.01699015311896801, -0.03475325554609299, -0.008007648400962353, -0.02139688841998577, -0.0047128815203905106, -0.0073105692863464355, -0.09031054377555847, -0.005081578623503447, -0.008234654553234577, -0.010793186724185944, -0.03982826694846153, 0.0023027011193335056, 0.02764255553483963, -0.017515335232019424, -0.030384408310055733, 0.06282767653465271, -0.03452232852578163, 0.056918803602457047, -0.03023735247552395, 0.02792537398636341, 0.006091204937547445, 0.013384459540247917, 0.014528878964483738, -0.006268644239753485, -0.0003273365437053144, 0.04416179656982422, -0.03665002062916756, 0.01668708212673664, -0.024642711505293846, 0.021675681695342064, 0.007136813830584288, -0.05877126008272171, -0.03689580038189888, -0.00331606506370008, 0.034703828394412994, 0.03285198286175728, 0.03228836879134178, 0.0019555266480892897, -0.05724044516682625, 0.020788274705410004, -0.04469897598028183, -0.056246671825647354, -0.05874844267964363, 0.006314949598163366, 0.0019087144173681736, -0.0456647127866745, 0.003274229820817709, -0.004056790843605995, 0.01167525164783001, -0.023203739896416664, -0.03055930882692337, -0.02398628368973732, -0.032030846923589706, 0.04545741155743599, -0.035573359578847885, -0.014534828253090382, 0.028830241411924362, 0.007704824209213257, 0.005238327197730541, 0.07053928077220917, 0.0062931738793849945, -0.01867532543838024, -0.004598455503582954, -0.031175704672932625, -0.008798201568424702, -0.026929069310426712, -0.03836539387702942, 0.004644131753593683, 0.011698185466229916, -0.012762484140694141, 0.05458323284983635, -0.06334394961595535, 0.11848575621843338, 0.07170218974351883, 0.0044280462898314, 0.014595499262213707, -0.003009926062077284, -0.0013440174516290426, 0.023239396512508392, -0.00469703646376729, 0.022319773212075233, -0.08162600547075272, 0.009361027739942074, 0.03056585229933262, -0.0070053525269031525, -0.03911815211176872, 0.004365188535302877, 0.05637659132480621, 0.03662727028131485, -0.0008301399066112936, 0.05097737908363342, 0.014935004524886608, 0.004254697822034359, -0.010610251687467098, 0.029360804706811905, 0.002424748847261071, 0.026059143245220184, 0.0271320678293705, 0.02313680574297905, 0.01855066418647766, 0.011877799406647682, 0.006728227250277996, 0.0433892197906971, 0.0041025420650839806, 0.04603079706430435, -0.016864847391843796, 0.023903751745820045, 0.05711625888943672, -0.007842815481126308, -0.014351964928209782, 0.034607015550136566, 0.0052978587336838245, -0.002280728192999959, 0.027932604774832726, -0.03858345001935959, 0.05065067112445831, 0.04555634409189224, -0.05455278232693672, -0.014202874153852463, 0.02066190540790558, -0.03182416036725044, -0.020624639466404915, -0.03212173655629158, -0.009681059047579765, -0.04407675191760063, -0.0029651387594640255, 0.051671795547008514, 0.00005229001908446662, 0.032327454537153244, -0.012078684754669666, -0.0009805946610867977, -0.0065033938735723495, 0.010675538331270218, 0.008309494704008102, -0.0067112138494849205, -0.06427471339702606, 0.0099645322188735, 0.02913050539791584, -0.030563920736312866, 0.0292969923466444, -0.018773989751935005, -0.053084053099155426, 0.014422743581235409, 0.016111304983496666, -0.0286452267318964, 0.0022856404539197683, 0.0022606397978961468, 0.027628201991319656, -0.029831647872924805, 0.006479197647422552, 0.00953067559748888, 0.03921898454427719, 0.0007091154111549258, 0.058341093361377716, -0.008791754022240639, -0.04402293637394905, -0.046605151146650314, 0.00380282592959702, 0.019247252494096756, -0.006888034287840128, -0.004777066875249147, 0.042442552745342255, 0.015839891508221626, -0.014793410897254944, -0.03628570958971977, -0.05395671725273132, 0.022122081369161606, 0.032760582864284515, 0.034712210297584534, -0.007475496735423803, -0.018695931881666183, 0.07971007376909256, 0.014968096278607845, -0.018277695402503014, -0.03448166698217392, -0.032035943120718, -0.032720260322093964, 0.01710999570786953, 0.023358969017863274, 0.006235267501324415, -0.015903936699032784, -0.0178365558385849, -0.010761652141809464, 0.037815529853105545, 0.046498872339725494, 0.01372618693858385, 0.006426507607102394, 0.016982760280370712, -0.01379428431391716, -0.013489361852407455, 0.06684191524982452, 0.02487429790198803, -0.025350959971547127, 0.0164639875292778, -0.023227719590067863, 0.030130796134471893, 0.033038266003131866, -0.009942933917045593, 0.0007303501479327679, -0.011761073023080826, -0.041240040212869644, -0.061647817492485046, 0.017603790387511253, 0.058191630989313126, -0.033649422228336334, 0.01076490432024002, 0.017144331708550453, 0.047584060579538345, -0.033070262521505356, -0.03195768967270851, 0.07392370700836182, 0.037117600440979004, -0.017126871272921562, 0.01696588844060898, -0.018500488251447678, 0.021664272993803024, 0.011777575127780437, -0.018586568534374237, -0.021762311458587646, 0.017330558970570564, 0.03961307182908058, 0.05461448058485985, -0.0437287837266922, -0.0192108117043972, 0.024599812924861908, -0.06392314285039902, 0.005413583479821682, -0.036823123693466187, 0.11562438309192657, -0.006155904848128557, 0.03307756036520004, 0.028989488258957863, -0.030929306522011757, -0.009975099936127663, 0.012960119172930717, -0.023929018527269363, 0.022594742476940155, -0.021639429032802582, -0.011102565564215183, 0.023412121459841728, -0.03636309131979942, 0.04626287519931793, -0.02826273813843727, -0.0180122759193182, 0.007193354424089193, 0.024930136278271675, -0.028230104595422745, 0.027038875967264175, -0.0015089523512870073, 0.00655233534052968, 0.009908662177622318, 0.03256756067276001, 0.010296876542270184, 0.020828640088438988, -0.02185472659766674, 0.03879375010728836, 0.026204025372862816, -0.056171681731939316, -0.04121757671236992, 0.009964718483388424, 0.005711197853088379, 0.04601743817329407, 0.0002952266950160265, 0.007743231952190399, -0.04597751051187515, 0.019218090921640396, -0.012813583947718143, 0.06251721829175949, 0.04994610697031021, 0.006453498732298613, 0.0027600142639130354, -0.02260824292898178, -0.018377140164375305, 0.023264650255441666, 0.021039359271526337, -0.005975716281682253, 0.02808694913983345, 0.03306536749005318, 0.023815007880330086, -0.09323687106370926, 0.01362959761172533, 0.03979259729385376, -0.03213366121053696, 0.013636603951454163, -0.013909243047237396, -0.018619738519191742, 0.0018294027540832758, -0.014395510777831078, 0.0338398739695549, 0.04327546805143356, -0.015015343204140663, 0.01173127070069313, 0.05743775889277458, -0.024649638682603836, -0.0819673240184784, 0.028627660125494003, 0.014210483059287071, 0.0492493100464344, -0.0016685912851244211, -0.041847534477710724, 0.02617316134274006, 0.010370006784796715, 0.042557913810014725, -0.015669643878936768, 0.0010248366743326187, -0.08324788510799408, 0.004879969637840986, 0.02972542494535446, 0.02315942943096161, -0.03411867469549179, 0.02086867205798626, -0.010620147921144962, -0.018930433318018913, 0.023669373244047165, -0.03368799760937691, 0.007815394550561905, -0.05026743933558464, 0.025462815538048744, -0.013493555597960949, 0.01669633761048317, -0.036777105182409286, -0.020399050787091255, -0.034277454018592834, 0.012342357076704502, -0.008795623667538166, -0.011927173472940922, -0.05121241509914398, 0.0339055098593235, 0.032595179975032806, 0.07483579218387604, -0.008129783906042576, -0.041649337857961655, -0.039604537189006805, 0.02433066815137863, -0.011047023348510265, -0.06158926337957382, 0.0136782918125391, -0.015191805548965931, -0.0008636639104224741, 0.03967491164803505, -0.016483191400766373, -0.03399454057216644, 0.022478176280856133, 0.03710728511214256, -0.00702561205253005, 0.007540739141404629, -0.014660133048892021, 0.034082360565662384, 0.014198880642652512, 0.02460748329758644, 0.025325903668999672, -0.026214731857180595, -0.012160088866949081, 0.017732856795191765, -0.007360723800957203, -0.02259150706231594, -0.041048530489206314, -0.0077844541519880295, -0.044413674622774124, -0.020459137856960297, -0.01342213898897171, 0.0015327591681852937, 0.013217771425843239, 0.03443209454417229, -0.02749798260629177, -0.03943338617682457, -0.0453413724899292, 0.0037016945425421, 0.015052341856062412, -0.0008593958336859941, 0.023390084505081177, 0.0024491327349096537, -0.02544119581580162, -0.013747465796768665, 0.043179403990507126, -0.0422142930328846, -0.015398328192532063, -0.02165387012064457, -0.03688057139515877, -0.01654224656522274, -0.04545057937502861, -0.021885192021727562, 0.021860960870981216, -0.029648814350366592, 0.05444753170013428, -0.01064584031701088, 0.05006153881549835, -0.03667352348566055, -0.031777311116456985, 0.010279673151671886, 0.0521676279604435, 0.03767018020153046, 0.035754114389419556, -0.02275179512798786, 0.03640944883227348, -0.026994457468390465, -0.018128085881471634, -0.09444211423397064, -0.0461592897772789, 0.043062664568424225, 0.00805589184165001, 0.003922285512089729, -0.030630389228463173, -0.017978325486183167, 0.003050386207178235, -0.033045217394828796, 0.012041638605296612, 0.05431491509079933, -0.004851364530622959, -0.011695515364408493, -0.018129533156752586, 0.04628123715519905, 0.07444179058074951, -0.02575596049427986, -0.010233105160295963, -0.014132079668343067, -0.0037067835219204426, 0.012718809768557549, -0.029840221628546715, -0.009731979109346867, -0.025013478472828865, -0.01079501397907734, -0.015692217275500298, 0.013991253450512886, 0.013135227374732494, 0.005417456850409508, -0.011008921079337597, -0.010374384932219982, -0.006884839851409197, 0.004693197552114725, -0.034517206251621246, -0.013616370968520641, -0.007900160737335682, 0.013993887230753899, -0.02649092674255371, -0.007746525574475527, -0.02205505408346653, -0.01597110740840435, 0.04235348850488663, -0.00822429545223713, -0.020074976608157158, 0.0052988044917583466, 0.052752282470464706, 0.00033914230880327523, 0.01581628993153572, 0.021344851702451706, -0.03505001589655876, 0.04460448771715164, -0.0057755461893975735, -0.020830880850553513, 0.023049939423799515, 0.0121345529332757, -0.03153408318758011, -0.028726086020469666, -0.017533857375383377, 0.0017493920167908072, 0.06695515662431717, 0.021024730056524277, 0.07240444421768188, 0.05749049782752991, -0.004003410693258047, 0.011813177727162838, 0.01779434084892273, -0.014926338568329811, -0.032503508031368256, -0.027747096493840218, 0.06111755222082138, -0.000007475338861695491, -0.014557906426489353, 0.027848724275827408, 0.04750201106071472, 0.03013426624238491, 0.061263635754585266, 0.032377760857343674, 0.033375535160303116, -0.0042361305095255375, -0.04664711654186249, -0.002465341007336974, 0.009700899943709373, -0.051781848073005676, 0.021417323499917984, -0.013260199688374996, -0.03137115761637688, 0.05766760930418968, 0.027211355045437813, 0.012668592855334282, -0.00046468526124954224, -0.01068923156708479, -0.05298060551285744, 0.009871147572994232, 0.029358968138694763, -0.0011964574223384261, 0.014437094330787659, 0.02201835811138153, 0.033637285232543945, -0.006356626283377409, -0.004113192204385996, -0.022402407601475716, -0.05830758437514305, -0.013508914038538933, -0.05903978645801544, -0.06367079168558121, -0.007627050392329693, 0.03222063183784485, -0.013994719833135605, 0.023862849920988083, -0.007734599523246288, 0.015539828687906265, 0.02206684648990631, 0.024821529164910316, -0.01049047987908125, 0.04487021267414093, 0.019988156855106354, 0.020531630143523216, 0.0074183037504553795, 0.008939978666603565, 0.12469583004713058, 0.0816299319267273, 0.01735871471464634, -0.0656653568148613, 0.029131809249520302, 0.00782972015440464, 0.02316775918006897, -0.008399027399718761, 0.003945694305002689, -0.007709531579166651, -0.027976324781775475, 0.021433508023619652, 0.026359016075730324, 0.019509971141815186, 0.05446450039744377, 0.08141084015369415, -0.008815020322799683, -0.030421027913689613, -0.012328226119279861, 0.02416069060564041, 0.01160948071628809, -0.004141798242926598, -0.046487294137477875, 0.00010014304280048236, 0.013679380528628826, -0.014847368001937866, -0.02036099322140217, -0.03147153928875923, 0.004588040057569742, -0.013291455805301666, -0.026101697236299515, -0.017858529463410378, -0.01425013318657875, -0.01283123530447483, -0.05233084410429001, -0.05286702886223793, 0.01675792783498764, -0.04990805685520172, 0.005074436776340008, 0.036061108112335205, -0.03490116447210312, -0.0009220864158123732, -0.00804859958589077, 0.008123698644340038, -0.00727928476408124, -0.005524531938135624, -0.053718701004981995, 0.006495857611298561, -0.0024446810130029917, -0.00004175414869678207, -0.02016107738018036, 0.034228235483169556, 0.0006376915262080729, -0.011512301862239838, -0.006660341750830412, 0.021278830245137215, 0.03429901599884033, -0.017056334763765335, -0.043625034391880035, 0.023628273978829384, 0.0006791895139031112, -0.0032348758541047573, -0.01551124919205904, -0.007873859256505966, -0.0341421440243721, 0.013277084566652775, -0.011788304895162582, -0.003622000105679035, -0.0202038511633873, 0.005053993780165911, 0.032761406153440475, -0.02772446721792221, -0.05183858796954155, 0.001714840647764504, -0.021106984466314316, 0.017969971522688866, 0.018577508628368378, -0.017289571464061737, -0.014748417772352695, -0.018459409475326538, -0.026123112067580223, -0.015852609649300575, -0.0357743538916111, 0.00042262161150574684, -0.011459440924227238, 0.022986814379692078, -0.007671524304896593, 0.010984672233462334, -0.0007879725890234113, 0.00421603349968791, 0.019854500889778137, 0.04924431070685387, -0.004166712518781424, -0.05592617765069008, 0.0065627992153167725, -0.031397849321365356, -0.05211083963513374, 0.009510740637779236, -0.04476826637983322, 0.05567771568894386, 0.005978115368634462, 0.010640713386237621, 0.009110533632338047, 0.016545511782169342, -0.0005118942935951054, -0.012248463928699493, -0.01733402907848358, -0.05864769220352173, -0.014656508341431618, 0.02029242180287838, -0.006625477224588394, -0.024238979443907738, 0.0019828728400170803, -0.04531313106417656, -0.023362869396805763, 0.018626246601343155, -0.018897932022809982, -0.03013974241912365, 0.02385561726987362, -0.015023170039057732, -0.0018790607573464513, -0.004285396076738834, 0.015396970324218273, -0.01291757170110941, -0.004214081447571516, -0.0012447925982996821, 0.0031786279287189245, 0.010316415689885616, -0.028965387493371964, 0.005039742682129145, 0.01969333179295063, 0.0035319721791893244, 0.008487665094435215, 0.00782703049480915, 0.01268680952489376, 0.03251873329281807, -0.02383418008685112, 0.0195193812251091, -0.02782178297638893, 0.021795129403471947, 0.027359489351511, -0.057329028844833374, -0.055981628596782684, 0.03224164992570877, -0.005831937305629253, 0.07173877954483032, 0.028892355039715767, 0.004000874701887369, 0.0063104936853051186, 0.05796387419104576, -0.03047182783484459, -0.038911279290914536, -0.03433861956000328, 0.05459270626306534, 0.04023196920752525, -0.013232781551778316, -0.009882823564112186, -0.010775018483400345, -0.004713389091193676, 0.03367957845330238, 0.058089204132556915, -0.00660017691552639, -0.025634152814745903, 0.010844158008694649, 0.0067423987202346325, 0.04208903759717941, 0.01940968446433544, -0.009944935329258442, 0.04058701545000076, 0.0146553423255682, -0.03969237953424454, -0.0010296553373336792, -0.003137570573017001, 0.0135465944185853, -0.05480270832777023, -0.037411272525787354, -0.0016912897117435932, 0.028786219656467438, 0.018072761595249176, -0.04544006660580635, 0.003412464167922735, 0.02967371977865696, 0.0020811886060982943, 0.012123857624828815, 0.015054948627948761, 0.030798906460404396, -0.039100226014852524, 0.003415773157030344, -0.017445053905248642, 0.03376738727092743, 0.011613123118877411, 0.013128060847520828, 0.032209668308496475, 0.02703864313662052, -0.015316649340093136, -0.056648507714271545, -0.019134726375341415, 0.0038303115870803595, -0.01932995766401291, -0.08327517658472061, -0.023814694955945015, -0.02758609876036644, -0.02579844743013382, 0.032804470509290695, -0.019721224904060364, 0.0024957587011158466, 0.030107494443655014, 0.033813368529081345, 0.012612913735210896, 0.021602071821689606, 0.02588127925992012, -0.00714148161932826, -0.019060857594013214, 0.011958122253417969, 0.034393489360809326, 0.011769325472414494, -0.007764993701130152, 0.003071920946240425, 0.07380442321300507, 0.014818686991930008, 0.010555529035627842, 0.012503044679760933, -0.0436575748026371, 0.02185376174747944, 0.013795658014714718, -0.011609451845288277, -0.004607087001204491, -0.05044298991560936, 0.04056750610470772, -0.05087745934724808, 0.011657897382974625, 0.031016582623124123, -0.0009960983879864216, -0.04560224339365959, 0.007931903004646301, -0.021111205220222473, -0.022328071296215057, -0.013246152549982071, 0.0070783100090920925, -0.02391974627971649, -0.04571240022778511, 0.012766816653311253, -0.00872884877026081, 0.016172578558325768, -0.004103373736143112, -0.000882141524925828, -0.015233077108860016, 0.05182751268148422, -0.05061088502407074, -0.030785655602812767, 0.007895844988524914, -0.002482757205143571, 0.045436009764671326, -0.06792048364877701, 0.07619757205247879, 0.013873171992599964, -0.02123907580971718, -0.05474024638533592, -0.04441496357321739, -0.03504212945699692, 0.018855327740311623, 0.03888256475329399, -0.007316164672374725, -0.011282109655439854, -0.024563485756516457, 0.046660568565130234, -0.007320945151150227, -0.03265128284692764, 0.04252253845334053, -0.0008014630293473601, -0.046773187816143036, -0.0036218927707523108, -0.014322093687951565, -0.01404141541570425, 0.008413968607783318, 0.020459692925214767, -0.0008058543317019939, 0.03052634187042713, -0.013731682673096657, -0.038804784417152405, 0.03166315332055092, 0.0056718154810369015, -0.010408802889287472, 0.011994902044534683, -0.018342100083827972, -0.008500696159899235, 0.01950187236070633, 0.0045578801073133945, -0.05181156098842621, 0.02686440758407116, -0.023998649790883064, -0.061967603862285614, -0.02602379582822323, -0.0026492346078157425, -0.002092190785333514, -0.04009881988167763, -0.015819407999515533, -0.016933290287852287, -0.06544868648052216, 0.009568781591951847, 0.05919446423649788, 0.0251445472240448, 0.026390567421913147, -0.06494143605232239, 0.03488113358616829, -0.01914316788315773, -0.04387675225734711, 0.02703097090125084, 0.016406724229454994, 0.00013161776587367058, 0.011631464585661888, 0.006343016866594553, 0.03329296410083771, 0.027701886370778084, 0.06543847918510437, -0.01555830892175436, 0.020547164604067802, -0.04545015096664429, 0.005092146806418896, 0.03164494037628174, -0.006574102211743593, -0.0009585842490196228, -0.00027517435955815017, -0.013871261849999428, 0.04176174849271774, -0.0023113407660275698, -0.0048020705580711365, -0.06562361866235733, -0.03255152329802513, -0.0314708948135376, -0.00016576916095800698, 0.019242266193032265, 0.0383836105465889, -0.007387896068394184, -0.0038501573726534843, -0.01466406136751175, -0.028672369197010994, 0.05782734975218773, -0.009825699031352997, 0.058715760707855225, 0.007640895899385214, -0.02486114390194416, -0.012949736788868904, -0.01764579303562641, -0.011167953722178936, 0.019833868369460106, 0.05023137480020523, 0.013835395686328411, 0.047906212508678436, 0.008108876645565033, -0.005209571681916714, 0.006347117479890585, -0.01143945287913084, -0.03486884385347366, -0.06118319556117058, -0.061244770884513855, 0.018616195768117905, -0.005505027715116739, 0.018584461882710457 ]
<p>I want add to my regression additional features to complicate my model and lower bias, after searching around internet is seems a good idea is to add square features, that can help regression learn in coefficients more knowledge.</p> <p>I want add to my regression model square of pairs of features $x * y$, i think that can help learn my model relationships between features variables that can be highly correlated.</p> <p>Problem is when I see at interpretation of $x * y$ it seems incorrect, when i get $high * high = higher$ ex. $5 * 5 = 25$ that is good, but $low * low = higher$ seems strongly invalid ex. $-5 * -5 = 25$, should be $-25$ for my problem statement. </p> <p>Same problems I have for $high * low = low$, ex. $5 * -5 = -25$, i think should be somewhere between $&lt;-5; 5&gt;$, for example in $0$.</p> <p>That anyone have any thoughts about what equation I can use to get correct representation?</p> <p>I will appreciate other ideas for new virtual calculated features.</p>
74,283
[ -0.0005806378903798759, 0.0055417753756046295, -0.0013612067559733987, 0.025389840826392174, 0.04470934718847275, 0.005167359486222267, -0.035289231687784195, -0.0280465055257082, 0.05376642197370529, -0.044625457376241684, 0.024253111332654953, 0.02592637576162815, 0.011036607436835766, -0.0018073762767016888, 0.020038412883877754, 0.01872793585062027, -0.019853023812174797, -0.02072110027074814, 0.0096907839179039, -0.015352245420217514, 0.00574356596916914, 0.0270862877368927, 0.021961569786071777, 0.00971486046910286, -0.04378651827573776, 0.06845426559448242, 0.03305678814649582, -0.028919830918312073, 0.010490942746400833, 0.04397061467170715, 0.03344910964369774, -0.030614858493208885, 0.008082889951765537, 0.03366946429014206, 0.002662450773641467, -0.015809228643774986, 0.021155279129743576, -0.038188181817531586, 0.0105090057477355, 0.04139397665858269, -0.00644870288670063, -0.022886177524924278, -0.009769327938556671, 0.04802943021059036, -0.0018373558996245265, -0.004266542382538319, -0.008422867394983768, -0.02430754154920578, 0.02535736933350563, -0.04140506312251091, 0.08646852523088455, 0.02845637872815132, 0.049024611711502075, 0.06061156466603279, -0.01735428348183632, 0.00490967370569706, 0.08100204914808273, 0.06827694922685623, -0.0045926449820399284, -0.05295485258102417, 0.014078649692237377, -0.0573132187128067, 0.0030776581261307, -0.010113147087395191, -0.033077422529459, 0.008960431441664696, -0.011272038333117962, -0.003494161181151867, -0.026429081335663795, -0.03625068813562393, 0.01967751421034336, 0.02970643900334835, 0.026022953912615776, -0.031665779650211334, 0.02342047356069088, -0.015361763536930084, 0.004606007132679224, 0.02698126807808876, 0.047546252608299255, -0.0031973528675734997, 0.01133662648499012, 0.023604903370141983, -0.0032207604963332415, 0.03014462999999523, 0.02326071448624134, -0.010475908406078815, 0.04578913003206253, 0.0027951558586210012, 0.035603493452072144, 0.03515530005097389, 0.0011674477718770504, 0.00021622140775434673, 0.0655164122581482, -0.014692937955260277, -0.03936503827571869, 0.008220972493290901, 0.015519064851105213, 0.0026132941711694, 0.03817666321992874, 0.005499379243701696, -0.025339273735880852, -0.04829335957765579, -0.029922867193818092, 0.07568315416574478, -0.03797651082277298, -0.04157532751560211, -0.042525745928287506, -0.010372756980359554, 0.039989784359931946, -0.041302602738142014, 0.006541885901242495, 0.023932289332151413, -0.018888862803578377, -0.036644347012043, 0.020532432943582535, -0.035673871636390686, -0.028325693681836128, -0.042575251311063766, 0.035538364201784134, 0.03395691514015198, 0.01662672497332096, -0.047268517315387726, 0.02054291032254696, -0.0032905610278248787, -0.04616755247116089, -0.011145999655127525, 0.019653990864753723, -0.038886722177267075, -0.03374180942773819, 0.02062237448990345, 0.041383326053619385, -0.019781116396188736, 0.02501305565237999, -0.009180213324725628, 0.015857713297009468, 0.050877850502729416, -0.07021895796060562, -0.08283676207065582, 0.04011797904968262, -0.017195243388414383, 0.01567084528505802, -0.032321564853191376, 0.0022840385790914297, 0.0333484522998333, 0.07453906536102295, 0.013414878398180008, 0.029894690960645676, 0.03378577530384064, -0.0003555437142495066, 0.0055059995502233505, -0.003796372329816222, -0.009398924186825752, -0.04974295571446419, -0.027494877576828003, -0.009763914160430431, -0.05626159533858299, 0.03889867290854454, 0.02394905872642994, -0.03254353627562523, 0.007236160337924957, 0.026617592200636864, -0.017946060746908188, -0.011490456759929657, 0.02677009254693985, 0.014370703138411045, -0.018285231664776802, 0.07423848658800125, 0.007308351807296276, 0.04196317866444588, 0.03854603320360184, -0.017965521663427353, 0.005899753887206316, 0.0031949470285326242, 0.04218176379799843, 0.07571946829557419, -0.003924359567463398, 0.0253720935434103, -0.01806625910103321, -0.006076312158256769, -0.007264161016792059, -0.060527317225933075, -0.039560697972774506, -0.04094799607992172, -0.009313075803220272, -0.0009822373976930976, 0.04961162060499191, -0.019166119396686554, 0.014850251376628876, 0.04461325705051422, -0.06892625987529755, -0.022542482241988182, -0.0852912962436676, -0.03673604130744934, -0.00726182758808136, -0.033940598368644714, -0.008570940233767033, -0.0030703814700245857, 0.055945854634046555, -0.023556886240839958, -0.0020484745036810637, 0.014874541200697422, 0.006220748648047447, 0.0765109732747078, -0.028697524219751358, 0.012842857278883457, 0.04505957290530205, 0.026360640302300453, -0.017773207277059555, 0.05044430121779442, -0.03289395198225975, -0.04034078121185303, 0.01510600931942463, -0.013594882562756538, 0.03547428175806999, -0.018052678555250168, -0.025652943179011345, 0.0058973063714802265, -0.0023674278054386377, 0.012372386641800404, 0.021545346826314926, -0.059990305453538895, 0.053252093493938446, 0.051473218947649, 0.03847341611981392, 0.011730602011084557, 0.01288663037121296, 0.018980734050273895, 0.02307383343577385, -0.02862251177430153, -0.026749717071652412, -0.015493635088205338, 0.016249556094408035, 0.004160299897193909, 0.024771424010396004, -0.06048345938324928, 0.024246374145150185, 0.05029081925749779, 0.021706905215978622, -0.00042411775211803615, 0.012393815442919731, 0.016179729253053665, 0.0033859964460134506, -0.0012364715803414583, 0.0004824633651878685, 0.03118344582617283, 0.009272539056837559, 0.009561915881931782, 0.04708149656653404, 0.011978557333350182, 0.014329785481095314, -0.011787294410169125, 0.045210063457489014, -0.0034816397819668055, -0.009968120604753494, -0.019406845793128014, 0.012561975978314877, 0.02567385695874691, -0.02661760523915291, -0.003554159076884389, 0.039432015269994736, -0.0076916953548789024, -0.028971731662750244, -0.01519866194576025, -0.02887638472020626, -0.014495872892439365, 0.04300191253423691, -0.03708358854055405, 0.031032370403409004, 0.007932353764772415, -0.021781736984848976, 0.02476857602596283, 0.00012596271699294448, -0.012250028550624847, -0.006195543333888054, 0.0008977454272098839, 0.04705539718270302, 0.018442176282405853, 0.01160380244255066, -0.026067640632390976, -0.01842840015888214, 0.01146883424371481, 0.013865556567907333, 0.02614278718829155, -0.0168108269572258, -0.06311070173978806, 0.009828307665884495, -0.07010094821453094, -0.021088216453790665, 0.022754861041903496, 0.007161946501582861, -0.023438449949026108, 0.0035797832533717155, -0.018611563369631767, -0.05596538260579109, -0.046534668654203415, -0.028588101267814636, 0.026301288977265358, -0.02132362127304077, -0.04898486286401749, 0.02810755744576454, -0.0073303780518472195, -0.0525941364467144, -0.004692705813795328, -0.04959169402718544, -0.03591831400990486, -0.02896813303232193, -0.006767249200493097, -0.007687231991440058, -0.0015784386778250337, 0.02269095741212368, 0.043703071773052216, 0.00058049859944731, 0.02095855213701725, -0.0684557631611824, -0.06032383069396019, 0.017354024574160576, 0.0178973451256752, 0.020198950543999672, 0.01798337884247303, 0.008825757540762424, 0.07113765925168991, 0.03310776129364967, -0.012643090449273586, -0.04549642279744148, -0.006867070682346821, -0.01763170026242733, -0.010524681769311428, -0.01233686227351427, 0.03117210604250431, 0.01949073001742363, 0.05178855359554291, 0.029427165165543556, 0.022617951035499573, 0.026235857978463173, -0.012317120097577572, -0.05410274118185043, 0.006803769618272781, -0.00565668661147356, 0.01773606799542904, 0.03793965280056, -0.016981394961476326, -0.03562801331281662, 0.006429991684854031, -0.004009035881608725, -0.007688841782510281, 0.008410108275711536, -0.04857068136334419, 0.017636217176914215, -0.022518448531627655, 0.003321815514937043, 0.0054550799541175365, -0.013989357277750969, 0.013249055482447147, -0.03204818442463875, -0.038042258471250534, 0.03519849479198456, 0.02951580099761486, -0.025437017902731895, 0.005954534746706486, 0.0320708304643631, 0.001304907607845962, 0.014582984149456024, -0.0057275849394500256, 0.024991771206259727, -0.016048140823841095, 0.013399197719991207, 0.00796685740351677, 0.011904283426702023, 0.022737868130207062, 0.050169605761766434, 0.0019118291093036532, 0.028642162680625916, -0.050727587193250656, 0.04826042801141739, -0.04923681169748306, -0.02140398696064949, -0.0011756710009649396, 0.050406623631715775, -0.011059549637138844, -0.0057363747619092464, 0.001288615632802248, -0.035505276173353195, 0.04451603814959526, 0.0027745214756578207, -0.0462193489074707, 0.03236234933137894, 0.011789352633059025, -0.005389986094087362, -0.006820771377533674, -0.005475952289998531, 0.0579751655459404, -0.030895017087459564, -0.030064189806580544, -0.015741778537631035, 0.007364955265074968, -0.02932257391512394, 0.040003836154937744, -0.032112110406160355, -0.03425416350364685, -0.01824893243610859, -0.005091451574116945, 0.004541863687336445, -0.05736671760678291, 0.029828988015651703, 0.017241939902305603, -0.011899339035153389, 0.02424657717347145, -0.029863253235816956, 0.022476565092802048, 0.06592167168855667, 0.009190906770527363, 0.029428327456116676, 0.03418109565973282, -0.04288419336080551, 0.011760197579860687, -0.02600478194653988, 0.05677032098174095, 0.04241809621453285, -0.010359656997025013, -0.015329227782785892, -0.030702099204063416, -0.04681551456451416, -0.0038036757614463568, 0.008222202770411968, 0.006288527976721525, 0.02126139961183071, 0.06560247391462326, -0.007519586477428675, -0.061540260910987854, 0.00933782383799553, 0.06159477308392525, 0.015222884714603424, 0.011266926303505898, -0.015149376355111599, -0.009117502719163895, 0.012570451013743877, -0.003102171467617154, 0.04743483290076256, -0.02174117974936962, 0.006446262821555138, -0.030410921201109886, 0.0621737502515316, -0.022039685398340225, -0.03332279995083809, 0.04670293629169464, 0.026621857658028603, 0.03924262151122093, 0.01173717062920332, 0.0007428625831380486, 0.000946934160310775, 0.032853737473487854, 0.0046166363172233105, 0.04270179569721222, -0.002020556014031172, -0.08746475726366043, -0.0024273053277283907, 0.02740788646042347, 0.08002301305532455, 0.008692792616784573, -0.037159424275159836, -0.06694941222667694, -0.029241370037198067, 0.038869064301252365, -0.01641405187547207, 0.024250591173768044, -0.015318645164370537, 0.00024472150835208595, -0.010837789624929428, -0.02015669085085392, -0.056305717676877975, 0.026032838970422745, -0.03122897446155548, 0.05755580589175224, -0.0412503145635128, -0.02955670654773712, -0.05105814337730408, 0.0065629202872514725, 0.007602572441101074, 0.06076602637767792, 0.0030719663482159376, 0.004803109914064407, -0.0016548450803384185, 0.025700781494379044, 0.0048451777547597885, -0.05581795051693916, 0.02238030917942524, 0.020651720464229584, -0.0046407910995185375, 0.03794533386826515, -0.009227869100868702, -0.012497982941567898, 0.018530501052737236, -0.012795835733413696, -0.015494597144424915, -0.021531904116272926, -0.023773254826664925, 0.04153929650783539, 0.04457208886742592, 0.02255186066031456, 0.08682530373334885, 0.03701702505350113, -0.0250016488134861, 0.01134462933987379, -0.04444997012615204, 0.005966483149677515, -0.03366147354245186, -0.03279450535774231, -0.03458355367183685, 0.013640464283525944, -0.01002762746065855, 0.029771041125059128, -0.01578933745622635, 0.02328070066869259, -0.04044876992702484, -0.03641599789261818, -0.01292717456817627, 0.03111908584833145, -0.001199190504848957, -0.028037263080477715, -0.005857142154127359, 0.0340154729783535, -0.015359058044850826, -0.016376622021198273, 0.004664948675781488, 0.019223811104893684, -0.013180077075958252, 0.008963514119386673, -0.02078600600361824, -0.027502398937940598, 0.005592268891632557, 0.01382317766547203, -0.030251488089561462, -0.027727140113711357, 0.025273645296692848, -0.009261948987841606, -0.0010522800730541348, -0.012186354957520962, -0.028755316510796547, -0.00396235566586256, 0.016190627589821815, -0.0030636771116405725, -0.002798378001898527, -0.03452947735786438, 0.026932571083307266, -0.011887727305293083, 0.02377195470035076, -0.03975691273808479, -0.052349358797073364, -0.01968090608716011, -0.012603419832885265, -0.028543813154101372, -0.028098206967115402, 0.00869141798466444, -0.027745259925723076, -0.02420712821185589, -0.021167870610952377, 0.049439653754234314, -0.042450714856386185, -0.03977018967270851, 0.018739067018032074, 0.018284041434526443, 0.04562472552061081, -0.023395216092467308, 0.017596857622265816, 0.047349512577056885, 0.017479518428444862, -0.006082738284021616, 0.01994733326137066, 0.00016012923151720315, -0.045756787061691284, 0.010176929645240307, -0.01531409565359354, 0.00039909459883347154, 0.02472974732518196, 0.00628376891836524, -0.0216368418186903, -0.03433573246002197, -0.006940293591469526, -0.011430811136960983, -0.029417455196380615, 0.020613661035895348, -0.007401975803077221, -0.020273108035326004, -0.012823508121073246, 0.017830614000558853, -0.008801124058663845, 0.0033310349099338055, 0.006881048437207937, -0.008675948716700077, -0.027569761499762535, 0.0067326994612813, 0.08312015235424042, 0.023034963756799698, 0.016245655715465546, -0.0025582213420420885, -0.016989270225167274, 0.06833142787218094, 0.028672631829977036, -0.006024240981787443, 0.002477560890838504, 0.04631801322102547, -0.030187875032424927, -0.04239503666758537, -0.05496756359934807, 0.0148766515776515, 0.09400685131549835, -0.04881332442164421, 0.06367550790309906, 0.027082286775112152, -0.023799190297722816, -0.0078072319738566875, -0.010255491361021996, -0.025487655773758888, 0.011409382335841656, -0.0026499570813030005, 0.0601516030728817, 0.001668881974183023, 0.011641309596598148, 0.014992062933743, 0.03807346895337105, 0.03606880083680153, 0.0604010634124279, -0.0008152113878168166, -0.0017270662356168032, 0.019753223285079002, -0.03530316799879074, -0.06007007509469986, 0.014680051244795322, -0.011482729576528072, 0.0017791097052395344, -0.029226573184132576, -0.020684856921434402, 0.06845543533563614, 0.03842116892337799, 0.012703187763690948, -0.06912360340356827, -0.04374859854578972, -0.049301620572805405, 0.012263189069926739, 0.019075360149145126, -0.03196490928530693, 0.03341250866651535, -0.021867530420422554, 0.00412147119641304, 0.005005341488867998, 0.027252959087491035, -0.05340006202459335, -0.0825614333152771, -0.014026162214577198, -0.03246840834617615, -0.022765127941966057, 0.022338947281241417, 0.03294260427355766, -0.029823385179042816, 0.023552075028419495, -0.03469108045101166, 0.016115151345729828, -0.025718072429299355, 0.019097264856100082, 0.009462683461606503, 0.047114744782447815, -0.005969648715108633, 0.0032205411698669195, 0.0033720838837325573, -0.01602722890675068, 0.1130310446023941, 0.08411060273647308, 0.01454440038651228, -0.03540060296654701, 0.028578009456396103, 0.00376723799854517, -0.014995054341852665, -0.04642555117607117, 0.02234291285276413, -0.007597758900374174, 0.011544388718903065, 0.040194038301706314, 0.06228029355406761, 0.03810673579573631, -0.0033443730790168047, 0.0364731140434742, -0.08122497797012329, -0.015677593648433685, 0.016872981563210487, 0.003941494971513748, 0.02406705915927887, 0.010466540232300758, -0.034054093062877655, -0.00938436295837164, -0.01127640251070261, -0.027170393615961075, -0.015004141256213188, 0.03228449448943138, 0.019071761518716812, 0.019639579579234123, -0.035724058747291565, 0.01653030700981617, 0.03293049335479736, 0.01279059611260891, 0.017083801329135895, 0.021667154505848885, 0.04093702882528305, -0.013313904404640198, -0.0008450032910332084, 0.004299767315387726, -0.005684065166860819, -0.006322674918919802, 0.029549337923526764, -0.00319681060500443, -0.033416301012039185, -0.014187028631567955, -0.03609185665845871, 0.058718591928482056, -0.03295842558145523, -0.014159676618874073, -0.011533427983522415, 0.00943791028112173, 0.0045426529832184315, -0.048632021993398666, -0.029644370079040527, 0.04807664453983307, 0.059018321335315704, -0.021633079275488853, -0.009848547168076038, -0.0008355691679753363, 0.04910355806350708, 0.011767769232392311, 0.024570483714342117, 0.03549160063266754, -0.03294987976551056, -0.017527639865875244, -0.03197372704744339, 0.04769402742385864, -0.02268502674996853, -0.0020608871709555387, -0.005909875966608524, -0.023986823856830597, -0.037572525441646576, -0.03184381499886513, 0.009998658671975136, 0.0032343484926968813, 0.004761964548379183, -0.02027938887476921, -0.018411295488476753, -0.031023936346173286, -0.05430864170193672, 0.012176083400845528, -0.032145556062459946, -0.0019214425701647997, -0.05480513721704483, 0.006596844643354416, 0.0014321377966552973, 0.039871715009212494, 0.02819179557263851, 0.03707680106163025, -0.02447584457695484, 0.027463115751743317, 0.026752259582281113, -0.03788838908076286, -0.028215959668159485, -0.005486411973834038, -0.05964845418930054, -0.01434999331831932, -0.01661037653684616, 0.045974910259246826, 0.021553885191679, -0.005399803631007671, -0.0050567686557769775, 0.07088586688041687, -0.023977216333150864, 0.002956657437607646, -0.009283475577831268, -0.035367559641599655, 0.006260312628000975, -0.0009451641235500574, 0.03836031258106232, -0.03072725236415863, -0.015778014436364174, -0.020540639758110046, -0.06035520136356354, 0.01676986552774906, 0.02244069054722786, -0.043086931109428406, 0.02719859406352043, -0.03330153599381447, 0.009731247089803219, -0.01240750215947628, -0.013269634917378426, -0.04170491546392441, 0.026177633553743362, 0.008857149630784988, -0.0761079266667366, -0.0008438471122644842, 0.012714304029941559, -0.01925482042133808, 0.011275306344032288, 0.04284517839550972, 0.022302307188510895, 0.04252678155899048, -0.027417391538619995, 0.0004583727568387985, -0.022290555760264397, 0.03792823851108551, -0.023843731731176376, -0.0314176008105278, -0.003908987622708082, -0.010491456836462021, -0.019726280122995377, 0.02700815163552761, -0.017201242968440056, 0.05246838554739952, 0.02335197478532791, 0.013392540626227856, -0.022476086392998695, 0.031199529767036438, -0.0068319812417030334, -0.01256038248538971, -0.007349886931478977, 0.018000800162553787, -0.015057419426739216, -0.000652575574349612, 0.031033648177981377, -0.026405291631817818, -0.008084665052592754, -0.011761324480175972, 0.0595194436609745, 0.030751021578907967, -0.03001120127737522, 0.014975452795624733, -0.020851565524935722, 0.04191572591662407, 0.011816923506557941, -0.002547427313402295, 0.035908911377191544, -0.0021022462751716375, -0.04304437339305878, 0.045558322221040726, 0.02706960402429104, 0.0311568770557642, -0.07774080336093903, -0.021427782252430916, 0.042210765182971954, 0.023094041272997856, 0.04190418869256973, -0.04990530014038086, 0.01368531584739685, 0.017048858106136322, -0.0272013321518898, 0.015796681866049767, -0.010011604987084866, 0.004952373914420605, -0.000547664356417954, 0.000016046431483118795, -0.018229734152555466, -0.02713015116751194, 0.0049853818491101265, 0.029494300484657288, 0.04910440370440483, 0.021126635372638702, -0.00429087970405817, -0.06408725678920746, -0.04850676283240318, -0.024424003437161446, 0.029041793197393417, -0.04921003803610802, 0.05439196899533272, -0.025869371369481087, -0.04988425597548485, 0.05686229467391968, -0.008937597274780273, 0.016475044190883636, 0.037999071180820465, 0.043315574526786804, 0.00877655390650034, 0.053915828466415405, 0.025623923167586327, -0.01206989400088787, -0.012743246741592884, -0.039105210453271866, 0.019477693364024162, 0.011384560726583004, -0.008426754735410213, 0.021427039057016373, 0.0021883093286305666, 0.022747328504920006, -0.016331637278199196, 0.03905055671930313, -0.025772754102945328, -0.003489807480946183, -0.005138393957167864, -0.002323457272723317, 0.021349744871258736, -0.06208540126681328, 0.02802470698952675, -0.024745849892497063, -0.002782687544822693, 0.021639076992869377, -0.012027704156935215, -0.010668565519154072, -0.028224052861332893, -0.006567816250026226, -0.04095305874943733, 0.0181878674775362, 0.012504802085459232, 0.020577864721417427, -0.0420779325067997, -0.015729747712612152, 0.016343796625733376, -0.057462673634290695, -0.018490372225642204, -0.020883914083242416, -0.062336720526218414, 0.04282352700829506, -0.011491959914565086, 0.0002684518985915929, -0.022717183455824852, -0.011417325586080551, -0.0020769902039319277, -0.06938011199235916, 0.021296070888638496, 0.011764947324991226, -0.004735560622066259, 0.010761905461549759, 0.0044100056402385235, -0.0002205154305556789, -0.010024388320744038, 0.053538933396339417, 0.021223904564976692, -0.013277651742100716, 0.00387988961301744, 0.058360833674669266, 0.016314752399921417, -0.045665591955184937, 0.05602223426103592, 0.005247191991657019, -0.0229023490101099, -0.04084184393286705, -0.04114450141787529, 0.019902922213077545, 0.004457159899175167, 0.031076302751898766, -0.04037400707602501, -0.008080512285232544, 0.007908276282250881, 0.0005851414753124118, 0.018534209579229355, 0.012083806097507477, -0.024072345346212387, 0.0493486262857914, 0.03926987946033478, 0.03611842170357704, 0.012745761312544346, 0.01958617754280567, -0.03976178914308548, -0.011699814349412918, -0.026352455839514732, -0.05468674376606941, -0.008687954396009445, 0.014682069420814514, 0.005242789164185524, -0.07512839883565903, 0.008121692575514317, 0.0549783818423748, -0.03871678560972214, -0.011108883656561375, 0.06084214150905609, 0.01085517555475235, 0.026065243408083916, 0.008773833513259888, 0.04836377874016762, -0.004082315601408482, -0.03583373501896858, 0.018808135762810707, -0.0174997691065073, 0.03592653572559357, -0.011559260077774525, 0.029967810958623886, 0.036129146814346313, -0.0007706502801738679, 0.04812084510922432, -0.005539914593100548, 0.025445345789194107, -0.02519913576543331, 0.017283236607909203, 0.017419995740056038, 0.02326323091983795, 0.012758789584040642, -0.038102973252534866, 0.014743506908416748, 0.04530071094632149, -0.05092161148786545, -0.018734555691480637, -0.06913124769926071, -0.018236743286252022, -0.006663847714662552, -0.02456802874803543, -0.029328620061278343, 0.023745931684970856, 0.005138951353728771, 0.010593938641250134, -0.008436445146799088, -0.01764162816107273, 0.02452583611011505, -0.021738359704613686, -0.00769827701151371, -0.02758011594414711, 0.011889198794960976, 0.03527168184518814, -0.017321081832051277, 0.006344787776470184, -0.0176069475710392, 0.04785897582769394, 0.06628139317035675, 0.049356188625097275, -0.028803395107388496, -0.04543697461485863, -0.0036600667517632246, 0.00919266790151596, -0.06440556049346924, -0.01746024563908577, -0.030865391716361046, -0.024386757984757423, -0.01733752340078354, -0.04003133252263069 ]
<p>I have a set of variables for building credit scorecards with logistic-regression. I need to bin some variables, for e.g. years of credit history. What is the method to determine how many bins and what is the interval for each bin? Thanks</p>
74,284
[ -0.009417707100510597, -0.018346531316637993, -0.029312651604413986, 0.01101496908813715, 0.0447905994951725, -0.02831951342523098, -0.0056025260128080845, 0.000968657317571342, 0.05367410182952881, -0.00034852485987357795, 0.055608246475458145, 0.05831998586654663, 0.021082565188407898, 0.020236553624272346, 0.021145382896065712, 0.0020567697938531637, -0.006646520923823118, 0.022313671186566353, 0.012253649532794952, -0.00935154128819704, 0.006876511964946985, -0.01284690760076046, 0.006182388868182898, 0.007435953710228205, -0.018398066982626915, 0.020014941692352295, 0.025794025510549545, -0.027508612722158432, 0.020300164818763733, 0.05635250732302666, -0.024126926437020302, -0.04729769006371498, 0.050521038472652435, 0.05425085872411728, 0.03564875200390816, -0.02412750944495201, -0.03596414253115654, -0.03592097759246826, -0.048107944428920746, 0.01828322373330593, -0.0620974563062191, -0.03387099876999855, 0.012207653373479843, 0.016437262296676636, -0.01745009794831276, -0.03129655495285988, 0.028289398178458214, -0.03453042358160019, 0.03716801479458809, -0.0418342724442482, 0.07594327628612518, -0.046051058918237686, 0.06857345253229141, 0.029648855328559875, -0.002042953623458743, 0.010987812653183937, 0.05854638293385506, 0.07077251374721527, -0.0157802551984787, -0.060537632554769516, -0.015396449714899063, -0.017341099679470062, 0.0073181805200874805, -0.019609063863754272, -0.03028150647878647, 0.030335785821080208, -0.012165963649749756, -0.02079959213733673, 0.048986077308654785, -0.024340283125638962, -0.01620263233780861, -0.0033850441686809063, 0.017744213342666626, -0.026829423382878304, -0.0026554185897111893, -0.05960547924041748, 0.0419267900288105, 0.01355291809886694, 0.03678064048290253, 0.037186551839113235, -0.011847778223454952, 0.028824953362345695, 0.021116456016898155, 0.005626074969768524, 0.030187368392944336, -0.0352451466023922, 0.08392420411109924, -0.039868324995040894, 0.01994408294558525, 0.021178070455789566, -0.013833928853273392, 0.009350920096039772, 0.03206253796815872, 0.03412775322794914, -0.05571566894650459, 0.07981187850236893, -0.023136140778660774, 0.023426931351423264, 0.00401246128603816, -0.020282110199332237, 0.024715399369597435, -0.035324014723300934, 0.0007165453862398863, 0.0559445284307003, -0.03998822346329689, 0.0021495516411960125, -0.007159315515309572, -0.00964666623622179, 0.02611214853823185, -0.034089285880327225, -0.0218303631991148, 0.02071077935397625, 0.02281724475324154, -0.01490755844861269, 0.027460340410470963, -0.007364616729319096, -0.02091159299015999, -0.024767279624938965, 0.043092675507068634, 0.04771462827920914, 0.012658975087106228, -0.0468318946659565, 0.04660041257739067, 0.019396202638745308, -0.06142691522836685, 0.031107265502214432, 0.025735648348927498, -0.002979429205879569, -0.030754219740629196, 0.04425796866416931, -0.027240870520472527, -0.05234300717711449, 0.05026821419596672, 0.0002939106780104339, 0.003363595111295581, 0.028279293328523636, -0.0633895993232727, -0.03800029680132866, -0.030138270929455757, -0.05150555446743965, 0.010984537191689014, -0.03016744554042816, 0.011630757711827755, 0.0425538569688797, 0.04648957774043083, 0.037702422589063644, 0.023534592241048813, 0.02594887837767601, 0.020527444779872894, 0.048210225999355316, -0.02241549827158451, -0.010734782554209232, -0.030620455741882324, 0.006410044617950916, 0.005868763197213411, -0.054779935628175735, 0.032955944538116455, 0.017388252541422844, 0.0032047287095338106, -0.018890943378210068, 0.012160816229879856, 0.03214677795767784, -0.014661545865237713, -0.0281236469745636, 0.016621550545096397, -0.02330072969198227, 0.079165980219841, -0.012938005849719048, 0.03961994871497154, 0.01837005279958248, -0.0213340912014246, -0.024003196507692337, 0.014154358766973019, 0.04557393118739128, 0.07033552974462509, -0.011070643551647663, -0.028481367975473404, -0.03111553192138672, 0.012592259794473648, -0.01386881060898304, -0.03083304688334465, -0.028915351256728172, 0.015461631119251251, 0.004318834748119116, 0.02701149880886078, 0.008299069479107857, -0.002355903387069702, -0.04859250783920288, -0.01049292553216219, -0.026836266741156578, -0.002349874936044216, -0.06905925273895264, 0.0030366703867912292, 0.0054937428794801235, -0.015029937960207462, 0.007355809677392244, 0.006381284445524216, 0.022114312276244164, -0.014028267934918404, -0.020516594871878624, -0.053384266793727875, -0.01154719665646553, 0.032430898398160934, -0.07720351219177246, 0.002432439476251602, 0.03180629387497902, 0.05133288353681564, -0.0073800464160740376, 0.07875380665063858, -0.044237785041332245, -0.02014848403632641, 0.021320302039384842, -0.03733859583735466, 0.027865123003721237, -0.02310226298868656, -0.005090545862913132, 0.011009803973138332, -0.016911501064896584, -0.008147962391376495, 0.023415252566337585, -0.025875264778733253, 0.05474701151251793, 0.07492973655462265, 0.02095882222056389, 0.000553568301256746, -0.021270262077450752, -0.007291859481483698, 0.017930034548044205, -0.02378610335290432, -0.033728618174791336, -0.054022375494241714, 0.0035490496084094048, 0.013073591515421867, 0.021262411028146744, -0.0015871013747528195, 0.012057159096002579, 0.04375189170241356, 0.027362385764718056, 0.004585100803524256, 0.028919799253344536, -0.008213101886212826, -0.00016528848209418356, 0.0012351124314591289, 0.020256035029888153, -0.004913228563964367, 0.009655003435909748, 0.04466898366808891, 0.020964087918400764, 0.03800109401345253, 0.012636766768991947, -0.013513363897800446, 0.03672410920262337, -0.02447873167693615, 0.003755333134904504, -0.03700026124715805, -0.05590958893299103, 0.06856474280357361, -0.01870686374604702, -0.0065238457173109055, 0.05988653749227524, 0.025279423221945763, 0.0003817746473941952, 0.03439173847436905, 0.01480227429419756, 0.015120288357138634, 0.06814666837453842, -0.06916262209415436, -0.01226799190044403, 0.018785672262310982, -0.03281934931874275, 0.04479723423719406, -0.009292373433709145, -0.05741697922348976, -0.039387550204992294, 0.029530389234423637, 0.019870661199092865, 0.015832841396331787, 0.038607724010944366, 0.03248992934823036, -0.039508722722530365, 0.0008230596431531012, -0.011090099811553955, 0.009288794361054897, -0.018601519986987114, -0.06853526085615158, -0.01673140935599804, 0.021054381504654884, -0.011216745711863041, 0.021908000111579895, -0.013816781342029572, -0.039808839559555054, 0.0277432631701231, -0.008001245558261871, -0.0315711572766304, 0.00795133225619793, 0.016016710549592972, 0.015053740702569485, -0.01346757635474205, -0.006993284914642572, 0.02228022739291191, 0.030822444707155228, -0.07074541598558426, 0.00042748343548737466, -0.04728429391980171, -0.010102066211402416, -0.05367976054549217, -0.022393522784113884, 0.004940921440720558, -0.009433102793991566, -0.02237721160054207, 0.047715507447719574, -0.005454708822071552, 0.006940754596143961, -0.05000479891896248, -0.07686346024274826, 0.007637050934135914, 0.008221005089581013, 0.0022320658899843693, -0.011437661945819855, -0.01544501818716526, 0.05099492892622948, 0.03783021494746208, 0.0014557825634256005, -0.05955955386161804, -0.025590669363737106, 0.0012155851582065225, 0.0007441174820996821, 0.007681865710765123, -0.0037918626330792904, 0.012075059115886688, 0.00987071543931961, 0.004421814810484648, 0.009949304163455963, 0.04995759204030037, 0.019542545080184937, 0.03122711554169655, 0.009618286043405533, -0.003234821604564786, -0.038078438490629196, 0.024484271183609962, 0.0077642230316996574, -0.02308063767850399, 0.016820617020130157, -0.02186247706413269, 0.03870828449726105, 0.042680539190769196, -0.02311074174940586, 0.016162347048521042, -0.03517196327447891, 0.0011200200533494353, -0.004491681233048439, -0.014581459574401379, 0.005679460242390633, -0.029399864375591278, 0.005278594791889191, 0.023701602593064308, 0.023605218157172203, -0.02764768712222576, 0.003748822258785367, 0.011014241725206375, 0.03501178324222565, -0.031242238357663155, 0.007005811203271151, 0.01765631139278412, -0.03684651479125023, 0.037260930985212326, -0.046882592141628265, -0.016234111040830612, 0.021018046885728836, 0.015146642923355103, 0.008560276590287685, 0.005612702574580908, -0.04984024539589882, 0.023013578727841377, -0.07479589432477951, 0.005250765476375818, -0.003813438583165407, 0.04914005473256111, 0.02935013920068741, 0.03164186328649521, 0.017085913568735123, -0.05265619978308678, 0.026684090495109558, 0.0028655556961894035, -0.03673698753118515, 0.04287621006369591, -0.010545280762016773, 0.004959807265549898, -0.027956487610936165, 0.0018860441632568836, 0.06636442244052887, -0.0359610877931118, 0.0015006959438323975, -0.014156524091959, 0.016340134665369987, -0.03258553519845009, 0.003750471631065011, -0.02467975579202175, -0.006175221875309944, 0.008780821226537228, 0.008397802710533142, 0.0052019585855305195, -0.0033963576424866915, 0.021631993353366852, 0.05186090245842934, 0.025111304596066475, 0.01635698974132538, -0.004028061404824257, -0.011016683652997017, 0.015527184121310711, 0.05460945516824722, 0.022827014327049255, 0.008538458496332169, -0.03597548231482506, 0.021643249318003654, -0.03204246237874031, 0.04247225075960159, 0.05843083932995796, -0.013969272375106812, -0.012182295322418213, -0.0264256801456213, 0.014751672744750977, 0.007806761190295219, -0.006249580066651106, -0.0030651455745100975, 0.025346586480736732, 0.06158869341015816, 0.030605122447013855, -0.07079005986452103, 0.00292143109254539, 0.10269416868686676, 0.013776354491710663, -0.01289309561252594, -0.007324493024498224, 0.023966535925865173, -0.0048280986957252026, -0.014095798134803772, 0.011408396996557713, 0.05141547694802284, -0.017039241269230843, 0.014822112396359444, 0.046425286680459976, -0.021217646077275276, -0.01657644659280777, 0.007617051247507334, 0.022652586922049522, 0.054273974150419235, -0.0253666490316391, -0.07169613242149353, 0.012847117148339748, 0.022205626592040062, 0.048879023641347885, 0.06709863990545273, -0.01910383626818657, -0.07936746627092361, 0.014585476368665695, 0.034959953278303146, 0.015218629501760006, -0.07743072509765625, -0.018746765330433846, -0.0033653622958809137, 0.005032668821513653, 0.0318245030939579, -0.03894616290926933, 0.019381798803806305, -0.028613777831196785, 0.04302547872066498, -0.015803314745426178, -0.006924799177795649, -0.0319189727306366, 0.03298529237508774, -0.0005651048850268126, 0.026248501613736153, -0.019577980041503906, -0.0067214216105639935, -0.02840438485145569, 0.02303125150501728, 0.015280240215361118, 0.07990491390228271, -0.0007347001228481531, -0.014132657088339329, 0.03582321107387543, -0.012130504474043846, -0.01952880620956421, -0.037880051881074905, 0.008269066922366619, 0.0019725714810192585, -0.009909556247293949, 0.021714244037866592, 0.010340527631342411, -0.056692950427532196, -0.010168233886361122, 0.027948101982474327, -0.015870053321123123, 0.028409743681550026, -0.03395027667284012, 0.02201117016375065, -0.0005315292510204017, 0.024172326549887657, 0.05443200469017029, 0.033467285335063934, -0.014251249842345715, 0.0424722284078598, -0.027034053578972816, 0.016847407445311546, -0.023225685581564903, -0.024570582434535027, -0.028969455510377884, -0.0026144571602344513, -0.01986236684024334, 0.024231141433119774, -0.03759021684527397, 0.016736188903450966, -0.01938757300376892, -0.019210103899240494, -0.0254802368581295, 0.047446299344301224, 0.0009214263409376144, -0.009602386504411697, 0.034735601395368576, 0.02290431596338749, -0.008788804523646832, 0.001883188495412469, 0.004391355440020561, -0.03285464271903038, 0.0043470896780490875, 0.0021388644818216562, -0.024908730760216713, 0.026986192911863327, -0.04131125658750534, -0.026448702439665794, -0.009763984009623528, 0.007940798066556454, 0.04392153024673462, -0.0027622547931969166, 0.011585896834731102, 0.009470771998167038, -0.04221034049987793, -0.029350033029913902, 0.003310748841613531, 0.0009118138113990426, 0.05032729730010033, -0.06177252158522606, 0.048032455146312714, -0.018405891954898834, -0.00510123185813427, -0.0664682686328888, -0.09983401745557785, 0.040708765387535095, 0.027268238365650177, -0.033831849694252014, -0.01705963909626007, 0.02954464964568615, 0.008009718731045723, -0.0003851080546155572, -0.05136638879776001, 0.04277870059013367, -0.0069104693830013275, -0.016060350462794304, -0.023571476340293884, 0.009066950529813766, 0.053941067308187485, 0.060157306492328644, 0.006635105703026056, -0.0024860198609530926, -0.032620206475257874, -0.036278143525123596, -0.0021773295011371374, -0.04461923614144325, -0.015280203893780708, -0.015054692514240742, -0.020476900041103363, 0.03475227579474449, 0.019698649644851685, -0.024100029841065407, -0.04178643971681595, -0.02128792367875576, -0.0023603783920407295, 0.008124219253659248, -0.0006837928085587919, 0.008812904357910156, -0.024274416267871857, -0.0016267161117866635, -0.03613407164812088, -0.03246258199214935, -0.022722141817212105, 0.003541188547387719, -0.0077149649150669575, 0.039324842393398285, -0.011985248886048794, 0.019434984773397446, 0.05947374925017357, 0.002618880942463875, -0.007594699040055275, -0.007232432719320059, -0.020301578566432, 0.03380006179213524, 0.020066622644662857, -0.03665349259972572, 0.03330106660723686, 0.012978745624423027, -0.010630014352500439, -0.015922170132398605, -0.055845241993665695, 0.004428607877343893, 0.05766484886407852, -0.01962752267718315, 0.04264327511191368, 0.06835320591926575, 0.015581754967570305, 0.0056341043673455715, -0.03727833926677704, -0.028901057317852974, 0.017850905656814575, -0.0052202739752829075, 0.06325113773345947, -0.000017621885490370914, 0.008535599336028099, 0.015056068077683449, 0.00920419953763485, 0.004768140614032745, 0.038108307868242264, -0.04057031869888306, 0.0035700651351362467, 0.03548669442534447, 0.008486959151923656, -0.019639208912849426, 0.022020816802978516, -0.01741802506148815, -0.013561789877712727, -0.016862111166119576, -0.02053084596991539, 0.032257866114377975, 0.02825246751308441, 0.008732923306524754, -0.045648105442523956, -0.03576425462961197, -0.026600897312164307, 0.006423815619200468, 0.005205557681620121, 0.010989679954946041, 0.041750404983758926, 0.020770233124494553, -0.010074356570839882, -0.008264121599495411, -0.0009679853683337569, 0.007252778857946396, -0.046042218804359436, -0.015574654564261436, -0.055012285709381104, -0.05891365557909012, -0.009692818857729435, 0.03261282294988632, -0.01844647526741028, 0.012534424662590027, -0.007252028211951256, -0.016436176374554634, -0.00005664271884597838, 0.02752741612493992, 0.02983250468969345, 0.09227842092514038, 0.018622001633048058, -0.015097111463546753, -0.005289074033498764, 0.006857780274003744, 0.10652387142181396, 0.11125841736793518, 0.0321093387901783, -0.08466562628746033, -0.002940972801297903, 0.0359843410551548, -0.00535960029810667, -0.03093177080154419, -0.0019133127061650157, -0.014884894713759422, -0.016222022473812103, 0.04581247642636299, 0.013360630720853806, -0.02438063733279705, 0.005406743846833706, 0.05327047035098076, -0.008456956595182419, 0.01713092438876629, -0.0005418702494353056, 0.01884622871875763, -0.010163248516619205, -0.012227359227836132, -0.06228053942322731, 0.02131563052535057, 0.040026720613241196, -0.021814651787281036, -0.005741209257394075, -0.013927419669926167, 0.013540259562432766, -0.00029774405993521214, -0.017978772521018982, -0.008986765518784523, 0.050588205456733704, 0.013956044800579548, 0.003549024695530534, -0.04098730534315109, 0.03751535713672638, -0.019229616969823837, -0.014092469587922096, 0.019586658105254173, -0.02739068679511547, -0.008604691363871098, -0.003097957232967019, -0.00840790569782257, -0.025316057726740837, -0.06051097437739372, -0.04199287295341492, 0.00944461114704609, 0.011888277716934681, 0.004153531976044178, -0.01970977708697319, 0.004810148850083351, 0.03291626274585724, -0.048156481236219406, -0.031106889247894287, 0.04262001812458038, 0.009866573847830296, -0.03226778283715248, -0.0017144769662991166, -0.021305134519934654, 0.008256209082901478, -0.004515955690294504, 0.04738576337695122, 0.002414602553471923, -0.015277749858796597, 0.001979519845917821, -0.05896984785795212, 0.02812003158032894, 0.006689469795674086, -0.013233869336545467, 0.016749944537878036, -0.06110788881778717, -0.034586697816848755, -0.0032769693061709404, 0.023129919543862343, 0.02161366119980812, -0.026087135076522827, -0.007048113737255335, -0.02585131861269474, 0.0012996684527024627, 0.01080084964632988, -0.02852296084165573, -0.007912300527095795, 0.0007871354464441538, -0.018250741064548492, 0.015050972811877728, -0.00030318647623062134, 0.024043245241045952, 0.027424229308962822, 0.03670414909720421, -0.003089361358433962, 0.027243079617619514, 0.022466477006673813, -0.0917840376496315, 0.0208083875477314, -0.00796642154455185, -0.04398520663380623, 0.008568888530135155, -0.04811100661754608, 0.07830120623111725, 0.010073184035718441, 0.04503365978598595, 0.021863844245672226, 0.01919945888221264, -0.011975502595305443, 0.008914202451705933, 0.03139197453856468, -0.05551224946975708, 0.018670789897441864, -0.0015688822604715824, -0.0069366260431706905, -0.05214785039424896, -0.03817945718765259, -0.03982985392212868, -0.016760120168328285, 0.04050799459218979, -0.014850473031401634, -0.06057893484830856, 0.019720997661352158, 0.017745764926075935, -0.04562794789671898, 0.0015259220963343978, -0.003636172041296959, -0.04775359854102135, 0.01660081557929516, -0.00853562168776989, -0.004521274473518133, 0.018953723832964897, -0.0003119568573310971, -0.02226388081908226, -0.01756000891327858, 0.0561971515417099, 0.03771049901843071, 0.040479693561792374, -0.007053090259432793, 0.015103882178664207, 0.013528789393603802, 0.011349648237228394, -0.025405393913388252, -0.009577183984220028, 0.0033156140707433224, -0.044275496155023575, 0.0017640000442042947, 0.008787454105913639, 0.007294353563338518, 0.03289690986275673, 0.037601009011268616, 0.014973520301282406, -0.038886658847332, 0.01491205021739006, -0.003212464740499854, -0.024187585338950157, -0.010300889611244202, 0.05357078090310097, -0.021403683349490166, 0.026479676365852356, -0.022246884182095528, 0.02246680110692978, -0.041538696736097336, 0.01139377523213625, 0.0522654727101326, 0.012112289667129517, -0.0015420124400407076, 0.00009142424823949113, 0.0015919804573059082, 0.0246416162699461, 0.007331753149628639, -0.020102104172110558, 0.03340005502104759, 0.06832481920719147, -0.011393819004297256, 0.04317426681518555, -0.012201763689517975, 0.024550195783376694, -0.09640559554100037, -0.007793833035975695, 0.008179378695786, 0.00675288075581193, 0.016345404088497162, -0.04711470752954483, 0.005471295211464167, 0.018779003992676735, -0.013659977354109287, 0.011826514266431332, 0.017380699515342712, 0.017137998715043068, -0.006606207229197025, -0.01715887524187565, 0.009045563638210297, -0.0034079428296536207, 0.027981087565422058, 0.005867449566721916, 0.05561118200421333, 0.014075427316129208, -0.02116972766816616, -0.042197201400995255, -0.006567171309143305, -0.002847430296242237, -0.0012971720425412059, -0.07380650192499161, 0.029327746480703354, -0.03398234397172928, -0.02427413873374462, 0.05053209140896797, -0.016155345365405083, 0.023985320702195168, 0.05992425978183746, 0.036340802907943726, 0.0180429108440876, 0.05448099225759506, 0.03910749405622482, -0.01923386938869953, 0.004635819233953953, -0.0029486287385225296, 0.024411773309111595, 0.009655661880970001, -0.03680798411369324, 0.010796771384775639, 0.04261841997504234, -0.016244998201727867, -0.07831551134586334, 0.029187297448515892, -0.010505886748433113, 0.010297398082911968, -0.019980236887931824, -0.019025757908821106, -0.010177564807236195, -0.04186788201332092, 0.0144420200958848, -0.0323265939950943, -0.01332241203635931, 0.030940011143684387, -0.016219500452280045, -0.012997320853173733, 0.01067047193646431, -0.027607014402747154, -0.049365460872650146, -0.011871164664626122, 0.014287823811173439, -0.027559669688344002, -0.05526233837008476, -0.0038214230444282293, 0.024467144161462784, -0.0007446440868079662, -0.029072057455778122, -0.01513378880918026, -0.046149976551532745, 0.024173419922590256, -0.043515391647815704, -0.009752638638019562, 0.058348070830106735, -0.012450451962649822, 0.02631782367825508, -0.08570083230733871, 0.05828310549259186, 0.008159331046044827, -0.016488518565893173, -0.035662468522787094, -0.023533618077635765, -0.018662072718143463, -0.008990166708827019, 0.0688069686293602, -0.011936374939978123, -0.00026855990290641785, -0.056423820555210114, 0.016701482236385345, 0.006187798455357552, -0.04324490204453468, 0.01578342728316784, 0.0006955937133170664, -0.04909292981028557, -0.02167838253080845, -0.030202055349946022, 0.010332989506423473, 0.001995252911001444, 0.030472680926322937, 0.012749552726745605, 0.015610827133059502, 0.011260299012064934, -0.03753209114074707, 0.005766297224909067, 0.005242571234703064, -0.03999325633049011, 0.025293448939919472, -0.00762030016630888, 0.02448340319097042, 0.020243389531970024, -0.006635702680796385, -0.08926445245742798, 0.03644828125834465, -0.00811559148132801, -0.005392779596149921, 0.012326817028224468, 0.03402304649353027, -0.014147482812404633, -0.07161202281713486, 0.01081096101552248, 0.0444423072040081, -0.03954431042075157, 0.016776632517576218, 0.030245304107666016, -0.014391439966857433, 0.03905542939901352, -0.02357826940715313, 0.011784907430410385, 0.021169716492295265, -0.0314803421497345, 0.0079102274030447, 0.019644325599074364, 0.011847523041069508, 0.019663667306303978, 0.009008905850350857, 0.010678685270249844, 0.014889954589307308, 0.00809516292065382, 0.017960265278816223, 0.02199864201247692, -0.02031383477151394, -0.0009953348198905587, -0.014617625623941422, -0.028851576149463654, 0.04366326332092285, 0.031800318509340286, -0.013325638137757778, 0.05508420243859291, -0.04884055629372597, 0.020708341151475906, -0.023027807474136353, -0.008758666925132275, -0.0615205243229866, 0.006428050808608532, 0.014809914864599705, 0.04737357795238495, 0.015532491728663445, -0.0027980732265859842, 0.00755239836871624, -0.002331295982003212, 0.043005283921957016, 0.005228104535490274, 0.019400622695684433, -0.01264230441302061, 0.024305211380124092, -0.02479473501443863, 0.0018174313008785248, -0.05894870311021805, -0.03505073860287666, 0.008068920113146305, 0.016123978421092033, 0.035714905709028244, -0.004096705932170153, -0.008195418864488602, -0.024380138143897057, 0.005679967813193798, -0.04902274161577225, -0.0049517503939569, -0.06171375885605812, 0.003366651013493538, -0.009716624394059181, -0.0157247856259346 ]
<p>So, when I did first year stats in undergrad, we did an experiment where we tampered with a bunch of coins, to see if it would cause a statistical difference in the results. This is a graph of the ratio of $heads:tosses$ for each series of flips:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/0KGkp.png" alt="coin tosses"></p> <p>We took the full data set in each case, and found that there were no significant differences from a null hypothesis of 50% heads.</p> <p>Had we stopped at 100 flips, or 150 flips we would have probably concluded that the Cupped coin was significantly biased. Would this have been invalid, and why? In particular, does it mean anything that the ratio is outside the 95% confidence interval more than 5% of the time?</p>
74,285
[ -0.033385805785655975, -0.021428581327199936, 0.013039863668382168, -0.016153384000062943, 0.04595489054918289, 0.021305983886122704, 0.0009210706339217722, -0.01900278590619564, -0.003326339880004525, -0.007920880801975727, 0.06251610070466995, 0.05214500054717064, 0.03335751220583916, 0.041560444980859756, 0.004678269382566214, 0.014603767544031143, 0.0064788516610860825, -0.0052375877276062965, 0.01404557004570961, -0.005878203082829714, -0.010510014370083809, 0.017311856150627136, -0.03676757216453552, -0.022357027977705002, -0.02991144359111786, 0.002279222011566162, 0.04394877329468727, -0.016262739896774292, 0.006860650610178709, 0.03197263926267624, -0.01897975616157055, -0.02731200121343136, 0.058448147028684616, 0.002288657473400235, 0.058872826397418976, -0.013293215073645115, -0.0005050206673331559, -0.03668447211384773, 0.008484848774969578, 0.046366121619939804, -0.051340192556381226, 0.024373937398195267, 0.017982786521315575, 0.04180588200688362, 0.016834428533911705, 0.027860917150974274, 0.025646617636084557, -0.051807720214128494, 0.02189854346215725, -0.023274505510926247, 0.04997580498456955, 0.004002079833298922, 0.04348364844918251, 0.03318402171134949, 0.02030963823199272, 0.020514383912086487, 0.05101357772946358, 0.047694139182567596, -0.04964018240571022, -0.07036493718624115, -0.030051223933696747, -0.05694825202226639, -0.019278354942798615, -0.002992859575897455, -0.033165544271469116, 0.020717643201351166, -0.01880258321762085, -0.03622474521398544, 0.015942947939038277, -0.0009302996331825852, 0.022707724943757057, 0.020369773730635643, 0.03130482882261276, -0.004572815727442503, -0.006506165489554405, -0.02521679736673832, 0.04850626736879349, 0.012362627312541008, 0.023045245558023453, 0.06297089904546738, 0.016286706551909447, -0.009947446174919605, 0.041634805500507355, 0.055599842220544815, 0.03303276002407074, 0.01573038101196289, 0.06304193288087845, -0.048804864287376404, 0.03604581952095032, 0.023399649187922478, -0.0069006942212581635, -0.001527315122075379, 0.029993511736392975, -0.003456170903518796, -0.044024836272001266, 0.013478726148605347, -0.011389817111194134, 0.01564609445631504, -0.02154482528567314, 0.005269514862447977, -0.01361799892038107, 0.003429777454584837, 0.02074153907597065, 0.05523088201880455, -0.018160082399845123, -0.01803436689078808, -0.014090379700064659, 0.01449577882885933, -0.021163467317819595, -0.012971555814146996, 0.00889047421514988, 0.0608646422624588, 0.005327572114765644, 0.051932308822870255, 0.011661714874207973, -0.0015631573041900992, -0.031185870990157127, -0.03585086762905121, 0.04645498842000961, -0.003927060402929783, 0.018493402749300003, -0.022513777017593384, 0.05576838180422783, -0.054720114916563034, -0.011876053176820278, 0.012096382677555084, 0.04201335087418556, 0.01673891767859459, -0.05508195608854294, 0.05674527958035469, 0.0027855336666107178, -0.017050612717866898, 0.030771566554903984, -0.009325907565653324, 0.04788318648934364, -0.022521965205669403, -0.09553936868906021, -0.07468529045581818, 0.043189819902181625, 0.037259459495544434, -0.01790451630949974, -0.09232692420482635, -0.00831653457134962, 0.029564734548330307, 0.044304732233285904, -0.011993423104286194, 0.050232917070388794, -0.04521791636943817, 0.02852729707956314, 0.038765888661146164, -0.021944647654891014, -0.005967976991087198, 0.008310970850288868, -0.046706538647413254, -0.026503635570406914, -0.05513107031583786, 0.030290652066469193, 0.03119577467441559, -0.0038141226395964622, -0.0353967659175396, -0.0239583570510149, -0.03586874529719353, 0.00012651100405491889, 0.010576682165265083, -0.012834237888455391, -0.007619192358106375, 0.10579779744148254, 0.004790251608937979, 0.02156936377286911, 0.006862776353955269, -0.033587779849767685, 0.03578905388712883, -0.0002980519784614444, 0.025132060050964355, 0.04728321358561516, -0.011497080326080322, 0.03661464899778366, -0.012694373726844788, 0.016820719465613365, -0.015192197635769844, -0.01222055871039629, 0.03740980103611946, 0.00638806214556098, 0.011063320562243462, 0.029178844764828682, -0.007909024134278297, 0.0031344208400696516, -0.036746785044670105, 0.005613692104816437, -0.05559452250599861, -0.03591164946556091, -0.08300452679395676, -0.03729858249425888, -0.02659601904451847, -0.03201669082045555, 0.02569490484893322, -0.029688002541661263, 0.002803254872560501, -0.02965262532234192, -0.028282638639211655, 0.018097206950187683, 0.010221215896308422, 0.05616429075598717, -0.021722273901104927, -0.015162208117544651, 0.06382086127996445, 0.0031828677747398615, -0.01636413298547268, 0.029504496604204178, -0.037498001009225845, -0.021128812804818153, -0.0023501284886151552, -0.026052001863718033, -0.03001578152179718, 0.026468561962246895, 0.00808016024529934, 0.03264646232128143, 0.003511162707582116, -0.017556309700012207, 0.02167036198079586, -0.04091872274875641, 0.05337716266512871, 0.023430779576301575, -0.0012894715182483196, 0.013886152766644955, 0.0005969363846816123, 0.03274747356772423, 0.006859554909169674, 0.026618855074048042, -0.04301076754927635, -0.04254929721355438, 0.011390775442123413, 0.0015666461549699306, -0.007474859710782766, -0.01596999354660511, 0.023947590962052345, 0.030529361218214035, 0.003674873849377036, 0.002252987353131175, 0.0015475478721782565, 0.014578718692064285, -0.03260575607419014, -0.03736083209514618, 0.005809813737869263, 0.01732710376381874, 0.0598503015935421, 0.02006020024418831, 0.002325355773791671, 0.015608778223395348, 0.057405050843954086, 0.00871703214943409, 0.04912184923887253, -0.029458722099661827, 0.006752256769686937, 0.02063191495835781, 0.010566932149231434, 0.0325046107172966, -0.02296292409300804, -0.009056692942976952, 0.01162030454725027, 0.009166782721877098, -0.01707896776497364, -0.028843538835644722, 0.0044796885922551155, 0.02889314480125904, 0.06337021291255951, -0.025939103215932846, 0.014021066017448902, 0.0181255005300045, -0.02465503104031086, -0.018383823335170746, -0.006208785343915224, -0.011812853626906872, -0.014405532740056515, 0.01624167338013649, 0.06303121894598007, 0.02024037577211857, 0.025551410391926765, -0.05299977958202362, -0.04637645557522774, -0.00752693135291338, 0.007419935893267393, 0.020885808393359184, 0.008112175390124321, -0.067897267639637, 0.007337908260524273, -0.02514035627245903, 0.020101670175790787, -0.022856131196022034, -0.0409134216606617, 0.03365852311253548, 0.019268786534667015, 0.014140862040221691, -0.021158890798687935, -0.013509167358279228, -0.012674248777329922, 0.008934113197028637, -0.04350099712610245, -0.041997432708740234, 0.03787372261285782, 0.02975533716380596, 0.015127947553992271, 0.04885168746113777, -0.016526589170098305, -0.03280593454837799, -0.02459096908569336, 0.005224763881415129, 0.0066201831214129925, 0.01605233922600746, 0.000987237086519599, 0.017322007566690445, 0.008751342073082924, -0.03438357636332512, -0.08318547159433365, -0.09014467895030975, -0.020742224529385567, 0.0009425430907867849, 0.013326453045010567, 0.011794766411185265, -0.01005858089774847, 0.08622248470783234, 0.053103361278772354, -0.033763691782951355, -0.03494530916213989, -0.023818297311663628, -0.0336323156952858, -0.013941249810159206, 0.001091456855647266, 0.027015427127480507, 0.007023020181804895, 0.019116146489977837, -0.013567128218710423, 0.03643004968762398, 0.017432859167456627, -0.014365932904183865, -0.02182406187057495, 0.03052365593612194, -0.00016744736058171839, -0.023952892050147057, 0.03518466651439667, 0.01819525472819805, -0.04923566058278084, -0.020052552223205566, 0.001673353835940361, 0.03953832760453224, 0.019747931510210037, -0.06472817808389664, 0.03955793380737305, -0.03689384087920189, 0.038181789219379425, -0.01064027938991785, 0.054875101894140244, -0.00396845955401659, 0.011053884401917458, -0.028723273426294327, -0.008641806431114674, 0.026364194229245186, -0.029666541144251823, 0.04252754524350166, 0.04592928662896156, -0.003523492254316807, -0.011605159379541874, -0.01940392330288887, -0.008158212527632713, -0.007403955329209566, 0.035161565989255905, -0.048226118087768555, -0.034269317984580994, 0.05032322183251381, 0.05713481456041336, 0.015649339184165, -0.03097863495349884, -0.05522328242659569, 0.04253889620304108, -0.06296226382255554, 0.021180633455514908, -0.025281820446252823, 0.033479444682598114, -0.004286053124815226, 0.03730389103293419, 0.02427428960800171, -0.03561706840991974, -0.04729526489973068, -0.00999379437416792, -0.06754624098539352, 0.027539541944861412, -0.009703525342047215, -0.042881984263658524, -0.03399234637618065, -0.024976316839456558, 0.042273033410310745, -0.04028826951980591, 0.030306154862046242, -0.02412290684878826, 0.0036902676802128553, -0.007394222542643547, 0.0192435160279274, -0.0271336380392313, -0.02673753909766674, 0.005529416259378195, 0.022603655233979225, 0.03907710686326027, -0.017737464979290962, 0.05566917732357979, 0.0010364602785557508, -0.009603885933756828, -0.01495034247636795, -0.036329485476017, -0.0013703942531719804, 0.02475467137992382, 0.04309030622243881, 0.03184610232710838, 0.02295253798365593, -0.08591416478157043, 0.04600374773144722, 0.026408711448311806, 0.07126209884881973, 0.06300566345453262, -0.020184550434350967, -0.02476087398827076, -0.03336247429251671, -0.01810409501194954, 0.01339024305343628, 0.015666918829083443, 0.006077100522816181, -0.024844229221343994, 0.06972929835319519, 0.01601800136268139, -0.05281408131122589, 0.026608189567923546, 0.043567631393671036, 0.016206666827201843, 0.02074049785733223, -0.06037925183773041, 0.010408973321318626, -0.01810321770608425, -0.02701057493686676, 0.015006298199295998, -0.0039161574095487595, 0.010728069581091404, 0.010678278282284737, 0.06681298464536667, -0.001956900581717491, -0.03733630105853081, 0.036342695355415344, -0.004213947337120771, 0.040688980370759964, -0.006323207635432482, 0.004217225126922131, 0.05812210217118263, 0.03192950412631035, 0.020350981503725052, 0.03907485678792, -0.022554002702236176, -0.0238795168697834, 0.027489827945828438, 0.060555726289749146, 0.0586475245654583, -0.04953034594655037, 0.021362684667110443, -0.007778088096529245, 0.028081487864255905, 0.04168656840920448, -0.0486876517534256, 0.04114260897040367, -0.008033421821892262, 0.01579243876039982, -0.041499584913253784, -0.04084707051515579, -0.05169647932052612, 0.006196116097271442, -0.02759562060236931, 0.011117846705019474, -0.030509700998663902, -0.04456445947289467, -0.016963118687272072, -0.02052411064505577, 0.02872583083808422, 0.043280478566884995, -0.03421022742986679, -0.004042681306600571, -0.019092246890068054, -0.01307943370193243, -0.00019062834326177835, -0.08586981147527695, 0.027485454455018044, -0.024385817348957062, 0.02038823999464512, 0.04956158250570297, 0.009395143017172813, -0.0024286634288728237, 0.026098966598510742, 0.012456702999770641, 0.0028006243519484997, 0.008703168481588364, -0.02573586069047451, 0.0557914562523365, 0.03454197943210602, 0.004350434057414532, 0.029772836714982986, 0.018102731555700302, 0.026069797575473785, -0.005738480947911739, -0.04636995494365692, 0.0287878829985857, -0.04978599026799202, 0.01139419712126255, -0.04089009016752243, -0.03077901154756546, -0.04212896525859833, 0.007513983175158501, 0.03903420642018318, 0.05956599861383438, -0.03569716587662697, -0.0102410688996315, -0.020361915230751038, 0.0119208674877882, 0.011463762260973454, -0.01599407196044922, -0.021389855071902275, 0.00862483773380518, 0.005365920718759298, 0.005213920027017593, -0.005562098231166601, -0.0243263840675354, 0.008371255360543728, 0.044502079486846924, -0.02507675252854824, 0.01688842847943306, -0.0600363090634346, -0.021953916177153587, -0.005033873021602631, -0.02264460176229477, 0.030384302139282227, -0.01880708895623684, 0.011013095267117023, 0.011381156742572784, -0.022479817271232605, -0.015517251566052437, 0.0220026895403862, -0.014480703510344028, 0.02992292493581772, -0.03012462705373764, 0.03607723116874695, -0.012653087265789509, 0.01397218182682991, -0.047804150730371475, -0.05196906626224518, 0.006394590251147747, 0.013845732435584068, -0.048517268151044846, 0.004125712905079126, -0.025425177067518234, 0.006183501798659563, -0.029007213190197945, -0.0210943091660738, 0.054872483015060425, -0.05459929257631302, -0.014126249589025974, -0.01760416105389595, -0.024602293968200684, 0.11013171076774597, -0.02439124323427677, -0.009466174989938736, 0.008356461301445961, -0.022503765299916267, -0.020112644881010056, 0.02911403775215149, 0.00597601430490613, -0.03137129172682762, -0.017269443720579147, -0.0029795558657497168, 0.02266613021492958, 0.00985824316740036, -0.015458609908819199, -0.02090700902044773, 0.007953292690217495, -0.016899386420845985, 0.05117439106106758, 0.001116779400035739, -0.020143773406744003, -0.012960469350218773, -0.012793286703526974, 0.0010584663832560182, 0.019432205706834793, 0.03009660355746746, -0.008335133083164692, 0.036653146147727966, 0.04190288484096527, -0.027537405490875244, 0.02994818426668644, 0.07404376566410065, -0.032012682408094406, -0.006002424284815788, -0.018716324120759964, -0.0464530885219574, 0.008585704490542412, 0.0268551018089056, 0.001346629112958908, 0.016153831034898758, -0.010751698166131973, -0.053713638335466385, 0.009463092312216759, -0.027996687218546867, 0.00014832321903668344, 0.06681288778781891, 0.04413077235221863, 0.026944750919938087, 0.021877232939004898, -0.016821708530187607, -0.00741716381162405, -0.03236548230051994, -0.001745905145071447, 0.0025895903818309307, 0.005224049557000399, 0.007339489180594683, -0.011544001288712025, 0.02074662409722805, 0.05126471817493439, 0.018511585891246796, -0.005529308691620827, 0.05485650897026062, 0.026208102703094482, 0.00007502616062993184, 0.018508082255721092, -0.004282069858163595, -0.03448427841067314, 0.039944831281900406, -0.04877477511763573, 0.001443797373212874, -0.06765583902597427, -0.03934083878993988, 0.03097943589091301, -0.00260275905020535, -0.018981104716658592, -0.02718486450612545, 0.005557268857955933, -0.0707399919629097, -0.04730210080742836, -0.0013340639416128397, -0.004429896827787161, 0.05039241164922714, -0.025322163477540016, 0.025601457804441452, -0.006513489410281181, 0.02804982289671898, -0.04147174954414368, -0.10394337773323059, -0.030144376680254936, 0.00033761351369321346, -0.02122148685157299, -0.002024744637310505, -0.04779887571930885, -0.02442907728254795, 0.021274438127875328, -0.057842910289764404, -0.008815957233309746, -0.010588614270091057, 0.007109517697244883, -0.03215406462550163, 0.04088354855775833, 0.031729597598314285, 0.0469256192445755, -0.016552239656448364, -0.02189129963517189, 0.12067366391420364, 0.053748197853565216, 0.020269669592380524, -0.01991860195994377, 0.04291284456849098, -0.010441702790558338, 0.023771457374095917, -0.005865756422281265, 0.04073920100927353, -0.023230675607919693, 0.01583806611597538, 0.038785941898822784, 0.0387004129588604, 0.04380720481276512, -0.0023226274643093348, 0.05027461051940918, -0.00007142822141759098, -0.0113067040219903, -0.005201779305934906, -0.013518181629478931, -0.017812807112932205, -0.017944931983947754, -0.03191230446100235, 0.01731651835143566, -0.012791833840310574, -0.03253724053502083, 0.03298903629183769, -0.01223430223762989, -0.0083271199837327, 0.05277375504374504, -0.024368958547711372, 0.013097363524138927, 0.015049399808049202, 0.008107987232506275, -0.05069763585925102, 0.0008505645673722029, 0.029608123004436493, -0.03160110116004944, 0.00403788685798645, 0.033765293657779694, 0.014913630671799183, -0.002491116290912032, 0.022579234093427658, 0.041737254709005356, -0.04871091619133949, -0.043202199041843414, -0.03572382405400276, 0.03999384865164757, 0.004035829100757837, 0.00861758179962635, -0.02495044283568859, -0.04332907125353813, -0.018103860318660736, -0.035065826028585434, -0.010992578230798244, 0.0008732206770218909, -0.0037525135558098555, -0.028662685304880142, -0.02476619742810726, -0.012222078628838062, 0.022836681455373764, -0.00859560165554285, 0.050686173141002655, 0.014644429087638855, -0.006537189707159996, -0.031550340354442596, 0.0068744164891541, 0.06047707423567772, 0.006894409190863371, -0.006115428172051907, 0.01914423145353794, 0.004285846836864948, -0.02091764099895954, 0.011861501261591911, 0.031482402235269547, 0.004684994462877512, 0.028716925531625748, 0.005977274384349585, -0.011422938667237759, -0.013980383984744549, -0.03617485612630844, 0.04354451224207878, -0.03176058828830719, -0.008357672020792961, -0.026782726868987083, -0.029170993715524673, 0.02254682034254074, 0.01707807369530201, 0.003674411913380027, -0.009077414870262146, 0.006738824769854546, 0.04762539640069008, 0.018646368756890297, -0.03186551481485367, -0.009229778312146664, -0.020088519901037216, -0.04076463356614113, -0.03315681591629982, -0.0260885301977396, 0.06028549745678902, 0.03249369189143181, 0.018677081912755966, 0.02433147467672825, 0.006559364032000303, 0.03707421198487282, 0.015832779929041862, 0.014657402411103249, -0.06399586796760559, -0.009442653506994247, 0.0360616110265255, -0.012126960791647434, -0.02830871380865574, -0.0696655735373497, -0.052621036767959595, -0.004010767675936222, 0.0004588270385283977, -0.019239678978919983, -0.024441508576273918, -0.025741197168827057, 0.02123660407960415, -0.02142057940363884, 0.018193945288658142, 0.011845007538795471, -0.04651829972863197, -0.049286097288131714, 0.03165208175778389, -0.008251558057963848, 0.043700989335775375, 0.006482226308435202, 0.008592816069722176, 0.028423093259334564, 0.027660731226205826, -0.018833301961421967, 0.008137045428156853, -0.04139646142721176, 0.011790276505053043, 0.02410569228231907, 0.012193329632282257, -0.04106207564473152, -0.009383823722600937, 0.06592153012752533, -0.059725478291511536, -0.027035417035222054, 0.013643020763993263, 0.00764352735131979, 0.001954405102878809, 0.008368676528334618, 0.007858227007091045, -0.0070463428273797035, 0.05417715758085251, -0.03631524741649628, -0.012508554384112358, -0.0023354697041213512, 0.006717929616570473, 0.027116896584630013, 0.0010335659608244896, 0.00786428339779377, 0.011610014364123344, 0.032727889716625214, 0.03765983507037163, 0.03381608799099922, 0.025651395320892334, -0.0067974296398460865, -0.03113238327205181, 0.014286153949797153, 0.012296819128096104, -0.02423333004117012, -0.006082628853619099, 0.0012874845415353775, 0.01847408339381218, -0.05020434409379959, 0.03817396238446236, -0.014439087361097336, 0.01287065353244543, -0.09925111383199692, -0.012779103592038155, 0.013691459782421589, 0.028489476069808006, -0.001005279365926981, -0.05157066509127617, 0.015755899250507355, 0.032655514776706696, -0.0624675489962101, 0.03168754652142525, -0.04426918551325798, -0.03214101865887642, -0.050138942897319794, -0.0022360242437571287, -0.016545426100492477, -0.007417446002364159, 0.00732171256095171, -0.0225941501557827, 0.0265181977301836, -0.002221763599663973, 0.008146910928189754, 0.029443582519888878, -0.002594337100163102, 0.038251835852861404, -0.01771516352891922, -0.05414532497525215, 0.020246019586920738, -0.01826607808470726, -0.03316677361726761, 0.02797836996614933, 0.00853608176112175, 0.029329383745789528, -0.021511614322662354, 0.03078353777527809, 0.010397600010037422, 0.03150179609656334, 0.036296043545007706, 0.010757815092802048, 0.01870543509721756, 0.00791134312748909, 0.008489859290421009, 0.03914167732000351, 0.010039620101451874, -0.009570769034326077, -0.0025846711359918118, -0.04878687858581543, -0.013563141226768494, -0.020020682364702225, -0.005463995970785618, -0.003855715738609433, 0.010597333312034607, 0.008762612007558346, 0.023350726813077927, -0.01124755572527647, 0.04889815300703049, -0.06720899045467377, -0.02796010673046112, 0.045094139873981476, 0.0005064699216745794, -0.03620085492730141, -0.00036385335261002183, -0.040328141301870346, -0.012033195234835148, -0.005313047673553228, 0.019894521683454514, -0.02377718687057495, -0.04346315562725067, -0.004522594157606363, -0.012620026245713234, 0.03794509544968605, 0.017533782869577408, 0.009665182791650295, -0.02639717422425747, 0.030056117102503777, -0.005328388884663582, 0.006071834824979305, 0.013941274955868721, -0.010924545116722584, -0.018094874918460846, -0.07910437881946564, 0.05462435260415077, -0.018629588186740875, -0.013161789625883102, -0.038502227514982224, 0.006534401327371597, -0.01063811220228672, 0.005889107473194599, 0.023982152342796326, 0.05184055119752884, -0.019742533564567566, 0.027792982757091522, -0.009480971843004227, 0.03352563828229904, -0.08306964486837387, 0.05866431072354317, -0.012607123702764511, 0.028196359053254128, -0.0013914076844230294, -0.009277869947254658, 0.0006263789837248623, 0.024455860257148743, 0.002497006906196475, 0.020977647975087166, 0.020998528227210045, 0.02223452739417553, -0.03188561275601387, 0.05414283648133278, 0.023701276630163193, -0.002902099397033453, 0.06981990486383438, 0.045180339366197586, 0.012981710024178028, -0.0018946692580357194, -0.004235300235450268, -0.04822564125061035, 0.03958897292613983, 0.005402803886681795, -0.013477188535034657, -0.014643761329352856, 0.011185937561094761, -0.04579676687717438, -0.027892200276255608, -0.00872002448886633, 0.008872704580426216, -0.040735337883234024, -0.0060968860052526, 0.01047708559781313, 0.004564567003399134, 0.00641896016895771, -0.03333062678575516, 0.012568547390401363, -0.01622987911105156, -0.04529667645692825, 0.0032457972411066294, -0.011548569425940514, -0.005128919612616301, 0.012467565946280956, -0.00474515650421381, 0.0382494255900383, 0.006446049548685551, 0.02768322080373764, 0.032129354774951935, 0.04844522848725319, -0.02377457357943058, -0.022168194875121117, 0.0003255528281442821, -0.03202413395047188, 0.0045728785917162895, -0.00836071465164423, -0.0009011650690808892, 0.04810271039605141, -0.005468529183417559, 0.01931958645582199, -0.02584220841526985, -0.013803115114569664, -0.003024928504601121, 0.03131473809480667, 0.014837486669421196, 0.021257275715470314, -0.011377115733921528, -0.025546904653310776, -0.028634846210479736, 0.03094414994120598, 0.03130745142698288, -0.002242004731670022, 0.01754814386367798, 0.011379898525774479, -0.009644578211009502, -0.02929852157831192, -0.006943568121641874, -0.028481485322117805, -0.032092537730932236, -0.003184765111654997, 0.01081971824169159, 0.019965870305895805, -0.020272405818104744, -0.05215572565793991, -0.01231856644153595, 0.05531102046370506, -0.04164205864071846, -0.041181452572345734, -0.012103655375540257, 0.03538691624999046, 0.01730293408036232, -0.03342944011092186 ]
<p>I have a "basic statistics" concept question. As a student I would like to know if I'm thinking about this totally wrong and why, if so: </p> <p>Let's say I am hypothetically trying to look at the relationship between "anger management issues" and say divorce (yes/no) in a logistic regression and I have the option of using two different anger management scores -- both out of 100.<br> Score 1 comes from questionnaire rating instrument 1 and my other choice; score 2 comes from a different questionnaire. Hypothetically, we have reason to believe from previous work that anger management issues give rise to divorce.<br> If, in my sample of 500 people, the variance of score 1 is much higher than that of score 2, is there any reason to believe that score 1 would be a better score to use as a predictor of divorce based on its variance? </p> <p>To me, this instinctively seems right, but is it so?</p>
74,286
[ -0.08539476990699768, 0.021175656467676163, -0.0315592885017395, -0.007770969532430172, 0.02730741538107395, -0.004370022099465132, -0.007160542532801628, -0.0008298887405544519, 0.037688568234443665, 0.0003700181550811976, 0.042608842253685, 0.017265671864151955, 0.05465161055326462, 0.022415144369006157, 0.029829204082489014, 0.0066721681505441666, 0.0210280679166317, 0.0038809000980108976, 0.02145565301179886, 0.03027484193444252, -0.002690912690013647, 0.008037654682993889, 0.0034080762416124344, -0.0358271598815918, -0.005896605085581541, 0.06940250098705292, 0.00211811694316566, -0.02548188343644142, 0.0145521005615592, 0.032357312738895416, -0.021251486614346504, 0.019139641895890236, 0.017861556261777878, 0.026349276304244995, 0.030304212123155594, 0.003743154928088188, -0.0024477187544107437, 0.023355895653367043, -0.02883446216583252, 0.05634039267897606, -0.00474515138193965, -0.03115352988243103, -0.013421478681266308, 0.020737862214446068, -0.043028514832258224, 0.031762998551130295, -0.020316317677497864, -0.03767405450344086, 0.008433100767433643, -0.04083562642335892, 0.047453511506319046, -0.00588734308257699, 0.029005130752921104, 0.04636738821864128, -0.005127228796482086, 0.00557360053062439, 0.07596834748983383, 0.06103546544909477, -0.0254860520362854, -0.02955150604248047, -0.0347370021045208, 0.0039015819784253836, -0.009239472448825836, 0.0007519123610109091, -0.018052276223897934, 0.032949965447187424, 0.012168501503765583, -0.035344868898391724, 0.04235861450433731, -0.015904968604445457, 0.005949131213128567, 0.019193535670638084, 0.05158715695142746, -0.011793452315032482, 0.010176914744079113, -0.027195250615477562, 0.012959077022969723, -0.01106759998947382, 0.01190945878624916, 0.06795034557580948, 0.010652105323970318, 0.02713288553059101, 0.0358915850520134, 0.06592972576618195, 0.018955500796437263, -0.02165178954601288, 0.05209961533546448, -0.039002373814582825, 0.030866408720612526, 0.030379928648471832, -0.015383089892566204, -0.009177359752357006, 0.012035858817398548, 0.011247553862631321, -0.03001353330910206, 0.04557749629020691, -0.03587070107460022, 0.06162864714860916, 0.04191999509930611, 0.01732981577515602, -0.018928203731775284, -0.0022714296355843544, 0.043520163744688034, 0.030438996851444244, -0.018286339938640594, -0.043791044503450394, 0.003020007163286209, 0.043984368443489075, 0.005122726317495108, -0.051172785460948944, -0.007518137339502573, 0.022366488352417946, -0.007132902275770903, 0.007641483563929796, 0.04793241247534752, -0.002047933405265212, -0.012783888727426529, -0.04125650227069855, 0.0439281165599823, 0.06154140830039978, 0.030868899077177048, -0.04206565394997597, 0.011226880364120007, -0.0423356257379055, 0.0012762314872816205, -0.009486344642937183, 0.016044480726122856, 0.0075635043904185295, -0.03761012479662895, 0.03187675401568413, 0.00039840457611717284, -0.009588908404111862, 0.009613408707082272, 0.03747451305389404, 0.004208279307931662, 0.022247720509767532, -0.09898985177278519, -0.03779817000031471, 0.03125963360071182, 0.018733087927103043, -0.004532069433480501, -0.08141899108886719, -0.021269598975777626, 0.00002233994018752128, 0.03680349886417389, 0.008426659740507603, 0.059499211609363556, 0.01436490099877119, 0.04789459705352783, 0.04375774785876274, -0.031314875930547714, -0.009974438697099686, -0.023246970027685165, -0.06681352108716965, 0.007067917846143246, -0.11512567847967148, -0.0014618579298257828, -0.015131616033613682, -0.00933875422924757, 0.009389064274728298, -0.04076659679412842, -0.008425598032772541, 0.011137200519442558, 0.009535564109683037, 0.047874026000499725, 0.026057053357362747, 0.07169017940759659, -0.00931231863796711, 0.019982440397143364, 0.0188318882137537, 0.01496901549398899, -0.0029172806534916162, 0.020602645352482796, 0.05816185474395752, 0.041962046176195145, 0.0017786860698834062, 0.0033071862999349833, -0.041518695652484894, 0.031221915036439896, 0.0033775484189391136, -0.04832695797085762, -0.009255959652364254, -0.011207737028598785, 0.018711473792791367, 0.009723708033561707, 0.028068803250789642, -0.017736686393618584, -0.0046156831085681915, 0.036808550357818604, -0.03531374782323837, -0.0671842023730278, -0.06597249954938889, 0.030961472541093826, -0.023845050483942032, -0.03667900338768959, 0.014529104344546795, -0.027819955721497536, 0.06495815515518188, -0.041113514453172684, -0.009739690460264683, -0.017379743978381157, -0.008239412680268288, 0.030292045325040817, -0.04803156107664108, 0.015137082897126675, 0.052151087671518326, 0.030513035133481026, -0.026122819632291794, 0.02751968428492546, -0.05221325904130936, -0.04982995241880417, 0.018082795664668083, -0.033870965242385864, 0.002640570979565382, 0.0022236935328692198, -0.04335058480501175, 0.029423797503113747, 0.00919357594102621, -0.017388401553034782, 0.027736356481909752, -0.07039964944124222, 0.07126317173242569, 0.05934976041316986, -0.03337670862674713, -0.015219829976558685, 0.022138850763440132, 0.021173061802983284, -0.014526115730404854, 0.00114284863229841, -0.02737453579902649, -0.027543017640709877, -0.004248773213475943, 0.025784604251384735, 0.010564123280346394, -0.008434743620455265, 0.03522403910756111, 0.05379398167133331, 0.010103601962327957, 0.005764619912952185, -0.0037479870952665806, 0.021092062816023827, -0.019968952983617783, -0.026869170367717743, 0.02907203510403633, -0.011777197942137718, 0.014748770743608475, 0.015404971316456795, -0.002825072268024087, 0.021053267642855644, 0.009111794643104076, 0.006295645143836737, 0.05115441232919693, -0.010744315572082996, 0.027702638879418373, -0.0035067913122475147, 0.005327723920345306, 0.03890659660100937, -0.014798453077673912, 0.020578257739543915, 0.06712840497493744, 0.03173377737402916, -0.03004065901041031, 0.02536063827574253, -0.0183480866253376, -0.0049924831837415695, 0.03907544165849686, -0.02668014168739319, 0.021926535293459892, 0.0070213875733315945, -0.038963232189416885, 0.005707122851163149, 0.013772735372185707, -0.04099321737885475, -0.028389157727360725, 0.0030082333832979202, 0.02567700482904911, 0.014501973055303097, 0.014144349843263626, -0.01175488531589508, -0.050895627588033676, -0.0007430913392454386, -0.011159788817167282, -0.016174837946891785, -0.002935874043032527, -0.04152503237128258, -0.01642279326915741, -0.05768122896552086, -0.007985759526491165, 0.01358506828546524, -0.011514710262417793, 0.006554317194968462, 0.04380622133612633, -0.013332960195839405, -0.05283448100090027, -0.025744518265128136, -0.04882294684648514, 0.0022597762290388346, 0.000461568939499557, -0.045434460043907166, 0.02247723937034607, 0.017335617914795876, -0.030537152662873268, -0.017165064811706543, -0.053286463022232056, -0.04824246093630791, -0.02214176207780838, -0.014323193579912186, 0.04135003685951233, 0.010642588138580322, -0.011844398453831673, 0.025827521458268166, -0.04669703543186188, -0.0347270742058754, -0.09088438749313354, -0.07199927419424057, 0.019015353173017502, 0.02560431882739067, 0.037473902106285095, -0.016541140154004097, -0.03627892583608627, 0.06820490211248398, 0.031854771077632904, -0.004204272758215666, -0.040142972022295, -0.030300481244921684, -0.0177971962839365, -0.027366146445274353, 0.027863427996635437, 0.022829167544841766, 0.011104173958301544, 0.0465933196246624, 0.011142788454890251, 0.03402218967676163, 0.022881759330630302, 0.013271957635879517, -0.016985230147838593, -0.005827345419675112, 0.021149590611457825, -0.03992771729826927, 0.04661019518971443, 0.012696390971541405, -0.034735750406980515, -0.0008064268040470779, -0.006591338664293289, 0.05626072734594345, -0.010006051510572433, -0.05153700336813927, 0.023169612511992455, -0.02217509225010872, 0.02320636622607708, -0.038314707577228546, 0.03279098868370056, 0.013058912940323353, -0.010332832112908363, -0.017575521022081375, 0.0010602980619296432, -0.01153501495718956, -0.009740562178194523, 0.011513368226587772, 0.04714672267436981, 0.032155781984329224, 0.006148621439933777, -0.02140584960579872, -0.009610430337488651, 0.0064545245841145515, 0.034086961299180984, -0.03392776846885681, -0.010944315232336521, 0.030853837728500366, 0.02580760046839714, -0.014367303811013699, -0.031208347529172897, -0.06499291211366653, 0.04549143463373184, -0.07598310708999634, -0.01563563197851181, -0.003198194084689021, 0.04999904707074165, -0.010874222964048386, 0.041616737842559814, 0.0332958959043026, 0.0035427312832325697, 0.006363845430314541, -0.01159198023378849, -0.03250615671277046, 0.02100013568997383, -0.017497165128588676, -0.026083998382091522, -0.006705946754664183, -0.058216843754053116, 0.04072519764304161, -0.019955024123191833, 0.015956468880176544, -0.012617779895663261, 0.026389114558696747, -0.0313224233686924, 0.0036453157663345337, -0.0563373789191246, -0.033138927072286606, -0.007309158332645893, 0.019268879666924477, -0.004655509255826473, -0.023183824494481087, 0.028471602126955986, 0.028163272887468338, 0.003939246293157339, -0.03134021908044815, -0.021178362891077995, -0.0058438740670681, 0.02970365434885025, 0.05302833393216133, 0.01587219350039959, 0.009609876200556755, -0.00884013157337904, 0.07436390221118927, 0.024628551676869392, 0.01783333718776703, 0.04723110795021057, -0.015625495463609695, -0.015640541911125183, 0.01506316289305687, -0.003228088840842247, -0.013628320768475533, 0.025091523304581642, 0.017638785764575005, -0.009042537771165371, 0.028705772012472153, 0.03498570993542671, -0.037329185754060745, -0.004931437782943249, 0.05564087629318237, 0.00896082166582346, -0.0017777560278773308, -0.05034028738737106, 0.009728258475661278, -0.018164271488785744, -0.03497131168842316, 0.03571556881070137, 0.013946028426289558, -0.029772790148854256, -0.009789418429136276, 0.06479218602180481, -0.016285071149468422, -0.0564890056848526, 0.0012155884178355336, 0.0155312679708004, 0.04005734995007515, 0.021263886243104935, -0.0384662002325058, 0.02494163252413273, 0.02275298722088337, 0.03531668335199356, 0.02290176786482334, 0.018701141700148582, -0.06629573553800583, 0.03243635222315788, 0.019112976267933846, 0.012355247512459755, -0.07252059131860733, -0.0028405976481735706, -0.009479447267949581, -0.024084676057100296, 0.016417760401964188, -0.03293434530496597, 0.022468414157629013, -0.009240959770977497, 0.03493691608309746, -0.027596572414040565, -0.012890367768704891, -0.06496050208806992, 0.04986334964632988, 0.00229853019118309, 0.011406083591282368, 0.002702748868614435, -0.032761674374341965, -0.0385892353951931, 0.014678248204290867, 0.04685172811150551, 0.06538215279579163, -0.04549749568104744, -0.028881575912237167, 0.01469042245298624, 0.03370245546102524, 0.0014750739792361856, -0.0467030368745327, 0.008575141429901123, -0.005269041284918785, 0.0016855649882927537, 0.04997995123267174, 0.0015851926291361451, -0.05470753461122513, -0.005680721718817949, 0.025166647508740425, -0.013556250371038914, 0.0161571204662323, 0.005911906715482473, 0.014537942595779896, 0.027608707547187805, 0.006103338673710823, 0.051870010793209076, 0.02147439867258072, 0.02488885447382927, 0.011218049563467503, -0.024795159697532654, 0.02703974023461342, -0.056191328912973404, -0.03986631706357002, -0.03239402174949646, 0.004883947316557169, -0.0036385785788297653, 0.019880563020706177, 0.009563329629600048, 0.014215663075447083, -0.027689354494214058, -0.01747738942503929, -0.00005028752639191225, 0.018968867138028145, -0.0018942597089335322, -0.007139765191823244, -0.029434891417622566, 0.037597279995679855, 0.006536376196891069, -0.012592125684022903, -0.01230824925005436, -0.014148462563753128, 0.027745340019464493, 0.03728528320789337, -0.05115094408392906, 0.007257299032062292, -0.03199038654565811, -0.04330774396657944, 0.02396879345178604, -0.0003640109207481146, 0.03380666673183441, -0.023041313514113426, 0.026211664080619812, 0.025783834978938103, -0.04936916381120682, -0.0203465074300766, -0.01019689068198204, 0.005252488423138857, 0.057570915669202805, -0.027954556047916412, 0.021479101851582527, -0.0247990470379591, -0.049424462020397186, -0.06573181599378586, -0.03473944962024689, 0.03288343548774719, 0.009666775353252888, -0.044244423508644104, -0.008005212992429733, 0.0015092443209141493, 0.014644598588347435, -0.024373261258006096, -0.013806440867483616, 0.09417944401502609, 0.000929723959416151, -0.049657754600048065, -0.01647738739848137, 0.004511116072535515, 0.08394493907690048, -0.016153790056705475, 0.01789897494018078, 0.02460123598575592, -0.038244184106588364, -0.025126870721578598, 0.010408617556095123, 0.020357348024845123, -0.04251336678862572, -0.016670458018779755, -0.032528653740882874, 0.014769074507057667, 0.03862579166889191, -0.019611280411481857, -0.01561351865530014, 0.008793576620519161, 0.004954178351908922, 0.03719824180006981, -0.033641185611486435, 0.006895224563777447, -0.001167378039099276, -0.01615241914987564, -0.012582813389599323, 0.013711834326386452, -0.009206410497426987, -0.0006349541363306344, 0.022039024159312248, 0.030462706461548805, -0.024298658594489098, 0.006756056100130081, 0.04801185801625252, 0.009330126456916332, -0.0018857303075492382, -0.014688100665807724, -0.03412112221121788, 0.03245736286044121, 0.009185177274048328, 0.007661811541765928, 0.019275996834039688, 0.06961420923471451, -0.018493711948394775, -0.017853936180472374, -0.029176291078329086, 0.007826349698007107, 0.07094446569681168, -0.01511137280613184, 0.023549074307084084, 0.07128909975290298, 0.010995334014296532, -0.00927822757512331, -0.0667148306965828, 0.015603606589138508, -0.027394820004701614, 0.013224375434219837, 0.022804370149970055, -0.05161210894584656, 0.016291115432977676, 0.016857462003827095, 0.025116633623838425, 0.05739884823560715, -0.009391256608068943, 0.023010162636637688, 0.03890356421470642, 0.015835771337151527, -0.0012596859596669674, -0.05511367321014404, 0.045515913516283035, -0.05911605805158615, 0.0028785490430891514, -0.02965170331299305, 0.0066870879381895065, 0.0435931421816349, 0.046654265373945236, 0.006622994318604469, -0.07100661844015121, -0.01987610198557377, -0.03776651248335838, 0.005533962044864893, -0.007187215145677328, 0.014698890037834644, 0.041967254132032394, -0.020452044904232025, 0.042108915746212006, -0.0008726129890419543, -0.012077696621418, -0.0420781709253788, -0.08786927163600922, -0.051760174334049225, 0.011818270199000835, -0.0251754280179739, 0.028662027791142464, -0.02576265297830105, -0.02828763984143734, 0.015011481940746307, -0.05145355314016342, 0.0017553146462887526, -0.015144570730626583, 0.02325994335114956, -0.03256494179368019, 0.04558943584561348, 0.022120926529169083, 0.04061850532889366, -0.0022945429664105177, 0.023175563663244247, 0.11407337337732315, 0.019615277647972107, 0.03505820780992508, -0.055367715656757355, 0.06982980668544769, 0.0020990183111280203, -0.014649941585958004, -0.0025593233294785023, 0.039371687918901443, 0.008323241956532001, 0.003311718814074993, 0.03694187477231026, 0.029843710362911224, 0.04707837849855423, -0.003928905352950096, 0.07294350862503052, 0.0019772853702306747, -0.00045037202653475106, 0.015192211605608463, -0.003965945448726416, 0.012220521457493305, -0.023526372388005257, 0.01751173473894596, 0.022306080907583237, 0.025267943739891052, 0.010819212533533573, 0.006440712139010429, -0.0071565695106983185, -0.007173162419348955, -0.012918880209326744, -0.013041891157627106, -0.001368238008581102, 0.019083837047219276, -0.0011219375301152468, -0.015242627821862698, -0.034828200936317444, 0.032005228102207184, -0.020094608888030052, 0.006878035143017769, 0.00801122933626175, -0.030520571395754814, 0.01905921660363674, 0.02002413384616375, -0.00016056255844887346, -0.06828740239143372, -0.03951790928840637, -0.03667095676064491, 0.034657783806324005, 0.013003362342715263, -0.010923736728727818, -0.02028961293399334, -0.002813268220052123, 0.007916554808616638, -0.045680999755859375, -0.030140291899442673, 0.033539339900016785, 0.008650483563542366, -0.02059047296643257, 0.007589728571474552, -0.03818918764591217, 0.03484976291656494, 0.013128731399774551, 0.021208982914686203, 0.038622234016656876, -0.05464978516101837, -0.04159056767821312, -0.005866797640919685, 0.041792672127485275, 0.04616672918200493, 0.006137189920991659, -0.0033411714248359203, -0.020962806418538094, -0.039054110646247864, 0.004489696118980646, 0.011737446300685406, 0.02533862553536892, 0.018346082419157028, -0.03406365215778351, -0.019519995898008347, -0.019179413095116615, -0.029936669394373894, 0.00641424348577857, -0.021219806745648384, -0.01011204719543457, -0.04643385857343674, 0.013857675716280937, 0.0049174148589372635, 0.025861358270049095, 0.015774954110383987, -0.008976739831268787, 0.03430594876408577, 0.04475197568535805, -0.011850670911371708, -0.03587503731250763, -0.0036914823576807976, -0.010587460361421108, -0.03614399954676628, -0.006484890356659889, 0.005073266103863716, 0.05131565034389496, 0.021763985976576805, 0.043676089495420456, 0.018761681392788887, 0.03591858223080635, 0.013086847960948944, 0.035426218062639236, 0.031720682978630066, -0.0587962307035923, -0.017881741747260094, 0.010114067234098911, -0.0051774997264146805, -0.015355152077972889, -0.01175547856837511, -0.05670180544257164, -0.06158833205699921, 0.014365158975124359, -0.011746875010430813, -0.03987358137965202, -0.017370328307151794, 0.015457564033567905, 0.006733499001711607, -0.07037447392940521, -0.008043833076953888, -0.03172001242637634, -0.009750080294907093, 0.004556645639240742, -0.02481091581285, 0.002372089307755232, 0.029147790744900703, -0.006347250659018755, 0.005621138494461775, 0.03568005934357643, -0.002710337284952402, 0.019682584330439568, -0.01014834176748991, 0.014241634868085384, -0.014926459640264511, 0.04751403257250786, -0.043623875826597214, 0.0020859127398580313, 0.034852124750614166, -0.028340507298707962, -0.03637716919183731, 0.025879278779029846, -0.01256586518138647, -0.02460457570850849, 0.017130928114056587, 0.025109808892011642, -0.027317939326167107, 0.05726911127567291, 0.0005967091419734061, 0.004373162519186735, -0.022642308846116066, 0.03470791503787041, 0.02202746644616127, -0.03118038736283779, 0.017042068764567375, 0.024015044793486595, -0.005834568291902542, 0.00010045078670373186, 0.03775937482714653, 0.0001895401073852554, 0.023752082139253616, 0.003985817544162273, 0.000979350646957755, -0.008018415421247482, -0.019338903948664665, -0.0017008406575769186, 0.03266631066799164, 0.07139118760824203, -0.033779438585042953, 0.01664135791361332, 0.018328502774238586, 0.025931112468242645, -0.06831918656826019, -0.02628951333463192, 0.024228520691394806, 0.036704033613204956, 0.016850244253873825, -0.04651987925171852, -0.0049928161315619946, 0.03534780815243721, -0.046140845865011215, -0.04576742649078369, -0.022063229233026505, 0.01813795231282711, -0.04846073314547539, 0.0017300944309681654, -0.044200584292411804, 0.0075374022126197815, 0.007225316483527422, -0.0025890269316732883, 0.03440529480576515, 0.01592344604432583, 0.03796879202127457, 0.007876215502619743, -0.04915982857346535, -0.00041295200935564935, 0.009751866571605206, -0.027010122314095497, 0.02781347744166851, -0.057024188339710236, -0.06170876696705818, 0.026567038148641586, 0.0010970259318128228, 0.02514704503118992, 0.015781044960021973, 0.03847504034638405, 0.029453830793499947, 0.02121116779744625, 0.013454094529151917, -0.004016802180558443, -0.004819805268198252, 0.02396176941692829, 0.013993602246046066, 0.018936455249786377, -0.022361649200320244, -0.003470305586233735, 0.026147883385419846, -0.039087988436222076, -0.01757148839533329, -0.017655665054917336, -0.025907373055815697, -0.025139810517430305, -0.00942484475672245, -0.006660819053649902, -0.008265198208391666, -0.0336323045194149, 0.016462599858641624, -0.048662152141332626, 0.0023633933160454035, 0.055317461490631104, 0.04278761148452759, -0.020578715950250626, 0.0017667502397671342, -0.006341169122606516, -0.054437000304460526, 0.014264758676290512, 0.007123349700123072, -0.0014705504290759563, -0.04692681133747101, -0.02301749587059021, -0.02596364915370941, -0.0025543945375829935, -0.022204440087080002, 0.019049575552344322, -0.039538901299238205, 0.0497242771089077, -0.045437347143888474, 0.022718170657753944, 0.02363305166363716, -0.05490932986140251, 0.005312206223607063, -0.09293122589588165, 0.08726286888122559, 0.006043805740773678, -0.009555822238326073, -0.041898444294929504, 0.008894519880414009, -0.02695688046514988, -0.012486313469707966, 0.036308325827121735, -0.006635784637182951, 0.0021436300594359636, -0.002627647016197443, -0.0011243767803534865, -0.015022900886833668, 0.0006688389112241566, 0.04041586071252823, -0.01761636696755886, 0.0064409454353153706, -0.0001911153522087261, -0.0019636820070445538, -0.020610863342881203, 0.018243959173560143, 0.04837050661444664, -0.04525401070713997, 0.025336071848869324, -0.0024742716923356056, 0.0018789282767102122, 0.02783449925482273, 0.0011985867749899626, 0.0002584986505098641, 0.04385313764214516, -0.013284698128700256, 0.01931876875460148, 0.01574820652604103, -0.015158330090343952, -0.09871477633714676, 0.02697007544338703, -0.021049635484814644, 0.0028693173080682755, -0.0036325925029814243, 0.01867957040667534, 0.007005893625319004, -0.05729913339018822, 0.009511766955256462, 0.039030253887176514, -0.025211384519934654, 0.014520777389407158, -0.01370228175073862, 0.015504445880651474, 0.008651546202600002, -0.005525199230760336, -0.00563337467610836, 0.02772550843656063, -0.031827718019485474, -0.022465946152806282, 0.021320099011063576, 0.05900588631629944, 0.03712046146392822, 0.010935152880847454, 0.01222133357077837, 0.010433021932840347, 0.02233187109231949, -0.0021593242418020964, 0.04876767098903656, -0.02043086104094982, -0.004222760908305645, -0.007661534007638693, 0.008882218971848488, 0.06010129302740097, -0.008631166070699692, -0.006283987779170275, 0.03821389004588127, -0.05441300943493843, -0.028445908799767494, -0.045912906527519226, -0.0037127607502043247, -0.0588352270424366, -0.020949583500623703, 0.03624879568815231, 0.010206970386207104, 0.04238856956362724, -0.0019561226945370436, -0.024792766198515892, 0.023030512034893036, 0.017484396696090698, -0.016371993348002434, 0.004083998501300812, -0.022586051374673843, 0.010097526013851166, -0.03596598654985428, -0.011241672560572624, -0.022057117894291878, -0.03289256617426872, 0.027326973155140877, 0.02007869817316532, 0.0545785054564476, -0.01572386734187603, -0.0471142940223217, -0.018813295289874077, 0.049742549657821655, -0.040727946907281876, -0.030096789821982384, -0.05730084702372551, 0.035972800105810165, 0.022783784195780754, -0.05642388388514519 ]
<p>I have time series data that represent dates/times of trades taken in a financial market. </p> <p>I would like to assign a score to this data that represents whether the trades are <code>mostly clustered</code> around particular time values or if they are <code>mostly spread out</code> evenly. I am going to have about 1000+ results per dataset.</p> <p><strong>Example situation one (High degree of "clustering" ):</strong> </p> <pre><code>1. 01/01/01 : 13:00 2. 01/01/01 : 13:10 3. 01/01/01 : 13:15 4. 01/01/01 : 13:25 5. 03/05/01 : 17:20 6. 03/05/01 : 17:35 7. 03/05/01 : 17:40 8. 03/05/01 : 17:45 </code></pre> <p><strong>Example situation two( Low degree of "clustering)"</strong></p> <pre><code>1. 01/01/01 : 13:00 2. 01/05/01 : 02:30 4. 02/12/01 : 06:40 5. 02/25/01 : 02:30 6. 03/30/01 : 21:10 7. 04/12/01 : 02:20 8. 05/02/01 : 03:25 </code></pre> <p>I can of course convert all the timestamps to posix time or whatnot so doing calculation with the time values won't be a problem. </p> <p>I was thinking possibly standard error?</p> <p>(For those who want more background info: I am using backtest results to modulate the size of my entry position in a complex manner. If the results contain trades that are clustered together, then they don't really count as 1 trade each (more like one big trade). This means that such results are untrustworthy and I should not act on them.) Thanks!</p>
37,109
[ -0.015551189891994, 0.000002910778448494966, -0.02035263366997242, -0.02177194319665432, 0.04718198999762535, 0.025797907263040543, 0.014165213331580162, -0.011675667017698288, 0.002774244174361229, -0.004974417854100466, 0.027032993733882904, 0.05945686250925064, 0.011751308105885983, 0.03731786459684372, 0.01609046757221222, -0.03435958921909332, 0.0054763746447861195, 0.013134749606251717, 0.001953065162524581, -0.02935088239610195, 0.025531943887472153, -0.013163015246391296, 0.011309996247291565, -0.012455873191356659, -0.031493864953517914, -0.005321907345205545, -0.005011782981455326, 0.0010696384124457836, -0.0060756513848900795, 0.04853874072432518, -0.05079979449510574, -0.04800178110599518, 0.034577853977680206, 0.026756800711154938, 0.019083183258771896, 0.01875459961593151, -0.029944002628326416, -0.04304024204611778, -0.036242254078388214, 0.03113551251590252, -0.05935457721352577, 0.020232172682881355, -0.004898520186543465, 0.03055112063884735, 0.051724884659051895, 0.033903833478689194, -0.01768876612186432, 0.0032069478183984756, 0.02322344295680523, -0.03302174434065819, 0.0624212920665741, -0.018186936154961586, 0.04275582730770111, -0.01842125505208969, -0.013789044693112373, 0.00815392192453146, 0.027237078174948692, 0.05106400325894356, 0.011895532719790936, -0.02576807327568531, -0.03464927896857262, 0.005191579926759005, 0.04624870792031288, -0.019665690138936043, -0.023704109713435173, 0.01794399321079254, -0.01932843029499054, -0.0018294723704457283, 0.03545401245355606, -0.03201471269130707, 0.004582998808473349, 0.006319795269519091, 0.026460187509655952, 0.02661183476448059, 0.010930021293461323, -0.03226924687623978, 0.025018632411956787, 0.000014851039850327652, 0.07100801914930344, 0.03147273138165474, -0.005980317946523428, 0.008751913905143738, 0.03291467949748039, 0.03342445194721222, 0.058107368648052216, 0.011404340155422688, 0.04927653819322586, -0.07078845798969269, 0.024512317031621933, 0.04031222313642502, -0.008158134296536446, -0.006304169073700905, 0.02540864422917366, 0.019062688574194908, -0.04331062361598015, 0.009082026779651642, -0.00893898494541645, 0.018530720844864845, -0.01144108735024929, 0.0021031517535448074, -0.006683472078293562, -0.06981760263442993, 0.0023173284716904163, 0.04395835101604462, -0.010280687361955643, 0.013344347476959229, -0.010276656597852707, -0.02646503783762455, 0.012488235719501972, -0.026685239747166634, -0.005164617206901312, -0.024917015805840492, -0.011276759207248688, -0.018142638728022575, 0.029452599585056305, -0.04632522538304329, -0.020869055762887, 0.010622626170516014, 0.038165654987096786, 0.03849346190690994, 0.07051006704568863, -0.011128893122076988, 0.03830297663807869, -0.033323030918836594, -0.05465282127261162, -0.004681532736867666, 0.02855929732322693, -0.03218035772442818, -0.022308651357889175, 0.07405562698841095, 0.012749002315104008, -0.014342442154884338, 0.05759615823626518, -0.04262305051088333, 0.06330297887325287, 0.012063552625477314, -0.05653096362948418, -0.031548261642456055, 0.03639953210949898, 0.02189994789659977, 0.0006956233410164714, -0.05887609347701073, -0.0013806084170937538, -0.002341295126825571, 0.03719897195696831, 0.055509909987449646, 0.03242463245987892, -0.006040236447006464, 0.01817486062645912, 0.03434601426124573, -0.0483696311712265, 0.0035475604236125946, -0.029993170872330666, -0.024727504700422287, -0.0021552073303610086, -0.02173355221748352, -0.008145707659423351, 0.01669619232416153, -0.022972237318754196, 0.008671882562339306, -0.005299622658640146, 0.006076406687498093, -0.006310780066996813, -0.01073040533810854, -0.00839784275740385, -0.02497171051800251, 0.05211782455444336, 0.01185824628919363, 0.03615713119506836, -0.006843288894742727, -0.027065446600317955, 0.011034546419978142, 0.019217785447835922, 0.028382882475852966, 0.05347934737801552, -0.0069189900532364845, 0.011531000025570393, -0.007098072208464146, 0.030206529423594475, 0.006536891218274832, -0.009588679298758507, -0.02033988945186138, -0.016313305124640465, -0.01996283419430256, 0.02402186021208763, 0.022063592448830605, 0.003978378605097532, -0.019363509491086006, 0.016855280846357346, -0.026491831988096237, -0.05334414914250374, -0.051048606634140015, 0.0018546521896496415, -0.04741418734192848, -0.03983968123793602, 0.011471336707472801, -0.023758646100759506, -0.0004665412416215986, -0.01836816966533661, -0.07399699091911316, -0.038783833384513855, -0.017610015347599983, 0.05429454147815704, -0.04131034016609192, -0.01554577611386776, 0.05604683607816696, 0.01073426939547062, -0.010531692765653133, 0.03336786478757858, -0.01597519963979721, -0.037356361746788025, 0.006456941366195679, -0.04950278624892235, 0.01989920064806938, -0.008381887339055538, -0.006661299150437117, 0.040893275290727615, -0.00881876889616251, -0.015009792521595955, -0.005067137070000172, -0.01981346495449543, 0.06345513463020325, 0.06790832430124283, 0.01275675743818283, -0.017928311601281166, 0.0014946562005206943, 0.02123846486210823, 0.013764928095042706, -0.057620156556367874, -0.003000164870172739, -0.04600141942501068, 0.007051508873701096, 0.033050209283828735, 0.029451964423060417, -0.023596063256263733, -0.009921065531671047, 0.09727505594491959, 0.0225484948605299, -0.02069982886314392, 0.028146201744675636, -0.023636791855096817, -0.005052776541560888, -0.0018427608301863074, 0.015603981912136078, 0.06394367665052414, -0.016649777069687843, 0.03830402344465256, 0.020485393702983856, 0.01927291229367256, 0.005343351047486067, 0.018756015226244926, 0.014536826871335506, -0.005859687924385071, -0.006817985791712999, -0.036353908479213715, -0.030101487413048744, 0.0393928661942482, -0.024515483528375626, 0.035703495144844055, 0.03323974460363388, -0.002595014637336135, -0.01532785315066576, 0.01151052676141262, -0.023383066058158875, -0.017765620723366737, 0.0035290943924337626, -0.023592490702867508, 0.0067692906595766544, 0.01222449541091919, -0.03400954231619835, 0.004957662429660559, 0.0015801856061443686, -0.014657687395811081, -0.034627240151166916, 0.03741791471838951, 0.04160464182496071, -0.015986857935786247, -0.009420795366168022, -0.029820099472999573, -0.013677050359547138, -0.034489914774894714, -0.0011182106100022793, 0.027656909078359604, 0.023447398096323013, -0.06308121234178543, 0.016949210315942764, 0.018045803532004356, -0.013395172543823719, 0.04736759141087532, 0.0123520502820611, -0.019384069368243217, 0.042544085532426834, -0.0009579891921021044, -0.01973791979253292, -0.032678354531526566, -0.03254251927137375, -0.004783122334629297, -0.027061790227890015, 0.00391738535836339, 0.04950878024101257, 0.043254029005765915, -0.08044283092021942, 0.01631338894367218, -0.03109842538833618, -0.003989932592958212, -0.04035957530140877, -0.012289240024983883, -0.016749456524848938, -0.04050446301698685, 0.004505935590714216, 0.0447842963039875, -0.032166749238967896, -0.009700971655547619, -0.028408097103238106, -0.07474280148744583, -0.007488073781132698, -0.008625337854027748, -0.0017902480904012918, 0.041917555034160614, -0.038636911660432816, 0.06778518855571747, 0.005918073933571577, -0.031088214367628098, -0.04787887632846832, -0.00497686630114913, -0.011288645677268505, -0.0028623833786696196, 0.014437487348914146, 0.0017933527706190944, -0.0000029885864023526665, -0.0013732785591855645, -0.0011495215585455298, 0.030637089163064957, 0.05791577696800232, -0.009877216070890427, 0.025093890726566315, 0.020651577040553093, 0.00522970175370574, -0.014326994307339191, 0.023359842598438263, 0.03805553540587425, -0.012319175526499748, -0.014143334701657295, 0.016033977270126343, 0.015189928002655506, 0.029413316398859024, -0.03630024567246437, 0.014796522445976734, 0.00047158487723208964, 0.02871035970747471, -0.01545751467347145, 0.025549333542585373, -0.01806638389825821, -0.031715087592601776, -0.04731130227446556, 0.03224329650402069, -0.0018563426565378904, -0.02621285989880562, 0.008979600854218006, 0.06773944944143295, 0.06396624445915222, 0.006749792955815792, -0.04758504033088684, -0.009105730801820755, -0.0006565044168382883, 0.011708667501807213, -0.053757473826408386, 0.0024219690822064877, 0.03909088671207428, 0.037001218646764755, 0.04462798312306404, 0.01504854392260313, -0.020252397283911705, 0.010651498101651669, -0.07209274917840958, 0.0019438283052295446, -0.02596191316843033, 0.07143197953701019, 0.028190655633807182, 0.03172466531395912, 0.016405891627073288, -0.05013025924563408, 0.025496136397123337, -0.0004412081325426698, -0.030483270063996315, 0.028513826429843903, 0.008379031904041767, -0.0378793403506279, -0.0014156243996694684, -0.001973657635971904, 0.014051259495317936, -0.02568734437227249, 0.03882819041609764, 0.009675160050392151, 0.01939050480723381, -0.024905454367399216, 0.023039110004901886, 0.02288641966879368, 0.013259056024253368, -0.020397139713168144, 0.038418181240558624, 0.030011823400855064, 0.005232236348092556, 0.06839257478713989, 0.03276129812002182, -0.012924806214869022, -0.013282340951263905, 0.01777183823287487, 0.023375248536467552, 0.006943804211914539, 0.02623646706342697, 0.03121507540345192, 0.003935814835131168, -0.05581870675086975, 0.03177089989185333, -0.014294551685452461, 0.014784272760152817, 0.038250599056482315, -0.03163764253258705, 0.011812143959105015, 0.008048249408602715, -0.024379979819059372, 0.03747473657131195, -0.005861618090420961, 0.02382984198629856, 0.01541184727102518, 0.018265560269355774, 0.02724268287420273, -0.04513964802026749, 0.033410608768463135, 0.1074213981628418, 0.023996733129024506, -0.01788809522986412, -0.02712608315050602, -0.05060185492038727, 0.043082963675260544, -0.011301209218800068, -0.023369742557406425, 0.04545598104596138, 0.003503886517137289, 0.021133070811629295, 0.01899527758359909, 0.006296192761510611, -0.016259891912341118, 0.019038347527384758, 0.03815332055091858, 0.04209137707948685, 0.028353281319141388, -0.014453621581196785, 0.027861904352903366, 0.03403933346271515, 0.054067011922597885, 0.023360244929790497, -0.012519171461462975, -0.12342080473899841, 0.015696503221988678, 0.008919419720768929, 0.0322653129696846, -0.0031695652287453413, -0.0018718059873208404, 0.0007486275280825794, 0.01729764975607395, 0.02174856700003147, -0.05471180006861687, 0.04866272211074829, -0.00624022027477622, 0.015212074853479862, -0.02800358273088932, -0.020425662398338318, -0.03606990724802017, 0.01753661222755909, -0.0028106002137064934, 0.06289802491664886, -0.022197816520929337, -0.04272463545203209, -0.0556810162961483, -0.007836093194782734, 0.02582581900060177, 0.0066135902889072895, -0.05983460694551468, -0.014614034444093704, -0.005179335828870535, 0.02040785178542137, -0.009003751911222935, -0.054413750767707825, -0.0021561519242823124, -0.003112523118034005, 0.013958169147372246, 0.04825323075056076, -0.013007024303078651, -0.02739754132926464, 0.02413010224699974, 0.02965116687119007, 0.01125306636095047, 0.016341250389814377, -0.008087445050477982, 0.07792259752750397, 0.01329970546066761, 0.05057550594210625, 0.015140128321945667, 0.008147691376507282, 0.023032579571008682, 0.025156481191515923, -0.017573056742548943, -0.005746101960539818, -0.027040816843509674, 0.028028644621372223, -0.021602340042591095, -0.010113026946783066, -0.034983500838279724, 0.013036194257438183, -0.023552466183900833, 0.0130486860871315, -0.014253822155296803, -0.0013241204433143139, 0.00817205011844635, 0.02702651359140873, 0.01996476761996746, -0.02011093497276306, -0.009583688341081142, -0.00014447994180954993, -0.031650248914957047, 0.004086468834429979, 0.00991219375282526, -0.0594334676861763, -0.007721164729446173, 0.012568698264658451, -0.03776947036385536, 0.009799757041037083, -0.0007795979036018252, 0.0011159885907545686, 0.000026628411433193833, 0.0007816361030563712, 0.032316435128450394, 0.001417033956386149, 0.030103428289294243, -0.01494826003909111, -0.004726065322756767, 0.001675172126851976, 0.006071506068110466, -0.025933194905519485, 0.022965891286730766, -0.04854749143123627, 0.047051794826984406, -0.0033345071133226156, -0.02849997766315937, -0.06651807576417923, -0.046528998762369156, 0.041637152433395386, 0.017611289396882057, -0.047701701521873474, -0.05631806701421738, -0.0069005414843559265, -0.01951664499938488, 0.0017856766935437918, -0.02008296176791191, 0.028980569913983345, 0.004881559871137142, -0.07505869120359421, 0.005542353261262178, 0.004879368934780359, 0.10189127177000046, 0.04196324199438095, 0.012715759687125683, 0.009898210875689983, 0.01491544395685196, -0.003830055007711053, 0.004157016519457102, -0.015322205610573292, -0.026809118688106537, -0.014769374392926693, -0.039836473762989044, -0.007770615629851818, 0.017666751518845558, -0.008199249394237995, 0.0015635305317118764, -0.021179642528295517, 0.006817466113716364, 0.01377375889569521, -0.02407100610435009, 0.03679833561182022, -0.021182527765631676, -0.02502903901040554, -0.012226657010614872, 0.00540592847391963, -0.037195269018411636, 0.014443835243582726, -0.022340087220072746, -0.004316779784858227, -0.04049760103225708, 0.015832267701625824, 0.0745265856385231, 0.007743789814412594, -0.05102096125483513, -0.017464863136410713, -0.027065077796578407, 0.02987983264029026, 0.025037001818418503, -0.025133181363344193, 0.016854755580425262, 0.01759134605526924, -0.02705620788037777, -0.021495357155799866, -0.013601132668554783, -0.022007256746292114, 0.05530933290719986, -0.00003024629404535517, 0.04562188312411308, 0.028379864990711212, 0.009944966994225979, 0.01505224872380495, -0.012884651310741901, 0.018039096146821976, -0.006941288709640503, 0.004664740990847349, 0.038622282445430756, 0.0062493919394910336, -0.0184628963470459, 0.019263679161667824, -0.002938407938927412, 0.02719159424304962, 0.039232343435287476, 0.03437284007668495, 0.015509698539972305, -0.011461924761533737, -0.02304295264184475, -0.029599927365779877, 0.019835323095321655, -0.04899194836616516, -0.004834841005504131, -0.05873878672719002, -0.030153824016451836, 0.027461785823106766, 0.04233285039663315, -0.01965171843767166, -0.037998657673597336, -0.030927814543247223, -0.045484334230422974, -0.001543496735394001, 0.025484224781394005, -0.04646843299269676, 0.004873956087976694, 0.016109414398670197, 0.06289276480674744, 0.00972637627273798, 0.013889343477785587, 0.0045700292102992535, -0.04324671998620033, -0.0291292741894722, -0.031889867037534714, -0.053239498287439346, 0.05660220980644226, -0.0069090682081878185, -0.028173476457595825, 0.01812330074608326, 0.007219858467578888, 0.0209092665463686, 0.013338695280253887, 0.03509551286697388, -0.022684156894683838, 0.09286469221115112, 0.017857853323221207, 0.0056532700546085835, -0.008888185024261475, -0.03864319622516632, 0.11564981192350388, 0.10458344221115112, 0.023556824773550034, -0.0447143130004406, 0.027238810434937477, 0.0288985688239336, 0.007973819971084595, -0.012557430192828178, 0.006702318787574768, 0.016234122216701508, -0.0295904278755188, 0.06045570969581604, 0.039230410009622574, 0.038435276597738266, -0.030721018090844154, 0.04166283831000328, -0.03741228207945824, 0.003574563190340996, 0.004961840342730284, 0.03701191395521164, 0.005996996536850929, -0.046821944415569305, -0.06601812690496445, -0.012637265957891941, 0.04104509577155113, 0.009432866238057613, 0.0274470504373312, -0.021195564419031143, -0.031950194388628006, 0.021453412249684334, 0.029910504817962646, -0.00577973248437047, 0.04555902257561684, -0.0013538991333916783, -0.0324191078543663, -0.038396529853343964, 0.007487514987587929, -0.019621597602963448, -0.005773015320301056, 0.010432903654873371, 0.01265041809529066, 0.007290995214134455, -0.004957328084856272, 0.05058712139725685, -0.049330707639455795, -0.03866345062851906, -0.004646452143788338, 0.007987705990672112, -0.014042385853827, -0.03037656471133232, 0.015463548712432384, 0.009509406052529812, 0.04008421301841736, -0.05201633274555206, -0.005533433984965086, 0.024422194808721542, 0.029325760900974274, -0.0322716198861599, -0.018669063225388527, -0.02546900510787964, 0.026226580142974854, -0.01431941520422697, 0.01859990879893303, 0.012668837793171406, -0.014557840302586555, 0.01095052994787693, -0.03580395504832268, 0.08104053139686584, -0.00834480207413435, 0.00471011595800519, -0.012044473551213741, -0.01756111904978752, -0.03051374852657318, 0.024769745767116547, 0.00897834450006485, -0.039494968950748444, 0.01200960110872984, -0.0016967529663816094, 0.002390044741332531, -0.0004042215587105602, -0.008784373290836811, 0.024884536862373352, -0.04030700400471687, -0.034932371228933334, -0.06784369051456451, -0.002321990206837654, 0.03662529215216637, 0.04590057581663132, 0.015051012858748436, 0.02688075229525566, -0.033011261373758316, 0.06928567588329315, -0.017302270978689194, -0.046021733433008194, -0.000001018490593196475, 0.022471312433481216, -0.016319744288921356, 0.013278428465127945, -0.01847492717206478, 0.07588252425193787, 0.04382387176156044, -0.03525472432374954, -0.007299244403839111, 0.01715983636677265, 0.028094733133912086, -0.02279210463166237, 0.009607186540961266, -0.06203470751643181, 0.00011294094292679802, -0.008714938536286354, -0.018107395619153976, -0.021177558228373528, -0.04729298874735832, -0.05766979977488518, -0.021425116807222366, -0.02752803824841976, -0.022018970921635628, -0.04050034284591675, 0.021261826157569885, -0.025432948023080826, -0.042851924896240234, -0.03597890958189964, 0.03815015032887459, 0.0023607006296515465, -0.02565486915409565, -0.04685608297586441, -0.03516078740358353, -0.010757913812994957, 0.007919400930404663, -0.017042329534888268, 0.007276870310306549, 0.06489396095275879, 0.02253071963787079, 0.01555410772562027, 0.01081899181008339, -0.0011049173772335052, -0.0006147169042378664, 0.011573792435228825, -0.03492385149002075, -0.01423587929457426, 0.006757399998605251, -0.06506916135549545, -0.05035528168082237, 0.04782447963953018, -0.003336372086778283, 0.024537760764360428, -0.019150976091623306, 0.024930575862526894, -0.014611074700951576, 0.04741807281970978, -0.020913315936923027, -0.03125526010990143, 0.028186503797769547, -0.016719304025173187, 0.0077000567689538, 0.020897889509797096, 0.016710061579942703, 0.015460347756743431, -0.03335173800587654, -0.02585838921368122, 0.015105344355106354, 0.04632338881492615, -0.009395936504006386, 0.018234502524137497, 0.023993531242012978, 0.0076108528301119804, 0.0017225468764081597, -0.06833457201719284, 0.03257254511117935, 0.03289039060473442, -0.059748999774456024, -0.010044390335679054, -0.027958424761891365, 0.002488326281309128, -0.0490737147629261, -0.01223255880177021, 0.028276532888412476, -0.016659948974847794, 0.03962724283337593, -0.05835928022861481, -0.013125836849212646, 0.004946006927639246, -0.05171883851289749, 0.021101148799061775, -0.01405608095228672, -0.005595327354967594, -0.005598006770014763, 0.0036504396703094244, -0.045533619821071625, 0.03359584882855415, 0.05180051922798157, 0.009997320361435413, 0.041049253195524216, 0.023157116025686264, 0.030874894931912422, -0.04248937964439392, -0.030533745884895325, 0.013386109843850136, 0.02205672860145569, -0.0640036016702652, 0.028601454570889473, -0.045235153287649155, -0.018539033830165863, 0.02443007379770279, -0.04748455807566643, 0.004665319342166185, 0.04295182228088379, 0.026149718090891838, -0.0012785381404682994, 0.061414528638124466, 0.02764037996530533, 0.003727252595126629, -0.011348064057528973, 0.027597185224294662, -0.0048831310123205185, 0.00273351208306849, -0.0014076163060963154, 0.032909296452999115, 0.008801354095339775, 0.002604095730930567, -0.01439192146062851, -0.0005308461841195822, -0.01029065903276205, -0.012119526974856853, -0.007333837915211916, 0.02756384015083313, 0.036780983209609985, -0.019532810896635056, -0.00951102189719677, 0.0030341409146785736, -0.0033361155074089766, 0.05280347540974617, 0.04467843845486641, -0.0280604250729084, 0.007030101493000984, -0.031024090945720673, -0.037334658205509186, 0.006310397293418646, -0.0021739124786108732, -0.0016348205972462893, -0.03942856192588806, -0.021971073001623154, 0.005762199871242046, -0.004779402166604996, -0.043244123458862305, -0.0024858040269464254, 0.06422743946313858, 0.06844791769981384, -0.03020101971924305, 0.012717247009277344, 0.042740240693092346, -0.011488426476716995, 0.054822828620672226, -0.09460004419088364, 0.052848875522613525, -0.007176340091973543, 0.03819027543067932, -0.04574163258075714, -0.017416294664144516, -0.06533432006835938, 0.01151322666555643, 0.030517762526869774, 0.006462159100919962, -0.01113351434469223, -0.022095555439591408, 0.002018895698711276, -0.01171679887920618, -0.0482221320271492, 0.05385546013712883, -0.012197166681289673, -0.01795482635498047, 0.007654112298041582, -0.049042683094739914, -0.0046697077341377735, -0.014436312951147556, 0.035403646528720856, -0.043116603046655655, -0.03800412639975548, -0.014954027719795704, -0.010479556396603584, 0.05048410966992378, -0.01730397157371044, 0.01155585702508688, 0.03882081061601639, 0.019018856808543205, -0.02472599409520626, 0.05989637225866318, -0.03862389549612999, -0.07158423215150833, 0.0392325259745121, -0.07073736190795898, -0.04926037788391113, 0.020700283348560333, 0.028925199061632156, -0.00938943400979042, -0.06202922388911247, -0.0007107684505172074, 0.010799692943692207, 0.008290380239486694, -0.017529718577861786, 0.019892513751983643, 0.0414433516561985, 0.026944920420646667, -0.024033572524785995, 0.010401461273431778, 0.013979258015751839, 0.007883989252150059, 0.03639068081974983, 0.01779021881520748, 0.06320029497146606, 0.02318717911839485, 0.02745799534022808, -0.023942390456795692, -0.010277971625328064, 0.030805284157395363, -0.003988303709775209, 0.045108046382665634, -0.0048339092172682285, 0.004268965683877468, 0.0344136506319046, -0.02568397857248783, -0.006474243476986885, 0.025212427601218224, -0.011068051680922508, -0.0007681293645873666, -0.033826395869255066, -0.00044479011557996273, -0.044241297990083694, -0.009483756497502327, -0.0012310363817960024, 0.008768091909587383, 0.00670467596501112, 0.04448060318827629, -0.06226310878992081, 0.0008446096908301115, -0.0034324072767049074, -0.002382830483838916, 0.027654914185404778, -0.04828277975320816, 0.019047114998102188, -0.010464437305927277, 0.03169148415327072, -0.022601056843996048, -0.035521723330020905, -0.053808651864528656, -0.02831524796783924, 0.016379790380597115, 0.005054180044680834, -0.004037804435938597, -0.043160777539014816, -0.024122659116983414, -0.008320456370711327, 0.014731395989656448, -0.06661837548017502, 0.013406092301011086, -0.05285590887069702, 0.04196973517537117, 0.0012763550039380789, -0.010180758312344551 ]
<p>I am going to be hosting a number (~10) of <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potluck" rel="nofollow">potluck meals</a> over the course of the summer, my pool of people to invite is about 40 people with about 10-15 coming to each meal. So I figure this would be a good opportunity to record data over time about the meals/people. The issue I am having is I am not sure what information to keep track of and what format to record it in.</p> <p>Here are some examples of trends I think would be interesting: </p> <ol> <li>How many meals I have invited people to</li> <li>On average which round of invites did people get invited to (some people rsvp as no in the beginning and so there is another 'round' of invites) <li>How many meals people have attended</li> <li>What items people have brought</li> </ol> <p>I have started a spreadsheet where each page is a meal, the first few columns of the page represent different rounds of invites, I input a persons name in the column that corresponds to the round of their invite. The last two columns are the ultimate rsvp from any round of invitation and the item brought if applicable.</p> <p>To summarize I am looking for an efficient and concise way of recording the data associated with these meals for the trends mentioned. Additionally I am looking for other trends I can keep track of, I am doing a lot of this communication via email so timestamps would potentially be available for other interesting trends.</p> <p>Help with good tags for this question would be appreciated.</p>
74,287
[ -0.020828163251280785, -0.07026928663253784, 0.0004206685407552868, 0.008965088054537773, 0.01790487766265869, -0.0015071744564920664, 0.02632168121635914, -0.016184456646442413, 0.027201807126402855, -0.001936482498422265, 0.01000529807060957, 0.03748778998851776, 0.009585786610841751, 0.019022125750780106, 0.03094349429011345, -0.0025815118569880724, 0.030691875144839287, -0.012458639219403267, 0.009045276790857315, 0.007805088069289923, 0.031066525727510452, -0.01249903254210949, 0.00031605592812411487, 0.00044409275869838893, -0.03394714370369911, 0.014775323681533337, 0.024617226794362068, 0.009484994225203991, -0.0071263499557971954, 0.05554085224866867, -0.01940668374300003, -0.04165763407945633, 0.012862267903983593, 0.012829339131712914, 0.008763513527810574, 0.020315730944275856, -0.06571552157402039, 0.0022304600570350885, 0.006582475267350674, 0.013314198702573776, -0.03689207136631012, -0.002793124644085765, -0.028148358687758446, 0.014426112174987793, -0.026439674198627472, -0.001388454344123602, 0.03525750711560249, -0.020110756158828735, -0.013616655953228474, -0.058905910700559616, 0.023981085047125816, 0.014393915422260761, 0.07032617926597595, 0.022840969264507294, -0.010185766033828259, 0.02238406054675579, 0.014689072966575623, 0.03693072497844696, 0.013777365908026695, -0.05445423722267151, 0.02043335512280464, -0.024754127487540245, -0.009462334215641022, 0.005216277204453945, -0.048718225210905075, 0.03337559103965759, -0.020160401239991188, -0.023707816377282143, 0.04716271907091141, -0.03322622552514076, -0.006286678370088339, 0.01569097302854061, 0.06997302919626236, -0.007468543015420437, 0.01579352654516697, -0.018999915570020676, -0.02384541928768158, -0.01309565082192421, 0.018259581178426743, 0.04836809262633324, -0.01120036095380783, -0.013255772180855274, 0.0005849539302289486, 0.031195439398288727, 0.03437647968530655, -0.03138764947652817, 0.05155988410115242, -0.04038127511739731, -0.028843019157648087, -0.006286274641752243, -0.011081178672611713, 0.0008508679457008839, 0.02128179557621479, 0.014771122485399246, -0.03330112248659134, -0.004184709396213293, -0.029939763247966766, 0.026675378903746605, -0.012980414554476738, -0.004774272907525301, 0.004281549248844385, 0.007325056008994579, 0.011070726439356804, 0.07242905348539352, -0.03157874196767807, -0.02140575274825096, -0.060718417167663574, -0.03173306584358215, 0.016075847670435905, -0.037044864147901535, -0.0050027924589812756, -0.019841903820633888, 0.0338640995323658, 0.009424694813787937, 0.004883804824203253, -0.04686563462018967, -0.024750489741563797, 0.02259964495897293, 0.046308405697345734, 0.04854049161076546, 0.04669250547885895, -0.017688632011413574, 0.038968730717897415, -0.042908236384391785, -0.06921068578958511, 0.04076070711016655, 0.021430647000670433, -0.017718862742185593, -0.028796972706913948, 0.06693535298109055, -0.011389711871743202, 0.010792446322739124, 0.02245916612446308, -0.04504369571805, -0.003507264656946063, 0.024322276934981346, -0.060538239777088165, -0.06454022973775864, 0.03968634828925133, 0.01717774011194706, -0.022081179544329643, -0.07753517478704453, -0.01863672584295273, 0.01038302294909954, 0.025378059595823288, -0.0023542286362499, -0.0071620456874370575, -0.0068513937294483185, 0.033110231161117554, 0.053032975643873215, -0.05837000533938408, 0.004057229030877352, 0.023469582200050354, -0.016545671969652176, -0.0033717097248882055, -0.06670697778463364, 0.0168122760951519, 0.04917999356985092, 0.023968297988176346, -0.029953502118587494, 0.03792918473482132, 0.011934480629861355, -0.009518654085695744, 0.009811650030314922, 0.05997224897146225, -0.045049894601106644, 0.10295771062374115, -0.026854274794459343, -0.012578888796269894, 0.02144567482173443, 0.0009172684513032436, 0.017779529094696045, 0.03211820870637894, -0.0005524650332517922, 0.02902626059949398, -0.00002005895657930523, 0.017737964168190956, 0.0035917777568101883, -0.03491860255599022, -0.0084503423422575, -0.007628368679434061, -0.05949772521853447, -0.00014885625569149852, 0.0038292782846838236, 0.04837489873170853, 0.02158026210963726, 0.0024105184711515903, -0.02448330633342266, 0.02846488729119301, -0.04173040762543678, -0.025691982358694077, -0.06392958760261536, -0.010763450525701046, 0.008208219893276691, 0.027702538296580315, 0.0094444015994668, -0.00038735594716854393, -0.00016665497969370335, 0.0028400938026607037, -0.03427064046263695, 0.0020051223691552877, -0.04532722756266594, 0.0070576416328549385, -0.057544369250535965, -0.02436215616762638, 0.07605549693107605, 0.027042292058467865, -0.05094282701611519, -0.008286983706057072, -0.0238666795194149, -0.027112571522593498, -0.05982544273138046, -0.05925113707780838, 0.05400682985782623, -0.021702837198972702, -0.016922570765018463, 0.005709684919565916, 0.026935771107673645, -0.048432283103466034, 0.02808242477476597, 0.0005926177254877985, 0.031226996332406998, 0.028439588844776154, 0.01304667629301548, 0.012250338681042194, -0.021178806200623512, 0.046569496393203735, 0.013424735516309738, -0.0009014646057039499, -0.018799221143126488, -0.06205595284700394, 0.002900144085288048, 0.009191088378429413, -0.003430754179134965, -0.011794568039476871, 0.004366329871118069, 0.03990049287676811, 0.00872296653687954, 0.019230209290981293, 0.015830310061573982, -0.011916539631783962, 0.05669355392456055, 0.008606158196926117, 0.05090220272541046, -0.0006937655853107572, 0.00382804311811924, -0.008606971241533756, -0.027128368616104126, 0.01079942099750042, 0.039466727524995804, -0.029463790357112885, -0.015943199396133423, 0.06625077873468399, 0.004670274443924427, -0.04314199835062027, 0.032804936170578, 0.05552496016025543, -0.046104952692985535, -0.012700419872999191, 0.026745272800326347, 0.03267698734998703, -0.032337337732315063, 0.014350865967571735, -0.05301427096128464, -0.016348036006093025, 0.012932511046528816, -0.04521094635128975, -0.0011348412372171879, 0.005671244114637375, -0.01430574618279934, 0.053828950971364975, -0.037194836884737015, -0.040756531059741974, -0.05049627646803856, 0.007739977445453405, -0.007336723152548075, -0.03631490841507912, 0.00775407999753952, -0.005338239949196577, -0.006202835123986006, 0.03140776604413986, -0.01145379338413477, 0.0036970069631934166, 0.014047214761376381, -0.04103446379303932, 0.003576946910470724, 0.043989285826683044, -0.00023710515233688056, 0.04010448232293129, 0.03622009605169296, -0.004089204594492912, 0.050370488315820694, 0.01855665072798729, -0.05177558586001396, -0.010092446580529213, 0.03322616592049599, 0.04819371551275253, -0.03170518949627876, -0.0018058974528685212, 0.02089790441095829, 0.004424705170094967, -0.019266702234745026, 0.026026863604784012, -0.0646330863237381, -0.035144444555044174, -0.0505109541118145, 0.003691607853397727, -0.013878446072340012, 0.019427252933382988, 0.0006936212303116918, -0.018672902137041092, 0.00624879403039813, 0.0014577566180378199, -0.05090019479393959, -0.040554944425821304, 0.011442406103014946, -0.030987337231636047, 0.052827730774879456, 0.028355734422802925, -0.02088671736419201, -0.02946656011044979, -0.00311710755340755, -0.07402446866035461, -0.04494633898139, -0.009896595031023026, -0.0014299139147624373, -0.025138378143310547, 0.047023579478263855, 0.031001286581158638, -0.031001590192317963, 0.004835729021579027, 0.01352250762283802, -0.021740199998021126, 0.03869646042585373, 0.00883763562887907, 0.004470304120332003, 0.0031658958178013563, -0.01305663026869297, -0.019474664703011513, 0.024270152673125267, 0.0374620147049427, -0.060028985142707825, -0.005810252856463194, -0.03676100820302963, 0.02047325111925602, 0.04462771862745285, -0.055517327040433884, -0.007273348513990641, -0.06116765737533569, -0.005099611356854439, -0.011227689683437347, -0.0022263505961745977, 0.02070453204214573, -0.029682829976081848, -0.029291685670614243, 0.013600535690784454, 0.024234838783740997, -0.011699984781444073, -0.006461108569055796, 0.06614713370800018, 0.06797685474157333, -0.02538641169667244, -0.0001488782581873238, -0.01573985069990158, -0.016874095425009727, 0.005300580058246851, -0.008819228038191795, -0.007697480730712414, 0.016265392303466797, 0.04302959516644478, -0.004643261898308992, 0.006611967924982309, -0.033709343522787094, -0.008847679942846298, -0.07883685827255249, -0.011523552238941193, -0.006214165594428778, 0.055773768573999405, -0.023008150979876518, 0.058870770037174225, 0.02486281469464302, -0.01226195227354765, 0.006787499412894249, -0.015323437750339508, -0.07036226242780685, 0.006148120854049921, -0.023000748828053474, 0.009549198672175407, 0.022394482046365738, -0.029860101640224457, 0.008039811626076698, 0.020428508520126343, 0.014142128638923168, 0.016860447824001312, 0.030992865562438965, 0.0007361694006249309, 0.019636625424027443, -0.03183255344629288, -0.0021329321898519993, 0.01444628182798624, 0.00612019095569849, 0.021574530750513077, 0.005434944294393063, 0.0461234450340271, 0.03541378304362297, -0.005206435453146696, -0.0417330339550972, -0.05597102269530296, 0.022691937163472176, -0.015225563198328018, 0.010763334110379219, 0.026509076356887817, 0.040427662432193756, -0.04111434146761894, 0.03947234898805618, -0.02077171765267849, 0.018705641850829124, -0.01518072746694088, 0.025703812018036842, 0.025999831035733223, -0.012278146110475063, -0.0002818086068145931, 0.025207964703440666, 0.008950401097536087, 0.013856405392289162, 0.024147532880306244, 0.034242574125528336, -0.018137913197278976, 0.00002012394179473631, 0.03823630139231682, 0.040206752717494965, -0.006495410576462746, -0.01260420773178339, 0.00710383290424943, 0.018208341673016548, 0.07559311389923096, -0.0011398526839911938, 0.024247583001852036, 0.08147595822811127, 0.038555633276700974, 0.02246694639325142, 0.005001131910830736, -0.04115733876824379, -0.03558803349733353, 0.009022338315844536, -0.01758083701133728, 0.05998076871037483, 0.003717661602422595, -0.03785271570086479, -0.016144292429089546, 0.033855192363262177, 0.0589279979467392, 0.013427866622805595, 0.005301366094499826, -0.1122378259897232, -0.013514796271920204, 0.06669606268405914, 0.08126568794250488, -0.04466734826564789, -0.00364882149733603, -0.04134950041770935, -0.03716123476624489, 0.047374606132507324, -0.020221535116434097, -0.0027332990430295467, -0.028284242376685143, -0.01842806674540043, -0.0070474036037921906, -0.006903364323079586, -0.0074905348010361195, -0.017864592373371124, -0.027676435187458992, 0.03371015191078186, -0.020923955366015434, -0.020048262551426888, -0.018164420500397682, 0.05647585168480873, 0.024242857471108437, 0.01203871052712202, -0.005389678757637739, -0.012050945311784744, 0.018257776275277138, -0.015335142612457275, -0.038683291524648666, -0.051876164972782135, -0.011933105066418648, 0.02267959900200367, 0.04141122102737427, 0.060660868883132935, -0.0077810706570744514, -0.01780419982969761, -0.04706272855401039, 0.005032428540289402, -0.01465415395796299, -0.014860273338854313, -0.05091701075434685, 0.02882849983870983, 0.022096483036875725, -0.022221066057682037, 0.04792264476418495, 0.06596303731203079, -0.012382094748318195, 0.014763334766030312, 0.0022870616521686316, -0.007271088659763336, -0.005602176301181316, 0.02400796487927437, -0.008549068123102188, -0.0023053765762597322, -0.05646764114499092, 0.0026830879505723715, -0.015693165361881256, 0.003647681325674057, -0.007181822322309017, -0.030947888270020485, -0.0074521806091070175, 0.03052729181945324, 0.040032777935266495, 0.04715234413743019, 0.009917374700307846, -0.02355421893298626, -0.0016485261730849743, -0.028440993279218674, 0.04543759301304817, -0.04193561524152756, 0.014044187031686306, -0.03676528483629227, -0.006724221166223288, 0.03820769488811493, -0.011016310192644596, -0.010319621302187443, 0.011998436413705349, -0.03200940042734146, 0.07176470756530762, -0.022473303601145744, 0.024540439248085022, 0.020012689754366875, -0.05008406937122345, 0.004215358756482601, 0.00920643750578165, -0.01349038165062666, 0.008430255576968193, -0.011018839664757252, 0.04228280484676361, -0.008980490267276764, -0.013492483645677567, -0.021852370351552963, -0.017493680119514465, 0.04945627227425575, -0.027227146551012993, -0.04651421308517456, -0.012809289619326591, -0.029185526072978973, -0.02102847583591938, -0.013897938653826714, -0.034368690103292465, 0.03836724907159805, -0.03368240222334862, -0.006893550977110863, -0.0032008755952119827, 0.030115071684122086, 0.08965770155191422, 0.023618623614311218, -0.028554866090416908, 0.028201935812830925, 0.009383786469697952, 0.002678278833627701, -0.03987881913781166, 0.003203864675015211, -0.02470197156071663, 0.010312826372683048, -0.027424056082963943, -0.018192753195762634, 0.05089258402585983, -0.05876205861568451, 0.026677658781409264, 0.015928367152810097, 0.0005931627238169312, -0.007409741636365652, -0.03547059744596481, 0.024847885593771935, -0.0358266606926918, -0.0038276927080005407, -0.035579193383455276, 0.02106894738972187, 0.018814681097865105, -0.018910512328147888, -0.010225624777376652, -0.018026985228061676, -0.020144743844866753, 0.00214202469214797, 0.05775323137640953, 0.0042146118357777596, -0.02385643683373928, 0.018192032352089882, -0.0017851116135716438, 0.044809501618146896, 0.028745243325829506, -0.01141101960092783, -0.0032009596470743418, 0.006663545034825802, -0.029376806691288948, -0.04583444818854332, -0.02554157003760338, -0.06233388930559158, 0.06187349185347557, -0.006265375297516584, 0.009143401868641376, 0.014075594022870064, -0.021418124437332153, 0.04155338555574417, -0.0024875327944755554, 0.01823623850941658, -0.02208048850297928, 0.026096628978848457, 0.042546749114990234, -0.01773853972554207, -0.023771952837705612, 0.021261872723698616, 0.02010742947459221, 0.03777852654457092, 0.050858885049819946, 0.046579670161008835, 0.008789265528321266, 0.01211751438677311, -0.06034042686223984, -0.041449323296546936, -0.01589098386466503, -0.04626507684588432, 0.04456485062837601, -0.023853106424212456, -0.02298874966800213, 0.03846115618944168, 0.04155193641781807, 0.00257685873657465, -0.013549593277275562, 0.01622009463608265, -0.06482982635498047, 0.02377716824412346, 0.024743719026446342, 0.00160784344188869, -0.01252852100878954, -0.033476319164037704, 0.03970315679907799, 0.010271349921822548, -0.00686623016372323, -0.021178027614951134, -0.052165478467941284, 0.01665595732629299, -0.02680038847029209, -0.07181155681610107, 0.036627255380153656, 0.0021105261985212564, -0.016527850180864334, -0.021481143310666084, -0.022911999374628067, -0.04128727689385414, 0.01270639430731535, 0.03245801851153374, -0.044194288551807404, 0.06173979863524437, 0.03636310249567032, 0.009918789379298687, -0.00017457488866057247, 0.006162768229842186, 0.1450733095407486, 0.05483515188097954, 0.031140480190515518, -0.04388805106282234, 0.005557581782341003, 0.04232192412018776, -0.007916262373328209, -0.03329775854945183, -0.024458657950162888, 0.01146326307207346, -0.014267237856984138, 0.05312231928110123, 0.06496978551149368, -0.02969055064022541, 0.02566436491906643, 0.021523060277104378, -0.020936599001288414, -0.03138473257422447, -0.004933398216962814, -0.0013839035527780652, -0.02435418590903282, 0.02611757069826126, -0.07355177402496338, 0.03219141811132431, 0.030399153009057045, 0.0005686463555321097, -0.001981009030714631, 0.008070619776844978, 0.024116070941090584, -0.0031139280181378126, -0.0011663074837997556, 0.013831987977027893, 0.014865700155496597, 0.021023230627179146, 0.03508530184626579, 0.025996821001172066, 0.016686255112290382, -0.0461835153400898, -0.0010385209461674094, 0.05248980224132538, 0.008587204851210117, -0.024743612855672836, -0.005811107810586691, -0.0268300361931324, -0.05866846442222595, -0.029490899294614792, -0.038373153656721115, -0.01783771999180317, -0.013897319324314594, -0.03621962293982506, -0.04446861892938614, -0.0054874541237950325, -0.009880241937935352, -0.031587231904268265, -0.010877884924411774, 0.012980417348444462, 0.025590654462575912, -0.040439359843730927, -0.0395069494843483, -0.04836883395910263, -0.0015147814992815256, -0.018156683072447777, 0.004719195421785116, 0.07628799229860306, -0.02732752449810505, -0.03728744387626648, -0.05653882026672363, 0.013912549242377281, 0.014265279285609722, -0.011889362707734108, -0.0035950320307165384, -0.009874614886939526, -0.029569905251264572, 0.008860521018505096, 0.022483721375465393, 0.0328250378370285, 0.021257923915982246, -0.003273796057328582, 0.052060652524232864, 0.006017370615154505, -0.01671961322426796, 0.03211095929145813, -0.015063490718603134, -0.0457889698445797, -0.019302653148770332, 0.00355966086499393, 0.020354056730866432, 0.00982108898460865, -0.012808402068912983, 0.026279933750629425, 0.008770358748733997, 0.07965055853128433, 0.0321599505841732, -0.00875852070748806, -0.010073501616716385, -0.016949476674199104, -0.038141828030347824, -0.03319690003991127, -0.0024707650300115347, 0.07910746335983276, -0.011003433726727962, -0.019762741401791573, -0.00882352888584137, 0.023420756682753563, 0.01990269497036934, 0.012288604862987995, 0.01874965988099575, -0.03618931397795677, 0.007413151208311319, -0.051925014704465866, -0.03400455415248871, -0.00825031753629446, -0.0340690053999424, 0.00772436149418354, 0.009147407487034798, -0.01978442072868347, -0.029750356450676918, -0.038958366960287094, 0.03444541618227959, -0.03702728822827339, 0.040272265672683716, -0.0060941060073673725, -0.0003227725683245808, -0.05121845379471779, -0.06469127535820007, 0.008203438483178616, 0.008520836010575294, -0.006898489315062761, 0.0623890720307827, -0.005530425813049078, 0.018986018374562263, 0.021544048562645912, 0.03139667958021164, 0.022435296326875687, -0.01561339944601059, 0.011506564915180206, -0.006775891873985529, 0.043344270437955856, -0.03476116061210632, -0.05964674428105354, 0.024849582463502884, -0.007368443533778191, -0.005393570754677057, 0.027646584436297417, 0.01844833977520466, 0.02164253406226635, 0.0283504668623209, -0.008570170029997826, 0.03739180415868759, 0.05368392542004585, -0.01264430396258831, -0.03178570419549942, 0.006051590666174889, -0.014616871252655983, 0.03259815275669098, 0.002760261530056596, -0.011450841091573238, 0.00703975697979331, -0.02029179036617279, -0.009376386180520058, 0.04616299644112587, 0.009161136113107204, 0.0018631278071552515, -0.04034456983208656, -0.01654571108520031, -0.0009078351431526244, -0.022858615964651108, 0.0051655941642820835, 0.008434568531811237, 0.053054917603731155, -0.07315022498369217, 0.04377942904829979, -0.024628404527902603, -0.02582930028438568, 0.02039213292300701, 0.012157561257481575, -0.004726745653897524, 0.006440564524382353, -0.011961466632783413, -0.038917768746614456, 0.0011177920969203115, 0.017328845337033272, 0.009741654619574547, 0.02996576763689518, 0.027765832841396332, 0.03016434796154499, -0.01992136240005493, 0.04753605276346207, -0.008325422182679176, 0.014592364430427551, 0.03174200281500816, 0.046933405101299286, 0.024222230538725853, 0.03393514081835747, 0.026304924860596657, -0.040242597460746765, -0.018670424818992615, -0.005315624643117189, 0.014666401781141758, -0.03578654304146767, 0.01065787486732006, 0.0004235752858221531, -0.06177904084324837, 0.019379636272788048, 0.01971699483692646, 0.0248040072619915, 0.020191030576825142, 0.016554126515984535, 0.0029499363154172897, 0.053631383925676346, 0.00014257515431381762, -0.003380857640877366, 0.015092757530510426, -0.000850507989525795, -0.003870166838169098, 0.04673414304852486, -0.005501388572156429, 0.02590625360608101, 0.016087623313069344, -0.003194665303453803, -0.014507518149912357, 0.013423089869320393, -0.02020258456468582, -0.01768210157752037, -0.023412909358739853, -0.05161510035395622, 0.060427453368902206, -0.0020924860145896673, 0.01224906463176012, -0.04401690512895584, 0.05008430406451225, 0.030155248939990997, -0.011779947206377983, 0.019832292571663857, 0.019937265664339066, 0.006624569185078144, -0.01327233575284481, -0.009989706799387932, -0.024612173438072205, -0.022614317014813423, -0.0390600711107254, -0.03236490115523338, -0.020325176417827606, 0.03560091555118561, -0.009925316087901592, 0.0133211649954319, 0.0005525125307030976, 0.04842230677604675, 0.016987666487693787, 0.00034173860331065953, 0.054630402475595474, 0.03435879200696945, 0.026578467339277267, -0.06592321395874023, -0.000020304558347561397, 0.03893695026636124, -0.006947814021259546, -0.010358628816902637, 0.0036284145899116993, -0.012349916622042656, 0.025969890877604485, 0.07691548019647598, -0.028814155608415604, -0.01395832747220993, -0.047664619982242584, -0.004807267803698778, 0.02413315512239933, -0.04424777626991272, 0.09050203859806061, -0.027760295197367668, 0.0031737862154841423, 0.00170156080275774, -0.037037529051303864, 0.020495988428592682, 0.00024279403442051262, 0.05687554180622101, -0.01887640170753002, 0.01070023700594902, 0.006804929580539465, -0.009855709969997406, -0.0066177151165902615, 0.06566591560840607, -0.0077672903425991535, 0.013493664562702179, -0.01227235235273838, -0.02683979645371437, 0.022452857345342636, 0.012278875336050987, -0.049723103642463684, 0.06465858966112137, -0.02596418932080269, -0.04544604569673538, 0.02038569748401642, 0.014580320566892624, -0.004112583119422197, -0.10724447667598724, -0.010979296639561653, 0.010438657365739346, -0.025295330211520195, -0.004502394702285528, 0.05511971190571785, 0.03762579336762428, 0.03425823897123337, -0.010437426157295704, 0.020932184532284737, -0.03720680624246597, -0.029445920139551163, -0.0009378206450492144, 0.03666694834828377, 0.04300839826464653, -0.01971198432147503, 0.013964824378490448, 0.025335125625133514, 0.009136675857007504, 0.016486015170812607, 0.008815250359475613, 0.03173137456178665, -0.013635613024234772, -0.00019600924861151725, -0.003688239958137274, -0.02736346237361431, 0.0015152693958953023, 0.05139036849141121, 0.02703253924846649, 0.038481418043375015, 0.00894281268119812, 0.008277397602796555, -0.0511724092066288, 0.009150553494691849, -0.03584027290344238, -0.00048207282088696957, -0.001291756983846426, 0.011451675556600094, -0.018602794036269188, 0.016388636082410812, 0.008669855073094368, -0.011093360371887684, 0.0417347252368927, -0.006862048525363207, 0.017307182773947716, -0.027515940368175507, -0.0019258827669546008, -0.006044057197868824, -0.037412431091070175, 0.025562819093465805, 0.007389827631413937, 0.03829359635710716, 0.025909684598445892, -0.026556670665740967, -0.010919306427240372, 0.012786620296537876, 0.030038340017199516, 0.030645305290818214, -0.036512523889541626, 0.009655432775616646, -0.05898057669401169, -0.025635186582803726, -0.046579327434301376, -0.019567236304283142 ]
<p>in a plot of my time series there is clearly visible that there is structural break, but I have to find the exact date. I want test this with the chow test. Although I understand how to perform this test if the date of the structural break is know, by simply using a linear regression with two dummy's one for the intercept and one for the slope,</p> <p>$R_t$ = $\beta_0 $+ $\beta_0^* · D_i + \beta_1 R_{m,t} + \beta_1^* · D_t · R_{m,t} + ε_t,$ </p> <p>Than using the chow test.. But if I do not know the exact date, (in other words: I do not know when $D_i$ and $D_t$ should be 1) how can I find the exact date?</p> <p>Thank you very much for reply</p>
74,288
[ 0.031033804640173912, 0.012982549145817757, -0.012088564224541187, -0.015455723740160465, 0.042370159178972244, 0.014894392341375351, -0.010594156570732594, -0.015990328043699265, 0.04332663491368294, -0.07978767901659012, 0.033842481672763824, 0.04710807651281357, 0.04770229011774063, 0.01527224201709032, 0.015720875933766365, 0.02101839892566204, -0.02738630212843418, -0.01829180307686329, -0.025076331570744514, 0.005387850105762482, 0.01161468867212534, -0.010163170285522938, 0.01643451489508152, -0.01232164166867733, -0.031473565846681595, 0.0238227266818285, 0.027637843042612076, -0.001616316381841898, -0.03137565404176712, 0.04713466763496399, -0.04415874928236008, -0.06314124912023544, 0.023556875064969063, 0.0439736433327198, 0.02693706564605236, 0.01439539436250925, 0.014628003351390362, -0.07929223775863647, -0.0060721770860254765, 0.02258283644914627, -0.012372436933219433, -0.02386789210140705, 0.015574326738715172, 0.03078160434961319, -0.0224264245480299, 0.020223256200551987, 0.03491586819291115, 0.006026453338563442, 0.07460333406925201, -0.0017822624649852514, 0.03196530044078827, -0.04192575439810753, 0.024106165394186974, -0.0076975650154054165, -0.038293130695819855, -0.03469102084636688, 0.031554918736219406, 0.07243823260068893, 0.001713347970508039, -0.046914443373680115, -0.03321845829486847, -0.029420970007777214, -0.004700335208326578, -0.04044021666049957, -0.05778082087635994, 0.07309224456548691, -0.026862407103180885, -0.005042009521275759, 0.04333782568573952, -0.04546027258038521, -0.0252375565469265, -0.02761167846620083, 0.0007810185197740793, -0.012629088014364243, -0.005550731439143419, -0.05604110658168793, 0.01854332536458969, 0.04164815694093704, 0.012354460544884205, 0.04333198443055153, 0.00241005327552557, -0.0035613905638456345, 0.04323345422744751, 0.05101408809423447, 0.024588583037257195, 0.010857363231480122, 0.05000775679945946, -0.029416529461741447, 0.02286171354353428, 0.05311713367700577, -0.012464569881558418, 0.01585603505373001, 0.013826911337673664, -0.03163181245326996, -0.009962005540728569, -0.0033448883332312107, -0.030843636021018028, 0.010930071584880352, -0.03994838148355484, 0.025708092376589775, -0.017400313168764114, -0.05797761306166649, 0.017239611595869064, 0.06536971777677536, -0.03105352818965912, 0.024589791893959045, 0.0015667291590943933, 0.0055395024828612804, -0.02129126712679863, -0.04858565703034401, -0.03240954130887985, 0.029210086911916733, 0.006094804499298334, 0.017481893301010132, 0.013578568585216999, 0.01065420638769865, -0.03695344552397728, -0.0250239297747612, 0.07724787294864655, 0.01347555872052908, 0.017516639083623886, -0.027642952278256416, -0.00017149365157820284, -0.027717307209968567, -0.04024704918265343, 0.049668893218040466, 0.006717856973409653, -0.016839103773236275, -0.0017052871407940984, 0.02294808253645897, -0.002161240903660655, -0.02454887516796589, 0.030380383133888245, -0.013748208992183208, 0.09162042289972305, -0.005252738017588854, -0.06930440664291382, -0.01906723342835903, 0.04727840796113014, 0.0009276295895688236, -0.007379468064755201, -0.05967189744114876, -0.029307572171092033, 0.008154618553817272, 0.04604855552315712, 0.03759731352329254, 0.030998948961496353, 0.03338923305273056, 0.003985320683568716, 0.019053885713219643, -0.04634428396821022, 0.039934661239385605, -0.00887645035982132, -0.012046154588460922, -0.003961519803851843, -0.056548599153757095, -0.007115798071026802, 0.03116714023053646, -0.021397236734628677, 0.01842951588332653, 0.055681657046079636, 0.04247983172535896, -0.02281617745757103, 0.03387925773859024, 0.0012002530274912715, -0.03620832413434982, 0.0872381404042244, -0.02448618784546852, 0.010314206592738628, 0.03714926168322563, -0.004472808446735144, -0.02741778828203678, 0.010632198303937912, 0.05262795463204384, 0.025886904448270798, -0.042317502200603485, 0.003139588050544262, -0.0018566532526165247, -0.0156409814953804, -0.004918633494526148, -0.05716986954212189, -0.02499634586274624, -0.02325701341032982, -0.014156881719827652, 0.02714223973453045, 0.045119062066078186, -0.02126437798142433, -0.011684030294418335, 0.02729855105280876, -0.0550997219979763, -0.04214868322014809, -0.021384524181485176, 0.0018221766222268343, -0.010074730962514877, -0.01093091070652008, 0.012940525077283382, -0.0033233975991606712, 0.010807662270963192, -0.017988216131925583, -0.017502671107649803, -0.014055442996323109, -0.027341177687048912, 0.005481317173689604, -0.011555547825992107, 0.018024200573563576, 0.030196649953722954, 0.07850435376167297, 0.03246286138892174, 0.02235933020710945, -0.03475503623485565, 0.01833307556807995, 0.03954778239130974, -0.05453377217054367, 0.015274000354111195, -0.04928997531533241, -0.012034028768539429, -0.00012063955364283174, -0.03418709337711334, 0.008993428200483322, 0.03309749439358711, -0.011620844714343548, 0.0294666588306427, 0.06606807559728622, 0.03270060569047928, 0.031413640826940536, -0.027990618720650673, 0.006837945431470871, 0.03547558933496475, -0.03290412575006485, -0.03618691489100456, -0.03824691101908684, -0.001816199510358274, 0.04267166182398796, 0.01876530982553959, 0.006900478154420853, 0.05601944029331207, 0.05924871936440468, 0.01769494265317917, 0.007456812541931868, 0.05107652768492699, -0.023794207721948624, -0.010377139784395695, -0.02561136893928051, -0.020931849256157875, 0.0030457181856036186, -0.00022956346219871193, 0.015487520955502987, -0.007964760065078735, 0.05377404764294624, -0.03451455011963844, -0.005462272558361292, 0.03613719344139099, -0.019129086285829544, -0.008933871053159237, 0.0011493359925225377, -0.010465946979820728, 0.0448496975004673, -0.0020166197791695595, -0.0087251802906394, 0.023452669382095337, 0.016632769256830215, -0.01208981592208147, -0.007120779249817133, -0.017602089792490005, 0.05037930980324745, 0.05607204511761665, -0.0396573543548584, -0.023952558636665344, 0.014146084897220135, -0.022229241207242012, 0.012133080512285233, -0.05024152621626854, -0.042062245309352875, -0.0045693302527070045, 0.002092868322506547, 0.023876279592514038, 0.003427464049309492, -0.017893988639116287, 0.014775468036532402, 0.0004697905096691102, 0.012893800623714924, -0.02377680502831936, 0.013159495778381824, 0.022686250507831573, -0.0390644371509552, 0.0048064556904137135, -0.010725346393883228, 0.026165524497628212, 0.028462575748562813, 0.046706221997737885, -0.013978489674627781, 0.02600124105811119, 0.035887107253074646, -0.0743570625782013, -0.0670713558793068, -0.032176822423934937, -0.0030153817497193813, -0.032456982880830765, -0.036568328738212585, 0.03343534469604492, 0.032107699662446976, -0.01731603965163231, 0.02711072936654091, -0.050054874271154404, 0.01055646687746048, -0.017734264954924583, -0.0071312678046524525, -0.034701697528362274, -0.026325806975364685, 0.015409108251333237, -0.012144937179982662, -0.005372174549847841, -0.00007994004408828914, -0.07037003338336945, -0.08477374166250229, 0.028411922976374626, 0.011729806661605835, 0.02881871536374092, 0.02791246399283409, -0.042396679520606995, 0.033437687903642654, 0.030215734615921974, -0.004818744026124477, -0.05523621663451195, 0.05525301769375801, -0.011033795773983002, -0.04273894429206848, 0.026030177250504494, 0.00029023358365520835, 0.019230017438530922, 0.020936602726578712, -0.013749572448432446, 0.009935814887285233, 0.027914034202694893, 0.01906242035329342, 0.01670236326754093, 0.011198955588042736, -0.007901130244135857, -0.016523318365216255, 0.008066398091614246, 0.021774930879473686, -0.0010394720593467355, -0.02596944198012352, -0.019452055916190147, 0.04588215798139572, 0.0358206108212471, -0.04523564130067825, 0.04163948446512222, -0.07079609483480453, -0.018138019368052483, 0.0011025461135432124, 0.05727635324001312, 0.018726771697402, -0.02815023809671402, -0.018038785085082054, -0.016085298731923103, 0.011937124654650688, -0.01167554035782814, -0.004919880069792271, 0.05503120645880699, 0.022343672811985016, -0.034550637006759644, 0.0023784791119396687, -0.01838758774101734, -0.0180504210293293, 0.044327959418296814, -0.04011816531419754, 0.0013137556379660964, 0.06621035188436508, 0.042215265333652496, 0.028692767024040222, -0.001713722012937069, -0.022915443405508995, -0.019610028713941574, -0.03575069084763527, -0.025638354942202568, -0.011689441278576851, 0.058620549738407135, 0.005365945398807526, 0.046325117349624634, 0.04300447553396225, -0.013813545927405357, 0.019609589129686356, -0.01509055495262146, -0.05233261361718178, 0.010237202048301697, -0.016024569049477577, -0.03786120191216469, 0.008673015050590038, -0.010890021920204163, 0.034168120473623276, -0.03297196328639984, 0.01021323911845684, -0.02071232534945011, 0.018523316830396652, -0.07236960530281067, 0.04043024033308029, -0.04063871130347252, 0.007330205757170916, 0.005791487172245979, 0.01226704753935337, 0.04720597714185715, -0.027993466705083847, 0.0022672282066196203, 0.04846575856208801, 0.010846604593098164, 0.0027921015862375498, -0.027913471683859825, -0.0007827983354218304, 0.015534928999841213, 0.00791948102414608, 0.06137898936867714, 0.000837378203868866, -0.0387086421251297, 0.07276307046413422, 0.021786559373140335, 0.048495814204216, 0.0452641025185585, 0.034103669226169586, -0.022967223078012466, -0.008907794952392578, 0.022811347618699074, 0.005701031070202589, 0.032278839498758316, 0.00879701692610979, 0.02509607933461666, 0.03994281589984894, 0.013909786939620972, -0.036034755408763885, 0.027798490598797798, 0.06681463122367859, -0.019690366461873055, -0.019211364910006523, -0.04526456817984581, -0.033688828349113464, -0.03843389078974724, -0.009186730720102787, -0.011896161362528801, 0.019605793058872223, -0.027573630213737488, 0.024762393906712532, 0.04415300861001015, 0.002936598379164934, -0.011786519549787045, -0.0179817583411932, 0.030885955318808556, 0.04859250411391258, 0.03457094356417656, -0.034857429563999176, 0.00946184154599905, 0.03130478411912918, 0.025862880051136017, 0.02003016509115696, 0.03218521922826767, -0.08746126294136047, 0.010418646037578583, 0.0651857927441597, 0.007892625406384468, -0.06887268275022507, -0.03441629931330681, -0.02988443709909916, 0.0006927983486093581, 0.028543416410684586, -0.0040575298480689526, 0.04316982626914978, -0.023878561332821846, 0.046237070113420486, -0.034257352352142334, -0.03143184259533882, -0.044258564710617065, 0.03174453228712082, 0.003918424714356661, 0.03124840185046196, -0.036707211285829544, 0.003662960836663842, -0.030288366600871086, -0.011533382348716259, -0.012636705301702023, 0.052123334258794785, -0.007352488115429878, 0.006127343513071537, 0.020770424976944923, 0.053259290754795074, -0.03414272144436836, -0.05896235257387161, 0.03289056569337845, -0.006632308010011911, -0.010102348402142525, 0.013269350863993168, -0.039442624896764755, 0.006517689675092697, 0.02279837056994438, 0.04125037416815758, 0.004631659481674433, 0.003696545958518982, -0.009211531840264797, 0.028085829690098763, 0.0398140624165535, -0.002528147306293249, 0.029674578458070755, 0.046942319720983505, -0.01073452178388834, 0.015525546856224537, 0.0034859960433095694, -0.010873256251215935, -0.0017657269490882754, -0.02072339504957199, -0.022607065737247467, 0.01977444998919964, -0.038174647837877274, 0.0039279223419725895, -0.0331466980278492, 0.01594330184161663, -0.006311440374702215, 0.014371146447956562, -0.014320834539830685, 0.03512616455554962, -0.004981547128409147, -0.0005837992066517472, 0.007395130582153797, 0.028408801183104515, -0.02862199768424034, 0.0025765830650925636, -0.025685973465442657, 0.008495789021253586, 0.027592776343226433, -0.0019532484002411366, 0.005694699008017778, 0.0311429500579834, -0.010037188418209553, -0.03419404849410057, 0.02700849063694477, -0.035839103162288666, 0.025523871183395386, -0.05052364617586136, 0.030309617519378662, 0.007899395190179348, -0.023209255188703537, 0.004511801525950432, 0.034127987921237946, 0.01731293648481369, 0.01708759367465973, -0.010356412269175053, -0.008287351578474045, 0.01810970902442932, -0.013968197628855705, -0.021805748343467712, -0.0616876557469368, 0.05565103888511658, 0.022123748436570168, -0.04622635245323181, -0.0060347034595906734, -0.00990707240998745, -0.0022283666767179966, -0.02335595339536667, -0.02400168403983116, 0.04219284653663635, -0.030284026637673378, -0.014139058999717236, -0.005309062544256449, 0.012004959397017956, 0.06143542379140854, 0.009977235458791256, 0.008459117263555527, 0.035554856061935425, -0.005510746967047453, -0.018833789974451065, -0.0006027519120834768, -0.009639468975365162, -0.021332265809178352, 0.000016629210222163238, -0.03945581987500191, -0.016277611255645752, 0.04474421963095665, -0.031596485525369644, -0.03890170156955719, 0.050249818712472916, 0.002424961654469371, 0.018735354766249657, -0.0676712840795517, 0.0073326220735907555, 0.013728160411119461, 0.002897322876378894, -0.0013984845718368888, -0.021723926067352295, 0.007766153663396835, -0.033994562923908234, -0.010088464245200157, -0.03652723878622055, -0.024183789268136024, 0.02972857840359211, 0.04469611123204231, 0.0316997729241848, -0.003289442975074053, -0.021595744416117668, 0.040621545165777206, 0.012728937901556492, 0.02899228222668171, -0.002763030817732215, 0.008072827011346817, 0.019210465252399445, -0.04165084660053253, -0.006439978256821632, -0.03423495218157768, 0.022428294643759727, 0.0754687488079071, 0.004895828664302826, 0.05626621097326279, 0.014620449393987656, 0.03927190601825714, -0.0033935573883354664, -0.03724216669797897, -0.005634743254631758, -0.01292432751506567, -0.016069306060671806, 0.030003555119037628, -0.023993389680981636, -0.02662903256714344, 0.021723760291934013, 0.0494239516556263, -0.008393369615077972, 0.045777883380651474, 0.041722677648067474, -0.010435139760375023, 0.05269194021821022, -0.02068846859037876, -0.03184230998158455, 0.00461377901956439, -0.02705705538392067, 0.046248145401477814, -0.031123440712690353, 0.013465416617691517, 0.02100791037082672, 0.054715607315301895, 0.011353423818945885, -0.0727108046412468, -0.009343753568828106, -0.07101044803857803, 0.0385628268122673, 0.026239721104502678, -0.029645487666130066, 0.028408758342266083, 0.0362052395939827, 0.052437204867601395, -0.028820037841796875, 0.007691135164350271, -0.01006789319217205, -0.04987513646483421, -0.012062231078743935, -0.02327110432088375, -0.01910565234720707, 0.029720235615968704, -0.0413474515080452, -0.01748359017074108, -0.005959535948932171, -0.012604959309101105, -0.025865208357572556, 0.007450631819665432, 0.035807278007268906, 0.006331386975944042, 0.06499685347080231, -0.027630740776658058, -0.011123480275273323, 0.0014798659831285477, -0.011361639946699142, 0.13755178451538086, 0.04484676197171211, -0.008257919922471046, -0.06631768494844437, -0.007282438222318888, 0.03975483030080795, 0.015979256480932236, -0.026843314990401268, 0.04309849441051483, 0.015358436852693558, -0.057242780923843384, 0.052040498703718185, 0.052946124225854874, -0.01696166768670082, -0.005682915449142456, 0.03754328936338425, -0.040651001036167145, -0.01730555295944214, 0.0024610122200101614, 0.02296615205705166, -0.013858010992407799, -0.01749386638402939, -0.035437263548374176, 0.03941172733902931, -0.012011539191007614, -0.029419420287013054, 0.022251131013035774, -0.033993177115917206, 0.004085981752723455, 0.0009379425900988281, -0.037433091551065445, 0.007121736649423838, 0.018470706418156624, 0.03537904843688011, -0.00552128441631794, -0.0186020415276289, -0.023389732465147972, -0.02603141963481903, 0.020862605422735214, 0.0214699599891901, -0.03322645649313927, -0.02093636617064476, -0.0028166223783046007, -0.023709440603852272, -0.02746942639350891, -0.029832035303115845, -0.0846697986125946, 0.03792248293757439, 0.01807265169918537, -0.05498209223151207, -0.01416812278330326, -0.015057443641126156, 0.005950042977929115, -0.01946263760328293, -0.02235846221446991, 0.031193897128105164, 0.027732986956834793, -0.021038195118308067, -0.004050752148032188, 0.01031880546361208, 0.01422810461372137, 0.01981448568403721, 0.0450340174138546, 0.015292463824152946, -0.05219127610325813, 0.03641245514154434, -0.002034796169027686, 0.056238409131765366, 0.020500948652625084, -0.001273688510991633, 0.02658865600824356, -0.009789477102458477, 0.002560935216024518, -0.009927673265337944, -0.009726636111736298, 0.005068326368927956, 0.02982497215270996, 0.023416416719555855, 0.0023671858943998814, 0.007274840958416462, -0.04417259991168976, 0.027579842135310173, -0.016544993966817856, -0.0058244625106453896, -0.061991799622774124, 0.04403698444366455, 0.06538161635398865, 0.05414072424173355, 0.03265343979001045, -0.0015231422148644924, 0.013028626330196857, 0.059899382293224335, 0.048797667026519775, -0.06119511276483536, -0.012625877745449543, 0.02003595232963562, -0.027497589588165283, -0.022602664306759834, -0.07558233290910721, 0.04174771159887314, 0.05401289835572243, -0.024198291823267937, -0.012205083854496479, 0.04866986721754074, 0.010734283365309238, -0.015791213139891624, 0.04463609308004379, -0.03756430000066757, 0.016202174127101898, -0.02422325685620308, -0.031188085675239563, -0.036754295229911804, -0.039350882172584534, -0.05032848194241524, -0.0160725936293602, -0.01420056913048029, -0.07365532219409943, -0.059031929820775986, 0.036004990339279175, -0.0016248560277745128, -0.0439932644367218, -0.02910788170993328, -0.007095518056303263, -0.02639913558959961, 0.020458420738577843, 0.017882274463772774, -0.009772072546184063, -0.018224559724330902, 0.02757543884217739, -0.012667729519307613, 0.00001447924387321109, 0.03945206478238106, 0.05570157244801521, 0.003025313140824437, -0.025195306167006493, 0.019195066764950752, -0.013628169894218445, 0.060261957347393036, 0.010821071453392506, 0.00672821095213294, -0.015504863113164902, -0.03890429437160492, -0.02907782793045044, 0.026351284235715866, 0.013576675206422806, -0.008959575556218624, -0.009143967181444168, -0.0005491325282491744, -0.014789920300245285, 0.025419440120458603, -0.019701490178704262, 0.007902625948190689, -0.023608023300766945, 0.02682046964764595, 0.0010948581621050835, 0.0020977386739104986, -0.015008553862571716, 0.019373148679733276, 0.015645045787096024, -0.011865527369081974, 0.010684727691113949, -0.010645519010722637, 0.005448045674711466, -0.0017594031523913145, -0.02916569821536541, -0.0034258903469890356, 0.013675954192876816, -0.026576800271868706, 0.03752310946583748, 0.08175156265497208, -0.022250419482588768, 0.011432460509240627, 0.009255679324269295, -0.032148391008377075, -0.07662754505872726, -0.024593742564320564, -0.00048746992251835763, 0.032258037477731705, 0.012162856757640839, -0.006809645798057318, 0.03880217671394348, 0.03688858076930046, -0.020446160808205605, 0.014036000706255436, 0.002611769363284111, 0.03243904933333397, -0.018303703516721725, -0.033828094601631165, 0.009279764257371426, 0.037716299295425415, 0.042923640459775925, -0.00453898124396801, 0.051006291061639786, 0.03590346500277519, 0.004687726031988859, -0.020822182297706604, 0.031634923070669174, 0.018419714644551277, 0.017311671748757362, -0.09292735159397125, 0.016508502885699272, -0.02528194896876812, -0.02932889759540558, 0.006061682943254709, -0.029485680162906647, 0.008959882892668247, 0.025753937661647797, 0.00006029194992152043, 0.0019118711352348328, 0.04771397262811661, 0.03981701284646988, 0.0173766128718853, -0.009189126081764698, -0.009420463815331459, -0.008585836738348007, 0.03035888634622097, -0.022982282564044, -0.010476295836269855, -0.04184756428003311, -0.022577451542019844, -0.04694990813732147, 0.005125375930219889, -0.023566262796521187, -0.014514928683638573, -0.00206428999081254, -0.03217322751879692, -0.0237310491502285, -0.01898573525249958, -0.021413380280137062, 0.007828005589544773, -0.029893087223172188, 0.03065336123108864, 0.05509326606988907, -0.017212120816111565, -0.03560304641723633, -0.01587294600903988, -0.05910611152648926, 0.021066905930638313, 0.03204109147191048, -0.012898754328489304, -0.07820093631744385, -0.016711344942450523, -0.005003378726541996, -0.012493496760725975, -0.04071047529578209, 0.029360635206103325, 0.009042934514582157, 0.047503743320703506, -0.008636676706373692, -0.03958069905638695, 0.002206910867244005, -0.026935899630188942, 0.028100375086069107, -0.06365590542554855, 0.04583200067281723, 0.02440938726067543, -0.019528601318597794, 0.020470745861530304, 0.012557726353406906, -0.06917132437229156, -0.013834647834300995, 0.028363138437271118, -0.013754041865468025, -0.00026405081734992564, 0.0029256015550345182, 0.02731993794441223, 0.005223400425165892, -0.00406278483569622, 0.02677658572793007, -0.012727714143693447, -0.007836355827748775, 0.03659951314330101, -0.023735174909234047, -0.0036499553825706244, 0.03868096321821213, 0.025568779557943344, -0.01537557877600193, 0.026076659560203552, 0.03009989857673645, 0.0021795479115098715, 0.01587957702577114, 0.010773934423923492, -0.02222554013133049, 0.06770095974206924, -0.007855797186493874, 0.009014218114316463, 0.014957724139094353, 0.0014059309614822268, -0.054902758449316025, 0.03321092948317528, -0.0690549910068512, -0.034348681569099426, -0.02395089715719223, -0.0075093782506883144, -0.017447644844651222, -0.05520153418183327, -0.019659873098134995, 0.004624864552170038, -0.00994885340332985, -0.0004496188194025308, -0.0059612588956952095, -0.015735521912574768, 0.035743918269872665, 0.021044692024588585, 0.03804253786802292, 0.0030003441497683525, -0.030930902808904648, 0.04813152179121971, 0.014254617504775524, 0.028914064168930054, -0.013926415704190731, 0.0006084166234359145, 0.02243630960583687, -0.023295007646083832, 0.02411574497818947, -0.011930885724723339, 0.02792278677225113, 0.01994429901242256, -0.019905846565961838, 0.018611909821629524, -0.006955910474061966, 0.01803499087691307, 0.009416245855391026, 0.001481353770941496, 0.032922081649303436, -0.025414634495973587, 0.016898997128009796, -0.002654224867001176, -0.01956997625529766, -0.045045964419841766, 0.03543486073613167, 0.004657258745282888, -0.010502845980226994, -0.03173668682575226, 0.02881034091114998, 0.040650203824043274, 0.011487881653010845, 0.027366304770112038, -0.02431103214621544, -0.015406087040901184, -0.006181556265801191, -0.01990872249007225, -0.026131749153137207, -0.016904693096876144, -0.059702496975660324, -0.04729362577199936, 0.010809711180627346, -0.0030358692165464163, -0.023174988105893135, -0.0215773843228817, -0.006271233316510916, -0.01399872824549675, -0.015830451622605324, -0.06984848529100418, -0.0039883083663880825, -0.0225966963917017, 0.023305049166083336, -0.03129250928759575, -0.0390242300927639 ]