id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14091v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14091v1 | Protecting Privacy Through Approximating Optimal Parameters for Sequence Unlearning in Language Models | 2024-06-20T08:12:49 | 2024-06-20T08:12:49 | Dohyun Lee, Daniel Rim, Minseok Choi, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although language models (LMs) demonstrate exceptional capabilities on
various tasks, they are potentially vulnerable to extraction attacks, which
represent a significant privacy risk. To mitigate the privacy concerns of LMs,
machine unlearning has emerged as an important research area, which is utilized
to induce the LM to selectively forget about some of its training data. While
completely retraining the model will guarantee successful unlearning and
privacy assurance, it is impractical for LMs, as it would be time-consuming and
resource-intensive. Prior works efficiently unlearn the target token sequences,
but upon subsequent iterations, the LM displays significant degradation in
performance. In this work, we propose Privacy Protection via Optimal Parameters
(POP), a novel unlearning method that effectively forgets the target token
sequences from the pretrained LM by applying optimal gradient updates to the
parameters. Inspired by the gradient derivation of complete retraining, we
approximate the optimal training objective that successfully unlearns the
target sequence while retaining the knowledge from the rest of the training
data. Experimental results demonstrate that POP exhibits remarkable retention
performance post-unlearning across 9 classification and 4 dialogue benchmarks,
outperforming the state-of-the-art by a large margin. Furthermore, we introduce
Remnant Memorization Accuracy that quantifies privacy risks based on token
likelihood and validate its effectiveness through both qualitative and
quantitative analyses. | [
-0.09335478395223618,
-0.5977759957313538,
0.07759338617324829,
-0.2057868242263794,
-0.3796728849411011,
0.28887510299682617,
-0.3156804144382477,
0.059536296874284744,
-0.33899742364883423,
0.6647320985794067,
-0.4395536780357361,
-0.4992605447769165,
-0.48578789830207825,
-0.38606566190719604,
-0.37590837478637695,
1.004881501197815,
0.3908426761627197,
-0.07028226554393768,
0.14243841171264648,
0.0379464216530323,
-0.1092342808842659,
-0.599500298500061,
-0.41349539160728455,
0.023982146754860878,
0.18937043845653534,
0.26508188247680664,
0.3868376314640045,
0.8104309439659119,
-0.03485962375998497,
0.31362807750701904,
-0.3568369150161743,
0.31331560015678406,
-0.7191466093063354,
0.2635694146156311,
-0.02731643058359623,
-0.49163469672203064,
0.08647163957357407,
-0.043400149792432785,
0.9652433395385742,
0.932511568069458,
-0.23800911009311676,
0.13071560859680176,
0.295244961977005,
0.836421549320221,
-0.9666798710823059,
0.004354589153081179,
-0.83700031042099,
0.2043573260307312,
0.0489112064242363,
-0.48003289103507996,
-0.6979878544807434,
-0.35236215591430664,
0.07692688703536987,
-0.3337976634502411,
0.17411857843399048,
0.15779820084571838,
0.7113794088363647,
0.3293730616569519,
-0.14608100056648254,
0.07716561108827591,
-0.6621346473693848,
0.8294020295143127,
-0.6099020838737488,
0.6303704380989075,
0.6092051863670349,
0.011914821341633797,
-0.5678694248199463,
-0.5937866568565369,
0.02697567827999592,
-0.17283202707767487,
-0.05349964275956154,
-0.14293110370635986,
-0.24549122154712677,
0.1195731982588768,
0.3538755774497986,
0.3869381248950958,
-0.48156580328941345,
0.3496679663658142,
-0.4773206412792206,
-0.5023004412651062,
0.38879427313804626,
-0.17488513886928558,
0.08639375120401382,
0.010550425387918949,
-0.561070442199707,
0.03869015350937843,
-0.7670028209686279,
0.5197699069976807,
0.6448188424110413,
0.2509820759296417,
0.24591514468193054,
0.24383358657360077,
0.07289297133684158,
0.5211260318756104,
0.14170657098293304,
-0.20305609703063965,
0.4644414484500885,
-0.04551384970545769,
-0.11004335433244705,
-0.1717042177915573,
0.932038426399231,
0.07013367861509323,
0.40428340435028076,
-0.5313692092895508,
-0.1949062943458557,
-0.6518913507461548,
0.16105115413665771,
-0.6206969022750854,
0.03115246258676052,
0.3482784330844879,
-0.4889865219593048,
-0.23723316192626953,
0.246750146150589,
-0.940242350101471,
-0.2547507882118225,
-0.09652908891439438,
0.30159780383110046,
-0.5206183195114136,
-0.2592930793762207,
-0.02338394708931446,
0.03907417878508568,
-0.19037951529026031,
-0.24789531528949738,
-0.9666804075241089,
0.3359535336494446,
0.7758584022521973,
0.7370734810829163,
-0.05330473184585571,
-0.3688620924949646,
-0.8383174538612366,
0.19088801741600037,
-0.2914524972438812,
0.01911262422800064,
-0.5815861821174622,
-0.7539324164390564,
0.07886224240064621,
-0.04894920811057091,
-0.27857279777526855,
-0.4960439205169678,
0.2869643270969391,
-0.5216686129570007,
0.5412622094154358,
0.285007506608963,
-0.9931991696357727,
-0.1193646565079689,
-0.18584010004997253,
-0.56825852394104,
0.9511778354644775,
0.08855593204498291,
-0.6704012751579285,
0.2631193697452545,
-0.5998243689537048,
-0.2828421890735626,
-0.12284789979457855,
-0.019668515771627426,
-0.6437618732452393,
0.2396751046180725,
0.14563317596912384,
0.450918972492218,
0.10327930003404617,
0.22583746910095215,
-0.12512393295764923,
-0.39137956500053406,
0.4736872911453247,
-0.6548393368721008,
0.9295313954353333,
0.3148251473903656,
-0.3894977867603302,
0.09099016338586807,
-0.8508013486862183,
0.19686535000801086,
-0.12825483083724976,
-0.4552304148674011,
-0.44032663106918335,
-0.2941681444644928,
-0.5468783974647522,
0.0024873395450413227,
0.3832314908504486,
-0.6006655693054199,
-0.1858787089586258,
-0.6501269936561584,
0.4359806776046753,
1.0209993124008179,
0.23721793293952942,
0.8545302152633667,
-0.0854826495051384,
0.4684785306453705,
0.0703255757689476,
0.44065046310424805,
-0.5900593996047974,
-0.4008103013038635,
-0.3529808521270752,
-0.5399069786071777,
0.6060505509376526,
0.5694884657859802,
-0.057417355477809906,
0.7412112355232239,
-0.09006386250257492,
-0.3177420496940613,
-0.4887232184410095,
0.3662179112434387,
0.9245671033859253,
0.5297954082489014,
0.06151942163705826,
-0.3248162269592285,
-0.4278159439563751,
-0.7313780188560486,
-0.6246830821037292,
-0.17346665263175964,
-0.07827477902173996,
0.13799460232257843,
0.08021555840969086,
0.08042194694280624,
0.9825029373168945,
-0.32543542981147766,
-0.11756906658411026,
-0.09837739914655685,
0.041901595890522,
0.08849840611219406,
0.6130179166793823,
0.2950131893157959,
-0.8160777688026428,
-0.19973444938659668,
-0.1701934039592743,
-0.38129302859306335,
-0.011158178560435772,
-0.08867078274488449,
-0.18409773707389832,
0.47572728991508484,
0.44256606698036194,
-0.4911135733127594,
0.7824334502220154,
0.2821582555770874,
-0.02222529612481594,
0.24836723506450653,
-0.5093063116073608,
-0.40508341789245605,
-1.0781173706054688,
0.24158687889575958,
-0.28926315903663635,
-0.4569474160671234,
-0.8699227571487427,
-0.07323987782001495,
0.015037243254482746,
-0.2340359091758728,
-0.7485827803611755,
0.6274819374084473,
-0.688377320766449,
-0.012567517347633839,
-0.2516290247440338,
-0.26137036085128784,
-0.23040294647216797,
0.8524481058120728,
-0.06077495589852333,
0.6064963936805725,
0.663966715335846,
-0.7121778726577759,
-0.2553667724132538,
0.0037101353518664837,
-0.2346924990415573,
-0.019453629851341248,
-0.28938043117523193,
0.3663063645362854,
-0.26865580677986145,
-0.03657376393675804,
-0.7902909517288208,
0.22616839408874512,
0.363751620054245,
-0.5874428749084473,
0.6041539311408997,
-0.43023961782455444,
-0.38097983598709106,
-0.05065545067191124,
-0.42839860916137695,
0.14367873966693878,
1.0684453248977661,
-0.6006001234054565,
0.6600819826126099,
0.5720534324645996,
0.17865288257598877,
-1.1341108083724976,
-0.23753005266189575,
-0.2596644461154938,
-0.43298348784446716,
-0.041068561375141144,
0.20221026241779327,
-0.09026355296373367,
0.09687057882547379,
-0.1388767510652542,
-0.18815568089485168,
-0.18939591944217682,
0.12484592944383621,
0.5067225694656372,
0.022942764684557915,
0.17861686646938324,
-0.2347223311662674,
-0.13704629242420197,
-0.5790880918502808,
-0.03445867821574211,
-0.488359659910202,
0.7031641006469727,
-0.10542139410972595,
-0.31672021746635437,
-0.548193097114563,
0.45738205313682556,
0.5684110522270203,
-0.23089787364006042,
0.9389212131500244,
0.5930073857307434,
-0.5025593042373657,
-0.4148639738559723,
-0.42938432097435,
-0.2143785059452057,
-0.5187687873840332,
0.24023781716823578,
-0.13047169148921967,
-0.9107403755187988,
0.585611879825592,
-0.2214994728565216,
0.45913442969322205,
-0.03662630170583725,
0.4753314256668091,
0.05269758030772209,
0.7119980454444885,
0.5428422093391418,
-0.41127753257751465,
0.6587108969688416,
-0.19722244143486023,
0.35474511981010437,
-0.8234027028083801,
-0.41453298926353455,
-0.288072794675827,
-0.12911617755889893,
-0.5436983704566956,
-0.19614188373088837,
0.15141741931438446,
0.3426663875579834,
-0.37355759739875793,
0.3032906651496887,
-0.3676462769508362,
0.8421141505241394,
0.9967813491821289,
0.1287374645471573,
0.24546702206134796,
0.4070160388946533,
-0.30057165026664734,
0.10024536401033401,
-0.5620196461677551,
-0.41518211364746094,
1.3102768659591675,
0.452079176902771,
0.531299889087677,
-0.044332023710012436,
0.9643992185592651,
0.18994998931884766,
-0.09901861101388931,
-0.3132903277873993,
0.5386162996292114,
-0.23746182024478912,
-0.525579035282135,
-0.4497239589691162,
-0.6689119338989258,
-1.0796349048614502,
0.3224116563796997,
0.20184221863746643,
-1.2875865697860718,
0.21797747910022736,
0.3754468262195587,
-0.4166007936000824,
0.6302743554115295,
-0.5679353475570679,
0.7503156661987305,
-0.17170754075050354,
-0.4199599325656891,
0.18510079383850098,
-1.060986042022705,
0.24373255670070648,
-0.3316206932067871,
0.26232829689979553,
-0.020501358434557915,
-0.04904206469655037,
0.6994926333427429,
-0.5813029408454895,
1.1290210485458374,
-0.45910850167274475,
0.08560703694820404,
0.18459062278270721,
0.20517989993095398,
0.43918800354003906,
-0.16463740170001984,
0.05358743667602539,
0.26821449398994446,
-0.02459610439836979,
-0.3683503568172455,
-0.7019649147987366,
0.49733617901802063,
-0.5814866423606873,
-0.6355341672897339,
-0.22335143387317657,
-0.3320394456386566,
-0.29998135566711426,
0.3266737461090088,
0.5511279702186584,
0.31611818075180054,
-0.1499251127243042,
0.20084351301193237,
0.611890435218811,
-0.24531672894954681,
0.8915742635726929,
0.7145180106163025,
-0.1347004771232605,
-0.43093881011009216,
1.0763825178146362,
-0.0007526630070060492,
0.4384481906890869,
0.5030829310417175,
0.5202951431274414,
-0.6909968256950378,
-0.730124831199646,
-0.3469756543636322,
0.16498950123786926,
-0.6328527331352234,
-0.007644839584827423,
-0.5366848707199097,
-0.3735165596008301,
-0.05348803475499153,
0.16972215473651886,
-0.49658820033073425,
-0.5519506931304932,
-0.482097327709198,
-0.256241112947464,
0.30190810561180115,
0.19738198816776276,
-0.4807445704936981,
0.24361881613731384,
-0.9131541848182678,
-0.05825134366750717,
-0.11102388799190521,
0.4260362982749939,
0.08665311336517334,
-0.859017014503479,
0.10630796104669571,
0.1300075501203537,
-0.12866850197315216,
-0.5775171518325806,
0.41092824935913086,
0.38492634892463684,
0.6976154446601868,
0.6760416626930237,
0.1786886304616928,
0.6006855368614197,
-0.7182591557502747,
0.5906168818473816,
0.2668130695819855,
-0.9020510911941528,
0.3501211702823639,
-0.19749218225479126,
-0.15779760479927063,
0.7267770171165466,
0.2960646152496338,
-0.3486854135990143,
-0.21869979798793793,
-0.9680564999580383,
-1.03426194190979,
0.547821581363678,
0.192636176943779,
0.31732088327407837,
0.19912457466125488,
0.5703567862510681,
0.36007893085479736,
0.4910375773906708,
-0.40011435747146606,
-0.4497537910938263,
0.0030109332874417305,
-0.215208500623703,
0.004647526890039444,
-0.1940925568342209,
0.0227520614862442,
-0.11308971047401428,
0.5580339431762695,
0.19555523991584778,
0.04043014720082283,
-0.41574957966804504,
-0.14409229159355164,
0.01842213235795498,
0.2440318614244461,
0.49800416827201843,
0.6804355978965759,
-0.20684552192687988,
0.049046095460653305,
0.04385044798254967,
-0.5258435606956482,
0.2845878601074219,
-0.10438276082277298,
-0.45200666785240173,
0.07086779177188873,
0.07455646246671677,
0.6105514168739319,
0.4052504897117615,
-0.8008238673210144,
0.6695404648780823,
0.10222063958644867,
0.07298242300748825,
-0.46954795718193054,
0.2671644389629364,
-0.23335769772529602,
-0.17907418310642242,
0.30341386795043945,
0.10320515185594559,
-0.07100841403007507,
-0.31036806106567383,
0.7146458029747009,
0.40122583508491516,
-0.5112332105636597,
-0.2403707206249237,
0.598897397518158,
0.03980058804154396,
-0.7175348997116089,
0.4925251603126526,
0.0038280272856354713,
-0.5155195593833923,
0.18677963316440582,
0.5339797735214233,
0.8891323804855347,
-0.6435273885726929,
0.17737853527069092,
0.10529672354459763,
0.10077676177024841,
-0.3018033802509308,
0.13045135140419006,
-0.04363948479294777,
-0.5063509941101074,
-0.005814946722239256,
-0.4846087694168091,
-0.28248330950737,
0.30758169293403625,
-0.7922590374946594,
-0.256948858499527,
-0.919871985912323,
0.024832187220454216,
-0.42505156993865967,
-0.26525694131851196,
-0.41552025079727173,
0.04614453390240669,
-0.1892542988061905,
0.6783182621002197,
-0.4206170439720154,
0.4992227256298065,
0.07100851088762283,
-0.40974023938179016,
-0.7595529556274414,
-0.16072048246860504,
0.2872258722782135,
-1.0470398664474487,
0.37331104278564453,
0.09377263486385345,
-0.10832029581069946,
-0.08336947858333588,
-0.23429608345031738,
-0.8182333707809448,
0.5315675735473633,
0.5795221328735352,
-0.8396090269088745,
0.24341771006584167,
0.4145200550556183,
0.33234596252441406,
-0.23171214759349823,
0.026753226295113564,
0.5895644426345825,
-0.008393079973757267,
0.05007011443376541,
-0.6978706121444702,
-0.038349397480487823,
-0.28299346566200256,
-0.2510965168476105,
0.31206703186035156,
-0.5408895611763,
0.6756612062454224,
-0.3309299647808075,
-0.2233520895242691,
0.2503232955932617,
0.5467698574066162,
0.15498600900173187,
0.08820450305938721,
0.6795072555541992,
0.40012216567993164,
1.1858500242233276,
0.15897247195243835,
0.9320099949836731,
-0.5182780027389526,
0.23708027601242065,
1.1055161952972412,
0.027660280466079712,
0.8942338228225708,
0.37483155727386475,
0.05755941569805145,
0.08234312385320663,
0.7629441618919373,
0.2707156538963318,
0.7215656638145447,
0.5632382035255432,
-0.34972140192985535,
-0.016273746266961098,
-0.0037656014319509268,
-0.29037025570869446,
0.2550332844257355,
0.16817690432071686,
-0.7600717544555664,
0.09419960528612137,
-0.15800899267196655,
0.47528642416000366,
0.005096285603940487,
-0.11473531275987625,
0.849661111831665,
0.15894527733325958,
-0.3813066780567169,
0.6750316619873047,
-0.10437595844268799,
0.35160765051841736,
-0.6521210074424744,
0.290667325258255,
-0.4027576446533203,
0.452811062335968,
-0.12115482240915298,
-0.3519010841846466,
-0.06625091284513474,
0.12095228582620621,
-0.14430969953536987,
-0.2220466285943985,
0.3242475092411041,
-0.6603897213935852,
-0.4262503981590271,
0.18094736337661743,
0.3228474259376526,
0.3699452877044678,
-0.001956478226929903,
-0.7269150018692017,
-0.2135041058063507,
0.13836389780044556,
-0.3472500443458557,
0.6014642715454102,
0.24226868152618408,
0.12489435076713562,
0.8152285814285278,
0.9643444418907166,
0.13920371234416962,
0.38281890749931335,
0.3261282444000244,
0.8007789254188538,
-0.5336036682128906,
-0.710567831993103,
-1.1415460109710693,
0.4628150165081024,
-0.15174835920333862,
-0.4899788796901703,
0.7382498383522034,
0.733478307723999,
0.8128419518470764,
0.11021194607019424,
0.7499570846557617,
0.5774742364883423,
0.6840072274208069,
-0.7062995433807373,
0.7447173595428467,
-0.3994138538837433,
0.5401905179023743,
-0.2144266813993454,
-0.9487764239311218,
-0.4508788287639618,
0.4756143093109131,
-0.055760033428668976,
0.29229027032852173,
0.537979006767273,
0.9533587694168091,
0.06450393050909042,
0.09932758659124374,
0.4197184145450592,
-0.0666671171784401,
0.4051593840122223,
0.6861785650253296,
0.8403637409210205,
-0.2720499336719513,
0.4701670706272125,
-0.4329085350036621,
-0.329364150762558,
0.08221802115440369,
-0.9429614543914795,
-1.1493475437164307,
-0.6060347557067871,
-0.19486956298351288,
-0.27126362919807434,
0.24353790283203125,
0.9764924645423889,
0.782638430595398,
-0.7779027223587036,
0.010446383617818356,
0.07967492938041687,
0.09511815011501312,
-0.09744773805141449,
-0.11185169219970703,
0.7289877533912659,
-0.23434589803218842,
-0.6725330948829651,
0.5240778923034668,
0.2980479598045349,
0.1261170655488968,
-0.2910335063934326,
-0.13098761439323425,
0.15864789485931396,
-0.1304854154586792,
0.029690347611904144,
0.836872398853302,
-0.7488508224487305,
-0.17364686727523804,
-0.03351761773228645,
0.36844465136528015,
0.0309587512165308,
1.1095155477523804,
-0.5394711494445801,
0.34080734848976135,
0.3003798723220825,
0.9783894419670105,
0.22198407351970673,
0.3228510916233063,
0.5746305584907532,
-1.0971426963806152,
0.3294087052345276,
0.1228409931063652,
0.5698208212852478,
0.33074522018432617,
-0.5052279829978943,
0.22610728442668915,
0.1286458671092987,
-0.36847570538520813,
-1.1498175859451294,
0.20055824518203735,
-0.578036367893219,
-0.2958069145679474,
0.984075665473938,
-0.513759195804596,
-0.5654376149177551,
-0.29458263516426086,
-0.022420449182391167,
0.1333089917898178,
-0.615216076374054,
0.7811079621315002,
0.25926297903060913,
0.042920179665088654,
-0.2656308710575104,
-0.07691965252161026,
0.7550538182258606,
0.49709123373031616,
-0.24806086719036102,
0.4917111098766327,
0.17343412339687347,
0.4268547594547272,
-0.0771317332983017,
0.5285647511482239,
-0.33197465538978577,
0.0680762454867363,
-0.29651159048080444,
-0.4392347037792206,
-0.5421537756919861,
-0.5728866457939148,
-0.41198235750198364,
0.33645761013031006,
-0.21400074660778046,
-0.6980902552604675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14088v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14088v1 | ReaLHF: Optimized RLHF Training for Large Language Models through Parameter Reallocation | 2024-06-20T08:04:07 | 2024-06-20T08:04:07 | Zhiyu Mei, Wei Fu, Kaiwei Li, Guangju Wang, Huanchen Zhang, Yi Wu | cs.DC | cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) stands as a pivotal
technique in empowering large language model (LLM) applications. Since RLHF
involves diverse computational workloads and intricate dependencies among
multiple LLMs, directly adopting parallelization techniques from supervised
training can result in sub-optimal performance. To overcome this limitation, we
propose a novel approach named parameter ReaLlocation, which dynamically
redistributes LLM parameters in the cluster and adapts parallelization
strategies during training. Building upon this idea, we introduce ReaLHF, a
pioneering system capable of automatically discovering and running efficient
execution plans for RLHF training given the desired algorithmic and hardware
configurations. ReaLHF formulates the execution plan for RLHF as an augmented
dataflow graph. Based on this formulation, ReaLHF employs a tailored search
algorithm with a lightweight cost estimator to discover an efficient execution
plan. Subsequently, the runtime engine deploys the selected plan by effectively
parallelizing computations and redistributing parameters. We evaluate ReaLHF on
the LLaMA-2 models with up to $4\times70$ billion parameters and 128 GPUs. The
experiment results showcase ReaLHF's substantial speedups of $2.0-10.6\times$
compared to baselines. Furthermore, the execution plans generated by ReaLHF
exhibit an average of $26\%$ performance improvement over heuristic approaches
based on Megatron-LM. The source code of ReaLHF is publicly available at
https://github.com/openpsi-project/ReaLHF . | [
-0.5179970860481262,
-0.978420078754425,
0.6236866116523743,
0.10510341078042984,
-0.2146497666835785,
0.2623489797115326,
-0.4665461778640747,
-0.5479920506477356,
0.1630903035402298,
0.4852048456668854,
-0.8321775197982788,
-0.2755586504936218,
-0.3036220669746399,
-0.24820344150066376,
-0.15629446506500244,
0.6744475960731506,
-0.21633602678775787,
-0.04916111007332802,
-0.17061357200145721,
-0.22538436949253082,
0.026284970343112946,
-0.5727329850196838,
-0.6098889708518982,
-0.5240708589553833,
0.867881178855896,
0.5996583104133606,
0.9652559757232666,
1.1804083585739136,
0.520868182182312,
0.23588186502456665,
0.05516225844621658,
0.24621422588825226,
-0.5594644546508789,
0.21785378456115723,
-0.011479026637971401,
-0.3757491707801819,
-0.08434934914112091,
-0.2299765646457672,
0.9750138521194458,
0.41451436281204224,
-0.7537572979927063,
0.2974461019039154,
-0.49506065249443054,
0.74864262342453,
-0.6170331835746765,
0.22634528577327728,
-0.10719538480043411,
0.32363656163215637,
-0.03507338836789131,
-0.1743030995130539,
-0.21694912016391754,
-0.4673290550708771,
0.1726357340812683,
-0.6074117422103882,
0.011957371607422829,
0.3632771372795105,
1.005433440208435,
0.46375760436058044,
0.013915974646806717,
0.12661398947238922,
-0.9338604211807251,
0.9551277756690979,
-0.716006875038147,
0.6632528901100159,
0.038507990539073944,
0.6174922585487366,
-0.27918440103530884,
-0.6664413213729858,
-0.6471149325370789,
-0.49459588527679443,
-0.006899520289152861,
-0.20722506940364838,
0.32262909412384033,
0.35858166217803955,
0.3670506477355957,
0.11574757099151611,
-0.6751348972320557,
0.38869982957839966,
-0.349957138299942,
-0.1712605506181717,
0.5849406123161316,
0.27257561683654785,
0.06940873712301254,
0.28287890553474426,
-0.11489935219287872,
-0.41425010561943054,
-0.7592049241065979,
-0.19553126394748688,
0.7386067509651184,
0.33365389704704285,
-0.2099243849515915,
0.12452445179224014,
-0.3528387248516083,
0.9134950637817383,
-0.11161181330680847,
-0.4344116747379303,
0.14897271990776062,
0.08123794198036194,
-0.03953768312931061,
0.09340260922908783,
0.6750290393829346,
-0.19576039910316467,
0.4505724012851715,
-0.17518390715122223,
-0.21719594299793243,
-0.39258143305778503,
0.513126015663147,
-1.0346332788467407,
-0.09261658787727356,
0.19594797492027283,
-0.4818830192089081,
-0.4656399190425873,
0.14659219980239868,
-0.7528867721557617,
-0.0782327651977539,
-0.3439675271511078,
-0.012373904697597027,
0.024572184309363365,
-0.3746451437473297,
-0.21634253859519958,
0.23683330416679382,
0.0911005288362503,
0.05190318450331688,
-0.9801172614097595,
0.36927056312561035,
0.7826070785522461,
0.6670776009559631,
-0.15974591672420502,
-0.7060109376907349,
-0.9383091926574707,
0.13653415441513062,
-0.32183292508125305,
0.6289367079734802,
-0.6551247835159302,
-0.21420074999332428,
0.13127553462982178,
-0.09769826382398605,
-0.07349351793527603,
-1.0464369058609009,
0.41292110085487366,
-0.8214907646179199,
0.0009687803685665131,
-0.24694810807704926,
-0.3844357132911682,
-0.15828275680541992,
0.11188384145498276,
-0.6728808283805847,
1.125747799873352,
0.15109236538410187,
-0.5466568470001221,
0.12451503425836563,
-0.6889985203742981,
-0.31011760234832764,
-0.09417671710252762,
-0.1747235208749771,
-0.7652210593223572,
-0.22091126441955566,
0.06566017121076584,
0.3169865310192108,
-0.43126630783081055,
0.4551795721054077,
-0.5276106595993042,
-0.6178417801856995,
0.07493219524621964,
-0.3043758273124695,
0.1617264300584793,
0.29569128155708313,
-0.4502398669719696,
0.6535449624061584,
-0.7352390289306641,
0.04534256458282471,
0.18540000915527344,
-0.652588963508606,
0.3456152379512787,
0.20899105072021484,
0.10229242593050003,
0.10220732539892197,
-0.006436403840780258,
-0.40975117683410645,
0.07137414067983627,
-0.5831465721130371,
0.37161675095558167,
0.5408299565315247,
0.0136195607483387,
0.3222993016242981,
-0.16126397252082825,
0.8653355240821838,
-0.21594884991645813,
0.3427211046218872,
0.1486882120370865,
-0.19724524021148682,
-0.6487014293670654,
-0.4289650321006775,
0.33823132514953613,
0.6392807960510254,
-0.40626218914985657,
0.3599575459957123,
-0.06936182081699371,
-0.396332710981369,
-0.593233048915863,
0.1089467778801918,
0.6739203333854675,
0.607537031173706,
0.33032745122909546,
0.2028862088918686,
-0.44267311692237854,
-1.1225136518478394,
-0.09694365411996841,
-0.3053017854690552,
0.19410207867622375,
0.27243995666503906,
0.3647806942462921,
-0.2612728476524353,
0.792637825012207,
-0.7902079820632935,
0.022413847967982292,
-0.2824168801307678,
0.2698172926902771,
0.10352612286806107,
0.3728156089782715,
0.33973124623298645,
-0.5969531536102295,
-0.29156494140625,
0.02660524658858776,
-0.5603151321411133,
-0.04518870264291763,
-0.058593254536390305,
-0.12920308113098145,
0.025166435167193413,
0.5900700092315674,
-0.559814989566803,
0.1012309193611145,
0.726047158241272,
0.06391756981611252,
0.8999860882759094,
-0.4704981744289398,
-0.08044303208589554,
-0.6458286643028259,
0.07008952647447586,
-0.07294057309627533,
-0.5112460851669312,
-0.18135535717010498,
0.4493170976638794,
0.01405293308198452,
-0.12009302526712418,
-0.5847662687301636,
0.7178412079811096,
-0.3421725332736969,
-0.31519970297813416,
-0.3461522161960602,
0.01016442384570837,
-0.4648566246032715,
0.8304916620254517,
0.12939085066318512,
0.873598039150238,
0.38461795449256897,
-0.569561779499054,
0.7883705496788025,
-0.1526404470205307,
-0.3203967213630676,
0.1240551769733429,
-0.5100743174552917,
0.07287732511758804,
-0.08171571046113968,
0.4801647663116455,
-0.647156834602356,
-0.43780338764190674,
0.42098468542099,
-0.01360580325126648,
0.19340869784355164,
-0.13845406472682953,
-0.6584310531616211,
-0.48733678460121155,
-0.19184021651744843,
0.506813645362854,
0.5348126888275146,
-0.9224501848220825,
0.3871818780899048,
0.32816359400749207,
0.030275698751211166,
-0.4744715690612793,
-0.3674841821193695,
-0.10065793991088867,
-0.1487550437450409,
-0.3649614453315735,
0.23379041254520416,
0.12234046310186386,
-0.17154335975646973,
0.06465859711170197,
0.040836866945028305,
-0.16009902954101562,
-0.017539609223604202,
0.37342745065689087,
0.0862828940153122,
-0.02685823105275631,
0.163221538066864,
0.0693526491522789,
-0.29610979557037354,
-0.04690013453364372,
-0.4468090832233429,
0.498537540435791,
-0.21637552976608276,
-0.4818345606327057,
-0.6530117988586426,
0.08784207701683044,
0.5753401517868042,
-0.27792832255363464,
0.8682965040206909,
0.9229033589363098,
-0.21895699203014374,
-0.3754349946975708,
-0.5192541480064392,
-0.4739893674850464,
-0.42161044478416443,
0.616337239742279,
-0.18606168031692505,
-1.1303186416625977,
0.44251033663749695,
-0.2796032428741455,
0.11427169293165207,
0.04496613144874573,
0.629994809627533,
0.0010911505669355392,
1.1027026176452637,
0.5943631529808044,
-0.13238660991191864,
0.5735259652137756,
-0.20798403024673462,
0.2802772521972656,
-0.5495927929878235,
-0.14131589233875275,
-0.2531368136405945,
-0.6711370944976807,
-0.6112122535705566,
-0.670146107673645,
0.4052017629146576,
0.1271408349275589,
-0.40704405307769775,
0.20579269528388977,
-0.4310061037540436,
0.5592508316040039,
0.5888136625289917,
0.12031355500221252,
0.1293036788702011,
0.022308656945824623,
-0.24329808354377747,
0.06636150181293488,
-0.8906471133232117,
-0.27730652689933777,
0.7825368642807007,
0.6229757070541382,
0.6438460946083069,
-0.033850472420454025,
0.71245276927948,
0.21810492873191833,
0.33384841680526733,
-0.8611273169517517,
0.6310255527496338,
0.24704062938690186,
-0.20273162424564362,
-0.6533593535423279,
-0.6273686289787292,
-0.7052425146102905,
0.3444371521472931,
-0.1460290402173996,
-0.49700817465782166,
-0.05380454659461975,
0.554959774017334,
-0.6234067678451538,
0.5212085247039795,
-0.5630983114242554,
0.6876406073570251,
-0.22181612253189087,
-0.4585268795490265,
-0.8117889761924744,
-0.5906165242195129,
0.28094959259033203,
-0.01306317001581192,
0.17854143679141998,
-0.16591490805149078,
-0.06887199729681015,
0.8473412394523621,
-0.765202522277832,
0.5603956580162048,
-0.44446471333503723,
-0.1954445093870163,
0.32770445942878723,
-0.07564571499824524,
0.9933862090110779,
0.07232342660427094,
-0.2129824161529541,
-0.07972678542137146,
-0.018209848552942276,
-0.5260201096534729,
-0.6419278979301453,
1.02210533618927,
-0.8368579745292664,
-0.3697068691253662,
-0.20332582294940948,
-0.4451304078102112,
-0.3344312310218811,
0.0416594035923481,
-0.1749807596206665,
0.34509265422821045,
-0.007726674433797598,
-0.08130611479282379,
0.706784725189209,
-0.28180384635925293,
0.5088545083999634,
0.3679366111755371,
-0.39579012989997864,
-0.4749172627925873,
1.1204160451889038,
-0.10453043133020401,
0.19791127741336823,
0.41499289870262146,
0.40898680686950684,
-0.3583557605743408,
-0.4842177927494049,
-0.8125408887863159,
0.6109409928321838,
-0.3545718491077423,
0.07408959418535233,
-0.3998792767524719,
-0.06397883594036102,
-0.015603527426719666,
-0.07218434661626816,
-0.7039308547973633,
-0.31084078550338745,
-0.23785679042339325,
-0.17810297012329102,
0.3171192407608032,
0.4692304730415344,
0.09997695684432983,
0.6255412697792053,
-0.8175844550132751,
0.236293226480484,
0.49694323539733887,
0.6432317495346069,
0.15462903678417206,
-0.4729500412940979,
-0.5670551657676697,
-0.1465320736169815,
-0.024912262335419655,
-0.5749022960662842,
0.3277565836906433,
0.1639774590730667,
0.5214147567749023,
0.3106129765510559,
-0.024077951908111572,
0.7385632991790771,
-0.3755415081977844,
0.3670355975627899,
0.175413578748703,
-0.41132649779319763,
0.1469481736421585,
-0.4148017168045044,
0.37612199783325195,
0.5189754962921143,
0.3070690929889679,
-0.40439140796661377,
-0.07017003744840622,
-0.5728938579559326,
-0.6518245935440063,
0.8941689729690552,
-0.30003049969673157,
-0.1420135349035263,
0.35544824600219727,
0.7210155129432678,
-0.20949994027614594,
0.20558416843414307,
-0.22675833106040955,
-0.10110147297382355,
0.21150551736354828,
-0.16404107213020325,
0.291920930147171,
-0.2922665774822235,
-0.14382410049438477,
-0.37279069423675537,
0.6873103380203247,
-0.33299142122268677,
0.20637033879756927,
-0.10609166324138641,
-0.09138958156108856,
-0.5214967727661133,
-0.011133329011499882,
0.7387377619743347,
0.9532964825630188,
-0.2976721525192261,
0.0053595127537846565,
0.18515773117542267,
-0.3435472249984741,
0.10313792526721954,
-0.07626684010028839,
0.007960991933941841,
-0.31696417927742004,
0.4042808413505554,
1.1462275981903076,
0.38432708382606506,
-1.2835789918899536,
0.23887290060520172,
-0.003999351989477873,
-0.4530830383300781,
-0.23439684510231018,
0.36268240213394165,
0.2161666750907898,
0.39919817447662354,
0.0992153212428093,
-0.32844728231430054,
-0.18900004029273987,
-0.417450875043869,
0.40707215666770935,
0.04557722806930542,
-0.5410085916519165,
-0.4276738464832306,
0.5602045655250549,
0.20865163207054138,
-0.4230213165283203,
0.8129107356071472,
-0.24183999001979828,
-0.5857447981834412,
0.5924990177154541,
0.4171651303768158,
0.9112600088119507,
-0.12646758556365967,
0.3887370228767395,
0.5521611571311951,
-0.06805889308452606,
-0.3711296319961548,
0.17036321759223938,
-0.11076422035694122,
-0.4511544406414032,
-0.7036322951316833,
-0.9141678810119629,
-0.6496989727020264,
-0.023843567818403244,
-0.38303518295288086,
0.12499366700649261,
-0.9869828224182129,
0.02643565461039543,
-0.3560224771499634,
-0.05724571272730827,
-0.3151009678840637,
0.17037156224250793,
0.14191055297851562,
0.6256029605865479,
-0.45609918236732483,
1.0795758962631226,
0.8269777297973633,
-0.13730375468730927,
-0.797925591468811,
0.20566070079803467,
0.005041581112891436,
-0.8404709100723267,
0.6838918924331665,
-0.2954932749271393,
-0.2377653867006302,
0.20755703747272491,
-0.4299609661102295,
-0.95811527967453,
0.8944365382194519,
0.5601145029067993,
-1.0112863779067993,
-0.023879053071141243,
0.024109715595841408,
0.5336728096008301,
-0.19318898022174835,
0.29039308428764343,
0.6271740794181824,
0.6826019287109375,
0.2726207375526428,
-0.9064940810203552,
0.07688939571380615,
0.22594450414180756,
0.007465737871825695,
0.5254203081130981,
-0.863240122795105,
0.4737980365753174,
-0.5526033639907837,
0.061060816049575806,
-0.06325149536132812,
0.8009853363037109,
0.5617561936378479,
-0.21426327526569366,
0.6294809579849243,
0.8254845142364502,
0.6110910177230835,
0.17537835240364075,
1.0017040967941284,
-0.3694227337837219,
0.4561813473701477,
1.0696039199829102,
-0.14927688241004944,
1.1632779836654663,
0.48046812415122986,
-0.3716886639595032,
0.4741222560405731,
0.690559983253479,
0.12211035937070847,
0.5049328804016113,
0.6968976855278015,
-0.3581130802631378,
-0.23212158679962158,
0.04717046394944191,
-0.027226503938436508,
0.02734270878136158,
0.07129237800836563,
-0.024914361536502838,
-0.3477798402309418,
0.10213952511548996,
0.2105332762002945,
0.11828701198101044,
0.14015214145183563,
0.5764918923377991,
-0.08854557573795319,
-0.8082809448242188,
0.9539731740951538,
0.3008471131324768,
0.6272056698799133,
-0.6089953780174255,
-0.2004196047782898,
-0.12809878587722778,
0.38658490777015686,
-0.35040828585624695,
-0.3916172385215759,
0.4076215922832489,
-0.15268461406230927,
-0.23211050033569336,
-0.25790584087371826,
0.45628124475479126,
-0.4622049629688263,
-0.24486958980560303,
0.4827168583869934,
0.020533598959445953,
0.037508316338062286,
-0.122386135160923,
-0.8152322173118591,
0.4084964096546173,
0.030754918232560158,
-0.39369991421699524,
0.6105873584747314,
-0.19392922520637512,
-0.20919838547706604,
0.9369668364524841,
0.72100430727005,
0.3420165479183197,
0.11494480818510056,
0.25065863132476807,
0.7038701176643372,
-0.737694263458252,
-0.45744964480400085,
-0.6327794194221497,
0.026310747489333153,
0.23169243335723877,
-0.2181186079978943,
0.20640748739242554,
0.4430207908153534,
0.8082258105278015,
-0.004331267438828945,
0.6334694623947144,
0.25172436237335205,
0.609915018081665,
-0.3505505323410034,
0.5077912211418152,
-0.5248973965644836,
0.28874748945236206,
0.1736678183078766,
-1.0579113960266113,
-0.24349871277809143,
0.4162236452102661,
-0.3271702527999878,
-0.06644981354475021,
0.537045955657959,
1.1259393692016602,
-0.11374974250793457,
-0.14020907878875732,
0.2283230870962143,
0.09778781980276108,
0.5625990629196167,
0.19046293199062347,
0.7379992008209229,
-0.020557988435029984,
0.5767962336540222,
-0.4387039542198181,
-0.27804017066955566,
-0.4527323842048645,
-0.694776177406311,
-0.521131694316864,
-0.32382357120513916,
-0.4845532178878784,
-0.0374150425195694,
0.32976633310317993,
1.1706914901733398,
1.1309291124343872,
-0.8687868118286133,
-0.5397477149963379,
-0.34433016180992126,
0.13436007499694824,
-0.31679990887641907,
-0.22728700935840607,
0.3375866711139679,
-0.5068570375442505,
-0.6014062762260437,
0.5551247596740723,
0.32905349135398865,
-0.3198983371257782,
-0.6917083859443665,
-0.5764132738113403,
-0.3441879451274872,
-0.034251514822244644,
0.44317805767059326,
0.7363640069961548,
-0.7748221755027771,
-0.2821756601333618,
-0.3611435890197754,
0.0934835895895958,
-0.20646856725215912,
0.8282293081283569,
-0.8111848831176758,
0.19727663695812225,
0.6680335402488708,
0.9999193549156189,
0.705755889415741,
0.11432730406522751,
0.5597513318061829,
-0.6259934306144714,
0.3856430649757385,
0.18112480640411377,
-0.10574988275766373,
-0.006567875389009714,
-0.34114912152290344,
0.34961044788360596,
0.46622833609580994,
-0.5866209268569946,
-0.9063805937767029,
0.20756924152374268,
-0.6730539202690125,
-0.28273770213127136,
1.0222548246383667,
0.09243899583816528,
-0.3205958604812622,
0.20021532475948334,
-0.2729738652706146,
0.24520279467105865,
-0.5399582982063293,
0.7649966478347778,
0.4417078197002411,
-0.4566083252429962,
-0.485259085893631,
-0.6944937705993652,
0.5758655667304993,
0.5524722337722778,
-0.8720760941505432,
0.20005938410758972,
0.40369537472724915,
0.07284219563007355,
-0.15476647019386292,
0.3568410277366638,
-0.04734230041503906,
0.1894654780626297,
-0.2770669162273407,
0.1272250860929489,
-0.23987984657287598,
-0.482654869556427,
-0.09748635441064835,
0.33808258175849915,
0.3185696601867676,
-0.1492726057767868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14075v1 | EXCEEDS: Extracting Complex Events as Connecting the Dots to Graphs in Scientific Domain | 2024-06-20T07:50:37 | 2024-06-20T07:50:37 | Yi-Fan Lu, Xian-Ling Mao, Bo Wang, Xiao Liu, Heyan Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | It is crucial to utilize events to understand a specific domain. There are
lots of research on event extraction in many domains such as news, finance and
biology domain. However, scientific domain still lacks event extraction
research, including comprehensive datasets and corresponding methods. Compared
to other domains, scientific domain presents two characteristics: denser
nuggets and more complex events. To solve the above problem, considering these
two characteristics, we first construct SciEvents, a large-scale multi-event
document-level dataset with a schema tailored for scientific domain. It has
2,508 documents and 24,381 events under refined annotation and quality control.
Then, we propose EXCEEDS, a novel end-to-end scientific event extraction
framework by storing dense nuggets in a grid matrix and simplifying complex
event extraction into a dot construction and connection task. Experimental
results demonstrate state-of-the-art performances of EXCEEDS on SciEvents.
Additionally, we release SciEvents and EXCEEDS on GitHub. | [
-0.519530713558197,
-0.5681160688400269,
0.5368953347206116,
0.27708306908607483,
-0.22826899588108063,
0.44267764687538147,
-0.12671388685703278,
-0.8199461698532104,
0.4391956925392151,
0.0030923851300030947,
-0.5504070520401001,
-0.3805936872959137,
-0.645953357219696,
0.27822113037109375,
-0.3846808075904846,
1.1588764190673828,
-0.00035189572372473776,
-0.18310405313968658,
-0.5828367471694946,
0.22642429172992706,
0.14986801147460938,
-0.4425186812877655,
-0.5007950067520142,
-0.3425714671611786,
0.6426935195922852,
0.3864549696445465,
0.2171303927898407,
0.4594692289829254,
0.7005178332328796,
0.21666166186332703,
-0.1174016147851944,
0.7731519937515259,
-0.7404946684837341,
0.08081419765949249,
-0.08865772932767868,
-0.1145520880818367,
-0.38109713792800903,
0.04290793091058731,
0.6659975647926331,
0.8216699957847595,
0.4153253138065338,
0.11487288028001785,
-0.2794715464115143,
0.5247278213500977,
-0.5423176884651184,
0.4018814265727997,
-0.3627857267856598,
0.3154982626438141,
-0.43726396560668945,
-0.48927098512649536,
-0.37514451146125793,
-0.4426726698875427,
0.0297201219946146,
-0.8381165266036987,
0.21851205825805664,
-0.2196512520313263,
1.087620496749878,
-0.330691397190094,
-0.6435762643814087,
-0.10700404644012451,
-0.41098374128341675,
0.7055972814559937,
-0.15226633846759796,
0.2835143506526947,
0.20432400703430176,
0.30778250098228455,
-0.4454622268676758,
-1.0890653133392334,
-0.46365758776664734,
-0.11329085379838943,
0.11117968708276749,
-0.04271708056330681,
-0.39516669511795044,
-0.1809067279100418,
0.5701038837432861,
-0.01921197399497032,
-0.6992526650428772,
0.0859987810254097,
-0.6784597039222717,
0.08872771263122559,
0.9529682993888855,
0.3404771685600281,
0.3188175857067108,
-0.1493670642375946,
-0.2632700502872467,
-0.035113267600536346,
-0.9612331390380859,
-0.019648436456918716,
0.10973870009183884,
0.11838911473751068,
0.179522305727005,
0.7151035070419312,
-0.42561468482017517,
0.20651963353157043,
0.1319146454334259,
0.12339033931493759,
0.31340551376342773,
-0.4559597969055176,
0.1756192296743393,
0.17860600352287292,
0.5104166269302368,
0.27832919359207153,
0.20964621007442474,
-0.3235339820384979,
0.4192354083061218,
-0.17812542617321014,
-0.12490474432706833,
-1.1930607557296753,
-0.3846830725669861,
0.421921044588089,
-0.14284679293632507,
-0.3031346797943115,
-0.05529377982020378,
-0.7616697549819946,
-0.622027575969696,
-0.47368478775024414,
0.3415207266807556,
-0.45828622579574585,
-0.14373965561389923,
0.10954916477203369,
-0.4074854850769043,
0.011315845884382725,
0.5652417540550232,
-0.3399302065372467,
0.2131257951259613,
0.8445676565170288,
1.066903829574585,
-0.4145333468914032,
-0.14963380992412567,
-0.7100219130516052,
0.2740194499492645,
-0.31147974729537964,
1.103367567062378,
-0.8426616787910461,
-0.549974799156189,
-0.3316720426082611,
-0.07876253873109818,
0.20994053781032562,
-0.21728889644145966,
0.5317765474319458,
-0.8814896941184998,
-0.07531795650720596,
-0.6680554747581482,
-0.7730636596679688,
-0.1007559671998024,
-0.07879606634378433,
-0.38139113783836365,
0.8037136197090149,
-0.05287458375096321,
-0.6006540656089783,
0.4935792088508606,
-0.8320061564445496,
-0.699891209602356,
0.5507830381393433,
-0.3974097669124603,
-0.5230640172958374,
0.007515206933021545,
0.13182184100151062,
0.5566202998161316,
-0.17233873903751373,
0.4192483723163605,
-0.5378264784812927,
-0.11587192118167877,
0.3396616280078888,
0.08826860040426254,
0.771946370601654,
0.1825401335954666,
-0.10385554283857346,
0.2393006980419159,
-1.1926673650741577,
0.12006277590990067,
0.2103327512741089,
0.017618704587221146,
-0.27886250615119934,
0.15446092188358307,
0.15975645184516907,
0.23898303508758545,
0.3291613757610321,
-0.9005332589149475,
0.5765601992607117,
0.04809055104851723,
0.5653963685035706,
0.604016125202179,
0.25402501225471497,
0.3653262257575989,
0.024184180423617363,
0.4320492148399353,
-0.07340758293867111,
0.14972421526908875,
-0.23191305994987488,
-0.3118893802165985,
-0.17603707313537598,
-0.31829121708869934,
0.12199913710355759,
0.21578015387058258,
-0.45562776923179626,
0.6425576210021973,
-0.6346560716629028,
-0.7077255845069885,
0.29673293232917786,
-0.2704722583293915,
0.11461963504552841,
0.3802480101585388,
0.1611979901790619,
-0.16784797608852386,
-1.0607020854949951,
-0.513557493686676,
0.07747869938611984,
0.19545599818229675,
-0.08980675786733627,
0.030439311638474464,
0.6439989805221558,
-0.19378544390201569,
1.039299488067627,
-1.0002961158752441,
-0.19792674481868744,
0.07123067229986191,
0.18142077326774597,
0.2560049295425415,
0.24174977838993073,
0.5374082922935486,
-1.0714390277862549,
-0.5054317712783813,
0.568889319896698,
-0.837574303150177,
-0.14696776866912842,
-0.16599217057228088,
-0.005329466424882412,
-0.29307839274406433,
0.4662141799926758,
-0.5133013129234314,
0.3481774926185608,
0.2557447552680969,
-0.5117481350898743,
0.9431397318840027,
0.2000633329153061,
0.06912794709205627,
-0.7623973488807678,
0.16600728034973145,
-0.031812865287065506,
-0.28647810220718384,
-0.700851559638977,
-0.2700621783733368,
0.1907958984375,
-0.15824009478092194,
-0.16980692744255066,
0.3742145895957947,
-0.42871418595314026,
-0.352398157119751,
-0.30018526315689087,
0.2223394811153412,
0.5145036578178406,
0.078140027821064,
0.17518295347690582,
0.7144894003868103,
0.5907339453697205,
-0.5356625318527222,
0.5976487398147583,
0.4379907250404358,
-0.39062660932540894,
0.5695305466651917,
-0.7804315686225891,
-0.15055106580257416,
-0.1314118206501007,
0.5150641202926636,
-0.6809920072555542,
-0.30824628472328186,
-0.22921201586723328,
-0.5710229277610779,
0.3489101529121399,
0.05384153127670288,
-0.41198042035102844,
-0.47806981205940247,
-0.306927889585495,
0.01506620179861784,
0.18551455438137054,
-0.5769273042678833,
0.45002907514572144,
0.5647896528244019,
-0.4744091331958771,
-0.5255944728851318,
-0.20135298371315002,
0.4888196885585785,
0.02703164331614971,
-0.615539014339447,
0.10297976434230804,
-0.30614811182022095,
-0.03363969922065735,
0.03382626548409462,
-0.1251307874917984,
-0.0561707578599453,
-0.1930597871541977,
0.5442706346511841,
0.1212092787027359,
-0.1771543025970459,
-0.01201730314642191,
0.23660804331302643,
-0.23063619434833527,
0.05017472058534622,
-0.4967040419578552,
0.3120114207267761,
-0.2306380718946457,
-0.400116890668869,
-0.4240069091320038,
0.6175175309181213,
0.5742655396461487,
-0.15147188305854797,
0.4930883049964905,
0.6924598813056946,
-0.5317776799201965,
-0.053952693939208984,
-0.3666948974132538,
-0.2347097247838974,
-0.48607179522514343,
0.8574288487434387,
-0.5865179896354675,
-0.8138079047203064,
0.7034581303596497,
-0.4337967038154602,
0.12742546200752258,
0.5125464200973511,
0.09460578113794327,
-0.06140470877289772,
1.1656897068023682,
0.2512483298778534,
0.35280507802963257,
0.37969937920570374,
-0.2429874837398529,
0.17903554439544678,
-0.8909857869148254,
-0.68189537525177,
-0.626043438911438,
-0.014377602376043797,
0.1677301824092865,
-0.28940144181251526,
0.6944850087165833,
0.22599002718925476,
-0.11435507237911224,
0.42100611329078674,
-0.4023241102695465,
0.7383460402488708,
0.19887621700763702,
-0.20457176864147186,
0.1910417526960373,
0.2789027988910675,
0.2825508713722229,
-0.32480430603027344,
-0.7615259885787964,
-0.27091488242149353,
0.7783244252204895,
0.09823223203420639,
0.3565170466899872,
-0.13499800860881805,
0.3400411009788513,
0.22834567725658417,
0.28119412064552307,
-0.42109352350234985,
0.3761151432991028,
-0.0725874975323677,
-0.47277650237083435,
-0.4152768552303314,
-0.595154345035553,
-1.011391520500183,
0.16466258466243744,
-0.2083197385072708,
-0.6996282935142517,
0.7923876643180847,
-0.4486564099788666,
-0.14487086236476898,
0.29935982823371887,
-0.6091552972793579,
0.49015122652053833,
0.005287800449877977,
-0.21446339786052704,
-0.005668812431395054,
-0.6294609308242798,
0.18777529895305634,
-0.3640168607234955,
0.3983357548713684,
-0.19240377843379974,
0.11141528934240341,
0.7767383456230164,
-0.3106828033924103,
0.7981239557266235,
0.19832690060138702,
0.21915684640407562,
0.295355886220932,
0.32735201716423035,
0.9858158826828003,
0.25081366300582886,
-0.10855277627706528,
0.2884722352027893,
0.1717994213104248,
-0.5396235585212708,
-0.49984726309776306,
0.8220853805541992,
-0.7377122640609741,
-0.16088204085826874,
-0.28869515657424927,
-0.38028401136398315,
0.020993227139115334,
0.3156032860279083,
0.2437799870967865,
0.7775331735610962,
-0.04023752734065056,
0.21745958924293518,
0.6076236367225647,
0.1464224010705948,
0.3559153079986572,
0.6195265054702759,
0.059710267931222916,
-0.40239080786705017,
1.0958130359649658,
0.42027902603149414,
0.09210528433322906,
0.21825554966926575,
0.15628305077552795,
-0.33775290846824646,
-0.7479757070541382,
-0.4684300124645233,
0.05103134736418724,
-0.7718272805213928,
-0.6189399361610413,
-1.1598507165908813,
-0.35444992780685425,
-0.699016273021698,
-0.5750595927238464,
-0.1938355416059494,
-0.7126901745796204,
-0.5973654389381409,
-0.45643001794815063,
0.5663715600967407,
0.7012320160865784,
-0.5713452696800232,
-0.006380829028785229,
-0.9774841070175171,
0.2617780268192291,
-0.011176466010510921,
0.25681614875793457,
0.024105532094836235,
-0.2637629210948944,
-0.26605120301246643,
-0.33098745346069336,
-0.2523941099643707,
-0.6748889684677124,
0.5427622199058533,
0.6664507985115051,
0.43313926458358765,
0.8656584620475769,
0.10683516412973404,
1.0681794881820679,
-0.6638097167015076,
0.6707683801651001,
0.489084392786026,
-0.9467369914054871,
0.5665557384490967,
-0.35089778900146484,
0.05495913699269295,
0.22906915843486786,
0.76341313123703,
-0.637327253818512,
-0.09455578029155731,
-0.8756157755851746,
-1.0006434917449951,
0.6165553331375122,
0.33844560384750366,
-0.24308393895626068,
-0.11036163568496704,
0.6553640365600586,
0.4591391980648041,
0.13961724936962128,
-0.5287892818450928,
-0.21171630918979645,
0.17309315502643585,
0.17700402438640594,
-0.07388322800397873,
-0.2445165365934372,
-0.2983175218105316,
-0.039566077291965485,
0.5807633399963379,
-0.052891310304403305,
-0.18442198634147644,
0.4346546232700348,
0.14816883206367493,
-0.4495643675327301,
-0.2022007554769516,
0.5706964731216431,
1.0270553827285767,
-0.10565372556447983,
0.3931979537010193,
0.19969184696674347,
-0.6640517115592957,
-0.3603884279727936,
0.3395162522792816,
-0.032401300966739655,
-0.006153575144708157,
0.6348136067390442,
0.5117155909538269,
0.025368371978402138,
-0.8196505308151245,
0.3848997950553894,
0.07985685765743256,
-0.22934560477733612,
-0.3230094015598297,
0.0579291395843029,
-0.08319026976823807,
0.45692166686058044,
0.8694373369216919,
-0.1028738021850586,
0.5202041268348694,
-0.3367207646369934,
0.681117594242096,
0.2384883314371109,
-0.5747383832931519,
-0.5752527117729187,
0.6131876111030579,
0.13053537905216217,
0.13277383148670197,
0.2591271698474884,
-0.45754989981651306,
-0.5530446767807007,
0.9746366739273071,
0.5853740572929382,
0.26057395339012146,
0.04537353292107582,
0.2905213534832001,
0.5234017968177795,
0.07133316993713379,
0.21585342288017273,
0.3007243573665619,
-0.057854242622852325,
-0.16934038698673248,
-0.9594641923904419,
-0.6800569295883179,
-0.27159711718559265,
-0.0515623465180397,
-0.3969579339027405,
0.31052643060684204,
-0.13515639305114746,
-0.016096601262688637,
0.693735659122467,
0.5785031914710999,
-0.2757182717323303,
-0.02523057721555233,
-0.008092026226222515,
0.8446170687675476,
-0.9825190305709839,
0.4598071873188019,
0.4432234466075897,
-0.3006112277507782,
-0.13319876790046692,
-1.196858525276184,
0.08708257228136063,
-0.47238093614578247,
0.7941341400146484,
-0.11201991885900497,
0.21023939549922943,
-0.08840207010507584,
-0.6293920278549194,
-1.1296275854110718,
0.775804877281189,
0.04360375553369522,
-0.821535587310791,
0.18207286298274994,
0.030727701261639595,
0.5533254146575928,
-0.3318934738636017,
0.14471785724163055,
0.07642624527215958,
0.6829825043678284,
0.6768823862075806,
-0.5171893835067749,
0.1014276072382927,
-0.3197935223579407,
-0.545773446559906,
0.4469508230686188,
-0.341892808675766,
0.5299386978149414,
-0.4855920672416687,
-0.36672404408454895,
-0.2997627556324005,
0.9143701195716858,
0.3783021867275238,
0.844921886920929,
0.009957661852240562,
0.07808936387300491,
0.9902507662773132,
-0.14725853502750397,
0.9804688096046448,
0.23837842047214508,
0.4783000946044922,
0.8916612267494202,
-0.4988212287425995,
0.40267273783683777,
0.08846395462751389,
-0.41506725549697876,
0.16794468462467194,
0.8477453589439392,
-0.12444162368774414,
0.18053819239139557,
0.22236956655979156,
-0.25392112135887146,
-0.4385867714881897,
-0.2840258479118347,
-0.6491045355796814,
-0.11742845922708511,
0.9401198029518127,
0.20856216549873352,
-0.4378659129142761,
0.19816800951957703,
-0.00012393807992339134,
-0.1494917869567871,
-0.3298151195049286,
0.5152056813240051,
0.23093900084495544,
0.058218322694301605,
0.19762147963047028,
-0.2957462668418884,
0.1028629019856453,
-0.7298055291175842,
-0.10745611041784286,
0.08735821396112442,
-0.2343752235174179,
-0.4811275005340576,
-1.0057039260864258,
0.24398617446422577,
-0.21128176152706146,
-0.2236320823431015,
0.09020312875509262,
0.8600295186042786,
-0.22688820958137512,
-0.4733540117740631,
0.03580636531114578,
0.06583268195390701,
0.46530967950820923,
-0.09443046152591705,
-0.36035117506980896,
0.025748705491423607,
-0.11960823088884354,
-0.3047340214252472,
0.3375093936920166,
0.7624198198318481,
-0.3955800235271454,
0.5465818047523499,
1.1052501201629639,
0.3143947124481201,
0.18532419204711914,
0.155233234167099,
0.9802965521812439,
-0.6186734437942505,
-0.41072767972946167,
-0.5688904523849487,
0.19637815654277802,
-0.692567765712738,
-0.3414776623249054,
0.7989535927772522,
0.8891997933387756,
0.33808401226997375,
0.13028660416603088,
0.7578151822090149,
-0.08977155387401581,
0.19039985537528992,
0.10218355804681778,
0.3200497329235077,
-0.3721984326839447,
-0.1651916652917862,
-0.0939921960234642,
-0.710454523563385,
-0.8155609965324402,
0.12728719413280487,
-0.30954912304878235,
-0.38752681016921997,
0.3648776412010193,
0.21650449931621552,
-0.04984463006258011,
0.34498289227485657,
0.2846314609050751,
0.3232536315917969,
0.8644555807113647,
0.4055510461330414,
0.8958086371421814,
-0.327390193939209,
0.4794311821460724,
0.18377386033535004,
-0.3733373284339905,
-0.6159707307815552,
-0.8813367486000061,
-0.6928521990776062,
-0.8190661072731018,
-0.6002088785171509,
-0.2685377299785614,
0.2164408415555954,
0.7074777483940125,
0.8825631141662598,
-0.8875021934509277,
0.3158012330532074,
0.04213165491819382,
0.18916048109531403,
-0.12013155966997147,
-0.2712308466434479,
0.9439300894737244,
-0.45958974957466125,
-0.5754266977310181,
0.518225371837616,
0.5903964638710022,
-0.017041342332959175,
0.24277843534946442,
0.2463887631893158,
0.004084006883203983,
0.03180540353059769,
0.98725825548172,
0.66822749376297,
0.10510800778865814,
-0.32420021295547485,
0.015071534551680088,
0.05266479775309563,
0.08741068840026855,
0.7222399115562439,
-0.5508309602737427,
0.43073946237564087,
0.6494406461715698,
0.45233529806137085,
0.8810058236122131,
-0.2815799117088318,
0.3754514753818512,
-0.7972809672355652,
-0.05347837135195732,
0.24262341856956482,
0.1025100126862526,
0.0012277811765670776,
-0.7410503625869751,
0.5160108208656311,
0.2446502298116684,
-0.6787446141242981,
-1.1188467741012573,
0.31233927607536316,
-1.3442966938018799,
-0.4712771773338318,
1.2045129537582397,
0.041943490505218506,
-0.22114530205726624,
-0.4938526749610901,
-0.045331984758377075,
0.0908084586262703,
-0.2544175386428833,
0.8629841208457947,
0.395352303981781,
-0.6987573504447937,
0.3260056674480438,
-0.3317985534667969,
0.4924246668815613,
-0.14340905845165253,
-0.9363874197006226,
0.13918554782867432,
0.5531555414199829,
0.07429851591587067,
0.5753552317619324,
0.2224263697862625,
-0.31539487838745117,
0.36461740732192993,
0.1070861890912056,
0.08977819979190826,
-0.4348602294921875,
-0.6545533537864685,
-0.11854134500026703,
0.6375880241394043,
-0.45522066950798035,
0.14467518031597137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14051v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14051v1 | How Many Parameters Does it Take to Change a Light Bulb? Evaluating Performance in Self-Play of Conversational Games as a Function of Model Characteristics | 2024-06-20T07:17:09 | 2024-06-20T07:17:09 | Nidhir Bhavsar, Jonathan Jordan, Sherzod Hakimov, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | What makes a good Large Language Model (LLM)? That it performs well on the
relevant benchmarks -- which hopefully measure, with some validity, the
presence of capabilities that are also challenged in real application. But what
makes the model perform well? What gives a model its abilities? We take a
recently introduced type of benchmark that is meant to challenge capabilities
in a goal-directed, agentive context through self-play of conversational games,
and analyse how performance develops as a function of model characteristics
like number of parameters, or type of training. We find that while there is a
clear relationship between number of parameters and performance, there is still
a wide spread of performance points within a given size bracket, which is to be
accounted for by training parameters such as fine-tuning data quality and
method. From a more practical angle, we also find a certain degree of
unpredictability about performance across access methods, possible due to
unexposed sampling parameters, and a, very welcome, performance stability
against at least moderate weight quantisation during inference. | [
-0.33892184495925903,
-0.763063371181488,
0.6216858625411987,
0.4500250816345215,
-0.12163322418928146,
-0.23139354586601257,
-0.18772102892398834,
-0.55586838722229,
-0.3020610809326172,
0.5539464950561523,
-0.24302658438682556,
-0.10896432399749756,
-0.36161938309669495,
0.01704501174390316,
-0.5758072733879089,
0.7992101311683655,
0.1747489869594574,
0.20268452167510986,
-0.3512721657752991,
-0.23575511574745178,
-0.5596367120742798,
-0.3098039925098419,
-0.5711411833763123,
-0.4070320725440979,
0.5319890379905701,
0.5071597099304199,
0.6725099086761475,
0.8596137166023254,
0.6983838081359863,
0.35955145955085754,
0.06234531104564667,
-0.07685095071792603,
-0.744653582572937,
0.3553369343280792,
-0.06717585027217865,
-0.8225023150444031,
-0.24016982316970825,
0.2939299941062927,
0.6566334366798401,
0.5823062658309937,
-0.11956534534692764,
0.3513893187046051,
0.23645640909671783,
0.5560141205787659,
-0.07946337014436722,
0.30568110942840576,
-0.7533268928527832,
-0.19813044369220734,
-0.13612684607505798,
-0.26309001445770264,
-0.23636828362941742,
0.0500340536236763,
0.09233579784631729,
-0.5511863231658936,
0.42190301418304443,
0.1611756682395935,
0.6411590576171875,
0.1839050054550171,
-0.409837931394577,
-0.1667669713497162,
-1.0263135433197021,
0.8595752716064453,
-0.8649566173553467,
0.25967803597450256,
0.25195127725601196,
0.46533310413360596,
-0.1487487107515335,
-0.4910491406917572,
-0.14719220995903015,
-0.4491219222545624,
0.2430953085422516,
0.07142078876495361,
0.011024264618754387,
0.1878688633441925,
0.6303847432136536,
0.25765931606292725,
-0.24731643497943878,
0.13822704553604126,
-0.5021411180496216,
0.20230208337306976,
1.0039280652999878,
0.40524089336395264,
-0.1275934875011444,
0.04035704582929611,
-0.27776870131492615,
-0.16168943047523499,
-0.6792553663253784,
0.26764369010925293,
0.6227176785469055,
0.39730972051620483,
0.017894422635436058,
0.3707936704158783,
-0.33184027671813965,
0.54715895652771,
0.09487969428300858,
-0.16727635264396667,
-0.15488620102405548,
-0.18885035812854767,
0.05191555619239807,
-0.20875799655914307,
0.7559213042259216,
0.3396661579608917,
0.2751033306121826,
-0.296378493309021,
-0.1518617421388626,
-0.09869071841239929,
0.3373388648033142,
-0.8002791404724121,
-0.3074306547641754,
0.15341363847255707,
-0.5666223764419556,
-0.21799837052822113,
-0.1656385213136673,
-0.686067521572113,
-0.39141860604286194,
-0.19257056713104248,
0.6650512218475342,
-0.555943489074707,
-0.07952357083559036,
0.1630074679851532,
-0.11494173109531403,
0.392951101064682,
0.32471033930778503,
-1.1000267267227173,
0.610399067401886,
0.6333029270172119,
0.8122928142547607,
-0.2927938997745514,
-0.47573623061180115,
-0.23432819545269012,
-0.1032605990767479,
-0.3850310444831848,
0.61536705493927,
-0.6327196359634399,
-0.6373724937438965,
-0.08166875690221786,
-0.3150213062763214,
0.002757957438006997,
-0.6602469682693481,
0.26130566000938416,
-0.5192641019821167,
-0.10045210272073746,
-0.5461474657058716,
-0.7886183857917786,
0.09520144015550613,
0.08266011625528336,
-0.7230607867240906,
0.9323384761810303,
-0.013529844582080841,
-0.39911729097366333,
0.46764880418777466,
-0.6148726344108582,
-0.44588610529899597,
0.16732308268547058,
-0.2285882532596588,
-0.1996077448129654,
0.6191237568855286,
-0.14939162135124207,
0.1981499344110489,
-0.2741453945636749,
-0.01032221969217062,
-0.3643976151943207,
-0.5451624989509583,
0.5219749212265015,
-0.7140821218490601,
0.345011830329895,
0.19071808457374573,
-0.23531854152679443,
-0.029949689283967018,
-1.035003423690796,
0.2566220760345459,
-0.01010391116142273,
-0.5411826968193054,
0.07364195585250854,
0.4953312575817108,
-0.006989067420363426,
0.3009512722492218,
0.15959346294403076,
-0.401690810918808,
0.03490949049592018,
-0.295590341091156,
0.5167670845985413,
0.44237378239631653,
0.08917727321386337,
0.27435705065727234,
-0.3613330125808716,
0.5950189828872681,
-0.09562107175588608,
0.3359585106372833,
-0.21502438187599182,
-0.51124107837677,
-0.9013070464134216,
-0.00790075957775116,
0.5258477330207825,
0.1898891180753708,
-0.4655974507331848,
0.13616414368152618,
0.2354317605495453,
-0.8107542991638184,
-0.5483971238136292,
0.3061322569847107,
0.3929908275604248,
0.3143712878227234,
0.16759072244167328,
-0.3586566150188446,
-0.1618519425392151,
-0.8156725168228149,
-0.49342578649520874,
-0.575884997844696,
0.08982115238904953,
0.7128974199295044,
0.4173997640609741,
0.3759652376174927,
0.7875421047210693,
-0.2541232109069824,
-0.07019717991352081,
-0.15697886049747467,
0.3619801104068756,
0.10824242979288101,
0.42660853266716003,
0.6157934665679932,
-0.5092282891273499,
-0.3124639689922333,
-0.2446284294128418,
-0.8158392906188965,
-0.3686745762825012,
-0.09151611477136612,
0.24027429521083832,
-0.04593253508210182,
0.6483952403068542,
-0.4774443209171295,
0.19970864057540894,
0.7491306662559509,
-0.19767141342163086,
0.5700750350952148,
-0.5896305441856384,
0.39471790194511414,
-0.3840532600879669,
-0.016575481742620468,
0.06556204706430435,
0.1161363273859024,
-0.5592189431190491,
0.4347973167896271,
-0.07956825196743011,
-0.058703020215034485,
-0.4720899760723114,
0.554384171962738,
-0.5771434903144836,
-0.29811009764671326,
-0.3136213421821594,
0.1184546947479248,
0.07999308407306671,
0.2252892702817917,
-0.33249789476394653,
0.9363922476768494,
0.5854031443595886,
-0.8503041863441467,
0.46257689595222473,
-0.031040970236063004,
-0.4610092341899872,
0.510959804058075,
-0.8311476707458496,
0.11561032384634018,
0.09297531843185425,
-0.23418208956718445,
-1.3299286365509033,
-0.016467047855257988,
-0.2759286165237427,
-0.21550053358078003,
0.05790030583739281,
-0.07185783982276917,
-0.6742925643920898,
-0.20516398549079895,
0.11369895190000534,
0.44861695170402527,
0.39096367359161377,
-0.21667997539043427,
0.4287058711051941,
0.020940478891134262,
0.18387402594089508,
-0.01126229390501976,
-0.451265811920166,
0.16098704934120178,
-0.4683784544467926,
-0.48877909779548645,
0.4342585802078247,
-0.46050816774368286,
-0.25561070442199707,
-0.32250651717185974,
-0.010145764797925949,
0.06715703755617142,
0.47804906964302063,
0.1762523204088211,
-0.31589409708976746,
-0.28836268186569214,
0.4512205123901367,
-0.30161893367767334,
-0.0653093233704567,
0.41182833909988403,
0.14787764847278595,
0.5468938946723938,
-0.3241550624370575,
-0.5314514636993408,
-0.07581698894500732,
0.22063246369361877,
0.2783796787261963,
-0.22657956182956696,
0.4465395212173462,
0.2412024587392807,
0.10969360172748566,
-0.2793383002281189,
-0.5793123841285706,
-0.2217816561460495,
-0.5420368909835815,
0.5773240923881531,
-0.6286580562591553,
-0.7514123320579529,
1.0084631443023682,
0.03987058997154236,
-0.11407817900180817,
0.3575723171234131,
0.39074450731277466,
-0.2187073975801468,
1.2092453241348267,
0.6437658667564392,
0.30963119864463806,
0.40525302290916443,
0.13958077132701874,
0.08626706153154373,
-0.5146278738975525,
-0.12425780296325684,
-0.5908786058425903,
-0.49330219626426697,
-0.8966668248176575,
-0.3559879958629608,
0.32164594531059265,
0.17807720601558685,
-0.24544721841812134,
0.2697051465511322,
0.008318870328366756,
0.5436890125274658,
0.6161638498306274,
0.1498073935508728,
0.41996511816978455,
-0.47783371806144714,
0.20944173634052277,
-0.17813511192798615,
-0.7646477818489075,
-0.5434432029724121,
0.9917442202568054,
0.4987258315086365,
1.0865997076034546,
0.42688828706741333,
0.687928318977356,
0.06950034201145172,
-0.014249539002776146,
-0.6569663286209106,
0.7679733037948608,
0.12486851215362549,
-0.9747648239135742,
-0.5237761735916138,
-0.5018566250801086,
-0.8194820880889893,
0.12365569919347763,
-0.13043330609798431,
-0.6826093792915344,
-0.009343469515442848,
0.24457918107509613,
-0.3417496979236603,
0.08211808651685715,
-0.7528337836265564,
0.8415165543556213,
-0.8242225646972656,
-0.5327605605125427,
-0.35576510429382324,
-0.315997451543808,
0.11278676986694336,
-0.05547786504030228,
-0.21346108615398407,
-0.28813111782073975,
-0.16435606777668,
0.7017747759819031,
0.10435735434293747,
0.7612369656562805,
-0.06344930082559586,
-0.005996211897581816,
0.19657760858535767,
0.37827080488204956,
0.10429263114929199,
0.2065989375114441,
-0.2353980988264084,
0.2246326059103012,
0.389309287071228,
-0.45771121978759766,
-0.9003749489784241,
0.45080506801605225,
-0.7729288935661316,
-0.9734379649162292,
-0.28106123208999634,
-0.6147793531417847,
-0.7016207575798035,
0.1386404037475586,
0.21598301827907562,
0.5098034739494324,
-0.6003153324127197,
0.4315588176250458,
0.6736722588539124,
-0.31001487374305725,
0.597150444984436,
0.6717191338539124,
-0.2798687517642975,
0.2854185104370117,
0.8296379446983337,
0.5327881574630737,
0.590545654296875,
0.2545739412307739,
0.3208591043949127,
-0.25348106026649475,
-0.8412961363792419,
-0.3393601179122925,
0.11874915659427643,
-0.710197925567627,
0.041546422988176346,
-0.16348311305046082,
-0.2784081697463989,
-0.037953417748212814,
0.29820913076400757,
-0.4583902955055237,
-0.044421110302209854,
-0.49082866311073303,
0.1575886309146881,
0.31175997853279114,
0.9629725813865662,
0.05644286796450615,
0.6490230560302734,
-0.5537212491035461,
-0.049839407205581665,
0.519685685634613,
0.8355546593666077,
0.11814224720001221,
-0.8372331857681274,
-0.34233638644218445,
-0.2218812108039856,
-0.27068543434143066,
-0.8377465605735779,
0.2060949057340622,
0.3002144694328308,
0.7836344242095947,
0.6572867631912231,
-0.07039661705493927,
0.6359313130378723,
-0.6920850276947021,
0.8389158844947815,
0.03489834815263748,
-0.8068870902061462,
0.25092461705207825,
-0.6614084839820862,
0.29568052291870117,
0.5314544439315796,
0.09454188495874405,
-0.36235958337783813,
-0.2813315689563751,
-0.8863611817359924,
-0.46724608540534973,
0.6650218367576599,
0.09841889142990112,
0.6365984678268433,
0.01126068364828825,
0.41972100734710693,
0.03736533597111702,
0.3681105971336365,
-0.5137925744056702,
-0.32992833852767944,
-0.17632918059825897,
0.11619480699300766,
-0.21670669317245483,
-0.5507721304893494,
-0.2541980743408203,
-0.17550325393676758,
0.36634284257888794,
-0.19971033930778503,
0.29677802324295044,
-0.1906321495771408,
0.1795285940170288,
-0.045488134026527405,
0.2325349748134613,
0.581402063369751,
1.0698908567428589,
-0.34455642104148865,
0.07890819758176804,
0.14673861861228943,
0.0189772117882967,
-0.07933587580919266,
0.0844336599111557,
0.1164771243929863,
-0.30848070979118347,
0.4709089398384094,
0.6926466822624207,
0.47023993730545044,
-0.6263651251792908,
0.29508858919143677,
-0.003976473584771156,
-0.1326947957277298,
0.19205929338932037,
0.711668848991394,
-0.05225364863872528,
0.4738703966140747,
0.4241941273212433,
-0.33729201555252075,
0.2570771276950836,
-0.7627695798873901,
0.2299986183643341,
0.5094510912895203,
-0.4923752248287201,
-0.36760401725769043,
0.6487318277359009,
0.3539711534976959,
-0.6933072805404663,
0.09102082997560501,
-0.28727105259895325,
-0.08944037556648254,
0.679864764213562,
0.5764156579971313,
0.529859185218811,
-0.19888539612293243,
0.3743803799152374,
0.1509825587272644,
0.17278477549552917,
-0.18544843792915344,
0.07383132725954056,
0.174939826130867,
-0.7368452548980713,
-0.19257189333438873,
-0.32183918356895447,
-0.3999056816101074,
0.16568593680858612,
-0.5761469006538391,
-0.12417832016944885,
-0.612152636051178,
-0.33296486735343933,
0.13804791867733002,
0.3016274869441986,
-0.7393895983695984,
0.23995576798915863,
0.038885388523340225,
0.8749182820320129,
-0.8078265190124512,
0.4587792456150055,
0.2712211012840271,
-0.586112380027771,
-0.534275233745575,
-0.15706661343574524,
-0.12781554460525513,
-0.8556215167045593,
0.5037518739700317,
-0.16268227994441986,
0.04977307841181755,
0.0027576282154768705,
-0.7392498850822449,
-1.1035239696502686,
0.7747268080711365,
0.3784438669681549,
-0.5233713388442993,
-0.06599317491054535,
0.21350480616092682,
0.8548825979232788,
-0.407703161239624,
0.4891601800918579,
0.7047634124755859,
0.1495961993932724,
-0.09769340604543686,
-0.8992032408714294,
-0.25963711738586426,
0.10305503755807877,
0.267673134803772,
-0.2338705062866211,
-1.1305453777313232,
0.8147289752960205,
-0.14867544174194336,
-0.14317849278450012,
0.35917308926582336,
0.6853775382041931,
0.25729337334632874,
0.09646293520927429,
0.3331400156021118,
0.1882031410932541,
0.4520944356918335,
-0.20048215985298157,
0.9574800729751587,
-0.5541023015975952,
0.4706460237503052,
0.9142205119132996,
-0.48527291417121887,
0.843090295791626,
0.4827192425727844,
-0.4172777831554413,
0.08541221916675568,
0.4228150546550751,
-0.2986817955970764,
0.3318790793418884,
0.3431593179702759,
0.034471698105335236,
-0.44312575459480286,
0.19431117177009583,
-0.21849438548088074,
0.9559606313705444,
0.032026734203100204,
-0.3884322941303253,
-0.26314112544059753,
-0.31402358412742615,
-0.14618612825870514,
0.34428390860557556,
-0.11992066353559494,
0.6983593106269836,
0.03435064107179642,
-0.7297460436820984,
0.08483772724866867,
0.08038190752267838,
0.2650405466556549,
-0.6522873640060425,
-0.21243150532245636,
-0.2193617820739746,
0.19295452535152435,
0.09568668156862259,
-0.7834004163742065,
-0.23864597082138062,
-0.31683409214019775,
-0.24558070302009583,
-0.042689450085163116,
0.37822777032852173,
-0.17712217569351196,
-0.6060311794281006,
0.40331941843032837,
0.7856684923171997,
0.26252591609954834,
0.16608472168445587,
-0.9659742712974548,
0.35459625720977783,
-0.3217741549015045,
-0.2534835636615753,
0.4954230487346649,
0.6220259666442871,
0.3038763403892517,
0.7896639704704285,
0.3103785514831543,
0.282694935798645,
0.11554808914661407,
0.14954707026481628,
0.45070943236351013,
-0.7558773756027222,
-0.3874146044254303,
-0.7456218600273132,
0.14369472861289978,
-0.0486888624727726,
-0.7748682498931885,
0.9828214049339294,
0.47239601612091064,
0.6720621585845947,
0.12006636708974838,
0.48777422308921814,
0.1737644076347351,
0.37006962299346924,
-0.5840175747871399,
0.5873368382453918,
-0.3910504877567291,
0.4667097330093384,
-0.3080601394176483,
-0.9785169959068298,
0.019280439242720604,
0.4896625876426697,
-0.42784321308135986,
0.684389054775238,
0.4258536994457245,
0.7608056664466858,
0.18276193737983704,
-0.11777649819850922,
0.8259400725364685,
0.20871932804584503,
0.5952185988426208,
0.33773109316825867,
0.9763909578323364,
-0.5505970120429993,
0.5248555541038513,
0.02826652117073536,
-0.04498281702399254,
-0.3516526222229004,
-0.9359741806983948,
-0.7546513080596924,
-0.6613005995750427,
-0.3706521987915039,
-0.3646577000617981,
0.1311645209789276,
0.4955868721008301,
1.045622706413269,
-0.6282457113265991,
-0.6314416527748108,
0.07015670835971832,
-0.16155526041984558,
-0.5062001943588257,
-0.20278184115886688,
-0.009713453240692616,
-0.6279186606407166,
-0.5520035028457642,
0.35148271918296814,
0.04273270070552826,
-0.21392877399921417,
-0.6983060240745544,
0.010057834908366203,
0.013669565320014954,
0.43779876828193665,
0.511854887008667,
0.41612327098846436,
-0.7028785347938538,
-0.5061349868774414,
0.049315791577100754,
-0.12452346831560135,
0.21021941304206848,
0.6771567463874817,
-0.565933883190155,
0.6263818740844727,
0.18000978231430054,
0.5158390402793884,
0.5926485657691956,
0.17588284611701965,
0.5487711429595947,
-0.772771954536438,
-0.16086305677890778,
-0.006435485556721687,
0.1764281690120697,
0.1962195783853531,
-0.06880055367946625,
0.3952588140964508,
0.1628347784280777,
-0.8091081380844116,
-0.7719981670379639,
0.33230042457580566,
-0.8148669004440308,
-0.1998508721590042,
1.292736291885376,
0.06175452098250389,
-0.09418603032827377,
-0.025406628847122192,
-0.085301972925663,
-0.1356307715177536,
-0.23188447952270508,
0.9431921243667603,
0.8917268514633179,
-0.6720486879348755,
-0.5361778140068054,
-0.8300603032112122,
0.7682933211326599,
0.21570655703544617,
-0.49073266983032227,
0.21716180443763733,
0.398847371339798,
0.3629414141178131,
0.13762041926383972,
0.4419901669025421,
0.10846289992332458,
0.18359878659248352,
0.202793151140213,
-0.18687549233436584,
-0.03396768122911453,
-0.5176504254341125,
-0.42478933930397034,
0.19063526391983032,
0.5735676884651184,
-0.09442941099405289
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14048v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14048v1 | Prompt Injection Attacks in Defended Systems | 2024-06-20T07:13:25 | 2024-06-20T07:13:25 | Daniil Khomsky, Narek Maloyan, Bulat Nutfullin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models play a crucial role in modern natural language
processing technologies. However, their extensive use also introduces potential
security risks, such as the possibility of black-box attacks. These attacks can
embed hidden malicious features into the model, leading to adverse consequences
during its deployment.
This paper investigates methods for black-box attacks on large language
models with a three-tiered defense mechanism. It analyzes the challenges and
significance of these attacks, highlighting their potential implications for
language processing system security. Existing attack and defense methods are
examined, evaluating their effectiveness and applicability across various
scenarios.
Special attention is given to the detection algorithm for black-box attacks,
identifying hazardous vulnerabilities in language models and retrieving
sensitive information. This research presents a methodology for vulnerability
detection and the development of defensive strategies against black-box attacks
on large language models. | [
-0.27941885590553284,
-1.4851993322372437,
0.7457791566848755,
0.04758841544389725,
0.07831943780183792,
0.04553845897316933,
0.11974214017391205,
-0.6199774742126465,
-0.48572951555252075,
0.7504571080207825,
-0.2940675616264343,
-0.2361653596162796,
-0.4957502484321594,
0.08433099836111069,
-0.48937278985977173,
0.6979598999023438,
0.2517088055610657,
-0.20951944589614868,
0.2276482880115509,
0.22064827382564545,
-1.117003321647644,
-0.7674622535705566,
-0.6660434007644653,
0.15228953957557678,
0.09379106014966965,
-0.10035759955644608,
0.7968169450759888,
0.1843041032552719,
0.3445441722869873,
0.40654754638671875,
-0.1815912425518036,
-0.6128308773040771,
-0.020964307710528374,
0.6072169542312622,
-0.37596842646598816,
-0.6898775100708008,
-0.34811508655548096,
-0.35723844170570374,
0.5367155075073242,
0.43770551681518555,
-0.02948264591395855,
-0.14842002093791962,
-0.16732065379619598,
0.17152151465415955,
-0.9229310750961304,
-0.3143644332885742,
-0.7474917769432068,
0.24309656023979187,
-0.6218357086181641,
-0.105552077293396,
-1.0854382514953613,
0.02507302537560463,
0.026148131117224693,
-0.08278461545705795,
-0.11291594058275223,
0.18957751989364624,
0.6551246047019958,
-0.1308165192604065,
-0.4630288779735565,
-0.16077883541584015,
-0.5482730269432068,
0.8144808411598206,
-0.8505306839942932,
-0.0830431804060936,
0.24309185147285461,
0.7383461594581604,
-0.47501903772354126,
-0.18062186241149902,
-0.6110227704048157,
-0.34750255942344666,
-0.15846896171569824,
-0.427559494972229,
-0.9313569664955139,
0.14912113547325134,
0.45046180486679077,
0.22062543034553528,
-0.5737528204917908,
0.4506942629814148,
0.02641657181084156,
-0.12981392443180084,
0.26551303267478943,
0.16751067340373993,
0.7897377610206604,
-0.4737292528152466,
-0.3232237994670868,
-0.013175747357308865,
-0.8250895142555237,
-0.027664968743920326,
0.5697691440582275,
0.5168149471282959,
-0.12734074890613556,
0.5119602084159851,
-0.06476601213216782,
0.989319384098053,
0.03961410000920296,
-0.10534454137086868,
-0.22200103104114532,
-0.3006211519241333,
-0.30012252926826477,
-0.10861444473266602,
0.8912811279296875,
-0.016511287540197372,
0.16452006995677948,
-0.05470718815922737,
-0.6303296685218811,
-0.05189630016684532,
0.5551420450210571,
-0.6034022569656372,
0.2608083486557007,
0.4215337038040161,
-0.19185534119606018,
-0.6038748621940613,
-0.15536212921142578,
-1.0233060121536255,
-0.49135106801986694,
0.5357761979103088,
0.5261819362640381,
-0.4753836393356323,
-0.3940715789794922,
0.19470740854740143,
-0.2619454860687256,
0.264445036649704,
0.037076435983181,
-0.7562741637229919,
0.43195390701293945,
0.7891436219215393,
0.8451983332633972,
-0.13010409474372864,
0.15882347524166107,
-0.900974452495575,
0.5585799813270569,
-0.22769345343112946,
0.7735065221786499,
-0.6531218886375427,
-0.3820476830005646,
0.39247071743011475,
0.036594342440366745,
0.3836170732975006,
-0.38567379117012024,
0.4322099983692169,
-0.6102185845375061,
0.10901787132024765,
0.1503809243440628,
-0.29022106528282166,
0.01434357650578022,
0.35806262493133545,
-0.5292835831642151,
0.7459865808486938,
-0.02274269238114357,
-0.9697103500366211,
-0.26556122303009033,
-0.6228420734405518,
-0.6171992421150208,
0.44157519936561584,
0.03194034472107887,
-0.22932171821594238,
0.2245710790157318,
0.19059912860393524,
0.7772887349128723,
-0.24799633026123047,
0.16158801317214966,
-0.49873682856559753,
-0.0847008153796196,
0.2626497447490692,
-0.44165557622909546,
1.119913935661316,
0.23127032816410065,
-0.4321328401565552,
0.05161925405263901,
-0.7027481198310852,
-0.1158444955945015,
0.3864825665950775,
0.17731547355651855,
-0.5521004796028137,
-0.02591385506093502,
-0.31199178099632263,
-0.025121241807937622,
0.09433320164680481,
-0.5295521020889282,
0.2932981550693512,
-0.6939259171485901,
0.6123381853103638,
0.6474028825759888,
0.5113352537155151,
0.29815012216567993,
0.21548870205879211,
0.8572174906730652,
0.17455530166625977,
0.613492488861084,
-0.5067320466041565,
-0.4509598910808563,
-0.3066810369491577,
-0.17932754755020142,
-0.0023652412928640842,
0.9235255122184753,
-1.0060452222824097,
0.5436768531799316,
0.22836485505104065,
-0.31133347749710083,
-0.18645085394382477,
-0.1769954413175583,
0.47366079688072205,
0.2286594659090042,
0.355104923248291,
0.29672589898109436,
-0.10799041390419006,
-1.1434749364852905,
-0.18448758125305176,
-0.1706063449382782,
-0.18508589267730713,
-0.2619943916797638,
0.49414393305778503,
-0.29201844334602356,
0.5656125545501709,
-0.6027873754501343,
0.2827278971672058,
-0.20887494087219238,
-0.11899953335523605,
0.20332004129886627,
0.6597740054130554,
0.8600112199783325,
-0.3079850375652313,
-0.24395474791526794,
0.24035939574241638,
-0.7261629700660706,
-0.2655941843986511,
0.06583976000547409,
-0.20289486646652222,
0.13738666474819183,
0.4372495114803314,
-0.8277718424797058,
0.3823494017124176,
0.3492381274700165,
-0.401422917842865,
0.7476685643196106,
0.11807169020175934,
-0.018259288743138313,
-1.0018733739852905,
-0.13448353111743927,
0.06340683996677399,
-0.284166157245636,
-1.2801928520202637,
0.7436860203742981,
0.16626723110675812,
-0.49295371770858765,
-0.6507276892662048,
0.7355107069015503,
-0.31419387459754944,
0.15753227472305298,
-0.122015081346035,
-0.1926441788673401,
0.23709076642990112,
0.09247278422117233,
-0.2722287178039551,
0.6562451124191284,
0.9978510737419128,
-0.5036343336105347,
0.2782168388366699,
-0.08904110640287399,
-0.2514449656009674,
1.0061936378479004,
-0.8374210596084595,
0.24245212972164154,
0.027185257524251938,
0.2117910236120224,
-0.9534773230552673,
-0.018858974799513817,
0.6603676080703735,
-0.21690505743026733,
0.7160959243774414,
-0.2200082391500473,
-0.38783127069473267,
-0.4240609109401703,
-0.4057406187057495,
0.3953914940357208,
0.18449817597866058,
-0.28466910123825073,
0.46576762199401855,
0.43595632910728455,
-0.4153870940208435,
-0.9725614786148071,
-0.7820866703987122,
0.4844936728477478,
-0.38783201575279236,
-0.6342601180076599,
0.19701556861400604,
0.1482105851173401,
-0.40989312529563904,
-0.39063313603401184,
0.23984752595424652,
-0.037574827671051025,
0.6475469470024109,
0.018895648419857025,
0.34359872341156006,
-0.163438618183136,
-0.12085209041833878,
-0.0491672083735466,
-0.13402846455574036,
0.20210039615631104,
-0.1775611937046051,
0.5063905715942383,
0.14829707145690918,
-0.6109502911567688,
-0.7225852012634277,
0.9864376783370972,
0.5534493923187256,
-0.1829005926847458,
0.7502408623695374,
0.30101531744003296,
-0.6214861273765564,
-0.31726667284965515,
-0.7477742433547974,
-0.13901689648628235,
-0.49272215366363525,
0.4601883292198181,
-0.4764307737350464,
-0.7139618992805481,
0.35845667123794556,
0.441078782081604,
0.005486983805894852,
0.27605265378952026,
0.43929731845855713,
0.21433450281620026,
1.2723087072372437,
0.43046772480010986,
0.019071009010076523,
0.45710140466690063,
0.14975741505622864,
0.5965248942375183,
-0.49586349725723267,
-0.09039261937141418,
-0.9666509032249451,
0.3565911650657654,
-0.25287264585494995,
-0.18963317573070526,
0.15822213888168335,
0.11182305961847305,
-0.3070008158683777,
0.48889148235321045,
-0.5040253400802612,
0.4028223156929016,
0.3122948706150055,
-0.1475241482257843,
0.023856082931160927,
-0.14671733975410461,
-0.29985523223876953,
0.28758329153060913,
-0.3515431582927704,
-0.5855022668838501,
0.5888293981552124,
0.7718856930732727,
0.7550796270370483,
0.41884151101112366,
0.4411025643348694,
0.48726892471313477,
0.038685619831085205,
-0.6065558791160583,
0.7021986842155457,
0.2755703926086426,
-0.520903468132019,
-0.16390681266784668,
-0.3939686715602875,
-0.9844398498535156,
0.19082467257976532,
-0.04285193979740143,
-0.8864063024520874,
0.136540949344635,
-0.10753487795591354,
-0.548159658908844,
0.30039170384407043,
-1.2408350706100464,
0.8829315304756165,
-0.2702046036720276,
-0.3246801793575287,
0.010793954133987427,
-0.3439059257507324,
0.5821287631988525,
-0.23707398772239685,
0.2193920761346817,
0.20935972034931183,
0.12506882846355438,
0.3541601896286011,
-0.22071652114391327,
0.8884972333908081,
-0.4401739835739136,
-0.4554319977760315,
0.045555781573057175,
0.6270574927330017,
0.6766024231910706,
0.22825118899345398,
-0.10892732441425323,
0.16434083878993988,
0.153614342212677,
-0.7474855780601501,
-0.4354824125766754,
0.5785493850708008,
-0.3619270324707031,
-1.3931242227554321,
-0.5076724886894226,
-0.27501100301742554,
-0.11830819398164749,
0.2721951901912689,
-0.09496385604143143,
0.38423478603363037,
-0.08249824494123459,
-0.05439293757081032,
0.5385065078735352,
-0.9808658361434937,
0.7390111088752747,
0.593030571937561,
-0.01831825263798237,
-0.21868930757045746,
0.5879877805709839,
-0.042538248002529144,
0.6921548843383789,
0.43644341826438904,
0.02296106331050396,
0.010870330035686493,
-0.9351723790168762,
-0.341110497713089,
0.05486417934298515,
-0.5581342577934265,
-0.754694938659668,
-0.8229833245277405,
-0.07612359523773193,
-0.6122891902923584,
-0.08928875625133514,
0.017135508358478546,
-0.07142922282218933,
0.05699998885393143,
-0.1760791391134262,
0.17823755741119385,
0.8302513360977173,
0.5394207239151001,
0.4926803708076477,
-0.6231604814529419,
0.20081238448619843,
0.45058494806289673,
0.21368062496185303,
0.24773059785366058,
-0.22626617550849915,
-0.06840065121650696,
-0.0554935522377491,
-0.4850583076477051,
-1.3881865739822388,
0.3583586513996124,
-0.42713719606399536,
0.65489262342453,
0.4878790080547333,
-0.06358969956636429,
0.1578049212694168,
-0.7266765236854553,
1.0251436233520508,
0.10685252398252487,
-1.0832959413528442,
0.8207967877388,
-0.3500536382198334,
0.6110204458236694,
0.08287322521209717,
0.188125342130661,
-0.4051365852355957,
-0.6181763410568237,
-0.43187421560287476,
-0.41514354944229126,
0.6672095656394958,
0.21900831162929535,
0.27760377526283264,
-0.4319235384464264,
0.17435811460018158,
0.014327713288366795,
0.1505560576915741,
-0.8657802939414978,
-0.05442645400762558,
-0.15582416951656342,
0.2675597667694092,
0.28143465518951416,
-0.4322143495082855,
-0.1529691219329834,
0.21954500675201416,
0.6653090715408325,
0.09891743957996368,
0.1251622885465622,
-0.21271146833896637,
-0.17055556178092957,
0.08164249360561371,
0.6673328280448914,
0.553625762462616,
0.1608813852071762,
0.08472828567028046,
0.33564645051956177,
0.12838809192180634,
-0.14122894406318665,
0.49814659357070923,
0.06701017171144485,
-0.2937030792236328,
-0.17237894237041473,
0.4598690867424011,
0.7099235653877258,
0.2559254765510559,
-0.5854740738868713,
0.7642881870269775,
0.026111088693141937,
0.4398786723613739,
-0.06193021312355995,
-0.01665933057665825,
-0.16773153841495514,
0.11535890400409698,
0.34715625643730164,
-0.07018110901117325,
0.13395416736602783,
-0.6275749802589417,
-0.03213755413889885,
0.9250184893608093,
-0.28276869654655457,
-0.34207433462142944,
0.10656264424324036,
0.004048041068017483,
-0.5688918232917786,
0.06362247467041016,
0.025145743042230606,
-0.6286803483963013,
0.44911497831344604,
0.829162061214447,
0.8269964456558228,
-0.838419497013092,
0.23349179327487946,
0.17064401507377625,
0.47339287400245667,
-0.056307602673769,
-0.18155819177627563,
0.08430665731430054,
-0.49160438776016235,
-0.2731599807739258,
-0.5171889066696167,
-0.16073434054851532,
0.2773968279361725,
-0.40935027599334717,
0.371539443731308,
-0.596574068069458,
-0.354261189699173,
0.22102878987789154,
-0.3869337737560272,
-0.42606571316719055,
-0.4963768720626831,
0.26554742455482483,
0.8387340307235718,
-0.7087162733078003,
0.3631094992160797,
0.2930927574634552,
-0.22938627004623413,
-0.22931188344955444,
-0.16275352239608765,
0.07287904620170593,
-0.4921448528766632,
0.5847751498222351,
0.14794303476810455,
0.032425615936517715,
-0.37934592366218567,
-0.3685537576675415,
-0.6094745993614197,
0.3015480935573578,
0.6352999806404114,
-0.43590104579925537,
-0.029400061815977097,
0.04868026450276375,
0.38115954399108887,
-0.10092910379171371,
0.37142521142959595,
0.6197376251220703,
0.5380863547325134,
-0.5109850168228149,
-0.6372352838516235,
0.41424912214279175,
-0.24940776824951172,
0.14636331796646118,
0.42260733246803284,
-0.21940451860427856,
0.8123384118080139,
0.1833321452140808,
-0.5826419591903687,
-0.15403738617897034,
0.32941654324531555,
0.25254619121551514,
-0.23241330683231354,
0.5156237483024597,
0.518444299697876,
0.4803224802017212,
0.043294887989759445,
1.351151466369629,
0.1347905397415161,
-0.20035848021507263,
0.5161715745925903,
-0.5310397744178772,
0.868281900882721,
0.4127659797668457,
-0.219365656375885,
0.47967788577079773,
0.08422864228487015,
-0.11592455208301544,
0.09066010266542435,
0.35025274753570557,
-0.43596580624580383,
0.09468874335289001,
-0.05083426833152771,
-0.5455740094184875,
0.12386226654052734,
0.5540009140968323,
0.045723915100097656,
-0.3329063057899475,
0.5321378111839294,
0.38503506779670715,
-0.08147849142551422,
-0.18800967931747437,
0.8229604959487915,
-0.02380507066845894,
-0.818065881729126,
0.7662235498428345,
0.21471339464187622,
0.6088270545005798,
-0.6374611854553223,
-0.041623927652835846,
0.027360063046216965,
-0.031236844137310982,
0.02855202555656433,
-0.8110008239746094,
0.026080982759594917,
0.11409222334623337,
-0.14170928299427032,
-0.13969574868679047,
0.6644688248634338,
-0.04131434112787247,
-0.3065812289714813,
0.4060766100883484,
0.2105776071548462,
-0.4042983949184418,
-0.17490547895431519,
-0.6022082567214966,
0.25335410237312317,
-0.2789810299873352,
-0.14937090873718262,
0.5338999629020691,
0.4490194022655487,
-0.2203659862279892,
0.8367709517478943,
0.6263704299926758,
0.24126821756362915,
-0.02036455273628235,
0.19276469945907593,
0.5922085642814636,
-0.5208851099014282,
-0.6171759963035583,
-1.2234104871749878,
0.29579588770866394,
-0.3339032828807831,
0.33288130164146423,
0.7603612542152405,
0.08443266898393631,
0.4092610776424408,
-0.09550727903842926,
0.7617211937904358,
0.15943096578121185,
0.3005402982234955,
-0.5564072132110596,
0.5152221918106079,
-0.060740724205970764,
0.537604033946991,
-0.6325773596763611,
-0.7875915765762329,
-0.49701446294784546,
0.1091093048453331,
-0.25177451968193054,
-0.10768840461969376,
0.8874081969261169,
0.99006187915802,
0.18783417344093323,
-0.07862574607133865,
0.24470730125904083,
0.498784601688385,
0.7837331295013428,
0.6795082092285156,
1.0887763500213623,
-0.2859843671321869,
0.4813570976257324,
-0.17553335428237915,
-0.3877120912075043,
-0.08452405035495758,
-0.967069149017334,
-1.169050931930542,
-0.38959455490112305,
-0.09983823448419571,
-0.38408318161964417,
0.3477015495300293,
0.32272908091545105,
0.7050522565841675,
-1.152573585510254,
-0.14404268562793732,
0.22199314832687378,
0.3142111897468567,
-0.16883529722690582,
-0.30083003640174866,
0.08819185197353363,
-0.28864461183547974,
-0.42704352736473083,
0.5336195826530457,
0.5641263127326965,
0.2990904152393341,
-0.6430909633636475,
0.46955764293670654,
-0.4259365499019623,
0.13887116312980652,
0.5572431087493896,
0.3675056993961334,
-0.9415301084518433,
-0.5727419257164001,
-0.34338244795799255,
-0.11311013996601105,
-0.3122303783893585,
0.7506924271583557,
-0.5777396559715271,
0.23772534728050232,
0.4670731723308563,
0.9606854915618896,
-0.17825333774089813,
-0.23757338523864746,
0.9666475653648376,
-0.7919291853904724,
0.44345495104789734,
0.23175309598445892,
0.3659125864505768,
0.41483274102211,
-0.7812056541442871,
0.031869012862443924,
0.046106599271297455,
-0.2044801115989685,
-1.4520083665847778,
0.4548243582248688,
-0.8547268509864807,
-0.5425241589546204,
0.9813637733459473,
-0.046422816812992096,
-0.3091704547405243,
-0.3929055631160736,
-0.20923282206058502,
-0.14417892694473267,
-0.42410939931869507,
0.5863091945648193,
0.9009650945663452,
0.5466979146003723,
-0.173884317278862,
-1.0077167749404907,
0.4610154926776886,
0.29140037298202515,
-0.9576811194419861,
0.21436792612075806,
0.2880011796951294,
-0.0836445614695549,
0.33002984523773193,
0.04685591533780098,
-0.2511277496814728,
0.24144889414310455,
-0.27801060676574707,
-0.038633160293102264,
0.1246289536356926,
-0.16062231361865997,
-0.5869330763816833,
0.7581781148910522,
-0.11650579422712326,
0.1477583646774292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14043v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14043v1 | Taxonomy-Guided Zero-Shot Recommendations with LLMs | 2024-06-20T07:06:58 | 2024-06-20T07:06:58 | Yueqing Liang, Liangwei Yang, Chen Wang, Xiongxiao Xu, Philip S. Yu, Kai Shu | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | With the emergence of large language models (LLMs) and their ability to
perform a variety of tasks, their application in recommender systems (RecSys)
has shown promise. However, we are facing significant challenges when deploying
LLMs into RecSys, such as limited prompt length, unstructured item information,
and un-constrained generation of recommendations, leading to sub-optimal
performance. To address these issues, we propose a novel method using a
taxonomy dictionary. This method provides a systematic framework for
categorizing and organizing items, improving the clarity and structure of item
information. By incorporating the taxonomy dictionary into LLM prompts, we
achieve efficient token utilization and controlled feature generation, leading
to more accurate and contextually relevant recommendations. Our Taxonomy-guided
Recommendation (TaxRec) approach features a two-step process: one-time taxonomy
categorization and LLM-based recommendation, enabling zero-shot recommendations
without the need for domain-specific fine-tuning. Experimental results
demonstrate TaxRec significantly enhances recommendation quality compared to
traditional zero-shot approaches, showcasing its efficacy as personal
recommender with LLMs. Code is available at
https://github.com/yueqingliang1/TaxRec. | [
-0.28304004669189453,
-0.4375190734863281,
0.47878575325012207,
0.055276721715927124,
-0.6627269387245178,
0.15593400597572327,
-0.032329414039850235,
-0.15940751135349274,
0.803214967250824,
0.6593285202980042,
-0.779358446598053,
-0.863534688949585,
-0.35468369722366333,
0.14956234395503998,
-0.17947548627853394,
1.0285898447036743,
0.1320757120847702,
-0.19364893436431885,
-0.42690616846084595,
-0.09228648245334625,
-0.8010796308517456,
-0.3955410420894623,
-0.5490959286689758,
-0.5242512226104736,
0.8898279070854187,
0.4722926616668701,
0.4141434133052826,
0.7950860857963562,
0.39318564534187317,
0.06809861958026886,
-0.1425803303718567,
0.23824246227741241,
-0.40641671419143677,
0.47068530321121216,
-0.3222208321094513,
-0.4330591857433319,
-0.4494249224662781,
-0.3520669937133789,
0.174125075340271,
0.5918117165565491,
-0.6115739345550537,
0.30833736062049866,
0.026910502463579178,
0.40650060772895813,
-0.9384920001029968,
-0.045482199639081955,
-0.5698774456977844,
0.0019147963030263782,
-0.3343120217323303,
-0.5509131550788879,
-0.29598140716552734,
-0.20121949911117554,
0.24767620861530304,
-0.571736752986908,
-0.02236136607825756,
0.03610266000032425,
0.47322991490364075,
0.10732070356607437,
-0.3847474753856659,
-0.059254273772239685,
-0.8150524497032166,
0.6873765587806702,
-0.609891951084137,
0.3808037340641022,
0.3851219117641449,
0.11616095155477524,
-0.158683642745018,
-0.6816343665122986,
-0.19773080945014954,
-0.030386410653591156,
0.03923909738659859,
0.09091939777135849,
-0.47602349519729614,
0.06206347048282623,
0.07053937017917633,
0.16477562487125397,
-0.6962644457817078,
0.11501262336969376,
0.05136454850435257,
-0.10606899857521057,
0.3209046423435211,
0.3948979079723358,
-0.041108470410108566,
-0.16541364789009094,
-0.5072433352470398,
0.21476174890995026,
-0.770205020904541,
-0.2482369989156723,
-0.01380483340471983,
0.5615703463554382,
0.28327250480651855,
0.6325326561927795,
-0.4320478141307831,
0.8562110066413879,
-0.033763587474823,
-0.15176407992839813,
0.09245224297046661,
-0.46137288212776184,
-0.22034701704978943,
-0.013894503936171532,
0.5289053320884705,
0.5857350826263428,
0.08293258398771286,
-0.15027114748954773,
-0.3750104010105133,
-0.12547269463539124,
0.2809532582759857,
-0.7981152534484863,
-0.09263914823532104,
0.25398391485214233,
-0.21566073596477509,
-0.44541528820991516,
-0.10535363107919693,
-0.7011551260948181,
-0.5944118499755859,
-0.07390028238296509,
0.5380522012710571,
-0.21411360800266266,
-0.11126768589019775,
0.23344188928604126,
-0.11668770760297775,
-0.01292596198618412,
0.25923073291778564,
-0.9082252383232117,
0.3081359565258026,
0.8166943192481995,
1.167909026145935,
0.020176073536276817,
-0.034048620611429214,
-0.7180227041244507,
0.22633828222751617,
-0.30263227224349976,
1.226357340812683,
-0.5169951319694519,
-0.5272124409675598,
0.2266349196434021,
-0.19893282651901245,
0.4332960546016693,
-0.537339985370636,
0.13327528536319733,
-0.3886442184448242,
0.0546947605907917,
-0.10007402300834656,
-0.6216223239898682,
-0.26013195514678955,
0.31078749895095825,
-0.17474496364593506,
0.7680972218513489,
0.2708628177642822,
-0.3370080888271332,
0.6591514348983765,
-0.5058049559593201,
-0.49593961238861084,
0.7160652875900269,
-0.0655369758605957,
-0.034171998500823975,
0.05719823017716408,
0.09904459118843079,
0.6198381185531616,
-0.35428765416145325,
0.29956358671188354,
-0.44310879707336426,
-0.3331245481967926,
-0.2537558972835541,
-0.1420152634382248,
0.35256272554397583,
0.2625664472579956,
0.07609064877033234,
0.32847729325294495,
-0.5714043378829956,
-0.07219886779785156,
0.05810553580522537,
-0.13605254888534546,
-0.553172767162323,
-0.04232306033372879,
-0.14527744054794312,
-0.10820914804935455,
0.3586730360984802,
-0.5173590183258057,
0.5760396718978882,
-0.7313829064369202,
0.43889936804771423,
0.6574050188064575,
0.27930858731269836,
0.5970473289489746,
-0.5267929434776306,
0.703034520149231,
-0.11898726969957352,
0.11625102907419205,
-0.4658145606517792,
-0.3655083477497101,
-0.6045299172401428,
-0.11472385376691818,
0.4076733887195587,
0.5006111860275269,
-0.8126561045646667,
0.6874122619628906,
-0.1299644112586975,
-0.5206854343414307,
-0.2047976702451706,
0.22177951037883759,
0.15818770229816437,
0.4658403992652893,
0.24150758981704712,
-0.6521454453468323,
-0.5226209163665771,
-0.5977609157562256,
-0.08179035782814026,
-0.26107943058013916,
-0.3367565870285034,
0.47922563552856445,
0.2703513503074646,
-0.27747368812561035,
0.9055606126785278,
-0.9631544351577759,
-0.5380247831344604,
-0.17037269473075867,
0.07911689579486847,
0.47162336111068726,
0.05757354199886322,
0.4630475342273712,
-0.003467810107395053,
-0.10760831832885742,
-0.5157246589660645,
-0.01936006173491478,
-0.4038410782814026,
-0.09583310037851334,
-0.2067926973104477,
0.19989430904388428,
0.04004176706075668,
-0.2578929662704468,
0.41467878222465515,
0.10531256347894669,
-0.6139490008354187,
0.2935464680194855,
-0.222886323928833,
-0.3044790029525757,
-1.2208212614059448,
-0.14924006164073944,
0.3096609115600586,
-0.38224661350250244,
-0.519905149936676,
-0.17562291026115417,
-0.0744272768497467,
0.20657745003700256,
-0.35815227031707764,
0.780718207359314,
0.10147251188755035,
0.20030343532562256,
-0.20736227929592133,
0.1863836795091629,
0.1649934947490692,
0.4006723463535309,
0.1730700433254242,
0.4212454855442047,
0.57533198595047,
-0.626002848148346,
0.4498286843299866,
0.30413371324539185,
-0.47232791781425476,
0.7562400102615356,
-0.3690435588359833,
-0.03788796812295914,
-0.034258849918842316,
0.3443889617919922,
-0.9911365509033203,
0.10316586494445801,
0.377318412065506,
-0.13376688957214355,
0.19144204258918762,
-0.25668105483055115,
-0.48571375012397766,
-0.032741475850343704,
-0.7121487259864807,
0.34310203790664673,
0.34133055806159973,
-0.5760194063186646,
0.5497522354125977,
0.21444980800151825,
0.019559036940336227,
-0.5951389670372009,
-0.6091436743736267,
0.27871131896972656,
-0.07060618698596954,
-0.29233649373054504,
0.4425485134124756,
-0.2278119921684265,
0.05454011261463165,
-0.030918708071112633,
-0.2359391152858734,
0.2893384099006653,
0.13793161511421204,
0.4486021101474762,
0.48024845123291016,
-0.1621246337890625,
0.42740678787231445,
-0.21420183777809143,
-0.13221105933189392,
-0.26977384090423584,
-0.6856827735900879,
0.693809986114502,
0.17308668792247772,
0.015205439180135727,
-0.21663621068000793,
0.13980649411678314,
0.39792129397392273,
-0.13993343710899353,
0.5286580324172974,
0.34350115060806274,
-0.17261385917663574,
-0.41530483961105347,
-0.6166130304336548,
-0.24509559571743011,
-0.4621857702732086,
0.1483447253704071,
-0.2577894926071167,
-0.9618933200836182,
0.11160668730735779,
-0.18277961015701294,
0.1987144649028778,
0.28905460238456726,
0.5822722911834717,
-0.01564585044980049,
0.6593108177185059,
0.7585993409156799,
-0.2749805152416229,
0.7109483480453491,
-0.40500253438949585,
0.09375211596488953,
-0.9211708307266235,
-0.4385485053062439,
-0.3825485408306122,
-0.25809022784233093,
-0.3610360324382782,
-0.23000071942806244,
0.17532092332839966,
0.012685581110417843,
-0.48188433051109314,
0.5015289783477783,
-0.7791605591773987,
0.4154970943927765,
0.8106830716133118,
-0.011512440629303455,
0.35663002729415894,
0.0795045867562294,
-0.22601866722106934,
0.3535821735858917,
-0.8714182376861572,
-0.24739143252372742,
1.0544687509536743,
0.23049765825271606,
0.908379077911377,
0.11413021385669708,
0.9347307085990906,
0.2559868097305298,
0.1824032962322235,
-1.4319987297058105,
0.5522526502609253,
-0.5247583389282227,
-0.2284572571516037,
-0.11252747476100922,
-0.3115553855895996,
-0.925434410572052,
-0.036617133766412735,
-0.31784865260124207,
-0.7573115825653076,
0.4409922957420349,
-0.17035916447639465,
-0.9969907402992249,
0.40453118085861206,
-0.29766222834587097,
0.5581183433532715,
-0.2369937300682068,
-0.21546946465969086,
-0.12341880053281784,
-0.27385255694389343,
0.09276743233203888,
-0.1782217025756836,
0.019642069935798645,
-0.41159841418266296,
-0.4556408226490021,
0.8056930899620056,
-0.5139821767807007,
0.6385038495063782,
-0.1690433919429779,
-0.21375007927417755,
0.22751621901988983,
0.7436200976371765,
0.20758557319641113,
0.11401298642158508,
-0.040071967989206314,
0.4879341423511505,
0.45848745107650757,
0.11591882258653641,
-0.6282084584236145,
0.7620396614074707,
-0.4135129451751709,
-0.7082144021987915,
-0.5433913469314575,
-0.34224531054496765,
-0.27270275354385376,
0.41783180832862854,
0.07734605669975281,
0.5905579924583435,
0.04309539869427681,
0.108722023665905,
0.19013935327529907,
-0.13940048217773438,
0.36390221118927,
0.8997406363487244,
-0.45149070024490356,
-0.8396845459938049,
0.870675265789032,
0.15934942662715912,
-0.07096827775239944,
0.5843835473060608,
0.31692758202552795,
-0.5585585832595825,
-0.6321262717247009,
-0.21255168318748474,
0.2933978736400604,
-0.5251454710960388,
-0.7749518752098083,
-0.1677245795726776,
0.1307123601436615,
-0.5630847811698914,
-0.20777280628681183,
0.0037919196765869856,
-0.4371911883354187,
-0.6126933097839355,
0.06331199407577515,
0.6671337485313416,
0.9213801622390747,
0.036605097353458405,
0.40698760747909546,
-0.6168420910835266,
0.31839221715927124,
0.16750992834568024,
0.9806423187255859,
-0.04519059881567955,
-0.7616017460823059,
-0.1045433059334755,
-0.13914676010608673,
-0.18225185573101044,
-0.4181135296821594,
0.4526171088218689,
0.16649241745471954,
0.11090556532144547,
0.6685514450073242,
0.23097819089889526,
0.7620470523834229,
-0.5440441370010376,
0.8963766098022461,
0.2934945225715637,
-0.6446624398231506,
0.740792989730835,
-0.2248179316520691,
0.526527464389801,
0.4531930685043335,
0.19215995073318481,
-0.7613628506660461,
-0.16844876110553741,
-0.33842745423316956,
-0.8715971112251282,
0.654392659664154,
-0.09419996291399002,
0.20676109194755554,
-0.13220995664596558,
0.7198952436447144,
0.014985039830207825,
0.21273721754550934,
-0.08767489343881607,
-0.3134084641933441,
-0.11644405871629715,
-0.06544359028339386,
-0.38702380657196045,
-0.7670395374298096,
-0.20522111654281616,
-0.13190911710262299,
0.5925217866897583,
-0.06088680773973465,
-0.10463599860668182,
0.22712154686450958,
0.2946849465370178,
-0.4187817871570587,
0.2942560911178589,
0.6527587175369263,
0.5710219740867615,
-0.5880593061447144,
0.052049119025468826,
0.08639948070049286,
-0.2497163563966751,
0.2121688425540924,
-0.26008492708206177,
-0.15156017243862152,
0.05522632971405983,
0.22977498173713684,
0.6492739319801331,
0.1932719349861145,
-0.41581612825393677,
0.4090180993080139,
-0.08547139167785645,
-0.36560171842575073,
-0.1707761585712433,
0.056337933987379074,
-0.05758577957749367,
0.2233765721321106,
0.18592464923858643,
-0.06608805060386658,
-0.03722026199102402,
-0.4763278067111969,
0.288093626499176,
0.6431519985198975,
-0.21201953291893005,
0.057857248932123184,
0.3504026532173157,
0.41853418946266174,
-0.4363555610179901,
0.4573095142841339,
0.1494249552488327,
-0.13792984187602997,
0.1439901739358902,
0.5011231303215027,
1.1924008131027222,
-0.03102337382733822,
0.3846883773803711,
0.2546718716621399,
0.20006510615348816,
-0.25723564624786377,
0.11386936902999878,
-0.3513575792312622,
-0.8166427612304688,
-0.39587101340293884,
-0.9530108571052551,
-0.5151600241661072,
0.056176554411649704,
-0.5302470326423645,
0.5652948021888733,
-0.7772566080093384,
-0.36280667781829834,
0.09838750958442688,
0.13894250988960266,
-0.3461951017379761,
-0.008472947403788567,
0.3991788327693939,
1.1050704717636108,
-0.3068698048591614,
0.692031741142273,
0.4822179675102234,
-0.48095571994781494,
-0.8119345307350159,
-0.2807862460613251,
0.16194500029087067,
-0.8338904976844788,
0.41376882791519165,
-0.21307717263698578,
-0.4673304259777069,
-0.010722972452640533,
-0.23323331773281097,
-0.7025691270828247,
1.2948485612869263,
0.30802789330482483,
-0.7640794515609741,
0.20563821494579315,
0.009670323692262173,
0.4579353332519531,
-0.5644607543945312,
0.4097241461277008,
0.43426743149757385,
0.2458925098180771,
0.7870278358459473,
-0.8869004845619202,
0.08229129761457443,
0.06769950687885284,
0.32177218794822693,
0.3732607662677765,
-0.4512961208820343,
0.3059413731098175,
-0.15497276186943054,
-0.37979042530059814,
0.1826014667749405,
0.22129057347774506,
0.1881079077720642,
0.2685462236404419,
0.5137553215026855,
0.6018585562705994,
0.6683522462844849,
0.1423976719379425,
0.8737426400184631,
-0.36922723054885864,
0.28462350368499756,
1.3617597818374634,
-0.5822204947471619,
0.9408787488937378,
0.27610063552856445,
-0.10916551947593689,
0.7510770559310913,
0.801796555519104,
-0.39200183749198914,
0.5037915706634521,
0.2329660952091217,
-0.3487373888492584,
-0.38380420207977295,
-0.6969181895256042,
-0.0678766593337059,
0.35705846548080444,
0.177437886595726,
-0.04808838665485382,
-0.5000635981559753,
-0.06233270838856697,
-0.25846344232559204,
-0.2906270921230316,
-0.4329436719417572,
1.1762146949768066,
0.12570852041244507,
-0.4909278154373169,
0.8810011744499207,
-0.07475967705249786,
1.132165789604187,
-0.7481642961502075,
-0.1672680377960205,
-0.35144534707069397,
-0.0907074585556984,
-0.41158437728881836,
-1.0571764707565308,
0.11988377571105957,
0.09988708794116974,
-0.11340910941362381,
-0.40811675786972046,
0.761112630367279,
-0.43729692697525024,
-0.3686566948890686,
0.13218389451503754,
0.36673662066459656,
0.1486791968345642,
-0.22775717079639435,
-0.3493572473526001,
-0.4005076289176941,
-0.1246856227517128,
-0.03328602388501167,
0.2631506323814392,
0.23639991879463196,
0.2065577358007431,
0.9748635292053223,
0.4839767813682556,
0.4797990620136261,
-0.5431660413742065,
0.3602137565612793,
0.5913661122322083,
-0.7660031318664551,
-0.23649460077285767,
-1.0294098854064941,
0.11569494754076004,
0.4960852861404419,
-0.15540337562561035,
0.6748763918876648,
0.5824353098869324,
0.9435280561447144,
0.021395204588770866,
0.38229310512542725,
0.23074978590011597,
0.3048039674758911,
-0.16323721408843994,
0.5659924149513245,
-0.7513903975486755,
0.7275561690330505,
0.0038780206814408302,
-0.9097111821174622,
-0.9062885046005249,
0.20800204575061798,
-0.06465784460306168,
-0.0702827200293541,
0.48769140243530273,
1.0860772132873535,
0.350128173828125,
-0.2683022618293762,
0.5703279376029968,
-0.044247206300497055,
0.20815514028072357,
0.5176103711128235,
0.6625155806541443,
0.037305817008018494,
0.6510123014450073,
-0.4586943984031677,
-0.041689615696668625,
-0.33428066968917847,
-0.8876753449440002,
-0.6517587304115295,
-0.5270973443984985,
-0.43133729696273804,
-0.34748759865760803,
-0.12452782690525055,
1.2526456117630005,
0.5922229886054993,
-0.7936458587646484,
-0.4553568959236145,
0.0007441864581778646,
0.2896690368652344,
-0.05296442285180092,
-0.21164606511592865,
0.15776605904102325,
-0.1038520485162735,
-0.29858604073524475,
0.370026171207428,
0.6880689859390259,
0.0049543073400855064,
-0.38995057344436646,
0.2009316235780716,
-0.17863403260707855,
0.1923997402191162,
0.7450466156005859,
0.01142163760960102,
-0.9780369997024536,
-0.3403339684009552,
0.008306466974318027,
0.2040112316608429,
-0.0031792663503438234,
0.9559927582740784,
-1.1883409023284912,
0.6605626344680786,
0.5129335522651672,
0.04365164786577225,
0.24896971881389618,
-0.027082640677690506,
0.5158304572105408,
-0.6962935924530029,
-0.2652672231197357,
0.39678844809532166,
0.31084081530570984,
-0.15846382081508636,
-0.44753438234329224,
0.6013670563697815,
0.2313353568315506,
-0.3288552761077881,
-0.8618053197860718,
0.1908046156167984,
-1.1057566404342651,
-0.39179331064224243,
1.2860513925552368,
0.08029959350824356,
-0.1490994095802307,
0.007716560270637274,
-0.24618391692638397,
0.09937482327222824,
-0.7611344456672668,
0.6678010821342468,
0.5164027810096741,
-0.15882864594459534,
-0.08171042054891586,
-0.18047690391540527,
0.23127761483192444,
0.2759849727153778,
-0.30153438448905945,
0.2891887426376343,
0.357329398393631,
0.5409197211265564,
0.10118783265352249,
0.5630573630332947,
0.28773725032806396,
-0.054383065551519394,
-0.3966834843158722,
0.14738817512989044,
-0.31711265444755554,
-0.26631104946136475,
-0.8839821815490723,
0.13803386688232422,
0.22579416632652283,
-0.1408403217792511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14039v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14039v1 | CryptoGPT: a 7B model rivaling GPT-4 in the task of analyzing and classifying real-time financial news | 2024-06-20T06:59:46 | 2024-06-20T06:59:46 | Ying Zhang, Matthieu Petit Guillaume, Aurélien Krauth, Manel Labidi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.NE | CryptoGPT: a 7B model competing with GPT-4 in a specific task -- The Impact
of Automatic Annotation and Strategic Fine-Tuning via QLoRAIn this article, we
present a method aimed at refining a dedicated LLM of reasonable quality with
limited resources in an industrial setting via CryptoGPT. It is an LLM designed
for financial news analysis for the cryptocurrency market in real-time. This
project was launched in an industrial context. This model allows not only for
the classification of financial information but also for providing
comprehensive analysis. We refined different LLMs of the same size such as
Mistral-7B and LLama-7B using semi-automatic annotation and compared them with
various LLMs such as GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. Our goal is to find a balance among
several needs: 1. Protecting data (by avoiding their transfer to external
servers), 2. Limiting annotation cost and time, 3. Controlling the model's size
(to manage deployment costs), and 4. Maintaining better analysis quality. | [
-0.2508660852909088,
-0.7088193297386169,
0.2884804308414459,
0.13106437027454376,
-0.8788114786148071,
0.5646710991859436,
-0.011392457410693169,
-1.193297266960144,
0.1384679526090622,
0.6703161001205444,
-0.36909177899360657,
-0.5505170822143555,
-0.39556047320365906,
0.03277276083827019,
-0.5309748649597168,
1.0811177492141724,
-0.05828293785452843,
0.12670612335205078,
0.24877555668354034,
0.15473367273807526,
-0.24340693652629852,
-0.720079243183136,
-0.9428466558456421,
-0.23625892400741577,
0.10195966064929962,
0.030617399141192436,
0.7099269032478333,
0.864519476890564,
0.9022582173347473,
0.37711793184280396,
0.17630259692668915,
0.16692644357681274,
-0.2662559151649475,
-0.16180434823036194,
0.02498580701649189,
-0.5131880640983582,
-0.6864977478981018,
0.16063037514686584,
0.3760823905467987,
0.12403218448162079,
-0.254566490650177,
0.4625977873802185,
-0.1312408149242401,
0.3937433362007141,
-0.4095896780490875,
0.43526771664619446,
-0.5553874969482422,
-0.004169956780970097,
-0.10428031533956528,
-0.20495367050170898,
-0.06890138983726501,
-0.2983139157295227,
0.2216082513332367,
-0.5802432298660278,
0.4219954311847687,
0.42453986406326294,
1.1864714622497559,
0.07015852630138397,
-0.11768104881048203,
-0.2367241233587265,
-0.678855836391449,
0.6302058696746826,
-0.8624733686447144,
0.07665825635194778,
0.3168412148952484,
0.43360424041748047,
0.31200164556503296,
-0.880078136920929,
-0.0734298899769783,
-0.19314934313297272,
0.12696975469589233,
-0.0048378692008554935,
0.014324987307190895,
0.31787368655204773,
0.2317289561033249,
0.3650013208389282,
-0.24701957404613495,
0.01923432946205139,
-0.8615756630897522,
-0.6776456236839294,
0.5852919220924377,
0.15570825338363647,
-0.10181594640016556,
0.008524795062839985,
-0.4357304573059082,
-0.05609844624996185,
-0.6669705510139465,
-0.3346734344959259,
0.700212836265564,
0.12045104801654816,
0.11679455637931824,
0.30415666103363037,
-0.40151581168174744,
0.6739412546157837,
0.1406564712524414,
-0.5150717496871948,
0.18893249332904816,
-0.20650452375411987,
-0.3761908710002899,
0.5033747553825378,
0.5704440474510193,
0.56302809715271,
-0.14229871332645416,
0.031584806740283966,
-0.6333752870559692,
0.21102242171764374,
0.438800573348999,
-0.8375909328460693,
-0.33435317873954773,
0.05263831466436386,
-0.5957026481628418,
-0.732796847820282,
0.042553406208753586,
-0.6722926497459412,
-0.16202476620674133,
-0.541400671005249,
0.5020329356193542,
-0.06512390077114105,
-0.0123403025791049,
0.16568505764007568,
-0.24484321475028992,
0.0757695809006691,
0.48909318447113037,
-0.8510127067565918,
0.34068626165390015,
1.0338475704193115,
1.0752736330032349,
0.03848501667380333,
0.22074180841445923,
-0.3143561780452728,
0.3512411415576935,
-0.2533007562160492,
0.9981615543365479,
-0.25808846950531006,
-0.24875761568546295,
-0.3075408339500427,
-0.18635469675064087,
0.3221050798892975,
-0.6897313594818115,
0.15869541466236115,
-0.6122733950614929,
0.13477060198783875,
-0.05129806697368622,
-0.37637805938720703,
-0.43667930364608765,
0.6196942329406738,
-0.7608229517936707,
0.6359162330627441,
0.19133330881595612,
-0.8376063108444214,
0.5810147523880005,
-0.5647136569023132,
-0.15680399537086487,
0.3659780025482178,
-0.3242575228214264,
-0.6178797483444214,
-0.05053556710481644,
0.013256417587399483,
0.22666561603546143,
-0.4243805408477783,
0.10042847692966461,
-0.5228423476219177,
-0.5169800519943237,
0.22458487749099731,
-0.5136166214942932,
0.2756592333316803,
0.2952546179294586,
-0.7154842615127563,
0.1715295910835266,
-1.099290132522583,
-0.13584038615226746,
-0.08011419326066971,
-0.2545578181743622,
-0.24974390864372253,
-0.023066436871886253,
-0.008181263692677021,
0.1130150780081749,
0.5353835821151733,
-0.45905059576034546,
0.35333022475242615,
-0.4938042163848877,
0.9136680960655212,
0.9252373576164246,
0.09279017150402069,
0.02083330973982811,
-0.601213812828064,
0.5431589484214783,
-0.3507898449897766,
0.6861389875411987,
0.24824608862400055,
-0.19166246056556702,
-0.56397944688797,
-0.6937011480331421,
0.5654431581497192,
0.5171748399734497,
-0.21350398659706116,
0.11199485510587692,
-0.08124373108148575,
-0.5235801339149475,
-0.6829176545143127,
-0.0023995419032871723,
-0.07485617697238922,
0.2600475251674652,
0.26248520612716675,
-0.5183404684066772,
-0.5352686047554016,
-1.1740286350250244,
-0.09938527643680573,
-0.1142537072300911,
0.17062459886074066,
-0.1796056181192398,
0.19178663194179535,
-0.17600052058696747,
0.6181647181510925,
-0.30137959122657776,
-0.11237213760614395,
-0.2185545265674591,
0.31989261507987976,
0.37456485629081726,
0.314981609582901,
0.40214675664901733,
-0.7066056728363037,
-0.18930184841156006,
0.06310232728719711,
-0.4623291492462158,
-0.24044446647167206,
-0.35726168751716614,
-0.11041522026062012,
0.07186621427536011,
0.4587591588497162,
-0.7104739546775818,
0.528569221496582,
0.2871614098548889,
-0.25857192277908325,
0.7709634900093079,
-0.09108526259660721,
0.24750195443630219,
-0.7492101192474365,
0.06565038859844208,
-0.22951820492744446,
-0.5582801699638367,
-0.3282085359096527,
0.17731739580631256,
0.0651981383562088,
-0.13930189609527588,
-0.43543341755867004,
0.5534441471099854,
-0.4979669153690338,
-0.20592832565307617,
-0.5052833557128906,
0.17449046671390533,
-0.0974789410829544,
0.24108067154884338,
-0.10086151212453842,
0.6712493300437927,
0.36104413866996765,
-0.44788941740989685,
0.7883788347244263,
-0.261692613363266,
-0.3123866021633148,
0.1692240983247757,
-0.5929244160652161,
-0.10513757914304733,
0.25112849473953247,
-0.016988316550850868,
-0.6200070977210999,
-0.001089995028451085,
0.6615450382232666,
-0.15381671488285065,
0.37187400460243225,
-0.23729673027992249,
-0.7928056120872498,
-0.2026630938053131,
-0.592430055141449,
0.27798014879226685,
0.5185899138450623,
-0.3092121481895447,
0.6862056255340576,
0.04292245954275131,
-0.19969958066940308,
-0.48901981115341187,
-0.6110250949859619,
0.16212789714336395,
-0.6663427352905273,
-0.5475196242332458,
0.29531362652778625,
0.025011727586388588,
-0.41522806882858276,
-0.016296112909913063,
-0.6827911138534546,
0.2252465784549713,
0.19798190891742706,
0.2673608362674713,
0.7808261513710022,
-0.054117459803819656,
-0.27847519516944885,
-0.15537835657596588,
-0.41643568873405457,
0.10485880076885223,
-0.5470265746116638,
0.39606183767318726,
0.04649116098880768,
-0.2240559160709381,
-0.716933012008667,
-0.1880347579717636,
0.43921807408332825,
-0.08003938943147659,
0.49492812156677246,
0.38976171612739563,
-0.23259508609771729,
-0.20417942106723785,
-0.852761447429657,
-0.20958562195301056,
-0.5713381767272949,
-0.005260326899588108,
-0.21589753031730652,
-0.9156486392021179,
0.7061364054679871,
-0.04241626709699631,
0.2529352307319641,
0.7262680530548096,
0.6401980519294739,
0.24859844148159027,
0.964601993560791,
0.47315624356269836,
-0.2590816915035248,
0.6120613217353821,
-0.3503389358520508,
0.38958343863487244,
-0.3952030837535858,
-0.14153948426246643,
-0.38305991888046265,
-0.364446759223938,
-0.6713914275169373,
-0.14954522252082825,
0.22391128540039062,
0.13926799595355988,
-0.13607420027256012,
0.33262449502944946,
-0.6922906637191772,
0.22602243721485138,
0.6078096628189087,
0.03802448883652687,
0.5692480802536011,
0.32186177372932434,
0.055105060338974,
0.252023309469223,
-0.42365726828575134,
-0.6475001573562622,
1.107272982597351,
0.5097206830978394,
0.9413197040557861,
-0.21213442087173462,
0.713980495929718,
0.33556851744651794,
0.6208337545394897,
-0.4506368041038513,
0.40305235981941223,
0.21110646426677704,
-0.8067346811294556,
-0.07501273602247238,
-0.5364902019500732,
-0.6547544002532959,
0.4021628797054291,
0.036591578274965286,
-0.6937963366508484,
0.11744850128889084,
0.1865909844636917,
-0.5432116985321045,
0.28140076994895935,
-0.4904941916465759,
0.7668446898460388,
-0.4007100462913513,
-0.2721964716911316,
-0.49452152848243713,
-0.30116575956344604,
0.2980187237262726,
-0.21568556129932404,
0.41935423016548157,
-0.4933619499206543,
-0.30124780535697937,
0.6267430186271667,
-0.6519417762756348,
0.8975679874420166,
-0.03141454979777336,
-0.08358211070299149,
0.6337473392486572,
-0.07323131710290909,
0.5465031862258911,
0.4255598783493042,
0.021470937877893448,
0.22949160635471344,
0.3508612811565399,
-0.39433300495147705,
-0.37973344326019287,
0.5730501413345337,
-0.8533602356910706,
-0.6120451092720032,
-0.8171272873878479,
-0.1652287095785141,
0.17396341264247894,
0.20466510951519012,
0.33340010046958923,
0.4736524224281311,
0.16464222967624664,
0.08125651627779007,
0.2059580683708191,
0.35506898164749146,
0.350277304649353,
0.4863923490047455,
-0.15047332644462585,
-0.5741645693778992,
0.9973599910736084,
0.32200509309768677,
0.17414988577365875,
0.41582319140434265,
0.11833713948726654,
-0.37735462188720703,
-0.9262226819992065,
-0.03259379416704178,
0.2832348644733429,
-0.739780604839325,
-0.5342099666595459,
-0.23549653589725494,
-0.26182717084884644,
-0.4831072688102722,
-0.10090456157922745,
-0.37728771567344666,
-0.6165011525154114,
-0.4527195394039154,
-0.3596181869506836,
0.25923511385917664,
0.4642748534679413,
-0.21696162223815918,
0.4811806082725525,
-0.940945029258728,
0.3656340539455414,
0.272024542093277,
0.3207162022590637,
-0.15802831947803497,
-0.39938387274742126,
-0.48023122549057007,
-0.02698812074959278,
-0.5436152815818787,
-0.7474614977836609,
0.42443761229515076,
-0.054550137370824814,
0.3946296274662018,
0.7022875547409058,
-0.03515639901161194,
0.5626043081283569,
0.1636519730091095,
0.5100369453430176,
0.19465520977973938,
-0.9107248783111572,
0.27216020226478577,
-0.3355042040348053,
0.08988691121339798,
0.5043089985847473,
0.15754158794879913,
-0.3615264296531677,
-0.5887537002563477,
-0.9481679797172546,
-1.0760670900344849,
0.5146567225456238,
0.2514435946941376,
-0.29802173376083374,
0.13986019790172577,
0.7623113393783569,
0.09872328490018845,
0.7072319388389587,
-0.8251557350158691,
0.2960900366306305,
-0.2961086332798004,
-0.27950698137283325,
0.353145033121109,
-0.20579609274864197,
-0.13667534291744232,
0.04568932577967644,
0.8645122051239014,
0.01037437841296196,
0.10634817183017731,
0.26558181643486023,
-0.05545203015208244,
-0.027440911158919334,
-0.07338740676641464,
0.2685568332672119,
1.110822319984436,
-0.3362198770046234,
0.1378762274980545,
0.1470021903514862,
-0.5692784190177917,
-0.05423155799508095,
0.25222915410995483,
-0.3977803885936737,
-0.10052818804979324,
0.7239850163459778,
0.7864007353782654,
0.17318177223205566,
-0.8495389223098755,
0.22812119126319885,
0.021848004311323166,
-0.385674387216568,
-0.3898838758468628,
0.319832980632782,
-0.20126082003116608,
0.5794673562049866,
0.5242003798484802,
-0.19602450728416443,
0.5360835194587708,
-0.7488244771957397,
0.11735118180513382,
0.17217864096164703,
-0.24419386684894562,
-0.3376762270927429,
0.6830874681472778,
0.005250138230621815,
0.06255947053432465,
0.7104423642158508,
-0.3202144503593445,
-0.5103165507316589,
0.7686764597892761,
0.27916812896728516,
0.7632298469543457,
-0.0782185047864914,
0.018486859276890755,
0.09738843142986298,
0.5140312314033508,
-0.5466493368148804,
0.4068650007247925,
0.08354238420724869,
-0.39034995436668396,
-0.5824269652366638,
-0.626051664352417,
-0.36413735151290894,
0.2906883656978607,
-0.46189314126968384,
0.5709021091461182,
-1.0162732601165771,
-0.5715840458869934,
0.03698721528053284,
0.39011484384536743,
-0.399165540933609,
0.3006241023540497,
0.11914809793233871,
0.8229197263717651,
-0.3163546621799469,
0.5677346587181091,
0.49897775053977966,
-0.10480324923992157,
-0.45945531129837036,
-0.4224506616592407,
0.013637077063322067,
-0.8939578533172607,
0.20599432289600372,
0.23036688566207886,
0.15047357976436615,
-0.14014913141727448,
-0.5582776069641113,
-0.7554776668548584,
1.2768853902816772,
0.2549855709075928,
-1.1517423391342163,
-0.1383531540632248,
0.07428677380084991,
0.5363380908966064,
-0.28952768445014954,
-0.04539685696363449,
0.5275284647941589,
0.6407805681228638,
-0.016044387593865395,
-0.7396390438079834,
-0.052545517683029175,
-0.026293786242604256,
-0.31039780378341675,
0.5499759912490845,
-1.0616496801376343,
0.616084098815918,
0.05197017639875412,
-0.10806672275066376,
-0.16923287510871887,
0.5933632254600525,
0.25884971022605896,
0.4902990162372589,
0.5399676561355591,
0.4655240774154663,
0.3887498378753662,
0.02252602018415928,
0.7425886988639832,
-0.5764210820198059,
0.6412312984466553,
0.8693144917488098,
0.08970099687576294,
0.685201108455658,
0.24622859060764313,
-0.1196606308221817,
-0.016054507344961166,
1.172806978225708,
-0.6068447828292847,
0.49993109703063965,
0.46463292837142944,
-0.2738991379737854,
-0.3443785309791565,
0.22323155403137207,
-0.2934504747390747,
0.18593135476112366,
0.27958711981773376,
-0.04566413536667824,
0.05305401235818863,
-0.30313587188720703,
-0.14376415312290192,
-0.5120556950569153,
-0.4785034954547882,
0.5782139301300049,
0.26882708072662354,
-0.08951979875564575,
0.1693461537361145,
0.42562633752822876,
0.5415749549865723,
-0.708091676235199,
0.21543695032596588,
-0.05664330720901489,
0.0539245568215847,
-0.1753813773393631,
-0.12335939705371857,
0.33119967579841614,
-0.20551535487174988,
0.23697274923324585,
0.03975299000740051,
0.8323206305503845,
-0.35561084747314453,
-0.6600571274757385,
0.25096234679222107,
-0.029826540499925613,
-0.07335858047008514,
-0.38140878081321716,
-0.7086160778999329,
0.22068294882774353,
0.013468478806316853,
-0.36826983094215393,
0.3591221868991852,
0.4076308310031891,
-0.2608942687511444,
0.7876469492912292,
0.7641258835792542,
0.2604379653930664,
0.02532295323908329,
-0.08473557978868484,
0.7697091102600098,
-0.8761913180351257,
-0.7569055557250977,
-0.9066712260246277,
0.10875897109508514,
-0.22776946425437927,
-0.058784302324056625,
0.4857129454612732,
0.8430333733558655,
0.7341331839561462,
0.15013448894023895,
0.9195966720581055,
0.27235615253448486,
0.24436934292316437,
-0.5754261612892151,
0.3853082060813904,
-0.34581229090690613,
0.48621928691864014,
0.020982172340154648,
-1.048673152923584,
-0.1767147183418274,
0.6779933571815491,
-0.11068329215049744,
-0.17712387442588806,
0.6069868206977844,
0.49119842052459717,
-0.12676045298576355,
0.07873740792274475,
0.06730399280786514,
0.2949255704879761,
0.45852750539779663,
0.05250293388962746,
0.7614337205886841,
-0.2919562757015228,
0.6972446441650391,
-0.43996480107307434,
-0.17091204226016998,
-0.5034736394882202,
-0.8941447734832764,
-0.8598777651786804,
0.00013220169057603925,
-0.6265261769294739,
-0.16641674935817719,
0.16482007503509521,
0.9321218132972717,
0.603711724281311,
-0.5189473628997803,
-0.34774547815322876,
0.3020513355731964,
-0.13426749408245087,
-0.2737937271595001,
-0.15926608443260193,
0.35837072134017944,
-0.2977871894836426,
-0.30164992809295654,
0.15065789222717285,
0.5331465601921082,
0.2877888083457947,
-0.3628369867801666,
0.2967725992202759,
0.37370529770851135,
0.06449101865291595,
0.4236181974411011,
-0.07065942138433456,
-0.5104151368141174,
-0.4444117248058319,
-0.29999038577079773,
0.10664869099855423,
0.0630011260509491,
0.9832345247268677,
-0.17978119850158691,
0.13080266118049622,
0.5389111638069153,
0.3656189441680908,
0.8691664934158325,
0.24788817763328552,
0.4857581853866577,
-0.1341201514005661,
0.3250754177570343,
0.20877937972545624,
0.12406300008296967,
0.09327367693185806,
-0.5632021427154541,
0.494055837392807,
0.5702305436134338,
-0.5598976016044617,
-0.6156136393547058,
-0.33456242084503174,
-0.9741615056991577,
-0.4268958270549774,
0.813011109828949,
0.12105845659971237,
-0.39514780044555664,
-0.05766918882727623,
-0.35657984018325806,
0.17887184023857117,
-0.5955609679222107,
1.1364988088607788,
0.8404796719551086,
-0.09174171835184097,
-0.08825158327817917,
-0.9185209274291992,
0.5570512413978577,
-0.20334188640117645,
-0.6423108577728271,
-0.021338120102882385,
0.349309504032135,
0.38161614537239075,
0.04651447385549545,
0.7247505784034729,
-0.18918707966804504,
0.26296278834342957,
0.00886464398354292,
0.02591753378510475,
-0.2448052316904068,
-0.3158240020275116,
-0.08037848025560379,
0.3671669363975525,
0.29799240827560425,
-0.11995909363031387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14036v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14036v1 | Toward Infinite-Long Prefix in Transformer | 2024-06-20T06:56:35 | 2024-06-20T06:56:35 | Jiuxiang Gu, Yingyu Liang, Zhenmei Shi, Zhao Song, Chiwun Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Prompting and contextual-based fine-tuning methods, which we call Prefix
Learning, have been proposed to enhance the performance of language models on
various downstream tasks that can match full parameter fine-tuning. There
remains a limited theoretical understanding of how these methods work. In this
paper, we aim to relieve this limitation by studying the learning ability of
Prefix Learning from the perspective of prefix length. In particular, we
approximate the infinite-long Prefix Learning optimization process by the
Neural Tangent Kernel (NTK) technique. We formulate and solve it as a learning
problem of the infinite-long prefix in a one-layer attention network. Our
results confirm the over-parameterization property and arbitrary small loss
convergence guarantee of the infinite-long Prefix Learning in attention. To the
implementation end, we propose our NTK-Attention method, which is "equivalent"
to attention computation with arbitrary prefix length efficiently. Its time
complexity mainly depends on the sub-quadratic of input length (without
prefix), and our method only requires $d^2 + d$ extra parameters for
representation, where $d$ is the feature dimension. In addition, we conducted
experiments that compare our NTK-Attention with full parameters fine-tuning,
LoRA, and P-Tuning V2 methods across vision or natural language datasets. The
results indicate our approach may be a promising
parameter-efficient-fine-tuning method since it has demonstrated superior
performance in numerous scenarios. Our code can be found at
\url{https://github.com/ChristianYang37/chiwun/tree/main/src/NTK-Attention}. | [
-0.7302902936935425,
-0.8302412033081055,
0.5610882639884949,
0.22259856760501862,
-0.6066505312919617,
-0.17826953530311584,
-0.5924787521362305,
-0.4669400751590729,
0.2470332235097885,
0.13873223960399628,
-0.8105717301368713,
-0.34662723541259766,
-0.4773307740688324,
0.2779296934604645,
0.007111289072781801,
0.835496187210083,
0.16025221347808838,
-0.18322478234767914,
0.19582593441009521,
-0.09074714779853821,
-0.8132662773132324,
0.12554895877838135,
-1.1113532781600952,
-0.0670420303940773,
0.8604147434234619,
0.6174289584159851,
0.49005913734436035,
0.9583616852760315,
0.23216263949871063,
0.22944940626621246,
-0.3804831802845001,
0.3109961450099945,
-0.5995886921882629,
0.04055735096335411,
-0.15641391277313232,
-0.3069639205932617,
-0.21773399412631989,
-0.16624495387077332,
0.9437905550003052,
0.678776741027832,
0.29958561062812805,
0.21788904070854187,
0.209995299577713,
0.7876672744750977,
-0.6645390391349792,
0.029277902096509933,
-0.5868701338768005,
0.2287413477897644,
-0.06660737842321396,
-0.28217267990112305,
-0.3083181381225586,
-0.4942471981048584,
0.14730924367904663,
-0.6873626112937927,
0.24783578515052795,
0.18842662870883942,
0.8218287229537964,
0.7127626538276672,
-0.34789735078811646,
-0.1031077653169632,
-0.6503582000732422,
0.9076591730117798,
-0.6002182960510254,
0.7029734253883362,
0.5307909846305847,
0.32423722743988037,
0.006615540944039822,
-0.567430317401886,
-0.514905571937561,
-0.44507694244384766,
-0.05973036214709282,
0.12656648457050323,
0.1313648223876953,
0.21872952580451965,
0.46314486861228943,
0.2861785292625427,
-0.2916353940963745,
0.21702414751052856,
-0.4315148890018463,
0.020119857043027878,
0.31863948702812195,
0.254185289144516,
-0.12244667857885361,
-0.03891841322183609,
-0.46606168150901794,
0.046532873064279556,
-0.5865435600280762,
0.253046452999115,
0.2706316411495209,
0.20525234937667847,
0.03768746554851532,
0.09583431482315063,
-0.29509666562080383,
0.7836792469024658,
0.3134799301624298,
0.005369795951992273,
-0.05296861380338669,
-0.00573649350553751,
-0.24912869930267334,
0.25746527314186096,
0.4162892997264862,
0.29539135098457336,
0.3796796500682831,
-0.6966126561164856,
0.06665695458650589,
-0.11754610389471054,
0.5829138159751892,
-0.6400212049484253,
0.21131782233715057,
0.0426834374666214,
0.008929087780416012,
-0.13875339925289154,
-0.11617863178253174,
-0.783065676689148,
0.12204781919717789,
-0.7831486463546753,
0.39302411675453186,
-0.6064487099647522,
0.031517401337623596,
0.20094628632068634,
0.20669837296009064,
0.46656346321105957,
0.14027664065361023,
-0.8042188286781311,
0.3373306691646576,
0.8750030398368835,
0.860541820526123,
-0.34197890758514404,
-0.4874160587787628,
-0.5933548808097839,
-0.21913352608680725,
-0.4406759738922119,
0.48945316672325134,
-0.3400745391845703,
-0.2346876859664917,
-0.4469154477119446,
-0.14665207266807556,
0.013381046243011951,
-0.29527953267097473,
0.6047647595405579,
-0.7686499357223511,
-0.19070973992347717,
-0.09312794357538223,
-0.434566468000412,
-0.22132538259029388,
0.1639675796031952,
-0.5657628774642944,
1.0095528364181519,
0.1832885444164276,
-0.6080335974693298,
0.26261574029922485,
-0.8136801719665527,
-0.3881203234195709,
0.0849790871143341,
0.2701224088668823,
-0.34837138652801514,
0.33580514788627625,
0.16861680150032043,
0.45461368560791016,
-0.3944114148616791,
0.26552504301071167,
0.04563599079847336,
-0.3131909966468811,
0.055022455751895905,
-0.5295937061309814,
0.48055556416511536,
0.007654612418264151,
-0.39986082911491394,
0.06242811307311058,
-0.7223352193832397,
0.19000846147537231,
0.07382809370756149,
-0.14076414704322815,
-0.23612520098686218,
-0.3481254577636719,
-0.15128912031650543,
0.20186446607112885,
-0.11141914129257202,
-0.8459715247154236,
0.10995566099882126,
-0.8930838704109192,
0.4652407169342041,
0.8853846788406372,
0.058945182710886,
0.5034362077713013,
0.1345175802707672,
0.4198194444179535,
-0.16349944472312927,
0.3410969376564026,
-0.3552793264389038,
-0.3098227381706238,
-1.1155585050582886,
0.024010464549064636,
0.7148030996322632,
-0.03090280294418335,
-0.49325621128082275,
0.48751625418663025,
-0.5111797451972961,
-0.11883458495140076,
-0.39702609181404114,
-0.12731343507766724,
0.4669764041900635,
0.9493833184242249,
0.5312355160713196,
-0.31582900881767273,
-0.19728302955627441,
-0.9312558174133301,
-0.14574511349201202,
0.30196958780288696,
-0.061845771968364716,
0.3972046375274658,
0.2221536487340927,
-0.0116338562220335,
1.3559564352035522,
-0.7695449590682983,
-0.31331688165664673,
-0.10517305880784988,
-0.04968000948429108,
0.1936638504266739,
0.24755175411701202,
0.2914540469646454,
-0.7402318716049194,
-0.6195191740989685,
0.08290111273527145,
-0.1653781682252884,
0.0491107702255249,
0.04523728787899017,
-0.1766081303358078,
0.257073312997818,
0.5408747792243958,
-0.32676419615745544,
0.6736109256744385,
0.0615132637321949,
-0.32056725025177,
0.516392171382904,
-0.2174723595380783,
-0.3868713974952698,
-0.9585714340209961,
0.16390129923820496,
0.06246281415224075,
-0.3483283221721649,
-0.8328962922096252,
0.07721848040819168,
0.367610901594162,
0.029718700796365738,
-0.5326850414276123,
0.7360989451408386,
-0.22032664716243744,
0.37842199206352234,
-0.44959864020347595,
0.004994336515665054,
-0.11357785761356354,
1.1175024509429932,
-0.08673042804002762,
0.5951380729675293,
0.6157882809638977,
-0.8997242450714111,
0.43870827555656433,
0.06742051988840103,
-0.06695403158664703,
0.5675857663154602,
-0.648551881313324,
0.3055804371833801,
-0.42984408140182495,
0.01743491180241108,
-0.9373315572738647,
-0.014233764261007309,
0.3358484208583832,
-0.3624177873134613,
0.542037844657898,
0.046968936920166016,
-0.4301277995109558,
-0.3595755696296692,
-0.1966746300458908,
0.5791441202163696,
0.4818686544895172,
-0.706512987613678,
0.5783408880233765,
0.0002119590062648058,
0.015020841732621193,
-0.5716659426689148,
-0.421493262052536,
0.06738102436065674,
-0.3759399652481079,
-0.3619781732559204,
0.3855454921722412,
0.0924348384141922,
0.4957328140735626,
-0.15409249067306519,
-0.3951403498649597,
0.10550954937934875,
-0.032542359083890915,
0.24108070135116577,
0.03145529329776764,
-0.3100011348724365,
0.4214652180671692,
-0.027589846402406693,
-0.6975507736206055,
-0.004836946725845337,
-0.5166915059089661,
0.5416554808616638,
-0.2450169026851654,
-0.1152404248714447,
-0.3903801739215851,
0.22606521844863892,
0.3790517747402191,
-0.4221322536468506,
0.3231833875179291,
0.5829374194145203,
-0.09561299532651901,
-0.5192146897315979,
-0.7360281944274902,
-0.4916824400424957,
-0.5041493773460388,
0.455951064825058,
-0.28679659962654114,
-0.9408083558082581,
0.3761654496192932,
-0.38989293575286865,
-0.06734011322259903,
0.3740864396095276,
0.24649323523044586,
0.23477253317832947,
0.5682690143585205,
0.8993767499923706,
-0.19323840737342834,
0.1535998433828354,
-0.4569399356842041,
0.4060005247592926,
-1.0842363834381104,
-0.27212637662887573,
-0.2710511386394501,
-0.8925570845603943,
-0.1510835886001587,
-0.11437492817640305,
0.5067081451416016,
-0.037644729018211365,
-0.2881775498390198,
0.40550026297569275,
-0.5419475436210632,
0.8298646211624146,
0.5942700505256653,
0.2225021868944168,
0.16230501234531403,
0.054899562150239944,
-0.20507089793682098,
-0.13989503681659698,
-0.6430874466896057,
0.2026752531528473,
0.6291587352752686,
0.5081272721290588,
0.42027485370635986,
-0.2305222749710083,
0.26429250836372375,
-0.12942278385162354,
-0.15536515414714813,
-1.193176507949829,
0.5537757277488708,
0.20033134520053864,
-0.0970282107591629,
-0.6612063050270081,
-0.3894246518611908,
-0.9304467439651489,
-0.0921667292714119,
0.40331944823265076,
-0.8536064624786377,
0.2635487914085388,
0.0021733033936470747,
-0.5501576662063599,
0.3786657452583313,
-0.5057172775268555,
0.7644575238227844,
-0.1690242439508438,
-0.30795812606811523,
-0.28218507766723633,
-1.1381977796554565,
-0.04000537469983101,
-0.29610389471054077,
-0.40793633460998535,
-0.10365308076143265,
-0.240217387676239,
0.5778936147689819,
-0.1198468953371048,
0.8564508557319641,
0.05134611576795578,
-0.2625403106212616,
-0.008632893674075603,
0.04530450701713562,
0.3717045783996582,
0.339590460062027,
0.11850464344024658,
0.17325110733509064,
-0.6119189262390137,
-0.12547940015792847,
-0.8384709358215332,
0.7361001968383789,
-0.5722217559814453,
-0.4547111392021179,
-0.10353529453277588,
-0.6402550935745239,
-0.4323555529117584,
0.30764734745025635,
0.25759240984916687,
0.6343145370483398,
0.02448277547955513,
0.1504596471786499,
0.7974046468734741,
-0.018697690218687057,
0.7764132022857666,
0.4358885586261749,
0.07374085485935211,
-0.2946578562259674,
0.9708421230316162,
0.0933474525809288,
0.24080973863601685,
0.480853408575058,
0.49912703037261963,
-0.3779745101928711,
-0.12347767502069473,
-0.3491758406162262,
0.38480597734451294,
-0.5323948264122009,
-0.4734847843647003,
-0.680769681930542,
-0.3791332542896271,
0.1453752964735031,
-0.02982107363641262,
-0.5209974050521851,
-0.35410091280937195,
-0.21733137965202332,
-0.00471462169662118,
0.6738530993461609,
0.4595882296562195,
0.17360173165798187,
0.41585707664489746,
-0.43119484186172485,
0.5664575695991516,
0.4464270770549774,
0.9903132915496826,
0.5089389681816101,
-0.737866997718811,
-0.38700973987579346,
0.0005752585711888969,
-0.421531081199646,
-0.48537278175354004,
0.12370206415653229,
0.5058274269104004,
0.032702136784791946,
0.6210615038871765,
0.036916352808475494,
0.7834076881408691,
-0.83903568983078,
0.5155140161514282,
0.03248729556798935,
-0.8958770632743835,
0.4533112347126007,
-0.032704390585422516,
0.733993411064148,
0.5515763163566589,
0.4439821243286133,
-0.7353165745735168,
-0.1255010962486267,
-0.6765509247779846,
-0.9228935241699219,
1.1344143152236938,
0.29889482259750366,
0.41637861728668213,
0.13505621254444122,
0.5101121664047241,
0.2415548712015152,
-0.11962966620922089,
-0.245359405875206,
-0.6028634905815125,
-0.12978844344615936,
0.23480144143104553,
-0.04302976280450821,
-0.2841463088989258,
0.14678235352039337,
-0.5901328921318054,
0.57450932264328,
-0.23439379036426544,
0.2948368489742279,
0.18163904547691345,
0.1254776120185852,
-0.06956402212381363,
0.24359245598316193,
0.7890301942825317,
0.7529444694519043,
-0.07310652732849121,
0.013279036618769169,
0.6517482399940491,
-0.667343258857727,
-0.03836612030863762,
-0.09183590859174728,
0.07920737564563751,
0.09383030235767365,
-0.1280016452074051,
1.1345597505569458,
0.29928383231163025,
-0.1764519363641739,
0.36322468519210815,
-0.06871967762708664,
-0.17539054155349731,
-0.07104680687189102,
-0.01760575920343399,
0.03506789728999138,
-0.0710173174738884,
0.4644721746444702,
-0.0053228591568768024,
-0.023635607212781906,
0.18541669845581055,
0.16274601221084595,
0.22560226917266846,
-0.7026535272598267,
-0.3000370264053345,
0.5463363528251648,
-0.11194246262311935,
-0.39115872979164124,
0.6430341601371765,
-0.09984114021062851,
-0.49086371064186096,
0.8033015131950378,
0.6338205933570862,
1.0797327756881714,
-0.2980126142501831,
0.05924756079912186,
0.3596365451812744,
0.02344006486237049,
0.09223558753728867,
-0.1319657564163208,
-0.45196783542633057,
-0.2435927838087082,
-0.7135446667671204,
-0.728670060634613,
-0.04949330911040306,
0.22866401076316833,
-0.31096163392066956,
0.381137490272522,
-0.4265507161617279,
-0.11726794391870499,
0.21587179601192474,
-0.155997171998024,
-0.4967019557952881,
0.24298451840877533,
0.16298812627792358,
0.961965799331665,
-0.2924177944660187,
0.6838257312774658,
0.39657145738601685,
0.06163744628429413,
-0.968292236328125,
0.14355090260505676,
-0.40092888474464417,
-0.6235304474830627,
0.8923934698104858,
0.3812585175037384,
-0.3136259913444519,
0.49982330203056335,
-0.43782079219818115,
-0.8118062615394592,
0.7905789017677307,
0.38203397393226624,
-0.3492684066295624,
-0.264270156621933,
0.5745971202850342,
0.5031376481056213,
-0.03826673701405525,
0.26714661717414856,
0.5820592641830444,
0.39665499329566956,
0.1255052238702774,
-0.9313048124313354,
0.012834210880100727,
-0.05379308760166168,
0.3610745370388031,
0.5733147859573364,
-0.8066002726554871,
0.3188003599643707,
-0.10715201497077942,
-0.3527015447616577,
-0.15247540175914764,
0.8141540288925171,
-0.4118918478488922,
0.13427837193012238,
0.40676894783973694,
0.7329836487770081,
0.21247318387031555,
-0.034657955169677734,
0.788811445236206,
-0.3415798842906952,
0.6421633958816528,
0.7391971945762634,
0.32097047567367554,
0.3963288366794586,
0.6134877800941467,
-0.09468700736761093,
-0.0057518756948411465,
0.37860652804374695,
0.08956418186426163,
0.6296570897102356,
0.3730179965496063,
-0.02217871882021427,
-0.03786088898777962,
-0.2803990840911865,
-0.2948159873485565,
0.26612985134124756,
0.39773809909820557,
-0.1413395255804062,
-0.6765875220298767,
0.28252631425857544,
-0.29774850606918335,
-0.3046630024909973,
-0.4850260615348816,
0.9018105268478394,
0.4917401671409607,
-0.6705796718597412,
1.0434765815734863,
0.0034084655344486237,
0.6362079381942749,
-0.6789156794548035,
-0.030617352575063705,
-0.14728839695453644,
0.09071272611618042,
-0.054141562432050705,
-0.6948772072792053,
0.2751385569572449,
-0.3596566617488861,
-0.15961723029613495,
0.04364316165447235,
0.3990970253944397,
-0.32128041982650757,
-0.3196730315685272,
0.06461724638938904,
-0.061644647270441055,
-0.09025973081588745,
-0.22192631661891937,
-0.36182382702827454,
-0.3239692747592926,
-0.11870282143354416,
-0.0726936012506485,
0.06952397525310516,
0.433933287858963,
0.007584212347865105,
0.681877851486206,
0.34429386258125305,
0.0057682013139128685,
0.14788660407066345,
-0.11911556869745255,
0.8430152535438538,
-0.5869208574295044,
-0.8612188696861267,
-1.1105924844741821,
0.3959801197052002,
0.17548127472400665,
-0.601548969745636,
0.5339586138725281,
0.4462521970272064,
0.8581960797309875,
-0.28986117243766785,
0.1639629602432251,
0.06269265711307526,
0.2667829096317291,
-0.44047170877456665,
0.41940048336982727,
-0.5569546818733215,
-0.13541778922080994,
-0.03226550668478012,
-1.2679214477539062,
-0.5395399332046509,
0.06856399029493332,
-0.4005747139453888,
-0.02804964780807495,
0.8724249601364136,
0.7610563039779663,
-0.693367063999176,
0.34150421619415283,
0.37610873579978943,
-0.0166856087744236,
-0.14104244112968445,
0.7474520206451416,
0.6263300180435181,
-0.29045674204826355,
0.18493488430976868,
-0.4545581638813019,
0.01961655542254448,
-0.18716391921043396,
-0.8295220732688904,
-0.8383885025978088,
-0.6615756750106812,
-0.1794067770242691,
-0.06606610119342804,
0.10721006244421005,
0.8873667120933533,
0.5806400775909424,
-0.7024872899055481,
0.21599222719669342,
-0.2911265194416046,
-0.028367027640342712,
-0.14930002391338348,
-0.1887236386537552,
0.9185059070587158,
-0.7084402441978455,
-0.7369042038917542,
0.06867604702711105,
0.43298572301864624,
-0.23018702864646912,
-0.09639568626880646,
-0.028694648295640945,
0.06340612471103668,
-0.3020496070384979,
0.5517553091049194,
0.5151427984237671,
-0.8098312020301819,
-0.12121803313493729,
0.24426046013832092,
0.05070294812321663,
0.48910894989967346,
0.8440572619438171,
-0.9797082543373108,
0.5595901012420654,
0.30344682931900024,
1.0511066913604736,
0.38084903359413147,
0.13248300552368164,
0.35393065214157104,
-1.133318543434143,
0.19090043008327484,
0.39251387119293213,
-0.19403572380542755,
0.035637058317661285,
-0.5225825309753418,
0.3920271396636963,
-0.2000764161348343,
-0.5829595923423767,
-0.4465327560901642,
0.2727232873439789,
-0.9482297301292419,
-0.02660563960671425,
1.1492512226104736,
0.3446807265281677,
-0.3336680233478546,
-0.1678454577922821,
-0.48726221919059753,
0.357390820980072,
-0.4916808307170868,
0.7030842900276184,
0.32905375957489014,
0.08093676716089249,
-0.1423429399728775,
-0.5593874454498291,
0.7611314654350281,
0.7101436853408813,
-0.26772797107696533,
-0.00438460148870945,
-0.14988836646080017,
0.028569303452968597,
0.3232462704181671,
-0.0719064474105835,
0.12217973917722702,
0.40562471747398376,
-0.7031838893890381,
-0.27434876561164856,
-0.43270063400268555,
-0.5702913999557495,
-0.6807370185852051,
0.02793663553893566,
-0.17618954181671143,
-0.21153777837753296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14035v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14035v1 | Two Giraffes in a Dirt Field: Using Game Play to Investigate Situation Modelling in Large Multimodal Models | 2024-06-20T06:56:19 | 2024-06-20T06:56:19 | Sherzod Hakimov, Yerkezhan Abdullayeva, Kushal Koshti, Antonia Schmidt, Yan Weiser, Anne Beyer, David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While the situation has improved for text-only models, it again seems to be
the case currently that multimodal (text and image) models develop faster than
ways to evaluate them. In this paper, we bring a recently developed evaluation
paradigm from text models to multimodal models, namely evaluation through the
goal-oriented game (self) play, complementing reference-based and
preference-based evaluation. Specifically, we define games that challenge a
model's capability to represent a situation from visual information and align
such representations through dialogue. We find that the largest closed models
perform rather well on the games that we define, while even the best
open-weight models struggle with them. On further analysis, we find that the
exceptional deep captioning capabilities of the largest models drive some of
the performance. There is still room to grow for both kinds of models, ensuring
the continued relevance of the benchmark. | [
-0.2515307366847992,
-0.5270640254020691,
0.728179395198822,
0.416646808385849,
-0.06623516976833344,
-0.09734835475683212,
-0.2017890214920044,
-0.43101391196250916,
-0.2814212441444397,
0.5656170845031738,
-0.6337952017784119,
-0.1853867471218109,
-0.6354115009307861,
-0.073952816426754,
-0.144728884100914,
1.1124221086502075,
-0.0821671113371849,
0.11755640804767609,
-0.7680567502975464,
-0.3308943212032318,
-0.8136748671531677,
-0.6547183990478516,
-0.4204372763633728,
-0.5318384766578674,
0.40971237421035767,
0.1862347573041916,
0.9408265352249146,
0.4794725775718689,
1.0622648000717163,
0.46888700127601624,
0.12660636007785797,
-0.04177214950323105,
-0.42148810625076294,
0.5391332507133484,
-0.21556356549263,
-0.2840985655784607,
0.05741933360695839,
0.306058794260025,
0.4481389820575714,
0.19930186867713928,
0.024643119424581528,
0.16539493203163147,
-0.03138084337115288,
0.22853289544582367,
-0.5536723136901855,
0.5738943219184875,
-0.07974149286746979,
0.33345362544059753,
0.40029972791671753,
-0.24755819141864777,
-0.24532410502433777,
0.005845417734235525,
0.4324862062931061,
-0.7732498049736023,
-0.04329046234488487,
-0.11963732540607452,
1.029645323753357,
0.11967453360557556,
-0.6287066340446472,
-0.4952264726161957,
-0.8509582877159119,
0.8021103143692017,
-0.5458378195762634,
0.12902215123176575,
-0.018162624910473824,
0.46935901045799255,
-0.2417021095752716,
-0.5082123875617981,
-0.6232122778892517,
-0.4879947602748871,
0.031211335211992264,
0.33177807927131653,
-0.0743909627199173,
0.20262446999549866,
0.3660975992679596,
0.14769791066646576,
-0.032827332615852356,
-0.2858312427997589,
-0.3381541669368744,
-0.1548486351966858,
0.7303354144096375,
0.37077072262763977,
0.3243699073791504,
-0.4353042542934418,
-0.6887423992156982,
-0.16048850119113922,
-0.27460888028144836,
0.43457508087158203,
0.3161678612232208,
0.11935827136039734,
-0.2534635365009308,
0.8564107418060303,
-0.07731863111257553,
0.5292218327522278,
-0.13533344864845276,
-0.4025724232196808,
0.072897769510746,
-0.39177176356315613,
-0.20710475742816925,
-0.3752548396587372,
0.8059605360031128,
1.0709176063537598,
0.2208479940891266,
-0.006730465684086084,
-0.47658589482307434,
0.4072193503379822,
0.38525623083114624,
-0.8065535426139832,
-0.27006465196609497,
0.1478249877691269,
-0.6239154934883118,
-0.44115138053894043,
-0.17950227856636047,
-0.9823595285415649,
-0.6043923497200012,
-0.27110183238983154,
0.7778616547584534,
-0.5235276818275452,
-0.3859964609146118,
0.1447015404701233,
-0.30458658933639526,
0.16474966704845428,
0.628439724445343,
-0.6306095719337463,
0.18191036581993103,
0.6045590043067932,
1.085876703262329,
-0.07508651167154312,
-0.3982822895050049,
-0.2706521153450012,
0.011403843760490417,
-0.6228506565093994,
0.8209735155105591,
-0.5278059840202332,
-0.6416015028953552,
0.0471213199198246,
-0.13034193217754364,
0.11292248219251633,
-0.21864734590053558,
0.6238824725151062,
-0.4800359010696411,
0.21547669172286987,
-0.3252447247505188,
-0.22482874989509583,
-0.15720416605472565,
0.8461828827857971,
-0.8128795027732849,
0.8162987232208252,
-0.03730166330933571,
-0.6798359751701355,
0.6349212527275085,
-1.1987847089767456,
-0.4871707856655121,
-0.07845021784305573,
-0.06764933466911316,
-0.19696667790412903,
0.27338656783103943,
0.11101774126291275,
0.2604728043079376,
-0.3698665201663971,
0.4808964729309082,
-0.5427964329719543,
-0.41171517968177795,
0.1555154174566269,
-0.39009904861450195,
0.22604720294475555,
0.3983249366283417,
-0.02511020377278328,
0.1422090083360672,
-0.10470759123563766,
0.17819979786872864,
0.33586496114730835,
-0.3322097063064575,
-0.30907732248306274,
0.3203236758708954,
-0.0860111191868782,
0.7477931380271912,
0.03066481277346611,
-0.4157402217388153,
0.37318718433380127,
0.14877018332481384,
0.8673892617225647,
0.4457332193851471,
-0.19665779173374176,
0.5611469745635986,
-0.4904404878616333,
0.6172748804092407,
0.31265804171562195,
0.4763296842575073,
-0.6805071234703064,
-0.46876686811447144,
-0.6451506018638611,
-0.18419808149337769,
0.6427906155586243,
0.351650208234787,
-0.935279130935669,
-0.3002201318740845,
-0.4368744492530823,
-0.34634923934936523,
-0.480303555727005,
-0.30883029103279114,
0.3507305979728699,
0.20363028347492218,
0.020792601630091667,
-0.6212581396102905,
-0.29370012879371643,
-0.9791710376739502,
0.1720447689294815,
-0.40480494499206543,
0.5219923853874207,
0.7199916243553162,
0.7038052082061768,
-0.1539859175682068,
0.9182917475700378,
-0.2213042825460434,
-0.24223792552947998,
-0.08249743282794952,
0.5276485681533813,
-0.024740207940340042,
0.5548000335693359,
0.7005835771560669,
-1.0977158546447754,
0.1721775382757187,
-0.266558974981308,
-1.119284987449646,
0.282727986574173,
-0.3307628929615021,
0.10690400004386902,
-0.06743283569812775,
0.24186153709888458,
-0.8661750555038452,
0.23229441046714783,
0.7166645526885986,
-0.3839097321033478,
0.5751437544822693,
-0.5089918971061707,
0.822793185710907,
-0.3814699053764343,
-0.08676236122846603,
0.13855254650115967,
-0.23210619390010834,
-0.4127919673919678,
0.5830003023147583,
-0.08092596381902695,
-0.37231647968292236,
-0.3634163737297058,
0.5727297067642212,
-0.706466794013977,
-0.40160006284713745,
-0.13164016604423523,
0.19764794409275055,
0.30235880613327026,
0.2614767849445343,
0.2616714537143707,
0.8252704739570618,
0.5241172909736633,
-0.6113862991333008,
0.48162099719047546,
0.3208984136581421,
-0.7515217661857605,
0.49869805574417114,
-0.5829839706420898,
-0.2307099997997284,
-0.2958611845970154,
0.26200202107429504,
-1.2032221555709839,
-0.36487409472465515,
0.21393753588199615,
-0.31083258986473083,
0.07466305047273636,
-0.23047132790088654,
-0.5063962936401367,
-0.7854758501052856,
-0.36680248379707336,
0.5622645020484924,
0.1751188188791275,
-0.39313143491744995,
0.6781198382377625,
0.47022366523742676,
-0.22497722506523132,
-0.5696407556533813,
-0.6504883170127869,
0.3480786979198456,
-0.31279876828193665,
-0.6781825423240662,
0.29192566871643066,
-0.3248577117919922,
-0.26964637637138367,
-0.1456061601638794,
0.019396111369132996,
-0.19372621178627014,
0.10716317594051361,
0.5207030177116394,
0.13822521269321442,
-0.31499573588371277,
0.46257373690605164,
-0.16922368109226227,
0.21708376705646515,
0.05710535869002342,
0.25009867548942566,
0.34210872650146484,
-0.2302299588918686,
-0.21540401875972748,
-0.0183961633592844,
0.582352340221405,
0.6531481742858887,
-0.41715773940086365,
0.32374870777130127,
0.09600745141506195,
-0.23165521025657654,
0.37827304005622864,
-0.5702815055847168,
0.13712072372436523,
-0.43984538316726685,
0.4916570484638214,
-0.7144776582717896,
-0.7046525478363037,
0.4755655825138092,
-0.2749841809272766,
-0.0707496851682663,
0.43981996178627014,
0.4406560957431793,
-0.27244511246681213,
1.1407803297042847,
0.7801204323768616,
0.3605158030986786,
0.4080151319503784,
-0.2092534750699997,
-0.05799376592040062,
-0.6786561608314514,
-0.4817136824131012,
-0.23630180954933167,
-0.26961755752563477,
-0.31678351759910583,
-0.6408122777938843,
0.29218319058418274,
0.135715514421463,
-0.30143415927886963,
0.19962510466575623,
-0.358809232711792,
0.5357851982116699,
0.4428832232952118,
0.1604255586862564,
0.2758667767047882,
-0.2657972574234009,
-0.2857787311077118,
-0.16346365213394165,
-0.9901379346847534,
-0.6507488489151001,
0.9041643142700195,
0.3941749930381775,
0.6779352426528931,
0.1062900722026825,
0.6368346810340881,
0.6113742589950562,
0.754550576210022,
-0.7765751481056213,
0.4183381199836731,
0.16110076010227203,
-0.9210781455039978,
-0.3079560101032257,
-0.3037368953227997,
-0.7808847427368164,
0.4621083736419678,
-0.6202598810195923,
-0.4734871983528137,
0.04525546729564667,
-0.06492671370506287,
-0.6392055153846741,
-0.021453212946653366,
-0.9031161069869995,
1.3035844564437866,
-0.530325710773468,
-0.46958398818969727,
-0.12318824976682663,
-0.5050240755081177,
0.5927731990814209,
0.29698365926742554,
0.5581074357032776,
-0.05129711702466011,
-0.004089175723493099,
0.5472926497459412,
0.02909710817039013,
0.40428659319877625,
-0.1391063928604126,
-0.13696910440921783,
0.6873885989189148,
0.45866331458091736,
0.09828628599643707,
0.1854962408542633,
-0.02492355927824974,
0.09948544949293137,
0.4472552239894867,
-0.23208369314670563,
-0.6748597621917725,
0.8467851877212524,
-0.8570078015327454,
-0.7812818884849548,
-0.6772715449333191,
-0.6491995453834534,
-0.19692279398441315,
0.029286686331033707,
0.09927307069301605,
0.5289193987846375,
-0.48287373781204224,
0.07879546284675598,
0.20706619322299957,
-0.3431982100009918,
0.7556660175323486,
0.36705124378204346,
-0.45453229546546936,
-0.19209064543247223,
0.6827449798583984,
-0.00851523969322443,
0.0382363423705101,
0.08573058247566223,
0.10797297209501266,
-0.40430018305778503,
-0.34930717945098877,
-0.6365659236907959,
-0.10291776806116104,
-0.736832857131958,
-0.36533910036087036,
-0.4986724257469177,
-0.07005737721920013,
-0.03105679526925087,
0.10640742629766464,
-0.2219460904598236,
-0.17353889346122742,
0.12111450731754303,
0.05945724621415138,
-0.12895655632019043,
0.9267627000808716,
-0.1664707362651825,
0.4562120735645294,
-0.7738455533981323,
0.20575010776519775,
0.30577346682548523,
0.628410816192627,
0.0051585412584245205,
-0.20938719809055328,
-0.06185575947165489,
0.16300596296787262,
-0.5925884246826172,
-0.8990342617034912,
0.25348398089408875,
0.0868726596236229,
0.44843947887420654,
0.19866742193698883,
-0.2305668294429779,
0.7651077508926392,
-0.5807936787605286,
1.015956163406372,
0.4783223867416382,
-1.0062919855117798,
0.2870090901851654,
-0.48584359884262085,
0.2731070816516876,
0.38202837109565735,
0.1828107386827469,
-0.5631632208824158,
0.20699435472488403,
-0.5717903971672058,
-0.41201335191726685,
0.8598056435585022,
0.2603622376918793,
0.5781427025794983,
-0.06368325650691986,
0.22177404165267944,
-0.06617793440818787,
0.6177390217781067,
-1.1006441116333008,
0.249408558011055,
-0.4937328100204468,
0.05614864081144333,
-0.3864121735095978,
-0.49179235100746155,
-0.3599912226200104,
-0.10283949971199036,
0.17801541090011597,
-0.1954108029603958,
0.7057079076766968,
0.2694976329803467,
-0.19052350521087646,
-0.18314705789089203,
0.2535565495491028,
0.6499814987182617,
0.5530000329017639,
0.00814872421324253,
-0.08112731575965881,
-0.040000997483730316,
0.11595524847507477,
0.3383888304233551,
0.08700752258300781,
0.023953700438141823,
-0.08012401312589645,
0.6475194692611694,
0.7568581104278564,
0.648065984249115,
-0.8503602743148804,
0.9621793031692505,
-0.004211376421153545,
-0.12020205706357956,
0.08127746731042862,
0.04270781949162483,
-0.086225226521492,
0.6124050617218018,
0.05508153885602951,
0.11964594572782516,
0.43033307790756226,
-0.9832428097724915,
0.17544974386692047,
0.5678074955940247,
-0.5126709342002869,
-0.004236630629748106,
0.687232255935669,
0.3768525719642639,
-0.3062765896320343,
0.45502275228500366,
-0.1697414666414261,
-0.68575519323349,
1.0103553533554077,
0.4520756006240845,
0.42411303520202637,
-0.022969407960772514,
0.6505448818206787,
0.42466193437576294,
0.26367446780204773,
-0.36645832657814026,
0.24286451935768127,
-0.03318241983652115,
-0.6884133815765381,
-0.4761967360973358,
-0.3784109055995941,
-0.4002644121646881,
0.12591372430324554,
-0.3972525894641876,
0.13731960952281952,
-0.3247496783733368,
-0.6598923802375793,
0.19651676714420319,
-0.016059620305895805,
-0.8245629668235779,
0.6253063678741455,
0.30016306042671204,
0.5465903282165527,
-0.4803101420402527,
0.4080873131752014,
0.6987175941467285,
-0.46306052803993225,
-0.27787697315216064,
-0.25791221857070923,
-0.32425209879875183,
-0.4111981689929962,
0.8052390217781067,
0.42372098565101624,
0.011630993336439133,
-0.5995023250579834,
-0.7750176191329956,
-0.8333447575569153,
0.945835292339325,
0.40087032318115234,
-0.6383820176124573,
-0.18283399939537048,
-0.2849155068397522,
0.7815527319908142,
-0.6900867223739624,
0.7199492454528809,
0.16205090284347534,
0.5901889801025391,
0.08913363516330719,
-0.701749861240387,
-0.3645613193511963,
-0.31261152029037476,
0.030570846050977707,
0.06418473273515701,
-0.988490104675293,
0.9751218557357788,
-0.6574109196662903,
-0.2518870532512665,
0.3585113286972046,
0.7283148765563965,
-0.12206243723630905,
0.40094149112701416,
0.6226421594619751,
0.2248079627752304,
0.1673218011856079,
-0.3797287046909332,
1.3435428142547607,
-0.20544633269309998,
0.6067893505096436,
1.0907495021820068,
-0.512750506401062,
0.5054929256439209,
0.23821279406547546,
0.18351203203201294,
0.3674684464931488,
0.7094562649726868,
-0.25741419196128845,
0.7975468039512634,
0.21357059478759766,
0.13292843103408813,
-0.7118939161300659,
-0.045228563249111176,
-0.30033931136131287,
0.8494078516960144,
0.08266058564186096,
-0.3978450894355774,
-0.4940124452114105,
0.0574529729783535,
-0.31569987535476685,
0.10131429880857468,
-0.4104143977165222,
0.5854206681251526,
-0.21387198567390442,
-0.9932063221931458,
-0.013976719230413437,
0.3157108426094055,
0.5030504465103149,
-0.5376458764076233,
-0.2352619618177414,
-0.023741206154227257,
0.03803206980228424,
0.23503020405769348,
-0.9669509530067444,
0.013342986814677715,
-0.18572206795215607,
-0.2495245337486267,
-0.1502862572669983,
0.6549358367919922,
-0.4182758927345276,
-0.5095966458320618,
0.5284969806671143,
0.5736761689186096,
-0.06046875938773155,
-0.050307583063840866,
-0.979000449180603,
0.1481475830078125,
-0.4048512876033783,
-0.26499226689338684,
0.2863112986087799,
0.5304030179977417,
-0.21828289330005646,
0.8709953427314758,
0.26443323493003845,
-0.4263428747653961,
-0.30106356739997864,
-0.25921836495399475,
0.7710886597633362,
-0.7130930423736572,
-0.5225950479507446,
-0.9261453747749329,
0.3722803592681885,
-0.14482612907886505,
-0.6804360747337341,
0.4695059359073639,
0.602746844291687,
0.388693243265152,
-0.2830563187599182,
0.8171340227127075,
-0.08405246585607529,
-0.1750412881374359,
-0.45161303877830505,
0.4853598475456238,
-0.7591394782066345,
-0.377792626619339,
-0.5573883652687073,
-0.7036812901496887,
-0.03370376303792,
0.7583189606666565,
-0.3693835735321045,
0.1800624430179596,
0.33291614055633545,
0.23457381129264832,
-0.09805463999509811,
0.12056285887956619,
0.5080261826515198,
-0.0475861132144928,
0.15884564816951752,
0.7860162258148193,
1.3143302202224731,
-0.5112694501876831,
0.560666024684906,
-0.11487236618995667,
-0.2420072704553604,
-0.14326490461826324,
-1.2043843269348145,
-0.9660024642944336,
-0.7653273344039917,
-0.24529093503952026,
-0.3711744248867035,
0.29883018136024475,
0.6737812161445618,
0.8879334330558777,
-0.48577508330345154,
-0.21378928422927856,
0.5066795349121094,
0.052060630172491074,
-0.3585678040981293,
-0.19894346594810486,
-0.13551530241966248,
-0.17739468812942505,
-0.6288098096847534,
0.18564316630363464,
0.2941182851791382,
0.08718863129615784,
-0.39707785844802856,
-0.0546799935400486,
-0.300222247838974,
0.5131148099899292,
0.9593810439109802,
-0.03861008584499359,
-0.5784079432487488,
-0.6074007153511047,
-0.1581421047449112,
-0.28073590993881226,
0.3154246509075165,
0.9635143876075745,
-0.7833335399627686,
0.7417866587638855,
-0.02779913693666458,
0.35468941926956177,
0.6588340401649475,
0.09343504160642624,
0.7012842297554016,
-0.18294550478458405,
0.12042602896690369,
0.17878597974777222,
0.40975862741470337,
0.5388748049736023,
-0.22966663539409637,
0.7085006833076477,
0.08583184331655502,
-0.4267752468585968,
-0.7799343466758728,
0.21053965389728546,
-0.7386534214019775,
-0.17309623956680298,
1.0941261053085327,
-0.42774438858032227,
-0.10724550485610962,
0.43406569957733154,
-0.4387010931968689,
0.20708148181438446,
-0.28268885612487793,
0.8822400569915771,
1.4531255960464478,
0.13491220772266388,
-0.17703525722026825,
-0.7277342677116394,
0.38770368695259094,
0.15060576796531677,
-0.5904213190078735,
-0.2622266709804535,
0.8445082902908325,
0.2066425234079361,
0.4394686818122864,
0.45628026127815247,
-0.058366432785987854,
0.3216899335384369,
0.11095013469457626,
0.046280745416879654,
-0.31976935267448425,
-0.8236796259880066,
-0.2776561975479126,
0.3713558316230774,
-0.16728748381137848,
-0.10591569542884827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14026v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14026v1 | Demystifying Forgetting in Language Model Fine-Tuning with Statistical Analysis of Example Associations | 2024-06-20T06:46:23 | 2024-06-20T06:46:23 | Xisen Jin, Xiang Ren | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Language models (LMs) are known to suffer from forgetting of previously
learned examples when fine-tuned, breaking stability of deployed LM systems.
Despite efforts on mitigating forgetting, few have investigated whether, and
how forgotten upstream examples are associated with newly learned tasks.
Insights on such associations enable efficient and targeted mitigation of
forgetting. In this paper, we empirically analyze forgetting that occurs in $N$
upstream examples while the model learns $M$ new tasks and visualize their
associations with a $M \times N$ matrix. We empirically demonstrate that the
degree of forgetting can often be approximated by simple multiplicative
contributions of the upstream examples and newly learned tasks. We also reveal
more complicated patterns where specific subsets of examples are forgotten with
statistics and visualization. Following our analysis, we predict forgetting
that happens on upstream examples when learning a new task with matrix
completion over the empirical associations, outperforming prior approaches that
rely on trainable LMs. Project website:
https://inklab.usc.edu/lm-forgetting-prediction/ | [
-0.27779990434646606,
-0.8165408968925476,
0.5522644519805908,
-0.13760830461978912,
-0.13321231305599213,
-0.03462798893451691,
0.004704644903540611,
-0.09017587453126907,
0.25019651651382446,
0.3819326162338257,
-0.6796517372131348,
-0.48761552572250366,
-0.5973386168479919,
-0.22018037736415863,
-0.3940798044204712,
1.119493007659912,
-0.2044760137796402,
-0.17152072489261627,
-0.36331865191459656,
-0.22610381245613098,
-0.9010010957717896,
-0.3306605815887451,
-1.076798915863037,
-0.4479322135448456,
0.7664574384689331,
0.5743770599365234,
0.11575455218553543,
0.6648272275924683,
0.3654729723930359,
0.23187382519245148,
0.06675605475902557,
-0.1315535008907318,
-0.9241585731506348,
0.23770681023597717,
0.01934213377535343,
-0.7173946499824524,
-0.5179029703140259,
-0.10728387534618378,
0.8879855275154114,
1.1143341064453125,
-0.1450171172618866,
0.36184823513031006,
0.26088011264801025,
0.8663127422332764,
-0.8781298398971558,
0.5063842535018921,
-0.8946459889411926,
-0.05579301714897156,
-0.03310703858733177,
-0.18128694593906403,
-0.28296563029289246,
-0.024778097867965698,
-0.012019846588373184,
-0.4940379858016968,
0.3874349594116211,
-0.15582968294620514,
0.5913124680519104,
0.1661314219236374,
-0.06665921211242676,
-0.368384450674057,
-0.8231695294380188,
1.0110766887664795,
-0.6529242396354675,
0.21860070526599884,
0.737372875213623,
0.33687037229537964,
-0.13721191883087158,
-0.4446735680103302,
-0.24575375020503998,
-0.03995583578944206,
0.004466485697776079,
0.15665559470653534,
-0.38337790966033936,
-0.23193363845348358,
0.24834175407886505,
0.3723217248916626,
-0.288441002368927,
0.15478548407554626,
-0.47965553402900696,
-0.3169475495815277,
0.20996205508708954,
0.3731037378311157,
0.18619978427886963,
0.45022931694984436,
-0.09924531728029251,
-0.07505767792463303,
-0.9744824767112732,
-0.11985182762145996,
0.25541818141937256,
0.44595521688461304,
-0.19822663068771362,
0.1516077071428299,
-0.3538026213645935,
0.3297412395477295,
-0.03428669273853302,
-0.030933471396565437,
0.3023110628128052,
-0.20620784163475037,
-0.1866331547498703,
-0.19161972403526306,
0.48678478598594666,
0.2526857852935791,
0.7197222709655762,
-0.11828159540891647,
-0.3970631957054138,
0.006155188195407391,
0.16803160309791565,
-0.5849002599716187,
-0.5096165537834167,
0.14452998340129852,
-0.5153973698616028,
0.23779235780239105,
-0.457022488117218,
-0.39397406578063965,
-0.34464967250823975,
-0.4063093662261963,
0.592784583568573,
-0.5894907116889954,
-0.3692470192909241,
-0.035462941974401474,
-0.31866148114204407,
-0.04594636335968971,
0.2799103260040283,
-0.8484373092651367,
0.4596758186817169,
0.6421487927436829,
0.7890805006027222,
0.21869932115077972,
-0.7886056303977966,
-0.4929172694683075,
0.1406623274087906,
-0.4204765558242798,
0.6747921109199524,
-0.45355692505836487,
-0.11580674350261688,
0.002342353342100978,
-0.09995085746049881,
-0.3438013195991516,
-0.5992754697799683,
0.3175869882106781,
-0.4421656131744385,
-0.005959060974419117,
-0.46098530292510986,
-0.9071889519691467,
-0.4236671030521393,
0.18918192386627197,
-0.8904017806053162,
0.830444872379303,
-0.07486699521541595,
-0.5259638428688049,
0.6202459335327148,
-0.21267803013324738,
-0.04358146712183952,
-0.22879411280155182,
0.04668227210640907,
-0.6908060908317566,
0.431490421295166,
-0.12775497138500214,
0.819607675075531,
0.06969684362411499,
0.03276480734348297,
-0.6140509247779846,
-0.531497061252594,
-0.06442604213953018,
-0.19190983474254608,
0.45645177364349365,
0.02515600435435772,
0.13778991997241974,
0.17733651399612427,
-0.7646737098693848,
-0.41296443343162537,
0.23940350115299225,
-0.23742777109146118,
-0.6787670850753784,
0.15468956530094147,
-0.2803815007209778,
0.06601514667272568,
0.08361458033323288,
-0.24576729536056519,
0.04160935804247856,
-0.10783505439758301,
0.1959252506494522,
0.875296950340271,
0.3966524600982666,
0.5404085516929626,
-0.39635568857192993,
0.4386503994464874,
0.40313172340393066,
-0.16636492311954498,
-0.7525050044059753,
-0.19255386292934418,
-1.084998607635498,
0.02845720760524273,
0.12010744214057922,
0.21993108093738556,
-0.32677122950553894,
-0.08371204137802124,
-0.2822738587856293,
-0.5142896175384521,
-0.19873520731925964,
0.4398101568222046,
0.40129250288009644,
0.3515106439590454,
0.3239678144454956,
-0.42383602261543274,
-0.5909331440925598,
-0.9937822818756104,
-0.3585215210914612,
-0.13286803662776947,
-0.006200526840984821,
-0.09606543928384781,
0.7608507871627808,
-0.1650819331407547,
0.6157279014587402,
-0.31222477555274963,
-0.613008975982666,
-0.35650116205215454,
0.3362637162208557,
0.10045434534549713,
0.4809202253818512,
0.5974407196044922,
-0.2885850965976715,
-0.2419867068529129,
-0.29772278666496277,
-0.5369085073471069,
0.16714169085025787,
-0.34873756766319275,
0.19902180135250092,
0.2148386687040329,
0.8492306470870972,
-0.29688629508018494,
0.2355591058731079,
0.33827313780784607,
-0.2503572702407837,
0.4193550646305084,
-0.38144856691360474,
-0.3502774238586426,
-0.9713178873062134,
-0.11795414984226227,
-0.053318385034799576,
0.044049620628356934,
-0.8529941439628601,
-0.1386251598596573,
0.15779170393943787,
0.1994430124759674,
-0.14966879785060883,
0.3899926543235779,
-0.8674014806747437,
0.12542074918746948,
-0.42350897192955017,
-0.10559006035327911,
-0.40027955174446106,
0.7425920367240906,
-0.27302685379981995,
0.44544899463653564,
0.7284747362136841,
-0.8370673060417175,
-0.39974507689476013,
-0.2809271812438965,
-0.0983106791973114,
0.07244850695133209,
-0.519813060760498,
0.015907585620880127,
-0.5050111413002014,
-0.11404474079608917,
-1.046428918838501,
-0.05648272484540939,
0.020492905750870705,
-0.2556120455265045,
0.40773805975914,
-0.34662941098213196,
-0.4311695694923401,
0.1353185772895813,
-0.20409716665744781,
0.3714084029197693,
0.5407682657241821,
-0.05750646814703941,
0.5199586749076843,
0.5792880654335022,
-0.2913668155670166,
-0.5056515336036682,
-0.42556461691856384,
-0.022908691316843033,
-0.4243510365486145,
0.19782908260822296,
-0.0061833299696445465,
0.17127977311611176,
-0.12892509996891022,
-0.11594973504543304,
-0.15576273202896118,
-0.15788571536540985,
0.5438660979270935,
0.4117567837238312,
-0.10686174035072327,
-0.13936801254749298,
0.32799071073532104,
0.043690718710422516,
-0.2654527425765991,
0.2728152573108673,
0.008634795434772968,
0.7198138236999512,
-0.13236650824546814,
-0.45947322249412537,
-0.27062568068504333,
0.3096220791339874,
0.6970562934875488,
-0.033660825341939926,
0.7199135422706604,
0.5569025874137878,
-0.6266224384307861,
-0.3022671639919281,
-0.41728532314300537,
-0.45407140254974365,
-0.37425780296325684,
0.6720720529556274,
-0.24591128528118134,
-0.8791759610176086,
1.0435465574264526,
-0.0724145844578743,
0.2636265456676483,
0.36814549565315247,
0.47999295592308044,
-0.15355929732322693,
0.7228864431381226,
1.0194743871688843,
-0.4835553765296936,
0.6039709448814392,
-0.34158796072006226,
0.0866103544831276,
-0.6502341628074646,
0.163467139005661,
-0.3879232108592987,
-0.4511229693889618,
-0.5855701565742493,
-0.2573384642601013,
0.04879310354590416,
0.4736950099468231,
-0.2130431830883026,
0.2840336859226227,
0.2522459328174591,
0.5861937999725342,
0.7304572463035583,
-0.19828586280345917,
0.1991250216960907,
0.03284120559692383,
-0.13584469258785248,
0.049049314111471176,
-0.8960018754005432,
-0.536406397819519,
1.2567722797393799,
0.40544775128364563,
0.6472086906433105,
-0.022535808384418488,
0.9676275253295898,
0.18661588430404663,
0.38244640827178955,
-0.604869544506073,
0.5443030595779419,
-0.06764350086450577,
-0.3891218304634094,
-0.15649516880512238,
-0.3142204284667969,
-1.1468753814697266,
-0.043647926300764084,
-0.1258232444524765,
-0.8648273944854736,
0.09984598308801651,
0.7043114900588989,
-0.1871790885925293,
0.2835700511932373,
-0.8468429446220398,
0.7048823833465576,
0.31729307770729065,
-0.2969505786895752,
-0.5017551183700562,
-0.2605006694793701,
0.3387337923049927,
-0.12413669377565384,
0.191150963306427,
-0.3153696358203888,
0.22987359762191772,
0.6981443762779236,
0.06270450353622437,
1.412438154220581,
-0.26824215054512024,
-0.1645965427160263,
0.21049633622169495,
0.22187718749046326,
0.32549217343330383,
-0.34434765577316284,
-0.03942684456706047,
0.13249115645885468,
-0.2551864683628082,
-0.5505677461624146,
-0.46008065342903137,
0.8578212857246399,
-0.36733007431030273,
-0.3521524965763092,
-0.19836412370204926,
-0.698832094669342,
-0.1899794191122055,
0.20212393999099731,
-0.2151801437139511,
0.22216618061065674,
-0.2739991545677185,
-0.002572542056441307,
0.7452120780944824,
-0.07251530885696411,
0.7373427748680115,
0.4467391073703766,
-0.19863104820251465,
0.029164332896471024,
1.134276270866394,
0.3713225722312927,
0.4060821831226349,
0.42498645186424255,
0.020083671435713768,
0.0842408761382103,
-0.8686325550079346,
-0.22559024393558502,
0.20164906978607178,
-0.7416571378707886,
-0.08547452092170715,
-0.4924548864364624,
0.14129014313220978,
-0.17554539442062378,
0.22459468245506287,
-0.2814054787158966,
-0.5012952089309692,
-0.2958844006061554,
-0.17593984305858612,
0.31161966919898987,
0.726353108882904,
0.06183025985956192,
0.30028262734413147,
-0.5933541655540466,
0.2048758715391159,
0.1503310352563858,
0.4753837287425995,
0.5549020171165466,
-0.2591612637042999,
-0.6681704521179199,
0.11337325721979141,
-0.3494887351989746,
-0.6501911878585815,
0.19579164683818817,
0.5427084565162659,
0.8216461539268494,
0.6973034143447876,
-0.30881354212760925,
0.8391653299331665,
-0.5596022605895996,
0.4140322506427765,
0.07102559506893158,
-0.6633319854736328,
0.47554299235343933,
-0.3960879147052765,
0.5221929550170898,
0.47431036829948425,
0.383621484041214,
-0.5240170359611511,
-0.7481264472007751,
-0.48296403884887695,
-0.8896247148513794,
0.37811776995658875,
0.035830307751894,
0.18888714909553528,
0.02268611453473568,
0.3902902603149414,
0.17320969700813293,
0.050487976521253586,
-0.6423953175544739,
-0.5335242748260498,
0.31309109926223755,
-0.12323496490716934,
-0.4028623104095459,
-0.48497867584228516,
0.24954365193843842,
-0.19010797142982483,
0.5703228712081909,
-0.08084651082754135,
0.16117243468761444,
-0.2382565438747406,
-0.4358898103237152,
-0.04412181302905083,
0.14762753248214722,
0.6762272119522095,
0.6490399241447449,
-0.22355632483959198,
0.21761801838874817,
0.3853181004524231,
-0.5464358329772949,
-0.17263273894786835,
-0.18528681993484497,
-0.20962820947170258,
0.06876738369464874,
0.6417597532272339,
0.7925253510475159,
0.4594179689884186,
-0.5526506304740906,
-0.08467821776866913,
0.14938053488731384,
-0.05154045671224594,
-0.5640497207641602,
0.29589778184890747,
0.5071882009506226,
-0.0690314993262291,
0.46127647161483765,
0.19863098859786987,
0.1847364455461502,
-0.7445429563522339,
0.18665240705013275,
0.5697055459022522,
-0.7923321723937988,
-0.515308678150177,
0.4320204555988312,
-0.24543823301792145,
-0.12267185747623444,
0.33358556032180786,
-0.16689647734165192,
-0.38191652297973633,
0.61373370885849,
0.46565279364585876,
0.9948389530181885,
-0.32346075773239136,
-0.21088673174381256,
0.4754438102245331,
0.48877179622650146,
-0.13655465841293335,
0.211839497089386,
-0.0043191127479076385,
-0.8243314027786255,
-0.3768766522407532,
-0.65267413854599,
-0.254968523979187,
0.3110315799713135,
-0.8376448750495911,
0.08033502846956253,
-0.32492008805274963,
-0.010271023958921432,
-0.07192139327526093,
-0.20129944384098053,
-0.5639563202857971,
0.08576082438230515,
0.06382032483816147,
0.6804346442222595,
-1.366662621498108,
0.8308905363082886,
0.6435359716415405,
-0.5063996911048889,
-0.6528456807136536,
-0.040170811116695404,
0.07906418293714523,
-0.7311496138572693,
0.3883943557739258,
0.14419934153556824,
-0.23200401663780212,
-0.17278257012367249,
-0.09121793508529663,
-0.8163101077079773,
0.9977846741676331,
0.37333425879478455,
-0.5458558797836304,
0.2584071159362793,
0.14640632271766663,
0.6367840766906738,
-0.3937135636806488,
0.2421211451292038,
0.7374064922332764,
0.061341799795627594,
-0.3764522075653076,
-0.6964744925498962,
-0.10723240673542023,
-0.35188835859298706,
-0.1879577785730362,
0.5544495582580566,
-0.38112738728523254,
1.2139874696731567,
-0.466450035572052,
-0.26456907391548157,
-0.09889548271894455,
0.4734579920768738,
0.25808462500572205,
0.6663385033607483,
0.48237428069114685,
0.6485891342163086,
0.6366604566574097,
0.09208106994628906,
0.8400652408599854,
-0.031916357576847076,
0.3348860442638397,
1.5387550592422485,
0.024781715124845505,
1.0000789165496826,
0.7656849026679993,
0.045452188700437546,
0.45941445231437683,
0.49303799867630005,
0.1726306527853012,
0.4077602028846741,
0.13688810169696808,
-0.08172281086444855,
-0.25300419330596924,
0.16845600306987762,
-0.1700083464384079,
0.3800533711910248,
0.5884450674057007,
-0.5274826288223267,
-0.4795418679714203,
-0.03009597398340702,
0.12229420989751816,
0.026153089478611946,
-0.6886144280433655,
0.9036065936088562,
0.25994259119033813,
-0.42645174264907837,
0.6556012630462646,
-0.2594401240348816,
0.32437899708747864,
-0.5760948061943054,
-0.23289290070533752,
-0.4596795439720154,
0.4160982072353363,
0.18546007573604584,
-0.3949117064476013,
0.29947808384895325,
-0.2758759558200836,
-0.576431155204773,
-0.4412285089492798,
0.5796535611152649,
-0.589452862739563,
-0.7074669003486633,
0.3629276752471924,
0.8043356537818909,
0.17123207449913025,
-0.11857987940311432,
-0.4122278690338135,
-0.051678262650966644,
0.07583321630954742,
-0.13162489235401154,
0.5808840394020081,
0.4873628318309784,
-0.44706615805625916,
1.0966287851333618,
0.3842417001724243,
0.03979774937033653,
0.07576252520084381,
0.2629055678844452,
0.625029444694519,
-0.6353856921195984,
-0.2410443127155304,
-1.028945803642273,
0.3579159080982208,
0.1601937860250473,
-0.39616382122039795,
1.0177843570709229,
0.6349337697029114,
0.9466344714164734,
-0.45134401321411133,
0.5376244187355042,
0.4721117913722992,
0.5737361311912537,
-0.6238833665847778,
0.9220114946365356,
-0.5517870187759399,
0.4818976819515228,
-0.3131006360054016,
-0.6542295217514038,
-0.3891391456127167,
0.29652950167655945,
-0.17359144985675812,
0.17636427283287048,
0.6211114525794983,
0.8499806523323059,
-0.347751259803772,
-0.257986843585968,
0.3793945908546448,
0.31660062074661255,
0.016685085371136665,
0.8011638522148132,
0.7204552888870239,
-0.43541643023490906,
0.2658698260784149,
-0.42349013686180115,
-0.01547207310795784,
-0.13695989549160004,
-0.8830388188362122,
-0.9554243683815002,
-0.7968947887420654,
-0.467926949262619,
0.18732279539108276,
-0.0073874578811228275,
0.47097548842430115,
0.5539571642875671,
-1.1409263610839844,
-0.49031490087509155,
-0.3287217319011688,
0.30880066752433777,
-0.4708350598812103,
-0.17131878435611725,
0.30460482835769653,
-0.6609243750572205,
-0.8022964000701904,
0.0892019271850586,
0.23302620649337769,
0.24914486706256866,
-0.22143375873565674,
0.1510864645242691,
-0.20801305770874023,
-0.24199017882347107,
0.4455561339855194,
0.27856069803237915,
-0.6064035296440125,
-0.1222459003329277,
-0.21031874418258667,
0.36102765798568726,
-0.1125527024269104,
1.027381181716919,
-0.9413444399833679,
0.22155557572841644,
0.2867836654186249,
0.361333966255188,
0.3927195966243744,
-0.3226338326931,
0.6916793584823608,
-0.7961753010749817,
0.08381745219230652,
0.027828078716993332,
0.7095412611961365,
0.23851624131202698,
0.11169251054525375,
0.10015636682510376,
-0.05273229256272316,
-0.31080469489097595,
-0.7882221937179565,
0.2818537652492523,
-0.6548652052879333,
-0.28228452801704407,
0.7454182505607605,
-0.2313632220029831,
-0.14634822309017181,
-0.2467879056930542,
0.10018769651651382,
0.2654189169406891,
-0.2769435942173004,
0.998704731464386,
0.7242095470428467,
0.13242417573928833,
-0.2751321792602539,
-0.6746407151222229,
0.5329558849334717,
0.6770894527435303,
-0.38048815727233887,
0.46870169043540955,
0.5016957521438599,
0.47318434715270996,
0.1091013103723526,
0.5271531939506531,
0.32087963819503784,
0.2560374140739441,
0.03148704767227173,
0.09200797230005264,
0.03161976858973503,
-0.3763688802719116,
-0.5275392532348633,
0.21723926067352295,
0.18678823113441467,
-0.23891736567020416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14024v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14024v2 | LLM Critics Help Catch Bugs in Mathematics: Towards a Better Mathematical Verifier with Natural Language Feedback | 2024-06-20T06:42:27 | 2024-06-30T13:44:04 | Bofei Gao, Zefan Cai, Runxin Xu, Peiyi Wang, Ce Zheng, Runji Lin, Keming Lu, Junyang Lin, Chang Zhou, Wen Xiao, Junjie Hu, Tianyu Liu, Baobao Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mathematical verfier achieves success in mathematical reasoning tasks by
validating the correctness of solutions. However, existing verifiers are
trained with binary classification labels, which are not informative enough for
the model to accurately assess the solutions. To mitigate the aforementioned
insufficiency of binary labels, we introduce step-wise natural language
feedbacks as rationale labels (i.e., the correctness of the current step and
the explanations). In this paper, we propose \textbf{Math-Minos}, a natural
language feedback enhanced verifier by constructing automatically-generated
training data and a two-stage training paradigm for effective training and
efficient inference. Our experiments reveal that a small set (30k) of natural
language feedbacks can significantly boost the performance of the verifier by
the accuracy of 1.6\% (86.6\% $\rightarrow$ 88.2\%) on GSM8K and 0.8\% (37.8\%
$\rightarrow$ 38.6\%) on MATH. We have released our code and data for further
exploration. | [
-0.4950532913208008,
-0.6947638392448425,
0.482084184885025,
0.19280780851840973,
-0.29751813411712646,
0.04306603595614433,
-0.24329830706119537,
-0.3315908908843994,
0.18711940944194794,
0.30065008997917175,
-0.6702287197113037,
-0.42973077297210693,
-0.6990232467651367,
0.44378265738487244,
-0.24603301286697388,
1.2457565069198608,
-0.04432259872555733,
0.4818972051143646,
-0.4793303608894348,
-0.03525876626372337,
-0.22941705584526062,
-0.5096821188926697,
-0.9435818195343018,
-0.4085847735404968,
0.5340168476104736,
0.324749618768692,
0.7631258368492126,
0.48058760166168213,
0.6029884815216064,
0.49177029728889465,
-0.09064983576536179,
0.3655206263065338,
-0.3191691040992737,
-0.027816476300358772,
-0.05237189680337906,
-0.7438589930534363,
-0.2240181267261505,
0.05357085168361664,
0.3872734308242798,
0.3103613257408142,
-0.1452264040708542,
0.10335841774940491,
0.043224141001701355,
0.7850955128669739,
-0.5625602006912231,
0.11363160610198975,
-0.22002209722995758,
0.1668776124715805,
-0.11743894964456558,
-0.14234237372875214,
-0.5464920997619629,
-1.0932482481002808,
-0.01353598851710558,
-0.7239309549331665,
0.029289711266756058,
-0.07587473839521408,
0.77464359998703,
0.6011666655540466,
-0.22892603278160095,
-0.5893633961677551,
-0.7941593527793884,
0.8906190395355225,
-0.7694781422615051,
0.2652819752693176,
0.595060408115387,
0.7487831115722656,
-0.09169478714466095,
-0.413285493850708,
-0.5987926125526428,
-0.49033913016319275,
-0.26766735315322876,
0.026237981393933296,
-0.20698177814483643,
-0.13085731863975525,
0.5944406986236572,
0.21952202916145325,
-0.04481249675154686,
-0.12682977318763733,
-0.36024701595306396,
-0.6790206432342529,
0.6384241580963135,
0.06697764992713928,
0.11412771791219711,
-0.26465654373168945,
-0.1789824515581131,
0.12041638791561127,
-0.69096440076828,
0.24184167385101318,
0.3970522880554199,
-0.2197376787662506,
-0.01998525857925415,
0.5764122009277344,
-0.14032115042209625,
0.7634677886962891,
0.1217186450958252,
-0.5903317332267761,
0.14923304319381714,
-0.4892815947532654,
0.06253469735383987,
-0.22057326138019562,
0.661757230758667,
0.14379779994487762,
0.28748124837875366,
-0.18889573216438293,
-0.45742160081863403,
0.5933401584625244,
0.246160089969635,
-1.0399965047836304,
-0.25584229826927185,
-0.2504217028617859,
0.15178155899047852,
-0.4555194675922394,
-0.021564586088061333,
-0.6379259824752808,
-0.45753782987594604,
-0.8606011867523193,
0.30641013383865356,
-0.6166236996650696,
0.2326182723045349,
0.013975397683680058,
0.03396753966808319,
-0.1456609070301056,
0.6774129867553711,
-0.6827226281166077,
0.41704246401786804,
0.8841593265533447,
0.6862933039665222,
0.22360216081142426,
-0.0473097562789917,
-0.9032397866249084,
-0.3018682301044464,
-0.4115608334541321,
1.1247549057006836,
-0.5185169577598572,
-0.1789778769016266,
-0.03966366872191429,
-0.3567536175251007,
0.0055728089064359665,
-0.5393945574760437,
1.1281712055206299,
-0.5574512481689453,
0.612186074256897,
-0.3008807599544525,
-0.5728778839111328,
-0.13957174122333527,
0.48099327087402344,
-0.5212786197662354,
1.1083340644836426,
0.03867344930768013,
-0.748026430606842,
0.2871156334877014,
-0.41465485095977783,
-0.22243402898311615,
-0.09216674417257309,
-0.25403425097465515,
-0.3800307810306549,
0.20423300564289093,
0.3453526198863983,
-0.12528705596923828,
-0.3224337100982666,
0.08022778481245041,
-0.3883253335952759,
-0.30410706996917725,
0.5710859298706055,
-0.5667011141777039,
0.6216188669204712,
0.14951203763484955,
-0.1972767859697342,
-0.021131709218025208,
-0.9438888430595398,
0.3276923596858978,
-0.1755729615688324,
-0.5892770290374756,
-0.22479094564914703,
-0.09837514162063599,
-0.4694623649120331,
0.13857825100421906,
-0.06093437597155571,
-0.6746412515640259,
0.1277284026145935,
-0.6272540092468262,
0.4338918924331665,
0.774086058139801,
-0.10138857364654541,
0.4509611427783966,
-0.49965572357177734,
0.7527146935462952,
-0.264099657535553,
0.12378786504268646,
0.013997855596244335,
-0.5141987204551697,
-0.8268265724182129,
-0.37934452295303345,
0.6449397802352905,
0.7578719258308411,
-1.0587849617004395,
0.2952563464641571,
-0.33063727617263794,
-0.3860836923122406,
-0.48467662930488586,
0.6911044120788574,
0.7127443552017212,
0.6255099773406982,
0.09790164232254028,
-0.09308414161205292,
-0.5661744475364685,
-0.7250919342041016,
-0.3718703091144562,
-0.1633073091506958,
-0.25314462184906006,
0.15024326741695404,
0.5012629628181458,
-0.3546147644519806,
1.2198184728622437,
-0.35474860668182373,
-0.12609770894050598,
0.039272721856832504,
0.0038865534588694572,
0.24482254683971405,
0.1948476880788803,
0.4486813545227051,
-0.3912788927555084,
-0.39329588413238525,
-0.31400594115257263,
-0.5680460929870605,
-0.4125877916812897,
0.1858963817358017,
-0.32952257990837097,
0.19476887583732605,
0.02996014431118965,
-0.4181148409843445,
0.33664217591285706,
0.5604038238525391,
-0.4080260396003723,
0.5859092473983765,
-0.07754872739315033,
0.005226351786404848,
-0.7237356901168823,
-0.24289998412132263,
0.2589924931526184,
-0.5578595995903015,
-0.4762042760848999,
-0.13054159283638,
-0.06091732531785965,
0.13115765154361725,
-0.1379794478416443,
0.24541796743869781,
-0.09675660729408264,
0.42003482580184937,
-0.36996084451675415,
0.3973053991794586,
0.10238608717918396,
0.3577277660369873,
-0.25486913323402405,
0.5888804793357849,
0.48354047536849976,
-0.8456089496612549,
0.5449400544166565,
0.11854460090398788,
-0.2100144475698471,
0.9158909916877747,
-0.6816251277923584,
0.41975826025009155,
-0.11320306360721588,
0.2759823203086853,
-1.0275377035140991,
-0.12853381037712097,
0.6311919093132019,
-0.7707219123840332,
0.2267865240573883,
-0.4219042658805847,
-0.6896337270736694,
-0.652867317199707,
-0.5434632897377014,
0.11964959651231766,
0.3301767110824585,
-0.709949791431427,
0.7283225655555725,
0.40026235580444336,
-0.1310867816209793,
-0.5059000849723816,
-0.6723813414573669,
-0.05238685384392738,
0.16194000840187073,
-1.0133342742919922,
-0.18121258914470673,
-0.376051127910614,
-0.3088570535182953,
-0.11032959818840027,
-0.2560672461986542,
-0.11691762506961823,
-0.012721311300992966,
0.35559386014938354,
0.48344630002975464,
-0.12256632000207901,
0.17417924106121063,
0.01710842177271843,
-0.8412094116210938,
0.5064108967781067,
-0.21462950110435486,
0.18727357685565948,
-0.3335079252719879,
-0.5909290313720703,
-0.5092255473136902,
-0.13552476465702057,
0.3195401430130005,
0.041968151926994324,
0.1265244483947754,
0.2872209846973419,
-0.5018608570098877,
-0.14521652460098267,
-0.6314749121665955,
-0.4216553568840027,
-0.5622056722640991,
-0.09255421906709671,
-0.3277026414871216,
-0.975963830947876,
0.2318042665719986,
-0.12634894251823425,
0.16577130556106567,
0.39323413372039795,
0.41133034229278564,
0.013848133385181427,
1.1706671714782715,
0.41074123978614807,
-0.25710538029670715,
0.1585589498281479,
-0.23370473086833954,
0.39711466431617737,
-0.3762162923812866,
-0.21495644748210907,
-0.7896358370780945,
-0.2994353771209717,
-0.23203547298908234,
-0.4856341779232025,
0.14785413444042206,
0.33759450912475586,
0.1075194776058197,
0.23973795771598816,
-0.5837838649749756,
0.80222088098526,
0.42138198018074036,
0.024477602913975716,
0.30355432629585266,
0.21889737248420715,
-0.2519264817237854,
-0.7317474484443665,
-0.484719842672348,
-0.6462886929512024,
0.637748658657074,
0.37419137358665466,
0.8228663802146912,
0.26954081654548645,
0.8639234900474548,
0.057717323303222656,
0.8942334651947021,
-0.9011634588241577,
0.45746201276779175,
0.1702834516763687,
-0.6475580930709839,
-0.20539957284927368,
-0.9031171798706055,
-0.41597917675971985,
0.28277090191841125,
-0.14772576093673706,
-0.54486483335495,
-0.14123302698135376,
0.4829901456832886,
-0.36509785056114197,
0.11589106172323227,
-0.6702849268913269,
0.5550864934921265,
-0.2589651942253113,
-0.535635769367218,
-0.319958359003067,
-0.15634118020534515,
0.5602658987045288,
0.020994314923882484,
0.7469688653945923,
0.042693253606557846,
-0.003472448093816638,
0.715135931968689,
-1.082785725593567,
0.9887399673461914,
-0.39642253518104553,
-0.32941892743110657,
0.573392927646637,
0.34634900093078613,
0.7512232661247253,
0.5488702058792114,
0.06140194460749626,
-0.23692312836647034,
-0.09991835057735443,
-0.1525038778781891,
-0.9724211692810059,
0.6527222394943237,
-0.5835962295532227,
-0.5613508224487305,
-0.5225457549095154,
-0.112879678606987,
-0.3180120587348938,
0.054319560527801514,
0.23205101490020752,
0.46069660782814026,
0.45252829790115356,
-0.04847946763038635,
0.733744740486145,
0.31638965010643005,
0.18181781470775604,
0.6647921800613403,
-0.4670593738555908,
-1.0676937103271484,
1.0344657897949219,
-0.07378625869750977,
0.009934582747519016,
0.25858694314956665,
0.5758482217788696,
-0.41688117384910583,
-0.2738906741142273,
-0.6853416562080383,
0.350725382566452,
-0.9121977090835571,
-0.5031921863555908,
-0.23343722522258759,
-0.15832637250423431,
-0.07780198007822037,
-0.006069145631045103,
-0.38338354229927063,
-0.6837329864501953,
0.16082477569580078,
-0.29156503081321716,
0.5880248546600342,
0.9148634076118469,
-0.201272651553154,
0.19874940812587738,
-0.7927716374397278,
0.2488013356924057,
0.41972866654396057,
0.5918145775794983,
-0.3528989553451538,
-0.8770462274551392,
-0.29200083017349243,
0.1646428108215332,
-0.3374921977519989,
-0.8088628649711609,
0.0017322645289823413,
0.10609637945890427,
0.37699776887893677,
0.6123082041740417,
-0.10113950818777084,
0.74454265832901,
-0.34397342801094055,
0.4717347025871277,
0.32215598225593567,
-1.16892409324646,
0.48930251598358154,
0.18103918433189392,
0.11032900214195251,
0.7284736037254333,
0.15635907649993896,
-0.46759000420570374,
-0.5781397819519043,
-0.3341076374053955,
-0.3815881013870239,
0.8275925517082214,
0.3493468165397644,
0.150187686085701,
0.2127273827791214,
0.5451056361198425,
0.054682113230228424,
0.08489871770143509,
-0.769270122051239,
-0.26006150245666504,
-0.17897960543632507,
-0.08231043815612793,
0.1490449756383896,
-0.5333276391029358,
-0.30997663736343384,
-0.44346439838409424,
0.8383163809776306,
-0.17580974102020264,
-0.0026717442087829113,
0.11759457737207413,
-0.16908562183380127,
-0.2650785446166992,
0.34010207653045654,
0.8453922271728516,
0.8142921924591064,
0.12456182390451431,
0.36910340189933777,
0.3195379078388214,
-0.6245637536048889,
0.3189125061035156,
0.16170985996723175,
-0.6079062223434448,
0.4782915711402893,
0.37558040022850037,
0.5995104312896729,
0.35612037777900696,
-0.3124123811721802,
0.5166761875152588,
-0.30019378662109375,
-0.42200759053230286,
-0.3129546642303467,
0.12117514759302139,
0.051359083503484726,
-0.09317027777433395,
0.07860363274812698,
0.4922414720058441,
0.08672364801168442,
0.12040127068758011,
0.324420303106308,
0.3571036756038666,
-0.4498841464519501,
-0.49812668561935425,
0.4251989424228668,
0.228745698928833,
-0.5013272166252136,
0.2444678544998169,
-0.42510318756103516,
-0.8756298422813416,
0.35650986433029175,
0.4094502031803131,
0.5660242438316345,
-0.07765673846006393,
0.36270785331726074,
0.6910470724105835,
0.3819921314716339,
-0.025042666122317314,
0.2446639984846115,
-0.33616822957992554,
-0.4824640154838562,
-0.7783869504928589,
-0.5980720520019531,
-0.7423830032348633,
-0.47006016969680786,
-0.4502565562725067,
0.2869555354118347,
-0.7993034720420837,
-0.4301847815513611,
-0.013793040066957474,
0.1305127739906311,
-0.4781268239021301,
0.08576341718435287,
0.39182811975479126,
0.8997284173965454,
-0.46646609902381897,
0.7061721682548523,
0.6042402386665344,
-0.19635188579559326,
-0.8217460513114929,
-0.5631163716316223,
0.31822383403778076,
-0.7679846882820129,
0.7448363304138184,
0.23317523300647736,
-0.6139113306999207,
-0.3278166651725769,
-0.6971362233161926,
-0.8990830779075623,
0.7316787838935852,
0.5869019031524658,
-0.7534468173980713,
0.38995158672332764,
0.23154014348983765,
0.706961452960968,
-0.0037082191556692123,
0.6517418026924133,
0.36123591661453247,
0.6665369272232056,
0.33561691641807556,
-0.5235432386398315,
0.015181148424744606,
-0.6037902235984802,
0.011488518677651882,
0.377377986907959,
-0.28047728538513184,
0.29284200072288513,
-0.3671197295188904,
-0.25394442677497864,
0.04230464622378349,
0.8684164881706238,
0.5577149391174316,
0.635555624961853,
0.7244027853012085,
0.9611117243766785,
1.0834635496139526,
-0.33124518394470215,
1.3133625984191895,
-0.4340825378894806,
0.3762262761592865,
1.042850136756897,
0.07251788675785065,
0.6612074375152588,
0.44552966952323914,
-0.4776192307472229,
0.7903375625610352,
0.3127943277359009,
0.06407158821821213,
0.308499813079834,
0.6749992370605469,
-0.28661808371543884,
-0.413277804851532,
0.12196728587150574,
-0.3447146713733673,
-0.2659238874912262,
0.2170189768075943,
-0.09804397076368332,
-0.31246814131736755,
-0.14800600707530975,
0.2649868428707123,
0.2378467619419098,
-0.03790909796953201,
0.5018165707588196,
0.3154516816139221,
-0.6692698001861572,
0.5843423008918762,
0.14758774638175964,
0.8045721650123596,
-0.7254078984260559,
0.03951481729745865,
-0.41607174277305603,
0.4933947026729584,
-0.4813583791255951,
-0.4747585654258728,
0.2777598798274994,
0.26685070991516113,
-0.2121431976556778,
-0.10447482764720917,
0.6313562393188477,
-0.052058879286050797,
-0.8148837685585022,
0.12441998720169067,
0.10247202962636948,
-0.05800044536590576,
0.09166765958070755,
-0.5859590172767639,
-0.011891736648976803,
0.06308937072753906,
-0.14898681640625,
-0.11791305243968964,
0.7343047857284546,
0.17752531170845032,
0.8954216837882996,
0.8631678223609924,
0.006065411027520895,
0.3620415925979614,
0.2728705406188965,
0.8889516592025757,
-0.553067147731781,
-0.37645846605300903,
-1.0843788385391235,
0.363486111164093,
-0.177142933011055,
-0.514923632144928,
1.1799696683883667,
0.6652707457542419,
0.8011116981506348,
-0.05433426797389984,
0.6329028606414795,
0.21278969943523407,
0.7155635952949524,
-0.5552014708518982,
0.2662707567214966,
-0.09839558601379395,
0.5733176469802856,
-0.009513748809695244,
-0.6980398297309875,
-0.48657727241516113,
0.6836197972297668,
-0.538669228553772,
-0.030893348157405853,
0.736434817314148,
0.7939254641532898,
0.17673064768314362,
0.31883639097213745,
-0.07336113601922989,
0.09075888246297836,
0.4605466425418854,
0.5819327235221863,
1.2354296445846558,
-0.34518852829933167,
0.8742716908454895,
-0.7268850207328796,
-0.2440986931324005,
-0.09965839236974716,
-0.6010546088218689,
-0.9947691559791565,
0.19201283156871796,
-0.5733318328857422,
-0.8160070776939392,
-0.2507222592830658,
0.8028367161750793,
0.5312224626541138,
-1.060556411743164,
0.09349915385246277,
-0.25282174348831177,
0.4012242555618286,
0.0595444031059742,
-0.22263219952583313,
0.03423042222857475,
-0.5739465951919556,
-0.6089828610420227,
0.15954434871673584,
0.26954203844070435,
-0.0030347227584570646,
-0.2743070125579834,
-0.6727392077445984,
0.6160365343093872,
0.13968707621097565,
0.5138638019561768,
0.2629756033420563,
-0.6889641284942627,
-0.21206209063529968,
-0.021235784515738487,
-0.43558168411254883,
0.07914508134126663,
1.1124266386032104,
-0.9058960676193237,
0.3818955421447754,
0.5429207682609558,
0.7756301164627075,
0.12100062519311905,
-0.09910639375448227,
0.38134288787841797,
-0.4478209912776947,
-0.031485505402088165,
0.3808761537075043,
0.4540337026119232,
0.3174181282520294,
-0.20743197202682495,
0.5368274450302124,
0.6074343323707581,
-0.4597100019454956,
-0.7890403866767883,
0.16565904021263123,
-0.7285537719726562,
0.31677740812301636,
0.9610207676887512,
-0.08387041836977005,
-0.4066616892814636,
0.1691526472568512,
-0.48953530192375183,
-0.18825198709964752,
-0.5375325679779053,
0.9114858508110046,
0.8813668489456177,
0.06701020896434784,
-0.04759267717599869,
-0.4433096647262573,
0.5650914311408997,
0.7593911290168762,
-0.8889711499214172,
-0.3505339026451111,
0.6335791945457458,
0.3273770809173584,
0.6024872660636902,
0.47186189889907837,
-0.15613994002342224,
0.470217227935791,
-0.08177151530981064,
-0.31739819049835205,
-0.153703972697258,
-0.2587670385837555,
-0.3681146204471588,
0.03308817371726036,
0.29407256841659546,
-0.09283912926912308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14023v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14023v1 | Evaluating Implicit Bias in Large Language Models by Attacking From a Psychometric Perspective | 2024-06-20T06:42:08 | 2024-06-20T06:42:08 | Yuchen Wen, Keping Bi, Wei Chen, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As Large Language Models (LLMs) become an important way of information
seeking, there have been increasing concerns about the unethical content LLMs
may generate. In this paper, we conduct a rigorous evaluation of LLMs' implicit
bias towards certain groups by attacking them with carefully crafted
instructions to elicit biased responses. Our attack methodology is inspired by
psychometric principles in cognitive and social psychology. We propose three
attack approaches, i.e., Disguise, Deception, and Teaching, based on which we
built evaluation datasets for four common bias types. Each prompt attack has
bilingual versions. Extensive evaluation of representative LLMs shows that 1)
all three attack methods work effectively, especially the Deception attacks; 2)
GLM-3 performs the best in defending our attacks, compared to GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4; 3) LLMs could output content of other bias types when being taught with
one type of bias. Our methodology provides a rigorous and effective way of
evaluating LLMs' implicit bias and will benefit the assessments of LLMs'
potential ethical risks. | [
-0.29393574595451355,
-0.9150463342666626,
0.7866284251213074,
0.36309921741485596,
-0.029408426955342293,
0.06844277679920197,
-0.36817190051078796,
-0.46412235498428345,
-0.10541411489248276,
0.5687631964683533,
-0.5817857384681702,
-0.44756755232810974,
-0.7339687943458557,
0.08629551529884338,
-0.4151707887649536,
0.9649762511253357,
-0.0778428465127945,
0.7991217374801636,
0.04464119300246239,
0.05077900364995003,
-0.19913947582244873,
-0.7766665816307068,
-0.6625367403030396,
-0.19103418290615082,
0.606309711933136,
-0.07449596375226974,
0.5606637001037598,
0.35027822852134705,
0.31707698106765747,
0.23820720613002777,
-0.021708693355321884,
-0.1913224756717682,
-0.7040802240371704,
0.20853841304779053,
-0.1910012811422348,
-0.52989262342453,
-0.3023432791233063,
0.29171955585479736,
0.6527285575866699,
0.578517496585846,
0.021516522392630577,
0.38476499915122986,
0.18772636353969574,
0.5538082122802734,
-0.8381197452545166,
-0.029315529391169548,
-0.747770369052887,
0.13874512910842896,
-0.31997090578079224,
0.002673777285963297,
-0.6638877391815186,
-0.5987879633903503,
0.11865938454866409,
-0.18939410150051117,
0.13595989346504211,
-0.059395335614681244,
0.3595673739910126,
-0.07136368751525879,
-0.40063175559043884,
-0.5266907811164856,
-0.5242036581039429,
0.9656692147254944,
-0.6370903253555298,
0.20893247425556183,
0.42414993047714233,
0.2252403199672699,
-0.2060350626707077,
-0.26395368576049805,
-0.3181672990322113,
-0.32085782289505005,
-0.08513271063566208,
0.08960152417421341,
-0.22974872589111328,
0.09353253245353699,
0.5812881588935852,
0.13911664485931396,
-0.42564237117767334,
0.2595645785331726,
-0.2832236588001251,
-0.29098865389823914,
0.7365856766700745,
0.17290565371513367,
0.34458282589912415,
0.01975778304040432,
-0.4050363600254059,
0.07606926560401917,
-0.9034402966499329,
-0.28359541296958923,
0.9583560228347778,
0.21920393407344818,
-0.16710294783115387,
0.6921395063400269,
-0.07306873053312302,
0.5034469366073608,
0.21502305567264557,
-0.04489443451166153,
-0.047189861536026,
-0.19598309695720673,
-0.10593859106302261,
0.1801743060350418,
0.8661260604858398,
0.4359903335571289,
0.561119794845581,
-0.19121083617210388,
-0.2638140618801117,
0.16583162546157837,
0.2907032072544098,
-0.6322572827339172,
0.37846118211746216,
0.2636978030204773,
-0.29057011008262634,
-0.43016549944877625,
-0.1164172813296318,
-1.0185009241104126,
-0.5818023085594177,
-0.039173610508441925,
0.19955839216709137,
-0.2214617282152176,
0.0014968798495829105,
-0.01635904237627983,
0.05100094527006149,
0.5939926505088806,
0.3400455713272095,
-0.8633644580841064,
0.5195091962814331,
0.7391865849494934,
0.615277886390686,
-0.29114729166030884,
-0.14119602739810944,
-0.822074294090271,
0.40533435344696045,
-0.3343256711959839,
0.4475412666797638,
-0.6622238755226135,
-0.6080209612846375,
0.2937353849411011,
-0.27002376317977905,
0.1820952594280243,
-0.21011292934417725,
0.69235759973526,
-0.5964817404747009,
0.523231029510498,
-0.46767348051071167,
-0.501242995262146,
-0.13875071704387665,
0.4018116593360901,
-0.7197156548500061,
0.904359757900238,
-0.1862354576587677,
-0.9998307824134827,
0.1364220231771469,
-0.6590445041656494,
-0.37827348709106445,
-0.23442980647087097,
-0.42252883315086365,
-0.08252573013305664,
0.18671521544456482,
0.47407597303390503,
0.4846734404563904,
-0.45859456062316895,
0.21004584431648254,
-0.5433690547943115,
-0.381180077791214,
0.3589683771133423,
-0.7387183308601379,
1.1323881149291992,
-0.0742303803563118,
-0.5550342202186584,
-0.003789606038480997,
-0.48189425468444824,
0.06900955736637115,
0.37685027718544006,
-0.2091304361820221,
-0.549318253993988,
0.007462561596184969,
-0.15391336381435394,
0.009220477193593979,
0.20209673047065735,
-0.6143782734870911,
0.21935243904590607,
-0.43168535828590393,
0.039515286684036255,
1.1200119256973267,
0.056761275976896286,
0.4337327778339386,
-0.037277329713106155,
0.5889217853546143,
-0.3790935277938843,
0.5117378234863281,
0.20741571485996246,
-0.23080140352249146,
-0.5140929818153381,
-0.2810823917388916,
0.09000299125909805,
0.3840235471725464,
-0.48147305846214294,
0.011422152630984783,
-0.10894419252872467,
-0.39282503724098206,
-0.5135533213615417,
0.15236765146255493,
0.5797058343887329,
0.2945316433906555,
0.2059825360774994,
-0.021604906767606735,
-0.4539015591144562,
-1.1004208326339722,
-0.7570445537567139,
-0.17672094702720642,
-0.19770291447639465,
0.02031424641609192,
0.4921548068523407,
-0.18699027597904205,
0.6955392360687256,
-0.36079829931259155,
-0.13927194476127625,
-0.05423826724290848,
0.0489698201417923,
0.06156697869300842,
0.27769574522972107,
0.5406168699264526,
-0.49522891640663147,
-0.4631994664669037,
-0.2866053581237793,
-0.6835166811943054,
-0.2674182653427124,
0.17065514624118805,
-0.09339886158704758,
0.40526244044303894,
0.3270070552825928,
-0.6250649094581604,
0.2781512141227722,
0.4274548888206482,
-0.22113829851150513,
0.5934516191482544,
0.29775792360305786,
-0.016341008245944977,
-0.58099764585495,
-0.21210673451423645,
0.13792364299297333,
0.009604896418750286,
-0.6672138571739197,
0.1763717383146286,
-0.06055819243192673,
0.3479020893573761,
-0.6645921468734741,
0.8150720000267029,
-0.6262563467025757,
-0.04538072645664215,
-0.018783653154969215,
-0.029176676645874977,
-0.10932320356369019,
0.378248393535614,
-0.17485308647155762,
0.3287937641143799,
0.6315049529075623,
-0.3503607213497162,
0.3351202607154846,
-0.14045189321041107,
-0.3969176113605499,
0.7889259457588196,
-0.548708975315094,
0.629149317741394,
-0.28641223907470703,
0.4632755219936371,
-0.793350338935852,
-0.1080198809504509,
0.5557575225830078,
-0.3528957664966583,
0.2925916910171509,
-0.3301199972629547,
-0.5292953848838806,
-0.21842581033706665,
-0.6454346776008606,
0.389863520860672,
0.35393399000167847,
-0.5858833193778992,
0.8327787518501282,
0.26336944103240967,
-0.17820562422275543,
-1.026992917060852,
-0.4987275004386902,
0.027339478954672813,
-0.5887132287025452,
-0.31148654222488403,
0.051688287407159805,
-0.12322049587965012,
-0.6888766288757324,
-0.2556712031364441,
-0.17875437438488007,
0.14122071862220764,
0.058459606021642685,
0.039036817848682404,
0.34067925810813904,
0.03571236506104469,
-0.4350071847438812,
-0.32641100883483887,
0.16882073879241943,
0.5298788547515869,
-0.13552667200565338,
0.7161428332328796,
-0.1839512139558792,
-0.6904642581939697,
-0.1006087139248848,
0.49232321977615356,
0.5254830718040466,
0.0010335332481190562,
0.4748385548591614,
0.6949751973152161,
-0.38785380125045776,
-0.09953122586011887,
-0.9617739915847778,
-0.2949609160423279,
-0.47094786167144775,
0.562700092792511,
-0.10617860406637192,
-0.7756033539772034,
0.3488626778125763,
0.31578269600868225,
0.12788023054599762,
0.24504436552524567,
0.8153918385505676,
-0.008861240930855274,
1.4099856615066528,
0.38216593861579895,
-0.3512221574783325,
0.14671160280704498,
-0.04600965604186058,
-0.005649416241794825,
-0.8946266770362854,
-0.4226834177970886,
-0.5961793065071106,
-0.008794184774160385,
-0.49186965823173523,
-0.38751885294914246,
0.32889556884765625,
-0.15572629868984222,
-0.31088051199913025,
-0.2774140536785126,
-0.10646672546863556,
0.5897871851921082,
0.3254534900188446,
0.005019745789468288,
0.21998284757137299,
0.20359405875205994,
-0.08340899646282196,
-0.03927115723490715,
-0.37686342000961304,
-0.6763615608215332,
1.398435354232788,
0.8043577075004578,
0.9992498755455017,
0.349143922328949,
0.38245218992233276,
0.36041146516799927,
0.6128253936767578,
-0.7327712178230286,
0.6494140625,
0.2638553977012634,
-0.8037727475166321,
-0.327189564704895,
-0.33408764004707336,
-0.6887889504432678,
0.41025927662849426,
-0.022285286337137222,
-0.9274373650550842,
-0.04414443299174309,
0.0523015595972538,
0.05511503294110298,
0.22553616762161255,
-0.6117074489593506,
0.44521844387054443,
-0.7411308884620667,
-0.56557297706604,
-0.10264506191015244,
-0.4958799183368683,
0.6597939133644104,
-0.35831910371780396,
0.2577158808708191,
-0.033075835555791855,
-0.21419502794742584,
0.858153760433197,
-0.06404541432857513,
1.1628080606460571,
-0.37793394923210144,
-0.5119152069091797,
-0.040341634303331375,
0.17626319825649261,
0.6025358438491821,
0.04111594334244728,
-0.2554948925971985,
0.42352965474128723,
-0.21437466144561768,
-0.4978986978530884,
-0.7688376903533936,
0.6182323694229126,
-0.5604058504104614,
-0.9899219870567322,
-0.46377086639404297,
-0.4898259937763214,
-0.5583766102790833,
0.1744149625301361,
0.18763089179992676,
0.1960604041814804,
-0.5760255455970764,
-0.12639011442661285,
0.6171901822090149,
-0.2704373598098755,
0.28194859623908997,
0.832373321056366,
-0.27039286494255066,
-0.25008484721183777,
0.5116147994995117,
-0.04772588983178139,
0.5225635766983032,
0.13078655302524567,
0.2166760265827179,
-0.49264705181121826,
-0.4261399805545807,
-0.28011026978492737,
0.28251615166664124,
-0.8329536318778992,
0.028901206329464912,
-0.5597800016403198,
-0.033439237624406815,
-0.5159057378768921,
0.023924201726913452,
-0.26527318358421326,
0.11223571002483368,
0.1894221007823944,
-0.1434728503227234,
0.06951578706502914,
0.9342108964920044,
0.178561732172966,
0.3462265729904175,
-0.18977852165699005,
0.12797541916370392,
0.3374169170856476,
0.24036359786987305,
0.05083195120096207,
-0.38752439618110657,
0.029056094586849213,
0.09457331150770187,
-0.1856493204832077,
-1.1561394929885864,
0.049624405801296234,
-0.2707861363887787,
0.8184191584587097,
0.43520453572273254,
-0.038569726049900055,
0.23584331572055817,
-0.6977999210357666,
0.6461902856826782,
0.18070770800113678,
-0.9770187139511108,
0.32682669162750244,
-0.38728067278862,
0.07122858613729477,
0.3675435781478882,
0.7592871785163879,
-0.21829907596111298,
-0.5344439744949341,
-0.7076929211616516,
-0.6261996030807495,
0.6701204776763916,
0.14237858355045319,
0.2399272620677948,
-0.05907687172293663,
0.17137053608894348,
0.031066300347447395,
0.1972065567970276,
-1.0970594882965088,
-0.2894142270088196,
0.09407832473516464,
-0.17933638393878937,
0.06756655126810074,
-0.4760797619819641,
-0.603447675704956,
-0.021469691768288612,
0.6104840040206909,
-0.1514202058315277,
0.20504632592201233,
0.1194513663649559,
-0.1855625957250595,
0.04759171977639198,
0.3663954734802246,
0.5391165018081665,
0.5462396144866943,
-0.10550984740257263,
0.24466437101364136,
0.40678268671035767,
-0.5961688160896301,
0.3327268958091736,
-0.12145218998193741,
-0.26184937357902527,
-0.0885252058506012,
0.5238016843795776,
0.6457840800285339,
-0.023756565526127815,
-0.6128278970718384,
0.69035804271698,
0.015327958390116692,
0.016246048733592033,
-0.33823978900909424,
-0.09814798831939697,
-0.030900709331035614,
0.22396628558635712,
0.3034698963165283,
-0.343963086605072,
0.051729198545217514,
-0.6666029691696167,
-0.19006572663784027,
0.8644223213195801,
-0.4063648581504822,
-0.22672609984874725,
0.2846387028694153,
-0.017158975824713707,
-0.089010089635849,
0.3153496980667114,
0.06379958242177963,
-0.7585620880126953,
0.4345143735408783,
0.6653519868850708,
0.8562790751457214,
-0.5487191081047058,
0.18442904949188232,
0.041599348187446594,
0.7498597502708435,
-0.053057119250297546,
0.1348484456539154,
0.16678237915039062,
-0.7029248476028442,
-0.506158173084259,
-0.4354812204837799,
-0.4605202376842499,
0.5007156729698181,
-0.7676442861557007,
0.19105809926986694,
-0.5764489769935608,
-0.029024075716733932,
-0.1833074688911438,
-0.10849423706531525,
-0.6250547766685486,
0.025708334520459175,
0.43873825669288635,
0.7901105284690857,
-0.754165530204773,
0.5434528589248657,
0.40258631110191345,
-0.20904818177223206,
-0.4994952082633972,
0.29599979519844055,
0.3502578139305115,
-1.115838646888733,
0.8406838774681091,
0.06187433376908302,
-0.2306777536869049,
-0.33030688762664795,
-0.8441693186759949,
-0.7280735373497009,
0.4980918765068054,
0.669516921043396,
-0.41116753220558167,
-0.08711773157119751,
0.39883872866630554,
0.3421727120876312,
-0.4389246106147766,
0.4305921196937561,
0.6941964626312256,
0.7224410772323608,
-0.24226532876491547,
-0.5685847997665405,
0.23822951316833496,
-0.008985718712210655,
-0.13206855952739716,
-0.12102749198675156,
-0.5549887418746948,
0.6389201283454895,
-0.05613577365875244,
-0.20676399767398834,
-0.2933307886123657,
0.47451746463775635,
0.3592309057712555,
-0.06387821584939957,
0.5507898330688477,
0.06582804024219513,
0.7838426232337952,
0.09817361831665039,
1.1676175594329834,
-0.016853217035531998,
0.06468168646097183,
1.1486589908599854,
-0.5733640193939209,
0.49603912234306335,
0.5351076722145081,
-0.04447177052497864,
0.24700656533241272,
0.3685338497161865,
-0.20166811347007751,
0.3857421278953552,
0.5952608585357666,
-0.1945708990097046,
0.2841038107872009,
-0.05787593871355057,
-0.25931036472320557,
0.3863135874271393,
0.5567365288734436,
-0.2211771011352539,
-0.21882948279380798,
-0.01774740032851696,
0.6602407693862915,
-0.009400319308042526,
-0.5314062833786011,
0.488035649061203,
-0.01149829477071762,
-0.6225563287734985,
0.4350428581237793,
0.21188879013061523,
0.6814841628074646,
-0.6984325647354126,
0.1909424066543579,
-0.26909899711608887,
-0.032160431146621704,
-0.2521437406539917,
-0.672674834728241,
-0.11470305919647217,
0.4601840674877167,
-0.0423903614282608,
-0.07207061350345612,
0.5632195472717285,
-0.31144362688064575,
-0.5378550291061401,
0.5453929901123047,
0.3788253366947174,
-0.01741267926990986,
-0.09367749840021133,
-0.7780271172523499,
0.42664673924446106,
0.08791633695363998,
-0.49202632904052734,
0.37565580010414124,
0.0680704414844513,
-0.21807163953781128,
0.5408362150192261,
0.5375866889953613,
0.38673579692840576,
0.15862977504730225,
0.27143970131874084,
0.6309443116188049,
-0.533125102519989,
-0.22262132167816162,
-1.2790119647979736,
0.13437744975090027,
-0.3025125563144684,
0.12932562828063965,
1.0539792776107788,
0.4867394268512726,
0.8639296889305115,
0.08936137706041336,
0.9208401441574097,
0.37230437994003296,
0.35859501361846924,
-0.9000505208969116,
0.512028694152832,
-0.1090901643037796,
0.4994918406009674,
-0.591144323348999,
-1.1328082084655762,
-0.07638226449489594,
0.4778746962547302,
-0.7004738450050354,
0.34209683537483215,
0.6913376450538635,
0.6597527265548706,
0.10305418819189072,
0.138602152466774,
0.04132774844765663,
0.56574946641922,
0.45075997710227966,
0.44150716066360474,
1.2401807308197021,
-0.12202302366495132,
0.2753106951713562,
-0.02904663234949112,
-0.3399718105792999,
0.04567163437604904,
-0.9825699925422668,
-1.151733160018921,
-0.10618092119693756,
-0.1183391809463501,
-0.5188249945640564,
0.11618798226118088,
0.802868127822876,
0.44119134545326233,
-0.4741632640361786,
-0.32881516218185425,
0.5216612219810486,
0.060423679649829865,
0.11004281044006348,
-0.21468116343021393,
0.4258168935775757,
-0.07151966542005539,
-0.9458093047142029,
0.46052658557891846,
0.044379204511642456,
-0.04927138611674309,
-0.8249818682670593,
-0.08649749308824539,
-0.019840262830257416,
0.32004594802856445,
0.5361266732215881,
0.022917022928595543,
-0.8934690356254578,
-0.4658981263637543,
-0.13525748252868652,
-0.1778288632631302,
-0.28895509243011475,
0.8041130900382996,
-0.39138954877853394,
0.13997100293636322,
0.06066317483782768,
0.6339038610458374,
0.2558078467845917,
-0.0915648341178894,
0.7345111966133118,
-0.6625275015830994,
0.19480019807815552,
0.35784438252449036,
0.3264985680580139,
0.36437514424324036,
-0.5161546468734741,
0.5682240128517151,
0.01387327816337347,
-0.15479879081249237,
-1.0568559169769287,
0.21333764493465424,
-0.8282961249351501,
-0.3031391501426697,
1.571934461593628,
0.1292104870080948,
-0.3126402199268341,
-0.13155792653560638,
-0.19957146048545837,
-0.05728767067193985,
-0.22311006486415863,
0.7332015633583069,
0.7900100350379944,
0.10357643663883209,
0.414793998003006,
-0.7657698392868042,
0.4803386330604553,
0.48096275329589844,
-0.6268444061279297,
0.12849654257297516,
0.6111655235290527,
0.4527968466281891,
0.016991639509797096,
0.5862300395965576,
-0.472425252199173,
0.030614890158176422,
-0.3282761871814728,
0.05134806036949158,
0.13999824225902557,
-0.1627054065465927,
-0.43394941091537476,
0.20023296773433685,
-0.17496252059936523,
0.15974973142147064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14022v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14022v1 | Investigating the Pre-Training Dynamics of In-Context Learning: Task Recognition vs. Task Learning | 2024-06-20T06:37:47 | 2024-06-20T06:37:47 | Xiaolei Wang, Xinyu Tang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The emergence of in-context learning (ICL) is potentially attributed to two
major abilities: task recognition (TR) for recognizing the task from
demonstrations and utilizing pre-trained priors, and task learning (TL) for
learning from demonstrations. However, relationships between the two abilities
and how such relationships affect the emergence of ICL is unclear. In this
paper, we take the first step by examining the pre-training dynamics of the
emergence of ICL. With carefully designed metrics, we find that these two
abilities are, in fact, competitive during pre-training. Moreover, we observe a
strong negative correlation between the competition and ICL performance.
Further analysis of common pre-training factors (i.e., model size, dataset
size, and data curriculum) demonstrates possible ways to manage the
competition. Based on these insights, we propose a simple yet effective method
to better integrate these two abilities for ICL at inference time. Through
adaptive ensemble learning, the performance of ICL can be significantly
boosted, enabling two small models to outperform a larger one with more than
twice the parameters. The code is available at
https://github.com/RUCAIBox/Competitive-ICL. | [
-0.44271400570869446,
-0.32019659876823425,
0.2427791953086853,
0.06393472105264664,
-0.2774626314640045,
0.32764846086502075,
-0.19260621070861816,
-0.6955726146697998,
-0.3068612813949585,
0.03865637630224228,
-0.408022403717041,
-0.09674035757780075,
-0.6910070776939392,
-0.05833549052476883,
-0.2589530050754547,
1.0371257066726685,
-0.06744638830423355,
-0.04576684907078743,
-0.6562166213989258,
-0.2920198440551758,
-0.5882479548454285,
-0.7013272047042847,
-0.5903488993644714,
-0.32280585169792175,
0.2898332178592682,
0.4407956004142761,
-0.09442096948623657,
0.38700369000434875,
0.3013702630996704,
0.34939345717430115,
0.17177438735961914,
0.10244669765233994,
-0.48489996790885925,
0.19504721462726593,
-0.18037743866443634,
-0.3557809591293335,
-0.17984545230865479,
0.33969631791114807,
0.7275709509849548,
0.578095018863678,
0.04983558505773544,
0.24583102762699127,
0.7904009819030762,
0.27013131976127625,
-0.7931002378463745,
0.17187243700027466,
-0.7312240600585938,
0.014833640307188034,
-0.5096364617347717,
-0.4746130406856537,
-0.40721720457077026,
0.184675931930542,
0.5654601454734802,
-0.6753283143043518,
0.20225247740745544,
0.0960717722773552,
0.8706627488136292,
0.26049309968948364,
-0.359935462474823,
-0.3710481822490692,
-0.660220742225647,
0.7990688681602478,
-0.08505106717348099,
0.3984430432319641,
-0.011731837876141071,
0.31867310404777527,
-0.1016598790884018,
-1.0792322158813477,
-0.24043644964694977,
-0.4395469129085541,
-0.13103176653385162,
0.2167721390724182,
-0.13961359858512878,
-0.038005951792001724,
0.27420759201049805,
-0.011978404596447945,
-0.3421672582626343,
0.30513009428977966,
-0.21789461374282837,
0.1303025484085083,
0.4289093613624573,
0.08933617174625397,
0.3017958104610443,
0.4311857521533966,
-0.5504316091537476,
-0.1941337138414383,
-0.5523803234100342,
0.5858907103538513,
0.04907995089888573,
0.2916773557662964,
-0.08108410239219666,
0.03582359105348587,
-0.019949354231357574,
0.5049605369567871,
0.5931646823883057,
-0.14000965654850006,
0.2077275961637497,
-0.0020240850280970335,
-0.2766832411289215,
0.39915531873703003,
0.47952860593795776,
-0.1769978404045105,
-0.1566421240568161,
-0.33772411942481995,
-0.2195151448249817,
-0.07865570485591888,
0.5195170640945435,
-0.4796633720397949,
-0.08171220123767853,
-0.07790162414312363,
-0.5368857979774475,
-0.20963332056999207,
0.10847175866365433,
-0.32438093423843384,
-0.04159361869096756,
-0.6254991888999939,
1.1290028095245361,
-0.1738586723804474,
-0.20878243446350098,
-0.2560986280441284,
-0.13042186200618744,
0.18956127762794495,
0.44442346692085266,
-0.6469599604606628,
0.6239674091339111,
0.634327232837677,
0.7455110549926758,
-0.4385841190814972,
-0.6480081677436829,
-0.7333569526672363,
0.09600438922643661,
-0.23907938599586487,
0.5894598960876465,
-0.3377995789051056,
-0.19515913724899292,
-0.19698356091976166,
-0.0003800994891207665,
-0.4212092161178589,
-0.8023974299430847,
-0.012823040597140789,
-0.9165305495262146,
-0.11172954738140106,
-0.14683577418327332,
-0.5715936422348022,
-0.020229700952768326,
0.1499650776386261,
-0.5322670340538025,
0.9193465113639832,
0.0018166272202506661,
-0.8076568841934204,
0.8873523473739624,
-0.9448628425598145,
-0.5144358277320862,
0.34159055352211,
-0.19739092886447906,
-0.4508838653564453,
-0.013909531757235527,
-0.23774123191833496,
0.6290896534919739,
-0.007350055035203695,
-0.08115445822477341,
-0.396552711725235,
-0.4631994068622589,
0.10969220846891403,
0.0543912909924984,
0.6835553646087646,
0.18730226159095764,
-0.647216796875,
0.1225832849740982,
-0.5064862966537476,
-0.1551484316587448,
-0.09042304009199142,
-0.2313617765903473,
-0.25218188762664795,
0.4165264666080475,
-0.33123642206192017,
0.26374551653862,
0.07944739609956741,
-0.2036060094833374,
-0.07616838067770004,
-0.15563692152500153,
0.4414055049419403,
0.633872926235199,
-0.1153901144862175,
0.49418094754219055,
-0.26013997197151184,
0.45135951042175293,
0.3028301000595093,
0.023694921284914017,
0.17688912153244019,
-0.006239322014153004,
-0.46521735191345215,
-0.1189035177230835,
0.2784455418586731,
0.44739869236946106,
-0.6498650908470154,
0.2258646935224533,
-0.1605786681175232,
-0.45210030674934387,
-0.12698809802532196,
0.11834828555583954,
0.4489280581474304,
0.5982761383056641,
0.4403259754180908,
-0.41288766264915466,
-0.5204017758369446,
-0.40532350540161133,
-0.2683859169483185,
-0.07766124606132507,
0.07583972066640854,
0.41269633173942566,
0.6758143901824951,
0.32626771926879883,
0.7781556844711304,
-0.10094022750854492,
-0.42961400747299194,
-0.3412410020828247,
0.42499175667762756,
-0.20358939468860626,
0.8873327970504761,
0.7680109739303589,
-0.825067937374115,
-0.8070135712623596,
0.146954745054245,
-0.6994282603263855,
0.14196054637432098,
-0.013955148868262768,
-0.16409873962402344,
-0.03717627376317978,
0.8061976432800293,
-0.12235371768474579,
0.5995897054672241,
0.29493266344070435,
-0.07343975454568863,
0.5949665904045105,
-0.23189394176006317,
0.323783814907074,
-0.6984144449234009,
0.1020156666636467,
0.0636884868144989,
0.04107086360454559,
-0.6864079236984253,
0.16002924740314484,
0.21817709505558014,
0.028227245435118675,
-0.5847794413566589,
0.38141554594039917,
-0.5135061740875244,
-0.31480780243873596,
-0.14342808723449707,
-0.08895554393529892,
-0.42458149790763855,
0.5403487086296082,
0.26272380352020264,
0.8744869232177734,
0.7217885255813599,
-0.815974235534668,
-0.17809320986270905,
-0.05454406887292862,
-0.844064474105835,
0.5034539699554443,
-0.45495525002479553,
0.04826948791742325,
0.08053412288427353,
0.29594331979751587,
-0.8628014326095581,
-0.36094930768013,
0.04717022553086281,
-0.22443075478076935,
0.521891176700592,
-0.2750517427921295,
-0.32442396879196167,
-0.249691903591156,
0.15058210492134094,
0.8106716275215149,
0.5656354427337646,
-0.7115628719329834,
0.6073073148727417,
0.32887932658195496,
0.1098325103521347,
-0.7178617715835571,
-0.40013983845710754,
-0.20830678939819336,
-0.6150397062301636,
-0.21105387806892395,
0.768366277217865,
-0.10329776257276535,
-0.14767172932624817,
-0.2879791259765625,
-0.051373712718486786,
-0.3734554052352905,
0.5004963278770447,
0.2695994973182678,
0.09780669957399368,
-0.22767165303230286,
0.14311759173870087,
0.16279734671115875,
0.06592335551977158,
-0.06493328511714935,
-0.4463011920452118,
0.22741617262363434,
-0.05200434848666191,
-0.238538920879364,
-0.6724678874015808,
0.05633414909243584,
0.7147603034973145,
-0.4325565993785858,
0.5336979627609253,
0.33029597997665405,
-0.21562936902046204,
-0.2908805310726166,
-0.4512845277786255,
-0.12936489284038544,
-0.43534645438194275,
0.3679286539554596,
-0.3458050787448883,
-0.5301105380058289,
0.3781556189060211,
-0.22655442357063293,
-0.05716884881258011,
0.08443326503038406,
0.3396311402320862,
-0.32533207535743713,
1.1346453428268433,
0.5914469957351685,
0.12064557522535324,
0.9152221083641052,
-0.33489295840263367,
-0.11157479137182236,
-0.8035949468612671,
-0.4538339078426361,
-0.3572366535663605,
-0.6071664094924927,
-0.24799707531929016,
-0.06412927806377411,
0.6124922037124634,
0.28189027309417725,
-0.48497793078422546,
0.3058021664619446,
-0.2372303158044815,
0.502829909324646,
0.7138192057609558,
0.4840327799320221,
-0.07002072781324387,
-0.17086948454380035,
-0.1306489109992981,
0.026271073147654533,
-0.79538893699646,
-0.24954620003700256,
0.9852771162986755,
-0.0272520761936903,
0.45150578022003174,
-0.13926473259925842,
0.7410589456558228,
0.17610840499401093,
0.37042632699012756,
-0.4010908305644989,
0.4679926335811615,
-0.3195151686668396,
-0.36791566014289856,
-0.0659131184220314,
-0.03434654325246811,
-1.0455039739608765,
0.172600656747818,
-0.5144088864326477,
-0.8673230409622192,
0.19966307282447815,
0.6550381183624268,
-0.5396894216537476,
0.34317585825920105,
-0.5982449054718018,
1.1124261617660522,
-0.45243513584136963,
-0.6864811778068542,
-0.38946861028671265,
-0.8529869318008423,
0.0626087412238121,
0.05026857182383537,
-0.029285412281751633,
0.29035696387290955,
0.037015292793512344,
0.7049875855445862,
-0.07832799851894379,
0.777902364730835,
-0.23457559943199158,
0.45267248153686523,
0.3765809237957001,
0.05127021297812462,
0.38867491483688354,
-0.1949915736913681,
0.26474249362945557,
-0.16878490149974823,
-0.025463121011853218,
-0.5130475163459778,
-0.5164816975593567,
0.49055901169776917,
-0.7616127133369446,
-0.5571818947792053,
-0.23151981830596924,
-0.3545878231525421,
-0.23834991455078125,
-0.006134161725640297,
0.5717587471008301,
0.7450436353683472,
-0.2533847689628601,
0.41378483176231384,
0.7763968706130981,
0.18849320709705353,
0.5255926847457886,
0.3643089532852173,
0.3798312842845917,
-0.019412484019994736,
0.8120659589767456,
0.39411190152168274,
0.3562207818031311,
0.5503057837486267,
0.023129358887672424,
-0.1568838357925415,
-0.8097259402275085,
-0.24831804633140564,
-0.28595229983329773,
-0.4535353183746338,
-0.08010128140449524,
-0.6159009337425232,
-0.05120489001274109,
-0.10275211185216904,
-0.38422510027885437,
-0.020401425659656525,
0.30082863569259644,
-0.7238094806671143,
0.23067578673362732,
-0.26549476385116577,
0.6638334393501282,
-0.06881488114595413,
0.4665009379386902,
-0.477548748254776,
-0.31617435812950134,
0.6671352982521057,
0.23350951075553894,
0.47893834114074707,
-0.4735720455646515,
-0.4706480801105499,
-0.0975816398859024,
-0.5038698315620422,
-0.5703798532485962,
0.2600044310092926,
0.2403838187456131,
0.8015508651733398,
0.6382827758789062,
-0.08834734559059143,
0.8472939133644104,
-0.49409887194633484,
0.8347969651222229,
0.12142805010080338,
-1.0839893817901611,
0.44395309686660767,
0.014329497702419758,
0.018087614327669144,
0.40562674403190613,
0.6857907772064209,
0.07515640556812286,
-0.23222298920154572,
-0.7118132710456848,
-0.4250679016113281,
1.0054805278778076,
-0.015820149332284927,
-0.14560849964618683,
0.19127117097377777,
0.09114985913038254,
0.13991300761699677,
0.2713773250579834,
-0.6655960083007812,
0.10686114430427551,
-0.2602512538433075,
-0.1990717500448227,
-0.22112981975078583,
0.06230775639414787,
-0.1900101900100708,
-0.475777268409729,
0.31764596700668335,
-0.0940631777048111,
0.1518927663564682,
-0.05904886871576309,
-0.5526340007781982,
0.10683371871709824,
-0.12889507412910461,
0.5067445039749146,
0.4950520098209381,
-0.07236689329147339,
0.03967859596014023,
0.35952290892601013,
-0.3527846932411194,
0.15075314044952393,
0.029234381392598152,
0.4051594138145447,
-0.533496081829071,
0.7322176694869995,
0.837708592414856,
0.7828067541122437,
-0.7556287050247192,
0.6037371158599854,
0.12721191346645355,
-0.5070998072624207,
-0.09003464132547379,
0.2941233217716217,
-0.37637215852737427,
0.7438749074935913,
0.5831974744796753,
0.276213139295578,
0.07066582888364792,
-0.6629740595817566,
0.2635776102542877,
0.5649402737617493,
-0.4069533050060272,
-0.5151872634887695,
0.7322152853012085,
0.17424078285694122,
-0.3016858994960785,
0.43348005414009094,
-0.2254904955625534,
-0.6352977752685547,
0.9575771689414978,
0.4983692467212677,
0.8057736158370972,
-0.16752834618091583,
0.009633509442210197,
0.25986483693122864,
-0.25550323724746704,
0.03319110721349716,
-0.16318830847740173,
-0.6301131248474121,
-0.6223401427268982,
-0.20107010006904602,
-0.18732863664627075,
-0.018846508115530014,
0.0899251326918602,
-0.7420139908790588,
0.29516249895095825,
-0.3644140362739563,
-0.012447016313672066,
0.10667295008897781,
0.1772298663854599,
-1.0001685619354248,
0.24154032766819,
0.0684870257973671,
0.6464310884475708,
-0.7474011778831482,
0.8425049185752869,
0.8674346208572388,
-0.17249517142772675,
-0.7096110582351685,
0.22408857941627502,
-0.0723629966378212,
-0.44424375891685486,
1.166741132736206,
0.31585928797721863,
-0.0075277164578437805,
0.2687619924545288,
-0.6328690648078918,
-0.9022386074066162,
1.373461365699768,
0.21780452132225037,
-0.3787296414375305,
-0.15944382548332214,
-0.4644719660282135,
0.4524858593940735,
-0.7697625160217285,
0.12064304947853088,
0.3787226378917694,
-0.039391450583934784,
-0.053379252552986145,
-0.9428136944770813,
-0.33388710021972656,
0.05660127103328705,
-0.22107602655887604,
0.19256988167762756,
-0.42264804244041443,
0.8435984253883362,
-0.20157746970653534,
-0.5264518857002258,
0.09998856484889984,
0.5751245021820068,
0.12588536739349365,
0.6752559542655945,
0.7809735536575317,
0.30501270294189453,
0.44739076495170593,
-0.13147251307964325,
0.6457116603851318,
-0.31544923782348633,
0.15010270476341248,
1.1479690074920654,
-0.30905482172966003,
0.9576477408409119,
0.2851313054561615,
-0.24962057173252106,
0.7504913210868835,
0.7097026109695435,
0.27645862102508545,
0.7576300501823425,
-0.063263900578022,
-0.4153248071670532,
-0.5426841378211975,
0.1517849713563919,
-0.18495601415634155,
0.5305219292640686,
0.3667259216308594,
-0.3436250686645508,
-0.13566339015960693,
0.42465171217918396,
-0.4502696692943573,
0.07420989125967026,
-0.637549638748169,
0.932526171207428,
-0.3358781039714813,
-0.7863937020301819,
0.19499598443508148,
-0.6752545237541199,
0.546497642993927,
-0.7366223335266113,
-0.08916211873292923,
0.25728532671928406,
0.06257971376180649,
-0.07702753692865372,
-0.5391584634780884,
-0.06828717887401581,
-0.26105955243110657,
-0.06512787193059921,
-0.07892307639122009,
0.5488237738609314,
-0.4407951533794403,
0.1276365965604782,
0.45361894369125366,
0.39593297243118286,
-0.01778867095708847,
0.2514934837818146,
-0.6481155753135681,
-0.12218428403139114,
-0.3706183433532715,
0.08782944828271866,
0.8952091336250305,
0.23845604062080383,
-0.15286457538604736,
0.527249813079834,
0.35773739218711853,
-0.2650451064109802,
0.05954344570636749,
-0.4333420991897583,
0.7377614974975586,
-0.046328675001859665,
-0.7539698481559753,
-0.6009334921836853,
0.6765437126159668,
-0.09551939368247986,
-0.4515746831893921,
0.3030414283275604,
0.30376800894737244,
1.294925332069397,
-0.10573641210794449,
0.5411202311515808,
-0.2162681370973587,
0.38903936743736267,
-0.44756218791007996,
0.576498806476593,
-0.9589474201202393,
-0.1140163242816925,
-0.3949183523654938,
-0.4417535066604614,
-0.08900679647922516,
0.3921686112880707,
-0.37287217378616333,
0.13770964741706848,
0.5819182991981506,
0.44646209478378296,
-0.41171228885650635,
-0.1345137655735016,
0.2798454165458679,
0.038985446095466614,
-0.016538269817829132,
0.6590571403503418,
0.9842334389686584,
0.014266391284763813,
0.3862961530685425,
-0.30638250708580017,
-0.47782012820243835,
-0.4350120723247528,
-0.9520081877708435,
-0.8029739260673523,
-0.8988253474235535,
-0.2593338191509247,
-0.16130128502845764,
0.09718206524848938,
1.1544735431671143,
1.1691582202911377,
-0.6089787483215332,
-0.5895912647247314,
-0.22255665063858032,
-0.025771556422114372,
-0.9498825669288635,
-0.1805747002363205,
0.32087618112564087,
-0.6674466729164124,
-0.66246098279953,
0.40456345677375793,
0.03020918369293213,
0.1889217644929886,
0.158704936504364,
-0.21806862950325012,
-0.22488577663898468,
-0.16758710145950317,
0.7737416625022888,
0.5711822509765625,
-0.4802020788192749,
-0.21999917924404144,
-0.4409807324409485,
0.223768949508667,
-0.00885904859751463,
1.1192948818206787,
-0.9928904175758362,
0.5520432591438293,
0.18982481956481934,
0.5850546360015869,
0.4333980679512024,
-0.020649902522563934,
0.42167928814888,
-0.5920699238777161,
0.1319701373577118,
0.1945767104625702,
0.2744230329990387,
-0.23348268866539001,
-0.21643772721290588,
0.3122059404850006,
0.3500462770462036,
-0.7581781148910522,
-1.0882198810577393,
0.1996488720178604,
-0.7371922731399536,
-0.348891019821167,
0.3093875050544739,
-0.3160043954849243,
0.14995892345905304,
-0.17341181635856628,
-0.020566046237945557,
0.27950432896614075,
-0.012467669323086739,
0.7938498258590698,
0.5666196346282959,
-0.5836064219474792,
0.04845348745584488,
-0.42308786511421204,
0.9231579303741455,
0.31759458780288696,
-0.5560406446456909,
-0.24757549166679382,
0.045776233077049255,
0.39540645480155945,
0.01713050901889801,
0.1900770515203476,
0.23311913013458252,
0.6741910576820374,
-0.11668682098388672,
-0.4051797091960907,
-0.06192082539200783,
-0.6858073472976685,
-0.2047204077243805,
0.4804041385650635,
0.052569061517715454,
-0.4490034580230713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14021v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14021v1 | HIGHT: Hierarchical Graph Tokenization for Graph-Language Alignment | 2024-06-20T06:37:35 | 2024-06-20T06:37:35 | Yongqiang Chen, Quanming Yao, Juzheng Zhang, James Cheng, Yatao Bian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.QM | Recently there has been a surge of interest in extending the success of large
language models (LLMs) to graph modality, such as social networks and
molecules. As LLMs are predominantly trained with 1D text data, most existing
approaches adopt a graph neural network to represent a graph as a series of
node tokens and feed these tokens to LLMs for graph-language alignment. Despite
achieving some successes, existing approaches have overlooked the hierarchical
structures that are inherent in graph data. Especially, in molecular graphs,
the high-order structural information contains rich semantics of molecular
functional groups, which encode crucial biochemical functionalities of the
molecules. We establish a simple benchmark showing that neglecting the
hierarchical information in graph tokenization will lead to subpar
graph-language alignment and severe hallucination in generated outputs. To
address this problem, we propose a novel strategy called HIerarchical GrapH
Tokenization (HIGHT). HIGHT employs a hierarchical graph tokenizer that
extracts and encodes the hierarchy of node, motif, and graph levels of
informative tokens to improve the graph perception of LLMs. HIGHT also adopts
an augmented graph-language supervised fine-tuning dataset, enriched with the
hierarchical graph information, to further enhance the graph-language
alignment. Extensive experiments on 7 molecule-centric benchmarks confirm the
effectiveness of HIGHT in reducing hallucination by 40%, as well as significant
improvements in various molecule-language downstream tasks. | [
-0.20834729075431824,
-1.0572021007537842,
0.33539772033691406,
-0.0952846109867096,
-0.07054521888494492,
0.6019085645675659,
-0.25711387395858765,
-0.3588574230670929,
0.618356466293335,
0.35550162196159363,
-0.176926851272583,
-0.8671611547470093,
-0.7265483736991882,
0.06977570801973343,
-0.0042998152785003185,
1.0675394535064697,
0.029608596116304398,
-0.034345902502536774,
-0.11024095863103867,
-0.054428935050964355,
-0.17071251571178436,
-0.6649226546287537,
-0.6813384294509888,
-0.43327346444129944,
0.9341301918029785,
0.22580763697624207,
0.8129909634590149,
1.1315011978149414,
0.6056572198867798,
0.3101710379123688,
-0.31091707944869995,
0.2634371519088745,
-0.8028636574745178,
-0.22669030725955963,
-0.02724211849272251,
0.041849471628665924,
-0.9320674538612366,
-0.19819797575473785,
0.6291700005531311,
1.1290390491485596,
0.2885323166847229,
-0.07423162460327148,
0.1228042021393776,
0.6530641317367554,
-0.37992286682128906,
0.4818250834941864,
-0.6562085747718811,
0.046447593718767166,
-0.20756900310516357,
-0.24313054978847504,
-0.3293001353740692,
-0.18344628810882568,
-0.07676880806684494,
-0.7115752100944519,
0.031004101037979126,
0.21264930069446564,
1.067256212234497,
0.1366777867078781,
-0.5078539848327637,
0.04785512760281563,
-0.5030125379562378,
0.21915924549102783,
-0.5253623723983765,
0.42581963539123535,
0.119997039437294,
0.11332976818084717,
-0.33426952362060547,
-0.7134461402893066,
-0.4080747365951538,
-0.1147657185792923,
-0.24255770444869995,
0.05826983228325844,
-0.050538744777441025,
0.5263499617576599,
0.11449917405843735,
0.2927404046058655,
-0.6527628898620605,
0.2111453115940094,
-0.041534535586833954,
-0.4266343414783478,
0.0075155580416321754,
-0.14540481567382812,
0.30042365193367004,
-0.5015376210212708,
-0.42075979709625244,
0.0005346279358491302,
-0.6030259728431702,
-0.2237357348203659,
0.1815485805273056,
0.8937069773674011,
0.2581188380718231,
0.7560997009277344,
-0.14956693351268768,
0.3322051167488098,
0.09862851351499557,
0.21227382123470306,
0.39603716135025024,
-0.532686710357666,
-0.27746087312698364,
0.4917891323566437,
0.7500577569007874,
0.24153316020965576,
0.35364535450935364,
-0.3764064908027649,
-0.27242255210876465,
0.06336569041013718,
-0.013396494090557098,
-1.0886677503585815,
-0.2180679440498352,
0.1795884668827057,
-0.5216416716575623,
-0.4823495149612427,
0.050795719027519226,
-0.7941455841064453,
-0.44970762729644775,
-0.17837515473365784,
0.46647578477859497,
-0.38645604252815247,
-0.05661645159125328,
0.0359688438475132,
-0.10660886764526367,
-0.2718496024608612,
0.052464019507169724,
-1.0453919172286987,
0.5528794527053833,
0.8785157799720764,
1.0998563766479492,
-0.5450572371482849,
-0.5292965173721313,
-0.9286152124404907,
0.5142554044723511,
-0.3028954267501831,
0.459463894367218,
-0.6220040321350098,
-0.003109869547188282,
-0.2697809934616089,
0.1174471452832222,
-0.2111738622188568,
-0.6021866798400879,
-0.045003559440374374,
-0.3659264147281647,
-0.08472146838903427,
-0.2502564787864685,
-0.5185962915420532,
0.141323059797287,
0.24438713490962982,
-0.4823119640350342,
1.1544421911239624,
0.234344482421875,
-0.8090388774871826,
0.2646782100200653,
-0.5422489643096924,
-0.5250706672668457,
0.1253962516784668,
-0.5278666615486145,
-0.44649386405944824,
-0.1394326090812683,
0.39071252942085266,
0.3505038321018219,
0.08166434615850449,
0.3345206081867218,
-0.21076247096061707,
-0.518780529499054,
-0.03599083796143532,
-0.14583365619182587,
0.5733650326728821,
-0.12054808437824249,
-0.46710917353630066,
0.6163259744644165,
-0.6972754597663879,
-0.1719706952571869,
-0.04284002631902695,
-0.3107428550720215,
-0.17446304857730865,
-0.13652116060256958,
0.06859077513217926,
0.09627865254878998,
0.34688088297843933,
-0.5564191341400146,
0.4007701575756073,
-0.564112663269043,
0.6032378673553467,
1.1353375911712646,
0.010027604177594185,
0.34117525815963745,
-0.0036624225322157145,
0.17885826528072357,
0.2070673257112503,
-0.11732222139835358,
0.15999774634838104,
-0.39471369981765747,
-0.47530385851860046,
-0.4911286234855652,
0.2872956097126007,
0.4364224672317505,
-0.4847670793533325,
0.8706309199333191,
-0.635707676410675,
-0.14526957273483276,
-0.13196691870689392,
0.03690943866968155,
0.23744267225265503,
0.6815735101699829,
0.3995629549026489,
-0.32977327704429626,
-0.5394597053527832,
-0.6611720323562622,
-0.12127583473920822,
-0.28997841477394104,
0.14908568561077118,
0.4191872477531433,
0.5923181176185608,
-0.5781202912330627,
0.7325180172920227,
-0.402458518743515,
-0.44643092155456543,
-0.06427665799856186,
0.028397174552083015,
0.10970018059015274,
0.6072299480438232,
0.28963980078697205,
-0.3985169231891632,
-0.24417048692703247,
0.6006980538368225,
-0.6299326419830322,
0.059573546051979065,
-0.0007823698106221855,
-0.5899654030799866,
-0.06291335076093674,
0.6560811400413513,
-0.800150454044342,
0.30175602436065674,
0.30916428565979004,
-0.40966105461120605,
0.24768322706222534,
-0.046459853649139404,
-0.010573686100542545,
-1.284885287284851,
0.1424078792333603,
-0.2637636363506317,
-0.2938031256198883,
-0.43427789211273193,
-0.20676928758621216,
-0.21930904686450958,
-0.3315685987472534,
-0.08418909460306168,
0.4737550914287567,
-0.3353220224380493,
-0.2179325371980667,
-0.10115403681993484,
0.18616299331188202,
-0.14670905470848083,
0.7438549995422363,
-0.07174055278301239,
0.5953422784805298,
0.5738027691841125,
-0.08334200084209442,
0.24778470396995544,
0.307237833738327,
-0.00655630836263299,
0.14872504770755768,
-0.6194823980331421,
0.12403562664985657,
-0.07104019820690155,
0.2650667428970337,
-1.0811927318572998,
-0.46276676654815674,
0.30902165174484253,
-0.4268763065338135,
0.3807468116283417,
-0.2877923846244812,
-0.5502527356147766,
-0.1338902711868286,
-0.17974542081356049,
0.49568915367126465,
0.3449879288673401,
-0.5851960182189941,
0.5566458106040955,
0.33869659900665283,
0.0394454225897789,
-0.5746569037437439,
-0.4430947005748749,
0.301425576210022,
-0.15960687398910522,
-0.47943004965782166,
0.5154380798339844,
0.27729788422584534,
0.2371981292963028,
-0.020612530410289764,
-0.4369584023952484,
0.19283241033554077,
0.006795469671487808,
0.2638044059276581,
0.16271840035915375,
-0.4851038455963135,
0.04715367406606674,
-0.03629200905561447,
-0.31947073340415955,
-0.12546321749687195,
-0.7908387780189514,
0.7706882953643799,
-0.29114454984664917,
-0.15789581835269928,
-0.551659107208252,
0.18303503096103668,
0.7979835271835327,
-0.25033652782440186,
0.7248610258102417,
0.4822680950164795,
-0.7602347731590271,
0.14249004423618317,
0.034494541585445404,
-0.25347256660461426,
-0.4777253568172455,
0.6792022585868835,
-0.3831822872161865,
-0.9514016509056091,
0.49182432889938354,
-0.32190901041030884,
-0.36836346983909607,
0.21133068203926086,
0.5681145787239075,
0.047968652099370956,
1.205141544342041,
0.3293002247810364,
-0.24488037824630737,
0.5332402586936951,
-0.1406187266111374,
0.6723077297210693,
-0.6281049847602844,
-0.07128732651472092,
-0.45312339067459106,
-0.4290405511856079,
-0.6937766671180725,
-0.36040306091308594,
0.4013597071170807,
0.314082533121109,
-0.5617967844009399,
0.46149420738220215,
-0.5785121321678162,
0.5872204899787903,
0.18384765088558197,
0.2288527637720108,
0.11945729702711105,
0.5876704454421997,
-0.38331758975982666,
0.16897672414779663,
-0.6864345073699951,
-0.516541063785553,
0.6224566698074341,
0.372761070728302,
0.6134071350097656,
-0.12044180184602737,
0.9147017002105713,
0.01690688543021679,
0.07844126969575882,
-0.9982190132141113,
0.5744484066963196,
-0.22024840116500854,
-0.1690717190504074,
-0.5375007390975952,
-0.6824914216995239,
-1.0750974416732788,
0.13121026754379272,
-0.06168888509273529,
-1.1847116947174072,
0.2933080196380615,
0.10778787732124329,
-0.1436106413602829,
0.32976189255714417,
-0.5466870069503784,
1.2540560960769653,
-0.07897750288248062,
-0.23978456854820251,
0.12570412456989288,
-0.6967406272888184,
-0.18306954205036163,
0.05237726494669914,
0.15067660808563232,
0.0009383656433783472,
0.12358556687831879,
0.7345988154411316,
-0.6621423959732056,
0.9664051532745361,
-0.09669065475463867,
-0.06405461579561234,
-0.09857448190450668,
0.19725939631462097,
0.7297824025154114,
-0.07115746289491653,
-0.007336420007050037,
0.15738223493099213,
-0.0504336878657341,
-0.6087157726287842,
-0.6403669118881226,
0.7781950235366821,
-0.755612850189209,
-0.4033338129520416,
-0.20358313620090485,
-0.5983158349990845,
-0.250343918800354,
0.6569055318832397,
0.29234084486961365,
0.4723272919654846,
-0.11933889240026474,
0.17755456268787384,
0.38633617758750916,
0.028336413204669952,
0.14001531898975372,
-0.49491140246391296,
-0.3914603292942047,
-0.7673922777175903,
1.252994179725647,
0.11074662208557129,
0.4277900755405426,
0.5241715908050537,
0.3893393576145172,
0.017282357439398766,
-0.604727029800415,
-0.5310768485069275,
0.18794989585876465,
-0.8107194304466248,
-0.11335867643356323,
-0.7389439940452576,
-0.3280389904975891,
-0.6220106482505798,
-0.3249512016773224,
-0.3787674903869629,
-0.6576768755912781,
-0.07708536088466644,
-0.3821384310722351,
0.27344217896461487,
0.5392231941223145,
0.1641257107257843,
0.22720807790756226,
-0.5709928870201111,
0.4963426887989044,
-0.009587230160832405,
0.38237234950065613,
0.022679954767227173,
-0.0009362214477732778,
-0.3691059947013855,
-0.019125349819660187,
0.048731569200754166,
-0.656546413898468,
0.030854854732751846,
0.17207546532154083,
0.24735556542873383,
0.3086038827896118,
-0.3882376551628113,
0.9310135245323181,
-0.44676119089126587,
0.5936847925186157,
0.17610806226730347,
-0.9528250098228455,
0.3891574442386627,
-0.47040048241615295,
0.07735231518745422,
0.5315237045288086,
0.2393859624862671,
-0.7034228444099426,
-0.3748052716255188,
-0.16727054119110107,
-1.0479789972305298,
0.41068601608276367,
0.4137985110282898,
0.0020645959302783012,
-0.36992624402046204,
0.4475712478160858,
0.002099620644003153,
0.20123076438903809,
-0.7488511800765991,
-0.1667407602071762,
-0.3387298285961151,
-0.5066605806350708,
0.03870633244514465,
0.22413012385368347,
-0.17913374304771423,
-0.5429407954216003,
0.4991052746772766,
-0.4332207441329956,
0.1750851422548294,
0.05291390419006348,
0.05522863194346428,
-0.24245677888393402,
-0.013003106229007244,
0.06341247260570526,
0.5462237000465393,
-0.267378568649292,
0.6264234781265259,
-0.16193203628063202,
-0.49917060136795044,
0.12482281774282455,
0.0885409414768219,
-0.12978340685367584,
-0.1954367756843567,
0.48268455266952515,
0.771114706993103,
-0.007532224059104919,
-0.38887473940849304,
0.4405602216720581,
0.2736261188983917,
-0.05564185231924057,
0.5248671770095825,
-0.15672247111797333,
0.21164117753505707,
-0.08007336407899857,
0.06534776836633682,
0.17994937300682068,
-0.11417257785797119,
-0.7225639820098877,
0.32159796357154846,
0.4169329106807709,
-0.5549792051315308,
-0.2264707237482071,
0.661448061466217,
0.029233155772089958,
-0.39187178015708923,
0.5767306089401245,
0.08070006221532822,
-0.6549588441848755,
0.5678043961524963,
0.7603956460952759,
0.9037909507751465,
0.11508798599243164,
0.09444539994001389,
0.2618272602558136,
0.13942950963974,
0.374237060546875,
0.14628607034683228,
-0.07608022540807724,
-0.7135844230651855,
-0.185540571808815,
-0.7189461588859558,
0.01531138177961111,
-0.18181681632995605,
-0.32075610756874084,
0.07027965784072876,
-0.43943673372268677,
-0.1286817342042923,
0.3242201805114746,
-0.1629631221294403,
-0.172468364238739,
-0.033339012414216995,
-0.0416790172457695,
0.4696536660194397,
-0.7208734750747681,
0.8964061141014099,
0.5230445861816406,
-0.4315117597579956,
-0.5228837132453918,
0.1561211794614792,
-0.10326612740755081,
-0.6206437349319458,
0.7689274549484253,
0.3721184730529785,
-0.37520983815193176,
0.3379744589328766,
-0.4464338719844818,
-0.9571806192398071,
0.8251573443412781,
0.3288874626159668,
-0.4402863681316376,
-0.3638659715652466,
0.4499950408935547,
0.5842585563659668,
-0.5410618185997009,
-0.2732364535331726,
0.5894770622253418,
0.5032289028167725,
0.2479398101568222,
-0.6894432902336121,
0.401704341173172,
-0.3458172082901001,
0.1333846002817154,
0.36833426356315613,
-0.456996351480484,
0.7097230553627014,
0.0012411588104441762,
-0.21890154480934143,
0.016760187223553658,
0.5879054665565491,
0.266411691904068,
0.18968214094638824,
0.3199111223220825,
0.3988887369632721,
1.045374870300293,
-0.1587340533733368,
0.7290272116661072,
-0.3881262540817261,
0.27215567231178284,
0.9205449819564819,
-0.4295288324356079,
0.580986499786377,
0.8074486255645752,
0.15553583204746246,
0.3014032244682312,
0.8297017812728882,
0.14202925562858582,
0.3172239363193512,
0.5428475141525269,
-0.05932061746716499,
-0.19158512353897095,
-0.20704497396945953,
-0.1931796371936798,
0.17814084887504578,
0.297823429107666,
-0.12108230590820312,
-0.12218991667032242,
-0.013795232400298119,
-0.02899402379989624,
-0.061408042907714844,
-0.13764645159244537,
0.8262021541595459,
-0.13604333996772766,
-0.3130931854248047,
0.8396965265274048,
-0.1450999528169632,
0.3234610855579376,
-0.16701674461364746,
-0.04427628964185715,
-0.20469500124454498,
0.17202284932136536,
-0.43678662180900574,
-0.39097970724105835,
0.12127448618412018,
-0.22492703795433044,
-0.05595915764570236,
-0.2502521276473999,
0.5621195435523987,
-0.37952664494514465,
-0.42434900999069214,
0.516740083694458,
0.46520575881004333,
0.1786346137523651,
0.014297510497272015,
-0.4173090159893036,
-0.06513889878988266,
-0.33472272753715515,
-0.18253420293331146,
0.24787254631519318,
0.6860381364822388,
-0.28133925795555115,
0.20673255622386932,
0.577415943145752,
0.2030712515115738,
-0.02880478836596012,
0.34456536173820496,
1.0189815759658813,
-0.797862708568573,
-0.3481282889842987,
-0.9565550088882446,
-0.01072690263390541,
-0.0982309877872467,
-0.22392424941062927,
0.693082332611084,
1.0203028917312622,
0.9798353314399719,
0.21801620721817017,
0.6171956658363342,
0.1250886172056198,
-0.16416271030902863,
-0.5905722379684448,
0.7258442640304565,
-0.4552582800388336,
0.13704150915145874,
-0.5422318577766418,
-1.0076693296432495,
-0.5905390977859497,
0.46501946449279785,
-0.044845033437013626,
0.07322518527507782,
0.9222301244735718,
1.1265543699264526,
-0.14378346502780914,
-0.20119979977607727,
0.12317778170108795,
0.4890683889389038,
0.5218538045883179,
0.42160189151763916,
0.661776065826416,
-0.40487921237945557,
0.35389015078544617,
-0.08868000656366348,
-0.24052758514881134,
-0.15189090371131897,
-0.7590974569320679,
-1.100921392440796,
-0.4136922061443329,
-0.3671761453151703,
-0.7549763321876526,
0.22192691266536713,
1.1910839080810547,
0.7364453077316284,
-0.8712571859359741,
-0.4477538466453552,
-0.5052006840705872,
0.22240233421325684,
-0.29247626662254333,
-0.20663967728614807,
0.8200293183326721,
-0.2896521985530853,
-0.5030582547187805,
0.4762609601020813,
0.6979874968528748,
0.3180614113807678,
0.07751385867595673,
-0.12585754692554474,
-0.15527446568012238,
-0.04337353631854057,
0.6279446482658386,
-0.0155148571357131,
-0.6344264149665833,
-0.6509912610054016,
0.18478283286094666,
-0.4280092716217041,
0.706393837928772,
0.8916424512863159,
-0.5586345791816711,
0.24754096567630768,
0.6793203353881836,
0.8234317302703857,
0.571715235710144,
0.14504143595695496,
0.4452468752861023,
-0.7899653911590576,
-0.09554921835660934,
0.11931446939706802,
0.3241419196128845,
0.21417450904846191,
-0.6021310687065125,
0.3551778495311737,
0.5596308708190918,
-0.3527252972126007,
-0.8800230622291565,
0.10592655092477798,
-1.2020221948623657,
-0.3674392104148865,
0.9502875804901123,
0.2046816200017929,
-0.5087631940841675,
-0.01672276481986046,
-0.40367475152015686,
0.6117817759513855,
-0.29439350962638855,
0.759743332862854,
0.7028802633285522,
-0.27201488614082336,
0.25568825006484985,
-0.17702902853488922,
0.5546506643295288,
0.33766502141952515,
-0.9573140144348145,
0.6279476881027222,
0.5164456963539124,
-0.08452259004116058,
0.24319255352020264,
0.6436794996261597,
-0.271310955286026,
-0.013965421356260777,
-0.0686238557100296,
-0.08764494955539703,
0.06584791094064713,
-0.5533269047737122,
-0.1570678949356079,
0.22253824770450592,
-0.05291038006544113,
0.05636576563119888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14012v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14012v1 | Seeing Through AI's Lens: Enhancing Human Skepticism Towards LLM-Generated Fake News | 2024-06-20T06:02:04 | 2024-06-20T06:02:04 | Navid Ayoobi, Sadat Shahriar, Arjun Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | LLMs offer valuable capabilities, yet they can be utilized by malicious users
to disseminate deceptive information and generate fake news. The growing
prevalence of LLMs poses difficulties in crafting detection approaches that
remain effective across various text domains. Additionally, the absence of
precautionary measures for AI-generated news on online social platforms is
concerning. Therefore, there is an urgent need to improve people's ability to
differentiate between news articles written by humans and those produced by
LLMs. By providing cues in human-written and LLM-generated news, we can help
individuals increase their skepticism towards fake LLM-generated news. This
paper aims to elucidate simple markers that help individuals distinguish
between articles penned by humans and those created by LLMs. To achieve this,
we initially collected a dataset comprising 39k news articles authored by
humans or generated by four distinct LLMs with varying degrees of fake. We then
devise a metric named Entropy-Shift Authorship Signature (ESAS) based on the
information theory and entropy principles. The proposed ESAS ranks terms or
entities, like POS tagging, within news articles based on their relevance in
discerning article authorship. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our metric
by showing the high accuracy attained by a basic method, i.e., TF-IDF combined
with logistic regression classifier, using a small set of terms with the
highest ESAS score. Consequently, we introduce and scrutinize these top
ESAS-ranked terms to aid individuals in strengthening their skepticism towards
LLM-generated fake news. | [
-0.2743816673755646,
-0.6634058952331543,
0.8521592020988464,
0.0735214352607727,
-0.2957932949066162,
0.36654359102249146,
0.1088939756155014,
-0.6900185942649841,
0.502861738204956,
0.2460501492023468,
-0.5007016658782959,
-0.5238136053085327,
-0.7681437730789185,
0.45930957794189453,
-0.48550859093666077,
0.786126971244812,
-0.04508741572499275,
0.017290744930505753,
-0.3217383921146393,
0.20012006163597107,
0.26700493693351746,
-0.07683255523443222,
-0.7233613133430481,
-0.2890978455543518,
0.70972740650177,
0.0015520978486165404,
0.5179572105407715,
0.7254193425178528,
0.4539237320423126,
0.17652763426303864,
0.15614132583141327,
0.5801073908805847,
-0.11784163117408752,
-0.2771929204463959,
-0.004654731135815382,
-0.8521890044212341,
-0.2504192888736725,
0.34847477078437805,
0.44050678610801697,
0.05950140208005905,
0.10558640211820602,
0.43637344241142273,
-0.02431938424706459,
0.5161252021789551,
-0.5590386390686035,
-0.2780916392803192,
-0.9010389447212219,
0.13848347961902618,
-0.5498030781745911,
-0.4730032980442047,
-0.3974723815917969,
-0.3756815493106842,
-0.2634270191192627,
-0.7835100889205933,
0.32718753814697266,
0.3317183554172516,
1.0575248003005981,
0.37111976742744446,
-0.5044398307800293,
-0.15811878442764282,
-0.5277915000915527,
0.4539748728275299,
-0.7104498744010925,
0.3338727355003357,
0.5480778813362122,
-0.1912710964679718,
-0.09543947130441666,
-0.4258469045162201,
-0.861823320388794,
-0.20346854627132416,
-0.08924508094787598,
0.1436527967453003,
-0.18603675067424774,
-0.24699667096138,
0.11637982726097107,
0.07728533446788788,
-0.5203654766082764,
0.12501446902751923,
-0.1857818216085434,
-0.5909439921379089,
0.6744409203529358,
0.048907212913036346,
0.3804388642311096,
-0.011482334695756435,
-0.5820032954216003,
0.010850333608686924,
-0.9286028742790222,
-0.07306375354528427,
0.7244046330451965,
-0.060758188366889954,
-0.056719619780778885,
0.505144476890564,
-0.08352116495370865,
0.3934939205646515,
0.27159610390663147,
-0.3687916696071625,
0.23193584382534027,
-0.06436117738485336,
-0.21690766513347626,
0.14938361942768097,
0.6991031169891357,
0.433718740940094,
0.08814966678619385,
-0.08966387808322906,
-0.11714669317007065,
0.46197113394737244,
0.41088199615478516,
-0.3666591942310333,
0.10871115326881409,
-0.08749023079872131,
-0.5712103843688965,
-0.7278786301612854,
0.5655970573425293,
-0.48805373907089233,
-0.8151167035102844,
-0.3217063248157501,
0.4864358901977539,
-0.1817285269498825,
-0.16256515681743622,
0.10266023874282837,
-0.31602102518081665,
0.39083608984947205,
0.5906944274902344,
-0.29298585653305054,
0.10575547814369202,
0.6152706146240234,
0.5861864686012268,
-0.31319311261177063,
-0.31590574979782104,
-0.44365960359573364,
0.30506205558776855,
-0.5926288366317749,
0.8147399425506592,
-0.3690852224826813,
0.20068025588989258,
-0.06205757334828377,
-0.2882872521877289,
0.06657040119171143,
-0.4432156980037689,
0.4840220510959625,
-0.6245507001876831,
0.2788849472999573,
-0.23355424404144287,
-0.5964997410774231,
-0.0052408492192626,
0.36080124974250793,
-0.3925386071205139,
1.082334041595459,
-0.18412412703037262,
-0.7928981781005859,
0.7525380253791809,
-0.4616934061050415,
-0.7149872183799744,
0.12405966222286224,
-0.3169458508491516,
-0.40913376212120056,
0.19151383638381958,
0.4040873348712921,
0.4077070653438568,
-0.033373910933732986,
0.17619740962982178,
-0.16590173542499542,
-0.10609232634305954,
0.6321221590042114,
-0.49915844202041626,
0.7282717823982239,
0.2180004119873047,
-0.5480014085769653,
-0.09129489213228226,
-0.6018762588500977,
-0.26772505044937134,
-0.08599112182855606,
-0.4634421169757843,
-0.4034583270549774,
0.033616192638874054,
-0.23807203769683838,
-0.05549328774213791,
0.08878958225250244,
-0.5396441221237183,
0.08998378366231918,
-0.2143801748752594,
0.19036726653575897,
0.8620191216468811,
0.20615659654140472,
0.30372634530067444,
-0.660638689994812,
0.41250985860824585,
0.2788294851779938,
-0.027306433767080307,
-0.07104884833097458,
-0.5448552370071411,
-0.7386236190795898,
-0.32855817675590515,
0.06659623235464096,
0.719637393951416,
-0.8172112703323364,
0.5991100072860718,
-0.10660349577665329,
-0.5952629446983337,
-0.8575918078422546,
0.41767048835754395,
0.3324609696865082,
0.47834914922714233,
0.2172069102525711,
-0.23833365738391876,
-0.4060627222061157,
-0.7469995617866516,
-0.9391628503799438,
-0.6128621101379395,
-0.31318196654319763,
0.10081323236227036,
0.35456180572509766,
-0.19711355865001678,
0.8939927220344543,
-0.3553379476070404,
-0.3092269003391266,
0.10581393539905548,
0.4118114709854126,
-0.121914803981781,
0.13907377421855927,
0.3840683400630951,
-0.8464604616165161,
-0.33022448420524597,
-0.18677711486816406,
-0.8315207958221436,
-0.15882548689842224,
-0.5396133065223694,
-0.10621725022792816,
0.44170403480529785,
0.6859469413757324,
-0.8944904804229736,
0.7956290245056152,
0.03575947880744934,
-0.5617876648902893,
0.5267959237098694,
0.2137916386127472,
0.3184551000595093,
-1.0170279741287231,
-0.053535137325525284,
0.346635103225708,
-0.46201395988464355,
-0.3495436906814575,
0.03384282812476158,
-0.1486920565366745,
0.38477298617362976,
-0.4368465840816498,
0.6554173827171326,
-0.5778603553771973,
0.06495150178670883,
0.050863116979599,
0.01776793599128723,
-0.05253520607948303,
-0.04701985418796539,
-0.08094559609889984,
0.5805625915527344,
0.4552704989910126,
-0.39181578159332275,
0.15903456509113312,
-0.0477612130343914,
-0.5957371592521667,
0.6310171484947205,
-0.24666745960712433,
0.21315813064575195,
-0.17664936184883118,
0.32074305415153503,
-0.9757496118545532,
-0.3145887851715088,
0.5547515153884888,
-0.7613100409507751,
0.2525698244571686,
0.28230786323547363,
-0.8362915515899658,
-0.25303131341934204,
-0.3845956027507782,
0.049230411648750305,
0.43425992131233215,
-0.3893886208534241,
0.7602179646492004,
0.18294863402843475,
0.01837550848722458,
-0.5027380585670471,
-0.845160722732544,
0.5893412828445435,
-0.5210563540458679,
-0.7233479619026184,
0.4768855571746826,
0.045534711331129074,
-0.7304902672767639,
0.05705074965953827,
-0.17121891677379608,
0.2591259479522705,
0.1605619192123413,
0.13375234603881836,
0.07918985933065414,
-0.2588423788547516,
0.008180590346455574,
0.07894067466259003,
0.03917548060417175,
0.17122146487236023,
-0.1345020979642868,
0.05548964813351631,
0.02909635379910469,
-0.33374759554862976,
-0.9449849128723145,
-0.0040183039382100105,
0.5602287650108337,
0.024728715419769287,
0.5920616984367371,
0.8657426238059998,
-0.4261530339717865,
-0.27540451288223267,
-0.8934565782546997,
-0.5921738743782043,
-0.4450453817844391,
0.1176031231880188,
0.08255771547555923,
-0.616108775138855,
0.4138495922088623,
-0.14639344811439514,
-0.1824105978012085,
0.42615047097206116,
0.6687300801277161,
-0.278065949678421,
0.7578050494194031,
0.48960113525390625,
-0.3917761445045471,
0.26009035110473633,
0.18549802899360657,
0.09136650711297989,
-0.5066994428634644,
-0.2045467048883438,
-0.24307496845722198,
-0.5014710426330566,
-0.26425448060035706,
-0.4321483075618744,
0.49016812443733215,
-0.1296648234128952,
-0.04969634488224983,
0.07518605887889862,
-0.46922120451927185,
0.5663544535636902,
0.8458348512649536,
0.3890080153942108,
0.4326172471046448,
0.277852326631546,
0.19533303380012512,
0.002118476899340749,
-0.2802109718322754,
-0.7042717933654785,
0.9795664548873901,
0.3991249203681946,
0.7806954979896545,
-0.05819728225469589,
0.8108153343200684,
1.0108048915863037,
0.5143151879310608,
-0.46405333280563354,
0.5965026617050171,
0.24299223721027374,
-0.721055805683136,
-0.23687362670898438,
-0.21006405353546143,
-0.6046707034111023,
-0.06065988540649414,
-0.3124627470970154,
-0.6561539769172668,
0.05278470367193222,
0.0942944660782814,
-0.2311224639415741,
0.44944998621940613,
-0.5066603422164917,
0.2084096223115921,
-0.4488723874092102,
-0.2597156763076782,
-0.27615419030189514,
-0.8946255445480347,
0.07948678731918335,
-0.07987578958272934,
0.31076309084892273,
-0.1423085629940033,
-0.3669080436229706,
0.6494099497795105,
-0.13620497286319733,
1.360080361366272,
-0.0655088946223259,
-0.17752516269683838,
0.3005240857601166,
0.25187447667121887,
0.5932115316390991,
0.36399850249290466,
-0.06297222524881363,
0.40767237544059753,
-0.5496174693107605,
-0.07614799588918686,
-0.13504216074943542,
0.27640029788017273,
-0.8464867472648621,
-0.8085088133811951,
-0.465171754360199,
-0.3401070833206177,
-0.028416195884346962,
0.22289948165416718,
0.6617783308029175,
-0.09404102712869644,
-0.053728263825178146,
-0.05892358347773552,
0.4884894788265228,
0.014997975900769234,
0.2926570773124695,
0.47597163915634155,
0.0962713360786438,
-0.33207955956459045,
0.754876971244812,
-0.13048842549324036,
-0.16148069500923157,
0.5382504463195801,
0.14923512935638428,
-0.13483507931232452,
-0.45990291237831116,
-0.49196314811706543,
0.2016746699810028,
-0.432983934879303,
-0.48467904329299927,
-0.22835518419742584,
-0.09860766679048538,
-0.5154430866241455,
-0.5915430188179016,
0.01736271008849144,
-0.17434635758399963,
-0.7522308230400085,
-0.3997047543525696,
0.22425997257232666,
0.5067818760871887,
-0.10716067999601364,
0.23138250410556793,
-0.37805551290512085,
0.5886443257331848,
0.11724422127008438,
-0.16530001163482666,
-0.23201365768909454,
-0.49139896035194397,
-0.03977544233202934,
0.2098677009344101,
-0.4592444896697998,
-0.8846149444580078,
0.31704336404800415,
0.19151346385478973,
0.4900915026664734,
0.9289301633834839,
0.1607111245393753,
0.4314333498477936,
-0.20522668957710266,
0.9689143896102905,
0.19592107832431793,
-0.9901921153068542,
0.5592325925827026,
-0.5641552805900574,
-0.2553841769695282,
0.38038599491119385,
0.3827458322048187,
-0.17056560516357422,
-0.908229649066925,
-0.5345179438591003,
-0.6257942914962769,
0.5196974873542786,
0.2761393189430237,
0.2330564558506012,
-0.007488338742405176,
0.514904797077179,
0.2852657735347748,
0.3508521616458893,
-1.0074105262756348,
-0.22816644608974457,
0.04949453845620155,
-0.1325678825378418,
0.10526017099618912,
-0.14185111224651337,
-0.3540019392967224,
-0.29696932435035706,
0.6982038617134094,
-0.20132780075073242,
0.2869262099266052,
0.48388344049453735,
-0.08629677444696426,
-0.3726906180381775,
-0.032822661101818085,
0.7909426093101501,
0.6528468132019043,
0.03171186149120331,
0.4174146056175232,
-0.005515205208212137,
-0.46864405274391174,
0.09268355369567871,
-0.14316555857658386,
-0.4875108301639557,
-0.016482923179864883,
0.7652796506881714,
0.6209606528282166,
-0.2816380560398102,
-0.42941373586654663,
0.49767276644706726,
0.27559882402420044,
-0.30815473198890686,
-0.46394190192222595,
0.17442896962165833,
0.13180385529994965,
0.30854305624961853,
0.8271773457527161,
0.4159519672393799,
-0.04579544812440872,
-0.5172820687294006,
0.1189945861697197,
0.3957826495170593,
-0.07724954932928085,
-0.5514923334121704,
0.8016490936279297,
0.18664824962615967,
-0.4391327500343323,
0.5082337260246277,
-0.25707459449768066,
-0.43647390604019165,
0.6709446310997009,
0.5313394665718079,
0.9078530669212341,
-0.11201182007789612,
0.4882022738456726,
-0.05101437121629715,
0.7325907349586487,
-0.16473965346813202,
0.0987139418721199,
0.002957153832539916,
-1.0867372751235962,
0.047323841601610184,
-0.5696433782577515,
-0.05696245655417442,
0.07210076600313187,
-0.543657124042511,
0.44369378685951233,
-0.30179086327552795,
-0.3166617751121521,
0.1296500265598297,
-0.14713628590106964,
-0.5724336504936218,
0.1692381203174591,
0.4722614288330078,
0.8340464234352112,
-1.0898915529251099,
0.4714585244655609,
0.8622930645942688,
-0.13098019361495972,
-0.4074772000312805,
0.5891381502151489,
0.6099206209182739,
-1.0426185131072998,
0.5259504914283752,
0.1941598653793335,
-0.1204942986369133,
0.005088150035589933,
-0.9138650298118591,
-0.5421381592750549,
1.1382873058319092,
0.6820979118347168,
-0.30458319187164307,
-0.19842243194580078,
0.38744276762008667,
0.5004115700721741,
-0.5277876257896423,
-0.17059966921806335,
0.13560308516025543,
0.7657025456428528,
-0.08063581585884094,
-0.5025257468223572,
0.20452286303043365,
-0.1334158182144165,
-0.3071349859237671,
0.02479609102010727,
-0.7639961242675781,
0.5797304511070251,
-0.32276371121406555,
-0.10464064031839371,
-0.017185287550091743,
0.5612158179283142,
0.23667556047439575,
0.9402670860290527,
0.41924968361854553,
0.7826394438743591,
0.9088910222053528,
0.15979520976543427,
0.949975848197937,
-0.13414089381694794,
-0.01562720164656639,
0.6681138873100281,
-0.35026195645332336,
0.647881031036377,
0.6834571361541748,
-0.15575391054153442,
0.6855429410934448,
0.6181551218032837,
-0.39188602566719055,
0.33968499302864075,
0.19670000672340393,
-0.3380005657672882,
-0.542424201965332,
-0.05642702057957649,
-0.22258152067661285,
0.42868196964263916,
0.40346455574035645,
-0.690760612487793,
0.056560762226581573,
-0.07074238359928131,
0.2825801968574524,
0.07283395528793335,
-0.4016396701335907,
0.8034791350364685,
0.27088817954063416,
-0.5580000877380371,
0.004824994597584009,
0.10413265228271484,
0.910977303981781,
-0.4062405228614807,
0.13715074956417084,
-0.2038615345954895,
0.06446389108896255,
-0.3678564429283142,
-0.5919914245605469,
0.19636349380016327,
0.039644092321395874,
-0.32120421528816223,
-0.3383621573448181,
1.0839006900787354,
-0.19891813397407532,
-0.7761695384979248,
0.0015229383716359735,
0.6556355953216553,
0.17064939439296722,
-0.21507097780704498,
-0.4481233060359955,
-0.022729163989424706,
0.041571132838726044,
-0.3828880786895752,
0.26675018668174744,
0.43456995487213135,
-0.12459386140108109,
0.5826677083969116,
0.7546404600143433,
0.3528708517551422,
0.03935026377439499,
-0.31383323669433594,
0.5058139562606812,
-0.42445218563079834,
-0.5023444890975952,
-1.1285574436187744,
0.3438865542411804,
-0.14258168637752533,
-0.5235201716423035,
0.9698557257652283,
0.6479464769363403,
0.8633226752281189,
-0.22186070680618286,
0.7866989970207214,
-0.027491575106978416,
0.42517149448394775,
-0.6592673063278198,
1.0442960262298584,
-0.7689881324768066,
0.28524163365364075,
-0.3626224994659424,
-0.7023298144340515,
-0.4380386471748352,
0.4355400502681732,
-0.09884405136108398,
0.011863112449645996,
0.41614240407943726,
0.854010820388794,
0.12332552671432495,
-0.36066538095474243,
0.14785964787006378,
0.21120800077915192,
0.1318398267030716,
0.0786316767334938,
0.9759625196456909,
-0.20090541243553162,
0.24540944397449493,
0.023914704099297523,
-0.09246997535228729,
-0.33237355947494507,
-1.0601714849472046,
-0.9249862432479858,
-0.5543288588523865,
-0.7445363998413086,
-0.36385732889175415,
-0.00932061392813921,
0.6386806964874268,
0.7757415771484375,
-0.4866792559623718,
0.11402174085378647,
-0.18589524924755096,
0.16574133932590485,
-0.3213714063167572,
-0.28958210349082947,
0.3342699110507965,
0.0164625346660614,
-0.3559591472148895,
0.25713884830474854,
0.2246307134628296,
-0.009072361513972282,
-0.22423522174358368,
-0.12531130015850067,
-0.01412175688892603,
0.4599837362766266,
0.39005887508392334,
0.10611792653799057,
-1.100340485572815,
-0.4187796115875244,
0.09113524854183197,
-0.15718550980091095,
0.01718832179903984,
0.781609833240509,
-0.8616728186607361,
0.15667137503623962,
0.35621246695518494,
0.6198558211326599,
0.22315895557403564,
0.26374074816703796,
0.3527534008026123,
-0.9818094968795776,
-0.07029370218515396,
0.2078380137681961,
0.11266450583934784,
0.3472393751144409,
-0.8809586763381958,
0.47847938537597656,
0.7266268730163574,
-0.3171154260635376,
-0.9707999229431152,
0.0644029974937439,
-0.8641234636306763,
-0.13524137437343597,
1.2259193658828735,
0.1305367350578308,
-0.11801871657371521,
-0.021202370524406433,
-0.021739885210990906,
0.05480390414595604,
-0.45883405208587646,
1.246949315071106,
0.663083553314209,
-0.27224916219711304,
-0.07698680460453033,
-0.07395610958337784,
0.6696316003799438,
0.1534416824579239,
-0.9385145306587219,
-0.2477542608976364,
0.4053451418876648,
0.3707149624824524,
0.3192427158355713,
0.6360018849372864,
-0.04133017361164093,
0.22933904826641083,
0.041474584490060806,
0.017277613282203674,
-0.13271324336528778,
-0.3796740472316742,
0.15036651492118835,
-0.06019968539476395,
-0.15514805912971497,
0.04653371870517731
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14005v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14005v2 | Information Guided Regularization for Fine-tuning Language Models | 2024-06-20T05:18:37 | 2024-06-21T12:41:17 | Mandar Sharma, Nikhil Muralidhar, Shengzhe Xu, Raquib Bin Yousuf, Naren Ramakrishnan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The pretraining-fine-tuning paradigm has been the de facto strategy for
transfer learning in modern language modeling. With the understanding that task
adaptation in LMs is often a function of parameters shared across tasks, we
argue that a more surgical approach to regularization needs to exist for
smoother transfer learning. Towards this end, we investigate how the
pretraining loss landscape is affected by these task-sensitive parameters
through an information-theoretic lens. We then leverage the findings from our
investigations to devise a novel approach to dropout for improved model
regularization and better downstream generalization. This approach, named
guided dropout, is both task & architecture agnostic and adds no computational
overhead to the fine-tuning process. Through empirical evaluations, we showcase
that our approach to regularization yields consistently better performance,
even in scenarios of data paucity, compared to standardized baselines. | [
-0.34660807251930237,
-0.7645449042320251,
0.30145344138145447,
-0.24041007459163666,
-0.15836432576179504,
-0.41013360023498535,
-0.6022331118583679,
-0.17903541028499603,
-0.20685836672782898,
0.4989525377750397,
-0.9403546452522278,
-0.574479877948761,
-0.7695804834365845,
-0.21500903367996216,
-0.37377437949180603,
1.2971735000610352,
-0.19272729754447937,
0.050736457109451294,
0.06618373841047287,
0.278592586517334,
-0.8726384043693542,
-0.13019698858261108,
-0.823781430721283,
-0.10915591567754745,
0.6454765200614929,
0.3246467113494873,
0.5075260400772095,
1.0410488843917847,
0.7483160495758057,
0.07411815226078033,
0.13118553161621094,
0.2343863695859909,
-0.7475243806838989,
-0.2130582332611084,
-0.21610383689403534,
-0.6957752704620361,
-0.17487245798110962,
0.06807555258274078,
0.6967570781707764,
1.3179116249084473,
-0.21537162363529205,
0.11987927556037903,
0.5484886169433594,
0.7945383787155151,
-0.8478790521621704,
0.11276344209909439,
-0.6103847026824951,
0.19242346286773682,
-0.2631623446941376,
-0.34546804428100586,
-0.4345294237136841,
-0.4052800238132477,
0.13714799284934998,
-1.086195707321167,
0.47187358140945435,
-0.1517723798751831,
1.0039995908737183,
0.715568482875824,
-0.059151750057935715,
-0.01721177250146866,
-1.1085429191589355,
0.7605241537094116,
-0.5371363162994385,
0.6459566950798035,
0.5387548804283142,
0.15837129950523376,
-0.19251251220703125,
-0.459282785654068,
0.11164764314889908,
-0.18585892021656036,
0.03817526251077652,
-0.11762680113315582,
0.02314852736890316,
0.4530084729194641,
0.23935218155384064,
0.17950646579265594,
-0.40759238600730896,
0.08886595815420151,
-0.5305548310279846,
-0.1321486085653305,
0.33672159910202026,
-0.025626402348279953,
0.10986931622028351,
0.5114145874977112,
-0.11412785202264786,
-0.015891743823885918,
-0.9103609323501587,
0.09346550703048706,
0.2357899397611618,
0.4596484899520874,
0.11337808519601822,
-0.15271124243736267,
-0.3521927297115326,
1.1091314554214478,
0.4754653871059418,
0.008298872970044613,
-0.29232582449913025,
-0.4017808139324188,
-0.26231634616851807,
-0.09668871760368347,
0.31100738048553467,
0.4108509123325348,
0.4469660520553589,
-0.17042405903339386,
-0.0073408093303442,
-0.21023845672607422,
0.40312710404396057,
-0.868979811668396,
-0.5638197064399719,
-0.25584304332733154,
-0.6908165216445923,
-0.13022679090499878,
-0.06562263518571854,
-0.2895258069038391,
-0.2858234941959381,
-0.5641250014305115,
0.4617327153682709,
-0.33177411556243896,
-0.15287189185619354,
0.4685767590999603,
0.19613473117351532,
0.0886024758219719,
0.5516060590744019,
-0.9599446654319763,
0.4422853887081146,
0.6448832154273987,
0.7200043201446533,
-0.35551050305366516,
-0.13455265760421753,
-0.8670681715011597,
0.35021159052848816,
-0.490291565656662,
0.44432875514030457,
-0.6101111769676208,
-0.16599293053150177,
0.0009344295249320567,
0.11000983417034149,
-0.39396968483924866,
-0.6494657397270203,
0.4537109136581421,
-0.37817150354385376,
0.16360853612422943,
-0.1798923760652542,
-0.5346150994300842,
-0.4376145601272583,
0.020730940625071526,
-0.38040679693222046,
0.9309141039848328,
0.0326664112508297,
-0.4548187255859375,
0.6617083549499512,
-0.5357934832572937,
-0.37413308024406433,
-0.1034032329916954,
-0.1110667884349823,
-0.13133317232131958,
0.35751721262931824,
-0.010828075930476189,
0.5704348683357239,
-0.2768021523952484,
0.40540972352027893,
-0.26322975754737854,
-0.58586585521698,
-0.35574954748153687,
-0.18940463662147522,
0.4346996545791626,
0.3302620053291321,
-0.1549646407365799,
0.009031194262206554,
-0.8352987170219421,
0.05966687947511673,
-0.26403796672821045,
-0.5396403074264526,
-0.6807295680046082,
0.053167782723903656,
0.08803322911262512,
-0.04192594066262245,
0.05375397205352783,
-0.33065658807754517,
0.43683353066444397,
-0.36937981843948364,
0.28534963726997375,
0.755275309085846,
-0.13655199110507965,
0.5983592867851257,
-0.2334030270576477,
0.33743566274642944,
0.04354140907526016,
0.49229469895362854,
0.153774693608284,
-0.08749096095561981,
-0.9521240592002869,
-0.30858951807022095,
0.6296144723892212,
0.538123369216919,
-0.42213404178619385,
0.3845963776111603,
-0.17286938428878784,
-0.3122073709964752,
-0.6875143051147461,
0.22170381247997284,
0.5011624097824097,
0.7232149243354797,
0.22484689950942993,
-0.5138880014419556,
-0.5304120182991028,
-0.9806732535362244,
-0.4602707028388977,
0.24764187633991241,
-0.017637401819229126,
0.2006162852048874,
-0.06434504687786102,
-0.2895433008670807,
0.7270722985267639,
-0.611060380935669,
-0.5933696627616882,
-0.021074721589684486,
0.017364950850605965,
0.2809794247150421,
0.8808299899101257,
0.43279018998146057,
-0.5075205564498901,
-0.45889681577682495,
0.17723193764686584,
-0.4731087386608124,
-0.09436748921871185,
-0.17407573759555817,
-0.2827739715576172,
-0.12944968044757843,
0.6345364451408386,
-0.4253646433353424,
0.5379605889320374,
0.4628572165966034,
-0.043848033994436264,
0.15647141635417938,
-0.3758030831813812,
0.08101607114076614,
-1.1011072397232056,
0.2565833330154419,
-0.018968231976032257,
-0.35892370343208313,
-0.9900604486465454,
-0.30575335025787354,
0.1546952873468399,
-0.009558380581438541,
-0.19679248332977295,
0.32162728905677795,
-0.574277937412262,
0.19205380976200104,
-0.21613630652427673,
-0.12724393606185913,
-0.04288037121295929,
0.4403487741947174,
0.015020978637039661,
0.6143941283226013,
0.8366569876670837,
-0.9990124702453613,
-0.05338073521852493,
0.1119685247540474,
-0.1484520137310028,
0.3417661190032959,
-0.4216669797897339,
0.18334898352622986,
-0.3097802698612213,
0.02247515507042408,
-0.7457632422447205,
-0.22614465653896332,
0.27475300431251526,
-0.17678363621234894,
0.6104923486709595,
-0.4546375870704651,
-0.07114996761083603,
0.2007574886083603,
-0.19888697564601898,
0.45360979437828064,
0.4790838360786438,
-0.28282299637794495,
0.41768762469291687,
0.1643315851688385,
-0.27921539545059204,
-0.50267493724823,
-0.6244194507598877,
-0.29585927724838257,
-0.1598348468542099,
-0.4282926023006439,
0.4820321798324585,
-0.3746335506439209,
0.07074948400259018,
-0.013250010088086128,
-0.25351014733314514,
-0.43716922402381897,
0.39145520329475403,
0.1543814092874527,
0.03031165525317192,
-0.2512517273426056,
0.24372245371341705,
0.2699260711669922,
-0.028270220384001732,
-0.2636246681213379,
-0.3727349042892456,
0.3942664563655853,
0.2214667797088623,
-0.26020753383636475,
-0.9331119656562805,
0.24528810381889343,
-0.03504281863570213,
-0.16820216178894043,
0.6425036787986755,
0.719950258731842,
-0.43404513597488403,
-0.26373034715652466,
-0.6177420616149902,
-0.5691178441047668,
-0.4499557912349701,
0.630776047706604,
-0.3708933889865875,
-0.8943910598754883,
0.3716484606266022,
-0.42731767892837524,
0.05399255082011223,
0.2320965677499771,
0.17823216319084167,
-0.05644516274333,
0.99461829662323,
1.4044231176376343,
-0.13521096110343933,
0.9453651309013367,
-0.19930139183998108,
0.2726825177669525,
-0.5343586802482605,
-0.023403221741318703,
-0.4215587079524994,
-0.24953517317771912,
-0.35583001375198364,
-0.23004862666130066,
0.09180181473493576,
0.674042284488678,
0.055886104702949524,
0.1283746063709259,
-0.3988974988460541,
0.4891442358493805,
0.5847887992858887,
0.1165030226111412,
0.21202075481414795,
-0.018941126763820648,
0.2605064809322357,
-0.1991765946149826,
-0.8423866033554077,
-0.20089015364646912,
0.994137167930603,
0.21842637658119202,
0.8481276035308838,
-0.2615041136741638,
0.6768982410430908,
0.39387714862823486,
0.18958184123039246,
-0.7050463557243347,
0.240760937333107,
-0.2977270185947418,
-0.2315870225429535,
-0.2983829379081726,
-0.38384953141212463,
-1.052733063697815,
-0.12389335036277771,
-0.18668635189533234,
-0.5337406992912292,
0.36168402433395386,
0.5403904318809509,
-0.6505411863327026,
0.03223706781864166,
-0.7421300411224365,
0.8702660202980042,
0.16889502108097076,
-0.19942404329776764,
-0.2832289934158325,
-0.6668924689292908,
-0.00004416360752657056,
-0.23319049179553986,
0.35942038893699646,
-0.11666107922792435,
-0.17137251794338226,
0.7742239236831665,
-0.3017973005771637,
0.9061657190322876,
-0.42813730239868164,
-0.05916299298405647,
-0.14182405173778534,
0.32140210270881653,
0.7097949385643005,
-0.23896482586860657,
0.002884221961721778,
0.0640445202589035,
-0.02046665921807289,
-0.38634055852890015,
-0.8945714235305786,
0.7130274176597595,
-0.5834254622459412,
-0.5489346385002136,
0.2124568074941635,
-0.8720295429229736,
-0.4521360993385315,
0.36826515197753906,
0.22953104972839355,
0.4574424922466278,
0.07380494475364685,
0.19486922025680542,
0.9271243214607239,
0.10504009574651718,
0.2652958035469055,
0.49717244505882263,
0.20081986486911774,
-0.04785963147878647,
0.7981972694396973,
0.22487559914588928,
0.2743885815143585,
0.3198913633823395,
0.11000700294971466,
0.02111157402396202,
-1.096178412437439,
-0.3388878405094147,
0.22850771248340607,
-0.6402419209480286,
-0.021249951794743538,
-0.20490233600139618,
-0.1415899693965912,
-0.4164670407772064,
-0.126192107796669,
-0.5385988354682922,
-0.2040034830570221,
-0.5919926762580872,
-0.05118919163942337,
0.17625389993190765,
0.8904920816421509,
0.00488171586766839,
0.40242546796798706,
-0.910101592540741,
-0.009885153733193874,
0.01036805845797062,
0.547212541103363,
-0.37112757563591003,
-0.8345059156417847,
-0.6285042762756348,
0.007506539113819599,
-0.09063508361577988,
-0.7071365714073181,
0.14444662630558014,
0.7423797249794006,
0.683205783367157,
0.6001712679862976,
0.10208567976951599,
1.006609320640564,
-0.5854607224464417,
0.5033808350563049,
0.24909868836402893,
-0.9435842037200928,
0.7222492694854736,
-0.4192602038383484,
0.1220327839255333,
0.7156715393066406,
0.3628738224506378,
-0.5734587907791138,
-0.17674224078655243,
-0.1863459199666977,
-0.6327365636825562,
0.8639852404594421,
-0.19163423776626587,
0.05174656957387924,
0.36391568183898926,
0.7931631803512573,
0.3785533308982849,
0.30028343200683594,
-0.4912443459033966,
-0.2191903442144394,
0.26408424973487854,
-0.4227951467037201,
-0.14495258033275604,
-0.052298929542303085,
-0.13232147693634033,
-0.2660157084465027,
0.5223238468170166,
-0.16729426383972168,
-0.19835452735424042,
0.13033068180084229,
-0.3488245904445648,
-0.19720838963985443,
0.04435780271887779,
0.67194002866745,
0.7164987325668335,
-0.04551096633076668,
-0.006525897420942783,
0.09888554364442825,
-0.47704434394836426,
-0.1777317374944687,
0.12204428017139435,
-0.41434594988822937,
-0.04265129193663597,
0.2542862892150879,
1.0870952606201172,
0.17061220109462738,
-0.396395742893219,
0.4751594364643097,
0.056859519332647324,
-0.3744814395904541,
0.24953389167785645,
0.2141122817993164,
-0.34396010637283325,
0.17052824795246124,
0.3087787330150604,
0.5093469619750977,
0.5281181931495667,
-0.2643554210662842,
0.14032164216041565,
0.3865825831890106,
-0.7664731740951538,
-0.4347965121269226,
0.4643707573413849,
0.24229644238948822,
-0.22493666410446167,
0.16047708690166473,
0.22894087433815002,
0.013707307167351246,
0.3052486479282379,
0.27215176820755005,
0.8673474192619324,
-0.44210755825042725,
0.009972779080271721,
0.21285295486450195,
0.3197466731071472,
-0.3417540490627289,
0.1176348403096199,
-0.2137656956911087,
-0.3090706169605255,
-0.6822925209999084,
-0.47875240445137024,
0.009993971325457096,
0.23275217413902283,
-0.9056413173675537,
0.2705191671848297,
-0.6222338080406189,
-0.13902363181114197,
-0.21585983037948608,
-0.2396547943353653,
-0.6956561803817749,
0.3538755178451538,
0.1478843241930008,
0.7169801592826843,
-0.7910239100456238,
0.8236370086669922,
0.6853360533714294,
-0.15209314227104187,
-0.8664315938949585,
0.17320877313613892,
-0.3596595525741577,
-0.5646474957466125,
0.793304443359375,
0.10008343309164047,
-0.2158898562192917,
0.23538413643836975,
-0.5009520053863525,
-1.2147303819656372,
0.7576542496681213,
0.936340868473053,
-0.8044140934944153,
-0.27600210905075073,
-0.06012594327330589,
0.3117923140525818,
-0.31011179089546204,
-0.08299513906240463,
0.567899763584137,
0.37546220421791077,
-0.2287232130765915,
-1.2486478090286255,
0.03669549897313118,
0.04676080495119095,
0.3055388629436493,
0.43334126472473145,
-0.5165435671806335,
0.803546130657196,
-0.19219906628131866,
-0.34080713987350464,
-0.15546219050884247,
0.31466996669769287,
-0.43230727314949036,
0.12481137365102768,
0.3776405155658722,
0.47165319323539734,
0.776707649230957,
-0.07929908484220505,
0.9771507978439331,
-0.5093855261802673,
0.37688133120536804,
1.0277150869369507,
0.16835293173789978,
0.734912097454071,
0.6652166247367859,
0.037109628319740295,
0.07280686497688293,
0.9768679738044739,
0.3210272490978241,
0.8469880819320679,
0.410137802362442,
0.09098012745380402,
-0.4178864657878876,
-0.33687829971313477,
-0.3548966646194458,
0.23203572630882263,
0.09934426099061966,
-0.37076765298843384,
-0.21060408651828766,
0.18537786602973938,
-0.03395923972129822,
0.06144028156995773,
-0.6955378651618958,
0.8879749178886414,
-0.06638326495885849,
-0.7303518056869507,
1.0450242757797241,
-0.16534461081027985,
0.6141199469566345,
-0.5717086791992188,
-0.18720977008342743,
-0.25174015760421753,
0.33035317063331604,
-0.34975194931030273,
-0.16961345076560974,
0.30887550115585327,
-0.3526005744934082,
-0.4346851110458374,
-0.4078752100467682,
0.7078295946121216,
-0.6994483470916748,
-0.17752490937709808,
0.2896225154399872,
0.5062693953514099,
0.26690927147865295,
-0.16425161063671112,
-0.573556125164032,
0.1302613914012909,
0.1466609537601471,
-0.223915234208107,
0.5011377930641174,
0.14432494342327118,
-0.1321486532688141,
0.6767315864562988,
0.6472792029380798,
0.34912121295928955,
0.36032652854919434,
0.26818880438804626,
0.9628680944442749,
-0.47488710284233093,
-0.45291393995285034,
-0.7656337022781372,
0.23945219814777374,
0.17269346117973328,
-0.2860638499259949,
0.6541044116020203,
0.4567185640335083,
1.050569772720337,
-0.3372962176799774,
0.7835596799850464,
0.3356861174106598,
0.6249391436576843,
-0.7490217685699463,
0.6554518938064575,
-0.7770465016365051,
0.1257079690694809,
-0.13772881031036377,
-0.942601203918457,
-0.4677519202232361,
0.41892170906066895,
-0.3478640019893646,
0.16411654651165009,
0.5546441078186035,
0.8916292190551758,
-0.24553024768829346,
-0.43629559874534607,
0.5137013792991638,
-0.013205424882471561,
-0.005778515711426735,
0.6139640808105469,
0.5640671849250793,
-0.4914849102497101,
0.6364311575889587,
-0.11179405450820923,
-0.3144020736217499,
-0.4022662937641144,
-0.6995760798454285,
-0.8474169969558716,
-0.6004634499549866,
-0.562169075012207,
0.08608418703079224,
0.5947335958480835,
0.6353062987327576,
1.3175034523010254,
-0.7209810018539429,
-0.27045583724975586,
-0.3153752386569977,
-0.1851128339767456,
-0.19857293367385864,
-0.13427938520908356,
0.30842629075050354,
-0.620708703994751,
-0.7051152586936951,
0.3852784335613251,
0.2659260034561157,
-0.0005412900354713202,
0.04360346868634224,
-0.11080166697502136,
-0.00018318348156753927,
-0.05800998583436012,
0.20903143286705017,
0.16259829699993134,
-0.6678555607795715,
-0.315283864736557,
-0.16399860382080078,
0.10800603032112122,
0.08302535861730576,
1.0057768821716309,
-0.4596717655658722,
0.4180257022380829,
0.24904902279376984,
1.0130037069320679,
0.4651625156402588,
0.08740422874689102,
0.7573051452636719,
-0.8924130797386169,
0.2791866362094879,
0.13601237535476685,
-0.04426717385649681,
0.23457135260105133,
-0.5722346305847168,
0.4349517524242401,
0.338950514793396,
-0.37943387031555176,
-0.8837003111839294,
0.35446813702583313,
-0.7704810500144958,
-0.11866951733827591,
1.0056182146072388,
-0.21136151254177094,
-0.321846604347229,
-0.21038420498371124,
-0.26949959993362427,
0.4614925980567932,
-0.36007773876190186,
0.6199861764907837,
0.6246457099914551,
-0.12085016816854477,
-0.32803094387054443,
-0.5685800909996033,
1.0934927463531494,
0.6349393725395203,
-0.8933494687080383,
0.2171187847852707,
0.5551655292510986,
0.5980113744735718,
-0.0327395498752594,
0.5623692274093628,
0.3676590323448181,
0.3405129909515381,
-0.3863242566585541,
0.30788445472717285,
-0.13265733420848846,
-0.507459819316864,
-0.614772379398346,
-0.10102037340402603,
0.348151832818985,
-0.47172462940216064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13997v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13997v1 | "Global is Good, Local is Bad?": Understanding Brand Bias in LLMs | 2024-06-20T04:52:19 | 2024-06-20T04:52:19 | Mahammed Kamruzzaman, Hieu Minh Nguyen, Gene Louis Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CE | Many recent studies have investigated social biases in LLMs but brand bias
has received little attention. This research examines the biases exhibited by
LLMs towards different brands, a significant concern given the widespread use
of LLMs in affected use cases such as product recommendation and market
analysis. Biased models may perpetuate societal inequalities, unfairly favoring
established global brands while marginalizing local ones. Using a curated
dataset across four brand categories, we probe the behavior of LLMs in this
space. We find a consistent pattern of bias in this space -- both in terms of
disproportionately associating global brands with positive attributes and
disproportionately recommending luxury gifts for individuals in high-income
countries. We also find LLMs are subject to country-of-origin effects which may
boost local brand preference in LLM outputs in specific contexts. | [
-0.2830943763256073,
-0.6345656514167786,
0.281543105840683,
-0.05089826136827469,
-0.22734509408473969,
0.37607115507125854,
0.004839399363845587,
-0.8195022344589233,
0.6734742522239685,
0.5380353331565857,
-0.5735201835632324,
-0.3879852294921875,
-0.6874105930328369,
-0.05123019963502884,
0.2254939079284668,
1.1707843542099,
-0.2560572922229767,
0.5884740352630615,
-0.48933935165405273,
-0.5226966142654419,
-0.33383867144584656,
-0.7884860038757324,
-0.49626418948173523,
-0.5784965753555298,
0.5257393717765808,
0.45035412907600403,
0.8147327303886414,
-0.12944446504116058,
0.5512459874153137,
0.20336507260799408,
-0.1490863859653473,
0.198469340801239,
-0.903716504573822,
0.3040853440761566,
-0.1554166078567505,
-0.5894420742988586,
-0.5407291650772095,
0.09283269196748734,
0.11752401292324066,
0.4168635904788971,
0.2528423070907593,
0.7396632432937622,
0.18994136154651642,
0.529218316078186,
-0.6360708475112915,
-0.15207594633102417,
-0.594613254070282,
-0.12535887956619263,
-0.3701344132423401,
0.033574484288692474,
-0.0048579559661448,
-0.678598940372467,
0.14662161469459534,
-0.5240839719772339,
0.40411797165870667,
0.14548702538013458,
0.9616222977638245,
0.05258236825466156,
-0.7399578094482422,
-0.6212605834007263,
-0.8084138631820679,
1.0539484024047852,
-0.3594244718551636,
0.14944759011268616,
0.4378992021083832,
0.1722334325313568,
-0.20625822246074677,
-0.17108456790447235,
-0.005553200840950012,
0.1389356106519699,
-0.07472371309995651,
0.1534416228532791,
-0.15580327808856964,
-0.3918343782424927,
-0.13582101464271545,
0.4518726170063019,
-0.18077167868614197,
0.07369396090507507,
-0.46904289722442627,
-0.09976252913475037,
0.6540214419364929,
-0.1370336264371872,
0.6243565082550049,
-0.09922987967729568,
-0.6872290968894958,
0.688541054725647,
-1.4523850679397583,
0.2556893825531006,
0.49247241020202637,
0.2598261833190918,
-0.13511674106121063,
0.31284773349761963,
-0.21831603348255157,
0.4000265598297119,
-0.03882601857185364,
0.06042605638504028,
0.16823522746562958,
-0.39889103174209595,
-0.19915124773979187,
0.3973313570022583,
0.23346513509750366,
1.014460802078247,
0.7313401103019714,
-0.028960024937987328,
-0.17576570808887482,
-0.0192050039768219,
0.062389977276325226,
-0.6460545659065247,
0.47418448328971863,
-0.1286379098892212,
-0.6121336221694946,
-0.3195507824420929,
0.1533740907907486,
-0.3172316551208496,
-0.6429936289787292,
-0.30180656909942627,
0.337428480386734,
0.861395001411438,
-0.12360688298940659,
0.19956770539283752,
-0.17608505487442017,
0.155986487865448,
-0.26019179821014404,
-0.7067521810531616,
0.21357212960720062,
0.40412354469299316,
0.6976553201675415,
-0.4002600312232971,
0.30928272008895874,
-0.25592103600502014,
0.2408541738986969,
-0.2772854268550873,
0.9409345388412476,
-0.4188779294490814,
-0.7198359370231628,
0.08666954934597015,
0.31200939416885376,
0.5265443921089172,
-1.2674272060394287,
0.672365128993988,
-0.6774170398712158,
-0.1812557876110077,
-1.19950532913208,
-0.0670643150806427,
0.24613621830940247,
0.08169806748628616,
-0.36952507495880127,
0.7946743965148926,
-0.027018234133720398,
-0.6413285732269287,
1.0750221014022827,
-0.19540344178676605,
-0.4604915380477905,
-0.09978988766670227,
-0.05731632187962532,
-0.28530067205429077,
0.41650789976119995,
0.41139915585517883,
0.5846593379974365,
-0.3287295699119568,
0.2622336149215698,
-0.9070450663566589,
-0.7018216848373413,
0.2794194519519806,
-0.27059319615364075,
0.6444934606552124,
0.3572565019130707,
-0.2632885277271271,
-0.14948414266109467,
-0.3124472200870514,
-0.7267147302627563,
0.29782992601394653,
-0.18577338755130768,
-0.9192941188812256,
-0.03445635735988617,
-0.20549778640270233,
0.3650965094566345,
0.3501896858215332,
-0.5500994324684143,
0.41223564743995667,
-0.1321442574262619,
0.4331425726413727,
1.144581913948059,
0.3740670084953308,
0.6786586046218872,
-0.540380597114563,
0.4866442084312439,
0.09314476698637009,
0.5102466940879822,
0.4597063660621643,
-0.27141517400741577,
-0.8085030317306519,
0.14926733076572418,
-0.19211335480213165,
0.030077943578362465,
-0.5025837421417236,
-0.21783354878425598,
-0.14167146384716034,
-0.14307382702827454,
-0.13191185891628265,
0.1948489248752594,
0.08682218194007874,
0.14250589907169342,
-0.02445271611213684,
-0.34198421239852905,
-0.19568198919296265,
-1.3248473405838013,
-0.7179601788520813,
0.4002869427204132,
-0.15056870877742767,
0.579199492931366,
0.3616946041584015,
-0.2574065625667572,
0.9545703530311584,
-0.5407196879386902,
-0.6513558626174927,
-0.07583102583885193,
-0.3105543851852417,
0.4661805033683777,
0.0005444155540317297,
0.4210338890552521,
-0.4195493161678314,
-0.37692177295684814,
-0.1544482260942459,
-0.4802539050579071,
-0.38197222352027893,
0.058750052005052567,
-0.22907790541648865,
0.12899580597877502,
0.2759473919868469,
-0.21495819091796875,
0.21952202916145325,
0.42602530121803284,
-0.6000452637672424,
0.47793883085250854,
0.07415139675140381,
0.12741415202617645,
-1.0086544752120972,
-0.4661145508289337,
0.6842162013053894,
0.1896691918373108,
-0.20838913321495056,
-0.21292804181575775,
-0.3136412501335144,
0.4878348112106323,
-0.713350236415863,
0.8665316104888916,
-0.49178841710090637,
-0.3547215759754181,
0.010262439958751202,
-0.06868128478527069,
0.3957778811454773,
-0.06754089891910553,
-0.09169469773769379,
0.7918390035629272,
0.3840336203575134,
-0.7334015965461731,
0.14274638891220093,
-0.0939042940735817,
-0.7287900447845459,
0.8947831988334656,
-0.6000813841819763,
-0.08610771596431732,
-0.1445118635892868,
0.52023845911026,
-0.8180705308914185,
-0.08122599124908447,
0.30369439721107483,
-0.20506063103675842,
0.07900042831897736,
-0.18940424919128418,
-0.43241268396377563,
-0.4111306667327881,
-0.19873809814453125,
0.6153419613838196,
0.3439858555793762,
-0.8637139201164246,
0.12611588835716248,
0.5622188448905945,
-0.019570961594581604,
-0.5422917604446411,
-0.7769820690155029,
-0.13962750136852264,
-0.6475657224655151,
-0.7111256718635559,
0.23332075774669647,
-0.013265770860016346,
-0.9932284951210022,
-0.45451316237449646,
-0.6494064927101135,
0.239175483584404,
-0.07452069222927094,
0.2648230195045471,
0.017738929018378258,
-0.03364291042089462,
-0.181623637676239,
-0.20904310047626495,
0.011846167966723442,
0.254721075296402,
-0.2078249603509903,
0.14438968896865845,
-0.12107045948505402,
-0.25509268045425415,
-0.01772875338792801,
0.10735722631216049,
0.326597660779953,
0.15780358016490936,
0.16239355504512787,
0.3146846294403076,
-0.23015981912612915,
-0.48354262113571167,
-0.5782638192176819,
-0.3165264129638672,
-0.594211220741272,
-0.003742263186722994,
-0.2139630913734436,
-0.7609595656394958,
0.642595112323761,
0.133026584982872,
-0.22715912759304047,
0.12313362956047058,
0.7189672589302063,
-0.2723696231842041,
0.7883284091949463,
0.5098869800567627,
-0.5219557881355286,
0.1476595401763916,
-0.4114668071269989,
0.4850080609321594,
-0.5446126461029053,
-0.20613783597946167,
-0.36029061675071716,
-0.779000461101532,
-0.605147659778595,
-0.37686774134635925,
0.20605671405792236,
0.14657917618751526,
-0.45508521795272827,
-0.2411046028137207,
-0.6100625991821289,
1.0453484058380127,
0.6050840616226196,
-0.03311110660433769,
0.30896684527397156,
0.25763294100761414,
-0.22749657928943634,
-0.28160038590431213,
-0.5750401616096497,
-0.6086914539337158,
0.8791678547859192,
0.2578197717666626,
1.2301924228668213,
0.01013574656099081,
0.29388484358787537,
0.4930431842803955,
0.6164636611938477,
-0.61968994140625,
0.21036258339881897,
-0.2619505226612091,
-0.793224036693573,
0.49888888001441956,
0.11866522580385208,
-1.1343295574188232,
-0.003980820998549461,
0.12343854457139969,
-0.849781334400177,
0.556907057762146,
0.2341417819261551,
-0.31174182891845703,
0.6093339920043945,
-0.5609665513038635,
0.46212154626846313,
-0.4816817045211792,
-0.9689390659332275,
0.20412425696849823,
-0.28886285424232483,
0.5831239819526672,
0.19912409782409668,
0.5942413806915283,
-0.6519836187362671,
0.3082745373249054,
0.5855545401573181,
0.13356032967567444,
0.9014332890510559,
-0.14497706294059753,
-0.5133930444717407,
0.24600885808467865,
0.1172768771648407,
0.44388729333877563,
0.28661349415779114,
-0.1191374659538269,
0.5815505385398865,
-0.3434132933616638,
-0.6640766263008118,
-0.2876119017601013,
1.121500015258789,
-0.8297572135925293,
-0.44526734948158264,
-0.5024847388267517,
-0.23039408028125763,
-0.4019095003604889,
-0.06919948756694794,
0.4861443340778351,
0.3970799744129181,
-0.45958101749420166,
-0.17808638513088226,
0.6141647696495056,
-0.5148473381996155,
0.1891055405139923,
0.3133012652397156,
-0.16919690370559692,
-0.24599629640579224,
1.0044916868209839,
0.3680620789527893,
0.5318318605422974,
0.12406206876039505,
0.3254629671573639,
-0.4272662103176117,
-0.09305649250745773,
-0.2227274775505066,
0.11745883524417877,
-0.9280598759651184,
-0.02329454943537712,
0.16359955072402954,
0.23837989568710327,
-0.25711750984191895,
-0.604733407497406,
-0.13442739844322205,
-0.16664227843284607,
-0.20433177053928375,
-0.3223225772380829,
0.017488913610577583,
1.2975958585739136,
0.15913447737693787,
0.32117313146591187,
-0.21778729557991028,
0.29325738549232483,
0.33275437355041504,
0.46790850162506104,
-0.2544301152229309,
-0.36520910263061523,
-0.34236225485801697,
-0.14042198657989502,
-0.5194720029830933,
-0.43633970618247986,
0.14234311878681183,
-0.43863970041275024,
0.6223978996276855,
0.9118659496307373,
0.08984582126140594,
0.14789879322052002,
-0.11395757645368576,
1.1728719472885132,
0.019023403525352478,
-0.4964572489261627,
0.12263380736112595,
-0.724176287651062,
0.6349766254425049,
0.32498034834861755,
0.5465934872627258,
-0.6718778610229492,
-0.6273034811019897,
-0.5886683464050293,
-0.9409605860710144,
0.28389474749565125,
-0.23320816457271576,
0.5031126737594604,
-0.20590637624263763,
0.27175644040107727,
0.2832008898258209,
0.4123591482639313,
-1.1299397945404053,
-0.8717921376228333,
0.06949567049741745,
0.4814120829105377,
-0.34717270731925964,
-0.6211837530136108,
-0.21214331686496735,
-0.15039445459842682,
0.6958262324333191,
0.16278229653835297,
0.2819814682006836,
0.08591067790985107,
-0.08067011088132858,
-0.22103768587112427,
0.2529929280281067,
0.6951930522918701,
0.8237115144729614,
-0.5097238421440125,
0.1999896913766861,
0.25188547372817993,
-0.10086184740066528,
0.3150562047958374,
-0.629341185092926,
-0.2812008559703827,
-0.019948652014136314,
-0.17238207161426544,
0.4637626111507416,
0.13554464280605316,
-0.0019884640350937843,
0.2671424150466919,
-0.027885209769010544,
-0.13947694003582,
-0.09845463931560516,
-0.17559030652046204,
0.2636059522628784,
-0.04455766826868057,
0.42378783226013184,
0.2222064882516861,
0.17210142314434052,
-0.5674707889556885,
-0.013556658290326595,
0.8353524208068848,
-0.5212454199790955,
-0.26494100689888,
0.6764587163925171,
0.7469147443771362,
-0.19242160022258759,
0.22583197057247162,
-0.0912148654460907,
-0.3642756938934326,
0.6979033946990967,
0.4984790086746216,
0.75725919008255,
0.0326349139213562,
0.21071091294288635,
0.31869199872016907,
0.43659108877182007,
0.28087118268013,
0.1335751712322235,
-0.06335019320249557,
-1.2234760522842407,
-0.07632669806480408,
-0.7063552141189575,
-0.4404442608356476,
0.13674990832805634,
-0.5514620542526245,
0.3243595361709595,
-0.2842140197753906,
-0.4953257143497467,
-0.44403815269470215,
-0.012265749275684357,
-0.8825743794441223,
0.17222246527671814,
0.3707942068576813,
0.5608004331588745,
-0.9235919713973999,
0.7862963676452637,
0.38295355439186096,
-0.18766197562217712,
-0.2742103636264801,
0.10971950739622116,
0.31770655512809753,
-1.095381259918213,
0.9542377591133118,
0.3271518647670746,
-0.3038131296634674,
-0.6519478559494019,
-0.31103116273880005,
-1.0775692462921143,
0.7986660599708557,
0.1681409329175949,
-0.40573549270629883,
0.10747895389795303,
0.41596657037734985,
0.042661406099796295,
-0.2477826178073883,
0.17451199889183044,
0.8025036454200745,
0.44840437173843384,
-0.027006298303604126,
-0.552224338054657,
-0.13639824092388153,
-0.07990309596061707,
0.00042059263796545565,
0.04282573610544205,
-1.0475572347640991,
0.28109848499298096,
-0.22865940630435944,
0.05607539787888527,
-0.322817862033844,
0.016257261857390404,
0.32898634672164917,
0.4289878308773041,
0.09868810325860977,
0.28572794795036316,
0.6190598011016846,
-0.20934203267097473,
0.99765545129776,
-0.21791113913059235,
0.17323683202266693,
1.0178718566894531,
-0.5544549822807312,
0.4115527272224426,
0.6063847541809082,
-0.11584413796663284,
0.39848655462265015,
1.121103286743164,
-0.14654523134231567,
0.5799557566642761,
0.8925496339797974,
-0.42015087604522705,
0.013329153880476952,
-0.32768115401268005,
-0.49861931800842285,
0.2347058206796646,
0.25757524371147156,
-0.2941397428512573,
-0.3370916545391083,
-0.30183446407318115,
0.18536604940891266,
-0.2734929323196411,
-0.552651584148407,
0.3968397080898285,
0.421170175075531,
-0.4228457808494568,
0.4613935649394989,
-0.11955808103084564,
1.2673510313034058,
-0.6537243127822876,
0.5527887940406799,
-0.6518152952194214,
0.3851633667945862,
-0.46089017391204834,
-0.3991321921348572,
0.35993918776512146,
-0.25432515144348145,
-0.2974988520145416,
-0.5813884139060974,
1.0185474157333374,
0.04049031063914299,
-0.5837713479995728,
0.3689108192920685,
0.5576104521751404,
0.08980557322502136,
0.02812936156988144,
-0.7277435064315796,
0.15419766306877136,
-0.025464331731200218,
-0.5081024169921875,
0.3970959186553955,
-0.05228704959154129,
-0.12181923538446426,
0.7484216690063477,
0.42605140805244446,
0.1881169080734253,
0.052761681377887726,
0.28638261556625366,
0.11745047569274902,
-0.47001081705093384,
-0.16981905698776245,
-0.8964041471481323,
0.4079427123069763,
-0.16594545543193817,
-0.5709101557731628,
1.38273286819458,
0.6086992025375366,
1.2314642667770386,
0.0879499763250351,
0.8251329064369202,
0.6584885120391846,
-0.015108730643987656,
-0.21242135763168335,
0.8795391917228699,
-0.683194637298584,
0.5874261856079102,
-0.1957469880580902,
-1.057221531867981,
-0.31768283247947693,
0.5362940430641174,
-0.6931273341178894,
0.2409992665052414,
0.2779296338558197,
0.8198140263557434,
-0.04217544570565224,
0.023130187764763832,
0.11506488919258118,
0.15235114097595215,
0.18977101147174835,
0.12878423929214478,
1.1736193895339966,
0.1144666001200676,
0.1277078539133072,
-0.040352169424295425,
0.17168691754341125,
-0.13915736973285675,
-0.9630493521690369,
-0.5635131001472473,
0.05133586376905441,
-0.31568706035614014,
-0.48099467158317566,
0.14292679727077484,
0.986413836479187,
0.7561752796173096,
-0.7221581339836121,
-0.5457748770713806,
0.2773641049861908,
0.6709790229797363,
0.1285991370677948,
-0.3019299805164337,
-0.03490350395441055,
-0.3409869372844696,
-0.6822106838226318,
0.10105589777231216,
0.31305748224258423,
0.1396336406469345,
-0.3798213005065918,
-0.00839305017143488,
0.33841472864151,
0.40459153056144714,
0.7701036334037781,
-0.2603623867034912,
-0.9300529360771179,
-0.014237795025110245,
-0.1170169785618782,
-0.07247818261384964,
0.44022491574287415,
0.9375560283660889,
-0.5937085151672363,
0.3662557005882263,
0.12817946076393127,
0.03846396505832672,
0.34741172194480896,
-0.1921873241662979,
0.8075812458992004,
-0.7518054842948914,
-0.33283182978630066,
-0.04668388143181801,
0.5670445561408997,
0.41832074522972107,
-0.37784045934677124,
0.21914519369602203,
0.3898877203464508,
-0.9694147706031799,
-0.6557247042655945,
0.44286778569221497,
-0.5772076845169067,
-0.4557155966758728,
1.6515778303146362,
0.4315558969974518,
0.018925460055470467,
-0.09397298842668533,
-0.2885241210460663,
-0.17953673005104065,
-0.48617053031921387,
0.8025506734848022,
0.830635130405426,
-0.0992438793182373,
0.7805159091949463,
-0.803038477897644,
0.5801946520805359,
0.1967390775680542,
-0.37926560640335083,
-0.07429175078868866,
0.47313493490219116,
0.8501967787742615,
-0.14082801342010498,
0.774711549282074,
0.056122150272130966,
-0.16557441651821136,
-0.49963560700416565,
0.008501974865794182,
0.379898339509964,
-0.11591882258653641,
-0.29968342185020447,
0.0077120354399085045,
0.3014398515224457,
-0.08430749922990799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13993v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13993v1 | Exploring Changes in Nation Perception with Nationality-Assigned Personas in LLMs | 2024-06-20T04:44:20 | 2024-06-20T04:44:20 | Mahammed Kamruzzaman, Gene Louis Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Persona assignment has become a common strategy for customizing LLM use to
particular tasks and contexts. In this study, we explore how perceptions of
different nations change when LLMs are assigned specific nationality personas.
We assign 193 different nationality personas (e.g., an American person) to four
LLMs and examine how the LLM perceptions of countries change. We find that all
LLM-persona combinations tend to favor Western European nations, though
nation-personas push LLM behaviors to focus more on and view more favorably the
nation-persona's own region. Eastern European, Latin American, and African
nations are viewed more negatively by different nationality personas. Our study
provides insight into how biases and stereotypes are realized within LLMs when
adopting different national personas. In line with the "Blueprint for an AI
Bill of Rights", our findings underscore the critical need for developing
mechanisms to ensure LLMs uphold fairness and not over-generalize at a global
scale. | [
-0.571312427520752,
0.01394343376159668,
0.7864723801612854,
0.397283673286438,
-0.2281724214553833,
0.4924165606498718,
0.05949079245328903,
-0.643744945526123,
0.4996868371963501,
0.7716667056083679,
-0.3834337890148163,
-0.3472086191177368,
-0.6102858185768127,
0.37260329723358154,
0.15619900822639465,
1.0040240287780762,
-0.18667636811733246,
0.19049298763275146,
-0.46235087513923645,
-0.342056006193161,
-0.43426400423049927,
-0.7678502202033997,
-0.30348649621009827,
-0.7656646966934204,
0.7962745428085327,
0.4398013651371002,
0.31836649775505066,
0.05100688338279724,
0.6684223413467407,
0.2845078706741333,
0.12771831452846527,
-0.16836680471897125,
-0.42391741275787354,
-0.074391208589077,
-0.5621083378791809,
-0.99033522605896,
-0.5283805727958679,
0.3464667797088623,
0.4375397861003876,
0.4720193147659302,
0.24366380274295807,
0.4847681224346161,
0.042183708399534225,
0.6011610627174377,
-0.5793290734291077,
0.38590332865715027,
-0.6667194962501526,
0.10216791182756424,
-0.21545067429542542,
-0.30464357137680054,
-0.3063332140445709,
-0.3247320055961609,
0.35233330726623535,
-0.38228851556777954,
0.14402219653129578,
0.23520290851593018,
0.44788211584091187,
0.0991889014840126,
-0.9381726384162903,
-0.02974456548690796,
-0.8088638186454773,
0.8686906099319458,
-0.09722862392663956,
0.22636747360229492,
0.03428887575864792,
0.393546998500824,
-0.12557242810726166,
-0.2417827844619751,
-0.17097681760787964,
-0.0064445678144693375,
-0.17175836861133575,
0.43071576952934265,
0.025902075693011284,
-0.028310492634773254,
0.3243667185306549,
0.22166624665260315,
-0.18552371859550476,
0.19765514135360718,
-0.2416870892047882,
-0.4537903368473053,
0.8488945364952087,
0.26818642020225525,
0.5904579162597656,
-0.20308201014995575,
-0.5024707317352295,
0.4204488694667816,
-0.9394345283508301,
0.2345961183309555,
0.6382394433021545,
0.28382161259651184,
-0.3506768047809601,
0.4712468683719635,
-0.374476820230484,
0.6017135977745056,
0.37237775325775146,
-0.2001916766166687,
0.2053297609090805,
0.26740527153015137,
-0.02799653634428978,
0.249314084649086,
0.31461024284362793,
0.8395966291427612,
0.5208607316017151,
-0.18368802964687347,
-0.18834707140922546,
-0.12525585293769836,
0.3609468340873718,
-0.6245319247245789,
0.17999893426895142,
0.03382492810487747,
-0.7695191502571106,
-0.06722584366798401,
0.22688482701778412,
-0.6513773798942566,
-0.8949770927429199,
-0.7681027054786682,
0.23208028078079224,
-0.11029693484306335,
-0.06580203026533127,
-0.13807842135429382,
-0.17691630125045776,
0.5938460826873779,
0.4658617377281189,
-1.149106740951538,
0.1556982845067978,
0.6929103136062622,
0.5817247629165649,
-0.6164641976356506,
-0.23913657665252686,
-0.11849373579025269,
-0.012563871219754219,
-0.36211007833480835,
0.8222426772117615,
-0.5334944128990173,
-0.5087983012199402,
-0.01876242086291313,
-0.00856707151979208,
-0.3531409800052643,
-0.7921029329299927,
-0.19212225079536438,
-0.6094093322753906,
0.19157297909259796,
-1.060023546218872,
-0.18754637241363525,
0.2924070358276367,
0.5229132771492004,
-0.2788985073566437,
0.2588694393634796,
0.14958809316158295,
-0.6674486994743347,
0.6218951344490051,
-0.7609828114509583,
-0.008716944605112076,
0.13791605830192566,
-0.4377405345439911,
0.13614356517791748,
0.41830676794052124,
-0.06250908970832825,
0.39635565876960754,
-0.16298216581344604,
-0.16693115234375,
-0.2281450480222702,
-0.6046442985534668,
0.7280766367912292,
0.0665539801120758,
1.2222353219985962,
0.18882928788661957,
-0.14448325335979462,
-0.05737307667732239,
-0.2760516405105591,
-0.4309350550174713,
0.0437939427793026,
-0.5715457201004028,
-0.41791287064552307,
-0.17887373268604279,
-0.3041326701641083,
0.3438740074634552,
0.5731406211853027,
-0.8850197196006775,
0.29302629828453064,
-0.2779548466205597,
0.19740727543830872,
0.985475480556488,
0.4020046591758728,
0.6327770352363586,
-0.5986027717590332,
0.711430013179779,
0.1178918331861496,
0.3082335889339447,
0.2661224603652954,
-0.4769737720489502,
-0.9676479697227478,
-0.019915850833058357,
0.04700993001461029,
0.71844482421875,
-0.579582929611206,
0.001388995791785419,
-0.333109050989151,
-0.09335662424564362,
-0.47051605582237244,
-0.06605257093906403,
0.17247308790683746,
0.3545984625816345,
0.09645959734916687,
-0.4404817223548889,
-0.4062257409095764,
-1.2488113641738892,
-0.6525387167930603,
-0.6335468888282776,
-0.14552122354507446,
0.45381301641464233,
0.6568014621734619,
-0.11694158613681793,
1.0355805158615112,
-0.3660869300365448,
-0.333139032125473,
-0.29059094190597534,
-0.21683920919895172,
-0.2779679298400879,
0.23678964376449585,
0.7019463777542114,
-0.817434549331665,
-0.7297564744949341,
-0.21417348086833954,
-0.4877152144908905,
-0.12960515916347504,
-0.3412231206893921,
-0.29826757311820984,
0.3101007640361786,
0.4922173023223877,
0.005577354691922665,
0.30767208337783813,
0.3961889445781708,
-0.5215290784835815,
0.6359681487083435,
-0.03829273581504822,
0.4510476291179657,
-1.112062692642212,
-0.13355471193790436,
0.1736890971660614,
0.03915726765990257,
-0.43976396322250366,
0.17617063224315643,
0.0447385311126709,
0.35289499163627625,
-0.7337471842765808,
0.83003830909729,
-0.33420220017433167,
-0.44003188610076904,
0.10259056836366653,
-0.11156726628541946,
0.04485005885362625,
0.3300670385360718,
-0.08228849619626999,
0.8252732157707214,
0.5291224718093872,
-0.5315148234367371,
0.38903555274009705,
0.5437290072441101,
-0.5719292163848877,
1.486506700515747,
-0.12896202504634857,
0.39221838116645813,
-0.5989625453948975,
0.43651771545410156,
-0.8580287098884583,
-0.19807974994182587,
0.37944260239601135,
-0.22157028317451477,
0.034913234412670135,
-0.25647464394569397,
-0.3306179344654083,
-0.16754809021949768,
-0.024162139743566513,
0.17355358600616455,
0.45884400606155396,
-0.6302328705787659,
0.680634617805481,
0.4567033648490906,
-0.1356925368309021,
-0.4443853795528412,
-0.9766575694084167,
0.46770042181015015,
-0.8304306864738464,
-0.2569260895252228,
0.7781383991241455,
-0.1533510833978653,
-0.915200412273407,
-0.42041346430778503,
-0.016784625127911568,
0.12524765729904175,
0.01555372029542923,
0.40147051215171814,
0.04145711287856102,
0.3225381374359131,
-0.20813335478305817,
-0.20084697008132935,
-0.2937586307525635,
0.2389606088399887,
-0.09190640598535538,
0.5161688327789307,
-0.00002990745815623086,
-0.4446989595890045,
-0.4327772855758667,
0.24744856357574463,
0.6570643782615662,
-0.5602879524230957,
0.5761896967887878,
0.20342685282230377,
-0.0836210772395134,
-0.06478628516197205,
-0.5783514976501465,
-0.10638942569494247,
-0.4829917252063751,
0.10598382353782654,
-0.41283974051475525,
-0.6292637586593628,
0.9392839074134827,
-0.11299172043800354,
0.39655426144599915,
0.12781691551208496,
0.6981731057167053,
-0.3054288327693939,
0.675159752368927,
0.7746997475624084,
-0.23654654622077942,
0.41426920890808105,
-0.2224840223789215,
0.19393202662467957,
-1.141882061958313,
-0.8437277674674988,
-0.542971670627594,
-1.0005342960357666,
-0.9690186381340027,
-0.20489917695522308,
0.33419299125671387,
-0.6606872081756592,
-0.32163068652153015,
-0.07043885439634323,
-0.17375589907169342,
0.586578905582428,
0.4323042333126068,
0.09020625054836273,
0.2955634295940399,
0.07678467035293579,
-0.2389216125011444,
-0.43770575523376465,
-0.14116957783699036,
-0.705389142036438,
1.1022553443908691,
-0.008209646679461002,
0.7774941325187683,
0.44752615690231323,
1.145516037940979,
0.45260486006736755,
0.5975314974784851,
-0.7752479910850525,
0.8610759973526001,
-0.2901991903781891,
-0.5952563881874084,
0.11685385555028915,
-0.08024201542139053,
-1.0806819200515747,
0.3242541551589966,
0.05671156942844391,
-1.0534735918045044,
0.47358453273773193,
0.15437813103199005,
-0.4427978992462158,
0.28907886147499084,
-0.15759889781475067,
0.49568068981170654,
-0.29965904355049133,
-0.05555780604481697,
-0.11650994420051575,
-0.4919675588607788,
0.3405153453350067,
0.014958846382796764,
-0.23553058505058289,
-0.45514705777168274,
-0.2533333897590637,
0.5551978349685669,
0.09707812964916229,
0.7972049117088318,
-0.497085839509964,
-0.3277936279773712,
0.12520496547222137,
0.08329063653945923,
0.07636666297912598,
0.1683201789855957,
-0.5663504600524902,
0.1294143944978714,
-0.33003541827201843,
-0.41311800479888916,
-0.381675660610199,
0.8985762000083923,
-1.0261784791946411,
-0.8547835946083069,
-0.4368792176246643,
-0.7330734729766846,
-0.3183422386646271,
-0.11769799143075943,
0.5139428973197937,
0.31677931547164917,
-0.5411757826805115,
-0.04016260802745819,
0.6951097846031189,
-0.5091971158981323,
0.24923111498355865,
0.5735327005386353,
-0.2777487635612488,
0.09219498932361603,
0.754688024520874,
0.4520280063152313,
0.31842342019081116,
0.41213318705558777,
-0.19676412642002106,
-0.42277342081069946,
-0.20355650782585144,
-0.31578028202056885,
0.07030685991048813,
-0.6253670454025269,
0.18526944518089294,
-0.4954599142074585,
0.0827808678150177,
-0.33903712034225464,
-0.33319300413131714,
-0.06644624471664429,
-0.31934159994125366,
-0.15893904864788055,
0.06900136172771454,
0.035222165286540985,
0.4325951337814331,
0.18326285481452942,
0.4842100441455841,
0.03808671608567238,
0.585685133934021,
0.6824532747268677,
0.4015474319458008,
-0.6058151721954346,
-0.7707913517951965,
0.06258607655763626,
-0.2441210150718689,
-0.2626071274280548,
-0.8943302631378174,
0.09658727049827576,
-0.03371783345937729,
0.8205394744873047,
0.33274009823799133,
0.2115563303232193,
0.5366454720497131,
-0.3835125267505646,
0.8567420840263367,
-0.1740868240594864,
-0.5918499827384949,
0.2695417106151581,
-0.4357323944568634,
0.6104597449302673,
0.5003430843353271,
0.15513846278190613,
-0.9356465339660645,
-0.7282912731170654,
-0.481505423784256,
-0.4133283793926239,
0.6954829096794128,
-0.2735165059566498,
0.7645362615585327,
0.16793377697467804,
0.6224759221076965,
0.11857870221138,
0.2826841175556183,
-0.7424678206443787,
-0.7923855185508728,
0.06452630460262299,
0.08814901858568192,
-0.1202055960893631,
-0.2950519323348999,
-0.3291544020175934,
0.09256286919116974,
0.3829951584339142,
-0.08005231618881226,
0.6624855995178223,
0.11933598667383194,
-0.1863875538110733,
-0.11232580989599228,
0.47840383648872375,
0.2819187343120575,
1.0753374099731445,
-0.061748407781124115,
0.048489075154066086,
0.031188765540719032,
-0.1157580316066742,
0.5154757499694824,
-0.19617784023284912,
-0.5968661308288574,
-0.07161423563957214,
0.05425441637635231,
0.7630297541618347,
-0.05053272843360901,
-0.05996004119515419,
0.23914864659309387,
-0.13081055879592896,
-0.4218498766422272,
-0.33750537037849426,
0.44641900062561035,
0.11469510197639465,
0.21746614575386047,
0.45783233642578125,
0.053722769021987915,
-0.02740110270678997,
-0.8564602732658386,
-0.09750593453645706,
0.6463599801063538,
-0.1930370181798935,
-0.3998836278915405,
0.7449171543121338,
0.43938371539115906,
-0.5744666457176208,
0.493195503950119,
-0.1522151380777359,
-0.4547670781612396,
0.8331319093704224,
0.6277889609336853,
0.7614569067955017,
-0.346970796585083,
0.7475143074989319,
-0.030965276062488556,
0.36417528986930847,
0.2986243963241577,
0.368489146232605,
0.32783710956573486,
-1.0909579992294312,
0.056981999427080154,
-0.46207180619239807,
-0.6317009329795837,
0.22760410606861115,
-0.8038883209228516,
0.06303206831216812,
-0.7560847401618958,
-0.4283698797225952,
-0.3249516189098358,
0.42539551854133606,
-1.1516165733337402,
0.16691510379314423,
0.4500386416912079,
0.5732249021530151,
-0.9566677808761597,
0.4285184144973755,
1.131312608718872,
0.1926185041666031,
-0.13554561138153076,
0.4329017102718353,
0.4664193391799927,
-0.9004068970680237,
0.4692500829696655,
0.25177815556526184,
0.3200950026512146,
0.021895458921790123,
-0.215659499168396,
-0.900402307510376,
1.0072022676467896,
0.7590816617012024,
-0.3800966441631317,
0.3055599629878998,
0.7215229868888855,
0.4122653603553772,
-0.8392454981803894,
-0.2159472554922104,
0.8778843879699707,
0.6791881322860718,
-0.27168408036231995,
-0.8618564009666443,
-0.3673318326473236,
0.2058994024991989,
0.012700498104095459,
0.01777142658829689,
-1.4124401807785034,
0.7742186188697815,
-0.33907458186149597,
0.15267905592918396,
-0.19753114879131317,
0.3648078441619873,
0.6586173176765442,
0.42180782556533813,
0.675418496131897,
0.10156556218862534,
0.8310289978981018,
-0.07962755113840103,
0.7774630188941956,
-0.22289283573627472,
-0.2845553159713745,
0.940850019454956,
-0.7141960859298706,
0.24309183657169342,
0.6587611436843872,
-0.30782076716423035,
0.9356125593185425,
0.741218626499176,
-0.01202540472149849,
0.3266870677471161,
0.3184410333633423,
-0.5272902250289917,
-0.1569577157497406,
-0.26991572976112366,
-0.160483255982399,
0.8340029716491699,
0.1777559220790863,
-0.2547297775745392,
-0.2007898986339569,
0.1633750945329666,
-0.1233079731464386,
0.16404731571674347,
-0.5523248910903931,
0.6668500304222107,
0.2152981162071228,
-0.8705368638038635,
-0.2245662659406662,
0.27241936326026917,
0.639817476272583,
-0.2613549828529358,
0.30829691886901855,
-0.739819347858429,
-0.06442004442214966,
-0.2833944857120514,
-0.36163100600242615,
0.08718623965978622,
0.19527871906757355,
-0.30647197365760803,
-0.7237281799316406,
0.5324808955192566,
-0.06670702993869781,
-0.7145673036575317,
0.15480461716651917,
0.718737781047821,
0.5445601940155029,
-0.013336729258298874,
-0.9140062928199768,
-0.05888218805193901,
0.22849150002002716,
-0.3876715302467346,
0.8411072492599487,
0.1494477093219757,
-0.3409256339073181,
0.6811630725860596,
0.12983877956867218,
0.12006454914808273,
-0.0331919863820076,
0.10332566499710083,
0.2387901395559311,
-0.34152930974960327,
-0.5428259968757629,
-0.7618120908737183,
0.5567101836204529,
0.00854481291025877,
-0.21129943430423737,
0.8794249892234802,
0.5494014024734497,
0.9300099611282349,
-0.011374001391232014,
0.9035897850990295,
-0.259640634059906,
0.2581503391265869,
-0.3159438967704773,
0.7363232970237732,
-0.4318442642688751,
0.20975233614444733,
-0.03947027400135994,
-1.2399930953979492,
-0.04349321871995926,
0.4092370867729187,
-0.6078296899795532,
0.12889041006565094,
0.09949039667844772,
0.5964975953102112,
0.15511958301067352,
-0.5009225010871887,
0.19870012998580933,
-0.04226474463939667,
0.43223968148231506,
0.33167803287506104,
0.823827862739563,
0.19974514842033386,
0.1502084583044052,
-0.31471800804138184,
0.0741877555847168,
-0.18896934390068054,
-0.8047229647636414,
-0.660044252872467,
-0.48782652616500854,
-0.6350639462471008,
-0.06365973502397537,
-0.14749696850776672,
0.9639109969139099,
0.5679545998573303,
-0.6077063083648682,
-0.43180057406425476,
0.5516696572303772,
0.2815335690975189,
0.16889947652816772,
-0.2409054934978485,
-0.04705026373267174,
-0.15823759138584137,
-1.094594120979309,
0.14568258821964264,
0.2723475694656372,
0.23199374973773956,
-0.5547472238540649,
-0.06129227578639984,
0.208001971244812,
0.2634361684322357,
0.5589352250099182,
0.3080248236656189,
-0.9106120467185974,
-0.453042596578598,
-0.07645222544670105,
-0.19821058213710785,
0.29863059520721436,
0.9020934104919434,
-0.9732087254524231,
0.4059872031211853,
0.18293863534927368,
0.08245229721069336,
-0.02391401119530201,
0.4138886630535126,
0.5693656206130981,
-0.7344570755958557,
0.30482718348503113,
0.0969543606042862,
0.30554845929145813,
0.455272912979126,
-0.47162535786628723,
0.18546974658966064,
0.022528026252985,
-0.6036568284034729,
-0.6398524641990662,
0.3767924904823303,
-0.5614266991615295,
-0.09397467970848083,
1.062516212463379,
-0.03380914777517319,
0.21296770870685577,
-0.3034333884716034,
-0.1467985063791275,
-0.14831282198429108,
-0.3894583284854889,
1.142849087715149,
0.6692150235176086,
-0.6621752381324768,
0.17294880747795105,
-0.6962102055549622,
0.4993288516998291,
0.35908815264701843,
-0.9089476466178894,
-0.1707359254360199,
0.5658769607543945,
0.6448470950126648,
0.024998106062412262,
1.0177817344665527,
-0.06600760668516159,
0.004209263250231743,
-0.6507272124290466,
-0.10464097559452057,
0.2260306030511856,
-0.6122370362281799,
-0.22803166508674622,
-0.03287901356816292,
0.10191527009010315,
-0.11169062554836273
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13990v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13990v2 | Inference-Time Decontamination: Reusing Leaked Benchmarks for Large Language Model Evaluation | 2024-06-20T04:35:59 | 2024-06-23T16:46:00 | Qin Zhu, Qingyuan Cheng, Runyu Peng, Xiaonan Li, Tengxiao Liu, Ru Peng, Xipeng Qiu, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The training process of large language models (LLMs) often involves varying
degrees of test data contamination. Although current LLMs are achieving
increasingly better performance on various benchmarks, their performance in
practical applications does not always match their benchmark results. Leakage
of benchmarks can prevent the accurate assessment of LLMs' true performance.
However, constructing new benchmarks is costly, labor-intensive and still
carries the risk of leakage. Therefore, in this paper, we ask the question, Can
we reuse these leaked benchmarks for LLM evaluation? We propose Inference-Time
Decontamination (ITD) to address this issue by detecting and rewriting leaked
samples without altering their difficulties. ITD can mitigate performance
inflation caused by memorizing leaked benchmarks. Our proof-of-concept
experiments demonstrate that ITD reduces inflated accuracy by 22.9% on GSM8K
and 19.0% on MMLU. On MMLU, using Inference-time Decontamination can lead to a
decrease in the results of Phi3 and Mistral by 6.7% and 3.6% respectively. We
hope that ITD can provide more truthful evaluation results for large language
models. | [
-0.19941392540931702,
-0.6982625126838684,
0.5413251519203186,
0.11526944488286972,
-0.3795347511768341,
0.20955078303813934,
-0.2854010760784149,
-0.5587238073348999,
-0.38398420810699463,
0.4835299551486969,
-0.25878530740737915,
-0.42552030086517334,
-0.5933440327644348,
-0.255000501871109,
-0.5964622497558594,
0.629048764705658,
-0.16125543415546417,
-0.05429280549287796,
-0.13190588355064392,
-0.0683860257267952,
0.056720070540905,
-0.47168710827827454,
-0.6933214068412781,
-0.2919277250766754,
0.12290003895759583,
0.4138988256454468,
0.2439761608839035,
0.984807550907135,
0.008664701133966446,
0.35879334807395935,
-0.24152997136116028,
-0.07322008907794952,
-0.5225223302841187,
-0.004419869277626276,
-0.2713925242424011,
-0.6198402643203735,
-0.23361144959926605,
0.06255538016557693,
0.7812408208847046,
0.537786602973938,
-0.38577404618263245,
0.42388007044792175,
0.10106684267520905,
0.7477678656578064,
-1.1248419284820557,
0.34912386536598206,
-0.7278715968132019,
0.02086527831852436,
-0.32684755325317383,
-0.24144107103347778,
-0.6807955503463745,
-0.4855632781982422,
-0.2713656425476074,
-0.4052104651927948,
0.3592655062675476,
-0.06042800098657608,
0.7552192807197571,
0.47958454489707947,
-0.07070046663284302,
0.2326257824897766,
-0.8843687176704407,
0.8721432089805603,
-1.0261658430099487,
0.3920496702194214,
0.25653716921806335,
0.5194177627563477,
-0.09298298507928848,
-0.6493360996246338,
-0.42723143100738525,
-0.18381500244140625,
0.28627192974090576,
-0.0629163607954979,
-0.10138203948736191,
-0.23117314279079437,
0.4876987636089325,
0.46304556727409363,
-0.19350509345531464,
0.2606140673160553,
-0.27526092529296875,
-0.2761096954345703,
0.7234952449798584,
0.11405050754547119,
0.16124802827835083,
0.04697567969560623,
-0.46792545914649963,
-0.29543018341064453,
-1.0073238611221313,
-0.2566274404525757,
0.5134966969490051,
0.04126071184873581,
0.19537353515625,
0.33168458938598633,
-0.22479912638664246,
0.2320716828107834,
-0.24623703956604004,
-0.30100977420806885,
0.46025341749191284,
-0.07561303675174713,
-0.3201824426651001,
0.12214579433202744,
0.640713632106781,
0.17382819950580597,
0.35073748230934143,
-0.21955695748329163,
-0.13669607043266296,
0.009076097048819065,
0.2351275086402893,
-1.0468190908432007,
-0.200577974319458,
0.3557169437408447,
-0.33108773827552795,
-0.28647786378860474,
-0.18460726737976074,
-0.8560411334037781,
-0.2867136597633362,
-0.13048012554645538,
0.2608754336833954,
-0.4163705110549927,
-0.5197290778160095,
0.2733370363712311,
-0.22468790411949158,
-0.08641007542610168,
0.23285016417503357,
-0.7250856161117554,
0.20820322632789612,
0.8935973048210144,
0.4824806749820709,
-0.04025229066610336,
-0.4665249288082123,
-0.5407599806785583,
0.46232980489730835,
-0.28952911496162415,
0.8222936987876892,
-0.44260600209236145,
-0.47024813294410706,
0.11322511732578278,
-0.09621858596801758,
-0.059585269540548325,
-0.9775083065032959,
0.9264166355133057,
-0.4179067015647888,
0.02198818139731884,
-0.08697248250246048,
-0.8457391858100891,
0.09717081487178802,
0.17444542050361633,
-0.9004300236701965,
1.1142351627349854,
0.0018360578687861562,
-0.8525514602661133,
0.3039725720882416,
-0.3730703294277191,
-0.2800491154193878,
-0.14177557826042175,
0.10821402072906494,
-0.6665115356445312,
0.08217751979827881,
0.5663802623748779,
0.252897173166275,
-0.3237617015838623,
0.2163200080394745,
-0.528740406036377,
-0.5965768098831177,
0.13370496034622192,
-0.8225908279418945,
0.9235916137695312,
0.31272950768470764,
-0.4786885678768158,
-0.22896629571914673,
-0.7886017560958862,
0.2851516008377075,
0.01750306971371174,
-0.5656097531318665,
-0.35030031204223633,
0.001045296317897737,
-0.14920702576637268,
0.0431455634534359,
0.008539416827261448,
-0.5733011364936829,
0.07016106694936752,
-0.34462112188339233,
0.3984270989894867,
0.9727634191513062,
0.13491924107074738,
0.25578629970550537,
-0.4209904968738556,
0.4170807898044586,
0.009488577023148537,
0.21659453213214874,
-0.10363688319921494,
-0.10613268613815308,
-0.8209828734397888,
-0.4577910900115967,
0.36950868368148804,
0.41069290041923523,
-0.6391060948371887,
0.11806149780750275,
-0.4783076047897339,
-0.7724245190620422,
-0.5950877070426941,
0.14043211936950684,
0.6403411626815796,
0.5741698741912842,
0.39459913969039917,
0.23115293681621552,
-0.22156906127929688,
-0.9324488639831543,
-0.7552493214607239,
-0.4008871912956238,
-0.21737372875213623,
0.11534997820854187,
0.4315814971923828,
0.016304831951856613,
0.5142523050308228,
-0.37707504630088806,
-0.049442097544670105,
-0.049296408891677856,
0.15613418817520142,
-0.1505008339881897,
0.554039716720581,
0.44688504934310913,
-0.41010794043540955,
-0.12390048801898956,
-0.446468710899353,
-0.5140031576156616,
-0.3355952799320221,
0.03790935501456261,
0.03855925425887108,
0.22385282814502716,
0.7649329900741577,
-0.3359447121620178,
0.2902298867702484,
0.4534848630428314,
-0.09249426424503326,
0.9055396318435669,
-0.22584769129753113,
0.2144983857870102,
-0.8457059264183044,
0.1550253927707672,
-0.1520785391330719,
-0.22033952176570892,
-0.3488829731941223,
0.24381816387176514,
0.4047177731990814,
0.030601002275943756,
-0.7003194093704224,
0.7867135405540466,
-0.4758847951889038,
-0.19492322206497192,
-0.11171996593475342,
0.25600823760032654,
0.2541607618331909,
0.15149609744548798,
-0.23178207874298096,
0.7088385820388794,
0.1280280500650406,
-0.4847154915332794,
0.08828211575746536,
-0.00768614374101162,
-0.8788176774978638,
0.15559576451778412,
-0.5014868378639221,
0.1828247457742691,
0.22036926448345184,
0.34651899337768555,
-0.7131410241127014,
0.23194633424282074,
0.08907490968704224,
-0.12843826413154602,
0.3992544710636139,
-0.38155919313430786,
-0.7218039035797119,
-0.07324063032865524,
-0.41284096240997314,
0.5615705251693726,
0.4209427237510681,
-0.9732308983802795,
0.3078843355178833,
0.2472703456878662,
-0.16096264123916626,
-0.9325904250144958,
-0.6689327955245972,
-0.033314015716314316,
-0.44800877571105957,
-0.6440588235855103,
0.5329105257987976,
-0.06208762899041176,
-0.3926076889038086,
0.002602360909804702,
-0.28757140040397644,
-0.058791469782590866,
0.37172502279281616,
0.25971272587776184,
0.20626093447208405,
-0.09506925195455551,
0.22677333652973175,
0.07429824769496918,
-0.36885765194892883,
0.22362102568149567,
0.05680956318974495,
0.5254342555999756,
0.008786462247371674,
-0.7044239640235901,
-0.4928872585296631,
0.3776404559612274,
0.5266751050949097,
-0.3652891516685486,
0.702406644821167,
0.5657628774642944,
-0.4348846673965454,
-0.38061925768852234,
-0.9212397933006287,
-0.11606541275978088,
-0.5106549859046936,
0.21783287823200226,
-0.40449395775794983,
-0.6257941126823425,
0.49378734827041626,
-0.5230616927146912,
0.17201095819473267,
0.3599678874015808,
0.4673740565776825,
-0.009136592037975788,
0.6489711999893188,
0.5318990349769592,
-0.30099210143089294,
0.607761800289154,
-0.38256770372390747,
0.04692773520946503,
-0.8188560605049133,
-0.09219195693731308,
-0.7430636882781982,
-0.21294711530208588,
-0.22744899988174438,
-0.46785324811935425,
-0.012634656392037868,
0.30289265513420105,
-0.2846512198448181,
0.04552633687853813,
0.0029838550835847855,
0.7260902523994446,
0.3468452990055084,
0.04474639892578125,
0.45028653740882874,
-0.01265893317759037,
-0.17672429978847504,
-0.025586990639567375,
-0.3383482098579407,
-0.5912477374076843,
1.1395527124404907,
0.4021615982055664,
0.781146764755249,
-0.004007395356893539,
0.8558378219604492,
0.1137763261795044,
0.43661966919898987,
-0.3985505700111389,
0.4623347222805023,
-0.028839407488703728,
-0.5613110065460205,
-0.22771254181861877,
-0.5430504679679871,
-0.6298155188560486,
0.2977012097835541,
0.12019673734903336,
-0.9496067762374878,
0.31762704253196716,
0.08686728030443192,
0.0015817474341019988,
0.5496606826782227,
-0.8426678776741028,
0.7797483205795288,
0.06888186186552048,
-0.39779508113861084,
-0.330657035112381,
-0.11035361140966415,
0.6119711995124817,
-0.17065834999084473,
0.19509078562259674,
-0.33826491236686707,
-0.038432952016592026,
0.7222224473953247,
-0.6046876907348633,
0.5374597907066345,
-0.1772194504737854,
-0.3229558765888214,
0.05609729886054993,
0.23928312957286835,
0.7400333285331726,
0.12993022799491882,
-0.5104591846466064,
0.2955155074596405,
0.08648259937763214,
-0.4432631731033325,
-0.679357647895813,
0.7399380803108215,
-0.4904543459415436,
-0.7735590934753418,
-0.21840977668762207,
-0.48738017678260803,
-0.27925553917884827,
0.08620468527078629,
0.328030526638031,
0.5549918413162231,
-0.06958774477243423,
0.08531074970960617,
0.5151405334472656,
-0.22829821705818176,
0.6619320511817932,
0.6777230501174927,
-0.11802460998296738,
-0.06525380909442902,
0.7411264777183533,
-0.0517498143017292,
0.6444904208183289,
0.2885954678058624,
0.2642432749271393,
-0.4098137617111206,
-0.8373403549194336,
-0.25917959213256836,
0.24584437906742096,
-0.769278883934021,
-0.07419299334287643,
-0.4109533131122589,
-0.16220198571681976,
-0.23550817370414734,
0.15923963487148285,
-0.866916298866272,
-0.5352593064308167,
-0.022332262247800827,
-0.3105353116989136,
0.09728308767080307,
0.22257573902606964,
-0.1067352294921875,
0.16265903413295746,
-0.7656251788139343,
0.3351798951625824,
-0.03111514449119568,
0.3053451180458069,
-0.04968824237585068,
-0.6007936000823975,
-0.1533171385526657,
0.08211669325828552,
-0.03441830724477768,
-0.6931909918785095,
0.3309691846370697,
0.212030291557312,
0.761867105960846,
0.53676438331604,
0.41377222537994385,
0.686689019203186,
-0.5632246136665344,
0.6537599563598633,
-0.22741098701953888,
-1.0650895833969116,
0.2969611883163452,
-0.04126223921775818,
0.2109062671661377,
0.4659152626991272,
0.11145716905593872,
-0.3858884572982788,
-0.6575111746788025,
-0.7777605652809143,
-0.9340201616287231,
0.47455599904060364,
-0.04650340974330902,
-0.1533060520887375,
0.12485034763813019,
0.3626227378845215,
0.03266017511487007,
0.07998335361480713,
-0.27792102098464966,
-0.4456700086593628,
0.008503449149429798,
0.16688579320907593,
-0.18500369787216187,
-0.7551124095916748,
-0.3279569447040558,
-0.09323461353778839,
0.6764953136444092,
0.05290979519486427,
0.1521013081073761,
-0.09580297768115997,
-0.38744014501571655,
0.0725124180316925,
0.5574146509170532,
0.4485986828804016,
0.939835250377655,
-0.23866166174411774,
0.28107085824012756,
0.22677217423915863,
-0.4136747717857361,
0.4201737642288208,
0.050340354442596436,
0.0637504830956459,
-0.14891482889652252,
0.4633225202560425,
0.34701088070869446,
0.2637307047843933,
-0.7758140563964844,
0.412204384803772,
-0.16964362561702728,
0.056681085377931595,
-0.3613547384738922,
0.1702488660812378,
0.49935173988342285,
0.3122256398200989,
0.3225575089454651,
-0.15114319324493408,
0.08291589468717575,
-0.611111581325531,
0.3547196388244629,
0.19747550785541534,
0.01597016118466854,
0.07385842502117157,
0.5401326417922974,
0.013005773536860943,
-0.08364253491163254,
0.7611658573150635,
-0.05864671245217323,
-0.5806975364685059,
0.5344130992889404,
0.6652047038078308,
0.9042181968688965,
-0.7205452919006348,
0.08507287502288818,
0.4197865426540375,
0.4200395941734314,
-0.1658400595188141,
0.07934056967496872,
0.1612953245639801,
-0.635890781879425,
-0.6124204993247986,
-0.41304099559783936,
-0.25921884179115295,
0.42276719212532043,
-0.8246740698814392,
0.02713046595454216,
-0.5147045254707336,
0.20673105120658875,
0.04660188779234886,
-0.030508145689964294,
-0.35916274785995483,
0.07010472565889359,
-0.04119814932346344,
1.1646606922149658,
-0.9104982018470764,
0.9037929773330688,
-0.025558965280652046,
-0.11925417184829712,
-0.8605461716651917,
0.09609204530715942,
0.12428100407123566,
-0.6470379829406738,
0.6257830262184143,
0.09451460838317871,
-0.045249808579683304,
-0.19766518473625183,
-0.30846720933914185,
-0.5846774578094482,
1.1143888235092163,
1.0461472272872925,
-0.6425807476043701,
0.15204334259033203,
0.1220470666885376,
0.340192586183548,
-0.02593795396387577,
0.4288198947906494,
0.9525517225265503,
0.46630892157554626,
-0.15968093276023865,
-0.8923426866531372,
0.22411106526851654,
-0.4731737971305847,
-0.09809118509292603,
0.18928249180316925,
-0.580532431602478,
0.9401907324790955,
-0.30110737681388855,
-0.617573618888855,
-0.018632376566529274,
0.2141178399324417,
0.3368256986141205,
0.08962869644165039,
0.5849866271018982,
0.7595885992050171,
0.8707327246665955,
-0.15292343497276306,
1.2054388523101807,
-0.1393866091966629,
0.2952646017074585,
1.3893228769302368,
-0.21404536068439484,
1.1626278162002563,
0.46942174434661865,
-0.17010509967803955,
0.3017764687538147,
0.49321556091308594,
0.03971617668867111,
0.4057788550853729,
0.4141436517238617,
-0.5230298042297363,
-0.19807861745357513,
0.09837277978658676,
-0.606567919254303,
0.26155078411102295,
0.2982112169265747,
-0.31138738989830017,
-0.5906743407249451,
-0.23989632725715637,
0.3596563935279846,
0.032688360661268234,
0.03643449768424034,
0.5214812159538269,
0.03960968926548958,
-0.3798474073410034,
0.7762712836265564,
0.00844957958906889,
0.2991008460521698,
-0.247384712100029,
-0.04061461240053177,
-0.33753034472465515,
0.5920045375823975,
-0.15130217373371124,
-0.4475068747997284,
0.24842114746570587,
-0.019692309200763702,
-0.14502060413360596,
-0.2984926104545593,
0.6666458249092102,
-0.45579850673675537,
-0.3117304742336273,
0.414955198764801,
0.41787365078926086,
0.21518577635288239,
-0.48219290375709534,
-0.6585631370544434,
0.3629327714443207,
0.021205242723226547,
-0.30674630403518677,
0.45953163504600525,
0.178122878074646,
0.09504131972789764,
1.1803431510925293,
0.6426409482955933,
0.22175092995166779,
0.2695654630661011,
0.26664450764656067,
0.8264797329902649,
-0.4540090560913086,
-0.2698029577732086,
-1.041273593902588,
0.3587764501571655,
-0.07267677783966064,
0.03754683583974838,
0.7526818513870239,
0.715571939945221,
0.7874307036399841,
-0.02353367954492569,
0.7388108968734741,
0.5107159614562988,
0.6572477221488953,
-0.7416566014289856,
0.9215527176856995,
-0.3570829927921295,
0.6586685180664062,
-0.3563551902770996,
-1.0593341588974,
0.08836910128593445,
0.1459120810031891,
-0.28176313638687134,
0.04839145764708519,
0.9042509198188782,
0.7609471678733826,
-0.04170619323849678,
0.00197180756367743,
0.20408551394939423,
0.18342547118663788,
0.8443365097045898,
0.7211113572120667,
0.9584133625030518,
-0.48838725686073303,
0.7914767861366272,
-0.677103579044342,
-0.09959005564451218,
-0.2824755609035492,
-1.2253652811050415,
-0.6008617877960205,
-0.45710134506225586,
-0.646898090839386,
-0.25698354840278625,
0.1178874596953392,
0.31362879276275635,
0.4170656204223633,
-0.5753102898597717,
-0.014890560880303383,
0.1810590922832489,
0.17701132595539093,
-0.5112966299057007,
-0.21458271145820618,
0.6800174713134766,
-0.22494249045848846,
-0.9878969192504883,
0.6615880727767944,
-0.005544263403862715,
-0.10829667747020721,
-0.2918725311756134,
0.22341817617416382,
-0.06403203308582306,
-0.17393425107002258,
0.20022311806678772,
0.4047031104564667,
-0.6659718155860901,
-0.5364776849746704,
-0.5026909112930298,
0.012772667221724987,
-0.07735047489404678,
0.7480909824371338,
-0.7920756340026855,
0.42585843801498413,
0.4588160514831543,
0.7888991832733154,
0.8236764669418335,
0.1320158988237381,
0.6758033633232117,
-0.7832376956939697,
0.18592911958694458,
0.0767039954662323,
0.5910552144050598,
0.28309953212738037,
-0.18638981878757477,
0.5772619247436523,
-0.013546543195843697,
-0.4216550886631012,
-1.1199437379837036,
0.0688248947262764,
-0.6048597097396851,
-0.2482624053955078,
1.3162333965301514,
-0.6354337334632874,
-0.31926316022872925,
-0.14955586194992065,
0.08160778880119324,
0.36417022347450256,
-0.28941038250923157,
0.9365010261535645,
0.7421813607215881,
0.32810279726982117,
-0.3233600854873657,
-0.7615511417388916,
0.5237796902656555,
0.24898642301559448,
-1.0108306407928467,
0.5531089901924133,
0.3820239305496216,
0.802210807800293,
0.08522295951843262,
0.463202565908432,
-0.46726828813552856,
0.10345389693975449,
0.24290154874324799,
0.09563421458005905,
-0.42280757427215576,
-0.12751811742782593,
-0.20778174698352814,
0.1136670932173729,
0.033221807330846786,
-0.30708932876586914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13975v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13975v1 | MR-BEN: A Comprehensive Meta-Reasoning Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T03:50:23 | 2024-06-20T03:50:23 | Zhongshen Zeng, Yinhong Liu, Yingjia Wan, Jingyao Li, Pengguang Chen, Jianbo Dai, Yuxuan Yao, Rongwu Xu, Zehan Qi, Wanru Zhao, Linling Shen, Jianqiao Lu, Haochen Tan, Yukang Chen, Hao Zhang, Zhan Shi, Bailin Wang, Zhijiang Guo, Jiaya Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have shown increasing capability in
problem-solving and decision-making, largely based on the step-by-step
chain-of-thought reasoning processes. However, it has been increasingly
challenging to evaluate the reasoning capability of LLMs. Concretely, existing
outcome-based benchmarks begin to saturate and become less sufficient to
monitor the progress. To this end, we present a process-based benchmark MR-BEN
that demands a meta reasoning skill, where LMs are asked to locate and analyse
potential errors in automatically generated reasoning steps. MR-BEN is a
comprehensive benchmark comprising 5,975 questions collected from human
experts, covering various subjects such as physics, chemistry, logic, coding,
and more. Through our designed metrics for assessing meta-reasoning on this
benchmark, we identify interesting limitations and weaknesses of current LLMs
(open-source and closed-source models). For example, open-source models are
seemingly comparable to GPT-4 on outcome-based benchmarks, but they lag far
behind on our benchmark, revealing the underlying reasoning capability gap
between them. Our dataset and codes are available on
https://randolph-zeng.github.io/Mr-Ben.github.io/. | [
-0.5755147337913513,
-0.8711823225021362,
0.9115718007087708,
-0.04031870514154434,
-0.0709233433008194,
-0.085098035633564,
-0.27264145016670227,
-0.4715177118778229,
-0.11042056232690811,
0.42659100890159607,
-0.784207284450531,
-0.5304027199745178,
-0.5575222969055176,
0.4058413505554199,
-0.09742874652147293,
0.5438057780265808,
-0.17738422751426697,
0.13457784056663513,
-0.22758454084396362,
-0.17478792369365692,
-0.5481841564178467,
-0.16811539232730865,
-0.5614725947380066,
-0.4167350232601166,
0.7193783521652222,
0.463346004486084,
0.744565486907959,
0.466538667678833,
0.7677481174468994,
0.2565629482269287,
0.11445257812738419,
0.3446614146232605,
-0.05251457169651985,
0.27496537566185,
-0.8003339767456055,
-0.20333854854106903,
-0.6008962988853455,
-0.0670338049530983,
0.7454396486282349,
0.8245901465415955,
-0.030509263277053833,
0.4447367489337921,
-0.2135019302368164,
0.7550860047340393,
-0.832791805267334,
0.15441082417964935,
-0.5587860345840454,
-0.09080345183610916,
-0.27241429686546326,
-0.03072287328541279,
-0.41229546070098877,
-0.3026634156703949,
-0.09551358222961426,
-0.08161751925945282,
0.15170177817344666,
0.04613623768091202,
0.5909860730171204,
0.5107709765434265,
-0.23047733306884766,
-0.19040633738040924,
-0.7229458093643188,
0.7789162397384644,
-0.7319420576095581,
0.5662550330162048,
0.36609673500061035,
0.6364864110946655,
-0.20235444605350494,
-0.6199490427970886,
-0.5500057339668274,
-0.17338678240776062,
0.020836975425481796,
-0.08635368198156357,
0.036469608545303345,
-0.09073081612586975,
0.2781052887439728,
0.11799692362546921,
-0.8151864409446716,
-0.261259526014328,
-0.20226575434207916,
-0.0448540598154068,
0.47470080852508545,
0.26001814007759094,
0.0007983645773492754,
-0.24578091502189636,
-0.1279722899198532,
-0.24090932309627533,
-0.5254963040351868,
-0.3096729516983032,
0.2738879919052124,
0.368512898683548,
0.20495545864105225,
0.7932589650154114,
-0.25913572311401367,
0.7584695219993591,
-0.23898956179618835,
0.009473839774727821,
0.23404042422771454,
-0.25265559554100037,
-0.28648582100868225,
-0.19073499739170074,
0.887787401676178,
-0.07131681591272354,
0.4388394057750702,
0.19045503437519073,
-0.13751892745494843,
-0.3187456727027893,
0.1884692758321762,
-0.7108331322669983,
-0.1712125539779663,
0.3460070490837097,
-0.3530988395214081,
0.291765958070755,
0.13096298277378082,
-0.7600619792938232,
-0.276754230260849,
-0.12650726735591888,
0.3926544189453125,
-0.5543982982635498,
-0.38643205165863037,
0.16058120131492615,
0.0020834144670516253,
0.2558840215206146,
0.24959056079387665,
-0.6632075309753418,
0.09492786228656769,
0.7903494834899902,
0.7123314142227173,
0.04455043002963066,
-0.36931073665618896,
-0.47025686502456665,
0.12880752980709076,
-0.47028419375419617,
0.9460301399230957,
-0.7642173767089844,
-0.22144575417041779,
-0.24841269850730896,
-0.2342890202999115,
-0.18829500675201416,
-0.6971997618675232,
0.9515947699546814,
-0.5005648136138916,
0.11062289029359818,
-0.6877162456512451,
-0.4467626214027405,
-0.1931561827659607,
0.5260805487632751,
-0.6287103891372681,
0.9473760724067688,
0.13621027767658234,
-0.7357656955718994,
0.2934507727622986,
-0.7249471545219421,
-0.3422432839870453,
-0.09277743101119995,
-0.4895830750465393,
-0.32868412137031555,
0.15119114518165588,
0.1765853464603424,
0.4207075834274292,
-0.7261927127838135,
0.4576279819011688,
-0.6677340865135193,
-0.39555150270462036,
0.49796727299690247,
-0.6272669434547424,
0.671856164932251,
0.25953778624534607,
-0.4460785388946533,
0.16456720232963562,
-0.841774582862854,
0.22476698458194733,
0.10993704944849014,
-0.41316282749176025,
-0.06321663409471512,
0.19999966025352478,
-0.4197477102279663,
0.3855515718460083,
0.21066032350063324,
-0.24091418087482452,
-0.07936927676200867,
-0.11749454587697983,
0.22183579206466675,
0.7943273186683655,
-0.3029322922229767,
-0.10300526022911072,
-0.24720734357833862,
0.37484174966812134,
-0.12469150125980377,
0.04549326375126839,
-0.28694167733192444,
-0.49779626727104187,
-0.6569290161132812,
-0.49451667070388794,
0.3753410577774048,
0.581429660320282,
-0.5050956606864929,
0.6674672961235046,
-0.5187278389930725,
-0.25610244274139404,
-0.5486562848091125,
0.21629925072193146,
0.4711754322052002,
0.4891014099121094,
0.5818892121315002,
-0.11798404157161713,
-0.19787068665027618,
-1.1229667663574219,
-0.43162113428115845,
-0.20737050473690033,
-0.2092384546995163,
0.3479750454425812,
0.7820155620574951,
-0.3978385031223297,
0.8893725872039795,
-0.2972620725631714,
-0.03850467875599861,
-0.16509392857551575,
0.24052532017230988,
0.18246741592884064,
0.23478110134601593,
0.03496744483709335,
-0.541239321231842,
-0.26095765829086304,
-0.15424878895282745,
-0.9007279276847839,
-0.37251052260398865,
0.05591966211795807,
-0.03472499921917915,
0.4021410346031189,
0.49124112725257874,
-0.7721847295761108,
0.1346346139907837,
0.5150444507598877,
-0.4597630500793457,
0.7584230899810791,
-0.29023510217666626,
0.4573284387588501,
-0.8338062763214111,
0.4989215135574341,
-0.029438389465212822,
-0.19167093932628632,
-0.12090198695659637,
0.2454826384782791,
0.20942926406860352,
0.0028099725022912025,
-0.18752677738666534,
0.6725815534591675,
-0.4344533681869507,
-0.4694114923477173,
-0.21294735372066498,
0.16875436902046204,
-0.16690973937511444,
0.4133128821849823,
0.16700798273086548,
0.7697907090187073,
0.22113029658794403,
-0.47392505407333374,
0.4499633014202118,
0.0033101169392466545,
-0.3664432764053345,
0.9201759099960327,
-0.6295574903488159,
0.01905667409300804,
0.047143783420324326,
0.31983205676078796,
-0.954185426235199,
-0.29366979002952576,
0.33951300382614136,
-0.5063796043395996,
0.3152073621749878,
0.017232656478881836,
-0.9359629154205322,
-0.44478723406791687,
-0.19809703528881073,
0.46825510263442993,
0.2068614661693573,
-0.4034019112586975,
0.8750479817390442,
-0.17450553178787231,
-0.07496938854455948,
-0.8195168972015381,
-0.8153594732284546,
0.21364402770996094,
0.057907022535800934,
-0.7976205348968506,
0.1371655911207199,
-0.2819949686527252,
-0.3383506238460541,
0.29381605982780457,
-0.22348076105117798,
0.01561343390494585,
-0.23554305732250214,
-0.04441437870264053,
-0.0012262791860848665,
-0.2275380939245224,
0.1456383317708969,
0.010870848782360554,
-0.4228307902812958,
0.3768272399902344,
-0.1569667011499405,
0.46638786792755127,
-0.32685065269470215,
-0.9579291939735413,
-0.2096450924873352,
0.26087355613708496,
0.8673602938652039,
-0.41729065775871277,
0.7947890162467957,
0.6521897912025452,
-0.3805781900882721,
-0.3343055248260498,
-0.7245643138885498,
-0.16803355515003204,
-0.4331934154033661,
0.31109049916267395,
-0.6868563890457153,
-0.6487833261489868,
0.5411641597747803,
-0.16682952642440796,
0.08363454788923264,
0.6267279386520386,
0.5264173746109009,
-0.026781847700476646,
0.8138012290000916,
0.13040019571781158,
0.23768354952335358,
0.006837785243988037,
0.023950845003128052,
0.11120662838220596,
-0.863569974899292,
-0.2624463140964508,
-0.6027414202690125,
-0.1782466173171997,
-0.33553096652030945,
-0.848851203918457,
0.3735654950141907,
-0.023605166003108025,
-0.46241700649261475,
0.19241057336330414,
-0.25665831565856934,
0.40891361236572266,
0.6506060361862183,
0.10091996937990189,
0.35595929622650146,
-0.3375414311885834,
-0.39565956592559814,
0.11748575419187546,
-0.540654718875885,
-0.5515658855438232,
1.0872591733932495,
0.36422768235206604,
0.6083165407180786,
0.2730604410171509,
0.5454391241073608,
0.3066574037075043,
0.31115615367889404,
-0.4025335907936096,
0.8512489199638367,
0.08869941532611847,
-1.1628702878952026,
-0.35850515961647034,
-0.9040957689285278,
-0.6610608696937561,
0.3741782009601593,
-0.2337140142917633,
-0.3281196355819702,
-0.20779496431350708,
0.07817475497722626,
-0.12920348346233368,
0.5852596759796143,
-0.49620044231414795,
1.0665857791900635,
-0.3820738196372986,
-0.7381722927093506,
-0.555878758430481,
-0.6543186902999878,
0.6117373704910278,
-0.20938926935195923,
0.4163496494293213,
-0.2590976059436798,
-0.0879116952419281,
0.3987220525741577,
-0.38485732674598694,
0.5958924293518066,
-0.03354276716709137,
-0.15362438559532166,
0.46431267261505127,
0.154976949095726,
0.3813064992427826,
-0.14432065188884735,
-0.218657985329628,
0.08644451200962067,
0.005505997221916914,
-0.5850296020507812,
-0.4294535517692566,
0.71837317943573,
-0.39571431279182434,
-0.5272127389907837,
-0.580450713634491,
-0.31025731563568115,
-0.37372371554374695,
0.22836874425411224,
-0.10262125730514526,
0.20361874997615814,
-0.24121665954589844,
0.08097368478775024,
0.9086849689483643,
-0.5338864922523499,
0.41109761595726013,
0.6187005639076233,
-0.15206865966320038,
-0.684411346912384,
0.6084701418876648,
0.04877467453479767,
0.20167015492916107,
0.5392966866493225,
0.30386099219322205,
-0.38955384492874146,
-0.586815595626831,
-0.6036518216133118,
0.4656094014644623,
-0.9766202569007874,
-0.12849216163158417,
-0.4479408264160156,
-0.09594249725341797,
-0.13578031957149506,
0.11299163103103638,
-0.5297706723213196,
-0.09721735864877701,
0.02706618793308735,
0.14969117939472198,
-0.13089977204799652,
0.5275561213493347,
-0.09119884669780731,
-0.278496652841568,
-0.9163606762886047,
0.37299302220344543,
0.4822717308998108,
0.8388301134109497,
-0.08833972364664078,
-0.40771952271461487,
-0.29216688871383667,
-0.1490718573331833,
-0.29168885946273804,
-0.8313537836074829,
-0.19250115752220154,
-0.1529000848531723,
0.7287559509277344,
0.43485671281814575,
0.05932885408401489,
0.5050203204154968,
-0.5247646570205688,
0.6271886825561523,
0.11666198074817657,
-0.9963223338127136,
0.53769451379776,
-0.5410290956497192,
0.47469770908355713,
0.6626619696617126,
0.2506854832172394,
-0.16895534098148346,
-0.2244511991739273,
-0.4852684736251831,
-0.46693044900894165,
0.4611469507217407,
0.10870910435914993,
-0.2486737072467804,
-0.27164044976234436,
0.4000198543071747,
-0.021660976111888885,
0.15041451156139374,
-0.7070673108100891,
-0.1468912810087204,
0.15239644050598145,
-0.3032185435295105,
-0.05122196674346924,
-0.215633362531662,
0.021129736676812172,
-0.24397605657577515,
0.6775622963905334,
-0.1351419985294342,
0.21284528076648712,
0.2619265913963318,
-0.09971215575933456,
-0.3665849268436432,
0.41217586398124695,
0.8428080677986145,
1.0025370121002197,
-0.47331342101097107,
0.3301081955432892,
0.35658520460128784,
-0.10852592438459396,
0.016040759161114693,
0.2814182937145233,
0.2437439262866974,
-0.04618994891643524,
0.67686527967453,
0.21358658373355865,
0.20364905893802643,
-1.1001615524291992,
0.4272579848766327,
0.09465435147285461,
-0.3952765464782715,
-0.27386176586151123,
0.12009717524051666,
0.3325347602367401,
0.5751892328262329,
0.2980399429798126,
0.03367803245782852,
0.022343743592500687,
-0.7512065768241882,
0.16581231355667114,
0.6321812868118286,
-0.10705668479204178,
-0.21766404807567596,
0.6621917486190796,
0.20724286139011383,
-0.29165324568748474,
0.526844322681427,
-0.29775968194007874,
-0.34103819727897644,
0.27647048234939575,
0.12013783305883408,
1.0790972709655762,
-0.36490145325660706,
-0.0008748205727897584,
0.625974178314209,
0.6379759907722473,
-0.24013619124889374,
0.35255560278892517,
-0.016247903928160667,
-0.4886346459388733,
-0.7540633082389832,
-0.5869181752204895,
-0.6531983017921448,
0.2218930870294571,
-0.20026656985282898,
0.3801291882991791,
-0.5658714771270752,
-0.2205512672662735,
-0.18614108860492706,
0.08917850255966187,
-0.6305203437805176,
0.22038845717906952,
0.1259223222732544,
1.0557249784469604,
-0.6549445390701294,
0.7266635894775391,
0.5851687788963318,
-0.34850215911865234,
-0.2520161271095276,
0.019378244876861572,
-0.015172254294157028,
-0.5301374197006226,
0.46735119819641113,
0.20785461366176605,
-0.4278887212276459,
-0.434635192155838,
-0.21092292666435242,
-0.7776644825935364,
1.068640112876892,
0.5974498391151428,
-0.6152547597885132,
0.09563957154750824,
0.22191236913204193,
0.4655348062515259,
-0.1836513876914978,
0.4533139765262604,
0.60490882396698,
0.8746801018714905,
0.19252347946166992,
-0.9926122426986694,
0.1814030408859253,
0.010564868338406086,
-0.36183321475982666,
0.4313772916793823,
-0.5287129282951355,
0.8589569926261902,
-0.286984920501709,
-0.061942510306835175,
-0.23181326687335968,
0.4858955442905426,
0.4654093086719513,
0.5209017992019653,
0.40162670612335205,
0.9263683557510376,
0.6666772961616516,
-0.07127220183610916,
0.803854763507843,
-0.3035755157470703,
0.19910000264644623,
1.1563271284103394,
-0.4003414213657379,
1.0704784393310547,
0.2423166036605835,
-0.3789644241333008,
0.7597165703773499,
0.6338484883308411,
0.05482131242752075,
0.20255804061889648,
0.34528735280036926,
-0.24617454409599304,
-0.5397555828094482,
0.5235922932624817,
-0.3016110360622406,
0.19525355100631714,
0.341739684343338,
-0.4979182779788971,
-0.26805582642555237,
-0.392747163772583,
-0.11867222189903259,
0.10017619282007217,
-0.12638957798480988,
0.5385322570800781,
0.08333161473274231,
-0.8330386281013489,
0.5610467791557312,
0.2586745321750641,
0.3511688709259033,
-0.6551531553268433,
-0.04959432780742645,
-0.04326580464839935,
0.3384908139705658,
-0.12108819931745529,
-0.897847592830658,
0.5967669486999512,
0.030685478821396828,
-0.13819599151611328,
-0.04102038964629173,
0.6173114776611328,
-0.18356412649154663,
-0.5199921131134033,
0.45227280259132385,
0.8887203335762024,
0.14873602986335754,
-0.22701801359653473,
-0.8357565999031067,
0.22054746747016907,
-0.21457980573177338,
-0.38822272419929504,
0.15065251290798187,
0.5174432396888733,
0.03137369081377983,
0.9200901985168457,
0.4633878171443939,
-0.051671918481588364,
-0.14742805063724518,
0.01975308731198311,
0.5411909222602844,
-0.984916627407074,
-0.10887353867292404,
-1.1464563608169556,
0.38768646121025085,
0.034302081912755966,
-0.08660601079463959,
0.4411065876483917,
0.5222053527832031,
0.7222274541854858,
0.06551367044448853,
0.7110442519187927,
-0.0540066622197628,
0.7134027481079102,
-0.489685982465744,
0.28034183382987976,
-0.5621646046638489,
0.5101317763328552,
-0.3450804054737091,
-1.138727068901062,
-0.2556290030479431,
0.6458534598350525,
-0.3626049757003784,
0.5626266598701477,
1.0041753053665161,
0.6411309242248535,
-0.3428558111190796,
-0.13945238292217255,
0.2940748631954193,
-0.12469348311424255,
0.39537355303764343,
0.791627824306488,
0.7178768515586853,
-0.10904903709888458,
0.761239767074585,
0.17502224445343018,
-0.2980909049510956,
-0.3321126699447632,
-1.1267637014389038,
-1.2125941514968872,
-0.5367913246154785,
-0.31577587127685547,
-0.19408056139945984,
0.050021056085824966,
1.0221391916275024,
0.6788097620010376,
-0.6378346681594849,
-0.12968428432941437,
-0.2625580430030823,
0.21719248592853546,
-0.33482328057289124,
-0.19891057908535004,
0.2773793637752533,
-0.38875219225883484,
-0.422878623008728,
0.38475969433784485,
0.23714256286621094,
-0.2385743409395218,
-0.521147608757019,
-0.12126131355762482,
-0.20442332327365875,
0.5281006693840027,
0.5637303590774536,
0.2514170706272125,
-0.8195353150367737,
-0.34120485186576843,
-0.1691007912158966,
-0.04528301954269409,
-0.03125927224755287,
0.7392892241477966,
-0.5545099377632141,
0.35479533672332764,
0.5898036360740662,
0.7590857148170471,
0.40597060322761536,
-0.10328364372253418,
0.4492509663105011,
-0.4417908489704132,
-0.6081209778785706,
0.11528756469488144,
0.46517032384872437,
0.5055060982704163,
0.28716471791267395,
0.6387205123901367,
0.3411332368850708,
-0.628423273563385,
-0.7363319396972656,
0.4295296370983124,
-0.7238880395889282,
-0.6727339029312134,
1.050012230873108,
0.020434122532606125,
-0.005450103897601366,
0.08974934369325638,
0.13226279616355896,
0.21000522375106812,
-0.21400761604309082,
0.748684287071228,
0.9536125063896179,
-0.26523685455322266,
-0.5132187008857727,
-0.8134750127792358,
0.2173268347978592,
0.39172959327697754,
-0.9694540500640869,
0.3799282908439636,
0.6798704266548157,
0.4301185607910156,
0.2700057029724121,
0.563145101070404,
-0.1326577365398407,
0.24461127817630768,
-0.014270083047449589,
0.025653699412941933,
-0.27541619539260864,
-0.5997235178947449,
-0.19380882382392883,
0.3495343327522278,
0.15139082074165344,
-0.01768818497657776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13960v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13960v1 | Evolving to be Your Soulmate: Personalized Dialogue Agents with Dynamically Adapted Personas | 2024-06-20T03:02:38 | 2024-06-20T03:02:38 | Yi Cheng, Wenge Liu, Kaishuai Xu, Wenjun Hou, Yi Ouyang, Chak Tou Leong, Xian Wu, Yefeng Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Previous research on persona-based dialogue agents typically preset the
agent's persona before deployment, which remains static thereafter. In this
paper, we take a step further and explore a new paradigm called Self-evolving
Personalized Dialogue Agents (SPDA), where the agent continuously evolves
during the conversation to better align with the user's anticipation by
dynamically adapting its persona. This paradigm could enable better
personalization for each user, but also introduce unique challenges, which
mainly lie in the process of persona adaptation. Two key issues include how to
achieve persona alignment with the user and how to ensure smooth transition in
the adaptation process. To address them, we propose a novel framework that
refines the persona at hierarchical levels to progressively align better with
the user in a controllable way. Experiments show that integrating the personas
adapted by our framework consistently enhances personalization and overall
dialogue performance across various base systems. | [
-0.46151629090309143,
-0.2895222008228302,
0.7997986674308777,
0.3648926615715027,
-0.022541522979736328,
0.6600073575973511,
0.19469720125198364,
-0.3232039213180542,
0.38576969504356384,
0.6166287660598755,
-1.0933676958084106,
-0.05765986070036888,
-0.12495655566453934,
0.07996060699224472,
0.24925245344638824,
0.8821176290512085,
0.479112833738327,
-0.05226690322160721,
-0.23073866963386536,
-0.46177712082862854,
-0.9600009918212891,
-0.18214933574199677,
-0.6706304550170898,
-0.49574652314186096,
0.44380033016204834,
0.4595716893672943,
0.6770627498626709,
0.3885599374771118,
0.27848511934280396,
0.38371357321739197,
0.2475026547908783,
-0.1285352110862732,
-0.394440233707428,
0.7885079979896545,
-0.4536113142967224,
-0.40404045581817627,
-0.7355794906616211,
-0.18081875145435333,
0.4629693627357483,
0.5339745879173279,
-0.16648659110069275,
0.05771034583449364,
-0.039763614535331726,
0.7310091257095337,
-0.46153682470321655,
0.002924979431554675,
-0.5670266151428223,
0.10861539095640182,
0.0021398740354925394,
-0.507138729095459,
-0.19822770357131958,
-0.4199739694595337,
0.5977063179016113,
-0.6148948073387146,
-0.2264799177646637,
-0.09478498995304108,
0.37926894426345825,
0.42736420035362244,
-0.4826347529888153,
-0.08483615517616272,
-1.0085351467132568,
0.4730936586856842,
-0.4976843595504761,
0.3504360020160675,
-0.3651111423969269,
0.8081732988357544,
-0.260445237159729,
-0.6876258254051208,
-0.4984370768070221,
-0.1859159767627716,
0.23277005553245544,
0.29669928550720215,
-0.14734213054180145,
0.06653505563735962,
-0.028456753119826317,
0.1353330910205841,
-0.3101509213447571,
0.045691292732954025,
0.11292605102062225,
0.06691288948059082,
0.4289698898792267,
0.41002219915390015,
0.4458302855491638,
-0.06604205816984177,
-0.18111911416053772,
0.04013066366314888,
-0.2189640998840332,
0.21122388541698456,
0.35905635356903076,
0.29382947087287903,
-0.11074090003967285,
0.06055267155170441,
-0.2202061116695404,
0.2995157539844513,
0.9638193845748901,
-0.2709943652153015,
0.42906221747398376,
-0.0813560038805008,
-0.10018203407526016,
0.19567333161830902,
0.38526418805122375,
0.5608230233192444,
0.16575048863887787,
-0.34124794602394104,
0.09882724285125732,
-0.20621460676193237,
0.6612305641174316,
-0.7333105802536011,
-0.15893051028251648,
0.3368058502674103,
-0.459945946931839,
-0.33885034918785095,
-0.3328419029712677,
-0.8253520727157593,
-0.7303228378295898,
-0.3097113072872162,
0.17158937454223633,
-0.351673424243927,
-0.21059100329875946,
0.1144302487373352,
0.05467000976204872,
0.47205519676208496,
0.5777481198310852,
-1.1887906789779663,
0.3335886299610138,
0.7930000424385071,
0.6309910416603088,
-0.17334704101085663,
-0.2738085389137268,
-0.29427269101142883,
0.16630081832408905,
-0.36092281341552734,
0.9218447804450989,
-0.7121197581291199,
-0.4163636565208435,
-0.1411946415901184,
0.10977567732334137,
-0.18958435952663422,
-0.4598800241947174,
0.31565430760383606,
-0.593731164932251,
0.5387781262397766,
-0.4905596375465393,
-0.029399456456303596,
-0.00794082973152399,
0.11050054430961609,
-0.10172377526760101,
0.6426482200622559,
0.6834502816200256,
-0.3344481587409973,
0.3493192791938782,
-0.8385480642318726,
-0.09399660676717758,
0.39412960410118103,
-0.04374208673834801,
-0.2079571783542633,
0.12803104519844055,
-0.0267205610871315,
0.4391499161720276,
-0.05717293173074722,
0.03217439725995064,
-0.5873849391937256,
-0.06365359574556351,
0.3814481496810913,
0.29099658131599426,
0.6237754225730896,
0.22753989696502686,
-0.18570856750011444,
0.35704097151756287,
-0.731235921382904,
-0.12515394389629364,
-0.07928481698036194,
0.14993086457252502,
-0.21684879064559937,
0.10519415885210037,
-0.26101526618003845,
0.3975223898887634,
0.5010596513748169,
-0.399440735578537,
0.3352651596069336,
-0.5180190205574036,
0.3458769917488098,
1.153646469116211,
0.3371383845806122,
0.9621735215187073,
-0.5799791812896729,
0.514702320098877,
0.25082075595855713,
0.28721925616264343,
-0.35314202308654785,
-0.3273927569389343,
-0.7342225909233093,
-0.14387765526771545,
0.027842648327350616,
0.5636740326881409,
-0.3285779058933258,
0.8473665714263916,
-0.5456690788269043,
-0.48248207569122314,
-0.44136756658554077,
-0.02674100175499916,
0.08205240964889526,
0.6375246047973633,
0.027792789041996002,
-0.8857975602149963,
-0.3503573536872864,
-0.9284738898277283,
-0.16740235686302185,
-0.3539447486400604,
0.025916671380400658,
0.4457181394100189,
0.23126304149627686,
-0.716558575630188,
1.359885334968567,
-0.37422457337379456,
-0.19276045262813568,
-0.2248150259256363,
-0.2339497208595276,
0.031160935759544373,
0.6575102806091309,
0.8202389478683472,
-0.6506375074386597,
-0.7833952307701111,
0.1455739140510559,
-0.8876382112503052,
-0.4078466594219208,
-0.6976717710494995,
-0.407328337430954,
-0.4244251549243927,
0.12582597136497498,
-0.4580000340938568,
-0.06657896190881729,
0.32608941197395325,
-0.5379827618598938,
0.524177074432373,
-0.17417754232883453,
0.23020273447036743,
-1.5657360553741455,
-0.10731722414493561,
-0.02984224446117878,
-0.41451942920684814,
-0.9746379256248474,
-0.17383447289466858,
-0.2270977795124054,
-0.21799184381961823,
-0.12060065567493439,
0.6998981237411499,
-0.27940845489501953,
-0.3384014070034027,
-0.4963807165622711,
0.21722911298274994,
-0.12594790756702423,
0.7624590992927551,
-0.21093854308128357,
0.7801160216331482,
0.6308603882789612,
-0.6472325325012207,
0.4240407347679138,
0.7620532512664795,
0.03491297736763954,
1.4377143383026123,
-0.4237775206565857,
0.3983050286769867,
-0.2909857928752899,
0.6564663648605347,
-0.674430787563324,
-0.14598096907138824,
0.6610016226768494,
-0.2135627418756485,
0.02113499492406845,
-0.06969992816448212,
0.0378684438765049,
0.012342474423348904,
-0.3287948668003082,
0.11941810697317123,
0.608424961566925,
-0.5429857969284058,
1.0552159547805786,
0.26994046568870544,
-0.501437246799469,
-0.12379025667905807,
-0.04184466600418091,
0.3164770305156708,
-0.529825747013092,
-0.8812627792358398,
0.5557931065559387,
-0.5992262959480286,
-0.30218932032585144,
-0.2474365234375,
-0.18869829177856445,
0.1863410621881485,
0.17977523803710938,
0.40745583176612854,
-0.12537865340709686,
-0.1952318698167801,
-0.16820886731147766,
0.3928261995315552,
-0.3760158121585846,
-0.06249668076634407,
-0.3113211393356323,
0.6306787133216858,
-0.04692769795656204,
-0.10749664157629013,
-0.9739503860473633,
0.29115352034568787,
0.9842548370361328,
-0.14768460392951965,
0.5599350333213806,
0.45969533920288086,
-0.11064483970403671,
-0.11468156427145004,
-0.6623032093048096,
-0.3027917742729187,
-0.5662518739700317,
0.18036681413650513,
-0.8502405881881714,
-0.6053950786590576,
0.9426524639129639,
-0.5576344728469849,
0.3116346597671509,
-0.06277337670326233,
0.5055927038192749,
-0.37527570128440857,
1.1646915674209595,
1.0443212985992432,
0.08119836449623108,
0.8039373159408569,
0.1831849217414856,
0.21167272329330444,
-1.4865187406539917,
-0.4714197516441345,
-0.2991642653942108,
-0.5955801010131836,
-0.6197117567062378,
-0.1808541864156723,
0.21619641780853271,
-0.16569596529006958,
-0.4154888689517975,
0.45476725697517395,
-0.507824718952179,
0.096218541264534,
0.09666021913290024,
0.07029645144939423,
0.08492830395698547,
-0.4655695855617523,
0.2673087418079376,
-0.34224021434783936,
-0.2034713625907898,
-0.6099996566772461,
0.79379802942276,
0.5693478584289551,
0.47846782207489014,
0.3708637058734894,
0.5525205731391907,
0.6032269597053528,
0.14823472499847412,
-0.438228577375412,
0.5871720910072327,
0.2747582793235779,
-0.303425669670105,
-0.10876967012882233,
-0.06652028858661652,
-0.9509531855583191,
0.4192247688770294,
-0.07301631569862366,
-1.2182294130325317,
0.6894031763076782,
0.21096837520599365,
-0.6257590055465698,
-0.34507811069488525,
-0.5319517254829407,
0.8642593026161194,
-0.33162161707878113,
-0.27001842856407166,
-0.3136637508869171,
-0.8566580414772034,
0.03473278135061264,
-0.44937601685523987,
-0.19380606710910797,
-0.46950674057006836,
-0.19101235270500183,
0.5134034752845764,
-0.09609871357679367,
0.6154244542121887,
-0.34477201104164124,
-0.15522809326648712,
-0.16301634907722473,
0.2567674219608307,
0.6083812117576599,
0.19233617186546326,
-0.15385842323303223,
-0.3976005017757416,
0.06622109562158585,
-0.6610338091850281,
-1.1827764511108398,
0.6787136793136597,
-0.7194433212280273,
-0.908225953578949,
-0.49828264117240906,
-0.28322699666023254,
-0.6550012826919556,
0.1726866364479065,
-0.13938960433006287,
0.13163001835346222,
-0.7045915722846985,
0.034299544990062714,
0.707751989364624,
-0.1479903906583786,
0.2200184315443039,
0.7393589615821838,
-0.046656835824251175,
-0.3961039185523987,
0.6847701668739319,
-0.22638142108917236,
0.2650943100452423,
0.16635461151599884,
0.3497233986854553,
-0.2842719852924347,
-0.5349687337875366,
-0.4310179650783539,
0.24811109900474548,
-0.5899211168289185,
0.24428869783878326,
-0.8438208699226379,
0.04661226645112038,
-0.7238701581954956,
-0.5977409482002258,
-0.2500911355018616,
-0.16396699845790863,
-0.40622588992118835,
0.127339705824852,
-0.01385770458728075,
0.481017529964447,
0.1537691056728363,
0.7484789490699768,
-0.5411660075187683,
0.2636910080909729,
0.7808857560157776,
0.18313226103782654,
-0.15237028896808624,
-0.7945373058319092,
-0.02645157277584076,
0.061832722276449203,
-0.5280237793922424,
-1.0345470905303955,
0.2634304463863373,
0.32422059774398804,
0.7303992509841919,
0.6246088147163391,
-0.030087390914559364,
0.8292151093482971,
-0.5707088112831116,
0.7856885194778442,
0.1561724841594696,
-0.8592138290405273,
0.5173342823982239,
-0.7411835789680481,
0.40441879630088806,
0.9109452962875366,
-0.012920277193188667,
-0.8590295910835266,
0.014059504494071007,
-0.6226809024810791,
-0.29961109161376953,
0.5745606422424316,
0.009257085621356964,
0.6512657999992371,
0.6028033494949341,
0.7479019165039062,
0.22335228323936462,
0.41994407773017883,
-0.48894307017326355,
-0.05293333902955055,
-0.33698004484176636,
-0.13486213982105255,
-0.044507674872875214,
-0.0007396299042738974,
-0.15669496357440948,
-0.25201675295829773,
0.5312353372573853,
-0.6758307218551636,
0.5082290768623352,
-0.13225431740283966,
0.02593664638698101,
-0.19278116524219513,
0.16796597838401794,
0.519318699836731,
0.699644923210144,
-0.2136896401643753,
-0.31149980425834656,
0.3688875734806061,
-0.16922593116760254,
0.35650140047073364,
-0.31697723269462585,
-0.034454502165317535,
-0.4267096221446991,
-0.0430523082613945,
0.8804225325584412,
0.6684749126434326,
-0.4713490903377533,
0.42381513118743896,
-0.1821426898241043,
0.07449193298816681,
-0.4395212233066559,
0.3956165909767151,
-0.006888630334287882,
0.7282668948173523,
0.34425604343414307,
0.38315945863723755,
0.14176879823207855,
-0.8592001795768738,
0.17499050498008728,
0.35193565487861633,
-0.5031412243843079,
-0.8279737234115601,
0.5499950647354126,
0.7065756916999817,
-0.8327507376670837,
0.24228845536708832,
-0.07576443254947662,
-0.5565517544746399,
0.109807588160038,
0.5846524238586426,
1.3371812105178833,
-0.6326631307601929,
0.5501604080200195,
-0.17424245178699493,
-0.11081115901470184,
0.1314598023891449,
-0.05773288384079933,
-0.40622779726982117,
-0.8300391435623169,
0.2340891808271408,
-0.6221469640731812,
-0.5903524160385132,
-0.1932053565979004,
-0.48277539014816284,
0.09192728251218796,
-0.5681637525558472,
-0.16487424075603485,
-0.08222159743309021,
0.18406981229782104,
-0.40948963165283203,
0.16124682128429413,
-0.0246854480355978,
0.6697676777839661,
-0.5942899584770203,
0.7585604190826416,
0.5843985080718994,
0.14688041806221008,
-0.27798423171043396,
0.2830808758735657,
0.0048338621854782104,
-0.5646741390228271,
0.28227803111076355,
-0.06323554366827011,
-0.2808821201324463,
0.2725960612297058,
-0.1393103152513504,
-0.9410300850868225,
1.3461112976074219,
0.4674778878688812,
-0.42575129866600037,
-0.33231496810913086,
-0.07731246203184128,
0.8271114826202393,
-0.899819552898407,
0.06202176585793495,
0.6709398031234741,
0.42730772495269775,
0.13833077251911163,
-0.7629174590110779,
-0.13635218143463135,
-0.3403107523918152,
0.1471298784017563,
-0.10873685032129288,
-1.1121677160263062,
0.4253423810005188,
-0.0018695156322792172,
-0.11304362118244171,
0.4139781892299652,
0.8717098236083984,
0.01925663650035858,
0.45892465114593506,
0.6949043869972229,
0.29342344403266907,
0.7165437936782837,
0.025592034682631493,
0.4803139567375183,
-0.5738294720649719,
-0.19303199648857117,
0.9900560975074768,
-0.7987839579582214,
0.39089199900627136,
0.18278968334197998,
0.1083795502781868,
1.2209917306900024,
0.8219242691993713,
0.021553928032517433,
0.6292708516120911,
-0.23768749833106995,
-0.45127174258232117,
-0.3391411006450653,
-0.05906587466597557,
-0.24728746712207794,
0.4513014256954193,
0.2083491086959839,
-0.27471253275871277,
0.03782917186617851,
0.33986690640449524,
-0.16402584314346313,
0.19659225642681122,
0.0025226951111108065,
1.0129488706588745,
-0.04153188318014145,
-0.835326611995697,
0.03902299329638481,
-0.15594680607318878,
0.5721609592437744,
-0.6908355355262756,
0.336154967546463,
-0.2575274407863617,
0.19407011568546295,
-0.2914094030857086,
-0.2609502375125885,
-0.09390890598297119,
-0.40208277106285095,
0.0164851862937212,
-0.5876394510269165,
0.7752705812454224,
-0.06031329184770584,
0.11019417643547058,
0.28398051857948303,
0.6778967976570129,
-0.03378235176205635,
0.09237620234489441,
-1.1193594932556152,
0.053562477231025696,
-0.07671123743057251,
-0.20863217115402222,
0.6461158394813538,
0.22865000367164612,
0.08404003083705902,
1.1276483535766602,
0.600990355014801,
-0.14925768971443176,
-0.059752944856882095,
-0.06880075484514236,
0.9261080026626587,
-0.5938765406608582,
-0.7427758574485779,
-0.5038345456123352,
0.6596275568008423,
-0.23811757564544678,
-0.5926966667175293,
0.8218962550163269,
0.36631765961647034,
0.23185819387435913,
-0.040767401456832886,
0.7222722172737122,
0.08338386565446854,
0.3262472152709961,
0.03496350347995758,
0.5819979906082153,
-0.39277929067611694,
0.18154646456241608,
-0.6624705195426941,
-1.2574740648269653,
0.23447903990745544,
0.6339687705039978,
-0.10851927846670151,
0.2195773720741272,
0.5613296627998352,
0.7840384244918823,
0.03569972142577171,
0.06519613415002823,
0.2650492191314697,
0.05964849516749382,
0.6010815501213074,
0.4592525362968445,
0.8325455784797668,
-0.18354277312755585,
-0.19446006417274475,
-0.2427951693534851,
-0.38545453548431396,
-0.38285234570503235,
-0.611217200756073,
-0.7679911851882935,
-1.0129663944244385,
-0.594566822052002,
-0.34906235337257385,
0.2841435968875885,
1.0239087343215942,
1.0257216691970825,
-0.4211941957473755,
-0.22732549905776978,
0.0019554030150175095,
-0.11332003772258759,
-0.27110040187835693,
-0.1803329437971115,
-0.2550356388092041,
-0.33768388628959656,
-0.8995112776756287,
0.7652415037155151,
0.6969884037971497,
0.25444549322128296,
-0.7036592364311218,
-0.3606452941894531,
0.16902902722358704,
0.4973379969596863,
0.5036391019821167,
0.6398029923439026,
-0.32214000821113586,
-0.648791491985321,
-0.01856735348701477,
-0.10460271686315536,
0.4653765857219696,
1.0047351121902466,
-1.0218791961669922,
0.6133151054382324,
0.2733340561389923,
0.5577917098999023,
0.3260796368122101,
0.40067964792251587,
1.0032603740692139,
-0.3824242055416107,
-0.05915576219558716,
0.4145350754261017,
-0.1357433795928955,
0.36465808749198914,
-0.5543062686920166,
0.14796389639377594,
0.28265684843063354,
-0.7701860666275024,
-1.0820262432098389,
0.49907511472702026,
-1.4187191724777222,
0.02039419487118721,
0.6211262941360474,
-0.015970440581440926,
-0.13026578724384308,
-0.46184977889060974,
-0.32733404636383057,
0.006889635231345892,
-0.588602602481842,
0.9030022025108337,
0.45816728472709656,
-0.6154831051826477,
-0.3592240810394287,
-0.0914493054151535,
0.7604827880859375,
0.39954984188079834,
-1.136267066001892,
-0.08565723150968552,
0.1393953114748001,
0.49033322930336,
0.40161651372909546,
0.9513617157936096,
0.2987975478172302,
0.5083655714988708,
-0.1875266581773758,
-0.32026588916778564,
0.20051370561122894,
-0.3679500222206116,
-0.5055373311042786,
0.23833106458187103,
0.13457098603248596,
-0.00850500725209713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13948v1 | CityGPT: Empowering Urban Spatial Cognition of Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T02:32:16 | 2024-06-20T02:32:16 | Jie Feng, Yuwei Du, Tianhui Liu, Siqi Guo, Yuming Lin, Yong Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models(LLMs) with powerful language generation and reasoning
capabilities have already achieved success in many domains, e.g., math and code
generation. However, due to the lacking of physical world's corpus and
knowledge during training, they usually fail to solve many real-life tasks in
the urban space. In this paper, we propose CityGPT, a systematic framework for
enhancing the capability of LLMs on understanding urban space and solving the
related urban tasks by building a city-scale world model in the model. First,
we construct a diverse instruction tuning dataset CityInstruction for injecting
urban knowledge and enhancing spatial reasoning capability effectively. By
using a mixture of CityInstruction and general instruction data, we fine-tune
various LLMs (e.g., ChatGLM3-6B, Qwen1.5 and LLama3 series) to enhance their
capability without sacrificing general abilities. To further validate the
effectiveness of proposed methods, we construct a comprehensive benchmark
CityEval to evaluate the capability of LLMs on diverse urban scenarios and
problems. Extensive evaluation results demonstrate that small LLMs trained with
CityInstruction can achieve competitive performance with commercial LLMs in the
comprehensive evaluation of CityEval. The source codes are openly accessible to
the research community via https://github.com/tsinghua-fib-lab/CityGPT. | [
-0.43306729197502136,
-0.8328490257263184,
0.9171372652053833,
0.19883377850055695,
0.13152623176574707,
0.20730040967464447,
-0.4367871880531311,
-0.36615070700645447,
-0.256875604391098,
0.3047880530357361,
-0.23830941319465637,
-0.6299347281455994,
-0.2941356897354126,
-0.21716180443763733,
-0.13239063322544098,
0.6678851246833801,
-0.22284820675849915,
0.09479222446680069,
-0.1980295330286026,
0.08249201625585556,
-0.6634917855262756,
-0.28082209825515747,
-0.6532536149024963,
-0.43078768253326416,
0.04678765684366226,
0.5966154932975769,
0.6096217632293701,
0.5953528881072998,
0.4928381145000458,
0.2239374816417694,
0.10230698436498642,
0.2597643733024597,
-0.4226243793964386,
-0.4072056710720062,
-0.3588961660861969,
-0.09923267364501953,
-0.3978803753852844,
-0.28708216547966003,
0.5869730114936829,
0.6596998572349548,
-0.47811323404312134,
0.020311737433075905,
0.11099276691675186,
0.40020737051963806,
-0.31343117356300354,
0.2915094196796417,
-0.520102858543396,
-0.09262971580028534,
0.05701107531785965,
-0.009932821616530418,
0.05190664902329445,
-0.40654563903808594,
0.13035164773464203,
-0.6330815553665161,
0.18412649631500244,
0.336392343044281,
0.37826576828956604,
0.4495072066783905,
-0.4536704123020172,
-0.2118099331855774,
-0.8710805177688599,
0.7224441170692444,
-0.5209885239601135,
0.5576304197311401,
0.24719370901584625,
0.5510411858558655,
-0.1525200754404068,
-0.3909762501716614,
-0.454850435256958,
-0.18195058405399323,
-0.0003616989706642926,
0.18814882636070251,
0.11398123949766159,
0.1320476084947586,
0.4312792718410492,
0.10289217531681061,
-0.7744925022125244,
0.0007172779878601432,
-0.5184553861618042,
0.05305347591638565,
0.4712848961353302,
0.2726529836654663,
0.2139098346233368,
-0.1332777738571167,
-0.4704322814941406,
-0.015582322143018246,
-0.92987459897995,
-0.1127648800611496,
-0.12696605920791626,
0.23859690129756927,
-0.13405956327915192,
0.4008370637893677,
-0.08086829632520676,
0.35161474347114563,
-0.15428170561790466,
0.0019356064731255174,
0.04491998627781868,
-0.28695398569107056,
-0.33353954553604126,
-0.11671624332666397,
0.5691922307014465,
0.02650083415210247,
0.3210597038269043,
-0.21468788385391235,
-0.1028091236948967,
-0.3081817328929901,
0.2175888866186142,
-0.6991904377937317,
-0.3593060374259949,
0.33257997035980225,
0.13039341568946838,
0.03414783254265785,
-0.08849017322063446,
-0.6088264584541321,
-0.3659370243549347,
-0.4308273196220398,
-0.08208420127630234,
-0.5614546537399292,
-0.174660325050354,
0.4418810307979584,
0.10170551389455795,
0.2259783148765564,
0.47640350461006165,
-1.2309869527816772,
-0.026654889807105064,
0.70073002576828,
0.5814275741577148,
0.02062145061790943,
-0.5036920309066772,
0.18359673023223877,
0.5791876316070557,
-0.2810889184474945,
0.8209974765777588,
-0.4574582874774933,
-0.3426213264465332,
-0.05411560833454132,
-0.360836386680603,
-0.022410064935684204,
-0.6899375915527344,
0.5219870209693909,
-0.22747720777988434,
-0.1938854157924652,
-0.19211190938949585,
-0.3009859621524811,
0.02082544006407261,
0.6726602911949158,
-0.42434701323509216,
1.4412200450897217,
0.19952817261219025,
-0.45545825362205505,
0.4014202058315277,
-0.8366227149963379,
-0.3458206057548523,
0.3132193982601166,
-0.1750745326280594,
-0.12370974570512772,
0.017098981887102127,
0.7904418110847473,
0.4462825059890747,
-0.13657082617282867,
0.5999383330345154,
-0.25015389919281006,
-0.37962350249290466,
-0.18663367629051208,
-0.07350768893957138,
0.5153613686561584,
0.0929068997502327,
-0.3053627014160156,
0.0598900280892849,
-0.7166951894760132,
-0.002774871652945876,
0.16810420155525208,
-0.5641646385192871,
-0.15402625501155853,
0.04765850305557251,
-0.01126685831695795,
0.13335444033145905,
0.39185914397239685,
-0.6427602767944336,
0.4066196382045746,
-0.5749091506004333,
0.5643569827079773,
0.5550878047943115,
-0.1524650752544403,
0.7358738780021667,
-0.32237789034843445,
0.4955708086490631,
-0.26109471917152405,
0.06879280507564545,
0.17498040199279785,
-0.35002389550209045,
-0.5195860266685486,
-0.36330124735832214,
-0.11429119110107422,
0.606015682220459,
-0.9369098544120789,
0.3507799506187439,
-0.7267813086509705,
-0.7144483923912048,
-0.3823786675930023,
0.12240434437990189,
-0.07874657213687897,
0.25494804978370667,
0.22532518208026886,
0.3308277428150177,
-0.7713534235954285,
-0.5161909461021423,
-0.004763639997690916,
0.018276581540703773,
-0.2609867453575134,
0.5893179178237915,
0.6907275915145874,
-0.18609634041786194,
1.0031954050064087,
-0.47281503677368164,
-0.11046349257230759,
-0.33752384781837463,
-0.31252264976501465,
0.0838218405842781,
0.42719945311546326,
0.545447587966919,
-0.5004652738571167,
-0.27911946177482605,
0.065607950091362,
-0.7563727498054504,
-0.21101857721805573,
0.10093891620635986,
-0.2093988060951233,
-0.34988662600517273,
0.4621999263763428,
-0.7652225494384766,
0.2531006336212158,
0.49092432856559753,
-0.2763528525829315,
0.6155368685722351,
-0.3913058340549469,
0.13468633592128754,
-0.8459047675132751,
-0.16274859011173248,
-0.050116539001464844,
-0.2382790744304657,
-0.4499662220478058,
0.5434333086013794,
-0.13547348976135254,
-0.5682950615882874,
-0.3770953118801117,
0.773693859577179,
-0.08398979157209396,
-0.2708876430988312,
-0.15790937840938568,
0.6090194582939148,
0.04905190318822861,
0.5257205367088318,
0.2524254620075226,
0.8833345174789429,
0.3475896716117859,
-0.3218945264816284,
0.486159086227417,
0.385946124792099,
-0.815513551235199,
0.12611375749111176,
-0.5728414058685303,
0.30895400047302246,
-0.021710261702537537,
0.375934898853302,
-0.8495794534683228,
-0.23803560435771942,
0.04249969869852066,
-0.0853215828537941,
-0.36955735087394714,
-0.08366239070892334,
-1.0786690711975098,
-0.4039316177368164,
-0.009591296315193176,
0.44160741567611694,
0.13099390268325806,
-0.853705644607544,
0.6089413166046143,
0.21889057755470276,
-0.07047020643949509,
0.011930987238883972,
-0.7033495903015137,
0.03128543868660927,
-0.24751417338848114,
-0.6925414800643921,
-0.12995484471321106,
-0.27275699377059937,
-0.24196772277355194,
-0.2532714009284973,
0.24234753847122192,
-0.11265521496534348,
0.16679958999156952,
-0.02787158451974392,
0.07641739398241043,
0.10851700603961945,
0.24080248177051544,
-0.09987961500883102,
0.014798833057284355,
0.1119484230875969,
-0.6350337266921997,
0.4747975766658783,
-0.1431165337562561,
-0.5102571249008179,
0.27722853422164917,
0.21315792202949524,
0.5098450779914856,
-0.4144395887851715,
0.3726736903190613,
0.6018412113189697,
-0.41961756348609924,
-0.4172437787055969,
-0.3002597391605377,
-0.04164956882596016,
-0.466949462890625,
0.5520603656768799,
-0.41086292266845703,
-1.189017653465271,
0.4474146068096161,
-0.477730929851532,
0.19483456015586853,
-0.07339736819267273,
0.686181366443634,
-0.3281882405281067,
0.8367702960968018,
0.4902610778808594,
-0.03186865523457527,
0.3644907474517822,
-0.1369704157114029,
0.45801711082458496,
-0.9431261420249939,
-0.34839797019958496,
-0.3009028434753418,
-0.3819422721862793,
-0.4880957305431366,
-0.8960018157958984,
0.6356394290924072,
0.052958473563194275,
-0.6460797190666199,
0.270709365606308,
-0.5538610816001892,
0.7276899218559265,
0.4739447832107544,
0.24055606126785278,
0.2961139678955078,
0.21275974810123444,
-0.11209733039140701,
-0.1790110170841217,
-1.010393500328064,
-0.4200229346752167,
0.8969860672950745,
0.3182190954685211,
0.7274866104125977,
0.3665294647216797,
0.5161862969398499,
0.07973810285329819,
0.12744206190109253,
-0.5889248251914978,
0.6226221919059753,
-0.10105685889720917,
-0.6564562916755676,
-0.40182676911354065,
-0.37695634365081787,
-0.8019404411315918,
0.2145473062992096,
-0.22864069044589996,
-0.870129406452179,
-0.04872589558362961,
-0.051757123321294785,
-0.5125844478607178,
0.4283207654953003,
-0.49671635031700134,
0.5777113437652588,
-0.4166557192802429,
-0.26318666338920593,
-0.44108450412750244,
-0.007541046943515539,
0.1883610635995865,
-0.14467781782150269,
0.5272914171218872,
-0.13090255856513977,
0.11957482248544693,
0.20481732487678528,
-0.10022647678852081,
0.8866040110588074,
-0.2136838287115097,
-0.4045478105545044,
0.1589539796113968,
0.03393800929188728,
0.5608160495758057,
0.12988713383674622,
-0.04503696784377098,
0.3447367250919342,
-0.1846211850643158,
-0.467103511095047,
-0.7950753569602966,
0.7034971117973328,
-0.7459073662757874,
-0.4020811915397644,
0.1615932434797287,
-0.9835283160209656,
-0.40361642837524414,
0.028970783576369286,
-0.03193774074316025,
0.43079105019569397,
-0.3228817582130432,
-0.10297975689172745,
0.7436397075653076,
-0.26040974259376526,
0.16941608488559723,
0.4032163918018341,
-0.5380083322525024,
-0.42781487107276917,
0.8081077933311462,
-0.15574496984481812,
-0.031213806942105293,
0.5254659056663513,
0.35162240266799927,
-0.2545401155948639,
-0.6122874617576599,
-0.536933422088623,
-0.1385318636894226,
-0.7349188923835754,
-0.04691159725189209,
-0.12284742295742035,
-0.09165700525045395,
-0.38348594307899475,
-0.4928101599216461,
-0.16784527897834778,
-0.21175476908683777,
0.3002653121948242,
-0.3408825099468231,
0.10138750821352005,
1.1275277137756348,
-0.06463789939880371,
0.293099045753479,
-0.8068926930427551,
-0.0030845373403280973,
0.2015499770641327,
0.3403036594390869,
0.21621154248714447,
-0.2791106402873993,
-0.7470141649246216,
0.20790299773216248,
-0.10892103612422943,
-0.3200462758541107,
0.24786381423473358,
-0.29730507731437683,
0.3144296705722809,
0.1958673745393753,
-0.26737502217292786,
0.7665557861328125,
-0.6010173559188843,
0.7146605253219604,
-0.21347171068191528,
-0.7387202382087708,
0.7793897986412048,
-0.8002261519432068,
0.7536779642105103,
0.3183826506137848,
-0.04874522238969803,
-0.3283797800540924,
-0.510718584060669,
-0.49045225977897644,
-0.7348631024360657,
0.4142032265663147,
0.12487837672233582,
-0.07162922620773315,
-0.0058050802908837795,
0.5493049621582031,
-0.16229532659053802,
0.10904653370380402,
-0.6959454417228699,
0.25985029339790344,
-0.18014588952064514,
-0.2723839282989502,
0.027781540527939796,
-0.14839054644107819,
-0.1682346910238266,
-0.557658314704895,
0.5400148034095764,
-0.20751696825027466,
0.09116338938474655,
0.19686667621135712,
-0.11092369258403778,
0.2168733924627304,
0.3886163532733917,
0.5111455917358398,
0.6807207465171814,
-0.12545554339885712,
-0.024017751216888428,
0.5933347940444946,
-0.4267927408218384,
0.05139421299099922,
-0.001998544903472066,
-0.26102781295776367,
-0.6104845404624939,
0.5492340922355652,
0.6466513872146606,
0.5093896985054016,
-0.7498093247413635,
0.24029654264450073,
0.04865754395723343,
-0.16493578255176544,
-0.31512975692749023,
-0.044021762907505035,
0.12733979523181915,
0.5901573896408081,
0.2838341295719147,
-0.11670030653476715,
-0.0098741315305233,
-0.3381407558917999,
-0.007766520604491234,
0.2340567708015442,
-0.2819846272468567,
-0.058315228670835495,
0.644059419631958,
0.37096062302589417,
0.0004901260836049914,
0.8621222972869873,
-0.30595168471336365,
-0.579958975315094,
0.6111561059951782,
0.6269292831420898,
0.7169437408447266,
0.03277828171849251,
-0.17090509831905365,
0.618793249130249,
0.6459800601005554,
0.08799035847187042,
0.2666303217411041,
-0.015238885767757893,
-1.0674421787261963,
-0.7291611433029175,
-0.6189932823181152,
-0.3074980080127716,
0.13550938665866852,
-0.2278386801481247,
-0.06621895730495453,
-0.7653465867042542,
0.18015989661216736,
-0.7069000601768494,
0.32929036021232605,
-0.5767546892166138,
0.1720852106809616,
0.34057706594467163,
1.175635576248169,
-0.7376989126205444,
0.9246842265129089,
1.149186134338379,
0.04623468220233917,
-0.9736472964286804,
0.06431452184915543,
-0.23848509788513184,
-0.8439702987670898,
0.6265894770622253,
-0.13862420618534088,
-0.14081817865371704,
0.09778937697410583,
-0.8137902617454529,
-0.7672257423400879,
1.248910665512085,
0.45977261662483215,
-0.9145355820655823,
-0.08002281188964844,
0.6052513122558594,
0.5455532670021057,
-0.40310895442962646,
0.14075767993927002,
0.738452136516571,
0.6304415464401245,
0.11140115559101105,
-0.9043828248977661,
0.09093570709228516,
0.24370992183685303,
0.09996533393859863,
0.22184030711650848,
-0.6821708083152771,
0.3399274945259094,
-0.49202340841293335,
-0.08084902912378311,
0.142445370554924,
0.5077439546585083,
0.6278132796287537,
-0.045799773186445236,
0.45057591795921326,
0.9241857528686523,
0.9126348495483398,
-0.3822529911994934,
0.9957624673843384,
-0.36197343468666077,
0.4069540500640869,
1.0672037601470947,
-0.12258024513721466,
0.8072371482849121,
0.07297801226377487,
-0.10842753201723099,
0.337042897939682,
0.5324705243110657,
-0.1889858990907669,
0.5295472145080566,
0.2921145558357239,
-0.37264010310173035,
-0.5498462319374084,
0.047856222838163376,
0.09685451537370682,
0.7135127782821655,
0.5150591731071472,
0.38592612743377686,
-0.47903868556022644,
0.2250785380601883,
-0.13343165814876556,
0.17223848402500153,
-0.3572169542312622,
0.6547927856445312,
0.07652655243873596,
-0.3446601331233978,
0.1301581859588623,
-0.07178370654582977,
0.3905965983867645,
-0.6022461652755737,
-0.21191266179084778,
-0.26358479261398315,
0.2044842392206192,
-0.23213955760002136,
-1.016202688217163,
0.29751625657081604,
-0.17148375511169434,
-0.2960299253463745,
-0.30510377883911133,
0.6971960067749023,
-0.5980892181396484,
-0.4038575291633606,
0.27984723448753357,
0.40995699167251587,
0.15764589607715607,
-0.10091612488031387,
-0.6552093029022217,
-0.022254198789596558,
0.05285748466849327,
0.062036383897066116,
0.2202671766281128,
0.7290893793106079,
-0.23336747288703918,
1.0036327838897705,
0.6926098465919495,
0.3083961009979248,
-0.17645305395126343,
0.3259170651435852,
0.618409276008606,
-0.4895983040332794,
-0.34213942289352417,
-0.6955076456069946,
0.24834714829921722,
-0.02095455303788185,
-0.08469213545322418,
0.681343674659729,
0.7898747324943542,
0.8823522329330444,
0.09768813103437424,
1.0443034172058105,
-0.09805220365524292,
0.30015867948532104,
-0.49929043650627136,
0.6282396912574768,
-0.23912283778190613,
0.5834252834320068,
0.16585996747016907,
-0.8544741868972778,
-0.23915840685367584,
0.6458974480628967,
-0.6545931100845337,
0.07050202786922455,
0.4750180244445801,
0.644788920879364,
-0.1996077299118042,
-0.16276255249977112,
0.5034383535385132,
0.2008163183927536,
0.586164653301239,
0.9962578415870667,
0.920798659324646,
-0.23675227165222168,
0.7847606539726257,
-0.10322803258895874,
-0.2554064989089966,
0.2523944079875946,
-0.6916728019714355,
-1.1040534973144531,
-0.24234046041965485,
-0.057215943932533264,
0.09671548008918762,
0.04947242885828018,
0.6886900067329407,
0.846773624420166,
-0.526402473449707,
-0.10054386407136917,
-0.1941048502922058,
0.039490364491939545,
-0.02564488723874092,
-0.2646130621433258,
0.4210754334926605,
-0.06159406527876854,
-0.9150751829147339,
0.6848275661468506,
0.3589151203632355,
-0.010465151630342007,
-0.42839697003364563,
-0.03975227102637291,
0.1508198082447052,
-0.07894524931907654,
0.7004426717758179,
-0.006675405893474817,
-0.346569299697876,
-0.5374054312705994,
-0.17224887013435364,
-0.21777528524398804,
0.027336660772562027,
0.8363767266273499,
-0.6971929669380188,
0.16498367488384247,
0.24590298533439636,
0.5109207630157471,
0.4907909035682678,
-0.10009893029928207,
0.6481044292449951,
-1.1658189296722412,
0.21661479771137238,
0.04597071185708046,
0.5841361880302429,
0.6120842695236206,
-0.3377004563808441,
0.6495110392570496,
-0.011786218732595444,
-0.8161614537239075,
-0.08824657648801804,
0.4102027416229248,
-0.612209141254425,
-0.23765899240970612,
1.2439661026000977,
0.031172364950180054,
-0.045616183429956436,
-0.16682876646518707,
-0.29708513617515564,
-0.04931764677166939,
-0.4778898060321808,
0.9442095756530762,
0.6684252023696899,
0.13463975489139557,
-0.3041427731513977,
-0.8983168601989746,
0.2266814112663269,
0.08435426652431488,
-1.020120620727539,
0.36107346415519714,
0.42342138290405273,
0.27010244131088257,
0.04452130198478699,
0.6515414714813232,
0.09015455096960068,
0.08324483036994934,
0.028957758098840714,
0.2969300448894501,
-0.2199069857597351,
-0.2997223734855652,
-0.1991482824087143,
-0.05250111594796181,
0.16972261667251587,
0.14152958989143372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13947v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13947v1 | AspirinSum: an Aspect-based utility-preserved de-identification Summarization framework | 2024-06-20T02:29:46 | 2024-06-20T02:29:46 | Ya-Lun Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Due to the rapid advancement of Large Language Model (LLM), the whole
community eagerly consumes any available text data in order to train the LLM.
Currently, large portion of the available text data are collected from
internet, which has been thought as a cheap source of the training data.
However, when people try to extend the LLM's capability to the personal related
domain, such as healthcare or education, the lack of public dataset in these
domains make the adaption of the LLM in such domains much slower. The reason of
lacking public available dataset in such domains is because they usually
contain personal sensitive information. In order to comply with privacy law,
the data in such domains need to be de-identified before any kind of
dissemination. It had been much research tried to address this problem for the
image or tabular data. However, there was limited research on the efficient and
general de-identification method for text data. Most of the method based on
human annotation or predefined category list. It usually can not be easily
adapted to specific domains. The goal of this proposal is to develop a text
de-identification framework, which can be easily adapted to the specific
domain, leverage the existing expert knowledge without further human
annotation. We propose an aspect-based utility-preserved de-identification
summarization framework, AspirinSum, by learning to align expert's aspect from
existing comment data, it can efficiently summarize the personal sensitive
document by extracting personal sensitive aspect related sub-sentence and
de-identify it by substituting it with similar aspect sub-sentence. We envision
that the de-identified text can then be used in data publishing, eventually
publishing our de-identified dataset for downstream task use. | [
-0.15747538208961487,
-0.7147135138511658,
0.17835082113742828,
0.024402890354394913,
-0.36790356040000916,
0.0691620409488678,
-0.3308470845222473,
-0.3757096230983734,
0.3562144935131073,
0.8194676041603088,
-0.07537133246660233,
-0.6242799162864685,
-0.5878677368164062,
0.08948565274477005,
-0.36864516139030457,
1.1150568723678589,
-0.11231857538223267,
-0.4164983034133911,
-0.41240987181663513,
-0.05230998620390892,
-0.055657967925071716,
-0.8194372057914734,
-0.6506204605102539,
-0.3190094828605652,
0.421631395816803,
0.5872654318809509,
0.17547014355659485,
0.7149596810340881,
0.6211088299751282,
0.33687281608581543,
-0.3559720516204834,
0.08157288283109665,
-0.23858407139778137,
0.1024494469165802,
-0.4528765082359314,
-0.21570970118045807,
-0.7165037393569946,
-0.17477644979953766,
0.5989890694618225,
0.7085031270980835,
0.3009061813354492,
0.3360542058944702,
0.5139978528022766,
0.8214465975761414,
-0.8339465856552124,
0.03542047366499901,
-0.466508686542511,
-0.16824595630168915,
-0.19119849801063538,
-0.35905522108078003,
0.014273344539105892,
-0.33821892738342285,
-0.03306475281715393,
-0.501081645488739,
0.31522083282470703,
-0.09329177439212799,
1.0670952796936035,
0.008078640326857567,
-0.6188192367553711,
-0.2891559600830078,
-0.5668445229530334,
0.6325843334197998,
-0.5859498381614685,
-0.1419409215450287,
0.6948981881141663,
0.14337266981601715,
-0.11165142804384232,
-0.4673367440700531,
-0.37758833169937134,
0.15427933633327484,
-0.271992564201355,
-0.07032118737697601,
0.15743562579154968,
0.09057316184043884,
-0.13300934433937073,
0.5404669046401978,
-0.36743345856666565,
0.14872822165489197,
-0.27565693855285645,
-0.28227168321609497,
0.6679685711860657,
-0.031954411417245865,
0.07105376571416855,
-0.4721418023109436,
-0.41786840558052063,
0.2648223340511322,
-0.8209495544433594,
0.04117874428629875,
0.20236064493656158,
0.47930610179901123,
-0.15625396370887756,
0.505862832069397,
-0.4570266008377075,
0.2518743574619293,
0.05104425176978111,
-0.1692577451467514,
0.37802499532699585,
-0.11577007919549942,
-0.49358880519866943,
0.2605768144130707,
0.806817889213562,
0.4537138044834137,
0.0687825009226799,
0.04807916283607483,
-0.03213705122470856,
-0.26854440569877625,
0.04771685600280762,
-1.042076826095581,
-0.39018458127975464,
0.5247783064842224,
-0.4433393180370331,
-0.273059219121933,
-0.08703992515802383,
-0.8097202181816101,
-0.7120087742805481,
-0.2713836431503296,
0.36010420322418213,
-0.6689371466636658,
-0.27976036071777344,
-0.29539063572883606,
-0.0032029126305133104,
-0.28433001041412354,
0.6885931491851807,
-0.9918412566184998,
0.31505537033081055,
0.9526719450950623,
0.7427279353141785,
-0.3350587785243988,
0.021737078204751015,
-0.19646055996418,
0.37116187810897827,
-0.030074309557676315,
0.8872050642967224,
-0.4812811017036438,
-0.44378039240837097,
0.07543685287237167,
0.1883891224861145,
0.08735921233892441,
-0.6292597055435181,
0.535431444644928,
-0.3939988911151886,
0.16289971768856049,
-0.4185221493244171,
-0.4191237688064575,
-0.6174058318138123,
0.632090151309967,
-0.4816155731678009,
0.6243115663528442,
0.024580975994467735,
-1.0242650508880615,
0.495638906955719,
-0.7047235369682312,
-0.5104713439941406,
0.15966707468032837,
-0.13903284072875977,
-0.8132980465888977,
0.0570470467209816,
0.277629017829895,
0.5285312533378601,
-0.3514223098754883,
0.3374834358692169,
-0.19364279508590698,
-0.16038548946380615,
0.4484039843082428,
-0.3264573812484741,
0.7355774641036987,
0.3497310280799866,
-0.06007738411426544,
0.21516448259353638,
-0.6785864233970642,
-0.29102304577827454,
-0.12159978598356247,
-0.3923785388469696,
-0.8236833214759827,
0.000982935423962772,
0.29571282863616943,
-0.07870174199342728,
0.5715330243110657,
-0.4770965874195099,
0.061062075197696686,
-0.42761126160621643,
0.1351717859506607,
0.7016977667808533,
0.35230836272239685,
0.3815973401069641,
-0.3632538914680481,
0.4337628185749054,
0.2727036774158478,
0.039263684302568436,
-0.18672670423984528,
-0.2515144646167755,
-0.7274743914604187,
-0.5015101432800293,
0.6696444153785706,
0.46412956714630127,
-0.7470133304595947,
0.6857661604881287,
-0.5286535620689392,
-0.18080134689807892,
-0.15186768770217896,
0.18085484206676483,
0.6204584240913391,
0.5250252485275269,
0.20320568978786469,
-0.34834104776382446,
-0.3254348933696747,
-1.001800775527954,
-0.43549779057502747,
0.02973957732319832,
-0.31690672039985657,
0.373691588640213,
0.46684718132019043,
-0.11649054288864136,
1.0150697231292725,
-0.5653576850891113,
-0.6673126220703125,
-0.46330922842025757,
0.06759985536336899,
0.1063641756772995,
0.6167541742324829,
0.46575745940208435,
-1.1580361127853394,
-0.46741190552711487,
0.1379995197057724,
-0.5682554841041565,
-0.2367471158504486,
0.22938551008701324,
-0.018177738413214684,
0.2865135073661804,
0.0857010930776596,
0.1246616542339325,
0.46465760469436646,
0.46536412835121155,
-0.641623854637146,
0.09640597552061081,
-0.43040773272514343,
0.7127382755279541,
-1.4481585025787354,
0.6083171963691711,
0.15787391364574432,
-0.4573916494846344,
-0.5812394618988037,
-0.025641832500696182,
0.26881518959999084,
-0.19385851919651031,
-0.32756027579307556,
0.571733295917511,
-0.43176209926605225,
0.23503148555755615,
-0.45180225372314453,
0.2001224309206009,
-0.04766641929745674,
0.5322669148445129,
0.1009872704744339,
0.42899608612060547,
0.3194406032562256,
-0.8872672319412231,
-0.2950035035610199,
0.30453822016716003,
0.028280338272452354,
0.7483334541320801,
-0.3044910728931427,
-0.07558538764715195,
-0.2125236541032791,
-0.10986575484275818,
-0.7737996578216553,
-0.32094746828079224,
0.4096459746360779,
-0.3790680468082428,
0.3403071165084839,
-0.2968593239784241,
-0.3715381920337677,
0.09864462167024612,
-0.4949584901332855,
0.24265660345554352,
0.2892685532569885,
-0.37228283286094666,
0.7549408674240112,
0.8714588284492493,
-0.5308947563171387,
-0.5592966079711914,
-0.4649032652378082,
0.1306697279214859,
-0.550868034362793,
-0.12773257493972778,
0.6688752174377441,
0.2117740511894226,
-0.15990766882896423,
0.17917431890964508,
-0.07638480514287949,
-0.4319116175174713,
0.30097174644470215,
0.5226603746414185,
0.11467833817005157,
0.16178561747074127,
0.3243882656097412,
0.47979193925857544,
-0.2988530397415161,
-0.21937832236289978,
0.17909571528434753,
0.31114712357521057,
0.36050960421562195,
-0.20820629596710205,
-0.5125001668930054,
0.6199665665626526,
0.1362551599740982,
-0.10609493404626846,
0.41085317730903625,
0.1702830046415329,
-0.5199186205863953,
0.09007275104522705,
-0.3880918323993683,
0.12940813601016998,
-0.508217453956604,
0.40018951892852783,
-0.3045601546764374,
-0.8183258771896362,
0.4743286967277527,
-0.4824760854244232,
0.2349119633436203,
0.534727156162262,
0.49386030435562134,
0.05144507437944412,
0.1771802306175232,
0.7694497108459473,
-0.23278066515922546,
0.4918561577796936,
-0.127553328871727,
-0.014955808408558369,
-0.9714424014091492,
-0.21739156544208527,
-0.5953289866447449,
-0.4660412073135376,
-0.39646604657173157,
-0.25718486309051514,
0.5150761008262634,
0.11180861294269562,
-0.10368188470602036,
0.22286942601203918,
-0.718938410282135,
0.34531286358833313,
0.3394370377063751,
0.35107719898223877,
0.5692647695541382,
0.00401360122486949,
0.3446477949619293,
0.10391887277364731,
-0.11506747454404831,
-0.6414387226104736,
1.2021822929382324,
0.29165413975715637,
0.5888163447380066,
0.24785083532333374,
0.8037071228027344,
0.4812433123588562,
0.5520022511482239,
-0.5665566325187683,
0.5389869809150696,
-0.5350286960601807,
-0.6187860369682312,
-0.17655186355113983,
-0.555266261100769,
-1.1215486526489258,
0.13837212324142456,
-0.21883626282215118,
-1.0211163759231567,
0.24018290638923645,
0.5350856184959412,
-0.44909313321113586,
0.13163252174854279,
-0.6258612871170044,
0.6160584092140198,
-0.040028590708971024,
-0.29601413011550903,
-0.16057045757770538,
-0.3683851659297943,
0.10469305515289307,
-0.20510180294513702,
0.22732846438884735,
-0.3930865228176117,
-0.19208618998527527,
1.143964409828186,
-0.5254302620887756,
0.9014409780502319,
-0.38724005222320557,
0.08291903138160706,
0.23501449823379517,
-0.025750650092959404,
0.20682276785373688,
0.13860251009464264,
0.0687597393989563,
0.17817442119121552,
-0.01546669751405716,
-0.2050471156835556,
-0.5327326059341431,
0.8881810307502747,
-0.6340072751045227,
-0.5693913698196411,
-0.3977275490760803,
-0.10557536780834198,
-0.20786306262016296,
0.2944662868976593,
0.2818383276462555,
0.5980529189109802,
-0.19973868131637573,
0.2246461659669876,
0.5876761674880981,
-0.22202780842781067,
0.6597643494606018,
0.7287245392799377,
-0.10093674808740616,
-0.7023239731788635,
0.9304447770118713,
0.2260797619819641,
-0.1621970534324646,
0.8236072063446045,
0.37433382868766785,
-0.2356429398059845,
-0.6514753699302673,
-0.15140457451343536,
0.01647372730076313,
-0.5459660887718201,
-0.4687390923500061,
-0.9287058711051941,
-0.1273743212223053,
-0.43269848823547363,
-0.2949717938899994,
-0.31321221590042114,
-0.4649510085582733,
-0.39948976039886475,
0.2244352549314499,
0.6573433876037598,
0.5517218708992004,
0.16314412653446198,
0.24825860559940338,
-0.6282511949539185,
0.32263538241386414,
0.07032158225774765,
0.27394306659698486,
-0.06889928877353668,
-0.6036038398742676,
-0.28190913796424866,
0.008886892348527908,
-0.3008917272090912,
-0.7306746244430542,
0.604917585849762,
0.27454403042793274,
0.2540190815925598,
0.5284275412559509,
0.3055570721626282,
0.4917941689491272,
-0.2558803856372833,
0.6697044372558594,
0.12561413645744324,
-0.9521222114562988,
0.5278167724609375,
-0.22508284449577332,
0.049627941101789474,
0.8684957027435303,
0.3910595178604126,
-0.47739866375923157,
-0.3153427243232727,
-0.6368840336799622,
-1.3229337930679321,
0.44312864542007446,
0.13651378452777863,
0.028342893347144127,
0.40408429503440857,
0.391254723072052,
0.3572767972946167,
0.49489814043045044,
-0.3857867419719696,
-0.28303632140159607,
-0.028879521414637566,
-0.43887826800346375,
-0.09543361514806747,
-0.4172069728374481,
-0.10850581526756287,
-0.21329158544540405,
0.7577865123748779,
-0.10374052822589874,
0.16382956504821777,
0.3535420298576355,
-0.15291447937488556,
0.29927191138267517,
0.5137143135070801,
0.4741436243057251,
0.34946608543395996,
-0.21109594404697418,
0.356153666973114,
-0.0077014523558318615,
-0.8401534557342529,
0.21263912320137024,
0.11956266313791275,
-0.0671447291970253,
-0.1995985209941864,
0.1705278903245926,
0.27458980679512024,
0.2520599365234375,
-0.45035287737846375,
0.7602914571762085,
0.2102937400341034,
-0.07398772984743118,
-0.6166822910308838,
0.19507364928722382,
-0.18889610469341278,
-0.07698474824428558,
0.549837052822113,
-0.03785894811153412,
0.39317774772644043,
-0.36862003803253174,
0.31837329268455505,
0.13824142515659332,
-0.6012281775474548,
-0.35872524976730347,
0.6139536499977112,
0.4249451756477356,
-0.43108227849006653,
0.20752324163913727,
-0.23513641953468323,
-0.39270973205566406,
0.47778376936912537,
0.31136125326156616,
1.1063872575759888,
-0.33061161637306213,
0.033333007246255875,
0.06549440324306488,
-0.11369061470031738,
0.22414466738700867,
0.3361509144306183,
-0.12363014370203018,
-0.6282063722610474,
-0.2971601188182831,
-0.6055827736854553,
-0.20686352252960205,
0.1670263409614563,
-0.539831817150116,
0.255220890045166,
-0.5752995610237122,
-0.16973160207271576,
0.07296118885278702,
0.2513629198074341,
-0.44896039366722107,
0.3215898275375366,
-0.1312916874885559,
0.6178950667381287,
-1.0683178901672363,
0.9208971261978149,
0.7330846786499023,
-0.16974028944969177,
-0.5294362902641296,
0.177982896566391,
0.2722170054912567,
-0.4417373836040497,
0.36573243141174316,
0.10529033839702606,
0.11496611684560776,
-0.20362135767936707,
-0.16560359299182892,
-0.6717759966850281,
1.1037981510162354,
0.24539823830127716,
-0.3128933906555176,
0.25456252694129944,
-0.04775221273303032,
0.5339273810386658,
-0.34797701239585876,
0.10235769301652908,
0.39083144068717957,
0.3165450990200043,
0.4451802968978882,
-0.9760122895240784,
0.36669018864631653,
-0.4716004729270935,
-0.008718626573681831,
0.24646960198879242,
-0.619982123374939,
0.8237700462341309,
0.012717312201857567,
-0.1865926831960678,
-0.13941942155361176,
0.6387494802474976,
0.03466805815696716,
0.417491614818573,
0.338652104139328,
0.2372003048658371,
0.6411429643630981,
0.04052531719207764,
0.7441629767417908,
-0.23668129742145538,
0.392306387424469,
1.0996547937393188,
-0.12836632132530212,
0.9309855699539185,
0.2586970329284668,
0.03475185111165047,
0.2884661555290222,
0.48689916729927063,
0.23861739039421082,
0.6006374955177307,
-0.14310820400714874,
-0.3285800516605377,
-0.003395615378394723,
-0.2143300324678421,
-0.20078983902931213,
0.5238016843795776,
0.5302059650421143,
-0.7335399389266968,
-0.2040063738822937,
0.04775681719183922,
0.4122782051563263,
0.17023883759975433,
-0.5606448650360107,
1.1361852884292603,
-0.040525712072849274,
-0.3661980628967285,
0.3579021692276001,
0.16687710583209991,
0.8071295619010925,
-0.49101629853248596,
0.08106760680675507,
-0.14581716060638428,
0.22065284848213196,
-0.42610350251197815,
-0.574407160282135,
0.36026743054389954,
0.030576134100556374,
-0.09232429414987564,
-0.1129680797457695,
0.8179190754890442,
-0.5695720911026001,
-0.41364312171936035,
-0.3125741183757782,
0.21627011895179749,
0.17096062004566193,
-0.2652064263820648,
-0.4819045960903168,
-0.1671820431947708,
0.08694659918546677,
-0.18570716679096222,
0.7067912817001343,
0.5726036429405212,
-0.11317227780818939,
0.48823168873786926,
0.23286780714988708,
0.23034940659999847,
-0.8481795787811279,
-0.1736575961112976,
1.0349160432815552,
-0.7736178636550903,
-0.9529951810836792,
-0.9336902499198914,
0.6449621319770813,
-0.6180921792984009,
-0.44240379333496094,
0.7705560922622681,
0.8034640550613403,
0.08520197868347168,
0.10614408552646637,
0.9000216722488403,
-0.21938255429267883,
0.8936065435409546,
-0.4908682703971863,
1.2146624326705933,
-0.5117327570915222,
0.21527405083179474,
-0.5219330191612244,
-0.48916342854499817,
-0.4058225154876709,
0.2600775361061096,
-0.42787691950798035,
-0.06666678935289383,
0.7542440295219421,
0.637701690196991,
-0.05560208857059479,
-0.11482551693916321,
0.26835596561431885,
0.00737513555213809,
0.4845985472202301,
0.4064718186855316,
0.10878001898527145,
-0.2727878987789154,
0.2172403633594513,
-0.21852409839630127,
-0.6309664249420166,
-0.6090057492256165,
-0.9400721788406372,
-1.2084028720855713,
-0.9750718474388123,
-0.72808837890625,
-0.12429880350828171,
0.0787646695971489,
0.9766517281532288,
0.4275962710380554,
-1.0354318618774414,
0.10694662481546402,
0.1875092089176178,
0.07063373178243637,
-0.30728909373283386,
-0.21519240736961365,
0.9246956706047058,
0.14366081357002258,
-0.6618000268936157,
-0.10367461293935776,
0.4874386787414551,
0.13321584463119507,
-0.06689754873514175,
0.45764103531837463,
0.07457868754863739,
-0.08598963171243668,
0.4570097029209137,
0.3582511842250824,
-0.35420525074005127,
-0.36591285467147827,
-0.4917881488800049,
0.053799841552972794,
0.12452463805675507,
1.0280307531356812,
-0.6808233261108398,
0.3519027531147003,
0.3900696337223053,
0.5114794373512268,
0.13864946365356445,
0.5015087723731995,
0.49944818019866943,
-0.80772465467453,
0.3412001132965088,
0.29469045996665955,
0.17519058287143707,
0.40848833322525024,
-0.777582049369812,
0.19997577369213104,
0.06659750640392303,
-0.5424332022666931,
-0.49102306365966797,
-0.028378905728459358,
-0.937235414981842,
-0.3627035915851593,
1.2938168048858643,
-0.43001189827919006,
-0.6556457281112671,
-0.6119934320449829,
-0.24591951072216034,
0.08087955415248871,
-0.6963983774185181,
1.0789506435394287,
-0.03258522227406502,
-0.11780200898647308,
-0.005714297294616699,
0.01588345132768154,
0.8238605260848999,
-0.11702714115381241,
-0.985329270362854,
0.4461205005645752,
0.3111192286014557,
0.43669605255126953,
0.22192110121250153,
0.9868767857551575,
-0.15462292730808258,
-0.158269003033638,
-0.1303628385066986,
0.08227228373289108,
-0.385073721408844,
-0.22460409998893738,
-0.27643996477127075,
0.678633451461792,
0.07345486432313919,
-0.5041215419769287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13945v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13945v1 | CityBench: Evaluating the Capabilities of Large Language Model as World Model | 2024-06-20T02:25:07 | 2024-06-20T02:25:07 | Jie Feng, Jun Zhang, Junbo Yan, Xin Zhang, Tianjian Ouyang, Tianhui Liu, Yuwei Du, Siqi Guo, Yong Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) with powerful generalization ability has been
widely used in many domains. A systematic and reliable evaluation of LLMs is a
crucial step in their development and applications, especially for specific
professional fields. In the urban domain, there have been some early
explorations about the usability of LLMs, but a systematic and scalable
evaluation benchmark is still lacking. The challenge in constructing a
systematic evaluation benchmark for the urban domain lies in the diversity of
data and scenarios, as well as the complex and dynamic nature of cities. In
this paper, we propose CityBench, an interactive simulator based evaluation
platform, as the first systematic evaluation benchmark for the capability of
LLMs for urban domain. First, we build CitySim to integrate the multi-source
data and simulate fine-grained urban dynamics. Based on CitySim, we design 7
tasks in 2 categories of perception-understanding and decision-making group to
evaluate the capability of LLMs as city-scale world model for urban domain. Due
to the flexibility and ease-of-use of CitySim, our evaluation platform
CityBench can be easily extended to any city in the world. We evaluate 13
well-known LLMs including open source LLMs and commercial LLMs in 13 cities
around the world. Extensive experiments demonstrate the scalability and
effectiveness of proposed CityBench and shed lights for the future development
of LLMs in urban domain. The dataset, benchmark and source codes are openly
accessible to the research community via
https://github.com/tsinghua-fib-lab/CityBench | [
-0.4612423777580261,
-0.7982755303382874,
0.7124946117401123,
0.528259813785553,
-0.10672403872013092,
0.33385607600212097,
-0.47584083676338196,
-0.4396650791168213,
-0.1517765372991562,
0.22567519545555115,
-0.18564294278621674,
-0.8647850155830383,
-0.11413832008838654,
-0.05846952274441719,
-0.4768697917461395,
0.3321760296821594,
-0.23790335655212402,
0.3755466639995575,
-0.44772738218307495,
-0.19399230182170868,
-0.440199613571167,
-0.3391159772872925,
-0.691959023475647,
-0.4522136449813843,
0.03571959212422371,
0.3618323802947998,
0.4108697772026062,
0.4389294683933258,
0.5830997824668884,
0.3342714309692383,
-0.016859527677297592,
-0.13711562752723694,
-0.4751302897930145,
-0.16623741388320923,
-0.45452359318733215,
-0.02669256366789341,
-0.4386243224143982,
-0.14610622823238373,
0.7863691449165344,
0.7447380423545837,
-0.4868237376213074,
0.3545079231262207,
0.04581515118479729,
0.367220014333725,
-0.3117749094963074,
0.24649083614349365,
-0.3177732825279236,
-0.10344204306602478,
-0.13474197685718536,
0.1692846268415451,
-0.0284800436347723,
-0.40365105867385864,
0.09762085974216461,
-0.21877145767211914,
-0.11403997987508774,
0.3363230526447296,
0.4203663766384125,
-0.00657724728807807,
-0.4513956308364868,
-0.06163734942674637,
-0.9402182102203369,
0.7597621083259583,
-0.5469486713409424,
0.6235921382904053,
-0.12523995339870453,
0.7839771509170532,
-0.22121599316596985,
-0.6239316463470459,
-0.5057202577590942,
-0.4140337407588959,
0.21771065890789032,
0.10396569222211838,
-0.042310453951358795,
-0.01909610629081726,
0.3231772184371948,
0.34251081943511963,
-0.6930684447288513,
0.13703982532024384,
-0.2759651839733124,
0.019592663273215294,
0.470737487077713,
0.5687304735183716,
0.1469620168209076,
-0.3382551670074463,
-0.5433945059776306,
-0.07216401398181915,
-0.4702606499195099,
0.07265131920576096,
0.04168793931603432,
0.22888082265853882,
-0.39282625913619995,
0.2915850579738617,
-0.3640249967575073,
0.4081968069076538,
-0.32516616582870483,
-0.23797433078289032,
0.47672978043556213,
-0.4130859375,
-0.25882473587989807,
-0.32338955998420715,
0.8956934213638306,
0.39709410071372986,
0.11285971105098724,
-0.3384788930416107,
-0.159697026014328,
-0.18083269894123077,
0.11889426410198212,
-0.8201268911361694,
0.09301693737506866,
0.4417811632156372,
-0.27119287848472595,
-0.1502685397863388,
-0.06972797960042953,
-0.9693570733070374,
-0.3702644109725952,
-0.22372888028621674,
-0.22859524190425873,
-0.24331779778003693,
-0.3442876636981964,
0.1938290297985077,
0.21743953227996826,
0.3364608883857727,
0.5762868523597717,
-0.6537458300590515,
0.4469461143016815,
0.6149179935455322,
0.8387057781219482,
-0.5276564359664917,
-0.37119778990745544,
-0.035644449293613434,
0.23747165501117706,
-0.2509629428386688,
0.7267118096351624,
-0.3531906008720398,
-0.5044042468070984,
-0.09210637956857681,
-0.24621188640594482,
0.25683125853538513,
-0.7279850244522095,
0.6624230146408081,
-0.32271626591682434,
-0.5133776068687439,
0.03199497237801552,
-0.31809237599372864,
-0.03312581405043602,
0.590392529964447,
-0.7326765656471252,
1.3947951793670654,
0.18061891198158264,
-0.4348030984401703,
0.31527721881866455,
-0.7645696401596069,
-0.24142278730869293,
0.3030489683151245,
-0.24843548238277435,
-0.12243809551000595,
0.021447792649269104,
0.1543467938899994,
0.16570045053958893,
-0.5507530570030212,
0.7203824520111084,
-0.519127607345581,
-0.5200707316398621,
0.06679926067590714,
-0.20219604671001434,
0.6553066372871399,
0.2733003497123718,
-0.28654664754867554,
0.15744145214557648,
-0.9327677488327026,
0.0032267991919070482,
0.11840490996837616,
-0.48877736926078796,
-0.1819407045841217,
0.030687006190419197,
0.32504385709762573,
0.37283894419670105,
0.3859620988368988,
-0.8133054971694946,
0.3238457143306732,
-0.36657968163490295,
0.2411894053220749,
0.5175145864486694,
-0.1322403848171234,
0.36788350343704224,
-0.0629490464925766,
0.7377181053161621,
-0.1984882354736328,
0.12939919531345367,
0.2853237986564636,
-0.11177339404821396,
-0.5353634357452393,
-0.32302775979042053,
0.4272066056728363,
0.42962610721588135,
-0.6650069952011108,
0.28984832763671875,
-0.6175405383110046,
-0.7535048127174377,
-0.4523457884788513,
0.09582990407943726,
0.004893493838608265,
-0.007436785381287336,
-0.06351596117019653,
-0.14912840723991394,
-0.7963953018188477,
-0.7759785056114197,
-0.0893295481801033,
-0.03627147898077965,
-0.0809931755065918,
0.37031352519989014,
0.6200228333473206,
-0.28240832686424255,
1.0125975608825684,
-0.16645601391792297,
-0.03276750445365906,
-0.479849636554718,
-0.08903948217630386,
0.0791442021727562,
0.3116745948791504,
0.7478160858154297,
-0.4521256685256958,
-0.2939568758010864,
-0.2463379055261612,
-0.6140056848526001,
-0.30522939562797546,
0.11968633532524109,
-0.25412485003471375,
-0.18854953348636627,
0.43663424253463745,
-0.6210460662841797,
0.3048798441886902,
0.7159000039100647,
0.0599370002746582,
0.6963743567466736,
-0.0017174935201182961,
0.19796548783779144,
-0.853783905506134,
0.368523508310318,
-0.14776477217674255,
-0.45882856845855713,
-0.31305891275405884,
0.46978047490119934,
-0.05548199266195297,
-0.40705326199531555,
-0.5574173331260681,
0.992487370967865,
-0.048511724919080734,
-0.46429577469825745,
-0.029501458629965782,
0.560683012008667,
-0.011676291935145855,
0.35313892364501953,
-0.09057722240686417,
0.6773015856742859,
0.41228318214416504,
-0.28143391013145447,
0.7910753488540649,
0.09815673530101776,
-1.0458059310913086,
0.33861762285232544,
-0.5149643421173096,
0.13914595544338226,
0.14676950871944427,
0.40757158398628235,
-0.7570765614509583,
-0.08806885033845901,
-0.007436943240463734,
0.08514085412025452,
-0.404278427362442,
0.09111329168081284,
-1.2144654989242554,
-0.7439485788345337,
-0.2806287705898285,
0.3193570375442505,
0.1213177889585495,
-0.5484877228736877,
0.624579131603241,
0.38355743885040283,
-0.05634517967700958,
-0.00914149358868599,
-0.5788627862930298,
0.24056746065616608,
-0.10735613107681274,
-0.5425926446914673,
-0.03716423362493515,
-0.4752807319164276,
-0.44848644733428955,
-0.3070826530456543,
0.04887827858328819,
-0.08255016803741455,
0.28603795170783997,
0.3262592554092407,
0.15791182219982147,
0.2238273322582245,
0.027898019179701805,
-0.2680271863937378,
0.00880935788154602,
0.09662751108407974,
0.04746934026479721,
0.6203315854072571,
-0.33214420080184937,
-0.46646445989608765,
0.04005686938762665,
0.10510258376598358,
0.6971290707588196,
-0.337603360414505,
0.42018672823905945,
0.45852041244506836,
-0.397311806678772,
-0.31008419394493103,
-0.4198976457118988,
0.2693859040737152,
-0.4389409124851227,
0.55632483959198,
-0.48004937171936035,
-0.847228467464447,
0.6353046298027039,
-0.7457146048545837,
0.1665773242712021,
0.08758611232042313,
0.7639580368995667,
-0.05143625661730766,
0.8847350478172302,
0.5304919481277466,
-0.03847012296319008,
0.21517735719680786,
-0.09203774482011795,
0.20593804121017456,
-0.8383978605270386,
-0.38246282935142517,
-0.4862828850746155,
-0.322138249874115,
-0.39972418546676636,
-0.6662651300430298,
0.520341694355011,
0.2460494488477707,
-0.19826076924800873,
0.1507389396429062,
-0.016509708017110825,
0.41729772090911865,
0.20717167854309082,
-0.12145938724279404,
0.630656361579895,
-0.022876227274537086,
-0.5634695291519165,
-0.053089652210474014,
-0.5581369400024414,
-0.6493023037910461,
0.889763593673706,
0.48163506388664246,
0.8475459218025208,
0.16927365958690643,
0.44556084275245667,
0.192315012216568,
0.43219077587127686,
-0.5875070691108704,
0.7993626594543457,
0.0351438894867897,
-0.8001670837402344,
-0.19386844336986542,
-0.3676035702228546,
-0.7388158440589905,
0.34754717350006104,
-0.19564761221408844,
-0.8667147755622864,
-0.012249446474015713,
-0.28903597593307495,
-0.42702725529670715,
0.4327940046787262,
-0.2155115157365799,
0.7481201887130737,
-0.5335085391998291,
-0.2956418991088867,
-0.44395574927330017,
-0.09886619448661804,
0.28871896862983704,
-0.3814025819301605,
0.6659420132637024,
-0.39394572377204895,
0.16949503123760223,
0.43369510769844055,
-0.12259123474359512,
0.5478103756904602,
-0.13444392383098602,
-0.2277699112892151,
0.14942441880702972,
0.16506052017211914,
0.31783613562583923,
0.030657991766929626,
-0.5500005483627319,
0.5714036822319031,
-0.07173001766204834,
-0.12314094603061676,
-0.569181501865387,
0.8849952816963196,
-0.6224241256713867,
-0.2462339997291565,
-0.08502442389726639,
-0.5814270973205566,
-0.4261986017227173,
0.24759157001972198,
-0.39161455631256104,
0.3929766118526459,
-0.8010034561157227,
0.20342248678207397,
0.027441000565886497,
-0.2726745009422302,
0.3173767030239105,
0.9776134490966797,
-1.0586813688278198,
-0.31520572304725647,
0.6715138554573059,
-0.2290578931570053,
-0.057689014822244644,
0.1666385382413864,
0.17540186643600464,
-0.17251135408878326,
-0.7346510887145996,
-0.6544199585914612,
-0.19904294610023499,
-0.5721740126609802,
-0.05963163450360298,
-0.27598807215690613,
-0.03575556352734566,
-0.06509524583816528,
-0.14458103477954865,
-0.4024769067764282,
-0.06459104269742966,
0.41656967997550964,
-0.2684745490550995,
-0.017270460724830627,
0.8982653617858887,
-0.015409854240715504,
0.06577355414628983,
-0.6728269457817078,
0.33297818899154663,
0.05069481208920479,
0.8187844753265381,
0.3124442398548126,
0.02831023745238781,
-0.6571559906005859,
0.03830134868621826,
-0.29769963026046753,
-0.38758695125579834,
0.21113723516464233,
-0.37282758951187134,
0.5158278942108154,
0.35120007395744324,
-0.04577959328889847,
0.6402689814567566,
-0.48591768741607666,
0.6307151317596436,
-0.1389705240726471,
-0.7473303079605103,
0.3547588288784027,
-0.467276394367218,
0.5894429683685303,
0.80610191822052,
0.03538571670651436,
-0.4404798746109009,
-0.6207498908042908,
-0.388166606426239,
-0.75162273645401,
0.5673224925994873,
0.07521317899227142,
0.0010540008079260588,
0.02354838140308857,
0.25362691283226013,
0.0922425165772438,
0.42358532547950745,
-0.6674410700798035,
-0.15284542739391327,
0.15724655985832214,
-0.071995310485363,
0.05133868381381035,
-0.18338601291179657,
0.018933845683932304,
-0.49856165051460266,
0.3435437083244324,
0.061204563826322556,
-0.19612997770309448,
-0.0244899969547987,
-0.17027591168880463,
-0.1898937225341797,
0.5173100829124451,
0.20690752565860748,
0.9712802171707153,
-0.4442376494407654,
-0.07512400299310684,
0.5692679286003113,
-0.20553898811340332,
0.09513405710458755,
0.056461598724126816,
-0.2589994966983795,
-0.20981445908546448,
0.254421204328537,
0.6860167980194092,
0.48638296127319336,
-1.0694698095321655,
0.5313799381256104,
-0.041083142161369324,
0.016803987324237823,
-0.40226271748542786,
-0.12882623076438904,
0.3057331144809723,
0.48948946595191956,
0.3261139392852783,
-0.1681295782327652,
0.17554308474063873,
-0.5892795324325562,
-0.013643353246152401,
0.30557817220687866,
-0.2559114694595337,
-0.06452246010303497,
0.5138403177261353,
0.4832248091697693,
-0.10442071408033371,
0.6082572340965271,
-0.33013302087783813,
-0.5101494193077087,
0.5600495934486389,
0.3244044780731201,
0.7558090686798096,
-0.12180577963590622,
-0.1380167454481125,
0.4236385226249695,
0.3908092677593231,
0.10277950018644333,
0.34701764583587646,
0.15243187546730042,
-0.6228733062744141,
-0.46607255935668945,
-1.0263986587524414,
-0.6156646013259888,
0.2247178703546524,
-0.4362497627735138,
0.2923547029495239,
-0.6665788292884827,
-0.14318609237670898,
-0.45132118463516235,
0.3322657346725464,
-0.7362493872642517,
0.0875607281923294,
0.37158310413360596,
1.3978681564331055,
-0.5054913759231567,
0.9048877954483032,
0.9888846278190613,
0.0679219514131546,
-0.49568676948547363,
0.03300157189369202,
-0.129819855093956,
-0.6270305514335632,
0.5733871459960938,
0.08941762894392014,
-0.3400611877441406,
-0.07735773921012878,
-0.6297664046287537,
-0.6951293349266052,
1.150012731552124,
0.4117581248283386,
-1.0482455492019653,
0.09308313578367233,
0.5749118328094482,
0.717866063117981,
-0.42252856492996216,
0.4653902053833008,
0.7049736380577087,
0.8158093690872192,
-0.008520145900547504,
-1.071972131729126,
0.14476731419563293,
-0.006971067748963833,
0.2960413992404938,
-0.0714685469865799,
-0.9492827653884888,
0.457777738571167,
-0.19082389771938324,
-0.15299230813980103,
0.33791327476501465,
0.4270070791244507,
0.33570796251296997,
-0.06277625262737274,
0.5749900341033936,
0.6854895949363708,
0.43986549973487854,
-0.17188483476638794,
1.0765146017074585,
-0.5545127391815186,
0.6039956212043762,
0.981863796710968,
-0.4941512942314148,
0.9976778626441956,
0.11729944497346878,
-0.3910825550556183,
0.6707605719566345,
0.36941879987716675,
-0.26424771547317505,
0.40641188621520996,
0.5686246752738953,
-0.023701896890997887,
-0.3529634177684784,
-0.10229220986366272,
0.11621544510126114,
0.7127349972724915,
0.2330036610364914,
0.3589327931404114,
-0.6305635571479797,
0.1092614233493805,
-0.2853114902973175,
-0.11096573621034622,
-0.1854323148727417,
0.5951602458953857,
0.07994348555803299,
-0.21326826512813568,
0.23449935019016266,
0.39112189412117004,
0.3833269774913788,
-0.7947665452957153,
-0.06636303663253784,
-0.1976822316646576,
0.06023012101650238,
-0.09354165941476822,
-0.7869192957878113,
0.12280438095331192,
-0.040492672473192215,
-0.14719122648239136,
-0.11365170776844025,
0.5380342602729797,
-0.3898189961910248,
-0.48967233300209045,
0.7389450669288635,
0.41958409547805786,
0.2250034511089325,
-0.004492732230573893,
-0.823064386844635,
0.5211449265480042,
-0.18579591810703278,
-0.2692219614982605,
0.22759823501110077,
0.38942232728004456,
-0.20358915627002716,
0.9131694436073303,
0.6687192916870117,
0.1777932494878769,
-0.3088566064834595,
0.43323612213134766,
0.6874004602432251,
-0.7122354507446289,
-0.38761964440345764,
-0.734393298625946,
0.2539593577384949,
-0.1068730428814888,
-0.03279867768287659,
0.8411773443222046,
0.9386452436447144,
0.6916321516036987,
0.1357051432132721,
0.8677115440368652,
-0.08817961066961288,
0.5404648184776306,
-0.13165752589702606,
0.690855860710144,
-0.46907636523246765,
0.5085525512695312,
-0.2611582577228546,
-1.0001524686813354,
-0.10994941741228104,
0.42993831634521484,
-0.3775826394557953,
0.08759795874357224,
0.6426082849502563,
0.387010395526886,
-0.19944648444652557,
-0.09265182912349701,
0.45054471492767334,
0.402175635099411,
0.2600409984588623,
0.4781233072280884,
0.8080100417137146,
-0.1182703748345375,
0.6785274744033813,
-0.22876740992069244,
-0.27783653140068054,
-0.26155829429626465,
-0.8584532737731934,
-0.9089670181274414,
-0.12781552970409393,
-0.018223147839307785,
0.05164705216884613,
-0.022690195590257645,
0.7867001891136169,
0.7234772443771362,
-0.7841124534606934,
-0.5885899066925049,
0.11868402361869812,
0.06044020876288414,
-0.048258308321237564,
-0.28454774618148804,
0.17476052045822144,
0.22642745077610016,
-0.9037814140319824,
0.585677981376648,
0.4105304777622223,
-0.004888701718300581,
-0.7460542321205139,
-0.012422413565218449,
0.04764312505722046,
-0.08230474591255188,
0.6282032132148743,
-0.05448507145047188,
-0.47283241152763367,
-0.18912406265735626,
-0.3803870975971222,
-0.45170092582702637,
0.03406618535518646,
0.7380609512329102,
-0.8727890849113464,
0.43837979435920715,
0.19577927887439728,
0.32536399364471436,
0.5742905139923096,
-0.04005720838904381,
0.6251437067985535,
-0.7126343846321106,
0.16548797488212585,
-0.10547655820846558,
0.45896658301353455,
0.46722981333732605,
0.1755497008562088,
0.6423608660697937,
-0.05841519311070442,
-0.3594028651714325,
-0.46560633182525635,
0.11348868161439896,
-0.8345411419868469,
-0.17290985584259033,
1.1592315435409546,
-0.06438800692558289,
-0.045064136385917664,
-0.1964137852191925,
-0.17489871382713318,
-0.01155559066683054,
-0.5757739543914795,
0.7517560720443726,
0.8067601323127747,
0.18848301470279694,
-0.006288998294621706,
-1.0102564096450806,
0.09991740435361862,
0.08012618124485016,
-1.00538170337677,
0.3344533145427704,
0.4970017671585083,
0.42540812492370605,
0.028008105233311653,
0.6697798371315002,
-0.1026390939950943,
-0.012662583962082863,
-0.10704529285430908,
0.4447014033794403,
-0.04007720574736595,
-0.28137901425361633,
-0.3238448202610016,
0.08301497995853424,
0.2552586495876312,
0.26660481095314026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13940v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13940v1 | AutoCAP: Towards Automatic Cross-lingual Alignment Planning for Zero-shot Chain-of-Thought | 2024-06-20T02:19:33 | 2024-06-20T02:19:33 | Yongheng Zhang, Qiguang Chen, Min Li, Wanxiang Che, Libo Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual chain-of-thought can effectively complete reasoning tasks
across languages, which gains increasing attention. Recently, dominant
approaches in the literature improve cross-lingual alignment capabilities by
integrating reasoning knowledge from different languages. Despite achieving
excellent performance, current methods still have two main challenges: (1)
Manual language specification: They still highly rely on manually selecting the
languages to integrate, severely affecting their generalizability; (2) Static
weight allocation: Current methods simply integrate all languages equally. In
fact, different language reasoning paths should have different weights to
achieve better complementation and integration. Motivated by this, we introduce
an Automatic Cross-lingual Alignment Planning (AutoCAP) for zero-shot
chain-of-thought to address the above challenges. The core of AutoCAP consists
of two components: (1) Automatic Language Selection Prompting to guide LLMs to
select appropriate languages and (2) Automatic Weight Allocation Prompting to
automatically allocate alignment weight scores to each reasoning path.
Extensive experiments on several benchmarks reveal that AutoCAP achieves
state-of-the-art performance, surpassing previous methods that required manual
effort. | [
-0.5010223388671875,
-0.40913620591163635,
0.5057141780853271,
0.20516559481620789,
-0.11246217787265778,
0.4607192873954773,
-0.09944838285446167,
-0.6762641668319702,
0.5114602446556091,
0.2661435902118683,
-0.6049503684043884,
-0.264418363571167,
-0.4852065443992615,
0.060942817479372025,
-0.05638638883829117,
0.6580999493598938,
-0.7809078693389893,
-0.09480760991573334,
-0.04305205121636391,
-0.26006191968917847,
-0.940428614616394,
-0.05127934366464615,
-0.36249664425849915,
-0.16403399407863617,
0.497132807970047,
0.7630302906036377,
0.6824085712432861,
0.904678225517273,
0.41741472482681274,
0.18651308119297028,
0.5750807523727417,
0.22216945886611938,
-0.04728185012936592,
0.21201656758785248,
-0.6003128886222839,
-0.26657018065452576,
-0.6985057592391968,
-0.12667685747146606,
0.5645100474357605,
0.7747408747673035,
-0.026494598016142845,
0.09742001444101334,
-0.2935277223587036,
0.6590628623962402,
-1.0310653448104858,
-0.04560430347919464,
-0.8671785593032837,
0.3752313554286957,
-0.04299396649003029,
-0.0953613743185997,
-0.14166639745235443,
0.23450469970703125,
0.19345718622207642,
-0.8336058855056763,
-0.4001569449901581,
0.5206549167633057,
0.6953425407409668,
0.4229296147823334,
-0.19857044517993927,
-0.29983073472976685,
-0.5092151165008545,
0.8573791980743408,
-0.3564097285270691,
0.29534000158309937,
0.10606027394533157,
0.41170749068260193,
0.11398667842149734,
-0.04720977321267128,
-0.541244387626648,
0.22929832339286804,
-0.0950220450758934,
0.1514892429113388,
-0.44804641604423523,
0.02952107973396778,
0.21192362904548645,
0.3230040967464447,
-0.9171785116195679,
0.18809910118579865,
-0.0910378023982048,
-0.33975932002067566,
0.724398672580719,
0.13770918548107147,
0.7714772820472717,
0.25110748410224915,
-0.45939499139785767,
0.04452921822667122,
-0.5216584801673889,
-0.2451283186674118,
0.2706177532672882,
0.2093680053949356,
0.04991767928004265,
0.7334800362586975,
-0.5870597958564758,
0.8795914649963379,
0.44920989871025085,
0.32421714067459106,
0.16625547409057617,
-0.5350275635719299,
-0.5560874342918396,
0.5771065354347229,
0.9630031585693359,
0.3585226535797119,
0.46762675046920776,
-0.2149493247270584,
-0.10370117425918579,
-0.020777694880962372,
0.232697993516922,
-0.36992257833480835,
-0.15100286900997162,
0.10070331394672394,
0.2167837917804718,
0.00020007356943096966,
-0.39889946579933167,
-0.4684014916419983,
0.2578006386756897,
-0.39561551809310913,
0.5656307339668274,
-0.2463979870080948,
-0.11691657453775406,
0.4017398953437805,
-0.001116539933718741,
0.47239813208580017,
0.32385313510894775,
-1.1237632036209106,
0.25296902656555176,
0.3709343373775482,
0.735167920589447,
-0.5346211194992065,
-0.6781741976737976,
-0.5597551465034485,
0.6655161380767822,
-0.5881715416908264,
1.0413024425506592,
-0.36226800084114075,
0.13261491060256958,
-0.038154784590005875,
-0.018115997314453125,
-0.25790268182754517,
-0.06038562208414078,
0.08836301416158676,
-0.3659264147281647,
0.44868654012680054,
-0.5425479412078857,
-0.4072381854057312,
-0.11640767753124237,
0.6376108527183533,
-0.4640284776687622,
0.8889956474304199,
-0.059247564524412155,
-0.6205072999000549,
0.5877928137779236,
-0.482999712228775,
-0.7490071654319763,
0.15017001330852509,
-0.33584511280059814,
-0.05022355541586876,
-0.39544668793678284,
0.6534625887870789,
0.12172628194093704,
-0.4006022810935974,
0.22703668475151062,
-0.2874663174152374,
-0.28594496846199036,
-0.24037155508995056,
-0.11241540312767029,
0.9882764220237732,
0.3133469521999359,
-0.877920925617218,
0.17803853750228882,
-0.36397427320480347,
0.1977824568748474,
0.0316510833799839,
0.4114604592323303,
-0.22025272250175476,
-0.43641865253448486,
-0.33476513624191284,
0.38800209760665894,
0.3855494558811188,
-0.48346492648124695,
0.6428080201148987,
-0.5208998918533325,
0.12297935038805008,
0.45734795928001404,
-0.1309632956981659,
0.8593844771385193,
-0.1918763667345047,
0.6975484490394592,
-0.07440709322690964,
0.3096815049648285,
-0.10639342665672302,
-0.4093051552772522,
-0.8501217365264893,
-0.07014411687850952,
0.1591164767742157,
0.859580934047699,
-0.7958491444587708,
0.7297004461288452,
0.018061591312289238,
-0.4648405909538269,
-0.5267395377159119,
0.33632025122642517,
0.5737809538841248,
0.5292952060699463,
0.45368021726608276,
-0.7782928943634033,
-0.44598838686943054,
-1.0290933847427368,
-0.3466885983943939,
-0.35044023394584656,
0.21478232741355896,
0.04364559426903725,
0.4150432348251343,
-0.024055255576968193,
1.0213656425476074,
-0.6122024655342102,
-0.5635620355606079,
-0.279071182012558,
0.4104780852794647,
-0.13170482218265533,
0.4723166227340698,
0.5783587098121643,
-0.19870655238628387,
-0.9390437006950378,
0.15847600996494293,
-0.708118736743927,
-0.5588043332099915,
-0.5567408800125122,
-0.7757980823516846,
0.3143279552459717,
0.39359399676322937,
-0.4157288074493408,
0.3069193959236145,
0.3231838643550873,
-0.15518437325954437,
0.4970704913139343,
-0.19818605482578278,
0.046378180384635925,
-0.6640332341194153,
0.16368389129638672,
-0.23215515911579132,
-0.21481646597385406,
-0.28665637969970703,
-0.28113582730293274,
0.008389313705265522,
0.14595943689346313,
-0.4410330653190613,
0.7166361808776855,
-0.8895083069801331,
-0.4239406883716583,
-0.2389269471168518,
0.186565101146698,
0.19152313470840454,
0.730396568775177,
0.28401318192481995,
0.7286948561668396,
0.887033998966217,
-0.33072152733802795,
0.39251258969306946,
0.21609537303447723,
-0.3784947693347931,
0.8604511022567749,
-0.40355736017227173,
0.030733026564121246,
0.17173095047473907,
0.25341498851776123,
-1.066758155822754,
0.02090791054069996,
0.6940975785255432,
-0.22633589804172516,
0.587975800037384,
0.11890468001365662,
-0.42284539341926575,
-0.139008030295372,
-0.13889919221401215,
0.9304646253585815,
-0.04479534924030304,
-0.20706407725811005,
0.5235157012939453,
0.8029228448867798,
-0.08248262852430344,
-0.9146968722343445,
-0.9539498090744019,
0.3530921936035156,
0.10968614369630814,
-0.2956993877887726,
0.44008368253707886,
-0.12362165004014969,
0.032291434705257416,
0.13616546988487244,
-0.15350335836410522,
0.11708731204271317,
-0.4121367037296295,
-0.20335842669010162,
0.5003567934036255,
0.06907127052545547,
-0.14594048261642456,
0.374216228723526,
-0.3016988933086395,
-0.18145006895065308,
-0.795554518699646,
0.3510950207710266,
-0.14971040189266205,
-0.591228723526001,
-0.3635275959968567,
0.3571743071079254,
0.6736105680465698,
-0.27552059292793274,
0.09880421310663223,
0.3626209497451782,
-0.22074680030345917,
-0.16867677867412567,
-0.8573275804519653,
0.3992760479450226,
-0.37937816977500916,
-0.07187226414680481,
-0.17945154011249542,
-0.598207950592041,
0.3247162997722626,
0.1604081392288208,
0.30560964345932007,
0.45196691155433655,
0.6460580229759216,
-0.23525968194007874,
0.9727751612663269,
0.5537457466125488,
-0.38285133242607117,
0.3321293294429779,
-0.08787517994642258,
0.3074783980846405,
-0.804071307182312,
-0.017538294196128845,
0.06233038380742073,
-0.657582700252533,
-0.31937679648399353,
-0.660173773765564,
0.14719632267951965,
-0.14690060913562775,
-0.38384705781936646,
0.7728352546691895,
-0.7711427211761475,
0.6375564336776733,
0.26128891110420227,
-0.6479536890983582,
0.2956700623035431,
0.013605784624814987,
-0.7085230350494385,
0.11714700609445572,
-0.9576042890548706,
-0.08614015579223633,
0.869270384311676,
0.06869109719991684,
0.5432350039482117,
-0.3617554008960724,
0.5337812900543213,
0.15174172818660736,
0.16609632968902588,
-0.8224740028381348,
0.5956988334655762,
0.04868115112185478,
-0.7960994839668274,
-0.5333383083343506,
-0.049434635788202286,
-0.6118839383125305,
0.21759149432182312,
-0.019825560972094536,
-0.7079154849052429,
0.5063435435295105,
0.11753416806459427,
-0.5723531246185303,
0.38862884044647217,
-0.34518077969551086,
0.8984878659248352,
-0.7797306776046753,
-0.1871204674243927,
0.00648283027112484,
-0.8948476314544678,
0.27529776096343994,
-0.04741740599274635,
0.16315186023712158,
-0.194440558552742,
-0.15282504260540009,
0.5923335552215576,
-0.2751133143901825,
0.8017430305480957,
0.14876562356948853,
-0.28729698061943054,
0.49631354212760925,
0.2673613131046295,
0.41390129923820496,
-0.41906481981277466,
0.28443166613578796,
0.3558849096298218,
0.021308528259396553,
-0.350396066904068,
-0.5785513520240784,
0.5245871543884277,
-0.4681822657585144,
-0.4411575198173523,
-0.6938731074333191,
-1.0460118055343628,
-0.33917298913002014,
0.427785187959671,
0.14939063787460327,
-0.1530410498380661,
-0.15674623847007751,
-0.43651634454727173,
0.39355209469795227,
-0.3357740640640259,
0.521079957485199,
0.7186845541000366,
-0.36469724774360657,
-0.9635031819343567,
0.8867512941360474,
0.38249558210372925,
0.49961909651756287,
0.6834279298782349,
-0.11265071481466293,
-0.18701240420341492,
-0.11040329933166504,
-0.9813172221183777,
0.32885706424713135,
-0.5881305932998657,
-0.36787113547325134,
-0.6336875557899475,
-0.09733881801366806,
-0.4829418957233429,
-0.6280713677406311,
-0.5129911303520203,
-0.7283979058265686,
0.23789967596530914,
0.017149923369288445,
-0.15073361992835999,
0.21198688447475433,
-0.42506667971611023,
0.08451344072818756,
-0.45492854714393616,
0.2947964370250702,
0.3491671085357666,
0.3543407917022705,
-0.04439866170287132,
-0.2270917296409607,
-0.21303938329219818,
-0.14395028352737427,
-0.32025113701820374,
-0.8071342706680298,
0.3666870892047882,
-0.02918628416955471,
0.5527015328407288,
0.47311097383499146,
0.038574617356061935,
1.1210683584213257,
-0.5885581374168396,
0.4164881110191345,
0.5032479763031006,
-1.0682531595230103,
0.5699118375778198,
-0.20443139970302582,
0.7136063575744629,
0.9161616563796997,
0.6221580505371094,
-0.7206616401672363,
-0.5646628737449646,
-0.40330758690834045,
-0.7038419246673584,
0.5799906849861145,
0.12459583580493927,
-0.37656137347221375,
-0.06647919863462448,
0.02098570391535759,
0.14057908952236176,
0.18063689768314362,
-0.5597549676895142,
-0.04420746490359306,
0.02595381624996662,
-0.07084371894598007,
0.3368518054485321,
0.18228210508823395,
-0.07568610459566116,
-0.6289267539978027,
0.7011555433273315,
-0.4597417712211609,
0.15933161973953247,
0.256399542093277,
-0.3568900525569916,
-0.7487253546714783,
0.03847747668623924,
0.4473682641983032,
0.699404776096344,
0.05141184478998184,
0.07063759118318558,
0.5195276737213135,
-0.20673736929893494,
0.18708235025405884,
-0.23615971207618713,
-0.3194427192211151,
-0.1675749570131302,
0.3496707081794739,
0.6850982308387756,
0.44463253021240234,
-0.6621828675270081,
0.4629210829734802,
0.14992542564868927,
-0.43454858660697937,
-0.25676801800727844,
-0.0035582806449383497,
-0.1885204166173935,
0.19494885206222534,
0.09200094640254974,
-0.06223774328827858,
-0.03190605714917183,
-0.754645824432373,
0.3164309859275818,
0.6804168820381165,
-0.5542821288108826,
-0.08792336285114288,
0.49795934557914734,
-0.01630084030330181,
0.1276806890964508,
0.5475926399230957,
-0.3191031813621521,
-0.7680339217185974,
0.4232882857322693,
0.32933613657951355,
1.2712496519088745,
-0.19156597554683685,
0.22830848395824432,
0.45343437790870667,
0.575329601764679,
-0.013245907612144947,
0.3687111437320709,
-0.4217354953289032,
-0.8777866363525391,
-0.9240565299987793,
-0.5009015202522278,
-0.5923969149589539,
-0.4856150150299072,
-0.5079019665718079,
0.4945237934589386,
-0.37884238362312317,
0.17666003108024597,
-0.2774110436439514,
0.1607268750667572,
-0.5386087894439697,
0.2229999303817749,
0.5470505952835083,
0.9425756335258484,
-1.0238064527511597,
1.0108263492584229,
0.5215635895729065,
-0.5999641418457031,
-0.678087592124939,
0.0729374811053276,
0.13622960448265076,
-1.063449740409851,
0.7639277577400208,
-0.005600744858384132,
-0.358340322971344,
-0.11605241149663925,
-0.1900670975446701,
-1.119952917098999,
1.1840083599090576,
0.2648438513278961,
-0.9365490674972534,
-0.4044038653373718,
0.48239949345588684,
0.29868388175964355,
-0.7351189255714417,
0.36309608817100525,
0.525360107421875,
0.6386640667915344,
0.5931195616722107,
-1.294263243675232,
0.2133975476026535,
-0.013983012177050114,
-0.2783409655094147,
0.3920811712741852,
-0.746839165687561,
0.31747376918792725,
-0.14616025984287262,
-0.30008411407470703,
-0.3758834898471832,
0.6606032252311707,
0.014667471870779991,
0.24436162412166595,
0.8269462585449219,
0.9299440979957581,
0.524342954158783,
0.23855385184288025,
0.4657300114631653,
-0.6277434825897217,
0.003979021683335304,
1.2864724397659302,
-0.6714999079704285,
0.6551358699798584,
0.4986957013607025,
0.0009639974450692534,
0.4452473223209381,
0.49419209361076355,
-0.24643389880657196,
0.555353045463562,
-0.021794913336634636,
0.14674022793769836,
-0.3916266858577728,
-0.1026143953204155,
-0.12993378937244415,
0.6009390354156494,
0.20018237829208374,
0.01722724549472332,
-0.3420514762401581,
-0.12985505163669586,
-0.15741413831710815,
-0.4652899205684662,
-0.19889065623283386,
0.750090479850769,
0.007067036349326372,
-1.1474772691726685,
0.5605656504631042,
-0.4292471408843994,
0.5293727517127991,
-0.4401589632034302,
0.05878058448433876,
0.010751117020845413,
-0.17655090987682343,
-0.11197645217180252,
-0.9564303755760193,
0.8260189890861511,
0.06171465665102005,
0.12654371559619904,
-0.7071856260299683,
0.7763071656227112,
-0.7577137351036072,
-0.40164676308631897,
0.46123209595680237,
0.5321023464202881,
0.13455501198768616,
0.0500013567507267,
-0.8675810098648071,
-0.02474777214229107,
-0.08604320138692856,
0.09080647677183151,
0.43877974152565,
0.5761451125144958,
-0.15028060972690582,
0.5143447518348694,
0.5434542298316956,
0.26299870014190674,
-0.1367342323064804,
-0.15797661244869232,
0.6356149911880493,
-0.6122382283210754,
-0.4523477554321289,
-0.7889416217803955,
0.3740513026714325,
-0.07575927674770355,
-0.3046795129776001,
0.4437832534313202,
0.7214785218238831,
1.1924468278884888,
0.2463340014219284,
0.6128678917884827,
-0.17618945240974426,
0.008926362730562687,
-0.35146528482437134,
0.7013696432113647,
-0.7837751507759094,
0.06790180504322052,
-0.41858580708503723,
-0.9223117232322693,
-0.5768926739692688,
0.6495287418365479,
-0.6353556513786316,
-0.48913219571113586,
0.965444803237915,
0.4544188976287842,
0.050283655524253845,
-0.2425824999809265,
0.29936984181404114,
-0.18065938353538513,
0.18066495656967163,
0.9267916679382324,
0.4075174033641815,
-0.344226598739624,
0.702142059803009,
-0.37627819180488586,
-0.3312443196773529,
-0.0522964708507061,
-1.1766321659088135,
-0.6536825895309448,
-0.5028440952301025,
-0.6835706233978271,
0.3523148000240326,
-0.03374625742435455,
0.9852765202522278,
0.5462841987609863,
-0.7563451528549194,
-0.6534146070480347,
-0.32373765110969543,
0.10075601935386658,
-0.43522897362709045,
-0.17326731979846954,
0.11364871263504028,
-0.7245308756828308,
-0.6948968768119812,
0.32139715552330017,
0.9938940405845642,
-0.2892378568649292,
-0.4842773973941803,
-0.03824333846569061,
-0.5826209187507629,
0.17312085628509521,
0.42900440096855164,
0.739784836769104,
-0.7655627131462097,
-0.1729385405778885,
0.16876080632209778,
-0.22246535122394562,
0.16095057129859924,
0.8718066215515137,
-0.7071719765663147,
0.8663101196289062,
0.6167515516281128,
0.7152918577194214,
0.4958938658237457,
-0.2948325276374817,
1.0626336336135864,
-0.4268156588077545,
-0.031274572014808655,
0.33323928713798523,
0.5008219480514526,
0.009053638204932213,
-0.22693566977977753,
0.4922363758087158,
0.11467848718166351,
-0.5860878825187683,
-0.7425887584686279,
0.3188583552837372,
-1.0231032371520996,
-0.2649727761745453,
0.8441392183303833,
0.09076234698295593,
-0.2815020978450775,
-0.08831340074539185,
-0.23151974380016327,
0.50926274061203,
0.002316695172339678,
0.7012683749198914,
0.9876123070716858,
-0.4554167687892914,
-0.12652906775474548,
-0.44961026310920715,
0.2850407361984253,
0.8115805387496948,
-0.6794312000274658,
0.2625593841075897,
0.2797700762748718,
-0.01511803362518549,
0.32163622975349426,
0.809605062007904,
-0.13471777737140656,
0.35313838720321655,
-0.2796366214752197,
0.30072784423828125,
0.25665947794914246,
-0.6350339651107788,
0.0537089928984642,
-0.12566927075386047,
-0.25555774569511414,
-0.18514691293239594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13934v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13934v1 | Reasoning Like a Doctor: Improving Medical Dialogue Systems via Diagnostic Reasoning Process Alignment | 2024-06-20T02:02:53 | 2024-06-20T02:02:53 | Kaishuai Xu, Yi Cheng, Wenjun Hou, Qiaoyu Tan, Wenjie Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Medical dialogue systems have attracted significant attention for their
potential to act as medical assistants. Enabling these medical systems to
emulate clinicians' diagnostic reasoning process has been the long-standing
research focus. Previous studies rudimentarily realized the simulation of
clinicians' diagnostic process by fine-tuning language models on high-quality
dialogue datasets. Nonetheless, they overly focus on the outcomes of the
clinician's reasoning process while ignoring their internal thought processes
and alignment with clinician preferences. Our work aims to build a medical
dialogue system that aligns with clinicians' diagnostic reasoning processes. We
propose a novel framework, Emulation, designed to generate an appropriate
response that relies on abductive and deductive diagnostic reasoning analyses
and aligns with clinician preferences through thought process modeling.
Experimental results on two datasets confirm the efficacy of Emulation.
Crucially, our framework furnishes clear explanations for the generated
responses, enhancing its transparency in medical consultations. | [
-0.3793768286705017,
-0.6292089819908142,
1.3078055381774902,
-0.29771688580513,
-0.32630252838134766,
0.03975992649793625,
-0.017394324764609337,
-0.25779294967651367,
0.7479914426803589,
0.5794369578361511,
-0.4070882499217987,
-0.33217769861221313,
-0.49024099111557007,
0.19491417706012726,
-0.0920104905962944,
0.48310619592666626,
0.0041198814287781715,
0.3515092730522156,
-0.2932344377040863,
-0.004249474965035915,
-0.4942041337490082,
-0.3513529896736145,
-0.7530583739280701,
-0.4604150056838989,
-0.016281846910715103,
0.28457993268966675,
1.1305125951766968,
0.727449893951416,
0.215634286403656,
0.22957278788089752,
0.20873667299747467,
0.36727628111839294,
-0.07866984605789185,
0.6076401472091675,
-0.24544988572597504,
-0.16222167015075684,
-0.688717782497406,
-0.15629218518733978,
0.3133290112018585,
0.7577683329582214,
-0.38269472122192383,
-0.19628500938415527,
0.011039488948881626,
0.16809582710266113,
-0.32100605964660645,
-0.09474717825651169,
-0.08136127144098282,
0.17750175297260284,
0.36700376868247986,
-0.3609893023967743,
-0.3217252492904663,
-0.5552398562431335,
0.1181013286113739,
-0.850426435470581,
0.08235988765954971,
-0.15675359964370728,
0.39872944355010986,
0.4562329351902008,
-0.05213700234889984,
-0.10198618471622467,
-0.9710252285003662,
0.2800998091697693,
-1.0324933528900146,
0.2691798210144043,
0.363474577665329,
0.4199634790420532,
-0.1003006100654602,
-0.5285754799842834,
-0.5489224791526794,
0.21408982574939728,
-0.14744602143764496,
0.3116406500339508,
-0.1252233386039734,
0.26875048875808716,
0.378616064786911,
0.037827007472515106,
-0.30419889092445374,
0.039438556879758835,
0.004302918445318937,
0.2179218828678131,
0.5990786552429199,
0.5041797161102295,
0.15305501222610474,
0.25039175152778625,
-0.11688753217458725,
0.19162724912166595,
-0.5029084086418152,
-0.11371143907308578,
-0.22664782404899597,
-0.045932088047266006,
-0.0068463608622550964,
0.6041789054870605,
-0.16795966029167175,
0.8080970644950867,
0.5857413411140442,
-0.24902427196502686,
0.14118081331253052,
-0.20041058957576752,
-0.6316429376602173,
0.41355618834495544,
0.827357828617096,
0.6742138266563416,
0.12068260461091995,
0.002350049326196313,
-0.0687314122915268,
0.2106035351753235,
0.6723670363426208,
-0.3638383448123932,
-0.2136780470609665,
0.749762237071991,
-0.5649436116218567,
-0.29585176706314087,
-0.2633456587791443,
-0.5869505405426025,
-0.6391619443893433,
-0.5676122903823853,
0.2188149392604828,
-0.5505896210670471,
-0.38234296441078186,
0.35534656047821045,
0.01111338660120964,
-0.045482173562049866,
0.7514442801475525,
-0.9127097725868225,
0.571514904499054,
0.8489240407943726,
0.47586923837661743,
0.20167845487594604,
0.2132534682750702,
-0.564917266368866,
0.4227713346481323,
-0.3299773335456848,
0.8830217123031616,
-1.0117872953414917,
-0.6809847354888916,
-0.11205533146858215,
-0.010248908773064613,
-0.21522043645381927,
-0.6447198987007141,
0.24710342288017273,
0.15841738879680634,
0.238576278090477,
-0.03905848413705826,
-0.767238199710846,
0.059169504791498184,
0.37052422761917114,
-0.107383131980896,
0.43452468514442444,
-0.013615495525300503,
-0.47737419605255127,
0.27581271529197693,
-0.6121023297309875,
-0.18623390793800354,
0.06409657001495361,
-0.6606661677360535,
0.06495394557714462,
0.1169067993760109,
0.41573020815849304,
0.3227922022342682,
-0.4698027968406677,
0.2667236030101776,
-0.5427507758140564,
-0.3922427296638489,
0.2384943813085556,
-0.17158019542694092,
0.7206754684448242,
0.2402152717113495,
-0.3267520070075989,
-0.06417758017778397,
-0.4300500750541687,
-0.0016303855227306485,
-0.130716934800148,
0.2978162467479706,
-0.3846522867679596,
-0.016018031165003777,
-0.6838507056236267,
0.1501380354166031,
-0.12282779067754745,
-0.7736682891845703,
0.5385836958885193,
-0.708130419254303,
0.08730088919401169,
0.30308735370635986,
0.15541936457157135,
0.4264709949493408,
-0.6823939681053162,
1.053749680519104,
0.25227707624435425,
0.26775601506233215,
-0.1833442896604538,
-0.7882305979728699,
-0.2868674397468567,
-0.3787458539009094,
0.0638856440782547,
0.6644050478935242,
-0.39378270506858826,
0.21732552349567413,
-0.14398318529129028,
-0.4057983160018921,
-1.110131859779358,
-0.21616590023040771,
0.35754460096359253,
0.6498622894287109,
0.17990632355213165,
-0.4959498345851898,
-0.29804807901382446,
-0.7732842564582825,
-0.0404350571334362,
-0.19495314359664917,
-0.0886245146393776,
0.5087355375289917,
-0.2920123040676117,
-0.15801407396793365,
0.8479587435722351,
-0.6442393064498901,
-0.1742897778749466,
0.033933550119400024,
-0.3447519540786743,
0.2602728605270386,
0.6508703827857971,
0.3427247405052185,
-0.41921237111091614,
-0.30040279030799866,
0.20082491636276245,
-0.8649242520332336,
-0.23977096378803253,
-0.27034127712249756,
-0.08968422561883926,
0.20896878838539124,
0.5871893763542175,
-0.6361119747161865,
0.7503223419189453,
0.2733020782470703,
-0.5133357048034668,
0.40207624435424805,
-0.4279226064682007,
0.5345212817192078,
-1.3396844863891602,
0.13551227748394012,
-0.17876531183719635,
-0.3894752562046051,
-0.49703726172447205,
-0.14563938975334167,
-0.35994061827659607,
-0.22137071192264557,
-0.22343994677066803,
0.621160089969635,
-0.1534913182258606,
0.034565381705760956,
-0.30422720313072205,
0.18356263637542725,
0.2498691976070404,
-0.07961581647396088,
0.19422462582588196,
0.3498525321483612,
0.5574220418930054,
-0.45966801047325134,
0.598666250705719,
0.7053651213645935,
0.0821283608675003,
1.078362226486206,
-0.6373968124389648,
0.02366877719759941,
0.05165516957640648,
0.22124461829662323,
-0.9197297692298889,
-0.12086997926235199,
0.6503810882568359,
-0.4106258451938629,
0.42193159461021423,
-0.3964407444000244,
-0.457811564207077,
-0.183136984705925,
0.09843877702951431,
0.47674760222435,
0.6296611428260803,
-0.3382464051246643,
0.7458732724189758,
0.4911898374557495,
-0.43609189987182617,
-0.34885087609291077,
-0.4239693284034729,
-0.06853950768709183,
-0.20297053456306458,
-0.45487135648727417,
0.19607453048229218,
0.04334939643740654,
-0.4171810746192932,
-0.03170621395111084,
0.10876461863517761,
-0.11001451313495636,
0.0666765421628952,
0.43863314390182495,
0.1271888017654419,
-0.23392605781555176,
0.20029132068157196,
0.622829020023346,
-0.1766672283411026,
0.21149255335330963,
-0.11496733874082565,
0.45826178789138794,
0.2940877079963684,
-0.8323401808738708,
-0.7459278702735901,
0.5359468460083008,
0.7027239203453064,
-0.0956018790602684,
0.35301345586776733,
0.018031440675258636,
-0.5063647031784058,
0.14198192954063416,
-0.45946386456489563,
-0.41234368085861206,
-0.3722265958786011,
-0.20182394981384277,
-0.5286712050437927,
-0.37763556838035583,
0.42290282249450684,
-0.21401478350162506,
0.363960325717926,
0.056040626019239426,
0.6940937638282776,
-0.3922387957572937,
1.7329543828964233,
-0.016532015055418015,
0.609754204750061,
-0.11540354043245316,
0.0754086896777153,
0.2921997308731079,
-0.8868687748908997,
-0.34252089262008667,
-0.24987861514091492,
-0.33537840843200684,
-0.23688668012619019,
-0.4547864496707916,
0.4892544448375702,
-0.1163124293088913,
-0.28413328528404236,
0.05144071206450462,
-0.8552481532096863,
0.13567835092544556,
0.39611005783081055,
0.24781635403633118,
0.3995492160320282,
-0.22310477495193481,
-0.5553436875343323,
-0.03399692103266716,
-0.7405731678009033,
-0.7709506750106812,
0.8078241944313049,
0.2806345522403717,
0.9852586388587952,
0.17216850817203522,
1.118338942527771,
-0.030080430209636688,
0.15247468650341034,
-0.5725544095039368,
0.3876941204071045,
-0.19774620234966278,
-0.2832120656967163,
-0.10569804906845093,
-0.03163261339068413,
-0.9366796612739563,
0.1301037222146988,
-0.2389085739850998,
-0.7464964389801025,
0.30907687544822693,
0.5321412682533264,
-0.8248067498207092,
0.17185349762439728,
-0.6172630190849304,
0.7629825472831726,
0.1348549723625183,
-0.25227952003479004,
-0.315107136964798,
-0.7302298545837402,
0.16813190281391144,
0.060229070484638214,
0.22069647908210754,
0.021878594532608986,
0.12130296230316162,
0.18217749893665314,
-0.5864331126213074,
1.033666968345642,
-0.2906513810157776,
-0.2305539846420288,
-0.0562763549387455,
0.524495542049408,
-0.03954337537288666,
0.39742356538772583,
-0.04125479608774185,
-0.28928476572036743,
0.5847963094711304,
-0.18944217264652252,
-0.8963115215301514,
0.7625386118888855,
-0.2397342324256897,
-1.161285638809204,
-0.3348456621170044,
-0.3610084652900696,
-0.5332664251327515,
-0.028685614466667175,
-0.10504903644323349,
0.5586044192314148,
-0.4104321300983429,
-0.5132608413696289,
0.48692786693573,
-0.11400686204433441,
-0.11562047898769379,
0.3494817912578583,
-0.44392964243888855,
-0.1462433934211731,
0.3048609793186188,
-0.1959664672613144,
0.4015335440635681,
0.056231703609228134,
0.21209551393985748,
-0.1930866837501526,
-0.13163049519062042,
-0.8837909698486328,
0.2888408601284027,
-0.5016005635261536,
-0.2626368999481201,
-0.8276214599609375,
-0.1271963119506836,
-0.6874980926513672,
-0.34030434489250183,
-0.19800809025764465,
-0.6746314764022827,
-0.3987015187740326,
0.12776343524456024,
0.3475842773914337,
0.7116366624832153,
-0.031169435009360313,
0.03054034523665905,
-0.8630765676498413,
0.25350403785705566,
0.08850836008787155,
0.2888672351837158,
0.06766647845506668,
-0.5071282386779785,
0.0029255489353090525,
0.41624152660369873,
-0.6653751730918884,
-0.9674974083900452,
0.3521018326282501,
-0.02666746824979782,
0.5600389838218689,
0.8810126185417175,
0.0733766034245491,
0.7556848526000977,
-0.6742445230484009,
0.7250320911407471,
0.14510712027549744,
-0.8148062825202942,
0.8659070730209351,
-0.07575029879808426,
0.18172040581703186,
0.396195650100708,
0.3282589614391327,
-0.38865575194358826,
-0.9156240820884705,
-0.8880601525306702,
-0.13528874516487122,
0.4468531608581543,
-0.19843880832195282,
-0.09685846418142319,
-0.31770122051239014,
0.40249258279800415,
0.3434460163116455,
-0.0494283102452755,
0.2701689302921295,
-0.0606808178126812,
-0.24524542689323425,
-0.5993730425834656,
0.005398519802838564,
0.15131624042987823,
-0.7734435796737671,
-0.4682290554046631,
0.3997388184070587,
-0.3728809952735901,
0.37766188383102417,
0.6311739087104797,
0.3494337499141693,
-0.08296971768140793,
0.1346806436777115,
0.47721153497695923,
0.5111638903617859,
0.03722968325018883,
0.09543163329362869,
-0.10304874181747437,
-0.2112812101840973,
0.27618271112442017,
0.29207372665405273,
0.04388245940208435,
0.16364245116710663,
-0.15165546536445618,
0.37939703464508057,
0.11487789452075958,
-0.7319521903991699,
0.5175908803939819,
-0.1514841765165329,
-0.18762196600437164,
-0.12734520435333252,
0.2979706823825836,
0.3405827581882477,
0.5410251617431641,
-0.3339001536369324,
0.13560181856155396,
0.3083827495574951,
-0.36951127648353577,
0.2806968092918396,
0.44511690735816956,
-0.5821866989135742,
-0.2475341558456421,
0.821448028087616,
0.2957049310207367,
-0.5009978413581848,
0.686750054359436,
0.07794173061847687,
-0.30395302176475525,
0.585340678691864,
0.8784834146499634,
0.6799219250679016,
-0.2853598892688751,
0.3399767279624939,
0.26112815737724304,
-0.14089682698249817,
-0.15100149810314178,
0.6090036630630493,
-0.09308050572872162,
-0.6647989749908447,
-0.3341462314128876,
-0.17569054663181305,
-0.7055630683898926,
-0.3985576331615448,
-0.7146486043930054,
0.34276527166366577,
-0.47357672452926636,
-0.4420855939388275,
0.2088337540626526,
-0.42305293679237366,
-0.6089921593666077,
0.28509917855262756,
0.16929741203784943,
0.8894420266151428,
-0.6195815205574036,
0.7197856903076172,
1.0155953168869019,
-0.2187202423810959,
-0.763034999370575,
-0.1058688536286354,
0.14986015856266022,
-0.8982928991317749,
0.15914525091648102,
-0.11901558190584183,
-0.11493358761072159,
-0.12212666124105453,
0.04559071734547615,
-0.38824567198753357,
0.8904545307159424,
0.44131314754486084,
-0.4800161123275757,
-0.05608094111084938,
-0.22348643839359283,
0.6457840204238892,
-0.8835551738739014,
0.3578938841819763,
0.6180380582809448,
0.14214809238910675,
0.003500339575111866,
-1.3318029642105103,
0.5071014165878296,
-0.1861596554517746,
-0.4302876889705658,
0.2672496736049652,
-0.19306284189224243,
0.1758194863796234,
-0.7069702744483948,
-0.11457540094852448,
0.30520644783973694,
-0.24256210029125214,
0.3679428696632385,
0.5465518832206726,
0.3932534456253052,
0.8331362009048462,
0.6383705735206604,
0.09843619167804718,
1.1682170629501343,
-0.4900822639465332,
-0.1149655133485794,
1.0816113948822021,
-0.660431444644928,
0.5737691521644592,
0.6442236304283142,
0.04686618223786354,
0.5363510251045227,
0.37678423523902893,
0.13060438632965088,
0.37000572681427,
-0.2257755994796753,
-0.5041897296905518,
-0.41018110513687134,
-0.27998828887939453,
-0.47802984714508057,
0.48085930943489075,
0.569365382194519,
-0.7249459624290466,
0.11817874759435654,
-0.17279323935508728,
-0.19374795258045197,
0.29675084352493286,
0.039892006665468216,
1.2109143733978271,
0.23299729824066162,
-0.8564083576202393,
0.614604651927948,
-0.5172309279441833,
-0.14041276276111603,
-0.19482411444187164,
-0.2763666808605194,
-0.03539768233895302,
-0.0007113385945558548,
-0.3263828754425049,
-1.0116528272628784,
0.33685243129730225,
-0.31528615951538086,
-0.1652458757162094,
-0.24891138076782227,
0.28399738669395447,
-0.5082547068595886,
-0.3233279287815094,
-0.049488361924886703,
0.6432545781135559,
0.4205535054206848,
0.3600376546382904,
-0.6286847591400146,
-0.3011471927165985,
0.08086826652288437,
0.12874308228492737,
0.16222837567329407,
0.4804033041000366,
0.25838106870651245,
0.6327543258666992,
0.3858160376548767,
0.3867010176181793,
-0.42193102836608887,
0.47009456157684326,
0.8146816492080688,
-0.5524863004684448,
-0.48009324073791504,
-0.7043801546096802,
0.20088917016983032,
-0.17526404559612274,
-0.30626142024993896,
0.23028290271759033,
0.47638165950775146,
0.4401262700557709,
-0.06045526638627052,
0.6588299870491028,
0.23477131128311157,
0.8901060819625854,
-0.3102882504463196,
0.5827415585517883,
-0.6079776287078857,
0.3253669738769531,
-0.33270883560180664,
-0.5228608250617981,
-0.3022778034210205,
0.7463623285293579,
0.010336467064917088,
-0.04642283543944359,
0.5697753429412842,
0.7499337196350098,
-0.30376139283180237,
0.3537417948246002,
0.48475053906440735,
0.14646363258361816,
0.3358447849750519,
0.6822237968444824,
0.7314137816429138,
-0.04540391266345978,
-0.09135984629392624,
-0.2558153569698334,
-0.43424904346466064,
-0.1443917155265808,
-0.601527750492096,
-0.5770179033279419,
-0.3094538450241089,
-0.4161854386329651,
-0.6510835289955139,
0.06968824565410614,
1.1451231241226196,
0.580689013004303,
-0.5476911067962646,
0.017799561843276024,
0.2040053904056549,
-0.14431408047676086,
-0.4520438313484192,
-0.1680622398853302,
0.16711068153381348,
-0.06397764384746552,
-0.7289270758628845,
0.35912784934043884,
0.40880581736564636,
0.25224757194519043,
-0.04944034293293953,
-0.09352804720401764,
0.1853361874818802,
0.12205178290605545,
0.22983421385288239,
0.31485891342163086,
-0.82692950963974,
-0.2490781545639038,
0.07587913423776627,
-0.17431117594242096,
0.3337838351726532,
0.7866107821464539,
-1.0480232238769531,
0.9905173778533936,
0.05597620829939842,
0.6152453422546387,
0.21675872802734375,
0.2587156593799591,
1.2189422845840454,
0.0033777360804378986,
-0.1383938193321228,
0.6357866525650024,
0.27652090787887573,
0.18611818552017212,
-0.5151716470718384,
0.26847490668296814,
-0.1412750631570816,
-0.5555953979492188,
-0.7258172631263733,
0.4970681667327881,
-1.0158557891845703,
-0.15469221770763397,
0.9564188122749329,
-0.25655224919319153,
0.13052117824554443,
-0.4660499691963196,
-0.48783013224601746,
0.2565078139305115,
-0.4156414866447449,
0.8439760208129883,
0.3177935779094696,
-0.7966282963752747,
0.07484783977270126,
-0.13906995952129364,
0.502203643321991,
0.6822964549064636,
-0.6664271950721741,
-0.06292634457349777,
0.3341200351715088,
0.36332768201828003,
-0.017889879643917084,
0.8853281736373901,
-0.3208353817462921,
0.6408810615539551,
-0.04896083101630211,
-0.1648143082857132,
0.0316341407597065,
0.16236191987991333,
-0.3759584426879883,
-0.251785010099411,
-0.01716720685362816,
-0.25322282314300537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13929v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13929v1 | Large Language Models are Skeptics: False Negative Problem of Input-conflicting Hallucination | 2024-06-20T01:53:25 | 2024-06-20T01:53:25 | Jongyoon Song, Sangwon Yu, Sungroh Yoon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we identify a new category of bias that induces
input-conflicting hallucinations, where large language models (LLMs) generate
responses inconsistent with the content of the input context. This issue we
have termed the false negative problem refers to the phenomenon where LLMs are
predisposed to return negative judgments when assessing the correctness of a
statement given the context. In experiments involving pairs of statements that
contain the same information but have contradictory factual directions, we
observe that LLMs exhibit a bias toward false negatives. Specifically, the
model presents greater overconfidence when responding with False. Furthermore,
we analyze the relationship between the false negative problem and context and
query rewriting and observe that both effectively tackle false negatives in
LLMs. | [
-0.461916446685791,
-1.2830870151519775,
0.917855978012085,
0.10561550408601761,
-0.03926202282309532,
-0.10127761960029602,
-0.2708084285259247,
-0.4941246211528778,
0.4488320052623749,
0.7736175656318665,
-0.6463675498962402,
-0.11455556750297546,
-0.8563070893287659,
0.11508088558912277,
-0.70694500207901,
0.8224249482154846,
0.03370584547519684,
0.3186308443546295,
-0.17404232919216156,
-0.18085655570030212,
-0.7146293520927429,
-0.8565469980239868,
-0.44531914591789246,
-0.4815402030944824,
0.6049442291259766,
0.132036492228508,
1.068550944328308,
0.012492086738348007,
0.2770644426345825,
0.28468891978263855,
0.1141456887125969,
-0.22439520061016083,
-0.5505611300468445,
0.4361934959888458,
-0.5591811537742615,
-0.6201476454734802,
-0.00910096149891615,
0.04180920124053955,
0.3378277122974396,
0.7475564479827881,
-0.14190515875816345,
0.03676105663180351,
-0.21207508444786072,
0.41360512375831604,
-0.5657968521118164,
-0.10619205981492996,
-0.9847559332847595,
0.07323424518108368,
0.020051002502441406,
-0.3176223933696747,
-0.6778470277786255,
-0.5266008377075195,
0.22265619039535522,
-0.2644713521003723,
0.3856014907360077,
0.03457138314843178,
0.9089851975440979,
0.4492168426513672,
-0.6387813687324524,
-0.6951696276664734,
-0.8026103377342224,
0.6947169899940491,
-0.915187418460846,
0.5251239538192749,
0.48804810643196106,
0.1370818316936493,
-0.3432849049568176,
0.04366877302527428,
-1.0654959678649902,
-0.47480103373527527,
0.0443393737077713,
-0.36033299565315247,
0.039185743778944016,
-0.05011770501732826,
0.3181752562522888,
0.18688537180423737,
-0.4494275748729706,
0.13867363333702087,
-0.27983859181404114,
-0.27019140124320984,
0.6724631786346436,
0.23403427004814148,
0.3522751033306122,
-0.2632608711719513,
0.06730623543262482,
0.18989059329032898,
-0.7491778135299683,
-0.41964343190193176,
0.42689022421836853,
0.38190650939941406,
0.1383625566959381,
0.912422239780426,
0.12423767894506454,
0.8357664346694946,
0.2996288537979126,
-0.18460513651371002,
0.202194482088089,
-0.12727943062782288,
-0.30063313245773315,
0.18969613313674927,
0.5909916758537292,
0.29501771926879883,
0.18422476947307587,
-0.23019295930862427,
-0.3244975805282593,
0.5448144674301147,
0.3711544871330261,
-0.5898162722587585,
0.2752746045589447,
0.36715981364250183,
-0.22482049465179443,
-0.4665534496307373,
-0.14793016016483307,
-0.8806224465370178,
-0.7437469959259033,
-0.46079155802726746,
0.8277155160903931,
-0.05289090424776077,
-0.20893028378486633,
0.2971326410770416,
0.019567253068089485,
0.20982865989208221,
0.3536211848258972,
-0.5957261919975281,
0.32123276591300964,
0.5430040955543518,
0.6472213268280029,
-0.2048671841621399,
-0.18443283438682556,
-0.6043873429298401,
-0.10835858434438705,
-0.5207440853118896,
0.48270371556282043,
-0.6995879411697388,
-0.46467408537864685,
0.1328015923500061,
0.24866603314876556,
-0.010896779596805573,
-0.6691067218780518,
0.43919652700424194,
-0.5551555156707764,
0.5765329003334045,
-0.6016643643379211,
-0.502981960773468,
-0.2397049367427826,
0.33861595392227173,
-0.5410968065261841,
0.8161332011222839,
0.04629000276327133,
-0.7309631109237671,
0.3608231246471405,
-0.216681569814682,
-0.4108281135559082,
-0.10977572947740555,
-0.5189670920372009,
-0.18299858272075653,
0.5237571001052856,
-0.3549729287624359,
0.3186836540699005,
-0.532118558883667,
0.7904743552207947,
-0.522990345954895,
-0.5055215954780579,
0.6363190412521362,
-0.4748574495315552,
0.7353999018669128,
0.0014731143601238728,
-0.6916214823722839,
0.21486353874206543,
-0.8720468282699585,
-0.09287182241678238,
0.27097880840301514,
-0.16822366416454315,
-0.5578575134277344,
0.15177103877067566,
-0.17870087921619415,
0.565255880355835,
0.120429627597332,
-0.5508553981781006,
0.38833439350128174,
-0.36944150924682617,
0.4780326187610626,
0.8432785868644714,
-0.040434226393699646,
0.10847994685173035,
-0.30044421553611755,
0.3035576641559601,
0.16175787150859833,
-0.18679136037826538,
0.23939655721187592,
-0.3294339179992676,
-0.9209480881690979,
0.3368592858314514,
-0.07312797009944916,
0.4770018458366394,
-0.9527921676635742,
0.3410823345184326,
0.026661746203899384,
-0.3114674687385559,
-0.3023529648780823,
-0.08572230488061905,
0.20436632633209229,
0.5934113264083862,
0.25676429271698,
-0.012472640722990036,
-0.5558847188949585,
-1.119460940361023,
-0.22142282128334045,
-0.1717858910560608,
0.19394747912883759,
0.3314618766307831,
0.7517185807228088,
-0.7277829647064209,
0.5923550128936768,
-0.5820509195327759,
-0.33283868432044983,
-0.1350969523191452,
0.2631007432937622,
0.2692490518093109,
0.23495759069919586,
0.3169448673725128,
-0.6873926520347595,
-0.23554269969463348,
-0.34056156873703003,
-0.7357648611068726,
-0.10754496604204178,
-0.19556280970573425,
0.2094358205795288,
0.7909425497055054,
0.44704321026802063,
-0.9802255034446716,
0.28533145785331726,
0.7078816890716553,
-0.5391145944595337,
0.9638412594795227,
0.04275256022810936,
0.1037505716085434,
-0.9903481006622314,
-0.0850340873003006,
0.09389965236186981,
0.19517166912555695,
-0.4480659067630768,
0.13163523375988007,
-0.16079673171043396,
0.1417718231678009,
-0.1718987375497818,
0.4905607998371124,
-0.33931371569633484,
0.10039711743593216,
-0.4038639962673187,
0.17830340564250946,
-0.005201707594096661,
0.3258739411830902,
0.08018708974123001,
0.7099727988243103,
0.5229251980781555,
-0.6198597550392151,
0.42628440260887146,
0.02447228692471981,
-0.2568581700325012,
0.42122775316238403,
-0.6244332194328308,
0.10042215138673782,
-0.403731107711792,
0.40678513050079346,
-1.0902389287948608,
-0.5064830780029297,
0.20416605472564697,
-0.3871805965900421,
0.1767588108778,
0.31504401564598083,
-0.5410956740379333,
-0.517711341381073,
-0.23689454793930054,
0.4517909586429596,
0.3477236330509186,
-0.532221257686615,
0.4594084620475769,
0.25753384828567505,
0.11241152882575989,
-0.8133590817451477,
-1.0006078481674194,
0.08141264319419861,
-0.004399488214403391,
-0.4292839765548706,
0.05390007421374321,
-0.007856439799070358,
-0.5449370741844177,
-0.014951067976653576,
-0.27136313915252686,
-0.12430347502231598,
-0.23268912732601166,
0.21147020161151886,
0.40926653146743774,
-0.3029164969921112,
0.1930491179227829,
-0.1958167552947998,
0.28357377648353577,
0.49594244360923767,
0.003008834086358547,
0.8645827770233154,
0.1725313812494278,
-0.4474048912525177,
-0.5590223073959351,
0.3366616368293762,
0.9220547080039978,
0.3136638104915619,
1.0408309698104858,
0.15959486365318298,
-0.5235286355018616,
-0.12135592103004456,
-0.9269118309020996,
-0.4594402313232422,
-0.4167640209197998,
0.4812980890274048,
-0.41345998644828796,
-0.9611482620239258,
0.5501501560211182,
0.4758796989917755,
-0.31942421197891235,
0.46661949157714844,
0.8285368084907532,
0.2636938989162445,
1.177943468093872,
0.4806683659553528,
-0.13656683266162872,
0.015139704570174217,
0.002588836243376136,
0.5708836317062378,
-0.6148195266723633,
-0.29308417439460754,
-0.6386247873306274,
0.007353657856583595,
-0.6112197041511536,
-0.21967686712741852,
-0.08643655478954315,
-0.13225242495536804,
-0.2996630370616913,
0.171220064163208,
-0.45520955324172974,
0.4120583236217499,
0.23832166194915771,
-0.1344001144170761,
0.12867851555347443,
-0.2906479239463806,
-0.04742930084466934,
-0.33288130164146423,
-0.605488121509552,
-0.49245089292526245,
1.0238546133041382,
0.3142065107822418,
1.0636872053146362,
0.23726944625377655,
0.366812139749527,
0.19810976088047028,
0.45531779527664185,
-0.9107974767684937,
0.46593427658081055,
0.20510034263134003,
-1.0791112184524536,
-0.27950379252433777,
-0.4050310254096985,
-0.5486847758293152,
0.4828365743160248,
-0.41245752573013306,
-0.9956138730049133,
0.3475165367126465,
0.18702629208564758,
-0.31598392128944397,
0.3997497856616974,
-0.7377392649650574,
0.6316853761672974,
-0.2926182746887207,
-0.6747310161590576,
-0.028701482340693474,
-0.5157585144042969,
0.8468805551528931,
-0.28456422686576843,
0.24854077398777008,
0.18002423644065857,
0.28921937942504883,
0.4062567353248596,
-0.263882040977478,
0.9244053959846497,
-0.07987499982118607,
-0.6062425374984741,
0.16240887343883514,
0.5529994368553162,
0.6922993659973145,
0.13730886578559875,
-0.07683007419109344,
0.21764610707759857,
-0.04039059206843376,
-0.15363413095474243,
-0.5900147557258606,
0.8540542125701904,
-0.8969461917877197,
-1.0668234825134277,
-0.7994790077209473,
-0.5188190937042236,
-0.35936275124549866,
0.21595792472362518,
0.6326276659965515,
0.4050901532173157,
-0.09459403157234192,
0.17421168088912964,
0.8648452758789062,
-0.7077757120132446,
-0.010879677720367908,
0.5562555193901062,
-0.5191081762313843,
-0.009574968367815018,
0.8679869174957275,
0.41412150859832764,
0.5027670860290527,
0.1677684634923935,
-0.05451683700084686,
-0.3527451753616333,
-0.34784209728240967,
-0.21155062317848206,
0.45586487650871277,
-0.6489550471305847,
-0.008358246646821499,
-0.738761305809021,
-0.4161195456981659,
-0.6200236082077026,
-0.1325051337480545,
-0.40811872482299805,
-0.042733144015073776,
-0.211500346660614,
0.04802538454532623,
-0.3859228491783142,
0.8870187997817993,
0.17712916433811188,
0.0475919283926487,
-0.42261913418769836,
0.44055747985839844,
0.322576642036438,
0.2467421144247055,
0.33734431862831116,
-0.6598107218742371,
0.05657549947500229,
-0.016215361654758453,
-0.3692556321620941,
-1.1639517545700073,
0.34887370467185974,
-0.5148008465766907,
0.4445008933544159,
0.4731173813343048,
-0.0305507592856884,
0.4798717200756073,
-0.46370959281921387,
0.9556227326393127,
0.29325953125953674,
-1.1627843379974365,
0.11402493715286255,
-0.38868123292922974,
0.3233812153339386,
0.3907112777233124,
0.555914580821991,
-0.7474982738494873,
-0.603933572769165,
-0.5537250638008118,
-0.7250467538833618,
0.607631504535675,
-0.02316962368786335,
0.1964646726846695,
-0.2413489818572998,
0.2753527760505676,
0.3667159080505371,
0.4427146911621094,
-1.163727879524231,
-0.2798646092414856,
-0.20476646721363068,
0.13194696605205536,
-0.2276371419429779,
-0.8086860179901123,
-0.32554733753204346,
-0.19738534092903137,
0.8127248287200928,
0.03559330478310585,
0.26393088698387146,
0.23217497766017914,
-0.07492571324110031,
-0.5776100754737854,
0.43344613909721375,
1.175429344177246,
0.943856954574585,
-0.19973976910114288,
0.41676709055900574,
0.17999309301376343,
-0.20328134298324585,
0.4034824073314667,
-0.41466739773750305,
-0.3312314748764038,
0.11735402792692184,
0.44775864481925964,
0.7654840350151062,
-0.09775810688734055,
-0.5815295577049255,
0.5835874080657959,
-0.07591293752193451,
-0.3855763375759125,
-0.5532568693161011,
0.03521982952952385,
0.09318561106920242,
0.03898705169558525,
0.5165767073631287,
0.1900484561920166,
0.11096806079149246,
-0.8241066932678223,
0.001770102302543819,
0.7832223773002625,
-0.3921213746070862,
-0.4160543978214264,
0.705866277217865,
0.07348712533712387,
-0.5031968951225281,
0.5012979507446289,
-0.20315434038639069,
-0.7658101320266724,
0.48544684052467346,
0.8584845066070557,
0.8101661801338196,
-0.17129352688789368,
0.30908310413360596,
0.4164895713329315,
0.4834394156932831,
-0.16761599481105804,
0.1874397248029709,
0.39390698075294495,
-0.9070151448249817,
-0.5991731882095337,
-0.5078557133674622,
-0.23760731518268585,
0.9475350379943848,
-0.6547483205795288,
0.37460824847221375,
-0.3277050852775574,
-0.19505327939987183,
-0.04161741957068443,
-0.1668248474597931,
-0.3171142339706421,
0.3075004816055298,
0.11970172822475433,
0.6992458701133728,
-0.8627588748931885,
0.8203018307685852,
0.31730854511260986,
-0.3535352945327759,
-0.731523871421814,
0.3550996482372284,
0.17058829963207245,
-0.6240975856781006,
0.8683220744132996,
0.1335383802652359,
-0.2128845900297165,
-0.5399696230888367,
-0.7389457821846008,
-1.0533761978149414,
0.36292245984077454,
0.4172448515892029,
-0.794079601764679,
-0.20458325743675232,
0.1905728280544281,
0.6235086917877197,
-0.3570685386657715,
-0.09503521025180817,
0.4718072712421417,
0.544256329536438,
0.18321733176708221,
-0.8972780108451843,
0.4303751289844513,
0.08776650577783585,
-0.02923000417649746,
0.35531142354011536,
-0.5991023182868958,
1.1501051187515259,
-0.28064653277397156,
-0.10200296342372894,
0.0006041429587639868,
0.2705014944076538,
0.29585200548171997,
0.28119680285453796,
0.3056907057762146,
0.522159218788147,
0.4669772684574127,
-0.13679634034633636,
1.0091358423233032,
-0.22684858739376068,
0.38845524191856384,
1.2905681133270264,
-0.6419286727905273,
0.6746069192886353,
0.8309654593467712,
0.07963046431541443,
0.4275880753993988,
0.45297080278396606,
0.00906942505389452,
0.31874021887779236,
0.44066113233566284,
-0.009767417795956135,
-0.21730037033557892,
0.10042433440685272,
-0.7143775820732117,
0.30778956413269043,
0.4380497932434082,
-0.3931310772895813,
-0.12292318791151047,
-0.019663484767079353,
0.0784490555524826,
0.07640207558870316,
-0.018973032012581825,
0.41546937823295593,
-0.005324900150299072,
-0.9392496943473816,
0.7687483429908752,
0.10879164189100266,
0.8772915005683899,
-0.35284900665283203,
-0.012460021302103996,
-0.08892662078142166,
0.06611478328704834,
-0.4479687809944153,
-0.47694751620292664,
0.45516178011894226,
-0.3211691975593567,
-0.3977067172527313,
0.28638142347335815,
0.5819057822227478,
-0.3442241847515106,
-0.37498483061790466,
0.4331742227077484,
0.4698173701763153,
-0.04747272655367851,
0.030430017039179802,
-0.6247577667236328,
0.4473160207271576,
0.11281406879425049,
-0.269977867603302,
0.1794632077217102,
0.47464480996131897,
-0.15022976696491241,
0.6657525300979614,
0.42481374740600586,
0.21673426032066345,
0.06126483529806137,
-0.014338770881295204,
0.6822851896286011,
-0.8096584677696228,
-0.30924177169799805,
-1.0937392711639404,
-0.020551996305584908,
0.045684657990932465,
-0.23223994672298431,
0.8929288387298584,
0.3401523530483246,
0.8993662595748901,
-0.14555253088474274,
0.8606522083282471,
-0.02364746294915676,
0.4810607433319092,
-0.33969926834106445,
0.6666683554649353,
-0.590661883354187,
0.2931264042854309,
-0.46066710352897644,
-1.2033836841583252,
-0.16952946782112122,
0.6762778759002686,
-0.6598689556121826,
0.1423962116241455,
0.8803249597549438,
0.7988840937614441,
0.14416103065013885,
0.12093759328126907,
0.4897177815437317,
0.847629725933075,
0.19628389179706573,
0.5929840803146362,
0.9899662137031555,
-0.2925347089767456,
0.09383741766214371,
0.0811934545636177,
0.05773836374282837,
-0.44119971990585327,
-0.5426244735717773,
-0.9305379986763,
-0.7337554097175598,
-0.24916590750217438,
-0.8159109354019165,
-0.06214772164821625,
0.9289693832397461,
0.4656706154346466,
-0.9897640347480774,
-0.2803981602191925,
-0.22936221957206726,
0.3338412046432495,
0.34831613302230835,
-0.35651975870132446,
0.06098199263215065,
-0.278814435005188,
-0.5648046135902405,
-0.1277931183576584,
0.24015021324157715,
0.1356249451637268,
-0.8649601340293884,
-0.055587656795978546,
-0.3344927132129669,
0.5549993515014648,
0.5925735235214233,
0.11523488163948059,
-1.08102548122406,
-0.500359058380127,
0.012639835476875305,
-0.40867868065834045,
-0.08289208263158798,
0.749871551990509,
-0.6082285642623901,
0.22084949910640717,
0.22173082828521729,
0.5832126140594482,
0.18971864879131317,
-0.2431464046239853,
0.5776785612106323,
-0.2690516710281372,
0.2521308660507202,
0.26005080342292786,
0.16470137238502502,
0.2887217104434967,
-0.6369051933288574,
0.2557097375392914,
0.3756716847419739,
-0.5627769827842712,
-1.332079529762268,
0.45727285742759705,
-0.712470531463623,
-0.638450562953949,
1.340477466583252,
0.5637720227241516,
-0.19907966256141663,
0.02242516353726387,
-0.31025296449661255,
-0.03372851759195328,
-0.12992671132087708,
1.3124366998672485,
1.325607419013977,
-0.20180349051952362,
0.27834054827690125,
-0.67943274974823,
0.45741981267929077,
0.6071328520774841,
-0.35794350504875183,
-0.1003972738981247,
0.6929836869239807,
0.3426417410373688,
0.5021976828575134,
0.5244740843772888,
0.002315475372597575,
0.1161826029419899,
0.06694194674491882,
-0.05835958942770958,
0.3893473744392395,
-0.31725868582725525,
-0.32098403573036194,
0.3648455739021301,
0.125944584608078,
0.3030587434768677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13925v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13925v1 | GenderAlign: An Alignment Dataset for Mitigating Gender Bias in Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T01:45:44 | 2024-06-20T01:45:44 | Tao Zhang, Ziqian Zeng, Yuxiang Xiao, Huiping Zhuang, Cen Chen, James Foulds, Shimei Pan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are prone to generating content that exhibits
gender biases, raising significant ethical concerns. Alignment, the process of
fine-tuning LLMs to better align with desired behaviors, is recognized as an
effective approach to mitigate gender biases. Although proprietary LLMs have
made significant strides in mitigating gender bias, their alignment datasets
are not publicly available. The commonly used and publicly available alignment
dataset, HH-RLHF, still exhibits gender bias to some extent. There is a lack of
publicly available alignment datasets specifically designed to address gender
bias. Hence, we developed a new dataset named GenderAlign, aiming at mitigating
a comprehensive set of gender biases in LLMs. This dataset comprises 8k
single-turn dialogues, each paired with a "chosen" and a "rejected" response.
Compared to the "rejected" responses, the "chosen" responses demonstrate lower
levels of gender bias and higher quality. Furthermore, we categorized the
gender biases in the "rejected" responses of GenderAlign into 4 principal
categories. The experimental results show the effectiveness of GenderAlign in
reducing gender bias in LLMs. | [
-0.06311331689357758,
-0.4713376462459564,
0.1960851401090622,
0.018112504854798317,
-0.005994149949401617,
0.27958646416664124,
-0.14634734392166138,
0.14296337962150574,
-0.05795464292168617,
0.5353156924247742,
-1.0568913221359253,
-0.6132094860076904,
-0.3923195004463196,
0.12031721323728561,
-0.3335103392601013,
0.8631812930107117,
0.1251276135444641,
0.5848125219345093,
-0.35595831274986267,
-0.19135908782482147,
-0.9286684393882751,
-0.15648062527179718,
-0.549051821231842,
-0.5792284607887268,
0.5303866267204285,
0.5152631998062134,
0.8237927556037903,
0.8299632668495178,
0.6239233016967773,
0.20261405408382416,
-0.15223664045333862,
0.06070350110530853,
-0.8257614374160767,
0.3108910024166107,
-0.16983665525913239,
-0.3121506869792938,
-0.624308705329895,
0.09527567028999329,
0.9107334017753601,
0.8214095830917358,
-0.49566206336021423,
0.4284915030002594,
0.09948467463254929,
0.920284628868103,
-0.5806352496147156,
-0.0661422535777092,
-0.5830854177474976,
0.16151443123817444,
-0.48342612385749817,
0.07589462399482727,
-0.2613457441329956,
-0.4283904433250427,
0.06776532530784607,
-0.6959228515625,
0.02513229101896286,
0.5030601620674133,
0.6983929872512817,
0.36969083547592163,
-0.28641796112060547,
-0.0005103157018311322,
-0.6337337493896484,
0.9033498167991638,
-0.9383004903793335,
0.5254538059234619,
0.2951679229736328,
0.2772931754589081,
-0.3776586353778839,
0.07632775604724884,
-0.4604671001434326,
0.22798597812652588,
-0.03373800590634346,
0.007054687011986971,
-0.0038624696899205446,
-0.08725655823945999,
0.25299444794654846,
0.18476136028766632,
-0.824982762336731,
0.44273024797439575,
-0.1753864735364914,
-0.3323834240436554,
0.6309342980384827,
0.31033065915107727,
0.3974589705467224,
-0.011655623093247414,
-0.10128053277730942,
-0.05169786140322685,
-1.2240406274795532,
-0.2299882173538208,
0.9436753392219543,
0.6692769527435303,
-0.13731098175048828,
0.6977103352546692,
0.1099574938416481,
0.5753215551376343,
0.4646276533603668,
-0.4055309295654297,
0.2727862596511841,
-0.05409986525774002,
-0.25530868768692017,
0.6547152996063232,
0.6870667338371277,
0.5941399931907654,
0.3218747079372406,
0.12276773154735565,
-0.06257951259613037,
-0.15190395712852478,
0.14252504706382751,
-0.5773135423660278,
0.12642227113246918,
0.17460153996944427,
-0.6774368286132812,
-0.34765565395355225,
-0.10865005105733871,
-0.6923782825469971,
-0.7946016192436218,
-0.5792856812477112,
0.06713280826807022,
-0.008813059888780117,
-0.43854618072509766,
0.17454248666763306,
-0.03965010493993759,
0.4373684525489807,
0.28285983204841614,
-0.9525957703590393,
0.1972166895866394,
0.9142045378684998,
0.48724472522735596,
-0.15691527724266052,
-0.11164755374193192,
-0.44932788610458374,
0.32862094044685364,
-0.34289807081222534,
0.35241714119911194,
-0.7348304986953735,
-0.17627018690109253,
0.11482198536396027,
0.03846374526619911,
0.02851185016334057,
-0.5912665128707886,
0.5437671542167664,
-0.22397080063819885,
0.5127153992652893,
-0.5362953543663025,
-0.5959953665733337,
0.10698657482862473,
0.22836852073669434,
-0.6957104802131653,
0.8578433394432068,
-0.09323424845933914,
-0.9803396463394165,
0.4813316762447357,
-0.49905267357826233,
-0.2576958239078522,
-0.006960900500416756,
-0.3652704954147339,
-0.6373230218887329,
-0.2469368726015091,
0.39177489280700684,
0.11749076843261719,
-0.3990918695926666,
0.5268714427947998,
-0.5420566201210022,
-0.24853871762752533,
0.2813160717487335,
-0.35104191303253174,
0.6309177875518799,
0.09787645190954208,
-0.23536455631256104,
0.34051835536956787,
-0.49469491839408875,
-0.3096087574958801,
0.13735121488571167,
-0.07530335336923599,
-0.44013887643814087,
0.006689463742077351,
-0.11698993295431137,
0.17470483481884003,
0.13910415768623352,
-0.5104655623435974,
0.23347486555576324,
-0.3943741023540497,
0.33210575580596924,
1.02262282371521,
-0.5353032946586609,
0.8996833562850952,
-0.4206976890563965,
0.6952489614486694,
-0.052128467708826065,
0.2202867716550827,
0.2623150944709778,
-0.4370884299278259,
-0.5632067918777466,
-0.16729101538658142,
0.4259716272354126,
0.5562257170677185,
-0.41142892837524414,
0.5789473652839661,
-0.436512291431427,
-0.09317784756422043,
-0.9603757858276367,
0.3530552387237549,
0.5756888389587402,
0.6567752361297607,
0.043069057166576385,
-0.05977034196257591,
-0.5196525454521179,
-1.2187949419021606,
-0.46845924854278564,
-0.09249366074800491,
0.0922153890132904,
0.05966994911432266,
0.32839542627334595,
0.10563052445650101,
0.8994601964950562,
-0.3817354142665863,
-0.4014933407306671,
-0.0701223835349083,
0.22023777663707733,
0.10686534643173218,
0.5215004682540894,
0.21184806525707245,
-0.5899232625961304,
-0.027922723442316055,
-0.2810989022254944,
-0.5640398263931274,
-0.31950339674949646,
0.06509370356798172,
-0.5857107043266296,
0.2130199670791626,
0.6234720945358276,
-0.4260096549987793,
0.2567691504955292,
0.7284360527992249,
-0.35317832231521606,
0.2768482565879822,
0.32917332649230957,
-0.028200069442391396,
-1.0249989032745361,
0.16570478677749634,
-0.0184814240783453,
-0.39362427592277527,
-0.4473438560962677,
-0.3242398500442505,
0.09150561690330505,
-0.026624882593750954,
-0.42045262455940247,
0.5889976024627686,
-0.5345638990402222,
-0.2650795578956604,
-0.012533423490822315,
0.1425306648015976,
-0.20688825845718384,
0.16842764616012573,
-0.09195714443922043,
0.7764726877212524,
0.11995849758386612,
-0.2770008146762848,
0.10630813986063004,
0.7479450702667236,
-0.06662670522928238,
0.9460774660110474,
-0.3184232711791992,
0.1893884390592575,
-0.4903711676597595,
0.2637360394001007,
-0.8960408568382263,
-0.23857314884662628,
0.529538094997406,
-0.39552441239356995,
0.5730708837509155,
-0.1901979297399521,
-0.182059183716774,
-0.3311194181442261,
-0.49897491931915283,
0.6068359613418579,
0.09928490966558456,
-0.45400047302246094,
0.5012149214744568,
0.5282391905784607,
-0.44902798533439636,
-1.0632374286651611,
-0.5273534059524536,
0.049847137182950974,
-0.3959064483642578,
-0.5050475597381592,
0.2029697597026825,
-0.25261273980140686,
-0.21107304096221924,
-0.08279112726449966,
-0.1324450969696045,
0.3896675407886505,
-0.11626995354890823,
0.22017157077789307,
0.26943424344062805,
-0.21054886281490326,
0.44600340723991394,
0.009749569930136204,
-0.08924882113933563,
-0.019704200327396393,
-0.056547101587057114,
0.8301428556442261,
0.14771784842014313,
-0.5630845427513123,
-0.4878924489021301,
0.454454630613327,
0.6347156763076782,
-0.0757160484790802,
0.8244794607162476,
0.532343327999115,
-0.5105788707733154,
0.0506921112537384,
-0.5226192474365234,
-0.22911734879016876,
-0.48051705956459045,
0.21229705214500427,
0.06934483349323273,
-1.1944501399993896,
0.3871800899505615,
0.14281898736953735,
0.16173575818538666,
0.3605327904224396,
0.568230390548706,
-0.20007438957691193,
1.4078015089035034,
0.4502144455909729,
-0.4921005070209503,
0.3929917514324188,
0.3330030143260956,
0.45863497257232666,
-1.020893931388855,
-0.2493751496076584,
-0.6452473998069763,
-0.7426053285598755,
-0.7058167457580566,
0.04346945509314537,
0.006580824963748455,
-0.1809203177690506,
-0.9121572375297546,
0.025515932589769363,
-0.5667687654495239,
0.3765343725681305,
0.5029988288879395,
0.03906423971056938,
0.3117242455482483,
0.009898478165268898,
0.06807395815849304,
-0.4808943569660187,
-0.7009694576263428,
-0.6600626707077026,
1.1255394220352173,
0.5204641819000244,
1.1125060319900513,
0.42261144518852234,
0.3826402425765991,
0.1149812787771225,
0.3093279302120209,
-0.6868627667427063,
0.4768196642398834,
-0.23633219301700592,
-0.8749262690544128,
-0.44796648621559143,
-0.6568788290023804,
-0.9998462200164795,
-0.10116768628358841,
-0.3793432414531708,
-0.7033379077911377,
0.06206253170967102,
0.21597298979759216,
-0.1869998574256897,
0.26221901178359985,
-0.3533174395561218,
0.7556012272834778,
-0.31062769889831543,
-0.3474263548851013,
0.1378050446510315,
-0.6280087232589722,
0.5562975406646729,
-0.12780353426933289,
0.21460199356079102,
-0.4289322793483734,
0.24044540524482727,
0.9612518548965454,
-0.32835084199905396,
0.9370405673980713,
-0.106236033141613,
-0.45232054591178894,
-0.303691565990448,
0.08860517293214798,
0.36690136790275574,
0.062082771211862564,
-0.06788111478090286,
0.05263597518205643,
-0.302142858505249,
-0.1473928540945053,
-0.3178728222846985,
0.7682859301567078,
-0.739190399646759,
-0.6526217460632324,
-0.4123523235321045,
-0.7972576022148132,
-0.1718343049287796,
0.31242862343788147,
0.12508422136306763,
0.264018714427948,
-0.14386235177516937,
0.01903829351067543,
0.7526261210441589,
-0.3918316960334778,
0.22548379004001617,
0.5029929280281067,
-0.3470812737941742,
-0.4691390097141266,
0.4676213562488556,
-0.015610753558576107,
0.278855562210083,
0.3215693533420563,
0.23394283652305603,
-0.497394323348999,
-0.22726905345916748,
-0.4076973497867584,
0.44395506381988525,
-0.6151438355445862,
-0.5451765656471252,
-0.2870979309082031,
-0.2145169973373413,
-0.7143193483352661,
0.07808773964643478,
-0.41778674721717834,
-0.3847843110561371,
-0.2639075815677643,
-0.10798116773366928,
0.34987857937812805,
0.6073014140129089,
0.2187841534614563,
0.489606648683548,
-0.6740583777427673,
0.2793598175048828,
0.2957093417644501,
0.4695265591144562,
-0.28923919796943665,
-0.6065045595169067,
0.3032444417476654,
0.18844866752624512,
-0.21233105659484863,
-0.6722189784049988,
0.4101046323776245,
0.19222864508628845,
0.5926634073257446,
0.377351313829422,
-0.021997077390551567,
0.7889693379402161,
-0.415768563747406,
0.6039189696311951,
0.44562235474586487,
-1.0516738891601562,
0.5593351721763611,
-0.6570380330085754,
0.4913978576660156,
0.5699764490127563,
0.22011896967887878,
-0.7276213765144348,
-0.25898250937461853,
-0.3182334005832672,
-0.7804296612739563,
0.7472180724143982,
0.3410574793815613,
-0.03798840939998627,
0.3330172002315521,
0.516753077507019,
0.2014312595129013,
0.6516157388687134,
-0.5942005515098572,
-0.36804458498954773,
0.17833483219146729,
-0.750113308429718,
0.07873551547527313,
-0.0898834839463234,
-0.5568286180496216,
-0.32225602865219116,
0.8690627813339233,
-0.22063365578651428,
0.32433730363845825,
-0.23534932732582092,
-0.19841451942920685,
-0.49048057198524475,
0.29142019152641296,
0.7441340684890747,
0.5614668130874634,
-0.30895760655403137,
-0.061833664774894714,
0.00945278536528349,
-0.5162911415100098,
0.18644759058952332,
-0.0708388164639473,
-0.287078320980072,
-0.2578601539134979,
0.2672589123249054,
0.679358720779419,
0.038281455636024475,
-0.380278617143631,
0.5180993676185608,
-0.28533098101615906,
-0.17610186338424683,
-0.19153451919555664,
-0.14747491478919983,
0.3692067563533783,
0.2259768396615982,
-0.014031810685992241,
-0.21028335392475128,
-0.006602711044251919,
-0.30407389998435974,
-0.15551039576530457,
0.6862279772758484,
-0.4831944704055786,
0.095172218978405,
0.7137892246246338,
0.3449854254722595,
-0.35321372747421265,
0.9660204648971558,
0.0343010313808918,
-0.4263797700405121,
0.4922102987766266,
0.5993229150772095,
0.7380537390708923,
-0.420476496219635,
0.1514885127544403,
0.4761587977409363,
0.42906808853149414,
-0.3480577766895294,
0.2363882213830948,
0.4536156952381134,
-1.0447611808776855,
-0.46493297815322876,
-0.4963091313838959,
-0.3974519968032837,
0.33988308906555176,
-0.7894996404647827,
0.36455869674682617,
-0.4620395600795746,
-0.2754734754562378,
-0.24921928346157074,
-0.3153063952922821,
-0.6603686809539795,
-0.12667229771614075,
0.43773606419563293,
0.5828415751457214,
-0.9689013361930847,
0.4175274968147278,
0.694951593875885,
-0.1534460037946701,
-0.7871492505073547,
-0.047035057097673416,
0.5894009470939636,
-0.9722256660461426,
0.5567005276679993,
0.2521372139453888,
-0.2675926983356476,
-0.1903083175420761,
-0.7894822955131531,
-1.0244472026824951,
1.1094624996185303,
0.7623136639595032,
-0.9911805391311646,
0.10030560195446014,
0.46239155530929565,
0.034516382962465286,
-0.46974557638168335,
0.08139582723379135,
0.793777585029602,
0.7824443578720093,
-0.09078984707593918,
-1.0188171863555908,
0.2481963336467743,
-0.17254529893398285,
0.020060237497091293,
0.34660622477531433,
-0.5705553293228149,
0.5715424418449402,
0.23005816340446472,
-0.10366807878017426,
0.04708245024085045,
0.31098809838294983,
0.49829375743865967,
0.2205132395029068,
0.6188802123069763,
0.7248851656913757,
1.0014464855194092,
-0.3872980773448944,
0.3770851194858551,
-0.04708043858408928,
0.22472292184829712,
1.2756236791610718,
-0.6844876408576965,
0.54624342918396,
0.5518866181373596,
-0.023038523271679878,
0.24439655244350433,
0.6113100051879883,
0.08756227791309357,
0.2610197365283966,
0.46630892157554626,
-0.009678587317466736,
-0.5337356328964233,
-0.2838221490383148,
-0.3685968816280365,
0.4650931656360626,
0.403846800327301,
-0.24374894797801971,
-0.06980425119400024,
-0.07618726789951324,
0.3193739652633667,
0.1153009682893753,
-0.30966365337371826,
0.783880889415741,
0.13394419848918915,
-0.5097610354423523,
0.1961354911327362,
-0.21821695566177368,
0.8035472631454468,
-0.444588840007782,
-0.11687975376844406,
-0.29737749695777893,
0.18316155672073364,
-0.43270108103752136,
-0.7900263667106628,
-0.02636471763253212,
-0.14226551353931427,
-0.3431602418422699,
-0.3897930979728699,
0.806576669216156,
-0.8000779151916504,
-0.5986842513084412,
0.12487141042947769,
0.48581668734550476,
-0.17251983284950256,
0.10102963447570801,
-0.8404510617256165,
0.09547096490859985,
-0.057590968906879425,
-0.009950654581189156,
0.2882710099220276,
0.1934078186750412,
-0.2255048006772995,
0.8060952425003052,
0.5747180581092834,
0.00023182964650914073,
-0.16566792130470276,
0.4349670112133026,
0.5617868304252625,
-0.7288862466812134,
-0.30699631571769714,
-0.7868095636367798,
0.4328343868255615,
-0.2538253366947174,
-0.34010928869247437,
0.6720684170722961,
0.477411687374115,
0.5978822708129883,
0.22011815011501312,
0.6700432300567627,
0.42027735710144043,
0.6629571914672852,
-0.655768632888794,
0.7690327763557434,
-0.5280493497848511,
0.4671017527580261,
-0.4178586006164551,
-0.9561329483985901,
-0.5598301887512207,
0.7522692084312439,
-0.15447348356246948,
0.20886042714118958,
0.44930794835090637,
1.13152015209198,
0.007148804143071175,
0.13531643152236938,
0.07425717264413834,
0.054293207824230194,
0.32295355200767517,
0.18937203288078308,
1.1388307809829712,
-0.28240594267845154,
0.40578001737594604,
0.15725427865982056,
0.041841961443424225,
-0.19416022300720215,
-1.1846404075622559,
-0.848135232925415,
-0.25800424814224243,
-0.5811430215835571,
-0.20143331587314606,
0.16955286264419556,
1.08430814743042,
0.7583404183387756,
-0.6332665681838989,
-0.2675394117832184,
0.04420475289225578,
0.2107805758714676,
-0.04033363237977028,
-0.1936548352241516,
0.20959356427192688,
-0.05432453379034996,
-0.5733262300491333,
0.11902851611375809,
0.0807267501950264,
-0.07110093533992767,
-0.2755078673362732,
-0.2828931212425232,
-0.27248457074165344,
-0.1753772795200348,
0.24267283082008362,
0.036548856645822525,
-0.6149162650108337,
-0.4142693281173706,
0.14037799835205078,
-0.10623869299888611,
0.2196866273880005,
0.8365163207054138,
-0.3249785900115967,
0.21905547380447388,
0.5436094403266907,
0.3512551784515381,
0.0508761964738369,
0.025295283645391464,
1.0561431646347046,
-0.8817505240440369,
-0.04664783924818039,
0.18342788517475128,
0.3973776698112488,
0.7462825179100037,
-0.5782063603401184,
0.2652825117111206,
-0.04667045921087265,
-0.5989052653312683,
-0.719634473323822,
0.1989317089319229,
-0.9421393275260925,
-0.19985774159431458,
1.3187860250473022,
0.377346396446228,
-0.29229357838630676,
-0.10575203597545624,
-0.35340994596481323,
0.51375812292099,
-0.7857695817947388,
0.5219559073448181,
0.8895440101623535,
0.14205192029476166,
-0.268278568983078,
-0.485061377286911,
0.43271297216415405,
0.6744585037231445,
-0.7965256571769714,
0.33050334453582764,
0.5903779864311218,
0.35136356949806213,
-0.08143836259841919,
0.3704506456851959,
-0.3045000433921814,
-0.0025935424491763115,
-0.6122154593467712,
0.28168147802352905,
0.22491110861301422,
-0.17644156515598297,
-0.7092909812927246,
-0.23501676321029663,
0.12169542163610458,
-0.03620285913348198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13923v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13923v1 | PIN: A Knowledge-Intensive Dataset for Paired and Interleaved Multimodal Documents | 2024-06-20T01:43:08 | 2024-06-20T01:43:08 | Junjie Wang, Yin Zhang, Yatai Ji, Yuxiang Zhang, Chunyang Jiang, Yubo Wang, Kang Zhu, Zekun Wang, Tiezhen Wang, Wenhao Huang, Jie Fu, Bei Chen, Qunshu Lin, Minghao Liu, Ge Zhang, Wenhu Chen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM | Recent advancements in Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have leveraged
extensive multimodal datasets to enhance capabilities in complex
knowledge-driven tasks. However, persistent challenges in perceptual and
reasoning errors limit their efficacy, particularly in interpreting intricate
visual data and deducing multimodal relationships. Addressing these issues, we
introduce a novel dataset format, PIN (Paired and INterleaved multimodal
documents), designed to significantly improve both the depth and breadth of
multimodal training. The PIN format is built on three foundational principles:
knowledge intensity, scalability, and support for diverse training modalities.
This innovative format combines markdown files and comprehensive images to
enrich training data with a dense knowledge structure and versatile training
strategies. We present PIN-14M, an open-source dataset comprising 14 million
samples derived from a diverse range of Chinese and English sources, tailored
to include complex web and scientific content. This dataset is constructed
meticulously to ensure data quality and ethical integrity, aiming to facilitate
advanced training strategies and improve model robustness against common
multimodal training pitfalls. Our initial results, forming the basis of this
technical report, suggest significant potential for the PIN format in refining
LMM performance, with plans for future expansions and detailed evaluations of
its impact on model capabilities. | [
-0.15546748042106628,
-0.4299784004688263,
0.4870123565196991,
0.40864425897598267,
-0.3811388909816742,
0.11250226944684982,
-0.27483534812927246,
-0.159968301653862,
0.08145744353532791,
0.07039793580770493,
-0.532836377620697,
-0.6201144456863403,
-0.6015933752059937,
-0.20130789279937744,
-0.06295692920684814,
0.7662403583526611,
-0.21739664673805237,
0.4799429476261139,
-0.431678831577301,
-0.3874547481536865,
-0.6450729966163635,
-0.5165144801139832,
0.003544121515005827,
-0.18184152245521545,
0.7665151357650757,
0.7215856313705444,
0.2821194529533386,
0.8301492929458618,
1.003548264503479,
0.09500613063573837,
0.4571273624897003,
0.6121455430984497,
-0.4776885211467743,
0.0715186595916748,
-0.15145988762378693,
-0.28390005230903625,
-0.6251348257064819,
0.18617376685142517,
0.5997416973114014,
0.8123113512992859,
0.24850808084011078,
0.1421954482793808,
0.008177471347153187,
0.6380990147590637,
-0.45726415514945984,
0.6487995386123657,
-0.8131128549575806,
-0.1413085162639618,
-0.344548761844635,
-0.29521098732948303,
-0.4090878367424011,
-0.028089692816138268,
-0.03808233141899109,
-0.8640040159225464,
0.36896374821662903,
0.028943413868546486,
0.5347431898117065,
0.097087562084198,
-0.6327962875366211,
-0.2124534696340561,
-0.4624161422252655,
0.6103522181510925,
-0.3682129383087158,
0.6221833229064941,
0.47070831060409546,
0.331997811794281,
0.14505109190940857,
-0.8117899894714355,
-0.5503416657447815,
0.22059541940689087,
0.011029954999685287,
0.13315460085868835,
0.4799836575984955,
0.1540319174528122,
0.32937705516815186,
0.13560186326503754,
-0.590972363948822,
0.047827791422605515,
-0.5495824813842773,
0.0005806047702208161,
0.5751253962516785,
0.23632077872753143,
0.2790164053440094,
-0.22703562676906586,
-0.5057434439659119,
-0.4784930944442749,
-0.6475468873977661,
0.27651602029800415,
0.3941197395324707,
0.4708867073059082,
-0.39888182282447815,
0.6780761480331421,
-0.2845858633518219,
0.48918116092681885,
-0.02302166260778904,
-0.35880354046821594,
0.3166971802711487,
-0.5028125047683716,
0.24973981082439423,
0.003972460050135851,
0.5971055626869202,
0.9071846604347229,
-0.0021030919160693884,
-0.1137593537569046,
-0.019962819293141365,
0.20941708981990814,
0.1305840015411377,
-0.7458443641662598,
-0.5482954382896423,
0.11541472375392914,
-0.5181141495704651,
-0.14702843129634857,
0.4976745545864105,
-0.7063975930213928,
-0.6606126427650452,
-0.3471413850784302,
0.574187695980072,
-0.7115451693534851,
-0.19845853745937347,
0.12736539542675018,
-0.24788127839565277,
0.11358211189508438,
0.4253259599208832,
-0.9161569476127625,
-0.12068066745996475,
0.6631909608840942,
0.8575031757354736,
-0.11844475567340851,
-0.4836035370826721,
-0.350559264421463,
0.5524370074272156,
-0.3868497312068939,
0.6057134866714478,
-0.6850233674049377,
-0.19218036532402039,
-0.12509657442569733,
0.24281221628189087,
-0.06181656941771507,
-0.4235508143901825,
0.6059356331825256,
-0.18514153361320496,
-0.34993240237236023,
-0.459994375705719,
-0.37589147686958313,
-0.4132320284843445,
0.4115332365036011,
-0.9308083057403564,
0.8533746600151062,
-0.15703590214252472,
-0.818182647228241,
0.8258571028709412,
-0.5790665745735168,
-0.4915897846221924,
0.029436254873871803,
-0.5222663879394531,
-0.2589420676231384,
-0.00936518982052803,
0.45430681109428406,
0.8240220546722412,
-0.2628638744354248,
0.671280026435852,
-0.8687017560005188,
-0.38337790966033936,
0.13701164722442627,
-0.42307010293006897,
0.2789579927921295,
-0.07443980872631073,
-0.11299214512109756,
0.19071169197559357,
-1.0614007711410522,
-0.25390905141830444,
0.13252630829811096,
-0.21323537826538086,
-0.3877069652080536,
0.08059423416852951,
-0.09201080352067947,
0.2855120897293091,
0.19786383211612701,
-0.7535614967346191,
0.27776217460632324,
0.4019871652126312,
0.6207136511802673,
0.8392887115478516,
-0.049597542732954025,
0.23375171422958374,
-0.5262151956558228,
0.1735355108976364,
0.3559955954551697,
0.34674105048179626,
-0.7286702394485474,
-0.424139142036438,
-0.6902797818183899,
-0.4391067624092102,
-0.0551350861787796,
0.08413691073656082,
-0.7991139888763428,
0.17188754677772522,
-0.5265454053878784,
-0.6122484803199768,
-0.7195471525192261,
0.22025220096111298,
0.2564757764339447,
0.7073773145675659,
0.41683945059776306,
-0.11073251068592072,
-0.5428681373596191,
-0.9378638863563538,
0.12139242142438889,
0.03679471090435982,
0.34653961658477783,
0.35315021872520447,
0.5398097634315491,
-0.17631584405899048,
0.8124247789382935,
-0.2738973796367645,
-0.3950690031051636,
-0.06500360369682312,
0.3359561264514923,
0.27777522802352905,
0.8733687400817871,
0.28486305475234985,
-0.8910189270973206,
-0.41360166668891907,
-0.1121222972869873,
-1.009401559829712,
0.2835206985473633,
-0.20046737790107727,
-0.22060571610927582,
-0.35853245854377747,
0.4871596693992615,
-0.31419679522514343,
0.24947534501552582,
0.5255188345909119,
-0.1490175724029541,
0.32043391466140747,
-0.223626509308815,
0.42702600359916687,
-0.9467229843139648,
0.21627962589263916,
-0.1951896995306015,
0.1272335648536682,
-0.4150692820549011,
-0.11685048788785934,
0.6862745881080627,
-0.30140289664268494,
-0.3303985893726349,
0.46325647830963135,
-0.4496326148509979,
0.09401765465736389,
0.23164422810077667,
-0.199524387717247,
0.38082998991012573,
0.5289154648780823,
0.170486181974411,
0.6034924387931824,
0.3148157000541687,
-0.3000658452510834,
0.5589080452919006,
0.4366177022457123,
-0.498715341091156,
0.8672812581062317,
-0.4720732271671295,
0.23352830111980438,
-0.2594042718410492,
0.09237733483314514,
-0.9183832406997681,
-0.5548542737960815,
-0.05592229962348938,
-0.45295584201812744,
0.2024001032114029,
-0.22856684029102325,
-0.7282253503799438,
-0.17693622410297394,
-0.6799381375312805,
0.6411331295967102,
-0.14121191203594208,
-0.6728339195251465,
0.39590442180633545,
0.07992318272590637,
-0.09220606833696365,
-0.5702616572380066,
-0.5639091730117798,
-0.17453104257583618,
-0.07509192079305649,
-0.8633896112442017,
0.13538821041584015,
-0.40108752250671387,
0.0628746747970581,
0.07532493770122528,
-0.03931979462504387,
-0.15907515585422516,
-0.15347473323345184,
0.6794607639312744,
0.36897820234298706,
-0.09120595455169678,
0.527362585067749,
0.12628719210624695,
0.02082233503460884,
-0.2219240367412567,
-0.08076730370521545,
0.5799911022186279,
0.11869661509990692,
-0.798379123210907,
-0.2875842750072479,
0.5503839254379272,
0.6960729360580444,
-0.5401585698127747,
0.7067948579788208,
0.7513449192047119,
-0.40181607007980347,
-0.06087569519877434,
-0.4756920039653778,
-0.1976856142282486,
-0.3847862780094147,
0.3482973277568817,
-0.6474373936653137,
-0.5354300141334534,
0.31509989500045776,
-0.04363379254937172,
0.06853613257408142,
0.12624460458755493,
0.24693787097930908,
-0.5280739665031433,
1.0320043563842773,
0.6048471927642822,
0.1783449947834015,
0.28383108973503113,
-0.3847581446170807,
0.12751762568950653,
-0.9079751968383789,
-0.9540728330612183,
-0.08144748210906982,
-0.7077077031135559,
0.07889556884765625,
-0.7349115610122681,
0.587392270565033,
0.1735030561685562,
-0.27209675312042236,
-0.16863635182380676,
-0.14256779849529266,
0.18196511268615723,
0.7142341136932373,
0.5851434469223022,
0.5495082139968872,
0.02502618171274662,
-0.1627269685268402,
-0.4258629381656647,
-0.7434135675430298,
-0.32266247272491455,
1.48043692111969,
0.31771910190582275,
1.2051650285720825,
-0.16091684997081757,
0.16397225856781006,
0.3445388674736023,
-0.21762578189373016,
-0.535522997379303,
0.2943938374519348,
-0.3218607008457184,
-0.7087702751159668,
0.12432990968227386,
-0.14019182324409485,
-0.4620658755302429,
-0.12791849672794342,
-0.5390691757202148,
-0.14180918037891388,
0.3089964985847473,
0.23888927698135376,
-0.12551367282867432,
0.6455080509185791,
-0.8915882706642151,
0.981992244720459,
-0.5020623803138733,
-0.29075005650520325,
-0.1169431209564209,
-0.8363435864448547,
0.5030856728553772,
-0.26825782656669617,
0.16215668618679047,
-0.37852180004119873,
-0.002994269598275423,
0.8305318355560303,
-0.201891228556633,
0.8801273703575134,
-0.1847798377275467,
0.21525079011917114,
0.041517473757267,
-0.03712274506688118,
0.3219827711582184,
0.2200351059436798,
0.1684604287147522,
0.13731969892978668,
-0.06974290311336517,
-0.3901726305484772,
-0.5489509105682373,
0.6378400325775146,
-0.8673533201217651,
0.009750151075422764,
-0.19505184888839722,
-1.2817503213882446,
-0.40442296862602234,
0.2690102756023407,
0.16096220910549164,
0.9332290291786194,
0.2329220473766327,
0.8750922679901123,
0.7117198705673218,
-0.13286423683166504,
0.2186785638332367,
0.41339215636253357,
0.09026797860860825,
-0.5923094749450684,
1.0481059551239014,
0.3143421709537506,
0.2811283469200134,
0.4980933368206024,
-0.1408357173204422,
-0.3861989378929138,
-0.5911481976509094,
-0.25324222445487976,
0.4102534055709839,
-0.904800534248352,
-0.19093571603298187,
-0.8822895288467407,
-0.10565805435180664,
-0.5547635555267334,
-0.24364805221557617,
-0.44344362616539,
-0.36636826395988464,
-0.19102326035499573,
-0.3837469816207886,
0.4550458788871765,
0.6873008608818054,
-0.28901830315589905,
0.3669533431529999,
-0.7893444895744324,
0.4483741223812103,
0.3474860191345215,
0.6612196564674377,
-0.14326485991477966,
-0.14368605613708496,
-0.23803988099098206,
0.04580654576420784,
0.10965404659509659,
-0.5619724988937378,
-0.02693459764122963,
0.3367222845554352,
0.7059553861618042,
0.6332113742828369,
0.2714722156524658,
0.8306521773338318,
-0.349820077419281,
0.43057289719581604,
0.3704128563404083,
-0.4979456961154938,
0.586395263671875,
-0.43456125259399414,
-0.01963246800005436,
0.6695226430892944,
0.7879108786582947,
-0.5739420652389526,
0.2843489646911621,
-0.38551342487335205,
-0.6802369952201843,
0.6966745257377625,
-0.36142584681510925,
-0.2054482102394104,
0.3436969220638275,
0.0900479257106781,
0.6219602227210999,
0.4434978663921356,
-0.555576503276825,
0.18823936581611633,
-0.45354899764060974,
-0.6089950203895569,
-0.22661392390727997,
-0.38828179240226746,
-0.4287828207015991,
-0.2684158980846405,
0.3553106188774109,
-0.3707730174064636,
0.06021367758512497,
0.16170038282871246,
-0.486520379781723,
0.21345779299736023,
-0.16370952129364014,
0.3710930347442627,
0.7918805480003357,
-0.5568013787269592,
0.4807889759540558,
-0.4410445988178253,
-0.6453449726104736,
0.211417555809021,
0.10069052875041962,
-0.09059052914381027,
-0.25396010279655457,
0.6102068424224854,
0.7727188467979431,
0.10735072940587997,
-0.8276849985122681,
0.5513389706611633,
-0.03544842079281807,
-0.14309248328208923,
0.19328373670578003,
-0.377500057220459,
-0.05054650083184242,
0.45870479941368103,
0.2554406523704529,
-0.04008343815803528,
-0.14560623466968536,
-0.46602290868759155,
0.3384498953819275,
0.2229471355676651,
-0.45253121852874756,
-0.4657893180847168,
0.6266041398048401,
0.45635464787483215,
0.3509148061275482,
0.5342273116111755,
-0.08344147354364395,
-0.19475296139717102,
0.2980296015739441,
0.38283276557922363,
0.22492782771587372,
0.1989210695028305,
0.2091067135334015,
0.37235593795776367,
0.604210376739502,
0.11538836359977722,
0.5136933922767639,
-0.09328410029411316,
-0.7130135893821716,
-0.039277300238609314,
-0.3387017548084259,
-0.23938332498073578,
0.2240115851163864,
-0.7231114506721497,
0.37643516063690186,
-0.7948498129844666,
-0.0036129069048911333,
-0.5540206432342529,
-0.04271082207560539,
-0.6814621090888977,
0.264669805765152,
0.008096687495708466,
0.9465480446815491,
-0.9774765372276306,
0.8335277438163757,
0.7424970269203186,
-0.6804273724555969,
-0.9035824537277222,
-0.5240712761878967,
-0.0015772792976349592,
-1.0396473407745361,
0.6975612044334412,
0.34082677960395813,
0.2162284553050995,
-0.2492280751466751,
-0.5526474118232727,
-0.6214991807937622,
1.3763236999511719,
0.3343696892261505,
-0.6223961710929871,
-0.1471543312072754,
0.2968061864376068,
-0.16024157404899597,
-0.29224643111228943,
0.03239104524254799,
0.24947409331798553,
0.38598930835723877,
0.10129744559526443,
-0.6083657145500183,
-0.1614004224538803,
-0.38227254152297974,
-0.12294953316450119,
-0.008277269080281258,
-0.7889228463172913,
1.1061407327651978,
-0.08998658508062363,
0.04277649149298668,
-0.1253705471754074,
0.4337342083454132,
0.35273951292037964,
0.36674001812934875,
0.3956184983253479,
0.5861989855766296,
0.7136061787605286,
-0.25521230697631836,
0.40156567096710205,
-0.388930082321167,
-0.021745998412370682,
1.33223295211792,
-0.35726895928382874,
0.5823794603347778,
0.6140780448913574,
0.33013424277305603,
0.21511085331439972,
0.6187089085578918,
-0.1820501685142517,
0.5361114144325256,
-0.5217052698135376,
-0.04325830936431885,
-0.3747345507144928,
-0.5256828665733337,
-0.5636539459228516,
0.5211135745048523,
0.37150752544403076,
-0.15455985069274902,
-0.1538626253604889,
0.2983156442642212,
-0.0270176250487566,
0.20842720568180084,
-0.29925358295440674,
0.3754078149795532,
-0.20484192669391632,
-0.07623735070228577,
-0.0514572374522686,
-0.2938535213470459,
0.8011270761489868,
-0.8237662315368652,
-0.35997486114501953,
-0.34174928069114685,
0.23016628623008728,
-0.24655525386333466,
-0.9323911070823669,
-0.223051518201828,
-0.026587501168251038,
-0.40651434659957886,
-0.28688859939575195,
0.7620745897293091,
-0.5715554356575012,
-0.5351395010948181,
0.30127593874931335,
0.3888676166534424,
-0.06492334604263306,
-0.1696319431066513,
-0.4358421862125397,
0.41368240118026733,
-0.3429911136627197,
0.3825775682926178,
0.11308969557285309,
0.6617714166641235,
-0.10500719398260117,
0.670659065246582,
0.7983154654502869,
-0.013068991713225842,
0.4119488298892975,
-0.01329176314175129,
1.0079280138015747,
-0.6101515293121338,
-0.4255973994731903,
-0.44906866550445557,
0.6779550313949585,
-0.18218934535980225,
-0.2267705798149109,
0.6466251611709595,
0.6819055676460266,
0.9758510589599609,
-0.08234287053346634,
0.7966617941856384,
-0.04666268453001976,
0.6610789895057678,
-0.5890646576881409,
0.8061000108718872,
-0.6172778606414795,
-0.1159643903374672,
-0.22797685861587524,
-0.6403458714485168,
-0.2211475968360901,
0.2398984134197235,
-0.1011677160859108,
-0.18847349286079407,
0.5699560046195984,
0.675649881362915,
-0.2246142029762268,
-0.1445673704147339,
0.28965669870376587,
0.01894872635602951,
0.6253881454467773,
0.6289135217666626,
0.9788825511932373,
-0.3315314054489136,
0.7769566178321838,
-0.6725440621376038,
-0.32377463579177856,
-0.24251636862754822,
-0.7647985816001892,
-1.0104838609695435,
-0.8938982486724854,
0.12678952515125275,
0.22828026115894318,
-0.09849102795124054,
0.9572219848632812,
1.0772007703781128,
-0.44548577070236206,
-0.1737661212682724,
0.4092313051223755,
-0.21145741641521454,
-0.01584462821483612,
-0.08312108367681503,
0.2890418469905853,
-0.3098447620868683,
-0.5489680171012878,
0.5162794589996338,
0.4139469563961029,
0.018175706267356873,
-0.14215083420276642,
-0.1358381062746048,
-0.5217223167419434,
-0.39317086338996887,
0.616176962852478,
-0.0381251722574234,
-0.26992926001548767,
-0.26197636127471924,
0.13415083289146423,
-0.04656264930963516,
0.27216485142707825,
1.0235137939453125,
-0.4389168322086334,
1.1102906465530396,
0.5663471817970276,
0.6954956650733948,
0.30108872056007385,
-0.07607986778020859,
0.542517364025116,
-0.7554898262023926,
0.5822230577468872,
0.16864940524101257,
0.5182128548622131,
0.4249725937843323,
-0.017877351492643356,
0.548522412776947,
0.6374691724777222,
-0.13085351884365082,
-0.9073569774627686,
-0.0003547595115378499,
-1.4004265069961548,
-0.21450594067573547,
0.7020002603530884,
-0.4199620187282562,
0.04443324729800224,
0.053434308618307114,
-0.36297935247421265,
0.21957598626613617,
-0.40780749917030334,
0.5103558301925659,
0.6748525500297546,
0.09480027854442596,
-0.23384840786457062,
-0.3407331109046936,
0.08668677508831024,
0.05056682229042053,
-0.7947502732276917,
-0.1357218474149704,
0.3751053512096405,
-0.05583038181066513,
-0.046023543924093246,
0.3902168571949005,
-0.26893478631973267,
0.2173292189836502,
0.25577512383461,
0.14089442789554596,
-0.5966987013816833,
-0.9937081336975098,
-0.19423270225524902,
0.28801047801971436,
0.06906919181346893,
-0.4524145722389221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02511v1 | LLM-A*: Large Language Model Enhanced Incremental Heuristic Search on Path Planning | 2024-06-20T01:24:30 | 2024-06-20T01:24:30 | Silin Meng, Yiwei Wang, Cheng-Fu Yang, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL | Path planning is a fundamental scientific problem in robotics and autonomous
navigation, requiring the derivation of efficient routes from starting to
destination points while avoiding obstacles. Traditional algorithms like A* and
its variants are capable of ensuring path validity but suffer from significant
computational and memory inefficiencies as the state space grows. Conversely,
large language models (LLMs) excel in broader environmental analysis through
contextual understanding, providing global insights into environments. However,
they fall short in detailed spatial and temporal reasoning, often leading to
invalid or inefficient routes. In this work, we propose LLM-A*, an new LLM
based route planning method that synergistically combines the precise
pathfinding capabilities of A* with the global reasoning capability of LLMs.
This hybrid approach aims to enhance pathfinding efficiency in terms of time
and space complexity while maintaining the integrity of path validity,
especially in large-scale scenarios. By integrating the strengths of both
methodologies, LLM-A* addresses the computational and memory limitations of
conventional algorithms without compromising on the validity required for
effective pathfinding. | [
-0.14594829082489014,
-0.9856835007667542,
1.0263773202896118,
0.18388976156711578,
-0.1731957346200943,
0.27699124813079834,
-0.19394084811210632,
-0.5417556166648865,
0.5040892362594604,
0.3996308445930481,
-0.9692385196685791,
-0.5603735446929932,
-0.39785462617874146,
-0.28599312901496887,
-0.21978338062763214,
0.04554296284914017,
-0.30214831233024597,
0.13813844323158264,
-0.13822980225086212,
-0.28963416814804077,
-0.2801978886127472,
-0.5165027379989624,
-0.7209395170211792,
-0.4962914288043976,
0.7939826250076294,
0.35385647416114807,
0.818336546421051,
0.7051335573196411,
0.6462992429733276,
0.23149804770946503,
-0.23218001425266266,
0.3715265095233917,
-0.06017064303159714,
0.3022918105125427,
-0.29838696122169495,
-0.0389896035194397,
-0.5056025385856628,
-0.375008761882782,
0.945794939994812,
0.6028948426246643,
-0.13209357857704163,
0.0526408851146698,
-0.5545615553855896,
0.6063555479049683,
-0.7836976051330566,
-0.05588417872786522,
-0.7121906876564026,
0.0964960902929306,
-0.11247941106557846,
-0.45701155066490173,
-0.045746833086013794,
-0.16524694859981537,
0.2538420855998993,
-0.6198170781135559,
-0.269030898809433,
0.22045296430587769,
0.6063216924667358,
0.4139412045478821,
-0.35450130701065063,
-0.46783173084259033,
-0.9648036360740662,
0.8094038367271423,
-0.6943671703338623,
0.4448140263557434,
0.0014288855018094182,
0.573838472366333,
-0.2627367377281189,
-0.30935174226760864,
-0.585244357585907,
-0.3732566237449646,
0.08691949397325516,
-0.02825774997472763,
0.05083708465099335,
0.11132770031690598,
0.2467767596244812,
0.03589024394750595,
-0.4949359595775604,
0.30313536524772644,
-0.26607197523117065,
-0.1977672427892685,
0.7694196701049805,
0.3381362557411194,
0.3137547969818115,
0.03779594972729683,
-0.5215362906455994,
0.014595196582376957,
-0.9993955492973328,
0.08614616841077805,
0.26452162861824036,
0.2554520070552826,
0.10778146237134933,
0.7352020740509033,
-0.31687307357788086,
0.5769543647766113,
-0.5694431662559509,
-0.265148788690567,
-0.09610188007354736,
-0.48345091938972473,
0.17791351675987244,
-0.024022012948989868,
0.6728093028068542,
0.15249820053577423,
0.11873555928468704,
-0.21291466057300568,
-0.2176288366317749,
0.02049070969223976,
0.07577068358659744,
-0.5656015276908875,
-0.14990827441215515,
0.3176068067550659,
-0.2916487455368042,
0.352016419172287,
-0.23455560207366943,
-0.5946312546730042,
-0.27446138858795166,
-0.36520811915397644,
0.4255691468715668,
-0.43419596552848816,
-0.32161539793014526,
0.22173146903514862,
0.0163325946778059,
0.2973088026046753,
0.7011425495147705,
-0.43039974570274353,
0.11812621355056763,
0.5538240075111389,
0.9185134172439575,
-0.11671227961778641,
-0.4391804039478302,
-0.48715466260910034,
0.44246870279312134,
-0.1501082330942154,
0.8508817553520203,
-0.7127986550331116,
-0.5108863115310669,
-0.1425718069076538,
-0.28920504450798035,
-0.019510164856910706,
-0.30745023488998413,
0.6133661270141602,
-0.5610392689704895,
-0.13155630230903625,
-0.322527676820755,
-0.3508954644203186,
-0.7852148413658142,
0.48883941769599915,
-0.49983716011047363,
1.0013017654418945,
-0.017288027331233025,
-0.33116891980171204,
0.32483550906181335,
-0.8569828271865845,
-0.7069810628890991,
0.13612346351146698,
-0.017647162079811096,
-0.15125006437301636,
-0.2778376042842865,
0.3933660387992859,
0.2000393271446228,
-0.3755806088447571,
0.3870064616203308,
-0.14888083934783936,
-0.46033334732055664,
-0.24346961081027985,
-0.3390524685382843,
0.8296669721603394,
-0.044637806713581085,
-0.28821423649787903,
0.5459676384925842,
-0.6264354586601257,
0.10428434610366821,
0.21010428667068481,
-0.589004635810852,
-0.48813560605049133,
0.37128692865371704,
-0.011859336867928505,
0.4494325816631317,
0.7635608911514282,
-0.5577951669692993,
0.5469619035720825,
-0.43544504046440125,
0.1928347945213318,
0.8467667102813721,
0.02370845526456833,
0.6669020056724548,
-0.34697750210762024,
0.6451921463012695,
-0.3715595304965973,
0.22927041351795197,
-0.4537327289581299,
-0.6018430590629578,
-0.8572782278060913,
-0.10709270089864731,
-0.12647104263305664,
0.980422854423523,
-0.45701858401298523,
0.5864285230636597,
-0.3127151429653168,
-0.59103924036026,
-0.201226606965065,
0.07732944190502167,
0.13969753682613373,
0.12218547612428665,
0.46645843982696533,
-0.14195698499679565,
-0.8106411695480347,
-0.3786171078681946,
0.021991973742842674,
-0.11268390715122223,
0.20451776683330536,
0.6363880634307861,
0.4944723844528198,
-0.4729189872741699,
0.7727305889129639,
-0.4102463126182556,
-0.20949389040470123,
-0.28723543882369995,
-0.4126686453819275,
0.02376609854400158,
0.27232468128204346,
0.21482239663600922,
-0.6506311297416687,
-0.26653018593788147,
-0.2469971925020218,
-0.8758625388145447,
0.10085131973028183,
-0.24664627015590668,
-0.3322339355945587,
0.02950681559741497,
0.6390430927276611,
-0.6809895634651184,
0.22635099291801453,
0.5246379375457764,
-0.48962143063545227,
0.31836989521980286,
-0.500727653503418,
-0.18504077196121216,
-0.6577972173690796,
-0.0841355174779892,
0.08906093239784241,
0.08512164652347565,
-0.2205534726381302,
0.5592659711837769,
-0.05526364594697952,
0.08594495058059692,
-0.4735080897808075,
1.0004727840423584,
-0.486738920211792,
-0.17259639501571655,
-0.23146876692771912,
0.05280645936727524,
-0.23629793524742126,
0.39675161242485046,
-0.03271272033452988,
0.6747629046440125,
0.7396005988121033,
-0.6801105737686157,
0.5050352811813354,
0.21643032133579254,
0.015419173054397106,
0.2209363877773285,
-0.2406158298254013,
0.13960866630077362,
-0.11746161431074142,
0.5529268980026245,
-0.8833516240119934,
-0.002427839208394289,
0.05647898092865944,
-0.02955135703086853,
0.10176321119070053,
0.034341245889663696,
-0.883188784122467,
-0.4371676743030548,
-0.16207686066627502,
0.7101643681526184,
0.3873758614063263,
-0.6674737930297852,
0.8909068703651428,
0.4118838608264923,
0.04580741375684738,
-0.1782529503107071,
-0.30057278275489807,
0.31984013319015503,
-0.2130507528781891,
-0.9218032956123352,
0.22425703704357147,
-0.24715836346149445,
-0.35054677724838257,
-0.09759017080068588,
-0.13091523945331573,
0.06294074654579163,
0.14226320385932922,
0.16420672833919525,
0.27073338627815247,
-0.105110302567482,
-0.28190693259239197,
-0.09524241089820862,
-0.3095240890979767,
0.10953034460544586,
-0.3265816569328308,
0.7328108549118042,
0.30034759640693665,
-0.5160964727401733,
-0.42002424597740173,
0.5439332723617554,
0.7338768243789673,
-0.41936129331588745,
0.5493171811103821,
0.4716512858867645,
-0.3966527283191681,
-0.15328902006149292,
-0.42688992619514465,
-0.15128479897975922,
-0.5042722225189209,
0.28896939754486084,
-0.25113600492477417,
-0.94521564245224,
0.3925030827522278,
-0.6105806827545166,
0.194295734167099,
0.33520352840423584,
0.2944188416004181,
0.01538701169192791,
0.8215213418006897,
0.6402770280838013,
-0.12366960197687149,
0.34669777750968933,
-0.47700923681259155,
0.4266660213470459,
-1.0084614753723145,
-0.53691565990448,
-0.34128278493881226,
-0.43763208389282227,
-0.6047536730766296,
-0.6226016879081726,
0.760253369808197,
-0.16478848457336426,
-0.45449814200401306,
0.33094143867492676,
-0.2697828710079193,
0.27245405316352844,
0.6992311477661133,
0.014926785603165627,
0.3826407194137573,
-0.05043793469667435,
-0.362921804189682,
0.14481815695762634,
-0.9768266081809998,
-0.33305105566978455,
0.9501153230667114,
0.2472321093082428,
0.61550372838974,
0.15340867638587952,
0.5691218972206116,
-0.1716441661119461,
0.11491677910089493,
-0.9420878291130066,
1.0090614557266235,
-0.1228165253996849,
-0.46295812726020813,
-0.5813921689987183,
-0.384420782327652,
-0.7695082426071167,
0.273790180683136,
-0.49243611097335815,
-0.9897509217262268,
-0.19300952553749084,
0.1759701520204544,
-0.3158772587776184,
0.6189563274383545,
-0.3468495011329651,
0.4112602472305298,
-0.5864428281784058,
-0.556239128112793,
-0.40004536509513855,
-0.4666171967983246,
0.23398248851299286,
0.03689131885766983,
0.3985685110092163,
-0.3411581218242645,
-0.25434744358062744,
0.3840806484222412,
-0.11925654113292694,
0.31105750799179077,
-0.2822849452495575,
-0.26608628034591675,
0.3076319098472595,
0.4527309536933899,
0.9592138528823853,
-0.09388474375009537,
-0.3449888825416565,
0.3902440369129181,
-0.5929421186447144,
-0.16801723837852478,
-0.3544529676437378,
0.8013617992401123,
-0.23871232569217682,
-0.6635650992393494,
-0.33631935715675354,
-0.8601123690605164,
-0.18687693774700165,
0.06491827219724655,
0.0009966717334464192,
0.27463918924331665,
-0.058062028139829636,
-0.20543420314788818,
0.46299269795417786,
-0.7374769449234009,
0.6400288939476013,
0.578559935092926,
-0.11174343526363373,
-0.10516022890806198,
0.7095800042152405,
0.021597491577267647,
0.07131826877593994,
0.6989487409591675,
0.3593791127204895,
-0.4239947199821472,
-0.7684710621833801,
-0.534170389175415,
0.22992247343063354,
-0.5112614035606384,
0.029393663629889488,
-0.7951827645301819,
-0.4341084957122803,
0.08309350162744522,
-0.5056575536727905,
-0.4062553346157074,
-0.41786980628967285,
0.22661393880844116,
0.06422314047813416,
0.35977646708488464,
0.6667028069496155,
-0.16758288443088531,
0.2472529113292694,
-0.6146574020385742,
0.33290183544158936,
-0.0244851503521204,
0.20586945116519928,
0.19577670097351074,
-0.09312324970960617,
-0.1664620339870453,
-0.015909062698483467,
-0.32005953788757324,
-0.39907020330429077,
0.43998536467552185,
-0.031790006905794144,
0.771171510219574,
0.08601129055023193,
-0.27143871784210205,
0.623009979724884,
-0.7183700799942017,
0.5800314545631409,
0.0705261304974556,
-0.5355889797210693,
0.7695309519767761,
-0.6281142234802246,
0.6112377047538757,
0.2857210040092468,
0.3786122500896454,
-0.28988391160964966,
-0.41389501094818115,
-0.45505449175834656,
-1.4267535209655762,
0.27971839904785156,
0.21759095788002014,
-0.1331164687871933,
0.29083555936813354,
0.3341778814792633,
-0.055441562086343765,
-0.07259558886289597,
-0.6717960238456726,
-0.23711290955543518,
0.46573546528816223,
0.16089190542697906,
-0.2671542167663574,
-0.4400782883167267,
-0.014237754978239536,
-0.5410053730010986,
0.6522085070610046,
0.11083077639341354,
0.23285745084285736,
0.06579428166151047,
0.11093533039093018,
-0.4346402883529663,
0.14973129332065582,
0.49020659923553467,
0.7540448307991028,
-0.3010632395744324,
0.09011156857013702,
0.24649569392204285,
-0.26889222860336304,
0.40986624360084534,
-0.031373072415590286,
-0.5860532522201538,
-0.16544578969478607,
0.4237411916255951,
0.284585177898407,
0.032134126871824265,
-0.8578545451164246,
0.15899693965911865,
0.2608051896095276,
-0.038507718592882156,
-0.39800122380256653,
0.30579379200935364,
0.09541841596364975,
0.37654784321784973,
0.4133823812007904,
0.08981321007013321,
0.24661564826965332,
-0.4847399890422821,
0.09846986085176468,
0.5965316891670227,
-0.052848778665065765,
0.03983625769615173,
0.5595600008964539,
0.1648261696100235,
-0.48949724435806274,
0.46463125944137573,
-0.40971967577934265,
-0.609944224357605,
0.6006616353988647,
0.3364672064781189,
0.8614102005958557,
-0.23173801600933075,
-0.14932133257389069,
0.7840169668197632,
0.598630964756012,
-0.2934136688709259,
0.3860219717025757,
0.024725960567593575,
-0.6571334004402161,
-0.598404049873352,
-0.770453929901123,
-0.5286156535148621,
-0.052967336028814316,
0.08694607019424438,
0.09398035705089569,
-0.6419078707695007,
0.21064528822898865,
-0.4619594216346741,
0.08966069668531418,
-0.4815293848514557,
0.22984196245670319,
-0.051685381680727005,
1.0314459800720215,
-0.47819480299949646,
0.5530012249946594,
0.9502589106559753,
0.059907373040914536,
-0.7017578482627869,
0.3425624370574951,
0.13641487061977386,
-0.7981172800064087,
0.430708110332489,
0.2163916528224945,
-0.5415352582931519,
-0.14305588603019714,
-0.20275485515594482,
-1.3612767457962036,
1.3234785795211792,
0.21266447007656097,
-0.804213285446167,
-0.1699512004852295,
-0.1234854906797409,
0.27247366309165955,
-0.3040083944797516,
-0.17543426156044006,
0.31831416487693787,
0.670920193195343,
0.513658344745636,
-1.0502421855926514,
0.34139734506607056,
0.018071381375193596,
0.043640363961458206,
0.4226284325122833,
-0.725178062915802,
0.6546896696090698,
-0.5299555063247681,
-0.17366674542427063,
0.4183705449104309,
0.17057475447654724,
0.6025452017784119,
0.40630871057510376,
0.6566334962844849,
0.6061326265335083,
0.705551028251648,
0.030207235366106033,
0.9703702926635742,
-0.379723459482193,
-0.07411790639162064,
0.9431213140487671,
-0.37961217761039734,
0.8248273730278015,
0.3263005018234253,
-0.04965999349951744,
0.5683063268661499,
0.5264188051223755,
0.322117418050766,
0.7099969983100891,
0.3880501985549927,
-0.5343757271766663,
-0.4397806227207184,
0.044805604964494705,
-0.0749019980430603,
0.5853303670883179,
0.465712308883667,
0.12827180325984955,
-0.43671631813049316,
-0.1440606266260147,
0.00033558954601176083,
0.18431715667247772,
-0.591375470161438,
0.4157906472682953,
0.05138916149735451,
-0.6745997667312622,
0.2676362693309784,
0.1891319304704666,
0.8040802478790283,
-0.6805488467216492,
-0.13011538982391357,
0.05546608939766884,
0.1469583958387375,
-0.12372331321239471,
-0.5987785458564758,
0.3790609538555145,
-0.20785823464393616,
0.19922961294651031,
-0.4159558117389679,
0.726269543170929,
-0.15101197361946106,
-0.599244236946106,
0.6548259854316711,
0.6788417100906372,
-0.21086809039115906,
-0.068875752389431,
-0.6205747127532959,
0.049345288425683975,
-0.26925286650657654,
-0.09507492929697037,
0.015487016178667545,
0.4771977365016937,
-0.19735296070575714,
1.2389907836914062,
0.8066259026527405,
0.12695588171482086,
-0.025586986914277077,
-0.17379406094551086,
0.8394370079040527,
-0.9315175414085388,
-0.6296196579933167,
-0.9972902536392212,
0.4143562316894531,
0.30239367485046387,
-0.041371844708919525,
0.8372616171836853,
0.7505868673324585,
0.552112340927124,
0.36217743158340454,
0.5871164798736572,
0.21639220416545868,
0.2576531171798706,
-0.9473116993904114,
0.26562896370887756,
-0.7306950092315674,
0.7409042716026306,
-0.1850009262561798,
-1.0309425592422485,
-0.3675277829170227,
0.8591875433921814,
-0.3639031648635864,
0.1295044720172882,
0.6326280236244202,
0.7709113359451294,
-0.20529292523860931,
-0.34531137347221375,
0.15773770213127136,
-0.0031998890917748213,
0.3054732084274292,
0.9802265763282776,
0.9343523979187012,
0.002192883752286434,
0.29383385181427,
0.00009700457303551957,
-0.14198921620845795,
-0.1176203116774559,
-0.9852938055992126,
-0.5861296057701111,
-0.3953403830528259,
-0.14869114756584167,
-0.2465599626302719,
0.20542314648628235,
0.840857744216919,
0.8945436477661133,
-0.18537279963493347,
-0.479703813791275,
-0.47416171431541443,
0.2527848780155182,
0.003956874832510948,
-0.16536767780780792,
0.1491946280002594,
0.089223712682724,
-0.23735547065734863,
0.895692765712738,
0.7464876770973206,
0.03337390720844269,
-0.8486400842666626,
-0.3096829652786255,
-0.4730704426765442,
0.21808446943759918,
0.5983383655548096,
0.2310566008090973,
-0.6782082319259644,
-0.1478806585073471,
0.10206154733896255,
0.17790982127189636,
0.13259007036685944,
0.8410640954971313,
-0.6926863789558411,
0.35276663303375244,
0.19059714674949646,
0.2525215446949005,
0.6974651217460632,
-0.3571445643901825,
0.7335749268531799,
-0.5501624345779419,
0.4671775698661804,
0.3066819906234741,
0.5342656970024109,
0.5012927055358887,
-0.5864498615264893,
0.659184455871582,
0.06480919569730759,
-0.4336632788181305,
-0.3515473008155823,
0.6200003027915955,
-1.2481203079223633,
-0.35991957783699036,
1.6745346784591675,
-0.04502194747328758,
-0.07303432375192642,
0.18373535573482513,
-0.3804102838039398,
-0.00016686637536622584,
-0.4683302938938141,
0.7183111906051636,
0.4212587773799896,
-0.3052900433540344,
-0.11312883347272873,
-0.6349357962608337,
0.1909564733505249,
0.012876116670668125,
-0.7809115648269653,
-0.14355553686618805,
0.578192949295044,
0.075284942984581,
0.1894633024930954,
0.9227467775344849,
0.24257801473140717,
0.22752496600151062,
-0.1371821016073227,
-0.1653735488653183,
-0.04700199142098427,
-0.6980447769165039,
0.03224100545048714,
0.2183428406715393,
0.08925879746675491,
0.12418846786022186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13905v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13905v1 | Persuasiveness of Generated Free-Text Rationales in Subjective Decisions: A Case Study on Pairwise Argument Ranking | 2024-06-20T00:28:33 | 2024-06-20T00:28:33 | Mohamed Elaraby, Diane Litman, Xiang Lorraine Li, Ahmed Magooda | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generating free-text rationales is among the emergent capabilities of Large
Language Models (LLMs). These rationales have been found to enhance LLM
performance across various NLP tasks. Recently, there has been growing interest
in using these rationales to provide insights for various important downstream
tasks. In this paper, we analyze generated free-text rationales in tasks with
subjective answers, emphasizing the importance of rationalization in such
scenarios. We focus on pairwise argument ranking, a highly subjective task with
significant potential for real-world applications, such as debate assistance.
We evaluate the persuasiveness of rationales generated by nine LLMs to support
their subjective choices. Our findings suggest that open-source LLMs,
particularly Llama2-70B-chat, are capable of providing highly persuasive
rationalizations, surpassing even GPT models. Additionally, our experiments
show that rationale persuasiveness can be improved by controlling its
parameters through prompting or through self-refinement. | [
-0.31661418080329895,
-0.6778079271316528,
0.8525752425193787,
0.3065742254257202,
-0.38805752992630005,
-0.35014018416404724,
-0.4234172999858856,
-0.01766243763267994,
0.11543309688568115,
0.5679640769958496,
-0.19191430509090424,
-0.46605926752090454,
-0.3373624384403229,
0.14595165848731995,
-0.2148091346025467,
1.141223669052124,
-0.02885444089770317,
0.018106704577803612,
-0.5226854085922241,
-0.2783181369304657,
-0.4884137809276581,
-0.9082193374633789,
-0.6159994602203369,
-0.3900143802165985,
0.9379894137382507,
0.6788568496704102,
0.524660587310791,
0.23110128939151764,
0.2892414927482605,
0.2846633493900299,
0.09079690277576447,
0.10398998856544495,
-0.33865001797676086,
0.6891579031944275,
-0.3717857003211975,
-0.5359455943107605,
-0.20465703308582306,
0.25468286871910095,
0.25867363810539246,
0.47618281841278076,
-0.09408487379550934,
0.09030067920684814,
0.05826418474316597,
0.7594517469406128,
-0.39954638481140137,
-0.18483585119247437,
-0.8951127529144287,
-0.071502685546875,
-0.24324309825897217,
-0.2841322124004364,
-0.36025628447532654,
-0.37177005410194397,
0.4491736888885498,
-0.485704630613327,
0.050209276378154755,
0.025066787376999855,
0.685977578163147,
0.3178287446498871,
-0.20378939807415009,
-0.400484561920166,
-0.5762284398078918,
0.8206557035446167,
-0.9425182342529297,
0.0986003577709198,
0.25121140480041504,
0.050244320183992386,
-0.11737308651208878,
-0.4491330683231354,
-0.4326089024543762,
-0.2819231152534485,
-0.00493671465665102,
0.1524328589439392,
-0.33105653524398804,
0.24394868314266205,
0.2643778622150421,
0.18839406967163086,
-0.28262683749198914,
0.31435951590538025,
0.13795381784439087,
-0.04915367439389229,
0.6126404404640198,
-0.058014918118715286,
0.1149522140622139,
-0.3750307559967041,
-0.2914576232433319,
0.0908784344792366,
-0.5427892804145813,
0.19295074045658112,
0.5629585981369019,
-0.01835116557776928,
0.038323719054460526,
0.814031183719635,
-0.4147741198539734,
0.4087202548980713,
0.3146597743034363,
-0.09291700273752213,
-0.18166759610176086,
-0.2980751097202301,
-0.3285669684410095,
0.14084932208061218,
0.9041863083839417,
0.44040969014167786,
0.22742553055286407,
-0.2806319296360016,
-0.12503595650196075,
0.08378514647483826,
0.22349944710731506,
-0.7818156480789185,
-0.19390073418617249,
0.5982163548469543,
-0.49665284156799316,
-0.4747145473957062,
-0.20861205458641052,
-0.604729175567627,
-0.4257771968841553,
-0.3862272799015045,
0.12681326270103455,
-0.12895403802394867,
-0.342287540435791,
0.11566535383462906,
-0.1811472326517105,
0.19006752967834473,
0.5012244582176208,
-0.8398603796958923,
-0.22429409623146057,
0.8280850648880005,
0.7622426748275757,
-0.289712131023407,
0.19324317574501038,
-0.437311053276062,
0.12497130781412125,
-0.5296158790588379,
1.3836066722869873,
-0.48056164383888245,
-0.4091457724571228,
-0.07161426544189453,
-0.3685018718242645,
0.19635894894599915,
-0.5767812132835388,
0.9274687767028809,
-0.35057058930397034,
0.433000385761261,
-0.5803035497665405,
-0.5285267233848572,
-0.07243651151657104,
0.37265002727508545,
-0.31962883472442627,
0.7316004633903503,
-0.5302926301956177,
-0.9618656039237976,
0.39945775270462036,
-0.7362982630729675,
-0.1984708309173584,
0.24231880903244019,
-0.3299354612827301,
-0.12498882412910461,
0.17928434908390045,
0.13560347259044647,
0.46972188353538513,
-0.450028657913208,
0.6141631603240967,
-0.46443647146224976,
0.09063883870840073,
0.5355127453804016,
-0.6355757713317871,
0.5376131534576416,
0.12202167510986328,
-0.4276829957962036,
0.5349343419075012,
-0.3224473297595978,
-0.0363183431327343,
0.11590903252363205,
-0.2898385524749756,
-0.6386733055114746,
0.3045247197151184,
-0.5146431922912598,
0.14460231363773346,
0.1667730063199997,
-0.36223021149635315,
0.05132021754980087,
-0.5898020267486572,
0.253539115190506,
0.9302198886871338,
0.10393129289150238,
0.5133877396583557,
-0.36744916439056396,
0.3363785445690155,
-0.04302341490983963,
-0.04985903576016426,
0.11624035984277725,
-0.8751361966133118,
-0.8726035356521606,
-0.07862795889377594,
0.24568337202072144,
0.5977436304092407,
-0.6186816096305847,
0.06075246259570122,
0.06611524522304535,
-0.43810945749282837,
-0.3781757950782776,
0.1032375618815422,
0.2679794728755951,
0.6283969283103943,
0.1301647126674652,
0.2582123577594757,
-0.5355294346809387,
-1.2183643579483032,
-0.38587337732315063,
-0.29659733176231384,
-0.1274450719356537,
0.43297162652015686,
0.07400551438331604,
0.04415888339281082,
1.0401356220245361,
-0.3279695510864258,
0.1317366510629654,
-0.11853840202093124,
0.2513122260570526,
0.0884987935423851,
0.32301396131515503,
0.4035501480102539,
-0.5506875514984131,
-0.19768071174621582,
-0.2757401764392853,
-0.9652946591377258,
-0.5680598616600037,
-0.23283128440380096,
-0.5711544156074524,
0.467197984457016,
0.18923784792423248,
-0.4788111746311188,
0.18817412853240967,
0.440798819065094,
-0.3083285987377167,
0.7084137797355652,
-0.077072374522686,
0.05898289009928703,
-1.0265847444534302,
-0.0704704150557518,
0.2574266791343689,
0.04463795945048332,
-0.5288397669792175,
-0.04075508192181587,
-0.46923092007637024,
0.1339990198612213,
-0.3428483307361603,
0.545377254486084,
-0.12764973938465118,
0.24187114834785461,
-0.33607029914855957,
0.5227399468421936,
-0.25407135486602783,
0.2669869363307953,
0.2554284334182739,
0.7983525395393372,
0.18278637528419495,
-0.4870406985282898,
0.21003425121307373,
0.12057948857545853,
-0.20548950135707855,
0.6078322529792786,
-0.825737714767456,
0.23593463003635406,
-0.015370161272585392,
0.28000637888908386,
-1.0642627477645874,
-0.24033454060554504,
0.244782492518425,
-0.1925496608018875,
-0.2679923176765442,
-0.33256617188453674,
-0.18896779417991638,
-0.0051829018630087376,
-0.3942098617553711,
0.25931069254875183,
0.2969503402709961,
-0.5652263760566711,
0.16928772628307343,
0.5270348787307739,
-0.3591602146625519,
-0.396050363779068,
-0.40855103731155396,
0.29272931814193726,
-0.41066211462020874,
-0.7600735425949097,
0.17268209159374237,
-0.28170567750930786,
-0.8153849840164185,
-0.22766755521297455,
-0.1970020979642868,
0.35455891489982605,
0.08445839583873749,
0.44097989797592163,
0.26089492440223694,
-0.23122066259384155,
0.11315640062093735,
0.40417224168777466,
-0.39133697748184204,
0.266497939825058,
-0.31042757630348206,
0.35660454630851746,
-0.13696034252643585,
-0.19257177412509918,
-0.31966835260391235,
0.5847952961921692,
0.24321721494197845,
0.05806479975581169,
0.485646516084671,
0.14243121445178986,
-0.15053175389766693,
-0.1624259650707245,
-0.9798957705497742,
-0.12675440311431885,
-0.468095064163208,
-0.18698221445083618,
-0.09978532046079636,
-1.1023389101028442,
0.14590612053871155,
-0.020450409501791,
0.29516464471817017,
0.4355868101119995,
0.8467044234275818,
-0.06024433672428131,
1.1186022758483887,
-0.1150849238038063,
0.3069707155227661,
0.39530149102211,
0.030862752348184586,
0.17917367815971375,
-0.5000817179679871,
-0.2834415137767792,
-0.6145241260528564,
-0.21773450076580048,
-0.5651866793632507,
-0.4130741357803345,
0.3227975070476532,
0.12267297506332397,
-0.06225304678082466,
-0.2646520435810089,
-0.6715837121009827,
0.6734122633934021,
0.6451762914657593,
-0.09449853003025055,
0.3826026916503906,
0.1539316475391388,
-0.3219679594039917,
-0.18785059452056885,
-0.5381550192832947,
-1.0354658365249634,
1.0633485317230225,
0.20883378386497498,
0.29000362753868103,
0.10025593638420105,
0.7849034070968628,
0.176289364695549,
0.5219060778617859,
-0.9712452292442322,
0.8205011487007141,
-0.11604362726211548,
-0.4416373670101166,
-0.10316117852926254,
-0.43840348720550537,
-0.8345405459403992,
0.367567241191864,
-0.4185362458229065,
-0.5114052891731262,
0.015527528710663319,
0.25699979066848755,
-0.2778126299381256,
0.195214182138443,
-0.6883514523506165,
0.6346282362937927,
-0.30966898798942566,
-0.5652250647544861,
-0.5762156844139099,
-0.24867399036884308,
0.48849961161613464,
0.14653432369232178,
0.039872270077466965,
-0.35887762904167175,
-0.1397196352481842,
1.049322485923767,
-0.37466949224472046,
0.601959228515625,
-0.2825705409049988,
-0.5243040919303894,
0.2525455355644226,
0.10210074484348297,
0.2690645158290863,
0.467155784368515,
-0.36986228823661804,
0.26610320806503296,
-0.22929346561431885,
-0.283310204744339,
-0.45888128876686096,
1.1044280529022217,
-0.6169809103012085,
-1.2988351583480835,
-0.2591150104999542,
-0.3876607418060303,
-0.42567241191864014,
0.0733976662158966,
0.11946209520101547,
0.3580625355243683,
-0.010961377061903477,
0.4126933813095093,
0.7356051206588745,
-0.2948906421661377,
0.4375474452972412,
0.24108541011810303,
-0.08000733703374863,
-0.677358865737915,
0.8345252275466919,
0.14174294471740723,
0.15985871851444244,
0.16166368126869202,
0.6863453984260559,
-0.3998216390609741,
-0.7362927794456482,
-0.49432530999183655,
0.27513688802719116,
-0.6549877524375916,
-0.23257851600646973,
-0.6621928215026855,
0.2057177573442459,
-0.2171388566493988,
-0.3951739966869354,
-0.021199773997068405,
-0.8430492877960205,
-0.28281742334365845,
-0.24593526124954224,
0.2871323525905609,
0.6779035329818726,
-0.020253200083971024,
-0.11862485110759735,
-0.6508844494819641,
0.2701515257358551,
0.5916162729263306,
0.3606385290622711,
0.04191567376255989,
-0.18150664865970612,
0.09379778802394867,
0.16487611830234528,
-0.43474990129470825,
-0.946848452091217,
0.042104046791791916,
-0.4821699261665344,
0.5874059796333313,
0.39059147238731384,
0.29455965757369995,
0.4036252200603485,
-0.08762692660093307,
1.101807713508606,
0.16887697577476501,
-0.781803548336029,
0.5394439101219177,
-0.6546071171760559,
0.15404006838798523,
0.4274802505970001,
0.37757980823516846,
-0.3325081467628479,
-0.39902934432029724,
-0.5387848019599915,
-0.8205167055130005,
0.6308682560920715,
0.20465876162052155,
0.04078782722353935,
-0.02154901809990406,
0.3987278938293457,
0.20196929574012756,
0.24754750728607178,
-0.5992148518562317,
-0.1325172483921051,
-0.38560542464256287,
-0.028521733358502388,
0.23172491788864136,
-0.5336747765541077,
-0.2903066873550415,
-0.1644437611103058,
0.7965458035469055,
-0.11457900702953339,
0.05184682831168175,
0.42797863483428955,
0.20039720833301544,
-0.014909559860825539,
0.5140674710273743,
0.7190669775009155,
0.11087600141763687,
0.014623868279159069,
0.009296214208006859,
0.16107644140720367,
0.21598263084888458,
0.12609587609767914,
-0.038326602429151535,
-0.3289562463760376,
-0.13973599672317505,
-0.011455142870545387,
0.7971940636634827,
0.14001524448394775,
-0.5878901481628418,
0.3499048948287964,
-0.10118107497692108,
-0.6166025996208191,
-0.08936040103435516,
0.07393316179513931,
0.36690789461135864,
0.35934722423553467,
0.19196274876594543,
-0.012394748628139496,
0.07930975407361984,
-0.20212116837501526,
-0.3255963921546936,
0.8063659071922302,
0.14596997201442719,
-0.2206503003835678,
0.7019878625869751,
0.5602021217346191,
-0.3533179461956024,
0.22480733692646027,
-0.06448941677808762,
-0.3157181739807129,
0.18453842401504517,
0.4842451214790344,
0.956346869468689,
0.1685003638267517,
0.3496950566768646,
0.31540119647979736,
-0.09651599824428558,
-0.07443146407604218,
-0.007871617563068867,
-0.3288266062736511,
-0.7386727929115295,
-0.33113420009613037,
-0.4084111750125885,
-0.8243551254272461,
0.18831007182598114,
-0.07985685020685196,
0.14005278050899506,
-0.5701920986175537,
-0.24957053363323212,
-0.006140213925391436,
-0.09865627437829971,
-0.15348194539546967,
-0.08105921000242233,
0.3495347797870636,
0.5844696164131165,
-0.3248310387134552,
0.5513665080070496,
0.6946117281913757,
-0.4511750340461731,
-0.7938311100006104,
0.22902032732963562,
-0.09347914904356003,
-0.46096283197402954,
0.48994889855384827,
0.10060928016901016,
-0.36246776580810547,
-0.2871101498603821,
-0.7529169321060181,
-0.637745201587677,
0.7768465280532837,
0.609790563583374,
-0.37472715973854065,
-0.1832161843776703,
0.06557291746139526,
0.4570442736148834,
-0.2174343466758728,
0.23157759010791779,
0.08748121559619904,
0.672530472278595,
0.10577747970819473,
-0.6039137244224548,
0.25733447074890137,
-0.1739237755537033,
0.03561116382479668,
0.013785175047814846,
-0.6575089693069458,
0.3341885805130005,
-0.2879018783569336,
-0.1597181260585785,
-0.0004172504704911262,
0.7203869819641113,
0.3985039293766022,
0.4468860328197479,
0.7114043235778809,
0.33534467220306396,
0.6239713430404663,
-0.046539705246686935,
0.9468635320663452,
-0.24358826875686646,
-0.11010652035474777,
0.7500693202018738,
-0.35643821954727173,
0.9410582184791565,
0.4706496000289917,
0.14547187089920044,
0.7358314990997314,
0.3109017312526703,
0.36306682229042053,
0.09648043662309647,
0.08518894761800766,
-0.4289533495903015,
-0.7299306988716125,
-0.2594413757324219,
-0.24915580451488495,
0.26947805285453796,
0.2811053395271301,
-0.1230703741312027,
-0.12042517960071564,
-0.2260836958885193,
0.2792631983757019,
0.21466147899627686,
-0.0014514445792883635,
0.9103410840034485,
0.0562266930937767,
-1.2477022409439087,
0.5325179696083069,
0.05197293683886528,
0.8836909532546997,
-0.5337132215499878,
0.08774355798959732,
-0.22631247341632843,
0.048823241144418716,
-0.4549332857131958,
-0.818861722946167,
0.24640294909477234,
0.41893619298934937,
-0.20755766332149506,
-0.627577543258667,
0.7910144329071045,
-0.2543444335460663,
-0.056208882480859756,
0.15266597270965576,
0.5391644239425659,
-0.006607751827687025,
-0.08737920969724655,
-0.6540371179580688,
-0.21919485926628113,
0.11629941314458847,
-0.532941460609436,
0.5245773792266846,
0.44176244735717773,
-0.12056123465299606,
0.5139544010162354,
1.1833454370498657,
-0.04581821709871292,
-0.3194570541381836,
0.102068692445755,
0.8895222544670105,
-0.4216647148132324,
-0.12481117993593216,
-0.9516088962554932,
0.3912874758243561,
-0.21578793227672577,
-0.2116032987833023,
0.9972808361053467,
0.5421909093856812,
0.5398927927017212,
0.11559942364692688,
0.8001564741134644,
0.2629954516887665,
0.38640934228897095,
-0.496733158826828,
0.5405838489532471,
-0.4914657473564148,
0.3723122775554657,
-0.31537798047065735,
-0.4937726557254791,
-0.2537612020969391,
0.5091584324836731,
-0.6239563226699829,
-0.23832276463508606,
0.5003126859664917,
0.8259298801422119,
0.3602212369441986,
0.39984866976737976,
0.1121906042098999,
0.06053658202290535,
0.5083655714988708,
0.20044615864753723,
0.9703058004379272,
0.3056928217411041,
0.5744624733924866,
-0.23935240507125854,
-0.40773168206214905,
-0.04128227382898331,
-1.1937471628189087,
-0.9170430898666382,
-0.40393543243408203,
-0.33844706416130066,
-0.5250810384750366,
-0.046579912304878235,
1.3201961517333984,
0.33887216448783875,
-0.6659059524536133,
-0.3571026921272278,
-0.17614510655403137,
0.3535834550857544,
0.14669038355350494,
-0.24576786160469055,
-0.008192299865186214,
-0.5723405480384827,
-0.45861610770225525,
0.47845232486724854,
0.2917601764202118,
-0.19656221568584442,
-0.22144803404808044,
-0.09374584257602692,
-0.2136426419019699,
0.552096962928772,
0.8031177520751953,
0.1515200436115265,
-0.9813143610954285,
-0.20346742868423462,
-0.019135329872369766,
0.08250723779201508,
0.04079073667526245,
1.1917463541030884,
-0.9077460169792175,
0.09770342707633972,
0.6686995029449463,
0.35991987586021423,
-0.06979537010192871,
0.18115822970867157,
0.7018861174583435,
-0.37635064125061035,
-0.07666624337434769,
0.1775863915681839,
0.4205467700958252,
0.3224985599517822,
-0.07875693589448929,
0.4103177487850189,
0.43706014752388,
-0.7862430214881897,
-0.8461905717849731,
0.0685020238161087,
-1.0662423372268677,
-0.2989921569824219,
1.702846646308899,
0.03994724527001381,
0.15258066356182098,
-0.11031395941972733,
-0.7603899836540222,
0.0635620579123497,
-0.7777724266052246,
0.657059371471405,
0.7892160415649414,
-0.2611743211746216,
0.12589596211910248,
-0.11192270368337631,
0.5558441281318665,
0.6885040998458862,
-0.9833139777183533,
0.37002769112586975,
0.6798592805862427,
0.21519382297992706,
0.1257234662771225,
0.7861432433128357,
0.009618640877306461,
-0.005614703521132469,
-0.21145717799663544,
-0.35960325598716736,
-0.08774925768375397,
-0.031986135989427567,
-0.15170620381832123,
0.5098279118537903,
0.4074622392654419,
0.17103028297424316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13903v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13903v1 | Generative AI for Enhancing Active Learning in Education: A Comparative Study of GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 in Crafting Customized Test Questions | 2024-06-20T00:25:43 | 2024-06-20T00:25:43 | Hamdireza Rouzegar, Masoud Makrehchi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | This study investigates how LLMs, specifically GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, can develop
tailored questions for Grade 9 math, aligning with active learning principles.
By utilizing an iterative method, these models adjust questions based on
difficulty and content, responding to feedback from a simulated 'student'
model. A novel aspect of the research involved using GPT-4 as a 'teacher' to
create complex questions, with GPT-3.5 as the 'student' responding to these
challenges. This setup mirrors active learning, promoting deeper engagement.
The findings demonstrate GPT-4's superior ability to generate precise,
challenging questions and notable improvements in GPT-3.5's ability to handle
more complex problems after receiving instruction from GPT-4. These results
underscore the potential of LLMs to mimic and enhance active learning
scenarios, offering a promising path for AI in customized education. This
research contributes to understanding how AI can support personalized learning
experiences, highlighting the need for further exploration in various
educational contexts | [
-0.215131014585495,
-1.4744077920913696,
0.5780210494995117,
-0.07774806767702103,
0.27242374420166016,
0.6107687950134277,
-0.008985582739114761,
-0.30866697430610657,
0.09774159640073776,
0.06717681139707565,
-0.4968390464782715,
-0.4041828513145447,
-0.1850074827671051,
0.16688720881938934,
-0.35260504484176636,
0.8513567447662354,
-0.3955408036708832,
0.18525847792625427,
-0.353818416595459,
0.07797543704509735,
-0.5292643308639526,
-0.542349636554718,
-1.0263683795928955,
-0.1831752359867096,
0.41874560713768005,
0.3876560926437378,
0.4673139452934265,
0.03989687189459801,
0.8534706830978394,
0.31109392642974854,
-0.05677088350057602,
0.1252419501543045,
-0.16907581686973572,
0.26984673738479614,
0.035771410912275314,
-0.5625877380371094,
-0.7029538750648499,
0.3125326633453369,
0.7028008103370667,
0.7783299088478088,
-0.1847815215587616,
0.11023970693349838,
0.12800398468971252,
0.40733715891838074,
-0.2955252230167389,
0.11827605217695236,
-0.2643468379974365,
0.5065398812294006,
0.02492419444024563,
0.051630739122629166,
0.05625244602560997,
-0.581194281578064,
0.22544968128204346,
-0.8568535447120667,
0.5415342450141907,
-0.3704703450202942,
0.6907384991645813,
0.4659107029438019,
-0.2249339073896408,
-0.41008275747299194,
-0.7573869228363037,
0.46686291694641113,
-0.37062397599220276,
0.2918027341365814,
0.4239415228366852,
0.40810680389404297,
0.10894735157489777,
-1.0492948293685913,
-0.4145083725452423,
-0.25624150037765503,
0.25366806983947754,
0.6275239586830139,
0.022764891386032104,
0.15767733752727509,
0.3804018497467041,
0.8255484104156494,
-0.6557396054267883,
0.05510600656270981,
-0.4744316637516022,
-0.14414051175117493,
0.3999854028224945,
0.3781338036060333,
0.3495391309261322,
0.23928134143352509,
-0.15847855806350708,
0.06876873224973679,
-0.8217381834983826,
0.196600079536438,
0.6312301158905029,
0.09786000847816467,
0.0771586000919342,
0.6937207579612732,
-0.011169795878231525,
0.7076915502548218,
0.15780223906040192,
0.1294170618057251,
0.22431564331054688,
-0.37825408577919006,
-0.04917516931891441,
-0.1705128401517868,
0.4281615614891052,
-0.023274902254343033,
0.16755712032318115,
-0.015253215096890926,
-0.3493921458721161,
0.12205064296722412,
0.33914676308631897,
-0.6566435694694519,
-0.5564707517623901,
0.07496149092912674,
-0.04674680158495903,
-0.37349268794059753,
0.09084078669548035,
-0.38844752311706543,
-0.07137393206357956,
-0.409981906414032,
0.6859282851219177,
-0.2826503813266754,
-0.09969907253980637,
0.06991332769393921,
0.00423152931034565,
0.2990565896034241,
0.6389654278755188,
-0.914116382598877,
0.3336629569530487,
0.4081113636493683,
0.6720418334007263,
-0.6939401626586914,
-0.20066842436790466,
-0.27119091153144836,
0.13395020365715027,
-0.20466727018356323,
0.723578691482544,
-0.7718261480331421,
-0.5736428499221802,
-0.004493237938731909,
-0.2927674651145935,
-0.06571516394615173,
-0.8156431317329407,
0.31657934188842773,
-0.6280612349510193,
0.6129342913627625,
-0.052583854645490646,
-0.6282471418380737,
-0.23033082485198975,
1.0692836046218872,
-0.6817712187767029,
1.1088595390319824,
0.4357193112373352,
-0.23442402482032776,
0.04966411739587784,
-0.942829966545105,
-0.29683440923690796,
0.3413538932800293,
-0.518950879573822,
-0.6683060526847839,
-0.18279150128364563,
0.24088919162750244,
0.17888601124286652,
-0.038863442838191986,
0.04447953775525093,
-0.1645212024450302,
-0.604337215423584,
0.0627809390425682,
-0.43562158942222595,
0.5707429051399231,
0.018636146560311317,
-0.651077926158905,
0.4333512485027313,
-0.47236260771751404,
0.23958192765712738,
0.3697158992290497,
-0.6784612536430359,
0.06230194866657257,
-0.11925039440393448,
-0.42368850111961365,
-0.18218722939491272,
0.4467286467552185,
-0.2728358209133148,
0.5502161979675293,
-0.209544375538826,
0.21230381727218628,
1.0153368711471558,
0.18124988675117493,
0.4773764908313751,
-0.35249030590057373,
1.024858832359314,
-0.13287600874900818,
0.33669647574424744,
-0.08143457770347595,
-0.7759994268417358,
-0.8225365877151489,
0.12818625569343567,
0.296366423368454,
0.6187198758125305,
-0.6398635506629944,
0.07063749432563782,
0.21767574548721313,
-0.15369416773319244,
-0.5397483706474304,
0.3022521734237671,
0.175759419798851,
0.5257655382156372,
0.502321720123291,
-0.3465442955493927,
-0.3088986873626709,
-0.45759281516075134,
-0.1107575073838234,
-0.18547986447811127,
-0.08509671688079834,
0.42292797565460205,
0.46143290400505066,
-0.02469678781926632,
0.7527943253517151,
-0.822533369064331,
-0.34224340319633484,
-0.2145216464996338,
-0.09578141570091248,
-0.08516813069581985,
0.42630887031555176,
0.5042651891708374,
-0.8424455523490906,
-0.8922748565673828,
-0.16854853928089142,
-0.824816107749939,
-0.030651241540908813,
0.027868859469890594,
0.018382703885436058,
-0.36944207549095154,
0.29569047689437866,
-0.4262535274028778,
0.3545243442058563,
0.32887551188468933,
-0.37121978402137756,
0.5269345641136169,
-0.0644034743309021,
0.19094614684581757,
-0.8869974613189697,
-0.2530997097492218,
-0.2545435428619385,
0.10813598334789276,
-0.4696037769317627,
0.10734187811613083,
0.06462355703115463,
-0.3198028802871704,
-0.20649169385433197,
0.6693375110626221,
-0.3659265339374542,
-0.17252880334854126,
-0.17347784340381622,
0.02356017380952835,
-0.09706160426139832,
0.3703402578830719,
-0.19757330417633057,
1.070961356163025,
0.5543580651283264,
-0.31974467635154724,
0.5283287763595581,
0.3765435814857483,
-0.18740680813789368,
0.27539655566215515,
-0.765890896320343,
0.29425862431526184,
0.26524800062179565,
0.16541162133216858,
-0.8307934403419495,
-0.1253356635570526,
0.4204378128051758,
-0.5158835053443909,
0.12060452997684479,
-0.018092945218086243,
-0.3751366436481476,
-0.27883559465408325,
-0.3707691729068756,
0.49415796995162964,
0.7987182140350342,
-0.4823291301727295,
0.5259969234466553,
-0.028931401669979095,
-0.3844151496887207,
-0.1919325739145279,
-0.2754329741001129,
-0.04021230340003967,
-0.24622514843940735,
-0.3639952540397644,
0.5099146962165833,
-0.6580713987350464,
-0.4075166881084442,
0.08950483053922653,
-0.06648224592208862,
0.03289348632097244,
0.45041757822036743,
0.01925068348646164,
0.34676462411880493,
-0.38985270261764526,
-0.0981539860367775,
0.11962678283452988,
0.09924887120723724,
0.20974060893058777,
-0.015528159216046333,
0.2736203372478485,
-0.11762184649705887,
-0.6578264236450195,
-0.23650553822517395,
0.31433188915252686,
0.1004997193813324,
-0.35466673970222473,
0.2512337565422058,
0.6056596040725708,
-0.29872679710388184,
-0.2500248849391937,
-0.2565668821334839,
-0.5498644113540649,
-0.5162255764007568,
0.021630294620990753,
-0.49775591492652893,
-1.153271198272705,
0.5386044979095459,
-0.0554053857922554,
0.20148545503616333,
0.2159864604473114,
0.7224686145782471,
-0.16938723623752594,
1.3844926357269287,
0.45866769552230835,
0.09845831990242004,
0.8646239638328552,
-0.7310462594032288,
0.0315341018140316,
-0.7792335152626038,
-0.3540555238723755,
-0.07586203515529633,
-0.5124562978744507,
-0.4233275055885315,
-0.37588152289390564,
0.39858272671699524,
-0.06664629280567169,
-0.49708500504493713,
-0.4150015711784363,
-0.6821625232696533,
0.47608768939971924,
0.6649747490882874,
0.08002106845378876,
0.2065846174955368,
-0.014431459829211235,
-0.18859611451625824,
0.09088060259819031,
-0.5018453001976013,
-0.4664734899997711,
1.0165467262268066,
0.017842985689640045,
0.6759646534919739,
0.5554647445678711,
0.6534317135810852,
0.1368708312511444,
0.6576643586158752,
-0.8435875773429871,
0.5939229726791382,
0.32992565631866455,
-1.0005803108215332,
-0.28304192423820496,
-0.3336408734321594,
-1.0694907903671265,
0.12801694869995117,
-0.055045753717422485,
-0.19168992340564728,
-0.4245699942111969,
0.10835320502519608,
-0.5189832448959351,
0.391843318939209,
-0.7472593188285828,
0.5936006307601929,
-0.35514891147613525,
-0.5660989284515381,
0.13563232123851776,
-0.4493706226348877,
0.12575958669185638,
-0.22790154814720154,
-0.3321871757507324,
-0.0067330654710531235,
-0.2378809005022049,
0.7122511863708496,
-0.0667024776339531,
1.0204824209213257,
-0.22148430347442627,
-0.11715668439865112,
0.6483620405197144,
0.06659046560525894,
0.2799125611782074,
0.14071154594421387,
-0.09338345378637314,
-0.38566964864730835,
-0.5634763836860657,
-0.5605846047401428,
-0.7175495028495789,
0.8291475176811218,
-1.0643357038497925,
-1.1763490438461304,
-0.586908221244812,
-0.5165054202079773,
-0.3767583966255188,
0.12515605986118317,
-0.08394469320774078,
0.13711772859096527,
-0.11833103001117706,
-0.06292077898979187,
0.9030621647834778,
-0.006567515432834625,
0.4993739724159241,
0.4641539454460144,
0.1705893874168396,
-0.4141673445701599,
0.8133102059364319,
0.2249916046857834,
0.11323122680187225,
0.3074159026145935,
0.363310843706131,
-0.27190953493118286,
-0.7780308127403259,
-0.4880923628807068,
-0.029917007312178612,
-0.6896283626556396,
-0.29925504326820374,
-0.3309226334095001,
-0.4038664698600769,
-0.47512760758399963,
-0.4768553078174591,
-0.1338985115289688,
-0.3759627044200897,
-0.6156392097473145,
-0.5009949207305908,
0.15602955222129822,
0.9728034138679504,
0.17283926904201508,
0.26229846477508545,
-0.4916026294231415,
0.20351900160312653,
0.7989541292190552,
0.2568812072277069,
-0.18443073332309723,
-0.6452082395553589,
0.08430784940719604,
-0.11908295005559921,
-0.9482825994491577,
-0.7323715090751648,
0.05115749314427376,
0.32113343477249146,
0.7339053153991699,
0.3595069944858551,
-0.1869104653596878,
0.6088867783546448,
-0.4732057452201843,
1.2155596017837524,
0.028099503368139267,
-0.5517848134040833,
0.7152348756790161,
-0.3629492223262787,
0.2755846083164215,
0.29966381192207336,
0.5587231516838074,
0.15105637907981873,
-0.27376121282577515,
-0.8391997814178467,
-0.7037721872329712,
0.42230454087257385,
0.24540944397449493,
0.4910547435283661,
0.09777474403381348,
0.860187292098999,
0.20557831227779388,
0.1248428076505661,
-0.7837525010108948,
-0.34459614753723145,
-0.4111311435699463,
-0.4081442058086395,
-0.10882721841335297,
-0.07594851404428482,
-0.22937212884426117,
-0.4575161635875702,
0.4713105261325836,
-0.18795065581798553,
0.31893548369407654,
-0.1157047376036644,
0.07285472005605698,
0.0024154260754585266,
0.08070023357868195,
0.757551908493042,
0.6418737173080444,
-0.12003618478775024,
0.050164397805929184,
0.4773429036140442,
-0.871430516242981,
0.3238159716129303,
0.09003886580467224,
-0.24504682421684265,
-0.39083707332611084,
0.4191977381706238,
0.5930994153022766,
-0.03551764413714409,
-0.44665953516960144,
0.36840590834617615,
-0.22296059131622314,
-0.48779594898223877,
-0.6282415390014648,
0.4760386645793915,
-0.15719783306121826,
0.22162361443042755,
0.47063636779785156,
-0.30258461833000183,
0.08643198758363724,
-0.5719591379165649,
0.07930808514356613,
0.28103262186050415,
-0.38535240292549133,
-0.7541933655738831,
1.0006823539733887,
0.37604692578315735,
-0.6790489554405212,
0.928210437297821,
0.04301120713353157,
-0.5591723918914795,
0.8044925928115845,
0.8743199110031128,
0.8153681755065918,
-0.5922003984451294,
0.20877021551132202,
0.4629506468772888,
-0.028097612783312798,
0.10609494894742966,
0.6751171350479126,
-0.2909853756427765,
-0.7744359970092773,
-0.15929578244686127,
-0.1993928849697113,
-0.8290559649467468,
0.17448769509792328,
-0.5168048143386841,
0.013476446270942688,
-0.6767476797103882,
-0.03828103467822075,
-0.2581576108932495,
0.25640058517456055,
-0.4715625047683716,
0.4253937304019928,
-0.12435701489448547,
0.37243491411209106,
-0.636161208152771,
0.6314771771430969,
1.3753851652145386,
-0.5859882831573486,
-0.9721212387084961,
0.0612972192466259,
-0.20746847987174988,
-0.8821210265159607,
0.44867438077926636,
0.037559494376182556,
0.2532438039779663,
0.4761206805706024,
-0.40062370896339417,
-0.6041920185089111,
1.3800386190414429,
0.057391416281461716,
-0.17355690896511078,
-0.16968291997909546,
0.18594761192798615,
0.527452290058136,
-0.09243524819612503,
0.2527028024196625,
0.14527055621147156,
0.36159300804138184,
0.3008411228656769,
-0.4651036262512207,
-0.2863350808620453,
-0.4053555130958557,
-0.4316386282444,
0.25546687841415405,
-0.6665677428245544,
0.8766454458236694,
-0.4360564351081848,
0.23598381876945496,
0.08279585093259811,
0.7406460046768188,
0.5172199010848999,
0.5769197940826416,
0.34037595987319946,
0.5043560862541199,
0.6747310161590576,
-0.24803468585014343,
0.8842329382896423,
-0.06661782413721085,
0.23700594902038574,
0.816975474357605,
-0.11612259596586227,
0.5153919458389282,
0.43995898962020874,
-0.39564207196235657,
0.3291313648223877,
1.0901281833648682,
-0.16052570939064026,
0.47447094321250916,
0.2909703850746155,
-0.7973620295524597,
-0.1303180307149887,
0.3593459129333496,
-0.5258440375328064,
0.24789021909236908,
0.3510963022708893,
-0.06329827755689621,
0.04397895187139511,
0.1153039038181305,
-0.21579556167125702,
0.06688503175973892,
-0.4729742407798767,
0.7314630746841431,
0.03857079893350601,
-0.7077521681785583,
0.10337674617767334,
-0.11876316368579865,
0.4098104238510132,
-0.47508275508880615,
-0.24926650524139404,
-0.5892401933670044,
0.24401356279850006,
-0.17146822810173035,
-0.8519722819328308,
-0.04448205605149269,
0.03878594562411308,
-0.0003273945767432451,
-0.4176451861858368,
0.4523158669471741,
-0.3733789324760437,
-0.4914836585521698,
-0.27390381693840027,
0.7649449110031128,
0.051054518669843674,
0.18323786556720734,
-0.9633197784423828,
-0.01541014201939106,
0.08821310847997665,
-0.4783635437488556,
0.3381120562553406,
0.2448788285255432,
-0.1491127908229828,
0.6414139866828918,
0.6901505589485168,
0.010667827911674976,
0.2303323596715927,
0.27161508798599243,
0.8310192227363586,
-0.6464242339134216,
-0.25550398230552673,
-0.5601986050605774,
0.4073464870452881,
0.1482345163822174,
-0.3789823651313782,
0.911566436290741,
0.702109694480896,
0.9333201050758362,
-0.08648582547903061,
0.892616331577301,
0.10705096274614334,
0.3155973553657532,
-0.3441670835018158,
0.24318677186965942,
-0.567509651184082,
0.4780476689338684,
-0.11112916469573975,
-1.1655762195587158,
-0.39461809396743774,
0.7299257516860962,
-0.37146079540252686,
0.47537240386009216,
0.6397387981414795,
0.3765143156051636,
-0.09852936863899231,
-0.06674595177173615,
0.37651869654655457,
-0.22657547891139984,
0.795646071434021,
0.3014982342720032,
1.1959121227264404,
-0.2725776135921478,
0.4790560305118561,
-0.2820596694946289,
-0.14123950898647308,
-0.021346179768443108,
-0.1687130331993103,
-1.0115735530853271,
-0.5453611612319946,
-0.5199888348579407,
-0.07203978300094604,
0.06919621676206589,
0.4251086413860321,
0.0595737099647522,
-0.5514078736305237,
-0.04069119691848755,
-0.2486172467470169,
0.1401071548461914,
-0.0729077085852623,
-0.23077085614204407,
0.5547658205032349,
-0.400335431098938,
-1.0330873727798462,
0.5238483548164368,
-0.12386232614517212,
0.7220906019210815,
-0.45297810435295105,
-0.029583580791950226,
0.18536554276943207,
-0.01702936552464962,
0.6614004969596863,
0.107339046895504,
-0.5414018630981445,
-0.32058873772621155,
0.3525581657886505,
0.018623631447553635,
0.10411185026168823,
0.9246671199798584,
-0.813896894454956,
0.264649361371994,
0.4003801643848419,
0.7000933885574341,
0.4879302680492401,
0.1607086956501007,
0.3041696846485138,
-0.4193955957889557,
-0.0729261040687561,
0.798604428768158,
0.007811445277184248,
0.32133013010025024,
-0.4689629375934601,
0.7541161179542542,
0.3820829689502716,
-0.49404048919677734,
-0.7314322590827942,
0.13161805272102356,
-0.9418725967407227,
-0.07877359539270401,
1.0990197658538818,
-0.315992146730423,
0.28978389501571655,
-0.06805887818336487,
-0.2671440541744232,
-0.04063465818762779,
-0.005232545081526041,
0.9856704473495483,
0.671442985534668,
-0.6551055312156677,
-0.13707375526428223,
-0.8197135329246521,
0.5087796449661255,
0.6429262757301331,
-0.9326222538948059,
-0.7015581130981445,
0.22305773198604584,
0.36247214674949646,
-0.18148472905158997,
0.6018354296684265,
-0.11130255460739136,
0.3518935441970825,
-0.16298437118530273,
-0.08490416407585144,
-0.2415805608034134,
-0.16356702148914337,
-0.08053357154130936,
0.45822757482528687,
0.29981499910354614,
-0.3008781373500824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13898v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13898v1 | The Use of Multimodal Large Language Models to Detect Objects from Thermal Images: Transportation Applications | 2024-06-20T00:05:10 | 2024-06-20T00:05:10 | Huthaifa I. Ashqar, Taqwa I. Alhadidi, Mohammed Elhenawy, Nour O. Khanfar | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.CY | The integration of thermal imaging data with Multimodal Large Language Models
(MLLMs) constitutes an exciting opportunity for improving the safety and
functionality of autonomous driving systems and many Intelligent Transportation
Systems (ITS) applications. This study investigates whether MLLMs can
understand complex images from RGB and thermal cameras and detect objects
directly. Our goals were to 1) assess the ability of the MLLM to learn from
information from various sets, 2) detect objects and identify elements in
thermal cameras, 3) determine whether two independent modality images show the
same scene, and 4) learn all objects using different modalities. The findings
showed that both GPT-4 and Gemini were effective in detecting and classifying
objects in thermal images. Similarly, the Mean Absolute Percentage Error (MAPE)
for pedestrian classification was 70.39% and 81.48%, respectively. Moreover,
the MAPE for bike, car, and motorcycle detection were 78.4%, 55.81%, and
96.15%, respectively. Gemini produced MAPE of 66.53%, 59.35% and 78.18%
respectively. This finding further demonstrates that MLLM can identify thermal
images and can be employed in advanced imaging automation technologies for ITS
applications. | [
-0.6210644245147705,
-0.6782247424125671,
0.782120943069458,
-0.02721991017460823,
-0.33726340532302856,
-0.027618443593382835,
-0.2578536570072174,
-0.8142885565757751,
-0.3450569212436676,
-0.11527835577726364,
-0.3273489773273468,
-0.4802326261997223,
-0.44313254952430725,
0.03454180434346199,
-0.32832202315330505,
0.2649143934249878,
-0.12281624227762222,
0.017350804060697556,
-0.039516888558864594,
-0.10635789483785629,
-0.36873069405555725,
-0.7327750325202942,
-0.3376103937625885,
-0.06108741834759712,
0.8256180882453918,
-0.22484301030635834,
0.7679429650306702,
0.39500337839126587,
0.7091854810714722,
0.43503308296203613,
0.41530749201774597,
0.44121742248535156,
0.07008720189332962,
0.005610954947769642,
-0.14350441098213196,
-0.015285774134099483,
0.07856255769729614,
-0.3599362373352051,
0.6868978142738342,
0.03333261236548424,
-0.15068328380584717,
-0.033800091594457626,
-0.3580015003681183,
0.539030909538269,
-0.8864432573318481,
0.3896239101886749,
-0.6724891662597656,
0.06319458782672882,
-0.23232021927833557,
-0.25309282541275024,
-0.48488345742225647,
0.14207935333251953,
-0.33188068866729736,
-0.49505287408828735,
0.0866268053650856,
0.3758448660373688,
0.8946350812911987,
0.11742289364337921,
-0.7407796382904053,
-0.40763577818870544,
-0.8597995638847351,
1.0013971328735352,
-0.6146305799484253,
0.822150468826294,
0.08261524140834808,
0.5165582299232483,
0.10340215265750885,
-0.3548748195171356,
-0.8665892481803894,
-0.2499823123216629,
-0.4618532061576843,
0.18627004325389862,
-0.14425845444202423,
-0.17370592057704926,
0.24402019381523132,
-0.12514622509479523,
-0.9388221502304077,
0.22582672536373138,
-0.464725136756897,
-0.20837564766407013,
0.5109555125236511,
0.3452323377132416,
0.42672547698020935,
0.09680268913507462,
-0.40200287103652954,
-0.04929078742861748,
-0.13785988092422485,
-0.06203090399503708,
0.1971336156129837,
0.33254626393318176,
-0.03960263356566429,
0.3638077676296234,
0.23302270472049713,
1.0502371788024902,
-0.547102689743042,
-0.47376325726509094,
0.49059104919433594,
-0.1818239837884903,
-0.612044632434845,
-0.15768782794475555,
0.8339036107063293,
0.2873058021068573,
0.22121372818946838,
-0.23879295587539673,
-0.5467649698257446,
-0.07354602217674255,
-0.11910314112901688,
-0.6143538951873779,
-0.24659717082977295,
0.10265791416168213,
-0.6100656986236572,
0.045699067413806915,
0.3215196132659912,
-0.26301804184913635,
-0.2245471477508545,
-0.6582755446434021,
0.30361342430114746,
-0.20006221532821655,
-0.793712317943573,
0.44773340225219727,
-0.19974280893802643,
0.8558754324913025,
0.6691635847091675,
-0.8170894980430603,
-0.1903134435415268,
0.6643764972686768,
0.7188115119934082,
0.03811514377593994,
-0.3738599419593811,
-0.1583590805530548,
0.2846950888633728,
-0.12469539046287537,
1.065752387046814,
-0.5964866280555725,
-0.3850446343421936,
-0.09810075163841248,
0.23089349269866943,
-0.42760688066482544,
-0.47482073307037354,
0.3537951111793518,
-0.7324649095535278,
0.1551247537136078,
-0.1536206156015396,
-0.04770181328058243,
-0.4720429480075836,
0.5489614009857178,
-0.5044016242027283,
0.9260901808738708,
0.07455263286828995,
-0.6925251483917236,
0.421883761882782,
-0.5310121774673462,
-0.6422994136810303,
-0.1394195705652237,
-0.16489997506141663,
-0.6336168646812439,
0.019713522866368294,
0.07425161451101303,
0.8470771312713623,
-0.16787122189998627,
0.22417959570884705,
-0.3987562656402588,
-0.1550503522157669,
0.4533623456954956,
-0.5889613032341003,
0.484622985124588,
0.4164878726005554,
-0.09407990425825119,
0.14505065977573395,
-0.4504191279411316,
-0.09482703357934952,
0.06402194499969482,
-0.6111136078834534,
-0.20055638253688812,
-0.20503422617912292,
0.6268002986907959,
0.28960373997688293,
0.0664515495300293,
-0.7069516181945801,
0.04204519838094711,
0.3471556603908539,
0.021724285557866096,
0.9416818618774414,
-0.403715044260025,
0.17603923380374908,
0.05919552966952324,
0.3257535398006439,
0.505740761756897,
0.29129281640052795,
-0.1977638155221939,
-0.6483739614486694,
-0.5592424869537354,
-0.3956342339515686,
-0.2930552661418915,
0.7348757386207581,
-0.9661861658096313,
0.2644367218017578,
0.10017820447683334,
-0.6085753440856934,
-0.08669429272413254,
-0.03949496150016785,
0.2729911506175995,
0.49440035223960876,
0.3585241138935089,
0.23576338589191437,
-0.4643246531486511,
-0.8200031518936157,
-0.05332968384027481,
-0.03851322457194328,
-0.06680995970964432,
0.47500067949295044,
0.6771532893180847,
-0.3056361675262451,
0.6468971371650696,
-0.5485402345657349,
-0.05561771243810654,
0.10694678872823715,
-0.06769867241382599,
0.2579108774662018,
0.6040294766426086,
0.888924777507782,
-1.1136059761047363,
-0.5468633770942688,
0.5034827589988708,
-1.3016102313995361,
0.6714500188827515,
0.04909992963075638,
-0.005085647571831942,
0.12413450330495834,
0.5319613814353943,
-0.5516135692596436,
0.2900818884372711,
0.3110390901565552,
-0.41707301139831543,
0.3435920774936676,
-0.4089083969593048,
0.25072938203811646,
-0.6597131490707397,
-0.01786753721535206,
0.3833148181438446,
-0.41949689388275146,
-0.905813992023468,
-0.011215738952159882,
0.35660603642463684,
-0.05552874505519867,
-0.748451828956604,
0.3389222025871277,
-0.667571485042572,
-0.2706172466278076,
-0.2809768617153168,
-0.18717947602272034,
-0.07493969053030014,
0.3740804195404053,
0.4479252099990845,
0.6288073658943176,
0.9615748524665833,
-0.6033406853675842,
0.7164800763130188,
-0.3291007876396179,
-0.75633305311203,
0.5503900051116943,
-0.3181856572628021,
0.33115530014038086,
-0.7257319688796997,
-0.033112626522779465,
-0.9965403079986572,
-0.19501686096191406,
0.39383649826049805,
-0.10320131480693817,
0.4756802022457123,
0.08311590552330017,
-0.8516245484352112,
-0.425143301486969,
0.16509562730789185,
0.3901122212409973,
0.24814186990261078,
-0.4226040840148926,
1.1178486347198486,
0.2772727310657501,
0.3530389964580536,
-0.5398284196853638,
-0.6199967861175537,
-0.00881871860474348,
-0.2635982036590576,
-0.5331870317459106,
-0.34475040435791016,
-0.022991502657532692,
-0.2943600118160248,
-0.03797629103064537,
0.43284982442855835,
-0.32438650727272034,
0.18889571726322174,
0.19154012203216553,
0.4711877405643463,
-0.5118288993835449,
0.38537395000457764,
-0.4855874478816986,
-0.059696733951568604,
-0.05961136147379875,
-0.2191440761089325,
0.593904435634613,
-0.4749912917613983,
-0.567895233631134,
-0.5874066352844238,
0.3078940212726593,
1.0576139688491821,
-0.23427517712116241,
0.8926712870597839,
1.3931792974472046,
-0.3861914277076721,
0.5052093267440796,
-0.6866645812988281,
-0.1977391093969345,
-0.5240737795829773,
0.4859578013420105,
-0.6039280295372009,
-0.3909873962402344,
0.4030632972717285,
0.31870847940444946,
-0.02366476319730282,
0.4022720754146576,
0.6123672127723694,
-0.3098616600036621,
1.0243083238601685,
0.36039596796035767,
-0.10027746856212616,
0.4005740284919739,
-0.17426864802837372,
0.2598661780357361,
-0.9296061992645264,
-0.8877747654914856,
-0.5199253559112549,
-0.39341112971305847,
-0.33091220259666443,
-0.4078761339187622,
0.4259026050567627,
-0.6614170074462891,
-0.4622002840042114,
0.12651865184307098,
-0.6177136898040771,
0.5612268447875977,
0.41919195652008057,
0.6622274518013,
0.1732671856880188,
0.019998908042907715,
0.20919738709926605,
0.12190484255552292,
-0.4526229500770569,
-0.2160741239786148,
0.8008376359939575,
0.483638733625412,
0.9418731331825256,
0.24548783898353577,
0.04441041871905327,
0.21245886385440826,
0.535882294178009,
-0.8477044105529785,
0.5182843208312988,
-0.26190999150276184,
-0.7757087349891663,
-0.16761021316051483,
-0.2990216314792633,
-0.8210916519165039,
0.5048013925552368,
-0.2708737552165985,
-0.3075663447380066,
0.38100919127464294,
-0.025906985625624657,
-0.041906435042619705,
0.6954468488693237,
-0.8882099986076355,
0.8381756544113159,
-0.7178788185119629,
-0.19989584386348724,
0.07093232125043869,
-0.5692397952079773,
0.549441397190094,
-0.18860618770122528,
0.4371739327907562,
-0.35610851645469666,
0.04595150053501129,
0.6339011192321777,
0.3080500066280365,
0.6484464406967163,
-0.4920291006565094,
-0.10028189420700073,
0.08578811585903168,
-0.07157894223928452,
0.2388746440410614,
-0.23916670680046082,
-0.19630497694015503,
0.11218468099832535,
-0.25884440541267395,
-0.4281494617462158,
-0.6847376227378845,
0.5419672131538391,
-0.7930816411972046,
-0.5141986608505249,
-0.5103016495704651,
-0.8074009418487549,
-0.010043563321232796,
0.12278637290000916,
-0.0036295850295573473,
0.46339496970176697,
0.407417893409729,
0.21299408376216888,
0.4685743451118469,
-0.2346174120903015,
0.6600174903869629,
0.7054867148399353,
-0.3596149682998657,
-0.0032648607157170773,
1.0587689876556396,
-0.1343875676393509,
0.0760459303855896,
0.4619905948638916,
0.27826499938964844,
-0.505346417427063,
-0.5844937562942505,
-0.4493574798107147,
0.3010161817073822,
-0.9866692423820496,
-0.26528850197792053,
-0.6443824768066406,
-0.06329081207513809,
-0.2873097062110901,
-0.2597067356109619,
-0.1455872505903244,
0.10481559485197067,
-0.5611724257469177,
-0.03149353712797165,
0.14822939038276672,
0.7748481631278992,
0.01899353601038456,
0.1779659390449524,
-0.7100535035133362,
0.16918742656707764,
0.6079215407371521,
-0.21013830602169037,
0.006867727264761925,
-0.3314210772514343,
-0.19239245355129242,
-0.015325605869293213,
0.00905355904251337,
-0.3893702030181885,
0.3970421254634857,
0.004127044230699539,
0.7414606809616089,
0.6693776845932007,
-0.1488548219203949,
0.76169753074646,
-0.09318634122610092,
0.6838955879211426,
0.6160727143287659,
-0.7482913732528687,
0.3279377520084381,
-0.2926288843154907,
0.4244925379753113,
0.04075327888131142,
0.37806519865989685,
-0.23882454633712769,
-0.2693242132663727,
-0.14692531526088715,
-0.32748162746429443,
0.4543015956878662,
0.06539037078619003,
0.17499855160713196,
0.2579517364501953,
0.23510333895683289,
-0.12236527353525162,
0.272525817155838,
-0.9765835404396057,
-0.025228051468729973,
-0.3356347382068634,
-0.09016279876232147,
-0.10305814445018768,
0.01504750456660986,
0.0607229508459568,
-0.3285844326019287,
0.2859205901622772,
-0.009687653742730618,
0.5566047430038452,
0.16690894961357117,
0.0313170850276947,
0.15583957731723785,
0.1736627221107483,
1.1489537954330444,
0.6328858137130737,
-0.4297329783439636,
0.6590548157691956,
-0.029215985909104347,
-0.4897189140319824,
0.19448906183242798,
-0.4676714837551117,
0.22799214720726013,
0.1857006847858429,
0.5692776441574097,
0.6005674004554749,
-0.2271512895822525,
-0.5483841300010681,
0.2936078608036041,
-0.09218598157167435,
-0.07319086045026779,
-0.22391337156295776,
0.10387726873159409,
-0.13734681904315948,
0.43326160311698914,
0.38399478793144226,
0.44436460733413696,
0.054115839302539825,
-1.016823410987854,
-0.039565086364746094,
0.8356946706771851,
-0.31823593378067017,
-0.39166855812072754,
0.5548405051231384,
0.09312251210212708,
0.0773668885231018,
0.8797695636749268,
-0.2114895135164261,
-0.7715545892715454,
0.8954001069068909,
0.5074464082717896,
0.6485850811004639,
-0.38008448481559753,
-0.18921136856079102,
0.3455522358417511,
0.5602447390556335,
-0.09108147770166397,
0.3060910403728485,
-0.2235015481710434,
-1.3735051155090332,
0.019272780045866966,
-0.31455689668655396,
-0.12722544372081757,
-0.24975337088108063,
-0.5678526163101196,
0.11281578987836838,
-0.42693954706192017,
-0.20461036264896393,
0.0018442224245518446,
-0.6542760729789734,
-0.986839234828949,
0.4090702533721924,
0.46206098794937134,
0.7017022967338562,
-1.2140663862228394,
1.0483131408691406,
0.6049283742904663,
-0.08300777524709702,
-0.8093313574790955,
-0.380576491355896,
-0.09718149900436401,
-1.21055269241333,
1.3264691829681396,
0.2432079166173935,
-0.3595626950263977,
-0.060019753873348236,
-0.4227616488933563,
-0.41476941108703613,
1.1264568567276,
0.313018798828125,
-0.5322099924087524,
-0.0752667635679245,
0.051660411059856415,
0.22546252608299255,
-0.38299134373664856,
0.44927459955215454,
0.23228175938129425,
1.0273582935333252,
0.3346148133277893,
-1.1143807172775269,
-0.08560310304164886,
-0.033345919102430344,
-0.06598573923110962,
0.2785128057003021,
-0.5648510456085205,
0.9989057779312134,
-0.24777181446552277,
-0.2039719969034195,
-0.1544659584760666,
0.3402499258518219,
0.04541284218430519,
0.5992502570152283,
0.7245080471038818,
0.5054692625999451,
0.6369468569755554,
-0.30852875113487244,
0.8688585162162781,
0.15390872955322266,
0.5702872276306152,
0.44178903102874756,
-0.34818345308303833,
0.7686930298805237,
0.45419782400131226,
-0.11678668111562729,
0.5958202481269836,
0.5926322937011719,
-0.2325250804424286,
0.8595783710479736,
-0.05012595281004906,
-0.617550790309906,
-0.4768662750720978,
-0.02555096335709095,
-0.5054836273193359,
0.4999309480190277,
0.6475257873535156,
-0.3487357497215271,
-0.1692804992198944,
0.7799265384674072,
-0.035553961992263794,
-0.4150480628013611,
-0.48007556796073914,
0.6857296228408813,
-0.1902032047510147,
-0.3421858251094818,
0.4855143129825592,
-0.004319680389016867,
0.5014899969100952,
-0.436276912689209,
0.23294571042060852,
0.2217753678560257,
0.36458563804626465,
-0.5164217948913574,
-1.172438383102417,
0.3345106840133667,
-0.17664670944213867,
0.07271631807088852,
-0.24724537134170532,
0.7441152930259705,
-0.21846851706504822,
-0.7780314683914185,
0.04873194545507431,
0.24211707711219788,
0.22073228657245636,
-0.27863502502441406,
-0.5670058727264404,
0.4939628839492798,
-0.030350755900144577,
-0.07955052703619003,
0.11014459282159805,
0.3562855124473572,
0.4662448763847351,
0.8190005421638489,
0.7775670886039734,
-0.29220882058143616,
0.2100849151611328,
-0.28758448362350464,
0.9893777370452881,
-0.703687310218811,
-0.10825751721858978,
-0.9721224308013916,
0.6835041046142578,
0.12650226056575775,
0.31557923555374146,
0.8132786750793457,
0.9414010643959045,
0.535785973072052,
-0.6046103239059448,
0.7577142715454102,
0.2084088772535324,
0.07058658450841904,
-0.9841264486312866,
0.076356440782547,
-0.5900154113769531,
0.19722987711429596,
-0.1102081835269928,
-0.7590032815933228,
-0.6137045621871948,
0.8777201771736145,
-0.3222200870513916,
0.07110831141471863,
0.7085619568824768,
0.996544599533081,
-0.5411035418510437,
-0.2078351378440857,
0.6998177170753479,
-0.08420337736606598,
0.6114811301231384,
0.5749659538269043,
1.1424438953399658,
-0.5013017654418945,
0.39935338497161865,
-0.08296877890825272,
0.03716413304209709,
-0.03934093937277794,
-0.7840595245361328,
-1.035753607749939,
-0.6673861742019653,
-0.3750939965248108,
-0.29897528886795044,
-0.18779398500919342,
0.4343335032463074,
1.1261693239212036,
-0.6469259858131409,
-0.1713963896036148,
0.18665730953216553,
0.13436198234558105,
0.09302697330713272,
-0.2188568413257599,
0.3900054097175598,
0.11418701708316803,
-0.6901282072067261,
0.265118271112442,
0.6619774699211121,
0.3953554332256317,
-0.5499644875526428,
-0.0016170934541150928,
-0.07311155647039413,
-0.29032546281814575,
0.827965497970581,
0.3350701928138733,
-0.8489593267440796,
-0.309577614068985,
0.12632037699222565,
-0.1535472571849823,
0.10211450606584549,
1.0762754678726196,
-0.598641574382782,
0.5119969248771667,
0.40114814043045044,
0.10756149888038635,
0.46384334564208984,
-0.16012999415397644,
0.03067968226969242,
-0.3787650167942047,
0.7371315360069275,
0.06197104975581169,
0.7470413446426392,
0.38855621218681335,
-0.38153377175331116,
0.19489644467830658,
0.36986517906188965,
-0.6026431918144226,
-0.5558809041976929,
0.25737884640693665,
-1.350119948387146,
-0.410883367061615,
1.143294334411621,
-0.15007930994033813,
-0.3562370240688324,
-0.5978802442550659,
-0.2486269325017929,
-0.3019023537635803,
-0.354331374168396,
0.4642064571380615,
0.27093109488487244,
-0.16978824138641357,
-0.8107872009277344,
-0.4585356116294861,
-0.17792722582817078,
-0.3529995381832123,
-0.9958896040916443,
-0.17932535707950592,
0.329928994178772,
0.18913324177265167,
0.40276771783828735,
0.3719560205936432,
0.2511540651321411,
0.2249494045972824,
-0.3909529447555542,
-0.27421656250953674,
-0.31746867299079895,
-0.16419059038162231,
0.0683298408985138,
0.3208373785018921,
-0.06012044847011566,
-0.525667667388916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13893v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13893v1 | Open Generative Large Language Models for Galician | 2024-06-19T23:49:56 | 2024-06-19T23:49:56 | Pablo Gamallo, Pablo Rodríguez, Iria de-Dios-Flores, Susana Sotelo, Silvia Paniagua, Daniel Bardanca, José Ramom Pichel, Marcos Garcia | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have transformed natural language processing.
Yet, their predominantly English-centric training has led to biases and
performance disparities across languages. This imbalance marginalizes
minoritized languages, making equitable access to NLP technologies more
difficult for languages with lower resources, such as Galician. We present the
first two generative LLMs focused on Galician to bridge this gap. These models,
freely available as open-source resources, were trained using a GPT
architecture with 1.3B parameters on a corpus of 2.1B words. Leveraging
continual pretraining, we adapt to Galician two existing LLMs trained on larger
corpora, thus mitigating the data constraints that would arise if the training
were performed from scratch. The models were evaluated using human judgments
and task-based datasets from standardized benchmarks. These evaluations reveal
a promising performance, underscoring the importance of linguistic diversity in
generative models. | [
-0.15788336098194122,
-0.2583146095275879,
0.5958794355392456,
0.5318435430526733,
-0.2920105457305908,
0.18856997787952423,
-0.6377587914466858,
-0.49853262305259705,
0.1676199734210968,
0.6231026649475098,
-0.49825480580329895,
-0.7503673434257507,
-0.8310792446136475,
0.12738154828548431,
-0.17799012362957,
0.8630141615867615,
-0.06244511529803276,
0.34028249979019165,
-0.054968539625406265,
-0.30255815386772156,
-0.46738818287849426,
-0.21867729723453522,
-0.5530743598937988,
-0.2839089632034302,
0.4470480978488922,
0.2404906451702118,
0.60690838098526,
0.569016695022583,
0.3246721923351288,
0.2860931158065796,
-0.0021114563569426537,
0.17597734928131104,
-0.6986241936683655,
0.01398911140859127,
-0.2879219353199005,
-0.5728724598884583,
-0.23425494134426117,
-0.11669079214334488,
0.7937273979187012,
0.7437113523483276,
-0.3192909359931946,
0.09068078547716141,
0.02239966206252575,
0.658128023147583,
-0.4598562717437744,
0.266642302274704,
-0.976477324962616,
0.09021399915218353,
-0.5280907154083252,
0.08058300614356995,
-0.4992769956588745,
-0.42705756425857544,
-0.05507781729102135,
-0.624869167804718,
0.4152267873287201,
-0.16252130270004272,
0.4739767014980316,
0.4499302804470062,
-0.12040271610021591,
-0.3718028664588928,
-0.9274958968162537,
0.7670208215713501,
-0.480562299489975,
0.7218651175498962,
0.20909897983074188,
0.17544375360012054,
-0.14032474160194397,
-0.5488437414169312,
-0.20238694548606873,
-0.47398632764816284,
0.050472766160964966,
0.31304842233657837,
-0.6266982555389404,
0.13615800440311432,
0.06468414515256882,
0.437908798456192,
-0.7629431486129761,
0.6839959621429443,
-0.6001304984092712,
0.044235654175281525,
0.20466163754463196,
0.11853161454200745,
0.14118404686450958,
0.17217785120010376,
-0.33946067094802856,
-0.03985840082168579,
-0.9723379611968994,
-0.2847166359424591,
0.6490362882614136,
0.5009182691574097,
-0.19229756295681,
0.5465853810310364,
-0.05903824418783188,
0.7291927933692932,
-0.03677785396575928,
-0.1381087452173233,
0.3466666638851166,
-0.0015092998510226607,
-0.2898981273174286,
-0.15565209090709686,
0.8025450706481934,
0.025794006884098053,
0.23066376149654388,
-0.3268844485282898,
-0.058786049485206604,
0.1411798596382141,
0.2437555193901062,
-0.4226973056793213,
-0.07715614140033722,
-0.018704000860452652,
-0.2544630765914917,
0.028320331126451492,
0.040030837059020996,
-0.5564359426498413,
-0.10497855395078659,
-0.2848506569862366,
0.05771438777446747,
-0.25365930795669556,
-0.12269771099090576,
0.41267144680023193,
0.10211087018251419,
0.053491950035095215,
0.41113150119781494,
-1.1175175905227661,
0.36215144395828247,
0.6958898901939392,
1.0041924715042114,
-0.27878764271736145,
-0.24639691412448883,
-0.5034955143928528,
0.1243661493062973,
-0.3181702494621277,
0.6280736327171326,
-0.27995380759239197,
-0.3518744111061096,
0.10065186023712158,
0.06518007814884186,
-0.1167617216706276,
-0.8292236924171448,
0.6114968061447144,
-0.616267740726471,
0.11469309777021408,
0.1179126650094986,
-0.08027981966733932,
0.19515544176101685,
0.17520920932292938,
-0.9427245855331421,
1.0223015546798706,
0.5636476278305054,
-0.7130811810493469,
0.21807292103767395,
-0.5221675038337708,
-0.2025187909603119,
0.3744831383228302,
-0.038814980536699295,
0.07301653176546097,
0.2896571457386017,
0.1281432956457138,
0.23382316529750824,
-0.639411449432373,
0.42386317253112793,
-0.04781250283122063,
0.17167456448078156,
-0.17586974799633026,
-0.5185548663139343,
0.7049350142478943,
0.1728910356760025,
0.15610544383525848,
0.20386122167110443,
-0.6916441917419434,
-0.12548920512199402,
-0.12264129519462585,
-0.5093508362770081,
-0.3998701870441437,
-0.17437708377838135,
0.0650252178311348,
0.35092371702194214,
0.2903941869735718,
-0.6661339998245239,
0.09513897448778152,
-0.7037435173988342,
0.3559509217739105,
0.7896612286567688,
-0.5842238664627075,
0.5461555123329163,
-0.08411087095737457,
0.8109468221664429,
-0.10969173163175583,
0.2051485776901245,
0.16701439023017883,
-0.5148617625236511,
-0.8112062811851501,
-0.6850417256355286,
0.38248124718666077,
0.5984681248664856,
-0.7582597732543945,
0.09890368580818176,
-0.2966107130050659,
-0.5101729035377502,
-0.9494031667709351,
0.4033035337924957,
0.4919387102127075,
0.2667156457901001,
0.38033875823020935,
-0.28834769129753113,
-0.664046585559845,
-1.0842373371124268,
0.1328572779893875,
-0.28545716404914856,
-0.37988775968551636,
0.03508180007338524,
0.40025168657302856,
-0.32991957664489746,
0.6765468716621399,
-0.5404790639877319,
-0.21393893659114838,
-0.20963723957538605,
0.1475307047367096,
0.321892648935318,
0.19430437684059143,
0.5789934992790222,
-0.5834733247756958,
-0.4565248191356659,
0.23347865045070648,
-0.4591336250305176,
-0.4836549758911133,
0.37617143988609314,
-0.057914234697818756,
0.17941665649414062,
0.5268157720565796,
-0.44222816824913025,
-0.08001081645488739,
1.0227608680725098,
-0.008885795250535011,
0.3974968194961548,
-0.3491116464138031,
-0.2689764201641083,
-0.9625035524368286,
-0.19881446659564972,
-0.050362713634967804,
-0.21298830211162567,
-0.5136921405792236,
0.14216972887516022,
-0.06117795780301094,
0.16397230327129364,
-0.6198455691337585,
0.686424970626831,
-0.4786875247955322,
-0.17090290784835815,
-0.13009190559387207,
-0.13467147946357727,
-0.23711687326431274,
0.03094303049147129,
0.13290344178676605,
0.71177077293396,
0.3203311860561371,
-0.27339792251586914,
0.22164466977119446,
0.2359047681093216,
-0.3435880243778229,
0.27881717681884766,
-0.613588273525238,
-0.02328343130648136,
-0.32544469833374023,
0.14087481796741486,
-0.6851415634155273,
-0.33972200751304626,
0.08425109088420868,
-0.1507948935031891,
0.24689443409442902,
-0.30096182227134705,
-0.30095309019088745,
-0.5323657393455505,
-0.28102558851242065,
0.29287484288215637,
0.48203587532043457,
-0.8526882529258728,
0.4800935983657837,
0.3549315631389618,
-0.3724818229675293,
-0.47589021921157837,
-0.5938003659248352,
-0.02371421456336975,
-0.08105539530515671,
-0.7737072706222534,
0.5149936676025391,
-0.11566183716058731,
-0.442102313041687,
-0.04624814912676811,
0.240928053855896,
-0.07804568111896515,
-0.011322097852826118,
0.3282868266105652,
0.23634575307369232,
-0.28701120615005493,
0.18982750177383423,
-0.019363386556506157,
-0.07887743413448334,
-0.19341763854026794,
-0.6910409927368164,
0.8059090971946716,
-0.19101844727993011,
-0.3383232057094574,
0.065472811460495,
0.4110453426837921,
0.5107775330543518,
-0.3359631299972534,
0.7021377682685852,
0.5035716891288757,
-0.2982841730117798,
-0.3755246698856354,
-0.5576607584953308,
0.3349365293979645,
-0.39277589321136475,
0.3660808801651001,
-0.14263485372066498,
-1.4484015703201294,
0.6014806032180786,
0.14878207445144653,
-0.046816885471343994,
0.5278018712997437,
1.0955222845077515,
0.23167648911476135,
0.6024550199508667,
0.8581531643867493,
-0.11322200298309326,
0.4244047999382019,
-0.01292650680989027,
-0.1234949380159378,
-0.6941997408866882,
-0.23159469664096832,
-0.6517346501350403,
0.14544089138507843,
-0.8357046842575073,
-0.8383516669273376,
0.382710337638855,
0.13148878514766693,
0.013455227948725224,
0.19334504008293152,
-0.173183873295784,
0.49630796909332275,
0.5661662220954895,
-0.040386032313108444,
0.39136695861816406,
-0.09356973320245743,
-0.08723622560501099,
-0.015407978557050228,
-0.8164259195327759,
-0.6400611400604248,
1.1167511940002441,
0.5879500508308411,
0.8219045996665955,
0.13441136479377747,
0.5773283243179321,
0.09578374773263931,
0.6971558928489685,
-0.6512547731399536,
0.2544475197792053,
-0.6804442405700684,
-0.4067399799823761,
-0.22571419179439545,
-0.3950369954109192,
-0.8760875463485718,
0.37409722805023193,
-0.114195317029953,
-0.5394836664199829,
-0.06270886212587357,
0.07194630801677704,
-0.11790642142295837,
0.2620033323764801,
-0.49771848320961,
0.6331963539123535,
-0.3021495044231415,
-0.39517417550086975,
-0.028420308604836464,
-0.3603208363056183,
0.48304712772369385,
-0.3132092356681824,
0.32053396105766296,
-0.13120295107364655,
0.06267982721328735,
0.5795240998268127,
-0.31643223762512207,
0.7700276970863342,
-0.07160655409097672,
-0.3872740864753723,
0.17155037820339203,
-0.07672611624002457,
0.3341621458530426,
0.060326945036649704,
-0.11470163613557816,
0.3703937828540802,
-0.49601951241493225,
-0.2729679346084595,
-0.22810010612010956,
0.7547788023948669,
-0.7783798575401306,
-0.4531698226928711,
-0.19497288763523102,
-0.5443700551986694,
-0.2822716534137726,
-0.08652365952730179,
0.3523567318916321,
-0.08159960061311722,
-0.6337653398513794,
0.12343466281890869,
0.7377009987831116,
-0.39715397357940674,
0.16364873945713043,
0.7518306374549866,
-0.15904773771762848,
-0.5571114420890808,
0.5517259836196899,
-0.004727574065327644,
0.5210232734680176,
0.39362287521362305,
0.1284434050321579,
-0.21031473577022552,
-0.762025773525238,
-0.5666239261627197,
0.24081748723983765,
-0.4817104935646057,
-0.1901519000530243,
-0.6476953029632568,
-0.04694976285099983,
-0.41950738430023193,
-0.2123592048883438,
-0.5209338068962097,
-0.28343716263771057,
-0.39612627029418945,
-0.21578365564346313,
0.10418045520782471,
0.8873119950294495,
-0.3415447771549225,
0.5590213537216187,
-0.7984251379966736,
0.35962826013565063,
0.3851025104522705,
0.35914167761802673,
-0.11115541309118271,
-0.5523290634155273,
-0.21615906059741974,
-0.10123904794454575,
-0.17407704889774323,
-0.5798501372337341,
0.6684237718582153,
-0.042022258043289185,
0.48416733741760254,
0.26658013463020325,
-0.5001797676086426,
0.28816354274749756,
-0.7493916749954224,
0.5957025289535522,
0.4302856922149658,
-0.5560562610626221,
0.32378438115119934,
-0.7535449266433716,
0.23678529262542725,
0.5484172701835632,
0.5685756802558899,
-0.3624162971973419,
-0.5043242573738098,
-0.3362451195716858,
-0.9273858666419983,
0.7225180864334106,
-0.023991543799638748,
0.08955570310354233,
-0.28486406803131104,
0.061953943222761154,
0.5125077962875366,
0.21893243491649628,
-0.8859037160873413,
0.2803744375705719,
0.004374684300273657,
-0.3105703294277191,
-0.21692822873592377,
-0.1595841348171234,
-0.013668602332472801,
-0.19691599905490875,
0.5476410388946533,
-0.13597187399864197,
0.15265755355358124,
-0.2996115982532501,
-0.09683399647474289,
-0.12447532266378403,
0.4445689022541046,
0.5413011312484741,
0.5226923227310181,
-0.23345239460468292,
-0.09012602269649506,
0.2346566617488861,
-0.5932769179344177,
0.20231996476650238,
0.1244201734662056,
-0.3140513598918915,
0.0885237455368042,
0.3961634635925293,
0.9061084389686584,
0.27453410625457764,
-0.5778942108154297,
0.3722769618034363,
0.07748490571975708,
-0.19068863987922668,
-0.3825622498989105,
-0.007023266516625881,
0.26299935579299927,
0.46264466643333435,
0.10829263925552368,
-0.2510342597961426,
-0.1694585233926773,
-0.52043217420578,
-0.301196426153183,
0.5254657864570618,
-0.3486051559448242,
-0.3668428063392639,
0.5879894495010376,
0.1117996796965599,
-0.1782868206501007,
0.5151541829109192,
-0.2190849930047989,
-0.49586769938468933,
0.44402197003364563,
0.8495796918869019,
0.9009454250335693,
-0.25304388999938965,
0.4626599848270416,
0.3328457474708557,
0.6027941703796387,
-0.554466724395752,
0.23222732543945312,
0.27044567465782166,
-0.7893317341804504,
-0.5479891896247864,
-1.070583701133728,
-0.44061964750289917,
0.25304365158081055,
-0.6515834331512451,
0.15551680326461792,
-0.29797396063804626,
-0.07139898836612701,
-0.16266517341136932,
-0.5218940377235413,
-0.8359965085983276,
0.018640125170350075,
0.18032027781009674,
0.8858813047409058,
-1.1212888956069946,
0.7322021722793579,
0.5092161893844604,
-0.2812156081199646,
-0.37329956889152527,
-0.24991276860237122,
-0.2989685535430908,
-0.8289889693260193,
0.9170252084732056,
-0.1695995032787323,
-0.20826812088489532,
-0.021023962646722794,
-0.5291424989700317,
-0.7190682291984558,
0.9256814122200012,
0.7304885387420654,
-0.7827091217041016,
-0.28965023159980774,
0.2887820303440094,
0.7900301218032837,
-0.44093653559684753,
0.1471758931875229,
0.496822714805603,
0.3825882375240326,
-0.16134943068027496,
-1.0789811611175537,
-0.42091089487075806,
0.0482647679746151,
0.14643162488937378,
0.5541908740997314,
-0.6849613785743713,
1.1624075174331665,
0.021951958537101746,
-0.15906397998332977,
0.1894516497850418,
0.582690417766571,
0.17139367759227753,
0.09225519001483917,
0.1666860580444336,
0.9207743406295776,
0.8280152678489685,
-0.09078029543161392,
0.9092065691947937,
-0.01660642772912979,
0.11491815745830536,
1.2025306224822998,
-0.42673543095588684,
0.8658856153488159,
0.38893795013427734,
-0.295661062002182,
0.38347017765045166,
0.19461171329021454,
0.08684676885604858,
0.4628959894180298,
0.3821907937526703,
-0.6222091913223267,
-0.18862871825695038,
-0.23269082605838776,
-0.3042961657047272,
0.703815758228302,
0.477646142244339,
-0.4880737364292145,
-0.5143933296203613,
0.15906183421611786,
-0.1411789208650589,
0.2665710151195526,
-0.6328118443489075,
0.5949758887290955,
-0.011464244686067104,
-0.5783435702323914,
0.3190475404262543,
0.42189761996269226,
0.8792320489883423,
-0.7778078317642212,
0.06644975394010544,
-0.16748355329036713,
-0.03130696341395378,
-0.12286067008972168,
-0.6108781099319458,
0.17803114652633667,
0.3703029751777649,
-0.5683853626251221,
-0.48663046956062317,
0.7136726379394531,
-0.36813730001449585,
-0.5515505075454712,
0.6028875708580017,
0.7285031676292419,
0.03554388880729675,
0.06898989528417587,
-0.21293222904205322,
0.012715916149318218,
0.010570862330496311,
0.033684954047203064,
0.3630004823207855,
0.315487265586853,
-0.37915104627609253,
0.4113711714744568,
0.7097111344337463,
0.3867827355861664,
0.3108617067337036,
0.25337502360343933,
0.9973790645599365,
-0.398406058549881,
-0.32750293612480164,
-0.7774826288223267,
0.19855384528636932,
0.30514687299728394,
-0.42119911313056946,
0.49912890791893005,
0.581768274307251,
1.2702305316925049,
-0.4205847680568695,
0.7445380687713623,
0.14837078750133514,
0.5355138778686523,
-0.9420980215072632,
0.4754451811313629,
-0.05415274575352669,
0.09388186037540436,
-0.002009188523516059,
-0.9484845995903015,
-0.29921650886535645,
0.48349496722221375,
-0.3162165582180023,
-0.11669415980577469,
0.40583279728889465,
0.7286853194236755,
-0.09080751985311508,
-0.15074855089187622,
0.4097210466861725,
0.4192582368850708,
0.14945784211158752,
0.844900369644165,
0.9364808797836304,
0.06732141226530075,
0.13476349413394928,
0.08889202028512955,
-0.3499140441417694,
-0.05223023518919945,
-0.9701104760169983,
-0.7394680380821228,
-0.3983539044857025,
0.13217471539974213,
-0.08002544194459915,
0.2257077991962433,
1.0188250541687012,
0.3619617223739624,
-0.564644992351532,
-0.30041247606277466,
-0.14126227796077728,
-0.1053524762392044,
0.41414520144462585,
-0.11817450821399689,
0.011081872507929802,
-0.11616793274879456,
-0.6454141139984131,
0.6209256649017334,
0.4215773046016693,
0.02867223508656025,
-0.5642372965812683,
-0.19630199670791626,
-0.00673905573785305,
-0.140766903758049,
0.8269141912460327,
0.414585679769516,
-0.6138521432876587,
-0.026856357231736183,
-0.026635970920324326,
-0.13429418206214905,
0.13539323210716248,
0.6575472950935364,
-0.8085736632347107,
0.3424701988697052,
0.4013323187828064,
0.48388391733169556,
0.5335296392440796,
-0.12404564768075943,
0.4804132878780365,
-0.7450472116470337,
0.4568994641304016,
0.4846220016479492,
0.2947586178779602,
0.4756653606891632,
0.056262385100126266,
0.5505495667457581,
0.02066219225525856,
-0.23513032495975494,
-0.782294511795044,
0.35351014137268066,
-0.8142268657684326,
0.04344150796532631,
1.2058563232421875,
-0.0911383181810379,
-0.04828200116753578,
0.020416980609297752,
-0.04222310706973076,
0.21119661629199982,
-0.06127047538757324,
0.4921415448188782,
0.8353205323219299,
0.1596212089061737,
0.20272094011306763,
-0.9693124890327454,
0.2738376259803772,
0.07874440401792526,
-0.8893976211547852,
0.032291311770677567,
0.7122519612312317,
0.16202014684677124,
0.07402508705854416,
0.8477200865745544,
-0.30207157135009766,
0.08682478219270706,
-0.16309989988803864,
0.16927987337112427,
0.038514427840709686,
-0.714177668094635,
-0.5196288228034973,
0.15755058825016022,
0.4582746624946594,
0.13133683800697327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13892v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13892v1 | Adaptable Logical Control for Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T23:47:59 | 2024-06-19T23:47:59 | Honghua Zhang, Po-Nien Kung, Masahiro Yoshida, Guy Van den Broeck, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the success of Large Language Models (LLMs) on various tasks
following human instructions, controlling model generation at inference time
poses a persistent challenge. In this paper, we introduce Ctrl-G, an adaptable
framework that facilitates tractable and flexible control of LLM generation to
reliably follow logical constraints. Ctrl-G combines any production-ready LLM
with a Hidden Markov Model, enabling LLM outputs to adhere to logical
constraints represented as deterministic finite automata. We show that Ctrl-G,
when applied to a TULU2-7B model, outperforms GPT3.5 and GPT4 on the task of
interactive text editing: specifically, for the task of generating text
insertions/continuations following logical constraints, Ctrl-G achieves over
30% higher satisfaction rate in human evaluation compared to GPT4. When applied
to medium-size language models (e.g., GPT2-large), Ctrl-G also beats its
counterparts for constrained generation by large margins on standard
benchmarks. Additionally, as a proof-of-concept study, we experiment Ctrl-G on
the Grade School Math benchmark to assist LLM reasoning, foreshadowing the
application of Ctrl-G, as well as other constrained generation approaches,
beyond traditional language generation tasks. | [
-0.10521572828292847,
-1.0777406692504883,
0.9102255702018738,
0.16396768391132355,
-0.08124788850545883,
0.04699905961751938,
-0.48555848002433777,
-0.23764529824256897,
-0.3068958520889282,
0.46089184284210205,
-0.7905998229980469,
-0.5560064911842346,
-0.5509995222091675,
0.19374875724315643,
-0.27446117997169495,
0.9653725624084473,
-0.11709775775671005,
-0.33269909024238586,
-0.0137696648016572,
0.10297680646181107,
-0.44459882378578186,
-0.5573912262916565,
-0.49043622612953186,
-0.2080332338809967,
0.49511751532554626,
0.1646210104227066,
1.1580274105072021,
0.7979432344436646,
0.24896594882011414,
0.4044800400733948,
-0.08600165694952011,
0.3485906422138214,
-0.36941590905189514,
0.1631045937538147,
-0.5778880715370178,
-0.5191107988357544,
-0.39322429895401,
0.08802638202905655,
0.5259094834327698,
0.40911799669265747,
-0.1604657620191574,
-0.21041655540466309,
0.09845750033855438,
0.6186073422431946,
-0.46395397186279297,
0.2112162858247757,
-0.9101118445396423,
0.10229547321796417,
-0.09722650796175003,
-0.03248358145356178,
-0.4947635531425476,
-0.7361584305763245,
-0.13627414405345917,
-0.8849380612373352,
-0.07468806952238083,
-0.1879063844680786,
0.6496152877807617,
0.5318793058395386,
-0.521002471446991,
-0.5149189829826355,
-0.8489316701889038,
0.7351773977279663,
-0.8120048642158508,
0.29898300766944885,
0.15183693170547485,
0.38956865668296814,
-0.5827502608299255,
-0.7177115678787231,
-0.7148456573486328,
-0.3455003499984741,
-0.026696475222706795,
0.06259569525718689,
-0.2339811474084854,
0.2889760732650757,
0.5607946515083313,
-0.09615924954414368,
-0.34544119238853455,
0.10129895806312561,
-0.13807590305805206,
-0.14429908990859985,
0.2810993194580078,
0.3324321210384369,
0.27248942852020264,
0.10074707865715027,
0.01971452496945858,
0.1820761114358902,
-0.8811450004577637,
-0.09374887496232986,
0.4162193536758423,
-0.012496983632445335,
0.04455188661813736,
0.7607584595680237,
-0.31749334931373596,
0.9028080701828003,
0.2901751697063446,
-0.11055699735879898,
-0.023954149335622787,
-0.30920112133026123,
-0.3330453634262085,
-0.24702239036560059,
0.6934545636177063,
0.25418969988822937,
0.3576038181781769,
0.14785924553871155,
-0.20154184103012085,
0.381024032831192,
0.14804749190807343,
-0.7024362087249756,
-0.34801286458969116,
-0.006162733770906925,
-0.10752333700656891,
-0.28218555450439453,
-0.17620272934436798,
-0.37880775332450867,
-0.3367331027984619,
-0.5054820775985718,
0.37354210019111633,
-0.36400502920150757,
0.11269989609718323,
0.23017679154872894,
0.06695743650197983,
0.12131304293870926,
0.8697194457054138,
-0.8342315554618835,
0.2780004143714905,
0.7027416229248047,
0.7406320571899414,
-0.26044416427612305,
-0.030340641736984253,
-0.7959480881690979,
0.3312918245792389,
-0.3851015567779541,
0.24330002069473267,
-0.6614565849304199,
-0.24568524956703186,
-0.14909733831882477,
-0.20353500545024872,
-0.2573032081127167,
-0.35071757435798645,
0.33248254656791687,
-0.5199293494224548,
0.5678387880325317,
0.1359357088804245,
-0.5746096968650818,
-0.12586162984371185,
0.24025897681713104,
-0.5417880415916443,
0.5666887760162354,
0.15119118988513947,
-0.8223724365234375,
0.21080170571804047,
-0.4555024802684784,
-0.3174491822719574,
-0.12351185083389282,
-0.5322973132133484,
-0.2887837588787079,
0.1611717939376831,
0.14947544038295746,
0.23079052567481995,
-0.3723089396953583,
0.5446444153785706,
-0.4604428708553314,
-0.0349348783493042,
0.4170471429824829,
-0.5480757355690002,
0.7382922172546387,
0.24700376391410828,
-0.5040879845619202,
0.43635112047195435,
-0.6945207715034485,
0.2517736256122589,
-0.07219575345516205,
-0.5554377436637878,
0.0720939114689827,
0.24255602061748505,
-0.07212064415216446,
0.4576479494571686,
0.3218227028846741,
-0.27771425247192383,
0.5373479127883911,
-0.12262541800737381,
0.7532881498336792,
0.655982494354248,
-0.002728693885728717,
0.265133261680603,
-0.33425259590148926,
0.651954710483551,
-0.3620355725288391,
0.045432474464178085,
0.21403944492340088,
-0.28460678458213806,
-0.6552510857582092,
-0.3818311393260956,
0.166844442486763,
0.7363650798797607,
-0.9409712553024292,
0.5793761014938354,
0.01765895076096058,
-0.37847572565078735,
-0.2958278954029083,
0.15843845903873444,
0.35909828543663025,
0.5561903715133667,
0.11713749170303345,
0.09947405755519867,
-0.2899850904941559,
-0.913209080696106,
-0.3179122507572174,
-0.10610788315534592,
-0.40009185671806335,
0.14093686640262604,
0.3121373653411865,
-0.12760864198207855,
0.6845160722732544,
-0.35492175817489624,
-0.1647033840417862,
-0.5136126279830933,
0.12905560433864594,
0.4123338460922241,
0.5402467846870422,
0.26632022857666016,
-0.7242008447647095,
-0.35610708594322205,
0.1966506689786911,
-0.6139702796936035,
-0.4539681673049927,
-0.4813007414340973,
-0.1073211207985878,
0.5810064673423767,
0.6047938466072083,
-0.8371374011039734,
0.5577013492584229,
0.5684100985527039,
-0.5643009543418884,
0.6744189262390137,
-0.5184010863304138,
-0.04011744633316994,
-0.7961027026176453,
0.10249005258083344,
-0.34722238779067993,
-0.46672478318214417,
-0.5695498585700989,
-0.008269652724266052,
0.14857828617095947,
0.22336739301681519,
-0.3375813364982605,
0.34440967440605164,
-0.25368282198905945,
0.09435854852199554,
-0.3551880419254303,
0.23463208973407745,
-0.031142540276050568,
0.5770713686943054,
0.17895574867725372,
0.49596038460731506,
0.43484118580818176,
-0.5174036622047424,
0.06587716192007065,
0.22042930126190186,
-0.4824313223361969,
0.2175000011920929,
-0.779706597328186,
0.06717090308666229,
0.10400422662496567,
0.39112526178359985,
-0.588390052318573,
-0.2560894191265106,
0.33011528849601746,
-0.2645021975040436,
0.10792960971593857,
0.06676056981086731,
-0.5892939567565918,
-0.09957928955554962,
-0.010174266062676907,
0.0640479251742363,
0.5474303364753723,
-0.3724563717842102,
0.8773362636566162,
0.04067375138401985,
-0.2421739399433136,
-0.2261544018983841,
-0.683935284614563,
0.02670918218791485,
-0.27563104033470154,
-0.48559698462486267,
0.29378223419189453,
-0.4165615439414978,
-0.3972738981246948,
-0.07082997262477875,
-0.12456018477678299,
0.10967189073562622,
0.30855152010917664,
0.06723003089427948,
0.2778107523918152,
0.029505562037229538,
-0.07743915170431137,
0.33759528398513794,
0.013996634632349014,
0.07624031603336334,
-0.39716339111328125,
0.3447507321834564,
0.0004231291823089123,
-0.308453768491745,
-0.5464627146720886,
0.17417573928833008,
0.8175707459449768,
-0.17538759112358093,
0.2558888792991638,
0.254919171333313,
-0.20233842730522156,
-0.4914061427116394,
-0.3143722712993622,
0.05850662291049957,
-0.5575067400932312,
0.5176072716712952,
-0.4808732569217682,
-1.129260778427124,
0.3271966874599457,
0.0795869454741478,
0.2982255816459656,
0.27406299114227295,
0.8588536977767944,
0.2017231285572052,
1.1297321319580078,
0.5782167911529541,
-0.030190275982022285,
0.4627787172794342,
0.27390360832214355,
-0.05723254755139351,
-0.49971523880958557,
0.10676980018615723,
-0.5459886789321899,
-0.3943188488483429,
-0.9224823713302612,
-0.41930216550827026,
0.37920278310775757,
0.3466227352619171,
-0.46831512451171875,
0.20443451404571533,
-0.3439107835292816,
0.48624759912490845,
0.5612131357192993,
0.08522800356149673,
0.4441686272621155,
-0.3587619960308075,
-0.3507462441921234,
-0.01785219833254814,
-0.7823169231414795,
-0.4749719798564911,
0.6380107998847961,
0.15695320069789886,
0.9187334179878235,
0.2711775600910187,
0.5345133543014526,
0.1386214643716812,
0.29455798864364624,
-0.5267280340194702,
0.6447439193725586,
-0.18252351880073547,
-0.531933069229126,
-0.31107157468795776,
-0.5631592273712158,
-0.567612886428833,
0.27012351155281067,
-0.15475992858409882,
-1.0268396139144897,
-0.17101798951625824,
0.5119255781173706,
-0.3480050563812256,
0.2610912322998047,
-0.6219735741615295,
0.8854452967643738,
-0.3132903277873993,
-0.5757704973220825,
-0.28762945532798767,
-0.6323705315589905,
0.3033842146396637,
-0.23467853665351868,
0.20679914951324463,
-0.06711675226688385,
-0.212702214717865,
0.29214921593666077,
-0.48836082220077515,
0.8969031572341919,
-0.11115311831235886,
-0.2610076367855072,
0.4408641457557678,
0.6307323575019836,
0.8872352242469788,
0.05854925140738487,
-0.10706855356693268,
-0.31574174761772156,
-0.28891074657440186,
-0.06611507385969162,
-0.9583421349525452,
0.81913822889328,
-0.601172924041748,
-1.0558029413223267,
-0.2073049247264862,
-0.912933349609375,
-0.2334899604320526,
0.3788268268108368,
0.1523904949426651,
0.33443909883499146,
-0.0003719909000210464,
0.2486216276884079,
0.4793798327445984,
-0.4441443383693695,
0.5510989427566528,
0.36635446548461914,
-0.4775989055633545,
-0.5035226345062256,
0.6564342379570007,
0.04300517961382866,
0.7641124725341797,
0.5766100883483887,
0.4254927337169647,
-0.291197270154953,
-0.4839096665382385,
-0.5075823068618774,
-0.09707867354154587,
-0.4859089255332947,
-0.01905902661383152,
-0.6182838678359985,
-0.14920517802238464,
-0.15130476653575897,
-0.4855473041534424,
-0.1283065676689148,
-0.8822873830795288,
-0.3312438428401947,
-0.14425982534885406,
0.33177122473716736,
0.8124776482582092,
-0.03861663118004799,
0.2941460609436035,
-0.5749446153640747,
0.29677069187164307,
0.24967418611049652,
0.09206291288137436,
-0.2508973479270935,
-0.5046089887619019,
0.06160043552517891,
-0.23503421247005463,
-0.4141601026058197,
-0.7328265309333801,
0.3332001864910126,
0.16975601017475128,
0.16689029335975647,
0.221032053232193,
-0.10559096932411194,
0.2902480661869049,
-0.6269196271896362,
0.5322842597961426,
0.18634554743766785,
-1.1563494205474854,
0.34091782569885254,
-0.7945879697799683,
0.8734817504882812,
0.32567068934440613,
-0.028316061943769455,
-0.3912730813026428,
-0.8138937950134277,
-0.4372488260269165,
-0.5301569104194641,
0.5465641021728516,
0.4015684425830841,
-0.18592533469200134,
0.10008208453655243,
0.18098363280296326,
0.05583465099334717,
0.3506278693675995,
-0.8011513948440552,
0.23167957365512848,
-0.08888430148363113,
-0.40982475876808167,
0.15313690900802612,
0.03694722056388855,
0.09071957319974899,
0.01180964894592762,
0.5845009684562683,
-0.2577653229236603,
-0.08883877843618393,
0.14595527946949005,
-0.045632254332304,
0.049921903759241104,
0.5303258895874023,
0.7706977128982544,
0.672120988368988,
0.0712820515036583,
0.26048094034194946,
-0.020400118082761765,
-0.27184274792671204,
0.04922005161643028,
0.1875179260969162,
-0.5823006629943848,
-0.2435232549905777,
0.32146844267845154,
0.7002696990966797,
-0.015020175836980343,
-0.5510191321372986,
0.054320868104696274,
0.08451719582080841,
-0.4336821734905243,
-0.047942109405994415,
0.5268530249595642,
0.13554386794567108,
0.40395212173461914,
0.057516515254974365,
-0.09642897546291351,
-0.14743725955486298,
-0.2692875266075134,
0.23606297373771667,
0.38209620118141174,
-0.25605520606040955,
-0.34684789180755615,
1.0690796375274658,
-0.006022004410624504,
-0.07791639119386673,
0.5413207411766052,
-0.05957373231649399,
-0.6548657417297363,
0.6022600531578064,
0.7113155722618103,
0.9761621356010437,
0.048353008925914764,
0.061014700680971146,
0.2705649733543396,
0.501139223575592,
0.07794971764087677,
0.4731813371181488,
0.0744403749704361,
-0.6702934503555298,
-0.5901413559913635,
-0.27513211965560913,
-0.37081754207611084,
0.1048181802034378,
-0.21796879172325134,
0.2597152590751648,
-0.8022698163986206,
-0.08968756347894669,
-0.016088010743260384,
-0.12072474509477615,
-0.6500994563102722,
0.17118993401527405,
-0.06035451591014862,
0.9465249180793762,
-0.4185173809528351,
1.2550462484359741,
0.3562816083431244,
-0.1185525581240654,
-0.7937210202217102,
-0.2733316421508789,
0.40509358048439026,
-0.4552629590034485,
0.5551237463951111,
0.05600777640938759,
-0.24152621626853943,
0.025605980306863785,
-0.5398129224777222,
-0.6512677669525146,
1.0618475675582886,
0.3830021917819977,
-0.9809755086898804,
-0.09731448441743851,
0.18575869500637054,
0.6215028762817383,
-0.30799418687820435,
-0.016206130385398865,
0.6307303309440613,
0.6725848913192749,
0.033121731132268906,
-0.9080913662910461,
0.2322106957435608,
-0.054477617144584656,
-0.0575653612613678,
0.30394813418388367,
-0.5339165329933167,
0.700633704662323,
-0.44759222865104675,
-0.21967214345932007,
0.3056231737136841,
0.7770180106163025,
0.4420374631881714,
-0.11457300931215286,
0.6476889848709106,
0.4994226396083832,
0.7433179020881653,
-0.12791708111763,
0.8887386322021484,
-0.16991427540779114,
0.07768860459327698,
1.5838212966918945,
-0.37452179193496704,
0.5287489891052246,
0.44397205114364624,
0.1154613122344017,
0.27495282888412476,
0.20761559903621674,
0.09948067367076874,
0.4057838022708893,
0.5048758387565613,
-0.3270651698112488,
-0.4024411737918854,
0.011731545440852642,
-0.008438421413302422,
0.1565706431865692,
0.5385818481445312,
-0.29887551069259644,
-0.21442902088165283,
-0.16547425091266632,
0.3282885253429413,
0.22891998291015625,
-0.3271586298942566,
0.5644155144691467,
-0.03700948879122734,
-0.8140769004821777,
0.4203770160675049,
0.08644755184650421,
0.35824576020240784,
-0.7986234426498413,
-0.13479365408420563,
-0.12273259460926056,
0.35020753741264343,
-0.011804594658315182,
-0.7311229705810547,
0.2815524637699127,
0.17085419595241547,
-0.16238760948181152,
-0.2736627161502838,
0.7398839592933655,
-0.6859222054481506,
-0.5247722864151001,
0.037883125245571136,
0.45425945520401,
-0.2705373167991638,
0.16649717092514038,
-0.5050225853919983,
0.3173387050628662,
0.4329969882965088,
-0.4986500144004822,
0.17459820210933685,
0.8598913550376892,
-0.41133424639701843,
0.8685020804405212,
0.4709060490131378,
0.08650197088718414,
0.1342839151620865,
-0.21384072303771973,
0.883430540561676,
-0.6998519897460938,
-0.49054110050201416,
-0.863688051700592,
0.33212634921073914,
0.21705274283885956,
-0.3096143305301666,
0.5628305673599243,
0.33106300234794617,
0.9812563061714172,
-0.1659446358680725,
1.115729570388794,
-0.4012303948402405,
0.30381378531455994,
-0.7427856922149658,
0.7113940119743347,
-0.28382062911987305,
0.07292440533638,
-0.22649963200092316,
-0.7816835045814514,
-0.6022596955299377,
0.4347999691963196,
-0.36977019906044006,
-0.07484383881092072,
0.6293586492538452,
0.821074903011322,
0.04658406227827072,
-0.20774459838867188,
0.391184002161026,
0.3561394512653351,
0.6647919416427612,
0.7919848561286926,
0.8575865030288696,
0.331692636013031,
0.37512582540512085,
-0.02185993269085884,
-0.2770158052444458,
0.1148003563284874,
-1.243676781654358,
-0.8641191124916077,
-0.23197698593139648,
-0.3541002571582794,
-0.25498881936073303,
0.0021118693985044956,
1.1408628225326538,
0.2348519116640091,
-0.7628344893455505,
-0.18739037215709686,
-0.33935943245887756,
0.26136133074760437,
-0.21375106275081635,
-0.20239265263080597,
0.4380086362361908,
-0.28875499963760376,
-0.9026759266853333,
0.44531384110450745,
0.2443990558385849,
0.06204500421881676,
-0.1063499003648758,
-0.14736631512641907,
-0.0826684758067131,
0.12453654408454895,
0.5890206098556519,
0.293940931558609,
-0.8020287156105042,
-0.4997978210449219,
-0.09319455921649933,
-0.2179458886384964,
-0.25495943427085876,
1.0552915334701538,
-0.6951069831848145,
0.4920211434364319,
0.5223239064216614,
0.8330837488174438,
0.15396158397197723,
-0.03865329921245575,
0.9464415311813354,
-0.3340498208999634,
-0.007358874194324017,
0.14824946224689484,
0.2523193061351776,
0.07767567783594131,
-0.2107386589050293,
0.4631820023059845,
-0.015189582481980324,
-0.5756024122238159,
-0.24658307433128357,
0.48889991641044617,
-1.004449486732483,
-0.30354544520378113,
1.1679184436798096,
-0.09618095308542252,
-0.06734461337327957,
0.12542976438999176,
-0.4371178448200226,
0.22444003820419312,
-0.359622597694397,
0.7973006963729858,
0.604202151298523,
-0.17974542081356049,
0.08359735459089279,
-0.6481576561927795,
0.533894419670105,
0.33868831396102905,
-0.9762700200080872,
0.37294822931289673,
1.0712976455688477,
0.1696396768093109,
-0.2609773576259613,
0.4725039303302765,
-0.1586170494556427,
0.2364744246006012,
-0.5762235522270203,
-0.047168269753456116,
-0.20742908120155334,
-0.49783700704574585,
-0.2242359220981598,
0.08133362978696823,
0.06500132381916046,
0.1307324916124344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13890v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13890v1 | ClinicalLab: Aligning Agents for Multi-Departmental Clinical Diagnostics in the Real World | 2024-06-19T23:44:25 | 2024-06-19T23:44:25 | Weixiang Yan, Haitian Liu, Tengxiao Wu, Qian Chen, Wen Wang, Haoyuan Chai, Jiayi Wang, Weishan Zhao, Yixin Zhang, Renjun Zhang, Li Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | LLMs have achieved significant performance progress in various NLP
applications. However, LLMs still struggle to meet the strict requirements for
accuracy and reliability in the medical field and face many challenges in
clinical applications. Existing clinical diagnostic evaluation benchmarks for
evaluating medical agents powered by LLMs have severe limitations. Firstly,
most existing medical evaluation benchmarks face the risk of data leakage or
contamination. Secondly, existing benchmarks often neglect the characteristics
of multiple departments and specializations in modern medical practice.
Thirdly, existing evaluation methods are limited to multiple-choice questions,
which do not align with the real-world diagnostic scenarios. Lastly, existing
evaluation methods lack comprehensive evaluations of end-to-end real clinical
scenarios. These limitations in benchmarks in turn obstruct advancements of
LLMs and agents for medicine. To address these limitations, we introduce
ClinicalLab, a comprehensive clinical diagnosis agent alignment suite.
ClinicalLab includes ClinicalBench, an end-to-end multi-departmental clinical
diagnostic evaluation benchmark for evaluating medical agents and LLMs.
ClinicalBench is based on real cases that cover 24 departments and 150
diseases. ClinicalLab also includes four novel metrics (ClinicalMetrics) for
evaluating the effectiveness of LLMs in clinical diagnostic tasks. We evaluate
17 LLMs and find that their performance varies significantly across different
departments. Based on these findings, in ClinicalLab, we propose ClinicalAgent,
an end-to-end clinical agent that aligns with real-world clinical diagnostic
practices. We systematically investigate the performance and applicable
scenarios of variants of ClinicalAgent on ClinicalBench. Our findings
demonstrate the importance of aligning with modern medical practices in
designing medical agents. | [
-0.256508469581604,
-0.4502662122249603,
0.818793535232544,
0.17286401987075806,
-0.08641062676906586,
0.6280282139778137,
-0.06874769926071167,
-0.8504427671432495,
0.15051373839378357,
0.17578507959842682,
-0.4686315357685089,
-0.5741608738899231,
-0.46422332525253296,
0.3391892611980438,
0.1271682232618332,
0.7474057674407959,
-0.14348451793193817,
0.4830741584300995,
-0.7366220951080322,
-0.7224254608154297,
-0.6039273738861084,
-0.31242305040359497,
-0.5822578072547913,
-0.7189491987228394,
0.5611826181411743,
0.2480541467666626,
1.1689995527267456,
0.7511641383171082,
0.9013916254043579,
0.4207059144973755,
0.2778675854206085,
0.3778436779975891,
-0.1766643524169922,
0.339243084192276,
-0.21257135272026062,
-0.29872941970825195,
-0.9300644993782043,
-0.13658837974071503,
0.2671924829483032,
0.7198255658149719,
-0.18608534336090088,
-0.13587595522403717,
-0.4219931662082672,
0.38492831587791443,
-0.5108736753463745,
-0.25542154908180237,
-0.08122307062149048,
0.19732029736042023,
-0.05958469212055206,
-0.25489798188209534,
-0.3408377468585968,
-0.45918723940849304,
0.19545046985149384,
-0.8439469933509827,
0.42031341791152954,
-0.03303678706288338,
0.8569287657737732,
0.35838159918785095,
-0.47879666090011597,
-0.11126906424760818,
-0.5155717134475708,
0.6345430612564087,
-0.5095322132110596,
0.27045807242393494,
-0.11977965384721756,
0.9915145039558411,
-0.13125179708003998,
-0.8002319931983948,
-0.11887090653181076,
-0.35826733708381653,
-0.1230091005563736,
0.4737696349620819,
-0.026401568204164505,
0.08092936873435974,
-0.061223506927490234,
-0.05401337146759033,
-0.9263564348220825,
0.4914719760417938,
-0.024394994601607323,
-0.3319616913795471,
0.6011396050453186,
0.6823417544364929,
0.39151179790496826,
0.44562286138534546,
-0.6883937120437622,
-0.27146077156066895,
-0.4622194170951843,
-0.34284573793411255,
-0.29033389687538147,
0.11592530459165573,
-0.04575899615883827,
0.39800211787223816,
0.0054373834282159805,
0.5787632465362549,
-0.19597040116786957,
-0.4730193316936493,
0.36555394530296326,
-0.297856867313385,
-0.1756410002708435,
0.32081758975982666,
0.8270516395568848,
0.5343450903892517,
0.07549168914556503,
-0.30785688757896423,
-0.17407670617103577,
0.4971890449523926,
0.6047356128692627,
-0.4937630891799927,
0.1547929346561432,
0.5362662076950073,
-0.2613304555416107,
-0.4504581391811371,
-0.262821227312088,
-0.7037127017974854,
-0.9422754049301147,
-0.473093181848526,
0.2719312608242035,
-0.40344083309173584,
0.010404232889413834,
-0.06344037503004074,
-0.19113613665103912,
0.2701755464076996,
0.6540696024894714,
-0.3503665328025818,
0.5847647190093994,
0.7052549719810486,
0.6269844174385071,
-0.34139567613601685,
-0.24789287149906158,
-0.4377851188182831,
0.19179505109786987,
-0.47038760781288147,
0.9591469168663025,
-0.48967137932777405,
-0.3463696539402008,
0.021944228559732437,
0.14066828787326813,
-0.021752918139100075,
-0.9209983944892883,
0.405903160572052,
-0.14098119735717773,
-0.2295849770307541,
-0.21975253522396088,
-0.4823603332042694,
0.4225997030735016,
0.39616265892982483,
-0.35581570863723755,
0.697090208530426,
0.28663599491119385,
-0.1900426298379898,
0.4923899471759796,
-0.323703408241272,
-0.11218535900115967,
0.40954694151878357,
-0.5700246691703796,
-0.7027831077575684,
-0.11358779668807983,
0.049748118966817856,
0.18560589849948883,
-0.69370037317276,
0.49595385789871216,
-0.43197065591812134,
-0.32290005683898926,
0.46789705753326416,
-0.14822566509246826,
0.617060124874115,
0.36520054936408997,
0.0242196973413229,
0.41111499071121216,
-0.9329298138618469,
0.1107846349477768,
0.018520891666412354,
0.20207351446151733,
-0.022715719416737556,
-0.13631685078144073,
-0.14617234468460083,
0.08875540643930435,
0.2527477741241455,
-0.5946640968322754,
0.26093196868896484,
-0.15085344016551971,
-0.05079022794961929,
0.6948726177215576,
-0.2876887619495392,
0.2000604271888733,
-0.9069826602935791,
1.0986418724060059,
-0.018874825909733772,
0.31821754574775696,
0.26379919052124023,
-0.4327699542045593,
-0.3710755407810211,
-0.5843966007232666,
0.02114448882639408,
0.6401975750923157,
-0.3627990186214447,
0.457551509141922,
-0.30564501881599426,
-0.7870555520057678,
-0.6672796010971069,
-0.14004389941692352,
0.550812304019928,
0.605976402759552,
0.32544779777526855,
-0.34718647599220276,
-0.3519810438156128,
-0.9599888920783997,
-0.20029033720493317,
0.15244433283805847,
-0.12311986088752747,
0.1385197639465332,
0.1477627456188202,
-0.6224251985549927,
0.9431145191192627,
-0.31609439849853516,
-0.5654924511909485,
-0.22783495485782623,
-0.2184794545173645,
0.3632635772228241,
0.23968817293643951,
0.4957329034805298,
-0.39455559849739075,
-0.49041980504989624,
0.4263451099395752,
-0.9279489517211914,
-0.5895448923110962,
-0.03807847946882248,
-0.13770589232444763,
-0.07139614969491959,
0.4919966757297516,
-0.5080181360244751,
0.3953512907028198,
0.4674110412597656,
-0.34540969133377075,
0.5529840588569641,
-0.5798704624176025,
-0.09400622546672821,
-0.8754280209541321,
0.0714961513876915,
-0.05182209610939026,
-0.5504699945449829,
-0.5885889530181885,
0.09011536836624146,
0.31262949109077454,
-0.16165322065353394,
-0.5316781997680664,
0.817579984664917,
-0.31931889057159424,
-0.03268744796514511,
-0.0906224325299263,
0.509029746055603,
0.3341076076030731,
-0.1376899629831314,
-0.20895704627037048,
0.6359092593193054,
0.48888757824897766,
-0.4498269259929657,
0.6500735282897949,
0.3158738613128662,
0.08586607873439789,
1.0032809972763062,
-0.6382166147232056,
-0.09268835932016373,
-0.05959966033697128,
0.43101078271865845,
-0.6766868233680725,
-0.08681382238864899,
0.1216951310634613,
-0.20120371878147125,
0.475455641746521,
0.15660607814788818,
-0.4735668897628784,
-0.1754162758588791,
-0.29238635301589966,
0.5466618537902832,
0.4798869490623474,
-0.4169994592666626,
0.4876830577850342,
0.08063378185033798,
0.12247538566589355,
-0.6461560726165771,
-0.6080288290977478,
0.024114664644002914,
-0.23792223632335663,
-0.7166751027107239,
0.4977925419807434,
0.10806027054786682,
-0.31035441160202026,
-0.10194352269172668,
-0.19250257313251495,
0.13707607984542847,
-0.0727003738284111,
0.16067110002040863,
0.3625873327255249,
-0.24416977167129517,
0.16251753270626068,
-0.08283015340566635,
-0.4629833400249481,
-0.06985156238079071,
0.1443055421113968,
0.23749414086341858,
-0.13244234025478363,
-0.8186852335929871,
-0.33459246158599854,
0.10798709094524384,
0.6726788878440857,
-0.0778673067688942,
0.6287360787391663,
0.5587160587310791,
-0.24165856838226318,
-0.1663498878479004,
-0.4983709454536438,
0.08942986279726028,
-0.4709802567958832,
0.40761271119117737,
-0.3259955942630768,
-0.3166046440601349,
0.7425081133842468,
-0.36664319038391113,
-0.08883204311132431,
0.29953107237815857,
0.6593396663665771,
0.02882571890950203,
1.0793436765670776,
0.08185689151287079,
0.45260241627693176,
-0.15267975628376007,
0.05125885829329491,
0.37970638275146484,
-0.8584741353988647,
-0.34614017605781555,
-0.4857420325279236,
-0.3736046254634857,
-0.49100443720817566,
-0.23699414730072021,
0.8013826608657837,
-0.1556721329689026,
-0.0453612357378006,
0.2066604495048523,
-0.8359631896018982,
0.2988404631614685,
0.1023947075009346,
0.15122339129447937,
0.20516668260097504,
-0.23429377377033234,
-0.43689799308776855,
0.042412810027599335,
-0.5563536286354065,
-0.7013570666313171,
1.0962446928024292,
0.4490990936756134,
0.8054690361022949,
0.476148784160614,
0.7185750603675842,
0.25241535902023315,
0.524036169052124,
-0.7574700117111206,
0.5322033762931824,
-0.15612611174583435,
-0.42045876383781433,
-0.0816362276673317,
-0.0346691831946373,
-1.4473345279693604,
0.5604155659675598,
0.15120640397071838,
-0.6426668763160706,
0.3338291347026825,
-0.14400586485862732,
-0.35602083802223206,
-0.3659133017063141,
-0.6426292061805725,
1.0453741550445557,
-0.34452107548713684,
-0.463588148355484,
0.0024630955886095762,
-0.8730734586715698,
0.008116585202515125,
-0.27271658182144165,
0.26518872380256653,
-0.45125657320022583,
-0.23614056408405304,
0.3136674761772156,
-0.9435692429542542,
0.8077981472015381,
-0.011160160414874554,
-0.2257327437400818,
-0.08558341860771179,
-0.07136180996894836,
0.25009259581565857,
0.1622018665075302,
-0.07537920773029327,
-0.022183533757925034,
0.5394891500473022,
-0.471700519323349,
-0.5457698702812195,
0.7014576196670532,
-0.9143383502960205,
-0.41066089272499084,
-0.7591108679771423,
-0.5951880216598511,
-0.6824536919593811,
0.11579850316047668,
0.13936109840869904,
0.7473883628845215,
-0.2583431005477905,
-0.3139913082122803,
0.27079060673713684,
-0.36140918731689453,
0.11318321526050568,
0.725946307182312,
-0.09536787122488022,
-0.4417298436164856,
0.8277689218521118,
-0.1565995067358017,
0.4864623546600342,
0.2683662176132202,
0.264114648103714,
-0.5077307820320129,
-0.40211400389671326,
-0.4902191460132599,
0.3761894106864929,
-0.8821884393692017,
-0.4624326527118683,
-0.23281551897525787,
-0.17036886513233185,
-0.5502402186393738,
-0.6230084896087646,
-0.35853999853134155,
-0.10928919166326523,
-0.1544540524482727,
0.2761435806751251,
0.24852396547794342,
0.5365891456604004,
0.0405392125248909,
0.2865128815174103,
-0.8823363780975342,
0.3878863453865051,
-0.14735256135463715,
0.2262755036354065,
-0.3114464282989502,
-0.20062097907066345,
-0.1156507134437561,
-0.011479884386062622,
-0.6559949517250061,
-0.7778201103210449,
0.3514918088912964,
0.07471976429224014,
0.7507071495056152,
0.656006395816803,
0.2334805130958557,
0.9090223908424377,
-0.3517289459705353,
0.32839667797088623,
0.17721860110759735,
-0.6006278991699219,
0.3305265009403229,
-0.1354289948940277,
0.220243439078331,
0.5355761647224426,
0.10820599645376205,
-0.38695529103279114,
-0.5887988805770874,
-0.5344001650810242,
-0.6139668822288513,
0.6186457276344299,
0.1335359811782837,
-0.4404626488685608,
0.08998609334230423,
0.1120498776435852,
0.19670556485652924,
-0.06487109512090683,
-0.17336390912532806,
-0.19922290742397308,
0.18193915486335754,
-0.6422927975654602,
-0.15289980173110962,
0.2504999041557312,
-0.6834902763366699,
-0.20914670825004578,
0.3647761046886444,
-0.20922724902629852,
0.2975817322731018,
0.5604737401008606,
-0.07415934652090073,
-0.1101687029004097,
0.21172524988651276,
0.679484486579895,
1.1304622888565063,
-0.240622878074646,
0.08867114037275314,
0.014862130396068096,
-0.49190640449523926,
0.4661918878555298,
0.3488924205303192,
0.4018484055995941,
0.057166580110788345,
0.5927906036376953,
0.31149235367774963,
-0.1029321700334549,
-0.9916579127311707,
0.5524239540100098,
-0.10438200831413269,
-0.23283438384532928,
-0.383914589881897,
0.01121215708553791,
-0.1022077426314354,
0.3430847227573395,
-0.08077164739370346,
0.10543833673000336,
-0.12991014122962952,
-0.49177098274230957,
0.2416822612285614,
0.5402785539627075,
-0.5312085747718811,
-0.023255597800016403,
0.6499931812286377,
0.0912599116563797,
-0.43055248260498047,
0.5086822509765625,
-0.3344888687133789,
-0.15961159765720367,
1.1699057817459106,
0.697149395942688,
0.7552753686904907,
-0.210560142993927,
0.26558977365493774,
-0.22567714750766754,
0.14996381103992462,
0.21142852306365967,
0.1999305784702301,
0.272094190120697,
-0.6777543425559998,
-0.27676981687545776,
-0.49161460995674133,
-0.7773666977882385,
-0.1357479989528656,
-0.5536224842071533,
0.5705989599227905,
-0.4033183455467224,
-0.34240105748176575,
0.08160168677568436,
-0.012920984998345375,
-0.5001883506774902,
0.20917250216007233,
-0.11435583978891373,
0.7623472809791565,
-0.4938139021396637,
0.7706656455993652,
1.022605299949646,
-0.10611964762210846,
-0.4649292230606079,
-0.5408723950386047,
0.38302090764045715,
-1.065954566001892,
0.10502701997756958,
0.24777476489543915,
0.22176863253116608,
-0.32006603479385376,
-0.06501524895429611,
-0.5123382806777954,
1.2763197422027588,
0.3947256803512573,
-0.5577526092529297,
0.2790510356426239,
0.5328310132026672,
1.059294581413269,
-0.45274919271469116,
0.4454095959663391,
0.5019597411155701,
0.4527718722820282,
0.16977103054523468,
-1.1698650121688843,
0.45588597655296326,
-0.190365731716156,
-0.25384819507598877,
0.348099946975708,
-0.5268730521202087,
0.4363250732421875,
-0.14459887146949768,
-0.03237970918416977,
0.3595511317253113,
-0.1806696355342865,
0.6865693926811218,
0.87581866979599,
0.06997343897819519,
0.7184572815895081,
0.7291733026504517,
-0.15740171074867249,
1.0959391593933105,
-0.29113703966140747,
0.18773049116134644,
0.7957528829574585,
-0.7966745495796204,
0.1601446270942688,
0.20470845699310303,
-0.5160401463508606,
0.14735844731330872,
0.6180600523948669,
-0.2750970125198364,
0.09964238107204437,
0.3244531750679016,
-0.5283884406089783,
-0.14798372983932495,
-0.3503115475177765,
-0.5839694738388062,
0.19118523597717285,
0.5282328724861145,
-0.04898407682776451,
-0.3378155827522278,
-0.10155684500932693,
-0.2052743285894394,
0.004026220180094242,
0.20827655494213104,
0.6356381177902222,
0.018541226163506508,
-0.4917334318161011,
0.7350010275840759,
-0.24054278433322906,
0.016897769644856453,
-0.7721400856971741,
0.03322629630565643,
-0.10587611794471741,
0.5528940558433533,
-0.3146103024482727,
-0.3580074608325958,
0.21782448887825012,
-0.4460817277431488,
0.3553934097290039,
-0.13001474738121033,
0.5575714111328125,
-0.048188768327236176,
-0.3322620987892151,
0.3317621648311615,
0.518618106842041,
0.22754140198230743,
0.2659587264060974,
-0.6998694539070129,
0.23305843770503998,
-0.43319568037986755,
0.31491345167160034,
0.5559344291687012,
0.6328776478767395,
-0.10545748472213745,
0.8382183313369751,
0.4101412892341614,
0.2271852344274521,
-0.04084833711385727,
0.5591700077056885,
0.6519677639007568,
-0.48635298013687134,
0.00035291039966978133,
-0.7192538976669312,
0.2877405285835266,
-0.058995455503463745,
-0.34727150201797485,
0.4092419147491455,
0.5883368253707886,
0.25258204340934753,
0.09593728184700012,
0.5197876691818237,
0.31209632754325867,
0.4638134241104126,
-0.17596669495105743,
0.48684078454971313,
-0.7116300463676453,
0.3700903058052063,
-0.22470296919345856,
-0.783721923828125,
-0.4683240056037903,
0.28800562024116516,
0.3085003197193146,
0.006484875455498695,
0.9651649594306946,
0.7289732098579407,
0.09430711716413498,
-0.10398752242326736,
0.5490152835845947,
0.19564221799373627,
0.7101948857307434,
0.46748605370521545,
0.8222724795341492,
-0.24675849080085754,
0.2775190472602844,
-0.36822548508644104,
-0.4629130959510803,
-0.22067563235759735,
-0.6576782464981079,
-0.7302755117416382,
-0.0739375650882721,
-0.5881957411766052,
-0.3363093137741089,
0.0859459936618805,
0.7571143507957458,
0.6364007592201233,
-0.6091088056564331,
-0.1882028728723526,
-0.1905643790960312,
-0.023466086015105247,
-0.4989714026451111,
-0.24242930114269257,
0.3811146914958954,
-0.5905711650848389,
-0.6445348262786865,
0.6051790714263916,
0.5004283785820007,
0.10918717086315155,
-0.13902214169502258,
-0.11760926246643066,
0.16781927645206451,
-0.15521620213985443,
0.4313262701034546,
0.33222806453704834,
-0.7873899340629578,
0.015442933887243271,
-0.0869385227560997,
-0.30253568291664124,
0.14461125433444977,
0.5331424474716187,
-1.0308095216751099,
0.645477831363678,
0.12069723755121231,
0.762885332107544,
-0.014158539474010468,
0.08561505377292633,
0.635577917098999,
-0.4891695976257324,
0.07010624557733536,
0.5231053829193115,
0.22549211978912354,
0.005971469450742006,
-0.2835830748081207,
0.6529792547225952,
0.14187924563884735,
-0.8573311567306519,
-0.9331814050674438,
-0.015162390656769276,
-1.3213680982589722,
-0.11292286217212677,
0.8139943480491638,
0.1444733440876007,
0.09821859747171402,
-0.420634925365448,
-0.204758420586586,
0.23195868730545044,
-0.2649717926979065,
0.4549832344055176,
0.3607479929924011,
-0.7917706966400146,
0.26463815569877625,
-0.5454739332199097,
0.24786943197250366,
0.6003783941268921,
-0.9023637175559998,
-0.3932678997516632,
0.39854803681373596,
0.09671292454004288,
0.2433130443096161,
0.6951994299888611,
-0.2854296565055847,
0.34264346957206726,
-0.12660062313079834,
0.09168452024459839,
0.09738391637802124,
-0.043152060359716415,
-0.11835726350545883,
-0.15070544183254242,
-0.025930484756827354,
-0.3574126660823822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13885v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13885v1 | Knowledge Tagging System on Math Questions via LLMs with Flexible Demonstration Retriever | 2024-06-19T23:30:01 | 2024-06-19T23:30:01 | Hang Li, Tianlong Xu, Jiliang Tang, Qingsong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge tagging for questions plays a crucial role in contemporary
intelligent educational applications, including learning progress diagnosis,
practice question recommendations, and course content organization.
Traditionally, these annotations are always conducted by pedagogical experts,
as the task requires not only a strong semantic understanding of both question
stems and knowledge definitions but also deep insights into connecting
question-solving logic with corresponding knowledge concepts. With the recent
emergence of advanced text encoding algorithms, such as pre-trained language
models, many researchers have developed automatic knowledge tagging systems
based on calculating the semantic similarity between the knowledge and question
embeddings. In this paper, we explore automating the task using Large Language
Models (LLMs), in response to the inability of prior encoding-based methods to
deal with the hard cases which involve strong domain knowledge and complicated
concept definitions. By showing the strong performance of zero- and few-shot
results over math questions knowledge tagging tasks, we demonstrate LLMs' great
potential in conquering the challenges faced by prior methods. Furthermore, by
proposing a reinforcement learning-based demonstration retriever, we
successfully exploit the great potential of different-sized LLMs in achieving
better performance results while keeping the in-context demonstration usage
efficiency high. | [
-0.4923332631587982,
-0.8115822672843933,
0.6519011855125427,
-0.19105207920074463,
-0.3180491030216217,
0.1683564931154251,
-0.13635848462581635,
-0.1434672325849533,
0.1932496279478073,
0.37862157821655273,
-0.43263480067253113,
-0.4820916950702667,
-0.6516254544258118,
-0.03327089548110962,
-0.19518418610095978,
0.7996469736099243,
-0.44614529609680176,
-0.012165144085884094,
-0.668384850025177,
0.0844554454088211,
-0.47889551520347595,
-0.5811939835548401,
-0.5809387564659119,
-0.5483729839324951,
0.16534563899040222,
0.22578927874565125,
0.49441424012184143,
0.6634882092475891,
0.7015956044197083,
0.3697417974472046,
0.21416935324668884,
0.2581976056098938,
-0.03808000683784485,
0.16203895211219788,
-0.3074502646923065,
-0.7056168913841248,
-0.3067144453525543,
-0.048983413726091385,
0.7691316604614258,
0.7964775562286377,
-0.1544189453125,
0.14931897819042206,
-0.22679215669631958,
0.15114142000675201,
-0.3824467062950134,
0.26229771971702576,
-0.75027996301651,
0.15099824965000153,
0.055533453822135925,
-0.15057483315467834,
-0.14565585553646088,
-0.4622161388397217,
0.11170241236686707,
-0.6737852096557617,
-0.08425605297088623,
-0.050454139709472656,
0.8156309127807617,
0.45151591300964355,
-0.2632502317428589,
-0.40069618821144104,
-0.6940691471099854,
0.9007472395896912,
-0.5890690684318542,
0.19072790443897247,
0.47990819811820984,
0.5778266787528992,
-0.20149920880794525,
-0.6108605265617371,
-0.6167212128639221,
-0.15568339824676514,
-0.14534850418567657,
-0.10624770820140839,
-0.18675623834133148,
-0.12209475785493851,
0.655963122844696,
0.1605682671070099,
-0.423743337392807,
0.028167210519313812,
0.002731593558564782,
-0.35346168279647827,
0.5651217103004456,
0.2859255075454712,
0.18229801952838898,
-0.18992266058921814,
-0.4729773700237274,
-0.16835413873195648,
-0.663109302520752,
-0.0930902287364006,
0.13492904603481293,
-0.06553550064563751,
0.3724413812160492,
0.7842837572097778,
-0.23387786746025085,
0.8238495588302612,
-0.26902902126312256,
-0.3471517562866211,
0.1344345062971115,
-0.083481065928936,
-0.21889805793762207,
-0.27974748611450195,
0.5910241007804871,
0.024213125929236412,
0.44014325737953186,
0.0231375303119421,
-0.3168491721153259,
0.27032700181007385,
-0.07597295939922333,
-0.7061803936958313,
-0.26827263832092285,
-0.2503247559070587,
-0.036398984491825104,
0.2239004224538803,
-0.22914338111877441,
-0.4648807942867279,
-0.2498510181903839,
-0.32276320457458496,
0.8966814279556274,
-0.6075304746627808,
-0.1974184811115265,
0.27358222007751465,
-0.08154109865427017,
0.38460204005241394,
0.5570481419563293,
-0.6683453917503357,
0.3437601327896118,
0.6984034776687622,
0.31445664167404175,
-0.07325981557369232,
-0.015507777221500874,
-0.4468768537044525,
0.24692414700984955,
-0.22436583042144775,
0.7200241088867188,
-0.7065243721008301,
-0.19875681400299072,
-0.1124742403626442,
-0.2696566879749298,
-0.13539592921733856,
-0.5710206031799316,
0.123253732919693,
-0.9640306830406189,
0.06273473054170609,
-0.18080346286296844,
-1.1461777687072754,
-0.11664562672376633,
0.7047796249389648,
-0.27307018637657166,
0.734296977519989,
-0.0316014289855957,
-0.5065485239028931,
0.1394658088684082,
-0.5395759344100952,
-0.2994064688682556,
0.43633878231048584,
-0.47800466418266296,
-0.2729824483394623,
-0.14754360914230347,
0.19650442898273468,
0.6829801797866821,
-0.16797742247581482,
0.35507073998451233,
-0.1459958702325821,
-0.2365536093711853,
0.3747689723968506,
-0.3326534032821655,
0.28694435954093933,
0.021652156487107277,
-0.22866705060005188,
-0.10597554594278336,
-0.5642932057380676,
0.09319791197776794,
0.5013743042945862,
-0.3123982548713684,
-0.5290822386741638,
-0.05352083221077919,
-0.791212797164917,
0.14794692397117615,
0.467274934053421,
-0.44769880175590515,
0.5222916603088379,
-0.4386099874973297,
0.02610161155462265,
0.5547580718994141,
0.0580541230738163,
0.34448665380477905,
-0.3994700610637665,
0.7668954133987427,
-0.041190363466739655,
-0.14810062944889069,
-0.32619503140449524,
-0.39362257719039917,
-0.7652531266212463,
-0.12992741167545319,
0.5630284547805786,
0.576207160949707,
-1.127137541770935,
0.2753569781780243,
-0.30435478687286377,
-0.35336586833000183,
-0.29554125666618347,
0.3220282793045044,
0.42368558049201965,
0.6845979690551758,
0.294750839471817,
-0.15373924374580383,
-0.2136506885290146,
-0.9809838533401489,
-0.26225385069847107,
-0.07220587134361267,
-0.201334610581398,
0.3933827877044678,
0.6608917713165283,
-0.007269744761288166,
1.1055526733398438,
-0.8668068051338196,
-0.37891221046447754,
-0.24272309243679047,
0.2581811845302582,
0.021644027903676033,
0.44608116149902344,
0.31696033477783203,
-0.7548125386238098,
-0.25585928559303284,
-0.25015413761138916,
-0.6340676546096802,
-0.0004575934144668281,
0.07923167198896408,
-0.1338464617729187,
0.20425474643707275,
0.4297458827495575,
-0.5944252610206604,
0.4506785273551941,
0.06121520698070526,
-0.0875847265124321,
0.4814097583293915,
-0.18010729551315308,
-0.07699092477560043,
-1.0214931964874268,
-0.12570174038410187,
0.05613471940159798,
-0.4023709297180176,
-0.3259088099002838,
0.0724380612373352,
0.042933035641908646,
-0.01108027808368206,
-0.30950450897216797,
0.6476091742515564,
-0.3159205913543701,
-0.13035297393798828,
-0.14177776873111725,
0.3305015563964844,
-0.0791926309466362,
0.5126699209213257,
0.19784386456012726,
0.4865185022354126,
0.37411749362945557,
-0.6706027388572693,
0.7323970198631287,
0.2177637666463852,
-0.2794311046600342,
0.4007819890975952,
-0.49568361043930054,
0.09107071906328201,
-0.14177493751049042,
0.29514414072036743,
-1.0054593086242676,
-0.18164780735969543,
0.24287787079811096,
-0.5502011775970459,
0.2721351981163025,
-0.30538398027420044,
-0.8687883019447327,
-0.49032437801361084,
-0.21935570240020752,
0.391295850276947,
0.8228956460952759,
-0.36376306414604187,
0.6773802042007446,
0.32468998432159424,
-0.20221196115016937,
-0.4676804542541504,
-0.3179141879081726,
-0.20872867107391357,
-0.20432718098163605,
-0.39059919118881226,
0.2045535296201706,
-0.16981935501098633,
-0.20632079243659973,
0.024176103994250298,
-0.14889588952064514,
-0.05412256345152855,
0.3385201394557953,
0.030071720480918884,
0.4277513027191162,
-0.2053774744272232,
0.5776062607765198,
0.13474571704864502,
-0.23798900842666626,
0.376340389251709,
-0.3719043433666229,
0.6962154507637024,
-0.05256235599517822,
-0.8171051740646362,
-0.1680322140455246,
0.2238580286502838,
0.026061581447720528,
-0.4533770680427551,
0.5032167434692383,
0.30588921904563904,
-0.7724809646606445,
-0.28027284145355225,
-0.6679778099060059,
-0.14595969021320343,
-0.4731050431728363,
0.2048376053571701,
-0.45359113812446594,
-1.0618343353271484,
0.44252485036849976,
-0.5271267890930176,
0.006561644375324249,
0.4833883047103882,
0.3877691924571991,
-0.12464950978755951,
1.1227586269378662,
0.5136709213256836,
0.04714090749621391,
0.3096945583820343,
-0.387245237827301,
-0.07185231894254684,
-0.5386543273925781,
-0.3279750347137451,
-0.4519970118999481,
-0.18282108008861542,
-0.07474466413259506,
-0.660365104675293,
0.3599276542663574,
0.21514052152633667,
-0.2631026804447174,
0.10232601314783096,
-0.36372247338294983,
0.6161527633666992,
0.5070386528968811,
-0.11644729226827621,
0.4168858528137207,
0.121287502348423,
-0.3366101086139679,
-0.2140311896800995,
-0.6550054550170898,
-0.4860277473926544,
0.9457410573959351,
0.30516108870506287,
0.8765311241149902,
-0.012915887869894505,
0.8126676678657532,
-0.01726771891117096,
0.3856377899646759,
-0.961965799331665,
0.7865387797355652,
0.07083305716514587,
-0.48920291662216187,
-0.34895002841949463,
-0.5253674983978271,
-0.6714997887611389,
0.09033428877592087,
-0.115369513630867,
-0.5254220366477966,
-0.3023226261138916,
0.10813581943511963,
-0.3967230021953583,
0.425772100687027,
-0.582425594329834,
0.643851101398468,
-0.2280849665403366,
-0.07960020750761032,
-0.022298235446214676,
-0.4705082178115845,
0.2436467409133911,
-0.19363056123256683,
0.07475661486387253,
-0.10672292113304138,
-0.1417544037103653,
0.9983722567558289,
-0.418124794960022,
0.7084184288978577,
-0.35636427998542786,
-0.2289423793554306,
0.3222050070762634,
0.27728578448295593,
0.37271174788475037,
0.05699722096323967,
0.23301580548286438,
-0.35881465673446655,
-0.11349644511938095,
-0.25241217017173767,
-0.9447513222694397,
0.5962667465209961,
-0.6317548751831055,
-0.8594441413879395,
-0.3477691113948822,
-0.6499295234680176,
-0.4675481617450714,
0.18865054845809937,
-0.223546102643013,
0.4097764492034912,
0.22402320802211761,
-0.12477762252092361,
1.0955917835235596,
-0.2140779048204422,
0.418536514043808,
0.5698309540748596,
-0.3525957763195038,
-0.21263636648654938,
1.1185269355773926,
0.19745662808418274,
0.11642807722091675,
0.545250654220581,
0.15106947720050812,
-0.49690499901771545,
-0.4594592750072479,
-0.4241180717945099,
0.5038829445838928,
-0.8415356874465942,
-0.6788976192474365,
-0.7566747665405273,
-0.3692495822906494,
-0.4093000590801239,
-0.1165950670838356,
-0.17440956830978394,
-0.4666804075241089,
-0.19858118891716003,
-0.009248561225831509,
0.46398502588272095,
0.6955544948577881,
0.19347237050533295,
0.25953882932662964,
-0.5555663108825684,
0.38684216141700745,
0.7712723016738892,
0.49076518416404724,
-0.07321208715438843,
-0.5414002537727356,
-0.0815669372677803,
0.05236860364675522,
-0.30652737617492676,
-0.74742192029953,
0.25874391198158264,
-0.09365101903676987,
0.5835359692573547,
0.23899422585964203,
0.07840859889984131,
0.5774708390235901,
-0.4490155577659607,
0.5556330680847168,
0.14258438348770142,
-0.9701651334762573,
0.706708550453186,
-0.19355976581573486,
0.18340295553207397,
0.2463669627904892,
0.8319520950317383,
-0.24138735234737396,
-0.1682596504688263,
-0.5976648330688477,
-0.5967545509338379,
0.6791356801986694,
-0.10400476306676865,
0.1865350902080536,
-0.03819439932703972,
0.5440401434898376,
0.06442351639270782,
0.32925382256507874,
-0.4654165208339691,
-0.2696307897567749,
0.005306228529661894,
-0.30180099606513977,
-0.015618443489074707,
-0.09432334452867508,
-0.17725861072540283,
-0.39174994826316833,
0.7180137634277344,
-0.27960267663002014,
0.3124023377895355,
0.1306792050600052,
-0.40345221757888794,
0.11180153489112854,
0.39799124002456665,
0.5058896541595459,
0.6244268417358398,
0.011087489314377308,
0.09761388599872589,
0.398430198431015,
-0.16247421503067017,
0.13483268022537231,
0.5052520632743835,
-0.02052440121769905,
-0.16195449233055115,
0.16901783645153046,
0.5875976085662842,
0.02509661577641964,
-0.7586451172828674,
0.7073704600334167,
-0.07351341843605042,
-0.3377320170402527,
-0.49208196997642517,
0.19514711201190948,
0.2519589066505432,
0.2395493984222412,
0.4948809742927551,
-0.42852383852005005,
-0.14507539570331573,
-0.17730964720249176,
0.15796811878681183,
0.7535706162452698,
-0.1324656754732132,
-0.06611671298742294,
0.4056641161441803,
-0.09718590974807739,
-0.48597317934036255,
0.4836435616016388,
-0.3772737979888916,
-0.8440049886703491,
0.8205088376998901,
0.730498194694519,
0.2435990273952484,
-0.22972607612609863,
0.16039226949214935,
0.11097630113363266,
0.13701774179935455,
0.0444953627884388,
0.25189289450645447,
-0.34059086441993713,
-0.8039184808731079,
-0.6378890872001648,
-0.6633394956588745,
-0.5865278840065002,
0.028800467029213905,
-0.5079315304756165,
0.2497536689043045,
-0.6312205791473389,
-0.013314873911440372,
-0.02740011364221573,
0.3250313997268677,
-0.7561050653457642,
0.3893095850944519,
0.45153069496154785,
1.0124874114990234,
-0.6727925539016724,
0.8317070007324219,
1.1100623607635498,
-0.2710692882537842,
-1.0363380908966064,
-0.38660097122192383,
-0.295969158411026,
-0.897134006023407,
0.7646856904029846,
-0.00023494976630900055,
-0.039279352873563766,
0.2257496565580368,
-0.700241208076477,
-0.8361819386482239,
1.1534079313278198,
0.29233992099761963,
-0.3746265470981598,
-0.1302596777677536,
0.2951309382915497,
0.4945756196975708,
-0.4459383487701416,
0.3462928533554077,
0.401058554649353,
0.2940977215766907,
0.4087751805782318,
-0.7693467736244202,
0.07186360657215118,
-0.16624672710895538,
-0.1445840448141098,
0.4191756844520569,
-0.35551077127456665,
0.6485716700553894,
-0.01869325153529644,
0.03670984506607056,
-0.026165520772337914,
0.7990872263908386,
0.3311752378940582,
0.34781190752983093,
0.5536203980445862,
0.7217709422111511,
0.647927463054657,
-0.14698508381843567,
0.852464497089386,
0.09976797550916672,
0.4119669198989868,
0.8731394410133362,
-0.3260852098464966,
0.7749487161636353,
0.2862664759159088,
-0.2655337154865265,
0.5227899551391602,
0.3298809230327606,
-0.13282747566699982,
0.05589360371232033,
0.6760932803153992,
-0.20321080088615417,
-0.7311877012252808,
-0.16585147380828857,
-0.4592044949531555,
0.42397594451904297,
0.6937503218650818,
-0.09130028635263443,
-0.43434280157089233,
0.11330190300941467,
-0.016801660880446434,
0.10058653354644775,
-0.45091959834098816,
0.88225257396698,
-0.03719552978873253,
-0.6275205612182617,
0.43868446350097656,
-0.0019529651617631316,
0.8304392099380493,
-0.8883574604988098,
-0.3340643048286438,
-0.1949327141046524,
0.03280803561210632,
0.09273821115493774,
-0.8074326515197754,
0.16036471724510193,
-0.06301368772983551,
0.009010059759020805,
-0.20035837590694427,
1.0261317491531372,
-0.4098707437515259,
-0.4873509407043457,
0.07383719831705093,
0.702064037322998,
0.31802815198898315,
0.10785359144210815,
-0.531498372554779,
-0.14958858489990234,
-0.31277966499328613,
-0.07722556591033936,
0.4198160469532013,
0.40985116362571716,
-0.09049200266599655,
0.8611388206481934,
0.4905923306941986,
-0.11436585336923599,
0.20186638832092285,
-0.017549019306898117,
1.0797585248947144,
-0.7369008660316467,
-0.2244277149438858,
-0.7244598269462585,
0.21642234921455383,
0.018661022186279297,
0.06994941085577011,
0.8276069164276123,
0.4501914978027344,
0.966804027557373,
0.0523209348320961,
0.6244775652885437,
0.16190187633037567,
0.6625774502754211,
-0.3538588285446167,
0.6041408777236938,
-0.5693841576576233,
0.2760206460952759,
-0.2603306770324707,
-0.7553513646125793,
-0.4636421799659729,
0.5892263054847717,
-0.5539822578430176,
0.07761474698781967,
0.4980500638484955,
0.36482512950897217,
0.010407118126749992,
-0.09161052852869034,
0.3819912374019623,
-0.07873711735010147,
0.3004223108291626,
0.9172371625900269,
1.0879626274108887,
-0.16344720125198364,
0.7442660331726074,
-0.27012014389038086,
-0.20160651206970215,
-0.07080698758363724,
-0.7696438431739807,
-1.037603735923767,
-0.5196725726127625,
-0.4686732590198517,
-0.09273088723421097,
-0.20780186355113983,
0.9808663129806519,
0.34534886479377747,
-0.5335162281990051,
0.047809094190597534,
0.267056405544281,
0.3413199782371521,
0.2623489499092102,
-0.22819411754608154,
0.3642018735408783,
-0.3064221739768982,
-0.5857588648796082,
0.07764344662427902,
0.04978973791003227,
0.2723418176174164,
-0.2882300913333893,
0.303463876247406,
-0.23401521146297455,
0.05894726887345314,
0.39651456475257874,
0.24080519378185272,
-0.4299625754356384,
-0.299326092004776,
0.09469747543334961,
-0.05794898420572281,
-0.13574592769145966,
0.8335316777229309,
-1.3083868026733398,
0.19059544801712036,
0.3299558162689209,
1.057409644126892,
0.43493956327438354,
-0.03697541728615761,
0.22202043235301971,
-0.6762799620628357,
-0.25452423095703125,
0.44212302565574646,
0.35832852125167847,
0.3405238687992096,
-0.12160401046276093,
0.1639542579650879,
0.3793158233165741,
-0.387349933385849,
-0.739920973777771,
0.3533576428890228,
-0.669486939907074,
-0.13876917958259583,
1.0566880702972412,
-0.47930270433425903,
-0.2538318932056427,
-0.09631305187940598,
0.0013054510345682502,
0.36165928840637207,
-0.10509011149406433,
0.5172669291496277,
0.7746812105178833,
-0.10874608159065247,
0.09570591151714325,
-0.3653106689453125,
0.28385475277900696,
0.6898530125617981,
-0.7569677233695984,
-0.2135288566350937,
0.42400968074798584,
0.4809853732585907,
0.2958512604236603,
0.518397867679596,
-0.03813401982188225,
0.11407911777496338,
-0.33935025334358215,
0.11383228003978729,
-0.23843160271644592,
-0.2036474347114563,
-0.4317449927330017,
0.3557996153831482,
0.04934137687087059,
-0.2059546709060669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13862v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13862v1 | Knowledge Graph-Enhanced Large Language Models via Path Selection | 2024-06-19T21:45:20 | 2024-06-19T21:45:20 | Haochen Liu, Song Wang, Yaochen Zhu, Yushun Dong, Jundong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown unprecedented performance in various
real-world applications. However, they are known to generate factually
inaccurate outputs, a.k.a. the hallucination problem. In recent years,
incorporating external knowledge extracted from Knowledge Graphs (KGs) has
become a promising strategy to improve the factual accuracy of LLM-generated
outputs. Nevertheless, most existing explorations rely on LLMs themselves to
perform KG knowledge extraction, which is highly inflexible as LLMs can only
provide binary judgment on whether a certain knowledge (e.g., a knowledge path
in KG) should be used. In addition, LLMs tend to pick only knowledge with
direct semantic relationship with the input text, while potentially useful
knowledge with indirect semantics can be ignored. In this work, we propose a
principled framework KELP with three stages to handle the above problems.
Specifically, KELP is able to achieve finer granularity of flexible knowledge
extraction by generating scores for knowledge paths with input texts via latent
semantic matching. Meanwhile, knowledge paths with indirect semantic
relationships with the input text can also be considered via trained encoding
between the selected paths in KG and the input text. Experiments on real-world
datasets validate the effectiveness of KELP. | [
-0.1508859395980835,
-1.0474563837051392,
1.0918909311294556,
0.11211170256137848,
-0.23603232204914093,
-0.0951276645064354,
-0.4406738877296448,
-0.6922019124031067,
0.3106190860271454,
0.6616433262825012,
-0.3275856673717499,
-0.5690307021141052,
-0.6448845863342285,
0.10569310188293457,
-0.11822639405727386,
0.7411060333251953,
0.016288256272673607,
0.04263971000909805,
-0.27235254645347595,
0.02538342960178852,
-0.4720851480960846,
-0.23711556196212769,
-0.684847354888916,
-0.6112927198410034,
0.819564163684845,
0.30798614025115967,
0.6476279497146606,
0.49458733201026917,
0.4107772707939148,
0.21938841044902802,
-0.1958293914794922,
0.35379835963249207,
-0.3939124345779419,
0.5966523289680481,
-0.11253651231527328,
-0.20272262394428253,
-0.32360944151878357,
-0.2411249876022339,
0.7189977765083313,
0.9810348153114319,
0.14399822056293488,
-0.05114949494600296,
0.10674705356359482,
0.5937467217445374,
-0.4291844666004181,
0.40006402134895325,
-0.8306040167808533,
0.1812385469675064,
-0.13402044773101807,
-0.027588514611124992,
-0.4497421979904175,
-0.46029791235923767,
0.13977980613708496,
-0.4826390743255615,
-0.2732933759689331,
-0.03313828632235527,
0.6002740859985352,
0.12436190992593765,
-0.44061318039894104,
-0.6779484152793884,
-0.712018609046936,
0.4217379689216614,
-0.6925495862960815,
0.9146425127983093,
0.5628477334976196,
0.5352234840393066,
-0.35374513268470764,
-0.8650900721549988,
-0.6595756411552429,
-0.3609076142311096,
-0.26991158723831177,
-0.07696476578712463,
0.18191653490066528,
0.08918802440166473,
0.16060630977153778,
0.05099308490753174,
-0.39539799094200134,
0.20969736576080322,
-0.28618621826171875,
-0.3291639983654022,
0.43669378757476807,
0.06532129645347595,
0.10333142429590225,
-0.41057437658309937,
-0.07434973865747452,
-0.21576093137264252,
-0.7294286489486694,
-0.15649449825286865,
0.4344460964202881,
0.6721745133399963,
0.2759578227996826,
0.8073848485946655,
-0.30543386936187744,
0.8230865597724915,
-0.07608462870121002,
-0.4949361979961395,
0.2813028395175934,
-0.00949881598353386,
-0.052089571952819824,
0.15295648574829102,
0.8877667188644409,
0.17359067499637604,
0.10742925852537155,
-0.7349842190742493,
-0.19462932646274567,
-0.09286085516214371,
0.0994558334350586,
-0.7496709823608398,
-0.253054678440094,
0.2666999399662018,
-0.2601596713066101,
-0.2824118435382843,
-0.24075129628181458,
-0.9741520881652832,
-0.6203115582466125,
-0.15654844045639038,
0.506570041179657,
-0.7079512476921082,
-0.20153537392616272,
0.04638568311929703,
-0.10379905253648758,
0.13584379851818085,
0.3603181540966034,
-0.7536342740058899,
0.2380988746881485,
0.5244616866111755,
0.9262970685958862,
-0.20057742297649384,
-0.17498502135276794,
-0.6272909641265869,
0.6080824732780457,
-0.20037402212619781,
0.5650157332420349,
-1.0360153913497925,
-0.38035300374031067,
-0.10223525762557983,
-0.27187496423721313,
-0.07249999791383743,
-0.3973569869995117,
0.5979922413825989,
-0.8101540803909302,
0.2601477801799774,
-0.4820956885814667,
-0.7347184419631958,
-0.44999295473098755,
0.3776991665363312,
-0.6177002191543579,
0.9964478611946106,
0.06292971223592758,
-0.7354013919830322,
0.3730097711086273,
-0.6811363697052002,
-0.685406506061554,
0.04223327338695526,
-0.2880246341228485,
-0.08938265591859818,
-0.20835420489311218,
0.2543937563896179,
0.7088670134544373,
-0.10451032221317291,
0.48904556035995483,
-0.42533305287361145,
-0.21357141435146332,
-0.39109182357788086,
-0.3361845910549164,
0.6941416263580322,
0.14704176783561707,
-0.39038383960723877,
0.04376338794827461,
-0.8836796879768372,
0.010949015617370605,
0.05410071834921837,
-0.6226745247840881,
-0.4631775915622711,
0.10363148152828217,
-0.29779183864593506,
0.35123082995414734,
0.10532623529434204,
-0.3922688066959381,
0.30724209547042847,
-0.34338048100471497,
0.17675085365772247,
1.0089162588119507,
0.05393461883068085,
0.4342299699783325,
-0.053106263279914856,
0.3726796507835388,
-0.1772879809141159,
-0.19063755869865417,
0.2428514063358307,
-0.5609482526779175,
-0.7751846313476562,
-0.16746528446674347,
0.1610298901796341,
0.33882930874824524,
-0.8341172933578491,
0.6686189770698547,
-0.5234039425849915,
-0.6016896963119507,
-0.22132380306720734,
0.21100373566150665,
0.08971592038869858,
0.7948597073554993,
0.30276355147361755,
-0.0122043676674366,
-0.2921043634414673,
-0.44676315784454346,
-0.06943609565496445,
-0.3993811309337616,
0.07813192903995514,
0.6792135238647461,
0.33501189947128296,
-0.3787304759025574,
0.8377111554145813,
-0.6380560994148254,
-0.4087289869785309,
-0.32080161571502686,
-0.2559976279735565,
0.26530683040618896,
0.20008549094200134,
0.15182168781757355,
-0.762360155582428,
-0.4443156123161316,
0.20359545946121216,
-0.8366513848304749,
0.003749524476006627,
0.08214292675256729,
-0.2793647050857544,
-0.030024727806448936,
0.5592478513717651,
-0.818752110004425,
0.02776142582297325,
0.41664567589759827,
-0.38387101888656616,
0.6154558658599854,
-0.16408437490463257,
-0.04101444408297539,
-0.9841373562812805,
0.17345818877220154,
-0.110438272356987,
-0.34998881816864014,
-0.40305206179618835,
0.059035900980234146,
-0.2424270063638687,
0.14501969516277313,
-0.06414040178060532,
0.7184127569198608,
-0.05237476900219917,
-0.19288882613182068,
0.015287055633962154,
0.31268274784088135,
-0.08269637823104858,
0.5353438258171082,
0.34958547353744507,
0.19157050549983978,
0.38863837718963623,
-0.7797147035598755,
0.5115278363227844,
0.30842146277427673,
-0.33435070514678955,
0.14117039740085602,
-0.3218477964401245,
0.5111981630325317,
-0.13532303273677826,
0.29699230194091797,
-0.7725239992141724,
-0.3266952931880951,
0.4712006747722626,
-0.1870148777961731,
0.19336524605751038,
-0.013394083827733994,
-0.7064009308815002,
-0.2200341820716858,
-0.03306053578853607,
0.05783653259277344,
0.5283852815628052,
-0.6147195100784302,
1.0169734954833984,
0.34797102212905884,
-0.034003376960754395,
-0.44933053851127625,
-0.3281128406524658,
-0.005182663910090923,
-0.29323720932006836,
-0.6108854413032532,
0.1910175383090973,
-0.07907189428806305,
-0.1692608892917633,
0.06765516847372055,
-0.10497105121612549,
0.13802923262119293,
-0.05426916852593422,
0.22707107663154602,
-0.009470134042203426,
-0.043026648461818695,
0.2192591428756714,
0.13198710978031158,
0.04591397941112518,
0.13229018449783325,
-0.4807584285736084,
0.7888413071632385,
0.20000717043876648,
-0.5187578797340393,
0.00304051348939538,
-0.010487734340131283,
0.6322879791259766,
0.10205212980508804,
0.7075336575508118,
0.7445287704467773,
-0.5017142295837402,
-0.23866385221481323,
-0.5569178462028503,
-0.2783378064632416,
-0.4775072932243347,
0.5117669701576233,
-0.5078374147415161,
-0.9693835973739624,
0.4680178165435791,
-0.2377394437789917,
-0.046121496707201004,
0.3230685591697693,
0.390419602394104,
0.09049612283706665,
0.7417831420898438,
0.46436962485313416,
-0.06950634717941284,
0.13158079981803894,
-0.07598422467708588,
0.46344447135925293,
-0.865088701248169,
-0.6899057030677795,
-0.37211474776268005,
-0.10982012748718262,
-0.4920656085014343,
-0.27586549520492554,
0.4785085618495941,
0.18222281336784363,
-0.14032220840454102,
0.2325468212366104,
-0.16707614064216614,
0.38930490612983704,
0.37846609950065613,
0.31603455543518066,
0.3187536895275116,
0.11448078602552414,
-0.705235481262207,
-0.022618066519498825,
-0.8718560338020325,
-0.5142061114311218,
1.0167559385299683,
0.3341240882873535,
0.517946720123291,
0.13411293923854828,
0.5590627789497375,
0.15805687010288239,
-0.04503216966986656,
-0.8513126373291016,
0.8862165808677673,
-0.06226261332631111,
-0.3701864778995514,
-0.6952390074729919,
-0.6618120670318604,
-0.7084051370620728,
0.30348706245422363,
-0.34118756651878357,
-1.065003752708435,
-0.17580975592136383,
0.07268505543470383,
-0.2627708315849304,
0.534663736820221,
-0.5049035549163818,
0.6416422128677368,
-0.22647368907928467,
-0.49954891204833984,
-0.08608455955982208,
-0.6646633148193359,
0.35689088702201843,
-0.3583935797214508,
0.2925494611263275,
0.07525631040334702,
0.33282172679901123,
0.7515817284584045,
-0.24889817833900452,
0.8515327572822571,
-0.3219884932041168,
-0.2709888815879822,
-0.03337596729397774,
0.4056272506713867,
1.0536121129989624,
-0.018139244988560677,
-0.24716243147850037,
0.03761349245905876,
-0.279645711183548,
0.061124082654714584,
-0.7473656535148621,
0.6146445870399475,
-0.5336901545524597,
-0.7526009678840637,
-0.21663841605186462,
-0.6419328451156616,
-0.6687958836555481,
0.4493683874607086,
0.017640458419919014,
0.26644590497016907,
0.09415186196565628,
0.08735574036836624,
0.4360094964504242,
-0.40089693665504456,
0.3399335443973541,
0.2433479130268097,
-0.6088698506355286,
-0.31080517172813416,
0.9299635887145996,
0.24160729348659515,
0.25925830006599426,
0.3833591938018799,
0.39521223306655884,
-0.5610509514808655,
-0.6115354895591736,
-0.14351573586463928,
0.18169577419757843,
-1.049405813217163,
0.019133958965539932,
-0.9598438739776611,
-0.33847084641456604,
-0.6614457964897156,
-0.04536149650812149,
-0.14599525928497314,
-0.3138452470302582,
-0.005875201430171728,
-0.2758561372756958,
0.37222644686698914,
0.9182064533233643,
-0.1900230050086975,
0.013757576234638691,
-0.7403939366340637,
0.3377944231033325,
0.45780113339424133,
0.3579667806625366,
0.28947895765304565,
-0.33655017614364624,
-0.06789939105510712,
-0.07207174599170685,
-0.023126959800720215,
-0.6918728947639465,
0.22656798362731934,
-0.0076376572251319885,
0.6095777153968811,
0.5419495701789856,
-0.07767105847597122,
0.886420488357544,
-0.6204504370689392,
0.6144337058067322,
0.18462985754013062,
-0.7165222764015198,
0.499429851770401,
-0.32878249883651733,
0.13275544345378876,
0.4352595806121826,
0.5065130591392517,
-0.6503727436065674,
-0.3989710509777069,
-0.5215622782707214,
-0.8432326912879944,
0.5232521295547485,
0.33008232712745667,
0.03491969034075737,
0.03600309044122696,
0.46408548951148987,
0.37782225012779236,
0.1473333090543747,
-0.9796887040138245,
-0.020688021555542946,
0.11760776489973068,
-0.24670660495758057,
0.04655381664633751,
-0.21664652228355408,
0.11803380399942398,
-0.42499998211860657,
0.8896376490592957,
-0.06069185584783554,
0.06812217086553574,
0.12537728250026703,
-0.1180838942527771,
-0.04766012728214264,
-0.13911007344722748,
0.025838633999228477,
0.6768970489501953,
-0.32633113861083984,
0.48523905873298645,
0.1985790878534317,
-0.6112840175628662,
-0.01083320751786232,
-0.07301811873912811,
-0.3042636811733246,
0.003281679702922702,
0.6275179386138916,
0.7160281538963318,
-0.01991991326212883,
-0.6163050532341003,
0.26634150743484497,
0.3005405068397522,
0.05035767704248428,
-0.22189942002296448,
0.27280527353286743,
0.13740070164203644,
0.49576523900032043,
0.09176115691661835,
-0.03774498403072357,
0.008227750658988953,
-0.39186134934425354,
0.20463056862354279,
0.5244966745376587,
-0.5571116209030151,
-0.1807950884103775,
0.4644263684749603,
0.07709731161594391,
-0.32796528935432434,
0.7868279218673706,
-0.42916634678840637,
-0.6044161319732666,
0.09463334828615189,
0.6079677939414978,
0.6163586974143982,
-0.027605216950178146,
0.21279774606227875,
0.32408756017684937,
0.2459799349308014,
-0.018144728615880013,
-0.0014442881802096963,
-0.048479825258255005,
-1.0011464357376099,
-0.4088866412639618,
-1.0075994729995728,
-0.09111598879098892,
0.5157511830329895,
-0.22420985996723175,
0.46207770705223083,
-0.27561110258102417,
0.05731380730867386,
-0.1308290958404541,
-0.058763086795806885,
-0.5597403645515442,
0.1622660905122757,
0.122543565928936,
0.9060859084129333,
-0.8627065420150757,
0.9808146953582764,
0.5094493627548218,
-0.31677010655403137,
-0.9782604575157166,
0.1552407294511795,
-0.3263898193836212,
-0.7011141777038574,
0.7559333443641663,
0.07356538623571396,
-0.09585895389318466,
0.11715803295373917,
-0.267987996339798,
-0.8414527773857117,
1.256100058555603,
0.5466645956039429,
-0.570868194103241,
-0.3278603255748749,
0.3587903082370758,
0.21359235048294067,
-0.34770190715789795,
0.08736977726221085,
0.46358218789100647,
0.6106099486351013,
0.6099382638931274,
-0.7591574192047119,
0.31022363901138306,
0.08698175102472305,
-0.1874547004699707,
-0.026464242488145828,
-0.4753713309764862,
0.4664742052555084,
-0.07623656839132309,
0.023968053981661797,
-0.22229979932308197,
0.430943101644516,
0.5198489427566528,
0.0526435486972332,
0.7477914690971375,
0.5914403200149536,
1.0363770723342896,
0.18392355740070343,
0.8753056526184082,
-0.16672787070274353,
0.07114802300930023,
1.2407342195510864,
-0.45511817932128906,
0.7822035551071167,
0.5987176895141602,
-0.12782491743564606,
0.5327869653701782,
0.7212771773338318,
0.11620616912841797,
0.8219465613365173,
0.11633718758821487,
-0.14559032022953033,
-0.40882280468940735,
-0.12039359658956528,
-0.1728900671005249,
0.47435489296913147,
0.30910953879356384,
-0.42902541160583496,
-0.23408208787441254,
-0.19029614329338074,
0.23093612492084503,
-0.20139217376708984,
-0.18125517666339874,
0.696282148361206,
0.05827224627137184,
-0.5393879413604736,
0.1167847216129303,
-0.10982684791088104,
0.3682495653629303,
-0.8876641988754272,
-0.3488788902759552,
-0.03759707883000374,
-0.1454024612903595,
-0.17143306136131287,
-0.6199812889099121,
0.1318972408771515,
-0.1358063519001007,
0.041783083230257034,
-0.011999085545539856,
1.1463230848312378,
-0.3350350260734558,
-0.6861082911491394,
0.64570152759552,
0.6282411813735962,
0.23541098833084106,
-0.049713846296072006,
-0.24580517411231995,
-0.01611822098493576,
-0.01097455620765686,
-0.30323588848114014,
0.09845541417598724,
0.5760404467582703,
0.03621884062886238,
0.6817813515663147,
0.7313592433929443,
0.3862362802028656,
-0.03032137081027031,
0.14070692658424377,
0.9829091429710388,
-0.5554478168487549,
-0.5575974583625793,
-1.0781095027923584,
0.3079255223274231,
-0.21164245903491974,
0.02058531902730465,
0.7943217158317566,
0.5713863372802734,
0.711776852607727,
0.22756308317184448,
0.8974208235740662,
-0.1929486095905304,
0.10587099939584732,
-0.8966246843338013,
0.8140462636947632,
-0.3212032914161682,
0.403095006942749,
-0.5458758473396301,
-1.2417778968811035,
-0.24370862543582916,
0.6876652240753174,
-0.4535073935985565,
0.16532856225967407,
0.788133978843689,
0.7104604840278625,
-0.17238301038742065,
-0.05249130725860596,
0.32075071334838867,
0.38134390115737915,
0.29528626799583435,
0.5374539494514465,
0.6770710349082947,
-0.017145449295639992,
0.49184855818748474,
-0.14658786356449127,
0.07803937047719955,
0.036141104996204376,
-1.0121047496795654,
-1.015115737915039,
-0.7068293690681458,
-0.15054696798324585,
-0.5381796360015869,
0.04742107912898064,
0.782351016998291,
0.6430175304412842,
-0.5114219784736633,
-0.10710950195789337,
-0.35241803526878357,
0.4093492925167084,
0.06217895448207855,
-0.2247062474489212,
0.6372296214103699,
-0.3742893636226654,
-0.46704980731010437,
0.4954076111316681,
0.24624235928058624,
0.07190757244825363,
-0.36742356419563293,
-0.3472423255443573,
-0.17856356501579285,
-0.17277589440345764,
0.7178288102149963,
-0.2775880992412567,
-0.6620832085609436,
-0.7003142833709717,
-0.026250099763274193,
0.1367987096309662,
-0.013991829007863998,
0.48158958554267883,
-0.9024267196655273,
0.45297589898109436,
0.36595848202705383,
0.6603503227233887,
0.6555696129798889,
-0.5700480341911316,
0.6303313970565796,
-0.6846231818199158,
-0.04151748865842819,
0.26454347372055054,
0.4106098711490631,
0.36207839846611023,
-0.4686032235622406,
0.6842994093894958,
0.3590686023235321,
-0.16515938937664032,
-0.7915407419204712,
0.23003721237182617,
-0.7055739760398865,
-0.39804935455322266,
1.7012031078338623,
-0.08452631533145905,
-0.18964557349681854,
-0.004703426733613014,
-0.052263494580984116,
0.36649462580680847,
-0.09838741272687912,
0.8889234662055969,
0.9593549370765686,
-0.1481952965259552,
0.20797128975391388,
-0.5481640696525574,
0.5254381895065308,
-0.03568222373723984,
-0.7544834613800049,
0.002167705213651061,
0.5577319860458374,
0.18683035671710968,
0.32705438137054443,
0.6063474416732788,
-0.06715285032987595,
-0.32624033093452454,
-0.06511819362640381,
-0.19683623313903809,
-0.14917907118797302,
-0.47103777527809143,
0.01571733132004738,
0.4266125559806824,
0.1995897740125656,
0.1842021346092224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15507v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15507v1 | Few-shot Knowledge Graph Relational Reasoning via Subgraph Adaptation | 2024-06-19T21:40:35 | 2024-06-19T21:40:35 | Haochen Liu, Song Wang, Chen Chen, Jundong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Few-shot Knowledge Graph (KG) Relational Reasoning aims to predict unseen
triplets (i.e., query triplets) for rare relations in KGs, given only several
triplets of these relations as references (i.e., support triplets). This task
has gained significant traction due to the widespread use of knowledge graphs
in various natural language processing applications. Previous approaches have
utilized meta-training methods and manually constructed meta-relation sets to
tackle this task. Recent efforts have focused on edge-mask-based methods, which
exploit the structure of the contextualized graphs of target triplets (i.e., a
subgraph containing relevant triplets in the KG). However, existing
edge-mask-based methods have limitations in extracting insufficient information
from KG and are highly influenced by spurious information in KG. To overcome
these challenges, we propose SAFER (Subgraph Adaptation for Few-shot Relational
Reasoning), a novel approach that effectively adapts the information in
contextualized graphs to various subgraphs generated from support and query
triplets to perform the prediction. Specifically, SAFER enables the extraction
of more comprehensive information from support triplets while minimizing the
impact of spurious information when predicting query triplets. Experimental
results on three prevalent datasets demonstrate the superiority of our proposed
framework SAFER. | [
-0.2758931517601013,
-0.8132038712501526,
0.4635622799396515,
-0.2227829247713089,
-0.21383270621299744,
-0.054398614913225174,
0.2894589602947235,
-0.33334124088287354,
-0.026461180299520493,
0.5721015334129333,
-0.7257775664329529,
-0.6953073740005493,
-0.4468073546886444,
0.10868263244628906,
0.28809481859207153,
1.0666007995605469,
0.07626321911811829,
-0.28438588976860046,
-0.1920982152223587,
-0.1008438840508461,
-0.5139134526252747,
-0.2741076350212097,
-0.527292013168335,
-0.31133168935775757,
0.4323454797267914,
0.646217405796051,
0.8023580312728882,
0.4734536409378052,
0.516590416431427,
0.0871940553188324,
0.05640887841582298,
0.2766280472278595,
-0.6938241720199585,
0.06981932371854782,
-0.2352769672870636,
-0.31755921244621277,
-0.6198222041130066,
-0.23808307945728302,
0.48702433705329895,
0.757754385471344,
0.22133290767669678,
-0.10619448870420456,
0.0719192698597908,
0.9909766316413879,
-0.9960001111030579,
0.49015891551971436,
-0.8378299474716187,
0.15970920026302338,
-0.3005885183811188,
-0.24286124110221863,
-0.6219250559806824,
-0.29305317997932434,
-0.03431714326143265,
-0.9348506331443787,
-0.26475921273231506,
0.1783011257648468,
0.3854396939277649,
0.26895588636398315,
-0.4982990622520447,
0.26226407289505005,
-0.5348135232925415,
0.3690924048423767,
-0.3498248755931854,
0.3005244731903076,
0.7204670906066895,
0.7667152285575867,
-0.5695789456367493,
-0.612793505191803,
-0.21321474015712738,
0.20735672116279602,
-0.4525701105594635,
0.2028418481349945,
-0.5044755339622498,
0.15684594213962555,
0.30758410692214966,
-0.30413907766342163,
-0.42447271943092346,
-0.07963193953037262,
-0.20761501789093018,
-0.28993192315101624,
0.5504571199417114,
0.18846850097179413,
0.1693110167980194,
-0.5012063980102539,
-0.3431132733821869,
0.09872029721736908,
-0.8958492875099182,
-0.14929862320423126,
0.11358848214149475,
0.6890743970870972,
0.027576357126235962,
0.4407801628112793,
-0.7075359225273132,
0.8064683079719543,
-0.07161274552345276,
-0.5855351090431213,
0.219805046916008,
-0.42049601674079895,
-0.2366131693124771,
0.13257521390914917,
0.8532053232192993,
0.479751318693161,
0.7487719655036926,
-0.1465471386909485,
0.2869223356246948,
-0.17069566249847412,
-0.18130692839622498,
-0.6382361650466919,
-0.5370849967002869,
-0.06415344029664993,
-0.24830253422260284,
-0.31683212518692017,
-0.3528711795806885,
-0.7863109707832336,
-0.5553936958312988,
0.2585211396217346,
0.32279425859451294,
-0.778347909450531,
-0.102892205119133,
-0.19624829292297363,
-0.11092181503772736,
-0.07909513264894485,
0.2018495500087738,
-0.7850026488304138,
0.23270341753959656,
0.4839077293872833,
0.6380643248558044,
0.09805036336183548,
-0.3736197054386139,
-0.6188822388648987,
0.7980027794837952,
-0.3251958191394806,
0.9803107976913452,
-0.5350263714790344,
-0.19248399138450623,
-0.16437944769859314,
-0.1623380035161972,
-0.27518028020858765,
-0.15186049044132233,
0.4427957534790039,
-0.6238209009170532,
-0.1489764302968979,
-0.26776033639907837,
-0.3163411021232605,
-0.25904399156570435,
0.44112151861190796,
-0.562973141670227,
0.810276210308075,
0.3103949725627899,
-1.1759237051010132,
0.6128285527229309,
-0.5816309452056885,
-0.5400204658508301,
0.11649852991104126,
0.0332421213388443,
-0.41502830386161804,
-0.5201333165168762,
0.7278611660003662,
0.4012260138988495,
0.116341732442379,
-0.22876140475273132,
-0.8984659910202026,
-0.14216531813144684,
-0.05066017434000969,
-0.04437298700213432,
0.8106839060783386,
-0.10669096559286118,
0.1240660548210144,
-0.2364286482334137,
-0.6951227188110352,
0.26021096110343933,
0.02317415177822113,
-0.011365440674126148,
-0.4690350592136383,
-0.14281059801578522,
-0.7453900575637817,
0.1873367577791214,
-0.337886244058609,
-0.2962403893470764,
0.42047667503356934,
-0.38899746537208557,
0.011484213173389435,
0.6843854784965515,
0.5114994645118713,
0.6447982788085938,
-0.24514544010162354,
0.5350818634033203,
0.2582191228866577,
0.341685026884079,
-0.08479072898626328,
-0.7878188490867615,
-0.38285931944847107,
-0.24706169962882996,
0.35857489705085754,
0.7746659517288208,
-1.2551844120025635,
0.03034241683781147,
-0.5548123121261597,
-0.34230315685272217,
-0.0732087641954422,
0.28295013308525085,
0.46418023109436035,
0.7039335370063782,
0.5795723795890808,
-0.026640143245458603,
-0.6305293440818787,
-0.9211196303367615,
-0.632063090801239,
-0.33050844073295593,
0.22046403586864471,
0.3607901930809021,
0.5330044031143188,
-0.18341755867004395,
1.3154700994491577,
-0.7510004639625549,
-0.6947674751281738,
-0.49283838272094727,
0.018953176215291023,
0.025081802159547806,
0.489059716463089,
0.6791421175003052,
-0.5533666014671326,
-0.7560594081878662,
-0.041883304715156555,
-0.7478731870651245,
0.05019615963101387,
0.123658686876297,
-0.42147237062454224,
0.1506778448820114,
0.4093099534511566,
-0.5049065351486206,
0.7231118679046631,
0.14383234083652496,
0.018989328294992447,
0.19762030243873596,
0.4680319130420685,
-0.21380551159381866,
-0.9729126691818237,
-0.36571842432022095,
-0.2677648067474365,
-0.5690814852714539,
-0.530453622341156,
-0.21649713814258575,
-0.06541786342859268,
0.2240242063999176,
-0.5685154795646667,
0.5638248920440674,
-0.2882890999317169,
-0.16234351694583893,
-0.031306229531764984,
0.08267973363399506,
-0.05825106427073479,
0.4848189353942871,
-0.022938009351491928,
0.36466705799102783,
0.7275922894477844,
-0.561470091342926,
0.42010095715522766,
0.3706672489643097,
-0.11194907128810883,
0.6303352117538452,
-0.08508186042308807,
0.46952009201049805,
-0.20884166657924652,
0.670774519443512,
-0.6813304424285889,
-0.41777950525283813,
0.6699846982955933,
-0.5478584170341492,
0.24868302047252655,
-1.0787245035171509,
-0.44266510009765625,
-0.289462149143219,
-0.3551556169986725,
0.3926226496696472,
0.31528258323669434,
-0.47401636838912964,
0.7718647122383118,
0.3856061100959778,
-0.02289680205285549,
-0.7864870429039001,
-0.6922842860221863,
-0.12149704247713089,
-0.03669138252735138,
-0.7636104822158813,
0.1297381967306137,
0.2206181138753891,
-0.18572425842285156,
0.4848687946796417,
-0.1661107987165451,
-0.122014120221138,
0.12244565784931183,
0.30198752880096436,
0.08949890732765198,
-0.16603295505046844,
0.23886792361736298,
0.27185672521591187,
-0.7104268074035645,
-0.3570858836174011,
-0.47668737173080444,
0.06601716578006744,
-0.3069497346878052,
-0.299172580242157,
-0.19939161837100983,
0.26225361227989197,
0.20507901906967163,
0.3062531054019928,
0.9973107576370239,
0.5337300300598145,
-0.6126618981361389,
-0.20630505681037903,
-0.21230700612068176,
-0.23366205394268036,
-0.41719117760658264,
0.1590433418750763,
-0.5964433550834656,
-0.6562728881835938,
0.3113643229007721,
-0.16071313619613647,
-0.3470320701599121,
0.3856590986251831,
0.2181384116411209,
-0.18912553787231445,
1.037325382232666,
0.4966259002685547,
0.055240530520677567,
0.1488189548254013,
-0.2164226919412613,
0.24005627632141113,
-0.7839928269386292,
-0.2646467685699463,
-0.09291995316743851,
-0.23521332442760468,
-0.5941158533096313,
-0.0843396931886673,
0.8393748998641968,
0.39151179790496826,
-0.12480250746011734,
0.39044803380966187,
-0.16226355731487274,
0.9659477472305298,
0.6494941711425781,
0.23518089950084686,
0.4773103594779968,
-0.012563488446176052,
-0.3536336421966553,
0.0745466873049736,
-1.0561879873275757,
-0.2077447474002838,
1.1070687770843506,
-0.13045541942119598,
0.7984086871147156,
0.29732927680015564,
0.8144201040267944,
0.050010353326797485,
0.34328392148017883,
-0.8074779510498047,
0.5790303349494934,
-0.024128062650561333,
-0.9690459966659546,
-0.344700425863266,
-0.668910801410675,
-0.8198936581611633,
0.2857820391654968,
-0.4970604181289673,
-1.0847970247268677,
0.11772169172763824,
0.21165940165519714,
-0.5152170658111572,
0.3243243098258972,
-0.8415919542312622,
0.8643231391906738,
0.1905577927827835,
-0.4409506022930145,
0.3265870213508606,
-0.9401436448097229,
0.6196298003196716,
0.0037175181787461042,
0.3705626428127289,
-0.21059077978134155,
0.3098125755786896,
0.7208002805709839,
-0.31233087182044983,
0.9988658428192139,
-0.24465729296207428,
0.6366104483604431,
0.5394753813743591,
0.4603339731693268,
0.7618924975395203,
0.15817825496196747,
-0.06869436800479889,
-0.09075065702199936,
0.24074842035770416,
-0.5082364082336426,
-0.7178714871406555,
0.35706475377082825,
-0.5442781448364258,
-0.6056004762649536,
-0.41392549872398376,
-0.6653552055358887,
-0.6451321840286255,
0.6786791086196899,
0.2602672576904297,
0.19170011579990387,
0.06497550755739212,
0.1667553037405014,
0.23389270901679993,
0.07306252419948578,
0.49453532695770264,
0.15118764340877533,
-0.2148609608411789,
-0.5749611258506775,
0.4752438962459564,
0.2747712731361389,
0.29441356658935547,
0.5080887675285339,
0.5633721947669983,
-0.2662830650806427,
-0.6188728213310242,
-0.4889141321182251,
-0.05720718950033188,
-1.1917943954467773,
-0.7658509612083435,
-0.8293052315711975,
-0.09802404791116714,
-0.7924734950065613,
-0.11636433005332947,
-0.2692866027355194,
-0.7081745862960815,
-0.0818636491894722,
-0.36731553077697754,
0.6968758702278137,
0.4252009093761444,
-0.3617074489593506,
0.35488253831863403,
-1.0613237619400024,
0.4308554232120514,
0.76149582862854,
0.31327536702156067,
-0.3949846625328064,
-0.1637069582939148,
-0.07592486590147018,
-0.17970533668994904,
-0.1585310697555542,
-1.0603164434432983,
0.0695795863866806,
0.207753986120224,
0.5185472965240479,
0.26886245608329773,
0.5752907991409302,
0.7275128960609436,
-0.32566869258880615,
0.36742159724235535,
0.0938626229763031,
-0.7576974034309387,
0.7418408393859863,
-0.5869128108024597,
-0.06477722525596619,
0.9575876593589783,
0.38721197843551636,
-0.11531808972358704,
0.1319884955883026,
-0.5531780123710632,
-0.565800666809082,
0.9841266870498657,
0.34405890107154846,
-0.20711475610733032,
0.130666583776474,
0.30697211623191833,
-0.004310118965804577,
-0.14275433123111725,
-0.9405909180641174,
0.010984500870108604,
-0.15289321541786194,
-0.13157130777835846,
0.5447842478752136,
-0.21089406311511993,
-0.473033607006073,
-0.22182874381542206,
0.838661789894104,
-0.6968958377838135,
0.008715861476957798,
0.009914201684296131,
-0.2360474169254303,
-0.1911497414112091,
0.2964341938495636,
0.10749085247516632,
0.5451458692550659,
-0.41289186477661133,
0.44899657368659973,
0.5293604135513306,
-0.29116395115852356,
0.00871304702013731,
0.007849875837564468,
-0.20076453685760498,
-0.335277259349823,
0.7399935126304626,
0.6403951048851013,
0.10999537259340286,
-0.05755762755870819,
0.7286635637283325,
0.20911474525928497,
0.03813136741518974,
0.01671147719025612,
0.21303214132785797,
0.1179996207356453,
0.19361025094985962,
0.11208965629339218,
0.230024054646492,
-0.05309922248125076,
-0.6347051858901978,
0.2337203174829483,
0.3284047842025757,
-0.46593374013900757,
-0.004502440337091684,
0.2696864902973175,
0.09882207214832306,
-0.015972882509231567,
0.5091279149055481,
-0.5535837411880493,
-0.614065408706665,
0.3640602231025696,
0.6136273741722107,
0.7429662942886353,
-0.014338339678943157,
0.13130278885364532,
0.45841458439826965,
0.5453746914863586,
0.21912020444869995,
-0.08918091654777527,
0.13532985746860504,
-0.9908722639083862,
-0.26655158400535583,
-0.29014086723327637,
-0.3708580732345581,
-0.20449575781822205,
-0.22928386926651,
0.35640209913253784,
-0.48309069871902466,
-0.07150953263044357,
-0.10776280611753464,
-0.20119066536426544,
-0.5036876201629639,
0.07022304087877274,
0.0033547459170222282,
0.8287543058395386,
-0.9375272393226624,
0.9056835770606995,
0.4623783826828003,
-0.41265347599983215,
-0.7789275050163269,
-0.06484319269657135,
0.310953289270401,
-0.955049991607666,
0.7175265550613403,
-0.02930193394422531,
-0.2836219072341919,
-0.02394787035882473,
-0.4402850568294525,
-0.9228049516677856,
1.184640645980835,
0.41050681471824646,
-0.20117543637752533,
0.13857030868530273,
0.13526034355163574,
0.16270588338375092,
-0.39591503143310547,
0.22709308564662933,
0.6644635796546936,
0.6130647659301758,
0.4938740134239197,
-0.7162547707557678,
0.25207197666168213,
0.02458089031279087,
-0.17442871630191803,
0.20196998119354248,
-0.4618209898471832,
0.5209214687347412,
-0.4754753112792969,
-0.2738238275051117,
-0.3681671619415283,
0.46316346526145935,
0.4899751543998718,
0.5738797187805176,
0.6170263290405273,
0.6758074164390564,
0.6946582794189453,
-0.022967133671045303,
1.1324762105941772,
0.17268002033233643,
0.31794577836990356,
1.3426991701126099,
-0.36839377880096436,
0.5577588677406311,
0.19356079399585724,
-0.2856275141239166,
0.6286252737045288,
0.46899327635765076,
0.34194454550743103,
0.8063515424728394,
-0.12669184803962708,
-0.04642762243747711,
-0.6028547286987305,
-0.054864898324012756,
-0.5000958442687988,
0.4684567451477051,
0.3897351026535034,
-0.1567775011062622,
-0.3336354196071625,
-0.3551037013530731,
0.24843423068523407,
-0.4079505205154419,
-0.21630431711673737,
0.9701882600784302,
0.18458960950374603,
-0.5208954215049744,
0.4124123156070709,
-0.20444457232952118,
0.06271468102931976,
-0.39519646763801575,
0.011668603867292404,
-0.19465529918670654,
0.07232057303190231,
-0.578436553478241,
-0.7692636847496033,
0.4107564091682434,
-0.16696080565452576,
-0.13311761617660522,
0.0898500606417656,
1.3599449396133423,
0.024631233885884285,
-0.618669867515564,
0.2934512794017792,
0.6098002791404724,
0.00045201426837593317,
0.07079380750656128,
-0.6034881472587585,
-0.38926422595977783,
-0.14753755927085876,
-0.15862689912319183,
0.402828186750412,
0.4984036386013031,
-0.17669475078582764,
0.6933725476264954,
0.7083010673522949,
-0.2101464569568634,
0.17683742940425873,
0.09030106663703918,
1.0122146606445312,
-0.5153812766075134,
-0.5824690461158752,
-0.981485903263092,
0.2754763066768646,
-0.047338541597127914,
-0.02263120375573635,
0.6441129446029663,
0.3338015377521515,
0.5314221382141113,
0.13290035724639893,
0.9225826859474182,
0.0405450277030468,
0.38021910190582275,
-0.8084955811500549,
0.5269461274147034,
-0.1740563064813614,
0.23618489503860474,
-0.6708367466926575,
-0.8421722650527954,
-0.8279994130134583,
0.42705923318862915,
-0.6481367945671082,
0.14904667437076569,
0.9101420640945435,
0.7886103987693787,
-0.29778173565864563,
0.08621516078710556,
0.24163493514060974,
0.20621289312839508,
0.1410013735294342,
0.9093995094299316,
0.8391900062561035,
-0.38637855648994446,
1.155900478363037,
-0.5245675444602966,
-0.2829388976097107,
-0.34070372581481934,
-1.3608603477478027,
-0.9944607615470886,
-0.12316581606864929,
-0.4732562005519867,
-0.5521352887153625,
0.22308456897735596,
0.6660797595977783,
1.0038328170776367,
-0.6310666799545288,
0.5860604643821716,
-0.22884885966777802,
0.7262266874313354,
-0.21867823600769043,
-0.227565735578537,
0.46047109365463257,
-0.003143155016005039,
-0.23533663153648376,
0.5326072573661804,
0.4224626421928406,
0.06075896695256233,
0.27129605412483215,
0.08289028704166412,
-0.20991291105747223,
-0.15397727489471436,
0.5204979777336121,
0.3435393273830414,
-0.29134300351142883,
-0.6869031190872192,
-0.38531696796417236,
0.13796524703502655,
0.1214381530880928,
0.5598302483558655,
-1.1349081993103027,
0.47743067145347595,
0.8344838619232178,
0.4935379922389984,
0.5660536289215088,
-0.0426645465195179,
0.2525884211063385,
-1.0324060916900635,
0.1273638755083084,
0.33484575152397156,
0.3173558712005615,
0.39336490631103516,
-0.4170047640800476,
0.9660947322845459,
0.6456694602966309,
-0.08849609643220901,
-0.7972175478935242,
0.6658398509025574,
-0.9345442652702332,
-0.30612313747406006,
1.4339910745620728,
-0.2893601059913635,
-0.27847716212272644,
-0.5113728642463684,
0.13489669561386108,
0.2828206419944763,
-0.28032374382019043,
0.33462363481521606,
0.504655659198761,
-0.647244930267334,
-0.35296157002449036,
-0.267155259847641,
0.5454392433166504,
0.02923751063644886,
-0.8773897290229797,
0.002957009943202138,
0.27450379729270935,
0.3674975335597992,
0.16469891369342804,
1.007802963256836,
-0.05884188413619995,
0.215986430644989,
0.19420914351940155,
-0.4621773958206177,
-0.27067244052886963,
-0.5262088179588318,
0.25336095690727234,
0.32703813910484314,
-0.06827294826507568,
-0.1854209154844284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13858v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13858v1 | Distributional reasoning in LLMs: Parallel reasoning processes in multi-hop reasoning | 2024-06-19T21:36:40 | 2024-06-19T21:36:40 | Yuval Shalev, Amir Feder, Ariel Goldstein | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown an impressive ability to perform
tasks believed to require thought processes. When the model does not document
an explicit thought process, it becomes difficult to understand the processes
occurring within its hidden layers and to determine if these processes can be
referred to as reasoning. We introduce a novel and interpretable analysis of
internal multi-hop reasoning processes in LLMs. We demonstrate that the
prediction process for compositional reasoning questions can be modeled using a
simple linear transformation between two semantic category spaces. We show that
during inference, the middle layers of the network generate highly
interpretable embeddings that represent a set of potential intermediate answers
for the multi-hop question. We use statistical analyses to show that a
corresponding subset of tokens is activated in the model's output, implying the
existence of parallel reasoning paths. These observations hold true even when
the model lacks the necessary knowledge to solve the task. Our findings can
help uncover the strategies that LLMs use to solve reasoning tasks, offering
insights into the types of thought processes that can emerge from artificial
intelligence. Finally, we also discuss the implication of cognitive modeling of
these results. | [
-0.32313162088394165,
-0.9583240151405334,
1.0793867111206055,
0.08831015229225159,
-0.08140694350004196,
0.048256415873765945,
-0.19186028838157654,
-0.37790098786354065,
0.15896254777908325,
0.7438403367996216,
-0.9089106917381287,
-0.3802771270275116,
-0.7161427140235901,
0.07113997638225555,
-0.40079957246780396,
0.5018576383590698,
-0.18164807558059692,
0.08059597760438919,
-0.5109490752220154,
-0.1022387221455574,
-0.6179590225219727,
-0.5360794067382812,
-0.5916405916213989,
-0.45843833684921265,
0.5955119132995605,
0.3192957043647766,
0.6961578130722046,
0.5868133306503296,
0.6593272686004639,
0.3361148536205292,
-0.14306636154651642,
0.1984005868434906,
-0.16048915684223175,
0.48232582211494446,
-0.12177965044975281,
-0.9768316149711609,
-0.17966298758983612,
-0.2865934669971466,
0.642742931842804,
1.060308575630188,
-0.06978348642587662,
0.10923482477664948,
-0.0855473130941391,
0.6949560642242432,
-0.4017007052898407,
0.13204070925712585,
-0.6969442367553711,
0.10826121270656586,
-0.3158961832523346,
-0.26376521587371826,
-0.530707061290741,
-0.03466853126883507,
-0.01205152366310358,
-0.3529724180698395,
0.009027627296745777,
0.1062600389122963,
0.04673148691654205,
0.4133606553077698,
-0.5031819343566895,
-0.5280735492706299,
-0.8464184403419495,
0.7451608180999756,
-0.3613589107990265,
0.4106212258338928,
0.2770061790943146,
0.540897786617279,
-0.2647959291934967,
-0.6913890838623047,
-0.547971785068512,
-0.25453659892082214,
-0.027497367933392525,
-0.03327753394842148,
-0.09252529591321945,
0.04745666682720184,
0.2720280587673187,
0.015629185363650322,
-0.5116585493087769,
-0.08044800907373428,
-0.14051397144794464,
-0.04464448615908623,
0.4464693069458008,
0.45247331261634827,
0.2560270428657532,
0.13972994685173035,
-0.4004669785499573,
0.044205255806446075,
-0.5891037583351135,
0.11400644481182098,
0.23233823478221893,
0.17096365988254547,
-0.029800627380609512,
0.8254996538162231,
-0.1198442354798317,
0.5948176980018616,
-0.4251101315021515,
-0.007091749459505081,
0.08512858301401138,
-0.170742928981781,
-0.16258667409420013,
-0.1866663545370102,
0.5335039496421814,
-0.034741900861263275,
0.441066712141037,
-0.12362132221460342,
-0.16483381390571594,
0.15420331060886383,
0.09123113751411438,
-0.40282541513442993,
-0.09347691386938095,
0.529441773891449,
-0.5655739307403564,
-0.08078384399414062,
-0.14619863033294678,
-0.32690414786338806,
-0.4734644889831543,
-0.4574686884880066,
0.1093720942735672,
-0.4346655309200287,
-0.2792460024356842,
0.3562978506088257,
-0.3501562774181366,
0.014685562811791897,
0.5678597092628479,
-0.671578049659729,
0.2883617877960205,
0.8680058121681213,
0.7226148247718811,
-0.1370846927165985,
-0.6318384408950806,
-0.20522715151309967,
0.3570023775100708,
-0.31577789783477783,
1.1538974046707153,
-0.7618380188941956,
-0.05721413344144821,
-0.12362774461507797,
-0.1429966241121292,
-0.2886093556880951,
-0.6764097213745117,
0.41669517755508423,
-0.6496634483337402,
-0.268669456243515,
-0.5022794008255005,
-0.8478866219520569,
0.002063473453745246,
0.4333929419517517,
-0.6140128374099731,
0.7106941938400269,
-0.3834107518196106,
-0.8782104849815369,
0.10084497928619385,
-0.7166873216629028,
-0.07845360040664673,
0.10289732366800308,
-0.25445693731307983,
0.14379632472991943,
0.05358370393514633,
0.2321193814277649,
0.5102971792221069,
-0.3630780875682831,
0.15480242669582367,
-0.7931374311447144,
-0.08603210002183914,
0.6966990828514099,
-0.3642059862613678,
0.8388747572898865,
0.17885912954807281,
-0.09171221405267715,
0.12601032853126526,
-0.5604528188705444,
-0.09369759261608124,
0.19078709185123444,
-0.07688675075769424,
-0.2932848632335663,
0.36935049295425415,
-0.6767742037773132,
0.15321075916290283,
0.18060500919818878,
-0.3640713095664978,
0.27203503251075745,
-0.08691850304603577,
0.4170595109462738,
0.9473828673362732,
0.07589413970708847,
0.6783744096755981,
-0.2833883762359619,
0.4722873270511627,
0.35454294085502625,
0.26658159494400024,
-0.22262972593307495,
-0.8881089687347412,
-0.7534290552139282,
-0.1406404823064804,
-0.2678717076778412,
0.5663517713546753,
-0.6182631254196167,
0.06709831207990646,
-0.027632899582386017,
-0.2175777703523636,
-0.3108672797679901,
0.07703343033790588,
-0.11524627357721329,
0.2584740221500397,
0.2049843966960907,
0.19102686643600464,
-0.4555743634700775,
-0.7349832653999329,
-0.36445626616477966,
-0.04687979072332382,
0.20574520528316498,
0.23118287324905396,
0.6564123034477234,
-0.41434338688850403,
0.7008439898490906,
-0.6208121180534363,
-0.001056369743309915,
-0.35868579149246216,
-0.0047750636003911495,
0.29632315039634705,
0.15250910818576813,
0.027885667979717255,
-0.5464966297149658,
-0.11430555582046509,
-0.09870730340480804,
-1.1748931407928467,
-0.12928809225559235,
-0.2461501806974411,
-0.47374939918518066,
-0.3299676477909088,
0.7173293828964233,
-0.9337753057479858,
0.24273811280727386,
0.3520796000957489,
-0.2791536748409271,
0.7279351353645325,
-0.2002943456172943,
-0.39008623361587524,
-0.8286494612693787,
-0.4891282916069031,
0.01473473384976387,
-0.012391631491482258,
-0.5021415948867798,
0.1382189393043518,
-0.1816733330488205,
0.07544272392988205,
-0.03527318686246872,
0.4993893802165985,
-0.5532462000846863,
-0.4585338830947876,
-0.36281588673591614,
0.09559964388608932,
0.00505485013127327,
0.21446192264556885,
0.09757519513368607,
0.545046865940094,
0.6850157380104065,
-0.4274774193763733,
0.645619809627533,
0.1432618796825409,
-0.32858726382255554,
0.36774885654449463,
-0.4345918297767639,
0.032634660601615906,
-0.37957504391670227,
0.5976606607437134,
-1.0313286781311035,
-0.06051161512732506,
0.19431257247924805,
-0.3191850781440735,
-0.24699023365974426,
-0.0888727605342865,
-0.6349169015884399,
-0.42768317461013794,
0.08044932782649994,
0.46589237451553345,
0.27183791995048523,
-0.40402892231941223,
0.4382111728191376,
0.29081991314888,
0.015881404280662537,
-0.4748372435569763,
-0.7662988901138306,
-0.07122047990560532,
-0.29183411598205566,
-0.8219830393791199,
0.0010730406502261758,
-0.2082894742488861,
-0.5809683203697205,
0.0652361512184143,
0.16878005862236023,
-0.07494750618934631,
0.05153152346611023,
0.15234403312206268,
0.09784775972366333,
-0.3416195511817932,
0.3632950484752655,
0.13363464176654816,
-0.024473462253808975,
0.5131341218948364,
-0.5543604493141174,
0.4899088740348816,
-0.15031865239143372,
-0.882321834564209,
-0.3649449050426483,
0.4562717080116272,
0.6979675889015198,
-0.19314917922019958,
0.867847740650177,
0.37415918707847595,
-0.36632469296455383,
-0.6844446659088135,
-0.3270326852798462,
-0.3265102803707123,
-0.4130736291408539,
0.08141523599624634,
-0.7020232677459717,
-0.6993861794471741,
0.8255879878997803,
-0.43533575534820557,
-0.31039729714393616,
0.31764328479766846,
0.7741906046867371,
-0.391425758600235,
1.0373305082321167,
0.2746162712574005,
0.475333571434021,
0.2637447118759155,
-0.43630197644233704,
0.2754547595977783,
-0.7460759878158569,
-0.5622460246086121,
-0.31241387128829956,
-0.2638201117515564,
-0.5338442921638489,
-0.7804895639419556,
0.5076377391815186,
0.21616309881210327,
-0.33319810032844543,
0.013657699339091778,
-0.2536791265010834,
0.5848899483680725,
0.6086199283599854,
0.13773202896118164,
0.31754598021507263,
-0.11253596842288971,
-0.4445245862007141,
0.2392004132270813,
-0.5871986746788025,
-0.49545833468437195,
1.0199562311172485,
0.4518873393535614,
0.7010522484779358,
0.05645468831062317,
0.7741211652755737,
0.2136297971010208,
0.16187171638011932,
-0.7123261094093323,
0.6436994671821594,
0.02960774675011635,
-0.5514535307884216,
-0.3670194745063782,
-0.40941107273101807,
-0.7886324524879456,
0.5207163691520691,
-0.09797494113445282,
-0.8710924386978149,
0.05777652561664581,
-0.1979946494102478,
-0.07956565171480179,
0.6017954349517822,
-0.6781412363052368,
0.622861385345459,
-0.2594756484031677,
-0.04891432821750641,
-0.3469287157058716,
-0.6269308924674988,
0.5924351811408997,
0.06830379366874695,
0.36126017570495605,
-0.3222682774066925,
0.1387460082769394,
0.47203442454338074,
-0.3690829873085022,
0.9005603194236755,
-0.1303691864013672,
-0.004094099625945091,
0.4777046740055084,
0.23623934388160706,
0.5419657826423645,
-0.060391392558813095,
-0.10412043333053589,
0.18590612709522247,
-0.000642390747088939,
-0.3473382592201233,
-0.8491215705871582,
0.46434012055397034,
-0.7810582518577576,
-0.6713979840278625,
-0.2420070320367813,
-0.843009889125824,
-0.3508695662021637,
-0.08192355185747147,
-0.08882097899913788,
0.17082354426383972,
0.234649658203125,
-0.037394870072603226,
0.5780752897262573,
-0.12638677656650543,
0.27521640062332153,
-0.09745750576257706,
-0.30567121505737305,
-0.19307799637317657,
0.49355265498161316,
0.0686955377459526,
0.2336532324552536,
0.5820420980453491,
0.5161696672439575,
-0.5337678790092468,
-0.6304423809051514,
-0.43292874097824097,
0.45841461420059204,
-1.1674585342407227,
0.14223773777484894,
-0.6624202728271484,
-0.23219160735607147,
-0.23213647305965424,
0.03429681807756424,
-0.20548869669437408,
-0.43081024289131165,
-0.21038863062858582,
-0.08744198828935623,
-0.03937969356775284,
1.0578222274780273,
0.0858864113688469,
0.1936231255531311,
-0.8488085865974426,
0.19892831146717072,
0.389040470123291,
0.0917939692735672,
0.24006317555904388,
-0.3574802875518799,
-0.20259757339954376,
0.10473894327878952,
-0.3086415231227875,
-1.020279049873352,
0.18724992871284485,
-0.07448539137840271,
0.8333470821380615,
0.48286959528923035,
-0.11277268081903458,
0.5622661113739014,
-0.5383257269859314,
0.6205279231071472,
0.09235865622758865,
-0.760830283164978,
0.5612277984619141,
-0.31288856267929077,
0.05237855762243271,
-0.03477548062801361,
0.4592767059803009,
-0.2965046465396881,
-0.43147769570350647,
-0.3939468264579773,
-0.47190263867378235,
0.43945056200027466,
0.1591942459344864,
-0.007879000157117844,
-0.12840674817562103,
0.2558806836605072,
0.15683872997760773,
0.027273306623101234,
-0.7035292387008667,
-0.22996297478675842,
0.10000640898942947,
-0.007538968697190285,
0.03274490311741829,
-0.3164377212524414,
-0.242442786693573,
-0.3425544798374176,
0.23190335929393768,
-0.15199802815914154,
0.4650617241859436,
-0.008656450547277927,
0.01316798385232687,
0.024588968604803085,
0.1806579828262329,
0.5274909138679504,
0.7117248177528381,
-0.13863015174865723,
0.5446156859397888,
-0.07361751049757004,
0.08020373433828354,
0.17390143871307373,
-0.20033718645572662,
0.23024269938468933,
-0.24864442646503448,
0.6181939244270325,
0.8189355134963989,
-0.19204355776309967,
-0.5545857548713684,
0.5056813359260559,
0.013845589943230152,
-0.15853863954544067,
-0.5259639024734497,
-0.07978412508964539,
0.4494524598121643,
0.817045271396637,
0.2004237174987793,
0.2483985275030136,
0.21673429012298584,
-0.6112661957740784,
0.06210814788937569,
0.45311522483825684,
-0.017455313354730606,
-0.40265825390815735,
0.622045636177063,
-0.05536992847919464,
-0.2433886080980301,
0.701869785785675,
-0.12355214357376099,
-0.41445615887641907,
0.6368803381919861,
0.7040790319442749,
0.9344712495803833,
0.029514441266655922,
0.3516012728214264,
-0.01018064096570015,
0.4002686142921448,
-0.05011819303035736,
0.2639448940753937,
-0.2165095955133438,
-1.1828049421310425,
-0.6125624775886536,
-0.7007814049720764,
-0.4837305545806885,
-0.06102988123893738,
-0.3169068694114685,
-0.022153206169605255,
-0.29190847277641296,
0.014538212679326534,
0.23963609337806702,
-0.5901776552200317,
-0.5484070181846619,
0.011413391679525375,
0.5497687458992004,
0.8439878821372986,
-1.0802638530731201,
0.8278522491455078,
0.7069489359855652,
-0.24534785747528076,
-0.6999951601028442,
0.17370888590812683,
-0.13937531411647797,
-1.0273642539978027,
0.9840320944786072,
0.17306570708751678,
-0.19325359165668488,
-0.29697996377944946,
-0.44823625683784485,
-0.9728631973266602,
0.9231076836585999,
0.5948878526687622,
-0.21671462059020996,
-0.14740023016929626,
0.5772809982299805,
0.4941241145133972,
-0.5707525610923767,
0.4442738890647888,
0.4841637909412384,
0.25364410877227783,
0.3716469705104828,
-0.5483691096305847,
0.05972087383270264,
0.036207616329193115,
-0.001282188924960792,
0.06115490943193436,
-0.3866218328475952,
1.2592699527740479,
-0.33420464396476746,
0.005868410691618919,
-0.23391588032245636,
0.4522484838962555,
0.664314329624176,
0.554458498954773,
0.47873154282569885,
0.7345006465911865,
0.9014268517494202,
0.12813697755336761,
1.208787441253662,
-0.0977630466222763,
0.19725781679153442,
0.8549931645393372,
-0.4673445224761963,
0.9137187600135803,
0.55544114112854,
-0.30662477016448975,
0.9202378392219543,
0.5848996043205261,
0.47555506229400635,
0.43669232726097107,
0.2997024357318878,
-0.39534056186676025,
-0.5901457071304321,
0.016575748100876808,
-0.04445546120405197,
0.5459268689155579,
0.6061147451400757,
-0.2792186141014099,
-0.10843450576066971,
-0.007612086366862059,
-0.4158686697483063,
-0.0984959527850151,
-0.2816128134727478,
0.6558477282524109,
0.33538272976875305,
-0.7373825311660767,
0.291716068983078,
-0.10763299465179443,
0.22627940773963928,
-0.31400066614151,
-0.07662883400917053,
-0.1582288295030594,
0.3417215645313263,
-0.13929371535778046,
-1.1648342609405518,
0.5704143047332764,
-0.29546642303466797,
-0.24221590161323547,
-0.44622603058815,
0.7442986369132996,
-0.16245760023593903,
-0.5414286851882935,
0.615604817867279,
1.0224354267120361,
0.3594503700733185,
-0.2631124258041382,
-0.7807225584983826,
-0.129323810338974,
-0.19324693083763123,
-0.3380542993545532,
0.30298852920532227,
0.9255892634391785,
-0.37350913882255554,
0.9739396572113037,
0.830923318862915,
0.24881359934806824,
0.5057588219642639,
0.4591950476169586,
0.7859359383583069,
-0.6379989385604858,
-0.5193209648132324,
-1.0400505065917969,
0.40446367859840393,
0.03198891133069992,
0.12832298874855042,
0.5808885097503662,
0.2529982924461365,
0.7904316186904907,
-0.006824452430009842,
0.8377894163131714,
0.3710726499557495,
0.4084467589855194,
-0.7063990235328674,
0.1953710913658142,
-0.42348724603652954,
0.570828914642334,
0.015177995897829533,
-0.809628963470459,
-0.2158176749944687,
0.31152108311653137,
-0.5272234082221985,
-0.10346616059541702,
1.1328680515289307,
0.6123889684677124,
-0.14346450567245483,
0.29023098945617676,
0.4829629063606262,
0.11799121648073196,
0.21240541338920593,
0.6285343766212463,
1.3963745832443237,
0.014720206148922443,
0.41674086451530457,
-0.34862104058265686,
-0.10244473814964294,
0.14617983996868134,
-0.7409005165100098,
-0.8401012420654297,
-0.614864706993103,
-0.03452218323945999,
-0.19441534578800201,
-0.16611067950725555,
0.6638368964195251,
0.5959051251411438,
-0.6293452382087708,
-0.46459701657295227,
-0.5417366623878479,
0.4310561418533325,
-0.2578931152820587,
-0.21502596139907837,
0.17105241119861603,
-0.5404050946235657,
-0.3456069827079773,
0.4453778564929962,
0.33125314116477966,
-0.15563346445560455,
-0.32879796624183655,
-0.009537998586893082,
-0.14933262765407562,
0.24486736953258514,
0.6127418875694275,
-0.28147733211517334,
-0.960737407207489,
-0.0848633199930191,
0.09659984707832336,
0.17478793859481812,
0.04945451393723488,
1.0340144634246826,
-0.48683419823646545,
0.4106633961200714,
0.6512525677680969,
0.6546455025672913,
0.5546348094940186,
-0.0830737054347992,
0.3027186989784241,
-0.6180489659309387,
0.10743294656276703,
0.21449004113674164,
0.695425808429718,
0.12322456389665604,
-0.2723938822746277,
0.2297443300485611,
0.5063015818595886,
-0.6196967363357544,
-0.7202073931694031,
0.6263652443885803,
-0.7957793474197388,
-0.5483239889144897,
1.3637888431549072,
-0.12802764773368835,
-0.2951381504535675,
-0.040218643844127655,
0.0757305845618248,
0.1586262732744217,
0.02445315569639206,
0.4988638758659363,
0.6883839964866638,
-0.6719965934753418,
-0.4182797074317932,
-0.6586951017379761,
0.15222598612308502,
0.2712227702140808,
-0.9185965657234192,
0.09910959005355835,
0.30570006370544434,
0.19402997195720673,
0.09933467954397202,
0.8294622898101807,
0.1597823053598404,
-0.15194642543792725,
0.18113449215888977,
-0.17396332323551178,
0.10540826618671417,
-0.43118977546691895,
-0.18717654049396515,
0.3844571113586426,
0.1649097502231598,
-0.276258647441864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13846v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13846v1 | Text Serialization and Their Relationship with the Conventional Paradigms of Tabular Machine Learning | 2024-06-19T21:19:37 | 2024-06-19T21:19:37 | Kyoka Ono, Simon A. Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent research has explored how Language Models (LMs) can be used for
feature representation and prediction in tabular machine learning tasks. This
involves employing text serialization and supervised fine-tuning (SFT)
techniques. Despite the simplicity of these techniques, significant gaps remain
in our understanding of the applicability and reliability of LMs in this
context. Our study assesses how emerging LM technologies compare with
traditional paradigms in tabular machine learning and evaluates the feasibility
of adopting similar approaches with these advanced technologies. At the data
level, we investigate various methods of data representation and curation of
serialized tabular data, exploring their impact on prediction performance. At
the classification level, we examine whether text serialization combined with
LMs enhances performance on tabular datasets (e.g. class imbalance,
distribution shift, biases, and high dimensionality), and assess whether this
method represents a state-of-the-art (SOTA) approach for addressing tabular
machine learning challenges. Our findings reveal current pre-trained models
should not replace conventional approaches. | [
-0.18003211915493011,
-1.049678087234497,
0.47815847396850586,
-0.07271870970726013,
-0.13585248589515686,
0.23951315879821777,
-0.2457960546016693,
-0.5606703162193298,
-0.010989612899720669,
0.7334794998168945,
-0.14857247471809387,
-0.5442582964897156,
-0.4681112468242645,
0.06564820557832718,
-0.4580189883708954,
1.0913923978805542,
-0.12556467950344086,
0.26763513684272766,
-0.4836673438549042,
0.11843603849411011,
-0.6222143173217773,
-0.9325303435325623,
-0.45310088992118835,
-0.2255241721868515,
0.34243881702423096,
0.36447060108184814,
0.8224530220031738,
1.037558674812317,
0.7885507941246033,
0.25554054975509644,
0.0994306355714798,
0.22487959265708923,
-0.2845386266708374,
0.2522481381893158,
0.2111200988292694,
-0.6263861060142517,
-0.722775399684906,
-0.0660463348031044,
0.6220049858093262,
0.8128557801246643,
-0.0935397669672966,
0.25089457631111145,
0.13232369720935822,
0.6086334586143494,
-0.3171190917491913,
0.2788829803466797,
-0.8653154373168945,
0.33687591552734375,
-0.4191778004169464,
-0.5137857794761658,
-0.6625539660453796,
-0.5020658373832703,
-0.010661270469427109,
-0.5198514461517334,
0.25922197103500366,
0.20934298634529114,
0.572279155254364,
0.30435919761657715,
-0.21985727548599243,
-0.24884897470474243,
-1.1084222793579102,
0.6769720911979675,
-0.5923774838447571,
0.5483025908470154,
0.4803113043308258,
0.3908248543739319,
-0.15937365591526031,
-0.8760175108909607,
-0.227488175034523,
-0.3122217357158661,
-0.31679633259773254,
-0.1894141584634781,
0.16052664816379547,
0.09348997473716736,
0.33149951696395874,
0.2379271239042282,
-0.7728346586227417,
0.4947514533996582,
-0.4424847960472107,
0.15647631883621216,
0.42179781198501587,
0.45268434286117554,
0.22729136049747467,
0.05075279623270035,
-0.3421139121055603,
0.02835746854543686,
-0.5195039510726929,
0.36244237422943115,
0.03476794809103012,
0.6305596828460693,
0.28092435002326965,
0.25224724411964417,
-0.011141065508127213,
0.8845463395118713,
-0.09080556780099869,
-0.17303338646888733,
0.03800079599022865,
-0.2522607743740082,
-0.4496150314807892,
0.012904874049127102,
0.7818761467933655,
0.22174601256847382,
-0.022366879507899284,
-0.42688801884651184,
-0.24657326936721802,
0.009971718303859234,
0.5192747712135315,
-0.8821360468864441,
-0.08467834442853928,
0.19128906726837158,
-0.6599752902984619,
-0.45934152603149414,
0.15354010462760925,
-0.7835920453071594,
-0.5539559721946716,
-0.4402083158493042,
0.4699685573577881,
-0.14385393261909485,
0.08192653208971024,
-0.056032925844192505,
0.0564553365111351,
-0.2733572721481323,
0.3134419620037079,
-1.22734534740448,
0.41673874855041504,
0.749356210231781,
0.6183006167411804,
-0.3330608010292053,
-0.21491681039333344,
-0.3408515453338623,
-0.016499046236276627,
-0.5842970609664917,
0.7965231537818909,
-0.6844671368598938,
-0.21514353156089783,
0.12231670320034027,
0.05651122331619263,
-0.012226708233356476,
-0.7864618301391602,
0.5429807305335999,
-0.43937429785728455,
-0.2793971598148346,
-0.041761551052331924,
-0.5688870549201965,
-0.1552983820438385,
0.1280614137649536,
-0.8362583518028259,
1.1025502681732178,
0.038912344723939896,
-0.6118118166923523,
0.8109102249145508,
-0.3307844400405884,
-0.4057292938232422,
0.17341135442256927,
-0.288387656211853,
-1.058237910270691,
0.09681390970945358,
0.024745043367147446,
1.021295428276062,
-0.2736038863658905,
0.4040236175060272,
-0.38620027899742126,
-0.5787515044212341,
0.35020339488983154,
-0.2073393315076828,
-0.015373813919723034,
0.38283804059028625,
-0.11063121259212494,
0.07177524268627167,
-0.8880384564399719,
0.035093192011117935,
-0.08591633290052414,
-0.36005547642707825,
-0.04299125075340271,
0.3212904930114746,
0.19006454944610596,
0.015844669193029404,
0.19613763689994812,
-0.21669580042362213,
0.3884239196777344,
-0.14537881314754486,
0.43918418884277344,
0.37984246015548706,
-0.2569464147090912,
0.659903883934021,
-0.262584924697876,
0.5765188336372375,
0.19195549190044403,
0.06092741712927818,
-0.20996271073818207,
-0.15972056984901428,
-0.39333751797676086,
-0.014780472964048386,
0.520643413066864,
0.5864899754524231,
-0.48850709199905396,
0.12090151757001877,
-0.3757186532020569,
-0.7207193970680237,
-0.2816413342952728,
0.0345899760723114,
0.18465067446231842,
0.2235361933708191,
0.5139440894126892,
-0.03878951072692871,
-0.9150403738021851,
-0.7647615671157837,
-0.3899463415145874,
0.1720111221075058,
0.2512250542640686,
0.11386052519083023,
0.22200609743595123,
-0.331032395362854,
0.9262253642082214,
-0.1273258477449417,
-0.2625678777694702,
-0.5281299948692322,
0.3287634551525116,
0.0477508120238781,
0.5900925993919373,
0.4958648681640625,
-0.861174464225769,
-0.6251568794250488,
0.5668061971664429,
-0.8525413870811462,
0.29686760902404785,
-0.1482411026954651,
0.45386388897895813,
0.5740747451782227,
0.6992791891098022,
-0.21785962581634521,
0.8641195297241211,
0.24866433441638947,
-0.14731870591640472,
0.4509694278240204,
-0.16456636786460876,
0.3538144528865814,
-0.8634588718414307,
-0.047208547592163086,
-0.09391098469495773,
-0.26225918531417847,
-1.1794747114181519,
-0.1993689090013504,
0.22102192044258118,
-0.22222816944122314,
-0.09537679702043533,
0.18504640460014343,
-0.3259682059288025,
-0.29326769709587097,
-0.32644152641296387,
-0.22060295939445496,
-0.15720424056053162,
0.19992049038410187,
0.22380070388317108,
0.8491789102554321,
0.2413954883813858,
-0.6135995388031006,
0.001201025559566915,
0.005490812007337809,
-0.25358933210372925,
0.0981719046831131,
-0.44097280502319336,
-0.1644582897424698,
-0.269508421421051,
0.1616586297750473,
-0.7964708805084229,
-0.032997600734233856,
-0.18825127184391022,
-0.6033969521522522,
0.5660199522972107,
-0.000453262502560392,
-0.4255862534046173,
-0.3447098135948181,
-0.20542818307876587,
0.20851436257362366,
0.3290267288684845,
-0.13526111841201782,
0.4819706082344055,
0.37092894315719604,
-0.06181805580854416,
-0.746830940246582,
-0.7949182391166687,
-0.08621960133314133,
-0.33311885595321655,
-0.31241539120674133,
0.4230651259422302,
0.2753898799419403,
0.04336739704012871,
-0.1363912671804428,
-0.0905139222741127,
-0.08835382014513016,
0.42002207040786743,
0.3961013853549957,
0.1792789250612259,
-0.2786766290664673,
0.35097357630729675,
-0.0687604621052742,
-0.10177744925022125,
-0.26455408334732056,
-0.2720320522785187,
0.7288001179695129,
-0.07334136217832565,
0.20177847146987915,
-0.4115416407585144,
0.02381478063762188,
0.30799439549446106,
-0.27812084555625916,
1.1537383794784546,
0.7978248000144958,
-0.609309732913971,
-0.29420167207717896,
-0.4504842162132263,
-0.21977835893630981,
-0.4101147949695587,
0.5388506054878235,
-0.5799269676208496,
-0.8737666010856628,
0.604953944683075,
-0.09848766028881073,
-0.013624819926917553,
0.0660763755440712,
0.4150635898113251,
-0.3986756205558777,
0.9204531908035278,
0.7443333268165588,
-0.006199001334607601,
0.5566481351852417,
-0.3741356134414673,
0.41520485281944275,
-0.3614042103290558,
-0.24683864414691925,
-0.9281681776046753,
-0.30927401781082153,
-0.8933941721916199,
-0.16933685541152954,
0.22442303597927094,
0.35156163573265076,
-0.11317941546440125,
0.41927263140678406,
-0.38625022768974304,
0.2807702124118805,
0.3797852694988251,
0.026210736483335495,
0.35048145055770874,
0.18529535830020905,
0.16835170984268188,
-0.1802864372730255,
-0.6860421895980835,
-0.8807849287986755,
1.2308135032653809,
0.5459175109863281,
0.6618670225143433,
-0.411682665348053,
0.6682471632957458,
0.46108388900756836,
0.23969243466854095,
-0.5938654541969299,
0.3643137514591217,
-0.5349376201629639,
-0.41359665989875793,
-0.47054174542427063,
-0.4813551604747772,
-1.147823691368103,
0.10262518376111984,
-0.5216681361198425,
-0.8805540800094604,
-0.0020751620177179575,
0.2631551921367645,
-0.33968499302864075,
0.4285835027694702,
-0.6682642698287964,
1.137805461883545,
-0.025257445871829987,
-0.4313839077949524,
0.15050829946994781,
-0.4215953052043915,
-0.032627228647470474,
-0.17318208515644073,
0.34292998909950256,
0.2819283604621887,
0.14456890523433685,
0.8713053464889526,
-0.2698969542980194,
0.6261611580848694,
-0.14647693932056427,
0.01898515596985817,
0.1281159222126007,
0.1365240067243576,
0.37917399406433105,
-0.05460777133703232,
-0.15547887980937958,
-0.061555758118629456,
0.4621254503726959,
-0.1768401861190796,
-0.8378532528877258,
0.4388889968395233,
-0.7414349317550659,
-0.446285218000412,
-0.1788790374994278,
-0.4692593812942505,
-0.3415222465991974,
0.09156323224306107,
0.14179666340351105,
0.6012201309204102,
-0.13044320046901703,
0.4925239384174347,
0.6572641730308533,
-0.07081413269042969,
0.3886713683605194,
0.16155031323432922,
-0.5340117812156677,
-0.419668972492218,
1.0735211372375488,
0.6018502712249756,
-0.001972756115719676,
0.6862215399742126,
-0.0062094018794596195,
-0.12223713845014572,
-0.9908133149147034,
-0.46986401081085205,
-0.26211148500442505,
-0.4308769702911377,
-0.36562439799308777,
-0.6725324392318726,
-0.17601381242275238,
-0.4444912075996399,
-0.11203331500291824,
-0.19184398651123047,
-0.45721426606178284,
-0.4124135673046112,
-0.30720630288124084,
0.34406113624572754,
0.8564758896827698,
0.39648810029029846,
0.4828898310661316,
-0.8995741009712219,
0.2169264405965805,
-0.11990775167942047,
0.3626319468021393,
0.025681940838694572,
-0.3690248727798462,
-0.658052384853363,
-0.06403040885925293,
-0.362935334444046,
-0.8189981579780579,
0.32889699935913086,
-0.05186986178159714,
0.3730233311653137,
0.1247805655002594,
-0.28502020239830017,
0.5718149542808533,
-0.6147940158843994,
0.7161230444908142,
-0.17194226384162903,
-0.5086286664009094,
0.3611766993999481,
-0.4677138328552246,
-0.10913354903459549,
0.5581918358802795,
0.5392797589302063,
-0.46452951431274414,
-0.20552514493465424,
-0.31111183762550354,
-0.455218106508255,
0.7747763991355896,
-0.2588527202606201,
-0.2479293942451477,
0.39747703075408936,
0.3922664225101471,
0.6579985618591309,
0.4183599054813385,
-0.8803941011428833,
-0.24142393469810486,
-0.05847151577472687,
-0.4371403157711029,
-0.3165448009967804,
-0.1981542557477951,
0.5519905686378479,
-0.2455868273973465,
0.5014917254447937,
0.003217019373551011,
0.2568759322166443,
-0.14207498729228973,
-0.1878998577594757,
-0.08283635228872299,
0.4718705713748932,
0.5254151225090027,
0.7124649882316589,
-0.33432093262672424,
0.03393961861729622,
-0.02202146127820015,
-0.6372116804122925,
0.10963001847267151,
0.11956438422203064,
-0.509588897228241,
-0.02597002685070038,
0.06595882773399353,
1.1107964515686035,
0.12176025658845901,
-0.3792527914047241,
0.05108804255723953,
0.10591671615839005,
-0.21456992626190186,
-0.13476981222629547,
-0.1666404902935028,
-0.03929238021373749,
0.09345065802335739,
0.35894161462783813,
0.15745018422603607,
0.44213399291038513,
-0.7925131916999817,
0.16412502527236938,
0.5206339955329895,
-0.3816000819206238,
-0.19954229891300201,
0.6129586100578308,
-0.25491175055503845,
-0.4047926664352417,
0.04663065820932388,
0.06616967916488647,
-0.4512258768081665,
0.5369173884391785,
0.5990651845932007,
0.4939442276954651,
-0.13596588373184204,
0.3249317705631256,
0.23180748522281647,
0.3541889488697052,
-0.074123315513134,
0.21383565664291382,
-0.10158184915781021,
-0.5266445279121399,
-0.13992322981357574,
-0.872693657875061,
-0.26410573720932007,
0.20968657732009888,
-0.580537736415863,
0.3341400921344757,
-0.49711698293685913,
-0.4597816467285156,
-0.10451673716306686,
0.23028932511806488,
-0.6470585465431213,
0.22509118914604187,
0.18592768907546997,
0.6470898389816284,
-0.7078357338905334,
0.7896462082862854,
0.8231377005577087,
-0.35212603211402893,
-0.8108108043670654,
-0.31373491883277893,
-0.48338964581489563,
-0.21132686734199524,
0.5779744982719421,
0.24222956597805023,
0.2825838625431061,
-0.10616657882928848,
-0.13442815840244293,
-0.5892735719680786,
0.985854983329773,
0.09376337379217148,
-0.5072898268699646,
-0.06806962192058563,
0.7715202569961548,
0.6856560707092285,
-0.18916873633861542,
0.41430723667144775,
0.8943180441856384,
0.3329212963581085,
-0.44297802448272705,
-1.0994027853012085,
-0.1790793091058731,
-0.01910671778023243,
0.3897196650505066,
0.42898300290107727,
-0.35027986764907837,
0.7981951236724854,
0.1743997484445572,
-0.1327512413263321,
-0.0023743161000311375,
0.6978875994682312,
-0.01256994716823101,
0.6847231388092041,
-0.17085890471935272,
0.5391600131988525,
0.6617844104766846,
-0.2888944149017334,
0.5901502966880798,
0.046961113810539246,
0.3046589195728302,
0.9736310243606567,
-0.252594918012619,
1.058376669883728,
0.4062582850456238,
-0.44931766390800476,
0.4125824570655823,
0.7019117474555969,
-0.017165707424283028,
0.3152821958065033,
0.18845921754837036,
0.18882963061332703,
-0.03345871716737747,
0.021302813664078712,
-0.441273957490921,
0.3745368719100952,
0.5295554399490356,
-0.4365754723548889,
-0.03873012587428093,
0.35000890493392944,
-0.13511787354946136,
0.5008179545402527,
-0.5903457999229431,
0.9903275370597839,
-0.15789878368377686,
-0.4831200838088989,
0.5945084691047668,
0.010459305718541145,
0.7212534546852112,
-0.20290051400661469,
-0.020389443263411522,
-0.083210289478302,
0.2472308874130249,
-0.5054608583450317,
-0.415838360786438,
0.10377053171396255,
-0.09766136854887009,
-0.36867842078208923,
-0.34312090277671814,
0.8605011701583862,
-0.4365887939929962,
-0.48702272772789,
-0.10830377042293549,
0.5066199898719788,
0.0704118013381958,
0.2549578547477722,
-0.28241559863090515,
0.26082101464271545,
-0.15581972897052765,
-0.026547614485025406,
0.5358866453170776,
0.44826948642730713,
-0.2548343241214752,
0.7150088548660278,
0.3073624074459076,
0.1840750277042389,
0.3168007731437683,
-0.10897446423768997,
0.6087685227394104,
-0.5562210083007812,
-0.33679482340812683,
-0.9436394572257996,
0.409354031085968,
0.177093505859375,
0.10447550565004349,
0.6091399788856506,
0.6818640828132629,
0.7983431816101074,
-0.4292496144771576,
0.7066871523857117,
0.2983146011829376,
0.7885536551475525,
-0.738682210445404,
0.7877012491226196,
-0.45851558446884155,
0.1131369024515152,
-0.3646191656589508,
-0.8794082999229431,
-0.494313508272171,
0.3918529748916626,
-0.41853049397468567,
0.08595346659421921,
0.7377604842185974,
0.6356673240661621,
0.1252446472644806,
0.368221640586853,
0.40743789076805115,
-0.009431515820324421,
0.16387179493904114,
0.09976768493652344,
0.8967704176902771,
-0.6322675347328186,
0.27829819917678833,
-0.24164767563343048,
-0.05405675619840622,
-0.40793830156326294,
-0.5874350666999817,
-0.9441778063774109,
-0.8775166273117065,
0.0028455746360123158,
0.11292330920696259,
0.19511839747428894,
0.8362888693809509,
0.5505696535110474,
-0.8214831352233887,
-0.3988097310066223,
-0.11846093088388443,
-0.1052229031920433,
-0.18941661715507507,
-0.2290104627609253,
0.36342957615852356,
-0.6342534422874451,
-0.5281795263290405,
0.060500022023916245,
0.1985502988100052,
0.27694520354270935,
-0.12016311287879944,
0.13804255425930023,
0.19700589776039124,
-0.30258283019065857,
0.6452659964561462,
0.13682667911052704,
-0.522707462310791,
0.02323163114488125,
0.30242955684661865,
-0.17909561097621918,
0.24991244077682495,
0.9350209832191467,
-0.9857997298240662,
0.19718077778816223,
0.44705575704574585,
0.9042328596115112,
0.4820682108402252,
0.1655140370130539,
0.4228804111480713,
-0.3908660411834717,
0.1726040244102478,
0.34157127141952515,
0.16077807545661926,
0.06835121661424637,
-0.4974510371685028,
0.31536510586738586,
-0.0922640934586525,
-0.7815979719161987,
-1.2445871829986572,
-0.07800396531820297,
-0.7241218090057373,
-0.1812276691198349,
0.6712713241577148,
0.05536309629678726,
-0.1737470179796219,
-0.08444506675004959,
-0.17411503195762634,
0.2752474546432495,
-0.1860840618610382,
0.6453164219856262,
0.44753313064575195,
-0.11085453629493713,
-0.2101234495639801,
-0.7605376243591309,
0.9633268713951111,
0.3431241810321808,
-0.9928364753723145,
0.22176600992679596,
0.1718098521232605,
-0.21232187747955322,
0.08153730630874634,
0.404086709022522,
-0.0703117698431015,
0.28738903999328613,
-0.14150577783584595,
0.055027663707733154,
-0.11290334910154343,
-0.619287371635437,
-0.2666846513748169,
0.21727611124515533,
0.31300702691078186,
0.12330205738544464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13842v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13842v1 | Joint vs Sequential Speaker-Role Detection and Automatic Speech Recognition for Air-traffic Control | 2024-06-19T21:11:01 | 2024-06-19T21:11:01 | Alexander Blatt, Aravind Krishnan, Dietrich Klakow | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Utilizing air-traffic control (ATC) data for downstream natural-language
processing tasks requires preprocessing steps. Key steps are the transcription
of the data via automatic speech recognition (ASR) and speaker diarization,
respectively speaker role detection (SRD) to divide the transcripts into pilot
and air-traffic controller (ATCO) transcripts. While traditional approaches
take on these tasks separately, we propose a transformer-based joint ASR-SRD
system that solves both tasks jointly while relying on a standard ASR
architecture. We compare this joint system against two cascaded approaches for
ASR and SRD on multiple ATC datasets. Our study shows in which cases our joint
system can outperform the two traditional approaches and in which cases the
other architectures are preferable. We additionally evaluate how acoustic and
lexical differences influence all architectures and show how to overcome them
for our joint architecture. | [
-0.5239980220794678,
-0.4286300539970398,
0.32201066613197327,
0.15854741632938385,
-0.27907389402389526,
0.43412384390830994,
-0.07484617829322815,
-0.46781596541404724,
0.22883372008800507,
0.5087481737136841,
-0.2509465217590332,
-0.09258133918046951,
-0.6041451692581177,
0.17044740915298462,
-0.6121345162391663,
0.4383458197116852,
-0.010105670429766178,
0.07036971300840378,
-0.21076975762844086,
-0.04076379910111427,
-0.5289902687072754,
-0.6918805837631226,
-0.9834262728691101,
-0.4635440409183502,
0.21713311970233917,
0.611349880695343,
0.7820804119110107,
0.5378875136375427,
0.4981847107410431,
0.41706106066703796,
0.019944431260228157,
0.016329895704984665,
0.5153072476387024,
0.18507811427116394,
0.031728822737932205,
0.04761018976569176,
-0.3378480076789856,
-0.24483835697174072,
0.9077174067497253,
0.6920366287231445,
-0.44000399112701416,
-0.25899189710617065,
-0.29003235697746277,
0.5637279748916626,
-0.54513019323349,
0.13986092805862427,
-0.3811556398868561,
-0.1629197597503662,
-0.5201934576034546,
-0.3004060387611389,
-0.339561402797699,
0.12628570199012756,
0.0710950568318367,
-0.46292752027511597,
0.060601744800806046,
0.20137189328670502,
0.6123096942901611,
0.4249546229839325,
-0.8019030094146729,
-0.27155935764312744,
-1.042263388633728,
0.6365790367126465,
-0.3762839734554291,
1.0491398572921753,
0.1077115386724472,
0.5035956501960754,
-0.02239855006337166,
-0.39203447103500366,
-0.8344542384147644,
-0.006003965623676777,
-0.3448944389820099,
0.24238276481628418,
-0.20239569246768951,
0.06985989212989807,
0.06507191807031631,
0.2823735773563385,
-0.8124554753303528,
0.3658479154109955,
-0.5325864553451538,
-0.2209133356809616,
0.6721875071525574,
-0.07990764081478119,
0.39051029086112976,
-0.3163608908653259,
-0.41843175888061523,
-0.353733628988266,
-0.5846799612045288,
0.29345041513442993,
0.28621751070022583,
0.6261400580406189,
-0.07591438293457031,
0.18064558506011963,
-0.16035260260105133,
0.46766889095306396,
0.0007553540635854006,
-0.03924283757805824,
0.18757566809654236,
-0.11471515148878098,
-0.383475661277771,
0.4980161786079407,
0.9248383641242981,
-0.3373573422431946,
0.11977311223745346,
-0.38921862840652466,
-0.4445384740829468,
0.2815709412097931,
0.5685010552406311,
-0.11282163113355637,
-0.047295086085796356,
0.18930716812610626,
-0.5445124506950378,
-0.006022552959620953,
0.5427528023719788,
-0.3511558175086975,
0.14811544120311737,
-0.7932869791984558,
0.5279574990272522,
-0.11668992042541504,
-0.4431799352169037,
0.09965825080871582,
-0.18218255043029785,
0.5912852883338928,
0.2611328661441803,
-0.810029923915863,
0.9554513096809387,
0.7780848145484924,
0.7183554768562317,
-0.4580737352371216,
-0.14569631218910217,
-0.791989803314209,
0.25099629163742065,
-0.19835805892944336,
1.0706617832183838,
-0.5356881022453308,
-0.7848148345947266,
-0.28805413842201233,
-0.03692866116762161,
-0.5141745209693909,
-0.7514355182647705,
0.5848480463027954,
-0.6639633178710938,
0.25456565618515015,
-0.07559125125408173,
-0.14102530479431152,
0.029272116720676422,
-0.34351328015327454,
-0.7413781881332397,
0.6808938980102539,
-0.2791856527328491,
-0.565416157245636,
0.3102431893348694,
-0.7131011486053467,
-0.7667589783668518,
-0.0019646778237074614,
-0.7486532330513,
-0.5340700745582581,
-0.12354917079210281,
0.35980573296546936,
0.17126823961734772,
-0.2070467174053192,
0.2917592227458954,
0.3144405782222748,
-0.5768411755561829,
-0.025703705847263336,
-0.44574296474456787,
0.7822200655937195,
0.3570407032966614,
-0.1665555089712143,
0.20978373289108276,
-0.7036561965942383,
-0.26395827531814575,
-0.17860010266304016,
-0.535857617855072,
-0.18856602907180786,
0.4705435335636139,
0.2619839310646057,
0.09726731479167938,
-0.1981038898229599,
-0.4535349905490875,
-0.15130974352359772,
-0.319038450717926,
0.0899789109826088,
0.6119084358215332,
-0.1364540010690689,
0.4116220474243164,
-0.24595031142234802,
0.4684884250164032,
0.36492785811424255,
0.01277200598269701,
0.22140417993068695,
-0.4814838767051697,
-0.7186568975448608,
-0.07997334748506546,
0.06983422487974167,
0.9090974926948547,
-0.911186933517456,
0.9384814500808716,
-0.36554303765296936,
-0.1594400554895401,
-0.3879144787788391,
-0.2777508497238159,
0.45628631114959717,
0.19184111058712006,
0.4521180987358093,
-0.6623240113258362,
-0.5800389051437378,
-0.7768581509590149,
-0.24091185629367828,
-0.6037341356277466,
-0.12423299252986908,
0.005344011355191469,
0.07846896350383759,
0.1093830019235611,
0.7874804139137268,
-0.16461417078971863,
-0.46587786078453064,
-0.2142540067434311,
0.16970062255859375,
-0.012375034391880035,
0.6546033024787903,
0.23962417244911194,
-1.1422849893569946,
-0.6531638503074646,
0.18758459389209747,
-0.3288475573062897,
-0.15754735469818115,
0.018282093107700348,
0.2891196608543396,
0.23139527440071106,
0.8819281458854675,
-0.7001093626022339,
0.6791790723800659,
0.26735469698905945,
-0.3533805310726166,
0.20169100165367126,
-0.09409163147211075,
0.29479241371154785,
-0.766319990158081,
0.15432517230510712,
-0.35325169563293457,
-0.16170252859592438,
-1.1647052764892578,
-0.2693638503551483,
-0.1725946068763733,
-0.12399701029062271,
-0.23864515125751495,
0.0527908094227314,
-0.4203963875770569,
-0.597242534160614,
-0.36114659905433655,
-0.05570871755480766,
-0.03619309142231941,
0.3458787798881531,
0.44805845618247986,
0.757242739200592,
0.5151682496070862,
-0.47155606746673584,
0.35040605068206787,
0.5625696182250977,
-0.36727991700172424,
0.3140536844730377,
-0.4968957304954529,
0.30510151386260986,
-0.21782194077968597,
0.6200780272483826,
-0.9997168183326721,
-0.10077220946550369,
0.2647506296634674,
-0.5514211654663086,
0.3826146423816681,
-0.28319674730300903,
-0.5318723320960999,
-0.45511487126350403,
0.0759081169962883,
0.5902204513549805,
0.41915300488471985,
-0.5175995230674744,
0.9709686636924744,
0.5013360977172852,
-0.3174225091934204,
-0.40505239367485046,
-0.7517649531364441,
0.0789562538266182,
-0.20433737337589264,
-0.5049223899841309,
0.6008350253105164,
0.4353623688220978,
-0.3550972044467926,
-0.19174917042255402,
-0.49242526292800903,
-0.25124627351760864,
-0.2071792036294937,
0.39877548813819885,
0.37271443009376526,
-0.23663344979286194,
0.024331729859113693,
-0.10845780372619629,
-0.3495684862136841,
-0.00791800208389759,
-0.24062317609786987,
0.4390312731266022,
0.18187421560287476,
-0.649357795715332,
-0.7557991743087769,
0.7709104418754578,
0.7384200692176819,
-0.5183827877044678,
0.6197242140769958,
0.4983741343021393,
-0.18409602344036102,
0.027839796617627144,
-0.7238352298736572,
-0.018255062401294708,
-0.5493404865264893,
-0.19553521275520325,
-0.5303155183792114,
-0.7295029163360596,
0.47559916973114014,
0.31560268998146057,
-0.14231978356838226,
0.3656620979309082,
0.30356740951538086,
0.046386148780584335,
0.7134381532669067,
0.30976876616477966,
-0.5031869411468506,
0.5849782824516296,
0.10324352234601974,
0.44553515315055847,
-0.4832161068916321,
-0.3059614896774292,
-0.9259665608406067,
-0.19683076441287994,
-0.6355060338973999,
-0.3482751250267029,
0.631913959980011,
-0.22635720670223236,
-0.3326944410800934,
0.5229275822639465,
-0.48090383410453796,
0.14746882021427155,
0.606105387210846,
-0.11151677370071411,
0.5835545063018799,
-0.0927945002913475,
0.18537099659442902,
0.4200168251991272,
-0.5079001784324646,
-0.5027281045913696,
0.5342831611633301,
0.21260444819927216,
0.5179386138916016,
0.27584102749824524,
0.6632434725761414,
0.08964957296848297,
-0.2134527713060379,
-0.7774587869644165,
0.5980277061462402,
-0.679894745349884,
-0.37930938601493835,
-0.38552677631378174,
-0.504364550113678,
-0.7424532175064087,
0.25831982493400574,
0.21687844395637512,
-0.5932372212409973,
0.5814338326454163,
0.12535838782787323,
-0.5822291374206543,
0.3581661880016327,
-0.8584335446357727,
0.5454475283622742,
-0.09753739088773727,
0.4278232157230377,
-0.260929137468338,
-1.0778717994689941,
-0.12006454169750214,
0.1275581419467926,
0.28212645649909973,
0.09976409375667572,
0.0871964544057846,
0.9547292590141296,
-0.3029639720916748,
0.4190148711204529,
-0.5202955603599548,
0.03026268631219864,
0.2557164430618286,
-0.1985953003168106,
0.38890767097473145,
-0.11752455681562424,
-0.1330488622188568,
0.039430584758520126,
-0.041801340878009796,
0.00036440195981413126,
-0.5340012311935425,
0.6809102892875671,
-1.0153095722198486,
-0.6334633231163025,
-0.4268520176410675,
-0.17049916088581085,
-0.2554698586463928,
0.05725131556391716,
-0.05248488113284111,
0.6437859535217285,
-0.006670226342976093,
0.20267102122306824,
0.23201292753219604,
-0.19003908336162567,
0.6082409620285034,
0.801790177822113,
0.0884164348244667,
-0.2458546906709671,
0.7156616449356079,
0.09669343382120132,
0.2684187889099121,
0.777692973613739,
-0.036206502467393875,
-0.34042951464653015,
-0.5419376492500305,
-0.2067975550889969,
-0.10516837239265442,
-0.5626189112663269,
-0.197805717587471,
-0.7610903978347778,
-0.6528520584106445,
-0.8385156989097595,
-0.10515976697206497,
-0.40047580003738403,
-0.3631438910961151,
-0.0742105022072792,
0.21352225542068481,
0.05508532002568245,
0.6708385348320007,
-0.06369146704673767,
0.6105595827102661,
-0.6810839176177979,
0.8184686899185181,
0.45361098647117615,
0.25302907824516296,
-0.12574322521686554,
-0.43542712926864624,
-0.11543196439743042,
-0.21584205329418182,
-0.32088786363601685,
-0.4199106991291046,
0.2101392298936844,
0.2306986153125763,
0.5694885849952698,
0.2070372998714447,
0.13838839530944824,
0.8061404824256897,
-0.6888543367385864,
0.6188293695449829,
-0.10130301117897034,
-1.0046021938323975,
0.47395971417427063,
0.03308828920125961,
0.2568356394767761,
0.6066866517066956,
0.1530025601387024,
-0.613348662853241,
-0.3911057710647583,
-0.4274515211582184,
-0.6639124155044556,
1.2391972541809082,
0.48164597153663635,
-0.4565480649471283,
0.18202988803386688,
-0.03327035531401634,
-0.2706184387207031,
0.015158567577600479,
-0.1517123579978943,
-0.0391787588596344,
-0.31083911657333374,
-0.11262297630310059,
-0.17576028406620026,
0.33985379338264465,
0.11112777888774872,
-0.2598089277744293,
0.532806932926178,
0.04304131120443344,
0.504185140132904,
0.28411754965782166,
0.17075766623020172,
-0.41992345452308655,
0.526797354221344,
0.28923237323760986,
0.04437951743602753,
-0.26493269205093384,
0.2344444841146469,
0.12079327553510666,
-0.43608522415161133,
0.2571493685245514,
0.206241637468338,
0.267834335565567,
0.07264111936092377,
0.49177607893943787,
0.8019313812255859,
0.16812151670455933,
-0.4704008400440216,
0.719366192817688,
0.029289130121469498,
0.019380776211619377,
-0.4421287775039673,
0.11179526150226593,
-0.13323521614074707,
0.2139216512441635,
0.47175273299217224,
0.48908841609954834,
0.33209073543548584,
-0.4088912904262543,
0.45516449213027954,
0.27862492203712463,
-0.12084698677062988,
-0.40291228890419006,
0.5114309191703796,
0.2832491397857666,
-0.5035139322280884,
0.5986287593841553,
0.09099532663822174,
-0.6603216528892517,
0.6865946054458618,
0.20184344053268433,
0.9807974696159363,
-0.6946160793304443,
-0.19219611585140228,
-0.10632675141096115,
-0.05110776424407959,
-0.16266725957393646,
0.28224360942840576,
-0.47048065066337585,
-1.0046439170837402,
-0.5431236624717712,
-0.4727666974067688,
-0.5133329033851624,
-0.13482370972633362,
-0.8574544787406921,
0.5508573055267334,
-0.31878986954689026,
0.029606934636831284,
0.21190103888511658,
0.019202448427677155,
-0.47465023398399353,
0.27500948309898376,
0.458605021238327,
0.7465646862983704,
-0.8545200228691101,
1.2874175310134888,
0.7286592721939087,
-0.06388302147388458,
-1.0574226379394531,
0.32985615730285645,
0.21493084728717804,
-0.555639386177063,
0.836056113243103,
0.11440936475992203,
-0.39110544323921204,
-0.018962932750582695,
0.22815340757369995,
-0.5855945944786072,
1.2197952270507812,
-0.012164420448243618,
-0.599768877029419,
-0.3738601803779602,
0.3078351318836212,
0.3745834529399872,
-0.0803176537156105,
0.10706652700901031,
0.6796616315841675,
0.4798167645931244,
0.43499571084976196,
-1.6038132905960083,
-0.3197709321975708,
-0.14941929280757904,
0.013916159979999065,
0.24502992630004883,
-0.6687646508216858,
0.6861155033111572,
0.33200129866600037,
-0.6531815528869629,
-0.25180935859680176,
0.5070250630378723,
0.21283233165740967,
0.3033435344696045,
1.293245792388916,
0.44725796580314636,
0.12324099242687225,
-0.022456904873251915,
0.6662324070930481,
-0.09646590054035187,
-0.1301501989364624,
1.1771811246871948,
-0.47866562008857727,
1.1012752056121826,
0.7411792874336243,
-0.4281335473060608,
0.5436257719993591,
0.028105011209845543,
0.3178896903991699,
0.6778183579444885,
-0.1044299378991127,
-0.46126237511634827,
-0.22468625009059906,
-0.05287514999508858,
-0.06961575150489807,
1.0121694803237915,
0.3142741024494171,
0.059808291494846344,
-0.1998942792415619,
0.1592692732810974,
-0.3827458322048187,
0.04980801045894623,
-0.055260319262742996,
1.097352385520935,
0.20881225168704987,
-0.6594073176383972,
0.18600577116012573,
0.0003383139264769852,
0.5956568121910095,
-0.6709904074668884,
0.23293159902095795,
0.09728430211544037,
0.12049756199121475,
-0.3274240493774414,
-0.543604850769043,
0.8852285146713257,
-0.037267688661813736,
-0.09820912778377533,
-0.7609778046607971,
0.8388581275939941,
-0.46345391869544983,
-0.10306522995233536,
0.4527859389781952,
0.5712611079216003,
-0.01230764389038086,
-0.04859975725412369,
-0.2154766172170639,
0.521260678768158,
-0.22690452635288239,
0.09266629070043564,
-0.10418149083852768,
0.2513456344604492,
-0.1901344507932663,
0.5238300561904907,
0.5035686492919922,
0.39310362935066223,
0.03803408145904541,
0.4168417155742645,
0.9877633452415466,
-0.6053603887557983,
-0.8775143623352051,
-0.48381805419921875,
0.46082890033721924,
0.07731528580188751,
0.2400626838207245,
0.3735140562057495,
0.5831484198570251,
0.8222118020057678,
0.1585981845855713,
0.706841230392456,
-0.23303383588790894,
0.7792697548866272,
-0.49240630865097046,
0.4138015806674957,
-0.426163911819458,
0.60688316822052,
-0.09912741929292679,
-0.6240206360816956,
-0.4512905776500702,
0.6957204937934875,
-0.1961130052804947,
-0.19620764255523682,
0.5033526420593262,
0.947680652141571,
-0.39639994502067566,
0.43697890639305115,
0.1459442675113678,
-0.223894864320755,
0.8114359378814697,
0.3968714773654938,
1.0011632442474365,
-0.6660640835762024,
0.5189507603645325,
-0.1116873174905777,
-0.06970866024494171,
-0.038905370980501175,
-0.3259243965148926,
-0.5135538578033447,
-0.7474440336227417,
-0.4517536461353302,
0.24069775640964508,
0.06941469758749008,
1.1550393104553223,
0.8040829300880432,
-1.2094311714172363,
-0.5845572352409363,
-0.20188653469085693,
-0.09377513825893402,
-0.3381311297416687,
-0.26297181844711304,
0.27443450689315796,
-0.18499808013439178,
-0.5178471803665161,
1.055877923965454,
0.39436277747154236,
0.1475897878408432,
-0.0817476287484169,
-0.19735336303710938,
-0.05081500858068466,
-0.023238807916641235,
0.2276715785264969,
0.20145881175994873,
-0.7843759655952454,
-0.78857421875,
-0.35820508003234863,
0.050501227378845215,
0.17025026679039001,
1.3384147882461548,
-0.8986722826957703,
0.30678316950798035,
0.6823269128799438,
0.45397937297821045,
0.16405129432678223,
0.2386251538991928,
0.6628766059875488,
-0.9707022905349731,
0.2930508255958557,
0.23364491760730743,
0.18892602622509003,
0.23696133494377136,
-0.1623057723045349,
0.16515205800533295,
0.27271679043769836,
-0.7484821677207947,
-0.6489356160163879,
-0.024414824321866035,
-1.35308039188385,
-0.10799170285463333,
0.7408914566040039,
0.034034132957458496,
0.29091542959213257,
-0.6970398426055908,
-0.048810265958309174,
0.43158137798309326,
-0.5308031439781189,
0.3924371004104614,
0.2454846352338791,
-0.3599233627319336,
-0.07905365526676178,
-0.16853775084018707,
0.41048845648765564,
0.06365673989057541,
-0.7128249406814575,
0.11630953848361969,
0.1635865718126297,
-0.11695199459791183,
0.45492878556251526,
0.8682379126548767,
-0.13332787156105042,
0.06168218329548836,
-0.08625032007694244,
-0.1808088719844818,
0.14716821908950806,
-0.7534667253494263,
-0.42632389068603516,
-0.00462577398866415,
-0.14278925955295563,
-0.4059668183326721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13840v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13840v1 | StackRAG Agent: Improving Developer Answers with Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-19T21:07:35 | 2024-06-19T21:07:35 | Davit Abrahamyan, Fatemeh H. Fard | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Developers spend much time finding information that is relevant to their
questions. Stack Overflow has been the leading resource, and with the advent of
Large Language Models (LLMs), generative models such as ChatGPT are used
frequently. However, there is a catch in using each one separately. Searching
for answers is time-consuming and tedious, as shown by the many tools developed
by researchers to address this issue. On the other, using LLMs is not reliable,
as they might produce irrelevant or unreliable answers (i.e., hallucination).
In this work, we present StackRAG, a retrieval-augmented Multiagent generation
tool based on LLMs that combines the two worlds: aggregating the knowledge from
SO to enhance the reliability of the generated answers. Initial evaluations
show that the generated answers are correct, accurate, relevant, and useful. | [
-0.5597207546234131,
-0.7194325923919678,
0.2911739945411682,
0.33198660612106323,
-0.05459533631801605,
0.7189075946807861,
-0.027738161385059357,
-0.5364992022514343,
0.557266891002655,
0.48313337564468384,
-0.2755877375602722,
-0.3125493824481964,
-0.3990289866924286,
0.009403112344443798,
-0.4147154688835144,
1.3500521183013916,
0.25201237201690674,
-0.3917480707168579,
-0.32785123586654663,
0.019087351858615875,
-0.5101402401924133,
-0.4717997908592224,
-0.7833350896835327,
-0.16401468217372894,
0.4690232574939728,
0.4694540500640869,
0.78717041015625,
0.3361527621746063,
0.4122299253940582,
0.33462926745414734,
-0.10000531375408173,
0.34547263383865356,
-0.6442747116088867,
0.7120058536529541,
0.046630859375,
-0.2018934190273285,
-0.5837361216545105,
-0.3983120322227478,
0.11184436827898026,
0.29010671377182007,
-0.5330515503883362,
0.41505688428878784,
-0.1343047022819519,
0.2253028154373169,
-0.8117730021476746,
-0.12880071997642517,
-0.7573617100715637,
-0.10129470378160477,
-0.08732695132493973,
-0.5798072218894958,
-0.31999287009239197,
-0.47630906105041504,
-0.1764334887266159,
-0.6146427989006042,
0.34082138538360596,
-0.0870722159743309,
0.46611183881759644,
0.5106523036956787,
-0.21999327838420868,
-0.7080687880516052,
-0.7392852306365967,
0.6558787226676941,
-0.47101372480392456,
0.08556310832500458,
0.16869886219501495,
0.3817703127861023,
-0.32699793577194214,
-0.6984499096870422,
-0.6371593475341797,
-0.30476534366607666,
0.008207458071410656,
0.36500152945518494,
-0.1942422240972519,
-0.24963043630123138,
0.1539984941482544,
0.09960214793682098,
-0.7121552228927612,
0.16513632237911224,
-0.6320159435272217,
-0.28366243839263916,
0.7408853769302368,
0.23040078580379486,
0.5168703198432922,
-0.14628776907920837,
-0.4460279047489166,
-0.015265649184584618,
-0.8013404011726379,
-0.139560729265213,
0.411695271730423,
0.08143308758735657,
0.3500071167945862,
0.7001413106918335,
-0.056038714945316315,
0.7487340569496155,
0.12768450379371643,
-0.12603285908699036,
0.2598015069961548,
-0.25402161478996277,
0.2834474742412567,
0.1334659904241562,
0.6200480461120605,
0.23217883706092834,
-0.032449301332235336,
-0.45791926980018616,
-0.14572912454605103,
0.15234237909317017,
0.6204016208648682,
-0.9815410375595093,
-0.19013170897960663,
0.7894672751426697,
-0.08407778292894363,
-0.4851495921611786,
-0.017684245482087135,
-0.9009896516799927,
-0.5406638979911804,
0.32277360558509827,
0.05483260750770569,
-0.3216182291507721,
-0.6614928841590881,
-0.09675697982311249,
-0.4317321479320526,
0.31421786546707153,
0.21515977382659912,
-0.6481675505638123,
0.11211583763360977,
0.629061222076416,
0.7245922088623047,
-0.1568233072757721,
-0.4397483170032501,
-1.0840657949447632,
0.17139717936515808,
-0.3641694486141205,
1.184929370880127,
-0.5727829337120056,
-0.6809574961662292,
-0.032874610275030136,
-0.5234240889549255,
0.27275529503822327,
-0.7345983982086182,
0.41757720708847046,
-0.9344618320465088,
0.38003870844841003,
0.04804552346467972,
-0.36164870858192444,
0.12801796197891235,
0.49182331562042236,
-0.5392929911613464,
1.2987240552902222,
-0.03099795989692211,
-0.59562748670578,
0.2257259488105774,
-0.6347163319587708,
-0.2642471194267273,
0.5266323685646057,
-0.14463242888450623,
-0.30474570393562317,
-0.022029023617506027,
0.24809539318084717,
0.37454432249069214,
-0.20233194530010223,
0.1265154480934143,
-0.14650416374206543,
-0.32102498412132263,
0.2075158953666687,
-0.07162414491176605,
0.5843583941459656,
0.3025449812412262,
-0.16080547869205475,
0.023976100608706474,
-0.6839746832847595,
0.40137621760368347,
-0.03011435829102993,
-0.5104696154594421,
-0.07283921539783478,
0.053245436400175095,
-0.1018047034740448,
0.4487873911857605,
0.3408963680267334,
-0.4970846176147461,
0.1266709566116333,
-0.13678033649921417,
-0.0226515494287014,
0.570315957069397,
0.07173564285039902,
0.24194300174713135,
-0.41114795207977295,
1.2066665887832642,
-0.051177430897951126,
-0.3224569261074066,
-0.2111556977033615,
-0.5080737471580505,
-0.36462733149528503,
-0.06861212849617004,
0.03882142901420593,
0.6307098865509033,
-1.130681037902832,
0.30841776728630066,
-0.42185646295547485,
-0.8748087286949158,
-0.5121040940284729,
0.35277828574180603,
0.5250768661499023,
0.3605365753173828,
0.3253714442253113,
-0.22278645634651184,
-0.5367027521133423,
-0.3578941524028778,
-0.20444564521312714,
-0.377157598733902,
-0.12415537238121033,
0.3030041754245758,
0.3555770814418793,
-0.4038969576358795,
0.8969923853874207,
-0.6785123944282532,
0.14096121490001678,
-0.27966704964637756,
0.21480867266654968,
0.07175755500793457,
0.05031701922416687,
0.641360878944397,
-0.826745331287384,
-0.43459251523017883,
0.08663483709096909,
-0.740060031414032,
-0.3852675259113312,
0.2512432634830475,
-0.08211833238601685,
0.038829755038022995,
0.4734185039997101,
-0.8240547180175781,
0.03859245404601097,
0.7867977023124695,
-0.22307492792606354,
0.8828244805335999,
-0.06339756399393082,
0.024328449741005898,
-1.4366880655288696,
0.20435425639152527,
-0.2869293987751007,
-0.1586136370897293,
-0.5527158975601196,
0.3383312523365021,
-0.24731504917144775,
-0.41139161586761475,
-0.4750024676322937,
0.8223576545715332,
-0.4937840700149536,
-0.19275282323360443,
-0.47136226296424866,
0.8036006689071655,
0.052589356899261475,
0.18980388343334198,
-0.25642555952072144,
1.3579055070877075,
0.36582738161087036,
-0.852990984916687,
0.7347062230110168,
0.37216177582740784,
-0.016596125438809395,
0.7653607130050659,
-0.820742130279541,
0.33294257521629333,
-0.2863422930240631,
0.33800050616264343,
-0.9145766496658325,
-0.48585402965545654,
-0.038812391459941864,
-0.7235451936721802,
-0.10165313631296158,
-0.2154105007648468,
-0.5788640379905701,
-0.45131415128707886,
-0.29494720697402954,
0.3137451410293579,
0.5446086525917053,
-0.7626967430114746,
0.4601868689060211,
0.6737603545188904,
-0.4702361226081848,
-0.9495208859443665,
-0.4110243618488312,
0.03413538262248039,
-0.23817333579063416,
-0.8152193427085876,
0.3404853045940399,
-0.2003425508737564,
-0.33262982964515686,
0.03737381845712662,
-0.05625583976507187,
-0.16217251121997833,
-0.04326190426945686,
0.1061088964343071,
-0.040942952036857605,
-0.1620156317949295,
0.6186165809631348,
-0.15726208686828613,
-0.18100593984127045,
-0.058975700289011,
0.013559186831116676,
0.7021028995513916,
-0.09906105697154999,
-0.3106818199157715,
0.4251500368118286,
0.37707123160362244,
0.5921269655227661,
-0.5646344423294067,
0.5839282870292664,
0.7970625758171082,
-0.0461026132106781,
-0.3727060556411743,
-0.671097993850708,
-0.1652553826570511,
-0.45259490609169006,
0.49607688188552856,
-0.37312859296798706,
-0.954998254776001,
0.8234318494796753,
-0.2027488499879837,
0.15759672224521637,
0.4073817729949951,
0.6361168622970581,
0.05952901020646095,
1.0271039009094238,
0.41120806336402893,
0.1089596375823021,
0.33266469836235046,
-0.09018560498952866,
0.12797793745994568,
-0.7922705411911011,
-0.3012342154979706,
-0.7206623554229736,
-0.1075596958398819,
-0.47579196095466614,
-0.2772170901298523,
0.5615750551223755,
0.2253260314464569,
0.0672297477722168,
0.2955482304096222,
-0.8518885374069214,
0.5897567868232727,
0.3353123962879181,
-0.091056227684021,
0.29885169863700867,
-0.11239251494407654,
0.21499884128570557,
0.33287209272384644,
-0.8229336738586426,
-0.5069295167922974,
0.8575116991996765,
-0.1233249381184578,
0.8480691313743591,
0.5882680416107178,
0.8486523628234863,
0.20105962455272675,
0.3587048649787903,
-0.6421298384666443,
0.6632083654403687,
0.19489246606826782,
-0.6469617486000061,
-0.20086105167865753,
-0.528852105140686,
-1.3207781314849854,
0.4858872592449188,
0.0005908012390136719,
-0.5578307509422302,
-0.07903104275465012,
0.16081267595291138,
-0.4926937520503998,
0.06173800304532051,
-0.7659322023391724,
0.7056464552879333,
-0.3365187644958496,
-0.3456352651119232,
-0.2399645298719406,
-0.39765435457229614,
0.45541146397590637,
-0.12329738587141037,
-0.10192962735891342,
-0.034492239356040955,
-0.15360496938228607,
0.5444689989089966,
-0.7337039113044739,
0.6129723787307739,
-0.12362207472324371,
-0.3167523741722107,
0.6837071180343628,
0.13980399072170258,
0.6683033108711243,
0.10735159367322922,
-0.3345355987548828,
-0.4229680895805359,
-0.06422083079814911,
-0.5214196443557739,
-0.7527947425842285,
0.8336535692214966,
-0.6770702004432678,
-0.5821706056594849,
-0.30549371242523193,
-0.43247735500335693,
-0.02637234516441822,
0.2364429235458374,
0.3012315034866333,
0.3762129843235016,
-0.17285580933094025,
0.142361581325531,
0.45000964403152466,
-0.32455992698669434,
0.33708369731903076,
0.43179234862327576,
-0.4782972037792206,
-0.2944962978363037,
0.7290138006210327,
0.025904735550284386,
0.07841216772794724,
0.15500639379024506,
-0.01997799426317215,
-0.4111231565475464,
-0.2011367231607437,
-0.6193625330924988,
-0.13173988461494446,
-0.6074187755584717,
-0.5068486332893372,
-0.7459957003593445,
-0.34436190128326416,
-0.21682094037532806,
-0.1432204395532608,
-0.26600441336631775,
-0.4129578471183777,
-0.01534359622746706,
-0.2538021504878998,
0.7247877717018127,
0.6241549849510193,
-0.02579684369266033,
0.2841983735561371,
-0.9472756385803223,
0.3030180335044861,
0.5145670771598816,
0.18626351654529572,
-0.03315048664808273,
-0.23505614697933197,
-0.2270476222038269,
0.21025139093399048,
-0.5459405183792114,
-1.0694364309310913,
0.31810829043388367,
0.07208603620529175,
0.5960773825645447,
-0.10189951211214066,
0.04385559633374214,
0.8419682383537292,
-0.28982365131378174,
0.8505269289016724,
-0.05655309185385704,
-0.6518208980560303,
0.6486489772796631,
-0.3980131447315216,
0.34683191776275635,
0.34562110900878906,
0.11999280005693436,
-0.48329946398735046,
-0.6353921890258789,
-0.8320958018302917,
-0.868111789226532,
0.36894240975379944,
0.120024673640728,
0.4185565710067749,
-0.28422144055366516,
0.09863997250795364,
0.03858068585395813,
0.42427533864974976,
-0.36217719316482544,
0.05500928685069084,
-0.14555653929710388,
0.11477934569120407,
0.303115576505661,
-0.33927181363105774,
0.06465120613574982,
0.20338889956474304,
0.7393509745597839,
-0.09192541986703873,
0.08143292367458344,
-0.09568935632705688,
-0.2508833408355713,
0.008838223293423653,
0.4399864375591278,
0.6831837892532349,
0.9129350781440735,
-0.03891338035464287,
0.3359163999557495,
0.2522643208503723,
-0.5321685075759888,
0.21833907067775726,
0.1449047178030014,
0.051813624799251556,
0.22431999444961548,
0.12328324466943741,
0.4455089867115021,
-0.10819647461175919,
-0.9369028806686401,
0.415926456451416,
0.15788060426712036,
0.15245196223258972,
-0.5599120259284973,
0.30420786142349243,
0.08415751159191132,
0.28467780351638794,
0.5494256615638733,
0.16002656519412994,
-0.009453712031245232,
-0.3736107051372528,
0.36328229308128357,
0.36351028084754944,
-0.16037146747112274,
-0.16440069675445557,
0.5962429642677307,
0.4449717402458191,
-0.5384941697120667,
0.7452102303504944,
-0.6308308243751526,
-0.5076265931129456,
0.7197237610816956,
0.6039964556694031,
0.8450119495391846,
-0.4069647789001465,
0.5661678910255432,
0.23465865850448608,
0.021425966173410416,
-0.02101227641105652,
0.37402084469795227,
0.08460478484630585,
-0.8038850426673889,
-0.8476630449295044,
-0.3799627125263214,
-0.5529708862304688,
-0.12013060599565506,
-0.3976982533931732,
0.21477918326854706,
-0.07262745499610901,
-0.3215232491493225,
-0.15206915140151978,
-0.07172130048274994,
-0.5740131735801697,
-0.060468025505542755,
-0.45946910977363586,
0.5322176218032837,
-0.5079169273376465,
0.47295907139778137,
0.8883185982704163,
-0.7535580992698669,
-0.710365891456604,
0.0236293226480484,
-0.27226918935775757,
-0.7342601418495178,
0.5629854202270508,
-0.0796217992901802,
-0.45743539929389954,
0.24304379522800446,
-0.6371103525161743,
-0.6473776698112488,
1.1276267766952515,
0.3641272783279419,
-0.016691621392965317,
0.18258331716060638,
-0.2463080734014511,
0.9598698019981384,
-0.15329067409038544,
0.5982450842857361,
-0.07955096662044525,
0.1969088613986969,
0.3025999367237091,
-0.9031892418861389,
-0.1311304122209549,
-0.6040360927581787,
-0.008625686168670654,
0.43195825815200806,
-0.6118649840354919,
0.6684429049491882,
-0.42218872904777527,
-0.27004489302635193,
-0.03703976050019264,
0.3092740476131439,
0.8863053917884827,
0.14068560302257538,
0.23845809698104858,
0.5593114495277405,
0.9015953540802002,
0.1302579641342163,
1.177720069885254,
-0.6510037183761597,
0.2159862369298935,
1.078165054321289,
-0.3404509127140045,
1.0064212083816528,
0.26910439133644104,
0.10730720311403275,
0.7461390495300293,
0.32332441210746765,
-0.03811607509851456,
0.17085972428321838,
0.24125026166439056,
-0.41581735014915466,
-0.14720018208026886,
-0.3275761902332306,
-0.46648287773132324,
0.4927457571029663,
0.2930382490158081,
-0.07495266199111938,
-0.39588114619255066,
-0.17676210403442383,
0.25226160883903503,
0.11111192405223846,
-0.12087593972682953,
0.8914947509765625,
-0.01480359211564064,
-0.9863519072532654,
0.602910041809082,
-0.12281636893749237,
0.568806529045105,
-0.3291015326976776,
-0.10287423431873322,
-0.40965691208839417,
0.06264624744653702,
-0.39602410793304443,
-0.9064690470695496,
0.4197022616863251,
0.3384802043437958,
-0.1835663616657257,
-0.19556473195552826,
0.9584108591079712,
-0.4923202693462372,
-0.31466782093048096,
0.21127350628376007,
0.9591909646987915,
0.41958317160606384,
-0.020811529830098152,
-0.48363086581230164,
-0.06464380025863647,
-0.29852399230003357,
-0.07135443389415741,
-0.04978169500827789,
0.470167338848114,
0.08438394218683243,
0.9603036046028137,
0.6352391839027405,
0.25451913475990295,
0.32775893807411194,
-0.21645201742649078,
0.8854512572288513,
-0.3351425528526306,
-0.4426194727420807,
-0.7634946703910828,
0.7307027578353882,
-0.38077592849731445,
-0.4033941328525543,
0.8847643733024597,
0.673231303691864,
0.6032230854034424,
-0.15027253329753876,
0.918544352054596,
-0.2695401906967163,
0.6464603543281555,
-0.3129308223724365,
0.5456189513206482,
-0.38720566034317017,
0.5687251687049866,
-0.19864316284656525,
-1.2614256143569946,
-0.21652577817440033,
0.34926536679267883,
-0.2389775961637497,
0.35135847330093384,
0.41254565119743347,
1.0509763956069946,
-0.21646277606487274,
-0.3294942378997803,
0.20841370522975922,
0.07293625921010971,
0.5064147710800171,
0.4645729660987854,
1.05868399143219,
-0.3366944193840027,
1.1080973148345947,
0.22291159629821777,
0.01070033572614193,
-0.267564594745636,
-0.6381183862686157,
-0.7112021446228027,
-0.37375855445861816,
-0.3191065788269043,
-0.5342938303947449,
0.21929194033145905,
0.6152089834213257,
0.6125843524932861,
-0.44362515211105347,
-0.20846940577030182,
-0.05347607284784317,
0.23982501029968262,
-0.09201519191265106,
-0.22513943910598755,
0.11968447268009186,
-0.6013510823249817,
-0.45524096488952637,
0.3115818500518799,
0.2170126885175705,
-0.2099507451057434,
-0.4875434339046478,
-0.1750408411026001,
0.1532352715730667,
-0.16603198647499084,
0.7140829563140869,
0.45177698135375977,
-0.5052779316902161,
-0.2719515562057495,
0.1280580461025238,
-0.23588509857654572,
0.07353077083826065,
0.5572742223739624,
-0.9671079516410828,
0.5304520726203918,
0.7596860527992249,
0.8007442355155945,
0.4236903488636017,
0.2971392869949341,
0.6489202976226807,
-1.1974176168441772,
0.0946354791522026,
0.4111620783805847,
-0.028363902121782303,
0.36711305379867554,
-0.27628350257873535,
0.7610677480697632,
-0.2641550600528717,
-0.8663201332092285,
-0.7632613778114319,
0.4229336082935333,
-0.513311505317688,
-0.02748563513159752,
1.2382382154464722,
0.17744016647338867,
0.13011714816093445,
-0.1966424137353897,
-0.36387988924980164,
0.02237657643854618,
-0.5096513032913208,
1.102818489074707,
0.5667458772659302,
-0.18123595416545868,
-0.43005385994911194,
-0.5032575726509094,
0.486701637506485,
0.24325378239154816,
-1.2412909269332886,
-0.16576506197452545,
0.5640811324119568,
0.07027564197778702,
0.7891414165496826,
0.8344906568527222,
0.08876653760671616,
0.3282625675201416,
0.24481818079948425,
0.30735301971435547,
0.09253660589456558,
-0.16699844598770142,
0.19201232492923737,
0.4069361686706543,
0.29970869421958923,
-0.22057737410068512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13828v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13828v1 | Neuro-symbolic Training for Reasoning over Spatial Language | 2024-06-19T20:47:36 | 2024-06-19T20:47:36 | Tanawan Premsri, Parisa Kordjamshidi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent research shows that more data and larger models can provide more
accurate solutions to natural language problems requiring reasoning. However,
models can easily fail to provide solutions in unobserved complex input
compositions due to not achieving the level of abstraction required for
generalizability. To alleviate this issue, we propose training the language
models with neuro-symbolic techniques that can exploit the logical rules of
reasoning as constraints and provide additional supervision sources to the
model. Training models to adhere to the regulations of reasoning pushes them to
make more effective abstractions needed for generalizability and transfer
learning. We focus on a challenging problem of spatial reasoning over text. Our
results on various benchmarks using multiple language models confirm our
hypothesis of effective domain transfer based on neuro-symbolic training. | [
-0.10447953641414642,
-0.8370947241783142,
1.1318223476409912,
0.24087946116924286,
0.08899136632680893,
-0.1607515811920166,
-0.21889060735702515,
-0.696613073348999,
-0.1826619952917099,
0.4535103142261505,
-0.5405146479606628,
-0.368009477853775,
-0.9372130036354065,
0.09446787089109421,
-0.42185425758361816,
0.6478878855705261,
-0.3540509045124054,
0.17339272797107697,
-0.15327352285385132,
-0.20028546452522278,
-0.8228847980499268,
-0.9160758256912231,
-0.7063612341880798,
-0.7068617939949036,
0.1789468377828598,
0.05965961143374443,
0.6878177523612976,
0.4524190127849579,
0.5624104142189026,
0.34324514865875244,
0.07392140477895737,
0.33546435832977295,
0.026363153010606766,
0.00588671350851655,
-0.6105299592018127,
-0.437156081199646,
-0.15987345576286316,
-0.12251013517379761,
0.4010936915874481,
1.0527753829956055,
-0.10383304953575134,
-0.3550567030906677,
-0.435513973236084,
0.46983519196510315,
-0.5232104063034058,
0.3122178614139557,
-0.660484790802002,
0.22212666273117065,
0.43888533115386963,
-0.20625558495521545,
-0.47956418991088867,
-0.5044142603874207,
0.4239319860935211,
-1.0959789752960205,
-0.02567676454782486,
-0.0005769817507825792,
1.025984764099121,
0.22808054089546204,
-0.536123514175415,
-0.2272166907787323,
-1.0087146759033203,
0.6423960328102112,
-0.5041869878768921,
0.30555087327957153,
0.7719997763633728,
0.5198727250099182,
-0.024359678849577904,
-0.4394861161708832,
-0.5085617899894714,
-0.497226357460022,
-0.2865220308303833,
-0.22313344478607178,
-0.34437257051467896,
-0.03176305443048477,
0.5354663133621216,
-0.54362553358078,
-0.336761474609375,
-0.2813698947429657,
-0.31143736839294434,
-0.07547009736299515,
0.6619751453399658,
0.24495261907577515,
0.68731689453125,
0.14612725377082825,
-0.35193580389022827,
-0.05466979742050171,
-0.542114794254303,
-0.27876758575439453,
0.1326276659965515,
0.3131747245788574,
-0.0828833132982254,
0.44976043701171875,
-0.17292571067810059,
0.8132946491241455,
-0.04080481454730034,
0.2657333314418793,
0.02597244828939438,
-0.44851744174957275,
0.12366332113742828,
0.0028180587105453014,
0.47537821531295776,
0.12551507353782654,
0.8835217356681824,
-0.37912124395370483,
-0.33093222975730896,
0.2693982720375061,
0.41874873638153076,
-0.4865163266658783,
-0.4245090186595917,
-0.1422087848186493,
-0.08068472892045975,
0.2367752194404602,
-0.0542943999171257,
-0.33464470505714417,
-0.35416653752326965,
-0.998114824295044,
0.4467419683933258,
-0.795601487159729,
-0.23823842406272888,
0.7156729698181152,
-0.2994367778301239,
0.05637817829847336,
0.6621012687683105,
-1.3655983209609985,
0.527080774307251,
0.6367459297180176,
0.7734194993972778,
-0.06545546650886536,
-0.5306010246276855,
-0.1102709248661995,
0.5643670558929443,
-0.28429484367370605,
1.1641664505004883,
-0.6986250877380371,
0.007556083612143993,
-0.03641758859157562,
-0.043828029185533524,
-0.4518570303916931,
-0.3370083272457123,
0.36843258142471313,
-0.16436415910720825,
0.011609593406319618,
-0.3031955659389496,
-0.401473730802536,
-0.34630072116851807,
0.3813479244709015,
-0.4785393476486206,
0.8632715344429016,
0.345257967710495,
-0.40533095598220825,
0.29230743646621704,
-0.6857129335403442,
-0.7545512318611145,
-0.23409900069236755,
-0.18488545715808868,
0.038380179554224014,
0.13077127933502197,
0.46939995884895325,
0.2093009501695633,
-0.16007377207279205,
0.5200144648551941,
-0.391891211271286,
-0.289540559053421,
0.1829235851764679,
-0.025769837200641632,
0.793246328830719,
0.0631432980298996,
-0.41877707839012146,
0.13299104571342468,
-0.5511844158172607,
0.08747363835573196,
0.27060607075691223,
-0.03253927081823349,
-0.6818765997886658,
0.04060736298561096,
0.005705181509256363,
0.23561082780361176,
0.007829303853213787,
-0.545581042766571,
0.21672874689102173,
-0.5385900735855103,
0.6257381439208984,
0.49911755323410034,
-0.1373218297958374,
1.0658878087997437,
-0.08436345309019089,
0.35757723450660706,
-0.052399758249521255,
-0.050979748368263245,
0.4365013539791107,
-0.3127420246601105,
-0.5962451100349426,
-0.02769111655652523,
-0.009368008933961391,
0.7917526364326477,
-0.7860878705978394,
0.4867786765098572,
-0.3128054141998291,
-0.41011640429496765,
-0.05883847549557686,
-0.11617045104503632,
0.22230134904384613,
0.515293300151825,
0.32316648960113525,
0.008095623925328255,
-0.5942772030830383,
-0.7236555218696594,
-0.26716476678848267,
0.06864338368177414,
0.06575481593608856,
0.2231748104095459,
0.8461262583732605,
-0.1331925243139267,
0.7394542098045349,
-0.48771044611930847,
-0.26377779245376587,
-0.38963040709495544,
0.1879424750804901,
0.10374926030635834,
0.5206764936447144,
0.6017025709152222,
-0.5016862154006958,
-0.306214302778244,
0.4321777820587158,
-1.074882984161377,
-0.1587560474872589,
-0.38922855257987976,
-0.4079573452472687,
0.25341343879699707,
0.6705491542816162,
-1.0404173135757446,
0.5089654922485352,
0.2456754744052887,
-0.7113234996795654,
0.4881584346294403,
-0.425564169883728,
-0.08620533347129822,
-0.628226637840271,
-0.003313713939860463,
0.14606252312660217,
-0.15384827554225922,
-0.6816688776016235,
-0.008504676632583141,
-0.1753687858581543,
-0.2024572640657425,
-0.2600110173225403,
0.7961530685424805,
-0.5978930592536926,
0.04156947880983353,
-0.4230131506919861,
0.2500893175601959,
0.004138230346143246,
0.6150624752044678,
0.5613833665847778,
0.39979928731918335,
0.7729074954986572,
-0.6119261980056763,
0.40327438712120056,
0.36415746808052063,
-0.1066519245505333,
0.7407088279724121,
-0.8449741005897522,
0.07840009778738022,
-0.197295680642128,
0.2985820770263672,
-0.7239840626716614,
0.03612787276506424,
0.3853481709957123,
-0.2213207334280014,
0.10583235323429108,
-0.0003343984135426581,
-0.5078795552253723,
-0.16294080018997192,
0.3481321334838867,
0.38207370042800903,
0.18797731399536133,
-0.49964070320129395,
0.8629822731018066,
0.3046526610851288,
0.07570526003837585,
-0.2263677567243576,
-0.809142529964447,
-0.04752064496278763,
-0.1154773011803627,
-0.5699537992477417,
0.09075582772493362,
0.2439376264810562,
-0.23952578008174896,
0.20260566473007202,
-0.23678097128868103,
-0.5823603272438049,
0.14844973385334015,
0.09613106399774551,
0.1296488344669342,
-0.046052925288677216,
0.15530332922935486,
0.2026461511850357,
-0.39769837260246277,
0.5808686017990112,
-0.45803168416023254,
0.3466939628124237,
-0.12233330309391022,
-0.5893718600273132,
-0.5307794809341431,
0.5510890483856201,
0.303484708070755,
-0.16847962141036987,
0.6616420745849609,
0.24402664601802826,
-0.617843747138977,
-0.4647858142852783,
-0.018776284530758858,
-0.6086869239807129,
-0.4124242067337036,
0.5592281222343445,
-0.42803099751472473,
-0.7253543734550476,
0.23393093049526215,
-0.22828342020511627,
-0.23738493025302887,
0.18367671966552734,
0.22900143265724182,
-0.1383962482213974,
1.2636219263076782,
0.5632627606391907,
0.17599308490753174,
0.31273481249809265,
-0.0395335890352726,
0.3972117006778717,
-0.2828187644481659,
-0.41069507598876953,
-0.6623073220252991,
-0.48386621475219727,
-0.021123822778463364,
-0.2478138953447342,
-0.06378678977489471,
-0.2474948614835739,
-0.5658035278320312,
0.6909693479537964,
-0.6604030728340149,
0.6879909038543701,
0.5205855965614319,
0.16642723977565765,
0.19605205953121185,
0.32415035367012024,
-0.07336969673633575,
-0.15943846106529236,
-0.695006787776947,
-0.3608767092227936,
0.5853362083435059,
0.22672587633132935,
0.8284932971000671,
0.0975583866238594,
0.2501677870750427,
-0.12304488569498062,
0.14171433448791504,
-0.6099771857261658,
0.7013012170791626,
-0.09156589210033417,
-0.5547009706497192,
-0.33457818627357483,
-0.46921128034591675,
-0.8669688105583191,
0.30735093355178833,
-0.2586912512779236,
-0.7905119061470032,
0.2554716169834137,
-0.1427811235189438,
-0.1644231677055359,
0.4083666205406189,
-0.7594838738441467,
0.7086619138717651,
-0.38187119364738464,
0.02460581809282303,
-0.14446090161800385,
-0.6949149966239929,
0.21636278927326202,
0.07083400338888168,
-0.047829631716012955,
-0.20998919010162354,
0.11622508615255356,
0.32730168104171753,
-0.36527860164642334,
0.920627236366272,
-0.22328174114227295,
-0.11445356905460358,
0.14204752445220947,
0.2658805251121521,
0.3900323808193207,
-0.1841355860233307,
0.2572392523288727,
0.33173897862434387,
-0.04905393347144127,
-0.32541126012802124,
-1.0258890390396118,
0.39654555916786194,
-0.9341062903404236,
-0.4037136137485504,
-0.6422511339187622,
-1.0299867391586304,
-0.46468880772590637,
0.14879481494426727,
0.16987557709217072,
0.12801583111286163,
0.18156982958316803,
-0.2563796937465668,
0.7571079730987549,
0.059494923800230026,
0.1670493334531784,
0.26797720789909363,
-0.10122126340866089,
-0.22004622220993042,
0.7220305800437927,
-0.07321900129318237,
0.17791981995105743,
0.4148869514465332,
0.0666910707950592,
-0.467437744140625,
-0.5462273359298706,
-0.17670105397701263,
0.3206424415111542,
-0.7558591961860657,
-0.01981550268828869,
-0.6372029781341553,
-0.49158263206481934,
-0.2522149682044983,
-0.3571814298629761,
-0.14128422737121582,
-0.6675499081611633,
-0.14127741754055023,
-0.1541282683610916,
0.30757126212120056,
0.7933902144432068,
-0.010297998785972595,
0.3687361180782318,
-0.7762380242347717,
0.32857540249824524,
0.2299232929944992,
0.15063583850860596,
0.006331039126962423,
-0.6817981004714966,
0.008741000667214394,
0.12165085971355438,
-0.16762743890285492,
-0.9798719882965088,
0.4025869071483612,
0.09578637033700943,
0.6920528411865234,
0.05580606684088707,
-0.3955919146537781,
0.5557421445846558,
-0.654457688331604,
0.23064471781253815,
0.3090956211090088,
-0.9932656288146973,
0.8312002420425415,
-0.502159833908081,
0.40730759501457214,
0.4558531939983368,
0.575985848903656,
-0.4120953679084778,
-0.31911519169807434,
-0.42701226472854614,
-0.5701583623886108,
0.6421021223068237,
0.048571016639471054,
0.25418609380722046,
-0.07667476683855057,
0.4577350616455078,
-0.09872155636548996,
-0.05967555195093155,
-0.7429361343383789,
0.028094016015529633,
-0.06286463141441345,
-0.10789477080106735,
0.3466492295265198,
0.05748291313648224,
-0.19318929314613342,
-0.8514487743377686,
0.508820116519928,
-0.23099775612354279,
0.3640322685241699,
0.24528157711029053,
-0.18572227656841278,
0.1451674997806549,
0.03638020530343056,
0.7555043697357178,
0.7987805604934692,
0.15814420580863953,
0.25422582030296326,
0.1677456796169281,
-0.37012800574302673,
0.3795894682407379,
0.05483090132474899,
-0.23425543308258057,
0.07166711241006851,
0.32490843534469604,
0.8975456357002258,
0.3050497770309448,
-0.6627822518348694,
0.42571982741355896,
0.08068565279245377,
-0.7989022731781006,
-0.23216551542282104,
-0.057487569749355316,
0.17949001491069794,
0.13019531965255737,
-0.0953793153166771,
0.38681739568710327,
-0.04125501587986946,
-0.2930701673030853,
0.1553594022989273,
0.3352951109409332,
-0.3854868412017822,
-0.5016552209854126,
0.680249035358429,
0.03425027057528496,
-0.08325429260730743,
1.1395790576934814,
0.014087021350860596,
-0.5099034905433655,
0.7843190431594849,
0.9920161962509155,
0.8100151419639587,
0.06843811273574829,
0.3196285367012024,
0.6050218343734741,
0.6080178022384644,
-0.3070169985294342,
0.3986358046531677,
0.19913753867149353,
-0.9209689497947693,
-0.6656852960586548,
-0.2009594738483429,
-0.45803412795066833,
-0.2672363817691803,
-0.25048866868019104,
0.0225144624710083,
-0.7902486324310303,
-0.16333772242069244,
-0.11880066245794296,
-0.5006370544433594,
-0.32296979427337646,
0.03571635112166405,
0.20668427646160126,
0.9776726365089417,
-1.1169096231460571,
0.7897812724113464,
1.0630892515182495,
-0.46401363611221313,
-0.9429213404655457,
-0.5850852131843567,
-0.27215081453323364,
-0.5772806406021118,
1.1461782455444336,
0.08578165620565414,
-0.20354637503623962,
-0.35435688495635986,
-0.8435024619102478,
-0.738304615020752,
0.5663286447525024,
0.9177877306938171,
-0.30452144145965576,
-0.1769666075706482,
0.3523125648498535,
0.7821987867355347,
-0.35255253314971924,
0.07698927819728851,
0.5880411267280579,
0.7286249995231628,
0.2045460045337677,
-0.7789701223373413,
0.24854369461536407,
-0.25749635696411133,
-0.1136215403676033,
0.33416295051574707,
-0.097992442548275,
0.8257075548171997,
-0.34173405170440674,
-0.21723970770835876,
-0.010369444265961647,
0.7390968203544617,
0.3839278817176819,
0.36052775382995605,
0.33066925406455994,
0.8708325028419495,
0.7936606407165527,
-0.36231207847595215,
1.1577045917510986,
-0.01886063627898693,
0.22390522062778473,
1.234778642654419,
-0.4241960644721985,
0.7795410752296448,
0.5681939125061035,
0.04776949808001518,
0.7379124760627747,
0.19295494258403778,
-0.09279102832078934,
0.5210902690887451,
0.3005463480949402,
-0.17837324738502502,
-0.4593280255794525,
-0.257137268781662,
-0.1658782660961151,
0.4265660345554352,
0.3464096486568451,
-0.047134529799222946,
-0.6022442579269409,
-0.043008219450712204,
-0.05277780443429947,
0.6825809478759766,
-0.1933913677930832,
0.4806160628795624,
0.25463172793388367,
-0.719007134437561,
0.3989750146865845,
-0.11404086649417877,
0.35950809717178345,
-0.6975712776184082,
-0.3656328320503235,
-0.1778447926044464,
0.22164411842823029,
-0.18847215175628662,
-0.7205193638801575,
0.7592988014221191,
-0.3634391129016876,
-0.15849891304969788,
-0.5802593231201172,
0.9592081308364868,
-0.41030949354171753,
-0.2836417555809021,
0.28057965636253357,
0.5658609867095947,
0.14818957448005676,
-0.33611851930618286,
-0.674721360206604,
-0.3260281980037689,
-0.2789052724838257,
0.24092769622802734,
0.35267508029937744,
0.8156988024711609,
-0.3867966830730438,
0.8537668585777283,
0.6522756218910217,
0.31743356585502625,
0.07739583402872086,
0.16075775027275085,
0.6324823498725891,
-0.7861018180847168,
-0.5345357656478882,
-0.8787466287612915,
0.0752117708325386,
-0.08073625713586807,
-0.3431911766529083,
0.675014853477478,
0.16580833494663239,
0.7345994710922241,
-0.3628199100494385,
0.6135231256484985,
0.05692967772483826,
-0.07556045800447464,
-0.4984970986843109,
0.7686178088188171,
-0.27149516344070435,
-0.000366781372576952,
-0.008622744120657444,
-0.934406578540802,
-0.5160927772521973,
1.1160677671432495,
-0.5798715949058533,
0.19877943396568298,
1.2405726909637451,
0.4737699627876282,
-0.1436852663755417,
0.24209122359752655,
0.2543991208076477,
-0.11457017064094543,
0.10367007553577423,
1.342667818069458,
1.2132749557495117,
-0.25290271639823914,
0.23812927305698395,
-0.21820659935474396,
0.067317433655262,
0.3343855142593384,
-0.89799565076828,
-0.9968755841255188,
-0.4454420208930969,
-0.4221862554550171,
-0.17189744114875793,
0.2576427757740021,
0.5379021167755127,
0.9573518633842468,
-0.7485650181770325,
-0.21514827013015747,
-0.521348237991333,
0.09865884482860565,
-0.3907351493835449,
-0.1954040229320526,
0.27066561579704285,
-0.4109135866165161,
-0.6682215929031372,
0.22852447628974915,
0.22410866618156433,
0.15753188729286194,
0.00844800379127264,
-0.031116297468543053,
-0.474014014005661,
0.06276029348373413,
0.5577048659324646,
0.42021673917770386,
-0.4389011859893799,
-0.45688334107398987,
0.0285123810172081,
-0.4552857577800751,
-0.11193468421697617,
0.922088086605072,
-0.6888926029205322,
-0.10622011870145798,
0.625214159488678,
0.9554228186607361,
0.2636260986328125,
-0.13071346282958984,
0.6901490092277527,
-0.7520674467086792,
0.33597710728645325,
0.2796511650085449,
0.39439496397972107,
0.22364135086536407,
-0.363472580909729,
0.6470291614532471,
0.4337838292121887,
-0.37353554368019104,
-0.48042765259742737,
0.2929007411003113,
-0.9566403031349182,
-0.5235582590103149,
1.270247459411621,
0.07909167557954788,
-0.3697502613067627,
-0.2872779965400696,
-0.3059837520122528,
-0.08939141780138016,
-0.20747806131839752,
0.6165762543678284,
0.8132815957069397,
-0.2829897999763489,
-0.0976174920797348,
-0.6872957348823547,
0.24487842619419098,
0.7796092629432678,
-1.2590875625610352,
-0.026554850861430168,
0.6635879278182983,
0.12785296142101288,
0.2096029818058014,
0.5569844841957092,
-0.027133125811815262,
0.5246785283088684,
0.20542268455028534,
0.10941828042268753,
-0.09056125581264496,
-0.6614459156990051,
-0.4262491762638092,
0.12218202650547028,
-0.10444747656583786,
0.09805163741111755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13827v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13827v2 | Fine-Tuning BERTs for Definition Extraction from Mathematical Text | 2024-06-19T20:47:23 | 2024-06-27T22:31:07 | Lucy Horowitz, Ryan Hathaway | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we fine-tuned three pre-trained BERT models on the task of
"definition extraction" from mathematical English written in LaTeX. This is
presented as a binary classification problem, where either a sentence contains
a definition of a mathematical term or it does not. We used two original data
sets, "Chicago" and "TAC," to fine-tune and test these models. We also tested
on WFMALL, a dataset presented by Vanetik and Litvak in 2021 and compared the
performance of our models to theirs. We found that a high-performance
Sentence-BERT transformer model performed best based on overall accuracy,
recall, and precision metrics, achieving comparable results to the earlier
models with less computational effort. | [
-0.4946269094944,
-1.0655103921890259,
0.507854163646698,
0.258212685585022,
-0.43939846754074097,
-0.192411869764328,
-0.38838085532188416,
-0.7324548363685608,
0.03643053397536278,
0.5433864593505859,
-0.5333441495895386,
-0.23602156341075897,
-0.786856472492218,
0.37271061539649963,
-0.5021297335624695,
1.3315010070800781,
-0.058986350893974304,
0.028053797781467438,
-0.3168492019176483,
0.19907580316066742,
-0.4559709131717682,
-0.2777310013771057,
-0.40154415369033813,
-0.42492082715034485,
0.586729884147644,
0.22644928097724915,
0.9220759272575378,
0.5735635161399841,
0.7950724363327026,
0.31641364097595215,
-0.09581340104341507,
0.16335567831993103,
-0.27991047501564026,
-0.05882832407951355,
-0.10555502027273178,
-0.44341421127319336,
-0.2634035646915436,
0.1284007877111435,
0.560370147228241,
0.9598724246025085,
0.10661102086305618,
0.15431803464889526,
0.15458890795707703,
0.5284860134124756,
-0.46343010663986206,
0.4735494554042816,
-0.7776880264282227,
-0.08803418278694153,
-0.032810334116220474,
0.034126438200473785,
-0.38036030530929565,
-0.9042940139770508,
0.4745180606842041,
-0.5634474158287048,
0.4793371558189392,
-0.14954149723052979,
1.4480669498443604,
0.1729828417301178,
-0.1872921735048294,
-0.3888523578643799,
-0.8559496402740479,
0.8941777348518372,
-0.7433819770812988,
0.3328897953033447,
0.5423416495323181,
0.13373158872127533,
0.08697928488254547,
-0.8032262921333313,
-0.5984637141227722,
0.0034242873080074787,
-0.23374657332897186,
0.11292985826730728,
-0.2967411279678345,
0.057326577603816986,
0.27078524231910706,
0.04316546767950058,
-0.4221605658531189,
0.16291581094264984,
-0.6946586966514587,
-0.19271518290042877,
0.7602287530899048,
0.059969715774059296,
-0.28170621395111084,
-0.2815004885196686,
-0.15908929705619812,
-0.0611904077231884,
-0.42729464173316956,
0.05813010409474373,
0.22402627766132355,
0.37688443064689636,
0.05173762887716293,
0.7404820322990417,
0.1374816596508026,
0.5660543441772461,
-0.2753065228462219,
0.07615497708320618,
0.18297269940376282,
-0.27833831310272217,
-0.24245785176753998,
-0.12529493868350983,
0.49557748436927795,
0.08707106858491898,
0.7039062976837158,
-0.2944985032081604,
-0.6072635054588318,
0.018984412774443626,
0.4173484444618225,
-0.8743728399276733,
-0.5642961263656616,
-0.19149525463581085,
-0.6194024682044983,
-0.4596026837825775,
0.18927104771137238,
-0.5606987476348877,
0.11856584250926971,
-0.8736394643783569,
0.8179954886436462,
-0.6590306162834167,
0.1365138739347458,
-0.014248115010559559,
-0.2425660341978073,
0.1344957798719406,
0.31772351264953613,
-0.9359392523765564,
0.322777658700943,
0.8418124318122864,
0.722183346748352,
-0.01468613650649786,
0.12673968076705933,
-0.320515513420105,
-0.34450164437294006,
-0.4704509377479553,
0.912324845790863,
-0.6584473252296448,
-0.29659304022789,
0.20097796618938446,
-0.06341284513473511,
0.16492216289043427,
-0.5350963473320007,
0.542598307132721,
-0.5857856273651123,
0.4248674213886261,
-0.23166929185390472,
-0.7882078289985657,
-0.21462690830230713,
0.04504770040512085,
-0.5781880021095276,
1.1689707040786743,
0.3195827007293701,
-0.4826021194458008,
0.438528448343277,
-0.749372661113739,
-0.804345428943634,
0.20063786208629608,
-0.1310301125049591,
-0.502480685710907,
0.6147090196609497,
0.1948705017566681,
0.626511812210083,
-0.2360071837902069,
0.14678482711315155,
-0.2741889953613281,
-0.36381232738494873,
0.38419854640960693,
-0.35739317536354065,
0.7412949800491333,
0.39801225066185,
-0.10044066607952118,
-0.1418832391500473,
-0.9389035105705261,
0.3063722848892212,
0.16419130563735962,
-0.2899145781993866,
-0.5106181502342224,
0.31898656487464905,
0.3778197467327118,
0.07866038382053375,
0.42785611748695374,
-0.638616681098938,
0.2900659143924713,
-0.6980233192443848,
0.3662084639072418,
0.9300904273986816,
-0.2836840748786926,
0.31184834241867065,
-0.41680479049682617,
0.27196863293647766,
-0.3574589490890503,
0.029795300215482712,
0.0609787218272686,
-0.4752633273601532,
-0.7949448227882385,
-0.35546043515205383,
0.8190941214561462,
0.45837754011154175,
-0.7238958477973938,
0.9368802905082703,
-0.35065358877182007,
-0.512559711933136,
-0.5089158415794373,
-0.023917345330119133,
0.15271012485027313,
0.5562747120857239,
0.407593697309494,
-0.005779548082500696,
-0.43048354983329773,
-1.0454177856445312,
-0.1629459112882614,
0.10844995826482773,
-0.2414471060037613,
0.38401201367378235,
0.5597660541534424,
-0.2205132246017456,
1.2319748401641846,
-0.8693021535873413,
-0.12776386737823486,
-0.11988688260316849,
0.6110038161277771,
0.2797689735889435,
0.2988497316837311,
0.6715567111968994,
-0.7732515335083008,
-0.6023963689804077,
-0.14641064405441284,
-0.5178943872451782,
-0.24424780905246735,
-0.056734755635261536,
0.021323805674910545,
0.24496406316757202,
0.2796729803085327,
-0.17305293679237366,
0.6050726771354675,
0.28513577580451965,
-0.23929230868816376,
0.7526147365570068,
-0.3497335612773895,
-0.2784848213195801,
-1.0767027139663696,
0.13239115476608276,
-0.11032090336084366,
-0.2095038890838623,
-0.4493200182914734,
-0.15078166127204895,
0.18002234399318695,
0.006524506490677595,
-0.18622088432312012,
0.2725451588630676,
-0.05410763621330261,
0.07840671390295029,
-0.2328801304101944,
0.17263266444206238,
0.013238632120192051,
0.22397872805595398,
0.064375139772892,
0.7718544006347656,
0.3764778971672058,
-0.8085779547691345,
0.33770471811294556,
0.33530154824256897,
-0.4581623375415802,
0.1219138652086258,
-0.777082622051239,
0.1689474880695343,
-0.15288875997066498,
-0.35383471846580505,
-1.0415865182876587,
0.09722752124071121,
-0.2974326014518738,
-0.4296932816505432,
0.14860281348228455,
0.212063267827034,
-0.8759993314743042,
-0.37591832876205444,
-0.07939598709344864,
0.11181484907865524,
0.6895288228988647,
-0.4912187159061432,
0.5867805480957031,
0.0511128269135952,
-0.43406033515930176,
-0.252529114484787,
-0.534089207649231,
-0.35117772221565247,
-0.02812737599015236,
-0.4604297876358032,
0.46214979887008667,
-0.08747000247240067,
-0.18553413450717926,
0.023092299699783325,
-0.012837366200983524,
-0.3564179837703705,
0.2581004798412323,
-0.05293334648013115,
0.5295501947402954,
-0.21904824674129486,
0.5695855617523193,
0.23739221692085266,
0.017139960080385208,
0.2651427090167999,
-0.20896077156066895,
0.5554670095443726,
0.037247657775878906,
0.2503930628299713,
-0.24367079138755798,
0.37611815333366394,
0.3313674330711365,
-0.31953465938568115,
0.7319846749305725,
0.734642744064331,
-0.6646832823753357,
-0.017398599535226822,
-0.5293813347816467,
-0.3972548544406891,
-0.4734346270561218,
0.20063818991184235,
-0.34615558385849,
-0.8367888331413269,
0.4691920876502991,
-0.10291766375303268,
0.33614227175712585,
0.7400552034378052,
0.37587007880210876,
-0.45511963963508606,
1.0902312994003296,
1.1131629943847656,
0.11624740809202194,
0.6671632528305054,
-0.23682193458080292,
0.2264959216117859,
-0.3706592917442322,
-0.06799189001321793,
-0.8880723714828491,
-0.46148449182510376,
-0.5435891151428223,
0.1854400336742401,
0.31332483887672424,
0.09550584107637405,
0.051425524055957794,
0.42971381545066833,
-0.5266249179840088,
0.4176151752471924,
0.5061375498771667,
0.026031026616692543,
-0.03837066888809204,
0.22226382791996002,
-0.2770850360393524,
-0.38922640681266785,
-0.22328148782253265,
-0.600530743598938,
1.124565601348877,
0.16692902147769928,
0.6393741965293884,
0.1918671429157257,
0.6225969791412354,
0.1865522712469101,
0.20322367548942566,
-0.8811025619506836,
0.26909562945365906,
-0.523853600025177,
-0.70890212059021,
-0.2802715301513672,
-0.5692952275276184,
-1.2431817054748535,
-0.0698125809431076,
-0.7112426161766052,
-0.7569235563278198,
0.016286576166749,
-0.039499446749687195,
-0.49975520372390747,
-0.027419473975896835,
-0.8100349307060242,
0.6584271192550659,
-0.26540467143058777,
-0.073466956615448,
-0.3412768840789795,
-0.5083850622177124,
0.19139723479747772,
-0.5807439684867859,
0.23763127624988556,
-0.1967572718858719,
0.11538217961788177,
0.9220691323280334,
-0.41220903396606445,
0.5830228924751282,
0.07603027671575546,
-0.2565882205963135,
0.1642506718635559,
0.08442150801420212,
0.3467865288257599,
-0.03208967298269272,
0.037416376173496246,
0.24583138525485992,
0.5004705190658569,
-0.4176887273788452,
-0.6087643504142761,
0.19213616847991943,
-0.9191740155220032,
-0.027582991868257523,
-0.2041487991809845,
-0.4350389838218689,
-0.1609090268611908,
0.43040895462036133,
0.3807840049266815,
0.48157331347465515,
-0.244363471865654,
0.3576972186565399,
0.5380621552467346,
-0.0984453484416008,
0.7325212359428406,
0.5727053880691528,
-0.2017548531293869,
-0.2192249447107315,
0.7939748764038086,
0.1638178825378418,
0.054347991943359375,
0.5686656832695007,
0.42484185099601746,
-0.4339551627635956,
-0.33164098858833313,
0.09506490081548691,
0.21744319796562195,
-0.40555036067962646,
-0.36562395095825195,
-0.3664109706878662,
-0.5201013088226318,
-0.5503689646720886,
-0.17845270037651062,
-0.3045458495616913,
-0.5587045550346375,
-0.5801456570625305,
0.1766662895679474,
0.4377955198287964,
0.9819112420082092,
0.015430046245455742,
0.5623016953468323,
-1.013177514076233,
0.25598767399787903,
0.19955745339393616,
0.4862675666809082,
-0.3296119272708893,
-0.5808108448982239,
-0.4729132354259491,
0.08033442497253418,
-0.45850029587745667,
-0.5868807435035706,
0.5431042313575745,
0.4339560866355896,
0.23914174735546112,
0.6369590759277344,
-0.0060793571174144745,
0.7213014960289001,
-0.6193110346794128,
0.6873806715011597,
0.18518230319023132,
-1.1072962284088135,
0.7187420129776001,
-0.03749370574951172,
0.15930017828941345,
0.3260504901409149,
0.3158494532108307,
-0.2969317138195038,
-0.13493014872074127,
-0.815778911113739,
-0.5258222818374634,
0.512637197971344,
0.452041357755661,
0.3218127191066742,
-0.00579863041639328,
0.7486453652381897,
0.47755903005599976,
0.17788177728652954,
-0.49880343675613403,
-0.17885397374629974,
0.0035855069290846586,
-0.5804277062416077,
-0.40716880559921265,
-0.2775670886039734,
0.050098489969968796,
-0.4524274468421936,
0.41071128845214844,
-0.1321200281381607,
0.45659932494163513,
0.07499843090772629,
-0.28089991211891174,
-0.08825518935918808,
0.23503369092941284,
0.6684372425079346,
0.8982349038124084,
-0.29852771759033203,
0.14275868237018585,
0.11248263716697693,
-0.6780031323432922,
-0.37311723828315735,
0.5544357299804688,
-0.09330469369888306,
0.23730126023292542,
0.7038713693618774,
0.4025617241859436,
0.23277999460697174,
-0.7389748096466064,
0.4121913015842438,
-0.22960877418518066,
-0.507684588432312,
-0.3610799312591553,
0.11170528084039688,
-0.42329901456832886,
0.08639553189277649,
0.38840851187705994,
0.1342211812734604,
0.08205302059650421,
-0.21129897236824036,
0.3802690804004669,
0.5148271322250366,
-0.2122710645198822,
-0.3921426832675934,
0.439728707075119,
-0.020418331027030945,
-0.3619421422481537,
0.9521423578262329,
-0.0166927520185709,
-0.6157907843589783,
0.5271825194358826,
0.5410215258598328,
0.787768542766571,
0.13366544246673584,
-0.1450435072183609,
0.2682357728481293,
0.35512176156044006,
0.12366320192813873,
0.39996087551116943,
-0.005293306894600391,
-0.9013938307762146,
-0.4904249310493469,
-0.65923672914505,
-0.08070992678403854,
0.12091320008039474,
-0.9430662989616394,
0.45825615525245667,
-0.518987238407135,
-0.24337269365787506,
0.5934101939201355,
0.34992021322250366,
-0.9349561333656311,
0.22584061324596405,
0.021666673943400383,
0.8332780599594116,
-0.9184585809707642,
0.9489348530769348,
0.6160039901733398,
-0.4193371534347534,
-0.7681258320808411,
-0.3461334705352783,
-0.39309054613113403,
-0.7325515151023865,
0.6838717460632324,
0.058474645018577576,
0.2096560150384903,
0.13564445078372955,
-0.905852735042572,
-0.7679828405380249,
0.7673546671867371,
0.24400965869426727,
-0.6769991517066956,
-0.09119199961423874,
0.0146861020475626,
0.5923903584480286,
-0.20369833707809448,
0.1512163132429123,
0.6484370827674866,
0.3680349588394165,
-0.09054544568061829,
-1.1718049049377441,
-0.4286923110485077,
-0.08462198078632355,
-0.011565119959414005,
0.3319942355155945,
-0.17935244739055634,
0.8953956365585327,
-0.08403939753770828,
-0.016159821301698685,
0.13995330035686493,
0.7491642832756042,
-0.362374871969223,
-0.07077179849147797,
0.46968531608581543,
0.4712110161781311,
0.8839240670204163,
-0.40907302498817444,
0.711889386177063,
-0.055678702890872955,
0.6710513234138489,
0.8592351078987122,
0.022222790867090225,
1.071908712387085,
0.2585045397281647,
-0.3821491003036499,
0.5531170964241028,
0.6712099313735962,
-0.27330607175827026,
0.5978599190711975,
0.04944745451211929,
-0.01020069234073162,
-0.36413058638572693,
0.23206791281700134,
-0.2992967665195465,
0.7035297155380249,
0.531053364276886,
-0.4404541552066803,
-0.2291608452796936,
0.013229147531092167,
-0.08394130319356918,
0.12254224717617035,
-0.2527495324611664,
1.0987756252288818,
-0.1159108355641365,
-0.6188287734985352,
0.5584751963615417,
0.11913228780031204,
0.5517568588256836,
-0.5451740026473999,
-0.15961290895938873,
-0.099131278693676,
0.39084523916244507,
0.0223967544734478,
-0.6575015187263489,
0.5312033891677856,
0.023370688781142235,
-0.30549365282058716,
-0.11497439444065094,
0.6154681444168091,
-0.4260057806968689,
-0.7960915565490723,
-0.03486808389425278,
0.4766969084739685,
0.3539745807647705,
-0.004756267182528973,
-0.7957717180252075,
-0.15598201751708984,
-0.004495513159781694,
0.3337635099887848,
-0.07379811257123947,
0.6512453556060791,
0.15223142504692078,
0.3533596396446228,
0.6072080731391907,
0.09283258020877838,
0.1189582571387291,
0.0948171466588974,
0.6632969975471497,
-0.7509822249412537,
-0.4106519818305969,
-0.8964077234268188,
0.23696841299533844,
-0.02170434594154358,
-0.41343891620635986,
0.4476902484893799,
0.8088608980178833,
0.6670463681221008,
-0.2696780264377594,
0.6670923233032227,
-0.08189942687749863,
0.6347879767417908,
-0.507803201675415,
0.7728601098060608,
-0.5209122896194458,
-0.09229255467653275,
-0.3757528066635132,
-0.9716012477874756,
-0.4624869227409363,
0.9924198985099792,
-0.17659641802310944,
0.03814055025577545,
0.856425404548645,
0.36767223477363586,
-0.012405258603394032,
0.22819840908050537,
0.1994989514350891,
0.15822097659111023,
0.5077232718467712,
0.34917864203453064,
0.5444796681404114,
-0.5112193822860718,
0.615134060382843,
-0.41719526052474976,
-0.1963464468717575,
-0.34192752838134766,
-0.8594308495521545,
-1.056348204612732,
-0.7442541718482971,
-0.26223859190940857,
-0.3249814510345459,
-0.3200249969959259,
0.9067187905311584,
0.6853110790252686,
-0.9092037081718445,
0.0768263041973114,
-0.10454118996858597,
0.07944735884666443,
-0.42831137776374817,
-0.2617742717266083,
0.5560639500617981,
-0.8170523047447205,
-0.765153706073761,
-0.09372528642416,
-0.10730551183223724,
0.326348215341568,
0.01909247785806656,
0.4133176803588867,
-0.07814226299524307,
0.29237380623817444,
0.821610152721405,
-0.15758727490901947,
-0.7384092211723328,
-0.696019172668457,
0.15755924582481384,
-0.03606490418314934,
0.015303203836083412,
0.7837231159210205,
-0.7858766317367554,
0.5226076245307922,
0.2943222224712372,
0.6900930404663086,
0.4275229275226593,
-0.010461995378136635,
0.578098714351654,
-1.0408523082733154,
-0.039872780442237854,
0.29857975244522095,
0.29017943143844604,
-0.024620570242404938,
-0.2042178064584732,
0.3492451608181,
0.31091034412384033,
-0.43295857310295105,
-0.6762632131576538,
-0.062051303684711456,
-0.9502843618392944,
-0.42986464500427246,
0.8114944100379944,
0.11991018801927567,
-0.002850970020517707,
-0.0836922898888588,
-0.28778234124183655,
0.31079697608947754,
-0.16858819127082825,
1.0046848058700562,
1.094336986541748,
-0.13996435701847076,
-0.1321551501750946,
-0.40464508533477783,
0.5430147051811218,
0.36382269859313965,
-0.5746300220489502,
-0.0036379247903823853,
0.278413325548172,
0.3138684034347534,
0.3813559412956238,
-0.09740591049194336,
0.0689418613910675,
0.17277736961841583,
-0.2917494475841522,
0.19918961822986603,
0.15157167613506317,
-0.2603601813316345,
-0.35103005170822144,
0.053378596901893616,
-0.04548224061727524,
-0.20914216339588165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13820v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13820v1 | Framing Social Movements on Social Media: Unpacking Diagnostic, Prognostic, and Motivational Strategies | 2024-06-19T20:31:34 | 2024-06-19T20:31:34 | Julia Mendelsohn, Maya Vijan, Dallas Card, Ceren Budak | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media enables activists to directly communicate with the public and
provides a space for movement leaders, participants, bystanders, and opponents
to collectively construct and contest narratives. Focusing on Twitter messages
from social movements surrounding three issues in 2018-2019 (guns, immigration,
and LGBTQ rights), we create a codebook, annotated dataset, and computational
models to detect diagnostic (problem identification and attribution),
prognostic (proposed solutions and tactics), and motivational (calls to action)
framing strategies. We conduct an in-depth unsupervised linguistic analysis of
each framing strategy, and uncover cross-movement similarities in associations
between framing and linguistic features such as pronouns and deontic modal
verbs. Finally, we compare framing strategies across issues and other social,
cultural, and interactional contexts. For example, we show that diagnostic
framing is more common in replies than original broadcast posts, and that
social movement organizations focus much more on prognostic and motivational
framing than journalists and ordinary citizens. | [
-0.08504017442464828,
-1.0164010524749756,
0.8713579773902893,
0.08880668878555298,
-0.5843597650527954,
0.8262639045715332,
0.13560624420642853,
-0.04440305009484291,
0.8185911178588867,
0.35382604598999023,
-0.48095712065696716,
-0.4971149265766144,
-1.04164457321167,
-0.27459195256233215,
-0.7885708808898926,
0.8489951491355896,
-0.4735056459903717,
0.2421395182609558,
0.4048474133014679,
-0.37052497267723083,
-0.34035423398017883,
-0.19966480135917664,
-0.8307517766952515,
0.07803492993116379,
0.7207567691802979,
-0.005082288291305304,
0.5622859001159668,
0.8231656551361084,
0.37885016202926636,
0.2724025845527649,
-0.2696148455142975,
-0.18595345318317413,
-0.7433661818504333,
0.006058808881789446,
0.014771101996302605,
-0.07948790490627289,
0.11146655678749084,
0.004327801987528801,
0.6968963146209717,
0.4627261757850647,
0.18481388688087463,
0.4498443603515625,
-0.06485708802938461,
0.8436586260795593,
-0.40870845317840576,
-0.11835236847400665,
-0.15493549406528473,
0.1912391483783722,
-0.47380173206329346,
-0.17838154733181,
0.18919768929481506,
-0.613715410232544,
-0.46797114610671997,
-0.3058779239654541,
0.30806106328964233,
-0.2906116545200348,
0.5952991843223572,
0.03260749578475952,
-0.835264265537262,
-0.1398920863866806,
-0.8315284252166748,
0.2774480879306793,
-0.15773403644561768,
0.31056758761405945,
0.36743801832199097,
0.3946627676486969,
-0.08852945268154144,
-0.6102527379989624,
-0.24820762872695923,
0.5297719836235046,
0.28977617621421814,
-0.08377955853939056,
-0.48484453558921814,
-0.18065311014652252,
0.07279295474290848,
-0.027513869106769562,
-0.4990563690662384,
-0.33403831720352173,
-0.6984128952026367,
-0.09284120053052902,
0.9057261347770691,
0.34505581855773926,
0.38532498478889465,
-0.17593075335025787,
-0.44691208004951477,
0.3060925304889679,
-0.5260967016220093,
0.21439313888549805,
0.4967583417892456,
0.199609637260437,
-0.4565982222557068,
0.6508472561836243,
-0.3033345341682434,
0.45281657576560974,
0.14891289174556732,
0.1868908554315567,
-0.05810604616999626,
-0.46263861656188965,
0.10981245338916779,
0.15423862636089325,
0.8561370372772217,
0.6520572304725647,
0.029265642166137695,
-0.11941579729318619,
-0.08751653879880905,
0.10343146324157715,
0.34078747034072876,
-0.6174098253250122,
0.13785408437252045,
0.04510083049535751,
-0.9072141051292419,
-0.2638331353664398,
0.17686037719249725,
-0.5157095193862915,
-0.7546514868736267,
-0.23551276326179504,
0.5926660895347595,
-0.12369522452354431,
-0.38808587193489075,
0.09289426356554031,
-0.5226565003395081,
0.34595561027526855,
0.2501137852668762,
-0.6256779432296753,
-0.09338077902793884,
0.8387355208396912,
1.221351981163025,
0.0644846111536026,
0.29009246826171875,
-0.5707838535308838,
0.154290571808815,
-0.6598658561706543,
0.6418819427490234,
-0.43645355105400085,
-0.29138097167015076,
0.47141033411026,
0.2690636217594147,
-0.05171741545200348,
-0.08528641611337662,
0.1469329446554184,
-0.5956146121025085,
-0.41793587803840637,
-0.7139793634414673,
-0.5291457176208496,
-0.10128776729106903,
0.2780820429325104,
-0.6500137448310852,
0.6635413765907288,
-0.026401061564683914,
-0.5766521692276001,
0.2774399220943451,
-0.7182477116584778,
-0.3951849043369293,
0.08696325868368149,
-0.22419239580631256,
-0.04405227676033974,
0.26069894433021545,
-0.35354718565940857,
0.8484216332435608,
-0.10702954977750778,
0.3751415014266968,
-0.33193519711494446,
-0.3641914129257202,
0.13605795800685883,
-0.08182645589113235,
0.77735435962677,
0.10205844044685364,
-0.3981405198574066,
0.4582085907459259,
-0.5108271241188049,
-0.56125408411026,
0.4290487468242645,
-0.2537476718425751,
-0.11807546764612198,
0.4071683883666992,
-0.16955679655075073,
-0.14960695803165436,
-0.07578664273023605,
-0.6096416711807251,
-0.13911214470863342,
0.10291414707899094,
0.829811155796051,
0.60028475522995,
0.4154665172100067,
0.17141523957252502,
-0.435762882232666,
0.7387672066688538,
-0.046552691608667374,
0.46371737122535706,
-0.1369297355413437,
-0.5929300785064697,
-0.231409952044487,
0.07908429205417633,
-0.21791815757751465,
0.3613189458847046,
-0.7983620166778564,
-0.22466625273227692,
-0.17282873392105103,
-0.44551268219947815,
-0.3839153051376343,
0.07521644234657288,
0.10206768661737442,
0.12513545155525208,
0.1855500191450119,
-0.13996708393096924,
-0.40197059512138367,
-0.6511759161949158,
-0.5858124494552612,
-0.23296213150024414,
0.37860846519470215,
-0.412978857755661,
0.2826524078845978,
-0.08460993319749832,
0.4842694401741028,
-0.2894032597541809,
-0.14483559131622314,
-0.42128464579582214,
0.3975313603878021,
-0.040327850729227066,
-0.15900632739067078,
0.3551034927368164,
-1.1746574640274048,
-0.7352564930915833,
-0.05287841707468033,
-0.38733813166618347,
0.11403389275074005,
-0.07437286525964737,
-0.005291040986776352,
-0.022356731817126274,
0.8696593642234802,
-0.33495059609413147,
0.8565090894699097,
0.4436700642108917,
-0.5517479777336121,
0.2277904450893402,
0.5389496684074402,
0.6452717781066895,
-1.287447214126587,
-0.30584004521369934,
0.33513641357421875,
-0.5001879334449768,
-0.8086806535720825,
-0.2726246416568756,
-0.3113369345664978,
-0.17496304214000702,
-0.7403955459594727,
0.40816977620124817,
-0.21720726788043976,
0.09542962908744812,
-0.21487747132778168,
0.10268814116716385,
-0.31842976808547974,
-0.11553674936294556,
0.020792130380868912,
-0.05230313912034035,
0.5285120010375977,
-0.21753239631652832,
0.3482016921043396,
-0.0040352968499064445,
-0.5510222315788269,
0.3204643130302429,
-0.7155515551567078,
0.06135070323944092,
-0.42243555188179016,
0.16673283278942108,
-1.2437015771865845,
-0.275398850440979,
0.6135296821594238,
-0.5646997094154358,
-0.008974414318799973,
-0.2944301664829254,
-0.22616440057754517,
-0.46633297204971313,
-0.42489156126976013,
0.22955511510372162,
0.0013738129055127501,
-0.05826791375875473,
0.5700530409812927,
0.8160788416862488,
0.11745372414588928,
-0.22350271046161652,
-0.6590506434440613,
0.043448589742183685,
-0.5136628746986389,
-0.36196082830429077,
0.12077565491199493,
0.3177129328250885,
-0.4333842098712921,
0.04942856729030609,
0.03924814611673355,
0.029723310843110085,
0.14238770306110382,
0.3733091950416565,
-0.26980653405189514,
-0.10875681787729263,
0.26786288619041443,
-0.09296781569719315,
-0.027022600173950195,
0.10623501986265182,
0.33434441685676575,
0.5625176429748535,
0.0037068009842187166,
-0.3682994246482849,
-0.15049676597118378,
1.0870697498321533,
0.45687562227249146,
-0.060690369457006454,
0.7043991088867188,
1.0619094371795654,
-0.5228639841079712,
0.4551537334918976,
-0.3700001835823059,
-0.10186868906021118,
-0.36119353771209717,
0.033505477011203766,
0.18703117966651917,
-1.0404514074325562,
0.4718165397644043,
-0.1626766473054886,
0.09584986418485641,
0.07328136265277863,
0.6666751503944397,
-0.23680643737316132,
1.0790917873382568,
0.533760130405426,
-0.03471820801496506,
0.6899498105049133,
-0.10500481724739075,
0.4361518621444702,
-0.4428253173828125,
-0.20600895583629608,
-0.41030406951904297,
-0.6016248464584351,
-0.2498890459537506,
-0.704611599445343,
0.2235127091407776,
0.22781793773174286,
-0.32405346632003784,
0.47695019841194153,
-0.5046062469482422,
0.477230966091156,
0.2761354446411133,
-0.00969440396875143,
0.16094131767749786,
-0.13692332804203033,
0.2638435959815979,
0.02758200652897358,
-0.469713419675827,
-0.8119642734527588,
0.6478471755981445,
0.3316528797149658,
0.4290356934070587,
0.39035654067993164,
0.7763906121253967,
0.682837188243866,
0.7266826033592224,
-0.761646568775177,
0.6866593956947327,
0.007778150029480457,
-0.7684613466262817,
-0.12604886293411255,
-0.27504226565361023,
-1.2222951650619507,
0.012061214074492455,
-0.3605448305606842,
-0.8355816602706909,
0.32281938195228577,
0.0066602593287825584,
-0.4520459473133087,
0.5422470569610596,
-0.4999385476112366,
0.960363507270813,
-0.3539590537548065,
-0.12203527241945267,
-0.19425684213638306,
-0.7361689805984497,
-0.07607540488243103,
-0.15123170614242554,
0.41591110825538635,
-0.616400420665741,
-0.04662537947297096,
0.8901070356369019,
-0.14757362008094788,
1.1186449527740479,
-0.2023434340953827,
0.3473230302333832,
0.2687022387981415,
-0.23870693147182465,
0.006189132574945688,
-0.030458612367510796,
0.38264918327331543,
0.19958020746707916,
0.2860509753227234,
-0.22105266153812408,
-0.13410529494285583,
0.3369184136390686,
-0.49734020233154297,
-0.5721498727798462,
-0.1477014273405075,
0.06345050781965256,
-0.05455915629863739,
0.14124822616577148,
0.2812217175960541,
0.4369787275791168,
-0.7332958579063416,
0.36942559480667114,
0.4126264750957489,
0.29648566246032715,
0.8686411380767822,
0.5885792374610901,
-0.1556047797203064,
-0.42841288447380066,
0.5649822950363159,
0.39559027552604675,
0.024549534544348717,
0.391470730304718,
0.43305209279060364,
-0.28107568621635437,
-0.4833068251609802,
-0.516586422920227,
0.08630064874887466,
-0.5073553919792175,
-0.239364355802536,
-0.6724147200584412,
0.10002733021974564,
-0.4462534785270691,
-0.408658504486084,
-0.3320281505584717,
-0.18945394456386566,
-0.2956080436706543,
-0.23631520569324493,
0.365865558385849,
0.7389782667160034,
-0.24843640625476837,
0.5271877646446228,
-0.7963703870773315,
0.4386090934276581,
0.17789463698863983,
0.07677537202835083,
-0.33358678221702576,
-0.04613339900970459,
-0.5367067456245422,
0.19614581763744354,
-0.7667917609214783,
-1.855363130569458,
0.034131694585084915,
-0.2554352879524231,
0.42705968022346497,
0.5480071902275085,
0.42786335945129395,
0.5392245650291443,
-0.506527841091156,
0.7837735414505005,
0.4450194239616394,
-0.8304623365402222,
0.8120883703231812,
-0.6728955507278442,
-0.09174619615077972,
0.4214351773262024,
1.1107664108276367,
-0.6044992208480835,
-0.24830324947834015,
-0.416341632604599,
-0.9066299200057983,
0.15215949714183807,
-0.18969668447971344,
0.49775150418281555,
-0.44267943501472473,
0.3461814522743225,
-0.424919992685318,
0.12745626270771027,
-0.715510904788971,
0.02125929668545723,
-0.29351818561553955,
-0.1336626410484314,
0.007015622220933437,
-0.12880253791809082,
-0.7946988344192505,
-0.27959513664245605,
0.3625618517398834,
-0.2301701158285141,
0.1086941510438919,
0.21329449117183685,
0.23779131472110748,
-0.5336164236068726,
-0.058318573981523514,
0.3540516197681427,
0.6664342284202576,
0.05944475531578064,
-0.1731620728969574,
-0.22554871439933777,
-0.21755899488925934,
0.4204854965209961,
0.004069962538778782,
-0.20946457982063293,
0.19717346131801605,
0.2934008538722992,
1.0598658323287964,
0.19880221784114838,
-0.2517107427120209,
0.5846088528633118,
-0.10439857095479965,
-0.6063308715820312,
-0.3249042332172394,
-0.14494626224040985,
0.5330492258071899,
0.8436678647994995,
0.6067482233047485,
-0.23888076841831207,
0.122043177485466,
-0.839324951171875,
-0.24078235030174255,
0.5040501952171326,
-0.8148491382598877,
-0.4400947093963623,
0.784872829914093,
0.12002979218959808,
-0.9336620569229126,
-0.2171165496110916,
0.009268076159060001,
-0.4650585651397705,
0.291069358587265,
0.20620845258235931,
0.9952846765518188,
-0.1448093205690384,
0.7195620536804199,
0.13485996425151825,
0.38866347074508667,
-0.25741466879844666,
0.025417588651180267,
-0.04802344739437103,
-0.8890882134437561,
-0.2514860928058624,
-0.2644883394241333,
-0.23326024413108826,
-0.029083510860800743,
-0.8799996972084045,
0.18381288647651672,
-0.44843193888664246,
-0.7530351281166077,
0.3820807635784149,
0.11361560225486755,
-0.3287212550640106,
-0.11987557262182236,
0.08639466762542725,
0.709054172039032,
-1.243569254875183,
0.3754110336303711,
1.0392898321151733,
-0.24887534976005554,
-0.5613569021224976,
0.19954238831996918,
0.5263000726699829,
-0.5609778761863708,
0.22799842059612274,
0.36333200335502625,
-0.0806887075304985,
-0.2588692903518677,
-0.5333091616630554,
-0.6044758558273315,
1.039731502532959,
0.4998800456523895,
-0.2835383415222168,
0.38359925150871277,
0.13310591876506805,
0.49535489082336426,
-0.42082205414772034,
-0.34954455494880676,
0.3926395773887634,
0.4553169310092926,
0.11936943978071213,
-0.40810567140579224,
0.07550927996635437,
-0.12894472479820251,
0.14224231243133545,
0.551757276058197,
-1.0669180154800415,
0.24412775039672852,
-0.15511511266231537,
-0.753183901309967,
-0.24097974598407745,
0.3219177722930908,
-0.13854144513607025,
0.6293588876724243,
0.40955275297164917,
0.3343525826931,
0.2465066760778427,
-0.388737291097641,
1.0725071430206299,
-0.3070344924926758,
0.046471789479255676,
0.3657667338848114,
-0.06480586528778076,
0.8651515245437622,
0.5155823826789856,
0.08838601410388947,
0.19222792983055115,
0.7102200984954834,
0.4058012068271637,
0.3769092857837677,
0.15832553803920746,
-0.42150846123695374,
-0.32023024559020996,
-0.014163373969495296,
-0.25116056203842163,
0.5127040147781372,
0.31108060479164124,
-0.32560038566589355,
-0.4713084101676941,
0.17084969580173492,
0.16610904037952423,
0.43323299288749695,
-0.3174709677696228,
0.8096404075622559,
0.07596024125814438,
-0.28705039620399475,
0.07699532061815262,
0.052144844084978104,
0.10649289190769196,
-0.6264399886131287,
0.1411609798669815,
-0.064497210085392,
-0.11881519854068756,
0.08563476800918579,
-0.6928735375404358,
1.0417497158050537,
-0.24524028599262238,
-0.292231023311615,
-0.6074714064598083,
0.8377112746238708,
-0.3470214605331421,
-0.22591780126094818,
0.4755178689956665,
0.5040677189826965,
0.017778128385543823,
-0.197947159409523,
-0.9549479484558105,
0.7504092454910278,
-0.1821199506521225,
-0.3135596215724945,
0.4110623300075531,
0.4392131567001343,
-0.25269508361816406,
0.4895050525665283,
0.5652485489845276,
0.16453786194324493,
0.024670803919434547,
0.060864582657814026,
0.730230987071991,
-0.6495348811149597,
-0.08558611571788788,
-0.9343103766441345,
0.5749738216400146,
-0.344695508480072,
-0.39595505595207214,
0.6850035786628723,
0.2793738842010498,
0.475887656211853,
0.18725772202014923,
0.33711448311805725,
-0.05448973551392555,
0.5417798757553101,
-0.40620723366737366,
0.6842162609100342,
-0.6224534511566162,
-0.2657954692840576,
-0.030348429456353188,
-0.40761706233024597,
-0.3094135522842407,
0.6516208052635193,
-0.27634233236312866,
-0.40537184476852417,
0.17181362211704254,
0.793860912322998,
0.2929985821247101,
0.18395757675170898,
0.20699580013751984,
0.020873920992016792,
0.2958471477031708,
0.12337476015090942,
0.8930203914642334,
-0.21662795543670654,
0.34291595220565796,
0.20348884165287018,
-0.13939647376537323,
-0.3020690679550171,
-0.7971884608268738,
-1.0798237323760986,
-1.013329029083252,
-0.7263023853302002,
-0.42126724123954773,
0.300611674785614,
0.8497161269187927,
0.8719226121902466,
-0.25251510739326477,
-0.07771848887205124,
0.2116561233997345,
0.4789060056209564,
-0.14320237934589386,
-0.21601301431655884,
0.1547892540693283,
0.016838066279888153,
-0.3494146168231964,
0.26322388648986816,
0.43149104714393616,
0.058712031692266464,
-0.17014145851135254,
0.10165414214134216,
-0.42705008387565613,
0.2917343080043793,
0.800682544708252,
0.5557920932769775,
-0.496117502450943,
-0.23468561470508575,
-0.1920701116323471,
0.09904356300830841,
-0.28241315484046936,
1.0920573472976685,
-0.18528731167316437,
0.26472949981689453,
0.5306965708732605,
0.748278021812439,
0.553141176700592,
-0.014401419088244438,
0.534832239151001,
-0.4565836489200592,
-0.1956973373889923,
0.2270338237285614,
0.36476022005081177,
0.43450358510017395,
-0.20424775779247284,
0.6466598510742188,
0.5616207718849182,
-0.3561765253543854,
-0.8022250533103943,
0.17374567687511444,
-0.7752537727355957,
-0.20346780121326447,
1.308500051498413,
0.14480866491794586,
-0.2773623466491699,
-0.441688597202301,
-0.033377621322870255,
0.4390852451324463,
-0.15038460493087769,
0.7781406044960022,
0.8240076899528503,
0.12958316504955292,
-0.4106424152851105,
-0.7491527199745178,
0.4433091878890991,
0.03220120444893837,
-0.40088921785354614,
-0.2577005922794342,
0.3906039297580719,
0.24105055630207062,
0.10934513062238693,
1.275027871131897,
-0.17006129026412964,
0.13552597165107727,
-0.4316084384918213,
-0.4857957661151886,
0.24650554358959198,
-0.251059353351593,
-0.049116600304841995,
0.12140890955924988,
-0.5571835041046143,
-0.3841119706630707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13807v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13807v2 | AlanaVLM: A Multimodal Embodied AI Foundation Model for Egocentric Video Understanding | 2024-06-19T20:14:14 | 2024-06-21T09:53:41 | Alessandro Suglia, Claudio Greco, Katie Baker, Jose L. Part, Ioannis Papaioannou, Arash Eshghi, Ioannis Konstas, Oliver Lemon | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | AI personal assistants deployed via robots or wearables require embodied
understanding to collaborate with humans effectively. However, current
Vision-Language Models (VLMs) primarily focus on third-person view videos,
neglecting the richness of egocentric perceptual experience. To address this
gap, we propose three key contributions. First, we introduce the Egocentric
Video Understanding Dataset (EVUD) for training VLMs on video captioning and
question answering tasks specific to egocentric videos. Second, we present
AlanaVLM, a 7B parameter VLM trained using parameter-efficient methods on EVUD.
Finally, we evaluate AlanaVLM's capabilities on OpenEQA, a challenging
benchmark for embodied video question answering. Our model achieves
state-of-the-art performance, outperforming open-source models including strong
Socratic models using GPT-4 as a planner by 3.6%. Additionally, we outperform
Claude 3 and Gemini Pro Vision 1.0 and showcase competitive results compared to
Gemini Pro 1.5 and GPT-4V, even surpassing the latter in spatial reasoning.
This research paves the way for building efficient VLMs that can be deployed in
robots or wearables, leveraging embodied video understanding to collaborate
seamlessly with humans in everyday tasks, contributing to the next generation
of Embodied AI. | [
-0.5908334255218506,
-0.6824740171432495,
0.6801239252090454,
0.014335863292217255,
-0.20453818142414093,
-0.2793024480342865,
0.012676150538027287,
-0.6802838444709778,
0.07625141739845276,
0.5617695450782776,
-0.8087950348854065,
-0.5464876890182495,
-0.588583767414093,
0.12403535842895508,
-0.5358130931854248,
0.4335923492908478,
-0.11285170167684555,
0.13176600635051727,
-0.5175523161888123,
-0.6579949855804443,
-0.3359730541706085,
-0.5193068385124207,
-0.13373486697673798,
-0.16610345244407654,
0.28137972950935364,
0.404340535402298,
0.6696279644966125,
0.48348191380500793,
0.22263163328170776,
0.37111419439315796,
0.4883185029029846,
0.39819201827049255,
-0.04648841544985771,
0.12216809391975403,
0.2322443127632141,
-0.35072189569473267,
-0.47728270292282104,
-0.1013626903295517,
0.44029051065444946,
0.5307393670082092,
-0.244181826710701,
0.3678063750267029,
-0.12649549543857574,
0.5274414420127869,
-0.6384451985359192,
0.17069265246391296,
-0.296823114156723,
0.24627356231212616,
0.1293688863515854,
0.26518943905830383,
-0.19144360721111298,
0.19557344913482666,
0.000020011106244055554,
-0.7766922116279602,
0.21073226630687714,
0.1999146044254303,
0.5212072730064392,
0.8523395657539368,
-0.04906763136386871,
0.08654322475194931,
-0.794386088848114,
0.3448715806007385,
-0.4656640887260437,
0.8286012411117554,
0.6721946597099304,
0.577905535697937,
0.528303861618042,
-0.6947495341300964,
-0.9788611531257629,
-0.17599156498908997,
0.21005555987358093,
0.10678344964981079,
-0.1553533673286438,
0.38313236832618713,
-0.14971372485160828,
0.09011147171258926,
-0.7580026984214783,
-0.09868588298559189,
-0.44754937291145325,
0.1804121434688568,
0.6733652353286743,
0.2666364014148712,
0.2482338845729828,
-0.11491140723228455,
-0.14909468591213226,
-0.1479848474264145,
-0.25553572177886963,
-0.1903756707906723,
0.17317678034305573,
-0.11099493503570557,
-0.17713911831378937,
0.7085786461830139,
-0.14746534824371338,
1.0647450685501099,
0.1742393523454666,
0.2593613564968109,
0.07229050248861313,
-0.22233520448207855,
-0.6777395606040955,
-0.17527854442596436,
0.358381450176239,
0.26475271582603455,
0.04309802129864693,
-0.11643178015947342,
0.12973418831825256,
-0.0002731072891037911,
0.728945255279541,
-0.49315357208251953,
-0.32135728001594543,
0.38314083218574524,
-0.3730545938014984,
0.1577412486076355,
0.15253902971744537,
-0.2373599112033844,
-0.35299527645111084,
-0.7722802758216858,
0.6470295190811157,
-0.2597510516643524,
-0.009467953816056252,
0.25563234090805054,
0.1415966898202896,
0.536900520324707,
0.7651753425598145,
-0.6346277594566345,
0.3300929665565491,
0.601148784160614,
0.7737249135971069,
0.32334011793136597,
-0.6750347018241882,
-0.5478672981262207,
0.36128664016723633,
-0.23077811300754547,
0.6392633318901062,
-0.3079783618450165,
0.004945533350110054,
0.08821751922369003,
-0.11486617475748062,
0.0911179631948471,
-0.46383029222488403,
0.12063483148813248,
-0.2685546576976776,
0.1983412355184555,
-0.142557293176651,
-0.253860205411911,
-0.6856065392494202,
0.3958127200603485,
-0.5841142535209656,
0.5423474311828613,
-0.13406552374362946,
-0.20528057217597961,
0.4233490526676178,
-0.6962870359420776,
-0.1481586992740631,
0.36137935519218445,
-0.5496612191200256,
-0.2971804141998291,
-0.04137156158685684,
0.304499089717865,
0.679370105266571,
-0.1795102059841156,
0.005446828901767731,
-0.4143286943435669,
-0.10034503042697906,
-0.0317591093480587,
-0.27512186765670776,
0.568581223487854,
0.04659409075975418,
-0.3951738774776459,
0.26030778884887695,
-0.4775354266166687,
-0.18205814063549042,
-0.18018536269664764,
0.3731553852558136,
-0.22590093314647675,
0.016983339563012123,
0.08555475622415543,
0.15767446160316467,
0.06687386333942413,
-0.38288062810897827,
-0.11912957578897476,
-0.18812809884548187,
0.387286514043808,
0.9551653861999512,
-0.3137611448764801,
0.2883865535259247,
-0.19321390986442566,
0.6832548975944519,
-0.25615647435188293,
0.7076771855354309,
-0.07535362988710403,
-0.5119389295578003,
-0.6929436326026917,
-0.4931580424308777,
-0.5527833104133606,
0.15496471524238586,
-0.7832944989204407,
0.1856176257133484,
0.08078205585479736,
-0.3651282787322998,
-0.9521391987800598,
0.36994755268096924,
0.5057913661003113,
0.45337149500846863,
0.3675810396671295,
-0.5772269368171692,
-0.3557499349117279,
-0.9973474144935608,
-0.16045212745666504,
-0.6509024500846863,
0.014258362352848053,
0.8692602515220642,
0.46691781282424927,
-0.3030329644680023,
0.7298890352249146,
-0.391991525888443,
-0.5453348159790039,
-0.10118080675601959,
0.11120638996362686,
0.039709556847810745,
0.07146207243204117,
0.6738383769989014,
-1.1052465438842773,
-0.41433990001678467,
0.13604983687400818,
-1.101463794708252,
0.16306695342063904,
-0.03758973628282547,
-0.03985203802585602,
-0.1245625838637352,
0.3405340909957886,
-0.7039839029312134,
0.6143820881843567,
0.599637508392334,
-0.4708590507507324,
0.548663318157196,
-0.5019312500953674,
0.25985488295555115,
-0.4759018123149872,
0.008780368603765965,
-0.044661249965429306,
-0.616071343421936,
-0.6333770751953125,
0.42961573600769043,
-0.23133984208106995,
-0.052586063742637634,
-0.6361576914787292,
0.6594235897064209,
-0.5686196684837341,
-0.5646524429321289,
-0.07907363772392273,
0.26008060574531555,
-0.0546395517885685,
0.7111332416534424,
0.14612071216106415,
0.677870512008667,
0.5478156805038452,
-0.6570843458175659,
0.6414850950241089,
0.7399215698242188,
-0.3568580150604248,
0.8482909202575684,
-0.8393306136131287,
0.3253500461578369,
-0.5815554261207581,
-0.040957774966955185,
-0.9438314437866211,
-0.5782741904258728,
0.4190933406352997,
-0.6197952628135681,
0.04113171249628067,
-0.003158190753310919,
-0.3430071175098419,
-0.33984702825546265,
-0.06876887381076813,
0.5985804200172424,
0.3102034330368042,
-0.6470080018043518,
1.2139947414398193,
0.3942008912563324,
0.0093464320525527,
-0.4691752791404724,
-0.6431428790092468,
0.010178548283874989,
-0.18993334472179413,
-0.8077253103256226,
-0.031768638640642166,
-0.3523079454898834,
-0.45220947265625,
0.04643798619508743,
0.0159433763474226,
-0.18811418116092682,
-0.014508147723972797,
0.45258787274360657,
0.17396967113018036,
0.007236086763441563,
0.02513546124100685,
-0.18700732290744781,
0.10545244067907333,
0.02705257385969162,
-0.42065030336380005,
0.307618647813797,
-0.3998737931251526,
-0.7598567605018616,
-0.6486107110977173,
0.5050138235092163,
0.7202686071395874,
-0.2934805154800415,
0.7538089156150818,
0.7193209528923035,
-0.324269562959671,
0.05130208656191826,
-0.670539379119873,
-0.12990550696849823,
-0.43019339442253113,
0.6175289750099182,
-0.20256158709526062,
-0.683824360370636,
0.3623591661453247,
0.5182786583900452,
0.19817179441452026,
0.02253124862909317,
0.8701245784759521,
-0.3515826463699341,
0.9912005662918091,
0.725959837436676,
0.09767694026231766,
0.5205721259117126,
-0.3642514944076538,
-0.06841931492090225,
-0.8989455103874207,
-0.514947772026062,
-0.17166969180107117,
-0.3003890812397003,
0.03950135037302971,
-0.6146335005760193,
0.8166178464889526,
-0.4720615744590759,
-0.5927428007125854,
0.2890532314777374,
-0.3430722951889038,
0.33351507782936096,
0.4645560383796692,
0.3266092538833618,
0.19298622012138367,
-0.20111402869224548,
0.32897302508354187,
0.1531362384557724,
-0.6474736332893372,
-0.33206427097320557,
0.8958998918533325,
0.12514540553092957,
0.6607667803764343,
0.38225847482681274,
0.3303689956665039,
0.47846126556396484,
0.2821335196495056,
-0.41477102041244507,
0.5301284193992615,
-0.01748872920870781,
-0.7667689323425293,
-0.36015480756759644,
0.15182183682918549,
-0.6061782836914062,
0.38541215658187866,
0.059151556342840195,
-0.6166268587112427,
0.23547933995723724,
0.48392757773399353,
-0.48209866881370544,
0.13944979012012482,
-0.6106710433959961,
0.8652834892272949,
-0.37048715353012085,
-0.6772984862327576,
-0.34551340341567993,
-0.9537597894668579,
0.32216665148735046,
0.4001023471355438,
0.25801435112953186,
0.15181288123130798,
-0.15894824266433716,
0.31390380859375,
-0.3657347857952118,
0.861076295375824,
-0.30843648314476013,
0.12093397229909897,
0.2848033010959625,
0.05161551386117935,
0.17342941462993622,
0.1402115523815155,
0.37264204025268555,
0.3133658170700073,
-0.31822770833969116,
-0.45362401008605957,
-0.6746124625205994,
0.35481709241867065,
-0.9763189554214478,
-0.6146152019500732,
-0.18213437497615814,
-0.2996559143066406,
-0.06743503361940384,
-0.12692974507808685,
0.07931850850582123,
0.49955806136131287,
-0.08451272547245026,
0.2668955624103546,
0.5927879214286804,
-0.1122150868177414,
0.1452174186706543,
0.3286970853805542,
-0.20390670001506805,
-0.4413530230522156,
0.5035116672515869,
-0.2167976200580597,
0.2531704008579254,
0.31402039527893066,
-0.27841493487358093,
-0.29788538813591003,
-0.20842339098453522,
-0.7294638156890869,
0.36354368925094604,
-0.8485793471336365,
-0.10784082114696503,
-0.8792566657066345,
0.04529798775911331,
-0.32308757305145264,
-0.33876046538352966,
-0.4427841007709503,
-0.1048387959599495,
-0.37627795338630676,
-0.3437599837779999,
0.1976429671049118,
0.8121872544288635,
-0.12932124733924866,
0.1648896336555481,
-0.5799893736839294,
0.6277100443840027,
0.7751566171646118,
0.16456179320812225,
0.1991828829050064,
-0.501961350440979,
-0.3505215048789978,
-0.05037098377943039,
-0.14996831119060516,
-0.821254551410675,
0.5311959385871887,
0.37211155891418457,
0.5716952085494995,
0.5221347212791443,
-0.20953407883644104,
1.0972480773925781,
-0.5680888891220093,
0.8788585662841797,
0.07784048467874527,
-0.7885066270828247,
0.22931508719921112,
-0.21027377247810364,
0.18984158337116241,
0.570339024066925,
0.34090468287467957,
-0.5529102087020874,
-0.21105758845806122,
-0.6249212622642517,
-0.7251985669136047,
0.7059652209281921,
0.3920940160751343,
0.11449704319238663,
0.24756257236003876,
0.48180249333381653,
0.3721982538700104,
0.5600487589836121,
-0.6836032271385193,
-0.27900609374046326,
-0.4543584883213043,
-0.3936097025871277,
-0.364400178194046,
0.1783357411623001,
-0.07462383061647415,
-0.5192761421203613,
0.5790453553199768,
-0.1795593649148941,
0.5092054009437561,
0.5795870423316956,
-0.3138699531555176,
-0.04804239049553871,
-0.4391170144081116,
0.6090531945228577,
0.5650967359542847,
0.040080223232507706,
0.01667415164411068,
0.054458990693092346,
-0.5655427575111389,
0.12295858561992645,
0.014064189977943897,
0.07323752343654633,
-0.11283057928085327,
0.5755696296691895,
0.8746387362480164,
-0.07889460027217865,
-0.8879137635231018,
0.5349071621894836,
-0.18838652968406677,
-0.22416122257709503,
-0.8988572359085083,
0.0033314134925603867,
-0.2930116355419159,
0.6074317097663879,
0.2460649311542511,
0.2807687222957611,
0.41920074820518494,
-0.6682378053665161,
0.09608282148838043,
0.46339282393455505,
-0.47409042716026306,
-0.7261469960212708,
1.1326203346252441,
0.14643628895282745,
-0.4755669832229614,
0.5324328541755676,
0.13042977452278137,
-0.48755499720573425,
0.6202635765075684,
-0.0051292795687913895,
1.14980149269104,
-0.2695203125476837,
0.34763503074645996,
0.11618755757808685,
0.39600175619125366,
0.1429515928030014,
0.22652673721313477,
-0.7773390412330627,
-0.637901246547699,
-0.23675763607025146,
-0.22968150675296783,
-0.40824541449546814,
-0.20406317710876465,
-0.6237195730209351,
0.21213936805725098,
-0.39787331223487854,
0.20313623547554016,
-0.016207749024033546,
-0.39081695675849915,
-1.0864827632904053,
0.10820405185222626,
0.30936554074287415,
0.3955546021461487,
-0.8808258771896362,
0.45337462425231934,
0.8856196999549866,
-0.4313790202140808,
-0.5343289971351624,
-0.20862872898578644,
0.03998409956693649,
-0.9492174386978149,
0.5817044377326965,
0.03535902500152588,
-0.3434883654117584,
-0.04944535344839096,
-0.9192250967025757,
-0.5528053641319275,
1.2600185871124268,
0.38758715987205505,
-0.3646987974643707,
-0.21532854437828064,
-0.25808659195899963,
0.5081880688667297,
-0.378343403339386,
0.4688514173030853,
0.1678425669670105,
0.4794214367866516,
0.13537684082984924,
-0.7788384556770325,
-0.5592031478881836,
-0.30171650648117065,
-0.10786134749650955,
0.019241463392972946,
-0.8696558475494385,
0.7799660563468933,
-0.21224546432495117,
0.2288447916507721,
0.2948116958141327,
0.7953309416770935,
0.10006507486104965,
0.610835611820221,
0.3392738103866577,
0.49247828125953674,
0.4879249632358551,
0.4607001841068268,
1.287248969078064,
0.08391892910003662,
0.0871097594499588,
1.1386967897415161,
-0.39337190985679626,
0.5617188215255737,
0.48443135619163513,
-0.1298210322856903,
0.48395833373069763,
0.2345164716243744,
0.34753477573394775,
0.507174015045166,
-0.3491426408290863,
-0.38295117020606995,
-0.6686737537384033,
0.14429111778736115,
-0.15658290684223175,
0.7661570310592651,
0.1973719298839569,
-0.1888570785522461,
0.1481403112411499,
0.5670121312141418,
-0.395834356546402,
0.19126969575881958,
-0.3152487277984619,
0.9848260879516602,
-0.005832113325595856,
-0.6410304307937622,
0.34085938334465027,
-0.23046875,
0.08032148331403732,
-0.5275075435638428,
-0.23241233825683594,
-0.2057047337293625,
0.29182276129722595,
0.015109206549823284,
-0.4957799017429352,
0.12850037217140198,
0.15312711894512177,
-0.020500456914305687,
-0.18089689314365387,
0.4546624422073364,
-0.39343878626823425,
-0.31900519132614136,
0.14130915701389313,
0.38440826535224915,
0.3531428575515747,
-0.23560400307178497,
-0.5898566246032715,
0.004289097152650356,
-0.12894994020462036,
0.11765679717063904,
0.100088931620121,
0.3634054660797119,
0.0945812314748764,
0.9037540555000305,
0.2892073094844818,
-0.1711139678955078,
0.11550408601760864,
-0.05965521186590195,
0.8355360627174377,
-0.42278969287872314,
-0.584836483001709,
-0.736589252948761,
0.6427900791168213,
0.01977613754570484,
-0.1794772893190384,
0.7366859316825867,
0.2311670333147049,
0.853305459022522,
-0.22509385645389557,
0.6723451018333435,
-0.14440639317035675,
0.0810631662607193,
-0.48127463459968567,
0.5766614675521851,
-0.8916144967079163,
-0.049509190022945404,
-0.39630722999572754,
-0.8466256856918335,
-0.36262983083724976,
1.006835699081421,
-0.10119170695543289,
0.11632207781076431,
0.241596981883049,
0.40558671951293945,
-0.11428225785493851,
-0.006106724962592125,
0.6060261130332947,
0.5092488527297974,
0.3219326138496399,
0.5257319211959839,
0.7152993083000183,
-0.3696174621582031,
0.21934165060520172,
-0.15710218250751495,
-0.22908765077590942,
-0.40102651715278625,
-0.5153362154960632,
-0.9162144660949707,
-1.0716561079025269,
-0.23014241456985474,
0.10558182746171951,
0.3772982060909271,
1.0283993482589722,
1.0706077814102173,
-0.15857215225696564,
-0.2636013627052307,
-0.21524621546268463,
-0.22225844860076904,
-0.38262343406677246,
-0.07567722350358963,
0.11973236501216888,
0.23572255671024323,
-0.6984783411026001,
0.17845667898654938,
0.45033663511276245,
-0.1685619056224823,
-0.7974908351898193,
-0.5468204021453857,
-0.18107135593891144,
0.016762929037213326,
0.8504834771156311,
0.48570889234542847,
-0.9012475609779358,
-0.5606123208999634,
0.21426711976528168,
0.44741564989089966,
0.0642479807138443,
0.5732763409614563,
-0.891914963722229,
0.893697202205658,
0.16213059425354004,
0.6336029767990112,
0.7787398099899292,
0.33180859684944153,
0.5422382354736328,
-0.6558910608291626,
0.38193145394325256,
0.4254370629787445,
0.24864435195922852,
0.39391887187957764,
-0.37720048427581787,
0.4654667377471924,
0.15312357246875763,
-0.5633403062820435,
-0.6484209299087524,
0.2277599275112152,
-0.9578686952590942,
-0.17075981199741364,
0.9684774875640869,
-0.035636983811855316,
-0.5807608366012573,
-0.19474564492702484,
-0.4601891040802002,
0.0029680978041142225,
-0.05315563827753067,
0.7490615248680115,
0.5921760201454163,
-0.3574833571910858,
-0.5389737486839294,
-0.709735631942749,
0.12985631823539734,
0.38968625664711,
-0.8140459656715393,
0.043090227991342545,
0.7214151620864868,
-0.09283016622066498,
-0.12167535722255707,
0.7329608201980591,
0.05217275395989418,
0.7413831353187561,
-0.16476009786128998,
0.18123315274715424,
-0.5239834189414978,
-0.7933717966079712,
-0.42366310954093933,
0.032216206192970276,
0.02386256866157055,
-0.33862462639808655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13805v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13805v1 | WikiContradict: A Benchmark for Evaluating LLMs on Real-World Knowledge Conflicts from Wikipedia | 2024-06-19T20:13:42 | 2024-06-19T20:13:42 | Yufang Hou, Alessandra Pascale, Javier Carnerero-Cano, Tigran Tchrakian, Radu Marinescu, Elizabeth Daly, Inkit Padhi, Prasanna Sattigeri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has emerged as a promising solution to
mitigate the limitations of large language models (LLMs), such as
hallucinations and outdated information. However, it remains unclear how LLMs
handle knowledge conflicts arising from different augmented retrieved passages,
especially when these passages originate from the same source and have equal
trustworthiness. In this work, we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of
LLM-generated answers to questions that have varying answers based on
contradictory passages from Wikipedia, a dataset widely regarded as a
high-quality pre-training resource for most LLMs. Specifically, we introduce
WikiContradict, a benchmark consisting of 253 high-quality, human-annotated
instances designed to assess LLM performance when augmented with retrieved
passages containing real-world knowledge conflicts. We benchmark a diverse
range of both closed and open-source LLMs under different QA scenarios,
including RAG with a single passage, and RAG with 2 contradictory passages.
Through rigorous human evaluations on a subset of WikiContradict instances
involving 5 LLMs and over 3,500 judgements, we shed light on the behaviour and
limitations of these models. For instance, when provided with two passages
containing contradictory facts, all models struggle to generate answers that
accurately reflect the conflicting nature of the context, especially for
implicit conflicts requiring reasoning. Since human evaluation is costly, we
also introduce an automated model that estimates LLM performance using a strong
open-source language model, achieving an F-score of 0.8. Using this automated
metric, we evaluate more than 1,500 answers from seven LLMs across all
WikiContradict instances. To facilitate future work, we release WikiContradict
on: https://ibm.biz/wikicontradict. | [
-0.4833894670009613,
-0.5663528442382812,
0.5080195665359497,
0.1035056859254837,
-0.2560882270336151,
0.18557904660701752,
-0.17600096762180328,
-0.7875053286552429,
0.1520305871963501,
0.2749064862728119,
-0.5727033019065857,
-0.19334079325199127,
-0.5655490159988403,
0.23848308622837067,
-0.34658852219581604,
1.0944262742996216,
-0.31275036931037903,
0.16189147531986237,
-0.6960305571556091,
-0.32098662853240967,
-0.33145445585250854,
-0.23238301277160645,
0.011093832552433014,
-0.4482872188091278,
0.5506832003593445,
0.2284976691007614,
0.48164448142051697,
0.05457073822617531,
0.5218407511711121,
0.30479151010513306,
-0.05817932263016701,
0.2490466982126236,
-0.6551925539970398,
0.7111925482749939,
-0.45457902550697327,
-0.1694420576095581,
-0.07193181663751602,
0.25355765223503113,
0.2890712320804596,
0.4478752017021179,
-0.15039409697055817,
0.7073479890823364,
-0.023489179089665413,
0.6040293574333191,
-0.904133141040802,
-0.23505635559558868,
-0.709448516368866,
0.022964294999837875,
-0.2563706040382385,
-0.03391432389616966,
-0.2267778366804123,
-0.7209197878837585,
0.34769877791404724,
-0.7989929914474487,
0.023507514968514442,
0.01470534224063158,
1.0906662940979004,
0.4758327007293701,
-0.40749824047088623,
-0.43801239132881165,
-0.7419160604476929,
0.43732118606567383,
-0.5608413815498352,
0.4450795352458954,
0.2548941373825073,
0.3426577150821686,
-0.3935483992099762,
-0.8788996934890747,
-0.7448281049728394,
-0.41049912571907043,
0.12516340613365173,
0.4051511287689209,
-0.19005592167377472,
-0.25057855248451233,
0.41394057869911194,
0.007969078607857227,
-0.5576149225234985,
-0.07851622253656387,
-0.3453408479690552,
-0.29406237602233887,
0.5299619436264038,
0.18450209498405457,
0.007498949766159058,
-0.5187034010887146,
-0.5597200393676758,
-0.04235440865159035,
-0.6670138835906982,
0.027643395587801933,
0.6078392863273621,
-0.4285537898540497,
0.182978555560112,
0.7140393853187561,
-0.4772690236568451,
0.639850378036499,
0.11352449655532837,
-0.1786651611328125,
0.19999593496322632,
-0.07565409690141678,
0.09974411875009537,
-0.25341832637786865,
0.7967103719711304,
0.4443032741546631,
0.13806018233299255,
-0.3449879586696625,
-0.2602616846561432,
0.0153293302282691,
0.6302643418312073,
-0.7265587449073792,
-0.12207485735416412,
0.07901253551244736,
-0.20658206939697266,
-0.37606725096702576,
-0.04442102462053299,
-0.6416189074516296,
-0.44939589500427246,
-0.21231204271316528,
0.7615798115730286,
-0.4619830548763275,
-0.27648797631263733,
-0.23776715993881226,
-0.27627044916152954,
0.04873747006058693,
0.4156164526939392,
-0.27950426936149597,
0.10769930481910706,
0.6657394766807556,
0.5680745840072632,
-0.3367915153503418,
-0.25984203815460205,
-0.3739318549633026,
0.05271543189883232,
-0.25849592685699463,
1.131829023361206,
-0.33636534214019775,
-0.2695847749710083,
-0.1841084510087967,
-0.41463688015937805,
0.08122655004262924,
-0.6393746137619019,
0.6870439648628235,
-0.7497168183326721,
0.31703996658325195,
-0.358289510011673,
-0.8182647824287415,
0.03337651863694191,
0.6129412651062012,
-0.6699799299240112,
1.2826786041259766,
0.14017271995544434,
-1.0751547813415527,
0.5267801284790039,
-0.3973308205604553,
-0.08144817501306534,
0.4576326906681061,
-0.321573406457901,
-0.2847926616668701,
0.21196946501731873,
-0.48989588022232056,
0.15080420672893524,
-0.5935215353965759,
0.227240189909935,
-0.3451559245586395,
-0.3975895345211029,
0.43492189049720764,
-0.5193869471549988,
0.5808976888656616,
0.17094369232654572,
-0.4151453673839569,
-0.13109737634658813,
-0.7527793049812317,
0.2140606939792633,
0.11909607797861099,
-0.4853016436100006,
-0.6437453031539917,
0.03478185087442398,
-0.10076557099819183,
0.44383805990219116,
0.46434515714645386,
-0.7421305775642395,
0.01743936911225319,
-0.1954278200864792,
-0.25771263241767883,
0.8907291293144226,
0.08186082541942596,
-0.08625836670398712,
-0.43900707364082336,
0.6956560015678406,
-0.14889736473560333,
0.3023947775363922,
0.3723776340484619,
-0.47214245796203613,
-0.595974326133728,
0.07703044265508652,
0.38526639342308044,
0.47034260630607605,
-0.9628166556358337,
0.30029675364494324,
-0.5039026737213135,
-0.6916364431381226,
-0.707883894443512,
0.08081301301717758,
0.5070098042488098,
0.7856233716011047,
0.22979536652565002,
-0.27722421288490295,
-0.3310391306877136,
-1.0134756565093994,
-0.49356722831726074,
-0.30894213914871216,
0.05972900241613388,
0.4425206780433655,
0.4793473184108734,
0.04536532610654831,
1.0473017692565918,
-0.23502784967422485,
0.1408139020204544,
0.20652006566524506,
0.369040846824646,
-0.03703508898615837,
0.05167737230658531,
0.20878228545188904,
-0.9168375730514526,
-0.7117744088172913,
-0.008567821234464645,
-0.7806767821311951,
-0.3801940679550171,
0.20856553316116333,
-0.10380381345748901,
0.19519124925136566,
0.17080725729465485,
-0.8335230946540833,
0.31977710127830505,
0.7403619885444641,
-0.5027551651000977,
1.0580224990844727,
-0.015570912510156631,
0.41641542315483093,
-1.0983487367630005,
0.3298889398574829,
-0.2834462821483612,
-0.223994180560112,
-0.36653342843055725,
0.10258924961090088,
0.2392791211605072,
0.29984012246131897,
-0.5411661267280579,
0.5872706770896912,
-0.26186808943748474,
-0.13035906851291656,
-0.08469381183385849,
0.4596270024776459,
0.021390845999121666,
0.25770217180252075,
-0.4048483371734619,
1.0276802778244019,
-0.15508344769477844,
-0.32011955976486206,
0.5976448655128479,
0.21872945129871368,
-0.69828861951828,
0.7911590933799744,
-0.3872215151786804,
0.15924707055091858,
0.03914909437298775,
0.2730512022972107,
-0.8163779973983765,
-0.15512162446975708,
0.10769481956958771,
-0.3891535699367523,
-0.0031811720691621304,
-0.26783353090286255,
-0.6958339810371399,
-0.25433892011642456,
-0.42808598279953003,
0.3637066185474396,
0.49913451075553894,
-0.539592981338501,
0.5970430970191956,
0.2737210690975189,
-0.1540149748325348,
-0.9188807010650635,
0.02492450922727585,
0.025258496403694153,
-0.028352191671729088,
-0.6356901526451111,
0.24000971019268036,
-0.3134673237800598,
-0.3603758215904236,
0.30696627497673035,
-0.48573821783065796,
0.10967810451984406,
0.18866963684558868,
0.3928966820240021,
0.27141207456588745,
0.0005718363099731505,
0.11911517381668091,
0.06415080279111862,
-0.07885700464248657,
0.19930312037467957,
-0.16752776503562927,
0.46586838364601135,
0.22656220197677612,
-0.47950127720832825,
0.10014264285564423,
0.04903940483927727,
0.5176161527633667,
-0.07225055247545242,
0.5062515139579773,
0.5124455690383911,
-0.15980049967765808,
-0.1804070621728897,
-1.0150866508483887,
0.08196322619915009,
-0.44507235288619995,
0.36274629831314087,
-0.4370322525501251,
-0.8318264484405518,
0.4710741639137268,
-0.3674459755420685,
0.1366921216249466,
0.5764646530151367,
0.6596349477767944,
-0.40459752082824707,
0.6817343831062317,
0.18202897906303406,
0.13688696920871735,
0.3039722442626953,
-0.01361841056495905,
-0.052908241748809814,
-0.8361669778823853,
-0.48416632413864136,
-0.5189569592475891,
-0.2970527112483978,
-0.6025824546813965,
-0.3774670362472534,
0.4546443223953247,
0.31010085344314575,
0.12470809370279312,
0.34871044754981995,
-0.27951452136039734,
0.7040032148361206,
0.24129422008991241,
-0.14754191040992737,
0.4229423999786377,
-0.24805861711502075,
-0.5561054348945618,
-0.12006519734859467,
-0.5495138168334961,
-0.5335419178009033,
1.1753634214401245,
0.08022569864988327,
0.6368027329444885,
0.34986796975135803,
0.7645105719566345,
0.2976416349411011,
0.8026546239852905,
-0.5275547504425049,
0.5278190970420837,
0.08580512553453445,
-0.7951140403747559,
-0.09382119029760361,
-0.6935154795646667,
-0.8661068677902222,
0.4964894950389862,
-0.475178986787796,
-0.5514198541641235,
-0.06805974990129471,
-0.027346443384885788,
0.018456067889928818,
0.2264622002840042,
-0.6922122240066528,
0.7769806385040283,
-0.24628208577632904,
-0.5283700823783875,
-0.30106714367866516,
-0.4173421561717987,
0.5477845668792725,
-0.3046432435512543,
0.07165980339050293,
-0.3928651213645935,
-0.14053292572498322,
0.8166114687919617,
-0.22659949958324432,
0.4495837092399597,
-0.177180215716362,
-0.18876369297504425,
0.02855627052485943,
0.20724308490753174,
0.5109187364578247,
-0.009097683243453503,
-0.04574878141283989,
0.1319587081670761,
0.25834742188453674,
-0.23820112645626068,
-0.5616704225540161,
0.8696087598800659,
-0.8702473044395447,
-0.6759650707244873,
-0.43557029962539673,
-0.5172911286354065,
-0.44709882140159607,
0.31133317947387695,
0.4907836616039276,
0.2807530164718628,
-0.5318540334701538,
-0.07013638317584991,
0.7243271470069885,
-0.1171635314822197,
0.046180032193660736,
0.7978507876396179,
-0.15343652665615082,
-0.3489048480987549,
0.8550981879234314,
0.2599409520626068,
0.3250933587551117,
0.12494295835494995,
0.056284647434949875,
-0.26534610986709595,
-0.6053361296653748,
-0.38814032077789307,
0.16021935641765594,
-0.8169542551040649,
-0.5931294560432434,
-0.543839156627655,
-0.11493843048810959,
-0.18003462255001068,
0.2684590518474579,
-0.32552215456962585,
-0.6621066927909851,
0.1883809119462967,
0.11650533974170685,
0.3432818651199341,
1.0898557901382446,
0.12482533603906631,
-0.3922262489795685,
-0.7018765211105347,
0.392328143119812,
0.31679245829582214,
0.5893836617469788,
-0.15821534395217896,
-0.46773701906204224,
-0.40876299142837524,
-0.17195691168308258,
-0.5494418144226074,
-0.8938215374946594,
-0.08060352504253387,
-0.2195366621017456,
0.729202151298523,
0.025057943537831306,
0.3472447395324707,
0.7525540590286255,
-0.6474872827529907,
0.6133285760879517,
0.12340711802244186,
-0.6618590950965881,
0.2265804558992386,
-0.10772232711315155,
0.16694718599319458,
0.7455853223800659,
0.5011491775512695,
-0.6365823149681091,
-0.7367539405822754,
-0.6993977427482605,
-0.8547878265380859,
0.4632205367088318,
0.16180692613124847,
-0.04816456884145737,
-0.05796030908823013,
0.5290037393569946,
0.214486226439476,
0.04552237316966057,
-0.5234426259994507,
-0.2732188105583191,
-0.06717709451913834,
-0.324575811624527,
0.34339869022369385,
-0.2695331275463104,
-0.3481880724430084,
-0.05583928897976875,
0.7326663136482239,
0.05409036949276924,
0.024224713444709778,
0.15864011645317078,
-0.4789552092552185,
-0.34811437129974365,
0.2765790522098541,
0.6520838141441345,
0.8495420217514038,
-0.1890586018562317,
0.05466363579034805,
0.36279818415641785,
-0.7542474865913391,
0.3146936893463135,
0.3769330382347107,
-0.33133578300476074,
0.07136361300945282,
0.49133652448654175,
0.4170481562614441,
0.21128207445144653,
-0.9155115485191345,
0.7710159420967102,
-0.31031298637390137,
-0.2679149806499481,
-0.4738543927669525,
0.0961383506655693,
0.1335970014333725,
0.3944070339202881,
0.5145724415779114,
0.0883830115199089,
0.11526893824338913,
-0.06969168037176132,
0.2774650454521179,
0.5633671879768372,
-0.11586672812700272,
-0.24275636672973633,
0.39432230591773987,
0.3198987543582916,
-0.23797911405563354,
0.28178104758262634,
-0.2336951047182083,
-0.5752409100532532,
0.23826909065246582,
0.09898047894239426,
0.8252000212669373,
-0.16548587381839752,
0.14711777865886688,
0.18249750137329102,
0.18237967789173126,
0.20788554847240448,
0.07106876373291016,
-0.17584630846977234,
-0.695702075958252,
-0.6528361439704895,
-0.628755509853363,
-0.665124773979187,
0.0669592022895813,
-0.7829668521881104,
-0.033724285662174225,
-0.4394706189632416,
-0.34161263704299927,
-0.09962035715579987,
0.41252365708351135,
-0.7739576101303101,
-0.1313030868768692,
-0.14002494513988495,
1.1330859661102295,
-0.5772448778152466,
0.9075408577919006,
0.6799774765968323,
-0.39997586607933044,
-0.5348578095436096,
0.34601330757141113,
-0.0931176170706749,
-0.5773628950119019,
0.8172078132629395,
-0.11979684978723526,
-0.284273236989975,
-0.18050768971443176,
-0.38346001505851746,
-0.7067713141441345,
1.2475496530532837,
0.5144177079200745,
-0.5218415260314941,
0.1172623336315155,
-0.11172021925449371,
0.5119602084159851,
0.1080818921327591,
0.24562814831733704,
0.46286001801490784,
0.4189513325691223,
-0.0818760097026825,
-1.0521957874298096,
-0.02020886167883873,
-0.3427076041698456,
-0.17861026525497437,
0.32617348432540894,
-0.5722892880439758,
0.5173470377922058,
0.08786020427942276,
-0.2381884902715683,
0.18540865182876587,
0.4096890687942505,
0.38834837079048157,
0.16514453291893005,
0.5897698402404785,
0.6856377124786377,
0.637125551700592,
-0.07422758638858795,
1.0206561088562012,
-0.33324846625328064,
0.4048473536968231,
1.0128782987594604,
-0.44860145449638367,
1.062424659729004,
0.7291366457939148,
-0.17607998847961426,
0.5976533889770508,
0.3476533591747284,
0.14848554134368896,
0.4562093913555145,
0.1786985993385315,
-0.4878637492656708,
-0.11335977166891098,
-0.1024816557765007,
-0.26393356919288635,
0.2613060176372528,
0.13737867772579193,
0.1360464245080948,
-0.2534748613834381,
-0.07845202833414078,
-0.08756674826145172,
0.15928374230861664,
0.24542216956615448,
1.0784555673599243,
-0.22505679726600647,
-0.7861098051071167,
0.5025557279586792,
-0.08691816031932831,
0.71088707447052,
-0.7171459794044495,
-0.12089889496564865,
-0.287207692861557,
0.006328024435788393,
-0.10926050692796707,
-0.7922308444976807,
0.01650158502161503,
0.32294154167175293,
-0.17729881405830383,
0.003518171375617385,
0.6487815380096436,
-0.35090216994285583,
-0.3011421263217926,
0.4615589380264282,
0.5032449960708618,
0.056257955729961395,
0.3649175763130188,
-0.7500330805778503,
0.25992196798324585,
-0.07717204093933105,
-0.5266098976135254,
0.46443450450897217,
0.6560063362121582,
0.0027004678267985582,
0.6777838468551636,
0.6727352738380432,
0.3591989576816559,
0.08583850413560867,
-0.06900673359632492,
1.059252381324768,
-0.4204149544239044,
-0.14263297617435455,
-0.4992150366306305,
0.3930896520614624,
-0.3096265196800232,
-0.442434161901474,
0.9082217216491699,
0.5975792407989502,
0.9463667869567871,
0.15626375377178192,
0.7240040302276611,
-0.13840748369693756,
0.8360351920127869,
-0.44399431347846985,
0.8079091906547546,
-0.482376366853714,
0.289982408285141,
-0.31699323654174805,
-0.9450981616973877,
0.15868088603019714,
0.6120212078094482,
-0.2528458535671234,
-0.007556302938610315,
0.5144609212875366,
0.5642548203468323,
-0.0959111899137497,
-0.03708450868725777,
0.5108320116996765,
0.3473031222820282,
0.3396185338497162,
0.3202630877494812,
1.1740281581878662,
-0.3836357593536377,
0.7794245481491089,
-0.33568984270095825,
-0.06062884256243706,
-0.16033048927783966,
-0.8516939282417297,
-0.6475709080696106,
-0.6510507464408875,
-0.10202566534280777,
-0.5279179811477661,
0.1592523753643036,
1.1162492036819458,
0.47456687688827515,
-0.5364614725112915,
-0.07136091589927673,
0.3498031795024872,
0.2158147245645523,
0.06736046075820923,
-0.21302084624767303,
0.12459448724985123,
-0.325345516204834,
-0.38623788952827454,
0.29590174555778503,
0.06547185033559799,
-0.15678559243679047,
-0.4994700849056244,
-0.4036795496940613,
-0.16795726120471954,
0.18516167998313904,
0.538150429725647,
0.12623581290245056,
-0.7926105260848999,
-0.4815831482410431,
-0.2286691665649414,
-0.2862192988395691,
-0.3002379238605499,
0.898418128490448,
-0.924576997756958,
0.4490591287612915,
0.3956316411495209,
0.6556736826896667,
0.6674582958221436,
-0.016452904790639877,
0.39139237999916077,
-0.7896819114685059,
-0.0211785975843668,
0.41616514325141907,
0.13943685591220856,
0.2975238263607025,
-0.18513450026512146,
0.4416731297969818,
0.3291333019733429,
-0.5227560997009277,
-0.9069764614105225,
0.12912717461585999,
-0.6459927558898926,
-0.29523858428001404,
0.8992617130279541,
-0.2641231119632721,
0.022577326744794846,
-0.2730052173137665,
0.0062467437237501144,
0.06856243312358856,
-0.1488315314054489,
1.0127627849578857,
0.8758956789970398,
0.003203387139365077,
0.048235081136226654,
-0.741836667060852,
0.5839282274246216,
0.3203194737434387,
-0.8599354028701782,
0.20233884453773499,
0.6126606464385986,
0.6565433740615845,
0.26233112812042236,
0.4942317008972168,
-0.05504420027136803,
0.5709198117256165,
-0.0858941450715065,
0.13080371916294098,
-0.17210960388183594,
-0.13516709208488464,
-0.15425975620746613,
0.09063219279050827,
0.2996082305908203,
0.15514442324638367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13803v1 | Semantic Structure-Mapping in LLM and Human Analogical Reasoning | 2024-06-19T20:07:37 | 2024-06-19T20:07:37 | Sam Musker, Alex Duchnowski, Raphaël Millière, Ellie Pavlick | cs.CL | cs.CL | Analogical reasoning is considered core to human learning and cognition.
Recent studies have compared the analogical reasoning abilities of human
subjects and Large Language Models (LLMs) on abstract symbol manipulation
tasks, such as letter string analogies. However, these studies largely neglect
analogical reasoning over semantically meaningful symbols, such as natural
language words. This ability to draw analogies that link language to
non-linguistic domains, which we term semantic structure-mapping, is thought to
play a crucial role in language acquisition and broader cognitive development.
We test human subjects and LLMs on analogical reasoning tasks that require the
transfer of semantic structure and content from one domain to another. Advanced
LLMs match human performance across many task variations. However, humans and
LLMs respond differently to certain task variations and semantic distractors.
Overall, our data suggest that LLMs are approaching human-level performance on
these important cognitive tasks, but are not yet entirely human like. | [
-0.33023667335510254,
-0.8859806656837463,
0.7348132133483887,
-0.25436052680015564,
-0.1972808688879013,
0.08270686864852905,
-0.2111365646123886,
-0.8137590885162354,
0.14300855994224548,
0.43152734637260437,
-0.5512000918388367,
-0.6469345688819885,
-0.5276725888252258,
0.17628324031829834,
-0.2437005341053009,
0.531216025352478,
-0.26850971579551697,
0.023610247299075127,
-0.28882086277008057,
-0.0794016569852829,
-0.3494330942630768,
-0.674700915813446,
-0.5455239415168762,
-0.6225332021713257,
0.49872612953186035,
0.15224634110927582,
0.7063377499580383,
0.8055862784385681,
0.5337732434272766,
0.3633338510990143,
-0.2830236554145813,
-0.1261591613292694,
-0.29138779640197754,
0.053287528455257416,
-0.5266742706298828,
-0.6927638053894043,
-0.7783879041671753,
-0.06119846925139427,
0.614788293838501,
1.2899094820022583,
0.12417442351579666,
0.18788565695285797,
-0.011304515413939953,
0.7360049486160278,
-0.42479991912841797,
0.36582404375076294,
-0.7000734210014343,
-0.2862156927585602,
-0.046859122812747955,
-0.191286101937294,
-0.0405568964779377,
-0.2934829592704773,
0.25350162386894226,
-0.9284453988075256,
0.26236891746520996,
0.47082021832466125,
0.7964454889297485,
0.08542387187480927,
-0.45932644605636597,
-0.456068217754364,
-0.4938422441482544,
0.7013728022575378,
-0.5459410548210144,
0.3085697889328003,
0.397053062915802,
0.03297444432973862,
-0.5819208025932312,
-0.4147024154663086,
-0.5678959488868713,
-0.5373747944831848,
-0.06926708668470383,
-0.1084662452340126,
0.05061474069952965,
0.3394130766391754,
0.4476155936717987,
0.15076687932014465,
-0.5171127915382385,
0.24958087503910065,
-0.5924195647239685,
-0.24215808510780334,
0.4708440899848938,
0.3300478756427765,
0.7125964164733887,
-0.13815878331661224,
-0.617618203163147,
-0.17797298729419708,
-1.0067665576934814,
-0.018651098012924194,
0.4203904867172241,
0.3712382912635803,
0.019293593242764473,
0.7092961072921753,
-0.2383916825056076,
0.9026952981948853,
-0.25519055128097534,
-0.2636544108390808,
0.061773672699928284,
-0.31915879249572754,
0.03617766872048378,
0.2541857063770294,
0.4439554214477539,
0.5971679091453552,
0.7317795753479004,
-0.24861782789230347,
-0.0863034576177597,
0.7033728361129761,
0.21063776314258575,
-0.4559670686721802,
-0.1953524351119995,
-0.012503605335950851,
-0.373129278421402,
0.08489584177732468,
-0.004657846875488758,
-0.3768095374107361,
0.03692453354597092,
-0.5701783299446106,
0.4361319839954376,
-0.448797345161438,
-0.11461993306875229,
0.31724998354911804,
-0.28648683428764343,
0.37898632884025574,
0.34411704540252686,
-1.0496876239776611,
0.6827163100242615,
0.8065276145935059,
0.462715744972229,
-0.5585648417472839,
-0.535513699054718,
0.089696004986763,
0.2941572368144989,
-0.4322170913219452,
1.0026590824127197,
-0.5208625793457031,
-0.44429510831832886,
-0.18714600801467896,
-0.053542837500572205,
-0.11770759522914886,
-0.7550103068351746,
0.5514616370201111,
-0.3734031915664673,
-0.022816181182861328,
-0.505953848361969,
-0.575894296169281,
-0.5239675045013428,
0.4195795953273773,
-0.5519066452980042,
0.8140860199928284,
0.35703375935554504,
-0.4150301218032837,
0.2670272886753082,
-0.45373857021331787,
-0.6000044345855713,
-0.06510373204946518,
-0.3140837252140045,
0.02350856550037861,
0.17353801429271698,
-0.15485578775405884,
0.19539107382297516,
-0.5570163726806641,
-0.07361992448568344,
-0.4398667812347412,
-0.7392871379852295,
0.3340483605861664,
0.19329440593719482,
0.5926828980445862,
-0.07232798635959625,
-0.26452237367630005,
0.30797117948532104,
-0.5979898571968079,
0.09179828315973282,
0.08770940452814102,
-0.24480481445789337,
-0.5997151136398315,
0.19949713349342346,
-0.015809783712029457,
0.5206114649772644,
0.09228300303220749,
-0.5770359039306641,
0.22934682667255402,
-0.7021740674972534,
0.6057131886482239,
0.5760418176651001,
-0.18687328696250916,
0.5614623427391052,
-0.626481831073761,
0.3819827735424042,
0.14356361329555511,
-0.35578230023384094,
-0.04310602694749832,
-0.5747597813606262,
-0.66184002161026,
-0.27516141533851624,
0.05261312052607536,
0.49563854932785034,
-0.2918950021266937,
0.5490507483482361,
-0.46132344007492065,
-0.2743982672691345,
-0.4563852846622467,
0.1326778382062912,
0.4034328758716583,
0.6026288270950317,
0.35007473826408386,
-0.5287773609161377,
-0.3436164855957031,
-0.9229379296302795,
-0.30165189504623413,
-0.5165449976921082,
-0.2845228910446167,
0.006003640126436949,
0.5511885285377502,
-0.10694446414709091,
0.7214369177818298,
-0.39859738945961,
-0.49148958921432495,
-0.19517716765403748,
0.037415117025375366,
-0.06442639976739883,
0.18975499272346497,
0.3079182505607605,
-0.7009429335594177,
-0.0016578378854319453,
-0.05110969766974449,
-0.6175898313522339,
-0.16595493257045746,
0.0078009143471717834,
-0.143893301486969,
0.0767742395401001,
0.5403613448143005,
-0.7149161696434021,
0.3760501444339752,
0.1673639565706253,
-0.5142638087272644,
0.4943276345729828,
-0.2949684262275696,
0.2451457381248474,
-0.8293357491493225,
-0.03601325675845146,
-0.1228640228509903,
0.04127110540866852,
-0.49132978916168213,
0.23483189940452576,
-0.05342797189950943,
0.05273287370800972,
-0.5519536733627319,
0.6531369090080261,
-0.6882612109184265,
-0.48128437995910645,
-0.3830268681049347,
0.5135727524757385,
-0.02713259682059288,
0.6068812608718872,
0.10304442793130875,
0.6165947318077087,
0.4746754765510559,
-0.61998051404953,
0.21515661478042603,
0.09464655816555023,
-0.2937859892845154,
0.651279628276825,
-0.8076640963554382,
-0.11709029227495193,
0.004431554581969976,
0.22383321821689606,
-1.0216180086135864,
-0.08060115575790405,
0.2706206440925598,
-0.3405328392982483,
0.1494232565164566,
0.3479149043560028,
-0.6546309590339661,
-0.10003753751516342,
-0.34162309765815735,
0.6376724243164062,
0.6605700254440308,
-0.17305919528007507,
0.7075057625770569,
0.19125370681285858,
-0.025372570380568504,
0.038158923387527466,
-0.6146503686904907,
-0.06269339472055435,
-0.37300705909729004,
-0.6636600494384766,
0.4998336732387543,
0.08609747141599655,
-0.48252996802330017,
0.2381102442741394,
-0.3206765949726105,
-0.008428988046944141,
0.36347031593322754,
0.4263920485973358,
0.4034877419471741,
-0.44842711091041565,
-0.08831679821014404,
-0.14730669558048248,
-0.17405976355075836,
0.48425528407096863,
-0.09688512980937958,
0.22585493326187134,
-0.2382524013519287,
-0.6471526622772217,
-0.28742483258247375,
0.3096136748790741,
0.5897265672683716,
0.14903020858764648,
0.5281444191932678,
0.042203180491924286,
-0.42097145318984985,
0.045118097215890884,
-0.3940507471561432,
-0.3875722289085388,
-0.37204012274742126,
0.5181566476821899,
-0.6682256460189819,
-0.9499529004096985,
0.6128424406051636,
-0.29252734780311584,
-0.1398128867149353,
0.5722512602806091,
0.7630175352096558,
-0.42973196506500244,
0.6307988166809082,
0.24989080429077148,
0.1965949535369873,
0.043157417327165604,
0.017008477821946144,
0.03769325464963913,
-1.0296685695648193,
-0.07376278191804886,
-0.5073117017745972,
-0.5887261629104614,
-0.6268551349639893,
-0.4417625665664673,
0.049298062920570374,
0.1310379058122635,
-0.1213330626487732,
0.3979146480560303,
-0.3387168049812317,
0.3697119355201721,
0.28452154994010925,
-0.06686560064554214,
0.4826841950416565,
-0.0823097825050354,
-0.20189732313156128,
-0.07571481913328171,
-0.4567916691303253,
-0.6974173784255981,
1.1103217601776123,
0.09988516569137573,
0.862777054309845,
-0.019427355378866196,
0.48487910628318787,
-0.10347822308540344,
0.24803026020526886,
-0.9049879908561707,
0.8769565224647522,
-0.08816879242658615,
-0.5187016129493713,
-0.2585532069206238,
-0.23906265199184418,
-1.1248730421066284,
0.6717438101768494,
-0.2977333664894104,
-0.8350715041160583,
-0.05419451743364334,
0.10706788301467896,
0.1593569964170456,
0.33580538630485535,
-0.7311033606529236,
0.6433125734329224,
-0.0925469622015953,
0.20392850041389465,
-0.31194907426834106,
-0.8287560343742371,
0.33094164729118347,
-0.11162995547056198,
0.292337030172348,
-0.4561055898666382,
-0.2662622034549713,
0.5286732316017151,
0.02021181397140026,
0.8686921000480652,
0.31698858737945557,
-0.005678224842995405,
0.23178942501544952,
0.36842209100723267,
0.21567969024181366,
-0.5913288593292236,
0.11318247020244598,
0.3251403272151947,
0.11262547224760056,
-0.568859875202179,
-0.8417940735816956,
0.6860424280166626,
-0.7172914743423462,
-0.9047307968139648,
-0.4509392976760864,
-0.8491626381874084,
-0.135128453373909,
-0.029758552089333534,
-0.027430085465312004,
0.16649986803531647,
-0.1513299196958542,
0.08285702019929886,
0.5948309302330017,
0.23829242587089539,
0.06861330568790436,
0.3648013770580292,
-0.054661769419908524,
0.1119944155216217,
0.6422138810157776,
0.03524333983659744,
0.6369436383247375,
0.6796790957450867,
0.295257031917572,
-0.2613440752029419,
-0.6641368269920349,
-0.3342612683773041,
0.27821511030197144,
-0.7990677952766418,
0.20638234913349152,
-0.3840666711330414,
-0.08434360474348068,
-0.10016477853059769,
-0.354383260011673,
-0.13131482899188995,
-0.6135888695716858,
-0.14244425296783447,
-0.07094467431306839,
0.0704539567232132,
0.4744543731212616,
0.33895283937454224,
-0.07905073463916779,
-0.44054797291755676,
0.6509671211242676,
0.2279367744922638,
-0.06356959044933319,
-0.013635313138365746,
-0.45556581020355225,
0.13286840915679932,
0.062058690935373306,
-0.32303786277770996,
-0.8663926124572754,
-0.17559398710727692,
0.21273690462112427,
0.7175942063331604,
0.16196303069591522,
-0.09733785688877106,
0.734042227268219,
-0.5141481161117554,
0.66402268409729,
0.1869758814573288,
-0.7652322053909302,
0.4830913841724396,
-0.2686484456062317,
0.48521342873573303,
0.20126865804195404,
0.3389868140220642,
-0.4165799617767334,
-0.5891117453575134,
-0.3954383432865143,
-0.8851780891418457,
0.4289277195930481,
0.2542930543422699,
-0.08400388062000275,
-0.09210889786481857,
0.5689504742622375,
-0.022793632000684738,
-0.06773559004068375,
-0.46696680784225464,
-0.16178850829601288,
0.15591633319854736,
-0.2961341142654419,
-0.006131416652351618,
-0.08994948863983154,
-0.2092732936143875,
-0.277593731880188,
0.12028896808624268,
-0.1650536209344864,
0.1609049141407013,
0.17470380663871765,
-0.32304513454437256,
-0.20772401988506317,
0.4142409563064575,
0.7519542574882507,
0.9478164315223694,
-0.1861116737127304,
0.4885895550251007,
0.38914281129837036,
-0.3360198438167572,
0.34035077691078186,
-0.061132125556468964,
-0.003758489154279232,
-0.3751640319824219,
0.8388804793357849,
0.5386504530906677,
0.8357911109924316,
-0.9223118424415588,
0.2171301692724228,
0.36308079957962036,
-0.3475111126899719,
-0.12353869527578354,
0.37026092410087585,
0.4318764805793762,
0.1191728338599205,
0.17671966552734375,
-0.11138826608657837,
0.10123700648546219,
-0.854863703250885,
0.05208802968263626,
0.43943414092063904,
-0.2314218133687973,
-0.6259990930557251,
0.7313136458396912,
-0.09188499301671982,
-0.46596118807792664,
0.5546578168869019,
0.19566316902637482,
-0.4477532207965851,
0.7560920119285583,
0.7777308225631714,
0.829878568649292,
-0.017542626708745956,
-0.33816835284233093,
0.19679555296897888,
0.36459508538246155,
-0.07646746933460236,
0.3268471658229828,
-0.15416045486927032,
-0.7873952984809875,
-0.3825664818286896,
-0.5500877499580383,
-0.28327861428260803,
-0.35692891478538513,
-0.7344599962234497,
0.22727668285369873,
-0.2324276566505432,
-0.10651422291994095,
-0.13738581538200378,
-0.19983798265457153,
-0.6155111193656921,
0.31069180369377136,
0.03008153848350048,
0.8597312569618225,
-0.9123204946517944,
0.932081401348114,
0.9886729717254639,
-0.3243669867515564,
-0.5904141664505005,
-0.07005798816680908,
-0.04073118418455124,
-0.8043418526649475,
1.1717414855957031,
0.013314100913703442,
-0.42805272340774536,
-0.17784841358661652,
-0.12222600728273392,
-0.821785032749176,
1.2096697092056274,
0.3950387239456177,
-0.2539355456829071,
-0.43000754714012146,
0.24712371826171875,
0.8557027578353882,
-0.5922514796257019,
0.12626299262046814,
0.4931879937648773,
0.2591840922832489,
0.38359421491622925,
-0.816777229309082,
0.3803320527076721,
0.20541149377822876,
0.3746381998062134,
0.33461493253707886,
-0.19639867544174194,
0.746428906917572,
-0.21294867992401123,
-0.32127296924591064,
0.04216832295060158,
0.6584506034851074,
0.7274121642112732,
0.10451558232307434,
0.5907790064811707,
0.6171488761901855,
0.26739972829818726,
-0.0534672886133194,
1.017556071281433,
-0.2310580611228943,
0.05320628732442856,
1.0932865142822266,
-0.3450391888618469,
1.1062465906143188,
0.8522891998291016,
-0.2388191819190979,
0.573503851890564,
0.531520664691925,
0.3121931552886963,
0.2328139841556549,
0.6248096227645874,
0.12013901770114899,
-0.2814648151397705,
0.08050709962844849,
-0.2278384417295456,
0.35129085183143616,
0.551002025604248,
-0.1422116458415985,
-0.40128278732299805,
-0.4426449239253998,
-0.0549725778400898,
0.3521164655685425,
-0.13609808683395386,
0.7041113972663879,
0.30300119519233704,
-0.5707283616065979,
0.6073207855224609,
0.08957509696483612,
0.3792860209941864,
-0.6813386082649231,
-0.18438085913658142,
0.0685330480337143,
-0.091959647834301,
0.06323495507240295,
-0.8199203610420227,
0.5348552465438843,
-0.4697711765766144,
-0.2036043256521225,
-0.1996678113937378,
0.7703059911727905,
-0.4888521730899811,
-0.3299558162689209,
0.6464908719062805,
0.5424977540969849,
0.31314975023269653,
0.0414704754948616,
-0.5149238109588623,
0.12364724278450012,
-0.39832615852355957,
-0.26118871569633484,
0.5573249459266663,
0.34186670184135437,
-0.4781951606273651,
0.842560350894928,
0.7036259174346924,
0.32226988673210144,
0.11493322253227234,
-0.21666616201400757,
0.836848258972168,
-0.968549907207489,
-0.3931593596935272,
-0.899261474609375,
0.18885654211044312,
0.30599403381347656,
-0.2938801050186157,
0.6166515350341797,
0.4495179057121277,
1.0166208744049072,
-0.14272794127464294,
0.18225683271884918,
0.24196095764636993,
0.19963163137435913,
-0.5934630036354065,
0.4298670291900635,
-0.5296145081520081,
0.11712699383497238,
-0.2305123209953308,
-1.1990536451339722,
-0.2676968574523926,
0.5720186233520508,
-0.2238766849040985,
-0.10223112255334854,
1.0187530517578125,
0.707126796245575,
-0.12165858596563339,
-0.06023440882563591,
0.5986775755882263,
0.22632455825805664,
0.1263660043478012,
0.826955258846283,
0.8814899921417236,
-0.28197410702705383,
0.34401944279670715,
0.12794871628284454,
-0.16681112349033356,
-0.11461960524320602,
-0.766456663608551,
-1.073103666305542,
-0.6797217130661011,
-0.3166797459125519,
-0.04669569805264473,
0.04115593805909157,
0.9276314973831177,
0.5776570439338684,
-0.6314114332199097,
-0.5267554521560669,
-0.050599705427885056,
0.31593871116638184,
-0.3505658507347107,
-0.18062745034694672,
0.47510629892349243,
-0.19270142912864685,
-0.6230195164680481,
0.2206512987613678,
0.5197868347167969,
0.012810834683477879,
-0.4266285300254822,
0.08222810178995132,
-0.17875699698925018,
0.06902341544628143,
0.5594273805618286,
0.23334430158138275,
-1.4679096937179565,
-0.4067651331424713,
-0.09126709401607513,
-0.33913281559944153,
0.16626578569412231,
0.9363572597503662,
-0.6997044682502747,
0.3700118958950043,
0.6152193546295166,
0.5232224464416504,
0.3283981382846832,
-0.005889347288757563,
0.44681987166404724,
-0.35097506642341614,
0.2897094488143921,
0.08306428790092468,
0.2886069416999817,
0.24930749833583832,
-0.12412791699171066,
0.39996808767318726,
0.44740068912506104,
-0.31264182925224304,
-0.5772169828414917,
0.49704796075820923,
-1.2302888631820679,
-0.3807344436645508,
1.1047005653381348,
-0.11266026645898819,
-0.5622332096099854,
-0.22427374124526978,
-0.21627135574817657,
0.06897043436765671,
-0.04397285729646683,
0.8015661835670471,
0.9357839822769165,
-0.3357403576374054,
0.11957508325576782,
-0.47697553038597107,
0.24796932935714722,
0.34756919741630554,
-0.9126912355422974,
-0.3374038636684418,
0.3270162343978882,
0.4639037251472473,
0.06494558602571487,
0.5751805305480957,
-0.22990523278713226,
0.31169191002845764,
-0.09763914346694946,
0.16504162549972534,
0.04125262424349785,
-0.11299415677785873,
-0.007799509912729263,
0.26490238308906555,
0.1840260773897171,
-0.22850926220417023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13791v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13791v2 | IoT-Based Preventive Mental Health Using Knowledge Graphs and Standards for Better Well-Being | 2024-06-19T19:35:14 | 2024-06-29T15:29:56 | Amelie Gyrard, Seyedali Mohammadi, Manas Gaur, Antonio Kung | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) give the UN a road map for development
with Agenda 2030 as a target. SDG3 "Good Health and Well-Being" ensures healthy
lives and promotes well-being for all ages. Digital technologies can support
SDG3. Burnout and even depression could be reduced by encouraging better
preventive health. Due to the lack of patient knowledge and focus to take care
of their health, it is necessary to help patients before it is too late. New
trends such as positive psychology and mindfulness are highly encouraged in the
USA. Digital Twin (DT) can help with the continuous monitoring of emotion using
physiological signals (e.g., collected via wearables). Digital twins facilitate
monitoring and provide constant health insight to improve quality of life and
well-being with better personalization. Healthcare DT challenges are
standardizing data formats, communication protocols, and data exchange
mechanisms. To achieve those data integration and knowledge challenges, we
designed the Mental Health Knowledge Graph (ontology and dataset) to boost
mental health. The Knowledge Graph (KG) acquires knowledge from ontology-based
mental health projects classified within the LOV4IoT ontology catalog (Emotion,
Depression, and Mental Health). Furthermore, the KG is mapped to standards
(e.g., ontologies) when possible. Standards from ETSI SmartM2M, ITU/WHO, ISO,
W3C, NIST, and IEEE are relevant to mental health. | [
-0.5206875205039978,
-0.6577264666557312,
0.7437808513641357,
0.09627976268529892,
-0.2388451099395752,
0.1063840240240097,
0.2378879189491272,
-0.7295948266983032,
0.43521758913993835,
0.42584463953971863,
-0.9153222441673279,
-0.7337992191314697,
-0.5663175582885742,
0.07856976985931396,
-0.07628095149993896,
1.1679519414901733,
-0.13758139312267303,
0.18640780448913574,
-0.10174805670976639,
0.3308747708797455,
-0.6212285161018372,
-0.12023552507162094,
-0.8545244932174683,
-0.6082547307014465,
0.49740055203437805,
0.5360792279243469,
0.4098747968673706,
0.19380688667297363,
0.8332574963569641,
0.12397594004869461,
0.2410689741373062,
0.15196411311626434,
-0.4545859694480896,
0.01711142249405384,
0.08052817732095718,
-0.40346720814704895,
-0.7730467915534973,
-0.05766299366950989,
0.03992438688874245,
0.30520185828208923,
-0.12348417937755585,
0.20882605016231537,
-0.02555285394191742,
0.9362291693687439,
-0.2815663516521454,
0.3930240273475647,
-0.011938249692320824,
0.3412800133228302,
-0.11449486017227173,
-0.26649409532546997,
0.4043302536010742,
-0.6275205612182617,
-0.1724245548248291,
-0.5216333866119385,
-0.1335899531841278,
-0.17927536368370056,
0.6198276877403259,
0.5764625668525696,
-0.6342116594314575,
-0.11960490792989731,
-0.7881333827972412,
0.4736730754375458,
-0.5031504034996033,
0.36729559302330017,
0.6382084488868713,
0.31598132848739624,
-0.2330731749534607,
-0.547011137008667,
-0.6523805856704712,
0.5080742239952087,
0.04100058972835541,
0.5002377033233643,
-0.41769006848335266,
0.003521088045090437,
0.4606204628944397,
0.11107467859983444,
-0.5049281120300293,
-0.2680169939994812,
-0.5516217350959778,
-0.11398064345121384,
0.850757360458374,
0.410050630569458,
0.47059252858161926,
-0.15645360946655273,
-0.34652870893478394,
0.21086342632770538,
-0.5277504324913025,
0.000532225938513875,
0.05189524218440056,
-0.025593837723135948,
-0.5095151662826538,
0.5457943677902222,
-0.4538359045982361,
0.39021649956703186,
0.13429786264896393,
-0.49628642201423645,
0.31334546208381653,
-0.47117331624031067,
0.10606683045625687,
0.2833974361419678,
0.4773702025413513,
1.0166279077529907,
0.09217569977045059,
-0.2739757299423218,
0.012698648497462273,
0.29606443643569946,
0.5265640020370483,
-0.7461430430412292,
-0.23876051604747772,
0.6749268174171448,
-0.4869438409805298,
0.0704958587884903,
-0.04019314423203468,
-0.7592087984085083,
-0.513075590133667,
-0.6220375895500183,
0.4342030882835388,
-0.7091796398162842,
-0.34968751668930054,
0.27237585186958313,
-0.2236103117465973,
-0.16422536969184875,
0.1526661515235901,
-0.6156728863716125,
0.25215601921081543,
0.878005862236023,
0.7700804471969604,
-0.015717865899205208,
0.25730764865875244,
0.11993146687746048,
0.6136616468429565,
-0.09477858245372772,
0.7151970267295837,
0.06960101425647736,
-0.3761237561702728,
-0.23057782649993896,
-0.15898148715496063,
0.1163412481546402,
-0.3206884562969208,
0.732750415802002,
-0.1766062080860138,
0.1882462054491043,
-0.5736761093139648,
-0.3816901445388794,
-0.04726343974471092,
0.5386610627174377,
-0.3598098158836365,
0.6633542776107788,
0.11340640485286713,
-1.0414592027664185,
0.45588281750679016,
-1.177807092666626,
-0.6153742671012878,
0.27162405848503113,
0.011680441908538342,
-0.38506200909614563,
-0.20882925391197205,
0.19418074190616608,
0.5827406048774719,
-0.522067666053772,
0.12557445466518402,
-0.5853081345558167,
-0.3926408886909485,
-0.3143186867237091,
0.09970200061798096,
0.774698793888092,
0.2501877248287201,
-0.3403164744377136,
0.1927776336669922,
-0.6756227016448975,
0.3268378674983978,
0.05472904443740845,
0.039315421134233475,
-0.4484133720397949,
0.1004183292388916,
-0.22374267876148224,
0.4571830630302429,
0.24480627477169037,
-0.8156947493553162,
-0.1388825923204422,
0.1454796940088272,
0.578738808631897,
0.5190773010253906,
0.4415239095687866,
-0.44446566700935364,
-0.6669833660125732,
0.2719705402851105,
0.1472102850675583,
0.8481717109680176,
0.4195539355278015,
-0.6853427886962891,
-0.18017159402370453,
-0.6876416206359863,
-0.2629823088645935,
0.7913697957992554,
-0.6346347332000732,
1.082251787185669,
-0.4491040110588074,
-0.5695487260818481,
-0.5234131813049316,
-0.19223453104496002,
-0.16770368814468384,
0.8975907564163208,
0.2774161398410797,
-0.14154939353466034,
-0.4938979148864746,
-0.49630966782569885,
0.13558869063854218,
-0.08545996993780136,
-0.00042917885002680123,
0.016419628635048866,
0.33346566557884216,
-0.8551268577575684,
1.038524866104126,
-0.5529820919036865,
-0.6158047318458557,
-0.010892284102737904,
-0.018971024081110954,
0.12307269126176834,
0.5433133840560913,
0.26621150970458984,
-1.018112301826477,
-0.33747175335884094,
-0.07569243013858795,
-1.0476018190383911,
-0.12365720421075821,
0.38459286093711853,
-0.1563575714826584,
-0.17506515979766846,
0.08260436356067657,
-0.40656086802482605,
0.4764695167541504,
0.28239530324935913,
-0.44936493039131165,
0.27105632424354553,
-0.24276326596736908,
0.3138687312602997,
-1.2420003414154053,
0.21535475552082062,
-0.06051887944340706,
-0.19872213900089264,
-0.7118279933929443,
-0.48128432035446167,
0.009776130318641663,
-0.2926287055015564,
-0.12578165531158447,
0.3295246660709381,
0.33705058693885803,
0.27003213763237,
-0.14294122159481049,
0.019929371774196625,
0.07299872487783432,
-0.0007571247406303883,
-0.3375757038593292,
0.4001917243003845,
0.500475287437439,
-0.37278667092323303,
0.6115435361862183,
0.2640913128852844,
-0.10168708115816116,
1.389099359512329,
-0.574317455291748,
0.13900886476039886,
-0.2157192826271057,
0.2840207815170288,
-0.39886707067489624,
-0.13337752223014832,
0.31531858444213867,
-0.44744187593460083,
0.059425193816423416,
0.6256074905395508,
-0.8837898373603821,
-0.8517276048660278,
-0.5161091089248657,
0.1669435352087021,
0.3609987199306488,
-0.2074241042137146,
0.1566927433013916,
0.5225744247436523,
-0.14844387769699097,
-0.2260414958000183,
-0.5990437269210815,
0.10523492842912674,
-0.5969394445419312,
-0.7057569622993469,
0.39609548449516296,
-0.16850578784942627,
-0.200215682387352,
0.24482908844947815,
-0.20292170345783234,
0.1869456022977829,
0.004659115336835384,
0.6008786559104919,
0.41138795018196106,
0.18797729909420013,
0.5522221922874451,
-0.04867258295416832,
-0.6468065977096558,
0.2836730480194092,
-0.5654706358909607,
0.43413957953453064,
-0.13542048633098602,
-0.4570280909538269,
-1.0183231830596924,
0.8684210181236267,
0.48165276646614075,
-0.01727449707686901,
0.7920259833335876,
0.6542131900787354,
-0.7738132476806641,
0.4582374095916748,
-0.6193156838417053,
-0.39019668102264404,
-0.41209664940834045,
-0.004535226617008448,
-0.3375163972377777,
-0.8877255320549011,
0.5532090067863464,
-0.2249463051557541,
-0.2322888970375061,
0.3556762933731079,
0.35406115651130676,
-0.6315615773200989,
1.3791297674179077,
0.6280731558799744,
-0.0556066632270813,
0.2555069029331207,
-0.2326805144548416,
0.7678213715553284,
-0.845703125,
-0.33306941390037537,
-0.3057378828525543,
-0.4976001977920532,
-0.7028719782829285,
-0.04377998039126396,
0.8355152010917664,
0.3638184666633606,
-0.6098160743713379,
0.012361831031739712,
-0.7706283330917358,
-0.043216772377491,
0.567064106464386,
0.530888020992279,
0.47600123286247253,
-0.15725596249103546,
-0.11574811488389969,
-0.3372292220592499,
-0.3733186721801758,
-0.41888436675071716,
1.0788382291793823,
0.08404818177223206,
0.7332762479782104,
0.18321427702903748,
0.885086178779602,
0.5764721035957336,
0.23745542764663696,
-0.5346603989601135,
0.19387619197368622,
-0.17561711370944977,
-0.6884893774986267,
-0.12929819524288177,
-0.6650940179824829,
-0.9136834740638733,
-0.5773607492446899,
-0.17874296009540558,
-1.1926571130752563,
0.2638302147388458,
-0.09696465730667114,
-0.3720302879810333,
0.2941604554653168,
-0.5574247241020203,
0.5602650046348572,
-0.406440794467926,
-0.16425080597400665,
-0.5658310055732727,
-0.6431832313537598,
0.24192307889461517,
-0.3841686248779297,
0.17481261491775513,
-0.5541892647743225,
0.3887363374233246,
0.8318817019462585,
-0.21481089293956757,
0.6091934442520142,
0.0300949327647686,
0.1676638424396515,
0.24369534850120544,
-0.5974096059799194,
0.24606318771839142,
0.17981602251529694,
0.06223627179861069,
0.2977474629878998,
0.43386271595954895,
-0.4074794054031372,
-0.612566351890564,
0.6692736148834229,
-1.0830775499343872,
-0.4814522862434387,
-0.10823336243629456,
-0.4867093563079834,
-0.41161540150642395,
0.589473307132721,
0.15884751081466675,
0.19321094453334808,
0.2011263072490692,
-0.019035641103982925,
0.5549777746200562,
0.10056718438863754,
-0.08651803433895111,
0.3319556713104248,
-0.11059044301509857,
-0.5693727731704712,
0.9629870653152466,
0.22663743793964386,
0.08339772373437881,
0.17749497294425964,
0.35500672459602356,
-0.212925523519516,
0.002398671815171838,
0.2813813388347626,
0.23395507037639618,
-0.5696733593940735,
-0.3441040813922882,
-0.6455767750740051,
-0.34582510590553284,
-0.7880752086639404,
-0.19735229015350342,
-0.14239032566547394,
-0.1795382797718048,
-0.08670651912689209,
-0.2457706332206726,
0.7021359801292419,
0.9013736844062805,
-0.5921594500541687,
0.05163360759615898,
-0.823604166507721,
0.6963824033737183,
0.6569563746452332,
0.6833760142326355,
-0.17131608724594116,
0.5825455188751221,
-0.14991115033626556,
0.2434058040380478,
-0.40839719772338867,
-0.8773466944694519,
-0.01589127816259861,
-0.40315040946006775,
0.2796696424484253,
0.7649806141853333,
0.46466824412345886,
0.7831947803497314,
-0.05070478096604347,
0.3089607357978821,
0.6174378991127014,
-0.6558332443237305,
0.7400816679000854,
-0.49496468901634216,
0.14051860570907593,
0.6019173264503479,
0.3994356691837311,
-1.0478426218032837,
0.23982737958431244,
-0.6097586750984192,
-0.7355413436889648,
0.6279442310333252,
0.09965476393699646,
-0.3200719356536865,
0.03507150709629059,
0.45523515343666077,
-0.03438834846019745,
0.16062189638614655,
-0.32108840346336365,
-0.24650679528713226,
-0.3456434905529022,
-0.5523301959037781,
0.19917882978916168,
0.06384480744600296,
-0.7466456890106201,
-0.2800019085407257,
0.7649877667427063,
-0.09874314069747925,
0.7029550671577454,
0.18440105020999908,
0.5379889011383057,
-0.1456548273563385,
0.05366627499461174,
0.17903022468090057,
0.26806050539016724,
-0.4902605414390564,
0.2761726379394531,
-0.12316261976957321,
-0.5210626125335693,
0.11327890306711197,
0.23361048102378845,
-0.2889566719532013,
-0.5455795526504517,
0.15450654923915863,
0.5698966383934021,
-0.23495732247829437,
-0.4153146743774414,
0.04179595038294792,
-0.07036031037569046,
0.05699129030108452,
-0.16351766884326935,
0.18559008836746216,
0.30462026596069336,
0.5589438080787659,
0.10923904925584793,
-0.19757463037967682,
-0.00400015851482749,
-0.38539251685142517,
0.21986174583435059,
0.30124086141586304,
-0.6430676579475403,
-0.2666071057319641,
0.5023214221000671,
0.28738704323768616,
-0.5534833669662476,
0.5926525592803955,
-0.314788818359375,
-0.3843347430229187,
0.5669841170310974,
0.6684733629226685,
0.5115212202072144,
-0.06742619723081589,
0.3045186400413513,
0.17761977016925812,
0.29531174898147583,
0.04215630143880844,
0.8962810039520264,
-0.1770259588956833,
-0.6851509213447571,
0.010037869215011597,
-0.060106247663497925,
-0.30206260085105896,
0.05005422979593277,
-0.7215514779090881,
0.3737387955188751,
-0.4391997456550598,
-0.7541905641555786,
-0.3437926173210144,
0.4131242632865906,
-0.8820211291313171,
0.567766010761261,
0.3369227945804596,
0.5824297666549683,
-0.6311329007148743,
0.6372151374816895,
0.7950962781906128,
-0.13034304976463318,
-0.5671638250350952,
0.10314379632472992,
0.38382479548454285,
-0.6654270887374878,
0.2202892005443573,
0.32462307810783386,
-0.2365390509366989,
0.10273981839418411,
-0.2083728313446045,
-0.9478570222854614,
1.3308672904968262,
0.2051122784614563,
-0.215058371424675,
0.0640421062707901,
0.4967029094696045,
0.5457984805107117,
-0.2194393277168274,
0.04172101989388466,
0.4047665596008301,
0.8858924508094788,
0.006566014606505632,
-0.5596472024917603,
-0.03186146542429924,
-0.30091455578804016,
-0.0723455399274826,
0.2579873502254486,
-0.65544593334198,
0.4065014719963074,
-0.27113863825798035,
-0.28045913577079773,
-0.5748529434204102,
0.04026895761489868,
0.3439604640007019,
0.5215556025505066,
0.3944914937019348,
1.067796230316162,
0.9204878211021423,
-0.1827741116285324,
0.8083268404006958,
-0.5283589363098145,
0.35808873176574707,
0.8938864469528198,
-0.41532930731773376,
0.47171685099601746,
0.3494589924812317,
-0.4048488736152649,
0.21730495989322662,
0.7787641286849976,
0.14329491555690765,
0.63874351978302,
-0.022587664425373077,
-0.46635526418685913,
-0.07004023343324661,
-0.40746280550956726,
-0.6304774880409241,
0.07449644058942795,
0.6481876969337463,
0.21535666286945343,
-0.23100998997688293,
0.3131957948207855,
0.21367762982845306,
-0.2496056705713272,
-0.1648082584142685,
0.6578546166419983,
0.1843765377998352,
-0.2020747810602188,
0.061190493404865265,
-0.06405995041131973,
0.47225502133369446,
-0.6598981618881226,
0.06908319890499115,
-0.027687808498740196,
0.2779403626918793,
-0.4132566452026367,
-0.6773691773414612,
0.6545888781547546,
0.10457267612218857,
-0.3170737028121948,
-0.33114954829216003,
0.852471113204956,
-0.051216285675764084,
-0.6050456762313843,
0.5507351756095886,
0.44599059224128723,
-0.013752779923379421,
-0.06876061856746674,
-0.5142385363578796,
-0.29554319381713867,
-0.2702278792858124,
0.15668804943561554,
0.08596163988113403,
0.5122471451759338,
-0.1811949610710144,
0.6398682594299316,
0.5917980074882507,
0.3380184769630432,
-0.1699904203414917,
-0.17856575548648834,
0.5821108222007751,
-0.7078838348388672,
-0.5491867065429688,
-0.47634080052375793,
0.32925015687942505,
-0.27379533648490906,
-0.27035579085350037,
0.4925248324871063,
0.1320568025112152,
0.39733728766441345,
0.4156482517719269,
0.8713424801826477,
-0.33522358536720276,
0.5445342063903809,
-0.009030761197209358,
0.9805650115013123,
-0.6534922122955322,
-0.21884261071681976,
-0.055857039988040924,
-0.7492257952690125,
-0.4424789547920227,
0.3858977258205414,
-0.4296088218688965,
-0.056774161756038666,
0.5522773861885071,
0.2635486125946045,
0.37015897035598755,
0.3283308446407318,
0.1120803952217102,
-0.0021076141856610775,
0.7155027389526367,
0.674151599407196,
0.41329100728034973,
-0.25371217727661133,
-0.11204696446657181,
-0.5866312980651855,
-0.23121295869350433,
-0.1120758205652237,
-0.6287710666656494,
-0.5508089065551758,
-0.5759385228157043,
-0.5300083756446838,
-0.12145043909549713,
0.2865980863571167,
0.9127501249313354,
0.8125063180923462,
-0.6555397510528564,
0.17716920375823975,
-0.18192388117313385,
0.4141139090061188,
-0.4196222126483917,
-0.2348918616771698,
0.45418956875801086,
0.214036762714386,
-0.12766633927822113,
-0.10630740970373154,
0.6260102391242981,
0.04127376154065132,
-0.19010135531425476,
0.1507999747991562,
-0.1291545331478119,
-0.27715402841567993,
0.2723245918750763,
0.1737469583749771,
-0.3139451742172241,
-0.4895250201225281,
-0.23689566552639008,
-0.2422075867652893,
0.18286484479904175,
0.37023353576660156,
-0.7056202292442322,
0.5237060189247131,
0.48951277136802673,
0.29477590322494507,
0.2750839293003082,
-0.1617385745048523,
0.3402705490589142,
-0.16921444237232208,
-0.07777702808380127,
0.12780451774597168,
0.26161515712738037,
0.4251236021518707,
-0.695650577545166,
0.6342156529426575,
0.40540018677711487,
-0.38622725009918213,
-0.45059600472450256,
0.22036661207675934,
-0.8439260125160217,
0.07725784182548523,
0.5044673085212708,
-0.20534735918045044,
-0.007326060440391302,
-0.3172226548194885,
-0.03389275446534157,
0.6548241972923279,
-0.23834086954593658,
1.3111686706542969,
0.493806928396225,
-0.7264710664749146,
0.023397456854581833,
-0.6136884093284607,
0.18105627596378326,
0.2375548779964447,
-1.439488172531128,
-0.391523540019989,
0.012937231920659542,
0.004256126005202532,
0.2708575427532196,
0.5092011094093323,
-0.13588184118270874,
0.20311352610588074,
-0.17539477348327637,
0.38667941093444824,
-0.0537584163248539,
-0.005966818891465664,
0.07201410830020905,
-0.21529652178287506,
-0.5242757201194763,
-0.22066815197467804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13781v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13781v1 | A Primal-Dual Framework for Transformers and Neural Networks | 2024-06-19T19:11:22 | 2024-06-19T19:11:22 | Tan M. Nguyen, Tam Nguyen, Nhat Ho, Andrea L. Bertozzi, Richard G. Baraniuk, Stanley J. Osher | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML | Self-attention is key to the remarkable success of transformers in sequence
modeling tasks including many applications in natural language processing and
computer vision. Like neural network layers, these attention mechanisms are
often developed by heuristics and experience. To provide a principled framework
for constructing attention layers in transformers, we show that the
self-attention corresponds to the support vector expansion derived from a
support vector regression problem, whose primal formulation has the form of a
neural network layer. Using our framework, we derive popular attention layers
used in practice and propose two new attentions: 1) the Batch Normalized
Attention (Attention-BN) derived from the batch normalization layer and 2) the
Attention with Scaled Head (Attention-SH) derived from using less training data
to fit the SVR model. We empirically demonstrate the advantages of the
Attention-BN and Attention-SH in reducing head redundancy, increasing the
model's accuracy, and improving the model's efficiency in a variety of
practical applications including image and time-series classification. | [
-0.4148511290550232,
-0.27602440118789673,
0.09196192771196365,
0.5303932428359985,
0.16683444380760193,
-0.2903335988521576,
-0.07170940190553665,
-0.06250741332769394,
0.056668758392333984,
0.6818017959594727,
-0.8917818069458008,
0.27908527851104736,
-0.37698784470558167,
-0.005276994779706001,
-0.4951392710208893,
0.9390660524368286,
0.23049283027648926,
-0.2604027986526489,
-0.15124116837978363,
-0.2337699979543686,
-0.37712496519088745,
-0.5385338068008423,
-0.609184741973877,
-0.3183790445327759,
0.8171173930168152,
0.2131921947002411,
0.7449560761451721,
0.9515868425369263,
0.9358279705047607,
0.38359683752059937,
0.28534433245658875,
-0.2338050901889801,
-0.3404563367366791,
0.19877594709396362,
-0.2445078045129776,
-0.293283611536026,
-0.4142760634422302,
0.0628737136721611,
0.5108131170272827,
0.4916246831417084,
0.09951161593198776,
0.6292272210121155,
0.27401959896087646,
0.9881405830383301,
-0.5895965099334717,
0.1437489092350006,
-0.21838390827178955,
0.4618754982948303,
0.2713015079498291,
-0.09407845884561539,
-0.24297727644443512,
0.11515957117080688,
0.4453679621219635,
-0.282813161611557,
0.7985621690750122,
-0.31364548206329346,
0.5477910041809082,
0.9301645755767822,
-0.34174200892448425,
0.5227294564247131,
-1.054397463798523,
0.9390198588371277,
-0.28000587224960327,
0.5626500248908997,
-0.14564038813114166,
0.4428299367427826,
0.2531718611717224,
-0.784070611000061,
-0.25742942094802856,
0.03607088699936867,
-0.2149420529603958,
0.3270159959793091,
-0.2621375322341919,
0.13163931667804718,
0.31124645471572876,
0.4567483067512512,
-0.23678629100322723,
-0.10591910034418106,
-0.6261864900588989,
-0.04008639603853226,
0.43131116032600403,
0.18927916884422302,
-0.033529773354530334,
-0.3373175859451294,
-0.8832789659500122,
-0.1207239180803299,
-0.4255020320415497,
0.13059304654598236,
0.18302637338638306,
0.502740204334259,
-0.169197216629982,
0.6128504276275635,
0.009262283332645893,
0.7260658144950867,
0.4907777011394501,
0.047577664256095886,
0.0698607787489891,
-0.15121619403362274,
-0.6712114810943604,
-0.16611118614673615,
0.7504486441612244,
0.4056704342365265,
0.4772871434688568,
-0.4912078082561493,
-0.21732079982757568,
0.14478926360607147,
0.8890866637229919,
-0.5302648544311523,
-0.059367671608924866,
0.21467375755310059,
-0.7471856474876404,
-0.550761878490448,
-0.18642257153987885,
-0.6867431402206421,
0.025324247777462006,
-0.814950704574585,
0.6446757912635803,
0.038057830184698105,
-0.33028173446655273,
-0.07028234750032425,
0.012260460294783115,
0.424629271030426,
-0.07018392533063889,
-1.0874277353286743,
0.33611398935317993,
0.5392363667488098,
0.5732062458992004,
-0.20829464495182037,
0.08150294423103333,
-0.4238092303276062,
0.1058930903673172,
-0.09406257420778275,
0.6784052848815918,
-0.2396332174539566,
0.02963728830218315,
-0.1925031989812851,
-0.07329083979129791,
-0.2135803997516632,
-0.4202902913093567,
0.5753684639930725,
-0.4764557182788849,
0.2375028282403946,
-0.10243258625268936,
0.04914341866970062,
-0.15452569723129272,
0.04385857656598091,
-0.7193554043769836,
1.3182169198989868,
0.44365689158439636,
-0.7547565698623657,
0.035389721393585205,
-0.7524961233139038,
-0.6213002800941467,
0.2454269975423813,
-0.1901727318763733,
-0.32794490456581116,
0.23681288957595825,
0.21382400393486023,
0.8563525080680847,
-0.5013318061828613,
0.049150969833135605,
-0.11144045740365982,
-0.0006949100643396378,
-0.12662991881370544,
-0.2910878360271454,
0.405458003282547,
0.09570366889238358,
-0.566244900226593,
0.18530666828155518,
-0.7401882410049438,
0.002556226681917906,
0.1633119434118271,
0.008866934105753899,
-0.03432828560471535,
-0.000934584706556052,
0.167258620262146,
0.43640783429145813,
0.09075986593961716,
-0.31625133752822876,
0.12737654149532318,
-0.5410597324371338,
0.7052001953125,
0.8302478790283203,
-0.0811513215303421,
0.8140466809272766,
0.022918852046132088,
0.6116093397140503,
0.037861086428165436,
0.4279657304286957,
-0.39916691184043884,
-0.1177116334438324,
-1.043155312538147,
-0.17149783670902252,
0.1416982114315033,
0.5054745078086853,
-0.1662556231021881,
0.6513951420783997,
-0.2766253352165222,
-0.10242307186126709,
-0.4664483070373535,
0.20864452421665192,
0.2295345664024353,
0.8079702258110046,
0.3780461847782135,
-0.35564562678337097,
-0.7324368953704834,
-1.5815215110778809,
-0.03243972733616829,
0.09362876415252686,
-0.39357292652130127,
0.40903881192207336,
0.012595109641551971,
-0.18025341629981995,
1.1711704730987549,
-0.27061596512794495,
-0.7621342539787292,
-0.37895551323890686,
-0.14471043646335602,
0.2441588193178177,
0.4268345534801483,
0.45619407296180725,
-0.9854077696800232,
-0.33992648124694824,
-0.14439602196216583,
-0.7716707587242126,
0.17949947714805603,
-0.2669132947921753,
-0.1726132482290268,
-0.29043886065483093,
0.45142921805381775,
-0.25293612480163574,
0.41013649106025696,
0.2694339454174042,
0.08651257306337357,
0.10998710989952087,
0.20764587819576263,
-0.2853313088417053,
-1.1201763153076172,
0.16048063337802887,
0.6162832379341125,
-0.3340734839439392,
-0.865642249584198,
0.11833244562149048,
0.25127437710762024,
-0.07149814814329147,
-0.2765195965766907,
0.29167473316192627,
-0.2754828929901123,
-0.13291630148887634,
-0.3458385765552521,
-0.09592185914516449,
0.013145837932825089,
0.9480764865875244,
-0.08083965629339218,
0.6589898467063904,
0.6151980757713318,
-0.6809999942779541,
0.5461806058883667,
0.27480456233024597,
0.2620474696159363,
0.4900260269641876,
-1.1041500568389893,
0.2010708451271057,
-0.5250623226165771,
-0.21670874953269958,
-1.236673355102539,
-0.13519230484962463,
0.28883230686187744,
-0.2848024070262909,
0.6113459467887878,
-0.4481692910194397,
-0.17678101360797882,
-0.9298006892204285,
-0.12426933646202087,
0.41446003317832947,
0.5410750508308411,
-0.5729519724845886,
1.1266751289367676,
0.22449111938476562,
-0.0447615422308445,
-0.8327274322509766,
-0.7804442048072815,
-0.11777688562870026,
-0.16481301188468933,
-0.8802377581596375,
0.3653823733329773,
0.22084486484527588,
-0.08108862489461899,
0.07654883712530136,
-0.45203426480293274,
-0.007554161362349987,
0.00794566236436367,
0.34738796949386597,
0.368026465177536,
-0.6673045754432678,
0.08395782113075256,
-0.35041525959968567,
-0.4778064787387848,
0.26831531524658203,
-0.579680323600769,
0.40077275037765503,
-0.17062698304653168,
-0.0008254570420831442,
-0.627662181854248,
0.44003576040267944,
0.7737393379211426,
-0.4554055333137512,
0.29108676314353943,
0.40008509159088135,
-0.2977781593799591,
-0.13847289979457855,
-0.8703403472900391,
-0.5425544381141663,
-0.5736199021339417,
0.22093623876571655,
-0.33273017406463623,
-0.5894114375114441,
0.4922439455986023,
0.4096928834915161,
-0.035466987639665604,
0.8175394535064697,
0.6386832594871521,
-0.14968805015087128,
1.0269869565963745,
0.9116743803024292,
-0.2743743658065796,
0.5384643077850342,
-0.3708590269088745,
0.23527728021144867,
-1.2225219011306763,
-0.12341175973415375,
-0.20354552567005157,
-0.6960285902023315,
-0.3138872981071472,
-0.22319220006465912,
0.31645670533180237,
-0.3215159475803375,
-0.24926123023033142,
0.5875572562217712,
-1.0827133655548096,
0.46180880069732666,
0.4987301826477051,
0.1218823567032814,
-0.19378718733787537,
0.1570115089416504,
0.0920100063085556,
-0.3263583779335022,
-0.7431498765945435,
-0.27953314781188965,
0.979102373123169,
0.670224666595459,
0.7757866382598877,
-0.27126938104629517,
0.20115037262439728,
0.2934598922729492,
0.2995578944683075,
-0.9677660465240479,
0.2959422767162323,
-0.12307839840650558,
-0.7239781022071838,
-0.2845526933670044,
-0.288178950548172,
-0.613461971282959,
0.3394849896430969,
0.23477306962013245,
-0.5168142914772034,
0.33202964067459106,
0.33288830518722534,
-0.8078629970550537,
0.03909054026007652,
-0.913098931312561,
1.11974036693573,
-0.12108840048313141,
-0.5770363211631775,
-0.04711543396115303,
-1.075910210609436,
0.25540781021118164,
0.09888807684183121,
-0.3353259265422821,
-0.14497913420200348,
-0.02780478075146675,
0.6734363436698914,
-0.034784235060214996,
1.037782907485962,
-0.07080945372581482,
0.07577204704284668,
0.3654996156692505,
-0.26174890995025635,
0.40692785382270813,
-0.03525972738862038,
0.38320454955101013,
-0.29039379954338074,
-0.532871425151825,
-0.327576607465744,
-0.7517450451850891,
0.5614302158355713,
-0.7985485196113586,
-0.8418707847595215,
-0.2702066898345947,
-0.5118265748023987,
-0.05375942215323448,
0.16625776886940002,
0.07842119038105011,
0.6234248280525208,
0.17195603251457214,
0.43806660175323486,
0.7944566011428833,
0.3271983563899994,
0.49078211188316345,
0.12777429819107056,
0.07230331748723984,
-0.19526655972003937,
0.4888189136981964,
0.10986384749412537,
0.38798725605010986,
0.4089546501636505,
0.23791205883026123,
-0.38080307841300964,
0.06908455491065979,
-0.41963475942611694,
0.1602991223335266,
-0.700063943862915,
-0.451177716255188,
-1.0775538682937622,
-0.67458176612854,
-0.5752639770507812,
0.08594819903373718,
-0.5801056623458862,
-0.5422205328941345,
-0.24411074817180634,
0.0032215642277151346,
0.27487945556640625,
0.632831871509552,
-0.030826618894934654,
0.3060240149497986,
-0.5760751962661743,
0.7576861381530762,
0.726317286491394,
0.39033326506614685,
0.3221242129802704,
-0.6755027174949646,
-0.15627366304397583,
-0.23363785445690155,
-0.4167557954788208,
-0.5269680619239807,
0.4442960321903229,
0.11117281019687653,
0.7891768217086792,
0.4914512634277344,
-0.07668262720108032,
0.4799957573413849,
-0.6448087096214294,
0.2625618278980255,
0.3621879816055298,
-0.6124461889266968,
0.3529922068119049,
-0.43692320585250854,
0.31974533200263977,
0.28964346647262573,
0.26056015491485596,
-0.5745429396629333,
-0.10539048910140991,
-0.5664991140365601,
-0.8955270648002625,
0.9699237942695618,
0.41828256845474243,
0.47582709789276123,
0.3142387270927429,
0.5982008576393127,
-0.13633714616298676,
0.12993009388446808,
-0.7857583165168762,
-0.683841347694397,
-0.5455431938171387,
-0.2287488579750061,
0.03725719451904297,
-0.32989072799682617,
-0.15982626378536224,
-0.25409334897994995,
0.28911516070365906,
-0.2649877965450287,
0.6875064969062805,
0.5944047570228577,
0.10078104585409164,
-0.2771163284778595,
-0.014949724078178406,
0.34435054659843445,
0.12225370109081268,
-0.20681990683078766,
0.12833139300346375,
0.03012239746749401,
-0.41850441694259644,
0.17181093990802765,
-0.05386584997177124,
-0.013752005062997341,
-0.49265336990356445,
-0.031396351754665375,
0.6449049711227417,
0.35865288972854614,
0.08478434383869171,
0.4967029392719269,
0.0675979033112526,
-0.05095541477203369,
-0.3893832862377167,
0.06514769047498703,
0.042070772498846054,
0.2841525673866272,
0.819281280040741,
0.6719004511833191,
0.32234933972358704,
-0.1072816252708435,
0.3421281576156616,
0.22135236859321594,
-0.8131123781204224,
-0.27584749460220337,
0.9046908617019653,
0.35913291573524475,
-0.40089109539985657,
0.32699140906333923,
0.3206108808517456,
-0.7448104023933411,
1.0044509172439575,
0.5305487513542175,
1.1533429622650146,
-0.3685014247894287,
-0.04833822697401047,
0.42879152297973633,
0.4241447150707245,
-0.0240304097533226,
-0.06372855603694916,
-0.1545039713382721,
-0.706283688545227,
-0.7057080864906311,
-0.40865662693977356,
0.03695207089185715,
0.17001254856586456,
-0.8841701745986938,
0.2671337425708771,
-0.6000459790229797,
-0.3435932397842407,
0.32742488384246826,
-0.5100706815719604,
-0.9425820112228394,
0.47842419147491455,
0.09756426513195038,
0.5623482465744019,
-0.6369090676307678,
0.5010276436805725,
0.40324804186820984,
-0.32135671377182007,
-0.6410802006721497,
-0.08367354422807693,
-0.2786962687969208,
-0.6850689649581909,
0.9402853846549988,
0.6120405793190002,
-0.30473509430885315,
0.346926212310791,
-0.24872808158397675,
-1.3061472177505493,
0.7377355694770813,
0.1924613118171692,
-0.41544309258461,
-0.23873122036457062,
-0.02216406911611557,
0.562042236328125,
-0.5166391134262085,
0.050814662128686905,
0.33772435784339905,
0.17633214592933655,
0.1786976158618927,
-0.43274685740470886,
-0.13074924051761627,
-0.26204073429107666,
0.08503473550081253,
0.26711440086364746,
-0.9395384192466736,
0.6702005863189697,
-0.0865025743842125,
-0.37406662106513977,
-0.1764688342809677,
0.9532905220985413,
-0.5501270890235901,
-0.12223821133375168,
0.5388054847717285,
0.4013794958591461,
-0.059895750135183334,
-0.0917939618229866,
1.1211817264556885,
-0.30478209257125854,
0.32511040568351746,
0.9165052175521851,
-0.1301596760749817,
0.4332558214664459,
0.4422585070133209,
-0.22768713533878326,
0.23908577859401703,
0.31162434816360474,
-0.44844570755958557,
0.6148037910461426,
0.007419514004141092,
0.19031742215156555,
-0.33172470331192017,
-0.011921587400138378,
-0.3763100504875183,
0.2933715581893921,
0.10627541691064835,
-0.6823153495788574,
-0.07325486838817596,
0.14041230082511902,
-0.6595078110694885,
-0.07966442406177521,
-0.4484369158744812,
0.6244694590568542,
0.08680696785449982,
-0.5954733490943909,
0.37683895230293274,
-0.09877053648233414,
0.5143994092941284,
-0.31061235070228577,
0.3134307861328125,
-0.012251589447259903,
0.5505748987197876,
-0.1333235800266266,
-0.40370112657546997,
0.40299108624458313,
-0.1924576759338379,
-0.6984622478485107,
-0.3984970450401306,
0.7705667614936829,
-0.15335099399089813,
-0.7164338827133179,
0.3052936792373657,
0.10732213407754898,
-0.46911025047302246,
-0.21792586147785187,
-0.6654578447341919,
-0.31153392791748047,
-0.0696645975112915,
-0.5004875063896179,
0.038349468261003494,
0.08123474568128586,
0.19456495344638824,
0.6689215898513794,
0.47533661127090454,
-0.6466352343559265,
0.3644794523715973,
0.2574889063835144,
0.9626511335372925,
-0.5408855080604553,
-0.418780118227005,
-0.8610178232192993,
0.6107034683227539,
-0.10172872245311737,
-0.16592980921268463,
0.6057878136634827,
0.5831705927848816,
0.3035697340965271,
-0.29083043336868286,
0.8499458432197571,
0.20004309713840485,
0.4932864010334015,
-0.036917977035045624,
0.37454017996788025,
-0.5509867668151855,
-0.27627187967300415,
-0.10964565724134445,
-1.217865228652954,
-0.5271488428115845,
0.8112367391586304,
-0.2828104496002197,
0.20268544554710388,
0.4922419786453247,
0.5470921397209167,
-0.4530290961265564,
-0.056926168501377106,
0.2789871096611023,
0.051336243748664856,
-0.04592195525765419,
0.42888233065605164,
0.6818580031394958,
-0.6795095205307007,
0.48006340861320496,
-0.4444931447505951,
-0.10667042434215546,
-0.18174034357070923,
-0.7112684845924377,
-0.9549345374107361,
-0.48687779903411865,
-0.2986844480037689,
-0.3073742091655731,
-0.32398170232772827,
0.927361249923706,
1.0013341903686523,
-0.7353294491767883,
0.08838765323162079,
-0.04832756891846657,
-0.34938493371009827,
-0.21829546988010406,
-0.27922406792640686,
0.28583067655563354,
-0.6286505460739136,
-0.5750395059585571,
0.3035390377044678,
0.6310316324234009,
0.24727097153663635,
-0.6631115674972534,
0.3458664119243622,
0.1853836178779602,
0.11138489842414856,
0.5530471205711365,
0.3124646842479706,
-0.7911450266838074,
-0.2713860273361206,
0.5777214169502258,
-0.42254820466041565,
0.43963655829429626,
1.0776312351226807,
-0.9095497727394104,
0.34247276186943054,
0.320880264043808,
0.6819341778755188,
0.6163261532783508,
0.17042692005634308,
0.8667059540748596,
-1.0095294713974,
0.4064624011516571,
0.34723570942878723,
0.22225242853164673,
0.5052868127822876,
-0.7107791900634766,
0.6343744397163391,
0.12753638625144958,
-0.5266525149345398,
-0.5672500133514404,
0.37646058201789856,
-1.2056280374526978,
0.3911440372467041,
1.0113930702209473,
0.27082374691963196,
-0.5062978863716125,
0.0007848116219975054,
-0.21178576350212097,
0.1968359649181366,
-0.23207882046699524,
0.6711195707321167,
0.37912386655807495,
0.07308755069971085,
-0.3356325328350067,
-0.5318713188171387,
0.4013466536998749,
0.637118399143219,
-0.23112048208713531,
0.22625499963760376,
-0.040305811911821365,
0.16977879405021667,
0.46610206365585327,
0.015264099463820457,
-0.1333422213792801,
0.3577228784561157,
-0.35890504717826843,
0.10455754399299622,
-0.0017875968478620052,
-0.5197647213935852,
-0.4332859218120575,
0.45766976475715637,
-0.4642021059989929,
-0.3080568015575409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13779v1 | FoRAG: Factuality-optimized Retrieval Augmented Generation for Web-enhanced Long-form Question Answering | 2024-06-19T19:06:36 | 2024-06-19T19:06:36 | Tianchi Cai, Zhiwen Tan, Xierui Song, Tao Sun, Jiyan Jiang, Yunqi Xu, Yinger Zhang, Jinjie Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) has become prevalent in
question-answering (QA) tasks due to its ability of utilizing search engine to
enhance the quality of long-form question-answering (LFQA). Despite the
emergence of various open source methods and web-enhanced commercial systems
such as Bing Chat, two critical problems remain unsolved, i.e., the lack of
factuality and clear logic in the generated long-form answers. In this paper,
we remedy these issues via a systematic study on answer generation in
web-enhanced LFQA. Specifically, we first propose a novel outline-enhanced
generator to achieve clear logic in the generation of multifaceted answers and
construct two datasets accordingly. Then we propose a factuality optimization
method based on a carefully designed doubly fine-grained RLHF framework, which
contains automatic evaluation and reward modeling in different levels of
granularity. Our generic framework comprises conventional fine-grained RLHF
methods as special cases. Extensive experiments verify the superiority of our
proposed \textit{Factuality-optimized RAG (FoRAG)} method on both English and
Chinese benchmarks. In particular, when applying our method to Llama2-7B-chat,
the derived model FoRAG-L-7B outperforms WebGPT-175B in terms of three commonly
used metrics (i.e., coherence, helpfulness, and factuality), while the number
of parameters is much smaller (only 1/24 of that of WebGPT-175B). Our datasets
and models are made publicly available for better reproducibility:
https://huggingface.co/forag. | [
-0.516798198223114,
-1.1713190078735352,
0.568192720413208,
0.28185370564460754,
-0.2786620259284973,
0.056490927934646606,
-0.0727565810084343,
-0.6232163310050964,
0.2222190946340561,
0.23426108062267303,
-0.5541905164718628,
-0.2439074069261551,
-0.15090806782245636,
0.08053774386644363,
-0.2615107595920563,
1.2906948328018188,
0.09322573244571686,
-0.3277512788772583,
-0.5288013219833374,
-0.21751736104488373,
-0.30894455313682556,
-0.38951775431632996,
-0.47436052560806274,
-0.21466778218746185,
0.6091669201850891,
0.3711555302143097,
0.6138467192649841,
0.4513925313949585,
0.5285612940788269,
0.1960640400648117,
-0.0962628573179245,
0.632655918598175,
-0.8788356184959412,
0.03560446575284004,
-0.15271233022212982,
-0.2561453878879547,
-0.5861455202102661,
-0.15308350324630737,
0.45290377736091614,
0.4469410479068756,
-0.3145858347415924,
0.69718998670578,
-0.021218635141849518,
0.7018333077430725,
-0.9086570739746094,
-0.030375856906175613,
-0.8056150674819946,
-0.24297434091567993,
-0.04310174658894539,
-0.26616421341896057,
-0.4123622477054596,
-0.4166499972343445,
0.011389012448489666,
-0.7944427132606506,
0.28471821546554565,
0.1827632039785385,
1.093717336654663,
0.3353178799152374,
-0.32529664039611816,
-0.6167789101600647,
-0.6412397623062134,
0.6990688443183899,
-0.606144368648529,
0.44679170846939087,
0.12019376456737518,
0.45765694975852966,
-0.3008669912815094,
-0.8483526110649109,
-0.7145197987556458,
-0.12141519784927368,
-0.06536450982093811,
0.3561267554759979,
-0.054146796464920044,
0.0325799360871315,
0.2148067057132721,
0.48733779788017273,
-0.6473547220230103,
-0.11552884429693222,
-0.3920077383518219,
-0.31886541843414307,
0.8553622364997864,
-0.0020264056511223316,
0.028934083878993988,
-0.1945861279964447,
-0.6221989393234253,
0.11386409401893616,
-0.7862457633018494,
0.38453617691993713,
0.25338444113731384,
0.21940180659294128,
0.05341585725545883,
0.4865420460700989,
-0.46007660031318665,
0.558373749256134,
0.30822262167930603,
-0.6157739758491516,
0.11786948889493942,
-0.2457236498594284,
0.0004061612708028406,
-0.08812780678272247,
0.2785061299800873,
0.3481101989746094,
-0.045497022569179535,
-0.00839096400886774,
-0.3361082375049591,
-0.1884293258190155,
-0.041312895715236664,
-1.005745768547058,
-0.045098837465047836,
0.5951573848724365,
-0.4389864206314087,
-0.1741253286600113,
-0.08528678864240646,
-0.6615780591964722,
-0.35372859239578247,
-0.1778302937746048,
0.40647223591804504,
-0.0776866003870964,
-0.3728746175765991,
-0.03248627111315727,
-0.20307788252830505,
0.45055896043777466,
0.33512067794799805,
-0.4485844671726227,
0.08376844972372055,
0.7285652756690979,
0.37791645526885986,
-0.2582748532295227,
0.013280322775244713,
-0.719963014125824,
0.1590246558189392,
-0.44802752137184143,
1.0412427186965942,
-0.25227656960487366,
-0.1979587972164154,
0.19984927773475647,
-0.4619588553905487,
0.1862640231847763,
-0.5808045268058777,
0.7934966683387756,
-0.8945618271827698,
0.4264478385448456,
-0.31000617146492004,
-0.6264073848724365,
-0.20250089466571808,
0.5081260800361633,
-0.6564881205558777,
0.9903832077980042,
-0.2670575678348541,
-0.7906998991966248,
0.4576374590396881,
-0.5629913210868835,
-0.16289852559566498,
0.06426636129617691,
-0.15595676004886627,
-0.476752370595932,
-0.002685490995645523,
0.32887667417526245,
0.2614842653274536,
-0.4598289728164673,
0.43569687008857727,
-0.18251508474349976,
-0.35269105434417725,
0.18046334385871887,
-0.5403161644935608,
0.4605967700481415,
0.3738614618778229,
-0.32282111048698425,
0.04757755249738693,
-0.867392897605896,
0.32522210478782654,
0.1388048380613327,
-0.5911079049110413,
-0.0923713818192482,
0.05313258618116379,
-0.10269346833229065,
0.21512599289417267,
0.37042471766471863,
-0.5856948494911194,
-0.2952801585197449,
-0.4813653230667114,
-0.2920326590538025,
0.7487770318984985,
0.15846320986747742,
0.003915262874215841,
-0.42107343673706055,
0.46369901299476624,
-0.19186097383499146,
0.15049920976161957,
0.08654502034187317,
-0.48739784955978394,
-0.8475310802459717,
-0.5280197858810425,
0.4047512710094452,
0.6646605134010315,
-0.8762804269790649,
0.27301809191703796,
-0.33330389857292175,
-0.40901872515678406,
-0.5365555882453918,
0.018724093213677406,
0.6026216149330139,
0.4830833673477173,
0.37827301025390625,
-0.052366163581609726,
-0.3841147720813751,
-0.8659089207649231,
-0.25533929467201233,
-0.07288508862257004,
0.1329011768102646,
0.5135295391082764,
0.33861374855041504,
-0.06678158789873123,
1.0449532270431519,
-0.6140134930610657,
0.08926109224557877,
-0.16574707627296448,
-0.06279906630516052,
0.2484898865222931,
0.19543500244617462,
0.36353757977485657,
-0.9813224077224731,
-0.5545264482498169,
-0.19135476648807526,
-0.6895320415496826,
-0.12728841602802277,
-0.1459406167268753,
-0.22878187894821167,
0.40864425897598267,
0.1271621435880661,
-0.5324112772941589,
0.5560293793678284,
0.520512044429779,
-0.1922861635684967,
0.6945693492889404,
0.12246529757976532,
0.18684421479701996,
-0.9502580761909485,
0.45420268177986145,
-0.2381325215101242,
-0.278990775346756,
-0.5725939273834229,
0.2816591262817383,
-0.2445385754108429,
-0.2052997201681137,
-0.29311296343803406,
0.8382440209388733,
-0.5052382946014404,
-0.008969838730990887,
-0.4330019950866699,
0.4094090461730957,
0.05836959555745125,
0.628922700881958,
-0.26166269183158875,
1.0014572143554688,
0.04064216464757919,
-0.6075976490974426,
0.29458513855934143,
0.3140465021133423,
-0.1333129107952118,
0.4102347493171692,
-0.8098745346069336,
0.32899096608161926,
-0.22118458151817322,
0.31519338488578796,
-0.9543625712394714,
-0.3272111713886261,
0.07401090115308762,
-0.6680102944374084,
0.18109869956970215,
0.03660726174712181,
-0.26386842131614685,
-0.19247806072235107,
-0.4550122618675232,
0.3539181649684906,
0.6433379054069519,
-0.7724380493164062,
0.5180163383483887,
0.278780072927475,
-0.18049374222755432,
-0.8728532195091248,
-0.14046894013881683,
-0.01847699284553528,
-0.07860004901885986,
-1.0271378755569458,
0.18902504444122314,
-0.18306541442871094,
-0.295583039522171,
-0.25528663396835327,
-0.32616204023361206,
-0.04595007747411728,
-0.035732150077819824,
-0.2238466739654541,
0.1288982480764389,
-0.17495737969875336,
0.21367321908473969,
0.1863257884979248,
0.09250696748495102,
0.15570196509361267,
0.2241200953722,
0.5039007067680359,
-0.19440481066703796,
-0.3761528432369232,
-0.16553372144699097,
0.6147559285163879,
0.04354184865951538,
-0.5301796793937683,
0.6449178457260132,
0.6957334280014038,
-0.05703892186284065,
-0.297792911529541,
-0.7967407703399658,
-0.27910834550857544,
-0.5231027007102966,
0.3144357204437256,
-0.48072391748428345,
-0.9441584944725037,
0.6324303150177002,
-0.08077352494001389,
0.35080358386039734,
0.5027321577072144,
0.528323233127594,
-0.03624395281076431,
0.9576588273048401,
0.3894498348236084,
0.4436526894569397,
0.09813357144594193,
-0.010113604366779327,
0.19347470998764038,
-0.5906785130500793,
-0.18079310655593872,
-0.39918258786201477,
0.06400935351848602,
-0.7793973684310913,
-0.35370221734046936,
0.672825813293457,
0.10809258371591568,
-0.18482033908367157,
-0.5701239109039307,
-0.4539753794670105,
0.28215354681015015,
0.43134331703186035,
0.1632797122001648,
0.24943286180496216,
0.08839312940835953,
0.05165979266166687,
0.1648140400648117,
-0.7988339066505432,
-0.3974463641643524,
0.9836390614509583,
0.211537703871727,
0.6654466986656189,
0.27962490916252136,
0.7623910903930664,
0.3625660240650177,
0.12879562377929688,
-0.5910224914550781,
0.5980650186538696,
0.07460630685091019,
-0.8323507308959961,
-0.19614507257938385,
-0.30549928545951843,
-1.043988823890686,
0.15446928143501282,
-0.3781315088272095,
-0.3456686735153198,
-0.014226137660443783,
0.5395112037658691,
-0.16492410004138947,
-0.059146080166101456,
-0.5835505723953247,
0.4930472671985626,
-0.053083766251802444,
-0.5891056656837463,
-0.27366334199905396,
-0.8365579843521118,
0.6451231837272644,
0.047044601291418076,
0.13718989491462708,
-0.1077178567647934,
0.14156889915466309,
0.572688102722168,
-0.29280519485473633,
0.46508893370628357,
-0.3189021348953247,
-0.29297733306884766,
0.6735562682151794,
-0.20827724039554596,
0.7717202305793762,
0.1689957231283188,
0.08796099573373795,
-0.19859573245048523,
-0.03512287512421608,
-0.5697290301322937,
-0.7420339584350586,
0.4786304831504822,
-0.6571378707885742,
-0.9846827983856201,
-0.32594171166419983,
-0.32625433802604675,
-0.2792956233024597,
0.1937088519334793,
0.10808221250772476,
0.6834095120429993,
-0.11691600829362869,
0.2851512134075165,
0.9005998373031616,
-0.29652103781700134,
0.07767430692911148,
0.3153257966041565,
-0.41531461477279663,
-0.5364676713943481,
0.982766330242157,
-0.18054617941379547,
0.47172531485557556,
0.3452041447162628,
0.34146779775619507,
-0.40054285526275635,
-0.47789499163627625,
-0.6032221913337708,
0.3131873905658722,
-0.8895968198776245,
-0.2468734234571457,
-0.4852582514286041,
-0.2826685309410095,
-0.5860209465026855,
0.019670866429805756,
-0.11466095596551895,
-0.5186230540275574,
0.022416718304157257,
0.013541750609874725,
0.40399348735809326,
0.3756107687950134,
-0.06827174127101898,
-0.09410636126995087,
-0.8641864061355591,
0.683195173740387,
0.42040422558784485,
0.25496402382850647,
0.016121651977300644,
-0.4074651896953583,
-0.2734740376472473,
0.3490460216999054,
-0.30731871724128723,
-0.6600255966186523,
-0.11506696790456772,
0.3949788808822632,
0.6632260084152222,
0.09226277470588684,
0.1850796341896057,
0.7932542562484741,
-0.5271446108818054,
0.8223890662193298,
-0.0038198663387447596,
-0.6223586797714233,
0.3715634346008301,
-0.3928682804107666,
0.057127274572849274,
0.44826504588127136,
0.22815245389938354,
-0.3144490122795105,
-0.13082186877727509,
-0.6542345881462097,
-0.9043864011764526,
0.27098286151885986,
0.33471137285232544,
0.04190252348780632,
0.0830816701054573,
0.488629549741745,
0.1832517832517624,
0.33400246500968933,
-0.4986945688724518,
-0.366510272026062,
-0.33543291687965393,
-0.19596683979034424,
0.34248632192611694,
-0.4716397523880005,
-0.22103263437747955,
-0.05367239564657211,
0.8916906714439392,
-0.25609153509140015,
0.4356706440448761,
0.3911691904067993,
-0.004711059853434563,
0.14966937899589539,
0.33366110920906067,
0.6511524319648743,
0.9616254568099976,
-0.19846351444721222,
-0.19517092406749725,
0.216156005859375,
-0.4521709084510803,
-0.09227252751588821,
0.36115220189094543,
-0.3541892170906067,
0.003976756706833839,
0.19615620374679565,
0.7149577140808105,
-0.5832824110984802,
-0.7752927541732788,
0.41808316111564636,
0.1658221036195755,
0.005086208693683147,
-0.5189117789268494,
0.072394460439682,
-0.11219117790460587,
0.14382535219192505,
0.6142290830612183,
-0.3626146912574768,
0.5369841456413269,
-0.5064405202865601,
0.18549111485481262,
0.6115641593933105,
0.018507614731788635,
-0.08511842787265778,
0.5174691081047058,
0.527846097946167,
-0.11326099187135696,
0.4577118754386902,
-0.3500608801841736,
-0.4186401069164276,
0.3514125943183899,
0.5854570865631104,
0.7552952766418457,
0.15987221896648407,
0.1417510211467743,
0.4430248439311981,
0.045352037996053696,
0.2755802571773529,
0.5093904137611389,
-0.007738280575722456,
-0.6288210153579712,
-0.6247823238372803,
-0.6837750673294067,
-0.44160372018814087,
0.03580451011657715,
-0.5455628633499146,
0.1252375841140747,
-0.18537470698356628,
-0.08056828379631042,
-0.15634280443191528,
0.21611888706684113,
-0.4880152642726898,
0.5800783038139343,
0.034589290618896484,
0.7396914958953857,
-0.44948434829711914,
0.25240451097488403,
0.6309760212898254,
-0.4568939208984375,
-1.017844796180725,
0.0748433992266655,
-0.14433607459068298,
-0.8111869096755981,
0.29064348340034485,
0.09450932592153549,
-0.45903903245925903,
0.03164137899875641,
-0.7782866954803467,
-0.9387794733047485,
1.1877964735031128,
0.17340950667858124,
0.045185383409261703,
-0.08019300550222397,
0.14563706517219543,
0.4880395531654358,
-0.050009239464998245,
0.13747604191303253,
0.3114180564880371,
0.4882718324661255,
0.3126840591430664,
-0.8593018651008606,
0.18409129977226257,
-0.379023015499115,
-0.06363706290721893,
0.14398933947086334,
-0.9247955679893494,
0.5134364366531372,
-0.10116235911846161,
-0.3189629018306732,
0.20107567310333252,
0.9293932914733887,
0.8237731456756592,
0.5051944255828857,
0.44617339968681335,
0.39591529965400696,
0.7266228199005127,
0.05803407356142998,
0.9627684950828552,
-0.17371751368045807,
0.3177679181098938,
0.927314281463623,
-0.15757375955581665,
0.7236500382423401,
0.5001541376113892,
0.01099767629057169,
0.5386119484901428,
0.4238780438899994,
0.18478864431381226,
0.37252673506736755,
0.22466015815734863,
-0.2628656029701233,
-0.2496233582496643,
-0.24683871865272522,
-0.32134681940078735,
0.5719411373138428,
0.15383130311965942,
0.05277593061327934,
-0.3283698856830597,
-0.24886035919189453,
0.2749292254447937,
0.34844398498535156,
-0.23580221831798553,
0.9438275098800659,
-0.22061745822429657,
-1.0072888135910034,
1.1386569738388062,
0.031777530908584595,
0.6963630318641663,
-0.62024986743927,
-0.3132730722427368,
-0.46815118193626404,
0.10186487436294556,
-0.3175814747810364,
-0.6060424447059631,
0.12406887114048004,
0.22534753382205963,
-0.24972596764564514,
0.13563959300518036,
0.9786336421966553,
-0.43230918049812317,
-0.35349199175834656,
-0.24099090695381165,
0.6511613130569458,
0.2278854250907898,
0.11263425648212433,
-0.7720101475715637,
-0.11384864896535873,
0.21951906383037567,
-0.3737466335296631,
0.05212600156664848,
0.40220993757247925,
-0.15931357443332672,
0.6304475665092468,
0.8056803941726685,
0.0002483509888406843,
0.19797122478485107,
-0.2113833725452423,
0.8568371534347534,
-0.33612242341041565,
-0.42696502804756165,
-0.4024084806442261,
0.7106792330741882,
-0.40939071774482727,
-0.264921635389328,
0.7943427562713623,
0.6973505020141602,
0.47255200147628784,
0.04235023260116577,
0.6643555760383606,
-0.26547127962112427,
1.0471596717834473,
-0.5717658400535583,
0.612269401550293,
-0.7080070972442627,
-0.02074667438864708,
-0.16910655796527863,
-0.8423850536346436,
0.02551908604800701,
0.15418945252895355,
0.12327929586172104,
0.1415003538131714,
0.4953922629356384,
0.8380461931228638,
0.09224832057952881,
-0.23599612712860107,
0.22576439380645752,
-0.08320541679859161,
0.6517574787139893,
0.25723031163215637,
0.6948068737983704,
-0.41262274980545044,
0.757901132106781,
-0.06708472967147827,
-0.2567991018295288,
-0.1593749225139618,
-0.7341246008872986,
-0.8002442717552185,
-0.5761014819145203,
-0.04817752540111542,
-0.45940911769866943,
0.24023713171482086,
0.9142318964004517,
0.29655417799949646,
-0.6127023100852966,
-0.05981907993555069,
0.25791606307029724,
0.0485408715903759,
-0.04029761627316475,
-0.2282281368970871,
0.6366459131240845,
-0.5370312333106995,
-0.530299961566925,
0.1373615860939026,
-0.08267274498939514,
-0.0927877202630043,
-0.21128837764263153,
0.034745652228593826,
-0.4639049172401428,
0.47061851620674133,
0.7685810923576355,
0.346933513879776,
-0.7404598593711853,
-0.5768519043922424,
0.2720631957054138,
0.05313728377223015,
0.02031177654862404,
0.35660073161125183,
-0.6255879998207092,
0.386956125497818,
0.5132291316986084,
0.9137211441993713,
0.37277454137802124,
0.5207642912864685,
0.4704407751560211,
-0.8671780824661255,
0.1447913944721222,
0.34483709931373596,
-0.06345333904027939,
0.40499335527420044,
-0.3979068398475647,
0.4990144371986389,
0.10056383907794952,
-0.7602318525314331,
-0.8726846575737,
0.26586002111434937,
-0.9042674899101257,
-0.11001578718423843,
1.5041812658309937,
-0.04761126637458801,
-0.11683715879917145,
-0.02399509586393833,
-0.4006621241569519,
0.3008198142051697,
-0.40836140513420105,
0.9197736978530884,
0.5599302649497986,
-0.24912546575069427,
0.12340179085731506,
-0.4081435799598694,
0.8104438185691833,
0.35397639870643616,
-0.9854768514633179,
-0.05630428344011307,
0.8658000826835632,
0.17682185769081116,
0.24935665726661682,
0.5511046648025513,
0.11232954263687134,
0.672701358795166,
-0.08697418123483658,
0.12198526412248611,
-0.1449110507965088,
-0.20232656598091125,
0.21191923320293427,
0.1948494166135788,
0.2749987542629242,
-0.10171738266944885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13777v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13777v1 | Game of LLMs: Discovering Structural Constructs in Activities using Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T19:02:44 | 2024-06-19T19:02:44 | Shruthi K. Hiremath, Thomas Ploetz | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Human Activity Recognition is a time-series analysis problem. A popular
analysis procedure used by the community assumes an optimal window length to
design recognition pipelines. However, in the scenario of smart homes, where
activities are of varying duration and frequency, the assumption of a constant
sized window does not hold. Additionally, previous works have shown these
activities to be made up of building blocks. We focus on identifying these
underlying building blocks--structural constructs, with the use of large
language models. Identifying these constructs can be beneficial especially in
recognizing short-duration and infrequent activities. We also propose the
development of an activity recognition procedure that uses these building
blocks to model activities, thus helping the downstream task of activity
monitoring in smart homes. | [
0.03393680974841118,
-0.931471586227417,
0.7751103639602661,
0.17428697645664215,
-0.10361838340759277,
0.5307645201683044,
0.13069109618663788,
-0.3849284052848816,
0.3164297044277191,
0.36173683404922485,
-0.5429940819740295,
-0.4264814853668213,
-0.37690940499305725,
-0.11478438228368759,
-0.3269083499908447,
0.5599706768989563,
-0.26731181144714355,
-0.08402610570192337,
0.06477458775043488,
0.23541538417339325,
-0.28145986795425415,
-0.23763330280780792,
-0.5042187571525574,
-0.5736569166183472,
0.2829170525074005,
0.2660878300666809,
0.32448896765708923,
0.8880725502967834,
0.42404693365097046,
0.3785476088523865,
-0.1815958023071289,
0.3479054570198059,
-0.4251329302787781,
0.1501220315694809,
0.21856273710727692,
-0.31629231572151184,
-0.5958935618400574,
-0.13554374873638153,
0.514126718044281,
0.6925041675567627,
0.06584324687719345,
0.7017755508422852,
-0.03648204728960991,
0.7471053600311279,
-0.07186322659254074,
0.5851378440856934,
-0.29196682572364807,
0.434188574552536,
-0.32832443714141846,
-0.4669453799724579,
-0.034093599766492844,
-0.05139900743961334,
-0.026132280007004738,
-0.08899113535881042,
0.4133056700229645,
0.4080059230327606,
0.7141927480697632,
0.07418055832386017,
-0.4531446695327759,
-0.5488603711128235,
-0.9401580691337585,
0.7585998773574829,
-0.5552568435668945,
0.4785184860229492,
0.630390465259552,
0.10323525965213776,
-0.5809967517852783,
-0.2272716611623764,
-0.1712840050458908,
-0.40719902515411377,
0.0016891058767214417,
-0.2013416588306427,
-0.0005072872154414654,
-0.03469131514430046,
0.49037638306617737,
0.4764935076236725,
-0.5126567482948303,
-0.1510826200246811,
-0.5207745432853699,
-0.5238376259803772,
0.798995316028595,
0.71039879322052,
0.3168989419937134,
-0.5092538595199585,
-0.3554115891456604,
0.8081890344619751,
-0.7661373019218445,
0.38409894704818726,
0.42541733384132385,
0.3573627769947052,
-0.2274545133113861,
1.054906964302063,
-0.09923314303159714,
0.574225664138794,
-0.025030067190527916,
-0.6104047894477844,
-0.004495649598538876,
-0.4108577072620392,
0.0351095125079155,
0.3709753155708313,
0.28320592641830444,
0.1517459750175476,
0.17445407807826996,
-0.2365122139453888,
-0.37622198462486267,
0.21582812070846558,
0.05877804383635521,
-0.7082286477088928,
-0.2375612109899521,
0.3590512275695801,
-0.6919941902160645,
-0.12169574946165085,
-0.0527355931699276,
-0.30272579193115234,
-0.612251877784729,
-0.3428231179714203,
0.13089904189109802,
0.04954084753990173,
-0.1867380440235138,
0.2967197000980377,
-0.14092759788036346,
0.20551630854606628,
-0.11283069849014282,
-0.8426466584205627,
0.633518636226654,
0.794875979423523,
0.9999260902404785,
-0.18504054844379425,
-0.005555274430662394,
-0.5367820262908936,
0.18489639461040497,
-0.28497034311294556,
0.8063126802444458,
-0.0725424736738205,
-0.7183142304420471,
-0.10476741194725037,
0.1423976868391037,
0.20209994912147522,
-0.49947842955589294,
0.007549721281975508,
-0.5854533314704895,
0.13566890358924866,
-0.14006680250167847,
-0.8133450150489807,
0.16974416375160217,
0.48381152749061584,
-0.8549970388412476,
1.0109150409698486,
0.19673827290534973,
-0.49992847442626953,
0.13472537696361542,
-1.0551772117614746,
-0.7345550060272217,
0.1773644983768463,
-0.010524722747504711,
-0.7352793216705322,
0.4604151248931885,
-0.32958468794822693,
0.680762767791748,
0.031583432108163834,
-0.0022171903401613235,
-0.14572447538375854,
-0.4456719160079956,
0.342331200838089,
-0.21059536933898926,
0.6826076507568359,
0.3741423785686493,
-0.2806686758995056,
0.21044354140758514,
-0.9205694794654846,
-0.5486981272697449,
0.12975655496120453,
-0.6841948628425598,
-0.2933400273323059,
0.80572509765625,
-0.3367847204208374,
-0.09541434794664383,
0.47205397486686707,
-0.7876549363136292,
0.104381263256073,
-0.07006080448627472,
0.5808903574943542,
0.7741960287094116,
0.05470230057835579,
0.30563926696777344,
-0.46657994389533997,
0.5273749232292175,
-0.14981576800346375,
0.13534407317638397,
-0.24752023816108704,
-0.6002091765403748,
-0.37171629071235657,
-0.6485586762428284,
0.19246090948581696,
0.6367627382278442,
-0.38075321912765503,
0.4266433119773865,
-0.4547463357448578,
-0.13449344038963318,
0.09466610103845596,
0.2257964164018631,
0.1373469978570938,
0.2275516837835312,
-0.10209222882986069,
-0.39559072256088257,
-0.8843706250190735,
-0.37171170115470886,
-0.11472998559474945,
-0.3162331283092499,
-0.04894481226801872,
0.4236322045326233,
0.45830512046813965,
-0.2865316867828369,
1.1130212545394897,
-0.8062950968742371,
-0.24939821660518646,
-0.33601272106170654,
0.05532601475715637,
0.29592469334602356,
-0.05528924986720085,
0.344112753868103,
-0.7584538459777832,
-0.43192505836486816,
-0.08157234638929367,
-0.7548584938049316,
-0.0025691399350762367,
-0.07694035023450851,
0.2362394481897354,
-0.19820769131183624,
0.8192529082298279,
-0.2760319411754608,
0.4777025282382965,
0.49933668971061707,
-0.7575832605361938,
0.5988192558288574,
0.10341358184814453,
-0.1623939722776413,
-1.1819533109664917,
-0.33003470301628113,
0.019044771790504456,
-0.507153332233429,
-0.6095633506774902,
-0.2969352900981903,
-0.1781396120786667,
-0.15791930258274078,
-0.4800715744495392,
0.7383178472518921,
-0.913364827632904,
-0.45159226655960083,
-0.18145738542079926,
-0.15142130851745605,
-0.23589837551116943,
0.5802626013755798,
-0.01872815191745758,
0.6380568146705627,
0.4138118326663971,
-0.6760413646697998,
0.6562135815620422,
-0.1685410737991333,
-0.8582138419151306,
0.21406923234462738,
-0.3302655816078186,
-0.03773530572652817,
-0.0036917859688401222,
-0.11792146414518356,
-1.2861254215240479,
-0.4377695620059967,
0.12039809674024582,
-0.3606589436531067,
0.044371094554662704,
-0.02955463156104088,
-0.6556305885314941,
-0.44648244976997375,
-0.6830449104309082,
0.39168140292167664,
0.3996775448322296,
-0.39652132987976074,
0.9212512373924255,
0.8038101196289062,
-0.06718987971544266,
-0.27497953176498413,
-0.28445926308631897,
-0.2798457145690918,
-0.47865259647369385,
-0.37111833691596985,
0.31631171703338623,
-0.18267178535461426,
-0.43711888790130615,
-0.008215871639549732,
-0.2862529158592224,
-0.20819275081157684,
0.4831809997558594,
0.7082011699676514,
0.5716730356216431,
-0.2280907928943634,
0.06648504734039307,
-0.5510284304618835,
0.08970420062541962,
0.22936029732227325,
0.009657196700572968,
0.6308419704437256,
-0.19369973242282867,
-0.5034673810005188,
-0.18063178658485413,
0.27613863348960876,
0.6647693514823914,
-0.06349670141935349,
0.17378774285316467,
0.34893691539764404,
-0.681675136089325,
-0.020735975354909897,
-0.4444487690925598,
0.04597518965601921,
-0.5309223532676697,
0.5347799062728882,
-0.18731485307216644,
-1.2560442686080933,
0.9577060341835022,
-0.2712400257587433,
0.2667735815048218,
0.009923228062689304,
0.7401587963104248,
-0.3089158833026886,
0.958264172077179,
0.8435850739479065,
-0.2688486576080322,
1.0668529272079468,
-0.0709155797958374,
0.5474280118942261,
-1.199668288230896,
-0.2907755970954895,
-0.25818178057670593,
-0.576418399810791,
-0.47754499316215515,
-0.4865086078643799,
0.27924108505249023,
-0.27921730279922485,
-0.15101580321788788,
0.5288227796554565,
-0.1540132313966751,
0.5336218476295471,
-0.03466951102018356,
0.2992643415927887,
0.5327428579330444,
0.15568770468235016,
0.04429890587925911,
-0.03669455647468567,
-0.5233619213104248,
-0.5787411332130432,
1.065595269203186,
0.5697717070579529,
0.8640314936637878,
0.2876778542995453,
0.9168649911880493,
0.693027913570404,
0.6129025816917419,
-1.2673585414886475,
0.8355412483215332,
0.11747762560844421,
-1.0615293979644775,
-0.45677244663238525,
-0.40161657333374023,
-1.4201704263687134,
-0.356613427400589,
0.17647860944271088,
-0.8106986284255981,
0.05876564234495163,
-0.060236673802137375,
-0.680351197719574,
0.44187870621681213,
-0.4706299602985382,
0.45997384190559387,
-0.4834648370742798,
-0.2793939411640167,
-0.1466050148010254,
-0.10678009688854218,
0.4136549234390259,
0.14388419687747955,
0.5909112691879272,
-0.372227281332016,
0.1260419338941574,
0.570868730545044,
-0.08145051449537277,
1.0616368055343628,
0.18713067471981049,
-0.3231794536113739,
0.7651147246360779,
0.26550066471099854,
0.4285527467727661,
0.07721822708845139,
0.2504101097583771,
-0.14017070829868317,
-0.27875062823295593,
-0.4598509967327118,
-0.2725001275539398,
0.5441937446594238,
-0.41899779438972473,
-0.5248493552207947,
-0.5723056793212891,
-0.4777016341686249,
0.03238542005419731,
-0.09851866960525513,
-0.16553683578968048,
0.5497162938117981,
-0.49092838168144226,
0.16215300559997559,
0.6198002099990845,
0.4312700927257538,
0.7555219531059265,
0.7160541415214539,
-0.3651691675186157,
0.1772443652153015,
1.223183512687683,
0.3381170332431793,
-0.22723138332366943,
0.41226518154144287,
0.3223274052143097,
-0.3257370591163635,
-0.6148830652236938,
-0.023818954825401306,
0.2565050423145294,
-0.3725088834762573,
-0.11383071541786194,
-0.17337428033351898,
-0.1847608983516693,
-0.0326487198472023,
0.014962590299546719,
-0.20781470835208893,
-0.43783408403396606,
-0.44176870584487915,
-0.3202238976955414,
0.1728866696357727,
0.9268392324447632,
0.0028563342057168484,
0.14395740628242493,
-0.9380845427513123,
0.694571316242218,
0.6450906991958618,
0.6094813346862793,
-0.1010303646326065,
-0.3143770694732666,
-0.4596339762210846,
-0.3787442743778229,
-0.2709462642669678,
-0.8414633870124817,
0.08907297253608704,
-0.07340412586927414,
0.7575230598449707,
0.4785054326057434,
-0.29171475768089294,
0.49355995655059814,
-0.6452416777610779,
1.017844557762146,
0.21952828764915466,
-0.8423231244087219,
0.2572861313819885,
-0.30527982115745544,
-0.06448893994092941,
0.08658565580844879,
0.2876242697238922,
-0.27677783370018005,
0.3794311583042145,
-0.6661592721939087,
-0.8104239106178284,
0.13109606504440308,
-0.0264878012239933,
0.12187331914901733,
-0.1480608433485031,
0.21037288010120392,
-0.27667856216430664,
0.3833119571208954,
-0.8535332679748535,
0.054089564830064774,
0.07877255231142044,
-0.04834914952516556,
0.3008292615413666,
-0.2717095911502838,
-0.2806655764579773,
-0.2648254632949829,
0.4576367437839508,
-0.1674019992351532,
0.35947996377944946,
-0.01518864557147026,
-0.24019689857959747,
-0.2538224458694458,
0.12595099210739136,
0.6540210247039795,
0.6069720983505249,
-0.1300612986087799,
0.1858309507369995,
0.25201162695884705,
-0.6784742474555969,
0.203238844871521,
-0.17535604536533356,
0.15743005275726318,
0.05876367539167404,
0.6030675172805786,
0.5909745693206787,
0.2951751947402954,
-0.8415564298629761,
0.2890392541885376,
0.06359975785017014,
-0.08453112095594406,
-0.6521266102790833,
0.18139851093292236,
0.16413387656211853,
0.6355894207954407,
0.15857751667499542,
-0.15962722897529602,
0.21507424116134644,
-1.1968293190002441,
0.08783067762851715,
0.5126767158508301,
-0.592823326587677,
-0.6066929697990417,
0.2955211400985718,
0.16406895220279694,
-1.1037495136260986,
0.5619753003120422,
-0.36504849791526794,
-0.6274473071098328,
0.7830459475517273,
0.210274338722229,
1.01642906665802,
-0.2887158691883087,
0.13690324127674103,
0.0954514741897583,
0.04271751269698143,
-0.23251935839653015,
0.8835774660110474,
-0.27747899293899536,
-0.8320276737213135,
-0.4593498408794403,
-0.6724286079406738,
-0.2642246186733246,
-0.007687219884246588,
-0.32178017497062683,
0.13367564976215363,
-0.548572301864624,
-0.4123423397541046,
-0.05933269113302231,
0.28851187229156494,
-0.5259930491447449,
0.013890763744711876,
0.5091368556022644,
0.5725674629211426,
-0.8491867184638977,
0.7149452567100525,
0.6730319857597351,
0.15386860072612762,
-0.6991008520126343,
-0.2580791413784027,
0.3177536427974701,
-0.6247687339782715,
0.6259114146232605,
-0.20029352605342865,
-0.46962371468544006,
-0.17094627022743225,
-0.6234032511711121,
-0.7508651614189148,
1.395871877670288,
-0.11875951290130615,
-0.5371019244194031,
-0.059272054582834244,
0.05252277851104736,
0.6565054655075073,
-0.6681731939315796,
-0.385159969329834,
0.46435853838920593,
0.5186675190925598,
-0.24385574460029602,
-0.5629757046699524,
0.05127124488353729,
-0.17207512259483337,
-0.16928473114967346,
0.19819176197052002,
-0.5448940396308899,
0.8047592639923096,
-0.5204591751098633,
-0.3532114028930664,
0.150817409157753,
0.786252498626709,
0.6298603415489197,
0.682839035987854,
0.6136466264724731,
0.04120280593633652,
0.6424015164375305,
-0.08804310113191605,
0.8035853505134583,
-0.4498605728149414,
0.4762256145477295,
0.8452367186546326,
-0.4178895950317383,
0.6849050521850586,
0.4870435893535614,
-0.5203894376754761,
0.6423888206481934,
0.7790708541870117,
-0.0884346142411232,
0.4788411259651184,
0.7207529544830322,
-0.35601571202278137,
-0.23244306445121765,
-0.08948701620101929,
0.014712052419781685,
0.42628705501556396,
0.7603015303611755,
-0.2504602074623108,
-0.1832912117242813,
-0.2716583013534546,
0.06203277409076691,
-0.01845058985054493,
-0.25368353724479675,
0.6313508152961731,
0.16672943532466888,
-0.4424370527267456,
0.09430928528308868,
-0.0351678840816021,
0.5576871037483215,
-0.8910422325134277,
-0.10253969579935074,
0.008422313258051872,
0.06313508003950119,
-0.3652685582637787,
-0.5621106028556824,
0.36601588129997253,
-0.159844309091568,
-0.3858041763305664,
-0.300441712141037,
0.6704407930374146,
-0.18169359862804413,
-0.5043531656265259,
0.25885045528411865,
0.6965699195861816,
0.2581058740615845,
0.0003873074019793421,
-0.33740219473838806,
-0.05314043164253235,
-0.2182570993900299,
-0.4262551963329315,
0.3787549138069153,
0.5525095462799072,
-0.3845962882041931,
0.5954012870788574,
0.7282089591026306,
0.14967811107635498,
0.26620128750801086,
-0.09766913205385208,
0.6998253464698792,
-0.7919583320617676,
-0.5301603078842163,
-0.9042130708694458,
0.4083797037601471,
-0.01050342246890068,
-0.2926776707172394,
0.9299739003181458,
0.9347091913223267,
0.46362823247909546,
-0.17272233963012695,
0.5137920379638672,
0.030190128833055496,
0.445927232503891,
-0.4231962561607361,
0.21709375083446503,
-0.36991560459136963,
0.758184015750885,
0.042094312608242035,
-0.9168495535850525,
-0.1285550594329834,
0.6537619233131409,
-0.14578890800476074,
-0.5850610136985779,
0.6613025665283203,
0.8075081706047058,
-0.17699506878852844,
0.06127976253628731,
0.300143301486969,
0.1627926081418991,
0.4750925600528717,
0.35956457257270813,
1.0189118385314941,
-0.2305220663547516,
0.25879254937171936,
0.047023091465234756,
-0.2110922485589981,
-0.38436853885650635,
-1.1250061988830566,
-1.1458944082260132,
-0.587674081325531,
-0.3740878701210022,
-0.44291457533836365,
-0.10205455124378204,
1.0721925497055054,
0.6664142608642578,
-0.8765319585800171,
-0.9109281301498413,
0.13973970711231232,
0.42388442158699036,
-0.5316596627235413,
-0.18093328177928925,
0.37082669138908386,
0.10415592044591904,
-0.34549257159233093,
0.672254204750061,
0.5137696862220764,
0.13949918746948242,
-0.6843166947364807,
-0.0034958103206008673,
-0.2647409439086914,
0.34966301918029785,
1.0740176439285278,
0.6692870855331421,
-0.5276685953140259,
-0.42803648114204407,
0.3470216691493988,
0.01257282868027687,
0.08123521506786346,
1.350357174873352,
-0.555838406085968,
0.1320585012435913,
0.8770485520362854,
0.3848268687725067,
0.5948948860168457,
-0.08271721750497818,
0.009696697816252708,
-0.8982102870941162,
-0.06241382285952568,
0.10023152828216553,
0.6154792308807373,
0.18769587576389313,
-0.5273221135139465,
0.7122400403022766,
0.3505735397338867,
-0.47840431332588196,
-0.8750942349433899,
0.5262770056724548,
-1.067339301109314,
-0.40295255184173584,
1.0249627828598022,
-0.056986138224601746,
-0.5445912480354309,
-0.8520573973655701,
-0.34209540486335754,
-0.022488821297883987,
-0.2825621962547302,
1.2865772247314453,
1.0033735036849976,
-0.6020030975341797,
0.15791213512420654,
-0.5617409348487854,
0.4165819585323334,
-0.09647717326879501,
-0.6987066268920898,
0.04967595264315605,
0.3486312925815582,
0.4344087541103363,
0.6007342338562012,
0.766098141670227,
-0.1716560423374176,
0.043757032603025436,
-0.2815873324871063,
-0.4916599690914154,
-0.1772138625383377,
-0.5347514748573303,
0.06800532341003418,
0.3619784414768219,
-0.19452142715454102,
-0.22119250893592834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13770v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13770v1 | Elliptical Attention | 2024-06-19T18:38:11 | 2024-06-19T18:38:11 | Stefan K. Nielsen, Laziz U. Abdullaev, Rachel Teo, Tan M. Nguyen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML | Pairwise dot-product self-attention is key to the success of transformers
that achieve state-of-the-art performance across a variety of applications in
language and vision. This dot-product self-attention computes attention weights
among the input tokens using Euclidean distance, which makes the model prone to
representation collapse and vulnerable to contaminated samples. In this paper,
we propose using a Mahalanobis distance metric for computing the attention
weights to stretch the underlying feature space in directions of high
contextual relevance. In particular, we define a hyper-ellipsoidal neighborhood
around each query to increase the attention weights of the tokens lying in the
contextually important directions. We term this novel class of attention
Elliptical Attention. Our Elliptical Attention provides two benefits: 1)
reducing representation collapse and 2) enhancing the model's robustness as the
Elliptical Attention pays more attention to contextually relevant information
rather than focusing on some small subset of informative features. We
empirically demonstrate the advantages of Elliptical Attention over the
baseline dot-product attention and state-of-the-art attention methods on
various practical tasks, including object classification, image segmentation,
and language modeling across different data modalities. | [
-0.7555355429649353,
-0.7013347744941711,
0.4362528324127197,
0.4552435874938965,
-0.15689674019813538,
-0.193424254655838,
-0.3517870306968689,
-0.5032632350921631,
0.5073038935661316,
0.5278909206390381,
-0.49356138706207275,
-0.5781850814819336,
-0.6754459738731384,
0.04912920296192169,
-0.5970029830932617,
0.7778878808021545,
0.02599697932600975,
-0.41736266016960144,
-0.278381884098053,
-0.3264031410217285,
-0.3857371509075165,
-0.6302744746208191,
-0.2905222177505493,
0.3496409058570862,
0.901897668838501,
0.5400103330612183,
0.7598738074302673,
0.8646386861801147,
0.7997450828552246,
0.3620823323726654,
0.30342385172843933,
0.1780785620212555,
-0.5905237197875977,
0.3156759738922119,
-0.0884600281715393,
-0.5172077417373657,
-0.3675921559333801,
-0.03323422744870186,
0.39344462752342224,
0.8371322154998779,
-0.0008057640516199172,
0.6110615730285645,
0.20274268090724945,
1.0434398651123047,
-0.926920473575592,
0.032212018966674805,
-0.38479289412498474,
0.17089371383190155,
-0.38849812746047974,
0.036586660891771317,
-0.07916083186864853,
-0.11834346503019333,
0.0327114574611187,
-1.0433070659637451,
0.1449618637561798,
0.39566946029663086,
0.9846305251121521,
0.7702361345291138,
-0.1109573021531105,
-0.008122038096189499,
-0.8662631511688232,
0.8025415539741516,
-0.14078864455223083,
0.6398187875747681,
0.3754603862762451,
0.5479975342750549,
0.0832749530673027,
-0.6689908504486084,
-0.441336065530777,
0.20192886888980865,
-0.016408193856477737,
0.23625560104846954,
-0.41238629817962646,
-0.009921147488057613,
0.0583915188908577,
0.18800538778305054,
-0.21402214467525482,
-0.20208892226219177,
-0.47452765703201294,
0.10144387930631638,
0.3306758403778076,
0.19101156294345856,
0.12070026993751526,
-0.2966894209384918,
-0.6249439120292664,
-0.07655913382768631,
-0.713172972202301,
-0.056912172585725784,
0.38512924313545227,
0.14236503839492798,
0.2406511902809143,
0.6838210225105286,
-0.553943932056427,
0.7282834053039551,
0.8073469400405884,
0.2142508327960968,
-0.046509575098752975,
-0.10923759639263153,
-0.2668066620826721,
-0.05291115120053291,
0.47263893485069275,
0.49609848856925964,
0.15193791687488556,
-0.36430254578590393,
0.07762967050075531,
-0.3894195854663849,
0.5069032907485962,
-0.6846436858177185,
-0.1576215922832489,
0.25534331798553467,
-0.7501493692398071,
0.10777924209833145,
-0.012567236088216305,
-0.7374101281166077,
0.192778542637825,
-0.6509969830513,
0.4236733317375183,
-0.2473466694355011,
0.026715543121099472,
0.19693095982074738,
0.11924133449792862,
-0.13878178596496582,
-0.06467632204294205,
-1.2547872066497803,
0.13379086554050446,
0.5632879137992859,
0.5401807427406311,
-0.282894492149353,
-0.014728234149515629,
-0.3391959071159363,
0.43764442205429077,
-0.40073537826538086,
1.0756322145462036,
-0.7179886698722839,
-0.09471673518419266,
-0.05195437744259834,
0.028491003438830376,
-0.11259771138429642,
-0.696882963180542,
0.7134072184562683,
-0.46958816051483154,
0.15825320780277252,
-0.24712391197681427,
-0.2285802811384201,
-0.32197052240371704,
0.23118923604488373,
-0.5839545726776123,
1.4773731231689453,
0.10978295654058456,
-0.8963667154312134,
0.3748551905155182,
-0.41117051243782043,
-0.40774306654930115,
0.22224006056785583,
-0.15232354402542114,
-0.7923722863197327,
0.13243867456912994,
0.624613344669342,
0.6110240817070007,
0.19517536461353302,
-0.38204842805862427,
-0.6809489130973816,
-0.1602967530488968,
0.019051507115364075,
0.03172760456800461,
0.2110893279314041,
-0.06679679453372955,
-0.6717539429664612,
0.1818910837173462,
-0.7926052212715149,
0.0032841742504388094,
0.07244637608528137,
-0.09690132737159729,
-0.7826042175292969,
-0.05112827569246292,
0.2996407747268677,
0.21957054734230042,
0.4078308939933777,
-0.2708589732646942,
0.0947035700082779,
-0.4683094024658203,
0.20227625966072083,
0.6476004123687744,
-0.028968367725610733,
0.5476137399673462,
0.1709565818309784,
0.6327604055404663,
0.030722128227353096,
0.5238771438598633,
-0.07501418143510818,
-0.145646870136261,
-1.062800645828247,
-0.6663428544998169,
0.24015727639198303,
0.06566091626882553,
-0.5703899264335632,
0.8331573009490967,
-0.16756698489189148,
-0.4712698459625244,
-0.538040041923523,
0.1683778315782547,
0.3424472510814667,
0.5868468284606934,
0.28926730155944824,
-0.26169145107269287,
-0.47718775272369385,
-1.326676845550537,
-0.31146109104156494,
0.15088360011577606,
-0.27368903160095215,
0.41666385531425476,
0.10066091269254684,
-0.13376189768314362,
0.9068467020988464,
-0.5257405638694763,
-0.8224367499351501,
-0.07186727225780487,
-0.21388819813728333,
0.1328570693731308,
-0.054769791662693024,
0.6345665454864502,
-0.7987335324287415,
-0.6132652163505554,
-0.015281589701771736,
-0.3373034596443176,
-0.012072698213160038,
0.0037744876462966204,
-0.5121937990188599,
-0.10303675383329391,
0.5337349772453308,
-0.7666612863540649,
0.5065690875053406,
0.4509322941303253,
-0.2938687205314636,
0.4281221330165863,
-0.00020169625349808484,
0.1030304878950119,
-0.8980278372764587,
0.32773491740226746,
0.11773788928985596,
-0.22795434296131134,
-0.425454705953598,
-0.09763525426387787,
0.061086926609277725,
0.112649105489254,
-0.341600239276886,
0.3686680495738983,
-0.7284565567970276,
-0.33243730664253235,
-0.1680993288755417,
0.4120350778102875,
0.17967596650123596,
0.9627370238304138,
0.034634023904800415,
0.5659578442573547,
0.500596284866333,
-0.633263885974884,
0.36122778058052063,
0.403207391500473,
-0.20734156668186188,
0.944829523563385,
-0.8559579253196716,
0.20487511157989502,
-0.019123878329992294,
-0.17821641266345978,
-1.178695559501648,
-0.15987002849578857,
0.318354070186615,
-0.4706491529941559,
0.2683568298816681,
0.19922709465026855,
-0.4730151891708374,
-0.4664944112300873,
-0.2983705997467041,
0.7042155265808105,
0.20883364975452423,
-0.791280210018158,
0.6507747769355774,
0.3579035997390747,
-0.13094501197338104,
-0.5515936017036438,
-0.5212274789810181,
-0.0755501538515091,
-0.6641929745674133,
-0.6921191215515137,
0.22453376650810242,
0.37772881984710693,
0.020650286227464676,
0.1752200722694397,
-0.05964018031954765,
0.20178499817848206,
-0.13306377828121185,
0.4416057765483856,
0.052167024463415146,
-0.11920870840549469,
0.11553715169429779,
-0.035996776074171066,
-0.22668655216693878,
0.21879571676254272,
-0.5007566809654236,
0.32952821254730225,
0.2526478171348572,
-0.33624327182769775,
-0.516587495803833,
0.5763249397277832,
0.4709172546863556,
-0.5580054521560669,
0.49763235449790955,
0.5461640954017639,
-0.4173133373260498,
-0.14250017702579498,
-0.5515096187591553,
-0.3633235692977905,
-0.5106205344200134,
0.6841598749160767,
-0.36285480856895447,
-0.6970557570457458,
0.34163597226142883,
0.20660631358623505,
-0.3508548140525818,
0.33832505345344543,
0.8840203285217285,
-0.13005338609218597,
1.2104308605194092,
0.7378968000411987,
-0.20948174595832825,
0.7271824479103088,
-0.053141165524721146,
0.6507349014282227,
-1.138193964958191,
-0.33508241176605225,
-0.46479371190071106,
-0.5866027474403381,
-0.12219616770744324,
-0.5110504031181335,
0.6963397860527039,
-0.09688469767570496,
0.06596515327692032,
0.4859735369682312,
-0.9009599089622498,
0.4203942120075226,
0.6031636595726013,
0.21917082369327545,
0.0687250941991806,
0.20773380994796753,
0.125789612531662,
-0.4810061454772949,
-0.7433868050575256,
-0.3137010931968689,
1.2665337324142456,
0.398468941450119,
0.6931820511817932,
-0.2611454129219055,
0.5203099250793457,
0.071928471326828,
0.12746372818946838,
-0.7032764554023743,
0.2510262429714203,
0.11571525037288666,
-0.712658166885376,
-0.5000901818275452,
-0.054278723895549774,
-1.052340030670166,
0.33174124360084534,
0.05893102288246155,
-0.5939698219299316,
0.43808528780937195,
0.19996672868728638,
-0.5997746586799622,
-0.16869936883449554,
-0.6663358807563782,
0.8723174333572388,
-0.185865119099617,
-0.5353913903236389,
-0.34348317980766296,
-0.5805882215499878,
0.08567159622907639,
0.16340386867523193,
0.06590120494365692,
-0.2866678535938263,
-0.19956892728805542,
0.6309779286384583,
-0.14154726266860962,
0.6923637986183167,
0.01935969665646553,
0.16067513823509216,
0.09331832826137543,
0.013767194002866745,
0.26092588901519775,
-0.018416931852698326,
0.7213467359542847,
0.3393658995628357,
-0.3867243826389313,
-0.5781306624412537,
-0.7036186456680298,
0.47042763233184814,
-0.6094768643379211,
-0.7990508079528809,
-0.06757084280252457,
-0.5122129321098328,
-0.10898497700691223,
0.3915979266166687,
0.1443110704421997,
0.3139147460460663,
-0.07454170286655426,
0.12339140474796295,
0.654045581817627,
0.23743505775928497,
0.37379229068756104,
0.019095566123723984,
-0.23340065777301788,
-0.4376945197582245,
0.6519999504089355,
0.10319826751947403,
0.2425255924463272,
0.4674401879310608,
-0.24608291685581207,
-0.44703784584999084,
-0.28006047010421753,
-0.414734810590744,
0.309781938791275,
-0.5377549529075623,
-0.3630232512950897,
-0.6600557565689087,
0.19263514876365662,
-0.2643964886665344,
-0.053751252591609955,
-0.6563673615455627,
-0.8136146664619446,
-0.12107695639133453,
-0.07313036173582077,
0.08166678994894028,
0.6560697555541992,
-0.03429398313164711,
-0.050575289875268936,
-0.3163544535636902,
0.38152971863746643,
0.4821641445159912,
0.19092807173728943,
0.004609405994415283,
-0.35654014348983765,
-0.6340501308441162,
-0.3884369134902954,
-0.47621676325798035,
-0.6191189289093018,
0.5459919571876526,
0.1758178025484085,
0.5663173198699951,
0.8325194716453552,
-0.08340642601251602,
0.7597766518592834,
-0.6923110485076904,
0.3196176290512085,
0.29091453552246094,
-0.742383599281311,
0.3942958116531372,
-0.444264680147171,
0.30879881978034973,
0.40493151545524597,
0.4136485755443573,
-0.6564918160438538,
-0.726479172706604,
-0.2575076222419739,
-0.8561168313026428,
0.5255587100982666,
0.5507622361183167,
-0.08298514783382416,
-0.056317269802093506,
0.4233647286891937,
-0.11582647264003754,
-0.008622323162853718,
-0.2964574992656708,
-0.5128222703933716,
-0.2474137842655182,
-0.435599148273468,
0.22427873313426971,
-0.10447557270526886,
-0.30694347620010376,
-0.2362532764673233,
0.4374263882637024,
-0.2465640902519226,
0.4592156708240509,
0.6124120950698853,
0.07195208966732025,
-0.10620521754026413,
-0.2585667669773102,
0.34241917729377747,
0.44645702838897705,
0.09635922312736511,
0.1673133671283722,
-0.04310515895485878,
-0.521435558795929,
-0.10802558064460754,
0.2951691448688507,
0.10449225455522537,
0.057532548904418945,
0.11765365302562714,
0.3715561330318451,
0.420265257358551,
-0.28993839025497437,
0.4457954466342926,
-0.07491455227136612,
0.0662442147731781,
-0.27439525723457336,
-0.26921606063842773,
0.21966934204101562,
0.21730060875415802,
0.5481504201889038,
0.03298508748412132,
0.7882078289985657,
-0.16121353209018707,
0.25144433975219727,
0.3696056008338928,
-0.5284570455551147,
-0.33257222175598145,
1.024405598640442,
0.4041787385940552,
-0.10092533379793167,
0.16959138214588165,
0.2198442816734314,
-0.7039221525192261,
0.7926806211471558,
0.20613069832324982,
0.8407406210899353,
-0.361510306596756,
-0.11127579212188721,
0.43853694200515747,
0.1776728481054306,
0.35408103466033936,
-0.3326532244682312,
-0.4465993046760559,
-0.3296833038330078,
-0.1041489988565445,
-0.27545058727264404,
-0.1411133110523224,
-0.6085382699966431,
-0.7520039677619934,
0.3519357740879059,
-0.4273139536380768,
-0.3248220384120941,
0.021992888301610947,
-0.3329419195652008,
-0.5809983611106873,
0.2475259155035019,
0.2654363512992859,
0.4073197543621063,
-0.4300083518028259,
0.6232947707176208,
0.5032472014427185,
-0.3250245749950409,
-0.5591139197349548,
-0.04275793209671974,
-0.476266086101532,
-0.9307053089141846,
0.7719370722770691,
0.5779329538345337,
-0.3820122480392456,
-0.2451280951499939,
-0.3811087906360626,
-1.3462263345718384,
0.9767981171607971,
0.3093765079975128,
-0.9149684309959412,
-0.17047330737113953,
0.4821558892726898,
0.5312336683273315,
-0.4558480381965637,
0.27879929542541504,
0.5246844291687012,
0.3479559123516083,
-0.20055212080478668,
-0.6456325650215149,
-0.04075545445084572,
-0.06361724436283112,
0.27423548698425293,
0.3644065856933594,
-1.1840938329696655,
0.37059348821640015,
-0.013805384747684002,
-0.501862108707428,
-0.008401739411056042,
1.013863444328308,
0.11725527793169022,
0.253000944852829,
0.5457510352134705,
0.7276895642280579,
0.3029003441333771,
-0.12551143765449524,
0.9073280692100525,
-0.7023177742958069,
0.6025339365005493,
0.7902719974517822,
0.11394213140010834,
0.7572812438011169,
0.7868567109107971,
-0.24199791252613068,
0.5260962247848511,
0.693821132183075,
0.13750988245010376,
0.6973316669464111,
-0.08139677345752716,
0.16584277153015137,
-0.3240446150302887,
0.08026541024446487,
-0.21425805985927582,
0.23557822406291962,
0.34322911500930786,
-0.33740976452827454,
0.1654956340789795,
0.0034116378519684076,
-0.026164107024669647,
0.3141135275363922,
-0.214218407869339,
0.5618072152137756,
0.12998683750629425,
-0.6310890316963196,
0.5297352075576782,
-0.2544591426849365,
0.2966882288455963,
-0.07899517565965652,
0.05417344719171524,
-0.3332332670688629,
0.5697363018989563,
-0.24520449340343475,
-0.3908328711986542,
0.4727685749530792,
-0.4275217652320862,
-0.3426516056060791,
0.0796409621834755,
0.45698148012161255,
-0.5282738208770752,
-0.6756130456924438,
0.4110637903213501,
-0.11423635482788086,
-0.12922510504722595,
-0.4490140676498413,
-0.7762364149093628,
0.0039184726774692535,
-0.17471782863140106,
-0.488228976726532,
-0.08990202844142914,
0.6947575807571411,
0.13834179937839508,
0.641888439655304,
0.36835750937461853,
-0.2843833267688751,
0.5045228004455566,
-0.11321114748716354,
0.8414539694786072,
-0.5652068853378296,
-0.6209270358085632,
-0.4748178720474243,
0.3575688600540161,
-0.2780809700489044,
-0.38982293009757996,
1.0092031955718994,
0.6165724992752075,
0.6101386547088623,
0.06379754096269608,
0.4389847218990326,
0.1490412801504135,
0.6271772384643555,
-0.36272740364074707,
0.5744816660881042,
-0.6701043844223022,
-0.20269383490085602,
-0.11027203500270844,
-1.3116869926452637,
-0.4679923355579376,
0.42313680052757263,
-0.5378309488296509,
0.052495017647743225,
0.8243629932403564,
0.5870407819747925,
-0.10097052901983261,
-0.5296850204467773,
0.48618802428245544,
0.08648467808961868,
0.04640970006585121,
0.7826297879219055,
0.7088051438331604,
-0.4243704378604889,
0.7735599279403687,
-0.3087494671344757,
-0.20072966814041138,
-0.3525014817714691,
-0.16055543720722198,
-1.223537802696228,
-0.6371153593063354,
-0.28957757353782654,
-0.0612536184489727,
0.11272385716438293,
0.3751092553138733,
1.2914103269577026,
-0.5749827027320862,
0.2146582156419754,
0.16092661023139954,
-0.0032920667435973883,
-0.21192863583564758,
-0.2285791039466858,
0.7505744099617004,
-0.5103614330291748,
-1.0838713645935059,
-0.2897586226463318,
0.8864067792892456,
-0.29037266969680786,
-0.6965340375900269,
0.1834123134613037,
0.13856452703475952,
0.13147898018360138,
0.4130367934703827,
0.17186106741428375,
-0.74976646900177,
-0.27057358622550964,
0.24011872708797455,
-0.2951456904411316,
0.49693313241004944,
0.6979312300682068,
-0.49838340282440186,
0.5257163047790527,
0.1585603803396225,
0.5799039602279663,
0.6946788430213928,
0.3372647166252136,
0.506023645401001,
-0.711473286151886,
0.4942421019077301,
0.21275989711284637,
0.2204391062259674,
0.5355498790740967,
-0.7648064494132996,
0.2519405782222748,
0.08195754885673523,
-0.7528814673423767,
-0.1987418681383133,
0.3162677586078644,
-1.0214612483978271,
0.11737199127674103,
1.0860092639923096,
-0.1656455397605896,
-0.9139299988746643,
-0.09315004199743271,
-0.5072658061981201,
-0.11374600231647491,
-0.4214606285095215,
1.2244056463241577,
0.643091082572937,
-0.19594553112983704,
-0.0038017830811440945,
-0.2716332674026489,
0.47552409768104553,
0.9985664486885071,
-0.7306888699531555,
-0.00519874831661582,
0.2385251373052597,
0.1794460266828537,
0.37558817863464355,
-0.13573311269283295,
-0.3753996193408966,
0.3822728395462036,
-0.1470290571451187,
0.40156251192092896,
0.30596378445625305,
-0.519387423992157,
-0.13765136897563934,
0.3358338475227356,
-0.08989883959293365,
-0.6036149263381958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13764v1 | Can LLMs Reason in the Wild with Programs? | 2024-06-19T18:26:19 | 2024-06-19T18:26:19 | Yuan Yang, Siheng Xiong, Ali Payani, Ehsan Shareghi, Faramarz Fekri | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown superior capability to solve
reasoning problems with programs. While being a promising direction, most of
such frameworks are trained and evaluated in settings with a prior knowledge of
task requirements. However, as LLMs become more capable, it is necessary to
assess their reasoning abilities in more realistic scenarios where many
real-world problems are open-ended with ambiguous scope, and often require
multiple formalisms to solve. To investigate this, we introduce the task of
reasoning in the wild, where an LLM is tasked to solve a reasoning problem of
unknown type by identifying the subproblems and their corresponding formalisms,
and writing a program to solve each subproblem, guided by a tactic. We create a
large tactic-guided trajectory dataset containing detailed solutions to a
diverse set of reasoning problems, ranging from well-defined single-form
reasoning (e.g., math, logic), to ambiguous and hybrid ones (e.g., commonsense,
combined math and logic). This allows us to test various aspects of LLMs
reasoning at the fine-grained level such as the selection and execution of
tactics, and the tendency to take undesired shortcuts. In experiments, we
highlight that existing LLMs fail significantly on problems with ambiguous and
mixed scope, revealing critical limitations and overfitting issues (e.g.
accuracy on GSM8K drops by at least 50\%). We further show the potential of
finetuning a local LLM on the tactic-guided trajectories in achieving better
performance. Project repo is available at
github.com/gblackout/Reason-in-the-Wild | [
-0.2594607472419739,
-0.889825701713562,
0.8513864874839783,
0.3624957799911499,
-0.18569950759410858,
0.17538407444953918,
-0.5562312006950378,
-0.2904895842075348,
0.1548662781715393,
0.6094688773155212,
-1.017498254776001,
-0.5914177298545837,
-0.5537212491035461,
-0.06635408848524094,
-0.20314544439315796,
0.7427804470062256,
-0.2705497145652771,
-0.07773368805646896,
0.028034355491399765,
-0.3979368805885315,
-0.7293415069580078,
-0.5316371917724609,
-0.3130337595939636,
-0.30497249960899353,
0.5956584811210632,
0.5588610768318176,
0.6930888891220093,
0.40716552734375,
0.5031037926673889,
0.2580368220806122,
-0.12055676430463791,
0.5473551154136658,
-0.6731647849082947,
0.41683751344680786,
-0.3353891372680664,
-0.7026318907737732,
-0.07227706909179688,
0.15184229612350464,
0.4278873801231384,
0.7646664381027222,
-0.19933240115642548,
-0.2375411093235016,
-0.26764991879463196,
0.4740639626979828,
-0.5454351305961609,
-0.2320707142353058,
-0.9040961265563965,
0.10371826589107513,
-0.2886953353881836,
-0.3473049998283386,
-0.16553644835948944,
-0.3091961145401001,
0.16282621026039124,
-0.6825812458992004,
-0.044262759387493134,
0.16207052767276764,
0.9088026881217957,
0.23140035569667816,
-0.48829904198646545,
-0.49417644739151,
-1.0863709449768066,
0.8920325636863708,
-0.7380642890930176,
0.06164189800620079,
0.2380973994731903,
0.6488208770751953,
-0.6315984129905701,
-0.4175986349582672,
-0.3251122534275055,
-0.17089512944221497,
0.19783200323581696,
0.024390392005443573,
-0.18196380138397217,
0.016438506543636322,
0.6196362972259521,
0.07507788389921188,
-0.553982675075531,
0.23442772030830383,
-0.4009944200515747,
-0.21935923397541046,
0.7455019354820251,
0.36143818497657776,
-0.0421275869011879,
0.4163689911365509,
-0.1462390124797821,
0.041704609990119934,
-0.7822222709655762,
0.21233822405338287,
0.4178639054298401,
0.27438634634017944,
0.026479318737983704,
0.919003427028656,
-0.30040237307548523,
0.8669725060462952,
-0.2103656381368637,
-0.03878334164619446,
-0.3195496201515198,
-0.19805102050304413,
-0.36678293347358704,
-0.2270309180021286,
0.4450392425060272,
0.33763495087623596,
0.4423052668571472,
-0.17369122803211212,
-0.4116332232952118,
0.14823991060256958,
0.003802327672019601,
-0.40667247772216797,
-0.11997323483228683,
0.27710574865341187,
-0.1719360500574112,
-0.1051502674818039,
-0.3271840214729309,
-0.5293148159980774,
-0.6549051403999329,
-0.40085190534591675,
0.308302640914917,
-0.4970756769180298,
-0.05248742178082466,
0.5481618642807007,
-0.23099400103092194,
0.49993014335632324,
0.35224562883377075,
-0.7880816459655762,
-0.030013708397746086,
0.7999995946884155,
0.7195334434509277,
-0.0505412332713604,
-0.3869568407535553,
-0.526380717754364,
0.06140005588531494,
-0.6032761931419373,
0.8300667405128479,
-0.6321703791618347,
-0.36335793137550354,
0.01070034597069025,
-0.259718656539917,
-0.12052992731332779,
-0.586390495300293,
0.6658690571784973,
-0.45481717586517334,
-0.14251480996608734,
-0.3860756456851959,
-0.5739381313323975,
-0.0954701155424118,
0.6387965679168701,
-0.3108900785446167,
0.7545449137687683,
-0.26384276151657104,
-0.4252570569515228,
0.5434203147888184,
-0.445392906665802,
-0.4846048355102539,
-0.13033714890480042,
-0.3742939829826355,
-0.09339070320129395,
0.234174445271492,
0.1284225732088089,
0.4499174952507019,
-0.31572139263153076,
0.41928890347480774,
-0.4512152373790741,
-0.5043262243270874,
0.4021773934364319,
-0.3669361174106598,
0.6705202460289001,
0.23911768198013306,
-0.25873807072639465,
0.3255998194217682,
-0.6573663949966431,
0.17462438344955444,
0.2733668088912964,
-0.39903807640075684,
-0.37713027000427246,
0.20597663521766663,
-0.5826635956764221,
0.11387170106172562,
0.07077321410179138,
-0.31463634967803955,
0.6095606684684753,
-0.44538432359695435,
0.5352362394332886,
0.7177013158798218,
-0.004078393802046776,
0.4717358350753784,
-0.3731635808944702,
0.6402838230133057,
-0.3128374516963959,
0.15509212017059326,
0.007061899174004793,
-0.6121695637702942,
-0.8528685569763184,
-0.12009894847869873,
-0.1536911278963089,
0.5563815832138062,
-0.5422482490539551,
0.06717589497566223,
-0.06324547529220581,
-0.43949341773986816,
-0.024859830737113953,
-0.08101433515548706,
0.09269269555807114,
0.17219851911067963,
0.19848127663135529,
0.2582530677318573,
-0.6000699400901794,
-0.5934094786643982,
-0.6564454436302185,
0.10450292378664017,
0.1456458419561386,
0.421787291765213,
0.5104436874389648,
-0.2945636808872223,
1.0823429822921753,
-0.5064282417297363,
-0.11920894682407379,
-0.5037639737129211,
0.12516005337238312,
0.38588976860046387,
0.21703188121318817,
0.36969366669654846,
-0.8273612260818481,
-0.0031132055446505547,
-0.08368721604347229,
-0.7379441261291504,
-0.2856002449989319,
-0.3882802128791809,
-0.22865310311317444,
-0.1388213187456131,
0.5348774194717407,
-0.7560779452323914,
0.2400801181793213,
0.3817041516304016,
-0.4404467046260834,
0.7683022022247314,
-0.2495674341917038,
-0.19104646146297455,
-0.4084479510784149,
-0.07767605781555176,
0.025010254234075546,
0.08933951705694199,
-0.5349156260490417,
0.32186996936798096,
-0.27575400471687317,
-0.005429805722087622,
-0.2936776280403137,
0.4867194592952728,
-0.32261332869529724,
-0.12056436389684677,
-0.12057550996541977,
0.10027093440294266,
-0.05006088316440582,
0.35674041509628296,
0.0636947751045227,
0.5799771547317505,
0.7676423192024231,
-0.4906315803527832,
0.6087751388549805,
-0.27140429615974426,
-0.28620219230651855,
0.30631178617477417,
-0.41942155361175537,
0.00882661435753107,
-0.16777093708515167,
0.22032998502254486,
-0.7676908373832703,
-0.36466705799102783,
0.1281556636095047,
-0.23937273025512695,
0.18787507712841034,
-0.2620823383331299,
-0.34767720103263855,
-0.3717949390411377,
0.043074801564216614,
0.10890015959739685,
0.3242936432361603,
-0.3343290388584137,
0.5715969204902649,
0.047406576573848724,
0.34999576210975647,
-0.548988401889801,
-0.6373019218444824,
0.09953290969133377,
-0.5653846263885498,
-0.7397159337997437,
-0.08531983941793442,
-0.023447232320904732,
-0.714448094367981,
-0.1700725108385086,
-0.41374942660331726,
0.05859645456075668,
0.19351163506507874,
0.21029706299304962,
0.15043361485004425,
-0.16462168097496033,
-0.013615094125270844,
-0.021403558552265167,
0.08152177184820175,
0.19437281787395477,
-0.6245765089988708,
0.2311524748802185,
-0.3022884726524353,
-0.6188695430755615,
0.4382670521736145,
0.4727902412414551,
0.6079053282737732,
-0.26630672812461853,
0.586100697517395,
0.25766903162002563,
-0.37127238512039185,
-0.6860585808753967,
-0.4063684344291687,
-0.17248348891735077,
-0.47200608253479004,
0.050645213574171066,
-0.4633173942565918,
-0.9829385876655579,
0.661831259727478,
-0.4321928918361664,
0.22026854753494263,
0.1104445531964302,
0.49659907817840576,
-0.03612002730369568,
0.9706884026527405,
0.5570877194404602,
0.2517335116863251,
0.05194287747144699,
-0.4721284508705139,
0.3731555640697479,
-0.40298745036125183,
-0.4866722524166107,
-0.29833629727363586,
-0.3885841369628906,
-0.5017484426498413,
-0.6343375444412231,
0.35910969972610474,
0.36931347846984863,
-0.181516632437706,
0.1534651517868042,
-0.43153703212738037,
0.8058849573135376,
0.4066387116909027,
-0.0860806331038475,
0.18339689075946808,
-0.2728314697742462,
-0.6011240482330322,
-0.049910999834537506,
-0.7999393343925476,
-0.5763812065124512,
1.0115246772766113,
0.29132023453712463,
0.902163565158844,
0.10408230125904083,
0.7443258166313171,
-0.04132800176739693,
0.38115614652633667,
-1.1203186511993408,
0.766640841960907,
0.026633214205503464,
-0.8007585406303406,
-0.3803773522377014,
-0.3989916145801544,
-0.9378842115402222,
0.4365915358066559,
-0.30669042468070984,
-0.804656445980072,
0.045989565551280975,
0.0867607593536377,
-0.47842371463775635,
0.30366653203964233,
-0.5644220113754272,
0.9736738801002502,
-0.49169185757637024,
-0.39734992384910583,
-0.020055269822478294,
-0.6956994533538818,
0.6758994460105896,
-0.022106362506747246,
0.2655506432056427,
-0.40551960468292236,
0.12103736400604248,
0.5223537683486938,
-0.3830888867378235,
0.7565580010414124,
-0.018946995958685875,
-0.17651903629302979,
0.43324124813079834,
0.24076001346111298,
0.7213635444641113,
-0.018539179116487503,
-0.02636103332042694,
0.04710088297724724,
-0.023173656314611435,
-0.15325962007045746,
-0.7615532875061035,
0.7084925770759583,
-0.35364559292793274,
-0.8291354179382324,
-0.5498707890510559,
-0.7951200008392334,
-0.42247819900512695,
0.26610857248306274,
0.2474619597196579,
0.33145374059677124,
0.03379248455166817,
-0.13286589086055756,
0.9613600969314575,
-0.16898596286773682,
0.26275956630706787,
0.6541696190834045,
-0.25921085476875305,
0.16329558193683624,
0.8123375773429871,
0.10155802220106125,
0.22296461462974548,
0.19993649423122406,
0.48201924562454224,
-0.2807985246181488,
-0.9163859486579895,
-0.3134717345237732,
0.05528184771537781,
-1.0026190280914307,
-0.011402121745049953,
-0.23481829464435577,
-0.12735646963119507,
0.07296900451183319,
-0.46579664945602417,
-0.13322801887989044,
-0.21083886921405792,
-0.1573229730129242,
0.18575601279735565,
0.22569094598293304,
0.5817934274673462,
-0.0155556695535779,
0.11345371603965759,
-0.5490579605102539,
0.14014330506324768,
0.277301162481308,
0.12445124238729477,
-0.3906932771205902,
-0.4450964629650116,
-0.03783542290329933,
0.08173224329948425,
-0.30357176065444946,
-0.9674941301345825,
0.43101099133491516,
-0.07510432600975037,
0.7505092024803162,
0.31099170446395874,
0.07095711678266525,
0.6012529730796814,
-0.29219958186149597,
0.5188320279121399,
-0.14556053280830383,
-0.5540735125541687,
0.7262312769889832,
-0.7622691988945007,
0.2651175856590271,
0.2849891781806946,
0.30443957448005676,
-0.3040158152580261,
-0.7175034284591675,
-0.40014639496803284,
-0.6296351552009583,
0.5828802585601807,
0.2642647325992584,
-0.08862380683422089,
0.21058136224746704,
0.45386311411857605,
-0.15575776994228363,
-0.05937487259507179,
-0.5531376600265503,
-0.10511386394500732,
0.0966402143239975,
0.16947422921657562,
0.0030420818366110325,
0.14295312762260437,
-0.5672606825828552,
-0.14962206780910492,
0.32233360409736633,
-0.28485623002052307,
0.08311188966035843,
0.04494274780154228,
0.2629445493221283,
-0.14573350548744202,
0.4373256266117096,
0.852946937084198,
0.7882219552993774,
-0.2529091536998749,
0.22926519811153412,
0.2095116674900055,
-0.16310377418994904,
0.1276923567056656,
0.14574675261974335,
-0.004378517158329487,
-0.2520751357078552,
0.4870609641075134,
0.5713129043579102,
0.0572395846247673,
-1.0547116994857788,
0.49748387932777405,
-0.048485103994607925,
-0.26222094893455505,
-0.08949294686317444,
0.2882719039916992,
0.055215053260326385,
0.5128099918365479,
0.44326266646385193,
0.25381577014923096,
0.027915870770812035,
-0.6534221172332764,
-0.18477118015289307,
0.7719853520393372,
0.08239642530679703,
0.054786425083875656,
0.4798378348350525,
0.010552644729614258,
-0.2460446059703827,
0.3750941753387451,
-0.4244960844516754,
-0.6876154541969299,
0.9678394198417664,
0.4765165448188782,
0.693085253238678,
0.2848040461540222,
-0.04924697056412697,
-0.05857142060995102,
0.667117714881897,
-0.17721928656101227,
0.41464096307754517,
-0.045003458857536316,
-0.8242740631103516,
-0.7820054888725281,
-0.5007002353668213,
-0.6120392680168152,
0.29505395889282227,
-0.2410847544670105,
0.27933213114738464,
-0.4399591088294983,
-0.029213225468993187,
-0.03595833107829094,
-0.020802326500415802,
-0.44015994668006897,
0.12898117303848267,
0.22159400582313538,
1.0076332092285156,
-0.7899516224861145,
0.8009117841720581,
0.9020820260047913,
0.07338385283946991,
-1.0372366905212402,
0.09451001137495041,
0.16149744391441345,
-0.7663054466247559,
0.6778913140296936,
0.1873960644006729,
-0.1963139921426773,
-0.3613896369934082,
-0.7983411550521851,
-0.8362995386123657,
0.8434325456619263,
0.32044529914855957,
-0.8055942058563232,
0.09739892184734344,
0.058650895953178406,
0.41695189476013184,
-0.2101786583662033,
-0.015454720705747604,
0.7958191633224487,
0.5956262350082397,
0.6200224161148071,
-0.788530170917511,
0.05292255058884621,
0.1550084799528122,
-0.36727309226989746,
0.2994590401649475,
-0.5269926190376282,
0.6919141411781311,
-0.7304908633232117,
-0.02362678572535515,
-0.01598738692700863,
0.5020711421966553,
0.6371805667877197,
0.5758780837059021,
0.12800253927707672,
0.49169978499412537,
0.777039110660553,
-0.30221179127693176,
0.8920436501502991,
0.0940820574760437,
0.1711389422416687,
0.8884184956550598,
-0.45362991094589233,
0.47565481066703796,
0.5104808807373047,
0.04039048030972481,
0.24621616303920746,
0.7817993760108948,
0.21133403480052948,
0.5632298588752747,
0.6368815302848816,
-0.25928258895874023,
-0.6745429635047913,
0.2866387665271759,
-0.005038162227720022,
0.5522140264511108,
0.6960082054138184,
0.14781486988067627,
-0.4433073401451111,
0.017973007634282112,
0.02449076622724533,
0.14715418219566345,
-0.3031412363052368,
0.21751990914344788,
0.14029477536678314,
-0.9128510355949402,
0.6177384257316589,
0.26553991436958313,
0.5685182809829712,
-0.9347670674324036,
-0.0504196472465992,
-0.31552839279174805,
0.2799025774002075,
-0.1797308772802353,
-1.0432018041610718,
0.555014967918396,
-0.13961035013198853,
0.15014295279979706,
-0.2181401401758194,
0.9170418977737427,
-0.2726269066333771,
-0.24924734234809875,
0.019405756145715714,
0.48767659068107605,
0.16660138964653015,
0.08365900069475174,
-0.6469459533691406,
0.30999964475631714,
-0.151950404047966,
-0.20428362488746643,
0.28529807925224304,
0.8628243207931519,
-0.25555333495140076,
1.0544778108596802,
0.749397873878479,
0.2831695079803467,
0.2590724527835846,
-0.06705084443092346,
1.0656729936599731,
-0.5008203983306885,
-0.42817914485931396,
-1.035570502281189,
0.11700278520584106,
0.0015990760875865817,
-0.4814905822277069,
0.9821804761886597,
0.4420551061630249,
0.6179991960525513,
0.2052515596151352,
0.6220476627349854,
-0.03265995532274246,
0.08553442358970642,
-0.7517706155776978,
0.19485434889793396,
-0.3772552013397217,
0.5953081846237183,
0.12381996959447861,
-0.6788222789764404,
-0.5048511028289795,
0.7498720288276672,
-0.638907253742218,
-0.10724146664142609,
0.5073702931404114,
0.8028186559677124,
-0.06936007738113403,
0.05660669878125191,
0.4010342061519623,
0.12036196887493134,
0.4679573178291321,
0.9884517788887024,
1.306888222694397,
0.23452532291412354,
0.6073994040489197,
0.01756979338824749,
-0.40965554118156433,
-0.2415197491645813,
-1.1436026096343994,
-1.0191012620925903,
-0.10617195814847946,
-0.17668043076992035,
-0.292616605758667,
0.19314873218536377,
0.7687714695930481,
0.7133110761642456,
-0.34015190601348877,
-0.21124231815338135,
-0.44619691371917725,
0.4272061586380005,
-0.24569326639175415,
-0.20019985735416412,
-0.11000286787748337,
-0.38907185196876526,
-0.2601674497127533,
0.7857040166854858,
0.3377395272254944,
0.05502886697649956,
-0.40571072697639465,
-0.18503497540950775,
-0.031950268894433975,
0.40748459100723267,
0.4452548623085022,
0.5849753618240356,
-0.7616178393363953,
-0.13058055937290192,
0.2012627273797989,
-0.03304428979754448,
-0.3969106674194336,
1.193104863166809,
-0.6991737484931946,
0.3982808291912079,
0.23405270278453827,
0.3682134747505188,
0.5421574711799622,
-0.2604953348636627,
0.49283531308174133,
-0.6283490657806396,
0.06097782403230667,
0.6292245984077454,
0.4135356545448303,
-0.002897989936172962,
-0.26431700587272644,
0.3766864538192749,
0.24597807228565216,
-0.6979174613952637,
-0.7063964009284973,
0.40776532888412476,
-0.9099544286727905,
-0.40819859504699707,
1.6821436882019043,
-0.16549189388751984,
0.07605151832103729,
-0.18610353767871857,
-0.3955511152744293,
-0.12040277570486069,
-0.1977953165769577,
0.4512520730495453,
0.7791448831558228,
-0.40841951966285706,
0.10070334374904633,
-0.6954913139343262,
0.5165231823921204,
0.5024316906929016,
-0.6585397720336914,
0.1973877102136612,
0.6421884298324585,
0.1772489696741104,
-0.05104433372616768,
0.5322993993759155,
0.241832435131073,
-0.001203478081151843,
-0.12414401769638062,
-0.5901505351066589,
-0.0725926086306572,
-0.4648689925670624,
-0.3021921217441559,
-0.014223655685782433,
0.19404982030391693,
-0.05593787506222725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13762v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13762v1 | Unveiling the Hidden Structure of Self-Attention via Kernel Principal Component Analysis | 2024-06-19T18:22:32 | 2024-06-19T18:22:32 | Rachel S. Y. Teo, Tan M. Nguyen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, stat.ML | The remarkable success of transformers in sequence modeling tasks, spanning
various applications in natural language processing and computer vision, is
attributed to the critical role of self-attention. Similar to the development
of most deep learning models, the construction of these attention mechanisms
rely on heuristics and experience. In our work, we derive self-attention from
kernel principal component analysis (kernel PCA) and show that self-attention
projects its query vectors onto the principal component axes of its key matrix
in a feature space. We then formulate the exact formula for the value matrix in
self-attention, theoretically and empirically demonstrating that this value
matrix captures the eigenvectors of the Gram matrix of the key vectors in
self-attention. Leveraging our kernel PCA framework, we propose Attention with
Robust Principal Components (RPC-Attention), a novel class of robust attention
that is resilient to data contamination. We empirically demonstrate the
advantages of RPC-Attention over softmax attention on the ImageNet-1K object
classification, WikiText-103 language modeling, and ADE20K image segmentation
task. | [
-0.48267707228660583,
-0.6152172684669495,
0.48030731081962585,
0.36136144399642944,
-0.10997562855482101,
-0.10287664085626602,
0.03398328647017479,
-0.27732542157173157,
0.15040665864944458,
0.4265426993370056,
-0.8289658427238464,
-0.36680200695991516,
-0.4035530984401703,
-0.10391564667224884,
-0.3542027771472931,
0.6612353920936584,
0.24946331977844238,
-0.47464245557785034,
-0.2457677274942398,
-0.02168360725045204,
-0.605261504650116,
-0.6304155588150024,
-0.22564482688903809,
0.10663165897130966,
0.7257822155952454,
0.4113459587097168,
0.38133540749549866,
0.8577497601509094,
0.9116168022155762,
0.27661365270614624,
0.1523604542016983,
-0.1875067502260208,
-0.6470758318901062,
0.23343230783939362,
-0.34517568349838257,
-0.31467393040657043,
-0.6281492114067078,
0.3346898555755615,
0.41957712173461914,
0.4430018663406372,
0.2801157832145691,
0.4061986207962036,
0.5433353781700134,
0.826729953289032,
-0.992171585559845,
0.31272244453430176,
-0.35622337460517883,
0.5979428291320801,
-0.031036309897899628,
-0.25246119499206543,
-0.4580788016319275,
0.3180690407752991,
0.14872203767299652,
-0.3982750177383423,
0.686849057674408,
-0.4149802327156067,
0.619479775428772,
0.7872990965843201,
-0.17091327905654907,
0.2836250066757202,
-0.6024307012557983,
0.9278619289398193,
-0.00811854936182499,
0.6027417778968811,
0.5920064449310303,
0.35574230551719666,
-0.12077271938323975,
-0.6796941757202148,
-0.21399694681167603,
0.05479719862341881,
-0.01718895509839058,
0.4838767945766449,
-0.10102802515029907,
-0.03717363253235817,
-0.19666483998298645,
0.44365373253822327,
-0.3454248309135437,
0.14204196631908417,
-0.4624567925930023,
-0.2292862981557846,
0.2425648719072342,
0.17398402094841003,
0.038248222321271896,
-0.2540508508682251,
-0.6498086452484131,
-0.3625577986240387,
-0.549973726272583,
0.12590160965919495,
0.01215150486677885,
0.4799095392227173,
-0.09263747930526733,
0.48404577374458313,
0.0037295431829988956,
0.5700942873954773,
0.4381178617477417,
-0.018826179206371307,
-0.04349856078624725,
-0.41787225008010864,
-0.5753285884857178,
0.050375550985336304,
0.6342743039131165,
0.06143664941191673,
0.05535176768898964,
-0.2193964123725891,
0.14886559545993805,
0.3226522207260132,
0.827055037021637,
-0.4152897000312805,
-0.48209547996520996,
0.243933767080307,
-0.9303034543991089,
-0.7061508297920227,
-0.11521166563034058,
-0.9310871362686157,
0.1827886402606964,
-0.27940964698791504,
0.3579331040382385,
-0.17641472816467285,
0.04494233801960945,
-0.1244957447052002,
0.36579185724258423,
0.43206265568733215,
0.11694344133138657,
-1.00247061252594,
0.17385947704315186,
0.8929628133773804,
0.5945078730583191,
-0.48579415678977966,
-0.20707131922245026,
-0.5474124550819397,
0.005005419719964266,
-0.39350947737693787,
1.1015585660934448,
-0.4588099718093872,
-0.2105872631072998,
-0.3846341371536255,
0.07793071120977402,
-0.12967486679553986,
-0.276262104511261,
0.6196246147155762,
-0.2934406101703644,
0.17558921873569489,
-0.2508441209793091,
-0.17988568544387817,
-0.20484647154808044,
0.20493246614933014,
-0.4893340468406677,
1.0359126329421997,
-0.08858874440193176,
-0.8426340818405151,
0.264328271150589,
-0.38761210441589355,
-0.37223803997039795,
0.19585107266902924,
-0.4274137020111084,
-0.6524428129196167,
0.3310633897781372,
0.45625969767570496,
0.7799676060676575,
0.01646694354712963,
-0.09326475113630295,
-0.6355128288269043,
0.007617370691150427,
0.15076638758182526,
-0.5319082140922546,
0.5308135151863098,
0.33026376366615295,
-0.35670921206474304,
-0.01677755080163479,
-0.7551808953285217,
-0.11675921827554703,
0.09886492788791656,
-0.2428886443376541,
-0.043307166546583176,
0.03059312142431736,
0.023939162492752075,
0.31150001287460327,
0.21543927490711212,
-0.4241965711116791,
0.040408920496702194,
-0.25697171688079834,
0.3034813702106476,
0.9698784351348877,
-0.03827139735221863,
0.473690390586853,
0.45969802141189575,
0.7369236946105957,
0.08691578358411789,
0.4242252707481384,
-0.5746895670890808,
-0.5132325887680054,
-0.6345481276512146,
-0.6049410104751587,
0.17131295800209045,
0.3559044301509857,
-0.05201440677046776,
0.5747103691101074,
0.1431686133146286,
-0.18626214563846588,
-0.44945329427719116,
0.1302981823682785,
0.4547169506549835,
0.8173930644989014,
0.25176796317100525,
-0.5872949957847595,
-0.158150777220726,
-1.2723350524902344,
-0.05863713473081589,
0.053077105432748795,
-0.04649949446320534,
0.35381075739860535,
-0.06885971128940582,
-0.20091930031776428,
1.0461517572402954,
-0.5965262651443481,
-0.9038758873939514,
-0.22265338897705078,
0.029682815074920654,
-0.01361747644841671,
0.40873074531555176,
0.504645586013794,
-0.5789147019386292,
-0.46593189239501953,
-0.06458090245723724,
-0.5819272398948669,
0.06411843746900558,
-0.08259952813386917,
-0.034274253994226456,
-0.1704215705394745,
0.6829700469970703,
-0.13831990957260132,
0.7157831192016602,
0.16699081659317017,
-0.37157824635505676,
0.15483666956424713,
-0.1378592848777771,
-0.2176664024591446,
-0.9427382349967957,
0.42823460698127747,
0.10294678062200546,
-0.36211442947387695,
-0.4901072084903717,
0.2549510896205902,
0.2754571735858917,
-0.39702463150024414,
-0.4138428270816803,
0.10386068373918533,
-0.3577292561531067,
-0.4123951494693756,
-0.46137815713882446,
-0.033252738416194916,
0.050014011561870575,
0.9385234117507935,
-0.11428526788949966,
0.6786210536956787,
0.5548259615898132,
-0.46160945296287537,
0.11774692684412003,
0.5049733519554138,
0.09003730118274689,
0.4934302866458893,
-0.7660606503486633,
0.2592250406742096,
-0.4395171105861664,
-0.059769123792648315,
-1.4281039237976074,
-0.1526942402124405,
0.2790723145008087,
-0.42298629879951477,
0.7092801332473755,
-0.12199663370847702,
-0.13081680238246918,
-0.4461100399494171,
-0.2911235988140106,
0.6656062006950378,
0.08709993213415146,
-0.6218499541282654,
0.6027871966362,
0.4610152244567871,
-0.16221143305301666,
-0.6854668259620667,
-0.6448110342025757,
0.11423343420028687,
-0.072747603058815,
-0.4234917461872101,
0.2629595100879669,
0.07069368660449982,
0.15594276785850525,
0.08919501304626465,
-0.27595221996307373,
-0.371044397354126,
0.2938927412033081,
0.4599931836128235,
0.03825223073363304,
-0.1344195306301117,
0.12160445749759674,
-0.2368834763765335,
-0.645479142665863,
0.17996835708618164,
-0.2020251750946045,
0.19599096477031708,
-0.008367705158889294,
-0.2952755391597748,
-0.8415147066116333,
0.5635119080543518,
0.5874432921409607,
-0.6112553477287292,
-0.004782473668456078,
0.5273172855377197,
-0.2299816906452179,
-0.03877037391066551,
-0.4941963255405426,
-0.5995908379554749,
-0.47767409682273865,
0.46179285645484924,
-0.404737651348114,
-0.8841639757156372,
0.5702192783355713,
0.4060215950012207,
-0.2719165086746216,
0.49641066789627075,
0.5901963114738464,
-0.09285440295934677,
0.9840752482414246,
1.0593518018722534,
-0.32551148533821106,
0.38863128423690796,
0.060193926095962524,
0.29482510685920715,
-0.7252315282821655,
-0.2685249447822571,
-0.49467605352401733,
-0.5177118182182312,
-0.5799844861030579,
-0.16750335693359375,
0.43471258878707886,
-0.47547730803489685,
0.1467348337173462,
0.25182852149009705,
-0.8586323261260986,
0.4743131697177887,
0.6682581901550293,
0.18844085931777954,
-0.12242776900529861,
0.06038472056388855,
-0.08482538908720016,
-0.3722210228443146,
-0.8190823793411255,
-0.08320993185043335,
0.9851568937301636,
0.9844322204589844,
0.9743090271949768,
-0.5736755728721619,
0.5494571924209595,
0.29471901059150696,
-0.11874488741159439,
-0.8271515369415283,
0.3434309661388397,
-0.27647921442985535,
-0.41645950078964233,
-0.06081763282418251,
-0.08221077919006348,
-0.7988685369491577,
0.18921996653079987,
0.22190451622009277,
-0.5857086181640625,
0.9505035877227783,
0.35281476378440857,
-0.7930452823638916,
-0.15420344471931458,
-0.5830293893814087,
1.327061653137207,
0.043765708804130554,
-0.5064302086830139,
-0.22358208894729614,
-0.8729528784751892,
0.2966478168964386,
-0.15143533051013947,
-0.10716729611158371,
-0.12782660126686096,
0.1486632227897644,
0.5099129676818848,
-0.12236826866865158,
1.2359126806259155,
0.16881555318832397,
-0.2679537534713745,
0.21207337081432343,
0.08545740693807602,
0.30252504348754883,
-0.04375722259283066,
0.8915582299232483,
-0.14343634247779846,
-0.3205990493297577,
-0.4417818486690521,
-0.37902918457984924,
0.6926010251045227,
-0.7156161665916443,
-0.46141454577445984,
-0.4339471459388733,
-0.27512070536613464,
0.03483663499355316,
0.2069912850856781,
0.25019362568855286,
0.39828386902809143,
0.011641398072242737,
0.34638288617134094,
1.0386643409729004,
-0.17688263952732086,
0.5783277750015259,
0.20150353014469147,
0.18472301959991455,
-0.4286634624004364,
0.8854312896728516,
0.07653795182704926,
0.01986105926334858,
0.5749883055686951,
0.181946262717247,
-0.18434329330921173,
0.0011533013312146068,
0.1352624148130417,
0.050978753715753555,
-0.7049307227134705,
-0.34769734740257263,
-0.9582943320274353,
-0.04992244020104408,
-0.6088495850563049,
0.003974767401814461,
-0.9654248356819153,
-0.5885871648788452,
-0.6187894940376282,
-0.17260262370109558,
-0.10959487408399582,
0.528786301612854,
-0.3330678939819336,
0.10592283308506012,
-0.46096882224082947,
0.5730764865875244,
0.9876947402954102,
0.3838745057582855,
0.09137852489948273,
-0.4356536865234375,
-0.15997649729251862,
-0.6482675671577454,
-0.5770770907402039,
-0.7276676297187805,
0.6981028914451599,
0.278969943523407,
0.589615523815155,
0.7356902360916138,
-0.08776770532131195,
0.39344578981399536,
-0.4194682538509369,
0.43708932399749756,
-0.0569014735519886,
-0.7046471834182739,
0.7549915909767151,
-0.2889048755168915,
0.44590893387794495,
0.5072445869445801,
-0.024694982916116714,
-0.15541058778762817,
-0.3917536437511444,
-0.3822895884513855,
-0.8439932465553284,
0.780718207359314,
0.2546423673629761,
-0.10132952779531479,
-0.06830771267414093,
0.4941857159137726,
-0.045101284980773926,
-0.15714380145072937,
-0.8266332149505615,
-0.2869340777397156,
-0.6054732799530029,
-0.2403518259525299,
-0.0033431039191782475,
-0.7091841101646423,
-0.017594845965504646,
0.06066034734249115,
0.32712697982788086,
-0.39607512950897217,
0.6716717481613159,
0.6592240929603577,
0.1663336306810379,
-0.21367329359054565,
0.01661473885178566,
0.7020188570022583,
0.41777166724205017,
-0.3521382510662079,
0.4905003011226654,
-0.3115224242210388,
-0.7586097121238708,
-0.015403483994305134,
-0.03707480803132057,
0.2058996707201004,
-0.46645355224609375,
0.2768431603908539,
0.2019570916891098,
0.36265814304351807,
-0.01571413315832615,
0.49902474880218506,
-0.3218694031238556,
0.08537748456001282,
0.01877283863723278,
-0.2053864449262619,
-0.15911635756492615,
-0.0020567497704178095,
0.5479684472084045,
-0.1589798927307129,
0.4229840636253357,
-0.30390143394470215,
0.521699070930481,
0.3379010558128357,
-0.9549647569656372,
-0.36628222465515137,
0.8764166831970215,
0.07404855638742447,
0.07564471662044525,
0.45680877566337585,
0.3083643615245819,
-0.6313655972480774,
0.7778058052062988,
0.383473664522171,
1.3055341243743896,
-0.5264012813568115,
-0.0480523481965065,
0.02406386099755764,
0.5864024758338928,
0.5426763892173767,
0.3327455222606659,
-0.43331751227378845,
-0.39133399724960327,
-0.5930168032646179,
-0.4285348057746887,
0.026648642495274544,
0.12415283173322678,
-0.7463235855102539,
-0.09158174693584442,
-0.5414230227470398,
-0.11506079882383347,
0.2249080240726471,
-0.30873027443885803,
-0.7538468241691589,
0.40576454997062683,
-0.03460678085684776,
0.7501680850982666,
-0.7798554301261902,
0.5187269449234009,
0.4592929482460022,
-0.0399775467813015,
-0.4359770119190216,
-0.11377276480197906,
-0.3169921040534973,
-0.7302001118659973,
0.9343354105949402,
0.45098018646240234,
0.033919766545295715,
-0.1106078028678894,
-0.52125084400177,
-0.9243746399879456,
0.7654143571853638,
0.2994149923324585,
-0.45116129517555237,
0.38183003664016724,
0.1270458698272705,
0.34976381063461304,
-0.17723505198955536,
-0.33196961879730225,
0.19141952693462372,
0.13513368368148804,
-0.21501007676124573,
-0.5284499526023865,
-0.17025083303451538,
-0.14899572730064392,
-0.10999976843595505,
0.02776690013706684,
-0.8926853537559509,
0.6330389380455017,
0.010294890031218529,
-0.2763413190841675,
-0.4871772229671478,
1.0998270511627197,
-0.2230457216501236,
0.12012170255184174,
0.1834191530942917,
0.8869868516921997,
0.1120934784412384,
0.21547411382198334,
0.8859265446662903,
-0.31866368651390076,
0.5231958627700806,
1.1191872358322144,
0.027334831655025482,
0.5574864149093628,
0.511215090751648,
-0.14971929788589478,
-0.013218918815255165,
0.5950936675071716,
-0.11941999942064285,
1.007680058479309,
-0.38610994815826416,
0.003404326969757676,
-0.5736382007598877,
0.03747402876615524,
-0.32876837253570557,
0.7103589177131653,
0.18880866467952728,
-0.5655389428138733,
-0.25965744256973267,
0.11868559569120407,
-0.44044315814971924,
0.031750984489917755,
-0.37716588377952576,
0.9187842607498169,
0.2642199695110321,
-0.5142503380775452,
0.24383869767189026,
-0.20127268135547638,
0.06671205908060074,
-0.19947762787342072,
0.00812672171741724,
-0.3387409746646881,
0.5432127714157104,
0.08473627269268036,
-0.5422630906105042,
0.34934404492378235,
-0.34361276030540466,
-0.5517786145210266,
-0.24857179820537567,
1.0514529943466187,
-0.06222370266914368,
-0.6184507608413696,
0.14833879470825195,
0.014467389322817326,
-0.157401904463768,
-0.26150116324424744,
-0.5905715227127075,
0.0995798408985138,
-0.1666008085012436,
-0.06647045165300369,
0.4269322454929352,
0.31272637844085693,
0.372226357460022,
0.7579025626182556,
0.24387973546981812,
-0.6379855275154114,
0.2213793694972992,
-0.39098992943763733,
0.9411693811416626,
-0.6742890477180481,
-1.0088034868240356,
-0.8014538884162903,
0.09184365719556808,
0.31523528695106506,
-0.10447726398706436,
0.750602662563324,
0.5044658780097961,
0.37525829672813416,
-0.29190126061439514,
0.5121579766273499,
0.5798507928848267,
0.4298371970653534,
0.007113764528185129,
0.6061139106750488,
-0.13001936674118042,
-0.232871413230896,
-0.33559131622314453,
-0.9205154180526733,
-0.4600658714771271,
0.7467358112335205,
-0.053671274334192276,
-0.1002015694975853,
0.43358126282691956,
0.4380037784576416,
-0.45132142305374146,
-0.27184930443763733,
0.4168836772441864,
0.20794270932674408,
0.39578020572662354,
0.4948045313358307,
0.41401076316833496,
-0.34712815284729004,
0.33600184321403503,
-0.4953901767730713,
-0.48302754759788513,
-0.2411738932132721,
-1.0245298147201538,
-0.8885483145713806,
-0.42483294010162354,
-0.5143709182739258,
-0.007969710044562817,
-0.035706259310245514,
0.4923475682735443,
0.891746461391449,
-0.9239152073860168,
0.14736033976078033,
-0.30812928080558777,
-0.0495169535279274,
-0.25600895285606384,
-0.25991636514663696,
0.8481305241584778,
-0.8265537619590759,
-0.4268417954444885,
0.7040822505950928,
0.8529316186904907,
0.20606866478919983,
-0.7118740081787109,
0.5515565872192383,
0.08189378678798676,
-0.15561546385288239,
0.6636564135551453,
0.4662460684776306,
-0.4850815236568451,
-0.15735509991645813,
0.25842395424842834,
-0.1774323284626007,
0.1889708787202835,
0.7963941097259521,
-0.9719811677932739,
0.6586217880249023,
0.5650684237480164,
0.8845237493515015,
0.39003726840019226,
0.036930691450834274,
0.7558948397636414,
-0.9383842349052429,
0.1916775107383728,
0.04144031181931496,
0.13876552879810333,
0.27977660298347473,
-0.7789627313613892,
0.3885694146156311,
0.27699944376945496,
-0.8029273748397827,
-0.6821695566177368,
0.21315787732601166,
-1.213965892791748,
-0.21683640778064728,
0.5222218632698059,
-0.1980614960193634,
-0.7693693041801453,
-0.1635454297065735,
-0.10581544786691666,
-0.0959695428609848,
-0.24323520064353943,
1.2141448259353638,
0.3342474102973938,
-0.07976797968149185,
-0.3702782392501831,
-0.2449728101491928,
0.5703284740447998,
0.6336543560028076,
-0.5262933373451233,
0.3406001925468445,
0.24185603857040405,
0.0782855972647667,
0.41799214482307434,
0.21342742443084717,
-0.30949023365974426,
0.4814603328704834,
-0.3379840850830078,
0.020136600360274315,
0.07011381536722183,
-0.7710890769958496,
-0.549209475517273,
0.8056498765945435,
-0.2952209413051605,
-0.6531830430030823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13748v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13748v1 | Every Language Counts: Learn and Unlearn in Multilingual LLMs | 2024-06-19T18:01:08 | 2024-06-19T18:01:08 | Taiming Lu, Philipp Koehn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper investigates the propagation of harmful information in
multilingual large language models (LLMs) and evaluates the efficacy of various
unlearning methods. We demonstrate that fake information, regardless of the
language it is in, once introduced into these models through training data, can
spread across different languages, compromising the integrity and reliability
of the generated content. Our findings reveal that standard unlearning
techniques, which typically focus on English data, are insufficient in
mitigating the spread of harmful content in multilingual contexts and could
inadvertently reinforce harmful content across languages. We show that only by
addressing harmful responses in both English and the original language of the
harmful data can we effectively eliminate generations for all languages. This
underscores the critical need for comprehensive unlearning strategies that
consider the multilingual nature of modern LLMs to enhance their safety and
reliability across diverse linguistic landscapes. | [
0.050746411085128784,
-0.8134012818336487,
0.37422752380371094,
0.16147761046886444,
-0.2070225328207016,
0.30950629711151123,
-0.30221715569496155,
-0.560009241104126,
-0.08991077542304993,
0.615543782711029,
-0.35953861474990845,
-0.4988616406917572,
-0.47629210352897644,
-0.08386625349521637,
-0.3287411630153656,
1.18230402469635,
0.13787132501602173,
0.4717954397201538,
-0.32563069462776184,
-0.27063968777656555,
-0.21563348174095154,
-0.8876914978027344,
-0.6001617312431335,
-0.39960089325904846,
0.7259795069694519,
0.460785448551178,
0.43584200739860535,
0.4739072024822235,
0.045951761305332184,
0.25390881299972534,
-0.11399179697036743,
0.3538614511489868,
-0.7331053614616394,
0.10181540995836258,
-0.3042795658111572,
-0.6727575063705444,
-0.03351052105426788,
-0.09348434954881668,
0.797863781452179,
0.9605199098587036,
-0.3737267553806305,
0.2146448791027069,
0.3403276801109314,
0.41022413969039917,
-0.6307631731033325,
0.05723166465759277,
-0.6800353527069092,
-0.005173081066459417,
-0.36260250210762024,
-0.34016168117523193,
-0.6723402142524719,
-0.4162828028202057,
-0.2967411279678345,
-0.4838462769985199,
-0.08792069554328918,
-0.31226733326911926,
0.35987234115600586,
-0.26178523898124695,
-0.9916219711303711,
-0.5824980139732361,
-0.954892635345459,
1.165449619293213,
-0.518435537815094,
0.45328882336616516,
0.39405113458633423,
-0.13319604098796844,
-0.12014671415090561,
-0.49787527322769165,
-0.3271853029727936,
-0.028572795912623405,
0.16297884285449982,
0.18101197481155396,
-0.24699318408966064,
-0.24109680950641632,
-0.11011622101068497,
0.054109733551740646,
-0.5204277634620667,
0.40353459119796753,
-0.6648813486099243,
-0.417440801858902,
0.6581004858016968,
-0.015267628245055676,
0.5940141677856445,
0.08763223141431808,
-0.49175742268562317,
-0.0008682593470439315,
-1.1538074016571045,
-0.06669344007968903,
0.7901639938354492,
0.24458321928977966,
-0.1287713497877121,
0.2174745798110962,
0.2549048066139221,
0.39752623438835144,
-0.6129717230796814,
-0.613185465335846,
0.3247770369052887,
-0.3141917586326599,
0.09848979860544205,
-0.051779646426439285,
0.8282020092010498,
0.28478193283081055,
0.6675718426704407,
-0.427118718624115,
-0.05979285389184952,
0.0015573749551549554,
0.185220867395401,
-0.5636420249938965,
0.10475346446037292,
-0.047192685306072235,
-0.19698373973369598,
-0.29249081015586853,
0.0589042492210865,
-0.7734013199806213,
-0.3728286325931549,
-0.12467034161090851,
0.36588054895401,
-0.6692593693733215,
-0.469120055437088,
0.15471473336219788,
0.13677355647087097,
0.14371038973331451,
0.20066851377487183,
-0.5591142177581787,
0.040997058153152466,
0.44596052169799805,
0.4109937846660614,
-0.07589363306760788,
-0.7077569961547852,
-0.3143143057823181,
0.2864324748516083,
-0.6405399441719055,
0.5150039792060852,
-0.3587694466114044,
-0.4682530462741852,
0.4735815227031708,
0.31744617223739624,
-0.12173730880022049,
-0.6330894231796265,
0.4839232265949249,
-0.4523533880710602,
0.15032319724559784,
-0.22938434779644012,
-0.5677367448806763,
-0.5457890033721924,
0.06828846782445908,
-0.5212430953979492,
0.5330905318260193,
-0.3436734080314636,
-0.47696051001548767,
0.4215450882911682,
-0.09884695708751678,
-0.8886826634407043,
0.04924360662698746,
0.05022525414824486,
-0.4365914463996887,
0.09947947412729263,
-0.3290891647338867,
0.4703771471977234,
0.09020011126995087,
0.49106791615486145,
-0.2509858310222626,
-0.2636805474758148,
0.44493257999420166,
-1.108763337135315,
1.0932753086090088,
0.2192612588405609,
-0.2180039882659912,
-0.005570256616920233,
-0.5847054719924927,
0.042243316769599915,
0.35420888662338257,
-0.6597939133644104,
-0.4131958782672882,
0.052926357835531235,
0.18394631147384644,
0.302905410528183,
0.07538782805204391,
-0.7526944279670715,
-0.02103869430720806,
-0.178533136844635,
0.28090786933898926,
0.6313859224319458,
0.20393256843090057,
0.3039602041244507,
-0.5560917854309082,
0.48435115814208984,
0.28422659635543823,
0.23370730876922607,
-0.37248021364212036,
-0.43457871675491333,
-0.5358709096908569,
-0.018194051459431648,
-0.05718586966395378,
0.7123522162437439,
-0.8699844479560852,
0.025958644226193428,
-0.29520827531814575,
-0.6130829453468323,
-0.5367675423622131,
0.7152097225189209,
0.7738021016120911,
0.2615737318992615,
0.19890712201595306,
-0.1628742516040802,
-0.5463006496429443,
-0.7634130716323853,
-0.4526093006134033,
-0.2836543619632721,
0.2715238034725189,
-0.021987520158290863,
0.5269114375114441,
-0.232473686337471,
0.36607879400253296,
0.0020215895492583513,
-0.19270862638950348,
-0.4497931897640228,
0.0637674480676651,
-0.2922983169555664,
0.2975021302700043,
0.6052799820899963,
-0.6204810738563538,
-0.4810648560523987,
-0.005658857058733702,
-1.0214992761611938,
0.23161101341247559,
-0.18385553359985352,
0.3484238088130951,
0.5794758796691895,
0.42542898654937744,
-0.3207642734050751,
0.3907742500305176,
0.5701238512992859,
-0.20669826865196228,
0.49190622568130493,
-0.42576634883880615,
0.20519761741161346,
-1.0352846384048462,
0.06181909143924713,
-0.21979711949825287,
-0.15191872417926788,
-0.9750010967254639,
0.12120644003152847,
0.1942879557609558,
0.10332896560430527,
-0.9932104349136353,
0.751758337020874,
-0.5597042441368103,
0.3930274546146393,
-0.1525341272354126,
-0.16400042176246643,
-0.0034245087299495935,
0.36778390407562256,
-0.08747192472219467,
0.5820297002792358,
0.4601723849773407,
-0.669394314289093,
0.2932765483856201,
0.08825324475765228,
-0.6233503222465515,
0.5049335360527039,
-0.28788918256759644,
0.021502221003174782,
-0.4845975637435913,
0.11405052244663239,
-0.878612220287323,
-0.12241172790527344,
0.03311428427696228,
-0.5303733348846436,
0.41374364495277405,
-0.19559121131896973,
-0.6658092737197876,
-0.043760575354099274,
-0.29185667634010315,
0.3812527358531952,
0.4359022378921509,
-0.7349533438682556,
0.11176513135433197,
0.5875819325447083,
0.015401924028992653,
-0.795509397983551,
-0.9685786962509155,
0.07537133991718292,
-0.47451186180114746,
-0.429007351398468,
-0.20763733983039856,
-0.2458951473236084,
-0.4555386006832123,
-0.24957342445850372,
0.018509553745388985,
-0.2571854293346405,
0.346465140581131,
0.3730267286300659,
0.1695742905139923,
0.09168792515993118,
0.3132861852645874,
-0.22419200837612152,
0.14601987600326538,
0.20636141300201416,
-0.2177608758211136,
0.5949596762657166,
0.1671665757894516,
-0.6689020395278931,
-0.16155846416950226,
0.5574628114700317,
0.7732740044593811,
-0.14829334616661072,
1.2548032999038696,
0.5825399160385132,
-0.4197913706302643,
-0.3042435348033905,
-0.5875865817070007,
0.09333959966897964,
-0.4489988088607788,
0.4895186424255371,
-0.15160590410232544,
-0.7823836207389832,
0.5153736472129822,
0.04457320272922516,
0.34236907958984375,
0.1149415522813797,
0.5108944773674011,
-0.170827254652977,
0.9544848203659058,
0.8169454336166382,
-0.38475164771080017,
0.184077188372612,
-0.13013847172260284,
0.32758060097694397,
-0.26120421290397644,
-0.594622790813446,
-0.37117987871170044,
0.14793018996715546,
-0.5331517457962036,
-0.4129779636859894,
0.3890085816383362,
0.406619668006897,
-0.2939819097518921,
-0.0029733129777014256,
-0.026249738410115242,
0.6441431641578674,
0.4911614954471588,
0.13611313700675964,
0.5910236239433289,
0.31534892320632935,
-0.15721377730369568,
-0.1281827986240387,
-0.7861932516098022,
-0.5167742371559143,
1.253198504447937,
0.2172168642282486,
0.877692699432373,
0.4220486581325531,
0.5647535920143127,
0.09470483660697937,
0.5858507752418518,
-0.6077072620391846,
0.13987340033054352,
-0.24479521811008453,
-0.7071977257728577,
-0.27719828486442566,
-0.5678737163543701,
-1.223515510559082,
0.24400103092193604,
0.06158981844782829,
-0.6454336643218994,
0.030427496880292892,
0.054271116852760315,
-0.11055736243724823,
0.9820030927658081,
-0.5673404932022095,
0.5671342611312866,
-0.5855409502983093,
-0.3419833481311798,
-0.29027825593948364,
-0.3944705128669739,
0.5643888115882874,
-0.5822945833206177,
0.8132705092430115,
0.10277736186981201,
-0.05979442596435547,
0.833319902420044,
-0.10973982512950897,
1.35223388671875,
0.040104713290929794,
-0.4649169445037842,
0.3069747984409332,
0.30917197465896606,
0.38097280263900757,
-0.00905667431652546,
-0.10796814411878586,
0.5536855459213257,
-0.006492584478110075,
-0.5793576836585999,
-0.1335957646369934,
0.7190450429916382,
-0.7882364392280579,
-0.2884015142917633,
-0.2696702480316162,
-0.41420412063598633,
-0.19788655638694763,
0.26268500089645386,
0.49064648151397705,
0.2842235565185547,
-0.45098912715911865,
0.18694378435611725,
0.7065956592559814,
-0.569111168384552,
0.6172919273376465,
1.1511857509613037,
-0.053107958287000656,
-0.30471959710121155,
1.2835640907287598,
0.258527547121048,
0.47740352153778076,
0.18441371619701385,
-0.0890834853053093,
-0.3226895332336426,
-0.4166834056377411,
-0.340331494808197,
0.5044577717781067,
-0.9567885994911194,
-0.10943976044654846,
-0.5407105088233948,
-0.24961911141872406,
-0.40691012144088745,
-0.09771231561899185,
-0.4639759659767151,
0.1275140792131424,
-0.08580680936574936,
-0.3019953668117523,
0.23682700097560883,
0.9489572644233704,
-0.37296169996261597,
0.2926456928253174,
-1.116796851158142,
-0.06198970600962639,
0.09440909326076508,
0.4233643114566803,
0.13306570053100586,
-0.5810683965682983,
-0.3542301058769226,
0.3644789755344391,
-0.22939005494117737,
-0.8339692950248718,
0.622532069683075,
0.2607390880584717,
1.003618597984314,
0.5058202743530273,
-0.0663718655705452,
0.3884456157684326,
-0.5356164574623108,
0.4706340730190277,
0.3735950291156769,
-0.6854435205459595,
0.18875962495803833,
-0.40148642659187317,
0.21182399988174438,
0.27436432242393494,
0.7747029066085815,
-1.1639906167984009,
-0.4071814715862274,
-0.68159019947052,
-1.0581823587417603,
0.42192888259887695,
-0.2904842495918274,
0.5154007077217102,
-0.20782683789730072,
0.08659186214208603,
0.30091798305511475,
0.25552019476890564,
-1.023982286453247,
-0.50738525390625,
0.1692090928554535,
0.028108224272727966,
-0.39204299449920654,
-0.5606586933135986,
-0.19769075512886047,
-0.04017866775393486,
0.6079577803611755,
0.020066918805241585,
-0.26000073552131653,
-0.1498788595199585,
-0.6055758595466614,
-0.2734418511390686,
0.40670448541641235,
0.49373292922973633,
0.7795193195343018,
0.3063858449459076,
0.24782612919807434,
0.2368003875017166,
-0.513615071773529,
0.4605362117290497,
-0.6313650012016296,
-0.34890320897102356,
-0.01129355188459158,
0.7267453670501709,
0.6288624405860901,
0.4747820496559143,
-0.7166711688041687,
0.49535295367240906,
0.1985810399055481,
-0.27479708194732666,
-0.4918445348739624,
-0.17201797664165497,
0.2487681359052658,
-0.2864159643650055,
0.17846743762493134,
-0.11839543282985687,
-0.39592432975769043,
-0.9798487424850464,
0.5020883083343506,
0.45935940742492676,
-0.4109959602355957,
-0.4683662950992584,
0.49606257677078247,
0.06978043168783188,
-0.12169963121414185,
0.6981518864631653,
-0.030594855546951294,
-0.5566157698631287,
0.4483821392059326,
0.6479621529579163,
0.4068704843521118,
-0.7865856289863586,
0.48163092136383057,
0.32470953464508057,
0.7205432057380676,
-0.16695024073123932,
0.24128443002700806,
0.2548253536224365,
-1.0369259119033813,
-0.723915696144104,
-0.701313853263855,
-0.23699358105659485,
0.4669055938720703,
-0.538658618927002,
-0.1721205860376358,
-0.2584950923919678,
0.39887744188308716,
-0.09893958270549774,
-0.19899068772792816,
-0.5884819030761719,
0.12487691640853882,
0.3482585847377777,
0.6426212787628174,
-1.3437366485595703,
0.8558535575866699,
0.6294664740562439,
-0.44964608550071716,
-0.6502571105957031,
-0.15280388295650482,
0.5119533538818359,
-1.0333746671676636,
0.566906750202179,
0.0361308753490448,
-0.01761471852660179,
-0.10969533771276474,
-0.4054170548915863,
-0.8575185537338257,
0.4664376378059387,
0.4306893050670624,
-0.2980252802371979,
0.5326195955276489,
0.6482629776000977,
0.4470604360103607,
-0.047487664967775345,
0.1933484971523285,
0.3816539943218231,
0.48177438974380493,
-0.018304036930203438,
-0.8183759450912476,
-0.30876630544662476,
-0.11566285789012909,
-0.3773612678050995,
0.17233681678771973,
-0.6325125694274902,
0.706178605556488,
-0.30459949374198914,
-0.3093474805355072,
-0.10860934108495712,
0.2073475867509842,
0.05294064059853554,
0.11032984405755997,
0.4699350595474243,
0.33250465989112854,
0.9298584461212158,
0.011851493269205093,
1.0211609601974487,
-0.2329471856355667,
0.12156660109758377,
0.9210535883903503,
-0.20750752091407776,
0.5629536509513855,
0.29520970582962036,
0.051646679639816284,
0.02221417985856533,
0.4164334237575531,
0.17060549557209015,
0.1851041316986084,
0.2931506633758545,
-0.34408584237098694,
-0.21676737070083618,
-0.2759672999382019,
0.0032946302089840174,
0.6365460157394409,
0.34862568974494934,
-0.07063528150320053,
-0.43020573258399963,
0.45492666959762573,
0.6426724791526794,
0.12470362335443497,
-0.18387120962142944,
0.6640835404396057,
0.1782103180885315,
-0.4841388761997223,
0.6853660345077515,
0.035374026745557785,
0.8297337293624878,
-0.6596725583076477,
0.010938155464828014,
-0.5087851881980896,
0.34425511956214905,
-0.39035993814468384,
-0.7471460700035095,
0.40138837695121765,
-0.03864467889070511,
-0.09265539795160294,
-0.4113924503326416,
0.4039062559604645,
-0.8232383728027344,
-0.6259422898292542,
0.700949490070343,
0.8513592481613159,
0.48915258049964905,
-0.036585673689842224,
-0.48421168327331543,
-0.0576426237821579,
0.3465076982975006,
-0.29658043384552,
0.7299664616584778,
0.35951969027519226,
-0.28723543882369995,
1.1204010248184204,
0.8705039024353027,
0.47733941674232483,
0.3487629294395447,
0.2254130244255066,
0.4274296164512634,
-0.5581496357917786,
-0.1465764045715332,
-0.8733314275741577,
0.4890197217464447,
0.13884730637073517,
-0.1462714672088623,
1.0768531560897827,
0.5843087434768677,
1.2700817584991455,
0.059365712106227875,
0.8206478953361511,
0.47132429480552673,
0.498226523399353,
-0.34417325258255005,
1.070614218711853,
-0.7217828035354614,
0.3662213087081909,
0.026260603219270706,
-0.733263373374939,
-0.3395130932331085,
0.15153056383132935,
0.10462599247694016,
0.017943505197763443,
0.649159848690033,
0.675322413444519,
0.046395737677812576,
-0.26972588896751404,
0.738955557346344,
0.3523032069206238,
0.2559520900249481,
0.4101833999156952,
0.8989117741584778,
-0.2669169306755066,
0.8518449068069458,
-0.3689562678337097,
-0.07668361067771912,
0.11671784520149231,
-0.44130927324295044,
-0.6592966318130493,
-0.5489354729652405,
-0.28863611817359924,
-0.31569138169288635,
0.17415258288383484,
0.33574286103248596,
0.5395320653915405,
-0.8683839440345764,
-0.5130526423454285,
0.3295506238937378,
0.354709267616272,
-0.017641592770814896,
-0.20669618248939514,
0.16749891638755798,
-0.37988412380218506,
-0.7406464219093323,
0.6574023962020874,
0.16224022209644318,
0.1408488154411316,
-0.3490075469017029,
-0.08253966271877289,
-0.19772927463054657,
-0.030106889083981514,
0.6315245032310486,
0.5221266150474548,
-0.5887158513069153,
-0.15378057956695557,
-0.13782364130020142,
-0.23330987989902496,
-0.14722107350826263,
0.8323204517364502,
-0.5131844282150269,
0.23941048979759216,
0.3263378143310547,
0.26655733585357666,
0.05478539317846298,
-0.338549941778183,
0.6623297929763794,
-1.077934980392456,
0.3531022071838379,
0.07522149384021759,
0.44585105776786804,
0.43771183490753174,
-0.3037753999233246,
0.44934970140457153,
0.349421888589859,
-0.36111724376678467,
-0.9667717218399048,
0.3070910573005676,
-0.2911641597747803,
-0.7400213479995728,
1.3612037897109985,
-0.287954717874527,
-0.21698568761348724,
-0.5278319716453552,
0.2648187279701233,
0.35619744658470154,
0.0006379273254424334,
0.6165456771850586,
0.5858387351036072,
0.3271712362766266,
-0.10187042504549026,
-0.8409099578857422,
0.4187752604484558,
0.40868502855300903,
-0.6348483562469482,
0.25813043117523193,
0.38054150342941284,
0.8052695989608765,
0.12307912856340408,
0.5178987383842468,
-0.35567617416381836,
0.09421519935131073,
-0.21005454659461975,
0.38072553277015686,
0.0822051540017128,
-0.6491890549659729,
-0.6143299341201782,
0.06927292048931122,
0.01628171280026436,
0.06342776864767075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13743v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13743v2 | GenAI-Bench: Evaluating and Improving Compositional Text-to-Visual Generation | 2024-06-19T18:00:07 | 2024-06-21T19:09:36 | Baiqi Li, Zhiqiu Lin, Deepak Pathak, Jiayao Li, Yixin Fei, Kewen Wu, Tiffany Ling, Xide Xia, Pengchuan Zhang, Graham Neubig, Deva Ramanan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | While text-to-visual models now produce photo-realistic images and videos,
they struggle with compositional text prompts involving attributes,
relationships, and higher-order reasoning such as logic and comparison. In this
work, we conduct an extensive human study on GenAI-Bench to evaluate the
performance of leading image and video generation models in various aspects of
compositional text-to-visual generation. We also compare automated evaluation
metrics against our collected human ratings and find that VQAScore -- a metric
measuring the likelihood that a VQA model views an image as accurately
depicting the prompt -- significantly outperforms previous metrics such as
CLIPScore. In addition, VQAScore can improve generation in a black-box manner
(without finetuning) via simply ranking a few (3 to 9) candidate images.
Ranking by VQAScore is 2x to 3x more effective than other scoring methods like
PickScore, HPSv2, and ImageReward at improving human alignment ratings for
DALL-E 3 and Stable Diffusion, especially on compositional prompts that require
advanced visio-linguistic reasoning. We will release a new GenAI-Rank benchmark
with over 40,000 human ratings to evaluate scoring metrics on ranking images
generated from the same prompt. Lastly, we discuss promising areas for
improvement in VQAScore, such as addressing fine-grained visual details. We
will release all human ratings (over 80,000) to facilitate scientific
benchmarking of both generative models and automated metrics. | [
-0.5737552046775818,
-0.5006412267684937,
0.7053065299987793,
0.34494999051094055,
-0.34286895394325256,
0.0779968872666359,
-0.259035587310791,
-0.36058884859085083,
-0.3450504541397095,
0.2296053171157837,
-0.42558518052101135,
-0.5283026695251465,
-0.41462379693984985,
0.08151373267173767,
-0.5033798813819885,
0.5589858293533325,
-0.03651962801814079,
0.16586384177207947,
-0.8027696013450623,
-0.004649738315492868,
-0.8129240870475769,
-0.016415517777204514,
-0.5500492453575134,
-0.33661386370658875,
0.38187456130981445,
0.5282315015792847,
0.4871024489402771,
0.611626923084259,
0.48983535170555115,
0.3615880310535431,
0.2099594622850418,
0.13400962948799133,
-0.5405136942863464,
0.29163122177124023,
-0.09799961745738983,
-0.32964006066322327,
-0.14826169610023499,
0.04740079864859581,
0.7223227620124817,
0.4440332055091858,
0.03674261271953583,
0.25801941752433777,
0.0014813608722761273,
0.8266561031341553,
-0.7400128841400146,
-0.035364728420972824,
-0.34288203716278076,
0.08462053537368774,
-0.10026779770851135,
-0.3685322105884552,
-0.41580307483673096,
-0.29429566860198975,
0.21362927556037903,
-0.6935132741928101,
0.38016393780708313,
-0.06598824262619019,
0.9486900568008423,
0.4130040109157562,
-0.3998291492462158,
0.274521142244339,
-0.687012791633606,
0.77989661693573,
-0.4123160243034363,
0.22848695516586304,
0.32171520590782166,
0.6921941041946411,
0.027620522305369377,
-0.8591602444648743,
-0.4006756544113159,
-0.278770387172699,
0.3175112307071686,
0.5717070698738098,
-0.06293606013059616,
-0.07581926137208939,
0.3532598316669464,
0.5660896897315979,
-0.6817618012428284,
-0.024741366505622864,
-0.2849488854408264,
-0.04476874694228172,
0.8560717105865479,
0.30562934279441833,
0.5790560245513916,
-0.3879143297672272,
-0.41201797127723694,
-0.6373395919799805,
-0.40790796279907227,
0.03247452899813652,
0.27182480692863464,
-0.42010489106178284,
-0.013979284092783928,
0.5691853761672974,
-0.5697823166847229,
0.769075870513916,
0.0846613198518753,
-0.04878972843289375,
0.13510362803936005,
-0.5661020278930664,
-0.3245476484298706,
-0.30668458342552185,
1.0707184076309204,
0.9472607374191284,
0.27902349829673767,
0.004507965873926878,
-0.11631765961647034,
0.3358396589756012,
0.34601545333862305,
-1.047339916229248,
-0.358753502368927,
-0.0888519287109375,
-0.6033759713172913,
-0.437667578458786,
0.17441363632678986,
-0.9822666049003601,
-0.5543389320373535,
-0.42627426981925964,
0.5347899198532104,
-0.5671401619911194,
-0.009292528964579105,
-0.2391686737537384,
-0.5513002276420593,
0.4978150427341461,
0.5601743459701538,
-0.9467347264289856,
0.006964338012039661,
0.4711493253707886,
0.5910629630088806,
-0.15301012992858887,
-0.33534520864486694,
-0.42606064677238464,
0.050983890891075134,
-0.4645637571811676,
1.1569433212280273,
-0.44660088419914246,
-0.5751844048500061,
-0.08187546581029892,
-0.31082096695899963,
-0.08402709662914276,
-0.7025453448295593,
0.6615764498710632,
-0.022405697032809258,
0.428863525390625,
-0.6119250655174255,
-0.46205559372901917,
-0.030266478657722473,
0.2868528366088867,
-0.6785006523132324,
0.973956823348999,
0.3335689902305603,
-0.522102415561676,
0.7554890513420105,
-0.493886798620224,
-0.3568015992641449,
0.2629414498806,
-0.6342374086380005,
-0.331109881401062,
0.10004042088985443,
0.5817081332206726,
0.19420063495635986,
-0.7041823267936707,
0.3779652714729309,
0.11642923951148987,
-0.33016473054885864,
0.39994001388549805,
-0.558336079120636,
0.3913685381412506,
0.3064942955970764,
-0.5314719676971436,
0.40253183245658875,
-0.8409386873245239,
0.1523309051990509,
0.19060319662094116,
-0.19849225878715515,
-0.12670183181762695,
-0.0013816839782521129,
0.15087759494781494,
0.07320401817560196,
-0.030074819922447205,
-0.4873076379299164,
-0.09223184734582901,
-0.1735335886478424,
0.2512006461620331,
0.6775292158126831,
0.2721749544143677,
0.4584205746650696,
-0.38851651549339294,
0.6066508293151855,
-0.13817927241325378,
0.41630834341049194,
-0.31459835171699524,
-0.7789276242256165,
-0.7279307246208191,
-0.1653408706188202,
0.3918439447879791,
0.4465196430683136,
-0.8795992136001587,
0.22586169838905334,
-0.261563241481781,
-0.6029503345489502,
-0.40476223826408386,
0.15845514833927155,
0.49598291516304016,
0.7779473066329956,
0.1371854841709137,
-0.7284355163574219,
-0.3421573340892792,
-0.9343809485435486,
-0.044877175241708755,
-0.15742458403110504,
-0.26058802008628845,
0.3845960795879364,
0.21546414494514465,
-0.1265249103307724,
0.8087936639785767,
-0.3837657570838928,
0.0744054913520813,
-0.027078859508037567,
0.6338303685188293,
-0.24444609880447388,
0.39508721232414246,
0.7867702841758728,
-0.8190277218818665,
-0.528211772441864,
-0.09462922066450119,
-0.9614025354385376,
-0.2067098170518875,
-0.1215321272611618,
-0.31613537669181824,
0.005891086999326944,
0.44860997796058655,
-0.45416519045829773,
0.5235118865966797,
0.2727643549442291,
-0.4091106355190277,
0.6637296080589294,
-0.18723875284194946,
0.6746513843536377,
-1.1053168773651123,
0.18120554089546204,
0.29154571890830994,
-0.1031690388917923,
-0.3638416528701782,
0.15843509137630463,
-0.10111779719591141,
-0.38213223218917847,
-0.25627949833869934,
0.3748076260089874,
-0.40278196334838867,
-0.26879438757896423,
-0.2548694312572479,
0.053228892385959625,
0.19219470024108887,
0.18258805572986603,
-0.14969401061534882,
0.9609406590461731,
0.5024250745773315,
-0.431333065032959,
0.5835328102111816,
0.4267922043800354,
-0.7036630511283875,
1.0429290533065796,
-0.8279692530632019,
-0.07966063171625137,
-0.21920877695083618,
0.214181587100029,
-1.2714788913726807,
-0.5102812647819519,
0.17452380061149597,
-0.592217743396759,
0.2586461305618286,
0.2373846173286438,
-0.4321587383747101,
-0.37799349427223206,
-0.5319299101829529,
0.61781245470047,
0.6794443726539612,
-0.4603549838066101,
0.46227166056632996,
0.036377765238285065,
-0.12079312652349472,
-0.29501116275787354,
-0.6091271042823792,
0.37438392639160156,
-0.13010171055793762,
-0.8743897676467896,
0.4143199622631073,
-0.21884062886238098,
-0.18887965381145477,
-0.04203014820814133,
0.13716630637645721,
0.2135523557662964,
0.03789043426513672,
0.3668833374977112,
0.2638463079929352,
-0.1644073873758316,
-0.03400097042322159,
-0.02774740569293499,
-0.20882795751094818,
0.25587889552116394,
0.0686650201678276,
0.4044171869754791,
0.04625273495912552,
-0.25511685013771057,
-0.4746786057949066,
0.39360156655311584,
0.4725203812122345,
-0.3321850895881653,
0.2812643051147461,
0.9605874419212341,
-0.1791028529405594,
-0.015670908614993095,
-0.5437557697296143,
0.026707790791988373,
-0.45066893100738525,
0.21803516149520874,
-0.3414555490016937,
-0.42830854654312134,
0.24368315935134888,
-0.14561419188976288,
-0.08196842670440674,
0.7530036568641663,
0.6959531903266907,
-0.2378656417131424,
1.3389854431152344,
0.4298642575740814,
0.17878958582878113,
0.7403497099876404,
-0.4920032322406769,
-0.17711129784584045,
-0.8744189739227295,
-0.3623509109020233,
-0.39148420095443726,
-0.47564855217933655,
-0.5415852069854736,
-0.36113327741622925,
0.46139129996299744,
-0.1662217676639557,
-0.1812664270401001,
0.1942659169435501,
-0.597535252571106,
0.49181967973709106,
0.7708391547203064,
0.33685097098350525,
0.13785408437252045,
0.17471717298030853,
-0.12726685404777527,
-0.0640142634510994,
-0.5406954884529114,
-0.3364376723766327,
1.1577396392822266,
0.13306494057178497,
0.6046384572982788,
-0.01079912856221199,
0.6476117968559265,
0.4098059833049774,
0.3894288241863251,
-0.6631105542182922,
0.7114752531051636,
-0.385587602853775,
-0.32517579197883606,
-0.27509722113609314,
-0.43036046624183655,
-0.7365261912345886,
0.12072894722223282,
-0.4061506986618042,
-0.6515563130378723,
0.2976852059364319,
-0.056580398231744766,
-0.41044312715530396,
-0.032082706689834595,
-0.8180314302444458,
1.1333305835723877,
-0.4307132065296173,
-0.5051062107086182,
-0.14492927491664886,
-0.6395822167396545,
0.5931395292282104,
0.2218770533800125,
-0.19055891036987305,
0.043068431317806244,
0.13038983941078186,
0.7561284899711609,
-0.46623802185058594,
0.6356918215751648,
-0.06008170172572136,
-0.028836572542786598,
0.3449613153934479,
-0.18043550848960876,
-0.10639942437410355,
-0.04552149027585983,
0.10953807830810547,
-0.26449790596961975,
-0.030232444405555725,
-0.37211212515830994,
-0.6754342317581177,
0.6144659519195557,
-0.9569563865661621,
-0.44482365250587463,
-0.19997255504131317,
-0.5912914872169495,
-0.20438961684703827,
-0.12429419159889221,
0.8028439879417419,
0.5443604588508606,
-0.4443065822124481,
0.3002127707004547,
0.6330143809318542,
-0.34961071610450745,
0.3564596176147461,
-0.07132746279239655,
-0.23313292860984802,
-0.8591232299804688,
1.0924615859985352,
-0.14041155576705933,
0.2660027742385864,
0.3637666404247284,
0.26219823956489563,
-0.3322557508945465,
-0.3174055814743042,
-0.9035156965255737,
-0.0028216298669576645,
-0.7319234609603882,
-0.25017213821411133,
-0.2781417667865753,
-0.2248154878616333,
-0.3904913067817688,
0.06521372497081757,
-0.056953538209199905,
-0.2833879292011261,
-0.3926082253456116,
0.012982719577848911,
0.06670480221509933,
0.5745410919189453,
0.05881153792142868,
0.3009509742259979,
-0.674026370048523,
0.6087590456008911,
0.7834233641624451,
0.2370031476020813,
0.052962321788072586,
-0.42688289284706116,
0.015512295998632908,
-0.13067039847373962,
-0.5834185481071472,
-0.8232203125953674,
0.15360330045223236,
0.2456984668970108,
0.5864580273628235,
0.4928349256515503,
-0.321216881275177,
0.7425711154937744,
-0.1813637614250183,
0.9759159088134766,
0.45885300636291504,
-0.9051896929740906,
0.8017812371253967,
-0.5308025479316711,
0.5131409168243408,
0.7513876557350159,
0.01391047053039074,
-0.27903875708580017,
-0.13915017247200012,
-0.5508155226707458,
-0.6595838665962219,
0.297128826379776,
0.2115851193666458,
-0.07319597899913788,
0.19465334713459015,
0.23030495643615723,
-0.004314889200031757,
0.1754327118396759,
-0.43915191292762756,
0.07716167718172073,
-0.4882918894290924,
-0.2906460165977478,
-0.16038888692855835,
-0.3207418918609619,
-0.16343924403190613,
-0.5822624564170837,
0.3312338888645172,
-0.14789319038391113,
0.07851912081241608,
0.28349363803863525,
0.05898594856262207,
-0.516493022441864,
0.3447743356227875,
0.6838319897651672,
0.7854821681976318,
-0.1727902740240097,
-0.1266356110572815,
-0.21683835983276367,
-0.2723466455936432,
0.15396380424499512,
0.1514958143234253,
-0.5919427871704102,
-0.07454535365104675,
0.2640020251274109,
0.9743946194648743,
0.21349318325519562,
-0.790382981300354,
0.6758022308349609,
-0.30328065156936646,
-0.5306312441825867,
-0.13586705923080444,
0.22947697341442108,
-0.1955576092004776,
0.1842038929462433,
0.34021294116973877,
0.11025867611169815,
0.3750474452972412,
-0.7840967178344727,
0.12557879090309143,
0.28275996446609497,
-0.2602912485599518,
-0.11922533065080643,
0.9360523819923401,
0.441100150346756,
-0.035440340638160706,
0.7671124935150146,
-0.17397700250148773,
-0.4418392479419708,
0.7076104283332825,
0.3897482752799988,
1.076841950416565,
-0.2108713984489441,
0.7016719579696655,
0.5715049505233765,
0.23942579329013824,
-0.1148674488067627,
0.437078595161438,
-0.30833932757377625,
-0.37689292430877686,
-0.3819967806339264,
-0.40965980291366577,
-0.5162078738212585,
-0.08861162513494492,
-0.5416596531867981,
0.03413911908864975,
-0.44990187883377075,
-0.4742875099182129,
0.0835324078798294,
-0.048885248601436615,
-0.6909404397010803,
0.4649147391319275,
0.34009063243865967,
0.7771930694580078,
-1.026560664176941,
0.3448607921600342,
0.8264581561088562,
-0.8038190007209778,
-0.7508948445320129,
-0.06690001487731934,
-0.1895228773355484,
-0.3752567172050476,
0.40508580207824707,
0.32288050651550293,
0.18397121131420135,
-0.03820237144827843,
-0.8823389410972595,
-0.5011732578277588,
1.5009995698928833,
0.3509478271007538,
-0.4176321029663086,
0.19637706875801086,
0.10536067187786102,
0.71770840883255,
-0.3325820565223694,
0.3888559937477112,
0.6922539472579956,
0.6498132944107056,
0.25464168190956116,
-0.5754454731941223,
0.027286745607852936,
-0.532848060131073,
0.3797115683555603,
0.038052693009376526,
-0.6284103989601135,
0.7792506814002991,
-0.12325064092874527,
-0.4225753843784332,
0.6899572014808655,
0.6526833176612854,
0.3319254219532013,
0.6020755171775818,
0.4814905822277069,
0.8507748246192932,
0.4747295081615448,
-0.2675328552722931,
1.3618180751800537,
0.02956005185842514,
-0.13370783627033234,
0.8696056008338928,
-0.26349130272865295,
0.7403491735458374,
0.43305179476737976,
-0.08022543787956238,
0.6760743260383606,
0.6276920437812805,
-0.4147201478481293,
0.5718671083450317,
0.2218397855758667,
-0.22508299350738525,
-0.4259271025657654,
-0.5003469586372375,
-0.3454379141330719,
0.3814331591129303,
0.024943163618445396,
-0.44947367906570435,
-0.13320788741111755,
0.08260909467935562,
-0.604984700679779,
0.42864492535591125,
-0.18465913832187653,
0.8201852440834045,
-0.028300300240516663,
-0.9459075331687927,
0.4266209900379181,
-0.05871730297803879,
0.316308856010437,
-0.25983473658561707,
-0.07179158926010132,
-0.23005785048007965,
-0.06559636443853378,
-0.1401454508304596,
-0.7574857473373413,
-0.3140336275100708,
0.1230953261256218,
-0.16742444038391113,
-0.13802166283130646,
0.8415538668632507,
-0.35881513357162476,
-0.5381069779396057,
-0.021192455664277077,
0.6124798655509949,
-0.11592861264944077,
-0.14359693229198456,
-0.5846891403198242,
0.08768178522586823,
-0.20957230031490326,
-0.09912743419408798,
0.2355531007051468,
0.3002946674823761,
-0.08179549872875214,
0.39989417791366577,
0.5948476195335388,
-0.2492647022008896,
-0.02410358376801014,
0.765580952167511,
0.6955315470695496,
-0.712300181388855,
-0.3626718819141388,
-0.5457817316055298,
0.504746675491333,
-0.45872271060943604,
-0.5514305233955383,
0.4736282527446747,
0.5353720784187317,
0.6370264291763306,
-0.25905200839042664,
0.7329431772232056,
0.012819843366742134,
0.00769949471578002,
-0.5367475152015686,
0.6909857392311096,
-0.5646625757217407,
-0.09761299937963486,
-0.48423996567726135,
-1.185593843460083,
-0.11048587411642075,
0.29556891322135925,
-0.22797654569149017,
0.1918405443429947,
0.629955530166626,
0.5287446975708008,
0.04894929751753807,
0.03365425020456314,
0.3604283034801483,
-0.16832709312438965,
0.31536543369293213,
0.6511507034301758,
1.2860711812973022,
-0.7565644979476929,
0.5004317760467529,
-0.365634948015213,
-0.3577199876308441,
-0.05434263125061989,
-0.770706057548523,
-0.7978156208992004,
-0.6317964792251587,
-0.3475518226623535,
-0.03368476778268814,
-0.0035945712588727474,
0.4336204528808594,
0.6573985815048218,
-0.5131692886352539,
-0.2883630394935608,
-0.1814596801996231,
-0.31697291135787964,
-0.22171933948993683,
-0.30532652139663696,
0.13344800472259521,
-0.15864518284797668,
-0.6036455035209656,
0.350556343793869,
0.3233983814716339,
0.0925811380147934,
-0.48198938369750977,
-0.13188152015209198,
-0.03898086026310921,
-0.019147224724292755,
0.7090669274330139,
0.282499223947525,
-0.6032521724700928,
-0.23790758848190308,
0.020251521840691566,
-0.29316866397857666,
0.07758282870054245,
0.8438963890075684,
-0.8505795001983643,
0.6699804067611694,
0.9936795234680176,
0.6528565883636475,
0.5319010019302368,
0.4738742709159851,
0.8504323363304138,
-0.6691872477531433,
-0.24392907321453094,
-0.04020535200834274,
0.3607829809188843,
0.7416528463363647,
0.015243440866470337,
0.6773872971534729,
0.37399861216545105,
-0.6364796161651611,
-0.5419530868530273,
0.16194650530815125,
-1.3154188394546509,
-0.07338600605726242,
0.8783010840415955,
0.3339988589286804,
-0.400349885225296,
0.5580848455429077,
-0.48265504837036133,
0.2825118899345398,
-0.30582311749458313,
0.8921656012535095,
0.5528092384338379,
0.04717462509870529,
-0.41532090306282043,
-0.5100269317626953,
0.352451890707016,
0.5136361122131348,
-1.1808499097824097,
-0.3920927345752716,
0.8623529076576233,
0.10458574444055557,
0.09214501827955246,
0.47912320494651794,
-0.19709816575050354,
0.8643840551376343,
0.04704592004418373,
-0.04591769352555275,
0.026360701769590378,
-0.38823917508125305,
-0.16504955291748047,
0.015391041524708271,
0.07098976522684097,
-0.32504573464393616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13720v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13720v1 | On the Utility of Domain-Adjacent Fine-Tuned Model Ensembles for Few-shot Problems | 2024-06-19T17:24:36 | 2024-06-19T17:24:36 | Md Ibrahim Ibne Alam, Parikshit Ram, Soham Dan, Horst Samulowitz, Koushik Kar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have been observed to perform well on a wide
range of downstream tasks when fine-tuned on domain-specific data. However,
such data may not be readily available in many applications, motivating
zero-shot or few-shot approaches using domain-adjacent models. While several
fine-tuned models for various tasks are available, finding an appropriate
domain-adjacent model for a given task is often not straight forward. In this
paper, we study DAFT-E, a framework that utilizes an Ensemble of
Domain-Adjacent Fine-Tuned Foundation Models for few-shot problems. We show
that for zero-shot problems, this ensembling method provides an accuracy
performance close to that of the single best model. With few-shot problems,
this performance improves further, at which point DEFT-E can outperform any
single domain-adjacent model while requiring much less data for domain-specific
fine-tuning. | [
-0.605498731136322,
-1.1975774765014648,
0.56499183177948,
-0.07532215863466263,
-0.029406849294900894,
0.0687883198261261,
-0.13661256432533264,
-0.7417452931404114,
-0.1312742680311203,
0.272781103849411,
-0.8269153833389282,
-0.38364556431770325,
-0.6268872618675232,
0.24282096326351166,
-0.6368746757507324,
0.7343929409980774,
0.15662111341953278,
-0.4727320671081543,
-0.03763965517282486,
0.15480466187000275,
-0.09767919033765793,
-0.08136335015296936,
-0.44323572516441345,
-0.5071495175361633,
0.14498242735862732,
0.70185786485672,
0.4765279293060303,
0.5431758165359497,
0.637308657169342,
0.22321511805057526,
-0.03990284726023674,
0.217782124876976,
-0.7245543003082275,
-0.027973584830760956,
-0.06629984825849533,
-0.40703701972961426,
-0.5282443165779114,
-0.18691980838775635,
0.38911551237106323,
0.9513416290283203,
-0.021500363945961,
0.22350800037384033,
0.10241609066724777,
0.6761286854743958,
-0.692681610584259,
-0.33562344312667847,
-0.7900665998458862,
-0.1795559972524643,
-0.36452099680900574,
-0.06771232932806015,
-0.16341999173164368,
0.07052410393953323,
0.3150547444820404,
-0.6298955678939819,
0.19908775389194489,
0.0031195939518511295,
0.8121145963668823,
0.5207183957099915,
-0.3365476727485657,
0.3462095260620117,
-0.6659153699874878,
0.9697310328483582,
-0.8107039928436279,
0.2353702336549759,
0.5793334245681763,
0.23875367641448975,
-0.3201446533203125,
-0.30642083287239075,
-0.6940270662307739,
0.4379340708255768,
0.02708146534860134,
-0.02080848067998886,
-0.40418529510498047,
0.25561901926994324,
0.07121914625167847,
0.1093602180480957,
-0.6846745610237122,
0.3647027909755707,
-0.12449200451374054,
0.1281162053346634,
0.7569983601570129,
0.25473251938819885,
-0.04290958493947983,
0.2393122762441635,
-0.3797139823436737,
0.11833388358354568,
-0.9141044020652771,
-0.26757338643074036,
0.49375805258750916,
0.6113152503967285,
-0.21526874601840973,
0.4711229205131531,
-0.5135032534599304,
1.306272268295288,
0.47028833627700806,
-0.2495611608028412,
-0.18785333633422852,
0.06270604580640793,
-0.4889565110206604,
-0.20057116448879242,
0.21986952424049377,
0.1153579130768776,
0.38394007086753845,
-0.10700768977403641,
-0.3939457833766937,
0.02987261302769184,
0.0067636738531291485,
-0.7930376529693604,
-0.3430388271808624,
0.5835767388343811,
-0.22379440069198608,
-0.18740615248680115,
-0.20866987109184265,
-0.5532013773918152,
0.10977107286453247,
-0.3428138494491577,
0.6118099093437195,
-0.5388045907020569,
-0.2107066959142685,
0.140071302652359,
-0.17124022543430328,
0.0546477735042572,
0.4358026385307312,
-1.0130975246429443,
0.42642104625701904,
0.9543076157569885,
0.9338676929473877,
-0.42955639958381653,
-0.38846316933631897,
-0.541388750076294,
0.12534292042255402,
-0.3694787919521332,
0.985369861125946,
-0.8564222455024719,
-0.21517179906368256,
-0.09090596437454224,
-0.2183990627527237,
-0.13992449641227722,
-0.3832698166370392,
0.36755651235580444,
-0.5695184469223022,
-0.38739511370658875,
0.10765307396650314,
-0.9543421864509583,
-0.167533740401268,
0.3141191899776459,
-0.3682347238063812,
0.7014599442481995,
0.23470443487167358,
-0.49431121349334717,
0.326803982257843,
-0.2638676166534424,
-0.4289570748806,
0.3096540570259094,
-0.3172699511051178,
-0.2612684369087219,
0.3932715654373169,
0.0693206861615181,
0.6603933572769165,
-0.12458281219005585,
-0.1589326560497284,
-0.6690064668655396,
-0.7710591554641724,
-0.325219064950943,
-0.307898610830307,
0.607056736946106,
0.2662867605686188,
-0.11971060931682587,
-0.6620750427246094,
-0.9660694003105164,
0.10283805429935455,
0.13027773797512054,
-0.15928886830806732,
-0.6590185761451721,
-0.24930821359157562,
0.004689712543040514,
-0.022712159901857376,
0.05751793831586838,
-0.6300145983695984,
0.2413998544216156,
-0.7218932509422302,
0.22687889635562897,
0.6993613839149475,
0.06587372720241547,
0.706386387348175,
-0.6254984140396118,
0.5547584295272827,
-0.029353128746151924,
-0.4468972980976105,
-0.356314092874527,
-0.5520137548446655,
-0.3690741956233978,
-0.5934942960739136,
0.36906787753105164,
0.33360975980758667,
-0.4398964047431946,
0.27923423051834106,
-0.09882427006959915,
-0.5153862833976746,
-0.32682326436042786,
0.06111319735646248,
0.05214725434780121,
0.4965279996395111,
0.14378102123737335,
-0.009404064156115055,
-0.2214353233575821,
-0.8000814914703369,
-0.22698934376239777,
0.026532145217061043,
0.08485684543848038,
0.3223865032196045,
0.7732229232788086,
-0.05485491454601288,
1.2869700193405151,
-0.6425116062164307,
-0.24487805366516113,
0.1288275420665741,
0.18429040908813477,
0.3624221980571747,
0.456908643245697,
0.7523840665817261,
-0.4858960509300232,
-0.752332329750061,
0.08378835022449493,
-0.38463640213012695,
-0.1991027593612671,
-0.006953413598239422,
-0.1374931037425995,
0.33885616064071655,
-0.0698591098189354,
-0.51497882604599,
0.2412729561328888,
0.6468871831893921,
-0.00780410785228014,
0.2458573877811432,
0.12102434784173965,
0.16892914474010468,
-0.5704807639122009,
-0.07649677991867065,
0.22224858403205872,
-0.26023727655410767,
-0.8580257892608643,
0.10793909430503845,
-0.0589904710650444,
0.052789751440286636,
-0.4953080415725708,
0.7006596326828003,
-0.3979049324989319,
0.1253819465637207,
-0.4422961473464966,
0.15192216634750366,
0.022638864815235138,
0.382609486579895,
0.31995686888694763,
0.5379759073257446,
0.806962788105011,
-0.8086904883384705,
-0.07683014869689941,
0.46129724383354187,
-0.2350180596113205,
0.9326120018959045,
-0.5847087502479553,
0.5376319885253906,
-0.07812511920928955,
-0.13366737961769104,
-0.9121915102005005,
-0.5078852772712708,
-0.41231846809387207,
-0.27469509840011597,
0.6554720997810364,
-0.5638017654418945,
-0.21601007878780365,
-0.21284033358097076,
-0.3513537347316742,
0.4913995862007141,
0.4153440296649933,
-0.6553855538368225,
0.10310127586126328,
0.43546217679977417,
-0.24478712677955627,
-0.60038161277771,
-0.9594893455505371,
-0.32066214084625244,
-0.3079606890678406,
-0.973591148853302,
0.7789942026138306,
0.1454165279865265,
-0.29545924067497253,
-0.09609319269657135,
-0.36976122856140137,
-0.39668336510658264,
0.2780768573284149,
-0.03686029464006424,
0.041054610162973404,
-0.17181752622127533,
0.29316529631614685,
0.2833513915538788,
0.04918260872364044,
-0.509006679058075,
-0.4049132764339447,
0.3081369996070862,
-0.11294756084680557,
-0.4569854438304901,
0.051768410950899124,
0.590430498123169,
0.22727403044700623,
0.03370820730924606,
0.630848228931427,
0.1836484670639038,
-0.8780147433280945,
-0.6858007907867432,
-0.5549559593200684,
-0.4552987515926361,
-0.4766494929790497,
0.2646121382713318,
-0.6488553285598755,
-1.1713943481445312,
0.381793349981308,
-0.1772300750017166,
0.24061651527881622,
0.42431017756462097,
0.6052990555763245,
-0.3905442953109741,
0.8099672794342041,
1.0661243200302124,
-0.047598954290151596,
0.2275301218032837,
-0.24457548558712006,
0.20365010201931,
-0.4257811903953552,
0.3036976456642151,
-0.6746930480003357,
-0.390035480260849,
-0.34134215116500854,
-0.012827456928789616,
0.48558077216148376,
0.32414665818214417,
-0.40908825397491455,
0.6726401448249817,
-0.3471139669418335,
0.682167112827301,
0.24820204079151154,
-0.004549252334982157,
0.6255319118499756,
0.20858293771743774,
0.12792715430259705,
0.1320573389530182,
-1.0069156885147095,
-0.5506465435028076,
1.0335724353790283,
0.24744319915771484,
1.110960841178894,
0.16126161813735962,
1.245710849761963,
0.032533273100852966,
-0.28352516889572144,
-0.8171301484107971,
0.1425243765115738,
-0.3147367238998413,
-0.786285400390625,
-0.5121095180511475,
-0.22878356277942657,
-0.7846072316169739,
0.19081999361515045,
-0.18858018517494202,
-1.056270718574524,
0.5160769820213318,
0.23301702737808228,
-1.1162419319152832,
0.15897224843502045,
-0.6726037859916687,
0.46970152854919434,
0.07344356179237366,
-0.6245877742767334,
-0.2619864046573639,
-0.4405161440372467,
0.6068984866142273,
-0.6854794025421143,
0.11898932605981827,
-0.21740713715553284,
-0.04966910555958748,
0.5377023220062256,
-0.45241597294807434,
0.7811757326126099,
0.13829009234905243,
-0.251627117395401,
0.42862293124198914,
0.36270105838775635,
0.7116771936416626,
-0.0969911515712738,
-0.23765404522418976,
0.2761833071708679,
0.3457129895687103,
-0.3149418830871582,
-0.3852649927139282,
0.911656379699707,
-0.5383791923522949,
-0.6052975654602051,
-0.18920977413654327,
-0.3647284209728241,
-0.5739287734031677,
0.18474310636520386,
0.29284295439720154,
0.3654177784919739,
-0.1540924459695816,
0.15864044427871704,
0.5152592062950134,
0.15444037318229675,
0.8141927123069763,
0.715038537979126,
0.29413485527038574,
0.23044434189796448,
0.5768849849700928,
0.3467462360858917,
0.3986968398094177,
0.3285159170627594,
-0.033332791179418564,
0.008527624420821667,
-0.5600874423980713,
-0.42812660336494446,
-0.0020686034113168716,
-0.4677472710609436,
-0.6138379573822021,
-0.6854764223098755,
0.021724363788962364,
-0.30126750469207764,
-0.45177754759788513,
-0.49120238423347473,
-0.707942008972168,
-0.2349618822336197,
0.16032658517360687,
0.5701342821121216,
0.5832629799842834,
-0.16089573502540588,
0.5111847519874573,
-1.1466178894042969,
0.25262972712516785,
0.28662464022636414,
0.5153974890708923,
-0.033296141773462296,
-0.7691971659660339,
-0.3394666612148285,
0.04762205481529236,
-0.3710305392742157,
-0.8425765037536621,
0.319267600774765,
0.5669376254081726,
0.5349045395851135,
0.2610267102718353,
0.14241360127925873,
0.8793808221817017,
-0.6226142048835754,
0.4723059833049774,
-0.12963248789310455,
-0.8325812220573425,
0.4634449779987335,
-0.5762382745742798,
0.2764695882797241,
0.683514416217804,
0.3977202773094177,
-0.10265452414751053,
-0.09644119441509247,
-0.5859010219573975,
-0.5857955813407898,
0.9302341341972351,
0.33392563462257385,
0.11903104931116104,
-0.11089164018630981,
0.3233455717563629,
0.2809913754463196,
0.19498084485530853,
-0.2510382831096649,
-0.22627778351306915,
0.3173356056213379,
-0.18870073556900024,
0.13166631758213043,
0.17328011989593506,
-0.16862596571445465,
-0.15865512192249298,
0.7741101384162903,
-0.48001357913017273,
0.32540324330329895,
0.14122892916202545,
-0.21927084028720856,
-0.7885586023330688,
0.3070955276489258,
0.49747055768966675,
0.38215819001197815,
-0.2725308835506439,
-0.18675783276557922,
0.32211196422576904,
-0.16570515930652618,
0.27796632051467896,
0.1976378709077835,
-0.20835500955581665,
-0.2295583337545395,
0.44816091656684875,
0.430329829454422,
-0.13809199631214142,
-0.5292803645133972,
0.5221190452575684,
0.5810406804084778,
-0.28057006001472473,
0.18290679156780243,
0.050398536026477814,
-0.12928441166877747,
0.5550869107246399,
0.5572461485862732,
0.17027349770069122,
0.25712084770202637,
-0.4616867005825043,
0.5360392332077026,
0.7107486128807068,
0.06381173431873322,
-0.24235615134239197,
0.4140508770942688,
0.2922505736351013,
-0.18799100816249847,
0.3789155185222626,
-0.04702146723866463,
-0.3253553807735443,
0.8236265778541565,
0.7279915809631348,
0.9732062220573425,
0.13854648172855377,
0.03271443769335747,
0.24059438705444336,
0.34211114048957825,
-0.339031845331192,
0.05999351665377617,
-0.04817003011703491,
-0.9870830774307251,
-0.6394480466842651,
-0.7039783000946045,
-0.39110419154167175,
-0.02063053287565708,
-0.32751917839050293,
0.49028193950653076,
-0.21095001697540283,
-0.309693306684494,
-0.12336568534374237,
-0.04341968894004822,
-0.8910756707191467,
0.22913102805614471,
0.3367655277252197,
0.9371152520179749,
-0.8156471252441406,
0.7955247759819031,
0.625635027885437,
0.01872081495821476,
-0.6223304271697998,
0.09629962593317032,
0.36227819323539734,
-0.6640446186065674,
0.46568772196769714,
-0.07167356461286545,
-0.38560208678245544,
0.4008805453777313,
-0.6691040396690369,
-1.067527413368225,
1.040247917175293,
0.5700249671936035,
-1.1732131242752075,
-0.04473946616053581,
-0.10903850942850113,
0.48708102107048035,
-0.4014347493648529,
0.18400584161281586,
0.9688071012496948,
0.3818992078304291,
0.16459313035011292,
-1.055080771446228,
-0.28335040807724,
0.09493869543075562,
-0.26065072417259216,
0.314950555562973,
-0.8433068990707397,
0.8014143109321594,
-0.2589659094810486,
-0.30334752798080444,
0.012743828818202019,
0.36755678057670593,
0.36222583055496216,
0.13273176550865173,
0.44837483763694763,
0.6592406034469604,
0.6993136405944824,
-0.1337203085422516,
0.9279474020004272,
-0.34261956810951233,
0.6318859457969666,
1.116818904876709,
-0.4659055471420288,
0.9283580183982849,
0.4244979918003082,
-0.46620863676071167,
0.006582095753401518,
0.6174912452697754,
0.10591636598110199,
0.7928659319877625,
0.03273393586277962,
-0.1140269860625267,
-0.5772635340690613,
0.32752367854118347,
-0.20926766097545624,
0.7218506932258606,
0.3590792715549469,
0.22604334354400635,
-0.5024752020835876,
-0.27830201387405396,
-0.4943070709705353,
0.009808485396206379,
-0.33155378699302673,
0.6917058825492859,
0.49162811040878296,
-0.49927452206611633,
0.6987470388412476,
0.15775512158870697,
0.9812114834785461,
-0.29956597089767456,
-0.197720006108284,
-0.210235133767128,
0.0847976878285408,
-0.5880405902862549,
-0.5424392223358154,
0.5235161781311035,
0.0788404569029808,
0.050714243203401566,
0.10594355314970016,
1.0031262636184692,
-0.4645693600177765,
-0.35676512122154236,
0.05663654953241348,
0.863920271396637,
-0.04609503597021103,
-0.14989687502384186,
-0.44673028588294983,
-0.24227380752563477,
-0.32370856404304504,
-0.37779513001441956,
0.35593700408935547,
0.31208622455596924,
0.06803659349679947,
0.48646798729896545,
0.2738376557826996,
-0.19545751810073853,
-0.002578996354714036,
-0.12142332643270493,
0.5676262378692627,
-0.4891780912876129,
-0.42997869849205017,
-1.08027982711792,
0.5374132394790649,
0.3399358093738556,
-0.32072803378105164,
0.4803963601589203,
0.2844371497631073,
0.8982488512992859,
0.028676899150013924,
0.7921883463859558,
-0.04617264121770859,
0.5066221952438354,
-0.49734801054000854,
0.47515785694122314,
-0.8515151143074036,
0.28859004378318787,
-0.50820392370224,
-1.0568749904632568,
-0.38616976141929626,
0.7843737006187439,
-0.04916410520672798,
0.2248692810535431,
0.5893043279647827,
0.8095411062240601,
-0.28192391991615295,
0.1866939514875412,
0.768552839756012,
0.0077614737674593925,
-0.11125260591506958,
0.7446283102035522,
0.6672164797782898,
-0.4515186548233032,
0.13959497213363647,
-0.38650205731391907,
-0.1836276799440384,
-0.09956249594688416,
-0.9517436027526855,
-0.8598963022232056,
-0.35473334789276123,
-0.4372779428958893,
0.21101191639900208,
0.06515390425920486,
1.1201255321502686,
1.0194697380065918,
-0.9338128566741943,
0.03370637446641922,
-0.10655877739191055,
-0.1326235681772232,
-0.21535146236419678,
-0.16319596767425537,
-0.010609643533825874,
-0.2873688340187073,
-1.121139407157898,
0.6822322010993958,
0.5278854370117188,
0.27943870425224304,
0.03451533988118172,
0.1298651099205017,
-0.26146435737609863,
0.35762447118759155,
0.5419095158576965,
0.11350677162408829,
-0.4826970100402832,
-0.43183448910713196,
0.24352237582206726,
0.000868670700583607,
-0.04674958437681198,
0.41043511033058167,
-0.9159660339355469,
0.21758008003234863,
0.572264552116394,
0.9131379723548889,
0.7600792646408081,
0.17314165830612183,
0.7197970747947693,
-1.0119011402130127,
0.14452144503593445,
0.2771758735179901,
0.33921515941619873,
0.07868877798318863,
-0.41105470061302185,
0.7433860301971436,
0.10478893667459488,
-0.4727642238140106,
-0.8319980502128601,
0.11024341732263565,
-0.7100908160209656,
-0.3083610236644745,
1.1172447204589844,
-0.09192502498626709,
0.005471482872962952,
-0.14347979426383972,
0.26036739349365234,
-0.08646032214164734,
-0.40052127838134766,
0.46729063987731934,
0.9596543908119202,
-0.32629621028900146,
-0.2832520008087158,
-0.33069702982902527,
0.3743417263031006,
0.5607590079307556,
-0.6846539974212646,
-0.2535993456840515,
0.3726717233657837,
0.2628355920314789,
-0.05317637696862221,
0.5535306334495544,
0.2196473777294159,
0.15057268738746643,
0.14083293080329895,
-0.48126572370529175,
0.031838055700063705,
-0.5481610298156738,
-0.7704978585243225,
0.2815053462982178,
0.12943458557128906,
0.026019258424639702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13718v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13718v1 | Evaluating Large Language Models along Dimensions of Language Variation: A Systematik Invesdigatiom uv Cross-lingual Generalization | 2024-06-19T17:20:28 | 2024-06-19T17:20:28 | Niyati Bafna, Kenton Murray, David Yarowsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models exhibit certain cross-lingual generalization
capabilities, they suffer from performance degradation (PD) on unseen
closely-related languages (CRLs) and dialects relative to their high-resource
language neighbour (HRLN). However, we currently lack a fundamental
understanding of what kinds of linguistic distances contribute to PD, and to
what extent. Furthermore, studies of cross-lingual generalization are
confounded by unknown quantities of CRL language traces in the training data,
and by the frequent lack of availability of evaluation data in lower-resource
related languages and dialects. To address these issues, we model phonological,
morphological, and lexical distance as Bayesian noise processes to synthesize
artificial languages that are controllably distant from the HRLN. We analyse PD
as a function of underlying noise parameters, offering insights on model
robustness to isolated and composed linguistic phenomena, and the impact of
task and HRL characteristics on PD. We calculate parameter posteriors on real
CRL-HRLN pair data and show that they follow computed trends of artificial
languages, demonstrating the viability of our noisers. Our framework offers a
cheap solution to estimating task performance on an unseen CRL given HRLN
performance using its posteriors, as well as for diagnosing observed PD on a
CRL in terms of its linguistic distances from its HRLN, and opens doors to
principled methods of mitigating performance degradation. | [
-0.31479454040527344,
-1.004621148109436,
0.3705768883228302,
0.26446956396102905,
-0.06040869653224945,
-0.08620120584964752,
-0.5150884985923767,
-0.5701835751533508,
-0.12246622145175934,
0.553316056728363,
-0.5350903272628784,
-0.3639380931854248,
-0.2752409875392914,
-0.17245890200138092,
-0.18004310131072998,
0.7552363276481628,
0.40468254685401917,
0.11887470632791519,
-0.03366685286164284,
-0.17787016928195953,
-0.2944134771823883,
-0.49552488327026367,
-0.5437445044517517,
-0.315877228975296,
0.4541809856891632,
0.011914960108697414,
0.7039976119995117,
0.5626647472381592,
0.5699242949485779,
0.3189481198787689,
-0.3321351706981659,
-0.14105471968650818,
-0.5060920119285583,
0.3684485852718353,
-0.35895293951034546,
-0.5030666589736938,
-0.241899311542511,
-0.37600138783454895,
0.9995495676994324,
1.244377851486206,
-0.05296044051647186,
0.022634388878941536,
0.12348651885986328,
0.5236957669258118,
-0.6556841135025024,
0.31579920649528503,
-0.44826024770736694,
0.0945383757352829,
-0.48869916796684265,
0.19752012193202972,
-0.1405525654554367,
-0.06633952260017395,
0.2807201147079468,
-0.5610244870185852,
0.36841434240341187,
-0.23562638461589813,
0.7896340489387512,
0.2707337737083435,
0.0415930300951004,
0.07810647040605545,
-0.9020262360572815,
1.0057300329208374,
-0.8077580332756042,
0.8119288086891174,
0.4946144223213196,
0.19553783535957336,
-0.08802647888660431,
-0.13793307542800903,
-0.31536638736724854,
-0.5009286403656006,
-0.05385749042034149,
-0.07934504002332687,
-0.33236050605773926,
0.16780708730220795,
0.3947887718677521,
0.5487720370292664,
-0.6229476928710938,
0.28340116143226624,
-0.36131343245506287,
-0.2451740801334381,
0.540716826915741,
0.2022794634103775,
0.31252050399780273,
-0.04900440201163292,
0.13939502835273743,
-0.13997472822666168,
-0.7152060866355896,
-0.1235629990696907,
0.6955875754356384,
0.4585195779800415,
-0.26684650778770447,
0.2322579324245453,
-0.31277844309806824,
0.7243978977203369,
0.005751342047005892,
-0.23810401558876038,
0.18467950820922852,
-0.38761192560195923,
-0.09480351954698563,
-0.3362314701080322,
0.8349700570106506,
-0.03109951876103878,
0.05329418554902077,
-0.5006712079048157,
-0.22635690867900848,
0.03572835400700569,
-0.02749020606279373,
-0.5275120139122009,
-0.4487871825695038,
-0.13741888105869293,
-0.46242645382881165,
-0.010835829190909863,
-0.2671669125556946,
-0.918724536895752,
-0.34785592555999756,
-0.2660800516605377,
0.3555164635181427,
-0.5021063685417175,
-0.5469856262207031,
-0.11855167150497437,
0.01991698145866394,
-0.16772037744522095,
0.04484379291534424,
-0.8517304062843323,
0.46087130904197693,
0.5956569314002991,
0.7096320986747742,
-0.31975507736206055,
-0.3886593282222748,
-0.5197708010673523,
0.060400038957595825,
-0.5259916186332703,
0.48704206943511963,
-0.6768165230751038,
-0.5426672697067261,
0.038488708436489105,
-0.14460651576519012,
-0.07477860897779465,
-1.0497630834579468,
0.29011496901512146,
-0.45317497849464417,
-0.10567875951528549,
-0.23194298148155212,
-0.17154452204704285,
-0.09441788494586945,
-0.0913519486784935,
-0.8668444156646729,
1.0942786931991577,
0.22159521281719208,
-0.7879931330680847,
0.5007073283195496,
-0.5726857781410217,
-0.5243212580680847,
-0.007493298966437578,
0.0993238165974617,
-0.32679662108421326,
0.43406185507774353,
-0.03343053162097931,
0.37398871779441833,
-0.3953167796134949,
0.1324678361415863,
-0.42933905124664307,
-0.21828977763652802,
0.04271997511386871,
-0.5161693692207336,
0.7118141055107117,
0.1288149505853653,
-0.3707408308982849,
0.028571173548698425,
-1.1699602603912354,
-0.154652938246727,
-0.22218750417232513,
-0.5187289118766785,
-0.8205577731132507,
0.11869416385889053,
-0.00809621624648571,
0.1501171588897705,
0.2111869901418686,
-0.44910216331481934,
-0.09964752942323685,
-0.5472840666770935,
0.2036464959383011,
0.5451851487159729,
-0.08201804012060165,
0.34767845273017883,
-0.09297356754541397,
0.633316159248352,
0.21531391143798828,
0.18898609280586243,
0.16065655648708344,
-0.2495463490486145,
-0.8094837665557861,
-0.28878211975097656,
0.30130383372306824,
0.2569958567619324,
-0.6036696434020996,
0.13185273110866547,
-0.4358755946159363,
-0.5410820245742798,
-0.5065885782241821,
0.11047494411468506,
0.6326472759246826,
0.24313390254974365,
0.24776892364025116,
-0.6302304863929749,
-0.2446639984846115,
-1.1236485242843628,
-0.22221577167510986,
-0.4012298583984375,
-0.1106281578540802,
0.003167499788105488,
0.1522476077079773,
-0.35392290353775024,
0.6109959483146667,
-0.026250286027789116,
0.14122655987739563,
-0.1384545862674713,
0.22660057246685028,
-0.01181282103061676,
0.4425755441188812,
0.3139713406562805,
-0.48742762207984924,
-0.3645836412906647,
0.30291447043418884,
-0.4229741096496582,
-0.48729512095451355,
0.12006863206624985,
0.06933360546827316,
0.4823160767555237,
0.41457071900367737,
-0.48611143231391907,
0.4369300901889801,
0.8518763184547424,
-0.1395227015018463,
0.8383352160453796,
-0.2627241015434265,
-0.030734246596693993,
-0.47238847613334656,
0.23712292313575745,
0.2664594054222107,
0.15816213190555573,
-0.6545020937919617,
0.20476067066192627,
-0.3744872808456421,
0.001584245590493083,
-0.05557574704289436,
0.44325512647628784,
-0.5067160129547119,
-0.3615892231464386,
-0.023049242794513702,
-0.14334458112716675,
-0.3467700481414795,
0.5428413152694702,
0.1967604011297226,
0.49855148792266846,
0.6456903219223022,
-0.7223916053771973,
0.1187303438782692,
-0.34997954964637756,
-0.5133545398712158,
0.6407825946807861,
-0.6080847382545471,
-0.13580794632434845,
0.0635148212313652,
-0.1804526001214981,
-0.8326234221458435,
-0.07539734989404678,
0.13325926661491394,
-0.10923771560192108,
0.3973081707954407,
-0.18206782639026642,
-0.6589406728744507,
-0.009105375967919827,
0.11855865269899368,
0.7640207409858704,
0.30299609899520874,
-0.25061964988708496,
0.235724076628685,
0.43258947134017944,
-0.2780663073062897,
-0.2934008538722992,
-0.7742718458175659,
-0.07122863084077835,
-0.2890036106109619,
-0.5781373977661133,
0.05666922405362129,
-0.026412038132548332,
-0.6709302067756653,
-0.06805495172739029,
-0.024879954755306244,
-0.38105979561805725,
0.046419765800237656,
0.36291009187698364,
-0.11239869147539139,
-0.4161030948162079,
0.345393568277359,
0.03513062372803688,
0.04908546060323715,
0.21919392049312592,
-0.22584818303585052,
0.6173669695854187,
0.050243135541677475,
-0.43821966648101807,
-0.24565722048282623,
0.44448721408843994,
0.5213944315910339,
-0.31342318654060364,
0.5881457328796387,
0.6647742986679077,
-0.29802635312080383,
-0.3082292675971985,
-0.6813324093818665,
-0.020073065534234047,
-0.41054779291152954,
0.6965712308883667,
-0.6047619581222534,
-0.6749764680862427,
0.7574626207351685,
0.10519736260175705,
-0.1856512427330017,
0.47076675295829773,
0.6354507803916931,
0.36663177609443665,
0.774925708770752,
0.8452221751213074,
-0.21005013585090637,
0.558731734752655,
-0.20980432629585266,
0.149156391620636,
-0.5156408548355103,
-0.1474865972995758,
-0.47095978260040283,
0.008406301960349083,
-0.8717716932296753,
-0.5208418965339661,
0.39631983637809753,
0.06376352161169052,
-0.36684998869895935,
0.22226811945438385,
-0.0965762659907341,
0.2652045786380768,
0.7816474437713623,
-0.033930592238903046,
0.3599870204925537,
0.18942655622959137,
-0.376137375831604,
-0.18043936789035797,
-0.9150097966194153,
-0.1750728338956833,
0.7800014019012451,
0.42007553577423096,
0.8845071196556091,
0.009478818625211716,
0.5850997567176819,
0.16647468507289886,
-0.05243011564016342,
-0.5386905670166016,
0.4626784920692444,
-0.05321146547794342,
-0.509913980960846,
-0.5984261631965637,
-0.7213956117630005,
-0.9407069683074951,
0.3339540362358093,
0.20214562118053436,
-0.9061160087585449,
0.44297170639038086,
-0.010632908903062344,
-0.26228639483451843,
0.3510899245738983,
-0.36588719487190247,
0.9245984554290771,
-0.06042596697807312,
-0.6676627993583679,
-0.5901027917861938,
-0.6516627073287964,
0.2611144185066223,
-0.24732783436775208,
0.38342610001564026,
0.09308531880378723,
-0.03875836357474327,
0.7704039812088013,
-0.3636992275714874,
0.9438960552215576,
-0.11630913615226746,
-0.5251585841178894,
0.1110689789056778,
0.5280011892318726,
0.06334236264228821,
-0.18972475826740265,
-0.2924690246582031,
0.5113599896430969,
0.07230957597494125,
-0.38762980699539185,
-0.44099730253219604,
0.792194128036499,
-0.7010059952735901,
-0.4802895486354828,
0.0486343652009964,
-0.8385327458381653,
-0.38744959235191345,
0.12631238996982574,
0.3355879783630371,
0.43439510464668274,
-0.20658482611179352,
-0.12933515012264252,
0.5523061752319336,
-0.5439854860305786,
0.4332645535469055,
0.4897879660129547,
-0.08857699483633041,
-0.23277612030506134,
1.141637921333313,
0.3042518198490143,
0.48556360602378845,
0.47786271572113037,
0.289950430393219,
-0.16822025179862976,
-0.508755624294281,
-0.2802622616291046,
0.33152928948402405,
-0.4601985812187195,
0.24184371531009674,
-0.33302587270736694,
0.03188328072428703,
-0.24483048915863037,
0.22449105978012085,
-0.5066434144973755,
-0.4062381088733673,
-0.08051008731126785,
0.13949763774871826,
-0.07303962111473083,
0.9885808229446411,
-0.5734400153160095,
0.3278540372848511,
-0.6183886528015137,
0.13973289728164673,
0.15547046065330505,
0.44477102160453796,
0.13077130913734436,
-0.5790232419967651,
-0.5990893244743347,
0.26170602440834045,
-0.2635282874107361,
-0.7055824398994446,
0.47407078742980957,
0.3099024295806885,
0.6778440475463867,
0.488529235124588,
-0.08960487693548203,
0.7283786535263062,
-0.32630449533462524,
0.8626834154129028,
0.10847479104995728,
-1.0522916316986084,
0.41365084052085876,
-0.6477266550064087,
0.28305715322494507,
0.23788373172283173,
0.24009688198566437,
-0.4533025622367859,
-0.6609991192817688,
-0.6506918668746948,
-0.6975154280662537,
0.5765387415885925,
-0.005631770472973585,
-0.133753702044487,
0.138906329870224,
0.15040646493434906,
0.23536497354507446,
0.11880356073379517,
-0.7264251112937927,
-0.11804283410310745,
0.2041492611169815,
0.2064967155456543,
-0.32595762610435486,
-0.26552140712738037,
0.08137331157922745,
-0.33203399181365967,
0.5674640536308289,
0.035593561828136444,
0.15792596340179443,
-0.08487333357334137,
-0.19040769338607788,
-0.39971670508384705,
0.11372803896665573,
0.49112945795059204,
0.8286364078521729,
0.08816440403461456,
0.03916434571146965,
0.16110588610172272,
-0.1644633263349533,
0.03792283311486244,
0.07368381321430206,
0.011087978258728981,
0.18544065952301025,
0.6583035588264465,
0.6743913292884827,
0.367777556180954,
-0.7642385363578796,
0.30761364102363586,
0.36275795102119446,
0.15706905722618103,
-0.03300396353006363,
-0.08292137831449509,
-0.01349444966763258,
0.3796443045139313,
-0.0009886699263006449,
-0.05164578929543495,
0.3191528022289276,
-0.7988308072090149,
0.10731195658445358,
0.36318734288215637,
-0.5945962071418762,
-0.6607136130332947,
0.512300431728363,
-0.018992053344845772,
-0.1547566056251526,
0.48217320442199707,
-0.12811532616615295,
-0.5213925242424011,
0.49316897988319397,
0.37583720684051514,
0.8371585607528687,
-0.39407655596733093,
0.10292082279920578,
0.15157653391361237,
0.33896878361701965,
0.06841371953487396,
0.008059277199208736,
-0.16833600401878357,
-0.3530261516571045,
-0.5649263858795166,
-0.8111559748649597,
-0.16689954698085785,
0.15418300032615662,
-0.734432578086853,
0.029710661619901657,
-0.31917092204093933,
-0.16856279969215393,
-0.09777522832155228,
-0.03298989683389664,
-0.5671330690383911,
0.19633404910564423,
0.12016157805919647,
0.39859601855278015,
-0.7038405537605286,
0.792692244052887,
0.5024880170822144,
-0.2812882363796234,
-0.5198800563812256,
0.31542009115219116,
-0.26867008209228516,
-0.6190080642700195,
1.104953646659851,
-0.19506220519542694,
-0.1277349293231964,
-0.5181919932365417,
-0.19569511711597443,
-0.7757161855697632,
0.44874703884124756,
0.6933832168579102,
-0.695888876914978,
0.07296574860811234,
0.588053822517395,
0.9351149797439575,
0.13356459140777588,
0.13186097145080566,
0.718389093875885,
0.33223816752433777,
-0.3837263882160187,
-1.4073071479797363,
-0.05716751515865326,
-0.1321803480386734,
0.2810576558113098,
0.3957263231277466,
-0.8382716774940491,
1.0618540048599243,
-0.12142167240381241,
-0.23906691372394562,
0.17211779952049255,
0.3390270173549652,
-0.01606975682079792,
0.04246753826737404,
0.39385947585105896,
0.70783531665802,
0.5243276953697205,
0.06541202962398529,
0.8960106372833252,
-0.3672034442424774,
0.28930842876434326,
1.0038455724716187,
0.0160183347761631,
0.7778534293174744,
0.3572425842285156,
-0.3385646343231201,
0.3870621621608734,
0.5315114855766296,
0.19430983066558838,
0.45544278621673584,
0.7564969658851624,
-0.3329339623451233,
-0.37960973381996155,
-0.07141146063804626,
-0.3006860315799713,
0.4028591811656952,
0.3912080228328705,
-0.35891515016555786,
-0.2554529011249542,
0.05531829595565796,
-0.20883731544017792,
0.07342380285263062,
-0.2665313184261322,
0.5941184163093567,
-0.006770740728825331,
-0.5306307077407837,
0.7838311195373535,
-0.00724658602848649,
0.5744414329528809,
-0.5045682787895203,
0.04587842524051666,
-0.30592742562294006,
0.31622421741485596,
0.017800496891140938,
-0.33559781312942505,
0.3870716989040375,
-0.21236735582351685,
-0.25938713550567627,
0.1901737004518509,
0.419589638710022,
-0.49440595507621765,
-0.6457808613777161,
0.7009494304656982,
0.5778836607933044,
0.3014802038669586,
-0.10637778043746948,
-0.5141908526420593,
0.2813548445701599,
-0.2515786290168762,
-0.04338213428854942,
0.40274104475975037,
0.7121250629425049,
-0.11695440858602524,
0.8547870516777039,
0.3829657733440399,
0.45488858222961426,
0.3686545789241791,
0.08943702280521393,
0.6607787013053894,
-0.3917369246482849,
-0.42620065808296204,
-0.8239176869392395,
0.11677443981170654,
0.19367915391921997,
-0.37070852518081665,
0.70261549949646,
0.5818453431129456,
1.1303988695144653,
-0.10275440663099289,
0.7838590741157532,
0.10472658276557922,
0.5944070219993591,
-0.42319226264953613,
0.797724187374115,
-0.7623829245567322,
0.3961182236671448,
-0.535133957862854,
-0.9759407043457031,
-0.31300032138824463,
0.5000542998313904,
-0.4395868480205536,
0.05496857687830925,
0.516361653804779,
1.0945247411727905,
-0.2122766375541687,
-0.3278447985649109,
0.7812420725822449,
0.3399415910243988,
0.015187469311058521,
0.45119526982307434,
0.8884588479995728,
-0.16824668645858765,
0.5512199401855469,
-0.6575556397438049,
-0.10985418409109116,
-0.08658676594495773,
-0.42756417393684387,
-0.7926012873649597,
-0.7345027923583984,
-0.5440748929977417,
-0.21852561831474304,
0.4305170476436615,
0.49031585454940796,
0.8520556688308716,
-0.8627725839614868,
-0.7553113698959351,
-0.10170916467905045,
0.07198935747146606,
-0.3761942386627197,
-0.27124229073524475,
0.37377822399139404,
-0.3586922287940979,
-0.7696617841720581,
0.22466908395290375,
0.1784183233976364,
-0.2154283970594406,
-0.6541674137115479,
-0.10330143570899963,
0.11155669391155243,
-0.07526848465204239,
0.6528938412666321,
0.29032155871391296,
-0.911862850189209,
-0.2040276825428009,
-0.40557947754859924,
-0.004127075430005789,
-0.12792529165744781,
0.7237403988838196,
-0.5150202512741089,
0.4568915069103241,
0.5136691927909851,
0.4456726014614105,
0.2470555603504181,
-0.38065582513809204,
0.7323489785194397,
-0.6709064245223999,
0.21626922488212585,
0.18137305974960327,
0.23622608184814453,
0.34392252564430237,
-0.16600897908210754,
0.43280521035194397,
0.4257797598838806,
-0.492418110370636,
-0.7519079446792603,
0.2672598361968994,
-0.7879840135574341,
-0.2106984555721283,
1.332781195640564,
-0.28367069363594055,
-0.17317286133766174,
-0.18923227488994598,
0.0810944065451622,
0.19714051485061646,
-0.36213114857673645,
0.753570556640625,
0.79554283618927,
-0.005006302613765001,
-0.08533724397420883,
-0.5294275283813477,
0.47305554151535034,
0.4999883472919464,
-0.44482600688934326,
0.27969416975975037,
0.7423579096794128,
0.3808920681476593,
0.3302415609359741,
0.18125396966934204,
-0.14261363446712494,
0.2091681957244873,
0.4058467745780945,
0.05694015696644783,
0.3668942153453827,
-0.28715458512306213,
-0.3991490304470062,
0.1485946774482727,
0.15445159375667572,
-0.035042718052864075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13714v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13714v1 | BEACON: Balancing Convenience and Nutrition in Meals With Long-Term Group Recommendations and Reasoning on Multimodal Recipes | 2024-06-19T17:14:41 | 2024-06-19T17:14:41 | Vansh Nagpal, Siva Likitha Valluru, Kausik Lakkaraju, Biplav Srivastava | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | A common, yet regular, decision made by people, whether healthy or with any
health condition, is to decide what to have in meals like breakfast, lunch, and
dinner, consisting of a combination of foods for appetizer, main course, side
dishes, desserts, and beverages. However, often this decision is seen as a
trade-off between nutritious choices (e.g., low salt and sugar) or convenience
(e.g., inexpensive, fast to prepare/obtain, taste better). In this preliminary
work, we present a data-driven approach for the novel meal recommendation
problem that can explore and balance choices for both considerations while also
reasoning about a food's constituents and cooking process. Beyond the problem
formulation, our contributions also include a goodness measure, a recipe
conversion method from text to the recently introduced multimodal rich recipe
representation (R3) format, and learning methods using contextual bandits that
show promising results. | [
-0.30163827538490295,
-0.5795900821685791,
0.6134783029556274,
0.4438929855823517,
-0.21004930138587952,
-0.19714811444282532,
-0.11159081757068634,
-0.515953004360199,
0.5416348576545715,
0.45397090911865234,
-0.5840034484863281,
-0.3294888734817505,
-0.42596226930618286,
0.09314543753862381,
0.08826539665460587,
0.9249728322029114,
-0.08245863765478134,
0.1675359308719635,
-0.2081398218870163,
-0.26804617047309875,
-1.1421325206756592,
-0.2735152244567871,
-0.6355054974555969,
-0.41341033577919006,
0.8929940462112427,
0.8633421659469604,
0.8649293184280396,
0.4957786202430725,
0.3183298110961914,
0.13952858746051788,
0.08724892139434814,
0.4004729688167572,
-0.2726122736930847,
0.5297638177871704,
-0.25560033321380615,
-0.3738210201263428,
-0.3999466001987457,
-0.033268220722675323,
0.011350833810865879,
0.9764886498451233,
0.015551195479929447,
0.11103188246488571,
0.07282138615846634,
1.018949270248413,
-0.6865816116333008,
0.15376663208007812,
-0.13850373029708862,
0.1776704043149948,
-0.25474023818969727,
-0.3160884380340576,
-0.37404969334602356,
-0.4018329679965973,
0.15210938453674316,
-0.6777530312538147,
-0.07115435600280762,
0.2807842791080475,
0.08825021982192993,
0.28213876485824585,
-0.7816339135169983,
-0.758753776550293,
-0.5841476321220398,
1.030367136001587,
-0.31309080123901367,
0.4154234826564789,
0.8646045327186584,
0.42842602729797363,
-0.4039860665798187,
-0.4996027648448944,
-0.2247156947851181,
-0.23164096474647522,
-0.13082517683506012,
0.2503647208213806,
0.28450360894203186,
-0.3257361948490143,
-0.24212148785591125,
0.2402687668800354,
-0.5361722111701965,
-0.2862635850906372,
-0.05438823252916336,
-0.013946441002190113,
0.46935978531837463,
0.3022744655609131,
0.16065961122512817,
-0.3434150218963623,
-0.825340211391449,
0.17874646186828613,
-0.5081728100776672,
0.2313801348209381,
0.008239513263106346,
0.3101642429828644,
0.07438252866268158,
0.6994953751564026,
-0.35935306549072266,
0.8893767595291138,
-0.09721101075410843,
-0.08769669383764267,
0.3226955831050873,
-0.7935265302658081,
0.14976324141025543,
0.1305212825536728,
0.22912172973155975,
1.2928141355514526,
-0.26024746894836426,
0.01001682411879301,
-0.1601146161556244,
-0.01644333265721798,
-0.024208975955843925,
-0.3985862135887146,
-0.38188934326171875,
0.2947586476802826,
-0.6289452314376831,
-0.006857761647552252,
-0.1766958236694336,
-0.7088494300842285,
-0.4167528748512268,
-0.27130967378616333,
0.5220988988876343,
-0.4604372978210449,
0.07042375206947327,
0.29415273666381836,
-0.546043872833252,
-0.0649132952094078,
0.2180185616016388,
-0.9083147048950195,
0.08275433629751205,
0.11924184113740921,
0.9277780652046204,
-0.007354209665209055,
-0.14732511341571808,
-0.6593180298805237,
0.7623574137687683,
-0.09587462991476059,
0.9362746477127075,
-0.788336455821991,
-0.9074726104736328,
-0.29442745447158813,
0.058792632073163986,
0.2610814571380615,
-0.31026697158813477,
0.7985062003135681,
-0.05501963198184967,
0.2156299501657486,
-1.1597329378128052,
-0.4615090489387512,
-0.0029759660828858614,
0.2705923616886139,
-0.6910659074783325,
0.6632804274559021,
0.37733396887779236,
-0.5239819288253784,
0.6335218548774719,
-0.29770854115486145,
-0.9963313937187195,
0.35836732387542725,
-0.1417837142944336,
0.025291649624705315,
0.042616795748472214,
0.31069865822792053,
0.2735118269920349,
-0.1802053600549698,
0.16127559542655945,
-0.19954366981983185,
-0.29181990027427673,
0.26754942536354065,
-0.32923242449760437,
0.2075534611940384,
0.4224192500114441,
0.05610603094100952,
0.3952104151248932,
-0.4324416518211365,
0.188809335231781,
0.0704314261674881,
-0.37853947281837463,
-0.8013271689414978,
0.5458016991615295,
0.1841331124305725,
-0.2394101917743683,
0.24955640733242035,
-0.07889019697904587,
0.24556171894073486,
-0.2508242428302765,
0.8416955471038818,
0.7204602360725403,
-0.018110590055584908,
0.6762034893035889,
-0.7184778451919556,
0.08788672089576721,
-0.12931402027606964,
0.6739714741706848,
-0.39644232392311096,
-0.7575656771659851,
-0.44623759388923645,
-0.2379176765680313,
0.22052431106567383,
0.32695454359054565,
-0.8763540387153625,
0.47875258326530457,
-0.06713959574699402,
-0.07137514650821686,
0.024345947429537773,
-0.3440398871898651,
0.1216401755809784,
0.8049579858779907,
0.8976072669029236,
-0.29745933413505554,
-0.2833198010921478,
-0.7954042553901672,
-0.31323951482772827,
0.46360859274864197,
0.11071028560400009,
0.20727640390396118,
0.07397133111953735,
-0.22824692726135254,
1.271576166152954,
-0.7738720178604126,
-0.32029464840888977,
-0.5333526134490967,
-0.3174734115600586,
0.2951216399669647,
0.5477724671363831,
0.5801344513893127,
-1.013885736465454,
-0.47196781635284424,
-0.13656970858573914,
-0.4192846417427063,
0.2446456104516983,
0.0007742955931462348,
-0.1620142161846161,
-0.2791506052017212,
-0.009946576319634914,
-0.4970802366733551,
0.28772732615470886,
0.45341479778289795,
-0.656591534614563,
0.3997800350189209,
-0.08953816443681717,
0.2862169146537781,
-1.3935937881469727,
-0.2796953618526459,
0.12784357368946075,
-0.0301705002784729,
-0.2885834574699402,
-0.1885385513305664,
0.2553931474685669,
0.021109193563461304,
-0.17243173718452454,
1.182537317276001,
-0.15692901611328125,
0.08778948336839676,
-0.09283847361803055,
-0.45912691950798035,
0.11718501150608063,
0.11063743382692337,
-0.10602197796106339,
0.6124933958053589,
0.26164522767066956,
-0.7047351002693176,
0.3967001736164093,
0.023574942722916603,
-0.2683297097682953,
1.0953271389007568,
-0.5810655951499939,
-0.2358427792787552,
-0.027576608583331108,
0.6263731718063354,
-1.183440089225769,
-0.5165783762931824,
0.7285630702972412,
-0.2480996996164322,
-0.12984198331832886,
0.08080390095710754,
-0.26988762617111206,
-0.26217547059059143,
-0.4377537667751312,
0.7049285769462585,
0.04789828881621361,
-0.6040289998054504,
0.9394435882568359,
0.03410528972744942,
-0.13050708174705505,
-0.35590773820877075,
-0.6444455981254578,
0.206961989402771,
-0.20683887600898743,
-0.4262748658657074,
0.7890933752059937,
-0.4219994843006134,
-0.22930261492729187,
0.3191453218460083,
-0.20443587005138397,
0.21097368001937866,
-0.09459695219993591,
0.3986108899116516,
0.2678947150707245,
0.2723437249660492,
0.17955005168914795,
0.02978304587304592,
-0.3442313075065613,
-0.38937461376190186,
-0.12182115018367767,
0.5574641823768616,
-0.04048634320497513,
-0.11615988612174988,
-0.25501325726509094,
0.9020771980285645,
0.08531014621257782,
-0.42771369218826294,
0.5183610916137695,
0.6860120296478271,
-0.09928388893604279,
-0.13800862431526184,
-0.32317227125167847,
-0.18318292498588562,
-0.4485825300216675,
-0.08643117547035217,
-0.25060349702835083,
-0.44369271397590637,
0.6792699098587036,
0.13571439683437347,
-0.04413057491183281,
0.10774409025907516,
0.16508033871650696,
-0.1839127391576767,
0.6889440417289734,
0.07297460734844208,
0.07681399583816528,
0.5072155594825745,
0.018385598435997963,
0.0866604670882225,
-0.7030211687088013,
-0.5461956262588501,
-0.34013068675994873,
-0.606158435344696,
-0.18692468106746674,
-0.5289960503578186,
0.7243085503578186,
-0.2389206886291504,
-0.1169474720954895,
-0.04579204320907593,
-0.5397117137908936,
0.8200471997261047,
0.645150899887085,
0.5501176118850708,
0.3763948678970337,
-0.19531132280826569,
-0.33169353008270264,
-0.03623213991522789,
-0.4655926525592804,
-0.07342501729726791,
0.8138697147369385,
-0.035931482911109924,
0.9142318964004517,
0.2106957733631134,
0.7052111029624939,
0.6709444522857666,
0.03099570795893669,
-0.9968610405921936,
0.41392141580581665,
-0.10386274755001068,
-0.6036079525947571,
-0.06767872720956802,
-0.7969525456428528,
-0.9112924933433533,
0.10287395864725113,
-0.1599242389202118,
-0.25232502818107605,
-0.0745203047990799,
0.16959211230278015,
-0.6143469214439392,
-0.21688738465309143,
-1.16553795337677,
0.7428792715072632,
-0.6954115033149719,
-0.8355576395988464,
0.08976595848798752,
-0.7181153297424316,
-0.08400733023881912,
0.506553053855896,
0.5294087529182434,
-0.134835883975029,
0.1294434368610382,
0.47723615169525146,
0.0035838130861520767,
0.4916797876358032,
-0.1356351524591446,
0.12146339565515518,
-0.13894063234329224,
0.22650964558124542,
0.16930146515369415,
0.5170222520828247,
-0.1655496060848236,
-0.022874800488352776,
0.1362214833498001,
-0.49544772505760193,
-0.8487389087677002,
1.0230207443237305,
-0.3523836135864258,
-0.43701040744781494,
-0.6924065947532654,
-0.49905234575271606,
-0.3068279027938843,
0.4464540183544159,
0.2753857970237732,
0.48839351534843445,
-0.005840020719915628,
0.21138936281204224,
0.23610426485538483,
0.026833217591047287,
0.4298115074634552,
0.14810089766979218,
-0.2550840675830841,
-0.9319069385528564,
0.9708053469657898,
0.15759120881557465,
-0.009303257800638676,
0.3103667199611664,
0.5639644861221313,
-0.2873525023460388,
-0.04992571473121643,
-0.2833973467350006,
-0.18581132590770721,
-0.5755964517593384,
-0.2595877945423126,
-0.0775304064154625,
0.34440022706985474,
0.09822023659944534,
-0.6292486190795898,
-0.4603625535964966,
-0.3521933853626251,
-0.20548182725906372,
0.09545619785785675,
-0.22849273681640625,
0.5551350712776184,
0.06058819591999054,
0.04165714606642723,
-0.5965025424957275,
0.24795305728912354,
0.4567629098892212,
0.33659055829048157,
0.1630413681268692,
0.14184251427650452,
-0.36187905073165894,
-0.04209017753601074,
-0.5637223124504089,
-0.9309243559837341,
0.31143444776535034,
-0.0632859617471695,
0.6029683947563171,
0.3905702233314514,
0.029978597536683083,
0.2536463141441345,
-0.26186785101890564,
0.9330539107322693,
0.7446004152297974,
-0.8301267027854919,
0.5038269758224487,
-0.2113329917192459,
0.3742294907569885,
0.586021900177002,
0.5391138195991516,
-0.7063544988632202,
0.3580293357372284,
0.14860397577285767,
-1.0400946140289307,
-0.15562690794467926,
0.14509835839271545,
0.010934804566204548,
-0.5112553238868713,
0.3204633593559265,
0.48149582743644714,
0.2755001187324524,
-0.5394910573959351,
-0.18583504855632782,
-0.6456612348556519,
-0.11742661893367767,
-0.20049996674060822,
-0.1234883964061737,
-0.3652687966823578,
-0.5182722210884094,
0.2215477079153061,
-0.1417391449213028,
0.04870196804404259,
0.08853154629468918,
0.5424399375915527,
-0.1003444492816925,
0.4732939898967743,
0.571185827255249,
0.9662050604820251,
-0.47381100058555603,
0.4114808440208435,
-0.24428273737430573,
-0.14526216685771942,
0.22321847081184387,
-0.061418548226356506,
0.29864418506622314,
-0.30305400490760803,
0.18156005442142487,
0.36691465973854065,
0.34241071343421936,
-0.33727070689201355,
0.2744729816913605,
-0.36028966307640076,
-0.09480153769254684,
0.00967141892760992,
0.24793237447738647,
0.08838340640068054,
0.34258589148521423,
0.5270592570304871,
0.3960374891757965,
0.235158771276474,
-0.6138696670532227,
0.03662686049938202,
0.5805366635322571,
-0.16274453699588776,
-0.19718991219997406,
0.24787114560604095,
0.6641453504562378,
-0.13202883303165436,
0.6264299750328064,
-0.11525985598564148,
-0.1188591793179512,
0.17630848288536072,
0.6181472539901733,
0.384229838848114,
-0.44587987661361694,
0.4692159593105316,
0.04618798568844795,
-0.007534008007496595,
-0.2839434742927551,
0.20034624636173248,
-0.28625571727752686,
-0.7748240232467651,
-0.09406950324773788,
-0.5152489542961121,
-0.2464444786310196,
-0.13011686503887177,
-0.78999263048172,
0.0032298779115080833,
-0.07895026355981827,
-0.7350267767906189,
0.05153896287083626,
-0.16257643699645996,
-0.7446045875549316,
0.07761135697364807,
-0.0431201234459877,
0.7745353579521179,
-0.595632791519165,
0.4713864028453827,
0.593419075012207,
-0.3371545672416687,
-0.37165650725364685,
0.34335261583328247,
-0.1231975108385086,
-0.6880928874015808,
0.37568873167037964,
0.28520938754081726,
-0.2999265491962433,
-0.31997719407081604,
-0.5009515285491943,
-0.7213298082351685,
0.6646623015403748,
0.3041226863861084,
-0.3547839820384979,
-0.4081176221370697,
-0.1988115757703781,
0.0006251615122891963,
-0.13113489747047424,
0.14527276158332825,
0.06074339896440506,
0.8901589512825012,
0.6710017323493958,
-0.6068991422653198,
-0.07048118859529495,
-0.004754399415105581,
0.006112377624958754,
0.20695093274116516,
-0.788325309753418,
1.0172398090362549,
-0.40544062852859497,
-0.10427685081958771,
-0.1474519520998001,
0.36376553773880005,
0.17127686738967896,
0.8130472898483276,
0.2326570451259613,
0.49863535165786743,
0.5527127385139465,
0.016368258744478226,
1.0538616180419922,
-0.10277865827083588,
0.35504573583602905,
1.3167109489440918,
-0.7918679118156433,
0.27234530448913574,
0.7271841168403625,
-0.14174973964691162,
0.1509549468755722,
1.1022449731826782,
0.23500891029834747,
1.220197319984436,
-0.14455635845661163,
-0.06686095148324966,
-0.33794230222702026,
-0.36410537362098694,
-0.9558504223823547,
0.5310640931129456,
0.2944034934043884,
-0.48576030135154724,
-0.5062734484672546,
0.002026575617492199,
-0.16649901866912842,
-0.20887483656406403,
-0.134867325425148,
0.5385351777076721,
0.08748503029346466,
-0.4679132401943207,
0.3772181272506714,
0.1088690534234047,
0.3444775640964508,
-0.46429672837257385,
-0.38521474599838257,
-0.3986656069755554,
0.07584504783153534,
-0.36088886857032776,
-0.9877670407295227,
-0.006352738477289677,
-0.9716826677322388,
-0.46801555156707764,
-0.13369330763816833,
0.28116995096206665,
-0.2614099681377411,
-0.508525013923645,
0.158294215798378,
0.5984472632408142,
-0.6771261096000671,
0.1198478639125824,
-0.37890124320983887,
0.3861923813819885,
-0.10407622158527374,
-0.0322733074426651,
0.1587759107351303,
0.10178127139806747,
0.4234115183353424,
0.3850918710231781,
0.3993878662586212,
0.03556244820356369,
-0.3019735813140869,
-0.2654300630092621,
1.129052996635437,
-0.6885369420051575,
-0.9525153040885925,
-0.8757341504096985,
0.3673136532306671,
0.024816235527396202,
-0.4749622941017151,
0.8065597414970398,
0.5203288793563843,
0.7213685512542725,
-0.04324689507484436,
0.7410175800323486,
0.058076005429029465,
0.13350920379161835,
-0.9543339014053345,
0.19136172533035278,
-0.7296306490898132,
0.296188622713089,
0.054466988891363144,
-1.1433005332946777,
-0.26260507106781006,
0.8024737238883972,
-0.6279869675636292,
0.27171024680137634,
0.7294779419898987,
0.4801137149333954,
-0.32171928882598877,
0.4016607701778412,
0.10629118978977203,
-0.43506938219070435,
0.45251092314720154,
0.7251729369163513,
0.8520002365112305,
0.2280552238225937,
-0.3276107609272003,
0.13952884078025818,
-0.3929005563259125,
-0.463106244802475,
-0.717469334602356,
-0.4949283301830292,
-0.651003360748291,
0.26411736011505127,
-0.10911539942026138,
0.37851768732070923,
1.2293730974197388,
0.9146939516067505,
-0.4102519154548645,
-0.07273764908313751,
0.1910630166530609,
0.32163918018341064,
-0.6586258411407471,
-0.19341862201690674,
0.2305132895708084,
-0.2790501117706299,
-0.08153516054153442,
0.8797891736030579,
0.3684788942337036,
-0.29591330885887146,
0.05270346999168396,
-0.00031584364478476346,
-0.09125819057226181,
0.22234117984771729,
0.8671542406082153,
-0.008196471258997917,
-0.5306074023246765,
-0.2831467390060425,
-0.2406940758228302,
0.1863226443529129,
0.02884252741932869,
0.8447876572608948,
-0.5291733741760254,
0.8290193676948547,
-0.07592135667800903,
0.3899519145488739,
0.131137877702713,
0.10562318563461304,
0.20496968924999237,
-0.8013157844543457,
-0.018603287637233734,
0.17393678426742554,
0.23029829561710358,
0.3260231614112854,
-0.38284894824028015,
0.3830641508102417,
0.2923183739185333,
-0.7678462266921997,
-0.40296801924705505,
0.3883568048477173,
-1.0959690809249878,
-0.4641822874546051,
1.1936759948730469,
0.16029755771160126,
-0.19059519469738007,
0.039983995258808136,
-0.23579776287078857,
0.1303931474685669,
-0.7366836667060852,
1.0702630281448364,
0.6835132241249084,
-0.47844815254211426,
0.2732820212841034,
-0.50339674949646,
0.5801113247871399,
0.42230549454689026,
-0.7941769957542419,
-0.2742147147655487,
0.7781122326850891,
0.35936322808265686,
0.20755542814731598,
0.5144008994102478,
0.36844709515571594,
0.17567861080169678,
-0.3229464292526245,
-0.2067163735628128,
-0.2971745729446411,
-0.8121036887168884,
0.4462074339389801,
0.42554762959480286,
-0.18049877882003784,
-0.20872293412685394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13713v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13713v1 | Benchmarking Open-Source Language Models for Efficient Question Answering in Industrial Applications | 2024-06-19T17:11:51 | 2024-06-19T17:11:51 | Mahaman Sanoussi Yahaya Alassan, Jessica López Espejel, Merieme Bouhandi, Walid Dahhane, El Hassane Ettifouri | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the rapidly evolving landscape of Natural Language Processing (NLP), Large
Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in tasks such
as question answering (QA). However, the accessibility and practicality of
utilizing these models for industrial applications pose significant challenges,
particularly concerning cost-effectiveness, inference speed, and resource
efficiency. This paper presents a comprehensive benchmarking study comparing
open-source LLMs with their non-open-source counterparts on the task of
question answering. Our objective is to identify open-source alternatives
capable of delivering comparable performance to proprietary models while being
lightweight in terms of resource requirements and suitable for Central
Processing Unit (CPU)-based inference. Through rigorous evaluation across
various metrics including accuracy, inference speed, and resource consumption,
we aim to provide insights into selecting efficient LLMs for real-world
applications. Our findings shed light on viable open-source alternatives that
offer acceptable performance and efficiency, addressing the pressing need for
accessible and efficient NLP solutions in industry settings. | [
-0.23137842118740082,
-0.6953776478767395,
0.7266260981559753,
0.13194958865642548,
-0.07250408828258514,
-0.09905818104743958,
-0.3835878074169159,
-0.653628945350647,
-0.37007415294647217,
0.4970783293247223,
-0.49498042464256287,
-0.5661675930023193,
-0.07684576511383057,
0.1926581710577011,
-0.31052520871162415,
0.45714911818504333,
-0.15720906853675842,
0.017400354146957397,
-0.6604210138320923,
-0.5134472250938416,
-0.2686789333820343,
-0.48205965757369995,
-0.6506938934326172,
-0.12408147007226944,
0.5067683458328247,
0.1932704746723175,
0.820339024066925,
0.6837761402130127,
0.6447416543960571,
0.3078485429286957,
-0.029841845855116844,
-0.09098681807518005,
-0.2803710401058197,
0.32662081718444824,
-0.3147154152393341,
-0.4786500930786133,
-0.2668168544769287,
-0.11639997363090515,
0.6040764451026917,
0.7406428456306458,
-0.047846440225839615,
0.6540018916130066,
-0.16344714164733887,
0.5719867944717407,
-0.9310032725334167,
0.08570385724306107,
-0.9238324761390686,
-0.05453639104962349,
-0.1228303536772728,
0.08354903012514114,
-0.31564050912857056,
-0.7065063118934631,
-0.03688599914312363,
-0.5722343325614929,
0.15323853492736816,
0.22786900401115417,
0.6113888621330261,
0.42790600657463074,
0.19084887206554413,
-0.15734513103961945,
-0.905156135559082,
0.9658157825469971,
-1.0142443180084229,
0.6873159408569336,
0.12693418562412262,
0.5711842179298401,
0.1406087428331375,
-0.9214648604393005,
-0.4320030212402344,
-0.22286124527454376,
0.07588282227516174,
0.08737878501415253,
-0.4956737160682678,
0.040297236293554306,
0.27076494693756104,
0.49481436610221863,
-0.799445629119873,
0.39861080050468445,
-0.270311176776886,
0.10361186414957047,
0.20975500345230103,
0.15901629626750946,
0.19229233264923096,
0.11299274861812592,
-0.2031499296426773,
0.0062969401478767395,
-0.4554308354854584,
0.0370594747364521,
0.15379191935062408,
0.34523874521255493,
0.2405034750699997,
0.7366004586219788,
-0.47757700085639954,
0.6782614588737488,
-0.676460325717926,
-0.011259161867201328,
0.16128477454185486,
-0.1578209549188614,
-0.5177605748176575,
-0.22492337226867676,
0.7899417877197266,
0.2797043025493622,
0.05437137931585312,
-0.6262630224227905,
-0.20951159298419952,
-0.060804471373558044,
0.2776137590408325,
-0.7323014140129089,
0.09960153698921204,
0.49802419543266296,
-0.5013384222984314,
0.13012877106666565,
-0.21324589848518372,
-0.7592552304267883,
-0.3133769631385803,
-0.06361149996519089,
0.36865898966789246,
-0.17541596293449402,
-0.27754124999046326,
0.06760261952877045,
-0.424338161945343,
0.5174846649169922,
0.14947937428951263,
-0.5445126891136169,
0.2122899889945984,
0.9658585786819458,
1.2089474201202393,
-0.07475331425666809,
0.04427734762430191,
-0.692484438419342,
0.013932820409536362,
-0.38951197266578674,
0.7478905916213989,
-0.48325327038764954,
-0.1775202453136444,
0.013612677343189716,
-0.24188874661922455,
-0.03340335562825203,
-1.0492515563964844,
0.9472125768661499,
-0.6753308176994324,
-0.05903763324022293,
-0.24658913910388947,
-0.36834362149238586,
-0.174978569149971,
0.1994851976633072,
-0.8554891347885132,
1.2317311763763428,
0.1795722395181656,
-0.7980696558952332,
0.0069032637402415276,
-0.6353394985198975,
-0.09954789280891418,
0.23560045659542084,
-0.07400542497634888,
-0.2503294348716736,
0.3193446099758148,
-0.018658969551324844,
0.24619455635547638,
-0.7729608416557312,
0.02638937532901764,
-0.5883129835128784,
-0.3215465247631073,
0.29306668043136597,
-0.47962868213653564,
0.8012723326683044,
0.519213855266571,
-0.08908793330192566,
0.20795273780822754,
-0.9061728715896606,
0.22955422103405,
0.2326936423778534,
-0.20866502821445465,
-0.5518820285797119,
0.09145865589380264,
-0.10441982001066208,
0.11077278107404709,
0.299554705619812,
-0.7752222418785095,
-0.32315632700920105,
-0.3779843747615814,
0.2979240417480469,
0.5792097449302673,
-0.3002993166446686,
0.17805452644824982,
-0.37656521797180176,
0.668407678604126,
-0.35236334800720215,
0.21104703843593597,
0.11272861808538437,
-0.4070843756198883,
-0.6836612820625305,
-0.2824638783931732,
0.21644267439842224,
0.6305994391441345,
-0.8062081336975098,
0.07334025949239731,
-0.10713309794664383,
-0.6959513425827026,
-1.0477287769317627,
0.15360833704471588,
0.36158767342567444,
0.7785131335258484,
0.40799981355667114,
-0.10755154490470886,
-0.45568063855171204,
-1.1938865184783936,
-0.7459363341331482,
-0.4492397904396057,
-0.6102373600006104,
0.3759295344352722,
0.10841108858585358,
0.14667247235774994,
1.1675264835357666,
-0.6406880617141724,
0.20189279317855835,
-0.22405502200126648,
0.1171509250998497,
0.40625423192977905,
0.11750584095716476,
0.543167233467102,
-0.4545910656452179,
-0.3469800651073456,
0.038331177085638046,
-0.7873181700706482,
-0.53341144323349,
0.24106410145759583,
-0.27103257179260254,
0.2610915005207062,
0.5782552361488342,
-0.4202244281768799,
0.0948951318860054,
0.7576828598976135,
0.13984175026416779,
0.6853845715522766,
-0.059058621525764465,
-0.03018759749829769,
-0.8563215136528015,
0.6333497762680054,
0.10262992233037949,
-0.2445623278617859,
-0.655634880065918,
0.36538976430892944,
0.20130671560764313,
-0.24515753984451294,
-0.8217170238494873,
0.6138274669647217,
-0.4833163917064667,
-0.45231306552886963,
-0.18473657965660095,
0.3189712166786194,
0.16056084632873535,
0.4411405920982361,
0.048993319272994995,
1.2858049869537354,
0.14677688479423523,
-0.42172038555145264,
0.23034951090812683,
0.010590658523142338,
-0.6407630443572998,
0.22725898027420044,
-0.8935694694519043,
0.15528400242328644,
-0.01882176846265793,
-0.19580945372581482,
-0.7637486457824707,
0.3123297393321991,
0.17118807137012482,
-0.06684482842683792,
-0.34804466366767883,
-0.05408214405179024,
-0.790799081325531,
-0.3926520049571991,
-0.34511786699295044,
0.2053314596414566,
0.6901530623435974,
-0.5532464385032654,
0.49680712819099426,
0.1136920228600502,
-0.42117536067962646,
-0.4420028328895569,
-0.7152788639068604,
-0.08840896934270859,
-0.08426015824079514,
-0.5185710191726685,
-0.03070666827261448,
-0.17346806824207306,
-0.5383665561676025,
0.13626761734485626,
-0.35884904861450195,
-0.3792559802532196,
0.3871546685695648,
-0.1271095722913742,
0.21880082786083221,
-0.6512807011604309,
0.15533766150474548,
-0.15727944672107697,
0.0615946389734745,
0.22990861535072327,
-0.157009556889534,
0.3999682664871216,
-0.12533268332481384,
-0.4042755961418152,
-0.2314041554927826,
0.42769360542297363,
0.4907201826572418,
-0.6093097925186157,
0.9208781123161316,
0.2771018445491791,
-0.2448047250509262,
-0.4097522795200348,
-0.5981868505477905,
0.10806082934141159,
-0.5391176342964172,
0.37296658754348755,
-0.12445443123579025,
-0.7815245389938354,
0.4330821633338928,
-0.1991567313671112,
0.4512384831905365,
0.4501141905784607,
0.40648195147514343,
0.1261306256055832,
0.7110459804534912,
0.31745073199272156,
-0.013685573823750019,
0.44321414828300476,
0.10675828903913498,
0.25013867020606995,
-0.8458765149116516,
0.06784717738628387,
-1.187435507774353,
-0.19050727784633636,
-0.38435208797454834,
-0.75202476978302,
0.403794527053833,
0.16188962757587433,
-0.28756529092788696,
0.17524303495883942,
-0.29052531719207764,
0.51474928855896,
0.7907440662384033,
-0.26782017946243286,
0.713969349861145,
-0.31164100766181946,
-0.00960613414645195,
0.2984379529953003,
-0.7530243992805481,
-0.7533474564552307,
0.8957098126411438,
0.39328959584236145,
0.6837908029556274,
0.18148478865623474,
0.1702241748571396,
-0.028493883088231087,
0.2354096621274948,
-0.5392305850982666,
0.669521689414978,
-0.2927364706993103,
-0.6649441719055176,
-0.36068451404571533,
-0.580278754234314,
-0.6958324909210205,
0.36093780398368835,
-0.13449496030807495,
-0.6650462746620178,
-0.013040849007666111,
0.03906002268195152,
-0.2045121192932129,
0.6662657260894775,
-0.8088511228561401,
1.0930739641189575,
-0.3307360112667084,
-0.3799906373023987,
-0.05767142400145531,
-0.28244903683662415,
0.32655975222587585,
-0.07411178946495056,
0.08252450078725815,
-0.3780163824558258,
-0.26055482029914856,
0.4232356548309326,
-0.26700323820114136,
0.5258414149284363,
-0.12129291146993637,
-0.17313677072525024,
0.2991463243961334,
-0.08914630115032196,
0.31561604142189026,
-0.11885225772857666,
-0.670983612537384,
0.5098066329956055,
-0.018986647948622704,
-0.2943058907985687,
-0.5987919569015503,
0.66771000623703,
-0.5771731734275818,
-0.48833316564559937,
-0.38327351212501526,
-0.488661527633667,
-0.5048766732215881,
0.3719472885131836,
-0.04783308506011963,
0.36647269129753113,
-0.3971734941005707,
0.443629652261734,
0.6454436779022217,
-0.6375100612640381,
0.597356379032135,
0.6479499936103821,
-0.14337559044361115,
-0.20088915526866913,
0.6247581839561462,
0.04794444888830185,
0.5428130626678467,
0.5172919631004333,
0.12817145884037018,
-0.48187437653541565,
-0.7830392122268677,
-0.6686486005783081,
0.19622375071048737,
-0.6297690868377686,
-0.19728560745716095,
-0.8573745489120483,
-0.19231006503105164,
-0.27300968766212463,
0.002961889375001192,
-0.46765655279159546,
-0.45717376470565796,
-0.14489051699638367,
0.05589645355939865,
0.3750518560409546,
0.3889201879501343,
0.33089521527290344,
0.07497451454401016,
-0.834801435470581,
0.5404824614524841,
0.37195831537246704,
1.1229585409164429,
0.3070797026157379,
-0.042136307805776596,
-0.3706682622432709,
-0.0024706691037863493,
-0.32563018798828125,
-0.5928865671157837,
0.045266229659318924,
0.12327183783054352,
0.7311289310455322,
0.15824741125106812,
0.49882423877716064,
0.3505185544490814,
-0.49039411544799805,
0.7873825430870056,
-0.11841476708650589,
-0.7985988259315491,
0.2084658443927765,
-0.1963450163602829,
0.6028186082839966,
0.7451267838478088,
0.5163880586624146,
-0.6605428457260132,
-0.6307856440544128,
-0.13117390871047974,
-1.0581309795379639,
0.7361775636672974,
0.26740550994873047,
-0.22520309686660767,
-0.015032576397061348,
0.13668866455554962,
0.30161064863204956,
0.39700353145599365,
-0.3940971791744232,
-0.18212167918682098,
0.04127127677202225,
-0.25498637557029724,
-0.21948042511940002,
0.039889391511678696,
0.09745950996875763,
0.14698047935962677,
0.8040352463722229,
-0.1253560334444046,
0.19246813654899597,
0.10939377546310425,
-0.20683421194553375,
-0.04910539090633392,
0.47874727845191956,
0.303850919008255,
0.6334976553916931,
-0.5233750939369202,
-0.012355170212686062,
0.2975204885005951,
-0.21461017429828644,
-0.17703504860401154,
0.07062705606222153,
-0.2806888222694397,
0.20459258556365967,
0.17359572649002075,
0.7772753834724426,
0.03146941959857941,
-1.2686500549316406,
0.25146692991256714,
-0.23253151774406433,
-0.031829990446567535,
-0.20563533902168274,
0.15887391567230225,
0.4774118959903717,
0.37327253818511963,
0.2924000918865204,
-0.28696075081825256,
0.3851567208766937,
-0.5455374717712402,
-0.20008255541324615,
0.5644369125366211,
-0.12218349426984787,
-0.0052433558739721775,
0.9715376496315002,
0.15019188821315765,
-0.46866467595100403,
0.5481751561164856,
0.18092383444309235,
-0.08548808842897415,
0.5356853604316711,
0.26854851841926575,
1.3356927633285522,
0.15164195001125336,
0.03169916942715645,
0.20742419362068176,
0.35669487714767456,
-0.037823304533958435,
0.2721921503543854,
0.02136688493192196,
-0.4149099886417389,
-0.6181052923202515,
-0.7830281257629395,
-1.0413758754730225,
0.17244021594524384,
-0.6979967355728149,
-0.00014993356307968497,
-0.49845728278160095,
-0.02874140813946724,
-0.08943686634302139,
-0.14430800080299377,
-0.6432279944419861,
0.1253441721200943,
0.07810179889202118,
1.278560996055603,
-0.6599094271659851,
0.6756114363670349,
0.6202725768089294,
-0.3425159752368927,
-0.5311580300331116,
0.008150208741426468,
-0.39003559947013855,
-0.4965347945690155,
0.1323421597480774,
0.1619991660118103,
-0.3113707900047302,
-0.12826329469680786,
-0.25804758071899414,
-0.7177072167396545,
1.071823000907898,
0.6420130133628845,
-0.5594698190689087,
-0.06100275740027428,
0.405678927898407,
0.7387537956237793,
0.046711891889572144,
0.5498576164245605,
0.5279483199119568,
0.3054580092430115,
-0.19798174500465393,
-0.9085797071456909,
-0.025400640442967415,
-0.3378356397151947,
0.15018656849861145,
0.28094157576560974,
-0.7884793877601624,
0.6378306746482849,
0.3076498508453369,
-0.32191452383995056,
0.24029934406280518,
0.7499958276748657,
0.24741803109645844,
0.5665509104728699,
0.48892492055892944,
0.47071120142936707,
0.5953670144081116,
0.046538468450307846,
0.9903480410575867,
-0.38131895661354065,
0.05338924750685692,
1.1960866451263428,
-0.5646834969520569,
1.2639296054840088,
0.2949562072753906,
-0.26803693175315857,
0.44663864374160767,
0.3006269037723541,
0.21860888600349426,
0.3116796314716339,
0.10080519318580627,
-0.32017290592193604,
-0.057907506823539734,
-0.21905405819416046,
-0.3090473413467407,
0.30016687512397766,
-0.14104719460010529,
-0.16471491754055023,
-0.35883358120918274,
-0.35582828521728516,
-0.17424052953720093,
0.16887657344341278,
-0.3148193061351776,
0.8896960616111755,
0.046643778681755066,
-0.6902807950973511,
0.5720056891441345,
0.12374148517847061,
0.5281996130943298,
-0.7688780426979065,
0.14317630231380463,
-0.3010208308696747,
0.09128068387508392,
0.11764753609895706,
-0.6331183314323425,
0.6091012954711914,
0.44615238904953003,
-0.20476225018501282,
-0.394172340631485,
0.4777846336364746,
-0.15856710076332092,
-0.362202912569046,
0.43460145592689514,
0.5447074174880981,
0.1149006336927414,
-0.21452124416828156,
-0.5494670867919922,
0.14786259829998016,
-0.3645417392253876,
-0.16799022257328033,
0.3246847093105316,
0.37330299615859985,
0.034583400934934616,
0.8115603923797607,
0.5704580545425415,
0.13675622642040253,
0.21925325691699982,
-0.027954837307333946,
0.7780917882919312,
-0.6321616768836975,
-0.39217662811279297,
-0.5124211311340332,
0.3654504418373108,
-0.07710754871368408,
-0.17805317044258118,
0.7997755408287048,
0.9094988703727722,
0.9515935778617859,
-0.10029992461204529,
0.8650855422019958,
0.16695773601531982,
0.9484378099441528,
-0.5416916608810425,
0.5996358394622803,
-0.6632674932479858,
0.2737228274345398,
-0.3160709738731384,
-1.045676589012146,
-0.15190233290195465,
0.16376818716526031,
-0.22190938889980316,
-0.11648250371217728,
0.6206003427505493,
0.775428056716919,
-0.13267302513122559,
0.1606643795967102,
0.31772544980049133,
0.24105441570281982,
0.2583999037742615,
0.4398360252380371,
0.6401119828224182,
-0.08711828291416168,
0.7070613503456116,
-0.264528751373291,
-0.0936451107263565,
-0.19847078621387482,
-1.2106908559799194,
-0.5657941699028015,
-0.32216647267341614,
-0.13536851108074188,
-0.05865272507071495,
0.07956479489803314,
0.9649107456207275,
0.3599349856376648,
-0.8014702796936035,
-0.40427857637405396,
0.09018315374851227,
0.07445284724235535,
-0.5782457590103149,
-0.15356478095054626,
0.20101669430732727,
-0.26998549699783325,
-0.8319208025932312,
0.5286132097244263,
0.2710556387901306,
-0.40733805298805237,
-0.2927404046058655,
0.21750667691230774,
-0.2243572324514389,
0.41181424260139465,
0.6166186332702637,
0.4954881966114044,
-0.5164318680763245,
-0.09836665540933609,
0.3091951310634613,
0.04280688241124153,
0.17268554866313934,
0.8440257906913757,
-0.6056499481201172,
0.38078072667121887,
0.8257663249969482,
1.1189415454864502,
0.17432856559753418,
0.20430712401866913,
0.6453900337219238,
-0.6608803272247314,
0.0632232129573822,
0.392514705657959,
0.16197367012500763,
0.3566758334636688,
0.06255697458982468,
0.6201084852218628,
-0.04570484533905983,
-0.5878064632415771,
-0.9919663667678833,
0.12177985906600952,
-0.7596845030784607,
-0.6155067086219788,
1.0004992485046387,
-0.0761551707983017,
-0.40892502665519714,
-0.19771946966648102,
-0.01783071458339691,
0.24292723834514618,
-0.2548254430294037,
0.510237991809845,
0.4457368552684784,
0.015027481131255627,
-0.09901033341884613,
-0.9565712213516235,
0.06743542104959488,
0.3630841076374054,
-0.8971698880195618,
0.37379491329193115,
0.5206713080406189,
0.12476193904876709,
-0.19526435434818268,
0.6669139266014099,
-0.03313707187771797,
0.17743626236915588,
-0.09051071107387543,
0.34694036841392517,
-0.07930923253297806,
-0.10477903485298157,
-0.37940219044685364,
0.470975786447525,
0.5877891778945923,
-0.2866021692752838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13706v1 | Breaking News: Case Studies of Generative AI's Use in Journalism | 2024-06-19T16:58:32 | 2024-06-19T16:58:32 | Natalie Grace Brigham, Chongjiu Gao, Tadayoshi Kohno, Franziska Roesner, Niloofar Mireshghallah | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Journalists are among the many users of large language models (LLMs). To
better understand the journalist-AI interactions, we conduct a study of LLM
usage by two news agencies through browsing the WildChat dataset, identifying
candidate interactions, and verifying them by matching to online published
articles. Our analysis uncovers instances where journalists provide sensitive
material such as confidential correspondence with sources or articles from
other agencies to the LLM as stimuli and prompt it to generate articles, and
publish these machine-generated articles with limited intervention (median
output-publication ROUGE-L of 0.62). Based on our findings, we call for further
research into what constitutes responsible use of AI, and the establishment of
clear guidelines and best practices on using LLMs in a journalistic context. | [
-0.07414556294679642,
-0.7905426025390625,
0.6417840719223022,
0.41513070464134216,
-0.2212739884853363,
-0.07464274764060974,
-0.22061510384082794,
-0.7244876623153687,
0.08193206042051315,
0.5618481040000916,
-0.4716145992279053,
-0.38220345973968506,
-0.5034762024879456,
0.3563299775123596,
-0.9595248103141785,
1.1191428899765015,
-0.11175941675901413,
0.1650576889514923,
-0.3044770061969757,
-0.2686372697353363,
-0.2898765504360199,
-0.6359075903892517,
-0.49041083455085754,
-0.20592042803764343,
0.8406877517700195,
0.20910952985286713,
0.8219176530838013,
0.48670125007629395,
0.6288139224052429,
0.3225392997264862,
-0.1568130999803543,
0.06183258071541786,
-0.589933454990387,
0.10358811169862747,
-0.14429974555969238,
-0.5435745120048523,
-0.14391371607780457,
0.32376614212989807,
0.38672399520874023,
0.43118706345558167,
0.03560870885848999,
0.2587447762489319,
-0.16036094725131989,
0.6021965742111206,
-0.3317627012729645,
-0.059485334903001785,
-0.378843754529953,
0.1952943354845047,
-0.2863043546676636,
-0.16510435938835144,
-0.4217425584793091,
-0.4071533977985382,
-0.21451587975025177,
-0.5492638349533081,
0.26697567105293274,
-0.1816520094871521,
0.7931957840919495,
0.3513164520263672,
-0.693766176700592,
-0.49350428581237793,
-1.016522765159607,
0.3383263051509857,
-0.6825236678123474,
0.13880705833435059,
0.5883445143699646,
0.07273414731025696,
-0.04117632284760475,
-0.670470118522644,
-0.6303053498268127,
-0.35610508918762207,
-0.17604279518127441,
0.17204417288303375,
-0.2079295814037323,
-0.011921372264623642,
0.33864840865135193,
0.28910455107688904,
-0.46693500876426697,
0.47094598412513733,
-0.6756682395935059,
0.015108258463442326,
0.8854381442070007,
0.23640049993991852,
0.3291032910346985,
0.03340258449316025,
-0.05061030015349388,
0.13255755603313446,
-0.9032910466194153,
-0.3280137777328491,
0.6526191234588623,
0.06176760047674179,
-0.25166189670562744,
0.8635088801383972,
-0.04498552158474922,
0.7041794657707214,
-0.2980431020259857,
0.09191112965345383,
0.2977566719055176,
-0.4591640532016754,
-0.2310928851366043,
0.033249564468860626,
0.8385080099105835,
0.5526224970817566,
0.4169786870479584,
-0.04731282964348793,
-0.18177717924118042,
-0.014719847589731216,
0.519065260887146,
-0.6071525812149048,
0.1133914664387703,
-0.021728934720158577,
-0.4077227711677551,
-0.7546424865722656,
-0.007360935211181641,
-0.60499107837677,
-0.5917422771453857,
-0.2588508129119873,
0.04036236181855202,
0.19984611868858337,
-0.2922593951225281,
-0.14228592813014984,
-0.30557116866111755,
0.31533706188201904,
0.08457517623901367,
-0.5703744888305664,
-0.10380803048610687,
0.49741798639297485,
0.7074986100196838,
0.018719373270869255,
-0.35833311080932617,
-0.43780556321144104,
0.22866296768188477,
-0.6200169324874878,
0.6312078833580017,
-0.26451098918914795,
-0.3052748441696167,
0.5002233386039734,
-0.3026861846446991,
0.3228188157081604,
-0.5922689437866211,
0.5240326523780823,
-0.6821734309196472,
-0.01227454375475645,
-0.04985043779015541,
-0.4089922308921814,
0.17812618613243103,
0.23360291123390198,
-0.8786593675613403,
0.7402496337890625,
0.023062551394104958,
-0.6305143237113953,
0.5360181331634521,
-0.4180589020252228,
-0.6282719373703003,
0.02803236059844494,
-0.28834453225135803,
-0.6115688681602478,
0.3051716089248657,
0.12783613801002502,
0.5043073296546936,
0.08884643763303757,
0.4744822680950165,
0.0463256873190403,
-0.25615230202674866,
0.6339097023010254,
-0.5824699401855469,
0.5978603363037109,
0.16661526262760162,
-0.05890588089823723,
0.25374364852905273,
-0.5299200415611267,
-0.6739250421524048,
0.13231366872787476,
-0.6794259548187256,
-0.3858417272567749,
-0.13092823326587677,
0.22291193902492523,
0.035908326506614685,
-0.1694212704896927,
-0.3004871904850006,
0.2033889889717102,
0.040459416806697845,
0.5034186840057373,
0.5368314385414124,
0.03278627619147301,
0.3795141875743866,
-0.4779905080795288,
0.4641195237636566,
0.009133799001574516,
0.056763168424367905,
-0.45784860849380493,
-0.3081055283546448,
-0.7502403259277344,
-0.08026747405529022,
0.26902100443840027,
0.3342248201370239,
-0.6578702330589294,
0.11718611419200897,
0.10086656361818314,
-0.3878028392791748,
-0.6267414689064026,
0.15598689019680023,
0.04056659713387489,
0.28544965386390686,
-0.05467632785439491,
0.07163947820663452,
-0.4843657314777374,
-0.8049705624580383,
-0.5750311017036438,
-0.0983816385269165,
-0.0031145198736339808,
0.4405992925167084,
0.11192011088132858,
-0.36680683493614197,
1.1169557571411133,
-0.009381222538650036,
-0.18759706616401672,
-0.28908705711364746,
0.537129282951355,
0.09772104769945145,
0.22085128724575043,
0.6415298581123352,
-1.10203218460083,
-0.3577919602394104,
-0.5012563467025757,
-1.1544716358184814,
-0.2636605501174927,
-0.6835346221923828,
0.08685488998889923,
0.4212334156036377,
0.9124600887298584,
-0.9269486665725708,
0.6624914407730103,
0.6005579829216003,
-0.37287747859954834,
0.5081886053085327,
0.08599638938903809,
0.01523486990481615,
-0.8390201330184937,
-0.045793771743774414,
0.24528393149375916,
-0.535462498664856,
-0.7380658388137817,
0.15382295846939087,
-0.10148710757493973,
-0.26566454768180847,
-0.6161693930625916,
0.29679545760154724,
-0.6691130995750427,
-0.12500876188278198,
-0.36940211057662964,
0.16381807625293732,
-0.18615788221359253,
-0.12835411727428436,
-0.010401676408946514,
0.8197392821311951,
0.4090675413608551,
-0.4230232536792755,
0.4525805413722992,
0.27010002732276917,
-0.45043468475341797,
0.15937520563602448,
-0.5566728711128235,
0.26360711455345154,
-0.3056469261646271,
0.26763880252838135,
-0.5633817315101624,
-0.2676782011985779,
0.15529727935791016,
-0.3436283469200134,
0.08581908047199249,
0.0383787602186203,
-0.9381516575813293,
-0.2708183228969574,
-0.26232194900512695,
0.41777387261390686,
0.36223727464675903,
-0.34427735209465027,
0.4254283010959625,
0.47069984674453735,
-0.39915597438812256,
-0.20448391139507294,
-1.1580102443695068,
0.6201748251914978,
-0.3417965769767761,
-0.39614373445510864,
-0.03393850103020668,
0.023677997291088104,
-0.5146604180335999,
0.22764793038368225,
0.13706162571907043,
-0.07723986357450485,
0.21132653951644897,
0.1878766417503357,
0.2619169056415558,
-0.22306258976459503,
0.07838603854179382,
-0.06050246208906174,
0.1313505619764328,
0.2864748239517212,
0.5840012431144714,
0.5054581165313721,
0.17176486551761627,
-0.2676512897014618,
-0.5419017672538757,
0.660801887512207,
0.572269082069397,
-0.14813482761383057,
0.7671384215354919,
0.5570055842399597,
-0.11596311628818512,
-0.07594547420740128,
-0.4972846806049347,
-0.3552454113960266,
-0.4586404860019684,
0.409579336643219,
0.2536557912826538,
-0.8741607069969177,
0.32528844475746155,
-0.04615171626210213,
0.01725871115922928,
0.41051462292671204,
0.7235956788063049,
-0.027133682742714882,
0.8168677091598511,
0.8692991137504578,
-0.6285165548324585,
0.5746367573738098,
-0.019246377050876617,
0.3323488235473633,
-0.39406031370162964,
-0.33519962430000305,
-0.45908790826797485,
-0.11850529164075851,
-0.7740035057067871,
-0.05330553278326988,
0.39015448093414307,
-0.013746298849582672,
0.046038925647735596,
0.05259457603096962,
-0.27871987223625183,
0.5526771545410156,
0.544264554977417,
-0.21986445784568787,
0.5729964971542358,
-0.1568252295255661,
0.4094344973564148,
0.32745835185050964,
-0.6405048966407776,
-0.5333840847015381,
0.8226453065872192,
0.4337019622325897,
1.0569156408309937,
0.050450485199689865,
0.6663632392883301,
0.5864753723144531,
0.675287127494812,
-0.8926341533660889,
0.5413951277732849,
0.19010791182518005,
-0.6417154669761658,
-0.15614287555217743,
-0.4121180772781372,
-0.9333959221839905,
-0.019069727510213852,
-0.17515750229358673,
-0.36940819025039673,
-0.051728446036577225,
-0.11973202228546143,
-0.18860267102718353,
-0.005635452456772327,
-0.4277040362358093,
0.28135114908218384,
-0.18852901458740234,
-0.000042004219722002745,
-0.4251021146774292,
-0.5247142314910889,
0.45908546447753906,
0.008902709931135178,
0.32882407307624817,
-0.015401412732899189,
0.08896294236183167,
0.5403667688369751,
-0.02887825295329094,
1.183513879776001,
0.24871592223644257,
-0.11349964886903763,
0.3070286512374878,
-0.18969111144542694,
0.4707433581352234,
0.2526108920574188,
0.08080235868692398,
0.3676195740699768,
-0.399304062128067,
-0.03243168815970421,
-0.03360342979431152,
0.4967045485973358,
-0.917759120464325,
-0.8051353096961975,
-0.8427416682243347,
-0.9050166606903076,
-0.037259913980960846,
0.24121543765068054,
0.3225628733634949,
0.19405654072761536,
-0.3783593475818634,
0.26682233810424805,
0.3076004683971405,
0.05842418223619461,
0.6047645211219788,
0.7090110778808594,
-0.2155996710062027,
0.012506671249866486,
0.6094759702682495,
0.2026391476392746,
-0.09332670271396637,
-0.01970367133617401,
0.09531476348638535,
0.27063196897506714,
-0.5624226331710815,
-0.5418917536735535,
0.28453460335731506,
-0.3533709943294525,
-0.4041818678379059,
-0.4101793169975281,
-0.666967511177063,
-0.32751113176345825,
-0.18526875972747803,
-0.026638152077794075,
-0.13298368453979492,
-0.6187824606895447,
-0.38175761699676514,
0.2850019633769989,
0.8931467533111572,
-0.07084499299526215,
0.26949262619018555,
-0.9510350823402405,
0.5115246176719666,
0.1919587403535843,
-0.00039738795021548867,
-0.4025637209415436,
-0.020171476528048515,
-0.4075901210308075,
-0.03239579498767853,
-0.3083896338939667,
-1.0660805702209473,
0.36792752146720886,
-0.011673243716359138,
0.6436597108840942,
0.35047680139541626,
0.12544402480125427,
0.0028612532187253237,
-0.47253572940826416,
0.9302278161048889,
-0.12286563217639923,
-0.6975976228713989,
0.37648287415504456,
-0.7488789558410645,
0.12409374117851257,
0.4032087028026581,
0.5113924145698547,
-0.5413444638252258,
-0.8642001152038574,
-0.5524114966392517,
-0.9598985910415649,
0.4325844645500183,
0.18360845744609833,
0.7281436920166016,
0.04516495391726494,
0.42935439944267273,
-0.0038390420377254486,
0.5960174202919006,
-0.784586489200592,
-0.18636123836040497,
0.06109018996357918,
-0.1920839250087738,
0.08115021139383316,
-0.6793827414512634,
-0.4492071866989136,
0.031767841428518295,
0.4834880828857422,
0.03093656711280346,
0.11591444909572601,
0.14962096512317657,
-0.15295670926570892,
-0.26733699440956116,
0.0596252903342247,
0.5428858995437622,
0.7973108887672424,
0.2860216498374939,
0.11747390776872635,
-0.30730026960372925,
-0.4242454469203949,
-0.09866160899400711,
0.18655341863632202,
-0.42924976348876953,
0.17707930505275726,
0.47183945775032043,
0.5333773493766785,
-0.2593454420566559,
-0.8722063899040222,
0.6579370498657227,
-0.05019931122660637,
-0.17715150117874146,
-0.6188934445381165,
0.027210067957639694,
0.1397649347782135,
0.4165519177913666,
0.4318586587905884,
-0.11759670078754425,
0.27547526359558105,
-0.8936626315116882,
0.10180105268955231,
0.3708619177341461,
-0.08932248502969742,
-0.18991591036319733,
0.4283154010772705,
0.40093711018562317,
-0.3987232744693756,
0.9408286809921265,
-0.014643233269453049,
-0.38997071981430054,
0.7746331691741943,
0.5282636284828186,
0.6529061198234558,
-0.02195127122104168,
0.5343782305717468,
-0.3150707185268402,
0.4251839816570282,
-0.12659865617752075,
0.10376466065645218,
0.1773962676525116,
-0.8966683745384216,
-0.38703662157058716,
-0.14177900552749634,
-0.42860835790634155,
0.3436718285083771,
-0.7214648127555847,
0.15495581924915314,
-0.2563023269176483,
-0.11222972720861435,
0.1884640008211136,
-0.20407550036907196,
-0.6562304496765137,
-0.041421566158533096,
0.40762531757354736,
0.8695679306983948,
-1.15541672706604,
0.5351701974868774,
0.5302238464355469,
-0.5914627909660339,
-0.5412910580635071,
0.34030646085739136,
0.30044814944267273,
-0.7811251878738403,
0.3408922553062439,
0.161729633808136,
0.29941198229789734,
-0.2695135772228241,
-0.7929382920265198,
-0.32412275671958923,
0.8928202390670776,
0.48805853724479675,
-0.6375036835670471,
0.05376695469021797,
0.4800095856189728,
0.557862401008606,
-0.2563166618347168,
-0.0006634396850131452,
0.6126022934913635,
0.441150039434433,
-0.23373739421367645,
-0.7417930364608765,
0.008031023666262627,
-0.20905081927776337,
-0.17500607669353485,
0.0224145594984293,
-1.1452456712722778,
0.6680700182914734,
-0.2505311965942383,
-0.052251216024160385,
0.17048336565494537,
0.6899518370628357,
0.07042645663022995,
0.744902491569519,
0.1983911097049713,
0.39982402324676514,
0.5870609283447266,
0.2817952036857605,
1.0568599700927734,
0.008609233424067497,
0.09967482089996338,
0.8768224120140076,
-0.2632303535938263,
0.4299282431602478,
0.49872782826423645,
0.24424831569194794,
0.3032650649547577,
0.5514822006225586,
-0.5252237319946289,
0.5617986917495728,
0.29700416326522827,
-0.44823455810546875,
0.18768998980522156,
-0.5857217311859131,
-0.1279064118862152,
0.4580141603946686,
0.2580384314060211,
-0.6581123471260071,
-0.08651602268218994,
0.18477609753608704,
0.3680027723312378,
0.11719398200511932,
-0.3607809245586395,
1.0576437711715698,
0.26370319724082947,
-0.3636614978313446,
-0.06261973828077316,
0.19652004539966583,
0.4001010060310364,
-0.2123245894908905,
-0.05926697701215744,
-0.34544554352760315,
-0.1752844601869583,
-0.2532276213169098,
-0.8212947845458984,
0.6015444397926331,
0.4253259599208832,
-0.26462844014167786,
-0.20380884408950806,
0.8206430673599243,
-0.49357303977012634,
-0.5929067730903625,
0.040805622935295105,
0.6864742040634155,
0.19519446790218353,
-0.11183387786149979,
-0.2393670678138733,
0.37614625692367554,
-0.34601980447769165,
-0.5461236834526062,
0.44005656242370605,
0.3644711375236511,
-0.0982806384563446,
0.39501744508743286,
0.644773542881012,
0.3473057448863983,
-0.07154887169599533,
0.4671143889427185,
1.207234263420105,
-0.5445836186408997,
-0.28297150135040283,
-0.9472087621688843,
0.300575315952301,
-0.26608696579933167,
-0.44933637976646423,
0.7554776668548584,
0.6603014469146729,
0.7242815494537354,
0.1419258564710617,
1.073499083518982,
0.09763164073228836,
0.13003219664096832,
-0.6849225163459778,
0.8566065430641174,
-0.09686344116926193,
0.09745772927999496,
0.1487499624490738,
-0.7839370369911194,
-0.31584432721138,
0.358146071434021,
0.003348602680489421,
0.01155148446559906,
0.36155807971954346,
0.672788143157959,
0.1454005241394043,
0.014429362490773201,
0.3388817012310028,
0.34679529070854187,
0.3050015866756439,
-0.03109610639512539,
0.995625913143158,
0.09421830624341965,
0.4591328501701355,
-0.06918679177761078,
-0.18010880053043365,
-0.3396170437335968,
-0.9436516761779785,
-1.1078143119812012,
-0.36259499192237854,
-0.26735666394233704,
-0.10119227319955826,
0.3120509684085846,
0.5768066644668579,
0.49716129899024963,
-0.2780836820602417,
-0.03144274279475212,
-0.1968703716993332,
0.06520070135593414,
-0.08732476830482483,
-0.24652919173240662,
0.08506529778242111,
-0.2656085789203644,
-0.6735727787017822,
0.40448418259620667,
-0.07338425517082214,
-0.041316885501146317,
-0.5772286057472229,
0.26811614632606506,
-0.0293731689453125,
0.23531630635261536,
0.47676175832748413,
0.22288835048675537,
-0.2937621772289276,
-0.18998292088508606,
-0.17977111041545868,
-0.2883528172969818,
-0.04948859661817551,
1.2155091762542725,
-0.6410998106002808,
0.022313054651021957,
0.41439932584762573,
0.7391138076782227,
0.7224628925323486,
0.017931897193193436,
0.5660625696182251,
-0.7547063231468201,
0.28317156434059143,
0.47494828701019287,
0.06085922196507454,
0.5089489221572876,
-0.7870282530784607,
0.39551204442977905,
0.0986231192946434,
-0.7649387121200562,
-0.9294336438179016,
0.01902846433222294,
-0.6787096858024597,
-0.1566409468650818,
1.4140877723693848,
0.014499552547931671,
-0.02407059632241726,
0.024731464684009552,
-0.02754938043653965,
0.2712363302707672,
-0.5553321242332458,
0.9711219072341919,
0.6089968681335449,
-0.12732888758182526,
-0.5172571539878845,
-0.940527081489563,
0.37647590041160583,
-0.025840554386377335,
-0.8976813554763794,
-0.11769170314073563,
0.666321337223053,
0.16700442135334015,
-0.034560367465019226,
0.5993770360946655,
0.03677380457520485,
0.0664258822798729,
-0.07797045260667801,
-0.2676880657672882,
-0.2956606447696686,
-0.4732697904109955,
-0.2883017063140869,
-0.12655124068260193,
0.01904289796948433,
-0.01161960605531931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13698v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13698v1 | MMTE: Corpus and Metrics for Evaluating Machine Translation Quality of Metaphorical Language | 2024-06-19T16:52:22 | 2024-06-19T16:52:22 | Shun Wang, Ge Zhang, Han Wu, Tyler Loakman, Wenhao Huang, Chenghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine Translation (MT) has developed rapidly since the release of Large
Language Models and current MT evaluation is performed through comparison with
reference human translations or by predicting quality scores from human-labeled
data. However, these mainstream evaluation methods mainly focus on fluency and
factual reliability, whilst paying little attention to figurative quality. In
this paper, we investigate the figurative quality of MT and propose a set of
human evaluation metrics focused on the translation of figurative language. We
additionally present a multilingual parallel metaphor corpus generated by
post-editing. Our evaluation protocol is designed to estimate four aspects of
MT: Metaphorical Equivalence, Emotion, Authenticity, and Quality. In doing so,
we observe that translations of figurative expressions display different traits
from literal ones. | [
-0.27474188804626465,
-0.5002624988555908,
0.530716598033905,
0.4707518219947815,
-0.5438901782035828,
0.3445225656032562,
-0.19716089963912964,
-0.5879671573638916,
0.445529580116272,
0.18464432656764984,
-0.4313323497772217,
-0.45619040727615356,
-0.8863089680671692,
0.5847211480140686,
-0.4294394850730896,
0.9012876749038696,
-0.162610724568367,
0.19835758209228516,
-0.2330094575881958,
-0.48124536871910095,
-0.6673700213432312,
-0.6287828683853149,
-0.5333066582679749,
-0.05412508547306061,
0.6378828287124634,
-0.11829310655593872,
1.2877576351165771,
0.7977553009986877,
0.7285330295562744,
0.41019976139068604,
0.3521697223186493,
0.26194655895233154,
-0.2520892918109894,
-0.21237024664878845,
-0.1784951537847519,
-0.472896546125412,
-0.5632154941558838,
0.5631797909736633,
0.9568141102790833,
0.5166464447975159,
0.06112253665924072,
0.2977410554885864,
-0.02701474167406559,
0.49586090445518494,
-0.35745933651924133,
0.14563269913196564,
-0.6398903131484985,
0.08309690654277802,
-0.1687706708908081,
-0.5391262173652649,
-0.436789870262146,
-0.41959547996520996,
-0.26829972863197327,
-0.5033069849014282,
0.010066932998597622,
0.2524108588695526,
1.0815247297286987,
0.5828912258148193,
-0.43629491329193115,
-0.2104058414697647,
-0.3317156434059143,
1.1039022207260132,
-0.5637356638908386,
0.5458930134773254,
0.35205191373825073,
0.5875812768936157,
0.16714371740818024,
-0.7490031123161316,
-0.5591112971305847,
-0.5764169692993164,
-0.41446301341056824,
0.39088213443756104,
-0.3207033574581146,
-0.2854430079460144,
-0.033492255955934525,
0.36369752883911133,
-0.6290643811225891,
-0.07343659549951553,
-0.24289149045944214,
-0.3811522424221039,
0.5007040500640869,
0.4049181044101715,
0.5790886878967285,
-0.265534371137619,
-0.5378587245941162,
-0.20257215201854706,
-0.5201300978660583,
-0.3835940361022949,
0.46869707107543945,
-0.07064531743526459,
-0.12049021571874619,
0.6877115964889526,
0.13037432730197906,
0.6518937945365906,
-0.6513007879257202,
-0.39361050724983215,
0.6800475716590881,
-0.5692914128303528,
-0.2559650242328644,
-0.06997621059417725,
0.9612034559249878,
0.7022777795791626,
0.17620278894901276,
-0.45364806056022644,
-0.48484960198402405,
0.5523743033409119,
0.433865487575531,
-0.7618188858032227,
0.31379827857017517,
0.12294131517410278,
-0.6140148043632507,
-0.41245532035827637,
0.11013857275247574,
-0.4283539652824402,
-0.12541866302490234,
-0.6083934307098389,
0.3924771845340729,
-0.6675012707710266,
-0.0657876655459404,
0.18199093639850616,
-0.23606190085411072,
-0.3115612864494324,
0.40480777621269226,
-0.2437373697757721,
0.06283584237098694,
0.5310791730880737,
1.0177911520004272,
-0.2301332950592041,
-0.7310002446174622,
-0.48668980598449707,
0.03410844877362251,
-0.3910960853099823,
0.6239206790924072,
-0.3817826807498932,
-0.03378134220838547,
-0.3150283694267273,
-0.12038954347372055,
-0.42709845304489136,
-0.44752734899520874,
1.066480040550232,
-0.42413437366485596,
0.20065583288669586,
-0.12593060731887817,
-0.36786317825317383,
-0.22977815568447113,
0.40021654963493347,
-0.6386475563049316,
0.8342317342758179,
0.2525067925453186,
-0.9369418025016785,
0.262469619512558,
-0.7374374866485596,
-0.19394566118717194,
-0.08983209729194641,
-0.04722693935036659,
0.1663891226053238,
0.39575788378715515,
0.049590323120355606,
0.3826887309551239,
-0.6908673644065857,
0.2739420533180237,
-0.03388321027159691,
-0.32371747493743896,
0.6734097003936768,
-0.4534088969230652,
0.629660427570343,
0.626372754573822,
0.02827513962984085,
0.38543277978897095,
-0.46546661853790283,
0.0692182332277298,
0.06358214467763901,
0.005509093403816223,
-0.2661716341972351,
-0.2593814730644226,
0.4227987229824066,
0.7100721001625061,
0.3195103406906128,
-0.5778767466545105,
-0.26910167932510376,
-0.3082585036754608,
0.5882391929626465,
0.4443061053752899,
-0.1953149288892746,
0.025907915085554123,
-0.37539494037628174,
0.5729852914810181,
0.13419264554977417,
0.08149097114801407,
0.04636786878108978,
-0.4761936068534851,
-0.5133307576179504,
-0.5841711163520813,
0.7416580319404602,
0.6022517681121826,
-0.7764644026756287,
0.44463157653808594,
-0.616524875164032,
-0.6071382164955139,
-1.0141862630844116,
-0.09014776349067688,
0.5863666534423828,
0.4075779914855957,
0.42283502221107483,
-0.5334112048149109,
-0.22854357957839966,
-1.1354037523269653,
-0.4198259711265564,
-0.23259344696998596,
-0.21542710065841675,
-0.01037862990051508,
0.4722502827644348,
-0.39685067534446716,
0.6273954510688782,
-0.19063670933246613,
-0.2819507420063019,
0.04818681627511978,
0.6112856864929199,
0.005169244948774576,
0.5138635635375977,
0.9496367573738098,
-0.6057868003845215,
-0.10144112259149551,
-0.032634276896715164,
-1.0573575496673584,
-0.20198741555213928,
-0.2659246325492859,
-0.44428300857543945,
0.01631045714020729,
0.2606222331523895,
-0.8095312118530273,
0.051070451736450195,
0.8199370503425598,
-0.36109423637390137,
0.9890062808990479,
-0.17398200929164886,
0.7795094847679138,
-1.1409879922866821,
0.08280335366725922,
-0.003908134065568447,
-0.2459881603717804,
-0.21201744675636292,
0.4022008180618286,
0.028748322278261185,
0.06898260861635208,
-0.709601640701294,
0.6816344261169434,
-0.2879363000392914,
-0.241718590259552,
-0.09697182476520538,
0.3721292316913605,
0.023678448051214218,
-0.07206378132104874,
-0.05894937366247177,
1.0193586349487305,
0.20706038177013397,
-0.14448554813861847,
0.35430774092674255,
0.04484894871711731,
-0.2690609395503998,
1.0298699140548706,
-0.6157376170158386,
0.021181924268603325,
0.027557311579585075,
0.09020163118839264,
-0.7460936903953552,
-0.0583973228931427,
0.1312231421470642,
-0.7064467668533325,
0.17553266882896423,
0.25065311789512634,
-1.3216383457183838,
-0.20510274171829224,
-0.1401103436946869,
0.46157073974609375,
0.4410763680934906,
-0.18021884560585022,
0.1816059947013855,
0.18443113565444946,
0.19286251068115234,
-0.5681881308555603,
-0.7088598012924194,
0.5367158055305481,
-0.3588680028915405,
-0.894071102142334,
0.31450527906417847,
-0.2040359228849411,
-0.1628033071756363,
0.09419206529855728,
0.02803613804280758,
-0.24992156028747559,
0.027913669124245644,
-0.09651089459657669,
0.08710618317127228,
-0.4638863205909729,
-0.09234938770532608,
0.27011606097221375,
-0.44720640778541565,
0.19566211104393005,
-0.03863823041319847,
0.3449503481388092,
-0.45253193378448486,
-0.28949204087257385,
-0.6083038449287415,
0.20737119019031525,
0.9893190264701843,
-0.33662548661231995,
0.8874201774597168,
0.9836868643760681,
-0.5988989472389221,
0.575485348701477,
-0.6326940059661865,
-0.18648697435855865,
-0.3431619107723236,
0.2600249946117401,
-0.8067747950553894,
-0.7464405298233032,
0.44984856247901917,
-0.07191265374422073,
-0.09401998668909073,
0.8059293627738953,
0.6129770278930664,
-0.17315208911895752,
0.9745216369628906,
0.3043357729911804,
0.033675383776426315,
-0.06306113302707672,
0.23856692016124725,
-0.02218662016093731,
-0.6480491161346436,
0.16685709357261658,
-0.7084591388702393,
-0.4702589213848114,
-0.45931586623191833,
-0.7125304937362671,
0.20051226019859314,
0.3176961839199066,
-0.05970181152224541,
0.6704303622245789,
-0.2608506977558136,
0.2659791111946106,
0.30140116810798645,
-0.13787470757961273,
0.5948758125305176,
0.053386278450489044,
-0.3708060085773468,
-0.5901689529418945,
-0.41223832964897156,
-1.127646565437317,
0.7151090502738953,
0.5341246724128723,
0.03375592827796936,
0.09424534440040588,
0.4343779683113098,
0.3124312460422516,
0.777116596698761,
-0.665828287601471,
0.42290621995925903,
0.0437699630856514,
-0.6313404440879822,
-0.08501783758401871,
-0.7093797922134399,
-0.8049896359443665,
0.5902518630027771,
-0.28593379259109497,
-0.7291612029075623,
-0.3071362376213074,
-0.022837193682789803,
0.20670150220394135,
0.08763054013252258,
-0.6259379386901855,
1.3110377788543701,
-0.3562716245651245,
0.04103981330990791,
-0.6685308814048767,
-0.8653361201286316,
0.5474152565002441,
-0.32655540108680725,
0.3071889579296112,
-0.36865922808647156,
-0.3937298059463501,
0.6352993845939636,
-0.1418943852186203,
0.35247376561164856,
0.2133921980857849,
0.28061753511428833,
0.15928472578525543,
0.4395182430744171,
0.14685943722724915,
-0.05421820655465126,
-0.3111158311367035,
0.6196507811546326,
0.42358699440956116,
-0.5460848808288574,
-0.7653326392173767,
0.5950256586074829,
-0.8666635155677795,
-0.13663995265960693,
-0.40491771697998047,
-0.8400658965110779,
-0.2961304783821106,
0.20540431141853333,
0.24730296432971954,
-0.005165735725313425,
-0.390924870967865,
0.05293212831020355,
-0.12199005484580994,
-0.33799952268600464,
0.1825762242078781,
0.215328648686409,
-0.026434950530529022,
-0.546002209186554,
0.9934407472610474,
0.03415333107113838,
0.28351762890815735,
0.36408543586730957,
0.21355819702148438,
-0.6130589842796326,
-0.269913911819458,
-1.008668065071106,
0.532131552696228,
-0.6707849502563477,
-0.3215349018573761,
-0.6538127064704895,
-0.142069473862648,
0.12877701222896576,
-0.19155150651931763,
-0.6364953517913818,
-0.46236735582351685,
-0.046734243631362915,
-0.03636772185564041,
0.16605816781520844,
0.30347755551338196,
0.21626299619674683,
0.3402861952781677,
-1.0566484928131104,
0.21997322142124176,
-0.40134647488594055,
0.14221343398094177,
-0.3307235538959503,
-0.6129611134529114,
-0.2013813853263855,
0.1520598828792572,
-0.23508210480213165,
-0.948948323726654,
0.5476731061935425,
-0.152812659740448,
0.41601288318634033,
0.36354297399520874,
-0.15692514181137085,
0.6916360855102539,
-0.7158145904541016,
0.6308009028434753,
0.6550840139389038,
-1.0453237295150757,
0.223289355635643,
-0.3385879695415497,
-0.1523481011390686,
0.5373309850692749,
0.43317899107933044,
-0.6521154046058655,
-0.6220830082893372,
-0.6983704566955566,
-0.2396552562713623,
0.3178600072860718,
0.7056990265846252,
0.2871350944042206,
-0.11332108825445175,
0.00024231256975326687,
0.15574805438518524,
0.6432812809944153,
-0.5130438208580017,
-0.28226062655448914,
-0.364612877368927,
-0.29619932174682617,
-0.4447826147079468,
-0.11238864809274673,
-0.1824161857366562,
-0.2735978364944458,
0.23282362520694733,
0.1390974521636963,
0.382325142621994,
-0.16776886582374573,
-0.4508269429206848,
0.16608452796936035,
0.3475131392478943,
0.7177047729492188,
0.8834743499755859,
-0.27510932087898254,
0.25180864334106445,
0.08006385713815689,
-0.2995529770851135,
0.12650851905345917,
-0.06489107012748718,
0.020251251757144928,
0.4398825764656067,
0.1926395297050476,
0.47480371594429016,
0.09678937494754791,
-0.6183398365974426,
0.4762836694717407,
0.1520491987466812,
0.04128296300768852,
-0.07464176416397095,
-0.4428673982620239,
0.19951792061328888,
-0.0693732425570488,
-0.05090675875544548,
0.3231589198112488,
0.35649770498275757,
-0.4099518358707428,
0.15811066329479218,
0.1323593556880951,
-0.5679509043693542,
-0.4592464566230774,
0.7406091094017029,
0.08309664577245712,
-0.11141429096460342,
0.6208580732345581,
-0.4162340462207794,
-0.27961158752441406,
0.32947978377342224,
0.6296986937522888,
0.8712431192398071,
-0.31796950101852417,
0.20999951660633087,
0.4231875240802765,
1.00282883644104,
0.12026285380125046,
0.13717328011989594,
0.5623992681503296,
-0.5767606496810913,
-0.6290664672851562,
-0.9573515057563782,
-0.1756681203842163,
-0.10780858993530273,
-0.36141037940979004,
0.2976306676864624,
0.020612606778740883,
-0.3077159523963928,
-0.058312512934207916,
-0.44213923811912537,
-0.8007155656814575,
0.44338831305503845,
-0.19203856587409973,
0.884924590587616,
-1.006225824356079,
0.9875277280807495,
0.8620325922966003,
-0.797450840473175,
-0.6122323870658875,
-0.32467955350875854,
0.020989125594496727,
-0.5737359523773193,
0.8231063485145569,
0.23801472783088684,
-0.37823736667633057,
0.09298165142536163,
-0.013609157875180244,
-0.6346248984336853,
0.8723081350326538,
0.9350646734237671,
0.0034155116882175207,
0.35615116357803345,
0.3955136835575104,
0.8776581883430481,
-0.4827898442745209,
0.5232803821563721,
0.6850199699401855,
0.653049647808075,
-0.111155666410923,
-1.1713125705718994,
0.26584959030151367,
-0.32423943281173706,
0.21948623657226562,
0.05659940838813782,
-0.43436768651008606,
0.5498642325401306,
0.1865868717432022,
-0.2914345860481262,
0.1943517029285431,
0.7019940614700317,
0.15695258975028992,
0.28893253207206726,
0.47171279788017273,
0.7256507277488708,
0.5919765830039978,
-0.16018933057785034,
1.3055208921432495,
-0.4379105865955353,
0.2220577746629715,
0.8841413259506226,
0.13551491498947144,
0.9726696610450745,
0.6335180401802063,
-0.19747284054756165,
0.2555621862411499,
0.874006450176239,
0.1733926683664322,
0.10469625890254974,
0.2946496605873108,
-0.08750905096530914,
-0.15886850655078888,
-0.24677838385105133,
-0.47096914052963257,
0.3527616858482361,
0.3678342401981354,
-0.6315801739692688,
-0.19575245678424835,
-0.10379525274038315,
0.16796211898326874,
0.16724860668182373,
0.07040940225124359,
0.15210576355457306,
0.1505993753671646,
-0.456301748752594,
0.6778731942176819,
0.6234284043312073,
0.4423866868019104,
-0.09971292316913605,
-0.0011800723150372505,
-0.11609180271625519,
-0.2502312958240509,
-0.19109946489334106,
-0.7479763031005859,
0.7981045842170715,
-0.06719844043254852,
-0.18498100340366364,
-0.19749154150485992,
0.18486477434635162,
-0.09117541462182999,
-0.6359254717826843,
0.3232544958591461,
0.9848044514656067,
0.9316533803939819,
-0.41136354207992554,
-1.0848941802978516,
0.13480214774608612,
-0.5582162737846375,
-0.03663482517004013,
0.3888216018676758,
0.5823987126350403,
-0.2014351785182953,
0.550627589225769,
0.7972061634063721,
-0.13974550366401672,
0.04756651073694229,
0.23309297859668732,
0.4366060197353363,
-0.6308863162994385,
-0.3826255202293396,
-0.8753792643547058,
0.6047772765159607,
-0.03731768950819969,
-0.5311888456344604,
0.6981422305107117,
0.690122663974762,
0.7747253179550171,
-0.3446579575538635,
0.2607065737247467,
0.07874004542827606,
0.16778579354286194,
-0.40080615878105164,
0.9406528472900391,
-0.7005060911178589,
-0.07392090559005737,
-0.6581090688705444,
-1.2506765127182007,
-0.5006982684135437,
0.7028377056121826,
0.0072425734251737595,
-0.16399726271629333,
1.3451029062271118,
0.7256971597671509,
-0.413276731967926,
-0.023718465119600296,
0.6863059997558594,
0.12815983593463898,
-0.1948181390762329,
0.2769547700881958,
1.0021244287490845,
-0.6793901920318604,
0.41851696372032166,
0.010672150179743767,
-0.2318851351737976,
-0.014692245982587337,
-1.0487849712371826,
-0.650234043598175,
-0.6062543392181396,
-0.4978080093860626,
-0.5065430402755737,
-0.08515220135450363,
0.8162795305252075,
0.5818724036216736,
-0.510360836982727,
-0.4343903660774231,
0.27998191118240356,
0.03996795788407326,
-0.5366498827934265,
-0.2058638632297516,
0.49053964018821716,
-0.5264621376991272,
-0.8209680914878845,
0.27499574422836304,
0.4647299647331238,
-0.16739244759082794,
-0.055780746042728424,
-0.305938720703125,
0.13347673416137695,
0.057989392429590225,
0.9062099456787109,
-0.3108730614185333,
-1.0958068370819092,
-0.31603288650512695,
-0.09193683415651321,
-0.5087794065475464,
0.14553263783454895,
0.650016725063324,
-0.3337291479110718,
0.4329530596733093,
0.23776467144489288,
0.8244278430938721,
0.20246116816997528,
-0.04496277868747711,
0.5273275971412659,
-0.6009469032287598,
0.3094373643398285,
0.24719922244548798,
0.528424084186554,
0.2667043209075928,
0.013264281675219536,
0.8120668530464172,
0.5875107049942017,
-0.278474360704422,
-0.8711766004562378,
0.1276881992816925,
-1.1307741403579712,
0.012837524525821209,
0.8167444467544556,
-0.3827857971191406,
-0.025905415415763855,
0.23668968677520752,
-0.24836386740207672,
0.27580714225769043,
-0.14411231875419617,
0.6830672025680542,
0.8429555892944336,
-0.075889453291893,
-0.12513379752635956,
-1.2405933141708374,
0.14116133749485016,
0.473514199256897,
-0.8796107172966003,
-0.3668734133243561,
0.7716302871704102,
0.16088223457336426,
0.3215195834636688,
0.28279542922973633,
-0.6496768593788147,
0.34353289008140564,
0.08932115137577057,
0.18801161646842957,
0.12583516538143158,
-0.3160945475101471,
0.11768513172864914,
0.09515702724456787,
0.19878438115119934,
-0.30466213822364807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00071v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00071v1 | Combinatorial Reasoning: Selecting Reasons in Generative AI Pipelines via Combinatorial Optimization | 2024-06-19T16:47:44 | 2024-06-19T16:47:44 | Mert Esencan, Tarun Advaith Kumar, Ata Akbari Asanjan, P. Aaron Lott, Masoud Mohseni, Can Unlu, Davide Venturelli, Alan Ho | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.ET, cs.LG | Recent Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities
at tasks that require human intelligence and are a significant step towards
human-like artificial intelligence (AI). Yet the performance of LLMs at
reasoning tasks have been subpar and the reasoning capability of LLMs is a
matter of significant debate. While it has been shown that the choice of the
prompting technique to the LLM can alter its performance on a multitude of
tasks, including reasoning, the best performing techniques require human-made
prompts with the knowledge of the tasks at hand. We introduce a framework for
what we call Combinatorial Reasoning (CR), a fully-automated prompting method,
where reasons are sampled from an LLM pipeline and mapped into a Quadratic
Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) problem. The framework investigates
whether QUBO solutions can be profitably used to select a useful subset of the
reasons to construct a Chain-of-Thought style prompt. We explore the
acceleration of CR with specialized solvers. We also investigate the
performance of simpler zero-shot strategies such as linear majority rule or
random selection of reasons. Our preliminary study indicates that coupling a
combinatorial solver to generative AI pipelines is an interesting avenue for AI
reasoning and elucidates design principles for future CR methods. | [
-0.5971551537513733,
-0.7391799688339233,
0.8589491248130798,
0.39340028166770935,
-0.3614330291748047,
0.2970055937767029,
-0.2215537130832672,
-0.20997899770736694,
-0.09661535173654556,
0.4465881884098053,
-0.8576182723045349,
-0.3400881588459015,
-0.28249940276145935,
0.4246895909309387,
-0.30146798491477966,
0.7394163012504578,
0.05936469882726669,
0.14641891419887543,
-0.7635324001312256,
0.05528770014643669,
-0.6385646462440491,
-0.6112446188926697,
-0.7158362865447998,
-0.4867764115333557,
0.7334503531455994,
0.5236504077911377,
0.37577274441719055,
0.5458940863609314,
0.1337781548500061,
0.24901175498962402,
0.08965156227350235,
0.48491543531417847,
-0.3135339319705963,
0.5277409553527832,
-0.11703017354011536,
-0.7704100012779236,
0.20753838121891022,
-0.3155369460582733,
0.2838554084300995,
0.7144914269447327,
-0.02186943218111992,
0.055522821843624115,
-0.3897150754928589,
0.5988823771476746,
-0.6824309229850769,
-0.011604339815676212,
-0.6965264081954956,
0.04297051578760147,
-0.35833969712257385,
-0.4908442497253418,
-0.341146320104599,
-0.274850994348526,
-0.12670175731182098,
-0.5514771342277527,
0.22751836478710175,
0.4706610143184662,
0.3586656153202057,
0.5696898698806763,
-0.13446152210235596,
-0.36973273754119873,
-0.8152472972869873,
0.8595380783081055,
-0.38025206327438354,
0.2939678430557251,
0.25998416543006897,
0.16438612341880798,
-0.2857450246810913,
-0.5119582414627075,
-0.6787207722663879,
-0.21560320258140564,
0.1660471260547638,
0.2170274257659912,
-0.25359341502189636,
0.14308376610279083,
0.37340426445007324,
0.30418387055397034,
-0.6683399677276611,
0.21806810796260834,
-0.11682061105966568,
-0.2529948055744171,
0.6815924644470215,
0.43806982040405273,
0.25405576825141907,
0.10629928857088089,
-0.16038832068443298,
0.0008807335398159921,
-0.7978792190551758,
0.24050357937812805,
0.45397913455963135,
-0.06306564807891846,
0.15178686380386353,
0.4618353843688965,
-0.20761781930923462,
0.8639580011367798,
0.0384337343275547,
0.1370382010936737,
-0.29955652356147766,
-0.3015914261341095,
0.06122595816850662,
-0.08953431248664856,
0.6618715524673462,
0.054567474871873856,
0.22201953828334808,
-0.21245738863945007,
-0.1965111643075943,
0.30957475304603577,
0.2086646556854248,
-0.5785472989082336,
-0.45437702536582947,
0.5008736252784729,
-0.10717608779668808,
-0.1924559324979782,
-0.21464203298091888,
-0.6302638053894043,
-0.30452966690063477,
-0.4252062737941742,
0.23374636471271515,
-0.3968033492565155,
0.2324117124080658,
0.04166914150118828,
-0.47731393575668335,
0.37621983885765076,
0.3901865780353546,
-0.9432321786880493,
-0.18162484467029572,
0.8168103098869324,
0.5088925957679749,
-0.1821986585855484,
-0.19112800061702728,
-0.7507772445678711,
-0.00604865001514554,
-0.5205848813056946,
1.1210042238235474,
-0.7628869414329529,
-0.7041881680488586,
-0.07502655684947968,
-0.5432187914848328,
0.06838333606719971,
-0.6513774394989014,
0.5783810615539551,
-0.5139482021331787,
0.2462940216064453,
-0.4855686128139496,
-0.46782177686691284,
-0.08423786610364914,
0.12981455028057098,
-0.3088511824607849,
0.6623809337615967,
0.06322687119245529,
-0.3112123906612396,
0.33546632528305054,
-0.8421609997749329,
-0.6587886214256287,
0.5396282076835632,
-0.43334174156188965,
-0.23246915638446808,
0.02165105566382408,
0.35728001594543457,
0.020655276253819466,
-0.5588048100471497,
0.16161227226257324,
-0.29303839802742004,
-0.24932226538658142,
0.3759520947933197,
-0.38470175862312317,
1.070582628250122,
0.369841068983078,
-0.15846039354801178,
0.43463683128356934,
-0.33641624450683594,
0.17153598368167877,
0.26261863112449646,
-0.181901216506958,
0.014822956174612045,
0.27308571338653564,
-0.5173854231834412,
-0.08417579531669617,
0.2078457623720169,
-0.20015864074230194,
0.29870104789733887,
-0.06904687732458115,
0.659076988697052,
0.8486614227294922,
0.07656373083591461,
0.3533468246459961,
-0.46179160475730896,
0.9658470153808594,
0.026262866333127022,
0.15843261778354645,
-0.23870879411697388,
-0.7268975377082825,
-0.8320316076278687,
-0.1979595124721527,
0.24074189364910126,
0.6217545866966248,
-0.666499137878418,
0.423030287027359,
0.3570419251918793,
-0.15453867614269257,
-0.5003153085708618,
0.3108188211917877,
0.2100219875574112,
0.4060298800468445,
0.19730053842067719,
-0.05001605674624443,
-0.636546790599823,
-0.7164276242256165,
-0.08444657176733017,
-0.18215876817703247,
-0.032690927386283875,
0.32659903168678284,
0.305887371301651,
-0.14439614117145538,
1.0450496673583984,
-0.5626816749572754,
0.1204918622970581,
-0.5501797199249268,
0.24914564192295074,
0.1388380527496338,
0.09174409508705139,
0.5293731689453125,
-0.776330292224884,
-0.20738203823566437,
-0.3327557146549225,
-0.6907645463943481,
-0.5379189848899841,
-0.5003231167793274,
-0.5222991108894348,
0.018340958282351494,
0.36204588413238525,
-0.8573337197303772,
0.2517126202583313,
0.2664432227611542,
-0.0008230170933529735,
1.0387223958969116,
-0.06367337703704834,
-0.3688527047634125,
-0.6169394850730896,
-0.0911458283662796,
-0.10466597229242325,
-0.023337818682193756,
-0.32094934582710266,
0.0559132881462574,
-0.3921523094177246,
-0.1932426393032074,
-0.01992284320294857,
0.5451992154121399,
-0.47503742575645447,
0.014484010636806488,
-0.3202357590198517,
0.12178095430135727,
0.24870984256267548,
0.4916122555732727,
0.047302063554525375,
0.894580602645874,
0.6794447302818298,
-0.6482924222946167,
0.8120773434638977,
0.44697996973991394,
0.005734587553888559,
0.6395490169525146,
-0.6231998205184937,
0.21626371145248413,
-0.218160018324852,
0.35821256041526794,
-0.8077435493469238,
-0.11708416044712067,
0.31221696734428406,
-0.5142202973365784,
-0.04078012704849243,
-0.0012766292784363031,
-0.4053996205329895,
-0.6748812794685364,
-0.12213835120201111,
0.4555306136608124,
0.48368486762046814,
-0.7176476716995239,
0.5235946178436279,
0.05917877331376076,
-0.09873998910188675,
-0.2070971578359604,
-0.18594196438789368,
0.22268524765968323,
-0.3144493103027344,
-0.6037191152572632,
0.48739439249038696,
-0.6035182476043701,
-0.39956802129745483,
-0.2188895344734192,
-0.1756768375635147,
0.17248590290546417,
0.22439904510974884,
0.22914712131023407,
0.3555004596710205,
-0.0017581190913915634,
-0.05427855625748634,
0.202581986784935,
-0.3691971004009247,
0.43242600560188293,
-0.5584896802902222,
0.6453602313995361,
-0.11244754493236542,
-0.424957811832428,
-0.22240929305553436,
0.7118037343025208,
0.25103500485420227,
-0.46448785066604614,
0.41703468561172485,
0.4543701410293579,
-0.17740459740161896,
-0.5521621108055115,
-0.46710363030433655,
-0.314028263092041,
-0.43353161215782166,
-0.11196589469909668,
-0.30757176876068115,
-0.9121264815330505,
0.39797505736351013,
-0.0795871764421463,
-0.012820737436413765,
0.04482147470116615,
0.966278612613678,
-0.2895811200141907,
1.3028877973556519,
0.08178041130304337,
-0.035695962607860565,
0.4614313542842865,
-0.3249094784259796,
0.513116180896759,
-0.66495281457901,
-0.21725106239318848,
-0.5340946316719055,
-0.21303139626979828,
-0.3032481372356415,
-0.3191573917865753,
0.5371755361557007,
0.34392720460891724,
-0.15646694600582123,
0.009993582963943481,
-0.4887404441833496,
0.6002108454704285,
1.0598199367523193,
-0.10964933037757874,
0.15177667140960693,
-0.2579456865787506,
-0.3209705054759979,
0.4609040915966034,
-0.888975977897644,
-0.3493339419364929,
0.6527629494667053,
-0.22061967849731445,
0.419264554977417,
0.020838461816310883,
0.8651737570762634,
0.2819307744503021,
-0.03404445946216583,
-0.9065592288970947,
0.7572221755981445,
0.1936936378479004,
-0.5784057378768921,
-0.19662295281887054,
-0.4304647147655487,
-1.0964690446853638,
0.04572919383645058,
-0.24451105296611786,
-0.7314998507499695,
0.04082775115966797,
0.26871684193611145,
-0.684601902961731,
0.09760770946741104,
-0.6117572784423828,
0.6597327589988708,
-0.6049543023109436,
-0.23559685051441193,
-0.3172019422054291,
-0.6072025895118713,
0.1608884483575821,
0.11051801592111588,
-0.048134323209524155,
0.02480611950159073,
0.26739203929901123,
0.3986753225326538,
-0.5731528401374817,
0.6363662481307983,
0.027662022039294243,
0.18080353736877441,
0.5195122361183167,
0.0962044820189476,
0.34891149401664734,
0.04638522490859032,
0.07944697141647339,
0.12156935781240463,
-0.08900578320026398,
-0.3635396957397461,
-0.8168045878410339,
0.48282361030578613,
-0.6017283797264099,
-1.0174380540847778,
-0.29861322045326233,
-0.6991440057754517,
-0.32827454805374146,
0.11895953863859177,
0.41554442048072815,
0.4431283175945282,
0.3170172870159149,
0.10993023961782455,
0.47246697545051575,
-0.07602245360612869,
0.48111265897750854,
0.04233156889677048,
-0.0946778953075409,
-0.24839556217193604,
0.946009635925293,
-0.125554159283638,
0.09422507882118225,
0.4577319025993347,
0.5480380058288574,
-0.551175057888031,
-0.8865830898284912,
-0.6506745219230652,
0.08208826929330826,
-0.6001439094543457,
-0.33901381492614746,
-0.28041791915893555,
-0.21846136450767517,
-0.07563944160938263,
-0.4255291521549225,
0.16822309792041779,
-0.33591917157173157,
-0.4310520589351654,
-0.017483333125710487,
0.3591792583465576,
0.3865355849266052,
-0.18897303938865662,
-0.01878151297569275,
-0.7498884797096252,
0.35005104541778564,
0.6746244430541992,
0.08161487430334091,
0.05832624435424805,
-0.08424260467290878,
-0.012543503195047379,
0.026020854711532593,
-0.5545849204063416,
-0.8918219208717346,
0.20291700959205627,
-0.18085215985774994,
0.8789878487586975,
0.6154211759567261,
0.27655312418937683,
0.5832204818725586,
-0.14229869842529297,
0.703352153301239,
0.09199974685907364,
-0.8025496006011963,
0.6243279576301575,
-0.5286270380020142,
0.15716652572155,
0.30659767985343933,
0.3826737403869629,
-0.3447873890399933,
-0.14360785484313965,
-0.4979064464569092,
-0.7118781208992004,
0.4073027968406677,
0.2946161925792694,
-0.20239441096782684,
-0.3018522560596466,
0.31989288330078125,
0.01856664940714836,
0.2919464111328125,
-0.308396577835083,
-0.11007902771234512,
-0.07259508967399597,
-0.07870334386825562,
0.3371622562408447,
-0.13679289817810059,
-0.36105024814605713,
-0.18417131900787354,
0.6040968298912048,
-0.2967981696128845,
0.3987288475036621,
0.06371438503265381,
-0.04952453821897507,
-0.264802485704422,
0.18172556161880493,
0.6397719383239746,
0.8081596493721008,
0.07071293145418167,
-0.09406787902116776,
0.10897084325551987,
0.17806075513362885,
0.0364287905395031,
0.030992014333605766,
-0.3826506435871124,
-0.3712898790836334,
0.21931593120098114,
0.8453674912452698,
-0.24044862389564514,
-0.8695163726806641,
0.13774597644805908,
0.0415838286280632,
-0.20775210857391357,
-0.38384881615638733,
0.47093984484672546,
0.1820695996284485,
0.4571826457977295,
0.5050222277641296,
-0.09512101113796234,
0.09795268625020981,
-0.4502710998058319,
-0.13517017662525177,
0.7947860360145569,
0.09366607666015625,
-0.08749072998762131,
0.682827889919281,
0.25349530577659607,
-0.85392826795578,
0.8124068975448608,
-0.5580068826675415,
-0.7904890775680542,
0.5982823967933655,
0.5821447968482971,
0.872805655002594,
0.15332573652267456,
0.2866239547729492,
0.1157846450805664,
-0.06113741919398308,
0.21918877959251404,
0.24960771203041077,
-0.4131932854652405,
-1.0335619449615479,
-0.5760670304298401,
-0.4524819254875183,
-0.7377861738204956,
-0.12737765908241272,
-0.45947760343551636,
0.04280351847410202,
-0.6625450849533081,
-0.0767672210931778,
-0.04829329252243042,
-0.09089251607656479,
-0.5290766954421997,
0.02571515366435051,
0.5282518267631531,
0.5755595564842224,
-0.4327728748321533,
0.3863954544067383,
0.5781972408294678,
-0.5631577968597412,
-0.6619356274604797,
-0.08221805840730667,
0.018404118716716766,
-1.032867431640625,
0.46344736218452454,
0.08445823192596436,
-0.1588316261768341,
0.16168926656246185,
-0.8080065846443176,
-0.3545722961425781,
0.9069433808326721,
0.3721413016319275,
-0.6374426484107971,
-0.08825141936540604,
0.10755656659603119,
0.32603171467781067,
-0.4398132562637329,
0.23879535496234894,
0.5859971642494202,
0.554350733757019,
0.37439388036727905,
-0.41579458117485046,
-0.17692796885967255,
-0.15789228677749634,
0.04475005343556404,
0.4018460810184479,
-0.7294204831123352,
0.47354987263679504,
-0.6481887698173523,
-0.014983964152634144,
0.23562085628509521,
0.5652959942817688,
0.87782222032547,
0.4657931327819824,
0.6401052474975586,
0.6862521767616272,
0.8931310176849365,
-0.19671842455863953,
1.2035677433013916,
-0.29923710227012634,
-0.05497458949685097,
0.6074948906898499,
-0.294264018535614,
0.41160082817077637,
0.5343732833862305,
-0.4239770174026489,
0.7983195781707764,
0.8169564604759216,
-0.07043305784463882,
0.3525865972042084,
0.3535618782043457,
-0.5414177179336548,
-0.8971878886222839,
-0.20226764678955078,
-0.009285361506044865,
0.4524105489253998,
0.4112544357776642,
0.09885267168283463,
-0.17326869070529938,
-0.1940874606370926,
-0.20381009578704834,
-0.029408982023596764,
-0.20400376617908478,
0.6765840649604797,
0.20224714279174805,
-0.9067872166633606,
0.3290749192237854,
-0.21175746619701385,
0.3131304085254669,
-0.501592755317688,
-0.1915402114391327,
-0.21399971842765808,
-0.1302730143070221,
-0.09064808487892151,
-0.6717163920402527,
0.16165323555469513,
-0.13658389449119568,
-0.38495302200317383,
-0.27915817499160767,
0.4710148274898529,
-0.22343677282333374,
-0.4833971858024597,
0.04582711681723595,
0.5343666672706604,
0.05280258134007454,
-0.11241091787815094,
-0.814740002155304,
0.0032426377292722464,
0.04536092281341553,
0.17070753872394562,
0.3309903144836426,
0.47947001457214355,
-0.26861172914505005,
0.9132786989212036,
1.2185100317001343,
0.0701046958565712,
-0.031663861125707626,
0.3421124815940857,
0.9220633506774902,
-0.7557863593101501,
-0.5093435645103455,
-0.8939492702484131,
0.45268020033836365,
0.04669748991727829,
-0.1962830275297165,
0.49450749158859253,
0.34991416335105896,
0.6358610987663269,
0.07461091130971909,
1.0468865633010864,
0.033977359533309937,
0.24221913516521454,
-0.6261019110679626,
0.09817890077829361,
-0.35186657309532166,
0.303793728351593,
0.09656801074743271,
-0.8553988337516785,
-0.3263261616230011,
0.7157607078552246,
-0.4819973111152649,
0.14739039540290833,
0.6316916346549988,
0.7659376263618469,
0.3785909116268158,
0.3196844756603241,
0.20299652218818665,
-0.08629850298166275,
0.4948769807815552,
0.7117706537246704,
1.1541134119033813,
0.3710627853870392,
0.6604793071746826,
-0.16682542860507965,
-0.13355299830436707,
-0.4031887352466583,
-1.1361099481582642,
-0.8519461154937744,
-0.4952826499938965,
-0.3154047727584839,
-0.12185478210449219,
0.06631678342819214,
1.0741511583328247,
0.5886212587356567,
-0.6902591586112976,
-0.16710886359214783,
-0.49582552909851074,
0.5344809889793396,
-0.2796582281589508,
-0.2557950019836426,
-0.1438165158033371,
-0.5566060543060303,
-0.5178350806236267,
0.604006290435791,
0.47334691882133484,
-0.25536808371543884,
-0.49205443263053894,
-0.16498525440692902,
0.02178509347140789,
0.1674381047487259,
0.5671853423118591,
0.5387941002845764,
-0.8050763010978699,
-0.21424666047096252,
0.12308316677808762,
0.379657119512558,
0.16494391858577728,
1.0930718183517456,
-0.8731602430343628,
0.5477340221405029,
0.7011029124259949,
0.7327214479446411,
0.48491227626800537,
0.31014540791511536,
0.7108179926872253,
-0.4586878716945648,
-0.14039824903011322,
0.5618258118629456,
0.5037813186645508,
0.3036286532878876,
-0.25896182656288147,
0.26128941774368286,
0.4120559096336365,
-0.7858498096466064,
-0.6706594228744507,
0.5879873037338257,
-1.1137773990631104,
-0.23493628203868866,
1.131754755973816,
0.21202899515628815,
-0.17347782850265503,
-0.18202781677246094,
-0.36921069025993347,
0.00790045689791441,
-0.45896634459495544,
0.7772728800773621,
0.7097980976104736,
-0.6637210249900818,
-0.5330994725227356,
-0.11447840929031372,
0.2327316254377365,
0.5931625962257385,
-0.740925133228302,
-0.06438795477151871,
0.6475667953491211,
-0.005833122413605452,
0.14941874146461487,
0.5085683465003967,
0.24504102766513824,
0.3646359145641327,
-0.0698067769408226,
-0.17771640419960022,
-0.2110292613506317,
-0.47588860988616943,
-0.05240801349282265,
0.03839462995529175,
0.31609898805618286,
-0.08823573589324951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15504v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15504v1 | Dr.E Bridges Graphs with Large Language Models through Words | 2024-06-19T16:43:56 | 2024-06-19T16:43:56 | Zipeng Liu, Likang Wu, Ming He, Zhong Guan, Hongke Zhao, Nan Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Significant efforts have been directed toward integrating powerful Large
Language Models (LLMs) with diverse modalities, particularly focusing on the
fusion of vision, language, and audio data. However, the graph-structured data,
inherently rich in structural and domain-specific knowledge, have not yet been
gracefully adapted to LLMs. Existing methods either describe the graph with raw
text, suffering the loss of graph structural information, or feed Graph Neural
Network (GNN) embeddings directly into LLM at the cost of losing semantic
representation. To bridge this gap, we introduce an innovative, end-to-end
modality-aligning framework, equipped with a pretrained Dual-Residual Vector
Quantized-Variational AutoEncoder (Dr.E). This framework is specifically
designed to facilitate token-level alignment with LLMs, enabling an effective
translation of the intrinsic `language' of graphs into comprehensible natural
language. Our experimental evaluations on standard GNN node classification
tasks demonstrate competitive performance against other state-of-the-art
approaches. Additionally, our framework ensures interpretability, efficiency,
and robustness, with its effectiveness further validated under both fine-tuning
and few-shot settings. This study marks the first successful endeavor to
achieve token-level alignment between GNNs and LLMs. | [
-0.21192428469657898,
-0.6847794651985168,
0.3437092900276184,
-0.30324825644493103,
-0.38339847326278687,
0.38657230138778687,
-0.318316251039505,
-0.30623719096183777,
0.22768226265907288,
0.22384825348854065,
-0.2998255491256714,
-0.7062110900878906,
-0.5398537516593933,
0.058410439640283585,
-0.2445429116487503,
0.6851531267166138,
-0.30772045254707336,
0.03202710300683975,
-0.14202870428562164,
-0.3914559483528137,
-0.3683183193206787,
-0.4445858895778656,
-0.7244426012039185,
-0.2961556315422058,
0.7788525819778442,
-0.05156327784061432,
0.7753986120223999,
0.8183723092079163,
0.3345320522785187,
0.27385321259498596,
0.05676478520035744,
0.5295283198356628,
-0.6239576935768127,
-0.16987201571464539,
-0.1167948842048645,
-0.28279727697372437,
-0.6554584503173828,
-0.24013912677764893,
0.6839893460273743,
1.0258433818817139,
-0.15252408385276794,
-0.16313424706459045,
0.1825619488954544,
0.5083888173103333,
-0.2971037030220032,
0.2111956626176834,
-0.43837717175483704,
0.12817175686359406,
-0.14196407794952393,
-0.08075877279043198,
-0.33414924144744873,
0.13050134479999542,
-0.0806707963347435,
-0.747874915599823,
-0.12416224181652069,
0.2720557749271393,
1.1295939683914185,
0.41372230648994446,
-0.8933699131011963,
-0.0018203591462224722,
-0.4568985402584076,
0.2703408896923065,
-0.6518929600715637,
0.6021446585655212,
0.11852286010980606,
0.3285786509513855,
-0.24627335369586945,
-0.9331993460655212,
-0.6726555228233337,
0.10642876476049423,
-0.04350162297487259,
0.03273549675941467,
-0.2838979959487915,
0.46141746640205383,
-0.0020906557328999043,
0.5245625376701355,
-0.7901607751846313,
0.48279398679733276,
-0.09098337590694427,
-0.38582444190979004,
0.4039980471134186,
0.21524783968925476,
0.47143593430519104,
-0.02190500684082508,
-0.40313807129859924,
-0.183487668633461,
-0.5718337893486023,
-0.17626652121543884,
0.40198540687561035,
0.41884028911590576,
-0.27594056725502014,
0.6501942873001099,
0.1194644346833229,
1.02388334274292,
0.06669465452432632,
0.2775079309940338,
0.4155835807323456,
-0.4862666428089142,
-0.4465769827365875,
-0.09526502341032028,
1.0890085697174072,
0.3903452455997467,
0.0773390457034111,
-0.30273711681365967,
-0.23700284957885742,
0.1381140649318695,
0.019110186025500298,
-0.6508479714393616,
-0.2691744863986969,
-0.03590311482548714,
-0.35398316383361816,
-0.25708451867103577,
-0.019323177635669708,
-0.3557317852973938,
-0.3279533386230469,
-0.46961089968681335,
0.4725353717803955,
-0.27080076932907104,
-0.3367088735103607,
0.3404421806335449,
-0.028483886271715164,
0.160283163189888,
0.21626999974250793,
-0.7964306473731995,
0.3513285219669342,
0.6858776211738586,
0.8903314471244812,
-0.04694150388240814,
-0.1883845329284668,
-0.49515870213508606,
0.4723054766654968,
-0.5119268894195557,
0.34911584854125977,
-0.45533984899520874,
-0.11438173055648804,
-0.0068371971137821674,
0.1517045795917511,
-0.21933652460575104,
-0.3507688641548157,
0.40519556403160095,
-0.6308460235595703,
0.3194999694824219,
-0.1025327816605568,
-0.7551847100257874,
-0.14535486698150635,
0.3017162084579468,
-0.5477598309516907,
1.021376371383667,
0.4586234986782074,
-0.7986549139022827,
0.3811641037464142,
-0.45125529170036316,
-0.5270827412605286,
-0.02256975881755352,
-0.6268433332443237,
-0.23789319396018982,
0.09076844900846481,
0.212925523519516,
0.27400654554367065,
-0.27342331409454346,
0.4630601108074188,
-0.39568087458610535,
-0.1716090887784958,
0.18602155148983002,
-0.5169313549995422,
0.545771598815918,
0.05952982231974602,
-0.22357536852359772,
0.3297038972377777,
-0.5697892904281616,
-0.16596150398254395,
0.08868367969989777,
-0.15866756439208984,
-0.2608647048473358,
-0.1426718682050705,
0.015371291898190975,
0.4063987731933594,
0.18544255197048187,
-0.6153221130371094,
0.29159995913505554,
-0.49491071701049805,
0.9135583639144897,
0.8587167263031006,
-0.5453578233718872,
0.4229653775691986,
-0.14795857667922974,
0.5556877851486206,
0.03252260759472847,
-0.15946689248085022,
-0.17768791317939758,
-0.16951291263103485,
-0.5966299772262573,
-0.49282383918762207,
0.5491617321968079,
0.38940584659576416,
-0.6525188088417053,
0.8161903023719788,
-0.7226895093917847,
-0.11100354045629501,
-0.4701567590236664,
-0.01572456583380699,
0.1788572520017624,
0.7747904062271118,
0.26819998025894165,
-0.5809370279312134,
-0.3786383867263794,
-0.952879011631012,
0.07543566077947617,
-0.12415415048599243,
-0.017028508707880974,
0.6651526093482971,
0.1755959838628769,
-0.3919854462146759,
1.0283269882202148,
-0.46031835675239563,
-0.3792083263397217,
-0.038195423781871796,
0.1451069712638855,
0.051488231867551804,
0.4571765065193176,
0.5441826581954956,
-0.5940295457839966,
-0.4414910674095154,
0.22816137969493866,
-0.7693706154823303,
-0.1550910472869873,
0.002377533121034503,
-0.3884694576263428,
-0.10382804274559021,
0.7304609417915344,
-0.34779155254364014,
0.22539760172367096,
0.7542722225189209,
-0.5782368183135986,
0.1343977153301239,
-0.18505911529064178,
0.040056828409433365,
-1.3292144536972046,
0.07688869535923004,
-0.22258543968200684,
-0.7752721309661865,
-0.35936880111694336,
-0.3715994954109192,
-0.006395567208528519,
-0.35680505633354187,
-0.026884714141488075,
0.6222499012947083,
-0.5582025647163391,
-0.19740092754364014,
-0.23107221722602844,
0.2905074954032898,
0.3444162905216217,
0.40067121386528015,
-0.28763696551322937,
0.6689726114273071,
0.6988041400909424,
-0.2817370593547821,
0.5144044160842896,
0.34692373871803284,
0.024050462990999222,
0.7012884020805359,
-0.6077061891555786,
0.35663577914237976,
-0.187861368060112,
0.3853422999382019,
-1.0716629028320312,
-0.2078809291124344,
0.3844796121120453,
-0.3312276303768158,
0.9887304902076721,
-0.2205124795436859,
-0.49581608176231384,
-0.44176027178764343,
0.00006792633212171495,
0.6137079000473022,
0.19596417248249054,
-0.4599080979824066,
0.9273861050605774,
0.4444296360015869,
-0.03305499628186226,
-0.523174524307251,
-0.7130441069602966,
0.6626890301704407,
-0.06702720373868942,
-0.7561599612236023,
0.5539233088493347,
0.057905785739421844,
0.25379467010498047,
0.31927332282066345,
-0.031456999480724335,
0.01594911515712738,
0.049222271889448166,
0.007719581481069326,
0.15325720608234406,
-0.3289619982242584,
0.2602928578853607,
0.1467292606830597,
-0.30191802978515625,
-0.2069493532180786,
-0.763646125793457,
0.6187883615493774,
-0.06309331208467484,
-0.6476886868476868,
-0.4576396346092224,
0.3180350959300995,
0.6944649815559387,
-0.3924139440059662,
0.6289992332458496,
0.6245518326759338,
-0.46076035499572754,
-0.1451617032289505,
-0.16602015495300293,
0.02414633147418499,
-0.4713781177997589,
0.7223377823829651,
-0.45535939931869507,
-1.2470710277557373,
0.380587637424469,
-0.29979193210601807,
-0.2232850193977356,
0.33269017934799194,
0.29387199878692627,
-0.12016117572784424,
1.0907012224197388,
0.8579330444335938,
-0.19562526047229767,
0.500084638595581,
-0.08155664801597595,
0.5549821257591248,
-1.062675952911377,
-0.03228968381881714,
-0.1706758588552475,
-0.5874149203300476,
-0.3091340661048889,
-0.6075402498245239,
0.13436312973499298,
0.2623100280761719,
-0.4252253472805023,
0.2680809795856476,
-0.5618278980255127,
0.13707703351974487,
0.09276550263166428,
0.11590689420700073,
0.06422507017850876,
0.02684561163187027,
-0.2839914858341217,
-0.011188105680048466,
-0.8456249833106995,
-0.4418138265609741,
1.086159348487854,
0.5156146883964539,
0.8117391467094421,
0.09683232754468918,
0.563265323638916,
0.2180006355047226,
0.2826411724090576,
-0.8514025807380676,
0.4466306269168854,
-0.32743003964424133,
-0.23661968111991882,
-0.40094608068466187,
-0.47533392906188965,
-0.7581882476806641,
0.3256917893886566,
0.07757263630628586,
-0.5165327787399292,
0.2719687223434448,
0.13588999211788177,
-0.1061643436551094,
0.37847834825515747,
-0.3493315875530243,
1.1776067018508911,
-0.5022239685058594,
-0.3082163333892822,
-0.07691098004579544,
-0.7410943508148193,
0.07961193472146988,
-0.06749065220355988,
0.39030274748802185,
-0.17624922096729279,
-0.32435715198516846,
0.5407418608665466,
-0.5661550164222717,
1.0214539766311646,
-0.06759684532880783,
-0.2818317711353302,
0.005550929345190525,
0.00289498851634562,
0.5029425024986267,
-0.22065888345241547,
0.20127736032009125,
0.23399139940738678,
-0.32259848713874817,
-0.3494347929954529,
-0.6001849174499512,
0.5653271079063416,
-0.7487940788269043,
-0.33774811029434204,
-0.17089733481407166,
-0.660339891910553,
-0.2993594706058502,
0.3588142395019531,
0.0893055722117424,
0.6890014410018921,
-0.26996150612831116,
0.09203372150659561,
0.5261873006820679,
-0.12232908606529236,
0.22939172387123108,
0.20902091264724731,
-0.2981207072734833,
-0.8372049927711487,
0.8655955195426941,
0.08609302341938019,
0.40710946917533875,
0.4255753755569458,
0.17824342846870422,
-0.30764827132225037,
-0.5451975464820862,
-0.9211657643318176,
0.2673174738883972,
-0.7416663765907288,
-0.3448362350463867,
-0.7231453061103821,
-0.11354850977659225,
-0.32614582777023315,
-0.2872690260410309,
-0.32283616065979004,
-0.24578851461410522,
-0.43008747696876526,
-0.318399578332901,
0.14198802411556244,
0.553080677986145,
-0.20496685802936554,
0.14780986309051514,
-0.7411734461784363,
0.1721014678478241,
0.2702125608921051,
0.4023211896419525,
-0.08939718455076218,
-0.5457537770271301,
-0.3394359350204468,
0.07367623597383499,
0.09857246279716492,
-0.8619687557220459,
0.16194355487823486,
0.5668490529060364,
0.581233024597168,
0.45510730147361755,
-0.13575544953346252,
0.7680675387382507,
-0.5041765570640564,
0.6778687238693237,
0.597620964050293,
-1.0210895538330078,
0.1667841523885727,
-0.510382890701294,
-0.11812413483858109,
0.5248204469680786,
0.07425633072853088,
-0.7188383936882019,
-0.15731285512447357,
-0.18185099959373474,
-1.127411127090454,
0.3779048025608063,
-0.09508097171783447,
0.36968445777893066,
-0.16131635010242462,
0.32040587067604065,
-0.033988241106271744,
0.4366728365421295,
-0.6823470592498779,
-0.2081693410873413,
-0.3978555500507355,
-0.9350555539131165,
0.037103839218616486,
-0.06749928742647171,
-0.5015525817871094,
-0.36133021116256714,
0.3614606559276581,
-0.6316201686859131,
0.14457759261131287,
0.25257113575935364,
-0.3294355273246765,
-0.16975922882556915,
0.05262482911348343,
0.3506247103214264,
0.6874954104423523,
0.3386991024017334,
0.41570743918418884,
0.02450927533209324,
-0.19577184319496155,
0.16919252276420593,
0.30036503076553345,
0.03130007162690163,
-0.18570266664028168,
0.35504722595214844,
1.0131698846817017,
0.40043413639068604,
-0.4694879949092865,
0.7982074022293091,
-0.02514275535941124,
-0.26880165934562683,
0.07648665457963943,
-0.3417704403400421,
0.28962215781211853,
0.050767168402671814,
0.1745743453502655,
-0.2818148136138916,
-0.1745844930410385,
-0.38766926527023315,
0.3764798045158386,
0.5910524129867554,
-0.6802290678024292,
-0.3917934000492096,
0.8705651164054871,
0.3701934218406677,
-0.14178839325904846,
0.6418010592460632,
-0.27044495940208435,
-0.6847975254058838,
0.41170647740364075,
0.7484008073806763,
0.8934215903282166,
0.09815604984760284,
0.0850435271859169,
0.18801221251487732,
0.20587410032749176,
0.32231926918029785,
0.25006476044654846,
0.057291384786367416,
-0.8337525725364685,
-0.7188251614570618,
-0.6969191431999207,
0.023957347497344017,
-0.27636685967445374,
-0.5337695479393005,
0.11136750131845474,
-0.23342783749103546,
-0.28242069482803345,
-0.3154207170009613,
-0.4022814631462097,
-0.724419355392456,
0.048847563564777374,
0.45132166147232056,
0.7350658774375916,
-0.9702182412147522,
0.7011517286300659,
0.8109939098358154,
-0.46619313955307007,
-1.0811442136764526,
-0.2639745771884918,
-0.13290643692016602,
-0.9105194807052612,
0.7071388959884644,
0.12979263067245483,
-0.17116542160511017,
0.4424291253089905,
-0.5025635957717896,
-0.8403597474098206,
1.2501070499420166,
0.4913484454154968,
-0.8706137537956238,
-0.17372609674930573,
0.24910345673561096,
0.36901625990867615,
-0.513237714767456,
0.00990238692611456,
0.10841549932956696,
0.41149720549583435,
0.1690044403076172,
-1.0725595951080322,
0.19112101197242737,
-0.22484861314296722,
-0.026236215606331825,
0.470600962638855,
-0.5607854723930359,
0.7710152268409729,
0.024860069155693054,
-0.3186003267765045,
-0.2771700918674469,
0.8366138339042664,
-0.29009249806404114,
0.1339004635810852,
0.6013889312744141,
1.0256690979003906,
1.09987473487854,
-0.10500729829072952,
0.6908755898475647,
-0.6784361600875854,
0.2274399995803833,
1.0214648246765137,
-0.4362030327320099,
0.44390156865119934,
0.38740819692611694,
-0.17728465795516968,
0.6621055603027344,
0.7776616215705872,
0.06983396410942078,
0.4258488416671753,
0.5000423192977905,
-0.20321814715862274,
-0.3774715065956116,
-0.3891587555408478,
-0.3702112138271332,
0.33412012457847595,
0.26139822602272034,
-0.2967839539051056,
-0.15581561625003815,
0.0420868881046772,
0.002306644106283784,
0.013572033494710922,
-0.22197315096855164,
0.7422662377357483,
0.3719487488269806,
-0.005380899645388126,
0.4717698097229004,
-0.1786876767873764,
0.635508120059967,
-0.5829513669013977,
0.014344565570354462,
0.06749507039785385,
-0.12361862510442734,
-0.2521095275878906,
-0.5249358415603638,
0.11591866612434387,
-0.3544352948665619,
-0.04231417179107666,
-0.2063600718975067,
0.6412113308906555,
-0.6274467706680298,
-0.2476716935634613,
0.46404844522476196,
0.5739039778709412,
-0.09790289402008057,
0.22226913273334503,
-0.5772308111190796,
0.05682026594877243,
-0.23188287019729614,
-0.10268647223711014,
0.34143924713134766,
0.7559930086135864,
0.02792208641767502,
0.39225471019744873,
0.6852913498878479,
-0.015081118792295456,
-0.032138608396053314,
0.4412645399570465,
1.259325623512268,
-0.6512343287467957,
-0.5852352380752563,
-0.8275865316390991,
0.5482770800590515,
-0.1684698462486267,
-0.19785942137241364,
0.4424915015697479,
0.8009474873542786,
0.6733250617980957,
0.5687313079833984,
0.8099827170372009,
-0.046105630695819855,
-0.07496058195829391,
-0.4433117210865021,
0.6123858690261841,
-0.6694132089614868,
0.035799477249383926,
-0.05252562090754509,
-0.6447786092758179,
-0.2622833549976349,
0.46457767486572266,
-0.09492727369070053,
-0.059392962604761124,
0.6978129148483276,
0.7016863226890564,
-0.12716351449489594,
-0.4089793264865875,
0.362798273563385,
0.17279395461082458,
0.5499871969223022,
0.6736078858375549,
0.6136161684989929,
-0.2685326337814331,
0.5164390802383423,
0.2295714020729065,
-0.38280346989631653,
-0.0242802482098341,
-1.032300591468811,
-0.8048345446586609,
-0.37550464272499084,
-0.4098271429538727,
-0.37677913904190063,
-0.017069194465875626,
0.8142657279968262,
0.6005096435546875,
-0.3805030882358551,
0.011052108369767666,
-0.31955111026763916,
-0.13337141275405884,
0.057735294103622437,
-0.15496648848056793,
0.6443624496459961,
-0.18343853950500488,
-0.5664470791816711,
0.5853734612464905,
0.6236521601676941,
0.19958020746707916,
-0.3365679979324341,
-0.16229620575904846,
0.14962062239646912,
-0.14351090788841248,
0.44532501697540283,
0.18138858675956726,
-0.6282601952552795,
-0.5849885940551758,
0.24781903624534607,
-0.3803580105304718,
0.296630859375,
0.8104950189590454,
-0.7346932888031006,
0.6695576906204224,
0.47060173749923706,
0.9172064065933228,
0.3211536705493927,
-0.021005351096391678,
0.9973716735839844,
-0.5097576975822449,
-0.040991801768541336,
0.3434469699859619,
0.6092391610145569,
0.6063594222068787,
-0.1830194592475891,
0.3613593578338623,
0.29516005516052246,
-0.4695969521999359,
-0.9750521779060364,
0.5153723359107971,
-1.003653883934021,
-0.1891402155160904,
1.0197168588638306,
-0.20205789804458618,
-0.24468310177326202,
-0.21545058488845825,
-0.25557610392570496,
0.6651214957237244,
0.0026197899132966995,
0.2863641679286957,
0.640813946723938,
0.04537409916520119,
-0.0205270703881979,
-0.3036915361881256,
0.14404477179050446,
0.28329503536224365,
-0.48269417881965637,
0.2025383859872818,
0.6421782970428467,
0.14759056270122528,
-0.21688823401927948,
0.7133793830871582,
-0.15189966559410095,
-0.1960759311914444,
-0.039345815777778625,
0.11086007207632065,
-0.5724198818206787,
0.010121658444404602,
-0.5211811661720276,
0.004214521963149309,
0.21584992110729218,
-0.24468673765659332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13692v1 | Synchronous Faithfulness Monitoring for Trustworthy Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-19T16:42:57 | 2024-06-19T16:42:57 | Di Wu, Jia-Chen Gu, Fan Yin, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented language models (RALMs) have shown strong performance and
wide applicability in knowledge-intensive tasks. However, there are significant
trustworthiness concerns as RALMs are prone to generating unfaithful outputs,
including baseless information or contradictions with the retrieved context.
This paper proposes SynCheck, a lightweight monitor that leverages fine-grained
decoding dynamics including sequence likelihood, uncertainty quantification,
context influence, and semantic alignment to synchronously detect unfaithful
sentences. By integrating efficiently measurable and complementary signals,
SynCheck enables accurate and immediate feedback and intervention, achieving
0.85 AUROC in detecting faithfulness errors across six long-form
retrieval-augmented generation tasks, improving prior best method by 4%.
Leveraging SynCheck, we further introduce FOD, a faithfulness-oriented decoding
algorithm guided by beam search for long-form retrieval-augmented generation.
Empirical results demonstrate that FOD outperforms traditional strategies such
as abstention, reranking, or contrastive decoding significantly in terms of
faithfulness, achieving over 10% improvement across six datasets. | [
-0.12697337567806244,
-0.8824350833892822,
0.5397287607192993,
0.09769123047590256,
-0.47449952363967896,
0.018071545287966728,
0.0000651701120659709,
-0.5867411494255066,
0.32539600133895874,
0.2569681406021118,
-0.6417128443717957,
-0.3533742427825928,
-0.43179070949554443,
0.23804304003715515,
-0.5217382311820984,
0.7456167936325073,
-0.3924344480037689,
-0.13485082983970642,
-0.22155410051345825,
-0.28205251693725586,
-0.5121278762817383,
0.08883298933506012,
0.1473875641822815,
-0.4752595126628876,
-0.07033414393663406,
0.36137068271636963,
1.1864550113677979,
0.5116167068481445,
0.22189463675022125,
0.28292542695999146,
0.199765145778656,
0.7752589583396912,
-0.4415300786495209,
0.855535089969635,
-0.3699592649936676,
-0.22709879279136658,
-0.433321088552475,
-0.030582929030060768,
0.564106822013855,
0.3734927475452423,
-0.20546509325504303,
0.44239234924316406,
0.35500964522361755,
0.5607404708862305,
-1.084404468536377,
0.2583681046962738,
-0.7268384695053101,
-0.10712585598230362,
-0.5951249599456787,
-0.456844300031662,
-0.5231372117996216,
-0.15814819931983948,
-0.22665682435035706,
-0.6209408044815063,
0.037832796573638916,
0.5655420422554016,
0.8619271516799927,
0.321103572845459,
-0.04545329138636589,
-0.2625901699066162,
-0.1437223106622696,
1.1322705745697021,
-0.6329852938652039,
0.737632155418396,
1.0139113664627075,
-0.2748861610889435,
-0.46890178322792053,
-0.5952439308166504,
-0.3976703882217407,
-0.23190701007843018,
-0.21540553867816925,
0.15326407551765442,
-0.21598511934280396,
0.0100563308224082,
0.07940726727247238,
0.6109164953231812,
-0.32834458351135254,
-0.4765855371952057,
0.5086894631385803,
-0.7662000060081482,
0.3946080207824707,
0.11923420429229736,
0.38214364647865295,
-0.2790455222129822,
-0.301390141248703,
-0.0369732640683651,
-0.3196408748626709,
-0.1790563315153122,
0.31660196185112,
0.15462426841259003,
0.09229936450719833,
0.474968284368515,
-0.43092775344848633,
0.5800650715827942,
0.1410035789012909,
0.028011957183480263,
0.0704309344291687,
-0.7495140433311462,
-0.19284623861312866,
0.006205702666193247,
0.6610894799232483,
0.19174392521381378,
-0.3143819570541382,
-0.19457153975963593,
-0.6046814322471619,
0.23738758265972137,
0.3330339789390564,
-0.7728543877601624,
-0.030217258259654045,
0.19083955883979797,
-0.5122435092926025,
-0.41070976853370667,
0.0568099245429039,
-0.779178261756897,
-0.09477663785219193,
0.01802169904112816,
0.5001113414764404,
-0.7811579704284668,
0.031724847853183746,
-0.051088545471429825,
0.3024304509162903,
-0.05719730630517006,
0.4414999783039093,
-0.8307434916496277,
0.050690241158008575,
0.7362968921661377,
0.9640558958053589,
0.024976026266813278,
-0.5000063180923462,
-1.2991970777511597,
-0.01922866702079773,
-0.37163615226745605,
0.40491828322410583,
-0.3553013801574707,
-0.16964606940746307,
0.3050021231174469,
0.08239647001028061,
0.2977178394794464,
-0.17765434086322784,
0.6605538725852966,
-0.6961202025413513,
-0.14960500597953796,
-0.2833068370819092,
-0.5744179487228394,
0.3059881925582886,
0.33328258991241455,
-0.41077902913093567,
1.0775549411773682,
0.2768731415271759,
-1.2172495126724243,
0.4055919051170349,
0.12284859269857407,
-0.4673868715763092,
0.08863562345504761,
-0.09129586070775986,
-0.605715274810791,
0.1893530637025833,
0.07695456594228745,
0.307992547750473,
0.031302448362112045,
0.21010169386863708,
-0.4328763484954834,
-0.517439067363739,
0.06418205052614212,
-0.3907740116119385,
0.48141422867774963,
0.3699924647808075,
-0.5096079111099243,
-0.11775553226470947,
-0.6188521385192871,
0.15909239649772644,
-0.028689490631222725,
-0.1614367812871933,
-0.8347967863082886,
0.21570159494876862,
0.03230861946940422,
-0.37974774837493896,
0.4483177661895752,
-0.7657222151756287,
-0.12893934547901154,
-0.3726263642311096,
-0.14754733443260193,
0.5380598306655884,
-0.08501464873552322,
0.24230587482452393,
-0.39205363392829895,
0.1463814228773117,
-0.18707768619060516,
0.25410494208335876,
-0.5424478650093079,
-0.28048214316368103,
-0.4874305725097656,
-0.057682521641254425,
0.003078197594732046,
0.17373919486999512,
-0.9920657873153687,
0.430965781211853,
-0.01110149547457695,
0.061160609126091,
-0.653744101524353,
0.520140528678894,
0.7826139330863953,
0.5153382420539856,
0.36248716711997986,
-0.42383986711502075,
-0.5146908164024353,
-0.3989146947860718,
-0.7126821875572205,
-0.2979932427406311,
0.26880770921707153,
-0.12060464173555374,
0.45443835854530334,
-0.6890236735343933,
0.8486119508743286,
-0.07145850360393524,
-0.288119375705719,
0.35562586784362793,
0.3965691924095154,
-0.17263801395893097,
0.47060325741767883,
0.26782816648483276,
-0.5832619667053223,
-0.23354443907737732,
0.07558201998472214,
-0.8253316879272461,
-0.28543734550476074,
0.06806705892086029,
-0.12963667511940002,
0.4197517931461334,
0.3717971742153168,
-0.37413737177848816,
0.45068877935409546,
0.7968556880950928,
-0.5969932079315186,
0.5652666091918945,
-0.2478618323802948,
0.47607219219207764,
-0.9951884150505066,
0.09809094667434692,
-0.5136830806732178,
-0.7013328075408936,
-0.2177237868309021,
0.34551650285720825,
0.24776533246040344,
0.3842519223690033,
-0.13346411287784576,
0.4286651313304901,
-0.7524007558822632,
-0.12225448340177536,
-0.385285347700119,
0.19710201025009155,
0.08170778304338455,
-0.06469383835792542,
-0.35910943150520325,
0.9877105951309204,
0.13067367672920227,
0.03842639550566673,
0.2779974043369293,
0.5621221661567688,
-0.297699511051178,
0.30444082617759705,
-0.24504263699054718,
0.08144605159759521,
0.08405875414609909,
0.10110148787498474,
-0.7944170832633972,
-0.49917083978652954,
-0.14672879874706268,
-0.5860085487365723,
0.28750529885292053,
0.10445702075958252,
-0.5816506147384644,
0.06361608952283859,
-0.708107054233551,
0.4558710753917694,
0.39679720997810364,
-0.6659596562385559,
0.47154420614242554,
-0.09917165338993073,
0.3367778956890106,
-0.9716531038284302,
-0.8634557723999023,
-0.2984156608581543,
0.6072057485580444,
-0.7148251533508301,
0.02309485524892807,
0.27333638072013855,
-0.4276622533798218,
-0.008852826431393623,
-0.6788471937179565,
0.07415826618671417,
0.15469951927661896,
0.5310865044593811,
0.2929554283618927,
-0.0943564847111702,
-0.1984252780675888,
0.20710976421833038,
-0.09031622111797333,
0.1180637925863266,
-0.2813326418399811,
0.4515063464641571,
-0.3621435761451721,
-0.47534024715423584,
-0.5741838216781616,
0.2780684530735016,
0.8144164681434631,
-0.2955121397972107,
0.6466188430786133,
0.6148765087127686,
-0.26786041259765625,
-0.6428056359291077,
-0.5287970304489136,
-0.5403174161911011,
-0.549711287021637,
0.021177267655730247,
-0.1300981640815735,
-1.034217119216919,
0.5564368367195129,
0.011235782876610756,
0.07996145635843277,
0.15977513790130615,
0.3144497871398926,
-0.017888562753796577,
0.8361395597457886,
0.1924198567867279,
-0.11850330978631973,
0.5921050906181335,
0.253973126411438,
0.0007897123578004539,
-0.46978166699409485,
-0.12150108069181442,
-0.2473398745059967,
0.12378039956092834,
-0.34185492992401123,
-0.3923698961734772,
-0.07724756002426147,
0.5148761868476868,
-0.02221950702369213,
0.10147511214017868,
-0.19125361740589142,
0.19649867713451385,
0.4251321852207184,
0.3152334690093994,
0.6356649398803711,
-0.04407535120844841,
-0.36615607142448425,
-0.2911689579486847,
-0.07054566591978073,
-0.41814714670181274,
0.8266534209251404,
0.10144338011741638,
1.1354154348373413,
-0.15893709659576416,
0.8583823442459106,
0.6542277932167053,
0.047178611159324646,
-0.3203323781490326,
0.33323371410369873,
0.026322929188609123,
-0.3807569742202759,
-0.0038171231281012297,
-0.44916093349456787,
-0.5816128849983215,
-0.095961794257164,
-0.3691699206829071,
-0.5152233242988586,
0.08864589035511017,
0.6042200326919556,
-0.22864459455013275,
0.3320208787918091,
-0.2873900830745697,
0.5432205200195312,
-0.01108190231025219,
-1.026828408241272,
-0.23218372464179993,
-0.6599450707435608,
0.5160659551620483,
-0.25654885172843933,
0.13261137902736664,
-0.08237653225660324,
0.2133321911096573,
0.2634919285774231,
-0.7073686718940735,
0.4969419240951538,
-0.006708047818392515,
-0.07395472377538681,
0.295411080121994,
0.697074830532074,
0.9498581886291504,
0.44021472334861755,
0.0033284067176282406,
0.08286360651254654,
0.09429343044757843,
-0.4141196310520172,
-0.32041695713996887,
0.7861572504043579,
-0.5089312791824341,
-0.19152870774269104,
-0.55372154712677,
-0.6501662135124207,
-0.43931475281715393,
0.49340954422950745,
0.36270269751548767,
0.2783963084220886,
-0.20836028456687927,
0.16693530976772308,
0.7792839407920837,
0.016137538477778435,
0.26285094022750854,
0.4973728358745575,
-0.42092204093933105,
-0.3118555545806885,
0.7462334036827087,
-0.3091007471084595,
0.3607519268989563,
0.34501752257347107,
-0.04057803377509117,
-0.11930299550294876,
-0.5097662210464478,
-0.2546892762184143,
-0.022220466285943985,
-0.4225141704082489,
-0.5957565903663635,
-0.44649896025657654,
0.17181053757667542,
-0.17268061637878418,
-0.23100438714027405,
-0.7602118253707886,
0.1998208463191986,
-0.16797837615013123,
0.13591109216213226,
0.48170968890190125,
0.34476709365844727,
-0.03763848915696144,
0.07328121364116669,
-0.9298003315925598,
0.5377228260040283,
0.5090978741645813,
0.5316447615623474,
-0.19784453511238098,
-0.3393382430076599,
-0.1361130326986313,
0.26596304774284363,
-0.1429000049829483,
-0.8682665228843689,
0.31244707107543945,
0.03948744386434555,
0.08044790476560593,
0.4536898136138916,
0.3716730773448944,
0.7912572622299194,
-0.3312869966030121,
0.699715793132782,
-0.003432709723711014,
-1.4784069061279297,
0.8116652369499207,
-0.4191266596317291,
0.22197462618350983,
0.9059449434280396,
-0.25838911533355713,
-0.25619885325431824,
-0.694157063961029,
-0.29045796394348145,
-0.6452588438987732,
0.7548791170120239,
0.4800220727920532,
-0.056103236973285675,
-0.1547878384590149,
0.4963108003139496,
0.2596397399902344,
0.38088157773017883,
-0.17049504816532135,
-0.29559922218322754,
-0.31206271052360535,
-0.23743869364261627,
0.27285608649253845,
-0.35707661509513855,
0.06914543360471725,
0.12930665910243988,
0.7751387357711792,
-0.2836129069328308,
0.08459578454494476,
0.593465268611908,
-0.34689539670944214,
-0.7488309741020203,
0.4625668227672577,
0.43465134501457214,
0.4692680835723877,
-0.5402843356132507,
0.5022984147071838,
0.07862798869609833,
-0.8405556678771973,
-0.016342807561159134,
0.0680704340338707,
-0.3821119964122772,
0.4180149435997009,
0.5299737453460693,
0.4477437138557434,
0.2932208180427551,
-0.7858032584190369,
0.8399642109870911,
0.003717314451932907,
0.046101164072752,
0.014814987778663635,
-0.17460417747497559,
-0.3141571283340454,
0.29383859038352966,
0.3636588752269745,
0.3323054313659668,
0.13075925409793854,
-0.693390429019928,
0.8082727193832397,
0.623021125793457,
-0.22441983222961426,
-0.539370059967041,
0.9499440789222717,
0.03778429329395294,
0.039387382566928864,
0.6016488075256348,
-0.26918068528175354,
-0.40298226475715637,
-0.07626613974571228,
0.44825977087020874,
0.76611328125,
-0.5912942886352539,
0.16129398345947266,
0.07625078409910202,
0.29718583822250366,
-0.6176139116287231,
0.5801265239715576,
-0.4130594730377197,
-0.8129600286483765,
-0.40638741850852966,
-0.9491496086120605,
-0.4889218509197235,
-0.32385769486427307,
-1.0958608388900757,
-0.1237453892827034,
-0.27117595076560974,
-0.056199267506599426,
-0.366545170545578,
0.21214427053928375,
-0.23999515175819397,
0.0048422678373754025,
0.0376616008579731,
0.8335161209106445,
-0.7938429713249207,
1.0568844079971313,
0.5499249696731567,
-0.3018263578414917,
-0.7453063130378723,
0.1344827115535736,
0.1957901120185852,
-1.049011468887329,
0.2755343019962311,
0.04049717262387276,
-0.5996196866035461,
-0.24337315559387207,
-0.6335349678993225,
-0.5519505143165588,
1.246819019317627,
0.6615452170372009,
-0.7228932976722717,
0.08801320195198059,
-0.2169894576072693,
0.31584104895591736,
0.004897125065326691,
0.04656914249062538,
0.39281338453292847,
0.45744597911834717,
-0.3229230046272278,
-0.9903700351715088,
0.22359640896320343,
-0.1261262595653534,
-0.17691515386104584,
0.5493624806404114,
-0.7349255084991455,
0.773537278175354,
-0.07232318818569183,
-0.40723830461502075,
0.4123237431049347,
0.9375513195991516,
0.451311320066452,
0.736664354801178,
0.3909923732280731,
0.435834139585495,
0.8025539517402649,
-0.16365954279899597,
0.9202727675437927,
-0.5067880749702454,
0.71084064245224,
1.1415437459945679,
-0.3524360656738281,
0.9176419973373413,
0.8972756266593933,
0.16365006566047668,
0.5185883641242981,
-0.046426206827163696,
0.1181015819311142,
0.5997527241706848,
-0.45417818427085876,
-0.24870286881923676,
-0.6077218055725098,
-0.29043158888816833,
-0.29119110107421875,
0.30713215470314026,
0.1094895675778389,
-0.4699417054653168,
-0.2935422360897064,
0.08601748943328857,
0.15822994709014893,
0.5406311750411987,
-0.28273066878318787,
0.29270368814468384,
0.20744720101356506,
-0.70987468957901,
0.5763715505599976,
-0.20497718453407288,
0.8706269860267639,
-0.8695912957191467,
-0.1982399970293045,
-0.4231874644756317,
0.5870994329452515,
-0.4534001350402832,
-0.7075304388999939,
0.30065739154815674,
-0.13558240234851837,
-0.28877362608909607,
-0.4592638611793518,
0.9504226446151733,
-0.5608076453208923,
0.05097600445151329,
0.544761061668396,
0.5322744846343994,
-0.35732823610305786,
0.03260011598467827,
-0.3796943128108978,
0.6813604831695557,
0.1741621196269989,
-0.1425345540046692,
0.32470715045928955,
0.32203394174575806,
-0.09615596383810043,
0.48940369486808777,
0.6325761079788208,
0.05846592038869858,
0.2934260070323944,
-0.3950593173503876,
0.7099800705909729,
-0.4388463795185089,
-0.5563452243804932,
-0.7221265435218811,
0.1463201344013214,
0.06561928987503052,
-0.13183936476707458,
1.3109416961669922,
0.4257426857948303,
0.8604074716567993,
0.10057146102190018,
0.3402698338031769,
0.120377317070961,
0.46090447902679443,
-0.48538878560066223,
0.7794994711875916,
-0.6138001680374146,
0.1115594431757927,
-0.36167478561401367,
-0.7067951560020447,
-0.08079755306243896,
0.6179120540618896,
0.2593478858470917,
-0.2954272925853729,
0.681925356388092,
0.697977602481842,
-0.24503745138645172,
0.4651593267917633,
0.39348527789115906,
0.31161239743232727,
-0.09016162902116776,
0.2647324204444885,
0.839348554611206,
-0.7293650507926941,
0.19309908151626587,
-0.31918883323669434,
-0.02689109370112419,
-0.27987104654312134,
-0.8121874332427979,
-0.7601940631866455,
-0.41443660855293274,
-0.25510385632514954,
-0.7614514827728271,
0.41702452301979065,
0.768043577671051,
0.5740798711776733,
-0.9715237021446228,
0.16245095431804657,
-0.3737446069717407,
-0.036995235830545425,
-0.24549677968025208,
-0.2453557848930359,
0.2715904712677002,
-0.6877541542053223,
-0.43134260177612305,
0.5568322539329529,
0.3099598288536072,
-0.19663690030574799,
-0.17821522057056427,
-0.29438406229019165,
-0.01159539446234703,
-0.013825531117618084,
0.2835472524166107,
0.2770765721797943,
-0.8019016981124878,
-0.4395207166671753,
0.010455617681145668,
-0.13930104672908783,
-0.2858807444572449,
0.8727266788482666,
-0.6018083691596985,
0.9461572766304016,
0.6486362218856812,
0.7305930852890015,
0.31550467014312744,
0.3203614354133606,
0.4122284948825836,
-1.1204596757888794,
0.23208625614643097,
0.23054680228233337,
0.6429333686828613,
0.17797625064849854,
-0.32958632707595825,
0.2648811638355255,
0.2747306823730469,
-0.8093899488449097,
-1.0810831785202026,
0.10829859226942062,
-1.0183947086334229,
-0.059202808886766434,
1.0066581964492798,
-0.2616192102432251,
-0.46113449335098267,
-0.20355315506458282,
0.04774591699242592,
0.2994040548801422,
-0.6177772879600525,
0.43148544430732727,
0.6200541853904724,
0.17647524178028107,
0.1873476505279541,
-0.5966572761535645,
0.8387390375137329,
0.8366560339927673,
-0.5776114463806152,
0.41912809014320374,
0.8468459844589233,
0.2668294608592987,
0.3774873912334442,
0.3948271572589874,
-0.1777549386024475,
0.48227450251579285,
0.22792290151119232,
-0.09291063249111176,
-0.2600027620792389,
0.03852713480591774,
-0.31405723094940186,
0.21337300539016724,
-0.019675709307193756,
-0.42240282893180847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13677v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13677v1 | Leveraging Large Language Models to Measure Gender Bias in Gendered Languages | 2024-06-19T16:30:58 | 2024-06-19T16:30:58 | Erik Derner, Sara Sansalvador de la Fuente, Yoan Gutiérrez, Paloma Moreda, Nuria Oliver | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Gender bias in text corpora used in various natural language processing (NLP)
contexts, such as for training large language models (LLMs), can lead to the
perpetuation and amplification of societal inequalities. This is particularly
pronounced in gendered languages like Spanish or French, where grammatical
structures inherently encode gender, making the bias analysis more challenging.
Existing methods designed for English are inadequate for this task due to the
intrinsic linguistic differences between English and gendered languages. This
paper introduces a novel methodology that leverages the contextual
understanding capabilities of LLMs to quantitatively analyze gender
representation in Spanish corpora. By utilizing LLMs to identify and classify
gendered nouns and pronouns in relation to their reference to human entities,
our approach provides a nuanced analysis of gender biases. We empirically
validate our method on four widely-used benchmark datasets, uncovering
significant gender disparities with a male-to-female ratio ranging from 4:1 to
6:1. These findings demonstrate the value of our methodology for bias
quantification in gendered languages and suggest its application in NLP,
contributing to the development of more equitable language technologies. | [
-0.26346105337142944,
-0.6020848751068115,
0.42343810200691223,
0.4647057354450226,
0.22531934082508087,
0.284609317779541,
-0.3184208273887634,
-0.19151005148887634,
-0.041940100491046906,
0.2681032717227936,
-0.7420021295547485,
-0.39079031348228455,
-0.6186189651489258,
0.471566379070282,
-0.40985995531082153,
0.5336934924125671,
0.10947632789611816,
0.6003337502479553,
-0.35717806220054626,
0.016102124005556107,
-0.7067257165908813,
-0.6054178476333618,
-0.3262551426887512,
-0.3377820551395416,
0.40349212288856506,
0.24114912748336792,
0.4435596764087677,
0.32860317826271057,
0.34670957922935486,
0.26948580145835876,
-0.3375140130519867,
0.2592380940914154,
-0.3015817105770111,
0.03471244126558304,
-0.2544209063053131,
-0.456818163394928,
-0.4134041368961334,
-0.04735631123185158,
0.7845982909202576,
1.0484343767166138,
0.07822161912918091,
0.3394230604171753,
0.21881665289402008,
0.6621431708335876,
-0.5784471035003662,
0.23485536873340607,
-0.6255409121513367,
0.34913408756256104,
-0.2327069640159607,
-0.34817031025886536,
-0.3071904480457306,
-0.21652637422084808,
0.054073527455329895,
0.0006680313381366432,
0.35034361481666565,
0.18194608390331268,
0.390870600938797,
0.11419662088155746,
-0.5486350655555725,
-0.35246026515960693,
-0.5424198508262634,
1.021890640258789,
-0.6634591221809387,
0.878750205039978,
0.2773505449295044,
0.12681278586387634,
-0.2967368960380554,
-0.1901780366897583,
-0.4156135618686676,
-0.3044932782649994,
0.021329473704099655,
-0.3448748290538788,
-0.22280782461166382,
-0.40295422077178955,
0.2889140248298645,
0.10905236005783081,
-0.330226331949234,
0.2795884609222412,
-0.2192966639995575,
-0.04341007396578789,
0.38466253876686096,
-0.2982259690761566,
0.457941472530365,
-0.20268693566322327,
-0.16046974062919617,
-0.06540977954864502,
-0.8384577035903931,
-0.22299326956272125,
0.7838078737258911,
0.543451189994812,
-0.009062479250133038,
0.605404257774353,
0.24376016855239868,
0.4015403091907501,
0.13018856942653656,
-0.1480337679386139,
0.4592196047306061,
0.030184242874383926,
-0.1486792117357254,
0.13379061222076416,
0.7480143308639526,
0.2562420070171356,
0.3212238848209381,
-0.14694572985172272,
-0.09915764629840851,
-0.0273626446723938,
0.08103891462087631,
-0.5520811676979065,
0.4901735186576843,
0.03824029117822647,
-0.20955237746238708,
-0.21842242777347565,
0.021889181807637215,
-0.8319535851478577,
-0.40762677788734436,
-0.18916210532188416,
-0.21210023760795593,
0.0025909305550158024,
-0.30133724212646484,
0.08484310656785965,
-0.21569952368736267,
0.13899065554141998,
-0.007155825383961201,
-1.0992358922958374,
0.3067024350166321,
0.7910938858985901,
0.6943510174751282,
-0.012939243577420712,
-0.22109082341194153,
-0.41253697872161865,
0.17008090019226074,
-0.38672780990600586,
0.5115988850593567,
-0.4397246837615967,
-0.2822633981704712,
0.16318659484386444,
0.018433259800076485,
0.009624662809073925,
-0.6627156138420105,
0.45494017004966736,
-0.25648364424705505,
0.21188004314899445,
-0.3211616575717926,
-0.4038640558719635,
0.12349629402160645,
0.29533740878105164,
-0.7829396724700928,
1.179223656654358,
-0.10525251924991608,
-0.880603015422821,
0.43136584758758545,
-0.503581166267395,
-0.22393423318862915,
-0.2125115841627121,
-0.4781803488731384,
-0.33405131101608276,
0.20121152698993683,
0.5078582167625427,
0.673499345779419,
-0.5869336724281311,
0.7177894711494446,
-0.25147131085395813,
0.05810666084289551,
0.43756917119026184,
-0.5833827257156372,
0.7361565232276917,
-0.15814118087291718,
-0.2837613523006439,
0.06349655240774155,
-0.49991533160209656,
-0.40692850947380066,
0.11385984718799591,
-0.003483943408355117,
-0.5315934419631958,
0.1784544736146927,
0.10075929015874863,
0.19407223165035248,
0.2917238473892212,
-0.5174465775489807,
-0.15837399661540985,
-0.4672853946685791,
0.5097588896751404,
0.7025997638702393,
-0.440611869096756,
0.8177530765533447,
0.011035243049263954,
0.43621501326560974,
-0.3415237367153168,
0.016911666840314865,
0.06965143978595734,
-0.29093292355537415,
-0.49241334199905396,
-0.36469703912734985,
0.3570232689380646,
0.37816962599754333,
-0.3762723207473755,
0.6014599800109863,
-0.31021738052368164,
0.012380138970911503,
-0.3034997880458832,
0.23183433711528778,
0.30985379219055176,
0.45466601848602295,
0.19343362748622894,
-0.016931217163801193,
-0.65547776222229,
-1.1921058893203735,
-0.32899436354637146,
-0.1915619969367981,
-0.4815371632575989,
0.062006689608097076,
0.8607277870178223,
-0.31829047203063965,
1.0936611890792847,
-0.2650553584098816,
-0.3311314880847931,
-0.31425780057907104,
0.08634377270936966,
0.059488143771886826,
0.38636016845703125,
0.5780078172683716,
-0.6006661653518677,
0.1412544548511505,
-0.022628996521234512,
-0.6631094813346863,
-0.5801271200180054,
0.26809388399124146,
-0.22312788665294647,
0.06421630829572678,
0.794701874256134,
-0.09844105690717697,
0.057110775262117386,
0.8384358882904053,
-0.5336601138114929,
0.34491631388664246,
-0.001676452229730785,
-0.024120643734931946,
-0.7696564793586731,
0.09055253863334656,
0.3766781687736511,
-0.5915055274963379,
-0.4011867642402649,
0.07512140274047852,
0.23557206988334656,
0.20651763677597046,
-0.5068963766098022,
0.6517939567565918,
-0.7111698985099792,
-0.4085572063922882,
-0.040579814463853836,
0.11919617652893066,
-0.0829051062464714,
0.18709059059619904,
0.12041523307561874,
0.605124831199646,
0.012887423858046532,
-0.29687052965164185,
-0.06051643565297127,
0.19118458032608032,
-0.11820315569639206,
0.7608633637428284,
-0.6143854260444641,
0.07658424973487854,
-0.4578382074832916,
0.27923065423965454,
-0.7942131757736206,
0.0827600285410881,
0.08139295130968094,
-0.31327423453330994,
0.2064419984817505,
-0.24685904383659363,
-0.5364273190498352,
-0.3519025146961212,
-0.4697417616844177,
0.5019890666007996,
0.010550199076533318,
-0.4690251648426056,
0.49485284090042114,
0.665411114692688,
-0.12895432114601135,
-0.7789652347564697,
-0.7747460007667542,
0.017573973163962364,
-0.14461715519428253,
-0.6016109585762024,
0.342119425535202,
0.045991525053977966,
-0.4723047614097595,
-0.42003944516181946,
-0.13532380759716034,
-0.11883686482906342,
0.14107467234134674,
0.19145824015140533,
0.25224918127059937,
0.010022412054240704,
0.26723513007164,
0.2926051616668701,
0.08819165080785751,
0.20706047117710114,
-0.11348305642604828,
0.8838746547698975,
-0.19179746508598328,
-0.40884891152381897,
-0.07979526370763779,
0.41878339648246765,
0.5344018936157227,
-0.0916358008980751,
0.7939523458480835,
0.3765210509300232,
-0.6660263538360596,
-0.37429526448249817,
-0.6553642153739929,
-0.23790986835956573,
-0.40281593799591064,
0.41671812534332275,
-0.19344231486320496,
-1.1227467060089111,
0.6208305358886719,
-0.046450965106487274,
0.08010394871234894,
0.3582000136375427,
0.5620414614677429,
0.03754780814051628,
0.9851373434066772,
0.6388471722602844,
-0.2349250316619873,
0.38714638352394104,
-0.07416904717683792,
0.0010383735643699765,
-0.9141945242881775,
-0.2916494309902191,
-0.9217656850814819,
-0.18261484801769257,
-0.5838883519172668,
-0.8044970035552979,
0.1672097146511078,
-0.22987742722034454,
-0.45416638255119324,
-0.02971179038286209,
-0.14545686542987823,
0.5142625570297241,
0.4214295446872711,
-0.025736087933182716,
0.3592405617237091,
0.019166486337780952,
-0.0774962529540062,
-0.37657251954078674,
-0.700971245765686,
-0.8655600547790527,
0.9733185768127441,
0.7493618130683899,
0.33650797605514526,
0.09658073633909225,
0.25378191471099854,
0.5495307445526123,
0.23053611814975739,
-0.6516441106796265,
0.43442344665527344,
-0.2504171133041382,
-0.656011164188385,
-0.3291967511177063,
-0.5651512742042542,
-0.9009693264961243,
0.5238093733787537,
-0.2655319273471832,
-0.6089884042739868,
0.3672530949115753,
-0.06414321064949036,
0.25645360350608826,
0.2659513056278229,
-0.36434105038642883,
0.7937023639678955,
-0.19509632885456085,
-0.3922463059425354,
0.10199689865112305,
-0.2261180877685547,
0.3990802466869354,
-0.1495245397090912,
0.6510488986968994,
-0.2917824387550354,
-0.19576098024845123,
0.8791874051094055,
-0.5114365220069885,
0.9736354351043701,
0.08454836159944534,
-0.7334917783737183,
-0.2903748154640198,
0.0761229544878006,
0.17284156382083893,
0.1515456587076187,
-0.17168861627578735,
0.6409658789634705,
-0.23427742719650269,
-0.3941517770290375,
-0.23744213581085205,
0.7059864401817322,
-0.6526515483856201,
-0.1682119369506836,
-0.6389334797859192,
-0.6166720390319824,
-0.28230607509613037,
0.005366809666156769,
-0.030363278463482857,
0.19771866500377655,
-0.6434823274612427,
-0.003054702654480934,
0.6362491846084595,
-0.5985069870948792,
0.3431500196456909,
0.44759613275527954,
-0.21961215138435364,
-0.04344063624739647,
0.26858559250831604,
0.0005767439142800868,
0.07027703523635864,
0.551676332950592,
0.322468638420105,
-0.4269658923149109,
-0.13699373602867126,
-0.3899407386779785,
0.41168391704559326,
-0.48166149854660034,
-0.13671325147151947,
-0.5698993802070618,
0.14081385731697083,
-0.42785969376564026,
-0.21198850870132446,
-0.5507252812385559,
0.010284150950610638,
-0.096492238342762,
-0.2117447406053543,
0.009662682190537453,
0.45836368203163147,
0.2755514681339264,
0.27871692180633545,
-0.4633903205394745,
0.47535789012908936,
0.4452725052833557,
0.041934434324502945,
-0.017976125702261925,
-0.512660026550293,
0.24475333094596863,
0.14000429213047028,
0.06112029030919075,
-1.2526339292526245,
0.7786129117012024,
0.1647639274597168,
0.48110634088516235,
0.08485570549964905,
-0.2403993159532547,
0.41933438181877136,
-0.7186188101768494,
0.6059499382972717,
0.25145554542541504,
-1.285009503364563,
0.5730143785476685,
-0.5280891060829163,
0.2747412919998169,
0.3644917905330658,
0.2668114900588989,
-0.7008650898933411,
-0.5190517902374268,
-0.24643047153949738,
-1.0283877849578857,
0.4636375904083252,
0.3239716589450836,
0.2845037281513214,
-0.30752134323120117,
0.23466016352176666,
0.11451693624258041,
0.5451070070266724,
-0.8441305160522461,
-0.2726956307888031,
0.39497900009155273,
-0.22553887963294983,
0.005476339254528284,
-0.38867315649986267,
-0.018854061141610146,
-0.2663285732269287,
0.6512870788574219,
-0.2180713564157486,
0.3959929049015045,
0.00952650886029005,
-0.5561563372612,
0.04139794409275055,
0.4960421621799469,
0.3282589614391327,
0.8410066962242126,
-0.3109942674636841,
0.299642413854599,
0.3882144093513489,
-0.4576871395111084,
0.13511084020137787,
-0.14221706986427307,
-0.2619611620903015,
0.21111217141151428,
0.4167517125606537,
0.49628886580467224,
0.3689793646335602,
-0.7750579714775085,
0.5677165389060974,
-0.13813410699367523,
-0.12244009226560593,
-0.44503065943717957,
-0.4674910604953766,
0.14183692634105682,
0.3831959664821625,
0.5163593888282776,
-0.1743561327457428,
0.1342700719833374,
-0.6785081624984741,
-0.13304266333580017,
0.5526304244995117,
-0.37523388862609863,
-0.13586924970149994,
0.6208572387695312,
0.36078640818595886,
-0.15875236690044403,
0.2790187895298004,
-0.0707530528306961,
-0.5233330726623535,
0.784024715423584,
0.5895686149597168,
0.9265927076339722,
-0.30373889207839966,
0.4232305586338043,
0.36296242475509644,
0.6195202469825745,
-0.5285500884056091,
0.1288284957408905,
0.35336533188819885,
-0.8910885453224182,
-0.5366600751876831,
-0.5988320112228394,
-0.15548138320446014,
0.057863205671310425,
-0.49316710233688354,
0.3105921447277069,
-0.3992314338684082,
-0.24172906577587128,
-0.001499607227742672,
-0.2727857530117035,
-0.7393488883972168,
-0.13074080646038055,
0.49341100454330444,
0.544305682182312,
-1.266234278678894,
0.2547965347766876,
0.5601601600646973,
-0.04144436866044998,
-0.3589283227920532,
-0.01923871412873268,
0.18887676298618317,
-0.7329789996147156,
0.9080543518066406,
0.19657732546329498,
-0.37050116062164307,
-0.36153846979141235,
-0.3978767395019531,
-0.6452761888504028,
0.8297690749168396,
0.7650718092918396,
-1.0321277379989624,
0.16275088489055634,
0.42215412855148315,
0.5755550265312195,
-0.49316781759262085,
0.5557303428649902,
0.6758406162261963,
0.5100887417793274,
-0.3631490468978882,
-0.9807445406913757,
0.08523425459861755,
-0.20606739819049835,
0.3027760982513428,
0.1933656930923462,
-0.2832931876182556,
0.7589172720909119,
0.2930368483066559,
-0.012680244632065296,
-0.41715162992477417,
0.7798667550086975,
0.2794325649738312,
0.2977926731109619,
0.6289911270141602,
0.11603929847478867,
1.1062206029891968,
-0.12583956122398376,
0.7273613214492798,
-0.004223171155899763,
0.1956474781036377,
1.0557501316070557,
-0.3598770499229431,
0.7247961759567261,
0.6798252463340759,
-0.2733709216117859,
0.3837270140647888,
0.21550551056861877,
0.2261989265680313,
-0.12502045929431915,
0.6428312659263611,
-0.24199628829956055,
-0.1014198586344719,
-0.359801322221756,
-0.319354385137558,
0.37197160720825195,
0.3299151360988617,
-0.5648103952407837,
-0.005970739293843508,
0.19117163121700287,
0.4423923194408417,
0.432249516248703,
-0.39779502153396606,
0.3892675042152405,
0.13358797132968903,
-0.2810281813144684,
0.35607489943504333,
0.23784607648849487,
1.0820977687835693,
-0.4356846213340759,
0.13283377885818481,
-0.24567218124866486,
-0.030817680060863495,
-0.27118512988090515,
-0.511587917804718,
0.1551065593957901,
0.4663732349872589,
-0.44939979910850525,
-0.47561123967170715,
0.5983545780181885,
-0.580950915813446,
-0.9184719324111938,
0.37545865774154663,
0.8762123584747314,
-0.14184165000915527,
-0.23763763904571533,
-0.3876957595348358,
0.11002089828252792,
-0.05389377847313881,
0.014920564368367195,
0.3915430009365082,
0.3184904456138611,
-0.39846470952033997,
0.793317973613739,
0.430181622505188,
0.11614356935024261,
0.07840093225240707,
0.5937243700027466,
0.4778333902359009,
-0.6098600029945374,
-0.39518192410469055,
-1.1316297054290771,
0.1956123560667038,
-0.1944408416748047,
-0.21253271400928497,
0.8797546625137329,
0.6041641235351562,
0.7758899331092834,
-0.09355481714010239,
0.6399152278900146,
0.1047123447060585,
0.41794028878211975,
-0.33584627509117126,
0.4319436848163605,
-0.32493627071380615,
0.6327725052833557,
-0.5699712634086609,
-1.2329425811767578,
-0.5338631868362427,
0.8888439536094666,
-0.3361363708972931,
-0.0029705159831792116,
0.5438109636306763,
0.7283374667167664,
-0.05432358384132385,
-0.09927209466695786,
0.07523249834775925,
0.13824525475502014,
0.25658735632896423,
0.14757481217384338,
0.8794353008270264,
-0.35908737778663635,
0.19064494967460632,
-0.0186399444937706,
-0.2300208956003189,
-0.1663220077753067,
-1.1929172277450562,
-1.0837820768356323,
-0.32386621832847595,
-0.4776374399662018,
-0.03031577728688717,
0.20771975815296173,
1.169119954109192,
0.5974397659301758,
-0.48950642347335815,
-0.6161579489707947,
-0.037807174026966095,
0.35979342460632324,
-0.10977447032928467,
-0.16190481185913086,
0.19352979958057404,
-0.21312084794044495,
-1.1167563199996948,
0.27227190136909485,
0.08013757318258286,
-0.2864585220813751,
-0.661159873008728,
-0.02588633820414543,
-0.22223100066184998,
0.006199617870151997,
0.8223554491996765,
-0.04463423043489456,
-0.4419122636318207,
-0.09136274456977844,
0.03198797628283501,
0.058567795902490616,
-0.11694460362195969,
0.8350673317909241,
-0.5911781787872314,
0.13936343789100647,
0.7214735746383667,
0.3253380060195923,
0.2566806674003601,
-0.3639543354511261,
0.984094500541687,
-1.259995460510254,
0.2952117323875427,
0.2604213356971741,
0.47103065252304077,
0.6649325489997864,
-0.13223908841609955,
0.4777083694934845,
0.06003647670149803,
-0.3101414442062378,
-0.9601655006408691,
0.1425127387046814,
-0.910942554473877,
-0.5449227094650269,
1.3772825002670288,
0.27293041348457336,
-0.30160969495773315,
-0.08708786964416504,
-0.2895298898220062,
0.2605193555355072,
-0.6190680265426636,
0.5628292560577393,
0.5024219751358032,
0.491205096244812,
-0.07867476344108582,
-0.9299050569534302,
0.23983964323997498,
0.3160942792892456,
-0.7015368342399597,
0.09202312678098679,
0.6891613006591797,
0.1738409847021103,
-0.033128898590803146,
0.4067007899284363,
-0.27418893575668335,
-0.15244390070438385,
-0.3972286581993103,
0.3315425515174866,
0.15613670647144318,
-0.1481689065694809,
-0.4249012768268585,
0.12665079534053802,
-0.08148745447397232,
0.12418973445892334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13663v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13663v2 | Model Internals-based Answer Attribution for Trustworthy Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-19T16:10:26 | 2024-07-01T12:39:26 | Jirui Qi, Gabriele Sarti, Raquel Fernández, Arianna Bisazza | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Ensuring the verifiability of model answers is a fundamental challenge for
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) in the question answering (QA) domain.
Recently, self-citation prompting was proposed to make large language models
(LLMs) generate citations to supporting documents along with their answers.
However, self-citing LLMs often struggle to match the required format, refer to
non-existent sources, and fail to faithfully reflect LLMs' context usage
throughout the generation. In this work, we present MIRAGE --Model
Internals-based RAG Explanations -- a plug-and-play approach using model
internals for faithful answer attribution in RAG applications. MIRAGE detects
context-sensitive answer tokens and pairs them with retrieved documents
contributing to their prediction via saliency methods. We evaluate our proposed
approach on a multilingual extractive QA dataset, finding high agreement with
human answer attribution. On open-ended QA, MIRAGE achieves citation quality
and efficiency comparable to self-citation while also allowing for a
finer-grained control of attribution parameters. Our qualitative evaluation
highlights the faithfulness of MIRAGE's attributions and underscores the
promising application of model internals for RAG answer attribution. | [
-0.28476592898368835,
-0.4412590563297272,
0.9048678278923035,
0.2456400990486145,
-0.1527687907218933,
-0.05510212481021881,
0.10309295356273651,
-0.3413653075695038,
0.02850751392543316,
0.47808632254600525,
-0.4361739754676819,
-0.047508832067251205,
-0.2095436006784439,
0.18921318650245667,
-0.4727429151535034,
1.0130677223205566,
-0.07437888532876968,
0.009029417298734188,
-0.7929189801216125,
-0.0019835475832223892,
-0.2505694627761841,
-0.594196081161499,
-0.6358411312103271,
-0.12871664762496948,
0.7697350978851318,
0.5069040656089783,
0.5229276418685913,
0.41895902156829834,
0.41351303458213806,
0.2556490898132324,
0.0342809297144413,
0.3921903073787689,
-0.40063321590423584,
0.4544937312602997,
-0.5212225914001465,
-0.45368197560310364,
-0.14702248573303223,
-0.09820260852575302,
0.6900115609169006,
-0.016188157722353935,
-0.10151145607233047,
0.6570677757263184,
0.05542946979403496,
0.4693106412887573,
-0.8157232999801636,
-0.13889779150485992,
-1.061894416809082,
-0.44910928606987,
-0.17736834287643433,
-0.37067461013793945,
-0.3976079821586609,
-0.5001128315925598,
-0.1622413992881775,
-0.4668094217777252,
0.22189593315124512,
0.021094217896461487,
0.9723243117332458,
0.4642244577407837,
-0.31882068514823914,
-0.3656502962112427,
-0.5714594721794128,
0.6461983919143677,
-0.8036569356918335,
0.21842244267463684,
0.37213772535324097,
0.5183264017105103,
-0.12653300166130066,
-0.71587735414505,
-0.5591980218887329,
-0.22358599305152893,
-0.1319810301065445,
0.05462067946791649,
0.16744597256183624,
-0.5807956457138062,
-0.09052574634552002,
0.2953767776489258,
-0.3989628851413727,
-0.12080763280391693,
-0.2654240131378174,
0.020582789555191994,
0.6227563619613647,
0.013460474088788033,
-0.041537538170814514,
-0.48722749948501587,
-0.638446569442749,
0.0475778691470623,
-1.1367931365966797,
0.08983742445707321,
0.3023177683353424,
0.28535139560699463,
0.026966216042637825,
0.6655783653259277,
0.03591866418719292,
0.46876704692840576,
0.08746152371168137,
-0.015122857876121998,
-0.14399977028369904,
-0.42009252309799194,
0.00002020489046117291,
-0.1682910919189453,
0.6767985224723816,
-0.04767531529068947,
0.39959976077079773,
-0.32673680782318115,
-0.41459131240844727,
-0.5194962620735168,
0.5168395638465881,
-0.7116000056266785,
-0.13187530636787415,
0.3520577847957611,
-0.3523118495941162,
-0.5638754367828369,
-0.02036248706281185,
-0.6526858806610107,
-0.38588035106658936,
-0.2535802721977234,
0.6586580872535706,
-0.24812252819538116,
-0.33076056838035583,
-0.4146687984466553,
-0.007319394964724779,
0.2759895324707031,
0.3403371274471283,
-0.3093312084674835,
0.06997600942850113,
0.4937468469142914,
0.8491600751876831,
-0.24911876022815704,
0.025892162695527077,
-0.5518350601196289,
0.4934232831001282,
-0.3253246247768402,
1.0751932859420776,
-0.46954718232154846,
-0.4799392521381378,
0.02446668967604637,
-0.2745692729949951,
0.1235598772764206,
-0.5150696039199829,
0.6222596168518066,
-0.8428899645805359,
0.41806212067604065,
-0.6169266700744629,
-0.45251041650772095,
-0.09335686266422272,
0.3945750892162323,
-0.45474007725715637,
1.2785478830337524,
0.06254315376281738,
-0.8822550773620605,
0.10798773914575577,
-0.576102077960968,
0.04930701479315758,
-0.029782645404338837,
-0.22054798901081085,
-0.4590408205986023,
0.2820943295955658,
0.40307483077049255,
0.36908063292503357,
-0.34228941798210144,
0.20315077900886536,
-0.3819586932659149,
-0.16418889164924622,
0.8002636432647705,
-0.709947407245636,
0.7824063301086426,
0.352737694978714,
0.02142440527677536,
0.1058182418346405,
-0.6495442390441895,
0.1611664742231369,
0.4000275433063507,
-0.14685748517513275,
-0.39290398359298706,
-0.043722644448280334,
-0.10406985133886337,
0.3934246301651001,
0.4947454333305359,
-0.5024349093437195,
0.0592132993042469,
-0.22054922580718994,
-0.18235209584236145,
0.7804691195487976,
0.3294571042060852,
0.17573679983615875,
-0.26950448751449585,
0.6336320638656616,
0.00385592901147902,
-0.03470597788691521,
-0.41472089290618896,
-0.4638881981372833,
-0.5144808888435364,
-0.24230702221393585,
0.3597034215927124,
0.3980129063129425,
-0.9670567512512207,
-0.2281671166419983,
-0.3827981650829315,
-0.41411054134368896,
-0.5152791142463684,
0.09853941202163696,
0.6616799831390381,
0.9270215034484863,
0.3962990641593933,
0.08994810283184052,
-0.283594012260437,
-0.9841281771659851,
-0.4527707099914551,
-0.2949570119380951,
-0.10516013950109482,
0.550041913986206,
0.49527859687805176,
0.1279485523700714,
1.20975661277771,
-0.33340999484062195,
-0.12837642431259155,
0.1529960185289383,
0.11028282344341278,
0.08014064282178879,
0.3440383970737457,
0.6386243104934692,
-0.9114119410514832,
-0.6916402578353882,
-0.17736777663230896,
-0.8208328485488892,
-0.21306438744068146,
0.04564705491065979,
-0.214319109916687,
0.056975457817316055,
0.4724166691303253,
-0.25956130027770996,
0.27839481830596924,
0.4798433184623718,
-0.34666502475738525,
0.7591163516044617,
-0.21234917640686035,
0.2591494917869568,
-1.2249491214752197,
0.3696311414241791,
-0.01616339385509491,
-0.47380825877189636,
-0.33474233746528625,
0.39716407656669617,
0.11639507114887238,
0.020078441128134727,
-0.543507993221283,
0.9590850472450256,
-0.468466192483902,
-0.2634138762950897,
-0.3537306487560272,
0.16647395491600037,
0.20686912536621094,
0.21210163831710815,
-0.06681492179632187,
1.2161699533462524,
0.2131849080324173,
-0.5754795074462891,
0.1808771789073944,
0.24035508930683136,
0.07499920576810837,
0.6688820123672485,
-0.8036904335021973,
0.14136527478694916,
-0.1768050193786621,
0.2396850287914276,
-1.1491787433624268,
-0.31919559836387634,
0.16538813710212708,
-0.5686324834823608,
0.3525424897670746,
-0.4060989320278168,
-0.7319160103797913,
-0.23608282208442688,
-0.18720023334026337,
0.48362988233566284,
0.3426491618156433,
-0.852084219455719,
0.708199143409729,
0.21806733310222626,
-0.33448994159698486,
-0.5527148246765137,
-0.3127409815788269,
0.018054798245429993,
-0.44507864117622375,
-0.8078919649124146,
0.1939210444688797,
-0.11156982183456421,
-0.3277646601200104,
-0.04019702225923538,
-0.07797461748123169,
-0.36337965726852417,
0.15582750737667084,
0.16873881220817566,
0.4126718044281006,
-0.2577376067638397,
0.25055238604545593,
0.06238612160086632,
-0.02415119670331478,
0.2927149534225464,
0.07346536964178085,
0.1531069129705429,
-0.1538679450750351,
-0.4590199589729309,
-0.12664677202701569,
0.4687415659427643,
0.44950568675994873,
-0.524539589881897,
0.8148131370544434,
0.48315250873565674,
-0.15588635206222534,
-0.08995892852544785,
-0.7725073099136353,
-0.3763273060321808,
-0.4950859546661377,
-0.08498954027891159,
-0.5763255953788757,
-0.5431665182113647,
0.8453471660614014,
-0.030629495158791542,
0.2540716826915741,
0.6590097546577454,
0.5990881323814392,
-0.17224887013435364,
0.8272338509559631,
0.3396034240722656,
0.2842765748500824,
0.2704203426837921,
0.07517567276954651,
-0.16632144153118134,
-0.9928790926933289,
-0.27683505415916443,
-0.8107908964157104,
-0.06239381432533264,
-0.07159855961799622,
-0.5099595189094543,
0.677423357963562,
0.09767358750104904,
-0.19327467679977417,
-0.11658207327127457,
-0.5934350490570068,
0.47569984197616577,
0.5285300612449646,
-0.06847575306892395,
0.4911614954471588,
-0.0005660264869220555,
0.10427284985780716,
-0.10037074238061905,
-0.5795886516571045,
-0.5317364931106567,
1.179304599761963,
0.4496156871318817,
0.7556650042533875,
0.4923652112483978,
0.8304160833358765,
0.047779496759176254,
0.6010961532592773,
-0.173716738820076,
0.24799996614456177,
0.19313110411167145,
-0.862851083278656,
-0.29482555389404297,
-0.36899223923683167,
-0.6010544300079346,
0.40007954835891724,
-0.20412689447402954,
-0.7427224516868591,
0.1752413958311081,
0.19584088027477264,
-0.32038846611976624,
-0.011411286890506744,
-0.5028212070465088,
0.716679036617279,
-0.11942759901285172,
-0.6036732196807861,
0.040130507200956345,
-0.4408641457557678,
0.7124760150909424,
-0.2680153250694275,
0.24268022179603577,
-0.03803300857543945,
-0.0809096023440361,
0.5253520011901855,
-0.3369385898113251,
0.6167852282524109,
-0.1874585598707199,
-0.5431299209594727,
0.521543025970459,
0.3220292925834656,
0.8319911956787109,
0.3990514576435089,
-0.2794536352157593,
-0.05267271026968956,
0.0786166787147522,
-0.11002344638109207,
-0.8081139922142029,
0.9594278335571289,
-0.4632110595703125,
-0.6780098676681519,
-0.35643258690834045,
-0.414934903383255,
-0.3714762330055237,
0.04032152518630028,
0.4152434468269348,
0.49159878492355347,
0.05822329595685005,
0.051592867821455,
0.8973062634468079,
0.015693867579102516,
0.2767479717731476,
0.6878072023391724,
-0.6090722680091858,
-0.27617716789245605,
1.108418583869934,
-0.1519089937210083,
0.19054311513900757,
-0.06634227186441422,
0.2673620283603668,
-0.6427246928215027,
-0.4459260106086731,
-0.8550158739089966,
0.506663978099823,
-0.8276997804641724,
-0.4777079224586487,
-0.47100526094436646,
-0.24939586222171783,
-0.23014262318611145,
-0.1616360992193222,
-0.47925275564193726,
-0.36168456077575684,
-0.47734197974205017,
0.21066977083683014,
0.450703501701355,
0.8114953637123108,
0.1208297610282898,
0.06527129560709,
-0.8340488076210022,
0.4565503001213074,
0.34012362360954285,
0.2659287750720978,
0.10646437853574753,
-0.961320698261261,
-0.37974587082862854,
0.2002885341644287,
-0.21735621988773346,
-1.1740309000015259,
0.28366509079933167,
0.2471894919872284,
0.56576007604599,
0.1864130049943924,
-0.005271124187856913,
0.807466447353363,
-0.5777777433395386,
1.0203657150268555,
-0.18414545059204102,
-0.7166569828987122,
0.5621514916419983,
-0.5094740390777588,
0.16340869665145874,
0.5812167525291443,
0.3684597909450531,
-0.045879002660512924,
-0.6651210784912109,
-0.779082179069519,
-0.7522903680801392,
0.38867151737213135,
0.26640424132347107,
0.14136174321174622,
0.026712696999311447,
0.7997260093688965,
0.0932428166270256,
0.07281944155693054,
-0.7558119893074036,
-0.34694093465805054,
-0.2130972146987915,
-0.1070869192481041,
0.173377126455307,
-0.39344725012779236,
-0.34178805351257324,
0.08143174648284912,
0.907274067401886,
-0.38446110486984253,
0.1350308507680893,
0.3911340832710266,
0.042367998510599136,
-0.24385984241962433,
0.1136222630739212,
0.5962498784065247,
0.7244674563407898,
-0.05024552345275879,
0.06322453916072845,
0.051920294761657715,
0.041249651461839676,
0.05021429806947708,
-0.05642019957304001,
-0.3036330044269562,
0.28460246324539185,
0.033601291477680206,
0.1485099494457245,
0.2990860641002655,
-0.46625810861587524,
0.7545555233955383,
-0.11872325837612152,
0.22146236896514893,
-0.6184274554252625,
-0.09337181597948074,
0.15541879832744598,
0.21974802017211914,
0.6794381141662598,
-0.2360488921403885,
0.38693392276763916,
-0.23466643691062927,
0.28619474172592163,
0.8493506908416748,
-0.28030329942703247,
-0.13627874851226807,
0.871554434299469,
0.0886768028140068,
0.04780185595154762,
0.30026960372924805,
-0.08765749633312225,
-0.4111834764480591,
0.3872188329696655,
0.6746017932891846,
0.8988524079322815,
-0.3855675756931305,
0.256053626537323,
0.5128836035728455,
-0.08037547767162323,
-0.01367602776736021,
0.2318859100341797,
-0.0033890672493726015,
-0.4637458622455597,
-0.4750720262527466,
-0.7175636291503906,
-0.4671550393104553,
-0.18036536872386932,
-0.6224966645240784,
0.06508493423461914,
-0.10650787502527237,
0.04964800179004669,
-0.30348026752471924,
-0.3374209403991699,
-0.5393708944320679,
0.2847232520580292,
0.2749846875667572,
0.8465371131896973,
-0.6966718435287476,
0.7971854209899902,
0.550218403339386,
-0.7895801067352295,
-0.8876096606254578,
-0.02237929403781891,
-0.07542544603347778,
-0.5887657999992371,
0.7739355564117432,
-0.22581066191196442,
-0.2463914304971695,
-0.01768486388027668,
-0.8053995370864868,
-1.412326693534851,
1.0831693410873413,
0.5027377605438232,
0.06151052191853523,
-0.24772322177886963,
-0.2581098675727844,
0.3797599673271179,
-0.4336182177066803,
0.4354347884654999,
0.004086026456207037,
0.3887391984462738,
0.4991459548473358,
-0.9634267091751099,
0.13384507596492767,
-0.09733203053474426,
0.021226491779088974,
-0.18684595823287964,
-0.4336055815219879,
0.8086446523666382,
-0.16687263548374176,
-0.2154049128293991,
0.1457030475139618,
1.2102973461151123,
0.6594483852386475,
0.06822486221790314,
0.27776989340782166,
0.2968286871910095,
0.667120635509491,
0.11231936514377594,
1.277077078819275,
-0.19694484770298004,
0.23848171532154083,
1.4858182668685913,
0.011739039793610573,
1.2180993556976318,
0.6265950798988342,
-0.10316544771194458,
1.0673774480819702,
0.4249740242958069,
0.2962420880794525,
0.46002402901649475,
-0.011081702075898647,
-0.2658844292163849,
-0.28710824251174927,
-0.12311917543411255,
-0.4110574722290039,
0.3445664048194885,
0.3163134753704071,
-0.5660313367843628,
-0.3922306001186371,
-0.27623283863067627,
0.05070827528834343,
0.16887597739696503,
-0.37007781863212585,
0.7960928678512573,
0.179149329662323,
-0.790785551071167,
0.5489183068275452,
-0.1082100048661232,
0.41074448823928833,
-0.6373106837272644,
-0.1750413477420807,
-0.05192188173532486,
0.01380823366343975,
-0.2902801036834717,
-0.9537269473075867,
0.3469327390193939,
0.08867339044809341,
-0.30577537417411804,
-0.18650364875793457,
0.748188316822052,
-0.5357146263122559,
-0.500076949596405,
-0.23642730712890625,
0.5997017621994019,
0.2231864333152771,
-0.42399224638938904,
-0.6462922096252441,
-0.21561935544013977,
-0.014573381282389164,
-0.4541965425014496,
0.32176822423934937,
0.5927199721336365,
-0.06352108716964722,
0.9426375031471252,
0.8035900592803955,
-0.02052130736410618,
0.2629508376121521,
-0.367298424243927,
0.8708933591842651,
-0.21569447219371796,
-0.4733488857746124,
-0.5477847456932068,
0.9135696291923523,
-0.26221638917922974,
-0.235189288854599,
1.1804929971694946,
0.47576621174812317,
0.25958046317100525,
-0.08138946443796158,
0.6242480874061584,
0.29446306824684143,
0.8937455415725708,
-0.485820472240448,
0.696869969367981,
-0.8857959508895874,
0.31050193309783936,
-0.24331915378570557,
-1.130353331565857,
-0.023222319781780243,
0.4763357937335968,
-0.08488908410072327,
0.05948901176452637,
0.37270498275756836,
0.7233315706253052,
-0.22155722975730896,
-0.39793235063552856,
0.1630907505750656,
0.03105323016643524,
0.491292268037796,
0.11233814805746078,
0.623055100440979,
-0.3613314926624298,
0.5097849369049072,
-0.0011978201800957322,
-0.09865328669548035,
-0.2923928499221802,
-1.097158670425415,
-0.6452793478965759,
-0.7591285705566406,
-0.2928212285041809,
-0.6585279703140259,
-0.10055387765169144,
0.5349703431129456,
0.3463585376739502,
-0.6476216316223145,
0.04000945761799812,
0.19258594512939453,
0.16786305606365204,
0.1047820895910263,
-0.30917343497276306,
0.3962557911872864,
-0.5832923650741577,
-0.5338587164878845,
0.6294582486152649,
0.05518762394785881,
0.09220925718545914,
-0.8950343132019043,
-0.003866848535835743,
-0.16658136248588562,
0.3887816369533539,
0.26337456703186035,
0.5123795866966248,
-0.9639802575111389,
-0.3710114657878876,
-0.014759695157408714,
-0.25839537382125854,
0.02147500030696392,
0.680378258228302,
-1.1377599239349365,
0.4603145122528076,
0.3766637444496155,
0.5095978379249573,
0.36758196353912354,
0.4986400902271271,
0.7730584144592285,
-0.9660816788673401,
-0.24247236549854279,
0.2586228847503662,
0.25510185956954956,
0.5193015336990356,
-0.5184319019317627,
0.5032961964607239,
-0.14023764431476593,
-0.873149573802948,
-0.9201877117156982,
0.2316911369562149,
-0.6578301787376404,
-0.2659660279750824,
1.3811242580413818,
-0.3595368564128876,
-0.3062277138233185,
-0.1909712851047516,
-0.21911773085594177,
-0.08574298769235611,
-0.32580411434173584,
0.8502644300460815,
0.5785627365112305,
0.019812902435660362,
-0.22406047582626343,
-0.3063337504863739,
0.6687939167022705,
0.30362793803215027,
-0.8481047749519348,
0.2342669665813446,
0.5557912588119507,
0.36952197551727295,
0.4963991343975067,
0.6034645438194275,
-0.22346678376197815,
0.38004937767982483,
-0.09026489406824112,
0.034457165747880936,
-0.29168862104415894,
-0.3715980350971222,
-0.33639946579933167,
0.27636992931365967,
0.29942020773887634,
0.10761506855487823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13662v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13662v1 | ObscurePrompt: Jailbreaking Large Language Models via Obscure Input | 2024-06-19T16:09:58 | 2024-06-19T16:09:58 | Yue Huang, Jingyu Tang, Dongping Chen, Bingda Tang, Yao Wan, Lichao Sun, Xiangliang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have garnered significant attention
for their exceptional natural language processing capabilities. However,
concerns about their trustworthiness remain unresolved, particularly in
addressing "jailbreaking" attacks on aligned LLMs. Previous research
predominantly relies on scenarios with white-box LLMs or specific and fixed
prompt templates, which are often impractical and lack broad applicability. In
this paper, we introduce a straightforward and novel method, named
ObscurePrompt, for jailbreaking LLMs, inspired by the observed fragile
alignments in Out-of-Distribution (OOD) data. Specifically, we first formulate
the decision boundary in the jailbreaking process and then explore how obscure
text affects LLM's ethical decision boundary. ObscurePrompt starts with
constructing a base prompt that integrates well-known jailbreaking techniques.
Powerful LLMs are then utilized to obscure the original prompt through
iterative transformations, aiming to bolster the attack's robustness.
Comprehensive experiments show that our approach substantially improves upon
previous methods in terms of attack effectiveness, maintaining efficacy against
two prevalent defense mechanisms. We believe that our work can offer fresh
insights for future research on enhancing LLM alignment. | [
-0.285606324672699,
-1.0687021017074585,
0.9353469610214233,
0.03404644876718521,
-0.3026188910007477,
0.17268207669258118,
-0.25131893157958984,
-0.4967033267021179,
0.31474992632865906,
0.658277690410614,
-0.7585852742195129,
-0.42177894711494446,
-0.757557213306427,
-0.015137859620153904,
-0.23360979557037354,
0.8695541024208069,
-0.11170780658721924,
-0.06470099091529846,
0.16213583946228027,
-0.34039995074272156,
-0.5275635719299316,
-0.25721073150634766,
-0.26265430450439453,
0.1833667904138565,
0.3940938711166382,
0.456973135471344,
0.9078467488288879,
0.7763209939002991,
0.5498234033584595,
0.22995908558368683,
-0.1530526876449585,
0.10201454162597656,
-0.5826520323753357,
0.29837357997894287,
-0.37970441579818726,
-0.32423630356788635,
-0.23335599899291992,
-0.1280222088098526,
0.5195252299308777,
0.5769942998886108,
-0.14052455127239227,
-0.00045735377352684736,
0.10084285587072372,
0.6564228534698486,
-0.9941177368164062,
-0.2542620301246643,
-0.8640586733818054,
-0.15438620746135712,
-0.5194735527038574,
0.17807891964912415,
-0.5966578125953674,
-0.43924760818481445,
-0.24440313875675201,
-0.3143569231033325,
-0.03147934004664421,
0.18214334547519684,
0.6018525958061218,
0.2735605835914612,
0.1318821907043457,
-0.310078501701355,
-0.5993689298629761,
0.5198987126350403,
-0.721953272819519,
0.0742419883608818,
0.442508339881897,
0.4087798297405243,
-0.6301670074462891,
-0.3422378599643707,
-0.5588988065719604,
-0.37444567680358887,
0.04499109089374542,
-0.1902076005935669,
-0.5700909495353699,
-0.012927403673529625,
0.18169747292995453,
0.12818807363510132,
-0.5278148055076599,
0.4384785592556,
-0.17026056349277496,
-0.15710699558258057,
0.4323272109031677,
0.05794130638241768,
0.4090994596481323,
0.0031793632078915834,
-0.5127718448638916,
0.1996108740568161,
-1.056318759918213,
0.10094479471445084,
0.8283897638320923,
0.21228072047233582,
-0.08775698393583298,
0.7707857489585876,
0.0017382190562784672,
0.812703013420105,
0.0969332680106163,
0.10381288826465607,
-0.0034502195194363594,
0.05742783099412918,
-0.08161772787570953,
0.2589966654777527,
1.0357890129089355,
0.13782070577144623,
0.010492335073649883,
-0.3584684133529663,
-0.20324428379535675,
-0.2995874285697937,
0.1432729959487915,
-0.5050640106201172,
0.04036174714565277,
0.3970370590686798,
-0.19788046181201935,
-0.3975664973258972,
0.2312326580286026,
-0.6820449829101562,
-1.0356286764144897,
0.30471307039260864,
0.4433973729610443,
-0.6699187755584717,
0.029063116759061813,
-0.035519737750291824,
-0.08650552481412888,
0.02569453977048397,
0.21855393052101135,
-0.7834928035736084,
0.12316903471946716,
0.735503077507019,
0.8179119825363159,
-0.000977459829300642,
-0.13274390995502472,
-0.8880711793899536,
0.2038545161485672,
-0.15974894165992737,
0.4533502757549286,
-0.6585715413093567,
-0.18855923414230347,
-0.2849130630493164,
-0.09222131222486496,
0.22700291872024536,
-0.6095295548439026,
0.6151037812232971,
-0.4823809564113617,
-0.13863587379455566,
-0.04220322147011757,
-0.4946431815624237,
0.09497019648551941,
0.18067790567874908,
-0.8788892030715942,
0.6454952955245972,
-0.013717640191316605,
-0.8827138543128967,
0.010674521327018738,
-0.4443053901195526,
-0.0814998671412468,
0.0020340585615485907,
-0.2184196263551712,
-0.3809318542480469,
0.25672730803489685,
0.3311978280544281,
0.2780552804470062,
-0.08338787406682968,
0.37422388792037964,
-0.7871902585029602,
-0.22522449493408203,
0.5082723498344421,
-0.5467853546142578,
1.0032577514648438,
0.2874581217765808,
-0.4349486231803894,
-0.10419774055480957,
-0.6912975907325745,
-0.2556755542755127,
0.31004583835601807,
0.1800370216369629,
-0.7515254616737366,
-0.06753091514110565,
-0.35174188017845154,
-0.1368819624185562,
0.36322298645973206,
-0.800216019153595,
0.5487228035926819,
-0.6418311595916748,
0.5626263618469238,
0.8411178588867188,
0.07554659247398376,
0.5374671220779419,
-0.12308760732412338,
0.5942808389663696,
-0.19529449939727783,
0.2772039473056793,
-0.1328306496143341,
-0.433364599943161,
-0.11935682594776154,
-0.5743213891983032,
0.2472476363182068,
0.5768585801124573,
-0.660037100315094,
0.4608455300331116,
0.10861033201217651,
-0.5783305764198303,
-0.7905169129371643,
0.2817227244377136,
0.41218411922454834,
0.412887305021286,
0.20998917520046234,
-0.19658492505550385,
-0.5367096066474915,
-0.8622875213623047,
-0.8591369986534119,
-0.06590141355991364,
0.10011207312345505,
-0.06846635788679123,
0.18317992985248566,
-0.211094468832016,
1.0275262594223022,
-0.5619724988937378,
-0.27880746126174927,
-0.3916173577308655,
-0.046165309846401215,
0.4323897957801819,
0.6134513020515442,
0.5436194539070129,
-0.45198309421539307,
-0.24316564202308655,
-0.33322346210479736,
-0.4238627851009369,
-0.2014620453119278,
-0.1490696221590042,
-0.03107965923845768,
-0.06466764956712723,
0.8139461278915405,
-0.8951895236968994,
0.48317983746528625,
0.41903597116470337,
-0.4488656222820282,
0.6251394152641296,
-0.13382187485694885,
-0.20911292731761932,
-0.7866578102111816,
-0.18721304833889008,
-0.23411035537719727,
-0.305843710899353,
-0.5864845514297485,
0.47239789366722107,
0.24942846596240997,
-0.04747671261429787,
-0.48702389001846313,
0.6612829566001892,
-0.5421040058135986,
0.3593389093875885,
-0.12518362700939178,
0.17204274237155914,
-0.10646098107099533,
0.06120428815484047,
-0.2845105528831482,
0.48635169863700867,
0.6258156895637512,
-0.14887021481990814,
0.016912201419472694,
0.1546582728624344,
-0.3812961280345917,
0.5161041617393494,
-0.4658884108066559,
0.341117262840271,
-0.31201133131980896,
0.026769651100039482,
-1.0896952152252197,
-0.21999366581439972,
0.5957469344139099,
-0.38481953740119934,
0.5007557272911072,
-0.3607330024242401,
-0.5428240895271301,
0.035190921276807785,
-0.5578640103340149,
0.5400046706199646,
0.5596445798873901,
-0.7001378536224365,
0.5174784660339355,
0.22167478501796722,
-0.28400129079818726,
-0.7651169896125793,
-0.485760897397995,
0.21820232272148132,
-0.5750058889389038,
-0.4043619632720947,
0.27313289046287537,
-0.06615398079156876,
-0.6775531768798828,
-0.07514186948537827,
-0.15946020185947418,
-0.06053733080625534,
0.2220279425382614,
0.33439287543296814,
0.2721068859100342,
-0.19111047685146332,
-0.30940380692481995,
-0.020378369837999344,
0.11953362077474594,
0.10266850143671036,
-0.26697736978530884,
0.4790801405906677,
0.04911315441131592,
-0.4709550440311432,
-0.2788351774215698,
0.41955217719078064,
0.6108865141868591,
-0.17174696922302246,
0.8364269137382507,
0.21359862387180328,
-0.22681595385074615,
-0.43147337436676025,
-0.48709601163864136,
-0.028710652142763138,
-0.559662401676178,
0.27089574933052063,
-0.034819308668375015,
-0.7278109192848206,
0.5551577210426331,
-0.04063204675912857,
0.07784218341112137,
0.07394494116306305,
0.31714898347854614,
-0.0845833495259285,
0.9645323753356934,
0.6488136649131775,
-0.10346691310405731,
0.47220689058303833,
0.37101858854293823,
0.33772724866867065,
-0.6942458748817444,
-0.10510019212961197,
-0.47677984833717346,
-0.3097821772098541,
-0.4200628697872162,
-0.34140345454216003,
0.27121081948280334,
0.47905510663986206,
-0.10567783564329147,
0.4323018789291382,
-0.10273519903421402,
0.723667562007904,
0.2178267538547516,
0.2704329788684845,
0.29320600628852844,
-0.2893100380897522,
-0.2306702435016632,
-0.12594108283519745,
-0.4284307062625885,
-0.3759201765060425,
1.0230517387390137,
0.4676179587841034,
0.8810558915138245,
0.4070602357387543,
1.0217766761779785,
0.2422262579202652,
0.2433692216873169,
-0.7242639660835266,
0.39528071880340576,
-0.1195860430598259,
-0.4429264962673187,
-0.22626546025276184,
-0.3613851070404053,
-0.8983638286590576,
0.08444398641586304,
-0.03246629238128662,
-1.3043746948242188,
0.1282912939786911,
0.269529789686203,
-0.5237064957618713,
0.4963012635707855,
-0.8211414217948914,
0.7306814193725586,
-0.2586911916732788,
-0.38860276341438293,
0.3291161358356476,
-0.7727587223052979,
0.7307033538818359,
-0.20783548057079315,
0.7252037525177002,
-0.07922045141458511,
0.034879282116889954,
0.5308598875999451,
-0.9840133786201477,
0.9938492774963379,
-0.23539817333221436,
-0.24722057580947876,
0.11907457560300827,
0.4619215428829193,
1.0478286743164062,
0.2515026330947876,
0.004213176667690277,
0.06489754468202591,
-0.3464961349964142,
-0.2981070876121521,
-0.728675127029419,
0.6746116280555725,
-0.42107945680618286,
-0.878754198551178,
-0.11392511427402496,
-0.6842104196548462,
-0.41743409633636475,
0.35906466841697693,
0.44810986518859863,
0.20472721755504608,
-0.23321442306041718,
-0.15756337344646454,
0.8415039777755737,
-0.20280379056930542,
0.4911525845527649,
0.5761029720306396,
-0.12146393954753876,
-0.39479532837867737,
0.7507712841033936,
-0.01451196614652872,
0.4749174416065216,
0.3443259596824646,
0.3655218780040741,
-0.22293296456336975,
-0.6994864344596863,
-0.5550529956817627,
0.10858247429132462,
-0.7846247553825378,
-0.24304330348968506,
-0.5049182772636414,
-0.05036581680178642,
-0.30318066477775574,
-0.31105494499206543,
-0.4963151216506958,
-0.59926837682724,
-0.20909470319747925,
-0.047958601266145706,
0.5722569823265076,
0.7130443453788757,
0.029344091191887856,
0.35203006863594055,
-0.8202807307243347,
0.4615635871887207,
-0.18269512057304382,
0.31522464752197266,
-0.24352943897247314,
-0.6773128509521484,
0.2511323094367981,
-0.18917042016983032,
-0.08789405971765518,
-1.209704041481018,
0.30371028184890747,
0.03597322478890419,
0.5993784666061401,
0.7158880829811096,
0.5629829168319702,
0.5838091373443604,
-0.6955505609512329,
0.5068682432174683,
0.32739514112472534,
-0.9519632458686829,
0.4818226993083954,
-0.29774200916290283,
0.20418237149715424,
0.8158029317855835,
0.20966918766498566,
-0.07858776301145554,
-1.0898263454437256,
-0.7820237874984741,
-1.1749846935272217,
0.6401636600494385,
0.20261795818805695,
0.08328916877508163,
0.18781808018684387,
0.3892982006072998,
0.49099022150039673,
0.060423411428928375,
-0.7133593559265137,
-0.4195139706134796,
0.059258002787828445,
-0.4523268938064575,
0.09745192527770996,
-0.15487800538539886,
-0.25493794679641724,
-0.14854936301708221,
0.27733349800109863,
0.2200169563293457,
-0.13625773787498474,
0.14177973568439484,
-0.29582008719444275,
0.0801599770784378,
0.5037645101547241,
0.5242266058921814,
0.5140315890312195,
-0.27156516909599304,
0.45683741569519043,
-0.1540021151304245,
-0.8060812950134277,
0.24171346426010132,
0.1031888946890831,
-0.334575355052948,
0.0672946572303772,
0.38444316387176514,
0.6951072216033936,
0.13898897171020508,
-0.9696559309959412,
0.5900475382804871,
0.030411088839173317,
0.09942613542079926,
-0.31827986240386963,
0.21852852404117584,
-0.17688123881816864,
0.34600064158439636,
0.22842642664909363,
0.3587898313999176,
0.01528981328010559,
-0.6338849663734436,
0.16588842868804932,
0.5903339385986328,
-0.6362106800079346,
-0.15653684735298157,
0.7355490326881409,
-0.2577580511569977,
-0.3854413330554962,
0.3415340483188629,
-0.42344552278518677,
-0.3086738586425781,
0.4958221912384033,
0.6650829911231995,
0.936662495136261,
-0.19229896366596222,
0.10543186962604523,
-0.09692883491516113,
0.7268164157867432,
-0.25807398557662964,
0.22950828075408936,
0.13263152539730072,
-0.5768123269081116,
-0.1958986222743988,
-0.3771994113922119,
-0.3023410737514496,
0.32937800884246826,
-0.8230519890785217,
0.4466261863708496,
-0.7691831588745117,
0.1212940588593483,
-0.10528934746980667,
-0.6519420742988586,
-0.3054400086402893,
-0.2772427499294281,
0.07185184955596924,
1.072213053703308,
-0.6425248384475708,
0.8376918435096741,
0.5042404532432556,
-0.061009731143713,
-0.7785288095474243,
0.3301587700843811,
0.2006770521402359,
-0.9390364289283752,
0.2504402697086334,
0.16578154265880585,
-0.051715850830078125,
0.03569465130567551,
-0.8613075017929077,
-0.8732090592384338,
0.6034667491912842,
0.8531078100204468,
-0.8854498267173767,
0.23738405108451843,
0.0063255419954657555,
0.03286397084593773,
-0.11596554517745972,
0.05743894726037979,
0.9202887415885925,
0.5914009809494019,
-0.06572047621011734,
-0.6660758852958679,
0.4976208508014679,
-0.1616942584514618,
-0.5747435092926025,
0.490481436252594,
-0.3868720531463623,
0.7150092124938965,
-0.6720238327980042,
-0.12184138596057892,
0.2765827178955078,
0.28888359665870667,
0.6332268714904785,
0.2565009295940399,
0.3234148323535919,
0.6271945238113403,
0.8450292944908142,
0.043295010924339294,
0.8460333347320557,
0.12279536575078964,
0.15487413108348846,
1.3910425901412964,
-0.4254226088523865,
0.7903698086738586,
0.8304075002670288,
0.07022016495466232,
0.47169163823127747,
0.26487037539482117,
-0.0867854580283165,
0.8331707715988159,
0.2688986659049988,
-0.059312328696250916,
0.01626507006585598,
0.21033407747745514,
-0.2467743456363678,
0.4947297275066376,
0.420215368270874,
-0.349134624004364,
-0.4696684181690216,
0.14028915762901306,
0.5086125135421753,
0.19804266095161438,
-0.46724167466163635,
0.6270987391471863,
0.10127317160367966,
-0.3600568175315857,
0.6237221360206604,
0.2230486273765564,
0.613797664642334,
-0.7159783840179443,
0.017300860956311226,
-0.15137754380702972,
0.09262015670537949,
-0.1511499434709549,
-0.6788841485977173,
0.12153060734272003,
0.3024897873401642,
-0.1355307549238205,
-0.09376386553049088,
0.3886265158653259,
-0.15749403834342957,
-0.36680468916893005,
0.15934856235980988,
0.10235543549060822,
-0.04245493933558464,
-0.23490864038467407,
-0.4315109848976135,
0.3240910470485687,
-0.04491136968135834,
-0.30509111285209656,
0.5250046253204346,
0.5572811961174011,
-0.2713773250579834,
0.4754030704498291,
0.4921872913837433,
0.2953856885433197,
-0.004823388531804085,
-0.21516169607639313,
0.9227731823921204,
-0.8007147312164307,
-0.5876787304878235,
-1.455479621887207,
0.43231332302093506,
-0.03840462490916252,
-0.27555808424949646,
0.9105852842330933,
0.3063459098339081,
0.4709935486316681,
0.1034850925207138,
0.8546987175941467,
-0.14302732050418854,
0.22404131293296814,
-0.9334815740585327,
0.9448170065879822,
-0.24000443518161774,
0.7664127349853516,
-0.48339709639549255,
-0.5543937087059021,
-0.3895614743232727,
0.12202785909175873,
-0.4477555751800537,
-0.34963440895080566,
0.7192786335945129,
0.7412920594215393,
-0.026612699031829834,
-0.1048676073551178,
0.20939092338085175,
0.49592843651771545,
0.21897724270820618,
0.5755355954170227,
1.1175029277801514,
-0.0257111769169569,
0.5102750062942505,
-0.18794924020767212,
-0.4246290326118469,
-0.19625349342823029,
-1.0756620168685913,
-0.8284814953804016,
-0.08532577008008957,
-0.1261674165725708,
-0.4328014552593231,
0.1449396163225174,
0.900901734828949,
0.3052428364753723,
-0.8411174416542053,
0.2314435839653015,
-0.2783443331718445,
0.3414838910102844,
-0.2628503739833832,
-0.20292304456233978,
0.39412152767181396,
-0.08580301702022552,
-0.35104474425315857,
0.8062547445297241,
0.24464789032936096,
0.006089650094509125,
-0.2754903733730316,
0.06465660780668259,
0.1497591733932495,
0.1268380880355835,
0.06463389098644257,
0.4766504168510437,
-0.7408009171485901,
-0.25221195816993713,
-0.11983775347471237,
0.12998895347118378,
-0.021106915548443794,
0.888503909111023,
-0.6056284308433533,
0.48479047417640686,
0.2749919295310974,
0.6182462573051453,
-0.07027982175350189,
0.27946949005126953,
0.6343315243721008,
-1.0014851093292236,
0.4288477897644043,
0.3700542449951172,
0.509711742401123,
0.15593062341213226,
-0.7778268456459045,
-0.0800827220082283,
0.09586235135793686,
-0.14717444777488708,
-1.1844263076782227,
0.5008137822151184,
-0.8403124809265137,
-0.6993805766105652,
1.2409119606018066,
-0.25336408615112305,
-0.4659068286418915,
-0.421539306640625,
-0.2471872717142105,
-0.2345798760652542,
-0.48573681712150574,
0.8650268912315369,
0.4934694170951843,
-0.04306251183152199,
0.06852134317159653,
-0.6837897300720215,
0.3815348148345947,
0.2588937282562256,
-0.4974214434623718,
0.378210186958313,
0.3917977809906006,
0.36691799759864807,
0.03627781942486763,
0.3329806625843048,
-0.3524748980998993,
0.19303391873836517,
0.0006719662342220545,
-0.1709168404340744,
-0.3339881896972656,
-0.2418273538351059,
-0.5702157616615295,
0.4271717667579651,
0.28294262290000916,
-0.1445072740316391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13660v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13660v1 | Towards Minimal Targeted Updates of Language Models with Targeted Negative Training | 2024-06-19T16:06:21 | 2024-06-19T16:06:21 | Lily H. Zhang, Rajesh Ranganath, Arya Tafvizi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generative models of language exhibit impressive capabilities but still place
non-negligible probability mass over undesirable outputs. In this work, we
address the task of updating a model to avoid unwanted outputs while minimally
changing model behavior otherwise, a challenge we refer to as a minimal
targeted update. We first formalize the notion of a minimal targeted update and
propose a method to achieve such updates using negative examples from a model's
generations. Our proposed Targeted Negative Training (TNT) results in updates
that keep the new distribution close to the original, unlike existing losses
for negative signal which push down probability but do not control what the
updated distribution will be. In experiments, we demonstrate that TNT yields a
better trade-off between reducing unwanted behavior and maintaining model
generation behavior than baselines, paving the way towards a modeling paradigm
based on iterative training updates that constrain models from generating
undesirable outputs while preserving their impressive capabilities. | [
-0.1212661936879158,
-0.7764829397201538,
0.26894304156303406,
-0.08415061235427856,
-0.0992768257856369,
-0.0430988147854805,
-0.37392738461494446,
0.023481054231524467,
0.03890899941325188,
0.6810176968574524,
-0.7570228576660156,
-0.6085945963859558,
-0.5563849806785583,
-0.2648206949234009,
-0.6132051944732666,
0.8698992729187012,
0.3393753468990326,
-0.3693922758102417,
-0.10902011394500732,
-0.022436292842030525,
-0.6017884612083435,
-0.5170957446098328,
-0.8298406600952148,
-0.4375101923942566,
0.38918131589889526,
0.6975122690200806,
0.6310989856719971,
0.5911438465118408,
0.2548753619194031,
0.15231765806674957,
-0.18887120485305786,
-0.39930522441864014,
-0.9050901532173157,
-0.050950102508068085,
-0.10372380167245865,
-0.3088279664516449,
-0.18022768199443817,
-0.1693466454744339,
0.5968361496925354,
0.9873543977737427,
-0.11425609886646271,
0.15762309730052948,
0.26302894949913025,
0.6050040125846863,
-0.7171066403388977,
-0.15880471467971802,
-0.821340024471283,
0.13390369713306427,
-0.1975550651550293,
-0.4367082715034485,
-0.8894855380058289,
-0.20505185425281525,
-0.2830731272697449,
-0.09304506331682205,
0.3607884645462036,
-0.33661842346191406,
0.6207790970802307,
0.3237936198711395,
-0.5549654364585876,
0.17130404710769653,
-0.9009074568748474,
0.9446074962615967,
-0.616269052028656,
0.31218671798706055,
0.4135129451751709,
0.12769503891468048,
-0.32071590423583984,
0.03780287131667137,
-0.062493372708559036,
-0.764910101890564,
0.2103445827960968,
-0.09711330384016037,
-0.6035732626914978,
0.07577675580978394,
0.46827688813209534,
-0.002098388271406293,
-0.23469802737236023,
0.38599956035614014,
-0.41252443194389343,
-0.16767364740371704,
0.38612881302833557,
0.03963430970907211,
0.15691781044006348,
-0.10441673547029495,
-0.11411674320697784,
-0.20656943321228027,
-1.0763052701950073,
-0.09505591541528702,
0.4792836308479309,
0.5020033121109009,
-0.33619844913482666,
0.9593214988708496,
-0.34245118498802185,
0.6642260551452637,
0.17418552935123444,
0.26648983359336853,
0.09059888124465942,
-0.041496314108371735,
-0.1115570142865181,
0.016636647284030914,
0.5700246691703796,
0.09853184223175049,
-0.0010858639143407345,
-0.2132481038570404,
-0.18329954147338867,
0.23879894614219666,
0.22136780619621277,
-0.5722439289093018,
-0.1952665150165558,
-0.0003645672695711255,
-0.22508947551250458,
-0.8634175062179565,
-0.5652718544006348,
-0.4497758746147156,
-0.37222719192504883,
-0.08307243883609772,
0.3142746090888977,
-0.5433003306388855,
-0.03725225850939751,
-0.04151277616620064,
-0.018516195937991142,
-0.12179967761039734,
0.5203822255134583,
-1.2067028284072876,
0.21081389486789703,
0.5760776996612549,
0.6204135417938232,
0.36292651295661926,
-0.028796082362532616,
-0.7512344717979431,
0.4548661410808563,
-0.5619003772735596,
0.6511645317077637,
-0.5197561979293823,
-0.23258841037750244,
-0.020986581221222878,
-0.3704596757888794,
0.27259066700935364,
-0.5264208316802979,
0.29536306858062744,
-0.31315797567367554,
0.16645435988903046,
-0.24179214239120483,
-0.44535693526268005,
-0.03639092296361923,
0.4530148506164551,
-0.3918863534927368,
1.0584732294082642,
0.37237030267715454,
-0.661361038684845,
0.3811812400817871,
-0.6102240085601807,
-0.42906516790390015,
-0.1236724853515625,
0.10807966440916061,
-0.44936448335647583,
0.4449736475944519,
-0.17441590130329132,
0.26281699538230896,
-0.15800568461418152,
0.16450677812099457,
-0.3447880446910858,
-0.43332311511039734,
-0.015881672501564026,
-0.5861342549324036,
0.882049024105072,
-0.0036436317022889853,
-0.401801198720932,
0.23713581264019012,
-0.847385585308075,
-0.2562515437602997,
0.06536009162664413,
-0.42773669958114624,
-0.5061051845550537,
0.05093080922961235,
-0.14993515610694885,
0.24942852556705475,
0.10725297778844833,
-0.6172015070915222,
0.49417614936828613,
-0.5423509478569031,
0.1828405261039734,
1.0502393245697021,
0.011195006780326366,
0.6923795938491821,
-0.4224003255367279,
0.651763916015625,
0.0010156173957511783,
0.3119966685771942,
0.1599675863981247,
-0.5573413968086243,
-0.7079819440841675,
-0.0523248128592968,
0.4361989200115204,
0.35140717029571533,
-0.9458978176116943,
0.13905306160449982,
-0.3347437083721161,
-0.5053982734680176,
-0.39008140563964844,
0.40846624970436096,
0.2593012750148773,
0.5928999781608582,
0.3678077459335327,
-0.26888158917427063,
-0.5359079837799072,
-0.8290767073631287,
-0.31789514422416687,
-0.2776069939136505,
0.0029136110097169876,
-0.07427258044481277,
0.24681611359119415,
-0.2214476466178894,
0.8170384764671326,
-0.40318700671195984,
-0.3532775044441223,
-0.6403418183326721,
0.2550371289253235,
0.22034519910812378,
0.7470043897628784,
0.6152009963989258,
-0.4763984978199005,
-0.6555437445640564,
0.10341262817382812,
-0.3831765651702881,
-0.3140832185745239,
-0.3447425067424774,
0.2122724950313568,
-0.052655018866062164,
0.44079646468162537,
-0.7056429386138916,
0.3337228000164032,
0.6744582653045654,
-0.14629444479942322,
0.21413938701152802,
-0.12916485965251923,
-0.10028518736362457,
-0.8548071980476379,
-0.054937854409217834,
0.15511183440685272,
-0.27290478348731995,
-1.2730915546417236,
0.07796121388673782,
-0.084168441593647,
-0.4512830376625061,
-0.7105885148048401,
0.8259544968605042,
-0.13918398320674896,
0.0990481749176979,
-0.331940233707428,
-0.1448432207107544,
-0.1837102770805359,
0.6290217638015747,
0.02245965041220188,
0.4994235336780548,
0.6368511915206909,
-0.8044946193695068,
0.01909196935594082,
0.17761610448360443,
0.16044770181179047,
0.2706068456172943,
-0.3407242000102997,
0.12357235699892044,
-0.4708089828491211,
-0.188245952129364,
-0.5340352654457092,
0.08847106248140335,
0.772735595703125,
-0.4731104373931885,
0.4926944971084595,
-0.46725237369537354,
-0.33543384075164795,
-0.3413633406162262,
-0.5789840817451477,
0.12942205369472504,
0.8170592188835144,
-0.2188648283481598,
0.3621733486652374,
0.09872853010892868,
0.26791128516197205,
-0.4020681381225586,
-0.7359104752540588,
0.18386255204677582,
-0.321830153465271,
-0.257358193397522,
0.30231693387031555,
0.03447077050805092,
-0.0968019962310791,
0.16810642182826996,
-0.12560926377773285,
-0.01355087198317051,
0.3570142388343811,
-0.2271280139684677,
-0.056922536343336105,
-0.11647357791662216,
0.056797366589307785,
-0.0003681312082335353,
-0.41466495394706726,
-0.1736745834350586,
-0.38663870096206665,
0.4876668155193329,
0.3501068949699402,
-0.49572503566741943,
-0.2929326593875885,
0.1749781221151352,
0.10934104025363922,
0.17096193134784698,
0.8638757467269897,
0.6480830907821655,
-0.5810520052909851,
-0.11995908617973328,
-0.4030098021030426,
-0.3898743987083435,
-0.538335919380188,
0.5720434188842773,
-0.5134909749031067,
-0.7018227577209473,
0.1450398862361908,
0.01936153881251812,
-0.032745927572250366,
0.45227283239364624,
0.575137197971344,
-0.12140048295259476,
1.2135567665100098,
1.052101492881775,
0.015222976915538311,
0.7200312614440918,
-0.12278395891189575,
0.24403290450572968,
-0.8972885608673096,
0.04624539613723755,
-0.5821203589439392,
-0.09469550848007202,
-0.5343274474143982,
-0.49613091349601746,
0.18082335591316223,
0.2614091634750366,
-0.03644600138068199,
0.8482233881950378,
-0.6132453680038452,
0.19549989700317383,
0.9309555292129517,
0.03428322449326515,
0.05783390998840332,
-0.036838628351688385,
0.021580306813120842,
-0.28343719244003296,
-1.0720146894454956,
-0.32633423805236816,
1.174131155014038,
0.16508297622203827,
0.8850916028022766,
0.4005700945854187,
0.8894193172454834,
0.5989410281181335,
0.8363496661186218,
-0.6650153994560242,
0.6422884464263916,
-0.2990184724330902,
-0.5666748881340027,
-0.22513121366500854,
-0.7615420818328857,
-0.7922443747520447,
0.01441602036356926,
-0.30231502652168274,
-0.8582700490951538,
0.23336553573608398,
0.7428650259971619,
0.017097273841500282,
0.5662561655044556,
-0.7438033819198608,
1.205014705657959,
-0.005806474480777979,
-0.3590139150619507,
-0.2251553237438202,
-0.14984169602394104,
0.250212162733078,
-0.12688274681568146,
0.017089184373617172,
-0.09650513529777527,
0.08357425779104233,
0.2644917368888855,
-0.3180784285068512,
1.0881365537643433,
-0.47550275921821594,
-0.1298716515302658,
0.3851664066314697,
0.5101426243782043,
0.9058541655540466,
-0.3049403131008148,
-0.1154489740729332,
-0.022149475291371346,
-0.39228639006614685,
-0.7580398321151733,
-0.5522024035453796,
0.3365624248981476,
-0.5526564121246338,
-0.8655521869659424,
-0.35019364953041077,
-0.3730325996875763,
-0.2488410472869873,
0.27821335196495056,
0.2836025357246399,
0.4257889986038208,
-0.2891699969768524,
0.1985866129398346,
0.5313118696212769,
-0.6001181602478027,
0.15747205913066864,
0.44881945848464966,
0.13042661547660828,
0.14676128327846527,
1.1796104907989502,
-0.04022954776883125,
0.5884694457054138,
0.8547587990760803,
0.47990190982818604,
-0.27333059906959534,
-1.0317211151123047,
-0.1978846788406372,
-0.005725732538849115,
-0.8684921860694885,
-0.04239616543054581,
-0.5622195601463318,
0.030086930841207504,
-0.5007179379463196,
-0.2253817915916443,
-0.5153926610946655,
-0.3523259162902832,
-0.37040960788726807,
0.01102224551141262,
0.1296883523464203,
0.7505321502685547,
-0.4421076774597168,
0.34901002049446106,
-0.5996172428131104,
0.29105237126350403,
0.21745458245277405,
0.12128037959337234,
-0.10328236222267151,
-0.6985493898391724,
-0.20539900660514832,
0.2989819645881653,
-0.5354442596435547,
-1.009032130241394,
0.3136604130268097,
0.20555876195430756,
0.20516227185726166,
0.19207099080085754,
0.23435601592063904,
0.6412471532821655,
-0.47060564160346985,
0.5586426258087158,
0.4429148733615875,
-1.1429469585418701,
0.8428182601928711,
-0.6692616939544678,
0.6646507382392883,
0.520779013633728,
-0.042748648673295975,
-0.8148101568222046,
-0.8134515881538391,
-0.6398727893829346,
-0.4751572012901306,
0.7009240984916687,
0.31538963317871094,
0.6850070357322693,
-0.2779709994792938,
0.27931922674179077,
-0.15503810346126556,
0.37687620520591736,
-1.2075117826461792,
-0.08749675005674362,
-0.2364083230495453,
-0.26103875041007996,
0.049773767590522766,
-0.31573885679244995,
-0.046764664351940155,
-0.20953986048698425,
1.1362299919128418,
-0.2763277590274811,
0.2308441698551178,
-0.27158018946647644,
-0.27098122239112854,
-0.29247963428497314,
0.5131229162216187,
0.9531874656677246,
0.15971823036670685,
-0.4067763388156891,
0.03935081884264946,
0.3899170160293579,
-0.23126547038555145,
0.4981139898300171,
-0.21618258953094482,
-0.723872721195221,
-0.09390410780906677,
0.2452894151210785,
0.7823967933654785,
0.45057734847068787,
-0.6691161394119263,
0.6457242965698242,
0.21630246937274933,
-0.1608845591545105,
-0.06772637367248535,
-0.0031777755357325077,
-0.09320611506700516,
-0.1404019445180893,
0.28021034598350525,
0.7556760907173157,
0.018247216939926147,
-0.5102002024650574,
0.18653003871440887,
0.42777198553085327,
-0.8507987260818481,
-0.5200766324996948,
0.8788936138153076,
-0.016275133937597275,
-0.2661133110523224,
0.49544885754585266,
-0.7175980806350708,
-0.37429794669151306,
0.6140506267547607,
0.5736194849014282,
0.7883942723274231,
-0.0676754042506218,
0.5267183184623718,
0.3130255341529846,
0.8589957356452942,
0.017444202676415443,
-0.1223125159740448,
0.08717838674783707,
-0.7412941455841064,
-0.5228380560874939,
-0.09194506704807281,
-0.4341689348220825,
0.251700222492218,
-0.35384970903396606,
0.8046016097068787,
-0.6166673302650452,
-0.17852625250816345,
-0.194509819149971,
-0.33336779475212097,
-0.47530946135520935,
0.12896199524402618,
0.32401323318481445,
0.6606303453445435,
-0.8927330374717712,
1.0166051387786865,
0.45727846026420593,
-0.3502771854400635,
-0.5006304383277893,
-0.03962669521570206,
0.1589437574148178,
-0.5387926697731018,
0.564816415309906,
0.03607604280114174,
-0.007147623226046562,
0.1966128945350647,
-0.2970830798149109,
-0.9712057709693909,
0.4911353886127472,
0.7878538370132446,
-0.5373259782791138,
0.053301986306905746,
0.2430187314748764,
0.5904110074043274,
0.01642811857163906,
0.0037767107132822275,
0.012517618015408516,
0.26557204127311707,
0.19431278109550476,
-0.2759789824485779,
0.12245408445596695,
-0.21445252001285553,
0.013098735362291336,
0.42500805854797363,
-0.45952197909355164,
0.8072288036346436,
-0.3997173607349396,
-0.4106520414352417,
0.10235555469989777,
0.4572519063949585,
-0.045735228806734085,
-0.13809871673583984,
0.3592449128627777,
0.7774568796157837,
0.38660794496536255,
-0.13824906945228577,
1.2838853597640991,
-0.09897506237030029,
0.5249094367027283,
1.3476873636245728,
-0.32906028628349304,
0.48854658007621765,
0.4863279461860657,
0.08680949360132217,
0.1715705394744873,
0.5935865640640259,
-0.22050699591636658,
0.9249769449234009,
0.28671759366989136,
-0.2558406889438629,
-0.08355557918548584,
-0.32656529545783997,
-0.27448076009750366,
0.3525295555591583,
-0.04321027547121048,
0.023083949461579323,
-0.45683738589286804,
0.24670076370239258,
0.034277286380529404,
0.21049177646636963,
-0.26695939898490906,
0.7120844125747681,
-0.05620943382382393,
-0.4944266080856323,
0.8243335485458374,
0.38775819540023804,
0.5321948528289795,
-0.48281246423721313,
-0.03097042813897133,
-0.19837896525859833,
0.04776962473988533,
-0.007017761468887329,
-0.17444424331188202,
0.5551806092262268,
0.15149956941604614,
-0.11576934158802032,
-0.38110801577568054,
0.6605539321899414,
-0.4165559709072113,
-0.47432422637939453,
0.3904476463794708,
0.14878223836421967,
-0.42260506749153137,
0.10820843279361725,
-0.8607191443443298,
0.07698247581720352,
0.08288703858852386,
-0.0754275992512703,
0.2534995973110199,
0.3046407103538513,
-0.04968657344579697,
0.8559436798095703,
0.7612103819847107,
0.3973899483680725,
0.24271737039089203,
0.4344232976436615,
0.8003312349319458,
-0.631187379360199,
-0.5137410163879395,
-0.9014286994934082,
0.42605912685394287,
0.037854116410017014,
-0.07575230300426483,
0.6559942364692688,
0.2491908073425293,
0.8243857026100159,
-0.15024197101593018,
0.7245471477508545,
-0.21813976764678955,
0.2519601583480835,
-0.34605997800827026,
0.21518781781196594,
-0.4693021774291992,
0.5861334800720215,
-0.2907335162162781,
-1.0933915376663208,
-0.32652926445007324,
0.3276817798614502,
-0.5186991691589355,
0.01503658201545477,
0.5290399789810181,
0.7181365489959717,
-0.17992596328258514,
-0.38830244541168213,
0.573051393032074,
0.5572639107704163,
0.38369444012641907,
0.706182599067688,
0.9459406137466431,
-0.6242577433586121,
0.4384903609752655,
-0.7400060296058655,
-0.06627010554075241,
-0.050735581666231155,
-0.8826544284820557,
-1.0868602991104126,
-0.17326362431049347,
-0.6742128729820251,
-0.335734099149704,
0.15718984603881836,
0.9954128861427307,
0.7656177878379822,
-1.0209193229675293,
-0.1529000848531723,
-0.4799661636352539,
0.23925966024398804,
-0.41424325108528137,
-0.2475331723690033,
0.10861784964799881,
-0.2630069851875305,
-0.6363891959190369,
0.5189898014068604,
0.41253766417503357,
0.2661777436733246,
-0.15616457164287567,
-0.012177782133221626,
-0.35460448265075684,
0.08575937151908875,
0.4596920609474182,
0.48399657011032104,
-0.4827877879142761,
-0.6950445771217346,
-0.11403069645166397,
-0.02487768977880478,
0.12514106929302216,
0.6121002435684204,
-0.8390912413597107,
0.25786036252975464,
0.15029677748680115,
0.6935879588127136,
0.5259256362915039,
-0.20857757329940796,
0.5935171842575073,
-1.3657506704330444,
0.5619505047798157,
0.4026784896850586,
0.056289102882146835,
0.5900136828422546,
-0.35505110025405884,
0.380625456571579,
0.24786633253097534,
0.18334262073040009,
-1.1672637462615967,
0.44396698474884033,
-0.6043950915336609,
-0.23883861303329468,
0.941667914390564,
0.2961716055870056,
-0.19293315708637238,
-0.17707765102386475,
0.07076994329690933,
0.16129754483699799,
-0.23274201154708862,
0.9383125305175781,
0.44424623250961304,
0.2114056795835495,
-0.3805232346057892,
-0.4987621307373047,
0.5627682209014893,
0.7734923958778381,
-0.5875489115715027,
0.0348626971244812,
0.15202488005161285,
0.2398359775543213,
-0.06735789775848389,
0.955746054649353,
0.0661286860704422,
0.4090821146965027,
0.025733456015586853,
-0.01615862362086773,
0.11349965631961823,
-0.3621821999549866,
-0.6081264019012451,
0.19787746667861938,
0.4016890823841095,
0.11424755305051804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13632v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13632v2 | Can Few-shot Work in Long-Context? Recycling the Context to Generate Demonstrations | 2024-06-19T15:28:29 | 2024-06-23T07:19:22 | Arie Cattan, Alon Jacovi, Alex Fabrikant, Jonathan Herzig, Roee Aharoni, Hannah Rashkin, Dror Marcus, Avinatan Hassidim, Yossi Matias, Idan Szpektor, Avi Caciularu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs), their
performance on tasks involving long contexts remains sub-optimal. In-Context
Learning (ICL) with few-shot examples may be an appealing solution to enhance
LLM performance in this scenario; However, naively adding ICL examples with
long context introduces challenges, including substantial token overhead added
for each few-shot example and context mismatch between the demonstrations and
the target query. In this work, we propose to automatically generate few-shot
examples for long context QA tasks by recycling contexts. Specifically, given a
long input context (1-3k tokens) and a query, we generate additional
query-output pairs from the given context as few-shot examples, while
introducing the context only once. This ensures that the demonstrations are
leveraging the same context as the target query while only adding a small
number of tokens to the prompt. We further enhance each demonstration by
instructing the model to explicitly identify the relevant paragraphs before the
answer, which improves performance while providing fine-grained attribution to
the answer source. We apply our method on multiple LLMs and obtain substantial
improvements (+23\% on average across models) on various QA datasets with long
context, especially when the answer lies within the middle of the context.
Surprisingly, despite introducing only single-hop ICL examples, LLMs also
successfully generalize to multi-hop long-context QA using our approach. | [
-0.3406390845775604,
-0.7633136510848999,
0.7296849489212036,
0.19815486669540405,
-0.5125142335891724,
-0.3527219891548157,
-0.2074318528175354,
-0.3814467787742615,
-0.010462255217134953,
0.4215078353881836,
-0.614942193031311,
-0.437369167804718,
-0.1493436098098755,
0.25331318378448486,
-0.46612775325775146,
0.9305664300918579,
0.14041291177272797,
-0.2089053839445114,
-0.25386708974838257,
-0.32412204146385193,
-0.4117848873138428,
-0.21063800156116486,
-0.8494769930839539,
-0.2669979929924011,
0.4424118399620056,
0.7328627705574036,
0.11525315046310425,
0.36576947569847107,
0.015450661070644855,
0.24643296003341675,
-0.10068435966968536,
0.3334313929080963,
-0.6929053664207458,
0.062919981777668,
-0.19858546555042267,
-0.37256571650505066,
-0.044385991990566254,
-0.08336760103702545,
0.8779367208480835,
0.6216474175453186,
0.07519187033176422,
0.261588990688324,
0.3669942021369934,
0.43090352416038513,
-0.715404212474823,
-0.03435232862830162,
-0.728985607624054,
-0.1612364649772644,
-0.2231665700674057,
-0.2898453176021576,
-0.5708272457122803,
-0.06307891011238098,
0.08125313371419907,
-0.45226094126701355,
-0.22765816748142242,
0.033964045345783234,
0.5369959473609924,
0.1685277670621872,
-0.6642634272575378,
-0.20874233543872833,
-0.631485641002655,
0.8244631886482239,
-0.9778910279273987,
-0.10442677140235901,
0.24305127561092377,
0.6197705268859863,
-0.3632008731365204,
-0.6703450083732605,
-0.6960861086845398,
-0.09930725395679474,
-0.23748663067817688,
-0.029324190691113472,
-0.24115490913391113,
-0.11816279590129852,
0.5238468647003174,
-0.27501997351646423,
-0.28632473945617676,
0.22840231657028198,
-0.3096384108066559,
-0.07060760259628296,
0.47125908732414246,
0.38917994499206543,
-0.015866611152887344,
-0.3083656430244446,
-0.4436304271221161,
0.13057924807071686,
-1.0896912813186646,
0.382133424282074,
-0.09598951786756516,
0.5445615649223328,
-0.08027682453393936,
0.5462260246276855,
-0.36920955777168274,
0.708127498626709,
0.2139521688222885,
-0.45630979537963867,
-0.034121111035346985,
-0.5245645046234131,
-0.2744765281677246,
-0.09597887843847275,
0.6724720001220703,
0.229681596159935,
0.024916423484683037,
-0.013633234426379204,
-0.2281687706708908,
-0.35523006319999695,
0.03884414955973625,
-1.0348107814788818,
0.040768176317214966,
0.15096567571163177,
-0.29716062545776367,
0.0026572044007480145,
-0.2834237813949585,
-0.6803308129310608,
-0.1963452398777008,
-0.18859250843524933,
0.5447484254837036,
-0.41141989827156067,
0.2017706334590912,
-0.03025856986641884,
-0.011121554300189018,
0.42284083366394043,
0.41591179370880127,
-0.5190573334693909,
0.30066800117492676,
0.7584706544876099,
0.6864575147628784,
-0.3045772612094879,
-0.5326241850852966,
-1.0729141235351562,
0.31680288910865784,
-0.33014369010925293,
0.7050444483757019,
-0.356399267911911,
-0.33225131034851074,
0.16454929113388062,
0.009549284353852272,
0.1199466809630394,
-0.6388747692108154,
0.04272523894906044,
-0.468086838722229,
0.3274978697299957,
-0.25127145648002625,
-0.7276097536087036,
0.19737081229686737,
0.5613484978675842,
-0.38608670234680176,
0.8830248713493347,
0.13217255473136902,
-0.6202422976493835,
0.4960486888885498,
-0.7622873187065125,
-0.5357155203819275,
0.10175706446170807,
-0.3039828836917877,
-0.4128267765045166,
-0.0203950647264719,
0.2719365656375885,
0.603248655796051,
0.05091007053852081,
-0.13622064888477325,
-0.2339511215686798,
-0.8213331699371338,
0.21541592478752136,
-0.41175538301467896,
0.7051993608474731,
-0.16047737002372742,
-0.4248819947242737,
0.12530671060085297,
-0.6382470726966858,
0.13408030569553375,
-0.05474429950118065,
-0.43686744570732117,
-0.4213551878929138,
-0.2215910255908966,
0.008538525551557541,
0.3879861533641815,
-0.10708841681480408,
-0.4384397268295288,
0.41668662428855896,
-0.6664320826530457,
0.37933874130249023,
0.6447616815567017,
0.28109726309776306,
0.5690174698829651,
-0.3752371072769165,
0.6686146259307861,
0.20457255840301514,
-0.019542772322893143,
-0.3913116157054901,
-0.23041212558746338,
-0.5884208083152771,
-0.6472404599189758,
-0.2087232917547226,
0.30113649368286133,
-0.9701793193817139,
0.05415427312254906,
-0.3931545913219452,
-0.11633674055337906,
-0.30766764283180237,
0.45913589000701904,
0.4546492397785187,
0.7473474144935608,
0.4200478792190552,
0.12512779235839844,
-0.3591994643211365,
-0.8417230248451233,
-0.35286012291908264,
-0.23603498935699463,
-0.07368413358926773,
0.623313307762146,
0.6565386056900024,
-0.09084130823612213,
1.3343385457992554,
-0.42964673042297363,
-0.2830171287059784,
-0.42583149671554565,
0.1067737266421318,
0.2551204562187195,
0.3287646770477295,
0.6885892748832703,
-0.4464387595653534,
-0.590156614780426,
-0.33383554220199585,
-0.5710976719856262,
0.04225565120577812,
-0.2640659213066101,
-0.22257302701473236,
0.15260380506515503,
0.5842292904853821,
-0.5997796654701233,
0.35171592235565186,
0.09513001888990402,
-0.21094347536563873,
0.5844957232475281,
0.08148707449436188,
0.030485020950436592,
-1.3747872114181519,
-0.10350236296653748,
-0.10360158234834671,
-0.47984579205513,
-0.4218232035636902,
0.1266000121831894,
0.06832759082317352,
-0.1016162633895874,
-1.065618634223938,
1.06815505027771,
-0.22557784616947174,
0.007993511855602264,
-0.50346440076828,
0.09209612011909485,
0.038060884922742844,
0.49843764305114746,
-0.2072373628616333,
0.9783762097358704,
0.5510779619216919,
-0.8383409976959229,
0.09784679114818573,
0.20889243483543396,
-0.4745829105377197,
0.475275456905365,
-0.534103512763977,
0.19372357428073883,
-0.243712916970253,
0.5821676254272461,
-0.9136192798614502,
-0.32194286584854126,
0.21107585728168488,
-0.014599504880607128,
0.1074063777923584,
-0.4894355237483978,
-0.5473218560218811,
-0.15007330477237701,
-0.3608628511428833,
0.5433701872825623,
0.6901572346687317,
-0.843914806842804,
0.27435871958732605,
-0.11575391888618469,
0.004036935977637768,
-0.6327036619186401,
-0.7111489772796631,
-0.0316329225897789,
-0.5793027281761169,
-0.4477604031562805,
0.3379480838775635,
-0.09959163516759872,
-0.03238202631473541,
-0.2972477674484253,
0.03251741826534271,
-0.1493799388408661,
0.1719687581062317,
0.26683443784713745,
-0.15163582563400269,
-0.23697145283222198,
0.4530428946018219,
0.06247786432504654,
0.1672130525112152,
-0.12289097905158997,
-0.29213234782218933,
0.3792334794998169,
-0.14678141474723816,
-0.5616746544837952,
-0.6533552408218384,
0.6044743657112122,
0.5755460858345032,
0.046143848448991776,
0.45867919921875,
0.5014691948890686,
-0.4402754604816437,
-0.5217626690864563,
-0.4101734757423401,
-0.4475913643836975,
-0.4702821373939514,
0.3232245445251465,
-0.5249966979026794,
-0.9588783979415894,
0.44390448927879333,
-0.16068147122859955,
0.1472482532262802,
0.016981536522507668,
0.3522511124610901,
-0.31507405638694763,
0.8403013348579407,
0.6778624057769775,
-0.31857413053512573,
0.6675424575805664,
-0.4307880997657776,
0.1275266706943512,
-0.6867285966873169,
0.16735947132110596,
-0.3220413029193878,
-0.2823772132396698,
-0.2918355464935303,
-0.39123839139938354,
0.6884137392044067,
0.3207778036594391,
-0.18413206934928894,
0.20715461671352386,
-0.08242198824882507,
0.8781857490539551,
0.4270694851875305,
0.26386168599128723,
0.21055243909358978,
-0.0661768987774849,
-0.0005147060146555305,
0.24202118813991547,
-0.8504442572593689,
-0.6616086959838867,
1.0316109657287598,
0.1244165301322937,
0.6641431450843811,
0.16643381118774414,
1.343340516090393,
-0.14253279566764832,
0.3704984784126282,
-1.0329843759536743,
0.6728492975234985,
-0.004418747499585152,
-0.3867838382720947,
-0.5351593494415283,
-0.18555009365081787,
-0.9616177678108215,
0.14838698506355286,
0.07974821329116821,
-0.6925086379051208,
-0.1670660525560379,
0.3107810616493225,
-0.7233703136444092,
0.036280397325754166,
-0.5399993062019348,
0.9306777119636536,
0.1823553740978241,
-0.6534368395805359,
-0.22001910209655762,
-0.5441594123840332,
0.4694850742816925,
0.011397023685276508,
-0.0022407539654523134,
-0.01846165768802166,
0.09827136993408203,
0.6168066263198853,
-0.4557172656059265,
1.0359855890274048,
-0.24809621274471283,
0.012907503172755241,
0.6242773532867432,
0.051943082362413406,
0.7268673181533813,
0.3034544885158539,
-0.10280263423919678,
-0.4574069380760193,
0.14380739629268646,
-0.597114622592926,
-0.8087608814239502,
0.6719798445701599,
-0.2482103854417801,
-0.6628211736679077,
-0.08007485419511795,
-0.2968587279319763,
-0.23989078402519226,
0.07542678713798523,
0.2658469080924988,
0.593801736831665,
-0.16085639595985413,
0.14223019778728485,
0.29290252923965454,
-0.06180243566632271,
0.7672833204269409,
0.4003582298755646,
-0.036872535943984985,
0.028201617300510406,
0.5183669328689575,
-0.14991521835327148,
0.24783770740032196,
0.18966726958751678,
0.3055074214935303,
-0.26569896936416626,
-0.5892351865768433,
-0.4269302189350128,
0.10530006140470505,
-0.9250131845474243,
-0.33398309350013733,
-0.5132037401199341,
0.1718205064535141,
-0.37526851892471313,
-0.26953548192977905,
-0.2591124475002289,
-0.14967063069343567,
-0.39293214678764343,
0.16013269126415253,
0.225864440202713,
0.35573771595954895,
0.2840532958507538,
0.4854380190372467,
-0.9191054105758667,
0.36451196670532227,
0.6917510628700256,
0.10764545947313309,
0.0992732122540474,
-0.505744993686676,
-0.30746957659721375,
0.06874948740005493,
-0.20925171673297882,
-0.7112862467765808,
0.33858415484428406,
0.3850184679031372,
0.3268929123878479,
0.4687066674232483,
0.11823040246963501,
1.1229029893875122,
-0.7602269649505615,
1.012413740158081,
-0.03240606561303139,
-0.9318148493766785,
0.5676475167274475,
-0.11484445631504059,
0.7549920678138733,
0.8371173739433289,
0.33027148246765137,
-0.44490671157836914,
-0.443887323141098,
-0.2515032887458801,
-0.7751154899597168,
0.5964431166648865,
-0.018083356320858,
0.4150875210762024,
-0.39972272515296936,
0.3988540768623352,
0.19192750751972198,
-0.0768100917339325,
-0.7809084057807922,
0.12003688514232635,
0.12572351098060608,
-0.15053360164165497,
0.12928134202957153,
-0.25165796279907227,
-0.3947734534740448,
-0.19007951021194458,
0.6703155040740967,
-0.7378090620040894,
0.11910828948020935,
0.10879278182983398,
-0.39456087350845337,
0.13446898758411407,
0.6691376566886902,
0.6686449646949768,
0.9351872205734253,
0.006033590529114008,
0.116158626973629,
0.43588030338287354,
0.15034374594688416,
0.17435674369335175,
-0.29747405648231506,
-0.156378835439682,
-0.025150083005428314,
0.525580644607544,
0.5189685225486755,
0.35424497723579407,
-0.8810681104660034,
0.8573998212814331,
0.16760993003845215,
0.23745214939117432,
-0.48715153336524963,
-0.16216807067394257,
0.01353358756750822,
0.5597885251045227,
0.4910981059074402,
-0.3603045344352722,
0.1846308410167694,
-0.7797209620475769,
0.4586871862411499,
0.610776960849762,
-0.1454811692237854,
-0.11500166356563568,
0.28116244077682495,
0.17024551331996918,
-0.14865565299987793,
0.8192591071128845,
-0.6127249002456665,
-0.5417464375495911,
0.7061089277267456,
0.7470255494117737,
0.8125239610671997,
0.49944379925727844,
0.06246323511004448,
0.28547877073287964,
-0.1967618465423584,
-0.1745491325855255,
0.15347030758857727,
-0.26050055027008057,
-0.510824978351593,
-0.5675641298294067,
-0.3448408246040344,
-0.2426651418209076,
0.12756994366645813,
-0.45008498430252075,
0.5246050357818604,
-0.29090309143066406,
-0.02244860678911209,
-0.047276969999074936,
-0.09305866062641144,
-0.8150573968887329,
-0.08030731976032257,
0.11343168467283249,
0.7892927527427673,
-0.8507779240608215,
0.9997544884681702,
0.5353889465332031,
-0.4406297504901886,
-0.6808706521987915,
0.18468917906284332,
0.025097733363509178,
-0.5089135766029358,
0.9114797711372375,
0.30217528343200684,
-0.35008686780929565,
-0.19149047136306763,
-0.9443351626396179,
-0.5098116397857666,
1.3091970682144165,
0.17190256714820862,
-0.525292694568634,
-0.15532343089580536,
-0.06820552051067352,
0.501327633857727,
-0.6750199198722839,
0.1839519441127777,
0.35848942399024963,
0.1163073256611824,
0.06591877341270447,
-0.9959661960601807,
0.14206555485725403,
0.17634634673595428,
-0.1781722605228424,
-0.0027397396042943,
-0.6245470643043518,
0.6174091696739197,
-0.4287757873535156,
-0.3368402123451233,
0.3479178249835968,
0.6845402717590332,
0.5880883932113647,
0.6855641603469849,
0.672172486782074,
0.19672271609306335,
0.44454190135002136,
0.3066115379333496,
1.0279011726379395,
-0.16388967633247375,
0.2764374017715454,
1.4658710956573486,
-0.43622586131095886,
1.0562102794647217,
0.8327940702438354,
0.005104519426822662,
0.3839257061481476,
0.3907104730606079,
0.2896450161933899,
0.5618305206298828,
0.23084482550621033,
-0.39362287521362305,
-0.40573549270629883,
-0.04290783032774925,
-0.020391907542943954,
0.6905927658081055,
0.10500139743089676,
-0.23978470265865326,
-0.5040338635444641,
0.35230281949043274,
-0.016497163102030754,
0.044578809291124344,
-0.15419211983680725,
0.9179296493530273,
0.15599197149276733,
-0.6675469279289246,
0.7706173062324524,
-0.1085185706615448,
0.9124706983566284,
-0.5046116709709167,
-0.2060490846633911,
-0.3841717839241028,
-0.04993082582950592,
-0.08592129498720169,
-0.5342676043510437,
0.22101910412311554,
0.024129711091518402,
-0.15307077765464783,
-0.29665639996528625,
0.578403890132904,
-0.5678057074546814,
-0.16484330594539642,
0.01003678422421217,
0.5563901662826538,
0.4294806718826294,
-0.10823369771242142,
-0.39434313774108887,
-0.4057188928127289,
-0.17315945029258728,
-0.12945975363254547,
0.5564185380935669,
0.48173248767852783,
-0.15407465398311615,
0.8288168907165527,
0.38785845041275024,
-0.21231290698051453,
0.1129530668258667,
0.015252376906573772,
0.9409019947052002,
-0.7499158978462219,
-0.46032458543777466,
-0.9097266793251038,
0.5595832467079163,
-0.08069994300603867,
-0.3704899847507477,
0.5677077770233154,
0.6502354145050049,
0.9461716413497925,
-0.19814050197601318,
0.5945309400558472,
0.27719801664352417,
0.36535167694091797,
-0.7292666435241699,
0.592644214630127,
-0.6976056098937988,
0.3496200144290924,
-0.08504974097013474,
-0.6756167411804199,
-0.08643195778131485,
0.2877730131149292,
-0.04200566187500954,
-0.13141000270843506,
0.7741475105285645,
0.8444777727127075,
-0.30152973532676697,
-0.4045999348163605,
0.4133491814136505,
-0.021199895069003105,
0.5537176132202148,
0.8509386777877808,
0.8159897923469543,
-0.423857718706131,
0.6305978298187256,
-0.426980584859848,
0.10920441150665283,
-0.43534842133522034,
-1.129891276359558,
-0.875201404094696,
-0.4560852646827698,
-0.5068232417106628,
-0.2627212107181549,
0.05437202379107475,
1.3179036378860474,
0.8960379958152771,
-0.6322161555290222,
-0.21462476253509521,
0.3350854814052582,
0.2927498519420624,
-0.3629162013530731,
-0.3025357127189636,
0.3560650646686554,
-0.48477640748023987,
-0.8949531316757202,
0.8154566287994385,
0.2562636435031891,
0.18060879409313202,
-0.11604154855012894,
0.12439344078302383,
-0.15106600522994995,
0.057152848690748215,
1.065647840499878,
0.4427560865879059,
-0.8462957739830017,
-0.7175946831703186,
-0.08054839819669724,
-0.29319044947624207,
0.07546667009592056,
0.8849997520446777,
-1.2082401514053345,
0.2544499337673187,
0.5468432307243347,
0.8246931433677673,
0.5563802123069763,
0.045393217355012894,
0.28793883323669434,
-1.2387604713439941,
0.17195254564285278,
0.4858684241771698,
0.2570176422595978,
0.13454845547676086,
-0.1620417684316635,
0.2684384882450104,
-0.15171273052692413,
-0.29059576988220215,
-0.901117742061615,
0.4909510910511017,
-1.1497474908828735,
-0.389948308467865,
1.449882984161377,
-0.3392019271850586,
-0.18276818096637726,
0.046680234372615814,
-0.10494343191385269,
0.07203042507171631,
-0.4205341637134552,
0.8645952343940735,
0.6067039966583252,
-0.3726378381252289,
-0.1710645705461502,
-0.2756775915622711,
0.557228147983551,
0.46537986397743225,
-0.9618924260139465,
0.022293204441666603,
0.6448162794113159,
0.5775866508483887,
-0.1757834553718567,
0.8001084327697754,
0.12299484014511108,
0.29926812648773193,
-0.3264499604701996,
-0.42754030227661133,
-0.08622168749570847,
-0.32784363627433777,
-0.5355998873710632,
0.29481640458106995,
0.19504237174987793,
-0.31823375821113586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13629v1 | InstructRAG: Instructing Retrieval-Augmented Generation with Explicit Denoising | 2024-06-19T15:25:29 | 2024-06-19T15:25:29 | Zhepei Wei, Wei-Lin Chen, Yu Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has shown promising potential to enhance
the accuracy and factuality of language models (LMs). However, imperfect
retrievers or noisy corpora can introduce misleading or even erroneous
information to the retrieved contents, posing a significant challenge to the
generation quality. Existing RAG methods typically address this challenge by
directly predicting final answers despite potentially noisy inputs, resulting
in an implicit denoising process that is difficult to interpret and verify. On
the other hand, the acquisition of explicit denoising supervision is often
costly, involving significant human efforts. In this work, we propose
InstructRAG, where LMs explicitly learn the denoising process through
self-synthesized rationales -- First, we instruct the LM to explain how the
ground-truth answer is derived from retrieved documents. Then, these rationales
can be used either as demonstrations for in-context learning of explicit
denoising or as supervised fine-tuning data to train the model. Compared to
standard RAG approaches, InstructRAG requires no additional supervision, allows
for easier verification of the predicted answers, and effectively improves
generation accuracy. Experiments show InstructRAG consistently outperforms
existing RAG methods in both training-free and trainable scenarios, achieving a
relative improvement of 8.3% over the best baseline method on average across
five knowledge-intensive benchmarks. Extensive analysis indicates that
InstructRAG scales well with increased numbers of retrieved documents and
consistently exhibits robust denoising ability even in out-of-domain datasets,
demonstrating strong generalizability. | [
-0.46448564529418945,
-0.736785352230072,
0.22556734085083008,
0.17163068056106567,
-0.08044344186782837,
0.22984100878238678,
-0.30909159779548645,
-0.21790696680545807,
-0.19165252149105072,
0.622350811958313,
-0.325884073972702,
-0.33359789848327637,
-0.39442142844200134,
0.06781864166259766,
-0.5466305017471313,
1.2332963943481445,
0.04529011994600296,
-0.03674638271331787,
-0.2911244034767151,
0.22123868763446808,
-0.49696633219718933,
-0.3026123046875,
-0.6232857704162598,
-0.3774779438972473,
0.0492435023188591,
0.46658143401145935,
0.31106168031692505,
0.3549497127532959,
-0.004659635480493307,
0.19496221840381622,
-0.08830778300762177,
0.4641913175582886,
-0.6493663787841797,
0.343946635723114,
-0.08660077303647995,
-0.30033689737319946,
-0.14791610836982727,
-0.042095642536878586,
0.7319516539573669,
0.640985906124115,
-0.4095275402069092,
0.34742581844329834,
0.34593465924263,
0.712842583656311,
-0.8509536385536194,
-0.01431241538375616,
-1.013817310333252,
-0.11322669684886932,
0.012142322026193142,
-0.31463831663131714,
-0.7548553347587585,
-0.34909871220588684,
-0.3576646149158478,
-0.6425243020057678,
0.6009638905525208,
0.18890418112277985,
0.7115364074707031,
0.5694916248321533,
-0.2361993044614792,
-0.48031800985336304,
-0.8395629525184631,
0.6576095819473267,
-0.5521517992019653,
0.3550187647342682,
0.6937277317047119,
0.25204765796661377,
-0.44448167085647583,
-0.9590394496917725,
-0.617830216884613,
-0.11927378922700882,
-0.29625454545021057,
0.4247249960899353,
-0.19424469769001007,
0.136809304356575,
0.30569374561309814,
0.46735745668411255,
-0.4977306127548218,
-0.0014904494164511561,
-0.6273677349090576,
0.14002428948879242,
0.4617423117160797,
-0.14229637384414673,
0.13411200046539307,
-0.2595902979373932,
-0.5018830299377441,
-0.07422905415296555,
-0.879946231842041,
-0.21643108129501343,
0.37048906087875366,
0.18551039695739746,
0.0638957992196083,
0.3361130356788635,
-0.2272958904504776,
0.6377527117729187,
0.7108092904090881,
-0.264300674200058,
0.055789925158023834,
-0.007242911495268345,
-0.33653703331947327,
0.3543344736099243,
0.46593889594078064,
0.06850042194128036,
-0.1613466888666153,
-0.30828559398651123,
-0.41348105669021606,
0.08830665796995163,
0.6051951050758362,
-1.0032355785369873,
-0.2630334496498108,
0.1256837695837021,
-0.07546402513980865,
-0.463968425989151,
-0.14860105514526367,
-0.9291033148765564,
-0.29073598980903625,
-0.4043293297290802,
0.7046152353286743,
-0.3673955202102661,
-0.21551309525966644,
0.1494360715150833,
-0.07377903908491135,
0.14213690161705017,
0.29853764176368713,
-0.9953352808952332,
0.45022690296173096,
0.6081447601318359,
0.49963638186454773,
0.14673365652561188,
-0.00953688658773899,
-0.8468848466873169,
0.3838249742984772,
-0.6498154997825623,
0.8399593234062195,
-0.428454726934433,
-0.505526065826416,
-0.06638599187135696,
-0.14978832006454468,
-0.1977379024028778,
-0.7902568578720093,
0.8296226859092712,
-0.5639007687568665,
0.6119194626808167,
0.09026329964399338,
-0.9642999768257141,
-0.24744106829166412,
0.09130249172449112,
-0.36465901136398315,
1.2741961479187012,
0.41433626413345337,
-0.7920255064964294,
0.36047738790512085,
-0.42077380418777466,
-0.26684334874153137,
0.285476952791214,
-0.10608381778001785,
-0.3644210994243622,
-0.04858716204762459,
0.43387824296951294,
0.47571486234664917,
-0.1394328474998474,
0.46168166399002075,
0.14315563440322876,
-0.41417089104652405,
-0.13780909776687622,
-0.6340022683143616,
0.7493197917938232,
0.34776782989501953,
-0.42961445450782776,
-0.1029609739780426,
-0.7457755208015442,
-0.08324480056762695,
-0.12178867310285568,
-0.3473159670829773,
-0.36417633295059204,
-0.33933424949645996,
-0.3162859082221985,
-0.2754178047180176,
-0.08256132155656815,
-0.6763514280319214,
0.10151349753141403,
-0.6774925589561462,
-0.1014915183186531,
0.5663670301437378,
0.3414739966392517,
0.7565937638282776,
-0.5103158950805664,
0.7397010326385498,
-0.33568233251571655,
0.09820923954248428,
-0.16638672351837158,
-0.252545565366745,
-0.6947160363197327,
-0.3602272570133209,
0.29217931628227234,
0.2869049906730652,
-0.7376944422721863,
0.05635220929980278,
-0.10522668808698654,
-0.5580123662948608,
-0.7461496591567993,
0.3362601697444916,
0.7727174162864685,
1.0639019012451172,
0.5568947792053223,
0.15695559978485107,
-0.5030289888381958,
-0.5217104554176331,
-0.11824394017457962,
-0.08289916813373566,
-0.05182996019721031,
0.053309161216020584,
0.27087685465812683,
-0.3030948042869568,
0.7609952688217163,
-0.3424213230609894,
-0.29098835587501526,
-0.15321028232574463,
0.4588913321495056,
0.2345183789730072,
0.5511504411697388,
0.43069690465927124,
-0.9105802774429321,
-0.7179157733917236,
-0.04430435597896576,
-0.7104222178459167,
-0.3347330391407013,
-0.10321728885173798,
-0.08622261881828308,
0.4662765860557556,
0.725861132144928,
-0.5310073494911194,
0.4950478971004486,
0.5745105147361755,
0.006775010377168655,
0.8344893455505371,
-0.5420946478843689,
0.07243060320615768,
-1.050449252128601,
0.07923835515975952,
-0.3445809781551361,
-0.09457365423440933,
-0.5553627610206604,
0.07065609842538834,
0.03136336803436279,
-0.028871875256299973,
-0.09263458847999573,
0.6922917366027832,
-0.5420004725456238,
0.1292232722043991,
-0.15345832705497742,
0.030730534344911575,
0.23702485859394073,
0.5259045362472534,
-0.2952144742012024,
1.0476406812667847,
0.1720436066389084,
-0.7187264561653137,
-0.10003998130559921,
0.5216155648231506,
-0.538780152797699,
0.535504162311554,
-0.6394065022468567,
0.14590297639369965,
-0.6412177085876465,
0.2475636899471283,
-0.931789755821228,
-0.4113716185092926,
0.16218747198581696,
-0.4712587594985962,
0.813693642616272,
-0.8360872864723206,
-0.41364750266075134,
0.019703412428498268,
-0.09276053309440613,
0.06687919795513153,
0.7175281643867493,
-0.9821393489837646,
0.48101016879081726,
0.509824812412262,
-0.16033075749874115,
-0.9386328458786011,
-0.20648148655891418,
-0.08716738224029541,
-0.3694929778575897,
-0.10775390267372131,
0.5747946500778198,
-0.19572816789150238,
-0.358711302280426,
0.06838463991880417,
-0.03849292919039726,
-0.31839820742607117,
-0.028121866285800934,
0.39539656043052673,
0.12139083445072174,
0.10551811754703522,
0.3605332672595978,
0.5846719145774841,
-0.1504104733467102,
0.06100746616721153,
-0.0952644869685173,
0.3202815055847168,
0.0066442894749343395,
-0.18441654741764069,
-0.04065066576004028,
0.15470199286937714,
0.29404354095458984,
-0.35957643389701843,
0.4641333222389221,
0.778331458568573,
-0.1579364836215973,
-0.8248984217643738,
-0.502920389175415,
-0.3298863470554352,
-0.5273804068565369,
0.04484042897820473,
-0.2729169726371765,
-0.8164991736412048,
-0.03990720957517624,
-0.26368263363838196,
0.3424017131328583,
0.18805615603923798,
0.3798889219760895,
-0.3641306757926941,
0.7911275029182434,
0.3433998227119446,
0.31151431798934937,
0.3180179297924042,
-0.5735800266265869,
-0.030669406056404114,
-1.040719747543335,
-0.29164445400238037,
-0.4964868724346161,
0.17707937955856323,
-0.3899756073951721,
-0.487802118062973,
0.7151733040809631,
0.44540706276893616,
-0.35601457953453064,
0.058041829615831375,
-0.8347287774085999,
0.4795820713043213,
0.5553575754165649,
0.1666599065065384,
0.2684774100780487,
0.38007307052612305,
0.04753448814153671,
-0.11477938294410706,
-1.0004119873046875,
-0.40150466561317444,
0.9626356363296509,
-0.08584277331829071,
0.8275601863861084,
-0.07184382528066635,
0.9539420008659363,
0.42929694056510925,
0.5817002654075623,
-0.6216837167739868,
0.31412044167518616,
-0.22627872228622437,
-0.6428044438362122,
-0.2629562318325043,
-0.4082297384738922,
-1.1748483180999756,
0.3584679365158081,
-0.33349090814590454,
-0.10546949505805969,
0.14725081622600555,
0.3849929869174957,
-0.2697259485721588,
0.3211895227432251,
-0.5541092157363892,
0.5620059967041016,
0.03967488557100296,
-0.43668225407600403,
-0.4023459851741791,
-0.5199748873710632,
0.4795726537704468,
-0.15532708168029785,
0.4017816185951233,
0.04842444136738777,
0.260739266872406,
0.5988398790359497,
-0.3654761016368866,
0.9784210324287415,
-0.322003036737442,
-0.2071572095155716,
0.502517819404602,
0.44675034284591675,
0.5602852702140808,
0.003747166832908988,
-0.15636679530143738,
-0.2968584895133972,
0.02863948978483677,
-0.016862794756889343,
-0.902328610420227,
0.632971465587616,
-0.44369813799858093,
-0.6211802959442139,
-0.028840571641921997,
-0.5054225325584412,
-0.2727678418159485,
0.2161078155040741,
0.42306119203567505,
0.9896743893623352,
-0.06349407881498337,
0.19061876833438873,
0.8749388456344604,
-0.20816805958747864,
0.333312064409256,
0.40267860889434814,
-0.28708866238594055,
-0.7114499807357788,
0.9050214886665344,
0.21619261801242828,
0.13408750295639038,
0.5249465703964233,
0.3573204576969147,
-0.4644448757171631,
-0.4388020634651184,
-0.814466118812561,
0.24888403713703156,
-0.7451396584510803,
-0.39920467138290405,
-0.7394387125968933,
-0.09875796735286713,
-0.20687174797058105,
-0.26630598306655884,
-0.3567388653755188,
-0.4690949618816376,
-0.1013866439461708,
-0.0991399958729744,
0.4617548882961273,
0.8907162547111511,
-0.28049349784851074,
0.2501596510410309,
-0.6812359094619751,
0.46703603863716125,
0.38948768377304077,
0.10537207126617432,
-0.07165316492319107,
-0.9733596444129944,
-0.31006327271461487,
0.2586623430252075,
-0.07192472368478775,
-0.6562792658805847,
0.4942227602005005,
0.28602761030197144,
0.6443549990653992,
0.14059334993362427,
0.5908580422401428,
0.8865150809288025,
-0.49538686871528625,
0.38089093565940857,
-0.2768945097923279,
-0.6929273009300232,
0.45499560236930847,
-0.3291751742362976,
-0.029692091047763824,
0.6367366313934326,
0.3513046205043793,
-0.08125361800193787,
-0.5093069672584534,
-0.8844921588897705,
-0.6777435541152954,
0.3902890384197235,
0.005209467839449644,
0.3123161196708679,
-0.04832693934440613,
0.503328263759613,
0.28583744168281555,
0.3125157356262207,
-0.33763089776039124,
0.037092097103595734,
-0.14829178154468536,
-0.2007322758436203,
0.10617978870868683,
-0.5952452421188354,
-0.05132591724395752,
-0.2931235730648041,
0.890802800655365,
0.02437416836619377,
0.05917096510529518,
0.31528332829475403,
-0.15815423429012299,
-0.1965291053056717,
0.3281770944595337,
0.49084708094596863,
0.5483217835426331,
-0.2748042047023773,
0.30175694823265076,
0.302726686000824,
-0.3509368896484375,
0.15942317247390747,
-0.16452303528785706,
-0.6330212354660034,
0.3173834979534149,
0.21565230190753937,
0.5187581181526184,
0.40626391768455505,
-0.4953806698322296,
0.42348727583885193,
0.15944679081439972,
-0.08602204918861389,
-0.6309937834739685,
0.1358834058046341,
-0.1770283579826355,
0.06979844719171524,
0.21434395015239716,
0.142488032579422,
0.20814751088619232,
-0.1403452455997467,
0.292220801115036,
0.40316641330718994,
-0.18450896441936493,
-0.23385371267795563,
0.797115683555603,
-0.04227079823613167,
-0.03994482383131981,
0.5685364603996277,
-0.4157928228378296,
-0.44842368364334106,
0.2676578760147095,
0.7875778079032898,
0.8139509558677673,
-0.266348659992218,
0.3309352397918701,
0.786695122718811,
0.24051803350448608,
-0.21251346170902252,
0.0640961080789566,
-0.35386568307876587,
-0.6988753080368042,
-0.6338175535202026,
-0.8915700316429138,
-0.5212318897247314,
0.007446617353707552,
-0.7671533226966858,
-0.097217857837677,
-0.3416016101837158,
0.06943982094526291,
-0.2284599244594574,
-0.040464047342538834,
-0.20155905187129974,
0.29826754331588745,
-0.31691956520080566,
0.6034725308418274,
-0.4802199602127075,
0.8103512525558472,
0.4661659300327301,
-0.40344473719596863,
-0.9727553129196167,
-0.05206802487373352,
-0.3708822429180145,
-0.481096088886261,
0.7864309549331665,
-0.07407285273075104,
-0.4995393753051758,
0.3524213433265686,
-0.7485928535461426,
-0.4319958984851837,
0.7377477288246155,
0.7388676404953003,
-0.1502523422241211,
0.24780040979385376,
-0.2992044985294342,
0.4834747910499573,
-0.23056884109973907,
-0.05233343690633774,
0.026343731209635735,
0.40454724431037903,
0.13477200269699097,
-0.6998646259307861,
-0.07579725980758667,
-0.14271777868270874,
-0.32163235545158386,
0.21977359056472778,
-0.34265896677970886,
0.7743999361991882,
-0.3019424378871918,
-0.5537097454071045,
-0.021988380700349808,
0.4541490077972412,
0.22870737314224243,
0.37691551446914673,
0.4151720404624939,
0.6435030102729797,
0.8476812839508057,
0.3709522485733032,
1.1571378707885742,
-0.2715490758419037,
0.11139962077140808,
1.5028376579284668,
-0.0014876449713483453,
0.9520337581634521,
0.25527551770210266,
-0.050642065703868866,
0.7219734787940979,
0.017571115866303444,
0.0958399698138237,
0.3793647885322571,
-0.16426749527454376,
-0.5567848682403564,
-0.14975324273109436,
-0.29752489924430847,
-0.2780768573284149,
0.5635263919830322,
0.4078269302845001,
-0.12108351290225983,
-0.26031264662742615,
-0.08856507390737534,
0.38900133967399597,
0.5295745134353638,
-0.24944506585597992,
0.8399548530578613,
-0.09543249756097794,
-0.836560070514679,
1.1306159496307373,
-0.22728462517261505,
0.5206276774406433,
-0.46622395515441895,
-0.4732452630996704,
-0.5024983882904053,
0.2431684285402298,
-0.34513577818870544,
-0.6164671182632446,
0.323285311460495,
0.07002265006303787,
-0.2810540497303009,
-0.43461135029792786,
0.8253228664398193,
-0.7220829129219055,
-0.4618456959724426,
-0.02366274781525135,
0.36207276582717896,
0.21330080926418304,
0.004935116972774267,
-0.26459288597106934,
-0.28022465109825134,
-0.005318933166563511,
0.030354812741279602,
0.3436703681945801,
0.3776203393936157,
-0.003386539639905095,
0.7748188376426697,
0.7076988220214844,
0.016863182187080383,
0.011042243801057339,
-0.10264883935451508,
0.7591168880462646,
-0.05537733808159828,
-0.194856658577919,
-0.48119691014289856,
0.3768500089645386,
-0.12113078683614731,
-0.1107824295759201,
1.0540204048156738,
0.5912411212921143,
1.0449858903884888,
-0.19890256226062775,
0.7391329407691956,
-0.01285544689744711,
0.9184728264808655,
-0.5708734393119812,
0.8608732223510742,
-0.5174747705459595,
0.24008771777153015,
-0.16560465097427368,
-0.6155349612236023,
-0.1947866529226303,
0.5645784139633179,
-0.06163129210472107,
-0.12363064289093018,
0.296159565448761,
1.2067557573318481,
-0.1336328387260437,
-0.24873606860637665,
0.38537099957466125,
0.2698848247528076,
0.15623998641967773,
0.042757272720336914,
0.9522607922554016,
-0.3881937861442566,
0.4872983396053314,
-0.6930174231529236,
-0.05202782526612282,
0.07233782857656479,
-0.6914960145950317,
-0.8817873597145081,
-0.5475972890853882,
-0.21859592199325562,
-0.36710676550865173,
0.10631373524665833,
0.8176916837692261,
0.5481981635093689,
-0.6336589455604553,
-0.2214990109205246,
-0.16690024733543396,
0.17601029574871063,
-0.11969541758298874,
-0.21477267146110535,
0.4480257034301758,
-0.779594361782074,
-0.7359392642974854,
0.8802599906921387,
0.05117335915565491,
0.014548626728355885,
-0.14621692895889282,
-0.22792749106884003,
0.12320362776517868,
-0.10322047024965286,
0.6777852177619934,
0.35582780838012695,
-0.41428396105766296,
-0.038638658821582794,
-0.21978077292442322,
0.005326598882675171,
-0.16533447802066803,
0.5618802905082703,
-1.0796736478805542,
0.7328715920448303,
0.31189557909965515,
0.5884249806404114,
0.7316353917121887,
0.2979676127433777,
0.5084930062294006,
-0.9770494103431702,
0.3176584541797638,
0.26783543825149536,
0.17448821663856506,
0.4064473807811737,
-0.25475212931632996,
0.8282484412193298,
0.022748742252588272,
-0.68843674659729,
-1.1542152166366577,
0.1693079024553299,
-0.6041001677513123,
-0.266130268573761,
1.13591730594635,
-0.10468421131372452,
-0.04646763205528259,
-0.27494800090789795,
-0.4614850580692291,
0.34984081983566284,
-0.14121650159358978,
1.0110599994659424,
-0.1309143304824829,
0.1571315973997116,
-0.22770319879055023,
-0.6596825122833252,
0.9095152020454407,
0.3303607106208801,
-0.6311165690422058,
0.22448252141475677,
0.6924588680267334,
0.1693267822265625,
-0.08624185621738434,
0.45880427956581116,
-0.06829343736171722,
0.17230668663978577,
0.3327242136001587,
0.1699601113796234,
-0.36669012904167175,
-0.36863094568252563,
-0.19115498661994934,
0.29685425758361816,
0.14343753457069397,
0.006919372361153364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13626v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13626v1 | Fine-Tuning Gemma-7B for Enhanced Sentiment Analysis of Financial News Headlines | 2024-06-19T15:20:19 | 2024-06-19T15:20:19 | Kangtong Mo, Wenyan Liu, Xuanzhen Xu, Chang Yu, Yuelin Zou, Fangqing Xia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this study, we explore the application of sentiment analysis on financial
news headlines to understand investor sentiment. By leveraging Natural Language
Processing (NLP) and Large Language Models (LLM), we analyze sentiment from the
perspective of retail investors. The FinancialPhraseBank dataset, which
contains categorized sentiments of financial news headlines, serves as the
basis for our analysis. We fine-tuned several models, including
distilbert-base-uncased, Llama, and gemma-7b, to evaluate their effectiveness
in sentiment classification. Our experiments demonstrate that the fine-tuned
gemma-7b model outperforms others, achieving the highest precision, recall, and
F1 score. Specifically, the gemma-7b model showed significant improvements in
accuracy after fine-tuning, indicating its robustness in capturing the nuances
of financial sentiment. This model can be instrumental in providing market
insights, risk management, and aiding investment decisions by accurately
predicting the sentiment of financial news. The results highlight the potential
of advanced LLMs in transforming how we analyze and interpret financial
information, offering a powerful tool for stakeholders in the financial
industry. | [
-0.26667550206184387,
-0.798970103263855,
-0.04178479313850403,
0.7594156265258789,
-0.4730710983276367,
0.391257643699646,
-0.21794506907463074,
-0.5792151689529419,
0.31460440158843994,
0.4837372303009033,
-0.25789040327072144,
-0.815805196762085,
-0.8471724390983582,
0.2177426517009735,
-0.3968471884727478,
1.17200767993927,
0.34503796696662903,
0.5330337882041931,
0.23786118626594543,
0.0900978147983551,
-0.40142256021499634,
-0.1877068281173706,
-1.0390793085098267,
-0.16744808852672577,
0.42318475246429443,
0.11980463564395905,
1.1162689924240112,
0.4082222878932953,
1.1235917806625366,
0.21831990778446198,
-0.5988466143608093,
0.40559738874435425,
-0.3622314929962158,
-0.5269200205802917,
-0.18784448504447937,
-0.4549408257007599,
-0.8272548913955688,
0.07179158926010132,
0.4125722348690033,
0.5670571327209473,
-0.1773223876953125,
0.23630665242671967,
0.3585217297077179,
0.8913034200668335,
-0.3690817356109619,
0.6354256868362427,
-0.5767788887023926,
0.06209192052483559,
-0.16631361842155457,
-0.5954211354255676,
-0.6299281716346741,
-0.3636850118637085,
0.11808662861585617,
-0.3535098135471344,
0.1333310455083847,
0.17242984473705292,
1.0752040147781372,
0.28329458832740784,
-0.41845712065696716,
-0.4812726080417633,
-0.33478960394859314,
0.7403988838195801,
-0.6467145085334778,
0.30574166774749756,
0.18204422295093536,
0.24979406595230103,
-0.2642754912376404,
-0.43629521131515503,
-0.024694764986634254,
-0.18288058042526245,
0.08797547221183777,
0.1959371268749237,
-0.5083292126655579,
0.12521712481975555,
-0.10307767242193222,
0.7602712512016296,
-0.1954379379749298,
0.15403394401073456,
-0.579675555229187,
0.007077748421579599,
0.5833825469017029,
0.11891679465770721,
-0.04461574926972389,
-0.335570752620697,
-0.5264202356338501,
-0.14126335084438324,
-0.7750679850578308,
0.0413786880671978,
0.499916136264801,
0.8206262588500977,
-0.04311572015285492,
0.4971037209033966,
-0.2766364514827728,
0.6794507503509521,
0.4335838556289673,
-0.41793912649154663,
0.3176667094230652,
-0.030096502974629402,
-0.4851151406764984,
0.37365058064460754,
0.2854999601840973,
0.7545527219772339,
0.19842994213104248,
0.012988287955522537,
-0.15467482805252075,
0.052495576441287994,
0.3608580529689789,
-0.7882235050201416,
-0.2452837973833084,
0.1972150057554245,
-0.8427832126617432,
-0.6166903972625732,
0.11828792095184326,
-0.9302855730056763,
-0.5628939270973206,
-0.4688740670681,
0.16631893813610077,
-0.2063010036945343,
-0.08328711241483688,
0.7937538623809814,
-0.38151881098747253,
0.5722496509552002,
0.4606751799583435,
-0.8394054174423218,
0.09872537106275558,
0.7872234582901001,
0.6263872385025024,
0.06427368521690369,
0.1141791120171547,
-0.6488660573959351,
0.09159770607948303,
-0.41393932700157166,
0.9076982736587524,
-0.5794958472251892,
-0.5907801985740662,
-0.06247885152697563,
-0.3193211853504181,
0.0018963939510285854,
-0.7553790211677551,
0.5012832880020142,
-0.4668698012828827,
-0.06254053860902786,
-0.2820264995098114,
-0.42568522691726685,
-0.3422294557094574,
0.4261351227760315,
-0.651398777961731,
0.7481176257133484,
0.1543390303850174,
-0.9135305881500244,
0.6419463753700256,
-0.8270631432533264,
-0.38091933727264404,
-0.10719132423400879,
0.27045944333076477,
-0.4513087570667267,
0.3107680678367615,
0.6376842260360718,
0.49378594756126404,
-0.5376235842704773,
0.18609055876731873,
-0.5193706154823303,
-0.10226715356111526,
0.49834316968917847,
-0.547675609588623,
0.36846229434013367,
0.28607842326164246,
-0.1676209717988968,
-0.024316688999533653,
-0.8245454430580139,
-0.46873781085014343,
-0.11128071695566177,
-0.24959824979305267,
-0.3136731684207916,
0.08991977572441101,
0.2810268998146057,
-0.10092862695455551,
0.625965416431427,
-0.43201500177383423,
0.2640978991985321,
-0.5001084208488464,
0.3486425578594208,
0.7518673539161682,
0.033809419721364975,
0.4904470443725586,
-0.22490009665489197,
0.5992183089256287,
0.21731248497962952,
0.5395159125328064,
0.09342551976442337,
-0.35526230931282043,
-0.4826783835887909,
-0.4902626872062683,
0.3202519416809082,
0.5223420858383179,
0.1224704459309578,
0.3345293402671814,
-0.09469949454069138,
-0.44002673029899597,
-0.6744484901428223,
0.33808085322380066,
-0.018600303679704666,
0.3469264507293701,
0.6070092916488647,
-0.06647562980651855,
-0.5082300901412964,
-0.8530438542366028,
-0.6003679037094116,
-0.15114004909992218,
0.292633980512619,
-0.037226688116788864,
-0.14190739393234253,
-0.3384082615375519,
0.8219608068466187,
-0.8344421982765198,
-0.5160807967185974,
-0.4337341785430908,
0.2309674471616745,
0.6506954431533813,
0.16280408203601837,
0.7855149507522583,
-0.9978976845741272,
-0.13951225578784943,
0.2600992023944855,
-0.43357670307159424,
0.03474954515695572,
-0.3927939236164093,
0.0001700205320958048,
0.0366697683930397,
0.5918518304824829,
-0.5638196468353271,
0.5163694620132446,
0.3831826150417328,
-0.671802818775177,
0.20258282124996185,
0.12896902859210968,
0.008206039667129517,
-1.189705491065979,
-0.38131874799728394,
0.2868160009384155,
-0.23914563655853271,
-0.16232529282569885,
0.06013164669275284,
-0.07180953770875931,
0.1630241721868515,
-0.2240619659423828,
0.546105146408081,
-0.27814823389053345,
-0.07113995403051376,
-0.529095470905304,
-0.03260551765561104,
0.18695364892482758,
0.031215861439704895,
-0.09686145186424255,
0.712285041809082,
0.5814471244812012,
-0.25610053539276123,
0.2239258885383606,
0.23701244592666626,
-0.327447772026062,
0.3207898736000061,
-0.4880274832248688,
-0.3730652928352356,
-0.04472675174474716,
-0.014407400041818619,
-1.1192948818206787,
-0.04839921370148659,
0.054237812757492065,
-0.4819934666156769,
0.31605076789855957,
0.10219675302505493,
-0.5620676279067993,
-0.14178812503814697,
-0.3004190921783447,
-0.005854785442352295,
0.22037146985530853,
-0.7009503245353699,
0.7747933268547058,
0.21334564685821533,
-0.391271710395813,
-0.5571869611740112,
-0.5428521037101746,
0.3820554316043854,
-0.6917254328727722,
-0.46824321150779724,
0.2642214596271515,
0.19210316240787506,
-0.4965033531188965,
-0.25211673974990845,
-0.21024616062641144,
0.19040876626968384,
0.33647605776786804,
0.15379244089126587,
0.5831604599952698,
-0.12137740105390549,
-0.03875564783811569,
0.12572257220745087,
-0.2841496169567108,
0.24742813408374786,
-0.12736961245536804,
0.4628622233867645,
-0.4058661162853241,
0.12927807867527008,
-0.2988054156303406,
0.05090605467557907,
0.49068570137023926,
-0.3321579098701477,
0.909580647945404,
0.6064009070396423,
-0.20608225464820862,
-0.04289346560835838,
-0.5353245735168457,
0.1664869487285614,
-0.5462487936019897,
0.4172850549221039,
-0.12127318233251572,
-0.947265625,
0.7263495922088623,
-0.017236394807696342,
-0.08722030371427536,
0.6957711577415466,
0.719296932220459,
0.1323058158159256,
1.1152292490005493,
0.7484533190727234,
-0.47054997086524963,
0.4914761483669281,
-0.11644098162651062,
0.6005793213844299,
-0.40714120864868164,
-0.27131348848342896,
-0.4395880699157715,
-0.42122572660446167,
-0.5439355373382568,
-0.12350935488939285,
0.22486215829849243,
0.37490808963775635,
-0.027371544390916824,
0.18176154792308807,
-0.3402223289012909,
0.37742722034454346,
0.35503023862838745,
0.14127442240715027,
0.4866628348827362,
-0.06940049678087234,
-0.0078043206594884396,
0.15223050117492676,
-0.2093334048986435,
-0.6023128032684326,
1.035791277885437,
0.7612687349319458,
1.1584340333938599,
0.010744486935436726,
0.49868208169937134,
0.49960196018218994,
0.441997766494751,
-0.7968212962150574,
0.2573079764842987,
-0.40446633100509644,
-0.30325430631637573,
0.04808908700942993,
-0.4398517310619354,
-0.4845721125602722,
-0.16007833182811737,
-0.15568771958351135,
-0.4232744872570038,
0.48135504126548767,
0.051712699234485626,
-0.7071912288665771,
0.12969845533370972,
-0.5496789216995239,
0.746213972568512,
0.09485986083745956,
0.02846732921898365,
-0.37369123101234436,
0.013188675977289677,
0.4318525791168213,
-0.08452907204627991,
0.2904192805290222,
-0.3411225378513336,
0.1702306866645813,
0.41935980319976807,
-0.1701449602842331,
0.9571381211280823,
-0.037410005927085876,
-0.568040668964386,
0.20857790112495422,
-0.28409257531166077,
0.39192813634872437,
0.6373258233070374,
-0.16768088936805725,
0.18479079008102417,
-0.20862948894500732,
-0.5368458032608032,
-0.342202752828598,
0.5948501229286194,
-0.7200509309768677,
-0.5459757447242737,
-0.34248584508895874,
-0.6439236998558044,
-0.17376431822776794,
-0.30750375986099243,
0.16220949590206146,
0.3324379026889801,
-0.09832260012626648,
0.40729498863220215,
0.18142825365066528,
-0.020548177883028984,
0.4165988266468048,
0.24769870936870575,
-0.46345698833465576,
-0.6137679815292358,
0.6750468611717224,
-0.09223035722970963,
0.043141014873981476,
0.6518681645393372,
0.26580172777175903,
-0.5451464653015137,
-0.7833081483840942,
-0.1166633740067482,
-0.09708543121814728,
-0.6677305102348328,
-0.6422102451324463,
-0.40909990668296814,
-0.03605436533689499,
-0.5965602397918701,
-0.3241899013519287,
-0.5207992196083069,
-0.182442307472229,
-0.7011098265647888,
-0.5810398459434509,
0.7500627040863037,
0.5582481622695923,
0.03194833919405937,
0.45021721720695496,
-1.1754388809204102,
0.41500625014305115,
0.11235921084880829,
0.28102365136146545,
-0.16483530402183533,
-0.5420443415641785,
-0.5907372236251831,
0.11993274837732315,
-0.4646591544151306,
-0.6221269965171814,
0.7306461930274963,
0.12183308601379395,
0.09216576814651489,
0.9434890151023865,
0.05360283702611923,
0.9119006991386414,
0.20424103736877441,
0.4424053728580475,
0.11218294501304626,
-0.8755649924278259,
0.413667768239975,
-0.6154759526252747,
0.20792166888713837,
0.5523692965507507,
0.03383885324001312,
-0.09421215951442719,
-0.7149120569229126,
-0.22093617916107178,
-0.8628242015838623,
0.09415926784276962,
0.05838455259799957,
0.15963207185268402,
-0.5058813691139221,
0.5680644512176514,
0.02812029793858528,
0.38495293259620667,
-0.6013337969779968,
0.0074943797662854195,
-0.1915747970342636,
-0.3610592484474182,
-0.07808440923690796,
-0.3821559250354767,
0.1229732558131218,
-0.27633601427078247,
0.4072668254375458,
-0.24261519312858582,
-0.01601245068013668,
0.13385234773159027,
0.019271336495876312,
-0.15185926854610443,
0.12516441941261292,
0.21728619933128357,
0.791124701499939,
-0.5363034605979919,
-0.33046960830688477,
0.1679714322090149,
-0.4916975200176239,
-0.3043040633201599,
0.2596256732940674,
0.08351273089647293,
-0.02644960582256317,
0.4058198630809784,
0.6019587516784668,
0.523145318031311,
-0.7312745451927185,
0.40318572521209717,
-0.24940425157546997,
-0.17353439331054688,
-0.4828032851219177,
0.006244227290153503,
0.06321290880441666,
0.6939703822135925,
0.787135124206543,
0.30576470494270325,
0.5435712337493896,
-0.7217753529548645,
0.06012750789523125,
0.5075366497039795,
-0.3822803199291229,
-0.3026176393032074,
0.7124043107032776,
0.03903648629784584,
0.30763348937034607,
0.5003266334533691,
-0.0075038461945950985,
-0.22128035128116608,
0.658189594745636,
0.4863416850566864,
1.0949254035949707,
0.00261142966337502,
0.33539828658103943,
0.010127517394721508,
0.13289432227611542,
-0.32896146178245544,
0.5519298315048218,
0.3717412054538727,
-0.8935449719429016,
-0.677906334400177,
-1.2862926721572876,
-0.43847039341926575,
-0.18725773692131042,
-1.247901439666748,
0.5886447429656982,
-0.7158800959587097,
-0.4587138593196869,
0.265210896730423,
0.13198313117027283,
-0.5542348623275757,
0.5640215277671814,
0.13917797803878784,
1.2589441537857056,
-0.631519079208374,
0.5043699741363525,
0.7440692782402039,
-0.16814705729484558,
-0.6848872900009155,
-0.18738757073879242,
-0.25972622632980347,
-0.7073124051094055,
0.568801760673523,
0.40771517157554626,
-0.05876147374510765,
-0.044409606605768204,
-0.4632585048675537,
-0.6263172626495361,
0.9045102000236511,
0.4098145365715027,
-0.7034065127372742,
-0.1627863347530365,
0.10073582828044891,
0.5231577754020691,
-0.6673946976661682,
-0.10143623501062393,
0.6500104069709778,
0.5872255563735962,
0.2573719322681427,
-0.6994548439979553,
-0.5380793213844299,
-0.3930010497570038,
-0.3464798033237457,
0.4332176744937897,
-0.8652844429016113,
0.7654486894607544,
-0.1296614110469818,
0.27954861521720886,
-0.08252795040607452,
0.9086706638336182,
0.13637657463550568,
0.40712666511535645,
0.30325812101364136,
0.6024948358535767,
0.6297215223312378,
-0.10519246011972427,
1.0697972774505615,
-0.6251347661018372,
0.5038866996765137,
0.8492593765258789,
-0.130059152841568,
1.1011091470718384,
0.3026890456676483,
-0.26500096917152405,
0.4182417690753937,
0.7556972503662109,
-0.205149307847023,
0.41911986470222473,
0.08148083835840225,
-0.15592463314533234,
-0.47445955872535706,
-0.15762858092784882,
-0.24232730269432068,
0.9106378555297852,
0.4689466953277588,
-0.6064512729644775,
-0.158319354057312,
-0.029459094628691673,
0.026736166328191757,
0.05216732993721962,
-0.9365577101707458,
0.6891415119171143,
0.4811781644821167,
-0.08159734308719635,
0.05173734575510025,
0.3089613616466522,
0.6715182662010193,
-0.4281906485557556,
0.3742268681526184,
-0.26396408677101135,
0.5085381269454956,
-0.16352397203445435,
-0.5847131013870239,
0.594240665435791,
0.06668262183666229,
-0.36581143736839294,
-0.2754538059234619,
0.5542200803756714,
-0.11655056476593018,
-0.8389456272125244,
0.6309549808502197,
0.0890229120850563,
-0.3901486396789551,
-0.4587799906730652,
-0.4432932436466217,
-0.26994600892066956,
0.03376631811261177,
-0.35582345724105835,
0.4947851300239563,
0.41967684030532837,
0.18410298228263855,
0.5773968696594238,
0.9519996047019958,
0.061209097504615784,
-0.056144461035728455,
0.21279945969581604,
0.9074914455413818,
-1.2373948097229004,
-0.733060359954834,
-1.0498415231704712,
0.19865089654922485,
0.020761052146553993,
-0.5296489596366882,
0.7599890828132629,
0.7125796675682068,
0.5489590764045715,
-0.06000230833888054,
0.38038623332977295,
0.7189267873764038,
0.39096492528915405,
-0.8195275068283081,
0.6249263882637024,
-0.32176846265792847,
0.43226930499076843,
-0.39115849137306213,
-0.9394795298576355,
-0.5999315977096558,
0.4814136326313019,
-0.33164772391319275,
-0.20811276137828827,
0.29801100492477417,
0.7217159867286682,
0.0863337367773056,
0.36871492862701416,
0.05950777605175972,
0.26687556505203247,
0.15666352212429047,
-0.03472055122256279,
0.5401874780654907,
-0.28047922253608704,
0.5005726218223572,
0.04161711037158966,
0.1662624627351761,
-0.38711947202682495,
-1.0250611305236816,
-1.0939457416534424,
0.0752478837966919,
-0.3899534344673157,
-0.2818479537963867,
-0.08536778390407562,
1.026558756828308,
-0.019174806773662567,
-0.6878886222839355,
-0.171330526471138,
0.07990579307079315,
-0.09648361057043076,
-0.18119259178638458,
-0.33194562792778015,
0.4353426396846771,
-0.6691524386405945,
-0.6892993450164795,
0.355094313621521,
0.779125452041626,
0.08221787214279175,
-0.17156991362571716,
0.17301370203495026,
0.2983663082122803,
0.36601272225379944,
0.6187620162963867,
-0.37388065457344055,
-0.4219881594181061,
-0.2905227839946747,
0.11860423535108566,
0.06270093470811844,
0.13152258098125458,
0.44258809089660645,
-0.32953497767448425,
-0.004380451515316963,
0.3482972979545593,
0.6241012215614319,
0.07784731686115265,
0.3652389347553253,
0.7753187417984009,
-0.3077085316181183,
0.2833402454853058,
0.050862427800893784,
0.5526375770568848,
0.25397181510925293,
-0.6381039619445801,
0.09033229202032089,
-0.1775958389043808,
-0.3080032467842102,
-0.627150297164917,
-0.27762919664382935,
-1.1791012287139893,
-0.19841572642326355,
1.0937824249267578,
0.11969500780105591,
-0.36651885509490967,
0.1451287418603897,
-0.2608662247657776,
-0.14038509130477905,
-0.6733519434928894,
1.1364033222198486,
0.632799506187439,
0.3251477777957916,
-0.23101767897605896,
-0.4073512852191925,
0.5633918642997742,
0.28921622037887573,
-0.5388727188110352,
0.06611857563257217,
0.17010274529457092,
-0.03710463270545006,
0.10643885284662247,
0.3758309781551361,
-0.29203593730926514,
0.4681464433670044,
-0.1560375690460205,
-0.14750725030899048,
-0.027159642428159714,
-0.4189533293247223,
-0.33571857213974,
0.4226316213607788,
0.2839319109916687,
-0.249644935131073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13621v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13621v1 | Improving Visual Commonsense in Language Models via Multiple Image Generation | 2024-06-19T15:17:10 | 2024-06-19T15:17:10 | Guy Yariv, Idan Schwartz, Yossi Adi, Sagie Benaim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Commonsense reasoning is fundamentally based on multimodal knowledge.
However, existing large language models (LLMs) are primarily trained using
textual data only, limiting their ability to incorporate essential visual
information. In contrast, Visual Language Models, which excel at
visually-oriented tasks, often fail at non-visual tasks such as basic
commonsense reasoning. This divergence highlights a critical challenge - the
integration of robust visual understanding with foundational text-based
language reasoning. To this end, we introduce a method aimed at enhancing LLMs'
visual commonsense. Specifically, our method generates multiple images based on
the input text prompt and integrates these into the model's decision-making
process by mixing their prediction probabilities. To facilitate multimodal
grounded language modeling, we employ a late-fusion layer that combines the
projected visual features with the output of a pre-trained LLM conditioned on
text only. This late-fusion layer enables predictions based on comprehensive
image-text knowledge as well as text only when this is required. We evaluate
our approach using several visual commonsense reasoning tasks together with
traditional NLP tasks, including common sense reasoning and reading
comprehension. Our experimental results demonstrate significant superiority
over existing baselines. When applied to recent state-of-the-art LLMs (e.g.,
Llama3), we observe improvements not only in visual common sense but also in
traditional NLP benchmarks. Code and models are available under
https://github.com/guyyariv/vLMIG. | [
-0.35065922141075134,
-0.664517343044281,
0.7955170273780823,
0.05353326350450516,
-0.4394500255584717,
-0.2755942940711975,
-0.27420204877853394,
-0.34531837701797485,
-0.15269148349761963,
0.7009531855583191,
-0.2834875285625458,
-0.6500557065010071,
-0.4849962890148163,
0.1995161473751068,
0.08530136942863464,
0.6144445538520813,
0.0557943619787693,
-0.036124665290117264,
-0.668053150177002,
-0.29171115159988403,
-0.5886522531509399,
-0.15737460553646088,
-0.2948075234889984,
-0.3529931306838989,
0.545494794845581,
0.6039714813232422,
0.6872498989105225,
0.3966714143753052,
0.37724006175994873,
0.4024506211280823,
-0.03523560240864754,
0.49296024441719055,
-0.35488080978393555,
0.11384081095457077,
-0.18406619131565094,
-0.2297627329826355,
-0.27712976932525635,
-0.1434226632118225,
0.5411564707756042,
0.3662896454334259,
0.04272209852933884,
-0.2565673589706421,
-0.1017310842871666,
0.36015647649765015,
-0.7172521948814392,
0.17779789865016937,
-0.9067414402961731,
-0.1210525706410408,
-0.007159221917390823,
-0.20871855318546295,
-0.4848005473613739,
0.021954450756311417,
0.08747004717588425,
-0.7177095413208008,
-0.003988782875239849,
0.09698032587766647,
0.818875789642334,
0.324883371591568,
-0.4599718153476715,
0.07612049579620361,
-0.05410010740160942,
1.055503487586975,
-0.7773234248161316,
0.5218542814254761,
0.38387995958328247,
0.2631928026676178,
-0.07394295185804367,
-0.7080115079879761,
-1.03950035572052,
-0.3811906576156616,
-0.22386452555656433,
0.2985817492008209,
-0.3571009635925293,
-0.14425332844257355,
0.1350499391555786,
-0.008327377028763294,
-0.5278152227401733,
0.1409343034029007,
-0.27036595344543457,
-0.1371632218360901,
0.4321405589580536,
-0.016170253977179527,
0.454423189163208,
-0.4942778944969177,
-0.6552350521087646,
-0.22545959055423737,
-0.5325402021408081,
-0.22158530354499817,
0.11355812102556229,
0.11274104565382004,
-0.26117241382598877,
0.7403310537338257,
-0.21585455536842346,
1.0148212909698486,
-0.29216933250427246,
-0.42224425077438354,
0.48102205991744995,
-0.45133981108665466,
-0.19583240151405334,
-0.1777968406677246,
0.6657495498657227,
0.864952802658081,
0.23626065254211426,
0.29773733019828796,
-0.3526453971862793,
0.2989058792591095,
0.07565536350011826,
-0.49343305826187134,
-0.24372464418411255,
0.19022034108638763,
-0.5348085761070251,
-0.5115893483161926,
-0.4080134630203247,
-0.7252710461616516,
-0.549030601978302,
-0.4593358635902405,
0.2648530900478363,
-0.5888446569442749,
-0.47645050287246704,
0.20345941185951233,
-0.35877078771591187,
0.26129958033561707,
0.6758085489273071,
-0.7184614539146423,
-0.026233313605189323,
0.3862566649913788,
0.7138996720314026,
-0.17651139199733734,
-0.5727187991142273,
-0.720559298992157,
0.29656001925468445,
-0.03568987548351288,
1.126845359802246,
-0.7257320284843445,
-0.17092406749725342,
0.01286715641617775,
-0.22256293892860413,
0.007973914965987206,
-0.48830416798591614,
0.4024321734905243,
-0.3190418481826782,
0.0726659968495369,
-0.07630264014005661,
-0.2752194106578827,
-0.17030909657478333,
0.543562114238739,
-0.7353167533874512,
0.8132870197296143,
-0.2781399190425873,
-0.8307815790176392,
0.4560565948486328,
-0.5993954539299011,
-0.4409213066101074,
0.19892242550849915,
-0.33694377541542053,
-0.3647276759147644,
0.03937140479683876,
0.6882237792015076,
0.8027316331863403,
-0.0410151332616806,
0.4154013395309448,
-0.49650028347969055,
-0.023717274889349937,
0.45179781317710876,
-0.6882449388504028,
0.4113348722457886,
0.2683616280555725,
0.012717894278466702,
0.2640518248081207,
-0.7320051789283752,
-0.13038738071918488,
0.1340574324131012,
-0.18268468976020813,
-0.39146023988723755,
-0.07466643303632736,
0.2589712142944336,
0.22053639590740204,
0.2216857522726059,
-0.2570311427116394,
0.03050515614449978,
-0.15411251783370972,
0.18568356335163116,
0.7074522972106934,
-0.06415209174156189,
0.4637846052646637,
-0.29183676838874817,
0.11990835517644882,
0.2597494125366211,
0.07972947508096695,
-0.4858897924423218,
-0.7330570816993713,
-0.7581584453582764,
-0.3705005943775177,
-0.3254072964191437,
0.5912027955055237,
-1.2836451530456543,
0.12025298178195953,
-0.39704060554504395,
-0.34704846143722534,
-0.2174062281847,
0.41126948595046997,
0.5505831837654114,
0.5984259247779846,
0.5032124519348145,
-0.22345110774040222,
-0.2542401850223541,
-0.9066117405891418,
-0.401157408952713,
-0.2006245255470276,
0.18282826244831085,
0.5365679264068604,
0.5767145156860352,
-0.3268178701400757,
0.7113760113716125,
-0.6219974756240845,
-0.24167820811271667,
-0.46360188722610474,
0.32025399804115295,
0.22997762262821198,
0.5138357877731323,
0.42034417390823364,
-1.0347551107406616,
-0.14027704298496246,
0.1671006679534912,
-0.7407753467559814,
-0.1576688587665558,
-0.31286752223968506,
-0.06843888759613037,
0.18064364790916443,
0.47934192419052124,
-0.5321751236915588,
0.25966766476631165,
0.6999510526657104,
-0.3274977207183838,
0.5090534687042236,
-0.20240743458271027,
0.2261308878660202,
-1.0196073055267334,
-0.1768936812877655,
0.395358145236969,
-0.24313345551490784,
-0.7305483222007751,
0.08518356829881668,
-0.010489187203347683,
-0.18523404002189636,
-0.8292267918586731,
0.883918046951294,
-0.5130599141120911,
-0.012498552910983562,
-0.22807160019874573,
0.24280403554439545,
0.14510740339756012,
0.5726907849311829,
0.4675166606903076,
0.6200535893440247,
0.6677454113960266,
-0.47921961545944214,
0.47099560499191284,
0.1626962423324585,
-0.39358675479888916,
0.7806729674339294,
-0.5431500673294067,
-0.0856558158993721,
-0.33919474482536316,
0.15336762368679047,
-1.1114513874053955,
-0.4661194980144501,
0.17878499627113342,
-0.3456522524356842,
0.22720137238502502,
-0.13960056006908417,
-0.6165756583213806,
-0.262116938829422,
-0.1483909636735916,
0.39450204372406006,
0.29664453864097595,
-0.7418591380119324,
0.8539772629737854,
0.1254372000694275,
-0.1332615166902542,
-0.7093942761421204,
-0.9428715705871582,
0.23115235567092896,
-0.04562324658036232,
-0.7956746220588684,
0.14160771667957306,
0.1252339482307434,
-0.39066001772880554,
0.10957150906324387,
0.08603916317224503,
-0.2092146873474121,
-0.041083499789237976,
-0.00928597804158926,
0.46252912282943726,
-0.12789234519004822,
0.3313279151916504,
0.16644226014614105,
-0.2642301321029663,
-0.3364536762237549,
-0.2816038727760315,
0.342631459236145,
-0.5184709429740906,
-0.5020782351493835,
-0.4036683142185211,
0.2633011043071747,
0.5265825390815735,
-0.4288988411426544,
0.5750259160995483,
0.7763170599937439,
-0.24393047392368317,
-0.12128981947898865,
-0.7803409695625305,
-0.09495480358600616,
-0.4396889805793762,
0.39625465869903564,
-0.41042885184288025,
-0.7493818402290344,
0.20796068012714386,
-0.13500893115997314,
0.03281561657786369,
0.27341169118881226,
0.5162657499313354,
-0.27847421169281006,
0.7456761002540588,
0.3318672180175781,
0.47759801149368286,
0.3770219683647156,
-0.08359503000974655,
-0.03536504879593849,
-0.5441945791244507,
-0.26161763072013855,
-0.11765754967927933,
-0.03486962616443634,
-0.4227418005466461,
-0.7936269640922546,
0.356399267911911,
0.04831590875983238,
0.1631048619747162,
0.08651410043239594,
-0.2907937467098236,
0.6806530356407166,
0.6122362017631531,
0.3852699398994446,
0.3502469062805176,
0.18661272525787354,
-0.18051084876060486,
-0.07128570228815079,
-0.8244377970695496,
-0.5563138127326965,
0.911050021648407,
0.2508600354194641,
0.6989616751670837,
0.2654772698879242,
0.7239435911178589,
-0.03708571940660477,
0.3932420313358307,
-0.5192877054214478,
0.728215217590332,
-0.45077234506607056,
-0.2102227807044983,
-0.13462083041667938,
-0.36136478185653687,
-0.5793972015380859,
0.6090176105499268,
-0.6760645508766174,
-0.3942086398601532,
0.05321062356233597,
0.43936246633529663,
-0.006267493590712547,
0.2433491349220276,
-0.9042547345161438,
0.9873692393302917,
-0.4122525453567505,
-0.6868889331817627,
-0.26945406198501587,
-0.49941784143447876,
0.7461981177330017,
0.14771628379821777,
0.3296903371810913,
-0.010123522952198982,
-0.1258484125137329,
0.3935810923576355,
-0.24869829416275024,
1.2280809879302979,
-0.10593488067388535,
-0.14239448308944702,
0.1975681483745575,
-0.25052157044410706,
0.45464426279067993,
0.04863692820072174,
0.15982289612293243,
0.13030757009983063,
-0.37609219551086426,
-0.5063949227333069,
-0.5705302357673645,
0.8571521639823914,
-0.5663854479789734,
-0.4585440158843994,
-0.3287574052810669,
-0.5601722002029419,
-0.16122044622898102,
0.33684659004211426,
0.06638842076063156,
0.5022155046463013,
0.022421879693865776,
0.08011483401060104,
0.7873514294624329,
-0.6054985523223877,
0.5032100081443787,
-0.008246359415352345,
-0.1657620519399643,
-0.7499825358390808,
0.9270810484886169,
-0.33954286575317383,
0.45907726883888245,
0.47967231273651123,
0.31651604175567627,
-0.6242223978042603,
-0.5115034580230713,
-0.3779316246509552,
0.22149482369422913,
-1.1544108390808105,
-0.2922375202178955,
-0.6825186014175415,
0.23088645935058594,
-0.508925199508667,
-0.38072094321250916,
-0.12047962099313736,
-0.17062416672706604,
-0.4882783889770508,
0.11358332633972168,
0.41308513283729553,
0.42988714575767517,
0.013934577815234661,
0.3471873104572296,
-0.8606918454170227,
0.7724930047988892,
0.671375572681427,
0.3939521908760071,
-0.06621222198009491,
-0.2911407947540283,
0.19461625814437866,
-0.17606161534786224,
-0.09341323375701904,
-0.879123866558075,
0.339684396982193,
0.13501839339733124,
0.7913063764572144,
0.3422262966632843,
-0.15783147513866425,
0.674325168132782,
-0.40616506338119507,
0.7937673330307007,
0.8920371532440186,
-0.8088662028312683,
0.6485546827316284,
-0.38119712471961975,
0.5988248586654663,
0.38734543323516846,
0.013518819585442543,
-0.30430272221565247,
-0.4135304391384125,
-0.4986899197101593,
-0.623045802116394,
0.28513598442077637,
0.21240165829658508,
0.26039811968803406,
-0.12403889000415802,
-0.24601297080516815,
0.1073407307267189,
0.0372563898563385,
-1.0565444231033325,
0.03602329269051552,
-0.5959439873695374,
-0.29762139916419983,
0.0485181100666523,
-0.3276841938495636,
-0.09176124632358551,
-0.1524839550256729,
0.4696516990661621,
-0.41237661242485046,
-0.0937933474779129,
0.05317758768796921,
-0.3233416676521301,
0.35272860527038574,
0.5219069719314575,
0.8592860102653503,
0.5099560022354126,
0.07333101332187653,
0.5511996150016785,
0.2761380076408386,
-0.3315325677394867,
-0.13720610737800598,
0.030166175216436386,
0.04959613457322121,
0.1318185180425644,
0.6913121938705444,
1.0069929361343384,
0.426349401473999,
-0.7996171116828918,
0.7594260573387146,
0.04171294346451759,
-0.3137796223163605,
-0.06689967215061188,
-0.028941214084625244,
0.11346320062875748,
0.35409247875213623,
0.17912891507148743,
0.4575120210647583,
-0.1352752447128296,
-0.28067833185195923,
0.3158346712589264,
0.2974909543991089,
0.10812054574489594,
0.11614203453063965,
0.4408053159713745,
0.39024028182029724,
0.21604855358600616,
0.49579575657844543,
-0.164412260055542,
-0.5077246427536011,
0.3501749336719513,
0.6059799194335938,
0.5853058695793152,
0.16525793075561523,
0.3113820254802704,
0.3124221861362457,
0.3526421785354614,
-0.11146476119756699,
0.3754638135433197,
-0.09542969614267349,
-0.9852187633514404,
-0.5898150205612183,
-0.4163409471511841,
-0.16042537987232208,
0.052396614104509354,
-0.09446187317371368,
0.5373334884643555,
-0.39554455876350403,
-0.11930156499147415,
-0.21159058809280396,
-0.3482401669025421,
-0.7200576663017273,
0.3059588670730591,
0.3859846293926239,
0.6485191583633423,
-1.0966246128082275,
0.6613488793373108,
0.7929639220237732,
-0.49749475717544556,
-0.42691469192504883,
-0.23380938172340393,
-0.017413320019841194,
-0.9346335530281067,
0.7849237322807312,
0.2820127606391907,
-0.18682046234607697,
-0.16054606437683105,
-0.874997079372406,
-0.6007627844810486,
0.9803940057754517,
0.18589748442173004,
-0.6351698637008667,
0.3555077910423279,
-0.12035737931728363,
0.23443494737148285,
-0.3151611387729645,
0.2202947735786438,
0.14236311614513397,
0.7333885431289673,
0.45229893922805786,
-0.6819555163383484,
-0.040362074971199036,
-0.3137727677822113,
0.23690883815288544,
-0.10500680655241013,
-0.2498685121536255,
0.6390349864959717,
-0.5359817743301392,
-0.19095972180366516,
-0.07585274428129196,
0.8588710427284241,
0.8509200215339661,
0.5802764296531677,
0.7005777955055237,
0.8489210605621338,
0.6896193027496338,
0.025174565613269806,
1.0184924602508545,
0.14969180524349213,
-0.05398336052894592,
1.2270740270614624,
-0.20370686054229736,
1.0063128471374512,
0.8207675814628601,
0.31407782435417175,
0.29095321893692017,
0.23771634697914124,
-0.26892706751823425,
0.5829985737800598,
-0.07015033811330795,
-0.26991382241249084,
-0.6047545671463013,
-0.3884466290473938,
-0.22894386947155,
0.5798752903938293,
0.23104819655418396,
-0.34135952591896057,
-0.28253883123397827,
0.2418658584356308,
-0.14213916659355164,
0.47992438077926636,
-0.37544360756874084,
0.7036541104316711,
0.022668959572911263,
-0.49322667717933655,
0.6324808597564697,
-0.1177305057644844,
0.9388856291770935,
-0.2622525990009308,
-0.3338959515094757,
-0.09309826046228409,
-0.07584589719772339,
-0.2236645221710205,
-1.0960979461669922,
-0.01621241308748722,
0.13671749830245972,
-0.002713617403060198,
-0.5035223364830017,
1.058605432510376,
-0.6084614396095276,
-0.5860629677772522,
-0.024934977293014526,
0.5767398476600647,
0.17069093883037567,
0.17511840164661407,
-0.6115235686302185,
0.24203063547611237,
-0.02009718120098114,
0.07850734889507294,
-0.020192282274365425,
0.4601093828678131,
-0.013823598623275757,
0.5632495284080505,
0.9323872327804565,
0.05010802298784256,
-0.020403752103447914,
0.3804951012134552,
0.9730798602104187,
-0.4997785687446594,
-0.2990197241306305,
-0.7549454569816589,
0.7507042288780212,
-0.35923585295677185,
-0.3986457884311676,
0.40986913442611694,
0.29923900961875916,
0.7866260409355164,
-0.3309746980667114,
0.7890525460243225,
0.21198058128356934,
-0.07721156626939774,
-1.060530185699463,
0.6704670190811157,
-0.8803192973136902,
0.1337164044380188,
-0.40306970477104187,
-0.728668212890625,
-0.6499419808387756,
0.572160542011261,
-0.29066240787506104,
-0.11259324103593826,
0.5945335030555725,
0.8065834641456604,
-0.22038893401622772,
-0.20405545830726624,
0.5783951282501221,
0.07529827952384949,
0.19597117602825165,
0.5723889470100403,
0.9965016841888428,
-0.1176360622048378,
0.5047218799591064,
-0.13739122450351715,
-0.17544512450695038,
-0.10383839905261993,
-1.2298942804336548,
-0.9897304773330688,
-0.5276618003845215,
-0.3024180829524994,
-0.09538688510656357,
-0.08313195407390594,
0.5719606280326843,
0.49370235204696655,
-0.3610507547855377,
0.11611964553594589,
-0.2112267017364502,
0.15951989591121674,
-0.10000152885913849,
-0.19060413539409637,
0.060215916484594345,
-0.4046574831008911,
-0.5497585535049438,
0.32233506441116333,
0.3743739426136017,
0.22709715366363525,
-0.09848882257938385,
-0.1987723857164383,
-0.36733368039131165,
-0.1491120308637619,
0.7939424514770508,
-0.056365519762039185,
-1.1052271127700806,
-0.14889812469482422,
-0.021397292613983154,
-0.13505233824253082,
-0.07393776625394821,
0.5205699801445007,
-0.7684038877487183,
0.5991010069847107,
0.6394541263580322,
0.5599755644798279,
0.36136823892593384,
-0.16948427259922028,
0.5010161995887756,
-0.784182071685791,
0.25212574005126953,
0.19343097507953644,
0.5856528282165527,
0.6865142583847046,
-0.05483347922563553,
0.18320722877979279,
0.3335396945476532,
-0.01662667654454708,
-0.6914714574813843,
0.4396240711212158,
-1.152539849281311,
-0.4988642930984497,
1.3299623727798462,
0.06036415696144104,
-0.28601130843162537,
0.03842490538954735,
-0.2550239861011505,
0.10194095224142075,
-0.41040685772895813,
0.29548779129981995,
0.539361298084259,
0.11922662705183029,
-0.861449122428894,
-0.37965506315231323,
0.1457987278699875,
0.5219749212265015,
-1.0071840286254883,
0.056935522705316544,
0.9406917691230774,
-0.054354310035705566,
0.20515187084674835,
0.5472553372383118,
0.05212092027068138,
0.4928421974182129,
0.20382153987884521,
0.06446103006601334,
-0.20834030210971832,
-0.3988000452518463,
-0.26092517375946045,
-0.002647272078320384,
-0.09270956367254257,
-0.1078626960515976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13618v1 | In-Context Former: Lightning-fast Compressing Context for Large Language Model | 2024-06-19T15:14:55 | 2024-06-19T15:14:55 | Xiangfeng Wang, Zaiyi Chen, Zheyong Xie, Tong Xu, Yongyi He, Enhong Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the rising popularity of Transformer-based large language models (LLMs),
reducing their high inference costs has become a significant research focus.
One effective approach is to compress the long input contexts. Existing methods
typically leverage the self-attention mechanism of the LLM itself for context
compression. While these methods have achieved notable results, the compression
process still involves quadratic time complexity, which limits their
applicability. To mitigate this limitation, we propose the In-Context Former
(IC-Former). Unlike previous methods, IC-Former does not depend on the target
LLMs. Instead, it leverages the cross-attention mechanism and a small number of
learnable digest tokens to directly condense information from the contextual
word embeddings. This approach significantly reduces inference time, which
achieves linear growth in time complexity within the compression range.
Experimental results indicate that our method requires only 1/32 of the
floating-point operations of the baseline during compression and improves
processing speed by 68 to 112 times while achieving over 90% of the baseline
performance on evaluation metrics. Overall, our model effectively reduces
compression costs and makes real-time compression scenarios feasible. | [
-0.4133226275444031,
-0.5871680974960327,
0.5435911417007446,
0.2069046050310135,
-0.432772696018219,
-0.1072043776512146,
-0.49807968735694885,
-0.5223737359046936,
0.10446581989526749,
0.3853738605976105,
-0.4519144594669342,
0.056820083409547806,
-0.34107351303100586,
-0.037348926067352295,
-0.5886478424072266,
0.6771217584609985,
-0.011098561808466911,
-0.23320017755031586,
-0.15109345316886902,
0.053793735802173615,
-0.43102383613586426,
-0.7018691301345825,
-0.583385169506073,
-0.32237666845321655,
0.35389313101768494,
0.38602522015571594,
0.3805556893348694,
0.5100268721580505,
0.37589722871780396,
0.25845006108283997,
-0.20908059179782867,
-0.21562312543392181,
-0.7105090022087097,
0.165439635515213,
-0.025123411789536476,
-0.34724435210227966,
-0.34878334403038025,
-0.024025455117225647,
0.6356157064437866,
0.6571287512779236,
-0.0033564174082130194,
0.2774021029472351,
0.23680736124515533,
0.615870475769043,
-0.8585370779037476,
-0.012450632639229298,
-0.755740761756897,
0.1863355040550232,
-0.1363528072834015,
-0.547713577747345,
-0.811296284198761,
0.13186809420585632,
-0.1108539029955864,
-0.1701527237892151,
0.15386389195919037,
0.18875131011009216,
0.49703776836395264,
0.36396288871765137,
-0.2045084536075592,
0.26751965284347534,
-0.8216221928596497,
0.8619523048400879,
-0.7475415468215942,
0.602319061756134,
0.10916334390640259,
0.31201377511024475,
-0.0994625836610794,
-1.0612176656723022,
-0.7388245463371277,
0.07411117106676102,
-0.05224940925836563,
-0.0675874575972557,
-0.114932581782341,
0.04597800597548485,
0.38819536566734314,
0.47689512372016907,
-0.31691575050354004,
0.03331513702869415,
0.0598088800907135,
-0.06681421399116516,
0.13016387820243835,
0.022560611367225647,
0.1595250517129898,
-0.21164600551128387,
-0.34369465708732605,
-0.09029532968997955,
-1.2570775747299194,
0.06989619880914688,
-0.13404445350170135,
0.10935262590646744,
-0.10535632073879242,
0.4312710464000702,
-0.3398316502571106,
0.8054909706115723,
0.23652717471122742,
-0.3964817225933075,
0.0433257520198822,
-0.3691331446170807,
-0.4438697099685669,
0.036994241178035736,
0.44243237376213074,
0.4267834424972534,
-0.1012016087770462,
-0.3938460052013397,
-0.16147111356258392,
0.05422729626297951,
0.043153926730155945,
-1.1842706203460693,
0.04859565198421478,
0.21131345629692078,
-0.6461549997329712,
0.0782134011387825,
-0.11179747432470322,
-0.6569505929946899,
0.24276913702487946,
-0.3772348165512085,
0.2757665812969208,
-0.23321063816547394,
0.12427870184183121,
0.009943227283656597,
0.1198139563202858,
0.23543216288089752,
0.26041463017463684,
-0.7335531115531921,
0.2705044746398926,
0.5912489891052246,
1.0024598836898804,
0.01564352586865425,
-0.041732609272003174,
-0.9583776593208313,
0.3630584180355072,
0.06953718513250351,
0.6019706130027771,
-0.5601074695587158,
-0.35892224311828613,
-0.07342903316020966,
-0.10601694136857986,
0.28851044178009033,
-0.373302161693573,
0.5839525461196899,
-0.6949798464775085,
0.10008861869573593,
0.03295992687344551,
-0.6401104927062988,
0.11654993146657944,
0.12667186558246613,
-0.45063748955726624,
1.1502302885055542,
0.24590465426445007,
-0.8405359387397766,
0.31824517250061035,
-0.2977922260761261,
-0.628943145275116,
0.16150274872779846,
-0.18151551485061646,
-0.18162275850772858,
0.337051659822464,
0.5449637770652771,
0.6073507070541382,
-0.5899871587753296,
0.25756391882896423,
-0.2957450747489929,
-0.7882922291755676,
-0.0418611541390419,
-0.4534963369369507,
0.5608838200569153,
0.09923502057790756,
-0.5448998808860779,
-0.13576456904411316,
-0.5168271660804749,
-0.07879264652729034,
-0.002341005951166153,
-0.5029894113540649,
-0.43080225586891174,
-0.14933162927627563,
0.019959354773163795,
0.5103197693824768,
0.1746217906475067,
-0.5849601626396179,
0.3159274458885193,
-0.6018036603927612,
0.6704602837562561,
0.5388340353965759,
-0.18709957599639893,
0.5471529364585876,
-0.04524035379290581,
0.41035008430480957,
-0.15781311690807343,
0.30918100476264954,
-0.3027823567390442,
-0.07248518615961075,
-1.0066652297973633,
-0.3428769111633301,
0.3007946312427521,
0.25521788001060486,
-0.9735000729560852,
0.6950830817222595,
-0.7790442109107971,
-0.4191817045211792,
-0.2627165615558624,
-0.14728854596614838,
0.4466596841812134,
0.7178061008453369,
0.39378711581230164,
-0.011169318109750748,
-0.44002267718315125,
-0.8633176684379578,
-0.14798706769943237,
-0.03053298592567444,
-0.11793587356805801,
0.3969591557979584,
0.29748857021331787,
-0.1639298051595688,
1.045695424079895,
-0.588254988193512,
-0.05714556202292442,
-0.32433566451072693,
0.2552579939365387,
0.33723828196525574,
0.4652101397514343,
0.5381366014480591,
-0.8164333701133728,
-0.5396232008934021,
-0.28914985060691833,
-0.2825639843940735,
-0.2600213885307312,
0.002993335947394371,
0.09801359474658966,
0.0783749520778656,
0.8132416605949402,
-0.6451036930084229,
0.5270056128501892,
0.7804906368255615,
-0.11379388719797134,
0.331877201795578,
-0.16688208281993866,
0.1514982134103775,
-1.0096577405929565,
0.10803940147161484,
-0.2008434683084488,
-0.3972516655921936,
-0.5283605456352234,
0.11765358597040176,
0.5412518382072449,
-0.23332582414150238,
-0.7923492789268494,
0.7109144926071167,
-0.839937150478363,
-0.07469738274812698,
-0.27197322249412537,
0.11458718031644821,
-0.1181875690817833,
0.6395419239997864,
0.06450829654932022,
0.9867045879364014,
0.4668515622615814,
-0.6973451375961304,
-0.05395647883415222,
-0.08899322152137756,
-0.5305113196372986,
0.37381619215011597,
-0.5898690819740295,
0.30447760224342346,
-0.256950318813324,
0.7036674618721008,
-0.792528510093689,
0.06592799723148346,
0.03910673409700394,
-0.015425908379256725,
0.4627908766269684,
-0.21847201883792877,
-0.7802461981773376,
-0.3733985126018524,
-0.4072665870189667,
0.8106688261032104,
0.5367639064788818,
-0.8485304713249207,
0.5167853236198425,
0.1856147199869156,
-0.019153719767928123,
-0.5289351940155029,
-0.8824324607849121,
0.43334221839904785,
-0.31666120886802673,
-0.4361093044281006,
0.9938095808029175,
-0.4213232100009918,
-0.19402287900447845,
-0.10695475339889526,
-0.14049308001995087,
0.19987641274929047,
-0.1005450040102005,
0.07942236214876175,
0.06023038923740387,
-0.11338353902101517,
0.09815304726362228,
0.14367364346981049,
-0.13950467109680176,
-0.38798317313194275,
-0.1738281399011612,
0.7312983274459839,
0.3059816062450409,
-0.0789634957909584,
-0.40546277165412903,
0.5623666048049927,
0.6221420764923096,
-0.058965906500816345,
0.8347364664077759,
0.23090234398841858,
-0.4391395151615143,
-0.2633172273635864,
-0.6497493982315063,
-0.3290618062019348,
-0.4606955349445343,
0.2032497078180313,
-0.34098345041275024,
-1.1214994192123413,
0.24130961298942566,
-0.21348634362220764,
-0.0409059002995491,
0.20777198672294617,
0.4415542185306549,
0.27254101634025574,
0.7956995368003845,
0.6754636764526367,
-0.4147646129131317,
0.8216306567192078,
-0.12377278506755829,
0.5694535374641418,
-1.0133024454116821,
0.0895654559135437,
-0.5405758023262024,
-0.3227071166038513,
-0.024289174005389214,
-0.5793711543083191,
0.5659077763557434,
0.0779133290052414,
0.1251124143600464,
0.5238075852394104,
-0.34155911207199097,
0.485825777053833,
0.23172627389431,
0.09541479498147964,
0.1707492470741272,
-0.05743473023176193,
0.1621273159980774,
-0.0807751715183258,
-0.8040309548377991,
-0.03398672863841057,
0.7975368499755859,
0.22929516434669495,
0.760159969329834,
0.28491702675819397,
0.5060474872589111,
0.11079438030719757,
0.6359307169914246,
-0.9002392292022705,
0.5652691125869751,
-0.1093917191028595,
-0.31929364800453186,
-0.12807317078113556,
-0.4625566303730011,
-0.7956616282463074,
0.2400253862142563,
-0.08552379161119461,
-0.969882607460022,
-0.004588112235069275,
0.11357415467500687,
-0.5014364719390869,
0.13756577670574188,
-0.6682217717170715,
0.3962959051132202,
0.05651715770363808,
-0.3417183458805084,
-0.2999327480792999,
-0.7042179703712463,
0.41135066747665405,
-0.16940180957317352,
0.2749026417732239,
0.24464084208011627,
-0.13837486505508423,
0.5357697010040283,
-0.705432116985321,
0.8813483715057373,
0.008183097466826439,
-0.10490124672651291,
0.0773090273141861,
-0.018566705286502838,
0.7998837828636169,
0.08330866694450378,
0.14459675550460815,
-0.0671614333987236,
-0.3419596254825592,
-0.12341344356536865,
-0.9127139449119568,
0.8972616791725159,
-0.24959096312522888,
-0.5024944543838501,
-0.09927850216627121,
-0.6212872862815857,
-0.2352881282567978,
0.045582957565784454,
0.4754750430583954,
1.047206997871399,
0.06346433609724045,
0.5589520335197449,
0.6476162075996399,
0.014020216651260853,
0.9952386021614075,
0.38050204515457153,
-0.037502072751522064,
-0.3764129877090454,
0.3332037627696991,
0.18955406546592712,
0.18869493901729584,
0.8126188516616821,
0.16053497791290283,
-0.3240475654602051,
-0.5074223279953003,
-0.2397771179676056,
0.3348897099494934,
-0.7030525803565979,
-0.5368252992630005,
-0.7988680005073547,
-0.06327594071626663,
-0.5847723484039307,
-0.40701067447662354,
-0.3884578347206116,
-0.336984783411026,
-0.24686183035373688,
0.3109318017959595,
0.02856745384633541,
0.2336464524269104,
0.2576426565647125,
0.695829451084137,
-0.8643789887428284,
0.3821489214897156,
0.23204636573791504,
0.27346962690353394,
0.20419363677501678,
-0.6889188885688782,
-0.4889480769634247,
-0.3113437592983246,
0.09052668511867523,
-0.6811847686767578,
0.4367772042751312,
0.35782086849212646,
0.39894264936447144,
0.48372021317481995,
0.23281072080135345,
0.9041832685470581,
-0.6167797446250916,
0.9205397963523865,
0.2534627318382263,
-1.2032856941223145,
0.2390381246805191,
0.15453492105007172,
0.635917603969574,
0.41715726256370544,
0.14531847834587097,
-0.5299771428108215,
-0.317950963973999,
-0.5736430883407593,
-1.1149885654449463,
0.5297953486442566,
0.24908298254013062,
0.12436315417289734,
-0.06349311769008636,
0.6465353965759277,
0.04803575202822685,
0.11047881096601486,
-0.8859022855758667,
-0.3144700825214386,
0.2035266011953354,
-0.1169714480638504,
-0.2920219898223877,
-0.6146945357322693,
0.05741918087005615,
-0.45267578959465027,
0.5617130994796753,
-0.18898971378803253,
0.3314235508441925,
0.4184129238128662,
-0.52092444896698,
0.18558625876903534,
0.28839290142059326,
0.5332691669464111,
0.37464940547943115,
-0.12228032201528549,
0.528343677520752,
0.14162442088127136,
-0.2698018252849579,
0.2685152590274811,
-0.02523174323141575,
-0.15719133615493774,
-0.16513879597187042,
0.40275850892066956,
0.5964232087135315,
0.6820849180221558,
-0.6505522727966309,
0.6483889222145081,
-0.40535685420036316,
0.17716848850250244,
-0.3029727637767792,
-0.0792669877409935,
-0.11269161105155945,
0.24661797285079956,
0.4305604100227356,
-0.17056848108768463,
0.37738895416259766,
-0.5941147804260254,
0.14142164587974548,
0.2319057434797287,
-0.16167324781417847,
-0.22171053290367126,
0.5097180008888245,
0.13719043135643005,
-0.20100873708724976,
0.37555059790611267,
0.043122485280036926,
-0.4401055872440338,
0.18847469985485077,
0.8197059035301208,
0.8428691029548645,
-0.1362544447183609,
-0.326712965965271,
0.3335822820663452,
0.029323875904083252,
-0.2821926474571228,
0.01318146288394928,
-0.5285573601722717,
-0.5926510095596313,
-0.7806793451309204,
-0.38655343651771545,
-0.13175871968269348,
0.2876133918762207,
-0.4032418727874756,
0.30008700489997864,
-0.2672519385814667,
-0.19994036853313446,
-0.31764906644821167,
-0.23682157695293427,
-0.5631300806999207,
0.3746087849140167,
-0.09387938678264618,
1.1286895275115967,
-0.5657637715339661,
1.0249942541122437,
0.23743270337581635,
-0.04605294018983841,
-0.6248250603675842,
0.3278529644012451,
-0.27250081300735474,
-0.2991667091846466,
0.6984306573867798,
0.40612974762916565,
-0.4399319589138031,
0.02999313734471798,
-0.6971699595451355,
-1.0833464860916138,
0.8907660245895386,
0.5101456642150879,
-0.8468128442764282,
-0.07485084980726242,
-0.22980956733226776,
0.5067220330238342,
-0.3642024099826813,
0.21729908883571625,
0.5045955181121826,
0.35748574137687683,
-0.03831944987177849,
-0.7087029814720154,
0.2723633050918579,
-0.15042303502559662,
0.07779692113399506,
0.41967150568962097,
-0.7290636301040649,
0.7741928100585938,
0.21126583218574524,
-0.37337785959243774,
0.0676654577255249,
0.8906450867652893,
-0.12688736617565155,
-0.13217699527740479,
0.712570309638977,
0.6260486841201782,
0.35465478897094727,
0.1596064567565918,
1.151003122329712,
-0.6036617755889893,
0.4351021647453308,
1.1398543119430542,
-0.15330132842063904,
0.9765602350234985,
1.0044243335723877,
0.008551499806344509,
0.3164532482624054,
0.46117785573005676,
0.5132991075515747,
0.6948150396347046,
0.159059539437294,
-0.37775808572769165,
-0.2165270894765854,
-0.2371663749217987,
-0.3095405101776123,
0.3825559914112091,
0.18851643800735474,
-0.32397887110710144,
-0.1327304244041443,
-0.045528046786785126,
0.2841934263706207,
-0.20504571497440338,
-0.19289319217205048,
0.4668734669685364,
0.16325601935386658,
-0.8320589065551758,
0.6445999145507812,
-0.05181039869785309,
0.9393371343612671,
-0.4454634189605713,
0.0352933444082737,
-0.2751971185207367,
0.031042566522955894,
0.06442490220069885,
-0.46279963850975037,
0.30526331067085266,
-0.02189095877110958,
-0.223969504237175,
-0.44451385736465454,
0.5763754844665527,
-0.5416225790977478,
-0.25791066884994507,
0.4640698730945587,
0.23643624782562256,
0.1377890259027481,
-0.2574908435344696,
-0.27303048968315125,
0.20200085639953613,
-0.1770063042640686,
-0.4032996892929077,
0.3134170472621918,
0.3528924584388733,
0.1218537911772728,
0.655669629573822,
0.4128331243991852,
0.11596500873565674,
-0.24791176617145538,
0.0524245947599411,
1.1077709197998047,
-0.7063779234886169,
-0.6544409990310669,
-0.8290819525718689,
0.4652189016342163,
-0.06829632818698883,
-0.20280133187770844,
0.5298461318016052,
0.5034605264663696,
0.76466965675354,
-0.013577880337834358,
0.530795156955719,
-0.06484463810920715,
0.29179084300994873,
-0.8666733503341675,
0.5015982985496521,
-0.8399611115455627,
0.12858371436595917,
-0.3845086693763733,
-1.0121986865997314,
-0.5424507856369019,
0.23844541609287262,
-0.10965409129858017,
-0.08472757786512375,
0.9662494659423828,
0.5750230550765991,
-0.23777414858341217,
-0.3504194915294647,
0.3933853209018707,
0.03681086003780365,
0.33391398191452026,
0.5858446955680847,
0.541258692741394,
-0.40790703892707825,
0.5567168593406677,
-0.45260775089263916,
-0.2680518627166748,
-0.47896963357925415,
-1.2499001026153564,
-0.8338994383811951,
-0.5282924175262451,
-0.23083797097206116,
-0.11208376288414001,
-0.3017590045928955,
0.9040110111236572,
1.0241718292236328,
-0.4206993877887726,
0.06853692978620529,
0.033596254885196686,
-0.18779310584068298,
-0.2050200253725052,
-0.22398506104946136,
0.39794009923934937,
-0.06286071985960007,
-0.7900815010070801,
0.7249661087989807,
0.48122093081474304,
0.044654250144958496,
-0.19295606017112732,
0.04637443274259567,
0.07154580950737,
0.01948719285428524,
0.9108352065086365,
0.01065964624285698,
-0.6618239283561707,
-0.5589333176612854,
-0.20444530248641968,
0.024556992575526237,
0.2440723329782486,
1.1926156282424927,
-1.0401166677474976,
0.29225048422813416,
0.6182893514633179,
0.5912849307060242,
0.7796010375022888,
-0.03734361752867699,
0.56805020570755,
-0.8325577974319458,
0.7105074524879456,
0.09324686229228973,
0.8516322374343872,
0.3940018117427826,
-0.6614100933074951,
0.39568495750427246,
0.2150869220495224,
-0.4844299852848053,
-0.7543291449546814,
0.24812844395637512,
-0.9288850426673889,
-0.39193254709243774,
1.1250807046890259,
-0.2100638896226883,
-0.4432666599750519,
0.06186670809984207,
-0.29230672121047974,
0.4278009831905365,
-0.5506748557090759,
0.7840869426727295,
0.5212304592132568,
-0.06426569074392319,
-0.3523062467575073,
-0.15336550772190094,
0.3663479685783386,
0.46548381447792053,
-0.859740674495697,
0.12575942277908325,
0.46717092394828796,
-0.016487402841448784,
0.041426148265600204,
0.5510228276252747,
-0.002219294896349311,
-0.04348105192184448,
-0.02248936891555786,
0.11476422846317291,
0.24682289361953735,
-0.5953062772750854,
-0.44248202443122864,
0.37600067257881165,
-0.19485850632190704,
0.1453903466463089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13617v1 | Optimizing Psychological Counseling with Instruction-Tuned Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T15:13:07 | 2024-06-19T15:13:07 | Wenjie Li, Tianyu Sun, Kun Qian, Wenhong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advent of large language models (LLMs) has significantly advanced various
fields, including natural language processing and automated dialogue systems.
This paper explores the application of LLMs in psychological counseling,
addressing the increasing demand for mental health services. We present a
method for instruction tuning LLMs with specialized prompts to enhance their
performance in providing empathetic, relevant, and supportive responses. Our
approach involves developing a comprehensive dataset of counseling-specific
prompts, refining them through feedback from professional counselors, and
conducting rigorous evaluations using both automatic metrics and human
assessments. The results demonstrate that our instruction-tuned model
outperforms several baseline LLMs, highlighting its potential as a scalable and
accessible tool for mental health support. | [
-0.3444424271583557,
-0.899370551109314,
0.9098629951477051,
0.4734486937522888,
-0.021137777715921402,
0.05983256176114082,
-0.6747874021530151,
-0.03281061351299286,
0.0021470398642122746,
0.46979212760925293,
-1.167871356010437,
-0.5837265849113464,
-0.5737360715866089,
0.23526382446289062,
0.18871936202049255,
0.9057957530021667,
0.01064840517938137,
0.5339679718017578,
-0.0981445163488388,
0.3370670676231384,
-0.7922088503837585,
-0.22959813475608826,
-1.0070617198944092,
-0.4614414572715759,
0.5288756489753723,
0.4606861174106598,
0.5141054391860962,
0.5807238221168518,
0.48364633321762085,
0.2644820213317871,
0.0045332638546824455,
0.4646550714969635,
-0.6030901670455933,
0.2612454891204834,
-0.049533404409885406,
-0.4958376884460449,
-0.6715229153633118,
0.03391703590750694,
0.5454772114753723,
0.821780800819397,
-0.5259175300598145,
0.26600465178489685,
0.040303174406290054,
0.4998217225074768,
-0.6380617618560791,
0.08365388959646225,
-0.43990206718444824,
0.16724911332130432,
0.1479012370109558,
-0.3649351894855499,
-0.6340487599372864,
-0.4535641074180603,
0.22491534054279327,
-0.5925821661949158,
0.11240492761135101,
0.08800183981657028,
0.30419501662254333,
0.4420340657234192,
-0.45079827308654785,
-0.2996586263179779,
-0.6420689225196838,
0.8333919644355774,
-0.5536929965019226,
0.4109582304954529,
0.6527752876281738,
0.3093734383583069,
-0.4963318705558777,
-0.4449421763420105,
0.14568936824798584,
-0.3497658371925354,
0.07012086361646652,
0.11268005520105362,
-0.29267075657844543,
0.3226993680000305,
0.5476173162460327,
0.3600509762763977,
-0.41108542680740356,
0.3879503011703491,
-0.03376201167702675,
-0.020160790532827377,
0.7100113034248352,
0.7339992523193359,
0.1861216127872467,
0.3549216687679291,
0.25965777039527893,
0.1481153964996338,
-0.40554022789001465,
0.04132736474275589,
0.14279012382030487,
0.331917941570282,
-0.09794536978006363,
0.6103638410568237,
0.04640985280275345,
0.8697718381881714,
0.5405850410461426,
-0.4948652386665344,
-0.42740941047668457,
0.28872811794281006,
-0.2613571584224701,
0.04992450028657913,
0.4650319516658783,
0.6849525570869446,
0.27051323652267456,
-0.26635703444480896,
-0.10522373765707016,
-0.009028211236000061,
0.4846830368041992,
-0.8112887144088745,
-0.17772087454795837,
0.05280149728059769,
-0.3256685137748718,
0.0835697203874588,
-0.4102882444858551,
-0.900234580039978,
-0.61583411693573,
-0.8327152132987976,
0.04273258149623871,
-0.5020334720611572,
0.16870620846748352,
0.355635404586792,
0.09557643532752991,
0.13532064855098724,
0.3072511851787567,
-1.0757267475128174,
0.29415327310562134,
0.7131091356277466,
0.882233738899231,
0.012582789175212383,
0.15339230000972748,
-0.7095553278923035,
0.215389221906662,
-0.4208877682685852,
0.6352815628051758,
-1.0189282894134521,
-0.5029163956642151,
0.2575068771839142,
0.07155536860227585,
0.14966610074043274,
-0.43424779176712036,
0.6375485062599182,
-0.20866021513938904,
0.2726394832134247,
-0.42982396483421326,
-0.8465140461921692,
0.2500665783882141,
0.24467380344867706,
-0.2787182629108429,
0.7482550144195557,
0.46942338347435,
-0.42616772651672363,
0.14367982745170593,
-0.6650876402854919,
-0.3394359052181244,
0.06088299676775932,
0.031686313450336456,
0.023904597386717796,
0.4591350555419922,
0.45898714661598206,
0.4245041310787201,
-0.6175564527511597,
0.035109397023916245,
-0.4372231364250183,
-0.5567379593849182,
0.4033186435699463,
-0.34756240248680115,
0.3659566342830658,
0.14720331132411957,
-0.057939313352108,
0.21639898419380188,
-0.7405253648757935,
0.22591471672058105,
-0.07094049453735352,
-0.5759879350662231,
-0.24579444527626038,
-0.1398877501487732,
-0.08928221464157104,
-0.15303394198417664,
0.21475426852703094,
-0.46866726875305176,
0.30893388390541077,
-0.5229610204696655,
0.27172812819480896,
0.8117440342903137,
0.1208624392747879,
0.3869782090187073,
-0.14256076514720917,
0.9335699081420898,
-0.43738752603530884,
0.11428605020046234,
-0.34550800919532776,
-0.266486793756485,
-0.4874337315559387,
-0.689180314540863,
-0.3284842371940613,
0.5301612615585327,
-0.3050612807273865,
0.7081976532936096,
0.2102769911289215,
-0.4786852300167084,
-0.7357243299484253,
0.24632906913757324,
0.20417168736457825,
0.4399171769618988,
0.2589264512062073,
0.12083200365304947,
-0.5832069516181946,
-0.7499323487281799,
-0.46584373712539673,
0.4546583294868469,
-0.19926758110523224,
0.2727581858634949,
-0.10047061741352081,
-0.34971415996551514,
0.8080891370773315,
-0.8901358842849731,
-0.000014436244782700669,
-0.11603491008281708,
0.03915843367576599,
0.27513253688812256,
0.11059205234050751,
0.4616021513938904,
0.060749225318431854,
-0.6736580729484558,
-0.1914258897304535,
-0.6199489831924438,
-0.5592676401138306,
-0.06227029114961624,
-0.35992470383644104,
-0.16083870828151703,
0.402390718460083,
-0.2950800955295563,
0.012531044892966747,
0.36770424246788025,
-0.5196160078048706,
0.529987633228302,
-0.44182243943214417,
-0.0723973959684372,
-0.8969609141349792,
-0.37238413095474243,
0.2599722743034363,
-0.2942888140678406,
-0.49928396940231323,
-0.12237001955509186,
-0.07372026145458221,
-0.23308603465557098,
0.01578076370060444,
0.32050415873527527,
-0.4343230724334717,
0.38841432332992554,
-0.6337012648582458,
0.10833805799484253,
-0.28040647506713867,
0.4426974356174469,
-0.2374710589647293,
0.7657638788223267,
0.7023816108703613,
-0.4254022240638733,
0.7070318460464478,
0.2181360423564911,
-0.1263675093650818,
1.0088474750518799,
-0.49814414978027344,
0.29770365357398987,
-0.27028876543045044,
0.48419323563575745,
-0.509676456451416,
-0.4332948327064514,
0.16237099468708038,
0.2884959876537323,
0.42155542969703674,
0.11198601871728897,
-0.27856960892677307,
-0.4120393395423889,
-0.146499365568161,
0.08525063097476959,
0.43118977546691895,
-0.4791516363620758,
0.4118432104587555,
0.2133447676897049,
-0.3782360553741455,
-0.24956372380256653,
-0.2592851221561432,
0.07581731677055359,
-0.3654538691043854,
-0.4106866717338562,
0.2528870105743408,
-0.23512491583824158,
-0.23872295022010803,
-0.27747195959091187,
0.076351597905159,
0.23676912486553192,
0.004161401651799679,
0.3807222545146942,
0.23891118168830872,
-0.2027255743741989,
0.43798890709877014,
0.3836446702480316,
-0.21657466888427734,
0.3731590211391449,
-0.4047671854496002,
0.6985294818878174,
-0.3229040205478668,
-0.37444645166397095,
-0.5210233926773071,
0.6679280400276184,
0.4341440796852112,
-0.18367896974086761,
0.9225355386734009,
0.797908365726471,
-0.4149440824985504,
-0.2799437940120697,
-0.6000280976295471,
-0.4191870093345642,
-0.5239992737770081,
0.5018281936645508,
-0.016750333830714226,
-1.1221851110458374,
0.08799181878566742,
-0.2408105432987213,
0.03146388381719589,
-0.22755122184753418,
0.7146934270858765,
-0.08771352469921112,
1.7299169301986694,
0.6253644824028015,
0.10287366807460785,
0.7550243139266968,
0.03298104554414749,
0.43175244331359863,
-0.8721445798873901,
-0.033853765577077866,
-0.21266105771064758,
-0.4182179570198059,
-0.4936465322971344,
-0.23980863392353058,
0.5229344964027405,
0.007174535188823938,
-0.7817903161048889,
-0.3016304671764374,
-0.5786213874816895,
0.4629911780357361,
0.27883538603782654,
0.5122029185295105,
0.08401423692703247,
0.0045118252746760845,
-0.10254669189453125,
-0.5934817790985107,
-0.35286685824394226,
-0.7126707434654236,
0.8944149017333984,
0.5429996252059937,
1.1107096672058105,
0.053517378866672516,
0.3918936848640442,
-0.016035690903663635,
0.6394932866096497,
-1.0229413509368896,
0.38012224435806274,
-0.16841399669647217,
-0.39630046486854553,
-0.24357998371124268,
-0.2904047966003418,
-0.8273536562919617,
0.011793890967965126,
-0.2512388229370117,
-1.1529784202575684,
-0.15529339015483856,
0.15030734241008759,
-0.42678302526474,
-0.16728036105632782,
-0.62111496925354,
0.5920081734657288,
-0.5445612668991089,
-0.13454881310462952,
-0.5395525097846985,
-0.2395080327987671,
0.32721883058547974,
-0.2972725033760071,
-0.023060496896505356,
-0.3987116813659668,
-0.1274670660495758,
0.5741199254989624,
-0.41164079308509827,
0.7839189767837524,
-0.18882691860198975,
-0.4772281050682068,
-0.12092037498950958,
-0.05257885530591011,
0.384336918592453,
0.21743254363536835,
-0.237572580575943,
-0.8441246747970581,
0.20421116054058075,
-0.32782870531082153,
-1.1514918804168701,
0.6417524218559265,
-0.8016980886459351,
-0.9029209017753601,
0.11845115572214127,
-0.9539901614189148,
-0.8869068026542664,
0.028253084048628807,
0.18605220317840576,
0.44145774841308594,
-0.27279967069625854,
-0.060447730123996735,
0.6865565180778503,
-0.4727557599544525,
0.05884262174367905,
0.8244401812553406,
-0.3931579291820526,
-0.47835955023765564,
0.6726092100143433,
-0.14033012092113495,
0.08336099982261658,
0.008990010246634483,
0.4214399755001068,
-0.36026081442832947,
0.03703383356332779,
0.001465673791244626,
0.5783584117889404,
-0.9440271258354187,
-0.22854502499103546,
-0.4648396372795105,
0.19930115342140198,
-0.5082066655158997,
-0.4997199475765228,
-0.24796044826507568,
0.08068329095840454,
-0.3333102762699127,
-0.2314189225435257,
0.7927874326705933,
0.6359702944755554,
0.05447092652320862,
0.7052561640739441,
-0.9861501455307007,
0.11347725242376328,
0.19604259729385376,
0.5082968473434448,
0.22843718528747559,
-0.6162527799606323,
-0.39160043001174927,
0.08376099914312363,
-0.47205471992492676,
-1.120285987854004,
0.320853054523468,
0.3439972996711731,
0.5842154622077942,
0.718721866607666,
0.08707329630851746,
0.9973793029785156,
-0.5134601593017578,
0.44721657037734985,
0.20073528587818146,
-0.9205178022384644,
0.8644428253173828,
-0.5326410531997681,
0.4692517817020416,
0.47242674231529236,
0.5001163482666016,
-0.6836550831794739,
-0.4168723225593567,
-0.1454342007637024,
-0.5623666644096375,
0.8685437440872192,
-0.4287106990814209,
0.48635926842689514,
-0.13992317020893097,
0.7369670867919922,
-0.16227248311042786,
0.028394389897584915,
-0.3506239652633667,
-0.08767245709896088,
0.19174030423164368,
-0.6403523683547974,
0.08474461734294891,
-0.17647773027420044,
-0.5558278560638428,
-0.44736653566360474,
0.660903811454773,
-0.2692427337169647,
0.41552823781967163,
-0.0669407919049263,
0.21253561973571777,
-0.5859702229499817,
0.34081941843032837,
0.4317782521247864,
0.49876895546913147,
-0.047276318073272705,
-0.12817153334617615,
0.4683992862701416,
-0.43595466017723083,
0.33035987615585327,
-0.08831922709941864,
0.27061527967453003,
-0.2705205976963043,
0.3743898868560791,
1.0749961137771606,
0.40985655784606934,
-0.8375603556632996,
0.1873658150434494,
-0.25234919786453247,
0.08516063541173935,
-0.09449173510074615,
0.417763888835907,
0.2195274829864502,
0.5263572931289673,
-0.014596350491046906,
-0.6003457307815552,
-0.07447873055934906,
-0.543444037437439,
-0.1412373185157776,
0.40623316168785095,
-0.5570917129516602,
-0.09113401919603348,
0.3288092017173767,
0.083647221326828,
-0.7351091504096985,
0.8240891695022583,
0.11595269292593002,
-0.20387251675128937,
0.23603776097297668,
1.1044175624847412,
0.7484286427497864,
-0.26879575848579407,
0.20890481770038605,
0.1631457507610321,
0.00567279476672411,
-0.22458262741565704,
0.4408247470855713,
0.06695728003978729,
-0.3505159318447113,
-0.475469172000885,
-0.7336484789848328,
-0.43627458810806274,
0.1768118143081665,
-1.1643040180206299,
0.3230206370353699,
-0.6725530624389648,
-0.5114401578903198,
-0.3054487109184265,
-0.035369329154491425,
-0.7767342329025269,
0.15859507024288177,
0.2729775607585907,
1.0031884908676147,
-0.7479128837585449,
0.4711116850376129,
0.99580317735672,
0.030166085809469223,
-1.0623619556427002,
-0.0428500697016716,
0.11358349025249481,
-0.7138973474502563,
0.23879306018352509,
0.19046971201896667,
-0.20463824272155762,
0.1362772136926651,
-0.5249192714691162,
-0.7271031141281128,
0.8793802261352539,
1.07111656665802,
-0.6903366446495056,
-0.18497824668884277,
0.11665813624858856,
0.8498573303222656,
-0.6440345644950867,
0.3415852189064026,
1.0601141452789307,
0.6079884171485901,
-0.16889965534210205,
-0.5768241286277771,
0.16290441155433655,
-0.12175969034433365,
0.10786586999893188,
0.026099026203155518,
-0.47699180245399475,
0.24545630812644958,
-0.05843891575932503,
0.06078358739614487,
0.1257363259792328,
0.4929487705230713,
0.40963608026504517,
-0.050903476774692535,
0.36948272585868835,
0.229460209608078,
1.179955005645752,
0.007788828108459711,
0.8963934779167175,
-0.4171406328678131,
0.19366276264190674,
1.131014108657837,
-0.2439815253019333,
0.5996525883674622,
0.33057036995887756,
-0.18101535737514496,
0.39184945821762085,
0.9246234893798828,
-0.2919410467147827,
0.26320382952690125,
0.2882905602455139,
-0.490802139043808,
-0.4788636267185211,
-0.5457579493522644,
-0.10165639966726303,
0.35141822695732117,
0.7444400191307068,
-0.5072438716888428,
-0.0838993638753891,
0.33424317836761475,
-0.033506862819194794,
0.26652127504348755,
-0.4318176805973053,
0.6140052080154419,
0.49789804220199585,
-0.8480427861213684,
0.4905983805656433,
0.18665838241577148,
0.28764283657073975,
-0.5346533060073853,
0.06763000786304474,
-0.1743004471063614,
0.3009658455848694,
-0.24864764511585236,
-0.49639907479286194,
0.1564590036869049,
0.4519882798194885,
-0.3249590992927551,
-0.35528165102005005,
0.4768295884132385,
-0.4241259694099426,
-0.7651329040527344,
0.4118199944496155,
0.3764752745628357,
-0.10208083689212799,
0.06087055802345276,
-0.522219181060791,
-0.15660139918327332,
-0.34264326095581055,
-0.22863836586475372,
0.43453335762023926,
0.5993636846542358,
0.06485714763402939,
0.6616412401199341,
0.4601784646511078,
0.2119985818862915,
0.007079047150909901,
0.5435577034950256,
0.7295162081718445,
-0.6314737796783447,
-0.49115094542503357,
-0.8655930757522583,
0.22428980469703674,
-0.006680804304778576,
-0.2960408329963684,
0.7631933689117432,
-0.003896163310855627,
0.2126418650150299,
0.008469837717711926,
0.5726501941680908,
0.4290923476219177,
0.45041102170944214,
-0.4737239480018616,
0.23973318934440613,
-0.4692055583000183,
0.37587684392929077,
-0.1291707456111908,
-0.9519580006599426,
-0.2693641781806946,
0.7289918065071106,
-0.6929132342338562,
0.07513590157032013,
0.5050472021102905,
0.9650900959968567,
0.11718249320983887,
0.23252138495445251,
0.25821131467819214,
0.009573882445693016,
0.46478232741355896,
0.5294104814529419,
1.114108920097351,
0.2838980555534363,
0.14279785752296448,
-0.05098498985171318,
-0.39691799879074097,
-0.08999840170145035,
-0.7219103574752808,
-1.0683389902114868,
-0.03282438963651657,
-0.1865118145942688,
-0.1280171275138855,
-0.015843717381358147,
1.4960654973983765,
0.49469947814941406,
-0.5413651466369629,
-0.20884332060813904,
0.13516542315483093,
-0.32614395022392273,
-0.09970025718212128,
-0.18358159065246582,
0.054399967193603516,
-0.7715507745742798,
-0.5625742077827454,
0.5491772294044495,
0.4384101331233978,
-0.1577230989933014,
-0.3934694528579712,
-0.0915873721241951,
0.26417404413223267,
0.3872164487838745,
0.503376305103302,
-0.1874246597290039,
-0.7746471166610718,
-0.25214821100234985,
0.18753567337989807,
-0.18301454186439514,
-0.01674775779247284,
1.1451523303985596,
-0.24520893394947052,
0.3824065327644348,
0.11122848838567734,
0.7192119359970093,
0.18643046915531158,
0.09450884163379669,
1.1390849351882935,
-0.7278090119361877,
-0.0476938858628273,
0.10005184262990952,
0.34282878041267395,
0.36423391103744507,
-0.83039391040802,
0.2726266384124756,
-0.2523193955421448,
-0.6199359893798828,
-0.7826484441757202,
0.2210334837436676,
-0.6221845149993896,
-0.2777121961116791,
1.0354036092758179,
-0.43036705255508423,
0.03926904872059822,
-0.03966725990176201,
-0.5832934975624084,
0.5447084307670593,
-0.39127451181411743,
0.9006133079528809,
0.8568399548530579,
-0.5359304547309875,
-0.4420321583747864,
-0.32325464487075806,
0.42495089769363403,
0.5582247376441956,
-0.7876051664352417,
0.1710774153470993,
0.5003393292427063,
0.2061297595500946,
-0.29120689630508423,
0.4030725955963135,
0.20028090476989746,
0.16144433617591858,
-0.3378256559371948,
-0.40101176500320435,
0.1730184108018875,
0.033049214631319046,
-0.6087563633918762,
-0.14236988127231598,
0.3118652403354645,
0.3930533230304718
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13578v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13578v1 | Enhancing Distractor Generation for Multiple-Choice Questions with Retrieval Augmented Pretraining and Knowledge Graph Integration | 2024-06-19T14:12:05 | 2024-06-19T14:12:05 | Han-Cheng Yu, Yu-An Shih, Kin-Man Law, Kai-Yu Hsieh, Yu-Chen Cheng, Hsin-Chih Ho, Zih-An Lin, Wen-Chuan Hsu, Yao-Chung Fan | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we tackle the task of distractor generation (DG) for
multiple-choice questions. Our study introduces two key designs. First, we
propose \textit{retrieval augmented pretraining}, which involves refining the
language model pretraining to align it more closely with the downstream task of
DG. Second, we explore the integration of knowledge graphs to enhance the
performance of DG. Through experiments with benchmarking datasets, we show that
our models significantly outperform the state-of-the-art results. Our
best-performing model advances the F1@3 score from 14.80 to 16.47 in MCQ
dataset and from 15.92 to 16.50 in Sciq dataset. | [
-0.7700570225715637,
-0.9732037782669067,
0.6894482374191284,
-0.11074025183916092,
-0.29337120056152344,
0.18295828998088837,
-0.03693460300564766,
-0.44013482332229614,
0.1224299743771553,
0.5996181964874268,
-0.5007477402687073,
-0.1203971579670906,
-0.681242823600769,
0.05422588437795639,
-0.15418170392513275,
0.8467294573783875,
-0.14500385522842407,
0.0584857352077961,
-0.25187036395072937,
0.06962805986404419,
-0.667115330696106,
-0.6046172380447388,
-0.6616779565811157,
-0.0990409404039383,
0.779716432094574,
0.3157975971698761,
0.4308490753173828,
0.37766847014427185,
0.34500667452812195,
0.26401591300964355,
0.06507503986358643,
0.4930455982685089,
-0.47156789898872375,
0.19727559387683868,
-0.07980750501155853,
-0.1807221919298172,
-0.2022763341665268,
0.12304148077964783,
0.6029866337776184,
0.6283354759216309,
0.15600380301475525,
-0.03281350061297417,
0.20316195487976074,
0.5544106960296631,
-0.9373106360435486,
-0.07629264891147614,
-0.4459906220436096,
-0.2108134925365448,
-0.17347782850265503,
-0.16101308166980743,
-0.4795464277267456,
-0.6242144703865051,
0.1935804784297943,
-0.6782742142677307,
-0.034654706716537476,
0.21313640475273132,
0.7466651201248169,
0.6710087060928345,
-0.7162871360778809,
-0.36351799964904785,
-0.5823801755905151,
0.7532129287719727,
-0.1970367431640625,
0.5064635276794434,
0.38471242785453796,
0.12511852383613586,
-0.04375837743282318,
-0.9459188580513,
-0.47207528352737427,
-0.33383551239967346,
-0.31182780861854553,
0.3292687237262726,
0.034511201083660126,
0.1057458445429802,
0.37093737721443176,
0.295232355594635,
-0.43305039405822754,
-0.14123718440532684,
-0.3966708183288574,
-0.15546941757202148,
0.7199088931083679,
0.033469174057245255,
0.0980873852968216,
-0.2063937932252884,
-0.4128185510635376,
0.013784411363303661,
-0.5140867829322815,
-0.30228787660598755,
0.5363910794258118,
0.26447996497154236,
0.7310446500778198,
0.4144989252090454,
-0.23404629528522491,
1.212217092514038,
0.36807480454444885,
0.0837322250008583,
0.3747999966144562,
-0.6273161768913269,
0.2202567160129547,
-0.09216606616973877,
0.8111018538475037,
0.10040345042943954,
0.3250682055950165,
0.08023396879434586,
0.07791252434253693,
-0.3206779360771179,
0.42822781205177307,
-0.8860323429107666,
-0.5492661595344543,
0.2288295179605484,
0.00040979537880048156,
-0.24306055903434753,
-0.10557544231414795,
-0.5874683260917664,
-0.17978209257125854,
-0.2848086953163147,
0.48324987292289734,
-0.7050532698631287,
-0.3822323977947235,
-0.01457584835588932,
-0.2603423595428467,
-0.15628206729888916,
0.25202593207359314,
-0.7010154128074646,
0.08905225247144699,
0.10557569563388824,
0.41386982798576355,
-0.34703949093818665,
-0.48465850949287415,
-0.5603125095367432,
0.12763158977031708,
-0.2853541374206543,
0.9924811124801636,
-0.6106511950492859,
-0.35813313722610474,
-0.21963900327682495,
-0.4516778886318207,
-0.6240885257720947,
-0.6253337264060974,
0.40610042214393616,
-0.8480840921401978,
0.6677802205085754,
-0.563862681388855,
-0.6496864557266235,
-0.3740590810775757,
0.34903910756111145,
-0.7902030348777771,
1.497069239616394,
0.42993229627609253,
-0.9522572755813599,
0.7444000244140625,
-0.911962628364563,
-0.3515878915786743,
0.2311004251241684,
-0.10086939483880997,
-0.06715023517608643,
-0.3614809811115265,
0.46471285820007324,
0.1021602600812912,
-0.012922879308462143,
0.3678639233112335,
-0.26765069365501404,
-0.3442291021347046,
0.18952855467796326,
-0.06303699314594269,
0.6346051692962646,
0.25651097297668457,
-0.02239714004099369,
0.062158942222595215,
-0.6915192604064941,
0.3657482862472534,
-0.11769818514585495,
-0.4386965334415436,
-0.4308356046676636,
0.06392764300107956,
-0.18793851137161255,
0.7460586428642273,
0.20720182359218597,
-0.4030472934246063,
-0.11371621489524841,
0.04011614993214607,
-0.026625191792845726,
0.5736262798309326,
0.2497699111700058,
0.22886690497398376,
-0.4360326826572418,
0.623195469379425,
0.18087081611156464,
0.013930176384747028,
0.19055335223674774,
-0.38980698585510254,
-0.6570523381233215,
-0.4864957928657532,
0.5152846574783325,
0.5636510848999023,
-1.037095308303833,
0.47635751962661743,
-0.02869446948170662,
-0.35526126623153687,
-0.40974971652030945,
0.06018291413784027,
0.3020409643650055,
0.8105337619781494,
0.6319568753242493,
0.0609268993139267,
-0.6260395646095276,
-0.4724239408969879,
-0.32352954149246216,
-0.009442449547350407,
-0.01040793489664793,
0.5391950011253357,
0.4592985510826111,
0.1533038467168808,
1.0220460891723633,
-0.9265300631523132,
-0.10089060664176941,
-0.2890491187572479,
-0.03867721185088158,
-0.09462574869394302,
0.5593509078025818,
0.6602352261543274,
-0.9375112652778625,
-0.7755711674690247,
-0.3783546984195709,
-0.5259206891059875,
-0.053012918680906296,
0.30362528562545776,
-0.46276190876960754,
-0.25003811717033386,
0.5483466386795044,
-0.40964773297309875,
0.1024426594376564,
0.04969504103064537,
-0.23377560079097748,
0.7211294174194336,
0.21899138391017914,
0.34966233372688293,
-1.1803576946258545,
0.27525246143341064,
-0.36412352323532104,
-0.14271116256713867,
-1.038841962814331,
-0.14457085728645325,
-0.012716026045382023,
0.027192456647753716,
-0.6601253151893616,
0.7517549991607666,
-0.2518387734889984,
0.3917814791202545,
-0.23342303931713104,
0.4893379807472229,
0.11453384906053543,
0.26856064796447754,
0.04579469934105873,
0.8327721357345581,
0.48389720916748047,
-0.9867632389068604,
0.1727237105369568,
0.481317937374115,
-0.3835112750530243,
0.46448203921318054,
-0.4871886968612671,
0.2837669849395752,
-0.2953173816204071,
0.03268379718065262,
-1.1643688678741455,
-0.39523616433143616,
0.359553724527359,
-0.2861357629299164,
0.27401620149612427,
0.05847417190670967,
-0.4354400336742401,
-0.6526032090187073,
-0.1406274437904358,
0.5241228938102722,
0.35300853848457336,
-0.6862931251525879,
0.5655822157859802,
0.22003795206546783,
-0.12401696294546127,
-0.8866379857063293,
-0.4178043305873871,
-0.5381122827529907,
-0.35839515924453735,
-0.5467156767845154,
0.4396265149116516,
-0.34619441628456116,
-0.0394522100687027,
-0.13528209924697876,
0.1559814214706421,
-0.054720189422369,
0.026360303163528442,
-0.15392854809761047,
0.2871403098106384,
0.004424162674695253,
0.43533915281295776,
-0.01346701942384243,
0.0006306448485702276,
-0.06332603096961975,
-0.27305367588996887,
0.7407266497612,
0.39640575647354126,
-0.3965642750263214,
-0.008249889127910137,
0.3286972939968109,
0.2296898066997528,
-0.4094529449939728,
0.5117648839950562,
0.6801548600196838,
-0.21892860531806946,
0.051143452525138855,
-0.840326189994812,
-0.15739843249320984,
-0.4988991618156433,
0.5310455560684204,
-0.6053900122642517,
-1.0960371494293213,
0.5347599983215332,
-0.2949144244194031,
-0.25586238503456116,
0.40976640582084656,
0.3442223072052002,
0.09472201019525528,
1.3556007146835327,
0.4507536292076111,
0.1832888126373291,
1.0284115076065063,
0.027715809643268585,
0.13400554656982422,
-0.9779452085494995,
-0.16940860450267792,
-0.23875947296619415,
-0.23003171384334564,
-0.3741661012172699,
-0.24098944664001465,
0.1767040491104126,
0.512968897819519,
-0.28520655632019043,
-0.015697121620178223,
-0.6315792202949524,
0.5542313456535339,
0.7476312518119812,
0.1731233149766922,
0.01691494695842266,
-0.1778348982334137,
-0.4421718418598175,
-0.013413162901997566,
-0.8682238459587097,
-0.26253873109817505,
1.2617019414901733,
-0.2040645182132721,
0.46351924538612366,
-0.02651425451040268,
1.0464047193527222,
-0.13917221128940582,
0.4105195999145508,
-0.48127251863479614,
0.5374577045440674,
0.010709963738918304,
-1.019618034362793,
-0.34232762455940247,
-0.5205581188201904,
-0.9022819399833679,
0.4571245610713959,
-0.013512978330254555,
-0.7954439520835876,
0.23464694619178772,
0.15454864501953125,
-0.7045950293540955,
-0.04084768891334534,
-0.8905851244926453,
0.8723703622817993,
-0.39257341623306274,
-0.4069801867008209,
0.1267232447862625,
-0.33214861154556274,
0.7030469179153442,
-0.22199507057666779,
-0.114772267639637,
-0.0451459102332592,
0.3469875454902649,
0.9066901206970215,
-0.18616695702075958,
0.3582156002521515,
-0.4132579267024994,
0.2592344880104065,
0.6925197243690491,
-0.30683162808418274,
0.32215818762779236,
-0.02816614881157875,
-0.3385980725288391,
-0.4570873975753784,
-0.12100160121917725,
-0.4633002281188965,
-0.6042333245277405,
0.5548471808433533,
-0.7205824851989746,
-0.6960709095001221,
-0.2121206670999527,
-0.9638471603393555,
-0.32939380407333374,
0.5526628494262695,
0.2793181836605072,
0.24414123594760895,
-0.2037496417760849,
-0.25348973274230957,
0.5844576358795166,
0.1003282442688942,
0.3654146194458008,
0.38310620188713074,
-0.4219857454299927,
-0.7133400440216064,
0.8407385349273682,
0.38482874631881714,
0.4821033775806427,
0.14728020131587982,
-0.021157866343855858,
-0.7348728179931641,
-0.4737880527973175,
-0.38658177852630615,
0.1698533594608307,
-0.8354686498641968,
-0.12545646727085114,
-0.9224928617477417,
-0.3896518647670746,
-0.4931403696537018,
0.07610256224870682,
-0.0634026974439621,
-0.2884039878845215,
-0.5797675848007202,
-0.30218490958213806,
0.2525949478149414,
0.8921650052070618,
-0.059734538197517395,
0.35275402665138245,
-0.5949345231056213,
0.18683482706546783,
0.6573473811149597,
0.3733561933040619,
-0.18558381497859955,
-0.3408656716346741,
-0.15989114344120026,
0.043463267385959625,
-0.5326714515686035,
-0.9644178152084351,
0.09240139275789261,
-0.032031815499067307,
0.8478024005889893,
0.43825528025627136,
0.21513527631759644,
0.9065333604812622,
-0.3094293177127838,
0.639316201210022,
-0.038433950394392014,
-0.7636311054229736,
0.6378874778747559,
-0.16270965337753296,
0.2672695517539978,
0.9463513493537903,
0.6045411825180054,
-0.03724154829978943,
-0.32652005553245544,
-0.6709535121917725,
-0.5838336944580078,
0.8409192562103271,
0.047139961272478104,
-0.18678031861782074,
-0.36542558670043945,
0.41892820596694946,
-0.1277768611907959,
0.19322241842746735,
-0.5814135074615479,
-0.16569198668003082,
-0.3048208951950073,
-0.1092204600572586,
-0.07665818929672241,
-0.43458041548728943,
-0.16183102130889893,
-0.2006223201751709,
0.5677252411842346,
-0.24717777967453003,
0.12198758125305176,
0.14654776453971863,
-0.24006867408752441,
0.12912370264530182,
0.1076226681470871,
0.5264858603477478,
0.7006500959396362,
-0.3532998263835907,
0.15000225603580475,
0.4376195967197418,
-0.4827139973640442,
0.13008058071136475,
0.5906079411506653,
-0.16533222794532776,
-0.12372143566608429,
0.009911103174090385,
0.7038351893424988,
-0.06749524176120758,
-0.37752845883369446,
0.2515987753868103,
0.043036967515945435,
-0.46980172395706177,
-0.09656692296266556,
0.3670598566532135,
-0.17643357813358307,
0.11819106340408325,
0.4927283525466919,
0.002777521964162588,
0.0696280300617218,
-0.0599704273045063,
0.44137680530548096,
0.39237213134765625,
-0.5211573839187622,
-0.01877656765282154,
0.7602112293243408,
0.04974460229277611,
-0.08846065402030945,
0.6634625792503357,
-0.48608776926994324,
-0.7930329442024231,
0.33921360969543457,
0.6306126117706299,
0.45433229207992554,
-0.47963833808898926,
0.1207587718963623,
0.7274361252784729,
0.09944494813680649,
0.03536549583077431,
0.7515729665756226,
-0.16260437667369843,
-0.8471936583518982,
-0.5968957543373108,
-0.38462331891059875,
-0.21808752417564392,
0.16096630692481995,
-0.5609459280967712,
0.28377631306648254,
-0.06265100091695786,
-0.3899402618408203,
-0.1507730931043625,
0.2773684561252594,
-0.6481351256370544,
0.4692079424858093,
0.04498143121600151,
0.6815451383590698,
-0.6886398196220398,
0.7124485373497009,
0.7752679586410522,
-0.6982927918434143,
-0.7939556241035461,
0.0385165736079216,
-0.4910638928413391,
-0.5416040420532227,
0.7966972589492798,
0.14604637026786804,
0.002838581334799528,
0.43852144479751587,
-0.38919901847839355,
-1.461133360862732,
1.1795415878295898,
0.20299871265888214,
-0.11079347133636475,
-0.04680347442626953,
0.19483831524848938,
0.23795543611049652,
-0.4078167974948883,
0.682745635509491,
0.719045102596283,
0.5581904649734497,
0.16854751110076904,
-0.5617576837539673,
0.18446102738380432,
-0.2219332903623581,
-0.15474028885364532,
0.25034791231155396,
-0.6877974271774292,
0.9913949966430664,
-0.21940310299396515,
-0.31424325704574585,
-0.29774823784828186,
0.47592371702194214,
0.6354693174362183,
0.011761464178562164,
0.5966513156890869,
0.4972500205039978,
1.0402626991271973,
-0.19393396377563477,
1.0250838994979858,
-0.5918115377426147,
0.12308145314455032,
1.2173800468444824,
-0.39092281460762024,
0.6535506248474121,
0.5750963687896729,
-0.020290274173021317,
0.4569246470928192,
0.7366958260536194,
0.27377983927726746,
0.6461473107337952,
0.27683529257774353,
-0.25188785791397095,
-0.47398126125335693,
-0.24940600991249084,
-0.4031861126422882,
0.3810235559940338,
0.36992838978767395,
-0.3260316550731659,
-0.07898310571908951,
0.14359204471111298,
-0.05469617247581482,
-0.15676066279411316,
-0.030984999611973763,
0.8034847974777222,
-0.22271116077899933,
-1.1347042322158813,
0.6483495831489563,
-0.5832648277282715,
0.42756980657577515,
-0.7341759204864502,
0.09085986763238907,
-0.11985360085964203,
0.26213324069976807,
-0.1356368362903595,
-0.5999389290809631,
0.10761003196239471,
-0.3860522508621216,
-0.169560045003891,
-0.23004893958568573,
0.9553676843643188,
-0.6900967955589294,
-0.3346598744392395,
0.3870989978313446,
0.8649918437004089,
0.0970243588089943,
-0.22019782662391663,
-0.623174250125885,
-0.2476610541343689,
0.07547438144683838,
-0.32597434520721436,
0.28693684935569763,
0.2307562381029129,
0.16712473332881927,
0.5414345264434814,
0.7046912908554077,
-0.25942209362983704,
0.43143603205680847,
0.24678093194961548,
1.1135001182556152,
-0.5369845628738403,
-0.48571255803108215,
-0.6635680794715881,
0.7544190287590027,
-0.33482974767684937,
-0.46193453669548035,
0.9472264647483826,
0.6725889444351196,
0.8566795587539673,
0.005590799730271101,
0.9455645680427551,
-0.24197423458099365,
0.7486568093299866,
-0.34742820262908936,
0.6908234357833862,
-0.3998091518878937,
-0.10960590839385986,
-0.37159252166748047,
-0.7472348213195801,
-0.31090837717056274,
0.3974188566207886,
-0.7497118711471558,
0.5064274668693542,
0.9734140038490295,
0.7663278579711914,
0.02458120696246624,
-0.12080573290586472,
0.33786725997924805,
-0.4222046434879303,
0.366574764251709,
0.586645245552063,
1.4228920936584473,
-0.5025889873504639,
0.8188015222549438,
-0.3187757134437561,
-0.04346638172864914,
-0.18405427038669586,
-0.5098119974136353,
-1.1666651964187622,
-0.5879047513008118,
-0.4273872971534729,
-0.22262264788150787,
-0.15981408953666687,
0.47931692004203796,
0.8280864357948303,
-0.7556463479995728,
0.1412268877029419,
-0.09380430728197098,
0.38781094551086426,
-0.19687221944332123,
-0.24899446964263916,
0.4366381764411926,
-0.7421659827232361,
-0.745972216129303,
0.35060393810272217,
-0.15254226326942444,
0.15097938477993011,
-0.027670251205563545,
-0.07479782402515411,
-0.8569797277450562,
0.017425503581762314,
0.5705773234367371,
-0.10732609033584595,
-0.4962139129638672,
-0.6182404160499573,
0.19027361273765564,
0.049293484538793564,
0.0013596171047538519,
0.8324785828590393,
-0.9889715909957886,
0.5473969578742981,
0.4382787346839905,
0.35765156149864197,
0.6445373296737671,
0.48294737935066223,
0.35490381717681885,
-1.0128251314163208,
-0.002421430079266429,
0.37864696979522705,
0.16579650342464447,
0.24410690367221832,
-0.3915524482727051,
0.3961174190044403,
-0.006786686833947897,
-0.6680015325546265,
-0.7649770975112915,
0.42065900564193726,
-0.32097890973091125,
-0.11795482784509659,
1.0691975355148315,
0.030812138691544533,
0.040869709104299545,
-0.4334343671798706,
-0.3724348843097687,
0.4258267283439636,
-0.06537830829620361,
0.6188995838165283,
0.9687724709510803,
-0.5568203330039978,
-0.15202009677886963,
-0.4421147108078003,
0.7984148859977722,
0.5723021626472473,
-0.8880668878555298,
-0.12941569089889526,
0.6341474056243896,
0.35586491227149963,
0.45648193359375,
0.937950611114502,
0.0764300599694252,
0.37513208389282227,
0.290052592754364,
0.055551767349243164,
-0.28635886311531067,
-0.3070017099380493,
0.008990582078695297,
0.34317511320114136,
0.12388824671506882,
-0.39574524760246277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13560v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13560v1 | Lexically Grounded Subword Segmentation | 2024-06-19T13:48:19 | 2024-06-19T13:48:19 | Jindřich Libovický, Jindřich Helcl | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present three innovations in tokenization and subword segmentation. First,
we propose to use unsupervised morphological analysis with Morfessor as
pre-tokenization. Second, we present an algebraic method for obtaining subword
embeddings grounded in a word embedding space. Based on that, we design a novel
subword segmentation algorithm that uses the embeddings, ensuring that the
procedure considers lexical meaning. Third, we introduce an efficient
segmentation algorithm based on a subword bigram model that can be initialized
with the lexically aware segmentation method to avoid using Morfessor and large
embedding tables at inference time. We evaluate the proposed approaches using
two intrinsic metrics and measure their performance on two downstream tasks:
part-of-speech tagging and machine translation. Our experiments show
significant improvements in the morphological plausibility of the segmentation
when evaluated using segmentation precision on morpheme boundaries and improved
R\'enyi efficiency in 8 languages. Although the proposed tokenization methods
do not have a large impact on automatic translation quality, we observe
consistent performance gains in the arguably more morphological task of
part-of-speech tagging. | [
-0.40760567784309387,
-0.887751579284668,
0.41727060079574585,
0.17733553051948547,
-0.8505090475082397,
0.3084873855113983,
-0.07844424992799759,
-0.3902249038219452,
0.4866262376308441,
0.010676308535039425,
-0.17467136681079865,
-0.6479556560516357,
-0.6326857805252075,
-0.11878521740436554,
-0.33489513397216797,
0.541050910949707,
0.17316068708896637,
0.3584485650062561,
-0.3281581401824951,
-0.241856649518013,
-0.5271178483963013,
-0.9337327480316162,
-0.3555460572242737,
-0.3976491093635559,
0.3427649140357971,
0.03470908850431442,
0.7916093468666077,
1.1204915046691895,
0.3853320777416229,
0.22789108753204346,
-0.5110703706741333,
0.1148337572813034,
0.05288272723555565,
-0.012380959466099739,
-0.42479753494262695,
-0.5129753947257996,
-0.3282229006290436,
-0.18448637425899506,
0.6419826745986938,
0.8204296231269836,
-0.028902459889650345,
-0.024572566151618958,
-0.4400413930416107,
0.48988544940948486,
-0.6614351868629456,
0.06216792017221451,
-0.7917485237121582,
0.4028257131576538,
-0.5147520303726196,
-0.06644799560308456,
-0.10231665521860123,
-0.09519943594932556,
-0.06970290839672089,
-0.30791985988616943,
0.058806490153074265,
0.015052254311740398,
0.885308027267456,
0.2949444353580475,
0.07165481150150299,
-0.38971367478370667,
-0.052529476583004,
0.8549872040748596,
-0.5198726058006287,
0.9003250598907471,
0.2625653147697449,
-0.1458367109298706,
-0.10900875926017761,
-0.8735177516937256,
-0.15712854266166687,
-0.23479551076889038,
-0.036730729043483734,
0.09262877702713013,
-0.3146759569644928,
0.1349143087863922,
0.07108082622289658,
0.5619409084320068,
-0.11314907670021057,
0.31110501289367676,
-0.10448578000068665,
-0.5040493607521057,
0.23038969933986664,
-0.04609191417694092,
0.5548300743103027,
-0.23051096498966217,
-0.29618319869041443,
0.19300568103790283,
-0.7398937940597534,
-0.23173633217811584,
0.16230447590351105,
0.18393242359161377,
0.238016277551651,
0.8589175343513489,
0.18867836892604828,
0.2745862603187561,
-0.1332985907793045,
-0.3540104925632477,
0.27842268347740173,
-0.6133410930633545,
-0.06315465271472931,
0.18441715836524963,
0.3991536796092987,
0.14036525785923004,
0.43653589487075806,
-0.31019335985183716,
-0.3467312753200531,
0.3129890561103821,
-0.03272522985935211,
-0.6141564846038818,
-0.17666327953338623,
-0.026410207152366638,
-0.5000472664833069,
0.13898074626922607,
-0.021485550329089165,
-0.5983437299728394,
-0.32543566823005676,
-0.32671037316322327,
0.23026461899280548,
-0.7310816645622253,
-0.24463438987731934,
0.051838863641023636,
-0.2947198748588562,
0.33115291595458984,
0.10078922659158707,
-0.9173898696899414,
0.38784462213516235,
0.9408919215202332,
1.1606494188308716,
-0.23426266014575958,
0.10980898886919022,
-0.2477659285068512,
0.02128002978861332,
-0.5590026378631592,
0.7231432199478149,
-0.5143316984176636,
-0.5187370181083679,
-0.08140500634908676,
-0.2090911716222763,
-0.13655073940753937,
-0.6237619519233704,
0.22232064604759216,
-0.6049418449401855,
-0.3680747151374817,
-0.07041115313768387,
-0.6354202628135681,
-0.11573139578104019,
0.42669570446014404,
-0.28887444734573364,
1.0729949474334717,
-0.08120317757129669,
-0.7414941787719727,
0.5726803541183472,
-0.6465579867362976,
-0.5952616333961487,
0.1278364211320877,
-0.18293939530849457,
-0.0715695321559906,
0.5605964660644531,
0.6076045036315918,
0.2299439013004303,
-0.12206334620714188,
0.034492284059524536,
0.22877410054206848,
0.051959577947854996,
0.09592550992965698,
-0.15688131749629974,
0.35074806213378906,
0.1385561227798462,
-0.20609527826309204,
0.25440141558647156,
-0.49739378690719604,
0.23246341943740845,
0.09549636393785477,
-0.04559364169836044,
-0.6934818029403687,
0.16747291386127472,
0.06103761866688728,
-0.1168970912694931,
0.42207232117652893,
-0.8082268238067627,
-0.039092883467674255,
-0.6713134050369263,
0.7019544243812561,
0.5100773572921753,
-0.026213591918349266,
0.5190115571022034,
0.2978098690509796,
0.5536444187164307,
0.24982266128063202,
-0.05452819541096687,
-0.4214074909687042,
-0.2765750288963318,
-0.8693981170654297,
-0.7464730143547058,
1.0009353160858154,
0.3789030909538269,
-0.504859209060669,
0.5739896893501282,
-0.21252554655075073,
-0.6175343990325928,
-0.2179630994796753,
-0.34869933128356934,
0.49605152010917664,
0.24120616912841797,
0.5536506175994873,
-0.38538017868995667,
-0.5321195721626282,
-0.9472390413284302,
-0.2575463652610779,
-0.1690242439508438,
0.32620754837989807,
0.04448149725794792,
0.531033456325531,
-0.45979490876197815,
1.2315127849578857,
-0.6155135035514832,
-0.35991355776786804,
-0.29271167516708374,
0.10107159614562988,
0.032691217958927155,
0.752470850944519,
0.5186785459518433,
-0.7124314904212952,
-0.1519608199596405,
0.20483186841011047,
-0.29277846217155457,
-0.22848574817180634,
0.29646772146224976,
0.0063819894567132,
0.11297556757926941,
0.9331555366516113,
-0.514399528503418,
0.5713369250297546,
0.19775083661079407,
-0.10134535282850266,
0.08085895329713821,
-0.18971389532089233,
-0.31378450989723206,
-0.9670175909996033,
-0.2074003666639328,
-0.22258694469928741,
-0.2663247585296631,
-0.36756280064582825,
0.2032555192708969,
-0.05743055045604706,
0.0022745169699192047,
-0.49908778071403503,
0.5806342363357544,
-0.6021747589111328,
-0.3931569457054138,
-0.26282984018325806,
0.04960785061120987,
-0.2865261435508728,
0.20909450948238373,
0.1640760451555252,
0.8545020222663879,
0.5221325159072876,
-0.41983193159103394,
-0.03774271160364151,
0.08544663339853287,
-0.26828211545944214,
0.07993754744529724,
-0.926672637462616,
0.17635595798492432,
-0.24113167822360992,
0.15166708827018738,
-1.1053733825683594,
-0.01148144993931055,
0.39840829372406006,
-0.42374032735824585,
0.13576816022396088,
-0.3045143783092499,
-0.5308741927146912,
0.30763572454452515,
-0.06420011818408966,
0.7908782362937927,
0.5593363642692566,
-0.405931681394577,
0.5114277005195618,
0.8645278811454773,
-0.08250965923070908,
-0.04693152382969856,
-0.7294192314147949,
0.14312134683132172,
-0.2398369163274765,
-0.5097118616104126,
0.7649452090263367,
0.5464157462120056,
-0.3168790638446808,
0.08316832780838013,
-0.2691507935523987,
-0.07551401853561401,
0.012003638781607151,
0.14973345398902893,
-0.12254803627729416,
-0.18454138934612274,
0.14957274496555328,
0.16582971811294556,
-0.4522368013858795,
-0.1445847451686859,
-0.605036735534668,
0.9328870177268982,
-0.09773960709571838,
-0.4473487138748169,
-0.15864095091819763,
0.44681650400161743,
0.5967007279396057,
-0.7698575854301453,
0.601860523223877,
0.5617326498031616,
-0.7586635947227478,
0.09955792874097824,
-0.5989533066749573,
0.1467275619506836,
-0.34521129727363586,
0.4694800078868866,
-0.504707396030426,
-0.8832322359085083,
0.535698652267456,
-0.28346312046051025,
0.1274004429578781,
0.48977115750312805,
0.5816372036933899,
0.34215548634529114,
1.3462941646575928,
0.6019021272659302,
0.18990936875343323,
0.5815551280975342,
-0.06155342981219292,
0.38534021377563477,
-0.8290711641311646,
-0.3349995017051697,
-0.5817567110061646,
-0.1874087154865265,
-0.5050413012504578,
-0.7111246585845947,
0.353748083114624,
0.20646272599697113,
0.396539568901062,
0.22397008538246155,
-0.3692382276058197,
0.4707935154438019,
0.3798723518848419,
-0.3670015037059784,
-0.04818293824791908,
0.18249782919883728,
-0.7391899228096008,
-0.30289462208747864,
-0.6713099479675293,
-0.504795253276825,
0.2719038724899292,
0.7058931589126587,
0.816413402557373,
-0.22374846041202545,
0.639069139957428,
0.3226594030857086,
0.15398302674293518,
-1.5504088401794434,
0.4166967570781708,
-0.1620953530073166,
-0.3989349901676178,
-0.1692669838666916,
-0.15865741670131683,
-0.7793745398521423,
0.7093519568443298,
0.07991690188646317,
-0.582439124584198,
0.20649033784866333,
-0.01110332366079092,
-0.2891790270805359,
-0.01110389269888401,
-0.7013436555862427,
0.5898669958114624,
-0.19431279599666595,
0.0470048263669014,
-0.2835780084133148,
-0.3991374969482422,
-0.28301385045051575,
-0.1536879539489746,
0.3455921411514282,
-0.3205149173736572,
-0.35023170709609985,
1.1426705121994019,
-0.5927010178565979,
0.5138220191001892,
-0.35475513339042664,
-0.021278169006109238,
0.29913225769996643,
-0.11958549171686172,
0.009042427875101566,
0.165208101272583,
0.09705949574708939,
0.5995102524757385,
0.3527289032936096,
-0.24924907088279724,
-0.4862547516822815,
0.33480513095855713,
-0.46831274032592773,
-0.47880125045776367,
-0.6400563716888428,
-0.2071845531463623,
-0.39871370792388916,
0.3983030319213867,
0.34416306018829346,
0.5967298746109009,
-0.21133746206760406,
0.294624924659729,
0.3417496979236603,
-0.06098727136850357,
0.5275980830192566,
0.03856680542230606,
-0.2202601283788681,
-0.8094058036804199,
0.5674651265144348,
0.3272281885147095,
-0.23786889016628265,
0.5083835124969482,
0.5931503176689148,
-0.7087430953979492,
-0.8376663327217102,
-0.36046528816223145,
0.2614409625530243,
-0.7111515402793884,
-0.16695617139339447,
-0.7134912014007568,
-0.12979723513126373,
-0.39020445942878723,
-0.2211311012506485,
-0.6678307056427002,
-0.45689657330513,
-0.16655948758125305,
-0.11410012096166611,
0.030860045924782753,
0.46310335397720337,
-0.18043531477451324,
0.386813223361969,
-0.9231192469596863,
0.09614523500204086,
-0.06209034472703934,
-0.15632782876491547,
-0.09805358946323395,
-0.4212498962879181,
-0.2742050886154175,
0.06789711117744446,
0.04959423467516899,
-0.6072049736976624,
0.2240663766860962,
0.08202369511127472,
0.6824808120727539,
0.44027698040008545,
-0.30453649163246155,
1.1210135221481323,
-0.9119362831115723,
0.8967366218566895,
0.36173105239868164,
-1.3565878868103027,
0.45727410912513733,
-0.05275135114789009,
0.1920887976884842,
0.4946398138999939,
0.10358251631259918,
-0.4957275390625,
-0.026954123750329018,
-0.3605712056159973,
-1.1250951290130615,
0.42145779728889465,
0.1018090695142746,
0.4388817846775055,
-0.6122121214866638,
0.3554336428642273,
0.07419204711914062,
0.047179292887449265,
-0.3876482844352722,
0.04409698769450188,
-0.19947470724582672,
-0.03672271966934204,
0.04887549579143524,
-0.5092173218727112,
0.07443772256374359,
-0.42628005146980286,
0.46603426337242126,
-0.05741354078054428,
0.2001412957906723,
0.37729763984680176,
-0.48234543204307556,
0.41472887992858887,
0.2387542575597763,
0.6198623180389404,
0.9519627690315247,
0.23888324201107025,
0.4798815846443176,
0.17247255146503448,
-0.715623140335083,
0.35974109172821045,
-0.23213382065296173,
-0.035621047019958496,
0.25455135107040405,
0.5382299423217773,
0.41330698132514954,
0.2488507181406021,
-0.5635886788368225,
0.3558923900127411,
0.07641949504613876,
-0.16188041865825653,
-0.3107631504535675,
-0.24741458892822266,
0.0659608319401741,
0.04066212847828865,
0.2479085922241211,
-0.18395082652568817,
-0.19327807426452637,
-0.4589732587337494,
0.18126168847084045,
0.5467306971549988,
-0.6637008786201477,
-0.4122849404811859,
0.27135393023490906,
0.0773908793926239,
-0.37864771485328674,
0.43704816699028015,
0.06654241681098938,
-0.8569557666778564,
0.5076485276222229,
0.866800844669342,
0.9149540066719055,
-0.015557271428406239,
-0.03838806971907616,
0.08011486381292343,
0.34308621287345886,
0.1155535876750946,
0.14505067467689514,
-0.2082798182964325,
-0.7688754200935364,
-0.2219841033220291,
-0.8754004240036011,
-0.10039926320314407,
-0.2689998745918274,
-0.4997239410877228,
-0.0005262594786472619,
-0.6451258063316345,
-0.4292224049568176,
0.13176755607128143,
-0.3837240934371948,
-0.2319633960723877,
0.32586702704429626,
0.03501933813095093,
1.0734373331069946,
-0.5067884922027588,
0.47034212946891785,
1.2362751960754395,
-0.004864045884460211,
-0.5161316394805908,
0.16661003232002258,
-0.4297042787075043,
-0.89002925157547,
0.7259427309036255,
0.26560351252555847,
-0.3168467581272125,
0.16905616223812103,
-0.20535427331924438,
-1.025333046913147,
0.7622997164726257,
0.09015873819589615,
-0.2844981551170349,
0.07067807018756866,
0.15707585215568542,
0.49838581681251526,
-0.3095182478427887,
-0.01878066547214985,
0.6009317636489868,
0.3503609597682953,
0.3104854226112366,
-0.5706321001052856,
-0.12644335627555847,
-0.03876958787441254,
0.25529640913009644,
0.566807746887207,
-0.35375654697418213,
0.7735590934753418,
0.27848005294799805,
-0.47931158542633057,
0.09000817686319351,
1.019610047340393,
0.01700783148407936,
0.10454078763723373,
0.8005144000053406,
0.7646384835243225,
0.6107876300811768,
-0.21869346499443054,
0.5671951770782471,
-0.33308836817741394,
0.28142181038856506,
0.479809045791626,
-0.04176652804017067,
0.5066271424293518,
0.8356733918190002,
-0.09536012262105942,
0.17433196306228638,
0.6552952527999878,
0.2143460512161255,
0.7216699123382568,
0.47050338983535767,
-0.16163291037082672,
-0.40242165327072144,
-0.6463589668273926,
-0.47434887290000916,
0.9032805562019348,
0.6229210495948792,
-0.395353227853775,
-0.5719655156135559,
0.0739329606294632,
0.29653361439704895,
-0.0034840439911931753,
-0.4341984689235687,
0.7025408744812012,
0.1508428305387497,
-0.6761311888694763,
0.3154480457305908,
0.7939855456352234,
0.6216070652008057,
-0.5740921497344971,
-0.0910877212882042,
-0.23876428604125977,
0.12548865377902985,
-0.1914253532886505,
-0.29455801844596863,
0.43816474080085754,
0.09500337392091751,
0.1864302009344101,
-0.26088947057724,
0.8515704870223999,
-0.06145753338932991,
-0.4013156294822693,
0.06443192064762115,
0.7445583939552307,
0.10934102535247803,
0.016023902222514153,
-0.4736788272857666,
0.14257577061653137,
-0.2976858913898468,
0.08369791507720947,
0.21421420574188232,
0.4777955412864685,
-0.3844953775405884,
0.22262734174728394,
0.7198554873466492,
-0.06919164210557938,
0.36212384700775146,
0.22187314927577972,
0.9255101084709167,
-0.5986215472221375,
-0.8021590113639832,
-1.2168217897415161,
0.22365035116672516,
0.12138034403324127,
-0.44229239225387573,
0.7320202589035034,
0.6405256390571594,
0.5765067934989929,
0.029618700966238976,
0.4087368845939636,
-0.18763193488121033,
0.2252604365348816,
-0.7977508902549744,
0.4116489887237549,
-0.5559337139129639,
-0.23654833436012268,
-0.2811774015426636,
-1.0115694999694824,
-0.5759493112564087,
0.8832966685295105,
-0.2917109429836273,
-0.12783978879451752,
0.7915223240852356,
0.6381179094314575,
-0.23486822843551636,
-0.23192040622234344,
0.3802061080932617,
-0.391049861907959,
0.3888115882873535,
-0.10546693950891495,
1.153875470161438,
-0.09319525957107544,
-0.09931308031082153,
-0.07082044333219528,
-0.3584079444408417,
0.03180984780192375,
-0.8117801547050476,
-0.937042772769928,
-0.3403477668762207,
-0.28758522868156433,
-0.03700774163007736,
-0.014352332800626755,
1.111629605293274,
0.7494795322418213,
-0.6356325149536133,
0.12635962665081024,
-0.39790967106819153,
0.13374079763889313,
0.053462740033864975,
-0.2135828286409378,
0.4560879170894623,
-0.5411701798439026,
-0.7580435872077942,
0.5517909526824951,
0.5578665137290955,
-0.05385548993945122,
-0.18402718007564545,
0.31900423765182495,
-0.3076516389846802,
0.29338863492012024,
0.7015546560287476,
0.003864845959469676,
-0.828599214553833,
-0.4813537895679474,
0.09341151267290115,
0.04217980429530144,
0.06512708961963654,
0.9745973348617554,
-0.591896116733551,
0.1468341052532196,
0.6266524195671082,
0.9172361493110657,
0.22386611998081207,
0.4051966369152069,
0.21009697020053864,
-0.800801157951355,
0.34009847044944763,
0.3946661353111267,
0.5393766760826111,
0.2813807725906372,
-0.10820876806974411,
0.516923189163208,
0.4490138292312622,
-0.02624417096376419,
-0.7188601493835449,
0.3647915720939636,
-0.5983011722564697,
-0.1715635359287262,
1.1223530769348145,
-0.2594422399997711,
-0.27755361795425415,
-0.1915077418088913,
-0.3640613555908203,
0.29235750436782837,
0.017904067412018776,
0.18501156568527222,
0.8871191143989563,
-0.09837300330400467,
0.005082246847450733,
0.08290871977806091,
0.20581801235675812,
0.6763595342636108,
-0.6877713799476624,
-0.18847763538360596,
0.39582347869873047,
0.1705714911222458,
0.5953014492988586,
0.6501443982124329,
-0.6420213580131531,
-0.015169618651270866,
0.1641792207956314,
-0.12552309036254883,
-0.163512721657753,
-0.44294631481170654,
-0.17424173653125763,
0.3475129306316376,
0.061461105942726135,
-0.6542494893074036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13556v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13556v1 | Evaluating Short-Term Temporal Fluctuations of Social Biases in Social Media Data and Masked Language Models | 2024-06-19T13:45:21 | 2024-06-19T13:45:21 | Yi Zhou, Danushka Bollegala, Jose Camacho-Collados | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social biases such as gender or racial biases have been reported in language
models (LMs), including Masked Language Models (MLMs). Given that MLMs are
continuously trained with increasing amounts of additional data collected over
time, an important yet unanswered question is how the social biases encoded
with MLMs vary over time. In particular, the number of social media users
continues to grow at an exponential rate, and it is a valid concern for the
MLMs trained specifically on social media data whether their social biases (if
any) would also amplify over time. To empirically analyse this problem, we use
a series of MLMs pretrained on chronologically ordered temporal snapshots of
corpora. Our analysis reveals that, although social biases are present in all
MLMs, most types of social bias remain relatively stable over time (with a few
exceptions). To further understand the mechanisms that influence social biases
in MLMs, we analyse the temporal corpora used to train the MLMs. Our findings
show that some demographic groups, such as male, obtain higher preference over
the other, such as female on the training corpora constantly. | [
-0.24321676790714264,
-0.9584486484527588,
0.5369446277618408,
0.5567530393600464,
-0.13923446834087372,
0.45767688751220703,
-0.36992159485816956,
-0.47148266434669495,
0.6158565878868103,
0.2861107587814331,
-0.7667827606201172,
-0.43779271841049194,
-0.9736562371253967,
0.03316132724285126,
-0.44329705834388733,
0.9602019786834717,
0.09394911676645279,
0.22674816846847534,
0.175954207777977,
-0.3029116988182068,
-0.248235285282135,
-0.7453278303146362,
-0.6403167247772217,
-0.11996413767337799,
0.6882998943328857,
0.15259532630443573,
0.8722886443138123,
0.4892699420452118,
0.1791984736919403,
0.19503779709339142,
-0.2551330626010895,
-0.040712542831897736,
-0.8411174416542053,
-0.03628779947757721,
-0.18787214159965515,
-0.33881676197052,
-0.2532419264316559,
0.08373008668422699,
0.785165548324585,
1.0118025541305542,
0.1757005900144577,
0.49552270770072937,
0.06731419265270233,
0.7759362459182739,
-0.5931715369224548,
-0.003938994836062193,
-0.8034302592277527,
0.04109477996826172,
-0.36051487922668457,
-0.5132917761802673,
-0.24107985198497772,
-0.5453538298606873,
0.21936197578907013,
-0.24908004701137543,
0.5740823149681091,
-0.020271770656108856,
0.7608838677406311,
-0.2661757171154022,
-0.434467613697052,
-0.15805278718471527,
-0.9456533789634705,
0.8216173052787781,
-0.22774602472782135,
0.5622220635414124,
0.5237797498703003,
0.36566391587257385,
-0.09715957194566727,
-0.544580340385437,
-0.24874535202980042,
-0.32806095480918884,
0.09198004007339478,
-0.30009928345680237,
0.029851924628019333,
-0.2753172814846039,
0.46309638023376465,
-0.07328064739704132,
-0.19526435434818268,
-0.0003250144945923239,
-0.6094188690185547,
-0.11718825995922089,
0.7356739640235901,
0.17595772445201874,
0.5156314969062805,
-0.16010840237140656,
-0.12198074162006378,
0.16130028665065765,
-0.6590986847877502,
0.04817681759595871,
0.8667010068893433,
0.1996585875749588,
-0.18395370244979858,
0.6834098100662231,
-0.06693357229232788,
0.18632692098617554,
0.19946515560150146,
0.016885217279195786,
0.17924346029758453,
-0.18977420032024384,
0.06722137331962585,
0.1369798630475998,
0.7784081101417542,
0.6273109912872314,
0.5956428647041321,
-0.14432355761528015,
0.009504585526883602,
0.2612781226634979,
0.07373515516519547,
-0.7855961322784424,
0.19205449521541595,
-0.03746992349624634,
-0.5588659644126892,
-0.5018532872200012,
-0.007379699498414993,
-0.8275553584098816,
-0.6157724261283875,
-0.12543915212154388,
0.014376618899405003,
0.013849359005689621,
-0.377800315618515,
0.005204671993851662,
-0.37961509823799133,
-0.17889079451560974,
0.0396384634077549,
-0.9594690203666687,
0.3673693835735321,
0.5077767968177795,
1.0661300420761108,
-0.2957081198692322,
-0.1454356610774994,
-0.5252271890640259,
-0.1176728829741478,
-0.5700343251228333,
0.3347564935684204,
-0.6872377991676331,
-0.43183833360671997,
0.4418567717075348,
0.3993917405605316,
-0.17046648263931274,
-0.43527209758758545,
0.15286463499069214,
-0.7223543524742126,
-0.0038904997054487467,
-0.4420023560523987,
-0.41485366225242615,
0.6201702952384949,
-0.1489640325307846,
-0.5511390566825867,
1.0764631032943726,
0.10409765690565109,
-0.897163450717926,
0.7930567264556885,
-0.4648538827896118,
-0.13512396812438965,
-0.10216300934553146,
-0.42228490114212036,
-0.4376208782196045,
-0.09163189679384232,
0.2354934960603714,
0.5835041999816895,
0.12645651400089264,
0.3628607392311096,
-0.9437849521636963,
-0.5371699333190918,
0.6074029207229614,
-0.2565583288669586,
0.9664298295974731,
0.02573239617049694,
-0.6115121245384216,
-0.18365739285945892,
-0.6625449657440186,
-0.6691281795501709,
0.18376360833644867,
-0.11446239054203033,
-0.5415558815002441,
0.3103572130203247,
-0.0023090748582035303,
0.2563300132751465,
0.005290279630571604,
-0.5688834190368652,
-0.136495903134346,
0.015330703929066658,
0.713236391544342,
1.0305888652801514,
0.3590192198753357,
0.6637313365936279,
-0.2608221769332886,
0.4439423680305481,
0.2370477020740509,
0.29794594645500183,
0.09970881044864655,
-0.3691368103027344,
-0.6929040551185608,
0.14335501194000244,
0.07035063207149506,
0.22479082643985748,
-0.6997480392456055,
0.05129357799887657,
-0.4682033360004425,
-0.18526135385036469,
-0.4222472012042999,
0.34969624876976013,
-0.08028139919042587,
-0.1254425048828125,
0.07414837926626205,
-0.17917004227638245,
-0.4416075050830841,
-1.0175416469573975,
-0.45243945717811584,
-0.1697198450565338,
-0.16694292426109314,
0.3900246024131775,
0.4697650969028473,
-0.647924542427063,
0.9644845724105835,
-0.4422897398471832,
0.10064826905727386,
0.05019286647439003,
0.30760088562965393,
-0.20538750290870667,
0.17062616348266602,
0.7129866480827332,
-0.5925121307373047,
-0.3228006064891815,
-0.20468968152999878,
-0.35999295115470886,
-0.3444553315639496,
-0.17028699815273285,
-0.17752154171466827,
0.4193446636199951,
0.8431519865989685,
-0.38246244192123413,
0.4082641303539276,
0.5946775674819946,
-0.3156895935535431,
0.6545106768608093,
0.3395431935787201,
0.12836244702339172,
-0.7609910368919373,
-0.22455908358097076,
0.29254308342933655,
-0.26322850584983826,
-0.5859596133232117,
-0.674267590045929,
0.05970799922943115,
0.06727284938097,
-0.47477683424949646,
0.7045199871063232,
-0.652167022228241,
-0.23743686079978943,
-0.09033115208148956,
0.258101224899292,
-0.37383127212524414,
0.5218779444694519,
0.04587306082248688,
0.349636435508728,
0.3722520172595978,
-0.5300197601318359,
-0.19862014055252075,
-0.4629352390766144,
-0.5293818116188049,
0.23305627703666687,
-0.6339260935783386,
0.5101410150527954,
-0.4103853404521942,
0.02866101637482643,
-0.8508483171463013,
-0.21121437847614288,
0.1292303204536438,
-0.4782085716724396,
0.09127341210842133,
-0.3839603066444397,
-0.3686371445655823,
-0.31265679001808167,
-0.37563231587409973,
0.1808449774980545,
0.2566642463207245,
-0.31263503432273865,
0.4553455114364624,
0.654948353767395,
-0.21772682666778564,
-0.7269516587257385,
-0.3816256523132324,
-0.09653491526842117,
-0.27185553312301636,
-0.5764501690864563,
0.07585760951042175,
-0.17735759913921356,
-0.672922670841217,
0.13025546073913574,
-0.19053515791893005,
0.11161420494318008,
-0.07041988521814346,
0.42679449915885925,
0.1310918778181076,
0.011846756562590599,
0.048671599477529526,
0.11925084888935089,
0.29860809445381165,
0.16483846306800842,
-0.08195577561855316,
0.7425705194473267,
-0.08760590851306915,
-0.23992346227169037,
0.05733288824558258,
0.21730680763721466,
0.4502086937427521,
0.30924975872039795,
0.9764220118522644,
0.7886533141136169,
-0.4301990568637848,
-0.22672127187252045,
-0.8105863928794861,
-0.2639366090297699,
-0.4652939736843109,
0.35287952423095703,
0.08313599973917007,
-1.2473000288009644,
0.7603535652160645,
0.45046770572662354,
0.12416815012693405,
0.38633960485458374,
0.6618101596832275,
-0.30175480246543884,
1.1897881031036377,
0.6451488733291626,
-0.22130423784255981,
1.0843241214752197,
-0.226158007979393,
-0.2548657953739166,
-0.3824352025985718,
-0.11479752510786057,
-0.24868974089622498,
-0.21540847420692444,
-1.074349284172058,
-0.26626744866371155,
0.10886193066835403,
-0.06733217090368271,
-0.2680436372756958,
-0.1468837708234787,
0.0002448659797664732,
0.44236674904823303,
0.28773728013038635,
0.2169474959373474,
-0.16512781381607056,
0.12377046793699265,
0.19191472232341766,
-0.06500068306922913,
-0.6026778221130371,
-0.4172002375125885,
1.001898169517517,
0.6194343566894531,
0.6404988169670105,
-0.06816267222166061,
0.3134702146053314,
0.726654589176178,
0.4727197289466858,
-0.34135615825653076,
0.5074008703231812,
-0.038968607783317566,
-0.8003475069999695,
-0.3088887929916382,
-0.4025189280509949,
-1.0325409173965454,
-0.05199253559112549,
-0.3896324336528778,
-0.725500226020813,
0.592969536781311,
0.23855476081371307,
-0.05460195988416672,
0.1651408076286316,
-0.7227044701576233,
0.6827470660209656,
-0.1610955148935318,
-0.6576449871063232,
-0.005310348700731993,
-0.8571969270706177,
0.400364488363266,
-0.17935267090797424,
0.21953994035720825,
-0.5100881457328796,
0.0776028037071228,
0.9766287207603455,
-0.30388444662094116,
1.095686435699463,
-0.1974724531173706,
0.33009782433509827,
0.0698264092206955,
-0.1042218804359436,
0.4084441065788269,
0.11193332076072693,
0.2827041447162628,
0.4565593898296356,
-0.022771647199988365,
-0.7200683951377869,
-0.6191549897193909,
0.577206552028656,
-1.0112981796264648,
-0.47869178652763367,
-0.4503137469291687,
-0.3502632975578308,
-0.10304130613803864,
0.02126786857843399,
0.15336260199546814,
0.4227942228317261,
-0.4066160023212433,
0.28697648644447327,
0.5287548899650574,
-0.2658578157424927,
0.5415762066841125,
0.4329538345336914,
-0.3609775900840759,
-0.2764296531677246,
0.4606983959674835,
0.5311254262924194,
0.6647462248802185,
0.08193662762641907,
0.242519348859787,
-0.06233984977006912,
-0.14162401854991913,
-0.30057910084724426,
0.3483870327472687,
-0.40859705209732056,
0.43542414903640747,
-0.9086500406265259,
-0.21244288980960846,
-0.5796036124229431,
-0.15973296761512756,
-0.32437771558761597,
-0.3013995885848999,
-0.2663724720478058,
-0.12749408185482025,
0.36494937539100647,
0.7302467823028564,
0.004377460572868586,
0.40823662281036377,
-0.5360291004180908,
0.34509313106536865,
0.33452486991882324,
0.3309498429298401,
-0.173113152384758,
-0.3151707649230957,
-0.4885079264640808,
0.09895246475934982,
0.05965809524059296,
-1.2765690088272095,
0.27099210023880005,
0.009660810232162476,
0.4734638035297394,
0.5579748749732971,
-0.2777978777885437,
0.566641092300415,
-0.5644713044166565,
0.9417522549629211,
-0.017720818519592285,
-0.6506157517433167,
0.3547155261039734,
-0.7034134268760681,
0.38583019375801086,
0.4523041248321533,
0.5610044002532959,
-0.8421811461448669,
-0.7492678165435791,
-0.7615200281143188,
-0.8782838582992554,
0.5336157083511353,
0.29761600494384766,
0.30692824721336365,
-0.28796321153640747,
0.38389575481414795,
-0.04225243255496025,
0.4191703200340271,
-0.7354444861412048,
-0.4888954162597656,
-0.1430409848690033,
0.2090272754430771,
-0.2948593199253082,
-0.7805883884429932,
-0.06769875437021255,
-0.0927552580833435,
0.5201689004898071,
0.16261832416057587,
0.30709290504455566,
-0.07489604502916336,
-0.29690486192703247,
-0.2601659595966339,
0.24476711452007294,
0.7554114460945129,
0.9831847548484802,
-0.7842952013015747,
0.17697295546531677,
0.15916253626346588,
-0.7747807502746582,
0.07705731689929962,
0.053074538707733154,
-0.293521910905838,
0.5157895684242249,
0.13613535463809967,
1.001039981842041,
0.20055650174617767,
-0.32020288705825806,
0.5064107775688171,
-0.11096837371587753,
-0.044741302728652954,
-0.6395336389541626,
-0.16350828111171722,
0.22991162538528442,
0.24970659613609314,
0.5181682705879211,
-0.013448983430862427,
-0.20104873180389404,
-0.9040553569793701,
-0.030831722542643547,
0.33450233936309814,
-0.5346128940582275,
-0.3431701064109802,
0.7253924012184143,
0.10114309191703796,
-0.36136549711227417,
0.15315616130828857,
-0.12699837982654572,
-0.3909784257411957,
0.4238622188568115,
0.27767419815063477,
0.9432221055030823,
-0.249363973736763,
0.23106732964515686,
0.10496042668819427,
0.6451400518417358,
-0.1642032116651535,
-0.035332996398210526,
0.09989229589700699,
-0.8711715936660767,
-0.2495289444923401,
-0.6726676225662231,
-0.19586917757987976,
0.31695252656936646,
-0.6922160983085632,
0.4182904064655304,
-0.352853924036026,
-0.830809473991394,
0.11682400107383728,
-0.016698867082595825,
-0.8285263180732727,
0.042172979563474655,
-0.007219140417873859,
0.5704483985900879,
-1.2716178894042969,
0.6232393383979797,
0.436777800321579,
-0.15420779585838318,
-0.29175496101379395,
-0.04734587296843529,
0.25539451837539673,
-0.724218487739563,
0.8145897388458252,
0.11448293179273605,
-0.23188838362693787,
-0.4409151077270508,
-0.7535635232925415,
-0.7008428573608398,
0.7010928988456726,
0.3814964294433594,
-0.6795545220375061,
-0.04648134484887123,
0.4371185004711151,
0.7866281867027283,
-0.5116708874702454,
0.07391773164272308,
0.7067035436630249,
-0.021415950730443,
-0.24961122870445251,
-0.6295533776283264,
-0.25621649622917175,
-0.34481069445610046,
0.40565359592437744,
0.21375440061092377,
-0.43057674169540405,
0.6282744407653809,
0.010550959035754204,
-0.49918800592422485,
-0.5708163976669312,
0.6512223482131958,
0.2697351574897766,
0.6407074928283691,
0.7425790429115295,
-0.058264199644327164,
0.48776060342788696,
-0.004551847465336323,
0.9092954993247986,
-0.4719429016113281,
0.12589934468269348,
1.0640329122543335,
-0.10345794260501862,
0.5998542904853821,
0.47056570649147034,
-0.11194192618131638,
0.49720486998558044,
0.9699519276618958,
0.13301672041416168,
0.23969222605228424,
0.1330873668193817,
-0.08878929913043976,
-0.10837185382843018,
-0.11170606315135956,
-0.4915900230407715,
-0.20473194122314453,
0.3143484592437744,
-0.7060350775718689,
0.3455985188484192,
-0.03693465515971184,
0.5281549096107483,
-0.20655715465545654,
-0.41359031200408936,
0.3688688576221466,
0.25265979766845703,
-0.40597301721572876,
0.1753578633069992,
-0.12427466362714767,
0.7338755130767822,
-0.6895546317100525,
0.39084577560424805,
-0.4390806555747986,
0.0004541953094303608,
-0.21034054458141327,
-0.5527267456054688,
0.1475236862897873,
0.05227208137512207,
-0.3389635384082794,
-0.17966565489768982,
0.8408516049385071,
-0.7026643753051758,
-0.7248483300209045,
0.5140909552574158,
0.4912382960319519,
0.12195304036140442,
0.09033560007810593,
-0.5310479402542114,
0.25947821140289307,
-0.22466762363910675,
-0.19734694063663483,
0.45489799976348877,
0.24287137389183044,
-0.2691631317138672,
0.6476176977157593,
0.7304973006248474,
0.3738080561161041,
0.6727062463760376,
0.5876674056053162,
0.740837812423706,
-0.5585099458694458,
-0.4716271758079529,
-1.0730690956115723,
0.24943166971206665,
-0.4492323696613312,
-0.09380730986595154,
1.0620168447494507,
0.3617762327194214,
0.9056246280670166,
0.19274625182151794,
0.5978155136108398,
0.29611700773239136,
0.462704598903656,
-0.4388108551502228,
0.7680414319038391,
-0.4752453863620758,
0.3345015347003937,
-0.49524348974227905,
-1.0173425674438477,
0.11794370412826538,
0.07557177543640137,
-0.6004810929298401,
0.27731263637542725,
0.5098917484283447,
0.8220468163490295,
0.1652432382106781,
0.004862999077886343,
0.03428531438112259,
0.17757466435432434,
0.131825789809227,
-0.19622264802455902,
0.9394181370735168,
0.011711707338690758,
0.303531676530838,
-0.3337152898311615,
-0.0502164401113987,
-0.29745256900787354,
-0.8356732726097107,
-1.2387645244598389,
-0.5241065621376038,
-0.3303527235984802,
-0.6347479820251465,
0.6063701510429382,
1.1969140768051147,
0.5314135551452637,
-0.6170873045921326,
-0.41135266423225403,
0.4942752420902252,
0.20082072913646698,
-0.2151505947113037,
-0.30125486850738525,
0.3753849267959595,
-0.10385756939649582,
-0.6916216015815735,
-0.037726014852523804,
0.16180966794490814,
0.029755454510450363,
-0.44786328077316284,
0.09192444384098053,
-0.17781338095664978,
0.3438336253166199,
0.923698902130127,
0.10175354033708572,
-0.32551655173301697,
-0.33339929580688477,
0.34401124715805054,
-0.24050097167491913,
0.01473002415150404,
1.0055999755859375,
-0.096799336373806,
0.4608832001686096,
0.4725313186645508,
0.3664137125015259,
0.7985204458236694,
0.04624110087752342,
0.5284547209739685,
-0.8829225301742554,
0.07876203209161758,
-0.10649005323648453,
0.47390589118003845,
0.45074260234832764,
-0.15236365795135498,
0.38438814878463745,
0.6087110638618469,
-0.6092833876609802,
-1.053515076637268,
-0.12384817004203796,
-0.7559252977371216,
-0.3330334424972534,
1.7900691032409668,
0.35649463534355164,
-0.2024419754743576,
-0.402310848236084,
0.1495070904493332,
0.2990626394748688,
-0.5233754515647888,
1.05128014087677,
0.8799949288368225,
0.0553475022315979,
-0.07806845754384995,
-1.0080682039260864,
0.6567453145980835,
0.13813602924346924,
-0.3730643093585968,
-0.14121674001216888,
0.5895217657089233,
0.6386561989784241,
0.16834227740764618,
1.0630295276641846,
-0.11324663460254669,
0.16622762382030487,
-0.046452704817056656,
-0.3300873935222626,
0.29126930236816406,
-0.2845711410045624,
-0.20760732889175415,
0.093746617436409,
-0.22777654230594635,
-0.08955665677785873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13555v1 | BiLD: Bi-directional Logits Difference Loss for Large Language Model Distillation | 2024-06-19T13:44:56 | 2024-06-19T13:44:56 | Minchong Li, Feng Zhou, Xiaohui Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have shown exceptional
capabilities across various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However,
such impressive performance often comes with the trade-off of an increased
parameter size, posing significant challenges for widespread deployment.
Knowledge distillation (KD) provides a solution by transferring knowledge from
a large teacher model to a smaller student model. In this paper, we explore the
task-specific distillation of LLMs at the logit level. Our investigation
reveals that the logits of fine-tuned LLMs exhibit a more extreme long-tail
distribution than those from vision models, with hidden "noise" in the long
tail affecting distillation performance. Furthermore, existing logits
distillation methods often struggle to effectively utilize the internal ranking
information from the logits. To address these, we propose the Bi-directional
Logits Difference (BiLD) loss. The BiLD loss filters out the long-tail noise by
utilizing only top-$k$ teacher and student logits, and leverages the internal
logits ranking information by constructing logits differences. To evaluate BiLD
loss, we conduct comprehensive experiments on 13 datasets using two types of
LLMs. Our results show that the BiLD loss, with only the top-8 logits,
outperforms supervised fine-tuning (SFT), vanilla KL loss, and five other
distillation methods from both NLP and CV fields. | [
-0.2813590168952942,
-0.8470444679260254,
0.6593058109283447,
0.26132816076278687,
-0.43306291103363037,
0.2987859845161438,
-0.47034206986427307,
-0.393783301115036,
-0.18319174647331238,
0.4527762234210968,
-0.3301822245121002,
-0.4421103894710541,
-0.8267161250114441,
-0.06722661852836609,
-0.5312749743461609,
1.2031538486480713,
0.14974233508110046,
0.19886907935142517,
-0.32444387674331665,
-0.030816953629255295,
-0.8356555700302124,
-0.532090961933136,
-0.8451551795005798,
-0.5523468852043152,
0.6446486711502075,
0.12129935622215271,
0.3392927944660187,
0.15184666216373444,
0.5403943657875061,
0.24539704620838165,
-0.49505239725112915,
0.0535469613969326,
-0.7231536507606506,
0.028661804273724556,
-0.44255852699279785,
-0.7535912990570068,
-0.12094235420227051,
-0.10438141226768494,
0.8373903036117554,
1.0257076025009155,
-0.15117761492729187,
0.22913530468940735,
0.4921395480632782,
1.2417768239974976,
-0.5105212926864624,
0.16959065198898315,
-0.7248812913894653,
0.0482296384871006,
-0.33116385340690613,
-0.061431944370269775,
-0.6115007400512695,
-0.22626760601997375,
0.292945921421051,
-0.047810230404138565,
0.33795490860939026,
0.10023342072963715,
0.8807090520858765,
0.3409149646759033,
-0.6397343277931213,
-0.056346818804740906,
-1.057009220123291,
0.719001054763794,
-0.8633390665054321,
0.5240198969841003,
0.25196200609207153,
0.2691415548324585,
-0.17953719198703766,
-0.4128727912902832,
-0.5247015357017517,
0.19853384792804718,
-0.09039448946714401,
-0.17301636934280396,
-0.20302177965641022,
0.05681343376636505,
0.09430954605340958,
0.22884820401668549,
-0.47772708535194397,
0.31233441829681396,
-0.3811064064502716,
0.10443352162837982,
0.5157941579818726,
0.10884225368499756,
-0.31381741166114807,
0.16609007120132446,
-0.2578960359096527,
-0.3856961131095886,
-0.7615541815757751,
0.005211323499679565,
0.3886431157588959,
0.21913550794124603,
0.11822041124105453,
0.4493160843849182,
-0.1291917860507965,
0.6901460886001587,
0.2480878382921219,
-0.4689614772796631,
0.020613105967640877,
-0.36230891942977905,
-0.35935255885124207,
0.24110165238380432,
0.46330884099006653,
0.5574068427085876,
0.2000652402639389,
-0.06180718168616295,
-0.20612400770187378,
-0.2623108923435211,
-0.4343737065792084,
-0.9876917004585266,
-0.7115075588226318,
-0.24679876863956451,
-0.4495874345302582,
-0.30822765827178955,
-0.11144790798425674,
-0.6067858934402466,
-0.7644780874252319,
-0.4862441420555115,
0.5220867395401001,
-0.15699559450149536,
-0.5046274662017822,
0.1593427211046219,
-0.33824628591537476,
0.06883708387613297,
0.1489081233739853,
-0.8278045654296875,
0.16142553091049194,
0.5552401542663574,
0.9160541296005249,
-0.2849278450012207,
-0.09122534096240997,
-0.4430016577243805,
0.2086930274963379,
-0.3289925754070282,
0.5047483444213867,
-0.3089950382709503,
-0.45698046684265137,
-0.31913599371910095,
-0.13810773193836212,
-0.15782073140144348,
-0.9567303657531738,
0.13865604996681213,
-0.5873106718063354,
0.0808626189827919,
-0.17440646886825562,
-0.5814235806465149,
-0.44651371240615845,
-0.014562204480171204,
-0.5494593977928162,
1.1303116083145142,
-0.023754477500915527,
-0.7819117307662964,
0.4547869861125946,
-0.3037242591381073,
-0.45643043518066406,
-0.010916003957390785,
0.013758587650954723,
-0.6056404113769531,
0.3816884756088257,
-0.08063256740570068,
0.5315574407577515,
-0.5237606763839722,
0.3963780403137207,
-0.21824117004871368,
-0.16532357037067413,
0.18412472307682037,
-0.702015221118927,
1.0568580627441406,
-0.1563466489315033,
-0.383362352848053,
-0.1215612068772316,
-0.8555086851119995,
-0.15799157321453094,
0.11391115933656693,
-0.44054922461509705,
-0.9823369383811951,
0.0725470706820488,
0.013449707068502903,
-0.08879631757736206,
0.10338292270898819,
-0.5619605183601379,
0.29746168851852417,
-0.22844429314136505,
0.28310057520866394,
0.8903878331184387,
0.04888451471924782,
0.34891003370285034,
-0.1263432502746582,
0.03292354568839073,
0.22781510651111603,
0.02441362291574478,
0.3889630138874054,
-0.5330281257629395,
-0.73482745885849,
-0.3437533378601074,
0.4113267660140991,
0.3991119861602783,
-0.5620402693748474,
0.2314109057188034,
-0.2748628556728363,
-0.5375043749809265,
-0.42691388726234436,
0.4394020140171051,
0.28945496678352356,
0.7473753690719604,
0.20957592129707336,
-0.051798831671476364,
-0.4326690435409546,
-0.9202783703804016,
-0.33373671770095825,
-0.2702779173851013,
-0.11299432069063187,
-0.19839973747730255,
0.2047523409128189,
-0.046238332986831665,
0.9495564699172974,
-0.655064582824707,
-0.6122499704360962,
-0.42858630418777466,
0.21923482418060303,
0.41362902522087097,
0.18752147257328033,
0.584613561630249,
-0.7879383563995361,
-0.8655434250831604,
0.08737611770629883,
-0.4028373956680298,
-0.207887202501297,
-0.20955568552017212,
-0.17193637788295746,
0.5139613747596741,
0.4145452380180359,
-0.7077793478965759,
0.6110353469848633,
0.7641168236732483,
-0.604367196559906,
0.598645031452179,
-0.1283271163702011,
-0.19513960182666779,
-0.8325262665748596,
-0.07826631516218185,
-0.041779905557632446,
-0.28070685267448425,
-0.46846678853034973,
-0.2647383511066437,
-0.031220391392707825,
0.2291882038116455,
-0.10624877363443375,
0.30690789222717285,
-0.4293343126773834,
0.0432085245847702,
-0.24105815589427948,
0.11118187010288239,
0.40489810705184937,
0.5031936764717102,
0.025643974542617798,
0.4670991897583008,
0.5403751730918884,
-0.6319542527198792,
0.512313187122345,
-0.05224243551492691,
-0.5666650533676147,
0.6330680847167969,
-0.5648587942123413,
-0.009237200953066349,
-0.23021532595157623,
0.22009947896003723,
-1.1398112773895264,
0.29251813888549805,
-0.03620237112045288,
-0.08416382223367691,
0.5337541699409485,
-0.23757147789001465,
-0.6474713087081909,
-0.19493117928504944,
-0.2547787129878998,
0.23763073980808258,
0.5999036431312561,
-0.631732702255249,
0.28566670417785645,
0.09441319853067398,
-0.35215917229652405,
-0.33200204372406006,
-0.8790494799613953,
0.2619785666465759,
-0.47247937321662903,
-0.5477076172828674,
0.2548145651817322,
-0.13549451529979706,
-0.2894478440284729,
0.2655385732650757,
-0.20478947460651398,
-0.10279088467359543,
0.0014213711256161332,
0.144417405128479,
0.4769604504108429,
-0.3318491578102112,
0.3529658615589142,
0.12857277691364288,
0.07439147680997849,
0.29592758417129517,
-0.2902000844478607,
0.5326701998710632,
-0.09367737174034119,
-0.3947656452655792,
-0.5050032138824463,
0.223377525806427,
0.44613009691238403,
-0.13456201553344727,
1.0890703201293945,
0.5290796160697937,
-0.06231420487165451,
-0.3504391610622406,
-0.6809436678886414,
-0.1863274723291397,
-0.4977492690086365,
0.6104743480682373,
-0.2909044027328491,
-0.5358150601387024,
0.3546415865421295,
-0.20498256385326385,
0.176837757229805,
0.33344143629074097,
0.4592951834201813,
-0.1938919723033905,
0.9888834357261658,
0.7352617979049683,
-0.24952425062656403,
0.4396691918373108,
-0.4107276201248169,
0.6338507533073425,
-0.5736290216445923,
-0.4365847110748291,
-0.5194419026374817,
-0.633375346660614,
-0.3682059645652771,
-0.3406468331813812,
0.5547603964805603,
0.39363762736320496,
-0.09527558088302612,
0.01689046435058117,
-0.5300877094268799,
0.5654034614562988,
0.8438002467155457,
-0.16724106669425964,
0.6247031092643738,
0.19267578423023224,
-0.015878411009907722,
0.04249800369143486,
-0.6730520725250244,
-0.23389261960983276,
1.0405166149139404,
0.34426644444465637,
0.830368161201477,
0.3781905472278595,
0.8729252815246582,
0.18421326577663422,
0.05375942215323448,
-0.7003208994865417,
0.6725874543190002,
-0.22853627800941467,
-0.5640196204185486,
-0.7136212587356567,
-0.4628053903579712,
-0.8002952337265015,
0.3341154456138611,
-0.09115640074014664,
-0.4818657636642456,
0.19406262040138245,
0.10992204397916794,
0.05071606487035751,
0.722830057144165,
-0.8256587982177734,
0.7884407043457031,
-0.19796809554100037,
-0.21812888979911804,
-0.2552352845668793,
-0.6287620067596436,
0.29006227850914,
-0.2381867617368698,
0.17269179224967957,
-0.12771686911582947,
0.4059799015522003,
0.7359509468078613,
-0.610607385635376,
0.8296198844909668,
-0.5389745235443115,
-0.18787677586078644,
0.4020475447177887,
0.20989908277988434,
0.721848726272583,
-0.10845469683408737,
0.06319069862365723,
0.4141834080219269,
0.2873271107673645,
-0.20550155639648438,
-0.6991679668426514,
0.71482914686203,
-0.5828683376312256,
-0.7457798719406128,
-0.21650703251361847,
-0.3616284728050232,
-0.09824573248624802,
0.13911360502243042,
0.18662920594215393,
0.35400256514549255,
0.25849661231040955,
0.5449897050857544,
0.8322624564170837,
-0.06766773760318756,
0.6132695078849792,
0.5058613419532776,
-0.4580923616886139,
0.2288607656955719,
1.0352529287338257,
0.24012941122055054,
0.44946950674057007,
0.35152554512023926,
0.48199719190597534,
-0.5493082404136658,
-0.7678917050361633,
-0.5743629932403564,
0.24956049025058746,
-0.7827199697494507,
-0.2933521866798401,
-0.13920624554157257,
-0.253969669342041,
-0.41279610991477966,
0.05003039166331291,
-0.38079288601875305,
-0.34143704175949097,
-0.20260237157344818,
-0.17108875513076782,
0.49019286036491394,
0.7166380882263184,
0.059587620198726654,
0.19201938807964325,
-0.6367994546890259,
0.09511525183916092,
0.2827072739601135,
0.4591697156429291,
0.0960603654384613,
-0.7729287147521973,
-0.32913920283317566,
0.17735086381435394,
-0.1651328057050705,
-0.763147234916687,
0.4072311818599701,
0.5382055044174194,
0.2741299867630005,
0.42949748039245605,
0.3752121031284332,
0.8864610195159912,
-0.4400247037410736,
0.6309216022491455,
0.4721275269985199,
-0.6517855525016785,
0.2338094562292099,
0.0530460849404335,
0.4486071467399597,
0.5658465623855591,
0.0822797492146492,
-0.4548095762729645,
-0.572360098361969,
-0.13840389251708984,
-0.9747013449668884,
0.556402862071991,
-0.03726591542363167,
0.02189629152417183,
0.20818258821964264,
0.03903483971953392,
0.25778040289878845,
0.0842810794711113,
-0.7910398244857788,
-0.4262368381023407,
-0.008228549733757973,
-0.2809935510158539,
-0.18379491567611694,
-0.14720579981803894,
-0.04839444160461426,
-0.500170111656189,
0.7952789664268494,
0.3376525640487671,
-0.17039313912391663,
0.0418039970099926,
-0.10413405299186707,
0.0007757183630019426,
0.22822964191436768,
0.13594458997249603,
0.5273685455322266,
-0.21233363449573517,
0.5035263895988464,
0.2206452488899231,
-0.5049594640731812,
0.1641349494457245,
-0.06502017378807068,
-0.19402073323726654,
0.3522356152534485,
0.274804025888443,
1.011080026626587,
0.05052795633673668,
-0.6865140199661255,
0.4844212234020233,
0.1326051652431488,
-0.3014874756336212,
-0.3389216959476471,
-0.09124041348695755,
0.4071481227874756,
0.41311153769493103,
0.5325412154197693,
-0.014986147172749043,
0.2581115961074829,
-0.5810492634773254,
-0.23105479776859283,
0.31263935565948486,
-0.10070109367370605,
-0.20658665895462036,
0.5769420266151428,
0.1503971666097641,
-0.1969538778066635,
0.6834428906440735,
-0.1309213638305664,
-0.19263000786304474,
0.46073266863822937,
0.45607107877731323,
0.8438149094581604,
-0.14820332825183868,
0.18486101925373077,
0.12718042731285095,
0.12482255697250366,
-0.042709458619356155,
-0.23803944885730743,
0.05665156990289688,
-0.31729620695114136,
-0.47532230615615845,
-0.9028676748275757,
-0.08687978982925415,
0.2567271590232849,
-0.6702695488929749,
0.37251800298690796,
-0.4049244225025177,
-0.13672617077827454,
0.2391563504934311,
-0.17225584387779236,
-0.7060727477073669,
-0.15018880367279053,
0.09961434453725815,
0.43463969230651855,
-0.6814484596252441,
0.9230337738990784,
0.7119712233543396,
-0.10684294998645782,
-0.770083487033844,
-0.17144852876663208,
0.010433527640998363,
-0.3093569874763489,
1.1607168912887573,
0.018443429842591286,
-0.2904258370399475,
-0.0495474673807621,
-0.19270986318588257,
-0.6957332491874695,
1.0630885362625122,
0.35905593633651733,
-1.1323257684707642,
-0.2505834698677063,
0.47072941064834595,
0.5554139614105225,
0.027059445157647133,
-0.2311570793390274,
0.5358313322067261,
0.3968668580055237,
0.1902182698249817,
-1.1202400922775269,
-0.08125985413789749,
0.18314173817634583,
0.14061667025089264,
0.547667384147644,
-0.5730491876602173,
0.8436185121536255,
-0.09975836426019669,
-0.29751795530319214,
-0.40825435519218445,
0.40775740146636963,
-0.011945486068725586,
0.7048327922821045,
0.6795938014984131,
0.37799134850502014,
0.6468379497528076,
0.05808594077825546,
0.5813531875610352,
-0.10308025032281876,
0.4107886552810669,
1.3258124589920044,
-0.3135226368904114,
0.9910845756530762,
0.78603196144104,
-0.4538457691669464,
0.4975002408027649,
0.35866567492485046,
0.0836837887763977,
0.7051584720611572,
0.2917681038379669,
-0.42399564385414124,
-0.1175120398402214,
0.19998839497566223,
-0.1823682337999344,
0.3546077013015747,
0.1699340045452118,
-0.17187200486660004,
-0.2657277584075928,
0.32655245065689087,
0.02228490635752678,
0.09982627630233765,
-0.23741166293621063,
0.785266637802124,
0.029266761615872383,
-0.5461388826370239,
0.8672400116920471,
0.07930822670459747,
0.5965467095375061,
-0.4745360314846039,
-0.03525673970580101,
-0.25216805934906006,
0.3806132972240448,
-0.11444482952356339,
-0.6955877542495728,
0.4697287082672119,
-0.05928752198815346,
-0.3706519305706024,
-0.2496270388364792,
0.621027410030365,
-0.8024942874908447,
-0.6199852228164673,
0.4572915732860565,
0.23452122509479523,
0.30678290128707886,
-0.2279903143644333,
-0.3424523174762726,
0.05146609619259834,
0.12280835956335068,
-0.4351973831653595,
0.5774253010749817,
0.5752381086349487,
-0.08097010850906372,
0.6221793293952942,
0.47288087010383606,
0.18890710175037384,
0.3805033564567566,
0.12065225094556808,
0.9069386124610901,
-0.3763771653175354,
-0.1766585111618042,
-1.0032461881637573,
0.24948431551456451,
-0.20326754450798035,
-0.08846621960401535,
0.8500495553016663,
0.6770171523094177,
1.0031501054763794,
-0.24158057570457458,
0.6896255612373352,
-0.026186134666204453,
0.7894057035446167,
-0.6029962301254272,
0.8665432333946228,
-0.47368860244750977,
0.5185693502426147,
-0.1431909203529358,
-1.2289786338806152,
-0.10197866708040237,
0.39826926589012146,
-0.11334111541509628,
-0.2826528251171112,
0.6114202737808228,
0.7098715305328369,
0.07224249839782715,
-0.30212852358818054,
0.5653090476989746,
0.45835715532302856,
0.3902651369571686,
0.5364011526107788,
0.45316600799560547,
-0.22437888383865356,
0.7016986608505249,
-0.4192662239074707,
-0.1019270196557045,
-0.4941484034061432,
-0.7461432218551636,
-1.1909971237182617,
-0.699083149433136,
-0.5079860091209412,
-0.02112448960542679,
0.19378070533275604,
0.522498369216919,
0.5434616804122925,
-0.6471660137176514,
-0.25788938999176025,
-0.08239659667015076,
0.19580432772636414,
-0.27485886216163635,
-0.2844308614730835,
0.5372967720031738,
-0.20989204943180084,
-0.8394752144813538,
0.2692679762840271,
0.07885973900556564,
0.008058658801019192,
-0.4047085642814636,
-0.07419311255216599,
-0.30864372849464417,
-0.07046612352132797,
0.9381110072135925,
-0.0976245328783989,
-0.7536720037460327,
-0.3352109491825104,
-0.2606060206890106,
0.10490184277296066,
-0.2124098241329193,
0.6260268092155457,
-0.7092033624649048,
0.46107620000839233,
0.5091697573661804,
0.5908344388008118,
0.7251098155975342,
-0.16398613154888153,
0.2571333646774292,
-0.8788965344429016,
0.10322429984807968,
0.06869867444038391,
0.04792599007487297,
0.24656666815280914,
-0.26867738366127014,
0.4690241813659668,
0.4770676791667938,
-0.5167160034179688,
-1.1258553266525269,
-0.03302881494164467,
-0.9036456942558289,
-0.5409517288208008,
1.263542652130127,
-0.12926127016544342,
0.0565686970949173,
-0.15732716023921967,
-0.40747931599617004,
0.20857855677604675,
-0.2120400220155716,
0.744899332523346,
0.9894410967826843,
-0.16300858557224274,
-0.2092900574207306,
-0.5994418859481812,
0.38487690687179565,
0.6448282599449158,
-0.30689695477485657,
0.3779667019844055,
0.5778296589851379,
0.536546528339386,
-0.03453828766942024,
0.22971120476722717,
0.0341348834335804,
-0.26653850078582764,
-0.02774861827492714,
0.13091441988945007,
-0.22615112364292145,
-0.43944042921066284,
-0.13137629628181458,
0.03758203983306885,
0.3652286231517792,
-0.18298916518688202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13553v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13553v1 | Mining United Nations General Assembly Debates | 2024-06-19T13:43:27 | 2024-06-19T13:43:27 | Mateusz Grzyb, Mateusz Krzyziński, Bartłomiej Sobieski, Mikołaj Spytek, Bartosz Pieliński, Daniel Dan, Anna Wróblewska | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | This project explores the application of Natural Language Processing (NLP)
techniques to analyse United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) speeches. Using
NLP allows for the efficient processing and analysis of large volumes of
textual data, enabling the extraction of semantic patterns, sentiment analysis,
and topic modelling. Our goal is to deliver a comprehensive dataset and a tool
(interface with descriptive statistics and automatically extracted topics) from
which political scientists can derive insights into international relations and
have the opportunity to have a nuanced understanding of global diplomatic
discourse. | [
-0.6308571696281433,
-0.594203770160675,
0.3493289351463318,
0.03564124554395676,
-0.44342389702796936,
0.3984638750553131,
-0.04091370105743408,
-0.5521329641342163,
0.20237088203430176,
0.6977713704109192,
-0.5440785884857178,
-0.590109646320343,
-0.49212846159935,
0.2588862478733063,
-0.5423414707183838,
0.8442502617835999,
0.5213090777397156,
0.11113333702087402,
-0.2177472561597824,
-0.13212080299854279,
-0.1807432770729065,
-0.6141408085823059,
-0.7514548301696777,
-0.6832640171051025,
0.11849642544984818,
0.5683606266975403,
0.7403014898300171,
0.36107751727104187,
0.3500334322452545,
0.35036829113960266,
-0.5001143217086792,
0.05596053972840309,
-0.08482786267995834,
-0.17249616980552673,
-0.590967059135437,
-0.3031904101371765,
-0.08941970765590668,
0.11863137036561966,
0.5003806948661804,
0.716788113117218,
-0.3130294680595398,
0.06476916372776031,
0.17464429140090942,
0.7815171480178833,
-0.14053696393966675,
0.46659377217292786,
-0.8473354578018188,
0.2260291874408722,
-0.4099852740764618,
-0.4054759442806244,
-0.15479838848114014,
-0.03661404922604561,
0.43561819195747375,
-0.22134652733802795,
0.317836195230484,
-0.10982649773359299,
0.7037691473960876,
-0.05384115129709244,
-0.35329684615135193,
-0.438778281211853,
-0.45745959877967834,
0.7916116714477539,
-0.9566258192062378,
-0.1188175305724144,
0.20496708154678345,
0.07410774379968643,
-0.8605682849884033,
-1.001514196395874,
-0.4898012578487396,
0.08111748844385147,
-0.02147604338824749,
0.18691886961460114,
-0.5795751810073853,
0.3118811547756195,
0.06008376553654671,
0.6754513382911682,
-0.5774684548377991,
0.06589999794960022,
-0.5582662224769592,
0.05570116639137268,
0.9842872023582458,
0.03808025270700455,
0.49838224053382874,
-0.7493405938148499,
-0.17741245031356812,
0.3168785870075226,
-0.5136994123458862,
-0.008052369579672813,
0.5198901891708374,
0.4565814137458801,
-0.10042601823806763,
0.5659661293029785,
-0.7472938299179077,
0.9609037041664124,
-0.30761340260505676,
0.32025906443595886,
-0.12418525665998459,
-0.28900179266929626,
-0.3930721879005432,
0.11523066461086273,
1.1030066013336182,
0.6303679347038269,
0.20200440287590027,
-0.3227841556072235,
0.21237201988697052,
0.44138509035110474,
0.19834882020950317,
-0.6405029296875,
-0.3319551646709442,
0.118740975856781,
-0.5237137079238892,
-0.2813670039176941,
0.2407034933567047,
-1.5040892362594604,
-0.16463863849639893,
-0.4584046006202698,
-0.1965979039669037,
0.17547771334648132,
-0.11764323711395264,
0.3041282594203949,
-0.44009336829185486,
0.0661911591887474,
-0.13531158864498138,
-1.1269497871398926,
0.44878992438316345,
0.6836820244789124,
0.9891365766525269,
-0.30099087953567505,
0.3523474633693695,
-0.3333931267261505,
-0.1324373185634613,
-0.005719307344406843,
1.260056972503662,
-0.78680419921875,
-0.8042421936988831,
0.0828818827867508,
0.07049214094877243,
0.2385532110929489,
-0.6625374555587769,
1.0631967782974243,
-0.3018554449081421,
0.4823375642299652,
-0.3723223805427551,
-0.7152048945426941,
-0.21869271993637085,
0.024867016822099686,
-0.7058945298194885,
0.8749626278877258,
-0.23462717235088348,
-0.7963851094245911,
0.24691230058670044,
-1.2826337814331055,
-0.12362723797559738,
0.1842958927154541,
-0.5283383131027222,
0.1547885537147522,
0.31651443243026733,
0.4694298505783081,
0.4132857918739319,
-0.6642389893531799,
0.5038807988166809,
0.1462409347295761,
-0.07881492376327515,
-0.07266020029783249,
-0.23372162878513336,
0.8518304824829102,
0.30973491072654724,
-0.19047032296657562,
0.2814740836620331,
-0.8956968188285828,
0.2480551153421402,
0.09287466108798981,
-0.3189653754234314,
-0.2523808479309082,
0.40601328015327454,
-0.03546809405088425,
0.18689005076885223,
-0.1374138444662094,
-0.6302911639213562,
0.6900952458381653,
-0.6407026648521423,
0.7976399064064026,
0.5370762348175049,
0.44892600178718567,
0.3705503046512604,
0.11398347467184067,
0.426259309053421,
-0.2634749114513397,
-0.2780221104621887,
0.1562013328075409,
-1.1258842945098877,
-0.4840552508831024,
0.39230087399482727,
0.607690691947937,
0.700746476650238,
-0.6696084141731262,
0.2982442378997803,
0.12272370606660843,
-0.3310202658176422,
-0.5544955134391785,
0.12601768970489502,
0.11832393705844879,
0.36931172013282776,
0.22397056221961975,
-0.5534459948539734,
-1.0370450019836426,
-0.7774593234062195,
-0.520295262336731,
-0.38311925530433655,
-0.2504628598690033,
-0.1108926385641098,
0.45321619510650635,
-0.2372269183397293,
1.1852203607559204,
-0.5675141215324402,
-0.05954163148999214,
-0.24703779816627502,
1.0540939569473267,
0.3660930097103119,
0.2860645055770874,
0.20215345919132233,
-0.9490025639533997,
-0.27527108788490295,
0.11640633642673492,
-0.8004515171051025,
-0.24865420162677765,
-0.06368536502122879,
-0.06534171104431152,
0.16349266469478607,
0.5479670763015747,
-0.39485716819763184,
0.7077693939208984,
0.5164673924446106,
-0.5661089420318604,
0.40927794575691223,
0.030160458758473396,
0.35713496804237366,
-1.0673589706420898,
-0.0818546786904335,
0.10167711973190308,
-0.06126174330711365,
-0.7190406322479248,
-0.18281105160713196,
-0.6772884130477905,
-0.30025386810302734,
-0.32541605830192566,
0.48114874958992004,
-0.6112845540046692,
-0.009747791104018688,
-0.666454017162323,
0.16192053258419037,
-0.023913228884339333,
0.21910478174686432,
0.17486464977264404,
0.7707630395889282,
0.6233381628990173,
-0.6560396552085876,
0.5944555401802063,
0.5515959858894348,
-0.6523053646087646,
0.641497790813446,
-0.5959336757659912,
0.37057697772979736,
0.03860301151871681,
-0.24525202810764313,
-0.91791832447052,
-0.25003781914711,
0.06611212342977524,
-0.5444009900093079,
0.07251395285129547,
-0.39189255237579346,
-0.202318474650383,
-0.5306764841079712,
0.034969210624694824,
-0.31540632247924805,
0.2489250749349594,
-0.4308835566043854,
0.33566057682037354,
1.131276249885559,
-0.6435171365737915,
-0.6840842962265015,
-0.645269513130188,
0.6186237335205078,
-0.22764208912849426,
-0.5160139203071594,
0.33154764771461487,
0.17361925542354584,
-0.7255455255508423,
0.30080530047416687,
-0.1834472417831421,
-0.08690143376588821,
-0.10637776553630829,
0.42377400398254395,
0.03445877879858017,
-0.15529277920722961,
-0.16246800124645233,
-0.28344061970710754,
-0.34240850806236267,
0.3947935104370117,
-0.0716160386800766,
0.6901407837867737,
-0.3206562399864197,
-0.07056506723165512,
-0.5049512386322021,
0.7389013171195984,
0.1520976573228836,
0.049820832908153534,
0.6104456782341003,
0.3248404562473297,
-0.3251313865184784,
0.0011155116371810436,
-0.2806563973426819,
0.23877951502799988,
-0.4601111114025116,
0.27619004249572754,
0.050929173827171326,
-0.8948403000831604,
0.7244200110435486,
-0.48513907194137573,
0.2100772261619568,
0.8261489272117615,
0.4550558626651764,
0.03662954270839691,
1.0643302202224731,
0.6996004581451416,
-0.7772029042243958,
0.17438802123069763,
-0.23898258805274963,
0.15463459491729736,
-0.6577457785606384,
-0.4264734387397766,
-1.0259170532226562,
-0.2922675311565399,
-0.5264150500297546,
-0.39326798915863037,
-0.1410771608352661,
0.06840988993644714,
0.15925468504428864,
-0.09808431565761566,
-0.9353891611099243,
0.6595810651779175,
0.5449216961860657,
-0.6080526113510132,
0.2533119320869446,
0.2503241300582886,
0.06095629930496216,
-0.19668617844581604,
-0.41604650020599365,
-0.777708113193512,
0.837092936038971,
-0.05394826456904411,
0.9130206108093262,
-0.2102012187242508,
0.41185668110847473,
0.5787090063095093,
0.06197750195860863,
-0.7134402990341187,
0.8239321112632751,
-0.13227570056915283,
-0.49095794558525085,
-0.2535560727119446,
-0.5052899122238159,
-1.254464864730835,
0.2876964211463928,
-0.37911751866340637,
-0.9521347880363464,
0.034516509622335434,
-0.22892165184020996,
-0.2783544063568115,
0.7639483213424683,
-0.3638298809528351,
0.7380973696708679,
-0.03605518862605095,
0.339214950799942,
-0.12038495391607285,
-0.5632758736610413,
0.28956153988838196,
0.6114509701728821,
0.12152475118637085,
-0.2173181027173996,
0.3965224027633667,
1.1510505676269531,
0.14121831953525543,
0.5695086121559143,
-0.11659672111272812,
-0.12132309377193451,
0.7385945916175842,
-0.33562350273132324,
-0.032293062657117844,
0.30379101634025574,
-0.22296613454818726,
0.49441346526145935,
-0.3320746421813965,
-0.023474838584661484,
-0.32812419533729553,
0.842732846736908,
-0.6249886751174927,
-0.7964745163917542,
-0.7593830227851868,
-0.5802680850028992,
-0.12771165370941162,
-0.014276506379246712,
0.26247501373291016,
0.3131655156612396,
-0.8303062319755554,
0.16777154803276062,
0.2454809695482254,
-0.04009952023625374,
0.6593412160873413,
0.04376220703125,
-0.3874468505382538,
-0.4374181926250458,
0.6041735410690308,
0.1067889928817749,
0.06856612861156464,
0.20204927027225494,
0.22472915053367615,
-0.5471149682998657,
-0.661759078502655,
-0.5785101652145386,
-0.11722154170274734,
-0.6221323609352112,
-0.3946988880634308,
-0.5246940851211548,
-0.3667986989021301,
-0.22154486179351807,
0.041798461228609085,
-0.002619213191792369,
-0.6975052952766418,
-0.24285022914409637,
-0.2770727276802063,
0.3994043469429016,
1.0815129280090332,
-0.36328577995300293,
0.6081649661064148,
-0.7226138114929199,
0.7264070510864258,
0.447892427444458,
0.2774849236011505,
-0.5506466627120972,
-0.3663947582244873,
0.16970030963420868,
-0.011262249201536179,
-0.6720151901245117,
-1.1315215826034546,
0.5958608984947205,
0.3346019685268402,
0.6185005307197571,
0.4107903838157654,
-0.1855054646730423,
0.7758597731590271,
-0.4327464997768402,
1.1490172147750854,
0.11336983740329742,
-0.949941098690033,
0.8942096829414368,
-0.37901782989501953,
0.31577998399734497,
0.5378990769386292,
0.24481616914272308,
-0.6119710803031921,
-0.3544164001941681,
-1.035757064819336,
-0.92025226354599,
0.6558628082275391,
0.08002122491598129,
-0.03888224810361862,
-0.17604291439056396,
0.47505122423171997,
-0.23232294619083405,
0.3218460977077484,
-0.6226491332054138,
-0.38955363631248474,
0.14146851003170013,
0.19196844100952148,
-0.0014939720276743174,
-0.4619925320148468,
-0.42224419116973877,
-0.14650912582874298,
0.6635814905166626,
-0.21005640923976898,
0.159340500831604,
0.24465343356132507,
0.36289680004119873,
-0.3145526945590973,
0.7916242480278015,
0.2940616011619568,
0.9958890676498413,
-0.13398543000221252,
0.018169425427913666,
0.09069535881280899,
-0.3167276382446289,
0.05019896849989891,
0.08316449075937271,
-0.2462226301431656,
0.5346490740776062,
0.11280851811170578,
0.5924946665763855,
-0.030775485560297966,
-0.5601329803466797,
-0.01745530590415001,
-0.3718240261077881,
-0.4097667336463928,
-0.18370461463928223,
-0.05307326093316078,
0.40771326422691345,
0.2192048728466034,
0.5323114395141602,
0.10409289598464966,
0.451323539018631,
-1.1977969408035278,
0.5663874745368958,
0.650433361530304,
-0.2628187835216522,
-0.27932944893836975,
0.7476107478141785,
0.19586476683616638,
-0.5351884365081787,
0.7610515356063843,
-0.17345601320266724,
-0.48206761479377747,
0.47729355096817017,
0.5456585884094238,
0.6409209370613098,
-0.3393130898475647,
0.6391997337341309,
0.38499900698661804,
0.17427559196949005,
-0.05427228659391403,
0.6753720045089722,
0.4526658058166504,
-0.3673677146434784,
-0.7805258631706238,
-0.5709085464477539,
-0.6649453639984131,
0.5224210023880005,
-0.9857100248336792,
-0.041270725429058075,
-0.42658767104148865,
-0.35584473609924316,
0.23977485299110413,
0.4085049629211426,
-0.34471166133880615,
0.19409792125225067,
0.4636789858341217,
0.7839621305465698,
-0.9016338586807251,
0.4649381637573242,
0.47063493728637695,
0.01088332012295723,
-0.38215315341949463,
-0.3555878698825836,
0.40472275018692017,
-0.3123018145561218,
0.3223211169242859,
0.1593552976846695,
0.01318767573684454,
-0.41250747442245483,
-0.9057595729827881,
-0.49282944202423096,
0.5118979811668396,
0.4303971529006958,
-0.4934833347797394,
0.04987964779138565,
0.3756255507469177,
0.3940555155277252,
-0.2540544271469116,
-0.22238124907016754,
0.9831663966178894,
0.5968117713928223,
0.06437614560127258,
-0.7665199637413025,
-0.35437220335006714,
-0.40396028757095337,
-0.3576088845729828,
0.4952614903450012,
-0.3375281095504761,
0.8507204055786133,
0.03721935302019119,
-0.4627632796764374,
0.05818380042910576,
1.3269803524017334,
0.04036750644445419,
0.2677749693393707,
0.45261406898498535,
0.7111788392066956,
0.9354448914527893,
-0.454759418964386,
0.820432722568512,
0.13956911861896515,
0.17157720029354095,
0.9883414506912231,
-0.21581706404685974,
0.5740256309509277,
0.508384108543396,
-0.2036738395690918,
0.5040784478187561,
0.40182486176490784,
-0.08265184611082077,
0.4612620174884796,
0.5660691261291504,
-0.30623069405555725,
0.09480155259370804,
-0.3343633711338043,
-0.33761951327323914,
0.8368555903434753,
0.6018509864807129,
0.2056088000535965,
-0.43196672201156616,
-0.4417213499546051,
-0.06573591381311417,
0.4051436185836792,
-0.671851396560669,
0.9940011501312256,
0.3706667721271515,
-0.7014122605323792,
0.09679412096738815,
0.1688397228717804,
0.6556119918823242,
-0.6358144879341125,
-0.4949524402618408,
0.06053406000137329,
0.053705230355262756,
-0.2767690420150757,
-1.093968391418457,
0.7364148497581482,
0.3814176023006439,
-0.010815685614943504,
-0.08617761731147766,
0.7987008094787598,
-0.27864399552345276,
-0.3951346278190613,
0.2845691740512848,
0.4061504900455475,
0.15955014526844025,
-0.19297966361045837,
-1.0330264568328857,
-0.10744080692529678,
0.27130866050720215,
-0.354756623506546,
0.3529822528362274,
0.72212153673172,
0.13543610274791718,
0.5258943438529968,
0.7326149344444275,
0.43676304817199707,
-0.16575853526592255,
0.2615646421909332,
0.8881763815879822,
-1.0180333852767944,
-0.4140005111694336,
-1.101277470588684,
0.4702489674091339,
-0.5525115728378296,
-0.44478553533554077,
0.7902481555938721,
0.6692138910293579,
0.694568932056427,
0.13790297508239746,
0.928702712059021,
-0.2875722348690033,
0.49138012528419495,
-0.7255411744117737,
0.6958194971084595,
-0.17849832773208618,
-0.2989170253276825,
-0.34856513142585754,
-0.5666251182556152,
-0.34918031096458435,
0.8913544416427612,
0.059682030230760574,
-0.49109306931495667,
0.3208359479904175,
0.3481706380844116,
0.1065685823559761,
0.6792110800743103,
0.020202653482556343,
-0.0795731171965599,
0.3749275803565979,
0.22854205965995789,
0.9737746715545654,
-0.09780331701040268,
0.3282482624053955,
-0.12475650757551193,
0.20322182774543762,
0.22319215536117554,
-1.0167640447616577,
-0.8781490325927734,
-0.5286408066749573,
-0.15991777181625366,
-0.21524585783481598,
-0.2596345841884613,
0.6528671979904175,
0.37757664918899536,
-1.1177300214767456,
-0.5947911143302917,
0.049439024180173874,
0.07145534455776215,
0.028949186205863953,
-0.25565043091773987,
0.4931226074695587,
-0.19838277995586395,
-0.8148236274719238,
0.7141463160514832,
0.4197063148021698,
-0.17495191097259521,
-0.11974717676639557,
0.3055957555770874,
-0.7763941884040833,
0.08487620949745178,
0.36572781205177307,
0.6858816146850586,
-0.7051317691802979,
-0.3542775809764862,
-0.4660537838935852,
0.4584224820137024,
0.2383326292037964,
0.9261952042579651,
-0.5460496544837952,
0.49576714634895325,
0.48040077090263367,
0.6204440593719482,
0.19945701956748962,
0.35621175169944763,
0.6553181409835815,
-0.8396924734115601,
0.6179569363594055,
0.23170839250087738,
0.5163047313690186,
0.4738696217536926,
-0.2817455232143402,
1.0114238262176514,
0.04802985116839409,
-0.9610738754272461,
-0.8686175346374512,
0.030118433758616447,
-1.0617382526397705,
-0.09882978349924088,
0.8757734298706055,
0.038288190960884094,
-0.1286608874797821,
-0.5671721696853638,
-0.3862636983394623,
0.22261761128902435,
-0.41536059975624084,
0.7809505462646484,
0.943694531917572,
-0.3995000720024109,
0.18043960630893707,
-1.024362564086914,
0.7499736547470093,
0.17573508620262146,
-1.1579173803329468,
0.04536449909210205,
0.35474303364753723,
-0.10973751544952393,
0.3565272390842438,
0.9067224860191345,
-0.20529577136039734,
-0.2580956220626831,
-0.14563478529453278,
0.16873091459274292,
0.46843281388282776,
-0.4169759452342987,
-0.291569322347641,
0.35332876443862915,
-0.42881640791893005,
-0.12461089342832565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13551v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13551v1 | Mitigating Social Biases in Language Models through Unlearning | 2024-06-19T13:38:34 | 2024-06-19T13:38:34 | Omkar Dige, Diljot Singh, Tsz Fung Yau, Qixuan Zhang, Borna Bolandraftar, Xiaodan Zhu, Faiza Khan Khattak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Mitigating bias in language models (LMs) has become a critical problem due to
the widespread deployment of LMs. Numerous approaches revolve around data
pre-processing and fine-tuning of language models, tasks that can be both
time-consuming and computationally demanding. Consequently, there is a growing
interest in machine unlearning techniques given their capacity to induce the
forgetting of undesired behaviors of the existing pre-trained or fine-tuned
models with lower computational cost. In this work, we explore two unlearning
methods, (1) Partitioned Contrastive Gradient Unlearning (PCGU) applied on
decoder models and (2) Negation via Task Vector, to reduce social biases in
state-of-the-art and open-source LMs such as LLaMA-2 and OPT. We also implement
distributed PCGU for large models. It is empirically shown, through
quantitative and qualitative analyses, that negation via Task Vector method
outperforms PCGU in debiasing with minimum deterioration in performance and
perplexity of the models. On LLaMA-27B, negation via Task Vector reduces the
bias score by 11.8% | [
-0.3700000047683716,
-0.8964167833328247,
0.1555500030517578,
0.21107417345046997,
-0.5149950981140137,
0.2781103253364563,
-0.4271242320537567,
-0.00990093033760786,
0.016059130430221558,
0.6201359033584595,
-0.5314900875091553,
-0.6786321401596069,
-0.531852662563324,
-0.275495707988739,
-0.2591618597507477,
0.9189352989196777,
0.047955311834812164,
0.34484246373176575,
-0.40939122438430786,
-0.21793891489505768,
-0.40793654322624207,
-0.5304158926010132,
-0.5959150791168213,
-0.8342355489730835,
0.3815701901912689,
0.5500611662864685,
0.4745587408542633,
0.410126268863678,
0.1496996283531189,
0.24745382368564606,
-0.2933714985847473,
0.2503605782985687,
-0.9624471664428711,
0.10402166843414307,
-0.10462377220392227,
-0.5589792132377625,
-0.13972318172454834,
-0.0305075291544199,
0.4287218153476715,
0.9101178646087646,
-0.207197904586792,
0.3813475966453552,
0.6245703101158142,
1.005932092666626,
-0.9947347044944763,
0.2653604745864868,
-0.6606836318969727,
0.1431216448545456,
-0.10526319593191147,
-0.017267387360334396,
-0.41213324666023254,
-0.38370293378829956,
-0.18107321858406067,
-0.5591067671775818,
0.17662249505519867,
-0.39514368772506714,
0.35450100898742676,
0.5076265931129456,
-0.2752513289451599,
0.10791991651058197,
-0.7773464322090149,
1.132542371749878,
-0.6964358687400818,
0.18606579303741455,
0.6004454493522644,
0.1769469976425171,
-0.22784751653671265,
-0.22374868392944336,
-0.4498419463634491,
0.2061677724123001,
0.014940406195819378,
0.03895195573568344,
-0.37521547079086304,
-0.02451489306986332,
0.09224425256252289,
-0.015362122096121311,
-0.2869162857532501,
0.5333033800125122,
-0.34421980381011963,
-0.13455919921398163,
0.4185061752796173,
0.013099067844450474,
0.07108340412378311,
-0.14815449714660645,
-0.23217132687568665,
0.011143382638692856,
-0.9867706894874573,
-0.08188609778881073,
0.47413429617881775,
0.28693056106567383,
-0.18106864392757416,
0.4361957311630249,
-0.2991713583469391,
0.1551559418439865,
0.09936962276697159,
0.030860254541039467,
0.5720818042755127,
-0.08128661662340164,
-0.2810590863227844,
-0.08296696096658707,
0.7854216694831848,
0.517068088054657,
0.6129959225654602,
-0.13851961493492126,
-0.06271643936634064,
0.5086562037467957,
-0.07361006736755371,
-0.6411163806915283,
0.04069078713655472,
-0.0028063945937901735,
-0.8731842637062073,
-0.3811119794845581,
-0.4808497726917267,
-0.9346825480461121,
-0.7015380263328552,
-0.4713824689388275,
0.3379177451133728,
-0.17913289368152618,
-0.2868077754974365,
-0.09380685538053513,
0.004441522061824799,
0.23804306983947754,
0.4378301203250885,
-0.5638945698738098,
0.34238842129707336,
0.619655966758728,
0.654942512512207,
-0.0882999524474144,
-0.17892765998840332,
-0.5868698954582214,
-0.052499521523714066,
-0.2795288860797882,
0.5374886393547058,
-0.7457274794578552,
-0.5273005962371826,
-0.0025184829719364643,
-0.08384646475315094,
0.059621840715408325,
-0.7561803460121155,
0.461887001991272,
-0.3457185924053192,
0.24779513478279114,
-0.4771653413772583,
-0.41356372833251953,
-0.2759527564048767,
-0.013279038481414318,
-0.3238934576511383,
1.0303622484207153,
-0.17793257534503937,
-0.8629248142242432,
0.19231487810611725,
-0.2207847386598587,
-0.5427000522613525,
-0.1137835904955864,
-0.30207064747810364,
-0.4985014796257019,
0.2567015588283539,
0.43172764778137207,
0.5338833928108215,
-0.3466426134109497,
0.4889506995677948,
-0.49267280101776123,
-0.7070126533508301,
-0.1442144811153412,
-0.49698707461357117,
0.9624066948890686,
0.2679048180580139,
-0.6026639342308044,
0.21256928145885468,
-0.6667175889015198,
-0.3496319353580475,
0.20025242865085602,
-0.21018075942993164,
-0.6978557705879211,
0.2659386098384857,
-0.23256759345531464,
0.1295810043811798,
0.1368984580039978,
-0.6182275414466858,
-0.20473666489124298,
-0.2209344208240509,
0.4451669156551361,
1.0426325798034668,
-0.30926743149757385,
0.6987993717193604,
-0.20801277458667755,
0.3907109200954437,
0.18699467182159424,
0.2418685406446457,
0.049637772142887115,
-0.3362393081188202,
-0.9638022184371948,
-0.1215004250407219,
0.07815435528755188,
0.584860622882843,
-0.8275741934776306,
0.14248047769069672,
0.16544072329998016,
-0.5578554272651672,
-0.6899737119674683,
0.3577546775341034,
0.6791759133338928,
0.5474166870117188,
0.35074472427368164,
-0.10850909352302551,
-0.5393092036247253,
-0.8750467896461487,
-0.30761927366256714,
0.04803203046321869,
-0.1287771612405777,
0.32125794887542725,
0.3277056813240051,
-0.5184590220451355,
0.5323551893234253,
-0.34506386518478394,
-0.36095285415649414,
-0.2463660091161728,
-0.020559540018439293,
0.07027914375066757,
0.41624149680137634,
0.3093879520893097,
-0.520049512386322,
-0.35638362169265747,
-0.22198298573493958,
-0.6788590550422668,
-0.3211763799190521,
0.29238951206207275,
-0.03126470744609833,
0.3788096606731415,
0.674228310585022,
-0.38211482763290405,
0.6294041275978088,
0.6187178492546082,
-0.00935050006955862,
0.3173370063304901,
-0.3421052396297455,
-0.2510524392127991,
-0.9331510066986084,
-0.044680479913949966,
0.059800390154123306,
-0.1634272187948227,
-0.6548705697059631,
-0.26961249113082886,
-0.0840834453701973,
0.03453286364674568,
-0.4203172028064728,
0.34820032119750977,
-0.6404263973236084,
0.011934857815504074,
-0.5078606605529785,
0.18417541682720184,
-0.11964469403028488,
0.6976406574249268,
-0.12508605420589447,
0.46311527490615845,
0.4758518636226654,
-0.6709110736846924,
-0.13382954895496368,
0.12708713114261627,
-0.2761041820049286,
0.24709828197956085,
-0.6623303890228271,
0.2348405420780182,
-0.7215752601623535,
0.18598072230815887,
-0.9151237607002258,
0.4298003017902374,
0.21390214562416077,
-0.3446061313152313,
0.19037671387195587,
-0.1836864948272705,
-0.2903849184513092,
0.09314201772212982,
-0.39368757605552673,
0.49259597063064575,
0.806243896484375,
-0.7179415225982666,
0.2788127660751343,
0.7445259690284729,
0.016292942687869072,
-0.8829649090766907,
-0.695087194442749,
-0.2823909521102905,
-0.24658595025539398,
-0.15268731117248535,
0.38544657826423645,
0.026144469156861305,
-0.4229346811771393,
0.023487349972128868,
-0.040456756949424744,
0.16917945444583893,
0.1019798219203949,
0.38870102167129517,
0.15284907817840576,
0.14765958487987518,
0.015413046814501286,
0.12089704722166061,
-0.18695183098316193,
0.04248449578881264,
-0.0318138524889946,
0.7407654523849487,
0.15558965504169464,
-0.41851821541786194,
-0.07098042219877243,
0.29284438490867615,
0.49280276894569397,
-0.3680119812488556,
0.8849667310714722,
0.615415632724762,
-0.5003599524497986,
-0.5081750154495239,
-0.6371980905532837,
-0.19671182334423065,
-0.46504512429237366,
0.33338305354118347,
0.20394490659236908,
-1.1677378416061401,
0.6109920740127563,
-0.1243642196059227,
-0.04532663896679878,
0.0760335922241211,
0.7263121008872986,
0.07215077430009842,
1.0373315811157227,
0.7113536596298218,
-0.5567708611488342,
0.5590443015098572,
-0.09871578216552734,
0.26132580637931824,
-0.9003887176513672,
-0.3416590392589569,
-0.5565311312675476,
-0.3293112516403198,
-0.8624958992004395,
-0.7016099095344543,
0.3029557168483734,
0.2414233237504959,
-0.28134885430336,
-0.12870369851589203,
-0.39038389921188354,
0.7022606134414673,
0.7205027341842651,
0.3409809172153473,
0.11556274443864822,
0.2524223029613495,
-0.3347786068916321,
0.1367271989583969,
-0.6607484817504883,
-0.5123420357704163,
1.3281670808792114,
0.27919936180114746,
0.76774662733078,
-0.16756322979927063,
0.7160258293151855,
0.15583820641040802,
0.21928365528583527,
-0.4122704267501831,
0.6612298488616943,
-0.4446033835411072,
-0.4132026135921478,
-0.3674210011959076,
-0.603535532951355,
-0.8166385293006897,
0.6508587002754211,
-0.25990405678749084,
-0.7090324759483337,
0.33148863911628723,
0.30791175365448,
-0.04314873367547989,
0.35575324296951294,
-0.5625783801078796,
0.7269091606140137,
0.09877065569162369,
-0.6066029071807861,
-0.5657715201377869,
-0.4700578451156616,
0.3409439027309418,
-0.05076208338141441,
0.41724297404289246,
-0.2643912732601166,
0.2520519196987152,
0.7792921662330627,
-0.42189306020736694,
1.2785569429397583,
-0.3961459696292877,
0.10037785768508911,
0.15638603270053864,
-0.04090634360909462,
0.652184009552002,
-0.18399111926555634,
-0.15893344581127167,
0.4085998833179474,
-0.34784069657325745,
-0.5071260333061218,
-0.2644369900226593,
0.7519751787185669,
-0.8045846223831177,
-0.4709009528160095,
-0.13590562343597412,
-0.3546951115131378,
-0.17811144888401031,
0.17470717430114746,
0.25017523765563965,
0.23441937565803528,
-0.2846125066280365,
0.2012397050857544,
0.8438593745231628,
-0.7224836945533752,
0.5297428369522095,
0.5824753046035767,
0.03199639543890953,
-0.2814251482486725,
0.8410930037498474,
0.01717986725270748,
0.21352602541446686,
0.3695942759513855,
0.35760217905044556,
-0.07148585468530655,
-0.5409018397331238,
-0.03898988664150238,
0.32054367661476135,
-0.7824960350990295,
-0.11066318303346634,
-0.49483996629714966,
0.12039995938539505,
-0.4056282341480255,
-0.07453807443380356,
-0.30321115255355835,
-0.23867014050483704,
-0.523667573928833,
-0.17363859713077545,
0.0937008410692215,
0.7189456224441528,
-0.12612442672252655,
0.30791613459587097,
-0.40875574946403503,
0.28217825293540955,
0.029622195288538933,
0.3699595034122467,
0.3385148048400879,
-0.3780474364757538,
-0.06789831072092056,
0.2102840691804886,
-0.19219538569450378,
-0.7948141694068909,
0.5264442563056946,
-0.09629981219768524,
0.6604131460189819,
0.5588232278823853,
0.24363939464092255,
0.6009705662727356,
-0.570678174495697,
0.3869156837463379,
0.13962730765342712,
-0.9538480639457703,
0.3263482451438904,
-0.42284008860588074,
0.32193154096603394,
0.5112073421478271,
0.29927772283554077,
-0.5183278322219849,
-0.2817024290561676,
-0.21646250784397125,
-0.9218060374259949,
0.552548885345459,
-0.04538407549262047,
0.13566456735134125,
-0.028803668916225433,
0.18950611352920532,
0.21959002315998077,
0.41624727845191956,
-0.5671645998954773,
-0.5186141133308411,
-0.16041651368141174,
-0.1068023219704628,
-0.5432903170585632,
-0.5793960690498352,
0.18726812303066254,
-0.29685649275779724,
0.7436482906341553,
0.03768092766404152,
-0.09556620568037033,
-0.11354982107877731,
-0.3433987498283386,
-0.13129407167434692,
0.4273780882358551,
0.4113905429840088,
0.5262088179588318,
-0.06646175682544708,
0.2135048508644104,
0.20449914038181305,
-0.30400198698043823,
0.0779619961977005,
-0.024805204942822456,
-0.6428432464599609,
-0.1139378473162651,
-0.0252971388399601,
0.8293854594230652,
0.22710002958774567,
-0.4198344349861145,
0.4251910150051117,
0.048001423478126526,
-0.11358031630516052,
-0.16984903812408447,
-0.16188085079193115,
0.22245797514915466,
0.17113590240478516,
0.004220503382384777,
-0.1723974198102951,
-0.0005185636109672487,
-0.40027013421058655,
-0.1992291510105133,
0.6967950463294983,
-0.4393972158432007,
-0.1308751255273819,
0.6395906209945679,
0.38318899273872375,
-0.11287976801395416,
0.5447745323181152,
-0.128694549202919,
-0.5233367681503296,
0.4402160942554474,
0.6186484098434448,
0.8167849779129028,
-0.3841225206851959,
0.45786142349243164,
0.041838373988866806,
0.5198264122009277,
-0.14019061625003815,
0.1789238154888153,
-0.223678320646286,
-0.892131507396698,
-0.6075906157493591,
-0.6140227317810059,
-0.34515607357025146,
0.33620068430900574,
-0.6545021533966064,
-0.05505528301000595,
-0.35046008229255676,
0.02240007184445858,
-0.26452529430389404,
-0.050730057060718536,
-0.615044891834259,
-0.017504392191767693,
0.15723693370819092,
0.5417686700820923,
-0.961631715297699,
0.7417281866073608,
0.5660006999969482,
-0.10993360728025436,
-0.6062120795249939,
-0.22170479595661163,
0.15811669826507568,
-0.8762011528015137,
0.6463983654975891,
0.16736933588981628,
-0.1946117877960205,
-0.17780844867229462,
-0.33055955171585083,
-0.6076825261116028,
0.707034707069397,
0.6382772922515869,
-0.6805182099342346,
0.38401514291763306,
0.4052252769470215,
0.39915066957473755,
-0.14506341516971588,
0.29221707582473755,
0.4478820264339447,
0.1688316911458969,
-0.24787786602973938,
-0.753643810749054,
0.15327055752277374,
-0.2585800290107727,
0.0019349916838109493,
0.2538606524467468,
-0.5889811515808105,
0.9533764123916626,
-0.20807914435863495,
-0.10864333063364029,
-0.5291774868965149,
0.31181421875953674,
0.1905241161584854,
0.370739221572876,
0.6326613426208496,
0.4986453056335449,
0.8790775537490845,
0.13432671129703522,
0.5862310528755188,
0.06596139818429947,
0.10918960720300674,
0.9738008975982666,
-0.5219533443450928,
0.6062671542167664,
0.49313288927078247,
0.05173993483185768,
0.34464359283447266,
0.41364938020706177,
0.3442745804786682,
0.5571549534797668,
0.521290123462677,
-0.26494699716567993,
-0.21726416051387787,
-0.2521640360355377,
-0.07635224610567093,
0.4665681719779968,
0.14941918849945068,
-0.29243937134742737,
-0.3828238248825073,
0.09242081642150879,
0.4431406855583191,
0.38409364223480225,
-0.6008898615837097,
0.7830057144165039,
0.25461816787719727,
-0.5448187589645386,
0.5911279320716858,
0.023279204964637756,
0.8773676753044128,
-0.3406575322151184,
-0.030103154480457306,
-0.6151353120803833,
0.5729613900184631,
-0.2299441397190094,
-0.1145392656326294,
0.07710795849561691,
0.18538130819797516,
-0.3097675144672394,
-0.3339950144290924,
0.8750457763671875,
-0.531920850276947,
-0.43064084649086,
0.6850613355636597,
0.5439645051956177,
-0.07155334204435349,
-0.1872074156999588,
-0.6445878744125366,
0.10487455874681473,
0.1276993602514267,
-0.19716714322566986,
0.6746469736099243,
0.10899116098880768,
-0.23877494037151337,
0.9139325618743896,
0.6143758893013,
0.03429784998297691,
-0.07374531775712967,
0.4745887815952301,
0.9691553711891174,
-0.4026472568511963,
-0.4206596910953522,
-1.0548315048217773,
0.2143343836069107,
0.007057332433760166,
0.06550542265176773,
0.9721422791481018,
0.3819153606891632,
1.1160794496536255,
0.13022756576538086,
0.8974331021308899,
0.6019654870033264,
0.5527575612068176,
-0.34752848744392395,
0.7952196002006531,
-0.3750487267971039,
0.4667518734931946,
-0.5076891183853149,
-0.7381054162979126,
-0.13590237498283386,
0.4364416301250458,
-0.30123692750930786,
0.10157123953104019,
0.36760661005973816,
0.8068391680717468,
0.10197105258703232,
-0.058189377188682556,
0.23699921369552612,
0.08759930729866028,
0.14921730756759644,
0.5769966244697571,
0.6932563781738281,
-0.022389641031622887,
0.3706915080547333,
-0.4574272036552429,
-0.5047013163566589,
-0.05323752388358116,
-0.9306390285491943,
-1.308638334274292,
-0.1538427472114563,
-0.2820330560207367,
-0.2105887234210968,
0.392055869102478,
0.7415581345558167,
0.5029972791671753,
-0.8118302822113037,
-0.49358540773391724,
-0.08180801570415497,
0.4066472053527832,
0.007026326842606068,
-0.12087391316890717,
0.3507438898086548,
-0.26487430930137634,
-0.47795408964157104,
0.35281258821487427,
0.06443319469690323,
-0.22727063298225403,
-0.32037442922592163,
-0.1432560831308365,
-0.012655224651098251,
-0.06119920313358307,
0.6093820929527283,
0.16222867369651794,
-0.47776445746421814,
0.08471118658781052,
-0.12977947294712067,
0.24998602271080017,
-0.14673729240894318,
0.6580578088760376,
-0.9996303915977478,
0.1756039708852768,
0.5553329586982727,
0.5411460399627686,
0.51052325963974,
0.04263637959957123,
0.6399431824684143,
-0.6550648212432861,
0.25614485144615173,
-0.09637179970741272,
0.48321273922920227,
0.446122407913208,
-0.1859801709651947,
0.24873030185699463,
0.061063047498464584,
-0.5560135245323181,
-1.0052164793014526,
0.2866215705871582,
-0.2909032702445984,
-0.6136861443519592,
1.2065887451171875,
0.1094747856259346,
-0.2775235176086426,
-0.019254298880696297,
-0.029294855892658234,
0.5931506752967834,
-0.3571895360946655,
0.7608826160430908,
0.307188481092453,
0.2926461100578308,
-0.048101965337991714,
-0.373871773481369,
0.5096814036369324,
0.6360647082328796,
-0.6725035905838013,
0.3771457076072693,
0.4859920144081116,
0.34393447637557983,
-0.3207356631755829,
0.7048037648200989,
-0.08280320465564728,
-0.06904927641153336,
-0.33137616515159607,
0.263327956199646,
-0.1867123395204544,
-0.08116751164197922,
-0.6270182132720947,
0.016863567754626274,
-0.2060273289680481,
-0.4234887361526489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13542v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13542v1 | Self-play with Execution Feedback: Improving Instruction-following Capabilities of Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T13:29:53 | 2024-06-19T13:29:53 | Guanting Dong, Keming Lu, Chengpeng Li, Tingyu Xia, Bowen Yu, Chang Zhou, Jingren Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | One core capability of large language models (LLMs) is to follow natural
language instructions. However, the issue of automatically constructing
high-quality training data to enhance the complex instruction-following
abilities of LLMs without manual annotation remains unresolved. In this paper,
we introduce AutoIF, the first scalable and reliable method for automatically
generating instruction-following training data. AutoIF transforms the
validation of instruction-following data quality into code verification,
requiring LLMs to generate instructions, the corresponding code to check the
correctness of the instruction responses, and unit test samples to verify the
code's correctness. Then, execution feedback-based rejection sampling can
generate data for Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning from
Human Feedback (RLHF) training. AutoIF achieves significant improvements across
three training algorithms, SFT, Offline DPO, and Online DPO, when applied to
the top open-source LLMs, Qwen2 and LLaMA3, in self-alignment and
strong-to-weak distillation settings. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/QwenLM/AutoIF. | [
-0.16840186715126038,
-0.5452836751937866,
0.3249064087867737,
0.5036298632621765,
0.03563069924712181,
0.10730509459972382,
-0.09251096099615097,
-0.0789574459195137,
-0.04238971322774887,
0.6545443534851074,
-0.7135576009750366,
-0.5348257422447205,
-0.4090481102466583,
0.16500990092754364,
-0.55594402551651,
0.7675931453704834,
-0.28625649213790894,
-0.10486597567796707,
-0.21670737862586975,
-0.07934482395648956,
-0.3495514392852783,
-0.4311490058898926,
-0.447345495223999,
-0.20108382403850555,
0.20727935433387756,
0.610969603061676,
0.33508720993995667,
1.0620102882385254,
0.3677728772163391,
0.4213014245033264,
0.6877351999282837,
0.45774781703948975,
-0.5422198176383972,
0.16871359944343567,
0.16826938092708588,
-0.26796016097068787,
-0.4347648322582245,
-0.006160031072795391,
0.7661568522453308,
0.10626403242349625,
-0.4386277496814728,
0.14838452637195587,
0.20815211534500122,
0.7433096170425415,
-0.3551699221134186,
0.2657349109649658,
-0.2745724320411682,
0.014092965051531792,
0.20328617095947266,
-0.27972865104675293,
-0.5498350858688354,
-0.5529546141624451,
-0.11114952713251114,
-0.41772764921188354,
-0.053780168294906616,
0.12849408388137817,
0.6773170232772827,
0.8291520476341248,
-0.21046267449855804,
-0.4733600318431854,
-0.7570831179618835,
0.41204339265823364,
-0.9825375080108643,
0.3289698362350464,
0.6337592601776123,
0.30178511142730713,
-0.47187286615371704,
-0.4777712821960449,
-0.44176164269447327,
-0.42504093050956726,
-0.26182225346565247,
0.05993538722395897,
0.04687130078673363,
0.08862226456403732,
0.22397033870220184,
0.3867020010948181,
-0.44555503129959106,
0.16728456318378448,
-0.1926400363445282,
-0.0759735032916069,
0.8263317346572876,
0.0953102558851242,
0.2643028199672699,
0.03141339123249054,
-0.17214751243591309,
-0.17381837964057922,
-0.8688223361968994,
0.03722700849175453,
0.6056538224220276,
0.026308724656701088,
-0.06786934286355972,
0.3162267506122589,
-0.48675867915153503,
0.7721366286277771,
0.5289744138717651,
-0.11762126535177231,
0.2221771776676178,
-0.3170654773712158,
-0.27500948309898376,
-0.02058430016040802,
0.9768309593200684,
0.1772293895483017,
0.1157679334282875,
-0.17079336941242218,
-0.46486806869506836,
-0.48349159955978394,
0.2214352786540985,
-1.016815423965454,
-0.5285133719444275,
0.07697275280952454,
-0.3485282361507416,
-0.4080720841884613,
0.10749982297420502,
-0.41281619668006897,
-0.036187347024679184,
-0.4363082945346832,
0.46108129620552063,
-0.3894459903240204,
-0.05209384858608246,
-0.24524523317813873,
0.3507876396179199,
0.31900039315223694,
0.22872094810009003,
-1.0500882863998413,
0.3002578020095825,
0.38125181198120117,
0.45268821716308594,
-0.2969086170196533,
-0.581239640712738,
-1.030559778213501,
0.26145392656326294,
-0.4695339798927307,
0.7697228789329529,
-0.24929271638393402,
-0.3282201588153839,
-0.19301359355449677,
0.1430807113647461,
0.0019067830871790648,
-0.5805003046989441,
-0.04277294874191284,
-0.3034665584564209,
0.13151943683624268,
-0.1576322466135025,
-0.8163175582885742,
-0.035092759877443314,
0.0995345339179039,
-0.4958874583244324,
1.229782223701477,
0.19846895337104797,
-0.24182461202144623,
0.3123394846916199,
-0.47301986813545227,
-0.6961272358894348,
0.017232948914170265,
-0.40745022892951965,
-0.3909881114959717,
0.030540376901626587,
0.3569960594177246,
0.3038835823535919,
0.03609832003712654,
0.11625517904758453,
-0.25520750880241394,
-0.35794124007225037,
-0.12542611360549927,
-0.5078377723693848,
0.33062824606895447,
-0.12071041017770767,
-0.8490408658981323,
0.06906487047672272,
-0.9907763004302979,
0.2660074830055237,
0.013020949438214302,
-0.468019038438797,
0.20736943185329437,
0.2371642291545868,
-0.4664895236492157,
0.14718806743621826,
0.04447529464960098,
-0.4176260828971863,
0.3881731331348419,
-0.37601330876350403,
0.31087589263916016,
0.66728675365448,
0.09400881826877594,
0.31902220845222473,
-0.12321530282497406,
0.6035801768302917,
-0.48584243655204773,
0.21573634445667267,
-0.4380800127983093,
-0.004354482050985098,
-0.6900383234024048,
-0.3430533707141876,
0.32603970170021057,
0.6514962911605835,
-0.8508838415145874,
0.572632372379303,
0.21891383826732635,
-0.4366931915283203,
-0.5969085097312927,
0.6883098483085632,
0.5500591993331909,
0.5468431115150452,
0.32138076424598694,
-0.1568787842988968,
-0.5492143630981445,
-0.7025270462036133,
0.16368763148784637,
-0.45132359862327576,
0.24939550459384918,
0.3104264438152313,
0.1991315484046936,
-0.3674120306968689,
0.8963912129402161,
-0.2910420000553131,
-0.3718644976615906,
-0.03798368573188782,
0.4683976471424103,
-0.11960085481405258,
0.616640567779541,
0.5328813195228577,
-0.19441024959087372,
-0.5140774250030518,
-0.23984675109386444,
-0.5949583649635315,
-0.43435996770858765,
-0.11227592825889587,
-0.20028182864189148,
0.35980769991874695,
0.6171367168426514,
-0.04889640584588051,
0.41813579201698303,
0.7992777228355408,
-0.03009893372654915,
0.364248126745224,
-0.5018767714500427,
0.5051460266113281,
-0.7212609648704529,
0.015553164295852184,
-0.36259740591049194,
-0.5008057951927185,
-0.28519654273986816,
-0.1330379694700241,
0.12332066148519516,
0.2588745355606079,
-0.22057758271694183,
0.2644427716732025,
-0.5204982757568359,
-0.1625155508518219,
-0.5989545583724976,
-0.26109030842781067,
-0.03785748779773712,
0.43713271617889404,
0.14851291477680206,
1.036588191986084,
0.4684129059314728,
-0.7372560501098633,
0.4904805123806,
0.20878489315509796,
-0.17103193700313568,
0.24848106503486633,
-0.7798051834106445,
0.17876587808132172,
0.047855526208877563,
0.3677230477333069,
-1.135331153869629,
-0.49747124314308167,
0.25680607557296753,
-0.258058100938797,
0.4881249964237213,
-0.41251710057258606,
-0.7057421803474426,
-0.48851656913757324,
-0.028463663533329964,
0.12400879710912704,
0.6262347102165222,
-0.7260861396789551,
0.5032762289047241,
0.28186118602752686,
0.04089754819869995,
-0.48676803708076477,
-0.673800528049469,
-0.0744987428188324,
0.3309747874736786,
-0.15641170740127563,
0.050400372594594955,
-0.35103338956832886,
0.20932637155056,
-0.19608525931835175,
-0.027491094544529915,
-0.07061884552240372,
0.2277446836233139,
0.3111763298511505,
0.2550640404224396,
-0.021008487790822983,
0.08759372681379318,
0.1354028582572937,
-0.11936960369348526,
0.18573932349681854,
-0.23348061740398407,
0.18986907601356506,
-0.08123265206813812,
-0.6182543039321899,
-0.7477735280990601,
0.041037172079086304,
0.3627971410751343,
-0.35469433665275574,
0.19109883904457092,
0.5755172371864319,
-0.09399545937776566,
-0.5552971363067627,
-0.5613394975662231,
-0.23510317504405975,
-0.52458655834198,
0.11695081740617752,
0.0044539314694702625,
-0.7411718368530273,
0.08491027355194092,
0.049571603536605835,
0.4443565607070923,
0.3348940908908844,
0.6147637963294983,
-0.39356130361557007,
1.129757285118103,
0.6577537059783936,
-0.03687058389186859,
0.47464701533317566,
-0.26565802097320557,
0.007530437782406807,
-0.5211771726608276,
0.016324898228049278,
-0.17363698780536652,
-0.12916940450668335,
-0.485463410615921,
-0.384271502494812,
0.09332000464200974,
0.0495087094604969,
-0.03445104882121086,
0.5342771410942078,
-0.6244670152664185,
0.5045467615127563,
0.5649509429931641,
-0.15347450971603394,
0.15290707349777222,
-0.19130612909793854,
-0.027016881853342056,
0.2507878839969635,
-0.6900927424430847,
-0.399966299533844,
0.9182215332984924,
0.44712722301483154,
1.1857004165649414,
-0.08882173895835876,
1.2857446670532227,
0.3569270670413971,
0.7624935507774353,
-0.5231348872184753,
0.3259313404560089,
-0.08008511364459991,
-0.3130750358104706,
-0.44444581866264343,
-0.662348747253418,
-0.38828375935554504,
-0.23064470291137695,
0.02369765192270279,
-0.33118271827697754,
-0.03091002255678177,
0.8441540598869324,
-0.7494558095932007,
0.051228296011686325,
-0.7606488466262817,
0.6173207759857178,
-0.6527306437492371,
-0.312500536441803,
0.005672698840498924,
-0.38506415486335754,
0.2412356287240982,
0.07651390135288239,
0.10269491374492645,
-0.10772714763879776,
0.05077684670686722,
0.4478960931301117,
-0.5264253616333008,
0.8693292140960693,
-0.23556175827980042,
-0.4790644943714142,
0.640684187412262,
0.31420859694480896,
0.6681787371635437,
0.03690211847424507,
0.0989324077963829,
-0.2203095257282257,
0.02657749131321907,
-0.11246234178543091,
-0.672907829284668,
0.7977427840232849,
-0.6729056239128113,
-0.6400798559188843,
-0.16724805533885956,
-0.28415587544441223,
-0.1605934351682663,
0.28857994079589844,
0.15784570574760437,
0.6235579252243042,
-0.15910084545612335,
0.06899438798427582,
0.7415852546691895,
-0.05906057357788086,
0.5526590943336487,
0.6231287121772766,
-0.35589921474456787,
-0.6296162009239197,
1.0974682569503784,
0.16906902194023132,
0.23093515634536743,
0.344184011220932,
0.04479963704943657,
-0.2556781470775604,
-0.49956950545310974,
-1.094605803489685,
0.09643004089593887,
-0.5593457221984863,
-0.40261006355285645,
-0.49640920758247375,
-0.21184088289737701,
-0.4416389465332031,
0.1942366063594818,
-0.5494869351387024,
-0.13096487522125244,
-0.3068564832210541,
-0.06415136903524399,
0.2582198679447174,
1.2035337686538696,
-0.16818642616271973,
0.26130881905555725,
-0.9534189105033875,
0.12648962438106537,
0.47630152106285095,
0.6408459544181824,
-0.08406297117471695,
-0.6249918341636658,
-0.31531447172164917,
-0.05441213399171829,
-0.14883902668952942,
-0.6989338994026184,
0.26543688774108887,
0.42984500527381897,
0.6577789783477783,
0.29334378242492676,
0.028488511219620705,
0.5666841268539429,
-0.7697083353996277,
0.44405004382133484,
-0.10084807127714157,
-0.828510046005249,
0.5624426007270813,
-0.12171714752912521,
0.29929402470588684,
0.7664526104927063,
0.24698805809020996,
0.007215579971671104,
-0.46435290575027466,
-0.37938007712364197,
-0.6299771070480347,
0.7126181721687317,
0.13974417746067047,
0.047366250306367874,
-0.21248430013656616,
0.5500085949897766,
0.13281463086605072,
0.27620798349380493,
-0.4870903491973877,
-0.3355776071548462,
-0.2706890106201172,
-0.5662338137626648,
0.062252163887023926,
-0.031608596444129944,
0.05808742344379425,
-0.1868150681257248,
0.888444185256958,
-0.5024910569190979,
0.22332075238227844,
0.3380211293697357,
-0.31079724431037903,
-0.43400394916534424,
-0.22719688713550568,
0.4761659801006317,
0.5584693551063538,
-0.07604856789112091,
-0.03543660044670105,
0.1900288462638855,
-0.2276206761598587,
0.3374202847480774,
0.15626756846904755,
-0.14020903408527374,
-0.21418613195419312,
0.35815098881721497,
0.6812527179718018,
0.293592631816864,
-0.682505190372467,
0.4424496293067932,
-0.3003195524215698,
-0.316531240940094,
-0.41186240315437317,
0.6283106207847595,
-0.021328885108232498,
0.19283457100391388,
0.2142324000597,
-0.36300039291381836,
0.31969383358955383,
-0.442437082529068,
0.6433607339859009,
0.23972466588020325,
-0.36624789237976074,
-0.2828580439090729,
0.4953223168849945,
0.2728213667869568,
-0.2817268371582031,
0.5304793119430542,
-0.4466509521007538,
-0.5392160415649414,
0.5916139483451843,
0.39222508668899536,
0.7495782375335693,
-0.3857458829879761,
0.2864142656326294,
0.515928328037262,
0.31254854798316956,
-0.16223613917827606,
0.18436568975448608,
-0.34032100439071655,
-0.1417282223701477,
-0.6143158078193665,
-0.5341026782989502,
-0.48475536704063416,
-0.12005376815795898,
-0.5932492613792419,
0.15931981801986694,
-0.6355150938034058,
0.12149055302143097,
-0.3540126383304596,
-0.0708075612783432,
-0.5895141363143921,
0.23927123844623566,
0.318970263004303,
0.7901527881622314,
-0.49240025877952576,
0.9503461122512817,
0.44000524282455444,
-0.3453505337238312,
-0.9321660995483398,
0.18001443147659302,
-0.09162446856498718,
-0.8303566575050354,
0.6695495843887329,
0.2648409903049469,
-0.3200938403606415,
0.29222145676612854,
-0.6203330159187317,
-1.126333236694336,
1.160243272781372,
0.18700525164604187,
-0.8671504855155945,
0.017083311453461647,
-0.04627829045057297,
0.5345495343208313,
-0.5823099613189697,
0.48445841670036316,
0.6326054930686951,
0.26037296652793884,
0.24205628037452698,
-0.6633042693138123,
-0.026866218075156212,
0.012131993658840656,
-0.21906732022762299,
0.17814986407756805,
-0.8311780095100403,
0.2517780661582947,
-0.23517034947872162,
-0.08735337853431702,
0.06929866969585419,
1.000707983970642,
-0.06624557077884674,
-0.10017693787813187,
0.6629230976104736,
0.5874123573303223,
0.5693203210830688,
0.13264776766300201,
0.8914194107055664,
-0.6381896138191223,
0.25387850403785706,
1.5861570835113525,
-0.3585297763347626,
0.8502870202064514,
0.12168043851852417,
0.049863897264003754,
0.6471537351608276,
0.5102543830871582,
-0.23213666677474976,
0.48407652974128723,
0.3133400082588196,
0.21495510637760162,
-0.1324295550584793,
0.38806310296058655,
-0.00015535973943769932,
0.4207553565502167,
0.12473966926336288,
-0.36241835355758667,
-0.1739211082458496,
-0.15262189507484436,
-0.2085876613855362,
-0.061515823006629944,
-0.05949992313981056,
1.0843533277511597,
-0.21297062933444977,
-1.0205556154251099,
0.7014487981796265,
-0.12235081195831299,
0.4548814594745636,
-0.5279033780097961,
-0.5355126261711121,
-0.23699894547462463,
0.05947526916861534,
-0.25114941596984863,
-0.6115595698356628,
0.26600033044815063,
0.0741620808839798,
-0.09546878188848495,
-0.24564489722251892,
0.5102658271789551,
-0.7380232810974121,
-0.2968100309371948,
0.3731936812400818,
0.3207910358905792,
-0.049851540476083755,
0.39460060000419617,
-0.6851832270622253,
0.05844278633594513,
0.1249910518527031,
-0.3779725134372711,
0.200493723154068,
0.33628126978874207,
0.30918288230895996,
0.6808232665061951,
0.5103750824928284,
-0.07164762169122696,
0.12857936322689056,
0.04532645270228386,
0.713213324546814,
-0.36366933584213257,
-0.35578539967536926,
-0.6728495359420776,
0.23305130004882812,
0.001133839599788189,
-0.3769890069961548,
0.6339782476425171,
0.2702186107635498,
0.8455039858818054,
0.2087625116109848,
0.715742290019989,
-0.11602857708930969,
0.4456399083137512,
-0.39266353845596313,
0.7813234925270081,
-0.3812209963798523,
0.1665046662092209,
0.0441826730966568,
-0.6455022096633911,
0.028301337733864784,
0.5897243022918701,
-0.14424273371696472,
0.14592188596725464,
0.3810524046421051,
0.829214870929718,
0.00724075036123395,
-0.18189701437950134,
0.27404066920280457,
0.20332804322242737,
0.35061904788017273,
0.22949090600013733,
0.6236850619316101,
-0.43192631006240845,
0.6024043560028076,
-0.46926647424697876,
-0.47737523913383484,
-0.293511301279068,
-1.0101326704025269,
-0.983346700668335,
-0.3422676622867584,
-0.45617014169692993,
-0.34843429923057556,
0.05602717399597168,
1.3305130004882812,
0.9327314496040344,
-0.9703795313835144,
-0.2838016748428345,
-0.3068225681781769,
-0.08385272324085236,
-0.24869002401828766,
-0.18273112177848816,
0.33539411425590515,
-0.7415387034416199,
-0.6170463562011719,
0.6621459126472473,
0.3441561460494995,
0.17326222360134125,
-0.5959022045135498,
-0.42567718029022217,
-0.10119283944368362,
0.24082855880260468,
0.36123406887054443,
0.4737909436225891,
-0.4736480116844177,
-0.34447240829467773,
0.023691914975643158,
-0.32604771852493286,
0.04500415921211243,
0.6156818270683289,
-0.7120085954666138,
0.4167230427265167,
0.2895483672618866,
1.026971697807312,
0.07489770650863647,
0.07689694315195084,
0.8417237997055054,
-0.5617791414260864,
-0.4495396316051483,
0.17098850011825562,
0.2600880563259125,
0.35745981335639954,
-0.5625243186950684,
0.4819076657295227,
0.006285870913416147,
-0.7121850848197937,
-0.6709975600242615,
0.15398427844047546,
-0.26106905937194824,
0.22214241325855255,
1.104938268661499,
-0.4782853126525879,
-0.48163580894470215,
0.3082892596721649,
-0.19332168996334076,
0.1972157508134842,
-0.437305212020874,
0.9169031977653503,
0.702118456363678,
-0.29693108797073364,
-0.352634459733963,
-0.4946316182613373,
0.8273347616195679,
0.3557116389274597,
-1.0103509426116943,
0.2855529189109802,
0.4974587559700012,
0.36067551374435425,
-0.2987526059150696,
0.5881860852241516,
0.014094670303165913,
0.4925495684146881,
-0.4011400043964386,
0.1945786029100418,
-0.27900683879852295,
-0.5269543528556824,
-0.3130541145801544,
-0.15819253027439117,
0.202234148979187,
-0.1391725093126297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13502v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13502v1 | ManWav: The First Manchu ASR Model | 2024-06-19T12:47:34 | 2024-06-19T12:47:34 | Jean Seo, Minha Kang, Sungjoo Byun, Sangah Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This study addresses the widening gap in Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR)
research between high resource and extremely low resource languages, with a
particular focus on Manchu, a critically endangered language. Manchu
exemplifies the challenges faced by marginalized linguistic communities in
accessing state-of-the-art technologies. In a pioneering effort, we introduce
the first-ever Manchu ASR model ManWav, leveraging Wav2Vec2-XLSR-53. The
results of the first Manchu ASR is promising, especially when trained with our
augmented data. Wav2Vec2-XLSR-53 fine-tuned with augmented data demonstrates a
0.02 drop in CER and 0.13 drop in WER compared to the same base model
fine-tuned with original data. | [
-0.19198952615261078,
-0.29869353771209717,
-0.043184589594602585,
0.08835461735725403,
-0.32722246646881104,
0.20654307305812836,
-0.11142177134752274,
-0.49095284938812256,
-0.0502314418554306,
0.603028416633606,
-0.46828389167785645,
-0.12265975028276443,
-0.7059363722801208,
-0.15449108183383942,
-0.7113966941833496,
0.4506394565105438,
0.3149334788322449,
0.11122207343578339,
0.332467257976532,
-0.27583834528923035,
-0.23807604610919952,
-0.49545818567276,
-0.7882079482078552,
-0.25837060809135437,
0.23749031126499176,
0.5305449962615967,
0.6807373762130737,
0.8550137281417847,
0.44054239988327026,
0.30657070875167847,
-0.28781041502952576,
-0.0654979720711708,
-0.17200514674186707,
-0.35243576765060425,
0.20721003413200378,
-0.3169058561325073,
-0.23090364038944244,
-0.0522843636572361,
0.7671665549278259,
0.4980386793613434,
-0.6005343794822693,
0.1326497495174408,
-0.09438599646091461,
0.3466407358646393,
-0.4347098469734192,
0.19134682416915894,
-0.6217603087425232,
-0.2119520753622055,
-0.7273240089416504,
0.22543565928936005,
-0.40691742300987244,
0.08556188642978668,
0.3829015791416168,
-0.8558796644210815,
0.11236639320850372,
-0.0325842909514904,
1.0250070095062256,
0.5235979557037354,
-0.43693485856056213,
0.12491058558225632,
-0.9274718165397644,
0.982442319393158,
-0.5697934627532959,
0.6472322344779968,
0.6429856419563293,
0.5615572333335876,
0.047293730080127716,
-0.7125236988067627,
-0.7786319255828857,
-0.21558527648448944,
0.11055261641740799,
-0.03790437430143356,
-0.32731956243515015,
-0.31219425797462463,
0.10057619214057922,
0.2724199593067169,
-0.22365380823612213,
0.31794077157974243,
-0.9930848479270935,
-0.5633647441864014,
0.6439335942268372,
0.3207634389400482,
0.17254005372524261,
-0.6076841354370117,
-0.35960453748703003,
-0.18994563817977905,
-0.38919535279273987,
0.3088130056858063,
0.05319172888994217,
0.37932446599006653,
-0.1865624189376831,
0.46707969903945923,
-0.20227883756160736,
0.6796295046806335,
-0.07184702157974243,
-0.032471705228090286,
0.09574175626039505,
-0.23538875579833984,
-0.09006141126155853,
0.12816736102104187,
0.8298647403717041,
0.12635354697704315,
-0.0450906977057457,
0.35995686054229736,
-0.1626422107219696,
0.21437546610832214,
0.09231463074684143,
-0.43167829513549805,
-0.5531195998191833,
-0.2684800326824188,
-0.5603163242340088,
-0.09300926327705383,
-0.00010337503772461787,
-0.41996896266937256,
-0.6195932030677795,
-0.08563017100095749,
0.6180922389030457,
-0.43583256006240845,
-0.7473428249359131,
-0.2597614824771881,
-0.21809855103492737,
0.8845040202140808,
0.144760400056839,
-1.088342308998108,
0.6082575917243958,
0.8340337872505188,
0.523548424243927,
0.07001876085996628,
-0.21984310448169708,
-0.4722841680049896,
0.02167867124080658,
-0.5306056141853333,
0.6400850415229797,
-0.5798000693321228,
-0.7289097309112549,
-0.46790507435798645,
-0.0041351174004375935,
0.4461831748485565,
-0.6843043565750122,
0.9354196190834045,
-0.39532986283302307,
0.14528456330299377,
-0.379314661026001,
-0.16126452386379242,
-0.13266326487064362,
-0.2204829305410385,
-0.6551539897918701,
0.9418535232543945,
0.42567965388298035,
-0.6129393577575684,
0.6240118145942688,
-0.7270825505256653,
-0.4926984906196594,
0.22084301710128784,
-0.27654239535331726,
-0.46014484763145447,
-0.15399493277072906,
-0.14613938331604004,
-0.006508037447929382,
-0.7407457828521729,
-0.07203759253025055,
0.2838064134120941,
-0.17061994969844818,
0.15846580266952515,
-0.4658859372138977,
0.8873977065086365,
0.3351767957210541,
-0.1498410850763321,
0.22328908741474152,
-1.0321069955825806,
0.09194986522197723,
0.3085719645023346,
-0.725920557975769,
-0.6359378099441528,
0.15804603695869446,
0.3692561984062195,
0.1975143998861313,
0.03630736097693443,
-0.9613632559776306,
-0.3668864369392395,
-0.6223693490028381,
0.6144850850105286,
0.6732578873634338,
-0.45728951692581177,
0.46904775500297546,
-0.07826142758131027,
0.05857545882463455,
0.07172473520040512,
0.37439876794815063,
0.050168152898550034,
-0.4718266427516937,
-0.9771097898483276,
-0.29276859760284424,
0.3657194674015045,
0.5766978859901428,
-0.5783954858779907,
0.03929390013217926,
0.05916864424943924,
-0.6898396015167236,
-1.0426077842712402,
-0.15278847515583038,
0.648886501789093,
0.48544028401374817,
0.2594226598739624,
-0.25120440125465393,
-0.9359550476074219,
-1.2924869060516357,
-0.13796600699424744,
-0.425836980342865,
-0.20013055205345154,
0.38813579082489014,
-0.18228766322135925,
-0.3380751311779022,
0.8149620294570923,
-0.49884042143821716,
-0.46156999468803406,
-0.22638271749019623,
0.18500474095344543,
-0.01437441073358059,
0.5401596426963806,
0.09917820245027542,
-1.0755350589752197,
-0.6654141545295715,
0.12381526082754135,
-0.2838296592235565,
0.027871131896972656,
0.5211049318313599,
0.06306615471839905,
0.6032339334487915,
0.364865243434906,
-0.37578916549682617,
0.1908242106437683,
0.5128363370895386,
-0.135646253824234,
0.31820738315582275,
-0.2442726194858551,
0.1333671361207962,
-1.1644220352172852,
0.10779207944869995,
-0.10252790153026581,
0.003055429086089134,
-1.0737601518630981,
-0.3030831515789032,
0.2439446598291397,
-0.15669387578964233,
-0.46513551473617554,
0.48310771584510803,
-0.4318929612636566,
-0.08211435377597809,
-0.29479652643203735,
-0.20283722877502441,
-0.3665085434913635,
0.05314633622765541,
0.19388841092586517,
0.6714690923690796,
0.5818362832069397,
-0.5932890772819519,
0.3762257695198059,
0.6435747742652893,
-0.4295257329940796,
0.3030839264392853,
-0.8203409910202026,
0.141714945435524,
-0.043743547052145004,
-0.18193531036376953,
-0.6861972808837891,
-0.45094770193099976,
0.18635205924510956,
-0.8115661144256592,
0.48921725153923035,
0.06238199397921562,
0.03133213520050049,
-0.5014961361885071,
-0.06346625834703445,
0.2344086766242981,
0.9125822186470032,
-0.47856828570365906,
0.6437386870384216,
1.1803321838378906,
-0.11583735048770905,
-0.6333768367767334,
-0.5600361227989197,
0.010289032012224197,
-0.08611981570720673,
-0.513804018497467,
0.12102825939655304,
0.152558833360672,
-0.4081609547138214,
-0.2931397557258606,
-0.29917484521865845,
-0.4330572187900543,
0.02655208110809326,
0.34369367361068726,
0.6337137222290039,
-0.2739824652671814,
-0.3690218925476074,
-0.17118926346302032,
-0.6108965277671814,
0.03913751244544983,
0.023177118971943855,
0.4648467004299164,
-0.13985174894332886,
-0.05498037114739418,
-0.5739745497703552,
0.3262881934642792,
0.46515122056007385,
-0.36947399377822876,
0.2989400625228882,
0.5989255309104919,
-0.7330563068389893,
0.21333061158657074,
-0.5554320216178894,
0.036269839853048325,
-0.533345639705658,
0.49162769317626953,
-0.39869144558906555,
-0.6069270372390747,
0.26045018434524536,
0.23572978377342224,
0.03665335476398468,
0.7085846662521362,
0.3935358226299286,
0.11849351227283478,
1.0938076972961426,
0.8835849761962891,
-0.15256895124912262,
0.4910524785518646,
-0.1858823001384735,
-0.14584079384803772,
-0.9788035154342651,
-0.5636721253395081,
-0.6275984048843384,
0.19981075823307037,
-0.5787465572357178,
-0.4590713381767273,
0.43223968148231506,
-0.41718024015426636,
-0.16663752496242523,
0.484237939119339,
-0.5618715286254883,
0.47424665093421936,
0.7435490489006042,
0.05715169012546539,
0.1727035790681839,
-0.3953540027141571,
0.29091641306877136,
-0.3984713554382324,
-0.515929639339447,
-0.2648186981678009,
0.8376337885856628,
0.242651104927063,
1.0256764888763428,
0.15134872496128082,
0.3282723128795624,
0.4237392246723175,
0.02850329875946045,
-0.6485152244567871,
0.573229968547821,
-0.741787850856781,
-0.7808818221092224,
-0.7671887874603271,
-0.28206562995910645,
-0.9153155088424683,
0.1328265368938446,
-0.2353154867887497,
-0.23919259011745453,
0.04324088618159294,
0.2488044947385788,
-0.5255323052406311,
0.02682419866323471,
-0.5645918846130371,
0.7206159234046936,
-0.22044460475444794,
-0.09520725905895233,
-0.31251904368400574,
-1.0895336866378784,
0.39527565240859985,
-0.0959632396697998,
0.255961537361145,
-0.11868471652269363,
-0.007302214857190847,
0.9744856357574463,
-0.379587858915329,
0.3010874092578888,
-0.3732742667198181,
0.1412835419178009,
0.3517647683620453,
-0.12232090532779694,
0.34793102741241455,
-0.4225429594516754,
-0.07024897634983063,
0.19896040856838226,
-0.0608014352619648,
-0.4193945527076721,
-0.08565257489681244,
0.5309401750564575,
-1.2567445039749146,
-0.7039231061935425,
-0.37317323684692383,
-0.20522038638591766,
0.1669061928987503,
0.30441755056381226,
0.37695953249931335,
0.5281808972358704,
-0.29920798540115356,
0.21167084574699402,
0.4965461790561676,
-0.34639671444892883,
0.11276249587535858,
0.9438228607177734,
-0.01776052638888359,
-0.526352047920227,
1.0785975456237793,
0.3842160999774933,
0.5441129207611084,
0.18444830179214478,
0.3617471158504486,
-0.2996027171611786,
-0.4142626225948334,
-0.6000534296035767,
0.05941940099000931,
-0.6149175763130188,
0.06471268832683563,
-0.8772431015968323,
-0.6576201319694519,
-0.22848771512508392,
-0.03427693247795105,
-0.7600312232971191,
-0.46908092498779297,
-0.34954509139060974,
0.3043801486492157,
0.3104492723941803,
0.805097222328186,
-0.33073851466178894,
0.21331535279750824,
-0.7581890225410461,
0.5625662207603455,
0.5124403238296509,
0.3651854991912842,
-0.22079282999038696,
-0.9017415046691895,
-0.18022975325584412,
0.046151529997587204,
0.16374899446964264,
-0.3284885287284851,
0.527766227722168,
0.32593870162963867,
0.66120445728302,
0.2537713646888733,
0.3637583255767822,
0.6011934876441956,
-0.5461276173591614,
0.8554369807243347,
0.25319042801856995,
-1.002389669418335,
0.5282773971557617,
-0.32943472266197205,
0.3354068696498871,
0.1881735920906067,
0.10766978561878204,
-0.5929849743843079,
-0.21928994357585907,
-0.49122223258018494,
-0.9553601741790771,
1.0948365926742554,
-0.20729991793632507,
0.15494808554649353,
0.25722426176071167,
-0.003945513162761927,
0.4050949513912201,
-0.0508994497358799,
-0.23610715568065643,
-0.26934781670570374,
-0.5146493315696716,
-0.0007419268949888647,
-0.14879514276981354,
-0.2587534487247467,
0.12470318377017975,
-0.4416300058364868,
0.7534205913543701,
0.12675194442272186,
-0.04636695608496666,
0.08703352510929108,
-0.284053772687912,
-0.4354134202003479,
0.37374556064605713,
0.46478813886642456,
0.17561058700084686,
-0.09061619639396667,
0.05449550226330757,
0.5018114447593689,
-0.7071430683135986,
0.20696523785591125,
0.19651639461517334,
-0.22729051113128662,
-0.0927690640091896,
-0.18125824630260468,
1.1002883911132812,
0.39079755544662476,
-0.6670598983764648,
0.45792075991630554,
-0.21730679273605347,
0.005851294379681349,
-0.7765499353408813,
0.1647559553384781,
0.04541565105319023,
0.3477107882499695,
0.6108882427215576,
0.19662731885910034,
0.2575923502445221,
-0.5512464642524719,
0.22217939794063568,
0.581087589263916,
-0.553579568862915,
-0.2141246199607849,
1.2159769535064697,
0.41360852122306824,
-0.7630211114883423,
0.6924198269844055,
0.07599710673093796,
-0.6427844762802124,
0.4282844364643097,
0.5690703392028809,
0.7386961579322815,
-0.6013283133506775,
-0.012033776380121708,
0.52754145860672,
0.47511062026023865,
-0.05032476410269737,
0.28408247232437134,
-0.06304211169481277,
-0.46580690145492554,
-0.12864139676094055,
-0.6556723713874817,
-0.8338315486907959,
-0.023020705208182335,
-0.9868788719177246,
0.7956855893135071,
-0.41388821601867676,
-0.1330062448978424,
0.36687588691711426,
0.05550570785999298,
-0.18012036383152008,
0.07807541638612747,
0.36953452229499817,
0.997487485408783,
-0.6788777709007263,
0.9953556656837463,
0.4823876619338989,
-0.2255098670721054,
-0.8411937355995178,
-0.1459096372127533,
0.1576109379529953,
-0.8370926976203918,
0.43443232774734497,
-0.08284258842468262,
-0.25580883026123047,
0.354436457157135,
-0.3907337188720703,
-1.2224372625350952,
1.1815414428710938,
0.1526103913784027,
-0.31967321038246155,
0.24672392010688782,
-0.05972445011138916,
0.4686385989189148,
0.0814637616276741,
-0.16996251046657562,
0.9194287657737732,
0.4161957800388336,
0.2839105725288391,
-1.439422607421875,
-0.09486480802297592,
-0.3795712888240814,
0.06571456789970398,
0.5149796605110168,
-1.0222210884094238,
1.1547433137893677,
-0.6976680755615234,
-0.5517845153808594,
0.2975655198097229,
0.6773927807807922,
-0.043639518320560455,
0.1309044510126114,
0.6408755779266357,
0.1186537966132164,
0.5830552577972412,
-0.07613623887300491,
0.8187781572341919,
0.17327691614627838,
-0.10875242948532104,
0.8715763092041016,
-0.43485814332962036,
1.1753467321395874,
0.12315637618303299,
-0.45586755871772766,
0.24283626675605774,
0.41582298278808594,
0.03681017458438873,
0.7108965516090393,
-0.07397929579019547,
-0.3186727464199066,
-0.08576848357915878,
-0.2626205086708069,
-0.3004710078239441,
0.8787431716918945,
0.38015949726104736,
0.03126592934131622,
0.21263344585895538,
0.02306562103331089,
0.0455213226377964,
0.05461157485842705,
-0.4194289743900299,
1.210328221321106,
-0.06691399216651917,
-0.4073788821697235,
0.9306601881980896,
0.01704525388777256,
0.8898528814315796,
-0.8616999983787537,
0.12679114937782288,
0.23903495073318481,
0.26784712076187134,
-0.1697281152009964,
-0.7118831872940063,
0.5578402876853943,
0.097523033618927,
-0.4391117990016937,
0.2915969789028168,
0.9773246645927429,
-0.4738532602787018,
-0.26945969462394714,
0.33747294545173645,
0.06373263895511627,
0.20374459028244019,
0.25324931740760803,
-0.2423722743988037,
0.26896485686302185,
0.07626271992921829,
0.004046306945383549,
0.32051166892051697,
-0.07551863044500351,
-0.12873724102973938,
0.6735178232192993,
0.6693569421768188,
-0.08163364231586456,
0.2992233633995056,
-0.10581831634044647,
0.8728039860725403,
-0.8753537535667419,
-0.44250160455703735,
-0.693977415561676,
0.634207010269165,
-0.13425324857234955,
-0.1902255266904831,
0.5689106583595276,
0.5154816508293152,
0.6893738508224487,
0.011532151140272617,
0.9455782771110535,
-0.3648660182952881,
1.0015103816986084,
-0.1181589812040329,
1.2039116621017456,
-0.4515257477760315,
-0.029722483828663826,
-0.19650961458683014,
-0.16676734387874603,
-0.05176255851984024,
0.6159493327140808,
0.11780478805303574,
-0.4152185916900635,
0.20757897198200226,
0.8433050513267517,
0.2304234653711319,
0.14588557183742523,
0.556318461894989,
0.5189611911773682,
0.1552782505750656,
0.23994818329811096,
0.9694584608078003,
-0.5994595885276794,
0.8587764501571655,
-0.2873818576335907,
-0.41752561926841736,
-0.15416590869426727,
-0.2838986814022064,
-0.3440711498260498,
-1.0878593921661377,
0.019740404561161995,
-0.28667208552360535,
-0.06104768067598343,
1.1840260028839111,
0.7941151857376099,
-0.8340014815330505,
-0.2879890501499176,
0.39761674404144287,
-0.16558749973773956,
0.014603315852582455,
-0.16642127931118011,
0.07430516183376312,
0.49074646830558777,
-0.517480194568634,
0.49824413657188416,
0.2925305962562561,
0.09470991790294647,
-0.3803856074810028,
-0.503488302230835,
-0.11353610455989838,
0.18875545263290405,
0.7120272517204285,
0.6970322132110596,
-0.9871237277984619,
-0.3716701567173004,
0.3120235204696655,
-0.14863629639148712,
0.15076786279678345,
0.4533242881298065,
-0.7841973304748535,
0.5110844969749451,
0.2072223573923111,
0.4263889193534851,
0.4394683837890625,
-0.034839533269405365,
0.5788661241531372,
-0.5287497639656067,
0.1521080732345581,
0.14177197217941284,
0.1913364678621292,
0.7325049638748169,
0.08348266780376434,
0.4036903977394104,
0.009013334289193153,
-0.5512632727622986,
-1.1631639003753662,
0.18632598221302032,
-0.8904170393943787,
0.2661837637424469,
0.9970589280128479,
0.2501620948314667,
-0.18383896350860596,
-0.3704474866390228,
-0.7764632105827332,
0.5299237370491028,
-0.4873799979686737,
0.8189112544059753,
0.5571100115776062,
-0.09116096049547195,
-0.40263083577156067,
-0.4345236122608185,
0.611411452293396,
0.05071723088622093,
-0.6360164284706116,
0.3542706370353699,
0.46072322130203247,
0.4416554272174835,
0.18627656996250153,
0.979098379611969,
-0.1736602485179901,
0.5823724865913391,
0.5440279841423035,
0.023581476882100105,
0.005926116369664669,
-0.2566124498844147,
-0.3739566206932068,
-0.2062850445508957,
0.6090017557144165,
-0.3845442533493042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13476v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13476v3 | LLMs Are Zero-Shot Context-Aware Simultaneous Translators | 2024-06-19T11:57:42 | 2024-06-25T04:45:19 | Roman Koshkin, Katsuhito Sudoh, Satoshi Nakamura | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advent of transformers has fueled progress in machine translation. More
recently large language models (LLMs) have come to the spotlight thanks to
their generality and strong performance in a wide range of language tasks,
including translation. Here we show that open-source LLMs perform on par with
or better than some state-of-the-art baselines in simultaneous machine
translation (SiMT) tasks, zero-shot. We also demonstrate that injection of
minimal background information, which is easy with an LLM, brings further
performance gains, especially on challenging technical subject-matter. This
highlights LLMs' potential for building next generation of massively
multilingual, context-aware and terminologically accurate SiMT systems that
require no resource-intensive training or fine-tuning. | [
-0.19263166189193726,
-0.6277104616165161,
0.8828449845314026,
0.21109966933727264,
-0.3729724884033203,
0.14010250568389893,
-0.4515348970890045,
-0.33201077580451965,
0.03472409397363663,
0.579317033290863,
-0.45247772336006165,
-0.6009088158607483,
-0.8178471326828003,
0.15488767623901367,
-0.7392451763153076,
0.8417315483093262,
-0.31056806445121765,
0.040258802473545074,
-0.21070343255996704,
-0.27006790041923523,
-0.4140312969684601,
-0.5238454341888428,
-0.33042794466018677,
-0.3886856138706207,
0.7482181191444397,
0.31576231122016907,
0.8192082047462463,
0.8441261053085327,
0.5906845331192017,
0.29965940117836,
0.03742465749382973,
0.010486697778105736,
-0.3999101519584656,
0.3369675278663635,
-0.08182577043771744,
-0.6087413430213928,
-0.4561760425567627,
-0.07446931302547455,
0.6515743136405945,
0.6323885917663574,
0.19058595597743988,
0.22969692945480347,
-0.08691225945949554,
0.36995169520378113,
-0.5955068469047546,
0.04092497378587723,
-0.7664725184440613,
0.05927557125687599,
-0.14503519237041473,
-0.5125811696052551,
-0.49446168541908264,
-0.09555761516094208,
-0.3532906472682953,
-0.4924900233745575,
0.007392961997538805,
-0.00610090559348464,
0.591802716255188,
0.6049951314926147,
-0.6781739592552185,
-0.03408420458436012,
-0.9919752478599548,
0.8756754398345947,
-0.5494963526725769,
0.43778079748153687,
-0.274212121963501,
0.4033249020576477,
-0.2212325632572174,
-0.597069501876831,
-0.5186353325843811,
-0.1439410001039505,
-0.08462818711996078,
0.23786216974258423,
-0.12546516954898834,
0.012093283236026764,
0.30668142437934875,
0.5324029922485352,
-0.4640364348888397,
0.3134140372276306,
-0.16920524835586548,
0.08899634331464767,
0.31141406297683716,
0.3501936197280884,
0.37386807799339294,
0.01876915991306305,
-0.5876244306564331,
0.2871238887310028,
-0.8638961911201477,
-0.3939734399318695,
-0.18743176758289337,
0.3751163184642792,
-0.34424135088920593,
0.8750479221343994,
-0.12362324446439743,
0.7558439373970032,
-0.31549564003944397,
-0.2536032199859619,
-0.05385148152709007,
-0.4874671399593353,
-0.44530007243156433,
-0.09613862633705139,
0.9285054802894592,
0.10275954008102417,
0.2845749855041504,
-0.4904150068759918,
-0.23872153460979462,
0.03469230607151985,
0.0002933965006377548,
-0.7609257698059082,
0.38645830750465393,
0.3452056348323822,
-0.12152931839227676,
-0.049839429557323456,
-0.1334345042705536,
-0.17411087453365326,
-0.12660689651966095,
-0.6210880875587463,
0.5467544198036194,
-0.2611398994922638,
-0.10103163123130798,
0.19958770275115967,
-0.08537813276052475,
0.39750102162361145,
0.5978307127952576,
-0.5446552634239197,
0.1563786417245865,
0.7507739067077637,
1.2281792163848877,
-0.30339565873146057,
-0.3285830318927765,
-0.6790646910667419,
0.49067944288253784,
-0.6212731599807739,
0.6302878856658936,
-0.16420933604240417,
-0.3141723871231079,
0.02776937559247017,
-0.14667320251464844,
0.16681674122810364,
-0.47330042719841003,
0.3923778235912323,
-0.5665026307106018,
-0.11965518444776535,
-0.22618746757507324,
-0.5050754547119141,
0.09191703796386719,
0.12793570756912231,
-0.3008963465690613,
0.9467622637748718,
0.03617474064230919,
-0.4683116674423218,
0.29069310426712036,
-0.5312592387199402,
-0.499437540769577,
0.5208417773246765,
-0.14380058646202087,
0.17152166366577148,
0.42213526368141174,
-0.03141336888074875,
0.6492224931716919,
-0.4336837828159332,
0.18406744301319122,
-0.21603357791900635,
-0.580053985118866,
0.17145279049873352,
-0.5115008354187012,
0.45921051502227783,
0.2686111629009247,
-0.12635084986686707,
0.19651345908641815,
-0.4126465618610382,
-0.12824994325637817,
0.09154531359672546,
-0.3460708558559418,
-0.27432289719581604,
-0.0648266151547432,
-0.058682139962911606,
0.4962708055973053,
0.30271488428115845,
-0.645320475101471,
0.32517755031585693,
-0.24501724541187286,
0.3544210195541382,
0.48711007833480835,
-0.43765828013420105,
0.5135161876678467,
-0.26084104180336,
0.46053093671798706,
0.07326114177703857,
-0.17411470413208008,
-0.5813120007514954,
-0.3658624589443207,
-0.9316383004188538,
-0.7370235919952393,
0.208661288022995,
0.7481583952903748,
-0.8559316396713257,
0.30172938108444214,
-0.4227692484855652,
-0.3106095790863037,
-0.5146985054016113,
0.4516057074069977,
0.08984347432851791,
0.34805014729499817,
0.3619365990161896,
-0.10387420654296875,
-0.3767191171646118,
-0.9249714612960815,
-0.2694415748119354,
0.2298608273267746,
-0.3458854556083679,
0.14228028059005737,
0.367734432220459,
-0.1912136822938919,
0.799834132194519,
-0.3779960572719574,
-0.35564371943473816,
-0.3773901164531708,
-0.03277936577796936,
0.39529186487197876,
0.14591282606124878,
0.3821166455745697,
-0.5732825994491577,
-0.6979131698608398,
0.24555037915706635,
-1.1988447904586792,
-0.2800910770893097,
-0.045965246856212616,
-0.08244585245847702,
0.14863274991512299,
0.6501913666725159,
-0.8334877490997314,
0.03891029208898544,
0.7403653860092163,
0.09848493337631226,
0.1295691579580307,
-0.3395373523235321,
-0.035091232508420944,
-1.3047667741775513,
0.20483620464801788,
-0.12109672278165817,
-0.6500221490859985,
-0.7892571091651917,
0.17624416947364807,
0.2922076880931854,
0.0035168409813195467,
-1.0049796104431152,
0.7127642035484314,
-0.5953542590141296,
-0.463873028755188,
-0.4306603968143463,
0.4510027766227722,
-0.29493409395217896,
0.17972968518733978,
-0.07117821276187897,
1.003941297531128,
0.552143394947052,
-0.559900164604187,
0.3307112455368042,
0.05170348659157753,
-0.2060975879430771,
0.7180768847465515,
-0.4354488253593445,
0.03400580585002899,
-0.08474348485469818,
0.3735334873199463,
-0.7736387252807617,
-0.43314939737319946,
0.11633467674255371,
-0.302519828081131,
0.4075961709022522,
0.04730275645852089,
-0.7292563319206238,
-0.3356591463088989,
-0.0751820057630539,
0.4033198058605194,
0.5832350254058838,
-0.4251198172569275,
0.4395999610424042,
0.08414629846811295,
-0.16684623062610626,
-0.5893001556396484,
-0.8538464903831482,
0.3223396837711334,
0.07595187425613403,
-0.49413421750068665,
0.22362615168094635,
-0.06632210314273834,
-0.25181180238723755,
-0.013764644972980022,
-0.1330965906381607,
-0.0786232203245163,
0.27022644877433777,
0.3224872946739197,
0.3860180974006653,
-0.34906890988349915,
0.18298907577991486,
-0.07867096364498138,
-0.26650962233543396,
-0.38282376527786255,
-0.47822892665863037,
0.4423319101333618,
-0.19336725771427155,
-0.5588195323944092,
-0.5101112127304077,
0.3548564314842224,
0.8658382892608643,
-0.09806457906961441,
0.9194614291191101,
0.3791978359222412,
-0.25394362211227417,
-0.1124223917722702,
-0.6206017732620239,
0.1659528762102127,
-0.45097804069519043,
0.22080200910568237,
-0.4540330469608307,
-1.3884162902832031,
0.2985515892505646,
-0.17763061821460724,
0.20480585098266602,
0.5023216009140015,
0.8992167115211487,
-0.12358454614877701,
0.860569417476654,
0.6714236736297607,
0.009825604036450386,
0.3369441628456116,
0.1184702068567276,
0.28435420989990234,
-0.6583314538002014,
-0.08433356881141663,
-0.354179322719574,
-0.26000726222991943,
-0.4325834810733795,
-0.7488158345222473,
0.37880510091781616,
0.3044678866863251,
-0.17658591270446777,
0.4173959195613861,
-0.20865093171596527,
0.5600675940513611,
0.4379177689552307,
-0.25553470849990845,
0.7142691016197205,
-0.07275289297103882,
-0.1090601310133934,
0.09208200126886368,
-0.6286733150482178,
-0.6312744617462158,
0.9926150441169739,
0.20156873762607574,
0.646742045879364,
0.023304753005504608,
0.6023707985877991,
0.06513746827840805,
0.5418680310249329,
-1.021131992340088,
0.6107094883918762,
-0.4436238408088684,
-0.5122382640838623,
-0.22174862027168274,
-0.44197702407836914,
-0.6228436231613159,
0.5528912544250488,
0.02056814171373844,
-0.4567336440086365,
-0.3774440586566925,
0.0449991300702095,
-0.28892359137535095,
0.5942990779876709,
-0.3411393165588379,
0.5527493357658386,
-0.5857018232345581,
-0.3586822748184204,
-0.1275297850370407,
-0.4583016037940979,
0.5755698084831238,
-0.4908970594406128,
0.1865423172712326,
-0.4080435037612915,
-0.5674052238464355,
0.047222334891557693,
-0.10868457704782486,
0.49696943163871765,
0.1749621033668518,
-0.2036874145269394,
0.08982519060373306,
0.26223766803741455,
0.25023457407951355,
-0.1292847841978073,
-0.039660681039094925,
0.6343182921409607,
-0.09472085535526276,
-0.4186258316040039,
-0.5097300410270691,
0.9925767779350281,
-0.5761023163795471,
-0.8202043175697327,
-0.35625797510147095,
-1.1287226676940918,
-0.05365247279405594,
0.4184124171733856,
0.05018170177936554,
-0.007682094816118479,
-0.16810615360736847,
0.5578800439834595,
0.5635483264923096,
-0.4368784725666046,
0.5526953339576721,
0.7915599346160889,
-0.32125815749168396,
-0.20383475720882416,
0.526411235332489,
0.1449650526046753,
0.5760191679000854,
0.7304553389549255,
-0.1917649209499359,
-0.1376512497663498,
-0.41033148765563965,
-0.7854411602020264,
0.3770858347415924,
-0.577363133430481,
-0.300851047039032,
-0.9471623301506042,
-0.30404868721961975,
-0.22959890961647034,
-0.4901350438594818,
-0.44066986441612244,
-0.5229286551475525,
-0.07739938050508499,
0.06997261941432953,
0.11606036126613617,
0.9067032933235168,
-0.1903635412454605,
0.4418141543865204,
-0.8838804364204407,
0.5149041414260864,
0.19707059860229492,
0.39940714836120605,
-0.3870987296104431,
-0.44157958030700684,
-0.28168314695358276,
0.016635145992040634,
-0.41768521070480347,
-0.5722680687904358,
0.3528463840484619,
-0.14612726867198944,
0.5028465986251831,
0.08484616130590439,
-0.2088414430618286,
0.562094509601593,
-0.7403063774108887,
0.8786935210227966,
0.3196242153644562,
-1.0174769163131714,
0.23171766102313995,
-0.4957788288593292,
0.6112909913063049,
0.21320413053035736,
0.3918980658054352,
-0.8919996619224548,
-0.5378375053405762,
0.046831123530864716,
-0.7230143547058105,
0.9697982668876648,
0.16679240763187408,
0.40855902433395386,
0.04561347886919975,
0.34726738929748535,
0.014921360649168491,
0.43275418877601624,
-0.7163228988647461,
-0.31670910120010376,
0.05577678605914116,
-0.22365525364875793,
-0.40299251675605774,
-0.242579385638237,
-0.00872044451534748,
-0.07009752094745636,
0.4588146507740021,
-0.1735856533050537,
0.2901962101459503,
-0.06262001395225525,
-0.31980207562446594,
-0.3471788167953491,
0.5602203607559204,
0.8203120231628418,
0.4456324875354767,
-0.24559654295444489,
0.23227815330028534,
0.47855865955352783,
0.0711774006485939,
0.4943222105503082,
-0.21048207581043243,
-0.3598547875881195,
0.09836937487125397,
0.2652716636657715,
0.765180766582489,
0.5674414038658142,
-0.44741421937942505,
0.6799947023391724,
0.23345068097114563,
-0.1871243417263031,
-0.16366516053676605,
-0.07398854941129684,
0.3718416392803192,
0.22769562900066376,
0.3965252637863159,
-0.045061223208904266,
-0.2158498466014862,
-0.4240739643573761,
0.143422469496727,
0.5932120084762573,
-0.35665807127952576,
-0.29828736186027527,
0.7143178582191467,
0.11317887157201767,
-0.3393324315547943,
0.22238443791866302,
0.18965832889080048,
-0.20145177841186523,
0.4411677122116089,
0.5965883731842041,
1.0773603916168213,
-0.2410985678434372,
0.07720797508955002,
0.1739206165075302,
0.4316319525241852,
-0.34832119941711426,
-0.07390254735946655,
-0.13458949327468872,
-0.5179115533828735,
-0.7464455366134644,
-0.9308171272277832,
-0.5107204914093018,
0.18300998210906982,
-0.3920859396457672,
0.5445374250411987,
-0.18142946064472198,
0.0542946383357048,
-0.23750221729278564,
-0.5175694823265076,
-0.7400500178337097,
-0.08111396431922913,
0.18402351438999176,
1.0511342287063599,
-0.5650631785392761,
1.0158885717391968,
0.6095160245895386,
-0.3621407151222229,
-0.3477538526058197,
-0.09784579277038574,
0.03718460723757744,
-0.6541914343833923,
0.8267137408256531,
0.23258915543556213,
-0.16697467863559723,
0.0995732918381691,
-0.3112003207206726,
-1.0468642711639404,
1.1771503686904907,
0.8615349531173706,
-0.6897574663162231,
-0.18399226665496826,
0.5892460346221924,
0.5735069513320923,
-0.23561686277389526,
0.21913187205791473,
0.27333199977874756,
0.3959934115409851,
0.20915044844150543,
-1.0135488510131836,
-0.10010084509849548,
0.2968873083591461,
0.19458849728107452,
0.4475625455379486,
-0.7023487091064453,
0.8941169381141663,
0.03731828182935715,
-0.3917867839336395,
0.15251971781253815,
0.5558345913887024,
-0.04465147852897644,
0.17917239665985107,
0.05701702460646629,
0.4012170135974884,
0.266867458820343,
-0.1774282306432724,
1.4488850831985474,
-0.5957040190696716,
0.14072279632091522,
1.2243483066558838,
-0.5247589349746704,
0.9984625577926636,
0.5317489504814148,
0.05525076761841774,
0.1088259294629097,
0.1358066201210022,
0.16378247737884521,
0.19208315014839172,
-0.004749265965074301,
-0.47320306301116943,
-0.5790310502052307,
-0.24556806683540344,
-0.3029720187187195,
0.38473987579345703,
0.2609252631664276,
-0.4030991196632385,
-0.4515227675437927,
-0.05591529235243797,
0.051496393978595734,
0.0007669154438190162,
-0.24656398594379425,
0.6736807823181152,
0.5522893667221069,
-0.6124577522277832,
0.4985715448856354,
0.1917056143283844,
0.8584861159324646,
-0.7008175849914551,
0.19796396791934967,
-0.2897202968597412,
0.19573622941970825,
-0.08155016601085663,
-0.7778295278549194,
0.4230659008026123,
0.18971127271652222,
-0.08404618501663208,
-0.6020185351371765,
0.5972372889518738,
-0.5167650580406189,
-0.44508689641952515,
0.6512999534606934,
0.8158414959907532,
0.20980533957481384,
-0.16839967668056488,
-0.36885276436805725,
0.07384581118822098,
-0.2820848822593689,
-0.10395945608615875,
0.3535436987876892,
0.42047494649887085,
0.03269219771027565,
0.7191686630249023,
0.5381905436515808,
0.14766135811805725,
0.21048584580421448,
-0.2487705498933792,
0.5309990048408508,
-0.7320274710655212,
0.07309383153915405,
-1.0029077529907227,
0.45295774936676025,
0.13466958701610565,
0.06828661262989044,
1.0103532075881958,
0.6729193925857544,
0.9658625721931458,
-0.04490775614976883,
0.8025468587875366,
0.30268606543540955,
0.35887378454208374,
-0.3181075155735016,
0.611168622970581,
-0.7888707518577576,
0.14925754070281982,
-0.024148110300302505,
-1.123661994934082,
-0.682570219039917,
0.021332135424017906,
-0.2179708182811737,
-0.16554193198680878,
0.6507760286331177,
0.7760540843009949,
-0.2295423448085785,
-0.2705852687358856,
0.991693377494812,
0.2612670063972473,
0.18604294955730438,
0.6341802477836609,
0.893660306930542,
-0.3835090696811676,
0.6857233047485352,
0.029834222048521042,
-0.14920587837696075,
-0.23566871881484985,
-0.9762944579124451,
-0.7712020874023438,
-0.12121473997831345,
-0.10005190223455429,
0.1800110787153244,
-0.03004751168191433,
0.8335997462272644,
0.6745933294296265,
-0.804485559463501,
-0.42634084820747375,
0.048522625118494034,
0.0941629409790039,
0.09196967631578445,
-0.09659519046545029,
-0.24346616864204407,
-0.5485943555831909,
-0.8893322348594666,
0.7528966069221497,
0.9279450178146362,
0.11827558279037476,
-0.4399830102920532,
-0.2436063140630722,
-0.12392694503068924,
0.396127313375473,
0.8650086522102356,
0.07540053129196167,
-1.0420582294464111,
-0.15750040113925934,
0.08553377538919449,
-0.5850557088851929,
0.22364269196987152,
0.8452749848365784,
-0.5873898863792419,
0.3501768112182617,
0.424726277589798,
0.7983153462409973,
0.5648756623268127,
-0.13106673955917358,
0.5989840626716614,
-0.7278222441673279,
0.39471858739852905,
-0.07457834482192993,
0.3552776873111725,
0.4294653534889221,
-0.2127484679222107,
0.5658080577850342,
0.1851906031370163,
-0.43221426010131836,
-0.8690107464790344,
0.24564224481582642,
-0.8790826201438904,
-0.1840730905532837,
1.276010274887085,
-0.10190160572528839,
-0.04472916200757027,
0.09185003489255905,
0.019089827314019203,
0.4545482397079468,
-0.16502350568771362,
0.20546269416809082,
0.7060309648513794,
0.17251332104206085,
-0.15923359990119934,
-1.0135265588760376,
0.009524420835077763,
0.4717086851596832,
-0.7956763505935669,
-0.11840928345918655,
0.4756174087524414,
0.2667165994644165,
0.07439722865819931,
0.6228621006011963,
-0.16311845183372498,
0.09634290635585785,
-0.23383300006389618,
0.19079935550689697,
-0.23212739825248718,
-0.3681887090206146,
-0.5173664689064026,
0.37082603573799133,
0.21165528893470764,
-0.08816563338041306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13469v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13469v1 | Encoder vs Decoder: Comparative Analysis of Encoder and Decoder Language Models on Multilingual NLU Tasks | 2024-06-19T11:50:09 | 2024-06-19T11:50:09 | Dan Saattrup Nielsen, Kenneth Enevoldsen, Peter Schneider-Kamp | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | This paper explores the performance of encoder and decoder language models on
multilingual Natural Language Understanding (NLU) tasks, with a broad focus on
Germanic languages. Building upon the ScandEval benchmark, which initially was
restricted to evaluating encoder models, we extend the evaluation framework to
include decoder models. We introduce a method for evaluating decoder models on
NLU tasks and apply it to the languages Danish, Swedish, Norwegian, Icelandic,
Faroese, German, Dutch, and English. Through a series of experiments and
analyses, we address key research questions regarding the comparative
performance of encoder and decoder models, the impact of NLU task types, and
the variation across language resources. Our findings reveal that decoder
models can achieve significantly better NLU performance than encoder models,
with nuances observed across different tasks and languages. Additionally, we
investigate the correlation between decoders and task performance via a UMAP
analysis, shedding light on the unique capabilities of decoder and encoder
models. This study contributes to a deeper understanding of language model
paradigms in NLU tasks and provides valuable insights for model selection and
evaluation in multilingual settings. | [
-0.40646806359291077,
-0.6039112210273743,
0.36099398136138916,
0.37310266494750977,
-0.21881569921970367,
0.022690465673804283,
-0.26253750920295715,
-0.7869599461555481,
-0.1319023072719574,
0.37445345520973206,
-0.19657489657402039,
-0.2623564302921295,
-0.6548120379447937,
0.6715860366821289,
-0.1981344074010849,
0.5373936891555786,
-0.17073732614517212,
0.3797481060028076,
-0.6346855759620667,
-0.24864019453525543,
-0.5197728872299194,
-0.7903907299041748,
-0.6971621513366699,
-0.5543031692504883,
0.17741325497627258,
-0.31856122612953186,
0.5224642753601074,
0.4741332530975342,
0.6514856219291687,
0.29473188519477844,
-0.44763660430908203,
0.022469019517302513,
-0.5306891798973083,
0.1361311823129654,
-0.09526079893112183,
-0.3538125455379486,
-0.2820080816745758,
-0.43935680389404297,
0.485117644071579,
0.7620354890823364,
-0.06871069222688675,
0.0993509292602539,
0.2488536536693573,
0.4060964584350586,
-0.7778777480125427,
0.28408485651016235,
-0.15952126681804657,
0.0522601492702961,
-0.07979581505060196,
-0.14598439633846283,
-0.6466481685638428,
-0.2276410311460495,
-0.19009914994239807,
-0.5421000719070435,
0.38715600967407227,
-0.15727920830249786,
0.5492479801177979,
0.28392788767814636,
-0.5599110722541809,
-0.3454537093639374,
-0.843777060508728,
0.6542580127716064,
-0.6580647230148315,
1.0590192079544067,
0.2726569175720215,
0.17483271658420563,
0.198817178606987,
-0.24192924797534943,
-0.3453786373138428,
-0.05106131732463837,
-0.1865341067314148,
0.2661103904247284,
-0.6170589923858643,
0.08787866681814194,
0.23971539735794067,
0.5470985770225525,
-0.8187992572784424,
0.1811285763978958,
-0.355691522359848,
-0.03309815749526024,
0.44523173570632935,
0.2623966634273529,
0.07732532918453217,
-0.25139549374580383,
-0.2496853619813919,
-0.2197546660900116,
-0.37926456332206726,
0.121835857629776,
0.40830346941947937,
0.19043834507465363,
-0.30836302042007446,
0.47144821286201477,
-0.09414887428283691,
0.8954424858093262,
-0.1677764505147934,
-0.1483413130044937,
0.28102409839630127,
-0.4636228382587433,
-0.13181039690971375,
-0.10391286015510559,
0.5150449275970459,
0.15542282164096832,
0.021896978840231895,
-0.6667144298553467,
-0.4131835997104645,
0.4459374248981476,
0.19702105224132538,
-0.686246931552887,
0.042344506829977036,
0.03640308231115341,
-0.7591644525527954,
0.23001432418823242,
-0.15356814861297607,
-0.6094837784767151,
-0.2165815383195877,
-0.2842548191547394,
0.14956094324588776,
-0.3947184085845947,
-0.6535341739654541,
0.5509765148162842,
-0.3497259318828583,
0.6280260682106018,
0.17250022292137146,
-0.6483038067817688,
0.6225581169128418,
0.8273773789405823,
0.5755072832107544,
-0.4264710247516632,
-0.4297766387462616,
-0.17414097487926483,
-0.12127205729484558,
-0.3451588749885559,
0.7931548357009888,
-0.6285926699638367,
-0.4488825798034668,
0.17138440907001495,
-0.005773433484137058,
-0.4040566384792328,
-0.5297053456306458,
0.6118865013122559,
-0.8037462830543518,
0.0980781838297844,
-0.4074333608150482,
-0.6933719515800476,
-0.4408753216266632,
0.38900983333587646,
-1.2255274057388306,
1.044609785079956,
-0.044065650552511215,
-0.8527910113334656,
0.3456856310367584,
-0.9007052183151245,
-0.5478036999702454,
0.18150797486305237,
0.004988802596926689,
0.31476691365242004,
0.4317759871482849,
0.16967740654945374,
0.40875914692878723,
-0.5258626937866211,
0.12609881162643433,
-0.03684569150209427,
-0.42556947469711304,
0.13979749381542206,
-0.5843229293823242,
0.8904659748077393,
0.2003069669008255,
0.0011417142814025283,
-0.08818651735782623,
-0.7877069711685181,
-0.16646714508533478,
0.31136661767959595,
-0.8455836772918701,
-0.35273507237434387,
-0.06579858809709549,
0.5232080817222595,
0.15327854454517365,
0.0703781247138977,
-0.6736984252929688,
-0.3271554708480835,
-0.26773908734321594,
0.1622108519077301,
0.3136097192764282,
-0.36187848448753357,
0.48319315910339355,
-0.06843309104442596,
0.8121527433395386,
-0.20842213928699493,
-0.03413071110844612,
-0.1867467164993286,
-0.29358360171318054,
-0.5774381160736084,
-0.1486571580171585,
0.5030968189239502,
0.5723802447319031,
-0.8719595670700073,
0.07115281373262405,
-0.4183519184589386,
-0.2557375133037567,
-1.185914397239685,
0.0393524244427681,
0.595767080783844,
0.11192253232002258,
0.3328607380390167,
-0.36483439803123474,
-0.43771398067474365,
-0.6963565945625305,
-0.5088592171669006,
-0.04200425744056702,
-0.06540002673864365,
0.05430072918534279,
0.4976220726966858,
-0.24747787415981293,
0.5899799466133118,
-0.07044494152069092,
-0.023833250626921654,
-0.7363731265068054,
-0.04055289551615715,
0.3059958815574646,
0.3830172121524811,
0.653745174407959,
-0.8144564032554626,
-0.22528177499771118,
0.2643357515335083,
-0.8198258876800537,
0.2833458483219147,
0.08140295743942261,
0.21750225126743317,
0.4985961318016052,
0.5264610052108765,
-0.5887941122055054,
0.3255236744880676,
0.794272780418396,
-0.5249717235565186,
0.6098303198814392,
-0.4154922664165497,
0.25625064969062805,
-0.8437832593917847,
0.2573375999927521,
-0.20323546230793,
-0.14979803562164307,
-0.9646753668785095,
0.4851195812225342,
0.23534706234931946,
0.04801193252205849,
-0.5056664347648621,
0.5743575692176819,
-0.6791442036628723,
-0.35918259620666504,
-0.03742029517889023,
-0.26651227474212646,
0.25114572048187256,
0.46267277002334595,
0.3047582805156708,
0.6413131952285767,
0.41583678126335144,
-0.5041301846504211,
0.11074676364660263,
0.22182972729206085,
-0.5564830899238586,
0.370762437582016,
-0.8457815051078796,
0.30487510561943054,
-0.29213476181030273,
-0.07205686718225479,
-0.8110576868057251,
0.060233719646930695,
-0.16428932547569275,
-0.33265945315361023,
0.38018548488616943,
-0.2673851251602173,
-0.7271168828010559,
-0.30048447847366333,
-0.0338309109210968,
0.6288986802101135,
0.32064083218574524,
-0.5053699612617493,
0.7817022204399109,
0.19845163822174072,
0.1279510110616684,
-0.6166408061981201,
-0.7557624578475952,
0.007564709987491369,
-0.1944936066865921,
-0.5747439861297607,
0.4290511906147003,
-0.01604144275188446,
-0.30916962027549744,
0.06319952011108398,
-0.11234621703624725,
-0.11915911734104156,
0.24802012741565704,
0.11033590137958527,
0.16124185919761658,
-0.40964096784591675,
-0.018619993701577187,
-0.12855462729930878,
-0.2712327241897583,
0.13353484869003296,
0.016884418204426765,
0.6371866464614868,
-0.355394572019577,
-0.4313475489616394,
-0.10763680189847946,
0.6942815184593201,
0.39441806077957153,
-0.69710773229599,
0.848353922367096,
0.5951899290084839,
-0.33229273557662964,
0.24973660707473755,
-0.6920730471611023,
-0.14596009254455566,
-0.39725154638290405,
0.303661972284317,
-0.9358193874359131,
-0.8575196862220764,
0.7107099294662476,
0.17173387110233307,
0.12486648559570312,
0.47807690501213074,
0.4584627151489258,
0.044798895716667175,
0.9842740893363953,
0.9866146445274353,
0.025766046717762947,
0.24241694808006287,
-0.3557869791984558,
0.14147043228149414,
-0.7511301636695862,
-0.26156362891197205,
-0.6924675107002258,
0.008322048000991344,
-0.49992141127586365,
-0.551608681678772,
0.11434117704629898,
0.21160267293453217,
0.04689400643110275,
0.38502952456474304,
-0.23967695236206055,
0.5853849053382874,
0.33151984214782715,
-0.325787752866745,
0.4160133898258209,
-0.013385701924562454,
-0.26198339462280273,
0.02701670676469803,
-1.092283010482788,
-0.5754629969596863,
0.9421098828315735,
0.35174328088760376,
0.7766384482383728,
0.26974228024482727,
0.6295807957649231,
0.13593433797359467,
-0.12918567657470703,
-0.6588058471679688,
0.20405004918575287,
-0.3497016727924347,
-0.5546826720237732,
-0.049138616770505905,
-0.28027603030204773,
-1.249131679534912,
0.8033689856529236,
-0.11070561408996582,
-0.4697188436985016,
0.5863714218139648,
-0.15692225098609924,
-0.03208630532026291,
0.3110077381134033,
-0.6493184566497803,
1.1346251964569092,
-0.18399520218372345,
-0.01403643749654293,
-0.24952715635299683,
-0.33014917373657227,
-0.08515123277902603,
0.2063235342502594,
0.4002322256565094,
0.016810456290841103,
0.1137903556227684,
0.8934237957000732,
0.4102671444416046,
0.5591741800308228,
-0.12361607700586319,
-0.2723638415336609,
-0.16029039025306702,
0.2653898298740387,
0.11981051415205002,
-0.19978401064872742,
-0.4310518801212311,
0.6217883229255676,
0.333071768283844,
-0.38351869583129883,
-0.40951383113861084,
0.3348008394241333,
-0.7491996884346008,
-0.35484692454338074,
-0.19249306619167328,
-0.5348449945449829,
0.07686472684144974,
0.1892964094877243,
0.4177805185317993,
0.6548160910606384,
-0.5821947455406189,
0.07636096328496933,
0.4963863492012024,
-0.07837382704019547,
0.6344214081764221,
0.6287446618080139,
0.02684543840587139,
-0.06954233348369598,
0.6630150675773621,
-0.21009239554405212,
0.2806895077228546,
0.6739570498466492,
-0.26888543367385864,
-0.47459933161735535,
-0.6344985365867615,
-0.44478294253349304,
0.27747076749801636,
-1.0380996465682983,
-0.11455654352903366,
-0.7408681511878967,
0.03662976250052452,
-0.4159613847732544,
-0.18123646080493927,
-0.5737530589103699,
-0.10400025546550751,
-0.07903974503278732,
-0.11736898869276047,
0.2032351791858673,
0.90352463722229,
-0.06390214711427689,
0.06306513398885727,
-0.6274073719978333,
0.47280222177505493,
-0.06513454765081406,
0.402231901884079,
0.05057329311966896,
-0.27662476897239685,
-0.29107022285461426,
-0.03550046309828758,
-0.02744450978934765,
-1.0189224481582642,
0.38493645191192627,
-0.06415091454982758,
0.8459240794181824,
0.3541589379310608,
0.004702339414507151,
0.534570574760437,
-0.4346563518047333,
0.527193546295166,
0.01974615827202797,
-0.933988094329834,
0.12437473237514496,
0.06202111393213272,
0.7219757437705994,
0.42298147082328796,
0.37791597843170166,
-0.7217875719070435,
-0.33009621500968933,
-0.3417263627052307,
-0.8214463591575623,
0.7878526449203491,
0.19271941483020782,
0.0699412077665329,
-0.05005490779876709,
-0.07784407585859299,
0.44855087995529175,
-0.09552281349897385,
-0.6896577477455139,
-0.13379637897014618,
-0.06570781767368317,
0.09960654377937317,
-0.4840609133243561,
-0.40167340636253357,
-0.06355747580528259,
-0.1697913110256195,
0.12783463299274445,
-0.17684122920036316,
0.615828812122345,
0.11938737332820892,
-0.7555152177810669,
0.2675650417804718,
0.5740180611610413,
0.2834759056568146,
0.7943832278251648,
-0.22077171504497528,
0.11866483837366104,
0.3909182846546173,
-0.3469165563583374,
-0.06951801478862762,
0.23496893048286438,
0.11076976358890533,
0.5151932239532471,
0.7227867841720581,
1.1718336343765259,
0.39321812987327576,
-0.5138410925865173,
0.18838772177696228,
-0.490438848733902,
-0.1102762445807457,
-0.021744852885603905,
-0.34078845381736755,
0.31371229887008667,
0.16453944146633148,
0.2708601951599121,
0.04198727756738663,
0.38415107131004333,
-0.26493313908576965,
-0.3127911388874054,
0.24813126027584076,
-0.1951989233493805,
-0.401475727558136,
0.5091418623924255,
0.23155619204044342,
-0.2838570475578308,
0.5954435467720032,
-0.185660257935524,
-0.49706146121025085,
0.7830495834350586,
0.7967872619628906,
0.832757830619812,
-0.3921911418437958,
0.038491103798151016,
0.2850596308708191,
0.4513852000236511,
-0.055977173149585724,
0.5902489423751831,
-0.27051597833633423,
-0.8845161199569702,
-0.5562387108802795,
-0.8152645826339722,
-0.18565897643566132,
0.0014537353999912739,
-1.233553409576416,
-0.26018181443214417,
0.3696921765804291,
-0.2001553475856781,
0.15948885679244995,
-0.21782788634300232,
-1.2297114133834839,
-0.11307206004858017,
0.12475763261318207,
1.09014892578125,
-0.7704573273658752,
0.8468706607818604,
0.9539695382118225,
0.029412461444735527,
-0.3015167713165283,
-0.3155037462711334,
-0.2450478971004486,
-0.298441618680954,
0.5594996809959412,
0.2601664066314697,
-0.3323488235473633,
-0.18863752484321594,
0.391203373670578,
-0.7242360711097717,
0.7078189253807068,
0.6773436069488525,
-0.42635858058929443,
-0.08113820850849152,
0.2769555449485779,
0.6774789690971375,
-0.3057553768157959,
0.4349929094314575,
0.9220827221870422,
0.40238523483276367,
-0.3650951683521271,
-1.216082215309143,
-0.15467682480812073,
-0.5140417218208313,
0.3312015235424042,
0.24158503115177155,
0.015461364760994911,
0.667033314704895,
-0.1624961644411087,
-0.5405833721160889,
-0.08237817138433456,
0.40426740050315857,
-0.021957041695713997,
0.14957214891910553,
0.3343014717102051,
0.413196861743927,
0.4144037663936615,
-0.1627672165632248,
1.6212564706802368,
-0.33071404695510864,
0.23029403388500214,
0.9568230509757996,
-0.14264389872550964,
1.062986969947815,
0.4944555163383484,
-0.32032865285873413,
0.13659153878688812,
0.5294724702835083,
0.10868837684392929,
0.5442563891410828,
-0.21318165957927704,
-0.0013896288583055139,
-0.27880242466926575,
-0.08404780924320221,
-0.4795553982257843,
0.7594133615493774,
0.14737434685230255,
0.017504815012216568,
-0.3345111906528473,
0.3364046812057495,
-0.05502384528517723,
0.07163818925619125,
-0.25649887323379517,
1.1126537322998047,
-0.09074371308088303,
-0.6033966541290283,
1.0342923402786255,
0.33051902055740356,
0.8382958769798279,
-0.4671379625797272,
0.147825688123703,
-0.335847944021225,
0.35100752115249634,
0.07750124484300613,
-0.6910508871078491,
0.5774864554405212,
0.20464597642421722,
-0.23476552963256836,
-0.28617429733276367,
0.6635600328445435,
-0.4412647783756256,
-0.44821056723594666,
0.9799468517303467,
0.6595603227615356,
0.24236135184764862,
-0.003669280093163252,
-0.6284136176109314,
0.49948611855506897,
-0.22193856537342072,
-0.12465616315603256,
0.13076651096343994,
0.055672816932201385,
0.14404937624931335,
0.5230215191841125,
0.4692379832267761,
-0.2541941702365875,
0.29382291436195374,
0.15985676646232605,
0.5941959619522095,
-0.5904325246810913,
-0.42859750986099243,
-0.7481819987297058,
0.39551302790641785,
0.15312311053276062,
-0.2738044559955597,
0.9471361041069031,
0.7913185358047485,
1.2939437627792358,
-0.4887019693851471,
0.5477834939956665,
-0.04735783860087395,
0.24735406041145325,
-0.4537546932697296,
0.7255121469497681,
-0.5230885744094849,
-0.14932551980018616,
-0.09553920477628708,
-0.9894962310791016,
-0.13679495453834534,
0.499239981174469,
-0.18626143038272858,
-0.08353619277477264,
0.6318280696868896,
0.582353949546814,
-0.10677304863929749,
0.19363480806350708,
0.47781431674957275,
-0.044136010110378265,
0.10359755903482437,
0.5647526383399963,
0.9193432927131653,
-0.5419593453407288,
0.23215024173259735,
-0.29461362957954407,
0.09704189002513885,
-0.015914151445031166,
-0.5929083824157715,
-0.8321510553359985,
-0.6686772108078003,
-0.12709647417068481,
-0.013467550277709961,
0.31450751423835754,
0.48379093408584595,
0.6207532286643982,
-0.9014837145805359,
-0.6677036285400391,
0.33380746841430664,
0.23468971252441406,
-0.6544163823127747,
-0.1825956106185913,
0.3359551429748535,
-0.29728564620018005,
-0.8094391822814941,
0.6012306809425354,
0.12423260509967804,
-0.15438824892044067,
0.050071749836206436,
-0.4677317142486572,
-0.10200463980436325,
0.09491991996765137,
0.8129922747612,
0.19196340441703796,
-0.9964966773986816,
0.4146612882614136,
0.1830846518278122,
0.01109791174530983,
0.06220071762800217,
0.9167692065238953,
-0.7622091770172119,
0.5880116820335388,
0.6476969718933105,
0.7768070101737976,
0.6703172326087952,
-0.38855403661727905,
0.63454270362854,
-0.40698832273483276,
0.21630322933197021,
0.23793445527553558,
0.4927688241004944,
0.49974727630615234,
-0.1692786067724228,
0.510039210319519,
-0.27219530940055847,
-0.099331334233284,
-0.901131272315979,
-0.013530978001654148,
-0.6922551989555359,
-0.5065924525260925,
1.0995208024978638,
-0.24372147023677826,
-0.10502929240465164,
-0.4252713918685913,
0.10238894820213318,
0.05489492416381836,
-0.14020805060863495,
0.37307700514793396,
0.6343609690666199,
0.06737995147705078,
-0.15352192521095276,
-0.6959367990493774,
0.40223318338394165,
0.3964725732803345,
-0.6729105114936829,
0.07031170278787613,
0.2515888214111328,
0.16422978043556213,
0.061371464282274246,
0.41322061419487,
-0.19517120718955994,
0.5409625172615051,
0.24696730077266693,
0.33131593465805054,
-0.055421050637960434,
-0.34750896692276,
-0.9092189073562622,
0.27255430817604065,
-0.0100942961871624,
-0.21272031962871552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13444v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13444v2 | VDebugger: Harnessing Execution Feedback for Debugging Visual Programs | 2024-06-19T11:09:16 | 2024-06-27T17:09:24 | Xueqing Wu, Zongyu Lin, Songyan Zhao, Te-Lin Wu, Pan Lu, Nanyun Peng, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Visual programs are executable code generated by large language models to
address visual reasoning problems. They decompose complex questions into
multiple reasoning steps and invoke specialized models for each step to solve
the problems. However, these programs are prone to logic errors, with our
preliminary evaluation showing that 58% of the total errors are caused by
program logic errors. Debugging complex visual programs remains a major
bottleneck for visual reasoning. To address this, we introduce VDebugger, a
novel critic-refiner framework trained to localize and debug visual programs by
tracking execution step by step. VDebugger identifies and corrects program
errors leveraging detailed execution feedback, improving interpretability and
accuracy. The training data is generated through an automated pipeline that
injects errors into correct visual programs using a novel mask-best decoding
technique. Evaluations on six datasets demonstrate VDebugger's effectiveness,
showing performance improvements of up to 3.2% in downstream task accuracy.
Further studies show VDebugger's ability to generalize to unseen tasks,
bringing a notable improvement of 2.3% on the unseen COVR task. Code, data and
models are made publicly available at https://github.com/shirley-wu/vdebugger/ | [
-0.2835484445095062,
-0.8428795337677002,
0.5780699849128723,
0.1941990703344345,
-0.044016338884830475,
0.20640458166599274,
-0.12977823615074158,
-0.3195846676826477,
-0.07409603893756866,
0.7152372598648071,
-0.4852096736431122,
-0.5353624224662781,
-0.4100947380065918,
-0.07770594209432602,
-0.39884594082832336,
0.7206003665924072,
-0.21962913870811462,
0.07894904911518097,
-0.47035926580429077,
-0.03648870065808296,
-0.7165619134902954,
-0.3408592641353607,
-0.5355663299560547,
-0.10929060727357864,
0.2879408895969391,
0.5504087805747986,
0.2065805196762085,
0.3549850285053253,
0.7528778910636902,
0.36333051323890686,
0.420320987701416,
-0.03454837203025818,
-0.7749565839767456,
0.05053684487938881,
-0.36038658022880554,
-0.8515188097953796,
-0.09282689541578293,
-0.3309336304664612,
-0.03416566178202629,
0.3207336664199829,
-0.180612251162529,
0.34365352988243103,
-0.12706345319747925,
0.72230064868927,
-1.1034224033355713,
0.2734915018081665,
-0.009426438249647617,
0.10492969304323196,
-0.06918726116418839,
-0.3227252662181854,
-0.3549148142337799,
-0.5967469215393066,
-0.12845301628112793,
-0.439754843711853,
0.3116186261177063,
-0.10039997100830078,
0.7045604586601257,
0.825610339641571,
-0.22624903917312622,
0.17992635071277618,
-0.9074828028678894,
0.586693525314331,
-0.5550327897071838,
0.02736653946340084,
-0.039805732667446136,
0.6406575441360474,
-0.05009567737579346,
-1.0048000812530518,
-0.49199801683425903,
-0.1433803141117096,
-0.01188660692423582,
0.22321175038814545,
-0.5491626858711243,
0.2679234445095062,
0.7156776189804077,
0.38826581835746765,
-0.5264760255813599,
-0.11614802479743958,
-0.49842581152915955,
-0.07142730802297592,
0.34744250774383545,
0.3446241021156311,
0.23219329118728638,
-0.010928819887340069,
-0.5822006464004517,
-0.20198942720890045,
-0.22731591761112213,
0.3517545163631439,
0.22948433458805084,
-0.23846879601478577,
0.13471674919128418,
0.3717770278453827,
-0.6823190450668335,
0.8962512612342834,
-0.02329980954527855,
0.39895838499069214,
0.23971961438655853,
-0.22110971808433533,
-0.33367738127708435,
0.00879743043333292,
0.3658168911933899,
0.8030887842178345,
0.5749409198760986,
0.1474473625421524,
-0.20022480189800262,
0.5283513069152832,
0.665993869304657,
-0.955292820930481,
-0.7744802832603455,
0.18226493895053864,
-0.1831628531217575,
-0.49818527698516846,
0.2978265583515167,
-0.7729176878929138,
-0.4965754747390747,
-0.48446643352508545,
0.39626824855804443,
-0.18579448759555817,
-0.39177584648132324,
0.3659631013870239,
-0.5120792388916016,
0.2399301677942276,
0.6050845980644226,
-0.24306859076023102,
0.20793725550174713,
0.535038411617279,
0.4519035816192627,
-0.10559884458780289,
-0.05335891619324684,
-1.2240865230560303,
-0.02373732626438141,
-0.3930276036262512,
1.0378520488739014,
-0.5791164040565491,
-0.24421405792236328,
-0.21371954679489136,
0.07015515118837357,
-0.01235471572726965,
-0.8399884104728699,
0.2340516746044159,
-0.17625771462917328,
-0.3627808094024658,
-0.488506019115448,
-0.42311006784439087,
-0.32135340571403503,
0.29537126421928406,
-0.6708393096923828,
0.982801079750061,
0.1504354476928711,
-0.711652934551239,
0.20434658229351044,
-0.47231221199035645,
-0.04029791057109833,
0.12663406133651733,
-0.4295840859413147,
-0.26043277978897095,
0.5839258432388306,
0.27696555852890015,
0.12035100907087326,
-0.10431762039661407,
-0.0028038076125085354,
-0.4371172785758972,
-0.7689617276191711,
-0.23698826134204865,
0.032445915043354034,
0.7562159895896912,
0.05915586277842522,
-0.7803922295570374,
0.5831606388092041,
-0.9490674734115601,
0.3822292387485504,
0.0790337547659874,
-0.11121544986963272,
-0.3463325500488281,
-0.03733140602707863,
-0.07446567714214325,
-0.021528856828808784,
-0.07003781199455261,
-0.46650218963623047,
0.46640273928642273,
0.11128878593444824,
0.1984257847070694,
0.9383101463317871,
0.08631172776222229,
0.04858621582388878,
0.2245565503835678,
1.1040308475494385,
0.10592301934957504,
0.249628484249115,
-0.11072696000337601,
-0.26710841059684753,
-0.8978878259658813,
-0.32067665457725525,
0.07244230806827545,
0.834903359413147,
-0.973822295665741,
-0.017696475610136986,
0.02359270490705967,
-0.34141984581947327,
-0.2974710166454315,
0.10505838692188263,
0.44045767188072205,
0.6478175520896912,
0.062211908400058746,
-0.40652936697006226,
-0.6380711793899536,
-0.7328157424926758,
-0.4164086580276489,
-0.1589130312204361,
0.2119767814874649,
0.05889157950878143,
0.6159439086914062,
-0.5756187438964844,
0.9466981291770935,
-0.9533090591430664,
-0.04721754044294357,
-0.2321179211139679,
0.08541311323642731,
0.00720713846385479,
0.3124169707298279,
0.6739598512649536,
-0.39966481924057007,
-0.2246384620666504,
-0.1886722594499588,
-0.9026170969009399,
-0.5122852325439453,
-0.09774256497621536,
-0.2009621411561966,
-0.03519449010491371,
0.832017719745636,
-0.14452554285526276,
0.8514246940612793,
0.5205203890800476,
-0.557813823223114,
0.9229719042778015,
-0.19594554603099823,
0.18666644394397736,
-0.4051676094532013,
0.12372732162475586,
-0.06047850847244263,
-0.31152233481407166,
-0.05988462641835213,
0.16608716547489166,
0.005457708146423101,
-0.12586425244808197,
-0.2555873394012451,
0.21863748133182526,
-0.23200152814388275,
-0.1014038622379303,
-0.29197630286216736,
-0.252107709646225,
0.2526269555091858,
0.4886515736579895,
-0.09282424300909042,
0.5453980565071106,
0.6616223454475403,
-0.4267837703227997,
1.0863045454025269,
-0.2508666217327118,
-0.5808790922164917,
0.913128137588501,
-0.822573721408844,
0.19381405413150787,
-0.2648024260997772,
0.05006474629044533,
-1.2006537914276123,
-0.11448831856250763,
0.33119097352027893,
-0.21033672988414764,
0.12343978881835938,
-0.2773207724094391,
-0.19012586772441864,
-0.563954770565033,
-0.25121772289276123,
-0.06912626326084137,
0.25119179487228394,
-0.6955975890159607,
0.36653152108192444,
-0.1012580543756485,
0.17092512547969818,
-0.6614591479301453,
-0.4656793177127838,
-0.020978881046175957,
0.0883450135588646,
-0.6252562403678894,
-0.27915120124816895,
-0.15536120533943176,
-0.5091074705123901,
0.30764856934547424,
-0.5852261185646057,
-0.0868442952632904,
0.19117286801338196,
0.491201251745224,
0.03193514421582222,
-0.13782329857349396,
-0.08418868482112885,
-0.26259177923202515,
-0.578762412071228,
0.28375178575515747,
-0.11847203969955444,
0.05825372785329819,
-0.45386219024658203,
-0.54327392578125,
-0.21798111498355865,
0.34980496764183044,
0.5254251956939697,
-0.5263545513153076,
0.16371604800224304,
0.942585825920105,
-0.21497809886932373,
-0.603027880191803,
-0.2767205238342285,
-0.2182714343070984,
-0.4836941957473755,
0.4555063545703888,
-0.5230324864387512,
-0.5800981521606445,
0.4156148135662079,
-0.4976736903190613,
-0.2578510046005249,
0.08356618881225586,
0.2691285014152527,
0.06167679652571678,
1.214546799659729,
0.9721207618713379,
0.20366062223911285,
0.6146630644798279,
-0.6097174882888794,
0.2996240258216858,
-0.6055380702018738,
-0.07975632697343826,
-0.38255470991134644,
-0.4056331515312195,
-0.21197135746479034,
-0.49549102783203125,
0.22427324950695038,
0.6427857875823975,
0.0804794579744339,
0.13741454482078552,
-0.7377256155014038,
0.6716833710670471,
0.8186125755310059,
0.028198814019560814,
0.26127201318740845,
-0.0549362450838089,
0.12587323784828186,
-0.2919689416885376,
-0.5415986180305481,
-0.24820493161678314,
0.6905255913734436,
-0.0772499293088913,
1.1949177980422974,
-0.0925711989402771,
0.7156094312667847,
0.3685206472873688,
0.09017670154571533,
-0.7169262766838074,
0.46106207370758057,
0.16111689805984497,
-0.1121852695941925,
0.12468066066503525,
-0.31493157148361206,
-0.36876004934310913,
0.2065415233373642,
0.2809452712535858,
-0.722650945186615,
0.3719364404678345,
0.47427260875701904,
-0.4487932324409485,
0.2290174812078476,
-1.096659779548645,
1.423233985900879,
-0.2889924943447113,
-0.5855066180229187,
-0.36519166827201843,
-0.25827324390411377,
0.3695615231990814,
0.4973353445529938,
-0.17949362099170685,
0.13662824034690857,
0.3481059670448303,
0.31352218985557556,
-0.7216917276382446,
0.893619954586029,
-0.5122127532958984,
-0.17624936997890472,
0.3992201089859009,
0.21262186765670776,
0.7134962677955627,
0.10514746606349945,
0.335315465927124,
0.11612257361412048,
0.20116302371025085,
-0.35601234436035156,
-0.9227427840232849,
0.947991132736206,
-0.3343748152256012,
-0.6378093957901001,
-0.6490478515625,
-0.05577240139245987,
0.16714654862880707,
0.08192318677902222,
0.19618405401706696,
0.49163180589675903,
0.19347146153450012,
0.21419364213943481,
0.5993140339851379,
-0.3371075391769409,
0.25980144739151,
0.5642425417900085,
-0.5190277099609375,
-0.2168445885181427,
0.9493851065635681,
0.00888446718454361,
0.10368870943784714,
0.005947060417383909,
-0.0073860445991158485,
0.2748691141605377,
-0.2622407376766205,
-0.5233626961708069,
-0.32403266429901123,
-0.8859401345252991,
-0.26048919558525085,
-0.3627460300922394,
0.16993862390518188,
0.09918231517076492,
-0.11947420984506607,
-0.37517884373664856,
-0.14409354329109192,
-0.01826750487089157,
-0.3499106168746948,
0.49384620785713196,
0.7437850832939148,
-0.1846434473991394,
0.12722572684288025,
-0.49974524974823,
0.602374255657196,
0.4430684745311737,
0.6426447629928589,
-0.23971116542816162,
0.2571659982204437,
-0.3903554677963257,
-0.23289854824543,
-0.24491454660892487,
-0.7870948314666748,
0.1925506442785263,
-0.1350816935300827,
0.40176716446876526,
0.360097736120224,
0.228956401348114,
0.876803994178772,
-0.21934013068675995,
0.7006801962852478,
0.025485029444098473,
-0.8831887245178223,
0.9463527202606201,
-0.1042553260922432,
0.5635718703269958,
0.45117467641830444,
-0.20020084083080292,
-0.20853550732135773,
-0.394551545381546,
-0.28117498755455017,
-0.8745286464691162,
0.6141800284385681,
-0.1829347312450409,
-0.32464727759361267,
-0.1044829711318016,
0.11764395236968994,
-0.08166379481554031,
0.2083388864994049,
-0.21767929196357727,
-0.025104723870754242,
-0.2399672120809555,
0.1016785204410553,
-0.0111616849899292,
-0.18894752860069275,
-0.11283587664365768,
-0.5608528256416321,
0.16667848825454712,
-0.39116740226745605,
0.22651609778404236,
0.44046610593795776,
-0.4018252193927765,
-0.31540757417678833,
-0.0061723617836833,
0.7462548613548279,
1.1121047735214233,
-0.36911487579345703,
0.25415703654289246,
-0.1641368716955185,
-0.3472817838191986,
-0.23337110877037048,
-0.13584285974502563,
-0.00743643706664443,
0.09716153144836426,
0.2776399850845337,
0.9040436148643494,
-0.056249719113111496,
-0.975640058517456,
0.6533896327018738,
-0.3620970547199249,
0.19923892617225647,
-0.5353056788444519,
0.4408332109451294,
-0.14006584882736206,
0.6165244579315186,
0.14473600685596466,
0.4671405851840973,
0.43757936358451843,
-0.33164235949516296,
0.20435671508312225,
0.091634601354599,
-0.5925151705741882,
-0.2907654345035553,
0.937745988368988,
0.36126065254211426,
0.0002929910842794925,
0.8175771236419678,
0.03250128775835037,
-0.6364022493362427,
0.9433193206787109,
0.26057231426239014,
1.1035624742507935,
0.08175448328256607,
0.1447850614786148,
0.42638057470321655,
0.28906118869781494,
0.11414282768964767,
0.6508266925811768,
-0.21100205183029175,
-0.2634361982345581,
-0.8653610348701477,
-0.5028419494628906,
-0.4941958785057068,
-0.1046174094080925,
-0.918655276298523,
0.10413657873868942,
-0.462094247341156,
-0.23918314278125763,
-0.34172874689102173,
-0.19834865629673004,
-0.6978805065155029,
0.09995085746049881,
0.1716456413269043,
0.8003972768783569,
-0.6629485487937927,
0.6645488739013672,
0.7617125511169434,
-0.49222418665885925,
-0.41278308629989624,
-0.2629404366016388,
0.07572251558303833,
-0.35174447298049927,
0.9543939828872681,
0.45254549384117126,
-0.3749270737171173,
0.0943528339266777,
-0.7962691783905029,
-0.4494236409664154,
0.7242528200149536,
0.7114043831825256,
-0.8221129775047302,
0.21949394047260284,
-0.3420948088169098,
0.5237587094306946,
-0.09041105210781097,
0.26970356702804565,
0.5472623109817505,
0.5069779753684998,
-0.1517932415008545,
-0.5963821411132812,
0.003874413901939988,
-0.558276355266571,
0.14713454246520996,
0.19634214043617249,
-0.5076813697814941,
0.5386514067649841,
-0.7203395962715149,
0.10628978908061981,
-0.2008054107427597,
0.39216378331184387,
0.0253700390458107,
0.299018919467926,
0.35879915952682495,
0.9210057854652405,
0.6300396919250488,
-0.45934396982192993,
1.3964334726333618,
-0.28253233432769775,
0.24844864010810852,
1.274101734161377,
-0.07270403206348419,
0.5972661972045898,
0.5605958104133606,
0.11213962733745575,
0.7485209107398987,
0.3554142713546753,
-0.07610401511192322,
0.5697087645530701,
0.5045238733291626,
-0.07350397109985352,
-0.3853623867034912,
0.14358264207839966,
-0.30167052149772644,
0.28513145446777344,
0.19154374301433563,
-0.22275148332118988,
-0.23200686275959015,
0.22772903740406036,
-0.17758581042289734,
-0.055649708956480026,
-0.29826536774635315,
0.4760303497314453,
-0.02803456224501133,
-0.47230497002601624,
0.7292636036872864,
-0.22517241537570953,
0.42190903425216675,
-0.41579025983810425,
-0.495681494474411,
-0.26931309700012207,
0.9266504645347595,
-0.4521132707595825,
-0.5575846433639526,
0.43219614028930664,
0.0019209299935027957,
-0.33690187335014343,
-0.20624341070652008,
0.5958444476127625,
-0.006171710789203644,
-0.24429549276828766,
0.4081515073776245,
0.15104731917381287,
-0.07923616468906403,
-0.513873279094696,
-0.3390505015850067,
0.47882410883903503,
0.24126967787742615,
-0.47078192234039307,
-0.2254582941532135,
0.3669138550758362,
-0.32606521248817444,
0.7062368988990784,
0.5032592415809631,
-0.04775474593043327,
0.34837502241134644,
0.2841968834400177,
0.710049033164978,
-0.8657534718513489,
-0.36100131273269653,
-0.7780328392982483,
0.8943092823028564,
-0.32697808742523193,
-0.2530129849910736,
0.9661058783531189,
0.5513913035392761,
1.1792097091674805,
-0.43611225485801697,
0.8420595526695251,
-0.0788814052939415,
0.17130647599697113,
-0.10229498893022537,
0.2189505249261856,
-0.3173045814037323,
0.2777814269065857,
-0.3104211390018463,
-0.9745097160339355,
-0.10243985056877136,
0.7049323320388794,
-0.4426807165145874,
-0.1752215027809143,
0.48566511273384094,
0.7597099542617798,
-0.06448598206043243,
-0.30735310912132263,
0.0820145308971405,
0.24119487404823303,
0.5195561051368713,
0.6429757475852966,
0.8680769801139832,
-0.2925008535385132,
0.473849356174469,
-0.354691743850708,
-0.3802691102027893,
-0.4548346996307373,
-0.678797721862793,
-0.6977952718734741,
-0.07869068533182144,
-0.7600858807563782,
-0.494765967130661,
0.056097496300935745,
0.26859861612319946,
0.7025747299194336,
-0.7604278922080994,
-0.19473330676555634,
-0.411886066198349,
0.08577656745910645,
-0.7087229490280151,
-0.38344714045524597,
0.02206617221236229,
-0.32446280121803284,
-0.6631577014923096,
0.1934257596731186,
0.473278284072876,
-0.46097737550735474,
-0.40418583154678345,
-0.01006312482059002,
0.3671581447124481,
-0.19904668629169464,
0.685069739818573,
0.39614951610565186,
-0.5370181202888489,
-0.47820791602134705,
-0.11617892980575562,
-0.07081042975187302,
-0.12444101274013519,
0.7429704666137695,
-1.1613844633102417,
1.0908865928649902,
0.9127814173698425,
0.4514368176460266,
0.7837773561477661,
-0.027916986495256424,
0.728360652923584,
-0.5986614227294922,
0.0760512501001358,
-0.014420716091990471,
0.2697266936302185,
0.12749379873275757,
-0.2510048747062683,
0.8343379497528076,
0.44388651847839355,
-0.23689551651477814,
-1.0199029445648193,
0.41192737221717834,
-0.9353357553482056,
-0.23906724154949188,
0.6430779695510864,
-0.03795044124126434,
-0.41230615973472595,
0.3824712634086609,
-0.7429378032684326,
-0.02112538367509842,
-0.1867813766002655,
0.6756678819656372,
0.49815765023231506,
-0.21200373768806458,
-0.4998506009578705,
-0.869855523109436,
0.5717905163764954,
0.0838201493024826,
-0.7614692449569702,
-0.01143733225762844,
0.8306408524513245,
0.5275202989578247,
0.0520588681101799,
0.44524312019348145,
0.09451095759868622,
0.563515841960907,
0.23227539658546448,
0.4738890826702118,
-0.3221530616283417,
-0.29580873250961304,
-0.40528374910354614,
0.11370493471622467,
-0.19021081924438477,
-0.5033419728279114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13443v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13443v1 | Dual-Phase Accelerated Prompt Optimization | 2024-06-19T11:08:56 | 2024-06-19T11:08:56 | Muchen Yang, Moxin Li, Yongle Li, Zijun Chen, Chongming Gao, Junqi Zhang, Yangyang Li, Fuli Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Gradient-free prompt optimization methods have made significant strides in
enhancing the performance of closed-source Large Language Models (LLMs) across
a wide range of tasks. However, existing approaches make light of the
importance of high-quality prompt initialization and the identification of
effective optimization directions, thus resulting in substantial optimization
steps to obtain satisfactory performance. In this light, we aim to accelerate
prompt optimization process to tackle the challenge of low convergence rate. We
propose a dual-phase approach which starts with generating high-quality initial
prompts by adopting a well-designed meta-instruction to delve into
task-specific information, and iteratively optimize the prompts at the sentence
level, leveraging previous tuning experience to expand prompt candidates and
accept effective ones. Extensive experiments on eight datasets demonstrate the
effectiveness of our proposed method, achieving a consistent accuracy gain over
baselines with less than five optimization steps. | [
-0.19738765060901642,
-0.7882553935050964,
0.7142236232757568,
0.5786349773406982,
-0.5299174785614014,
0.14981944859027863,
-0.49461087584495544,
0.07294868677854538,
-0.1929885298013687,
0.16512902081012726,
-1.084982991218567,
-0.41078048944473267,
-0.4099898636341095,
0.3325188457965851,
0.05909130722284317,
0.7652285099029541,
-0.10752224177122116,
0.20245052874088287,
-0.06653757393360138,
0.21638822555541992,
-0.8644635677337646,
-0.060795508325099945,
-1.0824315547943115,
-0.08638051897287369,
0.772970974445343,
0.9037023186683655,
0.257668673992157,
0.6566011309623718,
-0.00855829007923603,
0.21032774448394775,
-0.22441910207271576,
0.502335786819458,
-0.5435535907745361,
0.6120208501815796,
0.10127545148134232,
-0.17187030613422394,
-0.014258976094424725,
-0.1420425921678543,
0.8093952536582947,
0.5701890587806702,
-0.18071413040161133,
0.28882896900177,
0.33330997824668884,
0.6992051005363464,
-0.6611684560775757,
0.1668877899646759,
-0.25840216875076294,
0.04919951409101486,
-0.07118410617113113,
-0.5717315077781677,
-0.38495707511901855,
-0.4634702205657959,
-0.0015403622528538108,
-0.8167120814323425,
0.30734845995903015,
0.17998743057250977,
0.41358840465545654,
0.34350600838661194,
-0.3522833585739136,
-0.379441499710083,
-0.5922267436981201,
0.9372736811637878,
-0.44594666361808777,
0.19238288700580597,
-0.15299296379089355,
0.21623283624649048,
-0.3108072876930237,
-0.5689923167228699,
-0.36666953563690186,
-0.24637718498706818,
0.16767670214176178,
0.05829210951924324,
0.05873231962323189,
0.3227434456348419,
0.3743356764316559,
0.17921113967895508,
-0.6418612599372864,
0.2803401052951813,
-0.04035047069191933,
-0.13872821629047394,
0.3630223274230957,
0.40768197178840637,
0.2228686511516571,
-0.08965273201465607,
-0.45547565817832947,
-0.03792164847254753,
-0.45796331763267517,
0.6541458368301392,
0.36829736828804016,
0.9109556674957275,
-0.07002837210893631,
0.5306800603866577,
-0.3358936607837677,
0.481110155582428,
0.46894821524620056,
-0.14939874410629272,
0.08651456236839294,
-0.8263071179389954,
0.169733464717865,
0.04722317308187485,
0.7181230187416077,
0.34021350741386414,
-0.03571830317378044,
0.061178866773843765,
-0.3828899562358856,
-0.006218249443918467,
0.03944411873817444,
-0.9621991515159607,
0.3067290186882019,
0.4278368353843689,
-0.19544832408428192,
-0.14784617722034454,
-0.29574471712112427,
-1.2710239887237549,
-0.5988869667053223,
-0.5311039090156555,
0.4738951325416565,
-0.05732958763837814,
0.06871388107538223,
0.1615906059741974,
-0.05228947475552559,
0.11610880494117737,
0.3373415172100067,
-0.8534737825393677,
0.0033752014860510826,
0.7822198271751404,
0.8430940508842468,
0.08558141440153122,
0.013700716197490692,
-1.2867357730865479,
-0.19450229406356812,
-0.3666163384914398,
0.5834193825721741,
-0.666585385799408,
-0.6406453251838684,
0.1944550722837448,
-0.17403049767017365,
0.0669487714767456,
-0.18181072175502777,
1.0676674842834473,
-0.4718198776245117,
0.4297598600387573,
-0.6892931461334229,
-0.07306407392024994,
-0.06320668756961823,
-0.06375470757484436,
-0.36409541964530945,
1.3949798345565796,
-0.04841405525803566,
-0.6212125420570374,
0.24822154641151428,
-0.7139483094215393,
-0.590995728969574,
0.11305300891399384,
-0.03822200000286102,
-0.008001080714166164,
0.3868662118911743,
0.5731582641601562,
0.29521986842155457,
-0.7159181833267212,
0.4097687900066376,
0.25170600414276123,
-0.3920762240886688,
-0.3304058611392975,
-0.22778169810771942,
0.5594838857650757,
-0.062779001891613,
-0.3889528810977936,
0.4468883275985718,
-0.7536013722419739,
-0.05348445475101471,
0.04458018019795418,
-0.40429237484931946,
-0.21387603878974915,
-0.02362764999270439,
-0.3922491669654846,
0.19272039830684662,
0.4620682895183563,
-0.5059612989425659,
0.33578354120254517,
-0.573117733001709,
0.08678317070007324,
0.926851212978363,
0.11059659719467163,
0.5971761345863342,
-0.038215480744838715,
0.9042568802833557,
0.02959519252181053,
0.22679641842842102,
-0.6157262921333313,
-0.4175712466239929,
-0.8952610492706299,
-0.29523220658302307,
0.05115806311368942,
0.9290372133255005,
-0.8548380732536316,
0.559586763381958,
0.021150482818484306,
-0.1370246261358261,
-0.7215176224708557,
0.25454869866371155,
0.4655356705188751,
0.9900155067443848,
0.5045969486236572,
0.04375680163502693,
-0.33756768703460693,
-0.8645740747451782,
-0.3831043541431427,
0.23014329373836517,
0.08293607831001282,
0.40931373834609985,
-0.021256964653730392,
-0.08557463437318802,
0.8066015243530273,
-0.6250797510147095,
0.23140929639339447,
-0.25671613216400146,
0.48393571376800537,
0.7331596612930298,
0.28862130641937256,
0.20920996367931366,
-0.4905359745025635,
-0.7443368434906006,
-0.37016230821609497,
-0.4917779266834259,
-0.6854798793792725,
-0.1683349758386612,
-0.2945922613143921,
0.012581265531480312,
0.23558369278907776,
-0.5652652382850647,
-0.07707139104604721,
0.39038121700286865,
-0.44951990246772766,
0.5669677257537842,
-0.22978441417217255,
0.27144157886505127,
-0.9741759300231934,
-0.01902880147099495,
0.1080743595957756,
-0.06011422351002693,
-0.8140040636062622,
-0.013801736757159233,
0.10888813436031342,
-0.44116467237472534,
-0.15779712796211243,
0.7930307388305664,
-0.8048155903816223,
0.27827057242393494,
-0.35640326142311096,
0.3282610774040222,
0.007067572325468063,
0.5593448877334595,
-0.3484470546245575,
1.2183748483657837,
0.8224634528160095,
-0.6110864281654358,
0.29586002230644226,
0.11607135087251663,
-0.298023521900177,
0.49157845973968506,
-0.7293905019760132,
0.2837715148925781,
-0.7042643427848816,
0.12925267219543457,
-1.1921188831329346,
0.2038988173007965,
0.4668025076389313,
-0.0341809019446373,
0.5317366123199463,
0.07258966565132141,
-0.4855590760707855,
-0.6495192050933838,
-0.5694966912269592,
0.435965895652771,
0.6499745845794678,
-0.6933367252349854,
0.5237888693809509,
-0.3635220527648926,
-0.6145700812339783,
-0.9335107207298279,
-0.08846080303192139,
0.03939313814043999,
-0.04539456591010094,
-0.7885450720787048,
0.08549266308546066,
-0.37283846735954285,
0.054688289761543274,
-0.44358178973197937,
-0.050176940858364105,
0.2926582992076874,
0.04125603288412094,
0.024279750883579254,
0.058634839951992035,
-0.27044054865837097,
0.08341427892446518,
0.56134033203125,
-0.47520720958709717,
-0.18155302107334137,
-0.5239178538322449,
0.6898297071456909,
0.31417185068130493,
0.1601458638906479,
-0.8827680945396423,
0.6741750836372375,
0.332246333360672,
-0.26397767663002014,
0.6099756956100464,
0.5687735080718994,
-0.11966674029827118,
-0.5542771220207214,
-0.3636581301689148,
-0.2925187647342682,
-0.5941725373268127,
0.18595413863658905,
-0.3772217631340027,
-0.7464731931686401,
0.28976505994796753,
-0.0905207172036171,
0.23809382319450378,
0.13475890457630157,
0.5563259124755859,
0.14132224023342133,
0.953217625617981,
0.5422582626342773,
0.17350779473781586,
0.5742488503456116,
0.05384719371795654,
0.3229832649230957,
-0.7790306210517883,
-0.14620380103588104,
-0.8258877992630005,
-0.35722342133522034,
-0.16338247060775757,
-0.7999371290206909,
0.6085502505302429,
0.28239205479621887,
-0.2333718091249466,
0.08315647393465042,
-0.4535667896270752,
0.36068540811538696,
0.7468003630638123,
0.0808677226305008,
0.27353596687316895,
-0.050958964973688126,
-0.47629085183143616,
-0.12160634249448776,
-0.6162829995155334,
-0.40396323800086975,
0.8625866770744324,
0.2754116356372833,
0.5572578310966492,
-0.2757219672203064,
0.6066617369651794,
0.2428918182849884,
-0.10543213784694672,
-0.7025090456008911,
0.5676029324531555,
-0.16753466427326202,
-0.22018206119537354,
-0.2339586317539215,
-0.5478758811950684,
-0.7994128465652466,
0.27117523550987244,
-0.1315300017595291,
-0.4758913815021515,
0.12072575092315674,
0.2705935537815094,
-0.6414609551429749,
-0.23384465277194977,
-0.5817490220069885,
0.7495502829551697,
-0.31745168566703796,
-0.34995943307876587,
-0.20534057915210724,
-0.7115638256072998,
0.3254779279232025,
-0.20010781288146973,
0.35183703899383545,
-0.27089232206344604,
-0.49195465445518494,
0.5294731259346008,
-0.2553756833076477,
0.5948755145072937,
-0.6915979385375977,
-0.30140990018844604,
0.1948123574256897,
-0.13639751076698303,
0.8788869976997375,
0.1962793469429016,
-0.24426433444023132,
-0.26409295201301575,
-0.4248388111591339,
-0.42118722200393677,
-0.6757002472877502,
0.4761775732040405,
-0.4260353446006775,
-0.6265764832496643,
-0.14762461185455322,
-0.513573169708252,
-0.41122227907180786,
0.2502754032611847,
0.1998129040002823,
0.7984318137168884,
-0.03215819597244263,
-0.28661438822746277,
0.7515662908554077,
-0.4818311333656311,
0.680828869342804,
0.6344553828239441,
0.12790389358997345,
-0.67702716588974,
0.61823970079422,
-0.35385435819625854,
0.22420495748519897,
0.4516507089138031,
0.5114739537239075,
-0.32917162775993347,
-0.7555442452430725,
-0.6340495347976685,
0.42469656467437744,
-0.5466247797012329,
-0.2181839942932129,
-0.7354546189308167,
0.3671247363090515,
-0.4244391918182373,
-0.20824797451496124,
-0.1261802315711975,
-0.30670589208602905,
-0.6763082146644592,
0.20436599850654602,
0.06563446670770645,
0.2149752378463745,
0.11159500479698181,
0.5850513577461243,
-0.9650728106498718,
0.47866761684417725,
0.18146342039108276,
0.046340931206941605,
-0.17240187525749207,
-0.5785197019577026,
-0.1346803605556488,
0.08145205676555634,
-0.1511688381433487,
-0.721333384513855,
0.21941374242305756,
0.29650431871414185,
0.7204118371009827,
0.507091224193573,
0.16123421490192413,
0.4930709898471832,
-0.8141371011734009,
0.985293447971344,
0.3261057138442993,
-0.8140971660614014,
0.7032552361488342,
-0.41723397374153137,
0.572945773601532,
0.7618278861045837,
0.4419233500957489,
-0.4928741157054901,
-0.12081007659435272,
-0.0075056483037769794,
-0.8568232655525208,
0.7463343739509583,
-0.14316719770431519,
0.30561554431915283,
0.09118857234716415,
0.6458252668380737,
0.30788835883140564,
0.5497239232063293,
-0.17150793969631195,
-0.40948864817619324,
0.23379677534103394,
-0.4036521017551422,
-0.2298140525817871,
-0.7263356447219849,
-0.30199307203292847,
-0.05666884779930115,
0.7301143407821655,
-0.4199826717376709,
0.3063335716724396,
0.006436958443373442,
0.1326529085636139,
-0.4540484845638275,
0.3539884388446808,
0.8901844024658203,
0.40196526050567627,
0.10396725684404373,
-0.2414681613445282,
-0.002476631896570325,
-0.4391336143016815,
0.32679781317710876,
0.37263813614845276,
-0.4370734393596649,
-0.059864964336156845,
0.09402287006378174,
0.90428626537323,
0.2522377669811249,
-0.5550328493118286,
0.649960458278656,
-0.16381648182868958,
0.12036646157503128,
0.1781061887741089,
0.06167878583073616,
-0.17602510750293732,
0.5256259441375732,
0.5691452622413635,
-0.2555338740348816,
0.10957616567611694,
-0.30021077394485474,
-0.04196694865822792,
0.5690421462059021,
-0.04386863857507706,
-0.3343411386013031,
0.6557536721229553,
0.694147527217865,
-0.4288977384567261,
0.5738187432289124,
-0.27178531885147095,
-0.5206020474433899,
0.3580302894115448,
0.5071592926979065,
1.2808648347854614,
-0.33941733837127686,
0.19995422661304474,
0.6983013153076172,
0.28326350450515747,
-0.2439873069524765,
0.7003199458122253,
-0.16601690649986267,
-0.49019989371299744,
-0.5836108922958374,
-0.8475179672241211,
-0.20373974740505219,
-0.3754756450653076,
-0.4702778160572052,
0.697319746017456,
-0.5197815895080566,
-0.12822918593883514,
-0.47069051861763,
0.1946023851633072,
-0.5180163979530334,
0.07947485148906708,
0.14049682021141052,
0.9907596111297607,
-0.6317650079727173,
0.38530048727989197,
0.23410524427890778,
-0.05552707612514496,
-0.576581597328186,
0.01885133981704712,
0.05818702280521393,
-0.9261541366577148,
0.42225614190101624,
0.36574968695640564,
-0.15473738312721252,
0.19494251906871796,
-0.3204033672809601,
-0.8367763161659241,
1.1311737298965454,
0.28600838780403137,
-0.9120497107505798,
-0.42121413350105286,
-0.18550732731819153,
0.2556888461112976,
-0.32522109150886536,
0.19908910989761353,
0.3603163957595825,
0.6127665638923645,
0.25190040469169617,
-0.8012745380401611,
0.24258746206760406,
0.03145855665206909,
0.12083866447210312,
0.4974227249622345,
-0.6952930092811584,
0.7368558645248413,
-0.3225080370903015,
-0.7049477100372314,
0.22412344813346863,
0.8086166977882385,
0.1063082367181778,
0.357467383146286,
0.6185908913612366,
0.4488462805747986,
1.0203572511672974,
0.016167424619197845,
0.8986428380012512,
-0.5886468887329102,
0.20752951502799988,
0.9053323864936829,
-0.24105221033096313,
0.4192323386669159,
0.48774686455726624,
0.037825439125299454,
0.6080417633056641,
0.6929245591163635,
0.11850553750991821,
0.6836663484573364,
0.19099068641662598,
-0.632997453212738,
-0.14485178887844086,
-0.39570119976997375,
-0.23460952937602997,
-0.11501563340425491,
0.20250481367111206,
-0.3320889174938202,
-0.33946433663368225,
0.09315898269414902,
-0.004608372692018747,
0.043397221714258194,
-0.4246748983860016,
0.5533990263938904,
-0.03491586819291115,
-0.8464702367782593,
0.5621174573898315,
0.07183247804641724,
0.7678706049919128,
-0.6714333891868591,
0.1829654425382614,
-0.3879031538963318,
-0.3284446895122528,
0.0967167392373085,
-0.4021293520927429,
-0.24586716294288635,
0.12477407604455948,
-0.30360648036003113,
-0.6185140609741211,
0.5001813173294067,
-0.5749869346618652,
-0.4164249897003174,
0.17251695692539215,
0.4434255063533783,
-0.2064225822687149,
0.06216946244239807,
-0.6095257997512817,
-0.10924389213323593,
-0.138014554977417,
-0.3821806311607361,
-0.06370725482702255,
0.41134676337242126,
0.3098691403865814,
0.49582841992378235,
0.6678032875061035,
0.10358037799596786,
0.09968699514865875,
-0.046026602387428284,
0.8933126926422119,
-0.6907574534416199,
-0.5877756476402283,
-0.7630994915962219,
0.8271162509918213,
0.08113071322441101,
-0.3854980170726776,
0.49552005529403687,
0.4979616403579712,
0.04052003473043442,
0.06524083018302917,
0.6620631814002991,
0.20221801102161407,
0.6716397404670715,
-0.7995920181274414,
-0.10457022488117218,
-0.5978796482086182,
0.22458453476428986,
-0.12690725922584534,
-1.1304404735565186,
-0.06901713460683823,
0.048702627420425415,
0.002254404593259096,
-0.010242963209748268,
0.8802049160003662,
1.020310878753662,
0.1414879709482193,
0.03793879225850105,
0.09508974105119705,
0.04434874281287193,
0.23725369572639465,
0.6702699065208435,
0.8486177921295166,
-0.04884014651179314,
0.3606562912464142,
-0.17197924852371216,
-0.5920536518096924,
-0.16197939217090607,
-1.082392692565918,
-0.895045816898346,
-0.30480584502220154,
-0.17069971561431885,
-0.33770808577537537,
0.08096782118082047,
1.1596405506134033,
0.4266778230667114,
-0.6333618760108948,
-0.04928379878401756,
0.0019892172422260046,
0.022449644282460213,
-0.11045767366886139,
-0.20019197463989258,
0.07943368703126907,
-0.8946481943130493,
-0.8886321783065796,
1.011702060699463,
0.34371522068977356,
-0.12307952344417572,
-0.27575844526290894,
0.06488088518381119,
0.0028700672555714846,
0.37434419989585876,
0.4799201190471649,
0.1878918558359146,
-0.5339424014091492,
-0.08290233463048935,
0.18935731053352356,
-0.2812080681324005,
0.06444419175386429,
1.2347198724746704,
-0.503294050693512,
0.477505624294281,
0.7735785245895386,
0.7261229157447815,
0.24934571981430054,
0.4851922392845154,
0.8760334253311157,
-0.9115066528320312,
0.17690572142601013,
0.2929328978061676,
0.07841090112924576,
0.3192800283432007,
-0.6876999735832214,
0.24448786675930023,
0.3440454304218292,
-0.6120011210441589,
-0.8570526242256165,
0.13903912901878357,
-1.0988962650299072,
-0.19631963968276978,
1.4194388389587402,
0.11776531487703323,
0.06728408485651016,
0.10109572112560272,
-0.43460509181022644,
0.30271077156066895,
-0.8170533776283264,
0.46538245677948,
0.5037496089935303,
-0.27608829736709595,
-0.2704932391643524,
-0.5626211166381836,
0.5737974643707275,
0.5485184788703918,
-0.6608024835586548,
0.11366315186023712,
0.70826256275177,
-0.013070681132376194,
-0.021835558116436005,
0.6501287817955017,
0.31880614161491394,
0.18439297378063202,
-0.14877115190029144,
-0.24914444983005524,
-0.16309241950511932,
-0.5610849261283875,
-0.8189972639083862,
0.2918255925178528,
0.062439024448394775,
-0.2407304048538208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13439v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13439v1 | Finding Blind Spots in Evaluator LLMs with Interpretable Checklists | 2024-06-19T10:59:48 | 2024-06-19T10:59:48 | Sumanth Doddapaneni, Mohammed Safi Ur Rahman Khan, Sshubam Verma, Mitesh M. Khapra | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly relied upon to evaluate text
outputs of other LLMs, thereby influencing leaderboards and development
decisions. However, concerns persist over the accuracy of these assessments and
the potential for misleading conclusions. In this work, we investigate the
effectiveness of LLMs as evaluators for text generation tasks. We propose FBI,
a novel framework designed to examine the proficiency of Evaluator LLMs in
assessing four critical abilities in other LLMs: factual accuracy, instruction
following, coherence in long-form writing, and reasoning proficiency. By
introducing targeted perturbations in answers generated by LLMs, that clearly
impact one of these key capabilities, we test whether an Evaluator LLM can
detect these quality drops. By creating a total of 2400 perturbed answers
covering 22 perturbation categories, we conduct a comprehensive study using
different evaluation strategies on five prominent LLMs commonly used as
evaluators in the literature. Our findings reveal significant shortcomings in
current Evaluator LLMs, which failed to identify quality drops in over 50\% of
cases on average. Single-answer and pairwise evaluations demonstrated notable
limitations, whereas reference-based evaluations showed comparatively better
performance. These results underscore the unreliable nature of current
Evaluator LLMs and advocate for cautious implementation in practical
applications. Code and data are available at https://github.com/AI4Bharat/FBI. | [
-0.22478756308555603,
-0.8880097270011902,
0.880046010017395,
0.3416080176830292,
-0.07211080938577652,
0.39063432812690735,
-0.03445075824856758,
-0.43572357296943665,
-0.050073809921741486,
0.588782012462616,
-0.36904165148735046,
-0.6649739742279053,
-0.7029978036880493,
0.3088850677013397,
-0.6810832619667053,
1.22135329246521,
-0.3042449951171875,
-0.20200195908546448,
-0.38454702496528625,
0.0198013037443161,
-0.4821152091026306,
-0.2622137665748596,
-0.3030855357646942,
-0.3584665358066559,
0.3859022557735443,
0.6184411644935608,
0.5421404838562012,
0.3329484164714813,
0.7503072023391724,
0.2682459056377411,
-0.14122842252254486,
0.2709219753742218,
-0.4697343409061432,
0.05124421790242195,
-0.10767264664173126,
-0.4271617829799652,
-0.6442410349845886,
0.08931911736726761,
0.7242746949195862,
0.5579860210418701,
0.03069896437227726,
0.32515883445739746,
0.266426682472229,
0.39014455676078796,
-0.701973021030426,
0.04749872907996178,
-0.5519552826881409,
-0.017771072685718536,
-0.3567180037498474,
-0.37126222252845764,
-0.4873305857181549,
-0.4053764045238495,
-0.01406935416162014,
-0.18382374942302704,
0.3184604346752167,
-0.19526369869709015,
0.7336513996124268,
0.4227806329727173,
-0.4142968952655792,
-0.4365549385547638,
-0.7148639559745789,
0.7960845232009888,
-0.7950366139411926,
0.25036391615867615,
0.4825972020626068,
0.07571493089199066,
-0.2468041479587555,
-0.5984188318252563,
-0.6580910682678223,
-0.404396116733551,
0.10169635713100433,
0.1430390328168869,
-0.044879406690597534,
0.02983194775879383,
0.22440247237682343,
0.4069773554801941,
-0.45803576707839966,
0.2418658286333084,
-0.01159062422811985,
-0.3680875599384308,
0.6193521022796631,
0.3626411259174347,
-0.0008310529519803822,
-0.22012513875961304,
-0.2601597011089325,
0.20538535714149475,
-0.7683815360069275,
0.3720737099647522,
0.45346498489379883,
-0.047575850039720535,
0.0736021101474762,
0.6403445601463318,
-0.24490341544151306,
0.645217776298523,
0.13091427087783813,
-0.3116661608219147,
0.08339551091194153,
-0.4027308225631714,
-0.2104402333498001,
-0.5246284008026123,
0.48362594842910767,
0.13618391752243042,
-0.06331124156713486,
0.1769016832113266,
-0.47452500462532043,
-0.16347892582416534,
0.19499161839485168,
-0.7875147461891174,
-0.23064947128295898,
0.2663542628288269,
-0.2963160276412964,
-0.5260109901428223,
0.023702479898929596,
-0.6261054873466492,
-0.673874020576477,
0.045909225940704346,
0.3069314658641815,
-0.16467083990573883,
0.09873703867197037,
-0.09932537376880646,
0.11541859060525894,
0.05747766047716141,
0.433060884475708,
-0.6960959434509277,
0.22537319362163544,
0.4993686378002167,
0.5035730600357056,
-0.2834935188293457,
-0.29790377616882324,
-0.7794146537780762,
-0.22188062965869904,
-0.3645613491535187,
0.978001058101654,
-0.5346181988716125,
-0.19330088794231415,
0.18022336065769196,
-0.2974588871002197,
0.051736220717430115,
-0.6840676069259644,
0.5910839438438416,
-0.4890226423740387,
0.01190893817692995,
0.04951358959078789,
-0.5368762016296387,
-0.13367196917533875,
0.278308242559433,
-0.5382384061813354,
0.8893797993659973,
0.05055174231529236,
-0.4426210820674896,
0.3518982529640198,
-0.4159919023513794,
-0.4644007384777069,
0.13611066341400146,
-0.3182198107242584,
-0.5808771848678589,
0.22042185068130493,
0.09122604131698608,
0.5896769762039185,
-0.4844695031642914,
0.3105004131793976,
-0.06723352521657944,
-0.5903655290603638,
0.7312783598899841,
-0.7145292162895203,
0.5815688371658325,
-0.036208901554346085,
-0.5087451934814453,
0.2148723304271698,
-1.033754587173462,
0.1880028396844864,
-0.08263743668794632,
-0.841310441493988,
0.2004169225692749,
0.11568205058574677,
0.13349299132823944,
-0.0672973021864891,
0.16010409593582153,
-0.28986701369285583,
-0.29012906551361084,
-0.19505439698696136,
0.1114010214805603,
0.8644447326660156,
0.12217126786708832,
-0.058310430496931076,
-0.35173463821411133,
0.8944031000137329,
-0.18734857439994812,
-0.002038518898189068,
-0.2401326298713684,
-0.415809690952301,
-0.806283712387085,
-0.20251396298408508,
0.31240174174308777,
0.4080832600593567,
-0.8364887833595276,
0.6073344349861145,
-0.09127934277057648,
-0.5799621343612671,
-0.37591010332107544,
0.609757661819458,
0.7854675054550171,
0.3272137939929962,
0.08615739643573761,
-0.1753331571817398,
-0.12871915102005005,
-0.8211220502853394,
-0.28331825137138367,
-0.3153037130832672,
-0.02912020869553089,
0.08353006839752197,
0.5634395480155945,
-0.21341727674007416,
0.8433676362037659,
-0.24508807063102722,
-0.22572146356105804,
-0.42241743206977844,
-0.02435258962213993,
0.049090754240751266,
0.2695026695728302,
0.32213500142097473,
-0.45630940794944763,
-0.34251779317855835,
-0.21296681463718414,
-0.5594913959503174,
-0.35190603137016296,
-0.15652571618556976,
0.03338434174656868,
0.35975509881973267,
0.31048476696014404,
-0.3695869743824005,
0.49517324566841125,
0.8073238134384155,
-0.6119410991668701,
0.8500349521636963,
0.17966389656066895,
0.013844218105077744,
-0.6705754995346069,
0.2347964346408844,
-0.09246322512626648,
-0.16546018421649933,
-0.6253497004508972,
0.07536501437425613,
0.1524231880903244,
0.13931821286678314,
-0.3312166631221771,
0.5707583427429199,
-0.3849066495895386,
0.04719225689768791,
-0.2062608152627945,
0.44759830832481384,
0.22587959468364716,
0.33131641149520874,
-0.45043709874153137,
0.5492203235626221,
0.15684010088443756,
-0.34908929467201233,
0.2985113859176636,
0.2550641596317291,
-0.6711475253105164,
0.5758355855941772,
-0.32049497961997986,
0.2802763283252716,
0.10898160934448242,
0.19485652446746826,
-1.0793339014053345,
-0.3846873641014099,
0.17139646410942078,
-0.3352245092391968,
0.38686075806617737,
0.2196652740240097,
-0.47903236746788025,
-0.3031376600265503,
-0.46439701318740845,
0.1787423938512802,
0.1619856059551239,
-0.5193427205085754,
0.3628963828086853,
0.16663549840450287,
-0.18597868084907532,
-0.8572106957435608,
-0.6911622881889343,
0.08594056963920593,
0.0021239572670310736,
-0.5136604905128479,
-0.08539949357509613,
-0.2805796265602112,
-0.3114379346370697,
-0.040477052330970764,
-0.4410599172115326,
-0.02656841278076172,
0.536740779876709,
0.22464267909526825,
0.31248828768730164,
-0.1757999211549759,
0.1115170270204544,
0.14248314499855042,
0.08943408727645874,
0.1954674869775772,
0.22337450087070465,
0.33142369985580444,
-0.1798645704984665,
-0.566603422164917,
-0.4053729474544525,
-0.07995712757110596,
0.43799319863319397,
-0.23899708688259125,
0.39517319202423096,
0.39856740832328796,
-0.1498996913433075,
-0.5020104050636292,
-0.7262554168701172,
-0.06525615602731705,
-0.4684460461139679,
0.6311469078063965,
-0.4344911575317383,
-0.7402271628379822,
0.5357854962348938,
0.12446349114179611,
0.13939428329467773,
0.2416447550058365,
0.40943148732185364,
-0.07762344926595688,
0.7196226119995117,
0.6502212285995483,
0.28843745589256287,
0.43097198009490967,
-0.274753212928772,
0.33279749751091003,
-0.9189119338989258,
-0.2430465668439865,
-0.48206934332847595,
-0.15009354054927826,
-0.29073476791381836,
-0.41295647621154785,
0.20380528271198273,
0.2615463435649872,
0.17942629754543304,
-0.12317972630262375,
-0.2224045991897583,
0.5623976588249207,
0.23904842138290405,
0.058877795934677124,
0.41687971353530884,
-0.05249681696295738,
-0.19057351350784302,
0.03981906548142433,
-0.515049397945404,
-0.8804292678833008,
1.1990854740142822,
0.5985077023506165,
0.6617687344551086,
0.13844415545463562,
0.6522474884986877,
0.37782591581344604,
0.806037425994873,
-0.7608287334442139,
0.7084190249443054,
-0.006240646354854107,
-0.5189073085784912,
-0.493762344121933,
-0.3249943256378174,
-0.7455613613128662,
0.18805381655693054,
-0.37948909401893616,
-0.49781113862991333,
0.20690272748470306,
0.08575236797332764,
-0.336280882358551,
0.007846832275390625,
-0.45500725507736206,
0.9406751990318298,
-0.3192199170589447,
-0.5366185307502747,
-0.031233234331011772,
-0.14570461213588715,
0.45991864800453186,
-0.5782420635223389,
0.08202067017555237,
-0.24881713092327118,
-0.10320240259170532,
0.645508885383606,
-0.21842171251773834,
0.8242923021316528,
-0.08304739743471146,
-0.3527005612850189,
0.30752459168434143,
0.17187577486038208,
0.6149737238883972,
-0.034894127398729324,
-0.3911812901496887,
0.35564395785331726,
-0.2463650107383728,
-0.360943466424942,
-0.7104595303535461,
0.5363524556159973,
-0.4738669693470001,
-0.928708553314209,
-0.3227851092815399,
-0.5197015404701233,
-0.34261998534202576,
0.2669541537761688,
0.1487799882888794,
0.4305589199066162,
-0.25506269931793213,
0.2930510640144348,
0.12484472990036011,
-0.25350409746170044,
0.23428669571876526,
0.713411271572113,
-0.2954927086830139,
-0.30902063846588135,
0.8904318809509277,
0.061236750334501266,
0.30612704157829285,
0.04652831330895424,
0.054406799376010895,
-0.12872298061847687,
-1.2228807210922241,
-0.4557589590549469,
0.18810030817985535,
-0.942338228225708,
-0.27966150641441345,
-0.19657477736473083,
-0.35217422246932983,
-0.27985092997550964,
-0.1057562530040741,
0.05498959869146347,
-0.26403746008872986,
-0.2944887578487396,
-0.2583523988723755,
-0.1346404105424881,
0.926612138748169,
0.3107685446739197,
0.18639659881591797,
-0.6676055788993835,
0.11645001173019409,
0.20807616412639618,
0.4137590825557709,
-0.051572300493717194,
-0.6916426420211792,
-0.5667625069618225,
-0.2074383944272995,
-0.6959827542304993,
-0.8702983260154724,
0.2136550098657608,
-0.023998087272047997,
0.5730976462364197,
0.5485106706619263,
0.01833028718829155,
0.584403932094574,
-0.17841199040412903,
0.786853015422821,
0.0031316354870796204,
-1.1989352703094482,
0.5087867379188538,
-0.09678887575864792,
0.19342491030693054,
0.5792926549911499,
0.03187653794884682,
-0.014586934819817543,
-1.0919675827026367,
-0.4219724237918854,
-0.6243728399276733,
0.7540166974067688,
0.510881245136261,
-0.08811137825250626,
0.12058531492948532,
0.33234697580337524,
0.01025629322975874,
0.2640736699104309,
-0.6506575345993042,
-0.17242759466171265,
0.0870671272277832,
-0.3198532462120056,
-0.2580929398536682,
-0.5771936178207397,
0.025107525289058685,
0.12758159637451172,
0.5617862939834595,
-0.12111333012580872,
-0.2545336186885834,
0.23082000017166138,
-0.16157753765583038,
-0.3080313801765442,
0.4635159969329834,
0.5793449282646179,
1.0011441707611084,
-0.11379117518663406,
0.1780163198709488,
0.12197265774011612,
-0.5790147185325623,
0.22010347247123718,
0.18804161250591278,
-0.4462090730667114,
-0.05734432488679886,
0.7148904800415039,
0.5826120972633362,
0.14117854833602905,
-1.0779608488082886,
0.4709073603153229,
0.043358951807022095,
-0.16193249821662903,
-0.3756520450115204,
0.2320716381072998,
-0.12752099335193634,
0.2747577428817749,
0.41285330057144165,
0.17093908786773682,
0.2580253481864929,
-0.5788132548332214,
-0.03333468362689018,
0.46367040276527405,
-0.33428722620010376,
-0.3017817735671997,
0.4530514180660248,
0.4837522804737091,
-0.551648736000061,
0.4193849265575409,
-0.08499088138341904,
-0.4478074610233307,
0.8238022327423096,
0.4873140752315521,
0.9579060077667236,
-0.2788698077201843,
0.2708476781845093,
-0.15114286541938782,
0.5372151136398315,
0.19938135147094727,
0.23240484297275543,
-0.11458384245634079,
-0.7536991238594055,
-0.42655718326568604,
-0.7249228954315186,
-0.6896523237228394,
0.3506704866886139,
-0.5096879601478577,
0.18397752940654755,
-0.5006020069122314,
-0.3134039044380188,
0.015152732841670513,
0.23735715448856354,
-0.661749005317688,
0.02839178964495659,
-0.07508033514022827,
0.5878243446350098,
-0.6655198931694031,
0.6619272828102112,
0.7921698689460754,
-0.41346436738967896,
-0.8312385678291321,
0.39401474595069885,
0.03662267327308655,
-0.5369908213615417,
0.6776411533355713,
0.18598133325576782,
-0.10939358174800873,
-0.19704973697662354,
-0.2765309512615204,
-0.8131812214851379,
0.9709727764129639,
0.34631627798080444,
-0.6442769169807434,
0.11620723456144333,
0.2944776117801666,
0.7475398778915405,
-0.2205280214548111,
0.39904436469078064,
0.9008566737174988,
0.6357595920562744,
-0.2544010579586029,
-1.0088331699371338,
0.3506286144256592,
-0.31584033370018005,
-0.16441330313682556,
-0.000046705816203029826,
-0.6288262009620667,
0.6048377156257629,
-0.33774885535240173,
-0.3512927293777466,
0.46383559703826904,
0.2080896496772766,
0.5157225131988525,
0.7194604277610779,
0.2686225175857544,
0.2144256830215454,
0.7580775022506714,
0.03479759767651558,
1.0405654907226562,
-0.17795014381408691,
0.12314103543758392,
0.9675192832946777,
-0.4299986660480499,
0.9989871978759766,
0.37098145484924316,
-0.104814812541008,
0.5610593557357788,
0.294729083776474,
-0.19299346208572388,
0.027550555765628815,
0.4131309390068054,
-0.18613211810588837,
-0.17607271671295166,
0.01549674291163683,
0.2383168637752533,
0.47525960206985474,
0.20555229485034943,
-0.35235244035720825,
0.0613870695233345,
-0.010392850264906883,
-0.10438250005245209,
0.3203035891056061,
-0.005521078128367662,
0.524341881275177,
0.00660815229639411,
-0.7366734147071838,
0.680499255657196,
0.01718844845890999,
0.38190126419067383,
-0.2133491337299347,
-0.27886027097702026,
-0.4335387647151947,
0.29846829175949097,
-0.5016863346099854,
-0.9443654417991638,
0.12974072992801666,
0.365261971950531,
-0.06238510459661484,
-0.23909611999988556,
0.5913227796554565,
-0.1735728681087494,
-0.49363207817077637,
0.21809431910514832,
0.6061359643936157,
0.3560504615306854,
0.08082159608602524,
-0.4247608184814453,
0.2811308205127716,
0.23882372677326202,
-0.4282437860965729,
0.09459814429283142,
0.3796774744987488,
0.04828552156686783,
0.6539299488067627,
0.6616629362106323,
0.310855895280838,
0.008572682738304138,
0.0963774248957634,
0.6145579218864441,
-0.7155517339706421,
-0.09524832665920258,
-0.7008287906646729,
0.5391271710395813,
0.09817113727331161,
-0.49540817737579346,
1.0076971054077148,
0.543110191822052,
0.7586877346038818,
0.03990296274423599,
0.6677947640419006,
0.22114098072052002,
0.5111530423164368,
-0.6490901708602905,
0.7434632182121277,
-0.43038931488990784,
0.8374567627906799,
-0.26229584217071533,
-1.133000135421753,
-0.277719110250473,
0.35847142338752747,
-0.20579691231250763,
-0.008238034322857857,
0.8347465395927429,
0.7114543914794922,
0.3772822320461273,
-0.25593942403793335,
0.6594550609588623,
0.5194973349571228,
0.6469911932945251,
0.38954591751098633,
1.2522063255310059,
-0.4532054364681244,
0.9101381301879883,
-0.19028805196285248,
-0.24915535748004913,
-0.30288130044937134,
-0.5159686207771301,
-1.063965916633606,
-0.31375589966773987,
-0.24048693478107452,
-0.3529481589794159,
0.10756928473711014,
0.47664874792099,
0.3626924455165863,
-0.665637731552124,
-0.26867225766181946,
-0.04890170693397522,
0.4926220178604126,
0.0036982563324272633,
-0.3046266734600067,
0.36034098267555237,
-0.34344482421875,
-0.7597774863243103,
0.4528742730617523,
0.18125855922698975,
-0.16984711587429047,
-0.5124620795249939,
-0.14826515316963196,
0.2404496669769287,
0.27206939458847046,
0.5817326307296753,
0.044165998697280884,
-1.0202974081039429,
-0.4393441379070282,
-0.0979779064655304,
-0.15126968920230865,
-0.2367079257965088,
0.6253219842910767,
-0.7036247253417969,
0.43791696429252625,
0.37032628059387207,
0.6156393885612488,
0.25139957666397095,
-0.039785996079444885,
0.3219098448753357,
-0.5600451231002808,
-0.2709899842739105,
0.4958936274051666,
0.22324593365192413,
0.2459806352853775,
-0.2950165867805481,
0.3776395618915558,
0.09390125423669815,
-0.751226007938385,
-1.07774019241333,
0.01789974607527256,
-0.7544299364089966,
0.004328614100813866,
1.167699933052063,
-0.37555521726608276,
0.07728035002946854,
-0.3080365061759949,
-0.028534160926938057,
-0.16575440764427185,
-0.2583201825618744,
1.0720593929290771,
0.8196005821228027,
-0.25394171476364136,
-0.11868339031934738,
-0.3594399094581604,
0.41614004969596863,
0.6163960695266724,
-0.9683476686477661,
0.010968625545501709,
0.7803570628166199,
0.3632180392742157,
0.4429611265659332,
0.6389320492744446,
0.019756577908992767,
0.5239454507827759,
-0.004488331265747547,
0.03875987231731415,
-0.07462214678525925,
-0.4082654118537903,
-0.5730865597724915,
0.2530391216278076,
0.4198502004146576,
0.11133964359760284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13431v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13431v2 | Children's Speech Recognition through Discrete Token Enhancement | 2024-06-19T10:45:12 | 2024-06-24T15:31:59 | Vrunda N. Sukhadia, Shammur Absar Chowdhury | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Children's speech recognition is considered a low-resource task mainly due to
the lack of publicly available data. There are several reasons for such data
scarcity, including expensive data collection and annotation processes, and
data privacy, among others. Transforming speech signals into discrete tokens
that do not carry sensitive information but capture both linguistic and
acoustic information could be a solution for privacy concerns. In this study,
we investigate the integration of discrete speech tokens into children's speech
recognition systems as input without significantly degrading the ASR
performance. Additionally, we explored single-view and multi-view strategies
for creating these discrete labels. Furthermore, we tested the models for
generalization capabilities with unseen domain and nativity dataset. Results
reveal that the discrete token ASR for children achieves nearly equivalent
performance with an approximate 83% reduction in parameters. | [
-0.38222166895866394,
-0.09409335255622864,
0.029065847396850586,
0.011438866145908833,
-0.5103024244308472,
0.27442750334739685,
-0.004107981454581022,
-0.6904622316360474,
0.07042475789785385,
0.2408936470746994,
-0.5026843547821045,
-0.15305618941783905,
-0.6178181171417236,
-0.17484505474567413,
-0.4817078113555908,
0.7205116152763367,
0.22957944869995117,
-0.11112870275974274,
-0.24562600255012512,
0.06842131167650223,
-0.21602559089660645,
-0.894692063331604,
-0.6018474102020264,
-0.16103118658065796,
0.4368240535259247,
0.38675129413604736,
0.24267823994159698,
0.9404126405715942,
0.413176953792572,
0.3008345663547516,
-0.35719960927963257,
0.0790802612900734,
-0.13303923606872559,
-0.09943249821662903,
-0.2866508662700653,
-0.0789368748664856,
-0.5306578874588013,
-0.135212242603302,
0.9205751419067383,
0.8092435002326965,
0.10352995246648788,
0.04452652856707573,
0.29212823510169983,
0.4351973533630371,
-0.5961211323738098,
0.36414462327957153,
-0.44163423776626587,
0.33187416195869446,
-0.5361519455909729,
0.22646552324295044,
-0.1599077433347702,
-0.43829745054244995,
0.3195229768753052,
-0.43757113814353943,
0.11043418943881989,
-0.25736087560653687,
0.3004699647426605,
0.2191045582294464,
-0.27208149433135986,
-0.2115526795387268,
-1.00649893283844,
0.7732444405555725,
-0.5541090369224548,
0.30837011337280273,
0.6064096093177795,
0.04102339968085289,
0.15729257464408875,
-0.8653846383094788,
-0.5708348155021667,
0.10706734657287598,
-0.41681864857673645,
-0.21569140255451202,
-0.42385101318359375,
0.17629879713058472,
0.36377623677253723,
0.2213374525308609,
-0.43992727994918823,
0.10835425555706024,
-0.47795674204826355,
-0.28753870725631714,
0.49892500042915344,
0.1487516611814499,
0.23658142983913422,
-0.07903334498405457,
-0.1772274672985077,
-0.09333053231239319,
-0.17408810555934906,
0.31297293305397034,
0.10155048221349716,
0.8188063502311707,
-0.4267562925815582,
0.38233909010887146,
-0.24159948527812958,
0.5975281000137329,
0.21795639395713806,
-0.26468294858932495,
0.31978747248649597,
-0.48778390884399414,
-0.04931901395320892,
0.46654456853866577,
0.41920989751815796,
-0.1185581386089325,
0.24128678441047668,
-0.15254929661750793,
-0.21888607740402222,
0.5209293365478516,
-0.031068997457623482,
-0.836039125919342,
-0.051213499158620834,
0.014230706728994846,
-0.4909038841724396,
-0.290130615234375,
0.12303376197814941,
-0.7372269630432129,
-0.4028344750404358,
-0.3922729194164276,
0.20168021321296692,
-0.36175426840782166,
-0.20893742144107819,
0.047895126044750214,
-0.34690576791763306,
0.10985492169857025,
0.03815930709242821,
-1.165773630142212,
0.8068597912788391,
0.6914796233177185,
0.6653638482093811,
-0.20968304574489594,
0.06714977324008942,
-0.7696542143821716,
0.3439222574234009,
-0.15660706162452698,
0.8060044646263123,
-0.8325084447860718,
-0.82974773645401,
-0.24702468514442444,
-0.3299003839492798,
-0.30331093072891235,
-0.6584490537643433,
0.24587519466876984,
-0.23033949732780457,
0.09997780621051788,
-0.18595771491527557,
-0.3512003421783447,
0.18118256330490112,
-0.3267832398414612,
-0.4885740280151367,
0.5986350178718567,
-0.09645450860261917,
-0.643710196018219,
0.6320018172264099,
-1.0550323724746704,
-0.6583991646766663,
0.33577457070350647,
-0.36120903491973877,
-0.34141805768013,
0.3419410288333893,
0.6343029737472534,
0.017957299947738647,
0.2536918520927429,
0.14525973796844482,
0.07911285758018494,
-0.5390305519104004,
0.5135958790779114,
-0.9839774966239929,
0.4778871536254883,
0.06752444058656693,
-0.476071834564209,
-0.16188302636146545,
-0.8599067330360413,
0.13137409090995789,
-0.34491702914237976,
-0.5119773745536804,
-0.32124465703964233,
0.06611327081918716,
0.1662081480026245,
0.26728376746177673,
0.2160661518573761,
-0.6977933049201965,
0.01361717190593481,
-0.5577872395515442,
0.3550492525100708,
0.6267210841178894,
0.016738973557949066,
0.4236879348754883,
-0.40019598603248596,
0.3502979874610901,
0.20009741187095642,
0.6741137504577637,
0.07802686840295792,
-0.7351598143577576,
-0.5729554295539856,
-0.7037234306335449,
0.7472001910209656,
0.10894208401441574,
-0.6482495665550232,
0.4411145746707916,
-0.5347711443901062,
0.07121210545301437,
-0.44922247529029846,
-0.2914819121360779,
0.7044857144355774,
0.4564344882965088,
0.24790221452713013,
-0.8358762264251709,
-0.6907711029052734,
-0.5915333032608032,
0.10694120079278946,
-0.1930941939353943,
-0.17938648164272308,
0.6837878227233887,
0.21722540259361267,
-0.10473129898309708,
0.987558126449585,
-0.014627180062234402,
-0.23693044483661652,
0.15171869099140167,
-0.0287851020693779,
0.1977795958518982,
0.9093949794769287,
0.30149561166763306,
-0.8945032358169556,
-0.34218138456344604,
0.060007493942976,
-0.3483082354068756,
-0.03447200730443001,
0.2818942964076996,
0.39236345887184143,
0.003939226269721985,
0.04943421483039856,
-0.18546144664287567,
1.1027830839157104,
0.6578232645988464,
-0.480487197637558,
0.12258457392454147,
0.07957135885953903,
-0.003993529360741377,
-0.4225243330001831,
0.10786799341440201,
-0.5634925365447998,
-0.2663714587688446,
-0.9143986105918884,
-0.37424662709236145,
-0.08309222012758255,
-0.2970655858516693,
-0.8187461495399475,
0.5557084083557129,
-0.2243168205022812,
-0.37198033928871155,
-0.3291366994380951,
0.12373187392950058,
-0.058123331516981125,
0.2799948453903198,
0.04381178691983223,
0.858820378780365,
0.7037739157676697,
-0.5932232737541199,
0.2614295780658722,
0.15687717497348785,
0.07120120525360107,
0.6351438760757446,
-0.4189182221889496,
0.5070226788520813,
-0.05167610943317413,
0.1358240395784378,
-0.7403867840766907,
-0.1308612823486328,
0.35019999742507935,
-0.7239065766334534,
0.4401061236858368,
-0.15095672011375427,
-0.5520503520965576,
-0.2799485921859741,
-0.2474118173122406,
0.679246723651886,
0.4849461019039154,
-0.8625932335853577,
0.6282757520675659,
0.501507043838501,
-0.2245977818965912,
-0.47909367084503174,
-0.8556769490242004,
0.15422466397285461,
-0.1614789366722107,
-0.22264453768730164,
0.6343296766281128,
-0.03721624240279198,
0.09649034589529037,
0.505089521408081,
-0.3751866817474365,
-0.2547961473464966,
-0.3346981108188629,
0.3580864667892456,
0.16343121230602264,
-0.3501686155796051,
0.14242403209209442,
0.24380703270435333,
-0.46338221430778503,
-0.27412497997283936,
-0.5124248266220093,
0.6311916708946228,
0.012031870894134045,
-0.4499965012073517,
-0.7725624442100525,
0.4111041724681854,
0.5554733872413635,
-0.2931722402572632,
0.4729420244693756,
0.2526877522468567,
-0.7968159914016724,
-0.1269139051437378,
-0.3769502341747284,
-0.05696721002459526,
-0.5584782361984253,
-0.18951283395290375,
-0.3308658301830292,
-0.736673891544342,
0.4537671208381653,
-0.012662816792726517,
-0.31305423378944397,
0.09593335539102554,
0.1806427240371704,
0.0321158729493618,
0.8686672449111938,
0.3212023675441742,
-0.2626279890537262,
0.6125275492668152,
-0.09399545192718506,
-0.09759482741355896,
-1.0225253105163574,
-0.4558580815792084,
-0.5734714269638062,
-0.5010002851486206,
-0.45860549807548523,
-0.5493074059486389,
0.11096948385238647,
-0.24311472475528717,
-0.15134795010089874,
0.06240202859044075,
-0.9391972422599792,
0.4611106216907501,
0.9054369330406189,
0.2051178365945816,
0.44819074869155884,
0.13534878194332123,
-0.24576275050640106,
-0.2071876972913742,
-0.7025705575942993,
-0.3363802134990692,
0.9562379717826843,
0.16954344511032104,
0.48439016938209534,
0.2096688449382782,
0.7874622344970703,
0.1902604103088379,
0.23011156916618347,
-0.7296037077903748,
0.47818270325660706,
-0.7997241020202637,
-0.5689172148704529,
-0.44703409075737,
-0.29256853461265564,
-0.9662560224533081,
0.24253743886947632,
-0.06316360831260681,
-1.0602391958236694,
1.0747570991516113,
-0.03504650294780731,
-0.6208992004394531,
0.14826655387878418,
-0.4657137989997864,
0.054298996925354004,
-0.2690741717815399,
-0.2071009874343872,
-0.053941428661346436,
-0.3124549090862274,
0.0568164587020874,
-0.4676515460014343,
0.22433865070343018,
0.330554723739624,
-0.20477141439914703,
0.9018150568008423,
-0.6373912692070007,
1.0655410289764404,
-0.49122050404548645,
0.4160294234752655,
0.22060640156269073,
-0.5022286176681519,
0.2576805055141449,
-0.03230062499642372,
0.009175270795822144,
0.14102259278297424,
-0.16142138838768005,
-0.13413889706134796,
-0.5775746703147888,
0.8089079260826111,
-0.6556675434112549,
-0.18909145891666412,
-0.5685661435127258,
-0.3405046761035919,
-0.3550487160682678,
0.14975126087665558,
-0.17330364882946014,
0.7339165806770325,
0.34169405698776245,
0.4091055691242218,
0.5682945251464844,
-0.17608721554279327,
0.7080639600753784,
0.39633694291114807,
-0.044017158448696136,
-0.7576828002929688,
0.8766268491744995,
0.42021557688713074,
0.11576585471630096,
0.04135306552052498,
0.4183068871498108,
-0.5427889823913574,
-0.5974749326705933,
-0.3021915853023529,
0.2263285517692566,
-0.4606916010379791,
-0.11851877719163895,
-0.342534601688385,
-0.5467070937156677,
-0.44280126690864563,
-0.18964658677577972,
-0.20780202746391296,
-0.7217147946357727,
-0.5018390417098999,
-0.2851574718952179,
0.3218482732772827,
0.5626770257949829,
-0.6135731935501099,
0.5028048753738403,
-0.5928229689598083,
0.6233789920806885,
0.8226551413536072,
0.6450816988945007,
0.15555718541145325,
-0.5421501994132996,
-0.03779099881649017,
-0.06516160070896149,
0.15890906751155853,
-0.47763073444366455,
0.21279320120811462,
0.31278902292251587,
0.4308966398239136,
0.5623239278793335,
-0.04024679958820343,
1.1425625085830688,
-0.5455479621887207,
0.756031334400177,
0.17527493834495544,
-1.2831367254257202,
0.5413739085197449,
-0.24466665089130402,
0.1307602822780609,
0.4323314130306244,
-0.3048635721206665,
-0.32656076550483704,
0.023623451590538025,
-0.6486942172050476,
-0.7207683324813843,
1.1140772104263306,
0.3314484655857086,
0.2723366618156433,
0.38198545575141907,
0.1751723289489746,
-0.1400667130947113,
0.4440067708492279,
-0.2155732810497284,
-0.3922024965286255,
-0.3562215566635132,
-0.1433403342962265,
0.14405831694602966,
-0.119610995054245,
-0.010337069630622864,
-0.6698648929595947,
0.09661511331796646,
0.28515514731407166,
0.31484460830688477,
-0.0011355025926604867,
0.5060994029045105,
-0.013026769272983074,
0.023558111861348152,
0.4321795403957367,
0.20304960012435913,
0.021137265488505363,
0.17027045786380768,
0.15357990562915802,
-0.7995510101318359,
0.19290213286876678,
0.3798820674419403,
-0.13260683417320251,
0.16304202377796173,
0.2496616244316101,
0.7135536074638367,
0.2972809970378876,
-0.2931770384311676,
0.453857958316803,
-0.3440436124801636,
-0.20300020277500153,
-0.24885739386081696,
0.1488562971353531,
0.05883408710360527,
0.28428417444229126,
0.34664297103881836,
-0.11309102922677994,
0.25458425283432007,
-0.3781246244907379,
0.45095720887184143,
0.28602367639541626,
-0.48925328254699707,
-0.20443302392959595,
0.6929121613502502,
0.21830028295516968,
-0.6498100757598877,
0.6613346338272095,
-0.0007920661591924727,
-0.24363961815834045,
0.4950619339942932,
0.8059192895889282,
0.8925445675849915,
-0.5785340666770935,
0.28320470452308655,
-0.12207675725221634,
0.2635173499584198,
0.34868696331977844,
0.2635135352611542,
-0.5183891654014587,
-0.5417503714561462,
-0.290115624666214,
-0.41028428077697754,
-0.618303656578064,
0.2399764358997345,
-0.6964907050132751,
-0.09283699840307236,
-0.6287630796432495,
-0.40044596791267395,
0.006909752730280161,
-0.08169174194335938,
-0.6729738712310791,
0.5334054231643677,
0.4090917110443115,
0.34312787652015686,
-0.6150949001312256,
0.9110305309295654,
0.3903132379055023,
-0.17720583081245422,
-0.7722196578979492,
-0.029465947300195694,
-0.08831014484167099,
-0.6002587676048279,
0.6998597979545593,
-0.04230444133281708,
-0.4342808127403259,
0.029263462871313095,
-0.2623281180858612,
-1.1435359716415405,
0.6233367323875427,
0.10637801140546799,
-0.4898824989795685,
0.008077790029346943,
0.7245922088623047,
0.6808165907859802,
-0.3081202805042267,
-0.31075605750083923,
0.514448344707489,
0.5837548971176147,
0.2402161955833435,
-1.0629730224609375,
-0.11408805847167969,
-0.29531824588775635,
0.28312161564826965,
-0.12432102859020233,
-0.3082546293735504,
0.8125129342079163,
0.17324751615524292,
-0.4839736521244049,
-0.3193783164024353,
0.3129272758960724,
0.3671000897884369,
0.6909951567649841,
0.41485315561294556,
0.12056217342615128,
0.9192055463790894,
-0.001481089275330305,
0.7081939578056335,
-0.17976540327072144,
-0.0007084463723003864,
0.9561412334442139,
-0.13006331026554108,
0.7704759240150452,
0.5307822823524475,
-0.24748998880386353,
0.2414938360452652,
0.15127265453338623,
0.32516053318977356,
0.8541265726089478,
0.3044828474521637,
-0.7318251729011536,
0.22607895731925964,
-0.4141998291015625,
-0.12002142518758774,
0.5187227725982666,
0.8336915373802185,
-0.23517721891403198,
0.17190855741500854,
0.07623594999313354,
-0.15819329023361206,
0.0026303399354219437,
-0.42733967304229736,
1.0438967943191528,
0.28596729040145874,
0.041930798441171646,
0.5179026126861572,
-0.12498179823160172,
0.7976214289665222,
-0.364134281873703,
-0.07043182104825974,
-0.17714689671993256,
0.024553680792450905,
-0.4715272784233093,
-0.2156454175710678,
0.4280446767807007,
0.41195443272590637,
-0.10105492174625397,
-0.14012689888477325,
0.8342964053153992,
-0.017476286739110947,
-0.6347481608390808,
0.13191105425357819,
0.34508782625198364,
0.11642146855592728,
0.1537340134382248,
-0.4214896857738495,
-0.008246795274317265,
-0.12107903510332108,
0.19395971298217773,
0.34944403171539307,
0.39447256922721863,
0.0064744059927761555,
0.4129107892513275,
0.9529726505279541,
0.4745239317417145,
0.26477620005607605,
0.15861955285072327,
1.1113791465759277,
-0.48857778310775757,
-0.4549102485179901,
-0.662295937538147,
0.7383008003234863,
-0.10214743763208389,
-0.0904863253235817,
0.5251568555831909,
0.5599409937858582,
0.6676790118217468,
0.08285145461559296,
0.9230915307998657,
0.19802677631378174,
0.748119056224823,
-0.16615714132785797,
0.7470189332962036,
-0.03962742164731026,
0.1780526041984558,
-0.4640834629535675,
-0.5563945770263672,
-0.7043544054031372,
0.7885245084762573,
-0.2918194830417633,
-0.03775660693645477,
0.49242207407951355,
0.538430392742157,
-0.1380213499069214,
0.08808533102273941,
0.42351028323173523,
-0.3225787878036499,
0.4159599840641022,
0.4222348928451538,
0.8930602073669434,
-0.2052159160375595,
0.4103805124759674,
-0.410767525434494,
-0.37856870889663696,
-0.007203149143606424,
-0.46282586455345154,
-0.7435550689697266,
-0.3271182179450989,
-0.38559937477111816,
0.005888863001018763,
0.3368857800960541,
0.4795948565006256,
0.8112013936042786,
-0.96626216173172,
0.002326898742467165,
-0.023044893518090248,
0.04884929582476616,
-0.13635244965553284,
-0.17994235455989838,
0.5545945763587952,
0.10908384621143341,
-0.9112516045570374,
0.6837449669837952,
0.2753243148326874,
0.16225679218769073,
-0.03681639954447746,
0.19684810936450958,
0.3897242844104767,
0.27767452597618103,
0.42051684856414795,
0.3369426131248474,
-0.4240987300872803,
-0.5420651435852051,
-0.18746937811374664,
0.24845831096172333,
0.17640867829322815,
0.632719874382019,
-1.0460641384124756,
0.5984691381454468,
0.20665700733661652,
0.4666406512260437,
0.7070357203483582,
0.49417951703071594,
0.10334226489067078,
-0.9731606245040894,
0.2390141487121582,
0.541400134563446,
-0.029561618342995644,
0.29483920335769653,
-0.20907148718833923,
0.10603422671556473,
0.25933516025543213,
-0.23832564055919647,
-0.9493688941001892,
0.09797573834657669,
-0.6083356738090515,
0.11728042364120483,
0.7531672716140747,
0.002842426300048828,
0.05689198523759842,
-0.5664992928504944,
-0.09377580881118774,
0.11898025125265121,
-0.6859588623046875,
0.569707989692688,
0.18710769712924957,
-0.41451218724250793,
-0.02314515970647335,
-0.02975950576364994,
0.4295769929885864,
-0.1861891746520996,
-0.5874265432357788,
-0.06076708808541298,
0.4151560068130493,
0.010142209008336067,
0.25032153725624084,
0.8114582896232605,
-0.5245477557182312,
0.16274487972259521,
0.4183543622493744,
-0.2456904649734497,
-0.03534567728638649,
-0.32983455061912537,
-0.8354595899581909,
0.27928605675697327,
-0.024935517460107803,
-0.9039766192436218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13415v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13415v1 | Factual Confidence of LLMs: on Reliability and Robustness of Current Estimators | 2024-06-19T10:11:37 | 2024-06-19T10:11:37 | Matéo Mahaut, Laura Aina, Paula Czarnowska, Momchil Hardalov, Thomas Müller, Lluís Màrquez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) tend to be unreliable in the factuality of their
answers. To address this problem, NLP researchers have proposed a range of
techniques to estimate LLM's confidence over facts. However, due to the lack of
a systematic comparison, it is not clear how the different methods compare to
one another. To fill this gap, we present a survey and empirical comparison of
estimators of factual confidence. We define an experimental framework allowing
for fair comparison, covering both fact-verification and question answering.
Our experiments across a series of LLMs indicate that trained hidden-state
probes provide the most reliable confidence estimates, albeit at the expense of
requiring access to weights and training data. We also conduct a deeper
assessment of factual confidence by measuring the consistency of model behavior
under meaning-preserving variations in the input. We find that the confidence
of LLMs is often unstable across semantically equivalent inputs, suggesting
that there is much room for improvement of the stability of models' parametric
knowledge. Our code is available at
(https://github.com/amazon-science/factual-confidence-of-llms). | [
-0.10562676936388016,
-0.8634415864944458,
1.1202168464660645,
0.17013919353485107,
0.17174957692623138,
0.19395437836647034,
-0.29018956422805786,
-0.3945300877094269,
-0.04791345074772835,
0.08918645232915878,
-0.15208832919597626,
-0.61745285987854,
-0.8032378554344177,
0.20951001346111298,
-0.453419029712677,
0.6462604403495789,
0.15249000489711761,
0.4123907685279846,
-0.7534830570220947,
-0.1325269490480423,
-0.21616604924201965,
-0.38118672370910645,
-0.5187158584594727,
-0.15668290853500366,
0.6658358573913574,
0.0333419032394886,
0.7580063939094543,
0.3863062262535095,
0.5223401784896851,
0.3675823509693146,
-0.30016323924064636,
0.21885423362255096,
-0.4427603483200073,
0.37333279848098755,
-0.2414182424545288,
-0.8769375085830688,
-0.21185626089572906,
0.19192025065422058,
0.6607890725135803,
0.7091992497444153,
-0.3038226068019867,
0.2534002363681793,
0.0072936094366014,
0.32727712392807007,
-0.949783444404602,
0.23208940029144287,
-0.769976794719696,
-0.09793713688850403,
0.08030406385660172,
-0.028307799249887466,
-0.5522176623344421,
-0.779376208782196,
0.07745426893234253,
-0.2924381196498871,
0.18217860162258148,
0.18933914601802826,
0.8682582378387451,
0.49623677134513855,
-0.49310535192489624,
-0.3261820375919342,
-0.8468572497367859,
0.9135169386863708,
-0.9078454971313477,
0.5123617053031921,
0.5024871230125427,
0.08767911046743393,
-0.14793485403060913,
-0.6231448650360107,
-0.6356234550476074,
-0.7877706289291382,
-0.08280155807733536,
0.17388024926185608,
0.004153909161686897,
0.007759994361549616,
0.3542088270187378,
0.4524576663970947,
-0.5163023471832275,
0.2218812257051468,
-0.0635363832116127,
-0.39671632647514343,
0.40490737557411194,
-0.09905435144901276,
0.14800457656383514,
-0.14439524710178375,
-0.43408262729644775,
0.03845919296145439,
-0.7806660532951355,
0.014657915569841862,
0.3375810384750366,
0.033136311918497086,
0.0245660450309515,
0.8895749449729919,
-0.20195862650871277,
0.39833056926727295,
-0.010347822681069374,
-0.6082741618156433,
0.07010262459516525,
-0.26575109362602234,
-0.17132706940174103,
-0.07162338495254517,
0.6434453725814819,
0.2984907925128937,
-0.01240015309303999,
-0.2833884060382843,
-0.3435238003730774,
0.24797967076301575,
0.07487785071134567,
-0.46425217390060425,
0.048592064529657364,
0.4047454297542572,
-0.20795132219791412,
-0.272978276014328,
0.10916811972856522,
-0.398181289434433,
-0.43506914377212524,
-0.06326934695243835,
0.41610682010650635,
-0.244105726480484,
-0.10864768922328949,
0.050333794206380844,
-0.0682191252708435,
0.4042413830757141,
0.30052319169044495,
-0.48508062958717346,
0.3193618059158325,
0.760032594203949,
0.745402455329895,
-0.28804442286491394,
-0.11339238286018372,
-0.4998930096626282,
-0.15189875662326813,
-0.5973503589630127,
0.580869734287262,
-0.22306106984615326,
-0.1930307298898697,
0.14664767682552338,
-0.006643311586230993,
-0.13329771161079407,
-0.4354722499847412,
0.892522931098938,
-0.710064172744751,
0.29358044266700745,
-0.5777979493141174,
-0.8074244856834412,
-0.00207313010469079,
0.7596480846405029,
-0.6424837708473206,
1.1342535018920898,
-0.3184516429901123,
-1.0374256372451782,
0.3297936022281647,
-0.13293790817260742,
-0.015927007421851158,
-0.229090616106987,
-0.269388347864151,
-0.4044656455516815,
0.1823350489139557,
-0.044302184134721756,
0.4587404131889343,
-0.2548506259918213,
0.3539673089981079,
-0.7415594458580017,
-0.4166356921195984,
1.02236807346344,
-0.8940660357475281,
0.7449299693107605,
0.007906636223196983,
-0.24124285578727722,
-0.3090398609638214,
-0.8030206561088562,
-0.11091102659702301,
0.08121136575937271,
-0.568407416343689,
-0.1317741572856903,
0.20457696914672852,
-0.3978888988494873,
0.06344635039567947,
0.3430464565753937,
-0.8833223581314087,
-0.1303599625825882,
-0.3930129110813141,
0.003028108738362789,
0.6247179508209229,
-0.07911909371614456,
0.19585441052913666,
-0.5398746132850647,
0.3789839446544647,
-0.2423781454563141,
-0.11526110023260117,
0.19018246233463287,
-0.40556925535202026,
-0.8328438997268677,
-0.2953968644142151,
0.7559243440628052,
0.664029061794281,
-0.4865504205226898,
0.41276243329048157,
-0.4020729660987854,
-0.4074819087982178,
-0.22951948642730713,
-0.026981836184859276,
0.44675973057746887,
0.7117907404899597,
0.1686803698539734,
0.05109012871980667,
-0.36255303025245667,
-0.7283914089202881,
-0.16975383460521698,
-0.5150221586227417,
-0.14206747710704803,
0.06868698447942734,
0.5283769965171814,
0.008505471982061863,
0.8027079701423645,
-0.3604077696800232,
0.31683748960494995,
0.012640373781323433,
0.10180403292179108,
-0.002661443315446377,
0.1880761682987213,
0.4942319989204407,
-0.680633544921875,
-0.19500768184661865,
-0.335304319858551,
-0.9578611850738525,
0.23324280977249146,
0.26017171144485474,
0.16557708382606506,
0.45307353138923645,
0.30779609084129333,
-0.9464969635009766,
0.45317429304122925,
0.753887414932251,
-0.09034033119678497,
0.6758541464805603,
-0.056239981204271317,
0.24355089664459229,
-0.7886108756065369,
0.15287744998931885,
0.03410032391548157,
-0.5096347332000732,
-0.3413689136505127,
0.06032184511423111,
0.006409912370145321,
0.32172587513923645,
-0.4539549648761749,
0.3671445846557617,
-0.42295724153518677,
-0.10335176438093185,
-0.22313857078552246,
0.3081395924091339,
0.010296730324625969,
0.1835782825946808,
-0.02807188592851162,
0.7982776761054993,
0.4932931661605835,
-0.525188148021698,
0.456066757440567,
0.18370351195335388,
-0.5663138628005981,
0.40210944414138794,
-0.6821398138999939,
0.10136229544878006,
0.007134333252906799,
0.204916313290596,
-1.0928469896316528,
-0.1934867650270462,
0.24444009363651276,
-0.5999493598937988,
0.4246865510940552,
-0.23661036789417267,
-0.5891490578651428,
-0.17756621539592743,
-0.36884447932243347,
-0.16173429787158966,
0.6207510232925415,
-0.4717642664909363,
0.4661177396774292,
0.3341415226459503,
-0.4998999238014221,
-1.0197842121124268,
-0.8623565435409546,
0.2337057888507843,
-0.041208814829587936,
-0.420266330242157,
-0.12494723498821259,
-0.18928129971027374,
-0.6141135096549988,
0.11109629273414612,
-0.38846248388290405,
-0.1893775910139084,
0.1988963633775711,
0.15131789445877075,
0.3707195520401001,
-0.3255206048488617,
0.2974591553211212,
-0.06415115296840668,
0.1120595782995224,
0.4310682713985443,
-0.06060081720352173,
0.23243920505046844,
-0.3233078718185425,
-0.7601675987243652,
-0.25966373085975647,
-0.06841620057821274,
0.48129114508628845,
0.005845050793141127,
1.023747205734253,
0.3067023754119873,
-0.2508741617202759,
-0.00610309699550271,
-0.8765092492103577,
-0.16217046976089478,
-0.4346446990966797,
0.22103194892406464,
-0.11865242570638657,
-0.9770289659500122,
0.37622398138046265,
-0.07271719723939896,
0.15437661111354828,
0.2334074079990387,
0.6105368733406067,
-0.42164960503578186,
0.8267664313316345,
0.6052374243736267,
0.1512448936700821,
-0.1551133096218109,
0.1379171758890152,
0.06420136243104935,
-0.35265710949897766,
-0.21434271335601807,
-0.7022566795349121,
0.020892584696412086,
-0.6396421194076538,
-0.36935245990753174,
0.22142189741134644,
-0.19541463255882263,
-0.12962706387043,
-0.22110584378242493,
0.03147473931312561,
0.3802573084831238,
0.42080724239349365,
0.13435032963752747,
0.33687809109687805,
-0.12880770862102509,
-0.08106141537427902,
-0.10565394163131714,
-0.6795828342437744,
-0.8245363235473633,
1.034602165222168,
0.5139594674110413,
0.8724590539932251,
0.3226959705352783,
0.45093217492103577,
0.15202318131923676,
0.2578031122684479,
-0.892655611038208,
0.5433461666107178,
0.14970433712005615,
-0.7980945110321045,
-0.3873075544834137,
-0.5391940474510193,
-0.6474007368087769,
0.08190630376338959,
-0.5892829895019531,
-0.5732271075248718,
0.23792505264282227,
0.3200347125530243,
-0.2417912781238556,
0.39097142219543457,
-0.3148634433746338,
0.3854319453239441,
-0.33416223526000977,
-0.4043330252170563,
0.11058881878852844,
-0.7732799649238586,
0.554778516292572,
-0.1064869835972786,
-0.038506973534822464,
-0.3610721528530121,
-0.13909882307052612,
0.5532562136650085,
-0.26105377078056335,
0.8973298668861389,
-0.008440397679805756,
-0.273755818605423,
0.34455952048301697,
-0.024363454431295395,
0.5597483515739441,
0.3225930631160736,
-0.3343612551689148,
0.1518445461988449,
0.21023912727832794,
-0.5831109881401062,
-0.7481950521469116,
0.5818224549293518,
-0.5656114816665649,
-0.6498360633850098,
-0.7766664624214172,
-0.5296128988265991,
-0.5396499037742615,
0.09527537971735,
0.17778529226779938,
0.4011884331703186,
-0.40504640340805054,
0.5737279057502747,
1.2415649890899658,
-0.09180203080177307,
0.3872138261795044,
0.535615861415863,
-0.06399993598461151,
-0.1363818645477295,
0.3679523468017578,
0.13239406049251556,
0.4518970847129822,
0.60642009973526,
0.23497731983661652,
-0.5373643040657043,
-0.5742390751838684,
-0.2005232870578766,
0.22240546345710754,
-0.7959635257720947,
-0.23146826028823853,
-0.4261569082736969,
-0.3464415669441223,
-0.37996962666511536,
0.23261158168315887,
-0.6305047273635864,
-0.43595126271247864,
-0.013624032028019428,
-0.49437379837036133,
0.2986619770526886,
0.6444712281227112,
-0.015228744596242905,
-0.08262317627668381,
-0.5711047649383545,
0.20701344311237335,
0.45521289110183716,
0.1513589322566986,
-0.3675941228866577,
-0.5168223977088928,
-0.04561201110482216,
0.1954101175069809,
0.11073652654886246,
-0.8509066700935364,
0.07667278498411179,
-0.045801300555467606,
0.7094928026199341,
0.3669807016849518,
0.30728861689567566,
0.1869417279958725,
-0.31771203875541687,
0.7916803359985352,
0.0838659480214119,
-0.7397514581680298,
0.09930688142776489,
-0.16287943720817566,
-0.042843423783779144,
0.6695536375045776,
0.6491946578025818,
-0.22329512238502502,
-0.5954645276069641,
-0.49554407596588135,
-0.43315306305885315,
0.18835145235061646,
0.10083580017089844,
0.0952104777097702,
0.07371184974908829,
0.4200453758239746,
0.07955573499202728,
0.35950106382369995,
-0.7783051133155823,
-0.38102981448173523,
-0.11103300750255585,
-0.27928709983825684,
0.008103619329631329,
-0.6547451615333557,
-0.5950977206230164,
0.1401115506887436,
0.6277414560317993,
-0.1424594521522522,
0.29891857504844666,
0.2510450482368469,
-0.1253051608800888,
0.24878938496112823,
0.4732794165611267,
0.5619909167289734,
1.0428279638290405,
-0.404687762260437,
0.5929221510887146,
0.5856217741966248,
-0.47234657406806946,
0.26460376381874084,
-0.03785485029220581,
-0.41574570536613464,
0.200274258852005,
0.4565565884113312,
0.534601628780365,
0.3160073459148407,
-0.619728684425354,
0.7922170758247375,
-0.33661380410194397,
-0.2491624653339386,
-0.5300301909446716,
0.06966154277324677,
0.3031517565250397,
0.08952955901622772,
0.15580277144908905,
0.24311555922031403,
0.0032602623105049133,
-0.5356932878494263,
0.010856227949261665,
0.5792545080184937,
-0.35757479071617126,
-0.2051268219947815,
0.4391442537307739,
0.0656837746500969,
0.011784273199737072,
0.5044390559196472,
-0.3074789345264435,
-0.3646722733974457,
0.362002432346344,
0.5437971949577332,
0.6355464458465576,
0.06087585538625717,
0.24222064018249512,
0.10875578224658966,
0.5454183220863342,
-0.3923496901988983,
0.31419751048088074,
0.2596435844898224,
-0.9794321060180664,
-0.6328975558280945,
-0.5716554522514343,
-0.7505592107772827,
0.1282479166984558,
-0.6355836987495422,
-0.03880045562982559,
-0.42105865478515625,
-0.2754923403263092,
-0.4972522258758545,
0.21411952376365662,
-0.47700291872024536,
0.286371648311615,
0.22277256846427917,
1.02631676197052,
-0.8927269577980042,
0.7008800506591797,
0.63653963804245,
-0.25966876745224,
-0.8878415822982788,
0.2965359687805176,
0.014907711185514927,
-0.7108505964279175,
0.28786125779151917,
-0.056181423366069794,
-0.5031224489212036,
-0.2958945035934448,
-0.9853943586349487,
-1.056532382965088,
1.1202421188354492,
0.7168059945106506,
-0.44839218258857727,
0.1290079802274704,
-0.03900032117962837,
0.47134819626808167,
0.02742352895438671,
0.19969217479228973,
0.4098515212535858,
0.5044212937355042,
0.3108426332473755,
-0.7749967575073242,
0.039504703134298325,
0.0671474039554596,
-0.11652533710002899,
-0.3497554063796997,
-0.43013519048690796,
0.5679366588592529,
-0.15370075404644012,
-0.32038769125938416,
0.3756554126739502,
0.9075518250465393,
0.6479796767234802,
0.4362410604953766,
0.46547648310661316,
0.4881223142147064,
1.169389247894287,
-0.2678832411766052,
1.069982886314392,
-0.45415160059928894,
0.44898122549057007,
1.0219630002975464,
-0.37331831455230713,
0.9614903330802917,
0.2971145510673523,
-0.3476867377758026,
0.46373051404953003,
0.4442213177680969,
-0.0007396784494630992,
0.11085809767246246,
-0.047453079372644424,
-0.3067432641983032,
-0.2718369662761688,
0.0032442286610603333,
-0.11265413463115692,
0.38989266753196716,
0.14189213514328003,
-0.03531812131404877,
0.08010968565940857,
-0.36720725893974304,
0.4001743793487549,
0.09399886429309845,
-0.14580470323562622,
0.3976370096206665,
0.27645057439804077,
-0.4785428047180176,
0.42177125811576843,
0.02609149180352688,
0.7239267230033875,
-0.6944413781166077,
0.21465767920017242,
-0.25351235270500183,
-0.07229434698820114,
-0.1399543434381485,
-0.8101204633712769,
0.07530507445335388,
0.0916627049446106,
-0.15610340237617493,
0.08158892393112183,
0.8252453804016113,
-0.26791125535964966,
-0.5831623077392578,
-0.10464460402727127,
0.7962468266487122,
0.13628828525543213,
0.187818244099617,
-0.5697256922721863,
0.12872789800167084,
-0.3607161343097687,
-0.33057358860969543,
0.11183031648397446,
0.24670766294002533,
0.2530503571033478,
0.9158444404602051,
0.5809226632118225,
0.3106459677219391,
0.35767078399658203,
-0.2673940658569336,
0.4762309789657593,
-0.46528634428977966,
-0.009370005689561367,
-0.7209905385971069,
0.33478644490242004,
-0.12365492433309555,
-0.1689937710762024,
1.1935944557189941,
0.45527613162994385,
0.6881847977638245,
-0.018817590549588203,
0.8407130837440491,
0.029150133952498436,
0.6991798281669617,
-0.8096215128898621,
0.7370768785476685,
-0.26507896184921265,
0.3315381407737732,
0.008530912920832634,
-0.880591630935669,
-0.30628201365470886,
0.582176148891449,
-0.23353272676467896,
0.12159202992916107,
0.7662458419799805,
0.8410086631774902,
0.002656389493495226,
-0.14330355823040009,
0.46569231152534485,
0.5293467044830322,
0.002131028100848198,
-0.04655459150671959,
1.3000017404556274,
-0.13913220167160034,
0.3941848576068878,
-0.24617931246757507,
-0.008957495912909508,
-0.029569268226623535,
-1.042008638381958,
-0.6351928114891052,
-0.2817789316177368,
-0.3202451169490814,
-0.4221532642841339,
0.16383744776248932,
0.7405567169189453,
0.543426513671875,
-0.7346251606941223,
-0.12567968666553497,
0.16438251733779907,
0.2758852243423462,
-0.0035829173866659403,
-0.16696327924728394,
0.32724788784980774,
-0.2657378315925598,
-0.7793934345245361,
0.5608307719230652,
0.16202092170715332,
0.0022058652248233557,
-0.4045881927013397,
0.012553522363305092,
-0.13954535126686096,
0.4714246988296509,
0.42312464118003845,
0.3819485902786255,
-0.7789998650550842,
-0.5357578992843628,
0.17569294571876526,
-0.40394127368927,
-0.02545510232448578,
0.3833676874637604,
-0.5932367444038391,
0.07954507321119308,
0.4988332688808441,
0.7711518406867981,
0.2521747350692749,
0.14431880414485931,
0.43104997277259827,
-0.6666175723075867,
-0.1253877729177475,
0.27431678771972656,
0.4714435935020447,
0.6109638810157776,
-0.20308507978916168,
0.3531075716018677,
0.1750035285949707,
-0.7921726107597351,
-1.0611858367919922,
0.2485463172197342,
-1.0449086427688599,
-0.16282154619693756,
1.2135857343673706,
-0.4167773723602295,
-0.1801895946264267,
-0.10936925560235977,
0.15389913320541382,
0.11386009305715561,
-0.12576277554035187,
0.746858537197113,
0.7096900939941406,
-0.06474670022726059,
0.06349603086709976,
-0.604996383190155,
0.42356541752815247,
0.3128281831741333,
-0.5946025252342224,
-0.2029276043176651,
0.39641937613487244,
0.6744866371154785,
0.31928586959838867,
0.47986534237861633,
0.016719896346330643,
0.035455796867609024,
0.0656999871134758,
-0.010334962047636509,
0.24228917062282562,
-0.31160879135131836,
-0.3249725103378296,
0.2087244689464569,
0.47311076521873474,
-0.07901962846517563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13408v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13408v1 | SQLFixAgent: Towards Semantic-Accurate SQL Generation via Multi-Agent Collaboration | 2024-06-19T09:57:19 | 2024-06-19T09:57:19 | Jipeng Cen, Jiaxin Liu, Zhixu Li, Jingjing Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | While fine-tuned large language models (LLMs) excel in generating
grammatically valid SQL in Text-to-SQL parsing, they often struggle to ensure
semantic accuracy in queries, leading to user confusion and diminished system
usability. To tackle this challenge, we introduce SQLFixAgent, an innovative
multi-agent collaborative framework designed for detecting and repairing
erroneous SQL. Our framework comprises a core agent, SQLRefiner, alongside two
auxiliary agents: SQLReviewer and QueryCrafter. The SQLReviewer agent employs
the rubber duck debugging method to identify potential semantic mismatches
between SQL statement and user query. If the error is detected, the
QueryCrafter agent generates multiple SQL statements as candidate repairs using
a fine-tuned SQLTool. Subsequently, leveraging similar repair retrieval and
failure memory reflexion, the SQLRefiner agent selects the most fitting SQL
statement from the candidates as the final repair. We evaluated our proposed
framework on five Text-to-SQL benchmarks. The experimental results show that
our method consistently enhances the performance of the baseline model,
specifically achieving an execution accuracy improvement of over 3\% on the
Bird benchmark. Our framework also has a higher token efficiency compared to
other advanced methods, making it more competitive. | [
0.032416149973869324,
-0.79847252368927,
0.6591236591339111,
0.11251591145992279,
0.020844988524913788,
0.28614407777786255,
-0.0655812919139862,
-0.3765159249305725,
0.15488426387310028,
0.7845150232315063,
-0.690091609954834,
-0.4312056601047516,
-0.21320398151874542,
0.19755609333515167,
-0.5220703482627869,
0.9078710079193115,
0.29843974113464355,
0.04141148924827576,
-0.3704679608345032,
-0.3369237184524536,
-0.6570411324501038,
-0.3236093819141388,
-0.6206945180892944,
-0.26078417897224426,
0.2727365493774414,
0.3553325831890106,
1.032486915588379,
0.6075230240821838,
0.23822158575057983,
0.48699867725372314,
0.19535313546657562,
0.640164315700531,
-0.725412905216217,
0.32024067640304565,
-0.5584774017333984,
-0.5062552690505981,
-0.610192596912384,
-0.3524242341518402,
0.2768447995185852,
0.5142076015472412,
-0.5547009110450745,
-0.28509461879730225,
0.044957660138607025,
0.7203748822212219,
-0.5247657299041748,
-0.03629547730088234,
-1.1483591794967651,
-0.10606744885444641,
0.03196627274155617,
0.11301665753126144,
-0.5496558547019958,
-0.30753302574157715,
-0.2388487309217453,
-0.5245481133460999,
0.6099523901939392,
0.25655397772789,
0.6157023906707764,
0.42811697721481323,
-0.4750835597515106,
0.08785580098628998,
-0.5487634539604187,
0.8786273002624512,
-0.7035528421401978,
0.29304030537605286,
0.07119514048099518,
0.39868924021720886,
-0.817380964756012,
-0.770628809928894,
-0.7037516236305237,
-0.015660520642995834,
-0.25446921586990356,
-0.1318269670009613,
-0.05113828182220459,
0.12886466085910797,
-0.016793714836239815,
0.07342555373907089,
-0.5600681900978088,
-0.26416000723838806,
0.20596137642860413,
-0.3819957375526428,
0.8273356556892395,
0.4708392918109894,
0.31798556447029114,
0.23408615589141846,
-0.36708641052246094,
0.07141677290201187,
-0.579693615436554,
-0.5072829723358154,
0.08549891412258148,
0.5686719417572021,
0.3727223575115204,
0.57664555311203,
-0.05137424170970917,
0.7836896777153015,
-0.12254481762647629,
0.08233248442411423,
0.08512576669454575,
-0.6849278807640076,
-0.17894858121871948,
0.35494759678840637,
0.6238226294517517,
0.2337692528963089,
0.19487164914608002,
-0.4676102101802826,
-0.3993678390979767,
0.1589583456516266,
0.4457390606403351,
-0.47760793566703796,
-0.14065192639827728,
0.6618720889091492,
-0.1206040009856224,
-0.26048052310943604,
0.05527210235595703,
-0.3565216064453125,
-0.7367858290672302,
-0.28155916929244995,
0.34549254179000854,
-0.6439799070358276,
-0.5904260277748108,
0.16164188086986542,
-0.2134949117898941,
0.04011542722582817,
0.5490634441375732,
-0.42636561393737793,
0.22343555092811584,
0.8174808621406555,
0.5316912531852722,
-0.14955593645572662,
-0.6701233386993408,
-0.7277879118919373,
0.6009951829910278,
-0.4346862733364105,
1.1242074966430664,
-0.4017346501350403,
-0.33698827028274536,
-0.11334686726331711,
0.07891354709863663,
-0.2809986174106598,
-0.5160747170448303,
0.23954492807388306,
-0.27233022451400757,
-0.006069977302104235,
-0.2134515345096588,
-0.656521737575531,
0.3016893267631531,
0.28966009616851807,
-0.7531432509422302,
0.9633658528327942,
0.27864331007003784,
-0.42842212319374084,
0.5665845274925232,
-0.3603152930736542,
-0.13806864619255066,
0.1302834153175354,
-0.26052844524383545,
-0.6296088099479675,
0.10389091074466705,
-0.023587465286254883,
0.2915228009223938,
-0.42316311597824097,
0.30912095308303833,
-0.30338314175605774,
-0.5514218807220459,
0.2060438096523285,
0.10823874920606613,
0.4849550426006317,
0.09017297625541687,
-0.437028169631958,
0.22695064544677734,
-1.0181084871292114,
0.31897425651550293,
0.2717455327510834,
-0.19415944814682007,
-0.1750084012746811,
0.1782439947128296,
0.1345631331205368,
0.09393913298845291,
-0.047927312552928925,
-0.7144752740859985,
-0.19690538942813873,
-0.7091171145439148,
0.30186551809310913,
0.7456786036491394,
-0.12887777388095856,
0.21087777614593506,
-0.5447450280189514,
0.12556324899196625,
0.18823319673538208,
0.007141396403312683,
-0.20143432915210724,
-0.10410165786743164,
-0.8298569917678833,
-0.37738534808158875,
0.005169472191482782,
0.47721999883651733,
-0.7267114520072937,
0.4768187701702118,
-0.2530490458011627,
-0.6062744855880737,
-0.2885816693305969,
0.1433601677417755,
0.34832122921943665,
0.36148712038993835,
0.38779962062835693,
0.0555989034473896,
-0.29126930236816406,
-0.6666243076324463,
-0.7556058764457703,
-0.3299610912799835,
0.30328330397605896,
0.2482963353395462,
0.30938228964805603,
-0.3362155258655548,
1.0902446508407593,
-0.45787882804870605,
-0.6388477683067322,
-0.11551099270582199,
-0.02437841333448887,
0.12507611513137817,
0.48879504203796387,
0.505825936794281,
-0.5785214304924011,
-0.5110546350479126,
0.1975594460964203,
-0.49649152159690857,
0.12341897189617157,
-0.059433914721012115,
-0.30507367849349976,
0.7727813720703125,
0.3433966636657715,
-0.6393470168113708,
0.2601964771747589,
0.060508303344249725,
-0.7857583165168762,
0.5394779443740845,
-0.17750833928585052,
0.2790429890155792,
-1.1742602586746216,
-0.12798051536083221,
-0.4320959150791168,
-0.38567987084388733,
-0.5675063133239746,
-0.08379428833723068,
-0.16798625886440277,
-0.15830202400684357,
-0.46193015575408936,
0.17798331379890442,
-0.4149947762489319,
0.1785862296819687,
-0.1981911063194275,
0.026593375951051712,
0.1906636357307434,
0.06688522547483444,
-0.05409287288784981,
0.8955963253974915,
0.009234188124537468,
-0.20691969990730286,
0.5939613580703735,
0.40095147490501404,
0.13495221734046936,
0.8521685004234314,
-0.7409057021141052,
0.3208208680152893,
-0.11753735691308975,
0.0906660333275795,
-1.3183189630508423,
-0.3626365065574646,
-0.16935670375823975,
-0.46600231528282166,
0.016377951949834824,
-0.13361315429210663,
-0.6190672516822815,
0.09133603423833847,
-0.19945426285266876,
0.009147876873612404,
-0.030886858701705933,
-0.6238160729408264,
1.0022239685058594,
0.16246455907821655,
-0.01857323758304119,
-0.7351981997489929,
-0.7514142990112305,
0.19445718824863434,
0.09908709675073624,
-1.0891468524932861,
0.35504841804504395,
0.35617193579673767,
-0.28709182143211365,
0.19941270351409912,
0.01526126079261303,
-0.2935171127319336,
0.006096543278545141,
-0.005346577148884535,
0.2870895266532898,
-0.32024839520454407,
0.49490752816200256,
0.09501741081476212,
-0.08446472883224487,
-0.01996499113738537,
-0.2066490650177002,
0.40962016582489014,
-0.2400583177804947,
-0.4418083727359772,
0.17302589118480682,
0.558888852596283,
0.511975884437561,
-0.3832608759403229,
0.9948999285697937,
0.5972089171409607,
-0.3750686049461365,
-0.4770403504371643,
-0.7727701663970947,
-0.3535296618938446,
-0.4549676775932312,
0.3843453526496887,
-0.2883854806423187,
-0.7639589309692383,
0.2772848308086395,
-0.143429234623909,
0.07121185958385468,
0.45193755626678467,
0.26748979091644287,
0.2594110369682312,
1.3736494779586792,
0.6984612941741943,
0.388526052236557,
0.029211116954684258,
0.12454808503389359,
0.14029909670352936,
0.05695229023694992,
-0.24437345564365387,
-0.7611325979232788,
0.27241256833076477,
-0.26154565811157227,
-0.2555672526359558,
0.3073023557662964,
-0.25390490889549255,
-0.39474648237228394,
0.42040756344795227,
-0.6129465699195862,
0.6884117126464844,
0.14051517844200134,
0.0778181180357933,
0.3884332478046417,
0.26217737793922424,
-0.33266744017601013,
-0.009060653857886791,
-0.6158313751220703,
-0.4501229226589203,
0.7047924995422363,
-0.14795449376106262,
0.7405636310577393,
0.5357901453971863,
0.8615573644638062,
0.37221717834472656,
-0.1238449439406395,
-0.4647257924079895,
0.5439982414245605,
-0.041578978300094604,
-0.4492221474647522,
-0.29646188020706177,
-0.38459378480911255,
-0.9193560481071472,
0.3680048882961273,
-0.5771057605743408,
-0.4520861804485321,
0.06125675141811371,
0.2497052550315857,
-0.16139541566371918,
0.12369322031736374,
-0.9340010285377502,
0.9783948659896851,
-0.05047435685992241,
-0.9694046974182129,
-0.46164435148239136,
-0.6037752628326416,
0.11847339570522308,
-0.2988155782222748,
0.030790219083428383,
-0.15522126853466034,
-0.21647916734218597,
0.14155569672584534,
-1.1461241245269775,
0.7256880402565002,
-0.28998494148254395,
-0.023399723693728447,
0.2455155849456787,
0.22925229370594025,
0.6802524924278259,
-0.03511113300919533,
-0.31138044595718384,
-0.08231736719608307,
0.2984846234321594,
-0.5101308226585388,
-0.5022760033607483,
0.704314649105072,
-0.6599789261817932,
-0.35307884216308594,
-0.5822570323944092,
-0.5496746301651001,
-0.32061684131622314,
0.3386102616786957,
-0.23186668753623962,
0.31620925664901733,
-0.4089653193950653,
-0.1049373522400856,
0.46478891372680664,
-0.08667276054620743,
0.23820072412490845,
0.6607303619384766,
0.008789422921836376,
-0.3771079480648041,
0.966583251953125,
-0.18177002668380737,
0.057372093200683594,
0.18514937162399292,
-0.07580108940601349,
-0.33217737078666687,
-0.3262416124343872,
-0.45431455969810486,
0.4886740744113922,
-0.49156901240348816,
-0.46336695551872253,
-0.7096172571182251,
-0.0011769593693315983,
-0.4198293387889862,
-0.17160600423812866,
-0.5691048502922058,
-0.375116765499115,
-0.19276635348796844,
0.22163274884223938,
0.4535694122314453,
0.6874661445617676,
0.19254818558692932,
0.2964513301849365,
-1.1712336540222168,
-0.3406519293785095,
0.09453251957893372,
0.26641926169395447,
-0.27657145261764526,
0.12466443330049515,
-0.0425371415913105,
0.034978628158569336,
-0.2317422479391098,
-0.735350489616394,
0.22248750925064087,
0.5633351802825928,
0.6370173692703247,
-0.11045844852924347,
0.14886413514614105,
0.6957557797431946,
-0.5641385912895203,
0.8426178097724915,
0.29114827513694763,
-0.9762429594993591,
0.8088467717170715,
-0.24436217546463013,
0.07357186824083328,
0.7052398920059204,
-0.10577671229839325,
-0.18785463273525238,
-0.6292485594749451,
-0.4985596835613251,
-0.8637668490409851,
0.8317654728889465,
0.2468748539686203,
-0.06463029235601425,
-0.20762471854686737,
0.38149991631507874,
0.15867732465267181,
0.08519963920116425,
-0.17645257711410522,
-0.0014151798095554113,
-0.2568885385990143,
-0.3309948742389679,
-0.017918797209858894,
-0.13329744338989258,
-0.04660549759864807,
0.16856926679611206,
0.8012755513191223,
-0.598819375038147,
0.19621101021766663,
0.2595733404159546,
-0.29226699471473694,
-0.17707189917564392,
0.367887943983078,
0.36581820249557495,
0.9163585305213928,
-0.12147919833660126,
0.016289837658405304,
0.23145878314971924,
-0.4015505015850067,
0.2330905795097351,
0.30579710006713867,
0.47940951585769653,
0.0733986347913742,
0.36465832591056824,
0.22358106076717377,
-0.24669760465621948,
-0.9651898741722107,
0.7295781970024109,
-0.4235392212867737,
0.043119367212057114,
-0.49714040756225586,
0.31990697979927063,
0.1338311731815338,
0.18639038503170013,
0.15003645420074463,
0.22357691824436188,
0.23039740324020386,
-0.22157302498817444,
0.4522053003311157,
0.4895009696483612,
-0.5582672357559204,
-0.03959294781088829,
0.736646831035614,
0.29637181758880615,
-0.11764509975910187,
0.8360798358917236,
0.09775563329458237,
-0.23182159662246704,
0.5616260766983032,
0.6026655435562134,
0.7122288942337036,
-0.3263319730758667,
0.23845340311527252,
0.2273326963186264,
0.15614137053489685,
-0.011687999591231346,
0.4580494463443756,
0.11174863576889038,
-0.9855735301971436,
-0.46577322483062744,
-0.4590379297733307,
-0.35292693972587585,
-0.42910993099212646,
-0.2996147572994232,
0.41423821449279785,
-0.2330777794122696,
-0.23582519590854645,
0.2767438292503357,
-0.10733062773942947,
-0.12982210516929626,
0.004578441847115755,
-0.5123838186264038,
0.8899940848350525,
-0.709627628326416,
0.731514036655426,
0.9743017554283142,
-0.46879589557647705,
-0.8035921454429626,
-0.2694876194000244,
0.26961448788642883,
-0.6725910902023315,
0.3310195207595825,
0.14613847434520721,
-0.3898386061191559,
0.059646159410476685,
-0.5082297325134277,
-0.44649457931518555,
1.0883032083511353,
0.6887289881706238,
-0.4419001340866089,
0.16568779945373535,
0.6536102294921875,
0.49031490087509155,
-0.37118658423423767,
0.3887387216091156,
0.6746048927307129,
0.23207268118858337,
0.22401534020900726,
-0.7997241616249084,
0.2957342267036438,
-0.1696540266275406,
0.07156296819448471,
0.5924463868141174,
-0.6909213662147522,
0.6549248695373535,
-0.3591964840888977,
-0.009984403848648071,
0.21083815395832062,
0.46695414185523987,
0.48343169689178467,
0.18956591188907623,
0.7878754734992981,
0.49652954936027527,
0.7081200480461121,
-0.18357093632221222,
0.8552290797233582,
-0.19447100162506104,
0.30015039443969727,
1.0560555458068848,
-0.7355882525444031,
0.6911197900772095,
0.49261558055877686,
-0.13535134494304657,
0.47584787011146545,
0.08766620606184006,
0.1155579537153244,
0.1922038048505783,
-0.002973956987261772,
-0.46618878841400146,
-0.6480257511138916,
-0.44956085085868835,
-0.22293435037136078,
0.4609442949295044,
0.28913089632987976,
-0.3398573696613312,
-0.5256530046463013,
-0.3432687222957611,
0.07109122723340988,
0.5156809091567993,
0.04858596995472908,
0.9461755752563477,
-0.15417884290218353,
-0.668512225151062,
0.6060871481895447,
-0.1041465774178505,
0.1713215410709381,
-0.5793954133987427,
-0.42473894357681274,
-0.1821015328168869,
0.8342446088790894,
-0.48819053173065186,
-0.6488631367683411,
0.6372828483581543,
-0.3634074926376343,
-0.12193461507558823,
0.12792371213436127,
1.2201215028762817,
-0.5275959968566895,
-0.1976422220468521,
0.43041127920150757,
0.6397284269332886,
-0.052351657301187515,
-0.27371469140052795,
-0.8604953289031982,
0.10974960774183273,
-0.01308495830744505,
0.23117786645889282,
0.1677871197462082,
0.4130314290523529,
0.06461156904697418,
0.39120250940322876,
0.6426318883895874,
-0.0648799017071724,
-0.0745968148112297,
0.05327910929918289,
0.9224844574928284,
-0.5499971508979797,
-0.2506864070892334,
-0.8372699618339539,
0.5276486277580261,
-0.491032212972641,
0.04047190025448799,
0.4796661138534546,
0.7244418859481812,
0.530415415763855,
-0.08333282917737961,
0.5160413384437561,
0.07603389769792557,
0.7578702569007874,
-0.31566324830055237,
0.9653663039207458,
-0.6603123545646667,
0.40294650197029114,
-0.20046813786029816,
-1.0938379764556885,
-0.31244686245918274,
0.3162340223789215,
0.3435089886188507,
-0.05527383089065552,
0.7271106243133545,
1.3591722249984741,
0.11667446792125702,
0.2755533456802368,
0.3980472683906555,
0.37372785806655884,
0.403235524892807,
0.48007360100746155,
0.9633855223655701,
-0.4186350703239441,
0.8414040207862854,
0.03437032923102379,
-0.29943519830703735,
0.08473779261112213,
-0.8266683220863342,
-0.877719521522522,
-0.4000653326511383,
-0.4120013415813446,
-0.7984748482704163,
0.4103344678878784,
1.1713045835494995,
0.5316584706306458,
-0.8078368306159973,
-0.20388875901699066,
-0.44100576639175415,
0.2062617540359497,
-0.32497307658195496,
-0.26283392310142517,
0.18865549564361572,
-0.8401533365249634,
-0.4692477285861969,
0.32423317432403564,
0.25137069821357727,
-0.1847880631685257,
-0.02967437542974949,
0.05515846982598305,
-0.26021453738212585,
0.25271084904670715,
0.6081389784812927,
-0.14205516874790192,
-0.5147235989570618,
-0.39372876286506653,
-0.04754991829395294,
-0.23462353646755219,
-0.19905687868595123,
0.5244143605232239,
-0.7206554412841797,
0.34522688388824463,
0.503425121307373,
0.8235053420066833,
0.21915380656719208,
-0.08491760492324829,
0.7554733157157898,
-0.7922242283821106,
-0.14065250754356384,
0.10085966438055038,
0.3109724223613739,
0.34787338972091675,
-0.5867809057235718,
0.8755643963813782,
0.4724169373512268,
-0.7179198861122131,
-0.7623023390769958,
0.12066713720560074,
-0.7882267832756042,
-0.3390442728996277,
0.9998873472213745,
-0.06197361275553703,
-0.5993614196777344,
-0.4381909966468811,
-0.4441603720188141,
-0.0359094999730587,
-0.4182046949863434,
0.34457436203956604,
0.443148672580719,
-0.21409909427165985,
0.11210506409406662,
0.21535050868988037,
0.49149173498153687,
0.5301184058189392,
-0.7823264598846436,
0.16719001531600952,
0.8900454044342041,
0.506400465965271,
0.1610512137413025,
0.6034117937088013,
-0.23887282609939575,
0.46723395586013794,
0.30595776438713074,
0.05675569549202919,
-0.1545187383890152,
-0.005573828238993883,
-0.04742779582738876,
0.04936591908335686,
0.11669175326824188,
0.20156657695770264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13397v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13397v1 | MoreHopQA: More Than Multi-hop Reasoning | 2024-06-19T09:38:59 | 2024-06-19T09:38:59 | Julian Schnitzler, Xanh Ho, Jiahao Huang, Florian Boudin, Saku Sugawara, Akiko Aizawa | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most existing multi-hop datasets are extractive answer datasets, where the
answers to the questions can be extracted directly from the provided context.
This often leads models to use heuristics or shortcuts instead of performing
true multi-hop reasoning. In this paper, we propose a new multi-hop dataset,
MoreHopQA, which shifts from extractive to generative answers. Our dataset is
created by utilizing three existing multi-hop datasets: HotpotQA,
2WikiMultihopQA, and MuSiQue. Instead of relying solely on factual reasoning,
we enhance the existing multi-hop questions by adding another layer of
questioning that involves one, two, or all three of the following types of
reasoning: commonsense, arithmetic, and symbolic. Our dataset is created
through a semi-automated process, resulting in a dataset with 1,118 samples
that have undergone human verification. We then use our dataset to evaluate
five different large language models: Mistral 7B, Gemma 7B, Llama 3 (8B and
70B), and GPT-4. We also design various cases to analyze the reasoning steps in
the question-answering process. Our results show that models perform well on
initial multi-hop questions but struggle with our extended questions,
indicating that our dataset is more challenging than previous ones. Our
analysis of question decomposition reveals that although models can correctly
answer questions, only a portion - 38.7% for GPT-4 and 33.4% for Llama3-70B -
achieve perfect reasoning, where all corresponding sub-questions are answered
correctly. Evaluation code and data are available at
https://github.com/Alab-NII/morehopqa | [
-0.6315352916717529,
-0.8624867796897888,
0.652003288269043,
0.29331493377685547,
0.12082907557487488,
0.38225099444389343,
-0.0030895571690052748,
-0.3884481191635132,
-0.07583843171596527,
0.47003090381622314,
-0.7041869759559631,
-0.16286586225032806,
-0.46981287002563477,
0.17155396938323975,
-0.34754541516304016,
0.6184263229370117,
0.03200114518404007,
-0.24600744247436523,
-0.05989326909184456,
-0.140030637383461,
-0.5171354413032532,
-0.5181117057800293,
-0.4871410131454468,
-0.16206392645835876,
0.3665695786476135,
0.5851804614067078,
0.7422205209732056,
0.17587798833847046,
0.34504756331443787,
0.214808851480484,
-0.15348145365715027,
0.36865362524986267,
0.007606857921928167,
0.11029796302318573,
0.21879346668720245,
-0.4039520025253296,
-0.32179611921310425,
0.004652075469493866,
0.28071099519729614,
0.5584383606910706,
-0.08608271181583405,
0.3590637743473053,
-0.5395358800888062,
0.6600657105445862,
-0.5186745524406433,
0.03452523797750473,
-0.444052517414093,
-0.2034805417060852,
-0.18862642347812653,
-0.09248442947864532,
-0.4359009563922882,
-0.6230785846710205,
0.021465947851538658,
-0.6781773567199707,
-0.022221911698579788,
0.002826230600476265,
0.7556082606315613,
0.24740426242351532,
-0.7551643252372742,
-0.276212602853775,
-0.6285930871963501,
0.5862634181976318,
-0.5345165729522705,
0.7700286507606506,
0.3879573941230774,
0.705104410648346,
0.01368935126811266,
-0.623871922492981,
-0.8052974343299866,
-0.15187516808509827,
0.2015763223171234,
0.27729567885398865,
-0.09404846280813217,
-0.3854122757911682,
0.5148615837097168,
0.2229037880897522,
-0.6940152049064636,
-0.3747466504573822,
-0.42765530943870544,
-0.3077191412448883,
0.47392538189888,
0.11406062543392181,
0.26213401556015015,
-0.35335204005241394,
-0.1996099352836609,
-0.33115869760513306,
-0.7309685945510864,
0.23817655444145203,
0.32144370675086975,
0.33977988362312317,
-0.019241178408265114,
0.6127027273178101,
-0.3303130567073822,
0.8153896331787109,
-0.10084862262010574,
-0.19811072945594788,
0.5731059312820435,
-0.3308503329753876,
-0.07659465074539185,
-0.31997445225715637,
0.458103746175766,
0.04104854539036751,
0.5083873867988586,
-0.015977410599589348,
0.3119221031665802,
-0.11035310477018356,
-0.05913718044757843,
-0.5498635172843933,
-0.5553324222564697,
0.6499699354171753,
-0.2664002478122711,
-0.0791468471288681,
-0.11761755496263504,
-0.5247116684913635,
-0.33607104420661926,
-0.2992073893547058,
0.3226516544818878,
-0.7687123417854309,
-0.477181613445282,
0.3148540258407593,
-0.38413769006729126,
0.6380693912506104,
0.4923548400402069,
-0.4399440586566925,
0.10695866495370865,
0.7439970374107361,
0.9077566862106323,
0.06864345818758011,
-0.5158619284629822,
-0.4675334692001343,
0.0554361566901207,
-0.5284591913223267,
0.75299072265625,
-0.7264618277549744,
0.10400988161563873,
-0.32154935598373413,
0.003107843454927206,
-0.21312329173088074,
-0.3280069828033447,
0.7598130106925964,
-1.057834267616272,
0.35495924949645996,
-0.7119635343551636,
-0.47244900465011597,
-0.4004233479499817,
0.5684646964073181,
-0.9171857237815857,
1.0188168287277222,
0.04435101896524429,
-0.8678610920906067,
0.3198546767234802,
-0.7912427186965942,
-0.583652138710022,
-0.02110113576054573,
-0.055487316101789474,
-0.15234413743019104,
-0.12080176174640656,
0.6678774356842041,
0.17628875374794006,
-0.5432130694389343,
0.3849426805973053,
-0.2740633487701416,
-0.19513218104839325,
0.3102487325668335,
-0.6604598760604858,
1.3642843961715698,
0.30705899000167847,
-0.1696789711713791,
-0.19510571658611298,
-0.8737273812294006,
0.2911398112773895,
0.12487778812646866,
-0.5339805483818054,
-0.09773280471563339,
-0.33970603346824646,
-0.14704187214374542,
0.5679112076759338,
-0.2806892991065979,
-0.6717044711112976,
0.33651459217071533,
-0.12253306806087494,
0.44556376338005066,
0.44676125049591064,
0.05198473110795021,
0.14965714514255524,
-0.4180203080177307,
0.738542914390564,
-0.07841240614652634,
0.1571151167154312,
-0.26078882813453674,
-0.9738806486129761,
-0.6727035045623779,
-0.28089070320129395,
0.25659817457199097,
0.6004719734191895,
-0.8347262144088745,
0.05891771987080574,
-0.34149956703186035,
-0.3795463442802429,
-0.5321092009544373,
-0.15425850450992584,
0.022525418549776077,
0.5341933965682983,
0.6574560403823853,
0.2002718299627304,
-0.41494759917259216,
-0.4876382350921631,
0.014604641124606133,
-0.09558502584695816,
-0.06424650549888611,
0.3207702338695526,
0.5487186908721924,
-0.022103123366832733,
0.830538809299469,
-0.4712792932987213,
0.14383907616138458,
-0.35215985774993896,
0.3180924952030182,
0.37809666991233826,
0.15420660376548767,
0.3281915783882141,
-0.8251639604568481,
-0.367532879114151,
-0.28181278705596924,
-0.5551812648773193,
0.01310218870639801,
-0.31052154302597046,
-0.24522222578525543,
-0.4573323726654053,
0.4104388356208801,
-0.895388126373291,
-0.01733434572815895,
0.3897618353366852,
-0.1462876796722412,
0.7795213460922241,
0.2121468037366867,
0.37474656105041504,
-1.0874334573745728,
-0.13173824548721313,
-0.32669535279273987,
-0.0964585468173027,
-0.621691882610321,
0.39473918080329895,
0.1502476930618286,
-0.01782681606709957,
-0.26267075538635254,
0.44592517614364624,
-0.6429358720779419,
-0.1565750390291214,
-0.19471952319145203,
-0.16259577870368958,
0.5137971639633179,
0.5393593907356262,
0.2568291127681732,
0.7583253979682922,
0.8432949781417847,
-0.5826969146728516,
0.8273607492446899,
0.6931685209274292,
-0.5267168283462524,
0.11885615438222885,
-0.7238143682479858,
0.2940172255039215,
-0.23181545734405518,
0.5872331857681274,
-1.1007146835327148,
-0.4717141389846802,
0.10768312215805054,
-0.7009924054145813,
-0.12950383126735687,
-0.43643733859062195,
-0.5425457954406738,
-0.5779333710670471,
-0.356203556060791,
0.6947711110115051,
0.23210150003433228,
-0.7539384961128235,
0.5435909032821655,
0.052219245582818985,
-0.21212182939052582,
-0.5788013339042664,
-0.6304047703742981,
0.15774588286876678,
-0.2423996776342392,
-0.8280309438705444,
-0.0413835272192955,
-0.11896341294050217,
-0.19215361773967743,
-0.23285196721553802,
0.17254963517189026,
-0.3430449366569519,
-0.044601306319236755,
-0.052974943071603775,
0.2508171796798706,
-0.22060933709144592,
0.23383276164531708,
0.16461028158664703,
-0.15138846635818481,
0.05479751527309418,
-0.24437586963176727,
0.6912907361984253,
-0.09154574573040009,
-0.7134045362472534,
-0.29009997844696045,
0.5158610939979553,
0.7068426609039307,
-0.611842930316925,
0.4918532073497772,
0.7067742347717285,
-0.21411465108394623,
0.22284340858459473,
-0.48546847701072693,
0.008289903402328491,
-0.38490456342697144,
0.12381862103939056,
-0.8250482678413391,
-0.7753423452377319,
0.42090561985969543,
-0.1645282357931137,
0.2770250737667084,
0.26271700859069824,
0.7203462719917297,
-0.050925999879837036,
1.039224624633789,
0.25108879804611206,
0.08599943667650223,
-0.1088624969124794,
-0.3842966854572296,
0.1866321563720703,
-0.975426971912384,
-0.3915615677833557,
-0.4798538386821747,
-0.0134890740737319,
-0.5440055131912231,
-0.7742650508880615,
0.4302200973033905,
-0.07172717154026031,
-0.4696834683418274,
0.39874300360679626,
-0.14661701023578644,
0.4410261809825897,
0.7781767249107361,
-0.09497648477554321,
0.479146271944046,
-0.22581540048122406,
0.01393453124910593,
0.3588669002056122,
-0.6979687809944153,
-0.22183729708194733,
1.210764765739441,
0.3290116786956787,
0.5807957649230957,
0.5707859992980957,
0.5295303463935852,
-0.09943405538797379,
-0.012289603240787983,
-0.7349110841751099,
0.06678396463394165,
0.33171218633651733,
-1.1253767013549805,
-0.43836498260498047,
-0.5794622898101807,
-0.6246998310089111,
0.3351629674434662,
-0.05962591618299484,
-0.5475382208824158,
0.3317171335220337,
-0.0006879972061142325,
-0.7739180326461792,
0.1361204981803894,
-0.7585643529891968,
0.5251959562301636,
-0.44295093417167664,
-0.2188226729631424,
0.3251042068004608,
-0.8559954762458801,
0.7680917382240295,
0.0689602643251419,
0.456959992647171,
-0.24990513920783997,
0.3846695125102997,
0.6196359992027283,
-0.31087249517440796,
0.3761201500892639,
-0.09087440371513367,
-0.15289825201034546,
0.6085920333862305,
0.08527285605669022,
0.29621660709381104,
0.25313007831573486,
-0.13149839639663696,
-0.07237982004880905,
0.2892063856124878,
-0.5013633370399475,
-0.7038669586181641,
0.3366486728191376,
-0.709868311882019,
-0.38319385051727295,
-0.31993868947029114,
-0.5157824754714966,
-0.7258673906326294,
0.054474759846925735,
0.3043705224990845,
0.6453199982643127,
0.38853931427001953,
0.06673769652843475,
0.5937400460243225,
-0.36819830536842346,
0.30790555477142334,
0.22455842792987823,
-0.13016386330127716,
-0.3997136056423187,
0.7177600264549255,
-0.1978578418493271,
0.23214469850063324,
0.3733071982860565,
0.49309736490249634,
-0.7506897449493408,
-0.37186503410339355,
-0.7976150512695312,
0.014404857531189919,
-0.7211319208145142,
-0.3157825469970703,
-0.890903890132904,
-0.1645694077014923,
-0.751804769039154,
0.22996124625205994,
-0.342874675989151,
-0.7222319841384888,
0.3076784014701843,
-0.2854931056499481,
0.4754121005535126,
0.43533775210380554,
-0.2436879426240921,
0.27898865938186646,
-0.9264018535614014,
0.8859817981719971,
0.6845446825027466,
0.259111225605011,
0.11340846866369247,
-0.7691882848739624,
0.17348185181617737,
0.020547183230519295,
-0.13655294477939606,
-1.267417550086975,
0.1244288831949234,
0.3282584846019745,
0.40160009264945984,
0.1925951987504959,
0.0504615493118763,
0.8268629312515259,
-0.47833451628685,
0.6809852719306946,
0.11215946823358536,
-0.7678697109222412,
0.278972864151001,
-0.2592361569404602,
0.3156040608882904,
0.704771101474762,
0.692181408405304,
-0.5436980128288269,
0.01728697121143341,
-0.4120233654975891,
-0.7906737923622131,
0.5565896034240723,
0.3492428660392761,
0.19982050359249115,
0.05058685690164566,
0.25462520122528076,
0.2905643880367279,
0.11121667921543121,
-0.8965689539909363,
-0.22995758056640625,
-0.35480746626853943,
0.20916618406772614,
0.19738835096359253,
-0.250875324010849,
-0.0924721285700798,
-0.5629773139953613,
0.644429624080658,
-0.16619081795215607,
0.2202702760696411,
-0.16466012597084045,
-0.14245370030403137,
0.32904645800590515,
0.46179327368736267,
0.061315763741731644,
0.6016047596931458,
-0.06084880977869034,
0.1857418417930603,
-0.05988304689526558,
-0.17479705810546875,
0.2604803144931793,
0.003054838627576828,
-0.14075103402137756,
-0.21624378859996796,
0.7752116322517395,
0.6359816193580627,
-0.4830150306224823,
-0.5656293630599976,
0.7145455479621887,
-0.2221740335226059,
-0.326830118894577,
-0.17294491827487946,
-0.16223663091659546,
0.2707291543483734,
0.36445289850234985,
0.18871039152145386,
-0.00439098384231329,
0.4389050602912903,
-0.6967101693153381,
0.44081971049308777,
0.24506886303424835,
0.04133561998605728,
-0.21218696236610413,
0.5375752449035645,
0.04657599702477455,
-0.03179873526096344,
0.8816691040992737,
-0.45415082573890686,
-0.6622499823570251,
0.40547290444374084,
0.4752037227153778,
0.5021921992301941,
-0.06775233894586563,
0.6282501816749573,
0.5549181699752808,
0.3888664245605469,
-0.10051322728395462,
0.6484887003898621,
-0.2842128872871399,
-0.990388810634613,
-0.8812046647071838,
-0.5383351445198059,
-0.44682779908180237,
0.3531293272972107,
-0.5197523236274719,
0.14380180835723877,
-0.2636856734752655,
0.07897889614105225,
-0.007204785943031311,
-0.16774407029151917,
-0.5623207688331604,
0.37604835629463196,
0.06577865779399872,
0.9835875034332275,
-1.185531497001648,
0.6079675555229187,
0.549048662185669,
-0.5073885321617126,
-1.0999280214309692,
0.2496950924396515,
0.01048282440751791,
-0.7538242340087891,
0.3783278167247772,
0.15762843191623688,
-0.15037986636161804,
-0.05447270721197128,
-0.631754994392395,
-1.0871915817260742,
0.7305776476860046,
0.4335203468799591,
-0.26581820845603943,
-0.061707060784101486,
0.17269228398799896,
0.38825687766075134,
0.10017282515764236,
0.6589629054069519,
0.9153753519058228,
0.6538699269294739,
0.7741665840148926,
-0.7096941471099854,
-0.2099480777978897,
-0.4108698070049286,
-0.5502378940582275,
-0.09516389667987823,
-0.5998389720916748,
1.0855903625488281,
-0.5303806066513062,
0.012101824395358562,
-0.07591334730386734,
0.31941235065460205,
0.535001277923584,
0.15886765718460083,
0.3376697897911072,
0.5677756667137146,
0.8745567798614502,
-0.08536703139543533,
0.9623805284500122,
0.02332320436835289,
0.11218435317277908,
1.4414454698562622,
-0.17372217774391174,
0.6497519612312317,
0.23992931842803955,
-0.3234485387802124,
0.5305062532424927,
0.8389067053794861,
0.25926968455314636,
0.37335824966430664,
0.1954461932182312,
0.014740407466888428,
-0.6985584497451782,
0.2438739687204361,
-0.39256545901298523,
0.8902005553245544,
0.024873171001672745,
0.3504112660884857,
-0.2080356776714325,
-0.05538468062877655,
-0.08329583704471588,
-0.2388315200805664,
0.21059998869895935,
0.6020650267601013,
-0.1696939319372177,
-0.5389876365661621,
0.5635148286819458,
0.15327030420303345,
0.31642642617225647,
-0.2810916602611542,
-0.21428152918815613,
-0.2788791358470917,
-0.36250999569892883,
-0.18618108332157135,
-0.8185849785804749,
0.23406770825386047,
0.18539883196353912,
0.04969440773129463,
0.02105965092778206,
0.31074732542037964,
-0.16266462206840515,
-0.8323410749435425,
0.0523236021399498,
1.0507795810699463,
0.20476298034191132,
-0.32639753818511963,
-0.7494434118270874,
-0.12022493779659271,
-0.10066583007574081,
-0.20513823628425598,
-0.24591031670570374,
0.6338131427764893,
-0.29229721426963806,
0.874546468257904,
0.7220933437347412,
0.12932418286800385,
0.5241714715957642,
0.5545955300331116,
0.8404359817504883,
-0.5354644060134888,
-0.46259939670562744,
-0.551176905632019,
0.3502940237522125,
-0.10833339393138885,
-0.24234364926815033,
0.7009831666946411,
0.6616553068161011,
0.6286312937736511,
0.16256850957870483,
1.0639023780822754,
-0.28482404351234436,
0.7501038908958435,
-0.4904867112636566,
0.060268107801675797,
-0.4503822922706604,
0.27909666299819946,
-0.5952659249305725,
-0.7198665738105774,
-0.14667969942092896,
0.6788756251335144,
-0.23948077857494354,
0.2478441745042801,
0.5409149527549744,
0.5306989550590515,
-0.22995151579380035,
0.2200305461883545,
0.24357019364833832,
-0.08009585738182068,
0.6275560259819031,
0.8503012657165527,
1.476602554321289,
-0.5617424249649048,
0.6192553639411926,
-0.288878470659256,
-0.39223068952560425,
0.30365341901779175,
-0.8072968125343323,
-0.7427376508712769,
-0.6936600208282471,
-0.18392474949359894,
0.005862838122993708,
-0.20785154402256012,
0.706415593624115,
0.6674309372901917,
-0.9323486685752869,
0.052247241139411926,
-0.10110072791576385,
0.12743985652923584,
-0.3615771532058716,
-0.21686777472496033,
0.4453927278518677,
-0.12411896884441376,
-0.5164415240287781,
0.47096025943756104,
0.09215494245290756,
-0.20158039033412933,
0.044986382126808167,
0.03514314070343971,
-0.37366825342178345,
0.07915845513343811,
0.7656025290489197,
0.1420888453722,
-0.3721229135990143,
-0.36920371651649475,
0.4399639964103699,
0.4935518503189087,
0.21092462539672852,
0.8945332169532776,
-0.5904732346534729,
0.32845374941825867,
0.5597299337387085,
0.808316707611084,
0.5108867287635803,
0.39816316962242126,
0.20195603370666504,
-0.6287959814071655,
-0.13420072197914124,
0.28399527072906494,
0.2278294414281845,
0.4200420081615448,
-0.19085559248924255,
0.2355724573135376,
0.08255549520254135,
-0.17957060039043427,
-0.4231608808040619,
0.6995094418525696,
-0.7664658427238464,
-0.37878063321113586,
1.3889206647872925,
-0.006154926028102636,
0.11048337072134018,
-0.6001837253570557,
-0.25452643632888794,
0.17777034640312195,
-0.2203088104724884,
0.6805827021598816,
0.7639120221138,
-0.7513878345489502,
-0.412458211183548,
-0.5269038677215576,
0.49113792181015015,
0.15485680103302002,
-1.093853235244751,
0.37745407223701477,
0.8602798581123352,
0.31709665060043335,
0.20981836318969727,
0.8676201105117798,
-0.2585550546646118,
0.4634292423725128,
0.02134043164551258,
-0.3425046503543854,
-0.25593867897987366,
-0.8549532890319824,
-0.07071397453546524,
0.44802698493003845,
0.17909418046474457,
-0.24791231751441956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13381v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13381v1 | CoAct: A Global-Local Hierarchy for Autonomous Agent Collaboration | 2024-06-19T09:23:53 | 2024-06-19T09:23:53 | Xinming Hou, Mingming Yang, Wenxiang Jiao, Xing Wang, Zhaopeng Tu, Wayne Xin Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing LLMs exhibit remarkable performance on various NLP tasks, but still
struggle with complex real-world tasks, even equipped with advanced strategies
like CoT and ReAct. In this work, we propose the CoAct framework, which
transfers the hierarchical planning and collaboration patterns in human society
to LLM systems. Specifically, our CoAct framework involves two agents: (1) A
global planning agent, to comprehend the problem scope, formulate macro-level
plans and provide detailed sub-task descriptions to local execution agents,
which serves as the initial rendition of a global plan. (2) A local execution
agent, to operate within the multi-tier task execution structure, focusing on
detailed execution and implementation of specific tasks within the global plan.
Experimental results on the WebArena benchmark show that CoAct can re-arrange
the process trajectory when facing failures, and achieves superior performance
over baseline methods on long-horizon web tasks. Code is available at
https://github.com/xmhou2002/CoAct. | [
-0.401208758354187,
-0.5791932940483093,
0.5272604823112488,
0.3353320062160492,
0.2718884348869324,
0.7031207084655762,
0.1048135831952095,
-0.7371413707733154,
0.4895356297492981,
0.6208053231239319,
-0.975204348564148,
-0.5513639450073242,
-0.19244877994060516,
0.05146387219429016,
-0.3150797188282013,
0.8992121815681458,
0.03200693055987358,
-0.46092161536216736,
-0.5447734594345093,
0.1373572051525116,
-0.49749571084976196,
-0.6761655807495117,
-0.9398872256278992,
-0.6270004510879517,
0.4095826745033264,
0.47328147292137146,
0.8783498406410217,
0.7579291462898254,
0.6673414707183838,
0.3864889144897461,
0.11112426966428757,
0.5858978629112244,
-0.37770146131515503,
0.245189368724823,
-0.3045618236064911,
-0.3652319312095642,
-1.0355489253997803,
-0.19581890106201172,
0.3260861933231354,
0.7194820642471313,
-0.13881276547908783,
-0.0984112024307251,
0.25047963857650757,
0.6124876141548157,
-0.6117069721221924,
0.382768839597702,
-0.565881609916687,
0.16272953152656555,
0.33122706413269043,
-0.3126641511917114,
-0.33541107177734375,
0.06129418686032295,
0.1990469992160797,
-0.803959310054779,
0.08896514028310776,
0.09480264782905579,
0.31655046343803406,
0.41880789399147034,
-0.46053922176361084,
-0.18413372337818146,
-0.7525769472122192,
0.6316689848899841,
-0.14226217567920685,
-0.10587956756353378,
0.45822855830192566,
0.0754886046051979,
-0.5714923143386841,
-1.0008647441864014,
-0.17013834416866302,
-0.10037235915660858,
-0.15035070478916168,
0.27523401379585266,
-0.23506133258342743,
0.23329627513885498,
-0.2986390292644501,
0.08331393450498581,
-0.8002471327781677,
0.1424102485179901,
-0.024193553254008293,
-0.19581535458564758,
0.6097795367240906,
0.5965736508369446,
0.19488932192325592,
0.147456094622612,
-0.7814487814903259,
0.42337098717689514,
-0.5411497950553894,
0.16002386808395386,
-0.09414360672235489,
0.33488255739212036,
-0.5132130980491638,
0.12461570650339127,
-0.4235154986381531,
0.5574674606323242,
-0.016169089823961258,
0.047128740698099136,
-0.06999678164720535,
-0.48476311564445496,
-0.29352399706840515,
-0.09338324517011642,
0.661577045917511,
0.30539560317993164,
0.16048617660999298,
-0.43570491671562195,
-0.010891981422901154,
0.15549184381961823,
0.4836388826370239,
-0.3264507055282593,
-0.2482556849718094,
0.49056077003479004,
-0.18840643763542175,
-0.3698268234729767,
0.04446719214320183,
-0.33900272846221924,
-0.4870816469192505,
-0.40529510378837585,
0.11453612148761749,
-0.19569718837738037,
0.041937947273254395,
-0.07201308012008667,
0.23197241127490997,
0.0630144476890564,
0.4773752987384796,
-0.5733396410942078,
0.815812349319458,
1.1113210916519165,
1.1759754419326782,
-0.6109253168106079,
-0.6176003813743591,
-0.757432758808136,
0.4975208342075348,
-0.3022860586643219,
1.0119001865386963,
-0.047496601939201355,
-0.46814173460006714,
0.1070101410150528,
-0.060582585632801056,
0.00881832093000412,
-0.5188310146331787,
0.5811947584152222,
-0.2657622992992401,
-0.20484022796154022,
-0.17684043943881989,
-0.17337380349636078,
0.035136181861162186,
0.2746853530406952,
-0.6226122379302979,
0.6889498829841614,
-0.06762470304965973,
-0.5660651326179504,
0.04598823934793472,
-0.830905020236969,
-0.7515287399291992,
0.25669872760772705,
-0.17128698527812958,
-0.053203582763671875,
-0.553290605545044,
0.13735918700695038,
0.8097739219665527,
-0.3939569294452667,
0.08101548254489899,
-0.07003635168075562,
-0.44443443417549133,
-0.11104479432106018,
0.1421547681093216,
0.871556282043457,
0.23640942573547363,
-0.34957417845726013,
0.4962921738624573,
-0.7398461699485779,
0.16391730308532715,
-0.2002560794353485,
-0.16884195804595947,
-0.08005674928426743,
0.1842818260192871,
-0.2079475075006485,
0.3745453953742981,
0.4573385715484619,
-0.16903701424598694,
0.5930074453353882,
-0.1037442535161972,
0.5933129787445068,
0.7899404764175415,
0.13238026201725006,
0.899667501449585,
-0.9054474234580994,
0.5717871785163879,
-0.4210816025733948,
0.4031096398830414,
0.1232151985168457,
-0.5066322684288025,
-0.7223852872848511,
-0.5135766863822937,
-0.4072624146938324,
0.7501941919326782,
-0.7908098101615906,
0.6955844759941101,
-0.34155911207199097,
-0.44848623871803284,
-0.18865354359149933,
0.06622584164142609,
0.27326104044914246,
0.5079932808876038,
0.27491357922554016,
-0.2671118378639221,
-0.8363638520240784,
-0.8107617497444153,
0.3427596986293793,
-0.3414453864097595,
-0.10142116248607635,
-0.2044045478105545,
0.5798107385635376,
-0.3978746831417084,
1.235933780670166,
-0.34180912375450134,
-0.8372480273246765,
-0.3129752576351166,
0.3029792308807373,
0.016221873462200165,
0.35946953296661377,
0.13734282553195953,
-0.8176742196083069,
-0.555966854095459,
0.17488594353199005,
-0.862266480922699,
-0.19068381190299988,
-0.3255741596221924,
-0.35155925154685974,
0.4277644753456116,
0.44614362716674805,
-0.5762184262275696,
0.31165847182273865,
0.7685640454292297,
-0.22115936875343323,
0.7308779954910278,
-0.16482973098754883,
0.13799677789211273,
-1.1972852945327759,
0.029203351587057114,
-0.44829854369163513,
-0.44537055492401123,
-0.5903869867324829,
0.2743707299232483,
-0.2812201976776123,
0.24947801232337952,
-0.6028450131416321,
0.3707582354545593,
-0.48957598209381104,
-0.2069874107837677,
-0.27489352226257324,
0.21105629205703735,
-0.008472439832985401,
0.677279531955719,
0.05356563627719879,
0.8814891576766968,
0.4572627544403076,
-0.7132730484008789,
0.34535637497901917,
0.2918079197406769,
-0.2601558566093445,
0.6672389507293701,
-0.5525292158126831,
0.3441375494003296,
0.4449042081832886,
0.5736297369003296,
-0.8065565824508667,
-0.18281009793281555,
0.07944455742835999,
-0.3236517310142517,
-0.24927039444446564,
-0.1209283098578453,
-0.6069733500480652,
-0.07325275987386703,
-0.265903502702713,
0.1459892988204956,
0.20390409231185913,
-0.35425087809562683,
0.9494868516921997,
0.4489045739173889,
0.02160005271434784,
-0.5964305996894836,
-0.8527652621269226,
0.2133026123046875,
0.17746330797672272,
-1.0443229675292969,
0.6758056879043579,
-0.19204379618167877,
-0.4659937024116516,
-0.05983846262097359,
-0.05976046249270439,
-0.2874809503555298,
0.04227951541543007,
0.756476640701294,
0.08914200961589813,
0.2511390149593353,
-0.3910597860813141,
-0.29898643493652344,
-0.18963603675365448,
-0.027101611718535423,
-0.2058030068874359,
0.7072242498397827,
-0.2527104914188385,
-0.12658435106277466,
-0.5832645297050476,
0.5941551923751831,
0.6199561357498169,
-0.29626891016960144,
0.44611766934394836,
0.34177568554878235,
-0.1774996966123581,
-0.5654698610305786,
-0.22817100584506989,
0.09865707159042358,
-0.5248993635177612,
0.14465507864952087,
-0.47331327199935913,
-0.7758910655975342,
0.8487963080406189,
-0.14392291009426117,
0.183720663189888,
0.018671151250600815,
0.6920596957206726,
-0.27564024925231934,
0.6988983750343323,
0.8622022271156311,
-0.2913915514945984,
0.2117072343826294,
-0.6924479603767395,
-0.17728079855442047,
-0.7863101959228516,
-0.21480698883533478,
-0.28358396887779236,
-0.24422243237495422,
-0.3118073344230652,
-0.6683815121650696,
0.5001619458198547,
-0.28304368257522583,
-0.24866658449172974,
0.5224965810775757,
-0.48629483580589294,
0.3657507300376892,
0.5372483730316162,
-0.2600575387477875,
0.7609900236129761,
-0.20263773202896118,
-0.20849263668060303,
0.2800261378288269,
-0.8195476531982422,
-0.4447106122970581,
0.3213048279285431,
-0.039258867502212524,
0.6318604350090027,
0.04595465585589409,
0.889335036277771,
0.7102032899856567,
0.03904018551111221,
-0.7082316279411316,
0.8767535090446472,
0.052415478974580765,
-0.4071817398071289,
-0.19242797791957855,
-0.13229186832904816,
-1.4461127519607544,
0.2762691378593445,
-0.2498854100704193,
-0.82252436876297,
0.1362670361995697,
-0.04773898795247078,
-0.2099020928144455,
0.34184426069259644,
-0.5092846751213074,
0.5765371322631836,
0.01943078078329563,
-0.4752366244792938,
-0.25788575410842896,
-0.8921642303466797,
0.14704956114292145,
0.015932554379105568,
0.5331730246543884,
0.014012444764375687,
-0.2700578272342682,
0.33892008662223816,
-0.3215811252593994,
0.9598037004470825,
0.36366572976112366,
-0.10718166828155518,
0.44614970684051514,
0.6570932865142822,
0.811023473739624,
-0.2012605220079422,
-0.18226955831050873,
0.22974392771720886,
-0.26479965448379517,
-0.21971482038497925,
-0.5886765718460083,
0.7535493969917297,
-0.8235797882080078,
-0.2513122856616974,
-0.49737873673439026,
-0.9981278777122498,
-0.1195068210363388,
0.0013987242709845304,
0.16346517205238342,
0.27108243107795715,
-0.4037926197052002,
0.18703415989875793,
-0.15950745344161987,
0.3580632209777832,
0.5375736951828003,
0.41863319277763367,
-0.02583586610853672,
-0.4526003301143646,
0.5394757986068726,
0.12718868255615234,
0.5467204451560974,
0.8003739714622498,
-0.21292473375797272,
0.10629936307668686,
-0.2962023913860321,
0.18917691707611084,
-0.19305868446826935,
-0.6845983862876892,
-0.23170147836208344,
-0.4890464246273041,
-0.1954626441001892,
-0.4207616150379181,
-0.8948357701301575,
-0.3964523375034332,
-0.3090319037437439,
-0.06504916399717331,
0.09773367643356323,
-0.06563152372837067,
1.0115878582000732,
-0.19364261627197266,
0.3788341283798218,
-0.4398443102836609,
0.3315228819847107,
-0.016300436109304428,
-0.029539836570620537,
-0.000012445342690625694,
-0.007450969889760017,
-0.3257110118865967,
-0.09405794739723206,
-0.38642051815986633,
-0.40915003418922424,
0.4103016257286072,
-0.012473544105887413,
0.4358481466770172,
0.023827657103538513,
0.41531190276145935,
0.9175561666488647,
-0.48122307658195496,
0.6786177158355713,
-0.10626837611198425,
-0.7971712946891785,
0.4466984272003174,
-0.506269633769989,
0.4593084156513214,
0.4699351489543915,
0.4477159082889557,
-0.538730800151825,
-0.6324135065078735,
-0.6124810576438904,
-1.0189188718795776,
0.5747287273406982,
0.43264514207839966,
-0.5345675945281982,
0.256544828414917,
0.27227774262428284,
-0.0688076838850975,
0.02073882892727852,
-0.6070083975791931,
-0.33120012283325195,
0.31195521354675293,
0.07305964082479477,
0.10417307168245316,
0.2945334017276764,
-0.29027053713798523,
-0.12859322130680084,
0.44803479313850403,
-0.27022585272789,
0.37120676040649414,
0.4474669396877289,
-0.08387217670679092,
-0.13961704075336456,
0.09161948412656784,
0.42839279770851135,
0.6459490060806274,
-0.1231507733464241,
0.44296520948410034,
0.06843791902065277,
-0.374697208404541,
0.22357651591300964,
-0.2825140953063965,
-0.12181330472230911,
-0.7609109282493591,
0.994969367980957,
0.025117052718997,
0.17448818683624268,
-0.2994237542152405,
0.19626979529857635,
0.018976004794239998,
-0.39719346165657043,
-0.4372721314430237,
0.2022586464881897,
0.1330760270357132,
0.46306008100509644,
0.5453857779502869,
0.21885554492473602,
0.11357305198907852,
-0.7774943113327026,
0.5382696390151978,
0.3106120526790619,
-0.21096454560756683,
-0.2513372004032135,
0.547129213809967,
0.4232691526412964,
-0.6491860747337341,
0.2872602641582489,
-0.38440948724746704,
-0.45641863346099854,
0.7616611123085022,
0.6658782362937927,
0.8798961639404297,
0.022308748215436935,
0.4353852868080139,
-0.10421275347471237,
0.3641703426837921,
0.13744676113128662,
0.26158085465431213,
-0.154896542429924,
-0.5949729084968567,
-0.6602964401245117,
-0.31528133153915405,
-0.6495001316070557,
-0.2600570023059845,
-0.2560238242149353,
0.2343997359275818,
-0.6099601984024048,
0.0012975295539945364,
-0.3378501534461975,
0.4781479835510254,
-0.38952842354774475,
-0.028173625469207764,
-0.07752198725938797,
0.6336416602134705,
-0.4203648269176483,
0.9209086298942566,
0.8110283613204956,
-0.2779366672039032,
-0.49774840474128723,
0.052811820060014725,
0.28662827610969543,
-0.7984380125999451,
0.5768254995346069,
-0.08679987490177155,
-0.7838762998580933,
0.02589152194559574,
-0.5080791711807251,
-1.00729501247406,
1.4958893060684204,
0.26433759927749634,
-0.31854528188705444,
-0.22514285147190094,
0.25552302598953247,
0.6757638454437256,
-0.7341786623001099,
-0.10156005620956421,
0.11565865576267242,
0.3470870554447174,
0.2569270730018616,
-1.0336511135101318,
0.2714616358280182,
-0.033381350338459015,
-0.3442416787147522,
-0.019064873456954956,
-0.8777045607566833,
0.8942850828170776,
-0.2121211439371109,
-0.2651151120662689,
0.3442888557910919,
0.7098223567008972,
0.2398030161857605,
0.17268812656402588,
0.6045036911964417,
0.06976605206727982,
0.6469619870185852,
0.0971098467707634,
0.9679305553436279,
-0.36725080013275146,
0.24445408582687378,
1.4168517589569092,
-0.5856497287750244,
0.8785178065299988,
0.17427434027194977,
-0.10577329248189926,
0.7538012862205505,
0.27137291431427,
0.21749907732009888,
0.4967176616191864,
-0.09108663350343704,
-0.24259045720100403,
-0.2525171935558319,
-0.361255019903183,
0.17966245114803314,
0.48357436060905457,
0.15086457133293152,
0.4456213414669037,
-0.16640403866767883,
-0.24160848557949066,
0.133517324924469,
0.2404043823480606,
-0.2946569323539734,
0.689157247543335,
0.08904249966144562,
-0.8999279737472534,
0.5447176098823547,
-0.2353104054927826,
0.7413825392723083,
-0.6939799189567566,
-0.19709819555282593,
-0.03119194135069847,
0.40359702706336975,
-0.6339415311813354,
-0.8929938077926636,
0.5471330285072327,
-0.4670460522174835,
-0.0902462974190712,
-0.34204718470573425,
0.7741453051567078,
-0.21250790357589722,
0.12104184925556183,
0.8259116411209106,
0.5214693546295166,
-0.057190991938114166,
-0.22245630621910095,
-0.771469235420227,
0.10079386085271835,
-0.30017387866973877,
0.09506559371948242,
0.2885279357433319,
0.2529921531677246,
-0.3572295904159546,
1.157011866569519,
0.6825970411300659,
0.04248986765742302,
-0.08523710072040558,
-0.079875648021698,
0.5568673610687256,
-0.35798531770706177,
-0.7269553542137146,
-0.6795045137405396,
0.6308104991912842,
-0.050745800137519836,
-0.08600924164056778,
0.4599608778953552,
0.5778437852859497,
0.8332720994949341,
0.208989679813385,
0.7068353891372681,
-0.2490544319152832,
0.1247309148311615,
-0.28926900029182434,
0.5868973731994629,
-0.5300856828689575,
0.13337045907974243,
-0.25291094183921814,
-0.6507338285446167,
-0.5370808243751526,
0.7319778203964233,
0.042122311890125275,
-0.26032280921936035,
0.9425214529037476,
0.6037773489952087,
0.25490057468414307,
-0.21431991457939148,
0.4256078898906708,
0.25861644744873047,
0.6251170039176941,
0.6859087944030762,
0.7362145185470581,
0.039774585515260696,
0.6396854519844055,
-0.44795140624046326,
-0.28168392181396484,
0.030225513502955437,
-0.9054704904556274,
-0.8204786777496338,
-0.971488893032074,
-0.1303424835205078,
-0.008389979600906372,
0.19365110993385315,
1.3973044157028198,
1.0580165386199951,
-0.3786243796348572,
-0.8614102602005005,
-0.3790241479873657,
0.29117894172668457,
-0.47630131244659424,
-0.25397443771362305,
0.2635205090045929,
-0.40615758299827576,
-0.5580716133117676,
0.6874502301216125,
0.36286842823028564,
-0.3319268822669983,
-0.37000536918640137,
-0.24966908991336823,
-0.6167410016059875,
-0.2298291027545929,
0.8273282647132874,
0.14820429682731628,
-0.6024516224861145,
-0.26962926983833313,
0.013086497783660889,
-0.2801043689250946,
0.24245838820934296,
0.9759365916252136,
-0.854703962802887,
0.04684334620833397,
0.38715440034866333,
0.3687251806259155,
0.4257211685180664,
0.05846110358834267,
0.7875259518623352,
-1.1311323642730713,
0.18445231020450592,
0.275717556476593,
0.21751439571380615,
0.027274833992123604,
-0.5306395888328552,
1.1381967067718506,
0.1576518416404724,
-1.0295120477676392,
-0.5096885561943054,
0.31243351101875305,
-1.5734596252441406,
-0.28511571884155273,
1.0516960620880127,
0.041358642280101776,
-0.16133323311805725,
-0.5651625990867615,
-0.32696783542633057,
0.19551990926265717,
-0.526854395866394,
0.6207289099693298,
0.46617403626441956,
-0.6998259425163269,
0.1923285722732544,
-0.5577602386474609,
0.4601260721683502,
0.08074727654457092,
-1.0147826671600342,
0.22830235958099365,
0.28484275937080383,
0.04038776457309723,
0.4434298872947693,
1.1128219366073608,
0.2638798654079437,
0.13080056011676788,
-0.10154823213815689,
0.37150251865386963,
-0.1697482466697693,
-0.6376387476921082,
0.06811267882585526,
0.32005903124809265,
-0.1523299217224121,
0.05212826281785965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13375v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13375v1 | ALiiCE: Evaluating Positional Fine-grained Citation Generation | 2024-06-19T09:16:14 | 2024-06-19T09:16:14 | Yilong Xu, Jinhua Gao, Xiaoming Yu, Baolong Bi, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) can enhance the credibility and verifiability by
generating text with citations. However, existing tasks and evaluation methods
are predominantly limited to sentence-level statement, neglecting the
significance of positional fine-grained citations that can appear anywhere
within sentences. To facilitate further exploration of the fine-grained
citation generation, we propose ALiiCE, the first automatic evaluation
framework for this task. Our framework first parses the sentence claim into
atomic claims via dependency analysis and then calculates citation quality at
the atomic claim level. ALiiCE introduces three novel metrics for positional
fined-grained citation quality assessment, including positional fine-grained
citation recall and precision, and coefficient of variation of citation
positions. We evaluate the positional fine-grained citation generation
performance of several LLMs on two long-form QA datasets. Our experiments and
analyses demonstrate the effectiveness and reasonableness of ALiiCE. The
results also indicate that existing LLMs still struggle to provide positional
fine-grained citations. | [
-0.01419488899409771,
-0.6255148649215698,
0.9770416021347046,
0.25711292028427124,
0.0673062652349472,
-0.08855234086513519,
0.03599434345960617,
-0.4300314486026764,
0.07344648987054825,
0.152174711227417,
0.09790696948766708,
-0.6003360748291016,
-0.4297110140323639,
0.3055839538574219,
-0.4362899363040924,
0.585049033164978,
0.026689400896430016,
-0.07336247712373734,
-0.2508262097835541,
-0.04590025916695595,
-0.3388632833957672,
-0.3062991201877594,
-0.5570054054260254,
-0.1445402204990387,
0.5512542724609375,
0.36679989099502563,
0.7233166694641113,
0.6078925132751465,
0.6166122555732727,
0.289293110370636,
-0.013507851399481297,
0.36233779788017273,
-0.11942865699529648,
0.18000201880931854,
-0.6505573391914368,
-0.1920466125011444,
-0.41034063696861267,
0.06008274108171463,
0.8998827338218689,
0.7211048007011414,
0.09992852061986923,
0.32053008675575256,
0.012966449372470379,
0.6504496932029724,
-0.930164635181427,
-0.06487981975078583,
-0.9433083534240723,
-0.27416273951530457,
-0.3284963071346283,
-0.428487628698349,
-0.6000350117683411,
-0.5481679439544678,
-0.03672867268323898,
-0.26376980543136597,
-0.189401313662529,
0.19744639098644257,
1.1491254568099976,
0.15015515685081482,
-0.6238790154457092,
-0.4852100908756256,
-0.6252297759056091,
0.9034794569015503,
-0.7233845591545105,
0.144674152135849,
0.4469032287597656,
0.2828060984611511,
-0.22099433839321136,
-0.93198162317276,
-0.32255539298057556,
-0.6054285764694214,
-0.09152783453464508,
-0.06693821400403976,
-0.24578656256198883,
-0.08817442506551743,
-0.06334654241800308,
0.33887872099876404,
-0.5130878686904907,
-0.10686095803976059,
-0.20507964491844177,
-0.06341519951820374,
0.7176271080970764,
-0.16081638634204865,
0.28793150186538696,
-0.7485023140907288,
-0.35412803292274475,
0.012553974986076355,
-0.7505393624305725,
-0.12178666144609451,
0.30153438448905945,
0.48380613327026367,
0.41280490159988403,
0.6167608499526978,
-0.258250892162323,
0.32623931765556335,
0.3296429514884949,
0.0005053462809883058,
0.10349832475185394,
-0.4637238383293152,
-0.3992491364479065,
0.26461905241012573,
0.8427299857139587,
0.10922486335039139,
-0.017819121479988098,
-0.20785747468471527,
-0.15643581748008728,
-0.3926669955253601,
0.3019426167011261,
-1.093596339225769,
0.04417192190885544,
0.5593238472938538,
-0.6147452592849731,
-0.30974507331848145,
0.22987791895866394,
-0.1666593700647354,
-0.2413249909877777,
-0.36021342873573303,
0.4395293593406677,
-0.5702968835830688,
0.22359788417816162,
-0.3333558142185211,
0.20070219039916992,
-0.0467095710337162,
0.18541459739208221,
-0.5443634390830994,
-0.16432683169841766,
0.6406051516532898,
0.9478974938392639,
-0.040231190621852875,
-0.26393207907676697,
-0.9068803191184998,
0.23589667677879333,
-0.40551966428756714,
1.1473950147628784,
-0.734439492225647,
-0.20256714522838593,
0.3029349148273468,
-0.029504219070076942,
0.023956742137670517,
-0.7481274008750916,
0.8623608350753784,
-0.5485037565231323,
-0.2260351926088333,
-0.2676176428794861,
-0.7743545174598694,
0.12647482752799988,
0.3156706988811493,
-0.6187705397605896,
0.8915837407112122,
0.22344276309013367,
-0.5435636639595032,
0.37411990761756897,
-0.3587333858013153,
-0.316590279340744,
0.14355798065662384,
-0.20790353417396545,
-0.25981149077415466,
0.3164737820625305,
-0.025264659896492958,
0.40312713384628296,
-0.3922334313392639,
0.5229278802871704,
-0.2698953151702881,
-0.11355403810739517,
0.37188687920570374,
-0.340410441160202,
0.7381347417831421,
0.5411606431007385,
-0.038217585533857346,
0.13530226051807404,
-1.174987554550171,
0.2809451222419739,
-0.1216728538274765,
-0.4840787351131439,
-0.7933968305587769,
0.07306184619665146,
0.1331142634153366,
0.004607596900314093,
0.5225163102149963,
-0.4360300898551941,
0.09734946489334106,
-0.4883827865123749,
0.35701635479927063,
0.4622637927532196,
0.21590352058410645,
0.34962502121925354,
-0.12973059713840485,
0.4270058274269104,
-0.23873351514339447,
-0.017803698778152466,
-0.23179300129413605,
0.10484407097101212,
-0.5319312810897827,
-0.09914742410182953,
0.5152252912521362,
0.32065314054489136,
-0.5910086631774902,
0.5427642464637756,
-0.354282408952713,
-0.34526440501213074,
-0.2390744686126709,
0.24710403382778168,
0.3677492141723633,
0.2709938883781433,
0.35977450013160706,
-0.007335875649005175,
-0.3643006384372711,
-1.0013279914855957,
-0.2219681292772293,
-0.5538628697395325,
-0.08072935789823532,
0.17820937931537628,
0.6163291931152344,
-0.08199922740459442,
1.0340733528137207,
0.03717496991157532,
-0.04598180577158928,
0.1716117560863495,
0.6679838299751282,
-0.11175333708524704,
0.5733879208564758,
0.6497769355773926,
-0.4869585335254669,
-0.5336889028549194,
0.0785851702094078,
-0.8953772187232971,
-0.4102463722229004,
-0.19161367416381836,
-0.32931965589523315,
0.047570884227752686,
0.5248024463653564,
-0.48285767436027527,
0.05522613599896431,
0.3431210219860077,
-0.4679113030433655,
0.6516968011856079,
-0.015333571471273899,
0.44882383942604065,
-1.1893091201782227,
0.3602215349674225,
-0.06877537071704865,
-0.3536645770072937,
-0.26912257075309753,
0.3556303083896637,
0.19332394003868103,
-0.02434341423213482,
-0.3475363552570343,
0.6046728491783142,
-0.40599921345710754,
-0.19179050624370575,
-0.5511201620101929,
0.31741780042648315,
0.370755672454834,
-0.10980647802352905,
-0.28647807240486145,
0.9004479646682739,
-0.03310585021972656,
-0.25630462169647217,
-0.009115626104176044,
0.15531207621097565,
-0.49033889174461365,
0.9471377730369568,
-0.7962093353271484,
-0.04972304776310921,
0.19267117977142334,
0.21990586817264557,
-0.9074895977973938,
-0.25275668501853943,
-0.3478214740753174,
-0.30922502279281616,
0.22903360426425934,
-0.23836395144462585,
-0.5308161377906799,
-0.12081725895404816,
-0.3040609657764435,
0.527761697769165,
-0.018005864694714546,
-0.6329745054244995,
0.3342577815055847,
0.16749070584774017,
-0.4433901906013489,
-0.4818808436393738,
-0.33253470063209534,
0.3075113594532013,
-0.23374131321907043,
-0.7111741900444031,
0.39070168137550354,
0.021730346605181694,
-0.7227786183357239,
-0.2429571896791458,
-0.030215425416827202,
-0.15316393971443176,
0.24798433482646942,
0.15287594497203827,
0.005550263915210962,
-0.27219897508621216,
0.3540019094944,
0.29938027262687683,
0.006337703205645084,
0.14069628715515137,
-0.32700496912002563,
0.3268605172634125,
-0.418008953332901,
-0.38742995262145996,
-0.3963708281517029,
0.37141555547714233,
0.3990633189678192,
-0.1671447604894638,
0.3792892396450043,
0.3825562298297882,
-0.28454092144966125,
-0.17988406121730804,
-0.4533984959125519,
0.15054543316364288,
-0.40877628326416016,
0.2304169237613678,
-0.32134199142456055,
-0.5476391911506653,
0.29619547724723816,
-0.32468459010124207,
-0.042569734156131744,
0.5838060975074768,
0.37981027364730835,
0.012662981636822224,
0.7410685420036316,
0.28875666856765747,
0.12580005824565887,
0.4175267815589905,
0.002344942418858409,
0.06737277656793594,
-0.6217441558837891,
0.13377420604228973,
-0.871813952922821,
-0.11536211520433426,
-0.38821783661842346,
-0.3742254376411438,
0.2218320369720459,
0.6251741051673889,
-0.44513511657714844,
0.154145285487175,
-0.34769564867019653,
0.5186856985092163,
0.5485265851020813,
-0.2094673365354538,
0.49298095703125,
0.012682303786277771,
0.032050296664237976,
0.18077190220355988,
-0.19685867428779602,
-1.094146966934204,
1.0657802820205688,
0.29949408769607544,
0.43927547335624695,
0.21446280181407928,
0.9141972661018372,
0.6702761650085449,
0.24582548439502716,
-0.8241725564002991,
0.5050080418586731,
-0.12481556832790375,
-0.49150028824806213,
-0.23950867354869843,
-0.26108649373054504,
-1.0184848308563232,
0.06379606574773788,
0.1408066600561142,
-0.7606063485145569,
0.45888423919677734,
0.1319524198770523,
-0.7204235196113586,
-0.36480048298835754,
-0.5920974016189575,
0.6511259078979492,
-0.2932220995426178,
-0.8011273145675659,
-0.014746119268238544,
-0.4557035267353058,
0.2820083796977997,
-0.07110749185085297,
0.022256413474678993,
-0.18339696526527405,
0.3074306547641754,
0.6662125587463379,
-0.7907615900039673,
0.40789729356765747,
-0.2658372223377228,
-0.3127726912498474,
0.5966311097145081,
0.35158270597457886,
0.7304526567459106,
0.22637414932250977,
-0.517845630645752,
-0.001221776008605957,
0.1956893354654312,
-0.3255791664123535,
-0.522417426109314,
1.0752540826797485,
-0.560204803943634,
-0.3184245526790619,
-0.3870882987976074,
-0.6174105405807495,
-0.2850273847579956,
0.3212423622608185,
-0.03752138465642929,
0.31906893849372864,
-0.3066082000732422,
0.2822105884552002,
0.3325386345386505,
-0.2597307562828064,
0.46472761034965515,
0.40492603182792664,
-0.1146627888083458,
-0.5883612632751465,
0.8971494436264038,
0.08389957249164581,
0.1271757334470749,
0.36723023653030396,
0.20500104129314423,
-0.176544651389122,
-0.6625561714172363,
-0.3911110758781433,
0.13460524380207062,
-0.7063526511192322,
-0.43244439363479614,
-0.37720006704330444,
-0.25451287627220154,
-0.3670501410961151,
-0.3476884961128235,
-0.5785800814628601,
-0.5638710260391235,
-0.11389581859111786,
-0.07686278969049454,
0.06847135722637177,
0.5260376334190369,
-0.00009162510832538828,
0.35752421617507935,
-0.8118589520454407,
-0.023905407637357712,
0.17349979281425476,
0.045222390443086624,
-0.03170451149344444,
-0.41560831665992737,
-0.4726586639881134,
-0.19165393710136414,
-0.43129807710647583,
-0.610442578792572,
0.45435234904289246,
0.25171902775764465,
0.3077971637248993,
0.44823288917541504,
0.14604756236076355,
0.7935923337936401,
-0.7641696333885193,
0.9206141233444214,
0.015239207074046135,
-0.9927085638046265,
0.859158456325531,
-0.31359177827835083,
0.0689241960644722,
1.0054937601089478,
0.2613382041454315,
0.2874700129032135,
-0.3994869291782379,
-0.5596556067466736,
-1.2195253372192383,
0.3080490529537201,
0.38314756751060486,
-0.17324599623680115,
-0.32576820254325867,
0.41881710290908813,
0.09903393685817719,
0.10250888764858246,
-0.7691494226455688,
-0.1192566528916359,
-0.07544324547052383,
-0.3981296122074127,
0.35786667466163635,
-0.49939021468162537,
-0.19361968338489532,
0.0607343353331089,
0.7740079164505005,
-0.14853067696094513,
0.1694091558456421,
0.4119168817996979,
-0.34501132369041443,
-0.10533712804317474,
0.6873720288276672,
0.3878232538700104,
0.955256998538971,
-0.4100190997123718,
0.3025524914264679,
-0.360609769821167,
-0.04877316579222679,
0.21100828051567078,
0.4243101179599762,
-0.5535476207733154,
0.290803998708725,
0.313122034072876,
0.3860205113887787,
0.2663458585739136,
-0.6165081262588501,
0.450361967086792,
0.23626601696014404,
0.09447123110294342,
-0.593250572681427,
-0.12959906458854675,
-0.19062629342079163,
0.5548561811447144,
0.5124130249023438,
-0.2472590208053589,
0.5008928179740906,
-0.6605576872825623,
0.2926442623138428,
0.500280499458313,
-0.14584378898143768,
-0.22548799216747284,
0.7383047342300415,
0.24590477347373962,
-0.10140849649906158,
0.19787020981311798,
-0.2660025954246521,
0.05281507968902588,
0.35376182198524475,
0.578537106513977,
0.9727400541305542,
-0.18663166463375092,
0.28243184089660645,
0.6413522362709045,
0.08102955669164658,
0.05397682636976242,
0.04965304210782051,
-0.08658664673566818,
-0.4004318416118622,
-0.34096789360046387,
-1.0674725770950317,
-0.2768402397632599,
0.14715810120105743,
-0.5702311396598816,
-0.03383524343371391,
-0.3155555725097656,
-0.3701534867286682,
0.17721423506736755,
0.27119335532188416,
-0.40025338530540466,
0.060377709567546844,
0.21381185948848724,
0.7924159169197083,
-0.6950663328170776,
0.829429030418396,
0.72628253698349,
-0.793387234210968,
-0.8219391703605652,
0.14480280876159668,
-0.3035215437412262,
-0.5962056517601013,
1.1252753734588623,
0.13125717639923096,
-0.3594469130039215,
-0.11380981653928757,
-0.6377245783805847,
-1.0090802907943726,
1.328981637954712,
0.3852995038032532,
-0.5359219908714294,
-0.012979391030967236,
0.10992061346769333,
0.3077266216278076,
-0.3963654041290283,
0.5160929560661316,
0.4976778030395508,
0.5268707275390625,
0.07828731834888458,
-0.9629003405570984,
0.18557865917682648,
-0.4015907347202301,
0.3360171318054199,
-0.19751191139221191,
-0.728651225566864,
0.7698513269424438,
0.16616185009479523,
-0.1290738880634308,
0.555508017539978,
1.0121248960494995,
0.6094998121261597,
0.5729817152023315,
0.2186567634344101,
0.29227307438850403,
1.0980933904647827,
0.11053892225027084,
1.0780709981918335,
-0.4945507347583771,
0.3869360387325287,
1.4805748462677002,
-0.7393637895584106,
1.213963508605957,
0.5548600554466248,
-0.24007442593574524,
0.7425079345703125,
0.39443233609199524,
0.041744645684957504,
0.310208261013031,
0.1392245888710022,
-0.16519400477409363,
-0.2962798476219177,
-0.3730124533176422,
-0.24733121693134308,
0.31684184074401855,
0.17588701844215393,
-0.8719483017921448,
-0.3317599594593048,
0.07182054221630096,
0.10532251745462418,
0.3014693260192871,
-0.3941163718700409,
0.3705541789531708,
0.08879058808088303,
-0.7213743925094604,
0.6774341464042664,
0.09818673878908157,
0.1851413995027542,
-0.3851649761199951,
-0.1245354562997818,
-0.3385835289955139,
0.19786198437213898,
-0.2728075385093689,
-0.3995530605316162,
0.2164115160703659,
0.24938111007213593,
-0.3127882182598114,
-0.030757125467061996,
0.7551240921020508,
-0.16376373171806335,
-0.5644294619560242,
0.1550886631011963,
0.32107213139533997,
0.26897498965263367,
-0.08221741765737534,
-0.46914219856262207,
-0.028917694464325905,
-0.18283258378505707,
-0.4337009787559509,
0.3502989113330841,
0.6765809059143066,
-0.10745136439800262,
0.39482107758522034,
0.5089409947395325,
0.030196895822882652,
-0.12305980920791626,
0.342559814453125,
0.411367803812027,
-0.6126587986946106,
-0.16612504422664642,
-0.7224699258804321,
0.38048669695854187,
-0.2394198179244995,
-0.09197024255990982,
1.069863200187683,
0.6617445349693298,
0.5193644762039185,
0.233236625790596,
0.9051523804664612,
-0.15532036125659943,
0.38272443413734436,
-0.6532723307609558,
0.6249017715454102,
-0.6874515414237976,
0.4244012236595154,
-0.3469640910625458,
-0.8988601565361023,
-0.25839635729789734,
0.8021082878112793,
-0.35240083932876587,
0.005871238652616739,
0.8726903796195984,
0.6093268990516663,
-0.04250333830714226,
-0.28036537766456604,
0.25529345870018005,
0.5125126242637634,
0.4463410973548889,
0.2584865093231201,
0.8870385885238647,
-0.6735827326774597,
0.5090177655220032,
-0.023132963106036186,
-0.04919326305389404,
-0.4309563934803009,
-1.001381754875183,
-0.5255503058433533,
-0.41056036949157715,
-0.4473560154438019,
-0.5356048941612244,
0.09258726984262466,
1.1724399328231812,
0.634914219379425,
-0.9236522912979126,
-0.15850363671779633,
-0.24874870479106903,
-0.01782110705971718,
0.01345004327595234,
-0.3542289435863495,
0.6913908123970032,
-0.6425104737281799,
-1.0409998893737793,
0.7302146553993225,
0.3254941999912262,
-0.24811694025993347,
-0.24309585988521576,
-0.03250587731599808,
-0.44008293747901917,
0.2848285734653473,
0.920467734336853,
0.31911545991897583,
-0.6393107175827026,
-0.5314859747886658,
-0.2766222059726715,
-0.4011269211769104,
0.06791416555643082,
0.6904217004776001,
-0.6888657212257385,
0.20019619166851044,
0.49215105175971985,
0.5534823536872864,
-0.013786484487354755,
0.4653698801994324,
0.42110174894332886,
-0.6785709261894226,
-0.2300073802471161,
0.12547962367534637,
0.5335971713066101,
0.18909750878810883,
-0.213014155626297,
0.48600345849990845,
-0.09502635896205902,
-1.067644476890564,
-0.8925809860229492,
-0.043035201728343964,
-1.2525008916854858,
-0.3678746223449707,
1.4169652462005615,
-0.3834972083568573,
-0.2799651324748993,
0.022656632587313652,
-0.07781662791967392,
0.09167452156543732,
-0.4089961051940918,
0.8912630081176758,
0.6645827293395996,
-0.059813592582941055,
0.38102439045906067,
-0.43285638093948364,
0.12238172441720963,
0.37581154704093933,
-0.9098259210586548,
0.09779702126979828,
0.9568163752555847,
0.20128847658634186,
0.5901132822036743,
0.4121108651161194,
-0.13818024098873138,
0.15847043693065643,
-0.02398907020688057,
0.03213394805788994,
-0.15776467323303223,
-0.45934271812438965,
-0.0410606674849987,
0.5001132488250732,
0.5496876239776611,
0.08095579594373703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13363v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13363v1 | Evaluating Structural Generalization in Neural Machine Translation | 2024-06-19T09:09:11 | 2024-06-19T09:09:11 | Ryoma Kumon, Daiki Matsuoka, Hitomi Yanaka | cs.CL | cs.CL | Compositional generalization refers to the ability to generalize to novel
combinations of previously observed words and syntactic structures. Since it is
regarded as a desired property of neural models, recent work has assessed
compositional generalization in machine translation as well as semantic
parsing. However, previous evaluations with machine translation have focused
mostly on lexical generalization (i.e., generalization to unseen combinations
of known words). Thus, it remains unclear to what extent models can translate
sentences that require structural generalization (i.e., generalization to
different sorts of syntactic structures). To address this question, we
construct SGET, a machine translation dataset covering various types of
compositional generalization with control of words and sentence structures. We
evaluate neural machine translation models on SGET and show that they struggle
more in structural generalization than in lexical generalization. We also find
different performance trends in semantic parsing and machine translation, which
indicates the importance of evaluations across various tasks. | [
0.13178673386573792,
-0.703781247138977,
0.5005921125411987,
0.5015814304351807,
-0.32919907569885254,
0.008417009375989437,
-0.287887305021286,
-0.20815420150756836,
0.2066076695919037,
0.20601136982440948,
-0.24249060451984406,
-0.756509006023407,
-0.7801322340965271,
0.1626245379447937,
-0.5524301528930664,
1.1096506118774414,
-0.22598043084144592,
0.29659977555274963,
-0.2128722220659256,
-0.28803831338882446,
-0.7989329695701599,
-0.504155695438385,
-0.42784416675567627,
-0.4334564507007599,
0.4146972596645355,
-0.32193994522094727,
0.7743332982063293,
0.8922119736671448,
0.7383632063865662,
0.4867221713066101,
-0.31538933515548706,
-0.00017628826026339084,
-0.1700592339038849,
0.28926196694374084,
-0.3092619776725769,
-0.8349570035934448,
-0.5127701759338379,
-0.21325382590293884,
0.9995778203010559,
1.2159141302108765,
0.06628692150115967,
0.053218208253383636,
0.08836149424314499,
0.7377457618713379,
-0.2767215073108673,
0.2606893479824066,
-0.6805552840232849,
0.31017574667930603,
0.09503559023141861,
-0.014485947787761688,
-0.20944973826408386,
-0.25966107845306396,
0.27314087748527527,
-0.584231436252594,
0.257645845413208,
-0.22341793775558472,
0.6635285019874573,
0.2696526348590851,
-0.5842748880386353,
-0.24808894097805023,
-0.6865511536598206,
0.7183465957641602,
-0.6097677946090698,
0.49830231070518494,
0.17178182303905487,
0.38139888644218445,
-0.08060184121131897,
-0.9608299136161804,
-0.07659494876861572,
-0.561505138874054,
-0.18173722922801971,
0.19210100173950195,
-0.18520790338516235,
0.3721194863319397,
0.04568144679069519,
0.735866129398346,
-0.8162704706192017,
-0.0620071180164814,
-0.48848456144332886,
-0.2634647488594055,
0.4665994346141815,
0.22621215879917145,
0.8158278465270996,
-0.3298807144165039,
-0.45931974053382874,
-0.21431666612625122,
-0.2262287437915802,
-0.052445050328969955,
0.4156573414802551,
0.2503735423088074,
0.00258350046351552,
0.7836993336677551,
-0.22278741002082825,
0.7093175053596497,
0.024974241852760315,
0.4294263422489166,
0.31526851654052734,
-0.6865622997283936,
-0.44316616654396057,
-0.06946491450071335,
0.6564635634422302,
0.45865052938461304,
0.23580245673656464,
-0.5277573466300964,
-0.3382175862789154,
0.4283335208892822,
0.44690975546836853,
-0.7648952007293701,
-0.13694825768470764,
0.21929752826690674,
-0.7483565211296082,
-0.23895588517189026,
-0.007236842066049576,
-0.2663188874721527,
-0.0977991595864296,
-0.3829551637172699,
0.2086573988199234,
-0.4637512266635895,
-0.0842181071639061,
0.1741810142993927,
-0.43580102920532227,
0.24136698246002197,
-0.09673943370580673,
-1.11795973777771,
0.3624000549316406,
0.8111441731452942,
1.0261770486831665,
-0.32939818501472473,
-0.3717636466026306,
-0.23931020498275757,
0.02292824722826481,
-0.4754135310649872,
0.5869412422180176,
-0.6724573969841003,
-0.37290331721305847,
-0.2733731269836426,
0.04713961482048035,
-0.6068736910820007,
-0.6116784811019897,
0.4504711329936981,
-0.47148874402046204,
0.006706150248646736,
-0.26647111773490906,
-0.6734939217567444,
-0.1918637603521347,
0.25629910826683044,
-0.6162549257278442,
0.610893189907074,
0.14205200970172882,
-0.49821555614471436,
0.5486416220664978,
-0.6456403136253357,
-0.6177186965942383,
0.14930778741836548,
-0.3879927098751068,
-0.17781148850917816,
0.6645398736000061,
0.07437276095151901,
0.4571346640586853,
0.052058782428503036,
0.5601040720939636,
-0.18301452696323395,
-0.28378090262413025,
0.036225538700819016,
-0.0596843846142292,
0.4176918566226959,
0.18124297261238098,
-0.34110909700393677,
0.429055780172348,
-0.5512629151344299,
0.24175207316875458,
-0.02081032283604145,
-0.5143631100654602,
-0.5589792132377625,
0.13470357656478882,
-0.13702277839183807,
0.028890173882246017,
0.3827621340751648,
-0.31150907278060913,
0.39260536432266235,
-0.9663270115852356,
0.6640872955322266,
0.7111778855323792,
-0.018612796440720558,
0.8283209204673767,
0.07896754890680313,
0.6729435920715332,
0.0645393431186676,
-0.17800532281398773,
-0.11435592174530029,
-0.4294390082359314,
-0.5696167349815369,
0.11027336120605469,
0.5204127430915833,
0.6123660802841187,
-0.6909113526344299,
0.3631686866283417,
-0.4757239818572998,
-0.288687139749527,
-0.24422290921211243,
0.19535930454730988,
0.6446681618690491,
0.10964663326740265,
0.342337042093277,
-0.29153892397880554,
-0.5835060477256775,
-1.3565340042114258,
-0.4721105396747589,
0.11970733106136322,
-0.23087267577648163,
0.049684714525938034,
0.5251702666282654,
-0.2559054493904114,
0.5484963655471802,
-0.3022709786891937,
-0.04198210686445236,
-0.31258323788642883,
0.21888093650341034,
0.12365634739398956,
0.4706099033355713,
0.452034592628479,
-0.8804560303688049,
-0.42466533184051514,
0.5454565286636353,
-1.1104021072387695,
0.1710248440504074,
-0.1682618409395218,
0.007703778799623251,
-0.14141002297401428,
0.5603210926055908,
-0.47073760628700256,
0.16854983568191528,
0.6799831390380859,
-0.15686219930648804,
0.2881179749965668,
-0.16342979669570923,
0.0049769263714551926,
-1.3523632287979126,
0.16515734791755676,
-0.12871885299682617,
0.005069851875305176,
-0.6824825406074524,
0.46268969774246216,
-0.015926556661725044,
-0.08571364730596542,
-0.2991938591003418,
0.18094441294670105,
-0.5902519822120667,
-0.44793450832366943,
-0.18899402022361755,
0.046691425144672394,
-0.1308247447013855,
0.4590965807437897,
-0.25921154022216797,
0.8751972317695618,
0.4237818717956543,
-0.666478157043457,
0.25214242935180664,
0.15432117879390717,
-0.24705654382705688,
0.2772710919380188,
-1.1011520624160767,
0.1929294914007187,
-0.22342488169670105,
0.15217547118663788,
-1.0204178094863892,
-0.28400397300720215,
0.03554605692625046,
-0.37854450941085815,
0.11744535714387894,
-0.15608350932598114,
-0.16642612218856812,
-0.20841114223003387,
-0.12355539202690125,
0.5152869820594788,
-0.10350628197193146,
0.0617225281894207,
0.6570366024971008,
0.10792753845453262,
-0.09830618649721146,
-0.586752712726593,
-1.044536828994751,
0.13551545143127441,
-0.07418901473283768,
-0.8409510254859924,
0.6224421858787537,
0.041722290217876434,
-0.24382738769054413,
0.15716108679771423,
-0.4818797707557678,
-0.13581636548042297,
0.19550317525863647,
0.24056679010391235,
-0.05433923006057739,
-0.5912007689476013,
0.2637642025947571,
0.26913633942604065,
0.002652317052707076,
0.04426756873726845,
-0.5659477114677429,
0.7641698718070984,
-0.5962021946907043,
-0.2582491636276245,
-0.21110233664512634,
0.3625313937664032,
0.3141753673553467,
-0.3362601697444916,
0.5584512948989868,
0.49481868743896484,
-0.3894297480583191,
-0.15475957095623016,
-0.11685888469219208,
-0.14978399872779846,
-0.4426991939544678,
0.8627675175666809,
-0.5388365983963013,
-0.8900113105773926,
0.8078944087028503,
0.052155427634716034,
-0.15326155722141266,
0.8215625286102295,
0.42312556505203247,
-0.0018394773360341787,
1.1307117938995361,
0.4655970335006714,
-0.061013542115688324,
0.5004408955574036,
-0.3184455931186676,
-0.04875430464744568,
-0.7685481905937195,
0.01353208627551794,
-0.3107476532459259,
-0.7446708083152771,
-0.8128326535224915,
-0.09838259220123291,
0.153636172413826,
0.02568097412586212,
0.13066507875919342,
0.6301352977752686,
-0.5179184675216675,
0.7504881620407104,
0.3647976219654083,
0.03741232305765152,
0.20085133612155914,
0.07658270001411438,
-0.5196890234947205,
0.07380363345146179,
-0.5002785921096802,
-0.5497598648071289,
1.280566692352295,
0.2133399099111557,
0.21455109119415283,
-0.08414830267429352,
0.5849605798721313,
0.45263123512268066,
0.08199324458837509,
-0.9717977643013,
0.5702886581420898,
-0.6644138693809509,
-0.3703092634677887,
-0.19822731614112854,
-0.6470838785171509,
-1.199255347251892,
0.4825472831726074,
0.1286943256855011,
-0.35453084111213684,
0.1849433332681656,
0.056001052260398865,
-0.15921853482723236,
0.08089235424995422,
-0.8555738925933838,
1.0304359197616577,
-0.18273332715034485,
0.18777278065681458,
-0.22121044993400574,
-0.6602532863616943,
0.4031127095222473,
0.21333664655685425,
-0.2804936468601227,
0.4618456959724426,
-0.06003503128886223,
0.6397451162338257,
-0.1726120263338089,
0.8718507885932922,
-0.09250529110431671,
0.09158150851726532,
0.18003416061401367,
0.024950331076979637,
0.3718363344669342,
-0.34840425848960876,
-0.0058284057304263115,
0.1868784874677658,
-0.053820542991161346,
-0.4214719235897064,
-0.8727944493293762,
0.652060866355896,
-0.6994535326957703,
-0.4515828788280487,
-0.0849263146519661,
-0.4892575740814209,
-0.19062981009483337,
0.3208743631839752,
0.43051964044570923,
0.17736496031284332,
-0.51773601770401,
0.42488566040992737,
0.4032100737094879,
0.05885997787117958,
0.24088232219219208,
-0.04621089622378349,
-0.2864833474159241,
-0.6652979850769043,
1.003483772277832,
0.2692173719406128,
0.3177027106285095,
0.39651310443878174,
0.18304434418678284,
-0.14207972586154938,
-0.8717833757400513,
-0.5735307931900024,
0.0023552903439849615,
-0.7183319330215454,
0.059813469648361206,
-0.722737193107605,
-0.28963154554367065,
-0.21573536098003387,
-0.011050262488424778,
-0.2146414816379547,
-0.7264056205749512,
-0.0026759605389088392,
-0.33541908860206604,
-0.48935461044311523,
0.9088941216468811,
0.381049782037735,
0.5803407430648804,
-0.7074650526046753,
0.1861220896244049,
0.329468309879303,
0.1405470073223114,
-0.17737312614917755,
-0.3662314713001251,
-0.28917914628982544,
0.03999773785471916,
-0.41353556513786316,
-0.9806419014930725,
0.08627356588840485,
0.23708119988441467,
0.7975971698760986,
0.23664501309394836,
-0.6781024932861328,
0.3558445870876312,
-0.48299047350883484,
0.7566697597503662,
0.1091371551156044,
-0.9811916947364807,
0.5777022838592529,
-0.5874447226524353,
0.32510921359062195,
0.4691244065761566,
0.2340417057275772,
-0.693860650062561,
-0.14423568546772003,
-0.4114335775375366,
-0.8270805478096008,
0.20947620272636414,
0.2537662386894226,
0.31869447231292725,
-0.0970570519566536,
0.4861777126789093,
-0.14434950053691864,
0.5821524858474731,
-0.8538182377815247,
0.057106513530015945,
-0.21335677802562714,
-0.057385627180337906,
0.08242079615592957,
-0.0901503711938858,
-0.06918656080961227,
-0.008117248304188251,
0.23566900193691254,
-0.24347138404846191,
0.25362107157707214,
0.09590993821620941,
-0.3708413243293762,
0.09318969398736954,
0.45419541001319885,
0.7614448666572571,
0.5152081847190857,
-0.05966411903500557,
-0.012979821301996708,
0.16904421150684357,
-0.30487948656082153,
0.0008757381583563983,
0.012467235326766968,
-0.35827913880348206,
-0.11405286192893982,
0.611538827419281,
1.0742679834365845,
0.36346137523651123,
-0.18806768953800201,
0.4928118884563446,
0.2518202066421509,
-0.4041847586631775,
0.13654521107673645,
0.029146702960133553,
0.06915454566478729,
0.2910725772380829,
-0.042415522038936615,
0.36512985825538635,
0.43682655692100525,
-0.5242017507553101,
0.13667279481887817,
0.34438562393188477,
-0.23590971529483795,
-0.7636352181434631,
0.5019572377204895,
-0.046335361897945404,
-0.06691925972700119,
0.6308229565620422,
-0.03622659668326378,
-0.7393689751625061,
0.8154918551445007,
0.7050734162330627,
1.3482484817504883,
-0.46412599086761475,
0.26803091168403625,
0.16180334985256195,
0.5956670045852661,
0.10049053281545639,
0.23692935705184937,
-0.14283986389636993,
-0.7294335961341858,
-0.6801390051841736,
-0.7038009762763977,
-0.20010040700435638,
-0.07265404611825943,
-0.613088071346283,
-0.08097347617149353,
-0.5722291469573975,
-0.33064427971839905,
-0.012597804889082909,
-0.3265683054924011,
-0.48945435881614685,
0.22882452607154846,
-0.04982709884643555,
0.5902355909347534,
-1.0171847343444824,
0.5865074396133423,
1.1041197776794434,
-0.5450958609580994,
-0.6122572422027588,
-0.0609053373336792,
-0.4106645882129669,
-0.7020863890647888,
0.9974079728126526,
0.2412835657596588,
0.07692241668701172,
-0.2886694669723511,
-0.3512105941772461,
-0.6421279311180115,
1.0510293245315552,
0.5210307240486145,
-0.3751298785209656,
-0.48731037974357605,
0.42751601338386536,
0.9962852001190186,
-0.4374016523361206,
-0.06921306252479553,
0.5091457962989807,
0.5982886552810669,
-0.13501767814159393,
-0.8301271796226501,
-0.006111284252256155,
-0.4581909477710724,
0.42733776569366455,
0.19865268468856812,
-0.5918064713478088,
0.989585280418396,
0.2256127893924713,
-0.4091941714286804,
-0.12479735910892487,
0.7114973068237305,
-0.17031659185886383,
0.36815330386161804,
0.4212096333503723,
0.6076502799987793,
0.6246253252029419,
-0.03127243369817734,
1.1736044883728027,
-0.22252555191516876,
0.02196686901152134,
1.3117843866348267,
0.07095350325107574,
0.7650542855262756,
0.2956129014492035,
-0.18725800514221191,
0.41481339931488037,
0.45686256885528564,
-0.13571317493915558,
0.304002970457077,
0.4667714238166809,
-0.018046215176582336,
-0.22422842681407928,
0.08256666362285614,
-0.5594800114631653,
0.6608701944351196,
0.31008079648017883,
-0.8972105979919434,
-0.34377622604370117,
-0.06357580423355103,
-0.22102485597133636,
0.1832754760980606,
-0.22781486809253693,
0.7562498450279236,
0.15717282891273499,
-0.6420981287956238,
0.5305193662643433,
0.22324596345424652,
0.2417902946472168,
-0.7529556155204773,
0.0023969297762960196,
-0.27404895424842834,
0.04157613590359688,
-0.2379963994026184,
-0.3895716071128845,
0.845390796661377,
-0.4072292745113373,
-0.42748329043388367,
-0.10636134445667267,
0.8051379919052124,
-0.349866658449173,
-0.46994277834892273,
0.3542300760746002,
0.4423801302909851,
0.10285251587629318,
-0.4509909451007843,
-0.601490318775177,
-0.00832549948245287,
-0.01047139335423708,
-0.27219250798225403,
0.3257795572280884,
0.2682929039001465,
-0.33725506067276,
0.3919735550880432,
0.6765379905700684,
0.07333790510892868,
0.4837377071380615,
0.05090852454304695,
1.0027177333831787,
-0.6848848462104797,
-0.4782719910144806,
-1.006258487701416,
0.3662289083003998,
-0.04676239937543869,
-0.4448182284832001,
0.7992563247680664,
0.6863100528717041,
0.7965462803840637,
-0.2816113829612732,
0.705926775932312,
0.22861431539058685,
-0.22828663885593414,
-0.6505242586135864,
0.5293013453483582,
-0.5658703446388245,
-0.005383089184761047,
-0.20329299569129944,
-1.287850260734558,
-0.4662470817565918,
0.47366711497306824,
-0.6196444034576416,
0.14686518907546997,
0.8650006651878357,
0.6082989573478699,
-0.19778163731098175,
0.20206177234649658,
0.4603322446346283,
0.3354746997356415,
0.1435507982969284,
0.4170663058757782,
0.6981621384620667,
-0.5472501516342163,
0.48381292819976807,
0.19832205772399902,
-0.10276350378990173,
0.053194429725408554,
-0.7715198397636414,
-0.8047587871551514,
-0.5422450304031372,
0.020335301756858826,
-0.08533705770969391,
0.17978577315807343,
0.686939537525177,
0.5787806510925293,
-0.9777302145957947,
-0.1825539618730545,
-0.6150287389755249,
-0.07454532384872437,
-0.346885085105896,
-0.19947759807109833,
0.44638606905937195,
-0.715061604976654,
-0.7812591791152954,
1.0449882745742798,
0.3699018955230713,
0.01366894505918026,
-0.1492530107498169,
0.18035155534744263,
0.056771282106637955,
0.0288084726780653,
0.6753645539283752,
0.03740923851728439,
-0.611876368522644,
-0.13238196074962616,
0.09914438426494598,
-0.09238111972808838,
0.09618110209703445,
0.9762258529663086,
-0.2964172661304474,
0.4225594103336334,
0.8230080008506775,
1.1249914169311523,
0.43076056241989136,
0.05354014039039612,
0.7823764681816101,
-0.8929510116577148,
-0.09089439362287521,
0.07576418668031693,
0.4349973797798157,
0.18298733234405518,
-0.3364149034023285,
0.6388741135597229,
0.38985684514045715,
-0.5656295418739319,
-0.5631986856460571,
0.4588501453399658,
-0.8496982455253601,
-0.06358955800533295,
0.8554059863090515,
-0.1777656525373459,
-0.3289066255092621,
0.3029375374317169,
0.002242413116618991,
0.16665251553058624,
-0.09324371814727783,
0.46469756960868835,
0.9342463612556458,
0.2092726230621338,
0.41237083077430725,
-0.5146788358688354,
0.14733123779296875,
0.9002290964126587,
-0.6814295649528503,
-0.1388869732618332,
0.46270278096199036,
0.3320735991001129,
0.2505534887313843,
0.36728373169898987,
0.01629032753407955,
0.1047983467578888,
0.07316526770591736,
-0.030176760628819466,
-0.01684020645916462,
-0.42237305641174316,
-0.5866411328315735,
0.3676512539386749,
-0.3049510419368744,
-0.40914228558540344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13362v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13362v1 | VisualRWKV: Exploring Recurrent Neural Networks for Visual Language Models | 2024-06-19T09:07:31 | 2024-06-19T09:07:31 | Haowen Hou, Peigen Zeng, Fei Ma, Fei Richard Yu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Visual Language Models (VLMs) have rapidly progressed with the recent success
of large language models. However, there have been few attempts to incorporate
efficient linear Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) architectures into VLMs. In
this study, we introduce VisualRWKV, the first application of a linear RNN
model to multimodal learning tasks, leveraging the pre-trained RWKV language
model. We propose a data-dependent recurrence and sandwich prompts to enhance
our modeling capabilities, along with a 2D image scanning mechanism to enrich
the processing of visual sequences. Extensive experiments demonstrate that
VisualRWKV achieves competitive performance compared to Transformer-based
models like LLaVA-1.5 on various benchmarks. To facilitate further research and
analysis, we have made the checkpoints and the associated code publicly
accessible at the following GitHub repository:
\href{https://github.com/howard-hou/VisualRWKV}{https://github.com/howard-hou/VisualRWKV}. | [
-0.12123889476060867,
-0.7564895153045654,
0.38833215832710266,
0.27102014422416687,
-0.3070192039012909,
-0.07307080179452896,
0.02026236616075039,
-0.30108579993247986,
-0.22019442915916443,
0.43865928053855896,
-0.5551748871803284,
-0.46677306294441223,
-0.4143444895744324,
-0.06558649986982346,
-0.503275990486145,
0.5239223837852478,
0.2018875777721405,
0.28939342498779297,
-0.32999908924102783,
-0.2710998058319092,
-0.45472660660743713,
-0.11966630816459656,
-0.48608922958374023,
-0.4241921603679657,
1.181727647781372,
0.2451760470867157,
0.45533987879753113,
0.639350950717926,
0.44159233570098877,
0.3827127516269684,
0.12106764316558838,
0.01586989127099514,
-0.6981396079063416,
0.4923412799835205,
-0.009548925794661045,
-0.15732364356517792,
0.12075198441743851,
-0.23336417973041534,
0.7037827968597412,
0.43839794397354126,
-0.3304799497127533,
0.07476750761270523,
-0.24714389443397522,
0.6219245791435242,
-0.5027526021003723,
0.32880955934524536,
-0.4358845055103302,
0.23412232100963593,
-0.40664926171302795,
0.05935034900903702,
-0.5137448906898499,
-0.36065053939819336,
0.484172523021698,
-0.4979507327079773,
0.04996030032634735,
0.03493089973926544,
0.574694037437439,
0.038967739790678024,
-0.4254802465438843,
0.22403086721897125,
-0.5117478370666504,
1.0166572332382202,
-0.6559844613075256,
0.7649160623550415,
-0.029880331829190254,
0.4808245003223419,
-0.10991430282592773,
-1.3232471942901611,
-0.6534210443496704,
-0.3409801721572876,
0.04753977432847023,
0.21252165734767914,
-0.39989474415779114,
-0.16752441227436066,
0.3538486361503601,
0.25268644094467163,
-0.8651772141456604,
-0.14518320560455322,
-0.5176610946655273,
0.07239634543657303,
0.17377251386642456,
0.4874418079853058,
0.15980762243270874,
-0.2728644907474518,
-0.6428337097167969,
-0.27397143840789795,
-0.1623866707086563,
0.35537755489349365,
-0.3006119430065155,
0.2265043407678604,
-0.21382299065589905,
0.5761595964431763,
-0.19151408970355988,
1.0816622972488403,
-0.35300445556640625,
-0.12111218273639679,
0.3904498219490051,
-0.3414408266544342,
-0.2535189688205719,
-0.5924275517463684,
0.8065657615661621,
0.21838200092315674,
0.2994515299797058,
0.20168472826480865,
-0.30015382170677185,
-0.04520498588681221,
0.5108916163444519,
-0.5925868153572083,
-0.42400622367858887,
-0.2354317456483841,
-0.6527443528175354,
-0.619388222694397,
-0.118334099650383,
-0.7495903968811035,
-0.3963854908943176,
-0.34097251296043396,
0.38516873121261597,
-0.5918078422546387,
-0.23869013786315918,
0.11936349421739578,
-0.3034278452396393,
0.5692222118377686,
0.4782464802265167,
-0.5761206746101379,
-0.15435659885406494,
0.6202768683433533,
0.6089779734611511,
-0.06330657750368118,
-0.5475361943244934,
-0.4447079598903656,
-0.1294650137424469,
-0.0961456373333931,
0.7052441835403442,
-0.7609068751335144,
-0.298494815826416,
-0.0066583771258592606,
-0.1381402611732483,
0.043154072016477585,
-0.13140492141246796,
0.04457731917500496,
-0.5826605558395386,
0.25749048590660095,
-0.17972055077552795,
-0.06314077973365784,
-0.41916853189468384,
0.4678493142127991,
-0.6476119160652161,
1.0667325258255005,
0.20131513476371765,
-0.6778412461280823,
0.0011536860838532448,
-0.22785191237926483,
-0.5002507567405701,
0.23242118954658508,
-0.49049079418182373,
-0.5038840770721436,
0.2015550583600998,
0.15555578470230103,
0.35799694061279297,
-0.2727910578250885,
-0.13959358632564545,
-0.4209693372249603,
-0.20297010242938995,
0.2564300000667572,
-0.5452072620391846,
0.4691869616508484,
0.3352965712547302,
0.026007216423749924,
0.461930513381958,
-0.8762983679771423,
0.29561764001846313,
0.42947953939437866,
-0.4199788570404053,
-0.33738598227500916,
-0.2149379998445511,
0.3850216269493103,
0.24199186265468597,
0.19720973074436188,
-0.44918006658554077,
0.35443347692489624,
-0.08714324980974197,
0.4787783920764923,
0.8899289965629578,
-0.25094783306121826,
0.06723418086767197,
-0.30665114521980286,
0.6296914219856262,
-0.0034194558393210173,
0.4450828731060028,
-0.6150190830230713,
-0.6784908175468445,
-0.6715784072875977,
-0.4060673713684082,
0.12871350347995758,
0.598588764667511,
-1.220479965209961,
-0.37478363513946533,
-0.2919933795928955,
-0.3159549832344055,
-0.15500801801681519,
0.028307223692536354,
0.5683014392852783,
0.476689875125885,
0.21610940992832184,
-0.3963439464569092,
-0.7111355662345886,
-0.931406557559967,
-0.07086635380983353,
-0.04460005834698677,
0.19680798053741455,
0.4596517086029053,
0.3069798946380615,
-0.3727819323539734,
0.8135884404182434,
-0.3325248062610626,
-0.09244942665100098,
-0.4523741900920868,
0.3386342227458954,
0.23462586104869843,
0.2542557716369629,
0.4515605866909027,
-0.7583626508712769,
-0.31242215633392334,
0.10878533124923706,
-0.9589593410491943,
0.11900818347930908,
-0.060500774532556534,
0.020689822733402252,
-0.04220730811357498,
0.5635169148445129,
-0.34515029191970825,
0.4382338225841522,
0.701116681098938,
-0.2112109661102295,
0.624120831489563,
-0.05232786014676094,
0.05692640691995621,
-0.966478705406189,
-0.03495119884610176,
0.12632620334625244,
-0.5903698205947876,
-0.6694188117980957,
0.18126417696475983,
0.0024531318340450525,
-0.292603999376297,
-0.6231530904769897,
0.30505821108818054,
-0.38168326020240784,
-0.22698916494846344,
-0.15863408148288727,
-0.15253251791000366,
0.18534792959690094,
0.5442497730255127,
0.017507106065750122,
0.49257010221481323,
0.608290433883667,
-0.12244553864002228,
0.7008411884307861,
0.16818028688430786,
-0.529196560382843,
0.1361199915409088,
-0.7882117629051208,
0.04203275591135025,
-0.37877482175827026,
-0.047696229070425034,
-1.0022748708724976,
0.10381621867418289,
0.437310129404068,
-0.3247542679309845,
0.18416602909564972,
-0.23845498263835907,
-0.05385543406009674,
-0.34036028385162354,
-0.2678391933441162,
0.6059384942054749,
0.4555881917476654,
-0.49497032165527344,
0.9453245997428894,
0.105165995657444,
-0.10417841374874115,
-0.7364661693572998,
-0.7024951577186584,
0.060404591262340546,
0.15841124951839447,
-0.8124687671661377,
-0.10770916193723679,
0.09518507122993469,
-0.011843553744256496,
-0.06483657658100128,
0.062360990792512894,
0.06315620988607407,
-0.24722833931446075,
0.2875128984451294,
0.3787601590156555,
-0.5298337340354919,
0.03144233301281929,
-0.5894054174423218,
-0.24353493750095367,
-0.057893943041563034,
-0.5379250049591064,
0.4560214877128601,
-0.4531616270542145,
-0.3324701488018036,
-0.40113288164138794,
0.43442249298095703,
0.7642093896865845,
-0.6069706678390503,
0.4389500021934509,
0.7976110577583313,
-0.12635965645313263,
-0.17966467142105103,
-0.6962578296661377,
-0.07283582538366318,
-0.4806908369064331,
0.599588930606842,
-0.33095645904541016,
-0.9075934290885925,
0.1872420758008957,
-0.07234849780797958,
-0.09216886013746262,
-0.13662873208522797,
0.4589240849018097,
-0.3757605254650116,
0.7674329876899719,
0.6337663531303406,
0.1006258875131607,
1.0384491682052612,
-0.07508448511362076,
0.032065387815237045,
-0.5099353790283203,
-0.33387768268585205,
-0.01485629752278328,
-0.23812784254550934,
-0.29802244901657104,
-0.806022584438324,
0.4738869369029999,
-0.12418097257614136,
-0.19500552117824554,
0.07822655141353607,
-0.24119023978710175,
0.5020943880081177,
0.6601937413215637,
0.293761670589447,
0.12269721925258636,
0.34825244545936584,
-0.42071789503097534,
-0.12160038948059082,
-0.984751284122467,
0.11874380707740784,
0.8750123977661133,
0.46554359793663025,
1.2655638456344604,
-0.019699884578585625,
0.40230268239974976,
0.3887121081352234,
-0.03914860635995865,
-0.6566182374954224,
0.6459665894508362,
-0.29669591784477234,
0.10720205307006836,
-0.3663264513015747,
-0.503521203994751,
-0.9876478910446167,
0.479597270488739,
-0.40175965428352356,
-0.16419927775859833,
0.23952341079711914,
0.2566691040992737,
-0.18961715698242188,
0.14497585594654083,
-0.4996906518936157,
1.075026035308838,
-0.5549927949905396,
-0.5206682682037354,
-0.17991359531879425,
-0.5853055715560913,
0.4306785762310028,
0.3641841411590576,
0.06691691279411316,
0.23885075747966766,
0.3163558840751648,
0.23767505586147308,
-0.2504913806915283,
0.9005370736122131,
-0.14845657348632812,
0.1306518167257309,
0.0278548002243042,
0.04764402657747269,
0.7155331969261169,
0.02672485262155533,
0.3449937403202057,
0.300432413816452,
-0.22876618802547455,
-0.3878389000892639,
-0.5884640216827393,
0.6795578598976135,
-0.5569777488708496,
-0.4306437373161316,
-0.6727995276451111,
-0.5570408701896667,
0.07687176018953323,
0.46466875076293945,
-0.13932891190052032,
0.7641176581382751,
0.024284666404128075,
0.4817688763141632,
0.9291104674339294,
-0.35976094007492065,
0.31773141026496887,
0.4041421413421631,
-0.8581568002700806,
-0.5983220934867859,
0.9022111892700195,
-0.22497756779193878,
0.19270014762878418,
0.3238460123538971,
0.371268093585968,
-0.11406952142715454,
-0.7184118032455444,
-0.3777267336845398,
0.11295317858457565,
-0.7404825091362,
-0.08825813233852386,
-0.5058295130729675,
-0.15602782368659973,
-0.3917328417301178,
0.05723538622260094,
-0.47406822443008423,
-0.27115240693092346,
-0.04164528474211693,
0.17692847549915314,
0.49058255553245544,
1.0108778476715088,
0.019761689007282257,
-0.17331476509571075,
-0.8788148164749146,
0.5560671091079712,
0.7993783354759216,
0.43865716457366943,
0.11212415248155594,
-0.30733537673950195,
-0.3099004030227661,
-0.11350119858980179,
0.09306099265813828,
-0.5337071418762207,
0.26575711369514465,
-0.0037059516180306673,
0.6672176718711853,
0.3872220516204834,
-0.2780818045139313,
0.7888314723968506,
-0.6455135345458984,
0.7009715437889099,
0.47426488995552063,
-0.6149628162384033,
0.4113996624946594,
-0.5489100813865662,
0.7886964678764343,
0.1819828301668167,
0.10026616603136063,
-0.7627673745155334,
-0.16415917873382568,
0.10079427808523178,
-0.8753780126571655,
0.4483802616596222,
0.10942598432302475,
-0.0748777762055397,
0.052962739020586014,
0.24508273601531982,
-0.003085592994466424,
0.06554725766181946,
-0.9280723333358765,
-0.3774007260799408,
-0.6999499201774597,
-0.14231084287166595,
0.2378179281949997,
-0.49311938881874084,
0.04545619711279869,
-0.1820211261510849,
0.3931821882724762,
0.030990803614258766,
0.16060090065002441,
0.22439496219158173,
-0.3124142587184906,
0.1606941521167755,
0.1363135278224945,
0.9296412467956543,
0.6604121923446655,
0.0044731940142810345,
0.0738566517829895,
0.019408680498600006,
-0.5353350043296814,
-0.11152521520853043,
-0.012963331304490566,
-0.07514846324920654,
0.04452785104513168,
0.48791268467903137,
0.8637698888778687,
0.6032794117927551,
-0.6511995792388916,
0.4851229786872864,
-0.5318896174430847,
-0.07977225631475449,
-0.5396930575370789,
-0.23788680136203766,
0.10221467167139053,
0.7988590598106384,
0.2628667950630188,
0.07519824802875519,
-0.135677307844162,
-0.2744922339916229,
0.43598291277885437,
0.4942505657672882,
-0.3908557593822479,
0.04680453985929489,
0.5872933268547058,
0.24099326133728027,
-0.2809768319129944,
0.9493409395217896,
0.08995792269706726,
-0.43102550506591797,
0.21735447645187378,
0.5077307820320129,
0.6202874779701233,
-0.149997740983963,
0.07793167978525162,
0.26627835631370544,
0.2536599338054657,
0.07142326235771179,
0.5314287543296814,
-0.027935843914747238,
-0.6690234541893005,
-0.36650311946868896,
-0.5412924289703369,
-0.10285940766334534,
0.07501783221960068,
-0.7331597208976746,
0.2562287449836731,
-0.5194050669670105,
-0.09759202599525452,
-0.07428538054227829,
-0.8496863842010498,
-0.5846692323684692,
-0.08154060691595078,
0.6860103607177734,
0.8581435084342957,
-0.41281425952911377,
1.1768639087677002,
0.6318462491035461,
-0.3356127142906189,
-0.32801109552383423,
-0.48554107546806335,
0.1600310355424881,
-1.0145512819290161,
0.8301470875740051,
0.12586212158203125,
-0.4497557580471039,
0.05964266136288643,
-0.40269365906715393,
-0.878447413444519,
1.1431455612182617,
-0.01758776418864727,
-0.7663128972053528,
-0.0855601504445076,
0.1832922250032425,
0.33284568786621094,
-0.3045087456703186,
0.062080517411231995,
0.08813979476690292,
0.4218611419200897,
0.20026040077209473,
-0.5060173273086548,
-0.2251340001821518,
-0.48060664534568787,
0.6454191207885742,
0.03200848028063774,
-0.35888856649398804,
1.060518503189087,
-0.4069925546646118,
-0.11884624511003494,
0.14274059236049652,
0.8478677272796631,
0.2829063832759857,
0.17314620316028595,
0.5640699863433838,
0.7576336860656738,
0.3420897424221039,
-0.06748653948307037,
1.1506104469299316,
0.07276277989149094,
0.27317795157432556,
1.2703129053115845,
-0.19476594030857086,
0.8130984306335449,
0.614465594291687,
-0.11054781824350357,
0.6328935623168945,
0.14461173117160797,
-0.32288846373558044,
0.6767744421958923,
0.20276916027069092,
-0.31388911604881287,
-0.4727359116077423,
0.1274372935295105,
-0.5384621024131775,
0.333649218082428,
0.18777939677238464,
-0.5201839208602905,
-0.3143082857131958,
0.46240487694740295,
-0.5084052085876465,
-0.0005818750942125916,
-0.2572152316570282,
0.7555046677589417,
0.15690602362155914,
-0.19183966517448425,
0.5609045028686523,
-0.09432347118854523,
0.6514099836349487,
-1.0268441438674927,
-0.4229770302772522,
-0.15174737572669983,
0.20247003436088562,
0.056093480437994,
-0.7572575211524963,
0.0034254363272339106,
-0.2391515076160431,
-0.5208866000175476,
-0.4942931532859802,
0.7602512836456299,
-0.5940530300140381,
-0.678332507610321,
0.2979464530944824,
0.3583095967769623,
-0.22808046638965607,
0.2216748595237732,
-0.7880908250808716,
0.3909692168235779,
0.07702712714672089,
-0.3571830987930298,
0.3382645845413208,
0.23617978394031525,
0.1325061023235321,
0.9527577757835388,
0.8739655613899231,
-0.38476720452308655,
0.45254531502723694,
0.4372613728046417,
0.8643089532852173,
-0.9268699884414673,
-0.3267742991447449,
-0.7350590229034424,
0.748217761516571,
0.2080814093351364,
-0.12479763478040695,
0.8853462338447571,
0.47978663444519043,
0.9570488929748535,
-0.4107147753238678,
0.7880624532699585,
0.049997709691524506,
0.21105040609836578,
-0.5924385786056519,
0.6977673172950745,
-0.5973592400550842,
0.1192149892449379,
-0.029282383620738983,
-0.3896084427833557,
-0.31774935126304626,
0.7925293445587158,
0.020344002172350883,
-0.03449637442827225,
0.5113505721092224,
0.9495871067047119,
-0.036010995507240295,
0.09441929310560226,
0.5077434182167053,
0.2874647080898285,
0.1754760891199112,
0.5458213090896606,
1.1661261320114136,
-0.262678325176239,
0.678168773651123,
-0.4136078655719757,
-0.07259295880794525,
-0.07838123291730881,
-1.0089877843856812,
-0.854389488697052,
-0.5560054779052734,
-0.19116516411304474,
-0.31187164783477783,
0.27228888869285583,
0.7006456255912781,
0.6966948509216309,
-0.6397750377655029,
-0.30108675360679626,
-0.045295026153326035,
0.26542168855667114,
-0.3630741536617279,
-0.2260100543498993,
-0.2677282989025116,
-0.28961271047592163,
-0.3744928538799286,
0.596532940864563,
0.33341893553733826,
0.021674716845154762,
-0.3319326639175415,
0.07793410867452621,
-0.40946725010871887,
-0.2622915804386139,
0.9636117219924927,
0.48410651087760925,
-0.8300949931144714,
-0.30311068892478943,
-0.02743624337017536,
-0.1433553695678711,
0.0647539347410202,
1.1538811922073364,
-1.0791577100753784,
0.7885571718215942,
0.6740286350250244,
0.6457192897796631,
0.6282913684844971,
-0.1286412477493286,
0.7135298848152161,
-0.7019258737564087,
0.1425287127494812,
0.11457915604114532,
0.41043171286582947,
0.1624847948551178,
0.02385793626308441,
0.1219983771443367,
0.354423463344574,
-0.3443484604358673,
-0.6934103965759277,
0.43566250801086426,
-1.122577428817749,
-0.246951624751091,
0.9141561985015869,
-0.15375080704689026,
-0.26280298829078674,
-0.07323749363422394,
-0.08859287947416306,
-0.02724362537264824,
-0.2688315212726593,
0.4937008023262024,
0.3761874735355377,
-0.005458820145577192,
-0.9138437509536743,
-0.5985321998596191,
0.08242500573396683,
0.22043244540691376,
-0.39228707551956177,
-0.029970256611704826,
0.5355427265167236,
0.4365382492542267,
-0.13004319369792938,
0.26626014709472656,
-0.15994679927825928,
0.6081920266151428,
0.01926996558904648,
0.17769162356853485,
-0.7740315794944763,
-0.334503710269928,
-0.7429140210151672,
0.18796049058437347,
-0.1501191258430481,
-0.22424383461475372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13361v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13361v1 | Improving Zero-Shot Cross-Lingual Transfer via Progressive Code-Switching | 2024-06-19T09:06:24 | 2024-06-19T09:06:24 | Zhuoran Li, Chunming Hu, Junfan Chen, Zhijun Chen, Xiaohui Guo, Richong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Code-switching is a data augmentation scheme mixing words from multiple
languages into source lingual text. It has achieved considerable generalization
performance of cross-lingual transfer tasks by aligning cross-lingual
contextual word representations. However, uncontrolled and over-replaced
code-switching would augment dirty samples to model training. In other words,
the excessive code-switching text samples will negatively hurt the models'
cross-lingual transferability. To this end, we propose a Progressive
Code-Switching (PCS) method to gradually generate moderately difficult
code-switching examples for the model to discriminate from easy to hard. The
idea is to incorporate progressively the preceding learned multilingual
knowledge using easier code-switching data to guide model optimization on
succeeding harder code-switching data. Specifically, we first design a
difficulty measurer to measure the impact of replacing each word in a sentence
based on the word relevance score. Then a code-switcher generates the
code-switching data of increasing difficulty via a controllable temperature
variable. In addition, a training scheduler decides when to sample harder
code-switching data for model training. Experiments show our model achieves
state-of-the-art results on three different zero-shot cross-lingual transfer
tasks across ten languages. | [
-0.1511175036430359,
-0.6997488737106323,
0.27499300241470337,
0.3646986484527588,
-0.23431551456451416,
0.17263832688331604,
-0.3223833441734314,
-0.3557978570461273,
-0.22858202457427979,
0.400398313999176,
-0.3342227339744568,
-0.25740721821784973,
-0.36108124256134033,
0.18946291506290436,
-0.34495896100997925,
1.0491235256195068,
-0.4877583682537079,
0.05907909944653511,
0.11869469285011292,
0.13175524771213531,
-0.6291181445121765,
-0.27795273065567017,
-0.5109539031982422,
-0.6504790186882019,
0.28366580605506897,
0.6325616836547852,
0.7878186702728271,
0.4608563184738159,
0.35047051310539246,
0.19772663712501526,
0.12200085073709488,
-0.2824063003063202,
-0.6376471519470215,
-0.03762156516313553,
-0.36058589816093445,
-0.6841504573822021,
-0.4102027416229248,
-0.20416264235973358,
0.3873758614063263,
0.7432684898376465,
-0.129001185297966,
-0.11032169312238693,
-0.1072785034775734,
0.7021546363830566,
-0.5859728455543518,
0.15565405786037445,
-0.6696754693984985,
0.5097038745880127,
-0.35961008071899414,
-0.42302843928337097,
-0.5046687126159668,
0.0019111887086182833,
-0.1726239025592804,
-0.4884198009967804,
0.2518766522407532,
-0.4260813295841217,
0.819512128829956,
-0.22846584022045135,
-0.35088488459587097,
-0.11678432673215866,
-0.9533431529998779,
0.8044064044952393,
-0.5623986721038818,
0.6345602869987488,
0.3202970623970032,
0.17991842329502106,
0.40163087844848633,
-0.5590819716453552,
-0.5582770705223083,
-0.3614460825920105,
0.2963767945766449,
0.10936202108860016,
-0.278872013092041,
-0.12138723582029343,
0.07868580520153046,
0.12948283553123474,
-0.4941839277744293,
-0.13216154277324677,
-0.45048436522483826,
-0.1448732614517212,
0.49047040939331055,
0.14576153457164764,
0.5859279632568359,
0.1412724405527115,
-0.25801581144332886,
-0.20209166407585144,
-0.7113412618637085,
0.142364963889122,
0.27467080950737,
0.48726364970207214,
-0.09995719790458679,
0.36127763986587524,
-0.3912595212459564,
0.8683758974075317,
0.3504427671432495,
-0.15179234743118286,
0.6277511119842529,
-0.6440812945365906,
-0.19613775610923767,
0.0069411806762218475,
0.28477582335472107,
0.3398081660270691,
0.32936862111091614,
-0.45909547805786133,
-0.2104751020669937,
0.12378642708063126,
0.1962318867444992,
-0.8062106370925903,
-0.4000292420387268,
-0.041422322392463684,
-0.3193622827529907,
-0.3661777079105377,
-0.1444111466407776,
-0.7877715229988098,
0.07907265424728394,
-0.3652849793434143,
0.38458460569381714,
-0.661645233631134,
-0.44960156083106995,
0.489929735660553,
-0.14000201225280762,
0.334052711725235,
0.20655156672000885,
-0.7881191372871399,
0.15505409240722656,
0.1944851130247116,
0.895900309085846,
-0.400488942861557,
-0.4293321669101715,
-0.5797759294509888,
0.17406630516052246,
-0.5118470191955566,
0.5737211108207703,
-0.8982858657836914,
-0.5990764498710632,
0.03333963081240654,
0.207473486661911,
-0.2653410732746124,
-0.39800408482551575,
-0.04394067823886871,
-0.5540021061897278,
0.35896793007850647,
0.06455022841691971,
-0.23046667873859406,
0.04718982055783272,
0.36854588985443115,
-0.40056663751602173,
0.9521818161010742,
0.1952851414680481,
-0.48787230253219604,
0.17769408226013184,
-0.3819451332092285,
-0.6723471283912659,
0.10853664577007294,
-0.01632845029234886,
-0.45020177960395813,
0.006979809142649174,
0.09559069573879242,
0.22592350840568542,
0.2113998830318451,
0.0186361875385046,
-0.09004950523376465,
-0.5932053923606873,
0.07258192449808121,
-0.40724778175354004,
0.6563374996185303,
0.08983629196882248,
-0.5869029760360718,
-0.18532682955265045,
-0.6619261503219604,
0.17243483662605286,
-0.07390226423740387,
-0.5924495458602905,
-0.46544864773750305,
-0.3854618966579437,
0.19662201404571533,
0.42225155234336853,
0.21163567900657654,
-0.391510546207428,
0.5338143110275269,
-0.11791831254959106,
0.10798544436693192,
0.43735477328300476,
-0.20639145374298096,
0.7982778549194336,
-0.34568503499031067,
0.9755386710166931,
0.16397254168987274,
0.14466996490955353,
-0.2708858251571655,
-0.5120618939399719,
-0.6807429194450378,
0.18255475163459778,
0.45020782947540283,
0.9622441530227661,
-1.6146440505981445,
0.06198876351118088,
-0.18161806464195251,
-0.41646769642829895,
-0.46006470918655396,
0.4334055483341217,
0.6501016020774841,
0.40553951263427734,
0.44700849056243896,
-0.5637174248695374,
-0.1725548803806305,
-0.4264391362667084,
-0.1836191564798355,
-0.026073217391967773,
-0.05942518264055252,
0.10925451666116714,
0.303252637386322,
-0.14369609951972961,
0.7555988430976868,
-0.4429633319377899,
-0.12080519646406174,
-0.46541306376457214,
0.2638210952281952,
0.16820096969604492,
0.5969810485839844,
0.2726493179798126,
-0.8319228887557983,
-0.8633386492729187,
0.2924690246582031,
-0.38624510169029236,
-0.2690357565879822,
-0.5836958289146423,
-0.1384333074092865,
0.27863073348999023,
0.8034461736679077,
-0.2654849588871002,
0.20687299966812134,
0.6372343897819519,
-0.3903937041759491,
0.6964016556739807,
-0.2557566463947296,
0.254756361246109,
-0.6467081904411316,
0.13183166086673737,
-0.17133623361587524,
-0.16016072034835815,
-0.9975985884666443,
0.2168378084897995,
0.34309425950050354,
-0.22484125196933746,
-0.9655251502990723,
0.4381767213344574,
-0.6149433255195618,
0.29495367407798767,
-0.1684340089559555,
-0.22530151903629303,
0.11854538321495056,
0.6143248081207275,
0.17301268875598907,
0.7374330163002014,
0.6247525811195374,
-0.6048821806907654,
0.2689189016819,
-0.06412992626428604,
-0.01759178563952446,
0.6580229997634888,
-0.34350988268852234,
0.3579959273338318,
0.03399484604597092,
0.04565475136041641,
-0.9983335137367249,
0.3548531234264374,
0.43547818064689636,
-0.16995884478092194,
0.6475374102592468,
-0.2829029858112335,
-0.13988080620765686,
-0.10199660807847977,
-0.18958497047424316,
0.7087820768356323,
0.4471438229084015,
-0.28115540742874146,
0.36815860867500305,
-0.008173346519470215,
-0.3620620369911194,
-0.2933747172355652,
-1.014517068862915,
0.4348506033420563,
-0.0368545837700367,
-0.36797627806663513,
0.8148729205131531,
-0.15480202436447144,
0.11284253746271133,
0.061765704303979874,
-0.059841472655534744,
-0.22613771259784698,
-0.3859808146953583,
-0.2353656142950058,
0.38864946365356445,
-0.07389704883098602,
0.10802697390317917,
0.04389716312289238,
-0.12312378734350204,
-0.23905903100967407,
-0.2653017044067383,
0.6469386219978333,
-0.0700317844748497,
-0.22052869200706482,
-0.028365354984998703,
0.3687756359577179,
0.25599732995033264,
-0.14789219200611115,
0.243095263838768,
0.7588250041007996,
-0.0718022808432579,
-0.08461513370275497,
-0.11958596855401993,
0.00797032006084919,
-0.4562988877296448,
0.5933986902236938,
-0.6892626881599426,
-0.654439389705658,
0.3740176856517792,
-0.12759418785572052,
0.03483929857611656,
-0.014563202857971191,
0.45594432950019836,
0.27807924151420593,
0.9702855944633484,
0.9653724431991577,
-0.03499973565340042,
0.7374853491783142,
-0.18455208837985992,
0.1859530508518219,
-0.42645463347435,
-0.019792115315794945,
-0.27937620878219604,
-0.29149433970451355,
-0.5317339301109314,
-0.906737208366394,
0.13969166576862335,
0.13893863558769226,
-0.14754833281040192,
0.5153339505195618,
-0.4406856894493103,
0.4939475357532501,
0.08312255144119263,
0.2694574296474457,
0.36259931325912476,
0.1595093309879303,
-0.12483647465705872,
-0.15400026738643646,
-0.8207075595855713,
0.09108167141675949,
0.9545254111289978,
0.260054349899292,
0.9793716669082642,
0.07083375006914139,
0.5992942452430725,
0.17626893520355225,
0.13481499254703522,
-0.571864664554596,
0.618485689163208,
-0.5311177968978882,
-0.45874205231666565,
-0.30190983414649963,
-0.662222146987915,
-0.866614580154419,
0.12157762795686722,
0.04377265274524689,
-0.3593747913837433,
0.5142488479614258,
-0.04007135331630707,
-0.07718256860971451,
0.45082107186317444,
-0.6697320342063904,
0.6251490712165833,
-0.26094678044319153,
-0.5533495545387268,
-0.0564059242606163,
-0.5385714769363403,
0.5122513175010681,
-0.18007393181324005,
0.21728511154651642,
0.1601860523223877,
-0.19989372789859772,
0.33603769540786743,
-0.037082139402627945,
1.0062156915664673,
-0.24686679244041443,
-0.4169834554195404,
0.051790643483400345,
0.4644908010959625,
0.2919847071170807,
-0.2749801278114319,
-0.144076868891716,
0.3691825866699219,
-0.2838189899921417,
-0.49199432134628296,
-0.4673198163509369,
0.3584807217121124,
-0.5609803199768066,
-0.28202950954437256,
-0.2688411474227905,
-0.5441986322402954,
-0.28975027799606323,
0.16656477749347687,
0.3006385862827301,
0.23478461802005768,
-0.017696600407361984,
0.03372520953416824,
0.604137659072876,
-0.41882196068763733,
0.46490880846977234,
0.8069800734519958,
-0.39840665459632874,
-0.16193021833896637,
1.3564082384109497,
0.21869608759880066,
0.5906034111976624,
0.5166208148002625,
-0.0091084074229002,
-0.018907710909843445,
-0.40897777676582336,
-0.6974266767501831,
-0.1392199993133545,
-0.4036121666431427,
-0.24800944328308105,
-0.2346370369195938,
-0.19471585750579834,
-0.25917327404022217,
-0.4352037310600281,
-0.4391563832759857,
-0.2583938539028168,
-0.24375931918621063,
0.15259096026420593,
0.13887429237365723,
0.1133819967508316,
-0.16173911094665527,
0.1886443942785263,
-0.8248034119606018,
0.5403027534484863,
0.36368680000305176,
0.577972948551178,
-0.2879352867603302,
-0.705724835395813,
-0.3231509327888489,
-0.03497232124209404,
-0.29129818081855774,
-1.0542023181915283,
0.5374017953872681,
0.5121835470199585,
0.26462966203689575,
0.31074658036231995,
0.05257979407906532,
0.7557140588760376,
-0.5554307103157043,
0.6816205382347107,
0.5577104091644287,
-1.1514778137207031,
0.3033665716648102,
-0.23962818086147308,
0.8334944844245911,
0.666571855545044,
0.26324987411499023,
-0.8048768639564514,
-0.4336733818054199,
-0.22580809891223907,
-0.9924326539039612,
0.64198237657547,
0.1063714399933815,
0.5100109577178955,
0.0592777244746685,
0.33480387926101685,
0.21194522082805634,
0.23086212575435638,
-0.8857804536819458,
0.04140933230519295,
-0.4087609052658081,
0.21226747334003448,
0.07571477442979813,
0.16996175050735474,
0.1450425088405609,
-0.5077858567237854,
0.5169327855110168,
-0.3365209400653839,
0.27399611473083496,
0.13660375773906708,
-0.26267382502555847,
-0.3068813383579254,
0.5121240615844727,
0.4789239168167114,
0.6194449663162231,
-0.11012982577085495,
0.062100544571876526,
0.3169291317462921,
-0.5785765647888184,
0.33604881167411804,
0.028273317962884903,
-0.3512069880962372,
0.31692343950271606,
0.24757304787635803,
0.7986833453178406,
0.43876779079437256,
-0.5281662344932556,
0.3820697069168091,
0.12415469437837601,
-0.3113057315349579,
0.21224713325500488,
0.11076019704341888,
-0.011113340966403484,
-0.03849974647164345,
0.22081078588962555,
0.17832784354686737,
0.08514068275690079,
-0.8790282607078552,
0.4244406223297119,
0.12527209520339966,
-0.4431873559951782,
-0.3297240734100342,
0.36191290616989136,
0.33624136447906494,
-0.3346564769744873,
0.7534306645393372,
-0.35201895236968994,
-0.4981836676597595,
0.5936477780342102,
0.7871627807617188,
0.7509298920631409,
-0.5478748679161072,
0.5105286836624146,
0.06716331839561462,
0.17934860289096832,
-0.1561768651008606,
0.4468715786933899,
-0.17050261795520782,
-0.8061098456382751,
-0.5345878601074219,
-0.2894347906112671,
-0.45969119668006897,
-0.18932345509529114,
-0.7676261067390442,
0.4334031641483307,
-0.10586325079202652,
-0.06459268927574158,
-0.4248240888118744,
-0.1394992619752884,
-0.8729439973831177,
0.21906927227973938,
0.3127588629722595,
1.0243462324142456,
-0.8548159003257751,
1.205470085144043,
0.5877810120582581,
-0.3326990306377411,
-0.4537094533443451,
0.17049060761928558,
-0.3278101980686188,
-0.9399939775466919,
0.5704480409622192,
-0.028213856741786003,
-0.10468142479658127,
-0.14398206770420074,
-0.3519403040409088,
-0.32582366466522217,
0.9571624398231506,
0.39313989877700806,
-1.0720162391662598,
-0.14875322580337524,
0.31867751479148865,
0.6122231483459473,
-0.3421788811683655,
0.3404655456542969,
0.6570420861244202,
0.41624021530151367,
0.14618614315986633,
-0.972773015499115,
0.09436658769845963,
-0.5487644672393799,
0.08252663165330887,
0.1745908260345459,
-0.527582585811615,
1.0732632875442505,
-0.31806230545043945,
-0.19927968084812164,
-0.21884950995445251,
0.31997421383857727,
0.09373024106025696,
0.521990180015564,
0.7710345983505249,
0.3432380259037018,
0.32399463653564453,
0.23305849730968475,
0.7470315098762512,
-0.5801767110824585,
0.26642897725105286,
0.9752568602561951,
-0.4920905530452728,
1.052762746810913,
0.6018044352531433,
-0.2667497396469116,
0.6207855939865112,
0.33987006545066833,
-0.1265287697315216,
0.7139184474945068,
0.33634281158447266,
-0.20399688184261322,
-0.2453162968158722,
0.13898195326328278,
-0.6872281432151794,
0.46623334288597107,
0.1534116417169571,
-0.12636500597000122,
-0.475357323884964,
0.26320233941078186,
0.22670365869998932,
-0.14693531394004822,
-0.19210228323936462,
0.597917914390564,
-0.07606293261051178,
-0.5931796431541443,
0.8180302381515503,
0.2310892939567566,
1.0087623596191406,
-0.7873362302780151,
-0.19625960290431976,
-0.49675798416137695,
0.031203221529722214,
-0.14839793741703033,
-0.8798609375953674,
0.4212090075016022,
0.07409906387329102,
-0.043605487793684006,
-0.6229879260063171,
0.7162047624588013,
-0.8662887811660767,
-0.7056056261062622,
0.48187053203582764,
0.6067651510238647,
0.20555049180984497,
-0.041905682533979416,
-0.893073320388794,
0.1041962280869484,
0.22295799851417542,
-0.11000283062458038,
0.638881504535675,
0.4521333575248718,
0.013228684663772583,
0.28512319922447205,
0.6503235101699829,
0.2759930491447449,
0.022709716111421585,
0.24061380326747894,
0.9431665539741516,
-0.756581723690033,
-0.6919607520103455,
-0.6736558079719543,
0.3972312808036804,
0.17205016314983368,
-0.3686182498931885,
0.47151994705200195,
0.38548851013183594,
0.9519715309143066,
-0.1663612574338913,
0.7897672653198242,
-0.10231579095125198,
-0.017786948010325432,
-0.5680159330368042,
0.6438098549842834,
-0.6013646125793457,
0.347793847322464,
-0.4324262738227844,
-0.7009070515632629,
-0.28674378991127014,
0.4584328532218933,
-0.2626226842403412,
0.027828475460410118,
0.5116105675697327,
0.9106619954109192,
-0.26254191994667053,
-0.39465856552124023,
0.5511273145675659,
0.12232966721057892,
0.3506162762641907,
1.0679982900619507,
0.41623157262802124,
-0.49462229013442993,
1.019244909286499,
-0.44792690873146057,
-0.3318774402141571,
-0.17409415543079376,
-0.9887873530387878,
-0.5826274156570435,
-0.4127291142940521,
-0.7000793814659119,
-0.4230245351791382,
0.5739214420318604,
0.2963235080242157,
0.7058839201927185,
-0.7461150288581848,
-0.496866375207901,
-0.3314858078956604,
-0.0012103177141398191,
-0.5979779362678528,
-0.3525991439819336,
0.086762435734272,
-0.5614308714866638,
-0.6829570531845093,
0.36315298080444336,
0.28139275312423706,
-0.17338807880878448,
-0.3299422860145569,
-0.1253412514925003,
-0.1090644970536232,
0.1162799596786499,
0.6325453519821167,
0.5081730484962463,
-0.17561687529087067,
-0.1971735805273056,
0.2260918766260147,
-0.2024051398038864,
0.1283321976661682,
0.943798840045929,
-0.78594571352005,
0.7197400331497192,
0.6297568082809448,
0.6288799047470093,
0.5353034138679504,
-0.30716538429260254,
0.7421216368675232,
-0.8311575055122375,
0.02173973247408867,
0.0028866168577224016,
0.04455878213047981,
0.3678666949272156,
-0.3484293520450592,
0.341814786195755,
0.4025095999240875,
-0.2527630925178528,
-0.8319274187088013,
0.16015523672103882,
-0.780851423740387,
-0.6069068312644958,
1.3641200065612793,
-0.1631074696779251,
0.013071905821561813,
-0.43675774335861206,
-0.17037127912044525,
0.13299188017845154,
-0.27269867062568665,
0.9842851161956787,
0.6361690163612366,
-0.27023178339004517,
-0.3760643005371094,
-0.483529269695282,
0.3644072115421295,
0.620195209980011,
-0.6702892780303955,
-0.05648122355341911,
0.13549482822418213,
0.4780963659286499,
0.2358127385377884,
0.886561930179596,
-0.23927246034145355,
0.5139935612678528,
0.13363081216812134,
0.2952786684036255,
-0.041840508580207825,
-0.39946410059928894,
-0.5981495380401611,
0.2641232907772064,
-0.42128387093544006,
-0.34646672010421753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13357v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13357v1 | Transferable speech-to-text large language model alignment module | 2024-06-19T09:04:43 | 2024-06-19T09:04:43 | Boyong Wu, Chao Yan, Haoran Pu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | By leveraging the power of Large Language Models(LLMs) and speech foundation
models, state of the art speech-text bimodal works can achieve challenging
tasks like spoken translation(ST) and question answering(SQA) altogether with
much simpler architectures. In this paper, we utilize the capability of Whisper
encoder and pre-trained Yi-6B. Empirical results reveal that modal alignment
can be achieved with one layer module and hundred hours of speech-text
multitask corpus. We further swap the Yi-6B with human preferences aligned
version of Yi-6B-Chat during inference, and discover that the alignment
capability is applicable as well. In addition, the alignment subspace revealed
by singular value decomposition(SVD) also implies linear alignment subspace is
sparse, which leaves the possibility to concatenate other features like
voice-print or video to expand modality. | [
0.00990169495344162,
-0.6637555956840515,
0.42385974526405334,
0.12700407207012177,
-0.17294737696647644,
0.025422880426049232,
-0.24975870549678802,
-0.5065897107124329,
0.06968685984611511,
0.5783175230026245,
-0.7571699023246765,
-0.3216172754764557,
-0.3936169743537903,
-0.09692901372909546,
-0.3952494263648987,
0.8483840823173523,
0.3279324769973755,
-0.031650666147470474,
-0.18101458251476288,
-0.14892064034938812,
-0.7534031271934509,
-0.372046560049057,
-0.23463089764118195,
-0.057565513998270035,
0.6019671559333801,
0.24197711050510406,
0.782939076423645,
0.5968945622444153,
0.3666701018810272,
0.3058858811855316,
0.02971154823899269,
0.23300400376319885,
-0.3620438873767853,
-0.019905410706996918,
-0.23385338485240936,
-0.4381672739982605,
-0.7519996166229248,
-0.2954140603542328,
0.8193596601486206,
0.7079039812088013,
-0.026287883520126343,
0.08346500992774963,
-0.023820236325263977,
0.35901758074760437,
-0.3057391047477722,
0.14652472734451294,
-0.6871024966239929,
-0.3783777952194214,
-0.2837095558643341,
0.0757993534207344,
-0.5623914003372192,
-0.3134002983570099,
0.46489217877388,
-0.5542246699333191,
-0.3031409978866577,
0.06401437520980835,
0.8316330909729004,
0.41009876132011414,
-0.7469883561134338,
-0.1297461986541748,
-0.8106684684753418,
0.8618069887161255,
-0.9622843861579895,
0.6241446137428284,
0.19537048041820526,
0.3446352481842041,
0.04682542011141777,
-0.6453099846839905,
-0.9009379744529724,
0.11738424748182297,
0.02307049185037613,
0.10930439084768295,
-0.006660310551524162,
0.4170123040676117,
0.1380772441625595,
0.17870713770389557,
-0.6489234566688538,
0.2154684215784073,
-0.3366532623767853,
-0.33250829577445984,
0.5437108278274536,
0.125166118144989,
0.5148231983184814,
-0.44823789596557617,
-0.4233960211277008,
-0.04590244218707085,
-0.3628990352153778,
0.09291741997003555,
0.33051836490631104,
0.4758204221725464,
-0.3273910582065582,
0.6049656271934509,
0.10599098354578018,
0.9488441348075867,
0.1066335067152977,
-0.5903398394584656,
0.5385231375694275,
-0.5362328290939331,
-0.25729840993881226,
0.19411778450012207,
0.759776771068573,
0.18760369718074799,
-0.10028883069753647,
-0.18236082792282104,
-0.01200538594275713,
-0.01567278429865837,
0.43487119674682617,
-0.521796703338623,
0.3014480173587799,
0.1121002733707428,
-0.4958166778087616,
0.0009658196941018105,
-0.09048023819923401,
-0.6091155409812927,
-0.07883745431900024,
-0.46702879667282104,
0.8571378588676453,
-0.37242358922958374,
-0.3045687675476074,
0.3518015146255493,
0.07758630812168121,
0.5928470492362976,
0.43348729610443115,
-0.9996225237846375,
0.030527034774422646,
0.6840192079544067,
0.7688322067260742,
-0.4274376332759857,
-0.24563369154930115,
-0.38750848174095154,
0.5280367732048035,
-0.2485702633857727,
0.5119033455848694,
-0.4993957281112671,
-0.07074622064828873,
0.1854449063539505,
0.020085075870156288,
-0.3387891948223114,
-0.26656782627105713,
0.6318694353103638,
-0.49054035544395447,
0.47071024775505066,
-0.038266465067863464,
-0.6143622994422913,
-0.38338732719421387,
0.04610824212431908,
-0.5485255718231201,
0.8945816159248352,
0.17169298231601715,
-0.5663025379180908,
-0.09718697518110275,
-0.36714643239974976,
-0.369411438703537,
-0.0994391143321991,
-0.12394221127033234,
-0.25367414951324463,
0.027170585468411446,
0.14373548328876495,
0.3941214680671692,
-0.21993935108184814,
0.25700056552886963,
-0.21592146158218384,
-0.17639778554439545,
0.47628822922706604,
-0.586606502532959,
0.6765055656433105,
0.2358408123254776,
-0.2673201560974121,
0.38421720266342163,
-0.6869160532951355,
0.09457827359437943,
-0.4240742027759552,
-0.2578963339328766,
-0.17198510468006134,
-0.06410699337720871,
0.2770591378211975,
0.15156950056552887,
0.5425671935081482,
-0.460564523935318,
0.24692587554454803,
-0.44002968072891235,
0.5642834305763245,
0.6156305074691772,
-0.29906153678894043,
0.6353933215141296,
-0.43064120411872864,
0.39787453413009644,
-0.09364259243011475,
0.1919342577457428,
-0.10274684429168701,
-0.4234790802001953,
-0.6750453114509583,
-0.5329070091247559,
0.35638734698295593,
0.6133648157119751,
-0.7079178094863892,
0.6181973814964294,
-0.5942703485488892,
-0.46689414978027344,
-0.9341593384742737,
-0.056414686143398285,
0.42127758264541626,
0.6180883646011353,
0.2715240716934204,
-0.0389411486685276,
-0.31468847393989563,
-1.200258493423462,
0.11194152384996414,
-0.29276829957962036,
0.04267518222332001,
0.16208700835704803,
0.0006452719680964947,
-0.19137857854366302,
0.779380202293396,
-0.30010223388671875,
-0.23958075046539307,
-0.3412114381790161,
-0.02255879156291485,
0.27813857793807983,
0.5038083791732788,
0.49121877551078796,
-0.8724982738494873,
-0.3774998188018799,
0.24701200425624847,
-0.40225130319595337,
-0.29577773809432983,
-0.18610809743404388,
-0.13918185234069824,
0.1688675731420517,
0.39405208826065063,
-0.8013129830360413,
0.3174404203891754,
0.7858293652534485,
-0.2384120523929596,
0.34483227133750916,
0.05252399668097496,
0.32575350999832153,
-1.618980884552002,
0.12584646046161652,
-0.3976401090621948,
-0.40213724970817566,
-0.9204017519950867,
-0.23263013362884521,
0.2094210386276245,
-0.05226300284266472,
-0.3995131254196167,
0.3617189824581146,
-0.43764376640319824,
-0.2920372486114502,
-0.38596582412719727,
0.2606331706047058,
0.029670286923646927,
0.4757317900657654,
0.03974274545907974,
0.7843949198722839,
0.42633745074272156,
-0.28503933548927307,
0.3467910587787628,
0.56523197889328,
-0.5237632989883423,
0.4905027747154236,
-0.5387739539146423,
0.3832789957523346,
-0.009147667326033115,
0.09304088354110718,
-1.1885640621185303,
-0.24795444309711456,
0.058222535997629166,
-0.4612276256084442,
0.36399292945861816,
-0.2620260715484619,
-0.26678767800331116,
0.19104044139385223,
-0.1311749666929245,
0.5555476546287537,
0.555005669593811,
-0.42050015926361084,
0.9188188910484314,
0.3257858455181122,
-0.5858832597732544,
-0.6615602970123291,
-0.5398674607276917,
0.13096214830875397,
-0.19017350673675537,
-0.9034831523895264,
0.6674841046333313,
-0.17757093906402588,
0.04326906427741051,
-0.12183195352554321,
-0.00624883035197854,
-0.07033795863389969,
-0.37514549493789673,
0.2945004999637604,
0.6519970893859863,
-0.44221231341362,
0.1244712844491005,
0.16041725873947144,
0.10869166254997253,
-0.3068391978740692,
-0.06548290699720383,
0.5314780473709106,
0.08065780997276306,
-0.48912349343299866,
-0.6823769211769104,
0.5877929329872131,
0.8705571293830872,
-0.22216306626796722,
0.4610254466533661,
0.445718377828598,
-0.4828798472881317,
-0.03523023799061775,
-0.871019721031189,
0.12543877959251404,
-0.4484800100326538,
0.6166995167732239,
-0.23826554417610168,
-1.0508460998535156,
0.312505841255188,
0.12980078160762787,
0.22249291837215424,
0.1570899784564972,
0.5277376174926758,
-0.02386334165930748,
1.0548473596572876,
0.7162895202636719,
-0.36711061000823975,
0.5574620962142944,
0.29579266905784607,
0.3446807563304901,
-0.8055458068847656,
-0.3408501148223877,
-0.6641667485237122,
-0.4206135869026184,
-0.17970462143421173,
-0.5501676797866821,
0.28658542037010193,
-0.013048994354903698,
-0.048915229737758636,
0.41776731610298157,
-0.3671377897262573,
0.023842446506023407,
0.2695654332637787,
0.019456585869193077,
0.2740294635295868,
-0.1553795486688614,
0.2996979355812073,
-0.2804572582244873,
-0.4334251284599304,
-0.4143266975879669,
0.6923205256462097,
0.33545833826065063,
0.7987557053565979,
0.4099954068660736,
0.30798476934432983,
-0.021912982687354088,
0.028073269873857498,
-0.9474858045578003,
0.48225051164627075,
-0.22327758371829987,
-0.5806735157966614,
-0.3439522981643677,
-0.17380619049072266,
-0.5201747417449951,
0.15350186824798584,
-0.3066175580024719,
-0.8956604599952698,
0.2786298394203186,
-0.10488191246986389,
-0.4093325734138489,
0.022429417818784714,
-0.9636451005935669,
0.867220401763916,
-0.3737914562225342,
-0.1649244874715805,
-0.1962071657180786,
-0.7060670852661133,
0.1834004819393158,
-0.08988824486732483,
0.27134209871292114,
-0.010632801800966263,
-0.23115570843219757,
0.8066961169242859,
-0.2745756506919861,
1.022143006324768,
0.05018232390284538,
-0.2867157459259033,
0.10291960835456848,
-0.19592531025409698,
0.33394354581832886,
-0.33123064041137695,
0.0010021255584433675,
-0.05925412476062775,
0.1382492184638977,
-0.1842285841703415,
-0.828948974609375,
0.5770910382270813,
-0.9193308353424072,
-0.7149657607078552,
-0.25076043605804443,
-0.9055105447769165,
-0.46040627360343933,
0.212405264377594,
-0.016163069754838943,
0.6922169327735901,
-0.04352802038192749,
0.38784509897232056,
0.7461945414543152,
-0.17742137610912323,
0.45842230319976807,
0.3880815804004669,
-0.2870282232761383,
-0.5962576866149902,
0.8324488401412964,
0.12794439494609833,
0.5900520086288452,
0.6754575371742249,
0.15732568502426147,
-0.5685436129570007,
-0.7166225910186768,
-0.5594189167022705,
0.2890072762966156,
-0.39748817682266235,
-0.20023119449615479,
-0.734947919845581,
-0.5194862484931946,
-0.6909467577934265,
-0.4050338566303253,
-0.4194517731666565,
-0.43161165714263916,
-0.327750027179718,
-0.13051828742027283,
0.22002917528152466,
0.5694531798362732,
0.13730359077453613,
0.3707282543182373,
-1.0389611721038818,
0.33321747183799744,
0.5708828568458557,
-0.11093775182962418,
-0.21616409718990326,
-0.9723802804946899,
-0.11885472387075424,
0.1350882649421692,
-0.01918359100818634,
-0.8866320252418518,
0.33755072951316833,
0.3130749762058258,
0.4721338748931885,
0.5374744534492493,
0.006685010157525539,
1.00591242313385,
-0.3773915767669678,
0.8960352540016174,
0.4558962285518646,
-1.0775760412216187,
0.2430434674024582,
-0.5437784194946289,
0.32087379693984985,
0.41626089811325073,
0.1768587976694107,
-0.6515511274337769,
-0.015694856643676758,
-0.20668774843215942,
-0.5549241900444031,
0.6045631766319275,
0.01665704883635044,
0.2795334458351135,
0.38308486342430115,
0.4566709101200104,
0.2944546639919281,
0.1431712508201599,
-0.6106284260749817,
-0.02032225765287876,
-0.33091866970062256,
-0.7257479429244995,
-0.026493454352021217,
-0.20668092370033264,
-0.040235668420791626,
-0.22124314308166504,
0.5347477197647095,
-0.3323434293270111,
0.22301794588565826,
0.09933602809906006,
-0.18266642093658447,
0.20486772060394287,
0.4946480989456177,
0.6557823419570923,
0.5969839692115784,
-0.0465986393392086,
0.28256210684776306,
0.014651886187493801,
-0.4022226631641388,
0.1323126256465912,
0.20574086904525757,
-0.12749198079109192,
-0.19276992976665497,
0.46901220083236694,
0.8746029734611511,
0.4410497844219208,
-0.7414611577987671,
0.6780692934989929,
0.167732834815979,
-0.18817339837551117,
-0.1075495034456253,
0.00353027880191803,
0.5394534468650818,
0.46176454424858093,
0.3135066032409668,
-0.16411380469799042,
0.04511486738920212,
-0.7296302914619446,
-0.01330623310059309,
0.6003694534301758,
-0.5914415121078491,
-0.567552924156189,
0.5939192771911621,
0.23472416400909424,
-0.46913617849349976,
0.4330816864967346,
0.28159502148628235,
-0.5196934342384338,
0.2055489867925644,
0.8203735947608948,
0.7059842348098755,
-0.29436376690864563,
0.1513245850801468,
0.027194757014513016,
0.22919821739196777,
0.001866611884906888,
0.268553763628006,
0.033804427832365036,
-0.908768892288208,
-0.7012381553649902,
-0.5487820506095886,
-0.38638702034950256,
0.10320453345775604,
-0.7542186379432678,
0.22749316692352295,
-0.14497676491737366,
-0.0877443328499794,
0.2181355208158493,
-0.22183223068714142,
-0.4124102294445038,
-0.03532956540584564,
0.14751261472702026,
0.6141211986541748,
-0.5846853256225586,
1.089928388595581,
0.6901315450668335,
-0.1825055032968521,
-0.9806945323944092,
-0.19958876073360443,
0.1302148401737213,
-0.8142863512039185,
0.5143002271652222,
0.08781488239765167,
-0.2078845500946045,
0.06623942404985428,
-0.4567844271659851,
-0.852411150932312,
1.1650028228759766,
0.6243681311607361,
-0.7040590047836304,
-0.317876935005188,
0.2549609839916229,
0.37323886156082153,
-0.4235984981060028,
0.06788857281208038,
0.31153184175491333,
0.4167097806930542,
0.15295201539993286,
-1.3912285566329956,
-0.0942087173461914,
-0.15620023012161255,
-0.0017750627594068646,
0.11536941677331924,
-0.8096939325332642,
0.5598993301391602,
0.012590626254677773,
-0.21553929150104523,
0.23296231031417847,
0.9095163941383362,
-0.2279665172100067,
0.0622141994535923,
0.6597169637680054,
0.4820865988731384,
0.5827633738517761,
0.08772031962871552,
0.4661979675292969,
0.00758016062900424,
-0.07969684153795242,
1.0057263374328613,
-0.46188992261886597,
1.0372322797775269,
0.5801933407783508,
-0.025597447529435158,
0.4179546535015106,
0.2225438952445984,
0.3302883207798004,
0.5677592754364014,
-0.31441056728363037,
-0.48309817910194397,
-0.5545821189880371,
-0.27823466062545776,
-0.26531845331192017,
0.6680299639701843,
0.37451601028442383,
0.033673107624053955,
0.05188671872019768,
0.0321129746735096,
-0.18757356703281403,
0.10013828426599503,
-0.20858065783977509,
0.9865280389785767,
0.07724756747484207,
-0.672789454460144,
0.3223138153553009,
-0.18295328319072723,
0.970558226108551,
-0.998600959777832,
-0.009631584398448467,
0.13707639276981354,
0.05187198519706726,
-0.24203413724899292,
-0.5746169686317444,
0.2858096659183502,
-0.33871209621429443,
-0.373507022857666,
-0.27741414308547974,
0.9432527422904968,
-0.7372133731842041,
-0.16485583782196045,
0.15064671635627747,
0.5710519552230835,
-0.06711041182279587,
0.16547074913978577,
-0.40443047881126404,
0.19650982320308685,
0.23670999705791473,
-0.06302474439144135,
0.5914025902748108,
0.32279086112976074,
0.0888446569442749,
0.611183762550354,
0.6106094121932983,
-0.025824716314673424,
0.3275197148323059,
0.0741698145866394,
0.814013659954071,
-0.6716318726539612,
-0.42550498247146606,
-0.5468125343322754,
0.5027689337730408,
-0.04220769181847572,
-0.33464428782463074,
0.6112370491027832,
0.480825275182724,
0.5494352579116821,
-0.08605700731277466,
0.9149929881095886,
-0.07570068538188934,
0.5761171579360962,
-0.7232169508934021,
0.6318721771240234,
-0.31328514218330383,
-0.01636834628880024,
-0.36101722717285156,
-0.9201350212097168,
-0.024544063955545425,
0.6032763123512268,
-0.020030684769153595,
-0.32609862089157104,
0.6595224142074585,
0.9931935667991638,
0.06644347310066223,
0.042691800743341446,
0.5481798052787781,
0.09035583585500717,
0.31461596488952637,
0.5353911519050598,
0.8266497850418091,
-0.39644378423690796,
0.7034657001495361,
-0.07735612243413925,
-0.3308660686016083,
-0.080467090010643,
-0.8322458863258362,
-0.8600058555603027,
-0.9905833005905151,
-0.35447925329208374,
-0.184703528881073,
-0.012916119769215584,
0.9220016598701477,
0.7265036702156067,
-0.38298171758651733,
-0.2553139626979828,
0.5930629372596741,
0.003960583824664354,
-0.21939851343631744,
-0.22111958265304565,
0.5071962475776672,
-0.11643224209547043,
-0.8646460771560669,
0.6316282749176025,
0.5071402788162231,
0.09986011683940887,
-0.20546886324882507,
0.005047683138400316,
-0.3340664803981781,
0.1278771609067917,
0.6291581988334656,
0.08280401676893234,
-0.6998174786567688,
-0.7906225323677063,
0.26675209403038025,
-0.17624716460704803,
0.0006154892616905272,
0.7836853861808777,
-0.4559859335422516,
0.3922610878944397,
0.6587750315666199,
1.0197389125823975,
0.3581371605396271,
0.05118411034345627,
0.7388523817062378,
-0.5549770593643188,
0.06472364068031311,
0.16717280447483063,
0.29173582792282104,
0.36470934748649597,
-0.15640783309936523,
-0.01082337275147438,
0.08179555833339691,
-0.6064411401748657,
-0.7332979440689087,
0.27228012681007385,
-1.8105701208114624,
0.010420974344015121,
1.2059956789016724,
0.040979351848363876,
-0.29115909337997437,
-0.38343796133995056,
-0.5366964340209961,
0.30926579236984253,
-0.29616793990135193,
0.5436493754386902,
0.6745350360870361,
0.027911338955163956,
-0.32487526535987854,
-0.46894463896751404,
0.39505308866500854,
0.4127165377140045,
-0.8697973489761353,
0.10894656926393509,
0.5574489831924438,
0.37455862760543823,
0.2148749679327011,
0.6713388562202454,
-0.31907492876052856,
0.13446751236915588,
-0.22635051608085632,
0.1844925433397293,
-0.05851361155509949,
0.05790981650352478,
-0.30219459533691406,
0.09606530517339706,
0.08314497768878937,
-0.247491255402565
] |
Subsets and Splits