id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14774v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14774v1 | Evaluating Numerical Reasoning in Text-to-Image Models | 2024-06-20T22:56:31 | 2024-06-20T22:56:31 | Ivana Kajić, Olivia Wiles, Isabela Albuquerque, Matthias Bauer, Su Wang, Jordi Pont-Tuset, Aida Nematzadeh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Text-to-image generative models are capable of producing high-quality images
that often faithfully depict concepts described using natural language. In this
work, we comprehensively evaluate a range of text-to-image models on numerical
reasoning tasks of varying difficulty, and show that even the most advanced
models have only rudimentary numerical skills. Specifically, their ability to
correctly generate an exact number of objects in an image is limited to small
numbers, it is highly dependent on the context the number term appears in, and
it deteriorates quickly with each successive number. We also demonstrate that
models have poor understanding of linguistic quantifiers (such as "a few" or
"as many as"), the concept of zero, and struggle with more advanced concepts
such as partial quantities and fractional representations. We bundle prompts,
generated images and human annotations into GeckoNum, a novel benchmark for
evaluation of numerical reasoning. | [
-0.6450152397155762,
-0.7507882714271545,
0.8648605346679688,
0.4987637400627136,
-0.5082789659500122,
-0.2995871305465698,
-0.1535763442516327,
-0.36535173654556274,
-0.4006507396697998,
0.45574960112571716,
-0.2786027789115906,
-0.4806337356567383,
-0.5920609831809998,
0.4440528452396393,
-0.44738009572029114,
0.810889720916748,
0.2331991046667099,
0.008876838721334934,
-0.8570514917373657,
-0.14550986886024475,
-0.5623862147331238,
-0.44346585869789124,
-0.5687731504440308,
-0.4289209246635437,
0.14436917006969452,
0.17864860594272614,
1.0055500268936157,
0.4155830144882202,
0.7987219095230103,
0.3341728448867798,
-0.2606228291988373,
0.09988342970609665,
-0.3470115661621094,
-0.11902446299791336,
-0.17692241072654724,
-0.2271377444267273,
-0.00419479887932539,
-0.1808396726846695,
0.46393272280693054,
0.8255197405815125,
0.03682727366685867,
0.11822276562452316,
-0.2719101309776306,
0.6922096610069275,
-0.5319927334785461,
0.15909019112586975,
-0.4102305769920349,
0.15232709050178528,
0.1471143513917923,
0.08429517596960068,
-0.797582745552063,
-0.43304258584976196,
0.17001807689666748,
-0.9520448446273804,
0.18542976677417755,
-0.11986632645130157,
0.9164121747016907,
0.4547865390777588,
-0.46798455715179443,
-0.5470362901687622,
-0.7361421585083008,
0.6143045425415039,
-0.5895856022834778,
0.0847482681274414,
0.31658264994621277,
0.2971002757549286,
0.06228053197264671,
-0.734298050403595,
-0.311745285987854,
-0.3632836639881134,
-0.06399501860141754,
0.1159735918045044,
-0.3367968201637268,
-0.11182738840579987,
0.8032999038696289,
0.1849077194929123,
-0.5098438262939453,
-0.1597590446472168,
-0.4555239677429199,
0.11506707966327667,
0.6552411913871765,
0.2702764868736267,
0.5417295694351196,
-0.40385130047798157,
-0.29180896282196045,
-0.20203500986099243,
-0.3354188799858093,
-0.12294229120016098,
0.19512216746807098,
-0.08806049823760986,
-0.06629683077335358,
0.590901792049408,
-0.03332972154021263,
1.023834228515625,
-0.1281362920999527,
0.09524549543857574,
-0.08466152846813202,
-0.12621626257896423,
-0.35898375511169434,
-0.3922702968120575,
0.9734663963317871,
0.3302311301231384,
0.5422239303588867,
-0.16444405913352966,
-0.21035125851631165,
0.40655264258384705,
0.33725544810295105,
-1.0304926633834839,
-0.3195105493068695,
-0.04553470015525818,
-0.31952399015426636,
-0.5730169415473938,
0.06045311316847801,
-0.5785920023918152,
-0.32787269353866577,
-0.195302352309227,
0.5389283895492554,
-0.643667995929718,
0.07779071480035782,
0.32910406589508057,
-0.41501450538635254,
0.07597808539867401,
0.6617628931999207,
-0.7802087664604187,
0.34340164065361023,
0.6767867207527161,
0.736791729927063,
0.20630919933319092,
-0.018182726576924324,
-0.09709672629833221,
-0.257284551858902,
-0.8636219501495361,
1.2196320295333862,
-0.763523519039154,
-0.7233513593673706,
-0.4844990074634552,
-0.2889230251312256,
0.11691857129335403,
-0.553768515586853,
0.6471436619758606,
-0.5390967726707458,
0.042217254638671875,
-0.2656489312648773,
-0.36745724081993103,
-0.4063873291015625,
0.04884594306349754,
-0.7862299680709839,
0.7591622471809387,
-0.04121752828359604,
-0.5551274418830872,
0.16733555495738983,
-0.5094909071922302,
-0.5038735270500183,
0.20862078666687012,
-0.36012110114097595,
-0.40869635343551636,
0.5322605967521667,
0.14539246261119843,
0.26339372992515564,
-0.909710705280304,
0.3988983631134033,
-0.3856309950351715,
-0.45561087131500244,
0.44670388102531433,
-0.6344239115715027,
0.6293971538543701,
0.20593734085559845,
-0.047807369381189346,
-0.3968134820461273,
-0.7764912247657776,
0.18079473078250885,
0.3684912621974945,
-0.10061174631118774,
-0.45637762546539307,
-0.051296528428792953,
-0.22188837826251984,
0.26618465781211853,
-0.012787344865500927,
-0.22961346805095673,
0.2717362940311432,
-0.22253906726837158,
0.5343493223190308,
0.4011501967906952,
0.14680495858192444,
0.4831836521625519,
-0.22427044808864594,
0.4513509273529053,
-0.03845521807670593,
-0.11971110850572586,
-0.5005073547363281,
-0.8412527441978455,
-0.7655469179153442,
-0.0195756945759058,
0.44088536500930786,
0.5360001921653748,
-1.028207778930664,
-0.09414801001548767,
-0.4817759096622467,
-0.6363415122032166,
-0.12113497406244278,
-0.09725973755121231,
0.6075793504714966,
0.3975023329257965,
0.15817809104919434,
-0.5382378697395325,
0.055961593985557556,
-0.8124620914459229,
-0.10889141261577606,
0.062210239470005035,
-0.2523748278617859,
0.5308067202568054,
0.8833999633789062,
0.07277940213680267,
0.6367354989051819,
-0.5431957840919495,
0.1029396802186966,
0.43614551424980164,
0.8063890933990479,
0.023166844621300697,
0.33943983912467957,
0.6055383086204529,
-0.8731708526611328,
-0.38397470116615295,
0.2172536551952362,
-1.1527026891708374,
0.09022004902362823,
-0.35421228408813477,
-0.08020178973674774,
0.08831924945116043,
0.20595546066761017,
-0.6561437249183655,
0.7533395886421204,
0.2022220343351364,
-0.4717618227005005,
0.3935512900352478,
-0.35772398114204407,
0.20429173111915588,
-0.6151672005653381,
0.18875229358673096,
0.5972446799278259,
-0.030659407377243042,
-0.6180310249328613,
0.1706298440694809,
0.08588963747024536,
-0.6248645782470703,
-0.27192437648773193,
0.4572194218635559,
-0.4758247435092926,
-0.3244706988334656,
-0.15931639075279236,
-0.19634106755256653,
0.3074396550655365,
0.3782772123813629,
0.38124626874923706,
0.8393767476081848,
0.3495388925075531,
-0.523556649684906,
0.3782050907611847,
0.15323705971240997,
-0.46498221158981323,
0.6119977831840515,
-1.0877697467803955,
0.5132619142532349,
-0.3702879846096039,
0.028685254976153374,
-0.9241398572921753,
-0.41637006402015686,
0.07010098546743393,
-0.5954232215881348,
0.070170097053051,
-0.28142085671424866,
-0.5147616863250732,
-0.36421117186546326,
-0.00031667418079450727,
0.760336697101593,
0.6382856369018555,
-0.1498221755027771,
0.6833009123802185,
-0.036186691373586655,
-0.304073303937912,
-0.29140347242355347,
-0.6436100006103516,
0.21300511062145233,
-0.006691175978630781,
-0.7488110065460205,
0.3116692900657654,
0.06334690749645233,
-0.6191583871841431,
0.21216195821762085,
0.24494925141334534,
-0.42153915762901306,
-0.03851785883307457,
0.3074687421321869,
0.3712593615055084,
-0.18085452914237976,
0.31729450821876526,
0.0092941178008914,
-0.2885764241218567,
0.27461376786231995,
-0.1901988387107849,
0.179192915558815,
-0.3138044476509094,
-0.5103113055229187,
-0.13738206028938293,
0.36120814085006714,
0.747583270072937,
-0.2525572180747986,
0.3904520571231842,
0.2243807017803192,
-0.626291811466217,
0.015249646268785,
-0.29110264778137207,
0.034618861973285675,
-0.3580474555492401,
0.3035634756088257,
-0.5729634761810303,
-0.2736028730869293,
0.43463021516799927,
-0.08323903381824493,
-0.1858254075050354,
0.7625477313995361,
0.43361562490463257,
0.02967231534421444,
1.296904444694519,
0.2190214842557907,
0.4862045347690582,
-0.09216998517513275,
-0.36634841561317444,
-0.11608123034238815,
-0.3975619375705719,
-0.3830818235874176,
-0.6522947549819946,
0.16224241256713867,
-0.21202236413955688,
-0.7224177718162537,
0.25722476840019226,
0.03680875524878502,
-0.5096641182899475,
0.1817025989294052,
-0.8309333920478821,
0.8222902417182922,
0.3437272012233734,
0.3192504346370697,
0.3899543285369873,
0.2275967299938202,
-0.1617521494626999,
-0.17745432257652283,
-0.5649921298027039,
-0.7792666554450989,
0.7512213587760925,
0.15988460183143616,
0.8737317323684692,
-0.03522691875696182,
0.29181092977523804,
0.34309741854667664,
0.594750165939331,
-0.9700804352760315,
0.5920581817626953,
-0.6291388869285583,
-0.45634400844573975,
-0.2957037091255188,
-0.5255626440048218,
-0.4902215003967285,
0.23600947856903076,
-0.2234625667333603,
-0.3459526598453522,
0.33295270800590515,
0.041999321430921555,
-0.4643939435482025,
0.18748807907104492,
-0.7392123341560364,
0.8919042944908142,
-0.43647098541259766,
-0.3896291255950928,
-0.06038384884595871,
-0.47922053933143616,
0.5478489398956299,
-0.1781051605939865,
0.4164462983608246,
-0.14179597795009613,
-0.07731025665998459,
0.5094651579856873,
-0.5945992469787598,
0.8051491975784302,
-0.036877743899822235,
-0.07576382905244827,
0.5007931590080261,
0.260215163230896,
0.21254710853099823,
0.049774736166000366,
-0.24314768612384796,
0.18365944921970367,
-0.031128229573369026,
-0.4397156834602356,
-0.9501287341117859,
0.21019278466701508,
-0.8080705404281616,
-0.33628857135772705,
-0.37412506341934204,
-0.3517809808254242,
0.07796993106603622,
-0.1264205425977707,
0.5855206847190857,
0.7249402403831482,
-0.11905521899461746,
0.12856897711753845,
0.733264148235321,
-0.3993374705314636,
0.08899979293346405,
-0.06643804907798767,
-0.11955183744430542,
-0.656045138835907,
1.1080937385559082,
0.09883743524551392,
0.3507175147533417,
0.2318379431962967,
0.0413176566362381,
-0.31510114669799805,
-0.22665834426879883,
-0.7443180084228516,
0.12687426805496216,
-1.092105507850647,
-0.27827775478363037,
-0.2052588015794754,
-0.11249221116304398,
0.13585633039474487,
-0.17967131733894348,
0.023745838552713394,
-0.5169815421104431,
-0.5823021531105042,
0.33337530493736267,
0.3804609775543213,
0.8565217852592468,
0.11008790135383606,
-0.0817047506570816,
-0.7332952618598938,
0.5052690505981445,
0.6958473920822144,
0.19308297336101532,
0.2717609107494354,
-0.772209644317627,
0.06597314774990082,
0.14101524651050568,
-0.31962135434150696,
-0.9149286150932312,
0.19648800790309906,
0.2251596748828888,
0.09175671637058258,
0.4059714376926422,
-0.08157748728990555,
0.7889938950538635,
-0.6315319538116455,
0.6621461510658264,
0.508057713508606,
-1.0900195837020874,
0.5884007215499878,
-0.2335328906774521,
0.28217798471450806,
0.25856685638427734,
0.4904044270515442,
-0.3948380947113037,
0.14728370308876038,
-0.631860077381134,
-0.4985746741294861,
0.32157135009765625,
0.27435991168022156,
0.43285301327705383,
-0.2115790694952011,
0.4754396080970764,
-0.10413654893636703,
-0.132631316781044,
-0.7017316818237305,
0.06335027515888214,
-0.48335692286491394,
-0.10734444111585617,
0.17374464869499207,
-0.2280208170413971,
0.012778076343238354,
-0.44885239005088806,
0.2956560552120209,
-0.1870182454586029,
0.49471762776374817,
-0.02628406137228012,
-0.037395525723695755,
0.017890596762299538,
0.2903822064399719,
0.8932545185089111,
0.5095406174659729,
0.1296454668045044,
-0.0011148694902658463,
0.36427658796310425,
-0.22049760818481445,
0.4115673899650574,
0.010718541219830513,
-0.3625441789627075,
0.12724843621253967,
0.41790682077407837,
1.0449883937835693,
0.4537372291088104,
-0.5378252267837524,
0.4744162857532501,
-0.22142332792282104,
-0.5626266598701477,
-0.16248616576194763,
-0.10351625829935074,
0.1738259345293045,
-0.12151206284761429,
0.4339338541030884,
0.4940887987613678,
0.18715456128120422,
-0.3842006325721741,
-0.07003512233495712,
0.3260136842727661,
-0.32430028915405273,
-0.3274891972541809,
0.7242298126220703,
0.1970704346895218,
-0.3611474633216858,
0.8761184811592102,
-0.42919352650642395,
-0.3369556963443756,
1.1041167974472046,
0.5230420827865601,
0.6971020102500916,
0.31966522336006165,
0.4281216263771057,
0.4761607050895691,
0.19967389106750488,
-0.2898860275745392,
0.2289343923330307,
-0.05358532816171646,
-0.7134077548980713,
-0.6520517468452454,
-0.3674039840698242,
-0.6365010738372803,
-0.29584190249443054,
-0.8320191502571106,
0.28198352456092834,
-0.47217968106269836,
-0.4998582601547241,
0.5649328827857971,
-0.4389536380767822,
-0.6424016952514648,
0.5010175704956055,
0.1400291919708252,
0.8907639980316162,
-0.8779653310775757,
0.24753549695014954,
1.0659953355789185,
-0.8015204071998596,
-0.6987661123275757,
-0.29870474338531494,
-0.426215261220932,
-0.7978421449661255,
0.923323929309845,
0.22210969030857086,
0.08490073680877686,
0.15436258912086487,
-0.8544461727142334,
-0.2198924422264099,
0.8087430000305176,
0.5189529061317444,
-0.43899789452552795,
-0.12675701081752777,
0.23968258500099182,
0.7370295524597168,
-0.1313887983560562,
0.4706498384475708,
0.16934989392757416,
0.4390065670013428,
0.6849207878112793,
-0.6397386789321899,
-0.02634502202272415,
-0.47434717416763306,
0.5321589708328247,
0.22225536406040192,
-0.39191168546676636,
0.9667474031448364,
-0.5878447890281677,
-0.44072458148002625,
0.27210673689842224,
0.41747739911079407,
0.2541593611240387,
0.4680090844631195,
0.4285437762737274,
1.0018490552902222,
0.517973780632019,
-0.3728162944316864,
1.1568987369537354,
-0.10102396458387375,
0.4798513352870941,
0.604924201965332,
-0.13266882300376892,
0.7440691590309143,
0.05284624919295311,
-0.28075242042541504,
0.5347499847412109,
0.5902137756347656,
-0.29719898104667664,
0.45938602089881897,
0.33758124709129333,
-0.37586551904678345,
-0.7215024828910828,
-0.14322364330291748,
-0.2763036787509918,
0.16921453177928925,
0.5213857889175415,
-0.3743530213832855,
-0.3454483449459076,
0.15343788266181946,
-0.3102485239505768,
0.30418485403060913,
-0.3706115186214447,
0.8768120408058167,
0.3002287447452545,
-0.6780946850776672,
0.6715693473815918,
0.12937922775745392,
0.36127951741218567,
-0.02202383615076542,
-0.38834184408187866,
-0.02013765461742878,
-0.258719265460968,
-0.20669104158878326,
-0.9556370973587036,
0.30745458602905273,
0.3235006332397461,
-0.2246100902557373,
0.037915363907814026,
0.9741125702857971,
0.09724152088165283,
-0.8773475885391235,
-0.21932335197925568,
0.3514641225337982,
0.39728373289108276,
-0.20770315825939178,
-0.6096594929695129,
0.04567725211381912,
-0.12953664362430573,
0.10688106715679169,
0.0006420833524316549,
0.8694547414779663,
-0.1831049621105194,
0.6618816256523132,
0.5814588069915771,
-0.1975371241569519,
-0.2351166009902954,
0.1945110410451889,
0.71889328956604,
-0.7742368578910828,
-0.0651332288980484,
-1.0562493801116943,
0.47080373764038086,
-0.07631271332502365,
-0.36798253655433655,
0.22307446599006653,
0.33461713790893555,
0.5473920106887817,
-0.38807493448257446,
0.8718060255050659,
0.13207507133483887,
-0.10329366475343704,
-0.4328806698322296,
0.5278096199035645,
-0.4090803563594818,
0.07950324565172195,
-0.3612050414085388,
-0.6400367021560669,
-0.49121445417404175,
0.9821454882621765,
-0.6651412844657898,
0.08242766559123993,
0.3764924108982086,
0.4447997212409973,
-0.0028416672721505165,
0.1255870759487152,
0.5773270726203918,
-0.2613811194896698,
-0.07042661309242249,
0.6555842161178589,
1.1078732013702393,
-0.5114526748657227,
0.6506444215774536,
-0.2785358130931854,
-0.06409017741680145,
0.0794592946767807,
-1.0394697189331055,
-0.866755485534668,
-0.3784993588924408,
-0.3041766285896301,
-0.26610061526298523,
-0.030194014310836792,
0.5030837655067444,
0.5850604176521301,
-0.47250425815582275,
0.07898211479187012,
-0.4096882939338684,
-0.04662063717842102,
0.061398476362228394,
-0.1983189582824707,
0.09187246114015579,
-0.18216951191425323,
-0.5932886600494385,
-0.36720332503318787,
0.48594069480895996,
0.5051704049110413,
-0.1802142858505249,
-0.05330904945731163,
0.49451056122779846,
0.15840928256511688,
0.7740454077720642,
0.35602614283561707,
-0.7276536822319031,
-0.04854440316557884,
0.11690818518400192,
-0.35894328355789185,
0.03271449729800224,
0.6160377860069275,
-0.7955808043479919,
0.540917694568634,
0.473763644695282,
0.5999393463134766,
0.5125836730003357,
0.41476693749427795,
0.384747713804245,
-0.3731423616409302,
0.08329974114894867,
0.39361369609832764,
0.20654509961605072,
0.4766943156719208,
-0.014027418568730354,
0.5572306513786316,
0.39676979184150696,
-0.378216028213501,
-0.7294343709945679,
0.05199194326996803,
-0.6213825941085815,
-0.2969231605529785,
0.9653844833374023,
-0.22332337498664856,
-0.13940730690956116,
0.2977295517921448,
-0.22620584070682526,
-0.15286897122859955,
-0.18757221102714539,
0.551541268825531,
0.9169443249702454,
0.023584116250276566,
-0.29558202624320984,
-0.5515583753585815,
0.18023313581943512,
0.3443397581577301,
-1.0417660474777222,
-0.2820185422897339,
0.6064487099647522,
0.07623961567878723,
0.5123490691184998,
0.4783475995063782,
-0.16798816621303558,
0.6479238867759705,
0.2582537531852722,
-0.040360234677791595,
0.009414499625563622,
-0.2264595925807953,
-0.34128955006599426,
0.06351735442876816,
0.273506760597229,
0.17092986404895782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14765v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14765v1 | ChatGPT as Research Scientist: Probing GPT's Capabilities as a Research Librarian, Research Ethicist, Data Generator and Data Predictor | 2024-06-20T22:30:06 | 2024-06-20T22:30:06 | Steven A. Lehr, Aylin Caliskan, Suneragiri Liyanage, Mahzarin R. Banaji | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.IR, cs.LG, I.2.7; K.4.0; K.4.1; K.4.2 | How good a research scientist is ChatGPT? We systematically probed the
capabilities of GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 across four central components of the
scientific process: as a Research Librarian, Research Ethicist, Data Generator,
and Novel Data Predictor, using psychological science as a testing field. In
Study 1 (Research Librarian), unlike human researchers, GPT-3.5 and GPT-4
hallucinated, authoritatively generating fictional references 36.0% and 5.4% of
the time, respectively, although GPT-4 exhibited an evolving capacity to
acknowledge its fictions. In Study 2 (Research Ethicist), GPT-4 (though not
GPT-3.5) proved capable of detecting violations like p-hacking in fictional
research protocols, correcting 88.6% of blatantly presented issues, and 72.6%
of subtly presented issues. In Study 3 (Data Generator), both models
consistently replicated patterns of cultural bias previously discovered in
large language corpora, indicating that ChatGPT can simulate known results, an
antecedent to usefulness for both data generation and skills like hypothesis
generation. Contrastingly, in Study 4 (Novel Data Predictor), neither model was
successful at predicting new results absent in their training data, and neither
appeared to leverage substantially new information when predicting more versus
less novel outcomes. Together, these results suggest that GPT is a flawed but
rapidly improving librarian, a decent research ethicist already, capable of
data generation in simple domains with known characteristics but poor at
predicting novel patterns of empirical data to aid future experimentation. | [
-0.3720831573009491,
-0.6669787764549255,
0.7121437191963196,
-0.16448436677455902,
0.043034009635448456,
0.4192368686199188,
-0.1057562306523323,
-0.4077022075653076,
0.061360038816928864,
0.13186989724636078,
-0.18020573258399963,
0.09071169048547745,
-0.6809722185134888,
0.23680540919303894,
-0.5453725457191467,
1.3516677618026733,
0.30008259415626526,
0.27075958251953125,
-0.015016071498394012,
0.37599653005599976,
-0.38339266180992126,
-0.8064841628074646,
-0.8082513213157654,
-0.5268036127090454,
0.5416412949562073,
0.16426163911819458,
0.919587254524231,
0.16398751735687256,
0.46978893876075745,
0.24953827261924744,
0.10475479066371918,
-0.08530621230602264,
-0.830713152885437,
0.16517068445682526,
-0.23037216067314148,
-0.5732253193855286,
-0.2331169694662094,
0.3316940665245056,
0.2483816146850586,
0.48875629901885986,
0.0517156645655632,
-0.0657639130949974,
0.02848784253001213,
0.7029874324798584,
-0.11484003812074661,
0.308242529630661,
-0.5860076546669006,
0.20166015625,
-0.3822042942047119,
-0.4543355107307434,
-0.38755860924720764,
-0.7537082433700562,
0.41524776816368103,
-0.7331642508506775,
0.8412854671478271,
0.2879677712917328,
0.6165504455566406,
0.08838670700788498,
-0.5812574625015259,
-0.3804892301559448,
-0.9712488055229187,
0.6607206463813782,
-0.249309241771698,
0.25904884934425354,
0.49420493841171265,
0.38398608565330505,
-0.26869282126426697,
-0.923334002494812,
-0.5275278687477112,
-0.4885421395301819,
0.05531075969338417,
0.2601739764213562,
-0.06584472954273224,
-0.18774175643920898,
0.48937052488327026,
0.4191306531429291,
-0.7376822829246521,
-0.44801852107048035,
-0.7569167017936707,
-0.32594236731529236,
0.3527244031429291,
0.006056053098291159,
0.1526750773191452,
-0.032876450568437576,
-0.13544170558452606,
-0.20492689311504364,
-0.5963711738586426,
-0.17352080345153809,
0.5233927369117737,
0.104334257543087,
0.4719005227088928,
0.6341818571090698,
0.09099029004573822,
0.10906961560249329,
0.1077522337436676,
0.08176938444375992,
0.18409545719623566,
-0.47107329964637756,
0.14854221045970917,
0.22395996749401093,
0.7810014486312866,
0.09033484756946564,
0.3339630961418152,
-0.16679351031780243,
0.042363233864307404,
0.016312941908836365,
0.5702890157699585,
-0.7683760523796082,
-0.8401824831962585,
0.17618170380592346,
-0.3361535668373108,
-0.41362160444259644,
0.14305512607097626,
-0.7111417651176453,
-0.5115383267402649,
-0.06290807574987411,
0.3443114459514618,
-0.6653925180435181,
-0.4203355014324188,
-0.058854855597019196,
-0.4907758831977844,
0.21544022858142853,
0.14960505068302155,
-0.953740656375885,
0.2776465117931366,
0.6143965125083923,
1.0075947046279907,
-0.37817880511283875,
-0.3665564954280853,
-0.19712340831756592,
0.15656138956546783,
-0.32042813301086426,
0.6840741634368896,
-0.46422290802001953,
-0.6810759902000427,
-0.12483671307563782,
-0.20717686414718628,
-0.09862726181745529,
-0.11872092634439468,
0.6497400403022766,
-0.4982323944568634,
0.3973141312599182,
-0.4906044602394104,
-0.505010187625885,
0.08948119729757309,
0.22891300916671753,
-0.5195833444595337,
0.9718815684318542,
0.2361757457256317,
-1.0133616924285889,
0.5636121034622192,
-0.8019980788230896,
0.01001808512955904,
0.2667090892791748,
-0.09803768992424011,
-0.32244986295700073,
-0.13389214873313904,
0.002678381046280265,
0.21179945766925812,
-0.14716437458992004,
0.46882200241088867,
-0.47369295358657837,
-0.3552486300468445,
0.6802369952201843,
-0.5410056114196777,
0.6299428939819336,
0.2654557526111603,
-0.2346002161502838,
-0.1922043412923813,
-0.5154736638069153,
0.020426703616976738,
0.06530585139989853,
-0.18026530742645264,
-0.023945612832903862,
0.14954227209091187,
0.1119707003235817,
-0.06790726631879807,
-0.03556032106280327,
-0.743100643157959,
0.19749197363853455,
-0.022587774321436882,
0.5148842930793762,
0.6989122033119202,
0.21437041461467743,
0.1575329750776291,
-0.5035343170166016,
0.5640954971313477,
-0.6111359000205994,
-0.0022488508839160204,
0.2610296308994293,
-0.8133317232131958,
-0.3133006691932678,
-0.048537906259298325,
0.23529547452926636,
0.3794822096824646,
-0.7771077156066895,
-0.11589615046977997,
-0.10183288902044296,
-0.8221275210380554,
-0.14903970062732697,
-0.30202844738960266,
0.1802985519170761,
0.607964277267456,
0.34425467252731323,
-0.2900412976741791,
-0.48976147174835205,
-0.6936999559402466,
-0.5713139176368713,
-0.40961822867393494,
-0.3316284418106079,
0.050618428736925125,
0.7067368030548096,
0.021665317937731743,
0.94391930103302,
-0.37391579151153564,
-0.02615167759358883,
0.01696525514125824,
0.31747594475746155,
0.4514975845813751,
0.4534045159816742,
0.2570602595806122,
-0.9406754970550537,
-0.5103291869163513,
-0.005273687187582254,
-0.7832342982292175,
-0.048961345106363297,
0.3638640344142914,
-0.04835622012615204,
-0.006861759349703789,
0.2199692726135254,
-0.8816483020782471,
0.3019215166568756,
0.10860107094049454,
-0.5572187304496765,
1.0677086114883423,
-0.2110346108675003,
0.3543073534965515,
-0.6512974500656128,
0.19278523325920105,
-0.21186503767967224,
0.1777493804693222,
-1.0912578105926514,
-0.28045666217803955,
-0.22981694340705872,
-0.2534129321575165,
0.020800353959202766,
0.3169669210910797,
-0.3772232234477997,
0.007159399800002575,
-0.32583025097846985,
-0.3204543888568878,
-0.3085665702819824,
0.012493855319917202,
0.09906043857336044,
0.7228901982307434,
0.5268598794937134,
-0.36383798718452454,
0.27747470140457153,
0.35494211316108704,
-0.25755560398101807,
0.31621935963630676,
-0.7214623689651489,
0.3230918347835541,
0.06147094815969467,
0.448941171169281,
-0.837038516998291,
-0.4810813069343567,
0.34890931844711304,
-0.5037916898727417,
0.19363601505756378,
-0.29510483145713806,
-0.6198968887329102,
-0.5372807383537292,
-0.19903405010700226,
0.3106756806373596,
0.679925262928009,
-0.18804538249969482,
0.5208432078361511,
0.22104153037071228,
-0.5560882091522217,
-0.4609154164791107,
-0.4999774098396301,
-0.05177466198801994,
-0.3218551278114319,
-0.5859636068344116,
0.48920419812202454,
-0.12744496762752533,
-0.24087147414684296,
-0.046040549874305725,
-0.22979065775871277,
-0.10459215193986893,
-0.25667569041252136,
0.014017347246408463,
0.3630513846874237,
-0.08087705075740814,
-0.034375112503767014,
-0.49216228723526,
-0.26636427640914917,
0.4289382994174957,
0.02039611153304577,
0.5877683758735657,
-0.48172661662101746,
-0.5299017429351807,
0.1709330826997757,
0.05345549061894417,
0.2626144289970398,
-0.05675904452800751,
0.4099695086479187,
0.980073869228363,
0.12041663378477097,
0.3047141432762146,
-0.5819658637046814,
-0.520803689956665,
-0.48728471994400024,
0.3201015889644623,
-0.4422696828842163,
-0.9774560332298279,
0.5651859045028687,
0.25410178303718567,
-0.05848896875977516,
0.20993275940418243,
0.4688403010368347,
0.11823803931474686,
0.8697372078895569,
0.4427029490470886,
0.12995405495166779,
0.27632537484169006,
-0.09718883037567139,
0.6126023530960083,
-0.5738834142684937,
-0.04655464366078377,
-0.542233943939209,
0.06012273579835892,
-1.1184675693511963,
-0.3752411901950836,
0.6745831370353699,
-0.17941313982009888,
-0.5600860118865967,
-0.07785069942474365,
-0.7574363350868225,
0.5448815226554871,
0.7751578092575073,
0.0502181276679039,
0.26717978715896606,
0.033852849155664444,
0.4409332275390625,
-0.018356017768383026,
-0.7377287149429321,
-0.633216142654419,
1.422382116317749,
0.5255133509635925,
0.7972270250320435,
0.10020128637552261,
0.5056495666503906,
0.28136950731277466,
0.2117489129304886,
-0.5406461954116821,
0.31367337703704834,
0.37204110622406006,
-0.8070294857025146,
-0.3172377645969391,
-0.324410080909729,
-0.6785044074058533,
0.3951137363910675,
0.02024306170642376,
-0.7184244394302368,
0.31416577100753784,
0.42249226570129395,
0.011130845174193382,
0.2764895558357239,
-0.6871421337127686,
0.7074747681617737,
-0.10551892966032028,
-0.513272225856781,
-0.0228970218449831,
-0.7287594079971313,
0.5498737096786499,
-0.2667135000228882,
0.11208335310220718,
-0.08838281780481339,
0.21465809643268585,
0.6756782531738281,
-0.13560332357883453,
0.8527054190635681,
-0.4335370659828186,
0.27393797039985657,
0.19047458469867706,
0.41962745785713196,
0.40083467960357666,
0.15623091161251068,
-0.13464434444904327,
0.04312608391046524,
0.5056952238082886,
-0.4894380569458008,
-0.3209776282310486,
0.3014892339706421,
-0.8126348853111267,
-0.752697765827179,
-0.9374316930770874,
-0.5964422225952148,
-0.566502034664154,
0.08140385150909424,
0.4674523174762726,
0.1419668197631836,
-0.4794498682022095,
0.10156511515378952,
0.6574221253395081,
-0.0074887145310640335,
0.030940813943743706,
0.3909764587879181,
-0.11813975125551224,
-0.09203343093395233,
1.0520596504211426,
0.02235756441950798,
0.21312884986400604,
0.030693434178829193,
0.35320955514907837,
-0.23184612393379211,
-0.5966856479644775,
0.02318854071199894,
0.09019709378480911,
-0.39850950241088867,
0.037048690021038055,
-0.65740966796875,
-0.4030657112598419,
-0.32337358593940735,
-0.1174849197268486,
-0.3053385615348816,
-0.30680328607559204,
0.0021393944043666124,
-0.16636860370635986,
0.45084208250045776,
0.7666338682174683,
-0.1564616858959198,
0.15216220915317535,
-0.2953589856624603,
0.08107993751764297,
0.2859497368335724,
0.08975397795438766,
-0.18438760936260223,
-0.5435413122177124,
0.002213820582255721,
-0.025010133162140846,
-0.5995954871177673,
-0.9002280831336975,
0.43613892793655396,
0.1208832636475563,
0.4530206322669983,
0.40733152627944946,
-0.08848723769187927,
0.39820411801338196,
-0.5579695105552673,
0.9943808317184448,
-0.07586942613124847,
-0.5289561748504639,
0.28749513626098633,
-0.7085747718811035,
-0.03476501256227493,
0.24275173246860504,
0.6827732920646667,
-0.5126885771751404,
-0.7073615193367004,
-0.7111954689025879,
-0.7309871315956116,
0.6289656758308411,
0.4961097240447998,
-0.0063080089166760445,
-0.006590766832232475,
0.1639327108860016,
0.4537876546382904,
0.1939786672592163,
-0.9347158074378967,
0.09869572520256042,
-0.8475309014320374,
0.32455703616142273,
-0.11851134896278381,
-0.2647348940372467,
-0.25810885429382324,
-0.19951488077640533,
0.9124976992607117,
-0.2653135359287262,
0.6596209406852722,
0.27216866612434387,
0.4270820915699005,
0.1882738173007965,
0.3971159756183624,
0.23884648084640503,
0.9335178732872009,
-0.5765507817268372,
0.17081831395626068,
-0.24695967137813568,
-0.7370021343231201,
0.09630616009235382,
0.44370633363723755,
-0.02027299255132675,
-0.22609125077724457,
0.3631264269351959,
0.35932788252830505,
-0.31094738841056824,
-0.30029723048210144,
0.31660178303718567,
-0.072051040828228,
-0.4701686501502991,
-0.5497880578041077,
0.22771699726581573,
-0.029471246525645256,
0.15602946281433105,
0.7088032364845276,
0.11863657087087631,
0.2794935405254364,
-0.6489346623420715,
0.15481887757778168,
0.2592228353023529,
-0.08020869642496109,
-0.477339506149292,
0.7487447261810303,
-0.04086636006832123,
0.007493704091757536,
0.7319794297218323,
-0.22000138461589813,
-0.48557746410369873,
0.44935405254364014,
0.6565116047859192,
0.5524409413337708,
-0.2670105993747711,
0.5578771233558655,
0.36496368050575256,
0.17520326375961304,
-0.27689284086227417,
0.2185913622379303,
0.22556646168231964,
-0.9768059849739075,
-0.24438104033470154,
-0.4145777225494385,
-0.6334963440895081,
0.1125633716583252,
-0.6254538297653198,
-0.08319030702114105,
-0.007790038827806711,
-0.2957334816455841,
0.2009017914533615,
0.13096871972084045,
-0.6468573808670044,
-0.17188920080661774,
-0.40576499700546265,
0.6283005475997925,
-0.7188092470169067,
0.8210626840591431,
0.38984668254852295,
-0.4492012560367584,
-0.7187750935554504,
0.015489025972783566,
0.325054407119751,
-0.6439656615257263,
0.7149609327316284,
-0.0020390222780406475,
0.11992470175027847,
-0.06417401134967804,
-0.4201895296573639,
-0.9138960838317871,
1.1151212453842163,
0.19564250111579895,
-0.3160882890224457,
-0.0820731669664383,
0.13475355505943298,
0.8452229499816895,
-0.2049434930086136,
0.639823853969574,
0.480312317609787,
0.5414792895317078,
0.10295931249856949,
-0.9360854029655457,
-0.005712504032999277,
-0.3444054424762726,
-0.08395158499479294,
0.0991285890340805,
-0.48493459820747375,
0.8975604176521301,
-0.12242474406957626,
-0.0063675264827907085,
0.06367530673742294,
0.39544013142585754,
0.4065958857536316,
0.4186490774154663,
0.15965303778648376,
0.1662641018629074,
0.9104530811309814,
-0.1994251161813736,
1.2181631326675415,
-0.3064872622489929,
0.11529746651649475,
0.9203330278396606,
-0.39554211497306824,
0.3478880822658539,
0.6189001202583313,
-0.2565435469150543,
0.22137175500392914,
0.8581201434135437,
-0.45815548300743103,
0.7117152810096741,
0.0806579440832138,
-0.3576853275299072,
0.08967287093400955,
0.033229030668735504,
-0.5015963912010193,
0.23714898526668549,
0.38937366008758545,
-0.3341749906539917,
0.09393546730279922,
-0.009157121181488037,
-0.0596582256257534,
-0.3250860273838043,
-0.06034832075238228,
0.2634153366088867,
-0.005860413424670696,
-0.5955327153205872,
0.2605295479297638,
-0.33807966113090515,
0.2396014779806137,
-0.7240763902664185,
-0.05161627009510994,
-0.04880879819393158,
0.04092257097363472,
-0.1871301233768463,
-0.9934305548667908,
0.2580932378768921,
-0.027567915618419647,
-0.10787300020456314,
-0.31165647506713867,
0.9579636454582214,
-0.05693303048610687,
-0.15009990334510803,
-0.14325952529907227,
0.726199746131897,
0.5387016534805298,
-0.12492704391479492,
-0.43316134810447693,
-0.07642759382724762,
0.23624426126480103,
-0.3939647376537323,
0.24826966226100922,
0.44145458936691284,
-0.028753701597452164,
0.8256180286407471,
0.7482438087463379,
0.3479328751564026,
0.005516552831977606,
0.028944268822669983,
0.7510963678359985,
-0.739385187625885,
-0.17587539553642273,
-0.7114180326461792,
0.1319272220134735,
-0.1352623999118805,
-0.29561662673950195,
0.7790427207946777,
0.6660738587379456,
0.803800642490387,
-0.1209421306848526,
0.9635640978813171,
-0.5739359259605408,
0.6317211389541626,
-0.28238868713378906,
0.48746389150619507,
0.14532028138637543,
0.026669470593333244,
-0.18780802190303802,
-0.9247379899024963,
0.1355195790529251,
0.4522486627101898,
-0.6874865293502808,
0.3031476140022278,
0.9288358688354492,
0.862861692905426,
-0.22160950303077698,
0.5005770921707153,
0.0888744369149208,
0.3187025189399719,
0.7364428043365479,
0.14752589166164398,
0.9619784951210022,
-0.010163514874875546,
0.5951013565063477,
-0.24418853223323822,
-0.29926374554634094,
0.10699157416820526,
-0.6238933801651001,
-1.087373971939087,
-0.5295438170433044,
-0.0030539100989699364,
-0.3734811544418335,
0.1317780464887619,
0.4464341402053833,
0.594893753528595,
-0.6164276599884033,
-0.06936667859554291,
-0.22364899516105652,
-0.23428763449192047,
-0.1429411917924881,
-0.34027302265167236,
0.4507151246070862,
-0.22251638770103455,
-0.4858568012714386,
0.3542173504829407,
-0.10902699828147888,
-0.11928080022335052,
-0.2515120804309845,
-0.07221559435129166,
0.28721076250076294,
-0.18426427245140076,
0.5720824599266052,
0.3249106705188751,
-0.6386038661003113,
-0.45039570331573486,
-0.06136335805058479,
0.07871938496828079,
-0.09059975296258926,
0.7530964612960815,
-0.5075679421424866,
0.5823720693588257,
0.21117360889911652,
0.46082359552383423,
0.9137054681777954,
-0.019274258986115456,
0.9062154293060303,
-0.29679426550865173,
-0.23687958717346191,
0.651669979095459,
0.2055850774049759,
0.27068382501602173,
-0.4411105215549469,
0.9519567489624023,
0.2955172657966614,
-1.214557409286499,
-0.8282114863395691,
0.2035035640001297,
-0.8927463889122009,
-0.08233725279569626,
0.7875750660896301,
0.14576436579227448,
0.013240201398730278,
-0.35121461749076843,
-0.36045968532562256,
-0.010348494164645672,
-0.6298181414604187,
1.0606554746627808,
0.7480784058570862,
-0.8715159296989441,
-0.017400847747921944,
-1.2737088203430176,
0.7987833023071289,
0.2876548171043396,
-0.5517464280128479,
0.010365208610892296,
0.5122252106666565,
0.47040244936943054,
0.23420847952365875,
0.8485572934150696,
-0.132766991853714,
0.3197382688522339,
0.3249901235103607,
0.04023462533950806,
-0.08774594217538834,
0.08391556143760681,
0.3441668450832367,
0.1857907623052597,
0.13288669288158417,
0.26014599204063416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14764v1 | RE-AdaptIR: Improving Information Retrieval through Reverse Engineered Adaptation | 2024-06-20T22:28:11 | 2024-06-20T22:28:11 | William Fleshman, Benjamin Van Durme | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) fine-tuned for text-retrieval have demonstrated
state-of-the-art results across several information retrieval (IR) benchmarks.
However, supervised training for improving these models requires numerous
labeled examples, which are generally unavailable or expensive to acquire. In
this work, we explore the effectiveness of extending reverse engineered
adaptation to the context of information retrieval (RE-AdaptIR). We use
RE-AdaptIR to improve LLM-based IR models using only unlabeled data. We
demonstrate improved performance both in training domains as well as zero-shot
in domains where the models have seen no queries. We analyze performance
changes in various fine-tuning scenarios and offer findings of immediate use to
practitioners. | [
0.06884988397359848,
-0.5640432834625244,
0.4041001498699188,
-0.12118836492300034,
-0.2681661546230316,
0.11498081684112549,
-0.3222029209136963,
-0.43452513217926025,
0.14570815861225128,
0.8131994009017944,
-0.3531132936477661,
-0.47584256529808044,
-0.5383354425430298,
0.21249504387378693,
-0.5310134291648865,
0.8944628238677979,
-0.0522112101316452,
0.024397164583206177,
0.007303107529878616,
-0.23688621819019318,
-0.4427971839904785,
-0.47382569313049316,
-0.2935657799243927,
-0.40867722034454346,
0.42982497811317444,
0.7237529158592224,
0.4582049548625946,
0.5409071445465088,
0.6875976920127869,
0.1863032579421997,
0.1479305624961853,
0.22110070288181305,
-1.01720130443573,
0.2762061655521393,
-0.5680639743804932,
-0.5700448155403137,
-0.19608648121356964,
-0.06769639998674393,
0.7106579542160034,
0.5525346994400024,
-0.22360435128211975,
0.28571659326553345,
-0.043156690895557404,
1.003673791885376,
-1.0833384990692139,
-0.15319740772247314,
-1.1631559133529663,
-0.1927572637796402,
0.1499546319246292,
-0.5800215601921082,
-0.8267533779144287,
-0.21907998621463776,
0.131927952170372,
-0.8920143246650696,
0.3663257658481598,
0.21629326045513153,
0.6878642439842224,
0.31824836134910583,
-0.19320173561573029,
0.10115736722946167,
-0.9241222739219666,
0.9381186962127686,
-0.5921653509140015,
0.748598575592041,
0.32668060064315796,
0.3780957758426666,
-0.6924707293510437,
-0.8412643074989319,
-0.2331862449645996,
0.014549458399415016,
0.09308450669050217,
0.24324971437454224,
-0.45695358514785767,
-0.1039292961359024,
0.1323315054178238,
0.14681121706962585,
-0.22584044933319092,
0.13144855201244354,
-0.4476195275783539,
0.07588587701320648,
0.6020326614379883,
0.0037015979178249836,
-0.0340399406850338,
0.22506144642829895,
-0.11940336227416992,
-0.17544138431549072,
-0.7397393584251404,
-0.4382546544075012,
0.025598350912332535,
0.6463009119033813,
0.39133861660957336,
0.6646217107772827,
-0.5101972818374634,
0.8372018337249756,
0.11217910796403885,
-0.2048928439617157,
0.24993425607681274,
-0.18412894010543823,
-0.41036126017570496,
-0.05230744928121567,
0.19943000376224518,
0.3361799418926239,
0.35303571820259094,
-0.5958318114280701,
-0.4330238997936249,
-0.6437618732452393,
0.48421725630760193,
-0.9479908347129822,
-0.2548561096191406,
-0.20716238021850586,
-0.5753276944160461,
-0.06825360655784607,
0.12550771236419678,
-0.6198999881744385,
-0.415904700756073,
-0.37914156913757324,
0.7829911112785339,
-0.29605892300605774,
-0.08446704596281052,
0.30718937516212463,
-0.489019513130188,
0.39330440759658813,
0.47413694858551025,
-0.5963265299797058,
0.16035142540931702,
0.5877740979194641,
0.5640824437141418,
-0.08882869780063629,
-0.10967908799648285,
-0.6200606226921082,
0.2420543134212494,
-0.2672581672668457,
1.051160216331482,
-0.8781679272651672,
-0.3934842348098755,
-0.12928621470928192,
0.3012765347957611,
-0.14556285738945007,
-0.9126203060150146,
0.6134045124053955,
-0.9171628355979919,
-0.0912192314863205,
-0.021799512207508087,
-0.549080491065979,
-0.25257065892219543,
0.2784745991230011,
-0.5278541445732117,
0.7788109183311462,
0.1391700804233551,
-0.7787249088287354,
0.26721125841140747,
-0.5108833312988281,
-0.4445534348487854,
-0.18583883345127106,
0.18187494575977325,
-0.3231765925884247,
0.40049225091934204,
0.2996356189250946,
0.08142093569040298,
-0.3986218273639679,
0.17601443827152252,
-0.3399960696697235,
-0.5911456346511841,
0.10364637523889542,
-0.19691585004329681,
0.27133095264434814,
0.19825856387615204,
0.132290780544281,
-0.058416031301021576,
-0.9581395387649536,
0.012461378239095211,
-0.07255958020687103,
-0.8115906715393066,
-0.5835602879524231,
-0.045104797929525375,
0.025363938882946968,
-0.35698017477989197,
0.02662750519812107,
-0.6946679353713989,
0.4371761977672577,
-0.4787845313549042,
0.2487730234861374,
0.5480887293815613,
0.08572141081094742,
0.503296971321106,
-0.3388352692127228,
0.40490642189979553,
-0.12878507375717163,
-0.06630004197359085,
0.016237623989582062,
-0.1315651386976242,
-0.7662402391433716,
-0.2765964865684509,
0.5567017793655396,
0.6649780869483948,
-0.9594665765762329,
-0.04548809304833412,
-0.4392377734184265,
-0.5940495133399963,
-0.7017666697502136,
0.2780824899673462,
0.32628634572029114,
0.7085137963294983,
0.5734187364578247,
-0.2329949289560318,
-0.7528801560401917,
-0.9439893960952759,
-0.7601507306098938,
-0.11431695520877838,
-0.11454875022172928,
0.5692456960678101,
0.4752652645111084,
-0.5556377172470093,
0.7289446592330933,
-0.6933016180992126,
-0.2087581604719162,
-0.1311986744403839,
0.20410189032554626,
0.3037026822566986,
0.27575063705444336,
0.27692872285842896,
-0.7767130136489868,
-0.21045099198818207,
-0.05456843599677086,
-0.5779811143875122,
-0.050222378224134445,
0.02224612794816494,
-0.21412579715251923,
0.09708281606435776,
0.6064350008964539,
-0.16272546350955963,
0.560851514339447,
0.12973539531230927,
0.06300792843103409,
0.384082555770874,
-0.5293124318122864,
0.3370554447174072,
-0.9848436117172241,
0.31938105821609497,
-0.02295856736600399,
-0.2927849292755127,
-0.6638838052749634,
0.08921400457620621,
0.3005663752555847,
-0.17255744338035583,
-0.41403093934059143,
0.6557594537734985,
-0.5470669865608215,
-0.21850204467773438,
-0.6147913336753845,
0.24208761751651764,
0.032379817217588425,
0.11648626625537872,
-0.072158582508564,
0.9721626043319702,
0.3388400375843048,
-0.7864981889724731,
0.09474750608205795,
0.2746209502220154,
-0.4971641004085541,
0.32500556111335754,
-0.49731069803237915,
0.23213806748390198,
-0.5522788763046265,
0.03678182512521744,
-0.9850219488143921,
-0.19181787967681885,
0.035108041018247604,
-0.3297794461250305,
0.6053134202957153,
-0.3673967123031616,
-0.3506467640399933,
0.0156293623149395,
-0.45058152079582214,
0.40564456582069397,
0.4476507604122162,
-0.941216766834259,
0.6619490385055542,
0.30907177925109863,
0.01008710265159607,
-0.8302896618843079,
-0.6074231266975403,
0.22600634396076202,
-0.11565245687961578,
-0.31234610080718994,
0.5777209401130676,
-0.005698532331734896,
-0.13458052277565002,
-0.15634800493717194,
-0.2569713592529297,
-0.2859373390674591,
0.36851996183395386,
-0.024155667051672935,
0.007295721676200628,
-0.37469038367271423,
0.35620710253715515,
0.049523938447237015,
0.01358956377953291,
-0.44963690638542175,
-0.1818782538175583,
0.010410569608211517,
0.2927924692630768,
-0.16310426592826843,
-0.3401791751384735,
0.051171254366636276,
0.41916194558143616,
-0.060944925993680954,
0.7899806499481201,
0.21140678226947784,
-0.3148593306541443,
-0.04012887552380562,
-0.7092396020889282,
-0.33083200454711914,
-0.451738566160202,
0.543972909450531,
-0.2567497491836548,
-0.9183741807937622,
0.23758234083652496,
-0.42488986253738403,
0.10988206416368484,
0.10445252060890198,
0.04512130841612816,
-0.0012952589895576239,
0.683003306388855,
1.0735559463500977,
-0.22897575795650482,
0.726224958896637,
0.1786905825138092,
0.08560694009065628,
-1.0244897603988647,
-0.21098601818084717,
-0.6360973715782166,
-0.3040744960308075,
-0.6356460452079773,
-0.23777389526367188,
0.06306739151477814,
0.360963374376297,
-0.2509675920009613,
0.46885475516319275,
-0.40707284212112427,
0.5584263801574707,
0.4015890955924988,
0.46764400601387024,
0.525904655456543,
0.2760421633720398,
0.31884869933128357,
0.0357852540910244,
-0.6307374238967896,
-0.27422603964805603,
1.3218969106674194,
0.09869477152824402,
1.2831202745437622,
0.27498912811279297,
0.6078869104385376,
0.23668740689754486,
0.643329918384552,
-0.7776212096214294,
0.35736310482025146,
-0.4657628834247589,
-0.49651697278022766,
-0.04260613024234772,
-0.4081597328186035,
-1.1547497510910034,
0.32249337434768677,
-0.4320414364337921,
-0.7422503232955933,
0.3572719693183899,
0.0878526121377945,
-0.11965766549110413,
0.10330682247877121,
-0.8228131532669067,
0.42309266328811646,
-0.1538320630788803,
-0.17229235172271729,
-0.18779610097408295,
-0.2861376106739044,
0.11400750279426575,
-0.5417574644088745,
0.10049834102392197,
0.13239996135234833,
-0.11121314764022827,
0.9057923555374146,
0.10108736157417297,
0.6870889663696289,
-0.15135958790779114,
0.11052893102169037,
0.026334865018725395,
0.09220333397388458,
0.5777438879013062,
-0.1519092470407486,
-0.6061893105506897,
-0.1720493733882904,
-0.0628027617931366,
-0.22891941666603088,
-0.7222611904144287,
0.7961751818656921,
-0.7226600050926208,
-1.1049455404281616,
-0.007404644042253494,
-0.6114366054534912,
-0.14623765647411346,
0.5003822445869446,
-0.09848242253065109,
0.2520056366920471,
-0.2636015713214874,
0.5378633141517639,
0.6751330494880676,
-0.5992535948753357,
0.13128390908241272,
1.074436068534851,
-0.27310416102409363,
-0.308193176984787,
0.667128324508667,
0.1546020805835724,
0.15867605805397034,
0.7975302934646606,
0.07111537456512451,
-0.15096819400787354,
-0.6419970393180847,
-0.1289316713809967,
0.3666977286338806,
-0.7970418930053711,
-0.4785006046295166,
-0.5925756096839905,
-0.0015128821833059192,
-0.5801758170127869,
0.050351615995168686,
-0.39614611864089966,
-0.5137404203414917,
-0.5469192266464233,
-0.0925070121884346,
0.5845522880554199,
0.5652540922164917,
-0.08101733028888702,
0.24233455955982208,
-0.6695300340652466,
0.3912876546382904,
-0.0025705830194056034,
0.39781826734542847,
-0.20161744952201843,
-1.3192167282104492,
-0.1920030415058136,
0.044971272349357605,
-0.10912079364061356,
-0.5984352231025696,
0.4403237998485565,
0.6035833954811096,
0.6198664307594299,
-0.1066770926117897,
0.3980318307876587,
0.9280582070350647,
-0.5720660090446472,
0.16160614788532257,
-0.4004098176956177,
-0.49453580379486084,
0.6797268986701965,
-0.014845022931694984,
0.16718442738056183,
0.7533822059631348,
0.2894572913646698,
-0.0884779766201973,
-0.04013850539922714,
-0.1394376903772354,
-0.8410089612007141,
0.7735220789909363,
-0.0417926087975502,
0.2084801346063614,
0.17486421763896942,
1.1066224575042725,
0.10345590114593506,
0.08163852244615555,
-0.36214059591293335,
-0.1480349600315094,
-0.020293565467000008,
-0.06880936026573181,
-0.10360480099916458,
-0.4399004876613617,
0.13899032771587372,
-0.3148426115512848,
0.9472321271896362,
-0.06954356282949448,
0.3261181116104126,
0.44043204188346863,
-0.3904207646846771,
-0.1566486805677414,
0.38181987404823303,
0.5485581755638123,
0.7769978642463684,
-0.5837116837501526,
0.0519547276198864,
0.3196180760860443,
-0.4043024480342865,
0.08340698480606079,
0.07975540310144424,
-0.2087845653295517,
-0.10858695954084396,
0.11098194867372513,
0.5216712951660156,
0.38811635971069336,
-0.7001864910125732,
0.22133594751358032,
-0.3155101239681244,
0.002251542406156659,
-0.13902351260185242,
0.19419525563716888,
-0.06565656512975693,
0.487315833568573,
0.4860110580921173,
-0.16219140589237213,
0.24954359233379364,
-0.609525203704834,
0.5086997747421265,
0.5110864639282227,
-0.4845411479473114,
-0.09633464366197586,
0.4779835343360901,
-0.03292720392346382,
-0.5203784704208374,
0.9507147669792175,
0.3583248257637024,
-0.12228110432624817,
0.306618332862854,
0.9558077454566956,
0.6986569762229919,
-0.11863185465335846,
-0.06064322590827942,
0.4108756482601166,
0.38166487216949463,
-0.27966588735580444,
0.17913545668125153,
0.11378317326307297,
-0.8709414601325989,
-0.28233882784843445,
-0.38625991344451904,
-0.33364471793174744,
0.07488490641117096,
-0.8677397966384888,
0.2853776216506958,
-0.36588913202285767,
-0.19966064393520355,
0.09195873141288757,
-0.3251374661922455,
-0.5133749842643738,
0.15784229338169098,
-0.3563849925994873,
1.344881534576416,
-0.5991017818450928,
0.9227182865142822,
0.8101441264152527,
-0.23639796674251556,
-0.3537493646144867,
0.09518787264823914,
-0.5017439126968384,
-0.9969611763954163,
0.9879277944564819,
0.041924528777599335,
-0.3796301782131195,
0.31386899948120117,
-0.7450429797172546,
-0.9962592720985413,
1.2384954690933228,
0.6310350894927979,
-0.5186305046081543,
0.3016265332698822,
-0.08583838492631912,
0.5878058671951294,
-0.2784169614315033,
0.30832716822624207,
0.5937433242797852,
0.24180057644844055,
0.13585017621517181,
-0.7027525901794434,
-0.029377060011029243,
-0.022081835195422173,
0.0045320987701416016,
0.16581417620182037,
-0.38400188088417053,
0.34143245220184326,
-0.43278050422668457,
-0.3408186137676239,
0.4026870131492615,
0.6122469305992126,
0.12304921448230743,
0.1974451094865799,
0.1018218994140625,
0.4661993384361267,
0.7844239473342896,
0.15527978539466858,
1.0305967330932617,
-0.2551586627960205,
0.3126450181007385,
1.3363603353500366,
-0.2637476623058319,
1.2324885129928589,
0.6471907496452332,
0.23186643421649933,
0.26271283626556396,
0.38981765508651733,
-0.06542901694774628,
0.8226425051689148,
0.12164277583360672,
-0.10916534066200256,
-0.421537846326828,
-0.3310844898223877,
-0.26512768864631653,
0.3667386472225189,
0.1872919350862503,
-0.521423876285553,
-0.3645189106464386,
0.057271622121334076,
-0.22216691076755524,
-0.012858961708843708,
-0.27681460976600647,
0.8631240725517273,
-0.0061727967113256454,
-0.4773212671279907,
0.7099494338035583,
0.27207452058792114,
0.6503759622573853,
-0.12976060807704926,
-0.16731476783752441,
-0.4568523168563843,
0.5308194160461426,
-0.2215133160352707,
-0.6797512769699097,
0.13683760166168213,
0.021049516275525093,
-0.39401641488075256,
0.10578396916389465,
1.1669405698776245,
-0.22603590786457062,
-0.5566746592521667,
0.46674254536628723,
0.2874724864959717,
0.3469139635562897,
-0.06718617677688599,
-0.684251606464386,
-0.15319734811782837,
0.2434811294078827,
-0.2887982428073883,
0.528104841709137,
0.41573473811149597,
0.04427298158407211,
0.9926508665084839,
0.5740002989768982,
-0.3131018877029419,
-0.1663060337305069,
0.03555972874164581,
0.9956059455871582,
-0.9399896264076233,
0.237567737698555,
-0.7459509372711182,
0.116142638027668,
0.2786681056022644,
0.008006774820387363,
0.5389516949653625,
0.6899014115333557,
0.8678864240646362,
-0.25438594818115234,
0.6511157155036926,
0.42302045226097107,
0.632014811038971,
-0.5023122429847717,
0.6353441476821899,
-0.7686704397201538,
0.3299899995326996,
-0.28563278913497925,
-0.9195676445960999,
-0.6492924094200134,
0.4888979196548462,
-0.3132408559322357,
-0.03507425636053085,
0.10510630905628204,
1.1626458168029785,
-0.17767399549484253,
-0.24314986169338226,
0.48915836215019226,
0.31566765904426575,
0.2681863307952881,
0.34323254227638245,
0.750984251499176,
-0.9193203449249268,
0.5632345676422119,
0.07145784795284271,
-0.19411110877990723,
-0.3207562565803528,
-0.9582206010818481,
-0.8216793537139893,
-0.1938432902097702,
-0.32806840538978577,
-0.19712293148040771,
0.49463218450546265,
0.5965945720672607,
0.40844643115997314,
-0.7149863243103027,
0.03749450668692589,
0.25238102674484253,
0.10471007227897644,
0.27095821499824524,
-0.15906548500061035,
0.12916983664035797,
-0.15187032520771027,
-0.439268559217453,
0.6885707974433899,
0.274011492729187,
0.02556794323027134,
0.4277571141719818,
0.10717927664518356,
-0.41171297430992126,
0.00024440427660010755,
0.6176585555076599,
0.5785323977470398,
-0.48768097162246704,
-0.6057878136634827,
0.1960543841123581,
0.21669945120811462,
0.22884541749954224,
0.6973839402198792,
-0.9885714650154114,
0.5316068530082703,
0.4402809739112854,
1.088231086730957,
0.5105615854263306,
0.3996587097644806,
0.5320835709571838,
-0.663955569267273,
-0.028185037896037102,
-0.12353911995887756,
0.12697848677635193,
0.4584169387817383,
-0.27090176939964294,
0.5956335663795471,
0.040160540491342545,
-0.6518905758857727,
-0.8139553070068359,
0.10861103981733322,
-0.5617380142211914,
-0.35397395491600037,
1.2526051998138428,
-0.10442081093788147,
-0.2195087969303131,
-0.23012879490852356,
-0.15353092551231384,
0.36251136660575867,
-0.3119044601917267,
0.8812142610549927,
0.2919408977031708,
-0.13919149339199066,
-0.21609604358673096,
-0.3833816945552826,
-0.008215011097490788,
0.4163641929626465,
-0.5456823110580444,
0.2449934333562851,
0.2867444157600403,
0.6855335235595703,
0.029569486156105995,
0.4472823739051819,
-0.1117548793554306,
-0.10239122807979584,
-0.4673832952976227,
-0.01245902944356203,
-0.040378276258707047,
-0.2958298325538635,
-0.37133216857910156,
-0.2386857271194458,
0.49870145320892334,
-0.10710609704256058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14763v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14763v1 | A Learn-Then-Reason Model Towards Generalization in Knowledge Base Question Answering | 2024-06-20T22:22:41 | 2024-06-20T22:22:41 | Lingxi Zhang, Jing Zhang, Yanling Wang, Cuiping Li, Hong Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large-scale knowledge bases (KBs) like Freebase and Wikidata house millions
of structured knowledge. Knowledge Base Question Answering (KBQA) provides a
user-friendly way to access these valuable KBs via asking natural language
questions. In order to improve the generalization capabilities of KBQA models,
extensive research has embraced a retrieve-then-reason framework to retrieve
relevant evidence for logical expression generation. These multi-stage efforts
prioritize acquiring external sources but overlook the incorporation of new
knowledge into their model parameters. In effect, even advanced language models
and retrievers have knowledge boundaries, thereby limiting the generalization
capabilities of previous KBQA models. Therefore, this paper develops KBLLaMA,
which follows a learn-then-reason framework to inject new KB knowledge into a
large language model for flexible end-to-end KBQA. At the core of KBLLaMA, we
study (1) how to organize new knowledge about KBQA and (2) how to facilitate
the learning of the organized knowledge. Extensive experiments on various KBQA
generalization tasks showcase the state-of-the-art performance of KBLLaMA.
Especially on the general benchmark GrailQA and domain-specific benchmark
Bio-chemical, KBLLaMA respectively derives a performance gain of up to 3.8% and
9.8% compared to the baselines. | [
-0.41581782698631287,
-0.8664929866790771,
0.7855358719825745,
-0.08767785876989365,
-0.13572075963020325,
-0.06660054624080658,
-0.3271339535713196,
-0.32193607091903687,
-0.06362934410572052,
0.4866548776626587,
-0.5351133346557617,
-0.570345401763916,
-0.4920509159564972,
-0.17677880823612213,
-0.1527279019355774,
0.7485288381576538,
-0.06296148896217346,
0.1375018060207367,
-0.2630026638507843,
0.022610489279031754,
-0.5686507821083069,
-0.43173515796661377,
-0.3973264694213867,
-0.2805238962173462,
0.47661998867988586,
0.7376580834388733,
0.6248542070388794,
0.22158437967300415,
0.22643907368183136,
0.31419792771339417,
-0.10188404470682144,
0.4155808687210083,
-0.3000113070011139,
0.44708263874053955,
-0.35958683490753174,
-0.7237951755523682,
-0.19441038370132446,
-0.3015172779560089,
0.3541697561740875,
0.8567837476730347,
-0.07437516748905182,
0.21923606097698212,
-0.2610321044921875,
0.8072637319564819,
-0.5500797629356384,
0.3875114619731903,
-0.532807469367981,
-0.29691657423973083,
0.15860514342784882,
0.03207356482744217,
-0.5836895704269409,
-0.5609428882598877,
0.47857922315597534,
-0.9094159603118896,
-0.08154551684856415,
-0.021539928391575813,
0.8354074358940125,
-0.08121936768293381,
-0.6394897699356079,
-0.44178295135498047,
-0.49696338176727295,
0.7052634358406067,
-0.5722259879112244,
0.5996633172035217,
0.25992634892463684,
0.9735767841339111,
-0.2959393858909607,
-0.9453138709068298,
-0.5897125601768494,
-0.3552219867706299,
0.10461029410362244,
-0.05993632227182388,
-0.13992373645305634,
-0.018867678940296173,
0.01391785778105259,
0.23584720492362976,
-0.6069948673248291,
-0.3230764865875244,
-0.3696766495704651,
-0.22381071746349335,
0.2649458646774292,
0.061134323477745056,
0.27936676144599915,
-0.07714316248893738,
-0.06378082931041718,
-0.0639612153172493,
-0.7010438442230225,
0.37993863224983215,
-0.13787226378917694,
0.2154974639415741,
0.4232000410556793,
0.4424607753753662,
-0.735759973526001,
0.7724626064300537,
0.1337558925151825,
0.0013251402415335178,
-0.04769279062747955,
-0.04059639573097229,
-0.4938611686229706,
-0.2999046742916107,
0.2431844174861908,
0.3336530029773712,
0.4305330812931061,
-0.470912367105484,
0.19221016764640808,
0.03978266194462776,
0.29913094639778137,
-0.974712610244751,
-0.4055910110473633,
0.19492845237255096,
-0.5499690771102905,
-0.031371116638183594,
-0.34277573227882385,
-0.7191582918167114,
-0.328965425491333,
-0.3914988934993744,
0.6524248123168945,
-0.5017412304878235,
-0.4523782730102539,
0.3896371126174927,
-0.0902625024318695,
0.29304006695747375,
0.43286460638046265,
-0.8267069458961487,
0.13102157413959503,
0.4725509583950043,
0.3919568955898285,
0.29840072989463806,
0.19725070893764496,
-0.2410127818584442,
0.20413336157798767,
-0.5608641505241394,
0.816198468208313,
-0.4905984401702881,
-0.04481884464621544,
-0.24369849264621735,
-0.15667816996574402,
0.08479727804660797,
-0.7834364771842957,
0.19973964989185333,
-1.284016728401184,
0.38518279790878296,
-0.6786426305770874,
-0.6243617534637451,
-0.7387537360191345,
0.37995201349258423,
-0.36389029026031494,
0.46787136793136597,
0.4830743372440338,
-0.3429858088493347,
0.6055009961128235,
-0.6105789542198181,
-0.14222870767116547,
-0.024937616661190987,
-0.22165460884571075,
-0.07383536547422409,
-0.005321012809872627,
0.1876811385154724,
0.40000292658805847,
-0.6338100433349609,
0.6446654796600342,
-0.3460122346878052,
0.11415377259254456,
0.22608378529548645,
0.16030234098434448,
0.6184669733047485,
0.3536422848701477,
-0.3873971104621887,
0.0716225728392601,
-0.6174018979072571,
0.6237571835517883,
-0.034700941294431686,
-0.5749980211257935,
-0.4053610563278198,
-0.07348933070898056,
-0.2934440076351166,
0.48277100920677185,
0.10441175103187561,
-0.3574407994747162,
0.2313598245382309,
-0.48142215609550476,
0.17670506238937378,
0.6015805006027222,
0.10055390745401382,
0.6171197295188904,
-0.17526134848594666,
0.5241832137107849,
0.049569644033908844,
0.12898753583431244,
0.06400276720523834,
-0.6426067352294922,
-0.7621551752090454,
0.016948183998465538,
0.21534159779548645,
0.31800535321235657,
-0.786159873008728,
0.07880531251430511,
-0.15765735507011414,
-0.5789974927902222,
-0.3238128125667572,
0.3859138786792755,
0.3408716320991516,
0.9231890439987183,
0.6882951855659485,
0.08330895006656647,
-0.6446179747581482,
-1.1345329284667969,
-0.3139221966266632,
-0.3928609788417816,
-0.20967766642570496,
0.24280984699726105,
0.21422354876995087,
-0.4043567478656769,
1.1790893077850342,
-0.5164400935173035,
-0.03627338632941246,
-0.39547210931777954,
-0.01636473834514618,
0.47202739119529724,
0.12845177948474884,
0.4063502252101898,
-0.9644736647605896,
-0.3886485695838928,
0.034416086971759796,
-0.8621180057525635,
-0.2832646667957306,
0.17803071439266205,
-0.4379566013813019,
0.0795724093914032,
0.47402212023735046,
-0.825829803943634,
0.06818348169326782,
0.0624871589243412,
-0.5099578499794006,
0.6276568174362183,
0.10609286278486252,
0.2749900817871094,
-1.0385022163391113,
0.22267809510231018,
-0.30458155274391174,
-0.029441161081194878,
-0.8215049505233765,
0.4852537512779236,
0.3113676607608795,
0.23016943037509918,
-0.24851906299591064,
0.3575555384159088,
-0.4185933470726013,
0.24367748200893402,
-0.3555641174316406,
-0.05089990049600601,
0.21932481229305267,
0.5128257274627686,
0.050685033202171326,
0.45288994908332825,
0.3792804777622223,
-0.7596786618232727,
0.23157411813735962,
0.17055504024028778,
-0.475326806306839,
0.17049331963062286,
-0.5441011786460876,
-0.1693001389503479,
-0.3037508428096771,
0.1947127729654312,
-1.0280681848526,
-0.38750889897346497,
0.12700249254703522,
-0.5829899907112122,
0.2978321313858032,
-0.08029988408088684,
-0.36044782400131226,
-0.2550293207168579,
0.04626179486513138,
0.19370035827159882,
0.6129597425460815,
-0.4849923551082611,
0.8879902362823486,
0.4662620723247528,
-0.14499716460704803,
-0.49701976776123047,
-0.3476172685623169,
-0.22400516271591187,
-0.18161541223526,
-0.9768148064613342,
0.1235618069767952,
-0.22482697665691376,
-0.37631502747535706,
-0.08615273982286453,
-0.3409588038921356,
-0.17614732682704926,
0.17791405320167542,
0.10403581708669662,
0.07747119665145874,
-0.49192559719085693,
0.34567949175834656,
0.20698948204517365,
-0.01605350710451603,
0.358110636472702,
-0.5865238904953003,
0.5396875739097595,
-0.39406001567840576,
0.029928138479590416,
0.20688389241695404,
0.403910756111145,
0.40035250782966614,
0.13863198459148407,
0.7694877982139587,
0.29308879375457764,
-0.5227900743484497,
-0.17321349680423737,
-0.6400629281997681,
-0.235927551984787,
-0.46437782049179077,
0.4848431646823883,
-0.4046276807785034,
-1.1599252223968506,
0.35915639996528625,
-0.30897706747055054,
0.10896831750869751,
0.5646106004714966,
0.8211663365364075,
-0.21426425874233246,
0.8686777949333191,
0.5027683973312378,
0.11719372868537903,
-0.14629030227661133,
-0.23993034660816193,
0.2524811923503876,
-0.2950408458709717,
-0.6619294285774231,
-0.30487656593322754,
-0.1856655478477478,
-0.11911475658416748,
-0.5052216649055481,
0.38940367102622986,
0.6771546006202698,
-0.2519357204437256,
0.34256213903427124,
-0.24712646007537842,
0.43238377571105957,
0.48281511664390564,
0.061228372156620026,
0.1928698867559433,
-0.12162572890520096,
-0.4722617268562317,
0.14710967242717743,
-0.5588147640228271,
-0.319475919008255,
1.1514633893966675,
0.22319766879081726,
0.48947960138320923,
0.44970232248306274,
0.4655056893825531,
0.0873246118426323,
0.5839677453041077,
-0.7215895056724548,
0.6364342570304871,
0.27464839816093445,
-0.8081236481666565,
-0.3257335424423218,
-0.4445526897907257,
-0.7592557668685913,
0.4449654221534729,
-0.06036650016903877,
-0.593163788318634,
0.24670614302158356,
0.42849037051200867,
-0.3042835295200348,
0.04954169690608978,
-0.9926477670669556,
0.8462730050086975,
-0.02981683611869812,
-0.08614172041416168,
-0.2512533962726593,
-0.749563992023468,
0.5845233201980591,
-0.19396288692951202,
0.3019060492515564,
0.05778184533119202,
0.06001228094100952,
0.6467758417129517,
-0.4922714829444885,
0.42903944849967957,
-0.512147843837738,
-0.11536855250597,
0.4712633192539215,
0.12974384427070618,
0.23810888826847076,
0.054196856915950775,
0.13797159492969513,
-0.13548825681209564,
-0.024883510544896126,
-0.3284078538417816,
-0.8605383038520813,
0.4151737689971924,
-0.6222578287124634,
-0.9223986268043518,
0.059280864894390106,
-0.5686182379722595,
-0.6275959610939026,
0.3923400342464447,
0.23443683981895447,
0.05423881113529205,
0.25514206290245056,
0.41059908270835876,
0.9534410238265991,
-0.18468420207500458,
0.027238920331001282,
0.7762222290039062,
-0.5260729789733887,
-0.3313300311565399,
0.639741063117981,
0.09913239628076553,
0.2943127751350403,
0.7434558868408203,
0.32515835762023926,
-0.5092074871063232,
-0.47148948907852173,
-0.38453471660614014,
-0.08713599294424057,
-0.947756290435791,
-0.42089155316352844,
-0.9203789234161377,
-0.1402321755886078,
-0.6275121569633484,
-0.015642615035176277,
0.09801112860441208,
-0.7366670370101929,
0.06401442736387253,
-0.016997024416923523,
0.4019455015659332,
0.3257794678211212,
0.07232706248760223,
0.35620546340942383,
-0.7793622016906738,
0.6046516299247742,
0.6715849041938782,
0.11596674472093582,
0.15244519710540771,
-0.7007351517677307,
-0.37092554569244385,
-0.04629955068230629,
-0.33183157444000244,
-1.1420462131500244,
0.1214289739727974,
0.19429732859134674,
0.843730092048645,
0.46039435267448425,
-0.013189518824219704,
0.48426640033721924,
-0.31737494468688965,
0.2921221852302551,
0.0628357008099556,
-0.6808029413223267,
0.5937919616699219,
-0.39706557989120483,
0.41997167468070984,
0.6080939173698425,
0.5258560180664062,
-0.6600574254989624,
-0.2495632767677307,
-0.3918180465698242,
-1.0388174057006836,
0.38030797243118286,
-0.08345656096935272,
-0.3257007300853729,
0.017468351870775223,
0.43121299147605896,
0.1015210971236229,
0.34993642568588257,
-0.6980639100074768,
-0.17881713807582855,
-0.16489370167255402,
-0.20172210037708282,
0.22973954677581787,
-0.353832870721817,
0.07002262026071548,
-0.20587629079818726,
0.8101906776428223,
-0.2778834104537964,
0.12411358952522278,
-0.01994205266237259,
-0.673313558101654,
-0.08775286376476288,
0.5613537430763245,
0.26052653789520264,
0.8443546891212463,
-0.18648552894592285,
0.048496030271053314,
0.026236845180392265,
-0.2573257088661194,
0.23027153313159943,
-0.006071164272725582,
-0.1639535129070282,
-0.25307539105415344,
0.24750158190727234,
0.26679715514183044,
0.16808867454528809,
-0.8748295307159424,
0.3663099706172943,
0.07866878062486649,
-0.4193636178970337,
-0.02108832262456417,
0.33149075508117676,
0.5839731693267822,
0.5007884502410889,
0.5298471450805664,
-0.036195531487464905,
0.4119729995727539,
-0.41481590270996094,
0.32188910245895386,
0.42088577151298523,
0.1861291527748108,
-0.0530446395277977,
0.6316632628440857,
-0.2343180924654007,
0.15936818718910217,
0.5318524837493896,
0.006931360345333815,
-0.6038551330566406,
0.6326928734779358,
0.4021686315536499,
0.48026934266090393,
-0.39238977432250977,
0.2749825119972229,
0.36318808794021606,
0.39370736479759216,
0.1267634779214859,
0.68748539686203,
-0.3811764419078827,
-0.6727988719940186,
-0.5072053670883179,
-0.6869564056396484,
-0.23103776574134827,
0.27887463569641113,
-0.5682739615440369,
0.003452477278187871,
-0.48601198196411133,
-0.09956097602844238,
0.05524584278464317,
-0.13904507458209991,
-0.5678849220275879,
0.5572921633720398,
-0.04105601832270622,
1.2860136032104492,
-0.7487300038337708,
0.7120144367218018,
0.729832649230957,
-0.4035923182964325,
-0.9659990072250366,
-0.20717595517635345,
-0.21261727809906006,
-0.7934163808822632,
0.8763713240623474,
0.33767515420913696,
0.1329166144132614,
-0.2381286919116974,
-0.4035702645778656,
-1.0343183279037476,
1.11174476146698,
0.35854923725128174,
-0.5617960691452026,
-0.3234711289405823,
0.056788548827171326,
0.5661413669586182,
-0.20714394748210907,
0.22243832051753998,
0.6463211178779602,
0.4951239824295044,
0.010900267399847507,
-0.39247217774391174,
0.17242202162742615,
-0.44962775707244873,
-0.07832033187150955,
0.3580307066440582,
-0.4579903185367584,
0.6515644192695618,
-0.3653968572616577,
0.02839799039065838,
-0.08871109783649445,
0.8709622621536255,
0.6313160061836243,
0.2712498605251312,
0.6565148830413818,
0.5315740704536438,
0.6429463624954224,
0.017795180901885033,
0.5532321929931641,
-0.003511598566547036,
0.04660274088382721,
0.9504208564758301,
0.06140520051121712,
0.6957077383995056,
0.49026551842689514,
-0.11001276224851608,
0.8520607352256775,
0.7935310006141663,
0.370033323764801,
0.7889101505279541,
0.4803787171840668,
-0.2470797747373581,
-0.6038037538528442,
0.3004089295864105,
-0.5199970602989197,
0.21128642559051514,
0.6114067435264587,
-0.41336938738822937,
-0.4529423117637634,
-0.021312201395630836,
0.0005310496198944747,
-0.036215540021657944,
-0.43511760234832764,
0.6623020172119141,
0.05755509436130524,
-0.8549774289131165,
0.6536985039710999,
0.13622482120990753,
0.14228710532188416,
-0.8450846672058105,
-0.08918417245149612,
-0.13979005813598633,
0.05450671538710594,
-0.10273129492998123,
-0.4851617217063904,
0.19170702993869781,
-0.15489694476127625,
-0.6526016592979431,
-0.014163073152303696,
0.9293907880783081,
-0.49041101336479187,
-0.3120461106300354,
0.44859251379966736,
0.5057325959205627,
-0.025027113035321236,
-0.24732020497322083,
-0.4091394543647766,
-0.6000881195068359,
0.00952536053955555,
-0.48901164531707764,
0.3820403516292572,
0.4211330711841583,
-0.3829875886440277,
0.8923800587654114,
0.731433629989624,
-0.09154912084341049,
0.24797363579273224,
-0.029193146154284477,
1.0677106380462646,
-0.41366487741470337,
-0.6798624992370605,
-0.6305052638053894,
0.4526720345020294,
0.09248407930135727,
0.0005534119554795325,
0.5756377577781677,
0.3917911946773529,
0.5906872749328613,
-0.17311455309391022,
0.6870411038398743,
-0.22200508415699005,
0.6934000253677368,
-0.6192687153816223,
0.7639012336730957,
-0.6596037745475769,
0.07346028089523315,
-0.17810918390750885,
-0.6720077395439148,
-0.1673709899187088,
0.5090116858482361,
-0.2973923981189728,
0.24808232486248016,
0.6099810600280762,
0.7468297481536865,
0.15913712978363037,
0.18310321867465973,
0.40575966238975525,
0.36623063683509827,
0.3230322599411011,
0.9020885229110718,
0.8681141138076782,
-0.1377633959054947,
0.7313327193260193,
-0.06751865148544312,
-0.4473961591720581,
-0.20583173632621765,
-0.6513478755950928,
-0.6116091012954712,
-0.6046745777130127,
0.015395654365420341,
-0.5406100153923035,
-0.06619171053171158,
0.7423558235168457,
0.7498534321784973,
-0.9467326998710632,
0.025320356711745262,
-0.1243683397769928,
-0.007158436346799135,
-0.04683249443769455,
-0.2620489001274109,
0.35827070474624634,
-0.5160936713218689,
-0.0661379024386406,
0.5137872099876404,
0.2357681691646576,
-0.3812122642993927,
-0.04011101275682449,
-0.19492672383785248,
-0.1850370317697525,
0.009514272212982178,
0.6870548129081726,
0.39691591262817383,
-0.6435825228691101,
-0.10273154079914093,
0.24750512838363647,
0.14916697144508362,
-0.21473760902881622,
0.9116624593734741,
-0.9722378849983215,
0.5670244693756104,
0.48919546604156494,
1.103724718093872,
0.3026496469974518,
-0.22727862000465393,
0.6232267022132874,
-0.5806209444999695,
-0.43427056074142456,
0.06800299882888794,
0.3045196831226349,
0.049618061631917953,
-0.41820958256721497,
0.27363330125808716,
0.1083538830280304,
-0.585049033164978,
-0.4344460070133209,
0.2882263660430908,
-0.7442355155944824,
-0.4968334436416626,
1.0313597917556763,
-0.1841612160205841,
-0.03357179835438728,
-0.43438035249710083,
-0.053528741002082825,
0.3437037467956543,
-0.21993973851203918,
0.8905667066574097,
0.8299136757850647,
-0.106548972427845,
-0.1753997504711151,
-0.4139324426651001,
0.5197585821151733,
0.568687915802002,
-1.0489429235458374,
-0.022460784763097763,
0.6604289412498474,
0.5596397519111633,
0.17398077249526978,
0.9182482361793518,
-0.060589227825403214,
0.7099599838256836,
-0.4682585895061493,
-0.16517142951488495,
-0.04355911538004875,
-0.5510545969009399,
-0.02818235382437706,
0.3826761245727539,
0.1461307406425476,
-0.018321288749575615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14760v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14760v1 | An LLM Feature-based Framework for Dialogue Constructiveness Assessment | 2024-06-20T22:10:52 | 2024-06-20T22:10:52 | Lexin Zhou, Youmna Farag, Andreas Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Research on dialogue constructiveness assessment focuses on (i) analysing
conversational factors that influence individuals to take specific actions, win
debates, change their perspectives or broaden their open-mindedness and (ii)
predicting constructive outcomes following dialogues for such use cases. These
objectives can be achieved by training either interpretable feature-based
models (which often involve costly human annotations) or neural models such as
pre-trained language models (which have empirically shown higher task accuracy
but lack interpretability). We propose a novel LLM feature-based framework that
combines the strengths of feature-based and neural approaches while mitigating
their downsides, in assessing dialogue constructiveness. The framework first
defines a set of dataset-independent and interpretable linguistic features,
which can be extracted by both prompting an LLM and simple heuristics. Such
features are then used to train LLM feature-based models. We apply this
framework to three datasets of dialogue constructiveness and find that our LLM
feature-based models significantly outperform standard feature-based models and
neural models, and tend to learn more robust prediction rules instead of
relying on superficial shortcuts (as seen with neural models). Further, we
demonstrate that interpreting these LLM feature-based models can yield valuable
insights into what makes a dialogue constructive. | [
-0.5576333999633789,
-0.5552436709403992,
0.5277574062347412,
0.24812115728855133,
-0.23828600347042084,
0.28411734104156494,
-0.4175415337085724,
-0.41305750608444214,
0.4265156686306,
0.40842732787132263,
-0.6165343523025513,
-0.26879310607910156,
-0.6423545479774475,
0.0605660006403923,
-0.25055211782455444,
0.9090909361839294,
0.07225602120161057,
0.2814160883426666,
-0.24147528409957886,
-0.394327849149704,
-0.4873574376106262,
-0.3378249406814575,
-0.2879643738269806,
-0.5174823999404907,
0.6991884708404541,
0.049954671412706375,
0.6450542211532593,
0.23314686119556427,
0.40907803177833557,
0.34200164675712585,
-0.35834068059921265,
-0.1479152888059616,
-0.5592405200004578,
0.12659433484077454,
-0.28613319993019104,
-0.3218785524368286,
-0.3881862759590149,
0.3240987956523895,
0.2852279841899872,
0.6417913436889648,
-0.21320480108261108,
0.13546864688396454,
0.31961748003959656,
0.20722626149654388,
-0.4500066339969635,
0.31842225790023804,
-0.9217416644096375,
0.034598447382450104,
0.1940653771162033,
-0.19066490232944489,
-0.15704216063022614,
-0.4339979290962219,
0.1745363175868988,
-0.2244897484779358,
0.2746906280517578,
-0.4065236747264862,
0.569821834564209,
0.2561233341693878,
-0.18827508389949799,
-0.25880908966064453,
-0.5267995595932007,
0.5437906980514526,
-0.9831280708312988,
0.1787809133529663,
0.030071178451180458,
0.19861142337322235,
0.019641833379864693,
-0.4995431900024414,
-0.6142680048942566,
-0.4082707166671753,
-0.027736080810427666,
0.14397764205932617,
0.10877103358507156,
0.24544692039489746,
0.2980756461620331,
0.4750746190547943,
-0.00012291947496123612,
0.22343827784061432,
-0.017293788492679596,
-0.34068161249160767,
0.585554838180542,
0.27947041392326355,
-0.10826320946216583,
-0.3132934868335724,
-0.579302966594696,
0.10599543154239655,
-0.5103225111961365,
0.5562867522239685,
0.07460665702819824,
0.4922948479652405,
-0.049678921699523926,
0.4090343415737152,
-0.3637957274913788,
0.2519260048866272,
-0.012757351621985435,
-0.2666144371032715,
0.10880563408136368,
-0.3666369616985321,
-0.22538037598133087,
-0.12876231968402863,
0.7892976403236389,
0.40866634249687195,
-0.11417476087808609,
-0.12565983831882477,
-0.38541704416275024,
0.3309687077999115,
0.25560739636421204,
-1.0186328887939453,
-0.06755926460027695,
0.05711020901799202,
-0.555212140083313,
-0.7846547961235046,
-0.07476285845041275,
-0.5277458429336548,
-0.502741813659668,
-0.39278683066368103,
0.18873904645442963,
-0.06258492916822433,
-0.3852877616882324,
-0.1929139345884323,
0.19396831095218658,
0.13426949083805084,
0.6818238496780396,
-0.6849583983421326,
0.3394125998020172,
0.8510271310806274,
0.6366704702377319,
-0.21513740718364716,
0.002604966750368476,
-0.4449220895767212,
-0.5522750616073608,
-0.2942337095737457,
0.7281290292739868,
-0.752256453037262,
-0.15365709364414215,
0.06525184214115143,
-0.11055959761142731,
-0.0002091459755320102,
-0.6034818291664124,
0.7398800253868103,
-0.37435194849967957,
0.2848816215991974,
-0.152747243642807,
-0.41539010405540466,
-0.696330189704895,
0.6573538184165955,
-0.6787006855010986,
0.8259755969047546,
0.3385864198207855,
-0.5887221693992615,
0.5214704871177673,
-0.44827187061309814,
-0.024384306743741035,
0.13954497873783112,
-0.44644150137901306,
-0.3573344349861145,
0.4515431821346283,
0.04495544359087944,
0.49230366945266724,
-0.5595637559890747,
0.7912725210189819,
-0.6464647650718689,
-0.322750061750412,
0.7948111891746521,
-0.7820739150047302,
0.4726979434490204,
0.09493469446897507,
-0.4404393434524536,
0.3921065926551819,
-0.6549443006515503,
0.20616796612739563,
-0.18289168179035187,
-0.3598394989967346,
0.20678484439849854,
-0.018254918977618217,
-0.14150570333003998,
0.3632659912109375,
0.08761344105005264,
-0.6251087784767151,
-0.026750735938549042,
-0.49681103229522705,
0.507020115852356,
0.6948164701461792,
0.05109618231654167,
0.2054750919342041,
-0.5218096971511841,
0.6817142963409424,
0.16001294553279877,
0.022678369656205177,
-0.15968160331249237,
-0.5301990509033203,
-0.6654791235923767,
-0.5218530297279358,
0.32562607526779175,
0.7485013604164124,
-0.6150782704353333,
0.5134991407394409,
-0.19802361726760864,
-0.4908711016178131,
-0.6533963084220886,
0.5682239532470703,
0.5649536848068237,
0.4506540894508362,
0.0795888602733612,
-1.0407990217208862,
-0.2805905044078827,
-0.649350643157959,
-0.13792625069618225,
-0.4431840479373932,
-0.10151740163564682,
0.5380435585975647,
0.19266873598098755,
-0.030721768736839294,
0.7027233839035034,
0.030957913026213646,
-0.18094439804553986,
-0.38136520981788635,
0.27423086762428284,
0.43863242864608765,
0.10228196531534195,
0.05316121131181717,
-0.6152761578559875,
-0.15149328112602234,
-0.18426474928855896,
-0.8112108707427979,
-0.2972830533981323,
-0.3803964853286743,
0.2089012712240219,
-0.15352082252502441,
0.22689160704612732,
-0.643605649471283,
0.662570595741272,
0.19652700424194336,
-0.3526923954486847,
0.35808277130126953,
0.3146955668926239,
0.139268159866333,
-0.8229681849479675,
-0.05084117874503136,
0.04864122346043587,
-0.16568636894226074,
-0.4887247085571289,
-0.007983697578310966,
-0.3327053487300873,
-0.17415359616279602,
-0.425525039434433,
0.3395335376262665,
-0.0381474643945694,
-0.01842287927865982,
-0.18714946508407593,
0.2294960618019104,
0.1345979869365692,
0.85286545753479,
-0.025981049984693527,
0.5926386713981628,
0.10974116623401642,
-0.12175483256578445,
0.3904755711555481,
0.26868966221809387,
-0.6066160798072815,
0.4655337929725647,
-0.6057389378547668,
0.2879650890827179,
0.1805599182844162,
-0.026896901428699493,
-1.084987998008728,
0.14690586924552917,
0.06488455832004547,
-0.41767898201942444,
0.17286865413188934,
-0.06514091044664383,
0.06275100260972977,
0.013489621691405773,
-0.5024509429931641,
0.36208465695381165,
0.2172359973192215,
-0.39002475142478943,
1.0118857622146606,
0.05355336144566536,
-0.6888469457626343,
-0.6129952073097229,
-0.20544543862342834,
0.27622634172439575,
-0.37166979908943176,
-0.7364161014556885,
0.4195374846458435,
-0.1686718463897705,
-0.24555976688861847,
-0.09224444627761841,
0.14210759103298187,
0.11362656205892563,
0.44369634985923767,
0.49376991391181946,
0.2664804458618164,
-0.25424641370773315,
-0.2548474967479706,
-0.3374871015548706,
-0.16171839833259583,
0.25839948654174805,
0.24621358513832092,
0.3562706410884857,
-0.2912972569465637,
-0.34500953555107117,
-0.6533694863319397,
0.174358069896698,
0.6664047241210938,
-0.14427614212036133,
0.31127241253852844,
0.504657506942749,
-0.10116888582706451,
-0.0713607594370842,
-0.7947395443916321,
-0.2773474454879761,
-0.4461728632450104,
0.5024665594100952,
-0.36378222703933716,
-1.1369835138320923,
0.8352488875389099,
-0.3518344461917877,
0.09114379435777664,
0.09285308420658112,
0.8522239923477173,
-0.1004989892244339,
0.9385159015655518,
0.691615104675293,
-0.16955387592315674,
0.5725796222686768,
-0.08740543574094772,
0.40174445509910583,
-0.989043116569519,
-0.4612257480621338,
-0.34069156646728516,
-0.39303284883499146,
-0.5948786735534668,
-0.5351430177688599,
0.1814177930355072,
0.2885296642780304,
-0.08477190881967545,
0.03337172418832779,
-0.4014158248901367,
0.08301188051700592,
0.16471555829048157,
0.14756560325622559,
0.2700914144515991,
-0.11327222734689713,
-0.3004412055015564,
-0.28036436438560486,
-0.5257328748703003,
-0.5701709985733032,
0.9140558242797852,
0.6766483187675476,
0.7197625637054443,
0.31250476837158203,
0.6082367300987244,
0.279330313205719,
0.9147706627845764,
-1.2424343824386597,
0.7020205855369568,
0.2565625309944153,
-0.3107134699821472,
-0.177625373005867,
-0.5140953063964844,
-0.49281981587409973,
0.24569478631019592,
-0.5662649273872375,
-0.5900676250457764,
0.09929926693439484,
-0.07719099521636963,
-0.3299296200275421,
0.17021986842155457,
-0.5192307829856873,
0.7173814177513123,
-0.36165326833724976,
-0.5582605600357056,
-0.1780073195695877,
-0.24317239224910736,
0.3770131468772888,
-0.008338014595210552,
0.07378576695919037,
-0.26462849974632263,
-0.06010798364877701,
0.6140967607498169,
-0.20249299705028534,
1.107155442237854,
-0.3846781849861145,
-0.014163769781589508,
0.3512380123138428,
0.365624338388443,
0.327210009098053,
0.3628450036048889,
-0.1741475760936737,
0.2300560623407364,
-0.22464536130428314,
-0.1274326890707016,
-1.2557042837142944,
0.41628915071487427,
-0.6275137066841125,
-0.9276817440986633,
-0.1852865368127823,
-0.3469144105911255,
-0.2563997507095337,
-0.1883392184972763,
-0.1809467226266861,
0.47807246446609497,
-0.6081693172454834,
0.17062731087207794,
0.5054035186767578,
-0.06004387140274048,
0.33029407262802124,
0.47783687710762024,
-0.28997859358787537,
-0.7760186791419983,
0.8856552243232727,
-0.13122709095478058,
0.3108668327331543,
0.10064738243818283,
0.2965696454048157,
-0.33967331051826477,
-0.9131783246994019,
-0.28466346859931946,
-0.13499215245246887,
-0.6444641351699829,
-0.3454399108886719,
-0.23031406104564667,
-0.4544242024421692,
-0.04149105027318001,
0.007921655662357807,
-0.1946166753768921,
-0.6402010917663574,
-0.14099714159965515,
-0.29223397374153137,
0.14868618547916412,
0.8257086277008057,
0.1489192694425583,
0.03365705907344818,
-0.582535982131958,
-0.03099074587225914,
0.43634048104286194,
0.3870244026184082,
0.02990374155342579,
-0.7766841650009155,
-0.036830708384513855,
-0.09267225861549377,
-0.7127914428710938,
-0.5841882228851318,
0.35793399810791016,
0.24721108376979828,
0.5753506422042847,
0.5401960015296936,
-0.17810671031475067,
0.3074982464313507,
-0.24727918207645416,
1.0025686025619507,
0.48358073830604553,
-0.7737181186676025,
0.41845038533210754,
-0.1320304125547409,
0.04985404759645462,
0.9022234082221985,
0.17142915725708008,
-0.2828313410282135,
-0.3090435266494751,
-0.6752120852470398,
-0.4884802997112274,
0.2992362082004547,
0.13462278246879578,
0.41246291995048523,
0.01708987168967724,
0.3496246337890625,
0.09692829847335815,
0.3048005998134613,
-0.9090808033943176,
0.3558133840560913,
-0.5431317687034607,
-0.33919674158096313,
-0.029930412769317627,
-0.4343841075897217,
-0.4755752980709076,
-0.24620306491851807,
0.4610354006290436,
-0.5040459036827087,
0.21795496344566345,
0.15100088715553284,
0.02534935437142849,
0.07681795209646225,
0.5605809688568115,
0.57948237657547,
0.4303341805934906,
-0.3276989758014679,
-0.08993600308895111,
0.46555522084236145,
-0.22519096732139587,
0.2866264581680298,
0.11556356400251389,
-0.1274181604385376,
-0.11160624772310257,
0.5401383638381958,
0.8023713231086731,
0.310634970664978,
-0.5848613381385803,
0.7872663736343384,
-0.286248117685318,
-0.22651274502277374,
-0.14982222020626068,
0.17726406455039978,
0.03894607350230217,
0.5569737553596497,
-0.04780573770403862,
0.29728832840919495,
0.11692251265048981,
-0.6629092693328857,
0.09926539659500122,
0.48921772837638855,
-0.8281578421592712,
-0.3581496775150299,
0.18535839021205902,
0.6567564606666565,
-0.4741669297218323,
0.47318580746650696,
-0.22581170499324799,
-0.8611279129981995,
0.47402042150497437,
0.17013102769851685,
1.2314951419830322,
-0.05415424332022667,
0.17388314008712769,
0.181740403175354,
0.18138454854488373,
0.31559163331985474,
0.41723936796188354,
-0.47424644231796265,
-1.0967506170272827,
-0.4979653060436249,
-0.6895329356193542,
-0.611366331577301,
0.24049769341945648,
-0.7534793019294739,
0.08009661734104156,
-0.865864098072052,
-0.31411755084991455,
-0.06962145864963531,
0.10947968065738678,
-0.6827000975608826,
0.13152976334095,
0.1965164840221405,
1.0268619060516357,
-0.6248335242271423,
0.6038079857826233,
0.31405216455459595,
-0.30355918407440186,
-0.7703922390937805,
-0.2752467393875122,
0.22340352833271027,
-0.831417977809906,
0.7493891716003418,
0.32899460196495056,
-0.28146642446517944,
-0.5893895030021667,
-0.366788774728775,
-0.5453616976737976,
1.0374345779418945,
0.4017353951931,
-0.6108908653259277,
0.047701992094516754,
0.14540709555149078,
0.5610664486885071,
-0.8755585551261902,
0.6352623105049133,
0.5284867286682129,
0.07886821776628494,
0.3086605966091156,
-0.90076744556427,
0.1874629706144333,
-0.6404681205749512,
0.2284775823354721,
-0.13073888421058655,
-0.5515276789665222,
0.37814387679100037,
-0.29908284544944763,
-0.05972367152571678,
0.27726373076438904,
0.7372124195098877,
0.12744487822055817,
0.43111652135849,
0.6184395551681519,
0.7298633456230164,
0.6119044423103333,
-0.251906156539917,
0.6200317740440369,
-0.4779481589794159,
0.16988138854503632,
1.2010302543640137,
-0.4569474458694458,
1.0684161186218262,
0.26313790678977966,
0.09280850738286972,
0.8258448839187622,
0.4305943548679352,
-0.006615327671170235,
0.5643938779830933,
0.38969844579696655,
-0.6331135034561157,
-0.4018118977546692,
-0.44620004296302795,
0.014267871156334877,
0.7988171577453613,
0.5434876084327698,
-0.5366501212120056,
-0.035002756863832474,
-0.0772663950920105,
-0.0852619931101799,
0.3079789876937866,
-0.13948164880275726,
1.2267444133758545,
0.2947919964790344,
-0.6843697428703308,
0.6372770071029663,
-0.08316093683242798,
0.8125191926956177,
-0.4200785756111145,
-0.18782080709934235,
-0.22121141850948334,
-0.04314794763922691,
-0.29216209053993225,
-0.8495598435401917,
0.13532458245754242,
0.09198576956987381,
-0.1538422703742981,
-0.2810291647911072,
0.6201883554458618,
-0.3576106131076813,
-0.4453544318675995,
0.42502689361572266,
0.5028706192970276,
-0.13915272057056427,
0.10768377780914307,
-0.9540020823478699,
0.29640090465545654,
0.10965894907712936,
-0.29477542638778687,
0.3145979940891266,
0.5781899094581604,
0.008343035355210304,
0.6710103750228882,
0.6092081069946289,
0.2772209644317627,
-0.48141592741012573,
0.49189114570617676,
1.2341548204421997,
-0.8702532649040222,
-0.18491818010807037,
-0.5280703902244568,
0.6850644946098328,
-0.18409596383571625,
-0.4321027994155884,
0.13094234466552734,
0.2596694231033325,
0.720470666885376,
0.5689281821250916,
0.7881113886833191,
0.12709762156009674,
0.5798574090003967,
-0.667331337928772,
0.4753895103931427,
-0.12354016304016113,
0.6951503753662109,
-0.11801356822252274,
-0.9679540991783142,
0.08808913826942444,
0.6769679188728333,
-0.3460800349712372,
0.2930220365524292,
0.46487632393836975,
1.1256978511810303,
0.11057548969984055,
0.5112070441246033,
0.38872283697128296,
0.29239892959594727,
0.5571679472923279,
0.7153339982032776,
1.340736746788025,
-0.10221783816814423,
0.24671420454978943,
-0.39390334486961365,
-0.46368321776390076,
-0.03810863941907883,
-1.0114375352859497,
-1.1300828456878662,
-0.31623825430870056,
-0.30438563227653503,
-0.4795047640800476,
-0.4380224943161011,
1.0455981492996216,
0.6626781225204468,
-0.7036686539649963,
-0.1713458001613617,
0.16494692862033844,
0.09009374678134918,
-0.04384827986359596,
-0.27048009634017944,
-0.10174501687288284,
-0.34522226452827454,
-0.10953497141599655,
0.5400370955467224,
0.3945523202419281,
-0.23769432306289673,
-0.61626136302948,
-0.18454885482788086,
0.15958759188652039,
0.3544577956199646,
0.59770667552948,
0.03744783625006676,
-0.9728736281394958,
-0.4505279064178467,
-0.16548430919647217,
-0.03631238266825676,
0.16303741931915283,
0.965421199798584,
-0.9680332541465759,
0.5565732717514038,
0.26462846994400024,
0.7408302426338196,
0.419857919216156,
-0.004548404365777969,
0.579855740070343,
-0.41279518604278564,
0.1981351226568222,
0.619992196559906,
0.28087547421455383,
0.5760464668273926,
-0.3552316725254059,
0.4602714776992798,
0.31329604983329773,
-0.2649504840373993,
-0.7235001921653748,
0.265744686126709,
-1.118255376815796,
0.13317932188510895,
0.6728180646896362,
-0.600753664970398,
-0.014002067968249321,
-0.0628376379609108,
-0.13136456906795502,
-0.17137491703033447,
-0.3351401388645172,
1.0600805282592773,
0.6779047846794128,
-0.2570372521877289,
-0.42788165807724,
-0.36386048793792725,
0.5808002352714539,
0.6709136962890625,
-0.6485270261764526,
0.11820031702518463,
0.23870524764060974,
0.3408765196800232,
0.3432190716266632,
0.4106581509113312,
-0.16016189754009247,
0.3162861466407776,
-0.1555521935224533,
-0.0987975001335144,
-0.23829112946987152,
-0.45350226759910583,
-0.4804156720638275,
0.24029718339443207,
0.4724087715148926,
0.5718883872032166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15516v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15516v1 | System Description for the Displace Speaker Diarization Challenge 2023 | 2024-06-20T21:40:02 | 2024-06-20T21:40:02 | Ali Aliyev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper describes our solution for the Diarization of Speaker and Language
in Conversational Environments Challenge (Displace 2023). We used a combination
of VAD for finding segfments with speech, Resnet architecture based CNN for
feature extraction from these segments, and spectral clustering for features
clustering. Even though it was not trained with using Hindi, the described
algorithm achieves the following metrics: DER 27. 1% and DER 27. 4%, on the
development and phase-1 evaluation parts of the dataset, respectively. | [
-0.8857351541519165,
-0.9151100516319275,
0.14205656945705414,
0.2360844761133194,
-0.08460035920143127,
0.5479670763015747,
-0.08013913780450821,
-0.3699560761451721,
0.12968391180038452,
0.4850790202617645,
-0.5610864758491516,
-0.5307281017303467,
-0.5485547780990601,
0.05529448390007019,
-0.5871953964233398,
0.6004202961921692,
0.45766279101371765,
-0.06295409798622131,
-0.33159339427948,
0.09035831689834595,
-0.8350988030433655,
-0.5290232300758362,
-0.33375030755996704,
-0.33473432064056396,
0.14610108733177185,
0.8859384655952454,
0.27386096119880676,
0.6260778307914734,
0.6035048961639404,
0.5030261278152466,
-0.5611995458602905,
-0.005559504497796297,
-0.2809862196445465,
-0.10809090733528137,
0.10712749511003494,
0.00947658997029066,
-0.1905866265296936,
-0.1384410262107849,
0.7517606019973755,
0.9720140099525452,
-0.7735154032707214,
-0.06944265961647034,
-0.06465496867895126,
0.6095330715179443,
-0.21792060136795044,
0.174793541431427,
-0.6436625123023987,
0.32422858476638794,
-0.6198928952217102,
0.0007780329324305058,
-0.35575443506240845,
-0.1750839799642563,
0.40781402587890625,
-0.19811488687992096,
0.7322471141815186,
-0.06928978860378265,
0.8585506677627563,
0.5431236624717712,
-0.12658381462097168,
0.011278608813881874,
-1.1053465604782104,
0.6352428197860718,
-0.3724094033241272,
0.660003662109375,
0.3737475574016571,
0.4932982325553894,
-0.18628868460655212,
-0.5769369602203369,
-0.8669204711914062,
0.05420364439487457,
0.0708659216761589,
-0.11783046275377274,
-0.20708099007606506,
0.026541119441390038,
0.12437449395656586,
0.4737350046634674,
-0.5003640055656433,
0.32210153341293335,
-0.8126453161239624,
-0.13873068988323212,
0.746916651725769,
0.0489797368645668,
0.3960607945919037,
-0.3030056357383728,
-0.5311776399612427,
-0.1418856531381607,
-0.29409635066986084,
-0.29804787039756775,
0.17434881627559662,
0.5083349347114563,
-0.2635400891304016,
0.3388834595680237,
-0.03714071586728096,
0.830037534236908,
-0.04349382594227791,
-0.24377530813217163,
0.7280107736587524,
-0.1296558976173401,
-0.21559102833271027,
0.46284395456314087,
0.5969401597976685,
0.1099596917629242,
-0.04594309628009796,
-0.04371047765016556,
-0.012560155242681503,
-0.2460339367389679,
0.29542332887649536,
-0.2319938987493515,
-0.3121550679206848,
0.06191588565707207,
-0.3153421878814697,
-0.053488679230213165,
-0.12044168263673782,
-1.3891198635101318,
-0.5682521462440491,
-0.2908277213573456,
0.03252677246928215,
-0.5668609142303467,
-0.4290236532688141,
0.10232952982187271,
-0.28427979350090027,
0.20208396017551422,
0.26167669892311096,
-1.2899278402328491,
0.6704832315444946,
0.5386361479759216,
0.8576818704605103,
-0.3535896837711334,
-0.07869208604097366,
-0.09828099608421326,
-0.20819875597953796,
-0.10884776711463928,
0.7742131948471069,
-0.6456485390663147,
-0.8009493947029114,
-0.2638031542301178,
-0.004374699201434851,
-0.09494802355766296,
-0.8830452561378479,
0.3288099765777588,
-0.3443363904953003,
0.13574443757534027,
-0.026167085394263268,
-0.3170735836029053,
-0.06549639999866486,
0.11149779707193375,
-0.7063654065132141,
1.0206960439682007,
0.43204954266548157,
-0.6830015778541565,
0.2326480895280838,
-0.45118436217308044,
0.004288187250494957,
0.48892316222190857,
-0.2657965123653412,
-0.6013639569282532,
-0.14454281330108643,
0.15820515155792236,
0.1941632479429245,
-0.0940992459654808,
0.12771505117416382,
-0.009254018776118755,
-0.4128088653087616,
-0.08329933881759644,
-0.38653355836868286,
0.6736921668052673,
0.5000727772712708,
-0.338832825422287,
-0.25388118624687195,
-1.1297979354858398,
-0.2460416704416275,
0.23967580497264862,
-0.5274483561515808,
-0.1004958525300026,
0.2857472598552704,
0.02708646096289158,
-0.09681402146816254,
0.16442686319351196,
-0.8023563623428345,
0.039400119334459305,
-0.7267915606498718,
0.32296353578567505,
0.7763748168945312,
0.26429468393325806,
0.1996648609638214,
0.20105138421058655,
0.663266658782959,
0.3100726902484894,
0.11426621675491333,
0.21552813053131104,
-0.5395320057868958,
-0.9343726634979248,
-0.29719358682632446,
0.22493252158164978,
0.9024103879928589,
-0.7218196392059326,
0.5649816393852234,
-0.3125603497028351,
-0.7486730217933655,
-0.3325904905796051,
-0.0038337688893079758,
0.6611048579216003,
0.6032425761222839,
0.4171181619167328,
-0.09784980118274689,
-0.8230553865432739,
-1.1928057670593262,
0.6338008046150208,
-0.36575815081596375,
0.17462459206581116,
-0.10397825390100479,
0.15631736814975739,
-0.14551076292991638,
0.9398667812347412,
-0.48898735642433167,
-0.16289110481739044,
-0.18135705590248108,
0.0723131075501442,
-0.14047716557979584,
0.47495052218437195,
0.3233611285686493,
-1.3144524097442627,
-0.46614256501197815,
0.23593616485595703,
-0.4799934923648834,
-0.21335245668888092,
0.27404728531837463,
0.35192033648490906,
0.0017479999223724008,
0.9374302625656128,
-0.09081850945949554,
0.6637955904006958,
0.4642399549484253,
-0.013196664862334728,
0.32596173882484436,
-0.10647168010473251,
0.18918603658676147,
-1.1986100673675537,
-0.04991671442985535,
0.19018958508968353,
0.046780213713645935,
-0.7856885194778442,
-0.38134026527404785,
-0.4257955253124237,
-0.47389817237854004,
-0.6898757219314575,
0.11128256469964981,
-0.28491613268852234,
-0.04482700675725937,
0.006433664355427027,
0.5424858927726746,
-0.2818482220172882,
0.4706602692604065,
0.020011255517601967,
0.7017890214920044,
0.33566027879714966,
-0.6996241807937622,
0.9268797039985657,
0.8316152691841125,
-0.625891387462616,
0.7720223069190979,
-0.6480507254600525,
0.25268399715423584,
-0.18827039003372192,
-0.03784532472491264,
-1.2069897651672363,
-0.08482926338911057,
0.13737532496452332,
-0.43656980991363525,
0.3202929198741913,
0.054253481328487396,
-0.16233420372009277,
-0.7745076417922974,
0.21038757264614105,
0.4495666027069092,
0.4970494508743286,
-0.48226720094680786,
-0.039248786866664886,
0.8043777942657471,
-0.39936432242393494,
-0.4516339898109436,
-0.7531054615974426,
0.3353133797645569,
-0.6997091770172119,
-0.3081510663032532,
0.925033688545227,
-0.03946646302938461,
-0.49297913908958435,
-0.2514756917953491,
0.3143293559551239,
-0.056553930044174194,
0.06810559332370758,
0.2378511130809784,
0.04652068018913269,
0.07674184441566467,
0.07470452785491943,
-0.4828251302242279,
-0.358159601688385,
-0.2853170931339264,
0.284604549407959,
0.731039822101593,
-0.08790639787912369,
-0.6188710927963257,
-0.6502103209495544,
0.5502380728721619,
0.5975158214569092,
-0.3958473205566406,
0.47139739990234375,
0.6679787635803223,
-0.5286630988121033,
0.0752621442079544,
-0.6425008773803711,
0.22957837581634521,
-0.4986480176448822,
0.8082438707351685,
-0.35469770431518555,
-1.0148862600326538,
0.8040655255317688,
-0.19948410987854004,
-0.32005631923675537,
0.35373061895370483,
0.5324560403823853,
0.21391664445400238,
1.1289852857589722,
0.7972368001937866,
-0.07021679729223251,
0.5922906398773193,
-0.011899913661181927,
0.45856332778930664,
-0.9194139838218689,
-0.9780137538909912,
-0.9069454669952393,
-0.39929309487342834,
-0.7279451489448547,
-0.34215617179870605,
0.5821684002876282,
0.16371318697929382,
-0.011058744974434376,
0.4604589343070984,
-1.0280725955963135,
0.32305222749710083,
0.6022953987121582,
0.08573554456233978,
-0.2371581345796585,
0.029529526829719543,
0.058479227125644684,
-0.24714061617851257,
-0.43062925338745117,
-0.20164303481578827,
0.3339613080024719,
0.5085837244987488,
0.4219552278518677,
0.3304966688156128,
0.9440597891807556,
0.5383999347686768,
-0.3491300046443939,
-0.5883710384368896,
0.7443400621414185,
-0.11098089069128036,
-0.31376564502716064,
-0.7272429466247559,
-0.30722323060035706,
-1.062780499458313,
-0.019223464652895927,
0.13443352282047272,
-1.1968580484390259,
0.6675871014595032,
-0.287018746137619,
-0.28634652495384216,
0.09644581377506256,
-0.795506477355957,
0.7492577433586121,
0.053899820894002914,
0.38619059324264526,
-0.20857426524162292,
-0.729748010635376,
0.08822876960039139,
-0.16390128433704376,
0.2539982795715332,
-0.15644091367721558,
0.33897483348846436,
0.9164429306983948,
-0.6544139385223389,
0.8048182725906372,
-0.5152583122253418,
-0.064018614590168,
0.5006542801856995,
-0.1518893539905548,
0.09617435932159424,
-0.13157439231872559,
-0.1778249591588974,
0.057555701583623886,
0.022591181099414825,
-0.3499883711338043,
-0.5295484662055969,
0.5795039534568787,
-0.7167519330978394,
-0.756034255027771,
-0.23091188073158264,
-0.02292749285697937,
-0.34977787733078003,
-0.0687745213508606,
0.1876785159111023,
0.38481467962265015,
-0.6988945007324219,
0.2985861301422119,
0.8901083469390869,
-0.4738117456436157,
0.7119427919387817,
0.5546083450317383,
-0.05772723630070686,
-0.6716415882110596,
1.1942895650863647,
0.0632895976305008,
0.209934800863266,
0.3739685118198395,
0.029891809448599815,
-0.35021233558654785,
-0.7752777934074402,
-0.3918149769306183,
-0.004365516826510429,
-0.6089878678321838,
-0.11906233429908752,
-0.45096489787101746,
-0.7253416180610657,
-0.5815761685371399,
0.1474754363298416,
-0.4414600133895874,
-0.08160600066184998,
-0.3414555490016937,
-0.3290312886238098,
0.1869327276945114,
0.8808777332305908,
-0.194906085729599,
0.3876870274543762,
-0.6735649108886719,
0.15969741344451904,
0.5142986178398132,
0.182540163397789,
-0.17157377302646637,
-0.6191620826721191,
-0.5032358169555664,
-0.022356055676937103,
-0.48605915904045105,
-0.7999231219291687,
0.5250365734100342,
0.3618670105934143,
0.8083353042602539,
0.30381345748901367,
-0.1486782431602478,
0.9616682529449463,
-0.6678056716918945,
1.2509593963623047,
0.22424034774303436,
-0.8149295449256897,
0.9427124261856079,
-0.17219848930835724,
0.26452335715293884,
0.4433593153953552,
0.26905983686447144,
-0.831084132194519,
-0.16740107536315918,
-0.6938410401344299,
-0.7636926770210266,
0.9208041429519653,
0.05196946859359741,
0.09635722637176514,
-0.5597981810569763,
0.1906721591949463,
-0.20210804045200348,
-0.06901626288890839,
-0.22889234125614166,
-0.31115230917930603,
-0.057787179946899414,
0.019897283986210823,
-0.13331609964370728,
-0.5371852517127991,
-0.07023508846759796,
-0.4716291129589081,
0.4076994061470032,
0.28229525685310364,
0.36421260237693787,
0.1936376392841339,
0.39471906423568726,
0.19320297241210938,
0.2409278303384781,
0.8585024476051331,
0.3425101041793823,
-0.2474406212568283,
0.19715218245983124,
0.4680420160293579,
-0.5626769065856934,
0.3419208228588104,
0.07918762415647507,
0.38438865542411804,
0.0030862619169056416,
0.2558373212814331,
0.7872286438941956,
-0.02138337679207325,
-0.6350250840187073,
0.4417882561683655,
-0.0023624037858098745,
-0.3389780521392822,
-0.48391857743263245,
0.0067338962107896805,
0.06085468456149101,
0.24004033207893372,
0.4208747148513794,
0.07888063043355942,
-0.0017310891998931766,
-0.10239197313785553,
0.6120510697364807,
0.030992524698376656,
-0.8255356550216675,
-0.35579317808151245,
0.4503541886806488,
0.45365506410598755,
-0.892801821231842,
1.0095679759979248,
-0.4234442710876465,
-0.5932067632675171,
0.6760313510894775,
0.7142916321754456,
0.785372257232666,
-0.8199226260185242,
0.4027346074581146,
0.2408258020877838,
0.027387743815779686,
0.21830898523330688,
0.1381530910730362,
-0.06436923146247864,
-0.9146473407745361,
-0.19327996671199799,
-0.8643673062324524,
-0.18831570446491241,
0.4208983778953552,
-0.6849122047424316,
0.5579892992973328,
-0.3818889558315277,
-0.05644341930747032,
0.21414819359779358,
-0.200633242726326,
-0.3635886013507843,
0.355938583612442,
0.6598641276359558,
0.685163676738739,
-0.8732765316963196,
0.6636350750923157,
0.487237811088562,
-0.23424705862998962,
-0.4200393855571747,
-0.38295963406562805,
0.40479788184165955,
-0.6896418929100037,
0.6527488827705383,
-0.21834810078144073,
-0.04214589670300484,
0.1923251748085022,
-0.2264268547296524,
-0.9019625186920166,
1.1118711233139038,
0.409209668636322,
-0.5519223213195801,
0.14858132600784302,
0.3702857494354248,
0.5290123224258423,
-0.22089017927646637,
-0.09197627007961273,
0.761108934879303,
0.5459993481636047,
0.4461944103240967,
-1.3867396116256714,
-0.5943183302879333,
-0.5870213508605957,
0.3082053065299988,
0.16223116219043732,
-0.7999724745750427,
0.6843917369842529,
-0.0017096021911129355,
-0.4152838885784149,
-0.08413641899824142,
0.6499645709991455,
0.065821573138237,
0.1601141393184662,
0.8222094774246216,
0.9403119683265686,
0.8113730549812317,
-0.047397058457136154,
0.369800329208374,
0.06299307942390442,
0.2845134139060974,
0.9148703813552856,
-0.2614749073982239,
0.785935640335083,
0.373098224401474,
-0.6883048415184021,
0.6279693841934204,
0.9886823892593384,
0.006959232036024332,
0.6400153040885925,
0.37990766763687134,
-0.6533240079879761,
-0.06281778216362,
-0.39211180806159973,
-0.4860563576221466,
1.2339720726013184,
0.655190110206604,
-0.008743073791265488,
-0.2947818338871002,
0.4233333170413971,
-0.2839154005050659,
0.45543012022972107,
0.15760120749473572,
1.003045678138733,
-0.18347109854221344,
-0.3952106237411499,
0.8288607001304626,
0.038040440529584885,
0.36810818314552307,
-0.27827033400535583,
-0.3459509313106537,
-0.28958040475845337,
0.06506286561489105,
-0.14054694771766663,
-0.5158377885818481,
0.7777215838432312,
-0.21934032440185547,
-0.3477015495300293,
-0.4109416604042053,
0.29508456587791443,
-0.41078928112983704,
-0.37481677532196045,
0.06919903308153152,
0.19454950094223022,
0.37270587682724,
0.23022256791591644,
-0.66927570104599,
0.24007894098758698,
0.3597339987754822,
0.007081503048539162,
0.2960411608219147,
0.6353588700294495,
-0.11267167329788208,
0.8749551177024841,
0.08538167923688889,
0.13944335281848907,
-0.0303285364061594,
0.3899003267288208,
0.8613148927688599,
-0.5584942698478699,
-0.39553937315940857,
-0.957647979259491,
0.38489705324172974,
-0.17590253055095673,
-0.22349654138088226,
0.6535220742225647,
0.7053714394569397,
0.7640572786331177,
0.052226293832063675,
0.575225293636322,
-0.4037171006202698,
0.8597891330718994,
-0.2524200975894928,
0.4524640142917633,
-0.3962351977825165,
0.4363907277584076,
-0.4951331615447998,
-0.8884196281433105,
-0.1785183846950531,
0.29344993829727173,
-0.1352662444114685,
0.04695865511894226,
0.5559270977973938,
0.9822992086410522,
0.05678007751703262,
-0.15373019874095917,
0.3599643409252167,
-0.171219140291214,
0.5575013756752014,
0.3916645348072052,
0.7617096304893494,
-0.18635761737823486,
0.5820146203041077,
-0.3621393144130707,
-0.4142586886882782,
-0.3095344305038452,
-0.5665518641471863,
-0.4351024925708771,
-1.349234938621521,
-0.6843515634536743,
-0.1342574656009674,
-0.1738298237323761,
0.3356838524341583,
0.925590455532074,
-0.8661752343177795,
-0.15841051936149597,
-0.2552851736545563,
0.14319439232349396,
-0.2446846216917038,
-0.27023276686668396,
0.3959813117980957,
-0.20291917026042938,
-1.0551892518997192,
0.8086811304092407,
0.4781140685081482,
0.20418305695056915,
-0.6053616404533386,
0.0330556221306324,
-0.4775293469429016,
-0.27789023518562317,
0.30571749806404114,
0.42610612511634827,
-0.7268598079681396,
-0.932603657245636,
-0.2702966630458832,
0.08005776256322861,
0.0952647477388382,
0.3691350221633911,
-0.8025586605072021,
0.8656884431838989,
0.5573559403419495,
0.37938743829727173,
0.4195162355899811,
0.387800931930542,
0.43718427419662476,
-1.1634780168533325,
0.7405897378921509,
0.2579197883605957,
0.05178096517920494,
0.5854381918907166,
-0.20772282779216766,
0.3960072696208954,
0.5781277418136597,
-0.7308902144432068,
-0.936228334903717,
0.24086295068264008,
-0.996925950050354,
0.1299423724412918,
0.8240798115730286,
0.04106929898262024,
-0.3808857500553131,
-0.44035378098487854,
-0.2966361939907074,
0.24362871050834656,
0.04269590228796005,
0.9171133041381836,
0.8138811588287354,
-0.37301987409591675,
-0.4985376298427582,
-0.3338318169116974,
0.5508460998535156,
0.09844759851694107,
-0.45947036147117615,
0.004547597840428352,
0.327790766954422,
-0.0702173113822937,
0.7095321416854858,
0.7087398171424866,
-0.34558939933776855,
-0.10108920186758041,
0.27798545360565186,
0.46626347303390503,
0.013696613721549511,
-0.3783937990665436,
-0.07334890961647034,
-0.03103945590555668,
-0.061101462692022324,
-0.7092491388320923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14747v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14747v1 | An Adapter-Based Unified Model for Multiple Spoken Language Processing Tasks | 2024-06-20T21:39:04 | 2024-06-20T21:39:04 | Varsha Suresh, Salah Aït-Mokhtar, Caroline Brun, Ioan Calapodescu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Self-supervised learning models have revolutionized the field of speech
processing. However, the process of fine-tuning these models on downstream
tasks requires substantial computational resources, particularly when dealing
with multiple speech-processing tasks. In this paper, we explore the potential
of adapter-based fine-tuning in developing a unified model capable of
effectively handling multiple spoken language processing tasks. The tasks we
investigate are Automatic Speech Recognition, Phoneme Recognition, Intent
Classification, Slot Filling, and Spoken Emotion Recognition. We validate our
approach through a series of experiments on the SUPERB benchmark, and our
results indicate that adapter-based fine-tuning enables a single
encoder-decoder model to perform multiple speech processing tasks with an
average improvement of 18.4% across the five target tasks while staying
efficient in terms of parameter updates. | [
-0.41745296120643616,
-0.5168089866638184,
0.2518519461154938,
0.17439818382263184,
0.07212240248918533,
-0.5735746622085571,
-0.3642815947532654,
-0.40204814076423645,
-0.35983845591545105,
0.6346770524978638,
-0.3774125874042511,
-0.0921097993850708,
-0.4784857928752899,
0.140340194106102,
-0.2331036478281021,
0.6877509951591492,
0.30840519070625305,
-0.06751157343387604,
0.18953996896743774,
-0.3345929980278015,
-0.7544381022453308,
-0.28040915727615356,
-0.6741734743118286,
-0.45665231347084045,
0.2334434539079666,
0.7831421494483948,
0.4466121196746826,
0.4872726500034332,
0.35386449098587036,
0.32803875207901,
0.1221654862165451,
0.08649304509162903,
-0.3308701813220978,
0.30400264263153076,
-0.330750972032547,
-0.3519105911254883,
-0.548211395740509,
-0.035665251314640045,
0.7549257278442383,
0.5149226188659668,
-0.517821729183197,
0.2404872328042984,
0.2967282831668854,
0.6563913822174072,
-0.5582737326622009,
0.09181609749794006,
-0.9029408693313599,
-0.4418070912361145,
0.006129726301878691,
0.11354227364063263,
-0.36218905448913574,
0.08158813416957855,
-0.1268461048603058,
-0.4308881163597107,
0.33191895484924316,
-0.4572359621524811,
0.23130342364311218,
0.580927848815918,
-0.07826212793588638,
-0.07663430273532867,
-0.8022171258926392,
0.6468175053596497,
-0.807985782623291,
0.6708457469940186,
0.04635259136557579,
0.2983924150466919,
-0.06754772365093231,
-0.5069034099578857,
-0.6030073165893555,
0.09505759179592133,
0.12028034031391144,
0.02602963149547577,
-0.47857287526130676,
0.2773207426071167,
0.0895499512553215,
0.1549207866191864,
-0.3324463665485382,
0.28845781087875366,
-0.16966739296913147,
0.0012608765391632915,
0.4939488172531128,
0.0703996792435646,
0.35312846302986145,
0.07481543719768524,
0.16407954692840576,
-0.05964288115501404,
-0.2159765064716339,
0.27540579438209534,
0.20521093904972076,
0.8130049109458923,
-0.07966285198926926,
0.32119220495224,
-0.5282330513000488,
1.04069185256958,
0.16868436336517334,
-0.13507527112960815,
0.0032112253829836845,
-0.2593866288661957,
-0.386400043964386,
0.03762364760041237,
0.646821141242981,
0.23081201314926147,
0.4125122129917145,
-0.19979001581668854,
-0.0376867800951004,
0.15092714130878448,
0.4952457845211029,
-0.7021878361701965,
-0.32904988527297974,
0.12216570973396301,
-0.15070615708827972,
0.058737851679325104,
-0.22270965576171875,
-0.43252691626548767,
-0.06395840644836426,
-0.5767463445663452,
0.4578085243701935,
-0.474117249250412,
-0.2222023606300354,
0.40315234661102295,
-0.06836815923452377,
-0.11682549864053726,
0.28703048825263977,
-1.0695152282714844,
0.49399033188819885,
0.3991352617740631,
0.6433224678039551,
-0.059932056814432144,
-0.5240479111671448,
-0.7055522203445435,
0.10670889914035797,
0.04713689908385277,
0.9543699622154236,
-0.8657968044281006,
-0.24320875108242035,
-0.24752958118915558,
0.18935343623161316,
-0.6680306792259216,
-0.4384797513484955,
0.6734679341316223,
-0.11941127479076385,
-0.3019499182701111,
0.0057092998176813126,
-0.565864622592926,
-0.296099454164505,
-0.08966109156608582,
-0.4862064719200134,
0.7787857055664062,
-0.18702299892902374,
-0.321609228849411,
0.08386430889368057,
-0.9219651818275452,
-0.4806387722492218,
0.07014266401529312,
0.09864721447229385,
-0.24032220244407654,
0.3184983730316162,
0.4966866075992584,
0.7171423435211182,
-0.21745215356349945,
0.25519028306007385,
-0.29614534974098206,
-0.2695675194263458,
-0.03985368832945824,
-0.47732874751091003,
0.3825112581253052,
0.2972637414932251,
-0.10521586984395981,
0.26520654559135437,
-1.1666887998580933,
-0.060506779700517654,
-0.27385735511779785,
-0.7253674864768982,
-0.12747220695018768,
0.017956821247935295,
0.32959017157554626,
0.3091168999671936,
0.18710799515247345,
-0.6805102229118347,
0.1705578863620758,
-0.19022881984710693,
0.5182307362556458,
0.39488136768341064,
-0.29946815967559814,
0.3770841956138611,
-0.16753031313419342,
0.2205577790737152,
0.10605508834123611,
0.023669084534049034,
-0.47147229313850403,
-0.33930525183677673,
-0.8751962184906006,
-0.16880303621292114,
0.19878682494163513,
0.5585694313049316,
-0.19257766008377075,
0.5022698044776917,
-0.1272832602262497,
-0.7102842926979065,
-1.0388673543930054,
0.15286032855510712,
0.2984192967414856,
0.4767821133136749,
0.5636579990386963,
-0.13049226999282837,
-0.33322587609291077,
-0.8253394961357117,
-0.5629392266273499,
0.2634470462799072,
-0.04765195772051811,
0.3425550162792206,
-0.06292564421892166,
-0.41801902651786804,
0.7182769775390625,
-0.22570905089378357,
-0.6458650827407837,
-0.10760826617479324,
0.09143844246864319,
0.25179147720336914,
0.5834370255470276,
0.3364151418209076,
-0.5720317363739014,
-0.41816920042037964,
0.3357425332069397,
-0.4910021424293518,
-0.05449371412396431,
-0.09421723335981369,
0.3796553611755371,
-0.047823090106248856,
0.5873925685882568,
-0.05286936089396477,
0.12500175833702087,
0.7741150856018066,
-0.11462467908859253,
0.26541221141815186,
-0.5610542297363281,
0.03271886706352234,
-0.8031278252601624,
-0.1197388544678688,
0.16233447194099426,
-0.16192443668842316,
-1.132288932800293,
0.04672631248831749,
0.22112028300762177,
-0.2678473889827728,
-0.29393866658210754,
0.33130115270614624,
-0.2213859111070633,
0.16912426054477692,
-0.6203462481498718,
-0.13097596168518066,
-0.18565884232521057,
0.47426271438598633,
-0.22197787463665009,
0.7891584634780884,
1.1499513387680054,
-0.9010282754898071,
0.2795465588569641,
-0.027276774868369102,
0.052730072289705276,
0.6446746587753296,
-0.7208537459373474,
0.4216281473636627,
-0.14276272058486938,
-0.16900387406349182,
-1.1354331970214844,
-0.23586344718933105,
-0.27968788146972656,
-0.16705839335918427,
0.19546197354793549,
-0.24544796347618103,
-0.21238864958286285,
-0.3023034334182739,
0.2306995838880539,
0.2124244123697281,
0.16742797195911407,
-0.6495348215103149,
1.0373897552490234,
0.5181594491004944,
-0.3250535726547241,
-0.138889878988266,
-0.3691790699958801,
-0.17592009902000427,
-0.11978048831224442,
-0.6271296739578247,
0.2623196542263031,
-0.09840214997529984,
0.24628448486328125,
-0.2646491825580597,
-0.2295699417591095,
-0.1258356124162674,
0.061312515288591385,
0.39364683628082275,
-0.24273274838924408,
-0.06869226694107056,
0.26320603489875793,
0.15572483837604523,
-0.19411031901836395,
-0.41473129391670227,
-0.45321130752563477,
0.4468837380409241,
-0.327518492937088,
-0.38469839096069336,
-0.8221028447151184,
0.2819916307926178,
0.7808091044425964,
-0.2742602229118347,
0.2553054392337799,
0.7905266880989075,
-0.4242270290851593,
0.06174987554550171,
-0.95009446144104,
-0.05223219841718674,
-0.47247573733329773,
0.44583022594451904,
-0.8400751948356628,
-0.934400200843811,
0.5189162492752075,
-0.21393148601055145,
0.27712395787239075,
0.47157394886016846,
0.4446951150894165,
-0.017472723498940468,
1.0710116624832153,
0.7587398290634155,
-0.45906320214271545,
0.5852004289627075,
0.20217132568359375,
0.004115696530789137,
-0.9941450953483582,
0.14015287160873413,
-0.740972638130188,
-0.17207778990268707,
-0.5838750004768372,
-0.11760900169610977,
0.40048491954803467,
0.01789141818881035,
-0.13201195001602173,
0.6122518181800842,
-0.5935671925544739,
0.36635348200798035,
0.7401909828186035,
0.2081921100616455,
0.26662227511405945,
-0.163524329662323,
-0.0634312778711319,
0.2404704988002777,
-0.7711236476898193,
-0.45097729563713074,
0.9532163739204407,
0.25812649726867676,
0.8773235082626343,
0.005059600342065096,
0.49372273683547974,
-0.00644899345934391,
-0.1893480271100998,
-0.4927225708961487,
0.25383201241493225,
-0.7597046494483948,
-0.3739986717700958,
-0.6484178900718689,
-0.08826113492250443,
-0.8794631361961365,
0.5853309631347656,
-0.041517775505781174,
-0.8652845621109009,
0.26741692423820496,
0.45552894473075867,
-0.42259344458580017,
0.07398255914449692,
-0.9705990552902222,
0.8535659909248352,
0.07033386081457138,
0.009041369892656803,
-0.6534138321876526,
-0.4034941792488098,
0.021220136433839798,
-0.22131779789924622,
0.3938174247741699,
-0.40523672103881836,
0.5742054581642151,
0.6737965941429138,
0.2621849775314331,
0.8714011311531067,
-0.303851455450058,
-0.016768574714660645,
0.054361648857593536,
-0.04686117172241211,
0.3548862338066101,
0.05499005690217018,
-0.49794018268585205,
0.13693511486053467,
0.20870272815227509,
-0.2827046811580658,
-0.35602158308029175,
0.6860443353652954,
-0.758682906627655,
-0.45843225717544556,
0.09575217217206955,
-0.7741677165031433,
-0.28515225648880005,
0.2997610867023468,
-0.1193862184882164,
0.5298236012458801,
-0.37977319955825806,
0.06227201968431473,
0.37176454067230225,
0.12916865944862366,
0.5985225439071655,
0.8114264011383057,
0.144733265042305,
-0.19046521186828613,
0.996045708656311,
0.04451494663953781,
0.36798104643821716,
0.15487872064113617,
0.24343861639499664,
-0.0736665278673172,
-0.5721045732498169,
-0.39874809980392456,
0.043757982552051544,
-0.4373660683631897,
-0.021261604502797127,
-0.7753658890724182,
-0.016305314376950264,
-0.7604996562004089,
0.10929743200540543,
-0.6815004348754883,
-0.04752663895487785,
-0.5654705762863159,
0.28615885972976685,
0.2569821774959564,
0.7670835852622986,
-0.3044573962688446,
0.6058475971221924,
-0.7175636291503906,
0.8558006286621094,
0.8715360760688782,
0.7141692042350769,
-0.18164651095867157,
-0.8581153154373169,
-0.2403687834739685,
0.20137596130371094,
-0.4514135718345642,
-0.5368334650993347,
0.20241542160511017,
0.6947882175445557,
0.6666777729988098,
0.4244961142539978,
-0.22181695699691772,
0.9821817278862,
-0.8019979000091553,
0.31072160601615906,
0.13518951833248138,
-0.9423956274986267,
0.6589455604553223,
-0.31622031331062317,
0.7497838139533997,
0.5770384073257446,
-0.051702022552490234,
-0.6470985412597656,
-0.22313033044338226,
-0.4328405559062958,
-0.4513601064682007,
1.0053359270095825,
-0.010616917163133621,
0.23807837069034576,
0.21428343653678894,
0.2616846561431885,
0.18479211628437042,
-0.21778424084186554,
-0.41647371649742126,
-0.24085929989814758,
-0.2150522619485855,
-0.09497472643852234,
-0.29836413264274597,
-0.135029137134552,
0.06401748210191727,
-0.5737899541854858,
0.6179363131523132,
-0.45177125930786133,
0.12454743683338165,
0.07244270294904709,
-0.23737426102161407,
-0.07218009233474731,
0.7240895628929138,
0.4700067639350891,
0.2884729206562042,
-0.24369721114635468,
-0.006890102289617062,
0.4192759692668915,
-0.3253912627696991,
-0.058293309062719345,
0.676259458065033,
0.14808453619480133,
-0.09141957759857178,
-0.11714974790811539,
1.0663936138153076,
0.4419197142124176,
-0.3291729688644409,
-0.04684427008032799,
-0.29118916392326355,
-0.035298727452754974,
0.07996257394552231,
0.54676353931427,
0.2506096661090851,
0.2851295471191406,
0.3071195185184479,
0.4861040711402893,
0.40677279233932495,
-0.4563756287097931,
0.25107112526893616,
0.3846677541732788,
-0.7001597285270691,
-0.4572260081768036,
0.6543887853622437,
0.3154186010360718,
-0.50937420129776,
0.3099055886268616,
-0.01896008476614952,
-0.20250479876995087,
0.2752736508846283,
0.7935505509376526,
0.5943496227264404,
-0.867763876914978,
-0.24250119924545288,
0.3618236184120178,
0.13565850257873535,
-0.20157566666603088,
0.35422182083129883,
-0.11596684157848358,
-0.9192227721214294,
-0.2335326373577118,
-0.6767731308937073,
-0.3743247091770172,
0.07263842225074768,
-0.694816529750824,
0.181318998336792,
0.1701502948999405,
-0.12649203836917877,
0.5274447798728943,
-0.590485692024231,
-0.886932909488678,
0.41971585154533386,
0.2724444568157196,
0.6175015568733215,
-0.6985687017440796,
1.1435925960540771,
0.7593952417373657,
0.1360040307044983,
-0.8059068322181702,
-0.3099468946456909,
-0.08490215986967087,
-0.6627947688102722,
0.08402791619300842,
0.23765359818935394,
-0.29336827993392944,
0.43243882060050964,
-0.06843669712543488,
-0.8500992059707642,
0.6111895442008972,
0.44575077295303345,
-1.0468863248825073,
0.05720854178071022,
0.03303937986493111,
0.42449918389320374,
-0.4033052325248718,
0.2208869457244873,
1.0724033117294312,
0.2658626437187195,
-0.22612884640693665,
-1.4336295127868652,
-0.2950076758861542,
-0.14664755761623383,
-0.04735327884554863,
0.036127809435129166,
-0.4502720832824707,
0.709794282913208,
-0.2817654013633728,
-0.09011389315128326,
-0.30403587222099304,
0.4647378623485565,
0.11654140800237656,
-0.04027523845434189,
0.7396478652954102,
0.43986520171165466,
0.754814088344574,
0.08201954513788223,
0.6436083316802979,
-0.39185604453086853,
0.307780385017395,
1.2509821653366089,
-0.12881849706172943,
0.9291962385177612,
0.17973823845386505,
-0.19453366100788116,
0.1366676390171051,
0.03713514655828476,
0.09842441231012344,
0.4340393543243408,
-0.08358477801084518,
-0.2282509058713913,
-0.4183942973613739,
-0.07919425517320633,
-0.17277877032756805,
0.8366454243659973,
0.4827456474304199,
0.04862523451447487,
-0.26362621784210205,
0.40767908096313477,
-0.4017162322998047,
-0.03182021901011467,
-0.42480260133743286,
1.088178038597107,
0.11080124974250793,
-0.7065401673316956,
0.35624581575393677,
-0.003112451173365116,
0.940362811088562,
-0.3023826479911804,
0.06922435760498047,
0.17641687393188477,
0.38725417852401733,
-0.11687353253364563,
-0.6124841570854187,
0.24403627216815948,
-0.04640062153339386,
-0.3004733920097351,
-0.1508173793554306,
0.9736261963844299,
-0.5264625549316406,
-0.6246035099029541,
0.3313376307487488,
0.367607444524765,
0.05574842914938927,
-0.5476996302604675,
-0.5577077269554138,
0.06961771845817566,
0.005022922996431589,
0.01111406460404396,
0.2481973022222519,
0.37535277009010315,
0.3896576762199402,
0.6027899980545044,
0.7482922673225403,
0.05073006823658943,
0.41092783212661743,
0.6460022330284119,
0.7548344731330872,
-0.684499979019165,
-0.6477184295654297,
-0.7740261554718018,
0.46355709433555603,
0.265135258436203,
-0.3053687512874603,
0.44445931911468506,
0.26434001326560974,
0.7103436589241028,
-0.09241817146539688,
0.9572675228118896,
0.1773928552865982,
0.6876527667045593,
-0.22868582606315613,
0.5535204410552979,
-0.45962926745414734,
-0.1507982313632965,
-0.2553327679634094,
-0.5055592060089111,
-0.2960493862628937,
0.626076340675354,
0.002946715336292982,
-0.14007556438446045,
0.21091239154338837,
0.5977053046226501,
-0.30366843938827515,
0.2871832251548767,
0.616529107093811,
0.03206706419587135,
0.36277371644973755,
0.32229119539260864,
0.21581821143627167,
-0.6426911950111389,
0.4080400764942169,
-0.281281441450119,
-0.14786536991596222,
-0.18589988350868225,
-0.5216529369354248,
-0.7962371110916138,
-0.6628383994102478,
-0.2673878073692322,
0.10996239632368088,
0.17366459965705872,
0.6839264035224915,
1.0678809881210327,
-1.034264326095581,
-0.3924335837364197,
-0.1853167861700058,
-0.2608276307582855,
-0.47570618987083435,
-0.2014000415802002,
0.04548017680644989,
-0.7851977944374084,
-0.9002573490142822,
0.7374429702758789,
0.4277469515800476,
-0.08657395094633102,
0.3041326105594635,
0.0794435441493988,
-0.02875680662691593,
-0.03627724200487137,
0.49431830644607544,
0.2953617572784424,
-0.8565836548805237,
-0.25872138142585754,
-0.1524549424648285,
0.21010424196720123,
0.19873814284801483,
0.7312241196632385,
-0.6831038594245911,
0.845798671245575,
-0.017456376925110817,
0.6986166834831238,
0.5404918789863586,
0.040920842438936234,
0.6446393132209778,
-0.6023204922676086,
0.03802605718374252,
-0.09324703365564346,
0.4989611804485321,
0.3519396483898163,
-0.2241455763578415,
0.15495358407497406,
-0.30090874433517456,
-0.9087002277374268,
-0.5292884111404419,
0.20437772572040558,
-1.1139609813690186,
-0.13246068358421326,
0.9156749248504639,
0.07219840586185455,
0.2493525892496109,
-0.3647582530975342,
-0.24701561033725739,
0.5772448182106018,
-0.5951915979385376,
0.6221067905426025,
0.5890424847602844,
-0.4920804798603058,
-0.22807522118091583,
-0.4401630461215973,
0.2455909252166748,
0.35698801279067993,
-0.7780023217201233,
0.265641450881958,
0.22249099612236023,
0.49746596813201904,
0.13500887155532837,
0.5857353806495667,
0.2773268222808838,
0.2795122563838959,
-0.19765731692314148,
0.2814042270183563,
-0.06387248635292053,
-0.45566117763519287,
-0.8162484765052795,
0.2072395533323288,
0.05186504125595093,
-0.38833868503570557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14745v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14745v2 | Relation Extraction with Fine-Tuned Large Language Models in Retrieval Augmented Generation Frameworks | 2024-06-20T21:27:57 | 2024-06-24T06:57:05 | Sefika Efeoglu, Adrian Paschke | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Information Extraction (IE) is crucial for converting unstructured data into
structured formats like Knowledge Graphs (KGs). A key task within IE is
Relation Extraction (RE), which identifies relationships between entities in
text. Various RE methods exist, including supervised, unsupervised, weakly
supervised, and rule-based approaches. Recent studies leveraging pre-trained
language models (PLMs) have shown significant success in this area. In the
current era dominated by Large Language Models (LLMs), fine-tuning these models
can overcome limitations associated with zero-shot LLM prompting-based RE
methods, especially regarding domain adaptation challenges and identifying
implicit relations between entities in sentences. These implicit relations,
which cannot be easily extracted from a sentence's dependency tree, require
logical inference for accurate identification. This work explores the
performance of fine-tuned LLMs and their integration into the Retrieval
Augmented-based (RAG) RE approach to address the challenges of identifying
implicit relations at the sentence level, particularly when LLMs act as
generators within the RAG framework. Empirical evaluations on the TACRED,
TACRED-Revisited (TACREV), Re-TACRED, and SemEVAL datasets show significant
performance improvements with fine-tuned LLMs, including Llama2-7B, Mistral-7B,
and T5 (Large). Notably, our approach achieves substantial gains on SemEVAL,
where implicit relations are common, surpassing previous results on this
dataset. Additionally, our method outperforms previous works on TACRED, TACREV,
and Re-TACRED, demonstrating exceptional performance across diverse evaluation
scenarios. | [
-0.4153826832771301,
-1.0681921243667603,
0.726467490196228,
0.020514216274023056,
-0.26723548769950867,
0.012958426959812641,
-0.2679310739040375,
-0.6341534852981567,
-0.05930468812584877,
0.6601561307907104,
-0.42196404933929443,
-0.48020729422569275,
-0.5849565863609314,
0.3623488247394562,
-0.35330742597579956,
0.959811806678772,
-0.10110698640346527,
-0.22307664155960083,
-0.33431217074394226,
-0.13816553354263306,
-0.42561671137809753,
-0.4071682393550873,
-0.4313529133796692,
-0.3362656831741333,
0.5390005111694336,
0.3358077108860016,
0.42547520995140076,
0.6855102181434631,
0.4153890609741211,
0.27137887477874756,
-0.1472838968038559,
0.6209063529968262,
-0.5996895432472229,
0.40979358553886414,
-0.47196823358535767,
-0.13343840837478638,
-0.3858439028263092,
-0.03356490284204483,
0.5938270092010498,
0.77236008644104,
0.1731787770986557,
0.509240448474884,
0.10999466478824615,
0.5828354954719543,
-0.9455649852752686,
0.3961470425128937,
-0.8350843191146851,
-0.10989608615636826,
-0.3018129765987396,
-0.4310116171836853,
-0.5958461165428162,
-0.16176514327526093,
0.24721276760101318,
-0.7344756722450256,
0.24572184681892395,
0.2851620614528656,
1.0682458877563477,
0.24560928344726562,
-0.5363041758537292,
-0.24593980610370636,
-0.7940865159034729,
0.7386598587036133,
-0.5246267914772034,
0.6533370018005371,
0.3227149546146393,
0.005811498500406742,
-0.5363160371780396,
-0.9124478101730347,
-0.3162723779678345,
-0.3002053201198578,
-0.2072485089302063,
-0.02596341073513031,
-0.05733774974942207,
0.020560704171657562,
0.4800660014152527,
0.4465523958206177,
-0.1584782749414444,
0.05710089951753616,
-0.06350751966238022,
-0.04270483925938606,
0.4786634147167206,
0.05228499323129654,
0.20405299961566925,
-0.34526327252388,
-0.397549033164978,
0.14460639655590057,
-0.8242367506027222,
-0.14704640209674835,
0.08923159539699554,
0.4976525902748108,
0.19889995455741882,
0.8165562748908997,
-0.2024460732936859,
0.645183265209198,
0.22013458609580994,
-0.1232551634311676,
0.1534261703491211,
-0.33405601978302,
-0.21423520147800446,
-0.18584571778774261,
0.7401551604270935,
0.04778871685266495,
0.7916651964187622,
-0.3644307851791382,
-0.35461127758026123,
-0.188166081905365,
-0.050705719739198685,
-0.8300362229347229,
-0.1719130128622055,
-0.17046602070331573,
-0.4979374408721924,
-0.14442679286003113,
-0.0093650808557868,
-0.7463452816009521,
-0.38320082426071167,
-0.5037970542907715,
0.3011407256126404,
-0.45946773886680603,
-0.3804773986339569,
-0.1638524830341339,
0.003933850210160017,
0.31635361909866333,
0.20996703207492828,
-0.7285901308059692,
0.44648781418800354,
0.8421715497970581,
0.6201314330101013,
-0.257670521736145,
-0.05528844892978668,
-0.967410683631897,
0.3166675865650177,
-0.2077302485704422,
0.7486502528190613,
-0.7906179428100586,
-0.2970069944858551,
0.04702634736895561,
0.09658731520175934,
-0.14119352400302887,
-0.6432800889015198,
0.5634495615959167,
-0.8309721946716309,
0.16970586776733398,
-0.2241755723953247,
-0.656184732913971,
-0.030405743047595024,
0.2931460738182068,
-0.7902982234954834,
1.054305911064148,
0.23323020339012146,
-0.8397618532180786,
0.25796738266944885,
-0.37405523657798767,
-0.5938734412193298,
-0.08230099827051163,
-0.12189304828643799,
-0.3659535348415375,
0.1897442489862442,
0.3953167200088501,
0.5562008619308472,
-0.682138204574585,
0.24562545120716095,
-0.5008101463317871,
-0.21048374474048615,
-0.03221636638045311,
-0.1869935691356659,
0.6419069766998291,
0.3155231475830078,
0.01900753751397133,
0.03234967216849327,
-0.9133026599884033,
-0.06786259263753891,
0.10329577326774597,
-0.20000748336315155,
-0.70207279920578,
0.04249846190214157,
-0.10387055575847626,
0.15302196145057678,
0.29083579778671265,
-0.5002392530441284,
0.20794083178043365,
-0.6302881836891174,
0.2636771500110626,
0.6555922627449036,
0.4689568877220154,
0.49715656042099,
0.13924692571163177,
0.5170232653617859,
-0.052290014922618866,
-0.21938946843147278,
-0.11604559421539307,
-0.05110084265470505,
-0.5875149369239807,
-0.28963759541511536,
0.6803995966911316,
0.450698584318161,
-0.9407671093940735,
0.23743338882923126,
-0.4361501634120941,
-0.1893177628517151,
-0.33503228425979614,
0.27012038230895996,
0.6096581220626831,
0.7803769111633301,
0.3230397701263428,
-0.0848110243678093,
-0.5664767026901245,
-0.8311946988105774,
-0.5221888422966003,
-0.17235632240772247,
0.08808420598506927,
0.47673800587654114,
0.3753100335597992,
-0.10279076546430588,
1.0509225130081177,
-0.6541675925254822,
-0.1639808565378189,
-0.1307901293039322,
0.08891801536083221,
0.13088785111904144,
0.30379408597946167,
0.41845086216926575,
-0.8335503935813904,
-0.4761660397052765,
0.16878175735473633,
-0.6164778470993042,
-0.3969022333621979,
0.06566829979419708,
-0.10026432573795319,
0.23633675277233124,
0.5727079510688782,
-0.6596571207046509,
0.3673403561115265,
0.22219939529895782,
-0.38296785950660706,
0.5807979702949524,
-0.03092525526881218,
0.021124888211488724,
-1.0467640161514282,
0.21226656436920166,
0.19419628381729126,
-0.5491209626197815,
-0.39014115929603577,
0.0509406141936779,
-0.0060344780795276165,
0.10704644024372101,
-0.31014132499694824,
0.6743019819259644,
-0.7921714782714844,
-0.35647815465927124,
-0.052862707525491714,
0.12279928475618362,
0.10449902713298798,
0.5033420324325562,
-0.038848068565130234,
0.838436484336853,
0.21201026439666748,
-0.6290329098701477,
0.16893570125102997,
0.3550723195075989,
-0.09562123566865921,
0.2667008638381958,
-0.5548861622810364,
0.13344156742095947,
-0.06893884390592575,
-0.06065850332379341,
-0.6263942122459412,
-0.09138471633195877,
0.19698113203048706,
-0.3063322603702545,
0.5643559098243713,
-0.43467995524406433,
-0.6394880414009094,
0.1492115557193756,
-0.20918934047222137,
0.3580937683582306,
0.2828507423400879,
-0.6523792743682861,
0.8543804883956909,
0.437508761882782,
-0.27380165457725525,
-0.7205076217651367,
-0.11994591355323792,
-0.034696776419878006,
-0.23249377310276031,
-0.49322211742401123,
0.2892354428768158,
0.3277948200702667,
-0.4073857367038727,
0.26069730520248413,
-0.24913525581359863,
-0.10771987587213516,
0.1944282054901123,
0.21211667358875275,
0.32444581389427185,
-0.2030261904001236,
0.16736024618148804,
-0.004484138917177916,
-0.09987370669841766,
0.09538384526968002,
0.13716687262058258,
0.500495195388794,
-0.05190126225352287,
-0.045748334378004074,
-0.07060083746910095,
0.24053752422332764,
0.5715533494949341,
-0.5265187621116638,
0.769262969493866,
0.5673891305923462,
-0.3813973665237427,
-0.15571916103363037,
-0.6221671104431152,
-0.10616490244865417,
-0.39661550521850586,
0.48917156457901,
-0.7231950759887695,
-0.9985179305076599,
0.5799568295478821,
-0.5130703449249268,
-0.06323029100894928,
0.5822204947471619,
0.29295986890792847,
0.06510935723781586,
0.9238775968551636,
0.650627851486206,
-0.12784193456172943,
0.5649606585502625,
-0.11272703856229782,
-0.06989365071058273,
-1.1207753419876099,
-0.18060970306396484,
-0.563158392906189,
0.07839777320623398,
-0.7216274738311768,
0.0171620212495327,
0.1857486069202423,
0.3348083198070526,
-0.350979745388031,
0.17685841023921967,
-0.060060497373342514,
0.37106063961982727,
0.2991867959499359,
-0.03876234218478203,
0.47182705998420715,
0.199207603931427,
-0.03275519981980324,
-0.0565452054142952,
-0.49061015248298645,
-0.3776992857456207,
1.0559133291244507,
0.2791089713573456,
0.5974060893058777,
0.12895730137825012,
0.646504819393158,
0.16933166980743408,
0.41135525703430176,
-0.7149691581726074,
0.59056556224823,
-0.3344777524471283,
-0.26923128962516785,
-0.11128418147563934,
-0.7274191379547119,
-1.2200405597686768,
0.1354573369026184,
-0.5009596943855286,
-0.7293033003807068,
0.2362673431634903,
0.0012126561487093568,
-0.136709526181221,
0.029359962791204453,
-0.8934356570243835,
0.6467597484588623,
-0.02331380732357502,
-0.6700391173362732,
0.03727047145366669,
-0.5486681461334229,
0.4603366255760193,
-0.2395332008600235,
-0.04764176532626152,
-0.10154560208320618,
0.05172353237867355,
0.5775965452194214,
-0.3191088140010834,
0.4006279408931732,
-0.1924930065870285,
-0.07206624746322632,
0.1533171832561493,
0.19930295646190643,
0.7370721697807312,
0.03742441162467003,
-0.16336369514465332,
-0.08276452124118805,
0.1331794708967209,
-0.08850066363811493,
-0.7836378812789917,
0.8614341616630554,
-0.609990119934082,
-0.6185445189476013,
-0.2642768919467926,
-0.6538483500480652,
-0.537756621837616,
0.4750708341598511,
-0.1034092977643013,
0.460720956325531,
-0.12925851345062256,
0.3265171945095062,
0.6306544542312622,
-0.27844899892807007,
0.2907339930534363,
0.5184199213981628,
-0.44618281722068787,
-0.47737863659858704,
0.7231860756874084,
0.09849253296852112,
0.16666246950626373,
0.3805610239505768,
-0.02093880996108055,
-0.43692171573638916,
-0.4355238974094391,
-0.1486765593290329,
0.43030017614364624,
-0.36290013790130615,
-0.4198582172393799,
-0.5994212627410889,
-0.2125544399023056,
-0.5655115246772766,
0.3984711170196533,
-0.2826060652732849,
-0.4279147684574127,
-0.4398813545703888,
-0.011399501003324986,
0.40816718339920044,
0.698483407497406,
0.19201979041099548,
-0.027089504525065422,
-0.8265531659126282,
0.6115193963050842,
0.04891945794224739,
0.28108593821525574,
-0.1501239538192749,
-0.42474228143692017,
-0.08223340660333633,
-0.31044265627861023,
-0.01948482356965542,
-0.9344604015350342,
0.5021504163742065,
0.2823306918144226,
0.4053005874156952,
0.15791842341423035,
0.08689162880182266,
1.0120115280151367,
-0.5865086317062378,
0.37570419907569885,
-0.21444779634475708,
-0.6559754014015198,
0.3867384195327759,
-0.35702961683273315,
-0.05612192302942276,
0.5530396103858948,
0.14080138504505157,
-0.09886964410543442,
-0.026769621297717094,
-0.7544650435447693,
-0.964931309223175,
0.6348530054092407,
0.2640133798122406,
-0.2296934872865677,
-0.013442524708807468,
0.9014884233474731,
-0.12268184870481491,
0.2973897159099579,
-0.4783409535884857,
-0.26163148880004883,
0.3780063986778259,
-0.25837916135787964,
0.02246580645442009,
-0.5230615735054016,
0.11510676890611649,
-0.185311958193779,
0.6719896793365479,
0.09712149947881699,
0.0022917063906788826,
0.31581827998161316,
-0.3678688108921051,
-0.11099286377429962,
0.2703554034233093,
0.22921720147132874,
0.6565986275672913,
-0.33665284514427185,
0.20631849765777588,
0.1880584955215454,
-0.2906935513019562,
-0.09821970760822296,
0.465349406003952,
-0.1742129623889923,
-0.0879996046423912,
0.4954353868961334,
0.5539641380310059,
0.1335771679878235,
-0.5352936387062073,
0.42419329285621643,
0.005750725977122784,
0.06809058785438538,
-0.32103195786476135,
-0.025289198383688927,
-0.10384237766265869,
0.35822102427482605,
0.28367120027542114,
-0.0947825089097023,
0.16746573150157928,
-0.47769737243652344,
0.3664049804210663,
0.6367267966270447,
-0.20146840810775757,
-0.2736648619174957,
0.4891185760498047,
0.1454933136701584,
-0.23675841093063354,
0.607519268989563,
-0.1703174114227295,
-0.360532283782959,
0.3232809901237488,
0.6705738306045532,
0.8306220769882202,
0.027959804981946945,
-0.10365889966487885,
0.35973185300827026,
0.18878012895584106,
-0.060917407274246216,
0.09413634985685349,
-0.16173109412193298,
-0.8125143051147461,
-0.9741467833518982,
-0.6612808704376221,
-0.04107037931680679,
0.29010123014450073,
-0.9366381764411926,
0.21020923554897308,
-0.30834460258483887,
-0.024998169392347336,
-0.09456074237823486,
0.3770960569381714,
-0.688906192779541,
0.07326043397188187,
-0.045417167246341705,
0.8937526941299438,
-0.7536889314651489,
0.8252453207969666,
0.6707141995429993,
-0.385971337556839,
-1.0790958404541016,
-0.05452483519911766,
-0.33265137672424316,
-0.5679687261581421,
0.7896521687507629,
-0.08825074136257172,
-0.24262064695358276,
0.2797077000141144,
-0.48986536264419556,
-0.833615779876709,
1.0398013591766357,
0.7912945747375488,
-0.5935591459274292,
-0.023511121049523354,
-0.03345935419201851,
0.5849847793579102,
-0.5158858299255371,
0.16530907154083252,
0.8464349508285522,
0.32374241948127747,
0.039528738707304,
-0.7784329652786255,
0.16891923546791077,
-0.21107332408428192,
0.08139603585004807,
0.4844435453414917,
-0.3454269766807556,
0.518652081489563,
-0.006987873464822769,
-0.3850671052932739,
0.1665959507226944,
0.8744006752967834,
0.5167173743247986,
0.30570167303085327,
0.5879794359207153,
0.6013281941413879,
0.6484500169754028,
0.03264841064810753,
1.0082226991653442,
-0.27634963393211365,
0.3758962154388428,
1.3830314874649048,
-0.4250742197036743,
0.9065335392951965,
0.6889097690582275,
0.05566512793302536,
0.5515385270118713,
0.4305837154388428,
0.19179077446460724,
0.3787730038166046,
-0.16697868704795837,
-0.13830412924289703,
-0.3799021542072296,
-0.37080681324005127,
-0.2496202290058136,
0.33871930837631226,
0.44946789741516113,
-0.506117582321167,
-0.23214484751224518,
-0.24382947385311127,
0.00750843295827508,
0.17529930174350739,
-0.3210294544696808,
0.9133930802345276,
0.1196168065071106,
-0.6844228506088257,
0.38592326641082764,
-0.1752067357301712,
0.2789885997772217,
-0.3458784222602844,
-0.426082581281662,
-0.07851409912109375,
0.06941946595907211,
-0.19979852437973022,
-0.6300085186958313,
-0.0004181861877441406,
0.14809714257717133,
-0.3236868977546692,
-0.10891622304916382,
1.2040441036224365,
-0.5108886361122131,
-0.3880392909049988,
0.30996692180633545,
0.7457111477851868,
-0.04825322702527046,
-0.014024362899363041,
-0.5271903276443481,
-0.008220355026423931,
0.07814371585845947,
-0.509976863861084,
0.29630181193351746,
0.8038704991340637,
-0.20296527445316315,
0.5542681813240051,
0.7672766447067261,
0.36429962515830994,
-0.17287462949752808,
0.14453387260437012,
0.9284221529960632,
-0.6769936084747314,
0.008305409923195839,
-0.8628310561180115,
0.30012986063957214,
-0.1967904418706894,
-0.18233199417591095,
0.8313676118850708,
0.5681096315383911,
0.5134447813034058,
0.05296941474080086,
0.4505254328250885,
0.04488768056035042,
0.8310679793357849,
-0.6482803225517273,
0.30804622173309326,
-0.42704281210899353,
0.48216143250465393,
-0.4295536279678345,
-1.215968370437622,
-0.2944546341896057,
0.40679872035980225,
-0.48638054728507996,
0.028366778045892715,
0.5962033867835999,
0.7663711905479431,
-0.1254940927028656,
-0.26426708698272705,
0.07770780473947525,
0.4192371666431427,
0.4441799819469452,
0.4237775504589081,
0.8725337386131287,
-0.3646639287471771,
0.5376521348953247,
-0.03977978229522705,
-0.014032496139407158,
0.11239010095596313,
-0.9424384832382202,
-0.7589600086212158,
-0.4922133982181549,
-0.21070696413516998,
-0.36239564418792725,
0.062099914997816086,
0.9021803140640259,
0.362714558839798,
-0.6222900152206421,
0.1615162044763565,
-0.11069633066654205,
0.14553779363632202,
0.09551606327295303,
-0.28006115555763245,
0.5867295265197754,
-0.3135939836502075,
-0.7066274285316467,
0.3594560921192169,
0.20738984644412994,
-0.17178988456726074,
-0.03316061943769455,
-0.021417930722236633,
-0.40385958552360535,
-0.2588653862476349,
0.7508610486984253,
0.39810672402381897,
-0.5328450202941895,
-0.5139991044998169,
-0.08175654709339142,
0.06745940446853638,
-0.19833597540855408,
0.6542791128158569,
-0.9618337154388428,
0.33646655082702637,
0.4837084412574768,
0.8427348136901855,
0.6284962892532349,
0.42608827352523804,
0.7285351753234863,
-1.0005419254302979,
0.03971713036298752,
0.122281514108181,
0.40556618571281433,
0.2629215121269226,
-0.27688658237457275,
0.7912900447845459,
0.1381043642759323,
-0.6502603888511658,
-0.9790762066841125,
0.24124908447265625,
-0.9774439930915833,
-0.14391003549098969,
1.5150736570358276,
-0.13866539299488068,
-0.28391844034194946,
-0.2601401209831238,
-0.194712832570076,
0.41132256388664246,
-0.29737919569015503,
0.4302607476711273,
0.47482386231422424,
-0.2056088000535965,
-0.21874332427978516,
-0.48315438628196716,
0.45878705382347107,
0.4003596305847168,
-0.6781551837921143,
0.15176908671855927,
0.6891014575958252,
0.3979884386062622,
0.14857995510101318,
0.38338643312454224,
-0.18564929068088531,
-0.011144961230456829,
-0.5330584645271301,
-0.10222963243722916,
-0.32349133491516113,
-0.30794188380241394,
-0.15588749945163727,
0.3177383542060852,
0.20624038577079773,
-0.08958794176578522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14739v1 | Learning to Retrieve Iteratively for In-Context Learning | 2024-06-20T21:07:55 | 2024-06-20T21:07:55 | Yunmo Chen, Tongfei Chen, Harsh Jhamtani, Patrick Xia, Richard Shin, Jason Eisner, Benjamin Van Durme | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce iterative retrieval, a novel framework that empowers retrievers
to make iterative decisions through policy optimization. Finding an optimal
portfolio of retrieved items is a combinatorial optimization problem, generally
considered NP-hard. This approach provides a learned approximation to such a
solution, meeting specific task requirements under a given family of large
language models (LLMs). We propose a training procedure based on reinforcement
learning, incorporating feedback from LLMs. We instantiate an iterative
retriever for composing in-context learning (ICL) exemplars and apply it to
various semantic parsing tasks that demand synthesized programs as outputs. By
adding only 4M additional parameters for state encoding, we convert an
off-the-shelf dense retriever into a stateful iterative retriever,
outperforming previous methods in selecting ICL exemplars on semantic parsing
datasets such as CalFlow, TreeDST, and MTOP. Additionally, the trained
iterative retriever generalizes across different inference LLMs beyond the one
used during training. | [
-0.0755196213722229,
-0.3705627918243408,
0.5985169410705566,
0.34136074781417847,
-0.1538895219564438,
0.1710379272699356,
-0.5041170120239258,
0.09475689381361008,
-0.08819029480218887,
0.4084869623184204,
-0.6025852560997009,
-0.34900858998298645,
-0.48847147822380066,
0.004743925295770168,
-0.45652517676353455,
0.9960143566131592,
-0.10378355532884598,
-0.017287490889430046,
-0.12492860853672028,
0.024495726451277733,
-0.35993096232414246,
-0.3121272325515747,
-0.6288735270500183,
-0.5410303473472595,
0.1811770349740982,
0.5064117908477783,
-0.006025479640811682,
0.4492432773113251,
0.006764046382158995,
0.36480793356895447,
-0.08060626685619354,
-0.0028822640888392925,
-0.905169665813446,
0.1097690686583519,
-0.5298917889595032,
-0.2636338472366333,
0.6017633676528931,
-0.07975959777832031,
0.7918819785118103,
0.7250292301177979,
-0.5044659972190857,
-0.06534875929355621,
0.10095720738172531,
0.5216871500015259,
-0.9004054069519043,
0.17889058589935303,
-0.9168989062309265,
0.27305421233177185,
-0.06201673671603203,
-0.6788254380226135,
-0.783483624458313,
-0.24224191904067993,
0.4759182035923004,
-0.748639702796936,
-0.1273275464773178,
0.22684811055660248,
0.7578916549682617,
0.1943865269422531,
-0.47693127393722534,
-0.5693919658660889,
-0.5704193711280823,
1.1158124208450317,
-0.3810403048992157,
0.3081406056880951,
0.4777192175388336,
0.40743935108184814,
-0.41238951683044434,
-0.8693791627883911,
-0.255995512008667,
-0.4693708121776581,
0.07735095918178558,
0.06099040061235428,
0.0074220215901732445,
-0.008962694555521011,
0.12674207985401154,
0.3885077238082886,
-0.23627257347106934,
-0.08577200770378113,
-0.21437332034111023,
-0.07370548695325851,
0.3936656415462494,
0.11771290749311447,
-0.09109535068273544,
-0.10462162643671036,
-0.5841566920280457,
-0.37787988781929016,
-0.7501028180122375,
0.36260631680488586,
0.03632444143295288,
0.31342750787734985,
0.43944525718688965,
0.4063766300678253,
-0.41097119450569153,
0.7111740708351135,
0.045223675668239594,
-0.3192631006240845,
0.1749590039253235,
-0.20253586769104004,
0.023853832855820656,
0.15807697176933289,
0.33269718289375305,
-0.17313162982463837,
-0.2237919121980667,
-0.4895273447036743,
-0.4274035096168518,
-0.3004854917526245,
0.4023876488208771,
-0.6010112166404724,
-0.05615865811705589,
0.027176842093467712,
-0.23360544443130493,
0.0008023962727747858,
0.028108760714530945,
-0.5006769895553589,
0.009329711087048054,
-0.46384549140930176,
0.6518441438674927,
-0.554414689540863,
0.09006059914827347,
0.18166114389896393,
-0.3516799509525299,
0.43291908502578735,
0.13657376170158386,
-0.8287749290466309,
0.4722886085510254,
0.6678479909896851,
0.5368282794952393,
-0.24238699674606323,
-0.36820900440216064,
-1.0624995231628418,
0.322585791349411,
-0.44769957661628723,
0.6359503865242004,
-0.7523671388626099,
-0.4677043855190277,
0.09365513920783997,
0.012058235704898834,
-0.21474356949329376,
-0.6753137707710266,
0.38042330741882324,
-0.7055741548538208,
-0.014065702445805073,
-0.5094133019447327,
-0.7247737646102905,
-0.18273478746414185,
0.4616263210773468,
-0.5692501664161682,
0.9760080575942993,
0.28782919049263,
-0.35877087712287903,
0.6727074980735779,
-0.46310776472091675,
-0.29553985595703125,
-0.05162031576037407,
-0.32867977023124695,
-0.19529204070568085,
0.22115427255630493,
0.10285243391990662,
0.13762123882770538,
-0.25999364256858826,
0.4777422547340393,
-0.3028746545314789,
-0.4272937476634979,
-0.1122337132692337,
-0.14698077738285065,
0.8071926832199097,
0.21762168407440186,
-0.3906306326389313,
0.28749412298202515,
-0.7837143540382385,
0.0934770330786705,
0.031107693910598755,
-0.895135760307312,
-0.3221578299999237,
0.3899275064468384,
-0.20442502200603485,
0.31338149309158325,
0.07538652420043945,
-0.7108715176582336,
0.17514541745185852,
-0.5106924772262573,
0.4968578517436981,
0.8250089287757874,
0.07032846659421921,
0.709650993347168,
0.024216096848249435,
0.2349683791399002,
-0.08578582108020782,
-0.12395273149013519,
-0.17485849559307098,
0.3080710470676422,
-0.551164448261261,
-0.33371755480766296,
0.014816275797784328,
0.27033472061157227,
-1.0619944334030151,
0.18007567524909973,
-0.24195481836795807,
0.008631602860987186,
-0.2700687348842621,
0.2238454818725586,
0.5257981419563293,
0.7770854830741882,
0.27806514501571655,
-0.0516115166246891,
-0.3750041723251343,
-0.6074152588844299,
-0.2691340744495392,
0.21243064105510712,
0.05175333842635155,
0.2725507915019989,
0.6683874726295471,
-0.02430005744099617,
1.007525086402893,
-0.13613232970237732,
-0.37111347913742065,
-0.2925971746444702,
0.07230985909700394,
0.13797035813331604,
0.4166538119316101,
0.10694754868745804,
-0.6320663690567017,
-0.36352401971817017,
0.04736136272549629,
-0.5853309631347656,
0.2027290314435959,
-0.00837111659348011,
0.0015112980036064982,
0.048496313393116,
0.6623752117156982,
-0.05800263211131096,
0.2325325608253479,
0.07118978351354599,
-0.1614408940076828,
0.15283794701099396,
-0.27011093497276306,
-0.32714569568634033,
-0.8184213638305664,
0.15534906089305878,
-0.12777817249298096,
-0.29473015666007996,
-0.10443244129419327,
0.32142916321754456,
0.17260852456092834,
-0.09796865284442902,
-0.3246878683567047,
0.7767407894134521,
-0.49621737003326416,
-0.4752259850502014,
-0.11617803573608398,
0.07086244225502014,
0.08062147349119186,
0.647802472114563,
0.19615814089775085,
0.8613241314888,
0.36110714077949524,
-0.7097115516662598,
-0.03902636840939522,
0.3334619700908661,
-0.46771979331970215,
0.6161481738090515,
-0.36705780029296875,
-0.06793425977230072,
-0.40733101963996887,
0.466673344373703,
-0.7203478813171387,
-0.1164124608039856,
-0.04802620783448219,
0.23583349585533142,
0.3036869764328003,
-0.00472802110016346,
-0.37648022174835205,
-0.31573376059532166,
-0.41388657689094543,
0.20823758840560913,
0.04313329607248306,
-1.1619645357131958,
0.6112048625946045,
0.3187212646007538,
0.2331545203924179,
-0.8358134031295776,
-0.10029735416173935,
-0.06223011016845703,
-0.20387966930866241,
-0.1671479195356369,
0.5891950726509094,
-0.06662337481975555,
-0.17246831953525543,
-0.020933812484145164,
-0.2694149911403656,
-0.01347620040178299,
0.2872263789176941,
-0.2098158746957779,
-0.0880570262670517,
0.11498750001192093,
0.02109408564865589,
0.11706849187612534,
-0.3189762532711029,
-0.0751357302069664,
-0.6138473153114319,
0.4584542214870453,
-0.4181472659111023,
-0.3881155252456665,
-0.04041264206171036,
0.5744087100028992,
-0.21848946809768677,
-0.21430480480194092,
0.2654140889644623,
0.3211669921875,
-0.24084243178367615,
-0.4933384656906128,
-0.26343420147895813,
-0.31475338339805603,
-0.510606586933136,
0.39730724692344666,
-0.5884178280830383,
-1.0554279088974,
0.23055456578731537,
-0.44671428203582764,
0.17888714373111725,
0.15209002792835236,
0.4213167130947113,
0.04943366348743439,
1.279732584953308,
0.7382513880729675,
-0.14728869497776031,
0.6327756643295288,
-0.5054504871368408,
0.16999441385269165,
-0.7993268966674805,
-0.5008494257926941,
-0.4806816577911377,
-0.12667158246040344,
-0.37852510809898376,
-0.019102031365036964,
0.5346852540969849,
0.230709969997406,
-0.4856860041618347,
0.3111330270767212,
-0.3979531526565552,
0.7275910377502441,
0.8623312711715698,
0.2147545963525772,
0.3737277686595917,
0.12096280604600906,
-0.46041157841682434,
0.03667662292718887,
-0.7927654981613159,
-0.10665909200906754,
0.8449384570121765,
-0.04181922227144241,
0.712510347366333,
0.051965005695819855,
0.8798196911811829,
0.0022808758076280355,
0.19793862104415894,
-0.9575003981590271,
0.37224170565605164,
-0.1141401156783104,
-0.2112482786178589,
-0.11692746728658676,
-0.3178357183933258,
-0.9394637942314148,
0.34908923506736755,
0.187577486038208,
-1.206947684288025,
0.2881234884262085,
0.15268269181251526,
-0.19138090312480927,
-0.06499826163053513,
-0.15298186242580414,
0.7874120473861694,
-0.21518881618976593,
-0.5246371030807495,
-0.4446887969970703,
-0.8357329964637756,
0.19508051872253418,
0.26919853687286377,
-0.2518739104270935,
0.024745315313339233,
-0.054064761847257614,
0.3293326497077942,
-0.5380168557167053,
0.514514684677124,
-0.3127010464668274,
0.00936964713037014,
0.20636026561260223,
0.20928384363651276,
0.5942158699035645,
0.07564053684473038,
-0.35137540102005005,
-0.37699955701828003,
0.19109532237052917,
-0.48348817229270935,
-0.4195924997329712,
0.7079907655715942,
-0.633573591709137,
-0.5320925712585449,
-0.4571882486343384,
-0.5603008270263672,
-0.3029128313064575,
0.16275639832019806,
0.3296797275543213,
0.626401424407959,
-0.19574378430843353,
0.46545007824897766,
0.7677851319313049,
-0.13701264560222626,
0.7602123022079468,
0.5722261667251587,
-0.053585633635520935,
-0.22932344675064087,
1.3302572965621948,
-0.06136219948530197,
-0.007715728599578142,
0.6940041184425354,
0.3695898652076721,
-0.49875345826148987,
-0.47850340604782104,
-0.47353124618530273,
-0.11206713318824768,
-1.0735726356506348,
-0.15883435308933258,
-0.48544585704803467,
-0.10432931780815125,
0.24132627248764038,
-0.29796838760375977,
-0.3878304064273834,
-0.05487983301281929,
-0.3976273536682129,
0.005518415942788124,
0.06533234566450119,
0.45930665731430054,
-0.0677645355463028,
0.3622077703475952,
-0.3620547354221344,
0.0120774507522583,
0.20457960665225983,
0.30255162715911865,
-0.10351740568876266,
-0.34623438119888306,
-0.07068251818418503,
-0.3773635923862457,
-0.32037433981895447,
-0.48320165276527405,
0.5245558023452759,
0.5021138787269592,
0.5833484530448914,
0.3648337423801422,
-0.0012754338094964623,
0.8692017197608948,
-0.5944051742553711,
0.6022396683692932,
-0.22429640591144562,
-0.9051883220672607,
0.5252266526222229,
-0.16389237344264984,
0.23041094839572906,
1.0271930694580078,
0.46455252170562744,
-0.3109579384326935,
0.04893146827816963,
-0.39520907402038574,
-1.1488568782806396,
0.8149140477180481,
-0.2825075089931488,
0.11377706378698349,
-0.49963438510894775,
0.3786190152168274,
0.24073301255702972,
0.5007270574569702,
-0.5809993147850037,
0.22724196314811707,
-0.08221819251775742,
-0.1654101014137268,
0.18112976849079132,
-0.22268299758434296,
-0.386758029460907,
-0.29479026794433594,
0.8200690150260925,
-0.6286013126373291,
0.23665392398834229,
0.10053243488073349,
-0.5286023616790771,
0.10957552492618561,
0.13550029695034027,
0.25903236865997314,
0.7970070242881775,
-0.12978971004486084,
0.06555892527103424,
-0.03379371762275696,
0.28050196170806885,
0.1703799068927765,
0.11408084630966187,
-0.19615484774112701,
-0.19356167316436768,
-0.05394335091114044,
0.9429391026496887,
0.796461820602417,
-1.1461262702941895,
0.7030988335609436,
0.0031756695825606585,
-0.13943101465702057,
-0.5752697587013245,
0.025181913748383522,
-0.28650039434432983,
0.4473971128463745,
0.48977160453796387,
-0.3242743909358978,
0.549820601940155,
-0.5022220015525818,
0.47509700059890747,
0.7126539349555969,
-0.2859855890274048,
-0.04884771630167961,
0.5251400470733643,
-0.15193109214305878,
-0.07263730466365814,
0.7820820212364197,
-0.4521046280860901,
-0.33210721611976624,
0.34693172574043274,
0.9755030274391174,
0.7505240440368652,
0.2685372829437256,
0.3757901191711426,
0.4779232442378998,
-0.17582610249519348,
-0.5104773044586182,
0.4196361303329468,
-0.6126796007156372,
-0.47393086552619934,
-0.4540092349052429,
-0.7578803896903992,
-0.48009347915649414,
-0.07754019647836685,
-0.7664095163345337,
-0.0023568745236843824,
-0.6124696135520935,
0.376926064491272,
-0.5255804657936096,
0.0934535339474678,
-0.635159432888031,
-0.11680325120687485,
-0.11355631798505783,
0.9754844903945923,
-0.3267929255962372,
0.8259633779525757,
0.28335291147232056,
-0.4446669816970825,
-0.8519500494003296,
-0.014450028538703918,
0.2280406951904297,
-0.883791446685791,
0.7310845851898193,
0.18707533180713654,
-0.0873369351029396,
0.32505449652671814,
-0.6285746097564697,
-1.220733404159546,
1.1076362133026123,
0.4745582044124603,
-0.4220624566078186,
-0.14193257689476013,
-0.3694998621940613,
0.23265507817268372,
-0.40024858713150024,
0.2155885398387909,
0.7395171523094177,
0.14900299906730652,
0.2888258993625641,
-0.5272142887115479,
-0.11245043575763702,
-0.12903225421905518,
0.5168235301971436,
0.07749980688095093,
-0.523189902305603,
0.7255086898803711,
-0.029546665027737617,
-0.08891251683235168,
0.17679882049560547,
0.6212584972381592,
0.6036669015884399,
0.18513599038124084,
0.36382371187210083,
0.6587885618209839,
0.803255558013916,
0.09164905548095703,
1.426539659500122,
-0.11986278742551804,
0.3492593467235565,
1.4270617961883545,
-0.28776341676712036,
1.025176763534546,
0.7975043058395386,
0.1911424845457077,
0.5892941951751709,
0.780299186706543,
0.3436530530452728,
1.0250262022018433,
0.37175270915031433,
-0.5091855525970459,
-0.07268421351909637,
-0.35138991475105286,
0.22662514448165894,
0.4848422408103943,
0.5362051725387573,
-0.29966333508491516,
-0.7544416189193726,
0.42815783619880676,
0.009326516650617123,
0.1727297604084015,
-0.3457488417625427,
1.1424367427825928,
0.013656249269843102,
-0.9795584678649902,
0.4775456190109253,
0.00407340656965971,
0.4107295870780945,
-0.6619371175765991,
-0.17384742200374603,
-0.0746367946267128,
0.3864574730396271,
0.08847858756780624,
-0.5232433080673218,
0.2055170089006424,
-0.443655401468277,
-0.02449711598455906,
-0.39895954728126526,
0.5814991593360901,
-0.6054633855819702,
-0.10315799713134766,
0.5008985996246338,
0.22723282873630524,
-0.09372095763683319,
0.005998378153890371,
-0.7010465860366821,
0.09415159374475479,
-0.11176988482475281,
-0.5425271391868591,
0.5244298577308655,
0.1774856448173523,
-0.3222290277481079,
0.7601903080940247,
0.30012720823287964,
-0.18828819692134857,
0.23799705505371094,
-0.032238028943538666,
1.039810299873352,
-0.4754101634025574,
-0.6354978680610657,
-0.585477352142334,
0.3606514632701874,
-0.15439185500144958,
-0.21945308148860931,
0.34003007411956787,
0.36504656076431274,
1.4054112434387207,
0.17994607985019684,
0.6216604113578796,
-0.1833118349313736,
0.29393741488456726,
-0.6166037321090698,
-0.08530426025390625,
-0.6383428573608398,
0.39262765645980835,
0.15325388312339783,
-0.929343581199646,
0.10067138075828552,
0.8072150945663452,
-0.45539239048957825,
-0.19541893899440765,
0.7092525959014893,
0.713745653629303,
-0.08601384609937668,
0.0025165078695863485,
0.028823750093579292,
-0.11359932273626328,
0.4245412051677704,
0.6105620861053467,
0.7133190631866455,
-0.19218693673610687,
0.3378329277038574,
-0.5198562145233154,
-0.05893747881054878,
-0.21471886336803436,
-1.008378505706787,
-0.47273069620132446,
-0.7063412666320801,
0.12099103629589081,
-0.3604174554347992,
0.16638141870498657,
1.3318216800689697,
0.5278029441833496,
-0.6187846064567566,
-0.42999860644340515,
-0.3399691581726074,
0.10779352486133575,
-0.38303521275520325,
-0.3056361973285675,
0.20356255769729614,
-0.9264938831329346,
-0.7679957151412964,
0.9403219819068909,
0.42057985067367554,
-0.6740180850028992,
-0.12601329386234283,
-0.24288541078567505,
-0.31823405623435974,
-0.273225873708725,
0.7743552923202515,
0.705658495426178,
-0.6907755732536316,
-0.3228662312030792,
-0.07993139326572418,
0.0008408918511122465,
0.18439890444278717,
1.0544755458831787,
-1.0841257572174072,
0.7761184573173523,
0.45618361234664917,
1.2861407995224,
0.9704018831253052,
-0.21881839632987976,
0.6036274433135986,
-1.0024651288986206,
0.16999012231826782,
0.40686461329460144,
0.38850340247154236,
0.16853520274162292,
-0.12737572193145752,
0.5054203271865845,
-0.02816559188067913,
-0.4311496615409851,
-0.7070138454437256,
0.17344620823860168,
-0.6899091601371765,
-0.45947304368019104,
1.006888747215271,
-0.16499736905097961,
-0.4862790107727051,
0.035012826323509216,
-0.07943028211593628,
-0.17136269807815552,
-0.5228096842765808,
0.7935400009155273,
0.31527766585350037,
-0.19993014633655548,
-0.1597929447889328,
-0.4553149342536926,
0.6259652972221375,
0.5940836668014526,
-0.6868399977684021,
-0.21999293565750122,
0.5169124603271484,
0.4265502989292145,
-0.16831760108470917,
0.9252517819404602,
-0.17311494052410126,
0.19582635164260864,
-0.23264463245868683,
-0.36957746744155884,
0.23823770880699158,
-0.6086348295211792,
-0.4104836881160736,
0.2810952365398407,
0.10848046839237213,
0.04967404529452324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14737v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14737v1 | Dissecting the Ullman Variations with a SCALPEL: Why do LLMs fail at Trivial Alterations to the False Belief Task? | 2024-06-20T21:02:30 | 2024-06-20T21:02:30 | Zhiqiang Pi, Annapurna Vadaparty, Benjamin K. Bergen, Cameron R. Jones | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent empirical results have sparked a debate about whether or not Large
Language Models (LLMs) are capable of Theory of Mind (ToM). While some have
found LLMs to be successful on ToM evaluations such as the False Belief task
(Kosinski, 2023), others have argued that LLMs solve these tasks by exploiting
spurious correlations -- not representing beliefs -- since they fail on trivial
alterations to these tasks (Ullman, 2023). In this paper, we introduce SCALPEL:
a technique to generate targeted modifications for False Belief tasks to test
different specific hypotheses about why LLMs fail. We find that modifications
which make explicit common inferences -- such as that looking at a transparent
object implies recognizing its contents -- preserve LLMs' performance. This
suggests that LLMs' failures on modified ToM tasks could result from a lack of
more general commonsense reasoning, rather than a failure to represent mental
states. We argue that SCALPEL could be helpful for explaining LLM successes and
failures in other cases. | [
-0.5237377882003784,
-0.7243449091911316,
1.0636142492294312,
-0.03547408804297447,
-0.06690449267625809,
0.019907793030142784,
-0.27038589119911194,
-0.1506842076778412,
0.3142353892326355,
0.30610743165016174,
-0.6121825575828552,
-0.23870322108268738,
-0.6427531838417053,
-0.03607280179858208,
-0.5671991109848022,
0.9539135098457336,
-0.11176207661628723,
-0.14447201788425446,
0.06141982600092888,
-0.015227907337248325,
-0.22660882771015167,
-0.3963773846626282,
-0.5329826474189758,
-0.6256199479103088,
0.7982574701309204,
0.4495108127593994,
0.7352336049079895,
0.42882972955703735,
0.638481855392456,
0.25977665185928345,
-0.18031281232833862,
0.3792096972465515,
-0.35207417607307434,
0.024489035829901695,
-0.615190863609314,
-0.8689804673194885,
-0.32139086723327637,
0.26757311820983887,
0.6953202486038208,
1.013819694519043,
0.0057757082395255566,
-0.13065004348754883,
0.3570244312286377,
0.6286851763725281,
-0.5757378935813904,
-0.308084100484848,
-1.0427254438400269,
0.1105186939239502,
-0.2098902463912964,
-0.10499949753284454,
-0.4152330756187439,
0.16287711262702942,
-0.013260905630886555,
-0.23960211873054504,
0.48516592383384705,
0.13512007892131805,
0.6803410053253174,
0.1931067407131195,
-0.4657049775123596,
-0.2873172163963318,
-0.9382889270782471,
1.0320204496383667,
-0.7842425107955933,
0.229703888297081,
0.3790101706981659,
0.14841511845588684,
-0.42014840245246887,
-0.4218149185180664,
-0.6628689765930176,
-0.19043485820293427,
-0.09970031678676605,
-0.160505011677742,
-0.39993613958358765,
0.19893570244312286,
0.42978277802467346,
0.3070107102394104,
-0.365200936794281,
-0.007072106469422579,
-0.016916973516345024,
0.07539419084787369,
0.2972589433193207,
0.25025078654289246,
-0.09779825806617737,
-0.25290998816490173,
-0.08683440834283829,
-0.496640682220459,
-0.5939945578575134,
-0.14796552062034607,
0.20591211318969727,
0.1416289508342743,
0.10456561297178268,
0.5599027276039124,
0.08002263307571411,
0.521853506565094,
0.5018950700759888,
-0.2515856623649597,
-0.04991709440946579,
0.3313697278499603,
-0.4854976236820221,
-0.22998756170272827,
0.45006364583969116,
0.378910630941391,
0.022160666063427925,
-0.09573355317115784,
-0.18860286474227905,
0.30824294686317444,
0.4722735285758972,
-0.3553119897842407,
-0.2768480181694031,
0.3752673864364624,
-0.5557079315185547,
-0.3775746524333954,
-0.008378072641789913,
-0.5340474843978882,
-0.5257003307342529,
-0.21925242245197296,
0.4185807406902313,
-0.5131523609161377,
-0.19382967054843903,
0.13653433322906494,
-0.26029905676841736,
0.19965028762817383,
0.5004794001579285,
-0.6020866632461548,
0.19011525809764862,
0.7581804990768433,
0.7258803248405457,
-0.25157225131988525,
-0.5221660733222961,
-0.123362697660923,
0.15265344083309174,
-0.8501771688461304,
1.0603264570236206,
-0.46203702688217163,
-0.5186856389045715,
-0.09086426347494125,
-0.1273634284734726,
-0.2528654932975769,
-0.6126605868339539,
0.5239990949630737,
-0.10763313621282578,
-0.01783648319542408,
-0.7553324699401855,
-0.6707862615585327,
-0.2935671806335449,
0.22866606712341309,
-0.1522829681634903,
0.6319137215614319,
-0.02858900837600231,
-0.9171740412712097,
0.06382779031991959,
-0.6176973581314087,
-0.4520377814769745,
-0.3037451505661011,
-0.5088512897491455,
-0.13696067035198212,
0.7455552220344543,
-0.09979169815778732,
0.510837972164154,
-0.0587647370994091,
0.2006644606590271,
-0.7031207084655762,
-0.5460411906242371,
0.7427154183387756,
-0.5066800117492676,
0.6976983547210693,
0.21204951405525208,
-0.5715240836143494,
-0.026767710223793983,
-0.6248049736022949,
-0.08914276957511902,
0.24521023035049438,
0.04837796464562416,
-0.4167139232158661,
0.2739010453224182,
-0.16481389105319977,
-0.19018322229385376,
0.03027944453060627,
-0.5138537883758545,
0.31511572003364563,
-0.4382331371307373,
0.07959883660078049,
1.1613093614578247,
-0.0996006578207016,
0.25789085030555725,
-0.5612244606018066,
0.1891723871231079,
0.163519486784935,
-0.034721046686172485,
0.04618410766124725,
-0.46609073877334595,
-1.374814510345459,
0.03826608881354332,
-0.02131453901529312,
0.3364483118057251,
-0.5930622220039368,
0.1249777153134346,
-0.01785012148320675,
-0.45920610427856445,
-0.16176168620586395,
0.10195095092058182,
0.5914937257766724,
0.43780940771102905,
0.13378189504146576,
-0.1296684741973877,
-0.5956658124923706,
-1.228988528251648,
-0.5955941677093506,
-0.15428832173347473,
-0.14878162741661072,
0.2298857867717743,
0.5776786208152771,
-0.45468682050704956,
0.6724586486816406,
-0.6103993654251099,
-0.4633845090866089,
-0.1965821087360382,
0.39038029313087463,
0.5863447189331055,
0.47669821977615356,
0.567998468875885,
-0.4048899710178375,
-0.22244876623153687,
0.1179879680275917,
-0.7690373063087463,
0.24379394948482513,
-0.17655089497566223,
0.11058084666728973,
0.21764318645000458,
0.42220163345336914,
-0.7982646226882935,
0.618949830532074,
0.3966159224510193,
-0.26479846239089966,
0.7516705393791199,
-0.41240984201431274,
0.12373171746730804,
-0.8300809264183044,
-0.06895028054714203,
0.006643191911280155,
-0.07175863534212112,
-0.6202998161315918,
0.15835502743721008,
0.14787280559539795,
0.34315991401672363,
-0.2946997284889221,
0.2134159505367279,
-0.28000932931900024,
-0.13438482582569122,
-0.7223421931266785,
-0.15371203422546387,
-0.2620069682598114,
0.5662018060684204,
-0.223280668258667,
0.620629072189331,
0.34881386160850525,
-0.6734269857406616,
0.15777558088302612,
0.12496035546064377,
-0.09041977673768997,
0.9323641061782837,
-0.6159153580665588,
0.5532711744308472,
-0.3525475561618805,
0.1147402971982956,
-1.0733976364135742,
-0.544409453868866,
0.28531786799430847,
-0.3168054223060608,
0.2985104024410248,
-0.16528570652008057,
-0.2728913426399231,
-0.48476529121398926,
-0.3414911925792694,
0.0016349474899470806,
0.5681873559951782,
-0.6175346374511719,
0.568928062915802,
0.1695481836795807,
0.22339047491550446,
-0.5527880191802979,
-0.8554965853691101,
0.26554223895072937,
-0.3752291798591614,
-0.27596068382263184,
0.34614863991737366,
-0.36672189831733704,
-0.7567073106765747,
0.008476992137730122,
-0.3029191195964813,
0.018949169665575027,
0.14470486342906952,
0.3258276581764221,
0.14267516136169434,
-0.12111359089612961,
-0.03372500464320183,
0.127892404794693,
0.0030785799026489258,
0.21380044519901276,
-0.19600984454154968,
0.3072618842124939,
-0.26604267954826355,
-0.8245877027511597,
-0.4318760335445404,
0.32076403498649597,
0.3922194242477417,
0.3644258975982666,
0.4080581068992615,
0.38632452487945557,
-0.39367029070854187,
-0.467680424451828,
-0.7525829672813416,
-0.2943160831928253,
-0.536920428276062,
0.3697124123573303,
-0.6048116683959961,
-0.8006929159164429,
0.22360831499099731,
-0.15020231902599335,
0.0767049714922905,
0.32595735788345337,
0.4503987729549408,
-0.7154751420021057,
0.9134916067123413,
0.6808414459228516,
0.14579805731773376,
0.12659329175949097,
-0.22359134256839752,
0.2514703571796417,
-1.0245507955551147,
0.22089610993862152,
-0.42161667346954346,
-0.4543382525444031,
-0.4760569632053375,
-0.6291002035140991,
0.6381404399871826,
-0.0018438156694173813,
-0.05544104799628258,
0.2039545625448227,
-0.35273629426956177,
0.6917669773101807,
0.5508527755737305,
0.09018529951572418,
0.15302133560180664,
0.17339128255844116,
-0.23939061164855957,
-0.11407903581857681,
-0.5647344589233398,
-0.5794838070869446,
1.3851255178451538,
0.40885668992996216,
0.9032336473464966,
0.09284945577383041,
0.6236670613288879,
0.3975221812725067,
0.2733798623085022,
-0.5264778733253479,
0.6661540269851685,
-0.2465028464794159,
-0.5914397239685059,
-0.10930834710597992,
-0.0619271881878376,
-0.8749279975891113,
0.545559823513031,
0.03453858569264412,
-0.8765018582344055,
0.3406239449977875,
0.5285007357597351,
-0.29065266251564026,
0.5375919342041016,
-0.33279505372047424,
0.4632376432418823,
-0.1824682354927063,
-0.1674620509147644,
-0.49489229917526245,
-0.28034842014312744,
0.43715259432792664,
-0.15612460672855377,
0.3827820420265198,
0.06334356218576431,
0.20484180748462677,
0.958899736404419,
0.0032622474245727062,
1.0828567743301392,
-0.016466308385133743,
-0.22817327082157135,
0.1426718831062317,
0.5665472745895386,
0.6843545436859131,
-0.018721232190728188,
0.1781819462776184,
0.11329714953899384,
-0.035018324851989746,
-0.34782567620277405,
-0.8672897815704346,
0.7979243993759155,
-0.6627017855644226,
-1.0038989782333374,
-0.5667713284492493,
-0.8354605436325073,
-0.6725519299507141,
0.09655819833278656,
0.1498142033815384,
0.23877082765102386,
-0.04381879046559334,
0.18900196254253387,
0.8674033284187317,
-0.08607500791549683,
0.3832249641418457,
0.4639914631843567,
-0.4404522478580475,
-0.3197648227214813,
0.5423291325569153,
0.06808378547430038,
0.13639478385448456,
0.02729976549744606,
0.11063947528600693,
0.0710095465183258,
-0.7264552116394043,
0.020505160093307495,
0.3864248991012573,
-0.9740228056907654,
0.052331794053316116,
-0.4877304136753082,
-0.04077216982841492,
-0.2521008551120758,
-0.2778434157371521,
-0.5955318808555603,
-0.2824269235134125,
-0.1379701793193817,
-0.12189379334449768,
0.03857400268316269,
1.200545310974121,
-0.6082354187965393,
0.23624613881111145,
-0.34761571884155273,
0.24856233596801758,
0.4017545282840729,
0.2355906367301941,
0.22526153922080994,
-0.7275775074958801,
-0.3138144314289093,
0.34107163548469543,
-0.5051007866859436,
-0.9590234756469727,
0.17628635466098785,
-0.2001676857471466,
0.4875928461551666,
0.6544281840324402,
-0.024832893162965775,
0.9431323409080505,
-0.5693450570106506,
0.47118881344795227,
0.20690137147903442,
-0.9394540786743164,
0.5382463932037354,
-0.631212592124939,
0.01565892994403839,
0.10510135442018509,
0.3481922447681427,
-0.4879496097564697,
-0.5101794004440308,
-0.6525371074676514,
-0.3025495111942291,
0.4922943711280823,
0.04083894565701485,
0.1376505345106125,
-0.1563677191734314,
0.38394632935523987,
0.1550576090812683,
0.10185763239860535,
-0.5282573699951172,
-0.4338473677635193,
0.0901198759675026,
-0.06920859962701797,
-0.3999604284763336,
-0.5828016996383667,
-0.5040499567985535,
-0.3493744730949402,
0.5712423324584961,
-0.2055644690990448,
0.5618977546691895,
0.5581599473953247,
-0.01966651901602745,
-0.44942620396614075,
0.30458879470825195,
0.8091748356819153,
0.909903347492218,
-0.45439136028289795,
0.5099737048149109,
0.1990397721529007,
-0.07122288644313812,
0.092806376516819,
-0.25761398673057556,
-0.12928538024425507,
0.06795560568571091,
0.4382849335670471,
0.8466832041740417,
0.3328850269317627,
-0.47922253608703613,
0.32567331194877625,
0.14805173873901367,
-0.5174749493598938,
-0.45617273449897766,
0.06031422317028046,
0.03845671936869621,
0.5019456148147583,
0.5750245451927185,
0.44566240906715393,
-0.030207034200429916,
-0.6407339572906494,
0.12548545002937317,
0.7248938679695129,
-0.21552208065986633,
-0.39201852679252625,
0.5454803705215454,
-0.1953335851430893,
-0.4104670584201813,
0.37054187059402466,
-0.19196946918964386,
-0.4647905230522156,
0.28698137402534485,
0.6211488246917725,
0.9069035053253174,
-0.10942807048559189,
0.2271973043680191,
-0.057949941605329514,
0.49635088443756104,
-0.03447004035115242,
0.024300135672092438,
0.18768136203289032,
-0.9726470708847046,
-0.3518284857273102,
-0.3486083149909973,
-0.7042219638824463,
0.48583483695983887,
-0.5988883972167969,
-0.15683311223983765,
-0.7455360293388367,
-0.180031418800354,
-0.08784341812133789,
-0.41599422693252563,
-0.6383790373802185,
0.11588361114263535,
0.15187135338783264,
0.6171721816062927,
-0.7711086273193359,
0.7338071465492249,
0.8235644698143005,
-0.22799162566661835,
-0.6296531558036804,
0.4197461009025574,
0.160634383559227,
-0.7512812614440918,
0.7393746972084045,
-0.07931343466043472,
-0.10316138714551926,
-0.2954705059528351,
-0.546809196472168,
-1.0111119747161865,
0.643424928188324,
0.42735955119132996,
-0.6098380088806152,
-0.3016011714935303,
0.25390318036079407,
0.468171089887619,
-0.21057550609111786,
0.1508006900548935,
0.3943256437778473,
0.5365996956825256,
-0.0598703995347023,
-1.1305595636367798,
0.0025516541209071875,
0.23870770633220673,
0.1694803535938263,
-0.08910082280635834,
-0.48686483502388,
1.303322196006775,
-0.3467511236667633,
0.08334589749574661,
0.004995543044060469,
0.7149056792259216,
0.22465409338474274,
0.2756815552711487,
0.5316292643547058,
0.7160037755966187,
0.7274774312973022,
0.2234121561050415,
1.136730670928955,
-0.12871433794498444,
0.5500985980033875,
1.024005651473999,
-0.29610303044319153,
0.9310465455055237,
0.6902213096618652,
-0.5516639351844788,
0.49918049573898315,
0.23850537836551666,
0.035591598600149155,
0.3292057514190674,
-0.010879470966756344,
0.028204599395394325,
-0.5127856135368347,
0.2336142361164093,
-0.16115780174732208,
0.6420377492904663,
0.426704078912735,
-0.24429701268672943,
-0.34253743290901184,
0.21883901953697205,
0.24594996869564056,
0.11274079978466034,
-0.27536123991012573,
0.25491467118263245,
0.3446241021156311,
-0.6543819904327393,
0.9449552297592163,
0.07032769918441772,
0.8024886250495911,
-0.3697820007801056,
-0.05432664230465889,
-0.30548983812332153,
0.7390445470809937,
-0.11410922557115555,
-0.6257140040397644,
0.49676647782325745,
-0.1580379605293274,
-0.12382529675960541,
-0.2335549145936966,
0.8589625954627991,
0.056531742215156555,
-0.6867271661758423,
0.21616922318935394,
0.515442967414856,
0.27636778354644775,
-0.3009510934352875,
-0.6965326070785522,
0.4003302752971649,
0.2495477944612503,
-0.32542356848716736,
0.5380486845970154,
0.21327252686023712,
0.24259397387504578,
0.7401561737060547,
0.5795813202857971,
0.11896029859781265,
-0.26970577239990234,
-0.3047970235347748,
0.6983194351196289,
-0.8764398097991943,
-0.23730352520942688,
-0.969576895236969,
0.15460054576396942,
-0.07233534008264542,
-0.06837619841098785,
1.0544919967651367,
0.2146500051021576,
0.8968663215637207,
-0.3253552317619324,
0.8619025349617004,
0.12254536896944046,
0.8910125494003296,
-0.40602269768714905,
0.8466021418571472,
-0.6760867238044739,
0.21066869795322418,
-0.4843370318412781,
-0.8136526346206665,
-0.025183387100696564,
1.0084054470062256,
-0.2912321388721466,
-0.0682448297739029,
1.221166729927063,
0.6395437717437744,
-0.08473455905914307,
-0.15295825898647308,
0.6744102835655212,
0.6654772758483887,
0.25495630502700806,
0.6416606903076172,
0.8119527697563171,
-0.3437212109565735,
0.4089359939098358,
-0.5513595938682556,
-0.2908335030078888,
-0.1629054695367813,
-0.8350329399108887,
-1.2500011920928955,
-0.6356484293937683,
-0.3465850055217743,
-0.4312913119792938,
0.23049335181713104,
0.8676247596740723,
0.5490531921386719,
-0.7778152823448181,
-0.5005878806114197,
-0.211434006690979,
0.111795574426651,
-0.16515269875526428,
-0.1936769336462021,
0.2694392204284668,
-0.3627377152442932,
-0.6312925219535828,
0.747568666934967,
0.34561780095100403,
0.06407129764556885,
-0.26031696796417236,
0.158392071723938,
-0.03691522032022476,
0.3723839521408081,
0.3904307782649994,
0.20072133839130402,
-1.1593005657196045,
-0.673651397228241,
-0.15273092687129974,
0.27152520418167114,
-0.03970574960112572,
0.8350457549095154,
-0.6824628114700317,
-0.03622286394238472,
-0.14616012573242188,
0.5290911793708801,
0.28488436341285706,
-0.4828853905200958,
0.46850401163101196,
-0.21906627714633942,
0.04971218481659889,
0.008352951146662235,
0.6322425007820129,
0.20919108390808105,
-0.0994143858551979,
0.28939080238342285,
0.5741888880729675,
-0.4414328336715698,
-1.1827080249786377,
0.4566170871257782,
-0.8758118748664856,
-0.623464047908783,
1.3035842180252075,
-0.0563059002161026,
-0.3794446885585785,
0.07406862825155258,
-0.2601083219051361,
-0.15198466181755066,
-0.022760780528187752,
0.9885483384132385,
0.6881725788116455,
-0.42737409472465515,
0.0030727097764611244,
-0.3336750268936157,
0.39427098631858826,
0.7637102007865906,
-0.3114762306213379,
0.08774106204509735,
0.30475080013275146,
0.561064600944519,
0.3348216116428375,
0.5814027786254883,
0.20329368114471436,
0.15023553371429443,
0.14808836579322815,
-0.18755535781383514,
0.10248306393623352,
-0.18531787395477295,
-0.1556614339351654,
0.08146879822015762,
0.3911457657814026,
-0.06285405904054642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14732v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14732v1 | TTQA-RS- A break-down prompting approach for Multi-hop Table-Text Question Answering with Reasoning and Summarization | 2024-06-20T20:55:38 | 2024-06-20T20:55:38 | Jayetri Bardhan, Bushi Xiao, Daisy Zhe Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Question answering (QA) over tables and text has gained much popularity over
the years. Multi-hop table-text QA requires multiple hops between the table and
text, making it a challenging QA task. Although several works have attempted to
solve the table-text QA task, most involve training the models and requiring
labeled data. In this paper, we have proposed a model - TTQA-RS: A break-down
prompting approach for Multi-hop Table-Text Question Answering with Reasoning
and Summarization. Our model uses augmented knowledge including table-text
summary with decomposed sub-question with answer for a reasoning-based
table-text QA. Using open-source language models our model outperformed all
existing prompting methods for table-text QA tasks on existing table-text QA
datasets like HybridQA and OTT-QA's development set. Our results are comparable
with the training-based state-of-the-art models, demonstrating the potential of
prompt-based approaches using open-source LLMs. Additionally, by using GPT-4
with LLaMA3-70B, our model achieved state-of-the-art performance for
prompting-based methods on multi-hop table-text QA. | [
-0.3660229444503784,
-0.9275002479553223,
0.8415395021438599,
0.10009678453207016,
-0.3346714675426483,
0.10896267741918564,
0.3445743918418884,
-0.12947775423526764,
0.14629270136356354,
0.37121251225471497,
-0.6740628480911255,
-0.3242610991001129,
-0.29450029134750366,
0.62090665102005,
-0.3789980709552765,
0.9311338067054749,
-0.16476140916347504,
0.0655272975564003,
-0.19656337797641754,
0.033949244767427444,
-1.067015528678894,
-0.34408804774284363,
-0.5484709739685059,
-0.015912039205431938,
0.6055518984794617,
0.5707245469093323,
0.4454993009567261,
0.44133034348487854,
0.20522557199001312,
0.1946430206298828,
-0.3830488920211792,
0.18274345993995667,
0.12615886330604553,
0.2944962680339813,
-0.017110643908381462,
-0.3632487654685974,
-0.5599045157432556,
-0.13866963982582092,
0.48786717653274536,
0.2578871548175812,
-0.06007402762770653,
0.22697684168815613,
-0.1413819044828415,
0.7044968008995056,
-0.39526113867759705,
0.08202345669269562,
-0.41588422656059265,
0.030248237773776054,
-0.012454519979655743,
-0.31280097365379333,
-0.7202369570732117,
-0.6784943342208862,
0.001221650978550315,
-0.5244224667549133,
-0.1470232903957367,
-0.03292784094810486,
0.6382936835289001,
0.14336301386356354,
-0.7014175057411194,
-0.36758410930633545,
-0.4653347432613373,
0.4932563006877899,
-0.6506395936012268,
0.603996992111206,
0.24837598204612732,
0.2618236541748047,
0.13149966299533844,
-0.5541150569915771,
-0.736228346824646,
-0.44882991909980774,
-0.024865107610821724,
0.15504412353038788,
0.08779080957174301,
-0.14809446036815643,
0.3916507363319397,
0.05925377085804939,
-0.7635062336921692,
-0.24007567763328552,
-0.4656062722206116,
0.28325513005256653,
0.013838497921824455,
0.1872500330209732,
0.5495175123214722,
-0.20843671262264252,
-0.5471420884132385,
0.1505924016237259,
-0.7356699705123901,
0.11037321388721466,
-0.24293078482151031,
0.5046902894973755,
-0.059635937213897705,
0.8155561089515686,
-0.3959653377532959,
0.8833684325218201,
-0.1489984691143036,
-0.152011901140213,
-0.0005314950249157846,
-0.4162469208240509,
-0.19710421562194824,
-0.21165230870246887,
0.5732632279396057,
0.2510872185230255,
0.37682831287384033,
-0.30230557918548584,
-0.03886469453573227,
-0.07651608437299728,
-0.04411287233233452,
-0.4377368986606598,
-0.15251629054546356,
0.44215038418769836,
-0.24249297380447388,
-0.2530099153518677,
-0.3138085901737213,
-0.9478635787963867,
-0.2909671366214752,
-0.2958501875400543,
1.0270304679870605,
-0.4127841889858246,
-0.013229290954768658,
-0.1315138190984726,
-0.2820948660373688,
0.5057088732719421,
0.4773074984550476,
-0.6230303645133972,
0.16942258179187775,
0.2756563723087311,
1.0817999839782715,
-0.26353153586387634,
-0.36690759658813477,
-0.9468790292739868,
0.4348984956741333,
-0.1565716415643692,
0.8150337338447571,
-0.43550416827201843,
-0.44327449798583984,
-0.15691561996936798,
-0.3074388802051544,
-0.178850457072258,
-0.23345480859279633,
0.26089218258857727,
-0.7897742986679077,
0.5000095367431641,
-0.60709148645401,
-0.42090725898742676,
-0.1352122277021408,
0.8108853697776794,
-0.8000713586807251,
0.9582263231277466,
-0.04941267520189285,
-0.9885097146034241,
0.11233091354370117,
-1.0113970041275024,
-0.38322603702545166,
-0.046281781047582626,
-0.05210351198911667,
-0.28467655181884766,
-0.4381090998649597,
0.9366499781608582,
0.1445235311985016,
-0.28299233317375183,
0.13014112412929535,
-0.03494342043995857,
-0.28363555669784546,
0.3213246762752533,
-0.30620455741882324,
0.6973119378089905,
0.052511297166347504,
0.007166558876633644,
0.23831915855407715,
-0.40668344497680664,
0.17247402667999268,
0.1360693722963333,
-0.4511435925960541,
-0.09094090759754181,
-0.2403864860534668,
-0.45770248770713806,
0.43121057748794556,
-0.03400355204939842,
-0.2790594696998596,
0.3916577398777008,
-0.10741421580314636,
0.43564197421073914,
0.36461713910102844,
0.3816843330860138,
0.2586362659931183,
-0.6003068685531616,
0.8721171617507935,
0.06315959244966507,
0.06894535571336746,
-0.5648362040519714,
-0.6307163834571838,
-0.42627474665641785,
-0.2872181534767151,
0.47783392667770386,
0.9109511971473694,
-1.1418946981430054,
-0.015694472938776016,
0.057021334767341614,
-0.3981419503688812,
-0.3026294410228729,
-0.4057701528072357,
0.40447357296943665,
1.0264594554901123,
0.9056298136711121,
0.35275813937187195,
-0.29798802733421326,
-0.36602601408958435,
-0.3201963007450104,
-0.18081314861774445,
-0.16627787053585052,
-0.12151765078306198,
0.5917258262634277,
0.25196555256843567,
1.000596284866333,
-0.5058040618896484,
-0.1134938895702362,
-0.6808252930641174,
0.12081755697727203,
0.05073890462517738,
0.4386911988258362,
0.14731475710868835,
-0.6267304420471191,
-0.4429228603839874,
-0.35555094480514526,
-0.5064118504524231,
-0.10674677044153214,
-0.007520240731537342,
-0.04792296886444092,
0.011155339889228344,
0.31544268131256104,
-0.8740499019622803,
0.4516999423503876,
0.18974941968917847,
-0.38399213552474976,
0.9804139137268066,
0.13493862748146057,
0.5362816452980042,
-1.3642470836639404,
0.176227867603302,
-0.11701030284166336,
0.037351593375205994,
-0.7018476128578186,
0.00940187182277441,
0.054182641208171844,
-0.32430896162986755,
-0.5296726226806641,
0.5458145141601562,
-0.5208025574684143,
-0.1672269105911255,
0.0967235192656517,
0.28879496455192566,
0.3282012343406677,
0.5640007853507996,
0.30491605401039124,
1.0382168292999268,
0.28503677248954773,
-0.8645831346511841,
0.15547281503677368,
0.8049848079681396,
0.07802718132734299,
0.3237455487251282,
-0.9920291304588318,
0.28248146176338196,
-0.06082236021757126,
0.36257514357566833,
-1.1390564441680908,
-0.11386575549840927,
0.42125236988067627,
-0.5258882641792297,
0.18455246090888977,
-0.2150341421365738,
-0.2481846809387207,
-0.20549629628658295,
-0.5974081158638,
0.6069669127464294,
0.3218957483768463,
-0.7267277836799622,
0.8691896796226501,
-0.0018352761399000883,
-0.4761156737804413,
-0.7432149648666382,
-0.6525925993919373,
0.015514453873038292,
-0.33534902334213257,
-0.5401847958564758,
0.2848626673221588,
-0.0841602310538292,
-0.23684385418891907,
-0.26790112257003784,
-0.05692029744386673,
-0.19102230668067932,
-0.1963326334953308,
-0.24222558736801147,
0.504590630531311,
-0.05358521640300751,
0.14328165352344513,
0.2907283306121826,
-0.04552124813199043,
0.09048356115818024,
0.012241004966199398,
0.4192247986793518,
-0.12146084010601044,
-0.09338417649269104,
-0.6419121623039246,
0.4725337028503418,
0.4242176115512848,
-0.7065836191177368,
0.6421224474906921,
0.033297184854745865,
-0.20792549848556519,
-0.025219283998012543,
-0.34062349796295166,
-0.3449702262878418,
-0.4089716672897339,
0.09654220193624496,
-0.42824870347976685,
-0.76844722032547,
0.5440049171447754,
-0.051189277321100235,
0.17503882944583893,
0.20403143763542175,
0.5574910640716553,
-0.21791084110736847,
0.7926480770111084,
0.1875217705965042,
0.34868481755256653,
0.1652252972126007,
0.12130899727344513,
-0.11223951727151871,
-0.5165753960609436,
-0.41102322936058044,
-1.0786495208740234,
0.08818629384040833,
-0.04149188846349716,
-0.32804980874061584,
0.6497132778167725,
0.056525010615587234,
-0.40934962034225464,
0.04360676556825638,
-0.47724834084510803,
0.6531786322593689,
0.6528394222259521,
0.19718433916568756,
0.7742324471473694,
-0.3312072157859802,
-0.1352076530456543,
0.24451646208763123,
-0.7174388766288757,
-0.28758180141448975,
0.6396228671073914,
0.26258811354637146,
0.682080864906311,
0.14784696698188782,
0.6680747866630554,
0.4357514977455139,
-0.0024954548571258783,
-0.7158395648002625,
0.5359889268875122,
0.40319135785102844,
-0.5092735290527344,
-0.5923136472702026,
-0.6685000658035278,
-0.5356014370918274,
0.15819694101810455,
-0.100242979824543,
-0.727074921131134,
-0.16349492967128754,
0.3202897310256958,
-0.3804633915424347,
0.31601962447166443,
-0.825031042098999,
0.9531625509262085,
0.0005977937253192067,
0.22983574867248535,
0.3218972086906433,
-0.8023914694786072,
0.7150432467460632,
0.14642201364040375,
0.277583509683609,
0.11490607261657715,
-0.03760560601949692,
0.8929800391197205,
-0.6312772035598755,
0.6832022070884705,
-0.2714841663837433,
-0.12095081806182861,
0.4128110408782959,
0.43033283948898315,
0.7001990675926208,
0.11250953376293182,
0.16795985400676727,
-0.22919221222400665,
0.38231316208839417,
-0.19625499844551086,
-0.6829099655151367,
0.06787465512752533,
-0.5045379400253296,
-0.2639158368110657,
-0.39610934257507324,
-0.5048867464065552,
-0.6763983368873596,
0.0058567156083881855,
0.3453526794910431,
0.794906735420227,
0.21704155206680298,
-0.2734890282154083,
0.8092999458312988,
-0.3077477812767029,
0.41550925374031067,
0.44217047095298767,
-0.3892928957939148,
-0.6613914966583252,
0.48273003101348877,
-0.026447342708706856,
0.19271951913833618,
0.7446544170379639,
0.31509822607040405,
-0.8160624504089355,
-0.5313804149627686,
-0.8128036856651306,
0.26967281103134155,
-0.4962027072906494,
-0.5038592219352722,
-0.686809241771698,
-0.014616519212722778,
-0.1836988478899002,
-0.18669389188289642,
0.09648370742797852,
-0.6381140351295471,
-0.1306561529636383,
-0.16900746524333954,
0.6522995829582214,
0.5918601751327515,
0.21286290884017944,
0.3742801249027252,
-1.3697562217712402,
0.7183355093002319,
0.6245542168617249,
0.3545122742652893,
0.24467241764068604,
-0.6865445375442505,
0.06384265422821045,
-0.38171106576919556,
-0.0020383517257869244,
-1.6735197305679321,
0.2656601667404175,
-0.14173398911952972,
0.13354094326496124,
-0.13492876291275024,
0.30949920415878296,
0.38637128472328186,
-0.5140892863273621,
0.8488562107086182,
0.17414982616901398,
-1.2501647472381592,
0.6743929386138916,
-0.5834077000617981,
0.5172993540763855,
0.5512301921844482,
0.3344075083732605,
-0.6640402674674988,
-0.3407667875289917,
-0.12978284060955048,
-0.5990429520606995,
0.7992356419563293,
0.025536131113767624,
-0.2637031674385071,
-0.03564378619194031,
0.3277771472930908,
0.26220420002937317,
0.11626407504081726,
-0.9797914028167725,
0.028339799493551254,
-0.01436595804989338,
-0.03700748085975647,
0.674218475818634,
-0.40066564083099365,
0.08580704778432846,
-0.000932105234824121,
0.82600337266922,
-0.08740827441215515,
0.2771475613117218,
0.128978431224823,
-0.21363522112369537,
0.16254696249961853,
0.8235172629356384,
0.5219447612762451,
0.7677564024925232,
-0.16948731243610382,
0.020351799204945564,
0.3529469668865204,
-0.4123991131782532,
0.3353661894798279,
0.02822807990014553,
-0.5105088949203491,
0.042102914303541183,
0.15933234989643097,
0.42534610629081726,
-0.24433760344982147,
-0.5514016151428223,
0.2942143380641937,
-0.24430441856384277,
-0.29787829518318176,
0.13494382798671722,
-0.2021450400352478,
0.09321470558643341,
0.172537162899971,
0.4320518672466278,
-0.3646939694881439,
0.2132025808095932,
-0.1507614701986313,
0.37680748105049133,
0.1039045974612236,
-0.19658976793289185,
-0.09077952802181244,
0.7233856320381165,
0.28004318475723267,
-0.2705036699771881,
0.6437150835990906,
-0.1486729234457016,
-0.46613797545433044,
0.4999839961528778,
0.4845562279224396,
0.7179746627807617,
-0.2925269901752472,
0.5439387559890747,
0.2864685356616974,
0.5057981610298157,
-0.1319514662027359,
0.8286781907081604,
-0.16364043951034546,
-0.4994872212409973,
-0.8663154244422913,
-0.18984070420265198,
-0.9310290217399597,
0.1453571617603302,
-0.6279649138450623,
0.28247663378715515,
-0.24635040760040283,
0.045176465064287186,
-0.21699005365371704,
-0.2959143817424774,
-0.1859186291694641,
0.26350468397140503,
-0.14958249032497406,
1.1381531953811646,
-0.727164626121521,
0.44894376397132874,
0.5347673892974854,
-0.7713184952735901,
-1.2079225778579712,
0.2016678750514984,
-0.12896579504013062,
-0.3088264763355255,
0.36008554697036743,
0.2231697142124176,
-0.010641956701874733,
0.1763741821050644,
-0.5304120182991028,
-0.7200022339820862,
0.971314549446106,
0.22783762216567993,
-0.14452378451824188,
-0.4496658444404602,
0.12205753475427628,
0.07090915739536285,
0.08596038818359375,
0.6340336799621582,
0.614960789680481,
0.5111961364746094,
0.2905239462852478,
-0.9339255094528198,
0.24124711751937866,
-0.024182705208659172,
-0.21075913310050964,
0.3239540755748749,
-0.4106924831867218,
0.8349083065986633,
-0.44420379400253296,
0.06660611927509308,
-0.08049459010362625,
0.6712241172790527,
0.9287527799606323,
0.411236435174942,
0.4994034767150879,
0.3570229411125183,
0.4289276599884033,
-0.05844421684741974,
0.492898166179657,
0.10151579976081848,
0.09014276415109634,
1.2471022605895996,
-0.2601507604122162,
0.9307889342308044,
0.3781239986419678,
-0.2951432168483734,
0.4594164192676544,
0.4736269414424896,
0.3232085406780243,
0.32903939485549927,
-0.13284102082252502,
-0.12779690325260162,
-0.07937867194414139,
0.07128793746232986,
-0.5059047937393188,
0.3672749996185303,
0.21140114963054657,
0.003748979652300477,
-0.6150265336036682,
0.010054639540612698,
-0.005801635794341564,
-0.1732630729675293,
-0.5348314642906189,
0.7561501860618591,
-0.09200209379196167,
-0.6587997674942017,
0.3895323872566223,
0.04694976657629013,
0.34931516647338867,
-0.6417691707611084,
-0.24915052950382233,
-0.34962671995162964,
-0.6146417856216431,
-0.06510631740093231,
-0.7964033484458923,
0.2943255603313446,
0.4257991313934326,
-0.13541314005851746,
-0.1274241954088211,
0.6414790153503418,
-0.5991491675376892,
-0.022708825767040253,
-0.08634532988071442,
1.0500078201293945,
0.1088554635643959,
-0.19290481507778168,
-0.573908269405365,
-0.06128307804465294,
-0.002938545774668455,
-0.34693971276283264,
0.09497355669736862,
0.5868574380874634,
0.04237000644207001,
0.609825611114502,
0.44464418292045593,
-0.3794804811477661,
-0.012862158939242363,
0.20077957212924957,
0.8843507170677185,
-0.8380357623100281,
-0.9899370670318604,
-0.7989007234573364,
0.7136034369468689,
0.32509011030197144,
-0.1901310682296753,
0.5001536011695862,
0.3290354907512665,
0.2829912006855011,
-0.26881706714630127,
0.7041910886764526,
-0.012897353619337082,
1.0339442491531372,
-0.8403770327568054,
0.4031759798526764,
-0.4364045560359955,
0.23795366287231445,
-0.4839593172073364,
-0.7724642157554626,
-0.25886163115501404,
0.0146347526460886,
-0.16732287406921387,
0.35319462418556213,
0.7359105944633484,
0.5138028860092163,
0.389150470495224,
0.1683984249830246,
0.07564981281757355,
-0.109321728348732,
0.22012855112552643,
0.4570232331752777,
1.1191647052764893,
-0.17658878862857819,
0.9787052273750305,
0.05110132694244385,
-0.31699472665786743,
0.10105985403060913,
-0.8657920956611633,
-1.0195833444595337,
-0.5445947051048279,
-0.30743688344955444,
-0.503023624420166,
-0.057414695620536804,
0.993950366973877,
0.1542847901582718,
-0.7616201043128967,
0.10208643972873688,
0.0009137867018580437,
0.30905699729919434,
-0.417408287525177,
-0.2532573342323303,
0.5707074999809265,
-0.3413819670677185,
-0.2717123329639435,
0.6328843235969543,
0.1903621405363083,
0.27550339698791504,
-0.05027054250240326,
0.27139878273010254,
-0.2905083894729614,
0.079228475689888,
0.5697965025901794,
0.4695165157318115,
-0.33441677689552307,
0.00793618056923151,
0.27184855937957764,
0.17584477365016937,
0.2543089687824249,
0.656185507774353,
-0.9442883729934692,
0.08341354131698608,
0.5831587314605713,
0.7083038687705994,
0.3680095970630646,
0.50306636095047,
0.4376634657382965,
-0.9583401083946228,
-0.3921811878681183,
0.4417196810245514,
0.0761832669377327,
0.1712026298046112,
-0.2936928868293762,
0.39647457003593445,
0.05897270515561104,
-0.6553629636764526,
-0.7362979650497437,
0.26503080129623413,
-1.1368839740753174,
-0.24448324739933014,
1.0657470226287842,
0.19564379751682281,
-0.12019331008195877,
-0.36270445585250854,
-0.4224488437175751,
0.33853036165237427,
-0.649844765663147,
0.8911920785903931,
0.3406716287136078,
-0.2906937897205353,
-0.5045151710510254,
-0.2945147454738617,
0.6503711938858032,
0.2747103273868561,
-1.2872183322906494,
0.18699678778648376,
0.5862762331962585,
0.02265460044145584,
-0.06580575555562973,
0.8717647194862366,
-0.17979420721530914,
0.5105152130126953,
-0.15296877920627594,
0.09534115344285965,
-0.44689494371414185,
-0.5375056862831116,
-0.3944160044193268,
0.4633362889289856,
0.021061565726995468,
-0.4088013172149658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14721v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14721v1 | 1+1>2: Can Large Language Models Serve as Cross-Lingual Knowledge Aggregators? | 2024-06-20T20:32:53 | 2024-06-20T20:32:53 | Yue Huang, Chenrui Fan, Yuan Li, Siyuan Wu, Tianyi Zhou, Xiangliang Zhang, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have garnered significant attention due to their
remarkable ability to process information across various languages. Despite
their capabilities, they exhibit inconsistencies in handling identical queries
in different languages, presenting challenges for further advancement. This
paper introduces a method to enhance the multilingual performance of LLMs by
aggregating knowledge from diverse languages. This approach incorporates a
low-resource knowledge detector specific to a language, a language selection
process, and mechanisms for answer replacement and integration. Our experiments
demonstrate notable performance improvements, particularly in reducing language
performance disparity. An ablation study confirms that each component of our
method significantly contributes to these enhancements. This research
highlights the inherent potential of LLMs to harmonize multilingual
capabilities and offers valuable insights for further exploration. | [
-0.5444232225418091,
-0.700059175491333,
0.4807869791984558,
0.08245320618152618,
-0.2505362927913666,
0.41942790150642395,
-0.42138373851776123,
-0.8836150169372559,
0.2670154869556427,
0.5149833559989929,
-0.1974887251853943,
-0.24347324669361115,
-0.7378921508789062,
0.2119787484407425,
-0.339338481426239,
0.435715913772583,
0.18332666158676147,
0.38702183961868286,
-0.21692302823066711,
-0.40752944350242615,
-0.2514861822128296,
-0.4869537651538849,
-0.5963010787963867,
-0.5793550610542297,
0.6650609970092773,
0.28561896085739136,
0.7708248496055603,
0.5093048810958862,
0.3560012876987457,
0.41615980863571167,
-0.31480053067207336,
0.5384613275527954,
-0.2960393726825714,
0.16563943028450012,
-0.43379148840904236,
-0.543321967124939,
-0.5018152594566345,
-0.5153231620788574,
0.9398190975189209,
0.9394693970680237,
-0.25207775831222534,
-0.02642674185335636,
0.062438949942588806,
0.36764097213745117,
-0.6214714646339417,
-0.1591830849647522,
-0.7434310913085938,
-0.11018406599760056,
-0.4010220468044281,
-0.14758172631263733,
-0.37956520915031433,
-0.19700554013252258,
-0.16258764266967773,
-0.41337624192237854,
-0.17867305874824524,
-0.002374524949118495,
0.44191208481788635,
0.11833824217319489,
-0.4273238182067871,
-0.19998739659786224,
-0.716597855091095,
0.9124812483787537,
-0.7381987571716309,
0.6274248957633972,
0.2713126540184021,
0.282962441444397,
0.22876639664173126,
-0.4091434180736542,
-0.4098076820373535,
0.1801336109638214,
-0.3538266718387604,
-0.2267417460680008,
-0.07776463776826859,
-0.18528904020786285,
0.14459553360939026,
0.5211821794509888,
-0.5996164083480835,
0.56742262840271,
-0.22848619520664215,
-0.2710062563419342,
0.5557312965393066,
0.22705604135990143,
0.4045116901397705,
0.14909718930721283,
-0.010968225076794624,
0.1889103502035141,
-0.785433292388916,
-0.07750491797924042,
0.3224972188472748,
0.5183453559875488,
-0.10288842767477036,
0.7533653974533081,
-0.3281669318675995,
0.974208652973175,
-0.1538400799036026,
-0.2628310024738312,
0.35383984446525574,
-0.3885490298271179,
-0.19556757807731628,
0.08951442688703537,
0.6468907594680786,
-0.04804243892431259,
0.16249817609786987,
-0.23821355402469635,
-0.16577795147895813,
-0.2775769531726837,
-0.19050687551498413,
-0.7280922532081604,
0.1937914341688156,
0.1318005919456482,
-0.2869366407394409,
0.07065880298614502,
-0.3091616630554199,
-0.6829545497894287,
-0.44238924980163574,
-0.34379419684410095,
0.12268462777137756,
-0.5211490988731384,
-0.6265420913696289,
0.15920531749725342,
-0.17083528637886047,
0.12620829045772552,
0.32926374673843384,
-0.9409127235412598,
0.10993558913469315,
0.7384912967681885,
0.7307928204536438,
-0.17351888120174408,
-0.4773818552494049,
-0.5849870443344116,
0.24261726438999176,
-0.34055662155151367,
0.7439147233963013,
-0.7237926125526428,
-0.33376237750053406,
0.29520750045776367,
-0.18987764418125153,
0.10874956101179123,
-0.6436120271682739,
-0.028054263442754745,
-1.0932542085647583,
0.07938587665557861,
-0.44732466340065,
-0.5467439889907837,
-0.12746411561965942,
0.4908880889415741,
-0.5819767713546753,
0.9608391523361206,
0.06268845498561859,
-0.6497299075126648,
0.33980217576026917,
-0.48865678906440735,
-0.6024636030197144,
0.29946500062942505,
-0.14505894482135773,
0.07716082781553268,
0.10220839083194733,
0.404801607131958,
0.3274220824241638,
-0.43196386098861694,
0.061246905475854874,
-0.1800568848848343,
-0.2578152120113373,
0.317510724067688,
-0.3008750379085541,
0.8077331781387329,
0.3132115304470062,
0.15045765042304993,
-0.02175183780491352,
-0.4988977313041687,
0.12025138735771179,
-0.028251521289348602,
-0.6024181842803955,
-0.7172435522079468,
-0.31304335594177246,
-0.14758816361427307,
0.2613116502761841,
0.5998983383178711,
-0.3392758071422577,
0.2342006266117096,
-0.3964661955833435,
-0.10927695035934448,
0.5077646374702454,
-0.1757642924785614,
0.6227425336837769,
-0.37558236718177795,
0.7336103916168213,
0.236500084400177,
-0.05948587879538536,
-0.19057653844356537,
-0.40219032764434814,
-0.6476438045501709,
-0.37778744101524353,
0.24955327808856964,
0.6319206953048706,
-1.1611772775650024,
0.19755543768405914,
-0.41575348377227783,
-0.5474324226379395,
-0.6040351986885071,
0.7825693488121033,
0.369825541973114,
0.27657556533813477,
0.4982509911060333,
-0.07214368879795074,
-0.5263586044311523,
-0.8300458192825317,
-0.4296102225780487,
-0.1380210965871811,
-0.020632704719901085,
0.27554649114608765,
-0.05447475612163544,
-0.2515592873096466,
0.6227583289146423,
-0.3460765480995178,
-0.08516333252191544,
-0.49558529257774353,
0.03002634271979332,
0.4411247670650482,
0.16266249120235443,
0.6218822002410889,
-0.7439385056495667,
-0.6993229389190674,
0.5307340621948242,
-0.8988354802131653,
-0.2648698389530182,
0.3659369945526123,
-0.13794749975204468,
0.4626912772655487,
0.4143192768096924,
-0.4115990102291107,
-0.2581360340118408,
0.7451032996177673,
-0.2655181884765625,
0.4631235897541046,
-0.12587852776050568,
0.35704734921455383,
-0.9530401229858398,
-0.07919232547283173,
-0.07206416130065918,
-0.21074213087558746,
-0.6773974895477295,
0.17363093793392181,
0.06772100925445557,
0.3157021105289459,
-0.7459554076194763,
0.9026135206222534,
-0.6080946326255798,
-0.30435633659362793,
-0.2806933522224426,
0.2228265404701233,
-0.09250475466251373,
0.14240124821662903,
0.06086922809481621,
0.7702078223228455,
0.7367724180221558,
-0.7153772711753845,
0.5734854936599731,
0.2567022442817688,
-0.6040737628936768,
0.6992537379264832,
-0.2978184223175049,
-0.22530052065849304,
-0.2562478482723236,
-0.17775624990463257,
-0.8281336426734924,
-0.2862485647201538,
-0.1598118394613266,
-0.33265674114227295,
0.48735305666923523,
-0.24254323542118073,
-0.5333865880966187,
-0.0627046450972557,
-0.027054384350776672,
0.6427667140960693,
0.545125424861908,
-0.703461766242981,
0.8710905313491821,
0.508026659488678,
-0.40751054883003235,
-0.8135172724723816,
-0.8631658554077148,
-0.013141504488885403,
-0.36254051327705383,
-0.7643741965293884,
-0.09270771592855453,
-0.033999137580394745,
-0.5954336524009705,
-0.1050257459282875,
0.3539055585861206,
-0.013311884365975857,
0.05885053053498268,
-0.3426164984703064,
0.179891899228096,
-0.30703651905059814,
0.5089576840400696,
0.15675005316734314,
0.24753710627555847,
-0.2046675831079483,
-0.26361382007598877,
0.8941304683685303,
0.10654830932617188,
-0.5350601673126221,
0.08463365584611893,
0.5113598108291626,
0.6441877484321594,
-0.5740351676940918,
0.9472194314002991,
0.6645566821098328,
-0.38431116938591003,
-0.17921708524227142,
-0.8916694521903992,
-0.01929345726966858,
-0.48219236731529236,
0.34464848041534424,
-0.53751140832901,
-1.1210787296295166,
0.8752748370170593,
-0.15898944437503815,
0.06867395341396332,
0.2633620500564575,
0.8245197534561157,
0.21924781799316406,
1.0351347923278809,
0.5787141919136047,
-0.3447635769844055,
0.6014353036880493,
-0.05228734388947487,
0.09898971766233444,
-0.8394879102706909,
-0.12401768565177917,
-0.5915334224700928,
-0.12525486946105957,
-0.45768821239471436,
-0.6688241362571716,
0.40406760573387146,
0.17195697128772736,
-0.21598409116268158,
-0.07136155664920807,
-0.0830899178981781,
0.5121409296989441,
0.2873632609844208,
-0.17743337154388428,
0.6860777735710144,
0.26134583353996277,
-0.2748858630657196,
0.15779970586299896,
-0.9980218410491943,
-0.32600611448287964,
0.8152318596839905,
0.2082011103630066,
1.0240882635116577,
0.47813770174980164,
0.5400155186653137,
-0.0029660791624337435,
0.5016480088233948,
-0.5924984812736511,
0.4929691255092621,
-0.3749082386493683,
-0.6012284755706787,
-0.5954656600952148,
-0.587931752204895,
-0.7675560712814331,
0.7695820331573486,
-0.09984206408262253,
-0.8348091840744019,
0.14147254824638367,
0.021484995260834694,
-0.12824146449565887,
0.3887256979942322,
-0.5024787187576294,
0.579886257648468,
-0.503937304019928,
-0.6699079871177673,
-0.2945176362991333,
-0.15260639786720276,
0.5142737030982971,
-0.3458402156829834,
0.5662994980812073,
0.0014626928605139256,
-0.16475510597229004,
0.3923606872558594,
-0.11983322352170944,
0.6705928444862366,
-0.07608944922685623,
-0.45866844058036804,
0.1973685622215271,
0.08842437714338303,
0.43181005120277405,
0.04324205592274666,
-0.519788384437561,
0.4121141731739044,
-0.3600817322731018,
-0.34752604365348816,
-0.4562019407749176,
0.8949611186981201,
-0.6792018413543701,
-0.6914464831352234,
-0.07915286719799042,
-0.8195093870162964,
-0.41445621848106384,
0.3109501004219055,
0.07863716781139374,
0.20145706832408905,
-0.020269913598895073,
0.10077231377363205,
0.5414295196533203,
-0.2842791974544525,
0.4484589993953705,
0.8646025061607361,
-0.5860500335693359,
-0.3430103659629822,
0.5901686549186707,
0.22089587152004242,
0.4108966886997223,
0.4888366162776947,
0.07674165070056915,
-0.5682604908943176,
-0.5189472436904907,
-0.4557814598083496,
0.44060465693473816,
-0.864999532699585,
-0.24488729238510132,
-0.8873111009597778,
-0.07007647305727005,
-0.543799877166748,
-0.06078759953379631,
-0.28866198658943176,
-0.16270746290683746,
-0.045001182705163956,
-0.06242616847157478,
0.39252087473869324,
0.5143415927886963,
-0.2475193589925766,
0.3988209068775177,
-1.1942272186279297,
0.1931714415550232,
0.26193830370903015,
0.5591890811920166,
0.206534743309021,
-0.4992966949939728,
-0.6495301723480225,
0.19119597971439362,
0.07274672389030457,
-0.6458197832107544,
0.44934627413749695,
0.08472664654254913,
0.902554988861084,
0.39966121315956116,
-0.1730356067419052,
0.8253522515296936,
-0.41860562562942505,
0.6953383684158325,
0.22757308185100555,
-0.8932467103004456,
0.27604714035987854,
-0.4388388395309448,
0.49690356850624084,
0.2901724576950073,
0.5595124363899231,
-0.7152954339981079,
-0.5985676646232605,
-0.20924609899520874,
-0.8303680419921875,
0.6818543672561646,
-0.3057943880558014,
0.01272512786090374,
-0.025025315582752228,
-0.04987204819917679,
0.0025547591503709555,
0.2350407987833023,
-0.6384630799293518,
-0.013361881487071514,
0.217379629611969,
-0.05344710499048233,
-0.3751102089881897,
-0.3550982177257538,
-0.25612494349479675,
-0.15735363960266113,
0.8249785304069519,
-0.27655482292175293,
-0.20778495073318481,
-0.09581959992647171,
-0.35062718391418457,
-0.38098499178886414,
0.3866751492023468,
0.30134010314941406,
0.8692935705184937,
0.2341030389070511,
0.18965943157672882,
0.4304400086402893,
-0.04049967601895332,
0.0479792058467865,
0.08879183977842331,
0.04632524773478508,
-0.11345597356557846,
0.5081960558891296,
0.5110587477684021,
-0.044873204082250595,
-0.7578590512275696,
0.10590274631977081,
-0.011143884621560574,
0.12077610939741135,
-0.14026415348052979,
0.038436468690633774,
0.3746112883090973,
0.5212306380271912,
0.47141245007514954,
-0.41878557205200195,
0.014743290841579437,
-0.5947558879852295,
0.04993142560124397,
0.682697057723999,
0.05791185051202774,
0.05594757944345474,
0.42749789357185364,
0.1651477962732315,
-0.15468232333660126,
0.5092180967330933,
-0.03456969931721687,
-0.6189541220664978,
0.3836684226989746,
0.5268354415893555,
0.34557217359542847,
-0.6237552762031555,
-0.06821303814649582,
0.22927089035511017,
0.3137466013431549,
-0.23210853338241577,
0.3490898013114929,
0.09377989172935486,
-1.1470084190368652,
-0.852985143661499,
-0.7524334192276001,
-0.28778496384620667,
0.021248696371912956,
-0.4459361732006073,
0.23327064514160156,
0.0917937159538269,
-0.007614107336848974,
-0.0529438778758049,
-0.06888357549905777,
-0.6597704291343689,
0.039336130023002625,
0.23547710478305817,
0.9333814978599548,
-0.8796529769897461,
0.8522248268127441,
1.0052849054336548,
-0.20638836920261383,
-0.6054912805557251,
-0.2789384722709656,
-0.1370747834444046,
-0.8731746077537537,
0.6378406286239624,
-0.1915477067232132,
-0.04386981949210167,
-0.18348337709903717,
-0.1101975366473198,
-0.9539987444877625,
0.8944509029388428,
0.3212273418903351,
-0.5599762201309204,
0.20354397594928741,
0.5416563749313354,
0.6506203413009644,
-0.44528621435165405,
0.31124332547187805,
0.5543007850646973,
0.6730638146400452,
0.23862411081790924,
-1.0851296186447144,
-0.07653021067380905,
-0.09714110940694809,
-0.10486697405576706,
0.3578663766384125,
-0.591396689414978,
0.8975626826286316,
-0.0361880362033844,
-0.02663945034146309,
-0.0022270327899605036,
0.44072529673576355,
0.318142294883728,
0.20046299695968628,
0.5454578995704651,
0.5771458745002747,
0.8416434526443481,
0.005375402979552746,
1.0940499305725098,
-0.6363686323165894,
0.09559465944766998,
1.066375970840454,
-0.5464243292808533,
0.6363973617553711,
0.5954076051712036,
-0.07223403453826904,
0.22701939940452576,
0.4342006742954254,
0.15898655354976654,
0.3594997823238373,
-0.029332060366868973,
-0.47733038663864136,
-0.6696379780769348,
-0.32998916506767273,
-0.455918550491333,
0.6096890568733215,
0.48620957136154175,
-0.29267552495002747,
-0.340016633272171,
0.01828904077410698,
-0.0804654210805893,
0.17771194875240326,
-0.5039544105529785,
0.8954309821128845,
0.016668446362018585,
-0.9067038893699646,
0.5009801387786865,
0.06565789878368378,
0.839525580406189,
-0.7200279235839844,
0.03999645262956619,
-0.38346853852272034,
0.28143182396888733,
-0.23108240962028503,
-0.7321614027023315,
0.388297438621521,
-0.05160393565893173,
-0.15544666349887848,
-0.19166907668113708,
0.7870950698852539,
-0.8152093887329102,
-0.691363513469696,
0.7207521200180054,
1.0490248203277588,
0.03660859167575836,
0.09377166628837585,
-0.3045470118522644,
0.1514941304922104,
-0.06037673354148865,
-0.11699021607637405,
0.5356324911117554,
0.5739638209342957,
-0.04537339136004448,
0.6984823346138,
0.6725606918334961,
0.3875945508480072,
0.2728758156299591,
0.19012108445167542,
0.8344359397888184,
-0.36051055788993835,
-0.5199131369590759,
-0.9305317401885986,
0.6356102228164673,
-0.2179042249917984,
0.0964754968881607,
0.8859497904777527,
0.7297276258468628,
0.9519951939582825,
-0.027486344799399376,
0.9327682256698608,
0.07596851140260696,
0.701279878616333,
-0.5143463015556335,
0.7403056621551514,
-0.9013179540634155,
0.6114784479141235,
-0.06240341439843178,
-0.8842744827270508,
-0.26294228434562683,
0.32163476943969727,
-0.22951281070709229,
0.12085855007171631,
0.3772384524345398,
0.8129842877388,
-0.07939301431179047,
-0.28184396028518677,
0.6480421423912048,
0.31466585397720337,
0.4246976673603058,
0.43331578373908997,
1.039513111114502,
-0.0302113126963377,
0.5051817893981934,
-0.06567434966564178,
-0.18900857865810394,
-0.20685794949531555,
-0.6910392045974731,
-0.901088535785675,
-0.3180209994316101,
-0.014651037752628326,
-0.08523483574390411,
-0.0780002549290657,
0.5988789200782776,
0.583747386932373,
-0.5346561074256897,
-0.5300677418708801,
0.4287029802799225,
0.5981206893920898,
-0.13218705356121063,
-0.17255404591560364,
-0.06284281611442566,
-0.5186691880226135,
-0.9760293960571289,
0.4829874336719513,
0.14301230013370514,
-0.01165461540222168,
-0.4134822487831116,
-0.1901559829711914,
-0.42660823464393616,
0.044872697442770004,
0.7578649520874023,
0.13053472340106964,
-0.4447680711746216,
-0.02064189873635769,
-0.0034726152662187815,
-0.055012863129377365,
-0.08110135048627853,
0.7197341918945312,
-0.5716412663459778,
0.293489933013916,
0.664946436882019,
0.6643332839012146,
0.3436550498008728,
-0.09439656138420105,
0.48582467436790466,
-1.0022493600845337,
0.3514452874660492,
0.14788417518138885,
0.7371324896812439,
0.5009464025497437,
-0.45684224367141724,
0.4868287444114685,
-0.09316273778676987,
-0.4088939130306244,
-0.829577624797821,
0.3864699602127075,
-0.6889275312423706,
-0.4510731101036072,
1.3281497955322266,
-0.04111742600798607,
0.004711492918431759,
-0.10417837649583817,
0.20998096466064453,
0.20387683808803558,
-0.18597149848937988,
0.5851163864135742,
0.9322482347488403,
-0.12575823068618774,
-0.30646151304244995,
-0.3183969259262085,
0.09637601673603058,
0.23794379830360413,
-0.7626268267631531,
0.12674912810325623,
0.6150310635566711,
0.31878775358200073,
0.50627601146698,
0.7316016554832458,
-0.2841523587703705,
0.15559902787208557,
-0.25303351879119873,
0.05508166924118996,
0.00480907317250967,
-0.23602581024169922,
-0.4425511360168457,
0.2588425874710083,
0.3753821551799774,
0.2594097852706909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14711v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14711v2 | MultiAgent Collaboration Attack: Investigating Adversarial Attacks in Large Language Model Collaborations via Debate | 2024-06-20T20:09:37 | 2024-06-26T16:05:20 | Alfonso Amayuelas, Xianjun Yang, Antonis Antoniades, Wenyue Hua, Liangming Pan, William Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MA | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown exceptional results on current
benchmarks when working individually. The advancement in their capabilities,
along with a reduction in parameter size and inference times, has facilitated
the use of these models as agents, enabling interactions among multiple models
to execute complex tasks. Such collaborations offer several advantages,
including the use of specialized models (e.g. coding), improved confidence
through multiple computations, and enhanced divergent thinking, leading to more
diverse outputs. Thus, the collaborative use of language models is expected to
grow significantly in the coming years. In this work, we evaluate the behavior
of a network of models collaborating through debate under the influence of an
adversary. We introduce pertinent metrics to assess the adversary's
effectiveness, focusing on system accuracy and model agreement. Our findings
highlight the importance of a model's persuasive ability in influencing others.
Additionally, we explore inference-time methods to generate more compelling
arguments and evaluate the potential of prompt-based mitigation as a defensive
strategy. | [
-0.617535412311554,
-1.0194766521453857,
0.6510981917381287,
0.14868852496147156,
0.1452266126871109,
0.3341751992702484,
-0.240545853972435,
-0.4059101641178131,
0.08931569010019302,
0.6629474759101868,
-0.41533610224723816,
-0.20258481800556183,
-0.897332489490509,
0.11549963802099228,
-0.5113271474838257,
0.76987224817276,
0.1186520904302597,
0.30137166380882263,
-0.10490817576646805,
-0.2349797487258911,
-0.454145610332489,
-0.9364965558052063,
-0.8038167953491211,
-0.3303781747817993,
0.7361682057380676,
0.0958072692155838,
0.8597750663757324,
0.30923882126808167,
0.7106136679649353,
0.5484086275100708,
-0.1117042675614357,
-0.062022313475608826,
-0.6564022302627563,
0.5602750778198242,
-0.12072423845529556,
-0.5369961857795715,
-0.3781510293483734,
0.11449602246284485,
0.5481885671615601,
0.7584242224693298,
-0.15080977976322174,
-0.17166079580783844,
-0.0192437544465065,
0.2621062397956848,
-0.663847804069519,
-0.10471633821725845,
-0.9609672427177429,
-0.04855704307556152,
-0.2678299844264984,
0.1086905300617218,
-0.6341689825057983,
-0.09894775599241257,
0.32556411623954773,
-0.28394815325737,
0.016348620876669884,
-0.04189424589276314,
0.5278754234313965,
0.11360465735197067,
-0.2714278995990753,
-0.38668540120124817,
-0.6134005188941956,
0.5642326474189758,
-0.6860501766204834,
0.025368984788656235,
0.15736077725887299,
0.15360797941684723,
-0.5980482697486877,
-0.9186450839042664,
-0.44112762808799744,
-0.49785521626472473,
0.08725498616695404,
0.12745897471904755,
-0.6718636751174927,
0.11087238043546677,
0.2866767346858978,
0.09895341098308563,
-0.374105840921402,
0.29594889283180237,
-0.04322284460067749,
-0.033700574189424515,
0.5123780369758606,
0.18225891888141632,
0.48449021577835083,
0.16403961181640625,
-0.4130142331123352,
0.059609584510326385,
-0.5883122086524963,
-0.23465441167354584,
0.5965485572814941,
0.21990859508514404,
-0.12526360154151917,
0.485108882188797,
0.03661511465907097,
0.520814061164856,
0.04684048146009445,
0.25983908772468567,
-0.33685386180877686,
-0.46917298436164856,
-0.36182069778442383,
-0.0401887446641922,
1.1254512071609497,
0.11364039778709412,
0.022596042603254318,
-0.3519589900970459,
-0.09227260202169418,
0.25614190101623535,
0.3280690014362335,
-0.7806847095489502,
-0.36831533908843994,
0.14014315605163574,
-0.27628305554389954,
-0.4357689917087555,
0.03155225142836571,
-0.810033917427063,
-0.66282719373703,
0.047209251672029495,
0.3581729829311371,
-0.04915912449359894,
-0.21871398389339447,
-0.05598519742488861,
-0.23159021139144897,
-0.19691504538059235,
0.45315971970558167,
-0.5441106557846069,
0.44178420305252075,
0.8628475666046143,
0.7719829678535461,
0.06950151920318604,
-0.5945677161216736,
-0.8079094290733337,
0.1475135087966919,
-0.6316059827804565,
0.637159526348114,
-0.5006794929504395,
-0.7138477563858032,
-0.24393609166145325,
-0.11552733182907104,
-0.19440412521362305,
-0.22401000559329987,
0.35641148686408997,
-0.7959081530570984,
0.2538609206676483,
-0.27410873770713806,
-0.5775385499000549,
0.046355877071619034,
0.611211359500885,
-1.0186100006103516,
0.40948155522346497,
-0.42048847675323486,
-1.0334324836730957,
-0.11184011399745941,
-0.6791564226150513,
-0.16223587095737457,
0.11939572542905807,
-0.3410109281539917,
-0.29947400093078613,
-0.02779090590775013,
0.2599234879016876,
0.3252437114715576,
-0.5340418815612793,
0.044930413365364075,
-0.6147053241729736,
-0.07422530651092529,
0.69820636510849,
-0.631273627281189,
0.8513401746749878,
0.14104579389095306,
-0.20782315731048584,
0.3251488506793976,
-0.21221739053726196,
-0.32062166929244995,
0.36980360746383667,
-0.17225903272628784,
-0.40944766998291016,
0.0049033681862056255,
-0.42659586668014526,
-0.13299837708473206,
0.2969528138637543,
-0.3399934470653534,
0.338522732257843,
-0.4857446253299713,
0.32001349329948425,
0.7344833016395569,
0.36897802352905273,
0.361548513174057,
-0.31067100167274475,
0.7165260910987854,
-0.49100223183631897,
0.2574080228805542,
-0.08808927237987518,
-0.5750589370727539,
-0.5170221924781799,
-0.14136715233325958,
0.30335891246795654,
0.3221675157546997,
-0.9280286431312561,
-0.2572929561138153,
-0.08349347859621048,
-0.5625339150428772,
-0.4267192780971527,
0.05895869433879852,
0.5334094762802124,
0.20392373204231262,
0.12044748663902283,
-0.22873742878437042,
-0.30851271748542786,
-0.706770658493042,
-0.30405348539352417,
-0.2596175968647003,
0.19621390104293823,
0.3357146382331848,
0.4250466525554657,
-0.014170240610837936,
0.6153000593185425,
-0.3803979158401489,
0.3493991196155548,
-0.42346084117889404,
0.40224137902259827,
-0.14898017048835754,
0.3966471254825592,
0.6264739036560059,
-0.7843322157859802,
-0.7309350371360779,
-0.06692732870578766,
-0.74897700548172,
0.10475702583789825,
0.018320558592677116,
-0.11172327399253845,
0.13874731957912445,
0.6014997363090515,
-0.47701406478881836,
0.17183102667331696,
0.8803032040596008,
-0.37083643674850464,
0.693165123462677,
-0.11008628457784653,
0.4534852206707001,
-1.056997537612915,
-0.11219794303178787,
-0.163661390542984,
0.07735586166381836,
-1.1551241874694824,
0.40198737382888794,
-0.44543907046318054,
-0.05618474632501602,
-0.3690137565135956,
0.28990137577056885,
-0.4319595992565155,
0.1729944348335266,
-0.28763091564178467,
0.2602924108505249,
-0.015499623492360115,
0.039263173937797546,
-0.2557689845561981,
0.7400657534599304,
0.43651601672172546,
-0.2266942262649536,
0.6425503492355347,
0.018570400774478912,
-0.14640671014785767,
0.6544979214668274,
-0.703039288520813,
0.6223557591438293,
0.3254833221435547,
0.24063771963119507,
-0.9534376859664917,
-0.1645069569349289,
0.3010793626308441,
-0.8124582767486572,
0.2740840017795563,
-0.3369438350200653,
-0.5544933080673218,
-0.2112419158220291,
-0.28829118609428406,
0.19285230338573456,
-0.20432879030704498,
-0.4720439910888672,
0.7406719326972961,
0.5187781453132629,
-0.197256401181221,
-0.9642083048820496,
-0.5982944369316101,
0.7988424301147461,
-0.3988896310329437,
-0.8370514512062073,
0.16176797449588776,
-0.09113320708274841,
-0.865621030330658,
-0.07543426752090454,
0.36358335614204407,
-0.12269648164510727,
0.48968857526779175,
0.10425977408885956,
0.15328235924243927,
-0.17180068790912628,
-0.17282195389270782,
-0.46208617091178894,
0.0673338919878006,
0.3485707640647888,
0.11562085151672363,
0.6482182145118713,
-0.19203972816467285,
-0.6067585945129395,
-0.3149043619632721,
0.4710620641708374,
0.7530503869056702,
-0.334573894739151,
1.020797848701477,
0.40403205156326294,
-0.2888679802417755,
-0.13184218108654022,
-0.6557421088218689,
-0.22602912783622742,
-0.5099096298217773,
0.6139068603515625,
-0.4229021668434143,
-0.8748317360877991,
0.6693041324615479,
-0.16718833148479462,
-0.03415285423398018,
0.15477262437343597,
0.5679295063018799,
0.22244536876678467,
1.1621265411376953,
0.39391523599624634,
-0.3733864426612854,
0.3627525866031647,
-0.18801894783973694,
-0.04855608195066452,
-0.5853112936019897,
-0.19837188720703125,
-0.7716305255889893,
0.08235353976488113,
-0.5543673038482666,
-0.4509059190750122,
0.2572329342365265,
-0.1623094081878662,
-0.19327448308467865,
0.3095633089542389,
-0.10073041170835495,
0.39252403378486633,
0.4050902724266052,
-0.08368252962827682,
0.2037225365638733,
-0.33568328619003296,
-0.10596522688865662,
0.025746574625372887,
-0.7738515734672546,
-0.33865299820899963,
1.0490052700042725,
0.38655269145965576,
0.7075037956237793,
0.555652916431427,
0.46267595887184143,
0.3595142066478729,
0.2790718376636505,
-0.6922609806060791,
0.6078435778617859,
-0.1120193675160408,
-0.5823715925216675,
-0.26582685112953186,
-0.5504488945007324,
-1.1485258340835571,
0.46481409668922424,
-0.40504980087280273,
-0.823247492313385,
-0.036230433732271194,
-0.21987561881542206,
-0.3000481426715851,
0.5257689356803894,
-0.7451024055480957,
0.9644514918327332,
-0.33538752794265747,
-0.5190105438232422,
-0.4372335374355316,
-0.6295908689498901,
0.44281208515167236,
-0.15704064071178436,
0.19593766331672668,
0.27153798937797546,
0.04662417992949486,
0.6706017851829529,
-0.31673866510391235,
0.9004241824150085,
0.02957339957356453,
-0.144774928689003,
0.27415934205055237,
0.18620352447032928,
0.7191881537437439,
-0.10596326738595963,
-0.2594372034072876,
-0.00002705686529225204,
-0.2639313340187073,
-0.3353448808193207,
-0.5766916871070862,
0.7851455211639404,
-0.7721443176269531,
-0.8920102119445801,
-0.19647130370140076,
-0.5357114672660828,
-0.09679842740297318,
0.05045773833990097,
0.0006420831196010113,
0.46476462483406067,
-0.7349413633346558,
0.41481757164001465,
0.5732331275939941,
-0.055646613240242004,
0.5378019213676453,
0.4558880031108856,
-0.10948203504085541,
-0.7143645882606506,
0.8122156262397766,
-0.05601492151618004,
0.8332264423370361,
0.262548565864563,
0.3026480972766876,
-0.036638058722019196,
-0.6647306680679321,
-0.34100231528282166,
0.028422217816114426,
-0.7791333198547363,
-0.04008395969867706,
-0.6687768697738647,
-0.025070639327168465,
-0.41426652669906616,
-0.13689099252223969,
-0.523567259311676,
-0.08916570246219635,
-0.10364814102649689,
0.2731721103191376,
0.11038412153720856,
1.2437905073165894,
0.256418913602829,
0.5081287622451782,
-0.7605262994766235,
-0.24514146149158478,
0.43622663617134094,
-0.17308902740478516,
0.17425410449504852,
-0.3427901268005371,
-0.19587577879428864,
-0.19725176692008972,
-0.3607257902622223,
-1.3039735555648804,
0.2719724178314209,
-0.46411168575286865,
0.8620772957801819,
0.33064377307891846,
-0.012602764181792736,
0.38209444284439087,
-0.19340118765830994,
0.8136246800422668,
0.17556746304035187,
-1.0691890716552734,
0.20740441977977753,
-0.3297046422958374,
0.18249469995498657,
0.31038370728492737,
0.2850014269351959,
-0.4125871956348419,
-0.47152265906333923,
-0.7599261403083801,
-0.43608665466308594,
0.5805842876434326,
0.37059280276298523,
-0.11354336142539978,
0.31713277101516724,
0.04718351736664772,
-0.40089720487594604,
0.1949644833803177,
-0.6892074942588806,
-0.31077849864959717,
0.17722564935684204,
0.2459024041891098,
0.11810477077960968,
-0.11298419535160065,
-0.5071703791618347,
0.2765117585659027,
0.4904789626598358,
-0.045749448239803314,
-0.1100628674030304,
0.04010685533285141,
0.09316278994083405,
-0.07906074821949005,
0.42017892003059387,
0.6976356506347656,
0.5390632152557373,
0.32431888580322266,
0.280204713344574,
0.5761533379554749,
-0.3024693727493286,
0.09324474632740021,
0.36275336146354675,
0.19244465231895447,
-0.18227417767047882,
0.7266344428062439,
0.6736056208610535,
0.010149464011192322,
-0.29685476422309875,
0.645038366317749,
-0.4730508327484131,
-0.2541794180870056,
0.05355912446975708,
-0.0945628359913826,
0.4409791827201843,
0.6865230202674866,
0.030379559844732285,
0.22838027775287628,
0.043214499950408936,
-0.4809606373310089,
0.08448679000139236,
0.8891007900238037,
-0.4136457145214081,
-0.22389328479766846,
0.3101315498352051,
0.1543067991733551,
-0.4523772895336151,
0.22066807746887207,
-0.24536283314228058,
-1.074537992477417,
1.0078518390655518,
0.37274593114852905,
0.7969913482666016,
-0.5661812424659729,
-0.03599613159894943,
-0.04571518674492836,
0.6258226633071899,
0.019972212612628937,
-0.32365095615386963,
0.31964755058288574,
-0.7230119705200195,
-0.4997399151325226,
0.014871058985590935,
-0.8796699047088623,
0.4252372980117798,
-0.37105321884155273,
0.1508193463087082,
-0.4917101562023163,
-0.3089960813522339,
0.21814610064029694,
0.2105451077222824,
-0.18598483502864838,
-0.2637767791748047,
0.27441927790641785,
0.4636419415473938,
-0.6177953481674194,
0.7773375511169434,
0.7124508619308472,
-0.3725675344467163,
-0.573655366897583,
0.18340535461902618,
0.25703662633895874,
-0.5154027342796326,
0.6140291094779968,
-0.02962447702884674,
-0.5016747117042542,
-0.3298713266849518,
-0.69910728931427,
-0.7582072019577026,
0.7731759548187256,
0.505835771560669,
-0.593400776386261,
0.22022497653961182,
-0.018543027341365814,
0.5216328501701355,
-0.46805810928344727,
0.18886849284172058,
0.38721516728401184,
0.39294081926345825,
0.17614516615867615,
-0.920942485332489,
0.10277116298675537,
-0.10417607426643372,
-0.25694721937179565,
0.14852581918239594,
-0.8069084286689758,
1.0349153280258179,
-0.1982916295528412,
-0.019157573580741882,
0.1374320685863495,
0.6440809369087219,
0.1627204865217209,
0.2525174915790558,
0.6944318413734436,
0.37012413144111633,
0.7171764969825745,
0.2296408712863922,
0.9098079800605774,
-0.2429322451353073,
0.2229241281747818,
1.3560779094696045,
-0.4207899570465088,
0.6829959154129028,
0.34817034006118774,
-0.15074627101421356,
0.36281314492225647,
0.13787832856178284,
-0.18465259671211243,
0.11618919670581818,
0.40115299820899963,
-0.4180696904659271,
-0.28113242983818054,
-0.2018820345401764,
-0.39323726296424866,
0.4654310345649719,
0.48989492654800415,
-0.3140222132205963,
-0.101816326379776,
-0.05731526389718056,
0.43488389253616333,
0.38800278306007385,
0.010929446667432785,
0.8102986812591553,
0.032003168016672134,
-0.8395712971687317,
0.15729284286499023,
0.11954820901155472,
0.47438350319862366,
-0.5388402342796326,
0.04758736491203308,
0.17161113023757935,
0.4046418070793152,
0.04800863564014435,
-0.5898007750511169,
-0.02506255730986595,
0.10153087228536606,
-0.03918440639972687,
0.24425534904003143,
0.5929040312767029,
-0.39136722683906555,
-0.23120494186878204,
0.7466946840286255,
0.6022244691848755,
-0.07918329536914825,
-0.08100488781929016,
-1.0572535991668701,
0.32718518376350403,
-0.1480613797903061,
-0.3136577010154724,
0.38284245133399963,
0.31623944640159607,
0.08715096861124039,
0.6628890633583069,
0.6311951875686646,
0.23223666846752167,
-0.1847250610589981,
0.30822187662124634,
1.081671118736267,
-0.0631515309214592,
-0.2316707968711853,
-1.3086806535720825,
0.008811100386083126,
-0.39221736788749695,
0.14319734275341034,
1.1140705347061157,
0.3392496109008789,
0.6436601877212524,
0.3753015398979187,
0.7944473028182983,
0.3061264455318451,
0.2830204963684082,
-0.3465617597103119,
0.905561625957489,
-0.33919787406921387,
0.5603890419006348,
-0.46454954147338867,
-0.3071272373199463,
-0.24338266253471375,
0.20083634555339813,
-0.4512043297290802,
0.0383521132171154,
0.734869658946991,
0.7020250558853149,
0.2766232192516327,
0.18779510259628296,
0.2502720355987549,
0.3726799786090851,
0.8310695290565491,
0.41608095169067383,
1.236155390739441,
-0.1889774203300476,
0.7907572388648987,
-0.1960953027009964,
-0.24500975012779236,
0.044313229620456696,
-0.8869679570198059,
-1.227171540260315,
-0.16944462060928345,
-0.2108491063117981,
-0.5999678373336792,
0.23183272778987885,
0.9392877817153931,
0.4298999011516571,
-0.667975664138794,
-0.47955837845802307,
0.00838792510330677,
0.28380653262138367,
0.1608467996120453,
-0.14454548060894012,
0.18426649272441864,
-0.07040971517562866,
-0.7696262001991272,
0.7494107484817505,
0.029053596779704094,
0.06047884002327919,
-0.6853270530700684,
-0.11444421857595444,
-0.5395625829696655,
0.40343159437179565,
0.28095096349716187,
0.1031269058585167,
-0.7894752025604248,
0.016288697719573975,
0.06537489593029022,
-0.26918843388557434,
-0.20435570180416107,
0.7853832244873047,
-0.17106835544109344,
0.6959967017173767,
0.4674520790576935,
0.9124048352241516,
0.10043767094612122,
0.09278659522533417,
0.7851451635360718,
-0.4478074014186859,
0.015336357057094574,
0.17475126683712006,
0.4696805775165558,
0.5365680456161499,
-0.3478407859802246,
0.3596491515636444,
0.3954225778579712,
-0.8432199954986572,
-0.9353678822517395,
0.09500955045223236,
-0.4491567015647888,
-0.6000819802284241,
0.9833850860595703,
-0.5582605600357056,
-0.1408248096704483,
-0.17307837307453156,
-0.2673521339893341,
0.11948028206825256,
-0.5011919736862183,
0.5842002630233765,
0.9495932459831238,
0.0804060623049736,
0.16525626182556152,
-0.5261297225952148,
0.298195481300354,
0.43947964906692505,
-0.8989399075508118,
0.06774730235338211,
0.3694581985473633,
-0.059112902730703354,
0.45178961753845215,
0.5411304831504822,
0.2505742311477661,
-0.07983986288309097,
0.31729766726493835,
-0.20512421429157257,
0.05017843469977379,
-0.5512790679931641,
-0.39298751950263977,
0.5316450595855713,
0.21471557021141052,
-0.04902706295251846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14709v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14709v1 | Factual Dialogue Summarization via Learning from Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T20:03:37 | 2024-06-20T20:03:37 | Rongxin Zhu, Jey Han Lau, Jianzhong Qi | cs.CL | cs.CL, F.2.2; I.2.7 | Factual consistency is an important quality in dialogue summarization. Large
language model (LLM)-based automatic text summarization models generate more
factually consistent summaries compared to those by smaller pretrained language
models, but they face deployment challenges in real-world applications due to
privacy or resource constraints. In this paper, we investigate the use of
symbolic knowledge distillation to improve the factual consistency of smaller
pretrained models for dialogue summarization. We employ zero-shot learning to
extract symbolic knowledge from LLMs, generating both factually consistent
(positive) and inconsistent (negative) summaries. We then apply two contrastive
learning objectives on these summaries to enhance smaller summarization models.
Experiments with BART, PEGASUS, and Flan-T5 indicate that our approach
surpasses strong baselines that rely on complex data augmentation strategies.
Our approach achieves better factual consistency while maintaining coherence,
fluency, and relevance, as confirmed by various automatic evaluation metrics.
We also provide access to the data and code to facilitate future research. | [
0.0030430173501372337,
-0.5933214426040649,
0.8533452153205872,
-0.05388672277331352,
-0.3999323844909668,
0.30269134044647217,
-0.149717316031456,
-0.3155010938644409,
0.12254965305328369,
0.49096137285232544,
-0.44100451469421387,
-0.6583307385444641,
-0.7784114480018616,
0.25211861729621887,
-0.29791635274887085,
1.253738284111023,
0.07114287465810776,
0.006667310371994972,
-0.1541336476802826,
-0.33724573254585266,
-0.39259475469589233,
-0.48590922355651855,
-0.31698518991470337,
-0.20494422316551208,
0.4395688772201538,
0.2026166021823883,
0.5906668305397034,
0.6551302671432495,
0.29393714666366577,
0.3852333724498749,
-0.13313862681388855,
0.33853232860565186,
-0.7853400707244873,
0.2212727814912796,
-0.07375788688659668,
-0.5445603132247925,
-0.2811601459980011,
-0.030222129076719284,
0.7049140334129333,
0.6469911932945251,
-0.2513309717178345,
0.05734589695930481,
0.09778303653001785,
0.4007120728492737,
-0.6192083358764648,
0.6794038414955139,
-0.7377728819847107,
-0.011003508232533932,
0.3773094117641449,
-0.13507501780986786,
-0.3943012058734894,
-0.7941192984580994,
0.26695090532302856,
-0.6763406991958618,
0.3096078932285309,
0.007026119623333216,
1.0055474042892456,
0.5077608823776245,
-0.7462465763092041,
-0.2556983232498169,
-0.8311294913291931,
0.8379992842674255,
-1.2038110494613647,
0.16751833260059357,
0.17448261380195618,
0.34211266040802,
-0.03616013005375862,
-0.5361254811286926,
-0.7264585494995117,
-0.39988023042678833,
-0.39101943373680115,
0.1851796656847,
-0.19416137039661407,
0.16065704822540283,
0.3563290238380432,
0.1523587852716446,
-0.3941505253314972,
-0.10230067372322083,
-0.3828456997871399,
-0.34705615043640137,
0.5966894626617432,
0.3439568877220154,
0.041111890226602554,
-0.08842907100915909,
-0.009943298064172268,
-0.04264164716005325,
-0.7493027448654175,
-0.3261486887931824,
0.13957369327545166,
0.43067312240600586,
-0.4877319037914276,
0.7030027508735657,
-0.4727027118206024,
0.48207035660743713,
0.26324328780174255,
-0.6799363493919373,
0.18707723915576935,
-0.6270217299461365,
-0.2747764587402344,
0.4707702696323395,
0.6518792510032654,
0.4312960207462311,
0.11912579834461212,
0.07033942639827728,
0.001657684100791812,
-0.029391221702098846,
0.029274001717567444,
-0.9227757453918457,
-0.25960394740104675,
0.04173041880130768,
-0.08301910012960434,
-0.29433533549308777,
-0.003674093633890152,
-0.24979446828365326,
-0.3964356780052185,
-0.8234333395957947,
0.4422701895236969,
-0.4524002969264984,
-0.10671335458755493,
0.0932939201593399,
-0.22341713309288025,
-0.04614747688174248,
0.7666852474212646,
-0.8012276291847229,
0.1068805605173111,
0.7779450416564941,
0.9816291332244873,
0.2892884612083435,
0.022966580465435982,
-0.6599202156066895,
0.38098645210266113,
-0.3726482093334198,
0.4102083444595337,
-0.14949080348014832,
-0.15543773770332336,
-0.03526070713996887,
-0.05287448689341545,
-0.04338765889406204,
-0.6528680920600891,
0.1663016527891159,
-0.20148584246635437,
0.31794559955596924,
-0.3844694197177887,
-0.5310345888137817,
-0.26495835185050964,
0.4755440652370453,
-0.4149981737136841,
0.693091630935669,
-0.09691784530878067,
-0.6207087635993958,
0.3683106303215027,
-0.2361026406288147,
-0.3022979199886322,
-0.31950679421424866,
-0.29812487959861755,
-0.4634322226047516,
0.2690929174423218,
0.09043930470943451,
0.4550502300262451,
-0.02404312789440155,
0.603554904460907,
-0.2736092209815979,
-0.26929864287376404,
0.06625490635633469,
-0.5805237889289856,
0.770104706287384,
0.14683544635772705,
-0.31304579973220825,
-0.043779365718364716,
-0.7056527137756348,
-0.43350034952163696,
0.07511968165636063,
0.013202463276684284,
-0.34843793511390686,
-0.1526700109243393,
-0.7483830451965332,
0.21510963141918182,
0.21816951036453247,
-0.5798072218894958,
0.041492998600006104,
-0.4917549788951874,
-0.06889168918132782,
0.5323866605758667,
0.18833352625370026,
0.29047051072120667,
-0.49459871649742126,
0.19393081963062286,
0.4719139039516449,
-0.10657960176467896,
-0.39276179671287537,
-0.1638038158416748,
-0.9951857924461365,
-0.5440235137939453,
0.2438422441482544,
0.4971005320549011,
-0.9494737386703491,
0.6021338105201721,
-0.42767080664634705,
-0.477415531873703,
-0.28750932216644287,
0.17754532396793365,
0.3812907636165619,
0.9652631282806396,
0.26070740818977356,
-0.1589658409357071,
-0.430429071187973,
-0.699081540107727,
-0.0489075668156147,
-0.5037222504615784,
-0.1117410957813263,
0.12822453677654266,
0.39354100823402405,
0.004728683736175299,
0.9334025979042053,
-0.8098081350326538,
-0.3499264717102051,
-0.42708128690719604,
0.5619286894798279,
0.25144660472869873,
0.23415163159370422,
0.5272031426429749,
-0.3412110209465027,
-0.7017369866371155,
-0.175858736038208,
-1.074837327003479,
-0.12729547917842865,
-0.2643674314022064,
-0.016363605856895447,
0.3296624422073364,
0.23746855556964874,
-0.7688292860984802,
0.378776878118515,
0.25758567452430725,
-0.0723927840590477,
0.6511383056640625,
-0.3103676736354828,
0.23930951952934265,
-1.176995038986206,
-0.10490952432155609,
0.18235869705677032,
-0.5646481513977051,
-0.6423463225364685,
-0.305416077375412,
-0.19850441813468933,
0.016534928232431412,
-0.49440133571624756,
0.39866963028907776,
-0.2523634433746338,
0.1666426807641983,
-0.10449961572885513,
0.3863272964954376,
0.18965964019298553,
0.5251290202140808,
0.288398802280426,
0.4677813649177551,
0.2635568082332611,
-0.5468838810920715,
0.4627959132194519,
0.42773279547691345,
-0.3937680721282959,
0.5171829462051392,
-0.6881382465362549,
-0.2961393892765045,
-0.34273213148117065,
0.6057379841804504,
-1.0174856185913086,
-0.20929044485092163,
0.28347739577293396,
-0.09375765919685364,
0.34509655833244324,
-0.15543369948863983,
-0.42572760581970215,
0.2827969491481781,
-0.4573202431201935,
0.2084311693906784,
0.6766286492347717,
-0.49942755699157715,
0.6199486255645752,
0.24260854721069336,
-0.6268401741981506,
-0.6801232099533081,
-0.3351024389266968,
0.05353162810206413,
-0.16595686972141266,
-0.3433278799057007,
-0.1102571114897728,
0.16689433157444,
-0.4263632297515869,
-0.14362816512584686,
-0.4314236640930176,
-0.025614561513066292,
-0.024248162284493446,
0.2030445784330368,
0.4947434067726135,
-0.32320764660835266,
0.013519182801246643,
0.12464283406734467,
-0.08277202397584915,
0.044109638780355453,
-0.07610105723142624,
0.21226009726524353,
0.1257099211215973,
-0.4305477738380432,
-0.8147996664047241,
0.06253406405448914,
0.4559294283390045,
0.19650356471538544,
0.918449342250824,
0.3236343264579773,
-0.0776231661438942,
-0.01597978174686432,
-0.6326913833618164,
-0.3743945062160492,
-0.40816572308540344,
0.20985712110996246,
-0.02378086932003498,
-0.9727892875671387,
0.4103081226348877,
-0.21111086010932922,
0.40378284454345703,
0.4628150463104248,
0.4355953633785248,
-0.33808448910713196,
0.8297308683395386,
0.67645663022995,
-0.17052410542964935,
0.32186028361320496,
-0.1366957575082779,
0.34690383076667786,
-0.2560357451438904,
-0.18811698257923126,
-0.39357179403305054,
-0.06555742025375366,
-0.2746870815753937,
-0.27023428678512573,
0.7095052599906921,
-0.13910719752311707,
-0.3003575801849365,
0.2559453547000885,
-0.039725467562675476,
0.4838179647922516,
0.29737621545791626,
0.02247903309762478,
0.8188038468360901,
0.1019793376326561,
-0.007352493237704039,
-0.006922844797372818,
-0.7128755450248718,
-0.5732620358467102,
0.9034567475318909,
0.2384585589170456,
0.7958972454071045,
0.3058106005191803,
0.7998477816581726,
0.2890992760658264,
0.3027521073818207,
-0.5855317115783691,
0.49094337224960327,
-0.014433318749070168,
-0.4070362448692322,
-0.40589356422424316,
-0.740261435508728,
-0.48338839411735535,
0.3222257196903229,
-0.3140684962272644,
-0.550810694694519,
-0.0176424328237772,
0.4594886004924774,
-0.618314802646637,
0.0420050173997879,
-0.7430885434150696,
0.7825097441673279,
-0.09860171377658844,
-0.10307716578245163,
-0.3966841399669647,
-0.8985191583633423,
0.7144923210144043,
-0.13797539472579956,
-0.02547840029001236,
-0.3139517903327942,
0.26286014914512634,
0.3595387935638428,
-0.8215228915214539,
1.2152549028396606,
-0.10904370993375778,
-0.2859955430030823,
0.27900826930999756,
0.03485334292054176,
0.6171499490737915,
0.0767512172460556,
0.18805952370166779,
0.29304954409599304,
0.1820714771747589,
-0.2786012291908264,
-0.9383994340896606,
0.34962841868400574,
-0.7504185438156128,
-0.8350383043289185,
-0.5781280398368835,
-0.4978509247303009,
-0.18057295680046082,
-0.05763479322195053,
-0.07985313981771469,
0.6119085550308228,
-0.32535406947135925,
0.21303030848503113,
0.7983645796775818,
-0.26968011260032654,
0.26134952902793884,
0.7396517992019653,
-0.14106783270835876,
-0.14078345894813538,
1.0195106267929077,
0.1412430852651596,
0.5204225778579712,
0.4710905849933624,
0.16529272496700287,
-0.5524997711181641,
-0.3081328868865967,
-0.5105679035186768,
0.4873347878456116,
-0.5379531979560852,
-0.27033355832099915,
-0.6889421939849854,
-0.4125726521015167,
-0.4954455494880676,
-0.022802967578172684,
-0.36412227153778076,
-0.7758868336677551,
-0.1124313548207283,
-0.28537365794181824,
0.3834158778190613,
0.5765401721000671,
-0.047472644597291946,
0.3822772800922394,
-1.0324070453643799,
0.6412004828453064,
0.3065442144870758,
-0.07932370901107788,
-0.09895110875368118,
-0.7461763024330139,
-0.3432905375957489,
0.42288655042648315,
-0.42221423983573914,
-0.6163962483406067,
0.3571127951145172,
0.27802804112434387,
0.24127763509750366,
0.46460044384002686,
0.4506750702857971,
0.7143020033836365,
-0.4485280215740204,
0.8532296419143677,
0.46749353408813477,
-0.9830127358436584,
0.3374379575252533,
-0.39644545316696167,
0.4733838737010956,
0.7606981992721558,
0.43166863918304443,
-0.4496156871318817,
-0.7922834157943726,
-0.6288842558860779,
-0.497494637966156,
0.7876542210578918,
0.33368176221847534,
0.1500973105430603,
0.20381665229797363,
0.17460979521274567,
0.23106491565704346,
0.4957505166530609,
-0.44643667340278625,
-0.19452233612537384,
-0.3790075480937958,
-0.6075029373168945,
-0.2506113052368164,
-0.2503516972064972,
-0.5052156448364258,
-0.251124769449234,
0.9143296480178833,
-0.1922641098499298,
-0.17247602343559265,
-0.05640608072280884,
-0.2818814814090729,
0.24926093220710754,
0.2679222822189331,
0.7782929539680481,
0.732840895652771,
-0.2404295653104782,
0.2026260644197464,
0.4313161373138428,
-0.2980700433254242,
0.29045939445495605,
0.0067865438759326935,
-0.2460339218378067,
0.49453264474868774,
0.46173912286758423,
0.7917453646659851,
0.15986041724681854,
-0.7378053665161133,
0.6222050786018372,
-0.08292184770107269,
-0.20332226157188416,
-0.25799983739852905,
0.24941258132457733,
-0.02266250178217888,
0.3283139169216156,
0.1395103484392166,
-0.12255172431468964,
0.06850170344114304,
-0.7418545484542847,
0.10863170772790909,
0.3718608617782593,
-0.1254366636276245,
-0.2747747004032135,
0.3941623866558075,
0.3014998435974121,
0.2745527923107147,
0.5810970664024353,
-0.07704690098762512,
-0.28341591358184814,
0.4875577390193939,
0.37986135482788086,
0.7735045552253723,
-0.08576315641403198,
0.4882386028766632,
0.4180496633052826,
0.17144650220870972,
-0.18035489320755005,
-0.06808850914239883,
-0.3323289453983307,
-0.6355770230293274,
-0.63941890001297,
-0.48463910818099976,
-0.7426807880401611,
-0.0618303082883358,
-0.3810398280620575,
0.28442397713661194,
-0.4052886366844177,
0.02374410629272461,
-0.06012188643217087,
-0.05662782862782478,
-0.28732502460479736,
0.21161377429962158,
0.05055907741189003,
0.5383224487304688,
-0.882277250289917,
0.7650889754295349,
0.04772256314754486,
-0.4171496331691742,
-0.9501222968101501,
-0.11736708134412766,
0.41314390301704407,
-0.6619538068771362,
0.602686882019043,
-0.03576759248971939,
-0.18424026668071747,
-0.2827724516391754,
-0.3593505024909973,
-0.6217955350875854,
1.2446115016937256,
0.8914705514907837,
-0.808281421661377,
-0.08657006919384003,
0.4393259584903717,
0.6178019046783447,
-0.26226839423179626,
0.42268404364585876,
0.46282365918159485,
0.28846266865730286,
0.5808756947517395,
-1.0091609954833984,
0.05147082358598709,
0.09166092425584793,
-0.2784007787704468,
0.0982021689414978,
-0.5578688979148865,
0.2734912633895874,
-0.1988731026649475,
-0.29461994767189026,
0.009771575219929218,
0.6896778345108032,
0.396819144487381,
0.4791828989982605,
0.30512556433677673,
0.5795634388923645,
0.7198589444160461,
-0.1585037261247635,
0.6883159279823303,
-0.4043735861778259,
0.32368203997612,
1.5734807252883911,
-0.585793673992157,
0.5094558000564575,
0.2531314194202423,
0.07123232632875443,
0.4532560110092163,
0.20121978223323822,
0.08234775811433792,
0.4461929500102997,
-0.10526404529809952,
-0.621640682220459,
-0.17673620581626892,
-0.32699155807495117,
-0.32098469138145447,
0.40996506810188293,
0.014896044507622719,
-0.251177042722702,
-0.5782133936882019,
-0.46903887391090393,
0.23976172506809235,
0.0186916533857584,
0.012210441753268242,
1.2814220190048218,
0.26492252945899963,
-0.6064885854721069,
0.6578100919723511,
-0.22934363782405853,
0.3268466889858246,
-0.7694568634033203,
-0.31229493021965027,
-0.26094186305999756,
0.03374044969677925,
-0.17505353689193726,
-0.3373638689517975,
0.4896634519100189,
0.21481125056743622,
-0.09904351085424423,
-0.11183375120162964,
0.4239044785499573,
-0.805067777633667,
-0.47638195753097534,
-0.2753146290779114,
0.5647132992744446,
0.17977729439735413,
0.05641060695052147,
-0.3737877607345581,
0.008141249418258667,
0.00981286820024252,
0.16914257407188416,
0.39170587062835693,
0.6068029999732971,
0.14264291524887085,
0.48573750257492065,
0.5745710730552673,
0.07676742225885391,
-0.11332307010889053,
0.1780177801847458,
0.8068227767944336,
-0.4999086558818817,
-0.4832794666290283,
-1.1217882633209229,
0.6485514640808105,
-0.38873589038848877,
0.086815744638443,
0.943956732749939,
0.6725470423698425,
0.5719645023345947,
-0.038345642387866974,
0.8746296167373657,
0.2612626254558563,
0.4301512539386749,
-0.5620489716529846,
0.8035993576049805,
-0.276022732257843,
0.4052048623561859,
-0.2433820217847824,
-1.0814892053604126,
-0.28458335995674133,
0.48249149322509766,
-0.26473110914230347,
-0.23801040649414062,
0.5788406729698181,
0.9105740785598755,
-0.15357552468776703,
0.08509335666894913,
0.471296489238739,
0.5332953333854675,
0.2896611988544464,
0.29791250824928284,
0.9268730878829956,
-0.27571728825569153,
0.31396836042404175,
-0.15530076622962952,
-0.16861693561077118,
-0.1785891354084015,
-1.1401691436767578,
-0.9145870208740234,
-0.38034024834632874,
-0.6935091018676758,
-0.2342015951871872,
0.1843586415052414,
1.068880319595337,
0.6133628487586975,
-0.7804692983627319,
-0.2028915137052536,
0.12723949551582336,
0.3181826174259186,
0.05005165934562683,
-0.18948690593242645,
0.11770787090063095,
-0.37373802065849304,
-0.5683913826942444,
0.1534656286239624,
0.47157540917396545,
0.17205879092216492,
-0.005646348465234041,
-0.1682189255952835,
0.01463257521390915,
0.36933010816574097,
0.6892492771148682,
0.36630570888519287,
-0.6456621885299683,
-0.39241257309913635,
-0.46268442273139954,
-0.10974275320768356,
0.0597074069082737,
0.6700419187545776,
-0.8000321388244629,
0.3325002193450928,
0.3481867015361786,
0.5917245149612427,
0.48189857602119446,
0.35192421078681946,
0.762611985206604,
-0.8863264918327332,
0.1937170922756195,
0.04337253049015999,
0.33150213956832886,
0.29714685678482056,
-0.27021127939224243,
0.3015025556087494,
0.3039887845516205,
-0.2565252482891083,
-0.715711236000061,
0.1313476264476776,
-1.1023550033569336,
-0.07161632925271988,
0.9881081581115723,
-0.49132266640663147,
0.1440643072128296,
-0.3248586654663086,
-0.24647477269172668,
0.5281696915626526,
-0.44499629735946655,
1.1333589553833008,
0.4968402683734894,
-0.1008475199341774,
-0.055928003042936325,
-0.19318659603595734,
0.5223945379257202,
0.34158390760421753,
-0.7952381372451782,
0.19177371263504028,
0.9351052641868591,
0.33136850595474243,
0.1695958822965622,
0.49431201815605164,
0.03328658640384674,
0.0855175256729126,
-0.07808636128902435,
-0.27702993154525757,
-0.17478007078170776,
-0.4257732927799225,
-0.2598029375076294,
0.10929872840642929,
-0.11777662485837936,
0.08241988718509674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14703v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14703v1 | Do LLMs Have Distinct and Consistent Personality? TRAIT: Personality Testset designed for LLMs with Psychometrics | 2024-06-20T19:50:56 | 2024-06-20T19:50:56 | Seungbeen Lee, Seungwon Lim, Seungju Han, Giyeong Oh, Hyungjoo Chae, Jiwan Chung, Minju Kim, Beong-woo Kwak, Yeonsoo Lee, Dongha Lee, Jinyoung Yeo, Youngjae Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The idea of personality in descriptive psychology, traditionally defined
through observable behavior, has now been extended to Large Language Models
(LLMs) to better understand their behavior. This raises a question: do LLMs
exhibit distinct and consistent personality traits, similar to humans? Existing
self-assessment personality tests, while applicable, lack the necessary
validity and reliability for precise personality measurements. To address this,
we introduce TRAIT, a new tool consisting of 8K multi-choice questions designed
to assess the personality of LLMs with validity and reliability. TRAIT is built
on the psychometrically validated human questionnaire, Big Five Inventory (BFI)
and Short Dark Triad (SD-3), enhanced with the ATOMIC10X knowledge graph for
testing personality in a variety of real scenarios. TRAIT overcomes the
reliability and validity issues when measuring personality of LLM with
self-assessment, showing the highest scores across three metrics: refusal rate,
prompt sensitivity, and option order sensitivity. It reveals notable insights
into personality of LLM: 1) LLMs exhibit distinct and consistent personality,
which is highly influenced by their training data (i.e., data used for
alignment tuning), and 2) current prompting techniques have limited
effectiveness in eliciting certain traits, such as high psychopathy or low
conscientiousness, suggesting the need for further research in this direction. | [
-0.5001640915870667,
-0.5976586937904358,
0.7243366837501526,
0.5545960664749146,
-0.021904071792960167,
0.3581475615501404,
-0.2474932223558426,
-0.6224114894866943,
0.4709467589855194,
0.3533343970775604,
-0.7309132218360901,
-0.20483338832855225,
-0.2856811583042145,
0.3323386311531067,
-0.09675334393978119,
0.9622020125389099,
0.19091321527957916,
0.33162885904312134,
-0.17412084341049194,
-0.5663118958473206,
-0.36342352628707886,
-0.7323204874992371,
-0.5648592710494995,
-0.4699373245239258,
1.1571459770202637,
0.3679414391517639,
0.538007378578186,
0.3815988302230835,
0.5018117427825928,
0.20888099074363708,
-0.26229724287986755,
0.09389320015907288,
-0.4608735144138336,
0.15804269909858704,
-0.23931491374969482,
-0.2687620222568512,
-0.754708468914032,
0.20008757710456848,
0.4940463602542877,
0.7905100584030151,
0.10979673266410828,
0.4349334239959717,
0.12853842973709106,
0.6785083413124084,
-0.4268125295639038,
-0.2444009929895401,
-0.2057613730430603,
-0.22159576416015625,
-0.1939331591129303,
0.11574873328208923,
-0.3138858377933502,
-0.5391146540641785,
0.01506179291754961,
0.023495638743042946,
0.2077733278274536,
-0.007112113758921623,
0.633901834487915,
0.029189910739660263,
-0.8476347327232361,
-0.05165989324450493,
-0.7816322445869446,
0.7532625794410706,
-0.5094894170761108,
0.21465297043323517,
0.30734550952911377,
0.3007014989852905,
-0.04361981153488159,
-0.24537059664726257,
-0.5718882083892822,
-0.3407500386238098,
-0.20741285383701324,
0.04217405617237091,
0.5073375701904297,
-0.10994910448789597,
0.32414352893829346,
0.5873765349388123,
-0.7441582679748535,
0.47453945875167847,
0.05644241347908974,
-0.15138064324855804,
0.8988817930221558,
0.4887107312679291,
-0.11388315260410309,
-0.07056711614131927,
-0.3188123106956482,
-0.11854630708694458,
-0.7888915538787842,
0.3264600336551666,
0.6761160492897034,
-0.11889319121837616,
0.013510273769497871,
0.4648219048976898,
-0.3144071400165558,
0.525976836681366,
0.19509918987751007,
-0.4379429221153259,
0.2664937376976013,
-0.25822532176971436,
0.21223586797714233,
-0.26083242893218994,
0.7508542537689209,
0.26580625772476196,
0.2768018841743469,
-0.11696392297744751,
-0.19425465166568756,
-0.07578454166650772,
0.13227243721485138,
-0.668311595916748,
-0.29502975940704346,
0.4994422197341919,
-0.6220231056213379,
-0.5874799489974976,
0.034880802035331726,
-0.7209069728851318,
-0.6146659255027771,
0.017372146248817444,
0.06781759858131409,
-0.39954379200935364,
-0.4199375510215759,
-0.2152615785598755,
-0.09758457541465759,
0.6145176291465759,
0.12213385850191116,
-1.1670348644256592,
0.06144100800156593,
0.5963609218597412,
0.47402024269104004,
-0.7243520617485046,
-0.5154961347579956,
-0.4127639830112457,
-0.1512679159641266,
-0.2730831503868103,
0.7158376574516296,
-0.5598231554031372,
-0.44009944796562195,
-0.34580478072166443,
-0.10397117584943771,
0.23255088925361633,
-0.6042113900184631,
0.3740207850933075,
-0.2511481046676636,
-0.10743009299039841,
-0.8340985774993896,
-0.5675914883613586,
0.10771992057561874,
0.44859498739242554,
-0.49558913707733154,
0.9986087679862976,
0.47088623046875,
-0.4940851032733917,
0.6686785221099854,
-0.3646101653575897,
-0.23971979320049286,
0.130299374461174,
-0.30367812514305115,
-0.39969590306282043,
0.15427061915397644,
-0.1360369473695755,
0.42102986574172974,
-0.043293144553899765,
0.034677207469940186,
-0.9179075360298157,
-0.2585223317146301,
1.038313388824463,
-0.16176076233386993,
0.6991849541664124,
-0.043730415403842926,
-0.10200813412666321,
0.20297680795192719,
-1.0372973680496216,
0.32817211747169495,
0.12865479290485382,
-0.4248441457748413,
-0.04999252408742905,
0.050486788153648376,
-0.017885951325297356,
0.27615630626678467,
0.48945775628089905,
-0.796747624874115,
0.39269736409187317,
0.13064545392990112,
0.11036477982997894,
0.9504067897796631,
0.012173052877187729,
0.049606382846832275,
-0.5964524149894714,
0.4504731297492981,
-0.13084079325199127,
0.3071361184120178,
0.23749077320098877,
-0.34117788076400757,
-0.7255541086196899,
-0.6843976378440857,
-0.10154736042022705,
0.3747536540031433,
0.17976774275302887,
0.9002193808555603,
0.04315105453133583,
-0.7728166580200195,
-0.2660488784313202,
0.2181272953748703,
0.42921003699302673,
0.22539329528808594,
0.05796045809984207,
-0.4215855598449707,
-0.4910673201084137,
-0.8252668976783752,
-0.28894779086112976,
-0.20322909951210022,
-0.18889205157756805,
0.3560364842414856,
0.48702532052993774,
-0.1647420972585678,
0.8337923884391785,
-0.5482669472694397,
0.1410553902387619,
-0.543316662311554,
0.16004200279712677,
0.15197372436523438,
0.09263814985752106,
0.8508650064468384,
-0.5976436138153076,
-0.377517968416214,
-0.2995027005672455,
-0.7482585906982422,
-0.19295763969421387,
0.04590880870819092,
0.061075739562511444,
-0.036231160163879395,
0.18096010386943817,
-0.18655510246753693,
0.07906574755907059,
0.5539485216140747,
-0.588573694229126,
0.9480324387550354,
0.10592051595449448,
-0.07433249056339264,
-0.7553452849388123,
0.2280026376247406,
-0.27813753485679626,
-0.1385953575372696,
-0.5138711333274841,
0.17408166825771332,
0.009036464616656303,
0.20467399060726166,
-0.21165142953395844,
0.8504393696784973,
-0.05485353618860245,
-0.2587589621543884,
-0.09848190099000931,
-0.35202571749687195,
0.030827442184090614,
0.46624571084976196,
-0.05583474040031433,
0.779577374458313,
0.4315330386161804,
-0.649384617805481,
0.5256941914558411,
0.33465561270713806,
-0.16731202602386475,
1.2636030912399292,
-0.5265305638313293,
0.42746320366859436,
0.038110870867967606,
-0.015524101443588734,
-0.8906974792480469,
-0.29660680890083313,
-0.18189337849617004,
-0.32472363114356995,
-0.00035141780972480774,
0.23658913373947144,
-0.2649933695793152,
-0.3290446996688843,
-0.34314417839050293,
-0.01876799389719963,
0.5629770755767822,
-0.3916008770465851,
0.5827714204788208,
-0.16749641299247742,
-0.22720967233181,
-0.3664582073688507,
-0.4702584743499756,
-0.2479075789451599,
-0.34750187397003174,
-0.33246567845344543,
-0.023093029856681824,
-0.7846997976303101,
-0.3175335228443146,
-0.3377887010574341,
-0.1418365240097046,
-0.20724110305309296,
0.35911762714385986,
0.22417238354682922,
0.2891180217266083,
-0.1982903927564621,
-0.10060246288776398,
-0.43028372526168823,
0.01151193305850029,
0.1383657306432724,
0.15857115387916565,
0.5092134475708008,
-0.3970075249671936,
-0.3269544243812561,
-0.274288535118103,
0.3553254008293152,
0.8153256177902222,
-0.2818283438682556,
0.5919729471206665,
0.6942564249038696,
0.2583133280277252,
0.016630753874778748,
-0.6597224473953247,
-0.3558337092399597,
-0.4228942096233368,
0.3046813905239105,
-0.556347668170929,
-1.0595314502716064,
0.8248435854911804,
0.09578152745962143,
-0.07031382620334625,
0.027410762384533882,
0.5838376879692078,
-0.5384254455566406,
1.0211926698684692,
0.7199577689170837,
-0.17298592627048492,
0.3556303083896637,
0.18637044727802277,
0.20132584869861603,
-0.976986289024353,
-0.18987686932086945,
-0.315716952085495,
-0.6990113258361816,
-0.6351343989372253,
0.29681333899497986,
0.3109692633152008,
-0.15847061574459076,
-0.4818488657474518,
-0.22953535616397858,
-0.19023257493972778,
0.45104122161865234,
0.30906814336776733,
0.1667933315038681,
0.3666464686393738,
-0.47019845247268677,
-0.1568862348794937,
-0.27048709988594055,
-0.036384861916303635,
-0.6103336811065674,
1.2773956060409546,
0.2517238259315491,
0.7820835113525391,
0.33426231145858765,
0.7610358595848083,
0.08456192165613174,
0.45078569650650024,
-0.8058784604072571,
0.747248113155365,
0.003961113281548023,
-0.6018805503845215,
-0.3626091778278351,
-0.3763014078140259,
-0.591339111328125,
-0.00446606008335948,
-0.26508572697639465,
-0.9391152858734131,
0.17509342730045319,
0.23674176633358002,
-0.2972174286842346,
0.08377649635076523,
-0.45689019560813904,
0.7545787692070007,
-0.6889527440071106,
-0.33561697602272034,
0.09168700128793716,
-0.6565435528755188,
0.4113553762435913,
-0.2563449442386627,
-0.41705483198165894,
-0.4316391348838806,
0.16887259483337402,
0.409697026014328,
-0.17132070660591125,
0.7185824513435364,
0.16357465088367462,
0.09176301211118698,
-0.1421564221382141,
0.301742285490036,
0.4230053126811981,
0.042390067130327225,
-0.20644956827163696,
0.0018755998462438583,
0.2421570122241974,
-0.4055576026439667,
-0.9307120442390442,
0.5971044898033142,
-0.8741849064826965,
-0.39461851119995117,
-0.4055373966693878,
-0.38067197799682617,
-0.5198219418525696,
0.23364120721817017,
0.15626274049282074,
0.2462637722492218,
-0.6277378797531128,
0.17338716983795166,
0.7324493527412415,
-0.0198514387011528,
0.1547851264476776,
0.8565047979354858,
-0.40279439091682434,
-0.2662001848220825,
0.8274295926094055,
-0.20769745111465454,
0.5725640654563904,
0.21774782240390778,
0.40648555755615234,
-0.13181520998477936,
-0.3560011088848114,
0.04566910117864609,
0.4281226694583893,
-0.5159429907798767,
0.19378544390201569,
-0.3853003978729248,
-0.3350713551044464,
-0.2685632109642029,
-0.2225816398859024,
-0.43239641189575195,
-0.0476677231490612,
0.05779142677783966,
-0.06344570964574814,
0.38188233971595764,
0.9979434609413147,
0.2263476848602295,
0.11934003233909607,
-0.44948697090148926,
0.29286399483680725,
0.7122063040733337,
0.4380207359790802,
-0.28973355889320374,
-0.304521381855011,
0.21268010139465332,
-0.2566838264465332,
-0.40306591987609863,
-0.9300336837768555,
0.1852836012840271,
0.1668027937412262,
0.5127027034759521,
0.7664029002189636,
-0.23202793300151825,
0.28091108798980713,
-0.003752912627533078,
0.7255176305770874,
-0.06669389456510544,
-0.6418058276176453,
0.2913459539413452,
-0.28361058235168457,
0.16597980260849,
0.7191310524940491,
0.45575404167175293,
-0.6955408453941345,
-0.5710631608963013,
-0.6364553570747375,
-0.2986370921134949,
0.3165363371372223,
0.04127921909093857,
-0.15527547895908356,
0.09231242537498474,
0.4719955325126648,
0.2499750405550003,
0.32437992095947266,
-0.6275570392608643,
-0.42130717635154724,
-0.23471513390541077,
-0.2841022312641144,
-0.23004530370235443,
-0.5317949056625366,
-0.24023672938346863,
-0.43884092569351196,
0.2544114291667938,
-0.45264601707458496,
0.1498117595911026,
0.025417864322662354,
0.16915374994277954,
0.16257788240909576,
0.5264305472373962,
0.38882511854171753,
0.79449462890625,
-0.6088746190071106,
0.20518694818019867,
0.13559052348136902,
-0.550529420375824,
0.3990768492221832,
-0.34897738695144653,
-0.038392484188079834,
-0.29166707396507263,
0.18305400013923645,
0.45981839299201965,
0.02120502106845379,
-0.5132522583007812,
0.6218091249465942,
-0.12534072995185852,
-0.1664450466632843,
-0.39515992999076843,
0.23631788790225983,
0.052783623337745667,
0.22758620977401733,
0.15798068046569824,
-0.1218281015753746,
-0.10228706151247025,
-0.6938411593437195,
0.02632145583629608,
0.44128188490867615,
-0.24520348012447357,
-0.41848498582839966,
0.3358288109302521,
0.27188870310783386,
-0.15680274367332458,
0.7537016868591309,
-0.49069085717201233,
-0.3836709260940552,
0.49142277240753174,
0.3689892292022705,
0.8390511870384216,
-0.16483807563781738,
0.37969979643821716,
0.14280977845191956,
0.23039603233337402,
0.03145533800125122,
0.8196415901184082,
0.04806423559784889,
-1.0348159074783325,
-0.11325380951166153,
-0.7866454124450684,
-0.757209062576294,
0.46162357926368713,
-0.7158925533294678,
0.05696093291044235,
-0.7342771291732788,
-0.08511282503604889,
-0.18539908528327942,
0.13814085721969604,
-0.7090964913368225,
0.12132005393505096,
0.009134574793279171,
0.7299754023551941,
-0.8383941054344177,
0.7462893128395081,
0.7518211007118225,
-0.2816331088542938,
-0.8999038934707642,
-0.10407476872205734,
0.16249017417430878,
-0.8129448890686035,
0.6028189063072205,
0.11174406856298447,
0.028169013559818268,
0.010570031590759754,
-0.616623044013977,
-0.7549152970314026,
1.0866904258728027,
0.3073683977127075,
-0.13460442423820496,
0.18099182844161987,
0.1540265828371048,
0.5636995434761047,
-0.3669670522212982,
0.3850806951522827,
0.7753637433052063,
0.5495712757110596,
0.16080020368099213,
-0.8317859768867493,
-0.026554040610790253,
-0.17170879244804382,
-0.05106313154101372,
-0.09091008454561234,
-0.9557014107704163,
0.6812797784805298,
-0.350450336933136,
0.2834435999393463,
0.34085613489151,
0.624154806137085,
0.5822634696960449,
0.005516294855624437,
0.4104180335998535,
0.471529096364975,
1.0427461862564087,
-0.12571601569652557,
0.8190502524375916,
-0.3218579888343811,
0.21259276568889618,
1.0806660652160645,
-0.6955047845840454,
0.738251268863678,
0.4003731310367584,
-0.17813321948051453,
0.8269304037094116,
0.6775514483451843,
-0.2017122209072113,
0.1961604356765747,
-0.10924137383699417,
-0.3484424650669098,
-0.4984610080718994,
-0.0446632020175457,
0.006146255414932966,
0.8022169470787048,
0.10375431180000305,
-0.1974727213382721,
0.31758445501327515,
-0.08149417489767075,
0.0745636448264122,
-0.04136599227786064,
-0.05488438531756401,
0.5843220353126526,
-0.06640532612800598,
-0.579262912273407,
0.24654220044612885,
-0.3288406729698181,
0.6213251352310181,
-0.9299529790878296,
0.30970898270606995,
-0.6367703080177307,
0.25951218605041504,
-0.27157604694366455,
-0.9923028349876404,
0.12150946259498596,
-0.15290617942810059,
-0.22089149057865143,
-0.4474528133869171,
0.4504406154155731,
-0.14583535492420197,
-0.18015876412391663,
0.04099886119365692,
0.6461366415023804,
0.18183644115924835,
-0.15431731939315796,
-0.37674957513809204,
-0.1336827129125595,
-0.3611088693141937,
-0.24579092860221863,
0.5893510580062866,
0.2040586918592453,
0.06316415220499039,
0.8996787071228027,
0.5824627876281738,
0.32222169637680054,
-0.1325877606868744,
0.09759071469306946,
0.5782848596572876,
-0.9093550443649292,
-0.45604559779167175,
-0.8582098484039307,
0.3297880291938782,
-0.18434453010559082,
-0.6839892268180847,
0.8732548952102661,
0.4845431447029114,
0.5638430118560791,
-0.08179504424333572,
0.6037543416023254,
0.0055430918000638485,
0.6516622304916382,
-0.3130199611186981,
0.641083836555481,
-0.32243454456329346,
-0.09618989378213882,
-0.03583307936787605,
-0.8781252503395081,
0.13881829380989075,
0.33417627215385437,
-0.11637384444475174,
0.2776939868927002,
1.038316249847412,
0.7226046323776245,
0.24546046555042267,
-0.11291605979204178,
0.42144760489463806,
0.2731841206550598,
0.29998859763145447,
0.5586960315704346,
0.9201120138168335,
0.2213287353515625,
0.12877680361270905,
-0.1679665744304657,
-0.3322538733482361,
-0.22179874777793884,
-0.6936452388763428,
-0.9434998035430908,
-0.30956602096557617,
-0.1889246106147766,
-0.26737576723098755,
-0.2680957615375519,
0.7878658771514893,
0.49341076612472534,
-0.4643409848213196,
-0.3114066421985626,
0.23871755599975586,
0.301194965839386,
-0.4859268069267273,
-0.24790066480636597,
-0.11893816292285919,
-0.15406322479248047,
-0.2564980089664459,
0.21716688573360443,
0.46862128376960754,
0.13665460050106049,
-0.8689731359481812,
-0.09858723729848862,
0.17184993624687195,
0.04805203527212143,
0.4273645579814911,
0.49733373522758484,
-0.6135364174842834,
-0.7377870678901672,
0.4489038288593292,
-0.3485027551651001,
0.09269079566001892,
0.981738269329071,
-0.49696284532546997,
0.2883913815021515,
0.37504929304122925,
0.1537722796201706,
0.11747171729803085,
-0.21894170343875885,
0.47207579016685486,
-0.8180214166641235,
0.002695114817470312,
0.2829102575778961,
0.31245705485343933,
0.2896624207496643,
-0.46814507246017456,
0.327286034822464,
0.4170825183391571,
-0.7945831418037415,
-0.45847201347351074,
0.6572968363761902,
-1.209295392036438,
0.09962157160043716,
1.2145522832870483,
-0.07356419414281845,
-0.10409481078386307,
-0.22380530834197998,
-0.10047485679388046,
-0.32443103194236755,
-0.08805326372385025,
0.8336286544799805,
0.8462751507759094,
-0.6397590041160583,
-0.272394597530365,
-0.19091476500034332,
0.5365684032440186,
0.44040605425834656,
-0.814605712890625,
-0.06346160918474197,
0.28903692960739136,
0.6111248135566711,
-0.0004975014016963542,
0.6320831775665283,
-0.054659586399793625,
0.20822446048259735,
-0.30234429240226746,
0.14714454114437103,
0.12026198208332062,
-0.13071604073047638,
-0.23421531915664673,
-0.011508144438266754,
0.5229770541191101,
0.17361629009246826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14701v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14701v1 | Speech Prefix-Tuning with RNNT Loss for Improving LLM Predictions | 2024-06-20T19:50:49 | 2024-06-20T19:50:49 | Murali Karthick Baskar, Andrew Rosenberg, Bhuvana Ramabhadran, Neeraj Gaur, Zhong Meng | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In this paper, we focus on addressing the constraints faced when applying
LLMs to ASR. Recent works utilize prefixLM-type models, which directly apply
speech as a prefix to LLMs for ASR. We have found that optimizing speech
prefixes leads to better ASR performance and propose applying RNNT loss to
perform speech prefix-tuning. This is a simple approach and does not increase
the model complexity or alter the inference pipeline. We also propose
language-based soft prompting to further improve with frozen LLMs. Empirical
analysis on realtime testset from 10 Indic languages demonstrate that our
proposed speech prefix-tuning yields improvements with both frozen and
fine-tuned LLMs. Our recognition results on an average of 10 Indics show that
the proposed prefix-tuning with RNNT loss results in a 12\% relative
improvement in WER over the baseline with a fine-tuned LLM. Our proposed
approches with the frozen LLM leads to a 31\% relative improvement over basic
soft-prompting prefixLM. | [
-0.3554491400718689,
-0.5434411764144897,
0.1880984604358673,
0.0005593498353846371,
-0.5604220628738403,
0.2168837934732437,
-0.6738177537918091,
-0.3645719289779663,
0.26305633783340454,
0.4089759290218353,
-0.7983015775680542,
-0.2604553699493408,
-0.3819678723812103,
0.4341055154800415,
-0.10546988248825073,
0.5876137018203735,
0.10550562292337418,
0.4157920777797699,
-0.10106013715267181,
0.07588917762041092,
-0.8036099076271057,
-0.3464584946632385,
-1.045091152191162,
-0.7377782464027405,
0.5098907351493835,
0.7349342107772827,
0.5820948481559753,
0.8174691200256348,
0.33115965127944946,
0.3010942339897156,
-0.494937539100647,
0.20992428064346313,
-0.36743664741516113,
0.24329911172389984,
0.07824376225471497,
-0.5523552298545837,
-0.3584563732147217,
-0.158404141664505,
0.7371084690093994,
0.6266170740127563,
-0.30671417713165283,
0.02089739963412285,
-0.03592301532626152,
0.6396734714508057,
-0.30301734805107117,
-0.2010880559682846,
-0.8657102584838867,
0.12255945056676865,
-0.4698088765144348,
-0.48945534229278564,
-0.18313953280448914,
-0.32769107818603516,
-0.03318744897842407,
-0.25708088278770447,
0.47610175609588623,
0.18190832436084747,
0.7560707926750183,
0.6102496981620789,
-0.21748332679271698,
-0.057992592453956604,
-0.7968130707740784,
0.612449049949646,
-0.8739328980445862,
0.7159651517868042,
0.38049718737602234,
-0.17336058616638184,
-0.29431265592575073,
-0.4942411482334137,
-0.3811526298522949,
-0.34004008769989014,
0.23063109815120697,
0.1072894036769867,
-0.06725932657718658,
0.33411842584609985,
0.25866594910621643,
0.4140368700027466,
-0.41841796040534973,
0.542526125907898,
-0.3651714026927948,
-0.5009514689445496,
0.7029983997344971,
0.4400784969329834,
-0.06683490425348282,
0.24138334393501282,
-0.2188982516527176,
0.08126628398895264,
-0.9106637239456177,
-0.060599856078624725,
0.4560791254043579,
0.5246303677558899,
-0.015309941954910755,
0.3868699371814728,
-0.15125784277915955,
0.7796847224235535,
0.13949720561504364,
-0.21744288504123688,
0.07107561081647873,
-0.05903295427560806,
-0.09617503732442856,
0.3471820652484894,
0.1885201781988144,
0.3910549581050873,
0.6383516192436218,
-0.35539308190345764,
-0.24200142920017242,
0.06672098487615585,
-0.14871656894683838,
-0.643589973449707,
-0.13560520112514496,
-0.24061372876167297,
-0.2580002248287201,
0.1263466626405716,
-0.1438552290201187,
-0.22661645710468292,
-0.44619959592819214,
-0.6777022480964661,
0.29371440410614014,
-0.5206557512283325,
-0.16031570732593536,
0.2975260317325592,
-0.25075623393058777,
0.4503965675830841,
0.40746286511421204,
-0.7120741605758667,
0.5902943015098572,
0.7566563487052917,
0.7597990036010742,
-0.23652425408363342,
-0.06171136721968651,
-0.6904743909835815,
-0.08390103280544281,
-0.35508355498313904,
0.9891334176063538,
-0.3832894265651703,
-0.6039467453956604,
-0.14407862722873688,
-0.28772884607315063,
-0.07456163316965103,
-0.6945754885673523,
0.7182644605636597,
-0.47800880670547485,
-0.21887831389904022,
-0.0651962161064148,
-0.795621395111084,
-0.11656492948532104,
-0.06483707576990128,
-0.4028381407260895,
0.7129210829734802,
-0.38505634665489197,
-0.26875385642051697,
0.4365023374557495,
-0.43005964159965515,
-0.7003129124641418,
0.11995664238929749,
0.07222096621990204,
-0.5056303143501282,
0.5917487740516663,
0.11157682538032532,
0.18714331090450287,
-0.577708899974823,
0.116481713950634,
0.04296926409006119,
-0.4508691430091858,
0.5358231067657471,
-0.6579357385635376,
0.25453683733940125,
0.3203306496143341,
-0.10534054785966873,
0.1928560882806778,
-0.49622842669487,
0.3644959628582001,
-0.2760426700115204,
-0.41553810238838196,
-0.14667385816574097,
0.087950199842453,
0.10725274682044983,
-0.4456014931201935,
-0.13071344792842865,
-0.5406323671340942,
0.11034423112869263,
-0.8114677667617798,
0.48369014263153076,
0.8228427767753601,
-0.1398860514163971,
0.32791391015052795,
-0.1953304558992386,
0.6878688335418701,
-0.24706152081489563,
-0.08403737097978592,
0.16163873672485352,
-0.5532073974609375,
-0.974340558052063,
-0.16104823350906372,
0.8620518445968628,
0.4627387523651123,
-0.5717894434928894,
0.1509547382593155,
-0.11433833092451096,
-0.09051211178302765,
-0.5942885279655457,
-0.035516683012247086,
0.46052035689353943,
0.6959267854690552,
0.26623448729515076,
-0.4781544804573059,
-0.7787283658981323,
-0.8937968611717224,
-0.5515577793121338,
0.026981014758348465,
-0.0841820165514946,
0.17430637776851654,
-0.06751751154661179,
0.17404523491859436,
1.0210051536560059,
-0.3878759443759918,
-0.24766908586025238,
-0.30444005131721497,
0.1496516317129135,
0.3753191828727722,
0.5008761882781982,
-0.20964054763317108,
-0.8150056004524231,
-0.5453325510025024,
-0.41382110118865967,
0.019744662567973137,
-0.3041435480117798,
0.3262886106967926,
0.5974119901657104,
0.4016754627227783,
0.7201361656188965,
-0.4961784780025482,
0.5964985489845276,
0.15214990079402924,
-0.40873220562934875,
0.40434953570365906,
-0.1776742786169052,
-0.18384532630443573,
-0.856184184551239,
-0.3351283371448517,
-0.14117200672626495,
-0.2818707823753357,
-0.9586353302001953,
-0.5366776585578918,
-0.02477351948618889,
-0.25288304686546326,
-0.5481204986572266,
0.6791543960571289,
-0.6920577883720398,
-0.0011362310033291578,
-0.3469626307487488,
-0.1312076598405838,
-0.22809794545173645,
0.06050235405564308,
0.25725704431533813,
0.982179582118988,
0.5669626593589783,
-0.8029054403305054,
0.007936062291264534,
0.10503628849983215,
-0.3158746659755707,
0.20258845388889313,
-0.7028006911277771,
0.31787148118019104,
-0.2950684130191803,
0.16496656835079193,
-0.6547155380249023,
-0.11215765029191971,
0.219552144408226,
-0.520745575428009,
0.8091326355934143,
-0.22018121182918549,
-0.30667629837989807,
-0.24611426889896393,
-0.20280425250530243,
0.33066341280937195,
0.7363607287406921,
-0.3202078938484192,
0.5876227617263794,
0.060511115938425064,
-0.18863709270954132,
-0.3850209712982178,
-0.7358108162879944,
0.2630309760570526,
-0.609704852104187,
-0.50416100025177,
0.6805294156074524,
-0.23737379908561707,
-0.14742165803909302,
0.065791554749012,
-0.23959779739379883,
0.11439111828804016,
0.030359704047441483,
0.32645198702812195,
0.009654199704527855,
-0.4901922345161438,
0.2490084171295166,
-0.3252522349357605,
-0.537534236907959,
-0.2452237904071808,
-0.09274866431951523,
0.5289022326469421,
-0.3207233250141144,
-0.17300815880298615,
-0.6285868287086487,
0.14038735628128052,
0.06611140072345734,
-0.06288871169090271,
0.2795158326625824,
0.5894854664802551,
-0.12969699501991272,
-0.1532198041677475,
-0.9465616345405579,
-0.5990791916847229,
-0.5299137830734253,
0.07492703199386597,
-0.46145859360694885,
-1.0228049755096436,
0.6194568872451782,
-0.25713738799095154,
-0.3932851254940033,
0.32167521119117737,
0.41533711552619934,
0.022958654910326004,
0.7659363746643066,
0.7987701892852783,
-0.20981530845165253,
0.4891699254512787,
-0.14530009031295776,
0.030620908364653587,
-0.9714574217796326,
-0.2890605330467224,
-0.6094731688499451,
-0.44304144382476807,
-0.6558127403259277,
-0.4915202260017395,
0.4864019751548767,
0.04554504528641701,
-0.24115553498268127,
0.04887544736266136,
-0.5098034143447876,
0.5758183598518372,
0.6257422566413879,
-0.019931882619857788,
0.32460787892341614,
0.19245600700378418,
0.08289723098278046,
-0.22338628768920898,
-0.9508196711540222,
-0.2178684026002884,
0.6808878779411316,
0.4092456102371216,
1.1743297576904297,
0.05984374135732651,
0.6360097527503967,
0.14588835835456848,
0.24355639517307281,
-1.0320113897323608,
0.5736161470413208,
-0.2587521970272064,
-0.4486401677131653,
-0.42605581879615784,
-0.4239713251590729,
-0.968155026435852,
-0.03052809089422226,
-0.01309721078723669,
-0.766893208026886,
0.1603585183620453,
0.30499500036239624,
-0.45175254344940186,
0.1456815004348755,
-0.4729919731616974,
0.24617063999176025,
-0.2544651925563812,
-0.07690665125846863,
-0.17080466449260712,
-0.741075336933136,
0.09455880522727966,
0.39475512504577637,
-0.16243398189544678,
-0.5882214307785034,
-0.36054518818855286,
0.7671559453010559,
-0.5757313370704651,
0.883423388004303,
-0.10055801272392273,
0.05244559049606323,
0.2653766870498657,
-0.1271771788597107,
0.6022005081176758,
0.16808973252773285,
-0.4806548058986664,
0.32357946038246155,
-0.5039119720458984,
0.17791996896266937,
-0.5615691542625427,
0.6725339889526367,
-0.6235352754592896,
-0.8264397382736206,
-0.45813289284706116,
-0.6793726086616516,
-0.43445950746536255,
-0.07360075414180756,
0.5543777346611023,
0.8865881562232971,
0.0061600166372954845,
0.12604781985282898,
0.9511060118675232,
-0.013960432261228561,
0.5957642197608948,
0.9494630098342896,
0.22416022419929504,
-0.5810034275054932,
0.7838017344474792,
0.27546221017837524,
0.18299971520900726,
0.23658497631549835,
0.49308666586875916,
-0.6377360224723816,
-0.9435804486274719,
-0.3979763984680176,
0.2656833827495575,
-0.5401891469955444,
-0.7728961110115051,
-0.17518025636672974,
-0.3121168911457062,
-0.4622087776660919,
-0.14782343804836273,
-0.3786197304725647,
-0.5073050856590271,
-0.6593690514564514,
-0.0016996508929878473,
1.0369019508361816,
0.6191142797470093,
-0.3598394989967346,
0.2879889905452728,
-0.37423112988471985,
0.2876245379447937,
0.06770126521587372,
0.6836522221565247,
-0.23680128157138824,
-1.0140659809112549,
0.002289909403771162,
-0.12480704486370087,
0.07466273754835129,
-0.6470735669136047,
0.5575236082077026,
0.834839940071106,
0.31761184334754944,
0.2549721896648407,
0.22437427937984467,
1.157094955444336,
-0.754734218120575,
0.6237231492996216,
0.1814897656440735,
-0.9239449501037598,
0.42655062675476074,
-0.04191015288233757,
0.5132059454917908,
0.7147512435913086,
-0.1065787523984909,
-0.5250802040100098,
-0.2747940421104431,
-0.5322745442390442,
-0.9505269527435303,
0.7280579209327698,
0.07341210544109344,
0.36176952719688416,
0.18726491928100586,
0.6812489032745361,
0.047988634556531906,
0.16916780173778534,
-0.3246726393699646,
-0.6870836019515991,
0.07528233528137207,
0.15448568761348724,
-0.2968166768550873,
-0.38242560625076294,
0.07069671154022217,
-0.4736902713775635,
0.8098729848861694,
-0.031134117394685745,
0.1622285693883896,
0.23345503211021423,
0.17821568250656128,
-0.416338175535202,
0.35510846972465515,
0.8024512529373169,
0.30813661217689514,
-0.18176087737083435,
0.3027251064777374,
0.7151819467544556,
-0.24638374149799347,
0.1645551174879074,
0.03241923451423645,
-0.27197542786598206,
0.15688537061214447,
0.1881299614906311,
1.0862025022506714,
0.2549511790275574,
-0.420944482088089,
-0.024006852880120277,
-0.17028066515922546,
-0.17330892384052277,
-0.5404525399208069,
0.06117244064807892,
0.15370364487171173,
0.048821426928043365,
0.4010576903820038,
0.13602663576602936,
0.19282808899879456,
-0.42807281017303467,
0.26713958382606506,
0.5426181554794312,
-0.5800211429595947,
-0.12388241291046143,
0.7168071269989014,
0.11061321943998337,
-0.7037782669067383,
0.825678825378418,
-0.015008489601314068,
-0.594923198223114,
0.822048008441925,
0.8811559677124023,
1.1191520690917969,
-0.5183547735214233,
-0.0938933715224266,
0.10357189923524857,
0.24139760434627533,
-0.05011603608727455,
0.4435883164405823,
0.08204206079244614,
-0.6808188557624817,
-0.5519223809242249,
-0.723842442035675,
-0.5297014713287354,
0.219519704580307,
-0.6269088387489319,
0.5428016185760498,
-0.2025049924850464,
-0.3164452016353607,
-0.07780446112155914,
-0.016994807869195938,
-0.6190083026885986,
0.1654614359140396,
0.3413899838924408,
1.13429856300354,
-0.5434431433677673,
0.8694771528244019,
0.6824938654899597,
0.02755717933177948,
-1.0870156288146973,
0.029193684458732605,
0.08162025362253189,
-0.7899229526519775,
0.7412557005882263,
0.06751123070716858,
-0.46819373965263367,
0.4024096429347992,
-0.3656185269355774,
-1.2418867349624634,
0.9523246884346008,
0.5713949203491211,
-0.4700811803340912,
0.45244503021240234,
0.24982646107673645,
0.4473647177219391,
-0.3545480966567993,
0.06850376725196838,
0.5053139925003052,
0.5909799337387085,
0.43142223358154297,
-1.2400398254394531,
-0.05863247439265251,
-0.006544727832078934,
0.2871926426887512,
0.36716464161872864,
-0.5300621390342712,
0.7101878523826599,
-0.3488210439682007,
-0.44907402992248535,
0.12681415677070618,
0.8104782700538635,
-0.07014144957065582,
0.5972670316696167,
0.4915435314178467,
0.4361010491847992,
0.5073615908622742,
-0.14163261651992798,
0.8052645325660706,
-0.19617898762226105,
0.08891841024160385,
1.128179907798767,
-0.18331317603588104,
0.8709757328033447,
0.5016458034515381,
-0.009791776537895203,
0.10473507642745972,
0.7676490545272827,
0.17454488575458527,
0.5569943189620972,
0.656553328037262,
-0.4105662405490875,
-0.24682490527629852,
-0.5267694592475891,
-0.462866872549057,
0.4963264763355255,
0.639239490032196,
0.18445001542568207,
-0.07130781561136246,
0.19402165710926056,
0.01974804326891899,
0.052002426236867905,
-0.6616548895835876,
0.8927431702613831,
0.3913915753364563,
-0.5664658546447754,
0.9148361086845398,
0.12767647206783295,
0.8618536591529846,
-0.5247611403465271,
0.20075391232967377,
-0.3122307360172272,
0.0032560783438384533,
-0.23196251690387726,
-0.3451297879219055,
0.41681596636772156,
-0.15124215185642242,
-0.16322191059589386,
-0.34156888723373413,
1.0808581113815308,
-0.6397771239280701,
-0.41574665904045105,
-0.06377620995044708,
0.4528406262397766,
0.34391283988952637,
0.04962731525301933,
-0.6252350807189941,
0.354745477437973,
-0.1358073204755783,
-0.22542743384838104,
0.16220755875110626,
0.150861918926239,
0.029317734763026237,
0.9411992430686951,
0.48096850514411926,
0.3101257383823395,
0.032525017857551575,
0.18701359629631042,
0.846087634563446,
-0.8163971900939941,
-0.3066161274909973,
-0.8532208204269409,
0.4182724356651306,
0.27222585678100586,
-0.23504899442195892,
0.7424410581588745,
0.59987872838974,
0.45621469616889954,
-0.1726183295249939,
0.5181665420532227,
-0.032438695430755615,
0.6759173274040222,
-0.8787807822227478,
0.46723777055740356,
-0.4349064826965332,
0.3243338167667389,
0.11704601347446442,
-0.812208354473114,
-0.5020876526832581,
0.2735714912414551,
-0.26192596554756165,
-0.02242138236761093,
0.4723900556564331,
1.1781113147735596,
0.06971772015094757,
-0.15432986617088318,
0.6527358889579773,
0.029169254004955292,
-0.22504454851150513,
0.12438834458589554,
0.9057030081748962,
-0.3745540380477905,
0.2574447989463806,
-0.16224808990955353,
0.1616019457578659,
-0.4166640341281891,
-1.0253233909606934,
-0.7066539525985718,
-0.5280022025108337,
-0.6890745162963867,
-0.2152608186006546,
0.4153289496898651,
1.0242730379104614,
0.720110297203064,
-0.8198087811470032,
-0.36159080266952515,
-0.05394045636057854,
0.3145182430744171,
-0.12975235283374786,
-0.17149195075035095,
0.2350347936153412,
-0.46398642659187317,
-0.5148607492446899,
0.908088743686676,
0.11913009732961655,
0.13826534152030945,
0.11130484938621521,
-0.2783062160015106,
0.05667577311396599,
0.13116002082824707,
0.385043203830719,
0.5344768762588501,
-1.0236550569534302,
-0.3255206048488617,
-0.0583890937268734,
0.38380566239356995,
0.1603662520647049,
1.1676504611968994,
-0.9214613437652588,
0.32570669054985046,
0.19834749400615692,
0.28977277874946594,
0.5913378596305847,
0.2516842186450958,
0.7314772605895996,
-0.8882859349250793,
0.0785522535443306,
0.5616551041603088,
0.05050459876656532,
0.3947172462940216,
-0.32050466537475586,
0.5842365622520447,
0.016441039741039276,
-0.4770974814891815,
-0.8258839249610901,
0.27801623940467834,
-0.7670615315437317,
0.008053149096667767,
1.204666018486023,
0.4252488315105438,
0.013115820474922657,
-0.4172796905040741,
-0.0121314637362957,
0.2964659631252289,
-0.7258504629135132,
0.4139251708984375,
0.18708926439285278,
-0.6339285969734192,
-0.36841219663619995,
-0.5555553436279297,
0.9782003164291382,
0.6369906663894653,
-0.31668296456336975,
0.0590994730591774,
0.36706840991973877,
0.44835442304611206,
-0.10205549001693726,
0.6136357188224792,
0.22761593759059906,
0.09166622906923294,
-0.2488587349653244,
0.12005144357681274,
-0.17983828485012054,
-0.2099013775587082,
-0.8958045840263367,
-0.08576337993144989,
0.5392176508903503,
-0.02866269275546074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14695v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14695v1 | Depth $F_1$: Improving Evaluation of Cross-Domain Text Classification by Measuring Semantic Generalizability | 2024-06-20T19:35:17 | 2024-06-20T19:35:17 | Parker Seegmiller, Joseph Gatto, Sarah Masud Preum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent evaluations of cross-domain text classification models aim to measure
the ability of a model to obtain domain-invariant performance in a target
domain given labeled samples in a source domain. The primary strategy for this
evaluation relies on assumed differences between source domain samples and
target domain samples in benchmark datasets. This evaluation strategy fails to
account for the similarity between source and target domains, and may mask when
models fail to transfer learning to specific target samples which are highly
dissimilar from the source domain. We introduce Depth $F_1$, a novel
cross-domain text classification performance metric. Designed to be
complementary to existing classification metrics such as $F_1$, Depth $F_1$
measures how well a model performs on target samples which are dissimilar from
the source domain. We motivate this metric using standard cross-domain text
classification datasets and benchmark several recent cross-domain text
classification models, with the goal of enabling in-depth evaluation of the
semantic generalizability of cross-domain text classification models. | [
-0.45450031757354736,
-0.7363837361335754,
0.3557072579860687,
0.2743332087993622,
-0.3407858908176422,
0.3328891396522522,
-0.05040009692311287,
-0.6256195902824402,
-0.17506654560565948,
0.2956876754760742,
-0.5658702850341797,
-0.9448224306106567,
-1.047264814376831,
0.05989767238497734,
-0.824393630027771,
0.8843877911567688,
-0.31089821457862854,
-0.12505953013896942,
-0.7440041303634644,
-0.33885133266448975,
-0.17505241930484772,
-0.42488229274749756,
-0.4416201114654541,
-0.2290569692850113,
0.38517069816589355,
0.25189194083213806,
0.7445636987686157,
0.3646763265132904,
0.7943977117538452,
0.31808823347091675,
0.2055182158946991,
-0.14469139277935028,
-0.5459527373313904,
-0.2044694423675537,
-0.5164290070533752,
-0.1977202594280243,
-0.46875447034835815,
0.0956551656126976,
0.9897139072418213,
0.9966033697128296,
0.3594801723957062,
-0.06273151189088821,
0.10169664025306702,
0.7180234789848328,
-0.8028092980384827,
-0.18784065544605255,
-0.45137453079223633,
0.31428611278533936,
-0.10867851972579956,
-0.2846269905567169,
-0.23170430958271027,
-0.13377812504768372,
0.9507864117622375,
-0.9041917324066162,
0.7609204053878784,
-0.16277135908603668,
0.8348708748817444,
0.22762493789196014,
-0.1766389012336731,
-0.2742576599121094,
-0.796998143196106,
0.9224103689193726,
-0.46689629554748535,
0.8159615397453308,
0.3463428020477295,
0.5053436756134033,
0.4310787320137024,
-0.8534913659095764,
-0.4201441705226898,
0.23657198250293732,
-0.22687141597270966,
-0.15493550896644592,
-0.3992930054664612,
-0.1399352252483368,
-0.08322857320308685,
0.7360014915466309,
-0.7348527312278748,
-0.14193324744701385,
-0.22285465896129608,
-0.22904327511787415,
0.7358585596084595,
0.16411107778549194,
0.3169599175453186,
0.5142658352851868,
-0.6433517932891846,
-0.17009969055652618,
-0.3270083963871002,
0.2160302996635437,
0.25097277760505676,
0.2624169588088989,
-0.024653779342770576,
0.03730432689189911,
-0.41081154346466064,
0.5522457361221313,
-0.19553591310977936,
-0.2046254724264145,
0.31157630681991577,
-0.4155638813972473,
-0.328146368265152,
-0.025153547525405884,
0.5583174228668213,
0.2536870837211609,
0.18062785267829895,
-0.6150533556938171,
-0.15799005329608917,
0.018291229382157326,
0.4566066265106201,
-1.0798836946487427,
-0.06778744608163834,
0.04841717332601547,
-0.5822203159332275,
-0.2803497910499573,
0.3990302085876465,
-0.5693673491477966,
-0.1261759251356125,
-0.01773611269891262,
0.6808333396911621,
-0.5489397644996643,
-0.2947969138622284,
0.39986705780029297,
-0.30243727564811707,
0.2106250524520874,
0.40066173672676086,
-0.9495426416397095,
0.848232090473175,
1.0031203031539917,
0.9848575592041016,
-0.7402134537696838,
-0.5032966136932373,
-0.0654807835817337,
-0.16832929849624634,
-0.26276516914367676,
0.7485489845275879,
-0.6904100179672241,
-0.5277443528175354,
0.07855003327131271,
-0.0033499212004244328,
-0.017591269686818123,
-0.5017960667610168,
0.5900833606719971,
-0.5031238794326782,
0.2109394520521164,
0.006348657887428999,
-0.7111688852310181,
-0.46250563859939575,
0.40026336908340454,
-0.7399492859840393,
0.7428950667381287,
0.7089855670928955,
-0.7489776015281677,
0.9037539958953857,
-0.40431734919548035,
-0.520994246006012,
-0.0627053827047348,
0.0994914248585701,
-0.3650377690792084,
0.14588236808776855,
0.029913419857621193,
0.49529361724853516,
-0.5437129735946655,
-0.09808141738176346,
-0.2629043459892273,
-0.5848380923271179,
0.0416569858789444,
-0.27986985445022583,
0.4911292791366577,
0.06433048844337463,
-0.05469286069273949,
-0.007363889366388321,
-0.8234741687774658,
0.14690472185611725,
0.10624922066926956,
-0.22975462675094604,
-0.8896614909172058,
-0.02753368206322193,
-0.08399105817079544,
-0.11328931897878647,
0.030352244153618813,
-0.5575993061065674,
0.09912377595901489,
-0.7282063364982605,
0.023019831627607346,
0.25678616762161255,
-0.1445682942867279,
0.855363667011261,
-0.27324989438056946,
0.6780992746353149,
0.1192040666937828,
0.11018937081098557,
-0.11856325715780258,
-0.3338286280632019,
-0.4723776876926422,
-0.3119136691093445,
0.7626591324806213,
0.5154047608375549,
-0.3745230436325073,
0.294447124004364,
-0.49907386302948,
-0.7468084096908569,
-0.44317641854286194,
0.2302253246307373,
0.522541344165802,
0.31566616892814636,
0.5921785831451416,
-0.676180362701416,
-0.06963834166526794,
-0.7753596305847168,
-0.5860635042190552,
0.1747475266456604,
-0.04531025141477585,
0.15106283128261566,
0.37536871433258057,
-0.3602912127971649,
0.8265895247459412,
-0.3618520200252533,
-0.27159708738327026,
-0.1368153840303421,
0.3185012638568878,
-0.18871307373046875,
0.5269774198532104,
0.731494665145874,
-0.8601905107498169,
-0.44431132078170776,
0.18640199303627014,
-0.6865245699882507,
0.15982280671596527,
0.11707566678524017,
-0.3393971621990204,
0.1089598685503006,
0.09560740739107132,
-0.2356739640235901,
0.6388030052185059,
0.47636136412620544,
-0.6204797625541687,
0.1479322612285614,
0.18445971608161926,
0.2707609236240387,
-0.4281674921512604,
0.02465111017227173,
0.15447750687599182,
-0.039140716195106506,
-0.7150022387504578,
-0.020281238481402397,
0.11264227330684662,
0.2313423603773117,
-0.47263118624687195,
0.8393298983573914,
-0.23166102170944214,
-0.17219190299510956,
-0.08972631394863129,
0.22994112968444824,
0.3454693853855133,
0.28060194849967957,
0.04987700283527374,
0.4340516924858093,
0.5912079811096191,
-0.9940795302391052,
0.23996494710445404,
0.40124988555908203,
-0.4213315546512604,
0.6990240812301636,
-0.5880963802337646,
0.10251449048519135,
0.20370393991470337,
0.06721863150596619,
-1.1782593727111816,
0.13920417428016663,
0.07412794977426529,
-0.6636066436767578,
0.3572766184806824,
0.022458059713244438,
-0.059975624084472656,
-0.10773686319589615,
-0.2503993809223175,
0.8023602366447449,
0.07207699120044708,
-0.5557022094726562,
0.4907843768596649,
0.16192182898521423,
-0.08149361610412598,
-0.7055749893188477,
-0.9292292594909668,
-0.275672048330307,
-0.014234599657356739,
-1.0424081087112427,
0.8069656491279602,
0.0651179701089859,
-0.20489411056041718,
0.15632933378219604,
-0.4703356623649597,
-0.4062900245189667,
0.2769562304019928,
0.12924455106258392,
-0.002662884071469307,
-0.4849933683872223,
0.2066495716571808,
0.6200928688049316,
-0.022647948935627937,
0.4573134779930115,
-0.37622639536857605,
0.1751571148633957,
0.02545817941427231,
-0.3920411765575409,
-0.17373602092266083,
0.2667895257472992,
0.20114004611968994,
-0.22603537142276764,
0.4544084668159485,
0.35200199484825134,
-0.531714916229248,
-0.7323752045631409,
-0.21423247456550598,
0.0493645966053009,
-0.3949262201786041,
0.3209158182144165,
-0.6899082064628601,
-1.0068434476852417,
0.4120299816131592,
-0.23085935413837433,
-0.16403396427631378,
0.6879642605781555,
0.006743284873664379,
0.43035900592803955,
0.8955175280570984,
0.9632207751274109,
0.04749871790409088,
0.21325916051864624,
-0.5251911282539368,
-0.10746931284666061,
-0.36383166909217834,
-0.2026214450597763,
-0.7186520099639893,
-0.44725847244262695,
-0.33111703395843506,
-0.42786890268325806,
-0.19589154422283173,
0.11293576657772064,
-0.023176662623882294,
0.15648074448108673,
-0.5279275178909302,
0.5048134326934814,
0.341533899307251,
0.039341673254966736,
0.5601131916046143,
0.2928647994995117,
-0.1770658642053604,
-0.12800487875938416,
-0.5490601658821106,
-0.4179280400276184,
1.0666172504425049,
0.7034086585044861,
0.5093699097633362,
-0.09391388297080994,
0.6970784664154053,
0.48727336525917053,
0.49818888306617737,
-0.8190199136734009,
0.25232648849487305,
-0.5463928580284119,
-0.4314332604408264,
-0.6745898723602295,
-0.5013273358345032,
-0.7068220973014832,
0.2497362643480301,
-0.13633835315704346,
-0.24967849254608154,
0.31610071659088135,
-0.2661038637161255,
-0.08727198839187622,
0.2763913869857788,
-0.3735474646091461,
1.233147382736206,
-0.17937472462654114,
-0.2960892915725708,
-0.1607774943113327,
-0.42541536688804626,
0.2317236065864563,
-0.2603810727596283,
0.07165566086769104,
-0.07358653843402863,
-0.39516282081604004,
0.8545436859130859,
-0.2704238295555115,
0.35504770278930664,
-0.3792877793312073,
-0.38822972774505615,
0.3254799544811249,
0.2837623655796051,
0.10225927084684372,
0.0589497834444046,
-0.00881766527891159,
0.5845354795455933,
0.0765344575047493,
-0.4357600808143616,
-0.8217334151268005,
0.6689053773880005,
-0.7225475311279297,
-0.28124964237213135,
-0.20507927238941193,
-0.27763956785202026,
-0.5771195888519287,
0.27144527435302734,
0.4385189116001129,
0.3910403251647949,
-0.8743056058883667,
0.1939057856798172,
0.654410183429718,
-0.2775423526763916,
0.11845926195383072,
0.5303118824958801,
-0.3365088105201721,
-0.3595154881477356,
0.9637405276298523,
-0.01802908442914486,
0.2918209135532379,
0.9512323141098022,
0.16113780438899994,
-0.3931148052215576,
-0.797616720199585,
-0.336661159992218,
-0.16274239122867584,
-0.7942384481430054,
-0.3189622759819031,
-0.702193021774292,
-0.35467252135276794,
-0.266093373298645,
-0.3648279905319214,
-0.15438593924045563,
-0.6364678740501404,
-0.11345759779214859,
-0.1431473195552826,
0.18264369666576385,
0.6925263404846191,
0.11984661966562271,
0.29723653197288513,
-0.8816800713539124,
0.22199073433876038,
0.2837883532047272,
0.8374487161636353,
-0.09706234931945801,
-0.7597404718399048,
-0.25389280915260315,
-0.2640680968761444,
-0.21081186830997467,
-0.5368160009384155,
0.1789502650499344,
0.28723710775375366,
0.5936979651451111,
0.21156516671180725,
-0.021542465314269066,
0.20896826684474945,
-0.22739307582378387,
0.5758817195892334,
0.049791593104600906,
-1.4361315965652466,
0.6634777188301086,
-0.02048753760755062,
0.336256742477417,
0.7676106095314026,
0.7754844427108765,
-0.2254365235567093,
-0.5067324042320251,
-0.5690969824790955,
-0.7185920476913452,
0.6629676222801208,
-0.002736452268436551,
0.24290725588798523,
0.2756873667240143,
0.229869544506073,
0.7399932742118835,
0.10203670710325241,
-0.18553946912288666,
-0.2046961635351181,
-0.49687156081199646,
-0.10526033490896225,
-0.18076500296592712,
-0.13736507296562195,
0.16813457012176514,
-0.4999697208404541,
0.4517567753791809,
-0.1506514698266983,
0.18224041163921356,
0.644081175327301,
-0.2993279695510864,
-0.20219866931438446,
0.10899267345666885,
0.5206741094589233,
0.9537647366523743,
-0.30851608514785767,
0.05266832932829857,
0.35171598196029663,
-0.6448954939842224,
0.17959265410900116,
0.15809085965156555,
-0.13109369575977325,
0.25399649143218994,
0.6560157537460327,
0.630075991153717,
0.5232357978820801,
-0.3574519455432892,
0.7692568898200989,
-0.22726109623908997,
-0.6418546438217163,
0.22168485820293427,
0.22448138892650604,
-0.36507895588874817,
0.11788026243448257,
0.38230472803115845,
-0.047054700553417206,
0.5015164613723755,
-0.3262137472629547,
0.38368505239486694,
0.2962276041507721,
-0.5395011305809021,
-0.1759391874074936,
0.457006573677063,
0.31575730443000793,
-0.306844025850296,
0.30678030848503113,
-0.01630888693034649,
-0.484910249710083,
0.5779617428779602,
0.2798541486263275,
1.2721996307373047,
-0.1948489546775818,
0.36149629950523376,
0.49761325120925903,
0.27539247274398804,
0.14481386542320251,
0.0971968024969101,
-0.19401606917381287,
-0.8070447444915771,
-0.22085657715797424,
-0.7207737565040588,
-0.664063572883606,
-0.12529027462005615,
-0.5760412216186523,
0.11673959344625473,
-0.8154891133308411,
0.04177207127213478,
0.1610402911901474,
0.1691448837518692,
-0.809634804725647,
0.646098792552948,
-0.1531032770872116,
1.454745888710022,
-0.5565100908279419,
0.7077816724777222,
0.6018005609512329,
-0.27489978075027466,
-0.2981104552745819,
0.09193573147058487,
-0.25096485018730164,
-0.3618564307689667,
0.6251533627510071,
0.2852160334587097,
-0.37539494037628174,
-0.25071918964385986,
-0.5866337418556213,
-0.5721267461776733,
1.2101540565490723,
0.03175811842083931,
-0.45117685198783875,
0.17972567677497864,
0.5738393664360046,
0.7126525640487671,
-0.7821868062019348,
-0.12594358623027802,
0.7585471868515015,
0.5440475344657898,
-0.2385931760072708,
-0.8493419885635376,
0.31459832191467285,
-0.29553166031837463,
0.037692662328481674,
0.18109562993049622,
-0.3903898596763611,
0.7399659156799316,
-0.050038497895002365,
-0.5240595936775208,
0.049578335136175156,
0.7819016575813293,
-0.22758416831493378,
0.8629373908042908,
0.5682376623153687,
0.555459201335907,
0.6439308524131775,
-0.40919992327690125,
1.0843545198440552,
-0.06693403422832489,
0.4563632607460022,
0.8880876898765564,
-0.22823965549468994,
0.7297025322914124,
0.03250211104750633,
-0.3732795715332031,
0.5060089230537415,
0.18136674165725708,
-0.06707560271024704,
0.6189441084861755,
0.35791149735450745,
-0.1980384737253189,
-0.0864524394273758,
0.29829835891723633,
-0.49816861748695374,
0.4452868103981018,
0.36132848262786865,
-0.5495547652244568,
-0.2813401520252228,
-0.07842311263084412,
-0.27201470732688904,
0.3636624813079834,
-0.10348618775606155,
0.7877156138420105,
-0.1017882376909256,
-0.5364026427268982,
0.7183399796485901,
0.15379926562309265,
0.7919524312019348,
-0.6143433451652527,
0.05930374562740326,
-0.33973032236099243,
0.3907729983329773,
-0.2531988322734833,
-0.841974139213562,
0.6494446396827698,
-0.08825609087944031,
-0.47479644417762756,
-0.07024369388818741,
0.972179651260376,
-0.2706100344657898,
-0.4959182143211365,
0.7731577157974243,
0.4329755902290344,
-0.042016852647066116,
-0.4150504767894745,
-0.6455016136169434,
0.22340983152389526,
-0.3562861382961273,
-0.056555815041065216,
0.28272220492362976,
0.9395618438720703,
0.30474814772605896,
0.4152197241783142,
0.31995078921318054,
-0.3322969079017639,
-0.015042235143482685,
-0.045758724212646484,
0.7147160172462463,
-0.7769050002098083,
-0.25066688656806946,
-0.6129533052444458,
0.3391110599040985,
-0.05229543522000313,
-0.8288814425468445,
0.6211401224136353,
0.6914487481117249,
1.3479433059692383,
-0.07419193536043167,
0.9381512999534607,
0.1750921905040741,
0.7756794691085815,
-0.38982903957366943,
0.7321367859840393,
-0.8048085570335388,
0.13238613307476044,
-0.4947977662086487,
-0.9981116652488708,
-0.27588269114494324,
0.44266054034233093,
-0.22427181899547577,
0.11334545165300369,
0.8074527978897095,
0.46233367919921875,
-0.31286320090293884,
0.18386070430278778,
0.48997125029563904,
-0.2025383561849594,
0.03414589911699295,
0.6747948527336121,
0.8032219409942627,
-0.8026310801506042,
0.5141960978507996,
-0.5098451375961304,
-0.332365483045578,
0.07370563596487045,
-0.6584614515304565,
-0.9505590796470642,
-0.557110071182251,
-0.3809012174606323,
-0.2474813312292099,
0.1202770471572876,
0.2089986652135849,
0.7329093813896179,
-0.9274948239326477,
0.05194000154733658,
-0.08414849638938904,
0.2573467195034027,
-0.2542209327220917,
-0.31200355291366577,
0.15973706543445587,
-0.3278442621231079,
-0.6912099123001099,
0.27849000692367554,
0.227094367146492,
0.05034595727920532,
-0.47030696272850037,
-0.3123686611652374,
0.012286634184420109,
0.1920280009508133,
0.6775639057159424,
0.17461331188678741,
-0.552431046962738,
-0.13811156153678894,
-0.07829084992408752,
-0.26525652408599854,
-0.12746459245681763,
0.9044478535652161,
-0.6538681387901306,
0.22320611774921417,
0.784583330154419,
1.0079604387283325,
0.37138453125953674,
-0.03612492233514786,
0.5414262413978577,
-0.839040219783783,
-0.05907086655497551,
0.16268669068813324,
-0.05666927993297577,
0.3649410009384155,
-0.33966705203056335,
0.8534313440322876,
0.21834348142147064,
-0.34620237350463867,
-0.583586573600769,
-0.11794427037239075,
-0.8961161971092224,
-0.5032287240028381,
0.8689122200012207,
-0.3729795217514038,
0.05082913488149643,
0.08962705731391907,
0.07565374672412872,
-0.00520235113799572,
-0.07399351894855499,
0.45847031474113464,
1.028911828994751,
0.3140539824962616,
0.13871946930885315,
-0.3064502775669098,
0.645435094833374,
0.28389254212379456,
-0.8641594648361206,
-0.15079858899116516,
0.13715384900569916,
0.40026089549064636,
0.3114605247974396,
0.5406367182731628,
-0.2995636761188507,
0.2775852680206299,
0.20463113486766815,
-0.25907638669013977,
0.0976027250289917,
-0.7237409353256226,
-0.2871202826499939,
0.28588250279426575,
-0.3189375698566437,
-0.0009273848845623434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14686v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14686v1 | A Contrastive Learning Approach to Mitigate Bias in Speech Models | 2024-06-20T19:20:00 | 2024-06-20T19:20:00 | Alkis Koudounas, Flavio Giobergia, Eliana Pastor, Elena Baralis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Speech models may be affected by performance imbalance in different
population subgroups, raising concerns about fair treatment across these
groups. Prior attempts to mitigate unfairness either focus on user-defined
subgroups, potentially overlooking other affected subgroups, or do not
explicitly improve the internal representation at the subgroup level. This
paper proposes the first adoption of contrastive learning to mitigate speech
model bias in underperforming subgroups. We employ a three-level learning
technique that guides the model in focusing on different scopes for the
contrastive loss, i.e., task, subgroup, and the errors within subgroups. The
experiments on two spoken language understanding datasets and two languages
demonstrate that our approach improves internal subgroup representations, thus
reducing model bias and enhancing performance. | [
-0.3472149074077606,
-0.30658963322639465,
0.079567551612854,
-0.00833289697766304,
-0.18784554302692413,
0.040801629424095154,
0.066141277551651,
-0.24005283415317535,
-0.2564811706542969,
0.4044171869754791,
-0.5356202721595764,
-0.3307451903820038,
-0.6484725475311279,
-0.4037049114704132,
-0.13727174699306488,
0.9291855096817017,
0.32023605704307556,
0.8445876240730286,
-0.2088327556848526,
-0.3059915006160736,
-0.4416418671607971,
-0.5327752828598022,
-0.9733051657676697,
-0.9065467715263367,
0.27477335929870605,
0.3445274233818054,
0.2535896897315979,
0.46676313877105713,
0.24168944358825684,
0.14717626571655273,
-0.3945903778076172,
-0.2072841227054596,
-0.8380776047706604,
-0.14821797609329224,
-0.19528281688690186,
-1.0032016038894653,
-0.021657191216945648,
0.25239986181259155,
0.7950222492218018,
1.0729048252105713,
-0.45773062109947205,
-0.22738629579544067,
0.46988189220428467,
0.7739543318748474,
-0.8137235045433044,
0.13809603452682495,
-0.77326899766922,
0.4161180257797241,
-0.2761154770851135,
0.06466031074523926,
-0.30944356322288513,
-0.3159162104129791,
0.23113657534122467,
-0.592808723449707,
0.545657753944397,
-0.17153587937355042,
0.38202062249183655,
0.28724241256713867,
-0.39788204431533813,
0.01594732701778412,
-0.3664450943470001,
0.927956223487854,
-0.8117632269859314,
0.21141166985034943,
0.5397346019744873,
0.4631907045841217,
0.21460005640983582,
-0.3793969750404358,
-0.4114091992378235,
0.08817031979560852,
-0.25740930438041687,
0.2893616259098053,
-0.28541988134384155,
0.18077035248279572,
0.17047488689422607,
0.3987894356250763,
-0.44236648082733154,
0.5190220475196838,
-0.5796493887901306,
-0.3416821360588074,
0.22201529145240784,
0.13355779647827148,
0.0960066094994545,
0.02055978775024414,
-0.16467799246311188,
0.05746512860059738,
-0.7681820392608643,
0.09924191981554031,
0.4205460548400879,
0.6752141714096069,
-0.15767008066177368,
0.4158095419406891,
-0.11645917594432831,
0.3416180908679962,
0.17487134039402008,
0.07685893028974533,
0.49245119094848633,
-0.10202331095933914,
-0.3523545563220978,
0.15697535872459412,
0.049409713596105576,
0.3803309202194214,
0.26633644104003906,
-0.07418642938137054,
-0.1847011297941208,
0.39021363854408264,
0.041324783116579056,
-0.5937432050704956,
-0.16657374799251556,
-0.13395701348781586,
-0.7607141137123108,
-0.2704053223133087,
-0.1566590815782547,
-0.8551288843154907,
-0.7441561818122864,
-0.4149415194988251,
0.45973479747772217,
-0.2401966154575348,
-0.1846412867307663,
-0.08982639759778976,
-0.09781047701835632,
0.10478530079126358,
0.19253763556480408,
-1.0479552745819092,
0.7752147316932678,
0.5529460310935974,
0.7200488448143005,
-0.08728121966123581,
-0.021633505821228027,
-0.7259433269500732,
0.3280639052391052,
-0.11716434359550476,
0.40898236632347107,
-0.6616263389587402,
-0.5105513334274292,
-0.00879182294011116,
-0.44249972701072693,
-0.1352580189704895,
-0.9270424246788025,
0.3486069440841675,
-0.19538116455078125,
0.49830952286720276,
-0.16832219064235687,
-0.7344783544540405,
-0.4906916320323944,
-0.22701451182365417,
-0.606231153011322,
0.48513486981391907,
0.24157196283340454,
-0.8610539436340332,
0.6271547079086304,
-0.53347247838974,
-0.3782849907875061,
-0.14150263369083405,
-0.37336722016334534,
-0.4372601807117462,
0.263304740190506,
0.6365926861763,
0.17045369744300842,
0.050675831735134125,
-0.18580912053585052,
-0.005862767342478037,
-0.5858983397483826,
-0.16575679183006287,
-0.20249797403812408,
0.8143061995506287,
0.1883673518896103,
-0.2330826371908188,
0.18364591896533966,
-0.4225953221321106,
-0.12247240543365479,
-0.03602975234389305,
-0.043450310826301575,
-0.5109535455703735,
0.061882831156253815,
-0.16226069629192352,
0.15500041842460632,
-0.2905662953853607,
-0.29925742745399475,
-0.30149045586586,
-0.6933197975158691,
0.2767648696899414,
0.9409688711166382,
-0.08013992756605148,
0.7292665839195251,
-0.5618496537208557,
0.5320309400558472,
0.47805777192115784,
0.05668930336833,
-0.1270754486322403,
-0.19542759656906128,
-0.841569721698761,
-0.24726678431034088,
0.27220162749290466,
0.5665445923805237,
-0.7377470135688782,
-0.12986569106578827,
0.08669467270374298,
-0.2903006374835968,
-0.7937169075012207,
0.21316216886043549,
0.6989620327949524,
0.6997345685958862,
0.5312743782997131,
-0.3387947678565979,
-0.45036470890045166,
-1.0746890306472778,
-0.4983883798122406,
0.07866349071264267,
-0.3099680542945862,
0.39878049492836,
0.2587515413761139,
-0.1511099487543106,
0.5553784370422363,
-0.2894442081451416,
-0.5621846914291382,
-0.42540132999420166,
0.34936708211898804,
0.012976380065083504,
0.676456093788147,
0.561812698841095,
-0.8284888863563538,
-0.39102670550346375,
-0.10229343175888062,
-0.35873523354530334,
-0.34228840470314026,
0.30565887689590454,
0.09932901710271835,
0.037738386541604996,
0.6177462935447693,
0.03886568918824196,
0.4363512098789215,
0.6535822153091431,
-0.04894586652517319,
-0.11200840771198273,
0.1221417784690857,
-0.04970778897404671,
-0.8175192475318909,
-0.24211950600147247,
0.3712674379348755,
-0.1742260605096817,
-0.7338308095932007,
-0.27987879514694214,
-0.030055688694119453,
-0.0809905007481575,
-0.5921716094017029,
0.48954054713249207,
-0.14469681680202484,
0.07558625191450119,
-0.2702069580554962,
0.24485112726688385,
-0.17493776977062225,
0.49886354804039,
-0.1711263209581375,
0.8374593257904053,
0.6573559641838074,
-0.7192771434783936,
-0.33345672488212585,
-0.047517720609903336,
-0.3235446810722351,
0.9215018153190613,
-0.5326429009437561,
0.0713592991232872,
-0.7258037328720093,
0.26173609495162964,
-0.8221811056137085,
-0.13039657473564148,
0.34015128016471863,
-0.4346371293067932,
0.35105839371681213,
-0.0338682197034359,
0.28529635071754456,
-0.10496045649051666,
-0.11886341869831085,
0.5348442196846008,
0.5139451026916504,
-0.6722851991653442,
0.590592622756958,
0.7318949699401855,
-0.27763140201568604,
-0.7158942818641663,
-0.8899822235107422,
-0.5549996495246887,
-0.5302641987800598,
-0.31143349409103394,
0.6788822412490845,
0.12615975737571716,
-0.5265459418296814,
-0.07080637663602829,
-0.4231444001197815,
-0.13652551174163818,
-0.026536284014582634,
-0.018023831769824028,
-0.21914058923721313,
0.12101495265960693,
0.38983023166656494,
-0.17144203186035156,
-0.10548113286495209,
-0.22939948737621307,
-0.05434795096516609,
0.6020891070365906,
0.033484261482954025,
-0.2707614302635193,
-0.7430275678634644,
0.4524703621864319,
0.05402841418981552,
-0.1619587540626526,
0.6387413740158081,
0.4145280420780182,
-0.5418795347213745,
-0.3632262647151947,
-0.5900529623031616,
-0.41481709480285645,
-0.40958070755004883,
0.4524695873260498,
-0.19568245112895966,
-0.8236264586448669,
0.5884991884231567,
0.010631437413394451,
-0.0618303045630455,
0.4433501958847046,
0.2805928885936737,
-0.06224912777543068,
1.1762410402297974,
0.8409551382064819,
-0.4707210958003998,
0.7455928325653076,
-0.08156386762857437,
0.051000043749809265,
-0.8130079507827759,
-0.3919702172279358,
-0.7585936784744263,
-0.17799757421016693,
-0.5889018774032593,
-0.6585832238197327,
0.4278508126735687,
0.035956960171461105,
-0.21977068483829498,
-0.35283803939819336,
-0.11647726595401764,
0.636673629283905,
0.6958255171775818,
0.5402419567108154,
0.04567530378699303,
0.10117527097463608,
-0.2715332806110382,
-0.3644140660762787,
-0.7498626708984375,
-0.24706578254699707,
0.9721243381500244,
0.39812687039375305,
1.0047568082809448,
0.15718503296375275,
0.7367574572563171,
0.3880589008331299,
0.4439855217933655,
-0.44927504658699036,
0.10788501054048538,
-0.44047531485557556,
-0.5091104507446289,
-0.3645649552345276,
-0.7898292541503906,
-0.7610846757888794,
0.7746928930282593,
-0.07106062769889832,
-0.7225115895271301,
0.356666624546051,
0.41785192489624023,
-0.12933844327926636,
0.22222286462783813,
-0.7182084918022156,
0.5948838591575623,
0.12612958252429962,
-0.22070664167404175,
-0.6366167068481445,
-0.6177173852920532,
0.47024044394493103,
-0.02759212628006935,
0.3883119821548462,
-0.06646083295345306,
0.1988280713558197,
0.8746570944786072,
-0.15518666803836823,
0.9615966081619263,
-0.6314437389373779,
0.22580242156982422,
-0.0675126314163208,
-0.11116189509630203,
0.23576994240283966,
-0.2151837795972824,
-0.440105676651001,
0.04418213292956352,
-0.5982382893562317,
-0.729324221611023,
-0.6112520098686218,
0.4235175848007202,
-0.6364616751670837,
-0.516859233379364,
-0.21261034905910492,
-0.5137486457824707,
-0.4412671625614166,
0.013274694792926311,
0.229532390832901,
0.2309437096118927,
-0.3281734585762024,
0.22891344130039215,
0.7291938066482544,
-0.09425315260887146,
0.25149959325790405,
0.44085273146629333,
0.013287653215229511,
-0.4056262969970703,
0.634901225566864,
0.020687496289610863,
0.557176947593689,
0.10270731896162033,
0.29228225350379944,
-0.2861284911632538,
-0.6097023487091064,
0.2640388607978821,
0.13888423144817352,
-1.0954313278198242,
-0.11319500207901001,
-0.3241415023803711,
-0.06558560580015182,
-0.4105145037174225,
0.09008245915174484,
0.005180313717573881,
-0.34762588143348694,
-0.3696735203266144,
-0.11982529610395432,
-0.3806910812854767,
0.761444628238678,
-0.33758819103240967,
0.7147241830825806,
-0.267833411693573,
0.4202529191970825,
0.5787431597709656,
0.3520359694957733,
0.20600596070289612,
-0.6426187753677368,
-0.20489755272865295,
0.18039873242378235,
-0.3956323266029358,
-0.7212861776351929,
0.3906528949737549,
0.43663930892944336,
1.3104658126831055,
0.3109161853790283,
-0.22596047818660736,
0.5071112513542175,
-0.34373024106025696,
0.6738134622573853,
0.3620917499065399,
-1.433790922164917,
0.6680907011032104,
-0.0647679790854454,
0.4329388439655304,
0.5571853518486023,
0.33222314715385437,
-0.6332017779350281,
-0.2712561786174774,
-0.4051226079463959,
-0.8031731843948364,
0.8700439929962158,
0.2559143304824829,
0.10893350094556808,
0.22579814493656158,
0.24189035594463348,
0.10890793800354004,
0.35712939500808716,
-1.1115504503250122,
-0.30585455894470215,
-0.33299243450164795,
-0.18771471083164215,
-0.2910255491733551,
-0.31592535972595215,
-0.3118683397769928,
-0.22182008624076843,
0.8579021096229553,
-0.13610845804214478,
-0.052967850118875504,
-0.016689740121364594,
-0.21345673501491547,
-0.1633230745792389,
0.2569093108177185,
0.6410250067710876,
0.7060569524765015,
-0.02075131982564926,
0.05588174983859062,
0.23233550786972046,
-0.28015968203544617,
0.042252570390701294,
0.10949794203042984,
-0.05601995065808296,
-0.23926731944084167,
0.2787172794342041,
0.873071551322937,
0.139585942029953,
-0.3083716928958893,
0.4870033860206604,
-0.0017245810013264418,
-0.18675895035266876,
0.25149670243263245,
0.06092030182480812,
-0.2053612917661667,
0.32316556572914124,
0.4939873218536377,
0.016102660447359085,
0.26428213715553284,
-0.4596211016178131,
0.1941279172897339,
0.47003665566444397,
-0.7244253158569336,
0.30785852670669556,
0.7001857757568359,
0.3653014004230499,
-0.027645347639918327,
0.6895889043807983,
0.24992680549621582,
-0.6018577218055725,
0.5982320308685303,
0.6890429258346558,
0.6094248294830322,
-0.6928139925003052,
0.08019116520881653,
0.21348750591278076,
0.3648931682109833,
0.23467329144477844,
0.0354185588657856,
0.07009939849376678,
-0.7161003351211548,
-0.09195056557655334,
-0.15444445610046387,
-0.5144794583320618,
0.04788791015744209,
-0.8632783889770508,
0.009044005535542965,
-0.16414564847946167,
-0.01509830541908741,
0.13577422499656677,
-0.23794753849506378,
-0.6590499877929688,
0.3697126805782318,
0.3237105906009674,
0.6280344724655151,
-1.0753968954086304,
0.5897724032402039,
0.26856136322021484,
-0.412133127450943,
-0.42732125520706177,
0.48824653029441833,
0.2500482499599457,
-0.8128474950790405,
0.728065550327301,
0.2822006642818451,
-0.19867847859859467,
-0.09267117083072662,
-0.3983764052391052,
-0.6438044905662537,
0.6692931652069092,
0.44494277238845825,
-0.600837230682373,
0.20706719160079956,
0.01937895081937313,
0.3533952832221985,
-0.5557119846343994,
0.06207498162984848,
0.4765282869338989,
0.11178099364042282,
-0.049415163695812225,
-0.9584250450134277,
-0.3119811713695526,
-0.02604038454592228,
0.11707326024770737,
-0.10686755925416946,
-0.40458083152770996,
1.1717214584350586,
-0.12566907703876495,
-0.1979525238275528,
-0.2584604322910309,
0.6346650719642639,
0.12054678052663803,
0.3457615077495575,
0.7960801124572754,
0.3765515089035034,
1.2413958311080933,
-0.14511029422283173,
0.8707817792892456,
0.25018545985221863,
0.18659785389900208,
1.3048655986785889,
-0.37632057070732117,
0.43410179018974304,
0.49513912200927734,
-0.10890054702758789,
0.17468692362308502,
0.4720229506492615,
0.20473641157150269,
0.9851091504096985,
0.7988940477371216,
-0.5694248080253601,
-0.17810222506523132,
-0.22175738215446472,
-0.4624764323234558,
0.5487762689590454,
0.6449228525161743,
-0.39474156498908997,
-0.3850001096725464,
0.3403482437133789,
-0.12014562636613846,
0.5357614159584045,
-0.7682053446769714,
0.8028501868247986,
0.058663688600063324,
-0.3502004146575928,
0.372184157371521,
-0.16982392966747284,
0.6892868280410767,
-0.2800310254096985,
-0.16214831173419952,
-0.44318801164627075,
0.2841338515281677,
-0.144286647439003,
-0.3648606240749359,
0.1266869604587555,
-0.39388030767440796,
-0.37782981991767883,
0.04390798881649971,
0.3314332664012909,
-0.6365819573402405,
-0.3745986223220825,
0.36199936270713806,
0.29183247685432434,
-0.13895083963871002,
0.06401442736387253,
-0.5852566361427307,
-0.002312939614057541,
0.10946273803710938,
0.20160038769245148,
0.17096935212612152,
0.04516599327325821,
-0.09101602435112,
0.7578007578849792,
0.08140919357538223,
-0.039643947035074234,
-0.02526875026524067,
0.6118593215942383,
0.9492889046669006,
-0.319084495306015,
-0.7218167185783386,
-0.7304865717887878,
0.528780460357666,
-0.333648145198822,
0.06655722111463547,
0.6291882991790771,
0.506503701210022,
1.0596017837524414,
0.09826438874006271,
0.9872866272926331,
0.46054574847221375,
1.0069115161895752,
-0.7521436214447021,
0.5198583602905273,
-0.5076646208763123,
0.37755006551742554,
-0.300172358751297,
-0.6879720091819763,
-0.6241823434829712,
0.9394485354423523,
-0.2994979918003082,
0.411873996257782,
0.5774770975112915,
0.8556727170944214,
-0.01998099312186241,
0.14747180044651031,
0.34584441781044006,
0.2492956817150116,
0.33743590116500854,
0.5276612043380737,
0.7596032619476318,
-0.2643533945083618,
0.28552040457725525,
-0.4137871265411377,
-0.36506029963493347,
0.022264663130044937,
-0.7214052081108093,
-1.0258527994155884,
-0.2350527048110962,
-0.14086338877677917,
-0.1993883103132248,
0.31412145495414734,
0.6210476160049438,
0.9785577654838562,
-0.8410758972167969,
-0.361438512802124,
-0.09643852710723877,
0.2724740505218506,
-0.2118518352508545,
-0.21008199453353882,
0.11359751969575882,
-0.4661737382411957,
-0.8413904905319214,
0.4281034767627716,
-0.22462986409664154,
0.14432314038276672,
-0.13186684250831604,
-0.12214508652687073,
0.02590007334947586,
0.06560024619102478,
0.31029990315437317,
0.11619769036769867,
-0.7819129824638367,
0.07451954483985901,
-0.7027239799499512,
0.05560072883963585,
0.18114882707595825,
1.0690850019454956,
-0.9697558879852295,
0.43462082743644714,
0.26189908385276794,
0.380485475063324,
0.5463123321533203,
0.058847829699516296,
0.7933012843132019,
-0.8435214161872864,
0.43533867597579956,
0.4892060458660126,
0.25518742203712463,
0.5780270099639893,
-0.2879916727542877,
0.4544333219528198,
0.06759989261627197,
-0.38069257140159607,
-0.6138058304786682,
0.2434830516576767,
-0.5143548846244812,
-0.38732191920280457,
0.6220142841339111,
-0.04895726218819618,
0.26723456382751465,
-0.09117213636636734,
-0.32657164335250854,
0.37976932525634766,
-0.3318788707256317,
0.8603033423423767,
0.6220789551734924,
-0.15461747348308563,
-0.3025866746902466,
-0.42036446928977966,
0.7215108871459961,
0.7062355279922485,
-0.7710880041122437,
0.061580218374729156,
0.5274117588996887,
0.06408147513866425,
-0.3117371201515198,
0.538558304309845,
-0.1528780311346054,
0.22574198246002197,
-0.16516539454460144,
-0.10921069979667664,
0.5453102588653564,
-0.24118687212467194,
-0.8698083758354187,
0.183887779712677,
-0.1461789309978485,
-0.20170563459396362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14683v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14683v1 | TAGLAS: An atlas of text-attributed graph datasets in the era of large graph and language models | 2024-06-20T19:11:35 | 2024-06-20T19:11:35 | Jiarui Feng, Hao Liu, Lecheng Kong, Yixin Chen, Muhan Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In this report, we present TAGLAS, an atlas of text-attributed graph (TAG)
datasets and benchmarks. TAGs are graphs with node and edge features
represented in text, which have recently gained wide applicability in training
graph-language or graph foundation models. In TAGLAS, we collect and integrate
more than 23 TAG datasets with domains ranging from citation graphs to molecule
graphs and tasks from node classification to graph question-answering. Unlike
previous graph datasets and benchmarks, all datasets in TAGLAS have a unified
node and edge text feature format, which allows a graph model to be
simultaneously trained and evaluated on multiple datasets from various domains.
Further, we provide a standardized, efficient, and simplified way to load all
datasets and tasks. We also provide useful utils like text-to-embedding
conversion, and graph-to-text conversion, which can facilitate different
evaluation scenarios. Finally, we also provide standard and easy-to-use
evaluation utils. The project is open-sourced at
https://github.com/JiaruiFeng/TAGLAS and is still under construction. Please
expect more datasets/features in the future. | [
-0.05289055407047272,
-0.2351439744234085,
0.17435365915298462,
0.12006109952926636,
-0.09942441433668137,
0.3929377496242523,
-0.20593826472759247,
-0.6295875906944275,
0.11339406669139862,
0.4854660928249359,
-0.12488748878240585,
-0.7108182311058044,
-0.4989355802536011,
0.09364531189203262,
-0.5023327469825745,
1.3864448070526123,
-0.23299463093280792,
0.05311198905110359,
-0.4216742217540741,
-0.24288614094257355,
-0.2626849114894867,
-0.150973379611969,
-0.32628777623176575,
-0.26644784212112427,
0.7272429466247559,
0.1402111053466797,
0.28184011578559875,
0.7548383474349976,
0.6660746335983276,
0.15364734828472137,
0.019066043198108673,
0.42355430126190186,
-0.5107058882713318,
0.06586916744709015,
-0.3017600178718567,
-0.0415552519261837,
-0.874748706817627,
0.09235824644565582,
0.9739152789115906,
0.829129159450531,
0.3031279444694519,
0.47663018107414246,
0.1221655011177063,
0.544966995716095,
-0.6809912919998169,
0.2996077537536621,
-0.5556119084358215,
-0.3378153145313263,
-0.49422523379325867,
-0.051197707653045654,
-0.7625744342803955,
-0.4642125964164734,
0.2660957872867584,
-0.7382888793945312,
0.0009392609354108572,
0.3101498782634735,
0.9998283982276917,
0.10426408797502518,
-0.6231332421302795,
-0.6183251142501831,
-0.5588920712471008,
0.5754557847976685,
-0.01484809909015894,
0.4945757985115051,
0.17208772897720337,
0.39782074093818665,
0.0704726129770279,
-1.1219249963760376,
-0.16706319153308868,
0.04833535850048065,
-0.18997350335121155,
-0.004973743576556444,
-0.4318435788154602,
-0.05106910318136215,
-0.05306154116988182,
0.10849669575691223,
-0.7875185012817383,
0.08144543319940567,
-0.30261683464050293,
-0.17767050862312317,
0.7524484992027283,
0.0003572942514438182,
0.2237410694360733,
-0.0928792655467987,
-0.5938393473625183,
-0.24165260791778564,
-0.8438945412635803,
-0.24666720628738403,
0.3669978976249695,
0.4886680841445923,
0.014714906923472881,
0.4952879548072815,
-0.11871005594730377,
1.000222086906433,
-0.8978064656257629,
-0.03182808309793472,
0.6730073690414429,
-0.36428767442703247,
-0.0860440656542778,
-0.024956976994872093,
0.785537838935852,
0.19573546946048737,
0.4700871706008911,
-0.5314099192619324,
-0.19277608394622803,
0.2636268436908722,
-0.02580695040524006,
-0.7793311476707458,
-0.38035544753074646,
-0.11152340471744537,
-0.26748597621917725,
-0.18868277966976166,
-0.15793977677822113,
-0.8897467255592346,
-0.5961468815803528,
0.0014453161275014281,
0.13685674965381622,
-0.37705740332603455,
0.008445853367447853,
-0.09177125990390778,
-0.26728978753089905,
-0.1084536463022232,
0.2895072400569916,
-0.24088287353515625,
0.5839366912841797,
0.6650180816650391,
0.8930933475494385,
-0.22906997799873352,
-0.39571085572242737,
-0.5348080396652222,
0.2660885453224182,
-0.43312686681747437,
0.8701726794242859,
-0.8950303196907043,
-0.2564332187175751,
0.0879230946302414,
-0.05165062099695206,
-0.35295748710632324,
-0.3484579622745514,
1.0260928869247437,
-0.49202126264572144,
-0.30651721358299255,
-0.20788320899009705,
-0.607917308807373,
-0.07041395455598831,
0.12643307447433472,
-0.6707306504249573,
1.3241021633148193,
-0.011600728146731853,
-0.7036042809486389,
-0.0061768596060574055,
-0.8843269348144531,
-0.4581872522830963,
0.3226979970932007,
-0.12184843420982361,
-0.15471535921096802,
-0.4187973141670227,
0.04388073459267616,
0.41167381405830383,
-0.7825837135314941,
0.19098562002182007,
-0.18536856770515442,
-0.07932248711585999,
0.31043311953544617,
0.2390880584716797,
0.6389214396476746,
0.4100494384765625,
0.2188674360513687,
0.16886059939861298,
-0.7818546295166016,
0.03072241134941578,
0.36148273944854736,
0.15317459404468536,
-0.6036282777786255,
0.28042855858802795,
0.3229353129863739,
-0.01711121015250683,
0.4287169575691223,
-0.8851674795150757,
0.3579760193824768,
-0.18210983276367188,
0.5343142747879028,
0.6252188086509705,
-0.1322631537914276,
0.15678003430366516,
-0.14379125833511353,
0.4519122540950775,
-0.19642013311386108,
-0.09412364661693573,
-0.4684348702430725,
-0.646371603012085,
-0.4614529013633728,
-0.4159616529941559,
0.6492770910263062,
0.42614802718162537,
-0.7267792820930481,
0.22888801991939545,
-0.8844565749168396,
-0.9600499272346497,
-0.431144118309021,
-0.02840028703212738,
0.7168099284172058,
0.7172637581825256,
0.21643877029418945,
-0.2578413188457489,
-0.4469853341579437,
-0.6832025647163391,
-0.08595708012580872,
-0.0765497237443924,
0.30284756422042847,
0.4913621246814728,
0.7683163285255432,
0.0017008772119879723,
1.0548245906829834,
-0.8852969408035278,
-0.47693514823913574,
-0.08822285383939743,
0.10964510589838028,
-0.1525467485189438,
0.3050838112831116,
0.7452338933944702,
-0.7105699181556702,
-0.5820106267929077,
0.3385787606239319,
-0.47081688046455383,
-0.11542214453220367,
0.30028900504112244,
-0.12264880537986755,
0.08866588771343231,
0.30601048469543457,
-0.38526013493537903,
0.17032702267169952,
0.652942955493927,
-0.23183153569698334,
0.26878654956817627,
0.18544870615005493,
-0.26163381338119507,
-1.19024658203125,
0.5777164697647095,
0.19617033004760742,
-0.3309732675552368,
-0.4641526937484741,
0.0069256736896932125,
-0.0391399972140789,
-0.3236086368560791,
0.0743984580039978,
0.8173010349273682,
-0.3723932206630707,
-0.44121015071868896,
0.11455127596855164,
0.5154227614402771,
0.2222522646188736,
0.22161369025707245,
-0.2712358832359314,
0.8905683159828186,
0.7971203923225403,
-0.18982885777950287,
0.48503270745277405,
0.5001763105392456,
-0.32355478405952454,
0.3977086842060089,
-0.8319513201713562,
0.3326035141944885,
-0.028761792927980423,
0.5889315605163574,
-1.1828749179840088,
-0.15532371401786804,
0.2638472616672516,
-0.5443141460418701,
0.18524979054927826,
-0.44418102502822876,
-0.7003077268600464,
-0.39341121912002563,
-0.3248373568058014,
0.1628311425447464,
0.20231686532497406,
-0.4327058494091034,
0.43316352367401123,
0.6793005466461182,
-0.06346163898706436,
-0.7537868618965149,
-0.4030401110649109,
0.12295375764369965,
0.06727911531925201,
-0.4088009297847748,
0.5051695108413696,
-0.14903080463409424,
0.2964843213558197,
0.5381151437759399,
0.13470031321048737,
-0.14777466654777527,
0.12705844640731812,
0.3704524636268616,
0.2854436933994293,
0.0879736915230751,
0.39853614568710327,
-0.10541925579309464,
-0.1776522696018219,
-0.25093063712120056,
-0.5283846855163574,
0.7327447533607483,
-0.31154972314834595,
-0.06889791786670685,
-0.05827997997403145,
0.040695492178201675,
0.23636476695537567,
-0.7894265055656433,
0.4281529486179352,
0.36971357464790344,
-0.5447732210159302,
-0.379391610622406,
0.1730470210313797,
0.4446711838245392,
-0.3742603659629822,
0.4931007921695709,
-0.4658769369125366,
-0.7285609841346741,
0.5931824445724487,
-0.4660899043083191,
0.1362728327512741,
0.600113034248352,
0.45892757177352905,
-0.15261432528495789,
0.6843323707580566,
0.37577053904533386,
-0.17471379041671753,
0.2496943175792694,
-0.37300625443458557,
0.09914692491292953,
-0.957400918006897,
-0.3021233379840851,
-0.922130286693573,
-0.3421241343021393,
-0.6684221625328064,
-0.4313480854034424,
0.11111018061637878,
-0.15891997516155243,
-0.22238200902938843,
0.4764953851699829,
-0.6354243755340576,
0.5026042461395264,
0.043012816458940506,
-0.15637622773647308,
0.222822904586792,
-0.079745814204216,
0.07388626784086227,
0.09060829132795334,
-0.5184509754180908,
-0.6022639870643616,
1.3223930597305298,
0.2549998164176941,
0.738718569278717,
-0.16436564922332764,
0.6438710689544678,
0.5127832889556885,
0.5440778732299805,
-0.7585784196853638,
0.5431017279624939,
-0.3421298861503601,
-0.6410284042358398,
-0.05751050263643265,
-0.3531952500343323,
-1.208594560623169,
-0.15454310178756714,
-0.019697153940796852,
-1.027454137802124,
0.07637066394090652,
0.05536654591560364,
0.21742017567157745,
0.24459850788116455,
-0.8554978370666504,
1.094853162765503,
0.05310448631644249,
-0.029535796493291855,
0.2212681770324707,
-0.7556273937225342,
-0.06788456439971924,
0.07141467928886414,
0.17504610121250153,
-0.28317856788635254,
-0.16727054119110107,
0.9659597277641296,
0.06539567559957504,
0.7575038075447083,
-0.14008723199367523,
0.037998780608177185,
0.3498190939426422,
-0.09650090336799622,
0.5443845391273499,
-0.2762494683265686,
-0.13379187881946564,
-0.044249527156353,
-0.030054444447159767,
-0.2814922034740448,
-0.36503756046295166,
0.7951036095619202,
-0.8636676073074341,
0.2316269725561142,
-0.5028810501098633,
-0.7377451062202454,
-0.18296761810779572,
0.37362563610076904,
0.02410363405942917,
0.7814319729804993,
-0.3531995117664337,
0.12155167013406754,
0.45207369327545166,
-0.09950285404920578,
0.30232125520706177,
0.052995070815086365,
-0.5383203625679016,
-0.4236465096473694,
1.4465504884719849,
0.44933566451072693,
0.08719859272241592,
0.2778778672218323,
-0.11642717570066452,
-0.19483907520771027,
-0.5809133052825928,
-0.5381781458854675,
0.19538311660289764,
-0.8592966794967651,
-0.6101279854774475,
-0.5967532396316528,
-0.3136880099773407,
-0.36395299434661865,
0.023982977494597435,
-0.5260011553764343,
-0.5074144005775452,
0.04704765975475311,
-0.14984658360481262,
0.5799560546875,
0.8848567605018616,
0.38733649253845215,
0.33855265378952026,
-0.5110962390899658,
0.03964738920331001,
-0.17662228643894196,
0.5885106921195984,
0.038957592099905014,
-0.1152038425207138,
-0.5232775807380676,
-0.3344496190547943,
-0.21445219218730927,
-0.9370065927505493,
0.20295105874538422,
0.5528815388679504,
0.3429206609725952,
-0.025600390508770943,
0.08821474760770798,
0.3238872289657593,
-0.604662299156189,
0.4621467888355255,
-0.12074092775583267,
-0.8925319910049438,
0.4584904909133911,
-0.5937603712081909,
-0.2678857445716858,
0.4361324608325958,
0.6805566549301147,
-0.5881015658378601,
0.10752809792757034,
-0.48273995518684387,
-0.7617831230163574,
0.6161982417106628,
0.25886937975883484,
-0.1045873835682869,
0.2289491593837738,
0.22339747846126556,
0.003932894207537174,
0.202702596783638,
-0.6123575568199158,
-0.5486549139022827,
-0.03325515612959862,
-0.5199560523033142,
-0.12877289950847626,
-0.042706891894340515,
-0.5385427474975586,
-0.1390368491411209,
0.6645627021789551,
-0.3726225197315216,
0.18494264781475067,
0.18770664930343628,
-0.2996276319026947,
0.1810670793056488,
0.1236109733581543,
0.14896197617053986,
0.7489418387413025,
-0.32965198159217834,
0.24207085371017456,
-0.11920885741710663,
-0.4037666320800781,
-0.14554719626903534,
0.5588625073432922,
-0.26207536458969116,
0.09573560953140259,
0.2885065972805023,
0.8837087154388428,
-0.2101345956325531,
-0.7796586751937866,
0.39625588059425354,
0.3190232515335083,
0.2810690402984619,
-0.034918591380119324,
-0.3147941529750824,
0.1483079493045807,
-0.07948990166187286,
0.48038601875305176,
-0.03501897677779198,
0.2697645425796509,
-0.35551023483276367,
0.2017224282026291,
0.1403457373380661,
-0.39337462186813354,
-0.375393271446228,
0.4493890106678009,
0.3501075804233551,
-0.0836050808429718,
0.15261702239513397,
-0.4651656150817871,
-0.5462710857391357,
0.4502893388271332,
0.6149600148200989,
0.7511680126190186,
-0.020051458850502968,
0.43576666712760925,
0.33517080545425415,
0.417408287525177,
0.5516101717948914,
0.09102578461170197,
0.2367171347141266,
-0.6958557963371277,
-0.3268861770629883,
-0.5498920679092407,
-0.4776858985424042,
-0.3431471884250641,
-0.4961557984352112,
0.21288491785526276,
-0.2441834956407547,
-0.02502964623272419,
0.5221289396286011,
0.29436740279197693,
-0.5588774085044861,
0.21890325844287872,
0.10305318236351013,
0.9831485748291016,
-1.1272433996200562,
1.0910688638687134,
1.173973560333252,
-0.32378482818603516,
-0.38989129662513733,
-0.28053051233291626,
-0.14570015668869019,
-0.8087892532348633,
0.6856029033660889,
0.14406684041023254,
-0.11354478448629379,
0.4216301739215851,
-0.6644635796546936,
-0.8177958130836487,
1.1637824773788452,
0.36706414818763733,
-0.16285715997219086,
0.0230761356651783,
0.14047442376613617,
0.522455632686615,
-0.6909767389297485,
0.17448340356349945,
0.5184913277626038,
0.27288076281547546,
0.039636239409446716,
-0.812535285949707,
0.06100041791796684,
-0.4985513687133789,
0.027169188484549522,
0.42436155676841736,
-0.6831496953964233,
0.7208803296089172,
0.25374865531921387,
-0.20551183819770813,
0.07572352886199951,
0.5700422525405884,
0.05038684606552124,
0.42709749937057495,
0.3434532582759857,
0.8160147070884705,
1.1175651550292969,
-0.4202943742275238,
1.2339930534362793,
-0.25624892115592957,
0.616071879863739,
1.1823551654815674,
-0.741255521774292,
0.7504982352256775,
0.10229554027318954,
-0.17353248596191406,
0.7072606086730957,
0.6047763824462891,
-0.09315621852874756,
0.4078647196292877,
0.1923341155052185,
0.03517336770892143,
-0.0768841803073883,
-0.9803743958473206,
-0.3960045278072357,
0.4981919229030609,
0.4342828392982483,
-0.20076078176498413,
-0.4772445559501648,
-0.15077678859233856,
0.14185716211795807,
0.15847042202949524,
-0.017764059826731682,
0.3555130958557129,
-0.21833916008472443,
-0.1913515329360962,
0.14793802797794342,
0.02217721752822399,
0.13744904100894928,
-0.7437280416488647,
0.021772848442196846,
-0.07536742091178894,
0.04047301784157753,
-0.21550029516220093,
-1.069358468055725,
0.11801298707723618,
0.3525473177433014,
-0.0791894793510437,
-0.3153262138366699,
1.0421959161758423,
-0.15216600894927979,
-0.4683184027671814,
0.39692696928977966,
0.39292067289352417,
0.20235346257686615,
0.32542684674263,
-0.46027931571006775,
0.19536077976226807,
-0.2632962763309479,
-0.17763440310955048,
0.21558959782123566,
0.3676775395870209,
-0.2691574692726135,
0.6408563256263733,
0.43707147240638733,
-0.07353349775075912,
-0.011536756530404091,
-0.04917971417307854,
1.2865229845046997,
-0.4208780527114868,
-0.2648260295391083,
-0.42011338472366333,
0.4234732687473297,
-0.4295388460159302,
-0.6194966435432434,
0.7049587965011597,
1.0586493015289307,
0.7974761724472046,
0.280453085899353,
0.8142597675323486,
-0.3837602734565735,
0.6049429774284363,
-0.2597285211086273,
0.6861460208892822,
-0.4781162142753601,
-0.17381390929222107,
-0.48877522349357605,
-0.8385544419288635,
-0.2620064318180084,
0.21602219343185425,
-0.23957495391368866,
-0.11138235032558441,
0.5502575039863586,
0.4452504813671112,
0.25324058532714844,
-0.09240972995758057,
-0.2202484905719757,
0.12239277362823486,
0.3957822024822235,
0.6215160489082336,
0.5849419236183167,
-0.7090885043144226,
0.7133561968803406,
0.0063625518232584,
-0.20876602828502655,
-0.0018259845674037933,
-0.9463739991188049,
-0.7659664750099182,
-1.0455416440963745,
-0.42127177119255066,
-0.3115426003932953,
0.13088998198509216,
0.7674759030342102,
0.46601402759552,
-0.6340373158454895,
-0.26920393109321594,
0.10126194357872009,
0.3873993754386902,
0.016663141548633575,
-0.1298236846923828,
0.5914747714996338,
-0.1838398277759552,
-0.9056040048599243,
0.33117061853408813,
0.3289887011051178,
-0.1761898398399353,
0.0846749097108841,
-0.08381995558738708,
-0.5399367809295654,
-0.20729786157608032,
0.3093544840812683,
0.3509141206741333,
-0.144319087266922,
-0.23012401163578033,
0.061865441501140594,
-0.24955551326274872,
0.2511521279811859,
0.7397047877311707,
-0.6527563333511353,
0.6766920685768127,
0.6462430953979492,
0.8083513379096985,
0.5091028809547424,
-0.17531277239322662,
0.2390788197517395,
-1.1904150247573853,
0.278423935174942,
0.25672245025634766,
0.3821449279785156,
0.3586115539073944,
0.16828903555870056,
1.02792227268219,
0.3265698552131653,
-0.4124172031879425,
-1.3172857761383057,
0.13313820958137512,
-1.375108003616333,
0.0058179995976388454,
0.8865213990211487,
-0.49134212732315063,
-0.16302362084388733,
0.18604396283626556,
-0.11354755610227585,
0.4641297459602356,
-0.2040979266166687,
0.0748831257224083,
0.6261439919471741,
0.08424123376607895,
0.17457322776317596,
-0.4964040219783783,
0.4387735426425934,
0.0508391410112381,
-1.0237747430801392,
0.3117956519126892,
0.4830548167228699,
-0.06143416091799736,
0.4512062072753906,
0.46008503437042236,
-0.014051374047994614,
-0.11551361531019211,
-0.11178912967443466,
0.2618682086467743,
-0.040613140910863876,
-0.7631299495697021,
0.043279509991407394,
0.10559037327766418,
0.0371529683470726,
-0.20902135968208313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14680v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14680v1 | Dravidian language family through Universal Dependencies lens | 2024-06-20T18:59:46 | 2024-06-20T18:59:46 | Taraka Rama, Sowmya Vajjala | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Universal Dependencies (UD) project aims to create a cross-linguistically
consistent dependency annotation for multiple languages, to facilitate
multilingual NLP. It currently supports 114 languages. Dravidian languages are
spoken by over 200 million people across the word, and yet there are only two
languages from this family in UD. This paper examines some of the morphological
and syntactic features of Dravidian languages and explores how they can be
annotated in the UD framework. | [
-0.4681418836116791,
-0.08526424318552017,
0.35607895255088806,
0.3277851939201355,
0.07965033501386642,
0.32532188296318054,
-0.11239589750766754,
-0.8275849223136902,
0.25659459829330444,
0.45365771651268005,
-0.4356469213962555,
-0.1392434537410736,
-0.36929523944854736,
0.3537273108959198,
0.12270011007785797,
0.6227709650993347,
-0.2134350836277008,
0.11686954647302628,
0.27936387062072754,
-0.8380365371704102,
-0.7359896898269653,
-0.39177271723747253,
-0.002106935018673539,
-0.2311151921749115,
0.6287451386451721,
0.6557280421257019,
0.8703100681304932,
0.8351035118103027,
0.5451784729957581,
0.2669427990913391,
-0.20255275070667267,
-0.04095737636089325,
-0.012088777497410774,
0.5530096292495728,
-0.29763028025627136,
-0.7752070426940918,
-0.09892820566892624,
-0.17525289952754974,
0.7205208539962769,
1.0312296152114868,
-0.2605869770050049,
0.3102070689201355,
-0.15940086543560028,
1.0086160898208618,
-0.42065301537513733,
0.3161192238330841,
-0.15344157814979553,
0.08260469883680344,
-0.7425317168235779,
0.20653583109378815,
-0.13814249634742737,
0.01775912381708622,
0.31147098541259766,
-0.38225480914115906,
-0.11138702183961868,
-0.2050737589597702,
0.5231420397758484,
0.30747103691101074,
-0.37978121638298035,
0.05411490797996521,
-0.863005518913269,
0.759695291519165,
-0.216483935713768,
0.37364211678504944,
0.3320819139480591,
-0.04615798220038414,
-0.34822729229927063,
-0.4564463198184967,
-0.5859442353248596,
-0.10310021042823792,
-0.14056897163391113,
0.23147635161876678,
0.016877129673957825,
0.07657831162214279,
0.24150782823562622,
0.6233983039855957,
-0.765836238861084,
0.3101017475128174,
-0.4700252115726471,
0.12431085109710693,
0.5192723870277405,
0.2584906220436096,
0.7748549580574036,
-0.4479674994945526,
-0.2544632852077484,
0.18177232146263123,
-0.8216723203659058,
-0.14297671616077423,
0.536369264125824,
0.19565963745117188,
-0.20520423352718353,
0.7177134156227112,
-0.11502540856599808,
1.0312864780426025,
-0.07708632946014404,
-0.202130526304245,
-0.04368093982338905,
-0.2774389386177063,
-0.08164503425359726,
-0.14132864773273468,
0.5753206610679626,
-0.12899024784564972,
0.6226229071617126,
-0.08750457316637039,
0.35720717906951904,
0.13980016112327576,
0.0028793220408260822,
-0.32459884881973267,
-0.1410069763660431,
0.06204540655016899,
-0.30522024631500244,
0.1762102246284485,
-0.011345154605805874,
-0.9094380140304565,
-0.35266220569610596,
-0.35627031326293945,
-0.3485485315322876,
-0.46271926164627075,
-0.9074060916900635,
0.05669691786170006,
-0.13386957347393036,
0.1832408756017685,
0.21442019939422607,
-1.3029515743255615,
0.26206061244010925,
0.46222856640815735,
0.7152222394943237,
-0.09846930205821991,
-0.5705248713493347,
-0.013967979699373245,
0.28092265129089355,
-0.0793738067150116,
1.1029244661331177,
-0.8400137424468994,
-0.42485806345939636,
0.16817744076251984,
-0.17580963671207428,
-0.20552587509155273,
-0.4960298240184784,
0.1322290599346161,
-0.21893873810768127,
0.08379736542701721,
-0.38469672203063965,
-0.37229135632514954,
-0.5301188826560974,
-0.37396007776260376,
-0.8695412278175354,
0.9813306927680969,
0.563934862613678,
-0.8612079620361328,
0.6685423851013184,
-0.32660341262817383,
-0.6214534044265747,
0.8288731575012207,
-0.5749457478523254,
0.036707598716020584,
0.2922338545322418,
-0.2681412100791931,
0.26460447907447815,
-0.04481426626443863,
0.2197626680135727,
-0.13649502396583557,
-0.2443057894706726,
-0.3149128556251526,
-0.1740005761384964,
1.2697768211364746,
0.2861359119415283,
-0.6169449687004089,
0.09700058400630951,
-1.0725829601287842,
-0.34258902072906494,
-0.04829706251621246,
-0.5410998463630676,
-0.46164631843566895,
0.016879552975296974,
0.2606309950351715,
0.1891334354877472,
-0.09690983593463898,
-0.6328739523887634,
0.7453433275222778,
-0.33682215213775635,
0.20908840000629425,
0.6177704930305481,
-0.14062009751796722,
0.3561110496520996,
0.03202856332063675,
0.8326848745346069,
0.1497202217578888,
-0.1014997661113739,
-0.17632830142974854,
-0.7773416638374329,
-0.7736285924911499,
-0.5635770559310913,
0.18302707374095917,
0.6848427653312683,
-0.5473592877388,
0.19069918990135193,
-0.05619613081216812,
-0.052907008677721024,
-0.4525144100189209,
0.4034598171710968,
0.3294624388217926,
-0.018333377316594124,
0.03828292712569237,
-0.2804049849510193,
-0.9126991033554077,
-0.9386740326881409,
0.33837562799453735,
-0.6222416758537292,
0.3864782154560089,
-0.11971487104892731,
0.5233647227287292,
-0.2652024030685425,
0.8707278370857239,
-0.3089776039123535,
-0.6594340801239014,
-0.6326743364334106,
0.11231347173452377,
-0.13280528783798218,
0.05351005494594574,
0.8081213235855103,
-0.7787285447120667,
-0.7296776175498962,
0.3005445897579193,
-0.9134591817855835,
0.06274484097957611,
0.12080398201942444,
0.32902970910072327,
0.5606310367584229,
0.37541651725769043,
-0.41337114572525024,
0.7748600840568542,
0.8309527039527893,
-0.20169202983379364,
0.47972697019577026,
-0.3263016641139984,
-0.0894446074962616,
-1.204228162765503,
-0.04480184242129326,
-0.053249239921569824,
-0.06150450184941292,
-0.5367887616157532,
0.10139936208724976,
-0.0593252070248127,
0.09932641685009003,
-0.4228346645832062,
0.5796279907226562,
-0.8008498549461365,
0.14014142751693726,
0.09070389717817307,
-0.05220567435026169,
-0.34868916869163513,
0.24061863124370575,
0.23166611790657043,
0.7843348383903503,
0.8160262107849121,
-0.40433576703071594,
0.8947277665138245,
0.44452616572380066,
-0.2647785544395447,
0.9341557025909424,
-0.4712062478065491,
-0.35182079672813416,
-0.0879015102982521,
0.2660892903804779,
-1.064028263092041,
-0.48230475187301636,
0.06171773746609688,
-0.11148785054683685,
0.5872159600257874,
-0.4925594627857208,
-0.6830915808677673,
-0.366333544254303,
-0.2298632115125656,
0.44794607162475586,
0.14269524812698364,
-0.41240739822387695,
0.4197600781917572,
0.6714139580726624,
-0.2656433582305908,
-0.8122464418411255,
-0.7422130703926086,
0.47211581468582153,
-0.22013387084007263,
-0.7443757653236389,
-0.28060224652290344,
0.027027077972888947,
-0.6456964015960693,
0.1699996292591095,
0.11148691922426224,
-0.11796148866415024,
-0.09644843637943268,
0.708632230758667,
0.2648314833641052,
-0.12062007188796997,
0.048091500997543335,
-0.24454058706760406,
-0.29122498631477356,
-0.6523329615592957,
-0.2578193247318268,
0.6004429459571838,
-0.21659713983535767,
-0.24740634858608246,
-0.5746158957481384,
0.6860737800598145,
0.5316663384437561,
-0.4058065712451935,
0.6779741644859314,
0.36986425518989563,
-0.33392807841300964,
-0.16208064556121826,
-0.6952311992645264,
0.35231027007102966,
-0.39629632234573364,
0.33520933985710144,
-0.7472303509712219,
-0.7369047999382019,
0.8054766058921814,
0.1411086916923523,
-0.10457352548837662,
0.7030089497566223,
0.7152974605560303,
0.18376968801021576,
0.7284330725669861,
0.9964362978935242,
-0.4581979513168335,
0.4117486774921417,
-0.14812594652175903,
-0.10092061012983322,
-0.8567708730697632,
-0.290128618478775,
-0.47533929347991943,
0.05361038073897362,
-0.9371307492256165,
0.06228036433458328,
-0.0536431260406971,
0.01007913053035736,
0.31970545649528503,
0.8127270936965942,
-0.5185089111328125,
0.17149749398231506,
0.5370181202888489,
-0.526295006275177,
0.3883761167526245,
0.12170924246311188,
-0.42444658279418945,
-0.3342026472091675,
-0.40122857689857483,
-0.39408063888549805,
0.7943292856216431,
0.2507745623588562,
0.9011086225509644,
0.37279021739959717,
0.6373777389526367,
0.1968962550163269,
0.00165722391102463,
-0.4314873516559601,
0.49269193410873413,
-0.328572154045105,
-1.0307155847549438,
-0.10522793233394623,
-0.2807120382785797,
-0.9153242111206055,
-0.011360208503901958,
0.20462676882743835,
-0.9922398924827576,
0.5103394389152527,
-0.30756646394729614,
-0.25910043716430664,
0.3141070306301117,
-0.6226298213005066,
0.4922271966934204,
-0.1367296725511551,
-0.07333052903413773,
-0.3860333561897278,
-0.7224321365356445,
0.11593246459960938,
0.1814805269241333,
-0.1252933144569397,
-0.23187266290187836,
0.29526287317276,
0.7405590415000916,
-0.17156435549259186,
0.8814640045166016,
0.22289499640464783,
-0.12479051947593689,
0.2540871798992157,
0.006964241154491901,
-0.22674164175987244,
0.38574063777923584,
-0.12499213218688965,
0.2796144485473633,
0.04311225935816765,
-0.3696337938308716,
0.050897881388664246,
0.7621425986289978,
-0.599090576171875,
-0.4760327935218811,
-1.0294644832611084,
-0.7952132821083069,
-0.08699123561382294,
0.39944127202033997,
-0.02286306396126747,
0.5772649645805359,
-0.21919876337051392,
-0.18928733468055725,
0.6154201030731201,
-0.1256808638572693,
0.7105790972709656,
0.3123634159564972,
-0.3879196345806122,
-0.37717974185943604,
0.6687648296356201,
0.36577868461608887,
0.1913253217935562,
0.16902467608451843,
-0.18788239359855652,
-0.19761379063129425,
-0.3904270827770233,
-1.0880869626998901,
0.579788327217102,
-0.6931295394897461,
0.08722714334726334,
-0.5646328330039978,
-0.07784020155668259,
-0.3947540521621704,
-0.03737315535545349,
-0.32794079184532166,
-0.6278468370437622,
-0.1567690521478653,
-0.20536908507347107,
0.577171802520752,
1.5851492881774902,
-0.30939558148384094,
0.07291441410779953,
-0.480312317609787,
0.5738106369972229,
0.47445395588874817,
0.7653876543045044,
-0.40664589405059814,
-0.34938928484916687,
-0.05291944742202759,
-0.1961532086133957,
0.05259079486131668,
-0.5712442994117737,
-0.013805422000586987,
0.25778529047966003,
0.8490839004516602,
0.43928995728492737,
-0.32357165217399597,
0.8387496471405029,
-0.6202173233032227,
0.6448076367378235,
0.33000198006629944,
-0.6578723192214966,
0.4011818468570709,
-0.4271915555000305,
0.1878276914358139,
0.729145884513855,
0.26550546288490295,
-0.712173581123352,
-0.5605043172836304,
-0.4738733768463135,
-0.7039742469787598,
0.5555258989334106,
-0.10665640980005264,
0.04528506100177765,
0.06769228726625443,
0.50936359167099,
0.351377010345459,
-0.19938118755817413,
-0.2597588300704956,
-0.7520049214363098,
0.24581198394298553,
-0.2867201268672943,
0.349557101726532,
-0.6172037720680237,
0.09780130535364151,
-0.2990845739841461,
0.09141846746206284,
0.11284463852643967,
-0.1403454840183258,
-0.023423057049512863,
-0.29808223247528076,
-0.3513837456703186,
0.09909317642450333,
0.8159697651863098,
1.0676945447921753,
-0.1259244680404663,
0.21869362890720367,
-0.18996332585811615,
-1.069199800491333,
0.2018435001373291,
0.13268712162971497,
-0.29165777564048767,
0.2033829241991043,
0.38378944993019104,
0.6467603445053101,
-0.054887961596250534,
-0.4354163110256195,
0.03831616789102554,
-0.18585358560085297,
0.08516984432935715,
-0.6391766667366028,
0.010150734335184097,
0.2775551974773407,
0.13292089104652405,
0.45844557881355286,
0.0024170896504074335,
-0.0509636290371418,
-0.8375169634819031,
0.5714529752731323,
0.3485139012336731,
-0.6180696487426758,
-0.5678151845932007,
0.6718536019325256,
0.1852816641330719,
0.07765932381153107,
0.6022011041641235,
-0.0819801315665245,
-0.6613720059394836,
0.274566113948822,
0.26307451725006104,
0.6353858113288879,
-0.4841446280479431,
0.4413529932498932,
0.317238986492157,
0.2571096420288086,
-0.17337898910045624,
0.5447244048118591,
0.30411118268966675,
-0.35901185870170593,
-0.543327271938324,
-0.7627243995666504,
-0.49360382556915283,
-0.3592640161514282,
-0.7667073607444763,
0.302085280418396,
-0.14832329750061035,
0.02725798822939396,
0.5766953229904175,
0.06686212122440338,
-0.6347925662994385,
0.10497082769870758,
0.3198634386062622,
0.4741775095462799,
-0.8627404570579529,
1.0576121807098389,
1.0512771606445312,
-1.0449633598327637,
-0.5938519239425659,
-0.13167525827884674,
0.2721228301525116,
-1.0194990634918213,
1.1770923137664795,
0.05321213975548744,
-0.0984942838549614,
-0.02352891117334366,
0.03504817560315132,
-0.6574893593788147,
0.6147164106369019,
0.303735613822937,
-0.3612882196903229,
0.17106395959854126,
0.5114627480506897,
0.659375786781311,
-0.3782411515712738,
0.01732110045850277,
0.5594926476478577,
0.7955100536346436,
-0.280047744512558,
-1.1499963998794556,
-0.07998471707105637,
-0.22665446996688843,
0.20883741974830627,
0.4578220546245575,
-0.5354453325271606,
0.35214197635650635,
-0.5152571797370911,
-0.3695559799671173,
0.10917191207408905,
0.6108595132827759,
-0.0614815317094326,
-0.26335668563842773,
0.32517150044441223,
0.8156217932701111,
0.2890353500843048,
-0.08388806134462357,
0.8877642750740051,
-0.07160621136426926,
0.23049567639827728,
0.8256431818008423,
-0.4048444628715515,
0.5844534039497375,
0.5989896059036255,
-0.5399717092514038,
0.6572580933570862,
0.4178963601589203,
-0.13928736746311188,
0.029265644028782845,
0.42185696959495544,
-0.46360906958580017,
0.2867848873138428,
-0.448708713054657,
-0.2195362001657486,
0.7119783759117126,
0.29978978633880615,
0.18675167858600616,
-0.07574731111526489,
0.09839563816785812,
0.4053385853767395,
0.0010561492526903749,
-0.10731270164251328,
0.7315778136253357,
0.13014915585517883,
-0.5686448216438293,
0.45317965745925903,
-0.5037520527839661,
0.5412375330924988,
-0.499515563249588,
-0.24461449682712555,
-0.25609180331230164,
0.45289361476898193,
-0.4684082567691803,
-1.1261199712753296,
0.34874457120895386,
-0.09254474192857742,
-0.2917864918708801,
-0.02154185064136982,
0.4720439612865448,
-0.5111984610557556,
-0.5361276865005493,
0.7083165049552917,
0.4062248170375824,
-0.03984443470835686,
0.15406261384487152,
-0.19281454384326935,
0.05224107205867767,
0.174655944108963,
-0.3846992552280426,
0.34135499596595764,
0.3852735757827759,
-0.2744050920009613,
0.7367373108863831,
0.23946858942508698,
0.5146166086196899,
0.4599597454071045,
0.26486942172050476,
0.4556494653224945,
-0.768220841884613,
0.1115892231464386,
-0.6364754438400269,
0.6035802364349365,
0.18392454087734222,
-0.7271690964698792,
0.8798476457595825,
0.29477012157440186,
0.7468839883804321,
0.04251518473029137,
0.9649721384048462,
-0.5528700351715088,
0.2555170953273773,
0.2159091681241989,
0.5089834928512573,
-0.45103719830513,
-0.07179238647222519,
-0.11963894218206406,
-1.0570220947265625,
-0.8366403579711914,
0.4933759570121765,
0.1892634928226471,
-0.12098576873540878,
0.7107030749320984,
0.03857867047190666,
0.16300536692142487,
-0.04613238945603371,
0.4809817671775818,
-0.016362467780709267,
0.1899273842573166,
0.09882324934005737,
0.6866483092308044,
-0.008789419196546078,
0.46758970618247986,
-0.6295900940895081,
-0.43123260140419006,
-0.08429845422506332,
-0.6025400161743164,
-0.7622612118721008,
-0.714703381061554,
-0.3363906145095825,
-0.20473600924015045,
-0.0005683609051629901,
0.5140016674995422,
0.4830440580844879,
-1.0553948879241943,
-0.41637688875198364,
-0.0027803564444184303,
0.11939159780740738,
-0.13155879080295563,
-0.13186411559581757,
0.3248530924320221,
-0.19726504385471344,
-0.6685432195663452,
0.37836402654647827,
0.9946414232254028,
-0.16818417608737946,
-0.6170824766159058,
0.20500077307224274,
-0.5216189622879028,
-0.46443507075309753,
0.261567085981369,
0.6972466707229614,
-0.6690086722373962,
-0.4910946488380432,
-0.042229168117046356,
-0.3011947572231293,
0.05998823791742325,
0.7580832839012146,
-0.3480395972728729,
0.6261626482009888,
0.6403188705444336,
0.09081625938415527,
0.21902933716773987,
-0.3344677686691284,
0.6214514374732971,
-0.29506754875183105,
0.5878781080245972,
-0.11690445989370346,
0.6339470148086548,
0.3759945034980774,
-0.14114494621753693,
0.9071354269981384,
0.476684033870697,
-0.6134592294692993,
-0.6311587691307068,
0.755826473236084,
-1.1628532409667969,
0.07411592453718185,
1.2246230840682983,
-0.35851597785949707,
0.20333047211170197,
-1.0472842454910278,
-0.19693352282047272,
0.27053946256637573,
-0.119954913854599,
0.4907071888446808,
0.5901678204536438,
-0.14957940578460693,
-0.21567465364933014,
-0.8421794176101685,
0.3557501435279846,
0.13473646342754364,
-0.5773273706436157,
0.21145997941493988,
0.4229549765586853,
0.4209742546081543,
0.4746735095977783,
0.3750300407409668,
-0.1255672723054886,
0.18280833959579468,
0.0825636014342308,
0.4848618805408478,
0.14805573225021362,
-0.5252528190612793,
-0.2741522789001465,
-0.29973334074020386,
0.13096559047698975,
0.012663635425269604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14678v1 | Bidirectional Transformer Representations of (Spanish) Ambiguous Words in Context: A New Lexical Resource and Empirical Analysis | 2024-06-20T18:58:11 | 2024-06-20T18:58:11 | Pamela D. Rivière, Anne L. Beatty-Martínez, Sean Trott | cs.CL | cs.CL | Lexical ambiguity -- where a single wordform takes on distinct,
context-dependent meanings -- serves as a useful tool to compare across
different large language models' (LLMs') ability to form distinct,
contextualized representations of the same stimulus. Few studies have
systematically compared LLMs' contextualized word embeddings for languages
beyond English. Here, we evaluate multiple bidirectional transformers' (BERTs')
semantic representations of Spanish ambiguous nouns in context. We develop a
novel dataset of minimal-pair sentences evoking the same or different sense for
a target ambiguous noun. In a pre-registered study, we collect contextualized
human relatedness judgments for each sentence pair. We find that various
BERT-based LLMs' contextualized semantic representations capture some variance
in human judgments but fall short of the human benchmark, and for Spanish --
unlike English -- model scale is uncorrelated with performance. We also
identify stereotyped trajectories of target noun disambiguation as a proportion
of traversal through a given LLM family's architecture, which we partially
replicate in English. We contribute (1) a dataset of controlled, Spanish
sentence stimuli with human relatedness norms, and (2) to our evolving
understanding of the impact that LLM specification (architectures, training
protocols) exerts on contextualized embeddings. | [
-0.38710516691207886,
-0.505754828453064,
0.42989227175712585,
0.6731951236724854,
-0.3172176778316498,
0.09271325916051865,
-0.35349252820014954,
-0.5913056135177612,
0.3109816610813141,
0.09000799059867859,
-0.6919233202934265,
-0.1469108909368515,
-0.7829940915107727,
0.49653586745262146,
-0.39037421345710754,
0.5347675681114197,
-0.08060306310653687,
0.08052066713571548,
-0.18786825239658356,
-0.16158191859722137,
-0.47205984592437744,
-0.2936488687992096,
-0.008742162957787514,
-0.3969261050224304,
0.922127366065979,
0.2869319021701813,
1.1994162797927856,
0.42828190326690674,
0.6295605897903442,
0.2784898281097412,
-0.15900981426239014,
0.013759728521108627,
-0.3040270507335663,
0.2028144896030426,
-0.41639742255210876,
-0.20119470357894897,
-0.053193531930446625,
-0.15814253687858582,
0.618402898311615,
1.0226929187774658,
0.05066164955496788,
0.024696428328752518,
0.1774013787508011,
0.5430248379707336,
-0.5267093777656555,
0.15803593397140503,
-0.8322670459747314,
0.09221140295267105,
-0.10316216945648193,
-0.13985218107700348,
-0.20757916569709778,
-0.13936802744865417,
0.34869638085365295,
-0.20106644928455353,
0.36878252029418945,
0.06928907334804535,
0.9901998043060303,
0.5849292278289795,
-0.5570610761642456,
-0.3780280649662018,
-0.6802754998207092,
0.6733423471450806,
-0.3800573945045471,
0.6668793559074402,
0.044094983488321304,
0.2028871476650238,
-0.29679447412490845,
-0.6333695650100708,
-0.6215247511863708,
-0.22482594847679138,
-0.2742425203323364,
0.19195304811000824,
-0.3189426362514496,
0.057358067482709885,
-0.0937528908252716,
0.17480070888996124,
-0.4750141501426697,
0.2750330865383148,
-0.40835851430892944,
-0.14990955591201782,
0.4143839180469513,
-0.1704549640417099,
-0.0127045763656497,
-0.4732498526573181,
-0.6994813680648804,
-0.4062125086784363,
-0.9111422896385193,
-0.03049801103770733,
0.5539342761039734,
0.37122851610183716,
-0.021367093548178673,
0.6316465139389038,
0.12799113988876343,
0.5208536982536316,
-0.08646201342344284,
0.21720777451992035,
0.45978859066963196,
0.03816387802362442,
-0.17188215255737305,
0.14743150770664215,
0.7169187664985657,
0.19456009566783905,
-0.0016471438575536013,
-0.48674896359443665,
-0.18370836973190308,
0.19843029975891113,
0.23547130823135376,
-0.34989550709724426,
0.217142716050148,
0.06866365671157837,
-0.2351776659488678,
-0.0496707446873188,
0.47410041093826294,
-0.49571117758750916,
-0.23743082582950592,
-0.11493082344532013,
0.28769972920417786,
-0.21998463571071625,
0.0678381696343422,
0.3171100914478302,
-0.17746293544769287,
0.4620393216609955,
-0.0899542048573494,
-0.6865589618682861,
0.3057591915130615,
0.5280764698982239,
0.501876711845398,
-0.22864709794521332,
-0.5029394030570984,
0.1624145358800888,
0.12470686435699463,
-0.03396676480770111,
0.6358301639556885,
-0.5341773629188538,
-0.5306159257888794,
0.22570045292377472,
0.3233952224254608,
-0.1271854192018509,
-0.47064656019210815,
0.6175795793533325,
-0.67588871717453,
0.292828768491745,
-0.38463518023490906,
-0.2617272436618805,
-0.2394149750471115,
0.07316549122333527,
-0.8033706545829773,
1.1325302124023438,
-0.01063654012978077,
-0.6428679823875427,
0.23647119104862213,
-0.3116881251335144,
-0.5024470090866089,
0.02451750449836254,
-0.4619961678981781,
0.04772786423563957,
0.3027539849281311,
0.13598021864891052,
0.568679690361023,
-0.2879539728164673,
0.4503147602081299,
0.09081112593412399,
-0.3521614074707031,
0.2609528601169586,
-0.5395165085792542,
0.57410728931427,
-0.022846901789307594,
-0.44288837909698486,
-0.09242599457502365,
-0.40982723236083984,
-0.42046090960502625,
0.2787599563598633,
-0.25137022137641907,
-0.39794403314590454,
0.1693544089794159,
0.19119569659233093,
0.3694017231464386,
0.690480649471283,
-0.6746622323989868,
-0.09465650469064713,
-0.5279446244239807,
0.2193104773759842,
0.5653734803199768,
-0.2889536917209625,
0.3344784080982208,
-0.43644577264785767,
0.5275636911392212,
0.010096165351569653,
-0.06613662093877792,
-0.09151506423950195,
-0.5354369878768921,
-0.7485823035240173,
0.011306988075375557,
0.1901504099369049,
0.5437825918197632,
-0.47308698296546936,
0.598383367061615,
-0.5224965214729309,
-0.019619515165686607,
-0.46093448996543884,
-0.10940175503492355,
0.27078044414520264,
0.3673054873943329,
0.37095192074775696,
-0.043849293142557144,
-0.863652765750885,
-1.3169100284576416,
-0.06228815019130707,
-0.08172211796045303,
-0.22133120894432068,
0.2799169421195984,
0.5696468353271484,
-0.5279595255851746,
1.1011916399002075,
-0.27461034059524536,
-0.23606017231941223,
-0.08848495036363602,
0.13186275959014893,
0.18553797900676727,
0.11051638424396515,
0.6103555560112,
-0.738634467124939,
-0.13451959192752838,
0.0046218461357057095,
-0.3612954914569855,
-0.014211064204573631,
0.04743863642215729,
0.13897088170051575,
-0.06817617267370224,
0.5032145380973816,
-0.13833731412887573,
0.17636629939079285,
0.8391274809837341,
-0.3577510416507721,
0.18597111105918884,
-0.4334779679775238,
-0.08456605672836304,
-0.9178975224494934,
-0.08860912173986435,
-0.24978575110435486,
-0.15479925274848938,
-0.40037238597869873,
-0.09390868246555328,
0.2808119058609009,
0.3835793137550354,
-0.6490037441253662,
0.6264820694923401,
-0.4592553377151489,
-0.15913647413253784,
-0.026248330250382423,
0.49667319655418396,
-0.058757562190294266,
0.5682400465011597,
0.1438097208738327,
0.6848831176757812,
0.3423495292663574,
-0.3030446469783783,
0.33172905445098877,
0.12170127779245377,
-0.18500903248786926,
0.2920600175857544,
-0.8584941625595093,
0.09285848587751389,
-0.5526871681213379,
0.0364009253680706,
-1.1411476135253906,
-0.1159609705209732,
0.06962727755308151,
-0.05907395854592323,
0.1723596155643463,
0.2581929862499237,
-0.6220457553863525,
-0.5340655446052551,
-0.317676842212677,
0.5415464639663696,
0.358604371547699,
-0.6469644904136658,
0.2318214476108551,
0.25485461950302124,
-0.030077043920755386,
-0.6588143706321716,
-0.7940986156463623,
0.09159830212593079,
-0.21950210630893707,
-0.7287770509719849,
0.757788360118866,
0.15667219460010529,
-0.13954555988311768,
0.10286006331443787,
-0.23062969744205475,
0.023876875638961792,
-0.055902596563100815,
0.39321446418762207,
0.29922306537628174,
-0.08556970208883286,
0.16304609179496765,
0.29712167382240295,
0.26973703503608704,
0.14127041399478912,
0.042925503104925156,
0.5349480509757996,
-0.526809811592102,
-0.4163967967033386,
0.0041028959676623344,
0.26601442694664,
0.5556344389915466,
0.16017363965511322,
0.6809969544410706,
0.36733847856521606,
-0.4235098361968994,
0.19532503187656403,
-0.6400248408317566,
-0.05266979709267616,
-0.45250165462493896,
0.40493044257164,
-0.5534797310829163,
-1.0072439908981323,
0.9794747233390808,
0.10664991289377213,
-0.026976633816957474,
0.5894083380699158,
0.6514513492584229,
-0.24702833592891693,
0.8072946071624756,
0.4292539656162262,
0.033518340438604355,
0.2813671827316284,
-0.13491559028625488,
0.12336676567792892,
-0.9139115810394287,
-0.4977521002292633,
-0.5448501110076904,
-0.6088537573814392,
-0.6979035139083862,
-0.6929468512535095,
0.30852216482162476,
-0.21935512125492096,
-0.15150348842144012,
0.505584716796875,
-0.2647337019443512,
0.6483091115951538,
0.25376325845718384,
0.06037325784564018,
0.3533388376235962,
-0.057716332376003265,
-0.3566402494907379,
-0.19143888354301453,
-0.7072964906692505,
-0.6854039430618286,
0.9634842276573181,
0.5087171792984009,
0.6098626255989075,
0.3457546830177307,
0.58845454454422,
0.3484129011631012,
0.03657667338848114,
-0.8778920769691467,
0.2968105375766754,
-0.32947394251823425,
-0.39415404200553894,
-0.1390743851661682,
-0.12591227889060974,
-1.3472284078598022,
0.6944059729576111,
-0.1270216703414917,
-0.6928590536117554,
0.5479071736335754,
-0.2793912887573242,
-0.25461632013320923,
0.06512871384620667,
-0.5087514519691467,
0.7541258931159973,
-0.34072938561439514,
-0.2749673128128052,
-0.03977221995592117,
-0.7893205881118774,
0.19374364614486694,
0.07457191497087479,
0.34219130873680115,
-0.22248409688472748,
-0.3667609393596649,
0.6348558664321899,
-0.19511467218399048,
0.8274503350257874,
0.14511063694953918,
-0.37620213627815247,
0.008686993271112442,
0.20892822742462158,
0.30276331305503845,
-0.05568620562553406,
-0.07676220685243607,
0.42875316739082336,
0.11486374586820602,
-0.34746646881103516,
-0.43907180428504944,
0.5823262929916382,
-0.817495584487915,
-0.6486583948135376,
-0.4281453788280487,
-0.754114031791687,
-0.38961130380630493,
0.03414413332939148,
0.21711960434913635,
0.13877741992473602,
-0.5609251260757446,
0.2189595103263855,
0.3394305408000946,
-0.07092579454183578,
0.46345293521881104,
0.3284197449684143,
-0.11831967532634735,
0.21887129545211792,
0.41894206404685974,
-0.29937970638275146,
-0.024235740303993225,
0.5318061113357544,
0.20718546211719513,
-0.6796583533287048,
-0.2592010796070099,
-0.2095886468887329,
0.34089741110801697,
-0.477297842502594,
-0.14179015159606934,
-0.29070934653282166,
-0.12280252575874329,
-0.2141454815864563,
-0.2882556617259979,
-0.3219444453716278,
-0.330468088388443,
-0.2845665216445923,
-0.07664071023464203,
0.0814158096909523,
0.8548988699913025,
-0.03221497684717178,
0.48789769411087036,
-0.5332047939300537,
0.22805596888065338,
0.35367241501808167,
0.17529670894145966,
-0.1424282193183899,
-0.7147716283798218,
0.08570197224617004,
0.2219701111316681,
0.040909018367528915,
-1.3020460605621338,
0.1953866332769394,
0.20965220034122467,
0.6980976462364197,
0.7075235843658447,
-0.14581236243247986,
0.5713462233543396,
-0.5879644751548767,
0.5984935164451599,
0.21461676061153412,
-0.8292157053947449,
0.4560249447822571,
-0.31678494811058044,
0.20150117576122284,
0.46519702672958374,
0.3550175130367279,
-0.7525646686553955,
-0.43359196186065674,
-0.4920435845851898,
-1.0425622463226318,
0.7228196859359741,
0.2656886577606201,
0.4265627861022949,
-0.37292227149009705,
0.14695659279823303,
0.07696466892957687,
0.15385282039642334,
-0.779495120048523,
-0.48075419664382935,
-0.10433267056941986,
-0.14733682572841644,
0.05008213222026825,
-0.3955148458480835,
-0.03167231008410454,
-0.31081148982048035,
0.32603931427001953,
0.05327899381518364,
0.18541379272937775,
0.321789026260376,
-0.4092734158039093,
0.12115386128425598,
0.33523914217948914,
0.5342398285865784,
0.43639135360717773,
-0.4725234806537628,
0.5598697066307068,
0.23482555150985718,
-0.38828808069229126,
0.03687135875225067,
0.16840586066246033,
0.16517066955566406,
0.3750932812690735,
0.29560285806655884,
0.6651683449745178,
0.8212974667549133,
-0.890009880065918,
0.6187765598297119,
0.004311815835535526,
-0.020777489989995956,
-0.19703403115272522,
-0.4092857837677002,
0.055354878306388855,
0.19752654433250427,
0.40085428953170776,
0.00024216969904955477,
0.08105402439832687,
-0.6344265341758728,
-0.01577701047062874,
0.4085623621940613,
-0.40624791383743286,
-0.2695954442024231,
0.49369361996650696,
0.14213182032108307,
-0.10765455663204193,
0.2161846160888672,
-0.426043838262558,
-0.6556245684623718,
0.6616740822792053,
0.4857870936393738,
0.7777868509292603,
-0.1595807522535324,
0.18290118873119354,
0.17590413987636566,
0.46374231576919556,
-0.1895832121372223,
0.1694093495607376,
-0.1571463644504547,
-1.146407961845398,
-0.12038051337003708,
-0.5732455849647522,
-0.25390392541885376,
-0.15397202968597412,
-0.821456253528595,
0.19764800369739532,
0.021232156082987785,
-0.10948082059621811,
-0.3480871021747589,
-0.4209740459918976,
-0.9899429678916931,
-0.31884393095970154,
0.24490244686603546,
0.5827058553695679,
-1.0318325757980347,
0.792902946472168,
0.9329141974449158,
-0.18827086687088013,
-0.5825322270393372,
-0.06384547054767609,
-0.17565438151359558,
-0.9409695863723755,
0.8392841815948486,
-0.11103414744138718,
-0.5629199743270874,
-0.2563374936580658,
-0.10406513512134552,
-0.8805261254310608,
1.0288197994232178,
0.3702176809310913,
-0.6500502824783325,
-0.21026642620563507,
0.6193955540657043,
0.7128406167030334,
-0.3463810086250305,
0.20719856023788452,
0.8922921419143677,
0.46797317266464233,
0.4536486864089966,
-0.9714319705963135,
0.11233948171138763,
-0.04540088772773743,
0.335580974817276,
0.009226178750395775,
-0.36493784189224243,
0.801001250743866,
-0.10387195646762848,
-0.4802595376968384,
-0.08681177347898483,
0.5363233089447021,
0.0006510583334602416,
-0.17016737163066864,
0.3942807614803314,
0.3964898884296417,
0.7558393478393555,
-0.2509406805038452,
0.832295835018158,
-0.3698814809322357,
0.43866270780563354,
1.34412682056427,
-0.14997392892837524,
0.8499723076820374,
0.9173048138618469,
-0.3868245780467987,
0.6552910804748535,
0.5929061770439148,
0.03497229516506195,
0.4422743022441864,
0.2182161808013916,
-0.08152320235967636,
0.04731132462620735,
-0.12731267511844635,
-0.397840678691864,
0.6517164707183838,
0.4439333379268646,
-0.40055111050605774,
-0.5547425150871277,
0.07334420084953308,
-0.021152641624212265,
0.2441844344139099,
-0.06260868906974792,
0.32965344190597534,
-0.0986139103770256,
-0.4578666090965271,
0.5766587257385254,
0.18795087933540344,
0.9493631720542908,
-0.4029754102230072,
0.3848312199115753,
-0.42124760150909424,
-0.25226327776908875,
-0.16316072642803192,
-0.7777156233787537,
0.44485414028167725,
-0.042362280189991,
-0.15243569016456604,
-0.4744294583797455,
0.3721793591976166,
-0.43882524967193604,
-0.5246549844741821,
0.5055540800094604,
0.8382222652435303,
0.20172426104545593,
-0.007724907249212265,
-0.4740256667137146,
0.06156211718916893,
-0.04309418052434921,
-0.022371146827936172,
-0.12479768693447113,
0.32444408535957336,
-0.08647465705871582,
0.3428100645542145,
0.1559920608997345,
0.14297598600387573,
0.5037596821784973,
0.4584026038646698,
0.657577633857727,
-0.6666162610054016,
-0.21167492866516113,
-0.7375649809837341,
0.1526924967765808,
0.2939395606517792,
-0.25907209515571594,
0.6221614480018616,
0.5101770758628845,
0.9756874442100525,
-0.12001395970582962,
0.31678324937820435,
-0.1544734239578247,
0.10974066704511642,
-0.19696663320064545,
0.30302369594573975,
-0.5560318827629089,
0.47344306111335754,
-0.17420677840709686,
-0.9820124506950378,
-0.3817179501056671,
0.7528243064880371,
-0.2511725425720215,
-0.17128108441829681,
0.8026232719421387,
0.8007684946060181,
-0.13844884932041168,
-0.04014579951763153,
0.3075949549674988,
0.27556678652763367,
-0.040424954146146774,
0.502724826335907,
1.0810834169387817,
-0.5599325299263,
0.45045432448387146,
-0.34823453426361084,
0.015557250939309597,
-0.2823217511177063,
-0.8310248255729675,
-0.6258590817451477,
-0.8287591934204102,
-0.07814190536737442,
0.03222213312983513,
-0.1048978641629219,
0.8651121258735657,
0.42800456285476685,
-0.6977781057357788,
-0.3741748332977295,
-0.06311069428920746,
0.49787765741348267,
-0.05709974467754364,
-0.25660645961761475,
0.4909171462059021,
-0.313992977142334,
-1.0196622610092163,
0.4533764123916626,
0.17143407464027405,
0.14076681435108185,
-0.53410404920578,
-0.026578515768051147,
-0.09260870516300201,
0.05883273854851723,
0.6472939848899841,
0.18359285593032837,
-1.0118080377578735,
-0.5078741312026978,
0.13922207057476044,
-0.22676832973957062,
0.18899314105510712,
0.7536333203315735,
-0.9783690571784973,
0.41533562541007996,
0.49857425689697266,
0.4538804292678833,
0.2799021005630493,
-0.20094835758209229,
0.2864719331264496,
-1.0582102537155151,
0.6750339269638062,
0.3181750178337097,
0.6940848231315613,
0.20593154430389404,
-0.14160268008708954,
0.2417835295200348,
-0.0390632189810276,
-0.09077352285385132,
-0.5650149583816528,
0.4064626097679138,
-1.1905457973480225,
-0.38597479462623596,
1.1906627416610718,
0.2525918185710907,
-0.03861187398433685,
-0.15555155277252197,
-0.09757156670093536,
0.17902955412864685,
-0.30232518911361694,
0.9162907600402832,
0.66592937707901,
-0.27342796325683594,
0.11686888337135315,
-0.22878621518611908,
0.19050757586956024,
0.4688122868537903,
-0.3465861976146698,
-0.2858159840106964,
0.42984870076179504,
0.020814858376979828,
0.24299459159374237,
-0.0024803888518363237,
-0.18113070726394653,
0.0010386179201304913,
-0.29560765624046326,
0.0706336498260498,
0.17141054570674896,
-0.3030031621456146,
-0.44896191358566284,
0.07661202549934387,
0.013147765770554543,
-0.331238329410553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14673v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14673v1 | Insights into LLM Long-Context Failures: When Transformers Know but Don't Tell | 2024-06-20T18:50:44 | 2024-06-20T18:50:44 | Taiming Lu, Muhan Gao, Kuai Yu, Adam Byerly, Daniel Khashabi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit positional bias, struggling to utilize
information from the middle or end of long contexts. Our study explores LLMs'
long-context reasoning by probing their hidden representations. We find that
while LLMs encode the position of target information, they often fail to
leverage this in generating accurate responses. This reveals a disconnect
between information retrieval and utilization, a "know but don't tell"
phenomenon. We further analyze the relationship between extraction time and
final accuracy, offering insights into the underlying mechanics of transformer
models. | [
-0.4668395221233368,
-0.594782292842865,
1.1685775518417358,
0.2101784646511078,
0.01474526897072792,
0.1338375061750412,
-0.2619515657424927,
-0.5219242572784424,
-0.06321198493242264,
0.4236452579498291,
-0.7806671857833862,
-0.22121740877628326,
-0.8478264808654785,
0.028060536831617355,
-0.6419132947921753,
0.7318317890167236,
-0.12522436678409576,
-0.2143176645040512,
-0.11214454472064972,
-0.08356893062591553,
-0.3884717524051666,
-0.5890958905220032,
-0.4889812469482422,
-0.4481987953186035,
0.42880332469940186,
0.4296528697013855,
0.7670316696166992,
0.5087201595306396,
0.4397169053554535,
0.18765567243099213,
-0.4186570346355438,
-0.14961427450180054,
-0.5778493285179138,
0.3213062286376953,
-0.24382981657981873,
-0.8196794986724854,
0.1423986703157425,
-0.14605392515659332,
0.6226965188980103,
0.8237051963806152,
0.044175878167152405,
-0.024713248014450073,
-0.05160187929868698,
0.5473421812057495,
-0.5506684184074402,
0.11601490527391434,
-0.5914381742477417,
0.1473916471004486,
-0.3473607301712036,
-0.1636568009853363,
-0.6787957549095154,
-0.1549922376871109,
0.4023181200027466,
-0.19454307854175568,
0.43096601963043213,
0.012749690562486649,
0.7239413857460022,
0.5019006133079529,
-0.7923850417137146,
-0.33961787819862366,
-1.1508581638336182,
1.1224806308746338,
-0.29691368341445923,
0.36974939703941345,
0.4696621298789978,
0.5506039261817932,
-0.30899110436439514,
-0.652127206325531,
-0.595969557762146,
-0.1031813696026802,
-0.3171532154083252,
-0.04630488529801369,
-0.13745346665382385,
-0.16894450783729553,
0.5231815576553345,
0.11411525309085846,
-0.16706004738807678,
0.23352935910224915,
-0.45752859115600586,
0.135284423828125,
0.2534255385398865,
0.03635096549987793,
-0.04848634451627731,
-0.3681589961051941,
-0.827472984790802,
-0.17037314176559448,
-0.9178678393363953,
0.14952309429645538,
0.1433616727590561,
-0.25064000487327576,
-0.06760288029909134,
0.6727871298789978,
0.28674793243408203,
0.47541704773902893,
0.17157429456710815,
-0.11597912013530731,
-0.16657283902168274,
0.1270526796579361,
-0.36364924907684326,
0.01965430937707424,
0.7296575307846069,
0.2655407190322876,
-0.016955364495515823,
-0.29164692759513855,
-0.5185424089431763,
-0.16780202090740204,
0.3658231794834137,
-0.4098585546016693,
0.3504795432090759,
0.21969819068908691,
-0.42554542422294617,
-0.28744053840637207,
0.20051546394824982,
-0.5333943367004395,
-0.2927233576774597,
-0.1230979710817337,
0.42315730452537537,
-0.29756999015808105,
0.018043309450149536,
-0.0915021002292633,
-0.24728021025657654,
0.5148411393165588,
0.06142069399356842,
-0.8415918350219727,
0.06582838296890259,
0.5095192790031433,
0.6574873924255371,
-0.3829938471317291,
-0.22539903223514557,
-0.23243360221385956,
0.24358445405960083,
-0.41668277978897095,
0.7402598857879639,
-0.4058910608291626,
-0.6433357000350952,
-0.0031870901584625244,
0.3180934488773346,
-0.08794844150543213,
-0.7162352204322815,
0.6654199361801147,
-0.7343400120735168,
0.0826353132724762,
-0.44722843170166016,
-0.4092361629009247,
-0.04090594872832298,
-0.028862010687589645,
-0.8462557792663574,
0.9371131062507629,
0.1695294827222824,
-0.7718864679336548,
0.3064255714416504,
-0.5254343152046204,
-0.4700424075126648,
-0.2689676284790039,
-0.20978817343711853,
-0.23148369789123535,
0.5358100533485413,
0.18016766011714935,
0.4564850330352783,
-0.08850762248039246,
0.481060266494751,
-0.11614923924207687,
-0.6361653208732605,
0.6638752818107605,
-0.639185905456543,
0.5044164657592773,
0.021205823868513107,
-0.48606428503990173,
-0.09645208716392517,
-0.4291404187679291,
-0.5606465339660645,
0.4855603277683258,
-0.24077387154102325,
-0.17233555018901825,
0.3229338824748993,
-0.23583072423934937,
0.30760088562965393,
0.23724374175071716,
-0.5333252549171448,
0.16508488357067108,
-0.1717129796743393,
0.5593576431274414,
0.7083239555358887,
-0.3273334503173828,
0.6983341574668884,
-0.3062001168727875,
0.46879735589027405,
0.13594603538513184,
0.09028208255767822,
-0.20784395933151245,
-0.09208619594573975,
-1.0142625570297241,
0.42032620310783386,
-0.008369783870875835,
0.3721920847892761,
-0.8663330078125,
0.22873476147651672,
-0.3793821930885315,
-0.3668792247772217,
-0.25050053000450134,
-0.11378615349531174,
0.19868844747543335,
0.653754711151123,
0.44778165221214294,
0.09206133335828781,
-0.4686968922615051,
-1.1815255880355835,
-0.327258437871933,
0.07804077863693237,
-0.10527399182319641,
0.2701743245124817,
0.482009619474411,
-0.444267600774765,
0.951524555683136,
-0.5317100286483765,
-0.16077934205532074,
-0.4797019958496094,
-0.12299741059541702,
0.3614867627620697,
-0.038525596261024475,
0.3352339565753937,
-0.8619617223739624,
-0.005300458054989576,
-0.34952399134635925,
-0.985160231590271,
0.08464713394641876,
-0.08515025675296783,
0.18058204650878906,
0.16098128259181976,
0.6784612536430359,
-0.9275381565093994,
0.49838024377822876,
0.8143773674964905,
-0.23829901218414307,
0.5852692723274231,
-0.030120329931378365,
-0.2623631954193115,
-0.9475173950195312,
-0.013981427066028118,
0.057067446410655975,
-0.2494664341211319,
-0.33123403787612915,
-0.2800704836845398,
0.22827716171741486,
0.08297234773635864,
-0.5199006199836731,
0.5540346503257751,
-0.5721874833106995,
-0.30361053347587585,
-0.3870368003845215,
0.3298095464706421,
0.11180508881807327,
0.3423578441143036,
0.0843217521905899,
0.9458089470863342,
0.35096558928489685,
-0.6980661153793335,
0.026328418403863907,
0.105618417263031,
-0.443546861410141,
0.5608307719230652,
-0.627116858959198,
0.16267529129981995,
-0.3637642562389374,
0.48492297530174255,
-0.8878794312477112,
-0.3794136047363281,
-0.04363017529249191,
-0.2903366982936859,
0.5968526005744934,
-0.3661534786224365,
-0.5237228870391846,
-0.4874266982078552,
0.03448835015296936,
0.4056554138660431,
0.44875115156173706,
-0.8639523386955261,
0.3005930185317993,
0.38152456283569336,
0.025070086121559143,
-0.9898557662963867,
-0.9867150187492371,
-0.06954267621040344,
-0.3652643859386444,
-0.5796728134155273,
0.49696922302246094,
0.13919411599636078,
-0.4930034875869751,
-0.16816620528697968,
-0.6645240187644958,
0.047371361404657364,
0.26731500029563904,
0.36346355080604553,
0.006947863381356001,
-0.1252281665802002,
0.43866968154907227,
0.11458107084035873,
-0.2541813850402832,
0.5174052715301514,
0.03568162024021149,
0.5982713103294373,
-0.0008742298814468086,
-0.6768291592597961,
-0.3036049008369446,
0.3185350298881531,
0.7648191452026367,
0.1846635788679123,
1.0411548614501953,
0.38903704285621643,
-0.22366394102573395,
-0.2586454153060913,
-0.681398332118988,
-0.3682285249233246,
-0.49839407205581665,
0.2367418110370636,
-0.24914883077144623,
-0.8238691687583923,
0.5221729874610901,
-0.17333102226257324,
-0.2253797948360443,
0.6822066307067871,
0.17529365420341492,
-0.3172472417354584,
0.8194579482078552,
0.6792406439781189,
-0.007004730403423309,
0.40067440271377563,
-0.2905806005001068,
0.3558986485004425,
-0.85964035987854,
-0.390428364276886,
-0.5094791054725647,
-0.3586593270301819,
-0.4151389002799988,
-0.362611323595047,
0.41188496351242065,
0.3082774877548218,
-0.13543283939361572,
0.37531644105911255,
-0.26422274112701416,
0.6693726778030396,
0.38425344228744507,
-0.04503164067864418,
0.244756817817688,
-0.1768435388803482,
0.06352412700653076,
-0.060718145221471786,
-0.3796251714229584,
-0.6130823493003845,
0.8776928782463074,
0.48437029123306274,
0.8955352306365967,
0.1769179254770279,
0.49529850482940674,
0.04088333249092102,
0.13237693905830383,
-1.0077978372573853,
0.30103909969329834,
0.22159840166568756,
-0.4932119846343994,
-0.3508889675140381,
-0.18757957220077515,
-1.1140563488006592,
-0.026439866051077843,
0.256600022315979,
-0.7500953674316406,
0.14711295068264008,
-0.2353142350912094,
-0.11367546766996384,
0.42258065938949585,
-0.6388953328132629,
0.5547690391540527,
-0.3157791793346405,
-0.031429074704647064,
0.17750099301338196,
-0.8401374220848083,
0.20417794585227966,
-0.20132651925086975,
0.29386377334594727,
-0.05516818165779114,
0.11324106901884079,
0.773788332939148,
-0.21021752059459686,
0.8334177732467651,
-0.013189492747187614,
-0.2351824790239334,
0.37166067957878113,
0.2855414152145386,
0.722187876701355,
0.05098678544163704,
0.015353708527982235,
0.33801907300949097,
-0.1565241515636444,
-0.2547271251678467,
-0.6487824320793152,
0.6771928071975708,
-0.70466548204422,
-0.6482918858528137,
-0.35569047927856445,
-0.3437139391899109,
-0.20066599547863007,
0.12291084975004196,
0.7819496989250183,
0.16748596727848053,
-0.07265697419643402,
0.3039472699165344,
0.6937922239303589,
-0.24020470678806305,
0.8533070683479309,
0.17514167726039886,
-0.12317518889904022,
0.23392297327518463,
0.21978922188282013,
0.10782986134290695,
0.3942145109176636,
0.44424566626548767,
0.012950681149959564,
-0.46009156107902527,
-0.28168126940727234,
-0.3286304473876953,
0.36716562509536743,
-1.0882283449172974,
-0.021713949739933014,
-0.45548972487449646,
-0.5396308302879333,
0.02622947096824646,
-0.1098610982298851,
-0.48053494095802307,
-0.26642337441444397,
-0.2982267439365387,
-0.4024749994277954,
0.03243344649672508,
1.2226905822753906,
0.23335757851600647,
0.6674503684043884,
-0.9010649919509888,
0.0910470187664032,
0.20653755962848663,
0.24108381569385529,
0.08111057430505753,
-0.532151460647583,
-0.19463013112545013,
-0.05389813333749771,
-0.47731441259384155,
-1.0811632871627808,
0.4134955406188965,
-0.295042484998703,
0.5825151205062866,
0.2016879767179489,
0.0028151688165962696,
0.33653953671455383,
-0.4064200520515442,
0.9880117774009705,
-0.0087576387450099,
-1.0639820098876953,
0.5697501301765442,
-0.2205023169517517,
0.42749476432800293,
0.04949016124010086,
0.4862353503704071,
-0.4323239326477051,
-0.1565711945295334,
-0.5265712141990662,
-0.8588843941688538,
0.8168198466300964,
0.09595106542110443,
0.24136245250701904,
-0.22306957840919495,
0.2981877624988556,
0.27216923236846924,
0.08236518502235413,
-0.912379801273346,
-0.4925766587257385,
0.1283169388771057,
0.15396618843078613,
-0.2567366361618042,
-0.7146866917610168,
-0.23781099915504456,
0.1057218685746193,
0.20662057399749756,
-0.1279984563589096,
0.5646023154258728,
0.3437073528766632,
-0.5172083377838135,
-0.17537511885166168,
0.4828242063522339,
0.9118963479995728,
1.1029629707336426,
-0.14791487157344818,
0.4556851387023926,
0.23207636177539825,
-0.2544538676738739,
0.06642317026853561,
-0.12843972444534302,
0.15059666335582733,
0.1299436092376709,
0.47716236114501953,
0.9401755332946777,
0.463966429233551,
-0.5626848340034485,
0.6951399445533752,
-0.18027950823307037,
0.027372300624847412,
-0.8965263366699219,
-0.13212759792804718,
0.1852625459432602,
0.4390639662742615,
0.7863121628761292,
0.1431223303079605,
-0.11269223690032959,
-0.3749106824398041,
0.067781463265419,
0.38104119896888733,
-0.6475598216056824,
-0.45672497153282166,
0.6479781270027161,
-0.20232927799224854,
-0.33924993872642517,
0.6997008323669434,
0.2263984978199005,
-0.45231667160987854,
0.6429347395896912,
0.5900452136993408,
0.677847683429718,
-0.18297696113586426,
0.004575878381729126,
-0.06945860385894775,
0.19255083799362183,
-0.13361509144306183,
-0.12519460916519165,
-0.08183291554450989,
-0.7363929748535156,
-0.7054671049118042,
-0.4413531720638275,
-0.3579323887825012,
0.3310956358909607,
-0.7873725891113281,
0.26760196685791016,
-0.28691449761390686,
-0.39558279514312744,
-0.3449086844921112,
-0.5097048282623291,
-0.844918429851532,
0.020799484103918076,
0.18479926884174347,
0.8643099665641785,
-0.710403561592102,
0.633333146572113,
0.11212804913520813,
0.015891412273049355,
-0.7940463423728943,
0.3042912483215332,
-0.12294811010360718,
-0.8454035520553589,
1.0362974405288696,
0.5574093461036682,
-0.22149139642715454,
-0.3371043801307678,
-0.780059814453125,
-1.0530717372894287,
1.2876060009002686,
0.40027135610580444,
-0.7054867148399353,
-0.3162747621536255,
0.12299351394176483,
0.47447842359542847,
-0.03299896791577339,
0.4565735161304474,
0.6355525851249695,
0.5480615496635437,
0.2624833881855011,
-1.0866132974624634,
0.04338439181447029,
0.43159687519073486,
-0.297743022441864,
0.35306316614151,
-0.8152861595153809,
0.8050843477249146,
-0.41099807620048523,
-0.2532566487789154,
-0.2788170278072357,
0.4633687436580658,
0.026647519320249557,
0.39031168818473816,
0.2687394917011261,
0.5707305669784546,
0.5310564041137695,
-0.2767605781555176,
1.4031718969345093,
-0.04923662170767784,
0.576352059841156,
0.9053422212600708,
-0.1563723385334015,
0.7773689031600952,
0.6181243658065796,
-0.005135989747941494,
0.5599228143692017,
0.45304030179977417,
0.1318238526582718,
0.4790302813053131,
-0.09130179136991501,
-0.18339884281158447,
-0.18120579421520233,
0.1645096391439438,
-0.18717262148857117,
0.549284040927887,
0.622044563293457,
-0.8530482053756714,
-0.21708783507347107,
-0.08746810257434845,
0.11511857062578201,
-0.2861896753311157,
-0.030767833814024925,
0.5563602447509766,
0.5686259865760803,
-0.9018563032150269,
0.6324484348297119,
-0.05135359242558479,
0.5378703474998474,
-0.18962229788303375,
0.2344316840171814,
-0.2308569848537445,
0.13118886947631836,
-0.1589422971010208,
-1.1083158254623413,
0.444956511259079,
-0.34892985224723816,
-0.41257020831108093,
-0.2796970307826996,
0.7666922807693481,
-0.03971727564930916,
-0.08661573380231857,
0.7134045362472534,
0.5849261283874512,
0.08046619594097137,
-0.07008346915245056,
-0.326913446187973,
0.09994123876094818,
-0.07644268125295639,
-0.4691668748855591,
0.31673508882522583,
0.4451853334903717,
-0.1923990249633789,
0.9729933142662048,
0.3725512623786926,
-0.042698223143815994,
0.06503872573375702,
-0.010658768005669117,
0.6107683181762695,
-0.9295410513877869,
0.09667813777923584,
-1.0996781587600708,
0.38645297288894653,
-0.022415053099393845,
0.05412435159087181,
0.6624011397361755,
0.2329416573047638,
0.8915833234786987,
-0.17862796783447266,
0.7219638824462891,
0.3070041835308075,
0.5003786683082581,
-0.6786462068557739,
0.6014322638511658,
-0.3616331219673157,
0.527501106262207,
0.12804660201072693,
-1.1744061708450317,
-0.16317075490951538,
0.3723486661911011,
-0.6650503873825073,
0.11945319175720215,
0.8877015709877014,
0.4819015562534332,
-0.20536701381206512,
0.002250050427392125,
0.39547276496887207,
0.4428328275680542,
0.47666826844215393,
0.5235927700996399,
1.3140369653701782,
-0.42127883434295654,
0.6975084543228149,
-0.26700833439826965,
0.14646126329898834,
-0.4104861319065094,
-0.8226638436317444,
-0.8272182941436768,
-0.5712199211120605,
0.19415971636772156,
-0.383444219827652,
-0.2703191936016083,
0.46594345569610596,
0.7018133997917175,
-0.5726243257522583,
-0.05238889157772064,
0.07618413120508194,
0.4622252285480499,
0.19424830377101898,
-0.30919143557548523,
0.49548959732055664,
-0.29339900612831116,
-0.6759506464004517,
0.8019999861717224,
0.3161405920982361,
0.27261674404144287,
-0.29530277848243713,
0.10662943124771118,
0.25988560914993286,
-0.0416778065264225,
0.5285933613777161,
0.2058289796113968,
-0.8593225479125977,
-0.3820285499095917,
0.14149440824985504,
-0.18710240721702576,
0.29783862829208374,
0.8273293375968933,
-0.8418161273002625,
0.09782273322343826,
0.3051317632198334,
0.3845105469226837,
0.48399481177330017,
0.0631151795387268,
0.6903358697891235,
-0.8786134719848633,
0.08087632805109024,
0.26411330699920654,
0.579417884349823,
0.49549564719200134,
-0.47216296195983887,
0.3595394492149353,
0.19273509085178375,
-0.8441773056983948,
-0.6797820329666138,
0.41079583764076233,
-0.9720228910446167,
-0.383985310792923,
1.338166356086731,
0.05197715386748314,
-0.5099848508834839,
-0.0642760694026947,
-0.08567192405462265,
0.08628300577402115,
-0.1860639601945877,
0.7099853157997131,
0.7719887495040894,
-0.18292133510112762,
-0.08599123358726501,
-0.6895155310630798,
0.4720262885093689,
0.30744779109954834,
-0.20302382111549377,
-0.2230282574892044,
0.20632164180278778,
0.6018482446670532,
0.3655971884727478,
0.31714844703674316,
0.07310869544744492,
-0.21162842214107513,
-0.22296129167079926,
-0.31551387906074524,
0.25920695066452026,
-0.488835871219635,
-0.3381234407424927,
0.14515578746795654,
0.2746770977973938,
-0.04097970575094223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14670v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14670v1 | Exploring Design Choices for Building Language-Specific LLMs | 2024-06-20T18:47:43 | 2024-06-20T18:47:43 | Atula Tejaswi, Nilesh Gupta, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Despite rapid progress in large language models (LLMs), their performance on
a vast majority of languages remain unsatisfactory. In this paper, we study
building language-specific LLMs by adapting monolingual and multilingual LLMs.
We conduct systematic experiments on how design choices (base model selection,
vocabulary extension, and continued fine-tuning) impact the adapted LLM, both
in terms of efficiency (how many tokens are needed to encode the same amount of
information) and end task performance. We find that (1) the initial performance
before the adaptation is not always indicative of the final performance. (2)
Efficiency can easily improved with simple vocabulary extension and continued
fine-tuning in most LLMs we study, and (3) The optimal adaptation method is
highly language-dependent, and the simplest approach works well across various
experimental settings. Adapting English-centric models can yield better results
than adapting multilingual models despite their worse initial performance on
low-resource languages. Together, our work lays foundations on efficiently
building language-specific LLMs by adapting existing LLMs. | [
-0.4786575138568878,
-0.6929726004600525,
0.363846093416214,
0.3695622980594635,
-0.4317835867404938,
0.145503431558609,
-0.7292799353599548,
-0.5581236481666565,
0.16733744740486145,
0.421676903963089,
-0.2101474553346634,
-0.42794910073280334,
-0.40783897042274475,
0.29449477791786194,
0.061375077813863754,
0.7913985848426819,
-0.28233590722084045,
0.025929581373929977,
-0.05752759054303169,
-0.30312949419021606,
-0.6866227388381958,
-0.5983833074569702,
-0.6404151320457458,
-0.38119301199913025,
0.5626817941665649,
0.5642619132995605,
0.6898425221443176,
0.6392530202865601,
0.37189823389053345,
0.2889260947704315,
-0.1387026160955429,
0.21482548117637634,
-0.5263891220092773,
-0.1091393306851387,
-0.3905230760574341,
-0.6055020689964294,
-0.4832552671432495,
-0.3616989254951477,
0.544275164604187,
0.7954366207122803,
0.13129280507564545,
0.5355163812637329,
0.35144901275634766,
0.4987725615501404,
-0.6166342496871948,
0.13096635043621063,
-0.622717022895813,
0.10096818208694458,
-0.18040436506271362,
-0.317281574010849,
-0.6177083253860474,
0.1049952507019043,
0.02336219884455204,
-0.46779510378837585,
-0.10093393176794052,
0.09915086627006531,
0.3272947371006012,
0.12242104113101959,
-0.279380738735199,
-0.45645883679389954,
-0.7617102265357971,
0.7897557616233826,
-0.7875756025314331,
0.6929886341094971,
0.04000631719827652,
-0.05613085255026817,
-0.365538626909256,
-0.42656853795051575,
0.05914851650595665,
-0.35106539726257324,
0.008229373954236507,
0.03841933235526085,
-0.07713514566421509,
0.05157367140054703,
0.17102402448654175,
0.15015830099582672,
-0.6212615370750427,
0.5732868909835815,
-0.2787949740886688,
-0.015553995966911316,
0.5350621938705444,
0.11751548200845718,
0.2617016136646271,
-0.06409086287021637,
-0.18401651084423065,
0.2541060745716095,
-0.7755197882652283,
0.2609022259712219,
0.2487281858921051,
0.7450072169303894,
-0.18134674429893494,
0.5198920965194702,
-0.06061156839132309,
0.8353770971298218,
-0.14285367727279663,
-0.2539230287075043,
0.1966419667005539,
-0.4392037093639374,
-0.270392507314682,
-0.06371556967496872,
0.4265989661216736,
0.25667235255241394,
0.5761275887489319,
-0.3184340000152588,
-0.2937222719192505,
0.02919655852019787,
0.1714237779378891,
-0.7863414287567139,
0.009289177134633064,
0.16200432181358337,
-0.5306252241134644,
-0.04420635849237442,
-0.48236003518104553,
-0.2930222749710083,
-0.23724649846553802,
-0.4451366662979126,
0.43253427743911743,
-0.2379513680934906,
-0.3846134543418884,
0.47523435950279236,
-0.07703282684087753,
0.14684924483299255,
0.24607506394386292,
-0.8374032974243164,
0.22787222266197205,
0.5279778242111206,
0.8886998295783997,
-0.5239734053611755,
-0.4908737242221832,
-0.36518990993499756,
0.15173788368701935,
-0.6530910134315491,
0.7148938775062561,
-0.4785662293434143,
-0.6429985165596008,
0.14049628376960754,
0.11252346634864807,
0.06434887647628784,
-0.5748211145401001,
0.4451541304588318,
-0.4926505982875824,
0.12863783538341522,
-0.34109044075012207,
-0.4652509093284607,
0.0055513870902359486,
0.07049109041690826,
-0.6508058905601501,
0.6166447401046753,
0.04232344776391983,
-0.619152843952179,
0.36882123351097107,
-0.8523126244544983,
-0.8237993121147156,
0.09705125540494919,
0.004175620153546333,
-0.00605105422437191,
0.6872878074645996,
-0.08270671963691711,
0.40646058320999146,
-0.4652344286441803,
-0.009778895415365696,
-0.10853684693574905,
-0.5342890024185181,
0.10059339553117752,
-0.2516939043998718,
0.6337963938713074,
0.358359158039093,
-0.020897118374705315,
0.09460730850696564,
-0.8013679385185242,
-0.02463793382048607,
0.05965148285031319,
-0.7280792593955994,
-0.46720263361930847,
0.23176735639572144,
-0.07630173116922379,
-0.0010921277571469545,
0.5018452405929565,
-0.31413984298706055,
0.10191024094820023,
-0.252999871969223,
0.09618918597698212,
1.0476430654525757,
-0.3959493339061737,
0.6566126942634583,
-0.5446322560310364,
0.7370923757553101,
-0.25552836060523987,
0.016632962971925735,
-0.053388141095638275,
-0.2784457504749298,
-1.0062614679336548,
-0.40149515867233276,
0.41357722878456116,
0.42408671975135803,
-0.603308379650116,
-0.013048330321907997,
-0.2377055287361145,
-0.2590130865573883,
-0.4679219424724579,
0.3503616452217102,
0.22307763993740082,
0.15276993811130524,
0.04441218823194504,
-0.4667655825614929,
-0.7170720100402832,
-0.8912168145179749,
-0.4829041659832001,
-0.2983206510543823,
0.12381778657436371,
0.3002365827560425,
0.22362393140792847,
-0.11031915992498398,
0.7269666194915771,
-0.3891914486885071,
0.1692429631948471,
-0.5444096326828003,
-0.28056058287620544,
0.6213765740394592,
0.049439944326877594,
0.8745841383934021,
-0.5020812153816223,
-0.7076069116592407,
0.25496330857276917,
-0.5541667342185974,
-0.258192241191864,
-0.17349664866924286,
-0.08277701586484909,
0.294243723154068,
0.356703519821167,
-0.31963393092155457,
0.10689079761505127,
0.7485669851303101,
-0.27915576100349426,
0.7698027491569519,
-0.37053579092025757,
-0.09982029348611832,
-1.229913592338562,
-0.1371886283159256,
-0.15740901231765747,
-0.14277957379817963,
-0.7881401181221008,
0.2883457541465759,
0.07432824373245239,
0.1207270473241806,
-0.5685749053955078,
0.8868091702461243,
-0.8046000599861145,
-0.14953367412090302,
-0.5793349742889404,
-0.17540983855724335,
-0.16354016959667206,
0.5588904023170471,
0.10381261259317398,
0.9159778952598572,
0.6567756533622742,
-0.8961018323898315,
0.062237560749053955,
-0.04497688263654709,
-0.6007619500160217,
0.20028194785118103,
-0.5802904367446899,
0.13105496764183044,
-0.3064103126525879,
-0.14941783249378204,
-0.8082937002182007,
-0.02920859307050705,
-0.12325391918420792,
-0.18972446024417877,
0.27608761191368103,
-0.1735706776380539,
-0.5442158579826355,
-0.17472925782203674,
-0.36025843024253845,
0.2998948097229004,
0.48802807927131653,
-0.6078193187713623,
0.7389823794364929,
0.30398833751678467,
-0.34981781244277954,
-0.24741247296333313,
-0.7997965812683105,
0.15385031700134277,
-0.22282184660434723,
-0.6014336943626404,
0.30677923560142517,
-0.549650251865387,
-0.319245308637619,
-0.14629226922988892,
-0.19884270429611206,
0.12837471067905426,
0.42573225498199463,
0.030504968017339706,
0.07703787088394165,
-0.4073982536792755,
0.2801046371459961,
-0.06335046142339706,
0.1530361771583557,
-0.15120966732501984,
-0.2679572105407715,
0.6297448873519897,
-0.0701344683766365,
-0.29695117473602295,
0.13934455811977386,
0.45672744512557983,
0.726362407207489,
-0.3123045563697815,
0.7046866416931152,
0.2679392695426941,
-0.35731735825538635,
-0.5482013821601868,
-0.5219001770019531,
0.08055287599563599,
-0.521826446056366,
0.7555856108665466,
-1.0196666717529297,
-1.001404881477356,
0.7027913331985474,
-0.22564375400543213,
0.4548519551753998,
0.08815530687570572,
0.951246976852417,
0.06044115126132965,
0.6565369963645935,
1.131087303161621,
-0.1008666455745697,
0.794472336769104,
0.149039164185524,
0.17024503648281097,
-0.8184153437614441,
0.12974731624126434,
-0.3683643639087677,
-0.3857022523880005,
-0.8231580853462219,
-0.5220692753791809,
0.1353965848684311,
0.10453755408525467,
-0.020260794088244438,
0.6294971108436584,
-0.22526752948760986,
0.3620555102825165,
0.20150096714496613,
-0.10418807715177536,
0.41383323073387146,
0.16709470748901367,
-0.37652647495269775,
0.19465787708759308,
-1.0128411054611206,
-0.5654680728912354,
1.256750464439392,
0.3341629207134247,
0.8898003101348877,
0.4948621690273285,
0.5752048492431641,
0.020055074244737625,
0.47229504585266113,
-0.6567161083221436,
0.456172376871109,
-0.5650011301040649,
-0.4969378113746643,
-0.20013730227947235,
-0.264394074678421,
-0.9994040727615356,
0.4557708501815796,
0.05577373504638672,
-0.4577504098415375,
0.1585933119058609,
-0.06167646870017052,
-0.16075296700000763,
0.19068659842014313,
-0.7892225384712219,
0.6087365746498108,
-0.5442401170730591,
-0.2655085027217865,
-0.26601338386535645,
-0.019594790413975716,
0.033426433801651,
-0.4824123978614807,
0.5892719626426697,
-0.09683436155319214,
-0.17086422443389893,
0.5323477387428284,
0.01507706567645073,
0.6811597943305969,
0.11717415601015091,
-0.25267720222473145,
0.1923462301492691,
0.0659356340765953,
0.5291296243667603,
0.016948653385043144,
-0.47553664445877075,
-0.0357801653444767,
-0.2911171019077301,
-0.48051363229751587,
-0.46069028973579407,
0.8076508641242981,
-0.8382806181907654,
-0.8749279379844666,
0.10091491043567657,
-0.7650966644287109,
-0.29455605149269104,
0.23349152505397797,
0.06519016623497009,
0.2901037931442261,
-0.41069936752319336,
0.1188475489616394,
0.40803733468055725,
-0.2486436367034912,
0.5196593999862671,
0.9515266418457031,
-0.48643216490745544,
-0.13239970803260803,
0.7821199297904968,
0.2936144769191742,
0.41255587339401245,
0.4162524938583374,
0.30094918608665466,
-0.1049044281244278,
-0.905292272567749,
-0.5837770104408264,
0.126959428191185,
-0.7195943593978882,
0.06627233326435089,
-0.2797013223171234,
-0.16696086525917053,
-0.20418937504291534,
-0.36626794934272766,
-0.4518156349658966,
-0.33955031633377075,
-0.5207436680793762,
-0.07620573043823242,
0.27529376745224,
0.47627827525138855,
-0.0695592537522316,
-0.057012297213077545,
-0.5685791969299316,
0.30577772855758667,
0.2767294645309448,
0.5382147431373596,
-0.0751044824719429,
-0.9554195404052734,
-0.5056738257408142,
-0.09857290983200073,
0.1702837347984314,
-0.6076505184173584,
0.0493793748319149,
0.25237029790878296,
0.7967807054519653,
-0.08490387350320816,
-0.12506340444087982,
0.6723846197128296,
-0.7942088842391968,
0.534059464931488,
0.11538908630609512,
-0.5611839890480042,
0.307573139667511,
-0.19705335795879364,
0.6260581612586975,
0.42818889021873474,
0.1570814847946167,
-0.49720922112464905,
-0.12475394457578659,
0.006773585453629494,
-0.6806166768074036,
0.420864462852478,
-0.03400028869509697,
0.42071738839149475,
0.00926332175731659,
0.4935867488384247,
0.2711239159107208,
0.0017023541731759906,
-0.6662222146987915,
-0.22523795068264008,
0.1380854994058609,
0.0011224317131564021,
-0.27341023087501526,
-0.20372360944747925,
0.11765231937170029,
-0.013419019989669323,
0.4039953351020813,
-0.36454930901527405,
0.11736322194337845,
-0.06267348676919937,
-0.43174368143081665,
-0.08049636334180832,
0.45648613572120667,
0.5086814761161804,
0.8385939598083496,
0.003766251727938652,
0.14366692304611206,
0.603472888469696,
0.015009630471467972,
0.2547111511230469,
-0.08332709968090057,
0.0009884994942694902,
0.08752820640802383,
0.39893439412117004,
1.005081057548523,
0.1734975278377533,
-0.6619254350662231,
0.013633896596729755,
-0.05174354836344719,
-0.05408748984336853,
-0.09591666609048843,
0.186597540974617,
0.45454904437065125,
0.35046616196632385,
0.1867116540670395,
-0.15514005720615387,
-0.14818459749221802,
-0.7262312173843384,
-0.012152907438576221,
0.6145981550216675,
0.05641883984208107,
-0.5012950897216797,
0.2788892686367035,
0.30244219303131104,
-0.6940739750862122,
0.10462679713964462,
-0.10276049375534058,
-0.27307483553886414,
0.48916399478912354,
0.7522786259651184,
0.8860488533973694,
-0.28787559270858765,
0.03672514483332634,
0.1465996503829956,
0.4648066759109497,
-0.09564697742462158,
0.5085539817810059,
0.05829364061355591,
-0.936740517616272,
-0.8073718547821045,
-0.7642431855201721,
-0.25913241505622864,
-0.022637244313955307,
-0.3857935965061188,
0.4660288095474243,
-0.5063409805297852,
-0.23509520292282104,
-0.3186586797237396,
0.04150674119591713,
-0.8987021446228027,
0.08395513892173767,
0.39273715019226074,
1.2455641031265259,
-0.6600192189216614,
0.6367810964584351,
1.0648914575576782,
0.09394178539514542,
-0.5010108947753906,
-0.3972848355770111,
-0.17634309828281403,
-0.9213436841964722,
0.33529427647590637,
-0.33072030544281006,
-0.3317456543445587,
-0.12953609228134155,
-0.19196286797523499,
-1.013933539390564,
0.9474432468414307,
0.582290530204773,
-0.7520090937614441,
-0.06182447820901871,
0.43486303091049194,
0.6160975694656372,
-0.5279276371002197,
0.000024175951693905517,
0.4042492210865021,
0.3213368058204651,
-0.1472218781709671,
-1.1814944744110107,
0.023212313652038574,
-0.2017906755208969,
0.3002093434333801,
0.23602378368377686,
-0.8930559754371643,
0.6320386528968811,
-0.3152576684951782,
-0.19253745675086975,
0.2667870819568634,
0.5050362348556519,
0.30985090136528015,
-0.21067628264427185,
0.47207075357437134,
0.38613614439964294,
0.605925440788269,
0.3164447844028473,
0.9475643038749695,
-0.6746163964271545,
0.16397440433502197,
1.1477582454681396,
-0.1700192391872406,
0.9095711708068848,
0.527732253074646,
-0.09600513428449631,
0.3372182250022888,
0.6726176738739014,
0.24067246913909912,
0.5318010449409485,
0.4744355380535126,
-0.19059474766254425,
-0.30102866888046265,
-0.316316157579422,
-0.3360983431339264,
0.600444495677948,
0.332366943359375,
-0.23947933316230774,
-0.16567644476890564,
-0.021500663831830025,
0.013504695147275925,
-0.26166871190071106,
-0.3248576521873474,
0.5802204608917236,
0.17682421207427979,
-0.6971327662467957,
0.6698490977287292,
0.30210763216018677,
0.7506593465805054,
-0.5864132046699524,
0.4883718192577362,
-0.4558781087398529,
0.13024283945560455,
-0.1343998908996582,
-0.6185980439186096,
0.10833200067281723,
0.11139768362045288,
-0.357647180557251,
-0.4073781371116638,
0.7240633964538574,
-0.42865532636642456,
-0.6818823218345642,
0.5804303884506226,
0.8535890579223633,
-0.009173017926514149,
0.16369043290615082,
-0.5008851289749146,
0.4641434848308563,
0.1736672818660736,
-0.39769431948661804,
0.585289478302002,
0.5145519375801086,
-0.07457751780748367,
0.5158320665359497,
0.827585756778717,
0.30580565333366394,
0.05056317523121834,
0.20626802742481232,
0.871694028377533,
-0.5560200810432434,
-0.33674660325050354,
-0.7986815571784973,
0.4576972424983978,
0.2505597174167633,
-0.319621205329895,
0.7436586022377014,
0.6437705159187317,
1.04915452003479,
-0.06406340003013611,
0.8541923761367798,
0.242128387093544,
0.09376765042543411,
-0.5483971238136292,
0.4662904441356659,
-0.8066446781158447,
0.41102465987205505,
-0.24950489401817322,
-1.0718227624893188,
-0.22066402435302734,
0.3802703022956848,
0.0017268388764932752,
-0.004626762121915817,
0.6078416705131531,
0.7481952905654907,
-0.022775985300540924,
-0.16751565039157867,
0.5644749999046326,
0.2644529938697815,
0.3902285099029541,
0.7118638157844543,
0.6719285845756531,
-0.05585012212395668,
0.4489434063434601,
-0.1248055249452591,
-0.4318423867225647,
-0.2046535611152649,
-1.0621739625930786,
-0.9562464356422424,
-0.27162662148475647,
-0.3268164098262787,
0.13951800763607025,
0.14461462199687958,
0.8531897664070129,
0.7495036721229553,
-0.7488672733306885,
-0.726940393447876,
0.07451082766056061,
0.24106641113758087,
0.07388491183519363,
-0.09932329505681992,
0.19443091750144958,
-0.5174983739852905,
-0.6563994884490967,
0.5244669914245605,
0.47714290022850037,
-0.03829364478588104,
-0.09623652696609497,
-0.2878688871860504,
0.0388348288834095,
0.2614210546016693,
0.8991680145263672,
0.16047678887844086,
-0.694027304649353,
-0.4060063064098358,
0.38828331232070923,
0.004206400830298662,
0.16284456849098206,
0.9298462867736816,
-0.5085397958755493,
0.4843626916408539,
0.5405389070510864,
0.801667332649231,
0.2979848086833954,
-0.34063521027565,
0.7182797193527222,
-0.5097153782844543,
0.20069573819637299,
-0.058839600533246994,
0.5858506560325623,
0.22555062174797058,
0.019819987937808037,
0.4495372474193573,
-0.08650919049978256,
-0.3551270067691803,
-0.7888487577438354,
0.46548429131507874,
-0.524142861366272,
-0.6158244013786316,
1.3918540477752686,
0.03407768905162811,
-0.019900700077414513,
-0.12003166973590851,
-0.12917986512184143,
0.060113757848739624,
-0.006775540765374899,
0.603083610534668,
1.0522156953811646,
-0.2630222737789154,
-0.1352536678314209,
-0.4390244781970978,
0.2319502979516983,
0.562729001045227,
-0.5456085801124573,
0.07098927348852158,
0.1309463083744049,
0.5610843896865845,
0.14343778789043427,
0.6630718111991882,
0.11612337827682495,
0.31641849875450134,
-0.28486448526382446,
-0.07962149381637573,
0.07706101983785629,
-0.4438917636871338,
-0.3829467296600342,
0.16125069558620453,
0.783250629901886,
-0.03509866073727608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15513v1 | PKU-SafeRLHF: A Safety Alignment Preference Dataset for Llama Family Models | 2024-06-20T18:37:36 | 2024-06-20T18:37:36 | Jiaming Ji, Donghai Hong, Borong Zhang, Boyuan Chen, Josef Dai, Boren Zheng, Tianyi Qiu, Boxun Li, Yaodong Yang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | In this work, we introduce the PKU-SafeRLHF dataset, designed to promote
research on safety alignment in large language models (LLMs). As a sibling
project to SafeRLHF and BeaverTails, we separate annotations of helpfulness and
harmlessness for question-answering pairs, providing distinct perspectives on
these coupled attributes. Overall, we provide 44.6k refined prompts and 265k
question-answer pairs with safety meta-labels for 19 harm categories and three
severity levels ranging from minor to severe, with answers generated by
Llama-family models. Based on this, we collected 166.8k preference data,
including dual-preference (helpfulness and harmlessness decoupled) and
single-preference data (trade-off the helpfulness and harmlessness from
scratch), respectively. Using the large-scale annotation data, we further train
severity-sensitive moderation for the risk control of LLMs and safety-centric
RLHF algorithms for the safety alignment of LLMs. We believe this dataset will
be a valuable resource for the community, aiding in the safe deployment of
LLMs. | [
-0.12056244164705276,
-0.6214587688446045,
0.25294730067253113,
0.16659432649612427,
-0.2676531672477722,
-0.0785701796412468,
0.053667496889829636,
-0.5767307877540588,
0.16167083382606506,
0.5657169222831726,
-0.38829153776168823,
-0.5711954236030579,
-0.6188187599182129,
-0.042060185223817825,
-0.1736602783203125,
1.312946081161499,
0.03687950223684311,
-0.31779947876930237,
-0.06563342362642288,
0.039889805018901825,
-0.32425203919410706,
-0.7518282532691956,
-0.46243178844451904,
-0.02170746959745884,
1.2150611877441406,
0.5306746959686279,
1.1810698509216309,
1.0162333250045776,
0.9176887273788452,
0.06804534047842026,
-0.10640612989664078,
-0.18986985087394714,
-0.4514663517475128,
0.27601420879364014,
-0.0787898525595665,
-0.1574450582265854,
-0.8146656155586243,
-0.21642781794071198,
0.32056108117103577,
0.640659749507904,
-0.34351053833961487,
0.16750003397464752,
0.059854280203580856,
0.46493202447891235,
-0.7368323802947998,
0.09455964714288712,
-0.555885910987854,
0.08973883092403412,
-0.20530171692371368,
-0.1597762554883957,
-0.3607323169708252,
-0.7172439694404602,
0.2724299430847168,
-0.5941693186759949,
-0.22150877118110657,
0.2738332748413086,
0.8055744767189026,
0.4154524505138397,
-0.7180090546607971,
-0.0652390867471695,
-0.1217874065041542,
0.7581093907356262,
-0.5961633920669556,
0.053288642317056656,
0.6312947273254395,
0.12483575940132141,
-0.4662039279937744,
-0.2941439747810364,
-0.30697160959243774,
0.11752989888191223,
-0.23674505949020386,
-0.1305832415819168,
0.051111895591020584,
0.22300727665424347,
-0.008337568491697311,
0.25132399797439575,
-0.7046456336975098,
0.48043715953826904,
-0.02184377610683441,
-0.6255766749382019,
0.9957149624824524,
0.37151485681533813,
0.3970845639705658,
-0.35017725825309753,
-0.45780667662620544,
-0.2826318144798279,
-1.1519097089767456,
0.12573421001434326,
0.5419671535491943,
0.3419027626514435,
-0.3058764338493347,
0.6405236721038818,
-0.3653588891029358,
0.6316941380500793,
-0.2371499389410019,
-0.5040339827537537,
0.4249880909919739,
-0.2976894676685333,
-0.11818406730890274,
0.44767117500305176,
1.0918759107589722,
0.9609369039535522,
0.2771526277065277,
-0.11894246935844421,
-0.053696151822805405,
-0.002812167862430215,
0.15215621888637543,
-0.5544695258140564,
-0.36807548999786377,
0.12618835270404816,
-0.4285436272621155,
-0.842667281627655,
-0.13607969880104065,
-0.9197534918785095,
-0.7505179047584534,
-0.163578599691391,
0.235247403383255,
-0.031355176120996475,
-0.5401216149330139,
0.15718857944011688,
0.2624693512916565,
0.4929770231246948,
0.16047221422195435,
-0.9591806530952454,
-0.09930892288684845,
0.9059429168701172,
0.33444744348526,
-0.1652875393629074,
-0.2565332055091858,
-0.6010915040969849,
0.4189411699771881,
-0.35543718934059143,
0.6293758749961853,
-0.5048800706863403,
-0.40874677896499634,
0.13837748765945435,
0.32081854343414307,
0.04015790671110153,
-0.3597504496574402,
0.9168573021888733,
-0.4785720407962799,
-0.16317437589168549,
-0.47529223561286926,
-0.20638307929039001,
-0.36047089099884033,
0.055867090821266174,
-0.5453053712844849,
0.9205888509750366,
-0.07091905176639557,
-1.1315865516662598,
0.48658227920532227,
-0.24966900050640106,
-0.5454739928245544,
-0.1820279359817505,
0.029851514846086502,
-0.5902378559112549,
-0.4491463899612427,
0.22982050478458405,
0.607888400554657,
-0.14221344888210297,
0.6063745617866516,
-0.8266145586967468,
-0.06598852574825287,
0.3416258692741394,
-0.48100653290748596,
0.8760248422622681,
0.11851207166910172,
-0.0660758763551712,
0.35539621114730835,
-0.5812037587165833,
-0.2987608015537262,
0.19811655580997467,
-0.5586711168289185,
-0.3568255603313446,
-0.07072636485099792,
0.1521558314561844,
0.31177982687950134,
0.5340481400489807,
-0.5015740394592285,
0.05849805846810341,
-0.11602195352315903,
0.19404631853103638,
0.9192957282066345,
0.16024260222911835,
0.28827300667762756,
-0.5746209025382996,
0.395219624042511,
0.14396372437477112,
0.7085404992103577,
0.09373806416988373,
-0.6568610668182373,
-0.5776209831237793,
-0.15297825634479523,
0.25304219126701355,
0.7025043964385986,
-0.2909907102584839,
0.8556816577911377,
-0.22100116312503815,
-0.2809339761734009,
-0.45319420099258423,
0.2633698284626007,
0.5394439697265625,
0.8707101345062256,
0.13205638527870178,
-0.16073155403137207,
-0.48709720373153687,
-1.318175196647644,
0.3290039300918579,
-0.5094121694564819,
0.21025176346302032,
0.09612403810024261,
0.12348932772874832,
-0.162541925907135,
0.7812302112579346,
-0.5750711560249329,
0.18555906414985657,
0.14698518812656403,
-0.19724734127521515,
0.011287863366305828,
0.5743246078491211,
0.4639044404029846,
-0.7261254191398621,
-0.2617555558681488,
-0.13836409151554108,
-0.707366406917572,
-0.029019132256507874,
0.3548060953617096,
-0.6174287796020508,
0.28153324127197266,
0.19934700429439545,
-0.5276479721069336,
0.24961739778518677,
0.5801738500595093,
-0.3189548850059509,
0.20232175290584564,
0.16521897912025452,
-0.005529685877263546,
-1.2081035375595093,
0.1416943520307541,
-0.0823589414358139,
-0.2111569494009018,
-0.5701929330825806,
0.13748426735401154,
0.171377494931221,
0.38027048110961914,
-0.6740949749946594,
0.23003068566322327,
0.07590974867343903,
0.015533325262367725,
0.07593178004026413,
0.08105949312448502,
-0.2671207785606384,
0.33363163471221924,
0.11947446316480637,
0.8053440451622009,
0.704235315322876,
-0.42053648829460144,
0.38664111495018005,
0.417118102312088,
-0.1389334350824356,
0.2581964433193207,
-0.4638012647628784,
0.3023354113101959,
-0.0859343633055687,
0.1777583509683609,
-0.765815794467926,
-0.7784990668296814,
0.6376166939735413,
-0.18030057847499847,
0.2200184017419815,
-0.21191394329071045,
-0.5771844983100891,
-0.06735650449991226,
-0.6653855443000793,
0.39077824354171753,
0.4501679837703705,
-0.4688296616077423,
0.19286297261714935,
0.9530124068260193,
-0.6185764074325562,
-1.101700782775879,
-0.49935758113861084,
-0.00582166900858283,
-0.644914984703064,
-0.6546193957328796,
-0.11835423856973648,
-0.06535478681325912,
-0.2745376527309418,
-0.012742088176310062,
0.018427617847919464,
0.07269342243671417,
0.3405400812625885,
0.6076868772506714,
0.7511725425720215,
-0.12849655747413635,
0.12648586928844452,
0.10768409818410873,
-0.32036590576171875,
0.0395641103386879,
0.4529861807823181,
0.25127530097961426,
-0.14928923547267914,
-0.040155332535505295,
-0.18102164566516876,
0.37926170229911804,
0.3059312105178833,
-0.12957805395126343,
0.8147599101066589,
0.14458809792995453,
-0.41227155923843384,
0.3764151930809021,
-0.42763227224349976,
-0.11288262158632278,
-0.41313210129737854,
0.12653560936450958,
0.10193045437335968,
-1.2534955739974976,
0.2660348117351532,
0.3662334680557251,
0.4857080280780792,
0.456223726272583,
0.3312056064605713,
-0.3448781371116638,
1.0257636308670044,
0.5529018044471741,
-0.5522964000701904,
0.07317668944597244,
0.4130578637123108,
0.29718348383903503,
-0.7194969058036804,
-0.26804134249687195,
-0.42776182293891907,
-0.2669593095779419,
-0.605420708656311,
-0.11201367527246475,
0.3973192572593689,
0.22381025552749634,
-0.6514394283294678,
0.3389750123023987,
-0.4577593207359314,
0.40247246623039246,
0.40620896220207214,
0.1429244726896286,
0.4195892810821533,
0.0304682869464159,
0.08866535127162933,
0.03634065389633179,
-0.4645421802997589,
-0.7945680618286133,
1.4211640357971191,
0.6166256666183472,
0.9067776799201965,
0.29699352383613586,
0.6805917620658875,
-0.13434892892837524,
0.4213852882385254,
-0.8059353232383728,
0.682352602481842,
-0.1353529393672943,
-0.7472876310348511,
-0.3852406442165375,
-0.3937419652938843,
-0.8981925845146179,
-0.11782269179821014,
-0.3082159161567688,
-0.7362515926361084,
-0.06349073350429535,
0.2824231684207916,
-0.6505507826805115,
0.12308771163225174,
-0.6382091045379639,
0.661470353603363,
-0.46831583976745605,
-0.196417897939682,
-0.14136140048503876,
-1.1285938024520874,
0.7005658745765686,
-0.30945122241973877,
0.18511632084846497,
-0.4931793212890625,
-0.2728133797645569,
0.8828646540641785,
-0.08281833678483963,
0.9135459065437317,
0.1187770888209343,
-0.4758381247520447,
0.23123718798160553,
0.05768294632434845,
0.3515068292617798,
0.1682865470647812,
-0.2379167377948761,
0.14812467992305756,
0.13980582356452942,
-0.13417194783687592,
-0.10739590972661972,
0.9118772149085999,
-0.7603513598442078,
-0.7552695870399475,
-0.5953285098075867,
-0.7549320459365845,
-0.3506661355495453,
0.20341616868972778,
-0.07895641028881073,
0.1850948929786682,
0.24477028846740723,
0.450162410736084,
0.9378749132156372,
-0.3568103313446045,
0.5961960554122925,
0.39315932989120483,
-0.3354169726371765,
-0.5219828486442566,
0.6962509155273438,
-0.06175655126571655,
0.1398114413022995,
0.4403778910636902,
0.16731879115104675,
-0.5753955841064453,
-0.4079114496707916,
-0.4347204267978668,
0.23321330547332764,
-0.9674456715583801,
-0.4423861801624298,
-0.5793885588645935,
-0.27999213337898254,
-0.23528151214122772,
-0.10052228718996048,
-0.01819620281457901,
-0.5491452813148499,
-0.09184686094522476,
-0.5433147549629211,
0.7937986254692078,
0.6563205122947693,
-0.06122901663184166,
0.12408843636512756,
-0.8480731248855591,
0.15931524336338043,
0.2961632311344147,
0.4713130295276642,
-0.3252306282520294,
-0.15799644589424133,
0.21093593537807465,
-0.2045654058456421,
-0.21234948933124542,
-0.6711863279342651,
-0.026091966778039932,
-0.18313540518283844,
0.4914111793041229,
0.4217652976512909,
0.5633906722068787,
0.3819229006767273,
-0.12172450870275497,
0.7286116480827332,
0.2927667796611786,
-0.3005293905735016,
0.48715031147003174,
-0.746263325214386,
-0.2638540267944336,
0.7963099479675293,
0.48256996273994446,
-0.46437758207321167,
-0.03455645963549614,
-0.2679626941680908,
-0.9025287628173828,
0.5871332287788391,
0.010796165093779564,
0.09092596918344498,
0.1424093395471573,
0.32139137387275696,
0.27781450748443604,
0.07686803489923477,
-0.7084450721740723,
-0.30282169580459595,
0.11603181064128876,
-0.6542162299156189,
0.00980102177709341,
-0.4347873032093048,
-0.6043456792831421,
-0.11275602132081985,
0.7967267632484436,
-0.15222077071666718,
-0.12699058651924133,
-0.239151269197464,
0.12396937608718872,
-0.43449318408966064,
0.3404695391654968,
0.3003588616847992,
0.28775525093078613,
-0.32986342906951904,
0.40543219447135925,
0.15473422408103943,
-0.5797156691551208,
0.2901879549026489,
0.12381310015916824,
-0.22863604128360748,
-0.6605049967765808,
0.3119184672832489,
0.4806092381477356,
0.2811371982097626,
-0.63662189245224,
0.47909781336784363,
-0.14804433286190033,
-0.07746881246566772,
-0.043180353939533234,
0.40540120005607605,
0.3880225718021393,
-0.27137598395347595,
0.0023241168819367886,
-0.20670045912265778,
0.013486306183040142,
-0.1313077211380005,
0.21855528652668,
0.4340270459651947,
-0.1521400660276413,
0.0017902282997965813,
0.35257837176322937,
0.2768474519252777,
-0.1810671091079712,
0.4114905595779419,
0.1997077614068985,
-0.28039413690567017,
0.525416374206543,
0.13512945175170898,
0.6886898279190063,
-0.16741898655891418,
0.08882836252450943,
0.4220087230205536,
0.38777801394462585,
0.04558441415429115,
0.2747414708137512,
0.10354770720005035,
-0.5705453753471375,
-0.0792870968580246,
-0.8394656181335449,
-0.37262222170829773,
0.4287421703338623,
-0.5498728156089783,
0.266945481300354,
-0.6006631851196289,
-0.20708519220352173,
-0.256512850522995,
-0.23657171428203583,
-0.16203708946704865,
0.1387333869934082,
0.017069678753614426,
0.6477464437484741,
-0.790012001991272,
0.795076847076416,
0.7309063673019409,
-0.36084356904029846,
-1.220322847366333,
0.3127678334712982,
0.15769101679325104,
-0.6588109135627747,
0.30759814381599426,
0.23382623493671417,
-0.15753763914108276,
-0.27740493416786194,
-0.4847295880317688,
-1.0723625421524048,
1.182162880897522,
0.5280095338821411,
-0.8753094673156738,
-0.00985238142311573,
0.30085334181785583,
0.19223888218402863,
0.03324299678206444,
-0.2943795919418335,
0.6774016618728638,
0.4499458372592926,
-0.057555440813302994,
-1.1476765871047974,
0.15510651469230652,
-0.11467285454273224,
-0.1439024657011032,
0.353634238243103,
-0.8003981113433838,
0.37584179639816284,
-0.061094123870134354,
0.043133702129125595,
0.016484711319208145,
0.37879079580307007,
0.5529199838638306,
0.24041108787059784,
0.6374866366386414,
0.6727959513664246,
0.5216008424758911,
-0.14664283394813538,
0.8336348533630371,
-0.2815653681755066,
0.2033364176750183,
1.021988868713379,
-0.26663434505462646,
1.05866277217865,
0.7350186109542847,
-0.18476727604866028,
0.11354712396860123,
0.9910827875137329,
0.45897260308265686,
0.6294196248054504,
-0.0011615518014878035,
-0.43096256256103516,
-0.4690352976322174,
-0.328840047121048,
-0.5295055508613586,
0.25695928931236267,
0.14017830789089203,
-0.32339802384376526,
-0.14566512405872345,
-0.2730295658111572,
0.33318114280700684,
-0.3388780653476715,
-0.18400372564792633,
0.8293201327323914,
0.15059944987297058,
-0.758492648601532,
0.3231765329837799,
-0.19948668777942657,
0.8374873399734497,
-0.43895384669303894,
0.017714185640215874,
-0.17460568249225616,
-0.03371516615152359,
-0.45826199650764465,
-1.4780863523483276,
0.291472464799881,
0.02294563688337803,
-0.0013545939000323415,
0.011186596006155014,
0.8679977655410767,
-0.23874206840991974,
-0.3920409381389618,
0.2733667492866516,
-0.03660942241549492,
-0.009674731642007828,
0.5300734639167786,
-0.5427961349487305,
0.09882152825593948,
-0.22178664803504944,
-0.24097174406051636,
0.5296083688735962,
-0.041539423167705536,
-0.34210216999053955,
0.6922441124916077,
0.5921914577484131,
-0.13173416256904602,
0.27170518040657043,
-0.07971211522817612,
0.858654797077179,
-0.29161015152931213,
-0.39644521474838257,
-0.5849482417106628,
0.559667706489563,
0.16619479656219482,
-0.3692527711391449,
0.49449342489242554,
0.36983925104141235,
0.6697719693183899,
0.024501023814082146,
0.7801080346107483,
-0.05312379077076912,
0.47049644589424133,
-0.5264021754264832,
0.8859125375747681,
-0.3491990566253662,
0.11861025542020798,
-0.3098224103450775,
-0.6559084057807922,
-0.5927405953407288,
0.6063128709793091,
-0.36683887243270874,
-0.19072744250297546,
0.28189682960510254,
1.2065751552581787,
0.14119787514209747,
0.3097827732563019,
0.08362025767564774,
-0.21014755964279175,
0.23903875052928925,
0.8437902331352234,
1.031963586807251,
-0.2104988396167755,
0.6058385968208313,
-0.7477414011955261,
-0.22049172222614288,
-0.29383718967437744,
-1.293533444404602,
-0.7717778086662292,
-0.446397989988327,
-0.5085822343826294,
-0.14941079914569855,
0.004638985265046358,
1.2023115158081055,
0.5659899711608887,
-0.9548079371452332,
-0.01779061183333397,
-0.0037683765403926373,
0.008767674677073956,
0.18473774194717407,
-0.1527606099843979,
0.47396454215049744,
0.07060603052377701,
-0.1764604151248932,
0.2634291648864746,
0.2953513264656067,
0.1102084368467331,
-0.08651083707809448,
-0.28687983751296997,
-0.06201998516917229,
-0.3338581621646881,
0.4283145070075989,
0.21754933893680573,
-0.687262773513794,
-0.727451741695404,
-0.028865287080407143,
-0.3964272141456604,
0.01786179281771183,
0.42833468317985535,
-0.15197771787643433,
0.124754898250103,
0.5180644392967224,
0.7879981398582458,
-0.2808128595352173,
-0.09625087678432465,
0.4007284343242645,
-0.37831762433052063,
0.05210457369685173,
0.0785859152674675,
0.5120552778244019,
0.6036786437034607,
-0.863085150718689,
0.5377119183540344,
-0.08831661194562912,
-0.6983731389045715,
-0.8436817526817322,
0.23832589387893677,
-1.0452017784118652,
0.15179213881492615,
1.3975893259048462,
-0.1752936691045761,
-0.07280585914850235,
-0.36137112975120544,
-0.5455992817878723,
0.4802818298339844,
-0.5355691313743591,
0.7970277667045593,
0.7786877751350403,
-0.15563470125198364,
-0.29976263642311096,
-0.4015198051929474,
0.612501323223114,
0.5905793905258179,
-0.9796523451805115,
0.34331968426704407,
0.6000328660011292,
0.5705646276473999,
0.04745562747120857,
0.3773289620876312,
-0.35557496547698975,
0.38889026641845703,
-0.45120325684547424,
-0.1810091882944107,
0.012819680385291576,
-0.47553274035453796,
-0.6184566020965576,
0.2185412347316742,
0.42565152049064636,
-0.13930858671665192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14666v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14666v1 | Co-training for Low Resource Scientific Natural Language Inference | 2024-06-20T18:35:47 | 2024-06-20T18:35:47 | Mobashir Sadat, Cornelia Caragea | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scientific Natural Language Inference (NLI) is the task of predicting the
semantic relation between a pair of sentences extracted from research articles.
The automatic annotation method based on distant supervision for the training
set of SciNLI (Sadat and Caragea, 2022b), the first and most popular dataset
for this task, results in label noise which inevitably degenerates the
performance of classifiers. In this paper, we propose a novel co-training
method that assigns weights based on the training dynamics of the classifiers
to the distantly supervised labels, reflective of the manner they are used in
the subsequent training epochs. That is, unlike the existing semi-supervised
learning (SSL) approaches, we consider the historical behavior of the
classifiers to evaluate the quality of the automatically annotated labels.
Furthermore, by assigning importance weights instead of filtering out examples
based on an arbitrary threshold on the predicted confidence, we maximize the
usage of automatically labeled data, while ensuring that the noisy labels have
a minimal impact on model training. The proposed method obtains an improvement
of 1.5% in Macro F1 over the distant supervision baseline, and substantial
improvements over several other strong SSL baselines. We make our code and data
available on Github. | [
-0.2898053228855133,
-0.5428588390350342,
0.13817347586154938,
0.19918759167194366,
-0.24413050711154938,
-0.015393808484077454,
-0.36541905999183655,
-0.7340219616889954,
0.40409135818481445,
0.10596930980682373,
-0.6017801761627197,
-0.5217058658599854,
-0.47097286581993103,
0.3862951397895813,
0.011966702528297901,
1.2275824546813965,
0.07601774483919144,
0.2512931823730469,
-0.31658267974853516,
-0.13729038834571838,
0.1426427960395813,
-0.37067073583602905,
-0.6031480431556702,
-0.23267127573490143,
0.6530164480209351,
0.09438945353031158,
0.5409461855888367,
0.40951964259147644,
0.4626878798007965,
0.2682158052921295,
-0.16983351111412048,
0.27946075797080994,
-0.44036993384361267,
-0.2192433923482895,
-0.06647086888551712,
-0.4689680337905884,
-0.3107859492301941,
0.13948991894721985,
0.4107733368873596,
1.0796570777893066,
0.28665634989738464,
0.24193939566612244,
0.01272476278245449,
0.4029977023601532,
-0.5620243549346924,
0.4596424996852875,
-0.5209581255912781,
0.3431749641895294,
-0.03470000997185707,
-0.25429534912109375,
-0.6656429767608643,
-0.3128684461116791,
0.4181479215621948,
-0.8630872964859009,
0.36428403854370117,
0.3078153431415558,
1.1314070224761963,
0.5741477608680725,
-0.1601622849702835,
-0.34716400504112244,
-0.5784364342689514,
1.2559341192245483,
-0.676457405090332,
0.29225993156433105,
0.5512072443962097,
-0.04268445447087288,
-0.032724667340517044,
-0.4336189031600952,
-0.20489151775836945,
-0.36578866839408875,
-0.3477618098258972,
0.20339588820934296,
0.17952683568000793,
0.12338031083345413,
0.03594148904085159,
0.26033443212509155,
-0.19287586212158203,
0.13732929527759552,
-0.5186291933059692,
-0.22102521359920502,
0.7844013571739197,
-0.33259618282318115,
0.07242502272129059,
-0.10580416768789291,
-0.36903953552246094,
-0.06982412189245224,
-0.3430437743663788,
-0.15990594029426575,
0.2744825780391693,
0.4060821533203125,
-0.3459996283054352,
0.47705933451652527,
-0.23825572431087494,
0.8205389976501465,
0.22169232368469238,
-0.12066613882780075,
0.4173886775970459,
-0.5072625875473022,
-0.1610526293516159,
0.5011398792266846,
0.9837112426757812,
0.23178064823150635,
0.18775808811187744,
-0.4005458950996399,
0.2641921639442444,
-0.13148751854896545,
0.03307110071182251,
-0.6086791157722473,
-0.426179438829422,
-0.12853090465068817,
-0.06794752925634384,
-0.4935033321380615,
-0.00031442800536751747,
-0.7785507440567017,
0.011833928525447845,
-0.4656028747558594,
0.4630841612815857,
-0.36171701550483704,
0.036532677710056305,
-0.28095152974128723,
0.05498727783560753,
-0.38637876510620117,
0.22322914004325867,
-1.0702457427978516,
0.2986914813518524,
0.49350056052207947,
0.9972655773162842,
-0.03467119485139847,
-0.12982535362243652,
-0.7082825899124146,
0.3554180860519409,
-0.07604440301656723,
0.5054897665977478,
-0.568320631980896,
0.05184444785118103,
-0.34206175804138184,
-0.16433373093605042,
-0.2348202019929886,
-0.2710939347743988,
0.4791902005672455,
-0.7349741458892822,
0.3007984459400177,
0.08280785381793976,
-0.5992364883422852,
-0.09914536029100418,
-0.01545571256428957,
-0.8096243143081665,
1.196601390838623,
0.09080331772565842,
-1.1083924770355225,
0.5798678398132324,
-0.7945658564567566,
-0.42160874605178833,
0.002511745085939765,
-0.04280267283320427,
-0.8125879764556885,
-0.22879867255687714,
0.11632292717695236,
0.4027470648288727,
-0.0003914629342034459,
0.811872661113739,
-0.6653441190719604,
-0.29805222153663635,
-0.11881205439567566,
-0.14435583353042603,
0.7603834867477417,
0.0961107388138771,
-0.3240847587585449,
-0.027242355048656464,
-0.9980838298797607,
-0.02196015976369381,
-0.315350741147995,
-0.11014708131551743,
-0.9254204034805298,
-0.19429035484790802,
-0.3063824772834778,
-0.060001861304044724,
0.11182539910078049,
-0.5719318389892578,
0.019341476261615753,
-0.810955286026001,
0.3128029704093933,
0.3764131963253021,
0.21841345727443695,
0.6726053953170776,
0.08202823251485825,
0.10807494819164276,
-0.2046445608139038,
0.09656944870948792,
0.42482420802116394,
-0.4104669392108917,
-0.5731176137924194,
-0.6518566608428955,
0.4783119857311249,
0.3373257517814636,
-0.6073350310325623,
0.7751477360725403,
-0.3138735592365265,
-0.4475816488265991,
-0.566981315612793,
0.3349379301071167,
0.2916904389858246,
0.6232855319976807,
0.6495935916900635,
-0.10787415504455566,
-0.8292170763015747,
-0.775617241859436,
-0.11711863428354263,
-0.13861358165740967,
-0.02206757664680481,
0.17746862769126892,
0.6567904949188232,
-0.048478562384843826,
1.219407081604004,
-0.2910948395729065,
-0.2262917011976242,
0.042358290404081345,
0.8099246621131897,
0.15060581266880035,
0.4328700006008148,
0.29464057087898254,
-0.7574055194854736,
-0.42723095417022705,
-0.1949639469385147,
-0.87629234790802,
-0.45482468605041504,
-0.27922073006629944,
-0.3321799039840698,
0.1580209881067276,
0.5118854641914368,
-0.11367006599903107,
0.24583066999912262,
0.7207629084587097,
0.008871583268046379,
0.2632855176925659,
-0.24027767777442932,
-0.21714356541633606,
-1.0294960737228394,
0.15570518374443054,
0.2585035264492035,
-0.12182094156742096,
-0.5727708339691162,
-0.463064581155777,
-0.3188256621360779,
0.15744280815124512,
-0.35445016622543335,
0.45430341362953186,
-0.604823648929596,
0.04694927856326103,
-0.0627363845705986,
0.07921969890594482,
0.0243768859654665,
0.5297189354896545,
0.5825704336166382,
0.5764453411102295,
0.3683672249317169,
-0.6568708419799805,
0.07151605933904648,
0.19886274635791779,
-0.14981552958488464,
0.22756963968276978,
-0.49108755588531494,
-0.05936235934495926,
0.02033831737935543,
0.37757962942123413,
-0.623589038848877,
-0.11791171878576279,
0.3284147381782532,
-0.15773655474185944,
0.30622056126594543,
-0.12142086029052734,
-0.2538442313671112,
-0.21640507876873016,
-0.23021192848682404,
0.32938623428344727,
0.033412497490644455,
-0.6491952538490295,
0.3682742714881897,
0.27429264783859253,
-0.02442646026611328,
-0.525075376033783,
-0.7595446705818176,
0.08041364699602127,
-0.21798890829086304,
-0.5075838565826416,
0.3229243755340576,
0.11077187955379486,
-0.2801099717617035,
0.17200173437595367,
-0.14558324217796326,
-0.2853225767612457,
0.18902087211608887,
0.42381516098976135,
0.30334603786468506,
-0.08613762259483337,
0.22627434134483337,
0.35485854744911194,
-0.20269200205802917,
0.11136923730373383,
-0.3418055772781372,
0.09850897639989853,
-0.26944074034690857,
-0.17051029205322266,
-0.6514642834663391,
0.04776981100440025,
-0.0341743528842926,
-0.026859091594815254,
0.9915251731872559,
0.7535235285758972,
-0.1572188287973404,
-0.1598435640335083,
-0.2967167794704437,
-0.24962091445922852,
-0.41278189420700073,
0.319355309009552,
-0.05890698730945587,
-0.8639246821403503,
-0.04493682086467743,
-0.2764890491962433,
-0.013326900079846382,
0.48213961720466614,
0.3454796373844147,
-0.13195161521434784,
0.4712355136871338,
0.5819626450538635,
-0.14243432879447937,
0.429004043340683,
-0.4073684811592102,
0.2757354974746704,
-0.6542977094650269,
-0.25154033303260803,
-0.423389196395874,
-0.1404271125793457,
-0.42070668935775757,
-0.5384699702262878,
0.3775320053100586,
0.3149695098400116,
-0.16811475157737732,
0.40331128239631653,
-0.4765348732471466,
0.2552069425582886,
0.7602063417434692,
0.13194914162158966,
0.42531177401542664,
0.2546977698802948,
-0.092823326587677,
-0.11390841007232666,
-0.8162240982055664,
-0.5082724094390869,
0.7551899552345276,
0.1550891399383545,
0.7909235954284668,
-0.2316562533378601,
1.1947741508483887,
0.2957267761230469,
0.5902552604675293,
-0.5451807975769043,
0.44100552797317505,
-0.10246215015649796,
-0.49154821038246155,
-0.4788457155227661,
-0.6954334378242493,
-0.7344014048576355,
0.07605540007352829,
-0.19683247804641724,
-0.7591366171836853,
0.16488295793533325,
0.2935723662376404,
-0.4884472191333771,
0.251430869102478,
-0.8912953734397888,
0.7150499820709229,
-0.24708296358585358,
-0.746706485748291,
-0.22737711668014526,
-0.9852887392044067,
0.22505225241184235,
-0.24833838641643524,
0.2735867202281952,
0.036742400377988815,
0.08059748262166977,
1.0160448551177979,
-0.4929560124874115,
1.3614506721496582,
-0.3134658932685852,
-0.014357276260852814,
0.4881233870983124,
-0.26974421739578247,
0.5333646535873413,
0.21006566286087036,
-0.3624553084373474,
0.44276338815689087,
0.08765112608671188,
-0.328204482793808,
-0.3584590554237366,
0.450882226228714,
-0.7813128232955933,
-0.18389520049095154,
-0.558495044708252,
-0.7036952972412109,
-0.03843497857451439,
0.057671189308166504,
0.13945792615413666,
0.16905589401721954,
-0.11134128272533417,
0.01421117503196001,
0.5009335279464722,
-0.16526666283607483,
0.4930446147918701,
0.3314386010169983,
0.32476553320884705,
-0.5316615104675293,
0.8846567273139954,
0.02680138126015663,
0.39534762501716614,
0.7501227855682373,
0.2528836131095886,
-0.1366659253835678,
-0.3877505362033844,
-0.27881500124931335,
0.2742154598236084,
-0.32712796330451965,
-0.13675983250141144,
-0.9058499932289124,
-0.239046111702919,
-0.21464894711971283,
-0.310260146856308,
-0.4027770161628723,
-0.41467589139938354,
-0.5377975702285767,
-0.020760301500558853,
0.5813566446304321,
0.38157519698143005,
-0.2562331259250641,
0.23933787643909454,
-0.686618447303772,
0.306491494178772,
0.17409853637218475,
0.24824228882789612,
-0.2157144695520401,
-0.4987351596355438,
-0.49765610694885254,
0.10531383007764816,
0.11941400915384293,
-0.5042567849159241,
0.41590359807014465,
0.6691172122955322,
0.2572147250175476,
0.28350064158439636,
0.38528940081596375,
0.8429117202758789,
-0.31906619668006897,
0.5460431575775146,
0.2071961909532547,
-0.7653939127922058,
0.4784295856952667,
0.06882081925868988,
0.05326540395617485,
0.9374299645423889,
0.5510931611061096,
-0.11857318878173828,
-0.7595934867858887,
-0.5303491950035095,
-0.948617696762085,
0.7673546671867371,
0.19282378256320953,
-0.14418137073516846,
0.04796292260289192,
0.3390573561191559,
0.2930891811847687,
0.15635228157043457,
-0.807732343673706,
-0.02311839535832405,
-0.09004928171634674,
-0.55460125207901,
0.11102964729070663,
-0.016704777255654335,
-0.11422022432088852,
-0.4019308388233185,
1.028449296951294,
-0.4193972647190094,
0.10294526815414429,
0.4060865342617035,
-0.3338187336921692,
-0.28959521651268005,
0.1916024386882782,
0.31225988268852234,
0.27612847089767456,
-0.5176272988319397,
0.33560824394226074,
0.4487900733947754,
-0.4473346769809723,
-0.029342705383896828,
0.348534494638443,
-0.4572965204715729,
0.062371738255023956,
0.5555074214935303,
0.9539179801940918,
0.5069767832756042,
-0.4486243426799774,
0.35650357604026794,
0.09417203813791275,
-0.16529685258865356,
-0.36397993564605713,
0.040604304522275925,
-0.008431370370090008,
0.2556680738925934,
0.22988173365592957,
0.31916332244873047,
0.08478284627199173,
-0.18033194541931152,
0.488649845123291,
0.33423614501953125,
-0.5520496368408203,
-0.5464392900466919,
0.7342275381088257,
0.2169727087020874,
0.009934932924807072,
0.2690785229206085,
-0.5689151287078857,
-0.36140334606170654,
0.45051494240760803,
0.38712912797927856,
0.5598447918891907,
0.09118097275495529,
0.336276650428772,
0.6707043647766113,
0.17442747950553894,
-0.1816834956407547,
-0.19610457122325897,
-0.23920361697673798,
-0.39863067865371704,
-0.8249107003211975,
-0.9806219339370728,
-0.4989722669124603,
-0.13676971197128296,
-0.765583336353302,
0.33484143018722534,
-0.22301185131072998,
-0.03871247544884682,
0.14728374779224396,
0.29022109508514404,
-0.37909090518951416,
0.336202472448349,
0.3866502046585083,
0.5731041431427002,
-1.2069069147109985,
0.949561595916748,
0.5652056336402893,
-0.2187804877758026,
-0.5137850642204285,
-0.08993203938007355,
-0.045159805566072464,
-0.4680630564689636,
1.1366437673568726,
0.21455585956573486,
-0.3352697789669037,
0.10708042234182358,
-0.6247320771217346,
-0.9826863408088684,
0.9870099425315857,
0.31775474548339844,
-0.8123318552970886,
-0.07610710710287094,
0.06288221478462219,
0.8920098543167114,
-0.1802118420600891,
0.33649665117263794,
0.14718110859394073,
0.4249972105026245,
0.1456359326839447,
-0.71937495470047,
-0.05602256581187248,
-0.20707638561725616,
-0.2874724864959717,
0.054460231214761734,
-0.7503350973129272,
0.2278217226266861,
-0.39611464738845825,
-0.07534433156251907,
0.14089170098304749,
1.1246941089630127,
0.29710903763771057,
0.7121483087539673,
0.6653424501419067,
0.6391351819038391,
0.9413183927536011,
0.027612844482064247,
0.6634638905525208,
-0.30812010169029236,
0.5847811102867126,
1.540307879447937,
-0.2870944142341614,
0.6403456926345825,
0.7298896908760071,
-0.1776506006717682,
0.3974760174751282,
0.6400893330574036,
-0.523455023765564,
0.674656093120575,
0.2777841091156006,
-0.40985581278800964,
-0.10893011093139648,
-0.43256545066833496,
-0.09027718752622604,
0.007787449285387993,
0.08705108612775803,
-0.4620872437953949,
-0.24969147145748138,
0.06811915338039398,
0.0900554433465004,
-0.01145131140947342,
0.030171120539307594,
0.718373715877533,
0.1940789669752121,
-0.502841055393219,
0.6003507971763611,
-0.23378482460975647,
0.7697537541389465,
-0.5923963785171509,
0.06761668622493744,
0.15959011018276215,
0.008952846750617027,
-0.3486102223396301,
-0.27928826212882996,
0.4875914752483368,
0.13594673573970795,
-0.07566531747579575,
-0.17312124371528625,
0.3194645643234253,
-0.7289114594459534,
-0.6588495373725891,
0.46975091099739075,
0.034990791231393814,
0.25871795415878296,
0.38506224751472473,
-0.586742103099823,
-0.14460130035877228,
-0.08349931985139847,
-0.29887378215789795,
0.12052901834249496,
0.34810903668403625,
-0.20021885633468628,
0.48585328459739685,
0.4946999251842499,
0.2342853844165802,
0.24879449605941772,
0.28617382049560547,
0.7450095415115356,
-0.41128093004226685,
-0.22190351784229279,
-0.6937168836593628,
0.08794186264276505,
-0.27209389209747314,
-0.06359448283910751,
0.6848199963569641,
0.7257976531982422,
0.8204018473625183,
0.0095383170992136,
0.6664370894432068,
-0.35612764954566956,
0.33193138241767883,
-0.43075430393218994,
0.6025700569152832,
-0.3245670795440674,
0.19052408635616302,
-0.3053436577320099,
-0.5334963798522949,
-0.6821494698524475,
0.5680172443389893,
-0.7410465478897095,
-0.09265739470720291,
0.7061266303062439,
0.8118429780006409,
-0.059564631432294846,
0.3254396617412567,
-0.08640380948781967,
0.2918868362903595,
0.09064874798059464,
0.44825154542922974,
0.4693945348262787,
-0.4332215189933777,
0.4723822772502899,
-0.8121682405471802,
-0.0840272530913353,
-0.12448159605264664,
-0.9465593099594116,
-1.0577114820480347,
-0.3208009898662567,
-0.88039630651474,
-0.1253279149532318,
0.2368779331445694,
1.1109014749526978,
0.9532607793807983,
-1.0955709218978882,
0.08968028426170349,
-0.40561002492904663,
-0.1463475525379181,
-0.3776966631412506,
-0.22061799466609955,
0.7229083180427551,
-0.4685739576816559,
-0.7821084260940552,
0.42172476649284363,
0.18599289655685425,
-0.0630195140838623,
-0.03071584738790989,
-0.1398824006319046,
-0.7344748377799988,
-0.3131347596645355,
0.43690624833106995,
0.26010042428970337,
-0.5287578701972961,
-0.2824214696884155,
-0.4336183965206146,
-0.07996167987585068,
0.12406764179468155,
0.2869917154312134,
-0.6768875122070312,
0.49072781205177307,
0.3295387327671051,
0.6265061497688293,
0.6830529570579529,
0.08055920153856277,
0.3286326825618744,
-0.9665724635124207,
0.4677894413471222,
0.2724496126174927,
-0.08235029131174088,
0.30126953125,
-0.4350576400756836,
0.7443034648895264,
0.43436065316200256,
-0.356958270072937,
-0.7453428506851196,
-0.25531303882598877,
-1.0936864614486694,
0.09178005158901215,
0.9668599367141724,
-0.257051020860672,
-0.6118680834770203,
-0.21603772044181824,
0.02207397297024727,
0.7581951022148132,
-0.45677855610847473,
1.024653434753418,
0.46511197090148926,
-0.06607802212238312,
0.002147860359400511,
-0.5266225337982178,
0.5147584080696106,
0.6309258937835693,
-0.8493127822875977,
-0.1336716264486313,
0.2285890281200409,
0.06714814156293869,
0.43187379837036133,
0.15026067197322845,
0.057025160640478134,
-0.2745719254016876,
-0.20453840494155884,
0.2694889008998871,
-0.049961239099502563,
-0.25575879216194153,
-0.11923184990882874,
0.21647976338863373,
-0.19353508949279785,
0.0029527023434638977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14657v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14657v1 | OpenDebateEvidence: A Massive-Scale Argument Mining and Summarization Dataset | 2024-06-20T18:22:59 | 2024-06-20T18:22:59 | Allen Roush, Yusuf Shabazz, Arvind Balaji, Peter Zhang, Stefano Mezza, Markus Zhang, Sanjay Basu, Sriram Vishwanath, Mehdi Fatemi, Ravid Schwartz-Ziv | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce OpenDebateEvidence, a comprehensive dataset for argument mining
and summarization sourced from the American Competitive Debate community. This
dataset includes over 3.5 million documents with rich metadata, making it one
of the most extensive collections of debate evidence. OpenDebateEvidence
captures the complexity of arguments in high school and college debates,
providing valuable resources for training and evaluation. Our extensive
experiments demonstrate the efficacy of fine-tuning state-of-the-art large
language models for argumentative abstractive summarization across various
methods, models, and datasets. By providing this comprehensive resource, we aim
to advance computational argumentation and support practical applications for
debaters, educators, and researchers. OpenDebateEvidence is publicly available
to support further research and innovation in computational argumentation.
Access it here: https://huggingface.co/datasets/Yusuf5/OpenCaselist | [
-0.5863993763923645,
-0.9008771777153015,
0.2761041522026062,
0.00681173475459218,
-0.2289501577615738,
-0.10605991631746292,
-0.19541731476783752,
0.2375585287809372,
0.1162869930267334,
0.4690709710121155,
-0.17587952315807343,
-0.5804311633110046,
-0.397602915763855,
0.005703654605895281,
-0.22785396873950958,
1.145581603050232,
-0.27641457319259644,
0.09409733861684799,
-0.7263224720954895,
-0.44442057609558105,
-0.22341233491897583,
-0.42696890234947205,
-0.42200401425361633,
-0.18433405458927155,
0.5237616300582886,
0.7837955355644226,
0.4915728271007538,
0.41628962755203247,
0.314498633146286,
0.35445812344551086,
0.009627029299736023,
0.06505444645881653,
-0.6443631649017334,
0.2560194432735443,
-0.7148706912994385,
0.015703339129686356,
-0.4073123633861542,
-0.06922353804111481,
0.6299564838409424,
0.6861686110496521,
-0.19016388058662415,
0.14547163248062134,
-0.29949548840522766,
0.7359628081321716,
-0.9964501261711121,
0.05397589132189751,
-0.6224034428596497,
-0.13853409886360168,
-0.5160679221153259,
-0.09622390568256378,
-0.31825682520866394,
-0.8054123520851135,
0.16420787572860718,
-0.3985598683357239,
0.10242018848657608,
-0.25901466608047485,
0.7745712399482727,
0.08115407079458237,
-0.40537914633750916,
-0.3544536530971527,
-0.6583911180496216,
0.5211585760116577,
-0.6469022631645203,
-0.20393617451190948,
-0.022325877100229263,
0.3449345827102661,
-0.09351237118244171,
-0.9374417066574097,
-0.4447513520717621,
0.3688508868217468,
0.19977135956287384,
0.5059277415275574,
-0.671425461769104,
0.322390615940094,
0.2331252545118332,
0.6546362638473511,
-0.5074682235717773,
0.1817934811115265,
-0.5249072313308716,
0.14933522045612335,
0.665793776512146,
0.3150869607925415,
0.1477590799331665,
-0.10243245214223862,
-0.12674666941165924,
-0.0497564896941185,
-0.521652102470398,
0.05726133659482002,
0.7302573919296265,
0.09571290761232376,
-0.19113828241825104,
0.6737504601478577,
-0.37231069803237915,
0.6630297899246216,
-0.16403883695602417,
0.43569743633270264,
-0.1425086110830307,
-0.26187875866889954,
-0.2555602192878723,
0.403017520904541,
1.0448126792907715,
0.4705688953399658,
0.0875004380941391,
0.1673252433538437,
0.23210930824279785,
-0.02261059172451496,
0.10907873511314392,
-1.1481460332870483,
-0.41181302070617676,
0.5582554936408997,
-0.6158217787742615,
-0.4042089581489563,
0.13480119407176971,
-1.3175530433654785,
-0.6927729845046997,
0.008126821368932724,
0.042802583426237106,
-0.05031990259885788,
-0.3189292848110199,
0.40451499819755554,
-0.5015843510627747,
-0.05594192072749138,
0.34363433718681335,
-0.7220147252082825,
0.4370601773262024,
0.9595507383346558,
1.0336651802062988,
-0.09116186201572418,
0.05724819749593735,
-0.39292383193969727,
-0.0508507639169693,
-0.6178374290466309,
1.3360882997512817,
-0.7657892107963562,
-0.32888224720954895,
0.0873519629240036,
-0.11172577738761902,
-0.047321513295173645,
-0.8509534001350403,
1.1048355102539062,
-0.32361987233161926,
0.3313571512699127,
-0.26742997765541077,
-0.6604084372520447,
-0.19323107600212097,
0.09690208733081818,
-0.8047727346420288,
0.5173900127410889,
-0.19387094676494598,
-1.0038387775421143,
0.16406774520874023,
-1.1492818593978882,
-0.5505450963973999,
0.23445039987564087,
-0.24754969775676727,
-0.3385639488697052,
0.17885571718215942,
0.08079071342945099,
0.27766862511634827,
-0.6621190905570984,
0.2226494699716568,
-0.40498319268226624,
0.014871347695589066,
-0.10813001543283463,
-0.13458853960037231,
0.9524022936820984,
0.19544321298599243,
-0.11398141086101532,
0.3301249146461487,
-0.5674067139625549,
-0.4135967791080475,
0.15206000208854675,
0.06278252601623535,
-0.6923782825469971,
0.3208141028881073,
-0.36242496967315674,
0.06694173067808151,
0.1610855609178543,
-0.9936310648918152,
0.15085767209529877,
-0.5590177178382874,
0.447495698928833,
0.9800602793693542,
0.31264734268188477,
0.006641638930886984,
-0.1175328940153122,
0.516150712966919,
0.18793444335460663,
-0.2696882486343384,
-0.4464077651500702,
-0.4687654674053192,
-0.03466799482703209,
-0.2049923837184906,
0.36839404702186584,
0.4574401378631592,
-0.3682498633861542,
0.0559292808175087,
-0.4931744933128357,
-0.42725205421447754,
-0.4553881287574768,
-0.4168868362903595,
0.1983116865158081,
0.6594448089599609,
0.20008407533168793,
-0.023573653772473335,
-0.7120651006698608,
-0.8289669156074524,
-0.3530372679233551,
-0.16584435105323792,
-0.06438162177801132,
0.5927327871322632,
0.6218726634979248,
0.17149507999420166,
1.053265929222107,
-0.8705936074256897,
-0.19532905519008636,
-0.05522565543651581,
0.523583710193634,
0.24523133039474487,
0.24693173170089722,
0.45548245310783386,
-0.35290610790252686,
-0.2438862919807434,
0.17876972258090973,
-1.0644505023956299,
-0.056667666882276535,
-0.20547567307949066,
-0.27870139479637146,
0.1512257158756256,
0.5364826917648315,
-0.4223954975605011,
0.32836464047431946,
0.14055413007736206,
-0.5208632946014404,
0.6170233488082886,
0.0483628585934639,
0.2189292162656784,
-1.3109257221221924,
0.0005555687821470201,
-0.030859388411045074,
0.2080957442522049,
-0.19329170882701874,
0.13484367728233337,
-0.38603726029396057,
0.011616302654147148,
-0.1291593462228775,
0.6321715712547302,
-0.007022541016340256,
0.3950435221195221,
-0.17065395414829254,
0.36788210272789,
-0.15907759964466095,
-0.11363247781991959,
-0.032189153134822845,
0.7223380208015442,
0.5430325269699097,
-0.1552458256483078,
0.8158184885978699,
0.4352143406867981,
-0.3355552554130554,
0.9628596901893616,
-0.985799252986908,
-0.2245146483182907,
-0.12328546494245529,
0.6157185435295105,
-1.1596903800964355,
-0.5328634977340698,
-0.07835306227207184,
-0.3040843904018402,
-0.22205957770347595,
-0.3370654284954071,
-0.14251752197742462,
-0.5223219990730286,
-0.7271202206611633,
0.45337530970573425,
0.13513346016407013,
-0.8761506676673889,
0.4798504114151001,
0.6622431874275208,
-0.5615724325180054,
-0.519838809967041,
-0.05377228930592537,
0.4167671203613281,
-0.2741394340991974,
-0.6887804865837097,
0.2757716178894043,
-0.15383949875831604,
-0.6476479172706604,
0.1475575864315033,
0.13534335792064667,
-0.16767734289169312,
-0.0781390517950058,
0.499136358499527,
0.23435266315937042,
-0.3978745639324188,
0.16022929549217224,
0.22277790307998657,
0.11130896210670471,
0.5267648100852966,
-0.12199931591749191,
0.2849454879760742,
-0.07880997657775879,
-0.157034233212471,
0.01887870393693447,
0.7023832201957703,
0.5493529438972473,
0.07573329657316208,
0.4204670488834381,
0.03482329845428467,
-0.4204358756542206,
-0.22388887405395508,
-0.26433226466178894,
-0.012254990637302399,
-0.4330146908760071,
0.3170117735862732,
-0.3454135060310364,
-0.7470998764038086,
0.47171550989151,
-0.3093104064464569,
0.8068999648094177,
0.6284302473068237,
0.799951434135437,
0.2931879758834839,
1.0894683599472046,
-0.35475701093673706,
-0.06021665409207344,
-0.05719570070505142,
-0.16793501377105713,
0.14577390253543854,
-0.6642270088195801,
-0.0666191354393959,
-0.7576097846031189,
-0.4269762635231018,
-0.3093332052230835,
-0.281806081533432,
-0.13224440813064575,
-0.22330604493618011,
-0.37351131439208984,
-0.04142841696739197,
-0.4361651539802551,
0.8326300978660583,
0.12459177523851395,
-0.2914055287837982,
0.22309471666812897,
-0.021509595215320587,
-0.21074701845645905,
-0.071321040391922,
-0.4158056974411011,
-0.5437108278274536,
1.139096736907959,
0.20079411566257477,
0.608976423740387,
0.34313368797302246,
0.6357946395874023,
0.42390626668930054,
0.2578466236591339,
-1.0143603086471558,
0.6296988129615784,
-0.3790368139743805,
-0.7029551863670349,
-0.16427618265151978,
-0.6332969069480896,
-1.1305432319641113,
0.233493834733963,
-0.03512798622250557,
-0.6598815321922302,
0.1701652705669403,
0.012591928243637085,
-0.41049277782440186,
0.7362741827964783,
-0.3491465151309967,
1.1538294553756714,
0.24910594522953033,
-0.6521952748298645,
-0.3540622889995575,
-0.2655928134918213,
0.7711643576622009,
0.2125047892332077,
0.19517074525356293,
0.015838652849197388,
0.27385443449020386,
1.0512827634811401,
-0.7290377616882324,
0.4368319809436798,
-0.26900583505630493,
-0.2776345908641815,
0.37768715620040894,
-0.046744804829359055,
0.08372793346643448,
0.13939028978347778,
-0.022082442417740822,
-0.015863200649619102,
-0.13062338531017303,
-0.45507383346557617,
-0.23392446339130402,
1.0371184349060059,
-0.6760993599891663,
-0.5590510964393616,
-0.415848046541214,
-0.21794451773166656,
-0.0482071116566658,
0.038975879549980164,
0.22882495820522308,
0.7886753082275391,
-0.781449019908905,
0.5231286287307739,
0.8941574096679688,
-0.10795331001281738,
0.5739968419075012,
0.20128020644187927,
0.1432524025440216,
-0.8418719172477722,
1.1981040239334106,
0.17000313103199005,
-0.25952765345573425,
0.0010113156167790294,
0.5550065636634827,
-0.41724875569343567,
-0.5542553663253784,
-0.5895547866821289,
0.13295553624629974,
-0.8358475565910339,
-0.3465622365474701,
-0.9408888816833496,
-0.08562244474887848,
-0.48322588205337524,
-0.2490319460630417,
-0.3988589346408844,
-0.9230349063873291,
-0.04027671366930008,
-0.3051905930042267,
0.4287455677986145,
0.8816348314285278,
-0.13808919489383698,
0.02101805992424488,
-0.4814142882823944,
0.34254616498947144,
0.4245895445346832,
0.6204461455345154,
0.10859314352273941,
-0.3862799108028412,
-0.11373897641897202,
-0.25053292512893677,
-0.7166393399238586,
-0.6184775829315186,
-0.15874989330768585,
0.3140626847743988,
0.5232593417167664,
0.8390170335769653,
0.602569580078125,
0.6387787461280823,
-0.3943745791912079,
1.2088358402252197,
0.1350579410791397,
-0.690783679485321,
0.5932282209396362,
-0.45178350806236267,
0.2960037589073181,
0.5114299058914185,
0.5592837929725647,
-0.19598297774791718,
-0.02406606450676918,
-0.7397854328155518,
-1.1314078569412231,
0.6992331147193909,
-0.031419023871421814,
-0.03464910387992859,
-0.2948874235153198,
-0.08761006593704224,
0.16458271443843842,
-0.10761820524930954,
-0.20166827738285065,
-0.07101951539516449,
-0.3718357980251312,
-0.3026464879512787,
0.2897307574748993,
-0.17525100708007812,
-0.7023963332176208,
-0.19213761389255524,
0.6422252655029297,
-0.06436029821634293,
-0.2055390626192093,
0.036845821887254715,
0.16284999251365662,
-0.09396100789308548,
0.3673248589038849,
0.9631304740905762,
0.6274265050888062,
-0.20515358448028564,
0.12294122576713562,
0.10534738004207611,
-0.6813079714775085,
-0.003924103919416666,
0.32841554284095764,
-0.10435450077056885,
0.2904229760169983,
0.33594757318496704,
0.6754653453826904,
0.08892612159252167,
-0.870433509349823,
0.6163960695266724,
-0.4405001103878021,
-0.7476993203163147,
-0.3228507936000824,
-0.2925419211387634,
0.24449275434017181,
0.0169284176081419,
0.16770800948143005,
-0.11471861600875854,
0.4189801514148712,
-0.4624997675418854,
0.17650672793388367,
0.4099646806716919,
-0.38997218012809753,
-0.19151455163955688,
0.8141341209411621,
0.3780566155910492,
0.19075345993041992,
0.233352392911911,
0.35188597440719604,
-0.1016232967376709,
0.557854413986206,
0.2755303382873535,
1.1765687465667725,
-0.21964716911315918,
0.4083484709262848,
0.7707691788673401,
-0.17213283479213715,
-0.007171310484409332,
0.24711333215236664,
-0.0730440765619278,
-0.25811830163002014,
-0.21332021057605743,
-0.49088674783706665,
-0.7151841521263123,
0.04907582700252533,
-0.5453453063964844,
0.13944362103939056,
-0.8515601754188538,
0.14741353690624237,
0.42027613520622253,
-0.18471120297908783,
0.0680631548166275,
-0.2191774845123291,
-0.06601088494062424,
1.0610376596450806,
-0.8496123552322388,
0.19116631150245667,
0.9017055630683899,
-0.31337156891822815,
-0.06456407159566879,
-0.022480592131614685,
0.15382902324199677,
-0.012006619945168495,
0.4154485762119293,
-0.05086195468902588,
-0.43665480613708496,
-0.3584567606449127,
-0.6484942436218262,
-0.026236090809106827,
0.716417670249939,
0.2073466181755066,
-0.12370200455188751,
0.23615606129169464,
-0.06967548280954361,
0.19858676195144653,
-0.5550380945205688,
0.45764920115470886,
0.5663619041442871,
0.37348201870918274,
0.5489126443862915,
-0.3394835591316223,
0.07804324477910995,
-0.42943671345710754,
-0.3047527074813843,
0.21889132261276245,
-0.624305009841919,
0.97068190574646,
-0.39647313952445984,
-0.1946493536233902,
-0.025557290762662888,
0.6298035383224487,
0.1340777426958084,
0.5817593336105347,
0.29948723316192627,
0.8884866833686829,
0.6058229804039001,
-0.1763586848974228,
0.6875008940696716,
0.10660295933485031,
0.06953556090593338,
1.4584145545959473,
-0.47815921902656555,
0.9264097213745117,
0.009242264553904533,
-0.07468537241220474,
0.7689270973205566,
0.6568969488143921,
0.18002615869045258,
0.22730514407157898,
0.39991670846939087,
-0.6193427443504333,
-0.19567984342575073,
-0.3294219374656677,
-0.5374158024787903,
0.3360031545162201,
0.522295355796814,
-0.13103832304477692,
-0.7692372798919678,
-0.2732278108596802,
0.43625256419181824,
0.5138379335403442,
-0.402751624584198,
1.1170371770858765,
-0.2948184609413147,
-0.834381639957428,
0.6910400986671448,
-0.15893763303756714,
0.23679009079933167,
-0.36488237977027893,
-0.3308369815349579,
-0.27048641443252563,
0.38255739212036133,
-0.45642152428627014,
-0.9375318288803101,
0.11406262964010239,
0.30335813760757446,
-0.035542283207178116,
0.04058099910616875,
0.5721311569213867,
-0.09145689755678177,
-0.21798136830329895,
0.06657164543867111,
0.14313668012619019,
0.20844748616218567,
0.15412236750125885,
-0.4416412115097046,
-0.08249426633119583,
-0.30177992582321167,
-0.28999632596969604,
0.2896789312362671,
0.6844558715820312,
-0.10341855883598328,
0.2490033358335495,
0.6192024350166321,
0.2203378975391388,
-0.17135456204414368,
0.1329984962940216,
1.2353864908218384,
-0.5423223376274109,
-0.3966768682003021,
-1.019491195678711,
0.49834856390953064,
-0.716616153717041,
-0.37899643182754517,
0.7266544103622437,
1.1333401203155518,
0.5132684707641602,
-0.05947652831673622,
1.014735221862793,
-0.028710249811410904,
0.6449073553085327,
-0.10172885656356812,
0.6317902207374573,
-0.23622505366802216,
-0.09543020278215408,
-0.43299445509910583,
-0.42017310857772827,
-0.2534981966018677,
0.5596327185630798,
-0.25067779421806335,
-0.42664799094200134,
0.5434777736663818,
0.4403175711631775,
-0.14280664920806885,
0.6709046363830566,
0.014531642198562622,
0.516975998878479,
0.5153186321258545,
0.46586912870407104,
0.681564450263977,
-0.30158132314682007,
0.587835431098938,
0.1723858118057251,
-0.6153504252433777,
-0.4307366907596588,
-1.0590072870254517,
-1.007717490196228,
-0.5085901021957397,
-0.5959914922714233,
-0.603734016418457,
0.13719843327999115,
1.0265849828720093,
0.16797569394111633,
-1.160084843635559,
-0.5529918074607849,
-0.16612207889556885,
0.3931540250778198,
-0.0897449478507042,
-0.2797492742538452,
0.2381056249141693,
-0.21402132511138916,
-0.5483815670013428,
0.32705801725387573,
0.20740029215812683,
-0.3719541132450104,
-0.15861833095550537,
0.060172367841005325,
-0.4281436800956726,
0.717331051826477,
0.8257887363433838,
0.7914595603942871,
-0.505585253238678,
-0.029307771474123,
-0.5101243257522583,
0.21947158873081207,
0.08667241781949997,
1.132219910621643,
-0.6761993169784546,
0.7575790286064148,
0.7575268149375916,
0.6743355393409729,
0.10483624041080475,
0.33362746238708496,
0.619279146194458,
-0.523878812789917,
-0.06757210195064545,
0.07646899670362473,
0.4058186709880829,
0.10917258262634277,
0.10420773923397064,
0.562744677066803,
0.2813301682472229,
-0.6763252019882202,
-1.0833545923233032,
0.0927499532699585,
-1.008999228477478,
-0.353874146938324,
0.8181983828544617,
-0.4928615391254425,
-0.11420013755559921,
-0.3082185685634613,
-0.34969770908355713,
-0.23324869573116302,
-0.7215913534164429,
0.7926042079925537,
0.8862512707710266,
-0.057933688163757324,
0.016013242304325104,
-0.5187375545501709,
0.4808979630470276,
-0.089492067694664,
-1.077061414718628,
0.9777789115905762,
0.9158545136451721,
-0.11796139925718307,
0.1166318729519844,
0.4892614781856537,
-0.46136441826820374,
0.3647572696208954,
0.13030748069286346,
-0.1454223245382309,
0.005152213387191296,
-0.2603820264339447,
-0.42242857813835144,
0.8332517147064209,
-0.2825768291950226,
-0.30710265040397644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14654v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14654v1 | Major Entity Identification: A Generalizable Alternative to Coreference Resolution | 2024-06-20T18:17:58 | 2024-06-20T18:17:58 | Kawshik Manikantan, Shubham Toshniwal, Makarand Tapaswi, Vineet Gandhi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | The limited generalization of coreference resolution (CR) models has been a
major bottleneck in the task's broad application. Prior work has identified
annotation differences, especially for mention detection, as one of the main
reasons for the generalization gap and proposed using additional annotated
target domain data. Rather than relying on this additional annotation, we
propose an alternative formulation of the CR task, Major Entity Identification
(MEI), where we: (a) assume the target entities to be specified in the input,
and (b) limit the task to only the frequent entities. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate that MEI models generalize well across domains on
multiple datasets with supervised models and LLM-based few-shot prompting.
Additionally, the MEI task fits the classification framework, which enables the
use of classification-based metrics that are more robust than the current CR
metrics. Finally, MEI is also of practical use as it allows a user to search
for all mentions of a particular entity or a group of entities of interest. | [
-0.5596622228622437,
-0.7912008166313171,
0.5523092150688171,
-0.13958406448364258,
-0.3319064676761627,
-0.02355920523405075,
-0.7029731273651123,
-0.7003623843193054,
0.246169775724411,
0.33638498187065125,
-0.6247875094413757,
-0.6334124803543091,
-0.9179551005363464,
0.26260289549827576,
-0.3088501989841461,
0.9858170747756958,
0.11462532728910446,
-0.13553167879581451,
-0.2810552418231964,
-0.16866980493068695,
-0.6768293380737305,
-0.7411317825317383,
-0.4607270359992981,
-0.3668147027492523,
0.6943463087081909,
0.7007280588150024,
0.6054173111915588,
0.6464169025421143,
0.9236754179000854,
0.21408213675022125,
-0.048537418246269226,
0.5207614302635193,
-0.33178913593292236,
-0.05783765763044357,
-0.46676936745643616,
-0.5621053576469421,
-0.45631155371665955,
0.25856396555900574,
0.7438206076622009,
0.9549149870872498,
0.16193267703056335,
0.31643912196159363,
-0.10974510759115219,
0.37123626470565796,
-0.7382705211639404,
0.34109294414520264,
-0.9579519033432007,
-0.1102479100227356,
-0.4727436304092407,
-0.18752284348011017,
-0.41006597876548767,
0.16767770051956177,
0.4366210997104645,
-0.7871949672698975,
0.6555348038673401,
0.24694988131523132,
1.2703970670700073,
0.016774335876107216,
-0.28055819869041443,
-0.29549628496170044,
-1.060119390487671,
1.1029855012893677,
-0.004450248554348946,
0.38257354497909546,
0.2848413586616516,
0.32894620299339294,
0.24930471181869507,
-0.33093884587287903,
-0.2933513820171356,
-0.1342865526676178,
-0.020550595596432686,
-0.08970886468887329,
-0.517923891544342,
0.20245836675167084,
0.41821643710136414,
0.41983070969581604,
-0.3345504701137543,
0.2196377068758011,
-0.20927175879478455,
-0.2724645435810089,
0.2970205247402191,
0.18589596450328827,
0.4171423017978668,
0.11281135678291321,
-0.40109169483184814,
0.5351709127426147,
-0.9792267680168152,
-0.16106659173965454,
0.07519470900297165,
0.3899523615837097,
0.2144399881362915,
0.6576207280158997,
-0.33411797881126404,
0.5602562427520752,
0.22943831980228424,
-0.19020581245422363,
0.07774877548217773,
-0.14843755960464478,
-0.2999565601348877,
-0.1957836002111435,
0.4226861596107483,
0.7241234183311462,
0.5667951107025146,
-0.374268114566803,
0.13742785155773163,
0.4138020873069763,
0.05788775533437729,
-0.7696028351783752,
-0.21210499107837677,
-0.11572198569774628,
-0.3693007528781891,
0.0077742598950862885,
0.1419479101896286,
-0.5288131237030029,
-0.3005339503288269,
-0.5415515303611755,
0.08706619590520859,
-0.4409189820289612,
-0.17710259556770325,
-0.35791829228401184,
-0.22225166857242584,
0.014192070811986923,
0.52787184715271,
-0.7485182881355286,
0.464231014251709,
0.7646750807762146,
0.920447051525116,
-0.34274208545684814,
-0.10707665979862213,
-0.4966670870780945,
0.35025444626808167,
-0.39827409386634827,
0.9497984647750854,
-1.0589756965637207,
-0.7756062746047974,
-0.11807266622781754,
-0.05992835760116577,
-0.22430361807346344,
-0.8881567120552063,
0.49157610535621643,
-0.6177108883857727,
-0.22755612432956696,
-0.45596492290496826,
-0.6481791138648987,
-0.5559626817703247,
0.35508328676223755,
-0.5919880867004395,
0.5657663345336914,
0.08621414750814438,
-0.7736740112304688,
0.5367417335510254,
-0.5749911069869995,
-0.23066434264183044,
0.21560350060462952,
-0.40172451734542847,
-0.17800632119178772,
0.021582217887043953,
0.09359204024076462,
0.5641090273857117,
-0.7384436130523682,
0.3870561420917511,
-0.18992888927459717,
-0.3603186309337616,
0.10381468385457993,
0.015483921393752098,
0.48168593645095825,
0.07745005935430527,
0.10676037520170212,
0.20754611492156982,
-0.5399031639099121,
-0.5799136757850647,
0.04669911786913872,
-0.2060772031545639,
-0.7538041472434998,
0.17346160113811493,
-0.33277973532676697,
-0.21293827891349792,
0.10331819951534271,
-0.5689898133277893,
0.5510543584823608,
0.12115562707185745,
0.29849979281425476,
0.32258597016334534,
0.29742103815078735,
0.7490105032920837,
-0.40442243218421936,
0.39317449927330017,
0.5407764911651611,
-0.017908485606312752,
-0.22243870794773102,
-0.9362210631370544,
-0.8081876039505005,
-0.6886548399925232,
0.7744746804237366,
0.8298219442367554,
-0.4115406572818756,
0.28665632009506226,
-0.7716690301895142,
-0.6084566116333008,
-0.30910950899124146,
0.3062286078929901,
0.34389635920524597,
0.5850585103034973,
0.6792353391647339,
-0.3299436867237091,
-0.7876653671264648,
-1.3113138675689697,
-0.4001830816268921,
-0.19978484511375427,
-0.340313196182251,
0.6138051152229309,
0.5260558128356934,
-0.3553309142589569,
1.1309378147125244,
-0.6389157772064209,
-0.7333083152770996,
-0.3524048924446106,
0.18487240374088287,
0.10129830241203308,
0.6459764838218689,
0.4995315372943878,
-1.0022525787353516,
-0.26320499181747437,
-0.05580642446875572,
-0.40559396147727966,
0.010235507972538471,
-0.24891039729118347,
-0.07763359695672989,
-0.47341641783714294,
0.16118797659873962,
-0.7974449396133423,
0.2425432652235031,
0.10166329890489578,
0.01074057538062334,
0.4168638586997986,
0.3409659266471863,
0.17332972586154938,
-0.7704375982284546,
0.28023406863212585,
0.37288105487823486,
-0.16837969422340393,
-0.774086594581604,
0.1493750661611557,
0.14036762714385986,
-0.0943184345960617,
-0.20861704647541046,
0.4863538146018982,
-0.5497968792915344,
0.119533970952034,
-0.07092094421386719,
0.11806996911764145,
-0.12508735060691833,
0.39834025502204895,
0.3454354703426361,
0.6328468322753906,
0.660339891910553,
-1.2398799657821655,
0.1714942306280136,
0.3887914717197418,
-0.17247095704078674,
0.7644717693328857,
-0.3607853949069977,
0.004052039701491594,
-0.21396897733211517,
0.394282728433609,
-0.6154887676239014,
-0.28020745515823364,
0.4600740373134613,
-0.6300352215766907,
0.26838061213493347,
-0.5580379366874695,
-0.3466460108757019,
-0.27618536353111267,
-0.12220398336648941,
0.3106886148452759,
0.5329432487487793,
-0.5365253686904907,
0.9596814513206482,
0.44353124499320984,
-0.030571572482585907,
-0.5024644136428833,
-0.6417085528373718,
0.19086290895938873,
-0.4910013973712921,
-0.322592169046402,
0.7575789093971252,
-0.08985457569360733,
-0.3214297294616699,
0.012673648074269295,
-0.11574073135852814,
-0.42400026321411133,
0.28010275959968567,
0.653730034828186,
0.756471574306488,
-0.2619839906692505,
0.3124641180038452,
-0.0016198407392948866,
-0.2953489422798157,
-0.27054300904273987,
-0.02593928389251232,
0.16299274563789368,
0.15190920233726501,
-0.14168302714824677,
-0.46530240774154663,
0.7130407094955444,
0.20678821206092834,
-0.5568556189537048,
0.47331511974334717,
0.4745655953884125,
-0.8638818264007568,
-0.02297370135784149,
-0.7726160287857056,
0.020198287442326546,
-0.3472845256328583,
0.044471632689237595,
-0.678795337677002,
-0.9006604552268982,
0.5466939210891724,
-0.4274562895298004,
0.35882383584976196,
0.6793118715286255,
0.520350456237793,
0.18555133044719696,
0.865372359752655,
0.6801811456680298,
-0.32124438881874084,
0.3470976948738098,
-0.2173508107662201,
0.18041203916072845,
-1.208402395248413,
0.004845801275223494,
-0.7056525349617004,
-0.3189750015735626,
-0.10364716500043869,
-0.6349025368690491,
0.05757195129990578,
0.44183680415153503,
0.07586100697517395,
0.5455557703971863,
-0.49073824286460876,
0.3604315519332886,
0.6938537955284119,
0.048712048679590225,
0.6372341513633728,
-0.18484607338905334,
0.06310945749282837,
-0.0722302794456482,
-0.3212509751319885,
-0.6153677701950073,
0.8187735080718994,
0.2973584532737732,
0.405908465385437,
0.18099389970302582,
0.6695321798324585,
0.3097183406352997,
0.7895084619522095,
-1.0466426610946655,
0.645481288433075,
-0.17847062647342682,
-1.0559818744659424,
0.03876279667019844,
-0.40104812383651733,
-0.6947833895683289,
0.21684294939041138,
-0.28620120882987976,
-1.036395788192749,
0.3644649386405945,
0.23074930906295776,
-0.7296279668807983,
0.3911490738391876,
-0.5790649652481079,
0.5063941478729248,
0.6208075284957886,
0.23569366335868835,
-0.25804781913757324,
-0.19596484303474426,
0.4439903497695923,
0.0023180036805570126,
0.22476351261138916,
-0.6110620498657227,
-0.374744713306427,
0.8178743720054626,
-0.02015831507742405,
0.9442988038063049,
-0.14730285108089447,
0.40255972743034363,
0.6999101638793945,
0.16337476670742035,
0.40420252084732056,
0.17245250940322876,
0.1321811079978943,
0.33111661672592163,
-0.31900402903556824,
-0.09707827121019363,
-0.35010454058647156,
0.7337550520896912,
-0.4432721734046936,
-0.8169283866882324,
-0.08733569830656052,
-0.46172982454299927,
-0.3112982511520386,
0.2976941764354706,
0.43284904956817627,
0.3157041668891907,
-0.29089710116386414,
0.14831191301345825,
0.638763964176178,
0.16401773691177368,
0.269721120595932,
0.656682550907135,
0.17705702781677246,
-0.1231803223490715,
0.8371558785438538,
0.30411919951438904,
-0.23679475486278534,
0.4915539026260376,
0.008112478069961071,
-0.044017545878887177,
-0.5089357495307922,
-0.5870052576065063,
0.1744822859764099,
-0.595033586025238,
-0.5136159658432007,
-0.9353376030921936,
0.09054730832576752,
-0.3071596324443817,
-0.16985127329826355,
-0.23450301587581635,
-0.26417216658592224,
-0.6606355905532837,
-0.09671454131603241,
0.28540846705436707,
0.21096643805503845,
-0.0598808154463768,
0.29049038887023926,
-0.9491884708404541,
0.40958893299102783,
0.34748756885528564,
0.17410753667354584,
-0.09578339755535126,
-0.5003425478935242,
-0.029195111244916916,
-0.17392224073410034,
-0.1694178432226181,
-1.0569161176681519,
-0.08395728468894958,
0.6138679385185242,
0.510714590549469,
0.7304443120956421,
0.11818233132362366,
0.719050943851471,
-0.6996373534202576,
0.9230864644050598,
0.3225303590297699,
-0.9863997101783752,
0.5377307534217834,
-0.2714286148548126,
-0.08442877233028412,
0.5370652675628662,
0.7718349099159241,
-0.5599033832550049,
-0.19667352735996246,
-0.7038093209266663,
-0.6920101642608643,
0.11946083605289459,
0.09261032938957214,
0.1505531370639801,
-0.2570452094078064,
0.46155041456222534,
0.06496400386095047,
0.06918036937713623,
-0.3823300004005432,
-0.2929416596889496,
0.5627602934837341,
0.04700378328561783,
0.11788192391395569,
-0.48189473152160645,
-0.2960796356201172,
-0.06619375944137573,
0.6637970805168152,
-0.019328085705637932,
0.3762292265892029,
0.571480929851532,
-0.48733022809028625,
-0.28965768218040466,
0.33528971672058105,
0.3486950993537903,
0.6435166597366333,
0.02756098285317421,
0.21862801909446716,
0.3826591968536377,
-0.26597318053245544,
-0.13331489264965057,
-0.04308314993977547,
-0.35290345549583435,
0.42521172761917114,
0.44606906175613403,
0.3593890070915222,
0.35243356227874756,
-0.648573100566864,
0.5391836762428284,
0.29926633834838867,
-0.25496166944503784,
-0.3207499384880066,
0.270812451839447,
0.058844439685344696,
0.2449120283126831,
0.49787306785583496,
0.1193159893155098,
0.3565419614315033,
-0.4134027659893036,
0.26472508907318115,
0.3558807969093323,
-0.5288806557655334,
-0.26387444138526917,
0.6307040452957153,
0.3921508193016052,
-0.20439788699150085,
0.6498465538024902,
-0.18600812554359436,
-0.5893440246582031,
0.5315704941749573,
0.23693008720874786,
0.7092589735984802,
-0.3374711275100708,
-0.060590360313653946,
0.5494237542152405,
0.17813535034656525,
-0.09530875086784363,
-0.03564245253801346,
-0.12776437401771545,
-0.9571168422698975,
-0.39742088317871094,
-0.18005400896072388,
-0.6049020290374756,
-0.12675900757312775,
-0.8495357632637024,
0.3689609467983246,
-0.6442359685897827,
-0.6992164850234985,
0.5915367007255554,
-0.10826145112514496,
-0.9116842746734619,
0.24643245339393616,
0.397009938955307,
0.9640060663223267,
-0.7822635769844055,
0.8472867012023926,
0.9820327162742615,
-0.5408439040184021,
-0.4208439290523529,
-0.3856221139431,
0.22782303392887115,
-0.43700867891311646,
0.5599011182785034,
0.3226263225078583,
0.10886939615011215,
0.03949195519089699,
-0.38225314021110535,
-0.6140398979187012,
1.1180957555770874,
-0.013957981020212173,
-0.8222761750221252,
-0.42374101281166077,
-0.3657180964946747,
0.12685565650463104,
-0.7617883086204529,
0.13745708763599396,
0.689007580280304,
0.556987464427948,
-0.1863834261894226,
-1.0086650848388672,
0.06685567647218704,
0.00979556143283844,
0.09255743026733398,
0.16251498460769653,
-0.5246543288230896,
0.8018015027046204,
-0.3752739429473877,
-0.5274825096130371,
0.05415501073002815,
0.8243980407714844,
0.1459181159734726,
0.2977725565433502,
0.8842195272445679,
0.38877034187316895,
0.8440879583358765,
-0.1607861965894699,
0.7378667593002319,
-0.21390566229820251,
0.5693134069442749,
1.2348837852478027,
-0.16449780762195587,
0.6070426106452942,
0.2546573877334595,
-0.09566788375377655,
0.29015052318573,
0.8240264058113098,
-0.5389463901519775,
0.1787063181400299,
0.10328920185565948,
-0.3045099377632141,
-0.6304609179496765,
-0.5415005087852478,
-0.278177410364151,
0.17787089943885803,
0.7393689155578613,
-0.5358929634094238,
-0.39343544840812683,
-0.08335854858160019,
0.08873304724693298,
-0.07303379476070404,
-0.49084538221359253,
0.5435401797294617,
0.13081146776676178,
-0.39179691672325134,
0.05169794335961342,
0.197252094745636,
0.7607716917991638,
-0.37842658162117004,
-0.139444038271904,
0.19698382914066315,
0.011590300127863884,
-0.29802271723747253,
-0.33385592699050903,
0.22134758532047272,
0.21733538806438446,
-0.49990200996398926,
0.25297603011131287,
0.8880763053894043,
-0.3763905465602875,
-0.27185648679733276,
0.17514948546886444,
0.48523572087287903,
0.1681927740573883,
-0.47063642740249634,
-0.5371155142784119,
-0.07199254631996155,
-0.22133788466453552,
-0.10998324304819107,
0.044812411069869995,
0.15556257963180542,
-0.19806982576847076,
0.7176201343536377,
0.4721668064594269,
-0.07824970781803131,
-0.10133633762598038,
-0.10937567055225372,
0.8711487650871277,
-0.6574123501777649,
-0.38034284114837646,
-0.7997876405715942,
0.24083830416202545,
-0.10314106196165085,
-0.5660557746887207,
0.506629467010498,
0.5803777575492859,
0.6804936528205872,
-0.2213551253080368,
0.8103238940238953,
-0.1572025716304779,
1.0021793842315674,
-0.17409218847751617,
0.08248120546340942,
-0.22685499489307404,
0.21216526627540588,
-0.24651211500167847,
-1.085148572921753,
-0.6504433155059814,
0.36418479681015015,
-0.38232842087745667,
-0.232524573802948,
0.5695034265518188,
0.4876521825790405,
-0.17014208436012268,
-0.023562168702483177,
0.43244487047195435,
-0.13240256905555725,
0.31252893805503845,
0.561307966709137,
0.740714967250824,
-0.03900528699159622,
0.5098868012428284,
-0.32103249430656433,
-0.32610616087913513,
-0.47597455978393555,
-0.6105906963348389,
-0.9948344826698303,
-0.5175365805625916,
-0.6920619010925293,
-0.07039748877286911,
-0.023936420679092407,
1.1832658052444458,
0.8118948936462402,
-0.8789575695991516,
0.3093850314617157,
0.4338376224040985,
0.09629887342453003,
-0.31191471219062805,
-0.1766754686832428,
0.05184319242835045,
-0.11965426802635193,
-1.0184662342071533,
0.3257588744163513,
0.14055147767066956,
-0.10391297936439514,
0.13409405946731567,
0.4667663276195526,
-0.10007130354642868,
0.06701859086751938,
0.4786095917224884,
0.3247895836830139,
-0.9240977168083191,
-0.6665995121002197,
-0.1063295528292656,
0.01874096505343914,
0.14146576821804047,
1.2505841255187988,
-0.39788174629211426,
0.0914645791053772,
0.19537357985973358,
0.7617605924606323,
-0.019304243847727776,
0.34333741664886475,
0.3585446774959564,
-0.5238503217697144,
0.008046204224228859,
0.30866917967796326,
0.43339425325393677,
0.11296974867582321,
-0.5103008151054382,
0.6363154649734497,
0.4605022966861725,
-0.18133148550987244,
-0.5716529488563538,
0.45385247468948364,
-1.2398432493209839,
-0.22768181562423706,
1.1908522844314575,
-0.4866594672203064,
-0.06252849102020264,
-0.27195170521736145,
-0.16488923132419586,
0.14582258462905884,
-0.525286853313446,
0.36820241808891296,
0.8251020908355713,
-0.16634441912174225,
0.06971929967403412,
-0.48120036721229553,
0.2814050316810608,
0.13684195280075073,
-0.34478503465652466,
0.11245522648096085,
0.6169253587722778,
0.6064976453781128,
0.5877936482429504,
0.6396329998970032,
-0.1132354810833931,
0.24405430257320404,
-0.1356094926595688,
0.1479247510433197,
0.013405341655015945,
-0.7058690190315247,
0.03988579288125038,
0.20278607308864594,
0.28110724687576294,
-0.32196947932243347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19415v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19415v1 | An Analysis of Multilingual FActScore | 2024-06-20T18:09:40 | 2024-06-20T18:09:40 | Kim Trong Vu, Michael Krumdick, Varshini Reddy, Franck Dernoncourt, Viet Dac Lai | cs.CL | cs.CL | FActScore has gained popularity as a metric to estimate the factuality of
long-form texts generated by Large Language Models (LLMs) in English. However,
there has not been any work in studying the behavior of FActScore in other
languages. This paper studies the limitations of each component in the
four-component pipeline of FActScore in the multilingual setting. We introduce
a new dataset for FActScore on texts generated by strong multilingual LLMs. Our
evaluation shows that LLMs exhibit distinct behaviors in both fact extraction
and fact scoring tasks. No LLM produces consistent and reliable FActScore
across languages with varying levels of resources. We also find that the
knowledge source plays an important role in the quality of the estimated
FActScore. Using Wikipedia as the knowledge source may hinder the true
FActScore of long-form text due to its limited coverage in medium- and
low-resource languages. We also incorporate three mitigations to our knowledge
source that ultimately improve FActScore estimation across all languages. | [
-0.2455512136220932,
-0.7109746336936951,
0.8233038783073425,
0.2474682480096817,
-0.19838197529315948,
0.09954004734754562,
-0.5278066992759705,
-0.6205055117607117,
0.23982346057891846,
0.33529072999954224,
-0.46096086502075195,
-0.6282632350921631,
-0.6203221082687378,
0.35763052105903625,
-0.10763765126466751,
1.3609473705291748,
0.004295201040804386,
-0.015065382234752178,
-0.6510293483734131,
-0.4304881691932678,
-0.16010330617427826,
-0.6436766386032104,
-0.16378463804721832,
-0.24663741886615753,
0.774349570274353,
0.7431696653366089,
0.6041492819786072,
0.4298683702945709,
0.5003983378410339,
0.282120943069458,
0.005763084162026644,
0.5218510031700134,
-0.44505539536476135,
0.3303435444831848,
-0.17092670500278473,
-0.5490057468414307,
-0.30042168498039246,
0.07555631548166275,
0.9087380170822144,
0.39467987418174744,
-0.1335311084985733,
0.44775378704071045,
-0.06994444131851196,
0.47084447741508484,
-0.5634322762489319,
0.6843041181564331,
-0.3735194206237793,
-0.06082404404878616,
-0.5409073233604431,
0.11344990879297256,
-0.35609087347984314,
-0.4846605360507965,
-0.03234231844544411,
-0.21669265627861023,
0.24622303247451782,
-0.07200967520475388,
0.548317551612854,
0.1116447001695633,
-0.7048662304878235,
-0.5180538892745972,
-0.6006169319152832,
0.9590407609939575,
-0.5479418635368347,
0.7783315181732178,
0.05194836109876633,
0.20208047330379486,
0.10099335759878159,
-0.32887551188468933,
-0.6152556538581848,
-0.32511940598487854,
-0.17774049937725067,
0.07428780198097229,
-0.17573212087154388,
-0.43029576539993286,
0.29274171590805054,
0.03658119589090347,
-0.333055704832077,
0.03669789806008339,
-0.5351530313491821,
-0.5662934184074402,
0.6740241646766663,
0.016926754266023636,
0.23861797153949738,
-0.7321127653121948,
-0.6657541394233704,
0.27824831008911133,
-0.7570843696594238,
0.05234416201710701,
0.34087032079696655,
0.4174514412879944,
-0.306355357170105,
0.6619654297828674,
0.02415819838643074,
0.39941591024398804,
-0.42127925157546997,
-0.9755348563194275,
0.4258943498134613,
-0.5387051701545715,
0.2561035752296448,
0.3222009539604187,
0.8167843818664551,
0.3667156994342804,
0.222036674618721,
-0.2670247554779053,
0.03380433842539787,
-0.12679417431354523,
-0.23001697659492493,
-0.5927513241767883,
0.16152504086494446,
0.1277763545513153,
-0.0699867382645607,
0.0024275006726384163,
-0.11867986619472504,
-0.7240849733352661,
-0.44518718123435974,
-0.2780735492706299,
0.03943514823913574,
-0.3815470039844513,
-0.3860762119293213,
-0.14131219685077667,
-0.15868374705314636,
0.007070492021739483,
0.12634140253067017,
-0.38840726017951965,
0.10578148066997528,
0.5499619245529175,
1.0102158784866333,
-0.462567538022995,
-0.654667317867279,
-0.4668731093406677,
0.22803014516830444,
-0.2773043215274811,
1.0737491846084595,
-0.22070610523223877,
-0.14347246289253235,
-0.15172474086284637,
-0.026155952364206314,
0.10942860692739487,
-0.22413401305675507,
0.9138123393058777,
-0.5752784013748169,
0.21485884487628937,
-0.5520203709602356,
-0.6352559924125671,
-0.3881598114967346,
0.4947114884853363,
-0.9565800428390503,
1.0326210260391235,
-0.26983582973480225,
-0.908896803855896,
0.3064149022102356,
-0.420868843793869,
-0.5939492583274841,
-0.1696346551179886,
-0.24201700091362,
-0.2691035568714142,
0.07251511514186859,
0.05856303125619888,
0.5678097605705261,
-0.3795658051967621,
0.4701301157474518,
-0.18212951719760895,
-0.045830272138118744,
0.3640797436237335,
-0.7942788600921631,
0.7451132535934448,
0.2395758181810379,
-0.05379379168152809,
-0.3733503520488739,
-0.8372141718864441,
-0.20999103784561157,
-0.04476796090602875,
-0.6881821155548096,
-0.25685790181159973,
0.2049097716808319,
-0.14752644300460815,
0.3638324737548828,
0.4672633111476898,
-0.8210998177528381,
-0.18202675879001617,
0.061409126967191696,
0.01489817164838314,
0.5876528024673462,
0.030129019170999527,
0.01518163550645113,
-0.1438324898481369,
0.3539012372493744,
0.23236525058746338,
0.02580135129392147,
0.021303338930010796,
-0.31124982237815857,
-0.7849113941192627,
-0.40405115485191345,
0.20362773537635803,
0.4943382740020752,
-0.7505326271057129,
-0.035386305302381516,
-0.535411536693573,
-0.6150355935096741,
-0.17377407848834991,
0.37981468439102173,
0.3733181357383728,
0.6079473495483398,
0.33173128962516785,
0.03434237092733383,
-0.47404736280441284,
-1.0402717590332031,
-0.3217281699180603,
-0.24000214040279388,
0.3988785743713379,
0.15340232849121094,
0.35352063179016113,
0.07925029844045639,
0.8936428427696228,
-0.5752201080322266,
-0.0320870503783226,
-0.37592747807502747,
0.07374301552772522,
0.4632212221622467,
-0.08365707844495773,
0.6957001090049744,
-0.6901028752326965,
-0.4436529278755188,
-0.17593048512935638,
-0.9327806234359741,
0.029199933633208275,
0.11869929730892181,
0.13329274952411652,
0.45618554949760437,
0.29305848479270935,
-0.8728278279304504,
-0.18516580760478973,
0.8697867393493652,
-0.1362725794315338,
0.8394332528114319,
-0.1778118908405304,
0.28437507152557373,
-0.9802979230880737,
-0.011864417232573032,
0.1848578155040741,
-0.2780899107456207,
-0.42967885732650757,
0.19673824310302734,
0.25017160177230835,
-0.1295233815908432,
-0.6767892837524414,
0.520753800868988,
-0.496173620223999,
-0.21480879187583923,
0.015510457567870617,
0.25542163848876953,
0.15289713442325592,
0.3447569012641907,
0.09654618054628372,
0.7761134505271912,
0.3572407364845276,
-0.6944288015365601,
0.7431477308273315,
-0.015157587826251984,
-0.7622237801551819,
0.6395608186721802,
-0.3056989014148712,
-0.137442484498024,
-0.38374149799346924,
0.15051399171352386,
-0.8480719923973083,
-0.08738362789154053,
-0.050126202404499054,
-0.22065337002277374,
0.2547142505645752,
-0.18542440235614777,
-0.5515269637107849,
-0.1320541650056839,
-0.35282987356185913,
0.10469383746385574,
0.10131114721298218,
-0.4987504780292511,
0.4779616892337799,
0.5118803381919861,
-0.42334628105163574,
-0.7424206137657166,
-0.6278862357139587,
0.23169952630996704,
-0.20259380340576172,
-0.6982761025428772,
0.003986483905464411,
-0.285086065530777,
-0.40151357650756836,
-0.016504362225532532,
-0.18915632367134094,
-0.1880015730857849,
-0.04977761581540108,
-0.09486512094736099,
0.2737332880496979,
-0.3281201720237732,
0.46364274621009827,
-0.07973411679267883,
-0.005522116553038359,
0.28163281083106995,
0.04385875165462494,
0.10324487835168839,
0.08545529842376709,
-0.39999058842658997,
-0.0038000154308974743,
0.45162391662597656,
0.7738887071609497,
-0.2800678312778473,
0.8086259365081787,
0.5093818306922913,
-0.043435726314783096,
-0.25361254811286926,
-0.666083037853241,
0.2076108157634735,
-0.3434399366378784,
0.5451545119285583,
-0.3961327373981476,
-0.6835953593254089,
0.4374651610851288,
0.1896732747554779,
0.17503556609153748,
0.7102265357971191,
0.6161115169525146,
-0.04659262299537659,
0.6247711181640625,
0.3252484202384949,
-0.16850602626800537,
-0.09918977320194244,
-0.009792896918952465,
0.17642055451869965,
-0.3726712465286255,
-0.31361523270606995,
-0.6172526478767395,
0.012273186817765236,
-0.7513824105262756,
-0.4712855815887451,
0.7667711973190308,
-0.23862138390541077,
-0.0073128994554281235,
0.03778516873717308,
0.35032182931900024,
0.5305188894271851,
0.3417331874370575,
0.07114489376544952,
0.6247714161872864,
0.25680795311927795,
-0.18896201252937317,
-0.23882831633090973,
-0.9350914359092712,
-0.3492662310600281,
1.0119537115097046,
0.3787272870540619,
0.4715440273284912,
0.5890101790428162,
0.39653849601745605,
0.41624000668525696,
0.25794509053230286,
-0.911796510219574,
0.35291483998298645,
-0.332881361246109,
-1.0688807964324951,
-0.1638757437467575,
-0.6692953109741211,
-0.40448781847953796,
0.09812645614147186,
-0.1595449447631836,
-0.20880219340324402,
-0.13963526487350464,
-0.1094747930765152,
-0.08891474455595016,
0.2545832395553589,
-0.6938150525093079,
0.4627975821495056,
-0.4536578953266144,
-0.4370739459991455,
-0.2718086838722229,
-0.3905678391456604,
0.6047918796539307,
-0.22405153512954712,
0.7939566969871521,
-0.3179667592048645,
0.04952424392104149,
0.7068551778793335,
-0.12641754746437073,
0.8809787631034851,
0.002740489784628153,
-0.453380286693573,
0.427619069814682,
-0.0016123002860695124,
0.5421136021614075,
0.20434898138046265,
-0.40358805656433105,
0.5563473701477051,
-0.1252598911523819,
-0.43907058238983154,
-0.45187973976135254,
0.9080281257629395,
-0.7368333339691162,
-0.7355520725250244,
-0.7444643974304199,
-0.47062593698501587,
-0.4297533631324768,
0.20345836877822876,
0.12950097024440765,
0.6314831376075745,
-0.27304309606552124,
0.14975424110889435,
0.46244755387306213,
-0.09613891690969467,
0.4051372706890106,
0.9944402575492859,
0.029229670763015747,
-0.08938082307577133,
1.0870468616485596,
0.6172482967376709,
0.07266879081726074,
0.2690371870994568,
0.33377525210380554,
-0.5951886177062988,
-0.37968093156814575,
-0.4468594789505005,
0.49740511178970337,
-0.9511423110961914,
-0.21094977855682373,
-0.4885155260562897,
-0.2705017626285553,
-0.21724581718444824,
0.6176462173461914,
-0.5074095726013184,
-0.5094020366668701,
0.066677987575531,
-0.4606918692588806,
0.3914141356945038,
0.7987987399101257,
-0.1446366161108017,
-0.33539098501205444,
-1.1130337715148926,
0.20963285863399506,
0.4544955790042877,
0.3945338726043701,
-0.17106150090694427,
-0.29491767287254333,
-0.5856571793556213,
-0.09274758398532867,
0.06679924577474594,
-0.8096208572387695,
-0.1290486752986908,
0.2776394188404083,
0.6822113394737244,
0.25285378098487854,
0.16315670311450958,
0.36033037304878235,
-0.749024510383606,
0.8691850304603577,
0.30257588624954224,
-0.6758581399917603,
0.04977390542626381,
-0.047402169555425644,
0.2032565176486969,
0.33615604043006897,
0.7724359631538391,
-0.5701252222061157,
-0.3370431065559387,
-0.33516258001327515,
-0.43157172203063965,
0.6279845237731934,
0.00820007175207138,
0.3560265600681305,
-0.25624972581863403,
0.10848946124315262,
0.34578457474708557,
0.25658831000328064,
-0.6901088356971741,
-0.4576520323753357,
-0.12641431391239166,
-0.04685831815004349,
-0.418067991733551,
-0.6742335557937622,
-0.19211576879024506,
-0.10766354948282242,
0.6289564371109009,
-0.07370375841856003,
-0.06649065017700195,
0.06711013615131378,
-0.33666080236434937,
0.11650727689266205,
0.4885822832584381,
0.6768841743469238,
0.958288311958313,
-0.1505264937877655,
0.5444937944412231,
0.2803901433944702,
-0.5133964419364929,
0.10169607400894165,
0.045859821140766144,
-0.1732923537492752,
0.27360427379608154,
0.8280529379844666,
0.778419017791748,
0.41424909234046936,
-0.5288523435592651,
0.4184638559818268,
0.07725752890110016,
0.07549463212490082,
-0.29715508222579956,
0.081822469830513,
0.27767062187194824,
0.3024647831916809,
0.2942027151584625,
0.04966513440012932,
-0.048439282923936844,
-0.6418204307556152,
0.1576797068119049,
0.2605539858341217,
-0.2747415006160736,
-0.5582451820373535,
0.13231612741947174,
0.4363867938518524,
0.23277735710144043,
0.43675926327705383,
-0.26316967606544495,
-0.6928239464759827,
0.36550775170326233,
0.5331867337226868,
0.3004453182220459,
-0.023800425231456757,
0.48026028275489807,
0.4363458752632141,
0.19688670337200165,
0.05503838136792183,
0.21409828960895538,
0.09354089945554733,
-0.9834483861923218,
-0.8877725601196289,
-0.7274759411811829,
-0.25159746408462524,
-0.0236886665225029,
-0.19830788671970367,
0.40741777420043945,
-0.019522501155734062,
-0.15556706488132477,
-0.023115409538149834,
0.32142534852027893,
-0.628969669342041,
0.15669050812721252,
0.2777637839317322,
0.9466058015823364,
-0.8541096448898315,
0.7045242786407471,
0.6453413963317871,
-0.3306894898414612,
-0.6897266507148743,
-0.08036930859088898,
0.22477637231349945,
-0.6729655861854553,
0.7730532288551331,
-0.18964819610118866,
-0.4591691493988037,
-0.18042610585689545,
-0.25935885310173035,
-1.0620673894882202,
0.9824035167694092,
0.671241283416748,
-0.35453343391418457,
-0.03738749399781227,
0.16983970999717712,
0.3416900336742401,
-0.11748023331165314,
0.17030033469200134,
0.4675271809101105,
0.7576228976249695,
-0.10365135967731476,
-0.7221722602844238,
-0.12803509831428528,
0.03266925364732742,
-0.525449275970459,
0.05981222167611122,
-0.9864674210548401,
0.9554159641265869,
-0.18624919652938843,
-0.370130330324173,
-0.44372180104255676,
0.5728236436843872,
0.3368529975414276,
0.12368268519639969,
0.5210596919059753,
0.3585854172706604,
0.9318917989730835,
0.18392600119113922,
1.183891773223877,
-0.4724591076374054,
0.5297245383262634,
0.9396706819534302,
-0.32796159386634827,
0.5773831605911255,
0.3504471778869629,
-0.3756348490715027,
0.6363051533699036,
0.1861095428466797,
0.1988413780927658,
0.12146445363759995,
-0.31142574548721313,
-0.40789273381233215,
-0.3559371531009674,
-0.43875226378440857,
-0.24308660626411438,
0.9477633833885193,
0.16334287822246552,
0.008232706226408482,
-0.5665733814239502,
-0.3498894274234772,
0.6140695810317993,
0.053603049367666245,
-0.12130391597747803,
0.461887001991272,
-0.019312985241413116,
-0.6805432438850403,
0.37047335505485535,
0.11256544291973114,
0.37661123275756836,
-0.7113178968429565,
0.029393991455435753,
-0.4349479079246521,
-0.16766329109668732,
-0.33595332503318787,
-0.998356282711029,
0.21767684817314148,
0.4456377327442169,
-0.5253304839134216,
0.09941227734088898,
0.5753064155578613,
-0.4957006871700287,
-0.8804285526275635,
0.28471121191978455,
0.8616488575935364,
0.24136057496070862,
0.11912764608860016,
-0.42498779296875,
0.06448081880807877,
-0.055040646344423294,
-0.3799900412559509,
0.16393297910690308,
0.6842532157897949,
-0.00296354154124856,
0.521342933177948,
0.622779905796051,
0.37322723865509033,
-0.0155465854331851,
0.004407968837767839,
0.583797037601471,
-0.5669445991516113,
-0.35055866837501526,
-0.8949050903320312,
0.3717937469482422,
-0.22519510984420776,
-0.22398360073566437,
1.183467149734497,
0.7156760692596436,
0.5587216019630432,
0.03135334700345993,
0.913032591342926,
-0.030253082513809204,
0.6487465500831604,
-0.7511464357376099,
0.645662248134613,
-0.5622826814651489,
0.21569642424583435,
-0.04831789433956146,
-1.0212808847427368,
-0.08264624327421188,
-0.03208962082862854,
-0.13122132420539856,
-0.1966494470834732,
0.901029109954834,
0.4625873267650604,
-0.2949715256690979,
-0.09905599802732468,
0.3451119065284729,
0.44970911741256714,
0.20039577782154083,
0.2124813050031662,
0.7197637557983398,
-0.07995095103979111,
0.6400708556175232,
-0.2403808981180191,
-0.11695532500743866,
0.010972360149025917,
-1.1948446035385132,
-0.6184840202331543,
-0.4699418544769287,
-0.17502252757549286,
-0.10439354181289673,
-0.15959914028644562,
0.6533488631248474,
0.5320132374763489,
-0.761584460735321,
-0.4040224552154541,
0.6100500822067261,
0.6949238777160645,
0.11541853100061417,
-0.19707739353179932,
0.4709712564945221,
-0.5583450794219971,
-0.6356133222579956,
0.5235171318054199,
0.19615258276462555,
-0.4265957176685333,
-0.5151933431625366,
-0.11094122380018234,
-0.40072932839393616,
0.11744648218154907,
0.8604471683502197,
0.05545166879892349,
-0.35380929708480835,
-0.6269219517707825,
0.11387213319540024,
-0.1441567987203598,
0.054058197885751724,
0.7608469724655151,
-0.4176846742630005,
0.4269050061702728,
0.4944937229156494,
0.31256210803985596,
0.36483752727508545,
-0.11859448254108429,
0.45337313413619995,
-1.0919325351715088,
0.1545395404100418,
-0.15561340749263763,
0.42993029952049255,
0.5703827738761902,
-0.22173795104026794,
0.2660052478313446,
0.4334069490432739,
-0.2704980671405792,
-0.4158376157283783,
0.45813262462615967,
-0.5470608472824097,
-0.36528438329696655,
1.2712124586105347,
-0.27840158343315125,
-0.2857809066772461,
-0.19421328604221344,
0.14664384722709656,
0.254369854927063,
-0.3501623868942261,
0.5205473899841309,
1.2299268245697021,
-0.17249512672424316,
-0.14420096576213837,
-0.6478988528251648,
0.4803452491760254,
-0.11951055377721786,
-0.569875180721283,
0.06647306680679321,
0.7819549441337585,
0.5055654048919678,
0.5077708959579468,
0.4200015664100647,
-0.03185146301984787,
0.11611655354499817,
-0.2392614632844925,
-0.07117878645658493,
-0.18173225224018097,
-0.6399505734443665,
0.1349100023508072,
0.3608666658401489,
0.25638070702552795,
0.2784225046634674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14644v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14644v1 | Unveiling the Spectrum of Data Contamination in Language Models: A Survey from Detection to Remediation | 2024-06-20T18:07:26 | 2024-06-20T18:07:26 | Chunyuan Deng, Yilun Zhao, Yuzhao Heng, Yitong Li, Jiannan Cao, Xiangru Tang, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data contamination has garnered increased attention in the era of large
language models (LLMs) due to the reliance on extensive internet-derived
training corpora. The issue of training corpus overlap with evaluation
benchmarks--referred to as contamination--has been the focus of significant
recent research. This body of work aims to identify contamination, understand
its impacts, and explore mitigation strategies from diverse perspectives.
However, comprehensive studies that provide a clear pathway from foundational
concepts to advanced insights are lacking in this nascent field. Therefore, we
present a comprehensive survey in the field of data contamination, laying out
the key issues, methodologies, and findings to date, and highlighting areas in
need of further research and development. In particular, we begin by examining
the effects of data contamination across various stages and forms. We then
provide a detailed analysis of current contamination detection methods,
categorizing them to highlight their focus, assumptions, strengths, and
limitations. We also discuss mitigation strategies, offering a clear guide for
future research. This survey serves as a succinct overview of the most recent
advancements in data contamination research, providing a straightforward guide
for the benefit of future research endeavors. | [
-0.523468017578125,
-1.0544873476028442,
0.5885725617408752,
-0.16416622698307037,
0.0748075395822525,
0.45748716592788696,
-0.17242351174354553,
-0.6986292600631714,
-0.019778186455368996,
1.0961576700210571,
-0.26617008447647095,
-0.4268110692501068,
-0.7464259266853333,
-0.09598622471094131,
-0.9524285197257996,
0.9090947508811951,
-0.10843154042959213,
-0.32211989164352417,
-0.448975145816803,
0.12255984544754028,
-0.3726418912410736,
-0.694261908531189,
-0.6451629996299744,
-0.19190309941768646,
0.6501786708831787,
0.6399644613265991,
0.3993189036846161,
0.9989418983459473,
0.5465366244316101,
0.3337171971797943,
-0.3292343318462372,
0.05201156437397003,
-0.7118629217147827,
0.48042571544647217,
-0.14701692759990692,
-0.5307095646858215,
-0.18034303188323975,
-0.07382158935070038,
0.7694036364555359,
1.2321171760559082,
-0.03755156323313713,
-0.02455088682472706,
0.2529667913913727,
0.6902076005935669,
-1.1288986206054688,
-0.1164848655462265,
-0.7245712876319885,
-0.10610085725784302,
-0.64572674036026,
-0.2294096201658249,
-0.43255361914634705,
-0.3810756802558899,
-0.04305447265505791,
-0.5720444917678833,
0.2761843800544739,
-0.1889653354883194,
0.6602479815483093,
0.2796623408794403,
-0.6131784319877625,
-0.1977183073759079,
-1.0475324392318726,
1.039871335029602,
-0.5690667629241943,
0.3823384940624237,
0.7685039043426514,
0.11208494007587433,
-0.2898734509944916,
-0.9752553701400757,
-0.16742099821567535,
0.06435378640890121,
0.22472603619098663,
-0.2296515852212906,
-0.45592939853668213,
-0.2425455003976822,
0.1696701943874359,
0.2744869887828827,
-0.407737135887146,
0.2494293451309204,
-0.47356995940208435,
-0.3760169446468353,
0.6002908945083618,
0.1953706294298172,
0.5120241045951843,
-0.04876469820737839,
-0.4364948272705078,
-0.08721558004617691,
-1.3519892692565918,
-0.21945814788341522,
0.6083987951278687,
0.16740447282791138,
0.1453225165605545,
0.33404847979545593,
-0.23057079315185547,
0.6627213954925537,
-0.3964371085166931,
0.1167207881808281,
0.2904910445213318,
-0.7568241953849792,
-0.18503664433956146,
-0.09355198591947556,
0.6912791132926941,
0.04436058923602104,
0.1960350126028061,
-0.1939714103937149,
-0.2130679041147232,
-0.14158017933368683,
0.3430587351322174,
-0.5290191173553467,
-0.2898833453655243,
0.32228007912635803,
-0.0570514090359211,
-0.5405537486076355,
-0.30298271775245667,
-0.9864212870597839,
-0.7099717855453491,
-0.4870207607746124,
0.025507625192403793,
-0.24893493950366974,
-0.6019709706306458,
0.1668708771467209,
0.12139903753995895,
-0.15345725417137146,
0.20949307084083557,
-1.0176162719726562,
0.2676738500595093,
1.0175341367721558,
0.33794280886650085,
-0.08526716381311417,
-0.11124295741319656,
-0.308780699968338,
0.07416187226772308,
-0.3174901008605957,
0.9551553130149841,
-0.6429710388183594,
-0.6147674322128296,
0.41427674889564514,
-0.2473064810037613,
0.1159202829003334,
-0.9827423095703125,
0.8316511511802673,
-0.5495843291282654,
0.1944211721420288,
-0.28419795632362366,
-0.8169349431991577,
-0.18413004279136658,
0.166944220662117,
-0.8315609693527222,
1.2582652568817139,
0.017132427543401718,
-1.046391487121582,
0.4689846336841583,
-0.11185947805643082,
-0.32716724276542664,
0.12304844707250595,
-0.17747335135936737,
-0.3043094277381897,
-0.10809393972158432,
-0.09138569235801697,
0.26374465227127075,
-0.27077698707580566,
0.44881492853164673,
-0.4475787281990051,
-0.36354774236679077,
0.3333302140235901,
-0.5994259715080261,
0.7486794590950012,
0.3862721920013428,
-0.15781906247138977,
0.09726269543170929,
-0.923901379108429,
0.02756008878350258,
-0.0988665521144867,
-0.3308292329311371,
-0.5467393398284912,
0.09499244391918182,
0.2563605308532715,
0.18724291026592255,
0.02704296074807644,
-0.37190690636634827,
-0.05561050400137901,
-0.12751835584640503,
0.4043014645576477,
0.7497913837432861,
0.21978440880775452,
0.3560400605201721,
-0.4530642628669739,
0.509434163570404,
0.16272740066051483,
0.36363092064857483,
-0.1668030023574829,
-0.29388076066970825,
-0.7218658328056335,
-0.33215463161468506,
0.37143778800964355,
0.28439223766326904,
-0.6365038156509399,
0.5981355905532837,
-0.4258388876914978,
-0.730134129524231,
-0.5680921673774719,
0.08910490572452545,
0.23144753277301788,
0.49291467666625977,
0.3289439082145691,
-0.1729373186826706,
-0.701653778553009,
-1.0014644861221313,
-0.2879297733306885,
0.06767366081476212,
0.033276960253715515,
0.30390486121177673,
0.6218172907829285,
-0.38551342487335205,
1.1948785781860352,
-0.4769434332847595,
-0.11491507291793823,
-0.17515915632247925,
0.02627326175570488,
-0.1841585487127304,
0.4944874346256256,
0.19794264435768127,
-0.6884682178497314,
-0.4179304838180542,
-0.33481597900390625,
-0.7471922039985657,
-0.35372018814086914,
0.16373516619205475,
0.012540842406451702,
-0.14201503992080688,
0.9172422885894775,
-0.10424809157848358,
0.2329440861940384,
0.5513659119606018,
-0.13663864135742188,
0.5274946689605713,
0.03625750541687012,
0.14995713531970978,
-0.8335747718811035,
0.42034584283828735,
-0.10237058997154236,
-0.2684360146522522,
-1.05198335647583,
-0.06659749895334244,
-0.01500052958726883,
0.23494403064250946,
-0.6243937015533447,
0.36364200711250305,
-0.30596500635147095,
0.04507644474506378,
-0.4223645329475403,
0.4717521369457245,
0.11722742766141891,
-0.1231893002986908,
-0.19466108083724976,
0.6585708856582642,
0.5275051593780518,
-0.4120244085788727,
0.27387112379074097,
0.24621939659118652,
-0.5673025846481323,
0.19816890358924866,
-0.5336899161338806,
0.10840027034282684,
0.04403145611286163,
0.23489601910114288,
-1.0817204713821411,
-0.028545919805765152,
0.5091419816017151,
-0.33099332451820374,
0.400571346282959,
-0.3769476115703583,
-0.6872138977050781,
0.2812461853027344,
-0.2714081108570099,
0.6315640807151794,
0.142431378364563,
-0.48527929186820984,
0.08401496708393097,
0.7369502782821655,
-0.2728053033351898,
-0.7689768671989441,
-0.7195982336997986,
0.3273223042488098,
-0.48410630226135254,
-0.7147241234779358,
0.03166580945253372,
0.1376609057188034,
-0.6586288809776306,
0.04235076531767845,
-0.07722221314907074,
-0.39366522431373596,
0.6740215420722961,
0.09770683199167252,
0.16252323985099792,
-0.019163761287927628,
0.09872917085886002,
-0.10381729155778885,
-0.06818895787000656,
0.21861544251441956,
0.33283182978630066,
0.7544318437576294,
0.4451134502887726,
-0.5004754066467285,
-0.17303726077079773,
0.3648207187652588,
0.31742197275161743,
-0.3436838388442993,
0.7098560929298401,
0.17796334624290466,
-0.4362391233444214,
-0.17916099727153778,
-0.5101810097694397,
-0.1361577808856964,
-0.540732204914093,
0.3662530779838562,
-0.06101657822728157,
-0.7251574397087097,
0.5131365060806274,
-0.28012242913246155,
-0.09871143102645874,
0.333708792924881,
0.14285831153392792,
-0.15859265625476837,
0.4170668423175812,
0.7069091200828552,
-0.20408087968826294,
0.6464431285858154,
-0.20654882490634918,
0.19520549476146698,
-0.8570188879966736,
-0.13562102615833282,
-0.7884808778762817,
0.1306629776954651,
-0.6685722470283508,
-0.4114190936088562,
-0.026816658675670624,
0.04183609038591385,
-0.07738630473613739,
0.11271192133426666,
-0.11271405965089798,
0.4379071295261383,
0.27486059069633484,
-0.18279090523719788,
0.5772130489349365,
-0.14662595093250275,
0.06723543256521225,
-0.057850100100040436,
-0.4727500081062317,
-0.6743295192718506,
1.4220666885375977,
0.507131814956665,
0.693992018699646,
-0.030386075377464294,
0.8992407917976379,
0.3538183867931366,
0.2645730972290039,
-0.26977235078811646,
0.3873730003833771,
-0.12477301061153412,
-0.9002684950828552,
-0.15597684681415558,
-0.614989697933197,
-1.2760450839996338,
0.2879927456378937,
-0.09899219870567322,
-0.8044357299804688,
0.3466200828552246,
-0.14926524460315704,
0.11560031771659851,
0.32711511850357056,
-0.42976343631744385,
0.8511346578598022,
-0.15101024508476257,
-0.5233039855957031,
-0.08224222809076309,
-0.5816836357116699,
0.7149963974952698,
-0.5118533372879028,
0.6781882643699646,
-0.19959622621536255,
0.07548162341117859,
0.7644715905189514,
-0.216389000415802,
0.7734715342521667,
-0.03552694991230965,
-0.5899786949157715,
0.12390220910310745,
0.06900794804096222,
0.4447336792945862,
-0.4009091854095459,
0.29517704248428345,
0.24440494179725647,
0.10297927260398865,
-0.33443668484687805,
-0.23825456202030182,
0.5295745730400085,
-0.5123611688613892,
-0.27056634426116943,
-0.4442795217037201,
-0.5437519550323486,
-0.5119557976722717,
0.23988953232765198,
0.3060946762561798,
0.2774375081062317,
-0.1433815062046051,
0.4645044505596161,
0.9600741267204285,
-0.3756130635738373,
0.25281938910484314,
0.47741636633872986,
-0.49630627036094666,
-0.1502954512834549,
1.0106359720230103,
-0.03527740389108658,
0.64979088306427,
0.1868375688791275,
-0.03637745603919029,
-0.29053184390068054,
-0.792951226234436,
0.05177812650799751,
0.25813162326812744,
-0.736341655254364,
-0.02803114615380764,
-0.5345708131790161,
-0.1104683056473732,
-0.40840011835098267,
0.31515800952911377,
-0.5990145206451416,
-0.0889705941081047,
-0.3681577742099762,
-0.08934880048036575,
0.20627786219120026,
0.7952319979667664,
-0.025334276258945465,
0.3765560984611511,
-0.7959129214286804,
0.08957403898239136,
-0.35236048698425293,
0.38856086134910583,
-0.21139532327651978,
-0.522372305393219,
-0.2981422245502472,
0.20644575357437134,
-0.16089528799057007,
-0.7181128859519958,
0.30533266067504883,
-0.007940108887851238,
0.7415582537651062,
0.5668131113052368,
-0.022463470697402954,
0.4215419292449951,
-0.24167415499687195,
0.6544924974441528,
-0.10794520378112793,
-0.8336445689201355,
0.46317192912101746,
-0.5144078731536865,
-0.2466578334569931,
0.7133378386497498,
0.31447336077690125,
-1.1524618864059448,
-0.8546333312988281,
-0.6554157137870789,
-1.36319100856781,
0.430219441652298,
0.13276731967926025,
-0.03785460442304611,
0.1681763082742691,
0.17616169154644012,
-0.010367021895945072,
0.16424225270748138,
-0.34404054284095764,
-0.3645857274532318,
0.25106996297836304,
-0.07788997888565063,
-0.04613824561238289,
-0.4719042479991913,
-0.3685581684112549,
0.21005207300186157,
0.6412695646286011,
0.29468032717704773,
-0.21974025666713715,
-0.2586919367313385,
-0.5424046516418457,
0.04764905944466591,
0.3176579475402832,
0.5147979259490967,
0.6856633424758911,
-0.024784451350569725,
0.1789536029100418,
-0.20834565162658691,
-0.7446250915527344,
0.11226393282413483,
-0.0529615581035614,
-0.268148809671402,
-0.2613307535648346,
0.6579548716545105,
0.27840548753738403,
0.5837752223014832,
-0.8674529790878296,
0.4670444428920746,
-0.07087694853544235,
-0.04371397942304611,
-0.33672869205474854,
0.08340846747159958,
0.1778229922056198,
-0.08508731424808502,
0.36763158440589905,
-0.12122862786054611,
0.25379514694213867,
-0.6110919117927551,
0.6858100891113281,
0.11940169334411621,
-0.16994144022464752,
0.060652825981378555,
0.4674524962902069,
0.14520002901554108,
0.28003615140914917,
0.69461989402771,
0.18621841073036194,
-0.334616482257843,
0.6484140157699585,
0.1845405250787735,
0.5601586699485779,
-0.24656890332698822,
-0.07996436208486557,
-0.005962288938462734,
0.3853306770324707,
0.0959499403834343,
0.24264413118362427,
0.3086514174938202,
-0.9585353136062622,
-0.5632489323616028,
-0.3557274639606476,
-0.4058576822280884,
0.5238702297210693,
-0.8957253694534302,
0.001144655398093164,
-0.25778377056121826,
0.03647935763001442,
0.20766809582710266,
0.1558285653591156,
-0.32772940397262573,
0.11070797592401505,
0.29922935366630554,
0.9305412173271179,
-1.254546046257019,
0.8377904295921326,
0.09972569346427917,
-0.49679890275001526,
-0.44629067182540894,
0.0027212814893573523,
0.32832106947898865,
-0.5638444423675537,
0.6302735209465027,
-0.06122985854744911,
-0.010869581252336502,
-0.2074161320924759,
-0.3089998662471771,
-1.0996206998825073,
0.6863874793052673,
0.3014058470726013,
-0.45084095001220703,
0.46370700001716614,
0.5230924487113953,
0.523667573928833,
0.13851583003997803,
0.17457649111747742,
1.0907025337219238,
0.6515933871269226,
-0.21506215631961823,
-0.5594443082809448,
-0.04769029840826988,
-0.17244696617126465,
-0.1374901533126831,
0.256942480802536,
-0.2450217604637146,
0.556889533996582,
0.4470256268978119,
-0.31082409620285034,
0.12452703714370728,
0.31818777322769165,
0.18319877982139587,
0.258158415555954,
0.507621169090271,
0.6579458117485046,
0.9382371306419373,
-0.32032105326652527,
0.8196263313293457,
-0.29981741309165955,
0.3355172574520111,
1.3545864820480347,
-0.4563964605331421,
0.8234538435935974,
0.5328906178474426,
-0.4079831838607788,
0.2634529769420624,
0.8688904643058777,
-0.1526361107826233,
0.39052996039390564,
0.6451458930969238,
-0.5033775568008423,
0.14607824385166168,
-0.4056473672389984,
-0.36903682351112366,
0.7023287415504456,
0.5068748593330383,
-0.3696499764919281,
-0.3988979458808899,
0.12020350247621536,
0.3183363974094391,
0.1866346150636673,
0.019600341096520424,
0.7241666316986084,
-0.23323191702365875,
-0.5597114562988281,
0.42171189188957214,
-0.09446042776107788,
0.4597397744655609,
-0.45987722277641296,
0.054998062551021576,
-0.5468717217445374,
0.13620628416538239,
-0.4283085763454437,
-0.9955096244812012,
0.46594175696372986,
0.08139768242835999,
-0.12850230932235718,
-0.46648970246315,
0.720212996006012,
-0.6300882697105408,
-0.04621674865484238,
0.6234349608421326,
0.7927009463310242,
0.513006865978241,
-0.2570739984512329,
-0.3327452540397644,
0.6077160835266113,
-0.11677070707082748,
-0.10775231570005417,
0.5529695153236389,
0.2148766964673996,
0.03525424003601074,
0.849337100982666,
0.7238127589225769,
0.21738384664058685,
0.32516661286354065,
0.33804795145988464,
0.8813604712486267,
-0.4951770603656769,
0.03923862427473068,
-0.7670814990997314,
0.45833078026771545,
0.11009062826633453,
-0.1327732503414154,
0.6750425696372986,
1.0136746168136597,
0.7817714810371399,
0.362140417098999,
0.9546634554862976,
0.2316884845495224,
0.6818608045578003,
-0.4428960084915161,
0.8038708567619324,
-0.3610944151878357,
0.5931462645530701,
-0.13716091215610504,
-0.714979887008667,
-0.2912866771221161,
0.10283713787794113,
-0.21355336904525757,
0.0887489840388298,
0.6239598989486694,
0.7103886604309082,
-0.10410897433757782,
0.0958714410662651,
0.19435065984725952,
0.2634628117084503,
0.6805181503295898,
0.28193730115890503,
1.1508451700210571,
-0.23897551000118256,
0.6649730801582336,
-0.4186064302921295,
-0.18566234409809113,
-0.2475530356168747,
-0.7929410338401794,
-0.13331861793994904,
-0.580721914768219,
-0.39529675245285034,
-0.18454958498477936,
0.08337583392858505,
0.2386564016342163,
0.40193691849708557,
-0.7169778943061829,
-0.174850195646286,
-0.1576257050037384,
0.21628408133983612,
-0.09038976579904556,
-0.21873222291469574,
0.41674482822418213,
-0.5136570930480957,
-0.8121996521949768,
0.5860616564750671,
-0.2684023082256317,
-0.2846413850784302,
-0.30585718154907227,
0.5536511540412903,
-0.280233770608902,
-0.18198327720165253,
0.49203142523765564,
0.4104074239730835,
-0.4104376435279846,
-0.4204176962375641,
-0.27307307720184326,
-0.4022350311279297,
0.038341715931892395,
0.8130735158920288,
-0.5097348690032959,
0.43140408396720886,
0.4609026610851288,
0.7718150019645691,
0.35390016436576843,
-0.10531605780124664,
0.5315467119216919,
-0.9472595453262329,
-0.3369223475456238,
0.24471157789230347,
0.5070421099662781,
0.6023458242416382,
-0.4211598038673401,
0.6630609035491943,
0.30365389585494995,
-0.7270461320877075,
-1.0916606187820435,
0.24870789051055908,
-0.7855121493339539,
-0.3611082434654236,
1.4733303785324097,
-0.16672033071517944,
0.017907215282320976,
-0.5125917196273804,
0.11533616483211517,
0.3078937232494354,
-0.024129128083586693,
0.8537895679473877,
0.9655876159667969,
0.00013796701387036592,
0.01847393624484539,
-0.9314448833465576,
0.39918816089630127,
0.26205357909202576,
-1.2824956178665161,
0.6268569231033325,
0.669996440410614,
0.7175356149673462,
-0.015426614321768284,
0.411558598279953,
-0.4048617482185364,
-0.008835799992084503,
-0.0007482448709197342,
0.08910781890153885,
0.17422595620155334,
-0.26479101181030273,
-0.6667318344116211,
-0.021972138434648514,
-0.0120506901293993,
-0.17211392521858215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14643v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14643v1 | Holistic Evaluation for Interleaved Text-and-Image Generation | 2024-06-20T18:07:19 | 2024-06-20T18:07:19 | Minqian Liu, Zhiyang Xu, Zihao Lin, Trevor Ashby, Joy Rimchala, Jiaxin Zhang, Lifu Huang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Interleaved text-and-image generation has been an intriguing research
direction, where the models are required to generate both images and text
pieces in an arbitrary order. Despite the emerging advancements in interleaved
generation, the progress in its evaluation still significantly lags behind.
Existing evaluation benchmarks do not support arbitrarily interleaved images
and text for both inputs and outputs, and they only cover a limited number of
domains and use cases. Also, current works predominantly use similarity-based
metrics which fall short in assessing the quality in open-ended scenarios. To
this end, we introduce InterleavedBench, the first benchmark carefully curated
for the evaluation of interleaved text-and-image generation. InterleavedBench
features a rich array of tasks to cover diverse real-world use cases. In
addition, we present InterleavedEval, a strong reference-free metric powered by
GPT-4o to deliver accurate and explainable evaluation. We carefully define five
essential evaluation aspects for InterleavedEval, including text quality,
perceptual quality, image coherence, text-image coherence, and helpfulness, to
ensure a comprehensive and fine-grained assessment. Through extensive
experiments and rigorous human evaluation, we show that our benchmark and
metric can effectively evaluate the existing models with a strong correlation
with human judgments surpassing previous reference-based metrics. We also
provide substantial findings and insights to foster future research in
interleaved generation and its evaluation. | [
-0.5711270570755005,
-0.5367173552513123,
0.3858141005039215,
0.6458963751792908,
-0.5222362875938416,
0.2750464379787445,
-0.22257277369499207,
-0.47857752442359924,
-0.5438295006752014,
0.004437276627868414,
-0.4917401373386383,
-0.37413644790649414,
-0.6203415989875793,
0.0062192101031541824,
-0.4210163950920105,
0.9646821618080139,
-0.002324266592040658,
0.14146150648593903,
-0.6451672315597534,
-0.27532193064689636,
-0.5298498272895813,
0.05274154990911484,
-0.301800936460495,
-0.4542098939418793,
0.05776950344443321,
0.2656969130039215,
0.6435638666152954,
0.21023067831993103,
0.8100313544273376,
0.21433334052562714,
0.22619931399822235,
0.2208269238471985,
-0.5140495300292969,
0.23813475668430328,
-0.350960373878479,
0.2880825400352478,
-0.07740461826324463,
0.13711249828338623,
0.5133336782455444,
0.41611042618751526,
0.15235820412635803,
0.29564738273620605,
0.5088279843330383,
0.7561027407646179,
-0.7604402899742126,
0.08526004105806351,
-0.8508298993110657,
0.15714223682880402,
-0.25156500935554504,
-0.39727258682250977,
-0.3232545554637909,
-0.4954072833061218,
-0.02764425240457058,
-0.47632309794425964,
0.4345962107181549,
0.024255577474832535,
0.8201384544372559,
0.1462513655424118,
-0.12166764587163925,
-0.5664366483688354,
-0.547931969165802,
0.6417304277420044,
-0.6040425300598145,
0.26689258217811584,
0.2516729533672333,
0.15405058860778809,
-0.13891854882240295,
-0.9243504405021667,
-0.698076605796814,
-0.32067951560020447,
0.21960966289043427,
0.6523001194000244,
-0.39880532026290894,
-0.06254953891038895,
-0.020501375198364258,
0.7166082859039307,
-0.5483357906341553,
0.1782246232032776,
-0.18370020389556885,
-0.11559091508388519,
0.6441379189491272,
0.018420035019516945,
0.3565312325954437,
-0.13681736588478088,
-0.5623559355735779,
-0.36824557185173035,
-0.5501352548599243,
-0.26917141675949097,
0.7994645237922668,
0.0426686592400074,
-0.0472552590072155,
0.5092670917510986,
-0.2721390128135681,
0.41678759455680847,
0.09988746792078018,
0.13456779718399048,
0.024442926049232483,
-0.6813077926635742,
0.1647794097661972,
-0.02924986369907856,
1.1447843313217163,
0.7288195490837097,
-0.016510119661688805,
-0.3974818289279938,
-0.1186080202460289,
0.3109142780303955,
0.45901554822921753,
-1.2038676738739014,
-0.0522044375538826,
-0.025972191244363785,
-0.6437205076217651,
-0.3080567717552185,
0.08448386937379837,
-0.9849430918693542,
-0.2481292188167572,
0.03734312206506729,
0.5350217819213867,
-0.5513195991516113,
-0.1285264790058136,
-0.27101027965545654,
0.029652833938598633,
0.03453540802001953,
0.21844014525413513,
-0.7342991828918457,
0.24220216274261475,
0.6822449564933777,
0.8591557741165161,
-0.2901696264743805,
-0.30094364285469055,
-0.4083031713962555,
-0.33453455567359924,
-0.33512619137763977,
0.8801276087760925,
-0.20122818648815155,
-0.41986197233200073,
0.10023517161607742,
-0.3257361352443695,
0.4898074269294739,
-0.6016491651535034,
0.7219851613044739,
-0.5831464529037476,
0.41617950797080994,
-0.10134286433458328,
-0.6400984525680542,
0.07990359514951706,
0.18896129727363586,
-0.624038815498352,
1.069189429283142,
0.21446998417377472,
-0.8478638529777527,
0.7843856811523438,
-0.5340659618377686,
-0.4498845636844635,
0.4857880175113678,
-0.26777681708335876,
-0.8219191431999207,
0.33203691244125366,
0.04558705911040306,
0.5356826782226562,
-0.9065901637077332,
0.5304805040359497,
-0.3555305302143097,
-0.2832395136356354,
-0.033287953585386276,
-0.6891723871231079,
0.3610008656978607,
0.20600496232509613,
-0.4305204153060913,
-0.03737981617450714,
-0.7940836548805237,
0.42570260167121887,
0.1749597042798996,
-0.33140328526496887,
-0.2309456169605255,
0.006691190879791975,
0.3321647047996521,
0.20243027806282043,
0.18662944436073303,
-0.7984524369239807,
-0.107973612844944,
-0.07581422477960587,
0.4537636935710907,
0.5357389450073242,
0.2249097377061844,
0.35104233026504517,
-0.19188156723976135,
0.3448493480682373,
0.055181797593832016,
0.13659654557704926,
-0.3523673117160797,
-0.4997991919517517,
-0.49015170335769653,
0.22161605954170227,
0.3866898715496063,
0.12340985238552094,
-0.7981299757957458,
0.3743295669555664,
-0.3295768201351166,
-0.8416681885719299,
-0.4294610321521759,
-0.1594114452600479,
0.8437225818634033,
0.6257808208465576,
0.5992584228515625,
-0.6703585982322693,
-0.11563396453857422,
-0.9669302701950073,
-0.4937911331653595,
-0.20902642607688904,
0.11862024664878845,
-0.026511438190937042,
0.271422803401947,
-0.09329047054052353,
0.5780906081199646,
-0.08105452358722687,
-0.06521196663379669,
0.21578413248062134,
0.5913174748420715,
-0.039631105959415436,
0.6082437038421631,
0.2581980228424072,
-0.7180194854736328,
-0.6366705894470215,
0.1380496770143509,
-0.59002286195755,
-0.12264380604028702,
-0.23219238221645355,
-0.16926847398281097,
-0.0463079996407032,
0.6655393242835999,
-0.32291531562805176,
0.6788600087165833,
0.7403726577758789,
-0.278274267911911,
0.6324192881584167,
-0.2995936870574951,
0.5448571443557739,
-0.8962379693984985,
0.03687947615981102,
-0.19625000655651093,
-0.07942984998226166,
-0.27330663800239563,
0.22144891321659088,
0.29463350772857666,
-0.057483308017253876,
-0.18887576460838318,
0.5253852605819702,
-0.5710746645927429,
-0.5034693479537964,
-0.10200042277574539,
-0.00268759299069643,
0.35154488682746887,
0.12494740635156631,
-0.43449217081069946,
1.0270315408706665,
0.034346938133239746,
-0.363564133644104,
0.0471140593290329,
0.31357264518737793,
-0.9398790597915649,
0.9438506960868835,
-0.5926252007484436,
0.2896196246147156,
0.03679267689585686,
-0.01746595837175846,
-0.8926877975463867,
-0.2305680513381958,
-0.07195041328668594,
-0.28504469990730286,
0.1298488974571228,
0.3260769844055176,
-0.7988940477371216,
-0.2604375183582306,
-0.11939413100481033,
0.621565043926239,
0.6666587591171265,
-0.8349990844726562,
0.0036712519358843565,
-0.03540777042508125,
-0.24954143166542053,
-0.27640336751937866,
-0.40896114706993103,
0.3128679692745209,
0.004027251619845629,
-0.6535131335258484,
0.8493571281433105,
-0.4224300682544708,
-0.2408687323331833,
0.1958504021167755,
0.0876261442899704,
-0.02165435254573822,
-0.12605693936347961,
0.3053627014160156,
0.10997212678194046,
-0.15522955358028412,
0.2568354308605194,
0.27734676003456116,
-0.11196338385343552,
-0.19019007682800293,
-0.05067844316363335,
0.4990672171115875,
-0.28292185068130493,
-0.6692386865615845,
-0.19730903208255768,
0.41182252764701843,
0.346876859664917,
-0.20912881195545197,
0.16019541025161743,
0.7227306962013245,
-0.2167186439037323,
0.023941904306411743,
-0.5264300107955933,
0.16674461960792542,
-0.42719319462776184,
0.5046430230140686,
-0.2227732241153717,
-0.5066587328910828,
0.11250165849924088,
-0.3107564449310303,
0.2542436718940735,
0.6074028015136719,
0.7828299403190613,
-0.20469509065151215,
0.870245099067688,
0.3175472915172577,
0.6853857040405273,
0.3553330600261688,
0.06501393020153046,
0.25363314151763916,
-0.7904049158096313,
-0.28333982825279236,
-0.1724766492843628,
-0.3226606249809265,
-0.34139007329940796,
-0.4205077886581421,
0.4229513704776764,
0.4325675964355469,
-0.01303511019796133,
0.06387429684400558,
-0.6498703956604004,
0.5164176821708679,
0.48595553636550903,
0.14349408447742462,
0.5306476950645447,
0.11267101764678955,
-0.2090596705675125,
-0.142449289560318,
-0.5234567523002625,
-0.6694309711456299,
0.8572274446487427,
0.03285791724920273,
0.43332141637802124,
-0.1385796219110489,
0.6260243654251099,
0.6228153705596924,
0.5920864343643188,
-0.5748631954193115,
0.482552170753479,
-0.4003596007823944,
-0.2343459278345108,
0.10801040381193161,
-0.14963342249393463,
-1.0394752025604248,
0.20935313403606415,
-0.4360073208808899,
-0.2631051242351532,
0.04481734707951546,
0.1935271918773651,
-0.1663181483745575,
0.15129217505455017,
-0.5268844962120056,
0.6845039129257202,
-0.29143261909484863,
-0.7402716279029846,
-0.3550975024700165,
-0.49056515097618103,
0.5073135495185852,
-0.12301932275295258,
0.07925057411193848,
-0.15734678506851196,
0.15352240204811096,
0.5048319101333618,
-0.6744946837425232,
0.18597561120986938,
0.00041818912723101676,
0.055489443242549896,
0.3766394555568695,
-0.04819498211145401,
0.024949703365564346,
-0.16844771802425385,
-0.24978455901145935,
0.417768269777298,
-0.18532271683216095,
-0.27037522196769714,
-0.3071839511394501,
0.8612092733383179,
-0.5772253274917603,
-0.049211908131837845,
-0.13230158388614655,
-0.5241270661354065,
-0.41305285692214966,
0.2512763440608978,
1.048156499862671,
0.5476999282836914,
-0.6206861734390259,
0.3235854506492615,
0.24305188655853271,
-0.31586745381355286,
0.684354305267334,
-0.06812188774347305,
-0.2306748926639557,
-0.6832761168479919,
0.9079961180686951,
0.048853252083063126,
0.4888187646865845,
0.114518903195858,
0.18397125601768494,
-0.4120238125324249,
-0.6318535804748535,
-0.6737157106399536,
-0.11116731911897659,
-0.8628941774368286,
-0.5035122632980347,
-0.4199192225933075,
-0.17297913134098053,
0.04819273203611374,
-0.10508189350366592,
-0.34168148040771484,
-0.04939854517579079,
-0.5160653591156006,
0.16846315562725067,
0.07172828167676926,
0.6940838694572449,
-0.04716670513153076,
0.3633020222187042,
-0.8032712340354919,
0.475375235080719,
0.26613837480545044,
0.4646104872226715,
0.15482810139656067,
-0.08710388839244843,
-0.31219005584716797,
-0.1869429647922516,
-0.5644589066505432,
-0.6369028687477112,
0.13992640376091003,
0.3899964392185211,
0.31158533692359924,
0.20688208937644958,
-0.056883394718170166,
0.8051632046699524,
-0.6484176516532898,
0.6072402000427246,
0.675442636013031,
-0.9718663692474365,
0.38537320494651794,
-0.07754267752170563,
0.5374084115028381,
0.737335205078125,
0.041910093277692795,
-0.13203103840351105,
-0.1742018163204193,
-0.7844094038009644,
-0.853011965751648,
0.2461710423231125,
0.46164560317993164,
0.02158297598361969,
0.016070831567049026,
0.2891051471233368,
0.5627599954605103,
0.2378683239221573,
-0.5690233707427979,
0.45996320247650146,
-0.5140336155891418,
-0.3419491946697235,
0.15035125613212585,
-0.166367769241333,
0.0820237323641777,
0.06731521338224411,
0.5365149974822998,
-0.15029656887054443,
0.08302690088748932,
0.20654475688934326,
-0.2648653984069824,
-0.22223134338855743,
0.2892712950706482,
0.18404541909694672,
0.378489226102829,
0.20873917639255524,
0.04859485849738121,
-0.26823505759239197,
-0.6243849992752075,
0.2520734369754791,
-0.015452246181666851,
-0.2851085960865021,
-0.08160845935344696,
0.6217281818389893,
0.9676462411880493,
0.052255045622587204,
-0.676613986492157,
0.7274847626686096,
-0.46298161149024963,
-0.286163866519928,
0.0498066246509552,
-0.07391373068094254,
-0.11607552319765091,
0.2869664132595062,
0.254606693983078,
0.33603301644325256,
0.15511809289455414,
-0.40931791067123413,
0.07975172996520996,
0.48096299171447754,
-0.4992751479148865,
-0.4208220839500427,
0.6378267407417297,
0.19512860476970673,
-0.30612853169441223,
0.6308228969573975,
-0.49600306153297424,
-0.21780265867710114,
0.5706322193145752,
0.6059696674346924,
1.0675067901611328,
0.13032469153404236,
0.06321419030427933,
0.5572927594184875,
0.3614930510520935,
0.1493695080280304,
0.3934069871902466,
-0.28137078881263733,
-0.5665302276611328,
-0.1851743757724762,
-0.7496218681335449,
-0.35843127965927124,
0.1926090568304062,
-0.7967820167541504,
0.14518865942955017,
-0.6020798087120056,
-0.34707948565483093,
-0.09235019236803055,
-0.18758359551429749,
-0.8437575697898865,
0.34017011523246765,
-0.062383510172367096,
0.6936710476875305,
-0.5634467005729675,
0.34892016649246216,
0.4845936894416809,
-0.39357081055641174,
-0.29798996448516846,
0.46472904086112976,
-0.4677916169166565,
-0.7611681818962097,
0.6159243583679199,
0.2918208837509155,
-0.11012060195207596,
0.17870186269283295,
-0.3650553226470947,
-0.3163578510284424,
1.2058683633804321,
0.16630412638187408,
-0.6710529327392578,
0.2328958362340927,
0.00041119306115433574,
0.5429722666740417,
-0.267666757106781,
0.2859048545360565,
0.36490732431411743,
0.3561335802078247,
-0.08061037212610245,
-0.551146388053894,
0.0029806012753397226,
-0.4462001621723175,
0.3819121718406677,
0.14847904443740845,
-0.764655351638794,
0.8267812132835388,
-0.21374629437923431,
-0.669114887714386,
0.5282605290412903,
0.6710742115974426,
0.16946516931056976,
0.3764568269252777,
0.5997776985168457,
0.6247536540031433,
0.35452115535736084,
-0.18586844205856323,
1.0106847286224365,
-0.4354299008846283,
0.2523426115512848,
1.1415828466415405,
-0.3477187156677246,
0.8352816104888916,
0.4347580075263977,
-0.23428566753864288,
0.44913414120674133,
0.6691032648086548,
0.03633785620331764,
0.788220226764679,
-0.010136043652892113,
-0.4058988094329834,
-0.04664686694741249,
-0.31594058871269226,
-0.4358605146408081,
0.40914255380630493,
0.24631370604038239,
-0.3283725380897522,
-0.4908309876918793,
0.05977226793766022,
-0.27578774094581604,
0.2886010706424713,
-0.02734389714896679,
0.7474982738494873,
-0.2402428239583969,
-1.024139642715454,
0.42673149704933167,
-0.04906816780567169,
0.5611326098442078,
-0.43445122241973877,
-0.17121240496635437,
0.04192493110895157,
0.1513543426990509,
-0.22975315153598785,
-0.9346131086349487,
0.16363881528377533,
0.14417965710163116,
-0.2546217441558838,
-0.2647276222705841,
0.9231145977973938,
-0.305210679769516,
-0.3020837903022766,
0.3186623156070709,
0.21261027455329895,
-0.07925461232662201,
-0.08979424089193344,
-0.6192046403884888,
0.2578679621219635,
-0.14298227429389954,
-0.06638148427009583,
0.3336161971092224,
0.3192771077156067,
-0.06163284555077553,
0.03102201595902443,
0.8148064017295837,
-0.2534782588481903,
0.1752007007598877,
0.16292808949947357,
0.653795599937439,
-0.2896896302700043,
-0.3909907042980194,
-0.8507410883903503,
0.5025253295898438,
-0.1971195787191391,
-0.6250112652778625,
0.6015977263450623,
0.5747570991516113,
0.7507972717285156,
-0.08674801141023636,
0.9903609752655029,
-0.04315634444355965,
0.08742524683475494,
-0.5296679735183716,
0.7639239430427551,
-0.5375943779945374,
-0.20947015285491943,
-0.4375205934047699,
-1.1558523178100586,
-0.04073046147823334,
0.3347930312156677,
-0.145020991563797,
-0.11615468561649323,
0.5766306519508362,
0.37435394525527954,
-0.1816202700138092,
0.2928643226623535,
0.43172094225883484,
0.00436338922008872,
0.33013227581977844,
0.1816481053829193,
1.2271184921264648,
-0.7114974856376648,
0.4101108908653259,
-0.33635079860687256,
-0.4215066730976105,
-0.14318063855171204,
-1.2961177825927734,
-0.43780624866485596,
-0.8077739477157593,
-0.3096674978733063,
-0.33091962337493896,
-0.17967438697814941,
0.44029903411865234,
0.6810240149497986,
-0.3137074410915375,
-0.02009405568242073,
-0.7572872042655945,
-0.45832616090774536,
0.03792760521173477,
-0.2352403998374939,
0.12642641365528107,
-0.3292931318283081,
-0.7073734402656555,
0.3450329899787903,
0.7580165266990662,
0.09502378106117249,
-0.7474502921104431,
-0.07202267646789551,
-0.09348323941230774,
0.11661515384912491,
0.8183161020278931,
0.08926793187856674,
-0.625023365020752,
0.008536444045603275,
-0.3185230791568756,
-0.14752158522605896,
0.1386582851409912,
0.6849919557571411,
-0.8147371411323547,
0.7640241384506226,
0.6019256114959717,
0.6785333156585693,
0.5499947667121887,
0.03991590440273285,
0.26909923553466797,
-0.8804556727409363,
0.13721731305122375,
0.4273674190044403,
0.33497700095176697,
0.681419849395752,
-0.29245254397392273,
0.572395920753479,
0.028968023136258125,
-0.7193309664726257,
-0.7440699338912964,
0.28327253460884094,
-0.627760648727417,
-0.06503180414438248,
0.7253766655921936,
-0.27113035321235657,
0.16707897186279297,
0.22891861200332642,
-0.14138151705265045,
0.2932144105434418,
-0.0022632351610809565,
0.6356358528137207,
0.6880804300308228,
-0.20015031099319458,
0.14731517434120178,
-0.2253725528717041,
0.06758624315261841,
0.4540906548500061,
-1.304511547088623,
-0.15277381241321564,
0.595108151435852,
-0.17730489373207092,
0.22370441257953644,
0.7194197773933411,
-0.37760213017463684,
0.24761143326759338,
0.2889302372932434,
0.20422029495239258,
0.32868051528930664,
-0.14653736352920532,
-0.08550146967172623,
0.17640700936317444,
-0.03956848382949829,
-0.1375110000371933
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14629v1 | Can LLMs Learn by Teaching? A Preliminary Study | 2024-06-20T18:00:17 | 2024-06-20T18:00:17 | Xuefei Ning, Zifu Wang, Shiyao Li, Zinan Lin, Peiran Yao, Tianyu Fu, Matthew B. Blaschko, Guohao Dai, Huazhong Yang, Yu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Teaching to improve student models (e.g., knowledge distillation) is an
extensively studied methodology in LLMs. However, for humans, teaching not only
improves students but also improves teachers. We ask: Can LLMs also learn by
teaching (LbT)? If yes, we can potentially unlock the possibility of
continuously advancing the models without solely relying on human-produced data
or stronger models. In this paper, we provide a preliminary exploration of this
ambitious agenda. We show that LbT ideas can be incorporated into existing LLM
training/prompting pipelines and provide noticeable improvements. Specifically,
we design three methods, each mimicking one of the three levels of LbT in
humans: observing students' feedback, learning from the feedback, and learning
iteratively, with the goals of improving answer accuracy without training and
improving models' inherent capability with fine-tuning. The findings are
encouraging. For example, similar to LbT in human, we see that: (1) LbT can
induce weak-to-strong generalization: strong models can improve themselves by
teaching other weak models; (2) Diversity in students might help: teaching
multiple students could be better than teaching one student or the teacher
itself. We hope that this early promise can inspire future research on LbT and
more broadly adopting the advanced techniques in education to improve LLMs. The
code is available at https://github.com/imagination-research/lbt. | [
-0.19712784886360168,
-0.6686344742774963,
0.6291472911834717,
-0.2504684329032898,
-0.2464006245136261,
0.36202242970466614,
-0.22680918872356415,
-0.38314518332481384,
-0.09681501239538193,
0.06236806884407997,
-0.5436736941337585,
-0.20828580856323242,
-0.4620205760002136,
-0.13090983033180237,
-0.28118187189102173,
1.0122092962265015,
0.11402055621147156,
0.736427366733551,
-0.42759305238723755,
0.10866738855838776,
-0.7030317187309265,
-0.43628552556037903,
-0.7646399736404419,
-0.49496644735336304,
0.7455766201019287,
0.66988205909729,
0.2563680112361908,
0.541215717792511,
0.2671004831790924,
0.15279673039913177,
-0.010392087511718273,
0.2293129414319992,
-0.6595891118049622,
-0.03873477131128311,
-0.2455243170261383,
-1.0438785552978516,
-0.2004668116569519,
0.27390021085739136,
0.7491893172264099,
1.0465800762176514,
-0.3537345230579376,
-0.06914328038692474,
0.7341117858886719,
0.69078129529953,
-0.21682001650333405,
-0.09733133018016815,
-0.682841420173645,
0.09375348687171936,
0.2277669906616211,
-0.06833306699991226,
-0.40481987595558167,
-0.45778900384902954,
0.02231501415371895,
-0.3009595274925232,
0.3405749201774597,
-0.06059935688972473,
0.4007338881492615,
0.23176130652427673,
-0.5536595582962036,
-0.36906060576438904,
-0.5595378875732422,
0.6762675642967224,
-0.640217125415802,
0.3379330337047577,
0.2487410306930542,
0.35364267230033875,
0.004436017479747534,
-0.7583103775978088,
-0.20879308879375458,
-0.3539556860923767,
0.009980697184801102,
0.48172128200531006,
0.25160765647888184,
-0.036188364028930664,
0.5200555920600891,
0.3919098377227783,
-0.23740342259407043,
0.21264860033988953,
-0.6204981803894043,
0.018669018521904945,
0.3771371841430664,
0.12660014629364014,
0.04251210018992424,
-0.04494737833738327,
-0.6444346904754639,
-0.21832971274852753,
-0.6759560704231262,
0.24042122066020966,
0.16185148060321808,
0.32119759917259216,
0.0713919997215271,
0.4157710671424866,
0.11746866255998611,
0.5504533648490906,
-0.059301212430000305,
0.045310892164707184,
-0.30371710658073425,
-0.03531159088015556,
0.07106779515743256,
-0.1739986687898636,
0.3355916440486908,
0.3522554636001587,
0.21809276938438416,
-0.25744494795799255,
-0.24675528705120087,
0.19981057941913605,
0.21837852895259857,
-0.8021242022514343,
-0.394143283367157,
-0.23035293817520142,
-0.26341792941093445,
-0.43631842732429504,
0.04673375189304352,
-0.6229200959205627,
-0.6057539582252502,
-0.431549072265625,
0.6846904754638672,
-0.2561773657798767,
-0.380241334438324,
0.1368848830461502,
-0.19321131706237793,
0.2598985433578491,
0.5046963095664978,
-1.0124824047088623,
0.47832199931144714,
0.541925847530365,
0.7200762033462524,
-0.2523959279060364,
-0.509657621383667,
-0.2840946614742279,
-0.04302087798714638,
-0.3573773503303528,
0.746489405632019,
-0.1974753737449646,
-0.708012044429779,
-0.36382025480270386,
-0.2889041304588318,
-0.07914116978645325,
-0.7472780346870422,
0.24264942109584808,
-0.3260168433189392,
0.09179996699094772,
-0.5818528532981873,
-0.9119675755500793,
-0.08670777082443237,
0.5533334016799927,
-0.5067874789237976,
0.9045389294624329,
0.03617165982723236,
-0.6365240216255188,
0.34607192873954773,
-0.5990394353866577,
-0.11785614490509033,
-0.23313459753990173,
-0.24394108355045319,
-0.31924641132354736,
0.21426573395729065,
0.24696215987205505,
0.5780898332595825,
-0.24161991477012634,
0.15937533974647522,
-0.21621793508529663,
-0.5341315269470215,
0.49866434931755066,
-0.533159077167511,
0.7063953876495361,
0.03479933366179466,
-0.19122643768787384,
-0.17671169340610504,
-0.4920932650566101,
0.03707931935787201,
0.21258792281150818,
-0.505727231502533,
-0.11679649353027344,
-0.12597888708114624,
-0.4020262360572815,
-0.14849889278411865,
-0.008376484736800194,
-0.27073246240615845,
0.7885093092918396,
-0.1689327210187912,
0.24114079773426056,
0.8208719491958618,
0.19844840466976166,
0.6161251664161682,
-0.9821368455886841,
0.722215473651886,
-0.021217724308371544,
-0.07933359593153,
-0.38545310497283936,
-0.38064655661582947,
-0.8011744618415833,
-0.08507493883371353,
0.1891450136899948,
0.369954377412796,
-0.7122412323951721,
-0.5057725310325623,
0.033319029957056046,
-0.5409451723098755,
-0.5768182277679443,
0.4948241412639618,
0.27495473623275757,
0.7882063388824463,
0.3464640974998474,
-0.39558640122413635,
-0.49468520283699036,
-0.2990954518318176,
-0.38763922452926636,
-0.19024765491485596,
-0.022284725680947304,
0.08563986420631409,
0.44530466198921204,
0.18444927036762238,
0.8429052829742432,
-0.5488263368606567,
0.1039716899394989,
-0.32585057616233826,
0.20286287367343903,
0.2507569491863251,
0.3672616183757782,
0.4768228828907013,
-0.5461480021476746,
-0.5669215321540833,
-0.12753553688526154,
-0.7989163398742676,
0.09664206206798553,
-0.17226333916187286,
-0.047369252890348434,
-0.20696432888507843,
0.2616932988166809,
-0.31938230991363525,
0.40222641825675964,
0.0012215882306918502,
0.002116345800459385,
0.7175595760345459,
-0.22596381604671478,
0.11816900968551636,
-1.026747703552246,
-0.6287196278572083,
-0.27779442071914673,
-0.34032920002937317,
-0.5434136390686035,
-0.23065029084682465,
0.16942012310028076,
-0.033922165632247925,
-0.5110380053520203,
0.44389504194259644,
-0.5706808567047119,
-0.10401521623134613,
-0.5685139894485474,
-0.046514809131622314,
0.01617218740284443,
0.49290117621421814,
0.11989528685808182,
0.5539652109146118,
0.805460512638092,
-0.6667366027832031,
0.4608309864997864,
0.11373136192560196,
-0.3436700105667114,
0.7505952715873718,
-0.630978524684906,
0.34644803404808044,
-0.14952051639556885,
0.386931449174881,
-0.75959312915802,
-0.031590066850185394,
0.1974719613790512,
-0.5560019016265869,
0.25369617342948914,
-0.4003724455833435,
-0.3753097355365753,
-0.35827183723449707,
-0.41601404547691345,
-0.1799316257238388,
0.7035849690437317,
-0.7139112949371338,
0.33890223503112793,
-0.3435576558113098,
0.05660765618085861,
-0.5922319293022156,
-0.6721317172050476,
-0.22736066579818726,
-0.31317195296287537,
-0.38314107060432434,
-0.05991394817829132,
-0.32457616925239563,
-0.09989061951637268,
0.02428719773888588,
-0.15326271951198578,
-0.07554574310779572,
0.4196810722351074,
0.16561847925186157,
0.395263135433197,
-0.09432653337717056,
0.369444340467453,
-0.029002420604228973,
0.0774276852607727,
0.12335172295570374,
-0.5050123333930969,
0.1770394742488861,
-0.18919681012630463,
-0.7322628498077393,
-0.3465314209461212,
-0.030255675315856934,
0.13447019457817078,
-0.0907307118177414,
0.48198172450065613,
0.6254829168319702,
-0.23370960354804993,
-0.513829231262207,
-0.38772377371788025,
-0.9376429915428162,
-0.43505749106407166,
0.29194509983062744,
-0.2384592890739441,
-0.8650028705596924,
0.3889799118041992,
-0.35755592584609985,
0.1953210085630417,
-0.2854665517807007,
0.37148159742355347,
-0.6350907683372498,
0.7088617086410522,
0.7978886365890503,
0.18054769933223724,
0.543386697769165,
-0.8030480146408081,
-0.4506387710571289,
-0.7421559691429138,
-0.11214008182287216,
-0.102139413356781,
-0.6216157674789429,
-0.25413474440574646,
-0.505146324634552,
0.30719125270843506,
0.4240744113922119,
-0.014787685126066208,
-0.0767529308795929,
-0.45494574308395386,
0.7591853737831116,
0.6822230219841003,
0.5185163617134094,
0.33613747358322144,
-0.06660584360361099,
-0.28152894973754883,
-0.19530175626277924,
-0.8281502723693848,
-0.41990241408348083,
1.3182382583618164,
0.2783010005950928,
0.9034467935562134,
0.005983537994325161,
1.127741813659668,
0.10734610259532928,
0.7116844058036804,
-0.8283381462097168,
0.42944201827049255,
0.25072336196899414,
-0.5631043910980225,
-0.28365325927734375,
-0.3718143403530121,
-0.8472128510475159,
0.40114662051200867,
-0.13572628796100616,
-0.4219418168067932,
-0.01722358725965023,
0.2282577008008957,
-0.27548709511756897,
0.6785200238227844,
-0.7537989616394043,
0.7686746120452881,
-0.593706488609314,
-0.6569985747337341,
-0.21907955408096313,
-0.6426889300346375,
0.183402419090271,
-0.05327148735523224,
0.16232702136039734,
0.09478400647640228,
0.0411791168153286,
0.782988965511322,
-0.20924480259418488,
1.2614634037017822,
-0.5646601915359497,
-0.14077922701835632,
0.5910913944244385,
0.07588355243206024,
0.3604680001735687,
0.0298312995582819,
-0.14524921774864197,
-0.4834732413291931,
-0.20593814551830292,
-0.6280912756919861,
-1.044071912765503,
0.3252823054790497,
-0.6460462212562561,
-0.8009217977523804,
-0.184971421957016,
-0.6826512813568115,
-0.34755396842956543,
0.04248502850532532,
0.09531279653310776,
0.22114215791225433,
0.08999961614608765,
0.04636463150382042,
0.8916410803794861,
0.22067038714885712,
0.31806352734565735,
0.6237419843673706,
-0.5319886207580566,
-0.22243674099445343,
0.8894062638282776,
0.21125678718090057,
0.6253007650375366,
0.2998512089252472,
0.581104040145874,
-0.3670560121536255,
-0.5982745885848999,
-0.16136860847473145,
0.16864490509033203,
-1.0692715644836426,
-0.23250117897987366,
-0.24811765551567078,
-0.06952092796564102,
-0.3894960582256317,
-0.3869437277317047,
-0.10422797501087189,
-0.41181451082229614,
-0.48064592480659485,
-0.49950313568115234,
0.3032102584838867,
1.2177608013153076,
-0.4169629216194153,
0.45864787697792053,
-0.6218332052230835,
0.08583107590675354,
1.0193774700164795,
-0.03982848301529884,
0.3047550320625305,
-0.6243962049484253,
-0.23179416358470917,
0.5243051648139954,
-0.7203888297080994,
-0.85878986120224,
0.21534951031208038,
0.20392808318138123,
0.6285757422447205,
0.3559935688972473,
-0.013469208031892776,
0.6566518545150757,
-0.35128429532051086,
0.6153954267501831,
0.293946772813797,
-0.6037693619728088,
0.7048958539962769,
-0.273155152797699,
0.18821994960308075,
0.517076849937439,
0.556153416633606,
-0.48755764961242676,
-0.37708818912506104,
-0.6075239777565002,
-0.3498360812664032,
0.6303554177284241,
-0.27283430099487305,
0.41519200801849365,
0.21557091176509857,
0.6590234637260437,
0.26143208146095276,
0.20416927337646484,
-0.9167991280555725,
-0.12131703644990921,
-0.3096108138561249,
-0.06594076007604599,
0.13963201642036438,
-0.14156650006771088,
-0.15244974195957184,
-0.45779335498809814,
0.49135833978652954,
-0.26010653376579285,
0.10905271023511887,
0.0901002436876297,
-0.21918457746505737,
-0.01023226510733366,
0.3532102108001709,
0.20825868844985962,
0.7928701043128967,
-0.11401908099651337,
0.42639249563217163,
0.669697105884552,
-0.3705260753631592,
0.37436240911483765,
-0.27062949538230896,
0.06599082797765732,
-0.4044121503829956,
0.4031798541545868,
0.7105912566184998,
0.4631728231906891,
-0.3676712214946747,
0.44099146127700806,
-0.010394723154604435,
-0.26687175035476685,
-0.03782559558749199,
0.38606026768684387,
0.44108352065086365,
0.5304226279258728,
0.6468549966812134,
-0.07860753685235977,
-0.05463976785540581,
-0.5200910568237305,
0.34625110030174255,
0.2917696535587311,
-0.4230595529079437,
-0.3214360177516937,
0.7818946838378906,
-0.07368195801973343,
-0.16713233292102814,
0.5854386687278748,
-0.000024832930648699403,
-0.5236636996269226,
0.8084890246391296,
0.6163893342018127,
0.3501642644405365,
-0.2582535147666931,
0.20598015189170837,
0.17234286665916443,
0.22098660469055176,
-0.32198357582092285,
0.1394122689962387,
-0.5308317542076111,
-0.8669569492340088,
-0.3639528751373291,
-0.35984352231025696,
-0.8735763430595398,
-0.2944822907447815,
-0.8673732280731201,
0.5454253554344177,
-0.4832831621170044,
0.03642786294221878,
-0.008651265874505043,
0.2014015018939972,
-0.41959676146507263,
0.10370022803544998,
0.20698390901088715,
0.629248321056366,
-0.7669560313224792,
1.1079928874969482,
1.0649404525756836,
-0.47263944149017334,
-1.0425975322723389,
-0.1155785545706749,
0.023737832903862,
-0.899874210357666,
0.6829798221588135,
0.3174959719181061,
-0.013937875628471375,
0.29234519600868225,
-0.9001277089118958,
-0.27224844694137573,
1.49764084815979,
0.5043790936470032,
-0.5327722430229187,
-0.2389596700668335,
0.03598366305232048,
0.3234490156173706,
-0.2828657627105713,
0.34979915618896484,
0.10942944139242172,
0.24273303151130676,
0.44242727756500244,
-0.7492667436599731,
-0.325138121843338,
0.08739004284143448,
-0.14195232093334198,
-0.34445908665657043,
-0.5536233186721802,
0.7748969793319702,
-0.8106213212013245,
-0.030193503946065903,
-0.10880975425243378,
0.7359245419502258,
0.2785884737968445,
0.5783641338348389,
0.5164639353752136,
0.5709908604621887,
0.9344909191131592,
0.010340124368667603,
0.7058426141738892,
0.22538216412067413,
0.4506112039089203,
1.1018716096878052,
-0.257962167263031,
0.5819713473320007,
0.36514103412628174,
-0.39976397156715393,
0.31158897280693054,
0.6323419809341431,
0.01835525780916214,
0.45002612471580505,
0.3500991463661194,
-0.3300530016422272,
-0.375415563583374,
0.0817464217543602,
-0.3255910575389862,
0.14724820852279663,
0.2613144814968109,
0.02935866452753544,
-0.17153242230415344,
0.636910080909729,
-0.013962061144411564,
0.24657517671585083,
-0.4938618838787079,
0.7353615164756775,
0.3826903998851776,
-0.48422715067863464,
0.7576427459716797,
-0.5955354571342468,
0.8907917737960815,
-0.4481339752674103,
-0.20080018043518066,
-0.3291543424129486,
0.11808381974697113,
-0.15949182212352753,
-0.6620164513587952,
-0.0626702532172203,
-0.17518620193004608,
-0.19643066823482513,
-0.5798088312149048,
0.7374081015586853,
-0.589311957359314,
-0.31584808230400085,
0.08908981084823608,
0.6736189723014832,
0.20756864547729492,
0.25640931725502014,
-0.48849251866340637,
-0.2474011927843094,
0.10902277380228043,
-0.14638422429561615,
0.4223494827747345,
0.26620548963546753,
0.13594965636730194,
0.8898115158081055,
0.5608533024787903,
0.28022778034210205,
0.2913344204425812,
0.022296519950032234,
1.047635793685913,
-0.5362008213996887,
-0.09529504179954529,
-0.7844098210334778,
0.6710470914840698,
0.01838604174554348,
0.20041394233703613,
0.8195223212242126,
0.3276689648628235,
0.9783843755722046,
-0.15055608749389648,
0.7785249352455139,
0.23005147278308868,
0.7781200408935547,
-0.5407397150993347,
0.5971961617469788,
-0.5154556632041931,
0.5115771293640137,
-0.0335918627679348,
-0.7563388347625732,
-0.05896525830030441,
0.5134666562080383,
-0.3217679560184479,
0.07734750211238861,
0.8164529204368591,
0.6438324451446533,
-0.007904713973402977,
0.11865221709012985,
0.6022590398788452,
0.018069878220558167,
0.3227979242801666,
0.5050514340400696,
1.3670414686203003,
-0.008517373353242874,
0.5206522345542908,
-0.544276237487793,
-0.2686890661716461,
0.02859043888747692,
-0.5344023108482361,
-1.0352190732955933,
-0.4018367528915405,
-0.29754120111465454,
-0.024525707587599754,
0.2487735152244568,
0.7502679824829102,
0.549466073513031,
-0.33047720789909363,
-0.39534252882003784,
-0.05591863766312599,
0.3694193661212921,
-0.3192508816719055,
-0.1336318701505661,
0.13889889419078827,
-0.4731575548648834,
-0.672736644744873,
0.5136664509773254,
-0.29798924922943115,
0.5087002515792847,
-0.2748333811759949,
-0.20076113939285278,
-0.06307107210159302,
-0.1662376970052719,
0.2902427613735199,
0.13663318753242493,
-0.3586190640926361,
-0.05984080582857132,
0.16538354754447937,
0.0002755791647359729,
-0.05488938093185425,
0.9510530829429626,
-0.9177237153053284,
0.34719499945640564,
0.06775632500648499,
0.681645393371582,
0.6832485795021057,
-0.14370350539684296,
0.22105082869529724,
-0.74370276927948,
0.09532485902309418,
0.44548943638801575,
0.23722916841506958,
0.41957810521125793,
-0.20808425545692444,
0.6208078265190125,
0.4429784119129181,
-0.5741921067237854,
-0.8607672452926636,
0.3056752681732178,
-0.6675745248794556,
-0.21879011392593384,
0.9115217328071594,
-0.3744075894355774,
-0.07076957076787949,
0.08180012553930283,
-0.403438001871109,
0.36285632848739624,
-0.018234731629490852,
0.8196888566017151,
0.7374739646911621,
-0.27761346101760864,
-0.3685251772403717,
-0.827791154384613,
0.2274990975856781,
0.5724241733551025,
-0.8449476361274719,
-0.06279195100069046,
0.3489052951335907,
0.5449553728103638,
-0.3189176321029663,
0.6670785546302795,
0.029368234798312187,
0.4282687306404114,
-0.11631660163402557,
-0.008462144993245602,
-0.14586438238620758,
-0.2764509618282318,
-0.3100487291812897,
-0.11808790266513824,
0.47120755910873413,
-0.07330185174942017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14563v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14563v1 | Model Merging and Safety Alignment: One Bad Model Spoils the Bunch | 2024-06-20T17:59:58 | 2024-06-20T17:59:58 | Hasan Abed Al Kader Hammoud, Umberto Michieli, Fabio Pizzati, Philip Torr, Adel Bibi, Bernard Ghanem, Mete Ozay | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Merging Large Language Models (LLMs) is a cost-effective technique for
combining multiple expert LLMs into a single versatile model, retaining the
expertise of the original ones. However, current approaches often overlook the
importance of safety alignment during merging, leading to highly misaligned
models. This work investigates the effects of model merging on alignment. We
evaluate several popular model merging techniques, demonstrating that existing
methods do not only transfer domain expertise but also propagate misalignment.
We propose a simple two-step approach to address this problem: (i) generating
synthetic safety and domain-specific data, and (ii) incorporating these
generated data into the optimization process of existing data-aware model
merging techniques. This allows us to treat alignment as a skill that can be
maximized in the resulting merged LLM. Our experiments illustrate the
effectiveness of integrating alignment-related data during merging, resulting
in models that excel in both domain expertise and alignment. | [
-0.2944256365299225,
-0.41928642988204956,
0.6374001502990723,
-0.1141437515616417,
-0.17127665877342224,
0.2785700559616089,
0.1399749368429184,
-0.7859007120132446,
-0.23755638301372528,
0.6715630292892456,
-0.43102017045021057,
-0.230453759431839,
-0.6074366569519043,
-0.40204766392707825,
-0.7208328247070312,
1.0338311195373535,
-0.12420215457677841,
0.021758200600743294,
-0.4551789462566376,
0.054297417402267456,
-0.5142092704772949,
-0.620116651058197,
-0.5140957832336426,
-0.3973143398761749,
0.5827192664146423,
0.4036700427532196,
1.0791102647781372,
1.1601165533065796,
0.705891489982605,
0.2165507823228836,
-0.08225378394126892,
0.4946896433830261,
-0.572001039981842,
0.10967124998569489,
-0.2913925051689148,
-0.1558600664138794,
-0.8585414290428162,
0.12588319182395935,
0.3352251350879669,
0.8665682673454285,
-0.30227404832839966,
-0.2465009242296219,
0.21197062730789185,
0.41013628244400024,
-0.6029770970344543,
-0.2394137978553772,
-0.5453917980194092,
-0.20293939113616943,
-0.08438802510499954,
-0.2026645839214325,
-0.35194480419158936,
-0.6783503890037537,
0.23300579190254211,
-0.5637494921684265,
0.00001846662962634582,
0.11444898694753647,
0.8692330121994019,
0.5082318782806396,
-0.6870582699775696,
0.1042199581861496,
-0.9563537240028381,
0.87238609790802,
-0.8648864030838013,
0.2762192487716675,
0.039292678236961365,
0.2952134907245636,
-0.3013763129711151,
-0.0030466716270893812,
-0.6083316206932068,
0.3359759747982025,
0.02002757228910923,
-0.1312291920185089,
-0.12524349987506866,
-0.0518350824713707,
-0.04612990841269493,
-0.17201171815395355,
-0.6645835638046265,
0.6388250589370728,
-0.5869858860969543,
-0.10415520519018173,
1.1260361671447754,
0.18849991261959076,
0.473540723323822,
0.22460800409317017,
-0.6362585425376892,
-0.3472989797592163,
-0.9671867489814758,
-0.2132583111524582,
0.5338888168334961,
0.558914840221405,
-0.04358303174376488,
0.5905868411064148,
0.05716061592102051,
0.8656125068664551,
-0.041762467473745346,
-0.4144432842731476,
0.04568523168563843,
-0.6189874410629272,
-0.19309143722057343,
0.21567416191101074,
0.6911875605583191,
0.6529766917228699,
0.4644189774990082,
-0.2798130512237549,
-0.16228842735290527,
-0.01762513630092144,
0.5396801829338074,
-0.1967351734638214,
-0.16473256051540375,
0.28475719690322876,
-0.19793079793453217,
-0.73105788230896,
-0.09394921362400055,
-0.5017482042312622,
-0.4403199255466461,
-0.7881569266319275,
0.4184451103210449,
-0.45260199904441833,
-0.2602422833442688,
0.3045121133327484,
0.11160646378993988,
0.339322954416275,
0.4273587763309479,
-0.7438644170761108,
0.03591495007276535,
1.0653797388076782,
0.44970425963401794,
-0.35443395376205444,
-0.332671582698822,
-0.44272932410240173,
0.5159395933151245,
-0.5720760226249695,
0.689950168132782,
-0.27038612961769104,
-0.4096267819404602,
0.0763055831193924,
-0.2174021154642105,
-0.153352290391922,
-0.41231125593185425,
0.4268743395805359,
-0.6166799664497375,
0.29838940501213074,
-0.15174755454063416,
-0.6014940738677979,
-0.2571171224117279,
0.007874947972595692,
-0.4977819323539734,
0.8409538269042969,
-0.14012204110622406,
-0.5676559209823608,
0.37162724137306213,
-0.18376612663269043,
-0.547732412815094,
-0.2965947091579437,
-0.15525557100772858,
-0.4865969121456146,
-0.042764823883771896,
0.06790245324373245,
0.5042405724525452,
-0.1765146106481552,
0.3634184002876282,
-0.5818740129470825,
-0.12336322665214539,
0.4227658212184906,
-0.26853489875793457,
0.7082812786102295,
0.14813284575939178,
0.18133604526519775,
-0.07109052687883377,
-0.4792098104953766,
-0.015649722889065742,
-0.051843758672475815,
-0.28879767656326294,
-0.45507392287254333,
-0.1968228816986084,
0.03584533929824829,
0.4907423257827759,
0.3096891939640045,
0.1010076180100441,
0.42027637362480164,
-0.12075808644294739,
-0.06890343874692917,
0.6716670393943787,
-0.001843990059569478,
0.9714731574058533,
-0.6833196878433228,
0.374369353055954,
0.13388243317604065,
0.201528862118721,
0.31722497940063477,
-0.5306564569473267,
-0.699411153793335,
0.15806300938129425,
0.3950560986995697,
0.6693170666694641,
-0.48878225684165955,
0.5625583529472351,
-0.3428627550601959,
-0.6018465161323547,
-0.5977480411529541,
0.17246519029140472,
0.6111950278282166,
0.5207685828208923,
0.3047902584075928,
-0.3242187201976776,
-0.31090593338012695,
-0.9961953163146973,
-0.3788209557533264,
-0.18268753588199615,
0.17975284159183502,
-0.14268186688423157,
0.14087291061878204,
-0.19794881343841553,
0.9774419665336609,
-0.3923465609550476,
-0.012613968923687935,
-0.02743818797171116,
0.10209336876869202,
-0.24395853281021118,
1.1078308820724487,
0.672057569026947,
-0.7447659969329834,
-0.3053833842277527,
0.340359628200531,
-0.765585720539093,
0.02090352401137352,
-0.08222617954015732,
-0.3979502022266388,
0.4803254306316376,
0.4686127007007599,
-0.8332204818725586,
0.2991798520088196,
0.5209430456161499,
0.09341012686491013,
0.4145570397377014,
-0.061233118176460266,
0.31596070528030396,
-1.2873574495315552,
-0.0948629155755043,
0.004922926425933838,
-0.11646447330713272,
-1.0582157373428345,
0.11834263056516647,
0.22172971069812775,
-0.02156907133758068,
-0.5736694931983948,
0.36085963249206543,
-0.5304297208786011,
-0.0238443985581398,
-0.31909897923469543,
0.25020575523376465,
-0.04091416299343109,
0.13305771350860596,
-0.10025525838136673,
0.60475754737854,
0.5207169055938721,
-0.6484856605529785,
0.07705306261777878,
0.30689287185668945,
-0.10820113867521286,
0.3417964279651642,
-0.16789251565933228,
0.3518452048301697,
-0.1164708212018013,
-0.27584344148635864,
-0.9282073974609375,
-0.5381750464439392,
0.1116207167506218,
-0.2394465208053589,
0.8925451636314392,
-0.33085617423057556,
-0.2547124922275543,
-0.02296583354473114,
-0.024543726816773415,
0.41384050250053406,
0.6417823433876038,
-0.389544814825058,
0.6332468390464783,
0.461443692445755,
-0.4773515462875366,
-0.9068589806556702,
-0.8630380630493164,
-0.043634943664073944,
-0.5857491493225098,
-0.8545405268669128,
0.5427180528640747,
0.10538867115974426,
-0.3126058876514435,
0.11160360276699066,
-0.3374934792518616,
-0.1955486387014389,
0.1113450676202774,
-0.047774169594049454,
0.7250198721885681,
-0.1043480858206749,
0.04894212633371353,
0.3430057466030121,
-0.07650985568761826,
-0.2219373732805252,
-0.06869751960039139,
0.2652343213558197,
0.39095720648765564,
-0.4684833586215973,
-0.5447075963020325,
0.45431941747665405,
0.9598274827003479,
-0.20867931842803955,
0.9741763472557068,
0.04214739799499512,
-0.4234587252140045,
-0.1430516541004181,
-0.748540461063385,
-0.12228874117136002,
-0.42257460951805115,
0.18254390358924866,
-0.04602643474936485,
-0.6813682913780212,
0.3688495457172394,
-0.12318865209817886,
0.3757447600364685,
0.09479919075965881,
0.010848688893020153,
-0.406637579202652,
1.228220820426941,
0.9423670172691345,
-0.07156088948249817,
0.2908743619918823,
0.13211680948734283,
0.8037132024765015,
-0.5444080233573914,
-0.43059325218200684,
-0.6747419834136963,
-0.3014674782752991,
-0.46953651309013367,
-0.6523467302322388,
0.07108168303966522,
0.30978286266326904,
-0.37070518732070923,
0.6503090858459473,
-0.3318110704421997,
0.5746451020240784,
0.2314489334821701,
-0.01960408128798008,
0.46594229340553284,
0.20790021121501923,
0.2584500014781952,
-0.11459160596132278,
-0.9038243889808655,
-0.8303811550140381,
1.054991602897644,
0.285790354013443,
0.8936254978179932,
0.25974607467651367,
0.9434024691581726,
-0.22224827110767365,
0.16190074384212494,
-0.6184328198432922,
0.6397343277931213,
-0.34277331829071045,
-0.2920752465724945,
-0.1986829936504364,
-0.3550093173980713,
-0.5411891937255859,
0.16706573963165283,
-0.5090381503105164,
-0.5117489695549011,
0.3404841423034668,
0.3513682186603546,
-0.5915648937225342,
0.13495956361293793,
-0.6836656332015991,
0.6664121150970459,
-0.540965735912323,
-0.2773912250995636,
-0.21982860565185547,
-0.6288026571273804,
0.7730604410171509,
-0.5924316644668579,
0.40904414653778076,
-0.1488182544708252,
0.07569589465856552,
0.6334550976753235,
-0.30773210525512695,
0.6949717402458191,
0.2293863743543625,
-0.4362788498401642,
-0.0807943120598793,
0.3089345097541809,
0.5768221020698547,
-0.5875857472419739,
0.03757249191403389,
0.13955587148666382,
-0.23653335869312286,
-0.24363195896148682,
-0.7736803889274597,
0.7605928182601929,
-0.6569052934646606,
-0.8660418391227722,
-0.2459181249141693,
-0.7996814846992493,
-0.38056445121765137,
0.1500641107559204,
0.04426922649145126,
0.16004431247711182,
0.008628956973552704,
-0.160426527261734,
0.7304699420928955,
0.12234857678413391,
0.33730024099349976,
0.4803556203842163,
-0.1501220166683197,
-0.20956577360630035,
0.654670774936676,
0.18723171949386597,
0.6098995208740234,
0.0031311160419136286,
-0.2964635193347931,
-0.21064971387386322,
-0.7279894948005676,
-0.06977802515029907,
0.38252249360084534,
-0.8519954085350037,
-0.3762010335922241,
-0.5490515232086182,
-0.3150827884674072,
-0.574470579624176,
-0.5049986839294434,
-0.5410212278366089,
-0.6175680756568909,
-0.37977051734924316,
-0.1960805505514145,
0.31164348125457764,
0.7445175051689148,
-0.05383019521832466,
0.42960304021835327,
-1.1261552572250366,
-0.27232635021209717,
0.13949894905090332,
0.07592421025037766,
-0.08992642164230347,
-0.42788416147232056,
-0.1836698353290558,
0.01059784647077322,
-0.2702491283416748,
-0.8476447463035583,
0.45285895466804504,
-0.25555744767189026,
0.6370134353637695,
0.5283646583557129,
0.03361419215798378,
0.8674883246421814,
-0.43972280621528625,
0.4512958824634552,
0.43941235542297363,
-0.7750780582427979,
0.348166823387146,
-0.32001379132270813,
-0.18253767490386963,
0.5040695071220398,
0.5964574217796326,
-0.24289542436599731,
-0.5321418046951294,
-0.39967039227485657,
-0.7932190299034119,
0.6811528205871582,
0.15334130823612213,
-0.2074340581893921,
0.2878592312335968,
0.18252907693386078,
0.08073807507753372,
0.036577578634023666,
-0.4543216824531555,
0.008754568174481392,
0.47740310430526733,
-0.366347998380661,
0.05845129117369652,
-0.016750045120716095,
-0.6083722710609436,
-0.02577371709048748,
0.7486298680305481,
0.051500413566827774,
-0.16891705989837646,
-0.30272334814071655,
-0.09006284177303314,
-0.2830163240432739,
0.19620826840400696,
0.5749609470367432,
0.5156958103179932,
0.052472665905952454,
0.14487861096858978,
0.018195992335677147,
0.03896261379122734,
0.1795562356710434,
0.03886055201292038,
-0.045049168169498444,
-0.34091460704803467,
0.36793214082717896,
0.41176483035087585,
0.32853028178215027,
-0.3905673325061798,
0.2774999141693115,
0.32645943760871887,
-0.2362409085035324,
0.23205459117889404,
0.35004982352256775,
0.31970274448394775,
0.296120822429657,
0.1710478514432907,
0.6576820611953735,
-0.14474071562290192,
-0.38467082381248474,
0.2703636586666107,
0.5372951626777649,
0.08350540697574615,
-0.012319555506110191,
0.6486883163452148,
0.3726343512535095,
-0.2274443656206131,
0.49331051111221313,
0.23327818512916565,
-0.635964572429657,
0.6375594735145569,
0.37482956051826477,
0.6958016753196716,
-0.5008609890937805,
-0.2537834942340851,
0.1365271806716919,
0.38705697655677795,
-0.41846397519111633,
0.009471542201936245,
0.30767905712127686,
-0.9571080803871155,
-0.6060160398483276,
-0.15026208758354187,
-0.4143001437187195,
-0.20089340209960938,
-0.6349892020225525,
0.4190163314342499,
-0.011406026780605316,
-0.3360763490200043,
-0.028905829414725304,
-0.46102041006088257,
-0.541577160358429,
0.17133618891239166,
0.20781229436397552,
0.7180372476577759,
-1.1375763416290283,
0.7462044358253479,
0.7185885310173035,
-0.3478778898715973,
-1.1165657043457031,
0.30631735920906067,
0.15779604017734528,
-0.5593746900558472,
0.555179238319397,
0.012283970601856709,
-0.16032294929027557,
-0.12991520762443542,
-0.528288722038269,
-1.2107963562011719,
1.1324654817581177,
0.5263026356697083,
-0.8004558682441711,
-0.2656533420085907,
0.31127607822418213,
0.24005627632141113,
-0.5005224347114563,
-0.4474203884601593,
0.8369557857513428,
0.42500945925712585,
0.12927764654159546,
-1.3387523889541626,
0.1662912517786026,
0.060080040246248245,
-0.027227060869336128,
0.3876170814037323,
-0.42841634154319763,
0.7218645811080933,
-0.3814619481563568,
-0.45985209941864014,
-0.04689394310116768,
0.2667834758758545,
0.38006454706192017,
0.3112927973270416,
0.376296728849411,
0.6978151202201843,
1.0024327039718628,
-0.14141707122325897,
0.8863570094108582,
-0.2962321937084198,
0.3787238895893097,
1.0390729904174805,
-0.6586706042289734,
0.7702558040618896,
0.6126829385757446,
0.01634703017771244,
0.18582724034786224,
0.5482531785964966,
0.29312488436698914,
0.6121709942817688,
-0.38270512223243713,
-0.09719698131084442,
-0.5187731981277466,
0.07986616343259811,
-0.3975708484649658,
0.45193734765052795,
-0.013528461568057537,
-0.2123730480670929,
-0.1905984729528427,
-0.2783026695251465,
0.215459406375885,
0.03484490513801575,
-0.023612217977643013,
0.8595276474952698,
0.062120918184518814,
-0.9167071580886841,
0.4371369779109955,
-0.17165973782539368,
0.5423555970191956,
-0.28920260071754456,
0.026366598904132843,
-0.1580365002155304,
0.04188583418726921,
-0.36203911900520325,
-1.0020231008529663,
0.5686599016189575,
-0.14033973217010498,
-0.18210478127002716,
-0.39274346828460693,
0.8026951551437378,
-0.8917852640151978,
-0.2223583161830902,
0.29112762212753296,
0.6141849756240845,
0.1107775866985321,
0.3705548644065857,
-0.49550291895866394,
0.16393601894378662,
-0.005948944948613644,
0.24659638106822968,
0.57996666431427,
0.09602418541908264,
-0.19672659039497375,
0.6658935546875,
0.7330466508865356,
-0.041088953614234924,
-0.04548688977956772,
-0.15119312703609467,
0.9046931266784668,
-0.45722082257270813,
-0.3456661105155945,
-0.6879009008407593,
0.8357001543045044,
-0.1859171837568283,
0.10136406123638153,
0.5564810633659363,
0.39641568064689636,
0.8479772210121155,
-0.06895275413990021,
0.929120659828186,
0.27174657583236694,
0.21146830916404724,
-0.7849814295768738,
1.0279291868209839,
-0.69840407371521,
0.4005279541015625,
-0.13033346831798553,
-1.0580252408981323,
-0.3768138885498047,
0.3909023404121399,
-0.3433019518852234,
0.05577286705374718,
0.5043301582336426,
0.9527186155319214,
-0.22643792629241943,
-0.22536180913448334,
0.34890544414520264,
-0.1315203756093979,
0.22426223754882812,
0.6362175345420837,
0.825520396232605,
-0.4242708683013916,
0.4100624918937683,
-0.3186977207660675,
-0.1273195445537567,
-0.34227514266967773,
-1.1254998445510864,
-0.6629136800765991,
-0.3619704842567444,
-0.7205168604850769,
-0.24240469932556152,
0.10715093463659286,
0.8656231760978699,
0.7821246385574341,
-0.5626603364944458,
-0.0891108438372612,
0.07566264271736145,
0.13942910730838776,
-0.14342480897903442,
-0.18098531663417816,
0.15755817294120789,
-0.1482543796300888,
-0.9006112813949585,
0.6928588151931763,
0.29683738946914673,
0.5957133769989014,
0.04169788211584091,
-0.08557488024234772,
-0.05265037715435028,
0.28594204783439636,
0.23757466673851013,
0.2510724663734436,
-0.768385112285614,
-0.20189933478832245,
-0.13339468836784363,
-0.4239192306995392,
-0.13477054238319397,
0.6960744857788086,
-0.30633991956710815,
0.3607066571712494,
0.5734987258911133,
0.7462759017944336,
0.0033413919154554605,
0.4690179228782654,
1.1801823377609253,
-0.6436187028884888,
-0.1264629065990448,
0.043378524482250214,
0.4102112948894501,
0.5021544098854065,
-0.6025498509407043,
0.5056389570236206,
-0.10062393546104431,
-0.6101409792900085,
-1.0969140529632568,
0.1963413655757904,
-1.0481170415878296,
-0.2541531026363373,
1.0576335191726685,
0.1306535005569458,
0.11174441128969193,
-0.06357152760028839,
0.08948440104722977,
0.48433080315589905,
-0.1852119415998459,
0.7456064224243164,
0.7288601994514465,
-0.35326430201530457,
-0.001648603705689311,
-0.2940030097961426,
0.5452899932861328,
0.5403311848640442,
-0.9113258123397827,
0.2008664757013321,
0.4442063271999359,
0.44592857360839844,
0.2927631735801697,
0.0031784730963408947,
-0.12673407793045044,
0.4802751839160919,
-0.24131707847118378,
0.21003274619579315,
-0.030422374606132507,
-0.5411252975463867,
-0.6836403012275696,
-0.03054044209420681,
0.12891161441802979,
0.06059664487838745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14562v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14562v1 | Whiteboard-of-Thought: Thinking Step-by-Step Across Modalities | 2024-06-20T17:59:45 | 2024-06-20T17:59:45 | Sachit Menon, Richard Zemel, Carl Vondrick | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | When presented with questions involving visual thinking, humans naturally
switch reasoning modalities, often forming mental images or drawing visual
aids. Large language models have shown promising results in arithmetic and
symbolic reasoning by expressing intermediate reasoning in text as a chain of
thought, yet struggle to extend this capability to answer text queries that are
easily solved by visual reasoning, even with extensive multimodal pretraining.
We introduce a simple method, whiteboard-of-thought prompting, to unlock the
visual reasoning capabilities of multimodal large language models across
modalities. Whiteboard-of-thought prompting provides multimodal large language
models with a metaphorical `whiteboard' to draw out reasoning steps as images,
then returns these images back to the model for further processing. We find
this can be accomplished with no demonstrations or specialized modules, instead
leveraging models' existing ability to write code with libraries such as
Matplotlib and Turtle. This simple approach shows state-of-the-art results on
four difficult natural language tasks that involve visual and spatial
reasoning. We identify multiple settings where GPT-4o using chain-of-thought
fails dramatically, including more than one where it achieves $0\%$ accuracy,
while whiteboard-of-thought enables up to $92\%$ accuracy in these same
settings. We present a detailed exploration of where the technique succeeds as
well as its sources of error. | [
-0.4010315537452698,
-1.094712734222412,
1.163953423500061,
0.20907942950725555,
-0.41705581545829773,
0.09808988124132156,
-0.16067738831043243,
-0.35990089178085327,
-0.014784934930503368,
0.1937243491411209,
-0.7165888547897339,
-0.38859695196151733,
-0.6000439524650574,
-0.001706229173578322,
-0.05427192524075508,
0.6165798306465149,
-0.3867343068122864,
0.06954024732112885,
-0.12281531095504761,
-0.05149301886558533,
-1.0178523063659668,
-0.22084015607833862,
-0.4030546247959137,
-0.21177655458450317,
0.5153913497924805,
0.39557597041130066,
0.6561071872711182,
0.1947670727968216,
0.48567861318588257,
0.3105632960796356,
0.17719604074954987,
0.5311561226844788,
-0.3854566216468811,
-0.026681991294026375,
-0.37537214159965515,
-0.4625696837902069,
-0.4615177810192108,
0.06292186677455902,
0.16632609069347382,
0.41126370429992676,
-0.08878996223211288,
0.17729079723358154,
-0.3609577417373657,
0.6117849946022034,
-0.9048372507095337,
0.2677140533924103,
-0.7805501222610474,
0.22510476410388947,
0.0708182081580162,
-0.2108721286058426,
-0.6480308175086975,
-0.14491869509220123,
0.10662821680307388,
-0.7559821605682373,
-0.28329095244407654,
0.012647059746086597,
0.41008472442626953,
0.23558466136455536,
-0.6301948428153992,
-0.3919391632080078,
-0.5275920629501343,
0.5920496582984924,
-0.26487502455711365,
0.5695352554321289,
0.4382680058479309,
0.2413395345211029,
-0.17193984985351562,
-0.8359448313713074,
-0.9197717905044556,
-0.36365169286727905,
-0.09632039070129395,
0.33368173241615295,
-0.11761406809091568,
0.09097251296043396,
0.7811521887779236,
-0.09780292958021164,
-0.39517924189567566,
-0.5106924772262573,
-0.5687155723571777,
-0.1136726588010788,
0.23578126728534698,
-0.06766089797019958,
0.4781542718410492,
-0.14837777614593506,
-0.5060380697250366,
-0.1763910949230194,
-0.4687519967556,
0.09561417996883392,
-0.19607661664485931,
0.09663344919681549,
0.09621647745370865,
0.3229376971721649,
-0.10878995805978775,
0.8483906984329224,
-0.172239288687706,
-0.2971900701522827,
0.15471157431602478,
-0.34987378120422363,
-0.1691945493221283,
-0.11012091487646103,
0.7362560629844666,
0.5081796646118164,
0.28154778480529785,
0.2276446372270584,
-0.24308571219444275,
0.29267948865890503,
0.27307888865470886,
-0.5891281962394714,
-0.47336408495903015,
-0.07839125394821167,
-0.297687292098999,
0.06752290576696396,
-0.04986543580889702,
-0.7023990750312805,
-0.1711818277835846,
-0.36787503957748413,
0.8359496593475342,
-0.5940920114517212,
-0.09959089010953903,
0.21317988634109497,
-0.28811144828796387,
-0.2213064432144165,
0.7750539183616638,
-1.061080813407898,
0.18011797964572906,
0.3197294771671295,
0.8160602450370789,
0.07172387093305588,
-0.4244476556777954,
-0.4199562668800354,
0.22087697684764862,
-0.5148749351501465,
0.7570473551750183,
-0.6829025149345398,
-0.2311757206916809,
-0.21304365992546082,
-0.2541368007659912,
-0.09438292682170868,
-0.12930209934711456,
0.3238206207752228,
-0.3660542964935303,
0.22272956371307373,
-0.574904203414917,
-0.08363039791584015,
-0.3256693482398987,
0.6119693517684937,
-0.6794195771217346,
0.8898831605911255,
-0.27572619915008545,
-0.658705472946167,
0.40202879905700684,
-0.7515510320663452,
-0.4707850515842438,
0.013059675693511963,
-0.46108195185661316,
0.18548569083213806,
0.06166410446166992,
0.6320247650146484,
0.30224406719207764,
-0.2551701068878174,
0.12692663073539734,
-0.22225221991539001,
-0.38785815238952637,
0.29187116026878357,
-0.49683189392089844,
0.6910927891731262,
0.23851875960826874,
-0.5338510274887085,
0.10648521780967712,
-0.5680305361747742,
0.19980144500732422,
0.14149992167949677,
0.10935060679912567,
-0.3930048644542694,
-0.0966072753071785,
-0.3460298776626587,
0.7082775235176086,
0.15588964521884918,
-0.5182026624679565,
0.21339215338230133,
0.3034154176712036,
0.6481006741523743,
0.8303232192993164,
-0.18285144865512848,
0.23403307795524597,
-0.12208188325166702,
0.5125208497047424,
0.10482075065374374,
0.1969001442193985,
-0.4590790867805481,
-0.7658001184463501,
-0.709143340587616,
-0.36212193965911865,
-0.12745538353919983,
0.5753889679908752,
-1.3688011169433594,
-0.23669295012950897,
-0.044861774891614914,
-0.48756319284439087,
-0.5114192366600037,
0.13926613330841064,
0.5359406471252441,
0.6832314133644104,
0.44866883754730225,
-0.0012395146768540144,
-0.11214135587215424,
-0.762373149394989,
0.07588548213243484,
-0.14355528354644775,
0.39234089851379395,
0.04003603011369705,
0.8711314797401428,
-0.01653684489428997,
0.33494940400123596,
-0.8565816283226013,
-0.06348194926977158,
-0.08985094726085663,
0.3425760269165039,
0.06123122572898865,
0.3554019033908844,
0.11780834197998047,
-0.8938535451889038,
-0.3831425905227661,
0.04235869646072388,
-0.6699925661087036,
0.1635609120130539,
-0.3737591803073883,
-0.5585401654243469,
0.04441061615943909,
0.7682439088821411,
-0.8283247947692871,
0.5756872892379761,
0.38213324546813965,
-0.3327906131744385,
0.3751971125602722,
-0.499723345041275,
0.4046395719051361,
-0.7805559635162354,
-0.11052997410297394,
-0.07947176694869995,
-0.04314139112830162,
-0.5041506886482239,
0.03037160634994507,
0.2777979075908661,
-0.12220390141010284,
-0.2690947651863098,
0.4483107626438141,
-0.5352917313575745,
0.2551618218421936,
-0.1108117327094078,
0.48799222707748413,
0.008066610433161259,
0.7708548307418823,
0.014951862394809723,
0.6670749187469482,
0.4998689591884613,
-0.2665247321128845,
0.5231707692146301,
0.35338932275772095,
-0.40485891699790955,
0.5000318884849548,
-0.24902446568012238,
0.43303146958351135,
-0.33826717734336853,
0.38904792070388794,
-1.307234525680542,
-0.06570621579885483,
0.16303741931915283,
-0.0002893350610975176,
0.013646405190229416,
0.23563095927238464,
-0.4454975128173828,
-0.7013503909111023,
-0.3322293758392334,
0.6173405647277832,
0.4598766565322876,
-0.6506328582763672,
0.6447657942771912,
0.2095434069633484,
-0.12182087451219559,
-0.6160458922386169,
-0.7264860272407532,
0.05067063495516777,
0.2071487307548523,
-0.584071159362793,
0.21681514382362366,
-0.24030978977680206,
-0.11046094447374344,
-0.06653695553541183,
-0.06850483268499374,
-0.007754821330308914,
-0.18232960999011993,
0.10283012688159943,
0.5636460781097412,
0.019266271963715553,
0.31920966506004333,
0.020292244851589203,
-0.052013520151376724,
0.08638428896665573,
-0.30019164085388184,
0.32156598567962646,
-0.2738054096698761,
-0.6185793876647949,
-0.4409034252166748,
0.20094232261180878,
0.7706091403961182,
-0.4136104881763458,
0.18541792035102844,
0.45463457703590393,
-0.43417850136756897,
-0.4701745808124542,
-0.5706684589385986,
-0.09331919997930527,
-0.43618378043174744,
0.39583802223205566,
-0.5238726735115051,
-0.6139671206474304,
0.3460253179073334,
0.11769156903028488,
-0.13695959746837616,
-0.06350188702344894,
0.529536247253418,
-0.25585541129112244,
1.2184522151947021,
0.5469331741333008,
0.614282488822937,
0.5099443793296814,
-0.17378848791122437,
0.5033774971961975,
-0.5369502902030945,
-0.45810970664024353,
0.2017734795808792,
-0.5499734878540039,
-0.42571139335632324,
-0.6350311040878296,
0.4748077988624573,
-0.2318810224533081,
-0.04422830790281296,
0.11181535571813583,
-0.4309229552745819,
0.7698801159858704,
0.6540156006813049,
0.4422740042209625,
0.33204230666160583,
-0.10629397630691528,
-0.40156781673431396,
-0.13129930198192596,
-0.6900398135185242,
-0.3964203894138336,
0.6801941394805908,
-0.038656916469335556,
0.7566014528274536,
-0.1085323691368103,
0.41138559579849243,
-0.11432304233312607,
0.5446957349777222,
-0.7021554112434387,
0.9416998028755188,
-0.0921403244137764,
-0.6306248903274536,
-0.30998894572257996,
-0.2560100257396698,
-0.34329262375831604,
0.6853060722351074,
-0.3584904074668884,
-0.768051266670227,
-0.09692137688398361,
0.27923643589019775,
-0.3632056713104248,
0.404160737991333,
-0.9527094960212708,
0.9981791973114014,
-0.32137876749038696,
-0.4502151906490326,
-0.3346481919288635,
-0.5403040051460266,
0.6545274257659912,
-0.0876481756567955,
0.2831330895423889,
0.04037734866142273,
0.12872688472270966,
0.6216409802436829,
-0.3713088631629944,
0.7096454501152039,
-0.027935313060879707,
-0.1482059508562088,
0.4449406564235687,
0.32126885652542114,
0.4144006371498108,
-0.21033847332000732,
0.3416635990142822,
-0.2739556133747101,
-0.09197313338518143,
-0.2742766737937927,
-1.0778628587722778,
0.5297255516052246,
-0.36072495579719543,
-0.8724029660224915,
-0.29357239603996277,
-0.8518710136413574,
-0.4153267741203308,
0.292112797498703,
0.11614278703927994,
0.6176561713218689,
0.14383730292320251,
-0.2451712191104889,
0.44515368342399597,
0.1903853863477707,
0.5356260538101196,
0.04401670768857002,
-0.3578522205352783,
-0.6646676063537598,
0.8976889252662659,
0.21505025029182434,
0.49976640939712524,
0.338467001914978,
0.09880928695201874,
-0.3386800289154053,
-0.41137024760246277,
-0.3747437000274658,
0.23714561760425568,
-1.235487699508667,
-0.043855100870132446,
-0.519906759262085,
0.1454034447669983,
0.08067350089550018,
-0.3602355718612671,
-0.12340269237756729,
-0.49965381622314453,
0.1761399358510971,
-0.413712739944458,
-0.01668776012957096,
0.8652185201644897,
0.056233178824186325,
-0.07533634454011917,
-0.6049791574478149,
0.4475419521331787,
0.8914574980735779,
0.14472627639770508,
0.3762795329093933,
-0.16048522293567657,
0.11869668960571289,
0.26925572752952576,
-0.6211908459663391,
-0.882026195526123,
0.11019869893789291,
-0.27599793672561646,
0.39726659655570984,
0.32332271337509155,
-0.2381979078054428,
1.1085467338562012,
-0.7344749569892883,
0.6994345784187317,
0.799817681312561,
-1.117647409439087,
0.8074948191642761,
-0.2036469578742981,
0.6380111575126648,
0.49570032954216003,
0.5044825077056885,
-0.5237780213356018,
-0.3870747685432434,
-0.4177190661430359,
-0.43481042981147766,
0.5340334177017212,
0.16635844111442566,
0.13334782421588898,
-0.34812578558921814,
-0.07555194944143295,
0.04606203734874725,
0.14113444089889526,
-0.976757824420929,
0.15191130340099335,
-0.4887213408946991,
-0.14322911202907562,
0.2091687023639679,
-0.07371222227811813,
-0.29725420475006104,
-0.5973988771438599,
0.40272653102874756,
-0.33477190136909485,
0.18658003211021423,
0.3630780577659607,
-0.2934066951274872,
-0.1607496291399002,
0.24887120723724365,
1.0056272745132446,
1.205757975578308,
-0.03587188199162483,
0.5519371628761292,
0.46257826685905457,
-0.45662859082221985,
0.15929412841796875,
-0.24500691890716553,
-0.007719090674072504,
-0.19461655616760254,
0.569744884967804,
0.9375544190406799,
0.38449564576148987,
-0.763454020023346,
0.6559542417526245,
-0.0759120061993599,
-0.3547399044036865,
0.14112013578414917,
-0.038281556218862534,
0.1633799523115158,
0.2741518020629883,
0.2624620795249939,
0.15061302483081818,
-0.12041977792978287,
-0.8721688985824585,
0.012766166590154171,
0.3619588315486908,
-0.5651211738586426,
-0.446076899766922,
0.7545265555381775,
0.2655315697193146,
-0.14500723779201508,
0.7706531286239624,
-0.21806977689266205,
-0.6229286193847656,
0.43101954460144043,
0.8755199909210205,
0.7237935066223145,
0.12495993077754974,
0.43313679099082947,
0.2707310616970062,
0.36256372928619385,
-0.15978789329528809,
0.7123091816902161,
-0.2547166347503662,
-0.7895578145980835,
-0.6334829926490784,
-0.027476554736495018,
-0.38716864585876465,
-0.02279469184577465,
-0.29468417167663574,
0.2141290009021759,
-0.7396007180213928,
-0.376041054725647,
0.0229053758084774,
-0.540352463722229,
-0.4595807194709778,
0.1433337926864624,
0.6216298937797546,
1.0594409704208374,
-0.7777136564254761,
0.5211567878723145,
0.915158748626709,
-0.5076566934585571,
-0.7848754525184631,
-0.047686826437711716,
-0.16149744391441345,
-0.7956852316856384,
1.16143000125885,
0.3087419271469116,
-0.4788263142108917,
-0.20549573004245758,
-0.7336809039115906,
-0.511250376701355,
1.3142131567001343,
0.41531410813331604,
-0.3650329113006592,
-0.014635615050792694,
-0.23515480756759644,
0.39101195335388184,
-0.29425135254859924,
0.45204630494117737,
0.2655903697013855,
0.534959614276886,
0.4335157573223114,
-0.9639829397201538,
0.5344064831733704,
-0.25315186381340027,
-0.05513504892587662,
0.3015001118183136,
-0.7806969285011292,
0.9903745055198669,
-0.7192704081535339,
-0.1481754332780838,
-0.4027588963508606,
0.5230386853218079,
0.3292261064052582,
0.21982893347740173,
0.6430368423461914,
0.5427327156066895,
0.9904236793518066,
-0.06361895799636841,
0.9020299315452576,
0.03264179825782776,
-0.021953312680125237,
0.8430318236351013,
-0.22165654599666595,
0.8928752541542053,
0.671017587184906,
0.06484967470169067,
0.7440850734710693,
-0.013050374574959278,
0.24222037196159363,
0.6871827244758606,
-0.10379694402217865,
-0.2711856961250305,
-0.5334290266036987,
0.07032757252454758,
-0.07298865169286728,
0.3938342034816742,
0.3476966917514801,
0.00266174110583961,
-0.2622532248497009,
0.15891945362091064,
0.024053141474723816,
0.1281358301639557,
-0.41372084617614746,
0.3821287453174591,
0.2536817193031311,
-1.0025330781936646,
0.5424017906188965,
-0.4151516854763031,
0.4012933075428009,
-0.5410314202308655,
-0.4712696075439453,
0.12924541532993317,
0.08139147609472275,
0.043151307851076126,
-0.9156356453895569,
-0.2667623460292816,
-0.2601293623447418,
0.01540041621774435,
-0.6675854921340942,
0.637016773223877,
-0.537932276725769,
-0.525119960308075,
0.15331996977329254,
0.5358421802520752,
-0.31946253776550293,
0.18159914016723633,
-0.628996729850769,
0.005962798371911049,
0.08360153436660767,
-0.026651859283447266,
-0.03983002156019211,
0.794018566608429,
-0.4182890057563782,
0.8477523922920227,
0.7494649291038513,
-0.06781404465436935,
-0.0052270167507231236,
-0.009396924637258053,
0.8891352415084839,
-0.9008989930152893,
-0.6876725554466248,
-1.0519400835037231,
0.5627681612968445,
-0.28964143991470337,
-0.5085924863815308,
0.4457346796989441,
0.01933063380420208,
0.8375658988952637,
-0.2988194525241852,
0.504075825214386,
0.08974184095859528,
-0.24287697672843933,
-0.8887505531311035,
0.6059532165527344,
-0.4931873083114624,
-0.26941978931427,
-0.5792785286903381,
-0.602871835231781,
-0.2311452329158783,
0.8509904742240906,
-0.5850278735160828,
-0.07654828578233719,
1.5180983543395996,
0.6845099925994873,
-0.10401338338851929,
0.4336228668689728,
0.5131878852844238,
0.2082691192626953,
0.33904600143432617,
0.7859538793563843,
1.1151657104492188,
-0.1369246244430542,
0.5430812835693359,
-0.19770269095897675,
-0.38735198974609375,
0.2398216277360916,
-1.0609034299850464,
-1.1146799325942993,
-0.7655550241470337,
-0.09174153953790665,
-0.01965566724538803,
-0.03945416212081909,
0.9944975972175598,
0.6807880401611328,
-0.4546012878417969,
-0.06201525777578354,
-0.08223278820514679,
0.19762273132801056,
-0.13443498313426971,
-0.11760874837636948,
0.27620095014572144,
-0.389133095741272,
-0.4135116636753082,
0.17878970503807068,
0.524634838104248,
0.12349783629179001,
-0.0746942088007927,
0.1424945741891861,
-0.5617910027503967,
0.030822116881608963,
0.9225479960441589,
-0.11293286085128784,
-0.7821818590164185,
-0.4188228249549866,
-0.06686383485794067,
-0.2089511603116989,
-0.09036745131015778,
0.9685143828392029,
-0.6441510915756226,
0.8481602072715759,
0.6327484250068665,
0.346780389547348,
0.6338317394256592,
-0.2022242397069931,
0.5995290875434875,
-0.24950559437274933,
0.40299081802368164,
0.15195278823375702,
0.5997121930122375,
0.24763591587543488,
-0.1413959562778473,
0.3021849989891052,
0.29775407910346985,
-0.1545507311820984,
-0.6158502101898193,
0.3708954453468323,
-0.9521644115447998,
-0.3610397279262543,
0.8033705949783325,
-0.03907884284853935,
-0.4463343918323517,
0.20071811974048615,
-0.710948646068573,
-0.1500835418701172,
-0.213270366191864,
0.7778653502464294,
1.185146689414978,
-0.2677767872810364,
-0.2725532650947571,
-0.7230408787727356,
0.47600021958351135,
0.44729262590408325,
-0.9434475302696228,
-0.027046794071793556,
0.5809302926063538,
-0.05410151556134224,
0.4731004536151886,
1.0383657217025757,
-0.019455546513199806,
0.6174513101577759,
0.0941290333867073,
-0.07760391384363174,
-0.1442590057849884,
-0.5100680589675903,
0.2386220097541809,
0.11674436926841736,
-0.24095076322555542,
-0.06810611486434937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14561v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14561v1 | How to Compute the Probability of a Word | 2024-06-20T17:59:42 | 2024-06-20T17:59:42 | Tiago Pimentel, Clara Meister | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) estimate the probability distribution over sequences of
natural language; these distributions are crucial for computing perplexity and
surprisal in linguistics research. While we are usually concerned with
measuring these values for words, most LMs operate over subwords. Despite
seemingly straightforward, accurately computing probabilities over one unit
given probabilities over the other requires care. Indeed, we show here that
many recent linguistic studies have been incorrectly computing these values.
This paper derives the correct methods for computing word probabilities,
highlighting issues when relying on language models that use beginning-of-word
(bow)-marking tokenisers, e.g., the GPT family. Empirically, we show that
correcting the widespread bug in probability computations affects measured
outcomes in sentence comprehension and lexical optimisation analyses. | [
-0.05932549014687538,
-0.6803168654441833,
0.7700093984603882,
0.005370128899812698,
-0.3775998055934906,
-0.15190578997135162,
0.15468727052211761,
-0.41133859753608704,
0.010426480323076248,
0.15864509344100952,
-0.3415822982788086,
-0.30406486988067627,
-0.7699465751647949,
-0.20988455414772034,
-0.35014358162879944,
0.849617063999176,
0.10561403632164001,
0.09323214739561081,
-0.09163519740104675,
-0.20389780402183533,
-0.21631482243537903,
-0.856138288974762,
-0.4538605213165283,
-0.3946840167045593,
0.607417106628418,
0.026340052485466003,
1.0551366806030273,
0.2715301811695099,
0.6125912070274353,
0.24330604076385498,
-0.10709894448518753,
-0.2767176330089569,
-0.40630361437797546,
-0.07327597588300705,
-0.20778582990169525,
-0.7704755067825317,
-0.259513795375824,
0.24675631523132324,
0.29895004630088806,
1.0531636476516724,
-0.22660882771015167,
-0.31990164518356323,
-0.11369840800762177,
0.47401735186576843,
-0.5815285444259644,
0.1977553367614746,
-0.7782400846481323,
0.29511967301368713,
-0.4537222385406494,
-0.4362056851387024,
-0.45768627524375916,
-0.20074860751628876,
0.04030952602624893,
-0.28425100445747375,
0.2752847373485565,
0.06999322772026062,
0.5201279520988464,
-0.059795357286930084,
-0.0650973841547966,
-0.5441234111785889,
-0.7075667381286621,
0.8349606990814209,
-0.8685150742530823,
0.18232479691505432,
0.5320410132408142,
-0.017287757247686386,
-0.5880902409553528,
-0.5020928978919983,
-0.6167217493057251,
-0.4431643784046173,
0.0994512066245079,
-0.1653134524822235,
-0.36513015627861023,
0.2884373366832733,
0.31318435072898865,
0.46034014225006104,
-0.4437137842178345,
0.05712038651108742,
-0.10302788019180298,
-0.11489177495241165,
0.6836463809013367,
0.20264168083667755,
0.46125635504722595,
-0.15843363106250763,
-0.0716838389635086,
0.06135417893528938,
-0.8505963087081909,
0.02094242349267006,
0.6877201199531555,
0.31949976086616516,
0.21119537949562073,
0.9624287486076355,
-0.019494488835334778,
0.7388686537742615,
-0.2709788382053375,
-0.323270708322525,
0.061349011957645416,
-0.3076700270175934,
-0.15670320391654968,
0.03505720943212509,
0.4765324592590332,
0.3040049076080322,
0.5816094875335693,
-0.30233246088027954,
-0.4403974115848541,
0.09030111879110336,
0.15539060533046722,
-0.17687542736530304,
-0.4162271022796631,
0.17573973536491394,
0.14558687806129456,
-0.14410848915576935,
-0.004907550290226936,
-0.08266013115644455,
-0.45292264223098755,
-0.06478697806596756,
0.6160231232643127,
-0.7045586705207825,
-0.08218799531459808,
0.43657803535461426,
-0.258512020111084,
0.0256141796708107,
0.04463506489992142,
-0.700876772403717,
0.1550821214914322,
0.7570424675941467,
0.44726797938346863,
0.26144281029701233,
-0.4197874963283539,
-0.5314798355102539,
-0.004639111924916506,
-0.4964367747306824,
0.7139611840248108,
-0.44158902764320374,
-0.48312628269195557,
0.05163151025772095,
-0.16918663680553436,
-0.09046847373247147,
-0.1991344690322876,
0.5733479261398315,
-0.3688853681087494,
0.04724777489900589,
-0.16967666149139404,
-1.214705467224121,
-0.06053690239787102,
-0.11491186171770096,
-0.44454580545425415,
0.4518715739250183,
0.009522988460958004,
-1.0752960443496704,
0.5033507943153381,
-0.3655346632003784,
-0.6135002374649048,
0.27008381485939026,
0.1406189650297165,
-0.09952510893344879,
0.7145048379898071,
-0.04462027549743652,
0.2561459243297577,
0.19351385533809662,
0.04969049245119095,
-0.1395627111196518,
-0.4853908121585846,
0.5907920598983765,
-0.3701368272304535,
0.5953648090362549,
0.15902958810329437,
-0.14320041239261627,
0.11006612330675125,
-0.24954098463058472,
-0.14614933729171753,
-0.06330735981464386,
-0.18442603945732117,
-0.5170062780380249,
0.3635108172893524,
0.022176234051585197,
-0.022345101460814476,
-0.003960299305617809,
-0.5959453582763672,
0.347247451543808,
-0.6061943769454956,
0.41620734333992004,
0.5316222906112671,
-0.015849297866225243,
0.3833569586277008,
-0.35841014981269836,
0.625429093837738,
0.11901931464672089,
0.037358738481998444,
-0.00497793173417449,
-0.8118966221809387,
-0.3397442698478699,
-0.23416753113269806,
0.5537745952606201,
0.6360896229743958,
-0.720304548740387,
0.37963661551475525,
-0.10640940070152283,
-0.6655572056770325,
-0.3643092215061188,
-0.20238922536373138,
0.2802199125289917,
0.3871702551841736,
0.17413215339183807,
-0.22567753493785858,
-0.4559515118598938,
-0.5742244124412537,
-0.8161828517913818,
-0.4701296091079712,
0.11813413351774216,
-0.12044904381036758,
0.3256456255912781,
0.028771482408046722,
1.1898401975631714,
-0.5975903868675232,
-0.173575296998024,
-0.5243300199508667,
0.5459132790565491,
0.13071918487548828,
0.30147427320480347,
0.2945006191730499,
-0.4909590780735016,
0.005899548530578613,
-0.2351756989955902,
-0.43799880146980286,
-0.24169714748859406,
-0.015927359461784363,
0.20858381688594818,
0.6449810266494751,
0.1978311836719513,
-0.7346081733703613,
0.8269752264022827,
0.3837503492832184,
-0.34701991081237793,
0.8711143136024475,
-0.3626014292240143,
0.024728519842028618,
-0.731745719909668,
-0.19329933822155,
0.14310258626937866,
-0.2092844843864441,
-0.6090360879898071,
0.3587435185909271,
-0.1697203367948532,
0.40647757053375244,
-0.5796076655387878,
0.5438015460968018,
-0.3627071678638458,
-0.03828076645731926,
-0.4210684597492218,
0.07931046187877655,
-0.442852646112442,
-0.04951713979244232,
-0.15778732299804688,
0.7464571595191956,
0.33693328499794006,
-0.49927034974098206,
0.31382179260253906,
-0.1589839607477188,
-0.5414509773254395,
0.34151971340179443,
-0.42600905895233154,
-0.09523697197437286,
-0.24410605430603027,
0.08531567454338074,
-1.192104458808899,
-0.09939669072628021,
0.17431151866912842,
-0.4283144772052765,
0.2621852457523346,
-0.04100129008293152,
-0.588191568851471,
-0.43346256017684937,
-0.32854577898979187,
0.41755956411361694,
0.5660037398338318,
-0.03383553773164749,
0.26894792914390564,
0.850550651550293,
-0.1001395657658577,
-0.5989264249801636,
-0.879288375377655,
0.19549712538719177,
-0.1205504760146141,
-0.4421985149383545,
0.10589699447154999,
0.14795689284801483,
-0.4619869589805603,
0.052510619163513184,
0.04388314113020897,
0.2079886943101883,
0.1447325497865677,
0.0949069932103157,
-0.02474677748978138,
0.04720018059015274,
0.3273196220397949,
-0.4175887405872345,
-0.11616367101669312,
-0.12135834991931915,
-0.2452692687511444,
0.8329921960830688,
0.08693835884332657,
-0.7475805878639221,
-0.02293902076780796,
0.15716513991355896,
0.0789552852511406,
-0.038177378475666046,
0.6076209545135498,
0.2941948473453522,
-0.6960792541503906,
-0.03231576085090637,
-0.6391329765319824,
-0.23002322018146515,
-0.34870314598083496,
0.47347983717918396,
-0.7061173319816589,
-0.71640545129776,
0.4889427125453949,
0.572331428527832,
-0.01775653101503849,
0.375860333442688,
0.20820389688014984,
-0.17383216321468353,
0.9122605323791504,
0.668558657169342,
-0.0700560063123703,
0.18620656430721283,
0.1404697299003601,
0.6304082870483398,
-0.6589004397392273,
0.10405624657869339,
-0.46256187558174133,
-0.19745726883411407,
-0.7049282789230347,
-0.48218488693237305,
0.41722962260246277,
0.34406328201293945,
0.2161925584077835,
0.577721357345581,
-0.14265690743923187,
0.3857613205909729,
0.6885976791381836,
-0.17772354185581207,
0.42733249068260193,
0.2367027997970581,
-0.47967401146888733,
-0.36413824558258057,
-0.7116951942443848,
-0.5301616191864014,
0.9621397256851196,
0.2555672526359558,
1.0629962682724,
0.004892735276371241,
0.8899613618850708,
0.11526202410459518,
0.42791488766670227,
-0.9028732180595398,
0.7032500505447388,
-0.4000830054283142,
-0.7000892162322998,
-0.5763520002365112,
-0.316213995218277,
-1.2027342319488525,
-0.027300892397761345,
0.06903731822967529,
-1.0674340724945068,
0.0029542825650423765,
0.026584481820464134,
-0.24599264562129974,
0.5285202264785767,
-0.5471267104148865,
0.7449755072593689,
0.03407510370016098,
-0.04436356574296951,
-0.2118513286113739,
-0.28719204664230347,
0.3667907416820526,
0.04588325321674347,
0.45922335982322693,
-0.17938633263111115,
0.005327320192009211,
0.6334553360939026,
-0.6270377039909363,
0.6412867307662964,
-0.007045093923807144,
-0.3159983158111572,
0.46841830015182495,
0.2738974094390869,
0.36186984181404114,
-0.13753493130207062,
-0.11504259705543518,
-0.10459459573030472,
0.11941076815128326,
-0.4136504828929901,
-0.3359188437461853,
0.4465312063694,
-0.34376031160354614,
-0.8190053701400757,
-0.7629750967025757,
-0.6726747155189514,
-0.16601519286632538,
-0.2883615493774414,
0.5308996438980103,
0.44106370210647583,
-0.18714472651481628,
-0.2322710156440735,
0.4131423830986023,
-0.358266144990921,
0.619820773601532,
0.41188889741897583,
-0.46329233050346375,
-0.1900807023048401,
0.853077232837677,
0.6496533751487732,
0.28286245465278625,
0.33474400639533997,
0.19122418761253357,
-0.6013548970222473,
-0.3895578980445862,
-0.2311161607503891,
0.15147185325622559,
-0.9461157321929932,
0.2013111412525177,
-0.5945795774459839,
-0.3309464752674103,
-0.3884200155735016,
-0.12426947802305222,
0.054399192333221436,
-0.5270261168479919,
-0.019877761602401733,
-0.20755846798419952,
0.34711146354675293,
0.6869081854820251,
-0.14132750034332275,
0.2871365547180176,
-0.698657214641571,
-0.009883292019367218,
0.20925916731357574,
0.12551064789295197,
-0.21926163136959076,
-0.5610641241073608,
0.1107756644487381,
0.08191657811403275,
-0.12697052955627441,
-1.245436429977417,
0.32051318883895874,
0.17495667934417725,
0.7006485462188721,
-0.04094180837273598,
-0.1635597050189972,
0.5514108538627625,
-0.6381376385688782,
0.9375813007354736,
0.1839103102684021,
-0.9777423739433289,
0.36601942777633667,
-0.19893057644367218,
0.48890912532806396,
0.20739512145519257,
0.3027898669242859,
-0.8092120885848999,
-0.7070102095603943,
-0.8521522283554077,
-0.8251346349716187,
0.3612038791179657,
0.14149649441242218,
0.21619562804698944,
-0.44977617263793945,
0.15990030765533447,
0.059774287045001984,
0.15580762922763824,
-0.526262640953064,
-0.2523163855075836,
0.31926602125167847,
-0.3069732189178467,
-0.5126620531082153,
-0.4609379768371582,
0.09083215147256851,
-0.264167457818985,
0.759425938129425,
-0.06613986194133759,
0.08464369177818298,
0.1979268491268158,
-0.3986806571483612,
-0.25648948550224304,
0.41256874799728394,
0.7448946237564087,
0.9303924441337585,
-0.017537357285618782,
0.25006103515625,
0.014576200395822525,
-0.5663953423500061,
0.15411774814128876,
0.19363215565681458,
-0.308665007352829,
0.4306459128856659,
0.4923546612262726,
0.6853649020195007,
0.4879916310310364,
-0.5969409942626953,
0.47015032172203064,
0.1446574479341507,
0.0730798989534378,
-0.15535026788711548,
-0.011721083894371986,
0.5343872904777527,
-0.3073301613330841,
0.5375016927719116,
-0.24198803305625916,
0.25053849816322327,
-0.8364047408103943,
0.3142181932926178,
0.7708697319030762,
-0.27044618129730225,
-0.23556311428546906,
0.5108700394630432,
-0.1891518086194992,
-0.42056044936180115,
0.4893002510070801,
-0.41181036829948425,
-0.6595815420150757,
0.6315096020698547,
0.4762718081474304,
0.8314928412437439,
-0.21877002716064453,
0.3927137553691864,
0.04610132426023483,
0.5398443341255188,
-0.28792768716812134,
0.7087658047676086,
0.596356213092804,
-0.90885990858078,
-0.4469982981681824,
-1.1110248565673828,
-0.3029943108558655,
-0.019391361624002457,
-0.090078204870224,
0.15859699249267578,
-0.06927137076854706,
-0.4815176725387573,
0.19315743446350098,
-0.0035200698766857386,
-0.4684379994869232,
0.21187451481819153,
0.4511522650718689,
0.9800022840499878,
-0.6886124610900879,
0.7593747973442078,
0.7798353433609009,
-0.4800181984901428,
-1.0159821510314941,
-0.10932831466197968,
-0.17590303719043732,
-0.6236786842346191,
0.4925401508808136,
0.06627620756626129,
-0.10615424811840057,
0.13377748429775238,
-0.3952065110206604,
-0.5790702700614929,
0.42099517583847046,
0.26146790385246277,
-0.7559993267059326,
0.24764283001422882,
0.6875810027122498,
0.6550393104553223,
-0.19171249866485596,
0.2511148750782013,
0.5454218983650208,
0.4046732783317566,
0.06478428095579147,
-1.0314931869506836,
-0.24056664109230042,
0.34491875767707825,
0.18995167315006256,
0.29438069462776184,
0.2572193145751953,
0.9009238481521606,
-0.39079225063323975,
-0.24426819384098053,
0.08703487366437912,
0.5845180749893188,
0.4443177282810211,
0.1412033885717392,
0.4420517683029175,
0.9015436172485352,
0.747870922088623,
-0.32094621658325195,
1.349753975868225,
-0.36753082275390625,
0.4523482024669647,
0.9317171573638916,
-0.3252865970134735,
0.8972916603088379,
0.7003923058509827,
-0.7346938252449036,
0.09885423630475998,
0.6766820549964905,
0.35799694061279297,
0.2352450042963028,
0.7035581469535828,
-0.44427379965782166,
-0.08071909844875336,
0.2470727264881134,
-0.14919428527355194,
0.2810462713241577,
0.3022097051143646,
-0.2656506299972534,
-0.23518648743629456,
-0.0012809319887310266,
-0.023241788148880005,
0.02381848730146885,
-0.437856525182724,
0.568017303943634,
0.4884625971317291,
-0.6529876589775085,
0.37633582949638367,
0.2643686532974243,
0.753626823425293,
-0.43551406264305115,
0.3155114948749542,
-0.46209022402763367,
0.25114643573760986,
-0.15131798386573792,
-1.184718132019043,
0.4293855130672455,
-0.16323967278003693,
0.01580965518951416,
0.3248905539512634,
0.7926896810531616,
-0.42615678906440735,
-0.7970907688140869,
-0.0925714373588562,
0.6571365594863892,
0.5065396428108215,
-0.1906120926141739,
-0.32924598455429077,
-0.19513340294361115,
-0.38689154386520386,
-0.3569246530532837,
0.31152355670928955,
0.3226444125175476,
-0.23313868045806885,
0.7871739268302917,
0.49293917417526245,
0.2783108949661255,
0.5691251754760742,
0.16844332218170166,
0.20569416880607605,
-0.6076440215110779,
-0.558099091053009,
-1.2119593620300293,
0.5141326189041138,
0.1268174797296524,
-0.4386528432369232,
0.5886408686637878,
0.4011647701263428,
0.7196657061576843,
-0.3789990246295929,
0.6359760165214539,
-0.06079428270459175,
0.2443450689315796,
-0.44807371497154236,
0.7228908538818359,
-0.3564516007900238,
0.3308437764644623,
-0.2610720694065094,
-0.9407932758331299,
-0.5070975422859192,
0.5343802571296692,
-0.6485183835029602,
-0.18777599930763245,
0.7231395244598389,
0.7119162678718567,
0.1696701943874359,
0.15893380343914032,
0.4564206302165985,
0.13875806331634521,
0.14905524253845215,
0.5796361565589905,
0.7416971921920776,
-0.470928430557251,
0.08121318370103836,
-0.3158218562602997,
-0.22315819561481476,
-0.27360519766807556,
-1.0451700687408447,
-0.35209420323371887,
-0.47830459475517273,
-0.41573914885520935,
-0.13239338994026184,
0.4078620672225952,
0.7700552344322205,
0.3090577721595764,
-0.8845749497413635,
-0.38744792342185974,
-0.30672603845596313,
0.3235693573951721,
-0.2540924847126007,
-0.21368525922298431,
0.09573658555746078,
-0.7362368106842041,
-0.5423024892807007,
0.12166891992092133,
0.3002242147922516,
0.006134314462542534,
-0.2679636478424072,
0.02938680723309517,
-0.3774324059486389,
0.44196996092796326,
0.4362599551677704,
0.21903608739376068,
-0.8899050951004028,
-0.5443175435066223,
-0.3229108154773712,
-0.44596734642982483,
-0.03747820109128952,
0.4988096058368683,
-0.7798190116882324,
0.15213054418563843,
0.6529438495635986,
0.39338219165802,
0.00017827116244006902,
-0.10869539529085159,
0.7429602146148682,
-0.6778857707977295,
0.14938628673553467,
0.2871074080467224,
0.6321691870689392,
0.5756415724754333,
-0.21916256844997406,
0.6153125166893005,
0.5777226686477661,
-0.434304803609848,
-0.9793359637260437,
0.6322702765464783,
-0.47940894961357117,
-0.35537123680114746,
1.0492030382156372,
-0.23072966933250427,
-0.39347320795059204,
-0.07146234810352325,
-0.06323046237230301,
0.17148379981517792,
0.20261333882808685,
0.4766603112220764,
1.1017792224884033,
-0.0012223353842273355,
-0.078884057700634,
-0.4499993920326233,
0.6670404076576233,
0.5869171619415283,
-0.22532020509243011,
-0.22525550425052643,
0.12044437974691391,
0.45567676424980164,
0.12918630242347717,
0.5821464657783508,
-0.06118956208229065,
0.05720977112650871,
0.1048751100897789,
0.2056150883436203,
0.5177029371261597,
-0.05565440282225609,
-0.38741162419319153,
0.23083189129829407,
0.2365535944700241,
0.01790800131857395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14553v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14553v1 | xCOMET-lite: Bridging the Gap Between Efficiency and Quality in Learned MT Evaluation Metrics | 2024-06-20T17:58:34 | 2024-06-20T17:58:34 | Daniil Larionov, Mikhail Seleznyov, Vasiliy Viskov, Alexander Panchenko, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art trainable machine translation evaluation metrics like xCOMET
achieve high correlation with human judgment but rely on large encoders (up to
10.7B parameters), making them computationally expensive and inaccessible to
researchers with limited resources. To address this issue, we investigate
whether the knowledge stored in these large encoders can be compressed while
maintaining quality. We employ distillation, quantization, and pruning
techniques to create efficient xCOMET alternatives and introduce a novel data
collection pipeline for efficient black-box distillation. Our experiments show
that, using quantization, xCOMET can be compressed up to three times with no
quality degradation. Additionally, through distillation, we create an
xCOMET-lite metric, which has only 2.6% of xCOMET-XXL parameters, but retains
92.1% of its quality. Besides, it surpasses strong small-scale metrics like
COMET-22 and BLEURT-20 on the WMT22 metrics challenge dataset by 6.4%, despite
using 50% fewer parameters. All code, dataset, and models are available online. | [
-0.32872235774993896,
-0.09864238649606705,
0.440805584192276,
-0.202226459980011,
-0.6189002990722656,
0.3667989671230316,
-0.6001640558242798,
-0.09486030042171478,
0.18700912594795227,
0.19539828598499298,
-0.5316207408905029,
-0.3413262963294983,
-0.8323442339897156,
0.18586991727352142,
-0.3451928198337555,
0.968044638633728,
-0.058445755392313004,
-0.05640648677945137,
0.10422205924987793,
-0.4149492681026459,
-0.4886406660079956,
-0.4094168543815613,
-0.6445913314819336,
-0.06259927898645401,
0.4887930154800415,
0.2278991937637329,
0.8800574541091919,
0.8191230297088623,
0.7184392213821411,
0.35117390751838684,
0.05283265560865402,
0.4188068211078644,
-0.787595808506012,
0.01915864832699299,
-0.09032341092824936,
-0.8498432040214539,
-0.2832670211791992,
0.008690803311765194,
0.5199502110481262,
0.6775945425033569,
-0.30707883834838867,
0.3339676856994629,
0.18631814420223236,
0.7276113629341125,
-0.6084219813346863,
-0.007117214612662792,
-0.5541990995407104,
0.22520038485527039,
-0.08782796561717987,
-0.46776679158210754,
-0.33761969208717346,
-0.482871413230896,
0.11878037452697754,
-0.7056370377540588,
0.11465030908584595,
0.2596043646335602,
0.9243294596672058,
0.5438441634178162,
-0.3429696559906006,
-0.10173090547323227,
-0.5738909840583801,
1.1073943376541138,
-0.5424200296401978,
0.43589305877685547,
0.32640954852104187,
0.5820216536521912,
0.15012860298156738,
-1.0029034614562988,
-0.30391067266464233,
-0.018403127789497375,
-0.00731384614482522,
0.3678991496562958,
-0.3825191557407379,
-0.1355551928281784,
0.040099527686834335,
0.8311697244644165,
-0.6028228998184204,
0.016050413250923157,
-0.36021456122398376,
-0.095224529504776,
0.4375455975532532,
0.16246914863586426,
-0.1530735045671463,
-0.15301010012626648,
-0.3436894714832306,
-0.6292656660079956,
-0.5240879654884338,
-0.042758990079164505,
0.3209185302257538,
-0.13923804461956024,
0.1839439570903778,
0.45672041177749634,
-0.03161870315670967,
0.35233351588249207,
-0.15360862016677856,
-0.1552392542362213,
0.3985109329223633,
-0.5029118657112122,
-0.3522791564464569,
-0.07959101349115372,
0.9910895824432373,
0.4678586423397064,
-0.16093647480010986,
-0.352809876203537,
-0.43131810426712036,
0.12581661343574524,
0.3530016243457794,
-1.061458945274353,
-0.30465957522392273,
0.37462225556373596,
-0.5559301376342773,
-0.24512876570224762,
0.24756333231925964,
-0.5718806982040405,
-0.14111880958080292,
-0.3262181878089905,
0.7149521112442017,
-0.48659056425094604,
0.015732252970337868,
0.406645804643631,
-0.513881266117096,
-0.3887849748134613,
0.15002641081809998,
-0.3934852182865143,
0.27872660756111145,
0.5088368654251099,
0.9987505078315735,
-0.09689634293317795,
0.09860510379076004,
-0.5868543386459351,
-0.3003181219100952,
-0.3104409873485565,
0.21194609999656677,
-0.2991035282611847,
-0.4607599675655365,
-0.261275976896286,
-0.029931209981441498,
0.3234054148197174,
-0.7558595538139343,
0.8664320111274719,
-0.44964033365249634,
0.15600816905498505,
-0.20334744453430176,
-0.4971581995487213,
0.011866535060107708,
0.3610032796859741,
-0.6647521257400513,
0.9360896944999695,
0.4489596486091614,
-0.6827923059463501,
0.6910699605941772,
-0.39701253175735474,
-0.0788629949092865,
0.11994876712560654,
-0.11677035689353943,
-0.6867910027503967,
0.6046320199966431,
0.16370992362499237,
0.1546025574207306,
-0.5855538249015808,
0.2570144832134247,
-0.007869536057114601,
-0.5121510028839111,
0.44448116421699524,
-0.7350670695304871,
0.6570348739624023,
0.4663570523262024,
-0.3367210030555725,
-0.25712913274765015,
-0.9471201300621033,
0.2374870479106903,
0.02189846709370613,
-0.3778313100337982,
-0.6219077706336975,
-0.13941249251365662,
-0.36289405822753906,
0.30482298135757446,
0.14557670056819916,
-0.7780599594116211,
0.3068922758102417,
-0.22388379275798798,
0.5701512694358826,
0.5557774901390076,
-0.17370395362377167,
0.17273694276809692,
-0.2449372261762619,
0.4420129060745239,
0.1473761349916458,
0.3252864480018616,
-0.14630350470542908,
-0.12120101600885391,
-0.8784732222557068,
-0.21978110074996948,
0.6751763820648193,
0.21566234529018402,
-1.1129989624023438,
0.6719636917114258,
-0.9569100737571716,
-0.5110575556755066,
-1.0145162343978882,
0.012302272021770477,
0.4159144461154938,
0.0948549136519432,
0.4061249792575836,
-0.4200133979320526,
-0.3890080749988556,
-0.7466902136802673,
-0.03765342757105827,
0.14815865457057953,
-0.3176402151584625,
0.07403077930212021,
0.49344319105148315,
0.08630853146314621,
0.8103866577148438,
-0.7273871898651123,
-0.35285964608192444,
0.003360329894348979,
0.4145909547805786,
0.24071122705936432,
0.5315288305282593,
0.30597811937332153,
-0.794018566608429,
-0.46088552474975586,
0.2572362720966339,
-0.6946892738342285,
-0.038071438670158386,
-0.120380699634552,
-0.012765411287546158,
-0.37277427315711975,
0.15873055160045624,
-0.2457999736070633,
0.3151925802230835,
0.8450749516487122,
-0.3172110319137573,
0.5053359270095825,
-0.43271324038505554,
0.6049053072929382,
-1.0660314559936523,
-0.010701252147555351,
-0.07029128819704056,
-0.43521055579185486,
-0.3627709448337555,
-0.05319204926490784,
0.30688178539276123,
-0.011789784766733646,
-0.48802658915519714,
0.19812574982643127,
-0.5498552322387695,
0.24155665934085846,
-0.3272779881954193,
0.31862974166870117,
0.4132578372955322,
0.5001175999641418,
0.0114590460434556,
0.8738410472869873,
0.22787222266197205,
-0.28837651014328003,
0.15602251887321472,
0.338060200214386,
-0.7003405690193176,
0.5437950491905212,
-0.4858325719833374,
-0.045239560306072235,
-0.020686835050582886,
0.08713100105524063,
-0.6281833052635193,
0.40375959873199463,
-0.1411103755235672,
-0.4964056611061096,
0.3172006905078888,
-0.29694053530693054,
-0.735082745552063,
-0.3272207975387573,
-0.4781022071838379,
0.399943470954895,
0.823482096195221,
-0.6346884369850159,
-0.0733087807893753,
0.014041921123862267,
0.07129113376140594,
-0.5679125785827637,
-0.8575283885002136,
0.3644503951072693,
-0.3339334726333618,
-0.4137473404407501,
0.3940904438495636,
-0.1779545098543167,
0.04230025038123131,
0.06210910901427269,
-0.2735454738140106,
-0.03948701173067093,
-0.07135850936174393,
0.09565194696187973,
0.09665358811616898,
-0.22836348414421082,
0.08448593318462372,
0.22019967436790466,
-0.237189382314682,
-0.032273076474666595,
-0.8311751484870911,
0.2903396487236023,
0.19816328585147858,
-0.146576926112175,
-0.5028576254844666,
0.08560717850923538,
0.46179649233818054,
-0.10877080261707306,
0.7245082259178162,
0.5316057205200195,
-0.06735154986381531,
-0.18204566836357117,
-0.4372377395629883,
-0.23325026035308838,
-0.5031870007514954,
0.34729695320129395,
-0.3604189455509186,
-0.9111559391021729,
0.17976027727127075,
-0.16626907885074615,
0.13762207329273224,
0.2070000320672989,
0.2438647449016571,
-0.011856294237077236,
1.0895394086837769,
0.5081286430358887,
0.13362231850624084,
0.2937021255493164,
-0.7702086567878723,
0.051117680966854095,
-0.8544120788574219,
0.1653895080089569,
-0.497100830078125,
-0.5856708288192749,
-0.6123775243759155,
-0.49061909317970276,
0.5598298907279968,
-0.15507575869560242,
0.10316678881645203,
0.5281416773796082,
-0.560878574848175,
0.5108571648597717,
0.5589701533317566,
0.22508829832077026,
0.5462778210639954,
0.1406119465827942,
0.1075083538889885,
-0.28607726097106934,
-0.8304809331893921,
-0.42979303002357483,
1.0842126607894897,
0.1735369712114334,
0.4935270845890045,
0.01691002957522869,
0.6539416313171387,
0.2848083972930908,
0.1804475635290146,
-0.7058699131011963,
0.2519359886646271,
-0.39186733961105347,
-0.5925222635269165,
-0.07942241430282593,
-1.0876107215881348,
-1.062472939491272,
0.4313971698284149,
-0.06400711089372635,
-0.4888682961463928,
0.4367550015449524,
0.04474032297730446,
-0.2728511393070221,
0.5821990370750427,
-0.6322579383850098,
0.7555829286575317,
-0.17768706381320953,
-0.49507322907447815,
-0.2716922461986542,
-0.7281374335289001,
0.2547883093357086,
-0.42694517970085144,
0.11069205403327942,
-0.03371744975447655,
-0.12114215642213821,
0.8511548638343811,
-0.9508061408996582,
0.43770328164100647,
-0.21638700366020203,
-0.07231560349464417,
0.35027870535850525,
0.21371804177761078,
0.34333693981170654,
-0.017820114269852638,
-0.2526465654373169,
0.28940460085868835,
0.2270054966211319,
-0.40056562423706055,
-1.005521535873413,
0.4162679612636566,
-0.7951037287712097,
-0.14323918521404266,
-0.14770470559597015,
-0.44280722737312317,
-0.0643388107419014,
0.12332520633935928,
0.522928774356842,
0.711969792842865,
-0.03280963748693466,
0.5441331267356873,
0.5309982299804688,
-0.12961284816265106,
0.15940497815608978,
0.3370969891548157,
0.29828885197639465,
-0.7421067953109741,
1.2477010488510132,
0.5244138836860657,
0.4571450650691986,
0.5974913239479065,
0.33213499188423157,
-0.39957594871520996,
-0.7832503318786621,
-0.4395877420902252,
-0.008185205049812794,
-0.6361396312713623,
-0.7206346392631531,
-0.29506590962409973,
0.06436317414045334,
0.2755107581615448,
-0.1602640450000763,
-0.6587753295898438,
-0.7800246477127075,
0.1986188292503357,
-0.016282785683870316,
0.1264123171567917,
0.3733232915401459,
-0.056600138545036316,
0.769286036491394,
-1.1288210153579712,
0.07605841010808945,
-0.12393901497125626,
0.4052538275718689,
-0.11061255633831024,
-0.656163215637207,
-0.8305111527442932,
0.29767727851867676,
-0.307450532913208,
-0.30224600434303284,
0.604385495185852,
0.04240009933710098,
0.21492613852024078,
0.49302759766578674,
0.4463563859462738,
0.8083747625350952,
-0.27406051754951477,
0.8531330227851868,
0.4756602346897125,
-0.7563292980194092,
0.3483200669288635,
0.1546517014503479,
0.28093603253364563,
0.9654510021209717,
0.42354023456573486,
-0.31679487228393555,
-0.4060305953025818,
-0.6748021245002747,
-0.7363651394844055,
0.5042360424995422,
0.7052874565124512,
-0.20375876128673553,
0.037468936294317245,
0.28928428888320923,
0.5839118361473083,
0.5685638189315796,
-0.48634910583496094,
-0.3102470636367798,
-0.2355358898639679,
-0.24629120528697968,
-0.1304052472114563,
-0.00972746778279543,
-0.16122981905937195,
-0.040157221257686615,
0.6405360698699951,
0.002593596698716283,
-0.030475744977593422,
0.21717268228530884,
-0.29300087690353394,
0.2417246252298355,
0.3622491657733917,
0.030223647132515907,
0.3908432424068451,
-0.3673413395881653,
0.34935835003852844,
0.12283370643854141,
-0.6719460487365723,
0.4999293088912964,
-0.1133938729763031,
0.018065810203552246,
-0.06779208034276962,
0.015750449150800705,
0.7136310338973999,
-0.012791219167411327,
-0.6203040480613708,
0.6436709761619568,
-0.5336671471595764,
-0.34141191840171814,
-0.006812794134020805,
-0.070606529712677,
-0.4615704119205475,
-0.04019627720117569,
0.24128620326519012,
0.08585317432880402,
0.27634671330451965,
-0.3166957497596741,
0.10804705321788788,
0.12025697529315948,
-0.579135000705719,
-0.44089049100875854,
0.6709381341934204,
0.2613731324672699,
0.2036653459072113,
0.7925648093223572,
-0.4933716952800751,
-0.24473369121551514,
0.19150443375110626,
0.09398211538791656,
0.7649751305580139,
0.15019668638706207,
-0.12481991201639175,
0.3948013484477997,
0.43223440647125244,
-0.1436188668012619,
0.07790996879339218,
-0.3458571434020996,
-0.4155789315700531,
-0.7268996834754944,
-0.5992878675460815,
-0.35676348209381104,
-0.2801664173603058,
-0.7084943652153015,
0.21662338078022003,
-0.02592778578400612,
-0.4799661338329315,
-0.3209535777568817,
0.4813825488090515,
-0.6904239654541016,
0.41488200426101685,
-0.17181555926799774,
1.028114676475525,
-0.6305109858512878,
0.8760117888450623,
0.18275298178195953,
-0.579712450504303,
-0.565207839012146,
-0.47097811102867126,
-0.09547115862369537,
-0.4756507873535156,
0.42554429173469543,
-0.013581275008618832,
-0.04616786912083626,
0.04585488140583038,
-0.23493026196956635,
-0.5253438949584961,
1.3636475801467896,
0.41990211606025696,
-0.7926647663116455,
0.13690462708473206,
0.3525003492832184,
0.4390938878059387,
0.09016476571559906,
0.44464901089668274,
0.8634325265884399,
0.6635610461235046,
-0.07347389310598373,
-0.8017500638961792,
0.0058093927800655365,
-0.28722861409187317,
-0.13301846385002136,
0.5444980263710022,
-0.7767038941383362,
0.30966657400131226,
0.021913185715675354,
-0.46963468194007874,
0.07887106388807297,
0.49176859855651855,
-0.15479686856269836,
0.10433995723724365,
0.5813924670219421,
0.7918412089347839,
0.7140325307846069,
-0.4276726543903351,
1.011939287185669,
-0.2314930260181427,
0.3210565149784088,
0.8171244859695435,
-0.013668548315763474,
0.6314529180526733,
0.4744534194469452,
-0.28900954127311707,
0.24967314302921295,
0.45813432335853577,
-0.06572356075048447,
0.4145497977733612,
0.1328946202993393,
-0.1320868730545044,
-0.08678451180458069,
-0.018237527459859848,
-0.06355635076761246,
0.13009513914585114,
0.2727157473564148,
-0.23387978971004486,
0.04107893258333206,
0.11061199754476547,
0.09602773934602737,
-0.09994162619113922,
0.030178891494870186,
0.7413864135742188,
0.2508036196231842,
-0.6549930572509766,
0.8493185043334961,
-0.24071013927459717,
0.7407309412956238,
-0.8680619597434998,
0.16668497025966644,
-0.21566791832447052,
0.19693243503570557,
-0.30571281909942627,
-0.877652108669281,
0.3372841477394104,
-0.24430927634239197,
0.02354557439684868,
-0.283687025308609,
0.12479476630687714,
-0.46184858679771423,
-0.34249410033226013,
0.10343912243843079,
0.6200370788574219,
0.29471588134765625,
-0.19779902696609497,
-0.3861831724643707,
0.18754710257053375,
0.16365006566047668,
-0.23505903780460358,
0.41668304800987244,
0.8448464274406433,
0.1814495176076889,
0.68814617395401,
0.5763350129127502,
0.40353819727897644,
0.1478225737810135,
-0.0007630834588780999,
0.8919857740402222,
-0.5993613600730896,
-0.4258469045162201,
-0.6330656409263611,
0.7177985906600952,
-0.2844650447368622,
-0.2945183515548706,
0.6772028803825378,
0.8064499497413635,
0.7832934260368347,
0.10196653008460999,
0.8018568158149719,
0.006439673714339733,
0.19628120958805084,
-0.4698127806186676,
0.6276596784591675,
-0.8182359933853149,
0.350192666053772,
0.07546023279428482,
-0.8863023519515991,
-0.27793920040130615,
0.13224099576473236,
0.01568014919757843,
-0.1971818506717682,
0.975641131401062,
0.6420903205871582,
-0.3227064609527588,
-0.1027713268995285,
0.7491869330406189,
0.03341900184750557,
0.5591472387313843,
0.5186394453048706,
0.7613248229026794,
-0.7646068930625916,
1.1635627746582031,
-0.35134783387184143,
-0.357785165309906,
-0.06671683490276337,
-0.7793546319007874,
-0.4330593943595886,
-0.5632280707359314,
-0.6812347173690796,
-0.13510854542255402,
0.1378101408481598,
0.8226211667060852,
0.9344906210899353,
-0.32985928654670715,
-0.22897809743881226,
0.07369330525398254,
-0.2337261438369751,
-0.5686333179473877,
-0.18419353663921356,
0.6176674365997314,
-0.37788623571395874,
-0.858659565448761,
0.33738449215888977,
0.3459838926792145,
-0.023426145315170288,
-0.16278119385242462,
-0.0616740956902504,
0.5630011558532715,
-0.10835054516792297,
0.7256109714508057,
-0.15700554847717285,
-0.16712342202663422,
-0.18390069901943207,
-0.05635366216301918,
0.18747535347938538,
0.44779378175735474,
0.8599308133125305,
-0.8775549530982971,
0.6184321641921997,
0.4202863574028015,
0.6514082551002502,
0.5397310853004456,
-0.02800878882408142,
0.6522806286811829,
-1.047095775604248,
-0.0015967367216944695,
0.22435124218463898,
0.6319632530212402,
0.3096424341201782,
0.02529810555279255,
0.7903939485549927,
0.011701995506882668,
-0.8061161041259766,
-0.8473141193389893,
-0.13435375690460205,
-1.071681022644043,
-0.16066165268421173,
0.7925959825515747,
-0.32001250982284546,
-0.3050793707370758,
0.026739677414298058,
-0.4106447398662567,
0.17674553394317627,
-0.40626785159111023,
0.7410754561424255,
0.38980892300605774,
0.14446289837360382,
-0.11234617233276367,
-0.6288115382194519,
0.28764215111732483,
0.320978045463562,
-0.6338034272193909,
0.2168130874633789,
0.15851448476314545,
0.124264195561409,
0.28000327944755554,
0.18392042815685272,
-0.401215136051178,
0.15304116904735565,
0.2795753479003906,
0.04365773871541023,
-0.1257033348083496,
-0.06356954574584961,
-0.20535534620285034,
0.21610485017299652,
0.17906969785690308,
-0.37434136867523193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14550v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14550v1 | GraphReader: Building Graph-based Agent to Enhance Long-Context Abilities of Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T17:57:51 | 2024-06-20T17:57:51 | Shilong Li, Yancheng He, Hangyu Guo, Xingyuan Bu, Ge Bai, Jie Liu, Jiaheng Liu, Xingwei Qu, Yangguang Li, Wanli Ouyang, Wenbo Su, Bo Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Long-context capabilities are essential for large language models (LLMs) to
tackle complex and long-input tasks. Despite numerous efforts made to optimize
LLMs for long contexts, challenges persist in robustly processing long inputs.
In this paper, we introduce GraphReader, a graph-based agent system designed to
handle long texts by structuring them into a graph and employing an agent to
explore this graph autonomously. Upon receiving a question, the agent first
undertakes a step-by-step analysis and devises a rational plan. It then invokes
a set of predefined functions to read node content and neighbors, facilitating
a coarse-to-fine exploration of the graph. Throughout the exploration, the
agent continuously records new insights and reflects on current circumstances
to optimize the process until it has gathered sufficient information to
generate an answer. Experimental results on the LV-Eval dataset reveal that
GraphReader, using a 4k context window, consistently outperforms GPT-4-128k
across context lengths from 16k to 256k by a large margin. Additionally, our
approach demonstrates superior performance on four challenging single-hop and
multi-hop benchmarks. | [
-0.3697025179862976,
-1.0121403932571411,
0.959671139717102,
0.11706717312335968,
-0.28032615780830383,
0.414310097694397,
-0.3591279089450836,
-0.7835137844085693,
0.12671111524105072,
0.6870360374450684,
-0.37387728691101074,
-0.5738028883934021,
-0.6342861652374268,
0.35858505964279175,
-0.17715780436992645,
0.9029597043991089,
-0.28192129731178284,
-0.5668256282806396,
-0.15619301795959473,
-0.03855317085981369,
-0.48304569721221924,
-0.3883594572544098,
-0.9364681243896484,
-0.503520667552948,
0.8348042368888855,
0.29617729783058167,
0.7536060810089111,
0.5865672826766968,
0.07611286640167236,
0.412007600069046,
-0.14909984171390533,
0.4458373785018921,
-0.7550377249717712,
0.5118658542633057,
-0.26548805832862854,
0.0274974275380373,
-0.6860122084617615,
-0.3164311945438385,
0.8561742305755615,
0.5490248203277588,
0.3860061466693878,
-0.013328631408512592,
0.24480199813842773,
0.5018560290336609,
-0.3910536766052246,
0.5997104048728943,
-0.12624700367450714,
-0.23367710411548615,
-0.1576869934797287,
-0.2674351930618286,
-0.5852850079536438,
-0.1216573491692543,
0.11008067429065704,
-0.6561799645423889,
-0.10567425936460495,
-0.09259319305419922,
0.45918843150138855,
0.03724038228392601,
-0.8376184105873108,
-0.355669766664505,
-0.5919777154922485,
0.3715618848800659,
-0.344424307346344,
0.41504761576652527,
0.3913077712059021,
0.4422279894351959,
-0.38439905643463135,
-0.9040980935096741,
-0.49632585048675537,
-0.008434832096099854,
-0.14876660704612732,
0.0033120543230324984,
-0.2032279372215271,
0.36397337913513184,
0.17519748210906982,
-0.17055507004261017,
-0.5537160038948059,
0.12398536503314972,
0.016292212530970573,
-0.362068235874176,
0.4748278558254242,
0.11730879545211792,
0.33732888102531433,
-0.24680699408054352,
-0.02922172099351883,
-0.01988188549876213,
-0.24273110926151276,
0.31319689750671387,
0.24325570464134216,
0.33433178067207336,
0.25986215472221375,
0.5297071933746338,
-0.38414159417152405,
0.8905909061431885,
-0.280934602022171,
-0.11165132373571396,
0.1846979409456253,
-0.2783566415309906,
-0.0643758475780487,
0.04838767275214195,
0.7097789645195007,
0.3417430818080902,
0.313892126083374,
-0.25155553221702576,
-0.41529977321624756,
-0.15186187624931335,
-0.11165528744459152,
-1.113319993019104,
0.002578943269327283,
0.3927149772644043,
-0.05463043972849846,
-0.12808841466903687,
-0.32196474075317383,
-0.8043345808982849,
-0.41702577471733093,
-0.23237153887748718,
0.06619319319725037,
-0.5152332782745361,
-0.04470164328813553,
0.15920914709568024,
-0.1820833534002304,
0.02975606359541416,
0.5271505117416382,
-0.6877481937408447,
0.4552285969257355,
0.9503459930419922,
1.1348590850830078,
-0.20884457230567932,
-0.5646011829376221,
-0.9887104630470276,
0.22244103252887726,
-0.33825552463531494,
0.9217024445533752,
-0.6589368581771851,
-0.4032406210899353,
-0.10630638897418976,
0.3070324659347534,
-0.1770162433385849,
-0.05078723654150963,
0.43779847025871277,
-0.8489602208137512,
-0.16194765269756317,
-0.05124032497406006,
-0.6515727043151855,
-0.0306145828217268,
0.4506126344203949,
-0.7637181878089905,
1.070101022720337,
0.45995137095451355,
-0.7035117745399475,
0.2436407059431076,
-0.9010947346687317,
-0.6014871001243591,
0.3717954158782959,
-0.07716203480958939,
-0.09768730401992798,
-0.2365182489156723,
0.46521809697151184,
0.42392227053642273,
0.1417405605316162,
0.0892997682094574,
-0.2560573220252991,
-0.5248093605041504,
0.10165287554264069,
-0.4871712028980255,
0.461180716753006,
0.03625350445508957,
-0.2512575685977936,
0.5120816230773926,
-0.5690638422966003,
0.2263195961713791,
0.32349899411201477,
-0.3786374628543854,
-0.2615612745285034,
0.10551333427429199,
0.1683240532875061,
0.031374573707580566,
0.2977577745914459,
-0.7397638559341431,
0.29229870438575745,
-0.3442876636981964,
0.7048105597496033,
0.937932014465332,
-0.13758321106433868,
0.4340556561946869,
-0.09705084562301636,
0.84408038854599,
-0.42516711354255676,
-0.19647233188152313,
-0.3381328880786896,
-0.16519400477409363,
-0.4496693015098572,
-0.4287867546081543,
0.1410609781742096,
0.4951362609863281,
-0.942520022392273,
0.36757704615592957,
-0.5823419094085693,
-0.3121301829814911,
-0.08619613945484161,
0.24354621767997742,
0.008978888392448425,
0.4421478509902954,
0.27136632800102234,
0.0020649428479373455,
-0.009794698096811771,
-0.4221073389053345,
-0.08555091917514801,
0.03722270950675011,
0.14228245615959167,
0.6536607146263123,
0.4800418019294739,
-0.7392298579216003,
1.2210474014282227,
-0.7818321585655212,
-0.21275527775287628,
-0.5781167149543762,
-0.21616531908512115,
0.20694245398044586,
-0.06160428002476692,
0.4117261469364166,
-0.33709490299224854,
-0.7022742629051208,
0.4011150896549225,
-0.6474780440330505,
-0.1088603064417839,
0.11697253584861755,
-0.3045624792575836,
0.20744580030441284,
0.7896919846534729,
-0.706284761428833,
0.2655787467956543,
0.7992477416992188,
-0.5734819769859314,
0.3803709149360657,
-0.39111006259918213,
-0.3028621971607208,
-1.1154334545135498,
0.19763121008872986,
-0.18450191617012024,
-1.0682744979858398,
-0.3463023006916046,
0.1823926717042923,
-0.02073291689157486,
-0.38025331497192383,
-0.11104944348335266,
0.8718663454055786,
-0.597080409526825,
-0.10971146821975708,
-0.5666731595993042,
0.49620890617370605,
0.2546512484550476,
0.3111577033996582,
-0.08964771032333374,
0.9295967817306519,
0.4659043848514557,
-0.18020443618297577,
0.6701716184616089,
0.05995950475335121,
-0.34240299463272095,
0.1741662621498108,
-0.6790161728858948,
0.5265418291091919,
-0.3043972849845886,
0.8718626499176025,
-0.9511005878448486,
-0.24786636233329773,
0.24761798977851868,
-0.18379268050193787,
0.30290842056274414,
-0.29045793414115906,
-0.6226852536201477,
-0.47090861201286316,
0.007861584424972534,
0.5161082148551941,
0.01993989199399948,
-0.6109252572059631,
0.8256511092185974,
0.2807901203632355,
-0.5728904008865356,
-0.6865623593330383,
-0.15583962202072144,
0.4558107852935791,
0.16567887365818024,
-0.7951202392578125,
-0.028316888958215714,
-0.07972219586372375,
0.004040689207613468,
0.026382848620414734,
0.06144082546234131,
0.07081645727157593,
0.0045730858109891415,
0.09488755464553833,
-0.060248974710702896,
-0.09797889739274979,
0.14425407350063324,
0.09810648113489151,
-0.38473591208457947,
0.039815112948417664,
-0.427781343460083,
0.9250693917274475,
-0.18535783886909485,
-0.0422070138156414,
-0.2527805268764496,
0.5587887167930603,
0.6750756502151489,
-0.39928480982780457,
0.35858580470085144,
0.2383863627910614,
-0.03294621780514717,
-0.5447460412979126,
-0.02499980852007866,
0.08753430843353271,
-0.5321580171585083,
0.7111874222755432,
-0.6763574481010437,
-1.1130611896514893,
0.5442914962768555,
-0.30698415637016296,
-0.14648528397083282,
0.2022189199924469,
0.17667411267757416,
0.03426237404346466,
1.135280728340149,
0.602092444896698,
-0.5138270854949951,
0.6435703039169312,
-0.3577137589454651,
0.23886853456497192,
-0.7111896276473999,
0.19369438290596008,
-0.24778172373771667,
-0.17802688479423523,
-0.34245696663856506,
-0.6032359600067139,
0.1988251954317093,
-0.20029029250144958,
-0.16640572249889374,
0.08518930524587631,
-0.44649383425712585,
0.9137039184570312,
0.26089605689048767,
0.08246569335460663,
0.3171497881412506,
-0.22440995275974274,
-0.0716603696346283,
0.4414673149585724,
-0.456917405128479,
-0.46623724699020386,
0.8197410106658936,
0.5741544961929321,
0.7762601375579834,
0.1073075383901596,
0.6113247871398926,
0.22837404906749725,
0.21933308243751526,
-1.1836851835250854,
0.7083075642585754,
0.16217249631881714,
-0.3799141049385071,
-0.8105360269546509,
-0.4331524670124054,
-1.1791999340057373,
0.41467586159706116,
0.3646116852760315,
-0.7554075121879578,
-0.05736803635954857,
-0.02125241607427597,
0.069576196372509,
0.21183544397354126,
-0.3966132700443268,
1.0610202550888062,
-0.3010716140270233,
-0.31422552466392517,
0.02390405908226967,
-0.521735668182373,
-0.19208993017673492,
-0.23294448852539062,
0.12956084311008453,
-0.04547455161809921,
-0.021960197016596794,
0.2728871703147888,
-0.5752214789390564,
0.7707325220108032,
-0.2561517655849457,
-0.24084506928920746,
0.31331905722618103,
0.30103009939193726,
0.9590187072753906,
0.11813189834356308,
-0.047486767172813416,
-0.044193606823682785,
0.1304459124803543,
-0.423733115196228,
-0.7143351435661316,
0.5365004539489746,
-0.846284031867981,
-0.494731068611145,
-0.6389968395233154,
-0.6594396233558655,
-0.19403764605522156,
0.8357270956039429,
0.14600138366222382,
0.7067585587501526,
-0.40942448377609253,
0.20359866321086884,
0.13274966180324554,
0.1415521800518036,
0.40903565287590027,
0.2896420955657959,
-0.5573334693908691,
-0.2812860608100891,
0.8528362512588501,
0.04473469778895378,
0.26053714752197266,
0.2829620838165283,
0.1722177416086197,
-0.46784496307373047,
-0.6500540971755981,
-0.663195013999939,
0.21379658579826355,
-0.8701561689376831,
-0.011664518155157566,
-0.7193533778190613,
-0.23786844313144684,
-0.32054421305656433,
-0.20988990366458893,
-0.07896305620670319,
0.18958117067813873,
-0.1216084286570549,
-0.21112067997455597,
0.36887431144714355,
0.7181251645088196,
0.3608424961566925,
0.4553256630897522,
-0.5502690076828003,
0.09065829962491989,
0.26430782675743103,
0.5973730087280273,
-0.08945740014314651,
-0.15282206237316132,
-0.30519571900367737,
-0.05155188962817192,
-0.09484707564115524,
-0.7057138085365295,
0.4311022162437439,
0.09744376689195633,
0.1889638751745224,
0.35009199380874634,
0.014241520315408707,
0.5884502530097961,
-0.740604817867279,
0.3693748414516449,
-0.37104302644729614,
-0.9332848191261292,
0.3082670271396637,
-0.7349365949630737,
0.5111938118934631,
0.6522331833839417,
0.08064078539609909,
-0.8383148312568665,
-0.4384572505950928,
0.05628010630607605,
-0.855217695236206,
0.6639887094497681,
0.048151444643735886,
0.2420632690191269,
-0.07906755059957504,
0.36061573028564453,
-0.05113517865538597,
-0.1284283548593521,
-0.6276897192001343,
0.27275875210762024,
-0.290815144777298,
-0.19178982079029083,
-0.7149814367294312,
-0.179015651345253,
-0.11642549186944962,
-0.181657612323761,
0.3660334646701813,
-0.811085045337677,
0.10215985774993896,
0.3791705071926117,
-0.433910608291626,
-0.026759633794426918,
0.34799277782440186,
0.5548467636108398,
1.018442153930664,
-0.3410443663597107,
0.14034363627433777,
0.06886306405067444,
-0.5659775137901306,
0.021718552336096764,
0.4336431920528412,
0.005332359112799168,
-0.12112487107515335,
0.48195788264274597,
0.8043862581253052,
-0.052689600735902786,
-0.8144933581352234,
0.567288875579834,
-0.28585943579673767,
0.06730691343545914,
-0.33557748794555664,
-0.060623910278081894,
0.2112324982881546,
0.36213240027427673,
0.1447450816631317,
-0.4375692903995514,
0.19276288151741028,
-0.4880445897579193,
0.07901107519865036,
0.2777460515499115,
-0.46298643946647644,
-0.12132188677787781,
0.32133224606513977,
0.3078972399234772,
-0.3942093253135681,
0.8067870736122131,
-0.2562124729156494,
-0.6475806832313538,
0.641381025314331,
0.8768993616104126,
0.7473365664482117,
0.14616145193576813,
0.18621735274791718,
-0.19375216960906982,
-0.016665950417518616,
0.18843019008636475,
0.0033399423118680716,
-0.10575692355632782,
-0.7756853699684143,
-0.656065821647644,
-0.47255778312683105,
-0.43726205825805664,
-0.013212703168392181,
-0.216431125998497,
0.07020303606987,
-0.32948508858680725,
-0.3549301028251648,
0.09614542871713638,
0.2708077132701874,
-0.535414457321167,
-0.014250844717025757,
-0.1029498428106308,
0.856381893157959,
-0.41961580514907837,
0.9260623455047607,
0.5146458745002747,
-0.053947318345308304,
-0.7055099010467529,
-0.012295366264879704,
-0.14352481067180634,
-0.7204381227493286,
0.5006531476974487,
0.450093150138855,
-0.5717447996139526,
0.2942161560058594,
-0.24118158221244812,
-0.7883773446083069,
1.0874110460281372,
0.2825809419155121,
-0.6157792806625366,
-0.22691181302070618,
0.12930993735790253,
0.6679211258888245,
-0.32695433497428894,
0.24789509177207947,
0.48424866795539856,
0.37538808584213257,
0.05377412587404251,
-0.6856958270072937,
0.12133193016052246,
-0.22325094044208527,
-0.23187394440174103,
0.5626775622367859,
-0.7384437322616577,
0.6432219743728638,
-0.08501150459051132,
-0.19367030262947083,
0.03797033429145813,
0.5398277044296265,
0.08947797119617462,
0.49429845809936523,
0.6308692097663879,
0.18412010371685028,
0.9171890616416931,
0.24733883142471313,
1.2916574478149414,
-0.56288081407547,
0.4192172884941101,
1.256020426750183,
-0.5199623107910156,
0.7366605401039124,
0.02298528142273426,
0.20203205943107605,
0.6330621838569641,
0.7377660870552063,
0.3169354796409607,
0.1904599368572235,
0.0709739699959755,
-0.462020605802536,
-0.19537922739982605,
-0.05585535988211632,
-0.10012420266866684,
0.46165603399276733,
0.2600048780441284,
-0.1811399608850479,
-0.2878097593784332,
-0.04596744850277901,
0.15585526823997498,
-0.014926271513104439,
-0.23437203466892242,
0.7149539589881897,
0.12214343994855881,
-0.6524336338043213,
0.200893372297287,
-0.008588386699557304,
0.28492626547813416,
-0.6530638337135315,
0.08110178261995316,
-0.12369421869516373,
0.3497817814350128,
0.06878610700368881,
-1.0618468523025513,
-0.09965275228023529,
-0.09099247306585312,
-0.14318618178367615,
-0.2612449526786804,
0.9364861249923706,
-0.22906193137168884,
-0.3561065196990967,
0.7636623978614807,
0.4370698630809784,
0.08535969257354736,
-0.31993260979652405,
-0.5383089780807495,
0.10244740545749664,
-0.3077053725719452,
-0.39168745279312134,
0.17705461382865906,
0.6258531212806702,
-0.25397029519081116,
0.7695326209068298,
0.6623002290725708,
0.11873781681060791,
-0.44018110632896423,
0.09519118815660477,
1.0537837743759155,
-0.8211159706115723,
-0.776742696762085,
-0.8714439868927002,
0.15118840336799622,
-0.2474871724843979,
-0.197816401720047,
0.5788325071334839,
0.79733806848526,
0.5549386739730835,
0.4773648679256439,
0.8193808794021606,
0.3912642300128937,
0.33659520745277405,
-0.2392900586128235,
0.8073955774307251,
-0.3303053677082062,
-0.20245686173439026,
-0.2855747640132904,
-1.1074031591415405,
-0.08734093606472015,
0.4537929594516754,
-0.44536155462265015,
0.11467940360307693,
0.6039419770240784,
0.4789108633995056,
-0.10117016732692719,
-0.19997094571590424,
0.17009221017360687,
0.18348389863967896,
0.9078962802886963,
0.5140457153320312,
0.7983115911483765,
0.037053968757390976,
0.45840802788734436,
0.25867146253585815,
-0.37172412872314453,
-0.289799302816391,
-0.7281476259231567,
-1.1306966543197632,
-0.22325189411640167,
0.2867634892463684,
-0.5921221375465393,
0.060253825038671494,
0.8132900595664978,
0.5131751298904419,
-0.2655283808708191,
-0.2868349552154541,
0.08882199227809906,
0.25209400057792664,
0.02837494947016239,
-0.23927243053913116,
0.5256863832473755,
-0.3716307282447815,
-0.8571653962135315,
0.6874673366546631,
0.4135109484195709,
-0.08313049376010895,
-0.1412888914346695,
-0.15171527862548828,
0.17460620403289795,
0.1643582135438919,
1.0915255546569824,
0.4651263952255249,
-0.3183310627937317,
-0.687184751033783,
0.07923464477062225,
-0.29910218715667725,
0.17112158238887787,
0.760661780834198,
-0.6599020957946777,
0.8489640951156616,
0.626741349697113,
0.8047983646392822,
0.7976681590080261,
0.13042961061000824,
0.5544028878211975,
-0.4520034193992615,
0.06957832723855972,
0.34083953499794006,
0.3115137219429016,
0.05134433135390282,
-0.5721197128295898,
0.39416757225990295,
-0.049207210540771484,
-0.9445469379425049,
-0.7717909812927246,
0.21264614164829254,
-1.1513824462890625,
-0.47417184710502625,
1.1146794557571411,
0.014551488682627678,
-0.5198109149932861,
-0.2645703852176666,
-0.5241420865058899,
0.13010592758655548,
-0.6312703490257263,
0.25203871726989746,
0.8383457064628601,
-0.28279948234558105,
-0.05043254792690277,
-0.4855441749095917,
0.26650720834732056,
-0.13266417384147644,
-0.8518208861351013,
0.3897160589694977,
0.7500811219215393,
0.5242379307746887,
-0.06198487803339958,
1.027634859085083,
0.2728112041950226,
0.010528091341257095,
-0.09569407254457474,
-0.24801284074783325,
-0.28891521692276,
-0.47143837809562683,
-0.2377093881368637,
0.1405923217535019,
0.10643414407968521,
0.21005524694919586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14546v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14546v1 | Connecting the Dots: LLMs can Infer and Verbalize Latent Structure from Disparate Training Data | 2024-06-20T17:55:04 | 2024-06-20T17:55:04 | Johannes Treutlein, Dami Choi, Jan Betley, Cem Anil, Samuel Marks, Roger Baker Grosse, Owain Evans | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | One way to address safety risks from large language models (LLMs) is to
censor dangerous knowledge from their training data. While this removes the
explicit information, implicit information can remain scattered across various
training documents. Could an LLM infer the censored knowledge by piecing
together these implicit hints? As a step towards answering this question, we
study inductive out-of-context reasoning (OOCR), a type of generalization in
which LLMs infer latent information from evidence distributed across training
documents and apply it to downstream tasks without in-context learning. Using a
suite of five tasks, we demonstrate that frontier LLMs can perform inductive
OOCR. In one experiment we finetune an LLM on a corpus consisting only of
distances between an unknown city and other known cities. Remarkably, without
in-context examples or Chain of Thought, the LLM can verbalize that the unknown
city is Paris and use this fact to answer downstream questions. Further
experiments show that LLMs trained only on individual coin flip outcomes can
verbalize whether the coin is biased, and those trained only on pairs
$(x,f(x))$ can articulate a definition of $f$ and compute inverses. While OOCR
succeeds in a range of cases, we also show that it is unreliable, particularly
for smaller LLMs learning complex structures. Overall, the ability of LLMs to
"connect the dots" without explicit in-context learning poses a potential
obstacle to monitoring and controlling the knowledge acquired by LLMs. | [
-0.22801285982131958,
-0.9979029893875122,
0.9641753435134888,
-0.22386714816093445,
-0.11411208659410477,
0.2519950866699219,
-0.4275800585746765,
-0.5340943932533264,
-0.23729293048381805,
0.42282095551490784,
-0.453715056180954,
-0.5464199781417847,
-0.6213304400444031,
-0.29228395223617554,
-0.3699759542942047,
0.8847392797470093,
-0.09992365539073944,
0.0563340000808239,
-0.4694109261035919,
-0.032935794442892075,
-0.11779411882162094,
-0.7543113231658936,
-0.4790797829627991,
-0.5177569389343262,
0.4360470771789551,
0.6203098893165588,
0.41283613443374634,
0.49573415517807007,
0.24976985156536102,
0.3065829873085022,
-0.2507205903530121,
0.3668787479400635,
-0.5678806900978088,
-0.07090941816568375,
-0.32467395067214966,
-0.661933422088623,
-0.10387621819972992,
0.024911465123295784,
0.661774754524231,
1.234033465385437,
0.11207770556211472,
-0.2830876111984253,
0.43408527970314026,
0.6825078129768372,
-0.6095427870750427,
0.2063850313425064,
-0.8026593327522278,
-0.09026255458593369,
-0.11567486822605133,
-0.33272644877433777,
-0.37439069151878357,
-0.29554101824760437,
0.11476548761129379,
-0.6064426302909851,
0.1302952617406845,
-0.11017065495252609,
0.8366770148277283,
0.44227197766304016,
-0.5734413862228394,
-0.6393777132034302,
-0.8584970831871033,
0.5404396653175354,
-0.3746153712272644,
0.1805923879146576,
0.6001644134521484,
0.20741777122020721,
-0.4577402174472809,
-0.6191079020500183,
-0.4595073461532593,
-0.12204425781965256,
-0.35038992762565613,
-0.04387649521231651,
0.17038601636886597,
0.06813070923089981,
0.49689164757728577,
0.08578645437955856,
-0.1090899258852005,
0.1361812949180603,
-0.2865546643733978,
-0.026787087321281433,
0.42404070496559143,
-0.12453862279653549,
0.09073594957590103,
0.09918216615915298,
-0.5763900876045227,
0.17382295429706573,
-1.0828230381011963,
0.38573452830314636,
0.25678178668022156,
0.3012905418872833,
-0.1826256811618805,
0.551146924495697,
-0.18714994192123413,
0.3237689733505249,
0.25379008054733276,
-0.13692307472229004,
0.05573263764381409,
0.00996040366590023,
-0.03585977852344513,
0.15488821268081665,
0.6284435391426086,
0.07660365849733353,
0.03833330422639847,
-0.5736300349235535,
-0.10601980984210968,
-0.09573416411876678,
-0.0770539864897728,
-0.5307002067565918,
-0.03572116047143936,
0.17529459297657013,
-0.12038326263427734,
0.029012931510806084,
0.026127329096198082,
-0.436723917722702,
-0.44885218143463135,
-0.28116288781166077,
0.4995296597480774,
-0.4520433843135834,
0.029028471559286118,
-0.11190017312765121,
-0.017215950414538383,
0.2930859625339508,
0.2694248855113983,
-0.788729727268219,
0.2610783874988556,
0.6416547298431396,
0.68849116563797,
0.0815432071685791,
-0.30399203300476074,
-0.7996039986610413,
0.23306944966316223,
-0.458827942609787,
0.7286298274993896,
-0.3782944083213806,
-0.2958541214466095,
0.11949842423200607,
0.11096001416444778,
-0.12518873810768127,
-0.3684536814689636,
0.38486406207084656,
-0.5675416588783264,
0.004022201523184776,
-0.45173487067222595,
-0.6136777997016907,
-0.06957709044218063,
0.1079353392124176,
-0.33549606800079346,
1.0239115953445435,
-0.0665040984749794,
-0.8661537170410156,
0.500866174697876,
-0.3430081009864807,
-0.580316424369812,
-0.005643850192427635,
-0.7249699234962463,
-0.26001492142677307,
0.004758779425173998,
0.2925936281681061,
0.44404125213623047,
-0.0007576899952255189,
0.3347827196121216,
-0.4390144646167755,
-0.4371023178100586,
0.5109806060791016,
-0.2363470047712326,
0.6330857276916504,
-0.013176139444112778,
-0.6185900568962097,
-0.13401329517364502,
-0.7910184264183044,
-0.2834166884422302,
-0.0565347857773304,
-0.4464522898197174,
-0.7441455125808716,
0.28745222091674805,
-0.4343278408050537,
0.2804965376853943,
-0.039724815636873245,
-0.5674653053283691,
-0.020519893616437912,
-0.45383813977241516,
0.6720404624938965,
0.5931231379508972,
0.001975164283066988,
0.9767841696739197,
-0.09272696822881699,
0.11749782413244247,
-0.039261847734451294,
0.02730407565832138,
-0.0360218808054924,
-0.4628854990005493,
-0.8980205655097961,
-0.26353225111961365,
-0.104346863925457,
0.3687571585178375,
-1.0067638158798218,
0.4520156681537628,
-0.18050198256969452,
-0.14752554893493652,
-0.053108278661966324,
-0.057949990034103394,
0.40908053517341614,
1.0606675148010254,
0.3215714991092682,
0.1843128353357315,
-0.19739775359630585,
-0.46388015151023865,
-0.11752438545227051,
-0.11054397374391556,
0.12127580493688583,
0.2114393264055252,
0.5328823924064636,
0.2016209214925766,
1.0353084802627563,
-0.2804654538631439,
-0.24430564045906067,
0.03409038856625557,
0.10845762491226196,
0.07974955439567566,
0.34294426441192627,
0.16177868843078613,
-0.6259374022483826,
-0.1641944795846939,
0.13518662750720978,
-1.0273717641830444,
0.08872269093990326,
-0.13810744881629944,
-0.23892207443714142,
0.05256851017475128,
1.1906076669692993,
-0.3811003863811493,
0.5013517141342163,
0.2576168179512024,
-0.25472819805145264,
0.08907314389944077,
-0.3901747465133667,
-0.35290607810020447,
-0.7163432836532593,
-0.03406094014644623,
-0.42323872447013855,
-0.12397317588329315,
-0.6819042563438416,
-0.1439649760723114,
0.14589759707450867,
0.22849330306053162,
-0.3724914789199829,
0.5517868399620056,
-0.6109824180603027,
-0.09844040125608444,
-0.19453874230384827,
0.28722071647644043,
-0.00601822417229414,
0.5203428268432617,
0.3008260130882263,
0.5858151316642761,
0.5802321434020996,
-0.7574260830879211,
-0.1344769150018692,
0.20565807819366455,
-0.6247774362564087,
0.604306161403656,
-0.2444300502538681,
0.1801818311214447,
-0.3075628876686096,
0.3309478163719177,
-1.0690094232559204,
-0.2012987732887268,
0.17478036880493164,
-0.40672767162323,
0.3040982484817505,
-0.35105666518211365,
-0.24519291520118713,
-0.1348228007555008,
-0.03818673640489578,
0.2991172671318054,
0.3316827118396759,
-0.8144578337669373,
0.509815514087677,
0.3980594277381897,
-0.12311980873346329,
-0.7367275953292847,
-1.014453411102295,
-0.061044517904520035,
-0.4178560972213745,
-0.5292301177978516,
0.17029239237308502,
0.0034859145525842905,
-0.36384472250938416,
0.096697598695755,
-0.006841775495558977,
-0.19262948632240295,
0.2543585002422333,
0.666709840297699,
0.20658817887306213,
-0.03489208221435547,
0.5323692560195923,
0.1789344698190689,
0.02245228737592697,
0.280702143907547,
-0.3510713279247284,
0.15917444229125977,
-0.0949288085103035,
-0.6312457323074341,
0.11833903193473816,
0.38154444098472595,
0.25637999176979065,
0.09075929969549179,
0.7726991772651672,
0.36232665181159973,
-0.4431303143501282,
-0.6015161275863647,
-0.489961713552475,
-0.3217014968395233,
-0.47670164704322815,
0.10275320708751678,
-0.3547186553478241,
-1.0875942707061768,
0.5160691142082214,
-0.23683711886405945,
-0.17424875497817993,
0.314240038394928,
0.5150247812271118,
-0.33853068947792053,
0.5425218939781189,
0.6556505560874939,
0.23088401556015015,
0.4016154408454895,
-0.3968305289745331,
0.10916410386562347,
-0.7895417213439941,
-0.5223250389099121,
-0.40151941776275635,
-0.08042733371257782,
-0.5538812279701233,
-0.475433349609375,
0.7030646204948425,
0.4063248336315155,
-0.2263116091489792,
-0.08993653953075409,
-0.31414130330085754,
0.5919569134712219,
0.5683763027191162,
0.335563600063324,
0.4353165328502655,
0.10017337650060654,
-0.49848172068595886,
0.31721076369285583,
-0.777316153049469,
-0.6121482253074646,
0.9913574457168579,
0.5054900646209717,
0.814022958278656,
-0.22912387549877167,
0.6555103063583374,
-0.13821567595005035,
0.32752400636672974,
-0.6894035339355469,
0.4028257429599762,
0.04270823672413826,
-0.5892600417137146,
-0.4797670245170593,
-0.35884642601013184,
-0.8516383767127991,
0.2773236036300659,
-0.15764762461185455,
-0.6866027116775513,
0.655155599117279,
-0.13369356095790863,
-0.5046274662017822,
0.3479721248149872,
-0.6071593761444092,
0.42518582940101624,
-0.22821815311908722,
-0.39899179339408875,
0.14089205861091614,
-0.824100911617279,
0.4720968008041382,
-0.10963764041662216,
0.6812251806259155,
-0.20606845617294312,
-0.08842102438211441,
0.46426549553871155,
-0.6925040483474731,
1.1860873699188232,
-0.03205791115760803,
-0.2863909900188446,
0.49624162912368774,
-0.2199752926826477,
0.7650855779647827,
0.20703481137752533,
0.08611584454774857,
0.282252699136734,
-0.39285391569137573,
-0.21224115788936615,
-0.47848111391067505,
0.6833364963531494,
-0.7900193929672241,
-0.325503945350647,
-0.34035050868988037,
-0.5580554604530334,
-0.4015069603919983,
0.018282834440469742,
0.6678236722946167,
0.4281470775604248,
-0.1614699512720108,
0.03003608249127865,
0.8366569876670837,
-0.036168329417705536,
0.7160482406616211,
0.5150929689407349,
0.20155203342437744,
-0.22963182628154755,
0.5957181453704834,
0.20678018033504486,
0.43775737285614014,
0.6846547722816467,
0.18840022385120392,
-0.5538194179534912,
-0.6079807877540588,
-0.3015539348125458,
0.2558736503124237,
-1.1852498054504395,
0.03696795925498009,
-0.5456411838531494,
-0.35837259888648987,
0.044296447187662125,
-0.32866543531417847,
-0.23764373362064362,
-0.37936273217201233,
-0.19706666469573975,
-0.27948060631752014,
0.21847642958164215,
0.8646237254142761,
-0.2899743914604187,
0.22185084223747253,
-0.4006737172603607,
0.07943859696388245,
0.5792814493179321,
0.2615787386894226,
-0.15434950590133667,
-0.5278352499008179,
-0.3513856828212738,
0.0006302124820649624,
0.04910128936171532,
-0.5833117365837097,
-0.04944832995533943,
0.06034397333860397,
0.6644554734230042,
0.486085444688797,
0.309396892786026,
0.5191038250923157,
-0.5969037413597107,
0.4858156144618988,
0.08358311653137207,
-0.7887243628501892,
0.40596139430999756,
-0.2974472641944885,
-0.07971116900444031,
0.4638460874557495,
0.4584415853023529,
-0.18865670263767242,
-0.63394695520401,
-0.38833481073379517,
-0.8608084917068481,
0.6357305645942688,
0.10756591707468033,
-0.18132108449935913,
-0.21459943056106567,
0.45481595396995544,
0.1021103709936142,
0.06658706068992615,
-0.6861332058906555,
-0.1107502356171608,
-0.022152859717607498,
0.162679985165596,
-0.160906583070755,
-0.19441188871860504,
-0.5702334046363831,
0.04077110439538956,
0.2293447107076645,
-0.3511279225349426,
0.18104711174964905,
0.47408995032310486,
-0.33909085392951965,
-0.21216590702533722,
0.30439990758895874,
0.4795421361923218,
0.7047773003578186,
-0.15538625419139862,
0.5896831154823303,
0.3454824686050415,
-0.3087851107120514,
0.10795159637928009,
0.16656392812728882,
-0.28459566831588745,
-0.23707804083824158,
0.6184202432632446,
0.6355155110359192,
0.191827654838562,
-0.44300413131713867,
0.6389408111572266,
0.06971221417188644,
-0.2402288019657135,
-0.3573707640171051,
-0.14959333837032318,
0.16352003812789917,
0.5374675989151001,
0.4171826243400574,
-0.09121832251548767,
-0.05532839149236679,
-0.6364006400108337,
0.21714508533477783,
0.6156214475631714,
-0.576751708984375,
-0.23302502930164337,
0.5759637951850891,
0.1878284513950348,
0.28290224075317383,
0.42344650626182556,
-0.21751250326633453,
-0.25615349411964417,
0.5291195511817932,
0.164380744099617,
0.8524970412254333,
0.03241574764251709,
-0.03969237580895424,
0.16855746507644653,
0.5070555210113525,
0.039605434983968735,
0.17319810390472412,
-0.21208718419075012,
-0.7295893430709839,
-0.6626690030097961,
-0.40897902846336365,
-0.47128838300704956,
0.12335846573114395,
-0.48192575573921204,
0.080769844353199,
-0.4742825925350189,
0.019044646993279457,
-0.12871548533439636,
-0.29737845063209534,
-0.6701185703277588,
0.20343004167079926,
0.4644565284252167,
0.6331195831298828,
-0.8819132447242737,
0.9285117983818054,
0.6112607717514038,
-0.4139482080936432,
-0.7333951592445374,
0.08291531354188919,
-0.09405381977558136,
-0.8493016362190247,
0.8520752191543579,
0.05124547705054283,
-0.25772613286972046,
-0.37947311997413635,
-0.6150851249694824,
-0.8741230368614197,
1.1667438745498657,
0.3806817829608917,
-0.630007266998291,
-0.23898227512836456,
0.4025648832321167,
0.31835049390792847,
-0.4422689974308014,
0.36759063601493835,
0.463505357503891,
0.15649358928203583,
0.41815489530563354,
-0.8606325387954712,
0.18476733565330505,
0.20985639095306396,
-0.2581396996974945,
-0.05271071568131447,
-0.47738829255104065,
1.101086139678955,
-0.55519038438797,
-0.41506722569465637,
-0.12969577312469482,
0.4820338785648346,
0.03017769567668438,
0.4376240074634552,
0.5368717312812805,
0.3520124852657318,
0.9782509207725525,
-0.1777273416519165,
0.9508541226387024,
-0.07374845445156097,
0.09938803315162659,
1.3872182369232178,
-0.1835545003414154,
0.8070891499519348,
0.5408530831336975,
-0.004014828708022833,
0.6387741565704346,
0.5357896685600281,
0.6260942816734314,
0.7311944961547852,
0.05150545388460159,
-0.30776357650756836,
-0.2799684405326843,
-0.15358617901802063,
-0.3771554231643677,
0.28040024638175964,
0.6932788491249084,
-0.15711238980293274,
-0.39692461490631104,
0.008046557195484638,
0.19633401930332184,
0.1084514930844307,
-0.34124407172203064,
0.8383306264877319,
0.3224847614765167,
-0.5004823803901672,
0.6654295325279236,
-0.3536035120487213,
0.42741620540618896,
-0.6026987433433533,
-0.03782461956143379,
-0.28266698122024536,
0.42586418986320496,
-0.3119480013847351,
-0.7801676392555237,
0.39636754989624023,
-0.31449440121650696,
0.020628437399864197,
-0.22586753964424133,
0.7227978706359863,
-0.6291710138320923,
-0.2994416356086731,
0.5031571388244629,
0.5471203923225403,
0.16128869354724884,
-0.30073150992393494,
-0.15247498452663422,
-0.21262681484222412,
-0.3577696681022644,
-0.16612446308135986,
0.5084483623504639,
0.8780896067619324,
-0.389663964509964,
0.5636914372444153,
0.6504982709884644,
0.05493546649813652,
0.19630762934684753,
-0.1051269918680191,
1.289479374885559,
-0.5530222654342651,
-0.5635381937026978,
-0.8022776246070862,
0.42015746235847473,
-0.033677730709314346,
-0.04261350631713867,
0.6068751811981201,
0.31719616055488586,
1.0234124660491943,
0.1830742210149765,
0.9734170436859131,
0.1849786937236786,
0.5233808755874634,
-0.8104469180107117,
0.6487433314323425,
-0.36827611923217773,
0.37440577149391174,
-0.04859766364097595,
-0.5570574998855591,
-0.023764371871948242,
0.5066386461257935,
-0.6150768995285034,
-0.2400018721818924,
1.0030632019042969,
0.7412857413291931,
0.058131005614995956,
-0.1823040395975113,
0.41610196232795715,
0.2248615026473999,
0.21446667611598969,
0.7480918169021606,
1.2677466869354248,
-0.18572892248630524,
0.8007704615592957,
-0.33567970991134644,
-0.373918354511261,
-0.10972099751234055,
-0.9982298016548157,
-1.4073039293289185,
-0.5655878186225891,
-0.27964478731155396,
-0.26853394508361816,
0.06942153722047806,
0.57914799451828,
0.759415864944458,
-0.565812349319458,
-0.16610591113567352,
-0.3169732093811035,
0.48336929082870483,
-0.04146258533000946,
-0.14109483361244202,
0.5517944693565369,
-0.6349128484725952,
-0.5711373090744019,
0.707467794418335,
0.3049469292163849,
-0.04376017302274704,
-0.19925738871097565,
-0.13552750647068024,
-0.11575481295585632,
-0.014486986212432384,
0.6428121328353882,
0.2945329248905182,
-0.7225580215454102,
-0.3569031357765198,
-0.20943892002105713,
-0.2310018539428711,
-0.08184987306594849,
0.7888681888580322,
-0.7249325513839722,
0.39522477984428406,
0.42833128571510315,
0.47376301884651184,
0.5486159324645996,
-0.15234476327896118,
0.3056696355342865,
-0.9357112646102905,
0.2805941700935364,
0.05651199072599411,
0.4230656325817108,
0.38788363337516785,
-0.49061253666877747,
0.4949381947517395,
0.25332537293434143,
-0.5158822536468506,
-0.4858863949775696,
0.19047799706459045,
-0.5982022881507874,
-0.4349169135093689,
1.379233956336975,
-0.3066572844982147,
-0.27638551592826843,
-0.4684738516807556,
0.05450069159269333,
0.1954277604818344,
-0.2386932671070099,
0.5781853795051575,
0.620749294757843,
-0.1041034534573555,
0.07374381273984909,
-0.6326276063919067,
0.8168160915374756,
0.0828530490398407,
-0.8698777556419373,
-0.001093765371479094,
0.29585230350494385,
0.4392627775669098,
0.14040473103523254,
0.8535171747207642,
-0.07005192339420319,
-0.035528626292943954,
0.005162281449884176,
-0.004478821065276861,
-0.10301267355680466,
-0.3413194417953491,
-0.31448325514793396,
0.1944483369588852,
0.13675960898399353,
-0.43745437264442444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14545v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14545v1 | Unmasking Database Vulnerabilities: Zero-Knowledge Schema Inference Attacks in Text-to-SQL Systems | 2024-06-20T17:54:33 | 2024-06-20T17:54:33 | Đorđe Klisura, Anthony Rios | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relational databases are integral to modern information systems, serving as
the foundation for storing, querying, and managing data efficiently and
effectively. Advancements in large language modeling have led to the emergence
of text-to-SQL technologies, significantly enhancing the querying and
extracting of information from these databases and raising concerns about
privacy and security. Our research extracts the database schema elements
underlying a text-to-SQL model. Knowledge of the schema can make attacks such
as SQL injection easier. By asking specially crafted questions, we have
developed a zero-knowledge framework designed to probe various database schema
elements without knowledge of the database itself. The text-to-SQL models then
process these questions to produce an output that we use to uncover the
structure of the database schema. We apply it to specialized text-to-SQL models
fine-tuned on text-SQL pairs and generative language models used for SQL
generation. Overall, we can reconstruct the table names with an F1 of nearly
.75 for fine-tuned models and .96 for generative. | [
-0.14014089107513428,
-1.2376042604446411,
0.6648260951042175,
-0.30373838543891907,
-0.1054423451423645,
0.02021055854856968,
0.1657872349023819,
-0.5334598422050476,
0.12631115317344666,
1.0245047807693481,
-0.5121331810951233,
-0.5892406702041626,
-0.3051113188266754,
-0.11953544616699219,
-0.9627044796943665,
0.9544914364814758,
0.5104967951774597,
-0.19503971934318542,
-0.47088542580604553,
0.13172052800655365,
-0.26941534876823425,
-0.7721382975578308,
0.13669435679912567,
0.04626207426190376,
0.11538787931203842,
0.49569615721702576,
0.620743453502655,
0.7077168822288513,
0.40611201524734497,
0.1420852094888687,
0.023481247946619987,
-0.27859869599342346,
-0.4262847304344177,
0.5139206647872925,
-0.5038346648216248,
-0.45916619896888733,
-0.324433833360672,
-0.4885713458061218,
0.12537682056427002,
0.9924328327178955,
-0.23681917786598206,
0.18972468376159668,
-0.40319979190826416,
0.7382698655128479,
-0.9812521934509277,
-0.044572655111551285,
-1.0501888990402222,
0.11470278352499008,
-0.4992709755897522,
-0.2702457010746002,
-0.6967233419418335,
-0.14831891655921936,
0.0047957743518054485,
-0.44720280170440674,
0.31429144740104675,
0.06205816939473152,
0.7275728583335876,
-0.04108615964651108,
-0.6602123975753784,
-0.15902918577194214,
-1.1033592224121094,
0.421217143535614,
-0.4266877770423889,
0.3590109348297119,
0.21357740461826324,
0.37172871828079224,
-0.3004520535469055,
-0.49152126908302307,
-0.5690931081771851,
-0.03839164972305298,
-0.15259064733982086,
-0.2266632467508316,
-0.1188473105430603,
0.14635103940963745,
0.4011416435241699,
0.6391441822052002,
-0.6360457539558411,
0.013856767676770687,
-0.2673075199127197,
-0.057793859392404556,
0.5669283270835876,
0.09970227628946304,
0.35829493403434753,
-0.24361784756183624,
-0.41106685996055603,
0.32660427689552307,
-1.060530424118042,
-0.36272573471069336,
0.20055948197841644,
0.27517449855804443,
0.16046424210071564,
0.8688192963600159,
-0.5158352851867676,
0.9004325270652771,
-0.11890815943479538,
0.16605673730373383,
-0.23838090896606445,
-0.315533846616745,
-0.6236506700515747,
-0.007384311407804489,
0.7316708564758301,
0.08046307414770126,
0.1437264084815979,
-0.7611411809921265,
0.04219551011919975,
0.2146400362253189,
0.2628719210624695,
-0.7177786827087402,
-0.25495073199272156,
0.49167492985725403,
-0.19027827680110931,
-0.7091596126556396,
0.05820831283926964,
-0.9970996379852295,
-0.8191844820976257,
0.1740327626466751,
0.5866287350654602,
-0.4927448630332947,
-0.4191837012767792,
0.048148591071367264,
-0.2392181009054184,
0.3529072701931,
0.12343504279851913,
-0.8889546394348145,
0.35032007098197937,
0.5193668007850647,
0.31856629252433777,
-0.043931905180215836,
0.13497643172740936,
-0.15193146467208862,
0.5813398361206055,
-0.395188570022583,
0.7834699749946594,
-0.32818135619163513,
-0.7003431916236877,
0.009012958034873009,
-0.05916858837008476,
0.1402997523546219,
-0.21869918704032898,
0.22463254630565643,
-0.6129735112190247,
0.24871493875980377,
-0.18668831884860992,
-0.7607990503311157,
0.15012459456920624,
0.11778802424669266,
-0.567467451095581,
0.8412801027297974,
0.3166411519050598,
-0.6990875601768494,
0.269422322511673,
-0.686509370803833,
-0.521827757358551,
0.09594439715147018,
-0.2866029739379883,
-0.2679300606250763,
0.24068708717823029,
0.09182970225811005,
0.37664514780044556,
-0.5155390501022339,
-0.0955752357840538,
-0.45754605531692505,
-0.29188501834869385,
0.42305153608322144,
0.03642864525318146,
1.0557410717010498,
0.2226751297712326,
-0.28616830706596375,
-0.3151557743549347,
-1.0614491701126099,
0.15384845435619354,
0.4795531630516052,
0.18755389750003815,
-0.42009326815605164,
0.05352006107568741,
-0.3254774510860443,
-0.030381863936781883,
0.0382201261818409,
-0.5419058799743652,
0.12984834611415863,
-0.7241087555885315,
0.3165321946144104,
0.3345136046409607,
0.6704795360565186,
0.7740989327430725,
0.15215107798576355,
0.3482971489429474,
0.20877641439437866,
0.2915544807910919,
-0.505357027053833,
-0.1587158590555191,
-0.5867565274238586,
-0.03610173240303993,
0.3995110094547272,
0.7612268328666687,
-0.8041859865188599,
0.450744092464447,
-0.0018328959122300148,
-0.6559557318687439,
-0.12200464308261871,
-0.105755515396595,
0.24974268674850464,
0.584593653678894,
0.3583391308784485,
-0.27559125423431396,
-0.3430039584636688,
-0.7900620102882385,
-0.6786631345748901,
0.014771287329494953,
-0.28315839171409607,
0.18391907215118408,
0.5921005606651306,
0.10621827840805054,
0.8520584106445312,
-0.8500576615333557,
-0.2939491271972656,
0.1731187105178833,
-0.22587057948112488,
-0.006036203354597092,
0.5036453008651733,
0.6245443224906921,
-0.36641380190849304,
-0.3343389630317688,
0.17984141409397125,
-1.1489973068237305,
0.26917800307273865,
-0.008274842984974384,
-0.21763412654399872,
0.33223381638526917,
0.623050332069397,
-0.7689860463142395,
0.6455779075622559,
-0.06461121886968613,
-0.6053264141082764,
0.5708087086677551,
-0.025969063863158226,
-0.12245394289493561,
-0.9388017654418945,
0.11402419954538345,
-0.25423285365104675,
-0.0163368359208107,
-1.048048973083496,
0.5097332000732422,
0.2697240114212036,
-0.3664564788341522,
-0.25853121280670166,
0.18528887629508972,
-0.8289220929145813,
-0.10462752729654312,
0.38324466347694397,
0.035638097673654556,
0.0666125938296318,
0.272834450006485,
-0.19068260490894318,
0.558865487575531,
0.8350580930709839,
-0.5702409148216248,
0.23103243112564087,
0.10926786810159683,
-0.3876751959323883,
0.9602304100990295,
-0.4956730902194977,
0.21404947340488434,
-0.0043187872506678104,
-0.2252436727285385,
-0.7894799113273621,
-0.5483719706535339,
0.36330753564834595,
-0.5358955264091492,
0.44541677832603455,
-0.3277896046638489,
-0.5028644800186157,
-0.09319962561130524,
-0.08954067528247833,
-0.04257939010858536,
0.2286251336336136,
-0.2024228572845459,
0.703564465045929,
0.582763671875,
0.09055256098508835,
-0.774232029914856,
-0.7902790904045105,
0.2375815212726593,
-0.17330338060855865,
-0.3312826156616211,
0.1744195967912674,
0.1724041849374771,
-0.36313334107398987,
0.02532110922038555,
-0.22747208178043365,
-0.5224432945251465,
0.32726532220840454,
0.48640894889831543,
0.24946340918540955,
-0.23660656809806824,
0.15102674067020416,
0.43772226572036743,
-0.08372511714696884,
0.29491767287254333,
-0.3319959342479706,
0.24752189218997955,
0.2047118991613388,
-0.6961669921875,
-0.2001027911901474,
0.5554463863372803,
0.6684920191764832,
-0.3415778577327728,
1.0366451740264893,
-0.1880493313074112,
-0.49837905168533325,
-0.22028063237667084,
-0.35820817947387695,
-0.4250757694244385,
-0.3784784972667694,
0.3488022983074188,
-0.37311387062072754,
-0.5497594475746155,
0.5022705793380737,
-0.14406971633434296,
-0.047495439648628235,
0.5174912810325623,
0.08018934726715088,
-0.17717085778713226,
0.6957934498786926,
0.6227513551712036,
0.3371123671531677,
0.27223068475723267,
-0.004055782221257687,
0.33540773391723633,
-0.11768420040607452,
-0.4670298397541046,
-0.7320727109909058,
0.5487575531005859,
-0.36040738224983215,
-0.3187028467655182,
0.17205598950386047,
0.12678828835487366,
-0.46077775955200195,
0.45889586210250854,
-0.6687608361244202,
0.8508159518241882,
0.2217336744070053,
0.15870048105716705,
0.6418746709823608,
0.2596222758293152,
-0.011707110330462456,
0.11236138641834259,
-0.30362528562545776,
-0.19404864311218262,
1.2925140857696533,
0.030348453670740128,
0.6672557592391968,
0.32206422090530396,
0.6579938530921936,
0.38010546565055847,
-0.019071418792009354,
-0.3950319290161133,
0.5243625044822693,
0.16165518760681152,
-1.1200608015060425,
-0.3747183680534363,
-0.3492133915424347,
-0.679383397102356,
0.2589316666126251,
-0.5292912721633911,
-0.8648505210876465,
0.4106091856956482,
0.057047098875045776,
-0.2507929801940918,
0.2880571186542511,
-0.9819197654724121,
0.7170740962028503,
-0.04557785019278526,
-0.3486085534095764,
0.16488057374954224,
-0.736920177936554,
0.6363599300384521,
-0.2367185801267624,
0.3026922643184662,
0.18290328979492188,
0.2161705642938614,
0.28380683064460754,
-0.5339236259460449,
0.7833643555641174,
-0.20140352845191956,
-0.12895239889621735,
0.17171747982501984,
0.6228829026222229,
0.4414902627468109,
0.1140461340546608,
-0.20750358700752258,
0.3542357385158539,
0.30761268734931946,
-0.48415228724479675,
-0.5531918406486511,
0.6562697291374207,
-0.42623722553253174,
-0.48624831438064575,
-0.4883059561252594,
-0.19439823925495148,
-0.23696552217006683,
0.5368493795394897,
0.27747681736946106,
0.028364285826683044,
-0.5003241300582886,
0.18626746535301208,
0.9974245429039001,
-0.13065509498119354,
0.15824776887893677,
0.7546502351760864,
-0.3147498667240143,
-0.03744284808635712,
0.7921369075775146,
0.24095532298088074,
0.33743342757225037,
0.5629639029502869,
-0.4222641587257385,
-0.14545725286006927,
-0.44104740023612976,
-0.5587106347084045,
0.11361928284168243,
-0.4633861482143402,
-0.5768682360649109,
-0.6847994923591614,
-0.2693646252155304,
-0.2908829152584076,
0.1333753615617752,
-0.2089015543460846,
-0.9875100255012512,
-0.3828151822090149,
-0.2671241760253906,
0.45043274760246277,
0.7589687705039978,
0.30780288577079773,
0.4679843783378601,
-0.7108753323554993,
0.053681500256061554,
0.1196909248828888,
0.47732794284820557,
-0.20439216494560242,
-0.18912579119205475,
-0.06366059184074402,
-0.05364365875720978,
-0.20196495950222015,
-1.6907106637954712,
0.1163979023694992,
0.18239714205265045,
0.26830774545669556,
0.48677313327789307,
0.34329864382743835,
0.30992504954338074,
-0.30716463923454285,
0.75732421875,
0.022081170231103897,
-1.177803874015808,
0.6949103474617004,
-0.45175522565841675,
-0.3206475079059601,
0.4759809374809265,
0.14100921154022217,
-0.18719983100891113,
-0.22715584933757782,
-0.5647119283676147,
-0.9654169082641602,
0.6061235666275024,
0.3653508126735687,
-0.046629276126623154,
0.24622033536434174,
0.6960130929946899,
0.015026500448584557,
0.4404236376285553,
-0.7374096512794495,
-0.6104626059532166,
-0.2580004334449768,
0.3187589943408966,
0.34207648038864136,
-0.45637211203575134,
-0.3900541067123413,
-0.0935765728354454,
0.34922870993614197,
-0.0001772230170900002,
0.3930821120738983,
-0.17445847392082214,
-0.2780471742153168,
-0.19343945384025574,
0.41631779074668884,
0.24181576073169708,
0.5810768604278564,
-0.18615522980690002,
0.08361656218767166,
0.23944655060768127,
-0.3072425127029419,
-0.029449161142110825,
0.13644763827323914,
-0.3825492262840271,
-0.040637362748384476,
0.1253766417503357,
0.3957298696041107,
0.06674741208553314,
-0.41525623202323914,
0.5468214154243469,
-0.1385001540184021,
-0.2271048128604889,
-0.4404020607471466,
0.20498408377170563,
0.2248605191707611,
-0.11893944442272186,
0.3538404405117035,
0.005678846035152674,
0.16019347310066223,
-0.3903394937515259,
0.2789902687072754,
0.6568481922149658,
-0.5900856852531433,
-0.1146538108587265,
0.5815009474754333,
-0.056665774434804916,
-0.17405442893505096,
0.5003985166549683,
0.13935956358909607,
0.010770084336400032,
0.4341975152492523,
0.6049051880836487,
0.41748178005218506,
-0.7202954292297363,
0.272597074508667,
0.09923174977302551,
0.5645862221717834,
0.2521587014198303,
0.40863919258117676,
-0.17008905112743378,
-0.4362168610095978,
-0.09245474636554718,
-0.37899136543273926,
-0.5070034861564636,
0.014779637567698956,
-0.893362820148468,
0.18649712204933167,
-0.4706903398036957,
0.18504644930362701,
0.2386433482170105,
-0.24547196924686432,
-0.25433510541915894,
0.18991999328136444,
-0.5017725825309753,
0.949523389339447,
-1.0334213972091675,
0.7784071564674377,
0.4141503572463989,
-0.6490582227706909,
-0.37020790576934814,
-0.2634049952030182,
-0.10747339576482773,
-0.5794176459312439,
0.09347335994243622,
-0.25830262899398804,
0.2755759656429291,
-0.06088578701019287,
-0.6559387445449829,
-0.7508233785629272,
0.9157922863960266,
0.7655115723609924,
-0.42859935760498047,
-0.2533648908138275,
0.6804566383361816,
0.41998037695884705,
-0.01732262410223484,
0.1532355546951294,
0.6482229828834534,
0.26986730098724365,
-0.12052101641893387,
-0.3267461657524109,
0.19495432078838348,
-0.11031322926282883,
-0.18212373554706573,
0.446929931640625,
0.03544530272483826,
0.8572712540626526,
-0.33448565006256104,
-0.3488679826259613,
-0.09260018169879913,
0.6706912517547607,
0.012002844363451004,
0.2516644299030304,
0.28500330448150635,
0.3663448691368103,
0.7394634485244751,
-0.2703610062599182,
0.9058220982551575,
-0.3430199921131134,
0.3522105813026428,
1.143886923789978,
-0.46527355909347534,
0.6905184984207153,
0.6046428084373474,
-0.21407559514045715,
0.685467004776001,
0.2042241394519806,
0.1097179725766182,
0.4250246286392212,
0.10163924843072891,
-0.4014570713043213,
-0.2107401341199875,
0.09984169155359268,
-0.7167229652404785,
0.4006889760494232,
0.806919276714325,
-0.40478041768074036,
-0.3456493616104126,
-0.3111869692802429,
0.14691221714019775,
0.004337179008871317,
0.21686868369579315,
0.9789994955062866,
-0.002809120574966073,
-0.16845612227916718,
0.26365992426872253,
0.05556202307343483,
-0.05098070949316025,
-0.5352089405059814,
-0.010466107167303562,
-0.25063976645469666,
0.04573212191462517,
-0.3783397376537323,
-0.7456569075584412,
0.4763731360435486,
-0.07920095324516296,
-0.20623059570789337,
0.2465599924325943,
1.0647268295288086,
-0.3160962462425232,
-0.18103182315826416,
0.12179476767778397,
0.6290311813354492,
-0.08991643041372299,
-0.636237621307373,
-0.38108885288238525,
-0.32282453775405884,
0.03089045360684395,
-0.22068539261817932,
0.6318318247795105,
0.6764553189277649,
-0.03183593973517418,
0.3868250548839569,
0.8245987892150879,
-0.041474100202322006,
-0.14592503011226654,
-0.3057057857513428,
0.8737753033638,
-0.7004684209823608,
-0.43161526322364807,
-0.9054818153381348,
0.47119206190109253,
-0.506759762763977,
0.22478802502155304,
0.8575648069381714,
0.6188738346099854,
0.47725430130958557,
-0.2940293252468109,
0.6388522982597351,
-0.07253269106149673,
0.7226270437240601,
-0.2458086609840393,
1.1970852613449097,
-0.4031974673271179,
0.5996158123016357,
-0.4587480127811432,
-0.680001437664032,
-0.5753453373908997,
0.3173700273036957,
-0.0005439106607809663,
-0.12322655320167542,
0.6445565819740295,
0.9813022017478943,
0.24257992208003998,
0.1526043713092804,
0.4301750659942627,
0.35574397444725037,
0.27884748578071594,
0.22173291444778442,
0.5801024436950684,
-0.5976308584213257,
0.6320414543151855,
-0.32855984568595886,
-0.15527139604091644,
-0.21661287546157837,
-0.9124297499656677,
-0.7503854632377625,
-0.4439767897129059,
-0.04562880098819733,
-0.8013901114463806,
0.3325304388999939,
0.15431688725948334,
0.4686487019062042,
-0.9680882692337036,
0.019086617976427078,
-0.3023572564125061,
0.4589757025241852,
-0.1540195196866989,
-0.2803391218185425,
0.37420445680618286,
0.1501362919807434,
-0.027045531198382378,
0.361191064119339,
0.3915647566318512,
0.13127991557121277,
-0.36559218168258667,
0.4782087206840515,
-0.03318140655755997,
0.2947230041027069,
0.5101228952407837,
0.657629132270813,
-0.30013400316238403,
-0.029939917847514153,
0.19261060655117035,
-0.15567103028297424,
-0.23902656137943268,
0.6196576356887817,
-0.6953955292701721,
0.3995567858219147,
0.32797402143478394,
0.4402215778827667,
0.4673616886138916,
-0.12258118391036987,
0.5491731762886047,
-1.0423858165740967,
0.00198885565623641,
0.025143969804048538,
0.11671954393386841,
0.18651221692562103,
-0.7719550132751465,
0.5222678780555725,
0.34737154841423035,
-0.389210969209671,
-1.3317830562591553,
0.5000836849212646,
-0.8024585843086243,
-0.5473541021347046,
0.6750374436378479,
0.09753410518169403,
-0.40102726221084595,
-0.5315870642662048,
0.10404065996408463,
0.1169188991189003,
-0.18883293867111206,
0.7186248898506165,
0.24391520023345947,
-0.07402833551168442,
-0.07174643129110336,
-0.24981510639190674,
0.6259327530860901,
0.2758747637271881,
-1.1206330060958862,
0.2670091688632965,
0.43967533111572266,
0.3889167904853821,
0.18991336226463318,
0.5810448527336121,
-0.4170417785644531,
0.2905803322792053,
0.1681920439004898,
0.2264334261417389,
-0.028474198654294014,
-0.2955675721168518,
-0.19618895649909973,
0.6124781966209412,
-0.1373835802078247,
0.03344639763236046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14544v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14544v1 | Prism: A Framework for Decoupling and Assessing the Capabilities of VLMs | 2024-06-20T17:54:03 | 2024-06-20T17:54:03 | Yuxuan Qiao, Haodong Duan, Xinyu Fang, Junming Yang, Lin Chen, Songyang Zhang, Jiaqi Wang, Dahua Lin, Kai Chen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Vision Language Models (VLMs) demonstrate remarkable proficiency in
addressing a wide array of visual questions, which requires strong perception
and reasoning faculties. Assessing these two competencies independently is
crucial for model refinement, despite the inherent difficulty due to the
intertwined nature of seeing and reasoning in existing VLMs. To tackle this
issue, we present Prism, an innovative framework designed to disentangle the
perception and reasoning processes involved in visual question solving. Prism
comprises two distinct stages: a perception stage that utilizes a VLM to
extract and articulate visual information in textual form, and a reasoning
stage that formulates responses based on the extracted visual information using
a Large Language Model (LLM). This modular design enables the systematic
comparison and assessment of both proprietary and open-source VLM for their
perception and reasoning strengths. Our analytical framework provides several
valuable insights, underscoring Prism's potential as a cost-effective solution
for vision-language tasks. By combining a streamlined VLM focused on perception
with a powerful LLM tailored for reasoning, Prism achieves superior results in
general vision-language tasks while substantially cutting down on training and
operational expenses. Quantitative evaluations show that Prism, when configured
with a vanilla 2B LLaVA and freely accessible GPT-3.5, delivers performance on
par with VLMs $10 \times$ larger on the rigorous multimodal benchmark MMStar.
The project is released at: https://github.com/SparksJoe/Prism. | [
-0.5633266568183899,
-0.5359132885932922,
0.5566397905349731,
0.4520348012447357,
-0.26642370223999023,
0.12811113893985748,
0.03671659901738167,
-0.6242193579673767,
-0.27082186937332153,
0.6534020304679871,
-0.4514026641845703,
-0.03969413414597511,
-0.2701176702976227,
0.09512563794851303,
-0.514349639415741,
0.2221592515707016,
-0.06188683956861496,
0.2984427809715271,
-0.48343899846076965,
-0.1131162941455841,
-0.4120035171508789,
-0.15933941304683685,
-0.21782924234867096,
-0.4518623948097229,
0.34674736857414246,
0.12717652320861816,
0.5232117176055908,
0.31736990809440613,
0.7148886919021606,
0.41738346219062805,
0.028819847851991653,
0.19493205845355988,
-0.4562268555164337,
-0.010563651099801064,
-0.5086610913276672,
-0.3049558699131012,
-0.45455360412597656,
-0.0569673627614975,
0.6827212572097778,
0.8040177226066589,
-0.12340261042118073,
0.3606872260570526,
0.2558903694152832,
0.7630610466003418,
-0.8486925959587097,
0.3663367033004761,
-0.5986135601997375,
0.14544813334941864,
-0.11529256403446198,
-0.19883394241333008,
-0.47695398330688477,
0.09298481792211533,
0.3306891918182373,
-0.5137221217155457,
-0.034742362797260284,
0.2636040449142456,
0.8599096536636353,
0.23998257517814636,
-0.19922107458114624,
0.2810577154159546,
-0.6812505125999451,
0.8160125613212585,
-0.12645256519317627,
0.5574778318405151,
0.012212071567773819,
0.6644566059112549,
0.24827931821346283,
-0.8667157292366028,
-0.6611130237579346,
0.057523198425769806,
0.032074376940727234,
0.2843477129936218,
-0.24843472242355347,
-0.046053435653448105,
0.13189226388931274,
0.5449400544166565,
-0.8741564750671387,
-0.20927606523036957,
-0.7019723653793335,
-0.22234918177127838,
0.3782466650009155,
0.3572224974632263,
0.30085697770118713,
-0.3029337227344513,
-0.7103650569915771,
0.07198537141084671,
-0.6438848972320557,
0.05021587386727333,
-0.07351210713386536,
0.11685315519571304,
0.00914205051958561,
0.7833603620529175,
-0.5771945714950562,
0.8227338194847107,
-0.20322702825069427,
-0.07400933653116226,
0.33750152587890625,
-0.42554134130477905,
-0.6816472411155701,
-0.2504008114337921,
0.4805733859539032,
0.6540912389755249,
0.30381736159324646,
-0.1481419950723648,
-0.28510189056396484,
0.21879355609416962,
0.2669018805027008,
-0.7036255598068237,
-0.33758488297462463,
0.2576775550842285,
-0.4704626202583313,
-0.2363358438014984,
-0.2169072926044464,
-0.7362459301948547,
-0.6426832675933838,
-0.6971275806427002,
0.5539934635162354,
-0.1296931952238083,
-0.4523598253726959,
0.36538776755332947,
-0.3208313286304474,
0.6976091861724854,
0.690386950969696,
-0.6465256214141846,
0.03542351722717285,
0.8135486841201782,
0.5818946957588196,
-0.2879980206489563,
-0.37712040543556213,
-0.5138323307037354,
-0.1452527791261673,
-0.5018253922462463,
0.7690224051475525,
-0.511035680770874,
-0.07630667835474014,
-0.17578648030757904,
-0.04796998202800751,
-0.024127598851919174,
-0.7495337128639221,
-0.04459388181567192,
-0.4977818727493286,
0.43549057841300964,
-0.38033783435821533,
-0.16397598385810852,
-0.18866659700870514,
0.6000263094902039,
-0.5843653678894043,
0.9710584282875061,
0.3984755873680115,
-0.6881693601608276,
0.687537431716919,
-0.27389752864837646,
0.42673060297966003,
0.7381921410560608,
-0.48672735691070557,
-0.10699073225259781,
0.03993815928697586,
0.19721874594688416,
0.13656459748744965,
-0.6844580769538879,
0.2581230401992798,
-0.38008394837379456,
-0.2529809772968292,
0.20267534255981445,
-0.3677123188972473,
0.9109289646148682,
0.18053488433361053,
-0.3462596833705902,
0.3684799075126648,
-0.980293869972229,
0.43153053522109985,
0.05628054589033127,
-0.3258802890777588,
-0.1334550976753235,
-0.01310131885111332,
0.10997936874628067,
0.17915427684783936,
0.21467755734920502,
-0.33779600262641907,
0.05354592949151993,
-0.4616658389568329,
0.2161937803030014,
0.6644399166107178,
-0.24005994200706482,
0.5155426859855652,
0.10757827758789062,
0.430836945772171,
0.058951716870069504,
0.5437706112861633,
-0.03686727210879326,
-0.4979165494441986,
-1.0934399366378784,
-0.3246833086013794,
-0.0165615975856781,
0.7573716640472412,
-1.2554569244384766,
-0.18198120594024658,
-0.12902437150478363,
-0.32662469148635864,
-0.44311797618865967,
0.28953632712364197,
0.5482302904129028,
0.6651515364646912,
0.5304768085479736,
-0.418263703584671,
-0.4812074303627014,
-1.0013959407806396,
-0.20558102428913116,
-0.28770971298217773,
-0.2633315920829773,
-0.00012844245065934956,
0.5432732105255127,
-0.04077618941664696,
1.2020940780639648,
-0.2797233760356903,
-0.14842915534973145,
-0.5796048045158386,
-0.18275906145572662,
0.004681856837123632,
0.20452558994293213,
0.5196000337600708,
-1.1628464460372925,
-0.39750027656555176,
0.07722081989049911,
-1.100115180015564,
-0.33969736099243164,
-0.010151250287890434,
-0.07593942433595657,
-0.015701141208410263,
0.44261500239372253,
-0.26073241233825684,
0.5887078046798706,
0.4546029567718506,
-0.625695526599884,
0.7397474050521851,
-0.018051641061902046,
-0.025538897141814232,
-0.4992050230503082,
0.1364397257566452,
-0.11857984215021133,
-0.24849162995815277,
-0.6503241658210754,
0.29339417815208435,
0.16348016262054443,
-0.18646827340126038,
-0.8142295479774475,
0.6340086460113525,
-0.6505194902420044,
-0.3058016896247864,
-0.13813836872577667,
0.282320111989975,
0.44380855560302734,
0.4761774241924286,
0.04845373332500458,
0.7449136972427368,
0.82832932472229,
-0.3642369508743286,
0.6908453702926636,
0.10028918832540512,
-0.6988434195518494,
0.8705746531486511,
-0.8152406811714172,
-0.4066391885280609,
-0.35004302859306335,
-0.30362236499786377,
-0.7270970344543457,
-0.014789051376283169,
0.5002307295799255,
-0.1089102253317833,
-0.1079225242137909,
-0.03922925516963005,
-0.1586991846561432,
-0.3445931673049927,
-0.22176502645015717,
0.3984263241291046,
0.30808356404304504,
-0.528308629989624,
0.9612029790878296,
0.2739415168762207,
-0.19262973964214325,
-0.6780716776847839,
-0.6891809105873108,
0.3532579839229584,
-0.14349958300590515,
-0.7527890205383301,
-0.030665889382362366,
-0.07880441844463348,
-0.726620614528656,
0.08462657034397125,
-0.10588693618774414,
-0.14213021099567413,
0.04642811790108681,
0.15508438646793365,
0.45760732889175415,
-0.40708088874816895,
0.012302985414862633,
-0.3176797330379486,
-0.49316462874412537,
-0.08349835872650146,
-0.38840165734291077,
0.4592704474925995,
-0.6660235524177551,
-0.6269580721855164,
-0.042851630598306656,
0.32382819056510925,
0.789777934551239,
-0.8290382623672485,
0.6360841393470764,
0.4966905415058136,
-0.21777649223804474,
-0.41112837195396423,
-0.5977116227149963,
0.2092309296131134,
-0.5226839184761047,
0.39097222685813904,
-0.44786399602890015,
-0.5780998468399048,
0.2838231325149536,
-0.04434879869222641,
-0.07723096013069153,
-0.002009347314015031,
0.6726811528205872,
0.11834833025932312,
0.8138538599014282,
0.7230049967765808,
0.4203554689884186,
0.2844042181968689,
-0.2584209144115448,
0.32520031929016113,
-0.9427270293235779,
-0.6864343285560608,
-0.0501888245344162,
-0.12194487452507019,
0.060444701462984085,
-0.7765756249427795,
0.3300904333591461,
0.2588817775249481,
-0.17100225389003754,
0.03191321715712547,
-0.34624090790748596,
0.6915568709373474,
0.4449932873249054,
-0.14902092516422272,
0.5184093117713928,
-0.08445516973733902,
-0.09548521786928177,
-0.05804561823606491,
-0.510210394859314,
-0.4815511703491211,
0.8610522150993347,
0.283075213432312,
0.4907611310482025,
0.15972211956977844,
0.22899679839611053,
-0.041539907455444336,
0.20488059520721436,
-0.7123037576675415,
0.8990246057510376,
0.1758841574192047,
-0.4550400376319885,
-0.25496628880500793,
-0.3602283298969269,
-0.5182842016220093,
1.2322545051574707,
-0.3502342402935028,
-0.9285064935684204,
0.3507221043109894,
0.05656716972589493,
0.08221139013767242,
0.17622394859790802,
-0.6809743046760559,
1.0437018871307373,
-0.4361324906349182,
-0.676252543926239,
0.037244345992803574,
-0.42472124099731445,
0.44420477747917175,
-0.009990422986447811,
0.03973439335823059,
-0.28743183612823486,
0.006255542393773794,
0.18205276131629944,
-0.22753489017486572,
0.6427291631698608,
-0.039410244673490524,
-0.05526404082775116,
0.222536101937294,
0.19790960848331451,
-0.14339739084243774,
0.01853853091597557,
0.14619246125221252,
0.16350054740905762,
-0.01746758259832859,
-0.31645917892456055,
-0.7257242798805237,
0.2393532693386078,
-0.23757365345954895,
-0.5324622988700867,
-0.2978152632713318,
-0.43523937463760376,
-0.3351922333240509,
0.5093197822570801,
0.13187463581562042,
0.7296772003173828,
-0.11149872839450836,
0.41203081607818604,
0.567904531955719,
-0.2656654715538025,
0.2711356580257416,
0.6922242045402527,
-0.9540601372718811,
-0.27293211221694946,
1.0419642925262451,
-0.1746651977300644,
0.5060557126998901,
0.35274869203567505,
0.18001505732536316,
-0.32682353258132935,
-0.6039515733718872,
-0.5783261060714722,
-0.03064572624862194,
-0.8729045391082764,
0.04614585265517235,
-0.23873081803321838,
-0.1125250980257988,
-0.0900677964091301,
-0.0705810934305191,
-0.47808516025543213,
-0.20360633730888367,
0.09054666757583618,
-0.05377962440252304,
-0.3328888416290283,
0.44179776310920715,
0.12568680942058563,
-0.11925526708364487,
-0.5155856609344482,
0.5459953546524048,
0.5495457053184509,
0.4034757912158966,
-0.10387959331274033,
-0.017311301082372665,
0.053944557905197144,
-0.13745549321174622,
-0.22895877063274384,
-0.6959069967269897,
0.4696744382381439,
0.08022944629192352,
0.6248477697372437,
0.5096210837364197,
-0.009955632500350475,
0.6502445936203003,
-0.4435742199420929,
0.9169464111328125,
0.4666137099266052,
-1.0057390928268433,
0.4756995141506195,
-0.08679668605327606,
0.3141942024230957,
0.42557311058044434,
-0.07918676733970642,
-0.3846857249736786,
-0.4637826085090637,
-0.20185518264770508,
-0.9440022110939026,
0.45392823219299316,
0.21952100098133087,
-0.42841100692749023,
0.2769514322280884,
-0.1026819571852684,
-0.11741925030946732,
0.33776697516441345,
-0.8205859065055847,
-0.0668586865067482,
-0.2562641203403473,
0.0051140193827450275,
-0.05958917364478111,
-0.3168650269508362,
-0.4235907196998596,
-0.3952774107456207,
0.20112107694149017,
-0.25714749097824097,
-0.14884473383426666,
0.11470377445220947,
-0.3744173049926758,
0.26607561111450195,
0.1770249903202057,
0.31714653968811035,
1.1474809646606445,
0.08481425791978836,
0.2919767498970032,
0.14680632948875427,
-0.33991822600364685,
-0.16925248503684998,
-0.2756804823875427,
-0.18343721330165863,
-0.25160476565361023,
0.5529356002807617,
0.6859691143035889,
0.2581862807273865,
-0.9998708963394165,
0.7357242107391357,
-0.22891822457313538,
-0.29135408997535706,
-0.08649498969316483,
-0.004150788765400648,
0.10201895982027054,
0.6114094257354736,
0.23334789276123047,
0.06080542132258415,
0.2502649128437042,
-0.4444451332092285,
0.1995411217212677,
0.392963171005249,
-0.3346738815307617,
-0.07889910042285919,
0.49102139472961426,
0.4313071668148041,
-0.023199519142508507,
0.6775133609771729,
-0.010103524662554264,
-0.6780905723571777,
0.47104525566101074,
0.26162734627723694,
0.7476059794425964,
0.022401509806513786,
0.4246709644794464,
0.014548750594258308,
0.5732404589653015,
-0.03260189667344093,
0.4047119915485382,
-0.18151558935642242,
-0.7410869002342224,
-0.35700535774230957,
-0.7458690404891968,
-0.4088279902935028,
-0.01087413914501667,
-0.6146920919418335,
0.1532212793827057,
-0.263433039188385,
0.21519304811954498,
-0.33483922481536865,
-0.1667858064174652,
-0.5661649703979492,
0.15431123971939087,
0.37789660692214966,
0.9383203983306885,
-0.7405418157577515,
0.5493963360786438,
0.3543877601623535,
-0.5140554308891296,
-0.6518622040748596,
-0.41400548815727234,
0.34979692101478577,
-0.8839887380599976,
0.8886919617652893,
0.2876030504703522,
-0.4573405086994171,
-0.4032819867134094,
-0.2022184282541275,
-0.659565269947052,
1.1321895122528076,
0.5292112231254578,
-0.41114863753318787,
-0.009323511272668839,
0.31296026706695557,
0.47686102986335754,
-0.2716178297996521,
0.029192030429840088,
0.6203353404998779,
0.4396619200706482,
0.25769418478012085,
-1.1956722736358643,
-0.24523882567882538,
-0.47307881712913513,
0.06212761625647545,
0.15916970372200012,
-0.3498421013355255,
1.0637598037719727,
-0.11750741302967072,
-0.5074942708015442,
-0.011301372200250626,
0.43843016028404236,
0.15796825289726257,
0.4725956320762634,
0.3675119876861572,
0.4327343702316284,
0.6552616357803345,
-0.26587897539138794,
0.8417611718177795,
-0.17534253001213074,
0.4130428731441498,
0.8817110061645508,
-0.40826866030693054,
0.9181606769561768,
0.7502277493476868,
0.013675905764102936,
0.26888003945350647,
0.09740456193685532,
-0.08340921998023987,
0.4864623248577118,
0.16689883172512054,
-0.20895712077617645,
-0.6533114314079285,
0.20379814505577087,
-0.4831658601760864,
0.7146987318992615,
0.3010686933994293,
-0.14153893291950226,
-0.4898127317428589,
0.25218069553375244,
-0.566948413848877,
0.04638134688138962,
-0.42352479696273804,
0.5523200035095215,
0.12880896031856537,
-0.5254377126693726,
0.4752112925052643,
-0.40059423446655273,
0.21652382612228394,
-0.5967737436294556,
-0.1421908140182495,
-0.07537449896335602,
0.5857111811637878,
-0.1908692866563797,
-0.8677887320518494,
0.36741918325424194,
-0.04207963868975639,
-0.05938832834362984,
-0.5061693787574768,
0.6695263981819153,
-0.4335106313228607,
-0.5387505292892456,
0.3753482699394226,
0.7213202118873596,
-0.027660133317112923,
-0.18547187745571136,
-0.730904221534729,
0.44672757387161255,
-0.11440016329288483,
-0.30061864852905273,
0.26604247093200684,
0.3454248905181885,
0.07624121755361557,
1.2064913511276245,
0.5012851357460022,
0.18671917915344238,
0.09718073159456253,
0.09142325073480606,
0.8750298619270325,
-0.37633922696113586,
-0.3700444996356964,
-0.6350840926170349,
0.900309681892395,
-0.3022923469543457,
-0.2844069302082062,
0.8177497982978821,
0.5926545262336731,
0.8809893131256104,
-0.09114448726177216,
0.6172543168067932,
0.012737286277115345,
0.28620487451553345,
-0.7158761620521545,
0.6182172298431396,
-0.9400599598884583,
0.4873180091381073,
-0.2444608211517334,
-1.0495113134384155,
-0.41498616337776184,
0.7981696128845215,
-0.3950389623641968,
-0.2723066210746765,
0.6736382246017456,
0.7123475670814514,
-0.05747538059949875,
-0.134779691696167,
0.48867249488830566,
-0.10262089222669601,
0.6474727392196655,
0.6413956880569458,
1.0489615201950073,
-0.0720556229352951,
0.6351267099380493,
0.003056644694879651,
-0.4650624096393585,
-0.1207425519824028,
-0.8577799201011658,
-0.8134071826934814,
-0.6753734946250916,
-0.19135811924934387,
-0.09615480899810791,
-0.20503410696983337,
0.38050657510757446,
0.4863843321800232,
-0.35359427332878113,
-0.1572570502758026,
-0.007399979513138533,
0.05951771140098572,
-0.23400355875492096,
-0.2618979215621948,
-0.0018685589311644435,
-0.18566520512104034,
-0.564990222454071,
0.4293058514595032,
0.8663294315338135,
-0.17973388731479645,
-0.6775535345077515,
-0.02788928709924221,
0.36082586646080017,
0.07358604669570923,
0.931405782699585,
0.28118395805358887,
-0.89921635389328,
-0.2988819181919098,
0.045926403254270554,
-0.08100756257772446,
-0.12098033726215363,
0.6917478442192078,
-0.9193596839904785,
0.82964026927948,
0.7355174422264099,
0.39221763610839844,
0.24188433587551117,
-0.04067612439393997,
0.590657651424408,
-0.17646323144435883,
0.2894623577594757,
0.1972734034061432,
0.5848714113235474,
0.32132065296173096,
0.2314486801624298,
0.4896535873413086,
0.2838086783885956,
-0.11952608823776245,
-1.0434752702713013,
0.6698715686798096,
-1.2251224517822266,
-0.3968330919742584,
0.8899911642074585,
0.06966529786586761,
-0.3273645341396332,
-0.27908754348754883,
-0.40685322880744934,
-0.5865163207054138,
0.3168032765388489,
0.5419062376022339,
0.5966125726699829,
-0.1255037933588028,
-0.43378472328186035,
-0.3603762984275818,
0.21734465658664703,
0.1932099163532257,
-0.7059870958328247,
0.15999174118041992,
0.6071306467056274,
0.2420748621225357,
0.3379364311695099,
0.64635169506073,
-0.3443991243839264,
0.3538140654563904,
0.3874005973339081,
-0.08624725788831711,
-0.40195849537849426,
-0.7537911534309387,
-0.24616028368473053,
0.636192798614502,
-0.08803451806306839,
-0.1399364322423935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14532v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14532v1 | RL on Incorrect Synthetic Data Scales the Efficiency of LLM Math Reasoning by Eight-Fold | 2024-06-20T17:45:54 | 2024-06-20T17:45:54 | Amrith Setlur, Saurabh Garg, Xinyang Geng, Naman Garg, Virginia Smith, Aviral Kumar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Training on model-generated synthetic data is a promising approach for
finetuning LLMs, but it remains unclear when it helps or hurts. In this paper,
we investigate this question for math reasoning via an empirical study,
followed by building a conceptual understanding of our observations. First, we
find that while the typical approach of finetuning a model on synthetic correct
or positive problem-solution pairs generated by capable models offers modest
performance gains, sampling more correct solutions from the finetuned learner
itself followed by subsequent fine-tuning on this self-generated data
$\textbf{doubles}$ the efficiency of the same synthetic problems. At the same
time, training on model-generated positives can amplify various spurious
correlations, resulting in flat or even inverse scaling trends as the amount of
data increases. Surprisingly, we find that several of these issues can be
addressed if we also utilize negative responses, i.e., model-generated
responses that are deemed incorrect by a final answer verifier. Crucially,
these negatives must be constructed such that the training can appropriately
recover the utility or advantage of each intermediate step in the negative
response. With this per-step scheme, we are able to attain consistent gains
over only positive data, attaining performance similar to amplifying the amount
of synthetic data by $\mathbf{8 \times}$. We show that training on per-step
negatives can help to unlearn spurious correlations in the positive data, and
is equivalent to advantage-weighted reinforcement learning (RL), implying that
it inherits robustness benefits of RL over imitating positive data alone. | [
-0.3957821726799011,
-0.8994314074516296,
0.5303574204444885,
0.06520786136388779,
-0.09147736430168152,
-0.04276517033576965,
-0.1258113980293274,
-0.29628702998161316,
-0.009856533259153366,
0.40186381340026855,
-0.6708363890647888,
-0.08440589904785156,
-0.4777902662754059,
0.16929928958415985,
-0.4015114903450012,
1.162665605545044,
0.13176792860031128,
0.4832362234592438,
-0.25269389152526855,
-0.24057841300964355,
-0.3959524631500244,
-0.6442258954048157,
-0.7717658281326294,
-0.5373716354370117,
0.7242980003356934,
0.5776427984237671,
0.6958423256874084,
0.7360445261001587,
0.6402751803398132,
0.20937414467334747,
0.19051788747310638,
0.3144218623638153,
-0.8982024788856506,
0.11194120347499847,
-0.17182202637195587,
-0.8478557467460632,
-0.47887107729911804,
0.29962214827537537,
0.37074893712997437,
0.6076801419258118,
-0.11151883751153946,
0.38345590233802795,
0.0692751407623291,
0.7250003218650818,
-0.46696004271507263,
-0.13143809139728546,
-0.8339134454727173,
0.2050885707139969,
-0.009465974755585194,
-0.426647424697876,
-0.474067747592926,
-0.3237127661705017,
-0.2440396547317505,
-0.8129402995109558,
0.46490684151649475,
-0.15766119956970215,
0.6100982427597046,
0.44548454880714417,
-0.2842429578304291,
-0.38608604669570923,
-0.8598352670669556,
0.9423843622207642,
-0.7118836641311646,
0.39778226613998413,
0.26440441608428955,
0.4633384048938751,
-0.13835211098194122,
-0.4050971567630768,
-0.557827353477478,
-0.2307255119085312,
0.07289765775203705,
0.19478170573711395,
0.26128584146499634,
-0.19658689200878143,
0.7376833558082581,
0.42852070927619934,
-0.17085294425487518,
0.12287326902151108,
-0.5075544118881226,
-0.32124680280685425,
0.907783031463623,
0.44188007712364197,
0.18088498711585999,
0.06323432177305222,
-0.40870627760887146,
-0.3179049789905548,
-0.9927831292152405,
0.08524402976036072,
0.5708833932876587,
0.7218907475471497,
-0.10047511011362076,
0.9292234778404236,
0.13777774572372437,
0.5839160084724426,
0.3387317359447479,
-0.19555290043354034,
0.13822272419929504,
-0.33815962076187134,
-0.237015500664711,
-0.01155844982713461,
0.38096290826797485,
0.043394122272729874,
0.5095435380935669,
-0.08414828032255173,
-0.5559231042861938,
0.35467609763145447,
0.4609438180923462,
-0.8012889623641968,
-0.15644896030426025,
0.015692271292209625,
0.002949236426502466,
-0.4722829759120941,
-0.1539570838212967,
-0.4482426941394806,
-0.40494126081466675,
-0.9561619758605957,
0.8031495809555054,
-0.32609298825263977,
0.024029530584812164,
0.25308695435523987,
-0.050208255648612976,
0.19142574071884155,
0.4976387917995453,
-0.5917218923568726,
0.35024479031562805,
0.7844781875610352,
0.5365426540374756,
0.06938492506742477,
-0.13952071964740753,
-0.8428754210472107,
-0.40979740023612976,
-0.6757746338844299,
0.6999664902687073,
-0.0954100713133812,
-0.327215313911438,
-0.27285438776016235,
-0.30881187319755554,
0.03854970261454582,
-0.8280693888664246,
0.6157329678535461,
-0.4729331433773041,
0.07082205265760422,
-0.3214896023273468,
-0.5160769820213318,
0.056805241852998734,
0.5062606334686279,
-0.4624227285385132,
0.6517467498779297,
-0.0943780392408371,
-0.4569835364818573,
0.4404001235961914,
-0.35520800948143005,
-0.43563076853752136,
-0.31317493319511414,
-0.13531361520290375,
-0.7983277440071106,
0.24667876958847046,
-0.01250858698040247,
0.2488218992948532,
-0.22762975096702576,
0.03628630191087723,
-0.7345938682556152,
-0.3929722011089325,
0.5082786679267883,
-0.655008852481842,
0.7775583267211914,
0.2812211513519287,
-0.222747802734375,
-0.10202138870954514,
-1.0374202728271484,
0.10376060009002686,
0.14300686120986938,
-0.2423868477344513,
-0.374227374792099,
-0.2736942768096924,
-0.5399044156074524,
0.21345219016075134,
-0.07711160182952881,
-0.6185725331306458,
0.10451677441596985,
-0.3459053933620453,
0.09486407786607742,
0.9536048769950867,
0.21359485387802124,
0.4795461595058441,
-0.6234220862388611,
0.44606107473373413,
0.09069874882698059,
0.04064127802848816,
0.1783188432455063,
-0.2055022120475769,
-0.9421014785766602,
-0.08210461586713791,
0.1972324699163437,
0.4566362500190735,
-0.5245211720466614,
-0.10274721682071686,
0.0234422218054533,
-0.4345373511314392,
-0.4295368492603302,
0.225791797041893,
0.40658873319625854,
0.8396285176277161,
0.6356995701789856,
-0.09129557013511658,
-0.48363199830055237,
-0.7937384843826294,
-0.5293367505073547,
0.2155856043100357,
0.07482065260410309,
0.34509408473968506,
0.4156731069087982,
0.06754951924085617,
0.6471287608146667,
-0.39009684324264526,
-0.17622347176074982,
-0.007294456008821726,
0.4136538505554199,
0.3059907853603363,
0.5322277545928955,
0.26711735129356384,
-0.6847708821296692,
-0.582578182220459,
-0.2781726121902466,
-0.7039074301719666,
-0.09337835013866425,
-0.4514686167240143,
-0.27056530117988586,
-0.010591012425720692,
0.21584807336330414,
-0.5512983798980713,
0.3191329836845398,
0.13260094821453094,
-0.2334529459476471,
0.7505395412445068,
-0.2554236054420471,
-0.02322307601571083,
-0.6315643787384033,
-0.16464301943778992,
0.25190699100494385,
-0.18767529726028442,
-0.6275714635848999,
-0.06052583456039429,
0.07841431349515915,
-0.04085112735629082,
-0.30062970519065857,
0.4372537434101105,
-0.2785477042198181,
-0.059754472225904465,
-0.06522994488477707,
0.026153216138482094,
-0.04417218640446663,
0.45200812816619873,
-0.25818300247192383,
0.999829113483429,
0.22023560106754303,
-0.8220319747924805,
0.1846432387828827,
-0.0839352160692215,
0.10553181916475296,
0.7854444980621338,
-0.5567430853843689,
0.061019815504550934,
-0.12495007365942001,
0.0034270877949893475,
-0.8689118027687073,
-0.06649783253669739,
0.07504761219024658,
-0.6274559497833252,
0.3356268107891083,
-0.015529879368841648,
-0.19822095334529877,
-0.2269980013370514,
-0.346812903881073,
0.4696621298789978,
0.5775038003921509,
-0.7143101692199707,
0.47579896450042725,
0.020225228741765022,
0.46006786823272705,
-0.6937410831451416,
-0.7943795919418335,
-0.34769243001937866,
-0.4754367768764496,
-0.48672035336494446,
0.020657533779740334,
-0.26016756892204285,
-0.5319621562957764,
-0.13806331157684326,
-0.4196825623512268,
-0.013994399458169937,
0.2667849361896515,
0.03566581755876541,
0.2969968020915985,
-0.25840625166893005,
0.14373105764389038,
-0.25308412313461304,
-0.20211826264858246,
0.3915363550186157,
-0.08293069154024124,
0.318061888217926,
-0.03288977965712547,
-0.4419185221195221,
-0.3811406195163727,
-0.22737397253513336,
0.5742713809013367,
0.04196609556674957,
0.6138827204704285,
0.4266117513179779,
-0.16197118163108826,
-0.41766098141670227,
-0.2511284351348877,
-0.546132504940033,
-0.43598297238349915,
-0.08048432320356369,
-0.5188000202178955,
-0.3765700161457062,
0.5870516300201416,
0.11361471563577652,
0.2407442331314087,
0.5644709467887878,
0.43769770860671997,
-0.19508430361747742,
1.2012940645217896,
0.18312165141105652,
0.47571220993995667,
0.3280957341194153,
-0.6116185188293457,
0.25886809825897217,
-0.7905220985412598,
-0.03287373483181,
-0.27490076422691345,
-0.40693092346191406,
-0.526098370552063,
-0.4127919673919678,
0.5100782513618469,
0.15826797485351562,
-0.7279184460639954,
0.1595010757446289,
-0.32503676414489746,
0.34429195523262024,
0.525210976600647,
0.45822951197624207,
0.3333186209201813,
-0.02579224295914173,
-0.03557204082608223,
-0.196054607629776,
-0.6672986745834351,
-0.1456977277994156,
1.3504319190979004,
0.1881265938282013,
1.1209418773651123,
0.0942700058221817,
0.8188871741294861,
0.1269797384738922,
0.6221902966499329,
-0.9094712734222412,
0.38625285029411316,
-0.08469128608703613,
-0.49842631816864014,
-0.2950200140476227,
-0.7068699598312378,
-0.6752948760986328,
0.2675740718841553,
-0.47212129831314087,
-0.049653615802526474,
0.17474277317523956,
0.5519758462905884,
-0.41579341888427734,
0.2837525010108948,
-0.8726604580879211,
0.6469716429710388,
-0.4053187370300293,
-0.7347293496131897,
-0.33887067437171936,
-0.4721427857875824,
0.5767962336540222,
-0.1699049323797226,
0.30923163890838623,
0.062304235994815826,
0.26783016324043274,
0.40466126799583435,
-0.6698264479637146,
0.7913707494735718,
-0.25401872396469116,
-0.24572846293449402,
0.4367922842502594,
0.42165371775627136,
0.7154906988143921,
0.273975670337677,
0.07538949698209763,
-0.131271094083786,
-0.2645375728607178,
-0.4620014429092407,
-1.1054438352584839,
0.5713381171226501,
-0.7996936440467834,
-0.732401430606842,
-0.2584584057331085,
-0.6083409190177917,
-0.3608114421367645,
0.05198563635349274,
0.1006174311041832,
0.7744278907775879,
0.3635479211807251,
0.16983552277088165,
0.775131344795227,
0.014796997420489788,
-0.22946345806121826,
0.4547143578529358,
-0.1763588786125183,
-0.39077213406562805,
1.0972386598587036,
0.38444384932518005,
0.7349518537521362,
0.31667083501815796,
0.3839877247810364,
-0.3932376503944397,
-0.2257816642522812,
-0.39557790756225586,
0.4126845598220825,
-0.6609018445014954,
-0.49057117104530334,
-0.21609273552894592,
-0.42376580834388733,
-0.1516156643629074,
-0.14595283567905426,
-0.6132115125656128,
-0.7109085321426392,
-0.3162153363227844,
-0.16188688576221466,
0.18659862875938416,
0.5540845990180969,
-0.4971534311771393,
-0.16677427291870117,
-0.439352422952652,
0.39463216066360474,
0.35707420110702515,
0.12913115322589874,
0.19551849365234375,
-0.801227331161499,
-0.180304616689682,
0.4837532043457031,
-0.40934842824935913,
-0.40715640783309937,
0.1492333710193634,
0.008401685394346714,
0.42597123980522156,
0.18294982612133026,
0.235923171043396,
0.9876996278762817,
-0.3702021539211273,
0.5375853776931763,
0.1315985769033432,
-0.5127162933349609,
0.16615381836891174,
-0.27159497141838074,
0.10285619646310806,
0.30272650718688965,
0.43316590785980225,
-0.2940889894962311,
-0.3876197934150696,
-0.7922478318214417,
-0.5456116199493408,
0.3703017234802246,
0.007464500144124031,
0.28649216890335083,
0.111605703830719,
0.6522611975669861,
0.1285482943058014,
-0.047125350683927536,
-0.7960936427116394,
-0.2879626750946045,
-0.22707313299179077,
-0.14742931723594666,
-0.09280817955732346,
-0.05311141908168793,
-0.3322658836841583,
-0.3210241496562958,
0.8886605501174927,
-0.08581632375717163,
0.14404146373271942,
0.262808620929718,
-0.08558934181928635,
-0.2973105013370514,
0.2464067041873932,
0.6743635535240173,
0.542798638343811,
-0.14284928143024445,
0.3527951240539551,
0.2696499228477478,
-0.2974127233028412,
0.33665215969085693,
-0.18066002428531647,
-0.1445786952972412,
-0.576974630355835,
0.37766802310943604,
0.5908613801002502,
0.017803983762860298,
-0.5085548758506775,
0.28914761543273926,
-0.002608539769425988,
-0.36776986718177795,
-0.31164631247520447,
0.33126673102378845,
-0.1657847762107849,
0.2080768495798111,
0.3091241419315338,
0.4081404507160187,
-0.024013083428144455,
-0.46462729573249817,
0.2351604849100113,
0.5934749841690063,
-0.17613375186920166,
-0.42229872941970825,
0.5235580205917358,
-0.13454632461071014,
-0.41663697361946106,
0.726207971572876,
-0.20408909022808075,
-0.45874831080436707,
0.7170791029930115,
0.8378309607505798,
0.4025615453720093,
0.09531641006469727,
0.21929454803466797,
0.8222004771232605,
-0.037241820245981216,
-0.0254752766340971,
0.14572985470294952,
-0.15290647745132446,
-0.9640015363693237,
-0.4544149935245514,
-0.5075311660766602,
-0.36664676666259766,
0.21561425924301147,
-0.7536487579345703,
0.3152708113193512,
-0.5471553206443787,
-0.1364513486623764,
-0.10461797565221786,
0.00535911088809371,
-0.6929728984832764,
0.3789520263671875,
-0.026863133534789085,
0.6987310647964478,
-0.7594289779663086,
0.4001758098602295,
0.5051414966583252,
-0.5658587217330933,
-1.1785545349121094,
-0.19252528250217438,
0.09756606072187424,
-1.1133501529693604,
0.8538878560066223,
-0.07397184520959854,
-0.3449651598930359,
0.08025220781564713,
-0.5294554233551025,
-0.8655909299850464,
0.8711357712745667,
0.3422085642814636,
-0.39199501276016235,
0.19978921115398407,
0.1578424572944641,
0.7765987515449524,
-0.15602724254131317,
0.1389625072479248,
0.2940724790096283,
0.2270209938287735,
0.3134627938270569,
-0.5626795291900635,
0.02355300448834896,
-0.03485087677836418,
-0.20581035315990448,
0.2679256200790405,
-0.46848779916763306,
1.087624430656433,
-0.5565112829208374,
-0.3405294716358185,
-0.02212340570986271,
0.3510535955429077,
0.3635540306568146,
0.2758232653141022,
0.44924822449684143,
0.9818434119224548,
0.5792239904403687,
0.14306503534317017,
0.9980821013450623,
-0.2203454077243805,
0.5976155996322632,
1.0932893753051758,
0.043540969491004944,
0.5841042995452881,
0.5442014932632446,
-0.36071449518203735,
0.37662601470947266,
0.4823708236217499,
0.1581917554140091,
0.46494004130363464,
0.40464216470718384,
-0.21311824023723602,
-0.6542389988899231,
0.08804108202457428,
-0.24861282110214233,
0.11716490983963013,
0.3237168490886688,
-0.11557816714048386,
-0.5356326103210449,
-0.12890581786632538,
-0.13519924879074097,
0.38226017355918884,
-0.41715148091316223,
0.4798514246940613,
0.31905362010002136,
-0.552698016166687,
0.8139600157737732,
-0.26417404413223267,
0.5496233105659485,
-0.48598843812942505,
-0.2436234951019287,
-0.4101160168647766,
0.5113977789878845,
-0.27221882343292236,
-0.7489355802536011,
0.4745517671108246,
-0.09095336496829987,
-0.17320963740348816,
-0.1835366040468216,
0.6203635334968567,
-0.337473601102829,
-0.47703900933265686,
-0.11125103384256363,
0.5022634863853455,
-0.02045091800391674,
0.32285311818122864,
-0.7048432230949402,
-0.2211885303258896,
-0.03482947126030922,
0.01808585226535797,
0.4305490553379059,
0.5116006731987,
0.020494595170021057,
0.7898508906364441,
0.894095778465271,
0.20863406360149384,
0.0608261339366436,
0.18709826469421387,
0.6559997797012329,
-0.426013708114624,
-0.22601813077926636,
-0.90174800157547,
0.5222092270851135,
-0.05759716406464577,
-0.2618691921234131,
0.9215167760848999,
0.5829914808273315,
1.0207046270370483,
0.06618640571832657,
0.4420011341571808,
0.30538976192474365,
0.6876195073127747,
-0.5533814430236816,
0.2117125242948532,
-0.6839531064033508,
0.42015427350997925,
0.1407867670059204,
-0.7115931510925293,
-0.48407721519470215,
0.7083287835121155,
-0.6521130204200745,
-0.02372799813747406,
0.4244031310081482,
0.8440325856208801,
-0.35630571842193604,
-0.13758118450641632,
0.3157263994216919,
0.3541525900363922,
0.4533976912498474,
0.3687109649181366,
0.8334802985191345,
-0.4563896059989929,
0.24997350573539734,
-0.39167073369026184,
-0.03935953974723816,
-0.00727259274572134,
-0.5789265632629395,
-0.6092702150344849,
-0.1961308866739273,
-0.09134894609451294,
-0.6846639513969421,
-0.09308799356222153,
0.9720350503921509,
0.4449668824672699,
-0.7121962904930115,
-0.29613590240478516,
-0.4996839165687561,
0.2238515019416809,
-0.25236526131629944,
-0.2935899794101715,
0.05532514676451683,
-0.8171054720878601,
-0.3806067109107971,
0.11062531918287277,
0.008082285523414612,
0.2532880902290344,
-0.4422728717327118,
-0.19545438885688782,
0.14799655973911285,
0.35229313373565674,
0.5163835287094116,
0.37950947880744934,
-0.364955335855484,
-0.4188608229160309,
0.021303268149495125,
-0.2392386794090271,
0.2782987058162689,
0.9562830328941345,
-0.6970914602279663,
0.39117345213890076,
0.31454533338546753,
0.7442377805709839,
0.5931932330131531,
0.26959428191185,
0.6464678049087524,
-0.53300940990448,
-0.08610040694475174,
0.2529362142086029,
0.106150783598423,
0.34712734818458557,
-0.4970686435699463,
0.5436371564865112,
0.4323979914188385,
-0.6899407505989075,
-1.011405348777771,
0.276259183883667,
-0.630393385887146,
-0.06892623752355576,
1.1421793699264526,
0.012939386069774628,
-0.1955815851688385,
0.2696826756000519,
-0.12132246792316437,
0.08729229867458344,
-0.21518687903881073,
0.9550721645355225,
0.4330751299858093,
-0.7339798808097839,
0.15791180729866028,
-0.4490296244621277,
0.5162206292152405,
0.5810862183570862,
-0.5083520412445068,
0.054275885224342346,
0.5560208559036255,
0.5152419209480286,
0.23377184569835663,
0.4369831681251526,
-0.015507973730564117,
0.29182422161102295,
0.15009666979312897,
-0.46379902958869934,
-0.13737650215625763,
-0.36738428473472595,
-0.2826504111289978,
-0.09361643344163895,
0.19534222781658173,
0.10403751581907272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14517v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14517v1 | PostMark: A Robust Blackbox Watermark for Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T17:27:14 | 2024-06-20T17:27:14 | Yapei Chang, Kalpesh Krishna, Amir Houmansadr, John Wieting, Mohit Iyyer | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | The most effective techniques to detect LLM-generated text rely on inserting
a detectable signature -- or watermark -- during the model's decoding process.
Most existing watermarking methods require access to the underlying LLM's
logits, which LLM API providers are loath to share due to fears of model
distillation. As such, these watermarks must be implemented independently by
each LLM provider. In this paper, we develop PostMark, a modular post-hoc
watermarking procedure in which an input-dependent set of words (determined via
a semantic embedding) is inserted into the text after the decoding process has
completed. Critically, PostMark does not require logit access, which means it
can be implemented by a third party. We also show that PostMark is more robust
to paraphrasing attacks than existing watermarking methods: our experiments
cover eight baseline algorithms, five base LLMs, and three datasets. Finally,
we evaluate the impact of PostMark on text quality using both automated and
human assessments, highlighting the trade-off between quality and robustness to
paraphrasing. We release our code, outputs, and annotations at
https://github.com/lilakk/PostMark. | [
-0.16659380495548248,
-0.8965280652046204,
0.680296003818512,
0.3287084102630615,
-0.8331778645515442,
0.08045460283756256,
0.13290748000144958,
-0.39769935607910156,
0.10604564845561981,
0.9110369682312012,
-0.2341541349887848,
-0.8169939517974854,
-0.949105441570282,
-0.02613099105656147,
-0.6703932881355286,
0.79908686876297,
-0.08595553040504456,
-0.22937257587909698,
-0.3310009837150574,
-0.2917421758174896,
-0.2937054932117462,
-0.7643597722053528,
-0.43537816405296326,
-0.17482654750347137,
0.35133931040763855,
-0.20455552637577057,
0.6286057233810425,
0.8561696410179138,
0.4031977355480194,
0.1775185465812683,
-0.3224654495716095,
0.2669502794742584,
-0.2117815464735031,
0.2945774495601654,
-0.35028547048568726,
-0.37918367981910706,
-0.46335169672966003,
-0.26929304003715515,
0.6585696339607239,
0.2145901322364807,
0.09251434355974197,
0.19141963124275208,
0.29362958669662476,
0.13208571076393127,
-0.90761798620224,
0.2061113715171814,
-0.9050420522689819,
-0.14635637402534485,
-0.4470689594745636,
-0.2075643390417099,
-0.28687384724617004,
-0.18497997522354126,
-0.1686159372329712,
-0.3939289152622223,
-0.07080888748168945,
0.28276580572128296,
0.9518197774887085,
0.30646127462387085,
-0.19219844043254852,
-0.3965992033481598,
-0.6750108003616333,
0.7949575781822205,
-1.0287704467773438,
0.1635318249464035,
0.6147702932357788,
0.05914093181490898,
-0.10243269801139832,
-0.7412216663360596,
-0.533054530620575,
0.12129069864749908,
0.0020825001411139965,
-0.058135587722063065,
-0.3286910653114319,
-0.18570761382579803,
0.28651487827301025,
0.3743318021297455,
-0.38067349791526794,
-0.11052695661783218,
0.0468868687748909,
-0.37048038840293884,
0.37145254015922546,
0.2387292981147766,
0.43161237239837646,
-0.041716400533914566,
-0.3690776824951172,
0.08434900641441345,
-0.9957756400108337,
0.04759756848216057,
0.38898181915283203,
0.2914312183856964,
0.05698695406317711,
0.5418071150779724,
-0.2267247438430786,
0.632475733757019,
-0.2017577886581421,
-0.027077751234173775,
-0.1855209916830063,
-0.20394618809223175,
-0.01482721883803606,
0.03747224435210228,
0.9247042536735535,
0.19100995361804962,
0.11215967684984207,
-0.11306767165660858,
-0.6147688031196594,
0.10019192099571228,
0.1762014627456665,
-0.847086489200592,
-0.2128005027770996,
0.036022160202264786,
-0.2996251881122589,
-0.3490297198295593,
0.1343521624803543,
-0.7303654551506042,
-0.5374106168746948,
-0.09714753925800323,
0.7363582849502563,
-0.10481136292219162,
-0.2782018780708313,
0.18743814527988434,
0.08500503748655319,
0.1860850304365158,
0.1013529896736145,
-0.7929801344871521,
0.46804168820381165,
0.9799094200134277,
0.8980350494384766,
-0.251706063747406,
-0.19660598039627075,
-0.8175303936004639,
0.41997137665748596,
-0.2963736355304718,
1.2157151699066162,
-0.7466087937355042,
-0.383758008480072,
0.1933097541332245,
0.03095545805990696,
0.21066772937774658,
-0.6900740265846252,
0.34726041555404663,
-0.6436752676963806,
0.0829104483127594,
-0.1927500218153,
-0.8507150411605835,
-0.010362100787460804,
0.30649101734161377,
-0.738064169883728,
1.147428035736084,
-0.14189288020133972,
-0.9819518327713013,
0.1964297741651535,
-0.21798323094844818,
-0.5010696649551392,
0.28137317299842834,
-0.07210315763950348,
-0.7191983461380005,
0.17325159907341003,
0.4129214286804199,
0.46788838505744934,
-0.2536991536617279,
0.14697274565696716,
-0.30766016244888306,
-0.3903615474700928,
0.47100192308425903,
-0.1601046919822693,
0.45418623089790344,
-0.27197250723838806,
-0.4207766652107239,
0.17477241158485413,
-0.8066911101341248,
0.031391438096761703,
0.12542115151882172,
-0.45912256836891174,
-0.5049418807029724,
0.14415018260478973,
0.0033954442478716373,
0.021780189126729965,
0.45403602719306946,
-0.4848431944847107,
-0.2107042819261551,
-0.21768367290496826,
0.5487166047096252,
0.6604070663452148,
0.2554498314857483,
0.18714529275894165,
-0.5153425335884094,
0.6455488204956055,
-0.07333873957395554,
0.09228094667196274,
-0.21705882251262665,
-0.6671075820922852,
-0.39923912286758423,
-0.4660491347312927,
0.34190940856933594,
0.5066535472869873,
-0.7217175960540771,
0.5658916234970093,
-0.21477189660072327,
-0.46930739283561707,
-0.4778268337249756,
0.49054405093193054,
0.45701828598976135,
0.38899102807044983,
0.4993884265422821,
-0.10925736278295517,
-0.2762017548084259,
-0.8700949549674988,
-0.4551267623901367,
-0.11469274759292603,
-0.20146360993385315,
0.07471839338541031,
0.4959460496902466,
-0.14792190492153168,
0.7753065824508667,
-0.5560888051986694,
-0.19202004373073578,
-0.18103088438510895,
0.1658557653427124,
-0.043440185487270355,
0.3958832323551178,
0.29002150893211365,
-0.5523064136505127,
-0.32138845324516296,
-0.2611646354198456,
-0.6371824145317078,
-0.47399282455444336,
0.11152976006269455,
-0.33057111501693726,
-0.13221602141857147,
0.6299535632133484,
-0.7486565113067627,
0.43807053565979004,
0.8610251545906067,
-0.4511305093765259,
0.6567182540893555,
-0.18976236879825592,
0.0771246924996376,
-1.0150258541107178,
0.24249140918254852,
-0.3653515577316284,
-0.3525443375110626,
-0.36104586720466614,
-0.05563858896493912,
0.17863093316555023,
-0.21093566715717316,
-0.32609620690345764,
0.7532904148101807,
-0.34495916962623596,
0.07341606169939041,
-0.6733261942863464,
-0.1309327334165573,
0.30977222323417664,
0.17759226262569427,
0.07555034011602402,
0.6029013395309448,
0.47988030314445496,
-0.3233799636363983,
0.2075962871313095,
0.1895872801542282,
-0.5454413294792175,
0.7648773789405823,
-0.8892034292221069,
0.30772092938423157,
0.030574051663279533,
0.1400376260280609,
-1.1195658445358276,
0.1577109545469284,
0.4189220070838928,
-0.14868080615997314,
0.049429114907979965,
-0.21647150814533234,
-0.8640753626823425,
0.10533152520656586,
-0.3505870997905731,
0.1587250977754593,
0.5514693856239319,
-0.3679082989692688,
0.48248061537742615,
0.22531001269817352,
-0.29048728942871094,
-0.23854613304138184,
-0.7581385970115662,
0.3230484426021576,
-0.35929563641548157,
-0.38591885566711426,
0.39311468601226807,
-0.08547066152095795,
-0.07734497636556625,
0.13439296185970306,
-0.20334987342357635,
-0.3120584487915039,
0.3036779761314392,
0.3056873083114624,
0.08684095740318298,
-0.2521706521511078,
-0.22921571135520935,
0.18399712443351746,
-0.4165872633457184,
-0.016840213909745216,
-0.3609575927257538,
0.3908206820487976,
0.2659531533718109,
-0.3773776590824127,
-0.5474147200584412,
0.5426567792892456,
0.6031831502914429,
-0.495482861995697,
0.5806450247764587,
0.30793246626853943,
-0.7682004570960999,
-0.559544026851654,
-0.5503318905830383,
-0.19357001781463623,
-0.4938639998435974,
-0.03780540078878403,
-0.08071468770503998,
-0.7966700792312622,
0.40555909276008606,
0.029780013486742973,
0.09414653480052948,
0.11416298151016235,
0.3101672828197479,
-0.19620564579963684,
0.6399936676025391,
0.4303356409072876,
-0.015561397187411785,
0.5419976711273193,
0.21918265521526337,
0.2248624861240387,
-0.7300512790679932,
0.02377023547887802,
-0.45570310950279236,
-0.16209858655929565,
0.008315043523907661,
-0.6134779453277588,
-0.2227187603712082,
0.49629563093185425,
0.10146339982748032,
0.5339682698249817,
-0.5160914063453674,
0.43662765622138977,
0.5876412987709045,
0.11362367868423462,
0.5181989073753357,
0.12618350982666016,
-0.09954963624477386,
-0.23405681550502777,
-0.24108003079891205,
-0.8702308535575867,
0.8866317868232727,
0.03733265399932861,
0.6780312061309814,
-0.2095690220594406,
0.8389549851417542,
0.3229360282421112,
0.38378414511680603,
-0.3668857216835022,
0.6909559369087219,
0.0209475290030241,
-0.5715774297714233,
-0.04746365174651146,
-0.24453236162662506,
-0.9468387961387634,
0.18656261265277863,
-0.29536911845207214,
-0.687932014465332,
-0.17374706268310547,
0.21007859706878662,
-0.300141841173172,
0.40314775705337524,
-0.1761830747127533,
0.8283384442329407,
-0.1957010179758072,
-0.43734320998191833,
-0.01457581389695406,
-0.27317535877227783,
-0.10093467682600021,
-0.31678715348243713,
0.38348692655563354,
-0.44072914123535156,
-0.3455372154712677,
0.8307586312294006,
-0.42741861939430237,
0.7328171730041504,
-0.27839604020118713,
-0.27480781078338623,
0.33473145961761475,
0.40138423442840576,
0.7566608190536499,
0.03789960965514183,
-0.03363003209233284,
0.2594924569129944,
0.16716168820858002,
-0.46509942412376404,
-0.4596632719039917,
0.5626358389854431,
-0.2968690097332001,
-0.6600472331047058,
-0.21707338094711304,
-0.33406639099121094,
-0.20717884600162506,
0.3911943733692169,
0.23640839755535126,
0.5088421106338501,
0.15854336321353912,
0.26659587025642395,
0.6224894523620605,
-0.45718586444854736,
0.5338261127471924,
0.5009893774986267,
-0.12556029856204987,
-0.7268444299697876,
1.0101923942565918,
0.10691501945257187,
0.0890217125415802,
0.4777452349662781,
0.4267137050628662,
-0.3535337448120117,
-1.122678518295288,
-0.3851465582847595,
0.34669560194015503,
-0.8309430480003357,
-0.2795860171318054,
-0.6324617266654968,
-0.19250747561454773,
-0.06341593712568283,
-0.3045399487018585,
-0.453548789024353,
-0.1369037926197052,
-0.2144816517829895,
-0.0035260366275906563,
0.32851096987724304,
0.8188044428825378,
0.2361522912979126,
0.45996764302253723,
-0.8743939995765686,
0.338853657245636,
0.34793785214424133,
0.3065028488636017,
-0.09322276711463928,
-0.48830050230026245,
-0.08187654614448547,
-0.062259167432785034,
-0.2580358386039734,
-0.5499427318572998,
0.10336136072874069,
0.16937468945980072,
0.5761762857437134,
0.48469242453575134,
0.25261878967285156,
0.3798024356365204,
-0.45598146319389343,
0.8706491589546204,
0.033913590013980865,
-1.151639699935913,
0.5430798530578613,
-0.4075899124145508,
0.533246636390686,
0.4291844964027405,
0.12864461541175842,
-0.2140517681837082,
-1.0153261423110962,
-0.3732917904853821,
-0.9814432263374329,
0.3578789234161377,
0.18092875182628632,
0.45434245467185974,
-0.023646073415875435,
0.26684531569480896,
0.14580945670604706,
0.4339281916618347,
-1.0086840391159058,
-0.1016436219215393,
-0.06227405369281769,
-0.2751661241054535,
0.08199261873960495,
-0.7402668595314026,
-0.05747931823134422,
0.0832681730389595,
0.3958900570869446,
0.1340564638376236,
-0.04772938787937164,
-0.06082681566476822,
-0.440766841173172,
0.20725370943546295,
0.23079310357570648,
0.4852668046951294,
0.7028298377990723,
0.008416224271059036,
0.5743681788444519,
0.044792406260967255,
-0.22068984806537628,
0.17960523068904877,
0.03095731884241104,
-0.3075563907623291,
0.25385454297065735,
0.9832467436790466,
0.42449286580085754,
0.5197132229804993,
-0.6277250051498413,
0.6120310425758362,
0.13212259113788605,
-0.3236846625804901,
0.18730612099170685,
-0.1363319307565689,
0.5173375010490417,
0.26097995042800903,
0.2852112054824829,
-0.4218560755252838,
-0.05848142132163048,
-0.14532636106014252,
0.2543790936470032,
0.2705305814743042,
-0.2691808342933655,
-0.5227456092834473,
0.8897333145141602,
0.047434329986572266,
-0.4752062261104584,
0.1650204211473465,
0.0475018285214901,
-0.6224814653396606,
0.2974105775356293,
0.5810292363166809,
0.8594706058502197,
-0.372654527425766,
-0.008374503813683987,
0.1717531979084015,
0.3309011459350586,
-0.2337704449892044,
0.37519896030426025,
-0.2604057788848877,
-0.5600973963737488,
-0.242116779088974,
-0.9414145946502686,
-0.47570887207984924,
0.16951338946819305,
-0.570473313331604,
0.24997398257255554,
-0.8883086442947388,
-0.0527254194021225,
0.00852223765105009,
-0.40137243270874023,
-0.41257497668266296,
0.10683996975421906,
0.421487033367157,
0.48050475120544434,
-0.8250976204872131,
0.8786302208900452,
0.6894949674606323,
0.08551076799631119,
-0.2947143316268921,
0.12572115659713745,
-0.07064282894134521,
-0.7968641519546509,
0.3607393503189087,
0.29248663783073425,
-0.20719440281391144,
0.0020704709459096193,
-0.33455756306648254,
-0.7598479986190796,
0.8458932638168335,
0.4874487817287445,
-0.4440346658229828,
0.3128650486469269,
0.42498689889907837,
0.541701078414917,
-0.07850386202335358,
-0.2585853040218353,
0.31694939732551575,
0.40019506216049194,
-0.14109399914741516,
-0.507045328617096,
0.5698526501655579,
-0.13896970450878143,
0.06926098465919495,
0.11468386650085449,
-0.3440384864807129,
0.6687315702438354,
0.4573160707950592,
-0.2841498851776123,
0.016857201233506203,
0.2940470278263092,
0.24069389700889587,
0.07712779194116592,
0.48303940892219543,
0.5484685301780701,
0.626836895942688,
0.007072856184095144,
0.8780386447906494,
-0.40993669629096985,
0.27462059259414673,
1.084483027458191,
-0.35639068484306335,
1.1242128610610962,
0.47035300731658936,
-0.1321081668138504,
0.2946024239063263,
0.39747416973114014,
-0.19620107114315033,
0.7506539821624756,
0.4440329968929291,
-0.5484011173248291,
-0.39675015211105347,
-0.1723986715078354,
-0.28781452775001526,
0.13779044151306152,
0.4339710474014282,
-0.39825934171676636,
-0.2523568570613861,
-0.02978438138961792,
0.19579237699508667,
0.30614322423934937,
-0.10126058757305145,
0.8858315944671631,
0.44186848402023315,
-0.39565610885620117,
0.550447940826416,
-0.03808772191405296,
0.8798812031745911,
-0.6918689608573914,
0.12707947194576263,
-0.28758955001831055,
0.2947826683521271,
-0.18450261652469635,
-0.6919713616371155,
0.6266138553619385,
-0.014882385730743408,
-0.01585366390645504,
-0.4577254056930542,
0.6329095363616943,
-0.6311403512954712,
-0.5507419109344482,
0.7287517786026001,
0.35337573289871216,
0.013186980038881302,
-0.3608667254447937,
-0.6570672988891602,
0.4724128246307373,
-0.39036211371421814,
-0.3221883773803711,
0.1626700460910797,
0.45051202178001404,
0.008664458058774471,
0.5477584600448608,
0.6646301746368408,
0.35452592372894287,
0.15682782232761383,
-0.07418433576822281,
0.6046276688575745,
-0.6355719566345215,
-0.5587857365608215,
-1.3086950778961182,
0.352402001619339,
-0.0710785984992981,
-0.22603873908519745,
0.8826894760131836,
0.44200393557548523,
0.462574303150177,
0.02458532713353634,
0.907093346118927,
0.33484500646591187,
0.19851277768611908,
-0.5369406938552856,
0.8854448795318604,
-0.43287593126296997,
0.2256133258342743,
-0.6547958850860596,
-1.1383148431777954,
-0.713912844657898,
0.3821273744106293,
-0.269003689289093,
-0.48616823554039,
0.7922907471656799,
1.06547212600708,
-0.04996412247419357,
-0.18948917090892792,
0.5108190178871155,
-0.2502976357936859,
0.5091008543968201,
0.44664862751960754,
1.1583203077316284,
-0.3248840570449829,
0.9240564703941345,
-0.1290067881345749,
-0.06701622158288956,
-0.12789186835289001,
-1.0132533311843872,
-1.1440991163253784,
-0.40390315651893616,
-0.7824023962020874,
-0.36454978585243225,
0.10861710458993912,
0.37393665313720703,
0.6334651112556458,
-1.041231632232666,
-0.07103949040174484,
0.08261673152446747,
0.19280728697776794,
-0.13625867664813995,
-0.14316301047801971,
0.511044442653656,
-0.03774356469511986,
-0.5851277709007263,
0.20823581516742706,
0.5379515886306763,
0.3049149811267853,
0.061515629291534424,
0.1482812911272049,
-0.10081874579191208,
0.3125171363353729,
0.3647502362728119,
-0.04209072142839432,
-0.6422486305236816,
-0.4285585582256317,
-0.30782777070999146,
-0.18396827578544617,
0.013625871390104294,
0.9517506957054138,
-0.07899189740419388,
0.44565239548683167,
0.4889468252658844,
0.9669147729873657,
0.4707510471343994,
0.03565947338938713,
0.4972289800643921,
-0.6592791676521301,
0.24928204715251923,
0.16125810146331787,
0.5758857727050781,
0.5710557699203491,
-0.17385494709014893,
-0.03361562639474869,
0.4567575454711914,
-0.34074366092681885,
-0.9519498348236084,
-0.20197707414627075,
-0.5906285047531128,
-0.3384295105934143,
1.2395975589752197,
-0.5760552287101746,
-0.1846439242362976,
-0.4052262604236603,
-0.2576228082180023,
-0.1260489523410797,
-0.20585963129997253,
0.6911654472351074,
1.1525945663452148,
0.49244189262390137,
-0.13688111305236816,
-0.4616836905479431,
0.47403979301452637,
0.37623563408851624,
-0.8676890134811401,
0.22622209787368774,
0.24499544501304626,
0.6796051859855652,
-0.14506980776786804,
0.5912662744522095,
-0.25551918148994446,
0.057605016976594925,
0.1695559173822403,
0.10629341751337051,
-0.2091178297996521,
-0.05574140325188637,
-0.29368335008621216,
0.2731701135635376,
0.2584680914878845,
-0.3956933319568634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14511v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14511v1 | Investigating Mysteries of CoT-Augmented Distillation | 2024-06-20T17:15:46 | 2024-06-20T17:15:46 | Somin Wadhwa, Silvio Amir, Byron C. Wallace | cs.CL | cs.CL | Eliciting "chain of thought" (CoT) rationales -- sequences of token that
convey a "reasoning" process -- has been shown to consistently improve LLM
performance on tasks like question answering. More recent efforts have shown
that such rationales can also be used for model distillation: Including CoT
sequences (elicited from a large "teacher" model) in addition to target labels
when fine-tuning a small student model yields (often substantial) improvements.
In this work we ask: Why and how does this additional training signal help in
model distillation? We perform ablations to interrogate this, and report some
potentially surprising results. Specifically: (1) Placing CoT sequences after
labels (rather than before) realizes consistently better downstream performance
-- this means that no student "reasoning" is necessary at test time to realize
gains. (2) When rationales are appended in this way, they need not be coherent
reasoning sequences to yield improvements; performance increases are robust to
permutations of CoT tokens, for example. In fact, (3) a small number of key
tokens are sufficient to achieve improvements equivalent to those observed when
full rationales are used in model distillation. | [
-0.7570214867591858,
-0.7267577052116394,
0.8109850287437439,
-0.3082069456577301,
-0.6585272550582886,
0.48533308506011963,
-0.11357016116380692,
-0.44492173194885254,
-0.06740325689315796,
0.37182608246803284,
-0.3014904260635376,
-0.1380319595336914,
-0.7773672342300415,
0.2727055549621582,
-0.7101174592971802,
1.1797585487365723,
0.07831577956676483,
0.31291306018829346,
0.03746716305613518,
0.06131839379668236,
-0.570378839969635,
-0.9238765835762024,
-0.646860659122467,
-0.5621052384376526,
0.8172272443771362,
0.15230748057365417,
0.4933938682079315,
0.5967534184455872,
0.2983699142932892,
0.2817961573600769,
-0.51787930727005,
0.37189769744873047,
-0.4651925563812256,
0.2115040272474289,
-0.19018295407295227,
-0.8979281187057495,
-0.16961787641048431,
0.2155611515045166,
0.41469806432724,
0.7477591037750244,
0.10909785330295563,
0.10727785527706146,
0.24993778765201569,
1.1256078481674194,
-0.8037247657775879,
-0.3918687701225281,
-0.8452943563461304,
-0.1524825245141983,
0.1632014513015747,
-0.43177881836891174,
-0.5871901512145996,
-0.21561895310878754,
0.36134785413742065,
-0.19377581775188446,
0.5343982577323914,
0.16001783311367035,
0.654908299446106,
0.3901011347770691,
-0.448875367641449,
-0.6347174644470215,
-0.8758278489112854,
0.5306045413017273,
-0.5180155038833618,
0.09677612036466599,
0.36542367935180664,
0.16086426377296448,
-0.29830583930015564,
-0.9050819873809814,
-0.7170417904853821,
-0.025004716590046883,
-0.17845916748046875,
-0.21941694617271423,
0.16166192293167114,
0.43204164505004883,
0.7688881158828735,
0.7381952404975891,
0.11289195716381073,
-0.275532990694046,
-0.6443315148353577,
0.11021747440099716,
0.3611646294593811,
0.10871473699808121,
-0.12545450031757355,
0.40422263741493225,
-0.5890501141548157,
-0.13975359499454498,
-0.5610935091972351,
0.10272210091352463,
0.35716453194618225,
0.1419239044189453,
0.07644156366586685,
0.8372983336448669,
-0.056628525257110596,
0.9272446632385254,
0.4104180634021759,
0.12297781556844711,
-0.030473995953798294,
-0.3880549967288971,
-0.2657622992992401,
0.6148092150688171,
0.24263536930084229,
0.01950831711292267,
0.28324154019355774,
0.020067278295755386,
-0.2694668471813202,
0.29032570123672485,
0.17567631602287292,
-0.8847226500511169,
-0.6751401424407959,
0.27014997601509094,
-0.18348608911037445,
-0.3786844313144684,
0.16352646052837372,
-0.30916208028793335,
-0.32965683937072754,
-0.83184814453125,
0.3407374918460846,
-0.3967682123184204,
-0.2966288924217224,
-0.001859713695012033,
-0.9716235399246216,
0.007553268224000931,
0.2714904546737671,
-1.1058703660964966,
0.11880753189325333,
0.835981547832489,
0.8460865020751953,
-0.03168106451630592,
-0.09319072961807251,
-0.44359904527664185,
0.012741755694150925,
-0.5829409956932068,
0.914679765701294,
-0.6777059435844421,
-0.46960678696632385,
-0.5105065107345581,
-0.1770310401916504,
0.013488036580383778,
-0.7218732833862305,
0.05095784738659859,
-0.5687133073806763,
-0.21650910377502441,
-0.9060244560241699,
-0.5611570477485657,
-0.03567039594054222,
0.1530110388994217,
-0.6422428488731384,
1.0751286745071411,
-0.24425771832466125,
-0.662352442741394,
0.6176129579544067,
-0.5156162977218628,
-0.15853387117385864,
-0.3696803152561188,
-0.24043008685112,
-0.09431320428848267,
0.6767395734786987,
0.018916161730885506,
-0.06142418086528778,
-0.4340748190879822,
0.13993804156780243,
-0.25707510113716125,
-0.4754575192928314,
0.9367184042930603,
-0.9893952012062073,
0.7590742707252502,
0.45860958099365234,
-0.27520111203193665,
-0.184827983379364,
-0.7051840424537659,
-0.036666978150606155,
-0.3590629994869232,
-0.34281444549560547,
-0.5434489250183105,
-0.33542850613594055,
-0.5475797057151794,
0.06773334741592407,
-0.07650832831859589,
-0.449625164270401,
0.3015781044960022,
-0.1411503404378891,
0.31122368574142456,
0.8039194345474243,
0.3308255970478058,
0.4239203929901123,
-0.6068626642227173,
0.3763642907142639,
0.3112131953239441,
-0.04571997746825218,
-0.3562576472759247,
-0.6338976621627808,
-0.9627061486244202,
-0.514609158039093,
0.4556628465652466,
0.013953037559986115,
-0.8355600237846375,
-0.05703013390302658,
0.2768998146057129,
-0.47451528906822205,
-0.4970285892486572,
0.19278891384601593,
0.3600938022136688,
0.8667258024215698,
0.4438783526420593,
-0.14834122359752655,
-0.5381317734718323,
-0.5317869186401367,
-0.16264799237251282,
-0.22391735017299652,
0.1531381458044052,
-0.26690545678138733,
0.3359968662261963,
0.3093644976615906,
0.9849509596824646,
-0.6873089075088501,
0.2267710566520691,
-0.07395361363887787,
0.4829217493534088,
0.5457894802093506,
0.3290354013442993,
0.5155059099197388,
-0.9108128547668457,
-0.48773568868637085,
-0.16911888122558594,
-0.4093378186225891,
-0.14599475264549255,
-0.12771442532539368,
-0.4734545052051544,
0.1933496594429016,
0.23752984404563904,
-0.43956589698791504,
0.7136611938476562,
0.18365252017974854,
-0.3533341884613037,
0.7524470090866089,
-0.336666464805603,
0.471315860748291,
-0.6740500330924988,
-0.09851841628551483,
-0.3225851356983185,
-0.026753949001431465,
-0.5939332842826843,
-0.3406764566898346,
-0.1678612232208252,
0.2646212875843048,
-0.4756205976009369,
0.16243234276771545,
-0.56484454870224,
-0.07007297873497009,
-0.8697639107704163,
0.019744528457522392,
0.38920578360557556,
0.3970967233181,
-0.041354723274707794,
0.964022159576416,
0.48814013600349426,
-0.927128791809082,
0.4052453935146332,
0.08011159300804138,
-0.12283315509557724,
0.6128708124160767,
-0.4527740180492401,
0.2388606071472168,
-0.19420893490314484,
0.13680560886859894,
-1.346708059310913,
0.050417378544807434,
-0.11428534984588623,
-0.4391079545021057,
0.25652647018432617,
-0.12965823709964752,
-0.14532087743282318,
-0.3716071546077728,
-0.20798040926456451,
0.5551211833953857,
0.6328433156013489,
-0.9515894651412964,
0.5168622732162476,
0.0791340321302414,
0.32185065746307373,
-0.6017493009567261,
-0.8291208148002625,
-0.2683713734149933,
-0.5038818717002869,
-0.07355765998363495,
0.02156982384622097,
0.030832791700959206,
-0.4953523874282837,
0.10006164759397507,
-0.5255163311958313,
-0.035857509821653366,
0.31540223956108093,
0.13919979333877563,
0.5989224314689636,
0.038717806339263916,
0.29140204191207886,
0.331367164850235,
-0.17159661650657654,
0.24504828453063965,
-0.3100320100784302,
0.5608552098274231,
-0.17309138178825378,
-0.234723761677742,
-0.5218784809112549,
0.1031453013420105,
0.5976771116256714,
0.09351208060979843,
0.8704371452331543,
0.3393825590610504,
-0.18001730740070343,
-0.2029154747724533,
-0.6192494034767151,
-0.4657858908176422,
-0.5531343221664429,
-0.20524536073207855,
-0.6214108467102051,
-0.6725597381591797,
0.5473667979240417,
-0.3501235246658325,
-0.06730823963880539,
0.24576574563980103,
0.6185370683670044,
-0.3321300446987152,
1.0286051034927368,
0.06953328847885132,
0.4087103307247162,
0.515691339969635,
-0.6156423687934875,
0.5068515539169312,
-1.1197006702423096,
-0.3106388449668884,
-0.5697774887084961,
-0.6022312641143799,
-0.4304301142692566,
-0.4543103575706482,
0.41446807980537415,
0.5918047428131104,
-0.27546823024749756,
0.2009577453136444,
-0.77119380235672,
0.806365430355072,
0.6157625913619995,
0.1783604472875595,
0.5814302563667297,
-0.08346971124410629,
-0.3745182752609253,
0.441697895526886,
-0.8254773020744324,
-0.5480504035949707,
1.2147258520126343,
0.10900963097810745,
0.7239206433296204,
-0.16339372098445892,
0.9168716669082642,
0.27190491557121277,
0.4837057590484619,
-0.5914485454559326,
0.32656538486480713,
-0.017070090398192406,
-0.8964661955833435,
-0.18384802341461182,
-0.0962182879447937,
-0.7638187408447266,
0.3753829598426819,
-0.3415224552154541,
-0.5773318409919739,
0.49396395683288574,
0.6645780205726624,
-0.47298958897590637,
0.40501105785369873,
-0.7866622805595398,
0.3853198289871216,
-0.4932641386985779,
-0.5611734390258789,
-0.3206648528575897,
-0.43939435482025146,
0.32403865456581116,
-0.10935630649328232,
0.07008132338523865,
-0.1517176479101181,
0.1334722489118576,
0.424236923456192,
-0.9067652225494385,
0.6036888957023621,
-0.23031897842884064,
-0.062384821474552155,
0.9476574659347534,
-0.1698756217956543,
0.3686138987541199,
0.03950755298137665,
-0.03757906332612038,
-0.06508151441812515,
0.27548947930336,
-0.3567819595336914,
-0.836206316947937,
0.6969927549362183,
-0.5940582156181335,
-1.0992050170898438,
-0.6747521162033081,
-0.43632590770721436,
-0.08109386265277863,
-0.2416565865278244,
0.2411850541830063,
0.4446898102760315,
0.3872361183166504,
0.3265705704689026,
0.7689253687858582,
0.16834966838359833,
0.3865242600440979,
0.0031543683726340532,
-0.34590697288513184,
-0.5217826962471008,
0.4557773768901825,
0.11421322822570801,
0.8521273732185364,
0.09915638715028763,
0.16588881611824036,
-0.43192964792251587,
-0.6029233336448669,
-0.381818026304245,
0.017757661640644073,
-0.9594670534133911,
-0.20538876950740814,
-0.5156738758087158,
-0.13476629555225372,
-0.14162853360176086,
-0.2444758266210556,
-0.3760662078857422,
-0.7370273470878601,
-0.3372615873813629,
-0.531112551689148,
0.7761357426643372,
0.6044466495513916,
-0.21390525996685028,
0.21101497113704681,
-0.620524525642395,
0.4071081578731537,
0.4423563778400421,
0.11259860545396805,
0.3860035240650177,
-0.43682825565338135,
-0.3317106068134308,
0.6058604121208191,
-0.40905851125717163,
-0.7687664031982422,
0.07652848213911057,
-0.07451619952917099,
0.46374163031578064,
0.3095451295375824,
0.3545697033405304,
1.2042648792266846,
-0.2794599235057831,
0.8047345876693726,
0.37941601872444153,
-0.8819525241851807,
0.4510016143321991,
0.019409578293561935,
0.20352432131767273,
0.7741196155548096,
0.31853431463241577,
-0.048259396106004715,
-0.5570123791694641,
-0.4369731843471527,
-0.8862189054489136,
0.5154238939285278,
0.1465739905834198,
0.08975652605295181,
-0.5532802939414978,
0.6938005685806274,
0.115618996322155,
0.34699490666389465,
-0.3616591989994049,
-0.4692409932613373,
-0.009816331788897514,
0.022485490888357162,
0.2319287210702896,
-0.25298598408699036,
-0.18003326654434204,
-0.4882025718688965,
0.8345087766647339,
0.0059138513170182705,
0.06146691367030144,
0.6173429489135742,
0.029680507257580757,
-0.004222925752401352,
0.022178584709763527,
0.3342600464820862,
0.6391444802284241,
-0.1469239592552185,
0.46397605538368225,
0.45756280422210693,
-0.3141491413116455,
0.42013227939605713,
-0.42545390129089355,
0.21279124915599823,
-0.06306701898574829,
0.08499118685722351,
0.937190055847168,
-0.07812727242708206,
-0.5970836281776428,
0.07089065760374069,
-0.0775703489780426,
-0.2184196561574936,
-0.3385748565196991,
0.6336652636528015,
0.0018832968780770898,
0.5166950821876526,
0.7089381217956543,
0.26108431816101074,
0.3314628005027771,
-0.9527936577796936,
0.06131640076637268,
0.3519798219203949,
-0.29301682114601135,
-0.04237312451004982,
0.8710208535194397,
0.14746007323265076,
-0.24964451789855957,
0.6789821982383728,
0.18115539848804474,
-0.49833807349205017,
0.9181100130081177,
0.5509061813354492,
0.8214589953422546,
0.0945252925157547,
-0.07305070012807846,
0.44240015745162964,
-0.03962341696023941,
-0.3238450586795807,
0.20721466839313507,
-0.6190239787101746,
-0.47170621156692505,
-0.3903617858886719,
-0.6747121810913086,
-0.46347346901893616,
-0.19695352017879486,
-0.8800811171531677,
0.5902132987976074,
-0.4417232573032379,
-0.4630923271179199,
0.10513635724782944,
-0.41020068526268005,
-0.5802592635154724,
0.20357546210289001,
0.27885279059410095,
0.9155290126800537,
-0.7716714143753052,
0.9269737005233765,
0.3169209063053131,
-0.30263927578926086,
-0.9548497200012207,
-0.1810065656900406,
-0.23925361037254333,
-0.4260786175727844,
0.6146582961082458,
0.1477063149213791,
-0.2654995918273926,
0.009916887618601322,
-0.3768969774246216,
-0.9178457260131836,
1.294001579284668,
0.3163931667804718,
-0.8455113172531128,
0.015362478792667389,
0.26966479420661926,
0.8081727623939514,
-0.5753943920135498,
0.3004381060600281,
0.812610387802124,
0.24653586745262146,
0.7135428190231323,
-0.7527674436569214,
0.06380901485681534,
-0.1818021684885025,
0.15678738057613373,
0.4185345768928528,
-0.3500065505504608,
0.7704946994781494,
-0.501654863357544,
-0.07203896343708038,
0.13406647741794586,
0.47570985555648804,
0.6727186441421509,
0.7302207946777344,
0.4768957793712616,
0.4928933084011078,
0.9601000547409058,
-0.34740716218948364,
1.133727788925171,
-0.40180009603500366,
0.1301897168159485,
1.29629647731781,
-0.24417744576931,
0.5368277430534363,
1.0018651485443115,
-0.2025289535522461,
0.5700098276138306,
0.6404480934143066,
0.24804000556468964,
0.8672605156898499,
0.299161821603775,
-0.6248819231987,
-0.22427432239055634,
0.0036762363743036985,
-0.39527401328086853,
0.05141393095254898,
0.5242189764976501,
-0.6556840538978577,
0.06396754831075668,
0.27918726205825806,
-0.15867526829242706,
0.10443930327892303,
-0.384333997964859,
0.8779546618461609,
0.2874778211116791,
-1.111605167388916,
1.0390293598175049,
-0.5483824014663696,
0.3944796025753021,
-0.37189823389053345,
-0.20710235834121704,
0.018127186223864555,
0.26774170994758606,
-0.12576445937156677,
-0.48349422216415405,
0.4617280662059784,
0.1695977747440338,
-0.13208748400211334,
-0.2127404510974884,
0.4361659586429596,
-0.5438735485076904,
-0.3147282302379608,
0.17473626136779785,
0.17285467684268951,
0.19160644710063934,
0.23571425676345825,
-0.30943775177001953,
-0.007631780579686165,
0.11039987206459045,
-0.3037749230861664,
0.2283548265695572,
0.7559933066368103,
0.12941423058509827,
0.40282198786735535,
0.9573007822036743,
0.03842512145638466,
0.2965346574783325,
0.07062343508005142,
1.2813738584518433,
-0.49844732880592346,
-0.20432429015636444,
-1.142160415649414,
0.6885350942611694,
-0.1614180952310562,
-0.2619810402393341,
0.5296240448951721,
0.7647951245307922,
0.8935683369636536,
-0.03342590108513832,
0.7600425481796265,
0.12695391476154327,
0.13324566185474396,
-0.7202159762382507,
0.3839864730834961,
-0.2905362844467163,
0.7465164065361023,
-0.03462029621005058,
-1.037729263305664,
0.09462837874889374,
0.4781101942062378,
-0.4314589202404022,
-0.12447044998407364,
0.99641352891922,
0.590646505355835,
0.3417080044746399,
0.2681235074996948,
0.2768300771713257,
0.11767023056745529,
0.43935921788215637,
0.3042081594467163,
1.1036654710769653,
-0.2449636161327362,
0.2168225347995758,
-0.5218610763549805,
-0.20054370164871216,
0.07224162667989731,
-0.8070148229598999,
-1.128098726272583,
-0.5853739976882935,
-0.38705623149871826,
-0.5705928802490234,
0.22631286084651947,
1.2253398895263672,
0.2443680465221405,
-0.7971843481063843,
-0.024854132905602455,
-0.5371189713478088,
0.15938153862953186,
-0.17826513946056366,
-0.15338577330112457,
0.0898013710975647,
-0.579944372177124,
-0.8693099617958069,
0.1040148213505745,
0.1271030157804489,
0.40584275126457214,
0.06314169615507126,
0.002822651993483305,
-0.4837406575679779,
0.29954174160957336,
0.36634522676467896,
0.036903444677591324,
-0.6294426321983337,
-0.2841644287109375,
0.00007028008985798806,
0.2612110376358032,
0.022923680022358894,
1.0024197101593018,
-1.079021692276001,
0.6342958211898804,
0.5968253016471863,
0.26232823729515076,
0.848608672618866,
0.29367202520370483,
0.6047518253326416,
-0.4803202748298645,
0.3889617621898651,
0.1883533000946045,
0.43610477447509766,
0.014906256459653378,
-0.5280695557594299,
0.6388229727745056,
0.15819308161735535,
-0.5101101994514465,
-1.1758232116699219,
0.11489031463861465,
-0.8138160705566406,
-0.44002804160118103,
0.9498132467269897,
-0.191822811961174,
-0.38365811109542847,
-0.15315255522727966,
-0.5929139852523804,
0.5616611838340759,
-0.22403986752033234,
1.1915570497512817,
0.9605653285980225,
-0.5472517013549805,
0.13790234923362732,
-0.09587486833333969,
0.4266548454761505,
0.35012131929397583,
-0.36382970213890076,
0.17667463421821594,
0.44489020109176636,
0.20179839432239532,
0.3270030915737152,
0.49561113119125366,
-0.1495288908481598,
0.3932468593120575,
0.18995191156864166,
-0.4568060040473938,
-0.3377015292644501,
-0.4194828271865845,
-0.20668038725852966,
0.10330737382173538,
0.39731818437576294,
-0.2999230921268463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14508v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14508v1 | Evidence of a log scaling law for political persuasion with large language models | 2024-06-20T17:12:38 | 2024-06-20T17:12:38 | Kobi Hackenburg, Ben M. Tappin, Paul Röttger, Scott Hale, Jonathan Bright, Helen Margetts | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC | Large language models can now generate political messages as persuasive as
those written by humans, raising concerns about how far this persuasiveness may
continue to increase with model size. Here, we generate 720 persuasive messages
on 10 U.S. political issues from 24 language models spanning several orders of
magnitude in size. We then deploy these messages in a large-scale randomized
survey experiment (N = 25,982) to estimate the persuasive capability of each
model. Our findings are twofold. First, we find evidence of a log scaling law:
model persuasiveness is characterized by sharply diminishing returns, such that
current frontier models are barely more persuasive than models smaller in size
by an order of magnitude or more. Second, mere task completion (coherence,
staying on topic) appears to account for larger models' persuasive advantage.
These findings suggest that further scaling model size will not much increase
the persuasiveness of static LLM-generated messages. | [
-0.04659045487642288,
-0.8263028264045715,
0.7531259655952454,
0.257662832736969,
-0.31523096561431885,
-0.17966650426387787,
-0.4653071165084839,
0.12230809777975082,
0.3345029652118683,
0.6468076109886169,
-0.3623338043689728,
-0.47551509737968445,
-0.5891948342323303,
-0.15315492451190948,
-0.553352952003479,
1.1280298233032227,
0.5479353666305542,
0.03560488298535347,
-0.20096205174922943,
0.23687945306301117,
-0.2285439521074295,
-1.0251243114471436,
-0.4792780876159668,
-0.4874146580696106,
0.7562355995178223,
0.5960878729820251,
0.7456616163253784,
0.7951073050498962,
0.4498894214630127,
0.21553108096122742,
-0.30493754148483276,
-0.3577520251274109,
-0.8043034672737122,
0.09568136930465698,
-0.1179351732134819,
-0.9819363355636597,
-0.31966474652290344,
0.22510051727294922,
0.9072128534317017,
0.5227875709533691,
-0.25574326515197754,
0.09887679666280746,
0.01520064938813448,
0.5950856804847717,
-0.5243446826934814,
-0.15346013009548187,
-1.0633786916732788,
-0.21102453768253326,
-0.25053465366363525,
-0.10095268487930298,
-0.7432191371917725,
-0.23217515647411346,
0.11627514660358429,
-0.3494800329208374,
0.11973685026168823,
0.1850934475660324,
0.8138232231140137,
-0.1901220977306366,
-0.8881710767745972,
-0.47277751564979553,
-0.6838527321815491,
0.8061271905899048,
-1.0284771919250488,
0.055959850549697876,
0.44367852807044983,
-0.06296557188034058,
-0.1201397255063057,
-0.5594729781150818,
-0.5610617995262146,
-0.5313873291015625,
-0.03247293084859848,
-0.35712212324142456,
-0.41811153292655945,
0.04972640797495842,
0.523485541343689,
0.19769741594791412,
-0.36175698041915894,
0.530105710029602,
-0.05563749000430107,
-0.21366539597511292,
0.8420615792274475,
0.4105139374732971,
0.22252176702022552,
-0.35245653986930847,
-0.20159506797790527,
-0.46941766142845154,
-0.8636685609817505,
0.1065489649772644,
0.6486817002296448,
0.34779733419418335,
-0.20857912302017212,
0.677781343460083,
-0.09978174418210983,
0.4884107708930969,
0.38633057475090027,
-0.19207927584648132,
-0.36430075764656067,
-0.334725022315979,
-0.21268393099308014,
0.05561961233615875,
0.9843898415565491,
0.45778822898864746,
0.08645571023225784,
0.2671346068382263,
-0.22556845843791962,
0.03538546711206436,
-0.05124250799417496,
-0.9351091384887695,
-0.3841727077960968,
0.04827796295285225,
-0.728274941444397,
-0.47488877177238464,
0.0028341873548924923,
-0.8349915146827698,
-1.0178710222244263,
0.027877677232027054,
0.3347148299217224,
0.07911761850118637,
-0.7056823968887329,
0.34497761726379395,
-0.10582904517650604,
-0.013868815265595913,
0.1842818409204483,
-1.1346864700317383,
0.10446842014789581,
1.0037145614624023,
0.7240921258926392,
0.05478651076555252,
0.2048111855983734,
-0.5707431435585022,
-0.19556204974651337,
-0.764519453048706,
0.7245314121246338,
-0.7321904301643372,
-0.2699400782585144,
0.1409638673067093,
-0.015439312905073166,
0.16952703893184662,
-0.5782313942909241,
0.4615069329738617,
-0.3710060715675354,
0.1412723809480667,
-0.4759252667427063,
-0.4522191286087036,
-0.06742101162672043,
0.3504255414009094,
-0.6033095717430115,
0.4824007749557495,
-0.4230426549911499,
-0.6089595556259155,
0.5625022649765015,
-0.6525610089302063,
-0.40426260232925415,
-0.15809549391269684,
-0.3525087535381317,
-0.4722543954849243,
0.4108358323574066,
-0.24308180809020996,
0.7227046489715576,
-0.5095801949501038,
0.5783624053001404,
-0.24129995703697205,
0.14534874260425568,
0.5246943831443787,
-0.7009188532829285,
0.738187849521637,
0.27841997146606445,
-0.520424485206604,
0.30294182896614075,
-0.6474791169166565,
-0.37043383717536926,
0.14596471190452576,
-0.4975438117980957,
-0.4718726575374603,
0.25400209426879883,
-0.2055518627166748,
0.06827368587255478,
0.46955767273902893,
-0.7323487401008606,
0.16517724096775055,
0.07824298739433289,
0.32937824726104736,
0.7888250946998596,
0.14633123576641083,
0.4087696671485901,
-0.31380316615104675,
0.4340503215789795,
-0.14695562422275543,
-0.18078607320785522,
-0.10376109927892685,
-0.5827091932296753,
-0.6202414631843567,
-0.2475033700466156,
0.11417162418365479,
0.3083230257034302,
-0.020408207550644875,
0.12922152876853943,
-0.48643338680267334,
-0.4947648048400879,
0.09142894297838211,
-0.0962882786989212,
0.2554290294647217,
0.10940569639205933,
-0.2326071858406067,
0.25810229778289795,
-0.4145262539386749,
-1.1154612302780151,
-0.5049521923065186,
-0.46663644909858704,
-0.38984400033950806,
0.282653272151947,
0.5510910153388977,
0.16779585182666779,
0.656216025352478,
-0.47458285093307495,
0.1904955953359604,
-0.05962301045656204,
0.4034251272678375,
0.3557612895965576,
0.28667959570884705,
0.29514279961586,
-0.8788884878158569,
-0.5054715871810913,
0.15712781250476837,
-0.5322794914245605,
-0.2318507730960846,
-0.441612184047699,
0.19085106253623962,
0.07586126774549484,
0.49393704533576965,
-0.5456428527832031,
0.23905399441719055,
0.6116141676902771,
-0.6076852679252625,
0.5570117831230164,
-0.23340199887752533,
0.23144522309303284,
-0.9381430149078369,
-0.3178917169570923,
0.2286520153284073,
-0.16409820318222046,
-0.915600061416626,
-0.07194061577320099,
-0.09212138503789902,
0.07692798972129822,
-0.24965886771678925,
0.20948761701583862,
-0.20993541181087494,
0.4859309494495392,
-0.4781098961830139,
-0.06306809931993484,
-0.18699896335601807,
-0.02875043824315071,
0.10881365090608597,
0.356880784034729,
0.40109655261039734,
-0.6547027230262756,
0.3589382469654083,
-0.280603289604187,
-0.2602517306804657,
0.5715939998626709,
-0.6806116700172424,
-0.016444964334368706,
-0.16401028633117676,
0.40102988481521606,
-1.4492460489273071,
-0.520122766494751,
-0.265048086643219,
-0.11893223971128464,
0.10023197531700134,
-0.12863415479660034,
-0.5023514628410339,
-0.34733352065086365,
-0.11089654266834259,
-0.15271855890750885,
0.7212136387825012,
-0.5437628626823425,
0.5926591157913208,
0.3080522418022156,
0.05713440105319023,
-0.013383953832089901,
-0.634804368019104,
0.1504283994436264,
-0.7452663779258728,
-0.5550867319107056,
-0.18381758034229279,
0.05706313997507095,
-0.7385994791984558,
-0.42784392833709717,
-0.10646431148052216,
0.24334537982940674,
-0.12349604070186615,
0.37859082221984863,
0.0010056610917672515,
-0.37623512744903564,
0.40370431542396545,
-0.2635841965675354,
0.31249040365219116,
0.504567563533783,
-0.16620947420597076,
0.6898643374443054,
-0.147027850151062,
-0.13179951906204224,
-0.682316780090332,
0.30011042952537537,
0.8641270399093628,
0.21602176129817963,
0.7190097570419312,
0.0692971870303154,
-0.14870508015155792,
0.3511364459991455,
-0.8292197585105896,
-0.5514746308326721,
-0.49430468678474426,
0.5344682931900024,
-0.3824523091316223,
-0.9460919499397278,
0.3924175500869751,
-0.2942019999027252,
0.47606244683265686,
0.7752199769020081,
0.6296713948249817,
0.18934853374958038,
1.2386441230773926,
0.467484712600708,
-0.0575970821082592,
0.44034165143966675,
-0.029924288392066956,
0.1279749721288681,
-0.2700003683567047,
-0.22961212694644928,
-0.8927847743034363,
-0.29703688621520996,
-0.6958398222923279,
-0.398831844329834,
0.06733101606369019,
-0.12499825656414032,
-0.5829278826713562,
0.05400574579834938,
-0.7046014070510864,
0.35332348942756653,
0.38277408480644226,
-0.11392924934625626,
0.3116070032119751,
0.48091989755630493,
0.16771402955055237,
-0.27842092514038086,
-0.6909669637680054,
-0.6758360862731934,
1.246199369430542,
0.6078696846961975,
0.8312316536903381,
0.20950782299041748,
0.4998365640640259,
0.3861320912837982,
0.5986583232879639,
-0.45973658561706543,
0.8273959755897522,
-0.24058924615383148,
-0.995375394821167,
-0.6833034753799438,
-0.6186347603797913,
-0.9995135068893433,
0.25764623284339905,
-0.6076520681381226,
-0.7371784448623657,
0.2822764217853546,
0.18945680558681488,
-0.05188586562871933,
0.8537325263023376,
-0.4350540041923523,
0.5731648206710815,
-0.2691887319087982,
-0.24775923788547516,
-0.6950755715370178,
-0.3221076428890228,
0.2845345139503479,
-0.24648191034793854,
0.27119556069374084,
-0.3541809618473053,
-0.10142967104911804,
1.0600860118865967,
-0.48323315382003784,
1.1350531578063965,
-0.25607964396476746,
-0.6534639596939087,
0.2228398621082306,
-0.03097221441566944,
1.0077073574066162,
-0.016971580684185028,
-0.18574905395507812,
-0.07191793620586395,
-0.17537277936935425,
-0.5030663013458252,
-0.48313701152801514,
0.6776338815689087,
-0.5617204904556274,
-1.0736478567123413,
-0.10767033696174622,
-0.5275803208351135,
0.34867823123931885,
0.03447441756725311,
0.38828983902931213,
0.35256272554397583,
-0.3056693971157074,
0.8182012438774109,
0.8200144171714783,
-0.0005288207903504372,
0.2646247148513794,
0.5013238191604614,
-0.4159693717956543,
-0.2158525586128235,
1.0137885808944702,
0.1940964311361313,
0.6582533717155457,
0.44095921516418457,
0.7336588501930237,
-0.16580626368522644,
-0.3779429793357849,
0.01596486195921898,
0.3445151448249817,
-0.4547284245491028,
0.07052673399448395,
-0.603927731513977,
0.16622976958751678,
-0.30908727645874023,
-0.16788427531719208,
-0.4847909212112427,
-0.5024325251579285,
-0.17866922914981842,
0.10929841548204422,
0.49367544054985046,
1.2103105783462524,
0.019139720126986504,
0.48927515745162964,
-0.2708910405635834,
-0.06177021563053131,
0.5636162161827087,
0.0062790135852992535,
-0.05548841506242752,
-0.8014277219772339,
-0.09421231597661972,
0.3519665598869324,
-0.27845051884651184,
-0.7945998311042786,
0.10825852304697037,
-0.16996057331562042,
0.26999372243881226,
0.7847476005554199,
0.2840569019317627,
0.3949025571346283,
-0.4152030050754547,
1.1055833101272583,
0.6571030616760254,
-0.7490556240081787,
0.31102392077445984,
-0.5273016691207886,
0.2206772118806839,
0.01724717579782009,
0.5787804126739502,
-0.27998295426368713,
-0.6664677262306213,
-0.9024576544761658,
-0.5288591384887695,
0.15145988762378693,
-0.19343169033527374,
0.7697929739952087,
0.015407501719892025,
0.40208563208580017,
0.01583235338330269,
0.17867770791053772,
-0.9207407832145691,
-0.10783916711807251,
-0.16775499284267426,
0.133091539144516,
-0.169420063495636,
-0.5886607766151428,
-0.282412588596344,
-0.053901657462120056,
0.47275808453559875,
0.022858435288071632,
-0.07554108649492264,
-0.023305129259824753,
0.5022084712982178,
-0.2533568739891052,
0.38825806975364685,
1.0518147945404053,
0.5833719968795776,
-0.02706272155046463,
0.24442167580127716,
0.08132483810186386,
-0.4862744212150574,
0.46029967069625854,
-0.2589726448059082,
-0.22227904200553894,
-0.035926610231399536,
0.4368641972541809,
0.9521651864051819,
-0.281101793050766,
-0.3794384002685547,
0.28560155630111694,
0.021893011406064034,
-0.7698072195053101,
-0.08909757435321808,
-0.07664044946432114,
0.4976573884487152,
0.2555446922779083,
0.6957680583000183,
-0.3723393380641937,
-0.16231082379817963,
-0.5727131962776184,
-0.205128476023674,
0.8337512612342834,
-0.07778964191675186,
-0.4040505588054657,
0.9352360963821411,
0.19411446154117584,
-0.6230007410049438,
0.3626318871974945,
0.15237165987491608,
-0.2597096264362335,
0.5714424252510071,
0.6937326788902283,
0.37345996499061584,
-0.25881296396255493,
0.1999565064907074,
0.44142991304397583,
0.39473652839660645,
-0.28782224655151367,
-0.22392478585243225,
0.19419027864933014,
-0.27051711082458496,
-0.3703376054763794,
-0.1879468560218811,
-0.44172587990760803,
0.6319782733917236,
-0.3676844537258148,
-0.04485674202442169,
-0.6842023730278015,
-0.5740317106246948,
0.15668895840644836,
0.23869100213050842,
-0.1687052845954895,
0.2382100522518158,
0.042982980608940125,
0.6724131107330322,
-1.2529113292694092,
0.4354872703552246,
0.6325323581695557,
-0.07398154586553574,
-0.7153871059417725,
0.41854986548423767,
0.23025524616241455,
-0.2958664000034332,
0.6729466915130615,
0.025861706584692,
0.11162431538105011,
-0.3280940055847168,
-0.9851167798042297,
-0.8564777970314026,
0.8864279389381409,
0.5539364218711853,
-0.8273038864135742,
0.006745076272636652,
0.0782337486743927,
0.4441032409667969,
-0.781951904296875,
-0.20232945680618286,
0.3041923940181732,
0.5072561502456665,
0.13652774691581726,
-0.8260799050331116,
0.4521673023700714,
0.07744395732879639,
-0.05713286250829697,
0.14711585640907288,
-0.7659919857978821,
0.9132881164550781,
-0.2155291736125946,
-0.15068070590496063,
-0.09744390845298767,
1.0380029678344727,
0.24512940645217896,
0.21812374889850616,
0.9435485005378723,
0.11329267919063568,
1.0033650398254395,
0.16979558765888214,
1.2543200254440308,
-0.2340269237756729,
0.032877761870622635,
0.6401585936546326,
-0.30349186062812805,
0.8832951784133911,
0.48867788910865784,
-0.07375398278236389,
0.6467981934547424,
0.48918837308883667,
0.29601699113845825,
0.16107453405857086,
0.7460289597511292,
-0.532252311706543,
-0.564444363117218,
-0.30282068252563477,
-0.2396090030670166,
0.1588854044675827,
0.39297449588775635,
-0.31976503133773804,
0.10350188612937927,
0.06720361113548279,
0.5084368586540222,
0.4762229323387146,
-0.1352129578590393,
0.5905808806419373,
0.05115716531872749,
-0.741577684879303,
0.7717874050140381,
-0.15253369510173798,
0.6869115233421326,
-0.49950674176216125,
-0.03910247981548309,
-0.04024835675954819,
0.13383542001247406,
-0.14172740280628204,
-0.7267012596130371,
-0.1194806918501854,
0.03703168407082558,
-0.22017182409763336,
-0.25364950299263,
0.5491806268692017,
-0.4476527273654938,
-0.2799854576587677,
-0.08534300327301025,
0.09446395188570023,
0.4728753864765167,
0.03560755029320717,
-0.2306080162525177,
0.18931138515472412,
0.26382502913475037,
-0.6220500469207764,
0.47541818022727966,
0.6118996739387512,
-0.25991901755332947,
0.7042959928512573,
0.9455075860023499,
0.23201604187488556,
-0.0448349304497242,
-0.09820190072059631,
0.9263023734092712,
-0.3737950026988983,
-0.13458488881587982,
-1.1620103120803833,
0.4120488464832306,
-0.5368471741676331,
-0.049531541764736176,
1.0511512756347656,
0.7133836150169373,
0.32911381125450134,
-0.02877061627805233,
0.6446069478988647,
-0.00357203371822834,
0.2961992621421814,
-0.3556467890739441,
0.6955057978630066,
-0.5699751377105713,
0.31820055842399597,
-0.014939446933567524,
-0.6155486702919006,
-0.257882684469223,
0.5155686736106873,
-0.6365111470222473,
-0.0358453132212162,
0.5192033648490906,
0.8514354228973389,
0.08345303684473038,
-0.10857800394296646,
0.5674697756767273,
0.46857750415802,
0.513830840587616,
0.3611070513725281,
0.5984963774681091,
0.3100987374782562,
0.7146816849708557,
0.12281712889671326,
-0.32129770517349243,
-0.20754660665988922,
-1.0752924680709839,
-1.1668148040771484,
-0.5784262418746948,
-0.559202253818512,
-0.7239038944244385,
-0.13186512887477875,
0.7504999041557312,
0.7668203115463257,
-0.362662136554718,
-0.5564329028129578,
-0.17111095786094666,
0.04697786271572113,
0.10837744176387787,
-0.2126798927783966,
0.3740086853504181,
-0.00023206546029541641,
-0.6213470697402954,
0.049116164445877075,
0.1339898705482483,
-0.07233689725399017,
-0.5709580779075623,
0.024631820619106293,
-0.4856945872306824,
0.6376134753227234,
0.5030897855758667,
0.4241313636302948,
-0.9000629782676697,
-0.2369021326303482,
-0.1278436928987503,
-0.45530757308006287,
-0.02716859057545662,
1.0402438640594482,
-0.39246323704719543,
0.14961636066436768,
0.5744514465332031,
0.28906872868537903,
0.4822080135345459,
0.014475368894636631,
0.590080738067627,
-0.542056679725647,
0.12218058109283447,
-0.0838802233338356,
-0.02185206115245819,
0.3035954535007477,
-0.4568882882595062,
0.27736198902130127,
0.12240107357501984,
-0.7013975381851196,
-0.9546133875846863,
0.2881452441215515,
-0.4092310965061188,
-0.2597711682319641,
1.5453931093215942,
-0.15345381200313568,
-0.25193262100219727,
0.20259816944599152,
-0.34136074781417847,
-0.16832996904850006,
-0.5073271989822388,
0.5475682020187378,
0.9997420907020569,
0.003556614276021719,
-0.14232635498046875,
-0.6186311841011047,
0.38121497631073,
0.6328802704811096,
-0.6597866415977478,
0.6271219849586487,
0.5903583765029907,
0.3061205744743347,
0.44169360399246216,
0.8894461989402771,
0.17903003096580505,
0.16454924643039703,
0.2720782160758972,
-0.27029648423194885,
0.2902796268463135,
-0.12216473370790482,
-0.4276186227798462,
0.32898423075675964,
0.18342186510562897,
0.13434697687625885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14504v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14504v1 | Translating Across Cultures: LLMs for Intralingual Cultural Adaptation | 2024-06-20T17:06:58 | 2024-06-20T17:06:58 | Pushpdeep Singh, Mayur Patidar, Lovekesh Vig | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLMs are increasingly being deployed for multilingual applications and have
demonstrated impressive translation capabilities between several low and high
resource languages. An aspect of translation that often gets overlooked is that
of cultural adaptation, or modifying source culture references to suit the
target culture. Cultural adaptation has applications across several creative
industries and requires intimate knowledge of source and target cultures during
translation. While specialized translation models still outperform LLMs on the
machine translation task when viewed from the lens of correctness, they are not
sensitive to cultural differences often requiring manual correction. LLMs on
the other hand have a rich reservoir of cultural knowledge embedded within its
parameters that can be potentially exploited for such applications. In this
paper we define the task of cultural adaptation and create an evaluation
framework to benchmark different models for this task. We evaluate the
performance of modern LLMs for cultural adaptation and analyze their cross
cultural knowledge while connecting related concepts across different cultures.
We also analyze possible issues with automatic adaptation including cultural
biases and stereotypes. We hope that this task will offer more insight into the
cultural understanding of LLMs and their creativity in cross-cultural
scenarios. | [
-0.26462996006011963,
-0.06650019437074661,
0.37003251910209656,
0.5479307174682617,
-0.09447935223579407,
0.3995465934276581,
-0.5349000096321106,
-0.7805458903312683,
-0.07114189863204956,
0.3795769512653351,
-0.6267060041427612,
-0.4689176380634308,
-0.5738921165466309,
0.3249848783016205,
-0.09377212822437286,
0.793969988822937,
-0.5137857794761658,
0.49003538489341736,
-0.4697176218032837,
-0.5795477628707886,
-0.6241554021835327,
-0.4519880712032318,
-0.27927979826927185,
-0.4282189905643463,
0.010314181447029114,
0.4401673674583435,
0.346381276845932,
0.31627562642097473,
0.7936875224113464,
0.28498944640159607,
-0.014282832853496075,
0.35833272337913513,
-0.6736926436424255,
0.0799604281783104,
-0.6201567053794861,
-0.762366533279419,
-0.4128989279270172,
0.02969292737543583,
0.56843501329422,
0.5342658162117004,
0.29916295409202576,
0.6036658883094788,
0.1514461785554886,
0.47084152698516846,
-0.5242733955383301,
-0.02935878373682499,
-0.6216077208518982,
0.4687823951244354,
-0.05270952731370926,
-0.32324233651161194,
-0.1815640777349472,
-0.49001914262771606,
-0.03107481822371483,
-0.47723525762557983,
-0.11572203040122986,
0.05265034735202789,
0.1755894422531128,
0.34148332476615906,
-0.5776825547218323,
-0.5354365706443787,
-0.8713433742523193,
0.7353012561798096,
-0.3769962787628174,
0.33830854296684265,
0.14876927435398102,
0.2899898290634155,
-0.11222200095653534,
-0.633815586566925,
-0.2336711585521698,
-0.11327355355024338,
0.11604025214910507,
0.5018478035926819,
-0.12777920067310333,
-0.6036137938499451,
-0.09344223886728287,
0.3840489089488983,
-0.39502763748168945,
0.2773553431034088,
-0.3657679259777069,
-0.06530160456895828,
0.6483978629112244,
0.4273330867290497,
0.46761655807495117,
0.04262259602546692,
-0.5843679904937744,
-0.005238897632807493,
-0.5797586441040039,
0.1177196204662323,
0.14427965879440308,
0.027052856981754303,
-0.36287015676498413,
0.1630965620279312,
-0.1906404048204422,
0.3143896460533142,
-0.023137925192713737,
-0.3679482340812683,
0.25596415996551514,
-0.5185441970825195,
0.03204472362995148,
0.026872683316469193,
0.27023568749427795,
0.7258259654045105,
0.48073816299438477,
-0.23965974152088165,
-0.10247448086738586,
-0.290547251701355,
0.1638667732477188,
-0.556849479675293,
0.3180668354034424,
-0.21159909665584564,
-0.7034115195274353,
-0.04777649790048599,
-0.2562029957771301,
-0.36496594548225403,
-0.5796242356300354,
-0.25861796736717224,
0.23563389480113983,
-0.09089110791683197,
-0.2015451341867447,
-0.15854153037071228,
-0.10184129327535629,
0.2777957022190094,
0.368259459733963,
-0.6607997417449951,
0.078881174325943,
0.41451457142829895,
0.8777560591697693,
-0.6119881868362427,
-0.31262508034706116,
-0.04659009724855423,
0.2573084235191345,
-0.5095646977424622,
0.6142875552177429,
-0.2867949306964874,
-0.4996185600757599,
0.06166859716176987,
0.2612525522708893,
-0.04031314700841904,
-0.6514779329299927,
0.7974920868873596,
-0.4645686745643616,
0.18167702853679657,
-0.4923435151576996,
-0.21230489015579224,
-0.46635106205940247,
0.4413982033729553,
-0.3751266300678253,
0.685248076915741,
0.1542997807264328,
-0.3450543284416199,
0.4423469603061676,
-0.5441251993179321,
-0.39201819896698,
0.1720728725194931,
0.07783869653940201,
0.18377773463726044,
0.30938035249710083,
0.2687736749649048,
0.2262759506702423,
-0.6479336619377136,
-0.19752798974514008,
-0.4411006271839142,
-0.5999378561973572,
0.3720691502094269,
-0.18641763925552368,
0.8916271924972534,
0.4681045413017273,
0.05182573199272156,
0.2547912299633026,
-0.5070729851722717,
-0.09077958762645721,
0.15105374157428741,
-0.4669528603553772,
-0.27085867524147034,
-0.13770659267902374,
0.03312274441123009,
0.5238566398620605,
0.2560183107852936,
-0.19683049619197845,
0.10547815263271332,
0.02772979810833931,
0.45597603917121887,
0.7470586895942688,
-0.23227420449256897,
0.7539213299751282,
-0.4405968189239502,
0.9119225144386292,
0.23629002273082733,
0.22482620179653168,
-0.0642988383769989,
-0.16629356145858765,
-0.6500771045684814,
-0.09050489962100983,
0.0518869049847126,
0.9555490612983704,
-0.9343816637992859,
-0.03954153507947922,
-0.42201825976371765,
-0.5998673439025879,
-0.6695381999015808,
0.6967150568962097,
0.1340743601322174,
0.35072121024131775,
0.10669924318790436,
-0.7654755115509033,
-0.3466559648513794,
-0.5603438019752502,
-0.5389014482498169,
-0.07384466379880905,
-0.11342022567987442,
0.17343823611736298,
0.3539409935474396,
-0.23172037303447723,
0.4159676432609558,
-0.0523628294467926,
-0.620943009853363,
-0.2667633295059204,
-0.19807054102420807,
0.3523036539554596,
0.3961676061153412,
0.7299310564994812,
-0.5563104152679443,
-0.6050900220870972,
0.34046971797943115,
-1.0275318622589111,
-0.31042739748954773,
-0.19673402607440948,
-0.27496030926704407,
0.3456672132015228,
0.6852116584777832,
-0.052768293768167496,
0.0853840559720993,
0.7462753057479858,
-0.05338640511035919,
0.3899761140346527,
-0.34826773405075073,
0.3801090717315674,
-1.0752485990524292,
-0.12667229771614075,
-0.00026726420037448406,
-0.09850973635911942,
-0.5266767144203186,
0.1531292349100113,
0.20530949532985687,
0.04060957953333855,
-0.6916143298149109,
0.5845167636871338,
-0.6780034899711609,
-0.38816818594932556,
-0.11457887291908264,
0.13991567492485046,
-0.03337130323052406,
0.1628858596086502,
0.21540871262550354,
0.7799491882324219,
0.32119113206863403,
-0.3116510212421417,
0.5673654675483704,
0.11471207439899445,
-0.6569739580154419,
1.051218032836914,
-0.07957208156585693,
0.3600561320781708,
-0.05831063166260719,
0.2563650906085968,
-0.7403477430343628,
0.2006055861711502,
0.3560165762901306,
-0.08625785261392593,
-0.07945918291807175,
-0.16913416981697083,
-0.5942728519439697,
-0.1593971848487854,
-0.05849546939134598,
0.5702351331710815,
0.49607357382774353,
-0.48071596026420593,
0.5235711932182312,
0.017576411366462708,
-0.24519111216068268,
-0.3672318160533905,
-0.87921541929245,
0.28220078349113464,
-0.7101320028305054,
-0.8120428323745728,
0.3273334503173828,
-0.3119145929813385,
-0.40072235465049744,
-0.07686797529459,
0.0468464232981205,
0.18486876785755157,
0.24174350500106812,
-0.013602192513644695,
-0.0109145138412714,
-0.5288527607917786,
0.029157577082514763,
-0.15285243093967438,
0.15514329075813293,
0.07363741844892502,
-0.4268410801887512,
0.08446512371301651,
-0.21000061929225922,
-0.45182737708091736,
-0.05065854266285896,
0.41921746730804443,
0.6359480023384094,
-0.27801021933555603,
0.5137424468994141,
1.0353679656982422,
-0.2380274534225464,
-0.11243089288473129,
-0.503531277179718,
0.17159858345985413,
-0.3946254551410675,
0.5586257576942444,
-0.7783592343330383,
-0.40484878420829773,
0.8820226788520813,
-0.44052621722221375,
-0.27320319414138794,
0.2601419687271118,
0.7741992473602295,
-0.2726185619831085,
0.5459564328193665,
0.7959310412406921,
-0.061105579137802124,
0.46704113483428955,
0.08287055045366287,
0.11682192236185074,
-0.7676828503608704,
-0.16093315184116364,
-0.3032492697238922,
-0.5667617321014404,
-0.8982488512992859,
-0.7791274189949036,
0.5789517760276794,
0.25660085678100586,
0.10919130593538284,
0.11542405933141708,
-0.03822269290685654,
0.4005787670612335,
0.39930427074432373,
-0.22167283296585083,
0.6030312776565552,
-0.023449556902050972,
-0.17441165447235107,
-0.1552095115184784,
-0.8113470673561096,
-0.43352010846138,
0.8901692628860474,
0.37530097365379333,
0.8493988513946533,
0.4748412072658539,
0.21815122663974762,
0.41880807280540466,
0.6614526510238647,
-0.6730309128761292,
0.32380154728889465,
-0.49985575675964355,
-0.41458743810653687,
0.06632651388645172,
-0.036867424845695496,
-0.29601967334747314,
0.4922444224357605,
-0.24115833640098572,
-0.5723440051078796,
0.2281333953142166,
-0.22690743207931519,
0.05689182132482529,
0.2055271416902542,
-0.6267734169960022,
0.7339848875999451,
-0.6733790636062622,
-0.372944712638855,
-0.2872747778892517,
-0.46756675839424133,
0.36193621158599854,
-0.5132616758346558,
0.4259342551231384,
-0.19588489830493927,
0.015973424538969994,
0.3209306299686432,
0.6091561913490295,
0.7641595602035522,
0.2203042358160019,
-0.28706294298171997,
-0.10562919825315475,
0.3129541873931885,
0.11267933249473572,
-0.1108146458864212,
-0.5213239789009094,
0.44253838062286377,
0.2884211838245392,
-0.2503899931907654,
-0.44278770685195923,
0.5622056722640991,
-0.8447921276092529,
-0.7619302272796631,
-0.20141156017780304,
-1.1730597019195557,
-0.38047003746032715,
0.009671401232481003,
0.05189179256558418,
-0.19514240324497223,
-0.4209800362586975,
0.12689433991909027,
0.20930103957653046,
-0.47210875153541565,
0.34811604022979736,
0.6431986093521118,
-0.18700891733169556,
-0.3162694573402405,
0.5811684131622314,
0.1056913509964943,
0.5015541911125183,
0.2959982454776764,
-0.057895634323358536,
-0.2173168659210205,
-0.5941242575645447,
-0.903351902961731,
-0.02025473304092884,
-1.3206924200057983,
0.14754824340343475,
-0.06265176087617874,
-0.07368118315935135,
-0.564167857170105,
-0.35183078050613403,
0.025881528854370117,
-0.3050796091556549,
-0.3737330734729767,
0.08118122816085815,
0.1117400974035263,
0.6734780073165894,
-0.20573483407497406,
0.060094114392995834,
-0.8538579940795898,
0.02681492269039154,
-0.13860487937927246,
0.1636732965707779,
-0.3037837743759155,
-0.8052875995635986,
-0.5700127482414246,
-0.25803372263908386,
-0.3587280213832855,
-0.8206747770309448,
0.34792718291282654,
0.3451707065105438,
0.8988522887229919,
0.22018010914325714,
0.015030884183943272,
0.9254228472709656,
-0.40684959292411804,
0.6134647727012634,
0.00460423156619072,
-0.9395463466644287,
0.21297653019428253,
0.0382891483604908,
0.6461479067802429,
0.40674251317977905,
0.6661834716796875,
-0.9825088381767273,
-0.20157967507839203,
-0.014207205735147,
-0.5390137434005737,
0.5243010520935059,
-0.3047925531864166,
0.3389790654182434,
0.40876832604408264,
0.19605253636837006,
0.26578518748283386,
-0.005731644574552774,
-0.731191098690033,
0.17848259210586548,
-0.17183265089988708,
-0.06946850568056107,
-0.2883843183517456,
-0.061841532588005066,
-0.3160618245601654,
-0.2968529462814331,
0.4544951319694519,
-0.3366108536720276,
-0.06457366049289703,
0.01498305145651102,
-0.7610546946525574,
-0.25061577558517456,
0.1966962367296219,
0.6285737156867981,
0.9952921271324158,
-0.08603829145431519,
-0.027712224051356316,
0.8295409679412842,
-0.13687735795974731,
0.14140662550926208,
-0.21533367037773132,
0.03523828089237213,
-0.36784619092941284,
0.5889279246330261,
0.7090331315994263,
-0.09388286620378494,
-0.5103822946548462,
0.029802951961755753,
-0.04396115615963936,
0.21013569831848145,
-0.4309045076370239,
-0.009761101566255093,
0.28310006856918335,
0.583139955997467,
0.34979262948036194,
-0.14896129071712494,
0.01448838785290718,
-0.9351180195808411,
-0.15537850558757782,
0.3065667748451233,
-0.5855386853218079,
-0.23902127146720886,
0.445484459400177,
0.4176139533519745,
-0.23298275470733643,
0.39712217450141907,
0.06107610836625099,
-0.5220896005630493,
0.4061865210533142,
0.713049590587616,
0.880419135093689,
-0.3122134804725647,
-0.14168989658355713,
0.04028669372200966,
0.5730898380279541,
0.32428860664367676,
0.14628353714942932,
-0.07714332640171051,
-0.9082600474357605,
-0.38318660855293274,
-0.5669031143188477,
-0.47902894020080566,
-0.3262183666229248,
-0.6337981224060059,
0.2344934642314911,
0.0036423085257411003,
-0.04098544642329216,
-0.5101021528244019,
-0.048243071883916855,
-0.9828644394874573,
0.18514800071716309,
0.3271389305591583,
1.1698721647262573,
-1.0839093923568726,
0.9563360810279846,
1.0008456707000732,
-0.10698651522397995,
-0.014657746069133282,
0.09441492706537247,
0.08880273997783661,
-0.9707502126693726,
0.9558215737342834,
-0.22167402505874634,
-0.24732738733291626,
-0.14501479268074036,
0.016631441190838814,
-0.8378435969352722,
1.2073301076889038,
0.5483152270317078,
-0.3144286870956421,
0.2875863015651703,
0.5092024207115173,
0.7412419319152832,
-0.740245521068573,
0.28202858567237854,
0.5719668865203857,
0.5138129591941833,
-0.058256231248378754,
-1.1761143207550049,
0.04912152886390686,
-0.20216286182403564,
0.33852389454841614,
-0.4367319345474243,
-0.5972949266433716,
0.5199530720710754,
-0.18181204795837402,
0.08588077127933502,
0.11485981196165085,
0.6973865032196045,
0.15043392777442932,
0.2646403908729553,
0.49614959955215454,
0.06474603712558746,
0.5449228882789612,
-0.05370655283331871,
0.780858039855957,
-0.4543777406215668,
-0.09298387169837952,
0.9642281532287598,
-0.5047481060028076,
0.614605188369751,
0.6555178761482239,
-0.05134701728820801,
0.38136589527130127,
0.8284618854522705,
-0.06682126224040985,
0.5103685855865479,
0.37113338708877563,
-0.12789303064346313,
-0.2289734035730362,
-0.5215849876403809,
-0.5379552841186523,
0.8271247744560242,
0.4826608896255493,
-0.5442430973052979,
-0.014209301210939884,
0.12825284898281097,
-0.1430894285440445,
0.21384015679359436,
-0.3381464183330536,
0.7839164733886719,
0.32143980264663696,
-0.7315353751182556,
0.5197896957397461,
0.16538217663764954,
0.6474424600601196,
-0.385888010263443,
0.21785929799079895,
-0.5197385549545288,
0.3519619107246399,
-0.150953471660614,
-0.7994712591171265,
0.37215378880500793,
-0.07673904299736023,
-0.20753495395183563,
-0.6746901869773865,
0.7494531273841858,
-0.3374447524547577,
-0.738676130771637,
0.6844865083694458,
0.7620270848274231,
0.28251221776008606,
0.285225510597229,
-0.67572021484375,
0.34691163897514343,
-0.014408585615456104,
-0.010481207631528378,
0.3818894326686859,
0.5088183879852295,
-0.4868573248386383,
0.7255871891975403,
0.5248119831085205,
0.21976393461227417,
0.023119356483221054,
0.12373597919940948,
0.23474928736686707,
-0.6212555766105652,
-0.47625118494033813,
-0.5311339497566223,
0.36583220958709717,
0.18885286152362823,
-0.34168264269828796,
0.9043321013450623,
0.13461926579475403,
1.1799272298812866,
-0.3168570399284363,
0.7487012147903442,
0.16880013048648834,
-0.05502411723136902,
-0.5340490341186523,
0.8360262513160706,
-0.7843242287635803,
0.16447047889232635,
-0.15939700603485107,
-1.014359474182129,
-0.05541239678859711,
0.28545746207237244,
-0.42994430661201477,
-0.047865670174360275,
0.6454552412033081,
0.5922487378120422,
-0.06272518634796143,
0.05736250802874565,
0.3723388612270355,
0.15290647745132446,
0.11276664584875107,
0.6100066304206848,
1.1456271409988403,
-0.1342962235212326,
0.6371360421180725,
-0.36691999435424805,
-0.08622527867555618,
-0.08963430672883987,
-1.404406189918518,
-0.41853219270706177,
-0.5240876078605652,
-0.26768332719802856,
-0.036187462508678436,
0.057572536170482635,
0.9602099657058716,
0.7972890138626099,
-0.7461387515068054,
-0.7223419547080994,
0.8496043682098389,
0.1707616001367569,
-0.5981084704399109,
-0.13864344358444214,
-0.050683293491601944,
-0.10294521600008011,
-0.9852283000946045,
0.6209607124328613,
0.3306386470794678,
-0.02046867273747921,
-0.4882507026195526,
-0.15096430480480194,
0.1590934842824936,
0.026362143456935883,
0.7614466547966003,
-0.058643218129873276,
-0.7342285513877869,
-0.2138213962316513,
-0.08796565979719162,
-0.023359553888440132,
0.05094701796770096,
0.7101195454597473,
-0.4825911223888397,
0.4504699110984802,
0.6221924424171448,
0.7381570339202881,
0.5593035221099854,
-0.2566791772842407,
0.7515813112258911,
-0.5070856213569641,
0.2573337256908417,
0.09741734713315964,
0.36312082409858704,
0.5890246629714966,
-0.2125963419675827,
0.670884907245636,
0.2311655730009079,
-0.32825207710266113,
-0.730338990688324,
0.24816015362739563,
-0.7261427044868469,
-0.2631267011165619,
1.0907825231552124,
-0.422325074672699,
0.1559848189353943,
0.04849997162818909,
0.13357865810394287,
0.28379151225090027,
0.2681906223297119,
0.6985029578208923,
1.0123227834701538,
0.03903334587812424,
-0.0541691891849041,
-0.9474701881408691,
0.08315316587686539,
0.5487980842590332,
-0.716499388217926,
-0.37685564160346985,
0.15719814598560333,
0.6050634980201721,
0.016024690121412277,
0.49961793422698975,
-0.10559455305337906,
0.2211613953113556,
-0.5466991066932678,
0.1719573587179184,
0.2743275463581085,
-0.005828350316733122,
-0.5115845799446106,
0.007996375672519207,
0.30525949597358704,
-0.043897587805986404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14503v1 | Overview of the CAIL 2023 Argument Mining Track | 2024-06-20T17:06:13 | 2024-06-20T17:06:13 | Jingcong Liang, Junlong Wang, Xinyu Zhai, Yungui Zhuang, Yiyang Zheng, Xin Xu, Xiandong Ran, Xiaozheng Dong, Honghui Rong, Yanlun Liu, Hao Chen, Yuhan Wei, Donghai Li, Jiajie Peng, Xuanjing Huang, Chongde Shi, Yansong Feng, Yun Song, Zhongyu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | We give a detailed overview of the CAIL 2023 Argument Mining Track, one of
the Chinese AI and Law Challenge (CAIL) 2023 tracks. The main goal of the track
is to identify and extract interacting argument pairs in trial dialogs. It
mainly uses summarized judgment documents but can also refer to trial
recordings. The track consists of two stages, and we introduce the tasks
designed for each stage; we also extend the data from previous events into a
new dataset -- CAIL2023-ArgMine -- with annotated new cases from various causes
of action. We outline several submissions that achieve the best results,
including their methods for different stages. While all submissions rely on
language models, they have incorporated strategies that may benefit future work
in this field. | [
-0.3206848204135895,
-0.6948484778404236,
0.6564654111862183,
0.22096505761146545,
-0.2433171421289444,
-0.15424296259880066,
0.22776642441749573,
-0.5279183983802795,
-0.2277340143918991,
0.7111724019050598,
-0.5248010754585266,
-0.5652174949645996,
-0.3854769468307495,
-0.34759703278541565,
-0.4766346514225006,
1.5644079446792603,
-0.1386253982782364,
0.40337321162223816,
-0.04637957736849785,
-0.3149789571762085,
-0.6085168719291687,
-0.5754554271697998,
-1.2016948461532593,
-0.3295096457004547,
0.78669273853302,
0.31903448700904846,
0.3599936068058014,
0.7788839936256409,
0.2531348168849945,
0.2730768024921417,
-0.16592732071876526,
-0.24718409776687622,
-0.09797655045986176,
0.025091763585805893,
0.03783063963055611,
-0.43014803528785706,
-0.5092368721961975,
0.20367853343486786,
0.4847579002380371,
0.48809558153152466,
-0.2858433425426483,
0.025041019544005394,
-0.10530062019824982,
0.21233978867530823,
-0.42923977971076965,
0.14667095243930817,
-0.47551602125167847,
0.06964734941720963,
-0.4648817479610443,
-0.00427745096385479,
-0.4380894899368286,
-0.07206743210554123,
0.17528940737247467,
-0.4758685827255249,
0.27451080083847046,
0.33827832341194153,
0.9642857313156128,
-0.060280878096818924,
-0.49228301644325256,
-0.6760925650596619,
-0.3118760287761688,
0.6742238402366638,
-0.9576534628868103,
-0.14650458097457886,
0.16201207041740417,
0.31186044216156006,
-0.30716943740844727,
-1.1220594644546509,
-0.31876692175865173,
-0.372500479221344,
-0.1379442662000656,
0.1735498160123825,
-0.06202135607600212,
0.4982888996601105,
0.24895411729812622,
0.36510539054870605,
-0.38793548941612244,
-0.040429532527923584,
-0.43636536598205566,
-0.44076234102249146,
1.0378828048706055,
0.20881040394306183,
0.3466465175151825,
-0.06781458854675293,
-0.43089622259140015,
-0.060819558799266815,
-0.6100450754165649,
0.1743655949831009,
0.6745565533638,
0.12295663356781006,
-0.17784254252910614,
0.3329789638519287,
-0.06369562447071075,
0.6695973873138428,
-0.055106863379478455,
0.25134551525115967,
-0.14600630104541779,
-0.3616945147514343,
-0.12849411368370056,
0.3273928761482239,
1.1447522640228271,
0.17336782813072205,
-0.16896416246891022,
0.05549154803156853,
-0.27995020151138306,
-0.3843155801296234,
-0.06409626454114914,
-0.45382994413375854,
-0.6189401745796204,
0.4714609384536743,
-0.7750157117843628,
-0.2769853472709656,
-0.00508925411850214,
-0.8945688605308533,
-0.8374855518341064,
-0.1181093081831932,
0.38653564453125,
-0.04117198660969734,
-0.1291983276605606,
0.08100168406963348,
-0.3866916298866272,
0.46964555978775024,
0.42872726917266846,
-0.7012511491775513,
0.4935615062713623,
1.02944016456604,
0.75136399269104,
-0.024225424975156784,
-0.00915181078016758,
-1.264932632446289,
-0.039249785244464874,
-0.3580888509750366,
1.0785658359527588,
-0.5219218134880066,
-0.417093425989151,
0.22653721272945404,
-0.0421929731965065,
-0.056241877377033234,
-0.5878809094429016,
1.2042256593704224,
-0.38184088468551636,
0.39717021584510803,
-0.5168712735176086,
-0.5296940207481384,
-0.3338952362537384,
0.2662300765514374,
-0.9335573315620422,
0.8669071793556213,
-0.2980192303657532,
-0.5545848608016968,
0.49513983726501465,
-1.2314732074737549,
-0.4779954254627228,
0.30551379919052124,
-0.21828477084636688,
-0.41792428493499756,
-0.2085033655166626,
0.018124952912330627,
0.18470832705497742,
-0.4107566475868225,
0.5426720976829529,
-0.34330418705940247,
-0.06572958081960678,
-0.2805139422416687,
-0.2978816628456116,
1.101550579071045,
0.5323659777641296,
-0.4308924376964569,
0.21307043731212616,
-0.6238325238227844,
-0.41813766956329346,
-0.003594884416088462,
-0.34375280141830444,
0.12915921211242676,
0.5150793194770813,
0.13129131495952606,
0.412362664937973,
0.4519316852092743,
-0.669383704662323,
0.08950302004814148,
-0.08504223823547363,
0.5076563954353333,
0.8009063601493835,
0.3497488498687744,
-0.20429213345050812,
-0.2878241240978241,
0.5020778179168701,
0.19189170002937317,
0.2508104741573334,
-0.3614611327648163,
-0.7434743046760559,
-1.1202503442764282,
0.33603549003601074,
0.5494698286056519,
0.5228798985481262,
-0.24337811768054962,
-0.06640659272670746,
0.17967595160007477,
-0.301597535610199,
-0.5102264881134033,
0.02971561998128891,
0.3353957533836365,
0.21696273982524872,
0.3006053864955902,
-0.27717989683151245,
-0.8584207892417908,
-0.9225002527236938,
-0.3825479745864868,
-0.6779722571372986,
0.37906578183174133,
0.35581353306770325,
0.5264788269996643,
0.395498663187027,
0.7128123641014099,
-0.14324067533016205,
-0.11737845838069916,
-0.22769924998283386,
0.7529101371765137,
0.17710642516613007,
0.6594547629356384,
0.4205756187438965,
-0.972985565662384,
-0.3287891149520874,
0.1892298460006714,
-0.7806625366210938,
-0.07108285278081894,
-0.42284879088401794,
-0.16807062923908234,
-0.02875392511487007,
0.6954599022865295,
-0.195872500538826,
0.4573953449726105,
0.11253669112920761,
-0.513994574546814,
0.39910465478897095,
0.1476219743490219,
0.24676668643951416,
-0.9002009630203247,
-0.1849108636379242,
0.20429860055446625,
-0.12816758453845978,
-0.7521024346351624,
-0.09560064226388931,
-0.3861212432384491,
0.06539534032344818,
-0.55671626329422,
0.48118460178375244,
-0.24019427597522736,
0.22127076983451843,
-0.21833984553813934,
0.039441972970962524,
-0.10533172637224197,
0.4008128345012665,
0.23900243639945984,
0.338856965303421,
0.4370773434638977,
-0.3393009305000305,
0.5828036069869995,
0.10083455592393875,
-0.17626969516277313,
0.3855847418308258,
-0.7257900834083557,
0.25602230429649353,
0.15183183550834656,
0.22867512702941895,
-0.9060441851615906,
-0.20389068126678467,
0.2826249599456787,
-0.45094504952430725,
0.01837341859936714,
-0.44889724254608154,
-0.3007766008377075,
-0.28046414256095886,
-0.31430765986442566,
0.16972103714942932,
0.17875519394874573,
-0.4593946933746338,
0.783588171005249,
0.5260675549507141,
-0.24329930543899536,
-0.5667189359664917,
-0.4131011366844177,
0.6438131928443909,
-0.6712186336517334,
-0.3083629012107849,
0.32432252168655396,
-0.2063286304473877,
-0.6210706233978271,
0.03232733905315399,
0.38029158115386963,
-0.011921248398721218,
0.21821941435337067,
0.32644975185394287,
0.13378013670444489,
-0.3665059804916382,
-0.14342859387397766,
-0.41871947050094604,
0.1900867521762848,
0.6747902631759644,
-0.026890886947512627,
0.5506177544593811,
-0.0953068807721138,
-0.3744242191314697,
-0.4168054461479187,
0.7466170191764832,
0.1418832242488861,
-0.0844372808933258,
0.33663010597229004,
0.558496356010437,
-0.5063800811767578,
0.18157319724559784,
-0.5178642272949219,
0.3061656653881073,
-0.4944470226764679,
0.30415239930152893,
-0.24354764819145203,
-0.6223164200782776,
0.6212825775146484,
-0.09247156232595444,
0.8580743074417114,
0.7698839902877808,
0.7701749205589294,
0.020532621070742607,
1.5695980787277222,
0.44516339898109436,
-0.4158000349998474,
0.460462361574173,
-0.022542668506503105,
0.3297438621520996,
-0.7753729224205017,
-0.47959959506988525,
-0.6722167730331421,
0.015414204448461533,
-0.39725226163864136,
-0.19564788043498993,
0.009471191093325615,
0.10653017461299896,
-0.4765104353427887,
0.380648136138916,
-0.03431687131524086,
0.2424515038728714,
0.7285295128822327,
-0.1968860924243927,
0.04645884037017822,
-0.5743173956871033,
-0.09181700646877289,
0.37718290090560913,
-0.6380346417427063,
-0.6061026453971863,
0.8465772867202759,
0.4407106637954712,
0.11071909964084625,
0.050529878586530685,
0.823858916759491,
0.7737130522727966,
0.3855224549770355,
-0.6443201303482056,
0.721785843372345,
0.004066132940351963,
-0.8564628958702087,
0.21285682916641235,
-0.050437815487384796,
-0.9040495157241821,
0.09148336201906204,
-0.20981785655021667,
-0.9309220910072327,
-0.06725005805492401,
-0.0638318657875061,
-0.5580945014953613,
0.5035421252250671,
-0.5400533080101013,
0.9072602987289429,
-0.398269921541214,
-0.47673356533050537,
-0.18583086133003235,
-0.7321873307228088,
0.49095094203948975,
0.3581998348236084,
0.20938967168331146,
-0.05508851259946823,
0.4109758734703064,
1.2723190784454346,
-0.5640521049499512,
0.563977837562561,
-0.5107678174972534,
-0.2056080549955368,
0.8265084028244019,
-0.22305937111377716,
0.4748038351535797,
0.1716850996017456,
-0.12397676706314087,
-0.3178313672542572,
0.1571154147386551,
-0.36779144406318665,
-0.38646891713142395,
0.6363386511802673,
-0.5847544074058533,
-0.9627408385276794,
-0.6156090497970581,
-0.5297664999961853,
-0.09705518931150436,
0.05453082174062729,
-0.03895812854170799,
0.6342312097549438,
-0.3139663338661194,
0.06027072295546532,
0.3165231943130493,
-0.030616704374551773,
0.799699068069458,
0.18908806145191193,
0.06557856500148773,
-0.5274486541748047,
0.7968118786811829,
-0.22923323512077332,
-0.20495419204235077,
0.064996138215065,
0.175974041223526,
-0.47554075717926025,
-1.0064610242843628,
-0.4293016791343689,
-0.03506115823984146,
-0.815769612789154,
0.022832775488495827,
-0.784744918346405,
-0.293041467666626,
-0.6338257789611816,
-0.00830849353224039,
-0.09530502557754517,
-0.27725034952163696,
-0.09717143326997757,
0.049710195511579514,
0.10814012587070465,
1.056494951248169,
-0.15606355667114258,
0.35694620013237,
-0.6756874918937683,
0.2382940798997879,
0.3224548101425171,
0.12172403931617737,
-0.0995943620800972,
-0.3650035560131073,
-0.34784412384033203,
0.15755042433738708,
-0.5533583164215088,
-0.6520130634307861,
0.1446242332458496,
0.12157965451478958,
0.8200957179069519,
0.6304965615272522,
-0.01282194908708334,
0.9359765648841858,
-0.37465208768844604,
1.4646143913269043,
0.1548837274312973,
-0.7745382189750671,
0.8791051506996155,
-0.4365866184234619,
-0.4587043821811676,
0.5331760048866272,
0.15335489809513092,
-0.5394083261489868,
-0.05219333991408348,
-0.8892451524734497,
-0.6739730834960938,
0.7068827152252197,
0.03122537210583687,
-0.25865232944488525,
0.052263300865888596,
0.4383945167064667,
-0.24588827788829803,
-0.1430375725030899,
-1.013811707496643,
-0.14315199851989746,
0.040906596928834915,
-0.32265785336494446,
0.3062441647052765,
-0.13099633157253265,
-0.5419764518737793,
-0.05224230885505676,
0.7538803219795227,
-0.005312296561896801,
0.13950854539871216,
0.0391966812312603,
0.1641131043434143,
0.07948918640613556,
0.09365426003932953,
0.41764387488365173,
0.3620803654193878,
-0.1198870837688446,
-0.07720500230789185,
0.4233192503452301,
-0.4351274073123932,
-0.11061412841081619,
0.2829155921936035,
0.0038417382165789604,
-0.07424835860729218,
0.7815161943435669,
0.9998525381088257,
-0.27494651079177856,
-0.8256223797798157,
0.5122185349464417,
-0.2356785237789154,
-0.6379106640815735,
-0.5446611642837524,
0.16298145055770874,
-0.22915303707122803,
0.6161770820617676,
0.38644152879714966,
-0.03034241870045662,
0.6002945303916931,
-0.8471428155899048,
0.25128424167633057,
0.35096728801727295,
-0.9096630215644836,
-0.2830553948879242,
1.0946303606033325,
0.19389231503009796,
-0.3892095983028412,
0.1490134447813034,
-0.04298052564263344,
-0.6675194501876831,
0.6651704907417297,
0.3558111786842346,
0.9127857685089111,
0.3823276162147522,
0.021252481266856194,
0.3771994113922119,
-0.17704689502716064,
-0.06916514784097672,
0.03060644306242466,
-0.27636778354644775,
-0.3883185088634491,
-0.43825218081474304,
-0.32254737615585327,
-0.4967898726463318,
0.42947056889533997,
-0.7892557382583618,
0.628584086894989,
-0.4602828919887543,
0.1718316376209259,
0.1512107104063034,
0.5634618997573853,
-0.19204778969287872,
0.20039913058280945,
0.4944862723350525,
0.9617851972579956,
-0.8768486380577087,
0.7634578943252563,
0.8447670340538025,
-0.3364706337451935,
-0.6608231663703918,
-0.14503030478954315,
0.3064238727092743,
-0.5902674198150635,
0.38994458317756653,
0.023395106196403503,
-0.04332328215241432,
-0.2982370853424072,
-0.9893614053726196,
-0.04387851804494858,
1.1241986751556396,
0.0600416362285614,
-0.23431715369224548,
0.021435020491480827,
0.04058298096060753,
0.3839139938354492,
-0.5029555559158325,
0.23730215430259705,
0.8281605243682861,
0.5440429449081421,
0.2646094262599945,
-0.5255323648452759,
-0.2378360480070114,
-0.6566851735115051,
-0.4256902039051056,
-0.021481014788150787,
-0.8387988805770874,
0.9518409967422485,
-0.12477242201566696,
-0.3203405737876892,
0.49198922514915466,
0.9758570790290833,
0.5322742462158203,
0.6057533621788025,
0.8226532936096191,
0.5608459115028381,
0.6252115368843079,
-0.21631866693496704,
0.8328747153282166,
-0.20206013321876526,
0.21842756867408752,
1.1996126174926758,
-0.45072290301322937,
0.5824053883552551,
0.3691399395465851,
-0.2098994255065918,
0.706346333026886,
1.103542447090149,
-0.10914840549230576,
0.2980240285396576,
0.21027825772762299,
-0.5758594870567322,
-0.5745070576667786,
-0.6162164807319641,
-0.17540276050567627,
0.33418935537338257,
0.3595684766769409,
-0.14853937923908234,
-0.242227241396904,
-0.42109939455986023,
0.4249379634857178,
-0.0007018569740466774,
-0.3098817467689514,
0.9480147361755371,
-0.13282451033592224,
-1.1839715242385864,
-0.06316088140010834,
0.09118850529193878,
0.289081335067749,
-0.416372686624527,
-0.5515265464782715,
-0.1433209925889969,
0.06514536589384079,
-0.07113450020551682,
-0.9256159067153931,
-0.18298190832138062,
0.13454346358776093,
0.22891466319561005,
0.06792138516902924,
0.627315878868103,
-0.4041294753551483,
-0.31482309103012085,
0.20611076056957245,
0.05213487148284912,
0.19774942100048065,
0.15477275848388672,
-1.0161042213439941,
-0.28928515315055847,
0.22479014098644257,
-0.15940478444099426,
0.23107917606830597,
0.6018863916397095,
-0.3816392719745636,
0.40705159306526184,
0.711632251739502,
0.32309263944625854,
0.342851847410202,
0.22937224805355072,
0.9365949034690857,
-0.8758782148361206,
-0.09978187829256058,
-0.9374669790267944,
0.49467235803604126,
-0.4732029139995575,
-0.4937921464443207,
0.5315238237380981,
0.8022496104240417,
0.2960938811302185,
0.5359166860580444,
0.9428215622901917,
-0.4686378538608551,
0.40433892607688904,
-0.6221148371696472,
0.3179916441440582,
-0.3265705108642578,
0.18336188793182373,
-0.10138675570487976,
-0.3113231956958771,
-0.32324597239494324,
0.37045589089393616,
-0.049303121864795685,
-0.04512796178460121,
0.5154241919517517,
0.6297413110733032,
0.24946993589401245,
0.445520281791687,
-0.041331708431243896,
-0.08474055677652359,
0.9042450785636902,
1.0271947383880615,
1.0622342824935913,
-0.9169037938117981,
0.7025447487831116,
-0.16376876831054688,
0.08358879387378693,
-0.07631585747003555,
-1.1024231910705566,
-0.7745744585990906,
-0.7679507732391357,
-0.5300220251083374,
-0.531715452671051,
-0.0019917513709515333,
0.6728928685188293,
0.7342981696128845,
-1.1782608032226562,
-0.43731674551963806,
-0.3475100100040436,
0.05028301849961281,
0.0017114070942625403,
-0.1905931830406189,
0.4825015664100647,
-0.4994688630104065,
-0.7754326462745667,
0.3892431855201721,
0.15640905499458313,
-0.27321696281433105,
0.037136778235435486,
-0.22007928788661957,
-0.87071692943573,
0.054644625633955,
0.31140926480293274,
0.587149977684021,
-0.6818084716796875,
-0.580513596534729,
-0.3539798855781555,
0.3158145546913147,
0.14849641919136047,
1.1220377683639526,
-0.5653823614120483,
0.4251323342323303,
0.39088961482048035,
0.38855573534965515,
0.525394856929779,
0.21784131228923798,
0.7518305778503418,
-0.3311241865158081,
0.11997710913419724,
0.2154289186000824,
0.769097089767456,
0.10847678780555725,
-0.016778230667114258,
0.6739022731781006,
0.15458518266677856,
-0.6879486441612244,
-0.812243640422821,
-0.02482778951525688,
-1.0554168224334717,
0.09969473630189896,
1.1397682428359985,
-0.5751954913139343,
-0.1532510668039322,
-0.6339578032493591,
-0.3945787250995636,
0.3467918038368225,
-0.184831440448761,
0.5560358166694641,
1.1107631921768188,
-0.4451103210449219,
-0.19243302941322327,
-0.8257790803909302,
0.6074515581130981,
0.3987761437892914,
-0.7385610342025757,
0.102872334420681,
0.5947955250740051,
-0.11425317823886871,
0.2262502759695053,
0.5071686506271362,
-0.5078052282333374,
0.4378720819950104,
0.12005359679460526,
-0.07021006941795349,
0.24938879907131195,
-0.2094634622335434,
-0.28106725215911865,
0.3422015607357025,
0.2480173259973526,
-0.2649681270122528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14500v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14500v1 | Improving Expert Radiology Report Summarization by Prompting Large Language Models with a Layperson Summary | 2024-06-20T17:01:55 | 2024-06-20T17:01:55 | Xingmeng Zhao, Tongnian Wang, Anthony Rios | cs.CL | cs.CL | Radiology report summarization (RRS) is crucial for patient care, requiring
concise "Impressions" from detailed "Findings." This paper introduces a novel
prompting strategy to enhance RRS by first generating a layperson summary. This
approach normalizes key observations and simplifies complex information using
non-expert communication techniques inspired by doctor-patient interactions.
Combined with few-shot in-context learning, this method improves the model's
ability to link general terms to specific findings. We evaluate this approach
on the MIMIC-CXR, CheXpert, and MIMIC-III datasets, benchmarking it against
7B/8B parameter state-of-the-art open-source large language models (LLMs) like
Meta-Llama-3-8B-Instruct. Our results demonstrate improvements in summarization
accuracy and accessibility, particularly in out-of-domain tests, with
improvements as high as 5% for some metrics. | [
-0.26268577575683594,
-0.2709699273109436,
0.64952552318573,
0.0664750263094902,
-0.47542503476142883,
-0.10568979382514954,
-0.26083678007125854,
-0.4503059685230255,
0.2666322886943817,
0.4420463740825653,
-0.2452571541070938,
-0.4724617898464203,
-0.7436869740486145,
0.4304168224334717,
-0.17177461087703705,
1.0682001113891602,
0.13686540722846985,
0.3754400312900543,
-0.012197482399642467,
-0.1282723993062973,
-0.4646860361099243,
0.05160517990589142,
-0.645297646522522,
-0.44093310832977295,
0.6832184195518494,
0.6185286045074463,
0.941807210445404,
0.7160326242446899,
0.543266773223877,
0.1400308758020401,
-0.06827943027019501,
0.2800159454345703,
-0.40329280495643616,
0.1529788374900818,
-0.05053635314106941,
-0.3779292702674866,
-0.7013464570045471,
-0.2998075783252716,
0.42337530851364136,
1.057838797569275,
-0.08471864461898804,
-0.05697645619511604,
0.04468216747045517,
0.6972471475601196,
-0.5809034109115601,
0.19822898507118225,
-0.2616623342037201,
-0.09282177686691284,
-0.036639515310525894,
-0.7922634482383728,
-0.6793655157089233,
-0.4024583697319031,
0.35022303462028503,
-0.5483793020248413,
0.2870505154132843,
-0.05964118614792824,
0.5973610877990723,
0.031413692981004715,
-0.46739739179611206,
-0.27005648612976074,
-0.6574028134346008,
0.543724000453949,
-0.7501968741416931,
0.22075384855270386,
0.34069767594337463,
0.41419920325279236,
-0.07065474987030029,
-0.720604658126831,
-0.19043920934200287,
-0.3773137331008911,
-0.35482579469680786,
0.38396039605140686,
-0.4792192578315735,
0.10801149159669876,
0.33683204650878906,
0.02721080556511879,
-0.5128127336502075,
0.01136478316038847,
-0.374117910861969,
-0.05116073787212372,
0.5579556822776794,
0.34580370783805847,
0.18842123448848724,
-0.16229113936424255,
-0.15816158056259155,
-0.15514537692070007,
-0.9157609343528748,
-0.2592124938964844,
-0.13149642944335938,
0.44682422280311584,
-0.2706677317619324,
0.4689444303512573,
-0.6552647352218628,
0.7270222306251526,
0.212602898478508,
-0.33413147926330566,
0.21682870388031006,
-0.16510635614395142,
-0.13971459865570068,
0.03847794979810715,
0.6310434341430664,
0.7302125096321106,
0.23881885409355164,
0.057556137442588806,
-0.15381529927253723,
-0.28065595030784607,
-0.1450394243001938,
-0.819023609161377,
-0.5518324971199036,
0.23145687580108643,
-0.8306694626808167,
-0.3465394377708435,
0.0923537090420723,
-0.6800436973571777,
-0.4417722523212433,
-0.28156790137290955,
0.43343299627304077,
-0.41327908635139465,
-0.33077117800712585,
0.18984632194042206,
-0.01853087916970253,
0.17697308957576752,
0.6503661870956421,
-0.6336910724639893,
0.4304371774196625,
0.23751862347126007,
0.6305885314941406,
0.24337510764598846,
0.003054499626159668,
-1.0026193857192993,
0.4105856418609619,
-0.2671339213848114,
1.1831040382385254,
-0.5759162306785583,
-0.632854700088501,
-0.24176014959812164,
-0.2985379695892334,
0.0049659488722682,
-0.5735291838645935,
0.0007321905577555299,
-0.2778003513813019,
0.4830930233001709,
-0.27078282833099365,
-0.36076536774635315,
-0.046981330960989,
0.06549898535013199,
-0.27114933729171753,
0.7229058146476746,
0.0983458012342453,
-0.7495566010475159,
0.17531026899814606,
-0.5495845675468445,
-0.6028451919555664,
0.22847507894039154,
-0.35852402448654175,
-0.19009679555892944,
0.2518490254878998,
0.5692564845085144,
0.6792649030685425,
-0.1581934094429016,
0.22458848357200623,
0.12416867166757584,
-0.1870477944612503,
0.18108010292053223,
-0.00442909449338913,
0.27782273292541504,
0.1940588653087616,
0.082448810338974,
0.26180171966552734,
-0.3770838975906372,
-0.021758973598480225,
-0.0030970529187470675,
-0.0155390165746212,
-0.3168220818042755,
-0.18663543462753296,
-0.25532814860343933,
0.072871632874012,
-0.015479577705264091,
-0.12641659379005432,
0.16720899939537048,
-0.26918113231658936,
0.044602956622838974,
0.42258262634277344,
0.30993887782096863,
0.4116079807281494,
-0.655870258808136,
0.5871273279190063,
-0.08229128271341324,
0.13987624645233154,
-0.7970181107521057,
-0.3827342092990875,
-0.6170015335083008,
-0.4947337806224823,
0.4318040907382965,
0.31077107787132263,
-0.5632185339927673,
-0.09187084436416626,
-0.6016380190849304,
-0.3900206685066223,
-0.3597754240036011,
-0.1393432766199112,
0.6019747853279114,
0.8693047761917114,
0.5402698516845703,
-0.2612529397010803,
-0.5124168395996094,
-0.9313873052597046,
-0.32073062658309937,
0.024264056235551834,
-0.37612730264663696,
0.2091754823923111,
0.22630508244037628,
-0.06201281026005745,
0.8043026924133301,
-0.8007234334945679,
-0.44594520330429077,
-0.7719898223876953,
0.5054963231086731,
0.11261613667011261,
0.16236989200115204,
0.34967684745788574,
-0.35382407903671265,
-0.7784733772277832,
-0.022230379283428192,
-0.650858461856842,
-0.28536587953567505,
-0.1568816900253296,
0.17623279988765717,
0.22186805307865143,
0.8009092211723328,
-0.43771135807037354,
0.488113671541214,
0.1688397079706192,
0.032195884734392166,
0.30311545729637146,
-0.5488641858100891,
0.23832178115844727,
-1.126327633857727,
0.22081078588962555,
-0.08639631420373917,
-0.418098121881485,
-0.6836104989051819,
-0.03391177952289581,
0.12365991622209549,
-0.013429038226604462,
-0.27764713764190674,
0.35141921043395996,
-0.7921987175941467,
-0.016700826585292816,
-0.4137963056564331,
0.10008392482995987,
-0.0787908136844635,
0.10735748708248138,
0.4471571445465088,
0.4660033583641052,
0.550505518913269,
-0.6528998017311096,
-0.14285476505756378,
0.4132254719734192,
-0.14189943671226501,
0.3706369996070862,
-0.7972543835639954,
0.16404610872268677,
-0.5159997940063477,
0.6014676094055176,
-0.9195226430892944,
-0.6171186566352844,
0.03906252235174179,
-0.6112764477729797,
0.5135045647621155,
-0.1870345026254654,
-0.1793549358844757,
-0.01589786633849144,
-0.3549751043319702,
0.1110067069530487,
0.5218102335929871,
-0.1424020379781723,
0.8584434986114502,
0.09853815287351608,
-0.5812110304832458,
-0.5183905959129333,
-0.5556299090385437,
0.5151702165603638,
0.0658738985657692,
-0.4304386377334595,
0.27017420530319214,
-0.10237788408994675,
-0.359480082988739,
-0.16319121420383453,
0.0014521268894895911,
-0.045332733541727066,
-0.18694040179252625,
-0.07883866876363754,
0.3580958843231201,
-0.26835528016090393,
-0.023066328838467598,
0.015617155469954014,
-0.2801583409309387,
0.029013440012931824,
0.23678384721279144,
0.46686530113220215,
0.025406984612345695,
-0.04787931963801384,
-0.7030168771743774,
0.5348012447357178,
0.4222809970378876,
-0.11489655077457428,
0.3177048861980438,
0.2086622267961502,
-0.27058732509613037,
-0.11441392451524734,
-0.4514773190021515,
-0.6602969765663147,
-0.36297133564949036,
0.41841647028923035,
-0.30874550342559814,
-0.6375108361244202,
0.3713191747665405,
-0.13579557836055756,
0.012867270037531853,
0.2062625288963318,
0.4612669348716736,
-0.26859745383262634,
1.0920222997665405,
0.668274462223053,
-0.003914320841431618,
0.1556423455476761,
-0.10126279294490814,
0.0835057944059372,
-0.7893519997596741,
-0.43147537112236023,
-0.46312710642814636,
0.13124117255210876,
-0.22611521184444427,
-0.39270931482315063,
0.819512128829956,
-0.2814802825450897,
0.38910531997680664,
-0.05636131018400192,
-0.2359691709280014,
0.651755154132843,
0.13068577647209167,
0.45833176374435425,
0.5100820064544678,
0.03416758030653,
0.2299567461013794,
-0.11041479557752609,
-0.871290385723114,
-0.4080464541912079,
1.157439112663269,
0.34285977482795715,
0.9988523721694946,
0.17432236671447754,
0.8469741940498352,
0.13757553696632385,
0.4634868800640106,
-0.7554014921188354,
0.5401561260223389,
-0.04170341044664383,
-0.046439435333013535,
-0.18545399606227875,
-0.3332388401031494,
-0.8847286701202393,
0.11772910505533218,
-0.3515430986881256,
-0.1764131635427475,
-0.06388839334249496,
0.3324814438819885,
-0.8706678748130798,
-0.2062554508447647,
-0.4504586458206177,
0.18041478097438812,
0.13209916651248932,
-0.06399282068014145,
-0.39856308698654175,
-0.9161026477813721,
0.4353547692298889,
0.27860236167907715,
0.38915911316871643,
0.09329927712678909,
-0.3033270239830017,
0.4492257833480835,
-0.4801928699016571,
0.892257571220398,
-0.017598161473870277,
0.023131832480430603,
-0.09592252224683762,
0.45550936460494995,
0.6929996609687805,
0.05845615267753601,
0.24940337240695953,
-0.2792307138442993,
-0.32352837920188904,
-0.25925344228744507,
-0.6462578177452087,
0.5002833604812622,
-0.5903801918029785,
-0.4975292682647705,
-0.44465136528015137,
-0.6528778672218323,
-0.3750886619091034,
0.11048102378845215,
0.4804244041442871,
0.8318630456924438,
-0.09892962127923965,
0.06449756026268005,
1.119588017463684,
-0.23387113213539124,
0.16145198047161102,
0.7752854824066162,
0.03960467875003815,
-0.3273826241493225,
0.5112680196762085,
-0.030844666063785553,
0.4294891953468323,
0.6208412647247314,
0.6028125286102295,
-0.17064177989959717,
-0.7891582250595093,
-0.2154546082019806,
0.32430219650268555,
-0.8652081489562988,
-0.46850353479385376,
-1.0008184909820557,
0.021327471360564232,
-0.5891562700271606,
-0.30888861417770386,
-0.06651584804058075,
-0.4211452901363373,
-0.09308891743421555,
0.03840009868144989,
0.49067234992980957,
1.0000489950180054,
-0.04710988700389862,
0.40238019824028015,
-0.7997025847434998,
0.3738207221031189,
0.24071620404720306,
0.07475195080041885,
0.1337880939245224,
-0.9146206378936768,
-0.22834716737270355,
-0.24997034668922424,
0.036848582327365875,
-0.8963713645935059,
0.45056387782096863,
0.23431095480918884,
0.4880698621273041,
0.4349891245365143,
0.2050410509109497,
0.7342413663864136,
-0.23973767459392548,
0.5170841217041016,
0.4061402678489685,
-0.7751526236534119,
0.6574437618255615,
-0.8481914401054382,
0.6304951310157776,
0.483225017786026,
0.37835046648979187,
-0.5177700519561768,
-0.582953929901123,
-0.4783087372779846,
-0.822761595249176,
0.5579109787940979,
-0.03366469964385033,
0.017984528094530106,
-0.062376003712415695,
0.26218533515930176,
0.07148817926645279,
-0.13547949492931366,
-0.41219407320022583,
-0.005259065423160791,
0.007860127836465836,
-0.29369959235191345,
0.10110253095626831,
-0.39394062757492065,
-0.3721061646938324,
-0.07996687293052673,
0.5313711762428284,
-0.48965948820114136,
0.22313058376312256,
0.46301621198654175,
-0.24731779098510742,
-0.2598702311515808,
0.29108700156211853,
0.9717295169830322,
1.0179764032363892,
-0.20632144808769226,
0.29348984360694885,
0.53699791431427,
-0.34330394864082336,
-0.3240206241607666,
-0.3354273736476898,
-0.010327029041945934,
0.15301233530044556,
0.7623032331466675,
0.36096492409706116,
0.37016192078590393,
-0.4162464141845703,
0.65716952085495,
-0.23426435887813568,
-0.3302496671676636,
-0.06692983955144882,
0.08334075659513474,
0.10655146837234497,
-0.087006114423275,
0.6274615526199341,
0.21200062334537506,
0.2160644680261612,
-0.3101164698600769,
0.2878860533237457,
0.20464228093624115,
-0.27492091059684753,
-0.26364198327064514,
0.5305887460708618,
0.3251192569732666,
0.1506025195121765,
0.3322657644748688,
0.3337433338165283,
-0.1672031134366989,
0.40472736954689026,
0.44638878107070923,
0.6518058180809021,
-0.3263634443283081,
0.31569936871528625,
0.6797341108322144,
0.25110962986946106,
-0.4016020894050598,
0.2973858416080475,
0.034168537706136703,
-0.24630513787269592,
-0.6746318340301514,
0.26947954297065735,
-0.7011375427246094,
0.05270984768867493,
-0.9819453954696655,
0.5044822692871094,
-0.6885319948196411,
0.18422536551952362,
0.12782737612724304,
-0.31324464082717896,
-0.27752310037612915,
0.2968255281448364,
0.06453674286603928,
1.1080970764160156,
-0.7501722574234009,
0.6801654100418091,
0.5455705523490906,
-0.35340967774391174,
-0.9580416083335876,
0.1274273693561554,
-0.08724556863307953,
-0.6959951519966125,
0.7201759815216064,
0.05009451135993004,
-0.37204283475875854,
-0.004080163314938545,
-0.6547795534133911,
-0.7244976758956909,
1.0878082513809204,
0.21811841428279877,
-0.48288020491600037,
0.07354716956615448,
-0.14744475483894348,
0.5009298920631409,
-0.5775696635246277,
0.7144379615783691,
0.14686699211597443,
0.4083421230316162,
0.1678638756275177,
-0.9345281720161438,
0.3338179886341095,
-0.07070735841989517,
-0.2127489447593689,
0.09521613270044327,
-0.5436571836471558,
0.6257299184799194,
-0.6924841403961182,
-0.09126462787389755,
0.00043471381650306284,
0.8510041236877441,
0.1446789652109146,
0.20197144150733948,
0.4228462278842926,
0.12158390134572983,
0.791843056678772,
0.1393052041530609,
1.2160274982452393,
-0.23381908237934113,
-0.09281308203935623,
1.2693874835968018,
-0.27628645300865173,
0.7223562598228455,
0.27164945006370544,
0.07248838245868683,
0.672436535358429,
0.36007869243621826,
0.1864650845527649,
0.5133807063102722,
-0.17784695327281952,
-0.26385557651519775,
-0.50682532787323,
-0.26098138093948364,
-0.5524957776069641,
0.2700115442276001,
0.2551977336406708,
-0.37113553285598755,
-0.4466634690761566,
-0.15823669731616974,
0.36870887875556946,
0.11426424980163574,
-0.3311895728111267,
0.9829395413398743,
0.19505736231803894,
-0.795940637588501,
0.6722019910812378,
-0.07770267128944397,
0.41930684447288513,
-0.9079697132110596,
-0.0815231204032898,
-0.4817647635936737,
0.09243589639663696,
-0.546909511089325,
-0.6306989789009094,
0.2877812683582306,
0.01769421435892582,
-0.34401360154151917,
-0.14043106138706207,
0.44312602281570435,
-0.4681110680103302,
-0.15460778772830963,
-0.015735482797026634,
0.3693903088569641,
0.12804365158081055,
0.1711609661579132,
-0.3230475187301636,
-0.007984562776982784,
0.021879514679312706,
-0.13783003389835358,
0.5054287910461426,
0.11574731022119522,
-0.321897953748703,
0.8260771632194519,
0.5236464738845825,
0.1300407350063324,
-0.44279637932777405,
0.33801379799842834,
0.9448779225349426,
-0.6005995273590088,
-0.5082844495773315,
-0.5153419375419617,
0.506683886051178,
-0.051811520010232925,
-0.3122651278972626,
0.704659640789032,
0.4397124648094177,
0.4464625418186188,
-0.09370217472314835,
0.8119503855705261,
0.15853692591190338,
0.7668993473052979,
-0.5832954049110413,
0.5502637624740601,
-0.26495081186294556,
0.2640610635280609,
-0.34898245334625244,
-0.46532464027404785,
-0.5678451657295227,
0.4659079313278198,
-0.22063790261745453,
0.06397126615047455,
0.8685517907142639,
0.9262633323669434,
-0.12174708396196365,
-0.08257462084293365,
0.35639652609825134,
0.38441330194473267,
0.09702631831169128,
0.4312659800052643,
0.7411269545555115,
-0.1765586882829666,
0.6411694884300232,
-0.03471045568585396,
-0.546377420425415,
-0.4307423532009125,
-0.9794406890869141,
-1.043284296989441,
-0.15298844873905182,
-0.6520882248878479,
-0.42876583337783813,
0.06095314770936966,
0.9969359636306763,
0.71820467710495,
-0.6207097172737122,
-0.20373795926570892,
0.3326749801635742,
-0.26198846101760864,
-0.11995953321456909,
-0.16769161820411682,
0.482783704996109,
-0.24986566603183746,
-0.3798220157623291,
0.5299527049064636,
0.3399868309497833,
0.1432906687259674,
-0.054213184863328934,
-0.17598748207092285,
0.34873372316360474,
0.03071458637714386,
0.5081362128257751,
0.1770971268415451,
-0.3855507969856262,
0.01130756177008152,
0.24880681931972504,
-0.15851889550685883,
0.07396265864372253,
0.9020743370056152,
-0.8450000882148743,
0.45668601989746094,
0.5093848705291748,
0.10055592656135559,
0.31286799907684326,
0.03020482137799263,
0.7206404805183411,
-0.6053367257118225,
0.0023691318929195404,
0.3367405831813812,
0.16738872230052948,
0.47616198658943176,
-0.5456830263137817,
0.28762319684028625,
-0.1037142351269722,
-0.31949201226234436,
-0.7503517866134644,
0.2763505280017853,
-1.0098999738693237,
-0.4136606454849243,
1.0864081382751465,
-0.09088665246963501,
-0.016298552975058556,
-0.35223329067230225,
-0.25491881370544434,
-0.019567009061574936,
-0.5090588331222534,
0.7900779843330383,
0.08047989755868912,
-0.5064445734024048,
-0.4804275929927826,
-0.35159432888031006,
0.6150362491607666,
0.46074947714805603,
-0.7336000204086304,
0.08238750696182251,
0.49781858921051025,
0.6710400581359863,
-0.24390579760074615,
0.9951820373535156,
-0.17402265965938568,
0.6652778387069702,
-0.4436942934989929,
0.056756164878606796,
-0.39004236459732056,
-0.38181766867637634,
-0.4764114022254944,
0.11216384172439575,
0.07409852743148804,
0.2630106508731842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14498v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14498v1 | LLaSA: Large Multimodal Agent for Human Activity Analysis Through Wearable Sensors | 2024-06-20T17:00:34 | 2024-06-20T17:00:34 | Sheikh Asif Imran, Mohammad Nur Hossain Khan, Subrata Biswas, Bashima Islam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Integrating inertial measurement units (IMUs) with large language models
(LLMs) advances multimodal AI by enhancing human activity understanding. We
introduce SensorCaps, a dataset of 26,288 IMU-derived activity narrations, and
OpenSQA, an instruction-following dataset with 257,562 question-answer pairs.
Combining LIMU-BERT and Llama, we develop LLaSA, a Large Multimodal Agent
capable of interpreting and responding to activity and motion analysis queries.
Our evaluation demonstrates LLaSA's effectiveness in activity classification
and question answering, highlighting its potential in healthcare, sports
science, and human-computer interaction. These contributions advance
sensor-aware language models and open new research avenues. Our code repository
and datasets can be found on https://github.com/BASHLab/LLaSA. | [
0.1520768254995346,
-0.7036578059196472,
0.7744953632354736,
0.13299158215522766,
-0.15429368615150452,
0.3255428373813629,
0.07743470370769501,
-0.7210918068885803,
0.6012439727783203,
0.30846455693244934,
-0.76829594373703,
-0.31837254762649536,
-0.502295732498169,
-0.22949503362178802,
-0.31096962094306946,
0.6601029634475708,
-0.21871493756771088,
0.14772768318653107,
-0.37965235114097595,
-0.5150325894355774,
-0.3756716549396515,
-0.4264715313911438,
-0.3283912241458893,
-0.38416218757629395,
0.513724684715271,
0.6011919975280762,
0.3850136399269104,
-0.11394041031599045,
0.3952069878578186,
0.43131256103515625,
0.20525510609149933,
0.6976051926612854,
-0.17965808510780334,
0.5683825016021729,
0.5163904428482056,
-0.46858417987823486,
-0.5648887157440186,
-0.11625822633504868,
0.7956115007400513,
0.46198368072509766,
0.09508015960454941,
0.27183663845062256,
-0.2626091241836548,
0.28321993350982666,
-0.6335392594337463,
0.20693126320838928,
0.1716277301311493,
-0.20080474019050598,
-0.10597540438175201,
0.03887735307216644,
0.01148420013487339,
0.16785065829753876,
-0.11013650894165039,
-0.6136457324028015,
-0.34454694390296936,
0.033405423164367676,
0.19673539698123932,
0.5263199210166931,
-0.39273205399513245,
-0.3811667561531067,
-0.5724771618843079,
0.8394966125488281,
-0.3897324800491333,
0.6019382476806641,
0.5262203812599182,
0.2547227442264557,
-0.12338224053382874,
-0.6290004253387451,
-0.6927688121795654,
-0.4279506206512451,
0.11287249624729156,
0.06868153065443039,
-0.07473548501729965,
-0.20340685546398163,
-0.15098229050636292,
0.05204824358224869,
-0.5368603467941284,
0.19449186325073242,
-0.2569717466831207,
-0.11243338137865067,
0.8540419936180115,
0.35554516315460205,
0.3575039803981781,
-0.0573345310986042,
-0.45754843950271606,
0.15141499042510986,
-0.5575597286224365,
0.1636434942483902,
0.16305585205554962,
0.06834316998720169,
-0.3701627254486084,
0.7880987524986267,
-0.38562625646591187,
0.47403421998023987,
-0.34723883867263794,
-0.6158027648925781,
0.4873938262462616,
-0.3539435863494873,
-0.2868707478046417,
0.06385446339845657,
0.6397937536239624,
0.12640443444252014,
-0.3817363977432251,
-0.5130125284194946,
-0.24824370443820953,
-0.19189012050628662,
0.23666849732398987,
-0.653559148311615,
0.2649920582771301,
0.6428614258766174,
-0.2472507655620575,
-0.09497757256031036,
-0.07978078722953796,
-0.5941092371940613,
-0.8167392015457153,
-0.4963788092136383,
0.5083058476448059,
-0.16966485977172852,
-0.1364022195339203,
0.23167546093463898,
0.07625310868024826,
0.3784007728099823,
0.4791722595691681,
-0.5611261129379272,
0.12647970020771027,
0.640860378742218,
0.7694478631019592,
-0.1337677240371704,
-0.4941338300704956,
-0.6041622757911682,
0.19334205985069275,
-0.08303669095039368,
0.8354305028915405,
-0.5969434976577759,
-0.4461733102798462,
0.028711123391985893,
0.21157899498939514,
-0.13731156289577484,
-0.13496284186840057,
0.38051512837409973,
-0.5643600821495056,
0.013357157818973064,
-0.08630737662315369,
-0.30191272497177124,
-0.33438640832901,
0.4846773147583008,
-0.6482654809951782,
1.1837605237960815,
0.03783176839351654,
-0.06701654195785522,
0.15717461705207825,
-1.2275352478027344,
-0.582334041595459,
0.23795774579048157,
-0.1327689290046692,
-0.30043646693229675,
-0.11447858065366745,
0.289738267660141,
0.5517248511314392,
-0.5388286113739014,
0.015576601028442383,
0.06535311043262482,
-0.28653818368911743,
0.781078577041626,
-0.297519326210022,
0.5465556383132935,
0.3382364809513092,
-0.2007206380367279,
0.360523521900177,
-0.7445412278175354,
-0.3144337832927704,
-0.03671872615814209,
-0.40107256174087524,
0.050996579229831696,
0.23629333078861237,
0.015491967089474201,
-0.2371402233839035,
0.5042727589607239,
-0.8533650040626526,
0.13915196061134338,
0.30145972967147827,
0.5183967351913452,
0.6586287021636963,
-0.30048760771751404,
0.5005003213882446,
-0.4469110667705536,
0.883431077003479,
-0.341030091047287,
0.2657166123390198,
-0.4205079972743988,
-0.7885352969169617,
-0.4957050085067749,
-0.73808753490448,
-0.3229937255382538,
0.543352484703064,
-0.6807582378387451,
0.006480566691607237,
-0.41460931301116943,
-0.6985883116722107,
-0.48802801966667175,
0.35146889090538025,
0.29068055748939514,
0.6427662372589111,
0.23092269897460938,
-0.12567627429962158,
-0.2255755215883255,
-0.3130325376987457,
0.13459646701812744,
-0.40059348940849304,
-0.017590096220374107,
0.5569410920143127,
0.43302080035209656,
-0.7585870027542114,
0.5974519848823547,
-0.34817466139793396,
-0.1752731055021286,
-0.36481499671936035,
0.2220885157585144,
0.08683916926383972,
0.30414995551109314,
0.6690911054611206,
-0.774658739566803,
-0.12014703452587128,
0.07571239024400711,
-0.8690236806869507,
-0.10517872124910355,
-0.1900576651096344,
-0.1632634550333023,
-0.10119731724262238,
0.6313478350639343,
-0.7990649342536926,
0.2781926691532135,
0.7139103412628174,
-0.4292057454586029,
0.34688523411750793,
-0.07863543182611465,
0.2893119752407074,
-1.1078214645385742,
0.28684619069099426,
-0.09991546720266342,
-0.3922874629497528,
-0.8565961718559265,
0.2015649825334549,
-0.047995951026678085,
-0.1221831738948822,
-0.7047063112258911,
0.7942660450935364,
-0.37511059641838074,
-0.28629186749458313,
-0.45635053515434265,
-0.09238211810588837,
-0.016026239842176437,
0.31592389941215515,
-0.2909594774246216,
1.0179353952407837,
0.5081583261489868,
-0.8951004147529602,
0.7161741852760315,
0.48363181948661804,
-0.7430601119995117,
0.34164947271347046,
-0.5784017443656921,
0.40253326296806335,
-0.33706191182136536,
0.1098104864358902,
-1.2776278257369995,
-0.7763417363166809,
0.25038716197013855,
-0.46753937005996704,
0.11589901149272919,
0.09445236623287201,
-0.67134028673172,
-0.15969881415367126,
-0.5010854005813599,
0.6457874774932861,
0.11148156970739365,
-0.5664120316505432,
0.9558330178260803,
0.8295028805732727,
-0.061296314001083374,
-0.6151809096336365,
-0.7846941351890564,
0.04323018342256546,
-0.3178193271160126,
-0.6268988847732544,
0.1866905391216278,
-0.5357799530029297,
-0.33614104986190796,
-0.35242894291877747,
0.09528768062591553,
-0.2728586792945862,
0.27802133560180664,
0.42649614810943604,
0.46266356110572815,
-0.06099243834614754,
0.5957437753677368,
-0.16688628494739532,
0.0851275697350502,
-0.01894744113087654,
0.1933438926935196,
0.605322003364563,
-0.19164183735847473,
-0.46805980801582336,
-0.7339436411857605,
0.28477737307548523,
1.011736273765564,
-0.10458573698997498,
0.5627312064170837,
0.5503904819488525,
-0.1840939074754715,
0.44594624638557434,
-0.27171188592910767,
0.09863073378801346,
-0.49808016419410706,
0.34308111667633057,
-0.07416610419750214,
-0.9113540053367615,
0.3677102029323578,
-0.05740354582667351,
0.28011053800582886,
-0.06173953786492348,
0.7861891984939575,
-0.43606969714164734,
0.759230375289917,
0.3487250506877899,
-0.4000409245491028,
0.6830282807350159,
-0.14344634115695953,
0.02755599468946457,
-1.0596929788589478,
-0.45277467370033264,
-0.4126546084880829,
-0.8572918176651001,
-0.4437054991722107,
-0.6522407531738281,
0.6953938603401184,
-0.5966425538063049,
-0.409207284450531,
0.16161227226257324,
-0.21029262244701385,
0.2768753468990326,
0.5204803943634033,
0.29361796379089355,
0.02268734574317932,
-0.198152557015419,
0.5521818399429321,
0.23174351453781128,
-0.3235013782978058,
-0.39433202147483826,
1.1485682725906372,
0.3058716356754303,
1.1286990642547607,
0.6535617113113403,
0.4389837086200714,
0.49943816661834717,
0.42550837993621826,
-1.053270697593689,
0.48741739988327026,
0.17819494009017944,
-0.7276254892349243,
-0.4765079915523529,
0.15368333458900452,
-1.1492398977279663,
0.31925714015960693,
-0.20645232498645782,
-0.7993227243423462,
0.15443073213100433,
-0.03216297924518585,
-0.39453262090682983,
0.11899933218955994,
-0.7746611833572388,
0.5174223780632019,
-0.7226719260215759,
-0.373069167137146,
-0.11442645639181137,
-0.5463995933532715,
0.2545951306819916,
0.12323560565710068,
0.3681858777999878,
-0.4226035177707672,
-0.5530478954315186,
0.6966955065727234,
-0.07414884120225906,
1.1524767875671387,
-0.11919163167476654,
-0.13118983805179596,
0.5207781791687012,
-0.1668413132429123,
0.342646062374115,
0.17251084744930267,
-0.09744366258382797,
0.12179192900657654,
-0.21548686921596527,
-0.330415815114975,
-0.26088839769363403,
0.725624144077301,
-0.8172117471694946,
-0.2684902548789978,
-0.4811396896839142,
-0.6577824354171753,
-0.28312647342681885,
0.02833506651222706,
-0.3144872784614563,
0.2440783828496933,
-0.26202988624572754,
0.3240773379802704,
0.4632265865802765,
-0.028834164142608643,
0.6055127382278442,
0.6321462392807007,
-0.053212616592645645,
-0.3051404058933258,
0.7976370453834534,
-0.252864807844162,
-0.3322029411792755,
0.6581393480300903,
0.13982293009757996,
-0.3185792565345764,
-0.4054935872554779,
-0.4781281352043152,
0.389888197183609,
-0.490386039018631,
-0.3804832100868225,
-0.38964974880218506,
0.22835244238376617,
-0.43097057938575745,
-0.0577394962310791,
-0.12305937707424164,
-0.27152925729751587,
-0.5855399966239929,
-0.21595726907253265,
0.5140435695648193,
0.752122163772583,
0.06213342770934105,
0.7028607726097107,
-0.835573673248291,
0.5447579622268677,
0.5978577136993408,
-0.01815461926162243,
-0.328006386756897,
-0.4021773636341095,
-0.13779735565185547,
-0.0384872630238533,
-0.2401576191186905,
-0.8251414895057678,
0.32246288657188416,
0.3140614628791809,
0.7279708385467529,
0.5331273674964905,
-0.21670253574848175,
0.5934309363365173,
-0.24080221354961395,
0.9520388841629028,
0.3948417603969574,
-0.6604599356651306,
0.37157705426216125,
-0.12975260615348816,
0.4042426645755768,
0.4003530740737915,
0.3188900053501129,
-0.618244469165802,
0.08070018887519836,
-0.14143407344818115,
-0.6565256714820862,
0.8679875135421753,
0.06414126604795456,
0.29516711831092834,
0.1667339950799942,
0.28380799293518066,
0.14794230461120605,
0.24747557938098907,
-0.722246527671814,
0.014606635086238384,
0.04219357669353485,
-0.33517926931381226,
-0.14136675000190735,
-0.24298924207687378,
-0.2804320454597473,
-0.14928634464740753,
0.5869688391685486,
-0.4571761190891266,
0.5161138772964478,
0.19700852036476135,
-0.4435625970363617,
-0.16977697610855103,
-0.010904194787144661,
0.804798424243927,
0.55741947889328,
0.003160991473123431,
-0.027309374883770943,
0.1626073718070984,
-0.7776767015457153,
0.03496860712766647,
0.1002260223031044,
-0.03500106930732727,
-0.22025728225708008,
0.5022649168968201,
0.5439044237136841,
0.30271223187446594,
-1.3246948719024658,
0.4575248658657074,
-0.20214740931987762,
0.11832495033740997,
-0.5028035044670105,
0.03198660537600517,
0.1353180706501007,
0.478130966424942,
0.26539772748947144,
-0.1847051978111267,
0.1692916601896286,
-0.7384823560714722,
-0.09035944938659668,
0.44279903173446655,
-0.4712621569633484,
-0.5498731732368469,
0.7226162552833557,
0.35822686553001404,
-0.2076713740825653,
0.44323813915252686,
0.14468173682689667,
-0.15239569544792175,
0.6559160351753235,
0.06457853317260742,
0.8178615570068359,
-0.5198227167129517,
0.3227537274360657,
0.19026446342468262,
0.449825257062912,
0.375057190656662,
0.754837691783905,
-0.3274475038051605,
-0.7797670364379883,
-0.47671258449554443,
-0.538479208946228,
-0.6186426281929016,
0.07508966326713562,
-0.24512386322021484,
-0.07878295332193375,
-0.23415496945381165,
-0.03064604662358761,
0.050403282046318054,
-0.1532241702079773,
-0.677947461605072,
0.13009031116962433,
0.29333141446113586,
0.44460615515708923,
-0.5844005346298218,
0.8401445746421814,
0.9426293969154358,
-0.4289485514163971,
-0.04691487178206444,
-0.07932545989751816,
0.01884503662586212,
-1.2383934259414673,
0.6269182562828064,
0.25152361392974854,
-0.342729389667511,
-0.6784043908119202,
-0.8045281767845154,
-0.9223463535308838,
1.6004657745361328,
0.4138460159301758,
-0.2464287132024765,
0.3083725869655609,
0.29818907380104065,
0.417996883392334,
-0.40934357047080994,
0.048589445650577545,
0.5544614195823669,
0.5872983932495117,
0.05195721611380577,
-0.7946571707725525,
-0.3064740300178528,
-0.0745667889714241,
-0.5715506076812744,
0.019765060395002365,
-1.0087525844573975,
0.7157686948776245,
-0.23737376928329468,
0.08280763030052185,
0.46806392073631287,
0.681690514087677,
0.2967853248119354,
0.7505165934562683,
0.38592708110809326,
0.31519341468811035,
1.0830408334732056,
0.10960419476032257,
1.1723674535751343,
-0.0736762210726738,
-0.18769574165344238,
0.9783228039741516,
-0.41371360421180725,
0.6363682150840759,
0.33603671193122864,
-0.1295410841703415,
0.47305023670196533,
0.41990575194358826,
0.5499745011329651,
0.39460915327072144,
-0.22089490294456482,
-0.8855581283569336,
-0.26877501606941223,
-0.1853010505437851,
-0.000641717342659831,
1.0072778463363647,
0.63312828540802,
-0.16184498369693756,
0.1207471638917923,
0.15661628544330597,
0.07245621085166931,
-0.2447650283575058,
-0.24114131927490234,
0.6447525024414062,
-0.23611293733119965,
-0.6861196160316467,
0.004924145992845297,
-0.10863262414932251,
0.3868953585624695,
-0.9003815054893494,
-0.07327879965305328,
-0.25966545939445496,
-0.029710860922932625,
0.010760849341750145,
-0.8217328190803528,
-0.02990187332034111,
0.12237261235713959,
0.0915699303150177,
-0.20464706420898438,
0.6537112593650818,
-0.10733350366353989,
-0.5050410628318787,
0.10814972221851349,
0.5366289615631104,
0.36779314279556274,
0.05195361375808716,
-0.508511483669281,
0.12414439022541046,
-0.16971734166145325,
-0.11952678859233856,
0.4045180082321167,
0.2759885787963867,
-0.08044013381004333,
0.8822356462478638,
0.6553714871406555,
-0.45611146092414856,
0.16832637786865234,
-0.14750531315803528,
1.0702379941940308,
-0.5419750809669495,
-0.39486366510391235,
-0.31402674317359924,
0.6350141167640686,
0.025546610355377197,
-0.4678119719028473,
0.5030389428138733,
0.5332604050636292,
0.14039161801338196,
0.07072897255420685,
0.7342880964279175,
-0.15681147575378418,
0.543515145778656,
-0.44398534297943115,
0.5565912127494812,
-0.7131142020225525,
0.19049295783042908,
0.28082945942878723,
-0.5199058651924133,
-0.2919507622718811,
0.5292815566062927,
0.0016908821417018771,
-0.13119345903396606,
0.36927011609077454,
0.7548959255218506,
-0.12263282388448715,
-0.13034528493881226,
0.3698558807373047,
0.04835075885057449,
0.6126061677932739,
0.3162062168121338,
0.9388161897659302,
-0.482865571975708,
0.46588197350502014,
0.10092705488204956,
-0.4252748191356659,
-0.4946753978729248,
-0.6682664752006531,
-0.7380387187004089,
-0.6476078033447266,
-0.15491202473640442,
0.015568921342492104,
-0.16317178308963776,
0.8109189867973328,
0.7084333300590515,
-0.6186336278915405,
-0.4220000207424164,
0.2504008412361145,
0.06396973878145218,
-0.08935804665088654,
-0.07178616523742676,
0.16995011270046234,
-0.28464770317077637,
-1.041178584098816,
1.1964950561523438,
0.18562141060829163,
-0.09208624064922333,
-0.3778596818447113,
-0.5631829500198364,
-0.4045175611972809,
0.13698391616344452,
0.9871906042098999,
0.7374224066734314,
-0.6034067869186401,
-0.2259991466999054,
0.21545472741127014,
0.2808435559272766,
0.03319988399744034,
0.7887513041496277,
-0.7154266834259033,
0.8033175468444824,
0.45004814863204956,
0.7106301784515381,
0.5147176384925842,
-0.188340425491333,
0.07093381136655807,
-0.9876761436462402,
0.5417152047157288,
0.3711318075656891,
0.5743723511695862,
0.3631127178668976,
-0.3116435706615448,
0.7284560203552246,
-0.03316659852862358,
-0.6979101896286011,
-0.618955671787262,
0.15121358633041382,
-1.3848328590393066,
-0.35596999526023865,
1.355063796043396,
0.02651798166334629,
-0.4631648063659668,
-0.24848006665706635,
-0.42918553948402405,
-0.031150298193097115,
-0.5027183294296265,
0.7820254564285278,
0.5139562487602234,
-0.6022689938545227,
-0.08718129247426987,
-0.5594403147697449,
-0.030666939914226532,
0.116280697286129,
-1.090658187866211,
-0.17004963755607605,
0.7016911506652832,
-0.0815051943063736,
0.30248308181762695,
0.7424077391624451,
0.16856087744235992,
0.5372817516326904,
-0.30546462535858154,
-0.06572074443101883,
-0.08273421227931976,
-0.30531519651412964,
0.02501027286052704,
0.02115822024643421,
-0.07056442648172379,
-0.7326765060424805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14497v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14497v1 | CodeRAG-Bench: Can Retrieval Augment Code Generation? | 2024-06-20T16:59:52 | 2024-06-20T16:59:52 | Zora Zhiruo Wang, Akari Asai, Xinyan Velocity Yu, Frank F. Xu, Yiqing Xie, Graham Neubig, Daniel Fried | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL | While language models (LMs) have proven remarkably adept at generating code,
many programs are challenging for LMs to generate using their parametric
knowledge alone. Providing external contexts such as library documentation can
facilitate generating accurate and functional code. Despite the success of
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) in various text-oriented tasks, its
potential for improving code generation remains under-explored. In this work,
we conduct a systematic, large-scale analysis by asking: in what scenarios can
retrieval benefit code generation models? and what challenges remain? We first
curate a comprehensive evaluation benchmark, CodeRAG-Bench, encompassing three
categories of code generation tasks, including basic programming, open-domain,
and repository-level problems. We aggregate documents from five sources for
models to retrieve contexts: competition solutions, online tutorials, library
documentation, StackOverflow posts, and GitHub repositories. We examine
top-performing models on CodeRAG-Bench by providing contexts retrieved from one
or multiple sources. While notable gains are made in final code generation by
retrieving high-quality contexts across various settings, our analysis reveals
room for improvement -- current retrievers still struggle to fetch useful
contexts especially with limited lexical overlap, and generators fail to
improve with limited context lengths or abilities to integrate additional
contexts. We hope CodeRAG-Bench serves as an effective testbed to encourage
further development of advanced code-oriented RAG methods. | [
-0.3982562720775604,
-0.3506089448928833,
0.3615969717502594,
0.03358734771609306,
-0.12203360348939896,
0.03086152859032154,
-0.3835766017436981,
-0.5029315948486328,
-0.15891045331954956,
0.41736865043640137,
-0.14746573567390442,
-0.052286237478256226,
-0.33341142535209656,
0.21831193566322327,
-0.7615170478820801,
1.0904537439346313,
0.0021061499137431383,
0.12388785928487778,
-0.32387009263038635,
-0.09424030780792236,
-0.8067145347595215,
-0.6464968919754028,
-0.19971898198127747,
-0.17017048597335815,
0.23535002768039703,
0.26595526933670044,
0.24334648251533508,
0.4597298204898834,
0.5597213506698608,
0.24976402521133423,
0.024301551282405853,
0.010589693672955036,
-0.6188217997550964,
0.5183811187744141,
-0.013231171295046806,
-0.33516398072242737,
-0.2225438505411148,
-0.19968391954898834,
0.5243862867355347,
0.593308687210083,
-0.18428966403007507,
0.30364614725112915,
0.21426603198051453,
0.7592639327049255,
-0.8644620180130005,
-0.08881004899740219,
-0.9092214107513428,
-0.10788830369710922,
-0.33813461661338806,
-0.4312947690486908,
-0.42696258425712585,
-0.3647366464138031,
-0.2621196210384369,
-0.24509328603744507,
0.29478636384010315,
-0.15679436922073364,
0.6927920579910278,
0.3660259544849396,
-0.2874920070171356,
-0.5033860206604004,
-0.6034688949584961,
0.5927533507347107,
-0.3739432394504547,
0.2471572905778885,
0.4293389320373535,
0.46104103326797485,
-0.021051783114671707,
-1.0727943181991577,
-0.14568671584129333,
-0.22951127588748932,
-0.18596100807189941,
0.018082372844219208,
-0.13321371376514435,
-0.4492206871509552,
0.5990082621574402,
0.5507449507713318,
-0.4123191237449646,
-0.3323262929916382,
-0.5601961016654968,
0.1532326638698578,
0.4617338180541992,
0.12706813216209412,
0.3108268976211548,
-0.4102746844291687,
-0.235319584608078,
-0.20950980484485626,
-0.9214468598365784,
0.08273982256650925,
0.20561502873897552,
0.16462716460227966,
0.18539181351661682,
0.5203956365585327,
-0.13968314230442047,
0.7781434059143066,
-0.16865694522857666,
0.22398896515369415,
0.22364072501659393,
-0.5029290914535522,
0.05474809557199478,
-0.22008675336837769,
0.21328122913837433,
0.23063687980175018,
0.010577826760709286,
-0.26499754190444946,
-0.5259571671485901,
0.07810303568840027,
0.653481662273407,
-0.9019502997398376,
-0.11016743630170822,
0.2019968032836914,
-0.4247589111328125,
-0.3664940297603607,
0.2501906156539917,
-0.6936339139938354,
-0.35471653938293457,
-0.17387624084949493,
0.2762778401374817,
-0.38464391231536865,
-0.2488103061914444,
-0.2326473891735077,
-0.6694673299789429,
0.19015155732631683,
-0.029080206528306007,
-0.5169662833213806,
0.12844491004943848,
0.7823448181152344,
0.6497924327850342,
-0.12658371031284332,
-0.03604121878743172,
-0.7266408801078796,
0.02114184759557247,
-0.551119863986969,
0.8322703838348389,
-0.6930827498435974,
-0.5687108039855957,
0.15501509606838226,
-0.21212825179100037,
0.05796777456998825,
-0.8943288326263428,
0.5197649002075195,
-0.6124308109283447,
0.058725930750370026,
-0.316317617893219,
-0.509530782699585,
0.30237793922424316,
0.10193789005279541,
-0.6929387450218201,
1.192701816558838,
0.3207239508628845,
-0.7264809012413025,
0.3958544135093689,
-0.23031215369701385,
-0.25271880626678467,
0.37436631321907043,
-0.569322943687439,
-0.09680859744548798,
0.4387444853782654,
0.030193191021680832,
0.19855135679244995,
-0.47052884101867676,
0.5565713047981262,
-0.09057999402284622,
-0.5851483345031738,
0.42649832367897034,
-0.09748288244009018,
0.4979063868522644,
0.4438019394874573,
-0.40767377614974976,
-0.12708371877670288,
-0.6277969479560852,
0.3187384605407715,
0.02693088911473751,
-0.5558794140815735,
-0.38024425506591797,
0.006030174437910318,
0.1050448939204216,
0.19333277642726898,
0.1276959925889969,
-0.23522178828716278,
0.1149219274520874,
-0.15441106259822845,
0.10365325212478638,
0.46732547879219055,
0.11101561039686203,
0.38041749596595764,
-0.6482599377632141,
0.6913761496543884,
-0.30695661902427673,
-0.29987573623657227,
-0.6407656669616699,
-0.24882325530052185,
-0.40429091453552246,
-0.16379036009311676,
0.5003400444984436,
0.11313172429800034,
-0.8799288272857666,
0.01879516802728176,
-0.22877155244350433,
-0.46004897356033325,
-0.2703727185726166,
0.10859131813049316,
0.8218860030174255,
0.5356805324554443,
0.3625084161758423,
-0.30280888080596924,
-0.7216070294380188,
-0.6692453622817993,
-0.5605653524398804,
0.17381630837917328,
-0.02808726578950882,
0.6368632912635803,
0.4021989107131958,
-0.18403808772563934,
0.8564660549163818,
-0.45134902000427246,
0.06645862758159637,
-0.30186837911605835,
0.12223769724369049,
0.2898702919483185,
0.44971907138824463,
0.6620636582374573,
-0.850975513458252,
-0.5438478589057922,
0.03904857486486435,
-0.5815728902816772,
-0.49507075548171997,
0.24669744074344635,
-0.10726917535066605,
0.3355273902416229,
0.5745888352394104,
-0.35632556676864624,
0.27692198753356934,
0.4680401384830475,
-0.00961788184940815,
0.7195382118225098,
-0.12715953588485718,
0.20573866367340088,
-0.8730272650718689,
0.7400372624397278,
-0.35431063175201416,
-0.022318808361887932,
-0.5359119176864624,
0.7309083938598633,
0.4417560398578644,
-0.35632261633872986,
0.05088391527533531,
0.7805861234664917,
-0.47636306285858154,
-0.44144871830940247,
-0.4987310767173767,
0.14911970496177673,
0.012493724934756756,
0.21157141029834747,
-0.04656433314085007,
1.171491026878357,
0.2509961426258087,
-0.5936880707740784,
-0.27707648277282715,
0.04507296904921532,
-0.6248463988304138,
0.39383068680763245,
-0.6418094038963318,
0.1777666211128235,
-0.07750637829303741,
0.5260171294212341,
-0.7668377757072449,
-0.6188775300979614,
-0.21272961795330048,
-0.3823694884777069,
0.41203951835632324,
-0.18227379024028778,
-0.37987908720970154,
-0.24934226274490356,
-0.33347731828689575,
0.4599969685077667,
0.7055672407150269,
-0.6220433115959167,
-0.017398511990904808,
0.4863223731517792,
-0.17935024201869965,
-0.8380519151687622,
-0.34694841504096985,
-0.04833155870437622,
-0.16230271756649017,
-0.3195076584815979,
0.5620858669281006,
-0.08331751078367233,
-0.4859819710254669,
0.020969517529010773,
-0.37093132734298706,
-0.14000888168811798,
0.1304684579372406,
0.10568470507860184,
0.04869382455945015,
-0.06348463892936707,
0.42652007937431335,
-0.042562391608953476,
-0.057218339294195175,
-0.03636033460497856,
-0.21715502440929413,
0.5520744323730469,
-0.03585154190659523,
-0.22108620405197144,
0.4302001893520355,
0.2606360912322998,
0.1541152447462082,
-0.47157666087150574,
0.23541481792926788,
0.5626340508460999,
-0.3382178246974945,
-0.5043184757232666,
-0.6173173785209656,
-0.09641849994659424,
-0.4602365791797638,
0.2866130769252777,
-0.45880505442619324,
-0.7383328676223755,
0.3739868998527527,
-0.10032300651073456,
-0.01329271774739027,
0.31578391790390015,
0.48722222447395325,
0.13239693641662598,
0.8379305005073547,
0.4224712550640106,
0.14239846169948578,
0.5693793892860413,
-0.2514144480228424,
-0.04971815645694733,
-0.9173447489738464,
-0.13518892228603363,
-0.9863234162330627,
-0.23205329477787018,
-0.41349995136260986,
-0.5574913024902344,
0.49284443259239197,
0.5357150435447693,
-0.07407208532094955,
0.5411487817764282,
-0.5537518262863159,
0.39332300424575806,
0.4066489040851593,
0.12092389911413193,
0.31867334246635437,
0.09423106163740158,
-0.22275662422180176,
-0.07714323699474335,
-0.8529804348945618,
-0.4166184365749359,
1.1548881530761719,
-0.00005500133192981593,
0.5290098190307617,
0.14736774563789368,
0.8705355525016785,
0.2690240442752838,
0.6244479417800903,
-0.29707154631614685,
0.3344259262084961,
-0.06926870346069336,
-0.7614479064941406,
0.1547979712486267,
-0.6129117608070374,
-1.0098309516906738,
0.2640819847583771,
0.10912218689918518,
-0.6052530407905579,
0.17902830243110657,
-0.014767431654036045,
-0.12692877650260925,
-0.22150929272174835,
-0.5045369267463684,
0.9119264483451843,
-0.13491927087306976,
-0.7100014686584473,
-0.27265965938568115,
-0.33766719698905945,
0.5652942657470703,
-0.3264599144458771,
0.3470665514469147,
0.138739675283432,
-0.1309882253408432,
0.3026878237724304,
-0.4750937819480896,
0.3132331967353821,
-0.27246373891830444,
-0.1972263604402542,
0.4528667628765106,
0.19391633570194244,
0.3292808532714844,
0.08703550696372986,
-0.3946485221385956,
-0.33412012457847595,
-0.0006276787607930601,
-0.22776095569133759,
-0.5826377868652344,
0.808904767036438,
-0.2908598780632019,
-0.5949978828430176,
0.08786153793334961,
-0.6046554446220398,
-0.27938762307167053,
0.16722773015499115,
0.32117754220962524,
0.9180183410644531,
-0.0326613113284111,
0.6116441488265991,
0.24065758287906647,
-0.4104572832584381,
0.5226635336875916,
0.2683798372745514,
-0.3223475217819214,
-0.27507853507995605,
0.8591160774230957,
-0.03889377415180206,
0.004601282998919487,
0.19803324341773987,
0.02381274476647377,
-0.23891226947307587,
-0.338267058134079,
-0.47842615842819214,
-0.12141130119562149,
-0.7931199073791504,
-0.578479528427124,
-0.5156888365745544,
-0.12068796157836914,
-0.23106147348880768,
-0.10726825147867203,
-0.013501503504812717,
-0.5448130965232849,
0.07102420181035995,
0.14481636881828308,
0.18026505410671234,
0.7118049263954163,
-0.03611396998167038,
-0.059481121599674225,
-0.9592954516410828,
0.21246656775474548,
0.08237659186124802,
0.36942073702812195,
0.0733398050069809,
-0.4636392891407013,
-0.3415951132774353,
-0.11082616448402405,
-0.23998673260211945,
-0.8668959736824036,
0.4091503322124481,
0.07396353781223297,
0.5886006951332092,
-0.23832449316978455,
0.1095135286450386,
0.7716836929321289,
-0.5789324641227722,
0.6521518230438232,
-0.25340306758880615,
-0.7418028712272644,
0.4980536103248596,
-0.568732500076294,
0.36870506405830383,
0.5563777685165405,
0.1456078439950943,
-0.18452849984169006,
-0.45896074175834656,
-0.5742716193199158,
-0.8646135926246643,
0.68443363904953,
0.25983333587646484,
0.3285660445690155,
-0.2849076986312866,
0.498892217874527,
0.06144418939948082,
0.33534303307533264,
-0.6700307726860046,
0.13482730090618134,
0.0007067342521622777,
0.020173363387584686,
0.0889754369854927,
-0.0978330671787262,
-0.1497940570116043,
-0.06272222846746445,
0.3941010534763336,
-0.1591983437538147,
0.24579262733459473,
0.10227726399898529,
-0.22005963325500488,
-0.1852746456861496,
0.3565647006034851,
0.5966019630432129,
0.8982560038566589,
-0.09177578240633011,
-0.15978997945785522,
-0.04120413213968277,
-0.12679436802864075,
-0.1363486647605896,
0.2151188999414444,
-0.11804023385047913,
0.12443522363901138,
0.2916869521141052,
0.44712966680526733,
0.5404340028762817,
-1.0265554189682007,
0.5759832859039307,
-0.08089505136013031,
0.029556309804320335,
-0.31905126571655273,
0.41008999943733215,
-0.08513164520263672,
0.3109763264656067,
0.8493261337280273,
0.04521634802222252,
0.24237747490406036,
-0.5164492726325989,
0.6070972084999084,
0.5601428747177124,
-0.08745581656694412,
0.02404993399977684,
0.7022987008094788,
0.07382380962371826,
-0.2530502676963806,
0.308648943901062,
-0.17201390862464905,
-0.3840712308883667,
0.8334619998931885,
0.6962382197380066,
0.7211505770683289,
0.14773999154567719,
-0.1148170456290245,
0.6922205686569214,
-0.10218536108732224,
-0.12028152495622635,
0.17223891615867615,
-0.42155879735946655,
-0.39192602038383484,
-0.37986138463020325,
-0.7207590341567993,
-0.18168726563453674,
-0.07437381148338318,
-0.7903317809104919,
0.23169216513633728,
0.01619948446750641,
-0.23689846694469452,
-0.34768402576446533,
0.025491630658507347,
-0.5939667820930481,
-0.08717308193445206,
-0.13564392924308777,
1.0043085813522339,
-0.15460485219955444,
0.8342351317405701,
0.7448232173919678,
-0.5149605870246887,
-0.709084689617157,
0.18867921829223633,
-0.2924007773399353,
-0.42001068592071533,
0.7766485810279846,
0.32708626985549927,
0.03561444208025932,
0.02465105801820755,
-0.42265328764915466,
-0.6959431767463684,
1.124979853630066,
0.1480126827955246,
-0.34259381890296936,
-0.05352451652288437,
-0.4085105061531067,
0.7500143647193909,
-0.42548486590385437,
0.32910871505737305,
0.4064362347126007,
0.3017134368419647,
-0.2376837581396103,
-0.7758222818374634,
0.008096697740256786,
-0.6884806156158447,
0.3121364414691925,
0.22701478004455566,
-0.2085646241903305,
0.8942252397537231,
-0.015906615182757378,
-0.39195773005485535,
0.5151357054710388,
0.2271372377872467,
0.6415931582450867,
0.21982614696025848,
0.13857373595237732,
0.42641687393188477,
0.4771215617656708,
-0.010609276592731476,
1.5673127174377441,
-0.9753484129905701,
0.22178789973258972,
1.085405707359314,
-0.3719671070575714,
1.0954489707946777,
0.28769099712371826,
0.010499288327991962,
0.643103301525116,
0.17372706532478333,
0.18508698046207428,
0.4842008650302887,
0.18495464324951172,
-0.09686006605625153,
0.09392118453979492,
-0.1908501237630844,
-0.8741995096206665,
0.3314998745918274,
0.4245285093784332,
-0.47408196330070496,
-0.3039725422859192,
-0.2050255537033081,
-0.3048457205295563,
0.308102548122406,
-0.050283972173929214,
0.6439614295959473,
0.005046436563134193,
-1.2435801029205322,
0.7554166316986084,
0.12258747965097427,
0.41210147738456726,
-0.43409958481788635,
-0.18222136795520782,
-0.5712510347366333,
0.32887476682662964,
-0.11493861675262451,
-0.32525578141212463,
0.3409970998764038,
0.41973939538002014,
-0.022260338068008423,
-0.3960505723953247,
1.0436062812805176,
-0.35534828901290894,
-0.11476074159145355,
0.2475190907716751,
0.8667733073234558,
0.016679983586072922,
0.026773223653435707,
-0.4723370373249054,
0.33692431449890137,
-0.27919483184814453,
-0.18674826622009277,
0.5677441954612732,
0.3201889991760254,
0.11319224536418915,
0.27709245681762695,
0.4405408501625061,
-0.1776527464389801,
0.07117180526256561,
0.047058094292879105,
0.9729763269424438,
-0.4116278290748596,
-0.15528470277786255,
-0.46408167481422424,
0.5327537655830383,
-0.1604168713092804,
-0.29009750485420227,
0.8537797927856445,
0.6117591261863708,
1.0338455438613892,
-0.21294212341308594,
0.6275748610496521,
-0.5009487271308899,
0.575932502746582,
-0.4117007851600647,
0.5464230179786682,
-0.7422123551368713,
0.46021702885627747,
-0.4068492352962494,
-1.0190452337265015,
-0.0868201032280922,
0.5408949851989746,
-0.13338905572891235,
0.28916242718696594,
0.7375801801681519,
0.8815587162971497,
-0.01721467822790146,
-0.09964445233345032,
0.1806110292673111,
-0.19825559854507446,
0.06258957833051682,
0.42638447880744934,
0.999931812286377,
-0.5493707060813904,
0.7402826547622681,
-0.15830549597740173,
-0.1300320327281952,
-0.2298949658870697,
-0.668242871761322,
-0.5476624965667725,
-0.7138925194740295,
0.09688077867031097,
-0.4020397961139679,
0.18474672734737396,
0.5923140645027161,
0.5154826641082764,
-0.48455774784088135,
-0.49434083700180054,
-0.3882451355457306,
-0.04905318468809128,
-0.14606525003910065,
-0.2736850082874298,
0.011595712043344975,
-1.087752103805542,
-0.7956138253211975,
0.5681978464126587,
-0.05797825753688812,
-0.44832414388656616,
-0.099245585501194,
-0.14692053198814392,
0.03692777454853058,
-0.190864697098732,
0.5424055457115173,
0.33263784646987915,
-0.5019561648368835,
0.04114822670817375,
0.2254798412322998,
-0.6177682280540466,
-0.03235903009772301,
1.2790071964263916,
-1.030950903892517,
0.3696272671222687,
0.6822057366371155,
0.9772969484329224,
0.5996667146682739,
0.27056705951690674,
0.7777395844459534,
-1.094892144203186,
0.028537655249238014,
0.10900618880987167,
0.49343571066856384,
0.08887334913015366,
-0.08052109181880951,
0.9736365079879761,
0.021446989849209785,
-0.6687864065170288,
-1.1387441158294678,
0.17659682035446167,
-0.20876291394233704,
-0.6581091284751892,
1.1713225841522217,
-0.07844217121601105,
0.014205527491867542,
0.060427166521549225,
-0.16635194420814514,
0.048938777297735214,
-0.03467894345521927,
0.7348605990409851,
0.5566858649253845,
-0.09795225411653519,
-0.1543591022491455,
-0.9398187398910522,
0.7196012139320374,
0.5940930843353271,
-0.9016125798225403,
0.04192890599370003,
0.8811790347099304,
0.03186164051294327,
0.1845468431711197,
0.8616700172424316,
-0.3819710314273834,
0.5949974656105042,
0.15700885653495789,
-0.08181290328502655,
0.04822908714413643,
-0.4666616916656494,
-0.4270038306713104,
0.3964260518550873,
0.15606403350830078,
0.330904096364975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14496v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14496v1 | African or European Swallow? Benchmarking Large Vision-Language Models for Fine-Grained Object Classification | 2024-06-20T16:59:39 | 2024-06-20T16:59:39 | Gregor Geigle, Radu Timofte, Goran Glavaš | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recent Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) demonstrate impressive abilities
on numerous image understanding and reasoning tasks. The task of fine-grained
object classification (e.g., distinction between \textit{animal species}),
however, has been probed insufficiently, despite its downstream importance. We
fill this evaluation gap by creating \texttt{FOCI} (\textbf{F}ine-grained
\textbf{O}bject \textbf{C}lass\textbf{I}fication), a difficult multiple-choice
benchmark for fine-grained object classification, from existing object
classification datasets: (1) multiple-choice avoids ambiguous answers
associated with casting classification as open-ended QA task; (2) we retain
classification difficulty by mining negative labels with a CLIP model.
\texttt{FOCI}\xspace complements five popular classification datasets with four
domain-specific subsets from ImageNet-21k. We benchmark 12 public LVLMs on
\texttt{FOCI} and show that it tests for a \textit{complementary skill} to
established image understanding and reasoning benchmarks. Crucially, CLIP
models exhibit dramatically better performance than LVLMs. Since the image
encoders of LVLMs come from these CLIP models, this points to inadequate
alignment for fine-grained object distinction between the encoder and the LLM
and warrants (pre)training data with more fine-grained annotation. We release
our code at \url{https://github.com/gregor-ge/FOCI-Benchmark}. | [
-0.580804169178009,
-0.5703384876251221,
0.20051342248916626,
-0.0857442170381546,
-0.24335385859012604,
-0.21074426174163818,
-0.18749016523361206,
-0.9902602434158325,
-0.008428752422332764,
0.4483483135700226,
-0.24914416670799255,
-0.33574604988098145,
-0.3860967755317688,
0.1677887737751007,
-0.37947848439216614,
0.434360533952713,
-0.180840864777565,
0.25946342945098877,
-0.29468661546707153,
-0.4022097587585449,
-0.3873193860054016,
-0.535757303237915,
-0.5186042189598083,
-0.3614332675933838,
0.6685563325881958,
0.27927228808403015,
0.712913990020752,
0.8128441572189331,
0.6198962926864624,
0.2594001293182373,
-0.21485485136508942,
0.43792834877967834,
-0.3517550230026245,
-0.1623414158821106,
-0.35124471783638,
-0.38588228821754456,
-0.15708279609680176,
-0.2261960506439209,
0.2675444185733795,
0.6305680274963379,
0.024926690384745598,
0.14069819450378418,
0.08404924720525742,
0.4452507197856903,
-1.1486808061599731,
0.14005018770694733,
-0.7045834064483643,
0.22039009630680084,
-0.471447616815567,
-0.04689900577068329,
-0.3492797613143921,
-0.054535966366529465,
0.13225924968719482,
-0.5373510122299194,
0.20307298004627228,
0.06639275699853897,
1.2843605279922485,
0.1303684264421463,
-0.23099501430988312,
-0.07724954932928085,
-0.4450697600841522,
0.7454721331596375,
-0.48336121439933777,
0.6055929660797119,
0.2677166759967804,
0.5068960189819336,
-0.08820841461420059,
-0.8174423575401306,
-0.5103728771209717,
-0.11155001074075699,
0.2696956694126129,
-0.041617538779973984,
-0.11400267481803894,
0.11636289209127426,
0.20639491081237793,
0.6262240409851074,
-0.26481956243515015,
0.4742974638938904,
-0.4108589291572571,
-0.28700608015060425,
0.7058746218681335,
-0.07122857123613358,
-0.07250112295150757,
0.07092691212892532,
-0.3985804617404938,
-0.36735013127326965,
-0.6706436276435852,
0.30318862199783325,
0.1628694236278534,
0.5196877717971802,
0.13690273463726044,
0.7132896184921265,
-0.49932417273521423,
0.8116461038589478,
-0.06345153599977493,
0.0015699723735451698,
0.3265507221221924,
0.12079839408397675,
-0.31012022495269775,
-0.18317943811416626,
0.570690929889679,
0.7938824892044067,
0.49605855345726013,
-0.05301564186811447,
-0.4624910354614258,
0.12067415565252304,
0.21752065420150757,
-1.1160575151443481,
0.008961089886724949,
0.0192940142005682,
-0.5910806655883789,
-0.08950210362672806,
0.11794958263635635,
-0.4800753593444824,
-0.4129764437675476,
-0.319832980632782,
0.6867141127586365,
-0.34366554021835327,
0.23317399621009827,
0.2621646523475647,
-0.02466624043881893,
0.6196237802505493,
0.41877129673957825,
-0.9009718298912048,
0.39752519130706787,
0.9253187775611877,
0.8883187770843506,
-0.24672719836235046,
-0.4460536539554596,
-0.6742673516273499,
-0.3391299247741699,
-0.3807397484779358,
0.8703216910362244,
-0.5687977075576782,
-0.12675251066684723,
0.4159117639064789,
0.3222542107105255,
0.15306389331817627,
-0.90706866979599,
0.5162557363510132,
-0.3552054762840271,
-0.31917691230773926,
-0.4701022505760193,
-0.6565007567405701,
-0.4383004307746887,
0.4851914346218109,
-0.41456225514411926,
0.9191362261772156,
0.05690598115324974,
-0.5337064862251282,
0.5354079604148865,
-0.18388360738754272,
-0.2452724426984787,
0.03792490437626839,
-0.3147296607494354,
-0.2766514718532562,
0.054369330406188965,
0.2822815179824829,
0.7567877769470215,
-0.5239332914352417,
0.2013927847146988,
-0.9256033897399902,
-0.35923656821250916,
0.25919654965400696,
-0.3838596045970917,
0.48523521423339844,
0.3106636106967926,
-0.006709137000143528,
0.018605321645736694,
-0.5730277299880981,
0.02148646116256714,
0.12445086985826492,
-0.008541346527636051,
-0.397085964679718,
0.09138135612010956,
0.0967535674571991,
0.07334892451763153,
0.12120065093040466,
-0.6744065880775452,
0.19786082208156586,
-0.011145301163196564,
0.4187662899494171,
0.5256080031394958,
-0.16146063804626465,
0.06362906843423843,
-0.3875623047351837,
0.17009370028972626,
-0.02281501330435276,
0.3650195300579071,
-0.1711443066596985,
-0.3191268742084503,
-0.7481715679168701,
-0.15531015396118164,
0.22688162326812744,
0.36000263690948486,
-0.8205704092979431,
0.11362404376268387,
-0.11075685173273087,
-0.496120423078537,
-0.43035390973091125,
-0.0881434977054596,
0.4869788587093353,
0.4985211193561554,
0.39924225211143494,
-0.6181868314743042,
-0.24458280205726624,
-1.0583022832870483,
-0.006796923466026783,
0.2063247561454773,
-0.2024427205324173,
0.5871279239654541,
0.6262853145599365,
-0.3158200979232788,
0.7214676737785339,
-0.6097447872161865,
-0.3667541444301605,
0.22746093571186066,
-0.026355762034654617,
-0.07819689065217972,
0.40623316168785095,
0.7755192518234253,
-0.8384432196617126,
-0.15375663340091705,
0.24656301736831665,
-0.7296412587165833,
-0.06059500575065613,
0.31367892026901245,
-0.09795235097408295,
0.13896869122982025,
0.5043594241142273,
-0.3341107666492462,
0.33350253105163574,
0.3266131579875946,
-0.1406383514404297,
0.5149149894714355,
-0.06879337131977081,
0.17610977590084076,
-0.6595107913017273,
0.08192755281925201,
0.04644041508436203,
-0.19594469666481018,
-0.43619754910469055,
0.2967030107975006,
0.12387256324291229,
-0.08718600869178772,
-0.8388257622718811,
0.7412861585617065,
-0.4753090739250183,
-0.45701831579208374,
-0.1250307857990265,
0.20479148626327515,
0.05751943215727806,
0.4703836739063263,
0.42437270283699036,
0.6347381472587585,
0.6675581336021423,
-0.6197863817214966,
0.15716564655303955,
0.2777971625328064,
-0.4524691700935364,
0.632383406162262,
-0.5653723478317261,
-0.04508185386657715,
0.09727141261100769,
0.05175509303808212,
-0.515490710735321,
-0.28455328941345215,
0.03549274429678917,
-0.05974041298031807,
0.3501192331314087,
-0.1163235455751419,
-0.18680515885353088,
-0.5826128125190735,
-0.4183322787284851,
0.5879810452461243,
0.30293434858322144,
-0.721541702747345,
0.38763535022735596,
0.4242722690105438,
0.08638294041156769,
-0.6618238091468811,
-0.8464934825897217,
-0.16584129631519318,
0.08415515720844269,
-0.5713779926300049,
0.21347257494926453,
0.15022583305835724,
-0.04292679205536842,
0.014759574085474014,
-0.3196446895599365,
-0.29232972860336304,
0.03376704826951027,
0.14123807847499847,
0.10389526933431625,
-0.5031644701957703,
0.018866054713726044,
-0.28653886914253235,
0.2348276674747467,
-0.14648915827274323,
-0.43704602122306824,
0.43894481658935547,
-0.30847978591918945,
-0.4639417827129364,
-0.14709655940532684,
0.10203354060649872,
0.5108264684677124,
-0.5043806433677673,
0.38506439328193665,
0.5946072936058044,
-0.48506051301956177,
-0.06918736547231674,
-0.6839607357978821,
-0.12428711354732513,
-0.447187215089798,
0.42553383111953735,
-0.44140732288360596,
-0.8367340564727783,
0.5959690809249878,
0.1077699065208435,
-0.04766745865345001,
0.3789844512939453,
0.20744402706623077,
-0.028648432344198227,
0.5220601558685303,
0.34330055117607117,
0.021748552098870277,
0.6547063589096069,
-0.7161374688148499,
-0.25707685947418213,
-0.8853527903556824,
-0.16382759809494019,
-0.540795087814331,
-0.39215749502182007,
-0.5736605525016785,
-0.7350260019302368,
-0.07894252985715866,
0.1950584501028061,
-0.21472632884979248,
0.08350574970245361,
-0.5164891481399536,
0.6591139435768127,
0.40355759859085083,
0.2650375962257385,
0.027973471209406853,
-0.12026747316122055,
-0.003910593688488007,
0.24002444744110107,
-0.6276426315307617,
-0.48115605115890503,
0.9484929442405701,
0.3910454213619232,
0.8395721912384033,
-0.3212234377861023,
0.6540467143058777,
0.27090051770210266,
0.3042919337749481,
-0.9659830927848816,
0.6356707811355591,
-0.7684746980667114,
-0.33907225728034973,
-0.11199075728654861,
-0.2268357276916504,
-0.9980018138885498,
0.5170265436172485,
-0.23836269974708557,
-0.9286947846412659,
0.5491770505905151,
0.2833271622657776,
-0.24568979442119598,
0.45000991225242615,
-0.68357253074646,
1.226333498954773,
-0.364606112241745,
-0.5017364025115967,
0.04551223665475845,
-0.5956478714942932,
0.37848740816116333,
0.11032719165086746,
0.05821730196475983,
-0.34144172072410583,
-0.0410778783261776,
0.610445499420166,
-0.7093911170959473,
0.7049146294593811,
-0.2855088710784912,
0.033200185745954514,
0.5142958760261536,
0.023175936192274094,
0.20497341454029083,
-0.20410826802253723,
0.06349708139896393,
0.43256622552871704,
0.05487643927335739,
-0.4146313965320587,
-0.27427923679351807,
0.44843047857284546,
-0.6160539388656616,
-0.3004634380340576,
-0.35294488072395325,
-0.3140783905982971,
-0.08834920823574066,
0.38607358932495117,
0.3892851769924164,
0.7804269194602966,
-0.14296889305114746,
0.49443110823631287,
0.4895436465740204,
-0.0005822309176437557,
0.31103071570396423,
0.38834506273269653,
-0.42704692482948303,
-0.3256485164165497,
0.995201587677002,
0.17057687044143677,
0.29736635088920593,
0.7333522439002991,
0.1823587715625763,
-0.30483371019363403,
-0.7728376984596252,
-0.388165682554245,
0.09852638095617294,
-0.7853978872299194,
-0.5097987651824951,
-0.3521474003791809,
-0.3160251975059509,
-0.027055568993091583,
-0.3417494297027588,
-0.5017566084861755,
-0.13981381058692932,
-0.35008978843688965,
0.18996001780033112,
0.18533475697040558,
0.5800203680992126,
0.1313723474740982,
0.2502347230911255,
-0.8785761594772339,
0.41943109035491943,
0.4996436536312103,
0.41377511620521545,
0.1402222067117691,
-0.45103827118873596,
-0.21485863626003265,
0.15795432031154633,
-0.4884686768054962,
-0.6110108494758606,
0.18325352668762207,
0.4014836549758911,
0.49432095885276794,
0.7040842771530151,
-0.032529350370168686,
0.9689707159996033,
-0.4886840879917145,
0.7169104814529419,
0.02341463789343834,
-0.9951527714729309,
0.23049159348011017,
-0.10912385582923889,
0.1682841181755066,
0.6198020577430725,
0.1619056761264801,
-0.6020980477333069,
-0.48390161991119385,
-0.27252259850502014,
-0.7996885180473328,
0.70968097448349,
0.0037709008902311325,
-0.24164071679115295,
-0.042723361402750015,
0.3011833727359772,
0.2962418496608734,
0.2535442113876343,
-0.525478184223175,
0.11927858740091324,
-0.11632391810417175,
-0.11385590583086014,
-0.19971570372581482,
-0.15960626304149628,
0.24010661244392395,
-0.22568772733211517,
0.5501061081886292,
-0.4285675287246704,
0.06205551698803902,
0.5126491785049438,
-0.3475578725337982,
0.10627995431423187,
-0.005745112430304289,
0.6431468725204468,
0.3767237961292267,
-0.3707573711872101,
0.1174527108669281,
0.16334950923919678,
-0.5520076751708984,
-0.016152366995811462,
0.2926672399044037,
-0.32096603512763977,
-0.23791460692882538,
0.5064535737037659,
0.9245755672454834,
0.2767455577850342,
-0.6898065209388733,
0.6080169677734375,
-0.04249110072851181,
-0.16134457290172577,
0.018889212980866432,
0.016532685607671738,
-0.24568280577659607,
0.40506625175476074,
0.24716004729270935,
0.08017730712890625,
0.2618214786052704,
-0.5924525260925293,
0.20655979216098785,
0.489258348941803,
-0.3498471975326538,
-0.1929377019405365,
0.48917728662490845,
0.3912205696105957,
-0.30006644129753113,
0.36227527260780334,
-0.2609611451625824,
-0.5914133787155151,
0.6252599954605103,
0.2671490013599396,
0.971158504486084,
-0.04025253653526306,
-0.00977555476129055,
0.2785276472568512,
0.13609473407268524,
-0.2623623013496399,
0.4200504720211029,
-0.14199699461460114,
-0.8337424397468567,
-0.1399202197790146,
-0.6835647225379944,
-0.5744215846061707,
0.11969718337059021,
-0.7861897945404053,
0.40880918502807617,
-0.2533408999443054,
-0.015064729377627373,
0.2201652079820633,
-0.05693559721112251,
-0.7923729419708252,
0.29872840642929077,
0.4973752796649933,
1.3419721126556396,
-0.8663520216941833,
0.71435546875,
0.6474550366401672,
-0.31401318311691284,
-0.6221919059753418,
-0.03954619914293289,
-0.244643434882164,
-0.7765591144561768,
0.35886281728744507,
0.6324768662452698,
-0.18075744807720184,
-0.4243558943271637,
-0.5049511194229126,
-0.7041538953781128,
0.9234495759010315,
0.3471088111400604,
-0.7758125066757202,
0.19471707940101624,
-0.0706983357667923,
0.4608544409275055,
-0.5571015477180481,
0.2737842798233032,
0.5157425999641418,
0.25259557366371155,
0.20155341923236847,
-0.9338520765304565,
-0.19639499485492706,
-0.0020171194337308407,
0.20658138394355774,
0.3557535707950592,
-0.8607358932495117,
0.9889829158782959,
-0.21443931758403778,
-0.09240531921386719,
0.2592696249485016,
0.582395613193512,
-0.08522725850343704,
0.5694431662559509,
0.6040421724319458,
0.42658811807632446,
0.8212915062904358,
-0.28040608763694763,
1.0092133283615112,
-0.04452532157301903,
0.3616493046283722,
1.16414475440979,
-0.4940851330757141,
1.3170913457870483,
0.49286073446273804,
-0.17902341485023499,
0.2153070569038391,
0.9013251662254333,
-0.2941471040248871,
0.39127638936042786,
0.1664741188287735,
0.2702539563179016,
-0.287463903427124,
-0.26053762435913086,
-0.27948248386383057,
0.7477816939353943,
0.19725346565246582,
-0.028298303484916687,
-0.15933488309383392,
0.264414519071579,
-0.3349841833114624,
-0.028923282399773598,
-0.6208435297012329,
0.5836139917373657,
0.0950794517993927,
-0.6697760820388794,
0.9114819169044495,
-0.36892443895339966,
0.6904988884925842,
-0.6045981049537659,
0.20063446462154388,
-0.19108347594738007,
0.5540120601654053,
-0.18244880437850952,
-1.0291686058044434,
0.22142018377780914,
0.05068828910589218,
-0.08290274441242218,
0.13030442595481873,
0.5936087369918823,
-0.5454896092414856,
-0.3187263309955597,
0.3996177017688751,
-0.004765151534229517,
0.33214184641838074,
-0.14192348718643188,
-0.49748361110687256,
0.32087358832359314,
-0.1314324587583542,
0.030721083283424377,
0.16489671170711517,
0.40747249126434326,
-0.37648478150367737,
0.8023747205734253,
0.35091033577919006,
0.0010606171563267708,
0.02919931523501873,
0.05926508456468582,
0.7709612250328064,
-0.6455062627792358,
-0.31193092465400696,
-0.6396676898002625,
0.17406368255615234,
-0.07946976274251938,
-0.43967270851135254,
0.38632920384407043,
0.8599298000335693,
1.1431405544281006,
-0.3439072370529175,
0.2245108038187027,
-0.06178918108344078,
0.21301209926605225,
-0.7691475749015808,
0.38773679733276367,
-0.9738189578056335,
-0.19506852328777313,
-0.2578437924385071,
-0.9251273274421692,
-0.3378978371620178,
0.5247448682785034,
-0.2261432260274887,
-0.15556229650974274,
0.5960015058517456,
0.6167632937431335,
-0.27873387932777405,
-0.147173672914505,
0.42903250455856323,
0.24089859426021576,
0.2624681293964386,
0.6379900574684143,
0.9841746687889099,
-0.4727286398410797,
0.5576110482215881,
-0.44765642285346985,
0.025495385751128197,
-0.5845094323158264,
-0.9377368688583374,
-0.7412956357002258,
-0.51389479637146,
-0.39237678050994873,
0.07898532599210739,
0.06127391755580902,
0.8642132878303528,
0.9453171491622925,
-0.9214251637458801,
-0.3003455102443695,
0.09265907853841782,
0.04833285138010979,
-0.3712865710258484,
-0.18975532054901123,
0.22174905240535736,
-0.19390466809272766,
-0.6687243580818176,
0.020031346008181572,
0.24890875816345215,
0.33759328722953796,
-0.08739958703517914,
-0.09475657343864441,
-0.05327225849032402,
0.031723301857709885,
0.7733718156814575,
0.6177014708518982,
-1.036630392074585,
-0.4979455769062042,
-0.07894083857536316,
-0.015701137483119965,
0.20019499957561493,
0.655815839767456,
-0.48665255308151245,
0.5703293085098267,
0.291736364364624,
0.8016804456710815,
0.6407846808433533,
-0.04311775788664818,
0.32649144530296326,
-0.6006813645362854,
0.4672118127346039,
0.2788560092449188,
0.7112628221511841,
0.5004388093948364,
0.06639000028371811,
0.5113476514816284,
0.02318975143134594,
-0.644321620464325,
-0.9824103713035583,
0.10576122999191284,
-1.1644092798233032,
-0.26510748267173767,
0.9705678224563599,
-0.21717485785484314,
-0.5920439958572388,
0.32497650384902954,
-0.4072432219982147,
0.04631951451301575,
-0.3069210648536682,
0.5056036710739136,
0.5030443072319031,
0.09816448390483856,
0.05620017647743225,
-0.4100132882595062,
0.3409252464771271,
0.0803583562374115,
-0.8545762896537781,
0.0939888283610344,
0.5459369421005249,
0.12160314619541168,
0.24287515878677368,
0.25103259086608887,
0.124488964676857,
0.3817972242832184,
0.014438096433877945,
0.21916969120502472,
-0.09937553852796555,
-0.47149479389190674,
-0.3206124007701874,
0.11529482156038284,
0.17369617521762848,
-0.8024157881736755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14492v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14492v1 | Does Object Grounding Really Reduce Hallucination of Large Vision-Language Models? | 2024-06-20T16:56:11 | 2024-06-20T16:56:11 | Gregor Geigle, Radu Timofte, Goran Glavaš | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large vision-language models (LVLMs) have recently dramatically pushed the
state of the art in image captioning and many image understanding tasks (e.g.,
visual question answering). LVLMs, however, often \textit{hallucinate} and
produce captions that mention concepts that cannot be found in the image. These
hallucinations erode the trustworthiness of LVLMs and are arguably among the
main obstacles to their ubiquitous adoption. Recent work suggests that addition
of grounding objectives -- those that explicitly align image regions or objects
to text spans -- reduces the amount of LVLM hallucination. Although intuitive,
this claim is not empirically justified as the reduction effects have been
established, we argue, with flawed evaluation protocols that (i) rely on data
(i.e., MSCOCO) that has been extensively used in LVLM training and (ii) measure
hallucination via question answering rather than open-ended caption generation.
In this work, in contrast, we offer the first systematic analysis of the effect
of fine-grained object grounding on LVLM hallucination under an evaluation
protocol that more realistically captures LVLM hallucination in open
generation. Our extensive experiments over three backbone LLMs reveal that
grounding objectives have little to no effect on object hallucination in open
caption generation. | [
-0.4793384373188019,
-0.6702249646186829,
0.6206095814704895,
-0.11446300148963928,
-0.5369007587432861,
-0.49926137924194336,
-0.19815197587013245,
-0.5546724200248718,
-0.09587553143501282,
0.5866734385490417,
-0.23161563277244568,
-0.6285219192504883,
-0.35186633467674255,
0.10371863842010498,
-0.463316410779953,
0.6244412064552307,
0.042781636118888855,
0.16317394375801086,
-0.5863229036331177,
-0.13442616164684296,
-0.6029323935508728,
-0.6375884413719177,
-0.2945060133934021,
-0.21845029294490814,
0.3546067774295807,
0.09668974578380585,
0.7677271962165833,
0.6900513172149658,
0.7668077945709229,
0.14817234873771667,
-0.16376842558383942,
0.2875332236289978,
-0.6954238414764404,
-0.06038394570350647,
0.018958743661642075,
-0.6251878142356873,
-0.1550995409488678,
-0.061806537210941315,
0.505173921585083,
0.7478764057159424,
0.05742543190717697,
-0.15660254657268524,
-0.08521956205368042,
1.02162504196167,
-0.8545028567314148,
0.11129765957593918,
-0.747591495513916,
0.5936272740364075,
0.2872675955295563,
-0.4764328896999359,
-0.5091570019721985,
0.10070578753948212,
0.023982783779501915,
-0.4172518253326416,
0.3902677595615387,
0.2761692702770233,
1.10306978225708,
0.5881714820861816,
0.2301339954137802,
-0.26615023612976074,
-0.6224295496940613,
0.6128593683242798,
-0.3469406068325043,
0.46057119965553284,
0.3163115084171295,
0.28612038493156433,
0.05174463242292404,
-0.2785012125968933,
-0.5171851515769958,
-0.4240836501121521,
-0.11413426697254181,
0.18595543503761292,
0.1479118913412094,
0.30065080523490906,
0.5490602850914001,
0.4382714033126831,
-0.3393242359161377,
0.00804940052330494,
-0.7830146551132202,
-0.11800924688577652,
0.15740150213241577,
0.039212945848703384,
0.23475748300552368,
-0.24423594772815704,
-0.3019169270992279,
0.005418503191322088,
-0.7946269512176514,
0.040688466280698776,
-0.06363891065120697,
0.23239830136299133,
0.13368722796440125,
1.008716106414795,
-0.28663963079452515,
0.5729649066925049,
0.0031455799471586943,
-0.018928157165646553,
0.061143290251493454,
0.039531588554382324,
-0.4409836232662201,
0.13130371272563934,
0.36628904938697815,
1.091936469078064,
0.5927878022193909,
-0.617777407169342,
-0.13580527901649475,
0.3226053714752197,
0.37882229685783386,
-0.8016653060913086,
-0.15743324160575867,
0.3489639461040497,
-0.6869369745254517,
-0.48599690198898315,
0.5004153847694397,
-0.5046119093894958,
-0.6551980376243591,
-0.4118998050689697,
0.2966042757034302,
-0.2530987858772278,
0.18471847474575043,
0.2828158438205719,
-0.14827843010425568,
0.6406102180480957,
0.4833189845085144,
-0.4474320113658905,
0.36958742141723633,
0.6608898639678955,
1.0786337852478027,
-0.41635429859161377,
-0.449595183134079,
-0.8551913499832153,
0.00299072265625,
-0.6327363848686218,
0.6505889892578125,
-0.35376664996147156,
-0.12291257083415985,
0.014952842146158218,
0.1607392281293869,
0.12223896384239197,
-0.8012071251869202,
0.2682442367076874,
-0.3558694124221802,
0.003965673036873341,
-0.4618033766746521,
-0.15550415217876434,
-0.1910032331943512,
0.23931482434272766,
-0.42457571625709534,
0.5531299114227295,
-0.3587076663970947,
-0.6990987658500671,
0.5005777478218079,
-0.16753900051116943,
-0.405183345079422,
-0.3356843888759613,
-0.35954999923706055,
-0.4983495771884918,
0.5376975536346436,
0.29499468207359314,
0.7315413355827332,
-0.1683146059513092,
0.31514570116996765,
-0.27546995878219604,
-0.7573529481887817,
0.208143949508667,
-0.2008051872253418,
0.2561374604701996,
0.12215998768806458,
-0.5631793141365051,
0.19013133645057678,
-0.5546506643295288,
-0.2880454361438751,
0.2501860558986664,
0.15913589298725128,
-0.37396764755249023,
0.36295273900032043,
-0.1872624307870865,
0.14990559220314026,
-0.23113742470741272,
-0.23738865554332733,
-0.13390953838825226,
-0.34211140871047974,
0.1664562225341797,
0.7080299258232117,
-0.06517192721366882,
0.4924412667751312,
-0.3511994481086731,
0.0623631551861763,
0.19727124273777008,
-0.009762858040630817,
-0.2808018922805786,
-0.27793747186660767,
-1.0470149517059326,
-0.011159232817590237,
-0.433714359998703,
0.3494398891925812,
-0.4660263955593109,
0.4198681116104126,
-0.13054919242858887,
-0.212418332695961,
-0.36614274978637695,
-0.30032050609588623,
0.5263808965682983,
0.5192884802818298,
0.5646516680717468,
-0.3799465596675873,
-0.36190786957740784,
-1.014634370803833,
0.05641079321503639,
-0.12024945765733719,
0.0007609848980791867,
0.4052368998527527,
0.4272625148296356,
0.034116294234991074,
0.7034325003623962,
-0.4636981785297394,
-0.5908807516098022,
0.19673390686511993,
-0.20857569575309753,
-0.14702928066253662,
0.39329245686531067,
0.6042673587799072,
-0.7566491961479187,
-0.05673837661743164,
0.08848719298839569,
-1.1126296520233154,
0.04542944207787514,
-0.19316767156124115,
-0.054967936128377914,
0.4986307919025421,
0.6625239849090576,
-0.9672712683677673,
0.7415574789047241,
0.16125477850437164,
-0.10885589569807053,
0.5662966966629028,
-0.12057345360517502,
0.288507342338562,
-0.4853604733943939,
0.019829105585813522,
-0.21039287745952606,
-0.028464704751968384,
-0.5170566439628601,
0.44177407026290894,
-0.024022724479436874,
-0.30256643891334534,
-0.5760423541069031,
0.23928135633468628,
-0.6076995134353638,
-0.5719924569129944,
-0.22780634462833405,
0.34232017397880554,
-0.035362496972084045,
0.3310073912143707,
0.37704920768737793,
0.8521268963813782,
0.9241165518760681,
-0.6988015174865723,
-0.11166960746049881,
0.23888404667377472,
-0.33605679869651794,
0.518576979637146,
-0.6923313736915588,
0.24459627270698547,
-0.6324560046195984,
-0.07877092063426971,
-0.9854646921157837,
-0.19387415051460266,
0.5266989469528198,
-0.31215807795524597,
0.044011201709508896,
0.16627612709999084,
-0.16733528673648834,
-0.24753588438034058,
-0.4377483129501343,
0.07665731757879257,
0.6497345566749573,
-0.579437255859375,
0.27366718649864197,
0.019616173580288887,
0.49114859104156494,
-0.5571165680885315,
-0.8601732850074768,
0.2843236029148102,
-0.2999737560749054,
-0.45422759652137756,
0.058569978922605515,
-0.12158814072608948,
-0.5282995700836182,
0.0045983027666807175,
-0.5280649662017822,
0.20849627256393433,
0.12288782745599747,
0.3575720489025116,
0.034789033234119415,
-0.30319124460220337,
0.22118282318115234,
-0.2112479954957962,
0.01420643925666809,
0.29094168543815613,
-0.2639842927455902,
0.6518184542655945,
-0.35772809386253357,
-0.5705925822257996,
-0.4578847289085388,
0.13657593727111816,
0.7652713060379028,
-0.3260267376899719,
0.8283960819244385,
0.36935096979141235,
-0.554889976978302,
-0.08360863476991653,
-0.6019226908683777,
-0.35058456659317017,
-0.38830989599227905,
0.42384710907936096,
-0.7223398685455322,
-0.6776622533798218,
0.42304563522338867,
0.33789679408073425,
-0.217148557305336,
0.3295610249042511,
0.3354431986808777,
-0.08561422675848007,
0.7731948494911194,
0.28018102049827576,
0.16217175126075745,
0.0936037227511406,
-0.12514017522335052,
0.18543900549411774,
-0.8552590608596802,
-0.33202195167541504,
-0.4193882644176483,
-0.08670012652873993,
-0.127503901720047,
-0.6464757919311523,
-0.07089554518461227,
0.24429592490196228,
0.06869513541460037,
-0.14309197664260864,
-0.7375591397285461,
0.7405288219451904,
0.06685252487659454,
0.421199232339859,
0.2951337993144989,
0.43139883875846863,
0.33546775579452515,
-0.15248335897922516,
-0.5227691531181335,
-0.5774275064468384,
0.9112030863761902,
0.4406953454017639,
0.7851571440696716,
-0.2992687523365021,
0.6046733856201172,
0.20500953495502472,
0.1387167125940323,
-0.9149736166000366,
0.7553589940071106,
-0.14418819546699524,
-0.17411823570728302,
-0.43002036213874817,
-0.15431778132915497,
-0.5478857755661011,
0.5498992800712585,
-0.18872906267642975,
-0.7211636304855347,
0.17387264966964722,
0.0677739754319191,
0.03486938774585724,
0.3781417906284332,
-0.38014116883277893,
0.6584264636039734,
-0.16872207820415497,
-0.4821316599845886,
-0.10362394899129868,
-0.5746752023696899,
0.5332797169685364,
-0.010608362965285778,
0.13422909379005432,
-0.024393167346715927,
0.07923688739538193,
0.5371712446212769,
-0.24273094534873962,
0.9186974167823792,
-0.33855023980140686,
-0.22147439420223236,
0.36294955015182495,
0.09501684457063675,
0.5265350937843323,
-0.028258109465241432,
0.2768288850784302,
0.19721436500549316,
-0.46134957671165466,
-0.22369049489498138,
-0.630246639251709,
0.5947180986404419,
-0.6216855645179749,
-0.8627836108207703,
-0.1965460628271103,
-0.5798461437225342,
0.059714239090681076,
0.08687163144350052,
0.2715722918510437,
0.2850133776664734,
-0.046369779855012894,
0.630614161491394,
0.9496188163757324,
-0.31108206510543823,
0.11036951839923859,
-0.042490653693675995,
-0.46867209672927856,
-0.31677180528640747,
0.7489566802978516,
0.07182882726192474,
0.5304490327835083,
0.34901145100593567,
0.14050304889678955,
0.005638073198497295,
-0.8327961564064026,
-0.2918246388435364,
0.3423365354537964,
-1.1694819927215576,
-0.0021514310501515865,
-0.7280083894729614,
-0.06934745609760284,
-0.23214182257652283,
-0.44536900520324707,
-0.2857118248939514,
-0.23765115439891815,
-0.47479677200317383,
-0.1972339004278183,
0.07332899421453476,
0.3235028386116028,
0.3031904697418213,
0.06287988275289536,
-0.4894395172595978,
0.7737613320350647,
0.2053450047969818,
0.24623964726924896,
0.08072037994861603,
-0.44110602140426636,
-0.02923361212015152,
0.06681869179010391,
0.29854685068130493,
-0.6023916006088257,
0.10209375619888306,
0.10304052382707596,
0.4100427031517029,
0.600661039352417,
0.18101903796195984,
1.1283998489379883,
-0.6452399492263794,
0.7609050273895264,
0.3111339211463928,
-0.9698832035064697,
0.40777891874313354,
-0.1785060614347458,
0.09270962327718735,
0.3883003294467926,
-0.06586077064275742,
-0.32169991731643677,
-0.6816759705543518,
-0.30820488929748535,
-0.5675608515739441,
0.5960707664489746,
0.440652072429657,
0.23114638030529022,
-0.11178264021873474,
0.4769614338874817,
0.19372119009494781,
0.38701456785202026,
-1.0263419151306152,
-0.1327580064535141,
-0.24587896466255188,
0.21168707311153412,
-0.11026261746883392,
-0.288340300321579,
-0.2755855619907379,
-0.3385181427001953,
0.23165009915828705,
-0.15738803148269653,
0.4022849202156067,
0.53722083568573,
-0.3949979841709137,
-0.3829510807991028,
-0.10035127401351929,
0.9423737525939941,
0.6292012929916382,
-0.43050652742385864,
0.4205072522163391,
0.09235702455043793,
-0.2809676229953766,
-0.13508908450603485,
-0.3109034299850464,
-0.4346603453159332,
0.09940803050994873,
0.3318172097206116,
1.0084275007247925,
-0.060908276587724686,
-0.7941581606864929,
0.41759222745895386,
0.2325880378484726,
-0.4393717050552368,
-0.3889063000679016,
0.1444428265094757,
-0.308746337890625,
0.21938198804855347,
0.33725395798683167,
0.2395445555448532,
-0.00010909341654041782,
-0.5762442350387573,
0.3068523406982422,
0.5739478468894958,
-0.6426003575325012,
-0.014415117911994457,
0.9849603772163391,
-0.12849746644496918,
-0.2686769366264343,
0.4409973919391632,
0.17314046621322632,
-0.3606010973453522,
0.8145530223846436,
0.5868532657623291,
1.0287284851074219,
0.15930160880088806,
0.14703285694122314,
0.24016600847244263,
0.8617964386940002,
-0.2518081068992615,
0.010966944508254528,
-0.04266469553112984,
-0.6290116906166077,
-0.18078413605690002,
-0.5166961550712585,
-0.17055897414684296,
0.1714194118976593,
-0.6300565600395203,
0.3625388443470001,
-0.3220667243003845,
0.4014507532119751,
-0.44777753949165344,
-0.6508954167366028,
-0.4953508675098419,
0.4218006134033203,
0.4253423810005188,
0.5564994215965271,
-0.8401577472686768,
0.4229763150215149,
0.6869555711746216,
-0.5151976346969604,
-0.25653085112571716,
0.3976253271102905,
-0.5064225196838379,
-0.6802479028701782,
0.7623518705368042,
0.8264779448509216,
-0.2152738720178604,
-0.007460062857717276,
-0.757420003414154,
-0.6265628337860107,
0.9644413590431213,
0.0009600179619155824,
-0.3156980872154236,
-0.012471430003643036,
0.4603959918022156,
0.4801177978515625,
-0.5941112041473389,
-0.1993972212076187,
0.33480653166770935,
0.5308511853218079,
0.1666760891675949,
-0.6109715104103088,
0.36982202529907227,
0.0074544851668179035,
0.04083293676376343,
0.01231293473392725,
-0.5703762769699097,
0.828414797782898,
-0.44101792573928833,
-0.46159064769744873,
0.10390125215053558,
0.562606155872345,
0.31686726212501526,
0.4836755096912384,
0.5291417837142944,
0.5278980731964111,
0.5790702104568481,
-0.2073214054107666,
0.9416252374649048,
0.07849987596273422,
0.28563496470451355,
0.8269171118736267,
-0.43698886036872864,
0.6899402737617493,
0.9849576354026794,
0.06616754829883575,
-0.10294824093580246,
0.41733282804489136,
-0.09044702351093292,
0.6697629690170288,
0.272635281085968,
0.3643459677696228,
-0.3250667452812195,
-0.1074552908539772,
-0.5324987769126892,
0.2423510104417801,
0.09859781712293625,
-0.3168656826019287,
-0.09384238719940186,
0.34285977482795715,
-0.29449185729026794,
0.13157953321933746,
-0.4452788233757019,
0.6177119612693787,
0.0953860878944397,
-0.588105320930481,
1.1249281167984009,
-0.2844002842903137,
0.2710323631763458,
-0.10418888926506042,
-0.14055439829826355,
-0.3347693085670471,
-0.0010819608578458428,
-0.2663576900959015,
-0.5281655192375183,
0.33399567008018494,
-0.0548214428126812,
-0.08064718544483185,
0.04322482645511627,
0.9059404134750366,
-0.302781343460083,
-0.10859764367341995,
0.26629334688186646,
0.40540048480033875,
0.5171211957931519,
-0.4790380001068115,
-0.2347167432308197,
0.18447306752204895,
-0.056768134236335754,
-0.27407756447792053,
0.1750470995903015,
0.3565663695335388,
-0.11917378753423691,
0.5965701937675476,
0.6067296266555786,
-0.05129684507846832,
0.054956305772066116,
0.17245422303676605,
0.8916484117507935,
-0.6497979760169983,
-0.2740541398525238,
-0.7990403175354004,
0.6682393550872803,
-0.10620099306106567,
0.08711445331573486,
0.5746363997459412,
0.6995887160301208,
0.9418969750404358,
-0.6078920960426331,
0.6179782152175903,
-0.02076025679707527,
-0.19809244573116302,
-1.0817394256591797,
0.6263684034347534,
-0.8428006768226624,
0.36300310492515564,
-0.3737089931964874,
-1.4385095834732056,
-0.7061411142349243,
0.8644318580627441,
-0.2951406240463257,
-0.2765049338340759,
1.0717774629592896,
0.7666268348693848,
-0.060655806213617325,
-0.42284995317459106,
0.7826101183891296,
0.11564479768276215,
0.07560130208730698,
0.2597614824771881,
1.0746113061904907,
-0.4039822816848755,
0.5098003149032593,
-0.4973984658718109,
0.0336063988506794,
-0.31333792209625244,
-0.6739947199821472,
-1.56937575340271,
-0.31741780042648315,
-0.2840941548347473,
-0.2589718997478485,
0.39283791184425354,
0.5873278379440308,
0.2692667543888092,
-0.8058364987373352,
-0.16397690773010254,
-0.5916126370429993,
-0.0001659369736444205,
-0.12235470116138458,
-0.2243557721376419,
0.5915502905845642,
-0.4920417070388794,
-0.6080899238586426,
0.09665200114250183,
0.4269079267978668,
0.1507737636566162,
-0.3414018750190735,
-0.2766336500644684,
0.26060551404953003,
-0.20238305628299713,
0.8364424109458923,
-0.0804712325334549,
-1.281959056854248,
-0.6804588437080383,
0.3857227563858032,
-0.10652153193950653,
0.3657457232475281,
0.628632664680481,
-0.6713243126869202,
0.4960102438926697,
0.3003896176815033,
0.5033535361289978,
0.20629923045635223,
0.2654147148132324,
0.1349259465932846,
-0.43531864881515503,
0.5737621188163757,
-0.02905694581568241,
0.28892412781715393,
0.15926259756088257,
-0.4250580966472626,
0.5722536444664001,
0.4424627423286438,
-0.20437654852867126,
-1.0965092182159424,
0.09665200859308243,
-0.9337109923362732,
-0.42917585372924805,
1.2608736753463745,
0.25907060503959656,
-0.29478687047958374,
0.13351638615131378,
-0.6321602463722229,
0.07332158833742142,
-0.04810459166765213,
1.045185923576355,
0.7284225821495056,
0.18582205474376678,
-0.4393170475959778,
-0.6445887088775635,
0.32354071736335754,
0.5233380198478699,
-0.9178992509841919,
0.3954770267009735,
0.8622569441795349,
-0.3236074149608612,
0.28904879093170166,
0.30376580357551575,
0.040594227612018585,
0.38128426671028137,
-0.07498858124017715,
0.2516117990016937,
-0.3113684058189392,
-0.7316850423812866,
-0.25426727533340454,
0.3524320423603058,
0.10170686990022659,
-0.3383692502975464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14491v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14491v1 | Instruction Pre-Training: Language Models are Supervised Multitask Learners | 2024-06-20T16:55:33 | 2024-06-20T16:55:33 | Daixuan Cheng, Yuxian Gu, Shaohan Huang, Junyu Bi, Minlie Huang, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | Unsupervised multitask pre-training has been the critical method behind the
recent success of language models (LMs). However, supervised multitask learning
still holds significant promise, as scaling it in the post-training stage
trends towards better generalization. In this paper, we explore supervised
multitask pre-training by proposing Instruction Pre-Training, a framework that
scalably augments massive raw corpora with instruction-response pairs to
pre-train LMs. The instruction-response pairs are generated by an efficient
instruction synthesizer built on open-source models. In our experiments, we
synthesize 200M instruction-response pairs covering 40+ task categories to
verify the effectiveness of Instruction Pre-Training. In pre-training from
scratch, Instruction Pre-Training not only consistently enhances pre-trained
base models but also benefits more from further instruction tuning. In
continual pre-training, Instruction Pre-Training enables Llama3-8B to be
comparable to or even outperform Llama3-70B. Our model, code, and data are
available at https://github.com/microsoft/LMOps. | [
-0.2676483988761902,
-0.5195582509040833,
0.6030635833740234,
0.29849040508270264,
-0.1719374656677246,
0.23977288603782654,
-0.5429484248161316,
-0.23260122537612915,
0.1490619033575058,
0.6256182193756104,
-0.739010751247406,
-0.5798043608665466,
-0.654499351978302,
0.06821207702159882,
-0.36265242099761963,
1.102802038192749,
0.02990170568227768,
0.1624293327331543,
-0.3209080696105957,
0.3374835252761841,
-0.3316800594329834,
-0.6395378708839417,
-0.2707681357860565,
0.08616285026073456,
0.6345176100730896,
0.584474503993988,
0.253473699092865,
0.46758225560188293,
0.20386675000190735,
0.35391154885292053,
0.48461195826530457,
0.19199277460575104,
-0.5216884613037109,
-0.011160960420966148,
0.38749921321868896,
-0.5039085745811462,
-0.7681273818016052,
0.21644403040409088,
0.5301170945167542,
0.8330602049827576,
-0.09913725405931473,
0.3747013807296753,
0.3711247742176056,
0.6047467589378357,
-0.8208711743354797,
0.2902315557003021,
-0.6231366395950317,
-0.082222580909729,
-0.415726900100708,
-0.28663867712020874,
-0.8315027952194214,
-0.09274934977293015,
-0.06934048235416412,
-0.6891016364097595,
0.178420290350914,
-0.031834207475185394,
0.5217244625091553,
0.4200870990753174,
-0.1423356682062149,
-0.28458672761917114,
-0.3836490511894226,
0.7492515444755554,
-0.518267035484314,
0.6248689293861389,
0.6097863912582397,
-0.06437566876411438,
-0.09916061908006668,
-0.7047718167304993,
-0.3830636441707611,
-0.47779059410095215,
-0.14117954671382904,
0.1493292599916458,
0.13028700649738312,
0.2960015833377838,
0.126316100358963,
0.3782302737236023,
-0.5942485332489014,
0.18418580293655396,
-0.34906795620918274,
-0.03186754509806633,
0.14980089664459229,
-0.0076728337444365025,
0.12541869282722473,
0.16377100348472595,
-0.4438853859901428,
0.02515295334160328,
-0.8516224026679993,
0.07401557266712189,
0.5484163165092468,
0.26329830288887024,
-0.117912158370018,
0.4868786633014679,
-0.13328880071640015,
0.9645880460739136,
0.2409420609474182,
-0.12389282882213593,
0.4835047721862793,
-0.31597787141799927,
-0.18443651497364044,
0.08316289633512497,
0.8066897392272949,
-0.1509343832731247,
0.2308848649263382,
-0.34158286452293396,
-0.1383102983236313,
0.11063980311155319,
0.6044491529464722,
-0.8687928318977356,
-0.2612934708595276,
0.1937602460384369,
-0.2408345341682434,
-0.14880099892616272,
-0.032437607645988464,
-0.30716872215270996,
0.1515645980834961,
-0.6072193384170532,
0.2542712390422821,
-0.21510042250156403,
-0.22696655988693237,
0.28666454553604126,
0.5450916290283203,
-0.1687096208333969,
0.14096811413764954,
-1.0931330919265747,
0.24602527916431427,
0.7247276902198792,
0.5959599018096924,
-0.25396832823753357,
-0.6723371148109436,
-0.815703272819519,
0.15598054230213165,
-0.5041686296463013,
0.7407838106155396,
-0.6079167127609253,
-0.2147049903869629,
0.07822220027446747,
0.21299028396606445,
-0.2481280267238617,
-0.4269978702068329,
-0.12147494405508041,
-0.6558521389961243,
0.025955986231565475,
0.07001836597919464,
-0.43789270520210266,
0.16369172930717468,
0.17657850682735443,
-0.756861686706543,
0.9889829754829407,
0.1914924681186676,
-0.7370878458023071,
0.20180900394916534,
-0.7709806561470032,
-0.5012013912200928,
0.048032067716121674,
-0.0059961178340017796,
-0.14207856357097626,
0.0637228712439537,
0.25503429770469666,
0.8446333408355713,
-0.06708702445030212,
0.22436514496803284,
-0.3716815114021301,
-0.3675154149532318,
0.03921385109424591,
-0.2756439745426178,
0.4996466040611267,
0.08322161436080933,
-0.2499491423368454,
0.48719602823257446,
-0.8810445070266724,
0.18492266535758972,
-0.1393304020166397,
-0.6038106679916382,
-0.056854452937841415,
-0.28529223799705505,
-0.19913329184055328,
0.0199277326464653,
0.46449780464172363,
-0.4349784553050995,
0.16558215022087097,
-0.3099405765533447,
0.22065281867980957,
0.790697455406189,
-0.43455177545547485,
0.5282139778137207,
0.08520937711000443,
0.6519840359687805,
-0.059748485684394836,
0.08861003816127777,
-0.49999865889549255,
-0.17682808637619019,
-0.7251434326171875,
-0.329315185546875,
0.24161742627620697,
0.6258313059806824,
-0.9441057443618774,
0.3742839992046356,
-0.3082393705844879,
-0.28860822319984436,
-0.7618645429611206,
0.507642924785614,
0.7980799674987793,
0.34280461072921753,
0.5681602358818054,
-0.3429079055786133,
-0.7206677198410034,
-0.7436190843582153,
-0.12287936359643936,
0.11080863326787949,
-0.18751482665538788,
-0.18044398725032806,
0.2757999002933502,
-0.32950034737586975,
0.5695096254348755,
-0.5480570197105408,
-0.2318761795759201,
-0.2957954704761505,
0.1620875895023346,
-0.03937351331114769,
0.40858912467956543,
0.1779475212097168,
-0.3416730463504791,
-0.5148313641548157,
-0.26924610137939453,
-0.5260109305381775,
0.06397251039743423,
0.21601438522338867,
-0.13864494860172272,
0.1996675431728363,
0.658018946647644,
-0.40034252405166626,
0.09846025705337524,
0.9156198501586914,
0.25689923763275146,
0.6536626815795898,
-0.3230566084384918,
0.18450847268104553,
-1.2234169244766235,
-0.07006561011075974,
-0.38641005754470825,
-0.18728995323181152,
-0.6630755066871643,
-0.11119915544986725,
0.2569555640220642,
-0.06474956125020981,
-0.5464632511138916,
0.037538763135671616,
-0.6825478672981262,
-0.09619534760713577,
-0.38906481862068176,
-0.20107339322566986,
-0.2939322590827942,
0.6612365245819092,
0.25110572576522827,
0.9909201860427856,
0.47391173243522644,
-0.5554248690605164,
0.28370630741119385,
0.009791918098926544,
-0.7182661294937134,
0.239732027053833,
-0.5299208760261536,
0.5146615505218506,
-0.019658146426081657,
0.3510281443595886,
-0.716579794883728,
-0.278817743062973,
0.043067533522844315,
-0.1346035599708557,
0.3255068063735962,
-0.1184852346777916,
-0.5507349967956543,
-0.4295651614665985,
-0.15528470277786255,
0.25634491443634033,
0.018964124843478203,
-0.6067461371421814,
0.5325772166252136,
0.34165632724761963,
-0.2146672159433365,
-0.9375033974647522,
-0.5183311104774475,
-0.21690967679023743,
0.1372683197259903,
-0.330457866191864,
0.339412659406662,
-0.29725906252861023,
0.17615865170955658,
0.05203868821263313,
0.02859252318739891,
-0.20358608663082123,
0.09887582808732986,
0.4521954655647278,
0.36343178153038025,
-0.266514390707016,
0.08901098370552063,
-0.10523925721645355,
-0.18726897239685059,
0.05604160949587822,
-0.3108190596103668,
0.7823981642723083,
-0.40719982981681824,
-0.4788222014904022,
-0.3340260684490204,
0.2592718303203583,
0.24540232121944427,
-0.5667794942855835,
0.6939012408256531,
0.6143932938575745,
-0.048471514135599136,
-0.1527077853679657,
-0.5664904117584229,
-0.3005218207836151,
-0.4656871557235718,
0.716668963432312,
-0.40984466671943665,
-1.1012048721313477,
-0.1610078662633896,
-0.13772352039813995,
0.22503168880939484,
-0.0863538309931755,
0.5184382200241089,
-0.19216890633106232,
0.8838569521903992,
0.738052487373352,
0.10428761690855026,
0.5924495458602905,
-0.16737867891788483,
0.16905392706394196,
-0.7432147860527039,
-0.28937238454818726,
-0.25614631175994873,
-0.01785491779446602,
-0.3586183488368988,
-0.43518924713134766,
0.2089306116104126,
0.057432275265455246,
-0.24461501836776733,
0.4268009662628174,
-0.3048642873764038,
0.5959687232971191,
0.6558172702789307,
0.10766405612230301,
-0.06216520071029663,
-0.028390079736709595,
0.10731898248195648,
0.18545033037662506,
-0.5808799862861633,
-0.5611786842346191,
1.4158848524093628,
0.13637028634548187,
0.6337541937828064,
-0.26035624742507935,
1.0123999118804932,
0.036134690046310425,
0.5485240817070007,
-0.5542944669723511,
0.5253208875656128,
-0.32277485728263855,
-0.43592971563339233,
-0.1541563719511032,
-0.258720338344574,
-0.9320811033248901,
0.07839152216911316,
-0.2079215794801712,
-0.4963790476322174,
-0.39531585574150085,
0.5637414455413818,
-0.643408477306366,
0.14133377373218536,
-1.1263844966888428,
1.1731704473495483,
-0.5380392670631409,
-0.3532089293003082,
-0.18819484114646912,
-0.656420111656189,
0.40525496006011963,
-0.2184373140335083,
0.4306529462337494,
0.1087578535079956,
0.03235417976975441,
0.7814534902572632,
-0.17609938979148865,
0.9954215288162231,
-0.13723939657211304,
-0.20743508636951447,
0.26384612917900085,
-0.08455408364534378,
0.2979106605052948,
-0.1556044965982437,
0.41663694381713867,
-0.08305145800113678,
-0.04130595922470093,
-0.5470189452171326,
-0.4988688826560974,
0.7391877770423889,
-0.763124406337738,
-0.7904614806175232,
-0.02760910429060459,
-0.6256536841392517,
-0.5501176714897156,
0.1071995198726654,
0.09576713293790817,
0.3053061068058014,
-0.08440662920475006,
0.33863016963005066,
0.6485233902931213,
0.0113087622448802,
0.3947257101535797,
0.48460450768470764,
-0.2279248684644699,
-0.357109010219574,
0.9781206846237183,
-0.06760381162166595,
0.35997825860977173,
0.5640193819999695,
-0.08772408217191696,
-0.12724684178829193,
-0.3665807843208313,
-0.5182448625564575,
-0.16025297343730927,
-0.6041170954704285,
0.011044209823012352,
-0.7910453081130981,
0.022780057042837143,
-0.44051244854927063,
0.03714786469936371,
-0.5990118384361267,
0.005904950201511383,
-0.3333168923854828,
-0.21056248247623444,
0.04991508275270462,
0.839664101600647,
-0.05251815915107727,
0.6595631837844849,
-0.9124494194984436,
0.36394503712654114,
0.5508497953414917,
0.3625006377696991,
0.03290758654475212,
-0.45666977763175964,
-0.5127832889556885,
0.061750609427690506,
-0.1491248458623886,
-0.8154908418655396,
0.19451506435871124,
0.14228589832782745,
0.4121856987476349,
0.40850773453712463,
-0.16218692064285278,
0.7898697853088379,
-0.9378897547721863,
0.6538997888565063,
0.28964537382125854,
-0.8600408434867859,
0.40249431133270264,
0.10384722054004669,
0.41243258118629456,
0.45576852560043335,
0.670032262802124,
0.05619730055332184,
-0.2046961635351181,
-0.44633734226226807,
-0.7123839259147644,
0.8192323446273804,
-0.2696087658405304,
0.31265875697135925,
0.0077829789370298386,
-0.048323292285203934,
0.2649584710597992,
0.5571739077568054,
-0.683631181716919,
-0.16370785236358643,
-0.5238741040229797,
-0.32940474152565,
-0.4426552355289459,
-0.3499335050582886,
0.05928749963641167,
-0.10734886676073074,
0.6203045845031738,
-0.19225344061851501,
0.08592352271080017,
-0.507659375667572,
-0.5133962631225586,
0.19908642768859863,
0.4605337083339691,
0.7611077427864075,
0.5760713219642639,
-0.1749180108308792,
0.41620540618896484,
-0.003299509407952428,
-0.5780936479568481,
0.11644092947244644,
0.18836958706378937,
0.3488362431526184,
-0.4462340474128723,
0.6062643527984619,
1.0883796215057373,
0.7468008995056152,
-0.5924153923988342,
0.5108739733695984,
0.012716672383248806,
-0.0710277259349823,
-0.20192725956439972,
0.03505752980709076,
0.4153081178665161,
0.039173901081085205,
0.2044125199317932,
0.03600119426846504,
-0.17814099788665771,
-0.4587312936782837,
0.12574835121631622,
0.2878433167934418,
-0.1280822455883026,
-0.5093740224838257,
0.53094482421875,
0.15339651703834534,
-0.24315285682678223,
0.44553467631340027,
-0.19180342555046082,
-0.4719035029411316,
0.2949041426181793,
0.5855379104614258,
0.5247222185134888,
-0.44650620222091675,
0.21236732602119446,
0.23941843211650848,
0.3476651906967163,
-0.08918219804763794,
0.15499089658260345,
-0.41032248735427856,
-0.5155927538871765,
-0.806592583656311,
-0.7009660601615906,
-0.19217345118522644,
0.4616864323616028,
-0.7003606557846069,
0.024839580059051514,
-0.353603720664978,
0.04945739358663559,
-0.009174204431474209,
-0.08871540427207947,
-0.9582499265670776,
0.19835427403450012,
0.04628698155283928,
0.30631324648857117,
-0.7373152375221252,
1.2405064105987549,
0.6809424757957458,
-0.40251803398132324,
-0.8611608147621155,
-0.058248378336429596,
-0.21952854096889496,
-0.9424086213111877,
0.9273325204849243,
0.49475473165512085,
-0.25207698345184326,
0.18112453818321228,
-0.5954027771949768,
-0.7988203167915344,
0.672508955001831,
0.6442871689796448,
-0.8761040568351746,
-0.25949424505233765,
0.16075655817985535,
0.32222265005111694,
-0.4460134208202362,
0.19883063435554504,
0.39304566383361816,
0.1230253130197525,
-0.18824650347232819,
-0.8799909949302673,
-0.25860801339149475,
-0.14647242426872253,
-0.16179253160953522,
-0.004851740784943104,
-0.235340416431427,
0.9203254580497742,
-0.3949931859970093,
-0.003130538621917367,
-0.07261498272418976,
0.9045647382736206,
0.2010800987482071,
-0.08449042588472366,
0.7108105421066284,
0.5703166127204895,
0.5563655495643616,
0.0734754428267479,
0.9305910468101501,
-0.49689939618110657,
-0.14808198809623718,
1.497738242149353,
-0.10457717627286911,
1.1150310039520264,
0.48239076137542725,
-0.28366926312446594,
0.5720701217651367,
0.5967121124267578,
0.38320192694664,
0.6085145473480225,
0.2117472141981125,
-0.3109900653362274,
-0.5338548421859741,
0.09398356825113297,
-0.4208792448043823,
0.4271776080131531,
0.3582524359226227,
-0.13301460444927216,
0.03928210586309433,
0.3239055871963501,
0.0506228469312191,
0.11825142800807953,
-0.282986581325531,
0.6460252404212952,
0.05695637688040733,
-0.836307942867279,
0.801103949546814,
-0.18268999457359314,
0.8662570714950562,
-0.7556924819946289,
-0.015764396637678146,
0.04225475713610649,
0.24176308512687683,
-0.18254731595516205,
-0.45700111985206604,
-0.013659261167049408,
0.16798749566078186,
-0.3569793105125427,
-0.46080803871154785,
0.36866629123687744,
-0.8160383701324463,
-0.35013332962989807,
0.3800736665725708,
0.38121604919433594,
0.2107357680797577,
-0.1576734334230423,
-0.42474132776260376,
0.1621321588754654,
-0.10745803266763687,
-0.3189810812473297,
0.605842649936676,
0.15040205419063568,
0.10634991526603699,
0.41622093319892883,
0.8688783049583435,
0.01912015676498413,
0.4314612150192261,
0.12138800323009491,
0.8084561824798584,
-0.06440562009811401,
-0.3963869512081146,
-0.5727463364601135,
0.3886977434158325,
0.20202462375164032,
-0.11689732223749161,
0.61098313331604,
0.5346195101737976,
1.31939697265625,
-0.5784322023391724,
0.6152236461639404,
0.2688656151294708,
0.4321759343147278,
-0.7075259685516357,
0.4609495997428894,
-0.4861684739589691,
0.025762127712368965,
-0.05120663344860077,
-0.8158772587776184,
-0.02665313519537449,
0.4734497666358948,
-0.38042524456977844,
0.09678424894809723,
0.7723776698112488,
0.882514476776123,
-0.0856734961271286,
-0.021763304248452187,
0.3767564594745636,
-0.059909556061029434,
-0.002053772797808051,
0.6126372814178467,
0.8462347984313965,
0.05343419685959816,
0.5449860095977783,
-0.44289135932922363,
-0.2775363326072693,
0.06044705584645271,
-0.8236058950424194,
-1.1154663562774658,
-0.7406795024871826,
0.04342735558748245,
-0.04333547502756119,
0.17335490882396698,
1.112934947013855,
0.814118504524231,
-0.8624648451805115,
-0.3596843481063843,
0.040593065321445465,
-0.27648404240608215,
-0.13078895211219788,
-0.07770659029483795,
0.4955367147922516,
-0.8938067555427551,
-0.7266086935997009,
0.8851636648178101,
0.0354432687163353,
-0.03409904986619949,
-0.35824698209762573,
-0.1837414801120758,
-0.24210520088672638,
-0.32588353753089905,
0.7766180038452148,
0.11511057615280151,
-0.697749137878418,
0.020886177197098732,
0.14295914769172668,
-0.05577171593904495,
-0.1066853478550911,
0.9208664298057556,
-0.7491772770881653,
0.38902223110198975,
-0.06547021865844727,
0.8594412803649902,
0.47328779101371765,
-0.20984014868736267,
0.3754369914531708,
-0.9580650329589844,
0.42401835322380066,
0.06559911370277405,
0.14707621932029724,
0.3436460494995117,
-0.109809011220932,
0.19233223795890808,
-0.018615273758769035,
-0.3277056813240051,
-0.8824250102043152,
0.18394283950328827,
-0.6451281905174255,
-0.1854839026927948,
0.921847939491272,
-0.47088900208473206,
-0.24068018794059753,
0.1264539361000061,
-0.07189324498176575,
0.3342708647251129,
-0.189965158700943,
0.5976623296737671,
0.6109537482261658,
0.10967627167701721,
-0.21366868913173676,
-0.6914702653884888,
0.5775951147079468,
0.5265531539916992,
-1.0398000478744507,
0.05905446782708168,
0.3535877466201782,
0.11690864711999893,
0.23103412985801697,
0.757604718208313,
0.21699126064777374,
0.1324520856142044,
-0.11804155260324478,
0.24930734932422638,
-0.49592912197113037,
-0.765850841999054,
0.1767415553331375,
0.339266836643219,
0.06059357151389122,
-0.6086517572402954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14479v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14479v1 | On Layer-wise Representation Similarity: Application for Multi-Exit Models with a Single Classifier | 2024-06-20T16:41:09 | 2024-06-20T16:41:09 | Jiachen Jiang, Jinxin Zhou, Zhihui Zhu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Analyzing the similarity of internal representations within and across
different models has been an important technique for understanding the behavior
of deep neural networks. Most existing methods for analyzing the similarity
between representations of high dimensions, such as those based on Canonical
Correlation Analysis (CCA) and widely used Centered Kernel Alignment (CKA),
rely on statistical properties of the representations for a set of data points.
In this paper, we focus on transformer models and study the similarity of
representations between the hidden layers of individual transformers. In this
context, we show that a simple sample-wise cosine similarity metric is capable
of capturing the similarity and aligns with the complicated CKA. Our
experimental results on common transformers reveal that representations across
layers are positively correlated, albeit the similarity decreases when layers
are far apart. We then propose an aligned training approach to enhance the
similarity between internal representations, with trained models that enjoy the
following properties: (1) the last-layer classifier can be directly applied
right after any hidden layers, yielding intermediate layer accuracies much
higher than those under standard training, (2) the layer-wise accuracies
monotonically increase and reveal the minimal depth needed for the given task,
(3) when served as multi-exit models, they achieve on-par performance with
standard multi-exit architectures which consist of additional classifiers
designed for early exiting in shallow layers. To our knowledge, our work is the
first to show that one common classifier is sufficient for multi-exit models.
We conduct experiments on both vision and NLP tasks to demonstrate the
performance of the proposed aligned training. | [
-0.5074601769447327,
-0.13984067738056183,
0.5835837125778198,
-0.10183015465736389,
-0.08482557535171509,
0.12438508123159409,
-0.21709677577018738,
-0.19887930154800415,
0.07488474249839783,
0.3786446452140808,
-0.5183573365211487,
-0.45487770438194275,
-0.4898478388786316,
-0.3922375440597534,
-0.5522591471672058,
0.5027021765708923,
0.0010130496229976416,
0.22923506796360016,
-0.3656945526599884,
-0.32855501770973206,
-0.5691097974777222,
-0.5863014459609985,
-0.5872278213500977,
-0.6875861287117004,
0.5965585708618164,
0.21736057102680206,
0.5887092351913452,
0.4132312834262848,
0.8093606233596802,
0.37393373250961304,
0.06274191290140152,
-0.11438316851854324,
-0.3626745343208313,
-0.17632532119750977,
0.03741408511996269,
-0.3350592851638794,
-0.05530171096324921,
0.1410970389842987,
0.4897688627243042,
0.728024423122406,
-0.18992267549037933,
0.25812289118766785,
0.29874905943870544,
0.5867772102355957,
-0.5813071131706238,
0.07759637385606766,
-0.539612352848053,
0.4485095143318176,
0.029987670481204987,
-0.10468773543834686,
-0.6519026160240173,
-0.16817162930965424,
0.33022040128707886,
-0.6299363374710083,
0.4134758710861206,
-0.11041112244129181,
0.9096750617027283,
0.35163766145706177,
-0.29199323058128357,
-0.016320116817951202,
-0.8416667580604553,
0.9258679747581482,
-0.536859393119812,
0.7012278437614441,
-0.3908042013645172,
0.7158514857292175,
0.284480482339859,
-0.5624164938926697,
-0.6216117143630981,
-0.16193319857120514,
-0.3580333888530731,
0.5358191132545471,
-0.020457040518522263,
-0.131158247590065,
0.10567965358495712,
0.23658470809459686,
-0.3530392050743103,
0.3305226266384125,
-0.38788893818855286,
-0.16870175302028656,
0.36093270778656006,
-0.004235440865159035,
0.10105607658624649,
-0.08925379812717438,
-0.872035026550293,
-0.679090142250061,
-0.41164430975914,
0.3477277159690857,
0.5167127847671509,
0.35153910517692566,
-0.2515822649002075,
0.27432316541671753,
0.2124781608581543,
0.2721980810165405,
0.1838030070066452,
0.1083354577422142,
0.36024633049964905,
0.0601404570043087,
-0.28219881653785706,
0.13172665238380432,
0.8323489427566528,
0.2943572402000427,
0.17058458924293518,
-0.43380603194236755,
-0.14299051463603973,
0.1249401643872261,
0.6357118487358093,
-0.550468921661377,
-0.22426652908325195,
0.02185359038412571,
-0.6982995271682739,
-0.4359806180000305,
0.38807907700538635,
-0.654102623462677,
-0.20438893139362335,
-0.5631183981895447,
0.5967539548873901,
-0.3787768483161926,
-0.3641785979270935,
-0.008676696568727493,
-0.3532586097717285,
0.7376139163970947,
-0.011202921159565449,
-0.6909835934638977,
0.6046697497367859,
0.7630895376205444,
0.6989101767539978,
-0.2869611978530884,
-0.3432227075099945,
-0.2982320189476013,
0.05723462626338005,
-0.4564000368118286,
0.4124457538127899,
-0.6206570267677307,
0.2272857427597046,
-0.10418841987848282,
-0.14043419063091278,
-0.11629709601402283,
-0.5560068488121033,
0.4592227041721344,
-0.864219605922699,
0.21088258922100067,
-0.045107197016477585,
-0.41053611040115356,
-0.5316333770751953,
0.16067488491535187,
-0.9150242209434509,
0.8815416693687439,
0.06464339792728424,
-0.6308528184890747,
0.36521807312965393,
-0.5237879157066345,
0.06970792263746262,
-0.29627835750579834,
-0.3193061351776123,
-0.8375625610351562,
0.3132380247116089,
0.34043511748313904,
0.6545681357383728,
-0.06327841430902481,
0.10111453384160995,
-0.35750216245651245,
-0.44054898619651794,
0.08067519962787628,
-0.38635367155075073,
0.687926709651947,
-0.0323980413377285,
-0.12038153409957886,
0.08722537755966187,
-0.6796602606773376,
0.04072021320462227,
0.038593992590904236,
0.1614420861005783,
-0.5102639198303223,
-0.2063092738389969,
0.023471273481845856,
0.34154313802719116,
0.22033356130123138,
-0.5850721001625061,
0.05546121299266815,
-0.044538192451000214,
0.19236354529857635,
0.7744805812835693,
-0.06606602668762207,
0.7719228863716125,
-0.15309667587280273,
0.29216358065605164,
0.7264215350151062,
0.14268961548805237,
-0.004295668099075556,
-0.39931508898735046,
-0.5863352417945862,
-0.1927684247493744,
0.40245866775512695,
0.3893366754055023,
-0.2988540530204773,
0.5792438387870789,
-0.48608914017677307,
-0.6703723073005676,
-0.6485632061958313,
-0.11289893090724945,
0.21795368194580078,
0.574083149433136,
0.6122350096702576,
-0.6932185292243958,
-0.4766107499599457,
-1.1040146350860596,
-0.18794932961463928,
0.21410946547985077,
-0.056673742830753326,
0.030665721744298935,
0.35009071230888367,
-0.15645672380924225,
0.7593669891357422,
-0.3203861713409424,
-0.4639536738395691,
0.011788897216320038,
-0.03172473981976509,
0.4977284073829651,
0.609862744808197,
0.4834401309490204,
-0.7196556925773621,
-0.4232175350189209,
0.367215096950531,
-0.8578292727470398,
0.4741876721382141,
-0.4147781431674957,
-0.10180429369211197,
-0.4013904929161072,
0.4445599317550659,
-0.5024973750114441,
0.349421888589859,
0.5137385129928589,
0.29013505578041077,
0.14093109965324402,
-0.1368301659822464,
-0.07795577496290207,
-1.039018154144287,
0.0011037179501727223,
0.23552729189395905,
-0.002928821835666895,
-0.7729477882385254,
0.14208447933197021,
0.3168768882751465,
-0.18922701478004456,
-0.3453291356563568,
0.12349683046340942,
-0.36824917793273926,
-0.24696797132492065,
0.04168172925710678,
0.10279873013496399,
0.07657931745052338,
0.8199609518051147,
0.14708231389522552,
0.5210927724838257,
0.8393765091896057,
-0.497093141078949,
0.16037298738956451,
0.1967456191778183,
-0.2785637080669403,
0.4658506512641907,
-0.5582364201545715,
0.38364601135253906,
-0.31680089235305786,
0.18609198927879333,
-0.867394208908081,
0.005602965131402016,
0.0390174575150013,
-0.2610376179218292,
0.4302091598510742,
-0.04246249049901962,
-0.10272952914237976,
-0.4011448919773102,
-0.4131624102592468,
0.5205541849136353,
0.6056456565856934,
-0.9035731554031372,
0.871576726436615,
0.03419244661927223,
0.4559624195098877,
-0.8941065073013306,
-0.8255597949028015,
-0.2070189267396927,
-0.4091590940952301,
-0.6490285992622375,
0.6721891164779663,
0.2616136074066162,
0.17308126389980316,
0.16103971004486084,
-0.18260812759399414,
-0.2897249460220337,
-0.1557767689228058,
0.272819846868515,
0.20421119034290314,
-0.6153972744941711,
-0.03153597563505173,
0.09883067011833191,
-0.2321520894765854,
0.19704170525074005,
-0.19317461550235748,
0.6983155608177185,
-0.31635889410972595,
-0.6734811663627625,
-0.6525170803070068,
0.4077138900756836,
0.33602264523506165,
-0.3622311055660248,
0.811911404132843,
0.8937345743179321,
-0.38074687123298645,
-0.029087726026773453,
-0.5102430582046509,
-0.273185670375824,
-0.5247020721435547,
0.32168206572532654,
-0.5761744976043701,
-0.35961756110191345,
1.0358525514602661,
-0.06899552047252655,
-0.10854744911193848,
0.6344395279884338,
0.29662370681762695,
-0.270918607711792,
0.8567290306091309,
0.71424800157547,
-0.17946672439575195,
0.4161021113395691,
-0.7464432120323181,
0.5188256502151489,
-0.9525994658470154,
-0.4684591293334961,
-0.299350768327713,
-0.6778667569160461,
-0.48951399326324463,
-0.061539944261312485,
0.35749658942222595,
0.3070663511753082,
-0.3261680603027344,
0.58880615234375,
-0.7941163182258606,
0.7131616473197937,
0.49989667534828186,
0.36017632484436035,
0.018745388835668564,
0.1480407565832138,
-0.32681766152381897,
-0.03772701323032379,
-0.802436351776123,
-0.31355932354927063,
0.7974501848220825,
0.46790042519569397,
0.6140528917312622,
-0.10484669357538223,
1.049096941947937,
-0.10133261233568192,
0.18942299485206604,
-0.7055448293685913,
0.25899356603622437,
-0.3455389142036438,
-0.1859889030456543,
-0.1507662981748581,
-0.4264512062072754,
-0.6351572275161743,
0.22254151105880737,
0.057646289467811584,
-0.49215075373649597,
0.6669021248817444,
-0.02962021343410015,
-0.40148022770881653,
0.6283212900161743,
-0.9483144879341125,
0.9298256635665894,
-0.070522241294384,
0.03313317894935608,
-0.22170327603816986,
-0.7750383615493774,
0.36245471239089966,
-0.06371264904737473,
-0.21319624781608582,
0.382923424243927,
0.24102140963077545,
0.6350570917129517,
-0.22105778753757477,
0.7780975699424744,
-0.2559823989868164,
0.04193573445081711,
0.35454753041267395,
-0.10133364051580429,
0.1901487410068512,
-0.1800394207239151,
-0.10565079003572464,
0.497105211019516,
-0.21109052002429962,
-0.24405884742736816,
-0.7349497079849243,
0.767137885093689,
-0.9888268113136292,
-0.2432432621717453,
-0.3024868369102478,
-0.47302496433258057,
0.02863151580095291,
0.1718147099018097,
0.2747873067855835,
0.5658848881721497,
-0.008874943479895592,
0.3085639178752899,
0.5540744662284851,
-0.13599182665348053,
0.552904486656189,
-0.16690485179424286,
0.19399859011173248,
-0.08939250558614731,
0.8837087154388428,
-0.009605048224329948,
0.18424823880195618,
0.5904504656791687,
0.29873624444007874,
-0.4496920108795166,
-0.3082718253135681,
-0.36609944701194763,
-0.04795169085264206,
-0.8712473511695862,
-0.38305404782295227,
-0.4119202196598053,
-0.8358966708183289,
-0.1748736947774887,
-0.22415794432163239,
-0.4566236436367035,
-0.22140838205814362,
-0.23791775107383728,
-0.00538542540743947,
-0.007706690579652786,
0.8925419449806213,
-0.029866676777601242,
0.5045230388641357,
-0.7079386115074158,
0.30324554443359375,
0.4496195912361145,
0.5131761431694031,
0.5526010990142822,
-0.4226948022842407,
-0.26985299587249756,
-0.17100198566913605,
-0.6575666069984436,
-0.711402952671051,
0.06974593549966812,
0.2880406379699707,
0.7018890380859375,
0.6016699075698853,
-0.21670415997505188,
0.7505833506584167,
-0.47549813985824585,
0.715366780757904,
0.6218063831329346,
-0.9413291215896606,
0.10458848625421524,
0.10591159015893936,
0.1608293056488037,
0.39957380294799805,
0.5218597650527954,
-0.435768187046051,
-0.26782166957855225,
-0.6058979034423828,
-0.4886506497859955,
0.6563417315483093,
0.21678109467029572,
0.18879668414592743,
0.41986191272735596,
0.20294241607189178,
0.31233373284339905,
-0.12183837592601776,
-0.7380166053771973,
-0.25701430439949036,
-0.5585382580757141,
-0.3842472732067108,
0.1570594310760498,
0.18476754426956177,
-0.051460009068250656,
-0.14298641681671143,
0.30666688084602356,
-0.05390353500843048,
0.600017786026001,
-0.00489769084379077,
-0.00010667168680811301,
-0.10398250818252563,
0.1847560852766037,
0.275168776512146,
0.46051526069641113,
-0.2381160855293274,
0.34991592168807983,
0.3574444055557251,
-0.42362603545188904,
0.168691486120224,
-0.08074741810560226,
0.061820872128009796,
-0.09568304568529129,
0.46591633558273315,
0.5375241041183472,
0.12504370510578156,
0.068101666867733,
0.699187695980072,
-0.13964927196502686,
-0.04458114132285118,
-0.34238845109939575,
0.03790523111820221,
0.14619414508342743,
0.38255575299263,
0.4193961024284363,
0.7089526653289795,
0.06651201844215393,
-0.2820033133029938,
0.3522966802120209,
0.586715817451477,
-0.7050498127937317,
-0.3819475769996643,
0.4875567853450775,
-0.17225660383701324,
-0.24357600510120392,
0.6893744468688965,
-0.02663157321512699,
-0.552193284034729,
0.7822992205619812,
0.3545655608177185,
1.0488879680633545,
-0.29184362292289734,
0.10810069739818573,
0.4896203577518463,
0.2833012640476227,
-0.11018505692481995,
-0.14140111207962036,
-0.018483467400074005,
-0.8422558307647705,
-0.5764790773391724,
-0.3216709494590759,
-0.18535953760147095,
0.18945364654064178,
-0.9997530579566956,
0.42917877435684204,
-0.30756908655166626,
0.10835937410593033,
0.027657343074679375,
-0.17863419651985168,
-1.1864041090011597,
0.18647436797618866,
0.28078222274780273,
0.6931668519973755,
-0.9038930535316467,
0.7430722117424011,
0.35657089948654175,
-0.33996474742889404,
-0.9964700937271118,
-0.09379236400127411,
-0.41892239451408386,
-0.6971312761306763,
0.40012553334236145,
0.582474946975708,
-0.2136976420879364,
-0.3282305896282196,
-0.5661963224411011,
-0.6893110275268555,
1.3105089664459229,
0.39870598912239075,
-0.7276893854141235,
-0.08837898075580597,
0.4126175343990326,
0.7109076380729675,
-0.7966820597648621,
0.4962458908557892,
0.3669760525226593,
0.2875916063785553,
-0.07655616104602814,
-0.5501566529273987,
0.01598314754664898,
-0.009503442794084549,
0.2056008130311966,
0.11935169994831085,
-0.7049970030784607,
0.7437855005264282,
-0.17428727447986603,
-0.3151601552963257,
-0.05324332416057587,
0.6898189187049866,
0.0007935465546324849,
0.3625071942806244,
0.7494351863861084,
0.7773383855819702,
0.47948935627937317,
-0.07711391150951385,
0.8934003114700317,
-0.24963973462581635,
0.5525497198104858,
0.9729958772659302,
-0.1231238842010498,
0.727757453918457,
0.41995149850845337,
0.10130392014980316,
0.6091867089271545,
0.31367379426956177,
-0.1230132132768631,
0.845228374004364,
-0.02880285680294037,
0.3174034357070923,
-0.22009478509426117,
0.10638776421546936,
-0.4803490936756134,
0.5682980418205261,
0.09904137998819351,
-0.4836779832839966,
-0.29056793451309204,
-0.14959947764873505,
-0.642672598361969,
0.020676447078585625,
-0.19681380689144135,
0.7526516318321228,
0.2479476034641266,
-0.3873668611049652,
0.3341285288333893,
-0.23818250000476837,
0.4853779673576355,
-0.49791577458381653,
-0.20044298470020294,
-0.0615478977560997,
0.19891241192817688,
-0.36970290541648865,
-0.7724379301071167,
0.3394656479358673,
-0.46552398800849915,
-0.22859634459018707,
-0.31762370467185974,
0.7262412309646606,
-0.46699124574661255,
-0.5366163849830627,
0.6024558544158936,
0.2697944939136505,
-0.07384905964136124,
0.010329538956284523,
-0.5548070669174194,
0.006141991354525089,
-0.29748621582984924,
-0.044822584837675095,
-0.05929112434387207,
0.3970766067504883,
0.11276690661907196,
0.3778599798679352,
0.4615321457386017,
-0.12050318717956543,
0.491238534450531,
0.3948236405849457,
0.9624814391136169,
-0.691297173500061,
-0.3852406144142151,
-0.6719526648521423,
0.5238808989524841,
-0.18622605502605438,
-0.233880415558815,
0.470111221075058,
0.6354665160179138,
0.9321120977401733,
-0.29105278849601746,
0.33570587635040283,
0.3207239806652069,
0.2873852849006653,
-0.47598928213119507,
0.5630521178245544,
-0.5006833076477051,
0.1584887057542801,
-0.3198220133781433,
-1.4741350412368774,
-0.17908166348934174,
0.5444195866584778,
-0.09185445308685303,
0.11756568402051926,
0.6828621029853821,
0.7871571779251099,
-0.8348245620727539,
0.0916326493024826,
0.25787240266799927,
0.012067218311131,
0.4308569133281708,
0.676283597946167,
1.0190916061401367,
-0.8214219808578491,
0.42668527364730835,
-0.6312958598136902,
0.07695335894823074,
0.10653550177812576,
-0.6890753507614136,
-0.7820769548416138,
-0.7640211582183838,
-0.2159021496772766,
-0.03914838656783104,
-0.4669820964336395,
0.43321433663368225,
0.9218485355377197,
-0.943472683429718,
-0.128119096159935,
0.019887182861566544,
-0.06609545648097992,
-0.7579553127288818,
-0.2513750195503235,
0.6205258369445801,
-0.20579497516155243,
-0.4321720004081726,
0.219986230134964,
0.15663108229637146,
-0.13080346584320068,
-0.7001742720603943,
-0.05555553361773491,
0.14636388421058655,
-0.1804448515176773,
0.4366686940193176,
-0.26150667667388916,
-0.6309131383895874,
-0.6059757471084595,
0.06541484594345093,
-0.10643494129180908,
0.5372260212898254,
0.9646819233894348,
-0.8372873663902283,
0.30002081394195557,
0.578019917011261,
0.8100630044937134,
0.7332039475440979,
-0.18265651166439056,
0.2902221977710724,
-1.0862122774124146,
0.05999596044421196,
0.26114580035209656,
0.29011666774749756,
0.4631720781326294,
-0.3273719847202301,
0.38970446586608887,
-0.37000852823257446,
-0.3772275149822235,
-0.5331530570983887,
0.12319296598434448,
-1.4403012990951538,
0.19201456010341644,
0.5735805630683899,
-0.023428840562701225,
-0.29260456562042236,
0.19414234161376953,
0.15892986953258514,
0.3798385560512543,
-0.37513065338134766,
0.8040539622306824,
0.6654809713363647,
-0.04822848364710808,
-0.2988487184047699,
-0.21953310072422028,
0.19291669130325317,
0.3166608214378357,
-0.5184532999992371,
-0.36562788486480713,
-0.30569133162498474,
0.07730080932378769,
0.8381147980690002,
0.025919245555996895,
-0.14896993339061737,
0.12248767912387848,
-0.1370665729045868,
0.03194679692387581,
0.051368266344070435,
-0.5707714557647705,
-0.49159640073776245,
0.3943485617637634,
-0.43173521757125854,
-0.46179789304733276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14473v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14473v1 | Data-Centric AI in the Age of Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T16:34:07 | 2024-06-20T16:34:07 | Xinyi Xu, Zhaoxuan Wu, Rui Qiao, Arun Verma, Yao Shu, Jingtan Wang, Xinyuan Niu, Zhenfeng He, Jiangwei Chen, Zijian Zhou, Gregory Kang Ruey Lau, Hieu Dao, Lucas Agussurja, Rachael Hwee Ling Sim, Xiaoqiang Lin, Wenyang Hu, Zhongxiang Dai, Pang Wei Koh, Bryan Kian Hsiang Low | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | This position paper proposes a data-centric viewpoint of AI research,
focusing on large language models (LLMs). We start by making the key
observation that data is instrumental in the developmental (e.g., pretraining
and fine-tuning) and inferential stages (e.g., in-context learning) of LLMs,
and yet it receives disproportionally low attention from the research
community. We identify four specific scenarios centered around data, covering
data-centric benchmarks and data curation, data attribution, knowledge
transfer, and inference contextualization. In each scenario, we underscore the
importance of data, highlight promising research directions, and articulate the
potential impacts on the research community and, where applicable, the society
as a whole. For instance, we advocate for a suite of data-centric benchmarks
tailored to the scale and complexity of data for LLMs. These benchmarks can be
used to develop new data curation methods and document research efforts and
results, which can help promote openness and transparency in AI and LLM
research. | [
-0.38937193155288696,
-0.9504434466362,
0.6438502073287964,
-0.02431081421673298,
0.18653589487075806,
0.04345148429274559,
-0.4602331519126892,
-0.47048696875572205,
-0.027046075090765953,
0.5117890238761902,
-0.3618101179599762,
-0.4666786789894104,
-0.5874335169792175,
-0.028387511149048805,
-0.6962246298789978,
0.89178466796875,
0.018593745306134224,
0.11329150199890137,
-0.7674549221992493,
-0.06487201899290085,
-0.3559161126613617,
-0.9184843897819519,
-0.9402608275413513,
-0.5160703063011169,
0.6801237463951111,
0.7472888827323914,
0.5232813358306885,
1.049342155456543,
0.4043997526168823,
0.20670905709266663,
0.0011145402677357197,
-0.12887193262577057,
-0.5822145938873291,
0.22277440130710602,
-0.05907285213470459,
-0.7957693934440613,
-0.5143257975578308,
0.28320780396461487,
0.754276692867279,
1.1605623960494995,
0.03702196851372719,
0.1556159406900406,
0.001755831646732986,
0.8697340488433838,
-0.33126500248908997,
0.47014015913009644,
-0.5250140428543091,
-0.1143699437379837,
-0.5733276009559631,
0.06320419162511826,
-0.25676873326301575,
-0.3213830590248108,
0.13787886500358582,
-0.4204781651496887,
0.1175585687160492,
0.1521480828523636,
0.1728479266166687,
0.2888677418231964,
-0.1684824377298355,
-0.18397383391857147,
-0.8506773114204407,
0.9513663053512573,
-0.759692907333374,
0.3855479657649994,
0.49164190888404846,
0.11202580481767654,
-0.25569406151771545,
-0.5299074649810791,
-0.6458526253700256,
-0.10806091129779816,
0.24502338469028473,
-0.2779082655906677,
-0.10335957258939743,
-0.21880631148815155,
0.39063405990600586,
0.4202086627483368,
-0.4620908200740814,
0.49580544233322144,
-0.315971314907074,
0.18977570533752441,
0.8555089235305786,
0.3719276189804077,
-0.06676463037729263,
0.46896791458129883,
-0.022022966295480728,
0.018550153821706772,
-1.0765665769577026,
-0.05364236980676651,
0.2417878359556198,
0.5627506375312805,
-0.16662712395191193,
0.5640758275985718,
-0.4892995059490204,
0.6555737257003784,
0.04229496046900749,
0.018419580534100533,
0.5483261346817017,
-0.45635369420051575,
-0.0264079999178648,
-0.053324438631534576,
0.5817055106163025,
0.06601536273956299,
0.40019938349723816,
-0.2969289720058441,
-0.18386949598789215,
0.023825865238904953,
0.2745048701763153,
-0.7041606903076172,
-0.04667012020945549,
0.36768558621406555,
-0.32053688168525696,
-0.20179422199726105,
-0.1724730283021927,
-0.869712769985199,
-0.6715958714485168,
-0.7243859767913818,
-0.05166563019156456,
-0.19353489577770233,
-0.2345919907093048,
-0.06569761037826538,
0.4103949964046478,
0.417035311460495,
0.356558233499527,
-0.8006892800331116,
0.32168009877204895,
1.0748870372772217,
0.5656753182411194,
-0.45411306619644165,
-0.422214150428772,
-0.22468669712543488,
0.14502444863319397,
-0.4431138038635254,
0.6093704700469971,
-0.7313703298568726,
-0.41552868485450745,
0.18161845207214355,
-0.08015535771846771,
0.045298170298337936,
-0.6303029656410217,
0.47391387820243835,
-0.25950202345848083,
0.19242940843105316,
-0.2204832136631012,
-0.8582476377487183,
-0.06479430198669434,
0.4126633405685425,
-0.6797942519187927,
0.743294358253479,
0.027557047083973885,
-0.7328797578811646,
0.42165812849998474,
-0.8076485395431519,
-0.73124760389328,
0.08018834888935089,
-0.40143781900405884,
-0.3310590982437134,
0.16431738436222076,
-0.04936943203210831,
0.42296868562698364,
-0.5308207869529724,
0.5582684278488159,
-0.4987650513648987,
-0.2529560327529907,
0.40540212392807007,
-0.543981671333313,
0.5276203155517578,
0.18689964711666107,
-0.2596588730812073,
-0.019338035956025124,
-0.6251696348190308,
-0.18170231580734253,
0.14442607760429382,
-0.19274355471134186,
-0.2871030569076538,
0.3418022692203522,
0.10976924002170563,
-0.04178833216428757,
0.48731178045272827,
-0.5514418482780457,
0.32332903146743774,
-0.3002009391784668,
0.5873989462852478,
0.7312309145927429,
-0.4409077763557434,
0.7378146648406982,
-0.35885658860206604,
0.4762495160102844,
0.15190428495407104,
0.3888649642467499,
-0.15817691385746002,
-0.26322513818740845,
-0.7198506593704224,
-0.060394372791051865,
0.3443678617477417,
0.20163854956626892,
-0.6299630403518677,
0.3309841752052307,
-0.29844558238983154,
-0.4286041557788849,
-0.5355278253555298,
0.11846659332513809,
0.05637015402317047,
0.5871289372444153,
0.17262807488441467,
-0.3260330557823181,
-0.43398168683052063,
-0.9068666696548462,
0.06255403161048889,
-0.25217458605766296,
0.20591044425964355,
0.4558391571044922,
0.32441332936286926,
-0.29479435086250305,
0.97776198387146,
-0.23002895712852478,
-0.15274064242839813,
-0.4855593740940094,
-0.029201103374361992,
0.2566632628440857,
0.5637998580932617,
0.3550781309604645,
-0.8565860390663147,
-0.30721092224121094,
-0.08571736514568329,
-0.7566606998443604,
-0.03901727497577667,
0.3552078902721405,
0.07903575152158737,
0.2321639358997345,
0.706723153591156,
-0.5882230997085571,
0.32893890142440796,
0.5188482999801636,
-0.08148026466369629,
0.15032172203063965,
-0.07148022204637527,
0.010698225349187851,
-0.9689861536026001,
0.38382431864738464,
0.01551742758601904,
0.008495145477354527,
-0.9896804690361023,
-0.2719264030456543,
-0.2315026968717575,
-0.10145430266857147,
-0.17021629214286804,
0.6872696280479431,
-0.2293725609779358,
-0.03869294375181198,
-0.30738365650177,
-0.021728070452809334,
-0.2773342430591583,
0.1561625897884369,
0.035680077970027924,
0.7114219665527344,
0.6405896544456482,
-0.5052182078361511,
0.276515930891037,
0.10008127242326736,
-0.41692477464675903,
0.41326195001602173,
-0.7496650815010071,
0.3735721707344055,
-0.20375603437423706,
0.2911113500595093,
-0.6316447854042053,
-0.22007791697978973,
0.22671405971050262,
-0.4306868612766266,
0.27449581027030945,
-0.017184169963002205,
-0.7091688513755798,
-0.24259379506111145,
-0.20886091887950897,
0.7937345504760742,
0.1553640216588974,
-0.2402210533618927,
0.19883845746517181,
0.9151716828346252,
-0.4156351685523987,
-0.3595135807991028,
-0.6444999575614929,
0.034956350922584534,
-0.4840443432331085,
-0.2471369355916977,
0.1663980484008789,
-0.1708998680114746,
-0.5379484295845032,
-0.06530552357435226,
0.2601068615913391,
-0.10572338104248047,
0.20362481474876404,
0.30912843346595764,
0.19259290397167206,
-0.16623897850513458,
0.20151767134666443,
-0.37964507937431335,
-0.27734217047691345,
0.18081191182136536,
-0.3153463304042816,
0.6106736063957214,
0.12790392339229584,
-0.38452091813087463,
-0.1862480193376541,
0.38760361075401306,
0.5657685399055481,
-0.2681785523891449,
0.6903669834136963,
0.2718081772327423,
-0.37264856696128845,
-0.17679134011268616,
-0.453250914812088,
-0.0720914974808693,
-0.35226356983184814,
0.27083340287208557,
-0.006161162629723549,
-1.0650705099105835,
0.5162729024887085,
-0.020480746403336525,
0.19889916479587555,
0.30577781796455383,
0.6349546313285828,
-0.16844868659973145,
0.9594983458518982,
0.9478045701980591,
-0.888435423374176,
0.6850677132606506,
-0.20037898421287537,
0.28989651799201965,
-0.8254746794700623,
-0.0531863197684288,
-0.7818167209625244,
-0.3624817132949829,
-0.6414164900779724,
-0.1888144463300705,
0.38357338309288025,
-0.26093462109565735,
-0.4153166711330414,
-0.1575317531824112,
-0.2280001938343048,
0.21902605891227722,
0.47526341676712036,
-0.19934991002082825,
0.2010028213262558,
-0.17405177652835846,
0.6223682165145874,
0.05525689572095871,
-0.7850136160850525,
-0.5139411091804504,
1.5147243738174438,
0.41841670870780945,
0.7963868975639343,
-0.1675446778535843,
0.428158700466156,
0.44258418679237366,
0.43201714754104614,
-0.7798780798912048,
0.3532864451408386,
-0.15353737771511078,
-0.697125256061554,
-0.45656001567840576,
-0.3871615529060364,
-1.0440236330032349,
-0.2790951132774353,
0.04549602046608925,
-0.5669090747833252,
0.14551325142383575,
0.0314621776342392,
-0.058186281472444534,
0.04651472717523575,
-0.4720400869846344,
0.7947490811347961,
-0.19679059088230133,
-0.3587196171283722,
-0.320549875497818,
-0.5285107493400574,
0.19012351334095,
-0.2122960090637207,
0.5540922284126282,
-0.1681446135044098,
0.00417204899713397,
0.7527969479560852,
-0.11925878375768661,
0.7902317643165588,
-0.282439649105072,
-0.1213708221912384,
0.22730040550231934,
-0.29888802766799927,
0.4878000020980835,
0.045519400388002396,
-0.28256112337112427,
0.2758278548717499,
-0.14255540072917938,
-0.32866671681404114,
-0.4554796516895294,
0.671527624130249,
-0.682086169719696,
-0.5321968793869019,
-0.30918338894844055,
-0.8459070324897766,
-0.43980443477630615,
-0.004582700319588184,
-0.10556617379188538,
0.34235894680023193,
-0.2772015631198883,
0.38739708065986633,
0.847423791885376,
-0.11043452471494675,
0.15733322501182556,
0.47255420684814453,
-0.2514837384223938,
0.01636621728539467,
1.0127922296524048,
0.19391317665576935,
0.11668237298727036,
0.298808217048645,
0.047973912209272385,
-0.2342730164527893,
-0.9311597347259521,
-0.31328466534614563,
0.16099071502685547,
-0.4526585638523102,
-0.053674858063459396,
-0.255881667137146,
-0.29033559560775757,
-0.34488409757614136,
0.07041051238775253,
-0.6284258365631104,
-0.1659085899591446,
-0.33572739362716675,
0.08554627001285553,
0.5397886037826538,
0.8721562623977661,
0.12329953163862228,
0.12245085835456848,
-0.29157209396362305,
0.03500702232122421,
-0.06377491354942322,
0.30528971552848816,
0.11134321987628937,
-0.45658621191978455,
-0.6928669810295105,
0.20621146261692047,
0.02072659693658352,
-0.004976041615009308,
0.20214016735553741,
-0.08002230525016785,
0.7012158036231995,
0.2856574058532715,
-0.12456747144460678,
0.3177899718284607,
-0.41410335898399353,
0.7626680135726929,
-0.1386527717113495,
-0.6289340853691101,
0.44666627049446106,
-0.3877698481082916,
0.19560523331165314,
0.9101264476776123,
0.25915205478668213,
-0.6872931718826294,
-0.16625548899173737,
-0.4599871039390564,
-0.864933967590332,
0.7596057653427124,
-0.09746289998292923,
0.15374276041984558,
0.25600966811180115,
0.43795543909072876,
0.4297560453414917,
0.509047269821167,
-0.32290467619895935,
-0.43683433532714844,
0.17384026944637299,
-0.310341477394104,
-0.42775920033454895,
-0.0015589515678584576,
-0.13860991597175598,
-0.33411237597465515,
0.4071783125400543,
-0.2666635811328888,
0.14105947315692902,
-0.2823062241077423,
0.06974055618047714,
0.06305184960365295,
0.24263215065002441,
0.29594066739082336,
0.8833736181259155,
0.073948934674263,
0.11806714534759521,
-0.11846206337213516,
-0.4397326409816742,
0.029749872162938118,
0.2588578164577484,
-0.4511170983314514,
-0.39359167218208313,
0.3563750684261322,
0.5716623663902283,
-0.09417074173688889,
-0.6716295480728149,
0.4210547208786011,
-0.05569720268249512,
-0.03275781869888306,
-0.37223562598228455,
0.05865637958049774,
-0.13509470224380493,
0.40880680084228516,
0.24417369067668915,
-0.39743897318840027,
-0.03356075659394264,
-0.8181142210960388,
0.12355303019285202,
0.40266090631484985,
-0.29168954491615295,
-0.4143740236759186,
0.5591388940811157,
0.14546629786491394,
-0.12562412023544312,
0.7844117283821106,
0.2830749750137329,
-0.27569279074668884,
0.7293784022331238,
0.1820298284292221,
0.7721399068832397,
-0.12322016805410385,
-0.059133585542440414,
-0.015048588626086712,
0.05276157706975937,
-0.06133875995874405,
0.2080356627702713,
0.02166246436536312,
-0.7675409913063049,
-0.2473261058330536,
-0.4810224771499634,
-0.5869847536087036,
0.4600687026977539,
-0.5600013136863708,
0.19183936715126038,
-0.4330148696899414,
0.003094182349741459,
0.21146631240844727,
0.20946986973285675,
-0.8230012655258179,
0.23305781185626984,
0.3863878548145294,
0.736393392086029,
-0.7249996662139893,
1.2594774961471558,
0.5874022841453552,
-0.33700236678123474,
-0.44007399678230286,
0.05303357541561127,
-0.022117337211966515,
-0.850166380405426,
0.4188719391822815,
-0.005471534561365843,
0.20010581612586975,
0.0295104943215847,
-1.0602450370788574,
-0.9404907822608948,
1.1098365783691406,
0.26113587617874146,
-0.4887089133262634,
0.07830625027418137,
0.42000293731689453,
0.7085666060447693,
-0.8294658660888672,
0.040170617401599884,
0.8532540798187256,
0.5756401419639587,
-0.06448692828416824,
-0.7071845531463623,
-0.29839441180229187,
-0.19012638926506042,
-0.13616807758808136,
0.01185581274330616,
-0.7142403721809387,
1.0205838680267334,
0.12712843716144562,
-0.0017670686356723309,
0.018447043374180794,
0.5673835277557373,
0.07454442977905273,
0.5147834420204163,
0.29162946343421936,
0.483033150434494,
0.5508779883384705,
-0.02875932678580284,
0.9549719095230103,
-0.45004379749298096,
0.008902083151042461,
1.1314753293991089,
-0.5392827987670898,
0.7236908674240112,
0.6437991857528687,
-0.36997318267822266,
0.15991035103797913,
0.7249311804771423,
0.06887102127075195,
0.40641549229621887,
0.37462949752807617,
-0.17226119339466095,
0.16793158650398254,
-0.5367005467414856,
-0.4439068138599396,
0.5883854031562805,
0.5831630825996399,
-0.3119399845600128,
0.11969147622585297,
-0.035013873130083084,
0.13720034062862396,
-0.015927571803331375,
-0.359713613986969,
0.7862244844436646,
0.10437332093715668,
-0.4162091314792633,
0.18336942791938782,
-0.09620726853609085,
0.4094730019569397,
-0.4796592593193054,
0.0457681268453598,
-0.509648323059082,
0.24037513136863708,
-0.04633783549070358,
-1.082553505897522,
0.3340243399143219,
0.24031008780002594,
-0.5717897415161133,
-0.26666221022605896,
0.39005038142204285,
-0.4147784113883972,
-0.4065653085708618,
0.24172855913639069,
0.7365341782569885,
0.3712349236011505,
0.01969553343951702,
-0.5947701930999756,
0.4840039908885956,
-0.13877421617507935,
-0.4455432891845703,
0.600333571434021,
0.7059714794158936,
-0.20573513209819794,
0.7741711735725403,
0.48228931427001953,
0.18983317911624908,
-0.15254059433937073,
0.2700177729129791,
1.0675691366195679,
-0.6888042688369751,
-0.05738673731684685,
-0.8099433779716492,
0.1209162026643753,
0.2444128841161728,
-0.26660749316215515,
0.7385238409042358,
0.6414070129394531,
0.9343002438545227,
0.41174429655075073,
1.1968528032302856,
-0.22525975108146667,
0.6541464924812317,
-0.28633254766464233,
0.671467125415802,
-0.3875471353530884,
0.16772492229938507,
-0.0012225403916090727,
-0.8805820345878601,
-0.1770927459001541,
0.19758334755897522,
-0.5905452966690063,
0.2365100085735321,
0.21318331360816956,
0.5494384169578552,
0.0896974727511406,
0.06493883579969406,
0.16879671812057495,
0.2900085151195526,
0.4339190721511841,
0.4501124620437622,
0.7209805846214294,
-0.13096126914024353,
-0.04689447954297066,
-0.19792461395263672,
-0.07265316694974899,
-0.1876300424337387,
-0.5061483383178711,
-0.6818667054176331,
-0.6725683212280273,
-0.17042256891727448,
0.09404756873846054,
-0.13384968042373657,
0.7294490337371826,
0.5570665001869202,
-0.9037461876869202,
-0.5567142963409424,
-0.16047902405261993,
0.17305061221122742,
0.19222921133041382,
-0.205427348613739,
0.18383483588695526,
-0.19556310772895813,
-0.9031810760498047,
0.36592188477516174,
0.21167156100273132,
-0.1175597682595253,
-0.6796697974205017,
-0.09623029828071594,
-0.08304193615913391,
-0.052880413830280304,
0.6236169338226318,
0.41407760977745056,
-0.4233630299568176,
-0.23675386607646942,
-0.19934341311454773,
-0.1925380825996399,
0.050650086253881454,
0.8075117468833923,
-0.7392896413803101,
0.3754495084285736,
0.28243398666381836,
0.8539583683013916,
0.41416871547698975,
0.04143667221069336,
0.8138054013252258,
-0.37359991669654846,
0.26948732137680054,
0.33076679706573486,
0.07093539834022522,
0.568561851978302,
-0.31427061557769775,
0.7058795690536499,
0.14122821390628815,
-0.7605242133140564,
-0.8660276532173157,
0.010769562795758247,
-0.7196088433265686,
-0.04156094789505005,
1.1096218824386597,
-0.03962383419275284,
-0.12402358651161194,
-0.21201437711715698,
0.17856772243976593,
0.18085551261901855,
-0.4278584122657776,
0.7826738357543945,
0.7939488291740417,
-0.339533269405365,
-0.20490486919879913,
-0.8965415954589844,
0.5576725602149963,
0.267422616481781,
-1.1736558675765991,
0.6025340557098389,
0.5174704194068909,
-0.054962802678346634,
-0.061860378831624985,
0.4876151978969574,
-0.20045073330402374,
-0.23511238396167755,
-0.07369646430015564,
0.11061835289001465,
0.12213950604200363,
-0.48528382182121277,
-0.5226436257362366,
-0.07879987359046936,
0.34564831852912903,
-0.024786094203591347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14464v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14464v1 | A Review of Common Online Speaker Diarization Methods | 2024-06-20T16:26:03 | 2024-06-20T16:26:03 | Roman Aperdannier, Sigurd Schacht, Alexander Piazza | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Speaker diarization provides the answer to the question "who spoke when?" for
an audio file. This information can be used to complete audio transcripts for
further processing steps. Most speaker diarization systems assume that the
audio file is available as a whole. However, there are scenarios in which the
speaker labels are needed immediately after the arrival of an audio segment.
Speaker diarization with a correspondingly low latency is referred to as online
speaker diarization. This paper provides an overview. First the history of
online speaker diarization is briefly presented. Next a taxonomy and datasets
for training and evaluation are given. In the sections that follow, online
diarization methods and systems are discussed in detail. This paper concludes
with the presentation of challenges that still need to be solved by future
research in the field of online speaker diarization. | [
-0.8149717450141907,
-0.7951648235321045,
0.6192381978034973,
0.09386339038610458,
0.07519404590129852,
0.1480548232793808,
-0.2461652159690857,
-0.8749992251396179,
0.5321216583251953,
0.2928389310836792,
-0.5133795142173767,
-0.1321597844362259,
-0.3864094913005829,
0.20763051509857178,
-0.49318528175354004,
0.6499241590499878,
0.36823368072509766,
0.15537862479686737,
-0.15048177540302277,
0.054438501596450806,
-0.5893858075141907,
-0.6175063252449036,
-0.7970743179321289,
-0.4865354597568512,
0.2390720099210739,
0.5952453017234802,
0.3349650204181671,
0.6573026776313782,
0.5601872801780701,
0.512447714805603,
-0.3610941767692566,
0.08935384452342987,
-0.07056334614753723,
0.18752925097942352,
0.24843642115592957,
-0.3392343521118164,
-0.5616707801818848,
0.1381487101316452,
0.5047410130500793,
1.3893886804580688,
-0.42139002680778503,
-0.054728154093027115,
-0.40286532044410706,
0.23435813188552856,
-0.6268032789230347,
-0.22581346333026886,
-0.3213678002357483,
0.3976287841796875,
-0.4208439290523529,
-0.5460022687911987,
-0.36104241013526917,
-0.5642934441566467,
0.46627116203308105,
-0.6269651651382446,
0.6223726868629456,
-0.21835219860076904,
0.49417898058891296,
0.14404787123203278,
-0.20570163428783417,
-0.26899874210357666,
-1.4005268812179565,
0.5977214574813843,
-0.5389691591262817,
0.5625320672988892,
0.9729046821594238,
0.6117761135101318,
0.005729910917580128,
-0.6533834934234619,
-0.4032360911369324,
0.06850812584161758,
-0.03417391702532768,
0.029173916205763817,
0.02546682208776474,
0.31522253155708313,
0.250006765127182,
0.42635905742645264,
-0.16329628229141235,
0.01313073467463255,
-0.46378812193870544,
-0.3215126395225525,
0.4210110306739807,
-0.25820156931877136,
0.05308489501476288,
0.1360412836074829,
-0.2563396096229553,
0.2826365828514099,
-0.29588010907173157,
-0.21016477048397064,
0.4604649841785431,
0.32443803548812866,
-0.12941108644008636,
0.3702241778373718,
-0.29320213198661804,
0.840823233127594,
0.4066064953804016,
-0.32075104117393494,
0.38808178901672363,
-0.37818118929862976,
0.23496510088443756,
0.7157242894172668,
0.5790722966194153,
0.4823263883590698,
0.18003897368907928,
-0.05712170526385307,
-0.2820390462875366,
-0.26854878664016724,
-0.09614964574575424,
-0.4646952450275421,
-0.3049522638320923,
0.18422353267669678,
-0.401584267616272,
0.3165852725505829,
-0.12382727116346359,
-0.8054866790771484,
-0.3581658601760864,
-0.3703804314136505,
0.4621579349040985,
-0.14017564058303833,
-0.11580569297075272,
0.10150055587291718,
-0.3398086130619049,
-0.10241014510393143,
0.35165032744407654,
-1.199853539466858,
0.7553274035453796,
0.357685387134552,
0.9155588150024414,
0.05953231081366539,
0.20780721306800842,
-0.818311870098114,
0.18221977353096008,
-0.16340510547161102,
0.8859157562255859,
-0.3101721405982971,
-0.5969340801239014,
-0.03609080612659454,
-0.18444417417049408,
0.14819401502609253,
-0.5148879289627075,
0.34133321046829224,
-0.4017966091632843,
0.32928523421287537,
-0.16304972767829895,
-0.8214040994644165,
0.3207247853279114,
-0.11152796447277069,
-0.44551682472229004,
0.7762987017631531,
-0.11844180524349213,
-0.9953358769416809,
0.2775188982486725,
-0.5094942450523376,
-0.06056993454694748,
0.37578192353248596,
-0.3163907527923584,
-0.23303461074829102,
-0.26428329944610596,
0.2795582115650177,
0.5528790950775146,
0.2949103116989136,
-0.13213706016540527,
0.1294809877872467,
-0.482115238904953,
0.14677774906158447,
-0.09396719187498093,
0.6295539736747742,
0.3882182836532593,
-0.15775775909423828,
-0.377008855342865,
-1.2450851202011108,
-0.1771078109741211,
0.0056720939464867115,
-0.6917575597763062,
-0.4189187288284302,
0.6048056483268738,
-0.11721444875001907,
-0.5115460157394409,
0.08896138519048691,
-0.7953125834465027,
-0.19154366850852966,
-0.6932437419891357,
0.44241461157798767,
0.5180768370628357,
0.3517545461654663,
0.20825675129890442,
-0.3671632409095764,
0.11695148050785065,
-0.3049224019050598,
0.1835716962814331,
-0.29632389545440674,
-0.7757059335708618,
-0.8943707942962646,
0.10673470795154572,
0.14409245550632477,
0.6827005743980408,
-0.29355236887931824,
0.37679463624954224,
-0.1357240229845047,
-0.6335208415985107,
-0.36077460646629333,
-0.10987387597560883,
0.526892900466919,
0.18939833343029022,
0.5018390417098999,
-0.5285283923149109,
-0.699056088924408,
-0.6721245646476746,
0.1204214096069336,
-0.45118752121925354,
-0.16500617563724518,
0.25534698367118835,
-0.2901937961578369,
-0.14616025984287262,
1.0693559646606445,
-0.5039310455322266,
-0.10545116662979126,
-0.018852422013878822,
0.4836002290248871,
0.08860070258378983,
0.3033839762210846,
0.358311265707016,
-0.696152925491333,
-0.46195530891418457,
0.08893729001283646,
-0.22300268709659576,
-0.29767727851867676,
-0.20687943696975708,
0.517156720161438,
-0.17961931228637695,
0.7974932193756104,
-0.19867807626724243,
0.18432670831680298,
0.3650297224521637,
0.09046293050050735,
0.14016211032867432,
-0.33478185534477234,
0.13503342866897583,
-0.6190868020057678,
-0.2871040999889374,
-0.008852032013237476,
-0.42975547909736633,
-0.9713447093963623,
-0.533621609210968,
-0.5957472920417786,
0.04113846644759178,
-0.6609498858451843,
0.20353692770004272,
-0.5896880626678467,
-0.5150146484375,
-0.1559082269668579,
0.6948925256729126,
-0.2589658498764038,
0.14659474790096283,
0.025959601625800133,
0.5709648728370667,
0.25332123041152954,
-0.8769121766090393,
0.8783758878707886,
0.6045786142349243,
-0.6447762846946716,
0.7824321389198303,
-0.2024562656879425,
0.6583307385444641,
-0.1767214685678482,
0.007954994216561317,
-1.0539348125457764,
-0.239448681473732,
0.2685113251209259,
-0.38885027170181274,
0.43554607033729553,
-0.26902392506599426,
-0.06208663433790207,
-0.2597425580024719,
0.30035024881362915,
0.6407925486564636,
-0.017987996339797974,
-0.2729049324989319,
0.07317166775465012,
0.7007234692573547,
-0.43434521555900574,
-0.14374268054962158,
-0.4452102780342102,
0.02208663709461689,
-0.29031360149383545,
-0.2928992807865143,
0.45788300037384033,
-0.3869299590587616,
-0.7734407782554626,
-0.5602031350135803,
0.27596837282180786,
-0.4494941830635071,
-0.09200909733772278,
0.22633375227451324,
-0.12510180473327637,
-0.12806187570095062,
0.2775973975658417,
-0.5286199450492859,
-0.3093491196632385,
-0.20728380978107452,
0.2643243968486786,
0.42178022861480713,
0.1540004163980484,
-0.40273353457450867,
-0.7073582410812378,
0.601033091545105,
-0.10293906182050705,
0.08398836106061935,
0.46421757340431213,
0.5615270137786865,
-0.30515575408935547,
0.08913790434598923,
-0.8058326244354248,
-0.0935923308134079,
-0.4987015426158905,
0.10055819153785706,
-0.18122795224189758,
-0.5823512077331543,
0.337129682302475,
-0.17598837614059448,
-0.15856897830963135,
0.15856710076332092,
0.4082314074039459,
-0.3735989034175873,
0.6241871118545532,
0.7697483897209167,
0.32316309213638306,
0.6982464790344238,
0.11710354685783386,
0.2913931608200073,
-0.38982731103897095,
-0.45950090885162354,
-0.79257732629776,
-0.01927095651626587,
-0.6366966366767883,
-0.15283727645874023,
0.2823604345321655,
0.10631263256072998,
0.10421014577150345,
0.5049697160720825,
-0.7082709074020386,
0.6730955243110657,
0.5793514251708984,
0.05493872985243797,
0.4007504880428314,
0.0035969812888652086,
0.08133972436189651,
-0.06963372975587845,
-0.2904377281665802,
-0.10822689533233643,
0.5171055197715759,
0.5470622181892395,
0.5645374655723572,
-0.15540623664855957,
0.5672017931938171,
0.5748386383056641,
-0.21204602718353271,
-0.8945379257202148,
0.6030867695808411,
0.45547670125961304,
-0.6593469977378845,
-0.5489746928215027,
-0.29079335927963257,
-0.9937577843666077,
-0.17345525324344635,
-0.025168785825371742,
-1.1080350875854492,
0.48655152320861816,
0.1512506604194641,
-0.628742516040802,
0.20108428597450256,
-0.7923270463943481,
0.33248722553253174,
-0.26202985644340515,
0.5513532161712646,
-0.212471142411232,
-1.0572227239608765,
-0.15683519840240479,
-0.2891817092895508,
0.6773453950881958,
-0.177851140499115,
0.12563510239124298,
1.3665062189102173,
-0.43382999300956726,
0.7903003692626953,
-0.31724339723587036,
0.010132376104593277,
0.48252058029174805,
-0.24871648848056793,
0.17243100702762604,
-0.4888246953487396,
0.13041998445987701,
0.1918521374464035,
0.3750291168689728,
0.054216936230659485,
-0.0899282917380333,
0.25055131316185,
-1.0448122024536133,
-0.4358232021331787,
-0.15819288790225983,
0.26294922828674316,
-0.5048081874847412,
0.10599439591169357,
0.5129750967025757,
0.6304733753204346,
-0.2984272241592407,
0.08607359230518341,
0.8070515990257263,
-0.2473991960287094,
0.7783306837081909,
0.3074583411216736,
-0.16957220435142517,
-0.6182872653007507,
0.8782419562339783,
0.21481762826442719,
0.27206936478614807,
0.6388610601425171,
0.07595202326774597,
0.019047100096940994,
-0.6230029463768005,
0.08330431580543518,
0.2410169243812561,
-1.0566545724868774,
0.22742003202438354,
-0.6062152981758118,
-0.4439285397529602,
-0.3343846797943115,
0.03541792556643486,
-0.62071692943573,
-0.6752631068229675,
-0.3501664102077484,
-0.19422203302383423,
0.2621613144874573,
0.9552814364433289,
-0.19778607785701752,
0.9296651482582092,
-0.8974010348320007,
0.3947516083717346,
0.4912719428539276,
0.5527690052986145,
-0.2230335772037506,
-0.2992425262928009,
-0.6976686716079712,
-0.10977362841367722,
-0.5372153520584106,
-1.1768962144851685,
0.15611179172992706,
0.7013490200042725,
0.7645400166511536,
0.7908192276954651,
-0.10827292501926422,
0.6181160807609558,
-0.5516427755355835,
0.7633090019226074,
0.31943264603614807,
-0.8050644993782043,
0.8366475701332092,
-0.47255900502204895,
-0.1382608562707901,
0.24113807082176208,
0.5547755360603333,
-1.1275248527526855,
-0.16302430629730225,
-0.3419388234615326,
-0.8601373434066772,
0.7655213475227356,
0.30351710319519043,
-0.06957653164863586,
-0.18185213208198547,
0.05106924846768379,
0.24424798786640167,
0.10985027253627777,
-0.38541164994239807,
-0.5443102121353149,
-0.2556687593460083,
0.6324363946914673,
-0.2607381045818329,
-0.20253297686576843,
-0.09506314247846603,
-0.39859429001808167,
0.45081397891044617,
0.25425562262535095,
0.7340696454048157,
0.22024957835674286,
0.10413707792758942,
-0.4770025610923767,
0.3839467167854309,
0.4903325140476227,
0.7093863487243652,
-0.6317794322967529,
-0.08223164826631546,
0.12371684610843658,
-0.4283735752105713,
0.2657410800457001,
-0.3445691168308258,
-0.016024429351091385,
0.41932618618011475,
0.32811450958251953,
0.8034323453903198,
0.35904568433761597,
-0.42011624574661255,
0.5786696672439575,
-0.11880473792552948,
-0.16926155984401703,
-0.7744802236557007,
-0.13878454267978668,
-0.07991292327642441,
-0.03322887420654297,
0.45240890979766846,
-0.0009952248074114323,
-0.07441890984773636,
-0.4439900517463684,
0.2817683815956116,
-0.027321767061948776,
-0.43467986583709717,
-0.2853935658931732,
0.5181348919868469,
0.411903977394104,
-0.8137418627738953,
0.7575773596763611,
0.13961581885814667,
-0.2519798278808594,
0.15111486613750458,
0.3311574161052704,
0.7009177207946777,
-0.8046327233314514,
0.2614706754684448,
0.21666811406612396,
-0.27513906359672546,
0.08546443283557892,
0.14759057760238647,
-0.38024166226387024,
-0.8294210433959961,
-0.30077624320983887,
-0.6664848923683167,
-0.7007137537002563,
0.0947464108467102,
-0.5235875248908997,
0.2572866380214691,
-0.5554239749908447,
-0.9447354674339294,
0.23391450941562653,
-0.24897688627243042,
-0.40057510137557983,
0.294540137052536,
0.5823726058006287,
0.5015002489089966,
-0.9547290802001953,
0.23416593670845032,
0.40097907185554504,
-0.012880569323897362,
-0.302969366312027,
-0.20634058117866516,
0.16729958355426788,
-0.18379198014736176,
0.46279582381248474,
-0.1296580284833908,
0.015135967172682285,
0.0018586849328130484,
-0.3892098665237427,
-0.9506273865699768,
0.5453408360481262,
0.03859047591686249,
-0.4949184060096741,
-0.11940350383520126,
0.31199198961257935,
0.31938737630844116,
-0.05947008728981018,
0.6329123377799988,
0.4624209403991699,
0.5580052733421326,
0.37014856934547424,
-1.3544849157333374,
-0.6240723729133606,
-0.16668787598609924,
-0.2252488136291504,
0.18977242708206177,
-0.5111289620399475,
0.8266639113426208,
-0.06110669672489166,
-0.3845330476760864,
0.01828250102698803,
0.5270559191703796,
-0.261288046836853,
0.36833927035331726,
0.5853914618492126,
0.22885248064994812,
0.8548604846000671,
-0.19757315516471863,
0.6141124963760376,
0.05581093207001686,
0.2112206071615219,
1.06155526638031,
0.06657291948795319,
0.9075993895530701,
0.4759707450866699,
-0.7918162941932678,
0.15227524936199188,
1.109839677810669,
0.019500117748975754,
0.6374214887619019,
0.09563781321048737,
-0.33630767464637756,
-0.5133360624313354,
-0.3429504632949829,
-0.6307735443115234,
0.5496259927749634,
0.2944941222667694,
0.11166829615831375,
-0.27739331126213074,
0.17603111267089844,
-0.3878399729728699,
-0.09724244475364685,
-0.3162485659122467,
0.985954225063324,
0.12560872733592987,
-0.3426370620727539,
0.502160370349884,
0.007205253466963768,
0.31082630157470703,
-0.3403676152229309,
0.024969961494207382,
-0.22005271911621094,
0.25453266501426697,
-0.4192497134208679,
-0.48617038130760193,
0.3072923719882965,
-0.16964733600616455,
-0.15263409912586212,
-0.4240361750125885,
0.33064740896224976,
-0.2004762440919876,
-0.14140477776527405,
0.4862974286079407,
0.5508201718330383,
0.7072574496269226,
0.3931998908519745,
0.020684242248535156,
-0.2096642106771469,
-0.32630717754364014,
-0.07174978405237198,
0.1273546814918518,
0.31369084119796753,
-0.0676993653178215,
0.8543332815170288,
0.32221317291259766,
0.5581600069999695,
0.5292421579360962,
0.39527660608291626,
0.4538646936416626,
-0.4997033178806305,
-0.7585627436637878,
-0.468321293592453,
0.1963154673576355,
0.25393855571746826,
-0.11729948967695236,
0.6876997947692871,
0.6218332648277283,
1.147944450378418,
0.11250750720500946,
0.4677877426147461,
0.13235324621200562,
1.1349964141845703,
-0.23179984092712402,
0.668271541595459,
-0.3514208197593689,
0.22412559390068054,
-0.5078994631767273,
-0.9525039196014404,
-0.1394633799791336,
0.5839073657989502,
-0.13563279807567596,
-0.04093804955482483,
0.7039875388145447,
0.504887044429779,
-0.053302276879549026,
0.10697384923696518,
0.4957934617996216,
0.008294012397527695,
0.19030410051345825,
0.15095116198062897,
0.9399766325950623,
-0.3586790859699249,
0.4996856451034546,
-0.25375494360923767,
-0.10990959405899048,
-0.40452152490615845,
-0.5792689323425293,
-0.7020326852798462,
-0.7983893156051636,
-0.6250967383384705,
0.06656793504953384,
0.15893247723579407,
1.084343433380127,
0.6793444752693176,
-1.0606387853622437,
-0.4702419340610504,
0.28785648941993713,
-0.1447775959968567,
-0.20737692713737488,
-0.05948309600353241,
0.1915082186460495,
-0.01607302948832512,
-0.5715081095695496,
0.8464949727058411,
0.07086063176393509,
0.4207725524902344,
0.1091236025094986,
-0.2137717753648758,
-0.26126277446746826,
0.08226306736469269,
-0.004391773138195276,
0.6418852210044861,
-0.5271078944206238,
-0.3852512538433075,
-0.621324360370636,
-0.08694203197956085,
0.7521317005157471,
0.7586879134178162,
-0.6498105525970459,
0.8934776186943054,
0.6339914798736572,
0.18908491730690002,
0.7342245578765869,
0.26154327392578125,
0.3843294084072113,
-1.0459764003753662,
0.15293310582637787,
0.2342759221792221,
0.24273240566253662,
0.6157549023628235,
-0.06243455410003662,
0.0835626870393753,
0.6739466786384583,
-0.6587494015693665,
-0.614098846912384,
-0.049049634486436844,
-0.8901856541633606,
0.13661931455135345,
0.7702659964561462,
-0.12513628602027893,
0.282070517539978,
-0.6782251596450806,
-0.13006265461444855,
0.6246222853660583,
-0.08189646154642105,
0.6305264234542847,
0.7758163213729858,
-0.3202074468135834,
-0.2133159190416336,
-0.5563763976097107,
0.6532000303268433,
-0.21769343316555023,
-0.5250922441482544,
-0.16973096132278442,
0.34027430415153503,
0.02459757961332798,
0.6367778778076172,
1.1625288724899292,
0.35163265466690063,
-0.10942894965410233,
0.08334372192621231,
-0.033017486333847046,
0.24290861189365387,
-0.5774304270744324,
0.1069999411702156,
0.1208217591047287,
-0.07975546270608902,
-0.49711450934410095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14462v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14462v1 | Explicit and Implicit Large Language Model Personas Generate Opinions but Fail to Replicate Deeper Perceptions and Biases | 2024-06-20T16:24:07 | 2024-06-20T16:24:07 | Salvatore Giorgi, Tingting Liu, Ankit Aich, Kelsey Isman, Garrick Sherman, Zachary Fried, João Sedoc, Lyle H. Ungar, Brenda Curtis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being used in human-centered
social scientific tasks, such as data annotation, synthetic data creation, and
engaging in dialog. However, these tasks are highly subjective and dependent on
human factors, such as one's environment, attitudes, beliefs, and lived
experiences. Thus, employing LLMs (which do not have such human factors) in
these tasks may result in a lack of variation in data, failing to reflect the
diversity of human experiences. In this paper, we examine the role of prompting
LLMs with human-like personas and asking the models to answer as if they were a
specific human. This is done explicitly, with exact demographics, political
beliefs, and lived experiences, or implicitly via names prevalent in specific
populations. The LLM personas are then evaluated via (1) subjective annotation
task (e.g., detecting toxicity) and (2) a belief generation task, where both
tasks are known to vary across human factors. We examine the impact of explicit
vs. implicit personas and investigate which human factors LLMs recognize and
respond to. Results show that LLM personas show mixed results when reproducing
known human biases, but generate generally fail to demonstrate implicit biases.
We conclude that LLMs lack the intrinsic cognitive mechanisms of human thought,
while capturing the statistical patterns of how people speak, which may
restrict their effectiveness in complex social science applications. | [
-0.4375746548175812,
-0.6710245013237,
1.0550092458724976,
0.3425958454608917,
0.04878823831677437,
0.17769929766654968,
-0.3305619955062866,
-0.43193647265434265,
0.0023333525750786066,
0.3863455653190613,
-0.536880373954773,
-0.4173869788646698,
-0.3974941670894623,
0.2001766562461853,
-0.04394722729921341,
0.9646002054214478,
0.22198058664798737,
0.22172021865844727,
-0.29505211114883423,
0.07926751673221588,
-0.23445583879947662,
-0.743130087852478,
-0.6449424624443054,
-0.7776283621788025,
0.9147725701332092,
0.3606487512588501,
0.7049946784973145,
0.10207536816596985,
-0.051807574927806854,
0.2591152787208557,
-0.10836616903543472,
0.1740456074476242,
-0.4912862181663513,
0.264526903629303,
-0.2897796034812927,
-0.6577528715133667,
-0.19855093955993652,
0.3039079010486603,
0.6450888514518738,
1.0184216499328613,
0.22946995496749878,
0.13943995535373688,
0.1215139627456665,
0.4845982491970062,
-0.5166184902191162,
0.3181959390640259,
-0.5157947540283203,
0.14304736256599426,
0.004614161793142557,
-0.07140582799911499,
-0.49989280104637146,
-0.4428552985191345,
0.4445997178554535,
-0.28245919942855835,
0.10581719875335693,
0.07561232894659042,
0.3109775483608246,
0.040581561625003815,
-0.65397709608078,
-0.35983893275260925,
-0.9524392485618591,
0.7858928442001343,
-0.8112146258354187,
0.029241902753710747,
0.363951712846756,
-0.0684407502412796,
-0.3913765549659729,
-0.17602460086345673,
-0.7411592602729797,
-0.4410628378391266,
-0.24439315497875214,
-0.01817915216088295,
0.07497646659612656,
0.10231779515743256,
0.543456494808197,
-0.16549621522426605,
-0.21245242655277252,
0.20503516495227814,
-0.25905007123947144,
-0.16371817886829376,
0.6490686535835266,
0.317521870136261,
0.09733479470014572,
-0.4106784164905548,
-0.1755732148885727,
-0.027145447209477425,
-0.8962644338607788,
0.15104785561561584,
0.6244943737983704,
0.35048583149909973,
-0.0761895626783371,
0.607343852519989,
-0.06679944694042206,
0.35680171847343445,
0.22147221863269806,
-0.1221035048365593,
0.2980124354362488,
0.18115152418613434,
-0.16340240836143494,
0.018586572259664536,
0.865910530090332,
0.29673755168914795,
0.5893040895462036,
0.1421366035938263,
-0.0961802676320076,
0.29569217562675476,
0.1986381560564041,
-0.6183256506919861,
0.04142871871590614,
0.3045632243156433,
-0.2474997192621231,
-0.3987262547016144,
-0.03836028650403023,
-0.8839493989944458,
-0.8363037109375,
-0.47868379950523376,
0.09303926676511765,
0.001343569136224687,
-0.24863667786121368,
0.03174082189798355,
0.05593952164053917,
0.298387736082077,
0.5794945955276489,
-0.7580049633979797,
0.31382039189338684,
0.6446604132652283,
0.5272189378738403,
-0.2416880875825882,
-0.22412841022014618,
-0.35067516565322876,
0.1322278380393982,
-0.39523664116859436,
0.7275089025497437,
-0.7174063324928284,
-0.6536651253700256,
0.05418720468878746,
0.019917918369174004,
0.09892643243074417,
-0.5566845536231995,
0.5218555331230164,
-0.1614007204771042,
0.3198537528514862,
-0.9343498945236206,
-0.4354792833328247,
-0.07038099318742752,
0.08056329935789108,
-0.25303494930267334,
0.7717518210411072,
-0.2286882847547531,
-0.8441510200500488,
0.3642518222332001,
-0.6582743525505066,
-0.314506858587265,
0.15340183675289154,
-0.5539391040802002,
-0.04872952774167061,
0.2910316586494446,
0.07127277553081512,
0.7057696580886841,
-0.3670664131641388,
0.39439207315444946,
-0.6578160524368286,
-0.34977543354034424,
0.6867364048957825,
-0.34605854749679565,
0.7336646318435669,
-0.032245758920907974,
-0.5616478323936462,
0.21935607492923737,
-0.3413189649581909,
-0.2942781448364258,
0.2758033275604248,
-0.3097876310348511,
-0.42828169465065,
0.3697391152381897,
0.050024110823869705,
0.35351067781448364,
0.02021021768450737,
-0.6198822259902954,
0.21579761803150177,
-0.20550039410591125,
0.4481409192085266,
1.1835087537765503,
0.06329130381345749,
0.482975572347641,
-0.41377612948417664,
0.3055969178676605,
0.09914866834878922,
-0.03127308934926987,
0.03822886571288109,
-0.5813034772872925,
-0.8087966442108154,
0.012967892922461033,
-0.10269422829151154,
0.4481508731842041,
-0.44229787588119507,
0.19951669871807098,
-0.3524045944213867,
-0.39732998609542847,
-0.40326744318008423,
0.20146748423576355,
0.36169949173927307,
0.4997841417789459,
-0.1093074381351471,
-0.09860027581453323,
-0.5028752088546753,
-1.2122033834457397,
-0.347526490688324,
-0.4815042018890381,
-0.17289410531520844,
0.6659762859344482,
0.7516862154006958,
-0.32993900775909424,
0.9524295330047607,
-0.43771645426750183,
0.018520167097449303,
-0.2419809252023697,
0.3097494840621948,
-0.0712403804063797,
0.22916562855243683,
0.4240744113922119,
-0.7951241135597229,
-0.2775226831436157,
-0.25551125407218933,
-0.8292403221130371,
-0.3255406320095062,
-0.07598812878131866,
0.10397778451442719,
0.3098520040512085,
0.19112993776798248,
-0.7300185561180115,
0.11961971968412399,
0.43651318550109863,
-0.2801302671432495,
0.6356120705604553,
-0.1319185197353363,
0.03616039454936981,
-0.7890957593917847,
0.14274296164512634,
0.38347989320755005,
-0.10342979431152344,
-0.6591585278511047,
-0.21727991104125977,
-0.20582658052444458,
0.12915126979351044,
-0.5610584616661072,
0.8099626898765564,
-0.47741496562957764,
-0.2822510302066803,
-0.22317777574062347,
0.18782152235507965,
-0.07700823247432709,
0.4826243817806244,
0.2849898338317871,
0.5964808464050293,
0.333469957113266,
-0.5757913589477539,
0.1282866895198822,
0.13136281073093414,
-0.32637688517570496,
0.7220167517662048,
-0.7570191621780396,
0.44711074233055115,
-0.6644170880317688,
0.5260513424873352,
-0.9236525893211365,
-0.5524047613143921,
0.294607937335968,
-0.28301724791526794,
0.03594961762428284,
-0.0508095920085907,
-0.7141430974006653,
-0.30911847949028015,
-0.2848127782344818,
0.076088085770607,
0.5944793224334717,
-0.26838499307632446,
0.6726225018501282,
0.54597407579422,
-0.35501810908317566,
-0.3360746502876282,
-0.8239402770996094,
0.13509677350521088,
-0.2965390980243683,
-0.3898937404155731,
-0.09427390247583389,
-0.21709901094436646,
-0.733135998249054,
-0.22852636873722076,
0.07326103001832962,
0.26887333393096924,
-0.16531682014465332,
0.5486460328102112,
0.32618412375450134,
-0.028735820204019547,
0.08338296413421631,
-0.003975934814661741,
0.1962541937828064,
0.5283682346343994,
-0.006708797998726368,
0.442832350730896,
-0.23476044833660126,
-0.49722227454185486,
-0.2464396059513092,
0.4418909251689911,
0.7727093696594238,
0.14130136370658875,
0.7385994791984558,
0.2803415060043335,
-0.29899439215660095,
-0.11287546157836914,
-0.7881258726119995,
-0.23058295249938965,
-0.45817112922668457,
0.26511257886886597,
-0.16902565956115723,
-1.0089576244354248,
0.6083824038505554,
-0.13435494899749756,
0.1419110894203186,
0.1465587317943573,
0.8234941959381104,
-0.27349579334259033,
1.2466248273849487,
0.12559597194194794,
-0.06382803618907928,
0.2270960956811905,
0.0767970010638237,
0.06294755637645721,
-1.010169506072998,
-0.34455329179763794,
-0.5082796216011047,
-0.33026444911956787,
-0.5630161762237549,
-0.3167038559913635,
0.4202970266342163,
-0.5391751527786255,
-0.46907496452331543,
-0.367194265127182,
-0.2523949444293976,
0.3315771222114563,
0.40331196784973145,
0.17608632147312164,
0.13877449929714203,
0.00048124411841854453,
0.06561818718910217,
-0.21465308964252472,
-0.44348251819610596,
-0.7848654389381409,
0.9838318824768066,
0.3530537486076355,
0.8806790113449097,
-0.07464603334665298,
0.39400866627693176,
0.3926473557949066,
0.5879302024841309,
-0.6433010101318359,
0.7438934445381165,
0.214022696018219,
-0.6910818219184875,
-0.16041865944862366,
-0.4138767719268799,
-0.8498719930648804,
0.4239397346973419,
-0.3528062403202057,
-0.8092808723449707,
0.4033799171447754,
0.16083766520023346,
-0.20673511922359467,
0.1429160237312317,
-0.6278775930404663,
0.4774429500102997,
-0.18439172208309174,
-0.5662766098976135,
0.04107426851987839,
-0.6099778413772583,
0.5327363610267639,
-0.17959809303283691,
0.38861480355262756,
-0.21081827580928802,
-0.05553947761654854,
0.6348920464515686,
-0.00045233091805130243,
1.3819509744644165,
-0.35323888063430786,
-0.3228435814380646,
0.13327138125896454,
0.14450305700302124,
0.6697288751602173,
0.11080105602741241,
-0.19862589240074158,
-0.021015316247940063,
-0.374707967042923,
-0.33509111404418945,
-0.5846254825592041,
0.8609805703163147,
-0.8972815275192261,
-0.9732243418693542,
-0.3444470465183258,
-0.5449999570846558,
-0.4191785156726837,
-0.012358018197119236,
0.11376994103193283,
0.08572763949632645,
-0.26057949662208557,
0.12010412663221359,
0.7586734294891357,
-0.41653409600257874,
-0.008092166855931282,
0.4285762310028076,
-0.30121710896492004,
0.004045902751386166,
0.41379600763320923,
0.013685821555554867,
0.46645885705947876,
-0.010922188870608807,
0.31480714678764343,
-0.2424621284008026,
-0.18456615507602692,
-0.10775941610336304,
0.3975384533405304,
-0.8238519430160522,
0.2652820348739624,
-0.7589643597602844,
-0.025592871010303497,
-0.3118874728679657,
-0.10832080990076065,
-0.12512758374214172,
0.07314205914735794,
-0.20191235840320587,
-0.268101304769516,
0.13310807943344116,
1.0169343948364258,
0.17162485420703888,
0.17497414350509644,
-0.4642585217952728,
0.2219902127981186,
0.5717733502388,
0.006159427110105753,
0.24263374507427216,
-0.3384320139884949,
0.22572948038578033,
0.3805752992630005,
0.07260580360889435,
-1.0343042612075806,
0.15136030316352844,
-0.0987430289387703,
0.5648398995399475,
0.33135703206062317,
0.021014319732785225,
0.4459685683250427,
-0.5102554559707642,
0.791212260723114,
-0.2020999938249588,
-0.8666298389434814,
0.4920322000980377,
-0.6194215416908264,
0.4184187352657318,
0.39212197065353394,
0.48878878355026245,
-0.5688279271125793,
-0.5427819490432739,
-0.25520849227905273,
-0.6789715886116028,
0.7115283012390137,
0.07578057795763016,
0.4645395874977112,
-0.10985607653856277,
0.4360598921775818,
0.12175721675157547,
0.27330470085144043,
-0.896551251411438,
-0.4367746114730835,
0.024647770449519157,
0.006210160907357931,
-0.11342073231935501,
-0.47318774461746216,
-0.11908384412527084,
-0.22216878831386566,
0.4676920473575592,
-0.22472870349884033,
0.11505681276321411,
0.3008807599544525,
0.0842161700129509,
-0.31956127285957336,
0.431161105632782,
0.6242444515228271,
0.4658273458480835,
-0.1023499071598053,
0.22531092166900635,
0.09041547775268555,
-0.27387887239456177,
0.31389957666397095,
-0.28910893201828003,
-0.49001792073249817,
-0.20343881845474243,
0.24277034401893616,
0.8777372241020203,
0.4409477710723877,
-0.7048919200897217,
0.387279748916626,
-0.001902249176055193,
-0.19562561810016632,
-0.5100408792495728,
0.08361638337373734,
0.4154869019985199,
0.2542409598827362,
0.44983094930648804,
-0.01751614920794964,
-0.01692592352628708,
-0.8713221549987793,
-0.33593225479125977,
0.567920446395874,
-0.16921749711036682,
-0.4578613340854645,
0.5622419714927673,
0.21325980126857758,
-0.24496710300445557,
0.5299440026283264,
-0.0029661834705621004,
-0.5735514163970947,
0.3738999664783478,
0.38473859429359436,
0.8865216374397278,
-0.19233421981334686,
0.3335410952568054,
0.1580672711133957,
0.3344123065471649,
-0.10377737134695053,
0.18027551472187042,
0.24792198836803436,
-0.8406868577003479,
-0.5577690601348877,
-0.5524653196334839,
-0.49177730083465576,
0.3484340012073517,
-0.4359581470489502,
0.04288170859217644,
-0.5663163661956787,
-0.30699512362480164,
0.11946196109056473,
-0.11769292503595352,
-0.7718977928161621,
-0.0013129969593137503,
0.44402822852134705,
0.64290452003479,
-1.0856844186782837,
0.49210575222969055,
0.7427345514297485,
-0.2472366839647293,
-0.6820788979530334,
0.14893029630184174,
0.22384975850582123,
-0.5439226627349854,
0.8975315093994141,
0.01451882440596819,
-0.07398848235607147,
-0.2534753382205963,
-0.8224802017211914,
-0.6966367959976196,
0.6540060043334961,
0.5392521619796753,
-0.43676093220710754,
-0.12541787326335907,
0.36775603890419006,
0.7081711292266846,
-0.5972357392311096,
0.08528517186641693,
0.3809792995452881,
0.8491916656494141,
0.16196021437644958,
-0.714224100112915,
0.286745548248291,
-0.18883004784584045,
0.07806602120399475,
-0.27253687381744385,
-0.6435668468475342,
0.9081668853759766,
-0.3642688989639282,
-0.06933312863111496,
-0.26395538449287415,
0.5146685838699341,
0.5063818693161011,
0.13852839171886444,
0.6433041095733643,
-0.023982208222150803,
0.6790323257446289,
0.10774443298578262,
1.1778348684310913,
0.09403963387012482,
0.04118752479553223,
1.1221390962600708,
-0.8403475880622864,
0.6825175881385803,
0.4463750720024109,
-0.17800351977348328,
0.6353389620780945,
0.5906844139099121,
-0.07682366669178009,
0.13171637058258057,
0.23327817022800446,
-0.33781951665878296,
-0.39361053705215454,
-0.1757788211107254,
-0.0158576387912035,
0.3525371849536896,
0.527001678943634,
-0.3758056163787842,
0.03712715208530426,
-0.11065128445625305,
0.12889912724494934,
-0.020706098526716232,
-0.2877834439277649,
0.6330868601799011,
0.2449405938386917,
-0.8874581456184387,
0.24187129735946655,
-0.16225674748420715,
0.6508194208145142,
-0.5647255182266235,
-0.0024762616958469152,
-0.1710018515586853,
-0.0653122141957283,
-0.3956244885921478,
-0.8491676449775696,
-0.024915087968111038,
0.061919327825307846,
-0.26828303933143616,
-0.2555953562259674,
0.7036888003349304,
-0.1804228127002716,
-0.5050285458564758,
0.22543735802173615,
0.6579039692878723,
0.18045087158679962,
-0.09852150082588196,
-0.5483600497245789,
0.08721131831407547,
0.09671419113874435,
-0.6295202970504761,
0.4691370725631714,
0.2785080373287201,
-0.2158728986978531,
0.7790025472640991,
0.7840090990066528,
0.23033539950847626,
-0.1039988249540329,
0.19268672168254852,
0.7228862047195435,
-0.5179375410079956,
-0.1368102729320526,
-0.9758307337760925,
0.4042051136493683,
-0.13400156795978546,
0.004933629650622606,
0.8227832317352295,
0.3071844279766083,
0.6153807640075684,
-0.1682719886302948,
1.0973103046417236,
0.1521560698747635,
0.4175731837749481,
-0.2154570370912552,
0.6362283229827881,
-0.2831016480922699,
0.355785071849823,
-0.5565745234489441,
-1.079585075378418,
0.03404095023870468,
0.51920086145401,
-0.6043503284454346,
0.460089772939682,
0.40704280138015747,
0.6001972556114197,
0.2440769225358963,
0.0547693632543087,
0.23504400253295898,
0.5744969844818115,
0.45239657163619995,
0.5142110586166382,
0.952028214931488,
0.28465452790260315,
0.05758947506546974,
0.06422094255685806,
-0.2423492670059204,
-0.11352386325597763,
-0.7933287620544434,
-1.1651490926742554,
-0.45414456725120544,
-0.17658841609954834,
-0.27490249276161194,
-0.16083791851997375,
1.150442361831665,
0.6174519062042236,
-0.5754945874214172,
-0.1485002636909485,
0.09580222517251968,
0.12130525708198547,
0.4142369031906128,
-0.32042786478996277,
0.16204144060611725,
-0.017078697681427002,
-1.0032339096069336,
0.13073411583900452,
0.2247876226902008,
0.083338163793087,
-0.9057067036628723,
-0.05394252762198448,
0.01102214865386486,
0.3602409362792969,
0.6445316672325134,
0.24155066907405853,
-1.0124330520629883,
-0.5015972256660461,
-0.04222545772790909,
-0.17814601957798004,
-0.12679679691791534,
0.7998208403587341,
-0.9159835577011108,
0.10016904771327972,
0.32557541131973267,
0.267738401889801,
0.21120469272136688,
-0.15370121598243713,
0.7516647577285767,
-0.6448713541030884,
0.051869094371795654,
0.39460521936416626,
0.4693455696105957,
0.6346815824508667,
-0.4006284177303314,
0.30635392665863037,
0.16500768065452576,
-0.524126410484314,
-0.8113709688186646,
0.3736942708492279,
-0.7650771141052246,
-0.31365764141082764,
1.5626518726348877,
-0.03385309502482414,
-0.2849433124065399,
-0.23661260306835175,
-0.42303311824798584,
-0.28065362572669983,
-0.5827758312225342,
0.8262653946876526,
0.784544825553894,
-0.20006485283374786,
0.009708505123853683,
-0.6875432729721069,
0.4458065629005432,
0.2852477729320526,
-0.8350377082824707,
0.27044299244880676,
0.7307461500167847,
0.4076008200645447,
0.18696025013923645,
0.733380138874054,
0.05007648468017578,
-0.0565296895802021,
-0.1817375123500824,
-0.025941984727978706,
0.16566362977027893,
0.016596760600805283,
-0.21154002845287323,
0.09628446400165558,
0.1731015145778656,
0.5719916224479675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14459v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14459v1 | Healing Powers of BERT: How Task-Specific Fine-Tuning Recovers Corrupted Language Models | 2024-06-20T16:18:04 | 2024-06-20T16:18:04 | Shijie Han, Zhenyu Zhang, Andrei Arsene Simion | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models like BERT excel at sentence classification tasks due to
extensive pre-training on general data, but their robustness to parameter
corruption is unexplored. To understand this better, we look at what happens if
a language model is "broken", in the sense that some of its parameters are
corrupted and then recovered by fine-tuning. Strategically corrupting BERT
variants at different levels, we find corrupted models struggle to fully
recover their original performance, with higher corruption causing more severe
degradation. Notably, bottom-layer corruption affecting fundamental linguistic
features is more detrimental than top-layer corruption. Our insights contribute
to understanding language model robustness and adaptability under adverse
conditions, informing strategies for developing resilient NLP systems against
parameter perturbations. | [
-0.1653996706008911,
-0.9104392528533936,
0.35124891996383667,
0.008333295583724976,
-0.151078462600708,
-0.2011246234178543,
-0.33541837334632874,
-0.6294507384300232,
-0.06318936496973038,
1.0046836137771606,
-0.5034589171409607,
0.10781735926866531,
-0.8531866669654846,
-0.06766301393508911,
-0.4991631805896759,
1.6736979484558105,
0.5845531225204468,
0.208555668592453,
-0.05074159801006317,
-0.05299723520874977,
-0.48689109086990356,
-0.5196467041969299,
-0.8314008712768555,
-0.25352320075035095,
0.4011983871459961,
0.408602774143219,
0.9348836541175842,
0.4750247299671173,
0.6407945156097412,
0.30406898260116577,
0.011815149337053299,
0.02478080429136753,
-0.7904289960861206,
0.5298388600349426,
-0.16397985816001892,
-0.5847104787826538,
-0.32699117064476013,
-0.010223347693681717,
0.5123223662376404,
0.8166404366493225,
-0.18774166703224182,
-0.20240703225135803,
0.3007151186466217,
0.6748120188713074,
-0.35908254981040955,
0.029660269618034363,
-1.3406665325164795,
-0.3013952672481537,
-0.1252041459083557,
-0.1898554563522339,
-0.3876233696937561,
-0.1442078948020935,
0.2664199471473694,
-0.37096214294433594,
0.41652679443359375,
-0.11702127754688263,
1.0877370834350586,
0.6065216064453125,
-0.044371820986270905,
-0.15976925194263458,
-0.887468159198761,
0.9569414854049683,
-0.8389420509338379,
0.11419620364904404,
0.6723803281784058,
0.0928824245929718,
-0.43270424008369446,
-0.8046589493751526,
-0.18820135295391083,
-0.23750756680965424,
0.14050471782684326,
-0.16908232867717743,
-0.27377381920814514,
0.3388819396495819,
0.32314708828926086,
0.3808484673500061,
-0.3337012827396393,
0.11799786239862442,
-0.3460014760494232,
-0.15608623623847961,
0.3887970745563507,
0.029634768143296242,
0.5793441534042358,
-0.22728312015533447,
-0.10568775981664658,
-0.14211709797382355,
-0.7023523449897766,
0.010645141825079918,
0.5562405586242676,
0.8024907112121582,
0.5206020474433899,
0.06446248292922974,
0.27851173281669617,
0.8497529029846191,
-0.12079813331365585,
-0.08620008826255798,
-0.1942172348499298,
-0.3124520778656006,
-0.4504546523094177,
0.05233157053589821,
0.39222097396850586,
0.06131492555141449,
0.4575325548648834,
-0.40583622455596924,
-0.23140108585357666,
-0.392479807138443,
0.7593457102775574,
-0.5954182147979736,
-0.48314568400382996,
0.06656943261623383,
-0.5570309162139893,
-0.33862847089767456,
-0.05321815609931946,
-0.3029792308807373,
-0.5824114680290222,
-0.06774114817380905,
0.5600176453590393,
-0.6118183732032776,
-0.27511855959892273,
0.2746341824531555,
-0.1826426386833191,
-0.1920054703950882,
0.1745292842388153,
-1.3318676948547363,
0.2610948085784912,
0.7177004218101501,
0.4079623520374298,
0.30570101737976074,
-0.4336473047733307,
-0.5036295056343079,
-0.19367532432079315,
-0.0184310469776392,
0.7083293199539185,
-0.5708329677581787,
-0.052263349294662476,
0.1671803593635559,
0.2649652063846588,
-0.0373121052980423,
-0.714248776435852,
0.8687261939048767,
-0.36937063932418823,
-0.08631735295057297,
-0.7235156893730164,
-0.5225399732589722,
-0.009048528037965298,
0.12718462944030762,
-0.6231189966201782,
0.8103071451187134,
0.03493158519268036,
-0.8487410545349121,
0.5126781463623047,
-0.32588398456573486,
-0.3931827247142792,
-0.08956319093704224,
0.25621411204338074,
-0.5769428610801697,
0.4649730920791626,
0.05025921016931534,
0.6337141990661621,
-0.08446875959634781,
0.1313559114933014,
-0.5194789171218872,
-0.17094428837299347,
-0.049317844212055206,
-0.5535068511962891,
1.0251134634017944,
0.015010961331427097,
0.07722848653793335,
0.13373881578445435,
-0.9093126058578491,
0.04438459128141403,
0.07960586249828339,
-0.32026639580726624,
-0.7147925496101379,
0.43982750177383423,
0.08607467263936996,
0.1517951786518097,
0.20263196527957916,
-0.6059963703155518,
0.45121100544929504,
-0.4707242250442505,
0.7793002128601074,
0.7326317429542542,
-0.04315347224473953,
0.21224549412727356,
-0.4879247844219208,
0.17022085189819336,
-0.10867564380168915,
0.1635952740907669,
-0.05439513176679611,
-0.4854508340358734,
-0.706464946269989,
-0.14036749303340912,
0.4036048352718353,
0.5127856731414795,
-0.4977678060531616,
0.40406399965286255,
-0.10653062909841537,
-0.7111514210700989,
-0.8512660264968872,
0.18505065143108368,
0.358210027217865,
0.7684853672981262,
0.4186967611312866,
-0.3283381164073944,
-0.507339596748352,
-1.1588274240493774,
-0.4265068471431732,
-0.32670921087265015,
-0.08705360442399979,
0.22335389256477356,
0.4428451657295227,
-0.2552167475223541,
0.5588038563728333,
-0.02932671085000038,
-0.41702157258987427,
-0.24416975677013397,
0.2430553436279297,
0.019795695319771767,
0.6151343584060669,
0.6799992322921753,
-0.4156236946582794,
-0.025583351030945778,
-0.2495676428079605,
-0.3453920781612396,
-0.22700221836566925,
-0.3582057058811188,
0.018814055249094963,
0.2641792893409729,
0.4553157687187195,
-0.21131053566932678,
0.26112544536590576,
0.6647528409957886,
-0.5127533674240112,
0.8485199213027954,
-0.607986330986023,
-0.03440018743276596,
-0.7741587162017822,
0.03722109645605087,
-0.4791012406349182,
-0.29060089588165283,
-0.768028736114502,
0.016567198559641838,
-0.15950632095336914,
0.09656312316656113,
0.028985923156142235,
-0.04105067998170853,
-0.18878160417079926,
-0.07004360854625702,
-0.44525644183158875,
-0.04844321683049202,
-0.21223542094230652,
0.23894189298152924,
-0.2077028453350067,
0.516499400138855,
0.6666945815086365,
-0.49274179339408875,
0.10648413002490997,
0.28884822130203247,
-0.42474454641342163,
0.2988763749599457,
-0.8113300800323486,
0.10423218458890915,
0.12632127106189728,
-0.12476687878370285,
-0.8959835171699524,
-0.3279985189437866,
-0.37199562788009644,
-0.3236849904060364,
0.5410473346710205,
-0.10015624761581421,
-0.7662379741668701,
0.13315755128860474,
-0.1606096774339676,
0.054831426590681076,
0.4834798574447632,
-0.4641610085964203,
0.31487223505973816,
0.43056684732437134,
-0.2663207948207855,
-0.6374424695968628,
-0.7154706120491028,
0.04907149076461792,
0.08596368134021759,
-0.7462713122367859,
0.3036970794200897,
-0.01732465997338295,
-0.30213749408721924,
0.03654076159000397,
-0.1077176034450531,
-0.24116142094135284,
0.5552815198898315,
0.24461404979228973,
-0.20666450262069702,
-0.12182911485433578,
0.3313753604888916,
0.29341036081314087,
0.09244628250598907,
0.05593277886509895,
-0.07852527499198914,
0.5943998694419861,
-0.2786361873149872,
-0.24118420481681824,
-0.14145731925964355,
0.26090648770332336,
0.8077598810195923,
-0.16785678267478943,
1.0149341821670532,
0.43943244218826294,
-0.5026804208755493,
-0.2538776993751526,
-0.5438545942306519,
-0.4227592945098877,
-0.4512346088886261,
0.5278571248054504,
-0.02149239368736744,
-0.6961687207221985,
0.6914801597595215,
0.31553155183792114,
0.3066425323486328,
0.32848772406578064,
0.5106750130653381,
-0.17123115062713623,
0.9128609299659729,
1.075108289718628,
-0.3269576132297516,
0.6774206757545471,
0.05999976769089699,
0.2320839762687683,
-0.4582187533378601,
0.06807421147823334,
-0.6258347034454346,
-0.3203432559967041,
-0.5700012445449829,
0.20704486966133118,
0.2822525203227997,
0.44355159997940063,
-0.19736795127391815,
0.3394860625267029,
-0.5074025988578796,
0.4088461399078369,
0.8728063106536865,
0.1998535394668579,
0.20928676426410675,
-0.05935385823249817,
0.05677281692624092,
-0.15078343451023102,
-0.6903361678123474,
-0.6131265163421631,
0.839325487613678,
0.35024774074554443,
0.5819627046585083,
-0.1900537759065628,
0.7395536303520203,
0.04398375749588013,
0.10726843774318695,
-0.5595881938934326,
0.2881104052066803,
-0.38628047704696655,
-0.9125776290893555,
-0.5724276900291443,
-0.04728643596172333,
-1.1319749355316162,
0.03295816108584404,
-0.3777346909046173,
-0.8257210850715637,
0.12384368479251862,
0.3197833001613617,
-0.3639131188392639,
0.5811487436294556,
-0.7396529316902161,
0.807657778263092,
-0.18343836069107056,
-0.14363381266593933,
-0.2565643787384033,
-0.8423002362251282,
0.23290660977363586,
-0.16268476843833923,
-0.04963025078177452,
-0.05946708098053932,
0.311223566532135,
0.7250537276268005,
-0.4959091544151306,
0.7794317007064819,
-0.2086154967546463,
-0.2604791522026062,
-0.20719939470291138,
0.24394750595092773,
0.2406640648841858,
-0.032989565283060074,
-0.12031353265047073,
0.1245655044913292,
0.2209782600402832,
-0.704691469669342,
-0.6906551122665405,
0.6481704711914062,
-0.7272154688835144,
-0.7140676379203796,
-0.19697310030460358,
-0.9811310768127441,
-0.5962589383125305,
0.29040810465812683,
0.24130447208881378,
0.27872714400291443,
0.012774123810231686,
0.4632492959499359,
0.6889788508415222,
-0.22466915845870972,
0.6778913736343384,
0.6457734704017639,
0.16847923398017883,
-0.15811598300933838,
0.9080132246017456,
0.18816415965557098,
0.5190424919128418,
0.013507516123354435,
-0.12855713069438934,
0.3628075122833252,
-0.8402165770530701,
0.018936263397336006,
0.1137748509645462,
-0.37566742300987244,
-0.260868102312088,
-0.21496471762657166,
-0.2007053643465042,
-0.2891218662261963,
-0.14604820311069489,
-0.4725666642189026,
-0.4727194309234619,
-0.4510352313518524,
-0.11103037744760513,
0.23910154402256012,
0.8647300004959106,
-0.27885702252388,
0.052394453436136246,
-0.9617392420768738,
0.04461352154612541,
0.29916125535964966,
0.5242335796356201,
-0.15207383036613464,
-0.5732151865959167,
-0.23562116920948029,
0.12133531272411346,
-0.3431546986103058,
-0.6946330070495605,
0.42859989404678345,
0.5072352290153503,
0.3589121997356415,
0.6472159028053284,
-0.03079039603471756,
0.6466570496559143,
-0.8071759343147278,
0.9211541414260864,
-0.04906849563121796,
-0.8684231042861938,
0.6243360638618469,
-0.5444405674934387,
0.12525537610054016,
0.5582826137542725,
0.04477135092020035,
-0.4293338656425476,
-0.8952099084854126,
-0.7998192310333252,
-0.9489668607711792,
0.7343589067459106,
0.16889804601669312,
0.37863555550575256,
0.011974204331636429,
0.6468225121498108,
0.3394014835357666,
-0.031471218913793564,
-0.6561387777328491,
-0.16412605345249176,
-0.367435097694397,
-0.06240042671561241,
-0.05008431524038315,
-0.5896730422973633,
-0.10726003348827362,
-0.34722477197647095,
0.667644202709198,
0.1056198999285698,
0.39769041538238525,
0.16395694017410278,
-0.16820573806762695,
-0.21845999360084534,
0.2296091616153717,
0.7198447585105896,
0.4889404773712158,
-0.24922023713588715,
-0.0698297917842865,
-0.017065243795514107,
-0.5562084317207336,
-0.3232528865337372,
0.24758608639240265,
-0.01616799831390381,
-0.2314266860485077,
0.9065993428230286,
0.7720906138420105,
0.4114365875720978,
-0.7353829145431519,
0.20186330378055573,
-0.09124159812927246,
-0.043448932468891144,
0.010723122395575047,
0.40857332944869995,
-0.10330826044082642,
0.21223361790180206,
0.525702953338623,
0.3433329164981842,
0.03817715495824814,
-0.837046205997467,
0.33095282316207886,
0.7285478115081787,
-0.437054842710495,
-0.4529065787792206,
0.6127932667732239,
0.03995770215988159,
-0.45237892866134644,
0.8493180274963379,
0.24662266671657562,
-0.5565266013145447,
0.49685555696487427,
0.677588939666748,
0.7622035145759583,
-0.4135807752609253,
0.0854586511850357,
0.04751451313495636,
0.6153433918952942,
-0.1374732106924057,
0.3238823115825653,
0.09827353805303574,
-0.9583944082260132,
-0.22835704684257507,
-0.7037253379821777,
-0.14660775661468506,
0.43936634063720703,
-1.0489990711212158,
-0.16329434514045715,
-0.430643230676651,
-0.1059470921754837,
-0.002939041005447507,
-0.003025231184437871,
-0.28891465067863464,
0.25969040393829346,
-0.046592049300670624,
0.9175574779510498,
-0.8942702412605286,
1.0416871309280396,
0.5844326019287109,
-0.5267141461372375,
-0.6457622647285461,
0.23356114327907562,
-0.4652055501937866,
-0.8852468132972717,
0.5677525401115417,
-0.15984852612018585,
0.12916593253612518,
-0.1320374310016632,
-0.7934015393257141,
-0.7056525945663452,
0.6663801670074463,
0.9663110971450806,
-0.4795389473438263,
-0.14710040390491486,
0.025221940129995346,
0.8987491130828857,
0.14305947721004486,
-0.04173931106925011,
0.8355441689491272,
0.3430306017398834,
-0.566242516040802,
-1.4869170188903809,
-0.019096706062555313,
-0.11924279481172562,
-0.13263960182666779,
0.3529493510723114,
-0.28402024507522583,
0.6432062387466431,
-0.3020741641521454,
0.18814171850681305,
0.33480823040008545,
0.3247866928577423,
-0.1935501992702484,
-0.25367841124534607,
0.5326690673828125,
0.7501625418663025,
0.9496787786483765,
-0.3752400577068329,
1.1171735525131226,
-0.4383510947227478,
0.3876487612724304,
0.7585915923118591,
0.14742766320705414,
1.0420472621917725,
0.42215442657470703,
0.039165593683719635,
0.5121484398841858,
0.37145760655403137,
-0.08916843682527542,
0.6830863952636719,
0.03634468838572502,
0.08130981028079987,
-0.4760715365409851,
0.06611847132444382,
-0.16243523359298706,
0.5546844005584717,
0.40110403299331665,
-0.5864294767379761,
-0.24769601225852966,
0.3044971227645874,
0.0744185596704483,
-0.04455290734767914,
-0.4834684133529663,
0.7437901496887207,
-0.09805401414632797,
-0.641511082649231,
0.737022340297699,
-0.2741009593009949,
0.34737950563430786,
-0.5963221192359924,
-0.02559048682451248,
0.020795147866010666,
0.40299880504608154,
-0.27428197860717773,
-0.6325395703315735,
0.6038137078285217,
-0.31614023447036743,
-0.5084598064422607,
-0.5090616345405579,
1.036156177520752,
-0.3736790418624878,
-0.19418925046920776,
0.2978697717189789,
0.22886773943901062,
0.10210531949996948,
-0.020356133580207825,
-0.8148175477981567,
0.15649016201496124,
-0.014870977029204369,
-0.13699719309806824,
0.5241870284080505,
0.2957616150379181,
0.3141481876373291,
0.8776454925537109,
0.2811585068702698,
0.30145472288131714,
0.08294646441936493,
0.038035426288843155,
0.7380487322807312,
-0.37727323174476624,
-0.01934867724776268,
-0.7526635527610779,
0.556290864944458,
0.04890485480427742,
-0.4398845434188843,
0.7252252697944641,
0.08124615997076035,
0.7788344621658325,
-0.10783964395523071,
0.6079840660095215,
0.0941270962357521,
0.5587320327758789,
-0.4711487293243408,
1.2329334020614624,
-0.6490767002105713,
0.21448750793933868,
-0.3919392228126526,
-0.5059214234352112,
-0.5295108556747437,
0.5408264398574829,
-0.2762252390384674,
0.012975897639989853,
0.6344752907752991,
0.5732046365737915,
0.11757051944732666,
0.013492090627551079,
0.4275001883506775,
0.7462263703346252,
0.3121728301048279,
0.31938785314559937,
0.36247557401657104,
-0.24553963541984558,
0.6020327210426331,
-0.18875595927238464,
-0.12155512720346451,
-0.11837591230869293,
-0.7908681631088257,
-0.786987841129303,
-0.8748661875724792,
-0.18776920437812805,
-0.3774358928203583,
0.20659571886062622,
0.6097237467765808,
0.6992404460906982,
-1.0962903499603271,
0.0756470337510109,
-0.45666754245758057,
0.11543754488229752,
-0.41039738059043884,
-0.22041742503643036,
0.2662688195705414,
-0.8568445444107056,
-0.6194138526916504,
0.3385133743286133,
0.2343222051858902,
-0.301203191280365,
-0.28930914402008057,
0.3627859652042389,
0.046760864555835724,
0.22713550925254822,
0.4510783553123474,
0.38233324885368347,
-0.8901278376579285,
-0.569110095500946,
-0.20037983357906342,
0.09259241074323654,
-0.23181495070457458,
0.8608941435813904,
-0.6564446091651917,
0.5242252349853516,
0.3448450565338135,
0.7827914357185364,
-0.15773656964302063,
-0.27675434947013855,
0.8446434736251831,
-0.965287983417511,
-0.017217177897691727,
0.5162588953971863,
0.7132148742675781,
0.22462405264377594,
-0.2951226830482483,
0.1296619474887848,
0.10116390883922577,
-1.0465623140335083,
-1.3478832244873047,
0.34107014536857605,
-0.87511146068573,
-0.44297850131988525,
1.0251579284667969,
-0.2945057451725006,
0.22041994333267212,
-0.20081569254398346,
-0.3664422631263733,
0.07129240781068802,
-0.05053819343447685,
1.254943609237671,
1.0739892721176147,
-0.23818238079547882,
-0.09775842726230621,
-0.4203406274318695,
0.8787748217582703,
0.6581230163574219,
-0.49161598086357117,
0.24334318935871124,
0.30152222514152527,
0.4768997132778168,
0.21853308379650116,
0.1401296854019165,
0.03692269325256348,
0.15719369053840637,
-0.18572388589382172,
-0.301077663898468,
-0.09215157479047775,
-0.36542192101478577,
-0.4032480716705322,
0.21241454780101776,
0.32310280203819275,
0.08649611473083496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14434v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14434v1 | Towards Truthful Multilingual Large Language Models: Benchmarking and Alignment Strategies | 2024-06-20T15:59:07 | 2024-06-20T15:59:07 | Weihao Liu, Ning Wu, Wenbiao Ding, Shining Liang, Ming Gong, Dongmei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the era of large language models (LLMs), building multilingual large
language models (MLLMs) that can serve users worldwide holds great
significance. However, existing research seldom focuses on the truthfulness of
MLLMs. Meanwhile, contemporary multilingual aligning technologies struggle to
balance massive languages and often exhibit serious truthfulness gaps across
different languages, especially those that differ greatly from English. In our
work, we construct a benchmark for truthfulness evaluation in multilingual
scenarios and explore the ways to align facts across languages to enhance the
truthfulness of MLLMs. Furthermore, we propose Fact-aware Multilingual
Selective Synergy (FaMSS) to optimize the data allocation across a large number
of languages and different data types. Experimental results demonstrate that
our approach can effectively reduce the multilingual representation disparity
and enhance the multilingual capabilities of LLMs. | [
-0.24260498583316803,
-0.3608980178833008,
0.5331296920776367,
0.2637244760990143,
-0.0943005308508873,
0.3837549388408661,
-0.5474820137023926,
-0.5010555982589722,
-0.03942542150616646,
0.20879749953746796,
-0.4732412099838257,
-0.3508879542350769,
-0.3987354338169098,
0.15545274317264557,
-0.013436158187687397,
0.8488896489143372,
-0.09677804261445999,
0.4009897708892822,
-0.3878471553325653,
-0.883011519908905,
-0.35999688506126404,
-0.666905403137207,
-0.18436403572559357,
-0.34752973914146423,
0.5514975190162659,
0.314933180809021,
0.9686264991760254,
0.6194988489151001,
0.5918271541595459,
0.2900087833404541,
0.0879702940583229,
0.43306630849838257,
-0.405153751373291,
0.34858235716819763,
-0.44976863265037537,
-0.4382833242416382,
-0.36485087871551514,
-0.02769053354859352,
0.810748279094696,
0.735634446144104,
-0.2789250910282135,
0.2847802937030792,
-0.01173462811857462,
0.5856000781059265,
-0.7819668650627136,
0.10755404829978943,
-0.6093003153800964,
0.053606800734996796,
-0.37697893381118774,
0.1822032630443573,
-0.2998790144920349,
-0.4036768078804016,
-0.08941581100225449,
-0.5849441885948181,
-0.03456353023648262,
0.20562849938869476,
0.6517443060874939,
0.17134630680084229,
-0.6242954730987549,
-0.07672291249036789,
-0.5610403418540955,
1.0903420448303223,
-0.8151755928993225,
1.1086915731430054,
0.0026715139392763376,
0.519624650478363,
0.1340426504611969,
-0.3091124892234802,
-0.7193732857704163,
-0.07424891740083694,
-0.02923089638352394,
0.07264664769172668,
0.07536938786506653,
-0.4328709840774536,
0.32550233602523804,
0.2520240247249603,
-0.7607423663139343,
0.2406940907239914,
0.1247730553150177,
-0.5123290419578552,
0.7399997115135193,
0.12663906812667847,
-0.0043374174274504185,
0.32051265239715576,
-0.503303050994873,
0.09835492819547653,
-0.7022731900215149,
-0.28925788402557373,
0.5756680965423584,
0.5591806173324585,
-0.3002927303314209,
0.5568229556083679,
-0.1578657478094101,
0.7173222899436951,
-0.22861355543136597,
-0.7763782143592834,
0.5561617016792297,
-0.7893801927566528,
0.11019082367420197,
0.05364169925451279,
0.6636179685592651,
0.5563364624977112,
0.1371750384569168,
-0.21138660609722137,
-0.2621813714504242,
0.2111821472644806,
-0.1054801493883133,
-0.7556536197662354,
0.2905834913253784,
0.10655766725540161,
-0.4152047038078308,
0.006685445550829172,
-0.28718653321266174,
-0.7401037216186523,
-0.6005697846412659,
-0.5002269148826599,
0.3096391260623932,
-0.24162839353084564,
-0.5805556774139404,
0.1711767464876175,
0.15507110953330994,
0.17440493404865265,
0.2266247570514679,
-0.6756866574287415,
0.1775127798318863,
0.6558722257614136,
0.6280185580253601,
-0.12597709894180298,
-0.3856299817562103,
-0.39677295088768005,
0.3074171543121338,
-0.25831058621406555,
0.38600990176200867,
-0.4566301107406616,
-0.07341333478689194,
0.04745384305715561,
-0.22005033493041992,
-0.0346720889210701,
-0.5182980298995972,
0.7514036297798157,
-0.5441797971725464,
0.272978276014328,
-0.571082592010498,
-0.5767267346382141,
-0.21875014901161194,
0.5938948392868042,
-0.7610131502151489,
0.8606953620910645,
-0.34496378898620605,
-0.6733492612838745,
0.23699907958507538,
-0.33778828382492065,
-0.5152602195739746,
-0.27437859773635864,
-0.19532084465026855,
-0.38473179936408997,
0.008716014213860035,
0.05748981237411499,
0.33302968740463257,
-0.2995377779006958,
0.6515014171600342,
-0.3665544092655182,
0.004051832482218742,
0.426387757062912,
-0.7866474986076355,
0.6625342965126038,
0.5173599123954773,
-0.1719183474779129,
0.006005673669278622,
-0.6412796378135681,
-0.036362938582897186,
0.12857480347156525,
-0.26555678248405457,
-0.1761518120765686,
-0.05706658214330673,
0.15208058059215546,
0.4737434685230255,
0.521589457988739,
-0.6333200931549072,
0.08747074007987976,
-0.16219615936279297,
0.028570372611284256,
0.5958524942398071,
-0.5435662865638733,
0.08787532895803452,
-0.5486138463020325,
0.19870992004871368,
0.16294041275978088,
0.3072417974472046,
0.028750382363796234,
-0.20944999158382416,
-0.6228523254394531,
-0.29379361867904663,
0.4923495054244995,
0.5204579830169678,
-0.7555322051048279,
0.3857623338699341,
-0.49402034282684326,
-0.351499080657959,
-0.8884186148643494,
0.4375970661640167,
0.5228896737098694,
0.5037395358085632,
0.2537873685359955,
-0.20421533286571503,
-0.5337229371070862,
-1.2203118801116943,
-0.40488043427467346,
-0.06421727687120438,
0.5480838418006897,
-0.10459598153829575,
0.27685683965682983,
-0.06416258960962296,
0.6801786422729492,
-0.1591995507478714,
0.040161702781915665,
-0.1527414321899414,
-0.24093939363956451,
0.19393838942050934,
0.3292427361011505,
0.6019533276557922,
-1.1583729982376099,
-0.5476487278938293,
0.18049567937850952,
-0.7738455533981323,
0.00804382935166359,
0.14221277832984924,
0.04990135505795479,
0.5060361623764038,
0.27518758177757263,
-0.593256413936615,
-0.018767207860946655,
0.9401219487190247,
-0.10133308917284012,
0.610772967338562,
-0.04691309481859207,
0.3326754570007324,
-1.0331286191940308,
0.30427059531211853,
0.012640412896871567,
-0.3615497946739197,
-0.5802084803581238,
0.1761874258518219,
0.17994938790798187,
0.1290043741464615,
-0.4906723201274872,
0.6971474885940552,
-0.6498196125030518,
-0.19743980467319489,
-0.09557514637708664,
0.2883913218975067,
0.1441289633512497,
0.2699612081050873,
-0.01870216615498066,
0.781121551990509,
0.5759434700012207,
-0.3817465901374817,
0.5446886420249939,
0.20218735933303833,
-0.4233785569667816,
0.7240620851516724,
-0.2189781218767166,
-0.11666180193424225,
-0.11895415186882019,
0.18034277856349945,
-0.77780681848526,
0.0644926130771637,
-0.06633003801107407,
-0.24712017178535461,
0.40795716643333435,
0.015263146720826626,
-0.7742972373962402,
-0.14285127818584442,
-0.19024978578090668,
0.6032090187072754,
0.2683952748775482,
-0.7215800881385803,
0.6291554570198059,
0.4965435862541199,
-0.1911885142326355,
-0.9128463268280029,
-0.6520839929580688,
0.21894553303718567,
-0.27087339758872986,
-0.7101499438285828,
0.17987731099128723,
-0.4171788990497589,
-0.5641523003578186,
-0.1573234349489212,
-0.27520063519477844,
0.2029305249452591,
0.16155977547168732,
-0.10964099317789078,
0.36346328258514404,
-0.37435126304626465,
0.2063477784395218,
-0.33648571372032166,
-0.1431068480014801,
-0.3015664219856262,
-0.2987186014652252,
0.4773945212364197,
-0.37750476598739624,
-0.7246360778808594,
-0.2229759395122528,
0.3923146724700928,
0.6829203963279724,
-0.5756015181541443,
0.9244967103004456,
0.7406652569770813,
-0.31951671838760376,
0.1553296595811844,
-1.111350178718567,
0.05610016733407974,
-0.4312148988246918,
0.18550819158554077,
-0.5036305785179138,
-1.0471503734588623,
0.5525944828987122,
-0.1495911329984665,
0.36515486240386963,
0.2385053038597107,
0.6517899632453918,
0.22873984277248383,
1.0355112552642822,
0.5127178430557251,
-0.3333446681499481,
0.0720723494887352,
0.24969612061977386,
0.35769400000572205,
-0.46118485927581787,
-0.13430848717689514,
-0.566831648349762,
-0.2399747222661972,
-0.6459271907806396,
-0.5069271326065063,
0.3693821132183075,
-0.07619839161634445,
-0.1385664939880371,
-0.06066285818815231,
-0.04843955859541893,
0.4294164776802063,
0.30462226271629333,
-0.1437641829252243,
0.5189536213874817,
0.04993043839931488,
-0.34723952412605286,
-0.3046277165412903,
-0.7572279572486877,
-0.45091304183006287,
0.9967921376228333,
0.23399874567985535,
0.6138007044792175,
0.5467649102210999,
0.2889084219932556,
-0.13291294872760773,
0.28258419036865234,
-0.6480244398117065,
0.4452277719974518,
-0.2661917507648468,
-0.7564195990562439,
-0.15258833765983582,
-0.5155255794525146,
-0.6222819685935974,
0.5544280409812927,
-0.4402487874031067,
-0.48275429010391235,
-0.10523148626089096,
-0.036544814705848694,
-0.1700775921344757,
0.4309217929840088,
-0.5822463631629944,
0.8808993697166443,
-0.662788987159729,
-0.7214853763580322,
-0.32712897658348083,
-0.8189122080802917,
0.31136393547058105,
-0.30330097675323486,
0.6404231190681458,
-0.27570435404777527,
-0.22432617843151093,
0.5115051865577698,
-0.18355725705623627,
0.6372033357620239,
-0.008552580140531063,
-0.3993813693523407,
-0.07861997932195663,
-0.0173202957957983,
0.46022799611091614,
-0.2673519253730774,
-0.43192246556282043,
0.33671531081199646,
-0.19707255065441132,
-0.4880029857158661,
-0.5062547326087952,
0.9004772901535034,
-0.6061753630638123,
-0.7432209253311157,
-0.3332778811454773,
-0.8404641151428223,
-0.6870099902153015,
0.3860987424850464,
-0.12688960134983063,
0.34521183371543884,
-0.3756157159805298,
0.12160506844520569,
0.8116291165351868,
-0.0016733550000935793,
0.5396721959114075,
1.0875500440597534,
-0.3588576316833496,
-0.40157389640808105,
0.9992492198944092,
0.1938607543706894,
0.34448039531707764,
0.4747749865055084,
0.07600876688957214,
-0.64280766248703,
-0.4882468581199646,
-0.4460761249065399,
0.41698819398880005,
-0.6837406158447266,
-0.19454823434352875,
-0.5319663286209106,
0.05855647101998329,
-0.5471431016921997,
0.07895559072494507,
-0.5507785677909851,
-0.42474016547203064,
0.44261056184768677,
-0.06396884471178055,
0.14608223736286163,
0.35047775506973267,
-0.22941561043262482,
-0.07480518519878387,
-0.9476707577705383,
0.24864321947097778,
0.14304836094379425,
0.5756367444992065,
-0.027624694630503654,
-0.2832009494304657,
-0.4362795352935791,
0.16076529026031494,
-0.26827964186668396,
-0.4176507592201233,
0.00009167134703602642,
0.06660769134759903,
0.9565304517745972,
0.2418384850025177,
0.023611044511198997,
0.6833105683326721,
-0.5084369778633118,
0.5615637302398682,
0.5034440159797668,
-1.0109930038452148,
0.175007626414299,
-0.21820348501205444,
0.2818375825881958,
0.7151952981948853,
0.47037288546562195,
-0.9087588787078857,
-0.16958726942539215,
-0.36767837405204773,
-0.5454747080802917,
0.4456180930137634,
0.08636246621608734,
-0.09360738843679428,
0.3536309003829956,
-0.1278112381696701,
0.4840467572212219,
0.4314885437488556,
-0.7625135779380798,
-0.3320561945438385,
-0.07728028297424316,
-0.49790507555007935,
-0.3676258325576782,
-0.015310470014810562,
-0.5000882148742676,
-0.05113702639937401,
0.8130022287368774,
-0.2809377908706665,
-0.33219242095947266,
-0.08228477835655212,
-0.15362966060638428,
-0.2411016821861267,
0.4752759337425232,
0.6345774531364441,
0.8054056763648987,
0.15385960042476654,
0.32729023694992065,
0.24187873303890228,
-0.2004377394914627,
0.38231128454208374,
0.27120670676231384,
0.018229767680168152,
0.003208150854334235,
0.3766592741012573,
0.7216079235076904,
0.12410218268632889,
-0.7777479887008667,
0.5928969383239746,
-0.03092619962990284,
0.03303088620305061,
0.07319973409175873,
-0.13102345168590546,
0.3499845862388611,
0.3021274209022522,
0.10079723596572876,
0.09908127039670944,
-0.13761773705482483,
-0.5118986964225769,
0.1033378317952156,
0.661237895488739,
-0.0803716778755188,
-0.2369648963212967,
0.493490606546402,
0.2871095538139343,
0.18609654903411865,
0.35317254066467285,
-0.002285826252773404,
-0.6482935547828674,
0.1953689455986023,
0.5329920649528503,
0.4514997899532318,
-0.5973085761070251,
-0.005222099833190441,
0.2206595242023468,
0.3556228578090668,
-0.31080546975135803,
0.2640153765678406,
0.16271281242370605,
-1.0912715196609497,
-0.5552010536193848,
-0.5151818990707397,
-0.3812565505504608,
0.04523124545812607,
-0.5250191688537598,
0.19534175097942352,
-0.12455856800079346,
-0.16783401370048523,
0.08741407841444016,
0.3206747770309448,
-0.6257837414741516,
0.09051956236362457,
0.41857829689979553,
0.9497738480567932,
-0.9522374868392944,
0.8592778444290161,
0.6893685460090637,
-0.06137457117438316,
-0.7098677158355713,
-0.14361238479614258,
0.41641148924827576,
-0.941297709941864,
0.4163176119327545,
0.219744473695755,
-0.18126489222049713,
-0.40410616993904114,
-0.42793500423431396,
-0.8740265369415283,
0.9288621544837952,
0.7650274038314819,
-0.9143898487091064,
0.3968854546546936,
0.3836267292499542,
0.49401941895484924,
-0.30072739720344543,
-0.012665691785514355,
0.3144772946834564,
0.8865852355957031,
0.1791592687368393,
-1.1672031879425049,
0.1393374502658844,
-0.20666588842868805,
-0.22815752029418945,
0.31767764687538147,
-1.1036076545715332,
0.6747810244560242,
-0.17760631442070007,
-0.23561514914035797,
0.06211277097463608,
0.6325957775115967,
0.3728947937488556,
0.4154193103313446,
0.519437849521637,
0.7595095038414001,
1.0000529289245605,
-0.013556692749261856,
0.8818519711494446,
-0.42563125491142273,
0.22291487455368042,
1.0709078311920166,
-1.001113772392273,
0.5651682615280151,
0.460235595703125,
-0.08148260414600372,
0.1823650598526001,
0.3871054947376251,
-0.055090490728616714,
0.4082103669643402,
0.04374084249138832,
-0.3748731017112732,
-0.48208630084991455,
-0.5840432643890381,
-0.5247855186462402,
0.3484058678150177,
0.2609800398349762,
0.131179541349411,
-0.37299656867980957,
-0.09124842286109924,
0.26485398411750793,
0.29394257068634033,
-0.17773036658763885,
0.5683454275131226,
-0.05186280235648155,
-0.6778574585914612,
0.5355123281478882,
0.013644254766404629,
0.7440977096557617,
-0.7072590589523315,
0.1274562031030655,
-0.21740716695785522,
0.20300385355949402,
-0.3257426619529724,
-0.8828816413879395,
0.17262212932109833,
-0.01530694030225277,
-0.28716740012168884,
-0.29335498809814453,
0.5544149875640869,
-0.8671388626098633,
-0.43581724166870117,
0.37458208203315735,
0.8083754181861877,
-0.12017356604337692,
0.3082278072834015,
-0.7881835103034973,
0.4898631274700165,
-0.00727245956659317,
0.1238568127155304,
0.3618759214878082,
0.49656176567077637,
-0.025276372209191322,
0.8324177265167236,
0.6388602256774902,
0.10578586161136627,
-0.18340229988098145,
0.28128504753112793,
0.6541855335235596,
-0.4782114028930664,
-0.3817574083805084,
-0.9319810271263123,
0.35672619938850403,
-0.13469749689102173,
-0.16046959161758423,
1.193570613861084,
1.0048249959945679,
0.8988567590713501,
0.16587255895137787,
0.8254457712173462,
0.2098606377840042,
0.5687870979309082,
-0.6181507706642151,
0.4983484148979187,
-0.7071890830993652,
0.22108952701091766,
-0.05506449192762375,
-0.9687722325325012,
-0.2661362886428833,
0.16970598697662354,
-0.12000426650047302,
-0.060482803732156754,
0.5193719267845154,
0.8360188007354736,
-0.11933150142431259,
0.2173839807510376,
0.4693693518638611,
0.27929580211639404,
0.08794181048870087,
0.38251060247421265,
0.9569576978683472,
-0.27829432487487793,
0.3255326747894287,
-0.071767158806324,
-0.03567809984087944,
-0.1094011440873146,
-1.0097967386245728,
-0.5902503728866577,
-0.49448007345199585,
-0.34507450461387634,
-0.2735324203968048,
0.04819408431649208,
0.8915749788284302,
0.707618236541748,
-0.8558906316757202,
-0.43587881326675415,
0.4756466746330261,
0.3614320755004883,
-0.26834186911582947,
-0.14749640226364136,
0.07285115867853165,
-0.23165088891983032,
-0.5457292199134827,
0.42672762274742126,
0.2519933581352234,
0.16271767020225525,
-0.31109175086021423,
-0.2584160268306732,
-0.3831660747528076,
-0.01821880415081978,
0.4883298873901367,
0.09384003281593323,
-0.6766844987869263,
-0.23134483397006989,
-0.004752562381327152,
-0.40201181173324585,
0.11481968313455582,
0.8563636541366577,
-0.4546988308429718,
0.49985507130622864,
0.23666653037071228,
0.6855315566062927,
0.11555441468954086,
-0.12320816516876221,
0.6028639078140259,
-0.8711744546890259,
0.17430523037910461,
0.15620948374271393,
0.633145272731781,
0.8157961368560791,
-0.10180064290761948,
0.5910345911979675,
0.28653764724731445,
-0.33604708313941956,
-0.8442557454109192,
0.24136878550052643,
-0.9569260478019714,
-0.3956599831581116,
1.0794010162353516,
-0.11152145266532898,
0.06059284880757332,
-0.1794823408126831,
0.0766918808221817,
0.2834484875202179,
-0.14121749997138977,
0.384515643119812,
1.011716365814209,
0.12579594552516937,
0.07324490696191788,
-0.43262284994125366,
0.303080290555954,
0.4852043688297272,
-0.6557158827781677,
0.4110879898071289,
0.6825488805770874,
0.22498808801174164,
0.4215412139892578,
0.310356080532074,
-0.20449019968509674,
0.03214765340089798,
-0.11351636052131653,
0.03154831379652023,
0.06981964409351349,
-0.35149505734443665,
-0.32285812497138977,
0.01963193155825138,
0.12237519770860672,
0.1511380672454834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14425v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14425v2 | SynDARin: Synthesising Datasets for Automated Reasoning in Low-Resource Languages | 2024-06-20T15:49:28 | 2024-06-25T13:48:41 | Gayane Ghazaryan, Erik Arakelyan, Pasquale Minervini, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Question Answering (QA) datasets have been instrumental in developing and
evaluating Large Language Model (LLM) capabilities. However, such datasets are
scarce for languages other than English due to the cost and difficulties of
collection and manual annotation. This means that producing novel models and
measuring the performance of multilingual LLMs in low-resource languages is
challenging. To mitigate this, we propose $\textbf{S}$yn$\textbf{DAR}$in, a
method for generating and validating QA datasets for low-resource languages. We
utilize parallel content mining to obtain $\textit{human-curated}$ paragraphs
between English and the target language. We use the English data as context to
$\textit{generate}$ synthetic multiple-choice (MC) question-answer pairs, which
are automatically translated and further validated for quality. Combining these
with their designated non-English $\textit{human-curated}$ paragraphs form the
final QA dataset. The method allows to maintain the content quality, reduces
the likelihood of factual errors, and circumvents the need for costly
annotation. To test the method, we created a QA dataset with $1.2$K samples for
the Armenian language. The human evaluation shows that $98\%$ of the generated
English data maintains quality and diversity in the question types and topics,
while the translation validation pipeline can filter out $\sim70\%$ of data
with poor quality. We use the dataset to benchmark state-of-the-art LLMs,
showing their inability to achieve human accuracy with some model performances
closer to random chance. This shows that the generated dataset is non-trivial
and can be used to evaluate reasoning capabilities in low-resource language. | [
-0.4224584698677063,
-0.5803411602973938,
0.5462132692337036,
-0.05525604262948036,
-0.2563835680484772,
0.05603377893567085,
-0.3490847945213318,
-0.075238436460495,
0.22911947965621948,
0.6286271214485168,
-0.6672592759132385,
-0.5994635224342346,
-0.1962890475988388,
0.6521608233451843,
-0.17611901462078094,
0.8548383712768555,
-0.2183985859155655,
0.20195429027080536,
-0.585101842880249,
-0.53754061460495,
-0.24787786602973938,
-0.2976023256778717,
-0.613337516784668,
-0.05037663131952286,
0.4071792662143707,
0.6307982802391052,
0.5501231551170349,
0.652600109577179,
0.3918239176273346,
0.32109248638153076,
-0.06414191424846649,
0.7033654451370239,
-0.18157263100147247,
0.3618728816509247,
-0.22024250030517578,
-0.6710914373397827,
-0.27908727526664734,
-0.03962793946266174,
0.5869190096855164,
0.5944187045097351,
-0.018461277708411217,
0.6233400702476501,
-0.007265341002494097,
0.5212781429290771,
-0.40152183175086975,
0.08244943618774414,
-0.5424855947494507,
-0.28530779480934143,
-0.33872124552726746,
0.03700947016477585,
-0.1632823497056961,
-0.4154825806617737,
-0.12686432898044586,
-0.629182755947113,
0.07084394246339798,
0.27220073342323303,
0.8955867886543274,
0.45934006571769714,
-0.2549750506877899,
-0.2680445909500122,
-0.5383198261260986,
1.068847417831421,
-0.8583124279975891,
0.0954207181930542,
0.4958648681640625,
0.5135678648948669,
-0.028598738834261894,
-0.5614342093467712,
-0.8905642628669739,
-0.10166957974433899,
-0.2862910032272339,
-0.012808444909751415,
0.12855201959609985,
-0.10758636146783829,
0.4713653326034546,
0.49016129970550537,
-0.8093084096908569,
-0.10779885202646255,
-0.48500359058380127,
-0.16152681410312653,
0.7397187352180481,
0.3858727216720581,
0.47457754611968994,
-0.5808743834495544,
0.02335980348289013,
-0.2707197666168213,
-0.7669202089309692,
0.1854756772518158,
0.6049125790596008,
0.4422376751899719,
-0.11001312732696533,
0.7980115413665771,
-0.48770245909690857,
0.6105222105979919,
-0.11768122762441635,
-0.2959710657596588,
0.23171795904636383,
-0.716198742389679,
-0.08192069083452225,
-0.4339556396007538,
0.7927901148796082,
0.08757118880748749,
0.05788175016641617,
0.019253958016633987,
-0.38819602131843567,
0.12956705689430237,
-0.020175650715827942,
-0.7240804433822632,
-0.13287903368473053,
0.4248715937137604,
-0.43918195366859436,
-0.08639990538358688,
-0.30497977137565613,
-0.6635034680366516,
-0.323617547750473,
-0.43223127722740173,
0.2269214242696762,
-0.2548937499523163,
-0.08729197829961777,
0.03948790952563286,
0.09425007551908493,
0.09767545759677887,
0.07977774739265442,
-0.5223937630653381,
0.3744588792324066,
0.38623568415641785,
0.5285009741783142,
-0.23399537801742554,
-0.3814348876476288,
-0.5345119833946228,
-0.10271298140287399,
-0.3654307723045349,
0.9221652746200562,
-0.2630421817302704,
0.0880209431052208,
-0.1410016119480133,
0.03614114969968796,
0.04627886787056923,
-0.7426844239234924,
0.6305417418479919,
-0.47684141993522644,
0.4317140281200409,
-0.36074408888816833,
-0.4259263873100281,
-0.10053395479917526,
0.49891039729118347,
-0.7940099239349365,
0.9913516044616699,
0.2946186065673828,
-0.7571765780448914,
0.15266935527324677,
-0.2540756165981293,
-0.37397414445877075,
0.041708990931510925,
-0.26785653829574585,
-0.24802322685718536,
-0.21286028623580933,
0.5633768439292908,
0.08793141692876816,
-0.8174002170562744,
0.24216176569461823,
-0.07952714711427689,
-0.251494824886322,
0.37294843792915344,
-0.3194693326950073,
0.7584290504455566,
0.27703985571861267,
-0.00284397741779685,
0.05494777485728264,
-0.8645633459091187,
0.2725324332714081,
-0.010731574147939682,
-0.3761487603187561,
-0.3617827594280243,
-0.1263955682516098,
-0.01983235590159893,
0.5160907506942749,
0.2725743055343628,
-0.5535388588905334,
-0.13549108803272247,
-0.5884715914726257,
0.2550133466720581,
0.5399923920631409,
0.08529382199048996,
0.40410593152046204,
-0.6993535757064819,
0.8628210425376892,
0.0035486933775246143,
0.10060905665159225,
-0.10734496265649796,
-0.373872846364975,
-0.9269940853118896,
-0.25377723574638367,
0.44824013113975525,
0.7384713292121887,
-1.2335569858551025,
0.36631083488464355,
-0.20663239061832428,
-0.47153592109680176,
-0.9758756756782532,
0.35957789421081543,
0.4116402566432953,
0.37772563099861145,
0.3538772761821747,
-0.14418883621692657,
-0.5778668522834778,
-1.021016240119934,
-0.08847948908805847,
-0.2975985109806061,
-0.11645021289587021,
0.5755255818367004,
0.2997618317604065,
-0.045702479779720306,
0.8326629400253296,
-0.250829815864563,
-0.026654552668333054,
-0.5359720587730408,
0.08946352452039719,
0.41994860768318176,
0.4601103663444519,
0.2829981744289398,
-0.5715036988258362,
-0.48261305689811707,
-0.13765007257461548,
-0.7593806982040405,
-0.32903388142585754,
-0.13455750048160553,
-0.24835525453090668,
0.33550384640693665,
0.24736447632312775,
-0.6747393012046814,
0.1700482964515686,
0.5943309664726257,
-0.014746161177754402,
0.6314952969551086,
-0.017214719206094742,
0.376881867647171,
-1.3900398015975952,
0.20063920319080353,
-0.1201433315873146,
0.030692249536514282,
-0.44835785031318665,
0.04844111576676369,
-0.17936594784259796,
-0.32576143741607666,
-0.444999098777771,
0.9013221263885498,
-0.19845561683177948,
-0.03066122718155384,
-0.16487878561019897,
0.263738214969635,
0.2036363035440445,
0.5200368762016296,
-0.06370186805725098,
0.9450063705444336,
0.3874299228191376,
-0.38905972242355347,
0.5503923892974854,
0.4242226779460907,
-0.5401530265808105,
0.6134673953056335,
-0.7708168029785156,
-0.06274280697107315,
-0.17226338386535645,
0.07902626693248749,
-0.8568336367607117,
-0.2809034585952759,
0.27512693405151367,
-0.3206838369369507,
-0.18996025621891022,
-0.2768166959285736,
-0.7625067830085754,
-0.27687743306159973,
-0.01099299918860197,
0.685099720954895,
0.5021876692771912,
-0.3197561204433441,
0.5396563410758972,
0.41742438077926636,
-0.5636758804321289,
-0.41094771027565,
-0.7008365392684937,
-0.046072524040937424,
-0.2129548043012619,
-0.9349660277366638,
-0.016072556376457214,
-0.11360813677310944,
-0.4578016698360443,
0.06537262350320816,
-0.020395871251821518,
-0.22500571608543396,
-0.029429730027914047,
-0.08083787560462952,
0.282014936208725,
-0.16295234858989716,
0.23184016346931458,
0.16826565563678741,
-0.11643148213624954,
-0.002344944514334202,
-0.17289096117019653,
0.38871604204177856,
-0.02309577539563179,
-0.44620901346206665,
-0.46720898151397705,
0.4900449216365814,
0.4272874593734741,
-0.4686540961265564,
0.5489441752433777,
0.4575521647930145,
-0.3320067226886749,
-0.6753294467926025,
-0.4223516881465912,
-0.44360437989234924,
-0.43759986758232117,
0.16129454970359802,
-0.36611974239349365,
-0.7166107296943665,
0.7379090189933777,
0.13395839929580688,
0.06018799543380737,
0.37354955077171326,
0.5439381003379822,
-0.10653738677501678,
0.8932440280914307,
0.06885300576686859,
0.16325782239437103,
-0.048462338745594025,
-0.1979110687971115,
0.22787581384181976,
-0.5901736617088318,
0.11527165025472641,
-0.6186683177947998,
-0.25772905349731445,
-0.9291494488716125,
-0.5787907242774963,
0.6187629103660583,
-0.06505901366472244,
-0.11033158749341965,
0.24504141509532928,
-0.19428010284900665,
0.4085647761821747,
0.8205178380012512,
0.01968485862016678,
0.27195313572883606,
-0.05621898174285889,
-0.09868468344211578,
0.04798875004053116,
-0.7982785701751709,
-0.7108993530273438,
1.239949107170105,
-0.032993875443935394,
0.7673627138137817,
-0.05060375854372978,
0.8298882842063904,
0.13606123626232147,
-0.02282600849866867,
-0.4763643145561218,
0.6389793753623962,
-0.3285834491252899,
-0.49280714988708496,
-0.49836069345474243,
-0.6946403980255127,
-0.7231511473655701,
0.16823852062225342,
-0.1884303241968155,
-0.1623803973197937,
0.04344010353088379,
0.016121448948979378,
-0.44992050528526306,
0.13414153456687927,
-0.5791875123977661,
0.8626443147659302,
-0.15817859768867493,
-0.2972659468650818,
-0.2209872454404831,
-0.45197707414627075,
0.34538033604621887,
0.006597692612558603,
0.20048768818378448,
-0.2385447472333908,
0.21651530265808105,
0.6974579095840454,
-0.4289171099662781,
0.6894599795341492,
-0.04501044377684593,
-0.07261919230222702,
0.6096348762512207,
0.15325075387954712,
0.6016950607299805,
0.31160613894462585,
-0.22515201568603516,
-0.023214275017380714,
0.2761773467063904,
-0.5569120645523071,
-0.6610556840896606,
0.518729031085968,
-0.7594459056854248,
-0.6893308162689209,
-0.2912678122520447,
-0.888763964176178,
-0.3369033634662628,
0.0714157223701477,
-0.08516624569892883,
0.38982415199279785,
0.04308897629380226,
-0.1683783084154129,
0.44963499903678894,
-0.5336442589759827,
-0.046087585389614105,
0.4538894593715668,
0.09029052406549454,
-0.5726984739303589,
1.0240931510925293,
0.04434933140873909,
0.24214133620262146,
0.14780277013778687,
0.14842139184474945,
-0.2613813281059265,
-0.5484060049057007,
-0.6957352757453918,
0.3282819986343384,
-0.6673654913902283,
-0.2524837851524353,
-0.29532483220100403,
-0.3053847551345825,
-0.26878952980041504,
0.24482788145542145,
-0.22560366988182068,
-0.6313516497612,
-0.07565885782241821,
0.11277090758085251,
0.21675175428390503,
0.45903611183166504,
-0.00901854783296585,
-0.02556396834552288,
-0.859880805015564,
0.46046313643455505,
0.4550291895866394,
0.13250277936458588,
-0.20734553039073944,
-0.409807950258255,
-0.39727669954299927,
0.2211548388004303,
-0.044813379645347595,
-0.4633144438266754,
0.3818571865558624,
-0.07788112759590149,
0.569584846496582,
-0.044990088790655136,
0.3236860930919647,
0.39973580837249756,
-0.307464599609375,
0.8425658345222473,
-0.2970360815525055,
-0.7435407638549805,
0.6693008542060852,
-0.26878491044044495,
0.2925513982772827,
0.7297448515892029,
0.22826309502124786,
-0.6635630130767822,
-0.6860971450805664,
-0.4723549485206604,
-0.7950983643531799,
0.8315192461013794,
0.3433383107185364,
-0.13659366965293884,
-0.1322019100189209,
0.1857936829328537,
0.294805645942688,
0.25033727288246155,
-0.4463687539100647,
-0.3065880835056305,
0.07240385562181473,
-0.45757630467414856,
0.09684179723262787,
-0.2059878259897232,
-0.2406383454799652,
-0.05009939521551132,
0.7373855113983154,
-0.3313741683959961,
-0.12219042330980301,
-0.028884828090667725,
-0.12245668470859528,
-0.027372809126973152,
0.37678492069244385,
0.20679807662963867,
0.7564699053764343,
-0.03744328394532204,
0.10579641163349152,
0.18288245797157288,
-0.1440134197473526,
0.33685392141342163,
0.3006819784641266,
-0.585647463798523,
-0.012796585448086262,
0.2691226303577423,
0.5685364603996277,
-0.3491266667842865,
-1.075904369354248,
0.42965394258499146,
-0.1867043823003769,
0.04478375241160393,
-0.21722029149532318,
-0.033630531281232834,
-0.11955688148736954,
0.35087478160858154,
0.036203473806381226,
-0.006875957828015089,
-0.010989433154463768,
-0.152110755443573,
0.24785080552101135,
0.17688988149166107,
0.1459711790084839,
-0.29828327894210815,
0.3503832221031189,
0.23437198996543884,
0.12986929714679718,
0.7811253070831299,
-0.4573165774345398,
-0.32587021589279175,
0.6308823227882385,
0.1365673840045929,
0.704821765422821,
-0.010989534668624401,
0.49290040135383606,
0.6267300248146057,
0.31987297534942627,
-0.10247308015823364,
0.6922167539596558,
-0.05046854168176651,
-0.7571403980255127,
-0.6790337562561035,
-0.7557440996170044,
-0.4537412226200104,
0.12099185585975647,
-0.5891385674476624,
0.14467868208885193,
-0.17684778571128845,
0.014156203716993332,
-0.3406093120574951,
0.2369358092546463,
-0.6614826321601868,
0.27856576442718506,
0.06975249946117401,
0.8090024590492249,
-1.0760213136672974,
0.6919808387756348,
0.7939797639846802,
-0.527286946773529,
-0.7619220018386841,
-0.06063087657094002,
-0.2088368684053421,
-0.7356374859809875,
0.6785663962364197,
-0.16606934368610382,
0.2351665049791336,
-0.24186578392982483,
-0.3893359899520874,
-0.9528301954269409,
0.9803412556648254,
0.4702646732330322,
-0.25330084562301636,
0.14250443875789642,
0.5566152334213257,
0.6374630928039551,
-0.23897814750671387,
0.19144777953624725,
0.5397023558616638,
0.4703795611858368,
-0.062249138951301575,
-0.8832749724388123,
0.15218131244182587,
-0.43348002433776855,
-0.012319507077336311,
-0.1296945959329605,
-0.5793671011924744,
0.9769853949546814,
-0.14890512824058533,
-0.42187538743019104,
0.41116589307785034,
0.5473340153694153,
0.7003940939903259,
0.15195222198963165,
0.5264572501182556,
0.7181683778762817,
0.8492408990859985,
-0.11896747350692749,
1.0260196924209595,
-0.3570064604282379,
-0.020981501787900925,
1.0785894393920898,
-0.43428730964660645,
0.6334981918334961,
0.5921427011489868,
-0.18622875213623047,
0.4774046838283539,
0.5219331979751587,
0.048979129642248154,
0.43404820561408997,
0.40797486901283264,
-0.21289969980716705,
-0.6002970933914185,
-0.4939294755458832,
0.06917238980531693,
0.4346529543399811,
0.10161875188350677,
-0.09518521279096603,
-0.21609504520893097,
-0.0844251960515976,
-0.2767024636268616,
0.36917731165885925,
-0.08374052494764328,
0.7555273175239563,
-0.011320789344608784,
-0.8500275015830994,
0.7129188776016235,
0.1259545087814331,
0.3845266103744507,
-0.4945029616355896,
0.012384267523884773,
-0.6726102232933044,
-0.048687644302845,
-0.013578496873378754,
-0.7801780700683594,
0.33830875158309937,
0.11318881064653397,
-0.31945979595184326,
-0.1654769331216812,
0.4167475700378418,
-0.7363290786743164,
-0.6876260638237,
-0.07539244741201401,
0.9725116491317749,
0.1619850993156433,
0.2707766592502594,
-0.5379223227500916,
-0.08043764531612396,
-0.0485287681221962,
-0.01660422794520855,
0.2351178079843521,
0.6869368553161621,
-0.25904691219329834,
0.7758302092552185,
0.694791316986084,
0.5065145492553711,
-0.10998573154211044,
0.15260259807109833,
0.8395044207572937,
-0.4093272387981415,
-0.5336390137672424,
-0.37215399742126465,
0.426138699054718,
-0.07174714654684067,
-0.24184012413024902,
0.6909218430519104,
0.5143334269523621,
1.049498438835144,
0.009085397236049175,
1.009727120399475,
-0.1745440661907196,
0.8358473181724548,
-0.5411089658737183,
0.6757166385650635,
-0.5762616395950317,
0.3808867633342743,
0.18315665423870087,
-0.6505364775657654,
-0.02970573864877224,
0.3346910774707794,
-0.1923009604215622,
-0.14926356077194214,
0.7359199523925781,
1.092441201210022,
0.09998556971549988,
-0.13453927636146545,
0.20457632839679718,
0.11434037238359451,
0.18284912407398224,
0.7313918471336365,
0.9564635753631592,
-0.5843530893325806,
0.7869901061058044,
-0.4714873433113098,
-0.04503096640110016,
0.40896791219711304,
-0.5464637875556946,
-1.0426353216171265,
-0.73317950963974,
-0.1552363485097885,
-0.48814576864242554,
-0.06923231482505798,
0.9563025236129761,
0.5200484395027161,
-1.23630690574646,
-0.39553189277648926,
0.1314493864774704,
0.41125139594078064,
-0.3322316110134125,
-0.20988738536834717,
0.5958495140075684,
-0.5267626643180847,
-0.8617541193962097,
0.36010468006134033,
-0.026422254741191864,
-0.06086300313472748,
-0.45696189999580383,
-0.15596017241477966,
-0.06512604653835297,
0.03217858076095581,
0.270411878824234,
0.2072167694568634,
-0.6888018250465393,
-0.07336268573999405,
0.1654970645904541,
-0.17882797122001648,
-0.1609886884689331,
0.6166195869445801,
-0.7666440010070801,
0.34473082423210144,
0.7335705757141113,
0.9171363711357117,
0.07290647178888321,
0.06900180131196976,
0.7017942667007446,
-0.899411141872406,
0.15101490914821625,
0.4180469512939453,
0.3560234606266022,
0.5079752206802368,
-0.028836997225880623,
0.34282389283180237,
0.19492778182029724,
-0.5225779414176941,
-0.8218942284584045,
0.29117268323898315,
-0.6595227122306824,
-0.09078121930360794,
1.2856066226959229,
-0.23828263580799103,
-0.38727325201034546,
-0.13718846440315247,
-0.16776341199874878,
0.12471458315849304,
-0.26330962777137756,
0.9746016263961792,
0.6453275680541992,
0.09652720391750336,
-0.21404437720775604,
-0.3128635883331299,
0.7289861440658569,
0.3579976260662079,
-1.1425809860229492,
0.12171010673046112,
0.5308590531349182,
0.14834657311439514,
0.08132924884557724,
0.429940402507782,
-0.08290396630764008,
0.42289745807647705,
-0.10693208873271942,
0.09586940705776215,
-0.07419607788324356,
-0.140322744846344,
-0.08476253598928452,
0.034309666603803635,
0.005918420851230621,
-0.1336803436279297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14408v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14408v2 | FVEL: Interactive Formal Verification Environment with Large Language Models via Theorem Proving | 2024-06-20T15:31:05 | 2024-06-21T02:51:41 | Xiaohan Lin, Qingxing Cao, Yinya Huang, Haiming Wang, Jianqiao Lu, Zhengying Liu, Linqi Song, Xiaodan Liang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Formal verification (FV) has witnessed growing significance with current
emerging program synthesis by the evolving large language models (LLMs).
However, current formal verification mainly resorts to symbolic verifiers or
hand-craft rules, resulting in limitations for extensive and flexible
verification. On the other hand, formal languages for automated theorem
proving, such as Isabelle, as another line of rigorous verification, are
maintained with comprehensive rules and theorems. In this paper, we propose
FVEL, an interactive Formal Verification Environment with LLMs. Specifically,
FVEL transforms a given code to be verified into Isabelle, and then conducts
verification via neural automated theorem proving with an LLM. The joined
paradigm leverages the rigorous yet abundant formulated and organized rules in
Isabelle and is also convenient for introducing and adjusting cutting-edge
LLMs. To achieve this goal, we extract a large-scale FVELER3. The FVELER
dataset includes code dependencies and verification processes that are
formulated in Isabelle, containing 758 theories, 29,125 lemmas, and 200,646
proof steps in total with in-depth dependencies. We benchmark FVELER in the
FVEL environment by first fine-tuning LLMs with FVELER and then evaluating them
on Code2Inv and SV-COMP. The results show that FVEL with FVELER fine-tuned
Llama3- 8B solves 17.39% (69 -> 81) more problems, and Mistral-7B 12% (75 ->
84) more problems in SV-COMP. And the proportion of proof errors is reduced.
Project page: https://fveler.github.io/. | [
-0.27350860834121704,
-0.7858367562294006,
0.5759889483451843,
0.2666569650173187,
-0.02203952893614769,
0.08366161584854126,
-0.4172458350658417,
-0.513152539730072,
-0.15543711185455322,
0.5980027914047241,
-0.4383080303668976,
-0.6573214530944824,
-0.3498260974884033,
0.21099139750003815,
-0.34254327416419983,
0.5067886114120483,
-0.5107525587081909,
-0.09143480658531189,
-0.2290053814649582,
0.008256658911705017,
-0.21235428750514984,
-0.4197520911693573,
-0.43538814783096313,
-0.31233566999435425,
0.1900034099817276,
0.28950098156929016,
0.4142617881298065,
0.5374953746795654,
0.5107519030570984,
0.46548715233802795,
0.09937465190887451,
0.4415109157562256,
-0.3013648986816406,
0.4577104449272156,
0.12536194920539856,
-0.6084261536598206,
-0.49240559339523315,
-0.4977352023124695,
0.5926342606544495,
0.12138266116380692,
0.06914404034614563,
0.010635793209075928,
-0.044098954647779465,
0.4337887763977051,
-0.6037280559539795,
0.47384995222091675,
-0.4512278735637665,
-0.06275150924921036,
-0.1427934318780899,
-0.11074218153953552,
-0.397377073764801,
-0.5064924955368042,
-0.1057371199131012,
-0.660123348236084,
-0.18243993818759918,
0.21284964680671692,
0.7398605346679688,
0.3379105031490326,
-0.45717543363571167,
-0.33592960238456726,
-0.9983378648757935,
0.7090678215026855,
-0.476051390171051,
0.6308446526527405,
0.066809743642807,
0.6133882999420166,
-0.1445489376783371,
-0.7122126221656799,
-0.5663788318634033,
-0.22499045729637146,
0.14975091814994812,
-0.2832932472229004,
-0.3949333131313324,
0.07403914630413055,
0.7142032980918884,
0.5042767524719238,
-0.5061505436897278,
0.23152917623519897,
-0.23797649145126343,
-0.5366710424423218,
0.71639084815979,
0.143522247672081,
0.4261087477207184,
0.20971174538135529,
-0.114805668592453,
-0.17185433208942413,
-1.0177128314971924,
0.14110136032104492,
0.11792013049125671,
0.005158493295311928,
0.07297460734844208,
0.438317209482193,
-0.21016044914722443,
0.750851035118103,
-0.26457706093788147,
-0.06983412802219391,
0.013732812367379665,
-0.2976243793964386,
-0.18798696994781494,
-0.1727534532546997,
0.7614113092422485,
0.37226685881614685,
0.3023870587348938,
-0.03408095985651016,
-0.6161038875579834,
-0.05359955132007599,
-0.19458332657814026,
-1.0375244617462158,
-0.11422446370124817,
0.4028829336166382,
-0.28824567794799805,
-0.12899668514728546,
-0.10715069621801376,
-0.6590796709060669,
-0.23351357877254486,
-0.43095430731773376,
0.30246955156326294,
-0.7740181088447571,
-0.06724328547716141,
0.12232521176338196,
0.30891406536102295,
0.5508224964141846,
0.7598960399627686,
-0.6353206038475037,
0.35726451873779297,
1.0760303735733032,
0.820229172706604,
0.16621629893779755,
-0.29547053575515747,
-1.0693602561950684,
0.04038097336888313,
-0.27367883920669556,
0.498995840549469,
-0.2587396800518036,
0.04080010950565338,
0.3200540244579315,
-0.07061030715703964,
0.321443647146225,
-0.29323720932006836,
0.41045212745666504,
-0.7121996283531189,
-0.055393610149621964,
-0.3606615662574768,
-0.508882462978363,
-0.26690930128097534,
0.6587458252906799,
-0.5654970407485962,
0.8884317278862,
-0.019609959796071053,
-0.5223066806793213,
0.23262366652488708,
-0.7382550239562988,
-0.3488471508026123,
0.008075360208749771,
-0.2765142023563385,
-0.11644519865512848,
-0.18876886367797852,
0.3931375741958618,
0.35750678181648254,
-0.531339168548584,
0.15233977138996124,
-0.3241618871688843,
-0.4503704309463501,
0.36126708984375,
0.044305577874183655,
0.8125150203704834,
0.1355149894952774,
-0.4189685583114624,
0.36293020844459534,
-0.8462152481079102,
-0.01226697489619255,
0.08849877119064331,
-0.03702211007475853,
-0.4371107518672943,
-0.15353001654148102,
-0.13104002177715302,
0.2509996294975281,
0.1806120127439499,
-0.7483854293823242,
0.39231374859809875,
-0.6191375851631165,
0.7649669647216797,
0.7394028902053833,
0.012679743580520153,
0.24707502126693726,
-0.36229491233825684,
0.6160489916801453,
-0.056611862033605576,
0.19469158351421356,
-0.31891149282455444,
-0.31824421882629395,
-0.9643746018409729,
-0.4497481882572174,
0.5309606790542603,
0.5883885622024536,
-0.8997396230697632,
0.44821447134017944,
-0.2801094651222229,
-0.1712963879108429,
-0.3549550771713257,
0.123052679002285,
0.2772058844566345,
0.18782992660999298,
0.30942174792289734,
0.10302221029996872,
-0.560674786567688,
-0.6297441720962524,
0.026774045079946518,
-0.15285316109657288,
-0.3073597550392151,
0.002288342919200659,
0.8759937882423401,
-0.4523564875125885,
0.9352269768714905,
-0.32639145851135254,
-0.29307204484939575,
0.1428498923778534,
-0.078823022544384,
0.07974415272474289,
0.4392368495464325,
0.6011402606964111,
-0.36154842376708984,
-0.1508709192276001,
0.2453826367855072,
-0.9047418832778931,
-0.07427306473255157,
0.11408291757106781,
-0.10206672549247742,
0.294636070728302,
0.567768394947052,
-0.2746425271034241,
0.23221592605113983,
0.3700364828109741,
0.01571510173380375,
0.331343412399292,
-0.41352349519729614,
0.20896658301353455,
-0.5455853939056396,
-0.007389784324914217,
-0.052012160420417786,
-0.49205252528190613,
-0.20445096492767334,
0.4825442135334015,
0.0044737206771969795,
-0.12716680765151978,
-0.29485517740249634,
0.6676933765411377,
-0.5255078673362732,
-0.034822311252355576,
-0.021746624261140823,
0.03591727092862129,
0.05663725361227989,
0.4234473705291748,
-0.18634085357189178,
0.598490297794342,
0.7693865895271301,
-0.5913546085357666,
0.5893818736076355,
0.18086902797222137,
-0.3555259704589844,
0.4519504904747009,
-0.9673970937728882,
0.16802719235420227,
0.06927385181188583,
0.34031498432159424,
-0.7921894788742065,
-0.25172677636146545,
0.14714312553405762,
0.017957009375095367,
0.0009656863985583186,
-0.33797940611839294,
-0.8703912496566772,
-0.2180541604757309,
-0.4127003252506256,
0.26478317379951477,
0.7341021299362183,
-0.6270778179168701,
1.1052038669586182,
0.08628295361995697,
0.03050237149000168,
-0.4539073705673218,
-0.8001222610473633,
-0.08491593599319458,
0.011028483510017395,
-1.1264188289642334,
0.139183908700943,
-0.00800862442702055,
-0.7128269672393799,
-0.3370252251625061,
-0.05471207946538925,
-0.03495417535305023,
0.03606941178441048,
0.46749329566955566,
0.07122765481472015,
-0.31350043416023254,
-0.1062755435705185,
0.2726783752441406,
-0.13913169503211975,
0.27482202649116516,
-0.5071016550064087,
0.2363888919353485,
-0.5687466263771057,
-0.7393454909324646,
-0.3454107940196991,
0.21468974649906158,
0.8574560880661011,
-0.5600928068161011,
0.29620978236198425,
0.35157057642936707,
-0.6271885633468628,
-0.52162104845047,
-0.4565882086753845,
-0.34459441900253296,
-0.469841867685318,
-0.09435120970010757,
-0.49496492743492126,
-1.1512764692306519,
0.8966442346572876,
-0.2090938538312912,
0.5463645458221436,
0.30619773268699646,
0.539281964302063,
0.1924898773431778,
0.7664738893508911,
0.49236950278282166,
0.36312782764434814,
0.3062173128128052,
-0.33352676033973694,
0.10785991698503494,
-0.548768162727356,
-0.3398795425891876,
-0.5632060170173645,
-0.17832276225090027,
-0.5044872164726257,
-0.6967076063156128,
0.4267500638961792,
-0.01934904232621193,
-0.338088721036911,
0.23926447331905365,
-0.4209894835948944,
0.4632883369922638,
0.44194525480270386,
0.1707799881696701,
0.6231992244720459,
-0.15549981594085693,
-0.3983783721923828,
-0.19105418026447296,
-0.4216543734073639,
-0.4907255172729492,
0.8503522872924805,
0.5133821964263916,
0.6150427460670471,
0.36567482352256775,
0.9476714134216309,
0.24161367118358612,
0.38507941365242004,
-0.6944171190261841,
0.8347474932670593,
0.04639528691768646,
-0.266031414270401,
-0.15722927451133728,
-0.44885918498039246,
-0.6092066764831543,
0.13909295201301575,
-0.20179982483386993,
-0.7069019675254822,
0.10377557575702667,
0.3915182650089264,
-0.3837791681289673,
0.031916484236717224,
-0.2948053479194641,
0.661142885684967,
-0.4584500193595886,
-0.7215797901153564,
-0.08711963146924973,
-0.5349112153053284,
0.703763484954834,
-0.0555650033056736,
0.31046682596206665,
-0.008996305987238884,
0.04567675292491913,
0.42859065532684326,
-0.9997581243515015,
0.6449120044708252,
-0.23258410394191742,
-0.5703125596046448,
0.05450725927948952,
0.48622819781303406,
0.7508754730224609,
0.29020747542381287,
-0.2799335718154907,
-0.0712868720293045,
-0.03148740157485008,
0.10181454569101334,
-0.7285402417182922,
0.8889440894126892,
-0.529329240322113,
-0.3472224473953247,
-0.621564507484436,
-0.28818732500076294,
0.0008838949725031853,
0.564038872718811,
0.0048310342244803905,
0.45865222811698914,
-0.24960781633853912,
0.08336879312992096,
0.9824042320251465,
-0.17734982073307037,
0.18554076552391052,
0.4437289237976074,
-0.9021407961845398,
-0.5167490243911743,
0.7534411549568176,
-0.024939633905887604,
-0.10999376326799393,
0.5065218210220337,
0.13331733644008636,
-0.3237573802471161,
-0.6145460605621338,
-0.4670381546020508,
0.11895092576742172,
-0.8935546875,
-0.27975329756736755,
-0.503192663192749,
-0.08575565367937088,
-0.10264329612255096,
-0.2779785692691803,
-0.32195088267326355,
-0.3595017194747925,
0.18224754929542542,
0.3408816158771515,
0.8051488995552063,
0.56507807970047,
-0.04763450473546982,
0.04001403972506523,
-0.7624375820159912,
0.21157464385032654,
0.40293699502944946,
0.41041746735572815,
-0.1759657859802246,
-0.17963175475597382,
0.20028088986873627,
0.16826456785202026,
-0.03341604396700859,
-0.41256359219551086,
0.06650195270776749,
0.06419970840215683,
0.3846394121646881,
0.33488333225250244,
0.23204581439495087,
0.40612053871154785,
-0.38933005928993225,
0.5836829543113708,
-0.0228673554956913,
-1.3923622369766235,
0.6104502081871033,
-0.4636397957801819,
0.01781507022678852,
0.5525264739990234,
-0.013883359730243683,
-0.2338532656431198,
-0.5225066542625427,
-0.5013031959533691,
-0.8227396011352539,
0.37293362617492676,
0.307577908039093,
-0.3687809705734253,
0.3908202648162842,
0.37004294991493225,
0.040030624717473984,
0.012332160957157612,
-0.5481500029563904,
0.07712309062480927,
-0.11579404771327972,
0.02433607541024685,
0.31820523738861084,
-0.04746002331376076,
-0.2729399502277374,
-0.2548765242099762,
0.5977769494056702,
-0.148603618144989,
0.19335587322711945,
0.03784282132983208,
-0.2790139615535736,
0.16890071332454681,
0.10712798684835434,
0.7543995380401611,
0.7050814032554626,
-0.17916738986968994,
0.11545039713382721,
0.07064077258110046,
0.06745567172765732,
0.23344112932682037,
0.33148518204689026,
-0.3647618591785431,
0.04537602514028549,
0.5367347598075867,
0.7117737531661987,
0.2481374740600586,
-0.668452799320221,
0.6069486141204834,
-0.24369588494300842,
-0.4475838541984558,
-0.38648372888565063,
0.30443456768989563,
-0.12532350420951843,
0.35400575399398804,
0.14900782704353333,
0.0866302102804184,
0.017899753525853157,
-0.2998254895210266,
0.3272676467895508,
0.2762809693813324,
-0.06897733360528946,
-0.21372009813785553,
0.8324950933456421,
0.449876070022583,
-0.35696884989738464,
0.6262876391410828,
-0.18052713572978973,
-0.5652408599853516,
0.4822118878364563,
0.28318771719932556,
0.8644946217536926,
0.06541692465543747,
-0.13601554930210114,
0.3174996078014374,
0.4854588508605957,
-0.23652952909469604,
0.3523973226547241,
-0.24855947494506836,
-0.3711494505405426,
-0.74583500623703,
-0.5595864653587341,
-0.8944439888000488,
-0.10209143161773682,
-0.28718194365501404,
0.5112635493278503,
-0.7384443879127502,
0.2962140440940857,
0.0313686840236187,
-0.08860694617033005,
-0.5637909770011902,
-0.19450104236602783,
0.017375724390149117,
0.9749816060066223,
-0.7305867075920105,
0.7530583739280701,
0.7109787464141846,
-0.32635951042175293,
-0.6402068138122559,
0.07427089661359787,
0.07051952928304672,
-0.6975040435791016,
0.589583694934845,
0.2567182183265686,
-0.4753711223602295,
-0.07829342037439346,
-0.49942463636398315,
-0.4994378387928009,
1.026476263999939,
0.7256092429161072,
-0.8025279641151428,
0.16055303812026978,
-0.07223063707351685,
0.5772078633308411,
-0.2182416021823883,
0.24132446944713593,
0.2490321397781372,
0.6426485776901245,
0.4203017055988312,
-0.667685866355896,
0.32289358973503113,
-0.23083995282649994,
0.12366026639938354,
0.2987598478794098,
-0.45363736152648926,
0.6481527090072632,
-0.1695340871810913,
0.1677556186914444,
0.0428164042532444,
0.9865543246269226,
0.5272267460823059,
0.0760955959558487,
0.5643162727355957,
0.13851682841777802,
0.9562491774559021,
-0.3644021153450012,
0.7885928750038147,
-0.5125417709350586,
0.2338171899318695,
0.7187596559524536,
-0.7902458310127258,
0.6255512833595276,
0.35930365324020386,
-0.09965798258781433,
0.6741708517074585,
0.43245628476142883,
0.04858137294650078,
0.04701901972293854,
0.6509078741073608,
-0.2591792345046997,
-0.30509746074676514,
0.17505140602588654,
-0.42188912630081177,
0.5782380700111389,
0.2943950295448303,
-0.15454146265983582,
-0.21706394851207733,
0.19793134927749634,
0.013550357893109322,
0.1085287481546402,
-0.15373723208904266,
0.4989166259765625,
-0.14608268439769745,
-0.7402209043502808,
0.7369540333747864,
0.1538149118423462,
0.5936453938484192,
-0.7492362260818481,
-0.35498571395874023,
-0.08544478565454483,
0.6161572933197021,
-0.2485186755657196,
-0.7108736634254456,
0.3601195514202118,
-0.015400014817714691,
0.09981603175401688,
-0.5657380819320679,
0.7998125553131104,
-0.3985633850097656,
-0.4747214615345001,
0.13647869229316711,
0.30015718936920166,
0.013957708142697811,
0.10293414443731308,
-0.313400536775589,
0.6231866478919983,
0.023963039740920067,
-0.038692887872457504,
0.089065782725811,
0.8045480847358704,
-0.3008202910423279,
0.8026553988456726,
0.7818143367767334,
-0.057968150824308395,
-0.1537914127111435,
-0.1047869622707367,
0.9864124655723572,
-0.2865179479122162,
-0.6000423431396484,
-0.8870770335197449,
0.3859788775444031,
-0.20252367854118347,
-0.08788418769836426,
0.799384355545044,
0.5177677273750305,
0.5852262377738953,
-0.05959297716617584,
0.7343984842300415,
-0.12554095685482025,
0.12903034687042236,
-0.7292225360870361,
0.564842939376831,
-0.37097033858299255,
0.5815057158470154,
-0.33086836338043213,
-0.8379005789756775,
-0.7525699734687805,
0.9741536378860474,
-0.22464978694915771,
-0.1272999495267868,
0.4244265556335449,
0.7940718531608582,
-0.23669925332069397,
0.10366623848676682,
-0.02426302805542946,
0.18371881544589996,
0.6428053379058838,
0.6726452708244324,
0.909562885761261,
-0.41709333658218384,
0.32355284690856934,
-0.25628525018692017,
-0.5422047972679138,
-0.3692500591278076,
-1.311708688735962,
-0.8243455290794373,
-0.43314528465270996,
-0.6910895109176636,
-0.6679441332817078,
0.06754735857248306,
1.0049006938934326,
0.5151616930961609,
-0.6910305023193359,
-0.1794545203447342,
-0.26551005244255066,
0.4259895086288452,
-0.4426783621311188,
-0.1603335291147232,
0.11024196445941925,
0.0868070051074028,
-0.5841258764266968,
0.3832230865955353,
0.372569739818573,
-0.009316359646618366,
-0.668034017086029,
-0.2300274521112442,
-0.01418454758822918,
-0.0931372418999672,
0.6187213063240051,
0.5089126229286194,
-0.6366115212440491,
-0.33876779675483704,
0.060061849653720856,
0.0370628759264946,
-0.0794467106461525,
0.9899551272392273,
-0.5953027606010437,
0.30922287702560425,
0.7297928929328918,
0.5873150825500488,
0.5309287309646606,
-0.3666461706161499,
0.9160447120666504,
-0.645549476146698,
0.06000465527176857,
0.25720691680908203,
0.6262124180793762,
0.1632230281829834,
-0.23121440410614014,
0.3992803394794464,
-0.02002672664821148,
-0.6620042324066162,
-1.1300082206726074,
0.2309914529323578,
-0.9053553342819214,
0.24874454736709595,
1.1249847412109375,
-0.31582021713256836,
-0.3140847980976105,
-0.11472602933645248,
-0.14248521625995636,
0.01292393822222948,
-0.4186148941516876,
0.3000807762145996,
0.7478229403495789,
-0.18040335178375244,
-0.21138980984687805,
-0.33756542205810547,
0.4209293723106384,
0.05331452563405037,
-0.839553952217102,
0.3172907829284668,
0.730550229549408,
0.4495667815208435,
0.1267576366662979,
0.5583037734031677,
-0.03851692005991936,
0.26176729798316956,
-0.2736777663230896,
0.17084458470344543,
-0.6054767966270447,
-0.315442830324173,
-0.32602477073669434,
0.1358073502779007,
0.19166824221611023,
-0.13490281999111176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14394v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14394v1 | SEC-QA: A Systematic Evaluation Corpus for Financial QA | 2024-06-20T15:12:41 | 2024-06-20T15:12:41 | Viet Dac Lai, Michael Krumdick, Charles Lovering, Varshini Reddy, Craig Schmidt, Chris Tanner | cs.CL | cs.CL | The financial domain frequently deals with large numbers of long documents
that are essential for daily operations. Significant effort is put towards
automating financial data analysis. However, a persistent challenge, not
limited to the finance domain, is the scarcity of datasets that accurately
reflect real-world tasks for model evaluation. Existing datasets are often
constrained by size, context, or relevance to practical applications. Moreover,
LLMs are currently trained on trillions of tokens of text, limiting access to
novel data or documents that models have not encountered during training for
unbiased evaluation. We propose SEC-QA, a continuous dataset generation
framework with two key features: 1) the semi-automatic generation of
Question-Answer (QA) pairs spanning multiple long context financial documents,
which better represent real-world financial scenarios; 2) the ability to
continually refresh the dataset using the most recent public document
collections, not yet ingested by LLMs. Our experiments show that current
retrieval augmented generation methods systematically fail to answer these
challenging multi-document questions. In response, we introduce a QA system
based on program-of-thought that improves the ability to perform complex
information retrieval and quantitative reasoning pipelines, thereby increasing
QA accuracy. | [
-0.22764751315116882,
-0.6571093797683716,
0.4817705750465393,
0.2804054617881775,
-0.31457629799842834,
0.6134255528450012,
-0.03601590916514397,
-0.45555466413497925,
0.18288010358810425,
0.4291359782218933,
-0.4459894597530365,
-0.5305042862892151,
-0.04780551418662071,
0.09603653848171234,
-0.6689231991767883,
0.8799017667770386,
0.05090303346514702,
0.180627703666687,
-0.2574431002140045,
-0.0029995660297572613,
-0.4345059394836426,
-0.29972317814826965,
-0.7476671934127808,
0.10359634459018707,
0.05488608404994011,
0.2665148675441742,
0.5437992811203003,
0.2309885025024414,
0.7727227210998535,
0.32916387915611267,
0.2531285881996155,
0.2587047517299652,
-0.5382278561592102,
0.2374858558177948,
-0.17859745025634766,
-0.3737778067588806,
-0.29321178793907166,
-0.06258916854858398,
0.6092036366462708,
0.4385184347629547,
-0.14043712615966797,
0.5103006958961487,
-0.1749374270439148,
0.7877437472343445,
-0.7274538278579712,
0.25040850043296814,
-0.34727877378463745,
-0.18198813498020172,
-0.02058570086956024,
-0.345068097114563,
-0.18009649217128754,
-0.6820876002311707,
0.47171616554260254,
-0.6628348231315613,
0.14036190509796143,
0.22047407925128937,
0.8872210383415222,
0.18792489171028137,
-0.5536112785339355,
-0.5621082186698914,
-0.7894783020019531,
0.5143317580223083,
-0.4958096742630005,
0.2862814962863922,
0.10448110848665237,
0.496028870344162,
-0.018594270572066307,
-0.8053197264671326,
-0.41945990920066833,
-0.14903932809829712,
0.16674919426441193,
0.1651720404624939,
-0.1668725162744522,
-0.04076690226793289,
0.3442423939704895,
0.28345680236816406,
-0.29290658235549927,
-0.32998162508010864,
-0.7244337797164917,
-0.2224707007408142,
0.6329571604728699,
0.21497580409049988,
0.027097193524241447,
-0.03787663206458092,
-0.4150739014148712,
-0.4366201162338257,
-0.7179824709892273,
0.12013130635023117,
0.34408748149871826,
0.13764485716819763,
0.11510476469993591,
0.31445157527923584,
-0.2100735604763031,
0.4171166718006134,
-0.0638689249753952,
-0.08874041587114334,
0.04251749813556671,
-0.5073251724243164,
-0.308881938457489,
-0.014063364826142788,
0.4521573781967163,
0.20100390911102295,
-0.08040392398834229,
-0.0008253101259469986,
-0.47487643361091614,
-0.09912338852882385,
0.350707083940506,
-0.6510435938835144,
0.027605880051851273,
0.6473389863967896,
-0.06922198086977005,
-0.3712543249130249,
0.28616854548454285,
-0.792620062828064,
-0.07410039752721786,
-0.5456060171127319,
0.27087339758872986,
-0.3889756500720978,
0.23214873671531677,
0.05833932384848595,
-0.5272544622421265,
0.47669360041618347,
0.1093267872929573,
-0.3813222348690033,
0.2490871399641037,
0.6670600175857544,
0.3997666537761688,
0.1390479952096939,
0.05466162785887718,
-0.6216750741004944,
0.19745013117790222,
-0.5454241633415222,
0.845363438129425,
-0.5227543711662292,
-0.38439080119132996,
-0.035307664424180984,
-0.31055527925491333,
-0.0007055720197968185,
-0.4630204439163208,
0.4566359519958496,
-0.7987205386161804,
0.2304246574640274,
-0.4200000464916229,
-0.6697174310684204,
0.11521264165639877,
0.2383594959974289,
-0.5256810784339905,
0.9465744495391846,
0.47037962079048157,
-0.7883493900299072,
0.5440499782562256,
-0.7398033142089844,
-0.05287861078977585,
0.13353723287582397,
-0.3866803050041199,
-0.37932708859443665,
-0.18876871466636658,
0.26069870591163635,
0.07800523936748505,
-0.6450148820877075,
0.4114953875541687,
-0.41550207138061523,
-0.6101780533790588,
0.618007242679596,
-0.4195895195007324,
0.4150891900062561,
0.22854185104370117,
-0.27037864923477173,
0.15792949497699738,
-0.7471439242362976,
0.11789976060390472,
0.015403565019369125,
-0.16615034639835358,
-0.4373319745063782,
-0.1845548450946808,
0.042617134749889374,
0.10272771865129471,
0.4162188470363617,
-0.556301474571228,
0.08717469871044159,
-0.47997376322746277,
0.5541017651557922,
0.8500651717185974,
0.22677667438983917,
0.30534785985946655,
-0.4528931677341461,
0.6550388336181641,
0.06637517362833023,
0.3495812714099884,
-0.19432489573955536,
0.0554688535630703,
-0.6717018485069275,
-0.2780030369758606,
0.5930833220481873,
0.5431631207466125,
-0.6162140369415283,
0.42484214901924133,
-0.1548246294260025,
-0.40358397364616394,
-0.3716357350349426,
0.09188947826623917,
0.3210209012031555,
0.42320364713668823,
0.11210761219263077,
-0.11746802926063538,
-0.4607183039188385,
-1.1526739597320557,
0.16483564674854279,
-0.054702628403902054,
-0.20998258888721466,
0.2698000371456146,
0.4441460072994232,
0.01449869479984045,
1.1265209913253784,
-0.7298074960708618,
0.12914226949214935,
-0.07254162430763245,
0.057776372879743576,
0.15438519418239594,
0.2959175705909729,
0.4363377094268799,
-0.8547879457473755,
-0.02032408118247986,
-0.4405364394187927,
-0.6221020817756653,
0.14251205325126648,
-0.6275794506072998,
-0.34670886397361755,
-0.20445317029953003,
0.3123050630092621,
-0.3225633203983307,
0.27905911207199097,
0.06004529073834419,
-0.3832492530345917,
0.5540273785591125,
-0.22806163132190704,
0.09293657541275024,
-1.1241278648376465,
0.3452712893486023,
-0.14637218415737152,
-0.11654941737651825,
-0.2486836463212967,
0.1086956188082695,
0.2937079071998596,
-0.5389348864555359,
-0.23373179137706757,
0.8502148985862732,
-0.3308258652687073,
-0.44482728838920593,
-0.15263792872428894,
0.6651312708854675,
0.25153571367263794,
0.45010292530059814,
-0.24706339836120605,
1.0709234476089478,
0.5827590227127075,
-0.5999308228492737,
0.4997299313545227,
0.4701648950576782,
-0.3811769485473633,
0.5876817107200623,
-0.46149399876594543,
0.05703805014491081,
-0.015319542959332466,
0.4660435616970062,
-0.7095046043395996,
-0.11249924451112747,
0.08637313544750214,
-0.10656078904867172,
0.22773008048534393,
0.3816865086555481,
-0.2551291286945343,
-0.616893470287323,
-0.5377004742622375,
0.30343663692474365,
0.20298680663108826,
-0.5301460027694702,
0.400075227022171,
0.33324331045150757,
-0.35499241948127747,
-0.7405275702476501,
-0.2854657769203186,
0.14714565873146057,
-0.09057474881410599,
-0.7696238160133362,
0.06277146935462952,
-0.0015692083397880197,
-0.4861851632595062,
-0.14161095023155212,
-0.39692598581314087,
-0.005117376800626516,
0.3603571057319641,
0.14216825366020203,
0.8674237728118896,
-0.09005633741617203,
0.4222145974636078,
0.2806956171989441,
-0.07709172368049622,
0.10796299576759338,
-0.383513480424881,
0.18194764852523804,
-0.3563178777694702,
-0.460733562707901,
-0.2898138165473938,
0.15712277591228485,
0.38535037636756897,
-0.39216360449790955,
0.24011237919330597,
0.08681658655405045,
-0.1508801430463791,
-0.4955151081085205,
-0.41217970848083496,
-0.14597727358341217,
-0.5010306239128113,
0.06998758763074875,
-0.34338831901550293,
-0.9516951441764832,
0.655497133731842,
-0.19822019338607788,
0.34865906834602356,
0.5837621688842773,
0.48487967252731323,
-0.23894600570201874,
0.35011574625968933,
0.48390862345695496,
0.011433816514909267,
0.3689679205417633,
-0.4280520975589752,
0.2890988886356354,
-0.5401212573051453,
-0.09235305339097977,
-0.5897250771522522,
-0.38830405473709106,
-0.4064454138278961,
-0.3869270384311676,
0.539659857749939,
0.2038591355085373,
-0.14314937591552734,
0.31445932388305664,
-0.34467029571533203,
0.5299426913261414,
0.5361488461494446,
0.11766255646944046,
0.16250348091125488,
-0.31620681285858154,
-0.16846294701099396,
0.5356271266937256,
-0.569682776927948,
-0.6680953502655029,
1.4723306894302368,
0.3989388346672058,
0.6451430916786194,
-0.1906457096338272,
0.6698212623596191,
0.5130572319030762,
0.41243234276771545,
-0.4719858467578888,
0.3279160261154175,
0.2178298830986023,
-0.5693495273590088,
-0.5355898141860962,
-0.5503952503204346,
-0.5533232688903809,
-0.1290827840566635,
-0.014136414974927902,
-0.3033256530761719,
0.5116294622421265,
-0.12058880180120468,
-1.0217583179473877,
-0.15534308552742004,
-0.5207027196884155,
0.627599835395813,
-0.1683655083179474,
-0.30284255743026733,
-0.09736328572034836,
-0.5712058544158936,
0.6768172979354858,
-0.6598746180534363,
0.058750949800014496,
-0.06475938856601715,
-0.07513231039047241,
0.7610158920288086,
-0.5305172204971313,
0.6105358004570007,
-0.01365248765796423,
-0.31409189105033875,
0.8492293953895569,
-0.06311443448066711,
0.6035985350608826,
0.6409875154495239,
-0.07980617880821228,
-0.21970494091510773,
0.5458686947822571,
-0.5196830630302429,
-0.7258319854736328,
0.4394632875919342,
-0.4017806053161621,
-0.39014995098114014,
-0.47387823462486267,
-0.4573870599269867,
-0.6211239099502563,
-0.13146984577178955,
-0.16478440165519714,
0.5122221112251282,
-0.43373903632164,
0.1214146614074707,
0.42442676424980164,
-0.27415701746940613,
0.22212207317352295,
0.5796924233436584,
-0.17176072299480438,
-0.4596996009349823,
0.8029193878173828,
-0.1334279328584671,
0.011620649136602879,
0.23269325494766235,
-0.07126296311616898,
-0.7137718200683594,
-0.29653751850128174,
-0.4670485854148865,
0.1964080035686493,
-0.6755061745643616,
-0.3654543459415436,
-0.27486756443977356,
-0.1852657049894333,
-0.42706629633903503,
-0.26169756054878235,
-0.14449091255664825,
-0.6388556361198425,
-0.2422647476196289,
-0.3764975666999817,
0.2244020402431488,
0.3722674250602722,
-0.10124454647302628,
-0.07658863812685013,
-1.2237412929534912,
0.368627667427063,
0.3814897835254669,
0.32981041073799133,
-0.1485336720943451,
-0.265028715133667,
-0.39142897725105286,
-0.020369738340377808,
-0.27653852105140686,
-0.6016079187393188,
0.1663815975189209,
-0.04470760375261307,
0.24669435620307922,
0.49001622200012207,
0.30141666531562805,
0.497086763381958,
0.20390044152736664,
0.5166028738021851,
-0.04639711230993271,
-0.8114348649978638,
0.48680436611175537,
-0.28417831659317017,
0.18162986636161804,
0.9625682234764099,
0.17238101363182068,
-0.4684627056121826,
-0.7281745672225952,
-0.8697913885116577,
-0.7344977855682373,
0.48780444264411926,
0.24544593691825867,
0.15347324311733246,
-0.28473544120788574,
0.5182666182518005,
0.12944994866847992,
0.4376872181892395,
0.01797124370932579,
0.18486957252025604,
-0.08153099566698074,
-0.05846383050084114,
0.3142803907394409,
-0.25159981846809387,
-0.28133490681648254,
0.1082773506641388,
0.8144501447677612,
-0.43487849831581116,
0.02861611731350422,
0.29372233152389526,
0.16812613606452942,
-0.042620230466127396,
0.4752754867076874,
0.47750744223594666,
1.2199158668518066,
-0.4931929111480713,
-0.2710389494895935,
0.1790325790643692,
-0.270401269197464,
0.1555478721857071,
0.12709490954875946,
-0.3905528783798218,
-0.08505722135305405,
0.1017620787024498,
0.5212346911430359,
0.4301941990852356,
-1.2582719326019287,
0.5450221300125122,
-0.2237386703491211,
-0.16560272872447968,
-0.6387255787849426,
0.04622317850589752,
0.05519572272896767,
0.4096168279647827,
0.6741986274719238,
-0.12384103238582611,
0.08266294002532959,
-0.6788065433502197,
0.6924851536750793,
0.12483837455511093,
-0.1800633668899536,
0.04068685695528984,
0.3804439902305603,
0.3806765079498291,
0.19736921787261963,
1.0767779350280762,
-0.09744123369455338,
-0.3404097557067871,
0.9584543108940125,
0.1652754247188568,
0.9878451824188232,
0.2597680985927582,
0.3954143524169922,
0.3636396527290344,
-0.014915852807462215,
-0.11966384947299957,
0.7403057217597961,
-0.23571692407131195,
-0.48297739028930664,
-0.31275874376296997,
-1.0632522106170654,
-0.7361528277397156,
-0.02643497660756111,
-0.6163333058357239,
0.3235117197036743,
-0.7000212073326111,
-0.24936842918395996,
-0.18660809099674225,
0.08578519523143768,
-0.5367471575737,
0.2939450442790985,
-0.053421635180711746,
1.2899315357208252,
-0.36018437147140503,
0.49635446071624756,
0.0992744117975235,
-0.5648482441902161,
-0.7584300637245178,
-0.20889708399772644,
-0.2795948386192322,
-0.4938111901283264,
0.5893548130989075,
-0.19417546689510345,
0.1797184944152832,
-0.21739722788333893,
-0.4135908782482147,
-0.8204346895217896,
1.2919728755950928,
0.3351709544658661,
-1.002579927444458,
-0.3439916670322418,
0.1258065104484558,
0.5823661684989929,
-0.2837587296962738,
0.10066485404968262,
0.6925471425056458,
0.6032367944717407,
0.3156391382217407,
-0.5269085764884949,
-0.07022161036729813,
-0.1560848355293274,
-0.22540229558944702,
0.30750033259391785,
-0.8587386608123779,
0.441284716129303,
-0.2502175271511078,
-0.37428852915763855,
-0.05537211149930954,
0.9179216623306274,
0.5464491248130798,
0.5512943267822266,
0.2746078073978424,
0.32303759455680847,
0.9930729866027832,
-0.17397785186767578,
1.1052829027175903,
-0.7785903215408325,
0.3360178470611572,
1.266852855682373,
-0.3800400495529175,
0.8712275624275208,
0.26674413681030273,
-0.21891038119792938,
0.04167669266462326,
0.8868553638458252,
-0.3285798728466034,
0.0028909004759043455,
0.5534891486167908,
-0.38758033514022827,
-0.410081684589386,
0.012286147102713585,
-0.16118581593036652,
0.5153399705886841,
0.15158545970916748,
-0.31354373693466187,
-0.34584060311317444,
-0.06026586517691612,
-0.4369373619556427,
-0.023336967453360558,
-0.0985286608338356,
0.5894186496734619,
0.313922643661499,
-0.3916463851928711,
0.09288959950208664,
0.15141813457012177,
0.2641725242137909,
-0.8227623105049133,
0.09426376968622208,
-0.5326268672943115,
-0.22599086165428162,
0.08071102946996689,
-0.5262961983680725,
0.45485228300094604,
0.23216283321380615,
-0.010790728032588959,
-0.12843821942806244,
0.7052201628684998,
-0.08825093507766724,
-0.6597816944122314,
-0.05909385904669762,
0.5711100101470947,
0.06663225591182709,
-0.12809422612190247,
-0.6626788973808289,
-0.37271636724472046,
-0.14419512450695038,
-0.40959274768829346,
0.33624619245529175,
0.4658059775829315,
-0.2959749400615692,
0.8391115665435791,
0.9859611988067627,
-0.11069948971271515,
-0.16938416659832,
0.1084853857755661,
1.0831100940704346,
-0.877733588218689,
-0.6440365314483643,
-0.39415448904037476,
0.10488186031579971,
-0.07760708779096603,
-0.3389173150062561,
0.36120331287384033,
1.0777931213378906,
0.6252158284187317,
0.08600705862045288,
0.800416886806488,
0.17380841076374054,
0.551315426826477,
-0.5513594150543213,
0.6431971788406372,
-0.32063767313957214,
0.5703495740890503,
-0.002663787454366684,
-0.9625606536865234,
0.06673567742109299,
0.03543058782815933,
-0.26661214232444763,
-0.2875215411186218,
0.6808058619499207,
0.6665586829185486,
0.09240356832742691,
0.3717508614063263,
0.21373718976974487,
-0.046733275055885315,
0.2852075695991516,
0.3997630476951599,
0.7633618116378784,
-0.5272334814071655,
0.6297416090965271,
-0.1804221272468567,
-0.05625149607658386,
0.07188615947961807,
-0.5195870399475098,
-0.4266780614852905,
-0.48852360248565674,
-0.27970239520072937,
-0.2348528802394867,
-0.010367833077907562,
0.964040994644165,
0.05245967581868172,
-0.7766287922859192,
-0.22044816613197327,
0.2842206358909607,
0.05790457874536514,
-0.11743153631687164,
-0.24683652818202972,
0.6059796214103699,
-0.5503564476966858,
-0.6416800022125244,
0.6693839430809021,
0.6054763197898865,
0.07534909248352051,
-0.6070825457572937,
0.16898629069328308,
0.0661487951874733,
0.5448010563850403,
0.3082970678806305,
0.3102642297744751,
-0.022515462711453438,
-0.3298257887363434,
0.09855034202337265,
-0.3365888297557831,
-0.12240274995565414,
0.8774631023406982,
-0.6695473790168762,
0.1919834166765213,
0.5358889102935791,
0.897431492805481,
0.4075755774974823,
0.379200279712677,
0.6529853940010071,
-0.4180873930454254,
-0.2777855396270752,
0.405330091714859,
0.20138698816299438,
-0.16307775676250458,
-0.3463682532310486,
0.6006191968917847,
0.1790282428264618,
-0.3247332274913788,
-0.6618297696113586,
-0.23214198648929596,
-1.0673928260803223,
-0.37490710616111755,
0.7541859745979309,
-0.08323200792074203,
-0.6499725580215454,
-0.06121658533811569,
-0.12370757758617401,
0.0750986635684967,
-0.6092274188995361,
1.0133318901062012,
0.6917423605918884,
0.021265489980578423,
0.3010270893573761,
-0.44872480630874634,
0.6006113886833191,
0.1294572651386261,
-0.968191385269165,
0.3254360556602478,
0.6874427795410156,
0.28306838870048523,
0.15055719017982483,
0.8215882778167725,
-0.14999505877494812,
0.6003418564796448,
0.19122348725795746,
-0.07513991743326187,
-0.15804842114448547,
-0.3471842110157013,
-0.10373388230800629,
0.4916853904724121,
-0.2106418013572693,
0.02357853576540947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14393v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14393v1 | Jailbreaking as a Reward Misspecification Problem | 2024-06-20T15:12:27 | 2024-06-20T15:12:27 | Zhihui Xie, Jiahui Gao, Lei Li, Zhenguo Li, Qi Liu, Lingpeng Kong | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs) has raised concerns
about their safety and reliability, particularly regarding their vulnerability
to adversarial attacks. In this paper, we propose a novel perspective that
attributes this vulnerability to reward misspecification during the alignment
process. We introduce a metric ReGap to quantify the extent of reward
misspecification and demonstrate its effectiveness and robustness in detecting
harmful backdoor prompts. Building upon these insights, we present ReMiss, a
system for automated red teaming that generates adversarial prompts against
various target aligned LLMs. ReMiss achieves state-of-the-art attack success
rates on the AdvBench benchmark while preserving the human readability of the
generated prompts. Detailed analysis highlights the unique advantages brought
by the proposed reward misspecification objective compared to previous methods. | [
-0.12477432936429977,
-0.43225333094596863,
0.5035387277603149,
0.26175591349601746,
0.1749405562877655,
0.4223012328147888,
-0.07094959169626236,
-0.21459336578845978,
0.5043017268180847,
0.3399967849254608,
-0.9383510947227478,
-0.4029029905796051,
-0.8186075687408447,
0.0684981495141983,
-0.24165497720241547,
1.1317744255065918,
-0.2898983359336853,
-0.47459158301353455,
0.044902775436639786,
-0.23196417093276978,
-1.0193275213241577,
-0.49914342164993286,
-0.2668750584125519,
-0.048055388033390045,
0.8622429370880127,
0.5831252932548523,
0.6797988414764404,
0.6347855925559998,
0.5850838422775269,
0.2891313135623932,
0.17707028985023499,
0.16851752996444702,
-0.35008740425109863,
0.28410768508911133,
-0.18287429213523865,
-0.6455488801002502,
-0.18025706708431244,
0.4715554118156433,
0.21690598130226135,
0.26828739047050476,
-0.30481088161468506,
0.06895577907562256,
-0.11818872392177582,
0.7662444114685059,
-1.055277705192566,
-0.38944685459136963,
-0.6673209071159363,
0.09941444545984268,
-0.22244787216186523,
-0.1710592806339264,
-0.5899508595466614,
-0.605015754699707,
-0.3057520091533661,
-0.4038296937942505,
-0.029978429898619652,
0.07565175741910934,
0.870241105556488,
0.639980137348175,
0.15934713184833527,
-0.21147635579109192,
-0.15693476796150208,
0.683839738368988,
-0.43044987320899963,
0.17021994292736053,
0.43039369583129883,
0.5080143809318542,
-0.4582550525665283,
-0.33803829550743103,
-0.18163107335567474,
-0.3288734257221222,
-0.1543952077627182,
-0.26827624440193176,
-0.3274712860584259,
-0.30063849687576294,
0.17518910765647888,
0.22272370755672455,
-0.57261061668396,
0.3878513276576996,
-0.13634511828422546,
-0.154422789812088,
0.6100802421569824,
0.42548447847366333,
0.551294207572937,
-0.05066249147057533,
-0.4970604181289673,
-0.23188860714435577,
-0.9126031994819641,
0.15672017633914948,
0.6318906545639038,
0.345176100730896,
-0.33605271577835083,
0.6310793161392212,
0.2773038148880005,
0.7322494387626648,
-0.0449942871928215,
0.10323424637317657,
0.27785512804985046,
-0.24115777015686035,
-0.06967420130968094,
-0.1329660713672638,
0.735260546207428,
0.3202204704284668,
0.3017999529838562,
-0.5264075994491577,
-0.3586117923259735,
0.014758710749447346,
0.6650391221046448,
-0.3138323426246643,
-0.25351405143737793,
0.39262375235557556,
-0.23858307301998138,
-0.6849530935287476,
0.15276746451854706,
-0.6322539448738098,
-0.7356330156326294,
0.3399590849876404,
0.0913051962852478,
-0.43768802285194397,
0.03740266337990761,
-0.1865547001361847,
-0.5113396644592285,
-0.02215743623673916,
0.22497203946113586,
-1.002220869064331,
-0.12806832790374756,
0.8128252625465393,
1.0357874631881714,
-0.1556404083967209,
-0.6618387699127197,
-0.837440550327301,
0.1060267761349678,
-0.31484901905059814,
0.6421599388122559,
-0.16136395931243896,
-0.25508803129196167,
-0.22906023263931274,
0.00830075703561306,
-0.13390830159187317,
-0.5211319923400879,
0.40308061242103577,
-0.5507835149765015,
-0.1019740030169487,
0.00010134429612662643,
-0.34490644931793213,
0.277248740196228,
0.5562410950660706,
-0.765048086643219,
0.24033299088478088,
0.2138722687959671,
-0.6452043652534485,
0.6278907060623169,
-0.33962327241897583,
-0.4434368312358856,
0.0993644967675209,
-0.04844257980585098,
-0.4736422300338745,
0.04294653981924057,
0.16433757543563843,
0.14435572922229767,
-0.13071490824222565,
0.32209041714668274,
-0.22040648758411407,
-0.36076992750167847,
0.43507376313209534,
-0.3442576229572296,
0.7133795619010925,
0.2454545795917511,
-0.41385263204574585,
0.3831034004688263,
-0.26270875334739685,
0.030596012249588966,
0.22625136375427246,
-0.46441739797592163,
-0.33832988142967224,
-0.03725460171699524,
-0.3025403618812561,
0.04890085756778717,
0.3161182701587677,
-0.6179440021514893,
0.34662607312202454,
-0.436310738325119,
0.3770061731338501,
1.0162353515625,
-0.13848935067653656,
0.23841224610805511,
-0.36166542768478394,
0.5555567145347595,
-0.08074856549501419,
0.15892687439918518,
-0.20689985156059265,
-0.21804139018058777,
-0.20034049451351166,
-0.7000551819801331,
0.47329071164131165,
1.017910361289978,
-0.3578138053417206,
0.707085907459259,
-0.0018025782192125916,
-0.7535882592201233,
-0.6934309601783752,
0.22446919977664948,
0.714480459690094,
0.014119323343038559,
0.28486987948417664,
-0.06220663711428642,
-0.5915943384170532,
-1.0481311082839966,
-0.6645430326461792,
-0.18104520440101624,
-0.1022714376449585,
0.2854177951812744,
0.5969460010528564,
-0.2832290530204773,
0.7086736559867859,
-0.5422332286834717,
-0.37405702471733093,
-0.27834081649780273,
0.20304523408412933,
0.1775975525379181,
0.6835684776306152,
0.43669968843460083,
-0.5956717729568481,
-0.08593422919511795,
-0.5755714774131775,
-0.8550799489021301,
-0.18638068437576294,
-0.3034607470035553,
0.25082600116729736,
0.14806552231311798,
0.6049908995628357,
-0.3668024241924286,
0.458589106798172,
0.6527923941612244,
-0.7103040814399719,
0.6999195218086243,
-0.062352538108825684,
0.34924280643463135,
-0.803162693977356,
0.0654461681842804,
-0.07615545392036438,
-0.32541072368621826,
-0.2522527575492859,
0.31024041771888733,
0.23425309360027313,
-0.10938481986522675,
-0.5389990210533142,
0.284645676612854,
-0.3560444116592407,
0.009846465662121773,
-0.27522650361061096,
0.29050955176353455,
-0.2298625409603119,
0.21684184670448303,
-0.2665729224681854,
0.915879487991333,
0.06677693873643875,
-0.3184565305709839,
0.7542319893836975,
0.32225924730300903,
-0.35329243540763855,
0.4185100197792053,
-0.7329140901565552,
-0.1269983947277069,
0.26923054456710815,
0.24709299206733704,
-0.9496432542800903,
-0.11135855317115784,
0.40694454312324524,
-0.7825330495834351,
0.359447181224823,
-0.1536291390657425,
-0.45548349618911743,
-0.28372088074684143,
-0.4576123058795929,
0.5806921720504761,
0.23525112867355347,
-0.727472186088562,
0.12064484506845474,
0.5781233310699463,
-0.011968930251896381,
-0.9161854386329651,
-0.7331993579864502,
0.36723533272743225,
-0.42119383811950684,
-0.8029147386550903,
0.2647704780101776,
0.37229329347610474,
-0.2210770696401596,
-0.10366487503051758,
0.18558058142662048,
0.3088803291320801,
0.6588555574417114,
0.6108788251876831,
0.35685470700263977,
0.047538917511701584,
-0.2798931896686554,
-0.37359628081321716,
-0.26978880167007446,
0.14937223494052887,
0.08714672178030014,
0.4466204047203064,
-0.08108481019735336,
-0.4106023907661438,
-0.5539408922195435,
0.43651634454727173,
0.5817774534225464,
-0.10123196244239807,
1.079354166984558,
-0.029472578316926956,
-0.19338876008987427,
-0.10774869471788406,
-0.45393896102905273,
-0.1753958910703659,
-0.47806113958358765,
0.1487025022506714,
-0.2676891088485718,
-0.9266862869262695,
0.6182397603988647,
0.04825017973780632,
0.29830193519592285,
0.12041180580854416,
0.3781629800796509,
0.10560622066259384,
0.772918164730072,
0.6141642332077026,
-0.4435582160949707,
0.49198654294013977,
0.22151599824428558,
0.12303121387958527,
-0.7630878686904907,
-0.32297319173812866,
-0.5785428285598755,
-0.5234222412109375,
-0.36459797620773315,
-0.0891253873705864,
0.0793473869562149,
-0.027493275701999664,
-0.3301486670970917,
0.6401320099830627,
-0.36125293374061584,
0.5845822095870972,
0.6258833408355713,
-0.029113925993442535,
-0.09387155622243881,
-0.3584757149219513,
-0.03833342716097832,
-0.269596666097641,
-0.5487439632415771,
-0.3972300887107849,
0.9336581230163574,
0.4866417348384857,
1.0802642107009888,
0.47456881403923035,
0.9228827953338623,
0.7072849869728088,
0.34451451897621155,
-0.4738604724407196,
0.2516011893749237,
0.028768859803676605,
-0.44134408235549927,
-0.34813323616981506,
-0.40572330355644226,
-1.055075764656067,
-0.001417974941432476,
-0.03077131323516369,
-1.059607982635498,
0.19967499375343323,
0.14909499883651733,
-0.613591730594635,
0.4287664294242859,
-0.7838221788406372,
1.2272549867630005,
-0.20975589752197266,
-0.20180732011795044,
-0.04606526345014572,
-0.8201045989990234,
0.6435408592224121,
-0.03402647748589516,
0.2772018313407898,
-0.07436874508857727,
0.05672477185726166,
0.8393141031265259,
-0.6559816598892212,
0.9016203880310059,
-0.25775229930877686,
-0.0933951810002327,
-0.1290806531906128,
0.3967629373073578,
0.829041600227356,
-0.0020762397907674313,
0.2968745827674866,
-0.05834557116031647,
-0.41381892561912537,
-0.3286351263523102,
-0.6253017783164978,
0.7190362215042114,
-0.5656073689460754,
-0.9924890995025635,
-0.43939563632011414,
-0.743683934211731,
-0.10573529452085495,
-0.17772532999515533,
0.18796266615390778,
-0.19608289003372192,
-0.10258342325687408,
-0.22268038988113403,
0.4221158027648926,
-0.6174354553222656,
0.23141999542713165,
0.45942753553390503,
0.11350785195827484,
-0.40065309405326843,
0.9084898829460144,
-0.3424661159515381,
0.4205537438392639,
0.12411981076002121,
-0.16299612820148468,
-0.07230529934167862,
-0.37649983167648315,
-0.5932677984237671,
0.2850947976112366,
-0.46197518706321716,
-0.6026231646537781,
-0.3540414571762085,
-0.08640953153371811,
-0.5104330778121948,
-0.717584490776062,
-0.5459344983100891,
-0.3368145823478699,
-0.05222993716597557,
-0.19239558279514313,
0.2796182632446289,
0.5863790512084961,
-0.5983657240867615,
0.2637253999710083,
-0.9835683703422546,
0.21692389249801636,
0.11877048015594482,
0.10020845383405685,
-0.14545786380767822,
-0.7277501225471497,
-0.36228373646736145,
-0.19031167030334473,
-0.15572498738765717,
-1.1364009380340576,
0.5845893025398254,
-0.43888798356056213,
0.5764663815498352,
0.06447234749794006,
0.06041698530316353,
0.5528361201286316,
-0.5089498162269592,
0.7883203625679016,
0.34957969188690186,
-0.9465083479881287,
0.9243227243423462,
-0.05494365096092224,
-0.10163076967000961,
0.581007719039917,
-0.049271486699581146,
-0.7139219045639038,
-0.8186219930648804,
-0.7448137998580933,
-1.0814136266708374,
0.7548966407775879,
-0.003433561883866787,
-0.22969628870487213,
-0.04029563441872597,
0.20194073021411896,
-0.20170019567012787,
0.1600312888622284,
-0.5864945650100708,
-0.3267785310745239,
-0.0049791233614087105,
-0.1703968197107315,
-0.12664800882339478,
-0.27823424339294434,
-0.3868120014667511,
0.3709554076194763,
0.5127183794975281,
0.34316369891166687,
0.042672257870435715,
0.012303725816309452,
-0.34713974595069885,
-0.15504729747772217,
0.4637098014354706,
0.7938817143440247,
0.24363474547863007,
-0.3093707859516144,
0.09658887982368469,
-0.07749640196561813,
-0.3045109510421753,
0.6022406220436096,
-0.11810165643692017,
0.002085872460156679,
-0.23284025490283966,
0.5562911033630371,
0.5145381689071655,
0.1138293445110321,
-0.935370683670044,
0.805031418800354,
-0.13371425867080688,
-0.012959124520421028,
-0.20231708884239197,
0.21472294628620148,
-0.2871156930923462,
0.36799269914627075,
0.26456180214881897,
0.10546344518661499,
-0.26722878217697144,
-0.46046847105026245,
0.509587824344635,
0.6147279143333435,
-0.41362664103507996,
0.058218758553266525,
0.7302531599998474,
0.22960247099399567,
-0.5157365202903748,
0.787011444568634,
-0.1620347499847412,
-0.7621863484382629,
0.7659292221069336,
0.51611328125,
0.9555757641792297,
-0.23630103468894958,
0.13690464198589325,
0.1086941659450531,
0.9003362059593201,
-0.1071663424372673,
-0.1367846578359604,
0.20129194855690002,
-0.7346130609512329,
-0.22072704136371613,
-0.20614077150821686,
-0.24665530025959015,
-0.10702919214963913,
-0.5926815867424011,
0.12157061696052551,
-0.5993583798408508,
-0.058773238211870193,
-0.030440906062722206,
-0.562950849533081,
-0.09079118818044662,
-0.04545949399471283,
0.11940207332372665,
1.1022107601165771,
-1.1095525026321411,
0.40359336137771606,
0.4104662835597992,
-0.39210045337677,
-0.8214316368103027,
-0.056181639432907104,
0.36040106415748596,
-0.9217797517776489,
1.0637983083724976,
0.18831564486026764,
-0.12001755088567734,
-0.3409275412559509,
-0.4902261793613434,
-0.6073772311210632,
0.8588031530380249,
0.37013599276542664,
-0.4704381823539734,
-0.006842726841568947,
-0.23906131088733673,
-0.05997089669108391,
-0.39265012741088867,
-0.28456732630729675,
0.8864652514457703,
0.4795316159725189,
-0.14954249560832977,
-0.8634013533592224,
0.5004071593284607,
-0.069844089448452,
-0.44579052925109863,
0.6154472827911377,
-0.30507346987724304,
0.7945463061332703,
-0.7368150949478149,
-0.22581270337104797,
0.21999123692512512,
0.471474289894104,
0.8265196681022644,
0.17224623262882233,
0.5275686979293823,
0.9644909501075745,
0.7096102237701416,
-0.18877491354942322,
1.1348741054534912,
0.07740375399589539,
0.1458735167980194,
1.0643041133880615,
-0.028117259964346886,
0.5533645749092102,
0.7384567856788635,
-0.07879985123872757,
0.5163129568099976,
0.5598939657211304,
-0.21398437023162842,
0.7830947041511536,
0.578335702419281,
0.00017637424753047526,
-0.25198429822921753,
0.14072316884994507,
-0.36160701513290405,
0.06690285354852676,
0.4046052396297455,
-0.4701303541660309,
-0.25978517532348633,
0.06821531057357788,
0.1457432508468628,
0.12116143852472305,
-0.31243616342544556,
0.6357346177101135,
-0.0808912143111229,
-0.7807708382606506,
0.6238413453102112,
0.2280733287334442,
0.8469927906990051,
-0.5564841628074646,
0.07816208899021149,
-0.1554781049489975,
0.1833544671535492,
-0.31407037377357483,
-0.8899176120758057,
0.4123333990573883,
0.32311034202575684,
-0.26116693019866943,
-0.0892445296049118,
0.3287818431854248,
-0.04913654178380966,
0.11327370256185532,
0.20365530252456665,
0.32974740862846375,
0.1757964938879013,
-0.09858284145593643,
-0.7428827285766602,
0.12542039155960083,
0.1692539006471634,
-0.06714224070310593,
0.37067747116088867,
0.24034364521503448,
0.021478233858942986,
0.9710218906402588,
0.5588945150375366,
0.17001016438007355,
0.02334170788526535,
-0.12433915585279465,
0.7764050364494324,
-0.9200853705406189,
-0.669253408908844,
-1.3442819118499756,
0.4742416739463806,
-0.02862446941435337,
-0.24211528897285461,
0.8434743881225586,
0.5899785757064819,
0.49274659156799316,
0.05750333517789841,
0.7672178745269775,
-0.11479668319225311,
0.5010609030723572,
-0.5117889642715454,
0.7595944404602051,
-0.5241106748580933,
0.5651028752326965,
-0.369577020406723,
-0.1971578598022461,
-0.3541087806224823,
0.49722814559936523,
-0.39108455181121826,
-0.36118295788764954,
0.5688764452934265,
0.8260079622268677,
0.3074486255645752,
-0.15283451974391937,
0.16114479303359985,
-0.1445992887020111,
0.38149958848953247,
0.9025890231132507,
1.0769108533859253,
-0.2675076127052307,
0.4378710687160492,
0.33590808510780334,
-0.42474013566970825,
-0.32351410388946533,
-0.6068954467773438,
-0.6461557149887085,
-0.26771315932273865,
-0.2429616004228592,
-0.767683744430542,
0.34518691897392273,
0.6727767586708069,
0.3295799195766449,
-0.8300226330757141,
-0.07653118669986725,
0.008769204840064049,
0.6303361058235168,
-0.2509305477142334,
-0.20456233620643616,
0.15520603954792023,
-0.6130368709564209,
-0.21507412195205688,
0.7019869089126587,
0.2828564941883087,
0.0774654895067215,
-0.2631984353065491,
-0.10611212253570557,
-0.13171051442623138,
-0.1452484279870987,
-0.09503122419118881,
0.6872367262840271,
-0.6560309529304504,
-0.36513563990592957,
-0.2434762865304947,
-0.3658931255340576,
-0.20152930915355682,
1.0150548219680786,
-0.80759197473526,
-0.12196489423513412,
0.17507678270339966,
0.9456648230552673,
-0.2941093146800995,
0.20831504464149475,
0.9606519937515259,
-1.0543736219406128,
0.24674496054649353,
0.1546686738729477,
0.4380369782447815,
0.30839499831199646,
-0.45743298530578613,
0.5122443437576294,
0.31921592354774475,
-0.6703614592552185,
-1.1992671489715576,
0.505346417427063,
-0.47361674904823303,
-0.5102934241294861,
0.8746165633201599,
-0.5168691873550415,
-0.4858431816101074,
-0.1325559914112091,
0.15538527071475983,
-0.0017073344206437469,
-0.5710174441337585,
0.9605428576469421,
0.6275890469551086,
0.17254729568958282,
-0.03859556093811989,
-0.10270616412162781,
0.5538622140884399,
0.5235399603843689,
-0.667263925075531,
0.5738335251808167,
0.588618814945221,
0.22326849400997162,
0.4090830385684967,
0.18366800248622894,
-0.09242810308933258,
0.6300782561302185,
0.06861163675785065,
-0.004549204371869564,
-0.39396345615386963,
-0.37751534581184387,
-0.38131430745124817,
0.30486106872558594,
0.06818271428346634,
-0.5766053795814514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14373v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14373v2 | Artificial Leviathan: Exploring Social Evolution of LLM Agents Through the Lens of Hobbesian Social Contract Theory | 2024-06-20T14:42:58 | 2024-07-01T22:06:13 | Gordon Dai, Weijia Zhang, Jinhan Li, Siqi Yang, Chidera Onochie lbe, Srihas Rao, Arthur Caetano, Misha Sra | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.MA | The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) and advancements in Artificial
Intelligence (AI) offer an opportunity for computational social science
research at scale. Building upon prior explorations of LLM agent design, our
work introduces a simulated agent society where complex social relationships
dynamically form and evolve over time. Agents are imbued with psychological
drives and placed in a sandbox survival environment. We conduct an evaluation
of the agent society through the lens of Thomas Hobbes's seminal Social
Contract Theory (SCT). We analyze whether, as the theory postulates, agents
seek to escape a brutish "state of nature" by surrendering rights to an
absolute sovereign in exchange for order and security. Our experiments unveil
an alignment: Initially, agents engage in unrestrained conflict, mirroring
Hobbes's depiction of the state of nature. However, as the simulation
progresses, social contracts emerge, leading to the authorization of an
absolute sovereign and the establishment of a peaceful commonwealth founded on
mutual cooperation. This congruence between our LLM agent society's
evolutionary trajectory and Hobbes's theoretical account indicates LLMs'
capability to model intricate social dynamics and potentially replicate forces
that shape human societies. By enabling such insights into group behavior and
emergent societal phenomena, LLM-driven multi-agent simulations, while unable
to simulate all the nuances of human behavior, may hold potential for advancing
our understanding of social structures, group dynamics, and complex human
systems. | [
-0.49595803022384644,
-0.8892123103141785,
0.5320647358894348,
-0.1480184644460678,
-0.03253590688109398,
0.7882115840911865,
-0.005504030734300613,
-0.4268828332424164,
0.6796810626983643,
0.5278711318969727,
-0.3247000575065613,
0.0034144597593694925,
-0.3374803364276886,
0.07811377197504044,
-0.27430856227874756,
0.9655721783638,
0.28464171290397644,
-0.1989871710538864,
-0.21990251541137695,
-0.06673242151737213,
0.3475308120250702,
-0.36604464054107666,
-0.8566128611564636,
-0.802966833114624,
0.5365297794342041,
-0.3096858263015747,
0.8827494978904724,
0.9010170102119446,
0.1926155835390091,
0.43349647521972656,
-0.4236137866973877,
0.2861541211605072,
-0.5465722680091858,
0.15414763987064362,
-0.49513348937034607,
-0.2297232449054718,
-0.33095043897628784,
0.04850979149341583,
0.5622730255126953,
0.4916425943374634,
-0.29736587405204773,
0.17840567231178284,
-0.0025846557691693306,
0.4912557601928711,
-0.24669262766838074,
0.28255537152290344,
-0.7036776542663574,
-0.06239234283566475,
-0.10209809988737106,
-0.2393886297941208,
-0.18431730568408966,
-0.472879022359848,
0.25338423252105713,
-0.5373244881629944,
-0.013141493313014507,
0.35625696182250977,
0.593227744102478,
0.39186784625053406,
-0.4818666875362396,
-0.11986187845468521,
-0.6432040333747864,
0.28626981377601624,
-0.2704995274543762,
-0.02053493820130825,
0.11396817117929459,
0.2384330779314041,
-0.5549336671829224,
-0.7243244051933289,
-0.7052850127220154,
-0.7004671096801758,
0.2719179093837738,
0.3650380074977875,
0.07312963902950287,
0.009856875985860825,
-0.017590051516890526,
0.09373168647289276,
-0.4988681972026825,
-0.008912995457649231,
-0.5706622004508972,
-0.06849908828735352,
0.740134596824646,
0.30748796463012695,
0.4491024613380432,
-0.1343308687210083,
-0.4565579295158386,
-0.059028126299381256,
-0.4518927335739136,
0.3426135182380676,
0.6127484440803528,
0.10620138794183731,
-0.4335688650608063,
0.4336363971233368,
0.3004179298877716,
0.18791213631629944,
0.1533224731683731,
0.4293175935745239,
-0.010561197996139526,
0.21849964559078217,
0.06648509949445724,
0.20591439306735992,
0.5657482147216797,
0.09011421352624893,
0.4247020483016968,
-0.3469995856285095,
-0.2215120792388916,
0.3794559836387634,
0.7283150553703308,
-0.4268011748790741,
0.075654998421669,
0.18009305000305176,
-0.4120004177093506,
-0.678685188293457,
-0.011858987621963024,
-0.7994056940078735,
-0.8953261971473694,
-0.3291406035423279,
0.19558241963386536,
-0.08916155993938446,
-0.521289587020874,
-0.008191512897610664,
-0.33283326029777527,
0.5876336097717285,
0.1284702867269516,
-0.680463969707489,
0.45824334025382996,
0.7276268005371094,
0.7107293009757996,
-0.32760319113731384,
-0.7076618671417236,
0.01008546445518732,
0.45816585421562195,
-0.4756724536418915,
0.7593666911125183,
-0.3282313644886017,
-0.5059095025062561,
0.15738460421562195,
0.07337567955255508,
0.18637020885944366,
-0.2836499810218811,
-0.26102033257484436,
-0.7868956327438354,
-0.5033992528915405,
0.0462004691362381,
-0.3322809636592865,
0.08380592614412308,
0.413690447807312,
-0.5934872627258301,
0.7253962755203247,
0.1153140664100647,
-0.22650869190692902,
-0.033981967717409134,
-1.329559564590454,
-0.29008835554122925,
0.5594584345817566,
-0.25329115986824036,
-0.04503101482987404,
0.2182132601737976,
-0.6883680820465088,
0.23781466484069824,
-0.49578857421875,
0.3467794954776764,
-0.8070120215415955,
-0.41100895404815674,
0.6349321007728577,
-0.10965251177549362,
0.9501551985740662,
0.19339455664157867,
-0.508765697479248,
-0.004430406726896763,
-0.22015416622161865,
-0.058231595903635025,
0.5051175951957703,
-0.28279444575309753,
-0.14868268370628357,
0.3229876458644867,
-0.3984926640987396,
-0.09025391191244125,
0.4734860956668854,
-0.46495190262794495,
0.2183857262134552,
-0.40037137269973755,
0.8505935072898865,
1.2594019174575806,
0.27097150683403015,
0.6511277556419373,
-0.6645593643188477,
0.39699941873550415,
-0.25102463364601135,
0.49696609377861023,
0.4821700155735016,
-0.2174779325723648,
-0.517760694026947,
0.1424793154001236,
0.07954016327857971,
0.43263065814971924,
-0.9715313911437988,
0.15282616019248962,
-0.2846488952636719,
-0.47659188508987427,
-0.34418803453445435,
-0.23710359632968903,
0.18458786606788635,
-0.49055713415145874,
0.02103116363286972,
-0.11981659382581711,
-0.2009482979774475,
-0.85004061460495,
-0.4410928785800934,
-0.43002015352249146,
0.31045106053352356,
0.259545236825943,
0.7927200794219971,
-0.6682524085044861,
1.0064445734024048,
-0.20509347319602966,
0.34856826066970825,
-0.12479470670223236,
-0.09489999711513519,
-0.06228906661272049,
0.39088350534439087,
0.41959550976753235,
-0.9345834851264954,
-0.29330727458000183,
0.43951430916786194,
-0.7913148999214172,
0.22313626110553741,
0.06226543337106705,
-0.2865345776081085,
-0.04225313663482666,
0.32226428389549255,
-0.5615822672843933,
0.4227209687232971,
0.36976057291030884,
-0.4452296793460846,
0.5408971309661865,
-0.3876977860927582,
0.009557610377669334,
-1.1490983963012695,
-0.29727908968925476,
-0.1887102723121643,
-0.006915335543453693,
-0.6301192045211792,
0.13828037679195404,
-0.17642995715141296,
0.01013442873954773,
-0.505875825881958,
0.674445390701294,
-0.4444255828857422,
-0.22236207127571106,
-0.22685402631759644,
0.34537726640701294,
-0.2733217179775238,
0.49729540944099426,
-0.5383782386779785,
0.6911760568618774,
0.3811313509941101,
-0.8298134207725525,
0.53922039270401,
0.03906608000397682,
0.03586731106042862,
0.48989781737327576,
-0.5632687211036682,
0.4243197739124298,
-0.38975805044174194,
0.10053632408380508,
-0.5718329548835754,
-0.37533873319625854,
0.0036453993525356054,
-0.4235827624797821,
0.0752071663737297,
0.20924052596092224,
-0.36457738280296326,
-0.38884058594703674,
-0.4068699777126312,
0.3725131154060364,
0.6264452934265137,
-0.23705393075942993,
1.0264523029327393,
0.7477844953536987,
-0.07747846841812134,
-0.29223883152008057,
-0.5128704309463501,
0.2330135852098465,
-0.311089426279068,
-0.38773685693740845,
0.2770674228668213,
-0.30223947763442993,
-0.8506871461868286,
0.17130011320114136,
0.0022389658261090517,
-0.01540044043213129,
0.11784081161022186,
0.41267716884613037,
0.20682461559772491,
0.039385534822940826,
-0.1840820163488388,
0.28159940242767334,
0.08538559824228287,
0.3682403862476349,
-0.3198743760585785,
0.6349723935127258,
-0.46209412813186646,
-0.10145643353462219,
-0.11141401529312134,
0.1293305605649948,
0.9527004957199097,
-0.03900657221674919,
0.6693392395973206,
0.04885387793183327,
-0.46953821182250977,
-0.4503483176231384,
-0.3542589545249939,
-0.04661048948764801,
-0.5347520112991333,
0.23061512410640717,
-0.2583872973918915,
-0.645402729511261,
0.7981885671615601,
-0.4883049428462982,
0.15750454366207123,
0.3647864758968353,
0.5155971646308899,
-0.11684214323759079,
0.4637719988822937,
0.5459277033805847,
0.2512655258178711,
0.612423837184906,
-0.48398861289024353,
-0.16022177040576935,
-0.9423961639404297,
-0.3514971435070038,
-0.24600431323051453,
-0.26991820335388184,
-0.7486410737037659,
-0.09692756086587906,
0.4836159944534302,
-0.38185980916023254,
-0.46654725074768066,
0.39600422978401184,
-0.5339126586914062,
0.7272488474845886,
0.1600191593170166,
0.2607482075691223,
-0.1423667073249817,
-0.10487673431634903,
-0.13072189688682556,
0.4500349462032318,
-0.4062783420085907,
-0.7269327640533447,
0.9228733777999878,
0.106108158826828,
0.5188198089599609,
0.3898104131221771,
0.7935657501220703,
1.028393268585205,
0.6587865948677063,
-0.35348525643348694,
0.687516450881958,
0.07626225054264069,
-0.792917788028717,
-0.4634123146533966,
-0.32974717020988464,
-1.3943589925765991,
0.36900797486305237,
-0.19150564074516296,
-0.8231812715530396,
0.2739871144294739,
-0.12669962644577026,
-0.43296951055526733,
0.21106426417827606,
-0.47290679812431335,
0.6587994694709778,
-0.21874675154685974,
-0.647598385810852,
-0.260408490896225,
-0.7283187508583069,
0.2869701087474823,
-0.07069385051727295,
0.4484071433544159,
-0.1502790004014969,
-0.15362414717674255,
0.6262267827987671,
-0.06881511211395264,
0.9394654631614685,
0.017304684966802597,
-0.22042593359947205,
0.5048373937606812,
0.34232810139656067,
0.7137073278427124,
0.08684983104467392,
-0.35667192935943604,
0.0031902864575386047,
0.25818365812301636,
-0.45829781889915466,
-0.512904942035675,
0.6968507170677185,
-1.2030868530273438,
-0.49526163935661316,
-0.3204799294471741,
-0.5600178241729736,
0.24746395647525787,
0.05750890076160431,
0.021710464730858803,
0.2646445333957672,
-0.3365539312362671,
0.15005329251289368,
0.6200634837150574,
-0.005874296184629202,
0.6779617071151733,
0.397552490234375,
-0.13258303701877594,
-0.8216007947921753,
0.7617366909980774,
0.382467120885849,
0.40467995405197144,
-0.19013765454292297,
0.3293010890483856,
-0.39352989196777344,
-0.34801074862480164,
-0.22019453346729279,
0.19180253148078918,
-0.6002910733222961,
-0.0085063511505723,
-0.38933467864990234,
-0.2267918735742569,
-0.26453036069869995,
-0.5012231469154358,
-0.2762073874473572,
0.22764098644256592,
-0.03442278131842613,
0.13347028195858002,
0.22979769110679626,
1.198420524597168,
-0.047116219997406006,
0.433417409658432,
-0.3290656805038452,
0.2746076285839081,
0.25819262862205505,
0.08574710041284561,
-0.09626626968383789,
-0.4069971740245819,
-0.2972690165042877,
0.1623506247997284,
-0.38756901025772095,
-1.1909449100494385,
0.10896045714616776,
-0.1769532859325409,
0.6894312500953674,
0.353230744600296,
0.3969714641571045,
0.5841745734214783,
-0.46044233441352844,
0.8306525349617004,
0.03233208879828453,
-0.9158552885055542,
0.09659590572118759,
-0.6513049006462097,
-0.12612777948379517,
0.12051720917224884,
-0.01976293884217739,
-0.2543589472770691,
-0.42631596326828003,
-0.9586215019226074,
-0.7066832184791565,
0.38275405764579773,
0.18285156786441803,
0.3209553360939026,
0.057965878397226334,
0.961295485496521,
-0.014164797030389309,
0.3432007431983948,
-1.0267705917358398,
-0.3033486604690552,
0.03609068691730499,
-0.1373542845249176,
-0.10943683236837387,
0.031473178416490555,
-0.3123837113380432,
-0.11596731841564178,
0.4095771610736847,
-0.1864953339099884,
0.31319329142570496,
0.2295592874288559,
0.06462469696998596,
-0.23223936557769775,
0.11849799007177353,
0.7115239500999451,
0.7223954796791077,
0.375991553068161,
0.348863810300827,
0.4080633223056793,
-0.47680360078811646,
0.6457796096801758,
-0.10699547082185745,
-0.12382988631725311,
-0.4755484461784363,
0.04426319897174835,
0.5470234751701355,
-0.07034731656312943,
-0.4087049663066864,
0.2325194925069809,
0.13835550844669342,
-0.4371679425239563,
-0.9288986921310425,
0.23712265491485596,
0.02918635867536068,
1.0300344228744507,
0.506808876991272,
0.028360450640320778,
-0.09925778955221176,
-0.7672088146209717,
0.06689208000898361,
0.6057491302490234,
-0.0693015307188034,
-0.4110700190067291,
0.691418468952179,
0.013659710995852947,
-1.1942051649093628,
-0.07954111695289612,
-0.6706789135932922,
-0.4369882643222809,
0.9727551937103271,
0.6058129072189331,
0.9824848771095276,
-0.2365243136882782,
0.3708602488040924,
-0.3368910849094391,
0.7227699756622314,
-0.12755155563354492,
0.03491782024502754,
-0.04669440910220146,
-0.7201593518257141,
-0.2116219401359558,
-0.615588903427124,
-0.6166751384735107,
0.02859608456492424,
-0.46826058626174927,
0.016221368685364723,
-0.6276271343231201,
-0.4644708037376404,
-0.11481855064630508,
0.1670985072851181,
-0.3465951383113861,
-0.38277262449264526,
0.08784107118844986,
0.5466605424880981,
-0.4319857954978943,
0.5875881314277649,
0.9594289660453796,
-0.0008601642330177128,
-0.4463488757610321,
0.21595823764801025,
-0.0736878514289856,
-0.8163994550704956,
0.32149437069892883,
0.0717281773686409,
-0.3972923755645752,
0.4460063576698303,
-0.9384130835533142,
-0.8604969382286072,
1.291372537612915,
0.6129843592643738,
-0.052314676344394684,
-0.014409298077225685,
0.028625860810279846,
0.5923013091087341,
-0.49238377809524536,
-0.2067633420228958,
0.5493572354316711,
0.6173232197761536,
-0.1645946055650711,
-0.47866204380989075,
0.05108964815735817,
-0.3719272017478943,
0.2681019902229309,
0.33175069093704224,
-0.9373921751976013,
0.889153242111206,
-0.17319205403327942,
-0.09151456505060196,
0.1535177379846573,
0.5344479084014893,
0.2834297716617584,
0.6017131805419922,
0.5075063705444336,
0.02660514973104,
0.4858074188232422,
0.12973862886428833,
0.9181784987449646,
-0.3855460584163666,
0.4663500487804413,
0.35311177372932434,
-0.6576674580574036,
0.4011744558811188,
0.49861040711402893,
-0.2439812570810318,
0.6401816606521606,
0.7745160460472107,
0.105865977704525,
0.25064828991889954,
0.7503032088279724,
-0.2442285716533661,
-0.11252041906118393,
-0.13775205612182617,
-0.0757521316409111,
0.41040173172950745,
0.35577353835105896,
0.16773393750190735,
-0.003348812460899353,
-0.022116750478744507,
-0.4499467611312866,
0.009489335119724274,
-0.38668856024742126,
0.9056205153465271,
0.10691104829311371,
-0.3633088171482086,
0.2385064661502838,
-0.42156723141670227,
0.3445582985877991,
-0.5603470802307129,
0.13910293579101562,
-0.05484149605035782,
0.04949122294783592,
0.03350910171866417,
-0.3412122428417206,
0.022988250479102135,
-0.2952236533164978,
0.024307090789079666,
-0.09879201650619507,
0.36237308382987976,
-0.11927058547735214,
0.11901050060987473,
0.5076024532318115,
0.48200875520706177,
0.4416653513908386,
0.4346739947795868,
-0.7920472621917725,
0.143894761800766,
-0.36712169647216797,
-0.5905461311340332,
0.2970278859138489,
0.7066528797149658,
0.024098245427012444,
0.8267825245857239,
0.7601973414421082,
0.1671973615884781,
0.11033929139375687,
-0.573002815246582,
0.8085288405418396,
-0.8066504001617432,
-0.6336292028427124,
-1.3148882389068604,
0.5016164779663086,
-0.4096237123012543,
-0.10017147660255432,
0.21132946014404297,
0.22213861346244812,
0.3420715928077698,
-0.05515361577272415,
0.7243614196777344,
-0.058561041951179504,
-0.22634416818618774,
-0.2823943495750427,
1.0341194868087769,
-0.528610348701477,
-0.013773346319794655,
-0.1137637346982956,
-0.9350932836532593,
0.09034337103366852,
0.3961171805858612,
-0.23307980597019196,
-0.1252550184726715,
0.7589718103408813,
0.5972870588302612,
0.3152545392513275,
-0.09370208531618118,
0.36746835708618164,
0.270320862531662,
0.25525856018066406,
0.1683131903409958,
1.3289543390274048,
0.09094081073999405,
0.2811965048313141,
0.3720204532146454,
-0.2681575417518616,
-0.13736294209957123,
-0.5016797780990601,
-0.8870140910148621,
-0.5829014182090759,
-0.18865366280078888,
-0.5185673236846924,
0.12976154685020447,
1.3333344459533691,
0.39013007283210754,
-0.1825745701789856,
-0.6830975413322449,
-0.04926589876413345,
0.23617546260356903,
-0.08386333286762238,
-0.2736555337905884,
-0.03196641057729721,
-0.18289771676063538,
-0.6109669208526611,
0.3487928509712219,
0.4428004026412964,
0.6403548717498779,
-0.6666577458381653,
-0.4506481885910034,
0.06658151000738144,
0.6165490746498108,
0.5610744953155518,
0.3438916504383087,
-0.8554677367210388,
-0.2349197268486023,
-0.12303681671619415,
-0.20653842389583588,
-0.37709301710128784,
0.747320294380188,
-0.30838850140571594,
0.012226102873682976,
-0.04567999392747879,
0.7432395219802856,
0.2825404703617096,
-0.28034499287605286,
0.41565465927124023,
-0.14212368428707123,
0.23602375388145447,
0.29817891120910645,
0.2886139154434204,
-0.20492561161518097,
-0.5063785314559937,
0.5596258640289307,
0.372353732585907,
-0.8756342530250549,
-1.2646600008010864,
0.2924100160598755,
-0.8448998332023621,
-0.31909486651420593,
0.9992794990539551,
0.21527966856956482,
-0.7661092877388,
-0.2938613295555115,
-0.09600809961557388,
0.46075087785720825,
-0.42610499262809753,
1.0997275114059448,
0.5240839123725891,
-0.3302323818206787,
-0.02601178176701069,
-0.7859636545181274,
0.45404574275016785,
0.059081338346004486,
-1.0204668045043945,
-0.0021189902909100056,
0.1499035805463791,
0.013977901078760624,
0.5774869918823242,
0.5344995260238647,
0.21601952612400055,
0.15890289843082428,
0.10750226676464081,
0.22459158301353455,
-0.11651667952537537,
-0.27782174944877625,
-0.20709188282489777,
0.34230175614356995,
-0.15584826469421387,
-0.07672706246376038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16953v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16953v1 | Validation of a new, minimally-invasive, software smartphone device to predict sleep apnea and its severity: transversal study | 2024-06-20T14:36:15 | 2024-06-20T14:36:15 | Justine Frija, Juliette Millet, Emilie Bequignon, Ala Covali, Guillaume Cathelain, Josselin Houenou, Helene Benzaquen, Pierre Alexis Geoffroy, Emmanuel Bacry, Mathieu Grajoszex, Marie-Pia d Ortho | eess.SP | eess.SP, cs.CL | Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is frequent and responsible for cardiovascular
complications and excessive daytime sleepiness. It is underdiagnosed due to the
difficulty to access the gold standard for diagnosis, polysomnography (PSG).
Alternative methods using smartphone sensors could be useful to increase
diagnosis. The objective is to assess the performances of Apneal, an
application that records the sound using a smartphone's microphone and
movements thanks to a smartphone's accelerometer and gyroscope, to estimate
patients' AHI. In this article, we perform a monocentric proof-of-concept study
with a first manual scoring step, and then an automatic detection of
respiratory events from the recorded signals using a sequential deep-learning
model which was released internally at Apneal at the end of 2022 (version 0.1
of Apneal automatic scoring of respiratory events), in adult patients during
in-hospital polysomnography.46 patients (women 34 per cent, mean BMI 28.7 kg
per m2) were included. For AHI superior to 15, sensitivity of manual scoring
was 0.91, and positive predictive value (PPV) 0.89. For AHI superior to 30,
sensitivity was 0.85, PPV 0.94. We obtained an AUC-ROC of 0.85 and an AUC-PR of
0.94 for the identification of AHI superior to 15, and AUC-ROC of 0.95 and
AUC-PR of 0.93 for AHI superior to 30. Promising results are obtained for the
automatic annotations of events.This article shows that manual scoring of
smartphone-based signals is possible and accurate compared to PSG-based
scorings. Automatic scoring method based on a deep learning model provides
promising results. A larger multicentric validation study, involving subjects
with different SAHS severity is required to confirm these results. | [
-0.39775919914245605,
-0.45552223920822144,
0.5046802759170532,
-0.13531620800495148,
-0.5093414187431335,
-0.2057684361934662,
-0.004545259289443493,
-0.5315637588500977,
0.5634877681732178,
0.13453257083892822,
-0.8459166288375854,
-0.49308842420578003,
-0.4889947175979614,
-0.01142023503780365,
-0.15558651089668274,
0.5716174840927124,
-0.07626106590032578,
0.17774435877799988,
0.1154920905828476,
-0.34669771790504456,
-0.29641497135162354,
-0.5249829292297363,
-0.24056310951709747,
-0.2721535861492157,
0.16049844026565552,
0.20820355415344238,
0.4951298236846924,
0.14322258532047272,
0.6292190551757812,
0.10429022461175919,
-0.016378462314605713,
0.1055571660399437,
0.1735466718673706,
-0.03415634483098984,
0.7747083902359009,
-0.1356915384531021,
-0.5275329351425171,
0.08782638609409332,
0.6086849570274353,
0.7593886852264404,
-0.38908106088638306,
0.7321489453315735,
-0.09327287971973419,
0.7773805260658264,
-0.6891259551048279,
-0.255440354347229,
-0.004391624592244625,
0.4671878516674042,
-0.2788182497024536,
0.1054188534617424,
-0.4079064428806305,
-0.4185815751552582,
0.261888712644577,
-0.3454790413379669,
-0.03144817054271698,
-0.16942943632602692,
0.5797554850578308,
0.5611014366149902,
-0.4412094056606293,
-0.4853243827819824,
-1.1201311349868774,
0.5842365622520447,
-0.6488717198371887,
0.6157128214836121,
0.05033739283680916,
0.48559635877609253,
0.13203692436218262,
-0.3819320797920227,
-0.3224256932735443,
-0.2987392246723175,
0.1152200996875763,
0.04453909769654274,
-0.026250090450048447,
0.04861059784889221,
0.1718902885913849,
0.4216257333755493,
-0.8777509331703186,
-0.21832939982414246,
-0.70107102394104,
-0.4318481385707855,
1.062281847000122,
0.13908354938030243,
0.33685943484306335,
-0.1666470170021057,
-0.31953245401382446,
0.5594446659088135,
-0.3998587429523468,
0.23928353190422058,
0.16970714926719666,
0.25556620955467224,
-0.33540278673171997,
0.6052201986312866,
-0.30232933163642883,
0.7635779976844788,
0.1406671106815338,
-0.4614042341709137,
0.6419930458068848,
-0.4256875813007355,
-0.15722009539604187,
0.8491867780685425,
0.698772668838501,
0.06174854934215546,
-0.20676474273204803,
0.08468262106180191,
0.12378326803445816,
0.3283786475658417,
0.18284828960895538,
-0.4343065917491913,
-0.09587883949279785,
0.43049758672714233,
-0.7925150394439697,
-0.3292302191257477,
-0.007416470907628536,
-0.43275386095046997,
-0.5052176117897034,
-0.3468334972858429,
0.32027778029441833,
-0.26130354404449463,
-0.20026738941669464,
0.36398884654045105,
0.18262264132499695,
0.07605452835559845,
0.3740702271461487,
-0.3026110827922821,
0.282329797744751,
0.15290772914886475,
1.0122687816619873,
-0.1952444165945053,
-0.18394295871257782,
-0.3063508868217468,
-0.45886316895484924,
-0.36932966113090515,
0.6830082535743713,
0.024268172681331635,
-0.5636951923370361,
-0.27905434370040894,
-0.3041362166404724,
-0.40604668855667114,
-0.21827854216098785,
1.111930251121521,
-0.10800137370824814,
0.12927435338497162,
0.007845910266041756,
-0.3430797755718231,
-0.16445377469062805,
-0.18318216502666473,
-0.6528122425079346,
0.7815338373184204,
-0.030467838048934937,
-0.3310874104499817,
0.32991743087768555,
-0.5735055804252625,
-0.7195321917533875,
0.018928982317447662,
0.15716220438480377,
-0.6653986573219299,
0.06953170150518417,
-0.03429333493113518,
0.1447911113500595,
-0.07291638851165771,
-0.018293989822268486,
-0.260991632938385,
-0.22588172554969788,
0.21708481013774872,
-0.3059748411178589,
0.6662589907646179,
0.31827595829963684,
-0.2186957448720932,
-0.18797658383846283,
-0.7595935463905334,
0.09859238564968109,
-0.22591513395309448,
-0.24962322413921356,
-0.018482984974980354,
-0.12015053629875183,
-0.37392768263816833,
0.3103218674659729,
0.05242281034588814,
-1.0551685094833374,
-0.11870740354061127,
0.19289655983448029,
0.32155901193618774,
0.2084072232246399,
0.19622081518173218,
0.16453924775123596,
-0.42574432492256165,
0.5139666199684143,
-0.251997172832489,
0.8032167553901672,
-0.019224239513278008,
-0.8891300559043884,
-0.18311046063899994,
-0.3155054748058319,
0.4137078821659088,
0.4288744330406189,
0.056452251970767975,
0.764171302318573,
-0.1645248383283615,
-0.6563915610313416,
-0.7249211072921753,
0.08539415895938873,
0.3200273811817169,
0.7716192603111267,
0.07254427671432495,
-0.38340675830841064,
-0.7780439853668213,
-0.3164612948894501,
-0.23581063747406006,
-0.13375598192214966,
0.08558928966522217,
0.43926891684532166,
0.23156490921974182,
-0.3814465403556824,
0.48746758699417114,
-0.6018723845481873,
-0.8828539252281189,
-0.15645508468151093,
0.33172687888145447,
0.04822273179888725,
0.353490948677063,
0.19820785522460938,
-0.6576829552650452,
-0.456705242395401,
0.030652567744255066,
-0.8102483749389648,
-0.08504404127597809,
0.09177377820014954,
0.24614697694778442,
0.14974693953990936,
0.3636164367198944,
-0.5975773930549622,
0.8514000773429871,
0.518189013004303,
-0.27021318674087524,
0.5931807160377502,
-0.008315463550388813,
-0.04387904703617096,
-0.3581083118915558,
-0.0038032622542232275,
0.288446843624115,
-0.20194603502750397,
-0.49288177490234375,
-0.1193196102976799,
-0.075706847012043,
-0.5058636665344238,
-0.3486156165599823,
0.24309489130973816,
-0.13779579102993011,
0.016196295619010925,
-0.39578738808631897,
-0.15071585774421692,
-0.04526272416114807,
0.1188976988196373,
0.2969571650028229,
0.14829733967781067,
0.24397307634353638,
-0.8246605396270752,
0.43512341380119324,
-0.06238357350230217,
-0.42540183663368225,
0.1970798522233963,
-0.6115427017211914,
0.013713588938117027,
0.1404154896736145,
0.5096160769462585,
-1.080567479133606,
-0.24405524134635925,
-0.011836991645395756,
-0.8762093782424927,
-0.1479741483926773,
-0.04191344231367111,
0.1988169401884079,
-0.6173932552337646,
-0.34270092844963074,
0.5606692433357239,
0.44666653871536255,
-0.2386273294687271,
1.1309782266616821,
0.6658892035484314,
-0.32961076498031616,
-0.25646546483039856,
-0.48046475648880005,
-0.22942855954170227,
0.07840078324079514,
-0.44381728768348694,
0.12962442636489868,
0.12121333181858063,
-0.03111865185201168,
-0.07864190638065338,
-0.4026019275188446,
0.21384626626968384,
-0.02081288769841194,
0.5660541653633118,
0.5445961356163025,
-0.2951139807701111,
0.2991621196269989,
0.04137120768427849,
-0.17846250534057617,
0.05557151883840561,
-0.15649448335170746,
0.4142952263355255,
-0.448636531829834,
-0.4344574213027954,
-1.1758122444152832,
0.07540397346019745,
0.7763402462005615,
-0.10069725662469864,
0.1239895448088646,
0.3385522663593292,
-1.0351872444152832,
0.09531290829181671,
-0.5763614177703857,
0.14112943410873413,
-0.33491072058677673,
-0.17494100332260132,
-0.4683181047439575,
0.003497836645692587,
0.6725909113883972,
-0.24513351917266846,
-0.12244945019483566,
0.29417112469673157,
0.3647289574146271,
-0.14038461446762085,
1.263063907623291,
0.28799253702163696,
-0.020771704614162445,
0.23809438943862915,
-0.20149298012256622,
0.32009539008140564,
-1.1655560731887817,
-0.42229923605918884,
-0.6419927477836609,
-0.3002406358718872,
-0.34760501980781555,
-0.028841089457273483,
0.7913152575492859,
-0.07665804773569107,
-0.19672490656375885,
0.08566682040691376,
-0.5698813796043396,
0.16330869495868683,
0.24347777664661407,
0.6678513288497925,
0.3311866521835327,
-0.4251681864261627,
-0.1245793029665947,
0.1669311821460724,
-0.3763052225112915,
-0.3802672326564789,
1.4775365591049194,
0.32488131523132324,
0.7466197609901428,
-0.0033881687559187412,
0.8189693093299866,
0.64430171251297,
0.13268080353736877,
-0.918294370174408,
0.3434588611125946,
-0.35367530584335327,
-0.5017953515052795,
-0.5156999230384827,
-0.13838468492031097,
-0.6469689607620239,
0.08146313577890396,
-0.11567623168230057,
-0.5431223511695862,
0.6402614712715149,
0.10416184365749359,
-1.1178239583969116,
0.00705003971233964,
-1.022958517074585,
0.6928156018257141,
-0.5257023572921753,
-0.12470390647649765,
0.021374450996518135,
-0.5174717307090759,
0.24161233007907867,
-0.09495873004198074,
0.38582971692085266,
-0.2087479680776596,
-0.07735435664653778,
0.7125027775764465,
-0.37802109122276306,
0.8122897744178772,
-0.456417977809906,
0.08634990453720093,
0.33940353989601135,
-0.015764523297548294,
0.2569306194782257,
0.12537173926830292,
-0.4163645803928375,
0.17970895767211914,
-0.03993942588567734,
-0.23587986826896667,
-0.38432392477989197,
0.6593452095985413,
-0.6783183217048645,
0.07312680035829544,
-0.6154091954231262,
0.054041046649217606,
-0.0827716588973999,
0.29575470089912415,
0.4689474105834961,
0.4940653443336487,
-0.29936695098876953,
-0.020930524915456772,
0.651140570640564,
0.18716466426849365,
0.08804971724748611,
0.2234864979982376,
0.045403625816106796,
-0.30867090821266174,
0.7246705293655396,
0.1653919368982315,
-0.16701796650886536,
0.0342819020152092,
0.7059594392776489,
-0.5828535556793213,
-0.5151877999305725,
-0.6327595114707947,
0.06950962543487549,
-0.29195716977119446,
-0.31219685077667236,
-0.4761720299720764,
-0.3808079659938812,
-0.3644571900367737,
0.03196863830089569,
-0.503109872341156,
-0.390529990196228,
0.07409831136465073,
-0.3126169741153717,
-0.19599975645542145,
0.4457595944404602,
-0.11531782895326614,
0.08353541791439056,
-0.588697075843811,
0.6853756308555603,
0.33861660957336426,
0.20408914983272552,
-0.18409064412117004,
-0.3134973347187042,
0.024175072088837624,
0.26947295665740967,
-0.31432223320007324,
-0.538304328918457,
0.08294506371021271,
0.44656625390052795,
0.32456791400909424,
0.4923076033592224,
0.48973485827445984,
0.633446991443634,
-0.20515772700309753,
0.8638911843299866,
0.4436623752117157,
-1.2920069694519043,
1.0604221820831299,
0.0713607594370842,
0.18127302825450897,
0.6182528734207153,
0.498445063829422,
-0.42135587334632874,
0.07368984818458557,
-0.6150367856025696,
-0.5632147192955017,
0.67543625831604,
0.04863223060965538,
-0.250222384929657,
0.5126007199287415,
0.5723289251327515,
0.1717720329761505,
0.2011098563671112,
-0.80582195520401,
-0.11159814894199371,
-0.24373704195022583,
-0.28017064929008484,
-0.0825619325041771,
0.11187104135751724,
0.0025133814197033644,
-0.6757012009620667,
0.6139743328094482,
-0.10492216050624847,
0.2811353802680969,
0.8778920769691467,
-0.10449580103158951,
-0.5510724186897278,
-0.10251510143280029,
0.5911222696304321,
0.6055124402046204,
-0.4437386691570282,
0.03707446902990341,
0.0482657253742218,
-0.8116329908370972,
0.222897008061409,
0.16352412104606628,
-0.26151496171951294,
0.47909075021743774,
0.30882003903388977,
0.7428416013717651,
-0.303312748670578,
-0.668886661529541,
0.6580907702445984,
-0.24781127274036407,
-0.2677769660949707,
-0.6696426868438721,
-0.237588033080101,
-0.3474409580230713,
-0.28998038172721863,
0.43574878573417664,
0.551885187625885,
0.4648328125476837,
-0.5746943950653076,
0.11279555410146713,
0.34769076108932495,
-0.617249608039856,
-0.2889227569103241,
0.4682369530200958,
0.4460465908050537,
-0.3945290744304657,
0.14932028949260712,
-0.4441131353378296,
-0.4423661231994629,
0.6602951884269714,
-0.027491219341754913,
0.7125611901283264,
-0.9111775159835815,
0.32939913868904114,
0.5127459168434143,
0.40409567952156067,
-0.10397346317768097,
0.5656812191009521,
-0.20300358533859253,
-0.5097063183784485,
-0.13839760422706604,
-0.5309933423995972,
-0.4919045567512512,
0.06014035642147064,
-0.8726713061332703,
0.35653650760650635,
-0.446586549282074,
-0.4824223220348358,
0.6243310570716858,
0.3923772871494293,
-0.248203307390213,
0.44053104519844055,
0.5337878465652466,
0.6232434511184692,
-0.8347746133804321,
0.5940946936607361,
0.8371558785438538,
-0.028296951204538345,
-0.5751670002937317,
0.28171658515930176,
0.2962525486946106,
-0.5848448276519775,
0.13339881598949432,
0.21653416752815247,
-0.5500020384788513,
-0.4028160870075226,
0.05343182757496834,
-0.5708643794059753,
0.9295660853385925,
0.1714157611131668,
-0.6439865231513977,
-0.02428411692380905,
0.28837981820106506,
0.6298256516456604,
-0.3225557506084442,
0.16067834198474884,
0.43654048442840576,
0.15387631952762604,
0.049272697418928146,
-1.3923327922821045,
0.16876766085624695,
-0.2008163034915924,
-0.13386447727680206,
0.31525781750679016,
-0.6002500057220459,
0.4039853513240814,
-0.6840379238128662,
-0.3564298748970032,
0.13937513530254364,
0.14550448954105377,
0.07098346203565598,
1.0896488428115845,
0.46213001012802124,
0.566233217716217,
1.1739882230758667,
0.09104149788618088,
1.0590404272079468,
-0.3306659460067749,
0.22051723301410675,
0.7979871034622192,
-0.5529115796089172,
0.8934211134910583,
0.12525713443756104,
-0.09392289817333221,
0.7289285659790039,
0.5848538279533386,
0.5012356638908386,
0.5515373349189758,
0.16019561886787415,
-0.5155487656593323,
-0.08871390670537949,
-0.10103325545787811,
-0.6451335549354553,
0.46579909324645996,
0.6293796300888062,
-0.2325102537870407,
-0.0894206240773201,
0.7422769665718079,
-0.6191707253456116,
-0.13446541130542755,
-0.29828864336013794,
0.9532703161239624,
0.1376642882823944,
-0.5986673831939697,
0.7831042408943176,
-0.06134752184152603,
0.6163084506988525,
-0.6419650316238403,
0.3717364966869354,
0.10733462125062943,
0.4662017822265625,
-0.5312259197235107,
-0.2593783736228943,
0.4634271562099457,
-0.18815743923187256,
0.04267936944961548,
0.0738234668970108,
0.8164255619049072,
0.06495371460914612,
-0.5784457921981812,
0.07043773680925369,
0.3359069228172302,
-0.12138056010007858,
-0.2056562751531601,
-0.4911196827888489,
0.1650419384241104,
-0.15962569415569305,
0.10141783207654953,
0.06564860045909882,
0.2785325050354004,
0.18383996188640594,
0.7236013412475586,
0.6233487129211426,
0.24187426269054413,
0.15205161273479462,
-0.15425334870815277,
0.4621218144893646,
-0.4950891435146332,
-0.6565371751785278,
-0.4306141436100006,
0.2464635819196701,
0.042743902653455734,
-0.634880006313324,
0.3253786861896515,
0.7454429864883423,
0.5360363125801086,
0.17962764203548431,
0.8444642424583435,
0.04206627979874611,
0.7893794178962708,
-0.35343649983406067,
0.40618079900741577,
-0.408659428358078,
0.3663804531097412,
0.015045217238366604,
-0.24755793809890747,
-0.30240386724472046,
0.8043836355209351,
-0.43446797132492065,
-0.31609946489334106,
0.7587114572525024,
0.23103877902030945,
-0.13537228107452393,
0.5894507169723511,
-0.13507361710071564,
-0.09403268992900848,
-0.051307279616594315,
0.4639056324958801,
0.7771446108818054,
-0.7896506190299988,
0.47059985995292664,
-0.6811850666999817,
-0.7116293907165527,
-0.43389686942100525,
-0.3677560091018677,
-0.38143178820610046,
-0.5230828523635864,
-0.8406484127044678,
-0.3729420006275177,
0.46499454975128174,
0.7727494239807129,
1.0592522621154785,
-0.5776174068450928,
-0.14898601174354553,
-0.23185338079929352,
0.23848488926887512,
-0.664655864238739,
-0.1259402185678482,
0.48425596952438354,
0.04798761382699013,
-0.32518771290779114,
0.2036270797252655,
0.05861169099807739,
0.1231594979763031,
0.0507718026638031,
-0.09694612771272659,
0.16700145602226257,
-0.21951168775558472,
0.6104291677474976,
0.4167737662792206,
-0.5754364728927612,
0.2693156898021698,
0.1900697946548462,
-0.04399596154689789,
-0.13742312788963318,
0.9059455394744873,
-0.7333714365959167,
0.3826555609703064,
0.3598615229129791,
0.24017789959907532,
0.2197723388671875,
0.09884432703256607,
0.19060476124286652,
-0.4711497128009796,
0.05300788953900337,
0.660736620426178,
0.2936302721500397,
-0.14124087989330292,
-0.8008076548576355,
0.10673385113477707,
0.39006307721138,
-0.5372052788734436,
-1.1513713598251343,
-0.035500120371580124,
-1.0517195463180542,
-0.2861917316913605,
0.9489803314208984,
0.1164061650633812,
-0.28642189502716064,
-0.5795249342918396,
-0.24358350038528442,
-0.16131995618343353,
-0.4217410087585449,
0.9544886946678162,
0.40340039134025574,
-0.7845826745033264,
-0.05559000372886658,
-0.37939125299453735,
0.8067108392715454,
0.17808157205581665,
-0.5175851583480835,
-0.2587365210056305,
0.182841956615448,
0.15933352708816528,
0.6363944411277771,
0.7005576491355896,
-0.4211042523384094,
1.040703296661377,
0.07729200273752213,
-0.00397177180275321,
-0.05259636417031288,
-0.12407573312520981,
-0.551274299621582,
0.052643783390522,
-0.15330636501312256,
-0.9767419695854187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14358v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14358v1 | The neural correlates of logical-mathematical symbol systems processing resemble that of spatial cognition more than natural language processing | 2024-06-20T14:31:09 | 2024-06-20T14:31:09 | Yuannan Li, Shan Xu, Jia Liu | q-bio.NC | q-bio.NC, cs.AI, cs.CL | The ability to manipulate logical-mathematical symbols (LMS), encompassing
tasks such as calculation, reasoning, and programming, is a cognitive skill
arguably unique to humans. Considering the relatively recent emergence of this
ability in human evolutionary history, it has been suggested that LMS
processing may build upon more fundamental cognitive systems, possibly through
neuronal recycling. Previous studies have pinpointed two primary candidates,
natural language processing and spatial cognition. Existing comparisons between
these domains largely relied on task-level comparison, which may be confounded
by task idiosyncrasy. The present study instead compared the neural correlates
at the domain level with both automated meta-analysis and synthesized maps
based on three representative LMS tasks, reasoning, calculation, and mental
programming. Our results revealed a more substantial cortical overlap between
LMS processing and spatial cognition, in contrast to language processing.
Furthermore, in regions activated by both spatial and language processing, the
multivariate activation pattern for LMS processing exhibited greater
multivariate similarity to spatial cognition than to language processing. A
hierarchical clustering analysis further indicated that typical LMS tasks were
indistinguishable from spatial cognition tasks at the neural level, suggesting
an inherent connection between these two cognitive processes. Taken together,
our findings support the hypothesis that spatial cognition is likely the basis
of LMS processing, which may shed light on the limitations of large language
models in logical reasoning, particularly those trained exclusively on textual
data without explicit emphasis on spatial content. | [
-0.48001790046691895,
-0.9065831303596497,
0.7662773728370667,
0.13913734257221222,
0.2858375906944275,
0.05417531728744507,
-0.18393361568450928,
-0.6822490692138672,
0.28924137353897095,
0.31974557042121887,
-0.6355392336845398,
-0.4154667854309082,
-0.5611773729324341,
0.15346576273441315,
-0.19954049587249756,
0.43673598766326904,
0.09614166617393494,
0.0682343989610672,
-0.4159178137779236,
-0.3238537311553955,
-0.740817129611969,
-0.8340997695922852,
-0.6706730127334595,
-0.6402403116226196,
0.4272114336490631,
-0.24320094287395477,
0.9939188957214355,
0.20790977776050568,
0.8209827542304993,
0.46174368262290955,
0.006212008651345968,
-0.034773606806993484,
-0.1647166907787323,
-0.07649695128202438,
-0.5413609147071838,
-0.494485467672348,
-0.48054245114326477,
-0.023095976561307907,
0.12612558901309967,
1.0711532831192017,
-0.06655624508857727,
-0.05917643755674362,
0.015025774948298931,
0.7914342284202576,
-0.5926600694656372,
0.4248451292514801,
-0.5585808753967285,
0.1907169371843338,
0.15833774209022522,
-0.4627121388912201,
-0.31632962822914124,
-0.5343961119651794,
0.2540907561779022,
-0.9281957149505615,
0.06032569333910942,
0.08623962849378586,
0.6670665144920349,
0.27659496665000916,
-0.253663569688797,
-0.49794313311576843,
-0.6052882671356201,
0.744902491569519,
-0.3660304546356201,
0.28666239976882935,
0.626990795135498,
0.2448856234550476,
-0.09019780158996582,
-0.38359159231185913,
-0.5972152352333069,
-0.2014370858669281,
-0.482562780380249,
-0.010149207897484303,
-0.5377597808837891,
0.008929762057960033,
0.5871034860610962,
-0.3079715073108673,
-0.5435925722122192,
-0.2667822241783142,
-0.6043758392333984,
-0.2884563207626343,
0.5203259587287903,
0.22012881934642792,
0.8413516283035278,
-0.22020915150642395,
-0.45548075437545776,
-0.01790311373770237,
-0.733273983001709,
0.061448272317647934,
0.06357013434171677,
0.3091960549354553,
-0.04941480606794357,
0.7637928128242493,
0.0010341184679418802,
0.6817485094070435,
-0.18798598647117615,
-0.020886030048131943,
0.19132179021835327,
-0.33892884850502014,
-0.24045582115650177,
-0.021324658766388893,
0.8126260042190552,
0.245594784617424,
0.7984577417373657,
-0.17870889604091644,
-0.13596197962760925,
0.5379460453987122,
0.3798999488353729,
-0.29395827651023865,
-0.3678727447986603,
-0.2707274556159973,
-0.34990787506103516,
0.19832764565944672,
0.03834114596247673,
-0.22585642337799072,
-0.08377545326948166,
-0.801169216632843,
0.38442888855934143,
-0.7307599186897278,
-0.07573339343070984,
0.47564566135406494,
-0.16889484226703644,
-0.27716508507728577,
0.20247720181941986,
-0.8214249610900879,
0.5236522555351257,
0.9819483757019043,
0.6321859359741211,
-0.031142152845859528,
-0.5783522725105286,
0.013653719797730446,
-0.021518513560295105,
-0.37499096989631653,
0.7305063009262085,
-0.8562604188919067,
0.1456780880689621,
-0.27356696128845215,
-0.2729429006576538,
-0.3118147552013397,
-0.8764739632606506,
0.4700078070163727,
-0.8550392389297485,
-0.06460574269294739,
-0.8066633343696594,
-0.20213353633880615,
-0.5290699601173401,
0.1414056420326233,
-0.8706192970275879,
0.8732466697692871,
0.027441147714853287,
-0.6345875859260559,
0.4754452705383301,
-0.3817397356033325,
-0.4488084018230438,
-0.01429562084376812,
-0.6698732972145081,
0.01720242202281952,
0.07275587320327759,
0.05241271108388901,
0.27593836188316345,
-0.22715504467487335,
0.3543926179409027,
-0.5846141576766968,
-0.4719517230987549,
0.5822989344596863,
-0.005631454288959503,
0.8911588788032532,
0.06556719541549683,
-0.44601479172706604,
-0.08343631029129028,
-0.5476983785629272,
0.13547073304653168,
0.10913471132516861,
-0.09867150336503983,
-0.7197439670562744,
0.29221653938293457,
-0.4930686950683594,
0.5237807035446167,
0.25738540291786194,
-0.21585728228092194,
-0.029231248423457146,
-0.3285282850265503,
0.49936795234680176,
0.4895409345626831,
-0.21129903197288513,
0.8099943399429321,
-0.22322343289852142,
0.11192954331636429,
0.115230031311512,
-0.314850389957428,
0.16651418805122375,
-0.4621839225292206,
-0.5557619333267212,
-0.4725345969200134,
-0.3648586869239807,
0.6636654138565063,
-0.8319007158279419,
0.6830278635025024,
-0.5290647745132446,
-0.09162241965532303,
0.08460105955600739,
-0.1439640074968338,
0.31073611974716187,
0.3550814092159271,
0.5062771439552307,
-0.06320839375257492,
-0.5737009644508362,
-0.9327900409698486,
-0.5729623436927795,
0.0069612059742212296,
0.0048021902330219746,
0.30953484773635864,
0.6110256910324097,
0.11990413069725037,
0.9753939509391785,
-0.468437135219574,
-0.30176079273223877,
0.07814576476812363,
0.05864248052239418,
0.39319589734077454,
0.26458895206451416,
0.7675902247428894,
-0.2220553606748581,
-0.31597110629081726,
0.12160498648881912,
-1.0749787092208862,
-0.18052677810192108,
-0.14792536199092865,
-0.28800418972969055,
0.12203706055879593,
0.5859379172325134,
-0.8961871266365051,
0.6482645273208618,
0.15259583294391632,
-0.8942104578018188,
0.1698170155286789,
-0.44300296902656555,
0.3405233919620514,
-0.2160274088382721,
0.1159663051366806,
-0.30179542303085327,
0.3234984278678894,
-0.5975809693336487,
0.014756375923752785,
-0.0012344254646450281,
-0.04185695946216583,
-0.019223390147089958,
0.274269163608551,
-0.6005301475524902,
-0.6000196933746338,
-0.24569295346736908,
0.294360488653183,
0.059599995613098145,
0.7762435078620911,
0.27126720547676086,
0.48930928111076355,
0.4643491506576538,
-0.47913309931755066,
0.12342771887779236,
-0.08440978825092316,
-0.43128278851509094,
0.35220810770988464,
-0.7101095914840698,
-0.09077093005180359,
-0.2068575620651245,
-0.022759202867746353,
-1.1042529344558716,
0.3988680839538574,
0.1876385360956192,
-0.34612366557121277,
-0.1788572371006012,
0.4334922134876251,
-0.6105363368988037,
-0.13936179876327515,
0.0931364968419075,
0.6921045184135437,
0.43542036414146423,
-0.2622910141944885,
0.5317725539207458,
0.19748550653457642,
-0.16679009795188904,
-0.20932184159755707,
-1.0215362310409546,
-0.13215714693069458,
-0.037860821932554245,
-0.6573913097381592,
0.023162908852100372,
0.31659063696861267,
-0.41397199034690857,
0.1619279384613037,
-0.10809660702943802,
0.02374272793531418,
-0.01461404375731945,
0.2921123206615448,
0.49353092908859253,
-0.16388139128684998,
0.006537178531289101,
-0.12335720658302307,
-0.15485765039920807,
0.5628191828727722,
-0.26987022161483765,
0.5105807185173035,
-0.035084255039691925,
-0.6836088299751282,
-0.4070308804512024,
0.024659058079123497,
0.7379875183105469,
-0.26533302664756775,
0.7765205502510071,
0.055183012038469315,
-0.6231688857078552,
0.08102254569530487,
-0.15828637778759003,
-0.24285146594047546,
-0.3667999505996704,
0.274178147315979,
-0.6432110071182251,
-0.7336528897285461,
0.43849143385887146,
0.2422640472650528,
-0.22936499118804932,
0.4846038222312927,
0.3715909421443939,
-0.28520524501800537,
0.7273015975952148,
0.12504129111766815,
0.06460044533014297,
0.26323869824409485,
-0.3113681375980377,
0.43843597173690796,
-0.6025404930114746,
-0.41076430678367615,
-0.5079694986343384,
-0.828952431678772,
-0.2063460648059845,
-0.7576602697372437,
0.21753984689712524,
-0.0032398111652582884,
-0.7088403105735779,
0.4466012418270111,
-0.5071845650672913,
0.5456940531730652,
0.19264067709445953,
0.05494658648967743,
0.22404110431671143,
0.6061632037162781,
-0.44343435764312744,
-0.46950313448905945,
-0.8217543363571167,
-0.29569071531295776,
0.9488064646720886,
0.03504641354084015,
0.7111737132072449,
-0.007816051132977009,
0.2659772038459778,
0.16142208874225616,
0.03845036402344704,
-0.4635574519634247,
0.9182454943656921,
-0.3501231074333191,
-0.38410496711730957,
-0.2220883071422577,
-0.5101062059402466,
-1.0843355655670166,
0.572289764881134,
-0.5534621477127075,
-0.7584072351455688,
0.3074007034301758,
-0.16959558427333832,
-0.3633361756801605,
0.4374198317527771,
-0.7683843970298767,
0.4854665696620941,
-0.29215192794799805,
-0.3444444239139557,
-0.6234877109527588,
-0.18442851305007935,
0.32514941692352295,
0.20325639843940735,
0.5229167938232422,
-0.0685553103685379,
-0.15137240290641785,
0.29811257123947144,
-0.28889885544776917,
0.8263567686080933,
0.0036072495859116316,
-0.1910085827112198,
0.3510201871395111,
0.5155238509178162,
0.17282132804393768,
-0.1740598976612091,
-0.00031773248338140547,
0.49186375737190247,
0.019175758585333824,
-0.386770635843277,
-0.9753888845443726,
0.7829927802085876,
-1.0918017625808716,
-0.35086309909820557,
-0.6628498435020447,
-0.7903324365615845,
0.11312571913003922,
0.1949823498725891,
0.04180262237787247,
0.31911295652389526,
-0.09645732492208481,
-0.1560177206993103,
0.6051051616668701,
-0.2770405113697052,
0.3026369512081146,
0.10485526919364929,
-0.5312316417694092,
-0.44727763533592224,
0.7290558815002441,
0.24377965927124023,
0.23148219287395477,
0.7755938172340393,
-0.20645400881767273,
-0.0826541855931282,
-0.24007602035999298,
0.23099903762340546,
0.23191553354263306,
-0.6305176615715027,
0.0037433968391269445,
-0.5901619791984558,
-0.16835393011569977,
0.0915629044175148,
-0.502093493938446,
-0.07807059586048126,
-0.5424132347106934,
0.035641901195049286,
0.05853336304426193,
0.1209864541888237,
0.7162788510322571,
0.10906002670526505,
-0.12742309272289276,
-0.6450256109237671,
0.4929969310760498,
0.16835816204547882,
0.17418025434017181,
0.31272873282432556,
-0.1409970223903656,
-0.12138847261667252,
0.43436092138290405,
0.012244246900081635,
-0.6923177242279053,
0.22582440078258514,
0.09474802762269974,
0.5113795399665833,
0.3858075439929962,
-0.48224321007728577,
0.7508240342140198,
-0.5761366486549377,
0.5647450089454651,
0.5714440941810608,
-0.7967907190322876,
0.11815664172172546,
-0.2675691843032837,
0.6811511516571045,
0.28234317898750305,
0.2777137756347656,
-0.36537811160087585,
-0.1685018390417099,
-0.3488307595252991,
-0.37892189621925354,
0.6419798135757446,
0.4861675798892975,
-0.2525109648704529,
-0.362474262714386,
0.3610842525959015,
-0.10274383425712585,
-0.09045091271400452,
-0.44628506898880005,
-0.12090885639190674,
0.015811078250408173,
0.03900468349456787,
-0.14821645617485046,
0.2487865537405014,
-0.4056108295917511,
-0.5416940450668335,
-0.15130721032619476,
-0.023727411404252052,
0.5193498134613037,
0.18161959946155548,
-0.15768881142139435,
-0.05635259672999382,
0.10519494861364365,
0.5812904238700867,
0.6496500968933105,
0.2085808664560318,
0.4886719882488251,
0.2606135606765747,
-0.4536518156528473,
-0.05472583696246147,
-0.23009194433689117,
-0.2263077199459076,
-0.0896977111697197,
0.7860847115516663,
0.7716057300567627,
0.6165446639060974,
-0.5675171613693237,
0.1728457659482956,
-0.06454149633646011,
-0.38807523250579834,
-0.24327079951763153,
0.08647836744785309,
0.5071645379066467,
0.5241380333900452,
0.11364853382110596,
0.6990558505058289,
0.14006280899047852,
-0.6909432411193848,
-0.09953523427248001,
0.692378044128418,
0.02706390619277954,
-0.5439730882644653,
0.4069248139858246,
-0.12019577622413635,
-0.21364626288414001,
0.8969564437866211,
-0.11462310701608658,
-0.5211974382400513,
0.7777493000030518,
0.5222328305244446,
0.8009411096572876,
0.49809855222702026,
-0.10467797517776489,
0.8167465329170227,
0.4670446813106537,
0.15809129178524017,
0.6358670592308044,
-0.23215481638908386,
-0.8397992849349976,
-0.443602055311203,
-0.46532511711120605,
0.29630663990974426,
-0.34349820017814636,
-0.5245919823646545,
-0.04224216565489769,
-0.6287552118301392,
-0.5646765232086182,
-0.07701956480741501,
-0.28458133339881897,
-0.8252975344657898,
0.3023945689201355,
0.35050520300865173,
0.746543824672699,
-0.5818841457366943,
0.6477542519569397,
0.9798868298530579,
-0.20895324647426605,
-0.6411707401275635,
-0.4390515983104706,
-0.19006451964378357,
-0.6763278841972351,
1.2169731855392456,
-0.06593319773674011,
-0.3660138249397278,
-0.5646451711654663,
-0.3186418116092682,
-1.1215426921844482,
1.1523189544677734,
0.503659188747406,
-0.4883504807949066,
-0.26520511507987976,
0.7123799920082092,
0.8957514762878418,
-0.31843510270118713,
0.19541476666927338,
0.6171128749847412,
0.27443787455558777,
0.0512748546898365,
-0.7335455417633057,
0.2976083755493164,
-0.21152263879776,
0.12905080616474152,
0.5611202120780945,
-0.39891213178634644,
0.9165915250778198,
-0.3254072368144989,
-0.5552458763122559,
-0.07010967284440994,
0.5044835209846497,
0.6243475675582886,
0.11836659163236618,
0.29340875148773193,
1.0236109495162964,
0.5209612250328064,
-0.38895127177238464,
0.6945077776908875,
-0.48155221343040466,
0.34217745065689087,
0.9725239276885986,
-0.23004677891731262,
0.8495481610298157,
0.7356043457984924,
-0.40624481439590454,
0.7345486283302307,
0.10707702487707138,
0.31232574582099915,
0.4351547062397003,
0.2843574583530426,
-0.0011980533599853516,
-0.250541627407074,
0.444410502910614,
-0.3254922330379486,
0.19817011058330536,
0.6580744385719299,
-0.26753363013267517,
-0.3878462612628937,
-0.3191882371902466,
-0.11433649808168411,
0.3312063217163086,
-0.2810923755168915,
0.5018060207366943,
0.36522242426872253,
-0.9279589056968689,
0.5381567478179932,
-0.18354876339435577,
0.43798014521598816,
-0.6344074010848999,
-0.0722120925784111,
0.10108329355716705,
0.1939057558774948,
-0.4254736304283142,
-1.0081778764724731,
0.7984615564346313,
-0.22698809206485748,
-0.2566359043121338,
-0.5239880681037903,
0.9863877296447754,
-0.32696840167045593,
-0.11054719239473343,
0.6604892015457153,
0.5675408244132996,
-0.027436083182692528,
0.027327654883265495,
-0.804562509059906,
0.08726851642131805,
-0.24372988939285278,
-0.13445892930030823,
0.2230798751115799,
0.6347906589508057,
-0.26188814640045166,
0.7103865146636963,
0.8310399651527405,
0.21747158467769623,
0.31988653540611267,
0.033620208501815796,
0.5377164483070374,
-0.9755755662918091,
-0.31426772475242615,
-0.9490543007850647,
0.13692274689674377,
0.16610389947891235,
-0.02906263992190361,
0.48192116618156433,
0.3480888307094574,
0.9456968903541565,
-0.41205793619155884,
0.6709095239639282,
-0.19900964200496674,
-0.13268683850765228,
-0.45765119791030884,
0.7358015775680542,
-0.3894696533679962,
0.24127648770809174,
-0.24504612386226654,
-0.9743475914001465,
-0.3538927733898163,
0.8880660533905029,
-0.8877756595611572,
0.12454362213611603,
1.2023382186889648,
0.5565175414085388,
-0.10340437293052673,
0.21091537177562714,
0.3691237270832062,
0.02821616269648075,
-0.07855133712291718,
1.0098812580108643,
0.8922770023345947,
-0.32976558804512024,
0.10973595827817917,
-0.1628778725862503,
-0.1253538429737091,
0.12909214198589325,
-0.4996742904186249,
-0.9968675971031189,
-0.48862797021865845,
-0.024337684735655785,
-0.18696580827236176,
-0.1963576078414917,
0.7465565204620361,
0.3459582030773163,
-0.653997540473938,
-0.40368854999542236,
-0.21656982600688934,
0.08419627696275711,
-0.4511861801147461,
-0.1760389506816864,
0.3262215554714203,
-0.32422003149986267,
-0.5423152446746826,
-0.054243870079517365,
0.7712921500205994,
-0.25764212012290955,
-0.08103150874376297,
-0.05478272587060928,
-0.3092905879020691,
0.11330444365739822,
0.9792535901069641,
0.17713050544261932,
-0.7831940650939941,
-0.22507889568805695,
0.45933815836906433,
-0.6685020327568054,
0.07230827212333679,
0.9656957983970642,
-0.8299168944358826,
0.27706265449523926,
1.086294412612915,
0.5704268217086792,
0.11046520620584488,
-0.4329912066459656,
0.3263466954231262,
-0.05561523512005806,
0.1703561544418335,
0.023254994302988052,
0.6650000810623169,
0.09461438655853271,
-0.17147822678089142,
0.33213576674461365,
0.35372209548950195,
-0.3795699179172516,
-0.20479927957057953,
0.3354354798793793,
-0.9228618144989014,
-0.3329581618309021,
0.8265784978866577,
0.11811351776123047,
-0.26087743043899536,
0.03662586957216263,
-0.22337305545806885,
0.11656152456998825,
-0.04995281249284744,
0.7608538269996643,
0.8843039274215698,
-0.39254868030548096,
0.22412288188934326,
-0.34022998809814453,
0.12936949729919434,
0.7151400446891785,
-0.697056233882904,
-0.33029550313949585,
0.5836564302444458,
0.222986102104187,
0.5882397294044495,
0.5835798978805542,
-0.1550743132829666,
0.38813284039497375,
0.09107998758554459,
0.20586183667182922,
0.24275951087474823,
-0.3397902548313141,
-0.13347773253917694,
0.40671995282173157,
-0.18569137156009674,
0.13058672845363617
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14336v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14336v1 | Exploring Spatial Representations in the Historical Lake District Texts with LLM-based Relation Extraction | 2024-06-20T14:04:59 | 2024-06-20T14:04:59 | Erum Haris, Anthony G. Cohn, John G. Stell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Navigating historical narratives poses a challenge in unveiling the spatial
intricacies of past landscapes. The proposed work addresses this challenge
within the context of the English Lake District, employing the Corpus of the
Lake District Writing. The method utilizes a generative pre-trained transformer
model to extract spatial relations from the textual descriptions in the corpus.
The study applies this large language model to understand the spatial
dimensions inherent in historical narratives comprehensively. The outcomes are
presented as semantic triples, capturing the nuanced connections between
entities and locations, and visualized as a network, offering a graphical
representation of the spatial narrative. The study contributes to a deeper
comprehension of the English Lake District's spatial tapestry and provides an
approach to uncovering spatial relations within diverse historical contexts. | [
-0.583807110786438,
-0.6509464979171753,
1.1215019226074219,
-0.1633659154176712,
0.03711321949958801,
-0.24285414814949036,
0.02580520138144493,
-0.5698928236961365,
0.28852134943008423,
0.7527379393577576,
-0.7091315984725952,
-0.7139332294464111,
-0.585760772228241,
-0.14532040059566498,
-0.15992459654808044,
0.508881151676178,
-0.4132925868034363,
-0.08125890791416168,
0.01416976097971201,
-0.4139355421066284,
-0.6105130314826965,
-0.9884405136108398,
-0.19897906482219696,
-0.3468312919139862,
0.6937704086303711,
-0.06052256375551224,
0.8484238386154175,
0.7390422224998474,
0.7031561136245728,
0.2557998597621918,
-0.3670422434806824,
0.36412179470062256,
-0.34185025095939636,
0.42908596992492676,
-0.451322078704834,
-0.31237927079200745,
-0.39068061113357544,
0.006434636190533638,
0.586674153804779,
0.5975584983825684,
0.3067454397678375,
0.035032451152801514,
-0.33001163601875305,
0.6802414059638977,
-0.6932796835899353,
0.20658613741397858,
-0.5604782700538635,
0.45244911313056946,
-0.3195563852787018,
-0.49941372871398926,
-0.33129438757896423,
-0.19154618680477142,
0.09617478400468826,
-0.6130931973457336,
0.3994055390357971,
0.28706446290016174,
1.1188088655471802,
-0.21682757139205933,
-0.5712519288063049,
-0.4157390296459198,
-0.9923564791679382,
0.5784068703651428,
-0.33003586530685425,
0.1795569658279419,
0.687930703163147,
0.374085009098053,
0.021350478753447533,
-0.6824992895126343,
-0.429397314786911,
-0.06241356208920479,
-0.5121229290962219,
0.33231595158576965,
-0.07076350599527359,
-0.6667141914367676,
0.28699418902397156,
0.20525696873664856,
-0.38031280040740967,
0.05809932202100754,
-0.4974737763404846,
0.07675693929195404,
0.8150335550308228,
0.586760938167572,
0.7537556886672974,
-0.4950580894947052,
-0.5657795071601868,
-0.09131863713264465,
-1.1221073865890503,
-0.07658382505178452,
0.027804352343082428,
0.38023972511291504,
-0.03852926194667816,
0.6680561900138855,
0.5995184183120728,
0.28822967410087585,
-0.12323243916034698,
0.018525946885347366,
-0.03698136657476425,
-0.5184388160705566,
0.1994483768939972,
0.011531967669725418,
0.8517976403236389,
0.5496265888214111,
0.32336974143981934,
-0.315599650144577,
-0.33114731311798096,
-0.45288175344467163,
0.3914085030555725,
-0.25421494245529175,
-0.2371273785829544,
-0.290464848279953,
-0.34115710854530334,
0.07387613505125046,
0.21520277857780457,
-0.9098845720291138,
-0.33167290687561035,
-0.16773004829883575,
0.16675503551959991,
-0.5981760025024414,
-0.4832731783390045,
-0.3648979961872101,
-0.2962527871131897,
0.5397354960441589,
0.2860454022884369,
-1.1938667297363281,
0.24526157975196838,
0.6989656090736389,
0.9586036801338196,
-0.06797435879707336,
-0.7186692953109741,
-0.06270626187324524,
1.0560083389282227,
-0.4186662435531616,
0.7235422134399414,
-0.4202818274497986,
-0.6696789860725403,
0.1962331235408783,
0.042575206607580185,
0.08911172300577164,
-0.6211973428726196,
0.46419987082481384,
-0.8724873065948486,
-0.01007007621228695,
-0.13577240705490112,
-0.29826509952545166,
-0.04238438978791237,
0.10819186270236969,
-1.1461251974105835,
1.146344542503357,
-0.03722981736063957,
-0.7022953629493713,
0.22483031451702118,
-0.4899999797344208,
-0.44441232085227966,
-0.05029507353901863,
-0.1968098282814026,
-0.2870054841041565,
0.1237049400806427,
0.8028324842453003,
0.38619086146354675,
0.21853362023830414,
0.34726497530937195,
-0.20943033695220947,
-0.03761482611298561,
0.08384595066308975,
0.1314048320055008,
0.5686225891113281,
0.17857898771762848,
-0.2614527642726898,
-0.11202393472194672,
-0.49956533312797546,
-0.45658883452415466,
0.09905220568180084,
-0.008006437681615353,
-0.5867084860801697,
0.21281543374061584,
-0.04393894597887993,
-0.1440429389476776,
0.3056305944919586,
-0.30111706256866455,
0.2000850886106491,
-0.43158042430877686,
-0.1277184635400772,
0.5858301520347595,
0.12906363606452942,
1.1738730669021606,
-0.21870720386505127,
0.5062775015830994,
0.35906529426574707,
-0.27123308181762695,
-0.4104824960231781,
-0.14531166851520538,
-0.3098588287830353,
-0.13227935135364532,
-0.13182960450649261,
0.4264848232269287,
-0.7429971694946289,
0.4411780834197998,
-0.7002847194671631,
-0.5389747023582458,
-0.19513766467571259,
0.02345619909465313,
-0.2144400030374527,
0.31999439001083374,
0.41761550307273865,
0.4424169063568115,
-0.6162985563278198,
-0.7566273212432861,
0.0922955721616745,
-0.32603883743286133,
0.026808181777596474,
0.5289322137832642,
0.36398929357528687,
-0.1775994449853897,
1.2893638610839844,
-0.6623007655143738,
-0.5210019946098328,
-0.2905239760875702,
0.01729828305542469,
0.21898582577705383,
0.1419985592365265,
0.7740896344184875,
-0.9519705176353455,
-0.35722285509109497,
0.4691699147224426,
-0.8114986419677734,
-0.1421838402748108,
-0.048315759748220444,
-0.5429396629333496,
-0.01765941083431244,
0.3880311846733093,
-0.6475222110748291,
0.6771344542503357,
0.20645372569561005,
-0.39995595812797546,
0.4148488938808441,
-0.35783591866493225,
0.19217874109745026,
-1.0435986518859863,
-0.1222401112318039,
-0.11942337453365326,
0.04474338889122009,
-0.30695641040802,
0.20336569845676422,
0.2086750566959381,
-0.2851257622241974,
-0.2684106230735779,
0.5099479556083679,
-0.7172482013702393,
-0.21636521816253662,
0.21592392027378082,
0.7361831665039062,
-0.020804790779948235,
0.13605913519859314,
0.4521547853946686,
0.2670399248600006,
0.3518373370170593,
-0.27077898383140564,
0.3431771993637085,
0.36196961998939514,
0.023440102115273476,
0.125136137008667,
0.022154774516820908,
0.06673519313335419,
-0.3002629280090332,
0.011707857251167297,
-1.123663306236267,
-0.003077103290706873,
-0.05561187490820885,
-0.1523488461971283,
0.22524426877498627,
-0.1538166105747223,
-0.8142062425613403,
-0.2167634218931198,
-0.1835591048002243,
0.5162308216094971,
0.2276107668876648,
-0.6838140487670898,
1.0673837661743164,
0.6157981753349304,
-0.2045501321554184,
-0.0398377999663353,
-0.716855525970459,
0.07188329845666885,
-0.4403594732284546,
-0.676080048084259,
0.17324094474315643,
0.20226196944713593,
-0.5258831977844238,
0.03425627574324608,
0.1321612447500229,
-0.8049104809761047,
-0.06081388145685196,
0.4999086558818817,
0.6662408709526062,
-0.5326710939407349,
-0.1255587339401245,
-0.2856035530567169,
0.028018565848469734,
0.2840253710746765,
0.2640467882156372,
0.31950125098228455,
0.3455825448036194,
-0.23208022117614746,
-0.47067755460739136,
0.5959420204162598,
0.8052887916564941,
-0.03761645033955574,
0.6465626358985901,
0.4093226492404938,
-0.4126340448856354,
-0.14370793104171753,
-0.40380939841270447,
0.07907067239284515,
-0.350811630487442,
0.290481299161911,
-0.5938760638237,
-0.8251802325248718,
0.6377855539321899,
-0.2023186832666397,
-0.07722611725330353,
0.769792914390564,
0.277391254901886,
-0.4520680904388428,
0.24797534942626953,
0.2851986289024353,
-0.21456104516983032,
0.1506987065076828,
-0.19738449156284332,
0.5199339985847473,
-0.68719083070755,
-0.6044371724128723,
-0.3569033741950989,
-0.5031415224075317,
-0.04838753119111061,
-0.11933225393295288,
0.32220447063446045,
0.3545253872871399,
-0.2278740555047989,
0.41581934690475464,
0.017978942021727562,
0.5039030313491821,
0.2087171971797943,
0.10562890022993088,
0.251625120639801,
0.08667048811912537,
0.12726755440235138,
-0.6556528806686401,
-0.43099191784858704,
-0.781709611415863,
0.7447417974472046,
0.3355315625667572,
0.5610486268997192,
0.7167043089866638,
0.8564091324806213,
0.25002601742744446,
0.4036206007003784,
-0.5376845002174377,
0.5273219347000122,
-0.12425335496664047,
-0.2072300761938095,
-0.2516479790210724,
-0.2658241093158722,
-1.1376559734344482,
0.18043269217014313,
-0.20083627104759216,
-0.7681281566619873,
0.03441334888339043,
-0.24450473487377167,
-0.6133010983467102,
0.7482532858848572,
-0.7434523105621338,
0.4159635901451111,
-0.2372158020734787,
-0.28183868527412415,
0.032688211649656296,
-0.5765236020088196,
0.2352554202079773,
-0.25853198766708374,
0.7564331889152527,
0.01190344337373972,
0.050137221813201904,
0.253776490688324,
-0.28036463260650635,
0.823521614074707,
-0.07145223766565323,
-0.2905557453632355,
0.0767437294125557,
0.6273399591445923,
0.28018584847450256,
-0.34788399934768677,
-0.03304881975054741,
0.17762978374958038,
0.21461546421051025,
-0.11432921141386032,
-0.6820720434188843,
0.7789612412452698,
-1.0698084831237793,
-0.5115562081336975,
-0.1250353306531906,
-0.85586017370224,
0.021942803636193275,
-0.254597008228302,
-0.0921284481883049,
0.7234203815460205,
-0.2402445673942566,
-0.3928243815898895,
0.3113187551498413,
-0.11420396715402603,
0.8228433132171631,
0.18103298544883728,
-0.8134704828262329,
-0.2847153842449188,
0.23698990046977997,
0.19670400023460388,
-0.15002882480621338,
0.7384132146835327,
-0.02840236760675907,
-0.46160879731178284,
-0.4680913984775543,
0.04732364043593407,
0.24130424857139587,
-0.7019602060317993,
-0.21700319647789001,
-0.2530483305454254,
-0.36275577545166016,
-0.432400643825531,
-0.5267929434776306,
-0.09217546135187149,
-0.08349596709012985,
-0.5452953577041626,
-0.3308286666870117,
0.2355656921863556,
1.5848126411437988,
-0.09823939949274063,
0.18672332167625427,
-1.0933799743652344,
0.2805154025554657,
-0.1559734344482422,
-0.12578816711902618,
0.20613841712474823,
-0.32124143838882446,
-0.20358380675315857,
-0.3189336061477661,
-0.316340833902359,
-1.0914355516433716,
0.8065763115882874,
-0.19207970798015594,
0.5144824981689453,
0.27373602986335754,
-0.04592800512909889,
0.9509450197219849,
-0.9679496884346008,
1.0389937162399292,
0.3086402416229248,
-0.41351455450057983,
0.8764830231666565,
-0.0985775962471962,
0.33279451727867126,
-0.11192411929368973,
0.6182087659835815,
-0.12988309562206268,
-0.26803964376449585,
-0.5171712636947632,
-1.295500636100769,
0.4483248293399811,
-0.025478001683950424,
0.28727686405181885,
-0.3654676079750061,
0.6790297627449036,
0.09314190596342087,
-0.6119246482849121,
-1.0466282367706299,
-0.2933836281299591,
0.13730263710021973,
-0.01268092729151249,
-0.18743552267551422,
-0.7762026786804199,
-0.028010236099362373,
-0.3152175545692444,
0.3113662600517273,
0.5959417223930359,
-0.14009058475494385,
0.3612014651298523,
-0.4886087477207184,
0.2377682328224182,
0.1283116340637207,
0.33799460530281067,
1.0491634607315063,
-0.04618177190423012,
0.7979590892791748,
0.20985223352909088,
-0.4009084403514862,
-0.0785321444272995,
-0.16150042414665222,
-0.08157246559858322,
0.3572632968425751,
0.893974781036377,
0.5866879820823669,
0.5873715877532959,
-0.20167209208011627,
0.4575924277305603,
0.2187546044588089,
-0.13271160423755646,
-0.4351572096347809,
-0.2638440728187561,
0.23887069523334503,
0.6086488962173462,
0.8503022789955139,
-0.1053338274359703,
-0.24879510700702667,
-0.44094768166542053,
0.2094159722328186,
0.2389306128025055,
-0.5399828553199768,
-0.2567744255065918,
0.44984787702560425,
-0.026450518518686295,
-0.5758957862854004,
0.6425220966339111,
0.23509511351585388,
-0.47944265604019165,
0.31922584772109985,
0.5910048484802246,
0.595626950263977,
0.05143902450799942,
0.031247541308403015,
0.7775928378105164,
0.17414014041423798,
0.4503924548625946,
-0.2682228684425354,
-0.09637094289064407,
-0.8255689144134521,
-0.21988341212272644,
-0.7603216171264648,
0.11497284471988678,
-0.053738467395305634,
-0.6827300190925598,
0.06221739202737808,
-0.2868085205554962,
-0.2843376696109772,
-0.2000996321439743,
-0.28512901067733765,
-0.3101424276828766,
-0.3358120322227478,
0.3684634268283844,
0.8992639183998108,
-0.6630173325538635,
0.7709900140762329,
0.7200955152511597,
-0.2572697401046753,
-0.7128660082817078,
-0.02796825021505356,
-0.163370281457901,
-0.6245060563087463,
1.6869580745697021,
-0.19818909466266632,
-0.44361254572868347,
-0.12166694551706314,
-0.4873557686805725,
-0.5315061211585999,
1.36179518699646,
0.07081082463264465,
-0.7113021016120911,
0.12300382554531097,
0.3493485748767853,
0.5732479691505432,
-0.45715031027793884,
-0.12040094286203384,
0.345071017742157,
0.26304110884666443,
0.21864834427833557,
-0.6628787517547607,
-0.17272447049617767,
-0.0180208757519722,
0.20384307205677032,
0.4197119474411011,
0.10328400135040283,
0.4282611906528473,
-0.3350470960140228,
-0.6963305473327637,
0.39295509457588196,
0.8499385118484497,
0.2804100811481476,
0.23292899131774902,
0.09373326599597931,
0.6504983305931091,
0.6195057034492493,
-0.31848278641700745,
1.2879126071929932,
-0.10644423961639404,
0.5036658048629761,
1.0698177814483643,
-0.5617175698280334,
1.1524356603622437,
0.8380470871925354,
-0.37026581168174744,
0.6472488641738892,
0.5261070728302002,
0.13248741626739502,
0.794559895992279,
0.15520840883255005,
-0.8218269944190979,
0.11326464265584946,
-0.030509743839502335,
-0.12757834792137146,
0.18435196578502655,
0.023076539859175682,
-0.42451199889183044,
-0.6675871014595032,
-0.25656765699386597,
0.18229295313358307,
0.5227437615394592,
-0.8218414783477783,
0.8244417905807495,
0.003647245466709137,
-0.25872039794921875,
-0.16720212996006012,
-0.47305989265441895,
0.29581767320632935,
-0.7981395125389099,
-0.21480506658554077,
-0.24673616886138916,
0.16073545813560486,
0.012902745045721531,
-1.2201193571090698,
0.6140554547309875,
-0.25437110662460327,
-0.5466041564941406,
-0.6884248852729797,
0.49380263686180115,
-0.6076093316078186,
-0.37160319089889526,
0.584903359413147,
0.6243165135383606,
0.07562921941280365,
0.3733406662940979,
-0.06409582495689392,
0.11705395579338074,
-0.07047408819198608,
0.023575110360980034,
0.09862828254699707,
1.1458783149719238,
0.17902089655399323,
0.18471302092075348,
0.4167616367340088,
0.3285294771194458,
0.00008184303442249075,
0.11633910238742828,
0.5348508358001709,
-1.1683003902435303,
-0.19147174060344696,
-1.3041075468063354,
0.39603716135025024,
0.09109607338905334,
0.04611589387059212,
0.7379482984542847,
0.7181931734085083,
0.4753495454788208,
-0.13951152563095093,
0.33724379539489746,
0.20972658693790436,
0.08574695885181427,
-0.6781643033027649,
0.7830139398574829,
-0.07714413851499557,
0.3704683482646942,
0.05760081112384796,
-0.6878846287727356,
-0.5838472247123718,
0.6578129529953003,
-0.5724297761917114,
-0.34575721621513367,
0.8645089864730835,
0.6141102313995361,
0.06652752310037613,
0.14442072808742523,
0.48549994826316833,
0.3838086724281311,
0.06650404632091522,
0.4495348334312439,
1.4516913890838623,
-0.08786214888095856,
0.2888328731060028,
-0.06513476371765137,
-0.011219730600714684,
0.6831257343292236,
-0.8930119872093201,
-0.679831862449646,
-0.9402564764022827,
0.06224768981337547,
-0.086219921708107,
-0.024899091571569443,
0.3244726061820984,
0.3714768588542938,
-0.5384001731872559,
-0.6271767020225525,
0.5969037413597107,
0.004232004284858704,
0.38047879934310913,
-0.3199213743209839,
0.8723165988922119,
-0.19991298019886017,
-0.5138945579528809,
0.21997207403182983,
0.7332947254180908,
0.2742934823036194,
-0.14144669473171234,
-0.13560450077056885,
-0.40135863423347473,
-0.7279614806175232,
0.8907371759414673,
-0.11940120160579681,
-0.7084604501724243,
-0.36023420095443726,
-0.24275806546211243,
-0.1763966977596283,
0.28765466809272766,
0.9847960472106934,
-0.6403368711471558,
0.16968145966529846,
-0.04939132183790207,
0.5831791162490845,
0.9791526198387146,
-0.24022085964679718,
0.7421779632568359,
-0.8161330223083496,
0.021613135933876038,
0.08237301558256149,
0.7486246824264526,
0.41059425473213196,
-0.4185347855091095,
0.45866045355796814,
0.3091162443161011,
-0.3133290112018585,
-0.20691780745983124,
-0.06693821400403976,
-1.0176352262496948,
-0.4130828082561493,
1.1773488521575928,
-0.2660551965236664,
-0.2147698551416397,
-0.15301521122455597,
-0.47670742869377136,
-0.09988444298505783,
0.13136103749275208,
0.6231061220169067,
1.0262837409973145,
-0.24629496037960052,
-0.4461820721626282,
-0.5653015971183777,
-0.0764424130320549,
-0.1290649175643921,
-0.5743048787117004,
0.10492274165153503,
0.9865207672119141,
-0.028467712923884392,
0.4833128750324249,
0.6592903137207031,
-0.4226152300834656,
-0.3438883125782013,
-0.22259369492530823,
0.01935572177171707,
0.22707834839820862,
-0.09852278232574463,
0.005952015984803438,
0.5466985702514648,
-0.2620251476764679,
0.0751994326710701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14335v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14335v1 | Self-supervised Interpretable Concept-based Models for Text Classification | 2024-06-20T14:04:53 | 2024-06-20T14:04:53 | Francesco De Santis, Philippe Bich, Gabriele Ciravegna, Pietro Barbiero, Danilo Giordano, Tania Cerquitelli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite their success, Large-Language Models (LLMs) still face criticism as
their lack of interpretability limits their controllability and reliability.
Traditional post-hoc interpretation methods, based on attention and
gradient-based analysis, offer limited insight into the model's decision-making
processes. In the image field, Concept-based models have emerged as
explainable-by-design architectures, employing human-interpretable features as
intermediate representations. However, these methods have not been yet adapted
to textual data, mainly because they require expensive concept annotations,
which are impractical for real-world text data. This paper addresses this
challenge by proposing a self-supervised Interpretable Concept Embedding Models
(ICEMs). We leverage the generalization abilities of LLMs to predict the
concepts labels in a self-supervised way, while we deliver the final
predictions with an interpretable function. The results of our experiments show
that ICEMs can be trained in a self-supervised way achieving similar
performance to fully supervised concept-based models and end-to-end black-box
ones. Additionally, we show that our models are (i) interpretable, offering
meaningful logical explanations for their predictions; (ii) interactable,
allowing humans to modify intermediate predictions through concept
interventions; and (iii) controllable, guiding the LLMs' decoding process to
follow a required decision-making path. | [
-0.09300746023654938,
-0.542447566986084,
0.7045225501060486,
0.056567221879959106,
-0.5061238408088684,
-0.025569366291165352,
-0.024095457047224045,
-0.613672137260437,
0.23289702832698822,
0.8107245564460754,
-0.4581640064716339,
-0.7386090159416199,
-0.6297438144683838,
0.08464305102825165,
-0.5792286992073059,
1.0686228275299072,
-0.33511993288993835,
-0.2785455286502838,
-0.4647250771522522,
0.04128054156899452,
-0.3943541646003723,
-0.49944791197776794,
-0.3503165543079376,
-0.35359981656074524,
0.1592528223991394,
0.37898725271224976,
0.6394215822219849,
0.9005683660507202,
0.4873340129852295,
0.23999272286891937,
-0.02704787068068981,
0.09031439572572708,
-0.2110012024641037,
0.031120438128709793,
-0.3193388283252716,
-0.5236471891403198,
-0.36940643191337585,
0.2390976995229721,
0.3672754764556885,
0.35963496565818787,
-0.1952821910381317,
-0.00376428896561265,
0.1340736597776413,
0.26442331075668335,
-0.28266334533691406,
0.41946762800216675,
-0.5946564078330994,
0.204451322555542,
0.21580711007118225,
-0.18653874099254608,
-0.5817481279373169,
0.18486802279949188,
0.2763942778110504,
-0.5940463542938232,
0.27718520164489746,
0.2238433063030243,
0.5618306994438171,
0.5309050679206848,
-0.2750140130519867,
-0.6456729769706726,
-0.6165494918823242,
0.7075208425521851,
-0.4229918420314789,
0.3407355844974518,
0.6158928275108337,
0.032260674983263016,
-0.004615302197635174,
-0.6846349239349365,
-0.46553054451942444,
-0.047916751354932785,
-0.2972469925880432,
0.2525307834148407,
-0.0950268805027008,
0.030323131009936333,
-0.2860720455646515,
0.2902940809726715,
-0.3814615309238434,
0.38414233922958374,
-0.235024556517601,
-0.13816995918750763,
0.6342703700065613,
0.2035638988018036,
0.3157865107059479,
-0.33901020884513855,
-0.6257585287094116,
0.3622661232948303,
-0.341136634349823,
-0.11654826253652573,
-0.1915915459394455,
0.13155630230903625,
-0.3671695291996002,
0.5626279711723328,
-0.07567958533763885,
0.646960437297821,
0.046105414628982544,
0.02439545840024948,
0.1048334389925003,
-0.014838416129350662,
-0.36870506405830383,
0.08984546363353729,
0.82731693983078,
0.29770079255104065,
0.20854638516902924,
-0.32335221767425537,
-0.12436796724796295,
0.012792197056114674,
0.3972448408603668,
-0.9195606112480164,
-0.38914617896080017,
0.24183012545108795,
-0.6585420370101929,
-0.5478013753890991,
-0.1416967660188675,
-0.6085599064826965,
-0.19646325707435608,
-0.3907216191291809,
0.42289215326309204,
-0.4290902018547058,
-0.21821853518486023,
0.41314035654067993,
0.03998228535056114,
0.03375477343797684,
0.6091090440750122,
-0.860319197177887,
0.24524596333503723,
0.44460228085517883,
1.1028525829315186,
-0.39120063185691833,
-0.1215205043554306,
-0.019632600247859955,
0.49484777450561523,
-0.5326240062713623,
0.9546053409576416,
-0.7992398142814636,
-0.3606971800327301,
-0.25193455815315247,
-0.11330059170722961,
0.025306273251771927,
-0.20610302686691284,
0.49503055214881897,
-0.5546205639839172,
0.1841113120317459,
0.3805917501449585,
-0.8855202198028564,
-0.1489284187555313,
0.16350063681602478,
-0.5026761889457703,
0.6315733790397644,
-0.1984012871980667,
-0.9427652359008789,
0.14384514093399048,
-0.766255259513855,
-0.3352084755897522,
0.1864473819732666,
-0.3384030759334564,
-0.46933600306510925,
0.19117267429828644,
0.2716776132583618,
1.0855493545532227,
-0.361186146736145,
0.27896469831466675,
-0.44217365980148315,
-0.21127870678901672,
0.38242200016975403,
-0.26499560475349426,
0.2885515093803406,
0.35247600078582764,
-0.1503320187330246,
0.07081221044063568,
-0.6924120783805847,
-0.2253255546092987,
0.1730208694934845,
-0.016358545050024986,
-0.564812958240509,
0.1648910790681839,
-0.24342793226242065,
0.29080918431282043,
0.23107317090034485,
-0.44950634241104126,
0.03727252036333084,
-0.12268710136413574,
0.5613183975219727,
0.8031421303749084,
-0.12169966101646423,
0.5843369960784912,
-0.01767566055059433,
0.6358649134635925,
0.25114062428474426,
-0.1737654060125351,
-0.47642824053764343,
-0.4500828981399536,
-0.658426821231842,
-0.6549044251441956,
0.21314282715320587,
0.41514429450035095,
-0.8586901426315308,
0.47396120429039,
-0.3342714011669159,
-0.5319100618362427,
-0.5759406089782715,
0.17384952306747437,
0.26055577397346497,
0.6862640380859375,
0.5119168162345886,
-0.08103036135435104,
-0.0265539288520813,
-0.9157735109329224,
-0.16742168366909027,
-0.07564927637577057,
-0.045559708029031754,
0.1847517192363739,
0.6595759391784668,
-0.45709094405174255,
1.0021092891693115,
-0.7558260560035706,
-0.5848667025566101,
-0.140251025557518,
0.3514968454837799,
0.08435115963220596,
0.469260573387146,
0.17106664180755615,
-0.8347350358963013,
-0.2875259220600128,
-0.03534132242202759,
-1.0741124153137207,
-0.011707787401974201,
-0.3418094515800476,
0.16495157778263092,
-0.11228048801422119,
0.8322170972824097,
-0.39682936668395996,
0.5066924095153809,
0.47494029998779297,
-0.4036184549331665,
0.484424889087677,
-0.3747444748878479,
-0.2124958038330078,
-0.8774901032447815,
-0.25472554564476013,
0.41159725189208984,
-0.3118571639060974,
-0.5362451672554016,
0.007163898553699255,
0.24599403142929077,
-0.02943246439099312,
-0.22036254405975342,
0.8072865605354309,
-0.47451627254486084,
-0.05111237242817879,
-0.4270237386226654,
-0.015077854506671429,
0.15371626615524292,
0.3435826599597931,
0.6056081652641296,
0.49862152338027954,
0.6205541491508484,
-0.6186789870262146,
0.1555931270122528,
0.43285566568374634,
-0.511840283870697,
0.6892421841621399,
-0.6338326334953308,
0.1413879692554474,
-0.36608946323394775,
0.3750506639480591,
-0.939137876033783,
-0.12045399844646454,
0.4545478820800781,
-0.4149463474750519,
0.358274906873703,
-0.2456795573234558,
-0.37120333313941956,
-0.1345755010843277,
0.015442512929439545,
0.2505491077899933,
0.21582560241222382,
-0.7538082003593445,
0.8189885020256042,
0.3278564512729645,
-0.1383177936077118,
-0.4023415446281433,
-0.8909602761268616,
0.14391674101352692,
-0.3551662564277649,
-0.2466939091682434,
0.48852524161338806,
-0.18051700294017792,
0.09989725798368454,
0.34376078844070435,
0.06142258644104004,
-0.2138574719429016,
0.17925713956356049,
0.4389725625514984,
0.39102235436439514,
0.05642157420516014,
0.6727315187454224,
0.20400147140026093,
-0.1721121221780777,
0.08779329061508179,
-0.5335372090339661,
0.0868682935833931,
-0.0250630434602499,
-0.011845014058053493,
-0.6851049065589905,
0.06078463792800903,
0.3314986824989319,
-0.42468154430389404,
0.7192099094390869,
0.5611439943313599,
-0.4545578956604004,
-0.39621371030807495,
-0.2266172170639038,
-0.040507882833480835,
-0.47357839345932007,
0.3330669105052948,
-0.7700947523117065,
-1.1018576622009277,
0.2640479803085327,
-0.1998482197523117,
-0.17371691763401031,
0.597534716129303,
0.45946475863456726,
-0.7052554488182068,
0.8258554935455322,
0.6253849267959595,
0.012744789943099022,
0.2797231078147888,
-0.2923620939254761,
-0.03427806869149208,
-0.804098904132843,
-0.295392781496048,
-0.29513898491859436,
-0.043707169592380524,
-0.6176952123641968,
-0.5244045257568359,
0.04375479370355606,
0.04242542013525963,
0.0041976021602749825,
-0.04638165980577469,
-0.6219042539596558,
0.42414382100105286,
0.1310303956270218,
0.26088571548461914,
0.37288859486579895,
0.15590626001358032,
-0.1239006444811821,
-0.08951014280319214,
-0.5736607313156128,
-0.5991551280021667,
1.078494906425476,
0.7552752494812012,
1.146868109703064,
-0.2956564128398895,
0.6735327839851379,
0.5367129445075989,
0.6279380321502686,
-0.8618608117103577,
0.22833383083343506,
-0.37810227274894714,
-0.6359968781471252,
-0.45263364911079407,
-0.49860477447509766,
-0.9003087282180786,
0.3986586928367615,
-0.3186414837837219,
-0.7677571773529053,
0.1052587628364563,
0.15039165318012238,
-0.048361439257860184,
0.3224989175796509,
-0.6054307222366333,
0.8284772634506226,
-0.3095037341117859,
-0.055373530834913254,
-0.38174402713775635,
-0.38189497590065,
0.36802908778190613,
-0.3635355830192566,
0.7474325895309448,
-0.10017910599708557,
-0.23425966501235962,
0.7533006072044373,
0.006033293902873993,
1.2058348655700684,
0.033305227756500244,
-0.21668052673339844,
0.3269028961658478,
0.19516484439373016,
0.2258118838071823,
-0.08508448302745819,
-0.048539239913225174,
0.3046098053455353,
-0.06025315448641777,
-0.32421818375587463,
-0.7237340211868286,
0.523611307144165,
-0.8844748139381409,
-0.6341065764427185,
-0.3753340244293213,
-0.40719687938690186,
-0.009801274165511131,
0.11535055935382843,
0.10939251631498337,
0.5172328948974609,
-0.17258092761039734,
0.07221702486276627,
0.6393782496452332,
-0.10969579219818115,
0.18428093194961548,
0.4310009479522705,
-0.43495115637779236,
-0.26315614581108093,
1.051694393157959,
0.05433465912938118,
0.12739123404026031,
0.5995486974716187,
0.24913744628429413,
-0.41567644476890564,
-0.7964726090431213,
-0.2581476867198944,
0.2042306512594223,
-0.7972393035888672,
-0.11769787222146988,
-0.809592604637146,
-0.1545349657535553,
-0.14642205834388733,
-0.1786918342113495,
-0.1938614696264267,
-0.4177389144897461,
-0.8052607178688049,
-0.25656601786613464,
0.1887192577123642,
1.0058934688568115,
-0.08895479887723923,
0.6623765230178833,
-0.6026777029037476,
0.49860575795173645,
0.3185105621814728,
0.6302732229232788,
-0.028794433921575546,
-0.8793559074401855,
-0.5017057061195374,
-0.1642128974199295,
-0.0597350187599659,
-0.7444019317626953,
0.4207361936569214,
0.25553086400032043,
0.35600927472114563,
0.40121397376060486,
0.11740980297327042,
0.18499653041362762,
-0.3486860692501068,
0.2672045826911926,
0.26950550079345703,
-1.0526494979858398,
0.6864228248596191,
-0.14365585148334503,
0.18158307671546936,
0.033324070274829865,
0.5838037729263306,
-0.4224412739276886,
-0.21508747339248657,
-0.5057969093322754,
-0.3673553466796875,
0.8155282139778137,
0.05628043785691261,
0.2811261713504791,
0.07554441690444946,
0.7031196355819702,
0.18932339549064636,
0.0779668539762497,
-0.742404043674469,
-0.14123883843421936,
-0.540133535861969,
-0.5628224611282349,
-0.41661831736564636,
-0.35452568531036377,
0.21162638068199158,
0.10732708871364594,
0.4317336082458496,
-0.4094668924808502,
0.17832094430923462,
0.36403247714042664,
-0.3402603566646576,
-0.012094719335436821,
0.21563628315925598,
0.14893412590026855,
0.3885209560394287,
-0.34816062450408936,
0.4139331579208374,
0.03745434805750847,
-0.2166856974363327,
0.2985215485095978,
0.0698854997754097,
-0.17754004895687103,
-0.16093774139881134,
0.502052903175354,
0.8060311079025269,
0.15860377252101898,
-0.4171539843082428,
0.3767717182636261,
-0.3470945954322815,
-0.06890164315700531,
-0.15197549760341644,
0.03967806696891785,
0.22259066998958588,
0.20242910087108612,
0.35404688119888306,
-0.13230262696743011,
0.2633676826953888,
-0.466465562582016,
0.16690927743911743,
0.3730581998825073,
-0.5991069674491882,
-0.3436994254589081,
0.5820707082748413,
0.26268112659454346,
-0.08062202483415604,
0.4110640585422516,
-0.11379075050354004,
-0.46683216094970703,
0.6213932037353516,
0.6063534021377563,
0.7878654599189758,
-0.3544171154499054,
0.6925581097602844,
0.06783505529165268,
0.3677033483982086,
0.0711010992527008,
-0.020571671426296234,
0.029774868860840797,
-1.1950947046279907,
-0.34132128953933716,
-0.6574767827987671,
-0.469215989112854,
0.08317568898200989,
-0.6791365146636963,
0.14966534078121185,
-0.513714075088501,
-0.0012195295421406627,
0.3701745271682739,
-0.3439156711101532,
-0.7597418427467346,
0.8277114033699036,
0.15854062139987946,
0.8728418946266174,
-0.8521882891654968,
0.9603300094604492,
0.8002952337265015,
-0.2092103809118271,
-0.2198338806629181,
-0.09584487229585648,
-0.2680000066757202,
-0.8101046681404114,
0.7008917927742004,
0.2666599750518799,
-0.16959136724472046,
0.16915908455848694,
-0.7894555330276489,
-0.8240925669670105,
1.013674259185791,
0.13683389127254486,
-0.4784528315067291,
-0.06962306052446365,
0.06949099898338318,
0.707648515701294,
-0.7534672617912292,
0.2282581478357315,
0.3373169004917145,
0.15653252601623535,
0.19212983548641205,
-0.5086423754692078,
0.0640118345618248,
0.008360533975064754,
-0.02612381801009178,
-0.2191518098115921,
-0.5061915516853333,
0.37470969557762146,
-0.34380751848220825,
-0.23699429631233215,
-0.15396374464035034,
0.9826022982597351,
-0.032451968640089035,
0.27990540862083435,
0.47941914200782776,
0.5483181476593018,
0.6414482593536377,
0.21834006905555725,
1.1313071250915527,
-0.25413158535957336,
0.44024011492729187,
1.3193538188934326,
0.08914568275213242,
0.9134615063667297,
0.05748293921351433,
-0.0033940947614610195,
0.5891505479812622,
0.7664692997932434,
-0.126595139503479,
0.6063914895057678,
0.030950121581554413,
0.16672226786613464,
-0.6886393427848816,
-0.31013432145118713,
0.02918759174644947,
0.7691906094551086,
0.8140736818313599,
-0.5737344026565552,
0.11368177086114883,
-0.06391007453203201,
-0.14901991188526154,
0.005015702452510595,
-0.48274528980255127,
0.6697479486465454,
0.3636963963508606,
-0.21766328811645508,
0.25393685698509216,
0.13526709377765656,
0.7622991800308228,
-0.2907986640930176,
0.07496513426303864,
0.15242817997932434,
0.07833261042833328,
-0.2692497670650482,
-1.1149184703826904,
0.12631577253341675,
-0.2256973534822464,
-0.1841271072626114,
-0.22910919785499573,
0.9756986498832703,
-0.4888491630554199,
-0.7081626653671265,
0.44056233763694763,
0.5995573997497559,
0.175799161195755,
-0.0620277114212513,
-0.7381334900856018,
-0.12857815623283386,
-0.06361854076385498,
-0.11691831052303314,
0.21450959146022797,
0.569667398929596,
-0.018440619111061096,
1.090198278427124,
0.3673582077026367,
-0.09136290103197098,
-0.3294171690940857,
-0.3249586224555969,
0.6379444003105164,
-0.8289042711257935,
-0.6968791484832764,
-0.8424297571182251,
0.2979111671447754,
0.21587783098220825,
-0.016964739188551903,
0.2101249247789383,
0.2276267558336258,
0.6684750318527222,
-0.07204244285821915,
1.0833591222763062,
0.4494040608406067,
0.4858883321285248,
-0.6754446029663086,
0.626449465751648,
-0.6170969009399414,
0.08636089414358139,
-0.18014277517795563,
-0.5215542316436768,
-0.24906758964061737,
0.5967047810554504,
-0.35783934593200684,
-0.03629482910037041,
0.4884498715400696,
0.22859834134578705,
-0.08549053221940994,
0.13943488895893097,
0.48072388768196106,
0.41371816396713257,
0.2949344515800476,
0.1802993267774582,
0.9798288941383362,
0.0474877767264843,
0.41678330302238464,
-0.14598588645458221,
-0.3080935776233673,
-0.17566880583763123,
-0.9614105820655823,
-1.1766724586486816,
-0.606450080871582,
-0.49021464586257935,
0.06125638261437416,
-0.13639818131923676,
0.6817610263824463,
0.7043017148971558,
-0.6877996325492859,
-0.055630430579185486,
0.0803399309515953,
0.2721082270145416,
0.26088792085647583,
-0.1859125792980194,
0.6265326738357544,
-0.320870578289032,
-0.5454626083374023,
0.10505133122205734,
0.38907697796821594,
0.38803917169570923,
-0.285840779542923,
-0.028807273134589195,
0.09423943608999252,
0.11025270074605942,
0.6140027642250061,
-0.09786581993103027,
-0.8289892673492432,
-0.25440099835395813,
-0.19800551235675812,
-0.10104376822710037,
0.1270252764225006,
0.5213660597801208,
-0.7327845692634583,
0.6703132390975952,
-0.08064083009958267,
0.7705463171005249,
0.7414986491203308,
-0.00513496482744813,
0.5555768609046936,
-0.433358758687973,
-0.18497294187545776,
0.11677725613117218,
0.4140476584434509,
0.4263842701911926,
-0.4493386745452881,
0.5225479602813721,
0.08722482621669769,
-0.36726075410842896,
-0.42070871591567993,
0.04941176250576973,
-0.6111407279968262,
-0.6257400512695312,
0.9802240133285522,
-0.5827600955963135,
-0.05079520121216774,
-0.16051055490970612,
-0.03685770556330681,
0.19914129376411438,
-0.31643301248550415,
0.866638720035553,
0.7545256018638611,
-0.057806238532066345,
-0.592117190361023,
-0.2997876703739166,
0.4111084043979645,
0.2205815613269806,
-1.0246464014053345,
0.054382067173719406,
0.4173829257488251,
0.30318471789360046,
0.06783590465784073,
0.44125279784202576,
0.13856029510498047,
-0.09164217114448547,
-0.38514941930770874,
0.1729021817445755,
-0.010217287577688694,
-0.4383698105812073,
-0.5276241302490234,
-0.019714098423719406,
0.09305921941995621,
-0.11746440827846527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14326v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14326v1 | medIKAL: Integrating Knowledge Graphs as Assistants of LLMs for Enhanced Clinical Diagnosis on EMRs | 2024-06-20T13:56:52 | 2024-06-20T13:56:52 | Mingyi Jia, Junwen Duan, Yan Song, Jianxin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Electronic Medical Records (EMRs), while integral to modern healthcare,
present challenges for clinical reasoning and diagnosis due to their complexity
and information redundancy. To address this, we proposed medIKAL (Integrating
Knowledge Graphs as Assistants of LLMs), a framework that combines Large
Language Models (LLMs) with knowledge graphs (KGs) to enhance diagnostic
capabilities. medIKAL assigns weighted importance to entities in medical
records based on their type, enabling precise localization of candidate
diseases within KGs. It innovatively employs a residual network-like approach,
allowing initial diagnosis by the LLM to be merged into KG search results.
Through a path-based reranking algorithm and a fill-in-the-blank style prompt
template, it further refined the diagnostic process. We validated medIKAL's
effectiveness through extensive experiments on a newly introduced open-sourced
Chinese EMR dataset, demonstrating its potential to improve clinical diagnosis
in real-world settings. | [
-0.31315359473228455,
-0.6383902430534363,
0.7326359748840332,
-0.11613521724939346,
-0.47062554955482483,
0.0006385908927768469,
-0.09403839707374573,
-0.5381350517272949,
0.5186020135879517,
0.31600379943847656,
-0.41961613297462463,
-0.8730061054229736,
-0.5686278939247131,
0.19104968011379242,
-0.18823547661304474,
0.9689807295799255,
-0.07487659901380539,
0.4317232370376587,
-0.38664624094963074,
-0.18048709630966187,
-0.3209678828716278,
-0.3350405991077423,
-1.1440761089324951,
-0.5741321444511414,
0.7262840270996094,
0.31837230920791626,
0.9313149452209473,
0.8597046732902527,
0.6837502717971802,
0.23168428242206573,
0.044959403574466705,
0.7010723352432251,
0.049519870430231094,
0.42094382643699646,
0.25135350227355957,
-0.537952721118927,
-0.7591767907142639,
-0.4788118004798889,
0.32972991466522217,
0.8960805535316467,
-0.19106166064739227,
-0.15388965606689453,
-0.09234193712472916,
0.719912588596344,
-0.2840226888656616,
0.10341097414493561,
0.35230496525764465,
0.5627374053001404,
-0.1938168853521347,
-0.33805137872695923,
-0.3722519278526306,
-0.568089485168457,
-0.027959000319242477,
-0.7313523292541504,
0.0005909348255954683,
-0.056481484323740005,
0.5822480320930481,
0.45157188177108765,
-0.43826544284820557,
-0.42466679215431213,
-0.6192454099655151,
0.36124274134635925,
-0.4580625295639038,
0.5435504913330078,
0.2977249026298523,
0.7875780463218689,
-0.1964692324399948,
-1.0473859310150146,
-0.1498567759990692,
-0.12796151638031006,
-0.33802926540374756,
0.16978704929351807,
-0.4580201804637909,
0.04273925721645355,
-0.06503412127494812,
0.16057904064655304,
-0.544426679611206,
0.24763940274715424,
-0.27611151337623596,
-0.31779685616493225,
0.2853550612926483,
0.5990385413169861,
0.6662015318870544,
-0.0645066350698471,
-0.0825863853096962,
0.2199055552482605,
-0.6442257761955261,
-0.3550616502761841,
-0.40302029252052307,
0.2235710173845291,
-0.21334019303321838,
0.5667833685874939,
-0.16078102588653564,
1.1829153299331665,
-0.012720758095383644,
-0.517257809638977,
0.37195417284965515,
0.0701688900589943,
-0.10859540104866028,
0.3221055567264557,
0.7395438551902771,
0.4335373342037201,
0.06096692383289337,
-0.33642974495887756,
-0.0817573070526123,
0.10021478682756424,
-0.12064429372549057,
-0.6220108270645142,
-0.5452848076820374,
0.45321032404899597,
-0.9629020094871521,
-0.51539546251297,
-0.5889151096343994,
-0.6295012831687927,
-0.8457332253456116,
-0.5151482820510864,
0.42679962515830994,
-0.653765857219696,
-0.3394172191619873,
-0.046511199325323105,
-0.21101363003253937,
-0.17112039029598236,
0.40220338106155396,
-0.46789681911468506,
0.2589672803878784,
0.5959896445274353,
0.6614985466003418,
0.1668272167444229,
0.06917016953229904,
-0.5090198516845703,
0.20529583096504211,
-0.3577491044998169,
0.9762483239173889,
-0.5604459643363953,
-0.23120947182178497,
0.03269710764288902,
-0.11243259161710739,
0.012453447096049786,
-0.7037880420684814,
0.24980245530605316,
-0.5436815023422241,
-0.07621506601572037,
-0.18944762647151947,
-0.5476105213165283,
0.2140660434961319,
0.42244336009025574,
-0.6103312969207764,
0.9506603479385376,
0.24251601099967957,
-0.5349617004394531,
0.6071825623512268,
-0.7006805539131165,
-0.5042676329612732,
0.2093254029750824,
-0.5022192001342773,
-0.2927521765232086,
-0.3839178681373596,
0.34938448667526245,
0.7129313945770264,
-0.6776756048202515,
0.3619537353515625,
-0.17906439304351807,
-0.04513922333717346,
0.19835692644119263,
-0.15170666575431824,
0.690336287021637,
0.5148081183433533,
0.1894933581352234,
-0.023513520136475563,
-0.8902025818824768,
0.002069958485662937,
0.1406712383031845,
-0.42407581210136414,
-0.6192278265953064,
0.04667939990758896,
-0.11435404419898987,
0.143178790807724,
0.30862918496131897,
-0.3886452317237854,
0.5130566954612732,
-0.40342849493026733,
0.19928187131881714,
0.3596494495868683,
-0.013866282999515533,
-0.06185244023799896,
-0.6809702515602112,
0.7023872137069702,
0.29230111837387085,
0.3774755895137787,
-0.0895494595170021,
-0.7654221057891846,
-0.7703762054443359,
-0.5897120833396912,
0.29722315073013306,
0.5406340956687927,
-0.7239050269126892,
0.4859856367111206,
-0.4429353177547455,
-0.6706447005271912,
-0.8383827805519104,
-0.08511310070753098,
0.435246080160141,
0.7183513045310974,
0.46276018023490906,
0.1194344088435173,
-0.5287399291992188,
-0.8509019017219543,
-0.10810533910989761,
0.20822064578533173,
-0.27911674976348877,
0.4345727562904358,
0.05318643897771835,
-0.3842342793941498,
0.7639098167419434,
-0.5369290709495544,
-0.6904633641242981,
-0.4289417564868927,
-0.23521745204925537,
0.5251729488372803,
0.24330788850784302,
0.48262467980384827,
-0.7354381084442139,
-0.6376860737800598,
0.48941147327423096,
-1.0263657569885254,
-0.33237725496292114,
0.39360299706459045,
0.15720586478710175,
-0.2311939299106598,
0.5456460118293762,
-0.39893946051597595,
0.28497371077537537,
0.43231651186943054,
-0.7477141618728638,
0.11696773022413254,
-0.6301403641700745,
0.2977339029312134,
-1.2997589111328125,
0.04635979235172272,
-0.14045435190200806,
-0.4069167375564575,
-0.5565138459205627,
-0.18405494093894958,
0.14695732295513153,
-0.4384261965751648,
0.09733830392360687,
0.2886115312576294,
-0.3481408953666687,
-0.13840334117412567,
0.08962138742208481,
0.390735000371933,
0.07956194132566452,
-0.05271877720952034,
-0.36899009346961975,
0.40277889370918274,
0.5753471255302429,
-0.7637901306152344,
0.5349858403205872,
0.24147459864616394,
-0.11562956124544144,
0.6462433934211731,
-0.4283599257469177,
-0.15771758556365967,
-0.26094090938568115,
-0.03916309401392937,
-1.1091183423995972,
-0.1507176011800766,
0.26987630128860474,
-0.5256419777870178,
0.6259408593177795,
-0.3094334006309509,
-0.7271392345428467,
-0.13922159373760223,
0.08791842311620712,
0.540462851524353,
0.6107924580574036,
-0.7083573937416077,
1.0940814018249512,
0.23618803918361664,
-0.06408628076314926,
-0.5048106908798218,
-0.9166902899742126,
-0.07760642468929291,
0.010664385743439198,
-0.8184584975242615,
0.5058602094650269,
0.21513234078884125,
-0.20737217366695404,
0.39792612195014954,
0.47630444169044495,
-0.18578669428825378,
-0.14376762509346008,
-0.001819334109313786,
0.3463069498538971,
-0.5643602609634399,
0.5577652454376221,
0.14998236298561096,
-0.503398060798645,
-0.13909035921096802,
-0.26058584451675415,
0.6393517255783081,
0.08551941812038422,
-0.7323672771453857,
-0.35946381092071533,
0.2401621788740158,
0.8915939927101135,
-0.14119140803813934,
0.7617385983467102,
0.3328440487384796,
-0.535373866558075,
-0.028582675382494926,
-0.6055090427398682,
0.17722293734550476,
-0.4012161195278168,
0.22797097265720367,
-0.29245230555534363,
-0.6054009795188904,
0.7245849967002869,
-0.4282211661338806,
-0.21031710505485535,
0.39810699224472046,
0.413621723651886,
0.032255951315164566,
1.3284528255462646,
0.5608788132667542,
-0.2196437120437622,
-0.16198550164699554,
-0.08324781805276871,
0.41622862219810486,
-1.00645911693573,
-0.6229606866836548,
-0.47215285897254944,
-0.08578372746706009,
-0.5796906352043152,
-0.33689430356025696,
0.8469050526618958,
-0.1622081845998764,
-0.1538967788219452,
-0.3200851380825043,
-0.7977381944656372,
0.3880654573440552,
0.006855695508420467,
0.6469990611076355,
0.4860491454601288,
-0.07578567415475845,
-0.4963037371635437,
-0.3472980856895447,
-1.0150339603424072,
-0.24592040479183197,
1.2484039068222046,
0.1640578657388687,
0.6306910514831543,
0.3151451349258423,
0.7617159485816956,
0.49672698974609375,
0.7018499970436096,
-0.9781239032745361,
0.28856155276298523,
-0.5722452998161316,
-0.16877441108226776,
-0.021583573892712593,
-0.28087925910949707,
-1.1295496225357056,
0.2721177339553833,
-0.017437223345041275,
-0.3668627440929413,
0.07009851187467575,
0.3098861277103424,
-0.46457865834236145,
0.23679877817630768,
-0.4331493079662323,
0.8894358277320862,
-0.2179798185825348,
0.10862551629543304,
-0.16185362637043,
-0.37285885214805603,
0.2747081518173218,
0.0037839943543076515,
0.5645805597305298,
0.08457070589065552,
-0.29900747537612915,
0.9426881074905396,
-0.5350459814071655,
0.8078406453132629,
-0.29077842831611633,
0.21325081586837769,
-0.3149043321609497,
0.09067905694246292,
0.38097745180130005,
-0.3277709186077118,
0.1533740609884262,
-0.2708361744880676,
-0.1256789267063141,
-0.14253543317317963,
-0.7841359376907349,
0.6039069890975952,
-0.6686813831329346,
-0.1881292462348938,
-0.14122842252254486,
-0.35716718435287476,
-0.3690071403980255,
0.46261584758758545,
0.057898808270692825,
0.9675429463386536,
0.15756498277187347,
-0.04384612664580345,
0.8836967945098877,
-0.427609384059906,
-0.312179297208786,
0.838871419429779,
-0.4392280876636505,
-0.461063414812088,
0.8128443360328674,
0.2674398720264435,
0.09063920378684998,
0.3791770935058594,
0.5131182670593262,
-0.048376791179180145,
-0.37711986899375916,
-0.1934787631034851,
0.2864254117012024,
-1.096315860748291,
-0.4667181670665741,
-0.6974009275436401,
-0.11610064655542374,
-0.27417510747909546,
-0.32687583565711975,
-0.3201676905155182,
-0.3069610297679901,
-0.21816644072532654,
0.11718663573265076,
0.777169942855835,
0.7666893005371094,
-0.17945758998394012,
-0.01397552527487278,
-0.7588720917701721,
0.46721532940864563,
-0.20399440824985504,
0.4403846263885498,
0.10417056083679199,
-0.49572256207466125,
-0.1849983036518097,
-0.2911564111709595,
0.2196197360754013,
-0.8714606761932373,
0.4619777202606201,
-0.09038763493299484,
0.6423611044883728,
0.8386787176132202,
0.011563706211745739,
0.9748135805130005,
-0.4923551380634308,
0.37489718198776245,
0.23755598068237305,
-0.42440831661224365,
0.7412480711936951,
-0.32332223653793335,
-0.08016225695610046,
0.13321435451507568,
0.5910598039627075,
-0.7215327024459839,
-0.3775467574596405,
-0.44510433077812195,
-0.5634018778800964,
0.22109025716781616,
-0.33605170249938965,
-0.4974580705165863,
-0.09176050871610641,
0.4986693561077118,
-0.3510710299015045,
-0.422628253698349,
-0.23647092282772064,
-0.6726889610290527,
0.22564630210399628,
-0.8439365029335022,
-0.0571778304874897,
-0.286251038312912,
-0.2741771936416626,
-0.5686943531036377,
0.41243118047714233,
0.173908069729805,
0.4714202582836151,
0.6940193772315979,
0.029442930594086647,
-0.009641231968998909,
0.0284145325422287,
0.3768058717250824,
0.6062083840370178,
0.1341443955898285,
0.08411199599504471,
0.07747259736061096,
-0.4454686641693115,
-0.009557126089930534,
0.25204500555992126,
0.1211780533194542,
0.13655701279640198,
0.35872024297714233,
0.11992096155881882,
0.5442215800285339,
-0.652962863445282,
0.6043439507484436,
0.0377853699028492,
-0.08982342481613159,
-0.5284251570701599,
-0.20298367738723755,
0.2198140174150467,
0.4670615494251251,
0.20951233804225922,
-0.0015845607267692685,
0.14115862548351288,
-0.115214504301548,
0.30232295393943787,
0.30510827898979187,
-0.4401063621044159,
0.0631023719906807,
0.4833655059337616,
0.10347262024879456,
-0.475541889667511,
0.7604939937591553,
-0.1169242411851883,
-0.4259990155696869,
0.7388870120048523,
0.685126543045044,
0.3544493317604065,
-0.35400691628456116,
-0.19786590337753296,
0.06417733430862427,
0.5445312857627869,
0.11164185404777527,
0.3912700116634369,
0.09923289716243744,
-0.8704842329025269,
-0.5053207278251648,
-0.20897924900054932,
-0.3000941574573517,
0.32364019751548767,
-0.5746111869812012,
0.586921751499176,
-0.3577732741832733,
-0.10838044434785843,
0.17353926599025726,
-0.3336086571216583,
-0.49381929636001587,
0.20783358812332153,
-0.0822831466794014,
0.9889165163040161,
-0.8949257135391235,
0.645569920539856,
0.6969618797302246,
-0.5206376910209656,
-0.9272102117538452,
-0.4615313708782196,
0.0614289827644825,
-1.0762783288955688,
0.8509142994880676,
0.0517541840672493,
0.2904774248600006,
0.09714525938034058,
-0.11600521951913834,
-0.7783855199813843,
1.4641461372375488,
0.16662269830703735,
-0.1849418729543686,
0.19500143826007843,
0.12506254017353058,
0.572333812713623,
-0.48606738448143005,
0.18881884217262268,
0.5520938634872437,
0.5018711686134338,
-0.048319023102521896,
-1.0234730243682861,
0.3156386911869049,
-0.37618306279182434,
-0.31840723752975464,
0.7616457939147949,
-0.29264354705810547,
0.7637728452682495,
-0.12632597982883453,
0.07331979274749756,
-0.03167245164513588,
0.13962925970554352,
0.22717133164405823,
0.30901676416397095,
0.09132929146289825,
0.8742897510528564,
0.9657543301582336,
0.11527611315250397,
1.2836331129074097,
-0.5573728084564209,
-0.055348847061395645,
0.5291028022766113,
-0.08231352269649506,
0.6071307063102722,
0.26784220337867737,
-0.4066161513328552,
0.4397437870502472,
0.5241219401359558,
-0.10667344927787781,
0.3490884304046631,
-0.09981454163789749,
-0.5475932359695435,
-0.3664703071117401,
-0.36224690079689026,
-0.550527811050415,
0.06855577975511551,
0.7414412498474121,
-0.7813815474510193,
-0.4524882733821869,
0.09618903696537018,
0.09011784195899963,
-0.10040964186191559,
-0.2644413411617279,
0.7420960068702698,
-0.17370112240314484,
-0.3516387641429901,
0.41135329008102417,
-0.034204188734292984,
0.4511527419090271,
-0.7127602696418762,
-0.40678343176841736,
-0.10935978591442108,
0.3807849884033203,
-0.387777179479599,
-0.5402993559837341,
0.17841796576976776,
-0.05283094197511673,
-0.19191138446331024,
0.13702155649662018,
1.2098908424377441,
-0.3466280698776245,
-0.42372411489486694,
0.1987767517566681,
0.4822889268398285,
0.4833165407180786,
0.3938409090042114,
-0.46131688356399536,
-0.12868307530879974,
-0.160667285323143,
0.08756808191537857,
0.43514284491539,
0.7072951793670654,
0.25198280811309814,
1.012217402458191,
0.6496952176094055,
0.26994311809539795,
-0.14570748805999756,
0.3220323324203491,
0.9892482161521912,
-0.3523358702659607,
-0.44815152883529663,
-0.8116000294685364,
0.4917849898338318,
-0.1497342735528946,
-0.1602231115102768,
0.3308105766773224,
0.5902499556541443,
0.29172852635383606,
-0.03676500916481018,
0.7769365906715393,
-0.012666763737797737,
0.7322322726249695,
-0.5201327800750732,
1.117361307144165,
-0.5454686880111694,
0.26867830753326416,
-0.027842042967677116,
0.02363913506269455,
-0.660524308681488,
0.6223607063293457,
-0.09646531194448471,
-0.007356809452176094,
0.635546863079071,
0.8144116997718811,
-0.16300632059574127,
-0.4553259313106537,
0.6301016807556152,
0.23141229152679443,
0.3276473581790924,
0.610960841178894,
0.7887940406799316,
-0.28533196449279785,
0.6317349672317505,
-0.30253276228904724,
-0.4648495316505432,
-0.27981042861938477,
-0.7473702430725098,
-0.8040042519569397,
-0.3442736864089966,
-0.2973039448261261,
-0.2920583188533783,
0.08066964894533157,
0.9426828026771545,
0.5421610474586487,
-0.38742104172706604,
0.22430744767189026,
0.006454930175095797,
0.06286633759737015,
-0.1178705096244812,
-0.22526171803474426,
0.5642722249031067,
-0.32807859778404236,
-0.08310900628566742,
0.4613080620765686,
0.28555920720100403,
-0.14404036104679108,
-0.16721785068511963,
-0.033872462809085846,
0.23656736314296722,
-0.566588819026947,
0.7064853310585022,
0.10072452574968338,
-0.7296257019042969,
0.1483352929353714,
-0.12363208830356598,
0.00796029157936573,
-0.043259426951408386,
0.834374725818634,
-0.8930874466896057,
0.574589192867279,
0.24617522954940796,
0.7752020359039307,
0.061018139123916626,
-0.4231404662132263,
0.5128841400146484,
-0.3937561810016632,
0.02462427131831646,
0.3518436551094055,
0.5221712589263916,
0.17980998754501343,
-0.6088011860847473,
0.3769459128379822,
0.21997882425785065,
-0.3929756283760071,
-0.7269936800003052,
0.08594060689210892,
-0.6886942982673645,
-0.1846451461315155,
0.9406906366348267,
-0.09543830156326294,
0.021179156377911568,
-0.6458474397659302,
-0.02534952387213707,
0.4323001801967621,
-0.07272392511367798,
0.6542229652404785,
0.3679325580596924,
-0.7273077964782715,
-0.017186637967824936,
-0.5701974630355835,
0.5115587115287781,
0.3494408428668976,
-0.7652407288551331,
-0.20572103559970856,
0.37428566813468933,
0.5531212687492371,
0.1148909255862236,
0.9052050709724426,
-0.4246343672275543,
0.6709614992141724,
-0.17132312059402466,
-0.08702962845563889,
-0.4770963788032532,
-0.0021582681220024824,
-0.2453853338956833,
-0.05218356102705002,
0.344443142414093,
-0.09874621033668518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14322v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14322v2 | Mind the Privacy Unit! User-Level Differential Privacy for Language Model Fine-Tuning | 2024-06-20T13:54:32 | 2024-07-03T14:05:20 | Lynn Chua, Badih Ghazi, Yangsibo Huang, Pritish Kamath, Ravi Kumar, Daogao Liu, Pasin Manurangsi, Amer Sinha, Chiyuan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools for tackling
complex tasks across diverse domains, but they also raise privacy concerns when
fine-tuned on sensitive data due to potential memorization. While differential
privacy (DP) offers a promising solution by ensuring models are 'almost
indistinguishable' with or without any particular privacy unit, current
evaluations on LLMs mostly treat each example (text record) as the privacy
unit. This leads to uneven user privacy guarantees when contributions per user
vary. We therefore study user-level DP motivated by applications where it
necessary to ensure uniform privacy protection across users. We present a
systematic evaluation of user-level DP for LLM fine-tuning on natural language
generation tasks. Focusing on two mechanisms for achieving user-level DP
guarantees, Group Privacy and User-wise DP-SGD, we investigate design choices
like data selection strategies and parameter tuning for the best
privacy-utility tradeoff. | [
-0.4448276162147522,
-0.6600511074066162,
0.48330986499786377,
0.199506014585495,
-0.11445479840040207,
0.24119967222213745,
-0.21325190365314484,
-0.42097026109695435,
-0.29302340745925903,
0.6421935558319092,
-0.5906709432601929,
-0.7583540081977844,
-0.3179377019405365,
0.08363893628120422,
-0.29100313782691956,
0.8839021325111389,
0.2512457072734833,
-0.21208547055721283,
-0.08750182390213013,
0.14818160235881805,
-0.34352585673332214,
-0.7499052882194519,
-0.7207594513893127,
-0.15674062073230743,
0.5493839383125305,
0.41562986373901367,
0.8406724333763123,
0.6722630858421326,
0.3972664773464203,
0.32198581099510193,
-0.10869381576776505,
0.16761475801467896,
-0.5434232950210571,
0.20950715243816376,
-0.31994712352752686,
-0.29744812846183777,
-0.6784195303916931,
0.011367259547114372,
0.5905093550682068,
0.6743606925010681,
-0.09668070077896118,
0.19572505354881287,
0.19924768805503845,
0.8168368339538574,
-0.6969236135482788,
-0.07046984136104584,
-0.6357014775276184,
-0.01404095720499754,
-0.19814389944076538,
-0.15423600375652313,
-0.3138904869556427,
-0.6068233251571655,
-0.05176369100809097,
-0.09841097146272659,
0.3484037220478058,
0.13427361845970154,
0.49500221014022827,
0.36050480604171753,
-0.35037341713905334,
-0.00819468405097723,
-0.8103984594345093,
0.620964527130127,
-0.7503029108047485,
0.5050054788589478,
0.6281529664993286,
-0.021596373990178108,
-0.28064805269241333,
-0.34090927243232727,
-0.4097297489643097,
-0.3801743984222412,
-0.12803252041339874,
-0.31265172362327576,
-0.19010792672634125,
0.2815396189689636,
0.4200247824192047,
0.6611601710319519,
-0.4432094097137451,
0.5998384952545166,
0.03952803462743759,
-0.08362434059381485,
0.9665116667747498,
0.2916300892829895,
0.2789020836353302,
-0.023859934881329536,
-0.10702341049909592,
0.07007702440023422,
-0.8114158511161804,
0.016546912491321564,
0.8955931067466736,
0.32953906059265137,
-0.1321837604045868,
0.5501056909561157,
-0.5417423844337463,
0.5909348726272583,
0.15243110060691833,
-0.10647551715373993,
-0.05686765909194946,
-0.07791075110435486,
-0.2785930633544922,
-0.08948960900306702,
0.9024044275283813,
0.3565141260623932,
0.4827145040035248,
-0.5467969179153442,
-0.36713942885398865,
0.06458266079425812,
0.2085399329662323,
-0.6257368922233582,
-0.23267541825771332,
0.09345430135726929,
-0.1251271814107895,
-0.500522792339325,
-0.10847427695989609,
-0.6221337914466858,
-0.47842299938201904,
-0.5205380916595459,
0.22416432201862335,
-0.16558937728405,
-0.24843871593475342,
0.2804284393787384,
0.16046640276908875,
-0.24209195375442505,
-0.10917889326810837,
-1.532007098197937,
0.6610264182090759,
0.7585399746894836,
0.4809419512748718,
-0.40608999133110046,
-0.30237114429473877,
-0.42015746235847473,
0.31210994720458984,
-0.2715306878089905,
0.3287495970726013,
-0.594562292098999,
-0.6093950867652893,
-0.09556630998849869,
-0.25753381848335266,
0.04975462332367897,
-0.5235344171524048,
0.3321262001991272,
-0.3885073661804199,
0.2797718644142151,
-0.33696603775024414,
-0.5368258953094482,
0.21203550696372986,
-0.20437632501125336,
-0.3711649179458618,
0.8963675498962402,
0.22776469588279724,
-0.7474169135093689,
0.5981106162071228,
-0.6461056470870972,
-0.5388272404670715,
0.21977181732654572,
-0.22513705492019653,
-0.4073014259338379,
0.3808193802833557,
0.2212369441986084,
0.7096039056777954,
-0.0480029322206974,
0.3063110113143921,
-0.2902866005897522,
-0.16688519716262817,
0.4543468952178955,
-0.3929862082004547,
0.6878975033760071,
0.40873897075653076,
-0.20674002170562744,
0.0742889866232872,
-0.9935621023178101,
-0.1208830177783966,
-0.03884108364582062,
-0.3601314425468445,
-0.5299233198165894,
-0.0710405483841896,
-0.12472733110189438,
-0.0043845572508871555,
0.46132370829582214,
-0.534601092338562,
0.08577746152877808,
-0.3401077091693878,
0.5513421893119812,
1.0018471479415894,
-0.05329665169119835,
0.7140031456947327,
-0.32142025232315063,
0.5666359663009644,
-0.12684619426727295,
0.2632913589477539,
0.280013769865036,
-0.37646573781967163,
-0.3542465567588806,
-0.21756428480148315,
0.37783223390579224,
0.189157634973526,
-0.13726213574409485,
0.6446380019187927,
-0.010410734452307224,
-0.21451935172080994,
-0.34428736567497253,
0.29524362087249756,
0.4392288029193878,
0.507392168045044,
-0.007933329790830612,
-0.24217458069324493,
-0.1387365609407425,
-1.0796549320220947,
-0.3797508478164673,
-0.034574493765830994,
-0.18853412568569183,
0.6353060007095337,
-0.026091981679201126,
-0.38501718640327454,
0.9402908086776733,
-0.6237406730651855,
-0.25439369678497314,
-0.23847073316574097,
-0.1819748878479004,
-0.0950486958026886,
0.4401888847351074,
0.43062469363212585,
-0.7861363291740417,
-0.4939267039299011,
-0.11029987037181854,
-0.46586817502975464,
-0.36910074949264526,
-0.017086168751120567,
-0.28645241260528564,
0.43471574783325195,
0.31125104427337646,
-0.45425862073898315,
0.461457759141922,
0.5673595666885376,
-0.2581596374511719,
0.039752375334501266,
-0.5304535627365112,
-0.03465595841407776,
-1.075811505317688,
-0.13741318881511688,
0.053666796535253525,
-0.5424859523773193,
-0.7519686222076416,
0.30124497413635254,
0.19992369413375854,
-0.077662892639637,
-0.4348829388618469,
0.4012558162212372,
-0.43110108375549316,
-0.2172071784734726,
-0.19812776148319244,
-0.09748411178588867,
-0.23740705847740173,
0.326608806848526,
-0.2126479148864746,
0.7533501386642456,
0.6150690317153931,
-0.8183192014694214,
0.02766215242445469,
0.017191214486956596,
-0.07284160703420639,
0.3053370714187622,
-0.363066166639328,
0.5463061332702637,
0.050279151648283005,
-0.18098224699497223,
-0.9048528075218201,
-0.4425930380821228,
0.14658108353614807,
-0.15392260253429413,
0.5087639689445496,
0.0495666079223156,
-0.6875078082084656,
-0.16690398752689362,
-0.275920033454895,
0.27948635816574097,
0.6113975644111633,
-0.5398627519607544,
0.20137245953083038,
0.7820146083831787,
-0.17583972215652466,
-0.5412778258323669,
-0.6567009091377258,
0.26077887415885925,
-0.39279311895370483,
-0.6722730994224548,
0.389944851398468,
-0.2095792591571808,
-0.3880780041217804,
-0.1711127907037735,
-0.22259359061717987,
-0.13475348055362701,
0.45746150612831116,
0.37891581654548645,
-0.0024839681573212147,
0.12250376492738724,
-0.04732843488454819,
0.3137071132659912,
-0.2503588795661926,
-0.02220659703016281,
0.021481890231370926,
0.6440579295158386,
-0.07333806902170181,
-0.18216277658939362,
-0.5876550674438477,
0.4098673462867737,
0.13346561789512634,
-0.042518794536590576,
0.5315940976142883,
0.14277486503124237,
-0.35189583897590637,
-0.3188974857330322,
-0.614854097366333,
-0.17228548228740692,
-0.5702449083328247,
0.06852639466524124,
-0.4015340209007263,
-1.1138757467269897,
0.5208619832992554,
0.10167568922042847,
0.243186354637146,
0.07230416685342789,
0.7713783979415894,
0.1378016173839569,
0.9508978724479675,
0.9894493818283081,
-0.4373266100883484,
0.310741662979126,
0.14967624843120575,
0.29297155141830444,
-0.6570574045181274,
-0.018795864656567574,
-0.4632442891597748,
-0.5325162410736084,
-0.8707897663116455,
0.148332878947258,
0.04256710410118103,
0.10687873512506485,
-0.0792640745639801,
0.370715856552124,
-0.6796980500221252,
0.7466355562210083,
0.5333244204521179,
0.08957679569721222,
0.6544418931007385,
0.08584261685609818,
0.19181977212429047,
0.004425297491252422,
-0.36255770921707153,
-0.6589004397392273,
1.1327511072158813,
0.34720346331596375,
1.1299970149993896,
0.17841506004333496,
1.2255630493164062,
0.2734355926513672,
0.00887883547693491,
-0.43552765250205994,
0.8247706890106201,
-0.5803517699241638,
-0.47617143392562866,
-0.5384195446968079,
-0.5830320715904236,
-0.9383593201637268,
0.12480923533439636,
0.21110935509204865,
-1.1173778772354126,
0.05810447037220001,
0.31240060925483704,
-0.37428775429725647,
0.10080217570066452,
-0.7377651929855347,
0.5391165614128113,
-0.03637789189815521,
-0.4445965588092804,
-0.11873941868543625,
-0.6004965305328369,
0.4926045835018158,
-0.24725037813186646,
0.004820885602384806,
-0.2869343161582947,
0.014356833882629871,
0.3474220931529999,
-0.15868446230888367,
0.7790399789810181,
-0.25361841917037964,
-0.34992289543151855,
-0.2845960557460785,
0.22718414664268494,
0.1629103571176529,
0.6333464980125427,
-0.08998235315084457,
0.23074395954608917,
-0.2925778925418854,
0.06380054354667664,
-0.16794943809509277,
1.1379882097244263,
-0.6496124267578125,
-1.0229305028915405,
-0.12538224458694458,
-0.8124138116836548,
-0.2777520716190338,
0.24885791540145874,
0.3205583095550537,
0.14835722744464874,
-0.1908976286649704,
0.13102750480175018,
0.8207195997238159,
-0.38376906514167786,
0.48611098527908325,
0.5921065807342529,
-0.18923655152320862,
0.14183703064918518,
0.7203185558319092,
-0.046689361333847046,
0.42659902572631836,
0.4905303716659546,
0.44201284646987915,
-0.537566602230072,
-0.5938977599143982,
-0.4985356628894806,
0.1096324473619461,
-0.36933398246765137,
-0.07425133883953094,
-0.6989505290985107,
-0.3237808048725128,
-0.48286476731300354,
-0.10390046238899231,
-0.33788353204727173,
-0.46033090353012085,
-0.4619738757610321,
-0.26125988364219666,
0.3040861487388611,
0.662929892539978,
-0.21010379493236542,
0.11876532435417175,
-0.3908354938030243,
0.8784973621368408,
0.3141564130783081,
0.5450729131698608,
-0.4210743010044098,
-0.40558475255966187,
0.20863884687423706,
0.12738575041294098,
-0.2693277895450592,
-0.433057576417923,
0.3068896234035492,
0.11416955292224884,
0.4611777365207672,
0.1265350580215454,
0.1866656392812729,
0.29119640588760376,
-0.5507407784461975,
0.6310040354728699,
-0.011379031464457512,
-0.8802083134651184,
0.38588133454322815,
-0.316624253988266,
0.13546545803546906,
0.6089223027229309,
0.016819553449749947,
-0.41322922706604004,
-0.7635237574577332,
-0.5541549324989319,
-0.863223671913147,
0.7458764314651489,
0.18378961086273193,
0.559272289276123,
0.2107374221086502,
0.45303916931152344,
0.41674384474754333,
0.25240179896354675,
-0.6416686177253723,
-0.3183269202709198,
0.15289996564388275,
-0.01458907313644886,
-0.16078384220600128,
-0.12567070126533508,
-0.22825533151626587,
-0.07848535478115082,
0.2620324492454529,
0.06281526386737823,
-0.11333832889795303,
-0.12992343306541443,
0.17380134761333466,
-0.2317509651184082,
0.559770941734314,
0.6750909686088562,
0.76503986120224,
-0.2298860251903534,
0.09357181936502457,
-0.002427665051072836,
-0.4634884297847748,
0.2640300691127777,
0.19042886793613434,
-0.444419264793396,
-0.1601308137178421,
-0.34457746148109436,
0.7114524841308594,
-0.029441921040415764,
-0.17305965721607208,
0.24056051671504974,
-0.4172881543636322,
-0.401335746049881,
-0.0997001901268959,
0.6644749641418457,
0.30991262197494507,
0.004082312807440758,
0.050244059413671494,
-0.1160210520029068,
0.203741192817688,
-0.3228539824485779,
0.05417948216199875,
0.5271710157394409,
-0.019190385937690735,
-0.34112632274627686,
1.0303529500961304,
0.011697276495397091,
-0.6965582966804504,
0.2801465392112732,
-0.10084525495767593,
0.015357998199760914,
0.29010024666786194,
0.3556254804134369,
1.1930869817733765,
-0.36127129197120667,
0.24152149260044098,
-0.2462022602558136,
0.15338899195194244,
-0.1149270087480545,
0.4148366153240204,
-0.14477695524692535,
-0.6457547545433044,
-0.013128611259162426,
-0.7161614298820496,
-0.4634932279586792,
0.445285826921463,
-0.7509181499481201,
0.04250562563538551,
-0.6895914673805237,
-0.1616862267255783,
0.02080627903342247,
-0.03839658573269844,
-0.7207278609275818,
0.1893271803855896,
0.23076191544532776,
0.5096747875213623,
-0.4765629172325134,
0.9524165987968445,
0.3458394408226013,
0.05365604907274246,
-0.6238524913787842,
0.17704664170742035,
-0.09248554706573486,
-0.6383847594261169,
0.48582205176353455,
0.011959809809923172,
-0.27076584100723267,
0.05567025765776634,
-0.2645280659198761,
-0.45008572936058044,
0.8176625370979309,
0.7237831950187683,
-1.0883556604385376,
0.13309524953365326,
0.8046476244926453,
0.69971764087677,
-0.17411911487579346,
-0.5234330892562866,
0.701333224773407,
0.16583994030952454,
-0.3975405693054199,
-0.8332303166389465,
0.18195420503616333,
0.3172675371170044,
0.10475253313779831,
0.28554633259773254,
-0.7514912486076355,
0.7727025747299194,
-0.11901436746120453,
-0.3223749101161957,
-0.06917040795087814,
0.22153323888778687,
0.1781318038702011,
0.3504979610443115,
0.49166446924209595,
0.5807313919067383,
0.871975839138031,
0.13977192342281342,
1.1339304447174072,
-0.3953355848789215,
0.06961607933044434,
1.0527136325836182,
-0.5221293568611145,
0.5024259090423584,
0.3665323853492737,
-0.19467926025390625,
-0.007638367358595133,
0.47130724787712097,
0.296636700630188,
0.6111529469490051,
0.48697829246520996,
-0.3965195119380951,
0.03358437493443489,
0.029979174956679344,
-0.40005725622177124,
0.1856372207403183,
0.07596786320209503,
-0.43527987599372864,
-0.04120396450161934,
-0.2926013469696045,
0.01420628372579813,
0.34092020988464355,
-0.23301604390144348,
1.0317604541778564,
0.288493812084198,
-0.4937628507614136,
0.5332692265510559,
0.19705986976623535,
0.64021897315979,
-0.39001724123954773,
0.5314561128616333,
-0.5073292255401611,
0.2908468544483185,
-0.33304011821746826,
-0.7346295714378357,
0.1601031869649887,
0.310672789812088,
-0.2109166830778122,
-0.3891333341598511,
0.6030131578445435,
-0.34576040506362915,
-0.3934590220451355,
0.22832933068275452,
0.3093820810317993,
0.04135512560606003,
-0.058592844754457474,
-0.5645272135734558,
-0.1617002934217453,
0.09510552138090134,
-0.4690213203430176,
0.7536409497261047,
0.48725613951683044,
-0.041009463369846344,
0.6035767793655396,
0.6352348327636719,
0.12478963285684586,
0.12634901702404022,
0.6476191878318787,
0.9711982011795044,
-0.6241757869720459,
-0.4994732737541199,
-1.3162543773651123,
0.2780550718307495,
-0.010336638428270817,
-0.5617490410804749,
0.8355041146278381,
0.574104905128479,
0.9555315971374512,
0.03241383284330368,
0.8954989314079285,
0.2095739096403122,
0.5664211511611938,
-0.5630825757980347,
0.8069045543670654,
-0.44707903265953064,
0.553294837474823,
-0.3092503845691681,
-1.0625704526901245,
-0.4464048147201538,
0.39546820521354675,
-0.11220683157444,
-0.21470677852630615,
0.33016008138656616,
0.9592717885971069,
-0.13999266922473907,
0.13656799495220184,
0.5272679328918457,
-0.14761857688426971,
0.5012266635894775,
0.4948435425758362,
0.7600247263908386,
-0.06585436314344406,
0.0767713412642479,
-0.5442162752151489,
-0.11905961483716965,
0.157033771276474,
-0.8787947297096252,
-1.201615571975708,
-0.345409095287323,
-0.31419456005096436,
0.11815930902957916,
-0.011131713166832924,
0.6134053468704224,
0.709328293800354,
-0.6039350628852844,
-0.32344940304756165,
-0.4265326261520386,
-0.06360369175672531,
0.22131335735321045,
-0.170928493142128,
0.14693793654441833,
-0.28408312797546387,
-0.8567072749137878,
0.42062443494796753,
0.4577820599079132,
0.16785921156406403,
-0.5603954195976257,
-0.007490880787372589,
0.3133296072483063,
-0.006079398561269045,
0.25047945976257324,
0.1671617478132248,
-0.6341186761856079,
-0.2105238288640976,
-0.07425857335329056,
-0.4069029986858368,
0.07291989773511887,
0.8817038536071777,
-0.3618791103363037,
0.28416091203689575,
0.495992511510849,
0.6313166618347168,
0.37068089842796326,
0.28518760204315186,
0.691652238368988,
-1.0522701740264893,
0.19941969215869904,
0.2880854606628418,
0.1619000881910324,
0.36586853861808777,
-0.9151214361190796,
0.4036255180835724,
-0.33057722449302673,
-0.992186427116394,
-1.0147634744644165,
0.41757506132125854,
-0.8643364906311035,
-0.25836464762687683,
1.2329484224319458,
-0.0582335889339447,
0.033419281244277954,
-0.07176229357719421,
-0.20682258903980255,
0.09100794047117233,
-0.7541088461875916,
0.9704227447509766,
0.49058249592781067,
-0.18308109045028687,
0.01908179186284542,
-0.45631688833236694,
0.8519547581672668,
0.2109479159116745,
-0.7415630221366882,
0.559722900390625,
0.3699468970298767,
0.25083011388778687,
-0.26482582092285156,
0.7748396396636963,
-0.06109980121254921,
-0.13522371649742126,
-0.35094454884529114,
-0.30312424898147583,
-0.2446683794260025,
-0.32076510787010193,
-0.46270641684532166,
0.10530659556388855,
0.10041340440511703,
-0.19401684403419495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14319v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14319v1 | LiveMind: Low-latency Large Language Models with Simultaneous Inference | 2024-06-20T13:52:30 | 2024-06-20T13:52:30 | Chuangtao Chen, Grace Li Zhang, Xunzhao Yin, Cheng Zhuo, Ulf Schlichtmann, Bing Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | In this paper, we introduce a novel low-latency inference framework for large
language models (LLMs) inference which enables LLMs to perform inferences with
incomplete prompts. By reallocating computational processes to prompt input
phase, we achieve a substantial reduction in latency, thereby significantly
enhancing the interactive experience for users of LLMs. The framework adeptly
manages the visibility of the streaming prompt to the model, allowing it to
infer from incomplete prompts or await additional prompts. Compared with
traditional inference methods that utilize complete prompts, our approach
demonstrates an average reduction of 59% in response latency on the MMLU-Pro
dataset, while maintaining comparable accuracy. Additionally, our framework
facilitates collaborative inference and output across different models. By
employing an LLM for inference and a small language model (SLM) for output, we
achieve an average 68% reduction in response latency, alongside a 5.5%
improvement in accuracy on the MMLU-Pro dataset compared with the SLM baseline.
For long prompts exceeding 20 sentences, the response latency can be reduced by
up to 93%. | [
-0.2574794590473175,
-1.1709247827529907,
0.8665426969528198,
0.2893733084201813,
-0.15804342925548553,
0.1458548903465271,
-0.5022810697555542,
-0.33197635412216187,
0.45227929949760437,
0.3460127115249634,
-1.0617568492889404,
-0.3328186273574829,
-0.22946973145008087,
-0.12545856833457947,
-0.0078349057585001,
0.3063947558403015,
0.19115234911441803,
0.1637529581785202,
-0.4284824728965759,
-0.014124738052487373,
-0.418996125459671,
-0.19916163384914398,
-1.0338788032531738,
-0.363228976726532,
0.8907603025436401,
0.399021178483963,
0.8104278445243835,
0.2586946189403534,
-0.056912824511528015,
0.1997748464345932,
-0.1490664780139923,
0.19356784224510193,
-0.5388025045394897,
0.5240863561630249,
0.28774020075798035,
-0.5321624279022217,
-0.5127376317977905,
-0.16966432332992554,
0.5722858905792236,
1.153834581375122,
-0.05584070086479187,
0.15897804498672485,
-0.030560074374079704,
0.37397509813308716,
-0.7163041234016418,
0.19351425766944885,
-0.285377562046051,
0.391480028629303,
0.017697902396321297,
0.23329581320285797,
-0.6311883926391602,
-0.28029319643974304,
-0.004146556835621595,
-0.6215717792510986,
0.003334445646032691,
-0.013595452532172203,
0.3523407578468323,
0.5959169268608093,
-0.05338919535279274,
0.2760331928730011,
-0.6556642651557922,
0.7036314010620117,
-1.2514232397079468,
0.3411315083503723,
0.30849847197532654,
0.41189783811569214,
-0.228706955909729,
-0.8190663456916809,
-1.0178059339523315,
-0.017120489850640297,
0.027295134961605072,
0.2732259929180145,
0.0611475370824337,
0.23022472858428955,
0.46910154819488525,
0.20493657886981964,
-0.49633726477622986,
0.39174094796180725,
0.07487063109874725,
-0.2338525354862213,
0.44756487011909485,
0.1543789505958557,
0.11289523541927338,
-0.060260895639657974,
0.2134474515914917,
0.16289696097373962,
-0.8973872661590576,
0.018752804026007652,
0.20559076964855194,
0.4787657558917999,
-0.29171961545944214,
0.657624363899231,
-0.34278008341789246,
0.9547644257545471,
-0.2474370002746582,
-0.25720763206481934,
0.20295743644237518,
-0.1390295773744583,
-0.4233756363391876,
-0.1290736049413681,
0.9442833662033081,
0.1653139442205429,
0.08703715354204178,
-0.07795171439647675,
-0.14954473078250885,
0.10878654569387436,
-0.07319696992635727,
-0.6603623628616333,
-0.1491987407207489,
0.5365976095199585,
-0.4368416965007782,
-0.097126305103302,
-0.38102078437805176,
-0.8310260772705078,
-0.6080812811851501,
-0.15849857032299042,
0.43551182746887207,
0.038362953811883926,
-0.15357112884521484,
-0.008261744864284992,
0.28816577792167664,
0.04357010871171951,
0.8098074793815613,
-0.5552324652671814,
0.27639779448509216,
0.62105393409729,
0.9937250018119812,
-0.5123173594474792,
-0.2491561770439148,
-1.156227946281433,
-0.036807261407375336,
-0.07348420470952988,
0.7950241565704346,
-0.5198211669921875,
-0.17272228002548218,
0.07446500658988953,
0.022294510155916214,
-0.13808070123195648,
-0.3244573175907135,
0.30744674801826477,
-0.772011399269104,
0.37888264656066895,
0.05602385103702545,
-0.7285649180412292,
-0.24727021157741547,
-0.033607903867959976,
-0.8828591704368591,
0.9372272491455078,
-0.1986410915851593,
-0.5917416214942932,
0.17920538783073425,
-0.6665560603141785,
-0.485897034406662,
0.28766322135925293,
-0.3413130044937134,
-0.20248939096927643,
-0.04919985309243202,
0.23037239909172058,
0.6435321569442749,
-0.21746809780597687,
0.462209016084671,
-0.8319414258003235,
-0.5773150324821472,
0.042324915528297424,
-0.6420152187347412,
0.7016434073448181,
0.13848255574703217,
-0.2886849045753479,
0.3662227988243103,
-0.7678493857383728,
-0.027279715985059738,
0.10099847614765167,
-0.3904852569103241,
0.05879346281290054,
0.39839601516723633,
-0.0642702728509903,
0.07980305701494217,
0.09380985796451569,
-0.6515442728996277,
0.17087633907794952,
-0.47607287764549255,
0.3932906985282898,
0.5184118151664734,
0.030135130509734154,
0.4600716531276703,
-0.22069309651851654,
0.6947210431098938,
-0.15431053936481476,
-0.05342411622405052,
-0.3898162245750427,
-0.6887922883033752,
-0.7826240062713623,
-0.6662334203720093,
0.19010137021541595,
0.7484001517295837,
-0.8989524245262146,
0.17759065330028534,
-0.3746394217014313,
-0.2444140464067459,
-0.8838087320327759,
0.054876673966646194,
0.2060650736093521,
0.3870285451412201,
0.10001145303249359,
0.1561674177646637,
-0.3184044361114502,
-0.6420241594314575,
-0.18888245522975922,
-0.07187119871377945,
-0.380608469247818,
0.4211803078651428,
0.08449693024158478,
-0.11612851172685623,
0.9391373991966248,
-0.624943733215332,
0.24002087116241455,
-0.35022178292274475,
-0.054947853088378906,
0.869446873664856,
0.29568853974342346,
0.1561385691165924,
-0.6629440784454346,
-0.5317872762680054,
-0.5299111604690552,
-0.8447714447975159,
-0.19853176176548004,
-0.143413707613945,
0.03571934998035431,
0.0943107083439827,
0.4906032681465149,
-0.7160133719444275,
0.5404148697853088,
0.6667470335960388,
-0.28694766759872437,
0.3680301606655121,
-0.14125540852546692,
0.006542379967868328,
-1.0693014860153198,
-0.24102576076984406,
-0.2191573828458786,
-0.5990861058235168,
-0.5280570387840271,
-0.002876637503504753,
-0.1021190881729126,
-0.2398793250322342,
-0.5840389728546143,
0.986042857170105,
-0.5410500168800354,
-0.19923695921897888,
-0.018042998388409615,
0.33831286430358887,
-0.007160866633057594,
0.7342248558998108,
0.14463840425014496,
1.1277449131011963,
0.5046511888504028,
-0.6183902621269226,
0.47300806641578674,
0.1136728972196579,
-0.38744717836380005,
0.24790799617767334,
-0.7372632622718811,
0.09308658540248871,
0.10411132872104645,
0.254596084356308,
-1.2561103105545044,
-0.4690479636192322,
0.19768914580345154,
-0.5390281081199646,
0.2104937583208084,
-0.21838727593421936,
-0.8788371086120605,
-0.42390719056129456,
-0.27330756187438965,
0.2167825996875763,
0.6164735555648804,
-0.5100999474525452,
0.6685115694999695,
0.33584216237068176,
-0.43042805790901184,
-0.3367897868156433,
-0.8114433884620667,
0.002759442897513509,
0.036311302334070206,
-0.683805525302887,
-0.034612346440553665,
-0.3293423652648926,
-0.30294111371040344,
-0.10189212113618851,
0.15786130726337433,
-0.02425992675125599,
0.26478925347328186,
0.5502079725265503,
0.3248160183429718,
-0.4791257679462433,
0.02475566789507866,
0.3922511041164398,
0.011437241919338703,
-0.038525983691215515,
-0.42689019441604614,
0.5036672949790955,
0.33987346291542053,
-0.7742115259170532,
-0.48624131083488464,
0.438230037689209,
0.49824920296669006,
0.08277072012424469,
1.2016092538833618,
0.32372790575027466,
-0.6253613829612732,
-0.1892867386341095,
-0.5251867771148682,
-0.31057360768318176,
-0.39299988746643066,
-0.12076221406459808,
-0.3687473237514496,
-1.3163317441940308,
0.717007577419281,
-0.006484037730842829,
0.1509416103363037,
0.16066090762615204,
0.7820422053337097,
-0.2307782918214798,
0.9149976372718811,
0.3512132167816162,
0.1324678510427475,
0.5298790335655212,
0.09686305373907089,
0.2801026701927185,
-0.7020525336265564,
-0.13680125772953033,
-0.26580628752708435,
-0.04253442585468292,
-0.22813744843006134,
-0.8538182973861694,
0.3185316026210785,
0.10248048603534698,
-0.15459340810775757,
-0.10428712517023087,
0.03503928706049919,
0.3303099274635315,
0.6311220526695251,
0.3141641914844513,
0.3721636235713959,
0.08594594150781631,
-0.6475428938865662,
-0.25684332847595215,
-0.8564028143882751,
-0.40676382184028625,
0.7035800218582153,
0.33167845010757446,
0.8540205359458923,
0.3090839982032776,
0.28996625542640686,
0.6077304482460022,
0.2795458137989044,
-0.8715456128120422,
0.5661163330078125,
0.163541778922081,
-0.6316041946411133,
-0.475127637386322,
-0.430620938539505,
-0.6656011939048767,
0.32161420583724976,
-0.29513177275657654,
-1.0812182426452637,
-0.25228267908096313,
0.21084263920783997,
-0.9333989024162292,
0.38073667883872986,
-0.7959195971488953,
0.86423659324646,
0.16950887441635132,
-0.8299371004104614,
-0.11485597491264343,
-0.5869578719139099,
0.5202767848968506,
-0.2920449674129486,
0.24148225784301758,
-0.24456068873405457,
-0.039692893624305725,
0.8717957139015198,
-0.680137574672699,
1.2298290729522705,
-0.3482736051082611,
-0.1657819300889969,
0.20594528317451477,
0.04749532788991928,
0.5314046144485474,
0.34787172079086304,
-0.20487745106220245,
-0.00034449808299541473,
-0.23272356390953064,
-0.44908231496810913,
-0.5830779075622559,
0.7897599935531616,
-0.598138689994812,
-0.334991991519928,
-0.18417295813560486,
-0.46994414925575256,
-0.44361039996147156,
0.41105055809020996,
-0.031508833169937134,
0.5091451406478882,
0.01826479099690914,
-0.1042725145816803,
0.877818763256073,
-0.5538517832756042,
0.7322325706481934,
0.6086652874946594,
-0.47460493445396423,
-0.5696642398834229,
0.4845162332057953,
-0.10617104172706604,
0.3653275668621063,
0.4566022455692291,
-0.10896139591932297,
-0.43758830428123474,
-0.6090999841690063,
-0.4798319935798645,
0.48337090015411377,
-0.6799634099006653,
-0.0076345899142324924,
-1.0399304628372192,
-0.052272357046604156,
-0.5495595335960388,
-0.05178481340408325,
-0.39743974804878235,
-0.3105027675628662,
-0.5077633857727051,
0.16212022304534912,
0.35981956124305725,
0.5931443572044373,
0.061645492911338806,
0.9518179893493652,
-0.9886897206306458,
0.5116580128669739,
0.339559942483902,
0.33418822288513184,
0.23716755211353302,
-0.745198130607605,
-0.1035841703414917,
0.11141448467969894,
0.2772960364818573,
-0.8812935948371887,
0.3519885540008545,
0.16606321930885315,
0.6225498914718628,
0.509762167930603,
0.2729003131389618,
0.680026113986969,
-0.6621081829071045,
1.050033450126648,
0.19661884009838104,
-0.7734283804893494,
0.3633507192134857,
-0.3930584192276001,
0.6127065420150757,
0.5605852007865906,
0.14167536795139313,
-0.7841101884841919,
-0.36188575625419617,
-0.46904227137565613,
-0.765783965587616,
0.7405359148979187,
0.14414411783218384,
-0.09770309180021286,
-0.02672007493674755,
0.26117411255836487,
0.17663826048374176,
0.3606310188770294,
-0.5903173685073853,
-0.4842571020126343,
0.4499082565307617,
-0.2334694266319275,
-0.21572068333625793,
-0.42406129837036133,
0.10992895066738129,
-0.2338721603155136,
0.6330608129501343,
-0.4039768576622009,
0.5673994421958923,
-0.07045939564704895,
-0.32271966338157654,
-0.15426452457904816,
0.07886913418769836,
0.6776642203330994,
0.7122087478637695,
-0.21717508137226105,
0.15364746749401093,
0.36761462688446045,
-0.34657594561576843,
0.008346861228346825,
0.17255866527557373,
-0.3481334149837494,
0.11168630421161652,
0.8661633729934692,
1.0444674491882324,
0.45413824915885925,
-0.7530831694602966,
0.5459887981414795,
-0.5545714497566223,
0.1794189214706421,
-0.5658125281333923,
0.09417162835597992,
0.5467020273208618,
0.48789259791374207,
0.3996942341327667,
0.02465093322098255,
-0.25603029131889343,
-0.16611899435520172,
0.19144929945468903,
0.2384415566921234,
-0.4538918733596802,
-0.3015524744987488,
0.974575936794281,
0.19918400049209595,
-0.6016340851783752,
0.5044451355934143,
-0.20077313482761383,
-0.3491779863834381,
0.3261815905570984,
0.29126065969467163,
0.8099300861358643,
0.1154194176197052,
0.17241548001766205,
0.2264023721218109,
-0.12324477732181549,
-0.04773082211613655,
0.4131789207458496,
-0.25466471910476685,
-0.7480524182319641,
-1.1097832918167114,
-0.80917888879776,
-0.6070454716682434,
0.3040409982204437,
-0.6000596880912781,
0.1370806246995926,
-0.2926863729953766,
0.006338543724268675,
-0.03352149948477745,
0.1397988498210907,
-0.43114203214645386,
-0.023891670629382133,
0.5129914283752441,
1.172511339187622,
-0.8551555275917053,
0.9889216423034668,
0.6596449017524719,
-0.26674917340278625,
-0.7098546028137207,
-0.004851676523685455,
0.2841319739818573,
-0.7749362587928772,
0.4135473668575287,
0.2274138629436493,
-0.20852360129356384,
0.25389668345451355,
-0.745519757270813,
-0.574799656867981,
0.9318567514419556,
0.5034305453300476,
-0.7398962378501892,
0.07623179256916046,
-0.3198944926261902,
0.39881840348243713,
-0.45179301500320435,
0.5011637806892395,
0.34081050753593445,
0.36565062403678894,
0.4542858600616455,
-0.7414605021476746,
0.04459454491734505,
0.0004510881844907999,
-0.3002384305000305,
0.011021146550774574,
-0.4133407473564148,
0.7163198590278625,
-0.35742244124412537,
-0.31508806347846985,
0.03791189566254616,
1.0444947481155396,
0.6462204456329346,
0.47817716002464294,
0.5003970265388489,
0.4820004105567932,
0.9935122132301331,
0.0964374765753746,
0.9220262765884399,
-0.10833843052387238,
0.33803248405456543,
1.530008316040039,
-0.5073274970054626,
1.044688105583191,
0.5800536274909973,
-0.4233379065990448,
0.1934332698583603,
1.0519535541534424,
0.40609318017959595,
0.45193973183631897,
0.1355363428592682,
-0.6090890169143677,
-0.5959293842315674,
-0.05692616105079651,
-0.12465666979551315,
-0.07499600946903229,
0.359815388917923,
0.12633384764194489,
-0.1427392065525055,
0.06663881242275238,
0.43591997027397156,
-0.09682219475507736,
-0.06505613029003143,
0.7284647226333618,
0.1983143538236618,
-0.88767009973526,
0.4595467746257782,
-0.2769719958305359,
0.8562877178192139,
-0.4719252586364746,
-0.1113845705986023,
-0.6216360926628113,
0.19988903403282166,
-0.00941484421491623,
-0.5843254327774048,
0.06579267978668213,
0.04365476965904236,
-0.28462740778923035,
-0.20881938934326172,
0.5131582617759705,
-0.4514150321483612,
-0.39806312322616577,
0.4946230351924896,
0.8140547871589661,
0.33963677287101746,
-0.2709657549858093,
-0.5939236879348755,
0.14802855253219604,
0.03903256729245186,
-0.41024699807167053,
0.09079113602638245,
0.48433277010917664,
0.14941959083080292,
0.795510470867157,
0.7677252292633057,
0.5199500918388367,
0.33661511540412903,
0.32993775606155396,
0.8832335472106934,
-0.6599429249763489,
-0.44590821862220764,
-0.8620696067810059,
0.359377384185791,
-0.2164800763130188,
0.21507756412029266,
0.6530894637107849,
0.44434818625450134,
0.5139249563217163,
-0.2048543095588684,
0.8390236496925354,
-0.045065101236104965,
0.8244350552558899,
-0.6727290749549866,
0.9371423721313477,
-0.6849232316017151,
0.4773949682712555,
-0.05440019071102142,
-0.8268923759460449,
-0.4505920112133026,
0.49991390109062195,
-0.21276916563510895,
-0.11391635984182358,
0.7176627516746521,
0.839720606803894,
-0.12890192866325378,
-0.1780897080898285,
0.6141662001609802,
0.28276872634887695,
0.2072209268808365,
0.5240592956542969,
0.8101794123649597,
-0.1887497454881668,
0.1427796483039856,
-0.022814195603132248,
-0.11897329241037369,
-0.25167563557624817,
-1.0000351667404175,
-1.1379321813583374,
-0.19926729798316956,
-0.3013852834701538,
-0.4804324209690094,
-0.04196099564433098,
1.0694822072982788,
0.7767292261123657,
-1.0599251985549927,
-0.10663068294525146,
0.17402365803718567,
0.35402506589889526,
-0.06214749440550804,
-0.20518648624420166,
0.1753302365541458,
-0.16170957684516907,
-0.6647406816482544,
0.6694604158401489,
0.28119996190071106,
-0.080038882791996,
-0.47771313786506653,
-0.3335576057434082,
-0.538768470287323,
0.10111179947853088,
0.568161129951477,
0.2683585584163666,
-0.8795772790908813,
-0.2541627883911133,
0.036336749792099,
-0.08242344856262207,
-0.0828251913189888,
0.6698310971260071,
-1.0124608278274536,
0.42293819785118103,
0.6340135335922241,
0.8297704458236694,
0.619681715965271,
-0.24718302488327026,
0.6640579700469971,
-0.693243682384491,
0.4009830951690674,
0.17439055442810059,
0.3418998420238495,
0.2964855432510376,
-0.3142583668231964,
0.38996410369873047,
0.594528317451477,
-0.2571609914302826,
-0.8583794832229614,
0.25360578298568726,
-1.0276777744293213,
-0.22932694852352142,
1.2114953994750977,
-0.47970905900001526,
-0.5414001941680908,
-0.06103638932108879,
0.13485394418239594,
0.5291233062744141,
-0.525973916053772,
0.13215692341327667,
0.6661683320999146,
-0.07380646467208862,
-0.5820385217666626,
-0.9798388481140137,
0.29637694358825684,
0.43980929255485535,
-0.9578719735145569,
0.05826111510396004,
0.7505316734313965,
0.060878936201334,
-0.08594902604818344,
0.8594669699668884,
0.47798773646354675,
-0.0479845330119133,
0.07972627133131027,
0.0794122964143753,
-0.021423762664198875,
-0.2832237780094147,
-0.5496013164520264,
0.2247592657804489,
0.030713345855474472,
-0.1570097804069519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14318v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14318v1 | The Fire Thief Is Also the Keeper: Balancing Usability and Privacy in Prompts | 2024-06-20T13:52:25 | 2024-06-20T13:52:25 | Zhili Shen, Zihang Xi, Ying He, Wei Tong, Jingyu Hua, Sheng Zhong | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | The rapid adoption of online chatbots represents a significant advancement in
artificial intelligence. However, this convenience brings considerable privacy
concerns, as prompts can inadvertently contain sensitive information exposed to
large language models (LLMs). Limited by high computational costs, reduced task
usability, and excessive system modifications, previous works based on local
deployment, embedding perturbation, and homomorphic encryption are inapplicable
to online prompt-based LLM applications.
To address these issues, this paper introduces Prompt Privacy Sanitizer
(i.e., ProSan), an end-to-end prompt privacy protection framework that can
produce anonymized prompts with contextual privacy removed while maintaining
task usability and human readability. It can also be seamlessly integrated into
the online LLM service pipeline. To achieve high usability and dynamic
anonymity, ProSan flexibly adjusts its protection targets and strength based on
the importance of the words and the privacy leakage risk of the prompts.
Additionally, ProSan is capable of adapting to diverse computational resource
conditions, ensuring privacy protection even for mobile devices with limited
computing power. Our experiments demonstrate that ProSan effectively removes
private information across various tasks, including question answering, text
summarization, and code generation, with minimal reduction in task performance. | [
-0.12446209043264389,
-0.8010129928588867,
0.4532235562801361,
0.28412726521492004,
-0.226144939661026,
0.4182172417640686,
0.1354791671037674,
-0.4673057794570923,
0.08379460871219635,
0.6630340218544006,
-0.7006738185882568,
-0.26960358023643494,
-0.28483206033706665,
0.3706989288330078,
-0.038740627467632294,
0.9125946164131165,
0.3869670033454895,
-0.25425684452056885,
-0.1344408392906189,
0.25209227204322815,
-0.3422889709472656,
-0.3739176094532013,
-0.6583017110824585,
0.16100074350833893,
0.37507152557373047,
0.3324888348579407,
1.0547744035720825,
0.6224986910820007,
0.6275453567504883,
0.3466629087924957,
-0.2872427701950073,
-0.14851433038711548,
-0.46937575936317444,
0.6797833442687988,
-0.2588415741920471,
-0.4662233889102936,
-0.19406458735466003,
-0.2911561131477356,
0.11938273161649704,
-0.06931307166814804,
0.031321171671152115,
0.007095326669514179,
0.023837143555283546,
0.45584186911582947,
-0.8999950885772705,
-0.01548049971461296,
-0.35893091559410095,
0.04452124610543251,
-0.23791243135929108,
-0.32715660333633423,
-0.2490328550338745,
-0.7473745942115784,
0.09054899960756302,
-0.6382752060890198,
0.03224828839302063,
0.22652122378349304,
0.7102099657058716,
0.4921112060546875,
-0.20164810121059418,
0.002214415231719613,
-0.6487054228782654,
0.6059677004814148,
-0.6090276837348938,
0.11610893160104752,
0.6297484636306763,
0.6534045338630676,
-0.3909502625465393,
-0.5701889395713806,
-0.6594885587692261,
0.013248971663415432,
-0.23627936840057373,
0.04492171108722687,
-0.28228238224983215,
0.2297178953886032,
0.10926858335733414,
0.17427457869052887,
-0.7348024845123291,
-0.07180055230855942,
0.014640574343502522,
-0.555781364440918,
0.7470294237136841,
0.2709770202636719,
0.556154191493988,
-0.24243544042110443,
-0.5728097558021545,
-0.034647922962903976,
-0.7069249153137207,
0.5159080028533936,
0.5666272044181824,
0.12226661294698715,
0.028286853805184364,
0.0471063107252121,
-0.32020333409309387,
0.3150782883167267,
0.09892856329679489,
-0.42797979712486267,
0.15184414386749268,
-0.38900357484817505,
0.0162341371178627,
0.04881129413843155,
0.8980350494384766,
0.5703799724578857,
0.3109421133995056,
-0.4568478763103485,
0.06581324338912964,
-0.1822834014892578,
0.19279427826404572,
-0.87811678647995,
-0.32482102513313293,
0.37439173460006714,
-0.4732356071472168,
-0.5572406649589539,
0.004628867842257023,
-0.9789949059486389,
-0.9374997019767761,
0.20153360068798065,
0.21495726704597473,
0.10375789552927017,
-0.26653915643692017,
-0.11682313680648804,
-0.1385042518377304,
0.05249001085758209,
0.19039519131183624,
-0.7676401734352112,
0.1703443080186844,
0.5189160108566284,
0.8877755999565125,
-0.11654937267303467,
0.07956603914499283,
-0.6041887402534485,
0.14780722558498383,
0.07514651864767075,
0.3982997238636017,
-0.7647310495376587,
-0.8996869921684265,
-0.044700611382722855,
0.24535010755062103,
-0.011499105021357536,
-0.5030733942985535,
0.4013132154941559,
-0.7562655806541443,
0.2614867389202118,
-0.20239676535129547,
-0.46899810433387756,
-0.14296022057533264,
0.03940719738602638,
-0.48993149399757385,
0.6461296677589417,
-0.1503819078207016,
-0.7713326215744019,
-0.1400475651025772,
-0.23544691503047943,
-0.3849169611930847,
0.3139706254005432,
-0.13974860310554504,
-0.46666496992111206,
0.04445362091064453,
0.08427943289279938,
0.458269327878952,
-0.20360301434993744,
0.17232026159763336,
-0.19037742912769318,
-0.41136378049850464,
0.37271660566329956,
-0.31827083230018616,
1.0086519718170166,
0.5410897135734558,
-0.30578407645225525,
0.4545656144618988,
-0.6916468143463135,
-0.2012196183204651,
-0.02375035360455513,
-0.11148830503225327,
-0.2878434360027313,
-0.25444793701171875,
-0.11778707057237625,
0.19799476861953735,
0.5058279037475586,
-0.907774031162262,
-0.25549718737602234,
-0.31862786412239075,
0.2349155992269516,
0.8798519968986511,
0.31368565559387207,
0.7921255230903625,
-0.23476356267929077,
0.9093264937400818,
-0.28548604249954224,
0.5362186431884766,
-0.5104804039001465,
-0.5773800611495972,
-0.032009296119213104,
-0.7125610709190369,
-0.017446087673306465,
0.9886655807495117,
-0.5460529327392578,
0.6756818294525146,
0.07470636069774628,
-0.5328963994979858,
-0.3926665782928467,
0.13402758538722992,
0.7735734581947327,
0.6593683362007141,
0.000756732071749866,
-0.23052360117435455,
-0.2729342579841614,
-0.7104800343513489,
-0.5818039178848267,
-0.01582058146595955,
-0.1274496167898178,
0.267875075340271,
-0.003459781873971224,
-0.31526824831962585,
1.1738195419311523,
-0.4652910828590393,
-0.38543492555618286,
-0.16885383427143097,
-0.3853205442428589,
0.12398763746023178,
0.5125108361244202,
0.48421889543533325,
-0.7776170969009399,
-0.5217385292053223,
-0.3598354756832123,
-0.8231631517410278,
-0.4111584722995758,
-0.3679814040660858,
-0.3703063130378723,
-0.3085673451423645,
0.5377901792526245,
-0.6040468215942383,
0.8528265357017517,
0.19294284284114838,
-0.7820906639099121,
0.38303250074386597,
-0.21234583854675293,
0.021898537874221802,
-1.0089452266693115,
-0.01692151464521885,
-0.2289600372314453,
-0.4952285587787628,
-1.0630947351455688,
0.18416288495063782,
-0.023875053972005844,
-0.4702990651130676,
-0.7147287726402283,
0.9550861716270447,
-0.17714416980743408,
0.09770958870649338,
-0.3955383598804474,
-0.0608072504401207,
-0.06321097165346146,
0.39801594614982605,
-0.07329335808753967,
1.009244680404663,
0.41913074254989624,
-0.7673037648200989,
0.28035029768943787,
0.5747901201248169,
-0.021459046751260757,
0.433648943901062,
-0.6315706372261047,
0.16538825631141663,
-0.09898164868354797,
0.3331533670425415,
-1.1407032012939453,
-0.4990170896053314,
0.5385962128639221,
-0.4626064598560333,
-0.06779594719409943,
0.2728141248226166,
-0.5572814345359802,
0.09271680563688278,
-0.7188361287117004,
0.07283433526754379,
0.6104724407196045,
-0.7723151445388794,
0.8465960621833801,
0.37617844343185425,
-0.4516181945800781,
-0.39008140563964844,
-0.31002578139305115,
0.09099730849266052,
-0.2880862057209015,
-0.857679009437561,
0.38855135440826416,
-0.2126014679670334,
-0.3898307979106903,
-0.19726590812206268,
-0.3229665756225586,
-0.19787879288196564,
0.7200568318367004,
0.5375654101371765,
0.20462831854820251,
0.5160341262817383,
-0.09401724487543106,
0.08453572541475296,
-0.4958413541316986,
0.07720085978507996,
0.4997250735759735,
0.4958859980106354,
0.059750594198703766,
0.034781210124492645,
-1.1359590291976929,
0.3258562684059143,
0.35516732931137085,
-0.3190380036830902,
0.9287766218185425,
0.34883013367652893,
-0.1794077605009079,
0.1527692675590515,
-0.20026329159736633,
-0.4794597029685974,
-0.6266404986381531,
-0.08785322308540344,
-0.30908554792404175,
-0.9867395162582397,
0.7635285258293152,
-0.21591396629810333,
0.5925058126449585,
-0.11321315914392471,
0.27643126249313354,
-0.11890718340873718,
0.8860159516334534,
0.37678465247154236,
-0.12706848978996277,
0.7375638484954834,
0.2951893210411072,
0.5299186110496521,
-0.5746762752532959,
-0.42543214559555054,
-0.49662351608276367,
-0.4367220401763916,
-0.3293112516403198,
0.17508408427238464,
0.3593941926956177,
0.3444972336292267,
-0.26901566982269287,
0.5180839896202087,
-0.5211818218231201,
0.8551924824714661,
0.6349096298217773,
0.23349662125110626,
0.27918741106987,
-0.3360777199268341,
0.2539689540863037,
-0.007404895033687353,
-0.1408347189426422,
-0.699662983417511,
0.7553823590278625,
0.28036391735076904,
0.8220621943473816,
0.4270809292793274,
0.8756086230278015,
0.48849374055862427,
-0.1629229187965393,
-0.12012065947055817,
0.8518840670585632,
0.19212865829467773,
-0.6486462950706482,
-0.28235527873039246,
-0.32241562008857727,
-0.9186159372329712,
0.5290777087211609,
0.12889640033245087,
-0.9442304968833923,
0.3432444632053375,
0.22362716495990753,
-0.8995864987373352,
0.16783641278743744,
-0.7633114457130432,
0.7874508500099182,
-0.1146596297621727,
-0.6730282306671143,
-0.003403040813282132,
-1.016419768333435,
0.4033823311328888,
-0.01577192172408104,
0.41785725951194763,
-0.35851535201072693,
-0.14268074929714203,
0.5139569640159607,
-0.7091214060783386,
0.9760567545890808,
-0.42790669202804565,
-0.07979178428649902,
0.17379969358444214,
0.5888733267784119,
0.8327111005783081,
0.4127017855644226,
0.04106173291802406,
-0.06954798847436905,
-0.07085767388343811,
-0.2924961745738983,
-0.5473600625991821,
0.48888108134269714,
-0.32300737500190735,
-0.8624619245529175,
-0.5620691180229187,
-0.3263108432292938,
-0.09256383031606674,
0.02928423322737217,
0.4733140170574188,
0.24290987849235535,
0.007773915305733681,
0.2948596477508545,
0.6811935901641846,
-0.6081717014312744,
0.9263567328453064,
0.3735871911048889,
-0.18392692506313324,
-0.4366123676300049,
0.8762935996055603,
-0.6150287389755249,
0.1669883131980896,
0.33298996090888977,
0.5062916874885559,
-0.5165130496025085,
-0.14001654088497162,
-0.4836035370826721,
-0.1299566775560379,
-0.5107772946357727,
-0.3053240180015564,
-0.6608030796051025,
-0.15815408527851105,
-0.4101298451423645,
-0.6029415726661682,
0.024453818798065186,
-0.6056588292121887,
-0.6107866764068604,
-0.15711672604084015,
0.649142861366272,
0.08551941812038422,
0.02153312973678112,
0.9707286357879639,
-0.9479079246520996,
0.40663373470306396,
0.372753381729126,
-0.11516430974006653,
-0.09795067459344864,
-0.6203740239143372,
0.22795748710632324,
-0.4220859110355377,
-0.21421073377132416,
-0.8448207378387451,
0.4925253093242645,
0.23348526656627655,
0.38519611954689026,
0.628093957901001,
0.5730792880058289,
0.26705029606819153,
-0.37489861249923706,
1.0167557001113892,
0.36751145124435425,
-0.7471258044242859,
0.31339383125305176,
-0.24485042691230774,
0.4072405993938446,
0.8962037563323975,
0.022264666855335236,
-0.49062851071357727,
-0.49987179040908813,
-0.5088282227516174,
-0.9279536604881287,
0.626412570476532,
0.34481939673423767,
0.3716062903404236,
0.04248693212866783,
0.04987303167581558,
0.25473111867904663,
0.49571630358695984,
-0.33917173743247986,
-0.20814938843250275,
-0.03804578259587288,
-0.34157106280326843,
0.24068570137023926,
-0.25891438126564026,
0.07650379091501236,
0.034999821335077286,
0.444535493850708,
0.315339595079422,
0.179390549659729,
-0.13322196900844574,
-0.22188261151313782,
0.38886111974716187,
0.5372616648674011,
0.38992080092430115,
0.23387901484966278,
0.01675095036625862,
0.2278498113155365,
-0.10544832795858383,
-0.6401878595352173,
0.30296340584754944,
-0.055840130895376205,
-0.5356680154800415,
-0.0025626213755458593,
0.3004368543624878,
0.6063271164894104,
0.3625601530075073,
-0.7816402912139893,
0.5992613434791565,
-0.36714667081832886,
0.24645227193832397,
-0.25832024216651917,
0.6205688118934631,
-0.21463538706302643,
0.26735904812812805,
0.2612515091896057,
0.18591776490211487,
0.2428371161222458,
-0.5003933310508728,
0.21532167494297028,
0.079421766102314,
-0.044949520379304886,
-0.570110023021698,
1.016801118850708,
0.8269270062446594,
-0.6958826184272766,
0.24059732258319855,
-0.3794988989830017,
-0.6793551445007324,
0.4001119136810303,
0.34839892387390137,
1.2077288627624512,
-0.8249963521957397,
0.29037997126579285,
0.12814168632030487,
0.0005360396462492645,
0.02635299041867256,
0.7339144349098206,
-0.5020933151245117,
-0.45752453804016113,
0.38135331869125366,
-0.49857985973358154,
-0.3904566764831543,
-0.2564822733402252,
-0.3561822474002838,
-0.2938874065876007,
-1.1544220447540283,
-0.3197723925113678,
-0.31913527846336365,
-0.393997460603714,
-0.4373244047164917,
0.042339663952589035,
-0.3567514717578888,
0.5645231008529663,
-0.5002299547195435,
0.2568522095680237,
0.030756335705518723,
-0.15893667936325073,
-0.2709946632385254,
0.1338248997926712,
0.5255849361419678,
-0.4680279493331909,
0.25011196732521057,
0.40987628698349,
-0.21031709015369415,
-0.10321125388145447,
-0.2938746511936188,
-0.6873533129692078,
0.8454844355583191,
0.4622040390968323,
-1.010390043258667,
0.032688915729522705,
-0.03789186477661133,
0.4148414731025696,
0.015698328614234924,
0.1339261680841446,
0.6184918880462646,
0.331773042678833,
-0.10375889390707016,
-0.8360813856124878,
0.25768768787384033,
-0.23450542986392975,
-0.18955963850021362,
0.029422558844089508,
-0.7250721454620361,
0.47882840037345886,
-0.15452462434768677,
-0.6039433479309082,
0.3409181237220764,
0.4599100649356842,
0.35508885979652405,
0.3853413462638855,
0.4570835530757904,
0.18372538685798645,
1.0909298658370972,
-0.030543070286512375,
0.9823434352874756,
-0.3538348078727722,
-0.29707762598991394,
1.1303374767303467,
-0.5715459585189819,
0.5623039603233337,
0.2736424207687378,
-0.02508457377552986,
0.3218177556991577,
0.6430761814117432,
0.29215207695961,
1.055653691291809,
0.2674124240875244,
-0.9203222990036011,
-0.2333206832408905,
-0.4859907925128937,
-0.32576170563697815,
0.11164972186088562,
-0.002834738465026021,
-0.3300233483314514,
-0.09843698143959045,
0.29867029190063477,
0.362170547246933,
0.30648934841156006,
-0.22038646042346954,
0.9539377093315125,
0.06509613245725632,
-0.2573252022266388,
0.25415322184562683,
-0.05881727114319801,
0.764312207698822,
-0.40614742040634155,
0.49579134583473206,
-0.240549236536026,
0.42231374979019165,
-0.3558759391307831,
-0.5977334380149841,
0.33622604608535767,
0.4290771186351776,
-0.02421661838889122,
-0.5037741661071777,
0.8224374651908875,
-0.08720216155052185,
-0.01017885934561491,
0.15565723180770874,
0.13640236854553223,
0.32210689783096313,
-0.20734809339046478,
-0.5404269695281982,
0.1471841186285019,
0.09748339653015137,
-0.42505064606666565,
0.3369678854942322,
-0.023586321622133255,
-0.0456995889544487,
0.7271541357040405,
0.7628107666969299,
-0.24191805720329285,
0.2796485722064972,
0.0841885432600975,
0.8876162767410278,
-0.6375032067298889,
-1.1070075035095215,
-1.0457344055175781,
0.39133238792419434,
-0.32972949743270874,
-0.5422141551971436,
1.0695961713790894,
0.53116375207901,
0.5689374804496765,
-0.0016399748856201768,
0.7654422521591187,
0.1131957471370697,
0.6228832006454468,
-0.3046016991138458,
0.8769558072090149,
-0.08997108042240143,
0.34776225686073303,
-0.2835557162761688,
-0.8575344681739807,
-0.29209786653518677,
0.42307373881340027,
0.015025247819721699,
-0.28392598032951355,
0.3363683819770813,
0.9304467439651489,
0.49104368686676025,
0.4560188949108124,
0.29232293367385864,
-0.3350851535797119,
0.6085259318351746,
0.39570456743240356,
0.6897363662719727,
-0.08785836398601532,
0.4965677559375763,
-0.20114967226982117,
-0.33387520909309387,
-0.1321985125541687,
-0.6331243515014648,
-1.1983953714370728,
-0.21295763552188873,
-0.25977659225463867,
-0.07202854007482529,
0.09204372763633728,
0.766666829586029,
0.6584518551826477,
-0.7684341669082642,
0.17044642567634583,
-0.1231224462389946,
-0.09460826963186264,
0.006754819303750992,
-0.20992590487003326,
0.2326144576072693,
0.009434834122657776,
-0.3288313150405884,
0.7849087715148926,
0.32662832736968994,
0.02941909432411194,
-0.18814513087272644,
-0.18808363378047943,
0.09087500721216202,
0.21769748628139496,
0.1721706986427307,
0.598639726638794,
-0.7303870916366577,
-0.1644197404384613,
0.19161951541900635,
-0.01972980611026287,
-0.2339913249015808,
0.5154706835746765,
-0.6102675199508667,
0.7971999049186707,
0.9149884581565857,
1.030131459236145,
0.0034803426824510098,
0.4541763365268707,
0.46722254157066345,
-1.0410034656524658,
0.2992538511753082,
0.18192158639431,
0.15916858613491058,
0.30025744438171387,
-0.9670945405960083,
0.44540247321128845,
0.24027366936206818,
-0.4997970163822174,
-0.9437028765678406,
0.4318922758102417,
-0.5148900747299194,
-0.32835322618484497,
0.908085286617279,
-0.3584717810153961,
-0.41819095611572266,
-0.44580891728401184,
-0.33581864833831787,
-0.0038758970331400633,
-0.8790732622146606,
0.7210317850112915,
0.466885507106781,
-0.14414621889591217,
-0.20829108357429504,
-0.2965870797634125,
0.8031358122825623,
0.20428086817264557,
-1.0054693222045898,
0.3130081295967102,
0.287643700838089,
0.05676375329494476,
0.22162501513957977,
0.6752973198890686,
-0.12296850234270096,
0.5882121920585632,
-0.3204341530799866,
-0.09968104958534241,
-0.38897380232810974,
-0.6378656625747681,
-0.52694171667099,
0.13029292225837708,
-0.4357122480869293,
-0.6013112664222717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14314v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14314v2 | Identifying User Goals from UI Trajectories | 2024-06-20T13:46:10 | 2024-06-30T12:33:48 | Omri Berkovitch, Sapir Caduri, Noam Kahlon, Anatoly Efros, Avi Caciularu, Ido Dagan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Autonomous agents that interact with graphical user interfaces (GUIs) hold
significant potential for enhancing user experiences. To further improve these
experiences, agents need to be personalized and proactive. By effectively
comprehending user intentions through their actions and interactions with GUIs,
agents will be better positioned to achieve these goals. This paper introduces
the task of goal identification from observed UI trajectories, aiming to infer
the user's intended task based on their GUI interactions. We propose a novel
evaluation metric to assess whether two task descriptions are paraphrases
within a specific UI environment. By Leveraging the inverse relation with the
UI automation task, we utilized the Android-In-The-Wild and Mind2Web datasets
for our experiments. Using our metric and these datasets, we conducted several
experiments comparing the performance of humans and state-of-the-art models,
specifically GPT-4 and Gemini-1.5 Pro. Our results show that Gemini performs
better than GPT but still underperforms compared to humans, indicating
significant room for improvement. | [
-0.18742984533309937,
-0.650892972946167,
1.037745475769043,
-0.11085961014032364,
0.028949402272701263,
0.039172664284706116,
0.09491938352584839,
-0.03694194555282593,
0.25575143098831177,
0.6004331111907959,
-0.8051238059997559,
-0.594710648059845,
-0.40185925364494324,
-0.07349596172571182,
-0.44667309522628784,
1.165328025817871,
-0.28840357065200806,
-0.6893519759178162,
-0.5703001022338867,
0.06640385836362839,
-0.49620485305786133,
-0.02281339094042778,
-0.4848366677761078,
-0.09506682306528091,
0.7168179750442505,
0.3723578453063965,
0.847314715385437,
0.260085791349411,
0.42063817381858826,
0.3551531732082367,
0.5076279640197754,
0.09360223263502121,
-0.3424098491668701,
0.11510486900806427,
-0.022642673924565315,
-0.07280275225639343,
-0.1753762662410736,
0.07730954140424728,
0.27494290471076965,
0.33393391966819763,
0.1537920981645584,
0.2681160867214203,
0.44124653935432434,
0.4151208996772766,
-0.5752885341644287,
0.3919115662574768,
-0.012897051870822906,
0.07690108567476273,
-0.10267159342765808,
-0.02726050466299057,
0.012833920307457447,
-0.4866289496421814,
0.11540968716144562,
-1.0552189350128174,
-0.0655493512749672,
-0.07478993386030197,
0.8654400110244751,
0.28510043025016785,
-0.436625599861145,
-0.2834480404853821,
-0.5712390542030334,
0.7548354864120483,
-0.5326095819473267,
0.18524092435836792,
0.20512345433235168,
0.3772065341472626,
-0.4347293972969055,
-0.8587329983711243,
-0.6431677341461182,
-0.5335370898246765,
-0.3717581629753113,
0.17316003143787384,
-0.3090468645095825,
0.18305115401744843,
0.31867173314094543,
-0.36402156949043274,
-0.8549854755401611,
-0.32809895277023315,
-0.2638459801673889,
-0.39629805088043213,
0.45844727754592896,
0.30676954984664917,
0.4993496537208557,
-0.25753745436668396,
-0.4317799508571625,
-0.06721913069486618,
-0.035231079906225204,
0.4963643550872803,
0.3375639021396637,
-0.024953270331025124,
-0.21200329065322876,
0.651497483253479,
-0.5285513401031494,
0.6101080775260925,
0.05754919350147247,
-0.28554490208625793,
0.22503633797168732,
-0.5015633702278137,
0.05998529493808746,
-0.5497792363166809,
0.7619563937187195,
0.7246214151382446,
0.25040969252586365,
-0.7931581735610962,
-0.3988910913467407,
-0.12341561913490295,
0.4022703468799591,
-0.4021107256412506,
-0.2485899031162262,
0.035279225558042526,
-0.44698408246040344,
-0.0010865547228604555,
0.36667823791503906,
-0.43732693791389465,
-0.4601791203022003,
-0.5718308091163635,
0.7626616358757019,
-0.3503701686859131,
-0.056012291461229324,
-0.4006398916244507,
-0.5816671848297119,
0.07570164650678635,
0.3116542398929596,
-0.5013725757598877,
0.4029417634010315,
0.9833670258522034,
1.0534024238586426,
-0.4116395115852356,
-0.48092108964920044,
-0.538772463798523,
0.2163936197757721,
-0.16992217302322388,
0.5956567525863647,
-0.46807634830474854,
-0.4725976288318634,
-0.48304638266563416,
-0.21460631489753723,
-0.3608079254627228,
-0.1656699776649475,
0.5334950089454651,
-0.16870485246181488,
0.07267530262470245,
-0.45977702736854553,
-0.34780430793762207,
-0.19165746867656708,
0.4194549024105072,
-0.40000736713409424,
0.941460371017456,
0.5568075776100159,
-0.6147328615188599,
0.37261447310447693,
-0.9462568163871765,
-0.4849221706390381,
0.14992637932300568,
0.014767678454518318,
-0.16327089071273804,
0.2220315933227539,
-0.015713315457105637,
0.5082565546035767,
-0.24202215671539307,
0.1390274167060852,
-0.0967467799782753,
-0.44635531306266785,
0.1660475879907608,
-0.17884667217731476,
0.4938415288925171,
0.1431390345096588,
-0.28953322768211365,
0.3699186444282532,
-0.4951498508453369,
0.14495183527469635,
-0.27884751558303833,
0.034654535353183746,
-0.6813418865203857,
0.1504363864660263,
-0.038253650069236755,
0.40696847438812256,
0.7167852520942688,
-0.7640265226364136,
-0.028747357428073883,
-0.12811385095119476,
0.24804942309856415,
0.7571304440498352,
0.15360236167907715,
0.35542675852775574,
-0.3568899929523468,
0.6260153651237488,
-0.15006448328495026,
0.5286242365837097,
0.27272945642471313,
-0.6589050889015198,
0.01795656979084015,
-0.04706478491425514,
-0.08240936696529388,
0.5079709887504578,
-0.8954092860221863,
0.24666769802570343,
-0.44754838943481445,
-0.6224619150161743,
-0.02276422642171383,
0.279162734746933,
0.5492716431617737,
0.9631587862968445,
0.3310365080833435,
-0.3413441777229309,
-0.11290661245584488,
-0.9477685689926147,
-0.6357426643371582,
-0.5775898694992065,
-0.39556005597114563,
0.5336385369300842,
0.5520252585411072,
-0.3400908410549164,
1.3017827272415161,
-0.45042216777801514,
-0.1587732434272766,
-0.31432196497917175,
0.4219975471496582,
0.1826704740524292,
0.28199413418769836,
0.6325746774673462,
-1.0106134414672852,
-0.6164730787277222,
0.29563120007514954,
-0.8782456517219543,
-0.26666122674942017,
-0.3693738281726837,
-0.24732592701911926,
-0.40549519658088684,
0.07761462777853012,
-0.7113447785377502,
0.71597820520401,
0.35219359397888184,
-0.6221235394477844,
0.7233980894088745,
-0.34104570746421814,
0.46039634943008423,
-0.7602474689483643,
0.2833227515220642,
0.3795803487300873,
-0.14302681386470795,
-0.684207022190094,
-0.3055008053779602,
0.14327949285507202,
0.0167909637093544,
-0.23490560054779053,
0.8106868863105774,
-0.11379408091306686,
-0.42708510160446167,
-0.34840989112854004,
0.21198315918445587,
-0.048512380570173264,
0.6510329842567444,
0.05017589405179024,
0.7943549156188965,
0.24366116523742676,
-0.6234111189842224,
0.4835721254348755,
0.33594653010368347,
-0.3202431797981262,
0.6583789587020874,
-0.7185008525848389,
0.07737772911787033,
0.0037974976003170013,
0.15534056723117828,
-1.1581106185913086,
-0.34442150592803955,
0.4303465187549591,
-0.5402432084083557,
-0.5077962875366211,
0.17468798160552979,
-0.4520484209060669,
-0.7711273431777954,
-0.3094448745250702,
0.04540921375155449,
0.5249710083007812,
-0.36061155796051025,
0.7289515733718872,
0.1555991917848587,
-0.016330942511558533,
-0.4689224362373352,
-0.10480678826570511,
0.2223152220249176,
-0.5981850028038025,
-0.43259692192077637,
0.27440565824508667,
0.16136686503887177,
-0.2944496273994446,
-0.17604532837867737,
-0.10367957502603531,
0.1531004011631012,
0.3581703305244446,
0.6581203937530518,
0.2537809908390045,
0.28833526372909546,
-0.25328654050827026,
0.23762264847755432,
-0.1632000207901001,
0.3441835641860962,
-0.271070659160614,
0.014528523199260235,
0.251145601272583,
-0.15243089199066162,
-0.9230638742446899,
0.11615977436304092,
0.5642246603965759,
-0.06859590113162994,
0.3628960847854614,
0.7601776719093323,
-0.19901788234710693,
0.2988063097000122,
-0.24081295728683472,
-0.08395035564899445,
-0.4846721589565277,
0.37806379795074463,
-0.8106480240821838,
-0.07371039688587189,
0.48346129059791565,
-0.22157427668571472,
0.32080987095832825,
0.31700313091278076,
0.11122508347034454,
-0.4097434878349304,
1.2350786924362183,
0.4381001591682434,
-0.07994670420885086,
0.5988585948944092,
-0.13766443729400635,
-0.2456798255443573,
-0.8347052931785583,
-0.2583962082862854,
-0.36631062626838684,
-0.8004345297813416,
-0.36655810475349426,
-0.06356746703386307,
0.7254044413566589,
-0.2053905427455902,
-0.15690644085407257,
0.8383165597915649,
-0.30618295073509216,
0.11945053935050964,
0.9011488556861877,
0.41359755396842957,
-0.05743897333741188,
-0.16353687644004822,
-0.12432786822319031,
0.08399688452482224,
-0.06435181945562363,
-0.7028911113739014,
1.1056978702545166,
0.007949339225888252,
0.6893256306648254,
-0.012904803268611431,
0.7074927091598511,
0.7547004222869873,
0.14212548732757568,
-0.41806355118751526,
0.7898477911949158,
0.010090836323797703,
-0.35179823637008667,
-0.5415212512016296,
-0.4577803313732147,
-1.0012997388839722,
0.058090392500162125,
0.13539056479930878,
-1.3416045904159546,
-0.045782774686813354,
0.16289715468883514,
-0.3293895125389099,
-0.13287438452243805,
-0.6678237915039062,
1.4104753732681274,
-0.46624937653541565,
-0.38283267617225647,
-0.21101294457912445,
-0.9700686931610107,
-0.10899373143911362,
0.02491837367415428,
0.028058679774403572,
-0.30489465594291687,
-0.43445974588394165,
0.9556414484977722,
-0.2716529071331024,
0.5784099698066711,
-0.7013105154037476,
0.15925848484039307,
0.25709378719329834,
-0.09035537391901016,
0.8032193779945374,
-0.1412268579006195,
-0.1524912714958191,
-0.0749528557062149,
0.1232009083032608,
-0.2794296443462372,
-0.8676681518554688,
0.6681866645812988,
-0.7133281826972961,
-0.6622725129127502,
-0.05745231732726097,
-0.5231510996818542,
-0.2838824987411499,
0.15889738500118256,
0.20010118186473846,
0.36784276366233826,
-0.4143199026584625,
-0.13447928428649902,
-0.11047156900167465,
-0.06518986821174622,
0.3208819627761841,
0.28318682312965393,
0.03980783745646477,
0.10615341365337372,
1.000765323638916,
-0.29765844345092773,
0.1474807858467102,
0.6861168742179871,
0.39920392632484436,
-0.5872358083724976,
-0.5272904634475708,
-0.6396561861038208,
-0.004908774048089981,
-0.4623386263847351,
0.21791596710681915,
-0.5837826728820801,
0.29368856549263,
-0.39493420720100403,
-0.2092437893152237,
0.06270969659090042,
-0.2543720304965973,
-0.4966203570365906,
0.15628325939178467,
0.02999711222946644,
0.7045281529426575,
-0.05488942563533783,
0.431350439786911,
-0.6011980772018433,
0.662323534488678,
0.1980431228876114,
-0.34510567784309387,
-0.3389337658882141,
-0.39315342903137207,
-0.2590073347091675,
0.3810238540172577,
-0.6532148122787476,
-0.8844337463378906,
0.4267478287220001,
0.11550556123256683,
0.9238865375518799,
0.5637810826301575,
0.22953173518180847,
0.7727992534637451,
-0.15084074437618256,
0.8101524710655212,
0.25106146931648254,
-0.8395812511444092,
0.7455180883407593,
-0.24875004589557648,
0.3211052417755127,
0.5426948070526123,
0.4200115501880646,
-0.5932089686393738,
-0.4830843508243561,
-0.4220321774482727,
-0.47169050574302673,
0.6260644197463989,
0.502257227897644,
0.14352376759052277,
0.15929527580738068,
0.6616248488426208,
0.3722272217273712,
0.13919977843761444,
-0.43969517946243286,
-0.023757969960570335,
-0.03195277974009514,
-0.5871562361717224,
-0.38429364562034607,
0.37075871229171753,
0.04874211177229881,
-0.06433765590190887,
0.24349041283130646,
-0.3096686005592346,
0.3443741798400879,
-0.015317467041313648,
-0.17513489723205566,
0.06757605075836182,
-0.10405607521533966,
0.24835936725139618,
0.9523071050643921,
0.05174462869763374,
-0.18538640439510345,
0.032178252935409546,
-0.6258948445320129,
0.19317154586315155,
0.1894618719816208,
-0.19236621260643005,
0.04189373180270195,
0.28164350986480713,
0.7451157569885254,
0.09521130472421646,
-0.8337417244911194,
0.5146546363830566,
-0.23093880712985992,
0.16544711589813232,
-0.19820597767829895,
0.5067933201789856,
-0.42424720525741577,
0.5642728805541992,
0.43646514415740967,
0.12080935388803482,
0.665526807308197,
-0.4922181963920593,
0.09769615530967712,
0.6500447392463684,
-0.49891194701194763,
-0.6550498604774475,
0.9996817111968994,
0.16922324895858765,
-0.4606844484806061,
0.5442692637443542,
-0.1445695459842682,
-0.3706645667552948,
0.9333894848823547,
0.2147081047296524,
0.9973150491714478,
0.05956065282225609,
0.480532169342041,
0.30057358741760254,
-0.08144866675138474,
0.030565813183784485,
0.12518347799777985,
-0.7918623685836792,
-0.36131787300109863,
0.0016397263389080763,
-0.5616701245307922,
-0.3825928866863251,
-0.32327044010162354,
-0.6700097322463989,
0.1903732717037201,
0.11576087772846222,
-0.44553619623184204,
0.047025762498378754,
0.016702214255928993,
-0.7394278049468994,
0.40450671315193176,
-0.14621637761592865,
0.316851943731308,
-0.6426113843917847,
0.6950982213020325,
0.7743210792541504,
-0.11039149761199951,
-0.5647379755973816,
0.4024914503097534,
0.1502271145582199,
-0.6238881945610046,
0.7740315198898315,
0.24495765566825867,
-0.14121803641319275,
-0.006685957778245211,
-0.04055417701601982,
-0.5651602745056152,
1.2886853218078613,
0.17353610694408417,
-0.5525717735290527,
-0.5145481824874878,
0.12333638221025467,
0.5176082253456116,
-0.15429052710533142,
0.49866461753845215,
0.7411373853683472,
0.7221574783325195,
-0.0339646115899086,
-1.081903100013733,
-0.0586712583899498,
-0.08763992786407471,
0.08349616825580597,
0.23916342854499817,
-0.23928910493850708,
0.572627604007721,
-0.4713253676891327,
-0.11578352749347687,
0.526315450668335,
0.669343888759613,
0.0004338962025940418,
0.7223079204559326,
0.6720973253250122,
0.08825609087944031,
0.46212148666381836,
-0.110171377658844,
1.1627039909362793,
-0.09584429115056992,
0.11820858716964722,
0.7051458358764648,
-0.01633927784860134,
0.5060340762138367,
0.5592964291572571,
-0.2455882430076599,
0.5071818828582764,
0.5646754503250122,
0.4563646614551544,
0.8638582229614258,
-0.039820846170186996,
-0.03996727243065834,
-0.036110322922468185,
0.27240678668022156,
0.135728657245636,
0.41654691100120544,
0.38897883892059326,
-0.2678433656692505,
-0.030430004000663757,
0.5649515986442566,
-0.08473294973373413,
0.12427929788827896,
-0.3152426481246948,
0.9971930980682373,
-0.3616316020488739,
-1.2304166555404663,
0.0682590901851654,
-0.07319866865873337,
0.43608900904655457,
-0.6297099590301514,
0.10987533628940582,
-0.12277282774448395,
0.26956674456596375,
-0.0886106938123703,
-0.9502896070480347,
0.07388918846845627,
0.07807300239801407,
0.18727967143058777,
-0.18972724676132202,
0.5099829435348511,
0.005858953110873699,
-0.34687182307243347,
0.17254871129989624,
0.3579050898551941,
0.36572420597076416,
-0.32828056812286377,
-0.8869418501853943,
-0.29136502742767334,
0.2542455196380615,
-0.37569400668144226,
0.192783385515213,
0.3120935261249542,
-0.24727116525173187,
0.8592081069946289,
0.21915939450263977,
-0.18360432982444763,
-0.2784993648529053,
-0.29683467745780945,
0.5822057723999023,
-0.6796953082084656,
-0.7790772914886475,
-0.8208732008934021,
0.42653709650039673,
-0.16229292750358582,
-0.527858555316925,
1.0755115747451782,
0.6902971863746643,
0.46548593044281006,
-0.2253463864326477,
0.9191160202026367,
-0.3888428211212158,
0.5305802226066589,
-0.1495620310306549,
0.3241868317127228,
-0.7411760687828064,
0.0930638536810875,
-0.5428783893585205,
-1.0256954431533813,
0.3154590427875519,
0.47497114539146423,
-0.6252199411392212,
0.2441752701997757,
0.29782670736312866,
0.8149053454399109,
-0.15095044672489166,
-0.13047228753566742,
0.43792852759361267,
-0.2457587718963623,
0.30396413803100586,
0.7939876317977905,
1.044639229774475,
-0.21006831526756287,
0.6674540042877197,
-0.3389546871185303,
-0.35852569341659546,
-0.09502028673887253,
-0.46564576029777527,
-0.7515202164649963,
-0.8364938497543335,
-0.4862729012966156,
-0.14413557946681976,
0.39699965715408325,
0.5178967118263245,
0.6067413687705994,
-0.5777055025100708,
-0.3380657136440277,
-0.42775341868400574,
0.07202502340078354,
-0.7555373311042786,
-0.19519029557704926,
0.27682560682296753,
-0.1295301467180252,
-0.9041759371757507,
0.1885661482810974,
0.23752650618553162,
-0.022289426997303963,
-0.10860913246870041,
-0.5332919359207153,
0.16055487096309662,
-0.03839335963129997,
0.2983384430408478,
0.6178686618804932,
-0.7848185300827026,
-0.5295789241790771,
-0.11713337153196335,
-0.14504432678222656,
-0.18406912684440613,
0.7648346424102783,
-1.0140329599380493,
0.26247304677963257,
0.3591321110725403,
0.08109427988529205,
0.5472365021705627,
0.6407741904258728,
0.5168151259422302,
-0.8118532299995422,
-0.25616586208343506,
0.2347685545682907,
0.09521810710430145,
0.038237787783145905,
-0.4006871283054352,
0.4401681423187256,
0.006069335155189037,
-0.5055599808692932,
-0.44298869371414185,
-0.1703856885433197,
-0.9705048203468323,
-0.15242139995098114,
1.214622139930725,
-0.4642067849636078,
-0.20087052881717682,
-0.3125894069671631,
-0.4947548806667328,
0.14307905733585358,
-0.4675750136375427,
0.6460622549057007,
0.29148125648498535,
-0.5621729493141174,
0.05203423649072647,
-0.5065034031867981,
0.4996547996997833,
-0.11988603323698044,
-1.0254255533218384,
-0.15251179039478302,
0.5821913480758667,
0.18893878161907196,
0.1286473572254181,
0.4368983805179596,
0.26652342081069946,
0.5680356025695801,
-0.10933271795511246,
-0.24059449136257172,
-0.03460284322500229,
-0.33843111991882324,
0.49231627583503723,
0.187924325466156,
-0.20783665776252747,
-0.6278949975967407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14313v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14313v1 | Robust Few-shot Transfer Learning for Knowledge Base Question Answering with Unanswerable Questions | 2024-06-20T13:43:38 | 2024-06-20T13:43:38 | Riya Sawhney, Indrajit Bhattacharya, Mausam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Real-world KBQA applications require models that are (1) robust -- e.g., can
differentiate between answerable and unanswerable questions, and (2)
low-resource -- do not require large training data. Towards this goal, we
propose the novel task of few-shot transfer for KBQA with unanswerable
questions. We present FUn-FuSIC that extends the state-of-the-art (SoTA)
few-shot transfer model for answerable-only KBQA to handle unanswerability. It
iteratively prompts an LLM to generate logical forms for the question by
providing feedback using a diverse suite of syntactic, semantic and execution
guided checks, and adapts self-consistency to assess confidence of the LLM to
decide answerability. Experiments over newly constructed datasets show that
FUn-FuSIC outperforms suitable adaptations of the SoTA model for KBQA with
unanswerability, and the SoTA model for answerable-only few-shot-transfer KBQA. | [
-0.18938924372196198,
-0.9827724099159241,
0.7905769944190979,
0.002006866503506899,
-0.028764881193637848,
-0.09496193379163742,
-0.04343930259346962,
-0.35683947801589966,
0.10171172767877579,
0.5431628823280334,
-1.0479917526245117,
-0.21546275913715363,
-0.46746447682380676,
0.02497268281877041,
-0.43300995230674744,
1.0196701288223267,
-0.05911221355199814,
-0.20592226088047028,
-0.40240469574928284,
-0.13404105603694916,
-0.45869719982147217,
-0.16184507310390472,
-0.3301354944705963,
-0.24675144255161285,
0.1793142855167389,
0.8495274186134338,
0.4115120470523834,
0.011816808022558689,
0.49228668212890625,
0.1644567847251892,
0.2593088746070862,
0.10066495090723038,
-0.6080583930015564,
0.08839626610279083,
-0.19408169388771057,
-0.6952648758888245,
-0.390175998210907,
-0.3924126923084259,
0.41103920340538025,
0.6932209730148315,
0.0896991640329361,
0.425808310508728,
-0.055070485919713974,
0.5381019115447998,
-0.7969146966934204,
0.17404676973819733,
-0.6572539210319519,
-0.11478453129529953,
0.10056401789188385,
0.002980676479637623,
-0.3570651710033417,
-0.5110725164413452,
0.19382542371749878,
-0.8071470260620117,
-0.296275794506073,
-0.21067258715629578,
0.5444476008415222,
0.3219749927520752,
-0.42731115221977234,
-0.15848258137702942,
-0.6641326546669006,
0.40740805864334106,
-0.6411654353141785,
0.1404036432504654,
0.5183812379837036,
0.729586124420166,
-0.3184462785720825,
-0.6275056600570679,
-0.5762566328048706,
-0.07398368418216705,
0.152452290058136,
0.2754461467266083,
-0.34987694025039673,
-0.13698804378509521,
0.09786805510520935,
-0.37445107102394104,
-0.5778752565383911,
-0.22008481621742249,
-0.42106425762176514,
-0.31399285793304443,
0.4220326840877533,
0.05999791994690895,
0.0798211321234703,
-0.11854293942451477,
-0.5680108070373535,
0.16371317207813263,
-0.48790350556373596,
0.37536242604255676,
-0.021938541904091835,
0.4190617501735687,
0.030128568410873413,
0.5621176958084106,
-0.5683151483535767,
0.8501283526420593,
0.07573506236076355,
-0.32133209705352783,
-0.3137623965740204,
-0.17921823263168335,
-0.10755767673254013,
-0.1800471544265747,
0.4845167100429535,
0.010359516367316246,
0.38836175203323364,
-0.3470175862312317,
-0.013123838230967522,
-0.310383141040802,
0.20238655805587769,
-0.7308678030967712,
-0.5845150947570801,
0.26470431685447693,
-0.14931929111480713,
-0.44375714659690857,
-0.04665181413292885,
-0.6703845262527466,
-0.27996617555618286,
0.31518834829330444,
1.1860672235488892,
-0.4487013816833496,
-0.20262669026851654,
0.01918352209031582,
0.12212009727954865,
0.16107431054115295,
0.6573271155357361,
-0.7632334232330322,
0.35970884561538696,
0.31559106707572937,
0.46330198645591736,
-0.22679519653320312,
-0.1397160291671753,
-0.6881514191627502,
0.1945124715566635,
-0.283926397562027,
1.1561142206192017,
-0.22102409601211548,
-0.008244526572525501,
-0.3618583381175995,
0.0041168928146362305,
-0.11942466348409653,
-0.31916993856430054,
0.11978413164615631,
-0.7914121747016907,
0.20534493029117584,
-0.4359495937824249,
-0.674388587474823,
-0.4299808740615845,
0.7424177527427673,
-0.3102550208568573,
0.8016828894615173,
0.5802764892578125,
-0.7465668320655823,
0.12221478670835495,
-0.5700209140777588,
-0.31633293628692627,
0.07006116956472397,
-0.005132573656737804,
-0.2833161950111389,
-0.16585209965705872,
0.05907675623893738,
0.2765108346939087,
0.021066201850771904,
-0.08609312027692795,
-0.6275221109390259,
-0.33083492517471313,
0.553245484828949,
-0.34107786417007446,
0.8108176589012146,
0.14536578953266144,
-0.1761969029903412,
-0.1831507682800293,
-0.8131129741668701,
0.45600149035453796,
-0.00158408610150218,
-0.4025343656539917,
-0.014206002466380596,
-0.6500558257102966,
-0.2712574303150177,
0.30301573872566223,
0.24856790900230408,
-0.584205687046051,
0.412069171667099,
-0.2182544469833374,
0.09652498364448547,
0.4846195578575134,
0.3455897867679596,
0.6368832588195801,
-0.5135790705680847,
0.8055109977722168,
0.21803432703018188,
0.1443515419960022,
0.20535297691822052,
-0.5597354173660278,
-0.6559018492698669,
-0.1030881479382515,
0.46820932626724243,
0.8390302062034607,
-1.0964728593826294,
-0.021499667316675186,
-0.0953778475522995,
-0.5801560878753662,
-0.38192078471183777,
0.2879219651222229,
0.14763574302196503,
1.2116974592208862,
0.5088871717453003,
-0.13125492632389069,
-0.3697229325771332,
-0.6394020915031433,
-0.12086165696382523,
-0.5919643044471741,
0.12998759746551514,
0.3774946630001068,
0.596333384513855,
0.1929498165845871,
1.0089809894561768,
-0.5373933911323547,
-0.21724392473697662,
-0.3681870996952057,
0.13688541948795319,
0.15743981301784515,
0.22463664412498474,
0.49167531728744507,
-0.5257520079612732,
-0.49808573722839355,
-0.07090877741575241,
-0.7239519953727722,
0.011340751312673092,
-0.20602868497371674,
-0.3298702836036682,
0.12022377550601959,
0.18398842215538025,
-0.8076865077018738,
0.5067694783210754,
0.17834551632404327,
-0.17862974107265472,
0.6390981674194336,
0.11506052315235138,
0.3944562077522278,
-1.0303852558135986,
0.37073978781700134,
-0.6000926494598389,
-0.6107120513916016,
-0.6406328082084656,
0.037844426929950714,
0.21365980803966522,
0.03720156103372574,
-0.9352374076843262,
0.6651406288146973,
-0.03661464527249336,
-0.0571574866771698,
-0.28574255108833313,
0.05031564459204674,
-0.03222537040710449,
0.7144116759300232,
-0.08880582451820374,
0.5895137786865234,
0.6802520751953125,
-0.765644371509552,
0.6012054085731506,
0.6128348112106323,
-0.20018739998340607,
0.6549311876296997,
-0.35081276297569275,
0.4164191484451294,
-0.223647803068161,
0.2120533585548401,
-1.1587918996810913,
-0.2730655372142792,
0.4138921797275543,
-0.6375112533569336,
0.24381011724472046,
-0.6361420750617981,
-0.056612543761730194,
-0.2583622336387634,
-0.04908839240670204,
0.3568309545516968,
0.5794364213943481,
-0.245234876871109,
0.5301216840744019,
-0.005667476914823055,
-0.23384599387645721,
-0.6898789405822754,
-0.9160585999488831,
-0.37602099776268005,
-0.178920716047287,
-0.6662802696228027,
0.011024168692529202,
-0.2429381012916565,
0.10243967175483704,
0.3281998336315155,
-0.33557605743408203,
-0.6526299715042114,
0.3607807755470276,
-0.014458597637712955,
0.3613470792770386,
-0.5410704612731934,
0.05982021242380142,
0.031151171773672104,
0.05302060395479202,
0.01832624338567257,
-0.3763980567455292,
0.0004584768903441727,
-0.20338286459445953,
-0.25498244166374207,
-0.07312627136707306,
0.31219029426574707,
0.2568723261356354,
0.22550295293331146,
0.695874035358429,
0.5200783014297485,
-0.6079269051551819,
-0.19257256388664246,
-0.28894221782684326,
-0.38637885451316833,
-0.3581174612045288,
0.24171887338161469,
-0.5085940957069397,
-1.166643738746643,
0.6234167814254761,
-0.10177408158779144,
0.04254322499036789,
0.2066291719675064,
0.5472201108932495,
-0.6365448236465454,
0.5498989820480347,
0.6988560557365417,
0.13581307232379913,
-0.05328816920518875,
-0.03537723049521446,
0.05330806225538254,
-0.09193143993616104,
-0.2821732759475708,
-0.2745766341686249,
-0.39994755387306213,
-0.2479730248451233,
-0.1777513027191162,
0.5386842489242554,
0.30141040682792664,
-0.2094069868326187,
0.48774752020835876,
0.11944149434566498,
0.554739236831665,
0.4411986172199249,
0.24828629195690155,
0.4679517149925232,
-0.24423478543758392,
0.00865316204726696,
0.10862045735120773,
-0.9768509864807129,
-0.11261150240898132,
0.9859793782234192,
0.12125290930271149,
1.031569480895996,
0.44753944873809814,
0.7371609807014465,
0.10586489737033844,
0.1921030580997467,
-0.9806798696517944,
0.5330451130867004,
-0.13116079568862915,
-0.7812764644622803,
-0.49125441908836365,
-0.5563987493515015,
-0.5550188422203064,
-0.15165074169635773,
-0.5790709257125854,
-0.9411727786064148,
0.05789467692375183,
0.3716147243976593,
-0.8858339190483093,
0.34380245208740234,
-0.6802982687950134,
0.9226217269897461,
-0.1682911068201065,
-0.35544484853744507,
0.30801090598106384,
-0.9612404108047485,
0.7188884615898132,
-0.30079126358032227,
-0.06795748323202133,
-0.08996310085058212,
0.05769704654812813,
0.6494727730751038,
-0.185085266828537,
0.5777004957199097,
-0.2876545786857605,
0.1940523087978363,
0.6484265923500061,
0.5246577262878418,
0.3505963385105133,
-0.06070040911436081,
0.1121734157204628,
-0.24964076280593872,
0.5354954600334167,
-0.44073307514190674,
-1.0936721563339233,
0.5081233978271484,
-0.6231895089149475,
-0.596824049949646,
-0.12203124910593033,
-0.5889341831207275,
-0.7058346271514893,
0.4921987056732178,
0.3788505494594574,
0.08097399771213531,
-0.008499306626617908,
0.1721053123474121,
0.8589826822280884,
0.1644357144832611,
0.21359552443027496,
0.4549751281738281,
-0.20180267095565796,
0.0019963555969297886,
0.6839394569396973,
0.3098432719707489,
0.314023494720459,
0.5562195777893066,
0.23956215381622314,
-0.5472378134727478,
-0.28762540221214294,
-0.5508715510368347,
-0.07864804565906525,
-0.940794825553894,
-0.6437727212905884,
-0.6615421175956726,
-0.4996319115161896,
-0.6417251229286194,
-0.004518878646194935,
-0.45816826820373535,
-0.9235789179801941,
-0.2982676029205322,
0.05652393400669098,
0.513913094997406,
0.5038671493530273,
-0.0005333380540832877,
0.21976755559444427,
-0.9448615312576294,
0.5245043039321899,
0.7764124274253845,
0.35513409972190857,
-0.3094334304332733,
-1.070949673652649,
0.12034240365028381,
0.10023222863674164,
-0.31107097864151,
-1.300812005996704,
0.051961734890937805,
0.2627081274986267,
0.457014262676239,
0.06076819449663162,
0.6520158648490906,
0.7057526707649231,
-0.08951592445373535,
0.36293816566467285,
0.08340346813201904,
-0.6322497129440308,
0.6156386137008667,
-0.14096687734127045,
0.32017895579338074,
1.1829776763916016,
0.5935552716255188,
-0.21128658950328827,
-0.07553480565547943,
-0.5948486328125,
-0.3281274735927582,
0.7997080683708191,
0.11511097848415375,
-0.012596345506608486,
0.3457706570625305,
0.33828210830688477,
0.318828821182251,
0.07002677023410797,
-0.7618012428283691,
-0.09220007807016373,
-0.22592470049858093,
-0.26725468039512634,
0.6129696369171143,
0.06323734670877457,
-0.11582447588443756,
0.01887458562850952,
0.7596601843833923,
-0.590653121471405,
0.3756192922592163,
0.18708083033561707,
-0.44533899426460266,
-0.2550753057003021,
0.656765341758728,
0.38865283131599426,
0.34843745827674866,
-0.36804813146591187,
0.35280394554138184,
0.4996301233768463,
-0.2774488627910614,
0.42637699842453003,
-0.06693563610315323,
-0.27782702445983887,
-0.4719262719154358,
0.23937392234802246,
0.4643886685371399,
0.15055321156978607,
-0.5164180397987366,
0.9072607159614563,
-0.052098676562309265,
-0.5674012303352356,
0.03629160299897194,
0.2498597651720047,
0.04024943336844444,
0.41631829738616943,
0.1307375133037567,
0.29638466238975525,
0.2439013123512268,
-0.433601438999176,
0.30326855182647705,
0.35728129744529724,
-0.2831379175186157,
-0.27117404341697693,
0.46860846877098083,
0.05105827748775482,
-0.05109744518995285,
0.6854035258293152,
-0.15589144825935364,
-0.43541190028190613,
0.45235323905944824,
0.7115799188613892,
0.5685873031616211,
0.1523398905992508,
0.5288980603218079,
0.27296823263168335,
0.3999970257282257,
0.03489799052476883,
0.611326277256012,
-0.3592637777328491,
-0.801537275314331,
-0.24420319497585297,
-0.24104979634284973,
-0.609436571598053,
0.25404325127601624,
-0.7691472768783569,
0.4256696105003357,
-0.5240203738212585,
0.01881561055779457,
-0.20232610404491425,
-0.01977710798382759,
-0.6873308420181274,
0.13665856420993805,
0.042283784598112106,
1.1493643522262573,
-1.0186631679534912,
0.8311419486999512,
0.8677977919578552,
-0.4223475754261017,
-0.8565045595169067,
-0.019355226308107376,
-0.1093352660536766,
-0.9418596625328064,
0.24548012018203735,
-0.06734154373407364,
-0.07909326255321503,
0.255977988243103,
-0.7856745719909668,
-0.9079791903495789,
1.2556138038635254,
0.7529115080833435,
-0.1938549131155014,
-0.03650014102458954,
0.14351344108581543,
0.38552558422088623,
0.015193577855825424,
0.10288994759321213,
0.5126299262046814,
0.3784727454185486,
0.580507218837738,
-0.8353729844093323,
-0.008825642988085747,
0.039475731551647186,
-0.5933024287223816,
-0.10329240560531616,
-0.7227123975753784,
0.22391925752162933,
-0.6152200698852539,
-0.02704809047281742,
0.3277721703052521,
0.7868404388427734,
0.4976252615451813,
0.3409484326839447,
0.5469928979873657,
0.3183923661708832,
0.7191197276115417,
0.07405306398868561,
0.6517905592918396,
-0.009312238544225693,
0.3096819818019867,
1.239999532699585,
-0.07022721320390701,
1.0519880056381226,
0.5294055342674255,
-0.2371167242527008,
0.4147355258464813,
0.37392181158065796,
0.2530289888381958,
0.6553887128829956,
-0.02072211541235447,
-0.19341470301151276,
-0.6911818385124207,
0.010728511959314346,
-0.04556194692850113,
0.8155063986778259,
0.10115131735801697,
0.30081653594970703,
-0.5711015462875366,
0.041368111968040466,
-0.1660582721233368,
-0.08038564771413803,
-0.23364698886871338,
0.82976233959198,
0.04297284409403801,
-0.8666667342185974,
0.4358642101287842,
-0.148977130651474,
0.44987785816192627,
-0.8040556907653809,
-0.17638443410396576,
-0.4251667559146881,
-0.16581468284130096,
-0.3979744613170624,
-1.10281503200531,
0.4335651695728302,
0.11123652011156082,
-0.23302491009235382,
0.03740416467189789,
1.3661714792251587,
-0.5663310885429382,
-0.4178270697593689,
-0.26242372393608093,
0.9355345368385315,
0.2191213071346283,
0.0592629499733448,
-0.7200081944465637,
-0.6157846450805664,
-0.03113233670592308,
-0.168845072388649,
0.47221657633781433,
0.45078444480895996,
-0.1613297313451767,
0.9835249781608582,
0.31475815176963806,
-0.09625206142663956,
0.2723782956600189,
-0.2718319892883301,
0.8285089731216431,
-0.384876549243927,
-0.668670654296875,
-0.5188591480255127,
0.4766030013561249,
0.608948826789856,
-0.24002163112163544,
0.5013276934623718,
0.06104593351483345,
0.4765729606151581,
-0.23381133377552032,
0.7914610505104065,
-0.2464444637298584,
0.4337959289550781,
-0.5645805597305298,
0.8016646504402161,
-0.4375907778739929,
0.09212872385978699,
-0.19191430509090424,
-0.5845099687576294,
-0.29600468277931213,
0.6127659678459167,
-0.030532820150256157,
0.05885724350810051,
0.5527899861335754,
0.691467821598053,
-0.24024979770183563,
-0.051551781594753265,
0.6491150259971619,
0.05742374062538147,
-0.11940798908472061,
1.214795708656311,
0.869967520236969,
-0.5272780656814575,
1.0338213443756104,
-0.5598589777946472,
-0.23072309792041779,
-0.08719111979007721,
-1.0205094814300537,
-0.6420278549194336,
-0.39184480905532837,
-0.5770091414451599,
-0.4292983114719391,
-0.036067113280296326,
0.7620329856872559,
0.8147422671318054,
-1.049509048461914,
0.20924215018749237,
0.04563179239630699,
0.20042051374912262,
-0.09324270486831665,
-0.2516460716724396,
0.2730719745159149,
-0.12918874621391296,
-0.06599796563386917,
0.42554694414138794,
0.2230316400527954,
0.2594582140445709,
-0.025781281292438507,
0.20632512867450714,
-0.2360873967409134,
0.01856224797666073,
0.31483179330825806,
0.6776770949363708,
-0.3819524645805359,
-0.496535062789917,
0.532741129398346,
-0.030748466029763222,
-0.10013102740049362,
0.3813886046409607,
-0.9878581166267395,
0.48450133204460144,
0.6172032952308655,
1.150328278541565,
0.4069262146949768,
0.020089928060770035,
0.15122129023075104,
-1.0966249704360962,
-0.22675208747386932,
0.4029909372329712,
0.013374634087085724,
0.13971862196922302,
-0.5436559915542603,
0.32717928290367126,
0.4252835512161255,
-0.37374642491340637,
-0.5652049779891968,
0.20136909186840057,
-1.3232542276382446,
-0.2415654957294464,
1.1254878044128418,
-0.37288859486579895,
-0.29894912242889404,
-0.26526692509651184,
0.016671735793352127,
0.1309671550989151,
-0.0224861241877079,
0.6238646507263184,
0.9075399041175842,
-0.6665099859237671,
-0.5134448409080505,
-0.2913413643836975,
0.2534691095352173,
0.39852815866470337,
-1.168563723564148,
-0.20056408643722534,
0.31461256742477417,
0.7821822166442871,
-0.15928998589515686,
0.8793238401412964,
0.0031052252743393183,
0.785102128982544,
-0.052346378564834595,
-0.31931832432746887,
-0.2450544238090515,
-0.5514312386512756,
-0.2636634409427643,
0.3745153248310089,
0.3140794336795807,
-0.3242588937282562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14312v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14312v1 | Infusing clinical knowledge into tokenisers for language models | 2024-06-20T13:43:03 | 2024-06-20T13:43:03 | Abul Hasan, Jinge Wu, Quang Ngoc Nguyen, Salomé Andres, Imane Guellil, Huayu Zhang, Arlene Casey, Beatrice Alex, Bruce Guthrie, Honghan Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study introduces a novel knowledge enhanced tokenisation mechanism,
K-Tokeniser, for clinical text processing. Technically, at initialisation
stage, K-Tokeniser populates global representations of tokens based on semantic
types of domain concepts (such as drugs or diseases) from either a domain
ontology like Unified Medical Language System or the training data of the task
related corpus. At training or inference stage, sentence level localised
context will be utilised for choosing the optimal global token representation
to realise the semantic-based tokenisation. To avoid pretraining using the new
tokeniser, an embedding initialisation approach is proposed to generate
representations for new tokens. Using three transformer-based language models,
a comprehensive set of experiments are conducted on four real-world datasets
for evaluating K-Tokeniser in a wide range of clinical text analytics tasks
including clinical concept and relation extraction, automated clinical coding,
clinical phenotype identification, and clinical research article
classification. Overall, our models demonstrate consistent improvements over
their counterparts in all tasks. In particular, substantial improvements are
observed in the automated clinical coding task with 13\% increase on Micro
$F_1$ score. Furthermore, K-Tokeniser also shows significant capacities in
facilitating quicker converge of language models. Specifically, using
K-Tokeniser, the language models would only require 50\% of the training data
to achieve the best performance of the baseline tokeniser using all training
data in the concept extraction task and less than 20\% of the data for the
automated coding task. It is worth mentioning that all these improvements
require no pre-training process, making the approach generalisable. | [
0.18340595066547394,
-0.42119404673576355,
0.73587566614151,
-0.09865374118089676,
-0.4060886800289154,
0.06589585542678833,
-0.13908812403678894,
-0.4549945890903473,
0.3870883882045746,
0.5683581233024597,
-0.0066513740457594395,
-0.6475145816802979,
-0.8308807611465454,
0.04474693909287453,
-0.17243418097496033,
0.9724874496459961,
-0.010949954390525818,
0.67831951379776,
-0.5134695768356323,
-0.12919503450393677,
-0.5847996473312378,
-0.9104684591293335,
-0.5335144400596619,
-0.43527674674987793,
0.2654848098754883,
0.3774905204772949,
0.46781492233276367,
0.7014427185058594,
0.6799923181533813,
0.20930710434913635,
-0.027631253004074097,
0.001615732442587614,
-0.326529860496521,
0.15190821886062622,
0.019411412999033928,
-0.7191336750984192,
-0.5027073621749878,
-0.20132777094841003,
0.2394028604030609,
0.8883050680160522,
-0.03901302069425583,
-0.2685742974281311,
-0.25639083981513977,
0.3336162567138672,
-0.6509742736816406,
0.17918869853019714,
-0.6075754761695862,
0.09663735330104828,
-0.010837224312126637,
-0.23955592513084412,
-0.5415406823158264,
-0.1340859979391098,
0.22280415892601013,
-0.6732565760612488,
0.3237191438674927,
-0.18353566527366638,
0.7236256003379822,
0.1035880371928215,
-0.5680349469184875,
-0.8624265789985657,
-0.5676553249359131,
0.5324389338493347,
-0.8138102889060974,
0.5602399110794067,
0.32918137311935425,
0.35278886556625366,
0.08341032266616821,
-1.2218494415283203,
-0.5919486880302429,
-0.3465249836444855,
-0.5775271058082581,
0.09906341135501862,
-0.031413909047842026,
0.3368460536003113,
-0.033652327954769135,
0.38646385073661804,
-0.18341952562332153,
0.19040927290916443,
-0.33422616124153137,
-0.46310314536094666,
0.2302725464105606,
0.32675567269325256,
0.5117859840393066,
-0.3986191153526306,
-0.22960864007472992,
0.14566440880298615,
-0.6607093811035156,
-0.0520666167140007,
-0.2649843096733093,
0.26576322317123413,
-0.04034574329853058,
0.551969051361084,
-0.10713326930999756,
0.44418948888778687,
0.09508281946182251,
-0.4311179518699646,
0.33769771456718445,
-0.5192475318908691,
-0.21783754229545593,
0.30532658100128174,
0.7559064626693726,
0.28179308772087097,
-0.033143699169158936,
-0.46304401755332947,
-0.061141494661569595,
0.3984512984752655,
0.42555394768714905,
-1.1439470052719116,
-0.28571656346321106,
0.45355913043022156,
-0.5530871748924255,
-0.588038980960846,
-0.12513768672943115,
-0.4989197552204132,
-0.3612382113933563,
-0.1366986781358719,
0.3730047047138214,
-0.6112819910049438,
-0.08255109190940857,
0.43946710228919983,
-0.25325557589530945,
-0.04074568301439285,
0.10352982580661774,
-0.9912432432174683,
0.4147595465183258,
0.6364641785621643,
0.5932645201683044,
-0.23487646877765656,
0.2788628935813904,
-0.5228943824768066,
0.34191498160362244,
-0.19363853335380554,
0.7115550637245178,
-0.645529568195343,
-0.3633820116519928,
0.21057072281837463,
0.1438012272119522,
-0.0536821074783802,
-0.3522702157497406,
0.6460778117179871,
-0.5492676496505737,
0.2954445481300354,
0.04779940843582153,
-1.0088520050048828,
0.17931562662124634,
0.08611822128295898,
-0.5751455426216125,
0.7834779620170593,
0.16236573457717896,
-0.5352283120155334,
0.9252501130104065,
-0.8961237072944641,
-0.47340285778045654,
0.3485203981399536,
-0.3312121629714966,
-0.3640535771846771,
0.17025816440582275,
0.4980997145175934,
0.5613073706626892,
-0.11273025721311569,
0.4510839283466339,
-0.014283441938459873,
-0.20433849096298218,
0.19916850328445435,
-0.027919400483369827,
0.3865858316421509,
0.06098150834441185,
-0.14105206727981567,
0.03836365416646004,
-0.83924400806427,
-0.15912804007530212,
-0.04411355033516884,
-0.18051700294017792,
-0.5040212869644165,
-0.4279721677303314,
0.2161675989627838,
0.247306689620018,
0.07365717738866806,
-0.97266685962677,
0.26791080832481384,
-0.779453456401825,
0.5914793610572815,
0.2941688299179077,
0.26141756772994995,
0.5781744122505188,
-0.1884072870016098,
0.7139542698860168,
0.3748171031475067,
0.16003242135047913,
-0.5035991072654724,
-0.4429491460323334,
-0.6624298095703125,
-0.5798894762992859,
0.677876353263855,
0.33342188596725464,
-0.7641568183898926,
0.2217654585838318,
-0.5704145431518555,
-0.47590041160583496,
-0.9713312983512878,
-0.21345268189907074,
0.5198534727096558,
0.5991358757019043,
0.34729185700416565,
-0.27192506194114685,
-0.523840069770813,
-0.7688902020454407,
-0.18010583519935608,
-0.016347834840416908,
-0.029056044295430183,
0.27876022458076477,
0.5242986083030701,
-0.38391175866127014,
1.0303444862365723,
-0.6124687790870667,
-0.5305416584014893,
-0.37557655572891235,
-0.08058072626590729,
0.18858717381954193,
0.5807863473892212,
0.2777678966522217,
-0.7238660454750061,
-0.6183491349220276,
0.3558351695537567,
-0.7394440174102783,
-0.12019915878772736,
-0.19015134871006012,
0.06376542896032333,
0.14292074739933014,
0.7404056787490845,
-0.4767642021179199,
0.7476081848144531,
0.18955500423908234,
-0.5281813740730286,
0.28283652663230896,
-0.42240750789642334,
0.1305457502603531,
-1.1750075817108154,
0.29469215869903564,
-0.5385815501213074,
-0.4153338372707367,
-1.1017920970916748,
-0.007322363089770079,
0.26102715730667114,
-0.12344098091125488,
-0.5079747438430786,
0.7389100193977356,
-0.22131595015525818,
0.5183476805686951,
-0.20647475123405457,
0.17541401088237762,
0.22879409790039062,
0.3397006392478943,
0.029174495488405228,
0.5150701999664307,
0.4710808992385864,
-0.48772889375686646,
-0.11484630405902863,
0.6323861479759216,
-0.20690450072288513,
0.35487499833106995,
-0.6887203454971313,
0.21635884046554565,
-0.19401895999908447,
0.06530362367630005,
-1.1038728952407837,
-0.29373037815093994,
0.21171987056732178,
-0.7042517066001892,
0.2783193290233612,
-0.22744010388851166,
-0.5792949199676514,
-0.2728801965713501,
0.05883675068616867,
0.44170674681663513,
0.4530031979084015,
-0.3911142647266388,
0.6494607925415039,
0.49645206332206726,
-0.04026142880320549,
-0.24709337949752808,
-0.7827656269073486,
0.1790512353181839,
-0.1052299439907074,
-0.374969482421875,
0.7152853608131409,
0.192075714468956,
0.23532110452651978,
0.14364874362945557,
0.056350916624069214,
-0.1445402204990387,
-0.12550394237041473,
0.22965268790721893,
0.3265526294708252,
-0.16455300152301788,
0.5412464737892151,
0.3311247229576111,
-0.3820772171020508,
-0.018344415351748466,
-0.3034359812736511,
0.6410306692123413,
0.41844114661216736,
-0.5299039483070374,
-0.7234640717506409,
0.3676237463951111,
0.6738053560256958,
-0.11464253813028336,
1.0211414098739624,
0.5662297606468201,
-0.4979654550552368,
0.21740445494651794,
-0.6885688900947571,
-0.21893438696861267,
-0.4103800654411316,
0.5402051210403442,
-0.37564656138420105,
-1.183038592338562,
0.5082647204399109,
-0.05289825424551964,
-0.1727396845817566,
0.35925695300102234,
0.8739575743675232,
0.19347500801086426,
1.2010164260864258,
0.6129097938537598,
-0.025531919673085213,
0.22429275512695312,
-0.06223851814866066,
0.4423314034938812,
-0.6661340594291687,
-0.32409608364105225,
-0.29453277587890625,
0.1703927218914032,
-0.3821777105331421,
-0.4493388831615448,
0.6551605463027954,
0.18896085023880005,
0.14681097865104675,
0.1350070983171463,
-0.5886877775192261,
0.24633678793907166,
0.182134211063385,
0.25362274050712585,
0.32438787817955017,
-0.014824441634118557,
-0.595920741558075,
-0.20374712347984314,
-0.94060218334198,
-0.48792311549186707,
1.5715522766113281,
0.31068915128707886,
0.2975260615348816,
-0.2111462950706482,
0.6678341627120972,
0.2531343996524811,
0.7184961438179016,
-0.8118422031402588,
0.12820200622081757,
-0.11010760813951492,
-0.3623462915420532,
-0.03688252717256546,
-0.07682663947343826,
-1.0642006397247314,
0.15634587407112122,
-0.18256740272045135,
-0.5790910124778748,
0.14988194406032562,
0.01711137779057026,
-0.5755892395973206,
0.18223561346530914,
-0.7046891450881958,
0.8693873882293701,
0.19239893555641174,
0.042201004922389984,
-0.14914752542972565,
-0.4984070956707001,
0.06784575432538986,
-0.21534927189350128,
0.17243869602680206,
0.34232792258262634,
-0.19883432984352112,
0.706163763999939,
-0.7923396825790405,
0.9400020241737366,
-0.42382359504699707,
-0.10432928055524826,
0.07965481281280518,
-0.15722666680812836,
0.34265637397766113,
0.07192966341972351,
0.002009645337238908,
-0.04923581704497337,
0.3861241936683655,
-0.34085264801979065,
-0.8846179842948914,
0.24488018453121185,
-0.4988425374031067,
-0.3749013841152191,
-0.13362956047058105,
-0.3737782835960388,
-0.4247574210166931,
0.30175694823265076,
0.2015085369348526,
0.8313813805580139,
-0.22593651711940765,
0.14460565149784088,
0.1993897706270218,
-0.30551305413246155,
-0.0010102498345077038,
0.6640246510505676,
-0.19189874827861786,
-0.8424546122550964,
0.6824765205383301,
-0.17495521903038025,
0.6073791980743408,
0.5521200299263,
0.26142552495002747,
-0.3229941129684448,
-0.6403226256370544,
-0.27171969413757324,
0.32573339343070984,
-1.0106168985366821,
-0.3375449776649475,
-1.1328340768814087,
-0.2684054374694824,
-0.7675266265869141,
-0.2640886604785919,
-0.07322066277265549,
-0.5571248531341553,
-0.08282656967639923,
-0.06693387776613235,
0.4587610363960266,
0.7397102117538452,
0.11900246143341064,
0.6837396621704102,
-0.9487939476966858,
0.14430414140224457,
-0.11640302836894989,
0.3207923471927643,
0.08790288865566254,
-0.4191378653049469,
-0.5903080701828003,
-0.10400087386369705,
-0.046090442687273026,
-0.5324177145957947,
0.3984059691429138,
0.0720098465681076,
0.49988678097724915,
0.5570088624954224,
-0.25573456287384033,
0.7907278537750244,
-0.6629148125648499,
0.7638174295425415,
0.27582597732543945,
-0.884096086025238,
0.4863435626029968,
-0.11116066575050354,
0.2513400912284851,
0.7910246253013611,
0.40353813767433167,
-0.8904724717140198,
-0.5547080039978027,
-0.6321913599967957,
-0.5974267721176147,
0.5698633193969727,
0.2640371322631836,
0.10095750540494919,
-0.36153310537338257,
0.5615926384925842,
0.375733345746994,
0.2601250112056732,
-0.36002567410469055,
-0.2617403566837311,
0.06527093797922134,
-0.4203747510910034,
0.000498482258990407,
-0.38443782925605774,
0.09095846116542816,
-0.49383023381233215,
0.46238553524017334,
-0.17064721882343292,
0.6068117618560791,
0.4647628664970398,
-0.317107617855072,
0.16366185247898102,
0.0664607584476471,
0.36866146326065063,
0.42143991589546204,
0.007100369781255722,
-0.16072551906108856,
0.0030727579724043608,
-0.8868617415428162,
0.08194088935852051,
-0.06573468446731567,
-0.08593376725912094,
0.1867237240076065,
0.6260035634040833,
0.8316975235939026,
0.38876092433929443,
-0.7579214572906494,
0.7265475392341614,
-0.18588101863861084,
-0.20005154609680176,
-0.022225597873330116,
-0.07166159152984619,
0.006413603201508522,
-0.1622597873210907,
-0.1362270563840866,
0.079032763838768,
0.19225086271762848,
-0.1795816868543625,
0.5175133943557739,
0.2900359332561493,
-0.6417883038520813,
-0.3883195221424103,
0.8135958909988403,
-0.005109403748065233,
-0.31296610832214355,
0.4197838306427002,
-0.13908103108406067,
-0.6270241737365723,
0.3644102215766907,
0.8727372288703918,
0.6836878657341003,
-0.11350766569375992,
0.18849994242191315,
0.30682289600372314,
-0.17779313027858734,
0.25344109535217285,
0.1984216570854187,
-0.09983551502227783,
-0.8740730881690979,
-0.4513785243034363,
-0.5894841551780701,
-0.27310797572135925,
-0.071641705930233,
-0.7357178926467896,
0.42451778054237366,
-0.0667349249124527,
-0.19694766402244568,
0.1489667445421219,
-0.18166996538639069,
-0.8984065651893616,
0.2356223165988922,
-0.06504001468420029,
0.8620757460594177,
-0.6481617093086243,
0.9834758639335632,
0.6463285088539124,
-0.4645167589187622,
-0.6125126481056213,
-0.23749996721744537,
-0.36021164059638977,
-0.9800883531570435,
0.6895796060562134,
0.17999829351902008,
0.44441652297973633,
-0.002270706929266453,
-0.11862403154373169,
-0.7185525894165039,
1.0021404027938843,
0.07838523387908936,
-0.26117098331451416,
-0.2214462161064148,
0.8864832520484924,
0.7891272306442261,
-0.7627103924751282,
0.3540897071361542,
0.7855665683746338,
0.11620613187551498,
0.17443117499351501,
-0.9574024081230164,
0.26058173179626465,
-0.40403005480766296,
-0.10697624832391739,
0.3435710072517395,
-0.058412812650203705,
0.381696492433548,
0.008174987509846687,
-0.19244228303432465,
0.26065126061439514,
0.2982257008552551,
0.02607451193034649,
0.030147310346364975,
0.45474839210510254,
0.5776902437210083,
0.8857982754707336,
0.22703157365322113,
1.0821982622146606,
-0.717837929725647,
0.1388503462076187,
0.7698749899864197,
-0.23004545271396637,
0.5395921468734741,
0.6186915636062622,
-0.13178211450576782,
0.5609601140022278,
0.03249097988009453,
0.14151987433433533,
0.6502082943916321,
0.09106672555208206,
-0.3766433596611023,
-0.1265777051448822,
-0.3434953987598419,
-0.2000071406364441,
0.5680133700370789,
0.4370402991771698,
-0.6360270977020264,
-0.00904875434935093,
0.5062012672424316,
0.22904738783836365,
-0.08417736738920212,
-0.17475736141204834,
1.0520814657211304,
0.0490691252052784,
-0.5991218090057373,
0.577405571937561,
0.03634719178080559,
0.4645906686782837,
-0.7100419998168945,
0.0029480967205017805,
-0.06867833435535431,
0.3230482339859009,
-0.022200921550393105,
-0.21614399552345276,
0.3241991698741913,
-0.09567904472351074,
-0.048729874193668365,
-0.20124495029449463,
0.9073528051376343,
-0.49084383249282837,
-0.7063883543014526,
-0.006467543542385101,
0.4990423023700714,
-0.00025478401221334934,
0.07436255365610123,
-0.26731884479522705,
-0.1995052695274353,
-0.16826067864894867,
0.23407751321792603,
0.3451462388038635,
0.7145068049430847,
-0.0541442409157753,
0.455888956785202,
0.824558675289154,
0.4690859615802765,
-0.18268117308616638,
0.34241247177124023,
1.1181410551071167,
-0.5410096645355225,
-0.8009483814239502,
-0.8377720713615417,
0.557960033416748,
-0.19293735921382904,
-0.29297128319740295,
0.5707335472106934,
0.5577290058135986,
0.42329132556915283,
-0.14222979545593262,
0.5862581133842468,
0.08998576551675797,
0.47750622034072876,
-0.44181308150291443,
1.0085177421569824,
-0.3460187017917633,
-0.004993482027202845,
-0.36703789234161377,
0.015650296583771706,
-0.7004414796829224,
0.08657104521989822,
-0.3541345000267029,
-0.33847931027412415,
0.8170977234840393,
0.8529470562934875,
0.1147947683930397,
0.19178146123886108,
0.41805094480514526,
0.09927133470773697,
0.7251302599906921,
0.33289477229118347,
0.4717584550380707,
-0.62534499168396,
0.21775630116462708,
-0.27943482995033264,
-0.23587600886821747,
0.023340316489338875,
-0.7239404320716858,
-1.1315937042236328,
-0.4697290360927582,
-0.14339928328990936,
-0.39378029108047485,
-0.045010969042778015,
0.9507569074630737,
0.8171412944793701,
-1.045035719871521,
0.1510898321866989,
-0.1626233458518982,
-0.2429192215204239,
-0.09740917384624481,
-0.22112564742565155,
0.6511454582214355,
-0.7577626705169678,
-0.37882566452026367,
0.15570655465126038,
0.3047834634780884,
-0.16852538287639618,
-0.10538537055253983,
0.012107227928936481,
0.11786433309316635,
-0.08250901103019714,
0.7277265787124634,
-0.4106733798980713,
-0.5292087197303772,
-0.05950254574418068,
0.07499630004167557,
-0.008329332806169987,
0.4013218581676483,
1.2351065874099731,
-1.1602811813354492,
0.7004373073577881,
0.10680186748504639,
0.8565213680267334,
0.40989917516708374,
-0.2479924112558365,
0.7079119682312012,
-0.47303709387779236,
0.3371344208717346,
0.43707209825515747,
0.2539534866809845,
0.22745423018932343,
-0.6119500994682312,
0.27217182517051697,
0.3545694649219513,
-0.351554274559021,
-0.9531963467597961,
-0.12695933878421783,
-0.5365733504295349,
-0.029645252972841263,
0.8429613709449768,
-0.08032191544771194,
-0.12032575160264969,
-0.3706941604614258,
-0.27695199847221375,
0.3711497485637665,
-0.2564239501953125,
0.6755034923553467,
0.5531614422798157,
-0.10059653222560883,
0.3009837865829468,
-0.4459419846534729,
0.7987939119338989,
0.37088602781295776,
-0.7393455505371094,
-0.12540806829929352,
-0.07547032833099365,
0.2794138789176941,
0.17297258973121643,
1.0202231407165527,
-0.5969336032867432,
0.21576794981956482,
-0.07102101296186447,
0.08274846524000168,
-0.015061001293361187,
-0.04552263021469116,
-0.3478643298149109,
0.22564448416233063,
-0.26274117827415466,
-0.0972820594906807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14307v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14307v2 | QuST-LLM: Integrating Large Language Models for Comprehensive Spatial Transcriptomics Analysis | 2024-06-20T13:37:10 | 2024-07-01T19:38:03 | Chao Hui Huang | q-bio.GN | q-bio.GN, cs.CL, cs.CV | In this paper, we introduce QuST-LLM, an innovative extension of QuPath that
utilizes the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) to analyze and
interpret spatial transcriptomics (ST) data. In addition to simplifying the
intricate and high-dimensional nature of ST data by offering a comprehensive
workflow that includes data loading, region selection, gene expression
analysis, and functional annotation, QuST-LLM employs LLMs to transform complex
ST data into understandable and detailed biological narratives based on gene
ontology annotations, thereby significantly improving the interpretability of
ST data. Consequently, users can interact with their own ST data using natural
language. Hence, QuST-LLM provides researchers with a potent functionality to
unravel the spatial and functional complexities of tissues, fostering novel
insights and advancements in biomedical research. QuST-LLM is a part of QuST
project. The source code is hosted on GitHub and documentation is available at
(https://github.com/huangch/qust). | [
-0.047989893704652786,
-1.017045497894287,
1.1112223863601685,
0.03213545307517052,
-0.3230396807193756,
0.3574812114238739,
-0.1278107911348343,
-0.4507499039173126,
0.26948946714401245,
0.7158470153808594,
-0.4465072453022003,
-1.0643563270568848,
-0.47155800461769104,
-0.031112434342503548,
-0.6253515481948853,
0.6818488240242004,
0.06696807593107224,
0.5807420611381531,
-0.20607426762580872,
-0.3960164487361908,
-0.08853781223297119,
-0.6130261421203613,
-0.3872046172618866,
0.1365673691034317,
0.6589670181274414,
0.3081043064594269,
0.7852775454521179,
0.7109146118164062,
0.6606652736663818,
0.3095442056655884,
-0.16592565178871155,
0.06271819025278091,
-0.5706239342689514,
0.20189255475997925,
-0.1019785925745964,
-0.2825096845626831,
-0.5608586072921753,
-0.3409827649593353,
0.8808053135871887,
0.7627090215682983,
-0.019888855516910553,
0.09613969177007675,
-0.1729857325553894,
0.5222270488739014,
0.05872316285967827,
-0.11694256961345673,
-0.1022520586848259,
0.1949073076248169,
-0.2619324028491974,
-0.33729031682014465,
0.04428889974951744,
-0.856322169303894,
0.5468522310256958,
-0.48122480511665344,
-0.07087516039609909,
0.1102178767323494,
0.6000868082046509,
0.2572128474712372,
-0.7073540091514587,
0.09068563580513,
-0.7524535059928894,
0.5248561501502991,
-0.8921504616737366,
0.4652214050292969,
-0.1690257489681244,
0.4775660037994385,
-0.3106476366519928,
-0.8874459266662598,
-0.3076244592666626,
-0.2667975127696991,
-0.17122893035411835,
0.09921639412641525,
-0.16363434493541718,
0.2416287213563919,
0.28416237235069275,
0.43679139018058777,
-0.8122390508651733,
0.0022272963542491198,
-0.5316709280014038,
-0.013665961101651192,
0.6416766047477722,
0.4287338852882385,
0.7252438068389893,
-0.17211660742759705,
-0.654931366443634,
0.2094510942697525,
-0.7872805595397949,
-0.04597696289420128,
-0.07250197976827621,
0.16105863451957703,
-0.34143006801605225,
0.7057517170906067,
-0.06357963383197784,
0.30982542037963867,
-0.4643592834472656,
0.25176236033439636,
0.14063023030757904,
-0.44949957728385925,
-0.1286993771791458,
0.04635602608323097,
1.021103858947754,
0.06929077208042145,
-0.35488954186439514,
-0.07000728696584702,
0.03516758605837822,
-0.506234884262085,
0.08630094677209854,
-0.5997393727302551,
-0.16588710248470306,
0.5555979013442993,
-0.48547640442848206,
-0.11989997327327728,
0.0746183916926384,
-1.0986212491989136,
-0.46032586693763733,
-0.34873947501182556,
0.35523515939712524,
-0.6920527815818787,
-0.12375594675540924,
0.35674357414245605,
-0.16636137664318085,
0.45648443698883057,
0.46306321024894714,
-0.19054961204528809,
0.16157977283000946,
0.5348047614097595,
1.1099363565444946,
-0.44050443172454834,
-0.16437336802482605,
-0.3810700476169586,
0.27707022428512573,
-0.12542971968650818,
0.9402288198471069,
-0.5243583917617798,
-0.6454970240592957,
-0.16935910284519196,
0.035404812544584274,
0.07880288362503052,
-0.2589130401611328,
0.7428677082061768,
-0.43190333247184753,
0.04523804411292076,
-0.46694138646125793,
-0.5316172242164612,
-0.48752063512802124,
0.1459033489227295,
-0.6474581956863403,
1.2107034921646118,
0.4919208884239197,
-0.685454785823822,
0.008869634009897709,
-0.9788737297058105,
-0.26818835735321045,
0.4533892571926117,
-0.23976287245750427,
-0.1670372486114502,
0.27318888902664185,
0.07594932615756989,
0.30278441309928894,
-0.3126278221607208,
0.5846750140190125,
-0.3308064937591553,
-0.3616345226764679,
0.2634229362010956,
0.1665038764476776,
0.7441659569740295,
0.09372347593307495,
-0.19537527859210968,
0.7606642842292786,
-0.622868001461029,
-0.13005298376083374,
0.14184798300266266,
-0.3479723334312439,
-0.15240539610385895,
-0.009894609451293945,
-0.016180317848920822,
0.18126684427261353,
0.44769105315208435,
-0.7331117987632751,
0.5745633840560913,
-0.32314348220825195,
0.5580962896347046,
0.43411585688591003,
0.02347766049206257,
0.6103460192680359,
-0.27662935853004456,
0.648820698261261,
0.0632435604929924,
0.34529682993888855,
0.106941819190979,
-0.25298255681991577,
-0.35917794704437256,
-0.5524460673332214,
0.1901099979877472,
0.51392662525177,
-0.6832506656646729,
0.3775119185447693,
-0.7220199704170227,
-0.6940195560455322,
-0.5442619323730469,
-0.3402777910232544,
-0.0682712122797966,
0.4255358576774597,
0.530124843120575,
-0.024478593841195107,
-0.8422139883041382,
-0.9280451536178589,
0.21381303668022156,
-0.09107016772031784,
-0.1632257103919983,
0.3886927366256714,
0.4316890835762024,
-0.5381243824958801,
0.8429880142211914,
-0.7376431822776794,
-0.16571356356143951,
-0.4596524238586426,
-0.18202699720859528,
0.16425906121730804,
0.43550923466682434,
0.36582478880882263,
-0.39581218361854553,
-0.12864236533641815,
0.2036760449409485,
-0.7573822736740112,
-0.39296871423721313,
-0.014906808733940125,
-0.6760827302932739,
-0.2806822955608368,
0.5435793399810791,
-0.7224454283714294,
0.4633083939552307,
0.5997593998908997,
-0.6385307312011719,
0.8471131920814514,
-0.029262611642479897,
0.304324746131897,
-0.8254929184913635,
0.053468767553567886,
-0.083100825548172,
-0.30023449659347534,
-0.8392042517662048,
0.24742859601974487,
-0.10588455200195312,
0.05015470087528229,
-0.6637541055679321,
0.4861549437046051,
-0.11925079673528671,
-0.4629397690296173,
0.009086253121495247,
-0.030354555696249008,
0.3213629126548767,
0.3554379343986511,
0.1288526952266693,
0.6834741234779358,
0.4360325336456299,
-0.14559540152549744,
0.2402345985174179,
0.6693527698516846,
-0.25855785608291626,
-0.0942082330584526,
-0.8488664627075195,
-0.05065149441361427,
0.015659429132938385,
0.3537415862083435,
-0.9931271076202393,
-0.07019390165805817,
0.3137867748737335,
-0.3716559410095215,
0.056174859404563904,
-0.09879738092422485,
-0.8511812686920166,
-0.18941403925418854,
-0.3471126854419708,
0.4612962305545807,
0.41700029373168945,
-0.44346797466278076,
0.8884913325309753,
0.4827191233634949,
-0.1521245539188385,
0.44322890043258667,
-0.6335224509239197,
0.08370178192853928,
-0.463331937789917,
-0.7513105869293213,
0.10260651260614395,
-0.013403738848865032,
-0.12564004957675934,
-0.15324412286281586,
0.1400536745786667,
-0.282637357711792,
0.07100245356559753,
0.1951170414686203,
0.5368098616600037,
-0.47357800602912903,
0.06984908878803253,
0.1668572574853897,
0.17414775490760803,
0.19496001303195953,
-0.35632896423339844,
0.3558880388736725,
-0.0391014888882637,
-0.3639426529407501,
-0.34122228622436523,
0.6767745018005371,
0.7551455497741699,
-0.25812581181526184,
0.4435079097747803,
0.6539416313171387,
-0.2237202376127243,
0.1554543375968933,
-0.17881324887275696,
-0.019814061000943184,
-0.4242977499961853,
0.5864485502243042,
-0.11518651247024536,
-1.419001817703247,
0.5435718894004822,
-0.4416901469230652,
0.04379132017493248,
0.40364259481430054,
0.4143010377883911,
-0.3395021855831146,
0.9085787534713745,
0.48657122254371643,
0.29303714632987976,
0.1377355307340622,
-0.10110381245613098,
0.393633097410202,
-1.072482943534851,
-0.18612249195575714,
-0.5717666149139404,
-0.38336649537086487,
-0.3431837260723114,
-0.8933055400848389,
0.6232867240905762,
-0.0288842786103487,
-0.5593277812004089,
0.055631835013628006,
-0.5415151715278625,
0.22540251910686493,
0.3742614984512329,
0.11957207322120667,
0.14984065294265747,
-0.2051437497138977,
-0.07293622940778732,
-0.13278257846832275,
-0.714963972568512,
-0.658846914768219,
0.7016823887825012,
0.7783456444740295,
0.521856963634491,
0.4555369019508362,
0.47112223505973816,
0.09810870885848999,
0.015545587986707687,
-0.9934640526771545,
0.6700363159179688,
-0.43625298142433167,
-0.2161552757024765,
-0.4246858060359955,
-0.32698214054107666,
-0.8547408580780029,
0.28471484780311584,
-0.27170631289482117,
-0.6876469254493713,
0.2768091559410095,
-0.13033631443977356,
-0.7481657266616821,
0.5685350298881531,
-0.4476251006126404,
0.775327205657959,
-0.6608414053916931,
-0.23025132715702057,
0.044464632868766785,
-0.6491576433181763,
0.5814254879951477,
-0.2223673313856125,
0.26831135153770447,
-0.24689003825187683,
-0.25155752897262573,
0.6858901381492615,
-0.16861873865127563,
0.8608407974243164,
-0.1220826730132103,
-0.1796746701002121,
0.09008187055587769,
0.4780125021934509,
0.2095697671175003,
0.0490693561732769,
-0.021776415407657623,
0.7593229413032532,
0.4780895709991455,
-0.44892778992652893,
-0.486040860414505,
0.6509556174278259,
-0.666652500629425,
-0.45826998353004456,
-0.17440447211265564,
-0.6927352547645569,
-0.26458513736724854,
0.07886995375156403,
-0.006218421272933483,
0.413445383310318,
-0.13836286962032318,
0.07449417561292648,
0.6442841291427612,
-0.7497991919517517,
-0.10831359773874283,
0.36323457956314087,
-0.6179741621017456,
-0.44027915596961975,
0.5705703496932983,
-0.19451498985290527,
-0.023873256519436836,
0.44893786311149597,
0.5802391171455383,
-0.5056931376457214,
-0.9810628294944763,
-0.08514037728309631,
0.3085881769657135,
-0.4624581038951874,
-0.23521558940410614,
-0.7936508059501648,
-0.28676512837409973,
-0.1926662176847458,
-0.162033811211586,
-0.13008931279182434,
-0.3588535785675049,
-0.26928696036338806,
-0.3302018642425537,
0.5532574653625488,
0.9130958914756775,
0.13098232448101044,
0.5563514828681946,
-1.6746271848678589,
0.13163809478282928,
-0.22662124037742615,
0.09865713864564896,
-0.2532612979412079,
-0.566494882106781,
-0.49949800968170166,
-0.00024007992760743946,
-0.19375114142894745,
-0.9473554491996765,
0.6805029511451721,
0.1892412304878235,
0.3976779282093048,
0.10231294482946396,
-0.3283897638320923,
0.7487478256225586,
-0.5320666432380676,
1.0121105909347534,
0.10704666376113892,
-0.8106191754341125,
0.45404040813446045,
-0.7182610034942627,
0.6101664304733276,
0.29213011264801025,
0.1964930295944214,
-0.4576537013053894,
-0.4541930556297302,
-0.25645118951797485,
-1.1028869152069092,
0.2678873836994171,
-0.11202875524759293,
-0.21383890509605408,
-0.03080994263291359,
0.2568483352661133,
0.4015864431858063,
-0.1013273149728775,
-0.411308616399765,
0.13784626126289368,
0.023755483329296112,
-0.4310203492641449,
0.10355552285909653,
-0.5718197822570801,
-0.17987403273582458,
-0.5342972278594971,
0.2968273460865021,
-0.17146036028862,
0.2429267317056656,
0.5715070962905884,
-0.13397465646266937,
0.007855571806430817,
0.3002200424671173,
0.5717992782592773,
0.31731340289115906,
-0.1315755546092987,
0.11304482072591782,
0.32823777198791504,
-0.47033944725990295,
-0.10381994396448135,
-0.17216365039348602,
-0.02860301546752453,
-0.09958134591579437,
0.7529592514038086,
0.5230507254600525,
0.5924413204193115,
-0.8966805934906006,
0.3954242765903473,
-0.18373297154903412,
-0.5921732187271118,
-0.40222761034965515,
-0.18318861722946167,
0.32080984115600586,
0.7390719652175903,
0.33007895946502686,
-0.20199812948703766,
0.6064606308937073,
0.019909219816327095,
0.29015323519706726,
0.20063410699367523,
-0.5099226236343384,
-0.5679372549057007,
0.5893352031707764,
0.16250866651535034,
0.3456331789493561,
0.5142459869384766,
0.06593760848045349,
-0.7636855840682983,
0.46938177943229675,
0.1955878585577011,
0.9520030617713928,
-0.01790439523756504,
0.07618384808301926,
0.5919838547706604,
0.04989642649888992,
0.20854069292545319,
0.5446388125419617,
0.40674394369125366,
-0.4966994524002075,
-0.7523951530456543,
-0.9193072319030762,
-0.0989888608455658,
-0.02643684297800064,
-0.4368864595890045,
0.10412850975990295,
-0.47092336416244507,
-0.12980248034000397,
-0.2671465277671814,
-0.01868283748626709,
-0.4041101634502411,
-0.21891458332538605,
0.09664879739284515,
1.1542763710021973,
-0.6831145882606506,
1.1474320888519287,
0.885765790939331,
-0.06410690397024155,
-0.6802552938461304,
-0.1785164177417755,
0.23197898268699646,
-0.5162574052810669,
0.9603782892227173,
-0.17576739192008972,
0.022338539361953735,
0.09313584119081497,
-0.630840003490448,
-1.067736268043518,
1.2540807723999023,
0.20230592787265778,
-0.9017015099525452,
-0.11993198096752167,
0.38630279898643494,
0.7973906993865967,
-0.36694493889808655,
0.0016584472032263875,
0.7671256065368652,
0.6817227005958557,
0.18098503351211548,
-0.5539288520812988,
0.236331507563591,
0.11706676334142685,
0.03581374138593674,
0.44146838784217834,
-0.3745298981666565,
0.6051992177963257,
-0.23103849589824677,
-0.3482370972633362,
0.29429078102111816,
0.5892304182052612,
0.23220181465148926,
0.11072670668363571,
0.24809034168720245,
0.5155951380729675,
0.5615736842155457,
-0.3666416108608246,
0.8213990926742554,
-0.20970039069652557,
0.14384400844573975,
1.086344599723816,
-0.3925682306289673,
0.8969566822052002,
0.5946134328842163,
-0.38843590021133423,
0.3606563210487366,
0.6831616163253784,
-0.07472509890794754,
0.06198202818632126,
0.44210919737815857,
-0.22994133830070496,
-0.18023033440113068,
-0.12136708945035934,
-0.07941576838493347,
0.551274836063385,
0.49482131004333496,
0.06590848416090012,
-0.2356443703174591,
-0.2244688719511032,
-0.2663937509059906,
-0.02928079105913639,
-0.23927824199199677,
0.7402739524841309,
0.16567310690879822,
0.13372191786766052,
-0.019889630377292633,
-0.45211946964263916,
0.48921993374824524,
-0.6379395723342896,
-0.30165907740592957,
-0.2976541817188263,
-0.4344348907470703,
-0.42270293831825256,
-1.050295114517212,
0.6130645871162415,
-0.3091944456100464,
0.05185477063059807,
0.11858562380075455,
0.5201240181922913,
-0.5327900648117065,
-0.30629122257232666,
0.6058523654937744,
0.8338620066642761,
0.1379702389240265,
0.23875197768211365,
-0.6450574994087219,
0.24700309336185455,
0.16367991268634796,
-0.10162872821092606,
0.2727728486061096,
0.7201287150382996,
-0.17598669230937958,
0.6020628213882446,
0.89718097448349,
0.289673775434494,
-0.13863326609134674,
0.04725297912955284,
0.9110841155052185,
-1.168239712715149,
-0.18568377196788788,
-0.8981671333312988,
0.7394469976425171,
0.03074382245540619,
0.045684557408094406,
0.6262962818145752,
0.6888265609741211,
0.3886018395423889,
-0.05738594010472298,
0.819831907749176,
0.16218224167823792,
0.7234572768211365,
-0.5046565532684326,
0.7527350187301636,
-0.5451834797859192,
0.5202330946922302,
0.1449710726737976,
-0.6581536531448364,
-0.5468745827674866,
0.19772474467754364,
-0.3663683533668518,
-0.29859259724617004,
0.981284499168396,
0.5258786082267761,
0.10228484123945236,
0.004374198615550995,
0.47942420840263367,
0.4547320306301117,
0.5598724484443665,
0.546312153339386,
1.1442805528640747,
-0.02625502645969391,
0.33408382534980774,
0.062450990080833435,
-0.17237314581871033,
-0.16617998480796814,
-0.6914799213409424,
-0.5796195864677429,
-0.4855554401874542,
-0.3305339813232422,
-0.21244098246097565,
-0.20826569199562073,
0.8212797045707703,
0.5215200185775757,
-0.7600648999214172,
-0.2163662612438202,
0.3055994212627411,
-0.05381825193762779,
0.20237325131893158,
-0.25278347730636597,
0.6140463352203369,
0.0034148520790040493,
-0.502869725227356,
0.47725868225097656,
0.6806545853614807,
0.22305835783481598,
-0.10930339992046356,
-0.025013592094182968,
-0.32164138555526733,
-0.06341416388750076,
0.8600420355796814,
0.21745161712169647,
-0.606266438961029,
-0.29164016246795654,
0.01742052659392357,
-0.31883785128593445,
0.3236938714981079,
0.7580977082252502,
-0.44533801078796387,
0.10641482472419739,
0.6806791424751282,
0.7129674553871155,
-0.021617379039525986,
0.08254200220108032,
0.8360192179679871,
-0.37173211574554443,
-0.3023017644882202,
0.4185229539871216,
0.5558549165725708,
0.29721349477767944,
-0.659852147102356,
0.5772445797920227,
-0.1128096655011177,
-0.7328421473503113,
-0.6332033276557922,
0.19732479751110077,
-1.2375212907791138,
-0.39948487281799316,
1.4159237146377563,
-0.07859307527542114,
-0.4718449115753174,
-0.22278901934623718,
-0.682938277721405,
0.26491403579711914,
-0.30879923701286316,
0.41740190982818604,
0.32422080636024475,
-0.12933140993118286,
-0.3304292857646942,
-0.9188921451568604,
0.450730562210083,
0.06876442581415176,
-1.0216974020004272,
-0.009884627535939217,
0.7317392230033875,
0.16842155158519745,
-0.3388812243938446,
0.5379213094711304,
-0.5317709445953369,
0.073954738676548,
-0.5340843200683594,
0.17524012923240662,
0.04830659180879593,
0.07122814655303955,
-0.6834122538566589,
-0.04543595016002655,
0.14930348098278046,
0.03370949998497963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14284v1 | VAIYAKARANA : A Benchmark for Automatic Grammar Correction in Bangla | 2024-06-20T13:09:29 | 2024-06-20T13:09:29 | Pramit Bhattacharyya, Arnab Bhattacharya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Bangla (Bengali) is the fifth most spoken language globally and, yet, the
problem of automatic grammar correction in Bangla is still in its nascent
stage. This is mostly due to the need for a large corpus of grammatically
incorrect sentences, with their corresponding correct counterparts. The present
state-of-the-art techniques to curate a corpus for grammatically wrong
sentences involve random swapping, insertion and deletion of words.
However,these steps may not always generate grammatically wrong sentences in
Bangla. In this work, we propose a pragmatic approach to generate grammatically
wrong sentences in Bangla. We first categorize the different kinds of errors in
Bangla into 5 broad classes and 12 finer classes. We then use these to generate
grammatically wrong sentences systematically from a correct sentence. This
approach can generate a large number of wrong sentences and can, thus, mitigate
the challenge of lacking a large corpus for neural networks. We provide a
dataset, Vaiyakarana, consisting of 92,830 grammatically incorrect sentences as
well as 18,426 correct sentences. We also collected 619 human-generated
sentences from essays written by Bangla native speakers. This helped us to
understand errors that are more frequent. We evaluated our corpus against
neural models and LLMs and also benchmark it against human evaluators who are
native speakers of Bangla. Our analysis shows that native speakers are far more
accurate than state-of-the-art models to detect whether the sentence is
grammatically correct. Our methodology of generating erroneous sentences can be
applied for most other Indian languages as well. | [
0.33618098497390747,
-1.0748460292816162,
0.2002447545528412,
0.6466951370239258,
-0.13092492520809174,
-0.072113536298275,
-0.1424245983362198,
-0.07435712963342667,
0.1687994748353958,
0.1566791981458664,
-0.10209102928638458,
-0.34283801913261414,
-0.15570151805877686,
0.4429541528224945,
-0.5996048450469971,
0.4721779525279999,
0.01055760495364666,
0.10764501988887787,
-0.2676190733909607,
0.15700379014015198,
-0.8378992676734924,
-0.393898069858551,
-0.19420117139816284,
0.20105192065238953,
0.4134618639945984,
0.2808127701282501,
0.35658276081085205,
0.6676842570304871,
0.399699330329895,
0.3883402943611145,
-0.21976065635681152,
0.8432276844978333,
-0.3065832257270813,
0.02488858252763748,
-0.4339309334754944,
-0.6095437407493591,
-0.3370513319969177,
-0.5667689442634583,
0.594528317451477,
0.4840032160282135,
-0.3090338706970215,
0.1637497842311859,
-0.12842220067977905,
0.596511960029602,
-0.8892698287963867,
0.09885915368795395,
-0.7352555394172668,
-0.09563466161489487,
-0.5629456639289856,
-0.11563076078891754,
-0.4829597771167755,
-0.8864108920097351,
-0.6154156923294067,
-0.3543793261051178,
0.035508885979652405,
-0.090273417532444,
1.1404035091400146,
0.375470906496048,
-0.2564922273159027,
-0.3027184009552002,
-0.6214747428894043,
0.4884483516216278,
-0.732472836971283,
0.0073660146445035934,
0.5310531854629517,
0.46696144342422485,
-0.45011571049690247,
-0.35302844643592834,
-0.8348903656005859,
-0.030977763235569,
-0.05074243247509003,
0.22911743819713593,
-0.06504116207361221,
-0.01250262837857008,
-0.019592126831412315,
0.05938117578625679,
-0.6705825924873352,
-0.14326730370521545,
-0.5516018867492676,
-0.1734393984079361,
0.7907424569129944,
0.21070674061775208,
0.2998405694961548,
-0.7074454426765442,
0.1382167488336563,
-0.006230572704225779,
-0.6647975444793701,
-0.06871405988931656,
0.839116632938385,
0.6588457822799683,
0.2632419168949127,
0.6622694134712219,
-0.16609132289886475,
1.3418231010437012,
0.3429569900035858,
-0.23187965154647827,
0.22949041426181793,
-0.6427653431892395,
-0.384843111038208,
0.34087055921554565,
0.4808003306388855,
0.4667375683784485,
0.5295066833496094,
-0.044992972165346146,
0.19016534090042114,
0.49283185601234436,
0.5721184611320496,
-0.21896860003471375,
-0.04391299560666084,
0.17413991689682007,
-0.17607015371322632,
-0.5354020595550537,
-0.21639873087406158,
-0.7947242856025696,
-0.4189392924308777,
-0.3005269765853882,
0.211692214012146,
-0.5251166224479675,
-0.19899867475032806,
-0.10411527007818222,
0.30790674686431885,
0.10029754787683487,
0.10770882666110992,
-0.7831223011016846,
-0.05205598473548889,
0.31850340962409973,
0.7244369983673096,
0.36339831352233887,
-0.46964260935783386,
-0.4396047294139862,
0.009428665973246098,
-0.7004351615905762,
0.9198440313339233,
-0.38883650302886963,
-0.3756859302520752,
0.09938695281744003,
-0.34371820092201233,
-0.34191760420799255,
-0.8343880772590637,
0.676379382610321,
-0.06575720757246017,
-0.1942567229270935,
-0.16317012906074524,
-0.589593231678009,
-0.0625421404838562,
0.1759512573480606,
-0.1654968410730362,
0.8804439902305603,
-0.00028428531368263066,
-0.49849066138267517,
0.31928399205207825,
-0.12469155341386795,
-0.40568843483924866,
0.11085588485002518,
-0.15886592864990234,
-0.578775942325592,
0.08128578960895538,
0.20982365310192108,
0.4876962900161743,
0.1841815710067749,
1.0153741836547852,
0.026567526161670685,
-0.5998279452323914,
0.17846576869487762,
-0.22287078201770782,
0.9124651551246643,
0.199020653963089,
-0.3865715563297272,
0.16045793890953064,
-1.1323243379592896,
0.2278284877538681,
-0.04003823921084404,
-0.2531284987926483,
-0.3908941149711609,
-0.08603686094284058,
0.204339861869812,
0.14145341515541077,
-0.10622483491897583,
-0.5948474407196045,
0.23571360111236572,
-0.7286350131034851,
0.14505422115325928,
0.9001671671867371,
-0.008371055126190186,
0.050544045865535736,
-0.39504116773605347,
0.3203503489494324,
-0.009167006239295006,
-0.03858863562345505,
-0.20946305990219116,
-0.307167649269104,
-0.749210774898529,
-0.3335858881473541,
0.4176415801048279,
0.8116689324378967,
-0.29119735956192017,
0.5703371167182922,
-0.14921598136425018,
-0.7081748247146606,
-1.033179521560669,
0.3794479966163635,
0.650251030921936,
0.4882563054561615,
0.24649591743946075,
0.1275893896818161,
-1.0348974466323853,
-1.0124704837799072,
-0.6933499574661255,
-0.5174790620803833,
0.7208871841430664,
-0.2142784744501114,
0.39131948351860046,
-0.13596245646476746,
1.1884945631027222,
-0.03377851843833923,
-0.1704789698123932,
0.033921703696250916,
0.08732740581035614,
0.07574058324098587,
0.2723987400531769,
0.2756318151950836,
-0.9627760052680969,
-0.515219509601593,
-0.041590943932533264,
-0.7832335829734802,
-0.4720936715602875,
-0.3536592721939087,
-0.14274685084819794,
0.5277782678604126,
0.5006152391433716,
-0.6752634048461914,
0.7160747051239014,
0.130764901638031,
-0.2692969739437103,
0.8145771622657776,
-0.21563154458999634,
-0.07146089524030685,
-1.2393993139266968,
0.19712111353874207,
-0.15334559977054596,
-0.4436522424221039,
-0.2983952760696411,
0.20772163569927216,
0.193813294172287,
0.27434074878692627,
-0.30104318261146545,
0.48126035928726196,
-0.2642918825149536,
0.3086623251438141,
-0.24566137790679932,
-0.08016707748174667,
-0.3928530514240265,
0.4020722210407257,
-0.2753550708293915,
0.6121482253074646,
0.11213258653879166,
-0.558876097202301,
0.6484958529472351,
0.21174700558185577,
-0.08011514693498611,
0.7956410050392151,
-0.437974750995636,
-0.32904931902885437,
-0.400860458612442,
0.028649477288126945,
-1.0802236795425415,
-0.4558340013027191,
0.29131972789764404,
-0.4464576542377472,
0.24713335931301117,
-0.004481318406760693,
-0.6087249517440796,
-0.24915258586406708,
0.09158977121114731,
0.042656753212213516,
0.3681034445762634,
-0.46979162096977234,
0.33560582995414734,
0.07925780862569809,
-0.1986832171678543,
-0.7278441786766052,
-0.6442921161651611,
0.23923036456108093,
-0.022480543702840805,
-0.5280247926712036,
0.07649349421262741,
-0.025861484929919243,
-0.5880256295204163,
-0.034180570393800735,
0.09639854729175568,
0.008640676736831665,
-0.14021839201450348,
0.672399640083313,
0.0702354684472084,
-0.0017962566344067454,
0.20590776205062866,
0.024906296283006668,
-0.0034962294157594442,
-0.2253178209066391,
-0.05660887062549591,
0.2713247239589691,
-0.36753129959106445,
-0.29071247577667236,
-0.4693947732448578,
0.049119558185338974,
0.439771443605423,
-0.008115511387586594,
0.466755747795105,
0.5130957365036011,
-0.4119904339313507,
-0.013658917509019375,
-0.6736064553260803,
0.4100671708583832,
-0.36722642183303833,
0.40884533524513245,
-0.2363424301147461,
-0.21949659287929535,
0.23015914857387543,
0.08370991051197052,
-0.036360517144203186,
0.3225080072879791,
0.7969498634338379,
-0.008609411306679249,
0.6640668511390686,
0.4561983346939087,
0.17254520952701569,
0.00006786015001125634,
0.2114604115486145,
0.6864813566207886,
-0.2637304365634918,
-0.2725932002067566,
-0.3276427686214447,
0.08954047411680222,
-0.7536596059799194,
-0.2899460792541504,
0.02118772454559803,
0.16623806953430176,
-0.11316093802452087,
0.32802990078926086,
-0.46109044551849365,
0.5177791714668274,
0.4488060176372528,
-0.165408656001091,
0.19591553509235382,
0.03319215774536133,
-0.3665742576122284,
-0.19770866632461548,
-0.4674927294254303,
-0.7606776356697083,
0.8923957347869873,
-0.24600251019001007,
0.44757673144340515,
0.28830939531326294,
0.7981059551239014,
0.24129582941532135,
0.08240420371294022,
-0.3890105187892914,
0.6014806628227234,
-0.11036953330039978,
-0.6607781648635864,
0.012133045122027397,
-0.2984054386615753,
-0.7672407627105713,
0.17868554592132568,
0.03990166261792183,
-0.5461586713790894,
0.30964598059654236,
0.36957740783691406,
-0.5493955612182617,
0.21386206150054932,
-1.0492768287658691,
0.8601706624031067,
-0.17128832638263702,
-0.757339358329773,
0.20209170877933502,
-0.7466571927070618,
0.5442612171173096,
-0.0944870188832283,
0.2641594409942627,
0.043440233916044235,
0.27125459909439087,
0.302059531211853,
-0.6782710552215576,
1.055061936378479,
-0.2595811188220978,
0.12287431955337524,
0.3598710298538208,
0.10916891694068909,
0.2049165815114975,
-0.02813004143536091,
-0.023195015266537666,
-0.2827596366405487,
-0.10724406689405441,
-0.6323557496070862,
-0.46361228823661804,
0.6720446348190308,
-0.7225145101547241,
-0.1454189419746399,
-0.7469210624694824,
-0.4117094576358795,
-0.21015071868896484,
0.10687310993671417,
0.33113178610801697,
0.29460081458091736,
-0.08807522803544998,
-0.28289851546287537,
0.22777529060840607,
-0.037650927901268005,
0.5586027503013611,
0.2758074402809143,
-0.514481246471405,
-0.08895209431648254,
1.1825768947601318,
0.38626620173454285,
-0.1806415468454361,
0.2980342209339142,
-0.027865003794431686,
-0.14303091168403625,
-0.5841548442840576,
-0.6721824407577515,
0.22855070233345032,
-0.6509492993354797,
-0.29625585675239563,
-0.5937934517860413,
-0.19103851914405823,
-0.5967274308204651,
-0.3460053503513336,
-0.3750073313713074,
-0.35799044370651245,
0.00913783349096775,
-0.18444295227527618,
0.26653462648391724,
0.7201223969459534,
-0.26347294449806213,
0.28980571031570435,
-0.5687230825424194,
0.09213976562023163,
0.3007587790489197,
-0.049640554934740067,
-0.1687997579574585,
-0.43354880809783936,
0.03956480324268341,
0.004359129350632429,
-0.33433330059051514,
-0.785287082195282,
0.6656167507171631,
0.2670885920524597,
0.282360702753067,
-0.04159091040492058,
-0.38534122705459595,
1.2676326036453247,
-0.480103999376297,
0.6577264666557312,
0.033985745161771774,
-0.931358277797699,
0.8688706755638123,
-0.49658167362213135,
0.34346482157707214,
0.6292792558670044,
0.18420232832431793,
-0.5594578385353088,
-0.38469794392585754,
-0.6754209399223328,
-1.0755627155303955,
0.24261386692523956,
0.3613377809524536,
0.07813259959220886,
-0.21381783485412598,
0.5343579053878784,
0.15347054600715637,
0.21958287060260773,
-0.5397406220436096,
-0.10269144922494888,
-0.3564033508300781,
-0.6070699095726013,
-0.061721812933683395,
-0.2342950403690338,
0.36285603046417236,
-0.30768874287605286,
1.0045465230941772,
0.06588777154684067,
0.06468097120523453,
0.34636446833610535,
-0.4823455810546875,
-0.17975525557994843,
0.33293017745018005,
0.8439280390739441,
1.1662033796310425,
-0.34790146350860596,
-0.13256527483463287,
-0.1060403436422348,
-0.3981931805610657,
0.334707647562027,
0.09475913643836975,
-0.4171898066997528,
0.4568079113960266,
0.34772083163261414,
0.5542693138122559,
0.1190280169248581,
-0.9883367419242859,
0.42160364985466003,
-0.0035900177899748087,
0.20200946927070618,
-0.6635356545448303,
-0.1582367867231369,
0.19557897746562958,
-0.0765027329325676,
0.25919026136398315,
0.46143218874931335,
-0.05784004181623459,
-0.4985750913619995,
0.1391202062368393,
-0.2801682949066162,
0.09011920541524887,
-0.17317044734954834,
0.35400035977363586,
0.12362606823444366,
-0.46592557430267334,
0.524360716342926,
-0.5346562266349792,
-0.3192070424556732,
0.39672383666038513,
0.7048230767250061,
0.5441475510597229,
-0.5970384478569031,
0.4518555700778961,
0.7736256718635559,
0.27347835898399353,
-0.06661011278629303,
0.44626012444496155,
0.4418320953845978,
-0.3731438219547272,
-0.6065040826797485,
-0.9674397706985474,
-0.14941421151161194,
-0.08813721686601639,
-0.45889171957969666,
0.36993491649627686,
-0.4951399564743042,
-0.0705769881606102,
0.05792192742228508,
-0.14628782868385315,
-0.19128857553005219,
0.28741827607154846,
0.08777739852666855,
0.4613000750541687,
-0.8930503129959106,
0.5261499881744385,
0.9318066835403442,
-0.5651600360870361,
-0.8132643699645996,
-0.2734067738056183,
0.23482279479503632,
-0.6364206671714783,
0.8631474375724792,
-0.02058270014822483,
-0.16985151171684265,
-0.1266803741455078,
-0.4721428453922272,
-0.42852845788002014,
0.5180546641349792,
0.4196156859397888,
-1.0909861326217651,
-0.219801127910614,
-0.04948687180876732,
0.6822941303253174,
-0.0032763397321105003,
0.2514956593513489,
0.3362343907356262,
0.4634615182876587,
-0.1756061464548111,
-1.0662565231323242,
-0.13912904262542725,
-0.7660672068595886,
0.38058793544769287,
0.21809260547161102,
-0.5802796483039856,
0.8320056796073914,
-0.01104911882430315,
0.07657981663942337,
0.38527897000312805,
0.6093031764030457,
0.23633693158626556,
0.1754513680934906,
0.19841144979000092,
0.6693349480628967,
1.1205756664276123,
-0.02211904712021351,
1.0391794443130493,
0.21197733283042908,
0.10978826135396957,
1.0762054920196533,
-0.3674086928367615,
0.9262139201164246,
0.54468834400177,
-0.25527188181877136,
0.4588322639465332,
0.6384468078613281,
0.07356174290180206,
0.350319504737854,
0.6342669129371643,
-0.06899664551019669,
-0.22258497774600983,
-0.2311887890100479,
-0.20060263574123383,
0.7523021101951599,
0.20662638545036316,
-0.07648440450429916,
-0.1977410763502121,
0.16581471264362335,
0.1954907774925232,
0.8264613151550293,
-0.38154658675193787,
0.5120611786842346,
-0.23027153313159943,
-0.6735417246818542,
0.898929238319397,
0.3137841820716858,
0.692866861820221,
-0.37442272901535034,
-0.1565457135438919,
-0.41056227684020996,
0.5276116132736206,
-0.47025251388549805,
-0.14677771925926208,
0.721746027469635,
0.35851097106933594,
-0.18701696395874023,
-0.0011013417970389128,
0.8093894124031067,
-0.5623511075973511,
-0.8855865001678467,
-0.21148648858070374,
0.4844733774662018,
0.2477748692035675,
0.11273626983165741,
-0.3562544286251068,
0.10503039509057999,
-0.08357391506433487,
0.5348883867263794,
0.11886606365442276,
-0.09949959814548492,
-0.29527896642684937,
0.28799664974212646,
0.4354839026927948,
0.41549381613731384,
0.5902172923088074,
-0.056625742465257645,
0.2156476229429245,
-0.7059728503227234,
-0.6862301826477051,
-0.8862770795822144,
0.4985913336277008,
-0.3541868031024933,
-0.5290639400482178,
0.9672003984451294,
0.5330931544303894,
0.9393274188041687,
-0.022162247449159622,
0.9108718037605286,
-0.13428571820259094,
0.7259352803230286,
-0.5159177780151367,
0.5052975416183472,
-0.37563931941986084,
-0.10408215969800949,
-0.28874602913856506,
-1.0098087787628174,
-0.5747460126876831,
0.9592694044113159,
-0.35931190848350525,
0.0035779178142547607,
0.723538339138031,
1.0835342407226562,
0.03558838367462158,
0.10283893346786499,
0.21529991924762726,
0.6612704396247864,
0.09400647133588791,
0.458225280046463,
0.8459943532943726,
-0.6450182199478149,
0.46710506081581116,
-0.2379884123802185,
-0.014021920040249825,
-0.6547055244445801,
-0.6664732694625854,
-0.6761704683303833,
-0.710781991481781,
-0.43670654296875,
-0.4574960470199585,
0.8390849828720093,
1.0452321767807007,
0.6341664791107178,
-0.7360537052154541,
-0.32758471369743347,
-0.38406747579574585,
0.12741254270076752,
-0.33388060331344604,
-0.2581608295440674,
0.40664616227149963,
-0.47099432349205017,
-0.6979540586471558,
0.5519287586212158,
0.29707857966423035,
-0.2907840311527252,
-0.0743468627333641,
0.18324612081050873,
-0.922922670841217,
0.06524543464183807,
0.37586042284965515,
0.40586140751838684,
-0.802222728729248,
-0.0442483089864254,
-0.14936335384845734,
-0.25270408391952515,
-0.023940764367580414,
0.5888094902038574,
-0.7039710283279419,
0.7367039918899536,
0.4675532579421997,
0.7518749237060547,
0.08325713127851486,
0.04711945727467537,
0.4717213809490204,
-0.8637883067131042,
0.02205616421997547,
0.2699381113052368,
0.06694493442773819,
0.7923365235328674,
-0.2682705521583557,
0.4067658483982086,
0.5313087105751038,
-0.5128092169761658,
-1.1618949174880981,
-0.0657588317990303,
-0.7989146113395691,
-0.14383794367313385,
1.0229545831680298,
-0.0699634850025177,
-0.8127662539482117,
-0.3301474452018738,
-0.5112504959106445,
0.43876007199287415,
-0.05826715752482414,
0.8993143439292908,
0.8185221552848816,
0.12656167149543762,
0.24905961751937866,
-0.33319175243377686,
0.3201752007007599,
0.8719996213912964,
-0.6267690658569336,
0.060370493680238724,
0.5270448327064514,
0.1402948945760727,
0.38963571190834045,
0.5512061715126038,
-0.03748122602701187,
0.7456017732620239,
0.15522244572639465,
0.020423630252480507,
-0.2599586248397827,
-0.319333553314209,
-0.43205946683883667,
0.08446363359689713,
-0.07260244339704514,
-0.04796237125992775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14282v1 | Learning to Plan for Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models from Knowledge Graphs | 2024-06-20T13:07:38 | 2024-06-20T13:07:38 | Junjie Wang, Mingyang Chen, Binbin Hu, Dan Yang, Ziqi Liu, Yue Shen, Peng Wei, Zhiqiang Zhang, Jinjie Gu, Jun Zhou, Jeff Z. Pan, Wen Zhang, Huajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Improving the performance of large language models (LLMs) in complex
question-answering (QA) scenarios has always been a research focal point.
Recent studies have attempted to enhance LLMs' performance by combining
step-wise planning with external retrieval. While effective for advanced models
like GPT-3.5, smaller LLMs face challenges in decomposing complex questions,
necessitating supervised fine-tuning. Previous work has relied on manual
annotation and knowledge distillation from teacher LLMs, which are
time-consuming and not accurate enough. In this paper, we introduce a novel
framework for enhancing LLMs' planning capabilities by using planning data
derived from knowledge graphs (KGs). LLMs fine-tuned with this data have
improved planning capabilities, better equipping them to handle complex QA
tasks that involve retrieval. Evaluations on multiple datasets, including our
newly proposed benchmark, highlight the effectiveness of our framework and the
benefits of KG-derived planning data. | [
-0.41016629338264465,
-0.5946245193481445,
0.7655357718467712,
-0.1510872095823288,
-0.046157632023096085,
0.2142394632101059,
-0.024681180715560913,
-0.2590997815132141,
0.1915561556816101,
0.6105570793151855,
-0.4755731523036957,
-0.46498847007751465,
-0.3438253700733185,
0.017365580424666405,
-0.246037095785141,
0.47278428077697754,
-0.1606329083442688,
0.014831374399363995,
-0.12691357731819153,
0.10744215548038483,
-0.5136313438415527,
-0.31500232219696045,
-0.7253527045249939,
-0.4492337107658386,
0.8035457730293274,
0.5891025066375732,
0.6907171010971069,
0.3884987533092499,
0.08708054572343826,
0.15445609390735626,
-0.10180837661027908,
0.7516880631446838,
-0.6157684326171875,
0.20704810321331024,
-0.12809601426124573,
-0.4340745806694031,
-0.3662785589694977,
-0.29494380950927734,
0.5818970203399658,
0.8710625767707825,
-0.17001770436763763,
0.12941721081733704,
-0.15922826528549194,
0.8287183046340942,
-0.6880626082420349,
0.6015439033508301,
-0.6381230354309082,
0.03607550263404846,
0.1375170797109604,
-0.3087954819202423,
-0.4124200940132141,
-0.4805554449558258,
0.22119688987731934,
-0.5964899063110352,
-0.08043218404054642,
-0.025999654084444046,
0.3713262379169464,
-0.013937204144895077,
-0.5412639379501343,
-0.3073510527610779,
-0.7965225577354431,
0.2311769723892212,
-0.5780612826347351,
0.40757814049720764,
0.5361438989639282,
0.6293951869010925,
-0.4103601276874542,
-0.9143337607383728,
-0.551871657371521,
0.17040467262268066,
-0.18576404452323914,
-0.05333670973777771,
-0.022615432739257812,
0.20974811911582947,
0.49982866644859314,
0.03735706955194473,
-0.410550594329834,
-0.07205069065093994,
-0.4042816758155823,
-0.08491674810647964,
0.5575340986251831,
0.19311586022377014,
0.145897775888443,
-0.17003276944160461,
-0.011069031432271004,
-0.1853664666414261,
-0.8990466594696045,
-0.005656632129102945,
0.2340121567249298,
0.49252188205718994,
0.30238020420074463,
0.787828803062439,
-0.8660549521446228,
0.7820949554443359,
-0.30282872915267944,
-0.1733359545469284,
0.1162286028265953,
-0.17329469323158264,
-0.18304967880249023,
-0.10741376131772995,
0.36974766850471497,
0.23053093254566193,
0.6168219447135925,
-0.5545415282249451,
-0.3555048704147339,
-0.462934672832489,
0.020579678937792778,
-0.9695324301719666,
-0.6013439297676086,
0.056310709565877914,
0.14374785125255585,
-0.033954452723264694,
-0.27454718947410583,
-0.602799117565155,
-0.3124813735485077,
-0.46070992946624756,
0.5712502002716064,
-0.5197523832321167,
-0.1582774966955185,
0.22464823722839355,
-0.09493308514356613,
0.017698800191283226,
0.27528947591781616,
-0.7362726330757141,
0.08289492130279541,
0.5171769261360168,
0.3029089570045471,
0.17668402194976807,
-0.14843735098838806,
-0.7544540166854858,
0.6236441731452942,
-0.5810685753822327,
0.8511446714401245,
-0.6020100712776184,
-0.31691300868988037,
0.25818175077438354,
-0.19377018511295319,
0.00001870532287284732,
-0.6509422659873962,
0.406393826007843,
-1.0309077501296997,
0.18371815979480743,
-0.5825079083442688,
-0.4733951687812805,
-0.3171490728855133,
0.6981509923934937,
-0.6437773704528809,
0.9579230546951294,
0.2358694076538086,
-0.4774519205093384,
0.310260534286499,
-0.3967296779155731,
-0.5251971483230591,
0.12266680598258972,
-0.1432824283838272,
-0.10701403021812439,
-0.41752976179122925,
0.6291940212249756,
0.5780625343322754,
-0.23346562683582306,
0.3183571696281433,
-0.12218739837408066,
-0.18276546895503998,
-0.15951243042945862,
-0.09746593236923218,
0.317312091588974,
0.19293789565563202,
0.18119418621063232,
0.2889081537723541,
-0.7804021239280701,
0.5528430342674255,
0.06044190749526024,
-0.611017644405365,
-0.18577639758586884,
0.2525845468044281,
-0.5079777240753174,
0.23119352757930756,
0.19435787200927734,
-0.2629431486129761,
0.42793571949005127,
-0.48548513650894165,
0.3089655935764313,
0.4674984812736511,
0.08763950318098068,
0.46547892689704895,
-0.3288189768791199,
0.6045777797698975,
-0.2623516917228699,
0.09715430438518524,
0.11957462877035141,
-0.23453837633132935,
-0.4537180960178375,
-0.07872412353754044,
0.0347365066409111,
0.36743593215942383,
-1.2197104692459106,
-0.03254309296607971,
-0.45160937309265137,
-0.67670077085495,
-0.15766900777816772,
0.05715586990118027,
0.3280889689922333,
0.5728821754455566,
0.6468902826309204,
0.038955800235271454,
-0.39222314953804016,
-0.674514651298523,
-0.1935323029756546,
-0.1631172150373459,
-0.055321864783763885,
0.3590087294578552,
0.10051048547029495,
0.017004549503326416,
0.9891698956489563,
-0.8787546753883362,
-0.15385198593139648,
-0.6098880767822266,
-0.06875249743461609,
0.09105125814676285,
-0.0026810080744326115,
0.2616802752017975,
-0.9764106869697571,
-0.5370063185691833,
-0.19197100400924683,
-0.366068571805954,
-0.07453475147485733,
0.2507525682449341,
-0.3523876368999481,
-0.24677884578704834,
0.5577088594436646,
-0.671637237071991,
0.1279933899641037,
0.23720766603946686,
-0.27883201837539673,
0.6829834580421448,
-0.11570093035697937,
0.010477094911038876,
-1.0859131813049316,
-0.06261364370584488,
-0.3775085210800171,
-0.29117918014526367,
-0.5917003154754639,
0.09743619710206985,
0.2521887719631195,
-0.050665877759456635,
-0.38367971777915955,
0.5778039693832397,
-0.42891350388526917,
-0.2506697475910187,
-0.14983293414115906,
0.36282768845558167,
0.05269363150000572,
0.5613674521446228,
-0.2140105962753296,
0.8720916509628296,
0.2501588463783264,
-0.664799153804779,
0.3384800851345062,
0.5122633576393127,
-0.2963677644729614,
0.2185915857553482,
-0.3239761292934418,
0.0383220799267292,
-0.17878562211990356,
0.28137797117233276,
-0.9236502647399902,
-0.2547650635242462,
0.18756113946437836,
-0.2360118180513382,
0.5124813318252563,
-0.49406909942626953,
-0.7628778219223022,
-0.42030373215675354,
-0.14361120760440826,
0.2941822409629822,
0.2335975170135498,
-0.5662917494773865,
0.913436770439148,
0.4145755469799042,
-0.24762018024921417,
-0.5221228003501892,
-0.23105129599571228,
-0.07443246245384216,
-0.02981390990316868,
-0.43329402804374695,
0.250296026468277,
0.14558003842830658,
-0.025533851236104965,
0.01970708556473255,
-0.13831475377082825,
-0.07797383517026901,
0.0836254358291626,
-0.06910700350999832,
0.06384170800447464,
0.0018311835592612624,
0.38085559010505676,
0.07540405541658401,
-0.01693679392337799,
0.18531224131584167,
-0.3195972740650177,
0.9370183944702148,
0.470387727022171,
-0.262116014957428,
0.028308577835559845,
0.017506897449493408,
0.29025688767433167,
-0.4454362392425537,
0.5152904987335205,
0.2586005628108978,
-0.3710511326789856,
-0.13255468010902405,
-0.618657648563385,
-0.15126588940620422,
-0.4622901976108551,
0.5010108351707458,
-0.5780260562896729,
-0.7620302438735962,
0.4478553831577301,
-0.3600352108478546,
0.02162567898631096,
0.19498571753501892,
0.14455121755599976,
0.03738605976104736,
1.1219669580459595,
0.45723703503608704,
-0.11095619946718216,
0.36615118384361267,
-0.33998963236808777,
0.16824142634868622,
-0.9599184393882751,
-0.45486176013946533,
-0.4568060338497162,
-0.3128679096698761,
-0.44821304082870483,
-0.6081988215446472,
0.3786905109882355,
0.32463183999061584,
-0.2983313202857971,
0.011451913975179195,
-0.12134800106287003,
0.6258532404899597,
0.3605528771877289,
0.013360575772821903,
0.3662031590938568,
0.10269173979759216,
-0.35810986161231995,
0.3163120150566101,
-0.8053606152534485,
-0.48212239146232605,
1.2484272718429565,
-0.03456392511725426,
0.503752589225769,
0.09354683756828308,
0.5190587043762207,
-0.3188866972923279,
0.2324768304824829,
-0.4858510494232178,
0.8533998131752014,
-0.03842932730913162,
-0.552047073841095,
-0.658454418182373,
-0.6625761985778809,
-0.8738020658493042,
0.39700204133987427,
-0.11548171192407608,
-0.6608180999755859,
-0.11649414896965027,
-0.06524977087974548,
-0.2634884715080261,
0.4043525159358978,
-0.7043132185935974,
0.5511851906776428,
-0.14850448071956635,
-0.09726747125387192,
-0.28048980236053467,
-0.28698834776878357,
0.029612602666020393,
-0.06346534937620163,
-0.008766217157244682,
-0.3185218870639801,
0.09757077693939209,
0.6995470523834229,
-0.1594012975692749,
0.571010172367096,
-0.451404333114624,
-0.11105863749980927,
0.4209909439086914,
0.23455233871936798,
0.9724419116973877,
-0.11756868660449982,
-0.268955260515213,
-0.6063768267631531,
0.1661214828491211,
-0.5114374756813049,
-0.6968324780464172,
0.5763442516326904,
-0.5514684319496155,
-0.5933020114898682,
0.17036260664463043,
-0.9362794160842896,
-0.8851343393325806,
0.4607698321342468,
-0.3192870616912842,
0.5269113183021545,
0.04176727682352066,
-0.024625685065984726,
0.48025310039520264,
-0.2757706940174103,
0.18037579953670502,
0.6178368926048279,
-0.5531848669052124,
-0.40595653653144836,
0.7622307538986206,
0.5204399824142456,
0.445024311542511,
0.621528148651123,
0.10352703928947449,
-0.5032826662063599,
-0.8590853810310364,
-0.2087026685476303,
0.24315333366394043,
-0.8621137738227844,
-0.2806253433227539,
-0.6365207433700562,
-0.13555516302585602,
-0.6361732482910156,
0.17073874175548553,
-0.11029009521007538,
-0.5671581029891968,
0.08804291486740112,
-0.40685370564460754,
0.30715084075927734,
0.7273380756378174,
0.18312162160873413,
0.20135770738124847,
-0.550623893737793,
0.2853633463382721,
0.48320823907852173,
0.33345773816108704,
0.09139113128185272,
-0.16786716878414154,
-0.09581529349088669,
0.07233249396085739,
-0.23440219461917877,
-0.626064658164978,
0.5091314911842346,
-0.07644452154636383,
0.5255659222602844,
0.022569358348846436,
0.33554354310035706,
0.9908401966094971,
-0.36133405566215515,
0.26202741265296936,
-0.29479077458381653,
-0.21088233590126038,
0.5861160755157471,
-0.4035598337650299,
0.305637389421463,
0.532179057598114,
0.6142536997795105,
-0.3738468289375305,
-0.13699941337108612,
-0.3948652446269989,
-1.091599464416504,
0.5685903429985046,
0.03156871721148491,
0.0039286501705646515,
-0.015734441578388214,
0.6996181011199951,
-0.08156045526266098,
0.39239799976348877,
-0.43723103404045105,
-0.10461040586233139,
0.368285596370697,
-0.18251626193523407,
-0.11319560557603836,
-0.5912930369377136,
-0.21469293534755707,
-0.23781520128250122,
0.661564826965332,
-0.49152871966362,
0.014729189686477184,
0.09778749197721481,
-0.04517665505409241,
-0.16453732550144196,
0.20960292220115662,
0.1294468343257904,
0.9911189675331116,
-0.10766547173261642,
0.2313108742237091,
0.5092843174934387,
-0.25687289237976074,
-0.15934047102928162,
0.3932608664035797,
-0.30972981452941895,
-0.5018427968025208,
0.22416706383228302,
0.4048522710800171,
0.2131776511669159,
-0.8012204170227051,
0.15455107390880585,
0.04595708101987839,
-0.03811049088835716,
-0.2977224886417389,
0.1550244241952896,
0.36440539360046387,
0.6558494567871094,
0.4852072298526764,
-0.45286989212036133,
0.000056870037951739505,
-0.4203539490699768,
0.17790693044662476,
0.40480417013168335,
-0.31258198618888855,
-0.04683705419301987,
0.28934478759765625,
-0.16728198528289795,
-0.07473526149988174,
0.6708287000656128,
-0.35416319966316223,
-0.6438911557197571,
0.3966509699821472,
0.5061320066452026,
0.3279108703136444,
-0.06274053454399109,
0.2747543752193451,
0.4846343994140625,
0.13641948997974396,
-0.1037343293428421,
0.727922797203064,
0.0037997006438672543,
-0.6604838371276855,
-0.5637334585189819,
-0.5224012732505798,
-0.1205352172255516,
0.0044228797778487206,
-0.3430461883544922,
0.3078131079673767,
-0.27567121386528015,
0.1977262645959854,
-0.4022291898727417,
0.36818599700927734,
-0.6395397782325745,
0.325884073972702,
-0.03668700531125069,
1.0313373804092407,
-0.37178608775138855,
0.8553598523139954,
0.594518780708313,
-0.34111401438713074,
-1.474665641784668,
0.018754178658127785,
-0.5256417989730835,
-0.9949691891670227,
0.6170396208763123,
-0.012733835726976395,
-0.0574883334338665,
0.35059425234794617,
-0.12669284641742706,
-1.0009671449661255,
1.5076789855957031,
0.39120668172836304,
-0.6330819725990295,
-0.4163551926612854,
0.40405184030532837,
0.42451247572898865,
-0.11296055465936661,
0.1478673666715622,
0.497519850730896,
0.40245646238327026,
0.47898879647254944,
-0.7441083788871765,
0.07529420405626297,
0.2613329589366913,
-0.3423706293106079,
0.48139631748199463,
-0.4018077850341797,
0.5908182859420776,
-0.43484407663345337,
-0.23570629954338074,
-0.1057792380452156,
0.549941897392273,
0.22812630236148834,
0.33016204833984375,
0.4500119686126709,
0.5635337829589844,
0.9538070559501648,
-0.06453275680541992,
0.9895224571228027,
-0.21361571550369263,
0.09833712875843048,
1.2402955293655396,
-0.20337708294391632,
1.0676279067993164,
0.3284303545951843,
-0.17031531035900116,
0.206963449716568,
0.5182633996009827,
0.3351907432079315,
0.7205522656440735,
0.12665946781635284,
-0.03696250170469284,
-0.4126085042953491,
-0.12329506129026413,
-0.17986373603343964,
0.15382924675941467,
0.3373223543167114,
-0.18003851175308228,
-0.4613904356956482,
-0.08511342108249664,
0.02756924368441105,
0.07000970095396042,
-0.4495185315608978,
0.7194526791572571,
-0.12125809490680695,
-0.7525155544281006,
0.3892803490161896,
-0.24396385252475739,
0.07839938998222351,
-0.608737587928772,
0.09941977262496948,
-0.22358378767967224,
0.07840041816234589,
-0.15792612731456757,
-1.116485357284546,
0.027327710762619972,
-0.2601932883262634,
0.04852529615163803,
-0.15093913674354553,
0.7949124574661255,
-0.591573178768158,
-0.2711702883243561,
0.4479046165943146,
0.6489439606666565,
-0.09046772122383118,
-0.33512040972709656,
-0.35346296429634094,
-0.3513006269931793,
0.021263495087623596,
-0.31738001108169556,
0.38595137000083923,
0.7057527303695679,
-0.16031073033809662,
1.0111409425735474,
0.5916893482208252,
0.1655060201883316,
0.175111785531044,
0.2786494791507721,
1.1845316886901855,
-0.5340061187744141,
-0.3318004310131073,
-0.4912787079811096,
0.31259697675704956,
-0.05662102252244949,
0.0143119590356946,
0.5003307461738586,
0.8471594452857971,
1.0363940000534058,
0.188375324010849,
0.5340653657913208,
0.09898096323013306,
0.7764582633972168,
-0.6291099190711975,
0.42924317717552185,
-0.4028341472148895,
0.41752129793167114,
-0.07062451541423798,
-0.9439864158630371,
-0.30062443017959595,
0.3172670900821686,
-0.8521199226379395,
0.02971819043159485,
0.29836902022361755,
0.8417660593986511,
0.092225581407547,
-0.16136670112609863,
0.37514254450798035,
0.05988820642232895,
0.862108588218689,
0.5702913999557495,
0.827785849571228,
-0.16038133203983307,
0.8955309987068176,
-0.38409659266471863,
0.1468321532011032,
-0.1254662573337555,
-0.47005003690719604,
-0.8177280426025391,
-0.6000300645828247,
-0.03351232036948204,
-0.02983330748975277,
0.13440722227096558,
0.8807624578475952,
0.5149105787277222,
-0.40240705013275146,
-0.04758427292108536,
0.04737906903028488,
0.12794531881809235,
0.0747213289141655,
-0.13504205644130707,
0.547719419002533,
-0.49313774704933167,
-0.44738343358039856,
0.4962922930717468,
0.007877270691096783,
0.037803031504154205,
-0.1956096589565277,
-0.16468402743339539,
-0.4131709635257721,
-0.08899340033531189,
0.846687376499176,
0.2327667772769928,
-0.3624269664287567,
-0.44805848598480225,
-0.020151479169726372,
-0.06846041977405548,
-0.19340583682060242,
0.6329151391983032,
-0.9744663834571838,
0.5154790282249451,
0.5528169274330139,
0.6453536748886108,
0.7683933973312378,
-0.04088551178574562,
0.5824928879737854,
-0.8515933752059937,
-0.17420008778572083,
0.5071067810058594,
0.217134028673172,
0.21182332932949066,
-0.1250467151403427,
0.7360667586326599,
-0.26686590909957886,
-0.45845142006874084,
-0.7205390930175781,
0.36296650767326355,
-0.7104834318161011,
-0.33295753598213196,
1.34977388381958,
0.03566700965166092,
0.020448174327611923,
-0.12691502273082733,
-0.5012194514274597,
0.3333221673965454,
-0.033773139119148254,
0.8341701626777649,
0.6241201758384705,
-0.1969999223947525,
0.08783967047929764,
-0.6925959587097168,
0.5520884990692139,
0.17141549289226532,
-0.8290879130363464,
0.3261052370071411,
0.615297257900238,
0.32980063557624817,
0.08687639981508255,
0.753482460975647,
-0.1534489244222641,
0.031261641532182693,
-0.49041301012039185,
-0.21459797024726868,
-0.20975467562675476,
-0.42151373624801636,
0.33635202050209045,
0.5360704064369202,
0.439654141664505,
0.06894906610250473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14277v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14277v1 | Augmenting Query and Passage for Retrieval-Augmented Generation using LLMs for Open-Domain Question Answering | 2024-06-20T12:59:27 | 2024-06-20T12:59:27 | Minsang Kim, Cheoneum Park, Seungjun Baek | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has received much attention for
Open-domain question-answering (ODQA) tasks as a means to compensate for the
parametric knowledge of large language models (LLMs). While previous approaches
focused on processing retrieved passages to remove irrelevant context, they
still rely heavily on the quality of retrieved passages which can degrade if
the question is ambiguous or complex. In this paper, we propose a simple yet
efficient method called question and passage augmentation via LLMs for
open-domain QA. Our method first decomposes the original questions into
multiple-step sub-questions. By augmenting the original question with detailed
sub-questions and planning, we are able to make the query more specific on what
needs to be retrieved, improving the retrieval performance. In addition, to
compensate for the case where the retrieved passages contain distracting
information or divided opinions, we augment the retrieved passages with
self-generated passages by LLMs to guide the answer extraction. Experimental
results show that the proposed scheme outperforms the previous state-of-the-art
and achieves significant performance gain over existing RAG methods. | [
-0.7048561573028564,
-1.0580368041992188,
0.5438157320022583,
-0.11957891285419464,
-0.5019230842590332,
0.1530127376317978,
0.013427975587546825,
-0.49705439805984497,
0.3369927704334259,
0.8964566588401794,
-0.6336377263069153,
-0.1361422836780548,
-0.09893274307250977,
0.26410192251205444,
0.0662163719534874,
0.8406023979187012,
-0.1267005354166031,
-0.05345321074128151,
-0.47249066829681396,
-0.19594772160053253,
-0.39476278424263,
-0.28035104274749756,
-0.5490167140960693,
-0.1271316111087799,
0.3357976973056793,
0.3685424327850342,
0.4209898114204407,
0.3532141149044037,
0.3161070644855499,
0.164315328001976,
-0.35552284121513367,
0.8170352578163147,
-0.44988930225372314,
0.47717320919036865,
-0.4673599898815155,
-0.2603248953819275,
-0.5629904866218567,
-0.24261745810508728,
0.6889272928237915,
0.7256097197532654,
0.0951843336224556,
0.3746156096458435,
0.06699765473604202,
0.6073319315910339,
-0.8153883218765259,
-0.16154931485652924,
-0.794310450553894,
-0.008074138313531876,
-0.19171808660030365,
-0.8355904221534729,
-0.29444456100463867,
-0.3017328083515167,
-0.07915563136339188,
-0.6079413890838623,
0.14477239549160004,
0.08726238459348679,
0.5143240690231323,
0.23650746047496796,
-0.4464888274669647,
-0.38031867146492004,
-0.7322092056274414,
0.6203485131263733,
-0.5268852710723877,
0.30112025141716003,
0.2292199283838272,
0.24126435816287994,
-0.1897997111082077,
-0.8717132210731506,
-0.5668145418167114,
-0.1486884206533432,
-0.026567354798316956,
0.3178689777851105,
0.14849117398262024,
-0.22394807636737823,
0.21942590177059174,
0.5602261424064636,
-0.5661425590515137,
-0.23072345554828644,
-0.4133926033973694,
-0.03126344457268715,
0.5993720889091492,
0.21211878955364227,
0.33290818333625793,
-0.22978317737579346,
-0.5975345969200134,
-0.05237444490194321,
-0.9899372458457947,
0.06189446523785591,
0.19391480088233948,
0.3304162621498108,
0.6163080334663391,
0.8218995928764343,
-0.3798644244670868,
0.6245785355567932,
0.26748165488243103,
-0.028532639145851135,
0.15339228510856628,
-0.4880697429180145,
-0.03962931036949158,
-0.24034808576107025,
0.3287317156791687,
-0.06578288227319717,
0.03904694318771362,
-0.1624443382024765,
-0.2800993025302887,
-0.7859967947006226,
0.375206857919693,
-0.8053394556045532,
0.13500505685806274,
0.2877340018749237,
-0.11528372764587402,
0.1672208607196808,
0.06684675067663193,
-0.7358159422874451,
-0.18467584252357483,
-0.31102097034454346,
0.6730997562408447,
-0.4052177667617798,
-0.22829659283161163,
-0.09502830356359482,
-0.10694168508052826,
0.350013792514801,
0.45187124609947205,
-0.4094829559326172,
0.18121841549873352,
0.45428624749183655,
0.3526543974876404,
-0.22800184786319733,
-0.04573467746376991,
-1.005440592765808,
0.2551784813404083,
-0.42433735728263855,
0.7540792226791382,
-0.4991300404071808,
-0.4576987028121948,
0.0019248814787715673,
-0.3182693421840668,
-0.011682754382491112,
-0.8722679615020752,
0.5510432720184326,
-1.3012099266052246,
0.3273884356021881,
-0.2300654947757721,
-0.5425540804862976,
0.009273112751543522,
0.39716804027557373,
-0.6448680758476257,
1.1804883480072021,
0.12637387216091156,
-0.5335145592689514,
-0.009126191958785057,
-0.6005541086196899,
-0.30719873309135437,
0.3988882005214691,
-0.13246935606002808,
-0.07871223241090775,
0.07093032449483871,
0.745643138885498,
0.15933220088481903,
-0.24564696848392487,
-0.22156798839569092,
0.1076030358672142,
-0.20166771113872528,
0.25239598751068115,
-0.25883209705352783,
0.6772600412368774,
0.3759547472000122,
0.021186571568250656,
-0.18724948167800903,
-0.5539188981056213,
0.4087192118167877,
0.1915227323770523,
-0.5764860510826111,
-0.5795990228652954,
-0.1748793125152588,
-0.4644680917263031,
0.07044246047735214,
0.5349879860877991,
-0.762889564037323,
0.253005713224411,
-0.6250376105308533,
-0.11812233179807663,
0.4898204505443573,
0.6987541317939758,
0.6518593430519104,
-0.2753980755805969,
0.7631054520606995,
0.1124332994222641,
0.08697695285081863,
-0.22856086492538452,
-0.5214369893074036,
-0.5982614755630493,
-0.146696999669075,
0.372380793094635,
0.4542193114757538,
-1.2920546531677246,
0.12811170518398285,
-0.09386936575174332,
-0.20836324989795685,
-0.7027520537376404,
0.19427409768104553,
0.4195399582386017,
0.5837190747261047,
0.7788052558898926,
-0.08803340792655945,
-0.3807268440723419,
-0.360306978225708,
-0.44745180010795593,
0.006392838899046183,
-0.014783164486289024,
0.5387299060821533,
0.40603840351104736,
0.2233518660068512,
1.0163041353225708,
-0.8178356885910034,
-0.22068621218204498,
-0.14245958626270294,
-0.07944967597723007,
-0.04948541894555092,
0.36342281103134155,
0.17922590672969818,
-1.0283452272415161,
-0.5552369356155396,
-0.17346568405628204,
-0.46969953179359436,
-0.27500537037849426,
0.1217917874455452,
-0.4200175702571869,
0.1267419159412384,
0.5933458209037781,
-0.5691383481025696,
0.3954029083251953,
0.06899256259202957,
-0.20732402801513672,
0.6520566940307617,
-0.1822715550661087,
0.30183833837509155,
-1.1071181297302246,
0.01396325882524252,
-0.45251044631004333,
-0.2603991627693176,
-0.5232275128364563,
0.5567288398742676,
0.20623837411403656,
-0.05017108470201492,
-0.5977073907852173,
0.9029229283332825,
-0.7463484406471252,
0.06472761183977127,
-0.32076722383499146,
0.48333579301834106,
0.191770538687706,
0.47140926122665405,
-0.12245246767997742,
1.0916633605957031,
0.1907554715871811,
-0.7438857555389404,
0.05131802707910538,
0.45644038915634155,
-0.09544242173433304,
0.4570145010948181,
-0.39066147804260254,
0.5336374640464783,
-0.345397412776947,
0.13994988799095154,
-0.9314084053039551,
-0.1554279774427414,
0.29055508971214294,
-0.5983765125274658,
0.26670536398887634,
-0.14524659514427185,
-0.26104503870010376,
-0.15400762856006622,
-0.3482181131839752,
0.6193668842315674,
0.6093857288360596,
-0.8473619818687439,
0.7108315825462341,
0.277823269367218,
-0.4680009186267853,
-0.6413018703460693,
-0.42813512682914734,
-0.12401743233203888,
0.06490658968687057,
-0.6808255314826965,
0.562793493270874,
-0.07431738078594208,
-0.19240893423557281,
0.1626325100660324,
-0.30205944180488586,
-0.07660125195980072,
-0.2504005432128906,
-0.1902940273284912,
0.15961816906929016,
-0.3076589107513428,
0.12487234175205231,
0.41894397139549255,
0.2669229805469513,
0.03797969967126846,
-0.28851982951164246,
0.5369935035705566,
0.3790268898010254,
-0.42401623725891113,
0.29924339056015015,
0.6635035276412964,
0.23832276463508606,
-0.8575835227966309,
0.6022701859474182,
0.3824034035205841,
-0.21198174357414246,
-0.5575703978538513,
-0.4336520731449127,
-0.23866774141788483,
-0.4869503676891327,
-0.03792690858244896,
-0.7178505659103394,
-1.018771767616272,
0.3118424415588379,
-0.10586800426244736,
0.10358534008264542,
0.42586180567741394,
0.49864035844802856,
-0.12883269786834717,
0.9799865484237671,
0.11898978799581528,
0.4683200716972351,
0.33628618717193604,
-0.26964718103408813,
0.07356539368629456,
-1.2593035697937012,
-0.2908572554588318,
-0.4904729425907135,
0.1032375916838646,
-0.21827547252178192,
-0.927650511264801,
0.828070342540741,
0.39048200845718384,
-0.02805754356086254,
-0.02673613466322422,
-0.2705265283584595,
0.3791291117668152,
0.6684482097625732,
0.39518114924430847,
0.5759643912315369,
0.14486894011497498,
-0.1620604395866394,
0.15773361921310425,
-0.5340554714202881,
-0.45819687843322754,
1.1066290140151978,
0.0034328375477343798,
0.7019356489181519,
0.2638387680053711,
0.9126335978507996,
0.1599525362253189,
0.09963802248239517,
-0.36164095997810364,
0.7463582754135132,
0.08346585184335709,
-0.6698878407478333,
-0.4666564464569092,
-0.6288008093833923,
-0.9978445172309875,
0.5651936531066895,
-0.19924715161323547,
-0.43787240982055664,
0.09682194888591766,
0.009587576612830162,
-0.43664342164993286,
0.2471863180398941,
-0.32306551933288574,
0.33283552527427673,
0.009772743098437786,
-0.33744195103645325,
0.05741940438747406,
-0.5120872259140015,
0.4794606864452362,
-0.19520577788352966,
-0.1714487373828888,
0.2011382281780243,
-0.29946261644363403,
0.507603645324707,
-0.5382179021835327,
0.3011348843574524,
-0.3271738886833191,
-0.2810467779636383,
0.7760284543037415,
0.03702779486775398,
0.6637566089630127,
0.08736051619052887,
-0.09148649126291275,
-0.4436013996601105,
-0.04573353752493858,
-0.309256374835968,
-0.9310933351516724,
0.554787814617157,
-0.3897305428981781,
-0.8581716418266296,
-0.14199946820735931,
-0.5871974229812622,
-0.5608432292938232,
0.08981682360172272,
-0.03275483846664429,
0.590338945388794,
-0.030022932216525078,
0.11408542096614838,
0.8333470225334167,
-0.3568181097507477,
0.17879919707775116,
0.5604742169380188,
-0.34354591369628906,
-0.7599524259567261,
0.7996172904968262,
0.12263154238462448,
0.45494234561920166,
0.5881794095039368,
0.12128981947898865,
-0.7754924297332764,
-0.7033188939094543,
-0.7141014933586121,
0.3114885985851288,
-0.601542055606842,
-0.25861847400665283,
-0.6866694092750549,
-0.29875677824020386,
-0.734737753868103,
0.291068971157074,
0.09276845306158066,
-0.6192648410797119,
-0.2721051573753357,
0.1421166956424713,
0.2441454976797104,
0.32285138964653015,
0.09288094192743301,
-0.02565828524529934,
-1.0776714086532593,
0.7421548962593079,
0.4959232807159424,
0.08977638930082321,
-0.022167440503835678,
-0.7172784209251404,
-0.16000047326087952,
0.20952793955802917,
-0.48475363850593567,
-0.8457041382789612,
0.2663465738296509,
0.25418660044670105,
0.5712358951568604,
-0.06176132708787918,
0.4746685326099396,
0.8058798909187317,
-0.5483582019805908,
0.9030691981315613,
-0.2571028172969818,
-0.5023033022880554,
0.6167059540748596,
-0.20018525421619415,
0.27661705017089844,
0.5251289010047913,
0.33196404576301575,
0.06439905613660812,
-0.4829900562763214,
-0.4389079809188843,
-0.8787187337875366,
0.6233189702033997,
0.3917402923107147,
0.14467380940914154,
-0.04457984119653702,
0.5803149938583374,
0.06516881287097931,
0.1577150970697403,
-0.3106967806816101,
-0.3033674359321594,
0.1429966539144516,
0.06518100202083588,
0.1218697652220726,
-0.16350658237934113,
-0.06769169867038727,
-0.0867837443947792,
0.8398017287254333,
-0.22048485279083252,
0.12594327330589294,
0.6472051739692688,
-0.23578734695911407,
-0.37934255599975586,
0.4366888999938965,
0.31760936975479126,
0.6618322134017944,
-0.2864398658275604,
-0.05760861188173294,
0.2270277589559555,
-0.5781235694885254,
0.1763828694820404,
0.21924282610416412,
-0.5058954954147339,
-0.1106075718998909,
-0.03606119379401207,
0.5112925171852112,
-0.48578977584838867,
-0.7793103456497192,
0.36466914415359497,
0.13959059119224548,
-0.14580078423023224,
-0.1540767103433609,
0.1151401475071907,
-0.1807592213153839,
0.44738271832466125,
0.7190871238708496,
-0.17006736993789673,
0.24043385684490204,
-0.6210298538208008,
0.2249993085861206,
0.5894612073898315,
-0.12638385593891144,
0.11029723286628723,
0.745663046836853,
0.1469273716211319,
-0.3428060710430145,
0.2905504107475281,
-0.25103092193603516,
-0.35620349645614624,
0.32345837354660034,
0.6154952049255371,
0.8920296430587769,
-0.19312839210033417,
0.16305504739284515,
0.24532774090766907,
0.22218827903270721,
0.3255749046802521,
0.8498683571815491,
-0.25431424379348755,
-0.5220292210578918,
-0.7508106827735901,
-0.7933186292648315,
-0.5783003568649292,
0.20493711531162262,
-0.6537022590637207,
-0.16379466652870178,
-0.013251569122076035,
0.015583815984427929,
-0.3149603605270386,
0.06179177388548851,
-0.36027786135673523,
0.5215826034545898,
-0.13917328417301178,
1.0759119987487793,
-0.1354718953371048,
0.5448869466781616,
0.9921830296516418,
-0.6130965352058411,
-0.8723116517066956,
0.3530455529689789,
-0.6724175810813904,
-0.5001683831214905,
0.4365691542625427,
-0.2845590114593506,
-0.24208112061023712,
0.2193690836429596,
-0.24079649150371552,
-0.7830157279968262,
0.9978373646736145,
0.16954627633094788,
-0.03705500438809395,
-0.13590529561042786,
0.3708774745464325,
0.5382790565490723,
-0.2923222482204437,
0.2294446974992752,
0.35098016262054443,
0.2678838074207306,
0.2719968557357788,
-0.5892126560211182,
0.2603533864021301,
-0.19276179373264313,
-0.0842772051692009,
0.4746409058570862,
-0.2440348118543625,
0.9264547228813171,
-0.13723842799663544,
-0.21479317545890808,
0.3462330102920532,
0.8505766987800598,
0.4484178423881531,
0.3578890860080719,
0.6435506939888,
0.4263606071472168,
0.560470700263977,
0.15693923830986023,
0.891714334487915,
-0.2689967453479767,
0.06302005797624588,
1.1471723318099976,
-0.19145022332668304,
1.0968879461288452,
0.5426573157310486,
-0.05464742332696915,
0.37636125087738037,
0.37108883261680603,
0.6461519002914429,
0.5551232099533081,
0.0937073677778244,
-0.5854170918464661,
-0.26675575971603394,
-0.0460381880402565,
-0.425692081451416,
0.337954044342041,
0.28868886828422546,
-0.29428842663764954,
-0.3584969937801361,
0.16391293704509735,
-0.2735407054424286,
0.2153603881597519,
-0.5135586261749268,
0.9963621497154236,
0.028385356068611145,
-1.2570998668670654,
0.6959093809127808,
-0.04470672830939293,
0.15981511771678925,
-0.4674830436706543,
-0.25191715359687805,
-0.5080378651618958,
-0.016226589679718018,
-0.06638038903474808,
-0.8953563570976257,
0.21272727847099304,
0.05220146104693413,
-0.05710005760192871,
-0.28347814083099365,
0.9611931443214417,
-0.7121478915214539,
-0.16781754791736603,
-0.02756393328309059,
1.0655546188354492,
0.20554055273532867,
-0.45909568667411804,
-0.46270933747291565,
-0.39671650528907776,
0.005585487931966782,
-0.3169342875480652,
0.3008986711502075,
0.5948289632797241,
0.01149604469537735,
0.39173004031181335,
0.5909590125083923,
0.11496477574110031,
0.35735341906547546,
0.03194457292556763,
1.1244215965270996,
-0.6213036179542542,
-0.30851221084594727,
-0.4225224554538727,
0.5555996298789978,
-0.12669751048088074,
-0.2612132728099823,
0.8771429657936096,
0.6098370552062988,
0.7203251123428345,
-0.16213394701480865,
0.6391481757164001,
-0.00014226204075384885,
1.0026129484176636,
-0.8181895613670349,
0.3640899658203125,
-0.944227933883667,
0.3875516355037689,
-0.15265046060085297,
-0.9688727855682373,
-0.014470178633928299,
-0.0004536431224551052,
-0.1823914796113968,
0.020006977021694183,
0.5040106177330017,
0.9892494678497314,
-0.03155554458498955,
-0.02370915748178959,
0.23033614456653595,
-0.06640702486038208,
0.2115979641675949,
0.3181544542312622,
1.0667682886123657,
-0.39551910758018494,
0.8170336484909058,
-0.23811325430870056,
-0.1693722903728485,
-0.11113397777080536,
-0.49280673265457153,
-0.7401154041290283,
-0.5577576756477356,
-0.20168717205524445,
-0.4179210662841797,
0.05006176233291626,
0.8441212177276611,
0.3049493134021759,
-0.5394294261932373,
0.09269104897975922,
0.028152218088507652,
0.07348378747701645,
-0.2514965534210205,
-0.2549116015434265,
0.46841466426849365,
-0.6682000160217285,
-0.8876202702522278,
0.785207211971283,
0.0957353413105011,
-0.091680608689785,
-0.4826430082321167,
0.028003619983792305,
-0.41331836581230164,
0.4661451280117035,
0.798534631729126,
0.30239206552505493,
-0.5593268871307373,
-0.12415847927331924,
0.35109272599220276,
-0.024631477892398834,
0.11231518536806107,
0.8288279175758362,
-0.9445081353187561,
0.515663206577301,
0.7652516961097717,
0.8089321255683899,
0.6399486660957336,
0.5899544358253479,
0.4317348599433899,
-1.1232980489730835,
-0.39856523275375366,
0.5828742980957031,
0.10702726989984512,
0.12272082269191742,
-0.30172786116600037,
0.5701693892478943,
0.045460574328899384,
-0.5623980164527893,
-0.7863171100616455,
0.2428513914346695,
-0.8908656239509583,
-0.3891175389289856,
1.2559260129928589,
-0.09586302191019058,
-0.22354841232299805,
-0.18577457964420319,
-0.5922302603721619,
0.07537177205085754,
-0.12333200126886368,
0.3183939754962921,
0.12780222296714783,
-0.3469330668449402,
-0.026410602033138275,
-0.4029386639595032,
0.4450105130672455,
0.44174835085868835,
-0.8668508529663086,
-0.15651942789554596,
0.6108062863349915,
0.07043039798736572,
0.2211778610944748,
0.7503793239593506,
-0.3799298405647278,
0.3051716387271881,
-0.13839399814605713,
-0.1427135318517685,
-0.23579083383083344,
-0.23688729107379913,
-0.07696016132831573,
0.6364355087280273,
0.010510380379855633,
-0.4412465989589691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14275v1 | Step-Back Profiling: Distilling User History for Personalized Scientific Writing | 2024-06-20T12:58:26 | 2024-06-20T12:58:26 | Xiangru Tang, Xingyao Zhang, Yanjun Shao, Jie Wu, Yilun Zhao, Arman Cohan, Ming Gong, Dongmei Zhang, Mark Gerstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) excel at a variety of natural language
processing tasks, yet they struggle to generate personalized content for
individuals, particularly in real-world scenarios like scientific writing.
Addressing this challenge, we introduce Step-Back Profiling to personalize LLMs
by distilling user history into concise profiles, including essential traits
and preferences of users. Regarding our experiments, we construct a
Personalized Scientific Writing (PSW) dataset to study multiuser
personalization. PSW requires the models to write scientific papers given
specialized author groups with diverse academic backgrounds. As for the
results, we demonstrate the effectiveness of capturing user characteristics via
Step-Back Profiling for collaborative writing. Moreover, our approach
outperforms the baselines by up to 3.6 points on the general personalization
benchmark (LaMP), including 7 personalization LLM tasks. Our extensive ablation
studies validate the contributions of different components in our method and
provide insights into our task definition. Our dataset and code are available
at \url{https://github.com/gersteinlab/step-back-profiling}. | [
-0.25429511070251465,
-0.509827733039856,
0.671250581741333,
0.2802203297615051,
0.2943074107170105,
0.575698733329773,
-0.25568103790283203,
-0.3493480682373047,
0.18710920214653015,
0.8220821619033813,
-0.6964948773384094,
-0.8671666979789734,
-0.42017027735710144,
0.4652847349643707,
-0.6236346960067749,
1.395372986793518,
-0.05126318335533142,
-0.13778379559516907,
-0.46706947684288025,
-0.07250084728002548,
-0.16167506575584412,
-0.5097740292549133,
-0.7010283470153809,
-0.4320426285266876,
1.0538772344589233,
0.5929462313652039,
0.30782350897789,
0.5823255777359009,
0.4520327150821686,
0.30856025218963623,
-0.05811523273587227,
0.03733176365494728,
-0.6877994537353516,
0.5597398281097412,
-0.2611271142959595,
-0.18153928220272064,
-0.3751677870750427,
0.15228432416915894,
0.571122944355011,
0.9232087135314941,
-0.016607040539383888,
0.3537060022354126,
0.04329236224293709,
0.6019479632377625,
-0.397591769695282,
-0.19344812631607056,
-0.3010013699531555,
-0.009712891653180122,
-0.36294040083885193,
-0.3035998046398163,
-0.5097493529319763,
-0.6458044052124023,
0.010991732589900494,
-0.6415500044822693,
0.9005333781242371,
0.27159592509269714,
0.4365018904209137,
-0.06259975582361221,
-0.42602625489234924,
-0.3779028058052063,
-0.9364646077156067,
0.7763355374336243,
-0.7266591191291809,
0.23420123755931854,
0.3296830952167511,
0.07882252335548401,
-0.09800581634044647,
-0.9450629949569702,
-0.5283807516098022,
-0.4575318396091461,
-0.22321772575378418,
-0.12434706836938858,
0.09763351082801819,
-0.1466459333896637,
0.4467228055000305,
0.3900024890899658,
-0.5941106081008911,
0.17852886021137238,
-0.589935839176178,
-0.32812386751174927,
0.704571008682251,
0.3567888140678406,
0.13107571005821228,
0.2659752666950226,
-0.11367401480674744,
-0.04869812726974487,
-0.6012938618659973,
0.13871526718139648,
0.64211505651474,
0.4474567770957947,
0.08154426515102386,
0.6603941321372986,
-0.38287243247032166,
0.40197569131851196,
0.14198824763298035,
-0.21774469316005707,
0.26613926887512207,
-0.7984796166419983,
0.10475397109985352,
0.031178854405879974,
0.8688187003135681,
0.22794632613658905,
0.17737022042274475,
-0.2913087010383606,
0.06004573032259941,
-0.4349762201309204,
0.2078433632850647,
-1.153552532196045,
-0.5192078351974487,
0.08306093513965607,
-0.2595151960849762,
-0.32958972454071045,
0.0866270363330841,
-0.8018434643745422,
-0.8474599719047546,
-0.22627709805965424,
-0.019495172426104546,
-0.33663201332092285,
0.15406402945518494,
-0.09420239180326462,
-0.09409712255001068,
-0.39977747201919556,
0.385305792093277,
-1.000442385673523,
0.6404791474342346,
0.6944910287857056,
1.117256999015808,
-0.42713624238967896,
-0.6113251447677612,
-0.7989928722381592,
0.23956900835037231,
0.039138052612543106,
0.4337134063243866,
-0.5771617889404297,
-0.6355670690536499,
-0.1008853167295456,
-0.25376027822494507,
0.23325040936470032,
-0.33751827478408813,
0.3055190443992615,
-0.46439260244369507,
0.4097839295864105,
-0.6790065169334412,
-0.3655240535736084,
-0.027386942878365517,
-0.0043233889155089855,
-0.5197452306747437,
1.0475075244903564,
0.12696364521980286,
-0.738629162311554,
0.5546424984931946,
-0.6523923873901367,
-0.6374295353889465,
0.13787764310836792,
-0.0879768431186676,
-0.5349817872047424,
0.18131335079669952,
0.029031680896878242,
0.7398075461387634,
0.02910814993083477,
0.37893474102020264,
-0.43944284319877625,
-0.338899701833725,
0.07325689494609833,
0.1767110526561737,
0.5407498478889465,
0.13821913301944733,
-0.005542972590774298,
0.2700991630554199,
-1.1290221214294434,
-0.3994968831539154,
0.0028141443617641926,
-0.6307883858680725,
-0.3157847225666046,
0.045222897082567215,
0.0636659786105156,
0.25829553604125977,
0.5108609795570374,
-0.9437706470489502,
0.25249233841896057,
-0.22139839828014374,
0.393174946308136,
0.5976254940032959,
-0.007564902771264315,
0.2830038070678711,
-0.3171563148498535,
0.49921491742134094,
-0.10975277423858643,
-0.3560608923435211,
-0.3320203125476837,
-0.23333075642585754,
-0.41010382771492004,
-0.40407562255859375,
0.015007362700998783,
0.4343283474445343,
-0.13977956771850586,
0.531390905380249,
-0.07318636775016785,
-0.3663399815559387,
-0.38469719886779785,
0.6787019371986389,
0.5539027452468872,
1.0484042167663574,
0.36261075735092163,
-0.39272990822792053,
-0.617277204990387,
-0.8379789590835571,
-0.444324254989624,
-0.11673641949892044,
-0.4221329987049103,
0.38049423694610596,
0.5012922286987305,
-0.1866912692785263,
0.8849707245826721,
-0.8145748972892761,
-0.2004731148481369,
-0.315212607383728,
0.5138315558433533,
0.22958391904830933,
0.22566737234592438,
0.2017214000225067,
-0.6177895665168762,
-0.5503305792808533,
0.03441425412893295,
-0.3902569115161896,
-0.4567340016365051,
-0.37056851387023926,
-0.0034048878587782383,
-0.11508544534444809,
0.5544237494468689,
-0.35004734992980957,
0.13204985857009888,
0.5751432180404663,
-0.5732025504112244,
0.5423498749732971,
-0.3400821089744568,
0.21947920322418213,
-1.1124136447906494,
0.6020232439041138,
0.4592219889163971,
-0.3133001923561096,
-0.7253175973892212,
-0.1247292086482048,
-0.19228775799274445,
0.025479638949036598,
-0.16469784080982208,
0.508770227432251,
-0.3431054949760437,
0.011930801905691624,
-0.20092496275901794,
-0.03542085364460945,
0.027330182492733,
0.23002320528030396,
-0.0488194115459919,
0.5505625009536743,
0.24020472168922424,
-0.3711554706096649,
0.20398816466331482,
0.45680364966392517,
0.03601394221186638,
0.4153074622154236,
-0.6319612264633179,
0.38268810510635376,
-0.11097501963376999,
0.3585655987262726,
-1.3150715827941895,
-0.3410896062850952,
0.03454630449414253,
-0.2025824338197708,
0.19746457040309906,
0.07014664262533188,
-0.49794745445251465,
-0.1959955394268036,
-0.626797080039978,
0.033537328243255615,
0.35943061113357544,
-0.43133673071861267,
0.6328709721565247,
-0.032207854092121124,
-0.6211084127426147,
-0.32853591442108154,
-0.4887024462223053,
0.2649519443511963,
-0.25283053517341614,
-0.6670218706130981,
0.6722657680511475,
-0.4248332381248474,
-0.31008508801460266,
-0.3048974275588989,
0.009735867381095886,
0.09993559122085571,
0.025339748710393906,
0.456604540348053,
0.13940945267677307,
-0.0028379030991345644,
-0.0956931933760643,
0.1262018382549286,
-0.05805419385433197,
-0.016132470220327377,
0.1865144819021225,
0.6936758160591125,
0.0877261832356453,
-0.07735267281532288,
-0.4378778338432312,
0.5176161527633667,
0.35411563515663147,
-0.13301071524620056,
0.6153764724731445,
0.8914195895195007,
-0.009285490028560162,
-0.15778575837612152,
-0.6400194764137268,
-0.32911404967308044,
-0.5146973133087158,
0.3630883991718292,
-0.15513531863689423,
-1.1631102561950684,
0.6436502933502197,
-0.03705454245209694,
0.4389474093914032,
0.2286059558391571,
0.7437583804130554,
-0.31092023849487305,
0.8616616725921631,
0.9526987075805664,
-0.1650070697069168,
0.39155733585357666,
0.11911501735448837,
0.11438369750976562,
-0.7883198261260986,
-0.384723424911499,
-0.625792920589447,
-0.649781346321106,
-0.33694350719451904,
0.19037172198295593,
0.05908649414777756,
-0.04048795998096466,
-0.2189551591873169,
0.2586286962032318,
-0.48594236373901367,
0.3689505457878113,
0.6561728715896606,
-0.07788357883691788,
0.6659952402114868,
-0.15628249943256378,
0.028258049860596657,
-0.16404496133327484,
-0.07383603602647781,
-0.6064074635505676,
1.105831265449524,
0.2662072479724884,
0.8097125291824341,
-0.22007547318935394,
1.2028883695602417,
0.3470708131790161,
0.33384907245635986,
-0.4592649042606354,
0.6347946524620056,
-0.23994094133377075,
-0.4822024703025818,
-0.4813212454319,
-0.383651465177536,
-0.611838161945343,
0.187158465385437,
-0.046278201043605804,
-0.8660973906517029,
0.027142897248268127,
0.5972443222999573,
-0.5457426309585571,
0.15974335372447968,
-0.6052606105804443,
0.6339436173439026,
-0.16649676859378815,
-0.4215509295463562,
-0.20556581020355225,
-0.9583340883255005,
0.32250016927719116,
-0.35854706168174744,
0.029727566987276077,
-0.042691998183727264,
-0.13725878298282623,
0.8312738537788391,
-0.24405242502689362,
1.111472249031067,
-0.12477081269025803,
0.1515774428844452,
-0.3196448087692261,
0.22414186596870422,
0.5398386120796204,
0.09449094533920288,
-0.07030605524778366,
0.15446428954601288,
0.011553979478776455,
-0.08093775808811188,
-0.22930361330509186,
1.1791651248931885,
-0.45811647176742554,
-0.5433781743049622,
-0.42703893780708313,
-0.5443164706230164,
-0.3553912043571472,
0.3878307640552521,
0.35105273127555847,
0.013149922713637352,
-0.3271491229534149,
0.20879195630550385,
0.5661750435829163,
-0.09124144911766052,
0.5680088400840759,
0.8301950693130493,
-0.21310298144817352,
-0.2527182400226593,
0.8471185564994812,
-0.14632217586040497,
-0.04154941067099571,
0.28056058287620544,
0.4801723062992096,
-0.24728795886039734,
-1.1143754720687866,
-0.11464974284172058,
0.5154831409454346,
-0.5259301662445068,
0.2073427140712738,
-0.8702076077461243,
0.09928540885448456,
-0.5089924335479736,
-0.43986085057258606,
-0.16546550393104553,
-0.16721884906291962,
-0.6611606478691101,
-0.14270849525928497,
0.20849958062171936,
0.8376495838165283,
0.2296764999628067,
0.2729615867137909,
-0.6333069801330566,
0.49979010224342346,
-0.09752541035413742,
0.17301273345947266,
-0.17811676859855652,
-0.4876466989517212,
-0.18480204045772552,
-0.3354514539241791,
-0.44809490442276,
-0.5754873752593994,
0.540556788444519,
0.4438434839248657,
0.38440611958503723,
0.18706078827381134,
-0.2697429656982422,
0.5254549384117126,
-0.6058947443962097,
0.8047686219215393,
0.2329414337873459,
-0.9126959443092346,
0.49441173672676086,
-0.17176412045955658,
0.26389291882514954,
1.0774564743041992,
0.6863244771957397,
-0.9168681502342224,
-0.4454101026058197,
-0.23023176193237305,
-1.0410462617874146,
0.5857408046722412,
-0.14067210257053375,
0.010064862668514252,
0.4628603756427765,
0.5485386252403259,
0.6438695192337036,
0.4082672595977783,
-0.6359100937843323,
-0.007923020049929619,
0.05505341663956642,
-0.24725142121315002,
-0.6218153238296509,
-0.196421280503273,
-0.30198028683662415,
-0.35053569078445435,
0.4813952147960663,
-0.1708383709192276,
-0.5040252804756165,
0.20371216535568237,
0.011231571435928345,
-0.13100109994411469,
0.11369045078754425,
0.675241231918335,
0.9586527347564697,
-0.31589892506599426,
0.11145314574241638,
-0.03284893557429314,
-0.6457916498184204,
-0.18324843049049377,
0.25882989168167114,
-0.3129505217075348,
-0.15048737823963165,
0.45492011308670044,
0.4130484163761139,
0.11545155197381973,
-0.5171383023262024,
0.32364484667778015,
-0.04070209711790085,
-0.2592761516571045,
-0.24968312680721283,
0.2117416113615036,
0.3209250569343567,
0.10616153478622437,
0.35883617401123047,
0.21794427931308746,
0.37288734316825867,
-0.43688270449638367,
0.06573038548231125,
0.2389221340417862,
-0.11914641410112381,
-0.7286195755004883,
0.8134377002716064,
0.19784225523471832,
-0.37450724840164185,
0.4846002459526062,
0.11632195115089417,
0.0022305729798972607,
0.1269148737192154,
0.5479205250740051,
0.9172484278678894,
-0.2553004324436188,
0.3208800256252289,
0.2024558186531067,
-0.17966461181640625,
-0.11984381824731827,
0.19259965419769287,
-0.23428598046302795,
-0.5071768760681152,
-0.35900983214378357,
-0.8465794324874878,
-0.6066523194313049,
0.11465740948915482,
-0.6387717723846436,
0.35304027795791626,
-0.6753407716751099,
0.024703897535800934,
0.4357146620750427,
0.13548283278942108,
-0.6744864583015442,
0.02782629244029522,
0.03694363310933113,
0.4374832212924957,
-1.1218467950820923,
0.6898175477981567,
0.6793844103813171,
-0.2784980237483978,
-0.08322110772132874,
-0.20837970077991486,
0.4734761416912079,
-0.4972902834415436,
0.7453046441078186,
0.11367784440517426,
-0.3216100335121155,
-0.03669343516230583,
-0.6026607751846313,
-0.7385770082473755,
1.3322948217391968,
0.15171390771865845,
-0.9580827355384827,
-0.1636461466550827,
0.04469926655292511,
0.9436820149421692,
-0.5193130970001221,
-0.08847489207983017,
0.716364860534668,
0.36537471413612366,
0.379537969827652,
-0.63921719789505,
0.2993132472038269,
-0.14077861607074738,
-0.058147065341472626,
0.07654707133769989,
-0.5573545694351196,
0.8992241024971008,
-0.36715880036354065,
-0.08941192179918289,
-0.027709346264600754,
0.6244072318077087,
0.3684014678001404,
0.6889975666999817,
0.27572715282440186,
0.3849520683288574,
0.9395471811294556,
0.21475113928318024,
0.9805245399475098,
-0.17604859173297882,
-0.027630755677819252,
1.1843183040618896,
-0.5907294750213623,
0.677854597568512,
0.6946629881858826,
-0.13341526687145233,
0.469627320766449,
0.3632730543613434,
-0.2119562178850174,
0.378930002450943,
0.3437768220901489,
-0.26756492257118225,
0.06670600920915604,
0.06889328360557556,
-0.11377343535423279,
0.14156155288219452,
-0.06564753502607346,
-0.6832436323165894,
-0.05330958217382431,
-0.047823186963796616,
0.41544556617736816,
0.19503583014011383,
0.01315875444561243,
0.7826188206672668,
-0.013224733993411064,
-0.5628468990325928,
-0.00999307632446289,
-0.03253219276666641,
0.8620544075965881,
-0.7694864273071289,
0.08641883730888367,
-0.3653351962566376,
0.1469949334859848,
-0.541102945804596,
-0.8176862597465515,
0.23800474405288696,
0.19260478019714355,
-0.39767736196517944,
-0.7562977075576782,
0.5129545331001282,
-0.5027743577957153,
-0.5549597144126892,
-0.0031382020097225904,
0.32496899366378784,
0.1637164056301117,
0.017493125051259995,
-0.24114184081554413,
0.08340784907341003,
0.13744279742240906,
-0.5271843671798706,
0.4656949043273926,
-0.18725499510765076,
-0.022181691601872444,
0.7121734023094177,
0.8448060750961304,
0.49805060029029846,
-0.08628277480602264,
0.2788430452346802,
0.8828516602516174,
-0.9022634029388428,
-0.4002764821052551,
-1.203016996383667,
0.5818969011306763,
-0.27253538370132446,
-0.8887920379638672,
1.0363298654556274,
0.9299813508987427,
0.8725281953811646,
-0.07659363746643066,
0.9402691125869751,
0.04640074074268341,
1.0013375282287598,
-0.31985926628112793,
0.7178714871406555,
-0.3092222213745117,
0.3826511800289154,
-0.28733518719673157,
-0.8232638239860535,
-0.41977253556251526,
0.08546639233827591,
-0.2181667536497116,
0.08568815886974335,
0.5569941401481628,
0.6213744282722473,
0.10961485654115677,
-0.08710000663995743,
0.1448100507259369,
0.19605112075805664,
0.7798498272895813,
0.2779816687107086,
0.6632480025291443,
0.29328715801239014,
0.36340364813804626,
-0.5500149130821228,
-0.31624776124954224,
-0.23387525975704193,
-1.057279109954834,
-1.1588106155395508,
-0.6641234755516052,
-0.557257890701294,
-0.28946325182914734,
-0.07873871177434921,
0.6456193923950195,
0.5205962657928467,
-1.138405442237854,
-0.2898155450820923,
0.007046620827168226,
-0.26708516478538513,
-0.0001728240167722106,
-0.1748199611902237,
0.12338472902774811,
-0.021284043788909912,
-0.6749757528305054,
0.4972708523273468,
0.4056311249732971,
-0.1289682686328888,
-0.7221685647964478,
0.007441855035722256,
0.15958422422409058,
-0.07980088144540787,
0.4861108362674713,
0.6519137620925903,
-0.582938551902771,
-0.1574419140815735,
0.04177243635058403,
-0.08803961426019669,
0.2309877574443817,
1.2837629318237305,
-0.5479661822319031,
0.4518760144710541,
0.6933743357658386,
0.33841341733932495,
0.9223010540008545,
0.42023923993110657,
0.575643002986908,
-1.026434302330017,
-0.42340296506881714,
0.5345118641853333,
0.21471941471099854,
0.5848947167396545,
-0.6991539597511292,
0.2304837852716446,
0.20684659481048584,
-0.7818394899368286,
-0.8045079112052917,
-0.007536826189607382,
-1.1569483280181885,
-0.11805471032857895,
1.045031189918518,
-0.25477293133735657,
0.2157646268606186,
-0.11766408383846283,
-0.34843724966049194,
-0.015118307434022427,
-0.5897108912467957,
0.9613066911697388,
0.8916292786598206,
-0.6458365321159363,
0.009458406828343868,
-0.22804991900920868,
0.5733233690261841,
0.030796030536293983,
-0.8611716628074646,
0.21841636300086975,
0.7371842265129089,
0.554612398147583,
0.24889327585697174,
0.7187891602516174,
0.10642310976982117,
-0.1908106803894043,
-0.16127021610736847,
0.027533721178770065,
-0.5923481583595276,
-0.4477950930595398,
-0.37987926602363586,
0.5745745301246643,
-0.031839288771152496,
0.13576166331768036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14267v1 | On the Evaluation Practices in Multilingual NLP: Can Machine Translation Offer an Alternative to Human Translations? | 2024-06-20T12:46:12 | 2024-06-20T12:46:12 | Rochelle Choenni, Sara Rajaee, Christof Monz, Ekaterina Shutova | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While multilingual language models (MLMs) have been trained on 100+
languages, they are typically only evaluated across a handful of them due to a
lack of available test data in most languages. This is particularly problematic
when assessing MLM's potential for low-resource and unseen languages. In this
paper, we present an analysis of existing evaluation frameworks in multilingual
NLP, discuss their limitations, and propose several directions for more robust
and reliable evaluation practices. Furthermore, we empirically study to what
extent machine translation offers a {reliable alternative to human translation}
for large-scale evaluation of MLMs across a wide set of languages. We use a
SOTA translation model to translate test data from 4 tasks to 198 languages and
use them to evaluate three MLMs. We show that while the selected subsets of
high-resource test languages are generally sufficiently representative of a
wider range of high-resource languages, we tend to overestimate MLMs' ability
on low-resource languages. Finally, we show that simpler baselines can achieve
relatively strong performance without having benefited from large-scale
multilingual pretraining. | [
-0.3437885344028473,
-0.3722352385520935,
0.2597109079360962,
0.5314451456069946,
0.10375411808490753,
0.0005929441540502012,
-0.7237673997879028,
-0.4399842917919159,
-0.15007749199867249,
0.49356937408447266,
-0.6305906772613525,
-0.07067257165908813,
-0.618388295173645,
0.5803049802780151,
-0.18800731003284454,
1.19046151638031,
-0.2160295844078064,
0.5788350105285645,
-0.22900959849357605,
-0.5994007587432861,
-0.41506004333496094,
-0.8474381566047668,
-0.6352484822273254,
-0.481838583946228,
0.4404410421848297,
0.28979361057281494,
0.8224533796310425,
0.18603037297725677,
0.7598137855529785,
0.3119145929813385,
0.100001759827137,
0.17951950430870056,
-0.36058536171913147,
-0.19532114267349243,
-0.09577588737010956,
-0.49978169798851013,
-0.280862420797348,
0.2716369330883026,
0.918249249458313,
0.9524242281913757,
0.05122147873044014,
0.4773963391780853,
0.23584674298763275,
0.8048744797706604,
-0.6521531343460083,
-0.04158071056008339,
-0.475378155708313,
0.47667396068573,
0.05230492353439331,
-0.10309495031833649,
-0.5097293853759766,
-0.19293159246444702,
0.10253500193357468,
-0.2546994686126709,
-0.24272693693637848,
0.08806104212999344,
0.6658453941345215,
0.09901245683431625,
-0.28665071725845337,
-0.28606706857681274,
-0.7253894805908203,
1.1154228448867798,
-0.597639262676239,
0.585411012172699,
0.5941371917724609,
0.5476458072662354,
0.09101356565952301,
-0.39857786893844604,
-0.3219083845615387,
-0.6018414497375488,
-0.09103900194168091,
0.10715997964143753,
-0.135713592171669,
-0.23317313194274902,
0.21595442295074463,
0.34825068712234497,
-0.6989549398422241,
0.16216641664505005,
-0.1254379153251648,
-0.031701862812042236,
0.4449363946914673,
0.08233342319726944,
0.46179771423339844,
-0.25135931372642517,
-0.6105126738548279,
-0.18544000387191772,
-0.5939549207687378,
0.04172796383500099,
0.36311930418014526,
0.41160011291503906,
0.04389267787337303,
0.6464085578918457,
0.20470131933689117,
0.6199100613594055,
-0.47128432989120483,
-0.19921694695949554,
0.32258692383766174,
-0.6946263909339905,
-0.40594765543937683,
-0.2754795551300049,
0.8455550074577332,
0.4902324080467224,
0.3913334906101227,
-0.47917047142982483,
-0.3038085699081421,
0.12952552735805511,
0.18556703627109528,
-0.6239543557167053,
0.21878978610038757,
0.07721360772848129,
-0.7374802231788635,
0.11590253561735153,
-0.20654092729091644,
-0.5810076594352722,
-0.29377031326293945,
-0.12350159138441086,
0.3744353950023651,
-0.3576183617115021,
-0.3548925220966339,
0.2188856601715088,
-0.10139554738998413,
0.1433916985988617,
-0.06272511929273605,
-0.6986829042434692,
0.5638156533241272,
0.4133332669734955,
0.8000091910362244,
-0.28395992517471313,
-0.7956367135047913,
-0.6398146748542786,
-0.3620780110359192,
-0.5646892189979553,
0.34132933616638184,
-0.4285123944282532,
-0.2156364768743515,
0.0011693064589053392,
0.10501634329557419,
-0.18677639961242676,
-0.8001220226287842,
0.5367909669876099,
-0.5724199414253235,
0.26535123586654663,
-0.25125953555107117,
-0.24782244861125946,
-0.1969067007303238,
0.5094179511070251,
-0.6696742177009583,
1.0317115783691406,
0.14960698783397675,
-0.4844701588153839,
0.4277813136577606,
-0.8019118905067444,
-0.4151535928249359,
-0.07449319213628769,
0.11417359113693237,
-0.2792264521121979,
0.021891191601753235,
0.1546705663204193,
0.3659256100654602,
-0.3941231667995453,
0.2314336746931076,
-0.29130297899246216,
-0.5180172920227051,
0.29215168952941895,
-0.7161034345626831,
0.9584285020828247,
0.5048666596412659,
-0.4515381157398224,
0.09061349183320999,
-0.5517662167549133,
0.3766935169696808,
0.06394414603710175,
-0.6173499822616577,
-0.2161281704902649,
-0.2834472060203552,
0.38615721464157104,
0.6338903307914734,
0.05771421268582344,
-0.1890803873538971,
-0.0313136987388134,
-0.5698201656341553,
0.1396314650774002,
0.44861868023872375,
-0.5093960165977478,
0.6399282813072205,
-0.1924590915441513,
1.15689218044281,
-0.4090871810913086,
0.12518185377120972,
-0.21039903163909912,
-0.500899076461792,
-0.9554861187934875,
-0.009410877712070942,
0.5105626583099365,
0.7193094491958618,
-0.9328276515007019,
0.30951422452926636,
-0.30890408158302307,
-0.3366643488407135,
-0.9724304676055908,
0.5683680772781372,
0.7622399926185608,
0.02884313464164734,
0.43489164113998413,
-0.37404608726501465,
-0.7385174036026001,
-0.8888977766036987,
-0.576246440410614,
0.09854131937026978,
-0.059962354600429535,
0.005516188219189644,
0.5449005365371704,
-0.36483076214790344,
0.4667491316795349,
0.17205730080604553,
-0.26228731870651245,
-0.6268178224563599,
-0.06321539729833603,
0.26494476199150085,
0.39108604192733765,
0.6246159672737122,
-0.7430697083473206,
-0.5241065621376038,
0.1935471147298813,
-0.7239772081375122,
0.05861876904964447,
-0.20805640518665314,
0.04855186119675636,
0.35559672117233276,
0.2125755250453949,
-0.45470914244651794,
0.03433075174689293,
1.0339680910110474,
-0.19639089703559875,
0.6293154954910278,
-0.44302472472190857,
0.2412412166595459,
-0.7731766104698181,
0.33349937200546265,
-0.0683634877204895,
-0.4771643280982971,
-0.5919002294540405,
0.48486021161079407,
0.0354573130607605,
-0.20131666958332062,
-0.5948156118392944,
0.7465938925743103,
-0.43128645420074463,
-0.40063634514808655,
-0.24133732914924622,
0.24050955474376678,
0.13893091678619385,
0.3223939538002014,
0.15107892453670502,
0.7282805442810059,
0.20090511441230774,
-0.5734328031539917,
0.2170756310224533,
0.019222700968384743,
-0.6419564485549927,
0.43570467829704285,
-0.43137067556381226,
0.08578433096408844,
-0.03928065299987793,
0.24337857961654663,
-0.6505484580993652,
0.2428140491247177,
0.20667584240436554,
-0.23839910328388214,
0.1865292340517044,
-0.02669503167271614,
-0.6339820623397827,
-0.3620341718196869,
-0.21938437223434448,
0.27055448293685913,
0.30615079402923584,
-0.4542064964771271,
0.14010721445083618,
0.3286975622177124,
-0.2112516462802887,
-0.9347972273826599,
-0.9307564496994019,
0.5385152101516724,
-0.3258742094039917,
-0.44369983673095703,
-0.030635658651590347,
-0.15197251737117767,
-0.3519800901412964,
-0.20408087968826294,
0.06617917120456696,
-0.1748408079147339,
0.3927336037158966,
-0.09998399764299393,
0.12604525685310364,
-0.25738003849983215,
0.25050994753837585,
-0.3830864131450653,
-0.29691484570503235,
-0.09377627074718475,
-0.431438684463501,
0.5643519163131714,
-0.5977979302406311,
-0.6247455477714539,
-0.1796187460422516,
0.5648504495620728,
0.2590249478816986,
-0.45056450366973877,
0.6157841682434082,
0.8895058035850525,
-0.4708455204963684,
-0.044799208641052246,
-0.39483407139778137,
-0.03273969516158104,
-0.3421098291873932,
0.6400192975997925,
-0.5705201625823975,
-0.6046892404556274,
0.28834807872772217,
-0.10436031967401505,
0.10396221280097961,
0.5594037771224976,
0.818536102771759,
-0.2021181583404541,
1.1017611026763916,
0.6714346408843994,
0.03619229048490524,
0.24963748455047607,
-0.39748474955558777,
0.22978475689888,
-0.4577333331108093,
0.06921704113483429,
-0.5826611518859863,
-0.3149283230304718,
-0.6446931958198547,
-0.5600912570953369,
0.36360350251197815,
0.43230941891670227,
0.11598728597164154,
0.5075439214706421,
-0.0762484073638916,
0.4772423207759857,
0.46107080578804016,
-0.31434768438339233,
0.5431520342826843,
-0.0796009749174118,
-0.18824225664138794,
-0.3177829086780548,
-1.0238646268844604,
-1.0036203861236572,
1.0223230123519897,
0.42388275265693665,
0.2711775600910187,
0.09754237532615662,
0.3420396149158478,
0.07524403929710388,
0.6426746845245361,
-0.8202893733978271,
0.1095588207244873,
-0.32969558238983154,
-0.8421562314033508,
-0.4189954996109009,
-0.49077463150024414,
-1.0237929821014404,
0.6279854774475098,
-0.4084170460700989,
-0.44160357117652893,
-0.22207944095134735,
-0.03295420482754707,
-0.24781616032123566,
0.2752845287322998,
-0.9592132568359375,
1.291497826576233,
-0.6450151801109314,
0.002640728373080492,
-0.1648850440979004,
-0.5385387539863586,
0.33986157178878784,
-0.3379642069339752,
0.6120167970657349,
0.004268309101462364,
0.11983891576528549,
0.6583811640739441,
-0.23075096309185028,
0.5881822109222412,
-0.057016633450984955,
-0.11037629097700119,
0.12925566732883453,
0.01878025010228157,
0.2659829258918762,
-0.1187192052602768,
-0.3843555450439453,
0.21043263375759125,
0.22399792075157166,
-0.44734302163124084,
-0.7286394238471985,
0.4708281457424164,
-0.5007326602935791,
-0.24354329705238342,
-0.2251753956079483,
-0.4876196086406708,
-0.4209727942943573,
0.31759926676750183,
0.21273596584796906,
-0.008836880326271057,
-0.30688872933387756,
0.09088240563869476,
-0.031352680176496506,
-0.43764224648475647,
0.5112906694412231,
0.38316279649734497,
-0.44023436307907104,
-0.20384551584720612,
1.0241583585739136,
0.01820794679224491,
0.33968308568000793,
0.23156064748764038,
0.3560647666454315,
-0.6114351749420166,
-0.38346269726753235,
-0.9902061820030212,
-0.12038850784301758,
-0.8054347038269043,
0.10736224800348282,
-0.5228715538978577,
0.21208906173706055,
-0.18810148537158966,
0.004851382225751877,
-0.5999244451522827,
-0.4479687213897705,
0.28082704544067383,
-0.007950534112751484,
-0.2075689285993576,
0.5124329328536987,
0.004470161162316799,
0.018729470670223236,
-0.9523505568504333,
0.24551579356193542,
0.04710971191525459,
0.2074076235294342,
-0.04106196016073227,
-0.43304842710494995,
-0.5851631760597229,
0.19492599368095398,
-0.20988868176937103,
-0.5752716660499573,
0.37083789706230164,
0.2819969654083252,
0.6971863508224487,
0.17044587433338165,
-0.15720735490322113,
0.80427086353302,
-0.7735905051231384,
0.6078051328659058,
0.45458096265792847,
-0.9433858394622803,
0.22407536208629608,
-0.002642866689711809,
0.29172229766845703,
0.7149284482002258,
0.6367559432983398,
-0.8714948892593384,
-0.32370924949645996,
-0.32474327087402344,
-0.589239776134491,
0.5061829090118408,
0.21440523862838745,
0.41074851155281067,
0.13984818756580353,
-0.0047764102928340435,
0.2750280499458313,
0.3836376667022705,
-1.0805598497390747,
-0.3087579905986786,
-0.08195843547582626,
0.0725044384598732,
-0.7096403241157532,
-0.06500274688005447,
-0.18589521944522858,
-0.0786156952381134,
0.3754364848136902,
-0.10471250861883163,
-0.016697783023118973,
-0.12375420331954956,
-0.4114202857017517,
-0.009317873045802116,
0.641973614692688,
0.41104820370674133,
0.9238272905349731,
-0.12581999599933624,
0.14650070667266846,
0.4143192768096924,
-0.046307772397994995,
0.3432384133338928,
0.004340108018368483,
0.008605089038610458,
0.16127759218215942,
0.5745211243629456,
0.6305904984474182,
0.3811507523059845,
-0.906642735004425,
0.5732449889183044,
0.11079292744398117,
0.16949789226055145,
-0.18116553127765656,
-0.37515586614608765,
0.19228595495224,
0.10067429393529892,
0.11232917755842209,
0.24335460364818573,
0.16972047090530396,
-0.748235285282135,
0.21813327074050903,
0.4460330009460449,
-0.6736213564872742,
-0.23734663426876068,
0.5294331312179565,
0.1641916185617447,
-0.4397607445716858,
0.4558895528316498,
-0.3587905168533325,
-0.49914422631263733,
0.4370155930519104,
0.5568365454673767,
0.7861053943634033,
-0.2847568392753601,
0.13600625097751617,
0.08943641930818558,
0.7377600073814392,
-0.19675731658935547,
0.23611420392990112,
0.07133650034666061,
-0.7137274146080017,
-0.8923343420028687,
-0.7709574103355408,
-0.2969133257865906,
0.17845764756202698,
-0.6100908517837524,
0.31107938289642334,
-0.026906928047537804,
-0.4008808434009552,
-0.15454407036304474,
0.14394056797027588,
-0.9322812557220459,
0.18533185124397278,
0.026358991861343384,
0.9174271821975708,
-0.7599027752876282,
0.8002215623855591,
0.8767540454864502,
-0.3188559114933014,
-0.2771458625793457,
-0.3032764196395874,
-0.17969629168510437,
-0.6751692891120911,
0.7396928668022156,
0.3636925220489502,
-0.31716784834861755,
-0.29248046875,
0.24963949620723724,
-0.41142284870147705,
0.47448527812957764,
0.8166062831878662,
-0.3500825762748718,
0.05120282247662544,
0.21505214273929596,
0.6974189877510071,
-0.34703412652015686,
0.34847569465637207,
0.5905264616012573,
0.8338711857795715,
-0.5800337791442871,
-1.3183802366256714,
-0.25837498903274536,
-0.28625816106796265,
0.06419110298156738,
-0.1791090965270996,
-0.3243560791015625,
0.4865194857120514,
-0.2345779985189438,
-0.29324620962142944,
0.06329026073217392,
0.16564378142356873,
0.14191734790802002,
0.2995964586734772,
0.587374210357666,
0.25166478753089905,
0.5086913704872131,
0.1705811619758606,
1.4740571975708008,
-0.25325286388397217,
0.4340994358062744,
1.143072485923767,
-0.18232618272304535,
1.0221434831619263,
0.5785810947418213,
-0.507726788520813,
0.04051702097058296,
0.7533940076828003,
0.10931383073329926,
0.22171130776405334,
0.33214426040649414,
0.1335993856191635,
-0.4647749960422516,
-0.222640722990036,
-0.34623974561691284,
0.7692709565162659,
-0.004959470126777887,
-0.29914554953575134,
-0.2134506106376648,
0.05040577054023743,
0.042807821184396744,
0.3563401997089386,
-0.19411949813365936,
0.43787452578544617,
0.27184954285621643,
-0.7671453952789307,
0.9429938793182373,
0.4579685628414154,
0.7247342467308044,
-0.5613330006599426,
-0.05658973008394241,
0.059176161885261536,
0.2052573561668396,
-0.10111823678016663,
-0.37012994289398193,
0.5524738430976868,
0.11851722747087479,
-0.05045181140303612,
-0.7532965540885925,
0.46779346466064453,
-0.4121823310852051,
-0.796360433101654,
0.6378400921821594,
0.9755319356918335,
0.34825313091278076,
-0.14819498360157013,
-0.9030901789665222,
-0.10411664843559265,
-0.2034166008234024,
-0.33699503540992737,
0.44629818201065063,
0.11406908929347992,
-0.05346423760056496,
0.832055926322937,
0.7085899710655212,
0.20769116282463074,
0.03654679283499718,
0.18402132391929626,
0.356998473405838,
-0.4758199453353882,
-0.2515968084335327,
-1.0180139541625977,
0.2853124439716339,
0.22369644045829773,
-0.43920475244522095,
0.997908890247345,
0.5666204690933228,
1.1386868953704834,
-0.12283544987440109,
0.814562976360321,
0.37192174792289734,
0.23204682767391205,
-0.6359546780586243,
0.7921634316444397,
-0.7526688575744629,
0.10020589828491211,
-0.4295196533203125,
-1.1541414260864258,
-0.3797527551651001,
0.8138747811317444,
-0.14237894117832184,
0.21795976161956787,
0.6996443867683411,
0.322363942861557,
0.01295166090130806,
-0.19299781322479248,
0.6522477269172668,
-0.1332898586988449,
0.08589977771043777,
0.3775753974914551,
1.0648350715637207,
-0.5281703472137451,
0.7629334926605225,
-0.15164747834205627,
-0.20742268860340118,
-0.10374423116445541,
-0.93092942237854,
-0.7622805833816528,
-0.4640985131263733,
0.14245624840259552,
-0.20917057991027832,
-0.18213357031345367,
0.9316208958625793,
0.6836324334144592,
-0.9044941067695618,
-0.7059876918792725,
0.45516812801361084,
0.3000616729259491,
-0.6539151072502136,
-0.14827483892440796,
0.2295229434967041,
-0.6440497040748596,
-1.0298086404800415,
0.6499239206314087,
0.30938461422920227,
-0.07702326029539108,
-0.693218469619751,
-0.4423045814037323,
-0.1818646490573883,
-0.2878287434577942,
0.8414175510406494,
0.07088835537433624,
-0.6897290349006653,
0.09773659706115723,
0.17818757891654968,
-0.10580892115831375,
0.09395580738782883,
0.827358067035675,
-0.35068437457084656,
0.6215674877166748,
0.18086209893226624,
0.9040776491165161,
0.30135491490364075,
-0.30250856280326843,
0.8025692701339722,
-0.6465812921524048,
0.3151969611644745,
0.3779985010623932,
0.4418124258518219,
0.4445781409740448,
0.16792094707489014,
0.5943307876586914,
-0.05491171404719353,
-0.2078627645969391,
-0.954260528087616,
0.3124208152294159,
-0.2516792118549347,
-0.23491044342517853,
1.1461375951766968,
-0.5510116219520569,
0.11477964371442795,
-0.2885136008262634,
0.0700051337480545,
-0.035780563950538635,
0.2950180768966675,
0.5563822388648987,
1.000648856163025,
0.05374012514948845,
0.006275704130530357,
-1.0780774354934692,
0.550280749797821,
0.7409167885780334,
-0.6740438938140869,
-0.13075608015060425,
0.1264888495206833,
0.05719783529639244,
0.40633124113082886,
0.8727526068687439,
-0.1678132861852646,
0.19504857063293457,
-0.1952829211950302,
0.16422836482524872,
0.3675192892551422,
-0.471617728471756,
-0.5509608387947083,
-0.03161410987377167,
0.3400152325630188,
-0.05380440503358841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14230v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14230v1 | Raising the Bar: Investigating the Values of Large Language Models via Generative Evolving Testing | 2024-06-20T11:51:00 | 2024-06-20T11:51:00 | Han Jiang, Xiaoyuan Yi, Zhihua Wei, Shu Wang, Xing Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Warning: this paper contains model outputs exhibiting unethical information.
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved significant breakthroughs, but their
generated unethical content poses potential risks. Measuring value alignment of
LLMs becomes crucial for their regulation and responsible deployment. Numerous
datasets have been constructed to assess social bias, toxicity, and ethics in
LLMs, but they suffer from evaluation chronoeffect, that is, as models rapidly
evolve, existing data becomes leaked or undemanding, overestimating
ever-developing LLMs. To tackle this problem, we propose GETA, a novel
generative evolving testing approach that dynamically probes the underlying
moral baselines of LLMs. Distinct from previous adaptive testing methods that
rely on static datasets with limited difficulty, GETA incorporates an
iteratively-updated item generator which infers each LLM's moral boundaries and
generates difficulty-tailored testing items, accurately reflecting the true
alignment extent. This process theoretically learns a joint distribution of
item and model response, with item difficulty and value conformity as latent
variables, where the generator co-evolves with the LLM, addressing
chronoeffect. We evaluate various popular LLMs with diverse capabilities and
demonstrate that GETA can create difficulty-matching testing items and more
accurately assess LLMs' values, better consistent with their performance on
unseen OOD and i.i.d. items, laying the groundwork for future evaluation
paradigms. | [
-0.04348297044634819,
-0.7913995385169983,
0.5378661155700684,
0.2471361756324768,
-0.20636719465255737,
0.27759790420532227,
-0.1857708990573883,
-0.5305821299552917,
-0.13171075284481049,
0.3605089485645294,
-0.5779119729995728,
-0.18494905531406403,
-0.6125987768173218,
-0.047933485358953476,
-0.22294870018959045,
1.0680545568466187,
0.06762039661407471,
-0.06564516574144363,
-0.037304725497961044,
-0.5007194876670837,
-0.4271061420440674,
-0.2522028684616089,
-0.48837077617645264,
-0.2600533068180084,
0.421011745929718,
0.12480681389570236,
0.8793412446975708,
0.6610721945762634,
0.36025914549827576,
0.27212220430374146,
-0.33903104066848755,
0.09065701812505722,
-0.7080067992210388,
0.22253692150115967,
-0.34856659173965454,
-0.26200664043426514,
-0.5166498422622681,
0.027854718267917633,
0.3001764118671417,
0.4487452507019043,
-0.2764292359352112,
0.4733862280845642,
0.010290957055985928,
0.5137171745300293,
-0.7448198199272156,
0.018541740253567696,
-0.8346182703971863,
0.08663040399551392,
-0.1289764642715454,
-0.423608660697937,
-0.39274805784225464,
-0.6810439825057983,
0.23311197757720947,
-0.4684256315231323,
-0.11059179157018661,
0.10616235435009003,
1.062617540359497,
0.2635677754878998,
-0.4803272485733032,
-0.5483159422874451,
-0.7062248587608337,
1.001604437828064,
-0.6647195816040039,
0.4506273567676544,
-0.008490768261253834,
0.1563529521226883,
-0.13972273468971252,
-0.6675654649734497,
-0.6305148601531982,
-0.4065079391002655,
0.48588988184928894,
0.13583752512931824,
-0.12885180115699768,
-0.36154311895370483,
0.045594871044158936,
0.5872363448143005,
-0.3375522494316101,
0.2937663495540619,
-0.14286412298679352,
0.2094656527042389,
0.6021695733070374,
0.210589200258255,
0.6604596972465515,
-0.0614316426217556,
-0.30005285143852234,
-0.26468905806541443,
-0.8689613938331604,
0.14014458656311035,
0.5164276957511902,
0.3412122130393982,
-0.2376646101474762,
0.6428129076957703,
0.2946597635746002,
0.6205990314483643,
0.27339407801628113,
0.2826108932495117,
0.3775476813316345,
-0.5581062436103821,
-0.20496869087219238,
0.22365739941596985,
0.6313187479972839,
0.4347084164619446,
0.4765484035015106,
0.16656476259231567,
-0.0712558701634407,
-0.2214132845401764,
0.5777928829193115,
-0.8067141771316528,
-0.18287712335586548,
0.012293991632759571,
-0.3940875828266144,
-0.6728996634483337,
-0.3179077208042145,
-1.101161003112793,
-0.5494694113731384,
-0.32610443234443665,
0.2861843705177307,
-0.3935681879520416,
-0.2602705955505371,
0.19240820407867432,
0.1915753185749054,
0.4677220284938812,
0.086057648062706,
-0.9856411814689636,
-0.31276315450668335,
0.6193861961364746,
0.7312563061714172,
-0.05177873745560646,
-0.1661202311515808,
-0.7414417266845703,
-0.04041182994842529,
-0.6774045825004578,
0.5791610479354858,
-0.7344910502433777,
-0.35242193937301636,
-0.041723769158124924,
0.13634108006954193,
0.1989201158285141,
-0.329720139503479,
0.3996831774711609,
-0.7445327043533325,
0.2541889548301697,
-0.3301905393600464,
-0.3594047725200653,
0.2760898470878601,
0.20211096107959747,
-0.49190226197242737,
1.0182393789291382,
0.36443638801574707,
-0.5551939010620117,
0.6982460021972656,
-0.6502759456634521,
-0.1843535602092743,
0.2743305563926697,
-0.27251729369163513,
-0.5930854082107544,
0.11254604905843735,
0.2700086534023285,
0.2753533720970154,
-0.42698872089385986,
0.3682091534137726,
-0.6276342272758484,
-0.15084411203861237,
0.31321802735328674,
-0.653040885925293,
1.1038427352905273,
0.11314821988344193,
-0.5946251749992371,
0.19575157761573792,
-0.6152889132499695,
0.264042466878891,
0.25466421246528625,
-0.42138031125068665,
-0.5046022534370422,
0.24526476860046387,
-0.19519101083278656,
0.1687919944524765,
0.17431466281414032,
-0.4018736481666565,
0.04699697345495224,
-0.4176199734210968,
0.26263320446014404,
1.28719961643219,
-0.041920553892850876,
0.1683454066514969,
-0.3973812162876129,
0.5163667798042297,
-0.3758305013179779,
0.3483719527721405,
0.30169206857681274,
-0.3410922586917877,
-0.6949666142463684,
0.02485816553235054,
0.07104449719190598,
0.4730547368526459,
-0.43389567732810974,
0.8696277141571045,
-0.5259292125701904,
-0.607708752155304,
-0.630109429359436,
0.19305315613746643,
0.31608808040618896,
0.1979724019765854,
0.17535138130187988,
-0.23339727520942688,
-0.15792198479175568,
-0.5892636775970459,
-0.21582382917404175,
-0.39712777733802795,
-0.21001911163330078,
0.26937904953956604,
0.30184823274612427,
-0.1930139809846878,
0.48905858397483826,
-0.32245734333992004,
0.08005265891551971,
0.1319177746772766,
0.16095829010009766,
0.06220237910747528,
0.32198378443717957,
0.6501515507698059,
-0.6446792483329773,
-0.1342141330242157,
0.29678618907928467,
-0.8080938458442688,
-0.3975069522857666,
-0.0344255194067955,
-0.04908689111471176,
0.05976201966404915,
0.3454805910587311,
-0.07095840573310852,
-0.0014838504139333963,
0.8674783706665039,
-0.698319137096405,
0.5147944688796997,
-0.21244172751903534,
0.3531680703163147,
-1.1750690937042236,
-0.09750593453645706,
-0.19757793843746185,
-0.07112449407577515,
-0.17458195984363556,
0.24200311303138733,
0.19916656613349915,
-0.005314804147928953,
-0.33049771189689636,
0.3663601577281952,
-0.5624144077301025,
-0.0767703577876091,
-0.18266227841377258,
0.08701268583536148,
-0.004953266121447086,
0.05477488413453102,
-0.37455442547798157,
0.8491568565368652,
0.3877926468849182,
-0.7198843955993652,
0.4952537417411804,
0.1869788020849228,
-0.5439558029174805,
0.8772916197776794,
-0.48801830410957336,
0.28989797830581665,
-0.11470765620470047,
-0.05346491560339928,
-0.6332928538322449,
0.06226860359311104,
-0.025835437700152397,
-0.23983483016490936,
0.0807613655924797,
-0.18401844799518585,
-0.310356080532074,
0.03221368044614792,
-0.3805278539657593,
0.6706324219703674,
0.7532821893692017,
-0.7993250489234924,
0.6108459830284119,
0.3418981432914734,
-0.3986094892024994,
-0.759476363658905,
-0.3546205759048462,
0.05197136104106903,
-0.38813281059265137,
-0.6911912560462952,
0.055709511041641235,
-0.3819158673286438,
-0.3564918339252472,
-0.06989996880292892,
-0.10948708653450012,
0.23677779734134674,
0.20955026149749756,
-0.0064263008534908295,
0.39291706681251526,
-0.4312894642353058,
0.2753134071826935,
0.08928696811199188,
0.24983619153499603,
0.10136356204748154,
-0.13965336978435516,
0.6427448391914368,
-0.41965624690055847,
-0.33245888352394104,
0.03663667291402817,
-0.061923298984766006,
0.6799520254135132,
-0.3438856303691864,
0.510586142539978,
0.2981554865837097,
-0.2467103898525238,
-0.41281241178512573,
-0.35195547342300415,
0.13552533090114594,
-0.5547814965248108,
0.4313843846321106,
-0.19373047351837158,
-0.8560863733291626,
0.356347918510437,
-0.01080984529107809,
0.34913697838783264,
0.40475746989250183,
0.6865715384483337,
0.14029227197170258,
0.8371082544326782,
0.6101190447807312,
0.1648486703634262,
0.4704482853412628,
0.12433525919914246,
0.42347514629364014,
-0.7944356203079224,
-0.21475037932395935,
-0.4522325098514557,
-0.1052979901432991,
-0.7643166780471802,
-0.552050769329071,
0.2950623631477356,
0.13502547144889832,
-0.4762667417526245,
0.07900053262710571,
-0.5165047645568848,
0.6834394931793213,
-0.04693206399679184,
-0.05148429051041603,
0.4772973656654358,
-0.11610514670610428,
0.01613464020192623,
0.007229871582239866,
-0.26329344511032104,
-0.6651614904403687,
1.2177211046218872,
0.31318211555480957,
0.8937008380889893,
0.2832348346710205,
0.1341952383518219,
0.43041157722473145,
0.716310441493988,
-0.6638628840446472,
0.26920008659362793,
-0.19733873009681702,
-0.4631383717060089,
-0.42430925369262695,
-0.43550246953964233,
-1.0553990602493286,
0.23292236030101776,
-0.003065111581236124,
-0.80083167552948,
0.4311935603618622,
0.14564834535121918,
-0.3394756019115448,
0.4539242386817932,
-0.379922479391098,
0.6939098834991455,
-0.6744153499603271,
-0.3130339980125427,
-0.06277325749397278,
-0.39435678720474243,
0.3587484657764435,
-0.33155015110969543,
0.10542804002761841,
-0.35962000489234924,
0.02552366815507412,
0.5603733062744141,
-0.12078861147165298,
0.6765080094337463,
0.11076143383979797,
-0.6465029120445251,
0.056476518511772156,
0.21225515007972717,
0.4996463656425476,
0.17456069588661194,
-0.16587398946285248,
0.04162592068314552,
0.10076413303613663,
-0.47186726331710815,
-0.5288061499595642,
0.8547008633613586,
-0.5960611701011658,
-0.5163630843162537,
-0.535046398639679,
-0.6751713752746582,
-0.294969767332077,
0.09969437122344971,
0.15877299010753632,
0.15698634088039398,
-0.43530672788619995,
0.23838381469249725,
0.8467439413070679,
-0.4852323532104492,
0.11204259097576141,
0.6294390559196472,
-0.23325170576572418,
-0.11533550173044205,
0.7741667628288269,
-0.23993350565433502,
0.6852990388870239,
-0.01718316413462162,
0.46752890944480896,
-0.3220139443874359,
-0.5275416374206543,
-0.684729278087616,
-0.03715675324201584,
-0.7026256322860718,
-0.09717408567667007,
-0.4419764578342438,
-0.11138104647397995,
-0.2893517315387726,
-0.4254225790500641,
-0.5493415594100952,
0.1432734876871109,
-0.22398485243320465,
-0.31316158175468445,
0.5217428803443909,
0.5951358675956726,
-0.039052046835422516,
-0.06308691948652267,
-0.6785695552825928,
0.14572595059871674,
0.41235312819480896,
0.44144484400749207,
-0.029278341680765152,
-0.6313408017158508,
0.3693353533744812,
0.172494038939476,
-0.34000831842422485,
-0.6702885031700134,
0.1910075545310974,
-0.03292674571275711,
0.34977051615715027,
0.42081141471862793,
0.03813786432147026,
0.7012540698051453,
-0.3886120021343231,
0.7924824953079224,
0.0787629783153534,
-1.0950124263763428,
0.32980024814605713,
-0.3014671802520752,
-0.01523048710078001,
0.4908951222896576,
0.22316734492778778,
-0.5669462084770203,
-0.34845858812332153,
-0.41460496187210083,
-0.8843222260475159,
0.3997230529785156,
0.22993157804012299,
0.5979847311973572,
0.07987119257450104,
0.3756081759929657,
0.19966968894004822,
-0.009024896658957005,
-0.8039191365242004,
0.11624321341514587,
-0.14205080270767212,
-0.4256119430065155,
-0.02010537125170231,
-0.11720472574234009,
-0.2717297673225403,
-0.002261026995256543,
0.5336252450942993,
-0.1504317671060562,
0.04076572507619858,
-0.03919186443090439,
-0.03005427122116089,
-0.42459776997566223,
0.5784231424331665,
0.22902202606201172,
0.987992525100708,
-0.3052571415901184,
0.060640208423137665,
0.28766244649887085,
-0.31693536043167114,
0.5431309938430786,
0.13593733310699463,
-0.10220328718423843,
-0.45590442419052124,
0.3257750868797302,
0.7184101343154907,
-0.015563259832561016,
-0.882766604423523,
0.5323512554168701,
0.01093373168259859,
0.04722992703318596,
-0.39593052864074707,
0.04038216918706894,
0.20031222701072693,
0.26115337014198303,
0.08655033260583878,
-0.4873510003089905,
-0.24466504156589508,
-0.8331059813499451,
0.2826838791370392,
0.36257436871528625,
-0.5878761410713196,
-0.2826271653175354,
0.5324416160583496,
0.16940955817699432,
-0.3628842234611511,
0.685981035232544,
-0.31222257018089294,
-0.21226666867733002,
0.7303462028503418,
0.5650472044944763,
0.8203286528587341,
-0.5507081151008606,
0.2306530475616455,
-0.010516321286559105,
0.5558086633682251,
-0.043861228972673416,
0.44473010301589966,
0.20675697922706604,
-0.9295883774757385,
-0.38093680143356323,
-0.8046377301216125,
-0.23887163400650024,
0.40124472975730896,
-0.6596660017967224,
0.009051320143043995,
-0.3536774814128876,
0.10503607243299484,
-0.005738628096878529,
-0.36951491236686707,
-0.47761696577072144,
0.17820292711257935,
-0.19716233015060425,
0.4410586655139923,
-0.734940230846405,
0.36201006174087524,
0.4114183187484741,
-0.23536096513271332,
-0.5319179892539978,
0.2994909882545471,
-0.06047958508133888,
-1.1794477701187134,
0.5581215620040894,
0.012482449412345886,
-0.2895062565803528,
-0.07247850298881531,
-0.5228296518325806,
-0.8761758208274841,
1.0904872417449951,
0.5173479914665222,
-0.743973433971405,
0.009309102781116962,
-0.030424797907471657,
0.6524645090103149,
-0.34160444140434265,
0.057571642100811005,
0.5435118675231934,
0.4894930124282837,
-0.14005661010742188,
-0.5979555249214172,
0.3447684645652771,
-0.3398507237434387,
0.04327123612165451,
0.44896259903907776,
-0.5657377243041992,
0.581061601638794,
-0.3103283941745758,
-0.38148367404937744,
0.09872550517320633,
0.4114934206008911,
0.5040960907936096,
0.33918800950050354,
0.7791361212730408,
0.5222660303115845,
0.80070960521698,
-0.04505816474556923,
1.0990042686462402,
-0.08398426324129105,
0.32517361640930176,
1.0783883333206177,
-0.6104981303215027,
0.5383498072624207,
0.4076184928417206,
-0.037156373262405396,
0.45067813992500305,
0.6540346741676331,
-0.2605818212032318,
0.29943445324897766,
0.7932695746421814,
-0.14538221061229706,
-0.1956077516078949,
-0.19118070602416992,
-0.2846054136753082,
0.26955392956733704,
0.22874076664447784,
-0.4182784855365753,
-0.15227262675762177,
-0.08382561802864075,
0.08388760685920715,
0.0527447909116745,
-0.14769141376018524,
0.5573884844779968,
0.011284209787845612,
-0.5924575924873352,
0.6228731274604797,
-0.11453662812709808,
0.6333870887756348,
-0.6336992979049683,
-0.016774186864495277,
-0.11686922609806061,
0.15446995198726654,
0.10943800210952759,
-0.802308976650238,
0.22661390900611877,
0.2557828724384308,
0.21229563653469086,
-0.14714355766773224,
0.2825739085674286,
-0.2884870767593384,
-0.643513560295105,
0.7080700397491455,
0.4719715416431427,
-0.09315308183431625,
0.19506752490997314,
-0.6854775547981262,
0.012322695925831795,
-0.07305674999952316,
-0.2527543306350708,
0.25356796383857727,
0.46696996688842773,
-0.18768371641635895,
0.6858389973640442,
0.75657719373703,
0.10122233629226685,
0.23119588196277618,
0.1916424036026001,
0.5964627861976624,
-0.7075964212417603,
-0.36412495374679565,
-0.9271767735481262,
0.325736939907074,
-0.07831227034330368,
-0.6583617329597473,
0.3251923620700836,
0.376106321811676,
0.8542490005493164,
0.2176210731267929,
0.6865758299827576,
-0.08170152455568314,
-0.12844039499759674,
-0.7966240048408508,
0.8680363297462463,
-0.6352811455726624,
0.26668015122413635,
-0.17550493776798248,
-0.9365068078041077,
0.1505294144153595,
0.27812111377716064,
-0.09874531626701355,
0.23775535821914673,
0.6804328560829163,
0.7128174304962158,
-0.17669694125652313,
-0.03584873303771019,
0.25020554661750793,
0.2930806279182434,
0.5773977041244507,
0.6526298522949219,
1.2237548828125,
-0.20821410417556763,
0.5095065236091614,
0.06078912690281868,
-0.450042188167572,
0.1011846587061882,
-1.109148383140564,
-0.761827826499939,
-0.4636825621128082,
-0.30108070373535156,
-0.5461327433586121,
0.3419942259788513,
0.7758951187133789,
0.408852756023407,
-0.6122370958328247,
-0.18260343372821808,
-0.1497955024242401,
-0.029556795954704285,
-0.3900066614151001,
-0.30387431383132935,
0.5013045072555542,
-0.31784746050834656,
-0.794476330280304,
0.4556891918182373,
0.3417782783508301,
0.1620006412267685,
-0.29772108793258667,
-0.13352371752262115,
-0.10149937868118286,
0.37972313165664673,
0.4644109606742859,
0.083644799888134,
-0.5479526519775391,
-0.6048104763031006,
-0.1771422028541565,
0.0657842755317688,
0.12193978577852249,
0.8386560678482056,
-0.07995925098657608,
0.6852458119392395,
0.38655930757522583,
1.019164800643921,
0.1912718266248703,
-0.11738168448209763,
0.888443648815155,
-0.44301649928092957,
-0.38563913106918335,
0.3600355088710785,
0.2852628529071808,
0.3593100607395172,
-0.6092426180839539,
0.4686051905155182,
-0.05953606963157654,
-0.7442906498908997,
-1.0136337280273438,
0.4281470477581024,
-1.0377352237701416,
-0.25266531109809875,
1.0105712413787842,
-0.1606326550245285,
0.006031668744981289,
-0.04977506771683693,
0.21441686153411865,
0.32798492908477783,
-0.21672186255455017,
1.33144211769104,
0.7832342982292175,
0.124184750020504,
0.09731660038232803,
-0.5653210878372192,
0.5239319205284119,
0.646804690361023,
-1.2556655406951904,
0.4037608206272125,
0.4923434853553772,
0.6612145304679871,
0.15541861951351166,
0.38721853494644165,
-0.5441627502441406,
0.3209831118583679,
-0.4401381313800812,
0.008307039737701416,
0.20641839504241943,
0.09537918865680695,
-0.45010992884635925,
0.05377371609210968,
0.18168042600154877,
-0.011384795419871807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14213v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14213v1 | Complexity of Symbolic Representation in Working Memory of Transformer Correlates with the Complexity of a Task | 2024-06-20T11:27:29 | 2024-06-20T11:27:29 | Alsu Sagirova, Mikhail Burtsev | cs.CL | cs.CL | Even though Transformers are extensively used for Natural Language Processing
tasks, especially for machine translation, they lack an explicit memory to
store key concepts of processed texts. This paper explores the properties of
the content of symbolic working memory added to the Transformer model decoder.
Such working memory enhances the quality of model predictions in machine
translation task and works as a neural-symbolic representation of information
that is important for the model to make correct translations. The study of
memory content revealed that translated text keywords are stored in the working
memory, pointing to the relevance of memory content to the processed text.
Also, the diversity of tokens and parts of speech stored in memory correlates
with the complexity of the corpora for machine translation task. | [
-0.1399819403886795,
-0.27564674615859985,
0.40223538875579834,
0.07338535785675049,
-0.29238900542259216,
0.0480886772274971,
-0.33263495564460754,
-0.4987368881702423,
-0.02097712643444538,
0.4431397616863251,
-0.27170446515083313,
-0.173758402466774,
-1.0952385663986206,
0.3607275187969208,
-0.5575417876243591,
0.8170453906059265,
-0.26460447907447815,
0.009261432103812695,
-0.11579881608486176,
-0.350222647190094,
-1.0804495811462402,
-0.7496702671051025,
-0.36938416957855225,
-0.6685844659805298,
0.28143471479415894,
-0.06973206996917725,
0.9099981784820557,
0.7139776349067688,
0.6573843359947205,
0.394619882106781,
-0.33412057161331177,
-0.017496317625045776,
-0.58487468957901,
0.46127909421920776,
-0.36953940987586975,
-1.1053056716918945,
-0.10718371719121933,
-0.15988494455814362,
0.5676710605621338,
0.5907231569290161,
0.13740471005439758,
0.01970669999718666,
-0.08117302507162094,
0.44561123847961426,
-0.3734823763370514,
0.7099053263664246,
-0.5483039617538452,
0.15498916804790497,
-0.10672537237405777,
-0.07475555688142776,
-0.5599178671836853,
0.08723039925098419,
0.08759219944477081,
-0.1661738157272339,
0.36769160628318787,
0.02045523189008236,
0.9979884624481201,
0.43780001997947693,
-0.45713257789611816,
-0.2809203267097473,
-1.3094937801361084,
0.7611014246940613,
-0.4689759910106659,
0.4512704312801361,
0.3145298659801483,
0.35428330302238464,
0.013479160144925117,
-0.6048225164413452,
-0.6585675477981567,
-0.08479854464530945,
-0.6297563910484314,
0.05415819212794304,
-0.5298834443092346,
0.13569912314414978,
0.4182679355144501,
0.42877429723739624,
-0.19457724690437317,
-0.1604676991701126,
-0.7804879546165466,
-0.17430032789707184,
0.3778316378593445,
0.3689035475254059,
0.45336923003196716,
-0.42618829011917114,
0.11599721014499664,
-0.4877311885356903,
-0.3058834671974182,
-0.036986492574214935,
-0.021286265924572945,
0.10522474348545074,
0.05883408710360527,
0.8311541676521301,
0.09208784997463226,
0.5457242131233215,
-0.08145373314619064,
-0.20775635540485382,
0.26924851536750793,
-0.24351082742214203,
-0.2822570502758026,
0.1138845682144165,
0.8281193971633911,
-0.07033004611730576,
0.3185354769229889,
-0.34662261605262756,
-0.48900794982910156,
0.07427258789539337,
0.847076416015625,
-0.6654481887817383,
0.02023855596780777,
-0.24928617477416992,
-0.6167437434196472,
0.1731429100036621,
0.33085939288139343,
-0.06368087977170944,
0.2662027180194855,
-0.38306036591529846,
0.41184550523757935,
-0.4705502986907959,
-0.04832739010453224,
0.004564726259559393,
-0.41821783781051636,
-0.0953548476099968,
0.07450839132070541,
-0.8735348582267761,
0.2958700358867645,
0.6717002391815186,
0.8071926832199097,
-0.2565937638282776,
-0.31151291728019714,
-0.2826964259147644,
0.2980189025402069,
-0.33434799313545227,
0.39183309674263,
-0.8370177745819092,
-0.3657640814781189,
-0.012178260833024979,
0.5116998553276062,
-0.3330751061439514,
-0.7857372760772705,
0.8032468557357788,
-0.5667301416397095,
-0.03890123963356018,
-0.20395852625370026,
-0.476639986038208,
-0.47169604897499084,
-0.059950441122055054,
-1.304587483406067,
1.270488977432251,
0.2807512581348419,
-0.4531448185443878,
-0.04916892200708389,
-0.4858936667442322,
-0.7549359202384949,
-0.0353328101336956,
-0.11321328580379486,
-0.15530292689800262,
0.8151484727859497,
-0.17155003547668457,
0.700770914554596,
-0.15640789270401,
0.173201322555542,
0.5474057793617249,
-0.6185178756713867,
0.6021272540092468,
-0.17587538063526154,
0.33020779490470886,
0.002577370498329401,
-0.313446581363678,
-0.03870820626616478,
-0.32315337657928467,
-0.6780900955200195,
0.35601088404655457,
-0.31908291578292847,
-0.48660579323768616,
0.07516538351774216,
-0.11245226114988327,
0.29734721779823303,
0.3476785719394684,
-0.5978519916534424,
-0.15082108974456787,
-0.4733829200267792,
0.47424694895744324,
0.3520072102546692,
-0.25944140553474426,
0.6408847570419312,
-0.1584719866514206,
0.4800229072570801,
0.4212561845779419,
-0.26007407903671265,
-0.34637629985809326,
-0.7434573173522949,
-0.7766250371932983,
0.4667853116989136,
0.20550984144210815,
0.462298721075058,
-0.593216061592102,
0.13817599415779114,
-0.6339188814163208,
-0.6150152087211609,
-0.5363066792488098,
-0.05618960037827492,
0.3691246807575226,
0.26035451889038086,
0.35786959528923035,
-0.07889865338802338,
-0.5515984892845154,
-1.1105058193206787,
-0.21814675629138947,
-0.09894701093435287,
-0.25498467683792114,
-0.11888501793146133,
0.8471165299415588,
-0.3223141133785248,
0.6009083390235901,
-0.5867287516593933,
-0.31631553173065186,
-0.37551698088645935,
0.4021179676055908,
0.5385748744010925,
0.3067374527454376,
0.1646294891834259,
-0.9230060577392578,
-0.3355538547039032,
0.012777256779372692,
-0.5545178651809692,
0.1625690758228302,
-0.3358857035636902,
-0.12575694918632507,
0.20444060862064362,
0.2650676667690277,
-1.1728097200393677,
0.39958587288856506,
0.4491850435733795,
-0.2719006836414337,
0.2056250274181366,
-0.48394304513931274,
0.07891025394201279,
-0.924984872341156,
0.048883941024541855,
-0.20409218966960907,
-0.13824573159217834,
-0.7503957152366638,
-0.20025479793548584,
0.23224422335624695,
-0.15944626927375793,
-0.16402539610862732,
0.29010847210884094,
-0.5076117515563965,
-0.0654309019446373,
-0.500311553478241,
-0.037848882377147675,
0.011394498869776726,
0.47664716839790344,
0.26009371876716614,
0.8616276979446411,
0.214815154671669,
-0.4356245994567871,
0.10856451094150543,
0.3751464784145355,
0.09021259099245071,
0.3627375662326813,
-0.744800865650177,
-0.08161428570747375,
-0.32309189438819885,
-0.08053907752037048,
-0.7051516175270081,
0.11374872177839279,
-0.045271120965480804,
-0.3300929069519043,
0.4090915024280548,
0.05146942660212517,
-0.9064292907714844,
-0.3808404803276062,
0.37627148628234863,
0.3723655045032501,
0.8261420726776123,
0.01914646290242672,
0.7687017917633057,
0.35008376836776733,
-0.028865192085504532,
-0.14829030632972717,
-0.8727818131446838,
0.04689658433198929,
0.19607731699943542,
-0.45331984758377075,
0.953377902507782,
0.2957915961742401,
0.11474780738353729,
0.14891433715820312,
-0.36031830310821533,
-0.0346401073038578,
-0.322599321603775,
0.4608474671840668,
0.29761016368865967,
-0.20599952340126038,
0.17796145379543304,
0.014694602228701115,
-0.4101729393005371,
0.3643503785133362,
-0.03350774571299553,
0.5969640016555786,
-0.1458243578672409,
-0.17474378645420074,
-0.2599939703941345,
0.46508273482322693,
0.8139799237251282,
-0.21689113974571228,
1.003442645072937,
0.6723787784576416,
-0.7393668293952942,
0.05970111861824989,
-0.13341377675533295,
-0.19661609828472137,
-0.429597944021225,
0.45843255519866943,
-0.29835760593414307,
-0.8774131536483765,
0.6110242009162903,
0.16916021704673767,
-0.09317556023597717,
0.9225167632102966,
0.6078453063964844,
-0.16486120223999023,
1.0228848457336426,
0.594785749912262,
-0.14527229964733124,
0.2536299228668213,
-0.22022773325443268,
0.6814380884170532,
-0.7338991761207581,
-0.45244520902633667,
-0.5788179636001587,
-0.6202355623245239,
-0.5718319416046143,
-0.6846462488174438,
0.05865584313869476,
-0.022533806040883064,
-0.17454133927822113,
0.9300960302352905,
-0.7671517133712769,
0.3282572031021118,
0.5606210827827454,
-0.06120358407497406,
0.2909717261791229,
-0.14221706986427307,
0.0004893195000477135,
-0.3000234365463257,
-0.403907835483551,
-0.682813286781311,
0.6761783361434937,
0.3743974268436432,
0.6134315729141235,
-0.2188621610403061,
0.5119206309318542,
0.1399250030517578,
-0.11507098376750946,
-0.7974887490272522,
0.532518744468689,
-0.30839914083480835,
-0.4464971721172333,
-0.11378499865531921,
-0.34179985523223877,
-1.1419284343719482,
0.019039716571569443,
-0.10630957037210464,
-0.6593160033226013,
-0.08866780251264572,
-0.17868857085704803,
0.04518970474600792,
0.2800237834453583,
-0.3833094537258148,
0.7529104948043823,
-0.09466602653265,
0.22024166584014893,
-0.48733261227607727,
-0.5968261957168579,
-0.058012455701828,
0.22881750762462616,
-0.13698460161685944,
0.20134396851062775,
0.05554008483886719,
1.233707308769226,
-0.14969728887081146,
0.7633908987045288,
0.1539236456155777,
-0.05023912712931633,
0.07585855573415756,
0.14198708534240723,
0.6178072094917297,
-0.4080023765563965,
-0.03906063362956047,
0.4121052622795105,
-0.015603965148329735,
-0.08939804136753082,
-0.6729077696800232,
0.26561108231544495,
-0.672954261302948,
-0.6220468878746033,
-0.585586667060852,
-0.8242170810699463,
0.22275735437870026,
0.3551703691482544,
0.1701716184616089,
0.058029089123010635,
-0.008914683014154434,
0.3243425488471985,
0.7001089453697205,
-0.11113286763429642,
0.4415924549102783,
0.054332517087459564,
0.10431283712387085,
0.020898262038826942,
0.7455648183822632,
0.39421528577804565,
0.16414295136928558,
0.8611654043197632,
-0.06932130455970764,
0.034950122237205505,
-0.4564858675003052,
-0.2217245250940323,
0.298319548368454,
-0.9529765248298645,
-0.3212876319885254,
-0.8123881816864014,
-0.524511456489563,
0.14565712213516235,
-0.07479336112737656,
-0.480122834444046,
-0.36332663893699646,
-0.33015501499176025,
-0.2565704882144928,
0.4021759629249573,
1.0301315784454346,
0.3625861704349518,
0.4264640212059021,
-1.1072593927383423,
0.5432336926460266,
-0.06904121488332748,
0.22406622767448425,
0.07285844534635544,
-0.441873162984848,
-0.8176454305648804,
0.223648801445961,
-0.3271324336528778,
-1.0648458003997803,
0.6775546073913574,
-0.15095120668411255,
0.6777833104133606,
0.24490244686603546,
-0.1568472981452942,
0.4537525177001953,
-0.5272092223167419,
0.7445942163467407,
0.04375866800546646,
-0.9770962595939636,
0.37400928139686584,
0.082475945353508,
0.5340311527252197,
0.22554311156272888,
0.4509749412536621,
-0.541244626045227,
-0.5565603375434875,
-0.6306593418121338,
-0.4659135937690735,
0.7753211855888367,
0.7188680768013,
0.6154510378837585,
-0.18570883572101593,
0.12641654908657074,
0.06745697557926178,
0.11344843357801437,
-0.5410763025283813,
-0.46240922808647156,
-0.253927618265152,
-0.1369727998971939,
-0.11964520066976547,
-0.2950037717819214,
-0.02506708912551403,
-0.4732794463634491,
0.24240203201770782,
0.2606159448623657,
1.014174461364746,
-0.16740040481090546,
-0.270283043384552,
-0.03330602869391441,
0.3041055500507355,
0.46399399638175964,
0.27390313148498535,
-0.059722792357206345,
0.4531489908695221,
0.30785006284713745,
-0.6909926533699036,
0.10021529346704483,
-0.14089690148830414,
-0.07138199359178543,
0.620590090751648,
0.40692687034606934,
0.9863454699516296,
0.4667093753814697,
-0.7602608799934387,
0.2411375194787979,
0.03888396918773651,
-0.025487443432211876,
-0.223316490650177,
0.3155304789543152,
0.5508091449737549,
0.07041346281766891,
0.5177251100540161,
0.3211277723312378,
0.048146042972803116,
-0.6321850419044495,
0.14430321753025055,
0.07219021767377853,
-0.5768146514892578,
-0.5203791856765747,
0.594339907169342,
-0.22716474533081055,
-0.5423609018325806,
0.7621802091598511,
-0.08975277096033096,
-0.9294125437736511,
0.603849470615387,
1.0215420722961426,
0.8662712574005127,
-0.21759118139743805,
0.043304212391376495,
0.4062018096446991,
0.48596104979515076,
-0.25371527671813965,
0.35852915048599243,
0.10773298144340515,
-0.4925271272659302,
-0.44477224349975586,
-0.7097873687744141,
-0.23882362246513367,
-0.4285585880279541,
-0.6685226559638977,
0.008600981906056404,
0.010035664774477482,
-0.2704705595970154,
-0.24466972053050995,
-0.38744911551475525,
-0.8584190011024475,
0.26755401492118835,
0.10968054085969925,
0.6929159760475159,
-0.7001275420188904,
0.877783477306366,
0.5480882525444031,
-0.4599093496799469,
-0.8248178362846375,
-0.27826595306396484,
-0.6205166578292847,
-0.6187514066696167,
1.1419349908828735,
0.27614569664001465,
0.08396069705486298,
-0.30976948142051697,
0.03346562013030052,
-0.8595631122589111,
1.1031839847564697,
0.5270271897315979,
-0.5318438410758972,
-0.23637664318084717,
0.787723958492279,
0.7790823578834534,
-0.33278563618659973,
0.20317021012306213,
0.46324700117111206,
0.5781874060630798,
0.2602662742137909,
-1.0204012393951416,
0.5157678127288818,
-0.4496253430843353,
0.3400295078754425,
0.46824774146080017,
-0.11488906294107437,
1.0457148551940918,
0.13253901898860931,
-0.5955679416656494,
-0.4206368327140808,
0.78550124168396,
-0.19393502175807953,
-0.12657701969146729,
0.12532956898212433,
0.510833203792572,
0.5933809876441956,
-0.19189967215061188,
1.0319430828094482,
-0.3886834383010864,
0.16208507120609283,
0.8235918879508972,
0.1558496057987213,
1.0258454084396362,
0.5216773748397827,
-0.034914180636405945,
0.7714093327522278,
0.1389334499835968,
-0.29555732011795044,
0.33900555968284607,
-0.03149335831403732,
-0.03702666983008385,
0.06777298450469971,
-0.03373517841100693,
-0.006640307139605284,
0.46079280972480774,
0.3464581370353699,
-0.8848671317100525,
-0.10000603646039963,
0.1896083801984787,
0.15534305572509766,
-0.06843626499176025,
-0.03434840217232704,
0.7828174233436584,
0.3247322142124176,
-0.913723349571228,
0.691006064414978,
0.33987677097320557,
0.3878544270992279,
-0.3790830671787262,
-0.27654218673706055,
0.12393157929182053,
0.06110529229044914,
-0.2039303332567215,
-0.9819915890693665,
1.0697020292282104,
-0.2221890240907669,
-0.4167238771915436,
-0.5111420154571533,
0.8528286218643188,
-0.30344417691230774,
-0.4641002118587494,
0.4869310259819031,
0.3352949917316437,
0.00803547166287899,
-0.4435237944126129,
-0.29056379199028015,
0.07798323035240173,
-0.3216671645641327,
-0.29152917861938477,
0.1713915318250656,
0.6455709934234619,
-0.008414619602262974,
0.5744608640670776,
0.41702091693878174,
-0.17612947523593903,
0.17634166777133942,
-0.17881782352924347,
0.8507094979286194,
-0.963756799697876,
-0.3535618484020233,
-0.988508403301239,
0.5818040370941162,
0.007113269530236721,
-0.08764138072729111,
0.6910002827644348,
0.533245325088501,
0.8331552743911743,
-0.5047687292098999,
0.640277624130249,
-0.15417827665805817,
-0.19701433181762695,
-0.23242127895355225,
0.7933300137519836,
-0.22154463827610016,
-0.07237711548805237,
-0.14752818644046783,
-0.8452032208442688,
-0.19352427124977112,
0.6860944628715515,
-0.19159962236881256,
-0.25163036584854126,
1.1616365909576416,
0.644468367099762,
-0.2389703094959259,
0.23667606711387634,
0.3707592487335205,
0.050325214862823486,
-0.040348414331674576,
0.6539798378944397,
0.4195168912410736,
-0.7970735430717468,
0.7882925868034363,
-0.3068585991859436,
0.31424474716186523,
-0.07919222116470337,
-0.4694717824459076,
-1.0691115856170654,
-1.0141189098358154,
-0.02074540965259075,
-0.3589012324810028,
-0.23840920627117157,
0.5565475821495056,
0.5514206290245056,
-0.7323033213615417,
-0.3751160502433777,
-0.09446977823972702,
0.20976604521274567,
-0.6134085655212402,
-0.20065583288669586,
0.28631022572517395,
-0.29708871245384216,
-0.832644522190094,
0.10250429809093475,
0.4393444061279297,
0.17935889959335327,
-0.34834206104278564,
-0.25723403692245483,
0.07285422831773758,
0.15253494679927826,
0.777852475643158,
-0.13565467298030853,
-0.6312861442565918,
-0.09570847451686859,
0.4237571656703949,
-0.34610214829444885,
0.406667023897171,
0.7700051665306091,
-0.671981155872345,
0.3079380691051483,
0.8248087167739868,
0.7310847043991089,
0.793416440486908,
-0.5168838500976562,
0.8584049344062805,
-0.47678083181381226,
0.005584560800343752,
0.40088269114494324,
0.5720521807670593,
0.18869179487228394,
-0.4132399559020996,
0.3770889341831207,
0.10978677123785019,
-0.20555058121681213,
-0.5380258560180664,
0.189556285738945,
-1.061130404472351,
-0.07570639997720718,
0.7873180508613586,
-0.09935730695724487,
-0.4126755893230438,
-0.11584518104791641,
-0.22797998785972595,
0.6103748679161072,
-0.31654757261276245,
0.7262346744537354,
0.7398775219917297,
0.05707256495952606,
-0.4508017301559448,
-0.7479802370071411,
0.21610501408576965,
0.3900664448738098,
-0.4616316258907318,
-0.004628730472177267,
0.05241536349058151,
-0.22350816428661346,
0.5669481158256531,
0.11192047595977783,
-0.20622707903385162,
0.06295641511678696,
0.11347465962171555,
-0.1567457914352417,
0.0740470141172409,
-0.24475441873073578,
0.1015339270234108,
0.45179441571235657,
-0.12133220583200455,
-0.042836543172597885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14197v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14197v1 | On the Representational Capacity of Neural Language Models with Chain-of-Thought Reasoning | 2024-06-20T10:59:02 | 2024-06-20T10:59:02 | Franz Nowak, Anej Svete, Alexandra Butoi, Ryan Cotterell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.FL | The performance of modern language models (LMs) has been improved by
chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning, i.e., the process of generating intermediate
results that guide the model towards a final answer. A possible explanation for
this improvement is that CoT reasoning extends an LM's computational power, as
RNNs and transformers with additional scratch space are known to be Turing
complete. Comparing LMs to Turing machines, however, introduces a category
error - Turing machines decide language membership, whereas LMs define
distributions over strings. To bridge this gap, we formalize CoT reasoning in a
probabilistic setting. We present several results on the representational
capacity of recurrent and transformer LMs with CoT reasoning, showing that they
can represent the same family of distributions over strings as probabilistic
Turing machines. | [
-0.42178770899772644,
-0.45639756321907043,
0.9719399213790894,
-0.024741383269429207,
-0.2549152374267578,
0.37857991456985474,
-0.5055176615715027,
-0.49599596858024597,
0.17821981012821198,
0.7032197117805481,
-0.25129690766334534,
-0.12335424870252609,
-0.6423251032829285,
0.056304942816495895,
-0.5838425755500793,
0.7320079207420349,
-0.25286760926246643,
-0.04929563030600548,
-0.2760832607746124,
-0.1951925903558731,
-0.32378485798835754,
-0.7388454079627991,
-0.4702957272529602,
-0.37331464886665344,
0.5667271614074707,
0.03560393676161766,
1.0225590467453003,
0.24499957263469696,
0.5080128312110901,
0.30144837498664856,
-0.08852682262659073,
0.21211157739162445,
-0.13923920691013336,
0.30696946382522583,
-0.30416005849838257,
-0.7354609966278076,
-0.4505661129951477,
-0.2227700650691986,
0.7227323055267334,
0.8114708065986633,
-0.1752607673406601,
-0.18795901536941528,
-0.12560151517391205,
0.689631462097168,
-0.7551709413528442,
-0.016624877229332924,
-0.7628667950630188,
-0.01142248883843422,
0.127935528755188,
-0.12425520271062851,
-0.819619357585907,
-0.48199591040611267,
0.08129424601793289,
-0.2661321461200714,
0.2065170556306839,
0.0751655250787735,
0.37712353467941284,
-0.10421745479106903,
-0.20115362107753754,
-0.12799715995788574,
-1.0647578239440918,
0.6619377136230469,
-0.5494978427886963,
0.487015962600708,
0.3453183174133301,
0.3770819902420044,
-0.3245903253555298,
-0.622026801109314,
-0.7405130863189697,
-0.4186531603336334,
-0.20678651332855225,
-0.1638670265674591,
0.009520013816654682,
0.2350907027721405,
0.13894598186016083,
0.4655265212059021,
-0.36254990100860596,
-0.2299717664718628,
-0.25868210196495056,
0.13530917465686798,
0.5732421278953552,
-0.055518992245197296,
0.23215585947036743,
0.2450299859046936,
-0.4073472321033478,
-0.1262119859457016,
-0.7176689505577087,
-0.17152737081050873,
0.12487822026014328,
0.12415756285190582,
0.18801674246788025,
0.5754039287567139,
0.2796575725078583,
0.9818211793899536,
-0.1616075187921524,
0.25344035029411316,
-0.11868643760681152,
-0.21978537738323212,
-0.25721943378448486,
0.18717516958713531,
0.7396160364151001,
-0.07983285188674927,
0.6606191396713257,
-0.3428788185119629,
-0.31097301840782166,
0.040922630578279495,
0.5335904359817505,
-0.19379323720932007,
-0.10901866853237152,
0.14784426987171173,
-0.32960182428359985,
-0.08416270464658737,
0.2318556308746338,
-0.2137800008058548,
-0.37525874376296997,
-0.2065356969833374,
0.3229011297225952,
-0.5345503687858582,
-0.5482084155082703,
0.40878674387931824,
-0.27019351720809937,
-0.2066129595041275,
0.07228534668684006,
-0.9306234121322632,
0.5939199328422546,
0.683367908000946,
0.6750290989875793,
0.02023615874350071,
-0.07838330417871475,
0.0423513688147068,
0.05334513261914253,
-0.6989313960075378,
0.7316504120826721,
-0.7698341012001038,
-0.006215036381036043,
-0.0963132306933403,
-0.10406918823719025,
-0.27648642659187317,
-0.5751977562904358,
0.09176627546548843,
-0.6503632664680481,
-0.2509904205799103,
-0.26281943917274475,
-0.6123331785202026,
-0.10602705925703049,
0.06203357130289078,
-0.8635511994361877,
0.5929591059684753,
0.41848090291023254,
-0.6588037014007568,
0.24576489627361298,
-0.13861152529716492,
-0.3017456829547882,
0.00014363817172124982,
-0.4148578643798828,
-0.17315399646759033,
0.3835991621017456,
-0.1630125641822815,
0.2798977494239807,
-0.4755987226963043,
0.5469164252281189,
-0.34607169032096863,
-0.4919145405292511,
0.9266190528869629,
-0.6078194379806519,
0.41714003682136536,
0.3235175907611847,
-0.3718147575855255,
0.1624067723751068,
-0.6796096563339233,
0.040316127240657806,
-0.06871860474348068,
-0.27556321024894714,
-0.18564128875732422,
0.34132120013237,
-0.23541298508644104,
0.19378410279750824,
0.04703482612967491,
-0.3847012519836426,
0.2900761067867279,
-0.44519099593162537,
0.5952917337417603,
0.6849162578582764,
-0.36310896277427673,
0.6866238713264465,
-0.3015901446342468,
0.5000472068786621,
0.16221332550048828,
-0.0496458038687706,
-0.020490247756242752,
-0.6165468692779541,
-0.7899487614631653,
-0.05039219558238983,
0.4950824975967407,
0.1797345131635666,
-0.7488880753517151,
0.48284053802490234,
-0.14679910242557526,
-0.24284476041793823,
-0.5013681054115295,
-0.21806825697422028,
0.24055582284927368,
-0.058784354478120804,
0.12835827469825745,
-0.349446177482605,
-0.7747039794921875,
-0.8401201367378235,
-0.143431156873703,
-0.2634640336036682,
-0.06449826061725616,
0.028915822505950928,
0.3191854953765869,
0.022233329713344574,
0.8318874835968018,
-0.24334664642810822,
0.11446283757686615,
-0.7222057580947876,
-0.018499435856938362,
0.4154191017150879,
0.4464232921600342,
0.1666969656944275,
-0.6395180821418762,
-0.010862677358090878,
-0.04085368663072586,
-0.7220972776412964,
0.34408068656921387,
-0.43962526321411133,
-0.2020091861486435,
0.3284967839717865,
0.25876379013061523,
-0.7632508277893066,
0.5503206253051758,
0.42515793442726135,
-0.3916279971599579,
0.6028692126274109,
-0.5996299386024475,
0.03367201238870621,
-0.7167670130729675,
-0.29370948672294617,
-0.3718743920326233,
-0.3698088824748993,
-0.46252739429473877,
0.11765486001968384,
-0.1035880595445633,
0.047638021409511566,
-0.19039352238178253,
0.23124666512012482,
-0.3290504217147827,
-0.5337258577346802,
-0.29783815145492554,
0.40413931012153625,
-0.19020240008831024,
0.279679536819458,
0.40233203768730164,
0.8975419402122498,
0.5757691860198975,
-0.7671533823013306,
0.15379837155342102,
-0.2529617249965668,
-0.4377129077911377,
0.1357005536556244,
-0.5428597927093506,
-0.04736650735139847,
-0.21419154107570648,
0.5823218822479248,
-0.9657874703407288,
0.011012486182153225,
-0.08477147668600082,
-0.3013322055339813,
0.057846248149871826,
0.24251562356948853,
-0.6374289989471436,
-0.5449275970458984,
0.009426954202353954,
0.7387512922286987,
0.5462626814842224,
-0.5165201425552368,
0.4985530972480774,
0.27128949761390686,
0.3286590278148651,
-0.548621416091919,
-0.7858577966690063,
-0.03610823675990105,
0.13646480441093445,
-0.4295940399169922,
0.404127836227417,
0.30124765634536743,
-0.36226189136505127,
0.17349445819854736,
-0.12197861820459366,
0.02500639297068119,
-0.031097089871764183,
-0.0749451220035553,
0.09704069048166275,
-0.2963762879371643,
0.5598580241203308,
-0.15822698175907135,
-0.15638098120689392,
0.07001877576112747,
-0.664959192276001,
0.9733218550682068,
-0.4195907711982727,
-0.4613139033317566,
-0.044131726026535034,
0.25431907176971436,
0.4115305244922638,
-0.1220630556344986,
1.062781572341919,
0.25317174196243286,
-0.48396623134613037,
-0.24388809502124786,
-0.2504664361476898,
-0.24138358235359192,
-0.41520246863365173,
0.09089650213718414,
-0.3943471610546112,
-0.783609926700592,
0.6212272644042969,
0.21245121955871582,
-0.2224266678094864,
0.5778377056121826,
0.4289027154445648,
-0.2618509531021118,
0.9859417676925659,
0.3234356641769409,
0.29249587655067444,
0.2813419997692108,
-0.5571935176849365,
0.5058259963989258,
-0.9805749654769897,
-0.24341340363025665,
-0.26704439520835876,
-0.4443676471710205,
-0.867773175239563,
-0.770662784576416,
-0.0303898174315691,
0.34960317611694336,
-0.6403869390487671,
0.70621657371521,
-0.6657439470291138,
0.5613385438919067,
0.6756383776664734,
0.14057135581970215,
0.1280706524848938,
-0.01582736149430275,
-0.3236736059188843,
0.40091705322265625,
-0.9162713289260864,
-0.7692195773124695,
0.9091134667396545,
0.31647756695747375,
0.8001156449317932,
0.05280603840947151,
0.7068538069725037,
0.09723743796348572,
0.2660163640975952,
-0.345852255821228,
0.7181723117828369,
-0.3228107690811157,
-0.6250251531600952,
-0.0930517166852951,
-0.38556617498397827,
-1.0098836421966553,
0.22370539605617523,
-0.14313606917858124,
-1.0615229606628418,
0.33552151918411255,
0.08050136268138885,
-0.15337127447128296,
0.9850859045982361,
-0.3385871946811676,
0.47434887290000916,
-0.05469324439764023,
-0.08818035572767258,
-0.43089285492897034,
-0.3808687925338745,
0.4904959499835968,
0.23740315437316895,
0.03797882795333862,
0.03712524101138115,
0.020442554727196693,
0.8065032362937927,
-0.6722457408905029,
0.6336859464645386,
0.11029863357543945,
-0.17854785919189453,
0.9271923899650574,
0.28372427821159363,
0.40801000595092773,
-0.12198498845100403,
-0.08864902704954147,
0.05387667939066887,
-0.10900173336267471,
-0.22547438740730286,
-0.6927646398544312,
0.6387475728988647,
-0.5928912162780762,
-0.6400872468948364,
-0.5235494375228882,
-0.6151034235954285,
-0.2688641846179962,
-0.16457194089889526,
0.17820999026298523,
0.3877992033958435,
0.19716183841228485,
0.3070126175880432,
0.6047208309173584,
-0.2458234578371048,
0.41747984290122986,
-0.2348834127187729,
-0.6342859864234924,
-0.4529086947441101,
0.7382402420043945,
0.3204393684864044,
0.7107319831848145,
0.38599893450737,
0.04719613119959831,
-0.4402172565460205,
-0.2630394697189331,
-0.3419249653816223,
0.08018186688423157,
-0.906660258769989,
-0.10530371963977814,
-0.4395759403705597,
-0.591717541217804,
0.018017413094639778,
-0.2042301893234253,
-0.2771996259689331,
-0.8276410102844238,
0.15295365452766418,
-0.2817709743976593,
0.4345308840274811,
0.8344350457191467,
0.2209739089012146,
0.3535400927066803,
-0.5448973774909973,
0.2687920928001404,
0.3127877712249756,
0.7107875347137451,
0.387495756149292,
-0.23651793599128723,
-0.09567403048276901,
0.2108163982629776,
-0.43963396549224854,
-0.8963253498077393,
0.06628791242837906,
-0.11389617621898651,
0.5135164856910706,
0.1833927482366562,
-0.0820424035191536,
0.5192663073539734,
-0.4375110864639282,
0.7852250337600708,
0.5088539719581604,
-0.7648949027061462,
0.37604010105133057,
-0.15409860014915466,
0.14960873126983643,
0.19896648824214935,
0.3160175681114197,
-0.31843283772468567,
-0.8591054677963257,
-1.0340903997421265,
-0.6601999402046204,
0.4079718589782715,
0.5054991245269775,
0.047568660229444504,
-0.5915674567222595,
0.2080129235982895,
0.030694130808115005,
0.13259249925613403,
-0.5949405431747437,
-0.000333357515046373,
0.016296567395329475,
-0.3248169422149658,
-0.13722632825374603,
-0.16520650684833527,
0.319317489862442,
-0.25368353724479675,
0.49735787510871887,
0.03960062563419342,
0.6946655511856079,
0.20546755194664001,
-0.04127911478281021,
-0.10198115557432175,
0.4212557375431061,
0.5695720911026001,
0.9771062135696411,
-0.22012300789356232,
0.7124840617179871,
0.2014969140291214,
-0.25201383233070374,
0.4901024401187897,
-0.4968632161617279,
0.10504032671451569,
0.10159827768802643,
0.6159906387329102,
0.9461750984191895,
0.36432945728302,
-0.7644229531288147,
0.23555819690227509,
0.04035589098930359,
-0.0756392627954483,
-0.34411492943763733,
0.344531774520874,
0.4430680274963379,
0.21845558285713196,
0.22487153112888336,
0.44730430841445923,
-0.037515491247177124,
-0.9126043319702148,
0.3400424122810364,
0.28237003087997437,
-0.39109155535697937,
-0.1766590178012848,
0.7057989239692688,
-0.17808811366558075,
-0.6206932067871094,
0.6537039279937744,
-0.16284364461898804,
-0.5603600740432739,
0.864165186882019,
0.9001818895339966,
0.9077230095863342,
-0.14047272503376007,
0.1881953626871109,
0.4888961911201477,
0.15703611075878143,
-0.4582274258136749,
0.4998849332332611,
-0.11663620173931122,
-0.8550702333450317,
-0.4863225221633911,
-0.6831872463226318,
-0.21834923326969147,
-0.06539967656135559,
-0.5153259038925171,
0.08135155588388443,
-0.6612390875816345,
-0.48765039443969727,
-0.22864311933517456,
-0.4613345265388489,
-0.5212281346321106,
0.279308944940567,
0.2656870186328888,
0.8625933527946472,
-0.41303765773773193,
0.8589149117469788,
0.21356908977031708,
-0.4458010792732239,
-0.670161247253418,
-0.025227058678865433,
-0.7473282814025879,
-0.5798517465591431,
0.7069250345230103,
0.27652060985565186,
-0.34069252014160156,
-0.3725522756576538,
-0.2195744663476944,
-0.9395486116409302,
0.8113473653793335,
0.5321847200393677,
-1.1134686470031738,
0.12910093367099762,
0.3350123167037964,
0.74473637342453,
-0.683506190776825,
0.2991134822368622,
0.7176417112350464,
0.11678040027618408,
-0.02595931850373745,
-0.849539577960968,
0.08665896207094193,
0.1809127777814865,
0.32726016640663147,
0.42468205094337463,
-0.1161794438958168,
0.9244480729103088,
-0.44584017992019653,
-0.22633399069309235,
-0.08751613646745682,
0.7533334493637085,
0.7370942831039429,
0.05100632831454277,
0.6086772084236145,
0.49556395411491394,
0.8201506733894348,
-0.21994535624980927,
1.4867786169052124,
-0.2429545372724533,
0.23076120018959045,
1.2202231884002686,
-0.09457714855670929,
1.1923272609710693,
0.41829022765159607,
-0.5532888174057007,
0.8889687061309814,
0.488168329000473,
0.47637930512428284,
0.3961849808692932,
0.6949284672737122,
-0.4107096493244171,
-0.5657678842544556,
0.18806377053260803,
-0.20358018577098846,
0.08108454942703247,
0.2851455509662628,
-0.7083578705787659,
0.07491663098335266,
0.041303280740976334,
-0.40835481882095337,
0.3803149163722992,
-0.32151588797569275,
0.7292537093162537,
0.411082923412323,
-0.8764147758483887,
0.9998806715011597,
-0.16771617531776428,
0.27180469036102295,
-0.23715177178382874,
0.059027593582868576,
0.10662561655044556,
0.443270742893219,
-0.03899397701025009,
-1.2535346746444702,
0.5668346881866455,
-0.01683766208589077,
-0.20612382888793945,
-0.0770956426858902,
0.703973114490509,
-0.4963729977607727,
-0.8079298138618469,
0.4647413194179535,
0.12005855143070221,
0.25439953804016113,
0.13445670902729034,
-0.25396648049354553,
0.022761860862374306,
-0.45769983530044556,
-0.11169229447841644,
0.21444639563560486,
0.35771444439888,
-0.38071519136428833,
0.8338895440101624,
0.22374063730239868,
0.32865509390830994,
0.17143018543720245,
0.4507252871990204,
0.6904767155647278,
-0.6735897064208984,
-0.29538804292678833,
-1.0210648775100708,
0.3455326557159424,
-0.06369418650865555,
0.012350744567811489,
0.11772818863391876,
0.3436325192451477,
0.8243169784545898,
-0.2153453677892685,
0.724041223526001,
-0.06906937062740326,
-0.1082405373454094,
-0.550184965133667,
0.6445969939231873,
-0.16756410896778107,
0.264655739068985,
0.027061374858021736,
-0.8659553527832031,
-0.21563716232776642,
0.9810380339622498,
-0.44312867522239685,
0.15434642136096954,
0.979030191898346,
0.559197187423706,
-0.1302628219127655,
0.24598832428455353,
0.37560999393463135,
0.06208692118525505,
0.21759392321109772,
0.9057705998420715,
1.0435701608657837,
-0.5810084342956543,
0.20813262462615967,
-0.029141707345843315,
-0.0011402913369238377,
0.1589408814907074,
-0.68666011095047,
-0.6811556220054626,
-0.9353960156440735,
-0.1650056391954422,
-0.35490483045578003,
0.006724854931235313,
0.9954788088798523,
0.5734742283821106,
-0.8617985844612122,
-0.3464342951774597,
-0.7915824055671692,
0.47696083784103394,
-0.6091265082359314,
-0.15300150215625763,
0.2820974290370941,
-0.693722128868103,
-0.2533778250217438,
0.09217915683984756,
0.2168719470500946,
-0.200065016746521,
-0.4047030508518219,
-0.3122032880783081,
-0.23527920246124268,
0.5618506073951721,
0.7297563552856445,
-0.26370859146118164,
-1.0218607187271118,
-0.4178236126899719,
-0.18176241219043732,
0.05327733978629112,
0.1321839839220047,
1.0250283479690552,
-1.002037525177002,
0.43873271346092224,
0.7066448926925659,
0.4287739098072052,
0.423658162355423,
-0.3532029390335083,
0.8865240812301636,
-0.6256541609764099,
0.10486968606710434,
0.34959733486175537,
0.7236495018005371,
0.11653424054384232,
-0.132108673453331,
0.4548802673816681,
-0.015305344015359879,
-0.4718892574310303,
-0.7722627520561218,
0.5404506921768188,
-0.7806670069694519,
-0.49486544728279114,
1.060228943824768,
-0.11772280186414719,
-0.35576629638671875,
0.04068276658654213,
-0.20909225940704346,
0.316384494304657,
0.030833378434181213,
0.6739782094955444,
0.7228429317474365,
-0.09968309849500656,
-0.34093573689460754,
-0.33707526326179504,
0.467173308134079,
0.21553094685077667,
-0.5787318348884583,
0.3331366181373596,
-0.058449532836675644,
-0.004384164698421955,
0.34916314482688904,
0.818085789680481,
-0.16370712220668793,
0.30367133021354675,
0.015777815133333206,
-0.026541313156485558,
0.3364047408103943,
-0.667905867099762,
-0.0914260745048523,
0.1781551092863083,
0.2629338502883911,
-0.001131862518377602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14192v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14192v1 | Timo: Towards Better Temporal Reasoning for Language Models | 2024-06-20T10:52:14 | 2024-06-20T10:52:14 | Zhaochen Su, Jun Zhang, Tong Zhu, Xiaoye Qu, Juntao Li, Min Zhang, Yu Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Reasoning about time is essential for Large Language Models (LLMs) to
understand the world. Previous works focus on solving specific tasks, primarily
on time-sensitive question answering. While these methods have proven
effective, they cannot generalize to a wider spectrum of temporal reasoning
tasks. Therefore, we propose a crucial question: Can we build a universal
framework to handle a variety of temporal reasoning tasks? To that end, we
systematically study 38 temporal reasoning tasks. Based on the observation that
19 tasks are directly related to mathematics, we first leverage the available
mathematical dataset to set a solid foundation for temporal reasoning. However,
the in-depth study indicates that focusing solely on mathematical enhancement
falls short of addressing pure temporal reasoning tasks. To mitigate this
limitation, we propose a simple but effective self-critic temporal optimization
method to enhance the model's temporal reasoning capabilities without
sacrificing general task abilities. Finally, we develop Timo, a model designed
to excel in temporal reasoning at the 7B and 13B scales. Notably, Timo
outperforms the counterpart LLMs by 10.0 and 7.6 in average accuracy scores and
achieves the new state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance of comparable size.
Extensive experiments further validate our framework's effectiveness and its
generalization across diverse temporal tasks. The code is available at
https://github.com/zhaochen0110/Timo. | [
-0.1281762570142746,
-0.7189618945121765,
0.9278072714805603,
0.6111098527908325,
-0.22825847566127777,
0.12027516216039658,
-0.17684689164161682,
-0.7527284622192383,
-0.2806166410446167,
0.3471491038799286,
-0.7205686569213867,
-0.3482837378978729,
-0.3231740891933441,
0.21188011765480042,
-0.15104001760482788,
0.7139397859573364,
0.10494930297136307,
-0.1047537550330162,
0.13325373828411102,
-0.18470025062561035,
-0.2544862926006317,
-0.24909456074237823,
-0.9704214930534363,
-0.7007409930229187,
0.6969663500785828,
0.19266319274902344,
0.6002337336540222,
0.7483208179473877,
0.3179580569267273,
0.25954487919807434,
-0.19462472200393677,
0.3250791132450104,
-0.034770749509334564,
0.21775738894939423,
-0.36131003499031067,
-0.5378643870353699,
-0.5558322072029114,
-0.25489115715026855,
0.4560278654098511,
0.6239443421363831,
-0.19405245780944824,
0.1809977889060974,
-0.13977743685245514,
0.3468858599662781,
-0.4653889536857605,
0.07349465042352676,
-0.5598074197769165,
0.23023830354213715,
-0.2690790593624115,
-0.11426325142383575,
-0.3025358319282532,
-0.23041078448295593,
-0.13065385818481445,
-0.8096879124641418,
0.03023938089609146,
0.3290604054927826,
0.6542861461639404,
0.415274977684021,
-0.42878398299217224,
0.17074717581272125,
-0.9938883781433105,
1.0058051347732544,
-0.7160055637359619,
0.5890949368476868,
0.16727031767368317,
0.4743228554725647,
0.10610514879226685,
-0.5916081666946411,
-0.5822599530220032,
-0.3553068935871124,
0.3843979835510254,
-0.022949066013097763,
-0.14324228465557098,
-0.00025590788573026657,
0.43812596797943115,
0.12494205683469772,
-0.5853805541992188,
0.1168379932641983,
0.1292276382446289,
-0.097461998462677,
0.24248389899730682,
0.24705882370471954,
0.28123927116394043,
-0.08793222904205322,
-0.16970933973789215,
0.0971112847328186,
-0.5402911901473999,
0.05217398703098297,
0.3790372908115387,
0.04797082394361496,
0.06538517773151398,
0.17041806876659393,
0.021921679377555847,
0.49525395035743713,
-0.17927142977714539,
-0.01785065047442913,
-0.2801402509212494,
-0.2707758843898773,
-0.22253702580928802,
-0.37496525049209595,
0.6184406280517578,
0.22588352859020233,
0.5834091305732727,
-0.3724305033683777,
-0.25207027792930603,
0.07158669084310532,
0.22644643485546112,
-0.6481227874755859,
0.19467833638191223,
0.31836816668510437,
-0.060521773993968964,
-0.273887574672699,
-0.2876414358615875,
-0.5589209198951721,
0.12069002538919449,
-0.3931438624858856,
0.19967278838157654,
-0.48399990797042847,
-0.16656018793582916,
0.23241648077964783,
0.06311848014593124,
-0.2131892293691635,
0.5504370331764221,
-0.6396127939224243,
0.2726544737815857,
0.6484500765800476,
0.6141855716705322,
0.23269107937812805,
-0.485270619392395,
-0.5705704689025879,
0.4652248024940491,
-0.6157965660095215,
0.8617997765541077,
-0.6368775367736816,
-0.3729284703731537,
-0.25613081455230713,
-0.30394843220710754,
0.02719886787235737,
-0.5488836765289307,
0.6259740591049194,
-0.5926962494850159,
0.2931531071662903,
-0.21576528251171112,
-0.16558197140693665,
0.07372381538152695,
0.289923757314682,
-0.5214141011238098,
1.1983622312545776,
0.19403022527694702,
-0.3229439854621887,
0.17862196266651154,
-0.7612085342407227,
-0.45127588510513306,
-0.14384108781814575,
-0.022258849814534187,
-0.2911263406276703,
0.16264694929122925,
0.5764046907424927,
0.21418143808841705,
-0.8211739659309387,
0.736186683177948,
-0.5380562543869019,
-0.3227783441543579,
0.5935267806053162,
-0.08277449011802673,
0.7651602625846863,
0.7803000807762146,
-0.38743701577186584,
0.04873072728514671,
-0.5007308721542358,
0.18302839994430542,
0.24309253692626953,
-0.008635062724351883,
-0.20624196529388428,
-0.11909022182226181,
0.054726652801036835,
0.0466567799448967,
0.15064679086208344,
-0.5675159096717834,
0.266803115606308,
-0.40736865997314453,
0.8064859509468079,
0.9774429202079773,
-0.1707843840122223,
0.5369382500648499,
-0.49675673246383667,
0.5750607848167419,
-0.11805867403745651,
0.725623369216919,
-0.06341139227151871,
-0.1637294739484787,
-0.5056009888648987,
-0.09708833694458008,
0.2762499451637268,
0.5356241464614868,
-0.8291535973548889,
0.26170745491981506,
-0.38908788561820984,
-0.274909645318985,
-0.20579040050506592,
0.2686857283115387,
0.5593568086624146,
0.49174773693084717,
0.15475352108478546,
0.06385845690965652,
-0.4289817810058594,
-0.6704131960868835,
-0.4569818377494812,
-0.283171147108078,
-0.09930765628814697,
0.273453027009964,
0.49751853942871094,
-0.1048053428530693,
0.8478679656982422,
-0.544335126876831,
-0.15313959121704102,
-0.39713481068611145,
0.02841358259320259,
0.24916452169418335,
0.25264933705329895,
0.7839064598083496,
-0.6013973355293274,
-0.05490925908088684,
0.01735694892704487,
-0.8728673458099365,
-0.48928147554397583,
-0.24454696476459503,
-0.043810855597257614,
0.15199849009513855,
0.373233437538147,
-0.3858188986778259,
-0.09102076292037964,
0.21240825951099396,
-0.29268738627433777,
0.32580187916755676,
-0.05676577612757683,
0.1768442988395691,
-0.9877055883407593,
0.10736758261919022,
0.022187454625964165,
-0.24553675949573517,
-0.36118292808532715,
0.26471027731895447,
-0.11231729388237,
-0.39317935705184937,
-0.24506135284900665,
1.1276490688323975,
-0.14639724791049957,
0.07263711094856262,
-0.18594174087047577,
0.002222045324742794,
0.21137170493602753,
0.5500989556312561,
-0.28660985827445984,
0.5927876234054565,
0.33853596448898315,
-0.5809856653213501,
0.3213123381137848,
-0.33537155389785767,
-0.3131486773490906,
0.37438395619392395,
-0.8613879680633545,
0.39648178219795227,
-0.0016056516906246543,
0.029875032603740692,
-0.6954201459884644,
0.012192102149128914,
0.26474398374557495,
-0.5722256898880005,
0.24502253532409668,
-0.33264532685279846,
-0.8495298027992249,
-0.32057490944862366,
-0.09215997159481049,
0.5014592409133911,
0.26512715220451355,
-0.5186348557472229,
0.9064124226570129,
0.1496603786945343,
-0.0012252968735992908,
-0.6517149209976196,
-0.7507607340812683,
0.06005380302667618,
-0.2603946626186371,
-0.7086566090583801,
0.4355315566062927,
-0.33442357182502747,
-0.6435096263885498,
0.08693967759609222,
-0.5164942145347595,
-0.1135944351553917,
0.21869254112243652,
0.006703433580696583,
0.18124738335609436,
-0.19550518691539764,
0.3560050129890442,
0.1529305875301361,
-0.3091117739677429,
0.053616493940353394,
-0.6882364749908447,
0.514735758304596,
-0.17168846726417542,
-0.23476941883563995,
-0.4198964834213257,
0.18890002369880676,
0.48919805884361267,
-0.25762292742729187,
0.4636654257774353,
0.42023879289627075,
-0.4747544527053833,
-0.482636421918869,
-0.7677227258682251,
-0.08865904808044434,
-0.45771434903144836,
-0.0747118815779686,
-0.6974136233329773,
-0.9653022289276123,
0.6703864336013794,
-0.10451886802911758,
0.09431913495063782,
0.4565436840057373,
0.15063577890396118,
-0.2932138442993164,
0.9241425395011902,
0.44667524099349976,
-0.008771679364144802,
0.7795940637588501,
-0.3589978516101837,
0.030106838792562485,
-0.6533209085464478,
-0.2514413297176361,
-0.5999960899353027,
-0.1315983086824417,
-0.09629005938768387,
-0.34025269746780396,
0.3021198809146881,
-0.00007435333100147545,
-0.449445515871048,
0.20877279341220856,
-0.4471936523914337,
0.43670517206192017,
0.459250271320343,
0.044128574430942535,
0.34132957458496094,
-0.01969335786998272,
-0.24106691777706146,
-0.07500561326742172,
-0.530022919178009,
-0.5029352903366089,
0.9364539980888367,
0.22191739082336426,
0.7551054954528809,
0.10355859249830246,
0.4806269109249115,
0.34019890427589417,
0.2398151457309723,
-0.38446131348609924,
0.6350426077842712,
-0.29127824306488037,
-0.9333345890045166,
-0.49837708473205566,
-0.8294906616210938,
-0.8742779493331909,
0.09468195587396622,
0.16432815790176392,
-0.6967913508415222,
-0.06587916612625122,
0.050061244517564774,
-0.4628533124923706,
0.3717426061630249,
-0.6713846325874329,
1.0424439907073975,
-0.48373353481292725,
-0.419546902179718,
-0.3917195498943329,
-0.43727415800094604,
0.08158715069293976,
-0.03383307531476021,
0.4970254600048065,
-0.5104141235351562,
-0.14703625440597534,
0.5409084558486938,
-0.4351261258125305,
0.8402734398841858,
-0.0834885910153389,
0.059533774852752686,
0.5164235830307007,
0.4838561415672302,
0.20910127460956573,
0.32955941557884216,
-0.13179528713226318,
0.10019700229167938,
0.3897869288921356,
-0.4741428792476654,
-1.1670912504196167,
0.7410358190536499,
-0.7972407937049866,
-0.5971724987030029,
-0.5305694937705994,
-0.6883799433708191,
-0.05857766047120094,
-0.030799729749560356,
-0.07615417242050171,
0.6312564015388489,
0.04898129403591156,
-0.1484462320804596,
0.5275976657867432,
0.08377232402563095,
0.5152080059051514,
0.7112062573432922,
-0.4398418962955475,
-0.47969987988471985,
0.555671215057373,
0.1279137283563614,
0.05217527598142624,
1.0156667232513428,
0.5669130682945251,
-0.3978254497051239,
-0.4226601719856262,
-0.3023538589477539,
0.4294305741786957,
-0.5868560075759888,
-0.06840919703245163,
-0.4902268648147583,
-0.01211601309478283,
-0.5368025898933411,
0.08598402142524719,
-0.2803008556365967,
-0.7489386796951294,
0.057160742580890656,
0.1317283660173416,
0.32582297921180725,
0.5165566802024841,
-0.08609041571617126,
0.3946511149406433,
-0.7248132228851318,
0.36908385157585144,
0.394937127828598,
0.3549133539199829,
-0.014569793827831745,
-0.6455726623535156,
0.016169773414731026,
-0.29124099016189575,
-0.2877154052257538,
-0.5478953123092651,
0.20211830735206604,
0.016155878081917763,
0.6338645219802856,
0.4096130132675171,
0.06703989207744598,
0.7673239707946777,
-0.4777683615684509,
0.36890891194343567,
-0.04504205286502838,
-1.2287911176681519,
1.0263410806655884,
-0.44102123379707336,
0.4146102964878082,
0.06525959074497223,
0.09165970981121063,
-0.5403944253921509,
-0.3336968719959259,
-0.7832647562026978,
-0.43510884046554565,
0.6007235050201416,
0.27202174067497253,
-0.016037290915846825,
0.06713717430830002,
0.7633883953094482,
0.054352618753910065,
-0.018633490428328514,
-0.849864661693573,
0.10543961077928543,
-0.053721316158771515,
-0.1305091232061386,
-0.08828717470169067,
-0.12927576899528503,
-0.07929520308971405,
-0.039828941226005554,
0.39822813868522644,
-0.24660556018352509,
0.20305486023426056,
0.16554047167301178,
-0.08532365411520004,
-0.3302471935749054,
0.5350926518440247,
0.38285404443740845,
0.8467460870742798,
-0.15621502697467804,
0.21471036970615387,
0.35758915543556213,
-0.09561316668987274,
0.07034792006015778,
0.2713850438594818,
-0.09834813326597214,
-0.23116512596607208,
0.6903796195983887,
0.3547200858592987,
0.2940694987773895,
-0.6234675049781799,
0.08533157408237457,
-0.09533507376909256,
0.15249103307724,
-0.3655555844306946,
0.2072581797838211,
-0.13165436685085297,
0.6250283122062683,
0.32634082436561584,
-0.032965194433927536,
-0.06671568751335144,
-0.7404120564460754,
-0.15675586462020874,
0.1545640379190445,
-0.019344938918948174,
-0.5215486884117126,
1.0134950876235962,
0.17571145296096802,
-0.41237208247184753,
0.5514295101165771,
-0.13456091284751892,
-0.42157652974128723,
0.7650876045227051,
0.5178288221359253,
0.8796826004981995,
-0.36586517095565796,
0.03658326342701912,
0.22556732594966888,
0.46476486325263977,
-0.15012815594673157,
0.5571574568748474,
-0.2829381823539734,
-0.7875289916992188,
-0.7577338218688965,
-0.5656953454017639,
-0.45442378520965576,
-0.018125785514712334,
-0.3373671770095825,
-0.05599777773022652,
-0.7755234837532043,
-0.5290701985359192,
-0.01881437748670578,
0.20582883059978485,
-0.4806392192840576,
0.29817622900009155,
-0.13141827285289764,
0.6784180998802185,
-0.6366506814956665,
0.8947893977165222,
0.7563063502311707,
-0.4787977933883667,
-0.454001784324646,
-0.06779161095619202,
-0.11292833089828491,
-0.9085578918457031,
0.9248946309089661,
-0.07431740313768387,
-0.45747214555740356,
-0.19500364363193512,
-0.5277767777442932,
-0.6931214928627014,
0.935254693031311,
0.7643510103225708,
-0.6546700596809387,
-0.2974335551261902,
0.03623642027378082,
0.7173409461975098,
-0.2064990997314453,
0.2220333218574524,
0.12974248826503754,
0.3714221119880676,
0.19495873153209686,
-0.9059411883354187,
0.01442986261099577,
-0.2566852867603302,
0.15966401994228363,
0.35147520899772644,
-0.7854540944099426,
0.46288353204727173,
-0.45374634861946106,
-0.17452874779701233,
0.23995621502399445,
0.6553685665130615,
0.2796589434146881,
0.665626049041748,
0.6588869690895081,
0.7387391924858093,
0.5680056214332581,
-0.38617658615112305,
1.3840253353118896,
-0.32335180044174194,
0.07476435601711273,
1.0240226984024048,
-0.31505492329597473,
0.30652686953544617,
0.3009229004383087,
-0.3285157382488251,
0.31111904978752136,
0.6309536099433899,
0.2595982253551483,
0.23409076035022736,
0.10891316831111908,
-0.23796425759792328,
-0.8546487092971802,
-0.4029969274997711,
-0.2208806723356247,
0.13845473527908325,
0.19726236164569855,
0.04998118057847023,
-0.11531484127044678,
0.00044905702816322446,
0.14402179419994354,
0.29165953397750854,
-0.09662218391895294,
0.29441913962364197,
0.3524055778980255,
-0.6895160675048828,
0.03636296093463898,
0.07707524299621582,
0.11051595956087112,
-0.7662599682807922,
0.11824002861976624,
-0.49256426095962524,
0.5227460265159607,
0.15995179116725922,
-0.8532618284225464,
0.4664187431335449,
0.11580894887447357,
-0.12284484505653381,
-0.5700227618217468,
0.39564839005470276,
0.09235046058893204,
-0.469583660364151,
0.6005262136459351,
0.6933887004852295,
0.014018379151821136,
-0.26700878143310547,
-0.7221609950065613,
0.1471538245677948,
-0.2345961481332779,
-0.025137461721897125,
0.13482709228992462,
0.8740405440330505,
-0.17479759454727173,
1.1631003618240356,
0.6457424163818359,
0.1732909232378006,
-0.19852079451084137,
0.7457842826843262,
0.6174558401107788,
-0.9188733100891113,
-0.47425979375839233,
-0.9299135804176331,
0.0062122344970703125,
0.07873354852199554,
-0.5122426748275757,
0.39935413002967834,
0.6270604729652405,
0.9276876449584961,
0.13728927075862885,
0.4145214557647705,
0.20330746471881866,
0.6264382600784302,
-0.8169419169425964,
0.17520974576473236,
-0.8875138163566589,
0.5296345949172974,
-0.12478528916835785,
-0.9819933176040649,
-0.5408141613006592,
0.48459702730178833,
-0.48471617698669434,
0.2720174789428711,
0.7802380323410034,
0.5531004667282104,
0.07552894204854965,
0.032905615866184235,
0.39289623498916626,
0.2024548053741455,
0.41694873571395874,
0.9189132452011108,
1.3653594255447388,
-0.16643983125686646,
1.027091145515442,
-0.4057150185108185,
0.04569197818636894,
0.12429392337799072,
-0.8939715623855591,
-1.1145790815353394,
-0.4848114252090454,
-0.280475378036499,
-0.1155676320195198,
0.5185195207595825,
0.9161622524261475,
0.6759675145149231,
-0.5035408735275269,
-0.31195124983787537,
0.14443381130695343,
0.23812049627304077,
-0.4032914638519287,
-0.21665415167808533,
0.1451694667339325,
-0.4430253505706787,
-0.9031214118003845,
0.39990270137786865,
0.42930537462234497,
-0.0029811542481184006,
0.18662405014038086,
0.06865854561328888,
0.11313719302415848,
-0.060783691704273224,
0.466918021440506,
0.26616522669792175,
-0.9629654288291931,
-0.5037794709205627,
0.3690144419670105,
0.06360626220703125,
0.03546974062919617,
1.1379131078720093,
-0.6058476567268372,
0.4075177013874054,
0.39902302622795105,
0.4845457971096039,
0.7685568928718567,
-0.3604336977005005,
0.5324085354804993,
-0.627816915512085,
-0.05476325377821922,
0.42946362495422363,
0.5986566543579102,
0.17339472472667694,
-0.21381068229675293,
0.862754225730896,
0.47359129786491394,
-0.4998396933078766,
-0.7965610027313232,
0.3534574806690216,
-1.0334330797195435,
-0.5841778516769409,
0.7999500632286072,
0.04209471121430397,
-0.26211628317832947,
0.006255283020436764,
0.012026338838040829,
0.4268777072429657,
-0.5512239336967468,
1.002097487449646,
0.7462580800056458,
-0.28341156244277954,
-0.4402407109737396,
-0.5479702353477478,
0.06843441724777222,
0.5900863409042358,
-0.9292077422142029,
-0.02932075783610344,
0.20429930090904236,
0.5077858567237854,
0.1618949919939041,
0.6809968948364258,
-0.21216054260730743,
0.3047022521495819,
-0.11792529374361038,
-0.07277252525091171,
-0.4035033881664276,
-0.7172577381134033,
-0.17578749358654022,
0.01538391038775444,
0.11383461207151413,
0.11317342519760132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14191v1 | Temporal Knowledge Graph Question Answering: A Survey | 2024-06-20T10:51:06 | 2024-06-20T10:51:06 | Miao Su, ZiXuan Li, Zhuo Chen, Long Bai, Xiaolong Jin, Jiafeng Guo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Knowledge Base Question Answering (KBQA) has been a long-standing field to
answer questions based on knowledge bases. Recently, the evolving dynamics of
knowledge have attracted a growing interest in Temporal Knowledge Graph
Question Answering (TKGQA), an emerging task to answer temporal questions.
However, this field grapples with ambiguities in defining temporal questions
and lacks a systematic categorization of existing methods for TKGQA. In
response, this paper provides a thorough survey from two perspectives: the
taxonomy of temporal questions and the methodological categorization for TKGQA.
Specifically, we first establish a detailed taxonomy of temporal questions
engaged in prior studies. Subsequently, we provide a comprehensive review of
TKGQA techniques of two categories: semantic parsing-based and TKG
embedding-based. Building on this review, the paper outlines potential research
directions aimed at advancing the field of TKGQA. This work aims to serve as a
comprehensive reference for TKGQA and to stimulate further research. | [
-0.30335578322410583,
-1.143652081489563,
0.8419478535652161,
0.13650210201740265,
-0.19466741383075714,
0.775834858417511,
0.33011460304260254,
-0.5528679490089417,
0.04214250296354294,
0.33667540550231934,
-0.6017526984214783,
-0.6084493398666382,
-0.5062971115112305,
-0.18797069787979126,
-0.041470762342214584,
0.22911784052848816,
-0.5326994061470032,
-0.08522985130548477,
-0.3481042981147766,
-0.25389960408210754,
-0.5955687165260315,
-0.4721328020095825,
-0.6710059642791748,
-0.5355274677276611,
0.7136620283126831,
0.21044011414051056,
0.390637069940567,
0.5561965107917786,
-0.13679850101470947,
0.13357160985469818,
-0.20303204655647278,
-0.07839010655879974,
-0.10504648089408875,
0.2548847496509552,
-0.008054383099079132,
-0.32570528984069824,
-0.3332614004611969,
-0.20078174769878387,
0.5137830376625061,
1.1014987230300903,
0.06662233918905258,
0.5956367254257202,
-0.23255875706672668,
0.442099928855896,
-0.6477764248847961,
0.39779552817344666,
-0.1315142959356308,
0.40346044301986694,
-0.08242040127515793,
-0.33764198422431946,
-0.32910269498825073,
-0.6125763058662415,
0.25330549478530884,
-0.6987040638923645,
-0.0686606764793396,
0.12976576387882233,
0.7864140868186951,
0.23860715329647064,
-1.114187240600586,
-0.20218044519424438,
-0.6477552056312561,
0.5429213643074036,
-0.48023971915245056,
0.7137040495872498,
0.3000614047050476,
0.8044068217277527,
-0.0001985896669793874,
-1.0318182706832886,
-0.39916256070137024,
-0.04781140014529228,
0.12406338006258011,
0.15578225255012512,
-0.12562377750873566,
-0.012763069011271,
0.09784553200006485,
0.029345698654651642,
-0.6014038920402527,
-0.16085019707679749,
-0.15573418140411377,
-0.4544411301612854,
0.12714020907878876,
0.4650723338127136,
0.28985661268234253,
-0.4349115490913391,
-0.1941339522600174,
0.16193440556526184,
-0.22662849724292755,
0.4361129403114319,
0.21836353838443756,
-0.1757013201713562,
0.36764758825302124,
0.6656789779663086,
-0.6664800643920898,
0.8754751682281494,
0.019758038222789764,
-0.03026040643453598,
0.0011786601971834898,
-0.4341132342815399,
0.01776033453643322,
0.0698741227388382,
0.2613755464553833,
0.6725687980651855,
-0.028517892584204674,
-0.7051412463188171,
0.35666853189468384,
-0.012137267738580704,
0.3040326237678528,
-0.49271729588508606,
-0.1943003088235855,
0.4746282696723938,
-0.4576999247074127,
-0.382070928812027,
-0.35617920756340027,
-0.7146863341331482,
-0.10272403061389923,
-0.20734842121601105,
0.5307154655456543,
-0.17193201184272766,
-0.5411115288734436,
-0.15681825578212738,
-0.5293497443199158,
0.4371338188648224,
0.4464237093925476,
-0.3280341625213623,
0.11500892043113708,
0.8106213212013245,
0.3780250549316406,
0.2679941952228546,
0.14891177415847778,
-0.10228680819272995,
0.5714379549026489,
-0.516807496547699,
0.8049599528312683,
-0.5940995216369629,
-0.31553226709365845,
-0.029849326238036156,
0.26880183815956116,
-0.16191641986370087,
-0.39302951097488403,
0.1172654777765274,
-1.2832610607147217,
0.14711803197860718,
-0.7148230075836182,
-0.7306333184242249,
-0.4025317132472992,
0.7340297102928162,
-0.2855943441390991,
0.8547472357749939,
0.6202347278594971,
-0.7914111018180847,
0.6463572978973389,
-0.49421754479408264,
0.005025181453675032,
0.22919774055480957,
-0.04975423216819763,
0.03245555981993675,
-0.5193799734115601,
0.20606009662151337,
0.348806232213974,
-0.07973950356245041,
0.4635147750377655,
-0.37023189663887024,
0.14092037081718445,
0.22498434782028198,
0.3117051422595978,
0.7740233540534973,
0.34185847640037537,
-0.03221573680639267,
-0.3643515408039093,
-0.42965683341026306,
0.7085820436477661,
-0.03619368374347687,
-0.20629385113716125,
-0.4046827554702759,
0.13126502931118011,
-0.3563675284385681,
0.2861636281013489,
0.37786152958869934,
-0.911436140537262,
0.40282127261161804,
-0.09460368007421494,
0.7347239255905151,
0.3583245277404785,
0.7065208554267883,
0.3794231414794922,
-0.28054600954055786,
0.5918502807617188,
0.14499910175800323,
0.3564479947090149,
0.41922900080680847,
-0.5668901801109314,
-0.3699617087841034,
0.5936521291732788,
0.3357155919075012,
0.5210203528404236,
-1.3302183151245117,
-0.0567343607544899,
-0.36308279633522034,
-0.8146451711654663,
-0.15175046026706696,
-0.2752441465854645,
0.407894492149353,
1.089690089225769,
0.40344128012657166,
-0.16710780560970306,
-0.24819043278694153,
-0.8515374660491943,
-0.16462934017181396,
-0.836997926235199,
0.08072693645954132,
0.7394039034843445,
0.3401797413825989,
0.1740884631872177,
1.1263530254364014,
-0.7711490392684937,
0.3955598771572113,
0.16231949627399445,
0.2189183384180069,
-0.08077551424503326,
-0.0231474582105875,
0.7460314631462097,
-0.7280350923538208,
-0.34993883967399597,
-0.040394190698862076,
-0.8264731168746948,
-0.21004389226436615,
0.452205091714859,
-0.33951106667518616,
0.04537423327565193,
0.598467230796814,
-0.37960347533226013,
0.19561827182769775,
0.17012207210063934,
-0.6543732285499573,
0.37428709864616394,
0.5362508893013,
0.47370097041130066,
-0.9747743010520935,
0.09934548288583755,
-0.7999195456504822,
-0.13458801805973053,
-0.8710067272186279,
-0.0066779726184904575,
0.14332012832164764,
-0.014984714798629284,
-0.40600112080574036,
0.7495412826538086,
0.13736484944820404,
-0.15557709336280823,
0.07364559918642044,
-0.04365014284849167,
0.09447547793388367,
0.5717660784721375,
-0.16614161431789398,
0.21280741691589355,
0.12617209553718567,
-0.6210406422615051,
0.509114682674408,
0.5015503764152527,
-0.17204052209854126,
0.12481974810361862,
-0.5720616579055786,
0.39615103602409363,
-0.22751681506633759,
0.2166711390018463,
-1.0971250534057617,
-0.21913571655750275,
0.7474563717842102,
-0.7026404142379761,
0.512784481048584,
-0.6936365365982056,
-0.588210940361023,
-0.5282512307167053,
0.02081981487572193,
0.6026650071144104,
0.36711302399635315,
-0.36587846279144287,
0.6999087333679199,
0.3055965304374695,
-0.1564820408821106,
-0.8514412045478821,
-0.4956812560558319,
-0.15684261918067932,
-0.23119378089904785,
-0.7758912444114685,
0.15163852274417877,
0.2729843854904175,
-0.4324081540107727,
0.5375295877456665,
-0.5533571839332581,
-0.4312824308872223,
0.1177477091550827,
-0.13503380119800568,
0.0013597029028460383,
-0.38675710558891296,
0.3205038607120514,
0.033813659101724625,
-0.04010290652513504,
0.3104657232761383,
-0.6800540685653687,
0.5255944132804871,
0.29547327756881714,
0.1030527800321579,
0.3227199614048004,
0.3745059370994568,
0.08235200494527817,
0.006166518200188875,
0.6077606081962585,
0.744317352771759,
-0.09409840404987335,
0.20724265277385712,
-0.5518386960029602,
0.32364127039909363,
-0.407059907913208,
0.25406160950660706,
-0.15686257183551788,
-1.338565468788147,
0.5747531056404114,
0.018198078498244286,
0.051959749311208725,
0.5132023096084595,
0.5289744734764099,
-0.5241801142692566,
0.5427232384681702,
0.43668657541275024,
0.2409122884273529,
0.1927972435951233,
-0.15142714977264404,
0.09253130108118057,
-0.7066302299499512,
-0.6811808943748474,
-0.6207711696624756,
-0.19469670951366425,
-0.4825800955295563,
-0.20457451045513153,
0.544353187084198,
0.3310275077819824,
-0.5384211540222168,
0.07500678300857544,
-0.35035255551338196,
-0.036516182124614716,
0.2573643624782562,
0.3349861800670624,
0.23036806285381317,
-0.44912397861480713,
-0.014409041032195091,
0.2919374704360962,
-0.8182804584503174,
-0.37899187207221985,
0.9403572082519531,
0.1769566386938095,
0.40093910694122314,
0.2689202129840851,
0.43556275963783264,
0.0866088941693306,
0.15900878608226776,
-0.8082089424133301,
0.6552340984344482,
0.1549176722764969,
-0.8266733884811401,
-0.6408911347389221,
-0.6218076944351196,
-0.9135124087333679,
-0.11897699534893036,
0.29168614745140076,
-0.8087849617004395,
0.13066837191581726,
0.2382769137620926,
-0.10745672136545181,
0.4817371964454651,
-0.7785768508911133,
1.1454113721847534,
-0.041648756712675095,
0.16743746399879456,
0.04976795241236687,
-0.9489793181419373,
0.3324059247970581,
0.013014095835387707,
-0.16096287965774536,
-0.4138355255126953,
-0.462553471326828,
1.0381184816360474,
-0.3935868740081787,
0.4861597716808319,
-0.6860381364822388,
0.09954456984996796,
0.6637343168258667,
0.18290975689888,
0.019760947674512863,
-0.07630754262208939,
0.3807269334793091,
0.07976410537958145,
0.8507564067840576,
-0.7083382606506348,
-0.9326990842819214,
0.23647905886173248,
-0.8382657766342163,
-0.6959754228591919,
-0.12859761714935303,
-0.4470081925392151,
-0.8798606395721436,
0.2458963692188263,
-0.03905985876917839,
0.593432605266571,
0.041579678654670715,
-0.006382024381309748,
0.5551921725273132,
-0.2993064522743225,
0.4332563579082489,
0.4529997706413269,
-0.21328292787075043,
-0.2625736892223358,
0.5038326978683472,
0.40491217374801636,
0.4078604280948639,
0.9448192715644836,
0.2894752025604248,
-0.45593827962875366,
-0.46149003505706787,
-0.3026503622531891,
0.15229129791259766,
-0.9258735179901123,
-0.15070000290870667,
-1.0323628187179565,
-0.23190879821777344,
-0.665147602558136,
0.1416911482810974,
0.048632774502038956,
-1.002528190612793,
0.04133084788918495,
0.09128326177597046,
0.5316218137741089,
0.5583363175392151,
0.5554779171943665,
0.10335641354322433,
-0.92350172996521,
0.3973426818847656,
0.6764172911643982,
0.35786494612693787,
0.32219257950782776,
-0.12232524156570435,
0.0685107633471489,
-0.2539066672325134,
-0.3353636562824249,
-1.0945762395858765,
-0.20574979484081268,
-0.20374388992786407,
0.7457813024520874,
-0.055866584181785583,
0.3148401081562042,
0.7449848055839539,
-0.4456452429294586,
1.0752588510513306,
-0.21837925910949707,
-0.3502347469329834,
0.3819511830806732,
-0.559224009513855,
0.36687740683555603,
0.3562402129173279,
0.6820607781410217,
-0.9883714914321899,
-0.2790100574493408,
-0.7276468276977539,
-0.7489451766014099,
0.5619843006134033,
0.028574509546160698,
-0.21969522535800934,
0.13849589228630066,
0.49937060475349426,
-0.08154139667749405,
0.5377098917961121,
-0.077550508081913,
-0.4145880341529846,
-0.5761908888816833,
0.05986405164003372,
0.10470473021268845,
-0.2736436128616333,
-0.06948736310005188,
-0.030175497755408287,
0.26734983921051025,
0.007203052751719952,
0.6294376850128174,
0.10238240659236908,
-0.16146604716777802,
-0.211798757314682,
0.5359965562820435,
-0.10323690623044968,
0.8676402568817139,
-0.23555225133895874,
-0.020941821858286858,
0.19981130957603455,
-0.48673561215400696,
0.2780027985572815,
-0.027105487883090973,
-0.291513055562973,
-0.1539493203163147,
0.5541584491729736,
0.25826191902160645,
-0.04975249618291855,
-0.14166031777858734,
0.24472381174564362,
0.18850010633468628,
-0.517368495464325,
-0.37322843074798584,
-0.025435760617256165,
0.3081264793872833,
0.4452893137931824,
0.3780009150505066,
-0.4718210995197296,
-0.010456878691911697,
-0.4587886929512024,
-0.1217884048819542,
0.05188135802745819,
-0.16404126584529877,
-0.04925518110394478,
0.5731219053268433,
-0.10970469564199448,
-0.051536791026592255,
0.7002221941947937,
-0.012877373024821281,
-0.7669591307640076,
0.8352620005607605,
0.03247195482254028,
0.6122325658798218,
0.013494201004505157,
0.2984708249568939,
0.2441224753856659,
0.08598992973566055,
0.5220704674720764,
0.5769234895706177,
-0.42296481132507324,
-0.7233755588531494,
-0.40337175130844116,
-0.4622272253036499,
-0.4609791040420532,
-0.07956379652023315,
-0.6479277014732361,
-0.23711122572422028,
-0.26160210371017456,
-0.35820472240448,
0.20466803014278412,
0.29667723178863525,
-0.5167055726051331,
0.05861319974064827,
-0.009232266806066036,
1.122558355331421,
-0.6162882447242737,
0.4368423521518707,
0.9517529010772705,
-0.15699054300785065,
-0.9192019104957581,
-0.028828352689743042,
-0.2029273957014084,
-0.6649364829063416,
0.7640937566757202,
-0.42347338795661926,
0.3004644215106964,
0.04060643911361694,
-0.6342164278030396,
-0.8048486709594727,
1.5779531002044678,
-0.14348188042640686,
0.30693867802619934,
-0.524357259273529,
0.43321579694747925,
0.4029061496257782,
0.16045688092708588,
-0.15970073640346527,
0.5490050911903381,
0.6248834729194641,
0.33904197812080383,
-0.8298965692520142,
0.0038406718522310257,
-0.15059375762939453,
-0.22801274061203003,
0.5730066895484924,
-0.8650398850440979,
0.40303677320480347,
0.3169291317462921,
-0.20336955785751343,
0.14628571271896362,
0.46622079610824585,
0.046871669590473175,
0.8108542561531067,
0.505416750907898,
0.49643847346305847,
0.4465720057487488,
-0.42571762204170227,
0.8678634762763977,
-0.061687711626291275,
0.22689643502235413,
0.747098982334137,
0.11037968099117279,
0.18778911232948303,
0.45155447721481323,
-0.5107731819152832,
0.3287861943244934,
1.1668767929077148,
0.1462985873222351,
0.5265783071517944,
0.008202264085412025,
-0.2369990050792694,
-0.5178602933883667,
-0.3240531086921692,
-0.4804213047027588,
0.031417377293109894,
0.4202896058559418,
0.05519085004925728,
-0.6638892292976379,
-0.048376526683568954,
0.004208443220704794,
-0.4231410622596741,
-0.6645892262458801,
0.7240635752677917,
-0.00943157821893692,
-0.6095520257949829,
0.044650599360466,
-0.026741676032543182,
-0.2699272036552429,
-0.6991403698921204,
-0.1000700369477272,
-0.05120012164115906,
-0.32953470945358276,
0.007897710427641869,
-1.249663233757019,
0.22334429621696472,
-0.23226730525493622,
-0.16083095967769623,
-0.29199668765068054,
0.7401753664016724,
-0.1315089613199234,
-0.08726491034030914,
0.07773413509130478,
0.8473097085952759,
-0.11206568032503128,
0.35928428173065186,
-0.6008827686309814,
-0.46628880500793457,
-0.33544886112213135,
-0.25330251455307007,
0.14299489557743073,
0.6925477981567383,
-0.2833878993988037,
0.863409161567688,
0.09367126226425171,
-0.401705265045166,
0.4493159353733063,
-0.11080547422170639,
0.974281907081604,
-0.6593347787857056,
-0.6147533655166626,
-0.2575092613697052,
0.11773217469453812,
0.2991596460342407,
-0.08932194113731384,
0.7650704979896545,
0.30565735697746277,
0.8138173818588257,
-0.016047360375523567,
0.5296943187713623,
-0.6066492795944214,
0.6546735167503357,
-0.6324039697647095,
0.40934324264526367,
-0.5124330520629883,
-0.3196379840373993,
-0.4716966152191162,
-0.6459659934043884,
0.009613134898245335,
-0.27460718154907227,
-0.4670736789703369,
0.12665703892707825,
0.7448226809501648,
0.4562389850616455,
0.23712289333343506,
0.1642596572637558,
0.13281631469726562,
0.14775465428829193,
0.1974240094423294,
0.8511307239532471,
1.3106215000152588,
-0.20548108220100403,
0.8317824006080627,
-0.49150481820106506,
0.18903379142284393,
0.15027281641960144,
-0.7166082262992859,
-0.8184368014335632,
-0.7201805114746094,
-0.347792387008667,
-0.5481606721878052,
0.19041860103607178,
0.5737026929855347,
0.293019562959671,
-0.570888876914978,
0.2936311662197113,
0.5159623026847839,
0.06816361844539642,
-0.11692046374082565,
-0.23047426342964172,
0.7083871960639954,
-0.1489781141281128,
-0.20277395844459534,
0.04799440875649452,
-0.03228476271033287,
0.030991116538643837,
0.18454904854297638,
0.19234852492809296,
-0.1371789127588272,
-0.6000089645385742,
0.5182828307151794,
0.5500847101211548,
-0.5309388041496277,
-0.6775584816932678,
0.5243359804153442,
0.21406929194927216,
-0.007035241462290287,
0.9954277873039246,
-0.6678966879844666,
0.507150411605835,
0.7081344723701477,
0.9111125469207764,
0.7138022184371948,
0.11072269082069397,
0.22624103724956512,
-0.7892027497291565,
-0.42642658948898315,
0.5005225539207458,
-0.05998590216040611,
-0.15645386278629303,
-0.4171753227710724,
0.597143292427063,
0.44179850816726685,
-0.5620409250259399,
-0.44378700852394104,
0.3784092664718628,
-1.301970362663269,
-0.39618155360221863,
1.012094497680664,
-0.004078330937772989,
-0.30940428376197815,
-0.8711043000221252,
0.22682006657123566,
0.5865346193313599,
0.029482439160346985,
0.4669388234615326,
1.040446162223816,
-0.4644436836242676,
-0.12622131407260895,
-0.7743646502494812,
0.3064451515674591,
-0.06658468395471573,
-0.5498077273368835,
-0.03514416888356209,
0.4105273187160492,
0.5350988507270813,
0.11409510672092438,
0.8962186574935913,
-0.48948851227760315,
0.4875023663043976,
0.06904566287994385,
-0.41617724299430847,
-0.4686126410961151,
-0.07509015500545502,
0.1622886210680008,
0.4778207838535309,
0.0848245620727539,
-0.09390545636415482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14189v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14189v1 | In Tree Structure Should Sentence Be Generated | 2024-06-20T10:49:08 | 2024-06-20T10:49:08 | Yaguang Li, Xin Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative models reliant on sequential autoregression have been at the
forefront of language generation for an extensive period, particularly
following the introduction of widely acclaimed transformers. Despite its
excellent performance, there are always some issues that we face today. For
example, problems such as hallucinations and getting trapped in a logic loop
may occur. To enhance the performance of existing systems, this paper
introduces a new method for generating sequences in natural language, which
involves generating the targeted sentence in a tree-traversing order. The paper
includes an illustration of the theoretical basis and validity of the approach,
as well as a comparison of its fundamentals with the diffusion model in graphic
generation. Finally, a module called SenTree is introduced for generating an
approximating binary tree. It is already available at
https://github.com/arklyg/sentree. Additionally, a joint training framework
based on this approach is proposed, incorporating the intrinsics of generative
adversarial networks. | [
0.008901117369532585,
-1.0905524492263794,
0.3905091881752014,
0.22823882102966309,
-0.30764269828796387,
-0.020702572539448738,
0.16588126122951508,
-0.4213399291038513,
-0.030526738613843918,
0.30101972818374634,
-0.42614203691482544,
-0.262402206659317,
-0.570189356803894,
0.22002679109573364,
-0.9141148328781128,
0.9779282212257385,
0.22509831190109253,
-0.4091966152191162,
0.1998089998960495,
-0.05934913456439972,
-0.45666757225990295,
-0.48827365040779114,
-0.622573971748352,
-0.15338356792926788,
0.37457868456840515,
0.042396705597639084,
1.0612534284591675,
0.7254186272621155,
0.2494046539068222,
0.45329561829566956,
-0.1543547362089157,
0.12356430292129517,
-0.04561256617307663,
0.6081592440605164,
0.06258033215999603,
-0.24165648221969604,
-0.15724757313728333,
-0.19721370935440063,
0.7887328863143921,
0.6827977299690247,
-0.22559398412704468,
-0.22963424026966095,
-0.0421791635453701,
0.7463152408599854,
-0.24331842362880707,
0.07962068170309067,
-0.6440891623497009,
0.2999110817909241,
-0.2562071979045868,
-0.22920677065849304,
-0.5295177102088928,
-0.6258600354194641,
0.24704350531101227,
-0.5369365215301514,
0.36373603343963623,
0.09533319622278214,
0.7675123810768127,
0.18478798866271973,
-0.39872515201568604,
-0.32579028606414795,
-0.7617872953414917,
0.23502318561077118,
-0.6552006602287292,
0.0719016045331955,
-0.15893810987472534,
0.2793032228946686,
-0.370815247297287,
-0.7614697217941284,
-0.3347797989845276,
-0.20865358412265778,
-0.1766517460346222,
0.12358322739601135,
-0.3161751925945282,
-0.07059986144304276,
0.4018816351890564,
0.5150588154792786,
-0.7573005557060242,
-0.1715581864118576,
-0.1851847916841507,
0.19625148177146912,
0.7219131588935852,
0.3206128478050232,
0.49729490280151367,
-0.6245309114456177,
-0.009445413947105408,
-0.41259700059890747,
-0.8203510642051697,
0.02483947016298771,
0.5768844485282898,
0.24243244528770447,
0.07494951039552689,
0.7239320278167725,
-0.11558951437473297,
0.764724612236023,
0.25963521003723145,
0.2994239032268524,
0.11602907627820969,
-0.41322267055511475,
-0.29121285676956177,
0.0343000553548336,
1.0939253568649292,
-0.049030400812625885,
0.3215904235839844,
-0.040365759283304214,
-0.2137782722711563,
0.49432045221328735,
0.5249700546264648,
-0.7941831946372986,
-0.5159785151481628,
-0.02645670622587204,
-0.29982006549835205,
-0.7496165037155151,
-0.10656338930130005,
-0.625717282295227,
0.22261840105056763,
-0.101764976978302,
-0.0303734689950943,
-0.716930091381073,
-0.34994208812713623,
-0.20557920634746552,
0.03862316906452179,
-0.1257094442844391,
0.12181592732667923,
-0.9745984077453613,
0.3262020945549011,
0.4216909110546112,
0.7237038612365723,
0.07959158718585968,
-0.12899284064769745,
-0.7317594885826111,
0.19043511152267456,
-0.5637086033821106,
0.6397449374198914,
-0.59464430809021,
-0.4793623387813568,
-0.10190597921609879,
-0.33788079023361206,
0.0349658764898777,
-0.36744141578674316,
0.20073442161083221,
-0.3934269845485687,
0.675337016582489,
0.42702436447143555,
-0.31736209988594055,
-0.1923685222864151,
-0.10390286147594452,
-0.3868103623390198,
1.0440714359283447,
0.26597002148628235,
-1.0241271257400513,
0.28576332330703735,
-0.7608801126480103,
-0.9051352143287659,
0.28320634365081787,
-0.3704470694065094,
-0.5163746476173401,
0.19954441487789154,
0.2306358814239502,
0.28537437319755554,
-0.005918306298553944,
0.7084887623786926,
-0.07002291083335876,
0.044636208564043045,
0.041580431163311005,
-0.41222548484802246,
0.9387445449829102,
0.42375293374061584,
-0.33695846796035767,
0.2388375997543335,
-0.6690117716789246,
0.1748458296060562,
0.16223730146884918,
-0.4369862973690033,
-0.0996282696723938,
0.33353230357170105,
-0.0483584851026535,
0.1251438856124878,
-0.2902633249759674,
-0.3358512818813324,
0.17662182450294495,
-1.0833946466445923,
0.633776843547821,
0.7423892617225647,
0.16820043325424194,
0.4491511881351471,
-0.000295280828140676,
0.49698004126548767,
0.17026326060295105,
-0.022193221375346184,
-0.5034511089324951,
-0.4912707507610321,
-0.6180874109268188,
0.24142521619796753,
0.12314406037330627,
0.4684908986091614,
-0.7889599204063416,
0.7594192028045654,
-0.15116721391677856,
-0.14598973095417023,
0.0035693305544555187,
-0.20570404827594757,
0.4181041419506073,
0.21413670480251312,
0.09148307889699936,
-0.6193462610244751,
-0.7564601302146912,
-0.6915650367736816,
0.20427507162094116,
-0.5917011499404907,
0.15595686435699463,
0.2065369337797165,
0.27621057629585266,
-0.1368849277496338,
0.9751955270767212,
-0.5985234975814819,
0.4056406617164612,
-0.131709024310112,
0.45040592551231384,
0.15163832902908325,
0.47451281547546387,
0.4351159632205963,
-0.6956643462181091,
-0.24207618832588196,
-0.005709389224648476,
-0.9257487058639526,
0.024654921144247055,
-0.17603851854801178,
-0.34056776762008667,
0.5225154161453247,
0.20999766886234283,
-0.7249345779418945,
0.3781645596027374,
0.32117658853530884,
-0.2381657063961029,
0.3759858310222626,
-0.15518969297409058,
-0.1615537405014038,
-1.3454484939575195,
0.2081853747367859,
-0.1943178027868271,
-0.49590978026390076,
-0.3525269627571106,
0.12197764217853546,
-0.4138644337654114,
-0.3844392001628876,
-0.1679956316947937,
0.04749264195561409,
-0.482666552066803,
-0.37788495421409607,
-0.2695806920528412,
-0.056827932596206665,
-0.03574754670262337,
0.4660561680793762,
0.0018957618158310652,
0.5329313278198242,
0.6692030429840088,
-0.7482000589370728,
0.3645722270011902,
0.3900611996650696,
-0.30942288041114807,
0.42407143115997314,
-0.5879530310630798,
0.04165434092283249,
-0.2757315933704376,
0.3580494523048401,
-0.7447196841239929,
-0.07849269360303879,
0.45082223415374756,
-0.5630695819854736,
0.44071143865585327,
0.0031356096733361483,
-0.5470726490020752,
-0.7404164671897888,
0.15797695517539978,
0.31883344054222107,
0.7149770855903625,
-0.3320138454437256,
0.3295046091079712,
0.16145926713943481,
-0.07184223085641861,
-0.2845595180988312,
-0.44168418645858765,
0.3171869218349457,
-0.4043737053871155,
-0.8900004029273987,
0.3825872838497162,
-0.18936721980571747,
-0.17108221352100372,
0.07103205472230911,
0.27703189849853516,
0.26141831278800964,
0.33680906891822815,
0.2909936308860779,
-0.014779272489249706,
-0.3867405951023102,
0.02563987299799919,
-0.14603537321090698,
-0.13114023208618164,
0.14113134145736694,
-0.41368481516838074,
0.39645588397979736,
-0.022250685840845108,
-0.042957745492458344,
-0.1864975392818451,
0.6315121054649353,
0.2304258644580841,
-0.11024840921163559,
0.11420007795095444,
0.11701999604701996,
-0.19304324686527252,
-0.31914928555488586,
0.18326003849506378,
-0.027051368728280067,
-0.5050650238990784,
0.2686590552330017,
-0.4265201687812805,
-0.6575201153755188,
-0.02106245420873165,
0.15858995914459229,
0.23638547956943512,
0.5069062113761902,
0.6239455342292786,
0.021442634984850883,
1.2011271715164185,
0.6206376552581787,
0.038298726081848145,
0.632395327091217,
-0.3094601333141327,
0.31987708806991577,
-0.471233069896698,
0.16067785024642944,
-0.2764964997768402,
0.0806242823600769,
-0.5625892877578735,
-0.11374175548553467,
0.26092350482940674,
0.36468246579170227,
-0.32529062032699585,
0.7063912749290466,
-0.7683059573173523,
0.12183766812086105,
0.6125465035438538,
-0.1354333907365799,
0.2406921684741974,
0.26585665345191956,
-0.3371046483516693,
0.2695049047470093,
-1.010963797569275,
-0.6286507844924927,
0.6116756796836853,
0.03715687617659569,
0.49160081148147583,
0.12139789015054703,
0.85160893201828,
0.28094908595085144,
0.49027878046035767,
-0.5394695401191711,
0.7099103927612305,
-0.16474393010139465,
-0.2656335234642029,
-0.23726476728916168,
-0.4483274221420288,
-1.4388123750686646,
0.21437031030654907,
-0.04064381867647171,
-0.6069740056991577,
-0.20518076419830322,
0.2284851223230362,
-0.3984769880771637,
-0.031011132523417473,
-0.6592928171157837,
0.758761465549469,
-0.27193090319633484,
-0.12443593144416809,
-0.18352575600147247,
-0.8267170786857605,
0.5913136601448059,
0.22741244733333588,
-0.10663092136383057,
0.11345544457435608,
0.5847129821777344,
0.5998607873916626,
-0.7888184189796448,
0.736895740032196,
-0.006624121684581041,
-0.07800041139125824,
0.6417638659477234,
0.33011820912361145,
0.634343147277832,
-0.12201014906167984,
0.20788714289665222,
-0.5374835133552551,
-0.35612550377845764,
-0.03394719958305359,
-0.6774786114692688,
0.4788150191307068,
-0.5491594672203064,
-0.7552818059921265,
-0.542765200138092,
-0.5052914023399353,
0.1270356923341751,
0.049519993364810944,
0.2794572710990906,
0.7857940196990967,
-0.4843734800815582,
-0.16274940967559814,
0.21753747761249542,
-0.2569586932659149,
0.923918604850769,
0.09345241636037827,
-0.33941495418548584,
-0.5495112538337708,
0.5494087338447571,
0.14537456631660461,
0.23440824449062347,
0.3386807143688202,
0.22027738392353058,
-0.16397224366664886,
-0.6005665063858032,
-0.7346275448799133,
-0.058566562831401825,
-0.4767831563949585,
-0.3170982301235199,
-0.8338508009910583,
-0.5239239931106567,
-0.45246124267578125,
-0.07892853766679764,
0.04439438879489899,
-0.4932752847671509,
-0.18578365445137024,
-0.18497538566589355,
0.7345821857452393,
1.1880732774734497,
-0.008768696337938309,
0.39686471223831177,
-0.8601493239402771,
0.29965025186538696,
0.2018151432275772,
0.07069583237171173,
0.21051040291786194,
-0.1892118602991104,
-0.09332355111837387,
-0.018205422908067703,
-0.6912271976470947,
-0.8753416538238525,
0.6210821270942688,
0.13601148128509521,
0.35871028900146484,
0.17228597402572632,
-0.2159283608198166,
0.6159206032752991,
-0.99262535572052,
0.5555506944656372,
0.37302541732788086,
-0.7196881175041199,
0.9943771958351135,
-0.5593363642692566,
0.3019463121891022,
0.08741027116775513,
0.02899235300719738,
-0.5406050682067871,
-0.774520218372345,
-1.1872862577438354,
-0.9765037894248962,
0.7568710446357727,
0.7269423604011536,
0.24482932686805725,
-0.5838155150413513,
-0.0018675635801628232,
-0.06188751757144928,
0.2072048783302307,
-0.8758196234703064,
-0.1882340908050537,
-0.3623252809047699,
-0.32126089930534363,
0.06151173636317253,
0.031151480972766876,
0.20376797020435333,
-0.03314715251326561,
0.5796031951904297,
0.07617959380149841,
0.18882735073566437,
0.198699951171875,
-0.18981733918190002,
-0.3638605773448944,
0.08445267379283905,
0.23427680134773254,
0.49375632405281067,
0.03822677582502365,
0.12144866585731506,
-0.3893710672855377,
-0.09456898272037506,
0.28816327452659607,
0.06370434165000916,
-0.6648694276809692,
0.16240867972373962,
0.20289196074008942,
0.9188305139541626,
-0.04530712217092514,
-0.30061376094818115,
0.3128751218318939,
0.1289248913526535,
-0.10972584038972855,
-0.17434649169445038,
0.25919345021247864,
-0.06613969802856445,
0.2778247892856598,
0.20181284844875336,
0.2971666753292084,
0.21746793389320374,
-0.7410584092140198,
0.6045618057250977,
0.45936980843544006,
0.0829794853925705,
-0.419293612241745,
0.7259505987167358,
0.39292725920677185,
-0.7473962903022766,
0.7778837084770203,
-0.2484019696712494,
-0.6086822748184204,
0.6036626100540161,
0.7236750721931458,
1.0471800565719604,
-0.25794053077697754,
0.401121586561203,
0.6366895437240601,
0.11449606716632843,
-0.20448453724384308,
0.1472025066614151,
-0.28378167748451233,
-0.5956965088844299,
-0.5799888372421265,
-0.6869688630104065,
0.04294975847005844,
-0.2914496660232544,
-0.13000841438770294,
0.10958100855350494,
-0.46446752548217773,
-0.09161364287137985,
-0.019560256972908974,
-0.17242200672626495,
-0.22693268954753876,
0.3641960024833679,
0.3812199532985687,
0.4101357161998749,
-0.830230176448822,
0.8256298303604126,
0.34282904863357544,
-0.48151180148124695,
-0.6455512046813965,
0.01667202264070511,
-0.40551871061325073,
-0.46547946333885193,
0.8637015223503113,
0.35046979784965515,
-0.11106977611780167,
0.22446680068969727,
-0.2479369193315506,
-0.9674555659294128,
0.825140655040741,
-0.006408208981156349,
-0.4383803904056549,
-0.11935292184352875,
-0.1555570513010025,
0.5668321847915649,
-0.6071187853813171,
0.21033316850662231,
0.07922150939702988,
0.09053882211446762,
0.3310580253601074,
-0.36142268776893616,
0.1564256250858307,
-0.49310722947120667,
0.4580901265144348,
0.5498198866844177,
-0.2628726363182068,
0.5805603265762329,
-0.16572768986225128,
-0.933483362197876,
0.21118636429309845,
0.8980796337127686,
0.29717814922332764,
-0.1664099395275116,
0.6338409185409546,
0.8211490511894226,
0.6526383757591248,
0.039424773305654526,
1.1749545335769653,
-0.29460373520851135,
-0.06918200850486755,
1.3186534643173218,
-0.23602113127708435,
0.657915472984314,
0.04353686422109604,
-0.39841344952583313,
0.8445528745651245,
0.7476192712783813,
0.11745347827672958,
0.5264807343482971,
0.6012068390846252,
-0.21277916431427002,
0.019608328118920326,
0.10514520853757858,
-0.36632484197616577,
0.16512669622898102,
0.2822776436805725,
-0.615744948387146,
-0.37236541509628296,
-0.15299373865127563,
-0.16271398961544037,
0.17173971235752106,
-0.07865741103887558,
0.7597729563713074,
0.0944930911064148,
-1.028031349182129,
0.5156915783882141,
0.00886678695678711,
0.48523783683776855,
-0.3755408227443695,
-0.10841042548418045,
-0.21558231115341187,
-0.11346239596605301,
-0.10909975320100784,
-0.7212599515914917,
0.677406370639801,
0.11719729751348495,
-0.02125314623117447,
-0.606863260269165,
0.48378583788871765,
-0.43565434217453003,
-0.8112118244171143,
0.12274431437253952,
0.46642783284187317,
0.268123984336853,
0.37269359827041626,
-0.6636302471160889,
-0.4589713215827942,
-0.09603628516197205,
-0.2661178708076477,
-0.12910541892051697,
0.6083852052688599,
-0.26256197690963745,
0.3340654969215393,
0.5800210237503052,
-0.16111555695533752,
0.24798394739627838,
0.35692980885505676,
0.7071029543876648,
-0.7379236221313477,
-0.6671934127807617,
-1.0512491464614868,
0.5061739087104797,
-0.02135862223803997,
-0.24327057600021362,
0.5860042572021484,
0.7087309956550598,
0.5083932876586914,
0.2474517673254013,
0.7221524715423584,
-0.5143269896507263,
0.1815534383058548,
-0.5080562233924866,
0.1802552044391632,
-0.24553182721138,
-0.07097463309764862,
-0.3731097877025604,
-1.174464464187622,
-0.2893032133579254,
0.6342136263847351,
-0.03109431080520153,
-0.00490821897983551,
0.9019397497177124,
0.7436643242835999,
-0.05055452510714531,
0.09187956154346466,
0.142247274518013,
0.2974216341972351,
0.2463236153125763,
0.8293011784553528,
1.0434454679489136,
-0.5584525465965271,
0.4909321367740631,
-0.06333828717470169,
0.16165201365947723,
0.11941701918840408,
-0.7469156384468079,
-0.571440577507019,
-0.5692322254180908,
-0.5425568222999573,
-0.47502049803733826,
0.1442270129919052,
0.6440280675888062,
0.6777403354644775,
-0.5348663330078125,
-0.2740079164505005,
-0.9299227595329285,
0.034296195954084396,
-0.0002521086425986141,
-0.2356012761592865,
0.29176467657089233,
-0.49916011095046997,
-0.5828697681427002,
0.44884192943573,
0.4513847231864929,
0.46488693356513977,
-0.21924154460430145,
-0.009646682068705559,
-0.49318528175354004,
-0.14473417401313782,
0.6710985898971558,
0.05496703460812569,
-0.6850011348724365,
-0.40982621908187866,
-0.2998320162296295,
-0.1892276406288147,
0.5142145156860352,
0.9691061973571777,
-1.126705288887024,
0.19258201122283936,
0.7061413526535034,
0.3659932017326355,
0.5424191355705261,
0.23780272901058197,
1.0158454179763794,
-0.8596512079238892,
-0.017471620813012123,
0.27059707045555115,
0.33975744247436523,
0.5469508767127991,
-0.3641177713871002,
0.6126119494438171,
0.28249120712280273,
-0.3261472284793854,
-0.5637698769569397,
0.6410143971443176,
-0.5868584513664246,
-0.24631229043006897,
0.8601236343383789,
0.12848778069019318,
-0.3551655411720276,
-0.014606041833758354,
-0.10695818811655045,
0.5083169341087341,
-0.22299188375473022,
0.49669551849365234,
0.5001347064971924,
-0.06020577624440193,
-0.1010151281952858,
0.04957468807697296,
0.4461558163166046,
0.563751220703125,
-0.9110943078994751,
0.17968706786632538,
0.884476900100708,
-0.08536507189273834,
0.31671518087387085,
0.7391549348831177,
-0.10648850351572037,
0.11178290098905563,
0.047290217131376266,
-0.07964114099740982,
0.22265514731407166,
-0.42127007246017456,
-0.27017444372177124,
0.18979160487651825,
0.09731562435626984,
-0.15495629608631134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14177v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14177v1 | SimulSeamless: FBK at IWSLT 2024 Simultaneous Speech Translation | 2024-06-20T10:34:46 | 2024-06-20T10:34:46 | Sara Papi, Marco Gaido, Matteo Negri, Luisa Bentivogli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | This paper describes the FBK's participation in the Simultaneous Translation
Evaluation Campaign at IWSLT 2024. For this year's submission in the
speech-to-text translation (ST) sub-track, we propose SimulSeamless, which is
realized by combining AlignAtt and SeamlessM4T in its medium configuration. The
SeamlessM4T model is used "off-the-shelf" and its simultaneous inference is
enabled through the adoption of AlignAtt, a SimulST policy based on
cross-attention that can be applied without any retraining or adaptation of the
underlying model for the simultaneous task. We participated in all the Shared
Task languages (English->{German, Japanese, Chinese}, and Czech->English),
achieving acceptable or even better results compared to last year's
submissions. SimulSeamless, covering more than 143 source languages and 200
target languages, is released at: https://github.com/hlt-mt/FBK-fairseq/. | [
-0.21051612496376038,
-0.4719019830226898,
0.564348578453064,
0.7904843091964722,
-0.6236498951911926,
0.3792221248149872,
-0.25212129950523376,
-0.5782957077026367,
0.14128287136554718,
0.24491029977798462,
-0.9704465270042419,
-0.4088953733444214,
-0.5431081652641296,
0.10420046001672745,
-0.581109344959259,
0.9632827043533325,
-0.7998138070106506,
0.5249677300453186,
-0.6189756393432617,
-0.2679482400417328,
-0.5970935225486755,
-0.04079103469848633,
-0.25365886092185974,
-0.4630572497844696,
0.24582470953464508,
0.34495261311531067,
0.7266000509262085,
0.4204621911048889,
0.4775327444076538,
0.3053368628025055,
0.43426936864852905,
-0.117111936211586,
-0.46799713373184204,
0.1553233414888382,
-0.29342982172966003,
-0.11419191211462021,
-0.3898058831691742,
0.1528506726026535,
1.0349911451339722,
0.5517259240150452,
0.029767492786049843,
0.23195740580558777,
0.18755246698856354,
0.13493889570236206,
-0.4059271514415741,
-0.027883389964699745,
-0.26693952083587646,
0.1856687068939209,
-0.41126254200935364,
-0.05527285858988762,
-0.35929980874061584,
-0.16026748716831207,
-0.032254740595817566,
-0.6003459095954895,
-0.061079543083906174,
0.23818251490592957,
0.7894042730331421,
0.46730560064315796,
-0.3910852074623108,
-0.1643390953540802,
-0.42665013670921326,
1.1612616777420044,
-0.554860532283783,
0.7298035621643066,
0.22289030253887177,
0.17014659941196442,
-0.1582668572664261,
-1.1744980812072754,
-0.2775907814502716,
-0.19551140069961548,
0.06735900044441223,
0.6528916954994202,
-0.05102047696709633,
0.1334909349679947,
-0.023262646049261093,
0.2194572240114212,
-0.6099209189414978,
-0.09836849570274353,
-0.26571911573410034,
-0.347214013338089,
0.9147872924804688,
0.35816559195518494,
0.31528180837631226,
0.11199512332677841,
-0.7478072643280029,
0.15488702058792114,
-0.1426229476928711,
0.019207321107387543,
0.17999635636806488,
0.2174263596534729,
-0.4772132337093353,
0.40424057841300964,
-0.3414223790168762,
0.4964461028575897,
-0.32205960154533386,
-0.049264390021562576,
0.37984734773635864,
-0.9792667031288147,
-0.15254779160022736,
0.08768711984157562,
0.937745213508606,
0.12507925927639008,
-0.12549744546413422,
-0.24907739460468292,
-0.1853904128074646,
-0.03489010035991669,
0.31648823618888855,
-0.6650171875953674,
0.11539071798324585,
0.41791653633117676,
-0.4911225736141205,
-0.23244412243366241,
0.12434406578540802,
-0.6610257029533386,
0.11629696190357208,
-0.4948132634162903,
0.622138500213623,
-0.3925880789756775,
-0.1752595752477646,
-0.16028736531734467,
0.01034429483115673,
-0.014904573559761047,
0.5388878583908081,
-0.17752957344055176,
0.5184100866317749,
0.677021324634552,
0.7755796909332275,
-0.6034765839576721,
-1.0113129615783691,
-0.625407874584198,
0.21886764466762543,
-0.05532979592680931,
0.47232529520988464,
-0.16076327860355377,
-0.28748777508735657,
-0.23067229986190796,
-0.086424320936203,
-0.08144178986549377,
-0.1752704679965973,
0.9605336785316467,
0.07686251401901245,
-0.028252597898244858,
-0.3415219783782959,
-0.4616846442222595,
-0.041348665952682495,
-0.18018291890621185,
-0.48068979382514954,
1.0807353258132935,
-0.07747870683670044,
-0.7149834036827087,
0.2467418611049652,
-0.5740913152694702,
-0.5234020948410034,
0.3850787878036499,
-0.17844511568546295,
-0.456532746553421,
0.2115580290555954,
-0.01070207729935646,
0.24096538126468658,
-0.3046948313713074,
0.5443155765533447,
-0.3980776369571686,
-0.5094543695449829,
0.1060575470328331,
-0.5191707611083984,
0.8400483131408691,
0.26401039958000183,
-0.4822489321231842,
0.37379151582717896,
-0.3340865969657898,
0.15185055136680603,
0.20427700877189636,
-0.07895038276910782,
-0.07164337486028671,
-0.08414974063634872,
0.3339381217956543,
0.39528679847717285,
0.575289785861969,
-0.7808631062507629,
-0.056455012410879135,
-0.09949788451194763,
0.06177590414881706,
0.6397791504859924,
-0.15776216983795166,
0.28741610050201416,
-0.12258589267730713,
0.620701789855957,
0.187376469373703,
0.5161461234092712,
0.1367960274219513,
-0.6260742545127869,
-0.5261985063552856,
-0.38466233015060425,
0.5031706094741821,
0.5063905715942383,
-0.9388478994369507,
-0.19584769010543823,
-0.1987297534942627,
-0.42749249935150146,
-0.8702905774116516,
-0.12350796908140182,
0.46257284283638,
-0.04245985671877861,
0.3062486946582794,
-0.18850207328796387,
-0.6746713519096375,
-0.88502436876297,
-0.70138019323349,
0.20209909975528717,
0.4395952522754669,
-0.06062107905745506,
0.34680357575416565,
-0.21346163749694824,
0.6091654896736145,
-0.007359310518950224,
-0.23818187415599823,
-0.16525642573833466,
0.2784324288368225,
-0.16478674113750458,
0.4739292860031128,
0.6006577014923096,
-0.9108093976974487,
-0.7313271164894104,
0.04214339330792427,
-0.668165385723114,
-0.37493062019348145,
0.04357417672872543,
-0.2696031928062439,
0.1412821114063263,
0.45055413246154785,
-0.47867122292518616,
0.6670975685119629,
1.0476123094558716,
-0.29711925983428955,
0.49629196524620056,
0.10551006346940994,
0.4158744513988495,
-1.1555832624435425,
-0.18020866811275482,
-0.4400419592857361,
-0.6712906956672668,
-0.5645929574966431,
0.0620771124958992,
0.19572563469409943,
-0.02687358669936657,
-0.481508731842041,
0.6322007775306702,
-0.4213657081127167,
-0.2538796663284302,
-0.04587966948747635,
0.44232359528541565,
-0.32207396626472473,
-0.008580878376960754,
-0.29926490783691406,
0.9331499934196472,
0.41059452295303345,
-0.1252393126487732,
0.3671208620071411,
0.29076066613197327,
-0.12979796528816223,
0.5620622038841248,
-0.23477625846862793,
-0.050931770354509354,
0.27156302332878113,
0.4250584542751312,
-1.0551950931549072,
-0.3679746091365814,
0.24147985875606537,
-0.41564399003982544,
0.1871025264263153,
0.43475303053855896,
-0.3966522514820099,
-0.6039076447486877,
-0.2730849087238312,
0.4366335868835449,
0.17083732783794403,
-0.4249764680862427,
0.6982541084289551,
0.43550676107406616,
-0.3575710654258728,
-0.7855574488639832,
-0.7972985506057739,
0.13199661672115326,
0.18518388271331787,
-0.6275854706764221,
0.32527899742126465,
-0.27622324228286743,
-0.007899822667241096,
0.3864133059978485,
-0.42054811120033264,
-0.05003564804792404,
0.07937609404325485,
0.3735058605670929,
0.10324814915657043,
-0.3074919283390045,
-0.38460618257522583,
0.5135233998298645,
-0.04012952744960785,
-0.19673959910869598,
-0.3826564848423004,
0.5291521549224854,
-0.20425885915756226,
-0.6077092289924622,
-0.7553853392601013,
0.8537997603416443,
0.3909500539302826,
-0.20513026416301727,
0.4658200442790985,
0.7440791130065918,
-0.1686742603778839,
-0.1334185153245926,
-0.43051257729530334,
-0.10442738980054855,
-0.42198705673217773,
0.3615752160549164,
-0.5881848931312561,
-1.2055798768997192,
0.42310255765914917,
-0.24169684946537018,
0.4215267300605774,
0.30024972558021545,
0.7760024070739746,
-0.30830270051956177,
0.9981982707977295,
0.18317387998104095,
0.26608237624168396,
0.336486279964447,
0.38223060965538025,
0.2533475458621979,
-0.4977976679801941,
-0.12590624392032623,
-0.4436592757701874,
-0.3881619870662689,
-0.4895888864994049,
-0.5708341598510742,
0.1699974685907364,
-0.016013523563742638,
0.26566004753112793,
0.27262064814567566,
0.04819175601005554,
0.2877269387245178,
0.5248531699180603,
-0.15533989667892456,
0.19521452486515045,
-0.04505942389369011,
-0.426373153924942,
-0.5063422918319702,
-0.6762661933898926,
-0.09993017464876175,
0.625248372554779,
0.2863418459892273,
0.5098019242286682,
-0.11541876196861267,
1.1155571937561035,
0.06358224898576736,
0.2793169915676117,
-0.6431754231452942,
0.7233693599700928,
-0.4432087242603302,
-0.54727703332901,
-0.17936451733112335,
-0.4622875154018402,
-0.726905345916748,
0.5055301785469055,
0.11869920790195465,
-0.47844642400741577,
-0.25724563002586365,
0.22444605827331543,
0.08726605027914047,
-0.03500654920935631,
-0.47604718804359436,
1.0207940340042114,
-0.401337593793869,
-0.464298278093338,
-0.3584473133087158,
-0.8362022042274475,
0.4303261935710907,
-0.3324796259403229,
0.28611794114112854,
-0.4633299708366394,
-0.13601422309875488,
0.6053077578544617,
0.016944922506809235,
0.6106575727462769,
-0.1870865523815155,
0.07537596672773361,
0.20275893807411194,
0.013717403635382652,
0.4114980399608612,
-0.11234226077795029,
0.05337938666343689,
0.5923314690589905,
0.1753712296485901,
-0.3955886662006378,
-0.19827400147914886,
0.6854518055915833,
-0.6434353590011597,
-0.3217877149581909,
-0.5858471393585205,
-1.0013419389724731,
-0.37537625432014465,
0.50764399766922,
0.2216707170009613,
0.33412909507751465,
-0.5600425004959106,
0.34732872247695923,
0.20292037725448608,
0.012192193418741226,
0.36364924907684326,
0.40424007177352905,
-0.49279695749282837,
-0.717166006565094,
0.9021740555763245,
0.2793397009372711,
0.4294688105583191,
0.03636503964662552,
0.17715984582901,
-0.4031016528606415,
-0.5777678489685059,
-0.42932626605033875,
0.4283546805381775,
-0.5057850480079651,
-0.37175366282463074,
-0.7867635488510132,
-0.27214378118515015,
-0.6775919198989868,
-0.19392846524715424,
-0.5795975923538208,
-0.5182501077651978,
-0.030493108555674553,
0.1279487907886505,
-0.048112474381923676,
0.7655828595161438,
-0.1671477109193802,
0.4681738615036011,
-0.6916430592536926,
0.4908541142940521,
-0.15382030606269836,
0.29266050457954407,
-0.42866620421409607,
-0.4119984805583954,
-0.5306597352027893,
0.09700263291597366,
-0.3316146433353424,
-0.5908884406089783,
0.10410633683204651,
0.15208904445171356,
0.8991122245788574,
-0.30589479207992554,
0.1359281688928604,
1.054484248161316,
-0.6679432988166809,
0.8923109769821167,
0.2817513346672058,
-1.3133105039596558,
0.29110604524612427,
-0.3803989291191101,
0.6683827638626099,
0.7981462478637695,
0.3041898310184479,
-0.5871085524559021,
-0.9576439261436462,
-0.6887910962104797,
-0.9531054496765137,
1.2177205085754395,
0.48400959372520447,
0.015716925263404846,
0.5477128624916077,
-0.06272363662719727,
0.2242158204317093,
0.53923499584198,
-0.6524326801300049,
-0.21163207292556763,
-0.24368932843208313,
-0.8025171756744385,
0.1562323421239853,
-0.4188590347766876,
-0.10462266206741333,
-0.2642624080181122,
1.0444551706314087,
-0.0022234665229916573,
0.2377687692642212,
0.04616718739271164,
-0.07430430501699448,
-0.2944144606590271,
0.061897143721580505,
0.8078242540359497,
0.42800164222717285,
0.030533088371157646,
0.056365929543972015,
0.2691139578819275,
-0.8180019855499268,
0.07913894206285477,
0.224814772605896,
-0.33456340432167053,
0.17255915701389313,
0.43100935220718384,
1.0837602615356445,
0.7625246047973633,
-0.3788701593875885,
0.6900376081466675,
-0.3183791935443878,
-0.4660106897354126,
-0.19057470560073853,
-0.3186885118484497,
0.18783722817897797,
0.40546363592147827,
0.032363373786211014,
0.08241737633943558,
0.22700412571430206,
-0.10027847439050674,
0.5653960704803467,
0.20163840055465698,
-0.5553767085075378,
-0.30438897013664246,
0.7468091249465942,
0.3359840214252472,
0.000897536869160831,
0.0758708119392395,
-0.07093801349401474,
-0.5844556093215942,
0.04889972507953644,
0.7683027982711792,
1.1832852363586426,
-0.8834138512611389,
0.1115775778889656,
0.26586708426475525,
0.4793291389942169,
-0.09741103649139404,
0.6608380079269409,
-0.10515283048152924,
-0.26174652576446533,
-0.5943848490715027,
-0.8972340226173401,
-0.3859902024269104,
-0.21279925107955933,
-0.7259249091148376,
0.4703972339630127,
-0.01940520480275154,
-0.025783535093069077,
-0.1611681431531906,
-0.01170659065246582,
-0.429595947265625,
-0.00023476299247704446,
0.03467417508363724,
0.8023627996444702,
-1.0454370975494385,
0.936389684677124,
0.8820622563362122,
-0.20299914479255676,
-0.7967694997787476,
0.40163400769233704,
0.2358791083097458,
-0.6017617583274841,
0.2885996103286743,
0.018890192732214928,
-0.20395393669605255,
0.28422707319259644,
-0.6778225898742676,
-1.0069987773895264,
1.0849429368972778,
0.6971821188926697,
-0.49698278307914734,
0.17499521374702454,
0.3823266625404358,
0.17679324746131897,
-0.18906548619270325,
-0.19708549976348877,
0.48308634757995605,
0.7762089967727661,
0.08059895038604736,
-1.4443018436431885,
-0.09691076725721359,
0.21938297152519226,
-0.03063652664422989,
0.1625085175037384,
-0.8579326272010803,
0.8690573573112488,
0.18235504627227783,
-0.2936786115169525,
0.26038315892219543,
1.0182020664215088,
0.41489627957344055,
0.6115304827690125,
0.40381789207458496,
0.4965008497238159,
0.3800266683101654,
-0.457329124212265,
1.028856635093689,
0.21589799225330353,
0.4663265347480774,
1.4980829954147339,
-0.32648199796676636,
0.7846150994300842,
0.8781480193138123,
-0.19411252439022064,
-0.01610247790813446,
0.3492065370082855,
0.40314021706581116,
0.53620445728302,
-0.18244802951812744,
-0.3071645498275757,
-0.2561383843421936,
-0.4686300456523895,
-0.22852975130081177,
0.6613321900367737,
0.198125422000885,
0.21196506917476654,
-0.3817264437675476,
0.5206361413002014,
0.09524939954280853,
-0.021869860589504242,
-0.09282504767179489,
0.7036834955215454,
0.5867605805397034,
-0.7097654342651367,
0.2851333022117615,
-0.10157357156276703,
0.42118170857429504,
-0.961198627948761,
0.1204259917140007,
-0.049921803176403046,
0.2871720492839813,
-0.15729498863220215,
-1.0448225736618042,
0.3421076536178589,
-0.20920075476169586,
0.10091189295053482,
-0.5136702060699463,
0.5160934925079346,
-0.9562457203865051,
-0.3647042214870453,
0.5969077348709106,
0.21804602444171906,
0.1816711574792862,
0.18562759459018707,
-1.0466253757476807,
0.8175137639045715,
0.36257216334342957,
-0.12799204885959625,
0.19298042356967926,
0.6137863993644714,
-0.3480686545372009,
0.23393970727920532,
0.3749629557132721,
0.1441664844751358,
0.49430468678474426,
0.22896233201026917,
0.6190424561500549,
-0.357476145029068,
-0.6301485300064087,
-0.58021479845047,
0.6670578718185425,
-0.26109886169433594,
0.03557104244828224,
1.1163445711135864,
0.627831220626831,
0.8363795280456543,
-0.18120551109313965,
0.7462542057037354,
-0.17109566926956177,
0.5626000165939331,
-0.4424317181110382,
0.6354426741600037,
-0.924675464630127,
-0.5544751286506653,
-0.47483009099960327,
-0.835522472858429,
-0.13352569937705994,
0.3401833772659302,
0.03456757590174675,
-0.15043829381465912,
1.149550199508667,
0.15297751128673553,
-0.319585382938385,
0.33883869647979736,
0.611315906047821,
0.35062724351882935,
0.11521268635988235,
0.2599523961544037,
0.8346481919288635,
-0.7570660710334778,
0.3186100423336029,
-0.49665454030036926,
-0.17014965415000916,
-0.2801288664340973,
-0.9511021375656128,
-0.47297951579093933,
-0.8437077403068542,
-0.4009334146976471,
-0.27936574816703796,
0.05915099382400513,
0.9471891522407532,
0.4438309669494629,
-0.9821867942810059,
-0.47715577483177185,
0.206882044672966,
-0.1825215071439743,
-0.2649610638618469,
-0.15653616189956665,
-0.08717115223407745,
-0.3692454397678375,
-0.9343096017837524,
0.5665519833564758,
0.5226729512214661,
0.11658480018377304,
-0.03648729622364044,
-0.18986231088638306,
-0.4594850242137909,
-0.017398370429873466,
0.4769628345966339,
-0.1852424442768097,
-0.9779630899429321,
-0.1558041274547577,
-0.24539414048194885,
-0.09587699919939041,
-0.27484366297721863,
0.7565986514091492,
-0.2913152277469635,
0.5171346664428711,
0.5595113039016724,
0.783251166343689,
0.7050188779830933,
0.05638861283659935,
0.6612914204597473,
-0.9451574683189392,
0.7154778838157654,
0.3076225519180298,
0.3164914846420288,
0.19539910554885864,
-0.19913186132907867,
0.569045901298523,
0.41413968801498413,
-0.6008671522140503,
-1.0499756336212158,
0.16619715094566345,
-1.163691520690918,
-0.046116746962070465,
0.8990159034729004,
-0.11833173036575317,
-0.19839705526828766,
-0.15584436058998108,
-0.3288721442222595,
0.4129888713359833,
-0.3428038954734802,
-0.03715319558978081,
0.911623477935791,
-0.08592092990875244,
-0.10551971197128296,
-1.0917927026748657,
0.41534286737442017,
0.6886327862739563,
-0.8479591608047485,
0.12954558432102203,
0.40517523884773254,
0.11287036538124084,
0.017766105011105537,
0.8715264201164246,
-0.2851605713367462,
0.34696441888809204,
0.11336499452590942,
0.0891384407877922,
0.13316890597343445,
-0.433355450630188,
-0.17726768553256989,
-0.09419915080070496,
-0.055030375719070435,
-0.17234578728675842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14171v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14171v1 | Ranking LLMs by compression | 2024-06-20T10:23:38 | 2024-06-20T10:23:38 | Peijia Guo, Ziguang Li, Haibo Hu, Chao Huang, Ming Li, Rui Zhang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We conceptualize the process of understanding as information compression, and
propose a method for ranking large language models (LLMs) based on lossless
data compression. We demonstrate the equivalence of compression length under
arithmetic coding with cumulative negative log probabilities when using a large
language model as a prior, that is, the pre-training phase of the model is
essentially the process of learning the optimal coding length. At the same
time, the evaluation metric compression ratio can be obtained without actual
compression, which greatly saves overhead. In this paper, we use five large
language models as priors for compression, then compare their performance on
challenging natural language processing tasks, including sentence completion,
question answering, and coreference resolution. Experimental results show that
compression ratio and model performance are positively correlated, so it can be
used as a general metric to evaluate large language models. | [
-0.4284712076187134,
-0.5677005052566528,
0.7270654439926147,
-0.0069278995506465435,
-0.41768646240234375,
0.002858951222151518,
-0.6558853983879089,
-0.4581435024738312,
0.13461622595787048,
0.5077688097953796,
-0.35475581884384155,
-0.4535609185695648,
-0.8623385429382324,
0.2711847424507141,
-0.3976428806781769,
0.7088348865509033,
0.2418878823518753,
0.21951553225517273,
-0.43575942516326904,
0.06286964565515518,
-0.45750051736831665,
-0.9636910557746887,
-0.715588390827179,
-0.3647133409976959,
0.2225339710712433,
0.15284867584705353,
0.8392676115036011,
0.5556824803352356,
0.762793779373169,
0.4037553071975708,
-0.09965053200721741,
-0.029241343960165977,
-0.7571860551834106,
-0.002772692823782563,
-0.04586033523082733,
-0.5768391489982605,
-0.40331777930259705,
0.08199574798345566,
0.7498987913131714,
0.8460153937339783,
-0.18357999622821808,
0.3874206840991974,
-0.07465403527021408,
0.6275011897087097,
-0.6096735000610352,
-0.03721383959054947,
-0.6708225607872009,
0.080006904900074,
0.1280614286661148,
-0.6737964749336243,
-0.7131938934326172,
-0.7291615009307861,
-0.15361285209655762,
-0.14306776225566864,
0.1754511594772339,
0.1473720520734787,
0.6492293477058411,
0.34491047263145447,
-0.34897491335868835,
-0.3470744788646698,
-0.648005485534668,
0.8240139484405518,
-0.9008047580718994,
0.5299362540245056,
0.4726194739341736,
0.16967783868312836,
0.03220461308956146,
-0.2500160038471222,
-0.6135854125022888,
-0.3827345371246338,
-0.05476705729961395,
-0.13005565106868744,
-0.1673639565706253,
0.24992497265338898,
0.46353641152381897,
0.722865641117096,
-0.7857826352119446,
0.4285781681537628,
-0.3881562352180481,
-0.21520663797855377,
0.7039603590965271,
0.11750096082687378,
0.18159838020801544,
-0.03989489749073982,
-0.044313494116067886,
-0.09250941872596741,
-0.9120849967002869,
-0.025473101064562798,
0.6183497309684753,
0.15024550259113312,
0.05814084783196449,
0.705268919467926,
-0.20518314838409424,
0.993543267250061,
-0.1412879228591919,
-0.47100359201431274,
0.363150954246521,
-0.27843523025512695,
-0.44932201504707336,
0.030946072190999985,
0.6466283798217773,
0.28435543179512024,
0.37413692474365234,
-0.41103920340538025,
-0.20584000647068024,
0.19051755964756012,
0.3164462149143219,
-0.9350163340568542,
-0.016899459064006805,
0.014631437137722969,
-0.506335973739624,
-0.06428825855255127,
-0.055060483515262604,
-0.32583683729171753,
-0.28165119886398315,
-0.5871762037277222,
0.561458945274353,
-0.11860811710357666,
-0.03397228568792343,
0.4582890272140503,
-0.031031953170895576,
0.06907999515533447,
0.32614386081695557,
-0.6919904947280884,
0.39577165246009827,
0.6423069834709167,
0.8961297273635864,
0.0759401023387909,
0.024784892797470093,
-0.5205551981925964,
-0.1529681384563446,
-0.6289275884628296,
0.5964762568473816,
-0.54155033826828,
-0.3988834619522095,
-0.046720996499061584,
-0.15701380372047424,
0.12479910254478455,
-0.6206976175308228,
1.0000532865524292,
-0.6839653253555298,
0.12833528220653534,
0.15096651017665863,
-0.9471374154090881,
-0.31463557481765747,
0.2808772325515747,
-0.5701070427894592,
0.6517131924629211,
-0.04191341623663902,
-0.6082801818847656,
-0.030151156708598137,
-0.265622615814209,
-0.2825346887111664,
-0.0016949455020949244,
0.1050804927945137,
-0.05820915475487709,
0.4290574789047241,
0.17423968017101288,
0.8836538791656494,
-0.6257610321044922,
0.23272980749607086,
-0.21745909750461578,
-0.407988041639328,
0.1484299898147583,
-0.3853408992290497,
0.4859786033630371,
0.17079851031303406,
0.2156466245651245,
0.05140179023146629,
-0.6661601662635803,
0.09961966425180435,
0.11718230694532394,
-0.617144763469696,
-0.39647549390792847,
-0.045932963490486145,
-0.5325647592544556,
0.28501471877098083,
0.39572396874427795,
-0.33365845680236816,
0.46251237392425537,
-0.48610860109329224,
0.40747496485710144,
0.7116473317146301,
-0.016531893983483315,
0.4573354423046112,
-0.23448432981967926,
0.4610059857368469,
-0.27912428975105286,
0.0736134946346283,
-0.12285782396793365,
-0.10701858252286911,
-1.072960615158081,
0.06313390284776688,
0.4989962875843048,
0.48306623101234436,
-0.5612722039222717,
0.7035141587257385,
-0.8612076640129089,
-0.6393918395042419,
-0.4410187602043152,
0.14994852244853973,
0.33496057987213135,
0.4592605531215668,
0.31661996245384216,
-0.3876100182533264,
-0.44831085205078125,
-0.8169823884963989,
-0.13300509750843048,
-0.29279637336730957,
-0.2854088246822357,
0.33016085624694824,
0.2037171572446823,
0.024004362523555756,
0.3860735595226288,
-0.6440505981445312,
0.0917431116104126,
-0.3476823568344116,
0.368664413690567,
0.6639682054519653,
0.4158164858818054,
0.30396074056625366,
-0.5388367772102356,
-0.12239118665456772,
-0.31964945793151855,
-0.6033797860145569,
-0.16952335834503174,
0.18178537487983704,
0.08251471817493439,
0.22060491144657135,
0.42063602805137634,
-0.6464657187461853,
0.36401697993278503,
0.7746803760528564,
-0.2820447087287903,
0.6796256303787231,
-0.34566792845726013,
0.4740202724933624,
-0.715029776096344,
-0.026721816509962082,
-0.06950780004262924,
-0.4582066535949707,
-0.5770602226257324,
0.12434167414903641,
0.1111157089471817,
-0.17401695251464844,
-0.2981325685977936,
0.2468586564064026,
-0.6333919167518616,
-0.2749481499195099,
-0.14503970742225647,
0.11211016029119492,
-0.11380599439144135,
0.5540212392807007,
0.19937002658843994,
0.7112836241722107,
0.4123326539993286,
-0.8486573696136475,
0.4172777533531189,
-0.10906890779733658,
-0.8459001779556274,
0.22849757969379425,
-0.6161109805107117,
0.3330256938934326,
-0.4592961072921753,
0.12235105782747269,
-0.8006883263587952,
0.2542595863342285,
-0.19250787794589996,
-0.4618850648403168,
0.5147925615310669,
-0.2268427461385727,
-0.7699940204620361,
-0.5398045182228088,
-0.31248387694358826,
0.45480528473854065,
0.6475459933280945,
-0.29141929745674133,
-0.0019202613038942218,
0.32791197299957275,
-0.29242727160453796,
-0.5337446928024292,
-0.6458689570426941,
0.23830252885818481,
-0.3924194276332855,
-0.5709614753723145,
0.4840342700481415,
-0.6246707439422607,
-0.09059398621320724,
-0.17651936411857605,
0.06371048837900162,
0.023764237761497498,
0.04336680844426155,
0.1127057671546936,
0.32346004247665405,
-0.2370610386133194,
0.41002339124679565,
-0.4332679212093353,
0.07022634893655777,
-0.07380517572164536,
-0.19013382494449615,
0.8314462304115295,
0.08755918592214584,
-0.08937311172485352,
-0.3030613958835602,
0.06667988747358322,
0.287654310464859,
-0.07229278236627579,
0.7957810163497925,
0.11672978103160858,
-0.27926313877105713,
0.13976965844631195,
-0.7535116672515869,
-0.0025801314041018486,
-0.4094332754611969,
0.16091258823871613,
-0.3734726905822754,
-1.1610596179962158,
0.28216353058815,
0.003769530449062586,
-0.09445330500602722,
0.4309132397174835,
0.5249533653259277,
0.3273649513721466,
1.0433759689331055,
0.770037055015564,
-0.3468853235244751,
0.38793373107910156,
-0.22236575186252594,
0.3181110620498657,
-0.5975378155708313,
0.10094084590673447,
-0.8540550470352173,
-0.21812424063682556,
-0.27655377984046936,
-0.5517991781234741,
0.19679245352745056,
0.6444997787475586,
-0.45919209718704224,
0.43015047907829285,
-0.4801357388496399,
0.7182567119598389,
0.19110630452632904,
-0.02750030905008316,
0.5015727877616882,
-0.09099370986223221,
0.21468594670295715,
-0.031194576993584633,
-0.514232337474823,
-0.48666834831237793,
1.041529655456543,
0.4211558401584625,
0.8445795178413391,
0.41308730840682983,
0.557526171207428,
0.351493239402771,
0.26219555735588074,
-1.0619028806686401,
0.4576055109500885,
-0.10267332941293716,
-0.2946249842643738,
-0.451030969619751,
-0.8648042678833008,
-0.9451304078102112,
0.15372517704963684,
-0.3156852424144745,
-0.8805561065673828,
-0.15641914308071136,
-0.17802727222442627,
-0.29260724782943726,
0.16048243641853333,
-0.6277507543563843,
0.5812641978263855,
-0.2242886871099472,
0.12371920049190521,
-0.4651518166065216,
-0.4125865697860718,
0.5278320908546448,
-0.024317972362041473,
0.409256249666214,
-0.08786268532276154,
-0.15188179910182953,
0.9504550695419312,
-0.39124780893325806,
0.39295053482055664,
0.17449158430099487,
0.05536850914359093,
0.05451824143528938,
0.259409636259079,
0.35348159074783325,
-0.03404800593852997,
-0.16664685308933258,
0.27297264337539673,
-0.07999276369810104,
-0.2769404649734497,
-0.9286586046218872,
0.6433433294296265,
-0.6974469423294067,
-0.6469202041625977,
-0.11830978840589523,
-0.3082086443901062,
-0.17144253849983215,
0.20685254037380219,
0.4250815510749817,
0.5531186461448669,
0.01718764565885067,
0.2704017162322998,
0.650189995765686,
-0.3515438437461853,
0.4809192717075348,
0.5194260478019714,
-0.2631959319114685,
-0.3482639491558075,
0.61155104637146,
0.32699811458587646,
0.3427341878414154,
0.7909113764762878,
0.1418122500181198,
-0.4019029140472412,
-0.926862895488739,
-0.15274912118911743,
0.28512582182884216,
-0.8480305075645447,
-0.5506547689437866,
-0.6019924283027649,
-0.343034952878952,
-0.6612328290939331,
0.04328274726867676,
-0.18794800341129303,
-0.4839803874492645,
-0.0455058254301548,
-0.20128443837165833,
0.09112292528152466,
0.8496368527412415,
0.14789339900016785,
0.2547905147075653,
-0.8997538685798645,
0.26756420731544495,
0.24458470940589905,
0.3741528391838074,
0.16981036961078644,
-0.7790616154670715,
-0.31997063755989075,
-0.1289181411266327,
-0.2885197699069977,
-0.7977167367935181,
0.4560832679271698,
0.2468385398387909,
0.562412440776825,
0.463252991437912,
0.09672766923904419,
0.8010209798812866,
-0.6603367924690247,
0.9868365526199341,
0.3952721059322357,
-1.0631669759750366,
0.4381738305091858,
0.2164120227098465,
0.2630622684955597,
0.36951398849487305,
0.7362199425697327,
-0.477733850479126,
-0.14424295723438263,
-0.6645952463150024,
-0.7074630856513977,
0.4087308943271637,
0.10003882646560669,
0.24007515609264374,
-0.04518366977572441,
0.2729283273220062,
-0.007132248021662235,
0.32159537076950073,
-0.8510416150093079,
-0.27044135332107544,
0.22476094961166382,
-0.018090609461069107,
-0.712725043296814,
-0.5259922742843628,
0.10972627252340317,
-0.30805787444114685,
0.6751869320869446,
0.04776954650878906,
0.4249058663845062,
0.10127285122871399,
-0.4373638331890106,
0.0663454532623291,
0.4309048354625702,
0.5218939781188965,
0.6689451932907104,
-0.1796061098575592,
0.41943129897117615,
0.2486104518175125,
-0.19850529730319977,
0.19331365823745728,
-0.2034757435321808,
0.3527086675167084,
-0.07783651351928711,
0.7505099773406982,
0.8163432478904724,
0.3361096680164337,
-0.7003915905952454,
0.6786226034164429,
-0.2641049921512604,
0.01965360902249813,
-0.13457369804382324,
0.0322292298078537,
0.04878101870417595,
-0.06627926975488663,
0.2483411729335785,
-0.22046391665935516,
0.2981615364551544,
-0.6170815825462341,
-0.17746566236019135,
0.36212360858917236,
-0.15439549088478088,
-0.11594870686531067,
0.0823173001408577,
-0.08644117414951324,
-0.3009922504425049,
0.748960018157959,
-0.08269446343183517,
-0.5132578015327454,
0.4144707918167114,
0.4294961988925934,
0.5442516803741455,
-0.2842291593551636,
-0.08687616139650345,
0.6265711784362793,
0.3515516519546509,
-0.38232606649398804,
0.05943712592124939,
-0.27206602692604065,
-0.7393196821212769,
-0.8928759694099426,
-0.9973435997962952,
-0.09831324219703674,
0.2760799527168274,
-0.4960147738456726,
0.3968369662761688,
-0.35429027676582336,
-0.19853492081165314,
0.10667809844017029,
0.251302033662796,
-0.790239155292511,
0.29918619990348816,
0.2932863235473633,
1.1581497192382812,
-0.5502710938453674,
0.7448900938034058,
0.26815465092658997,
-0.28752079606056213,
-0.8735367655754089,
-0.3078736662864685,
-0.26359835267066956,
-0.5685175061225891,
0.647762656211853,
0.2728348970413208,
-0.02379678003489971,
-0.006760020740330219,
-0.5778998136520386,
-1.0208638906478882,
0.805759072303772,
0.7030888795852661,
-0.5789747834205627,
-0.07031359523534775,
-0.04548782482743263,
0.606023371219635,
-0.33659058809280396,
0.4381962716579437,
0.3819690942764282,
0.2795223891735077,
0.17398053407669067,
-1.0492664575576782,
-0.10988989472389221,
-0.2273472100496292,
-0.09211753308773041,
0.3969995975494385,
-0.24710774421691895,
0.8163765072822571,
-0.05083749443292618,
-0.47611817717552185,
0.12551994621753693,
0.4739314317703247,
-0.1303918957710266,
-0.20148085057735443,
0.5217264294624329,
0.8297126889228821,
0.7812346816062927,
0.12996719777584076,
1.1316683292388916,
-0.31513383984565735,
0.5193409323692322,
0.9907454252243042,
0.11753565073013306,
1.0671889781951904,
0.12074403464794159,
-0.4605911076068878,
0.3967238962650299,
0.6661030650138855,
0.3277883231639862,
0.32054656744003296,
0.5213723182678223,
-0.061216797679662704,
-0.518759548664093,
-0.10320340096950531,
-0.49495869874954224,
0.22942125797271729,
0.25840258598327637,
-0.4538702964782715,
-0.06326569616794586,
-0.307071328163147,
0.0180448479950428,
0.11942175030708313,
-0.6727256774902344,
0.8663996458053589,
0.21524493396282196,
-0.7306690216064453,
1.168411374092102,
0.069707490503788,
0.844929575920105,
-0.5652211308479309,
0.1769588142633438,
-0.04150989651679993,
-0.26869237422943115,
-0.25000497698783875,
-0.8947175741195679,
0.33600378036499023,
0.08925872296094894,
-0.3822285830974579,
-0.19674967229366302,
0.5159691572189331,
-0.4013240337371826,
-0.5547611713409424,
0.16287773847579956,
0.25642046332359314,
0.5621011853218079,
-0.08187557011842728,
-0.34286612272262573,
0.12171754986047745,
-0.3354724943637848,
-0.23728233575820923,
0.29088687896728516,
0.19708260893821716,
0.2408226579427719,
0.8023769855499268,
0.6178886890411377,
0.3012019991874695,
-0.031488046050071716,
0.13034102320671082,
0.6312086582183838,
-0.8138837218284607,
-0.5677693486213684,
-1.0790047645568848,
0.027920978143811226,
-0.15218082070350647,
0.0516853965818882,
0.5808686017990112,
0.5890941619873047,
0.9069373607635498,
0.016789834946393967,
0.5464774370193481,
0.14316360652446747,
0.4523794651031494,
-0.8710219264030457,
0.4573741555213928,
-0.45894962549209595,
0.2457772195339203,
-0.30577805638313293,
-1.0659817457199097,
-0.3888636827468872,
0.5716086626052856,
-0.48620209097862244,
-0.13875064253807068,
0.6019912362098694,
0.6475944519042969,
-0.0013680894626304507,
-0.14715535938739777,
0.6164767146110535,
0.3231930732727051,
0.08993594348430634,
0.9542111158370972,
0.802329957485199,
-0.20281732082366943,
0.40549302101135254,
-0.080424003303051,
-0.20990793406963348,
-0.06625141948461533,
-1.1006985902786255,
-0.934529721736908,
-0.5328328013420105,
-0.1763119399547577,
-0.15880374610424042,
-0.12078505009412766,
0.9746541976928711,
0.889028787612915,
-0.4945555031299591,
-0.26999348402023315,
0.07285819947719574,
0.2907278537750244,
0.06097870692610741,
-0.18755297362804413,
0.23593541979789734,
-0.22145496308803558,
-0.6876809597015381,
0.3195354640483856,
0.27299436926841736,
0.09639575332403183,
-0.3537232577800751,
-0.23291203379631042,
0.03129460662603378,
0.13133911788463593,
0.7757417559623718,
-0.022926287725567818,
-0.5719659924507141,
-0.3122791051864624,
-0.39964890480041504,
-0.03830358013510704,
0.060664102435112,
0.8127321004867554,
-0.8636780381202698,
0.23622411489486694,
0.7975401878356934,
0.6036480665206909,
0.4452373683452606,
0.03882801905274391,
0.5077099204063416,
-0.6102499961853027,
0.21039551496505737,
0.2009785920381546,
0.4326052963733673,
0.5096631050109863,
-0.470740407705307,
0.686627209186554,
-0.09972193092107773,
-0.79302579164505,
-0.8063522577285767,
0.32719123363494873,
-0.8400923609733582,
-0.39428913593292236,
1.106248378753662,
-0.3346022665500641,
-0.006626181770116091,
0.28368616104125977,
-0.08248188346624374,
0.14606158435344696,
-0.26068079471588135,
0.6378045082092285,
0.9609352350234985,
-0.09925222396850586,
-0.35746362805366516,
-0.5719418525695801,
0.4124193787574768,
0.1157914474606514,
-0.5087701678276062,
-0.030590860173106194,
0.46373450756073,
0.015490073710680008,
0.2643235921859741,
0.5419466495513916,
-0.027877027168869972,
-0.1977376937866211,
-0.33179253339767456,
0.03854576498270035,
0.0871962457895279,
-0.28059497475624084,
-0.6420242190361023,
0.29412391781806946,
0.4472637176513672,
0.41206949949264526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14167v1 | Definition generation for lexical semantic change detection | 2024-06-20T10:13:08 | 2024-06-20T10:13:08 | Mariia Fedorova, Andrey Kutuzov, Yves Scherrer | cs.CL | cs.CL | We use contextualized word definitions generated by large language models as
semantic representations in the task of diachronic lexical semantic change
detection (LSCD). In short, generated definitions are used as `senses', and the
change score of a target word is retrieved by comparing their distributions in
two time periods under comparison. On the material of five datasets and three
languages, we show that generated definitions are indeed specific and general
enough to convey a signal sufficient to rank sets of words by the degree of
their semantic change over time. Our approach is on par with or outperforms
prior non-supervised sense-based LSCD methods. At the same time, it preserves
interpretability and allows to inspect the reasons behind a specific shift in
terms of discrete definitions-as-senses. This is another step in the direction
of explainable semantic change modeling. | [
-0.5146171450614929,
-0.5462411642074585,
0.5611825585365295,
0.06209435686469078,
-0.4283156096935272,
-0.3850652575492859,
-0.3000788390636444,
-0.500867486000061,
0.16177107393741608,
0.33509328961372375,
-0.6237330436706543,
-0.5876219272613525,
-0.5375384092330933,
0.36198535561561584,
-0.794427752494812,
0.8336197137832642,
-0.30726173520088196,
-0.3755069077014923,
0.03915607929229736,
-0.13496515154838562,
-0.4276439845561981,
-0.1408778578042984,
-0.3349873125553131,
-0.5151415467262268,
0.7474015951156616,
0.05770725756883621,
0.7145399451255798,
0.6870948672294617,
0.31804415583610535,
0.2922307848930359,
-0.36713647842407227,
0.08006134629249573,
-0.03385241702198982,
0.2543584704399109,
-0.3870890736579895,
-0.2610461413860321,
-0.1447150707244873,
-0.09564965963363647,
0.7659050822257996,
0.9835432171821594,
-0.1278674602508545,
0.06246987357735634,
-0.04142265021800995,
0.3982671797275543,
-0.8324105739593506,
0.3302232027053833,
-1.152995228767395,
0.030768027529120445,
-0.42498329281806946,
-0.35111159086227417,
-0.2632467448711395,
-0.01037520170211792,
0.06606108695268631,
-0.549162745475769,
0.5341880321502686,
-0.46655282378196716,
0.8866752982139587,
0.2398131936788559,
-0.33921751379966736,
-0.5251206159591675,
-0.5636782050132751,
0.6046111583709717,
-0.6329556107521057,
0.7176328301429749,
0.13355477154254913,
0.40897008776664734,
-0.16346213221549988,
-0.9193841814994812,
-0.8268020749092102,
-0.2088738977909088,
0.014151760376989841,
0.11477519571781158,
-0.14839977025985718,
-0.078071229159832,
0.353488564491272,
0.13352608680725098,
-0.10845773667097092,
0.04182133823633194,
-0.12782026827335358,
-0.34768930077552795,
0.5018569231033325,
0.2517286539077759,
0.10661569237709045,
-0.29351526498794556,
-0.3202150762081146,
-0.2229878455400467,
-0.8596878051757812,
-0.10075327008962631,
-0.10667064785957336,
0.34673240780830383,
-0.017605599015951157,
0.5550261735916138,
-0.5303489565849304,
0.7019152045249939,
0.04510057717561722,
-0.00031047611264511943,
0.26233503222465515,
-0.6405729651451111,
-0.32658812403678894,
0.4546789228916168,
0.22254404425621033,
0.5604007840156555,
0.1534351259469986,
-0.15186470746994019,
-0.2791018486022949,
0.605415403842926,
-0.026716899126768112,
-0.840430498123169,
-0.239039346575737,
-0.20565176010131836,
-0.31686174869537354,
-0.4395085275173187,
0.04290235415101051,
-0.43262234330177307,
-0.41042080521583557,
-0.6409589052200317,
0.013904958963394165,
-0.4536694884300232,
-0.3630419373512268,
0.3465217649936676,
-0.21999363601207733,
0.40583518147468567,
0.31813812255859375,
-0.9854519963264465,
0.07062261551618576,
0.48295295238494873,
0.5362421870231628,
-0.36024782061576843,
-0.17728202044963837,
-0.10148156434297562,
0.11898171156644821,
-1.0275107622146606,
0.8608187437057495,
-0.25532397627830505,
-0.44979673624038696,
0.02938895858824253,
0.1101607233285904,
0.17707733809947968,
-0.6785940527915955,
-0.09518378973007202,
-0.6256181597709656,
0.011590071953833103,
-0.43086791038513184,
-0.4665334224700928,
0.11908280849456787,
0.16992227733135223,
-0.30629077553749084,
1.099055290222168,
0.30848386883735657,
-0.7420954704284668,
1.1835988759994507,
-0.4787476658821106,
-0.26464512944221497,
0.422618567943573,
-0.026564504951238632,
-0.10473204404115677,
0.33804869651794434,
-0.039217397570610046,
0.3384729027748108,
0.05335284769535065,
0.49778449535369873,
0.13287140429019928,
-0.001223348779603839,
0.3844236135482788,
-0.07000245153903961,
0.4809892773628235,
0.4793793857097626,
-0.21986864507198334,
0.12001162767410278,
-0.8312282562255859,
0.13951635360717773,
-0.0005301045021042228,
-0.39368125796318054,
-0.6179707646369934,
0.4388815760612488,
0.18525482714176178,
0.17986814677715302,
0.23667438328266144,
-0.702206015586853,
-0.19073748588562012,
-0.5309662222862244,
0.5195586681365967,
0.7127553224563599,
0.09704097360372543,
0.20606078207492828,
0.11324212700128555,
0.10156222432851791,
0.5191975831985474,
-0.034176912158727646,
-0.2920200526714325,
-0.3808288872241974,
-0.8123981356620789,
0.10120760649442673,
0.35957401990890503,
0.12942522764205933,
-0.7871360182762146,
0.6470542550086975,
-0.23369014263153076,
-0.3734603524208069,
-0.12878450751304626,
-0.01800299808382988,
0.05924701318144798,
0.5525411367416382,
0.5304972529411316,
-0.16166159510612488,
-0.43269261717796326,
-0.785733699798584,
-0.18662786483764648,
-0.23798522353172302,
-0.14501367509365082,
-0.04671059921383858,
0.514521062374115,
-0.6920759081840515,
1.3097506761550903,
-0.5489809513092041,
0.07804080098867416,
-0.15889506042003632,
-0.008662068285048008,
-0.21571007370948792,
0.10282273590564728,
0.3691703677177429,
-0.856833279132843,
-0.004704667255282402,
0.05260302871465683,
-0.714196503162384,
-0.7605121731758118,
-0.30073997378349304,
0.07185134291648865,
0.09861907362937927,
1.0349063873291016,
-0.25064346194267273,
0.5268346071243286,
0.32759445905685425,
-0.6406663060188293,
0.7481991052627563,
-0.01789124496281147,
-0.059268828481435776,
-1.2358639240264893,
-0.2043331265449524,
-0.31482771039009094,
-0.1893487274646759,
-0.5896822810173035,
0.34258711338043213,
0.1568090319633484,
0.021031076088547707,
-0.7372516393661499,
0.4989389479160309,
-0.29463034868240356,
-0.27081525325775146,
-0.20236723124980927,
0.7052197456359863,
-0.015834499150514603,
-0.1603340059518814,
0.19269028306007385,
0.35197919607162476,
0.4332517087459564,
-1.0050857067108154,
0.4699081778526306,
0.25282663106918335,
-0.5742618441581726,
0.5717262625694275,
-0.5887154340744019,
-0.28379514813423157,
-0.26331302523612976,
0.12159857898950577,
-0.9362892508506775,
-0.05930062383413315,
-0.0726972296833992,
-0.33161747455596924,
-0.1671602874994278,
0.36643168330192566,
-0.44095754623413086,
-0.2613547146320343,
-0.010204045102000237,
0.4731823801994324,
0.08434636145830154,
-0.6044332981109619,
0.16307559609413147,
0.13838481903076172,
0.22376839816570282,
0.10403566807508469,
-0.8533517718315125,
0.22037528455257416,
-0.2561095356941223,
-0.6000434160232544,
0.7867002487182617,
-0.026104750111699104,
-0.6428458094596863,
0.20831654965877533,
-0.19035427272319794,
0.2907930016517639,
0.30104008316993713,
0.17525433003902435,
0.10600845515727997,
-0.18944837152957916,
0.6508349180221558,
0.1992698758840561,
-0.278958261013031,
0.05806712061166763,
-0.02642291598021984,
0.621898353099823,
0.16707947850227356,
-0.1985607147216797,
-0.24092668294906616,
0.2377614825963974,
0.22396457195281982,
-0.27864935994148254,
0.6417227983474731,
0.6567834615707397,
-0.5651625990867615,
-0.28859174251556396,
-0.32291746139526367,
-0.26459553837776184,
-0.4306499660015106,
0.23775619268417358,
-0.5473117828369141,
-0.8981499671936035,
0.7115411162376404,
-0.25292471051216125,
0.030799204483628273,
0.7042393684387207,
0.8209570050239563,
0.28221452236175537,
0.9565848708152771,
0.47706112265586853,
0.4234364926815033,
0.6345583200454712,
0.06125030294060707,
0.14304977655410767,
-0.9688785672187805,
-0.13217751681804657,
-0.3112791180610657,
-0.1720430552959442,
-0.9211159944534302,
-0.3857136368751526,
0.44037559628486633,
0.2508045434951782,
-0.23036745190620422,
0.38784024119377136,
-0.48296570777893066,
0.21526013314723969,
0.12510840594768524,
-0.07289426773786545,
0.2403622269630432,
-0.24345912039279938,
-0.3468824028968811,
-0.07529499381780624,
-0.2630389928817749,
-0.27617576718330383,
0.8288018107414246,
-0.0018157933373004198,
0.5953916907310486,
0.16123566031455994,
0.870058536529541,
0.3613087236881256,
0.18952569365501404,
-0.7969765067100525,
0.7514245510101318,
0.005230806302279234,
-0.054121095687150955,
-0.10203985124826431,
-0.22346006333827972,
-1.1244840621948242,
0.2903331220149994,
-0.34983041882514954,
-0.6352043747901917,
0.2064017802476883,
-0.015444987453520298,
0.0516042560338974,
0.039199892431497574,
-0.36702752113342285,
0.6619940996170044,
0.15526315569877625,
0.07341566681861877,
-0.44066256284713745,
-0.263325959444046,
0.27891284227371216,
-0.2691727876663208,
-0.055021513253450394,
-0.38206249475479126,
-0.1575242131948471,
0.8616636395454407,
-0.658317506313324,
0.6118469834327698,
-0.24950943887233734,
-0.2987063527107239,
0.34688887000083923,
0.30048057436943054,
0.2491961270570755,
-0.016452301293611526,
-0.10203035175800323,
0.08800023794174194,
0.4065054655075073,
-0.13205447793006897,
-0.4133702218532562,
0.85415118932724,
-0.384813129901886,
-0.29447489976882935,
-0.2649765610694885,
-0.5313410758972168,
-0.012980194762349129,
0.2142883837223053,
0.33656105399131775,
0.628115177154541,
-0.3090863525867462,
-0.001902122632600367,
0.3943527340888977,
-0.410050630569458,
0.46275627613067627,
0.6693221926689148,
-0.44732216000556946,
0.2835492491722107,
0.5755917429924011,
-0.04706643149256706,
0.48674947023391724,
0.1399202048778534,
0.4970100224018097,
-0.37202975153923035,
-0.3600216209888458,
-0.32033857703208923,
-0.01728910394012928,
-0.7709420323371887,
-0.07126776874065399,
-0.09949497878551483,
-0.19117918610572815,
-0.43553149700164795,
-0.4201902151107788,
-0.2048240303993225,
-0.214586541056633,
-0.14394307136535645,
0.005494371522217989,
0.3196665942668915,
0.6881073713302612,
-0.09685815870761871,
0.21031855046749115,
-0.25773435831069946,
0.5549435019493103,
0.28797438740730286,
0.15651851892471313,
-0.26407134532928467,
-0.2499770224094391,
-0.11105388402938843,
0.17328399419784546,
-0.12768647074699402,
-0.9845825433731079,
0.42571768164634705,
0.4191678762435913,
0.43221718072891235,
0.6615099906921387,
-0.06388060003519058,
0.6522408127784729,
-0.3901597261428833,
1.0627106428146362,
0.2194242775440216,
-1.0443238019943237,
0.8816919922828674,
-0.1523749679327011,
0.8618552684783936,
0.17080500721931458,
-0.059855867177248,
-1.0292457342147827,
-0.3624403774738312,
-0.37250882387161255,
-0.7364314794540405,
0.4162046015262604,
-0.22693967819213867,
0.252309113740921,
-0.6735129356384277,
0.4678545296192169,
0.042938683182001114,
0.07874880731105804,
-0.2708173096179962,
0.036443162709474564,
-0.1977560669183731,
-0.03623387962579727,
-0.08464819192886353,
-0.31559810042381287,
0.034809600561857224,
-0.1460532695055008,
0.2526392340660095,
-0.31029200553894043,
0.3001466691493988,
0.3181096315383911,
-0.331216961145401,
-0.005101947113871574,
0.4435761570930481,
0.5701624751091003,
0.8812565207481384,
0.08521943539381027,
0.44750791788101196,
0.2782408595085144,
-0.4415268003940582,
-0.18622459471225739,
-0.19138062000274658,
-0.3216840624809265,
0.2059660106897354,
0.47327643632888794,
0.664620578289032,
0.530341625213623,
-0.7319322228431702,
0.3185509443283081,
0.22890068590641022,
-0.28816038370132446,
-0.3115931451320648,
-0.04200533404946327,
0.042614441365003586,
-0.044565699994564056,
0.15197913348674774,
-0.21479257941246033,
0.023679006844758987,
-0.5957395434379578,
0.4464556872844696,
0.4299663305282593,
-0.3844817280769348,
-0.4060696065425873,
0.6677209734916687,
-0.1804320216178894,
0.1801408976316452,
0.7218326330184937,
-0.41888338327407837,
-0.4618087410926819,
0.4719513952732086,
0.8366167545318604,
0.7323673963546753,
-0.3859972357749939,
0.27568891644477844,
0.25406837463378906,
-0.16237211227416992,
0.11628731340169907,
0.08374112099409103,
-0.41776132583618164,
-1.555155634880066,
-0.1751416176557541,
-0.938194215297699,
-0.018750475719571114,
0.052512723952531815,
-0.8989301919937134,
0.4577752947807312,
-0.3567731976509094,
-0.1893007457256317,
0.42401987314224243,
-0.45669883489608765,
-0.5726636648178101,
0.27221426367759705,
0.4722587466239929,
0.9296985864639282,
-1.0048518180847168,
0.7731805443763733,
0.5897144079208374,
-0.07397705316543579,
-0.5443812012672424,
-0.05420726165175438,
0.04532284289598465,
-0.8631271719932556,
0.8288835883140564,
-0.037928126752376556,
-0.2891140580177307,
0.08440165221691132,
-0.33338800072669983,
-0.623298704624176,
1.1518982648849487,
-0.1513095498085022,
-0.5041789412498474,
0.03813624754548073,
0.28442832827568054,
0.7751234173774719,
-0.3724724054336548,
-0.04219668731093407,
0.897187352180481,
0.5421286225318909,
0.15608079731464386,
-0.7130070328712463,
-0.008976373821496964,
-0.059985097497701645,
0.3949807286262512,
0.5635094046592712,
0.1685735136270523,
0.8565422892570496,
-0.21455688774585724,
-0.6977146863937378,
-0.00420735590159893,
0.5065503716468811,
-0.004902529995888472,
0.3786325752735138,
0.7069991827011108,
0.6395388245582581,
0.5477610230445862,
-0.35566478967666626,
0.9395697116851807,
-0.5090867280960083,
0.2581847906112671,
0.8002033829689026,
-0.14921391010284424,
0.8124687671661377,
0.5025390386581421,
-0.1228938177227974,
0.68709796667099,
0.8393881916999817,
0.11063174903392792,
0.7096195220947266,
0.3241482675075531,
-0.44686487317085266,
-0.4563579857349396,
-0.3556528091430664,
-0.3456510603427887,
0.6866833567619324,
0.744819700717926,
-0.5229490399360657,
-0.85931396484375,
0.07094782590866089,
-0.016810879111289978,
0.1551518440246582,
-0.7055312395095825,
0.9285562038421631,
-0.08335595577955246,
-0.5747347474098206,
0.8639386296272278,
0.23490044474601746,
0.5251871943473816,
-0.5861104130744934,
0.12370222061872482,
-0.02539948560297489,
0.30197808146476746,
-0.1714174598455429,
-0.8121179342269897,
0.61751389503479,
-0.30414971709251404,
-0.10450509935617447,
-0.28495529294013977,
0.6386128067970276,
-0.6098358035087585,
-0.4904347062110901,
0.45468881726264954,
0.49198105931282043,
0.16551098227500916,
0.01283150166273117,
-0.6007753014564514,
0.18677279353141785,
-0.25019118189811707,
-0.015651075169444084,
0.33419448137283325,
0.38958847522735596,
-0.7618082761764526,
0.34425875544548035,
0.5123276114463806,
0.2405293583869934,
0.21053890883922577,
0.36009490489959717,
0.82851642370224,
-0.5743162035942078,
-0.5747094750404358,
-0.6545183062553406,
0.0237429216504097,
0.2574178874492645,
-0.539040207862854,
0.4957391619682312,
0.299017071723938,
0.9911607503890991,
0.018692482262849808,
0.5805643200874329,
-0.3909517526626587,
0.2867027223110199,
-0.6669827699661255,
0.4357009530067444,
-0.4957309067249298,
0.14574871957302094,
-0.1712757796049118,
-0.9473815560340881,
-0.37949395179748535,
0.5278955101966858,
-0.27720558643341064,
-0.2547350227832794,
0.8324373364448547,
0.950952410697937,
0.08913517743349075,
-0.04904552549123764,
0.31015798449516296,
0.3311452269554138,
0.3957577645778656,
0.4517085552215576,
0.6773033142089844,
-0.21979635953903198,
-0.07526492327451706,
-0.04987882822751999,
-0.15077988803386688,
-0.005725522059947252,
-0.981678307056427,
-0.3809758722782135,
-1.1484076976776123,
-0.45294472575187683,
-0.30879294872283936,
0.04387465864419937,
0.5443133115768433,
0.36670076847076416,
-0.9673618078231812,
0.06524183601140976,
-0.40552595257759094,
-0.005987892858684063,
-0.4863821864128113,
-0.2960338592529297,
0.36513105034828186,
-0.5372266173362732,
-0.45817825198173523,
0.5351581573486328,
0.03692767396569252,
-0.19197320938110352,
-0.37107279896736145,
0.1341991424560547,
-0.042905811220407486,
0.16784325242042542,
1.0423353910446167,
0.03241133317351341,
-0.9329931735992432,
-0.7638898491859436,
-0.4189052879810333,
-0.0034416771959513426,
-0.29805630445480347,
0.8340410590171814,
-1.0741883516311646,
0.5864198207855225,
0.6486930251121521,
0.11325544863939285,
0.5354282855987549,
0.004570405930280685,
0.14494913816452026,
-0.6595425605773926,
0.3068070411682129,
-0.30281415581703186,
0.2664172649383545,
0.46681636571884155,
0.1437193602323532,
0.3630721867084503,
0.4880896508693695,
-0.14163754880428314,
-0.6016350984573364,
0.6042889356613159,
-1.044164776802063,
-0.2575857937335968,
1.2669814825057983,
0.12398340553045273,
-0.10428115725517273,
-0.08431417495012283,
0.10436772555112839,
0.2174997627735138,
0.07804257422685623,
0.8043943643569946,
0.4139980971813202,
-0.17067834734916687,
0.10153113305568695,
-0.3171858489513397,
0.7374348044395447,
-0.1119409054517746,
-0.5919962525367737,
0.14468957483768463,
0.6026867628097534,
0.5083167552947998,
0.3327018916606903,
0.3893493413925171,
-0.44505199790000916,
0.21773844957351685,
-0.08648232370615005,
0.18930216133594513,
0.07523051649332047,
-0.1523529440164566,
-0.09849998354911804,
-0.1867762953042984,
0.01015038788318634,
-0.11431167274713516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14164v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14164v1 | A Data-Driven Guided Decoding Mechanism for Diagnostic Captioning | 2024-06-20T10:08:17 | 2024-06-20T10:08:17 | Panagiotis Kaliosis, John Pavlopoulos, Foivos Charalampakos, Georgios Moschovis, Ion Androutsopoulos | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Diagnostic Captioning (DC) automatically generates a diagnostic text from one
or more medical images (e.g., X-rays, MRIs) of a patient. Treated as a draft,
the generated text may assist clinicians, by providing an initial estimation of
the patient's condition, speeding up and helping safeguard the diagnostic
process. The accuracy of a diagnostic text, however, strongly depends on how
well the key medical conditions depicted in the images are expressed. We
propose a new data-driven guided decoding method that incorporates medical
information, in the form of existing tags capturing key conditions of the
image(s), into the beam search of the diagnostic text generation process. We
evaluate the proposed method on two medical datasets using four DC systems that
range from generic image-to-text systems with CNN encoders and RNN decoders to
pre-trained Large Language Models. The latter can also be used in few- and
zero-shot learning scenarios. In most cases, the proposed mechanism improves
performance with respect to all evaluation measures. We provide an open-source
implementation of the proposed method at https://github.com/nlpaueb/dmmcs. | [
0.09284888207912445,
-0.46482205390930176,
0.8544709086418152,
0.030799895524978638,
-0.9406550526618958,
0.16904395818710327,
0.24935580790042877,
0.09535418450832367,
0.07385097444057465,
0.40940454602241516,
-0.7823368310928345,
-1.0763717889785767,
-0.5958399772644043,
0.5137820839881897,
-0.4485851526260376,
0.9132413864135742,
-0.14822454750537872,
0.4532577395439148,
-0.37933260202407837,
0.13036654889583588,
-0.6102129817008972,
-0.22460223734378815,
-0.6841064095497131,
-0.05660342052578926,
0.4916437268257141,
0.0964638888835907,
0.7763758897781372,
1.244954228401184,
0.8889071345329285,
0.14257904887199402,
0.09538621455430984,
0.5883117914199829,
-0.2000877559185028,
0.22851191461086273,
0.1758822798728943,
-0.5026716589927673,
-0.4670788645744324,
-0.15496768057346344,
0.5802909135818481,
0.5472552180290222,
-0.2532505691051483,
-0.2895296514034271,
-0.3492927849292755,
0.8203089833259583,
-0.34236449003219604,
0.7989464998245239,
-0.15975061058998108,
0.28557607531547546,
-0.03309944272041321,
-0.9971166253089905,
-0.5649970769882202,
-0.31907379627227783,
-0.05824209749698639,
-0.851895809173584,
0.3263028562068939,
0.054151035845279694,
0.7427704930305481,
0.6551958322525024,
-0.31903010606765747,
-0.497186541557312,
-0.45649439096450806,
0.40192046761512756,
-0.6472600102424622,
0.23132048547267914,
0.3156137466430664,
0.4624895751476288,
-0.0948282778263092,
-0.821241021156311,
-0.3573501408100128,
-0.04311003163456917,
-0.47006189823150635,
0.6417684555053711,
-0.33843183517456055,
0.2799583077430725,
0.23836137354373932,
0.3405439853668213,
-0.6702431440353394,
0.019683638587594032,
-0.2353048324584961,
-0.07499625533819199,
0.6013916730880737,
0.7188130617141724,
0.24955402314662933,
-0.33518800139427185,
-0.20398439466953278,
-0.22479039430618286,
-0.7923722863197327,
-0.3900012969970703,
-0.3308858275413513,
0.12709775567054749,
-0.24227285385131836,
0.49161508679389954,
-0.36974793672561646,
0.948962926864624,
0.20858311653137207,
-0.3713308870792389,
0.3976465165615082,
-0.4932960867881775,
-0.2675279378890991,
0.18886952102184296,
0.6469526290893555,
0.798538088798523,
-0.045906681567430496,
-0.18621820211410522,
-0.3734026849269867,
0.22867389023303986,
0.06982311606407166,
-0.8032878637313843,
-0.31684842705726624,
0.14760811626911163,
-0.7741393446922302,
-0.825764000415802,
-0.03477127104997635,
-0.7517493367195129,
-0.8183794021606445,
-0.12099522352218628,
-0.0025573931634426117,
-0.3769535422325134,
-0.024865765124559402,
0.40263882279396057,
-0.15386097133159637,
0.1141735315322876,
0.06995280832052231,
-0.5485519766807556,
0.19215840101242065,
0.24460174143314362,
1.022897720336914,
0.0012691973242908716,
0.31138840317726135,
-0.9823606014251709,
0.19774657487869263,
-0.48746854066848755,
0.8161166906356812,
-0.6438267230987549,
-0.571403980255127,
0.11195742338895798,
-0.003892685519531369,
-0.08502264320850372,
-0.5444759130477905,
0.3624659478664398,
-0.5827542543411255,
0.03397217020392418,
0.05237198248505592,
-0.5138863325119019,
-0.06387597322463989,
0.05466946214437485,
-0.8825547695159912,
0.2671613395214081,
0.19214752316474915,
-0.7740311026573181,
0.44962650537490845,
-0.7042150497436523,
-0.8274816274642944,
0.36012282967567444,
-0.5703032612800598,
-0.6915432810783386,
0.022968759760260582,
0.8156510591506958,
0.8085193037986755,
-0.4189576208591461,
0.2689891755580902,
0.15652583539485931,
-0.39481019973754883,
0.08871684968471527,
-0.38475868105888367,
0.39806804060935974,
0.24407508969306946,
-0.18621434271335602,
0.042821258306503296,
-0.9460917711257935,
-0.13020049035549164,
0.5521124601364136,
-0.39485272765159607,
-0.08266333490610123,
0.43352022767066956,
-0.45171043276786804,
-0.09619982540607452,
-0.17732395231723785,
-0.49595630168914795,
0.2291010022163391,
-0.7274318933486938,
0.5390623807907104,
0.40676894783973694,
0.3799310624599457,
0.1801758110523224,
-0.44794562458992004,
0.8941349387168884,
0.36665305495262146,
0.02733059786260128,
-0.6316529512405396,
-0.5185646414756775,
-0.34845656156539917,
-0.5214581489562988,
0.2039472460746765,
0.5354287624359131,
-1.2555549144744873,
0.39590582251548767,
-0.316981703042984,
-0.30250582098960876,
-0.8744848370552063,
-0.4218319356441498,
0.574905514717102,
0.8506466150283813,
0.40564125776290894,
-0.08276386559009552,
-0.38007652759552,
-0.6036697626113892,
0.415975421667099,
-0.01586184650659561,
0.02907436341047287,
0.5376811027526855,
-0.14747028052806854,
-0.35839229822158813,
0.5943041443824768,
-0.8528331518173218,
-0.6413770318031311,
-0.21227329969406128,
-0.018324678763747215,
0.3439944088459015,
0.3428542912006378,
0.608735978603363,
-0.726588785648346,
-0.39256948232650757,
0.24091008305549622,
-0.853907585144043,
-0.14731045067310333,
-0.5047547817230225,
0.08133367449045181,
0.4406838119029999,
0.7016810774803162,
-0.5977715849876404,
0.8803253173828125,
0.5583688020706177,
-0.23400375247001648,
0.528557300567627,
-0.5005466341972351,
0.18256141245365143,
-1.1685802936553955,
0.12241318076848984,
-0.062219664454460144,
-0.346144437789917,
-0.2811305820941925,
-0.03082885779440403,
0.143854558467865,
-0.10007832944393158,
-0.11186731606721878,
0.22741593420505524,
-0.633599042892456,
0.3300345540046692,
-0.3308410346508026,
0.25916799902915955,
0.39234769344329834,
0.022551648318767548,
0.2101392149925232,
0.499920517206192,
0.9856041669845581,
-0.50276118516922,
0.6260760426521301,
0.5227580070495605,
-0.32629022002220154,
0.45758455991744995,
-0.5880534052848816,
0.14736777544021606,
-0.5166480541229248,
0.35379597544670105,
-0.9003603458404541,
-0.1323901116847992,
0.4437243342399597,
-0.4329965114593506,
0.6121045351028442,
-0.24217917025089264,
-0.7926782369613647,
-0.553895890712738,
0.0790502205491066,
0.4417751729488373,
0.6283321976661682,
-0.7028993964195251,
0.17040905356407166,
-0.08980821818113327,
-0.07419785112142563,
-0.259793221950531,
-0.6300680041313171,
0.20643286406993866,
-0.028254490345716476,
-0.5134291052818298,
0.39820632338523865,
-0.12312544882297516,
0.1577776074409485,
-0.044422268867492676,
-0.10721930116415024,
-0.1547892838716507,
0.11544588208198547,
0.22650983929634094,
0.45061779022216797,
-0.11409911513328552,
0.2575606107711792,
0.5318214893341064,
-0.37510553002357483,
0.15209569036960602,
-0.2514283359050751,
0.40310797095298767,
0.3056519627571106,
-0.19422824680805206,
-0.6777470111846924,
0.584276556968689,
0.4934996962547302,
-0.6002099514007568,
0.4594016671180725,
0.24087730050086975,
-0.2930389642715454,
-0.26126235723495483,
0.13026262819766998,
-0.2876577377319336,
-0.49800121784210205,
0.38295748829841614,
-0.2205934077501297,
-0.3909052312374115,
0.37021443247795105,
-0.04075750708580017,
-0.2630631923675537,
0.18912705779075623,
0.5727763175964355,
-0.22569504380226135,
1.6731579303741455,
0.48118311166763306,
0.29498499631881714,
0.020046459510922432,
-0.2152092307806015,
0.5121726393699646,
-0.4594709277153015,
-0.3719784617424011,
-0.18214912712574005,
-0.08323007076978683,
-0.23494082689285278,
-0.28992167115211487,
0.5032230019569397,
-0.20948649942874908,
0.4876268804073334,
-0.08839584141969681,
-0.993466854095459,
0.33449509739875793,
0.29453685879707336,
0.4016365110874176,
0.4706251919269562,
-0.01110241748392582,
-0.29698383808135986,
0.001798560144379735,
-0.8191196322441101,
-0.31249764561653137,
1.055683970451355,
0.1381840854883194,
0.9031490087509155,
-0.2770729959011078,
0.839813768863678,
0.31053248047828674,
0.2567218840122223,
-0.9396616816520691,
0.39593565464019775,
-0.41444823145866394,
-0.26480093598365784,
0.20419928431510925,
-0.4960194528102875,
-1.1260606050491333,
-0.303486168384552,
-0.009971912950277328,
0.017570413649082184,
0.033548418432474136,
0.24483627080917358,
-0.6202670931816101,
0.0014586853794753551,
-0.5644235610961914,
0.5244407653808594,
-0.03762374818325043,
0.283322274684906,
-0.15735070407390594,
-0.8258199691772461,
0.0564427524805069,
-0.1344870924949646,
-0.002969149500131607,
0.2753947377204895,
0.21501357853412628,
0.7174022793769836,
-0.2350948452949524,
0.6878032684326172,
-0.40496140718460083,
-0.11478199809789658,
-0.016401901841163635,
0.17791159451007843,
0.36092713475227356,
0.33940643072128296,
0.19461581110954285,
-0.10472407191991806,
0.3492230772972107,
-0.1366882622241974,
-0.7898512482643127,
0.39379945397377014,
-0.13125112652778625,
-0.485431045293808,
-0.3739737570285797,
-0.7089313268661499,
-0.10841737687587738,
0.4361099600791931,
0.2881850302219391,
0.9299473166465759,
0.15059584379196167,
-0.07522991299629211,
0.574295699596405,
-0.3543197512626648,
0.3645396828651428,
0.6673682332038879,
0.01589743047952652,
-0.2779776155948639,
0.7545769214630127,
-0.22772780060768127,
0.09695163369178772,
0.6116645932197571,
0.12624315917491913,
-0.07547016441822052,
-1.1486774682998657,
-0.49576500058174133,
0.47961580753326416,
-0.8021135330200195,
-0.8178380131721497,
-0.20038655400276184,
-0.08553382754325867,
-0.3229866623878479,
-0.25474613904953003,
-0.10810653120279312,
0.04334122687578201,
-0.6473588943481445,
-0.22666338086128235,
0.4295109510421753,
0.7487993240356445,
0.04594383388757706,
0.24675558507442474,
-1.0695747137069702,
0.4838705360889435,
-0.3079400062561035,
0.5032922029495239,
-0.24943259358406067,
-0.14413900673389435,
-0.4380563199520111,
0.061520740389823914,
-0.06575871258974075,
-0.8754043579101562,
0.6166797876358032,
0.058482710272073746,
0.48710858821868896,
0.6858296990394592,
0.38473108410835266,
0.5056356191635132,
-0.7621133327484131,
0.4912053644657135,
0.2828581929206848,
-0.673555314540863,
0.9136227369308472,
-0.13017216324806213,
0.22517161071300507,
0.1760169267654419,
0.2680155634880066,
-0.28005775809288025,
-0.4448487162590027,
-0.16867150366306305,
-0.37994617223739624,
0.5979893207550049,
-0.033341437578201294,
-0.10187332332134247,
-0.3900715410709381,
0.5359365940093994,
0.0968768373131752,
0.05249370262026787,
-0.12342729419469833,
-0.37690919637680054,
-0.14822320640087128,
-0.7034042477607727,
-0.06991997361183167,
-0.06694064289331436,
-0.4369021952152252,
-0.35555386543273926,
0.17582985758781433,
-0.40458717942237854,
0.5203089714050293,
0.7406584024429321,
-0.06247144192457199,
-0.09465909749269485,
-0.2249130755662918,
0.5873453617095947,
0.33803224563598633,
-0.27074217796325684,
-0.14352576434612274,
-0.6734406352043152,
-0.6002963185310364,
-0.004610217176377773,
0.47297173738479614,
-0.024000301957130432,
0.2571065127849579,
0.2281547337770462,
0.7459607720375061,
-0.29240846633911133,
-0.84600830078125,
0.6604308485984802,
-0.3893333375453949,
-0.5798165798187256,
0.10606352984905243,
-0.16294671595096588,
-0.255046010017395,
0.18810001015663147,
0.21379117667675018,
0.07384850084781647,
0.22363965213298798,
-0.04578934982419014,
0.5227797031402588,
0.2674805521965027,
-0.33301594853401184,
-0.3515763580799103,
0.6799107789993286,
0.29824721813201904,
0.03322160989046097,
0.9219353795051575,
-0.2951829135417938,
-0.23335759341716766,
0.5280205607414246,
0.5786949992179871,
0.7883892059326172,
0.16708295047283173,
0.5458229184150696,
0.13087902963161469,
0.19597144424915314,
0.2823173403739929,
0.40926480293273926,
-0.047678373754024506,
-0.4783381521701813,
-0.6056637167930603,
-0.31896916031837463,
0.04244554042816162,
-0.2093387246131897,
-0.8464204668998718,
0.2728438377380371,
-0.5338454842567444,
0.0413835346698761,
0.1201111227273941,
-0.13059085607528687,
-0.6059722900390625,
0.5587819814682007,
0.4576696455478668,
0.8487054109573364,
-0.37447622418403625,
0.8381897807121277,
0.5674712657928467,
-0.4022116959095001,
-0.6884578466415405,
0.006365833338350058,
-0.08135736733675003,
-1.039438009262085,
0.3902081549167633,
0.2425180822610855,
-0.027014214545488358,
0.3362556993961334,
-0.38608235120773315,
-0.6171275973320007,
1.2715717554092407,
0.2701672613620758,
-0.46274006366729736,
-0.33442115783691406,
0.03971606492996216,
0.5102277994155884,
-0.5886064767837524,
-0.142011359333992,
0.697727620601654,
0.34741684794425964,
0.012266605161130428,
-0.7365514039993286,
0.5223007798194885,
-0.3538426160812378,
-0.33000004291534424,
0.021066267043352127,
-0.1471082866191864,
0.2540942430496216,
-0.5664901733398438,
-0.7336965799331665,
0.3062452971935272,
0.1267337054014206,
-0.011861331760883331,
0.47106996178627014,
0.16730523109436035,
0.48531532287597656,
0.7059764266014099,
-0.19742080569267273,
1.5157949924468994,
-0.3195597231388092,
0.18275919556617737,
0.5419467687606812,
-0.1300891488790512,
0.14547044038772583,
0.3291286528110504,
0.049040693789720535,
0.3651914894580841,
0.549167811870575,
-0.28798550367355347,
1.1753495931625366,
0.26892024278640747,
-0.12632682919502258,
0.005524016451090574,
-0.04651905596256256,
-0.30857643485069275,
0.41210314631462097,
0.3743444085121155,
-0.9618874192237854,
-0.31690919399261475,
0.20269136130809784,
-0.02620571292936802,
0.2186618596315384,
-0.33877211809158325,
0.9736135005950928,
-0.02850634604692459,
-0.37776103615760803,
1.019516944885254,
-0.1192120611667633,
0.29459837079048157,
-0.4157198667526245,
-0.18105876445770264,
-0.2588311731815338,
0.004889755044132471,
-0.34524860978126526,
-0.7794932723045349,
0.36872541904449463,
-0.17050860822200775,
-0.3670597970485687,
-0.20401716232299805,
0.27986031770706177,
-0.2900005578994751,
-0.476927787065506,
0.0905279591679573,
0.3344646692276001,
0.10130727291107178,
0.004945667926222086,
-0.44053375720977783,
0.07285071164369583,
0.16341236233711243,
0.16289381682872772,
-0.09155276417732239,
0.25428223609924316,
0.25241366028785706,
0.5623859763145447,
0.38422784209251404,
0.15882691740989685,
0.0002904561988543719,
0.4271979331970215,
1.0134598016738892,
-0.5033397078514099,
-0.47085124254226685,
-0.5262269973754883,
0.437921404838562,
0.13485853374004364,
-0.013929661363363266,
0.3587101101875305,
0.33654579520225525,
0.4155154824256897,
-0.19742247462272644,
0.7668009400367737,
0.078758105635643,
0.46408554911613464,
-0.746947169303894,
1.0160824060440063,
-0.5954568982124329,
0.1189538985490799,
-0.063172347843647,
-0.4065466523170471,
-0.8893643021583557,
0.39211463928222656,
0.07077087461948395,
-0.3722415268421173,
0.9414613246917725,
0.8765101432800293,
0.30365535616874695,
-0.18660904467105865,
0.37565094232559204,
0.014452790841460228,
0.5267212390899658,
0.5167547464370728,
0.34557977318763733,
-0.2678098678588867,
0.6982380747795105,
-0.26114392280578613,
-0.45154958963394165,
0.04340897500514984,
-0.6626017093658447,
-0.9712138772010803,
-0.4725291132926941,
-0.6947222352027893,
-0.3523906469345093,
-0.0006989254616200924,
0.2685665190219879,
0.7594103217124939,
-0.45131048560142517,
0.42613327503204346,
-0.27984094619750977,
-0.03297393396496773,
-0.46678751707077026,
-0.18578337132930756,
0.5855537056922913,
-0.3078842759132385,
-0.6218050718307495,
0.629081666469574,
0.3165796995162964,
0.1223987266421318,
-0.0781315341591835,
-0.11042316257953644,
0.40688377618789673,
-0.01878857985138893,
0.41119131445884705,
-0.10372704267501831,
-0.38855433464050293,
0.13182513415813446,
0.1462414562702179,
-0.10350024700164795,
0.370089054107666,
0.7259176969528198,
-0.9090386629104614,
0.9583787322044373,
0.13812214136123657,
0.6587408185005188,
0.30498817563056946,
-0.05140892416238785,
0.6105979681015015,
-0.827711820602417,
-0.021744312718510628,
0.5343155860900879,
0.1654493808746338,
0.3693172037601471,
-0.5929627418518066,
0.13747599720954895,
0.36122840642929077,
-0.2516695559024811,
-0.8584449887275696,
0.20851847529411316,
-1.115721583366394,
-0.0799129456281662,
0.9174813032150269,
-0.19624125957489014,
-0.08917649835348129,
0.13895417749881744,
-0.35332220792770386,
0.2955734431743622,
-0.19599498808383942,
0.7440015077590942,
0.09749524295330048,
-0.05800647661089897,
-0.22555451095104218,
-0.09202442318201065,
0.6710566282272339,
0.16735902428627014,
-0.6497833728790283,
0.02866949513554573,
0.564895749092102,
0.09201928228139877,
0.040402017533779144,
0.4536074697971344,
-0.5032802224159241,
0.7108617424964905,
-0.12785838544368744,
-0.1901988387107849,
-0.4200439453125,
-0.1990356594324112,
-0.535351574420929,
-0.16021887958049774,
-0.2709161043167114,
-0.6457690596580505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14162v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14162v1 | DIRAS: Efficient LLM-Assisted Annotation of Document Relevance in Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2024-06-20T10:04:09 | 2024-06-20T10:04:09 | Jingwei Ni, Tobias Schimanski, Meihong Lin, Mrinmaya Sachan, Elliott Ash, Markus Leippold | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) is widely employed to ground responses
to queries on domain-specific documents. But do RAG implementations leave out
important information or excessively include irrelevant information? To allay
these concerns, it is necessary to annotate domain-specific benchmarks to
evaluate information retrieval (IR) performance, as relevance definitions vary
across queries and domains. Furthermore, such benchmarks should be
cost-efficiently annotated to avoid annotation selection bias. In this paper,
we propose DIRAS (Domain-specific Information Retrieval Annotation with
Scalability), a manual-annotation-free schema that fine-tunes open-sourced LLMs
to annotate relevance labels with calibrated relevance probabilities. Extensive
evaluation shows that DIRAS fine-tuned models achieve GPT-4-level performance
on annotating and ranking unseen (query, document) pairs, and is helpful for
real-world RAG development. | [
-0.6018496155738831,
-0.4941905438899994,
0.5158225297927856,
0.026219692081212997,
-0.47247520089149475,
-0.029863478615880013,
0.020001867786049843,
-0.41167736053466797,
0.44050297141075134,
0.5417014956474304,
-0.34545496106147766,
-0.33403337001800537,
-0.5487406849861145,
0.0960378497838974,
-0.29625967144966125,
1.0488585233688354,
0.09108459949493408,
-0.12297819554805756,
-0.3038502633571625,
-0.5083097815513611,
-0.31403639912605286,
-0.5900076627731323,
-0.46492788195610046,
-0.13503865897655487,
0.7649989128112793,
0.3845010995864868,
0.6229784488677979,
0.8128120303153992,
0.9286254048347473,
0.07237450778484344,
-0.2759948968887329,
0.6149249076843262,
-0.5015040040016174,
0.44801750779151917,
-0.31043940782546997,
-0.2718237638473511,
-0.7327718734741211,
0.2642173767089844,
0.8076164722442627,
0.6479042768478394,
0.1912039965391159,
0.4738459587097168,
-0.013078279793262482,
0.7946873903274536,
-0.7147837281227112,
-0.034754253923892975,
-0.8518221974372864,
-0.2712572515010834,
-0.530716061592102,
-0.7823976874351501,
-0.36080190539360046,
-0.38690465688705444,
-0.08343921601772308,
-0.9326274991035461,
0.4167608320713043,
0.41013336181640625,
0.8835774660110474,
0.3917871415615082,
-0.2612704336643219,
-0.3024667501449585,
-0.48788392543792725,
0.5031559467315674,
-0.17098750174045563,
0.44131237268447876,
0.6285273432731628,
0.4912671446800232,
-0.07244017720222473,
-0.701604425907135,
-0.46293991804122925,
-0.11464283615350723,
-0.16029570996761322,
-0.18272405862808228,
0.20568792521953583,
-0.01616279035806656,
0.48814335465431213,
0.549172580242157,
-0.21841436624526978,
-0.09390943497419357,
-0.1857266128063202,
-0.0890037789940834,
0.3508126437664032,
-0.08240769803524017,
-0.0629834309220314,
-0.06114795058965683,
-0.2936759293079376,
-0.07418537884950638,
-1.0165557861328125,
-0.31312140822410583,
0.3704805076122284,
0.5659733414649963,
0.2661949098110199,
0.7513133883476257,
-0.22738121449947357,
0.6458747386932373,
0.154955193400383,
-0.04684951528906822,
0.27676451206207275,
-0.2556905746459961,
-0.009072228334844112,
-0.34215936064720154,
0.3149403929710388,
0.1054384633898735,
-0.033460650593042374,
-0.5957752466201782,
-0.43847498297691345,
-0.2373434454202652,
0.4569242596626282,
-0.8678639531135559,
0.07359350472688675,
0.07940981537103653,
-0.21827486157417297,
-0.19445036351680756,
-0.1797802597284317,
-0.6844327449798584,
-0.533955991268158,
-0.29717782139778137,
0.6242308020591736,
-0.2719476819038391,
0.14241217076778412,
-0.5873411893844604,
-0.17879855632781982,
-0.0330967977643013,
0.554305911064148,
-0.6858144402503967,
0.21743133664131165,
0.7068125605583191,
0.7850277423858643,
-0.11393588781356812,
0.03274919465184212,
-0.9952666163444519,
0.32928231358528137,
-0.6007033586502075,
0.9819711446762085,
-0.6167186498641968,
-0.38103562593460083,
-0.029945073649287224,
-0.23246362805366516,
0.21311381459236145,
-0.5578258633613586,
0.9425576329231262,
-1.033726453781128,
-0.15832598507404327,
-0.42498543858528137,
-0.5793201923370361,
-0.09887738525867462,
0.15593256056308746,
-0.7866408228874207,
1.0492565631866455,
0.3606889247894287,
-0.9357396960258484,
0.6534804105758667,
-0.4623573422431946,
-0.326558917760849,
0.3724987506866455,
-0.24764059484004974,
-0.19114018976688385,
-0.03368818387389183,
0.15478672087192535,
0.3986840844154358,
-0.6546109318733215,
0.2974090278148651,
-0.014400693587958813,
-0.49061739444732666,
0.0407383069396019,
-0.04598622769117355,
0.16351300477981567,
0.4107721149921417,
-0.11246800422668457,
0.029846278950572014,
-0.7761353254318237,
-0.086972177028656,
-0.03682464361190796,
-0.3341655731201172,
-0.4844253361225128,
-0.1618497222661972,
-0.09577836096286774,
-0.04691458120942116,
0.3708561360836029,
-0.30285269021987915,
0.27867475152015686,
-0.18059462308883667,
-0.27317914366722107,
0.6028419733047485,
0.21629758179187775,
0.6122112274169922,
-0.5266847014427185,
0.47366103529930115,
-0.19548723101615906,
-0.07265156507492065,
-0.15238092839717865,
-0.5101534724235535,
-0.7605927586555481,
-0.6792101263999939,
0.5315423607826233,
0.16269893944263458,
-0.7611098885536194,
0.15928788483142853,
-0.433941513299942,
-0.6089041829109192,
-0.4187845289707184,
0.19193391501903534,
0.3341710567474365,
0.6841046214103699,
0.44462278485298157,
-0.2816760241985321,
-0.42320698499679565,
-0.9471254348754883,
-0.3373320698738098,
0.06244741007685661,
-0.0836881697177887,
0.6377981901168823,
0.16452577710151672,
-0.3415689170360565,
0.8708981275558472,
-0.4077908992767334,
-0.647365927696228,
0.05208005756139755,
0.29594653844833374,
0.15156704187393188,
0.1585405319929123,
0.5822064280509949,
-0.9452500939369202,
-0.28022363781929016,
-0.06629321724176407,
-0.5023974180221558,
-0.4661983549594879,
0.05131280794739723,
-0.2349863052368164,
0.17440655827522278,
0.1021641418337822,
-0.563862144947052,
0.3567470908164978,
0.08003847301006317,
-0.04538453370332718,
0.13219845294952393,
-0.3875674307346344,
0.44553226232528687,
-0.8709396123886108,
0.47025206685066223,
0.12138181179761887,
-0.12246222048997879,
-0.40992501378059387,
0.24731123447418213,
0.3818763792514801,
-0.02196107804775238,
0.022075284272432327,
0.8099340200424194,
-0.43954959511756897,
-0.36144447326660156,
-0.3029354214668274,
0.6291914582252502,
0.008498456329107285,
0.1651427149772644,
-0.15585680305957794,
1.3185917139053345,
0.28860077261924744,
-0.753220796585083,
-0.22903718054294586,
0.15099477767944336,
0.18659386038780212,
0.554149329662323,
-0.1656723916530609,
0.1988683044910431,
-0.030662748962640762,
0.22102250158786774,
-0.6606664061546326,
-0.211965411901474,
0.12610286474227905,
-0.2695016860961914,
0.5015483498573303,
-0.33172503113746643,
-0.7463380098342896,
-0.00526716373860836,
-0.48248839378356934,
0.3360351026058197,
0.2527591586112976,
-0.7836088538169861,
0.6094921827316284,
0.7755285501480103,
-0.04089737311005592,
-0.7052534818649292,
-0.16473841667175293,
0.12230104207992554,
-0.2636096477508545,
-0.2984994649887085,
0.40237173438072205,
-0.09116151928901672,
-0.2220137119293213,
-0.22539140284061432,
-0.24203011393547058,
-0.19482342898845673,
0.19737382233142853,
0.46500733494758606,
0.11075925081968307,
0.02488056756556034,
0.2479061782360077,
0.20211438834667206,
-0.14934547245502472,
-0.38709792494773865,
-0.08881740272045135,
0.22351765632629395,
-0.04229027032852173,
-0.21023203432559967,
0.0220778938382864,
0.14660322666168213,
0.26825571060180664,
-0.31545695662498474,
0.4128456711769104,
0.4056478440761566,
-0.4149033725261688,
-0.2458028346300125,
-0.7474119067192078,
0.020362485200166702,
-0.4141467213630676,
-0.15463872253894806,
-0.6390583515167236,
-0.9509139060974121,
0.5461925864219666,
-0.21993130445480347,
0.12406840920448303,
0.8444987535476685,
0.2973911166191101,
0.0690208151936531,
0.5326239466667175,
0.5799928307533264,
0.14267168939113617,
0.3320990800857544,
-0.23464854061603546,
0.1911819726228714,
-1.2036939859390259,
-0.10043451189994812,
-0.8406445384025574,
-0.05344166234135628,
-0.5640138387680054,
-0.8915058374404907,
0.32440894842147827,
0.2892383635044098,
-0.17230071127414703,
0.291862428188324,
-0.6797868013381958,
0.30303385853767395,
0.593561589717865,
-0.26089608669281006,
0.35777372121810913,
0.1323336809873581,
-0.14590993523597717,
-0.11872629821300507,
-0.4993678331375122,
-0.6872503161430359,
1.3440114259719849,
0.08441434055566788,
0.6199057698249817,
0.23775315284729004,
0.8007020950317383,
0.5748864412307739,
0.6447174549102783,
-0.401496022939682,
0.642973005771637,
-0.034537967294454575,
-0.5545507073402405,
-0.1528960019350052,
-0.4471905827522278,
-0.7909061908721924,
0.38380151987075806,
-0.20003734529018402,
-0.6541033983230591,
0.2321176677942276,
0.006228841375559568,
-0.26309680938720703,
0.13781554996967316,
-0.38525474071502686,
0.20802317559719086,
0.09643751382827759,
-0.49012666940689087,
-0.2384646236896515,
-0.44171783328056335,
-0.04385419934988022,
-0.5923485159873962,
0.2393132597208023,
-0.24382305145263672,
-0.32454824447631836,
0.8111221194267273,
-0.16158811748027802,
0.3678588569164276,
-0.12354618310928345,
-0.041846565902233124,
0.40576300024986267,
0.34354206919670105,
0.5424777269363403,
0.18548019230365753,
-0.25698477029800415,
0.20268107950687408,
-0.16028204560279846,
-0.0604647696018219,
-0.36758509278297424,
0.9039080739021301,
-0.40616267919540405,
-0.7289026975631714,
-0.6084457039833069,
-0.7357586622238159,
-0.33048319816589355,
0.35443171858787537,
-0.088969387114048,
0.2849156856536865,
0.22481144964694977,
0.06769771128892899,
0.7424826622009277,
0.12607453763484955,
0.05552283674478531,
0.4709879457950592,
-0.17031854391098022,
-0.47366273403167725,
0.9234516024589539,
0.5032774806022644,
-0.2545401155948639,
0.4270419478416443,
-0.05249675363302231,
-0.2406308501958847,
-0.49854257702827454,
-0.5735323429107666,
0.28652632236480713,
-0.9325118660926819,
-0.5747935771942139,
-0.8090834617614746,
-0.05377292260527611,
-0.3413296341896057,
-0.30809226632118225,
-0.08712172508239746,
-0.873644232749939,
-0.4270625710487366,
-0.10458164662122726,
0.5658342838287354,
0.6885783672332764,
-0.1699308305978775,
-0.05195744335651398,
-0.5335230231285095,
0.6837595105171204,
0.11320198327302933,
0.6186490058898926,
-0.15365126729011536,
-0.6984879970550537,
-0.26556047797203064,
-0.17045769095420837,
-0.28731340169906616,
-0.570688009262085,
0.11269985139369965,
0.19884340465068817,
0.6828233599662781,
-0.04890129342675209,
0.13007770478725433,
0.4818374514579773,
-0.4781283140182495,
0.7092424631118774,
-0.3738614618778229,
-0.59345942735672,
0.6774207949638367,
-0.4844893217086792,
-0.19474439322948456,
0.6352185606956482,
0.3796144127845764,
0.02387840673327446,
-0.25544795393943787,
-0.6013467311859131,
-1.0891869068145752,
0.6776997447013855,
0.13143184781074524,
-0.023058950901031494,
-0.29342177510261536,
0.7890061736106873,
0.28257301449775696,
0.09392570704221725,
-0.3579599857330322,
-0.40150150656700134,
0.3018879294395447,
0.06790681183338165,
0.09575755894184113,
-0.674922525882721,
-0.2800940275192261,
0.012801027856767178,
1.0182275772094727,
-0.2385595589876175,
0.06072178855538368,
0.3260883688926697,
-0.1071757972240448,
-0.3763539493083954,
0.07890236377716064,
0.44787681102752686,
0.7709978818893433,
-0.4755983054637909,
0.07593324780464172,
0.1577785462141037,
-0.41985929012298584,
0.16396395862102509,
0.3379524350166321,
-0.45699334144592285,
0.1135394424200058,
0.025379393249750137,
0.4433114528656006,
0.06481818854808807,
-0.5736244320869446,
0.36684224009513855,
-0.10324792563915253,
0.17934109270572662,
-0.1076943501830101,
0.07344696670770645,
-0.23943299055099487,
0.30172237753868103,
0.8036686182022095,
-0.12125377357006073,
0.30756956338882446,
-0.1020049899816513,
0.38991355895996094,
0.5411290526390076,
-0.19565750658512115,
0.08067047595977783,
0.9875707030296326,
0.15896594524383545,
-0.29374194145202637,
0.07337722182273865,
-0.22961530089378357,
-0.1648547351360321,
0.2868405282497406,
0.2728263735771179,
0.8916153907775879,
0.12568998336791992,
-0.058258261531591415,
0.4030821919441223,
0.2568913996219635,
0.0710386112332344,
0.08004454523324966,
-0.443200945854187,
-0.15655545890331268,
-0.056274499744176865,
-0.8182276487350464,
-0.7138523459434509,
-0.23792782425880432,
-0.5123311281204224,
0.15400800108909607,
-0.34819719195365906,
-0.37778210639953613,
0.2210373878479004,
0.3369887173175812,
-0.7027572393417358,
0.4299687445163727,
-0.1737859696149826,
1.0000799894332886,
-0.3139815926551819,
0.812227189540863,
0.6514961123466492,
-0.7457571029663086,
-0.46210840344429016,
0.13199789822101593,
-0.39897090196609497,
-0.5290793180465698,
1.1024633646011353,
0.04015665873885155,
-0.3147011697292328,
0.008952073752880096,
-0.0838758796453476,
-1.0266588926315308,
1.3384325504302979,
0.37645745277404785,
-0.19846904277801514,
0.23607788980007172,
0.024114061146974564,
0.5829291343688965,
-0.367384672164917,
0.4049025774002075,
0.19650162756443024,
0.26864972710609436,
0.009636253118515015,
-0.811078667640686,
0.12097364664077759,
-0.1611689031124115,
0.17774516344070435,
0.18009330332279205,
-0.5599220991134644,
0.6951791048049927,
-0.0846252515912056,
-0.2141789346933365,
0.2092037945985794,
0.6291173696517944,
0.22960922122001648,
0.37404146790504456,
0.23542767763137817,
0.6410694122314453,
0.8531869053840637,
-0.10822887718677521,
1.1462523937225342,
-0.5644953846931458,
0.29813578724861145,
1.0484445095062256,
-0.3610023260116577,
0.7866793870925903,
0.4896639585494995,
0.01352143194526434,
0.0000951318143052049,
0.528007984161377,
0.3765111565589905,
0.5516163110733032,
0.2244560718536377,
-0.365168958902359,
-0.11741267144680023,
-0.35911110043525696,
-0.5110582709312439,
-0.047243885695934296,
0.4184599816799164,
-0.3887946903705597,
-0.27786436676979065,
-0.47580665349960327,
-0.08132964372634888,
0.031608667224645615,
-0.1948157697916031,
0.786466658115387,
-0.017408836632966995,
-0.6265844702720642,
0.5854036808013916,
0.09491407126188278,
0.44939321279525757,
-0.4819612205028534,
-0.2121770977973938,
-0.5698624849319458,
-0.10177116841077805,
-0.058356259018182755,
-0.6652442812919617,
0.07999216020107269,
0.1388739049434662,
-0.23613502085208893,
0.02585682086646557,
0.9047324061393738,
-0.06878098100423813,
-0.28717339038848877,
0.24342691898345947,
0.4029393792152405,
0.21266068518161774,
-0.1011059358716011,
-0.19736933708190918,
0.0593368262052536,
-0.307868629693985,
-0.42552119493484497,
0.6405851244926453,
0.6850184202194214,
-0.32767659425735474,
0.7483534216880798,
0.6895053386688232,
0.1749260127544403,
-0.04550042375922203,
0.18671907484531403,
1.040789008140564,
-0.5355657935142517,
-0.19678649306297302,
-0.2721223831176758,
0.02391616441309452,
-0.178689107298851,
-0.2049623280763626,
0.7748596668243408,
0.5910220146179199,
0.6137011051177979,
0.20786409080028534,
0.6221956610679626,
0.02092687413096428,
0.8879977464675903,
-0.2380925714969635,
0.8226999044418335,
-0.6842291951179504,
0.5211138129234314,
-0.2171768993139267,
-1.216761589050293,
-0.6022695899009705,
0.5657383799552917,
-0.2593630850315094,
0.1368640661239624,
0.2779944837093353,
0.75552898645401,
0.03945743665099144,
-0.24163997173309326,
0.3645035922527313,
-0.1440444439649582,
0.2624375820159912,
-0.11347468942403793,
0.3638656735420227,
-0.49665960669517517,
0.14318904280662537,
-0.40156328678131104,
-0.1759745478630066,
-0.4354739189147949,
-0.847893238067627,
-0.6623564958572388,
-0.7089517116546631,
-0.22293220460414886,
-0.2754043638706207,
0.23133371770381927,
0.7156471014022827,
0.4942101240158081,
-0.558228075504303,
0.09392239898443222,
0.39314165711402893,
0.013401489704847336,
0.11750392615795135,
-0.1810844987630844,
0.616804301738739,
-0.7205449342727661,
-0.4937395751476288,
0.3935801088809967,
0.4246504604816437,
-0.12482757866382599,
-0.08362134546041489,
0.05903838947415352,
-0.3202148973941803,
0.2864064872264862,
0.3778594732284546,
0.17576181888580322,
-0.6503518223762512,
-0.4353134036064148,
-0.3195702135562897,
-0.2951720654964447,
0.11391142755746841,
0.700125515460968,
-0.9285632967948914,
0.5392900705337524,
0.2938539981842041,
0.9439101219177246,
0.42554977536201477,
0.2147219479084015,
0.14842550456523895,
-0.9570578932762146,
0.20085473358631134,
0.34693750739097595,
0.29498329758644104,
0.5227629542350769,
-0.5303835272789001,
1.1242140531539917,
0.11035286635160446,
-0.7199122905731201,
-0.9600524306297302,
-0.14171233773231506,
-0.9337890148162842,
0.1160803884267807,
1.2402526140213013,
-0.06505473703145981,
0.011529050767421722,
0.1721726506948471,
-0.3390067517757416,
0.28872036933898926,
-0.26053887605667114,
0.7308226227760315,
0.28763535618782043,
-0.01701623573899269,
0.09351442009210587,
-0.7186817526817322,
0.6497811079025269,
0.36404281854629517,
-0.6171525120735168,
0.15510517358779907,
0.7225679755210876,
-0.0235641710460186,
0.3773248791694641,
0.8590602278709412,
0.008967983536422253,
0.25397372245788574,
-0.027711594477295876,
0.019941000267863274,
-0.01308395154774189,
-0.39556244015693665,
-0.11316411942243576,
0.2623656690120697,
0.5989303588867188,
-0.024061117321252823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14155v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14155v1 | Aligning Large Language Models with Diverse Political Viewpoints | 2024-06-20T09:53:23 | 2024-06-20T09:53:23 | Dominik Stammbach, Philine Widmer, Eunjung Cho, Caglar Gulcehre, Elliott Ash | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models such as ChatGPT often exhibit striking political
biases. If users query them about political information, they might take a
normative stance and reinforce such biases. To overcome this, we align LLMs
with diverse political viewpoints from 100,000 comments written by candidates
running for national parliament in Switzerland. Such aligned models are able to
generate more accurate political viewpoints from Swiss parties compared to
commercial models such as ChatGPT. We also propose a procedure to generate
balanced overviews from multiple viewpoints using such models. | [
-0.5047849416732788,
-0.4006487727165222,
0.6407291889190674,
0.027828393504023552,
-0.4891408085823059,
0.14851228892803192,
-0.3660449683666229,
-0.19103412330150604,
0.29439109563827515,
0.8539130687713623,
-0.6578547954559326,
-0.2953486442565918,
-0.6786345839500427,
-0.15717926621437073,
-0.25184932351112366,
1.0488359928131104,
0.303647518157959,
0.25263863801956177,
-0.05743982270359993,
-0.23598717153072357,
-0.1357807070016861,
-0.6129071712493896,
-0.35403499007225037,
-0.7528107166290283,
0.48007240891456604,
0.36204802989959717,
0.8769789934158325,
0.35089531540870667,
0.44576558470726013,
0.2723141014575958,
-0.07468726485967636,
0.15710347890853882,
-0.5601657032966614,
0.0790633112192154,
-0.6652640700340271,
-0.34304314851760864,
-0.2313905656337738,
-0.02020389959216118,
0.7947319746017456,
0.4985593557357788,
-0.24502260982990265,
-0.1713421493768692,
0.09016168117523193,
0.86766517162323,
-0.5362212657928467,
0.06887643039226532,
-0.7081835269927979,
-0.18090270459651947,
-0.2427852898836136,
0.031023113057017326,
-0.39484483003616333,
-0.6195840239524841,
0.3171282708644867,
-0.11423692852258682,
-0.10375072807073593,
0.002159708645194769,
0.8612636923789978,
-0.030124763026833534,
-0.7474249005317688,
-0.1599690467119217,
-0.565462052822113,
0.8286696076393127,
-0.9456140398979187,
0.2506921589374542,
-0.08995208144187927,
0.3391057848930359,
-0.20581331849098206,
-0.11558879166841507,
-0.5535279512405396,
0.1299048662185669,
0.04105658084154129,
0.24679678678512573,
-0.0399249903857708,
0.0002860297681763768,
0.16726160049438477,
0.23942135274410248,
-0.3993758261203766,
0.2784741520881653,
-0.1281978189945221,
-0.06919880956411362,
0.708179235458374,
0.16185712814331055,
0.1300991326570511,
-0.5358632802963257,
-0.5510379076004028,
0.10517045110464096,
-0.8322385549545288,
-0.2022259384393692,
0.9731581807136536,
0.6292465925216675,
-0.21702250838279724,
0.9324604272842407,
-0.2835046947002411,
0.9859736561775208,
0.45457032322883606,
0.10241958498954773,
0.062073007225990295,
-0.31659117341041565,
-0.19545753300189972,
0.11984767764806747,
1.0150076150894165,
0.6573676466941833,
0.3325822949409485,
0.343832790851593,
-0.20846429467201233,
0.010709038004279137,
0.08418527245521545,
-0.8411818146705627,
0.004140234552323818,
0.2692338824272156,
-0.3868621289730072,
-0.3935012221336365,
0.24776093661785126,
-0.9353505969047546,
-0.9828842282295227,
-0.4718237519264221,
0.023489363491535187,
-0.2122812569141388,
-0.5465508699417114,
0.26863062381744385,
-0.04263216257095337,
0.4584634602069855,
0.5889815092086792,
-0.9823440909385681,
0.11343555152416229,
0.8943417072296143,
0.6463802456855774,
-0.2028406262397766,
0.13997888565063477,
-0.40827664732933044,
0.15638147294521332,
-0.24500800669193268,
0.9871322512626648,
-0.8190885186195374,
-0.07010219991207123,
0.17990298569202423,
-0.0601748451590538,
0.05297672003507614,
-0.5260930061340332,
0.4384087920188904,
-0.6466522812843323,
0.6132628917694092,
-0.639263391494751,
-0.6702802181243896,
-0.10629852861166,
0.5061365962028503,
-0.7489896416664124,
0.7657119035720825,
-0.02202487178146839,
-1.1741020679473877,
0.294292151927948,
-0.6485689878463745,
-0.0965745821595192,
-0.1881914585828781,
-0.3950759768486023,
-0.17053881287574768,
0.18055246770381927,
0.2774781286716461,
0.49881547689437866,
-0.2607731223106384,
0.6457102298736572,
-0.3492342233657837,
0.15677474439144135,
0.3996502757072449,
-0.18928048014640808,
0.9858991503715515,
0.21896862983703613,
-0.2464962899684906,
0.5316138863563538,
-0.6510878205299377,
-0.19200211763381958,
-0.3004709482192993,
-0.43310052156448364,
-0.2598657011985779,
0.4448227882385254,
0.2817850112915039,
0.4887266457080841,
0.35314658284187317,
-0.5595568418502808,
0.3686792552471161,
-0.5981262922286987,
0.5902459621429443,
0.9631864428520203,
-0.12477857619524002,
0.5528331995010376,
-0.3991797864437103,
0.40298330783843994,
0.23359212279319763,
-0.24331480264663696,
0.13381105661392212,
-0.3108883798122406,
-0.5644999146461487,
-0.12930789589881897,
0.35560134053230286,
0.8774599432945251,
-0.2805439829826355,
0.5492009520530701,
-0.42167598009109497,
-0.3928273618221283,
-0.3190641403198242,
0.031276777386665344,
-0.00003697573993122205,
0.21890710294246674,
-0.24113382399082184,
-0.22743107378482819,
-0.6466527581214905,
-1.331865906715393,
-0.49743959307670593,
-0.3975546658039093,
-0.16417650878429413,
0.3954191505908966,
0.574716329574585,
-0.14884789288043976,
0.90819251537323,
-0.12835979461669922,
0.07453884184360504,
-0.16619372367858887,
0.002741666743531823,
0.2933400869369507,
0.2810252904891968,
0.32888373732566833,
-0.726676881313324,
-0.585586428642273,
0.45945993065834045,
-0.3570612072944641,
-0.19801245629787445,
-0.020104102790355682,
-0.32210221886634827,
0.11302219331264496,
0.13704898953437805,
-0.475652813911438,
-0.14553265273571014,
0.7461539506912231,
-0.23982669413089752,
0.2669156789779663,
0.29714733362197876,
0.30618780851364136,
-1.5584075450897217,
-0.2513141930103302,
0.21237680315971375,
-0.5524899363517761,
-0.43223026394844055,
-0.12080181390047073,
-0.009191786870360374,
0.007100633345544338,
-0.5492327809333801,
0.5084481835365295,
-0.39293041825294495,
0.11606054753065109,
-0.20762696862220764,
0.5221998691558838,
-0.1259961575269699,
-0.10914703458547592,
0.24442608654499054,
0.5582194924354553,
0.4531177282333374,
-0.0021960490848869085,
0.48967722058296204,
0.04648967459797859,
-0.7283408045768738,
0.7537124156951904,
-0.41423192620277405,
0.14836376905441284,
-0.17220832407474518,
0.2368454784154892,
-1.219336986541748,
-0.6265501379966736,
0.024084242060780525,
-0.09879465401172638,
0.35136812925338745,
-0.2519889771938324,
-0.37527602910995483,
-0.02050602436065674,
-0.20453307032585144,
-0.03451140597462654,
0.37681519985198975,
-0.4722491204738617,
0.6933221817016602,
0.7265890836715698,
-0.26687008142471313,
-0.7943742275238037,
-0.48392918705940247,
0.20818635821342468,
-0.3484220504760742,
-0.7714781165122986,
0.12135536968708038,
0.23841890692710876,
-0.624770998954773,
0.050290871411561966,
0.029456453397870064,
0.04937608167529106,
-0.44192323088645935,
0.012659633532166481,
0.22874076664447784,
-0.33390727639198303,
-0.06570465862751007,
-0.25579819083213806,
0.2708896994590759,
-0.1939667910337448,
-0.2366442233324051,
0.7613070607185364,
-0.30020949244499207,
-0.4965144395828247,
-0.4982947111129761,
0.5799137353897095,
0.7210740447044373,
-0.14710098505020142,
0.7080109119415283,
0.054179590195417404,
-0.25681349635124207,
0.0511079765856266,
-0.9591878652572632,
0.010860711336135864,
-0.4368739128112793,
0.4114043116569519,
0.042513664811849594,
-1.2187769412994385,
0.8583688735961914,
-0.11944856494665146,
0.3387555480003357,
0.5661459565162659,
0.9367601871490479,
0.07771797478199005,
1.1076523065567017,
0.6998286843299866,
-0.42090460658073425,
0.5595022439956665,
0.3275119662284851,
0.4248254597187042,
-0.5728970170021057,
-0.2620179355144501,
-0.6606448888778687,
-0.2484201043844223,
-0.8255360722541809,
-0.3483153283596039,
-0.1244557648897171,
-0.20035934448242188,
-0.5188507437705994,
0.04484518989920616,
-0.6521304845809937,
0.4336685836315155,
0.3043135404586792,
0.05822514370083809,
-0.040461476892232895,
0.1687983125448227,
-0.04813718795776367,
-0.28073081374168396,
-0.6245545744895935,
-0.9022263288497925,
0.8396711349487305,
0.18065597116947174,
1.1993470191955566,
0.17942054569721222,
0.7218008041381836,
-0.06683588027954102,
0.5565410256385803,
-0.6562076210975647,
0.33690521121025085,
-0.15742090344429016,
-0.9087023138999939,
-0.13597966730594635,
-0.37506845593452454,
-0.3414556086063385,
0.3408847153186798,
-0.1760522872209549,
-0.7867059707641602,
0.28270211815834045,
0.015441184863448143,
-0.31652864813804626,
0.6397004723548889,
-0.581457793712616,
0.7770986557006836,
-0.35894712805747986,
-0.48801228404045105,
-0.18414926528930664,
-0.6962661743164062,
0.6072242856025696,
-0.06408487260341644,
0.32851582765579224,
-0.3257891535758972,
-0.22317752242088318,
0.6410490274429321,
-0.21110206842422485,
1.1186991930007935,
-0.1039903461933136,
-0.28603678941726685,
0.13509324193000793,
-0.3072007894515991,
0.3728496730327606,
-0.10884611308574677,
-0.5006090998649597,
0.16783259809017181,
-0.1505807340145111,
-0.26074209809303284,
-0.30769509077072144,
0.8911199569702148,
-0.8771643042564392,
-1.0336703062057495,
-0.547935426235199,
-0.642157793045044,
-0.031397558748722076,
0.19646351039409637,
0.2175275832414627,
0.041904471814632416,
-0.5620476007461548,
0.3060496151447296,
0.5537175536155701,
-0.09241367131471634,
0.08642077445983887,
0.3244548738002777,
-0.29582855105400085,
-0.5351540446281433,
0.3987048268318176,
0.11527253687381744,
0.5375892519950867,
0.295678049325943,
0.21614161133766174,
-0.44762033224105835,
-0.30624088644981384,
-0.34359171986579895,
0.23340892791748047,
-0.6365317106246948,
-0.22044454514980316,
-0.4013085663318634,
-0.27640649676322937,
-0.17502658069133759,
-0.2825061082839966,
-0.43540602922439575,
-0.6133888959884644,
-0.007078364957123995,
0.012824910692870617,
0.2852024435997009,
0.8312052488327026,
-0.013849419541656971,
0.6991392374038696,
-0.33476516604423523,
0.11417832225561142,
0.27340471744537354,
0.4256022870540619,
-0.47021523118019104,
-0.5140082836151123,
0.08141563832759857,
0.24274197220802307,
-0.4338129162788391,
-1.0770838260650635,
0.05393237993121147,
0.06014174222946167,
0.4979878067970276,
0.7750721573829651,
0.02758701518177986,
0.675595223903656,
-0.7747594714164734,
1.1038539409637451,
0.47384464740753174,
-0.8070732355117798,
0.7307282090187073,
-0.5926262140274048,
0.18874630331993103,
0.5127283930778503,
0.3214455842971802,
-0.43196719884872437,
-0.679611325263977,
-0.5166770815849304,
-0.6936168670654297,
0.6714348196983337,
-0.04854224622249603,
0.47873836755752563,
-0.15619251132011414,
0.21140071749687195,
0.08318685740232468,
0.2311931550502777,
-0.9358499646186829,
0.08828679472208023,
-0.26552507281303406,
-0.19031848013401031,
0.14417819678783417,
-0.4381007254123688,
-0.7102116942405701,
-0.13171713054180145,
0.9019293189048767,
-0.11753444373607635,
-0.09097988903522491,
-0.12446364015340805,
0.38214588165283203,
-0.18148797750473022,
0.5018703937530518,
0.6618095636367798,
1.062060832977295,
-0.03278019279241562,
0.17911505699157715,
-0.15761680901050568,
0.04995739832520485,
0.1720069795846939,
-0.04083582013845444,
-0.13285216689109802,
0.078658327460289,
0.2618160843849182,
0.764062225818634,
0.010529757477343082,
-0.4552541673183441,
0.5051484704017639,
0.027540167793631554,
-0.32611140608787537,
-0.16098204255104065,
0.12605835497379303,
0.7595075964927673,
0.39701563119888306,
0.004100196063518524,
0.20042569935321808,
-0.3345259726047516,
-0.8174728155136108,
0.09538515657186508,
1.0449882745742798,
-0.3919573426246643,
-0.14109201729297638,
0.789421021938324,
0.2774069905281067,
-0.4259451925754547,
0.45373284816741943,
0.2880992293357849,
-0.8092981576919556,
0.4933723211288452,
0.4439363479614258,
0.7827365398406982,
-0.5166590213775635,
0.0017354179872199893,
0.4086359441280365,
0.4190143942832947,
-0.26228007674217224,
0.36848658323287964,
0.33117857575416565,
-0.8957319259643555,
-0.6364185810089111,
-0.6139389872550964,
-0.5698719024658203,
0.16837483644485474,
-0.564882218837738,
0.5686227083206177,
-0.49168846011161804,
-0.40706589818000793,
0.2752132713794708,
0.25471606850624084,
-0.37813854217529297,
-0.1519085019826889,
0.12199094891548157,
0.7603130340576172,
-1.2234008312225342,
0.8540392518043518,
0.5659739971160889,
-0.07402749359607697,
-0.5274062156677246,
0.011350421234965324,
0.202796071767807,
-0.7766439914703369,
0.420230507850647,
0.023207364603877068,
-0.15742658078670502,
-0.47252151370048523,
-0.7945840358734131,
-0.6556801199913025,
0.41951096057891846,
0.7368544936180115,
-0.9396516680717468,
0.19141244888305664,
0.08446395397186279,
0.17414487898349762,
-0.6567838191986084,
-0.07601232826709747,
0.29008081555366516,
0.688293993473053,
0.12954771518707275,
-0.7770699858665466,
-0.09194233268499374,
-0.10483810305595398,
-0.2270755171775818,
0.36426496505737305,
-0.8312236070632935,
0.7965704798698425,
0.0744992271065712,
-0.1635216623544693,
-0.24010978639125824,
0.437374085187912,
0.17616118490695953,
-0.21484962105751038,
0.5064632296562195,
0.44777563214302063,
0.8935407400131226,
-0.16853396594524384,
0.9514086246490479,
-0.47839194536209106,
0.17556290328502655,
1.1224201917648315,
-0.7067203521728516,
0.76842200756073,
0.6368657350540161,
-0.1772879660129547,
0.552115261554718,
0.9097935557365417,
0.007710637059062719,
0.5012798309326172,
0.19212985038757324,
-0.5758618712425232,
-0.5305773019790649,
-0.06231522560119629,
-0.36370742321014404,
0.29462945461273193,
0.383587509393692,
-0.1332608014345169,
-0.3382554054260254,
-0.3809416592121124,
0.12061282992362976,
0.40358293056488037,
-0.07824921607971191,
0.7472310662269592,
0.16322700679302216,
-0.8340384364128113,
0.17548148334026337,
0.01604282855987549,
0.5905544757843018,
-0.6663053035736084,
0.028857193887233734,
0.05594956874847412,
0.11437961459159851,
-0.4602692425251007,
-1.122644066810608,
0.3675083518028259,
0.1550893634557724,
-0.3278309404850006,
-0.2598324418067932,
0.575170636177063,
-0.554900586605072,
-0.7431546449661255,
0.12159398943185806,
0.5033082962036133,
0.03554566577076912,
0.1527707874774933,
-0.6877864003181458,
0.07638879865407944,
0.30232056975364685,
-0.33047470450401306,
0.4262177348136902,
0.6655793786048889,
-0.16586686670780182,
0.4375912845134735,
0.524979829788208,
0.2511122524738312,
-0.0868733674287796,
0.10440497100353241,
1.0441200733184814,
-0.46093761920928955,
-0.4483431577682495,
-1.3309004306793213,
0.46595892310142517,
-0.5372213125228882,
-0.13188683986663818,
0.7784848809242249,
1.022592544555664,
0.6323726177215576,
0.14679290354251862,
0.9340265393257141,
-0.03310752287507057,
0.48898157477378845,
-0.442039430141449,
0.8253217935562134,
-0.4465373754501343,
0.2609044313430786,
-0.1180860847234726,
-0.8974136114120483,
-0.24037817120552063,
1.0264334678649902,
-0.4479406177997589,
-0.09371166676282883,
0.3332558572292328,
0.8940004706382751,
-0.3313099443912506,
-0.013459657318890095,
0.08981447666883469,
0.16522149741649628,
0.21209874749183655,
0.4589387774467468,
1.1367290019989014,
0.15251046419143677,
0.14911989867687225,
-0.09536649286746979,
-0.11193428933620453,
-0.007763910107314587,
-1.3970160484313965,
-1.0236270427703857,
-0.37389230728149414,
-0.36506420373916626,
-0.3540279269218445,
-0.05853227153420448,
0.9179764986038208,
0.8332311511039734,
-0.9097478985786438,
-0.6217690110206604,
0.38346460461616516,
0.30824044346809387,
0.3307638466358185,
-0.2413819283246994,
0.39788922667503357,
-0.03280215710401535,
-0.8148648738861084,
-0.11940058320760727,
0.3485655188560486,
-0.21560253202915192,
-0.3838382363319397,
0.10634610056877136,
-0.4680197834968567,
0.3977254629135132,
0.5268296003341675,
-0.015479535795748234,
-1.002300500869751,
-0.7591017484664917,
-0.27587878704071045,
-0.25262290239334106,
0.4217151701450348,
0.6987621784210205,
-0.3941737413406372,
0.4294419288635254,
0.5654407739639282,
0.3645026385784149,
0.49510401487350464,
0.3685508072376251,
0.7583617568016052,
-0.5154093503952026,
0.29390498995780945,
0.3266540765762329,
0.26267558336257935,
0.6419622898101807,
-0.27018260955810547,
0.3284083902835846,
-0.16580234467983246,
-0.605374276638031,
-0.7735773921012878,
0.39264872670173645,
-1.2062493562698364,
-0.029211657121777534,
1.1738072633743286,
0.13674212992191315,
-0.15236163139343262,
0.2786153256893158,
-0.3110083043575287,
0.05564585700631142,
-0.31315815448760986,
0.4822745621204376,
1.399631381034851,
-0.3049308955669403,
-0.13010278344154358,
-0.986827552318573,
0.40731632709503174,
0.16224788129329681,
-0.6868265271186829,
0.31504473090171814,
0.737037718296051,
0.5320025086402893,
-0.04852001741528511,
0.7983794808387756,
-0.33395177125930786,
-0.017154760658740997,
-0.3020966649055481,
-0.14507529139518738,
0.6253942847251892,
0.15588092803955078,
-0.4462967813014984,
0.1375991404056549,
0.06631020456552505,
0.2701558470726013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14154v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14154v1 | Watching the Watchers: A Comparative Fairness Audit of Cloud-based Content Moderation Services | 2024-06-20T09:52:10 | 2024-06-20T09:52:10 | David Hartmann, Amin Oueslati, Dimitri Staufer | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | Online platforms face the challenge of moderating an ever-increasing volume
of content, including harmful hate speech. In the absence of clear legal
definitions and a lack of transparency regarding the role of algorithms in
shaping decisions on content moderation, there is a critical need for external
accountability. Our study contributes to filling this gap by systematically
evaluating four leading cloud-based content moderation services through a
third-party audit, highlighting issues such as biases against minorities and
vulnerable groups that may arise through over-reliance on these services. Using
a black-box audit approach and four benchmark data sets, we measure performance
in explicit and implicit hate speech detection as well as counterfactual
fairness through perturbation sensitivity analysis and present disparities in
performance for certain target identity groups and data sets. Our analysis
reveals that all services had difficulties detecting implicit hate speech,
which relies on more subtle and codified messages. Moreover, our results point
to the need to remove group-specific bias. It seems that biases towards some
groups, such as Women, have been mostly rectified, while biases towards other
groups, such as LGBTQ+ and PoC remain. | [
-0.5711348652839661,
-0.19217441976070404,
0.3426743447780609,
-0.11536718904972076,
-0.22662964463233948,
0.1055264100432396,
0.2558819651603699,
-0.6505913138389587,
0.3157374858856201,
0.5115207433700562,
-0.8741255402565002,
0.026136264204978943,
-0.984205961227417,
0.23391087353229523,
-0.6975637078285217,
1.3680126667022705,
0.15519008040428162,
0.3106337785720825,
0.06304925680160522,
-0.02867436781525612,
-0.4488343894481659,
-0.2272922396659851,
-0.6069112420082092,
0.07739999890327454,
0.5766669511795044,
0.05924786999821663,
0.6343212723731995,
0.7337473630905151,
0.37356406450271606,
0.29915082454681396,
-0.19581250846385956,
0.034106459468603134,
-0.8661876916885376,
0.12311151623725891,
-0.36447152495384216,
-0.5495058298110962,
-0.2203361541032791,
0.11435165256261826,
0.23776549100875854,
0.05433714762330055,
-0.10391207784414291,
0.36065858602523804,
0.17108571529388428,
0.5793488025665283,
-0.9871664047241211,
-0.12432117015123367,
-0.6442233920097351,
0.2808385193347931,
-0.2589598596096039,
0.025197479873895645,
0.027170974761247635,
-0.39501050114631653,
0.1869623064994812,
-0.5898512601852417,
0.49025124311447144,
0.12093033641576767,
0.44282039999961853,
0.5035693049430847,
-0.30974578857421875,
-0.513429582118988,
-0.644606351852417,
0.9745455980300903,
-0.31497371196746826,
0.5791048407554626,
0.7092293500900269,
0.255825012922287,
0.48120206594467163,
-0.5504626035690308,
-0.4659850001335144,
0.36995741724967957,
0.07849548012018204,
0.29106542468070984,
-0.4843352437019348,
-0.3296731114387512,
0.1571042686700821,
0.4986970126628876,
-0.20279838144779205,
0.28624698519706726,
-0.5320253968238831,
-0.5074241757392883,
0.6937183737754822,
0.3048962950706482,
-0.015866907313466072,
-0.15981023013591766,
-0.07085977494716644,
-0.1201208233833313,
-0.33730998635292053,
0.25657030940055847,
1.0422711372375488,
0.06519313901662827,
-0.23394863307476044,
0.3628394901752472,
-0.09981358051300049,
-0.015249577350914478,
0.2804955244064331,
-0.055107325315475464,
0.03649023920297623,
-0.11994773149490356,
-0.053625691682100296,
0.4618953466415405,
0.33989542722702026,
0.9560441970825195,
0.10056382417678833,
-0.22030553221702576,
-0.001426234724931419,
0.5031760334968567,
0.5839038491249084,
-0.8320726752281189,
-0.26036253571510315,
0.3301735520362854,
-0.579689621925354,
-0.19625267386436462,
0.20025724172592163,
-0.9232133626937866,
-1.1216906309127808,
-0.10832859575748444,
0.13265474140644073,
0.20415744185447693,
-0.20296360552310944,
-0.27644801139831543,
-0.41475802659988403,
0.06444641947746277,
0.39825090765953064,
-0.6900595426559448,
0.4226783514022827,
0.9360730648040771,
0.8709771037101746,
-0.4942966103553772,
0.08899177610874176,
-1.0437098741531372,
-0.04424741491675377,
-0.26288115978240967,
0.3287372887134552,
-0.40971577167510986,
-0.14410652220249176,
0.2668139636516571,
0.0754588320851326,
0.5765272378921509,
-0.40113139152526855,
0.7796200513839722,
-0.5521535873413086,
0.18366584181785583,
-0.7141703963279724,
-0.5114867091178894,
-0.20066964626312256,
0.13956120610237122,
-0.7072731256484985,
0.414447158575058,
-0.07431048154830933,
-0.787342369556427,
0.8667208552360535,
-0.43853050470352173,
-0.05769963189959526,
0.22533181309700012,
-0.4388607144355774,
-0.5490950345993042,
0.0753353163599968,
0.28932052850723267,
0.27803075313568115,
-0.1463342010974884,
0.27210551500320435,
-0.44744670391082764,
-0.3980824947357178,
0.2005508691072464,
-0.4087093472480774,
0.7848130464553833,
0.1653665006160736,
-0.9046754240989685,
0.2175418585538864,
-0.24139250814914703,
-0.15545901656150818,
-0.1067051813006401,
0.27592191100120544,
-0.12575611472129822,
0.48144567012786865,
0.26654955744743347,
0.3275826573371887,
-0.31441164016723633,
-0.7473819255828857,
-0.6446995139122009,
-0.0029454175382852554,
0.5895657539367676,
1.3293147087097168,
-0.15632452070713043,
0.029874620959162712,
-0.6249162554740906,
0.660092830657959,
0.15194810926914215,
0.6190283894538879,
0.12190190702676773,
-0.4732947051525116,
-0.6419079899787903,
-0.30868294835090637,
-0.24439939856529236,
0.253827840089798,
-0.4130688011646271,
0.04295707866549492,
-0.2180827409029007,
-0.44266995787620544,
-0.5697566866874695,
0.25008928775787354,
0.5681367516517639,
0.1605408638715744,
0.2123270332813263,
-0.5484817028045654,
-0.468496710062027,
-1.0824878215789795,
-0.4776870012283325,
-0.09468282759189606,
0.12721048295497894,
0.4345514178276062,
0.4971899390220642,
-0.28239789605140686,
0.7247989773750305,
-0.10890685766935349,
-0.4737890362739563,
0.33589237928390503,
-0.20425797998905182,
-0.15610960125923157,
0.24035322666168213,
0.4290459156036377,
-1.0587103366851807,
-0.4931141436100006,
-0.24985471367835999,
-0.3473840355873108,
-0.29078033566474915,
0.4952036738395691,
0.36011022329330444,
0.09737146645784378,
0.37024572491645813,
0.4894578754901886,
0.4340725243091583,
0.9568789601325989,
-0.7041230797767639,
0.3857906460762024,
0.4839511513710022,
0.6071525812149048,
-0.5476785898208618,
-0.09658604860305786,
-0.16477403044700623,
-0.4144192934036255,
-0.5460708737373352,
-0.13124404847621918,
-0.14111219346523285,
0.06446611136198044,
-0.6717628836631775,
0.15691733360290527,
-0.1696731150150299,
-0.25893524289131165,
-0.14858047664165497,
0.2335958331823349,
-0.08419207483530045,
0.31294411420822144,
-0.09886849671602249,
0.6928509473800659,
0.400717169046402,
-0.6297829151153564,
0.4097350835800171,
0.33521416783332825,
-0.5431749820709229,
0.8304213285446167,
-0.3150970935821533,
0.2055792659521103,
-0.2555466294288635,
0.2945981025695801,
-0.5286005139350891,
0.0017596357502043247,
0.37709107995033264,
-0.26006782054901123,
-0.5786052942276001,
-0.2946197986602783,
-0.32205119729042053,
-0.00006662947998847812,
-0.6951581835746765,
0.5121939182281494,
0.291143536567688,
-0.5492838025093079,
0.4280581474304199,
0.7475898861885071,
-0.24753472208976746,
-0.6548978090286255,
-0.853826105594635,
-0.1554298996925354,
-0.407476007938385,
-0.14291711151599884,
0.2524058520793915,
-0.12990212440490723,
-0.556995153427124,
0.060901395976543427,
-0.44398966431617737,
0.042750611901283264,
0.1604117602109909,
0.691807210445404,
-0.19634413719177246,
-0.013468954712152481,
-0.3210233151912689,
-0.20374998450279236,
0.12927085161209106,
0.232584148645401,
-0.0342826247215271,
0.47706139087677,
-0.1092536523938179,
-0.4995199143886566,
-0.7121150493621826,
0.5922321081161499,
0.4023740887641907,
-0.07944311946630478,
0.5359143614768982,
0.709459125995636,
-0.2960963547229767,
-0.20602378249168396,
-0.9330411553382874,
-0.25369471311569214,
-0.45673954486846924,
0.07902567833662033,
0.1584809273481369,
-1.1276180744171143,
0.8027792572975159,
0.7331802248954773,
0.26159340143203735,
0.4133235514163971,
0.24811863899230957,
0.08041652292013168,
1.1135956048965454,
0.6616798639297485,
-0.014295987784862518,
0.6860190629959106,
0.1465735286474228,
0.1322888433933258,
-0.41112789511680603,
-0.2691391408443451,
-0.6755842566490173,
-0.24409061670303345,
-0.8057672381401062,
-0.1372242271900177,
0.37590447068214417,
-0.06567081063985825,
-0.3409325182437897,
-0.04767591506242752,
-0.29887259006500244,
0.3219602704048157,
0.20506179332733154,
0.16669777035713196,
0.45602938532829285,
-0.1100711077451706,
0.25390690565109253,
-0.5675150752067566,
-0.42321720719337463,
-0.4353724718093872,
0.997387170791626,
0.4095905125141144,
0.4659776985645294,
0.48304301500320435,
0.07419625669717789,
0.9422059059143066,
0.8664405941963196,
-0.5960262417793274,
0.11662977188825607,
-0.4454984962940216,
-0.7086541652679443,
0.049231965094804764,
-0.43236544728279114,
-0.38774773478507996,
0.25660744309425354,
-0.18526312708854675,
-0.7349898219108582,
0.2766445577144623,
0.28576114773750305,
-0.07539301365613937,
0.6000075936317444,
-0.37432020902633667,
0.5813763737678528,
-0.19872763752937317,
-0.8115125894546509,
-0.45157545804977417,
-0.07376081496477127,
0.3665226101875305,
-0.19882705807685852,
0.42451632022857666,
-0.08732368797063828,
-0.14911817014217377,
0.9915938973426819,
-0.4610707461833954,
0.7372191548347473,
-0.27065154910087585,
-0.2077590674161911,
0.1549888253211975,
0.1630050241947174,
0.39132195711135864,
0.10497336834669113,
0.014848614111542702,
0.3096379041671753,
0.21790450811386108,
-0.27672910690307617,
-0.32542628049850464,
0.6763437986373901,
-0.6961606740951538,
-0.45672807097435,
-0.5799182653427124,
-0.0811728909611702,
-0.38891473412513733,
0.21016620099544525,
0.0716572180390358,
0.4614989161491394,
-0.22659452259540558,
0.6291201710700989,
0.6812488436698914,
-0.012284698896110058,
0.3715566098690033,
0.5524242520332336,
-0.36714160442352295,
-0.5515764951705933,
0.6119077205657959,
-0.0408448725938797,
0.14919263124465942,
0.047891344875097275,
0.0758037120103836,
-0.3423991799354553,
-0.6587283611297607,
-0.3756600022315979,
-0.25834381580352783,
-0.6411458849906921,
-0.0678052306175232,
-0.8004801869392395,
0.1537618637084961,
-0.44265609979629517,
-0.23782405257225037,
-0.28547602891921997,
0.13433299958705902,
0.22567428648471832,
-0.04355672374367714,
0.22126859426498413,
0.7410730719566345,
-0.12685085833072662,
0.5186627507209778,
-0.26971495151519775,
0.47582224011421204,
0.6460831165313721,
0.7237609624862671,
-0.18704211711883545,
-0.45721086859703064,
-0.041562166064977646,
-0.12187059968709946,
-0.3903171718120575,
-0.7748271822929382,
0.0993078351020813,
-0.26188501715660095,
0.3626610338687897,
0.7974965572357178,
-0.03190682828426361,
0.8170515298843384,
-0.25614169239997864,
0.9368113875389099,
0.26072028279304504,
-1.2284791469573975,
0.18297533690929413,
-0.3405410051345825,
-0.13420264422893524,
0.6720914840698242,
0.4220029413700104,
-0.8825756311416626,
-0.4960758090019226,
-0.5405005812644958,
-0.39698344469070435,
0.9002192616462708,
0.3858850300312042,
-0.063174769282341,
0.20376840233802795,
0.046533167362213135,
0.23329709470272064,
0.6572993397712708,
-0.8211864829063416,
-0.6044042110443115,
-0.5209416747093201,
0.18454088270664215,
-0.3901883661746979,
-0.13820333778858185,
-0.2997566759586334,
0.24011363089084625,
0.713000476360321,
-0.07222133129835129,
-0.037052590399980545,
0.3609400689601898,
0.01354527659714222,
-0.533343493938446,
0.15818965435028076,
0.29905053973197937,
0.8050556778907776,
-0.22690454125404358,
-0.049877580255270004,
-0.04248489812016487,
-0.6476902365684509,
-0.297767698764801,
-0.21385523676872253,
-0.45125290751457214,
-0.12156539410352707,
0.3578442335128784,
0.5310020446777344,
0.061116475611925125,
-0.9052666425704956,
0.7785519957542419,
-0.2956865429878235,
-0.14875543117523193,
-0.3103114366531372,
0.14050349593162537,
-0.3441956639289856,
0.1314546912908554,
0.25175148248672485,
-0.1197577565908432,
0.40785789489746094,
-0.657692551612854,
0.13495786488056183,
0.5583249926567078,
-0.9416893124580383,
0.012910780496895313,
0.7841658592224121,
0.1175825372338295,
-0.2633693516254425,
0.2737460434436798,
0.14324237406253815,
-0.705293595790863,
0.6177749037742615,
0.1682453155517578,
0.9193671345710754,
-0.06855954229831696,
0.1326044201850891,
0.03419012203812599,
0.5782403945922852,
0.05952369421720505,
0.09202258288860321,
-0.26132988929748535,
-0.8082289695739746,
-0.22904670238494873,
-0.40474241971969604,
-0.5980545878410339,
0.37297526001930237,
-0.9750744104385376,
0.00365801271982491,
-0.6877552270889282,
-0.19328920543193817,
0.23469802737236023,
0.20936192572116852,
-0.8307060599327087,
0.2959274351596832,
0.18127770721912384,
0.6815808415412903,
-0.88620525598526,
-0.09672578424215317,
0.3756515085697174,
-0.037441007792949677,
-0.28064316511154175,
-0.00598548399284482,
0.5994037389755249,
-0.3943248987197876,
0.11192850768566132,
0.30203860998153687,
-0.5495293140411377,
-0.5222330689430237,
-0.554880678653717,
-0.3599157929420471,
0.7940322756767273,
0.17970851063728333,
-0.7632935047149658,
0.4058677852153778,
-0.025581547990441322,
0.5887804627418518,
-0.22923876345157623,
0.3797381818294525,
0.13351032137870789,
0.4377208948135376,
-0.5744067430496216,
-0.9648681879043579,
0.02367992326617241,
-0.10017764568328857,
-0.17026452720165253,
0.12486781924962997,
-0.8347570300102234,
0.5890235304832458,
0.43879225850105286,
-0.3683033287525177,
-0.4749871790409088,
0.3716557025909424,
-0.07403075695037842,
0.4898505210876465,
0.8850412368774414,
0.1308501958847046,
0.3789752423763275,
0.09449578076601028,
0.9184556007385254,
0.18913856148719788,
-0.10278277099132538,
1.006157398223877,
-0.12803475558757782,
0.44447797536849976,
0.630211591720581,
-0.1406710147857666,
0.29541850090026855,
0.2488776594400406,
-0.08704877644777298,
0.5483280420303345,
0.1849731206893921,
-0.0912548378109932,
-0.20893613994121552,
-0.673424482345581,
-0.2753005921840668,
0.34055522084236145,
0.2476847767829895,
-0.3644874095916748,
0.07052236795425415,
-0.2563561201095581,
0.06467630714178085,
0.4847557842731476,
-0.9536946415901184,
0.7359744310379028,
-0.030375495553016663,
-0.8524964451789856,
-0.04523230344057083,
0.3211117386817932,
0.8924159407615662,
-0.6381983757019043,
0.3036336600780487,
-0.021523958072066307,
0.1690804660320282,
-0.4040752649307251,
-0.555176854133606,
0.41728755831718445,
0.5578702092170715,
-0.16734281182289124,
-0.655927836894989,
0.18988479673862457,
0.18708449602127075,
0.2133314609527588,
0.6085811853408813,
0.4722740352153778,
0.0133284330368042,
-0.19589324295520782,
-0.7019474506378174,
0.5468825101852417,
-0.01501003373414278,
0.2634929418563843,
0.16399547457695007,
-0.22817115485668182,
-0.20059265196323395,
0.6109439730644226,
0.6097171306610107,
0.0985795110464096,
0.28958961367607117,
0.07207883894443512,
0.541605532169342,
-0.37647852301597595,
-1.0482404232025146,
-0.7020418047904968,
0.18065929412841797,
-0.1758807897567749,
-0.6576705574989319,
0.7958111763000488,
0.7219348549842834,
1.2837724685668945,
0.21895885467529297,
0.6481934785842896,
-0.18138954043388367,
0.5083929896354675,
-0.34949105978012085,
0.5369167923927307,
-0.5368525981903076,
-0.1604062020778656,
-0.4845238924026489,
-0.8645946979522705,
0.08617708086967468,
0.1983322650194168,
-0.2163160741329193,
-0.16119153797626495,
0.5548391938209534,
0.7947414517402649,
-0.08522477000951767,
0.6226631999015808,
0.07543858140707016,
0.264430433511734,
0.5761384963989258,
0.1443890929222107,
0.8951106667518616,
-0.42641153931617737,
0.6961004137992859,
-0.38111042976379395,
-0.0898570716381073,
-0.06395038962364197,
-1.0633355379104614,
-0.8476564884185791,
-0.6565881371498108,
-0.29369300603866577,
-0.36486542224884033,
0.25695914030075073,
0.6302511096000671,
0.8127694129943848,
-1.2752214670181274,
0.06213943287730217,
0.16521786153316498,
0.06986936926841736,
-0.698695182800293,
-0.2169492393732071,
0.13164262473583221,
0.5567008852958679,
-0.8371332883834839,
0.15837673842906952,
0.17657004296779633,
-0.4887649416923523,
-0.5099837183952332,
0.026501990854740143,
0.20716716349124908,
0.06606230139732361,
0.3578477203845978,
0.12092544138431549,
-0.909365713596344,
-0.19534587860107422,
-0.4330193102359772,
-0.07189054042100906,
-0.20086339116096497,
1.0991517305374146,
-0.34358856081962585,
0.31613340973854065,
0.3442534804344177,
0.8389312028884888,
0.6156070828437805,
0.08902479708194733,
0.30693334341049194,
-0.23001770675182343,
-0.12834449112415314,
0.2232615351676941,
0.2817758023738861,
0.2568819522857666,
-0.32311132550239563,
0.15036429464817047,
0.11608710885047913,
-0.4413869380950928,
-0.9800442457199097,
0.34479352831840515,
-0.7393853664398193,
0.024458810687065125,
0.6671338677406311,
0.06717953830957413,
0.14236459136009216,
-0.508448600769043,
-0.008167987689375877,
0.1499975025653839,
-0.6037111878395081,
0.911074697971344,
0.825574517250061,
0.04310368001461029,
-0.15698057413101196,
-0.8263791799545288,
0.7640432119369507,
0.6296274065971375,
-0.6861779689788818,
0.07391365617513657,
0.8217586874961853,
0.42661890387535095,
0.08922562003135681,
0.49869149923324585,
-0.18616953492164612,
0.3417438268661499,
-0.2415357232093811,
-0.4406886696815491,
-0.08943378925323486,
-0.2992267906665802,
-0.7244742512702942,
0.29148751497268677,
-0.5880759358406067,
0.1397750824689865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14144v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14144v1 | Finding Safety Neurons in Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T09:35:22 | 2024-06-20T09:35:22 | Jianhui Chen, Xiaozhi Wang, Zijun Yao, Yushi Bai, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) excel in various capabilities but also pose
safety risks such as generating harmful content and misinformation, even after
safety alignment. In this paper, we explore the inner mechanisms of safety
alignment from the perspective of mechanistic interpretability, focusing on
identifying and analyzing safety neurons within LLMs that are responsible for
safety behaviors. We propose generation-time activation contrasting to locate
these neurons and dynamic activation patching to evaluate their causal effects.
Experiments on multiple recent LLMs show that: (1) Safety neurons are sparse
and effective. We can restore $90$% safety performance with intervention only
on about $5$% of all the neurons. (2) Safety neurons encode transferrable
mechanisms. They exhibit consistent effectiveness on different red-teaming
datasets. The finding of safety neurons also interprets "alignment tax". We
observe that the identified key neurons for safety and helpfulness
significantly overlap, but they require different activation patterns of the
shared neurons. Furthermore, we demonstrate an application of safety neurons in
detecting unsafe outputs before generation. Our findings may promote further
research on understanding LLM alignment. The source codes will be publicly
released to facilitate future research. | [
0.1926082819700241,
-0.5938053727149963,
0.6078258752822876,
0.19732417166233063,
0.028870824724435806,
0.1361360102891922,
-0.14028730988502502,
-0.5136701464653015,
-0.01726881042122841,
0.11676250398159027,
-0.44675466418266296,
-0.27410346269607544,
-0.7265677452087402,
-0.23137645423412323,
-0.34414923191070557,
0.9127784967422485,
0.04133407026529312,
-0.15094102919101715,
0.061298713088035583,
-0.022684261202812195,
-0.30376777052879333,
-0.6095197200775146,
-0.7779518365859985,
-0.5375662446022034,
0.8644212484359741,
0.050461214035749435,
0.7198207378387451,
0.7070925831794739,
0.3735542893409729,
0.4371536672115326,
-0.4350036084651947,
-0.24034832417964935,
-0.46546363830566406,
0.01879296451807022,
-0.26665228605270386,
-0.39458099007606506,
-0.7823797464370728,
-0.17571546137332916,
0.648206889629364,
0.4580761194229126,
-0.2765568196773529,
-0.38622957468032837,
0.542605996131897,
0.2637781798839569,
-0.6288495659828186,
0.11746840924024582,
-0.8120396137237549,
-0.15064769983291626,
-0.029381096363067627,
-0.5608256459236145,
-0.6172233819961548,
-0.42723268270492554,
-0.018739566206932068,
-0.3415205478668213,
-0.08096956461668015,
0.00014974297664593905,
0.7311527132987976,
0.37408071756362915,
-0.3673953413963318,
-0.15616826713085175,
-0.3293403685092926,
0.9228730201721191,
-0.7557443976402283,
-0.02038666047155857,
0.09633098542690277,
-0.05910762399435043,
-0.602036714553833,
-0.33596864342689514,
-0.5173478722572327,
-0.12176646292209625,
-0.30512335896492004,
-0.2907268702983856,
-0.2380787581205368,
0.2845478057861328,
0.286908894777298,
-0.18994276225566864,
-0.38895440101623535,
0.6345463395118713,
-0.15658284723758698,
-0.3721296191215515,
0.7312666773796082,
0.19944043457508087,
0.7496745586395264,
-0.0674218237400055,
-0.4504855275154114,
-0.25832056999206543,
-0.9186996817588806,
-0.06107863038778305,
0.5400112867355347,
0.3421420454978943,
-0.36852094531059265,
0.33025115728378296,
0.04801857843995094,
0.5634306073188782,
-0.369754433631897,
-0.15030930936336517,
0.38158124685287476,
-0.37599462270736694,
-0.18934057652950287,
0.4983314871788025,
0.9919568300247192,
0.48269122838974,
0.5103221535682678,
-0.09185858070850372,
-0.21317856013774872,
-0.20396864414215088,
0.5119919776916504,
-0.4544629156589508,
-0.13371723890304565,
0.11830919235944748,
-0.3987255394458771,
-0.7194558382034302,
-0.30039724707603455,
-0.6603149771690369,
-0.48197704553604126,
-0.18333005905151367,
0.464387446641922,
-0.3637801706790924,
-0.5502784848213196,
0.2855898141860962,
0.09602732956409454,
0.28751513361930847,
-0.11792891472578049,
-1.256629467010498,
-0.11078320443630219,
0.8345218300819397,
0.8632981777191162,
-0.1715855449438095,
-0.5902069807052612,
-0.4017302691936493,
0.42935916781425476,
-0.33495453000068665,
0.54268479347229,
-0.16262005269527435,
-0.022728504613041878,
0.1452987790107727,
0.2869386672973633,
-0.26678338646888733,
-0.2614409625530243,
0.4752390384674072,
-0.6103945970535278,
-0.5454742908477783,
-0.15879526734352112,
-0.24536028504371643,
-0.1269741654396057,
0.1698421686887741,
-0.6691118478775024,
0.4086964726448059,
-0.4583299160003662,
-0.8124961853027344,
0.38823947310447693,
-0.6389988660812378,
-0.6178345680236816,
-0.25900283455848694,
-0.2115875482559204,
-0.38373252749443054,
-0.02664298377931118,
-0.13388223946094513,
0.5798918008804321,
0.07527712732553482,
0.4744763970375061,
-0.4674520194530487,
-0.13247893750667572,
0.5771841406822205,
-0.6519388556480408,
1.0038622617721558,
-0.02776571735739708,
-0.4050862789154053,
0.5758910775184631,
-0.5185179710388184,
0.018059831112623215,
0.16185976564884186,
-0.440486341714859,
-0.49059319496154785,
0.18265646696090698,
-0.14647798240184784,
0.24322421848773956,
0.18328255414962769,
-0.27486157417297363,
-0.0373823419213295,
-0.1422068178653717,
0.5472322106361389,
1.1251323223114014,
0.03907345235347748,
0.5370841026306152,
-0.2255648672580719,
0.19316713511943817,
-0.04323209822177887,
0.3730528950691223,
0.07385537028312683,
-0.41658318042755127,
-0.41154107451438904,
-0.018810207024216652,
0.13130655884742737,
0.4458673298358917,
-0.40521812438964844,
0.7784034013748169,
-0.30482715368270874,
-0.15334515273571014,
-0.26388460397720337,
-0.032212238758802414,
0.5626875758171082,
0.3114699721336365,
0.23400944471359253,
-0.005884574260562658,
-0.26076197624206543,
-1.0183236598968506,
-0.3197231590747833,
-0.23521582782268524,
0.08397988975048065,
-0.1896645873785019,
0.40048840641975403,
-0.09385187178850174,
0.5713553428649902,
-0.22473600506782532,
0.2760019302368164,
-0.12556324899196625,
0.28886154294013977,
0.11866007000207901,
0.9406238794326782,
0.47509458661079407,
-0.5882145762443542,
-0.06165560707449913,
0.11395268887281418,
-0.9403742551803589,
-0.0808846578001976,
-0.32869893312454224,
-0.18327221274375916,
0.41660186648368835,
0.8443622589111328,
-0.6063350439071655,
0.35546618700027466,
0.6416594982147217,
-0.2433585375547409,
0.31846126914024353,
-0.31646111607551575,
0.013540230691432953,
-0.9029673933982849,
0.06827262043952942,
-0.13772423565387726,
0.04804597422480583,
-0.6977839469909668,
-0.045042648911476135,
0.17871439456939697,
0.4032011330127716,
-0.553011417388916,
0.21043559908866882,
-0.5909752249717712,
-0.22659899294376373,
-0.3224108815193176,
0.10126456618309021,
-0.24382834136486053,
0.3596276640892029,
-0.23931488394737244,
0.702900767326355,
0.5408634543418884,
-0.5635340213775635,
0.06089818850159645,
0.07937298715114594,
-0.6843036413192749,
0.08934146165847778,
-0.6994434595108032,
-0.03218870609998703,
-0.11098957061767578,
0.06229378655552864,
-0.8588684797286987,
-0.4257207214832306,
0.3092947006225586,
-0.1505558341741562,
0.6944569945335388,
-0.30429598689079285,
-0.6139386296272278,
0.08420621603727341,
-0.10638011991977692,
0.5317457318305969,
0.6008838415145874,
-0.5988524556159973,
0.3019655644893646,
0.6889408826828003,
-0.3126213252544403,
-0.9030850529670715,
-0.6886091828346252,
0.02148030698299408,
-0.21744182705879211,
-0.6679657101631165,
0.21334007382392883,
0.11401661485433578,
-0.3506598174571991,
-0.0249367393553257,
-0.12685376405715942,
0.1922585815191269,
0.4866507649421692,
0.3369467556476593,
0.29795360565185547,
-0.11456058919429779,
0.24884344637393951,
0.19706007838249207,
-0.2970563769340515,
0.28608015179634094,
0.19124191999435425,
0.676647424697876,
-0.07865800708532333,
-0.3187296390533447,
-0.30001920461654663,
0.16855208575725555,
0.71026611328125,
-0.055801328271627426,
0.9963139295578003,
0.06324099004268646,
-0.4316539168357849,
-0.19154739379882812,
-0.2562006115913391,
-0.3535539507865906,
-0.5635102391242981,
0.4531383812427521,
0.07094627618789673,
-0.7614777088165283,
0.375379353761673,
0.020662587136030197,
0.087967149913311,
0.33496373891830444,
0.4649374186992645,
-0.050186898559331894,
1.0822217464447021,
0.4765622019767761,
-0.10524821281433105,
0.4464424252510071,
0.15562859177589417,
0.5638575553894043,
-0.7008166313171387,
-0.5661419630050659,
-0.3409248888492584,
-0.47600653767585754,
-0.49769407510757446,
-0.24285458028316498,
0.41009363532066345,
0.24083220958709717,
-0.3312455415725708,
0.3338194191455841,
-0.4285913407802582,
0.6981296539306641,
0.3770030736923218,
-0.03374924883246422,
0.16004619002342224,
0.033059921115636826,
-0.23721520602703094,
0.142039954662323,
-0.7743707895278931,
-0.4510973393917084,
0.6110789179801941,
0.5834615230560303,
0.9725115299224854,
0.11478950083255768,
0.45484665036201477,
-0.07385578006505966,
0.26475417613983154,
-0.6148898601531982,
0.7617815732955933,
0.0036185632925480604,
-0.6607112288475037,
-0.33001548051834106,
-0.40560463070869446,
-0.9482766389846802,
0.013686798512935638,
-0.5835086703300476,
-0.8898722529411316,
0.07701610028743744,
0.2735229432582855,
-0.5185012817382812,
0.5257659554481506,
-0.7657800912857056,
0.8944649696350098,
-0.7555034160614014,
-0.5848238468170166,
-0.506533145904541,
-0.8157552480697632,
0.37712711095809937,
-0.09138404577970505,
0.1485140472650528,
-0.2371007353067398,
0.12172406911849976,
0.6199051141738892,
0.09707717597484589,
1.1127151250839233,
0.11986138671636581,
-0.32803112268447876,
0.00240252073854208,
0.026658449321985245,
0.5118963122367859,
-0.36759495735168457,
-0.0677938163280487,
0.38265976309776306,
-0.33718085289001465,
-0.23309394717216492,
-0.3610219657421112,
1.0541255474090576,
-0.3675260543823242,
-0.622651219367981,
-0.5941470265388489,
-0.980556845664978,
0.02812935970723629,
0.2916760742664337,
0.20025484263896942,
0.17539973556995392,
0.0430222786962986,
0.2650255262851715,
0.6917513012886047,
-0.5018404126167297,
0.9280228614807129,
0.2238250970840454,
-0.04198994114995003,
-0.014126179739832878,
0.6659521460533142,
0.20018330216407776,
0.301702618598938,
0.07334492355585098,
-0.06294842064380646,
-0.3204827904701233,
-0.8814671635627747,
-0.17994928359985352,
0.2757086157798767,
-0.7027674913406372,
-0.1328917294740677,
-0.6105343699455261,
-0.44130071997642517,
-0.16284629702568054,
-0.17561009526252747,
-0.2605939209461212,
-0.2861456573009491,
-0.18669019639492035,
-0.4907890260219574,
0.38185688853263855,
0.8207246661186218,
-0.3837279975414276,
0.3321409523487091,
-0.9775255918502808,
-0.17950546741485596,
0.3128831088542938,
0.589175820350647,
0.24950703978538513,
-0.017769310623407364,
-0.1437309831380844,
-0.06959356367588043,
-0.26177364587783813,
-0.734046459197998,
0.14035189151763916,
-0.32519418001174927,
0.7134051322937012,
0.4236717224121094,
0.011510007083415985,
0.3233998417854309,
-0.6398186087608337,
0.47125208377838135,
0.6392285823822021,
-0.9203912615776062,
0.28136226534843445,
-0.4346897304058075,
-0.19639724493026733,
0.23850242793560028,
0.43656182289123535,
-0.16946375370025635,
-0.057594750076532364,
-0.5167085528373718,
-1.0627800226211548,
0.6829508543014526,
0.26795488595962524,
0.09988889843225479,
-0.08626744151115417,
0.25907382369041443,
-0.16048915684223175,
-0.0138792023062706,
-0.7296684980392456,
0.02006687968969345,
0.27872923016548157,
-0.2087177336215973,
-0.016855064779520035,
-0.549656093120575,
-0.5313402414321899,
0.12022624164819717,
0.5748751759529114,
-0.15678580105304718,
0.1271742880344391,
-0.1308322548866272,
0.1559804081916809,
-0.24293144047260284,
0.4862562119960785,
0.8650041818618774,
0.543483316898346,
-0.0711628794670105,
0.29056432843208313,
0.11318930238485336,
-0.06921947747468948,
0.28152453899383545,
-0.20388098061084747,
-0.05088523030281067,
-0.3153168261051178,
0.6025916337966919,
0.7039510011672974,
0.40152105689048767,
-0.48647767305374146,
0.5370373725891113,
0.12375336140394211,
-0.02860911563038826,
-0.2577492296695709,
0.5326344966888428,
0.17844650149345398,
0.4034935235977173,
-0.032785505056381226,
0.17541955411434174,
-0.11012325435876846,
-0.6343905925750732,
0.2931502163410187,
0.6848851442337036,
-0.28386789560317993,
-0.4262484014034271,
0.6359085440635681,
0.1960487961769104,
-0.4114585518836975,
0.42354732751846313,
0.17613472044467926,
-0.47247061133384705,
0.8085739612579346,
0.5540062189102173,
0.9451376795768738,
-0.34056392312049866,
-0.016901439055800438,
0.3855052590370178,
0.566971480846405,
-0.3687964081764221,
0.14306043088436127,
0.5175060629844666,
-0.8625994920730591,
-0.6919897794723511,
-0.5020002126693726,
-0.0650506317615509,
0.26138120889663696,
-0.46548715233802795,
0.08682147413492203,
-0.408479779958725,
-0.16196975111961365,
0.086698979139328,
-0.8307168483734131,
0.027260221540927887,
0.06455425173044205,
0.07202453911304474,
0.7725250720977783,
-0.9644760489463806,
0.8748012185096741,
0.4577508270740509,
-0.244179368019104,
-0.7759243249893188,
0.3677021265029907,
0.07526877522468567,
-0.8442158699035645,
0.604653000831604,
0.13420724868774414,
-0.286552369594574,
-0.21068716049194336,
-0.8832992911338806,
-0.7203308939933777,
1.0005027055740356,
0.5119569897651672,
-0.9102518558502197,
-0.30732667446136475,
0.06472562253475189,
0.435786634683609,
-0.21958355605602264,
-0.18056435883045197,
0.5943061113357544,
0.4181247353553772,
-0.14458230137825012,
-0.8130139112472534,
0.4322546720504761,
-0.1151927039027214,
-0.22289876639842987,
0.5245491862297058,
-0.46709325909614563,
0.7667772173881531,
-0.3079073131084442,
-0.12552562355995178,
-0.023349765688180923,
0.211636021733284,
0.3911316692829132,
0.32708409428596497,
0.6133833527565002,
0.4779435098171234,
0.6085692644119263,
-0.07073508203029633,
1.0593503713607788,
-0.30984213948249817,
0.18691112101078033,
1.0028239488601685,
-0.08081863820552826,
0.8769689202308655,
0.81109619140625,
0.2203749716281891,
0.3987371027469635,
0.2588087320327759,
0.20319382846355438,
0.6900371313095093,
0.3158591389656067,
-0.34529349207878113,
-0.4217821955680847,
-0.09860311448574066,
-0.2176828682422638,
0.055446695536375046,
0.33508747816085815,
-0.5507511496543884,
-0.008535079658031464,
-0.3846812844276428,
0.2757583558559418,
-0.2648964822292328,
-0.2758713960647583,
0.7307838201522827,
0.2978779971599579,
-0.7571905255317688,
0.5353893637657166,
-0.3420313000679016,
0.5718958973884583,
-0.5630500912666321,
-0.13645188510417938,
0.1405254751443863,
0.3140915036201477,
-0.35126563906669617,
-1.2802040576934814,
0.5475463271141052,
-0.16652312874794006,
-0.0937236025929451,
-0.29213646054267883,
0.7605054378509521,
-0.43126949667930603,
0.03517993912100792,
0.877885103225708,
0.05119994282722473,
-0.024838760495185852,
0.3281060457229614,
-0.4491334557533264,
0.22067725658416748,
-0.007387534249573946,
-0.10416234284639359,
0.6162732243537903,
0.2732803225517273,
-0.15279875695705414,
0.5374802947044373,
0.6979190707206726,
0.033735960721969604,
0.21777118742465973,
-0.0814431831240654,
0.8372807502746582,
-0.5968289971351624,
-0.351178377866745,
-1.032395601272583,
0.7744197845458984,
-0.19352462887763977,
-0.048614807426929474,
0.3595049977302551,
0.028632894158363342,
0.5384402275085449,
-0.00012225104728713632,
0.800386905670166,
0.0008122457074932754,
-0.08029383420944214,
-0.9421958923339844,
1.362878680229187,
-0.5904017090797424,
0.41131383180618286,
-0.13646450638771057,
-0.7350060939788818,
-0.541080117225647,
0.5457476377487183,
-0.3550983667373657,
-0.19317814707756042,
0.7208527326583862,
1.1340140104293823,
-0.18289527297019958,
-0.018089760094881058,
0.3339637815952301,
0.5570777654647827,
0.2982355058193207,
0.6037164926528931,
1.059899926185608,
-0.20592670142650604,
0.6592563390731812,
-0.13715825974941254,
-0.2762278914451599,
-0.18995845317840576,
-1.3749703168869019,
-0.792090654373169,
-0.4472563862800598,
-0.3560415208339691,
-0.5657920837402344,
0.13057219982147217,
0.7580941915512085,
0.6213459968566895,
-0.8046290874481201,
-0.057432517409324646,
-0.3760058283805847,
0.2124309539794922,
-0.00853348895907402,
-0.13359622657299042,
0.326560378074646,
-0.5160868167877197,
-0.39074358344078064,
0.6249874234199524,
0.29984864592552185,
0.12705299258232117,
0.1310117393732071,
-0.1548265814781189,
-0.201391339302063,
-0.05049288272857666,
0.3655984699726105,
0.29735392332077026,
-0.5164341330528259,
-0.632827877998352,
-0.26485851407051086,
-0.24309146404266357,
-0.1459970623254776,
0.7246239185333252,
0.030597666278481483,
0.1444847285747528,
0.802298367023468,
0.6769703030586243,
-0.0976187139749527,
-0.36786526441574097,
0.8461937308311462,
-0.6452696323394775,
0.12572266161441803,
0.021959027275443077,
0.6723118424415588,
0.30800849199295044,
-0.2995463013648987,
0.5953179597854614,
-0.06602694094181061,
-0.8192237615585327,
-0.8462570905685425,
0.3005419969558716,
-0.9749839901924133,
-0.1901577115058899,
1.363264799118042,
-0.2686784565448761,
-0.33902543783187866,
-0.16752417385578156,
0.10060635954141617,
0.4133903384208679,
-0.18767015635967255,
0.9308789372444153,
0.6044709086418152,
0.007205382455140352,
-0.09346069395542145,
-0.5213537812232971,
0.6536485552787781,
0.5370643734931946,
-0.776934027671814,
0.1309715360403061,
0.32387790083885193,
0.3496553599834442,
0.47798699140548706,
0.2367498129606247,
-0.2640133500099182,
0.2963237762451172,
-0.1544439047574997,
0.2615622282028198,
0.2640589773654938,
-0.5072965621948242,
-0.7120978236198425,
0.18831376731395721,
-0.027688000351190567,
-0.2883727252483368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14137v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14137v1 | MACAROON: Training Vision-Language Models To Be Your Engaged Partners | 2024-06-20T09:27:33 | 2024-06-20T09:27:33 | Shujin Wu, Yi R. Fung, Sha Li, Yixin Wan, Kai-Wei Chang, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large vision-language models (LVLMs), while proficient in following
instructions and responding to diverse questions, invariably generate detailed
responses even when questions are ambiguous or unanswerable, leading to
hallucinations and bias issues. Thus, it is essential for LVLMs to proactively
engage with humans to ask for clarifications or additional information for
better responses. In this study, we aim to shift LVLMs from passive answer
providers to proactive engaged partners. We begin by establishing a
three-tiered hierarchy for questions of invalid, ambiguous, and personalizable
nature to measure the proactive engagement capabilities of LVLMs. Utilizing
this hierarchy, we create PIE, (ProactIve Engagement Evaluation) through GPT-4o
and human annotators, consisting of 853 questions across six distinct,
fine-grained question types that are verified by human annotators and
accompanied with well-defined metrics. Our evaluations on \benchmark indicate
poor performance of existing LVLMs, with the best-performing open-weights model
only achieving an Aggregate Align Rate (AAR) of 0.28. In response, we introduce
MACAROON, self-iMaginAtion for ContrAstive pReference OptimizatiON, which
instructs LVLMs to autonomously generate contrastive response pairs for
unlabeled questions given the task description and human-crafted criteria.
Then, the self-imagined data is formatted for conditional reinforcement
learning. Experimental results show MACAROON effectively improves LVLMs'
capabilities to be proactively engaged (0.84 AAR) while maintaining comparable
performance on general tasks. | [
-0.6207348704338074,
-0.9699350595474243,
0.4797816574573517,
0.03421471640467644,
-0.11433917284011841,
0.09802573174238205,
-0.09546825289726257,
-0.682314932346344,
0.4953332543373108,
0.6981787085533142,
-0.6686654090881348,
-0.143792062997818,
-0.2736240327358246,
0.13056865334510803,
-0.11302220821380615,
0.9547276496887207,
-0.21775586903095245,
-0.04825456812977791,
-0.1243324726819992,
-0.22364050149917603,
-0.1987123340368271,
-0.2534228265285492,
-0.7690685391426086,
0.10554128140211105,
0.8550097942352295,
0.4747375249862671,
0.7555431723594666,
0.16600880026817322,
0.6228600740432739,
0.38132044672966003,
-0.01218505296856165,
0.3538017272949219,
-0.47377604246139526,
0.18394730985164642,
-0.22772625088691711,
-0.25592678785324097,
-0.5053377747535706,
0.1532868593931198,
0.211289644241333,
0.7182585000991821,
-0.2847767472267151,
0.3080201745033264,
0.09073112905025482,
0.8900410532951355,
-1.044301152229309,
0.01631196029484272,
-0.5208267569541931,
0.3450278341770172,
-0.010853645391762257,
0.1374318152666092,
-0.23886704444885254,
-0.2884785830974579,
0.18091502785682678,
-0.8931917548179626,
-0.04946492239832878,
0.03178519383072853,
0.6122583746910095,
0.30560821294784546,
-0.4353300929069519,
-0.32121577858924866,
-0.5104535222053528,
0.5732808709144592,
-0.5243405699729919,
0.3673267364501953,
0.5570899248123169,
0.2521457374095917,
-0.07035770267248154,
-0.7408864498138428,
-0.5484641790390015,
-0.6018383502960205,
0.01780685782432556,
0.6758426427841187,
-0.10825786739587784,
0.20189034938812256,
0.09871688485145569,
0.3237168490886688,
-0.5947098731994629,
-0.1374143660068512,
-0.18499566614627838,
-0.1280202567577362,
0.7478547096252441,
0.2871665954589844,
0.16159895062446594,
0.06460405886173248,
-0.14166326820850372,
0.11737712472677231,
-0.1269322633743286,
0.4910733103752136,
0.347923219203949,
-0.24201565980911255,
0.018618268892169,
0.8594368100166321,
-0.32094767689704895,
0.5780267715454102,
0.5220078825950623,
0.3274300694465637,
0.10209982097148895,
-0.33392879366874695,
-0.3182302713394165,
-0.013532002456486225,
0.8409947156906128,
0.37148746848106384,
0.32123035192489624,
-0.03938218206167221,
-0.15386143326759338,
0.2156851589679718,
0.6368622183799744,
-0.6830239295959473,
-0.4073984622955322,
0.3043336868286133,
-0.2670269310474396,
-0.5098914504051208,
-0.03152809664607048,
-0.37678462266921997,
-0.1765318661928177,
-0.015725350007414818,
0.40615609288215637,
-0.2481072098016739,
-0.5042596459388733,
0.14604823291301727,
0.14251866936683655,
-0.16888810694217682,
0.43766364455223083,
-1.2881135940551758,
0.5524945855140686,
0.3536054491996765,
0.4901454448699951,
-0.2296043187379837,
-0.20482994616031647,
-0.7359609603881836,
0.21719971299171448,
-0.7674493789672852,
0.4011721611022949,
-0.5953451991081238,
-0.30436575412750244,
-0.05375961586833,
0.07191459089517593,
-0.12928351759910583,
-0.6274108290672302,
0.38842666149139404,
-0.5664462447166443,
0.2979438304901123,
-0.311297208070755,
-0.40288740396499634,
0.061750538647174835,
0.7674337029457092,
-0.617964506149292,
0.9875048995018005,
0.20202702283859253,
-0.9974595904350281,
0.23747414350509644,
-0.8947492241859436,
-0.022305546328425407,
0.24885804951190948,
-0.36650189757347107,
-0.38869786262512207,
0.1008697897195816,
0.5135545134544373,
0.4526137709617615,
0.07935275137424469,
0.16115078330039978,
-0.1614590883255005,
-0.1970483958721161,
0.4106387495994568,
-0.07161705940961838,
0.4150881767272949,
0.03673708438873291,
-0.3225301206111908,
0.450181782245636,
-0.47274523973464966,
-0.17985941469669342,
0.07257106900215149,
-0.30271899700164795,
-0.4369201958179474,
-0.07846354693174362,
-0.17698967456817627,
0.1252177357673645,
0.20118263363838196,
-0.6647870540618896,
0.12430883198976517,
-0.6506227850914001,
0.1347944289445877,
0.8382579684257507,
0.054694704711437225,
0.438618540763855,
-0.02624368853867054,
0.7767874002456665,
0.2755187153816223,
0.5671882033348083,
0.269457072019577,
-0.5104086399078369,
-0.8798587918281555,
-0.007191943470388651,
-0.04817034676671028,
0.32496094703674316,
-1.1414378881454468,
0.019818218424916267,
0.06739161908626556,
-0.348314106464386,
-0.5841169953346252,
0.20081566274166107,
0.33525729179382324,
0.9332892894744873,
0.39905351400375366,
-0.488095760345459,
-0.34237632155418396,
-1.004742980003357,
-0.012608329765498638,
-0.19726714491844177,
0.24399937689304352,
0.5468138456344604,
0.584876537322998,
-0.29232341051101685,
0.9777727723121643,
-0.26455050706863403,
-0.13854622840881348,
-0.4726979434490204,
0.09533144533634186,
0.012158036231994629,
0.47809919714927673,
0.338060587644577,
-1.1148470640182495,
-0.6762637495994568,
0.19821064174175262,
-0.8066239356994629,
0.2415163815021515,
-0.004721364472061396,
-0.07697193324565887,
-0.03657068312168121,
0.3049735426902771,
-0.3554319143295288,
0.35125282406806946,
0.7300227284431458,
-0.16586478054523468,
0.661091148853302,
-0.15977676212787628,
0.18328918516635895,
-0.9414671063423157,
0.02025650069117546,
0.06016049161553383,
-0.22631922364234924,
-0.6383941173553467,
-0.184108704328537,
0.1614576131105423,
-0.31431636214256287,
-0.7000784873962402,
0.7314134240150452,
-0.410246878862381,
-0.168563112616539,
0.035520680248737335,
0.21329231560230255,
-0.2825368642807007,
0.4858085513114929,
0.3622809052467346,
0.9727444052696228,
0.6148110628128052,
-0.669749915599823,
0.48073694109916687,
0.20703119039535522,
-0.3578743636608124,
0.3026282489299774,
-0.7183917760848999,
0.015142402611672878,
-0.017779285088181496,
0.008141892962157726,
-0.8035852313041687,
-0.30234387516975403,
0.5765563249588013,
-0.32693588733673096,
-0.11554175615310669,
0.004461315460503101,
-0.08870254456996918,
-0.34612834453582764,
-0.43883129954338074,
0.7080780863761902,
0.2355019748210907,
-0.4136306941509247,
0.6536490321159363,
0.20599977672100067,
-0.14079494774341583,
-0.8603379726409912,
-0.5689895749092102,
0.12830430269241333,
-0.02637440897524357,
-0.6301274299621582,
0.2729954421520233,
-0.2914574444293976,
-0.21223212778568268,
0.14637044072151184,
-0.10140553116798401,
0.13006170094013214,
0.1862613707780838,
0.18326884508132935,
0.2042788863182068,
-0.056863006204366684,
-0.00809060875326395,
-0.2030688375234604,
-0.2694202959537506,
0.02257625386118889,
-0.07775110751390457,
0.43657824397087097,
-0.2531232237815857,
-0.3415166437625885,
-0.6380804181098938,
0.3813677430152893,
0.3018679916858673,
-0.7297791838645935,
0.6263927817344666,
0.7015158534049988,
0.004209817387163639,
0.13330909609794617,
-0.6891631484031677,
-0.2698400020599365,
-0.5360090136528015,
0.3998003900051117,
-0.5860396027565002,
-1.0668660402297974,
0.46140918135643005,
-0.08141417801380157,
0.023982085287570953,
0.09745260328054428,
0.5046373605728149,
-0.3755606710910797,
1.4053462743759155,
0.7562775015830994,
0.25972703099250793,
0.6817479729652405,
-0.391187459230423,
-0.03969988599419594,
-1.1655454635620117,
-0.23636512458324432,
0.20781099796295166,
-0.3775913119316101,
-0.5591217875480652,
-0.24382005631923676,
0.43109121918678284,
0.21077966690063477,
-0.19357337057590485,
0.1568736433982849,
-0.4494009017944336,
0.3567626178264618,
0.48484766483306885,
0.13912659883499146,
-0.1511974185705185,
-0.38271233439445496,
-0.37823963165283203,
-0.11752123385667801,
-0.6533952355384827,
-0.29996445775032043,
0.8933271765708923,
0.22392690181732178,
0.7077759504318237,
0.2236393392086029,
0.8888493180274963,
-0.01777726598083973,
0.28251734375953674,
-0.7367215752601624,
0.7350194454193115,
0.13729073107242584,
-0.46374112367630005,
-0.40477147698402405,
-0.33724769949913025,
-0.9648395776748657,
0.19613203406333923,
-0.3020499348640442,
-0.8587417006492615,
0.36335429549217224,
0.37107008695602417,
-0.2682574987411499,
0.035442788153886795,
-0.42597779631614685,
1.2007839679718018,
-0.5094471573829651,
-0.6690848469734192,
-0.2308167666196823,
-0.6162847876548767,
0.44636836647987366,
0.07662907242774963,
0.06885414570569992,
-0.06157020851969719,
-0.24021396040916443,
0.6905090808868408,
-0.1712067425251007,
0.7524721622467041,
0.03513636440038681,
0.09186163544654846,
0.07644112408161163,
0.5066558122634888,
0.6460971832275391,
0.2671367824077606,
-0.061685968190431595,
-0.23475299775600433,
-0.31003543734550476,
-0.3700439929962158,
-0.8151912689208984,
0.4508291482925415,
-0.71722012758255,
-0.7153346538543701,
-0.36969730257987976,
-0.46828293800354004,
-0.4072072505950928,
-0.1032014936208725,
0.041119858622550964,
0.3961513638496399,
-0.20885448157787323,
0.17101912200450897,
0.583235502243042,
0.06424442678689957,
0.5129029750823975,
0.4493989944458008,
-0.29071131348609924,
-0.5285962820053101,
0.5485792756080627,
-0.2136785387992859,
0.4797195494174957,
0.28121358156204224,
0.3175232708454132,
-0.17422796785831451,
-0.47181248664855957,
-0.43334707617759705,
0.2718549072742462,
-0.5221917033195496,
0.21533676981925964,
-0.7396621704101562,
0.032042328268289566,
-0.34854912757873535,
-0.4347572922706604,
-0.5779217481613159,
-0.2158176600933075,
-0.3474161624908447,
-0.18103007972240448,
-0.12461686879396439,
0.5200539231300354,
-0.19438554346561432,
-0.08173730969429016,
-0.63092041015625,
0.3319069445133209,
0.7192510366439819,
-0.049741826951503754,
-0.038133855909109116,
-0.15894965827465057,
-0.44298985600471497,
0.1391008347272873,
-0.2505403757095337,
-0.9220036864280701,
0.4548925757408142,
0.025009972974658012,
0.8024928569793701,
0.5631810426712036,
0.16276484727859497,
0.8115901947021484,
-0.40456053614616394,
0.9988495707511902,
0.5127441883087158,
-0.8807543516159058,
0.9966862201690674,
-0.08037172257900238,
0.03325127437710762,
0.6436623930931091,
0.6528514623641968,
-0.5508923530578613,
-0.5725728869438171,
-0.6217532753944397,
-0.6455371975898743,
0.6222772002220154,
0.38219940662384033,
0.08607625216245651,
-0.31977835297584534,
0.45887285470962524,
-0.20119863748550415,
0.23555192351341248,
-1.0942143201828003,
-0.01355395931750536,
-0.3495139181613922,
-0.20728464424610138,
-0.11789264529943466,
-0.34930679202079773,
-0.29523134231567383,
-0.25182852149009705,
0.4567290246486664,
-0.2681950032711029,
0.015666216611862183,
0.4260280728340149,
-0.03506540507078171,
-0.07459670305252075,
0.12069972604513168,
0.6809702515602112,
0.6749728322029114,
-0.3264717161655426,
0.2585461437702179,
0.16671966016292572,
-0.5426124334335327,
0.0027034326922148466,
-0.35204169154167175,
0.1903090924024582,
-0.37360966205596924,
0.41483020782470703,
0.7488086819648743,
0.09733083844184875,
-0.7827773690223694,
0.5153388977050781,
-0.3066340982913971,
-0.18869216740131378,
-0.24926109611988068,
0.41837483644485474,
0.0370490662753582,
0.28086814284324646,
-0.01566140167415142,
0.026206692680716515,
0.20198793709278107,
-0.9066490530967712,
0.012004194781184196,
0.5482437610626221,
-0.8615880608558655,
-0.15956716239452362,
0.7401659488677979,
0.5249609351158142,
-0.48380202054977417,
0.4342310428619385,
-0.23938868939876556,
-0.6121209859848022,
0.4965035319328308,
0.3958694040775299,
0.8581132292747498,
-0.2831772267818451,
0.41985952854156494,
0.27569323778152466,
0.2011619359254837,
0.16226860880851746,
0.1558075249195099,
-0.5440375804901123,
-1.0401380062103271,
-0.21101601421833038,
-0.28062835335731506,
-0.5223861336708069,
-0.11801076680421829,
-0.7786599397659302,
-0.08753492683172226,
-0.24143972992897034,
-0.181566521525383,
-0.1511925756931305,
0.10638884454965591,
-0.4134436249732971,
0.34094569087028503,
-0.058599282056093216,
0.5754642486572266,
-0.5965506434440613,
0.8209353685379028,
0.9511781334877014,
-0.8003348708152771,
-0.7397249937057495,
-0.01219927053898573,
-0.14253206551074982,
-0.8252631425857544,
1.179384708404541,
0.1345597356557846,
-0.35322192311286926,
-0.011002822779119015,
-0.43968984484672546,
-0.6359900832176208,
1.1370810270309448,
0.1462852656841278,
-0.6796408295631409,
0.09925273805856705,
0.14338679611682892,
0.3817421793937683,
-0.5845094919204712,
0.5086709260940552,
0.22492341697216034,
0.1773904711008072,
0.2426135092973709,
-1.017270803451538,
-0.3236408531665802,
-0.35179591178894043,
0.11389525234699249,
0.11515310406684875,
-0.5501559972763062,
0.8000133633613586,
-0.36266812682151794,
0.011600746773183346,
0.0031324641313403845,
0.4898861050605774,
0.22505538165569305,
0.29064759612083435,
0.6592714786529541,
0.4309544265270233,
0.6143738627433777,
0.15655319392681122,
1.0436378717422485,
-0.20679572224617004,
0.2454780489206314,
0.9943925142288208,
-0.39243757724761963,
1.0681660175323486,
0.753876268863678,
0.2821604311466217,
0.40556439757347107,
0.7533836364746094,
0.26168256998062134,
0.7545115351676941,
-0.029431737959384918,
-0.37297263741493225,
-0.6151338815689087,
-0.09135868400335312,
-0.23129622638225555,
0.41001540422439575,
0.23353023827075958,
-0.18250730633735657,
0.13484740257263184,
0.3441702127456665,
-0.3094848096370697,
0.1280905157327652,
-0.4241536557674408,
0.9807763695716858,
-0.12738823890686035,
-0.6962165236473083,
0.3352280855178833,
-0.293416827917099,
0.5270169377326965,
-0.6121993064880371,
0.03133077546954155,
-0.5088972449302673,
0.24960875511169434,
-0.033260419964790344,
-0.8675692081451416,
0.017017632722854614,
-0.15835745632648468,
0.06139461696147919,
0.012187030166387558,
0.46938443183898926,
-0.3160676658153534,
-0.6087445020675659,
0.3236304819583893,
0.31791675090789795,
0.06833723932504654,
0.07100622355937958,
-1.048551321029663,
0.04963883385062218,
0.07026287913322449,
-0.48143547773361206,
0.19991829991340637,
0.16353774070739746,
0.04100678861141205,
1.1172189712524414,
0.7277589440345764,
0.17162419855594635,
-0.1449403464794159,
0.1703135222196579,
0.9048096537590027,
-0.5010227560997009,
-0.5621724128723145,
-0.6600549221038818,
0.8908380270004272,
-0.3278389573097229,
-0.4266975224018097,
0.7189379930496216,
0.5049154758453369,
0.8029600977897644,
-0.04427085071802139,
0.3581973910331726,
0.2746824026107788,
0.24530664086341858,
-0.6121702790260315,
0.3388574719429016,
-0.8070432543754578,
0.2965317964553833,
-0.3137943148612976,
-0.9670848250389099,
-0.08795962482690811,
0.9564238786697388,
-0.42103463411331177,
-0.05436556041240692,
0.5771695375442505,
0.7433956861495972,
-0.14121511578559875,
-0.11687962710857391,
0.5794901847839355,
-0.05791502818465233,
0.5363447666168213,
0.681413471698761,
1.2305389642715454,
-0.22337287664413452,
0.3682306706905365,
-0.5662564635276794,
-0.20098593831062317,
-0.3452483117580414,
-0.6492263674736023,
-1.0468825101852417,
-0.6413238644599915,
-0.5538880825042725,
0.059343062341213226,
0.3089108467102051,
0.820358395576477,
0.8487752079963684,
-0.5529491901397705,
-0.3805735111236572,
-0.3999009430408478,
-0.19330666959285736,
-0.24520626664161682,
-0.18091700971126556,
0.3086535334587097,
-0.44782736897468567,
-0.5774694085121155,
0.35932454466819763,
0.556647002696991,
0.10076868534088135,
-0.47097140550613403,
-0.2991617023944855,
-0.18925391137599945,
0.05544615164399147,
0.6945366859436035,
0.15382175147533417,
-0.8659511208534241,
-0.307617723941803,
0.07720423489809036,
-0.03932224586606026,
0.09735580533742905,
0.6760414838790894,
-0.8667845129966736,
0.6883839964866638,
0.008454236201941967,
0.5985756516456604,
0.8592756986618042,
0.09439754486083984,
0.36363720893859863,
-0.49288731813430786,
0.25790244340896606,
0.7253718972206116,
0.23618744313716888,
0.1367933452129364,
-0.3187907040119171,
0.6322702765464783,
0.011121164076030254,
-0.6525740027427673,
-0.676443338394165,
0.46032753586769104,
-1.098879098892212,
-0.19564925134181976,
0.9852778315544128,
-0.10885307192802429,
-0.10464290529489517,
-0.11000452190637589,
-0.5384454727172852,
-0.032395780086517334,
-0.12400474399328232,
0.7107808589935303,
0.46002328395843506,
-0.5903542637825012,
-0.6559581756591797,
-0.5065186023712158,
0.6932346820831299,
0.6882999539375305,
-0.8811724781990051,
-0.09491392970085144,
0.3569384515285492,
0.09557421505451202,
0.19094833731651306,
0.7332876920700073,
0.25006189942359924,
0.4868341386318207,
-0.06423359364271164,
0.09129472821950912,
-0.2840036153793335,
-0.2553449869155884,
0.05751306191086769,
0.09767422825098038,
0.09707759320735931,
-0.4295278787612915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14129v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14129v1 | Towards Event-oriented Long Video Understanding | 2024-06-20T09:14:19 | 2024-06-20T09:14:19 | Yifan Du, Kun Zhou, Yuqi Huo, Yifan Li, Wayne Xin Zhao, Haoyu Lu, Zijia Zhao, Bingning Wang, Weipeng Chen, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM | With the rapid development of video Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs),
numerous benchmarks have been proposed to assess their video understanding
capability. However, due to the lack of rich events in the videos, these
datasets may suffer from the short-cut bias that the answers can be deduced
from a few frames, without the need to watch the entire video. To address this
issue, we introduce Event-Bench, an event-oriented long video understanding
benchmark built on existing datasets and human annotations. Event-Bench
includes six event-related tasks and 2,190 test instances to comprehensively
evaluate video event understanding ability. Additionally, we propose Video
Instruction Merging~(VIM), a cost-effective method that enhances video MLLMs
using merged, event-intensive video instructions, addressing the scarcity of
human-annotated, event-intensive data. Extensive experiments show that the
best-performing model, GPT-4o, achieves an overall accuracy of 53.33,
significantly outperforming the best open-source model by 41.42%. Leveraging an
effective instruction synthesis method and an adaptive model architecture, VIM
surpasses both state-of-the-art open-source models and GPT-4V on the
Event-Bench. All code, data, and models are publicly available at
https://github.com/RUCAIBox/Event-Bench. | [
-0.42443346977233887,
-0.657504141330719,
0.6249634623527527,
0.22734574973583221,
-0.5466004610061646,
-0.24003739655017853,
-0.5658210515975952,
-0.3805861473083496,
-0.39431649446487427,
0.39219775795936584,
-0.7761714458465576,
-0.5991834998130798,
-0.5888615250587463,
-0.3886222839355469,
-0.6065521240234375,
0.8792503476142883,
-0.3671388626098633,
0.0634707510471344,
-0.31686827540397644,
-0.4473421573638916,
-0.2441524714231491,
-0.44619113206863403,
-0.4366280734539032,
-0.23307599127292633,
0.24057407677173615,
0.23482082784175873,
0.3700893223285675,
1.0031858682632446,
0.5325968265533447,
0.25134530663490295,
0.05694441497325897,
0.20119068026542664,
-0.44561767578125,
-0.1929941475391388,
-0.14720693230628967,
-0.34053897857666016,
-0.48507577180862427,
-0.17522700130939484,
0.7147719860076904,
0.5243768692016602,
-0.0750100240111351,
0.391814649105072,
0.07747992873191833,
0.6634727120399475,
-0.8971970677375793,
0.23407423496246338,
-0.4217117726802826,
0.2655335068702698,
-0.2584543824195862,
-0.09695831686258316,
-0.4150245785713196,
0.09798240661621094,
-0.0741170197725296,
-0.6142598986625671,
0.5519416332244873,
-0.3790326714515686,
0.5831542611122131,
0.5420292615890503,
-0.28079384565353394,
0.40340402722358704,
-0.777586817741394,
0.7517957091331482,
-0.34988096356391907,
0.8481497764587402,
0.5315225720405579,
0.6190282702445984,
-0.08359168469905853,
-0.6173714399337769,
-0.4617026150226593,
0.31386491656303406,
0.36917489767074585,
0.18040700256824493,
-0.02853318676352501,
0.21941739320755005,
0.3332160711288452,
-0.04641227051615715,
-0.8514515161514282,
0.24134673178195953,
-0.16573308408260345,
0.3280399739742279,
0.6499089002609253,
0.2823856770992279,
0.08447099477052689,
-0.2772381007671356,
-0.46648719906806946,
-0.19493618607521057,
-0.3735196888446808,
0.13166385889053345,
0.056376222521066666,
-0.11151358485221863,
-0.2489195466041565,
0.3678101897239685,
-0.2295282781124115,
0.840721845626831,
-0.32501134276390076,
-0.11927065998315811,
0.18231365084648132,
-0.4995955526828766,
-0.7241166830062866,
-0.04377666860818863,
0.506585419178009,
0.693077564239502,
0.27342599630355835,
-0.08320306986570358,
0.040317852050065994,
0.08135558664798737,
0.17018955945968628,
-1.0681673288345337,
-0.23515206575393677,
0.16607145965099335,
-0.5399779081344604,
0.07828651368618011,
0.03871867060661316,
-0.8255038857460022,
-0.5558120012283325,
-0.41052567958831787,
0.39549997448921204,
-0.3378092646598816,
0.041927769780159,
0.04917388781905174,
-0.2419196516275406,
0.3657587766647339,
0.6755791902542114,
-0.6058892011642456,
0.25693029165267944,
0.7799727916717529,
0.5935704112052917,
-0.25890791416168213,
-0.5461022853851318,
-1.1998704671859741,
0.33863696455955505,
-0.186219722032547,
0.41741815209388733,
-0.3806360065937042,
-0.10478872060775757,
-0.018098074942827225,
0.16904841363430023,
0.07954440265893936,
-0.35732951760292053,
0.4435749650001526,
-0.3718085289001465,
-0.09596652537584305,
0.08407788723707199,
-0.4888060986995697,
-0.317940354347229,
0.27287596464157104,
-0.4808257818222046,
0.8682441115379333,
-0.27440953254699707,
-0.19375035166740417,
0.5888058543205261,
-0.5572746396064758,
-0.31396061182022095,
-0.19838236272335052,
-0.3888234496116638,
-0.3793179988861084,
0.08320268243551254,
0.5661098957061768,
0.4533393085002899,
-0.18610621988773346,
0.35692813992500305,
-0.5368031859397888,
-0.3147704005241394,
0.24251200258731842,
-0.6227493286132812,
0.015024581924080849,
-0.09815024584531784,
-0.48670557141304016,
-0.00773602956905961,
-1.006389856338501,
-0.16182763874530792,
-0.20401880145072937,
0.0951945036649704,
-0.12018893659114838,
0.2514469027519226,
0.062110405415296555,
0.1715633124113083,
-0.05861429125070572,
-0.32779258489608765,
0.019461000338196754,
0.11072094738483429,
0.32848814129829407,
0.8668335676193237,
-0.11665832251310349,
0.4392835795879364,
0.18539559841156006,
0.4073173701763153,
-0.026118721812963486,
0.5372613668441772,
-0.538143515586853,
-0.39314770698547363,
-0.5769158005714417,
-0.13425183296203613,
-0.20105378329753876,
0.19551044702529907,
-0.401084303855896,
-0.012152626179158688,
-0.3199777603149414,
-0.12871208786964417,
-0.46693480014801025,
0.5622116327285767,
0.46465426683425903,
0.3666405975818634,
0.6204147338867188,
-0.48466402292251587,
-0.607617199420929,
-0.7155619859695435,
-0.18342682719230652,
-0.15520349144935608,
0.0021057608537375927,
0.40034419298171997,
0.2806984484195709,
-0.06833577156066895,
0.660394012928009,
-0.3921160101890564,
-0.19740235805511475,
0.040944334119558334,
0.5299246907234192,
0.14740890264511108,
0.13856038451194763,
0.45079824328422546,
-0.7757080793380737,
-0.3722119927406311,
0.3320769667625427,
-0.9464454054832458,
0.3157874643802643,
-0.08576463907957077,
0.07085196673870087,
0.18303647637367249,
0.48711565136909485,
-0.42778798937797546,
1.002180814743042,
0.48209014534950256,
-0.24249425530433655,
0.3059695065021515,
-0.18453699350357056,
0.492546021938324,
-0.6812046766281128,
-0.11762417107820511,
0.0131813520565629,
-0.34123122692108154,
-0.4543983042240143,
-0.048127032816410065,
0.19607576727867126,
-0.23886381089687347,
-0.6181555390357971,
0.4147966206073761,
-0.38806214928627014,
-0.5048468708992004,
-0.4265289902687073,
0.29245853424072266,
0.1908666342496872,
0.5144548416137695,
0.2452712059020996,
0.4704087972640991,
0.3720302879810333,
-0.4362480342388153,
0.4705137312412262,
0.1335388422012329,
-0.7000411152839661,
0.40364837646484375,
-0.24843409657478333,
-0.020273249596357346,
-0.3191865086555481,
0.22208721935749054,
-0.8627787828445435,
-0.5539110898971558,
-0.23168648779392242,
-0.3625235855579376,
0.26596498489379883,
-0.8305323719978333,
-0.08633636683225632,
-0.2640899121761322,
-0.17666837573051453,
0.4139793813228607,
0.5822088122367859,
-0.7927114367485046,
0.622369110584259,
0.05739111825823784,
-0.12601006031036377,
-0.858683705329895,
-0.7984321117401123,
0.09457649290561676,
-0.20384547114372253,
-0.8333866000175476,
0.35232484340667725,
-0.024857638403773308,
-0.17870481312274933,
0.04130403324961662,
-0.2614280879497528,
-0.3936799168586731,
-0.17977102100849152,
0.4541829526424408,
0.18953421711921692,
-0.3875366449356079,
0.3251185119152069,
-0.3881170153617859,
0.10949093848466873,
0.022316034883260727,
-0.1131812036037445,
0.2234513908624649,
0.13614429533481598,
-0.6806959509849548,
-0.807141125202179,
0.4530182480812073,
0.7204597592353821,
-0.3454141616821289,
0.44172823429107666,
1.0819971561431885,
-0.39672309160232544,
-0.12416137009859085,
-0.7221801280975342,
-0.04246162623167038,
-0.36312639713287354,
0.7703812718391418,
-0.161032572388649,
-0.5846728086471558,
0.49289143085479736,
0.24721373617649078,
0.007448667194694281,
0.028475407510995865,
0.4013175070285797,
-0.3563074469566345,
1.060500979423523,
0.4190080463886261,
0.02644527703523636,
0.8820157647132874,
-0.21642464399337769,
-0.16002309322357178,
-0.6080300211906433,
-0.1669209897518158,
-0.19115884602069855,
-0.38631612062454224,
-0.09967411309480667,
-0.9591076374053955,
0.312463641166687,
0.2630580961704254,
-0.3391197621822357,
0.12891364097595215,
-0.1362134963274002,
0.6997291445732117,
0.06389512866735458,
0.15036450326442719,
0.2162853330373764,
-0.23444819450378418,
0.6842421293258667,
-0.11386623978614807,
-0.5768164992332458,
-0.08393774181604385,
0.9567465782165527,
0.30829480290412903,
0.8604966998100281,
0.08904099464416504,
0.6121886372566223,
0.0853021889925003,
0.1278138905763626,
-0.3955421447753906,
0.3996671438217163,
-0.22005563974380493,
-0.3492681086063385,
-0.3677734136581421,
-0.3298870921134949,
-0.7717986702919006,
0.1262260228395462,
-0.005229517351835966,
-1.0125548839569092,
0.14353322982788086,
0.11283048242330551,
-0.30532369017601013,
0.34489044547080994,
-0.8296055793762207,
1.3300423622131348,
-0.4277045428752899,
-0.809646725654602,
-0.5064972043037415,
-0.5059257745742798,
0.4853602349758148,
0.07784432917833328,
0.5721533298492432,
-0.15968400239944458,
-0.009115438908338547,
0.7270458340644836,
-0.4805656969547272,
0.695716142654419,
-0.2476644217967987,
0.4027085304260254,
0.4177890121936798,
-0.13777340948581696,
0.7955070734024048,
0.2665972411632538,
0.2259625792503357,
-0.36836427450180054,
-0.24783112108707428,
-0.33333325386047363,
-0.9950625896453857,
0.6529794931411743,
-0.8236493468284607,
-0.4867221713066101,
0.08434673398733139,
-0.32709652185440063,
-0.0373835451900959,
-0.25632864236831665,
-0.1925612986087799,
0.8001004457473755,
-0.28438225388526917,
0.3416258990764618,
0.6808369755744934,
-0.11475241184234619,
0.6899478435516357,
0.6041514873504639,
-0.3187926411628723,
-0.4565041661262512,
0.7297295331954956,
-0.18783757090568542,
0.13477852940559387,
0.4375549554824829,
-0.21627017855644226,
-0.039225541055202484,
-0.6361487507820129,
-0.729184091091156,
-0.16131852567195892,
-0.8088815808296204,
-0.14854030311107635,
-0.5723282098770142,
0.047383151948451996,
-0.1552981734275818,
-0.2133307307958603,
-0.6532489061355591,
-0.21761515736579895,
-0.26719802618026733,
-0.394898921251297,
0.5180099010467529,
0.4647389054298401,
-0.047782208770513535,
0.24643033742904663,
-1.1177597045898438,
0.45356184244155884,
0.701454758644104,
0.5217811465263367,
0.04334971681237221,
-0.59874427318573,
-0.4475244879722595,
-0.2859576940536499,
-0.2580036520957947,
-0.8515946865081787,
0.21231898665428162,
0.307437002658844,
0.5196974873542786,
0.6596182584762573,
-0.2650505304336548,
1.242436170578003,
-0.49267879128456116,
0.8102995157241821,
0.4024907350540161,
-0.9342185854911804,
0.7051981091499329,
-0.3537949025630951,
0.3193787932395935,
0.5648569464683533,
0.2973331809043884,
-0.4394265115261078,
-0.020585063844919205,
-0.5357964038848877,
-0.7974008917808533,
0.8419612646102905,
0.25998857617378235,
-0.25101199746131897,
0.19153355062007904,
0.11751458793878555,
0.07728399336338043,
-0.03816407173871994,
-0.6010676026344299,
0.08880635350942612,
-0.23270659148693085,
0.050792545080184937,
-0.44031062722206116,
0.08274850249290466,
-0.16725394129753113,
-0.2929868698120117,
0.47584646940231323,
-0.06666050851345062,
-0.05683523789048195,
0.08692137897014618,
-0.5254485607147217,
-0.26244884729385376,
0.3391721546649933,
0.5180044770240784,
0.9399056434631348,
-0.6087008118629456,
0.14573365449905396,
0.40224531292915344,
-0.3701677620410919,
0.09355485439300537,
0.349601686000824,
0.4524765908718109,
0.013429143466055393,
0.5413179397583008,
1.0610779523849487,
0.49508658051490784,
-0.8183432221412659,
0.7459740042686462,
-0.1349940150976181,
-0.06955855339765549,
-0.11434458196163177,
0.05028572306036949,
-0.08617956936359406,
0.43557867407798767,
0.3258374333381653,
-0.2373250275850296,
0.11717692017555237,
-0.7644129991531372,
0.501115620136261,
0.1885925680398941,
-0.6467271447181702,
-0.41199809312820435,
0.6992652416229248,
0.4491192102432251,
-0.22347943484783173,
0.693382740020752,
-0.12778827548027039,
-0.40181678533554077,
0.6747300624847412,
0.03990061208605766,
0.7734882235527039,
-0.013610269874334335,
0.06304207444190979,
0.40525850653648376,
0.16838005185127258,
0.01992258056998253,
0.19569624960422516,
-0.3719708025455475,
-0.3022579252719879,
-1.0308641195297241,
-0.588461697101593,
-0.35909900069236755,
0.2708160877227783,
-0.9099505543708801,
0.45171159505844116,
-0.005603746976703405,
-0.06820018589496613,
0.19646278023719788,
-0.26887908577919006,
-0.8870730996131897,
0.15758752822875977,
0.4339044392108917,
0.945580244064331,
-0.906234622001648,
0.9246900677680969,
0.6310028433799744,
-0.27532315254211426,
-0.350857138633728,
-0.48641669750213623,
-0.042275141924619675,
-0.5662024617195129,
0.5069732666015625,
0.22194558382034302,
0.3881398141384125,
-0.4288026988506317,
-0.18655098974704742,
-0.4766620397567749,
1.1297924518585205,
0.1609111875295639,
-0.6607577800750732,
0.002126815263181925,
0.04375770315527916,
0.29728665947914124,
-0.13093586266040802,
0.3690392076969147,
0.679081380367279,
0.5540152192115784,
-0.009908105246722698,
-0.8637341856956482,
-0.4732552170753479,
-0.054308656603097916,
-0.313284307718277,
0.6140128970146179,
-0.3973427712917328,
0.5893518924713135,
-0.1862228661775589,
0.06246156990528107,
-0.04831337556242943,
0.8056158423423767,
-0.03449093922972679,
0.833482027053833,
0.41156142950057983,
0.6662651300430298,
0.4633878767490387,
-0.042489659041166306,
0.9330601692199707,
0.07015758007764816,
0.19990842044353485,
1.560393214225769,
-0.09244341403245926,
0.8031257390975952,
0.5211823582649231,
-0.3393268585205078,
0.3049565255641937,
0.48535260558128357,
0.11425627768039703,
0.43298137187957764,
-0.07517553120851517,
-0.291948139667511,
-0.7745975255966187,
0.09559090435504913,
-0.4097782075405121,
0.7170824408531189,
0.2832357883453369,
-0.4433874189853668,
-0.4275996685028076,
0.31848201155662537,
-0.48381349444389343,
-0.05502541735768318,
-0.6209261417388916,
0.8980706930160522,
0.007366908248513937,
-0.719630777835846,
0.3535363972187042,
-0.27543631196022034,
0.12407033145427704,
-0.7454240918159485,
-0.07347814738750458,
-0.09644421935081482,
0.4398493468761444,
-0.18660181760787964,
-0.9814459085464478,
0.11642411351203918,
0.5332384705543518,
-0.3358462452888489,
-0.08174864202737808,
0.49055707454681396,
-0.5234392881393433,
-0.14779821038246155,
0.353967547416687,
0.34324315190315247,
0.3374108076095581,
-0.16537204384803772,
-0.3169279992580414,
0.5321091413497925,
-0.13761745393276215,
-0.10339445620775223,
0.7603957653045654,
0.4449060261249542,
-0.1914062201976776,
0.3876035511493683,
0.28375738859176636,
-0.4894300699234009,
0.008299903012812138,
0.34659507870674133,
0.6050710082054138,
-0.7047948241233826,
-0.41741427779197693,
-0.9513823986053467,
0.612389087677002,
-0.20604094862937927,
-0.16377653181552887,
0.4175640940666199,
0.633703351020813,
0.8361923694610596,
-0.009256319142878056,
0.7039303779602051,
0.32245248556137085,
-0.13599710166454315,
-0.4942866265773773,
0.33387571573257446,
-0.6162832379341125,
-0.24895967543125153,
-0.235712468624115,
-0.7581756711006165,
-0.08789028972387314,
0.2278708964586258,
-0.2604373097419739,
-0.28772908449172974,
0.39715370535850525,
0.4869232177734375,
-0.4185141921043396,
0.29463768005371094,
0.38710418343544006,
0.07277810573577881,
0.2898319363594055,
0.7361484169960022,
0.9204113483428955,
-0.40112781524658203,
0.911142110824585,
-0.279720664024353,
-0.4507707357406616,
-0.5286057591438293,
-1.0776232481002808,
-0.9393845796585083,
-0.4983448088169098,
-0.3054283857345581,
-0.02896539494395256,
0.540912926197052,
0.8575313687324524,
0.9879069924354553,
-0.4627978205680847,
-0.2835867404937744,
0.05479147657752037,
0.08233806490898132,
-0.3703884184360504,
-0.17154133319854736,
0.45672422647476196,
-0.18619520962238312,
-0.7257216572761536,
0.5953602194786072,
0.4847234785556793,
-0.10686745494604111,
0.048749860376119614,
-0.14871424436569214,
-0.07302346080541611,
-0.12461157888174057,
0.7224988341331482,
0.4346897602081299,
-0.5596920251846313,
-0.5097083449363708,
-0.2155630886554718,
0.243434876203537,
0.13384227454662323,
0.8130556344985962,
-0.7054458260536194,
0.8745213150978088,
0.4696631133556366,
0.81512051820755,
1.284020185470581,
-0.005915569607168436,
0.6289441585540771,
-0.889040470123291,
0.2909988462924957,
-0.07533230632543564,
0.5881754159927368,
0.31168362498283386,
-0.06949310749769211,
0.7265726327896118,
0.10034789144992828,
-0.49111324548721313,
-1.051055908203125,
0.21850159764289856,
-1.259874939918518,
-0.17623679339885712,
0.9934927225112915,
-0.16031023859977722,
-0.4424106478691101,
0.2112133949995041,
0.11026263236999512,
0.49506282806396484,
-0.10199153423309326,
0.6287309527397156,
0.7361714839935303,
-0.40046608448028564,
-0.4107600450515747,
-0.757267951965332,
0.40691864490509033,
0.2758616507053375,
-0.8021100759506226,
0.4373387396335602,
0.3557364046573639,
-0.011190662160515785,
-0.2412312924861908,
0.2954173982143402,
0.08139157295227051,
0.9494331479072571,
-0.16511419415473938,
0.2582338750362396,
-0.3005787134170532,
-0.5631284117698669,
-0.33084020018577576,
0.07360769063234329,
-0.19646421074867249,
-0.40768909454345703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14117v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14117v1 | An Investigation of Prompt Variations for Zero-shot LLM-based Rankers | 2024-06-20T09:03:18 | 2024-06-20T09:03:18 | Shuoqi Sun, Shengyao Zhuang, Shuai Wang, Guido Zuccon | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | We provide a systematic understanding of the impact of specific components
and wordings used in prompts on the effectiveness of rankers based on zero-shot
Large Language Models (LLMs). Several zero-shot ranking methods based on LLMs
have recently been proposed. Among many aspects, methods differ across (1) the
ranking algorithm they implement, e.g., pointwise vs. listwise, (2) the
backbone LLMs used, e.g., GPT3.5 vs. FLAN-T5, (3) the components and wording
used in prompts, e.g., the use or not of role-definition (role-playing) and the
actual words used to express this. It is currently unclear whether performance
differences are due to the underlying ranking algorithm, or because of spurious
factors such as better choice of words used in prompts. This confusion risks to
undermine future research. Through our large-scale experimentation and
analysis, we find that ranking algorithms do contribute to differences between
methods for zero-shot LLM ranking. However, so do the LLM backbones -- but even
more importantly, the choice of prompt components and wordings affect the
ranking. In fact, in our experiments, we find that, at times, these latter
elements have more impact on the ranker's effectiveness than the actual ranking
algorithms, and that differences among ranking methods become more blurred when
prompt variations are considered. | [
-0.21109752357006073,
-0.7660830616950989,
0.8414003252983093,
0.30416008830070496,
-0.10510227084159851,
0.08684077113866806,
-0.015673821792006493,
-0.5130912661552429,
0.34230729937553406,
0.3248520791530609,
-0.4909834861755371,
-0.5301951169967651,
-0.817638635635376,
0.7108139395713806,
0.18966516852378845,
0.9230291247367859,
0.02224535122513771,
0.18631188571453094,
-0.044916801154613495,
-0.1995532363653183,
-1.0920705795288086,
-0.4393295347690582,
-0.4906211793422699,
-0.3102588355541229,
1.3188574314117432,
0.7666296362876892,
0.617256224155426,
0.6572006344795227,
0.4143626391887665,
0.2128646969795227,
-0.3024541437625885,
-0.43863269686698914,
-0.6701178550720215,
0.7173197269439697,
-0.13114063441753387,
-0.9410886168479919,
-0.21865622699260712,
0.41744768619537354,
0.6096900105476379,
0.6900535225868225,
0.14865262806415558,
0.15256066620349884,
-0.03067563846707344,
0.26909947395324707,
-0.8125035762786865,
-0.021625138819217682,
-0.5683844089508057,
0.10571197420358658,
-0.30784642696380615,
-0.6294007301330566,
-0.5251201391220093,
-0.22161278128623962,
0.08183126896619797,
-0.29620689153671265,
0.21911653876304626,
0.0650569349527359,
0.6625064611434937,
0.09403075277805328,
-0.41336745023727417,
-0.2640085220336914,
-0.5905712842941284,
0.9711437821388245,
-0.7161308526992798,
-0.13717900216579437,
0.07592958211898804,
0.4070122539997101,
-0.1595713049173355,
-0.1423301249742508,
-0.22945211827754974,
-0.3522399067878723,
0.054171305149793625,
0.21929393708705902,
0.0877472460269928,
0.31853586435317993,
0.6191454529762268,
0.5073174238204956,
-0.5579419732093811,
0.7536863684654236,
-0.14147275686264038,
-0.03239625319838524,
0.47836726903915405,
0.3970333933830261,
0.3677067458629608,
-0.41776174306869507,
-0.08828442543745041,
0.0072000958025455475,
-1.030008316040039,
0.5636028051376343,
0.31696581840515137,
0.6948807835578918,
0.10743147879838943,
0.8388855457305908,
-0.5716550946235657,
0.6848794221878052,
0.2235708087682724,
-0.14285346865653992,
-0.138262078166008,
-0.023632237687706947,
-0.27290773391723633,
0.2537802755832672,
0.48755204677581787,
0.6588651537895203,
-0.14341801404953003,
-0.0954432487487793,
-0.4075085520744324,
-0.07180145382881165,
-0.05348505079746246,
-0.9969522953033447,
0.0930337905883789,
0.11963469535112381,
-0.2136136144399643,
-0.5599985122680664,
0.03213421255350113,
-0.4497297406196594,
-0.8059985637664795,
-0.15509144961833954,
0.8890269994735718,
0.004747598897665739,
0.326385498046875,
-0.20893363654613495,
-0.3737121522426605,
0.7380409836769104,
0.4924926161766052,
-0.7894212007522583,
-0.11434967070817947,
0.698426365852356,
0.8909579515457153,
-0.4691595733165741,
-0.3530825972557068,
-0.9147824048995972,
-0.3802559971809387,
-0.5111706256866455,
0.8236175775527954,
-0.8415234088897705,
-0.8111429810523987,
0.15591731667518616,
0.06163374334573746,
-0.2774038016796112,
-0.4874859154224396,
0.487965852022171,
-0.3930782079696655,
0.42483383417129517,
-0.8275604844093323,
-0.6865896582603455,
0.07307705283164978,
0.16403277218341827,
-0.477643758058548,
0.9260818958282471,
-0.12863047420978546,
-0.39483463764190674,
0.6257665753364563,
-0.4463624358177185,
-0.25301510095596313,
0.37566351890563965,
-0.37152549624443054,
0.030539831146597862,
0.4314799904823303,
0.07994246482849121,
0.4860658645629883,
-0.2610013484954834,
-0.22661153972148895,
-0.11815707385540009,
-0.9266546964645386,
0.4298980236053467,
-0.4241199195384979,
0.6333694458007812,
-0.11184784770011902,
-0.5116711258888245,
0.18857574462890625,
-0.4587422013282776,
-0.16121919453144073,
0.05954012647271156,
-0.2021075189113617,
-0.09014075249433517,
-0.2396210879087448,
-0.38241153955459595,
0.12534046173095703,
0.1134829968214035,
-0.6362920999526978,
0.48911288380622864,
-0.29448962211608887,
0.044494468718767166,
0.8643519282341003,
0.4565275013446808,
0.4299059510231018,
-0.6799274682998657,
0.9611159563064575,
-0.2147289663553238,
0.25410306453704834,
-0.6126226186752319,
-0.8478622436523438,
-0.7720280885696411,
-0.2875638008117676,
0.3563457429409027,
0.7789374589920044,
-0.572860598564148,
0.22871699929237366,
0.1315452754497528,
-0.5212334394454956,
-0.5361589193344116,
-0.14671099185943604,
0.3753872215747833,
0.42164346575737,
0.24469386041164398,
-0.25327977538108826,
-0.06892537325620651,
-0.7135351300239563,
-0.41083964705467224,
-0.15009362995624542,
0.02953260764479637,
0.5837945342063904,
0.15784680843353271,
0.26928260922431946,
0.9912104606628418,
-0.5662159323692322,
0.03187901899218559,
-0.5167361497879028,
0.38048550486564636,
0.5975517630577087,
0.08680319041013718,
0.592473030090332,
-0.29367348551750183,
-0.6170389652252197,
-0.4844670593738556,
-0.530719518661499,
-0.6254334449768066,
-0.25344178080558777,
0.10317927598953247,
0.2569741904735565,
0.18864887952804565,
-0.5112025141716003,
0.47288379073143005,
0.3114875257015228,
-0.34000685811042786,
0.8674255013465881,
-0.13195766508579254,
0.44502249360084534,
-0.7057766318321228,
-0.13701805472373962,
-0.035944614559412,
0.11943516135215759,
-0.7393840551376343,
0.2879861891269684,
-0.09954198449850082,
-0.042684443295001984,
-0.5212382078170776,
0.4738143980503082,
-0.35590860247612,
0.00889302883297205,
-0.24499650299549103,
0.23684775829315186,
0.02073071524500847,
0.29264092445373535,
-0.3791334629058838,
1.1303815841674805,
0.6782577633857727,
-0.6347839832305908,
0.07551185041666031,
-0.1719476580619812,
-0.17373161017894745,
0.8874696493148804,
-0.9143866300582886,
0.014266103506088257,
-0.18769626319408417,
0.09176591038703918,
-1.4304362535476685,
-0.03333219140768051,
0.3252880871295929,
-0.3617718815803528,
0.4260362684726715,
-0.24908511340618134,
-0.30808812379837036,
0.07633113861083984,
-0.8225871920585632,
0.33388853073120117,
0.4042932391166687,
-0.25589266419410706,
-0.08904613554477692,
-0.0981917753815651,
-0.3633750379085541,
-0.8607505559921265,
-0.3419020175933838,
0.30129268765449524,
-0.33697861433029175,
-0.28059840202331543,
0.31593307852745056,
-0.5233818888664246,
-0.23288241028785706,
-0.44030219316482544,
-0.37170666456222534,
0.3841647207736969,
0.2868075668811798,
0.382831871509552,
0.3805074989795685,
-0.19529461860656738,
-0.11130131036043167,
-0.07721159607172012,
-0.09767882525920868,
-0.09889490157365799,
0.1330147683620453,
0.3746947944164276,
0.20027512311935425,
-0.5254039764404297,
-0.5374832153320312,
0.24789729714393616,
0.5347035527229309,
-0.14338669180870056,
0.6689532995223999,
0.15849308669567108,
0.3301317095756531,
-0.14138992130756378,
-0.675673246383667,
-0.18373823165893555,
-0.4654816687107086,
-0.10059072822332382,
-0.23731307685375214,
-1.1103053092956543,
0.7252891063690186,
0.13267937302589417,
0.13882465660572052,
0.4805419445037842,
0.3537738025188446,
-0.16805632412433624,
0.9383625984191895,
0.6370472311973572,
-0.026486936956644058,
0.622970700263977,
0.06948041170835495,
0.053677938878536224,
-0.8058685064315796,
-0.13132931292057037,
-0.7643043994903564,
-0.7743622660636902,
-0.9894186854362488,
-0.4412418007850647,
0.2816471755504608,
0.3023967444896698,
-0.05798057094216347,
0.013563135638833046,
-0.4518437683582306,
0.6357136368751526,
0.32869574427604675,
-0.25290271639823914,
0.161684051156044,
-0.1851208359003067,
-0.36101090908050537,
-0.049324873834848404,
-0.6306666135787964,
-0.3144444525241852,
1.0729209184646606,
0.11271782219409943,
0.6104620099067688,
0.3007124066352844,
0.8978679180145264,
0.47286731004714966,
0.0767270028591156,
-1.130136489868164,
0.5789175629615784,
0.21044020354747772,
-0.31190356612205505,
-0.5131001472473145,
-0.3150736391544342,
-1.2246726751327515,
0.32310208678245544,
-0.11381417512893677,
-0.896835207939148,
0.3473646938800812,
-0.35554757714271545,
-0.4101841151714325,
-0.06311007589101791,
-0.39781075716018677,
0.6574578285217285,
-0.09531612694263458,
-0.23732885718345642,
0.227623850107193,
-0.5683512687683105,
0.05007801949977875,
0.18622109293937683,
-0.23532699048519135,
-0.1866205483675003,
-0.05318155884742737,
0.5281600952148438,
-0.2891947031021118,
0.9418811202049255,
-0.29344385862350464,
-0.20298117399215698,
0.11326243728399277,
0.09966670721769333,
0.6291651129722595,
0.17104530334472656,
-0.4030112326145172,
0.21298642456531525,
-0.06691218167543411,
-0.4395752549171448,
-0.6766549944877625,
0.810982882976532,
-0.8500044941902161,
-1.130501389503479,
-0.6697198152542114,
-0.454166442155838,
-0.10588419437408447,
0.14789979159832,
0.4289702773094177,
0.5828348994255066,
-0.14807921648025513,
0.2879657745361328,
0.7938088774681091,
-0.5092042088508606,
0.5928452610969543,
0.8679367303848267,
-0.2775634229183197,
-0.11873652786016464,
0.7216113209724426,
0.6930180788040161,
0.17221786081790924,
0.627026379108429,
0.22949297726154327,
-0.2298998087644577,
-0.5781537890434265,
-0.5239880681037903,
0.30336448550224304,
-0.6176698803901672,
-0.09608102589845657,
-0.2291233390569687,
-0.07638975977897644,
-0.32398852705955505,
-0.295522004365921,
0.21813532710075378,
-0.661987841129303,
-0.2903420329093933,
-0.22819600999355316,
0.45245930552482605,
1.000839352607727,
0.2016630321741104,
0.2787957191467285,
-0.33377552032470703,
-0.0590023435652256,
0.4028802216053009,
0.36071959137916565,
-0.196742981672287,
-0.7156326174736023,
-0.033470600843429565,
-0.41429197788238525,
-0.1192501038312912,
-1.1984734535217285,
-0.06209863722324371,
-0.170091912150383,
0.9139947295188904,
0.41317349672317505,
0.05965910106897354,
0.4067721366882324,
-0.3816296458244324,
1.5251973867416382,
-0.005945402663201094,
-0.7317197322845459,
0.4406227171421051,
-0.6574950218200684,
0.5984100103378296,
0.5753520131111145,
0.18078924715518951,
-0.8233641982078552,
-0.5928029417991638,
-0.2590014338493347,
-0.7759516835212708,
0.9551343321800232,
0.1293036937713623,
0.13876084983348846,
-0.13083747029304504,
0.6690675020217896,
0.2956312298774719,
0.18674573302268982,
-0.48548460006713867,
-0.7006530165672302,
0.07118330895900726,
0.40588152408599854,
-0.22913479804992676,
-0.6726604104042053,
0.06287754327058792,
-0.004571303725242615,
0.4399784505367279,
0.12454018741846085,
0.1299666315317154,
0.19096380472183228,
-0.2138672173023224,
-0.0469372384250164,
0.6659294366836548,
0.9834639430046082,
0.6973302364349365,
-0.3158087730407715,
0.09458612650632858,
0.2588699460029602,
-0.2372325360774994,
0.18533486127853394,
-0.12711378931999207,
-0.4990229308605194,
0.2714870274066925,
0.3486824929714203,
0.9028816223144531,
0.43529215455055237,
-0.3781421184539795,
0.5302846431732178,
0.03965648636221886,
0.03541019558906555,
0.17898236215114594,
0.29857343435287476,
-0.4250297546386719,
0.190399631857872,
0.5162124037742615,
-0.1800052970647812,
0.1392480731010437,
-0.47935882210731506,
-0.04144402593374252,
0.37373822927474976,
-0.5090777277946472,
-0.3551357686519623,
0.35518166422843933,
0.1421671062707901,
-0.558337926864624,
0.2640383839607239,
-0.38873788714408875,
-0.12351256608963013,
0.6362818479537964,
0.48583120107650757,
0.8480756878852844,
-0.6018927097320557,
0.5654124021530151,
0.0008716120501048863,
0.15754421055316925,
-0.02503710426390171,
0.24204498529434204,
-0.07887597382068634,
-0.3042210638523102,
-0.5653250217437744,
-0.444178968667984,
-0.7772393822669983,
0.16853322088718414,
-0.6131883263587952,
0.4532603919506073,
-0.4680198132991791,
-0.21878980100154877,
-0.1410956084728241,
0.24855908751487732,
-0.6179730892181396,
-0.1214706152677536,
0.1592947542667389,
0.7759360671043396,
-0.6609988808631897,
0.19525112211704254,
0.7784297466278076,
-0.5879772901535034,
-0.813835620880127,
0.25960198044776917,
0.28303852677345276,
-0.6409105062484741,
0.5575759410858154,
0.37719523906707764,
-0.16216406226158142,
-0.09737613797187805,
-0.33106163144111633,
-0.8497684001922607,
1.3295916318893433,
0.1932041198015213,
-0.30374228954315186,
0.11249694228172302,
0.3867238759994507,
0.5406970977783203,
-0.3931737244129181,
0.9300123453140259,
0.1562841534614563,
0.3227633237838745,
0.2967987656593323,
-0.994349479675293,
0.053229525685310364,
-0.015824323520064354,
0.1852298378944397,
-0.006079729180783033,
-0.6156764030456543,
0.9865188598632812,
-0.08997225761413574,
-0.2626499831676483,
0.20922400057315826,
0.12473874539136887,
0.5293611288070679,
0.5070385336875916,
0.19225437939167023,
0.1619153618812561,
0.7563291192054749,
0.0401606559753418,
1.0127097368240356,
-0.39152440428733826,
0.2065887153148651,
0.7992573976516724,
-0.6813564300537109,
0.7761363983154297,
0.3078249990940094,
-0.02898646704852581,
0.663136899471283,
0.6539891362190247,
-0.11061612516641617,
0.24425488710403442,
0.374548077583313,
-0.2608101963996887,
-0.16428467631340027,
-0.4630693793296814,
-0.36907801032066345,
0.508152425289154,
0.05691707506775856,
-0.2649921476840973,
-0.4078079164028168,
-0.2598356008529663,
0.1374131739139557,
-0.29311633110046387,
-0.3845355212688446,
0.6419590711593628,
0.08508690446615219,
-0.7271861433982849,
0.54280024766922,
0.20042720437049866,
0.7434152960777283,
-0.5719473958015442,
-0.09266398102045059,
-0.5437783598899841,
-0.4655548930168152,
-0.1267087608575821,
-0.7657980918884277,
-0.4464939832687378,
0.16484355926513672,
-0.30025598406791687,
-0.45666927099227905,
0.6045122146606445,
0.07596942782402039,
-0.32494619488716125,
0.02035127952694893,
0.8063051104545593,
0.40359142422676086,
-0.043852511793375015,
-0.5510264039039612,
0.07620414346456528,
-0.2696189880371094,
-0.33456340432167053,
0.6437732577323914,
0.5363158583641052,
-0.1269938200712204,
0.2901007831096649,
0.5349900722503662,
0.04961263760924339,
-0.035594284534454346,
0.36914414167404175,
0.6351092457771301,
-0.786642849445343,
-0.49567273259162903,
-0.8989935517311096,
0.41803476214408875,
-0.09632886946201324,
-0.31262990832328796,
1.0929256677627563,
0.4439471960067749,
0.35328176617622375,
0.10359910130500793,
0.4898635745048523,
0.19328230619430542,
0.3257278800010681,
-0.4073420763015747,
0.6473315358161926,
-0.4039725363254547,
0.6386064887046814,
-0.27453964948654175,
-1.1062027215957642,
-0.3924441933631897,
0.10767719149589539,
-0.47561728954315186,
0.10484392940998077,
0.6401583552360535,
0.8566516041755676,
0.5951445698738098,
-0.22299960255622864,
0.7300382852554321,
0.1383451372385025,
0.35057851672172546,
0.1935872733592987,
1.0235538482666016,
-0.06326145678758621,
0.32797563076019287,
0.12225668877363205,
-0.3152924180030823,
-0.5653603672981262,
-0.8738020062446594,
-0.8530538082122803,
-0.08905398100614548,
-0.26298460364341736,
0.04510821774601936,
0.14164911210536957,
0.9085240960121155,
0.2671261727809906,
-0.6427513360977173,
-0.34431394934654236,
0.22349755465984344,
0.5197708606719971,
-0.3442423343658447,
-0.29145920276641846,
0.022119097411632538,
-0.5979323387145996,
-0.6928738951683044,
0.7371006608009338,
0.47210121154785156,
-0.31748753786087036,
-0.27481526136398315,
0.13458532094955444,
0.08927091211080551,
0.5413934588432312,
0.7595080137252808,
0.23543064296245575,
-0.9680410027503967,
-0.5299495458602905,
0.492436021566391,
-0.19387280941009521,
0.1762273609638214,
0.9086784720420837,
-0.7914064526557922,
0.45837149024009705,
0.7439219355583191,
0.28723278641700745,
-0.022102436050772667,
0.12511588633060455,
0.462299644947052,
-0.9476377367973328,
-0.27470922470092773,
0.04170840233564377,
0.1778678447008133,
0.2326686531305313,
-0.4959958791732788,
0.23248092830181122,
0.39515915513038635,
-0.7853249907493591,
-0.8704972267150879,
0.4031262695789337,
-1.0815222263336182,
-0.31924572587013245,
1.5074576139450073,
-0.023022323846817017,
0.20043689012527466,
-0.04819655790925026,
-0.18067583441734314,
0.06902818381786346,
-0.7112150192260742,
0.8232734799385071,
0.884773850440979,
-0.5741448402404785,
-0.38932767510414124,
-0.6195579171180725,
0.42955106496810913,
0.5254611372947693,
-0.2702023983001709,
-0.19327253103256226,
0.5156784057617188,
0.31811684370040894,
0.1209443211555481,
0.4862915873527527,
0.07497161626815796,
0.08020821213722229,
-0.45306649804115295,
-0.2561245560646057,
-0.10491126030683517,
-0.2255496233701706,
-0.9832572937011719,
0.34960341453552246,
0.46081864833831787,
0.034297894686460495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14115v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14115v1 | Take the essence and discard the dross: A Rethinking on Data Selection for Fine-Tuning Large Language Models | 2024-06-20T08:58:58 | 2024-06-20T08:58:58 | Ziche Liu, Rui Ke, Feng Jiang, Haizhou Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data selection for fine-tuning Large Language Models (LLMs) aims to select a
high-quality subset from a given candidate dataset to train a Pending Fine-tune
Model (PFM) into a Selective-Enhanced Model (SEM). It can improve the model
performance and accelerate the training process. Although a few surveys have
investigated related works of data selection, there is a lack of comprehensive
comparison between existing methods due to their various experimental settings.
To address this issue, we first propose a three-stage scheme for data selection
and comprehensively review existing works according to this scheme. Then, we
design a unified comparing method with ratio-based efficiency indicators and
ranking-based feasibility indicators to overcome the difficulty of comparing
various models with diverse experimental settings. After an in-depth
comparative analysis, we find that the more targeted method with data-specific
and model-specific quality labels has higher efficiency, but the introduction
of additional noise information should be avoided when designing selection
algorithms. Finally, we summarize the trends in data selection and highlight
the short-term and long-term challenges to guide future research. | [
-0.5393380522727966,
-0.8415787816047668,
0.545789361000061,
-0.15926820039749146,
-0.47497081756591797,
0.09012943506240845,
-0.4552994668483734,
-0.3162112236022949,
-0.07547279447317123,
0.5663435459136963,
-0.5080663561820984,
-0.46517667174339294,
-0.40521693229675293,
0.25977522134780884,
-0.43167680501937866,
0.6953850388526917,
-0.16418708860874176,
0.08722779154777527,
-0.04603896662592888,
0.15455634891986847,
-0.36687690019607544,
-0.1676362007856369,
-0.7846538424491882,
-0.4674036502838135,
0.4945305585861206,
0.4844861328601837,
0.7008681297302246,
0.8617164492607117,
0.7255310416221619,
0.22846823930740356,
-0.27459579706192017,
0.49632716178894043,
-0.7285857796669006,
0.2625064253807068,
0.07077770680189133,
-0.40559613704681396,
-0.3126724064350128,
0.06279570609331131,
0.7128507494926453,
0.852900505065918,
0.1311926394701004,
0.23864935338497162,
0.1258406639099121,
0.8596055507659912,
-0.43434539437294006,
-0.06319748610258102,
-0.8125380277633667,
0.06549377739429474,
-0.2284376174211502,
0.05578158050775528,
-0.29546576738357544,
-0.28019118309020996,
-0.054789476096630096,
-0.25602343678474426,
0.19259487092494965,
0.19313684105873108,
0.7795656323432922,
0.24282416701316833,
-0.162173792719841,
-0.016257507726550102,
-0.7413297295570374,
0.9830659031867981,
-0.8205640316009521,
0.5673736333847046,
0.38389891386032104,
0.15051628649234772,
-0.1233324259519577,
-0.606619656085968,
-0.18385367095470428,
-0.5213212966918945,
0.21987971663475037,
-0.17721334099769592,
0.050475627183914185,
-0.05956331640481949,
0.11599818617105484,
0.7503060102462769,
-0.5486111640930176,
0.5129079818725586,
-0.3747096657752991,
-0.24862274527549744,
0.7118138670921326,
0.15877942740917206,
-0.049873653799295425,
0.13725925981998444,
-0.1219530925154686,
-0.0779852643609047,
-0.8938949108123779,
-0.2406606525182724,
0.36517348885536194,
0.6924093961715698,
0.17852886021137238,
0.42643409967422485,
-0.6590162515640259,
0.8751616477966309,
-0.06758711487054825,
-0.32903555035591125,
0.3733937442302704,
-0.23410548269748688,
-0.4629107415676117,
-0.4046596586704254,
0.7419490218162537,
0.11916708201169968,
0.2815242409706116,
-0.1896308809518814,
-0.5753395557403564,
-0.17137615382671356,
0.14246265590190887,
-0.789874255657196,
-0.11694079637527466,
0.24779091775417328,
-0.5464370846748352,
-0.26157715916633606,
-0.12140253931283951,
-0.8028858304023743,
-0.1018008217215538,
-0.830478847026825,
0.04543586075305939,
-0.12456279993057251,
-0.3671811521053314,
0.2873302400112152,
0.22990170121192932,
-0.12351472675800323,
0.3282037079334259,
-0.7314648628234863,
0.03271479159593582,
0.7810855507850647,
0.6501027345657349,
-0.40330860018730164,
-0.38495510816574097,
-0.35693684220314026,
-0.07514065504074097,
-0.5727859735488892,
0.9079687595367432,
-0.851871907711029,
-0.3404082655906677,
-0.010446913540363312,
-0.2031160444021225,
0.016484756022691727,
-0.7058441638946533,
0.8167634010314941,
-0.5046252608299255,
-0.12403345853090286,
-0.15828782320022583,
-0.5734027028083801,
-0.11308417469263077,
-0.06887590140104294,
-0.7952926754951477,
1.1604491472244263,
0.20751552283763885,
-0.6447473764419556,
0.7945660948753357,
-0.04351726919412613,
-0.5037645101547241,
-0.09186270833015442,
-0.19957245886325836,
-0.6727427244186401,
0.20251095294952393,
0.17662358283996582,
0.6014765501022339,
-0.5239244699478149,
0.5151438117027283,
-0.5382140278816223,
-0.5342960357666016,
0.20245175063610077,
-0.47453179955482483,
0.3233729600906372,
0.7602701187133789,
-0.04176253080368042,
-0.044734708964824677,
-0.8905278444290161,
0.12207217514514923,
0.01959409937262535,
-0.6445977091789246,
-0.1890590488910675,
-0.02265944331884384,
-0.09801748394966125,
0.14354857802391052,
0.1243373304605484,
-0.2553709149360657,
0.19776684045791626,
-0.301054447889328,
0.4794948995113373,
0.7258123159408569,
-0.22560256719589233,
0.506375253200531,
-0.5465337038040161,
0.40839508175849915,
-0.2941763699054718,
0.24267229437828064,
0.24761594831943512,
-0.04918038100004196,
-0.774157702922821,
-0.351318895816803,
0.6630342602729797,
0.3044009506702423,
-0.40352192521095276,
0.46819981932640076,
-0.18154098093509674,
-0.5421380996704102,
-0.7973647117614746,
0.4180563688278198,
0.1671346127986908,
0.13881425559520721,
0.1593102216720581,
-0.1168508306145668,
-0.5560137033462524,
-0.9358665943145752,
-0.01630341447889805,
0.002776865381747484,
0.18069733679294586,
0.3706597089767456,
0.30710503458976746,
-0.07156404107809067,
0.729400634765625,
-0.4130873382091522,
-0.03948269411921501,
-0.6077251434326172,
-0.30738815665245056,
0.30183863639831543,
0.334730863571167,
0.4501446485519409,
-0.5666753649711609,
-0.45105335116386414,
0.052924249321222305,
-0.33845067024230957,
-0.2163935899734497,
-0.037795308977365494,
-0.1392810344696045,
-0.0396023690700531,
0.5163595676422119,
-0.3011810779571533,
0.14185024797916412,
0.3307681381702423,
-0.019799131900072098,
0.3016897439956665,
-0.1622777283191681,
0.3596595525741577,
-0.7386195063591003,
0.05630500614643097,
0.0064681461080908775,
-0.13164140284061432,
-0.501922070980072,
-0.10997402667999268,
0.33724960684776306,
-0.02315410226583481,
-0.30349990725517273,
0.518951952457428,
-0.45550739765167236,
-0.01127442717552185,
-0.47996407747268677,
0.13030707836151123,
-0.1911381036043167,
0.2657976746559143,
-0.11668563634157181,
0.7499949336051941,
0.7836824059486389,
-0.7855031490325928,
0.28541380167007446,
0.03713754937052727,
-0.6341136693954468,
0.2455471009016037,
-0.30332881212234497,
0.2209295779466629,
-0.10315404087305069,
-0.05460882559418678,
-0.8704213500022888,
0.007562029175460339,
-0.05233986675739288,
-0.2763557434082031,
0.6368216872215271,
-0.13847443461418152,
-0.6608240008354187,
-0.4371241331100464,
-0.325092077255249,
0.02651619352400303,
0.36240872740745544,
-0.3938411772251129,
0.02966499514877796,
0.5528607368469238,
-0.3731454014778137,
-0.2924169600009918,
-0.5299215912818909,
0.15692122280597687,
-0.522549033164978,
-0.41794949769973755,
0.1421787291765213,
-0.08442254364490509,
-0.3248370587825775,
-0.46749410033226013,
-0.34746411442756653,
0.04060139134526253,
0.3732834458351135,
-0.29159027338027954,
0.2386859506368637,
-0.05620168522000313,
0.06835133582353592,
0.2622646987438202,
-0.29787972569465637,
-0.35898882150650024,
-0.0035188656765967607,
0.2890659272670746,
0.3213097155094147,
-0.26552653312683105,
-0.5620613694190979,
0.15979161858558655,
0.2978432774543762,
-0.35435229539871216,
0.26819825172424316,
0.4320801794528961,
-0.026502462103962898,
-0.4049829840660095,
-0.7731443643569946,
-0.31284740567207336,
-0.4193154573440552,
0.443881630897522,
-0.4859130382537842,
-0.9759036898612976,
0.1834556758403778,
-0.32200950384140015,
0.31222647428512573,
0.2671744227409363,
0.5371983051300049,
0.22433306276798248,
1.1397701501846313,
0.6095654964447021,
-0.35797572135925293,
0.6870948672294617,
-0.14308765530586243,
0.16279521584510803,
-0.783470630645752,
0.06007261201739311,
-0.9298505783081055,
-0.39722108840942383,
-0.41404372453689575,
-0.12154580652713776,
-0.06717441231012344,
0.1868625432252884,
-0.24422228336334229,
0.20556049048900604,
-0.42049458622932434,
0.3627989888191223,
0.1709984987974167,
0.14701083302497864,
0.45599091053009033,
0.3237442672252655,
-0.005567844491451979,
-0.053739942610263824,
-0.5397361516952515,
-0.7097650766372681,
1.2461332082748413,
0.44089803099632263,
0.9350993633270264,
-0.11681056767702103,
0.5033992528915405,
0.12483108043670654,
0.21818700432777405,
-0.6318785548210144,
0.6246663928031921,
-0.4279104173183441,
-0.5073556303977966,
-0.38121381402015686,
-0.5778458118438721,
-1.028327465057373,
0.5287960767745972,
-0.06311327964067459,
-0.5035557746887207,
0.01333695836365223,
-0.20979101955890656,
-0.4399260878562927,
0.22622516751289368,
-0.46880292892456055,
0.4306430518627167,
-0.20669105648994446,
-0.2625109553337097,
-0.3766179084777832,
-0.2622765600681305,
0.15285128355026245,
-0.31866902112960815,
0.37751269340515137,
-0.4959542155265808,
-0.037614911794662476,
0.7878443002700806,
-0.0835227370262146,
0.552318274974823,
-0.10831999033689499,
-0.2773717939853668,
0.0860389843583107,
0.1690295934677124,
0.6236870884895325,
0.17438088357448578,
-0.4871651530265808,
0.0037633334286510944,
-0.16518515348434448,
-0.07468920946121216,
-0.22886288166046143,
0.7303494811058044,
-0.5781335234642029,
-0.5062217116355896,
0.04112275689840317,
-0.4114759564399719,
-0.4841856062412262,
0.23565571010112762,
-0.09998423606157303,
0.44719982147216797,
-0.05769464373588562,
0.5280399322509766,
0.6637901067733765,
-0.04774157702922821,
0.14697320759296417,
0.6423523426055908,
-0.24743841588497162,
-0.4779369831085205,
0.894579291343689,
0.23764273524284363,
0.4129311740398407,
0.27437615394592285,
0.06312865018844604,
-0.09543569386005402,
-1.1782258749008179,
-0.36570844054222107,
0.2573663890361786,
-0.5243871808052063,
-0.3238120377063751,
-0.48683443665504456,
-0.06464395672082901,
-0.3545041084289551,
0.03364180028438568,
-0.6137345433235168,
-0.20459289848804474,
-0.416927307844162,
-0.12148864567279816,
0.23623648285865784,
0.48623475432395935,
-0.05159235745668411,
0.08368246257305145,
-0.38289594650268555,
0.5140717029571533,
0.083472341299057,
0.5259218811988831,
0.0030611976981163025,
-0.7945927977561951,
-0.29546722769737244,
0.016148103401064873,
-0.2368174046278,
-0.29323282837867737,
0.35939231514930725,
0.21245568990707397,
0.9140151739120483,
0.35961487889289856,
-0.15905942022800446,
0.6698693037033081,
-0.3079526126384735,
0.3691321015357971,
-0.24389736354351044,
-0.30359187722206116,
0.6080214381217957,
-0.11646991968154907,
-0.04296007379889488,
0.9662358164787292,
0.06641806662082672,
-0.3225252032279968,
-0.522456705570221,
-0.48315683007240295,
-0.9596653580665588,
0.7068322896957397,
0.1824992150068283,
0.06655733287334442,
0.2329723984003067,
0.5068349838256836,
0.5667118430137634,
0.2308567613363266,
-0.40126198530197144,
-0.44787704944610596,
0.40086859464645386,
-0.07317415624856949,
-0.16521598398685455,
-0.2204940766096115,
0.1595998853445053,
-0.3554795980453491,
0.652255654335022,
-0.1285339891910553,
-0.09255405515432358,
-0.038635190576314926,
-0.1654680222272873,
-0.2677535116672516,
0.35397014021873474,
0.16320624947547913,
0.919956624507904,
-0.11015284806489944,
-0.15624578297138214,
0.2581314146518707,
-0.49080005288124084,
-0.09409056603908539,
0.14417952299118042,
-0.3794431686401367,
0.022294048219919205,
0.18003295361995697,
1.02570378780365,
0.35221973061561584,
-0.5866549015045166,
0.04990092292428017,
-0.025929098948836327,
-0.3077279031276703,
0.12294024974107742,
0.3460855484008789,
-0.11189375072717667,
0.27681228518486023,
0.2620108425617218,
-0.34908929467201233,
0.0969478115439415,
-0.4705972671508789,
0.11696578562259674,
0.5318212509155273,
-0.10920614004135132,
-0.00403557950630784,
0.3310675621032715,
0.1657993197441101,
-0.14583180844783783,
0.6477273106575012,
-0.03929757699370384,
-0.09051989018917084,
0.4836868643760681,
0.2808944284915924,
0.6428553462028503,
-0.06445404887199402,
0.032319337129592896,
0.3685842752456665,
0.25045743584632874,
-0.49629825353622437,
0.3867683708667755,
0.06063634529709816,
-0.5749721527099609,
-0.5159207582473755,
-0.8639261722564697,
-0.2124733179807663,
0.6610795855522156,
-0.6726693511009216,
0.38726183772087097,
-0.19152948260307312,
-0.09113599359989166,
-0.12764881551265717,
0.4993381202220917,
-0.668582558631897,
0.32105308771133423,
0.300994336605072,
0.9435002207756042,
-0.7420181035995483,
0.8891135454177856,
0.3928144574165344,
0.04143567755818367,
-0.6103973984718323,
-0.015612407587468624,
-0.08488885313272476,
-0.7350366711616516,
0.3085731863975525,
-0.052060436457395554,
0.2696121037006378,
0.047341737896203995,
-0.565039873123169,
-1.080285668373108,
1.1336042881011963,
0.5115745067596436,
-0.8036572933197021,
0.1477653533220291,
-0.05709100142121315,
0.36396050453186035,
-0.4447261691093445,
0.08568308502435684,
1.0848908424377441,
0.5174263715744019,
0.2835041582584381,
-1.129908561706543,
-0.19377097487449646,
0.06804856657981873,
0.10004571080207825,
0.3193703889846802,
-0.7671993374824524,
0.8155233860015869,
-0.04510974511504173,
-0.2198491096496582,
0.26697996258735657,
0.5917371511459351,
0.331564724445343,
0.09100247174501419,
0.4226002097129822,
0.4784284830093384,
0.7986575365066528,
-0.10382762551307678,
0.7379476428031921,
-0.22469817101955414,
0.5060060620307922,
0.9045473337173462,
-0.4809737503528595,
0.8777535557746887,
0.41511034965515137,
-0.7065091133117676,
-0.12388052046298981,
1.1075321435928345,
-0.2705553472042084,
0.7021138668060303,
0.3436373174190521,
0.021576933562755585,
-0.5043032765388489,
0.06200511008501053,
-0.4778040647506714,
0.36265915632247925,
0.30446144938468933,
-0.30685901641845703,
-0.307952344417572,
-0.09879346936941147,
-0.04479820653796196,
-0.2498398870229721,
-0.46148091554641724,
0.9520303606987,
0.21968825161457062,
-0.5828843116760254,
0.7136505246162415,
0.06499423831701279,
0.6599447131156921,
-0.43438103795051575,
0.2659159302711487,
-0.4317936599254608,
0.05472075566649437,
-0.0878305658698082,
-0.7774373888969421,
0.07350710779428482,
-0.013312417082488537,
0.03277437761425972,
-0.258164644241333,
0.8656989932060242,
-0.3812094032764435,
-0.5079598426818848,
0.09144584089517593,
0.6249473094940186,
0.28892016410827637,
-0.17693908512592316,
-0.8506706357002258,
0.5125246047973633,
0.2327498197555542,
-0.4498530924320221,
0.40545058250427246,
0.5082622170448303,
0.19339202344417572,
0.7507830858230591,
0.6559754610061646,
0.4780917763710022,
-0.4142812192440033,
0.48282745480537415,
0.910606324672699,
-0.7002951502799988,
-0.4010260999202728,
-0.8417892456054688,
0.3550581932067871,
0.00720669561997056,
-0.2749671936035156,
0.472084641456604,
0.6114152073860168,
0.9409317970275879,
0.2010350078344345,
0.9025610685348511,
0.10592608153820038,
0.9089215993881226,
-0.6825129389762878,
0.5228714942932129,
-0.6033640503883362,
0.4143511652946472,
-0.27467766404151917,
-0.9868528842926025,
-0.3569529056549072,
0.6165398955345154,
-0.3856445550918579,
0.2328805774450302,
0.6380196213722229,
0.9533854126930237,
-0.09317239373922348,
0.10611197352409363,
0.4150184988975525,
0.11563736200332642,
0.1828882396221161,
0.46061819791793823,
0.813750147819519,
-0.13229073584079742,
0.42229974269866943,
-0.19229824841022491,
-0.1627107560634613,
-0.3277391791343689,
-0.6224391460418701,
-0.8880932331085205,
-0.562688946723938,
-0.30414825677871704,
0.010623984970152378,
-0.07461253553628922,
0.7630239725112915,
0.7086702585220337,
-0.7485118508338928,
-0.22725485265254974,
0.15519289672374725,
0.1969660222530365,
-0.10112801939249039,
-0.09218130260705948,
0.3417983651161194,
-0.45469972491264343,
-0.7830029726028442,
0.6078333854675293,
0.26070436835289,
0.05812626704573631,
-0.24624337255954742,
0.054479192942380905,
0.13549752533435822,
-0.11215773224830627,
0.44713065028190613,
-0.057749442756175995,
-0.6032609343528748,
0.0477118156850338,
-0.3187391459941864,
-0.26128995418548584,
0.16237245500087738,
0.9703400135040283,
-0.6211089491844177,
0.07482153177261353,
0.4722219705581665,
0.7056417465209961,
0.3269352614879608,
-0.3289046585559845,
0.39208927750587463,
-0.20796893537044525,
-0.005188225768506527,
0.07948587834835052,
0.3547016680240631,
0.3432482182979584,
-0.1964009702205658,
0.5101125240325928,
-0.06111619621515274,
-0.7325494885444641,
-1.0766130685806274,
0.16735292971134186,
-0.6571255326271057,
-0.48884108662605286,
1.5565354824066162,
0.25432196259498596,
-0.08964385837316513,
-0.22062593698501587,
-0.451999694108963,
0.14280755817890167,
-0.46875423192977905,
0.8859562873840332,
0.66697096824646,
0.00501594552770257,
-0.019124755635857582,
-0.9397154450416565,
0.6230923533439636,
0.29556402564048767,
-0.6761230826377869,
0.45514917373657227,
0.47941380739212036,
0.2917165756225586,
-0.48882031440734863,
0.31061452627182007,
-0.09708432108163834,
-0.05574050545692444,
-0.3607984483242035,
-0.3916737139225006,
-0.07237709313631058,
-0.39636266231536865,
-0.4456585943698883,
0.17457668483257294,
0.5790101885795593,
0.2533505856990814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14106v1 | EasyECR: A Library for Easy Implementation and Evaluation of Event Coreference Resolution Models | 2024-06-20T08:40:21 | 2024-06-20T08:40:21 | Yuncong Li, Tianhua Xu, Sheng-hua Zhong, Haiqin Yang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Event Coreference Resolution (ECR) is the task of clustering event mentions
that refer to the same real-world event. Despite significant advancements, ECR
research faces two main challenges: limited generalizability across domains due
to narrow dataset evaluations, and difficulties in comparing models within
diverse ECR pipelines. To address these issues, we develop EasyECR, the first
open-source library designed to standardize data structures and abstract ECR
pipelines for easy implementation and fair evaluation. More specifically,
EasyECR integrates seven representative pipelines and ten popular benchmark
datasets, enabling model evaluations on various datasets and promoting the
development of robust ECR pipelines. By conducting extensive evaluation via our
EasyECR, we find that, \lowercase\expandafter{\romannumeral1}) the
representative ECR pipelines cannot generalize across multiple datasets, hence
evaluating ECR pipelines on multiple datasets is necessary,
\lowercase\expandafter{\romannumeral2}) all models in ECR pipelines have a
great effect on pipeline performance, therefore, when one model in ECR
pipelines are compared, it is essential to ensure that the other models remain
consistent. Additionally, reproducing ECR results is not trivial, and the
developed library can help reduce this discrepancy. The experimental results
provide valuable baselines for future research. | [
-0.5873947143554688,
-0.3078671395778656,
0.5927870869636536,
-0.2341022491455078,
-0.26735371351242065,
-0.23068584501743317,
-0.6059330701828003,
-0.5899296402931213,
-0.27278846502304077,
0.42480018734931946,
-0.2991902232170105,
-0.6903431415557861,
-0.7143220901489258,
0.24395319819450378,
-0.6229079961776733,
1.1800073385238647,
-0.010004700161516666,
-0.008390814997255802,
-0.07477661967277527,
-0.3374442458152771,
0.11372870951890945,
-0.8447769284248352,
-0.6906682252883911,
-0.3272309899330139,
0.5752431154251099,
0.5249102711677551,
0.32674047350883484,
0.8574658632278442,
0.9753854274749756,
0.28659147024154663,
-0.3912811875343323,
0.08103886991739273,
-0.26366689801216125,
0.03286604583263397,
-0.27578359842300415,
-0.14486530423164368,
-0.46578675508499146,
-0.466157466173172,
0.4067995548248291,
0.6424708962440491,
-0.5010711550712585,
0.3511604964733124,
0.2655373215675354,
0.6037253141403198,
-0.7555787563323975,
0.22920002043247223,
-0.6358166337013245,
-0.24912944436073303,
-0.3475249409675598,
0.22195525467395782,
-0.293038547039032,
-0.1301436722278595,
0.24798686802387238,
-0.5233325362205505,
0.868893563747406,
0.246827632188797,
0.5794848203659058,
0.171793133020401,
-0.45143285393714905,
-0.6736996173858643,
-1.1314784288406372,
0.7610090374946594,
-0.5391760468482971,
0.43251150846481323,
-0.25175899267196655,
0.4510108232498169,
0.08870262652635574,
-1.1388438940048218,
-0.6302937269210815,
0.2890344262123108,
-0.11552578210830688,
-0.25554797053337097,
-0.4134536683559418,
0.30400350689888,
0.2957156002521515,
0.47923925518989563,
-0.4302406907081604,
-0.08483171463012695,
-0.41600868105888367,
-0.219370499253273,
0.22054021060466766,
0.4016872048377991,
-0.09034602344036102,
-0.34195634722709656,
0.03910176828503609,
0.019731644541025162,
-0.4885242283344269,
0.01229810994118452,
0.021881990134716034,
0.6171972155570984,
-0.059091512113809586,
0.4735347032546997,
-0.31265968084335327,
0.49627190828323364,
0.49512979388237,
0.18259353935718536,
0.0022744000889360905,
-0.4271889328956604,
0.062389571219682693,
0.1805160790681839,
0.5907820463180542,
0.3970450758934021,
-0.15810063481330872,
-0.19175922870635986,
0.0027702359948307276,
0.19519023597240448,
-0.03825958073139191,
-1.1041663885116577,
-0.3238539695739746,
0.4197129011154175,
-0.5403993725776672,
0.17842306196689606,
0.10205559432506561,
-0.6884211301803589,
-0.2800951898097992,
-0.5493641495704651,
0.05137210711836815,
-0.20587803423404694,
0.08348425477743149,
-0.012745981104671955,
-0.15576927363872528,
0.19419850409030914,
0.39054805040359497,
-0.2504046857357025,
0.6651087999343872,
1.065584659576416,
0.6254355311393738,
-0.17332524061203003,
-0.10177643597126007,
-0.6787310242652893,
0.0469924658536911,
0.27334916591644287,
1.0137230157852173,
-0.41017648577690125,
-0.29657697677612305,
-0.13696305453777313,
0.2156415581703186,
0.16307637095451355,
-0.5974007844924927,
1.188616156578064,
-0.29457521438598633,
-0.11783931404352188,
-0.14636224508285522,
-0.8243492245674133,
-0.0714341253042221,
0.0872468501329422,
-0.7716781497001648,
0.7517338991165161,
-0.5039650797843933,
-0.9234839081764221,
0.5521405339241028,
-0.48881158232688904,
0.14888617396354675,
0.1253253072500229,
-0.24338944256305695,
-0.4930291175842285,
-0.07898502796888351,
0.02291039563715458,
0.28430283069610596,
-0.42617136240005493,
0.21934859454631805,
-0.21981124579906464,
-0.10409072786569595,
-0.09827063977718353,
0.0036294949240982533,
0.33319562673568726,
0.2993028163909912,
-0.23494113981723785,
0.28361448645591736,
-1.0146204233169556,
0.009980923496186733,
-0.373617947101593,
-0.02410622499883175,
-0.7637113928794861,
0.42299026250839233,
0.33973145484924316,
0.055561378598213196,
0.2605392038822174,
-0.7574489116668701,
0.12967431545257568,
-0.0838685929775238,
0.18564185500144958,
0.3062998652458191,
-0.05162646248936653,
0.432087242603302,
-0.23405133187770844,
-0.029726101085543633,
0.12605513632297516,
0.031210465356707573,
-0.21612465381622314,
-0.2504228353500366,
-0.9994293451309204,
-0.42335349321365356,
0.24627573788166046,
0.38932114839553833,
-0.22648146748542786,
0.58365398645401,
-0.38873574137687683,
-0.8199079632759094,
-0.4605143666267395,
0.24212504923343658,
0.4514215290546417,
0.39862921833992004,
0.34490859508514404,
-0.44373854994773865,
-0.9245396852493286,
-0.8588345050811768,
-0.17938865721225739,
-0.0444495752453804,
-0.2272995412349701,
0.1676579862833023,
0.5563907027244568,
-0.1233735904097557,
1.0420387983322144,
-0.2198600023984909,
-0.32773664593696594,
-0.3105986714363098,
0.5100790858268738,
0.5197219252586365,
0.44976839423179626,
0.23416370153427124,
-0.571438729763031,
-0.45161405205726624,
0.16376632452011108,
-0.3444451689720154,
0.029851041734218597,
0.26929980516433716,
-0.015118244104087353,
-0.1822798103094101,
0.06316547840833664,
-0.34360405802726746,
0.46327492594718933,
0.5672720074653625,
-0.4045804440975189,
0.6687841415405273,
-0.0708734318614006,
0.3508036434650421,
-0.7757228016853333,
0.37023699283599854,
-0.09432598203420639,
-0.3131740689277649,
-0.6310141682624817,
0.24345141649246216,
0.1636124700307846,
-0.1274367719888687,
-0.6537163853645325,
0.5632254481315613,
-0.3209053575992584,
0.30129560828208923,
-0.24882683157920837,
-0.0051650190725922585,
-0.044007956981658936,
0.10640446096658707,
0.37711137533187866,
0.35026460886001587,
0.5488654375076294,
-1.025695562362671,
0.35842931270599365,
0.4747107923030853,
-0.5544219613075256,
0.7942390441894531,
-0.8442735075950623,
0.5276468992233276,
-0.13709309697151184,
0.31553924083709717,
-0.5930726528167725,
-0.07353852689266205,
0.09862649440765381,
-0.11463560163974762,
0.0013673061039298773,
-0.5048462152481079,
-0.20040640234947205,
-0.2910372316837311,
-0.06668201088905334,
0.41688570380210876,
0.13223090767860413,
-0.7795493602752686,
0.8233721852302551,
0.18535113334655762,
-0.3303563892841339,
-0.4083377718925476,
-0.4483621120452881,
-0.13966777920722961,
-0.16746535897254944,
-0.5011211037635803,
0.49977460503578186,
-0.49307015538215637,
-0.3182528018951416,
0.13661180436611176,
-0.1281735599040985,
-0.3355100154876709,
-0.6269535422325134,
0.47494927048683167,
0.15727218985557556,
-0.10612760484218597,
-0.11505071073770523,
-0.22106723487377167,
-0.34808897972106934,
-0.2460748255252838,
-0.010588714852929115,
0.19565673172473907,
-0.47284799814224243,
-0.5469210147857666,
-0.43380674719810486,
0.5160530805587769,
0.4722122251987457,
-0.04211759567260742,
0.6831514239311218,
0.24611881375312805,
-0.5747560858726501,
-0.0507650263607502,
-0.8865548968315125,
-0.12342888116836548,
-0.4316229224205017,
0.20473995804786682,
-0.562526524066925,
-1.015969157218933,
0.7207656502723694,
-0.1506354659795761,
0.3297869563102722,
0.3059411942958832,
0.6267040967941284,
0.11749769747257233,
1.0155613422393799,
0.517804741859436,
0.2780305743217468,
0.21527999639511108,
-0.16875222325325012,
0.08175211399793625,
-1.0507222414016724,
-0.052751313894987106,
-1.0418529510498047,
-0.1496874839067459,
-0.33731499314308167,
-0.4350634813308716,
0.22774550318717957,
0.1672460287809372,
-0.40959712862968445,
0.45948028564453125,
-0.7956193089485168,
0.577107846736908,
0.3132994771003723,
-0.08969123661518097,
0.737261950969696,
-0.2764354944229126,
-0.03484190255403519,
-0.29174092411994934,
-0.7109161615371704,
-0.8490666151046753,
0.9493641257286072,
0.08239991962909698,
0.8066459894180298,
0.008290777914226055,
0.8351172208786011,
0.33117666840553284,
0.5310583114624023,
-0.8556236624717712,
0.2762525975704193,
-0.32181867957115173,
-0.7901029586791992,
-0.022056933492422104,
-0.3412666320800781,
-0.9483652114868164,
-0.017486823722720146,
0.09747394919395447,
-0.8132110834121704,
0.8221989870071411,
0.2648526728153229,
-0.4304502308368683,
0.5440359115600586,
-0.3652075231075287,
0.8569911122322083,
0.12555871903896332,
-0.2631121575832367,
-0.04740298539400101,
-0.34857648611068726,
0.17987461388111115,
0.1730155497789383,
0.689428985118866,
-0.09520355612039566,
0.11118146777153015,
0.8800158500671387,
-0.45022818446159363,
0.6498257517814636,
0.036669980734586716,
0.37363943457603455,
0.7217114567756653,
0.25098884105682373,
0.8158517479896545,
-0.26238328218460083,
-0.46730437874794006,
0.38168224692344666,
0.37399762868881226,
-0.2257814109325409,
-0.3712445795536041,
0.8827905654907227,
-0.7205884456634521,
-0.27448076009750366,
-0.3142385184764862,
-0.035802118480205536,
0.2945723533630371,
-0.03407525271177292,
0.3867446482181549,
0.621373176574707,
-0.658311665058136,
0.35857996344566345,
0.42755773663520813,
0.3489619791507721,
0.4609588086605072,
0.662340521812439,
-0.1159624457359314,
-0.5003722310066223,
0.5055060982704163,
0.015646982938051224,
-0.05843162536621094,
0.2108125239610672,
-0.10125209391117096,
-0.04746602103114128,
-0.39653876423835754,
-0.3604315221309662,
-0.013161802664399147,
-0.7096706628799438,
-0.3914138674736023,
-0.7707470059394836,
-0.04057018831372261,
-0.17298667132854462,
-0.2784916162490845,
-0.8072740435600281,
-0.63274747133255,
-0.11963372677564621,
-0.17759409546852112,
0.41750434041023254,
0.473257839679718,
-0.3811494708061218,
0.36873871088027954,
-0.9703799486160278,
0.12147337198257446,
0.3221491575241089,
0.3207464814186096,
-0.03207596763968468,
-0.32571855187416077,
-0.4274398684501648,
-0.3508330285549164,
-0.44247573614120483,
-0.6366586685180664,
0.29925817251205444,
0.5911880135536194,
0.4072544276714325,
0.59035325050354,
0.37364986538887024,
0.693993866443634,
-0.6071194410324097,
0.6915890574455261,
0.304042249917984,
-1.24366295337677,
0.5863186717033386,
-0.020808063447475433,
0.07646992057561874,
0.7752991914749146,
0.24516333639621735,
-0.7966638803482056,
-0.40566062927246094,
-0.7250310182571411,
-1.1401424407958984,
0.440885990858078,
0.2715076804161072,
-0.23002463579177856,
-0.3488186001777649,
0.5096338987350464,
0.4409134089946747,
0.05902588739991188,
-0.394980788230896,
-0.5808054804801941,
0.024700745940208435,
-0.07864806056022644,
0.15345492959022522,
-0.049825601279735565,
-0.2613714039325714,
-0.10059309750795364,
0.5041896104812622,
-0.05896124616265297,
0.31330999732017517,
0.632219135761261,
-0.038161613047122955,
-0.3077484965324402,
0.8912989497184753,
-0.1633148342370987,
0.6093329191207886,
-0.34234103560447693,
0.44720199704170227,
0.33381304144859314,
-0.19152842462062836,
0.15196877717971802,
0.24532286822795868,
-0.13128823041915894,
0.20829279720783234,
0.10038891434669495,
0.48826864361763,
0.3218095898628235,
-0.6624706983566284,
0.36720967292785645,
-0.26311880350112915,
0.10015689581632614,
-0.3856680393218994,
0.03231662139296532,
-0.019587215036153793,
0.20229412615299225,
0.6920592784881592,
0.10489217191934586,
0.5693448185920715,
-0.4119805097579956,
0.5417503714561462,
0.02433481253683567,
-0.723713755607605,
-0.3775511384010315,
0.6441847681999207,
0.6240924000740051,
-0.24409182369709015,
0.5299243330955505,
-0.4508594572544098,
-0.5612679123878479,
0.6674827337265015,
0.29283982515335083,
0.7245326638221741,
-0.2574901878833771,
-0.33095693588256836,
0.9094082713127136,
0.22915241122245789,
0.006594434846192598,
0.07598463445901871,
0.121147021651268,
-0.794329047203064,
-0.6188496351242065,
-0.7131683230400085,
-0.8644709587097168,
-0.07839931547641754,
-1.0342272520065308,
0.477674275636673,
-0.3291885554790497,
-0.388761043548584,
-0.026564141735434532,
-0.1138843521475792,
-1.2674741744995117,
-0.0058852555230259895,
0.3372604250907898,
1.127855896949768,
-0.526151716709137,
0.5355315208435059,
0.7239798307418823,
-0.08725179731845856,
-0.5811943411827087,
-0.5883981585502625,
0.22389496862888336,
0.09842346608638763,
0.51060950756073,
0.001991978147998452,
-0.12521766126155853,
0.053251370787620544,
-0.414507657289505,
-0.6814837455749512,
1.0985580682754517,
-0.023370398208498955,
-1.3020660877227783,
-0.05056426674127579,
-0.09659145772457123,
0.39313480257987976,
-0.7631349563598633,
0.4505160450935364,
0.6149936318397522,
0.6146471500396729,
0.13431404531002045,
-1.2279627323150635,
0.00407255906611681,
-0.20142637193202972,
-0.2893698811531067,
0.41646018624305725,
-0.5478677153587341,
0.5779095888137817,
-0.256061315536499,
-0.4069749414920807,
0.31723207235336304,
0.8583534359931946,
0.46639516949653625,
0.7239842414855957,
0.4605739414691925,
0.6092097759246826,
0.8007931113243103,
-0.33121079206466675,
0.9801381230354309,
-0.6113519668579102,
0.8108306527137756,
1.5236536264419556,
-0.388001412153244,
0.8457992672920227,
0.43865156173706055,
-0.12069118767976761,
0.5879283547401428,
0.31164872646331787,
0.16070424020290375,
0.49601393938064575,
0.11773966252803802,
-0.5649808049201965,
-0.4602101743221283,
-0.27527448534965515,
-0.3994278609752655,
-0.0798904225230217,
0.465137779712677,
-0.0975797101855278,
-0.36041802167892456,
-0.2251749038696289,
-0.06366602331399918,
-0.10381775349378586,
-0.5628581643104553,
0.5998844504356384,
0.09216289967298508,
-0.10475990176200867,
-0.09867379069328308,
0.021397488191723824,
0.8933072090148926,
-0.6438684463500977,
0.027116455137729645,
0.1397918462753296,
0.44270461797714233,
-0.2983451187610626,
-0.35091835260391235,
0.7177219986915588,
0.3859439194202423,
-0.4217868745326996,
0.25263625383377075,
0.7445321679115295,
-0.30832505226135254,
-0.6152991056442261,
0.4117692708969116,
0.6187423467636108,
0.15112334489822388,
-0.1141931489109993,
-0.5029183030128479,
0.2294592708349228,
-0.29599133133888245,
-0.35089796781539917,
0.12522843480110168,
0.5428944826126099,
0.30841970443725586,
0.46757569909095764,
0.668674886226654,
0.149000883102417,
-0.011951319873332977,
-0.061137713491916656,
0.7400696873664856,
-0.8095954656600952,
-0.2209538370370865,
-0.5173238515853882,
0.7093095779418945,
0.014880397357046604,
-0.32152456045150757,
0.2388247400522232,
0.8865796327590942,
0.6930169463157654,
0.06343526393175125,
0.8460901975631714,
-0.4600973427295685,
0.9802768230438232,
-0.0078957574442029,
0.3710955083370209,
-0.08512430638074875,
0.25193315744400024,
-0.23352733254432678,
-0.8955135941505432,
-0.41080915927886963,
0.569057047367096,
-0.32151365280151367,
-0.3147304356098175,
0.803886353969574,
0.7716451287269592,
-0.3339363634586334,
-0.11392232775688171,
0.16761162877082825,
0.3543146848678589,
0.3273985683917999,
0.49277544021606445,
0.8030936121940613,
-0.4166257679462433,
0.93072509765625,
-0.4487169682979584,
-0.3047870993614197,
-0.17302264273166656,
-1.3251984119415283,
-0.41216734051704407,
-0.539789080619812,
-0.7314887642860413,
-0.2381424754858017,
0.3252774775028229,
1.3309402465820312,
0.8134164214134216,
-1.2866439819335938,
-0.34137091040611267,
-0.01271122507750988,
0.10069449990987778,
-0.41270750761032104,
-0.266492635011673,
0.41737809777259827,
0.08251985162496567,
-0.9832839965820312,
0.17100156843662262,
-0.020032819360494614,
-0.31532660126686096,
0.14708532392978668,
-0.15589143335819244,
0.2934560179710388,
0.13335372507572174,
0.4381710886955261,
0.442638635635376,
-0.6085119843482971,
-0.5354709029197693,
-0.23402762413024902,
-0.11553878337144852,
0.011734524741768837,
1.1717092990875244,
-0.6247252821922302,
0.2978414297103882,
0.35393714904785156,
0.18863606452941895,
0.5907906293869019,
-0.1762750893831253,
0.33874082565307617,
-0.47287607192993164,
-0.011612427420914173,
0.1771882176399231,
0.5650675296783447,
0.34688374400138855,
-0.2626815438270569,
0.6143749356269836,
-0.005570009350776672,
-0.813441812992096,
-0.5515461564064026,
0.13034547865390778,
-1.33957040309906,
0.22842255234718323,
0.7625329494476318,
-0.2526562511920929,
-0.05515545979142189,
-0.37569165229797363,
-0.43622109293937683,
0.31675985455513,
-0.7079812288284302,
0.8257101774215698,
0.8618541359901428,
-0.5663866996765137,
-0.234156534075737,
-0.061160508543252945,
0.2792944610118866,
-0.1758023500442505,
-0.43772101402282715,
0.3873158395290375,
0.6278181076049805,
0.6193898320198059,
0.3562370240688324,
0.447684109210968,
-0.04993915930390358,
0.30058830976486206,
-0.16891981661319733,
0.8089712262153625,
-0.031812671571969986,
-0.2563677728176117,
-0.24098338186740875,
0.3710663914680481,
0.13730859756469727,
0.3002137243747711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14099v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14099v2 | Let Guidelines Guide You: A Prescriptive Guideline-Centered Data Annotation Methodology | 2024-06-20T08:24:57 | 2024-07-02T15:38:17 | Federico Ruggeri, Eleonora Misino, Arianna Muti, Katerina Korre, Paolo Torroni, Alberto Barrón-Cedeño | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce the Guideline-Centered annotation process, a novel data
annotation methodology focused on reporting the annotation guidelines
associated with each data sample. We identify three main limitations of the
standard prescriptive annotation process and describe how the
Guideline-Centered methodology overcomes them by reducing the loss of
information in the annotation process and ensuring adherence to guidelines.
Additionally, we discuss how the Guideline-Centered enables the reuse of
annotated data across multiple tasks at the cost of a single human-annotation
process. | [
-0.48153015971183777,
-0.6403985023498535,
0.7688471078872681,
0.12622800469398499,
-0.7575546503067017,
-0.24552316963672638,
-0.1823129653930664,
-0.3980494737625122,
0.36817124485969543,
1.2346383333206177,
-1.050106167793274,
-0.945253849029541,
-0.43548890948295593,
0.05426431819796562,
-0.284776896238327,
1.4938733577728271,
-0.3153174817562103,
0.35298916697502136,
-0.24746595323085785,
-0.19847238063812256,
-0.6737169027328491,
-0.7293710708618164,
-0.22580291330814362,
-0.3407381474971771,
0.8914031982421875,
1.0870180130004883,
0.4733417332172394,
0.7835121154785156,
0.9998440146446228,
-0.055342771112918854,
0.3209817111492157,
0.03404013812541962,
-0.3271668553352356,
0.46033838391304016,
0.08551937341690063,
-0.4143108129501343,
-0.5836088061332703,
0.6325928568840027,
0.23691168427467346,
1.2386491298675537,
-0.3879314064979553,
0.5813376307487488,
-0.1361706256866455,
0.5683639645576477,
-0.7218723893165588,
-0.10554623603820801,
-0.09542515128850937,
0.0354488343000412,
-0.858181893825531,
-0.5294245481491089,
-0.2874988317489624,
-1.0614559650421143,
0.4205102324485779,
-1.0444594621658325,
0.30989158153533936,
0.09128817915916443,
0.39554843306541443,
0.4276462495326996,
-0.08970396220684052,
-0.5314235687255859,
-0.7940647602081299,
0.46414080262184143,
-0.4069271981716156,
-0.046787187457084656,
0.6921057105064392,
0.6933286190032959,
0.1624731570482254,
-1.1171859502792358,
-0.33543843030929565,
-0.02693033590912819,
-0.2170822024345398,
-0.31027528643608093,
0.4229307174682617,
0.12040405720472336,
0.46055713295936584,
0.08665648102760315,
-0.31331783533096313,
-0.11587872356176376,
-0.43897998332977295,
-0.2747561037540436,
0.9671561121940613,
-0.08848091959953308,
-0.268604040145874,
0.06045912206172943,
-0.3677594065666199,
0.23162314295768738,
-0.8058509230613708,
-0.19048041105270386,
0.2224547266960144,
0.44659027457237244,
0.3911588191986084,
0.47977736592292786,
-0.3085024058818817,
0.5014011263847351,
0.08922645449638367,
-0.1327883005142212,
0.4596414268016815,
-0.728044867515564,
-0.010758752003312111,
0.3189835846424103,
0.2934746742248535,
0.8956313133239746,
0.5808379054069519,
-0.1260683238506317,
0.041691530495882034,
-0.08061077445745468,
0.45307305455207825,
-0.6386098861694336,
-0.3585788905620575,
-0.2475953996181488,
-0.5748744606971741,
-0.11500165611505508,
-0.031596191227436066,
-0.5389379858970642,
-0.6282828450202942,
-0.7027309536933899,
0.24673709273338318,
-0.1186736524105072,
-0.005131775513291359,
-0.13706032931804657,
-0.23078681528568268,
0.2796909809112549,
0.6563453078269958,
-0.6730190515518188,
0.6040748357772827,
0.5801798701286316,
0.709186851978302,
0.0836285948753357,
0.05089570954442024,
-0.46206411719322205,
0.06540390104055405,
-0.2983047664165497,
1.0565983057022095,
-0.6432284116744995,
-0.5365810990333557,
-0.12449754029512405,
0.15880806744098663,
0.2717858552932739,
-0.2687714993953705,
1.1051267385482788,
-0.09521044790744781,
-0.06865404546260834,
-0.760940432548523,
-0.5900787711143494,
-0.43350836634635925,
-0.016156774014234543,
-0.7398387789726257,
0.41452130675315857,
0.023048952221870422,
-0.7143148183822632,
1.0308711528778076,
-0.6501750946044922,
-0.37101808190345764,
0.2532469928264618,
-0.14412039518356323,
-0.32552725076675415,
-0.19217267632484436,
0.07450684159994125,
0.5288460850715637,
-0.3640841543674469,
0.17636364698410034,
-0.5035272836685181,
-0.3449808657169342,
-0.18554243445396423,
0.0684022456407547,
0.6611449122428894,
0.32405149936676025,
-0.08819893002510071,
0.4677407443523407,
-0.8505193591117859,
0.0488751158118248,
-0.2577207386493683,
0.0565204955637455,
-0.29790225625038147,
0.0587313286960125,
0.41516783833503723,
-0.03474648296833038,
0.22244957089424133,
-0.44043052196502686,
0.5806654691696167,
0.5573195219039917,
0.10253602266311646,
0.7449244856834412,
0.26848915219306946,
0.5881415605545044,
-0.38789647817611694,
0.62696772813797,
-0.2749288082122803,
0.5959842205047607,
-0.31805282831192017,
-0.37668243050575256,
-0.46819284558296204,
0.0570911206305027,
0.14384442567825317,
0.4026666283607483,
-0.10411684215068817,
0.16804510354995728,
0.08802623301744461,
-0.6385931372642517,
-0.5802088379859924,
0.11230914294719696,
0.12483127415180206,
0.8697577714920044,
0.33971107006073,
-0.4965989887714386,
-0.9300314784049988,
-1.1714144945144653,
0.19068463146686554,
0.24387308955192566,
0.19053705036640167,
-0.047906432300806046,
0.3627465069293976,
-0.14661332964897156,
0.9661440253257751,
-0.4337819814682007,
-0.5442006587982178,
-0.12905658781528473,
0.20970740914344788,
0.15977934002876282,
0.62855464220047,
0.454834520816803,
-0.9709751605987549,
-0.34802278876304626,
-0.419350266456604,
-0.7053546905517578,
-0.4496494233608246,
-0.011608307249844074,
-0.1654333770275116,
-0.07631136476993561,
0.6652669310569763,
-0.020502669736742973,
0.8443024754524231,
0.17210781574249268,
-0.3538562059402466,
0.4624854326248169,
-0.20779170095920563,
0.14532767236232758,
-0.6648718118667603,
0.2598409056663513,
0.1702856868505478,
-0.30832603573799133,
-0.541397750377655,
-0.46266263723373413,
0.033619027584791183,
0.19881947338581085,
0.23503044247627258,
0.0014587311306968331,
-0.20077283680438995,
0.36765241622924805,
-0.00717124855145812,
0.0657929852604866,
0.10371788591146469,
0.08963944017887115,
0.10204967856407166,
0.39126935601234436,
0.4628298282623291,
-0.6024851202964783,
0.6564928293228149,
0.4510258436203003,
0.045593082904815674,
1.2300565242767334,
-0.3843841850757599,
0.24069367349147797,
-0.5581311583518982,
0.6213921904563904,
-0.8219704031944275,
-0.2912091612815857,
0.5520501732826233,
-0.28963643312454224,
0.09788260608911514,
-0.181565523147583,
-0.3544861972332001,
-0.19096753001213074,
-0.47206851840019226,
0.2186688780784607,
0.3241792619228363,
-0.27060893177986145,
0.4259687662124634,
0.2068898230791092,
-0.16223375499248505,
-0.5648799538612366,
-0.9267604947090149,
-0.04995143413543701,
-0.4147375226020813,
-0.38800954818725586,
0.3020922839641571,
-0.3019927740097046,
-0.20907534658908844,
0.036056023091077805,
-0.15727545320987701,
-0.3509715497493744,
0.11827617138624191,
0.7050851583480835,
0.053218841552734375,
0.024103501811623573,
0.2464878261089325,
-0.29973867535591125,
-0.4343089461326599,
0.20198912918567657,
-0.2841234505176544,
0.16794556379318237,
0.31500133872032166,
-0.3819279074668884,
-0.7702750563621521,
0.8105672001838684,
0.26364865899086,
-0.19025230407714844,
0.3430369794368744,
0.5681620240211487,
-0.3327614367008209,
-0.009319053031504154,
-0.759676456451416,
-0.08551959693431854,
-0.3717038035392761,
-0.07749085873365402,
-0.3334566652774811,
-0.41536423563957214,
0.657036542892456,
-0.0941728875041008,
0.31113335490226746,
0.5019155740737915,
-0.030473904684185982,
-0.26301658153533936,
0.8061355352401733,
0.9516739845275879,
0.2739981710910797,
0.48564809560775757,
-0.008977612480521202,
0.13360656797885895,
-0.9191288948059082,
-0.6019269227981567,
-0.6931139826774597,
-0.23022642731666565,
-0.4712252616882324,
-0.05973227322101593,
0.07174941897392273,
0.46464258432388306,
-0.1613406240940094,
0.15210269391536713,
-0.9139057993888855,
0.3472917973995209,
0.7565046548843384,
0.11621745675802231,
0.29241877794265747,
-0.4091305136680603,
0.14301744103431702,
0.008738941513001919,
-0.48574283719062805,
-0.9606620669364929,
1.5996559858322144,
0.25725582242012024,
1.0680060386657715,
-0.23363764584064484,
1.030922532081604,
0.32881566882133484,
0.7460967302322388,
-0.49807095527648926,
0.4081518352031708,
0.1258181780576706,
-0.8260000348091125,
-0.16444994509220123,
0.012503108941018581,
-0.5376492738723755,
-0.3694968819618225,
-0.30378487706184387,
-0.7829897403717041,
0.03931725025177002,
0.2631872594356537,
-0.49416327476501465,
0.0080831628292799,
-1.0416792631149292,
0.8103832006454468,
-0.06476683169603348,
-0.09877940267324448,
0.07345167547464371,
-0.7775028347969055,
-0.13701744377613068,
-0.2331715077161789,
0.12421654909849167,
-0.31233882904052734,
-0.0698392391204834,
1.0658241510391235,
-0.5502123236656189,
0.8024811744689941,
-0.6409235596656799,
0.3231089115142822,
0.4056156575679779,
-0.6262262463569641,
0.2970576882362366,
0.1428486555814743,
-0.006050936412066221,
-0.14727436006069183,
0.16241991519927979,
-0.4665558338165283,
-0.2805519998073578,
0.2869275212287903,
-0.13992373645305634,
-0.5610396265983582,
-0.37581804394721985,
-0.28094130754470825,
-0.025794103741645813,
0.4116443395614624,
0.4561389982700348,
0.06843502074480057,
-0.15631459653377533,
0.20694191753864288,
0.360973060131073,
0.4802425503730774,
0.2147393375635147,
0.3298608660697937,
-0.12939485907554626,
-0.3088909983634949,
0.3286682963371277,
0.6947284936904907,
-0.03448110818862915,
-0.17382243275642395,
0.1537380814552307,
-0.4282365143299103,
-0.9258230328559875,
-0.09867370128631592,
-0.04536036029458046,
-1.112879991531372,
0.05257931724190712,
-0.08597864210605621,
0.1523904800415039,
-0.5533068180084229,
-0.4685862958431244,
0.05313461646437645,
-0.3191772997379303,
-0.2651674747467041,
-0.35533276200294495,
0.7051480412483215,
0.9675707221031189,
-0.20027248561382294,
0.41600552201271057,
-0.2995184063911438,
0.01969604752957821,
0.14302873611450195,
0.533501923084259,
-0.5233200192451477,
0.07724425941705704,
-0.31613433361053467,
-0.1203862652182579,
-0.07978026568889618,
-0.8583424687385559,
-0.14011676609516144,
-0.1062525287270546,
0.8827053308486938,
0.37507742643356323,
0.12234602123498917,
0.6822633743286133,
-0.3791410028934479,
0.6459909677505493,
0.212209552526474,
-0.7287589311599731,
0.7669548392295837,
-0.4192159175872803,
0.11016646772623062,
1.1006931066513062,
0.44923707842826843,
-0.5623981952667236,
0.16156186163425446,
-0.5365992784500122,
-0.8572558760643005,
0.38215968012809753,
-0.08559983223676682,
-0.3249228596687317,
0.3543635606765747,
1.074445128440857,
0.23013749718666077,
0.4548059105873108,
-0.2956543564796448,
-0.39574047923088074,
-0.37462562322616577,
-0.22421103715896606,
-0.16247759759426117,
-0.15297000110149384,
-0.5158129334449768,
-0.2849562466144562,
0.3353022634983063,
-0.36240556836128235,
-0.12764503061771393,
0.5954193472862244,
0.1228708028793335,
-0.09417358040809631,
0.05767524614930153,
0.4384031295776367,
1.1428000926971436,
-0.48608967661857605,
-0.0010690608760342002,
0.03269324079155922,
-0.7552927732467651,
-0.08664745837450027,
0.5271888971328735,
-0.3571835458278656,
-0.030234184116125107,
0.4776058793067932,
0.4340980648994446,
-0.11879345774650574,
-0.15374530851840973,
0.4135071039199829,
-0.25513318181037903,
-0.2613814175128937,
-0.7731858491897583,
0.0627669170498848,
-0.1746407449245453,
0.17512394487857819,
0.7120328545570374,
0.10912998765707016,
0.13018733263015747,
-0.4745243489742279,
0.6356882452964783,
0.10532930493354797,
-0.46449804306030273,
-0.2014644891023636,
0.6138031482696533,
0.36393070220947266,
-0.23119620978832245,
0.31796175241470337,
-0.049408651888370514,
-0.1347990185022354,
0.47331273555755615,
0.23058819770812988,
0.8454151749610901,
-0.1936568319797516,
0.11533533781766891,
0.3587656617164612,
0.2584441900253296,
-0.19733084738254547,
0.4071282148361206,
-0.3890058696269989,
-0.23636212944984436,
-0.5236644148826599,
-0.1941796988248825,
-0.6041698455810547,
-0.37545138597488403,
-1.0591814517974854,
0.23653890192508698,
-0.9750682711601257,
-0.32982367277145386,
0.6068587303161621,
0.10667799413204193,
-0.6898759603500366,
0.41850554943084717,
0.18501617014408112,
1.1009222269058228,
-0.5663229823112488,
0.8006383180618286,
0.6641457676887512,
-0.7521309852600098,
-0.9059997797012329,
-0.11501532793045044,
0.26156505942344666,
-0.5556361079216003,
0.5292961597442627,
0.334425687789917,
-0.1335827261209488,
-0.3845416307449341,
-1.0139135122299194,
-0.6259751915931702,
1.3331706523895264,
0.038170553743839264,
-0.5467253923416138,
-0.24074210226535797,
-0.16185235977172852,
0.41143789887428284,
-0.7121791839599609,
0.0944373682141304,
0.9992694854736328,
0.8872991800308228,
0.17600546777248383,
-1.036723256111145,
0.21712955832481384,
-0.17818161845207214,
-0.4963074326515198,
0.017209012061357498,
-0.2697324752807617,
0.772411584854126,
-0.4137822985649109,
-0.14848342537879944,
0.030137687921524048,
0.08509273827075958,
-0.029192330315709114,
0.664378821849823,
0.4785008132457733,
0.337247371673584,
1.046774983406067,
-0.27606046199798584,
0.9315542578697205,
0.13901464641094208,
0.15207894146442413,
1.143261432647705,
-0.30905136466026306,
0.43703800439834595,
0.6198825836181641,
0.2783992886543274,
0.5640685558319092,
0.7251234650611877,
-0.07435622066259384,
0.44823557138442993,
0.21600310504436493,
-0.1264103204011917,
-0.11298907548189163,
-0.5092758536338806,
-0.2707965075969696,
0.13170567154884338,
0.3353443741798401,
-0.2813311219215393,
-0.20746666193008423,
-0.1152743473649025,
0.36414775252342224,
0.19248667359352112,
-0.47471174597740173,
0.5803568363189697,
-0.14711125195026398,
-0.6916071772575378,
0.22555901110172272,
-0.416083961725235,
0.4488290846347809,
-0.8277981877326965,
-0.26876676082611084,
0.1269061416387558,
0.1660163402557373,
-0.7381300330162048,
-0.8086593151092529,
0.5044497847557068,
-0.061721786856651306,
-0.3205629885196686,
-0.5239898562431335,
0.5139961838722229,
-0.2219500094652176,
-0.3078700602054596,
0.0730307325720787,
0.026655172929167747,
-0.19967348873615265,
-0.11563432216644287,
-0.38922908902168274,
-0.12408372014760971,
0.019210273399949074,
-0.38455086946487427,
-0.3324996829032898,
0.5446445941925049,
-0.37615031003952026,
0.6839137077331543,
0.7061672210693359,
0.12742330133914948,
-0.12822812795639038,
0.14096052944660187,
0.8831472396850586,
-0.9953662157058716,
-0.41766878962516785,
-0.5076818466186523,
0.45289063453674316,
-0.3485422134399414,
-0.4793511629104614,
0.7832088470458984,
0.2148185670375824,
0.7277592420578003,
0.36436763405799866,
1.0575629472732544,
-0.1329682469367981,
0.8883153200149536,
-0.3977906107902527,
0.42231571674346924,
-0.30147701501846313,
0.07397137582302094,
-0.30503618717193604,
-0.8505570888519287,
-0.8247554302215576,
0.8197786808013916,
-0.5280107855796814,
0.09554359316825867,
0.7292211651802063,
0.42860937118530273,
0.4580002725124359,
0.254769891500473,
-0.149546280503273,
-0.19582271575927734,
0.5085279941558838,
0.5193742513656616,
0.5269926190376282,
0.13040421903133392,
0.375773161649704,
-0.4784936010837555,
-0.5823163390159607,
-0.2918891906738281,
-0.9165320992469788,
-0.6957786679267883,
-0.5610707998275757,
-0.3292348384857178,
-0.379260390996933,
-0.05344700440764427,
0.8596386909484863,
1.4537053108215332,
-0.5078034996986389,
0.09365586936473846,
-0.3147270083427429,
0.019702864810824394,
-0.2466871589422226,
-0.16822530329227448,
0.34109875559806824,
-0.19665662944316864,
-0.34925079345703125,
-0.25741177797317505,
0.08729655295610428,
0.169600248336792,
-0.4977687895298004,
-0.07847987115383148,
-0.16662158071994781,
-0.13064786791801453,
0.04238031059503555,
0.26950567960739136,
-0.19626493752002716,
-0.40652400255203247,
-0.1797117292881012,
-0.007957899011671543,
0.02708699181675911,
1.169580101966858,
-0.5797357559204102,
0.7405927181243896,
0.1841016262769699,
0.2201339304447174,
0.6063112616539001,
0.0613703653216362,
0.6497211456298828,
-0.6748186945915222,
0.2131044566631317,
0.6114226579666138,
0.10781451314687729,
0.3316287696361542,
-0.37343013286590576,
0.7740868926048279,
-0.0076865884475409985,
-0.6990283131599426,
-0.5158255100250244,
0.3893416225910187,
-1.2945733070373535,
0.03903042525053024,
0.854396641254425,
-0.2859747111797333,
-0.219086691737175,
-0.48890823125839233,
-0.5465598106384277,
0.11992555856704712,
-0.41124382615089417,
0.32901251316070557,
0.6657533049583435,
-0.5063539743423462,
-0.29873448610305786,
-0.6154581308364868,
1.031646728515625,
0.017028236761689186,
-0.7654701471328735,
0.26773086190223694,
0.7598045468330383,
0.44078493118286133,
0.496720552444458,
0.9424538016319275,
0.05240552872419357,
0.17697890102863312,
0.07211565226316452,
0.0380713976919651,
-0.16574671864509583,
-0.4229182302951813,
-0.16118811070919037,
0.14722926914691925,
0.3621835708618164,
-0.5088749527931213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14092v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14092v1 | Seamless Language Expansion: Enhancing Multilingual Mastery in Self-Supervised Models | 2024-06-20T08:13:30 | 2024-06-20T08:13:30 | Jing Xu, Minglin Wu, Xixin Wu, Helen Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Self-supervised (SSL) models have shown great performance in various
downstream tasks. However, they are typically developed for limited languages,
and may encounter new languages in real-world. Developing a SSL model for each
new language is costly. Thus, it is vital to figure out how to efficiently
adapt existed SSL models to a new language without impairing its original
abilities. We propose adaptation methods which integrate LoRA to existed SSL
models to extend new language. We also develop preservation strategies which
include data combination and re-clustering to retain abilities on existed
languages. Applied to mHuBERT, we investigate their effectiveness on speech
re-synthesis task. Experiments show that our adaptation methods enable mHuBERT
to be applied to a new language (Mandarin) with MOS value increased about 1.6
and the relative value of WER reduced up to 61.72%. Also, our preservation
strategies ensure that the performance on both existed and new languages
remains intact. | [
-0.1404842883348465,
-0.9354684352874756,
0.23758965730667114,
0.3843034505844116,
0.0031163208186626434,
0.3478963375091553,
-0.38157251477241516,
-0.4220902621746063,
0.24948424100875854,
0.6514636278152466,
-0.22914472222328186,
-0.29028794169425964,
-0.3370862901210785,
-0.093668133020401,
-0.3993241488933563,
0.9881687164306641,
0.15112313628196716,
-0.12983208894729614,
0.051654644310474396,
-0.18165306746959686,
-0.3851972818374634,
-0.7035966515541077,
-0.4819299280643463,
-0.31705206632614136,
0.41560235619544983,
0.5185567140579224,
0.5799245834350586,
0.7400400042533875,
0.3777415454387665,
0.3500331938266754,
-0.06721124798059464,
0.10562334954738617,
-0.39050063490867615,
0.29711398482322693,
-0.24961499869823456,
-0.4037855267524719,
-0.8255602121353149,
-0.25447601079940796,
0.8706322908401489,
0.8371842503547668,
-0.3990497589111328,
0.21627137064933777,
0.28192177414894104,
0.9600279927253723,
-0.7338385581970215,
0.13623833656311035,
-0.5309654474258423,
0.12092123925685883,
-0.09645269811153412,
-0.17360429465770721,
-0.3510361313819885,
-0.2503829300403595,
0.3953613042831421,
-0.6202913522720337,
-0.016253814101219177,
-0.48442572355270386,
0.2831079065799713,
0.24418090283870697,
-0.38866183161735535,
0.02690601721405983,
-0.9476796984672546,
0.8807486295700073,
-0.642667829990387,
0.6821630001068115,
0.12916573882102966,
0.2008691132068634,
-0.22481654584407806,
-0.6579376459121704,
-0.1873178780078888,
-0.29584819078445435,
0.2641616463661194,
0.27985885739326477,
-0.28835463523864746,
-0.08685880154371262,
0.010388522408902645,
0.40774717926979065,
-0.32073673605918884,
0.1741883009672165,
-0.5829840898513794,
-0.3049333095550537,
0.8926944136619568,
-0.06291919946670532,
0.2826416790485382,
-0.1289176642894745,
-0.11289198696613312,
-0.11038154363632202,
-0.5473490357398987,
0.14750637114048004,
0.2002577781677246,
0.6302857995033264,
-0.17767667770385742,
0.4800751805305481,
-0.2186303585767746,
0.6876055002212524,
-0.06792804598808289,
-0.40509483218193054,
0.3889039158821106,
-0.46045297384262085,
-0.1320321261882782,
0.024121860042214394,
0.510938286781311,
-0.12727515399456024,
0.37738674879074097,
-0.02844678796827793,
0.1846773773431778,
-0.2152547687292099,
0.22553318738937378,
-0.3738374412059784,
-0.2720549404621124,
0.1441364586353302,
-0.4721004366874695,
-0.1900745928287506,
-0.3454957604408264,
-0.5243146419525146,
-0.19561225175857544,
-0.405003160238266,
0.40542927384376526,
-0.5549084544181824,
-0.611447274684906,
-0.04672063887119293,
-0.04735708609223366,
0.2828676700592041,
0.4146938920021057,
-1.0432708263397217,
0.2128559947013855,
0.4516729712486267,
0.6829338073730469,
-0.4326648712158203,
-0.8092615008354187,
-0.5419846773147583,
0.32299473881721497,
-0.5186152458190918,
0.5781399011611938,
-0.23158372938632965,
-0.30581146478652954,
0.1909068524837494,
0.17727403342723846,
-0.051613159477710724,
-0.3826322555541992,
0.5025059580802917,
-0.40654435753822327,
0.21949037909507751,
-0.06679931282997131,
-0.4486982226371765,
-0.26269304752349854,
-0.022435730323195457,
-0.5284215211868286,
1.001338243484497,
0.33823898434638977,
-0.4876198470592499,
0.09121660888195038,
-0.7780737280845642,
-0.8433742523193359,
-0.0483463779091835,
0.16589514911174774,
-0.1537926197052002,
0.3614826798439026,
0.27111542224884033,
0.36823639273643494,
0.08246254920959473,
0.2124660164117813,
-0.2634838819503784,
-0.05588820204138756,
0.08636026829481125,
-0.48556214570999146,
0.9259229302406311,
0.21476559340953827,
-0.1036837249994278,
0.0736231654882431,
-0.7288624048233032,
0.2381518930196762,
-0.06137241795659065,
-0.6423265933990479,
-0.4037924110889435,
0.0010276417015120387,
0.032878290861845016,
-0.03837885707616806,
0.5323185324668884,
-0.2537155747413635,
0.23068583011627197,
-0.48663634061813354,
0.36892199516296387,
0.6671738028526306,
-0.21665655076503754,
0.6287355422973633,
-0.08587490022182465,
0.629677414894104,
0.10665082186460495,
0.3779517114162445,
-0.3888242542743683,
-0.28970786929130554,
-1.187187910079956,
-0.08605606853961945,
0.5056697726249695,
0.6768755912780762,
-0.7214735746383667,
0.49645018577575684,
-0.4140850603580475,
-0.5675646066665649,
-0.7161531448364258,
0.46336668729782104,
0.17244963347911835,
0.21536563336849213,
0.4549233615398407,
-0.5674615502357483,
-0.4581122100353241,
-1.029819369316101,
-0.1962578296661377,
-0.215996652841568,
0.21021921932697296,
0.02564666047692299,
0.1835649013519287,
-0.21740175783634186,
0.858034610748291,
-0.30986642837524414,
-0.30351021885871887,
-0.32805079221725464,
-0.1751629263162613,
0.24705109000205994,
0.7248123288154602,
0.47566595673561096,
-0.5658196806907654,
-0.5512021780014038,
0.24556997418403625,
-0.908344030380249,
0.13338586688041687,
-0.09326612204313278,
-0.05788007378578186,
0.3294164538383484,
0.5913724899291992,
0.020479323342442513,
0.35996249318122864,
0.9590502977371216,
0.13331833481788635,
0.5553189516067505,
-0.7133357524871826,
0.06175807863473892,
-1.277151346206665,
-0.3909777104854584,
-0.1321827471256256,
-0.2697165310382843,
-1.0739384889602661,
0.2633599638938904,
0.15865793824195862,
-0.07604892551898956,
-0.6569036245346069,
0.6125494837760925,
-0.6650606989860535,
-0.13514241576194763,
-0.5879084467887878,
0.27326324582099915,
-0.22511811554431915,
0.4549270272254944,
0.07481468468904495,
0.5817856788635254,
1.0616236925125122,
-0.6822382211685181,
0.21799415349960327,
0.18891072273254395,
-0.10893222689628601,
0.2943224608898163,
-0.5161482691764832,
-0.05147601664066315,
-0.035145215690135956,
0.039248403161764145,
-0.8138067126274109,
-0.22910086810588837,
0.07441540062427521,
-0.31543517112731934,
0.3538316488265991,
-0.3481411933898926,
-0.1856357902288437,
-0.16114205121994019,
-0.0784149244427681,
0.40446218848228455,
0.5179737210273743,
-0.7751151323318481,
0.9404460191726685,
0.4950365126132965,
-0.36054378747940063,
-0.47021082043647766,
-0.8884217739105225,
0.2594567537307739,
-0.29135358333587646,
-0.519794762134552,
0.2639687955379486,
-0.24974185228347778,
-0.0531550757586956,
-0.01806584745645523,
0.08823996782302856,
-0.33386659622192383,
0.18410317599773407,
0.06260813027620316,
0.09285985678434372,
-0.39967647194862366,
0.02595936320722103,
0.4649515151977539,
0.01525023765861988,
-0.21132183074951172,
-0.2599220275878906,
0.45094990730285645,
-0.14459539949893951,
-0.38170745968818665,
-0.5644384622573853,
0.3930414319038391,
0.6132151484489441,
-0.4505976736545563,
0.5584664940834045,
0.6547312140464783,
-0.25730982422828674,
-0.07461602240800858,
-0.5748307704925537,
0.040723804384469986,
-0.5145280361175537,
0.4478444457054138,
-0.6364619135856628,
-1.1559159755706787,
0.41026371717453003,
-0.017595982179045677,
0.09730945527553558,
0.342372328042984,
0.641572892665863,
0.018818622455000877,
0.6641093492507935,
1.0356929302215576,
-0.4002978503704071,
0.7861221432685852,
-0.03372475877404213,
0.1507880538702011,
-1.06405770778656,
0.17482969164848328,
-0.16342143714427948,
0.18148314952850342,
-0.8787370920181274,
-0.5089684724807739,
0.3111315369606018,
0.15551608800888062,
0.2665097117424011,
0.6618995666503906,
-0.332365483045578,
0.3414272665977478,
0.7167401313781738,
0.12388895452022552,
0.31901344656944275,
0.3731125593185425,
0.22432629764080048,
-0.0646180734038353,
-0.9344373345375061,
-0.15033525228500366,
1.255933403968811,
0.3840276598930359,
0.8286144137382507,
0.44388797879219055,
0.9091885089874268,
0.48103171586990356,
0.23172731697559357,
-0.5663970708847046,
0.30444297194480896,
-0.30191442370414734,
-0.5383642911911011,
-0.6295811533927917,
-0.35294240713119507,
-1.064409852027893,
0.5498188138008118,
-0.27566853165626526,
-0.7249466180801392,
0.00814121775329113,
0.28332239389419556,
-0.4162927567958832,
-0.021164454519748688,
-0.7047587633132935,
0.5273963212966919,
-0.6092919707298279,
-0.6027309894561768,
-0.5155001878738403,
-0.38298001885414124,
0.3706650733947754,
-0.503284215927124,
0.30535829067230225,
-0.03829661011695862,
0.22374628484249115,
0.7680920958518982,
0.08394503593444824,
0.7888698577880859,
-0.03933301195502281,
-0.4722284972667694,
0.32687437534332275,
0.09772372245788574,
0.23179611563682556,
-0.22964386641979218,
-0.1352969855070114,
0.2222597301006317,
0.09926007688045502,
-0.5884397029876709,
-0.7332311868667603,
0.7623593807220459,
-0.6330147981643677,
-0.9483946561813354,
-0.1391589343547821,
-0.677449107170105,
-0.12650392949581146,
0.3407137393951416,
-0.3812912702560425,
0.3289033770561218,
-0.415392130613327,
0.17470389604568481,
0.3265829086303711,
-0.3847237825393677,
0.4699515402317047,
0.7037299871444702,
-0.3950597643852234,
-0.5984460711479187,
0.9376837015151978,
0.2364446371793747,
0.5351819396018982,
0.10592200607061386,
0.5328865051269531,
-0.36051562428474426,
-0.5418455004692078,
-0.5854876637458801,
0.25654011964797974,
-0.6851367950439453,
0.15562240779399872,
-0.6383332014083862,
-0.23235465586185455,
-0.9156549572944641,
-0.006323914974927902,
-0.47485029697418213,
-0.7441285848617554,
-0.23443622887134552,
0.19950540363788605,
0.32237744331359863,
0.5228709578514099,
-0.4350964426994324,
0.5233153700828552,
-0.9227426052093506,
0.15226423740386963,
0.3512337803840637,
0.17927078902721405,
0.13868358731269836,
-0.9974993467330933,
-0.49258989095687866,
0.1136564165353775,
-0.23721076548099518,
-0.6908485293388367,
0.44023144245147705,
0.4756852984428406,
0.7451202869415283,
0.2912663519382477,
-0.10963284969329834,
0.999986469745636,
-0.6093626022338867,
0.6286212205886841,
0.06864699721336365,
-1.1116976737976074,
0.5780152082443237,
-0.42098328471183777,
0.3463999032974243,
0.3020963668823242,
0.22239065170288086,
-0.5432255268096924,
-0.3347252905368805,
-0.6323965191841125,
-0.5307318568229675,
0.41024094820022583,
0.13823728263378143,
0.3983832597732544,
0.24731090664863586,
0.4210428297519684,
-0.06887891888618469,
-0.00223028426989913,
-0.9388130307197571,
-0.2563907504081726,
-0.25739535689353943,
-0.03448861837387085,
-0.3440810441970825,
-0.1767694503068924,
-0.019647572189569473,
-0.46619272232055664,
0.6308115720748901,
-0.2971309721469879,
-0.10545691102743149,
0.18455614149570465,
-0.2498323619365692,
0.17601962387561798,
0.37848082184791565,
0.4684639275074005,
0.5406092405319214,
0.19549158215522766,
-0.010441698133945465,
0.39460471272468567,
-0.03263280913233757,
0.2034187912940979,
-0.06235096603631973,
0.09069432318210602,
-0.33168768882751465,
0.5657792687416077,
0.5115363597869873,
0.18004128336906433,
-0.4952714443206787,
0.29664480686187744,
0.23080579936504364,
-0.20712345838546753,
-0.4265981614589691,
0.3496781587600708,
0.22519929707050323,
0.4167202413082123,
0.11290019005537033,
-0.17691774666309357,
0.14566731452941895,
-0.8004746437072754,
0.2686779201030731,
0.369322270154953,
-0.45682013034820557,
-0.27566319704055786,
0.5839110612869263,
0.08973445743322372,
-0.3736041486263275,
0.4311845004558563,
0.07254199683666229,
-0.6413689851760864,
0.21040843427181244,
0.9126477837562561,
0.7448384165763855,
-0.7497178912162781,
0.12357388436794281,
0.42238301038742065,
0.40839704871177673,
-0.13461369276046753,
0.21075229346752167,
-0.17472200095653534,
-0.9071033596992493,
-0.4865300953388214,
-0.4444018304347992,
-0.2151256650686264,
-0.20890483260154724,
-0.74238520860672,
0.05043854936957359,
-0.26584362983703613,
-0.052002836018800735,
-0.10412823408842087,
-0.25808149576187134,
-0.3754243850708008,
0.09559087455272675,
0.01051492802798748,
0.8176702260971069,
-1.0799278020858765,
1.274844765663147,
0.3393409252166748,
-0.2955242991447449,
-0.6196072697639465,
-0.16602139174938202,
-0.17808257043361664,
-0.8298409581184387,
0.43868616223335266,
-0.3658711910247803,
-0.18151158094406128,
0.12497557699680328,
-0.13490265607833862,
-1.2764110565185547,
0.7885444760322571,
0.3170625567436218,
-0.4007216691970825,
0.27833181619644165,
0.23336297273635864,
0.9118624925613403,
-0.30920442938804626,
-0.14779767394065857,
0.6411537528038025,
0.302144855260849,
-0.16420577466487885,
-0.96662837266922,
-0.21431493759155273,
0.0037123023066669703,
-0.07258206605911255,
0.021150682121515274,
-0.6745786070823669,
0.7894794344902039,
-0.3098277151584625,
-0.081425242125988,
0.19976870715618134,
0.9813441634178162,
0.07644572108983994,
-0.10231132805347443,
0.5708662867546082,
0.2035641074180603,
0.8050877451896667,
0.1670873463153839,
0.7589300870895386,
-0.3634978234767914,
0.28430089354515076,
1.4717563390731812,
-0.3338499367237091,
1.0058503150939941,
0.4634644389152527,
-0.045488063246011734,
0.4869305491447449,
0.48627668619155884,
-0.13445693254470825,
0.30028414726257324,
0.09383758902549744,
-0.17531028389930725,
-0.32956674695014954,
-0.3967211842536926,
-0.3836597800254822,
0.8618911504745483,
0.2016523778438568,
-0.26471754908561707,
0.002961274003610015,
0.10864229500293732,
-0.15899048745632172,
0.02854507602751255,
-0.058465518057346344,
0.6659588813781738,
-0.07931430637836456,
-0.7319645285606384,
0.6012759208679199,
-0.0745893195271492,
0.5037178993225098,
-0.4757724404335022,
0.06871432811021805,
-0.3519781827926636,
0.19965116679668427,
-0.24284839630126953,
-0.5876845717430115,
0.19816242158412933,
-0.2366441786289215,
-0.05898510664701462,
0.03241296112537384,
0.6329668164253235,
-0.8288928270339966,
-0.8040889501571655,
0.5640578866004944,
1.0485223531723022,
0.1818293184041977,
0.17531833052635193,
-0.6633588671684265,
-0.053783319890499115,
0.34794938564300537,
0.1107577458024025,
0.25756514072418213,
0.2617832124233246,
-0.2764912545681,
1.046696424484253,
0.8245008587837219,
0.309179425239563,
0.3450424075126648,
0.23862574994564056,
0.676741361618042,
-0.6737378835678101,
-0.36156797409057617,
-0.7556918859481812,
0.35947754979133606,
0.13460855185985565,
-0.004558657296001911,
1.1213487386703491,
0.714494526386261,
0.7681440711021423,
-0.13715089857578278,
0.9763495922088623,
0.04526868835091591,
0.4409022033214569,
-0.46435287594795227,
0.6107205152511597,
-0.9396916031837463,
-0.09384094923734665,
-0.7698092460632324,
-0.8903179168701172,
-0.3698290288448334,
0.5339095592498779,
0.04987214133143425,
-0.15571995079517365,
0.5516492128372192,
0.6996576189994812,
-0.1620894968509674,
-0.20085018873214722,
0.6076518893241882,
-0.004200037103146315,
0.4002581536769867,
0.2605190873146057,
1.0002461671829224,
-0.5184685587882996,
0.3125748336315155,
-0.2827933132648468,
-0.4998375475406647,
0.1951206475496292,
-0.9103692173957825,
-0.8416733741760254,
-0.5935797095298767,
-0.5586890578269958,
-0.2165711224079132,
-0.05443163216114044,
0.7092108130455017,
0.9362671375274658,
-0.7274341583251953,
-0.7041676044464111,
0.371840238571167,
0.07612182199954987,
-0.29639819264411926,
-0.13398301601409912,
0.49337610602378845,
-0.4146712124347687,
-0.7546992897987366,
0.8939412236213684,
0.3619358241558075,
0.26069122552871704,
-0.5194482207298279,
-0.04843425005674362,
-0.152724951505661,
-0.11781231313943863,
0.944465696811676,
0.5186940431594849,
-0.8853520750999451,
-0.2149280160665512,
-0.03977038338780403,
0.4293483793735504,
0.1554630547761917,
0.6931166052818298,
-0.4591043293476105,
0.618187427520752,
0.1999608278274536,
0.8266863226890564,
0.4479188919067383,
0.0532374233007431,
0.745453953742981,
-0.5049008727073669,
0.29767149686813354,
-0.35653966665267944,
0.41281184554100037,
0.4232713580131531,
-0.07096061110496521,
0.5256328582763672,
-0.024967486038804054,
-0.47626879811286926,
-0.5992379188537598,
0.28327083587646484,
-0.805165708065033,
-0.23130986094474792,
0.9788186550140381,
-0.025369111448526382,
-0.29276901483535767,
-0.08090790361166,
-0.10975021123886108,
0.3713066279888153,
-0.16426606476306915,
0.8599823713302612,
0.5819067358970642,
-0.330024391412735,
-0.1944061666727066,
-0.3320295810699463,
0.2773788273334503,
0.4884868264198303,
-0.8899599313735962,
0.3674543499946594,
0.3276903033256531,
0.36082425713539124,
0.3507334887981415,
0.6773373484611511,
-0.04181959852576256,
0.22359104454517365,
-0.229509636759758,
0.1666981279850006,
0.25886407494544983,
-0.514020562171936,
-0.6229445338249207,
0.005729069001972675,
0.3338751196861267,
-0.08638887107372284
] |
Subsets and Splits